Foreword
The art of cheesemaking has been augmented steadily by greater knowledge on the science of cheesemaking. This...
390 downloads
3949 Views
111MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Foreword
The art of cheesemaking has been augmented steadily by greater knowledge on the science of cheesemaking. This evolution has resulted from basic and applied research and from the increased need to understand and control the characteristics of milk, the microorganisms used in the manufacture and maturation of cheese, the manufacturing technologies, and the physical properties and flavour of cheese. Traditional methods of cheese manufacture have been modified by the need for greater efficiencies in the manufacture and maturation of cheese and by changes in the marketing channels for cheese. Accommodating these changes while maintaining the characteristics of a given cheese variety has been accomplished by the application of scientific principles. The need for greater understanding of the characteristics of cheese has also been driven by the increased use of cheese as an ingredient in other foods. This has required specific control of selected properties of cheese to impart the desired properties to the food, and to retain characteristics of the cheese during various food processing technologies. The successive editions of Cheese: Chemistry, Physics and Microbiology have documented the application of science to the art of cheesemaking. Certain characteristics are common in all editions: a thorough description and evaluation of scientific and technological advances, prodigious referencing to direct readers to more in-depth discussion of topics, and careful editing to impart consistency of discussion and a smooth transition between chapters. However, each edition has been revised to incorporate new information and to reflect recent trends in describing the science of cheesemaking and maturation and in the use of cheese as a food ingredient. Scientific principles emphasised in Volume 1 cover microbiological, chemical and physical attributes of cheese as in previous editions. Greater emphasis is given to the genetics and metabolic activity of lactic starters and on the secondary microflora in the third edition. Conversion of components (lactose, lactate, citrate, lipids, proteins) by microbial metabolism and enzymatic action is discussed in several chapters. Inclusion of modern sensory evaluation techniques and instrumental identification of flavour compounds recognises the relationship between these areas. A new chapter on acid gels provides the basic background for discussion in Volume 2 on cheese varieties made by acid or heat plus acid coagulation that are becoming more important as food ingredients. Volume 2, as in previous editions, focuses on various types of cheese, but the cheeses have been grouped into more logical categories based upon characteristics rather than geographical regions of production. The first chapter of Volume 2 provides an overview of the diversity of cheese varieties and systems of categorising varieties. A similar approach in the second chapter familiarises the reader with the general aspects of cheese technology to emphasise that there are common elements in cheesemaking and maturation and that cheese varieties result from specific deviations from or additions to these common elements. The last chapter is appropriately a discussion of cheese as an ingredient, which recognises recent trends in the science of cheese. A substantial bank of knowledge has been accumulated on cheese and this has been rigorously incorporated into the two volumes. It is inevitable that this bank of knowledge will be revised and expanded. The third edition of Cheese: Chemistry, Physics and Microbiology provides the base upon which these revisions and expansions can be undertaken objectively. N.E Olson Department of Food Science, University of Wisconsin, Madison
List of Contributors
Dr J.M. Banks
Ms Y.E Collins
CHARIS Food Research Hannah Research Institute Ayr KA6 5HL Scotland
Dairy Products Research Centre Teagasc, Moorepark Fermoy Cork Ireland
Dr T. Beresford
Dairy Products Research Centre Teagasc, Moorepark Fermoy Cork Ireland Dr E. Beuvier
Station de Recherches en Technologie et Analyses Laitieres Institut National de La Recherche Agronomique F-39801 Poligny Cedex France Dr S. Buchin
Station de Recherches en Technologie et Analyses Laitieres Institut National de La Recherche Agronomique F-39801 Poligny Cedex France Dr M.J. Callanan
Dairy Products Research Centre Teagasc, Moorepark Fermoy Cork Ireland Dr J.-E Chamba
Institut Technique Francais de Fromages 74801 La Roche sur Foron Cedex France Professor T.M. Cogan
Dairy Products Research Centre Teagasc, Moorepark Fermoy Cork Ireland
Professor M.J.C. Crabbe
Division of Cell and Molecular Biology School of Animal and Microbial Sciences The University of Reading Whiteknights Reading RG6 6AJ UK Dr A.C. Curtin
Department of Food and Nutritional Sciences University College Cork Ireland Professor E Dejmek
Department of Food Engineering Lund University Box 124, 221 00 Lund Sweden Dr C.M. Delahunty
Department of Food and Nutritional Sciences University College Cork Ireland Dr A.D.W. D o b s o n Department of Microbiology University College Cork Ireland Dr C.W. Donnelly Department of Nutrition and Food Sciences University of Vermont 200 Carrigan Building Burlington VT 05405-0044 USA
x
List of Contributors
Dr M.A. Drake
Dr A.A.A. Magboul
Department of Food Science North Carolina State University Campus Box 7624 Raleigh NC 27695-7624 USA
DAL Food Industries Industrial Area No. 1/15 Block 4F Khartoum North, PO Box 708 Sudan
Dr G.E Fitzgerald
National Food Biotechnology Centre Departments of Microbiology and Food & Nutritional Sciences University College Cork Ireland Professor P.E Fox Department of Food and Nutritional Sciences University College Cork Ireland Dr T.P. Guinee
Dairy Products Research Centre Teagasc, Moorepark Fermoy Cork Ireland Dr D.S. Horne
CHARIS Food Research Hannah Research Institute Ayr KA6 5HL Scotland
Professor J.-L. Maubois Laboratoire de Recherches kaiti~res Institut National de la Recherche Agronomique 35012 Rennes Cedex France Dr S. McGrath
National Food Biotechnology Centre Department of Microbiology University College Cork Ireland Dr P.L.H. McSweeney
Department of Food and Nutritional Sciences University College Cork Ireland Professor V.V. Mistry Dairy Science Department South Dakota State University Brookings SD 57007 USA Dr N.M. O'Brien
Dr E Irlinger
Institut National de La Recherche Agronomique 78850 Thiverval-Grignon Cedex France Dr J.-L. Le Qu~r~
Institut National de la Recherche Agronomique Unit6 Mixte de Recherche sur les Aromes 17 rue Sully F-21065, Dijon France Dr J.A. Lucey
Department of Food Science University of Wisconsin-Madison 1605 Linden Drive Madison, WI 53706-1565 USA
Department of Food and Nutritional Sciences University College Cork Ireland Dr D.J. O'Callaghan Dairy Products Research Centre Teagasc, Moorepark Fermoy Cork Ireland Dr J. O'Callaghan Department of Microbiology University College Cork Ireland
List of Contributors
Department of Food and Nutritional Sciences University College Cork Ireland
Mr V.K. Upadhyay Department of Food and Nutritional Sciences University College Cork Ireland
Dr E. Parente
Professor P. Walstra
Dipartimenta Biologia Universit/~ della Basilicata Campus di Macchia Romana 85100 Potenza Italy
Department of Food Science The Argricultural University 6703 HD Wageningen The Netherlands
Dr R.P. Ross Dairy Products Research Centre Teagasc, Moorepark Fermoy Cork Ireland
Department of Life Sciences University of Limerick Castletroy Limerick Ireland
Dr T.P. O'Connor
Dr D. van Sinderen Department of Microbiology University College Cork Ireland
Dr M.G. W i l k i n s o n
Professor A. Williams
CHARIS Food Research Hannah Research Institute Ayr KA6 5HL Scotland
xi
Preface to the First Edition
Cheese manufacture is one of the classical examples of food preservation, dating from 6000-7000 BC. Preservation of the most important constituents of milk (i.e. fat and protein) as cheese exploits two of the classical principles of food preservation, i.e.: lactic acid fermentation, and reduction of water activity through removal of water and addition of NaC1. Establishment of a low redox potential and secretion of antibiotics by starter microorganisms contribute to the storage stability of cheese. About 500 varieties of cheese are now produced throughout the world; present production is - 1 0 7 tonnes per annum and is increasing at a rate of --~4% per annum. Cheese manufacture essentially involves gelation of the casein via iso-electric (acid) or enzymatic (rennet) coagulation; a few cheeses are produced by a combination of heat and acid and still fewer by thermal evaporation. Developments in ultrafihration facilitate the production of a new family of cheeses. Cheeses produced by acid or heat/acid coagulation are usually consumed fresh, and hence their production is relatively simple and they are not particularly interesting from the biochemical viewpoint although they may have interesting physico-chemical features. Rennet cheeses are almost always ripened (matured) before consumption through the action of a complex battery of enzymes. Consequently they are in a dynamic state and provide fascinating subjects for enzymologists and microbiologists, as well as physical chemists. Researchers on cheese have created a very substantial literature, including several texts dealing mainly with the technological aspects of cheese production. Although certain chemical, physical and microbiological aspects of cheese have been reviewed extensively, this is probably the first attempt to review comprehensively the scientific aspects of cheese manufacture and ripening. The topics applicable to most cheese varieties, i.e. rennets, starters, primary and secondary phases of rennet coagulation, gel formation, gel syneresis, salting, proteolysis, theology and nutrition, are reviewed in Volume 1. Volume 2 is devoted to the more specific aspects of the nine major cheese families: Cheddar, Dutch, Swiss, Iberian, Italian, Balkan, Middle Eastern, Mould-ripened and Smear-ripened. A chapter is devoted to non-European cheeses, many of which are ill-defined; it is hoped that the review will stimulate scientific interest in these minor, but locally important, varieties. The final chapter is devoted to processed cheeses. It is hoped that the book will provide an up-to-date reference on the scientific aspects of this fascinating group of ancient, yet ultramodern, foods; each chapter is extensively referenced. It will be clear that a considerably body of scientific knowledge on the manufacture and ripening of cheese is currently available but it will be apparent also that many major gaps exist in our knowledge; it is hoped that this book will serve to stimulate scientists to fill these gaps. I wish to thank sincerely the other 26 authors who contributed to the text and whose co-operation made my task as editor a pleasure. RE Fox
Preface to the Second Edition
The first edition of this book was very well received by the various groups (lecturers, students, researchers and industrialists) interested in the scientific and technological aspects of cheese. The initial printing was sold out faster than anticipated and created an opportunity to revise and extend the book. The second edition retains all 21 subjects from the first edition, generally revised by the same authors and in some cases expanded considerably. In addition, l0 new chapters have been added: Cheese: Methods of chemical analysis; Biochemistry of cheese ripening; Water activity and the composition of cheese; Growth and survival of pathogenic and other undesirable microorganisms in cheese; Membrane processes in cheese technology, in Volume 1 and North-European varieties; Cheeses of the former USSR; Mozzarella and Pizza cheese; Acid-coagulated cheeses and Cheeses from sheep's and goats' milk in Volume 2. These new chapters were included mainly to fill perceived deficiencies in the first edition. The book provides an in-depth coverage of the principal scientific and technological aspects of cheese. While it is intended primarily for lecturers, senior students and researchers, production management and quality control personnel should find it to be a very valuable reference book. Although cheese production has become increasingly scientific in recent years, the quality of the final product is still not totally predictable. It is not claimed that this book will provide all the answers for the cheese scientist/technologist but it does provide the most comprehensive compendium of scientific knowledge on cheese available. Each of the 31 chapters is extensively referenced to facilitate further exploration of the extensive literature on cheese. It will be apparent that while cheese manufacture is now firmly based on sound scientific principles, many questions remain unanswered. It is hoped that this book will serve to stimulate further scientific study on the chemical, physical and biological aspects of cheese. I wish to thank sincerely all the authors who contributed to the two volumes of this book and whose cooperation made my task as editor a pleasure.
RE Fox
Preface to the Third Edition
Very considerable progress has been made on the scientific aspects of cheese since the second edition of this book was published in 1993. This is especially true for the Microbiology of Cheese and the Biochemistry of Cheese Ripening; consequently those sections have been expanded very considerably. The general structure of the book is similar to that of the earlier editions, with the more general aspects being treated in Volume 1 and the more applied, variety-related aspects in Volume 2. The book contains 36 chapters. Reflecting the very extensive research on cheese starters in recent years, four chapters have been devoted to this topic in the third edition. Another new feature is the inclusion of two chapters on cheese flavour; one on sensory aspects, the other on instrumental methods. In Volume 2 of the second edition, cheese varieties were treated mainly on a geographical basis. While some elements of the geographical distribution remain, cheese varieties are now treated mainly based on the characteristic features of their ripening. Obviously, it is not possible to treat all 1000 or so cheese varieties, but the 10 variety-related chapters in Volume 2 cover at least 90% of world cheese production and it is very likely that your favourite cheese is included in one of those 10 chapters. Cheese is the quintessential convenience food and is widely used as an ingredient in other foods and in the USA approximately 70% of all cheese is used as a food ingredient. The use of cheese as a food ingredient is a major growth area; consequently, a chapter has been devoted to the important features of cheese as an ingredient, including a section on Enzyme-modified Cheese. Each chapter is extensively referenced to facilitate further exploration of the extensive literature on cheese. While the book is intended for primarily lecturers, senior students and researchers, production m a n a g e m e n t and quality control personnel should find it to be a very useful reference book. We wish to thank sincerely all authors who contributed to the two volumes of this b o o k and whose cooperation made our task as editors a pleasure. Special thanks are due to Ms Anne Cahalane for very valuable assistance. RE Fox P.L.H. McSweeney T.M. Cogan T.R Guinee
Cheese: An Overview P.F. Fox and P.L.H. McSweeney, Department of Food and Nutritional Sciences, University College, Cork, Ireland
Historical Cheese is the generic name for a group of fermented milk-based food products, produced in a wide range of flavours and forms throughout the world. Although the primary objective of cheesemaking is to conserve the principal constituents of milk, cheese has evolved to become a food of haute cuisine with epicurean qualities, as well as being highly nutritious. Sandine and Elliker (1970) suggested that there are more than 1000 varieties of cheese. Walter and Hargrove (1972) described more than 400 varieties and listed the names of a further 400, while Burkhalter (1981) classified 510 varieties (although some are listed more than once). Jim Path (University of Wisconsin) has compiled a list of 1400 varieties (visit www.cdr.wisc.edu). As discussed in detail in 'Diversity of cheese varieties: An Overview', Volume 2, a number of attempts have been made to classify cheese varieties into meaningful groups. The most common criterion for the classification is texture (very hard, hard, semi-hard, semi-soft, soft) which is related mainly to the moisture content of the cheese. Various attempts have been made to improve on this basis of classification, for example, by including the milk-producing species, moisture to protein ratio, method of coagulation, cooking temperature, microflora. These classification schemes are discussed in 'Diversity of cheese varieties: An Overview', Volume 2. However, no classification scheme developed to date is completely satisfactory; the inclusion of chemical indices of ripening would be useful. It is commonly believed that cheese evolved in a region known as the 'Fertile Crescent', i.e., from the Tigris and Euphratres rivers, through what is now southern Turkey to the Mediterranean coast, some 8000 years ago. The so-called 'Agricultural Revolution' occurred in this region with the domestication of plants and animals. Presumably, humans soon recognized the nutritive value of milk produced by domesticated animals and contrived to share the mother's milk with her offspring. Apparently, goats and sheep, which are gregarious and docile, were the first dairy animals domesticated, but cattle have become the dominant dairy species in most parts of the world (c. 85% of the total world supply of milk is obtained from cows).
Milk is also a rich source of nutrients for bacteria which contaminate the milk, some species of which utilize milk sugar, lactose, as a source of energy, producing lactic acid. Bacterial growth and acid production would have occurred during storage or during attempts to dry milk in the prevailing warm, dry climate to produce a more stable p r o d u c t - air-drying of meat, fruits and vegetables appears to have been practised as a primitive form of food preservation at this period in the development of civilization. When sufficient acid has been produced, the principal proteins of milk, the caseins, coagulate, i.e., at their isoelectric p o i n t s - --~pH 4.6, to form a gel in which the fat is entrapped. The rate of acidification by the adventitious microflora would usually be slow, allowing the (unhomogenized) fat globules to form a cream layer. This layer of sour cream could be blended into the lower protein gel or scooped off for the production of butter. Thus originated three of our classical fermented dairy products: fermented milks, sour cream and lactic butter, all of which are still produced widely, sometimes depending on the adventitious microflora for acidification, but now usually through the growth of cultures of lactic acid bacteria. The first fermented dairy foods were produced by a fortuitous combination of e v e n t s - the ability of a group of bacteria, the lactic acid bacteria (LAB), to grow in milk and to produce enough acid to reduce the pH of milk to the isoelectric point of the caseins, at which these proteins coagulate. Neither the LAB nor the caseins were designed for this outcome. The caseins were 'designed' to coagulate following limited proteolysis in the stomach of neonatal mammals, the gastric pH of which is around 6, i.e., very much higher than the isoelectric point of the caseins. The ability of Lactococcus lactis to ferment lactose, a sugar specific to milk, is plasmid-encoded, suggesting that this characteristic was acquired relatively recently in the evolution of these bacteria. Their natural habitats are vegetation and/or the intestine, from which they presumably colonized the teats of dairy animals, contaminated with lactosecontaining milk; it is likely that through evolutionary pressure, these bacteria acquired the ability to ferment lactose. When an acid-coagulated milk gel is broken, e.g., accidentally by movement of the storage vessel or intentionally
Cheese: Chemistry, Physics and Microbiology, Third edition - Volume 1: General Aspects ISBN: 0-1226-3652-X Set ISBN: 0-1226-3651-1
Copyright 9 2004 Elsevier Ltd All rights reserved
2
Cheese: An Overview
by breaking or cutting, it separates into curds and whey. It would have been realized quickly that the acid whey is a pleasant, refreshing drink for immediate consumption while the curds could be consumed fresh or stored for furore use. In fact, whey was long considered to have medicinal benefits (see Hoffmann, 1761). It was probably soon realized that the shelf-life of the curds could be extended by dehydration and/or by adding salt; heavily salted cheese varieties are still widespread throughout the Middle East and small quantifies of a number of dehydrated cheeses are produced in North Africa and the Middle East, e.g., Tikammart and Aoules (Algeria), Djamid (Jordan), Ekt (Saudi Arabia) and Madraffarah (Syria) (see Phelan et al., 1993). It is presumed that one of the principal families of cheese, the acid cheeses, modern members of which include Cottage cheese, Cream cheese and Quarg, originated in this way. While lactic acid, produced in situ, is believed to have been the original milk coagulant, an alternative mechanism was also recognized from an early date. Many proteolytic enzymes can modify the casein system in milk, causing it to coagulate under certain circumstances. Enzymes capable of causing this transformation are widespread in nature, e.g., bacteria, moulds, plant and animal tissues, but an obvious source would have been animal stomachs. It would have been observed that the stomach of young mammals after slaughter contained curds, especially if the animals had suckled shortly before slaughter; curds would also have been observed in the vomit of human infants. Before the development of pottery (---5000 BC), storage of milk in bags made from animal skins was probably common (as it still is in many countries). Stomachs of slaughtered animals provided ready-made, easily sealed containers; under such circumstances, milk would extract enzymes (chymosin and some pepsin) from the stomach tissue, leading to its coagulation during storage. The properties of rennet-coagulated curds are very different from those produced by isoelectric (acid) precipitation, e.g., they have better syneresis properties which makes it possible to produce low-moisture cheese curd without hardening. Rennet-coagulated curds can, therefore, be converted to a more stable product than acid curds and rennet coagulation has become predominant in cheese manufacture, being exploited for c. 75% of total world production. Although animal rennets were used from early times, rennets produced from a range of plant species, e.g., fig and thistle, also appear to have been common in ancient times. However, plant rennets are not suitable for the manufacture of long-ripened cheese varieties and gastric proteinases from young animals became the standard rennets until a recent shortage of supply made it necessary to introduce 'rennet substitutes'.
While the coagulation of milk by the in situ production of lactic acid was, presumably, accidental, the use of rennets to coagulate milk was intentional. It was, in fact, quite an ingenous invention- if the conversion of milk to cheese by the use of rennets was discovered today, it would be hailed as a major biotechnological discovery! The advantages accruing from the ability to convert the principal constituents of milk to cheese would have been apparent from the viewpoints of storage stability, ease of transport and, presumably, as a means of diversifying the human diet and cheese manufacture became well established in the ancient civilizations of the Middle East, Egypt, Greece and Rome. There are numerous references to cheese and other foods in the Bible (see MacAlister, 1904). Milk and dairy products formed an important part of the diet of peoples of the Near East during Biblical times; indeed Palestine was praised as 'a land flowing with milk and honey' (Exodus 3.8). Animals herded during Biblical times for milk production included goats (e.g., Proverbs 27.27), sheep (e.g., Deuteronomy 14.4) and possibly camels (Genesis 32.15). Cows' milk is rarely specified in the Old Testament, presumably because of the unsuitability of the terrain of the Holy Land for cow pasture. In addition to milk, other foods of dairy origin mentioned in the Bible include curds (perhaps fermented milk: Genesis 18.8; Isaiah 7.22) and butter (Psalms 55.21). There are several clear references in the Old Testament to cheese, e.g., Job (1520 BC, where Job remarks to God 'did Thou not pour me out like milk and curdle me like cheese'; Job 10.10) and Samuel (1170-1017 BC; as a delicacy sent by Jesse to his sons (I Samuel 17.18) and as a gift presented to David (II Samuel 17.29)). Cheese is represented in the tomb art of Ancient Egypt and in Greek literature. Vegetable rennets are mentioned in the first work of European literature; Homer (c. eighth century BC) implies the use of fig rennet in the Iliad ( ' . . . as when fig juice is added to white milk and rapidly coagulates, and the milk quickly curdles as it is stirred, so speedy was his healing of raging Ares.' Iliad 5) and describes the Cyclops, Polyphemus, making ewes' milk cheese in the Odyssey (Book 9) using 'well made dairy vessels' and 'pails swimming with whey'. Other Greek authors who mention cheese include the Father of History, Herodotus (484-408 BC), who referred to 'Scythian cheese' and the philosopher, Aristotle (384-322 BC), who noted that 'Phrygian' cheese was made from the milk of mares and asses. Apparently, cheese was prescribed in the diet for Spartan wrestlers in training. Cheese manufacture was well established in the Roman Empire and was a standard item in the rations
Cheese: An Overview
issued to Roman soldiers. Cheese must have been popular with Roman civilians also and demand exceeded supply, forcing an emperor, Diocletian (AD 284-305), to fix a maximum price for cheese. Many Roman writers, e.g., Cato the Elder (234-149 BC), Varro, Columella and Pliny the Elder, described cheese manufacture and quality and the culinary uses of cheese. Pliny the Elder (AD 23-79) mentioned cheese in his encyclopedia, Historia Naturalis (Book 28) and described its uses in the diet and in medicinal applications. Varro (c. 116-27 Bc; De Agricultura 2.3-2.6) distinguished between 'soft and new cheese' and that which is 'old and dry' and described the Roman cheesemaking season in the spring and summer. Varro briefly described cheese manufacture: to about 2 congii (c. 5.7 L) of milk was added a piece of rennet from the hare or kid (in preference to that from the lamb). Varro described the quantity of rennet to be added as 'the size of an olive', implying that the rennet was solid, perhaps a piece of stomach tissue. If so, then this rennet may be analogous to rennet paste, which is used today for the manufacture of certain Italian cheese varieties (see 'Biochemistry of Cheese Ripening: Introduction and Overview', 'Lipolysis and Catabolism of Fatty Acids in Cheese', Volume 1). Fig latex and vinegar were mentioned by Varro as an alternative rennet and vinegar is also mentioned as a means for coagulating milk (as practised today in the manufacture of some forms of Queso Blanco and Ricotta). However, the most complete ancient description of cheesemaking is given by Lucius Junius Moderatus Columella, a Roman soldier and author from Gades (modern Cadiz), in his treatise on agriculture, De Re Rustica (c. AD 50). A manufacturing procedure for Roman cheese, based on the description of Columella, is given in Fig. 1, which includes many observations and practices recognizable by modern cheesemakers. He recommends that the (raw) milk be held at 'some degree of heat' but warns against over-heating by placing the pail on the flames of a fire. Columella distinguished between cheese with a 'thin consistency' (soft?) which must be sold quickly 'while it is still fresh and retains its moisture' and that with a 'rich and thick consistency' (hard?) which may be held for a long period. Since the concept of pH and the existence of bacteria were unknown in antiquity, no mention is made of starter; the cheese curd was acidified using the adventitious microflora of the raw milk. However, Columella did discuss different types of rennets in some detail. He recommended coagulation using rennet from lamb or kid but states that milk can also be coagulated using flowers of certain thistles (perhaps Cynara cardunculus), seeds of the safflower (Carthamus tinctorius), or sap from the fig tree. Interestingly, Col-
3
PAIL OF MILK (Sheep or goat) Rennet, > weight of denarius (c. 3.4 g) (Lamb, kid or other)
'Some degree of heat' I F (Stand not far from the fire) Coagulum
Drain whey quickly when milk coagulated using wicker baskets or moulds. Aid whey drainage using weights
j WHEY
Curds
~'
I Place cheese in a cool shady place Surface application of dry salt
l
Rind formation Pressing using weights Further application of dry salt Repeat for 9 days Wash cheeses using water
Place cheeses in rows on wickerwork trays Allow them to become 'moderately dry' Pack closely on shelves in an enclosed place not exposed to the wind Cheese becomes 'more tender' I Cheese can be 'exported beyond the sea'
I
CHEESE
"
Figure 1 Flow diagram for the manufacture of a type of Roman cheese based on the description of Columella (De Re Rustica, 7.8.1-7.8.7).
umella recommended that the smallest amount of rennet possible be used to ensure high quality cheese. This may be related to the excessive proteolytic activity of plant proteinases used as rennets which often produce bitter cheese. Whey drainage was through wicker baskets, perhaps analogous to the drainage of whey through moulds in the manufacture of certain soft cheeses (e.g., Camembert). No mention was made by Columella of cooking the curds/whey mixture prior to whey drainage; moisture control seems to have been by pressing the curds during whey drainage or pressing the cheese after salting. Salting was by means of the repeated application of dry salt to the cheese surface (which is still practiced, e.g., in the manufacture of Blue cheese), which encouraged further loss of moisture ('acid liquid'). However, Columella also mentioned brine salting as a method of 'hardening' cheese. The cheeses were washed with water, allowed to form a rind and placed on shelves in an enclosed place 'so that the cheese may remain more
4
Cheese: An Overview
tender'. Interestingly, the comparative form of the adjective used in the Latin text (tenerior) can also be translated as 'more soft'; if this is the intended meaning, it is the first recorded mention of the changes which occur in cheese during ripening. Columella also discussed defects which may occur in cheese, including being 'full of holes' (perhaps mechanical openings as the remedy recommended is increased pressing), too salty or too dry. According to Columella, cheeses were flavoured with herbs and coloured with smoke, practices which persist to a certain extent today. He also described briefly the manufacture of 'hand-pressed' (manu pressure) cheese in which hot water is poured over the curds which are then shaped by hand, a practice perhaps related to the kneading and stretching steps for pasta-filata varieties. Thus, cheesemaking practice appears to have changed little from the time of Columella until the nineteenth century! The great migrations of peoples throughout Europe immediately before and after the fall of the Western Roman Empire must have promoted the further spread of cheese manufacture, as did the Crusaders and other pilgrims of the Middle Ages. Probably, the most important agents contributing to the development of cheese 'technology' and to the evolution of cheese varieties were monasteries and feudal estates. In addition to their roles in the spread of Christianity and in the preservation and expansion of knowledge during the Dark Ages, the monasteries made considerable contributions to the advancement of agriculture in Europe and to the development and improvement of food commodities, notably wine, beer and cheese. Many of our current well-known cheese varieties were developed in monasteries, e.g., Wenslydale (Rievaulx Abbey, Yorkshire), Port du Salut or Saint Paulin (Monastery de Notre Dame du Port du Salut, Laval, France), Fromage de Tamie (Abbey of Tamie, Lac d'Annecy, Geneva), Maroilles (Abbey Moroilles, Avesnes, France) and Trappist (Maria Stern Monastery, Banja Luka, Bosnia). The inter-monastery movement of monks would have contributed to the spread of cheese varieties and probably to the development of new hybrid varieties. The great feudal estates of the Middle Ages were self-contained communities. The conservation of surplus food produced in summer for use during winter was a major activity on such estates and undoubtedly cheese represented one of the more important of these conserved products, along with cereals, dried and salted meats, dried fruits, dried and fermented vegetables, beer and wine. Cheese probably represented an item of trade when amounts surplus to local requirements were available. Within these estates, individuals acquired special skills which were passed on to succeeding generations. The feudal estates evolved into
villages and some into larger communities. Because monasteries and feudal estates were essentially selfcontained communities, it is readily apparent how several hundred distinct varieties of cheese evolved from essentially the same raw material, milk or rennet-coagulated curds, especially under conditions of limited communication. Traditionally, many cheese varieties were produced in quite limited geographical regions, especially in mountainous areas, where communities are isolated. The localized production of certain varieties is still apparent and indeed is preserved for those varieties with controlled designations of origin (Appelation d'Origine ContrOl~e). Regionalization of certain cheese varieties is particularly marked in Spain, Portugal and Italy, where the production of many varieties is restricted to very limited region. Almost certainly, most cheese varieties evolved by accident because of a particular set of local circumstances, e.g., a peculiarity of the local milk supply, either with respect to chemical composition or microflora, an 'accident' during storage of the cheese, e.g., growth of mould or other microorganisms. Presumably, those accidents that led to desirable changes in the quality of the cheese were incorporated into the manufacturing protocol; each variety thus underwent a series of evolutionary changes and refinements. The final chapter in the spread of cheese throughout the world resulted from the colonization of north and south America, Oceania and Africa by European settlers who carried their cheesemaking skills with them. Cheese has become an item of major economic importance in some of these 'new' countries, notably the US, Canada, Australia and New Zealand, but the varieties produced are mainly of European origin, modified in some cases to meet local requirements. Cheese was not manufactured in these regions before colonization by Europeans; in fact, there were no cattle, sheep or goats in Australia, North or South America and there were no land mammals in New Zealand before the arrival of Europeans. For further information on the history of cheese, the reader is referred to Squire (1937), Cheke (1959), Davis (1965), Kosikowski (1977), Scott (1986), Kosikowski and Mistry (1997) and Robinson and Wilbey (1998). For references on Roman agriculture, see White (1970). Cheesemaking remained an art rather than a science until relatively recently. With the gradual acquisition of knowledge on the chemistry and microbiology of milk and cheese, it became possible to direct the changes involved in cheesemaking in a more controlled fashion. Although few new varieties have evolved as a result of this improved knowledge, the existing varieties have become better defined and their quality more consistent.
Cheese: An Overview
Considering the long history of cheesemaking, one might be inclined to the idea that what have come to be regarded as standard varieties have been so for a long time. However, although the names of many current varieties were introduced several hundred years ago (Table 1), these cheeses were not standardized; for example, the first attempt to standardize the wellknown English varieties, Cheddar and Cheshire, was made by John Harding in the mid-nineteenth century. Prior to that, 'Cheddar cheese' was that produced in a particular area in England around the village of Cheddar, Somerset, and probably varied considerably depending on the manufacturer and other factors. Cheese manufacture was a farmstead enterprise until the mid-nineteenth c e n t u r y - the first cheese factory in the US was established near Rome, NY, in 1851 and the first in Britain at Longford, Derbyshire, in 1870. Thus, there were thousands of cheese manufacturers and there must have been great variation within any one general type. This situation persists in a modified form today in Switzerland and Italy where there are a large number of small cheese factories, often grouped together into consortia for the purposes of marketing and quality control. When one considers the very considerable inter-factory, and indeed intra-factory, variations in quality and characteristics which occur today in well-defined varieties, e.g., Cheddar, in spite of the very considerable scientific and technological advances, one can readily appreciate the variations that must have existed in earlier times. Some major new varieties, notably Jarlsberg and Maasdamer, have been developed recently as a consequence of scientific research. Many other varieties have evolved very considerably, even to the extent of becoming new varieties, as a consequence of scientific research and the development of new technology- notable examples are (US) Queso Blanco, various cheeses produced by ultrafiltration and various forms of Quarg. There has been a marked resurgance of farmhouse cheesemaking in recent years; many of the cheeses being produced on farms are not standard varieties and some of these may evolve to become new varieties.
Table 1
First recorded date for some major cheese varieties (Scott, 1986)
Goronzola Schabzieger Roquefort Maroilles Schwangenk&se Grana Taleggio
897 1000 1070 1174 1178 1200 1282
Cheddar Parmesan Gouda Gloucester Stilton Camembert St Paulin
1500 1579 1697 1783 1785 1791 1816
5
A major cause of differences in the characteristics of cheese is the inter-species differences in the composition and physico-chemical characteristics of the milk used. Although milks from several species are used in cheese manufacture, the cow is by far the most important; sheep, goat and buffalo are commercially important in certain areas. Approximately 85, 11, 2 and 2% of total milk is produced from cows, buffalo, sheep and goats, respectively. However, most sheep's and goats' milk is used for cheese manufacture and therefore are disproportionately important; many famous cheese varieties are made from sheep's milk, e.g., Roquefort, Manchego, Feta and all the various Pecorino and Canestrato varieties. There are very significant inter-species differences in the composition of milk which are reflected in the characteristics of the cheeses produced from them. Major inter-species differences of importance in cheesemaking are the concentration and types of caseins, concentration of fat and especially the fatty acid profile, concentration of salts, especially of calcium. There are also significant differences in milk composition between breeds of cattle and these also influence cheese quality, as do variations due to seasonal, lactational and nutritional factors and of course the methods of milk production, storage and collection.
Cheese Science and Technology Cheese is the most diverse group of dairy products and is, arguably, the most academically interesting and challenging. While many dairy products, if properly manufactured and stored, are biologically, biochemically, chemically and physically very stable, cheeses are, in contrast, biologically and biochemically dynamic, and, consequently, are inherently unstable. Throughout manufacture and ripening, cheese production represents a finely orchestrated series of consecutive and concomitant biochemical events which, if synchronized and balanced, lead to products with highly desirable aromas and flavours but when unbalanced, result in off-flavours and odours. Considering that, in general terms, a basically similar raw material (milk from a very limited number of species) is subjected to a manufacturing protocol, the general principles of which are common to most cheese varieties, it is fascinating that such a diverse range of products can be produced. No two batches of the same variety, indeed probably no two cheeses, are identical. A further important aspect of cheese is the range of scientific disciplines involved: study of cheese manufacture and ripening involves the chemistry and biochemistry of milk constituents, fractionation and chemical characterization of cheese constituents, microbiology, enzymology, molecular genetics, flavour
6
Cheese: An O v e r v i e w
chemistry, nutrition, toxicology, rheology and chemical engineering. It is not surprising, therefore, that many scientists have become involved in the study of cheese manufacture and ripening. A voluminous scientific and technological literature has accumulated, including a range of books (e.g., Sammis, 1948; Van Slyke and Price, 1949; Kosikowski and Mocquot, 1958; Davis, 1965, 1967; Kosikowski, 1977; Davies and Law, 1984; Eck, 1984; Scott, 1986; Fox, 1987, 1993; Buch Kristensen, 1995; Kosikowski and Mistry, 1997; Law, 1997, 1999; Robinson and Wilbey, 1998; Eck and Gilles, 2000; Fox et al., 2000) and chapters in many others. In addition, there are numerous encyclopedias or pictorial books, with brief descriptions of cheese, e.g., Simon (1956), Layton (1973), Mair-Waldburg (1974), Cantin (1976), Eekhof-Stork (1976), Christian (1984), Robinson (1995), Jenkins (1996) and Harbutt (1999, 2002). There are also a number of country-specific or variety-specific books, e.g., Squire (1937), Cheke (1959), Fraser (1960), Meyer (1973), Montandon (1981), Rance (1982), Gonzalez and del Cerro (1988), Berger et al. (1989), Anifantakis (1991), Robinson and Tamime (1991), Zehren and Nusbaum (1992), Resmini et al. (1992), Masui and Yamada (1996), Vizzardi and Maffeis (1999), Ottogalli (2001) and Kammerlehner (2003). Most of the above books deal mainly with cheese technology; the present book concentrates on the more scientific aspects of cheese. The book is in two volumes. The more general aspects of cheese manufacture, i.e., molecular properties of rennets, coagulation mechanism, curd syneresis, starters, salting, rheology, the biochemistry of ripening, pre-concentration by uhrafiltration and nutritional aspects, which apply, more or less, to most cheese varieties, are considered
Milk
Manufacture (5-24 h)
in the first volume. The second volume deals with specific aspects of the principal families of cheese. The principal objective of this introductory chapter is to provide an integrated overview of cheese manufacture and to provide some general background for the more detailed later chapters that follow.
Outline of Cheese Manufacture Almost all acid-coagulated and a little rennet-coagulated cheese is consumed fresh, i.e., the flavour, texture and appearance of the cheese are in their final form at the end of curd production and the curds are not subjected to a period of maturation/ripening. The production of acid-coagulated cheeses can be summarized as:
Cheese
Preparation of milk curd Selection Standardization Pasteurization *Others Acidification Coagulation Syneresis (dehydration) Cut Cook Agitation Other operations, e.g., Cheddaring Kneading/stretching Pressing Salting
Milk
Acidification
= Coagulum
Cut/break
(biological chemical) or
Cold-pack cheese ~
~ Curds and whey
1 Cook Separate Wash Curds
Optional flavours/dressings heat homogenize Package Hot-pack cheese
However, the production of the majority of rennetcoagulated cheese varieties can be sub-divided into two well-defined phases, manufacture and ripening, both of which involve a number of processes:
Ripening (2 week-2 year)
Development of characteristic microflora Metabolism of residual lactose Citrate metabolism Proteolysis Lipolysis Secondary reactions Fatty acid catabolism Amino acid catabolism Lactate metabolism
* e.g., bactofugation, microfiltration, addition of colour (annato)
Mature cheese
Cheese: An Overview
The manufacturing phase might be defined as those operations performed during the first 24 h, although some of these operations, e.g., salting and dehydration, may continue over a longer period. Although the manufacturing protocol for individual varieties differs in detail, the basic steps are common to most varieties; these are: acidification, coagulation, dehydration (cutting the coagulum, cooking, stirring, pressing, salting and other operations that promote gel syneresis), shaping (moulding and pressing) and salting. Cheese manufacture is essentially a dehydration process in which the fat and casein in milk are concentrated between 6- and 12-fold, depending on the variety. The degree of dehydration is regulated by the extent and combination of the above five operations, in addition to the chemical composition of the milk. In turn, the levels of moisture and salt, the pH and the cheese microflora regulate and control the biochemical changes that occur during ripening and hence determine the flavour, aroma and texture of the finished product. Thus, the nature and quality of the finished cheese are determined largely by the manufacturing steps. However, it is during the ripening phase that the characteristic flavour and texture of the individual cheese varieties develop. Selection and pre-treatment of cheese milk
Cheese manufacture commences with the selection of milk of high microbiological and chemical quality. The adventitious microflora of milk is normally heterogeneous. Some of these microorganisms, especially the LAB, may be beneficial. Previously, and still for some minor artisanal cheeses, the indigenous LAB were responsible for acid production but selected starter LAB cultures are used for acidification in most cases. Non-starter LAB (NSLAB) probably contribute positively to the ripening of raw milk cheese (see 'Microbiological changes during ripening', 'Biochemistry of Cheese Ripening: Introduction and Overview', 'Metabolism of Residual Lactose and of Lactate and Citrate', 'Lipolysis and Catabolism of Fatty Acids in Cheese', 'Proteolysis in Cheese during Ripening' and 'Catabolism of Amino Acids in Cheese During Ripening', Volume 1) but they are variable and uncontrolled and may be responsible for some of the variability in raw milk cheese. For large-scale cheesemaking operations, it is preferable to kill the NSLAB by pasteurization (although this is not the primary objective of pasteurization). There is increasing interest in inoculating pasteurized milk with selected lactobacilli as an adjunct culture (see 'Secondary and Adjunct Cultures', Volume 1).
7
Some members of the adventitious microflora are undesirable. The most important are number of pathogens, the killing of which is the primary objective of pasteurization (see 'Growth and Survival of Microbial Pathogens in Cheese', Volume 1). Raw milk may also contain several spoilage microorganisms, e.g., coliforms (which are unlikely to be a problem today), psychrotrophs (especially if the milk is cold-stored for a long period) and Clostridiurn tyrobutyricium. Growth of this sporeforming organism during ripening of most cheese varieties results in a defect known as late gas blowing caused by an anaerobic metabolism of lactate to butyrate and H2. Contamination with CI. tyrobutyricum is minimized by good on-farm hygiene, contaminants may be removed by bactofugation or microfiltration, or their growth may be prevented by NaNO3 or lysozyme. Cheesemilk must be free from antibiotics, which totally, or partially, inhibit the starter bacteria; delayed acidification results in an abnormal composition and microflora and consequently in flavour and textural defects and perhaps very significantly in the growth of harmful, pathogenic or food-poisoning microorganisms. All aspects of cheese curd production (rennet coagulation, gel firmness, syneresis) are affected by the chemical composition of the cheesemilk, especially the concentrations of casein, calcium and pH. The specific effects of compositional parameters on various aspects of curd formation will be described in detail in several subsequent chapters. For a comprehensive description of the chemistry of milk and milk constituents, the reader is refered to Fox (1982, 1983, 1985, 1987, 1992, 1995, 1997) and Fox and McSweeney (1998, 2003). In modern commercial practice, milk for cheese is normally cooled to 4 ~ immediately after milking and may be held at about this temperature for several days on the farm and at the factory. Apart from being selective for the development of an undesirable psychrotrophic microflora, cold-storage causes physico-chemical changes (e.g., shifts in calcium phosphate equilibrium and dissociation of some micellar caseins) which have undesirable effects on the cheesemaking properties of milk; these changes are reversed on heating, e.g., at 50~ for 10-20 min or under HTST pasteurization conditions and hence are of no practical significance. However, cold storage after heat treatment aggravates the adverse effects of heating on the rennet coagulation of milk; this effect is known as rennet hysteresis. The composition of most cheeses falls within certain compositional ranges, sometimes with legal status. The most important compositional factors are fat-in-dry matter (FDM), moisture in non-fat substances (MNFS; which is, in effect, the ratio of moisture to protein), moisture, salt (best expressed as salt-in-moisture, S/M) and pH. The values for FDM and MNFS are determined
8
Cheese: An Overview
mainly by the composition of the cheesemilk and extent of syneresis, respectively. The composition of milk should be adjusted to give the desired values of fat and protein. Previously, the ratio of fat:protein was altered by natural creaming (which is still used for Parmigiano-Reggiano, Grana Padano and some other Italian cheeses) or by the addition of cream or skim milk. It is now possible, and commercially practiced to an increasing extent, to adjust the concentrations, as well as the ratio, of fat and protein in the cheesemilk by manipulating the fat content of the milk together with protein standardization using low concentration factor ultrafiltration. These operations improve the cheesemaking characteristics of the milk and increase and standardize the yield of curd. Owing to the importance of Ca 2+ in various aspects of cheese manufacture and quality (see 'Rennets: General and Molecular Aspects', 'Rennet-induced Coagulation of Milk' and 'The Syneresis of Rennet-coagulated Curd', Volume 1), it is common practice to supplement cheesemilk with CaC12. pH is also a critical factor in cheesemaking and since the pH of milk varies (e.g., increases with advancing lactation and during mastitic infection), it is recommended that the pH should be standardized, preferably using the acidogen, gluconic acid-g-lactone. Although raw milk is still used in both industrial and farmhouse cheesemaking, most cheesemilk is pasteurized, usually immediately before use. Pasteurization alters the indigenous microflora and facilitates the manufacture of cheese of more uniform quality, but unless due care is exercised, it may damage the rennet coagulability and curd-forming properties of the milk, as will be discussed in 'Rennet-induced Coagulation of Milk', Volume 1. Even when milk is properly pasteurized, the resulting cheese develops a less intense flavour and ripens more slowly than raw milk cheese. Several heatinduced changes, e.g., killing of indigenous microorganisms, inactivation of indigenous milk enzymes and partial denaturation of whey proteins and their interaction with micellar K-casein, could be responsible for these changes. The relative contribution of these factors to the differences between cheeses made from raw or pasteurized milk has been an active area of research in recent years (see Fox et al., 2000; 'The Microbiology of Cheese Ripening', 'Raw Milk Cheeses' and 'Biochemistry of Cheese Ripening: Introduction and Overview', Volume 1). A number of approaches have been used to render cheesemilk free from its indigenous microflora or to inhibit the growth of NSLAB in order to study their contribution to ripening. Non-starter lactic acid bacteria have been removed physically from raw
skim milk by microfiltration (e.g., McSweeney et al., 1993; Beuvier et al., 1997), environmental contamination has been minimized by manufacturing cheese under strictly controlled microbiological conditions (McSweeney et al., 1994), ripening cheese at a low (c. 1 ~ temperature to reduce the growth rate of NSLAB (Shakeel-Ur-Rehman et al., 2000b,c) and the use of antibiotics to inhibit the growth of NSLAB (ShakeelUr-Rehman et al., 1999). Attempts have been made to mimic the NSLAB microflora of raw milk cheese by adding selected strains of NSLAB (see Lynch et al., 1999) to pasteurized cheesemilk or by inoculating pasteurized cheesemilk with raw milk (by blending a low level, e.g., 1%, of raw milk with pasteurized milk; Shakeel-Ur-Rehman et al., 2000a). The results of these studies suggest that heat-induced changes to the microflora of raw milk are the major cause of the differences between raw and pasteurized milk cheeses. However, denaturation of certain indigenous enzymes, particularly lipoprotein lipase, may contribute to the observed differences. Pasteurization of cheesemilk minimizes the risk of cheese serving as a vector for food-poisoning or pathogenic microorganisms, so that even high-quality raw milk may be unacceptable for cheese manufacture. In addition to rendering milk safe from a public health viewpoint, pasteurization renders good quality raw milk almost free of bacteria and improves the consistency of cheese. Pasteurization of milk is essential for the production of cheese of consistent quality in the large, highly mechanized factories that are common today. Although more consistent than cheese made from raw milk, it is also less highly flavoured. To increase the intensity of the flavour of cheese made from pasteurized milk, it is becoming increasingly common to inoculate pasteurized milk with selected organisms, usually lactobacilli, isolated from good quality raw milk cheese (see Lynch etal., 1999; 'Secondary and Adjunct Cultures' and 'The Microbiology of Cheese Ripening', Volume 1). Thermization (--65 ~ • 15 s) of cheesemilk on arrival at the factory is common or standard practice in some countries. The objective of thermization is to control psychrotrophs and the milk is normally pasteurized before cheesemaking. Microfiltration and bactofugation may be used to remove spores from milk to avoid the defect known as late gas blowing (see 'The Microbiology of Cheese Ripening', Volume 1). Not more than 75% of the total protein in milk is recovered in rennet-coagulated cheeses. Obviously, a considerable economic advantage would accrue if some or all of the whey proteins could be incorporated into the cheese. Ultrafiltration (UF) offers a means for accomplishing this, with considerable
Cheese: An Overview
success in the case of semi-soft or soft cheeses, especially Feta and Quarg, but with less success for hard and semi-hard varieties. The application, and associated problems, of UF in cheese manufacture is comprehensively reviewed in 'Application of Membrane Separation Technology to Cheese Production', Volume 1. An alternative approach is to heat denature the whey proteins (e.g., 90 ~ • 1 min) to induce their interaction with the casein micelles. Normally, such severe heat treatments are detrimental to the renneting properties of milk but the effects can be off-set by acidification or supplementation with calcium (see 'Rennet-induced Coagulation of Milk' and 'The Syneresis of Rennet-coagulated Curd', Volume 1). In the authors' experience, yield increases of up to 8% can be achieved by this approach, while retaining acceptable quality. However, to the authors' knowledge, the technique is not used commercially except for Quarg, e.g., the thermo-Quarg process (see 'Acid- and Acid-Rennet-Curd Cheeses: Part A Quark, Cream Cheese and Related Varieties', Part B Cottage Cheese', and Part C 'Acid-heat Coagulated Cheeses', Volume 2). Acidification
One of the basic operations in the manufacture of most, if not all, cheese varieties is a progressive acidification throughout the manufacturing stage, i.e., up to 24 h, and, for some varieties, during the early stages of ripening also, i.e., acidification commences before and transcends the other manufacturing operations. Acidification is normally via in situ production of lactic acid, although pre-formed acid or acidogen (usually gluconic acid-g-lactone) is now used to directly acidify curd for some varieties, e.g., Mozzarella, UF Feta-type and Cottage cheese. Until relatively recently, and still in some cases, especially in artisanal varieties, the indigenous microflora of milk was relied upon for acid production. Since this was probably a mixed microflora, the rate of acid production was unpredictable and the growth of undesirable bacteria led to the production of gas and off-flavours. It is now almost universal practice in industrial cheesemaking to add a culture (starter) of selected lactic acid-producing bacteria to raw or pasteurized cheesemilk to achieve a uniform and predictable rate of acid production. For cheese varieties that are cooked to not more than 40 ~ a starter consisting of Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis and/or Lc. lactis subsp, cremoris is normally used while cultures of Streptococcus therrnophilus and a Lactobacillus spp. (Lb. delbrueckii subsp, bulgaricus, Lb. delbrueckii subsp, casei, Lb. delbrueckii subsp, lactis or Lb. helveticus) or a Lactobacillus culture alone is
9
used for varieties that are 'cooked' to higher temperatures, e.g., Swiss and hard Italian varieties. Probably the earliest form of starters were 'slopback' c u l t u r e s - a sample of whey from one day's cheesemaking was incubated overnight and used as a starter culture on the following day. Such starters are still used for some high-cook cheese varieties (e.g., Parmigiano-Reggiano and Grana Padano). Incubation of hot whey is selective for thermophilic microorganisms and although slop-back cultures are very heterogeneous, they work well if managed carefully. Originally, and still for many varieties, mixed-strain mesophilic starters were used for low-cook cheese. Because the bacterial strains in these starters may be phage-related (i.e., subject to infection by a single strain of bacteriophage) and also because the strains in the mixture may be incompatible, thereby leading to the dominance of one or a few strains, the rate of acid production by mixed-strain starters is variable and unpredictable, even when the utmost care in their selection and handling is exercised. To overcome these problems, single-strain mesophilic starters were introduced in New Zealand about 1935. Unfortunately, many of the fast acid-producing, single-strain starters produced bitter cheese, the cause(s) of which will be discussed in 'Starter Cultures: General Aspects', Volume 1. This problem was resolved by using selected pairs of fast and slow acid producers. Defined-strain mesophilic starters are widely used in many countries, frequently consisting of a combination of 2-6 selected, phage-unrelated strains which give very reproducible rates of acid production if properly selected and maintained. The use of defined-strain thermophilic starters is becoming more common. The science and technology of starters have become highly developed and specialized; 'Starter Cultures: General Aspects', Volume 1, is devoted to these developments. Acid production at the appropriate rate and time is the key step in the manufacture of good quality cheese (excluding the enzymatic coagulation of the milk, which is a sine qua non for rennet-coagulated cheese varieties). Acid production affects several aspects of cheese manufacture, many of which will be discussed in more detail in later chapters, i.e.: 9 Coagulant activity during coagulation. 9 Denaturation and retention of the coagulant in the curd during manufacture and hence the level of residual coagulant in the curd; this influences the rate of proteolysis during ripening, and may affect cheese quality. 9 Strength of the coagulum, which influences cheese yield.
10
Cheese: An Overview
9 Gel syneresis, which controls cheese moisture and hence regulates the growth of bacteria and the activity of enzymes in the cheese; consequently, it strongly influences the rate and pattern of ripening and the quality of the finished cheese. 9 The rate of pH decrease determines the extent of dissolution of colloidal calcium phosphate which modifies the susceptibility of the caseins to proteolysis during manufacture, influences the rheological properties of the cheese, e.g., compare the texture of Emmental, Gouda, Cheddar and Cheshire cheese, and determines the meltability and stretchability of cheese curd (e.g., Mozzarella and Pizza cheese). 9 Acidification controls the growth of many species of bacteria in cheese, especially pathogenic, food poisoning and gas-producing microorganisms; in fact, properly made cheese is a very safe product from the public health viewpoint. In addition to producing acid, many starter bacteria produce bacteriocins that also restrict or inhibit the growth of non-starter microorganisms.
'Salt in Cheese: Physical, Chemical and Biological Aspects', Volume 1. In a few special cases, e.g., Domiati, a high level of NaC1 (10-12%) is added to the cheesemilk, traditionally to control the growth of the indigenous microflora. This concentration of NaC1 has a major influence, not only on acid development, but also on rennet coagulation, gel strength and syneresis (cf., 'Rennet-induced Coagulation of Milk' and 'The Syneresis of Rennet-coagulated Curd', Volume 1).
Mesophilic Lactococcus spp. are capable of reducing the pH of cheese to - 4 . 6 and Lactobacillus spp. to somewhat lower values, perhaps 3.8. The natural ultimate pH of cheese curd falls within the range 4.6-5.1. However, the period required to attain the ultimate pH varies from --5 h for Cheddar to 6-12 h for Blue, Dutch and Swiss varieties. The differences arise from the amount of starter added to the cheesemilk (0.2-5%), the cooking temperature and schedule which may retard the growth of the starter microorganisms and the rate of subsequent cooling of the curd. The level and method of salting have a major influence on pH changes in cheese. The concentration of NaC1 in cheese (commonly 0.7-4%, i.e., 2-10% salt in the moisture phase) is sufficient to halt the growth of starter bacteria. Some varieties, mostly of British origin, are salted by mixing dry salt with the curd towards the end of manufacture and hence the pH of curd for these varieties must be close to the ultimate value (---pH 5.1) at salting. However, most varieties are salted after moulding by immersion in brine or by application of dry salt on the surface; as discussed in 'Salt in Cheese: Physical, Chemical and Biological Aspects', Volume 1, salt diffusion in cheese moisture is a slow process and thus there is ample time for the pH to decrease to - 5 . 0 before the salt concentration becomes inhibitory. The pH of the curd for most cheese varieties, e.g., Swiss, Dutch, Tilsit, Blue, etc., is 6.2-6.5 at moulding and pressing but decreases to - 5 during or shortly after pressing and before salting. The significance of various aspects of the concentration and distribution of NaC1 in cheese will be discussed in
The majority of cheeses are produced by enzymatic (rennet) coagulation. With a few exceptions (e.g., Serra da Estrela (Portugal) in which acid proteinases from the flowers of the cardoon thistle, Cynara cardunculus, are used), acid (aspartyl) proteinases of animal or fungal origin are used. Rennet from the stomachs of young animals (calves, kids, lambs, buffalo) was used traditionally. The principal enzyme in rennet prepared from young animal stomachs is chymosin ('--95% of total milk-clotting activity), with a little pepsin. However, limited supplies of such rennets (due to the birth of fewer calves and an increasing trend in many countries to slaughter calves at an older age than previously), concomitant with a worldwide increase in cheese production, have led to a shortage of calf rennet and consequently rennet substitutes (usually bovine or porcine pepsins and less frequently, chicken pepsin, and the acid proteinases from Rhizomucor miehei and less frequently R. pusillus or Cryphonectria parasitica) are now used widely for cheese manufacture in many countries with more or less satisfactory results. The calf chymosin gene has been cloned in Kbryveromyces lactis, E. coli and Aspergillus niger and chymosin from these organisms is now widely used. Reviews on rennet substitutes include Sardinas (1972), Ernstrom and Wong (1974), Nelson (1975), Sternberg (1976), Green (1977), De Koning (1979), Phelan (1985), Fox and McSweeney (1997). The molecular and enzymatic properties of calf chymosin and other acid proteinases used as rennets are reviewed in detail in 'Rennets: General and Molecular Aspects', Volume 1.
Coagulation
The essential characteristic step in the manufacture of all cheese varieties is coagulation of the casein component of the milk protein system to form a gel which entraps the fat, if present. Coagulation may be achieved by: 9 limited proteolysis by selected proteinases; 9 acidification to pH --~4.6; 9 acidification to about pH 5.2 in combination with heating to - 9 0 ~
Cheese: An Overview
Although it appears to have been recognized since 1917 (see Berridge, 1942) that milk is not coagulated by rennet at low temperatures, Berridge (1942) is usually credited with clearly demonstrating that the rennetcatalysed coagulation of milk occurs in two phases: a primary enzymatic phase and a secondary nonenzymatic phase. The primary phase has a temperature coefficient (Q10) of---2 and occurs in the range 0-50 ~ while the secondary phase has a Q10 of --~16 and occurs very slowly or not all at temperatures <---18 ~ The two phases can thus be readily separated by performing the primary phase at a low temperature, e.g., --~10 ~ when cold-renneted milk is warmed, coagulation occurs very quickly. Cold renneting, followed by rapid warming, forms the basis of attempts to develop methods for the continuous coagulation of milk but such approaches have not been successful commercially. Normally, the two phases of rennet coagulation overlap to some extent, the magnitude of overlap being quite extensive at low pH, high temperature and in milk concentrated by ultrafiltration. The primary phase of rennet action appears to have been recognized, in general terms, by Hammersten, during the period 1880-1890, who reported the formation of small peptides during renneting. Richmond (1899) described the action of rennet as follows: 'the action of rennet is to split the casein into a dyscaseose, the calcium salt of which is insoluble and which forms a curd, and a soluble caseose; the insoluble curd carries down with it a large portion of the fat.' The coagulation of milk attracted quite a lot of interest during the early part of the twentieth century. For example, Alexander (1910, 1912) proposed that the casein in milk exists as an unstable colloid which is protected and stabilized by the whey protein, lactalbumin (He was probably the first to use the idea of a 'protective colloid' in casein chemistry); he proposed that rennet coagulated milk by hydrolysing (destroying) the protective colloid. The protective colloid (Schutzcolloid) hypothesis of the colloidal stability of casein and the rennet coagulation of milk was supported by Marui (1926) and Linderstr~m-Lang (1929) but not by Palmer and Richardson (1925) and Palmer (1935) who claimed that increased sensitivity of rennetaltered casein was responsible for the rennet-induced coagulation of milk rather than the destruction of a protective colloid. The early literature on the rennet coagulation of milk was reviewed by Palmer and Richardson (1925) and Palmer (1935) and in a long series of articles in Le Lait by Porcher (1929, 1930, 1931). However, a full explanation of the process had to await the isolation of the casein micelle-protective protein, n-casein, by Waugh and von Hippel (1956). These workers showed that the protective capacity of
11
K-casein was destroyed on renneting and Wake (1959) demonstrated that K-casein is the only milk protein hydrolysed during the primary phase of rennet action. Only one peptide bond, Phel05~Metl06, is hydrolysed (Delfour et al., 1965), resulting in the release of the hydrophilic C-terminal segment of K-casein (the (caseino)macropeptides, some of which are glycosylated). The unique sensitivity of the P h e ~ M e t bond of K-casein, hydrolysis of which occurs optimally at pH 5.1-5.5 has been the subject of extensive study since 1965 and this work is reviewed in 'Rennetinduced Coagulation of Milk', Volume 1. The visual coagulation of milk is really only the start of the gelation process which continues for a considerable period thereafter. Although these post-coagulation changes determine many of the critical cheesemaking properties of the gel, e.g., curd tension (which influences cheese yield) and syneresis properties (which determine the moisture content and hence the ripening profile of the cheese), it is perhaps the least well-understood phase of the cheesemaking process. The recent literature on aspects of the post-visual coagulation phase is reviewed in 'Rennet-induced Coagulation of Milk' and 'The Syneresis of Rennet-coagulated Curd', Volume 1. Post-coagulation operations
A rennet-coagulated milk gel is quite stable if maintained under quiescent conditions but if it is cut or broken, it syneresis rapidly, expelling whey. The rate and extent of syneresis are influenced, inter alia, by how finely the coagulum is cut (small pieces promote syneresis; the coagulum for high-moisture cheeses is not cut but is ladeled into moulds), milk composition, especially [Ca 2+] and [casein], pH, cooking temperature, rate of stirring of the curd-whey mixture and of course, time (see 'The Syneresis of Rennet-coagulated Curd', Volume 1). The composition of the finished cheese is to a very large degree determined by the extent of syneresis and since this is under the control of the cheesemaker, the differentiation of the individual cheese varieties really begins at this stage, although the composition of cheesemilk, the amount and type of starter and the amount and type of rennet are also significant in this regard. The temperature to which the curds are cooked varies from ---30 ~ (i.e., no cooking) for high-moisture cheeses (e.g., Camembert) to ---55 ~ for low-moisture cheese (e.g., Parmigiano-Reggiano). After cooking, the curds and whey are separated by various, variety-specific techniques. The curds for most varieties are transferred to moulds where further drainage and acidification occur. Curds that have undergone extensive syneresis in the vat (i.e., have a
12
Cheese: An Overview
low moisture content) are pressed in the moulds, sometimes according to a programmed increase in pressure, with the objective of fusing the curds and rendering the cheeses free from mechanical openings and reducing the moisture content further. The curds for two families of cheese, Cheddar and pasta-filata, are subjected to special treatments prior to moulding. Cheddar-type cheese undergoes a process called 'cheddaring'. In the traditional process, the drained curds are piled into two beds in the vat, separated by a channel for whey drainage. The beds of curd are cut into blocks, - 1 0 cm side, which are inverted every 15 min and later piled two or three blocks high. This process continues for ---2 h until the pH decreases to ---5.4. During cheddaring, the blocks of curd flow slightly and the cheese acquires a fibrous texture similar to that of cooked chicken breast meat. In the modern mechanized process, the drained curds are transferred pneumatically to a tower (---10 m tall) or to a moving belt; in the tower or on the belt, the mass of curds flows slightly but much less than in the traditional process. Previously, it was believed that the flow during cheddaring was essential for the texture of Cheddar, but it is likely that the most important change during cheddaring is acidification which dissolves the CCP - when the Ca:protein ratio decreases to a certain value, the texture assumes the characteristics of Cheddar cheese. The manufacture of Mozzarella curd is similar to that for Cheddar up to the point at which the pH decreases to ---5.4. The acidified curds are then heated in hot water to 60-65 ~ kneaded and stretched. It is claimed that the kneading and stretching are essential for the characteristic fibrous texture and stretchability of Mozzarella. However, it may be that the function of heating and kneading is simply to inactivate enzymes and kill bacteria and, in effect, to stabilize the characteristics of the cheese. Heating and kneading were probably introduced originally to control the microflora of cheese curd produced from milk of poor microbiological quality. The unique manufacturing schedule for the specific varieties is not considered in this book and the interested reader is referred to appropriate texts (e.g., Van Slyke and Price, 1949; Davis, 1965, 1967; Kosikowski, 1977; Eck, 1984; Scott, 1986; Robinson, 1995; Kosikowski and Mistry, 1997; Robinson and Wilbey, 1998; Eck and Gilles, 2000). Some chemical and physico-chemical aspects of the manufacture of the major cheese families are discussed in Volume 2. Flow diagrams for some important cheese varieties are shown in Fig. 2. The last manufacturing operation is salting. While salting contributes to syneresis ( - 2 kg H 2 0 are lost per kg NaC1 taken up), it should not be used as a means of
controlling the moisture content of cheese. Salt has several functions in cheese which are described in 'Salt in Cheese: Physical, Chemical and Biological Aspects', Volume 1. Although salting should be a very simple operation, quite frequently it is not performed properly, with consequent adverse effects on cheese quality. As indicated previously, cheese manufacture is essentially a dehydration process. With the development of ultrafiltration as a concentration process, it was obvious that this process would have applications in cheese manufacture, e.g., for standardizing cheesemilk with respect to fat and casein, or for the preparation of a concentrate with the composition of the finished cheese, commonly referred to as 'pre-cheese'. Standardization of cheesemilk by adding UF concentrate (retentate) is now common in some countries and the manufacture of precheese has been successful commercially for a range of soft and semi-soft cheese varieties (see 'Application of Membrane Separation Technology to Cheese Production', Volume 1). Ripening
Some cheeses, mainly acid-coagulated varieties, are consumed fresh and such cheeses constitute a major proportion of the cheese consumed in some countries; the principal acid-curd cheeses are described in ' A c i d - a n d Acid-Rennet-Curd Cheeses: Part A Quark, Cream Cheese and Related Varieties', Part B Cottage Cheese' and Part C 'Acid-heat Coagulated Cheeses', Volume 2. However, most cheese varieties undergo a period of ripening (curing, maturation) which varies from - 2 weeks (e.g., for Mozzarella) to :>2 years (e.g., Parmigiano-Reggiano or extramature Cheddar), the duration of ripening being generally inversely related to the moisture content of the cheese. Many varieties may be consumed at any of the several stages of maturity, depending on the flavour preferences of consumers and economic factors. Although curds for different cheese varieties are recognizably different at the end of manufacture (mainly as a result of compositional and textural differences arising from differences in milk compositional and processing factors), the unique characteristics of the individual cheeses develop during ripening, although in most cases the biochemical changes that occur during ripening, and hence the flavour, aroma and texture of the mature cheese, are largely pre-determined by the manufacturing process, i.e., by composition, especially moisture, NaC1 and pH, by the type of starter and in many cases by secondary inocula added to, or gaining access to, the cheesemilk or curd.
v-o
-
it"
r._ rr
?
rn
"0
~
m Q)
o e._~
oo
D
,-~ i
.. ~)
~0
~-
0
Q)
0
-
~
o
I
cO
r
~
"0
Q)
r
:Z:
o
>"
~
"0=)!' ~o
6
o
o-
o
o'
~1
~
.z
~
~"
"
~
o ~
.~-~o .
~ o o~
o,
~
~'
d
m
o ,.~
~176 ~ i - -
~
,oo~
,~
E
"i
a..
.~.~
o
t
___
"0
~0
"r
,-
~
~ o
=-on =
.~_
oo
~ "-
=~=
a'~
" e,~
o~
"= |
_~ 0_
o,
o oeo ~
-- ".-.-,-8
~'
I~ ~o
~ - - ~ - - ~ - - ="
-
'
~
r-'l
"~ |
~
~
- - o~ o - - ~=
~o~
-
~o|
(
r
I
~
~
-"0
o~
~ ~,
o
o~ "~o
"~
o
0 8 .__o ~-
~
~
~'
~- ~
"d
o o
~
(.)
!
~ &d
o~
I
o ,.9,o
"0 cffl
0 .~.
~o o
.~.
~g ~o o
o,-
~.~ .~ ~.~
_-
">'
~
o~
.9-~ "'r 9 0
o
E~., ~:~..
._N "0
8 ~o.
~
q
o~ 9~,~.~.-o :5o_
~
g 4 g
oO e-
'-
I
i
"~
7. e-
~
I
o6 t~ (D cO 0 c._ O~ O~ (1) 0 t--
rr
. tO _ O~
E n -o -o c(0
o
(0 "13
o v
co
c-
E E U.I ..Q ~4
(D t-
o
0
0
._ "0
U_
L_
lie
13
14 Cheese: An Overview During ripening, an extremely complex set of biochemical changes occur through the catalytic action of the following agents: 9 coagulant; 9 indigenous milk enzymes, especially plasmin and lipoprotein lipase, which are particularly important in cheese made from raw milk; 9 starter bacteria and their enzymes; 9 secondary microflora and their enzymes. This secondary microflora may arise from the adventitious microorganisms in milk that survive pasteurization or gain entry to the milk after pasteurization, e.g., Lactobacillus, Pediococcus, Micrococcus, or they may be inoculated as secondary starter, e.g., Propionibacterium in Swiss cheese, Penicillium roqueforti in Blue varieties, P. camemberti in Camembert or Brie, or the cheese may acquire a surface microflora from the environment during ripening, e.g., the complex Gram-positive microflora of smear-ripened cheeses such as Tilsit, Limburger, etc. In many cases, the characteristics of the finished cheese are dominated by the metabolic activity of these microorganisms. The primary biochemical changes which occur during ripening involve the metabolism of residual lactose and of lactate and citrate, lipolysis and proteolysis which are described in 'Biochemistry of Cheese Ripening: Introduction and Overview', 'Metabolism of Residual Lactose and of Lactate and Citrate', 'Lipolysis and Catabolism of Fatty Acids in Cheese', 'Proteolysis in Cheese during Ripening', Volume 1. These primary changes are followed and overlapped by a host of secondary catabolic changes, including the various reactions involving amino acid catabolism (transamination, deamination, decarboxylation and various lyase activities 'Catabolism of Amino Acids in Cheese During Ripening', Volume 1), fatty acid catabolism and related reactions (]3-oxidation of fatty acids, esterification, formation of thioesters) and the catabolism of lactic acid to CO2 and H20 or the propionic, acetic or butyric acids and CO2 or H2. While it is not possible to review the biochemistry involved in the ripening of all individual cheese varieties, an overview of the principal ripening reactions is presented in 'Biochemistry of Cheese Ripening: Introduction and Overview', 'Metabolism of Residual Lactose and of Lactate and Citrate', 'Lipolysis and Catabolism of Fatty Acids in Cheese', 'Proteolysis in Cheese during Ripening', 'Catabolism of Amino Acids in Cheese During Ripening', Volume 1. The rheological properties of cheese are reviewed in 'Rheology and Texture of Cheese', Volume 1. Microbiological changes which occur during ripening are discussed
in 'The Microbiology of Cheese Ripening', Volume 1 and the volatile flavour compounds in cheese and sensory properties of cheese are discussed in 'Sensory Character of Cheese and its Evaluation' and 'Instrumental Techniques', respectively, of Volume 1. More detailed discussions of specific aspects of the ripening of the principal families of cheese, extra-hard varieties, Cheddar, Gouda, Swiss-type cheese, mould ripened varieties, pasta-filata cheeses and sheep's and goats' milk are given in Volume 2 together with discussion of processed cheese products and the uses of cheese as a food ingredient. While most people consume cheese principally for its organoleptic qualities, it must be remembered that cheese is a very valuable source of nutrients, especially protein, calcium and phosphorus; see 'Nutritional Aspects of Cheese', Volume 1. Cheese is the quintessential convenience food which can be consumed in many forms without preparation. In addition, a large proportion of cheese (50-70%) is used as an ingredient (see 'Cheese as an Ingredient', Volume 2) or converted to more stable, more convenient products by heat treatment to yield processed cheeses which are discussed in 'Pasteurized Processed Cheese and Substitute/Imitation Cheese Products', Volume 2.
C h e e s e Production and C o n s u m p t i o n World cheese production was ---16.5 • 100 tonnes in 2002 and has increased at an average annual rate of---3% over the past 20 years. Europe, with a production of "--8.7 • 106 tonnes per annum ('--53% of world production) is the largest producing region; North and Central America produces - 2 8 % of world cheese. The production of cheese by country and region are shown in Table 2. Cheese consumption varies widely between countries, even within Europe; it is noteworthy that with the exceptions of Israel and the Dutch Antilles, no Asian, African or South American country is listed among the top 23 cheese-consuming countries (Table 3). Cheese consumption in most countries for which data are available has increased considerably since 1970. Thus, while cheese manufacture is practised worldwide, it is apparent from Tables 2 and 3 that cheese is primarily a product of European countries and those populated by European emigrants. However, cheese in some form is produced in most countries throughout the world and some interesting minor varieties are produced in 'non-dairying' countries (see Phelan et al., 1993).
Cheese: An O v e r v i e w
Table 2
15
Production of all types of cheese (tonnes) in 2001 (source: www.FAO.org)
World
Africa Asia Europe (total) European Union (15) North and Central America South America Oceania Developed countries Developing countries Albania Algeria Angola Argentina Armenia Australia Austria Azerbaijan, Republic of Bangladesh Belarus Belgium-Luxembourg Bhutan Bolivia Bosnia and Herzegovina Botswana Brazil Bulgaria Canada Chile China Colombia Costa Rica Croatia Cuba Cyprus Czech Republic Denmark Dominican Republic Ecuador Egypt El Salvador Eritrea Estonia Ethiopia Finland France Georgia Germany Greece Guatemala Honduras Hungary Iceland Iran, Islamic Rep of Iraq
16507068
704227 1039789 8674772 6834006 4653978 709686 724615 14145817 2361251 12050 1540 1230 420000 2616 444000 145320 10750 1000 54497 65000 44 6834 8700 2214 38500 46150 359720 57184 217250 52500 6861 21879 14500 5030 139074 300000 2500 7265 465000 2400 312 15500 3975 106000 1666850 75 1773000 236200 11100 8975 89240 4860 199168 30586
Ireland Israel Italy Japan Jordan Kazakhstan Kenya Kyrgyzstan Latvia Lebanon Lithuania Macedonia,The Fmr Yug Rp Malta Mauritania Mexico Moldova, Republic of Mongolia Morocco Myanmar Namibia Netherlands, The New Zealand Nicaragua Niger Nigeria Norway Oman Panama Peru Poland Portugal Romania Russian Federation Slovakia Slovenia South Africa Spain Sudan Sweden Switzerland Syrian Arab Republic Tajikistan Tanzania, United Rep of Tunisia Turkey Turkmenistan Ukraine United Kingdom United States of America Uruguay Uzbekistan Venezuela, Boliv Rep of Yemen Yugoslavia, Fed Rep of Zambia Zimbabwe
9375O 102029 1020712 123000 3662 6750 210 3500 12400 21564 57900 1540 282 2058 153861 5250 1260 7716 31976 7O 660000 280615 13195 14655 6955 81700 824 7866 8934 460100 72800 37500 433000 54660 21684 36000 180374 151000 132000 162300 93475 6715 2000 6420 126156 1600 109000 382000 4073000 29320 20675 89150 11185 11500 773 2100
16
Cheese: An Overview
Table 3
Supply of cheese (kg per caput per annum) in 2000 (source: www.FAO.org)
World Greece France Netherlands, The Italy Austria Germany Sweden Israel Netherlands Antilles Iceland Denmark Norway United States of America Switzerland Finland Belgium-Luxembourg Czech Republic Estonia Malta Argentina Canada Poland New Zealand Lebanon Slovakia Australia United Kingdom Hungary Portugal Ireland Slovenia Egypt Kuwait Spain Bermuda Barbados Cyprus Saint Lucia Syrian Arab Republic Grenada Croatia Lithuania French Polynesia New Caledonia Sudan Bulgaria Trinidad and Tobago Venezuela, Boliv Rep of Albania Panama Latvia United Arab Emirates Bahamas Belarus Belize Bosnia and Herzegovina Chile
2.6 25.4 23.6 22.5 20.5 19.2 18.9 17.4 16.7 16.2 15.5 15.1 15.1 14.9 14.8 14.1 13.7 13.5 13.1 13.0 12.2 11.8 11.1 10.2 9.7 9.4 9.2 9.2 8.9 8.8 8.5 8.1 7.0 6.7 6.3 6.0 5.8 5.7 5.5 5.4 5.3 5.2 5.0 4.8 4.8 4.8 4.5 4.3 4.2 4.1 4.1 3.9 3.9 3.8 3.8 3.8 3.7 3.7
Iran, Islamic Rep of Russian Federation Saudi Arabia Uruguay Botswana Japan Antigua and Barbuda Swaziland Jordan Mauritius Mexico Turkey Macedonia,The Fmr Yug Rp Dominica Romania Saint Vincent/Grenadines El Salvador Cuba Honduras Libyan Arab Jamahiriya Jamaica Costa Rica Guyana Iraq Ukraine Yugoslavia, Fed Rep of Azerbaijan, Republic of Niger Colombia Guatemala Moldova, Republic of Saint Kitts and Nevis Suriname Taji kistan Uzbekistan Seychelles South Africa Tunisia Yemen Bolivia Mauritania Algeria Armenia Dominican Republic Kyrgyzstan Myanmar Ecuador Korea, Republic of Nicaragua Cape Verde Kazakhstan Mongolia Brunei Darussalam Fiji Islands Maldives Morocco Paraguay Peru
3.0 2.9 2.8 2.8 2.7 2.6 2.3 2.3 2.2 2.2 2.0 2.0 1.9 1.8 1.8 1.8 1.7 1.6 1.6 1.6 1.5 1.4 1.4 1.4 1.4 1.4 1.3 1.3 1.2 1.2 1.2 1.2 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.0 0.9 0.9 0.9 0.8 0.8 0.7 0.7 0.7 0.7 0.7 0.6 0.6 0.6 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.4 0.4 0.4 0.4 0.4 0.4
Brazil Gabon Turkmenistan Vanuatu China Malaysia Philippines Zimbabwe Angola Djibouti Eritrea Ethiopia Gambia Georgia Haiti Kiribati Lesotho Liberia Nigeria Senegal Tanzania, United Rep of Zambia Bangladesh Benin Burkina Faso Burundi Cambodia Cameroon Central African Republic Chad Comoros Congo, Dem Republic of Congo, Republic of C6te d'lvoire Ghana Guinea Guinea-Bissau India Indonesia Kenya Madagascar Malawi Mali Mozambique Namibia Nepal Pakistan Papua New Guinea Sao Tome and Principe Sierra Leone Solomon Islands Sri Lanka Thailand Togo Uganda Viet Nam
0.3 0.3 0.3 0.3 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Cheese: An Overview
References Alexander, J. (1910). Some colloid- chemical aspects of digestion, with ultramicroscopic observations. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 32,680-687. Alexander, J. (1912). The rennin coagulation of milk from a colloid - chemical standpoint. Proc. 8th Int. Congress Appl. Chem. pp. 12-14. Anifantakis, E.M. (1991). Greek Cheeses: A Tradition of Centuries. National Dairy Committee of Greece, Athens. Berger, W., Klostermeyer, H., Merkenich, K. and Uhlmann, G. (1989). Die Schmalzkascherstellung. BK Ladenburg, Ladenburg, Germany. Berridge, NJ. (1942). The second phase of rennet coagulation. Nature 149, 194-195. Beuvier, E., Berthaud, K., Cegarra, S., Dasen, A., Pochet, S., Buchin, S. and Duboz, G. (1997). Ripening and quality of Swiss-type cheese made from raw, pasteurized or microfiltered milk. Int. Dairy J. 7, 311-323. Buch Kristensen, J.M. (1995). Cheese Technology - A Northern European Approach. International Dairy Books, Aarhus, Denmark. Burkhaher, G. (1981). Catalogue of Cheeses. Document 141. International Dairy Federation, Brussels. Cantin, C. (1976). Guide Pratique des Fromages. Solar Editeur, Paris. Cheke, V. (1959). The Story of Cheesemaking in Britain. Routledge & Kegan Paul, London. Christian, G. (1984). World Guide to Cheese (English translation by S. Harris). Amoldo Mondadori Editore S.p.A., Milan. Davies, EL. and Law, B.A., eds (1984). Advances in the Microbiology and Biochemistry of Cheese and Fermented Milk. Elsevier, London. Davis, J.G. (1965). Cheese, Vol. 1, Basic Technology: Vol. 2: Bibliography. Churchill Livingstone, London. Davis, J.G. (1967). Cheese, Vol. III, Manufacturing Methods: Vol. IV: Bibliography. Churchill Livingstone, London, 1976, Paddington Press Ltd., London. De Koning, P.J. (1979). Rennet and its substitutes. Document 126. International Dairy Federation, Brussels. pp. 11-15. Delfour, A.,Jolles, J., Alais, C. andJolles, P. (1965). Caseino-glycopeptides: characterization of a methionine residue and of the N-terminal sequence. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 19,452-455. Eck, A., ed. (1984). Le Fromage. Lavoisier, Paris. Eck, A. and Gilles, J.-C. (2000). Cheesemaking from Science to Quality Assurance. Technique and Documentation, Paris. Eekhof-Stork, N. (1976). World Atlas of Cheese. Paddington Press Ltd, London. Ernstrom, C.A. and Wong, N.P. (1974). Milk clotting enzymes and cheese chemistry, in, Fundamentals of Dairy Chemistry, 2nd edn, Webb, B.H., Johnson A.H. and Alford, J.A., eds, AVI Publishing Co. Inc., Westport, CT. pp. 662-771. Fox, P.E, ed. (1982). Developments in Dairy Chemistry- 1 Proteins. Applied Science Publishers, London. Fox, P.E, ed. (1983). Developments in Dairy Chemistry- 2 Lipids. Applied Science Publishers, London. Fox, P.E, ed. (1985). Developments in Dairy Chemistry- 3 Lactose and Minor Constituents. Elsevier, London.
17
Fox, P.E, ed. (1987). Cheese: Chemistry, Physics and Microbiology, Vols 1 and 2. Elsevier, London. Fox, P.E, ed. (1992). Advanced Dairy Chemistry, Vol. 1, Proteins. Elsevier, London. Fox, P.E, ed. (1993). Cheese: Chemistry, Physics and Microbiology, Vols 1 and 2, 2nd ed. Chapman & Hall, London. Fox, RE, ed. (1995). Advanced Dairy Chemistry, Vol. 2, Lipids. Chapman & Hall, London. Fox, P.E, ed. (1997). Advanced Dairy Chemistry, Vol. 3, Lactose, Water, Salts and Vitamins. Chapman & Hall, London. Fox, P.E and McSweeney, P.L.H. (1997). Rennets: their role in milk coagulation and cheese ripening, in, Microbiology and Biochemistry of Cheese and Fermented Milk, 2nd edn, Law, B.A., ed., Blackie Academic and Professional, Glasgow. pp. 1-49. Fox, P.E and McSweeney, P.L.H. (1998). Dairy Chemistry and Biochemistry. Blackie Academic and Professional, London. Fox, P.E and McSweeney, P.L.H., eds (2003). Advanced Dairy Chemistry, Vol. 1, Proteins. Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, New York. Fox, P.E, Guirlee, T.P., Cogan, T.M. and McSweeney, P.L.H. (2000). Fundamentals of Cheese Science. Aspen Publishers, Gaithersburg, MD. Fraser, S. (1960). The Cheeses of Old England. Abelard-Schuman, London. Gonzalez, M.A. and del Cerro, C.G. (1988). Quesos de Espafia. Espasa-Calpe, S.A., Madrid. Green, M.L. (1977). Milk coagulants. J. Dairy Res. 44, 159-188. Harbutt, J. (1999). A Cook's Guide to Cheese. Anness Publishing Ltd, London. Harbutt, J. (2002). The World Encyclopedia of Cheese. Anness Publishing Ltd, London. Hoffmann, E (1761). A Treatise on the Virtues and Uses of Whey. L. Davis and C. Reymers, London. pp. 1-34. Jenkins, S. (1996). Cheese Primer. Workman Publishing, New York. Kammerlehner, J. (2003). Kdsetechnologie. Verlag Reisinger Kuenstlerpresse W Bode, Frising. Kosikowski, EV. (1977). Cheese and Fermented Milk Foods. Edwards Bros, Inc., Ann Arbor, MI. Kosikowski, EV. and Mistry, V.V. (1997). Cheese and Fermented Milk Foods, Vols 1 and 2, 3rd edn, Kosikowski, EV., ed., LLC, Westport, CT. Kosikowski, EV. and Mocquot, G. (1958). Advances in Cheese Technology. FAO Studies 38, FAO, Rome. Law, B.A., ed. (1997). Microbiology and Biochemistry of Cheese and Fermented Milk, 2nd edn, Blackie Academic and Professional, London. Law, B.A., ed. (1999). The Technology of Cheesemaking. Sheffield Academic Press, Sheffield. Layton, J.A. (1973). The Cheese Handbook. Dover Publications Inc., New York. Linderstr~m-Lang, K. (1929). Studies on casein. III. On the fraction of casein. Comptes-rendus des Travaux du Laboratoire Carlsberg 17(9), 1-116. Lynch, C.M., Muir, D.D., Banks, J.M., McSweeney, P.L.H. and Fox, P.E (1999). Influence of adjunct cultures of Lactobacillus paracasei ssp. paracasei or Lactobacillus plantarum on Cheddar cheese ripening.J. Dairy Sci. 82, 1618-1628.
18
Cheese: An Overview
MacAlister, A. (1904). Food, in, A Dictionary of the Bible Dealing with Its Language, Literature and Contents, Including Biblical Theology, Vol. 2, Hastings, H., ed., T and T Clark, Edinburgh. pp. 27-43. Mair-Waldburg, H. (1974). Handbook of Cheese: Cheeses of the World A to Z. Volkwertschaftlecher Verlag GmBH, Kempten Allgan, Germany. Marui, S. (1926). Unterschungen Ober des halferment. III. Mitteilung die ersetzerkeit der phosphate druch andre substance. Biochem. Z. 173, 381-388. Masui, K. and Yamada, T. (1996). French Cheeses. Dorling Kindersley, London. McSweeney, P.L.H., Fox, P.E, Lucey, J.A., Jordan, K.N. and Cogan, T.M. (1993). Contribution of the indigenous microflora to the maturation of Cheddar cheese. Int. Dairy j. 3,613-634. McSweeney, P.L.H., Walsh, E.M., Fox, P.E, Cogan, T.M., Drinan, ED. and Castelo-Gonzalez, M. (1994). A procedure for the manufacture of Cheddar cheese under controlled bacteriological conditions and the effect of adjunct lactobacilli on cheese quality. IrishJ. Agric. Food Res. 33, 183-192. Meyer, A. (1973). Processed Cheese Manufacture. Food Trade Press, London. Montandon, J. (1981). Kdse aus der Schweiz. Edita SA, Lausanne, Switzerland. Nelson, J.H. (1975). Application of enzyme technology to dairy manufacturing. J. Dairy Sci. 58, 1739-1750. Ottogalli, G. (2001). Atlante dei Formaggi. Ulrico Hoepli, Milan. Palmer, L.S. (1935). Coagulation of milk, in, Fundamentals of Dairy Science. Associates of Lore, A. Rogers, Reinhold Publishing Corp., New York. pp. 205-249. Palmer, L.S. and Richardson, G.A. (1925). The colloidal chemistry of rennet coagulation. Third Colloid Symposium Monograph. Chemical Catalogue Co. Inc., New York. pp. 112-134. Phelan, J.A. (1985). Milk Coagulants- An Evaluation of Alternatives to Standard Calf Rennet. PhD Thesis. National University of Ireland, Cork. Phelan, J.A., Renaud, J. and Fox, RE (1993). Some nonEuropean cheese varieties, in, Cheese: Chemistry, Physics and Microbiology, Vol. 1, 2nd edn, Fox, RE, ed., Chapman & Hall, London. pp. 421-465. Porcher, C. (1929). La methode synthetique dans l'etude du lait, le lait au point de vue colloidal, recherches sue le mechanisme de Faction de la pressure. Le Lait 9 (several articles). Porcher, C. (1930). La methode synthetique dans l'etude du lait, le lait au point de vue colloidal, recherches sue le mechanisme de Faction de la pressure. Le Lait I0 (several articles). Porcher, C. (1931). La methode synthetique dans l'etude du lait, le lait au point de vue colloidal, recherches sue le mechanisme de l'action de la pressure. Le Lait 11 (several articles). Rance, P. (1982). The Great British Cheese Book. Macmillan, London. Resmini, P., Pompei, C., Volonterio, G., Lembo, P., Lodi, R., Riva, M. and Spedicato, E. (1992). I Prodotti Caseari del Mezzogiorno. Consiglio Nationale delle Ricerche, Roma.
Richmond, H.D. (1899). Dairy Chemistry: A Practical Handbook. Charles Griffin and Co. Ltd, London. Robinson, R.K., ed. (1995). A Colour Guide to Cheese and Fermented Milk. Chapman & Hall, London. Robinson, R.K. and Tamime, A.Y. (1991). Feta and Related Cheeses. Ellis Horwood Ltd, Chichester. Robinson, R.K. and Wilbey, R.A. (1998). Cheesemaking Practice, 3rd edn, Scott, R., ed., Aspen Publishers, Gaithersburg, MD. Sammis, J.L. (1948). Cheesemaking. Cheesemaker Book Co., Madison, WI. Sandine, W.E. and Elliker, P.R. (1970). Microbiologically induced flavors and fermented foods: flavor in fermented dairy products. J. Agric. Food Chem. 18, 557-562. Sardinas, J.L. (1972). Microbial rennets. Adv. Appl. Microbiol. 15, 39-73. Scott, R. (1986). Cheesemaking Practice. Applied Science Publishers, London. Shakeel-Ur-Rehman, McSweeney, RL.H. and Fox, RE (1999). A study on the role of the indigenous microflora on the ripening of Cheddar cheese. Milchwissenschaft 54, 388-392. Shakeel-Ur-Rehman, McSweeney, P.L.H., Banks, J.M., Brechany, E.Y., Muir, D.D. and Fox, P.E (2000a). Ripening of Cheddar cheese made from blends of raw and pasteurized milk. Int. Dairy J. 10, 33-44. Shakeel-Ur-Rehman, Banks, J.M., McSweeney, P.L.H. and Fox, RE (2000b). Effect of ripening temperature on the growth and significance of non-starter lactic acid bacteria in Cheddar cheese made from raw of pasteurized milk. Int. Dairy J. 10, 45-55. Shakeel-Ur-Rehman, Banks, J.M., Brechany, E.Y., Muir, D.D., McSweeney, P.L.H. and Fox, P.E (2000c). Influence of ripening temperature on the volatiles profile and flavour of Cheddar cheese made from raw or pasteurized milk. Int. DairyJ. 10, 55-65. Simon, A.L. (1956). Cheeses of the World. Faber & Faber, London. Squire, E.H., ed. (1937). Cheddar Gorge: A Book of English Cheeses. Collins, London. Sternberg, M. (1976). Microbial rennets. Adv. Appl. Microbiol. 20, 135-157. Van Slyke, L.L. and Price, W.V. (1949). Cheese. Orange Judd, New York. Vizzardi, M. and Maffeis, P. (1999). Forrnaggi Italliane: StoriaTecnologia e Microbiologia lattiero-casearia. Edizioni Agricole della Calderini, Bologna. Wake, R.G. (1959). Studies on casein. V. The action of rennin on casein. Aust. J. Biol. Sci. 12,479-489. Walter, H.E. and Hargrove, R.C. (1972). Cheeses of the World. Dover Publications, Inc., New York. Waugh, D.E and von Hippel, P.H. (1956). K-Casein and the stabilization of casein micelles. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 78, 4576-4582. White, K.D. (1970). Roman Farming. Thames and Hudson, London. Zehren, VL. and Nusbaum, D.D. (1992). Process Cheese. Cheese Reporter Publishing Co., Madison, WI.
Rennets: General and Molecular Aspects M.J.C. Crabbe, Division of Cell and Molecular Biology, School of Animal and Microbial
Sciences, The Universityof Reading, UK
Introduction Natural chymosin may consist of up to six molecular species, corresponding to genetic variants A and B, each of which is a mixture of three forms differing at the N-terminus, with one being three residues longer, and the other two residues shorter, than the mature chymosin (Lilla et al., 2001). The function of chymosin is to coagulate milk in the stomach. Rennet may be considered as a functional enzyme preparation that is effectively and naturally adapted to the purposes of cheesemaking (Ye et al., 2000). Proteolytic enzymes can be classified on the basis of their catalytic activity into one of the four groups serine, cysteine, metallo and aspartic proteinases (Kay, 1985). Chymosin (rennin; EC 3.4.23.4) is a neonatal gastric aspartic proteinase and is of commercial importance in cheesemaking. It belongs to the aspartic proteinase family which is widely distributed in many organisms and tissues with different physiological and functional properties (Chitpinityol and Crabbe, 1998). The nucleotide and amino acid sequences and the three-dimensional structures of several aspartic proteinases are available and provide information for the protein engineering design of this protein family. Enzymes can now be produced recombinantly in various expression systems in sufficient amounts for structural and functional studies.
Chymosin and Other Aspartic Proteinases Aspartic proteinases contain two aspartyl residues (Asp32 and Asp215, pepsin numbering) at the active site (Tang et al., 1973). They are susceptible to inhibition by pepstatin, a pentapeptide naturally produced by Streptomyces strains (Umezawa et al., 1970), and to affinity labelling at the catalytic aspartates using either diazoacetylnorleucinemethyl ester (DAN) in the presence of cupric ions (Rajagopalan et al., 1966) or 1,2epoxy-3-(p-nitrophenoxy) propane (EPNP).
Natural sources Aspartic proteinases can be found throughout nature from viruses to higher plants and mammals. They are
generally divided into two major groups - pepsin-like and retroviral enzymes. These enzymes have been isolated from five major sources: a. The stomach. Several types of gastric enzyme, pepsin (EC 3.4.23.1), pepsin B (EC 3.4.23.2), gastricsin (EC 3.4.23.3) and chymosin (EC 3.4.23.4), are produced in the abomasal mucosa as inactive precursors, zymogens. Pepsin is the predominant proteinase in adult mammals (Tang et al., 1973). Gastricsins are found in all parts of the mammalian stomach, or-cells of pancreatic islet, prostate gland and seminal vesicles. Chymosin is produced early on during gestation (in utero) in the abomasal mucosa of newborn mammals, including calf (Fohmann, 1970), piglet (Fohmann et al., 1978), kitten (Jensen et al., 1982), seal (Shamsuzzaman and Haard, 1984) and lamb (Baudys et al., 1988; Pungercar et al., 1991). The production of these enzymes varies, depending on the age of the animal and the feeding regime (Andr4n and Bj6rck, 1986). b. Lysosomes of many cell types contain cathepsin D (Hurley et al., 2000) and cathepsin E. Cathepsin E is found in gastric mucosa, thymus, spleen and blood cells (Kageyama, 1995). Human cathepsin D is possibly involved in the degradation of intracellular and endocytosed proteins, and is a prognostic indicator of breast tumour invasiveness. There appears to be a role for this enzyme during proteolysis in cheese ripening, most clearly in cheese where rennet activity is low, such as Swiss cheese, Quarg and Feta. c. Tissues such as kidney and sub-maxillary gland produce renin (Kay, 1985). d. Plants, including squash, cucumber, tomato, barley, rice, wheat, sorghum and lotus (Doi et al., 1980; Morris et al., 1985; Polanowski et al., 1985; Belozersky et al., 1989). e. Micro-organisms. Several aspartyl proteinases are secreted by fungi, including Cryphonectria parasitica (Sardinas, 1968), Penicillium janthinellum (Hofmann and Shaw, 1964), Rhizomucor pusillus (Arima et al., 1970), Rhizomucor miehei (Sternberg, 1971), Rhizopus chinensis (Fumamoto et al., 1967), Aspergillus awamori
Cheese: Chemistry, Physics and Microbiology, Third edition - Volume 1: General Aspects ISBN: 0-1226-3652-X Set ISBN: 0-1226-3651-1
Copyright 9 2004 Elsevier Ltd All rights reserved
20
Rennets: General and Molecular Aspects
(Ostoslavskaya et al., 1986), Aspergillus niger (Koaze, et al., 1964) and Trichoderma reesei (Pitts, 1992). Proteinases have been found in the yeasts ,saccharomyces cerevisiae (MacKay et al., 1988), Candida tropicalis (Togni et al., 1991) and Yarrowia lipolytica (Yamada and Ogrydziak, 1983). Thermopsin is secreted by ,sulfolobus acidocaldarius, a thermophilic archaebacterium (Lin and Tang, 1990). Retroviral aspartic proteinases are dimeric, and each monomer is about half the size of a eukaryotic aspartic proteinase and carries only one catalytic aspartic residue. Retropepsins have been found in several viruses, including human immunodeficiency virus (HIV), Rous sarcoma virus, avian myeloblastosis virus and simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV) (Toh et al., 1985; Kotler et al., 1989). These proteinases are required for processing for RNA dimerization within the virion, and hence for infectivity. Physical properties and stability of aspartyl proteinases
Molecular weight and isoelectric point Chymosin and aspartic proteinases have a molecular weight in the range 32-39 kDa, with a multiplicity of isoelectric points corresponding to a number of isozymes, auto-degradation and post-translationally modified products. N-linked glycosylation has been found in several proteinases such as cathepsin D (N67 and N183), ,5. cerevisiae proteinase A (N67 and N263), rhizomucor protease (N173) and human renin (N07). Specific receptors for phosphorylation have been found in porcine pepsin at $68 (Tang et al., 1973), bovine pepsin and human cathepsin D (Martin and Corre, 1984; Metcalf and Fusek, 1993). Transgenic sheep chymosin appears to be identical to calf chymosin (Mezina et al., 2001). Enzyme stability Chymosin is most stable at pH values between 5.3 and 6.3. However, even at pH 2, chymosin is relatively stable (Fohmann, 1959a). Under acidic conditions (pH 3-4), the enzyme loses its activity rapidly, probably caused by auto-degradation, while at alkaline pH values (above 9.8), loss is due to an irreversible conformational change (Cheeseman, 1965). Loss of activity of chymosin A is higher than for chymosin B (Foltmann, 1966). Chymosin is more stable at 2 ~ than at room temperature (Fohmann, 1959b). Kawaguchi etal. (1987) reported the rapid loss of the activity of chymosin when the temperature is increased from 45 to 55 ~ Photo-oxidation of histidine, as well as modification of the e-amino group of lysine, slightly affects the activity of chymosin (Hill and Laing, 1965; Smith et al., 1991b,c). Chymosin
loses approximately half of its activity after incubation in 4.6 mol/1 urea at 37 ~ for 30 min (Sugrue et al., 1990). It has been shown that both pro-part and cysteine residues are essential for refolding of chymosin after denaturation (Sugrue et al., 1990; Huang et al., 1992). Chymosin in a crystalline form appears to be very stable (Fohmann, 1992). Prochymosin is more stable than chymosin at neutral pH (Fohmann, 1966). At pH values below 5.0, prochymosin is converted to chymosin whereas at pH above 11.0 the stability of prochymosin is lost due to a conformational change. Pseudochymosin is stable at acidic pH for days but is quickly converted to chymosin if the pH is increased above 4.5 (Barkholt et al., 1979). Rhizomucor protease, cryphonectria protease and S. cerevisiae proteinase A are stable at pH 3.5-7.0 (Sardinas, 1968; Dreyer etal., 1986; Bailey and Siika-aho, 1988). Pepsin shows greater general stability than chymosin; for example, after incubation in 6 mol/1 urea at 37 ~ for 30 min, only 10% of the original activity is lost (Cheeseman, 1965). The thermostability of pepsin is reduced in solution at high pH, in the presence of urea or salt solution, but is increased in the presence of pepstatin (Privalov et al., 1981). At pH 6.0, pepsin is more stable than pepsinogen. At pH values between 8.5 and 10.5, pepsinogen is less stable than prochymosin and cannot be converted to the active form in an acidic environment (McPhile, 1975). Inactivation of pepsin can be initiated by dissociation of the N-fragment, and the sequence of this portion is a major determinant of enzyme stability (Tanaka and Yada, 2001). Prochymosin can be efficiently refolded in high yields by controlled air oxidation (Menzella etal., 2002). Aspartic proteinases containing carbohydrate are more stable towards high temperature, denaturants and degradation than proteins without carbohydrate (Aikawa et al., 1990; Berka et al., 1991; Brown and Yada, 1991). Glycosylation of rhizomucor protease by either chemical or genetic modification resulted in a loss of stability and an increase in the ratio of milk-clotting activity to proteolyric activity (C/P ratio) (Brown and Yada, 1991; Aikawa et al., 1992). The stability of rhizomucor proteinase was reduced by pre-treatment with acid, oxidation of methionine or modification of the E-amino group of lysine (Hubble and Mann, 1984; Smith et al., 1991b).
Enzyme solubility The solubility of chymosin is affected by pH, temperature and ionic strength of the solution (Fohmann, 1959b). Non-crystallized chymosin is soluble in solution containing 1 molA NaC1 and at pH 5.5. In a solution of >2 molA NaC1, chymosin appears to be insoluble. Crystallized chymosin shows higher solubility at 25 ~
Rennets: General and Molecular Aspects
than at 2 ~ (Fohmann, 1970); however, amorphous precipitates of chymosin are more stable at 2 ~ than at 25 ~ At pH values close to the isoelectric point, chymosin is very insoluble at an ionic strength of 0.005; its solubility is increased by increasing its ionic strength. Structure of chymosin and other aspartic proteinases Gene sequence and primary structure The genomic DNA of avian and mammalian aspartic proteinases, chicken embryonic pepsinogen (Hayashi et al., 1988), human renin (Miyazaki et al., 1984), bovine chymosin (Hidaka et al., 1986) and human pepsinogen (Sogawa et al., 1983), is comprised of nine exons separated by eight introns, and all exon-intron junction points are highly conserved. These results support the belief that the genes for these enzymes have evolved from a common ancestral gene. Conversely, in several microbial aspartic proteinases, including those of S. cerevisiae (Ammerer etal., 1986), C. tropicalis (Togni et al., 1991), R. pusillus (Tonouchi et al., 1986) and R. miehei (Gray et al., 1986), no intron was found in the genes for these enzymes. However, in the genes for the aspartic proteinases of R. niveus (Horiuchi et al., 1988) and A. awamori (Berka et al., 1990), one and three short introns, respectively, were found, but their exon-intron junctions were at different positions from those in the genes for mammalian and avian aspartic proteinases. Calf chymosin is found in two major forms, A and B, chymosin B being more abundant. Chymosins A and B differ at only one amino acid position: chymosin A has an aspartate residue at position 243 (pepsin numbering), whereas this is a glycine residue in chymosin B. A third form, chymosin C, appears to be a degradation product of chymosin A that lacks three residues, D244-F246 (Danley and Geoghegan, 1988). It is likely that chymosins A and B are synthesized from different alleles of the same polymorphic gene, rather than a multiple gene family, as only one locus of the chymosin gene was found from the hybridization of the calf genome with the chymosin gene (Donnelly et al., 1986). Fig. 1 illustrates the nucleotide (cDNA) and amino acid sequences of calf chymosin B. The secretion signals of aspartic proteinases are approximately 15-24 residues long with low sequence homology (Fig. 2). These secretion sequences tend to be rich in hydrophobic amino acids. The known pro-regions of aspartic proteinases are shown in Fig. 3. The pro-peptides are 38-54 amino acid residues in length and are rich in basic residues. Although sequence identity is high among the closely related enzymes, there are variables in the cleavage site between the pro-segment and the mature enzyme.
21
A lysine residue (K36P; pepsinogen numbering) is conserved in all proteinases, except lamb prochymosin and barley aspartic proteinase, and this residue has been postulated to interact with the catalytic aspartate residues in the zymogen molecule Games and Sielecki, 1986; Fohmann, 1988). The pro-segments are probably important for correct folding, targeting and control of the activation of zymogens (Koelsch et al., 1994). Chymosin is a single polypeptide chain enzyme of 323 amino acid residues with a low content of basic residues, and rich in dicarboxylic and [3-hydroxy amino acid residues (Fohmann et al., 1977, 1979; Harris et al., 1982; Moir etal., 1982; Hidaka etal., 1986). The sequence alignment of calf chymosin with those of lamb chymosin, porcine pepsin, penicillopepsin, rhizopus protease and S. cerevisiae proteinase A is illustrated in Fig. 4. There are variable numbers of cysteine residues in their sequences but their positions, when present, are conserved. Therefore, there is the potential for two disulfide bridges in the Rhizomucor and Rhizopus enzymes, a single disulfide bridge in the Cryphonectria, Penicillium and Aspergillus enzymes, and no disulfide bridges in the Irpex aspartic proteinase. Secondary structure The secondary structure of chymosin consists mainly of [3-sheets with a few small or-helical segments. The secondary structure of chymosin is illustrated in Fig. 5. The sheets and helices are named by analogy to the scheme adapted for cryphonectria protease (Blundell et al., 1985, 1990). The strands are named aN, bN, CN, dN, a'N, b'N, C'N, d'N, qN and rN in the N-terminal domain and ac, bc, co, de, a'c, b'c, c'c, d'c, qc and rc in the C-terminal domain. The helices are named hN and hc in the N- and the C-terminal domains, respectively. The antiparallel [3-strands form three welldefined sheets (Newman et al., 1991). The sheets, 1N and 1c, are formed by seven or eight strands in a similar pattern in both lobes and are related by a topological two-fold axis. The b, c, b' and c' strands form sheets 2N and 2c which occur beneath 1N and 1c, respectively. Sheet 3 is formed by six [3-strands, aN, rN, qN, qc, rc and ac, all of which are antiparallel. This sheet resides beneath the strands forming the base of the active site cleft. In each lobe, strands labelled a, b, c, d are related to a', b', c', d' by the intra-lobe diad and these strands are related to their equivalents in the opposite lobe by the inter-lobe diad. The helices hN, h'N, hc and h'c occur in topological intra- and interdomain two-fold symmetry in that they all occur after the d strands. The fifth helix occurs between the C'N and d'N strands and the sixth occurs at a large insertion in the C-terminal domain.
22
Rennets: General and Molecular Aspects
CCC
AGA
TCC
AAG
ATG
AGG
TGT
CTC
GTG
GTG
CTA
CTT
GCT
GTC
TTC
GCT
CTC
TCC
CAA
GGC
GCT
M
R
C
L
V
V
L
L
A
V
F
A
L
S
Q
G
A
PPI
P1
GAG
ATC
ACC
AGG
ATC
CCT
CTG
TAC
AAA
GGC
AAG
TCT
CTG
AGG
AAG
GCG
CTG
AAG
GAG
CAT
GGG
G
I
T
R
I
P
L
Y
K
G
K
S
L
R
K
A
L
K
E
H
G
PI0
P20
CTT
CTG
GAG
GAC
TTC
CTG
CAG
AAA
CAG
CAG
TAT
GGC
ATC
AGC
AGC
AAG
TAC
TCC
GGC
TTC
L
L
E
N
F
L
E
K
E
E
Y
G
I
S
S
K
Y
S
G
F
P30
G
P40
1
GAG
GTG
GCC
AGC
GTG
CCC
CTG
ACC
AAC
TAC
CTG
GAT
AGT
CAG
TAC
TTT
GGG
AAG
ATC
TAC
CTC
E
V
A
S
V
P
L
T
N
Y
L
D
S
Q
Y
F
G
K
I
Y
L
i0
20
GGG
ACC
CCG
CCC
CAG
GAG
TTC
ACC
GTG
CTG
TTT
GAC
ACT
GGC
TCC
TCT
GAC
TTC
TGG
GTA
CCC
G
T
P
P
N
E
F
T
V
L
F
D
T
G
S
S
D
F
W
V
P
30
40
TCT
ATC
TAC
TGC
AAG
AGC
AAT
GCC
TGC
AAA
AAC
CAC
CAG
CGC
TTC
GAC
CCG
AGA
AAG
TCG
TCC
S
I
Y
C
K
S
N
A
C
K
N
H
Q
R
F
D
P
R
K
S
S
50
60
ACC
TTC
CAG
AAC
CTG
GGC
AAG
CCC
CTG
TCT
ATC
CAC
TAC
GGG
ACA
GGC
AGC
ATG
CAG
GGC
ATC
T
F
Q
N
L
G
K
P
L
S
I
H
Y
G
T
G
S
M
Q
G
I
70
80
CTA
GGC
TAT
GAC
ACC
GTC
ACT
GTC
TCC
AAC
ATT
GTG
GAC
ATC
CAG
CAG
ACA
GTA
GGC
CTG
AGC
L
G
Y
D
T
V
T
V
S
N
I
V
D
I
Q
Q
T
V
G
L
S
9O
i00
ACC
CAG
GAG
CCC
GGG
GCA
GTC
TTC
ACC
TAT
GCC
GAA
TTC
GAC
GGG
ATC
CTG
GGG
ATG
GCC
TAC
T
Q
E
P
G
D
V
F
T
Y
A
E
F
D
G
I
L
G
M
A
Y
ii0
120
CCC
TCG
CTC
GCC
TCA
GAG
TAC
TCG
ATA
CCC
GTG
TTT
GAC
AAC
ATG
ATG
AAC
AGG
CAC
CTG
GTG
P
S
L
A
S
E
Y
S
I
P
V
F
D
N
M
M
N
R
H
L
V
130
140
GCC
CAA
GAC
CTG
TTC
TCG
GTT
TAC
ATG
GAC
AGG
AAT
GGC
CAG
GAG
AGC
ATG
CTC
ACG
CTG
GGG
A
Q
D
L
F
S
V
Y
M
D
R
N
G
Q
E
S
M
L
T
L
G
TAC
150
160
GCC
ATC
AAC
CCG
TCC
TAC
TAC
ACA
GGG
TCC
CTG
CAC
TGG
GTG
CCC
GTG
ACA
GTG
CAG
CAG
A
I
N
P
S
Y
Y
T
G
S
L
H
W
V
P
V
T
V
Q
Q
170
180
Y 190
TGG
CAG
TTC
ACT
GTG
GAC
AGT
GTC
ACC
ATC
AGC
GGT
GTG
GTT
GTG
GCC
TGT
GAG
GGT
GGC
TGT
W
Q
F
T
V
D
S
V
T
I
S
G
V
V
V
A
C
E
G
G
C
200
210
CAG
GCC
ATC
TTG
GAC
ACG
GGC
ACC
TCC
AAG
CTG
GTC
GGG
CCC
AGC
AGC
GAC
ATC
CTC
AAC
ATC
Q
A
I
L
D
T
G
T
S
K
L
V
G
P
S
S
D
I
L
N
I
220
230
CAG
CAG
GCC
ATT
GGA
GCC
ACA
CAG
AAC
CAG
TAC
GGT
GAG
TTT
GAC
ATC
GAC
TGC
GAC
AAC
CTG
Q
Q
A
I
G
A
T
Q
N
Q
Y
G
E
F
D
I
D
C
D
N
L
240
250
AGC
TAC
ATG
CCC
ACT
GTG
GTC
TTT
GAG
ATC
AAT
GGC
AAA
ATG
TAC
CCA
CTG
ACC
CCC
TCC
GCC
S
Y
M
P
T
V
V
F
E
I
N
G
K
M
Y
P
L
T
P
S
A
260
270
TAT
ACC
AGC
CAA
GAC
CAG
GGC
TTC
TGT
ACC
AGT
GGC
TTC
CAG
AGT
GAA
AAT
CAT
TCC
CAG
AAA
Y
T
S
Q
D
Q
G
F
C
T
S
G
F
Q
S
E
N
H
S
Q
K
280
290
TGG
ATC
CTG
GGG
GAT
GTT
TTC
ATC
CGA
GAG
TAT
TAC
AGC
GTC
TTT
GAC
AGG
GCC
AAC
AAC
CTC
W
I
L
G
D
V
F
I
R
E
Y
Y
S
V
F
D
R
A
N
N
L
300
310
GTG
GGG
CTG
GCC
AAA
GCC
ATC
V
G
L
A
K
A
I
320
Figure 1
* GGG
TGA
TCACATCGcTGACCA
...........
323
Nucleotide and amino acid sequence of calf chymosin B cDNA (adapted from Moir et aL, 1982).
Rennets: General and Molecular Aspects
Secretion signal peptides Fungi A. A. R. R. R. R.
awamori 1 oryzae 2 miehei 3 pusillus 4 niveus 5 chinensis 6
Mammals Bovine chymosin 7 Lamb chymosin 8 Porcine pepsin 9 Human pepsin 1~ Rat pepsin1 Rat cathepsin D12
MWFSKTAALVLGLSSAVSA*A MVILSKVAAVAVGLSTVASA*L MLFSQITSAILLTAASLSLTTA*R MLFSKISSAILLTAASFALTSA*R MKFTLISSCVALAAMTLAVEAA*P MTFTLNSSCIAIAALAVAVNAA*P
MRCTVVLLAVFALSQG*A MRCLVVLLAVFALSQG*A MKWLLLLSLVVLSEC*L MKWLLLLGLVALSE*C MKWMVVALLCLPLLEA*S MQTPGVLLLILGLLDASS*S
Yeast S. cerevisiae (YPA) 13 MFSLKALLPLALLLVSANQVAA*K S. cerevisiae (BAR1) TM M S A I N H L C L Y L I L A S F A I I N T I T A * L C. tropicalis15 M A T I F L F T K N V F I A . LA. FA. L
Plant Barley AP R16
MGTRGLALALLAAVLLQTVPAASEA*
E
Figure 2 Alignment of the secretion signal peptides of aspartic proteinases. The junctions between putative signal sequence and proenzyme are indicated by (*) and possible sites are indicated by (.). References: (1) Berka et aL (1990); (2) Ward and Kodama (1991); (3) Gray et aL (1986) and Boel et aL (1986); (4) Tonouchi etal. (1986); (5) Chen etaL (1991); (6) Horiuchi etaL (1988); (7) Harris et aL (1982) and Moir et aL (1982); (8) Pungercar et aL (1991); (9) Lin et aL (1989); (10) Hayano et aL (1988); (11)Ishihara etaL (1989); (12) Birch and Loh (1990); (13) Ammerer etaL (1986); (14) MacKay etaL (1988); (15) Togni etal. (1991); (16) Runeberg-Roos et aL (1991) (adapted from Orprayoon, 1994).
Tertiary structure The three-dimensional structure of several aspartic proteinases has been solved by X-ray crystallography (Fig. 6). These include porcine pepsin (Andreeva et al., 1984; Abad-Zapatero et al., 1990; Cooper et al., 1990; Sielecki et al., 1990), pepsinogen (James and Sielecki, 1986; Hartsuck and Remington, 1988), human renin (Sielecki et al., 1989), cryphonectria protease (Blundell et al., 1990), penicillopepsin (James and Sielecki, 1983), rhizopus protease (Suguna et al., 1987) and retroviral proteinases (Lapatto etal., 1989; Miller etal., 1989; Wlodawer et al., 1989). Crystals of chymosin obtained by Bunn et al. (1971) showed that the space group was either I222 or I212121, with one molecule in the asymmetric unit. The structure of recombinant bovine chymosin has been independently solved and refined at 2.3 A resolution (Gilliland et al., 1990) and at 2.2 ft, resolution (Newman et al., 1991). Crystallographic studies at 2.0 A resolution have also been performed on a site-specific mutant of chymosin, in which Vtll was replaced by phenylalanine, and the structure has been refined to an R-factor of 19.5% (Strop et al., 1990). All the molecules display very similar secondary and tertiary structures.
23
The structure of chymosin B described below was solved by Gilliland et al. (1990) and by Newman et al. (1991). The crystals of chymosin have the space group of 1222 with approximate overall dimensions of 40 • 60 • 65 A (Gilliland et al., 1990). The protein has a bilobal folding pattern formed by the N- and the C-terminal domains divided by a deep active-site cleft. A 2.5-A extended cleft contains the catalytic aspartates and the substrate-binding pockets. These two lobes are related by an approximately 2-fold axis which passes between the two catalytic aspartate residues, 32 and 215, and forms the approximate intra-molecular symmetry (Fig. 7). High symmetry between the N- and the C-lobes is found inside the active site and the core of the enzyme (Newman etal., 1991). Intra-domain pseudo-diad axes in the N- and the C-domains of chymosin have rotations of 180 ~ and 177 ~ respectively, with negligible translations (Newman et al., 1991). There are three disulphide bridges at positions 45 . . . 50, 2 0 6 . . . 210 and 2 4 9 . . . 282. In addition, ion-pairs are found between R59... D57, R157... E308, R157. 9 9 1326 (COO-), R307... Dll and R315... D138 (Gilliland et al., 1990; Newman et al., 1991). Chymosin also contains a single cis-proline, P23, o n the w-turn connecting strand bN to CN (Gilliland et al., 1990; Newman et al., 1991). In rhizomucor protease, cryphonectria protease and porcine pepsin, a cis-proline is found at an identical position to that in chymosin (Blundell etal., 1990; Cooper et al., 1990; Newman et al., 1993) while two cis-proline residues are found at positions 23 and 324 in rhizopus protease (Suguna et al., 1987) and three cisproline residues are found at positions 111,194 and 297 in human renin (Dhanaraj et al., 1992). The active site of aspartic proteinases is highly conserved and consists of residues, Asp--Thr--Gly, from each domain of the enzyme. Nine per cent sequence identity is observed between the N- and the C-terminal lobes of chymosin (Newman et al., 1991). A comparison of chymosin structure with that of other aspartic proteinases reveals a high degree of structural homology (Gilliand et al., 1990). Chymosin has the closest structural agreement with porcine pepsin. Of the fungal proteinases, the rhizopus protease molecule has higher structural homology with chymosin than with penicillopepsin or cryphonectria protease. The structural superposition of aspartic proteinases reveals that the N-terminal domain has greater structural similarity than the C-terminal domain (Gilliland et al., 1990). The C-terminal domain is more separated from the rest of the molecule than the N-terminal domain, and the rigid body movement appears in the C-terminal domain (residues 190-302) (Sali et al., 1992). The greatest differences between these proteinases are in the surface loop regions. One remarkable difference is the
24
Rennets-General and Molecular Aspects
Propeptide Fungi A. awamori APR1 A. oryzae APR 2 A. miehei APR 3 M. pusillus APR 4 R. niveus APR 5 R. chinensis APR 6
APAPRTRKGFTINQIARPANKTRTINLPGMYARS
.......
LA-KFGGTVPQSVKEA-A*SK
LPTGPSHSPHARRGFTINQITRQTARVGPKTASFPAIYSRALA-KYGGTVPAKLKSAVA*GH RPVSKQSESKDKLLALPLTSVSRKFSQTKFGQQQ RPVSKQSDADDKLLALPLTSVNRKYSQTKHGQQ
.......
LAEKLAG
.....
LKPFSE*AA
........
AAEKLGG
.....
IK-A-F*AE
PNGKKINIPLAKNN
....
SY-KPSA--KNALNKA
......
LA-KYNRRKVGSGGITTE*AS
PGEKKISIPLAKNP
....
NY-KPSA--KNAIQKA
......
IA-KYNKHKINTSTGGIV*AG
Mammals AEITRIPLYKGKSLRKAL-KEHGLLE-DFLQKQQYG-ISSKYS ....... GF*GE Bovine prochymosin 7 AEITRIPLYKGKPLRKAL-KERGLLE-DFLQKQQYG-ISSEYS ....... GF*GE Lamb prochymosin 8 SIHRVPLKK GKSLRKQL-KDHGLLE-DFLKKHPYN-PASKYHPV ...... L*TA Chicken pepsinogen 9 LVKVPLVRKKSLRQNLIKD-GKLK-DFLKTHKHN-PASKYFPE---AAAL*IG Porcine pepsinogen10 IMYKVPLIRKKSLRRTL-SERGLLK-DFLKKHNLN-PARKYFPQWE-APTL*VD Human pepsinogenl 1 Human progastricsin12 AVVKVPLKKFKSIRETM-KEKGLLG-EFLRTHKYD-PASKYRFGD ..... L*SV TFSLPTRTATFERIPLKKMPSVREIL-EERG--V-DMIRLSAEWGVFTK Mouse prorenin 13 TFGLPTDTTTFKRIFLKRMPSIRESL-KERG--V-DMARLGPEWSQPMK Human prorenin14 SALVRIPLHKFTSIRRTM-SEVGGSVEDLIAK .... GPVSKYSQAV-PAVTE*GP Human procathepsin D 15 SALIRIPLRKFTSIRRTM-TEVGGSVGDLI .... LKGPITKYSMQSSPRTKE*PV Rat procathepsin D 16 Yeast KVHKAKIYKHELSDEMKEVTFEQHLAHLGQKYLTQFEKANPEVVFSREHPFFTE*GG S. cerevisiae APR 17 LAFALFAQGLTIPD ..... GIEKRTDKVVSLDFTVIRKPFNATAHR---LIQKR*SD C. tropicalis APR 18 Plant EGLVRIALKKRP-IDRNSRVATGLSGGEEQP---LLSG ...... AN---PLR*SE Barley APR 19
-R*PS -R*LT
Figure 3 Alignment of the propeptides of aspartic proteinases. The junctions between proenzyme and mature enzyme are indicated by (*). References: (1) Berka et al. (1990); (2) Ward and Kodama (1991); (3) Gray etaL (1986) and Boel et al. (1986); (4) Tonouchi et al. (1986); (5) Horiuchi et al. (1988); (6) Chen et al. (1991); (7) Harris et al. (1982) and Moir et al. (1982); (8) Pungercar et al. (1991); (9) Baudys and Kostka (1983); (10) Lin et al. (1989); (11) Sogawa et al. (1983); (12) Wong and Tang (1986); (13) Holm et al. (1984); (14)Imai et al. (1983); (15) Faust et al. (1985); (16) Birch and Loh (1990); (17) Ammerer et al. (1986); (18) Togni et al. (1991 ); (19) Runeberg-Roos et al. (1991 ) (adapted from Orprayoon, 1994).
position of the flap (residues 73-85 in chymosin). This region participates in the substrate-binding specificity. In chymosin, the position of Y77 is stabilized by interaction with hydrophobic residues F]]9 and L32 (Gilliland et al., 1990). In other aspartic proteinases, Y77 hydrogenbonds to W39. In pepsin, the location of the hydroxyl group of Yrr is occupied by a water molecule, w424, in the chymosin crystal. This water molecule forms two hydrogen bonds with the hydroxyl group of Y75 and with the conserved water molecule, w403. In the VlllF mutant chymosin, the flap appears to occupy two different conformations corresponding to that found in native chymosin and pepsin (Strop et al., 1990). This suggests that chymosin can exist in two alternative structural forms: the active form in which S 1 and $3 binding pockets are free for substrate binding and the self-inhibited form in which these pockets are occluded by its own Y77 residue (Andreeva et al., 1992; Gustchina et al., 1996). The structure of 5. cerevisiae proteinase A agrees overall with other uninhibited aspartic proteinases, although the conformation of Y75 occupying the $1 substratebinding pocket is similar to that in chymosin, suggesting a functional significance for this conformation (Gustchina et al., 2002). The conversion of chymosin
from the self-inhibited to the active form can be promoted by an allosteric activator, the histidine-proline cluster ( n H i s m P r o - - H i s m P r o m H i s m ) of K-casein, thereby explaining the catalytic specificity of chymosin towards K-casein. Three-dimensional structures of homodimer retroviral proteinases are to a large extent similar and bear close resemblance to the structure of bilobal fungal and mammalian aspartic proteinases (Lapatto et al., 1989; Miller et al., 1989; Navia et al., 1989; Wlodawer et al., 1989). The structural superpositions between the retroviral enzymes and the eukaryotic aspartic proteinases appear to be similar. It is not clear whether the eukaryotic proteinases are derived from a homodimer enzyme by gene duplication and fusion (Tang et al., 1978) or evolved from a cellular gene by one or more deletion events (Rao et al., 1991). Nevertheless, an engineered homodimer of the pepsin N-terminal lobe, which exhibits a general proteolytic activity, reveals the close relationship between these two aspartic proteinase families (Lin et al., 1992). The active site
The active-site aspartates, D32 and D215, are situated on the corners of the two extended loops (t~-structures
Rennets" General and Molecular Aspects
I0 4CMS
20
30
40
50
GEVASVPLTNY-LDSQYFGKIYLGTPPNEFTVLFDTGSSDFWVPSIYCKSNAC-KNHQR
4PEP
IGDEPLENY-LDTEYFGTIGIGTPAQDFTVIFDTGSSNLWVPSVYCSSLAC-TNHNL
2APP
AASGVATNTPTANDIEEYIPVTIG--GTTLNLNFDTGSSDLWVFSTELP-ASQQSGHSV
2APR
AGVGTVPMTDYGNDIEYYGQVTIGTPGKKFNLDFDTGSSDLWIASTLCT--NCGSGQTK
4APE
STYSATTTPIDSLDDAYITPVQIGTPAQTLNLDFDTGSSDLWVFSSETTASE-VDGQTI
YPE
GGH-DVPLTNYLNA-QYYTDITLGTPPQNFKVILDTGSSNLWVPSNECGSLAC-FLHSK
Strand
a"
Strand
60 4CMS
70
b ~
Strand
80
c"
90
i00
ii0
FDPRKSSTFQNL-GKPLSIHYGT-GSMQGILGYDTVTVSNIVDIQQTVGLSTQEPGDVFTY
4PEP
FNPQDSSTYQST-SGELSITYGT-GSMTGILGYDTVQVGGISDTNQIFGLSETEPGSFLYY
2APP
YNPSA--TGKELSGYTWSISYGDGSSASGNVFTDSVTVGGVTAHGQAVQAAQQISAQFQQD
2APR
YDPNQSSTYQAD-GRTWSISYGDGSSASGILAKDNVNLGGLLIKGQTIELAKREAASFASG
4APE
YTPSKSTSTKLLSGATWSISYGDGSSSSSDVYTDTVSVGGLTVTGQAVESAKKVSSSFTED
YPE
YDHEASSSYKAN-GTEFAIQYGTG-SLEGYISQDTLSIGDLTIPKQDFAEATSEPGLTFAF Strand
d"
Strand
120
i30
4CMS
AEFDGI
4PEP
AP FDG I LGLAY
2APP
TNNDGLLGLAFS
2APR
- PNDGLLGLGFDT
LGMAYPSLAS
S INTVQPQSQTTFFDTVKS I TTVR-
ST I DGLLGLAFSTLNTVS GKFDGI
LGLGYDTI Strand
Strand
FSVYMDRNG
.... QESMLTLG
QDL F SVYLS SNG- - -DS GSWLLG ..... QPGVYD
I SQGL I SRP I FGVYLGKAKN-
FDNAKA-
S - LDS PVFTADLGY
-GGGGEY
a
Strand
180
..... HAPGTYNFG
b
Strand
190
200
c
Strand 210
AIDPSYYTGSLHWVPVTV-
QQYWQFTVDSVTI
G I DS SYYTGS
LNWVPVSV-
EGYWQ
I T LDS I TMDGET
2APP
F I DS S KYTGS
LTYTGVDNS
QGFWS
FNVDS YTAGS
Q - SG - DG - FSG IADTGTTLLLDD
2APR
GYDSTKFKGS
LTTVP
I TVDRATVGT
S TVA- S S - FDGI LDTGTTLL
I DNS RGWWG
SGVVVACEGGCQAI
d 220
4CMS
4APE
F IDTTAYTGGITYTAVSTLQHFWEWTSTGYAVGSGTFKSTS
YPA
G I D E S KF KGD I TWL PVRRKa"
230
FG I FG
SVD- - - KWPPFYNAIQQDLLDEKRFAFYLGDTSKDTENGGEATFG
4PEP
Strand
r
160
S - L -AQ PL FAVALKHQ
-GVKT PMDNL PTSQQTF
q 150
E - - -YS I PVFDNMMNRHLVAQDL
4APE
170
140
P S I SAS - - - GAT PVFDNLWDQGLVS
YPA
4CMS
25
AYWEVKF
Strand
VDTGT
S LLTGPTSA SVV
I L PNN I
- IDGIADTGTTLLYLPATV
E G I GLGD E YAE L E S -HGAA I DTGT S L I T L P S GL
b"
240
LDTGTSKLVGPSSD
IACS GGCQAI
Strand
250
260
270
c" 280
ILNIQQAI-GATQNQ-YGEFDIDCDNLSYMPTVVFEINGKMYPLTPSAYTSQD---QGFC
4PEP
IANIQADI-GASENS-DGEMVISCSSIDSLPDIVFTIDGVQYPLSPSAYILQD---DDSC
2APP
VSQYYSQVSGAQQDSNAGGYVFDCST--NLPDFSVSISGYTATVPGSLINYGPSGDGSTC
2APR
AASVARAY-GASDNS-DGTYTISCDT-SAFKPLVFSINGASFQVSPDSLVFEEF--QGQC
4APE
VSAYWAQVSGAKSSSS-VGYVFPCSAT--LPSFTFGVGSARIVIPGDYIDFGPISTGSSC
YPA
AEMINAEI-GAKKGW-TGQYTLDCNTRDNLPDLIFNFNGYNFTIGPYDYTLEV---SGSC Strand
d" 290
Strand
q
300
Strand
r
310
320
4CMS
TSGFQSENHS
.... QKWILGDVFIREYYSVFDRANNLVGLAKAI
4PEP
TSGFEGMDVPTSSGELWILGDVFIRQYYTVFDRANNKVGLAPVA
2APP
LGGIQSNSGI
.... GFSIFGDIFLKSQYV~FDSDGPQLGFAPQA
2APR
IAGFGYG-NW
.... GFAIIGDTFLKNNYVVFNQGVPEVQIAPVAE
4APE
FGGIQSSAGIG
.... INIFGDVALKAAFWFNGATTPTLGFASK
YPA
ISAITPMDFPEPVGPLAIVGAFLRKYYSIYDLGNNAVGLAKAI
Figure 4 The sequence alignment of calf chymosin (4CMS, Newman et aL, 1991) with other aspartic proteinases based on threedimensional structures. References: 4PEP: porcine pepsin (Sielecki et aL, 1990); 2APP: penicillopepsin (James and Sielecki, 1983); 2APR: rhizopuspepsin (Suguna etaL, 1987); 4APE: endothiapepsin (Pearl and Blundell, 1984); YPA: S. cerevisiae proteinase A (Dreyer et aL, 1986) (adapted from Orprayoon, 1994).
within sheets CNdN and ccdc) in the N- and the C-terminal domains. The side chains of these t w o aspartates are oriented towards each other around the pseudo-interlobe diad axis in a complicated hydrogenbonding network, known as the 'fireman's grip' (Pearl and Blundell, 1984) shown in Fig. 8. This network is
formed by the interaction of two loops (residues 31-35 and residues 214-218) and a central water molecule. The side chain of T33 and its symmetry-related T126 form hydrogen bonds across the diad axis to the carbonyl oxygens of L214 and F3i, respectively, and to the peptide N atoms of T216 and T33, respectively. The carboxyl
26
Rennets: General and Molecular Aspects
~N
t
b~
d/v
eN,
t ~45t "
'
/ h;.
hN
hr: i
{
.....m:,,L ,_
"~SL .J ~_~,, .... !~~"~
c
[~
"
,
.~
Fag.,
i~
h.,v2
{. jlS.~
.
!/
~_
t
qtv
hN / ' g u rrr
/
-
'~ - i l l ~
t t
dc
_2
l-|e-
cc
t
bc
.
t
at.
Figure 5 A schematic diagram of the secondary structure of chymosin. The directions of the strands are indicated by the large arrows. The inter- and intra-lobe two-fold axes are shown as large and small diad markers. The main hydrogen bonds are indicated by arrows in the direction of donor to acceptor (adapted from Newman et al., 1991).
oxygens of D32 and D215 are hydrogen-bonded with nitrogen atoms of the conserved G34 and G217, respectively. In addition, the side chains of $35 and T218 also form hydrogen bonds with the outer oxygen atoms of D32 and D215, respectively. There are some conserved glycine residues in eukaryotic aspartic proteinases which are believed to be important; among them, G34
and G217 are conserved in all aspartic proteinases. Side chains at these positions would interfere sterically with the catalytic aspartates. Residue D303 is conserved among all proteinases with an acidic pH optimum. However, in renins, which have a more neutral pH optimum, this residue is replaced by an alanine. The effect of the side chain at this position on the pKa has
Rennets: General and Molecular Aspects
27
"'M,.
Nr
chymosin
rcine pepsin
I
~A aa.
,I
Cryphonectrl
Rhizomucor protease
mouse renin human renin
yeast proteinase A
HIV proteinase
Figure 6 Three-dimensional structures of aspartic proteinases showing the high degree of structure homology among these proteinases (adapted from Pitts et aL, 1992).
been revealed by site-directed mutagenesis of renin (Yamauchi etal., 1988) and chymosin (Mantafounis and Pitts, 1990). The hydrogen bond between D303 and T216 may affect the pKa of D215 via the peptide dipole of Tz16-G217 (Pearl and Blundell, 1984).
Catalytic mechanisms
The catalytic mechanism of aspartic proteinases has been modelled based on the structural analysis of several aspartic proteinase-inhibitor complexes. Early mechanisms (James etal., 1977, 1982; James and
28
Rennets: General and Molecular Aspects
i 9 ""
ii
Figure 7 A plot of the Ce~ position of chymosin. The approximate molecular symmetry axes are shown as follows: (i) the inter-lobe non-crystallographic 2-fold screw axis relating the N- and C-terminal lobes; (ii) the intra-domain axis for the N-terminal domain; (iii) the intra-domain axis for the C-terminal domain (adapted from Newman et aL, 1991).
Sielecki, 1985) proposed that catalysis was initiated by protonation of the carbonyl oxygen of the substrate by a proton from D215, followed by nucleophilic attack on the carbonyl carbon of the substrate aspartate residue by a hydroxide ion generated from water after donation of its proton to D32. These protonation events lead to the formation of the tetrahedral intermediate. The breakdown of the intermediate is generated by
protonation of the nitrogen atom either from bulk solvent or from the catalytic carboxyl group of D215. Protonation of the substrate carbonyl and nucleophilic attack may appear simultaneously during the formation of the tetrahedral intermediate. Similarly, proton transfer from the intermediate to the diad may occur at the same time as the protonation of the nitrogen atom of the substrate during the cleavage of the resultant intermediate (Polgar, 1987). Pearl (1987) suggested that the distortion of the scissile bond towards the enzyme-substrate binding may facilitate the collapse of the intermediate by generating lone pair orbitals antiperiplanar to the CmN bond but not to the hydroxyl C n O bond. Therefore, the leaving product is a free amine rather than the original nucleophile. In addition, the charged oxygen of a solvent molecule forms hydrogen bonds with residues D32 and $35 (Suguna et al., 1987) or residues G76, D77 or Y75 on the flap (Blundell et al., 1987; Pearl, 1987). Yeerapandian et al. (1990) have proposed the catalytic mechanistic model outlined in Fig. 9. The proR(statine-like) hydroxyl of the tetrahedral carbonyl hydrate is hydrogen-bonded to the outer oxygen of D32 and D215. The second hydroxyl oxygen of the hydrate is hydrogen-bonded only to the carboxyl oxygen of D32. The scissile bond carbonyl is protoned by D32 and is simultaneously attacked by a water molecule polarized into a nucleophilic state by D215. The rigid movement in the enzyme-substrate complex may impel distortion of the amide bond and facilitate the attack of nucleophilic water on the polarized carbonyl. Thus, in the tetrahedral intermediate I, the negatively charged D31 is stabilized by extensive hydrogen bonding. The amide nitrogen will have been pyramidalized with the new arrangement,
HE 31 ..~~,~.
"',
:3~~
c:J 217
218
Figure 8 The 'fireman's grip' at the active site of chymosin. Hydrogen bonds (broken lines) involved are T216N . . . m33oy1 (2.8 A), T330 "/1 . . . K2140 (2.7 ,~,), T 3 3 N . . . m216Oy1 (2.9 ,~,) and T2160"/1 . . . F310 (2.8 ,~). Other hydrogen bonds contributing to the stability of 032 and D215 are also shown (adapted from Newman et al., 1991).
Rennets: General and Molecular Aspects
H~ /l:r
/~..0,..
N
R
H'""
~'O ~
29
-
H. H
R/~O""~\H ~
ASP 21 $
aS,,' 2~s
\ M.... "'~"O
"'"O
\o I ASP 32
ASP 32 (a)
(b)
reactants
o,,olvent protonal~on.
tetrahedral intermediate I nitrogen ,twerson
/
C-N bonr mta1~n
fission, p r o t o n a h o f /
4./Fr'
H~
Asp 215 prolonation.
o\
H H
ASP 21 $ 0
..... ON
fission.
H....~. H
prolonalion
"-.
/ ASP 215
0
ASP 32
ASP 32 (d) products
o"
(c)
tetrahedral internted/ate il
Figure 9 A proposed catalytic mechanism for aspartic proteinases (Veerapandian et aL, 1990).
favouring protonation. A proton can be transferred from bulk solvent or from D215. A similar mechanistic proposal has been described by James et al. (1992). Pepsin and chymosin have been shown to catalyse peptide synthesis (Fruton, 1982; Jakubke, 1987; Abdel Malak, 1992). Formation of a peptide is catalysed by chymosin optimally at pH 4-5 which is similar for peptide hydrolysis (Abdel Malak, 1992). The pH optimum for peptide synthesis catalysed by pepsin is further from that for peptide hydrolysis. The catalytic ability of the enzyme is sensitive to the amino acid residues flanking the bond to be formed or hydrolysed as well as the nature of adjacent amino acid residues. Zymogen activation
The structure of porcine pepsinogen has been refined at high resolution (James and Sielecki, 1986; Sielecki et al., 1991; Hartsuck et al., 1992). Structural comparisons between pepsin and pepsinogen suggest that the enzyme and proenzyme structures are very similar. Most of the differences occur in the proximity of the cleft which, in pepsinogen, is covered and filled by the pro-part (1P-44P) and the first 13 residues of pepsin.
The extension of 13 residues adopts completely different conformations in the active and the zymogen forms (James and Sielecki, 1986). The secondary structure of the zymogen consists mainly of [3-sheet, with an approximate 2-fold axis of symmetry (James and Sielecki, 1986). The activation peptide packs into the active site cleft, and the N-terminus (2P-9P) occupies the position of the mature N-terminus (2-9) since the first ten amino acids of the pro-part form [3-strand aN of pepsinogen. Therefore, changes upon activation include excision of the activation peptide and proper relocation of the mature N-terminus. At neutral or alkaline pH, the pro-segment of pepsin binds and is stabilized across the active site between the two lobes by electrostatic, hydrogenbonding and hydrophobic interactions which contribute to the binding between the pro-segment and the rest of the protein (Sielecki et al., 1991). Lowering of pH protonates acidic residues on the mature enzyme portion of the molecule, thereby disrupting favourable electrostatic interactions with positively charged amino acid residues on the pro-segment. Subsequent conformational change of the zymogen leads to intramolecular proteolytic cleavage that liberates
30
Rennets: General and Molecular Aspects
the pro-segment from the zymogen (McPhile, 1972; Nielsen and Fohmann, 1993). The mechanisms of activation of zymogens of the aspartic proteinase are different and depend on the pH. At pH below 2.5, conversion of pepsinogen is primarily by an intramolecular mechanism. The propeptide is cleaved monomolecularly at position M16p-E17P, resulting in an active pseudo-enzyme which is enzymatically active and may form a complex with the released pro-segment. At pH values below 4.0, the L44p--I1 bond is not susceptible to proteolytic cleavage but becomes susceptible at higher pH. At low pH, the cleavage sites differ among the aspartic proteinases- F27p--Lx8p for calf prochymosin, human progastricsin and chicken pepsinogen, M16p--ElFp for porcine pepsinogen B and L26p--I27P for procathepsin D (Barkholt and Foltmann, 1975; Barkhoh et al., 1979; Truk et al., 1985; Fohmann, 1993; Larsen et al., 1993). Removal of the entire propeptide predominately occurs at pH 3-4 through an intermolecular mechanism. It has been suggested that cleavage of the F42p--G1 bond of prochymosin is faster at pH 2 than at pH 4.5 (Barkholt et al., 1979). The recombinant pepsinogen originally from Rhizopus and produced in E. coli can convert to the active enzyme in an acidic medium by a similar mechanism as for pepsinogen (Chen et al., 1991). The pseudorhizopus protease and rhizopus protease are generated by the cleavage at N38p--T39p and V45p--A1, respectively (p = prochymosin). Moore et al. (1995) have studied the crystal and the molecular structures of human progastricsin at 1.62 A resolution and suggest that human progastricsin has a conformational structure and mechanism of activation analogous to those for pepsinogen. Site-directed mutagenesis at the two sites for autoproteolysis of prochymosin suggests that these processing sites can function independent of one another (McCaman and Cummings, 1986, 1988). Changing the prochymosin sequence from F27p--L28P--Q29p--K30p--Q31P to F27P--P28p--R29P--Q30P--Q31P resulted in the partially activated zymogen at pH 2, while at pH 4.5, normal activation processing and proteolytic processing occurred (McCaman and Cummings, 1986). Conversely, when the seven residues including the processing site at pH 4.5 were removed, a new cleavage site (S37e--V38p) was generated at pH 4.5 while the processing site at pH 2 was not affected (McCaman and Cummings, 1988). The activation reactions are dependent on pH, salt concentration and temperature. At pH 5 and ---20 ~ activation is completed in two or three days (Rand and Ernstrom, 1964), while at pH 2, "-20 ~ and an ionic strength of 0.1, activation is completed in 5-10min (Fohmann, 1962). However, autoproteolysis alone may
not be able to generate the mature form of the enzymes as shown in procathepsin D, which cannot autoactivate to the mature enzyme at acidic pH (Larsen et al., 1993). Prochymosin is also activated by proteolytic enzymes, including plasmin, Legionella pneumophila metalloproteinase and Aspergillus oryzae thermolysin (Stepanov et al., 1990). Position 36p in the propeptides of gastric aspartic proteinases is generally occupied by lysine or arginine. This has led to the conclusion that a basic residue at this position, which interacts with the active-site aspartates, is essential for folding and activation of the zymogen. Lamb prochymosin has been shown by cDNA cloning to possess glutamic acid at position 36p. To investigate the effect of this natural mutation which appears to contradict the proposed role of this residue, calf and lamb prochymosins and their two reciprocal mutants, K36pE and E36pK, respectively, were expressed in E. coli, refolded in vitro and autoactivated at pH 2 and 4.7 (Francky et al., 2001). All four zymogens could be activated to active chymosin and, at both pH values, the two proteins with E36p showed higher activation rates than the two K36p forms. E36p was also demonstrated in natural prochymosin isolated from the fourth stomach of lamb, as well as being encoded in the genomes of sheep, goat and mouflon, which belong to the subfamily Caprinae. A conserved basic residue at position 36p of prochymosin is thus not obligatory for its folding or autocatalytic activation. The apparently contradictory results for porcine pepsinogen A (Richter et al., 1999) can be reconciled with those for prochymosin. K/R36p is involved in stabilizing the propeptide-enzyme interaction, along with residues nearer the N-terminus of the propeptide, the sequence of which varies between species. The relative contribution of residue 36p to stability differs between pepsinogen and prochymosin, being larger in the former (Francky et al., 2001). oLB-Crystallin, the small heat shock protein (Plater et al., 1996; Crabbe and Hepburne-Scott, 2001; Derham et al., 2001) can form a complex with prochymosin. After activation, once chymosin is recovered without bound cxB-crystallin, the yield of activity is increased (Chitpinityol et al., 1998b). Substrate-binding pockets and specificity
A high concentration of NaC1 or (NH4)2SO4 increases the hydrolytic activity of pepsin and retroviral proteinases, in addition to broadening their specificities (Kotler et al., 1989; Tropea et al., 1992). Aspartic proteinases have an extended substratebinding pocket that can accommodate at least seven amino acid residues. Detailed structural studies of
Rennets: General and Molecular Aspects
aspartic proteinase-inhibitor complexes have been used to identify the amino acid residues in each subsite (Bott et al., 1982; Andreeva et al., 1984; James et al., 1985; Blundell etal., 1987; Cooper etal., 1987; Foundling et al., 1987; James and Sielecki, 1987; Suguna et al., 1987). In chymosin, the subsites S1 and $1' are shallow pockets within the active site cleft. The S1 subsite (for binding of F105) has greater specificity than SI', and is blocked by YF5 (Gilliland et al., 1990). Therefore, a significant movement of the flap is essential to allow binding of the substrate. The S1 is quite hydrophobic compared to SI' in which an additional charged residue, E290, is near to the K-casein M106 side chain. The $2 pocket has low specificity and allows the peptide side-chains to adopt a range of conformations whereas at subsites $1 and $3, the conformation of the side chains is strongly restricted (Dhanaraj et al., 1992). Chymosin residues involved in the interactions with the corresponding residues of the substrate are shown together with a sequence identical to that of the K-casein cleavage site in Table 1. There are two differences in the S1 subsites of chymosin and the fungal proteinases that promote more hydrophobic S1 subsites (Gilliland et al., 1990). The first is the position of the flap region which is due to the reorientation of Yr5 and a deletion of one amino acid residue in this loop. Another difference is the substitution of L30 in chymosin for the D30 or the N30 of the rhizopus protease and penicillopepsin, respectively. In human cathepsin E, the important specificitydetermining interactions are found in the $3 (El3) and $2 (T222, E287, L289, 1300) subsites (Raonaik et al., 1995). Figure 10 summarizes the results of cleavage of the B chain of oxidized insulin by chymosin and some related acid proteinases. In chymosin, the S1 subsite has favourable interactions with aromatic amino acids at P1 whereas the SI' subsite is less specific (Bang-Jensen et al., 1964; Fohmann, 1964; Guillou e t a l . , 1991; Nedjar etal., 1991).
31
The fungal and yeast proteinases have an S1 subsite with a deeper pocket and broader specificity. Therefore, the $1 pocket can accomodate lysine as well as hydrophobic residues at P1 (Oka et al., 1973; Hofmann et al., 1984; Newman et al., 1993). However, in rhizomucor protease, specificity for lysine at P1 was not observed due to the absence of polar residues at positions 30 and 111. In retroviral aspartic proteinases, the primary specificities for HIV-1 and HIV-2 aspartic proteinases at P1 are L, M, Y and E and at PI' are P, M, F and A (Poorman et al., 1991). Among the isozymes of chymosin, chymosin A has a significantly higher specific activity than chymosin B (Fohmann, 1960) which may be the result of the enhanced binding affinity of K-casein through, possibly, the stronger electrostatic interactions between the substrate and chymosin A. In addition, these two isozymes have different pH optima, 4.2 and 3.7 for chymosin A and B, respectively. These different values may be the result of an extensive hydrogen-bonding network near the two catalytic aspartates. The optimum pH for proteolysis by aspartic proteinases depends upon the species from which the enzyme is produced, and the substrate used (Table 2). HIV-1 proteinase and renin have a high pH optimum among aspartic proteinases. The residues $35, T218 and D303 have been postulated to play a role in the pH profile of aspartic proteinases. In vitro mutagenesis of A35S of HIV-1 proteinase (A28S in HIV-1 numbering) showed a lowering of pKa2 (compared to wild type) by 1.2 units but no effect was found in the pKal value (Ido et al., 1991). In contrast, mutation of $35A in porcine pepsin lowered pKal and pKa2 but raised it for rhizopusprotease. Site-directed mutagenesis of T218A in porcine pepsin, chymosin and rhizopus protease shifted the pH optimum by 0.2-0.5 units (Mantafounis and Pitts, 1990; Tang et al., 1992). Mutation of A303D in renin lowered the pH optimum by 0.5 units (Yamauchi et al., 1988). Similarly, mutation of D303A in chymosin raised the optimum pH by 0.6 units (Mantafounis and Pitts, 1990). The double mutations, T218A/D303A
Table 1 The substrate-binding pockets of chymosin. Chymosin residues involved in the interactions with the corresponding residues of the substrate are shown together with residues at the K-casein cleavage site (adapted from Gilliland et aL, 1990; Newman et aL, 1991) Subsite
K-Casein residues
Chymosin residues
S4 S3 S2 $1 $1' $2' $3'
His102 Leul03 Serl04 Phel05 Met106 Alal07 Ile108
Ser219, Lys220, Gin288 Ser12, Gin13, Tyr75, Phe117, Gly217, Thr218, 8er219 Gly76, Thr77, Gly217, Thr218, Lys220 Leu30, Asp32, Gly34, Tyr75, Gly76, Phe117, Ile120, Asp215, Gly217, Thr219 Gly34, Tyr189, Asp215, Thr218, Glu289, Ile301 Gly34, Ser35, Tyr189 Tyr189
32
Rennets: General and Molecular Aspects
1 F
Chymosin 1 PeP sin2 Rhizopuspep sin3 Penicillopep sin3 Endothiapep sin4 Proteinase A s Cathepsin E 6 R. miehei APR 7 R. pusillus APR 8
i0 V
N
Q
H
L
C
G
S
H
20 L
1"
V
E
1" 1" 1" 1" 1" 1"
1]" 1" 1]" 1" 1"
1"
1]" 1" 1~ It
A
L
Y
L
V
C
G
30 E
R
1]" 1" 1" 1" It 1]' 1" 1" 1" 11" 1]" 1" 1" 1]" 1]" 1" 1" 11" 1]" 1]" 1" 1]" 1" 1]' 1]" 1]' 1]" 1" 1]" 1]" 1"
G
F
F
Y
T
P
KA
1" 1" 1" 1]"
1~ 1~ 1~ 1~ 1~
1" 1]" it "1" 1]" 1" 1]" 1]" 1]' 1]" 1]" 1]" 1)" 1~ It 1` It
Figure 10 Comparison of the cleavage specificity of chymosin towards the B-chain of oxidized insulin with those of some other aspartic proteinases. References: (1) Foltman (1964); (2) Sanger and Tuppy (1981); (3) Oka et al. (1973); (4) William et al. (1972); (5) Takahashi (1995); (6) Athauda et al. (1991) (pH 3.0); (7) Rickert (1971); (8) McCullough and Whitaker (1971). Legends: (1]') Main cleavage site and (1') other sites of action.
in chymosin affected the pH optimum similarly to that of D303A mutatagenesis (Pitts et al., 1993). The substrate specificity of aspartic proteinases is affected by the operating pH and the presence of salts (Kotler et al., 1989; Athauda et al., 1991; Tropea et al., 1992). The pH dependence of hydrolysis of synthetic substrates demonstrates that secondary specificity occurs at subsite $3 of mammalian aspartic proteinases whereas lower specificity is found in microbial proteinases (Dunn et al., 1986). In chymosin, isoleucine or valine is favoured at P3, and tyrosine, valine or serine at P2 (Guillou et al., 1991). The favourable interaction between K220 (NH3 +) of chymosin and glutamate ( C O 0 - ) in P2 of the substrate is suggested to cause the Table 2
effects of pH on hydrolysis (Dunn et al., 1987). The specificity at P2 towards both K220 and Q288 has been determined by in vitro mutagenesis (Suzuki et al., 1990; Quinn et al., 1991). We have studied the effect of replacing threonine 77 of chymosin by aspartate (mutant T77D), as well as the addition of two residues (mHmG) (mutant PC + 2) to the C-terminus of the protein, on the activity of the enzyme on a synthetic hexapeptide, L m S ~ F ( N O 2 ) ~ N I ~ A ~ L m O M e , as substrate (Chitpinityol et al., 1996, 1998a). For the recombinant wild type, the optimum pH was 3.7, similar to that reported for the authentic chymosin B using the same substrate (Martin et al., 1980). The PC + 2 mutant had an optimum pH
pH optimum for general proteolysis by chymosin and other aspartic proteinases
Enzymes
Substrates
Optimum pH
Chymosin
Acid-denatured haemoglobin
3.7
Bovine serum albumin Oxidized B-chain of insulin o~-,13-Caseins
3.4 3.5 4.5
Milk-clotting activity Synthetic peptides K-Casein H--P--H--P--H--L--SmF--M--A--Imp--p--K--K Oxidized B-chain of insulin Trypsinogen Haemoglobin Haemoglobin K-Casein Milk clotting Hammerten casein z--Phe--Leu--Ala--Ala Acid-denatured haemoglobin
6-6.3 4.7 5.5 5.4 2.0 3-4 2-2.5 4.0 4.5 5.5 3.5 3-4 3.2
Berridge (1945); Fish (1957) Foltmann (1959a) Fish (1957) Lindqvist and Storgads (1960) Okigbo et aL (1985a) Raymond et aL (1972) van Hooydonk et al. (1984) Visser et aL (1976, 1987) Fish (1957) Hofmann and Shaw (1964) William et aL (1972) Arima et al. (1970) Arima et al. (1970) Arima et aL (1970) Arima et aL (1970) Oka et aL (1973) Dreyer et aL (1986)
Haemoglobin
1.1
Takahashi (1995)
Pepsin Penicillopepsin Endothiapepsin Rhizomucorpepsin
S. cerevisiae
References
proteinase A A. niger proteinase A
Rennets: General and Molecular Aspects similar to the native enzyme. The optimum pH of T r r D mutant chymosin was shifted towards neutrality by 1 pH unit, to pH 4.7 from 3.7. The optimum temperature for the activity of the TrrD mutant was increased relative to the wild-type enzyme, from approximately 45 ~ for the wild type and PC + 2 mutant, to 55 ~ for the TrrD mutant. These changes may be due to the increased negative charge at the 'flap' region that may have altered the network hydrogen bonding and influenced the substrate recognition of the enzyme.
Inhibitors All aspartic proteinases are inhibited by pepstatin, by the binding of the hydroxyl group of statine to the two catalytic aspartates (Marciniszyn et al., 1976a,b). The inhibition constant (Ki) of pepstatin for chymosin determined at pH 6.0 and 3.2 is 2.2 • 10 -7 mol/1 and 3.2 • 10-8mol/1, respectively (Powell etal., 1985). Pepsin and cathepsin also show pH-dependency of the inhibitory effect (Knight and Barrett, 1976; Baxter et al., 1990), and psuedochymosin is more sensitive to pepstatin than chymosin (McCaman et al., 1985). As pepstatin is relatively ineffective towards calf chymosin, analogue inhibitors have been developed. A series of inhibitors have been designed by Powell et al. (1985), including R(CO) N H ~ L ~ S - - S t a ~ A ~ I m P ~ P ~ K ~ K (R = acyl group) which has a Ki value for chymosin almost 20-fold better than pepstatin at pH 6.0 and approximately 10-fold better at pH 3.1 than pepstatin. Chymosin is inhibited by the pro-part of chicken pepsinogen (Ki value of 8 • 10 -8 molA at pH 5.6) but not by its own pro-segment (Strop et al., 1990).
M e c h a n i s m of Milk Clotting In milk, the primary soluble proteins are the whey proteins, ot-lactalbumin and [3-1actoglobulin. The insoluble proteins are found in large colloidal particles, called casein micelles. K-Casein is a calcium-insensitive protein which forms a protective layer around the calciumsensitive caseins (ORS1-, Ors2- , ~ - and y-), resulting in stable casein micelles. In the presence of chymosin, milk clotting occurs in two separate steps. The first phase starts with the cleavage of K-casein at the F105~M106 bond which results in the release of a hydrophilic glycopeptide (residues 106-169) that passes into the whey, and para-K-casein that remains in the micelles, para-K-Casein is positively charged at neutral pH and causes a decrease of electric repulsive forces between casein micelles (Green, 1973). Hydrolysis of other proteins in milk, including ors1-, ors2- and [3-caseins and ot-lactalbumin monomer, by chymosin has been reported with a much slower rate
33
of proteolysis (Caries and Dumas, 1985; Miranda et al., 1989). The proteolytic action of microbial proteases on K-casein has been reported (de Koning, 1967; Yu et al., 1968; Larson and Whitaker, 1970). Porcine pepsin A and C, and R. miehei proteinase cleave the same bond as chymosin (F105~M106), but C. parasitica proteinase cleaves the $104~F105 bond (Dr~nse and Foltmann, 1989). Chymosin causes limited hydrolysis of K-casein, with the formation of only macropeptide and para-K-casein, while fungal proteinases cause extensive non-specific hydrolysis of both K-casein and para-K-casein (Shammet etal., 1992). Visser et al. (1980) suggested that other residues near the cleaved bond are also involved in the hydrolytic reaction. From studies with synthetic peptides, two additional residues at both sides of the hydrolysable bond are required for appreciable reaction (Raymond et al., 1972). The peptide corresponding to residues 98-111 of K-casein ( H - - P m H - - P m H m L - - S - - F - - M m A m I m ProP--K) was found to provide a complete requirement for hydrolysis (Visser et al., 1987, 1988). Initially, the stability of the micelle is destroyed by the action of chymosin. This is followed by a nonenzymatic secondary phase in which the aggregation of para-K-casein and other caseins occurs under the influence of Ca 2+ and eventually results in gel formation (Bringe and Kinsella, 1986a; Merin et al., 1989). The formation of a clot is Ca 2+ dependent. The primary and the secondary phases of milk clotting overlap as the aggregation of micelles begins before the enzymatic process is complete (Brown and Collinge, 1986; Bringe and Kinsella, 1986b). Several factors influence the milk-clotting process, including pH, temperature, ionic strength, enzyme concentration and salts (Foltmann, 1970; Okigbo et al., 1985a,b; Bringe and Kinsella, 1986a,b). The reaction is pH dependent; at high pH (6.6-6.7), the clotting time and the curd firmness are reduced (Okigbo etal., 1985a), while at low pH (3-4), the hydrolytic activity is high and a decrease in curd yield occurs. Generally, milk clotting is performed at pH 6.3-6.6; only when direct acidification is used does rennet coagulation occur at a pH value down to 5.6. The rate of milk clotting increases with temperature as long as the enzyme is stable (Berridge, 1942). Increasing the temperature above 30-32 ~ or reducing the pH from 6.6 permits flocculation at a lower percentage of K-casein hydrolysis (Dalgleish, 1982). However, the induction of gel formation at 35 ~ requires approximately 65% hydrolysis of K-casein (Carlson et al., 1986). The differences in milk constituents (both proteins and other chemicals) as well as the pre-treatment process can affect the rate of the primary enzymatic stage. The time
34
Rennets: General and Molecular Aspects
taken to coagulate milk decreases with increasing enzyme concentration, but the formation and firmness of the gel is not altered (Bringe and Kinsella, 1986a). Milk-clotting activity is also dependent on the source of chymosin; for example, porcine chymosin is eight times more active on porcine milk than on bovine milk; calf chymosin is only half as active on porcine milk as on bovine milk and the activity of lamb chymosin is about 20% higher on ovine milk than on bovine milk (Foltmann, 1992). Calcium ion concentration affects milk clotting by forming bridges between micelles to form the coagulum and minimizes variability arising from inconsistency in milk composition (Berridge, 1952; Bringe and Kinsella, 1986b). However, Pyne (1955) reported that other ions, such as strontium, magnesium and barium, could affect the Ca 2+ requirement for coagulation. Milk clotting is inhibited by anions (Bringe and Kinsella, 1986b). While synthetic substrates have been used to reveal the hydrolytic mechanism of chymosin and other aspartic proteinases (Raymond etal., 1972; Martin etal., 1980; Visser et al., 1987, 1988), milk clotting is much more complicated than the hydrolysis of a synthetic substrate. For cheesemaking, the appropriate enzyme should have a high ratio of milk-clotting activity to proteolytic activity (C/P) (Dalgleish, 1982). The C/P ratio of chymosin is higher than for other enzymes; over 2 times higher than rhizomucor protease, 4 times higher than cryphonectria protease and over 25 times higher than pepsin, trypsin and papain (Martin et al., 1980; Yada and Nakai, 1986).
Recombinant Calf Chymosin Chymosin has been used as the milk-clotting enzyme for the industrial production of cheese. Several rennet substitutes have been used, including bovine pepsin (from adult cows), fungal proteinases and other proteolytic enzymes. However, they have a much greater level of non-specific proteolytic activity, and in some cases higher thermostability that causes more degradation of milk proteins to peptides, leading to a reduction in yield and poor flavour development in some types of cheese. Consequently, there have been numerous attempts to produce chymosin in micro-organisms. Prokaryotic expression
The first report of an attempt to produce chymosin in E. coli was that of Uchiyama et al. (1980). Efforts to express prochymosin cDNA in E. coli led to intracellular accumulation of inactive chymosin in the form of inclusion bodies (Emtage et al., 1983; Nishimori et al., 1984; McCaman et al., 1985; Kawaguchi et al., 1987;
Chitpinityol etal., 1998a). Generally, chymosin was synthesized in the form of M-prochymosin or N-terminal fusion proteins under the control of E. coli lac promoter (Nishimori et al., 1984; McCaman et al., 1985), trp promoter (Beppu, 1983; Emtage et al., 1983; Kawaguchi et al., 1984; Marston et al., 1984; Nishimori etal., 1984), tac promoter (McCaman etal., 1985; Strop etal., 1990), APR promoter (Caulcott etal., 1985), pho A promoter (Little et al., 1989) or T7 promoter (Chitpinityol et al., 1998a). In E. coli expression systems, the recombinant prochymosin was expressed at a high level which resulted in the accumulation of highly refractive inclusion bodies (Emtage et al., 1983; Kawaguchi et al., 1984; Shoemaker et al., 1985). The inclusion bodies produced were up to 40% of the total cell mass and were organized in an irregular mass without any obvious membranelike boundary, with an average diameter of 0.5-1 tzm (Marston et al., 1984; McCaman et al., 1985; Strop et al., 1990; Kapralek et al., 1991). The synthesis of prochymosin as intracellular inclusion bodies causes a fragilility of cell membranes, and the loss of cell respiratory activity and their ability to multiply (Marston et al., 1985; Kapralek et al., 1991). The production of inclusion bodies can be improved by the plasmid construction, plasmid stability, host strain, composition of the cultivation medium and growth temperature (Caulcott et al., 1985; Kawaguchi et al., 1986, 1987; Kapr~ilek et al., 1991). The N-terminal methionine of Met-prochymosin can be removed together with pro-part during acid activation. The insoluble form of prochymosin requires denaturing condition (8 mol/1 urea or 6 mol/1 guanidine HC1) to solubilize prochymosin, followed by renaturation to generate correctly folded protein that can be activated (Shoemaker et al., 1985). The deletion of disulfide bonds from prochymosin showed that the presence of disulfide bonds was not reponsible for inclusion body formation (McCaman, 1989). Improvements in the production of recombinant chymosin in E. coli have been successively developed by selection of host strain, the modification of plasmids and the optimization of cultivation conditions (Kawaguchi et al., 1986; Kapr~ilek et al., 1991). It has also been found that a high yield of active recombinant calf chymosin can be achieved by optimizing solubilization and renaturation conditions (Tichy et al., 1993; Yonezawa et al., 1993; Chitpinityol et al., 1996; Chitpinityol et al., 1998a,b). In our experiments (Chitpinityol et al., 1998a), the recombinant enzyme was refolded by a modified procedure based on that of Marston et al. (1984). Table 3 shows that the yield of chymosin was maximal when the urea mixture was diluted 25-fold (0.32 tool/1 final urea concentration). If the solubilization mixture was diluted over 25-fold, the yield of chymosin was
Rennets: General and Molecular Aspects
35
Table 3 Effect of dilution ratios on the yield of chymosin recovered by refolding. Washed inclusion pellets (protein concentration, 7.9 mg/ml) were solubilized in 8 mol/I urea buffer, pH 8. The urea mixture was incubated at 25 ~ for 1 h before the insoluble molecules were removed by centrifugation. The urea solution was then diluted in a high pH buffer (pH 10.7) for renaturation of prochymosin. The protein concentration was determined by using a BCA Protein Assay Reagent Dilution ratio of urea mixture in buffer pH 10. 7
Final urea concentration (M)
Initial concentration of protein in buffer (mg/ml)
Final amount of activated chymosin (mg)
1:10 1:20 1:25 1:30 1:40
0.80 0.40 0.32 0.27 0.20
0.79 0.39 0.32 0.26 0.20
0.46 0.49 0.50 0.40 0.26
dependent on the protein concentration in the alkaline buffer. Table 4 shows that 0.25 mg/ml protein was optimal under the refolding conditions used. This optimized procedure improves the yield of recombinant enzyme nearly three-fold. Since insoluble proteins require a further refolding process prior to regaining enzymatic activity, there have been attempts to produce prochymosin extracellularly. The N-terminal sequence of prochymosin was fused to a signal peptide of the outer membrane protein A; this resulted in cell lysis after induction (Elliott et al., 1989). Holland et al. (1990) reported that the fusion of hemolysin Hly A 8 signal sequence to the C-terminal of prochymosin resulted in the production of hybrid protein up to 25% of the total cell proteins, of which 0.8% was a soluble hybrid product. An expression system for the production of soluble porcine pepsinogen A has been developed by fusing the pepsinogen and the thioredoxin genes and then expressing the fused product in E. coli (Tanaka and Yada, 1996). Other bacterial expression systems used to produce prochymosin include Lc. lactis, Bacillus subtilis and L forms of Proteus mirabilis (Kapralek et al., 1991; Parente et al., 1991; Simons et al., 1991). In Lc. lactis, the cDNA for prochymosin was expressed under the control of proteinase prtP promoter by fusion with various lengths of Lc. lactis cell envelope-located protease (Simons et al., 1991). Under the control of the T5 phage promoter and
the induction of a two-cistron sequence at the 5' region of the gene, prochymosin was synthesized as insoluble aggregates in B. subtilis cells but the yield was still low (Parente et al., 1991). The extracellular production of prochymosin in B. subtilis can be achieved by fusing the prochymosin gene to the B. subtilis subtilisin signal sequence and production reached up to 100 mg/1 (Parente et al., 1991). Using L forms of a P. mirabilis expression system, the fusion of prochymosin cDNA minus codons 1-4 to streptococcal pyrogenic exotoxin type A gene (speA') sequences resulted in the secretion of fusion prochymosin up to 40 lxg/ml of cell-free culture fluid (Kapralek et al., 1991). Eukaryotic expression
Several eukaryotes, including yeast, fungi, insect and mammalian cells, have been used for the production of prochymosin and chymosin. In S. cerevisiae, the cDNA coding for preprochymosin, prochymosin or chymosin has been expressed under the control of phosphoglycerate kinase (pgk), galactosidase (gal 1 and gal 10) and triosephosphate isomerase (tpi). The proteins are synthesized mainly as insoluble forms which accumulate in the cells and are difficult to activate (Mellor et al., 1983; Golf et al., 1984; Moir and Davidow, 1991). Expression of preprochymosin cDNA did not allow the secretion of chymosin, while substituting yeast invertase signal
Table 4 Effect of protein concentration on the refolding of recombinant prochymosin. Inclusion bodies solubilized in 8 M urea were diluted to various protein concentrations in phosphate buffer, pH 10.7. The urea final concentrations were kept at 0.32 mol/l. The protein concentrations were determined by using a BCA protein assay reagent Initial protein concentration (mg/ml)
Initial amount of protein (mg)
Final amount of activated chymosin (mg)
% of refolding
0.32 0.28 0.25 0.22 0.19
1.58 1.42 1.26 1.11 0.95
0.33 0.31 0.37 0.28 0.18
20.86 21.85 28.99 25.54 18.66
36
Rennets: General and Molecular Aspects
peptide for the chymosin secretion signal peptide led to the secretion of approximately 10% of the total prochymosin made (Moir et al., 1985). The secretion of prochymosin is critical for obtaining soluble activatable proteins. The failure to form or the incorrect formation of disulfide bonds is characterized by insoluble prochymosin produced in the cytoplasm of both yeast (Smith et al., 1985) and E. coli (Shoemaker et al., 1985). Using yeast secretion signals, integration of the transcriptal units into yeast genome and mutations of the host genome, the secretion of prochymosin increased at least 80-fold which allowed the production of activatable prochymosin to a level of 20 mg/l of culture medium (Smith et al., 1985; Moir and Davidow, 1991). Kluyverornyces lactis has been developed as an alternative host to S. cerevisiae in the expression of recombinant proteins. It has been used successfully to secrete prochymosin under various signal sequences. Efficient synthesis and secretion of prochymosin to more than 95% of the theoretical levels was achieved by using the K. lactis lactase gene (Lac4) (van den Berg et al., 1990). Commercially viable yields have been obtained from this species by DSM Food Specialities, Delft, the Netherlands. The yeast, Yarrowia lipolytica, has also expressed prochymosin using either the Leu2 or the alkaline protease XPR2 promoters (Franke et al., 1988). All of the prochymosin produced by these systems was readily activated to mature chymosin. Filamentous fungi have also been used as hosts for the production of chymosin. In Aspergillus nidulans, chymosin was synthesized as an active extracellular enzyme using the glucoamylase (glaA) promoter from A. niger (Cullen et al., 1987). A commercial strain of A. niger var. awarnori has been used to express prochymosin cDNA under different expression cassettes (Ward, 1989; Ward et al., 1990). The level of active extracellular chymosin was 250mg/1 when prochymosin cDNA was fused with the entire coding sequence for glucoamylase and expressed in the host which has been deleted of the aspergillopepsin A gene (pepA) (Ward et al., 1990). The introduction of an N-linked glycosylation site on the flap region resulted in a 10-fold increase in the production of secreted glycosylated chymosin over the wild-type chymosin, possibly as a result of improved secretion efficiency. The milk-clotting activity of glycosylated chymosin was reduced to about 20% of the native enzyme. However, almost all of the activity was recovered after endoglycosidase H treatment (Berka et al., 1991). The production of chymosin by A. niger var. awamori has been obtained up to 1.3 g/1 by combining a mutagenesis and an efficient screening programme (Dunn-Coleman et al., 1991). About 10 mg/l chymosin has been produced by A. oryzae using a host or-amylase promoter (Boel et al.,
1987) whereas in the same expression system, a more than 3 g/1 of rhizomucor protease was obtained (Christensen et al., 1988). The production of chymosin by Trichoderma reesei has also been reported, using chymosin signal peptide, cellobiohydrolase I (cbh I) sequence or the fusion of cbh I-chymosin signal sequence (Harkki et al., 1989). Chymosin A was produced at a level of 40 mg/1 (Harkki et al., 1989). A number of chymosin mutants cloned in T.. reesei have been reported to exhibit novel properties, including mutants with a shift in the pH optimum, substrate-specificity pocket and an altered surface loop (Pitts et al., 1991, 1993). These mutants might be of interest in commercial investigations. The prochymosin secreted by T. reesei was readily activated to chymosin. In HeLa cells, calf preprochymosin cDNA has been expressed under the CMV-SV promoter (Kolmer et al., 1991). The product was processed to prochymosin prior to secretion into the cultivation medium at a level of 10-20 mg/1 and readily activated to chymosin by acid treatment. Recombinant chymosin is now produced in largescale commercial operations using E. coli (California Biotechnology and DSM Food Specialities, the Netherlands), Kluyverornyces lactis (DSM Food Specialities, the Netherlands) or mammalian cells (Upjohn, USA) as the hosts (Hodgson, 1993). Many firms, including Genencor/Genentech, Celltech, Hansen and Novo, produce recombinant enzymes for laboratory use. Varieties of cheese have been made using recombinant chymosin and evaluated in comparison to cheese produced using the natural enzyme. No significant differences could be detected between them, regarding recovery of milk solids, rate of proteolysis during ripening, as well as in the characteristics of the final cheese products (Green et al., 1985; Kawaguchi et al., 1987; Hicks et al., 1988; Bines et al., 1989; Flamm, 1991; Ward and Kodama, 1991). Recombinant lamb chymosin has been used as an alternative coagulant in cheese production, and the overall quality was at least comparable to cheese made with recombinant calf chymosin, and was scored better than cheese made using bovine rennet (Rogelj et al., 2001).
References
Abad-Zapatero, C., Rydel, TJ. and Erickson, J. (1990). Revised 2.3 /~ structure of porcine pepsin: evidence for a flexible subdomain. Proteins: Struct. Funct. Genet. 8, 62-81. Abdel Malak, C.A. (1992). Calf chymosin as a catalyst of peptide synthesis. Biochem. J. 288, 941-943. Aikawa, J., Yamashita, T., Nishiyama, M., Horinouchi, S. and Beppu, T. (1990). Effects of glycosylation on the secretion and enzyme activity of mucor rennin, an aspartic proteinase
Rennets: General and Molecular Aspects
of Mucor pusillus, produced by recombinant yeast. J. Biol. Chem. 265, 13955-13959. Aikawa, J., Nishiyama, M. and Beppu, T. (1992). Protein engineering of milk-clotting aspartic proteinases. Scand. J. Clin. Lab. Invest. 52 ($210), 51-58. Ammerer, G., Hunter, C.P., Rothman, J.H., Saari, G.C., L.A. and Stevens, T.H. (1986). PEP4 gene of Saccharomyces cerevisiae encodes proteinase A, a vacuolar enzyme required for processing of vacuolar precursors. Mol. Cell. Biol. 6, 2490-2499. Andreeva, N.S., Zdanov, A.S., Gustchina, A.E. and Fedorov, A.A. (1984). Structure of ethanol-inhibited porcine pepsin at 2/~ resolution and binding of the methyl ester of phenylalanyl-diiodotyrosine to the enzyme. J. Biol. Chem. 259, 11353-11365. Andreeva, N., Dill, J. and Gilliland, G.L. (1992). Can enzymes adopt a self-inhibited form? Results of X-ray crystallographic studies of chymosin. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 184, 1074-1081. Andr~n, A. and BjOrck, L. (1986). Milk-feeding maintains the prochymosin production in cells of bovine abomasal mucosa. Acta Physiol. Scand. 126, 419-427. Arima, K., Yu, J. and Lwasaki, S. (1970). Milk-clotting enzyme from Mucor pusiUus var. Lindt. Meth. Enzymol. 19, 446-459. Athauda, S.B.P., Takahashi, T., Inoue, H., Ichinose, M. and Takahashi, K. (1991). Proteolytic activity and cleavage specificity of cathepsin E at the physiological pH as examined towards the B chain of oxidized insulin. FEBS Lett. 292, 53-56. Bailey, M.J. and Siika-aho, M. (1988). Production of microbial rennin. Biotechnol. Lett. 10, 161-166. Bang-Jensen, V., Fohmann, B. and Rombauts, W. (1964). Studies on rennin: X on the proteolytic specificity of rennin. C. R. Travaux Lab. Carlsberg 34, 326-345. Barkholt, P.V. and Foltmann, B. (1975). Amino acid sequence of the peptide segment liberated during activation of prochymosin (prorennin). Eur. J. Biochem. 55, 95-103. Barkholt, RV., Christensen, K.A. and Fohmann, B. (1979). Investigations on the activation of bovine prochymosin. Eur. J. Biochem. 94, 573-580. Baudys, M. and Kostka, V. (1983). Covalent structure of chicken pepsinogen. Eur. J. Biochem. 136, 89-99. Baudys, M., Erdene, T.G., Kostka, V., Pavl~k, M. and Foltmann, B. (1988). Comparison between prochymosin and pepsinogen from lamb and calf. Comp. Biochem. Physiol. 89B, 385-391. Baxter, A., Campbell, CJ., Grinham, C.J., Keane, R.M., Lawton, B.C. and Pendlebury, J.E. (1990). Substrate and inhibitor studies with human gastric aspartic proteinases. Biochem. J. 267,665-669. Belozersky, M.A., Sarbakanova, S.T. and Dunaevsky, Y.E. (1989). Aspartic proteinase from wheat seeds: isolation, properties and action on gliadin. Planta 177, 321-326. Beppu, T. (1983). The cloning and expression of chymosin (rennin) genes in microorganisms. TIBTECH 1, 85-89. Berka, R.M., Ward, M., Wilson, L.J., Hayenga, K.J., Kodama, K.H., Carlomagno, L.P. and Thompson, S.A. (1990). Molecular cloning and deletion of the gene encoding
37
aspergillopepsin A from Aspergillus awamori. Gene 86, 153-162. Berka, R.M., Bayliss, ET., Bloebaum, P., Cullen, D., DunnColeman, N.S., Kodama, K.H., Hayenga, K.J., Hitzeman, R.A., Lamsa, M.H., Przetak, M.M., Rey, M.W., Wilson, L.J. and Ward, M. (1991). Aspergillus niger var. awamori as a host for the expression of heterologous genes, in, Applications of Enzyme Biotechnology, Kelly, J.W. and Baldwin, T.O., eds, Plenum Press, New York. pp. 273-292. Berridge, N.J. (1942). The second phase of rennet coagulation. Nature i49, 149-194. Berridge, N.J. (1945). The purification and crystallization of rennin. Biochem. J. 39,179-187. Berridge, N.J. (1952). Some observations on the determination of the activity of rennet. Analyst 77, 57-60. Bines, V.E., Young, P. and Law, B.A. (1989). Comparison of Cheddar cheese made with a recombinant calf chymosin and with standard calf rennet. J. Dairy Res. 56, 657-664. Birch, N.P. and Loh, Y.P. (1990). Cloning, sequence and expression of rat cathepsin D. Nucleic Acids Res. 18, 6445-6446. Blundell, T.L., Jenkins, J.A., Pearl, L.H., Sewell, B.T. and Pedersen, V. (1985). The high-resolution structure of endothiapepsin, in, Aspartic Proteinases and their Inhibitors, Kostka, V., ed., Walter de Gruyter, Berlin. pp. 151-161. Blundell, T.L., Cooper, J., Foundling, S.I., Jones, D.M., Atrash, B. and Szelke, M. (1987). On the rational design of renin inhibitors: X-ray studies of aspartic proteinases complexed with transition-state analogues. Biochemistry 26, 5585-5589. Blundell, T.L., Jenkins, J.A., Sewell, B.T., Pearl, L.H., Cooper, J.B., Tickle, I.J., Veerapandian, B. and Wood, S.R (1990). X-ray analyses of aspartic proteinases: the threedimensional structure at 2.1 A resolution of endothiapepsin. J. Mol. Biol. 210, 919-941. Boel, E., Bech, A., Randrup, K., Draeger, B., Fiil, N.P. and Foltmann, B. (1986). Primary structure of a precursor to the aspartic proteinase from Rhizomucor miehei shows that the enzyme is synthesized as a zymogen. Proteins: Structure, Function and Genetics 1,363-369. Boel, E., Christensen, T. and W61dije, H.E (1987). Process for the production of protein products in Aspergillus oryzae and a promoter for use in Aspergillus. European Patent Application 0238023. Bott, R., Subramanian, E. and Davies, D.R. (1982). Threedimentional structure of the complex of the Rhizopus chiensis carboxyl proteinase and pepstatin at 2.5 ~ resolution. Biochemistry 21, 6956-6962. Bringe, N.A. and Kinsella, J.E. (1986a). Use of platelet aggrerometer to monitor the chymosin-initiated coagulation of casein micelles. J. Dairy Res. 53,359-370. Bringe, N.A. and Kinsella, J.E. (1986b). Influence of calcium chloride on the chymosin-initiated coagulation of casein micelles. J. Dairy Res. 53,371-379. Brown, R.J. and Collinge, S.K. (1986). Actual milk coagulation time and inverse of chymosin activity. J. Dairy Res. 69,956-958.
38
Rennets: General and Molecular Aspects
Brown, E.D. and Yada, R.Y. (1991). A kinetic and equilibrium study of the denaturation of aspartic proteinases from the fungi, Endothia parasitica and Mucor miehei. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1076, 406-415. Bunn, C.W., Moews, P.C. and Baumber, M.E. (1971). The crystallography of calf rennin (chymosin). Phil. Trans. R. Soc. London. B178, 245-258. Carles, C. and Dumas, B.R. (1985). Kinetics of the action of chymosin (rennin) on a peptide bond of bovine OtSl-casein. FEBS Lett. 185,282-286. Carlson, A., Hill, G.C. and Olson, N.E (1986). The coagulation of milk with immobilized enzymes: a critical review. Enzyme Microb. Technol. 8, 642-650. Caulcott, C.A., Lilley, G., Wright, M., Robinson, M.K. and Yarranton, G.T. (1985). Investigation of the stability of the plasmids directing the expression of Met-prochymosin in Escherichia coli. J. Gen. Microbiol. 131, 3355-3365. Cheeseman, G.C. (1965). Denaturation of rennin: effect on activity and molecular configuration. Nature 205, 1011-1012. Chen, Z., Koelsch, G., Han, H., Wang, X., Hartsuck, J.A. and Tang, J. (1991). Recombinant rhizopuspepsinogen: expression, purification and activation properties of recombinant rhizopuspepsinogens. J. Biol. Chem. 266, 11718-11725. Chitpinityol, S. and Crabbe, MJ.C. (1998). Chymosin and aspartic proteases. Food Chem. 61,395-418. Chitpinityol, S., Goode, D. and Crabbe, MJ.C. (1996). Does oL-crystallin chaperone prochymosin folding? in, Perspectives on Protein Engineering, Geisow, M.J. ed., Biodigm Ltd. pp. 29-30. Chitpinityol, S., Goode, D. and Crabbe, M.J.C. (1998a). Sitespecific mutations of calf chymosin B which influence milk-clotting activity. Food Chem. 62, 133-139. Chitpinityol, S., Goode, D. and Crabbe, M.J.C. (1998b). Studies on the binding of oL-crystallin to recombinant prochymosins and chymosin. Mol. Vision 4, 1-7. Christensen, T., Woeldike, H., Boel, E., Mortensen, S.B., Hjortshoej, K., Thim, L. and Hansen, M.T. (1988). High level expression of recombinant genes in Aspergillus oryzae. Bio/Technology 6, 1419-1422. Cooper, J.B., Foundling, S.I., Hemmings, A., Blundell, T.L., Jones, D.M., Hallet, A. and Szelke, M. (1987). The structure of a synthetic pepsin inhibitor complexed with endothiapepsin. Eur. J. Biochem. 169, 215-221. Cooper, J.B., Khan, G., Taylor, G., Tickle, I.J. and Blundell, T.L. (1990). X-ray analyses of aspartic proteinases. II. Three-dimensional structure of the hexagonal crystal form of porcine pepsin at 2.3 A.J. Mol. Biol. 214, 199-222. Crabbe, M.J.C. and Hepburne-Scott, H.W. (2001). Small heatshock proteins (sHSPs) as potential drug targets. Curr. Pharm. Biotechnol. 2, 77-111. Cullen, D., Gray, G.L., Wilson, L.J., Hayenga, K.J., Lamsa, M.H., Rey, M.W., Norton, S. and Berka, R.M. (1987). Controlled expression and secretion of bovine chymosin in AspergiUus nidulans. Bio/Technology 5,369-376. Dalgleish, D.G. (1982). The enzymatic coagulation of milk, in, Developments in Dairy Chemistry, Vol. 1, Fox, P.E, ed., Applied Science Publishers, London. pp. 157-187.
Danley, D.E. and Geoghegan, K.E (1988). Structure and mechanism of formation of chymosin C derived from recombinant chymosin A. J. Biol. Chem. 263, 9785-9789. de Koning, P.J. (1967). Studies of Rennin and the Genetic Variants of Casein. PhD Thesis, University of Amsterdam. Derham, B.K., van Boekel, M.A.M., Muchowski, P.J., Clark, J.I., Horwitz, J., Hepburne-Scott, H.W., Harding, J.J. and Crabbe, M.J.C. (2001). Chaperone function of mutant versions of otA- and otB-crystallin prepared to pinpoint chaperone binding sites. Eur. J. Biochem. 268,713-721. Dhanaraj, V., Dealwis, C.G., Frazao, C., Badasso, M., Sibanda, B.L., Tickle, I.L., Cooper, J.B., Driessen, H.P.C., Newman, M., Aguilar, C., Wood, S.P., Blundell, T.L., Hobart, P.M., Geoghegan, K.E, Ammirati, M.J., Danley, D.E., O'Connor, B.A. and Hoover, D.J.H. (1992). X-ray analyses of peptide-inhibitor complexes define the structural basis of specificity for human and mouse renins. Nature 357,466-472. Doi, E., Shibata, D., Matoba, T. and Yonezawa, D. (1980). Characterization of pepstatin-sensitive acid protease in resting rice seeds. Agric. Biol. Chem. 44, 741-747. Donnelly, W.J., Carroll, D.P., O'Callaghan, D.M. and Walls, D. (1986). Genetic polymorphism of bovine chymosin. J. Dairy Res. 53,657-664. Dreyer, T., Halkier, B., Svendsen, J. and Ottesen, M. (1986). Primary structure of the aspartic proteinase A from Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Carlsberg Res. Commun. 51, 27-41. Dmnse, H.B. and Fohmann, B. (1989). Specificity of milkclotting enzymes towards bovine K-casein. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 995,221-224. Dunn, B.M., Jimenez, M., Parten, B.E, Valler, M.J., Rolph, C.E. and Kay, J. (1986). A systematic series of synthetic chromophoric substrates for aspartic proteinases. Biochem. J. 237, 899-906. Dunn, B.M., Valler, MJ., Rolph, C.E., Foundling, S.I., Jimenez, M. and Kay, J. (1987). The pH dependence of the hydrolysis of chromogenic substrates of the type, Lys-Pro-Xaa-Yaa-Phe-(NO2). Phe-Arg-Leu, by selected aspartic proteinases: evidence for specific interactions in subsites $3 and $2. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 913, 122-130. Dunn-Coleman, N.S., Bloebaum, P, Berka, R.M., Bodies, E., Robinson, N., Armstrong, G., Ward, M., Przetak, M., Carter, G.C., LaCost, R., Wilson, L.J., Kodama, K.H., Baliu, E.E, Bower, B., Lamsa, M. and Heinsohn, H. (1991). Commercial level of chymosin production by Aspergillus. Bio/Technology 9,976-981. Elliott, S., Wilderspin, A.E and Pitts, J.E. (1989). Construction of an ompA-prochymosin signal fusion in pIN-III ompA2. Biochem. Soc. Trans. 17, 764-765. Emtage, J.S., Angal, S., Doel, M.T., Harris, T.J.R., Jenkins, B., Lilley, G. and Lowe, P.A. (1983). Synthesis of calf prochymosin (prorennin) in Escherichia coli. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA 80, 3671-3675. Faust, PL., Kornfeld, S. and Chirgwin, J.M. (1985). Cloning and sequence analysis of cDNA for human cathepsin D. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 82, 4910-4914.
Rennets: General and Molecular Aspects
Fish, J.C. (1957). Activity and specificity of rennin. Nature 180,345 (1 page). Flamm, E.L. (1991). How FDA approved chymosin: a case history. Bio/Technology 9,349-351. Foltmarln, B. (1959a). Studies on rennin. II. On the crystallisation, stability and proteolytic activity of rennin. Acta Chem. Scand. 13, 1927-1935. Foltmann, B. (1959b). Studies on rennin. III. On the solubility of rennin. Acta Chem. Scand. 13, 1936-1942. Foltmann, B. (1960). Studies on rennin: IV Chromatographic fractionation of rennin. Acta Chem. Scand. 14, 2059-2061. Foltmann, B. (1962). Studies on rennin. VI. The heterogeneity of prorennin and its transformation into rennin. C. R. Travaux Lab. Carlsberg 32,425-444. Foltmann, B. (1964). On the amino acid composition of prorennin, rennin and of peptides liberated during the activation of prorennin. C. R. Travaux. Lab. Carlsberg 34, 275-286. Foltmann, B. (1966). A review on prorennin arid rennin. C. R. Travaux Lab. Carlsberg 35, 143-231. Foltmann, B. (1970). Prochymosin and chymosin (prorennin and rennin). Methods Enzymol. 19,421-437. Foltmann, B. (1988). Structure and function of proparts in zymogens for aspartic proteinases. Biol. Chem. HoppeSeyler 369, 311-314. Foltmann, B. (1992). Chymosin: a short review on foetal and neonatal gastric proteases. Scand. J. Clin. Lab. Invest. 52 ($210), 65-79. Foltmann, B. (1993). Ontogeny and characterization of porcine prochymosin, pepsinogen B, progastricsin and pepsinogen A, in, Abstracts of the Fifth International Conference on Aspartic Proteinases, September 19-25, 1993. Gifu, Japan. L5/5. Foltmann, B., Pedersen, V.B., Jacobsen, H., Kauffman, D. and Wybrandt, D. (1977). The complete amino acid sequence of prochymosin. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA 74, 2321-2324. Foltmann, B., Lonblad, P. and Axelsen, N.H. (1978). Demonstration of chymosin (EC 3.4.23.4) in the stomach of newborn pig. Biochem. J. 160,425-427. Foltmann, B., Pedersen, V.B., Kauffman, D. and Wybrandt, G. (1979). The primary structure of calf chymosin. J. Biol. Chem. 254, 8447-8456. Foundling, S.I., Cooper, J., Watson, EE., Cleasby, A., Pearl, L.H., Sibanda, B.L., Hemmings, A., Wood, S.P., Blundell, T.L., Valler, M.J., Norey, C.G., Kay, J., Boger, J., Dunn, B.M., Leckie, B.J., Jones, D.M., Atrash, B., Hallett, A. and Szelke, M. (1987). High resolution X-ray analysis of renin inhibitor-aspartic proteinase complexes. Nature 327, 349. Francky, A., Francky, B.M., Strukelj, B., Gruden, K., Ritonja, A., Krizaj, I., Kregar, I., Pain, R.H. and Pungercar, J. (2001). A basic residue at position 36p of the propeptide is not essential for the correct folding and subsequent autocatalytic activation of prochymosin. Eur. J. Biochem. 268, 2362-2368. Franke, A.E., Kaczmarek, ES., Eisenhard, M.E., Geoghgan, K.E, Danley, D.E., De-Zeeuw, J.R., O'Donnell, M.M., Gollaher, M.G., Jr. and Davidow, L.S. (1988). Expression and secretion of bovine prochymosin in Yarrowia lipolytica. Dev. Ind. Microbiol. 29, 43-47.
39
Fruton, J.S. (1982). Proteinase-catalysed synthesis of peptide-bonds. Adv. Enzymol. 53,239-306. Fumamoto, J., Tsuru, D. and Yamamoto, T. (1967). A reninlike enzyme from Rhizopus chinensis. Agric. Biol. Chem. 31,710-717. Gilliland, G.L., Winborne, E.L., Nachman, J. and Wlodawer, A. (1990). The three-dimensional structure of recombinant bovine chymosin at 2.3 A resolution. Proteins: Struct. Funct. Genet. 8, 82-101. Golf, C.G., Moir, D.T., Kohno, T., Fravius, T.C., Smith, R.A., Yamasaki, E. and Taunton-Rigby, A. (1984). Expression of calf prochymosin in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Gene 27, 35-46. Gray, G.L., Hayenga, K., Cullen, D., Wilson, LJ. and Norton, S. (1986). Primary structure of Mucor miehei aspartyl protease: evidence for a zymogen intermediate. Gene 48, 41-53. Green, M.L. (1973). Studies on the mechanism of clotting of milk. Neth. Milk DairyJ. 27, 278-285. Green, M.L., Angal, S., Lowe, P.A. and Marston, EA.O. (1985). Cheddar cheese-making with recombinant calf chymosin synthesized in Escherichia coli. J. Dairy Res. 52, 281-286. Guillou, H., Miranda, G. and Pelissier, J.P. (1991). Hydrolysis of [3-casein by gastric proteases. Int. J. Peptide Protein Res. 37,494-501. Gustchina, E., Rumsh, L., Ginodman, L., Majer, P. and Andreeva, N. (1996). Post X-ray crystallographic studies of chymosin: the existence of two structural forms and the regulation of activity by the interaction with the histidine-proline cluster of K-casein. FEBS Lett. 379, 60-62. Gustchina, A., Li, M., Phylip, L.H., Lees, W.E., Kay, J. and Wlodawer, A. (2002). An unusual orientation for Tyr75 in the active site of the aspartic protease from Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 295, 1020-1026. Harkki, A., Uusitalo, J., Bailey, M., Penttil~, M. and Knowles, J.K.C. (1989). A novel fungal expression system: secretion of active calf chymosin from the filamentous fungus Trichoderma reesei. Bio/Technology 7, 596-603. Harris, T.J.R., Lowe, EA., Thomas, P.A.W., Millican, T.A., Patel, T.A., Bose, C.C., Carey, N.H. and Doel, M.T. (1982). Molecular cloning and nucleotide sequence of cDNA coding for calf preprochymosin. Nucl. Acids Res. 10, 2177-2187. Hartsuck, J.A. and Remington, S.J. (1988). Porcine pepsinogen crystallography, in, 18th Linderstrom-Lang Conference Proceedings, Elsinore, Denmark. pp. 33-34. Hartsuck, J.A., Koelsch, G. and Remington, S.J. (1992). The high-resolution crystal structure of porcine pepsinogen. Proteins: Struct. Funct. Genet. 13, 1-25. Hayano, T., Sogawa, K., Ichihara, Y., Fujii-Kuriyama, Y. and Takashashi, K. (1988). Primary structure of human pepsinogen C gene. J. Biol. Chem. 263, 1382-1385. Hayashi, K., Yasugi, S. and Mizurlo, T. (1988). Isolation and structural analysis of embryonic chicken pepsinogen gene: avian homologue of prochymosin gene. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 152,776-782.
40
Rennets: General and Molecular Aspects
Hicks, C.L., O'Leary, J. and Bucy, J. (1988). Use of recombinant chymosin in the manufacture of Cheddar and Colby cheese.J. Dairy Sci. 71, 1127-1131. Hidaka, M., Sasaki, K., Uozumi, T. and Beppu, T. (1986). Cloning and structural analysis of the calf prochymosin gene. Gene 43, 197-203. Hill, R.D. and Laing, R.R. (1965). The action of rennin on casein: the effect of modifying functional groups on the rennin. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 99,352-359. Hodgson, J. (1993) Expression systems: a user's guide. BioITechnology 11,887-893. Hofmann, T. and Shaw, R. (1964). Proteolytic enzymes of Penicillium janthinellum. I. Purification and properties of a trypsinogen-activation enzyme (peptidase A). Biochim. Biophys. Acta 92,543-557. Hofmann, T., Hodges, R.S. and James, M.N.G. (1984). Effect of pH on the activities of penicillopepsin and rhizopuspepsin and a proposal for the productive substrate-binding mode in penicillopepsin. Biochemistry 23,635-643. Holland, B., Kenny, B., Steipe, B. and Pl{ickthun, A. (1990). Secretion of heterologous proteins in Escherichia coli. Meth. Enzymol. 182,132-143. Holm, I., Ollo, R., Panthier, J.J. and Rougeon, E (1984). Evolution of aspartyl proteases by gene duplication: the mouse renin gene is organized in 2 homologous clusters of 4 exons. EMBO J. 3,557-562. Horiuchi, H., Yanai, K., Okazaki, T., Takagi, M. and Yano, K. (1988) Isolation and sequencing of a genomic clone encoding aspartic protease of Rhizopus niveus. J. Bacteriol. 170, 272-278. Huang, H., Zhang, Z., Liu, N., Zhang, Y., Zhang, G. and Yang, K. (1992). Functional implication of disulfide bond, Cys250-Cys283, in bovine chymosin. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 187,692-696. Hubble, J. and Mann, P. (1984). Destabilization of microbial rennet. Biotechnol. Lett. 6, 341-344. Hurley, M.J., Larsen, L.B., Kelly, A.L. and McSweeney, P.L.H. (2000). The milk acid proteinase cathepsin D: a review. Int. DairyJ. 10,673-681. Ido, E., Han, H.-P., Kezdy, EJ. and Tang, J. (1991). Kinetic studies of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 protease and its active-site hydrogen bond mutant A28S. J. Biol. Chem. 266, 24359-24366. Imai, T., Miyazaki, H., Hirose, S., Hayasi, T., Kageyama, R., Ohkubu, H., Nakanishi, S. and Murakami, K. (1983). Cloning and sequence analysis of cDNA for human renin precursor. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 80, 7405-7409. Ishihara, T., Ichihara, Y., Hayano, T., Katsura, I., Sogawa, K., Fujii-Kuriyama, Y. and Takahashi, K. (1989). Primary structure and transcriptional regulation of rat pepsinogen C gene.J. Biol. Chem. 264, 10193-10199. Jakubke, H.D. (1987). Peptide synthesis from pepsin and chymosin in, The Peptides: Analysis, Synthesis, Biology, Udenfried, S. and Meienhofer, J., eds, Vol. 9. Academic Press, New York. pp. 103-165. James, M.N.G. and Sielecki, A.R. (1983). Structure and refinement of penicillopepsin at 1.8 A resolution. J. Mol. Biol. 163,299-361. James, M.N.G. and Sielecki, A.R. (1985). Stereochemical analysis of peptide bond hydrolysis catalyzed by the
aspartic proteinase penicillopepsin. Biochemistry 24, 3701-3713. James, M.N.G. and Sielecki, A.R. (1986). Molecular structure of an aspartic proteinase zymogen, porcine pepsinogen, at 1.8 A resolution. Nature 319, 33-38. James, M.N.G. and Sielecki, A.R. (1987). Aspartic proteinases and their catalytic pathway, in, Biological Macromolecules and Assemblies, Jurnak, E and McPherson, A., eds, John Wiley & Sons, New York. pp. 413-482. James, M.N.G., Hsu, I.-N. and Delbaere, L.T.J. (1977). Mechanism of acid protease catalysis based on the crystal structure of penicillopepsin. Nature 267,808-813. James, M.N.G., Sielecki, A., Salituro, E, Rich, D.H. and Hofmann, T. (1982). Conformational flexibility in the active sites of aspartyl proteinases revealed by a pepstatin fragment binding to penicillopepsin. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 79, 6137-6141. James, M.N.G., Sielecki, A. and Hofmann, T. (1985). X-ray diffraction studies on penicillopepsin and its complexes: the hydrolytic mechanism, in, Aspartic Proteinases and Their Inhibitors, Kostka, de Gruyter, V., ed., New York. pp. 163-177. James, M.N.G., Sielecki, A., Hayakawa, K. and Gelb, M.H. (1992). Crystallographic analysis of transition state mimics bound to penicillopepsin: difluorostatine- and difluorostatone-containing peptides. Biochemistry 31, 3872-3886. Jensen, T., Axelsen, N.H. and Foltmann, B. (1982). Isolation and partial characterization of prochymosin and chymosin from cat. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 705,249-256. Kageyama, T. (1995). Procathepsin E and cathepsin E. Meth. Enzymol. 248, 120-136. Kapr~ilek, E, Jecmen, P., Sedlacek, J., Fabry, M. and Zadrazil, S. (1991). Fermentation conditions for high-level expression of the tac-promoter-controlled calf prochymosin cDNA in Escherichia coli HB101. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 37, 71-79. Kawaguchi, Y., Shimizu, N., Nishimori, K., Uozumi, T. and Beppu, T. (1984). Renaturation and activation of calf prochymosin produced in an insoluble form in Escherichia coli. J. Biotechnol. 1,307-315. Kawaguchi, Y., Yanagida, N., Uozumi, T. and Beppu, T. (1986). Improved direct expression of prochymosin cDNA through changing the SD-ATG codon length. Agric. Biol. Chem. 50,499-500. Kawaguchi, Y., Kosugi, S., Sasaki, K., Uozumi, T. and Beppu, T. (1987). Production of chymosin in Escherichia coli cells and its enzymatic properties. Agric. Biol. Chem. 51, 1871-1877. Kay, J. (1985). Aspartic proteinases and their inhibitors. Biochem. Soc. Trans. 13, 1027-1029. Knight, C.G. and Barrett, A.J. (1976). Interaction of human cathepsin D with the inhibitor pepstatin. Biochem. J. 155, 117-125. Koaze, Y., Goi, H., Ezawa, K., Yamada, Y. and Hara, T. (1964). Fungal proteolytic enzymes. Part 1. Isolation of two kinds of acid-proteases excreted by Aspergillus niger var. macrosporus. Agric. Biol. Chem. 28, 216. Koelsch, G., Mares, M., Metcalf, P. and Fusek, M. (1994). Multiple functions of pro-parts of aspartic proteinase zymogens. FEBS Lett. 343, 6-10.
Rennets: General and Molecular Aspects
Kolmer, M., Ord, T. and Ulmanen, I. (1991). Expression of recombinant calf chymosin in mammalian cell culture. J. Biotechnol. 20, 131-140. Kotler, M., Danho, W., Katz, A.A., Leis, J. and Skalka, A.M. (1989). Avian retroviral protease and cellular aspartic proteases are distinguished by activities on peptide substrates. J. Biol. Chem. 264, 3428-3435. Lapatto, R., Blundell, T., Hemmings, A., Overington, J., Wilderspin, A., Wood, S., Merson, J.R., Whittle, P.J., Danley, D.E., Geoghegan, K.E, Hawrylik, S.J., Lee, S.E., Scheld, K.G. and Hobart, P.M. (1989). X-ray analysis of HIV-I proteinase at 2.7 A resolution confirms structural homology among retroviral enzymes. Nature (London) 342,299-302. Larsen, L.B., Boisen, A. and Peterson, T. (1993). Procathepsin D cannot autoactivate to cathepsin D at acid pH. FEBS Lett. 319, 54-58. Larson, M.K. and Whitaker, J.R. (1970). Endothia parasitica protease: parameters affecting activity of the rennin-like enzyme. J. Dairy Sci. 53,253-261. Lilla, S., Caira, S., Ferranti, P. and Addeo, E (2001). Mass spectroscopic characterization of proteins in rennet and in chymosin-based milk clotting preparations. Rapid Commun. Mass Spectrom. 15, 1101-1112. Lin, X., Wong, R.N.S. and Tang, J. (1989). Synthesis, purification, and active site mutagenesis of recombinant porcine pepsinogen. J. Biol. Chem. 264, 4482-4489. Lin, X. and Tang, J. (1990). Purification, characterization and gene cloning of thermopepsin, a thermostable acid protease from Sulfolobus acidocaldarius. J. Biol. Chem. 265, 1490-1495. Lin, X., Lin. Y., Doelsch, G., Gustchina, A., Wlodawer, A. and Tang, J. (1992). Enzymic activities of two-chain pepsinogen, two-chain pepsin, and amino terminal lobe of pepsinogen. J. Biol. Chem. 267, 17257-17263. Lindqvist, B. and Storgads, T. (1960). An electrophoretic investigation of the degradation of [3-casein by crystalline rennin. Acta Chem. Scand. 14, 757-764. Little, S., Campbell, C.J., Evans, I.J., Hayward, E.C., Lilley, R.J. and Robison, M.K. (1989). A short N-proximal region of prochymosin inhibits the secretion of hybrid proteins from Escherichia coli. Gene 83,321-329. MacKay, V.L., Welch, S.K., Insley, M.Y., Manney, T.R., Holly, J., Saari, G.C. and Parker, M.L. (1988). The Saccharomyces cerevisiae BAR1 gene encodes an exported protein with homology to pepsin. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 85, 55-59. Mantafounis, D. and Pitts, J. (1990). Protein engineering of chymosin: modification of the optimum pH of enzyme catalysis. Protein Eng. 3,605-609. Marciniszyn, J., Hartsuck, J.A. and Tang, J. (1976a). Mode of inhibition of acid proteases by pepstatin. J. Biol. Chem. 251, 7088-7094. Marciniszyn, J., Huang, J.S., Hartsuck, J.A. and Tang, J. (1976b). Mechanism of intramolecular activation of pepsinogen.J. Biol. Chem. 251, 7095-7102. Marston, EA.O., Lowe, P.A., Doel, M.T., Shoemaker, J.M., White, S. and Angal, S. (1984). Purification of calf prochymosin (prorennin) synthesized in Escherichia coll. Bio/Technology 2,800-804.
41
Marston, EA.O., Angal, S., White, S. and Lowe, P.A. (1985). Solubilization and activation of recombinant calf prochymosin from Escherichia coll. Biochem. Soc. Trans. 13, 1035. Martin, P. and Corre, C. (1984). Fractionation of the multiple forms of bovine gastric aspartic proteases by chromatofocusing. Anal. Biochem. 143,256-264. Martin, P., Raymond, M.N., Bricas, E. and Dumas, B.R. (1980). Kinetic studies on the action of Mucor pusillus, Mucor miehei acid proteases and chymosins A and B on a synthetic chromophoric hexapeptide. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 612,410-420. McCaman, M.T. (1989). Fragments of prochymosin produced in Escherichia coli form insoluble inclusion bodies. J. Bacteriol. 171, 1225-1227. McCaman, M.T. and Cummings, D.B. (1986). A mutated bovine prochymosin zymogen can be activated without proteolytic processing at low pH. J. Biol. Chem. 261, 15345-15348. McCaman, M.T. and Cummings, D.B. (1988). Unusual zymogen-processing properties of a mutated form of prochymosin. Proteins: Structure, Function and Genetics 3, 256-261. McCaman, M.T., Andrews, W.H. and Files, J.G. (1985). Enzymatic properties and processing of bovine prochymosin synthesized in Escherichia coll. J. Biotechnol. 2, 177-190. McCullough, J.M. and Whitaker, J.R. (1971). Substrate specificity of the milk-clotting protease from Mucor pusillus determined on the oxidized B-chain insulin. J. Dairy Sci. 54, 1575-1578. McPhile, P. (1972). A spectrophotometric investigation of the pepsinogen-pepsin conversion. J. Biol. Chem. 247, 4277-4281. McPhile, P. (1975). The origin of the alkaline inactivation of pepsinogen. Biochemistry 14, 5253-5256. Mellor, J., Dobson, M.J., Roberts, N.A., Tuite, M.E, Emtage, J.S., White, S., Lowe, RA., Patel, T., Kingsmann, A.J. and Kingsmann, S.M. (1983). Efficient synthesis of enzymatically active calf chymosin in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Gene 24, 1-14. Menzella, H.G., Gramajo, H.C. and Ceccarelli, E.A. (2002). High recovery of prochymosin from inclusion bodies using controlled air oxidation. Protein Expr. Purific. 25, 248-255. Merin, U., Talpaz, H. and Fishman, S. (1989). A mathematical model for the description of chymosin action on casein micelles. J. Dairy Res. 56, 76-86. Metcalf, P. and Fusek, M. (1993). Two crystal structures for cathepsin D: the lysosomal-targeting signal and active site. EMBOJ. 12, 1293-1302. Mezina, M.N., Lavrenova, G.I., Prokofev, M.I., Starovoitova, V.V., Ermolaev, V.I., Chernyh, V.Y., Baladina, G.N. and Demidovich, S.S. (2001). Isolation of milk-clotting enzyme from transgenic sheep milk and its comparison with calf chymosin. Biochemistry (Moscow) 66, 378-383. Miller, M., Jaskolski, M., Rao, J.K.M., Leis, J. and Wlodawer, A. (1989). Crystal structure of a retroviral protease proves relationship to aspartic protease family. Nature 337, 576-579.
42
Rennets: General and Molecular Aspects
Miranda, G., Haze, G., Scanff, P. and Pelissier, J.P. (1989). Hydrolysis of ot-lactalbumin by chymosin and pepsin: effect of conformation and pH. Lait 69,451-459. Miyazaki, H., Fukamizu, A., Hirose, S., Hayashi, T., Hori, H., Ohkubo, H., Nakanishi, S. and Murakami, K. (1984). Structure of the human renin gene. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 81, 5999-6003. Moir, D.T. and Davidow, L.S. (1991). Production of proteins by secretion from yeast. Meth. Enzymol. 194, 491-502. Moir, D., Mao, J., Schumm, J.W., Vovis, G.E, Alford, B.L. and Rigby, A.T. (1982). Molecular cloning and characterization of double-stranded cDNA coding for bovine chymosin. Gene 19, 127-138. Moir, D.T., Moa, J., Duncan, M.J., Smith, R.A. and Kohno, T. (1985). Production of calf chymosin by the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, in, Developments in Industrial Microbiology, Vol. 26, Underkofler, L., ed., Society for Industrial Microbiology, Arlington, VA, USA. pp. 75-85. Moore, S.A., Sielecki, A.R., Chernaia, M.M., Tarasova, N.I. and James, N.G. (1995). Crystal and molecular structures of human progastricsin at 1.62 ft, resolution. J. Mol. Biol. 247,466-485. Morris, P.C., Miller, R.C. and Bowles, D.J. (1985). Endopeptidase activity in dry h a r v e s t - ripe wheat and barley grains. Plant Sci. 39, 121-124. Navia, M.A., Fitzgerald, P.M.D., McKeever, B.M., Leu, C.-T., Heimbach, J.C., Herber, W.K., Sigal, I.S., Darke, P.L. and Springer, J.P. (1989). Three-dimentional structure of aspartic protease from human immunodeficiency virus HIV-1. Nature 337,615-620. Nedjar, S., Humbert, G., Deaut, J.Y.L. and Linden, G. (1991). Specificity of chymosin on immobilized bovine B-chain insulin. Int. J. Biochem. 23,377-381. Newman, M., Safro, M., Frazao, C., Khan, G., Zdanov, A., Tickle, I.J., Blundell, T.L. and Andreeva, N. (1991). X-ray analyses of aspartic proteinases. IV. Structure and refinement at 2.2 A resolution of bovine chymosin. J. Mol. Biol. 221, 1295-1309. Newman, M., Watson, E, Roychowdhury, P, Jones, H., Badasso, M., Cleasby, A., Wood, S.P., Tickle, I.J. and Blundell, T.L. (1993). X-ray analyses of aspartic proteinase. V. Structure and refinement at 2.0 A resolution of the aspartic proteinase from Mucor pusillus. J. Mol. Biol. 230, 260-283. Nielsen, ES. and Foltmann, B. (1993). Activation of porcine pepsinogen A: the stability of two non-covalent activation intermediates at pH 8.5. Eur. J. Biochem. 217, 137-142. Nishimori, K., Shimizu, N., Kawaguchi, Y., Hidaka, M., Uozumi, T. and Beppu, T. (1984). Expression of calf prochymosin cDNA by plasmid vectors using tryptophan operon promotor. Gene 29, 41-49. Oka, T., Ishino, K., Tsuzuki, H., Morihara, K. and Arima, K. (1973). On the specificity of a rennin-like enzyme from Mucorpusillus. Agric. Biol. Chem. 37, 1177-1184. Okigbo, L.M., Richardson, G.H., Brown, R.J. and Ernstrom, C.A. (1985a). Effect of pH, calcium chloride, and chymosin concentration on coagulation properties of abnormal and normal milk. J. Dairy Sci. 68, 2527-2533. Okigbo, L.M., Richardson, G.H., Brown, R.J. and Ernstrom, C.A. (1985b). Interaction of calcium, pH, temperature
and chymosin during milk coagulation. J. Dairy Sci. 68, 3135-3142. Orprayoon, P. (1994). Protein Engineering of the Surface Loops of Chymosin. PhD Thesis, University of London. Ostoslavskaya, V.I., Revina, L.P., Kotlova, I.A., Levin, E.D., Timokhina, E.A. and Stepanov, V.M. (1986). Structure and function of aspartic proteases. Bioorg. Khim. 8, 1030-1047. Cited in Ward & Kodama (1991). Parente, D., de Ferra, E, Galli, G. and Grandi, G. (1991). Prochymosin expression in Bacillus subtilis. FEMS Microbiol. Lett. 77, 243-250. Pearl, L. (1987). The catalytic mechanism of aspartic proteinases. FEBS Lett. 214, 8-12. Pearl, L. and Blundell, T.L. (1984). The active site of aspartic proteinases. FEBS Lett. 174, 96-101. Pitts, J.E. (1992). Crystallization by centrifugation. Nature 355, 117-120. Pitts, J.E., Quinn, D., Uusitalo, J.M. and Penttil/i, M.E. (1991). Protein engineering of chymosin and expression in Trichoderma reesei. Food Biotechnol. 19,663-666. Pitts, J.E., Dhanaraj, V., Dealwis, C.G., Mantafounis, D., Nugent, P., Orprayoon, P., Cooper, J.B., Newman, M. and Blundell, T.L. (1992). Multidisciplinary cycles for protein engineering: site-directed mutagenesis and X-ray structural studies of aspartic proteinases. Scand. J. Clin. Lab. Invest. 52 ($210), 39-50. Pitts, J.E., Uusitalo, J.M., Mantafounis, D., Nugent, P., Quinn, D., Orprayoon, P. and Penttil/i, M.E. (1993). Expression and characterization of chymosin pH optima mutants produced in Trichoderma reesei. J. Biotechnol. 28, 69-83. Plater, M.L., Goode, D. and Crabbe, M.J.C. (1996). Effects of site-directed mutations on the chaperone-like activity of alpha B crystalline. J. Biol. Chem. 271, 28558-28566. Polanowski, A., Wilusz, T., Kolaczkowska, M.K., Wieczorek, M. and Wilimowska-Pelc, A. (1985). Purification and characterisation of aspartic proteinases from Cucumis sativus and Cucurbita maxima seeds, in, Aspartic Proteinases and their Inhibitors, Kostka, V., ed., Walter de Gruyter & Co., Berlin. pp. 49-52. Polgar, L. (1987). The mechanism of action of aspartic proteases involves 'push-pull' catalysis. FEBS Lett. 219, 1-4. Poorman, R.A., Tomasselli, A.G., Heinrikson, R.L. and Kezdy, EJ. (1991). A cumulative specificity model for proteases from human immunodeficiency virus types 1 and 2, inferred from statistical analysis of an extended substrate data base.J. Biol. Chem. 266, 14554-14561. Powell, M.J., Holdsworth, R.J., Baker, T.S., Titmas, R.C., Bose, C.C., Phipps, A., Eaton, M., Roph, C.E., Valler, M.J. and Kay, J. (1985). Design and synthesis of statine-containing inhibitors of chymosin, in, Aspartic Proteinases and Their Inhibitors, Kostka, V., ed., Walter de Gruyter & Co., Berlin. pp. 479-483. Privalov, P.L., Mateo, P., Khechinashvili, N.N., Stepanov, V.M. and Revina, L.P. (1981). Comparative thermodynamic study of pepsinogen and pepsin structure. J. Mol. Biol. 152,445-464. Pungercar, J., Strukelj, B., Gubensek, E, Turk, V. and Kregar, I. (1991). Amino acid sequence of lamb preprochymosin and its comparison to other chymosin, in, Structure and Function
Rennets: General and Molecular Aspects
of Aspartic Proteinases, Dunn, B.M., ed., Plenum Press, New York. pp. 127-131. Pyne, G.T. (1955). The chemistry of casein: a review of the literature. Dairy Sci. Abstr. 17, 532-553. Quinn, D., Pitts, J.E., Mantafounis, D., Lawler, S.E., Uusitalo, J., Penttil/i, M. and Strop, P. (1991). Modifying the substrate specificity of chymosin. Biochem. Soc. Trans. 19, 267S. Rajagopalan, T.G., Stein, W.H. and Moore, S. (1966). The inactivation of pepsin by diazoacetylnorleucine methyl ester. J. Biol. Chem. 241, 4295-4297. Rand, A.G. and Ernstrom, C.A. (1964). Effect of pH and sodium chloride on activation of prorennin. J. Dairy Sci. 47, 1181-1187. Rao, M.J.K., Erickson, J.W. and Wlodawer, A. (1991). Structure and evolutionary relationships between retroviral and eukaryotic aspartic proteinases. Biochemistry 30, 4663-4671. Raonaik, C., Guruprasad, K., Batley, B., Rapundalo, S., Hill, J., Blundell, T., Kay, J. and Dunn, B.M. (1995). Exploring the binding preferences specificity in the active-site of human cathepsin-E. Protein 22, 168-181. Raymond, M.N., Garnier, J., Bricas, E., Cilianu, S., Blasnic, M., Chain, A. and Lefrancier, P. (1972). Studies on the specificity of chymosin (rennin). I. Kinetic parameters of the hydrolysis of synthetic oligopeptide substrates. Biochemie 54, 145-154. Richter, C., Tanaka, T., Koseki, T. and Yada, R.Y. (1999). Porcine pepsinogen folding and activation. Eur. J. Biochem. 261,746-752. Rickert, W. (1971). The degradation of the B-chain of oxidized insulin by Mucor miehei protease. C. R. Travaux Lab. Carlsberg 34, 326-345. Rogelj, I., Perko, B., Francky, A., Penca, V. and Pungercar, J. (2001). Recombinant lamb chymosin as an alternative coagulating enzyme in cheese production. J. Dairy Sci. 84, 1020-1026. Runeberg-Roos, P., TOrmakangas, K. and Ostman, A. (1991). Primary structure of a barley-grain aspartic proteinase: a plant aspartic proteinase resembling mammalian cathepsin D. Eur. J. Biochem. 202, 1021-1027. Sali, A., Veerapandian, B., Cooper, J.B., Moss, D.S., Hofmann, T. and Blundell, T.L. (1992). Domain flexibility in aspartic proteinase. Proteins: Struct. Funct. Genet. 12, 158-170. Sanger, E and Tuppy, H. (1981). The amino-acid sequence in the phenylalanyl chain of insulin: II The investigation of peptides from enzymatic hydrolysate. Biochem. J. 49, 481-490. Sardinas, J.L. (1968). Rennin enzymes of Endothia parasitica. Appl. Microbiol. 16,248-253. Shammet, K.M., Brown, R.J. and McMahon, D.J. (1992). Proteolytic activity of some milk-clotting enzymes on K-casein. J. Dairy Sci. 75, 1373-1379. Shamsuzzaman, K. and Haard, N.E (1984). Purification and characterization of a chymosin-like protease from the gastric mucosa of the harp seal (Pagphilusgroen landicus). Can. J. Biochem. Cell Biol. 62,699-708. Shoemaker, J.M., Brasnett, A.H. and Marston, EA.O. (1985). Examination of calf prochymosin accumulation in
43
Escherichia coli: disulphide linkages are a structural component of prochymosin-containing inclusion bodies. EMBOJ. 4,775-780. Sielecki, A.R., Hayakawa, K., Fujinaga, M., Murphy, M.E.P, Fraser, M., Muir, A.K., Carilli, C.T., Lewicki, J.A., Baxter, J.D. and James, M.N.G. (1989). Structure of recombinant human renin, a target for cardiovascular-active drugs, at 2.5 A resolution. Science 243, 1346-1351. Sielecki, A.R., Fedorov, A.A., Boodhoo, A., Andreeva, N.S. and James, M.N.G. (1990). The molecular and crystal structures of monoclinic porcine pepsin refined at 1.8 A resolution. J. Mol. Biol. 2 I4, 143-170. Sielecki, A.R., Fujinaga, M., Read, R.J. and James, M.N.G. (1991). Refined structure of porcine pepsinogen at 1.8 A resolution. J. Mol. Biol. 219, 671-692. Simons, G., Rutten, G., Hornes, M., Nijhuis, M. and van Asseldonk, M. (1991). Production of prochymosin in lactococci, in, Structure and Function of Aspartic Proteinases, Dunn, B.M., ed., Plenum Press, New York. pp. 115-119. Smith, R.A., Duncan, M.J. and Molt, D.T. (1985). Heterologous protein secretion from yeast. Science 229, 1219-1224. Smith, J.L., Bayliss, FT. and Ward, M. (1991a). Sequence of the cloned pyr4 gene of Trichoderma reesei and its use as a homologous selective maker for transformation. Curr. Genet. 19, 27-33. Smith, J.L., Billings, G.E. and Yada, R.Y. (1991b). Chemical modification of amino groups in Mucor miehei aspartic proteinases, porcine pepsin, and chymosin. I. Structure and function. Agric. Biol. Chem. 55, 2009-2016. Smith, J.L., Billings, G.E. and Yada, R.Y. (199 lc). Chemical modification of amino groups in Mucor miehei aspartic proteinases, porcine pepsin, and chymosin. II. Conformation stability. Agric. Biol. Chem. 55, 2017-2024. Sogawa, K., Fujii-Kuriayma, Y., Mizukami, Y., Ichihara, Y. and Takahashi, K. (1983). Primary structure of human pepsinogen gene. J. Biol. Chem. 258, 5306-5315. Stepanov, V.M., Lavrenova, G.I., Terent'eva, E.Y. and Khodova, O.M. (1990). Prochymosin activation by non-aspartic proteinases. FEBS Lett. 260, 173-175. Sternberg, M.Z. (1971). Crystalline milk-clotting protease from Mucor miehei and some of its properties. J. Dairy Sci. 54, 159-167. Strop, P, Sedlacek, J., Stys, J., Kaderabkova, Z., Blaha, I., Pavlickova, L., Pohl, J., Fabry, M., Kostka, V., Newman, M., Frazao, C., Shearer, A., Tickle, I.J. and Blundell, T.L. (1990). Engineering enzyme subsite specificity: preparation, kinetic characterization, and X-ray analysis at 2.0-/~ resolution of Va1111Phe site-mutated calf chymosin. Biochemistry 29, 9863-9871. Sugrue, R., Marston, EA.O., Lowe, PA. and Freedman, R.B. (1990). Denaturation studies on natural and recombinant bovine prochymosin (prorennin). Biochem. J. 27I, 541-547. Suguna, K., Bott, R.R., Padlan, E.A., Subramanian, E., Sheriff, S., Cohen, G.H. and Davies, D.R. (1987). Structure and refinement at 1.8 A resolution of the aspartic proteinase from Rhizopus chinensis. J. Mol. Biol. 196, 877-900. Suzuki, J., Hamu, A., Nishiyama, M., Hironouchi, S. and Beppu, T. (1990). Site-directed mutagenesis reveals func-
44
Rennets: General and Molecular Aspects
tional contribution of Thr218, Lys220 and Asp304 in chymosin. Protein Eng. 4, 69-71. Takahashi, K. (1995). Proteinase A from Aspergillus niger. Meth. Enzymol. 248, 146-155. Tanaka, T. and Yada, R.Y. (1996). Expression of soluble cloned porcine pepsinogen A in Escherichia coli. Biochem. J. 315, 443-446. Tanaka, T. and Yada, R.Y. (2001). N-Terminal portion acts as an initiator of the inactivation of pepsin at neutral pH. Protein Eng. 14, 669-674. Tang, J., Sepulveda, P., Marciniszyn, J., Chen, K.C.S., Huang, W.-Y., Tao, N., Liu, D. and Lanier, J.P. (1973). Amino acid sequence of porcine pepsin. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 70, 3437-3439. Tang, J., James, M.N.G., Hsu, I.N., Jenkins, J.A. and Blundell, T.L. (1978). Structural evidence for gene duplication in the evolution of the acid proteases. Nature 271, 618-621. Tang, J., Lin, L., Co, E., Hartsuck, J.A. and Lin, X. (1992). Understanding HIV-proteinase: Can it be translated into effective therapy against AIDS? Scand. J. Clin. Lab. Invest. 52 ($210), 127-135. Tichy, P.J., Kapr~ilek, E and Jecmen, P. (1993). Improved procedure for a high-yield recovery of enzymatically active recombinant calf chymosin from Escherichia coli inclusion bodies. Protein Expr. Purific. 4, 59-63. Togni, G., Sanglard, D., Falchetto, R. and Monod, M. (1991). Isolation and nucleotide sequence of the extracellular acid protease gene (ACP) from the yeast Candida tropicalis. FEBS Lett. 286, 181-185. Toh, H., Ono, M., Saigo, K. and Miyata, T. (1985). Retroviral protease-like sequence in yeast transposon Tyl. Nature 315,691. Tonouchi, N., Shoun, H., Uozumi, T. and Beppu, T. (1986). Cloning and sequencing of the gene for mucor rennin, an aspartate protease for Mucor pusillus. Nucl. Acids Res. 14, 7557-7568. Tropea, J.E., Nashed, N.T., Louis, J.M., Sayer, J.M. and Jerina, D.M. (1992). Effect of salt on the kinetic parameters of retroviral and mammalian aspartic proteases. Bioorg. Chem. 20, 67-76. Turk, V., Lah, T., Puizdar, V., Babnik, J., Kotnik, M. and Kregar, I. (1985). Cathepsins D and E: molecular characteristics and mechanism of activation, in, Aspartic Proteinases and Their Inhibitors, Kostka, V., ed., Walter de Gruyter and Co., Berlin. pp. 283-297. Uchiyama, H., Uozumi, T., Beppu, T. and Arima, K. (1980). Purification of prorennin mRNA and its translation in vitro. Agric. Biol. Chem. 44, 1373-1381. Umezawa, H., Aoyagi, T., Morishima, H., Matsuzaki, M., Hamada, M. and Takeuchi, T. (1970). Pepstatin, a new peptide inhibitor produced by actinomycetes. J. Antibiotics 23,259-262. van den Berg, J.A., van der Laken, K.J., van Ooyen, A.J.J., Renniers, T.C.H.M., Rietveld, K., Schaap, A., Brake, A.J., Bishop, R.J., Schultz, K., Moyer, D., Richman, M. and Schuster, J.R. (1990). Kluyveromyces as a host for heterologous gene expression: expression and secretion of prochymosin. Bio/Technology 8, 135-139.
van Hooydonk, A.C.M., Olieman, C. and Hagedoorn, H.G. (1984). Kinetics of the chymosin-catalysed proteolysis of K-casein in milk. Neth. Milk Dairy J. 38, 207-222. Veerapandian, B., Cooper, J.B., Sali, A. and Blundell, T.L. (1990). X-ray analyses of aspartic proteinases. III. Threedimensional structure of endothiapepsin complexed with a transition-state isostere inhibitor of renin at 1.6 A resolution. J. Mol. Biol. 216, 1017-1029. Visser, S., van Rooijen, P.J., Schattenkerk, C. and Herling, K.E.T. (1976). Peptide substrates for chymosin (rennin): kinetic studies with peptides of different chain length including parts of the sequence 101-112 of bovine K-casein. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 438, 265-272. Visser, S., van Rooijen, P.J. and Slangen, C.J. (1980). Peptide substrates for chymosin (rennin): isolation and substrate behaviour of two tryptic fragments of bovine K-casein. Eur. ]. Biochem. 108,415-421. Visser, S., Slangen, C.J., and van Rooijen, P.J. (1987). Peptide substrates for chymosin (rennin): interaction sites in K-casein related sequences located outside the (103-108) haxapeptide region that fits into the enzyme's active site cleft. Biochem. J. 244,553-558. Visser, S., Vanalebeek, G.J., Rollema, H.S. and Friedenthal, M.K. (1988). Spectrophotometric method for the determination of chymosin and pepsin in calf and adult bovine rennets. Neth. Milk Dairy J. 42,221-232. Ward, M. (1989). Production of calf chymosin by Aspergillus awamori, in, Genetics and Molecular Biology of Industrial Microorganisms, Hershberger, C.L., Queener, S.W. and Hegeman, G., eds, American Society for Microbiology, Washington. pp. 288-294. Ward, M. and Kodama, K.H. (1991). Introduction to fungal proteinases and expression in fungal systems, in, Structure and Function of the Aspartic Proteinases, Dunn, B.M., ed., Plenum Press, New York. pp. 149-159. Ward, M., Wilson, L.J., Komada, K.H., Rey, M.W. and Berka, R.M. (1990). Improved production of chymosin in Aspergillus by expression as a glucoamylase-chymosin fusion. Bio/Technology 8,435-440. William, D.C., Whitaker, J.R. and Caldwell, P.V. (1972). Hydrolysis of peptides bonds of the oxidized B-chain of insulin by Endothia parasitica protease. Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 149, 52-61. Wlodawer, A., Miller, M., Jaskolski, M., Sathyanarayana, B.K., Baldwin, E., Weber, I.T., Selk, L.M., Clawson, L., Schneider, J. and Kent, S.B.H. (1989). Conserved folding in retroviral proteases: crystal structure of a synthetic HIV-I protease. Science 245,616-621. Wong, R.N.S. and Tang, J. (1986). Cloning and sequence: analysis of cDNA for human progastricsin. Federation Proc. 45, 105. Yada, R.Y. and Nakai, S. (1986). Use of principal component analysis to study the relationship between physical/chemical properties and milk-clotting to proteolytic activity ratio of some aspartyl proteinases. J. Agric. Food Chem. 34, 675-679. Yamada, T. and Ogrydziak, D.M. (1983). Extracellular acid proteases produced by Saccharomycopsis lipolytica. J. Bacteriol. 154, 23-31.
Rennets: General and Molecular Aspects
Yamauchi, T., Nagahama, M., Hori, H. and Murakami, K. (1988). Functional characterization of Asp-137 mutant of human renin expressed in COS cells. FEBS Lett. 230, 205-208. Ye, X.Y., Yoshida, S. and Ng, T.B. (2000). Isolation of lactoperoxidase, lactoferrin, alpha-lactalbumin, beta-lactalbumin B and beta-lactoglobulin A from bovine rennet whey using ion exchange chromatography. Int. J. Biochem. Cell Biol. 32, 1143-1150.
45
Yonezawa, M., Suzuki, J., Nishiyama, M., Horinouchi, S. and Beppu, T. (1993). Role of the amino-terminal amino acid sequences determinating the in vitro refolding process of prochymosin polypeptide. J. Biotechnol. 28, 85-97. Yu, J., Iwasaki, S., Tamura, G. and Arima, K. (1968). Physical properties and amino acid composition of mucorrennin crystal isolated from Mucor pusillus var. Lindt. Agric. Biol. Chem. 32,1051.
Rennet-induced Coagulation of Milk D.S. Horne and J.M. Banks, Charis Food Research, Hannah Research Institute, Ayr KA6 5HL, Scotland
Introduction
The first stage of cheese manufacture is the conversion of liquid milk to cheese curd. Traditionally, this was achieved by the addition of rennet to coagulate the milk and by the subsequent expulsion of the whey by syneresis. In this chapter, we will be concerned with the first of these steps, the enzyme-induced coagulation. Later chapters will review syneresis and curd-handling procedures. We will consider the basic chemistry and physics underlying aggregation and gel formation, and the technological factors (milk composition, processing) that influence the coagulation process. In doing so, we will be covering ground treated in two separate consecutive chapters on enzymatic coagulation of milk (Dalgleish, 1993) and on post-coagulation phenomena (Green and Grandison, 1993) in the earlier editions, but updating and broadening those reviews. Attention is also drawn to more recent work by Lomhoh and Qvist (1999). Milk can also be clotted by acidification or a combination of significant acidification and minor enzymic action. These aspects form the subject of 'Formation, Structural Properties and Rheology of Acid-coagulated Milk Gels', Volume 1. After the addition of chymosin or other milk-clotting enzyme to the milk, nothing apparently happens for some time until the milk coagulates rapidly. During this lag phase, the enzyme hydrolyses the K-casein which stabilizes the casein micelles. When sufficient destabilization has been brought about, an aggregation reaction is set in train and this eventually leads to a three-dimensional, space-filling gel, the cheese curd. Previously, this overall coagulation reaction has been envisaged as occurring in three stages. The enzymatic proteolysis forms the first or primary phase, and leads to the activation of the aggregating species. In the secondary phase, which overlaps the first, since the milk may begin to clot before the enzymatic cleavage of K-casein is complete (Green et al., 1978; Dalgleish, 1979; Chaplin and Green, 1980), the destabilized micelles begin to aggregate and most of the previous discussions stop with this stage (Dalgleish, 1992, 1993; Hyslop, 2003). Those authors recognize the possibility of a third stage but consider this to involve changes largely in the curd structure once it has formed. Just as the first and the second stage overlap, it will be our c o n -
tention that so too does the aggregation phase overlap the development of curd structure and properties. Indeed conceptually, together they comprise the gelation process. We therefore view this partitioning of second and third stages as wholly (or largely?) artificial and aim to treat the formation of the coagulum, at least to the cutting stage, in a single mechanistic framework. The drastic changes, post-cutting, take the curd into a completely different environment, and their treatment is beyond the remit of this chapter.
Milk P r o p e r t i e s
Cheesemaking capitalizes on the curdling of milk. To understand the coagulation reaction, we must look more closely at the individual components of milk to discern their role, particularly the fat, the protein and the minerals. Fat
Fat exists in natural milk as small globules surrounded by membrane proteins and in a size range dependent on breed, lactational status and diet of the cow. The fat in milk helps to produce flavour, aroma and body in mature cheese. Unless the milk is homogenized, the fat globules are physically trapped in the protein network created in gel formation. Hence, their size and the network mesh size interact in determining the overall yield of cheese. Otherwise, the fat globules play the part of an inert filler in influencing curd rheological properties but no active role in gel formation. Homogenization of the milk, which creates many more smaller fat droplets, stabilizes these droplets by utilization of adsorbed whey and casein proteins. Where these are caseins, they can be involved in gel formation and influence its development. These aspects are considered in later sections. Protein
Two types of protein are found in milk: the globular whey proteins, which are soluble in the serum phase, and the caseins which exist in a stable colloidal suspension of aggregates known as casein micelles. Cheesemaking exploits the destabilizing mechanisms nature
Cheese: Chemistry, Physics and Microbiology, Third edition- Volume 1: General Aspects ISBN: 0-1226-3652-X Set ISBN: 0-1226-3651-1
Copyright 9 2004 Elsevier Ltd All rights reserved
48
Rennet-induced Coagulation of Milk
has built into this colloidal system by using the natural enzyme, chymosin, originally extracted from the stomach of the calf but nowadays available in cloned form, to hydrolyse the K-casein and induce the destabilization of the casein micelle system to form a gel. The properties of the caseins and their micellar form play a major role in defining that reaction and its final outcome. Casein chemistry
The caseins are a family of phosphoproteins. In bovine milk, the family consists of four distinct gene products, designated OLsl-, OLsz-, [3- and K-caseins. Together, they constitute around 80% of bovine milk protein and are found in the approximate proportions 4:1:4:1, respectively (Davies and Law, 1980; Walstra and Van Vliet, 1986). Two post-translational modifications of the proteins, newly synthesized in the mammary gland, have a major impact on the physico-chemical, functional and assembly properties of the proteins. These reactions are glycosylation and phosphorylation. In bovine casein, only K-casein is found glycosylated with several threonine, and occasionally serine, residues in the hydrophilic C-terminal end of the K-casein molecule carrying relatively short sugar chains (Zevaco and Ribadeau-Dumas, 1984; Vreeman etal., 1986). Glycosylation is not complete, however, and the nonglycosylated form is still the major component (Vreeman et al., 1986). These oligosaccharide chains increase the negative charge (through inclusion of sialic acid), the hydrodynamic bulk and the hydrophilic character of the C-terminal end of the K-casein molecule. The second post-translational reaction is phosphorylation. All the caseins are phosphorylated at serine, or rarely threonine, residues to varying extents. The phosphorylation reaction requires a particular sequence template, mSer--X--A, where X is any amino acid and A is Glu, SerP or, rarely, Asp (Mercier, 1981). The pattern of serine residues along the amino acid sequences of Ors1-, C~sz-and [3-caseins ensures that most of the phosphorylated residues are found in clusters in these molecules, one in [3-casein, two in OLsl-casein and three in oLsz-casein (Swaisgood, 1992). K-Casein is unique amongst the caseins in the absence of phosphoseryl clusters along its sequence. Most K-casein molecules contain only one phosphoseryl residue but some evidence indicates a minor amount of doubly phosphorylated proteins but still only as singlets (Vreeman et al., 1977). Bovine caseins are almost always fully phosphorylated to the level of their potential. At most only one of the template serines is found without its expected phosphate residue in Ors1- and [3-caseins. Most gaps are found with O~sz-casein where the variability ranges from 10 to 13 moles P per mole protein (Whitney, 1988).
The influence of the varying degrees of phosphorylation of the caseins is mirrored in the sensitivity of these molecules to calcium-induced precipitation. Thus, Otsz-casein is the most calcium sensitive, precipitating at Ca 2+ concentrations less than 2 mM (Aoki et al., 1985), while OLsl-casein precipitates in the range 3-8 mM (Parker and Dalgleish, 1981; Aoki et al., 1985; Farrell et al., 1988) and [3-casein precipitates in the range 8-15 mM Ca 2+ at 37 ~ but remains in solution at 1 ~ (Parker and Dalgleish, 1981; Farrell etal., 1988). K-Casein remains soluble at all these calcium concentrations and prevents the precipitation reaction when present with the other casein types, producing instead a colloidal suspension. Casein structures
Controversy still exists over the level of secondary structure present in the caseins. Previously, much of this was designated to the random coil in line with the open, highly hydrated state presented by the molecules in solution. Because of this, the caseins have been described as rheomorphic proteins, indicating that their conformational structure is dictated by, and is responsive to, the molecular environment (Holt and Sawyer, 1993). Views have shifted, however, and current opinion suggests that parts of [3- and K-caseins might adopt the polyproline II-helix structural motif (Farrell et al., 2001; Syme et al., 2002). From the point of view of their self-association and micellar assembly, the amphiphilicity of the caseins may play a more crucial role than recognizable secondary structural elements (Horne, 2002). The clustering of the phosphoseryl residues has already been mentioned, and these groupings are further flanked by polar and charged residues making these regions very hydrophilic. Other regions of the casein molecules have a high concentration of hydrophobic residues, conferring on the molecules an almost block copolymerlike structure. Thus, the N-terminal peptide of [3-casein with the phosphoseryl cluster is very hydrophilic and the C-terminal is very hydrophobic. The behaviour of this protein on adsorption at a hydrophobic interface reflects this segregation, with the hydrophobic C-terminus adsorbing strongly and the hydrophilic N-terminal sticking out into solution (Horne and Leaver, 1995). Ample experimental evidence from dynamic light scattering, neutron reflectivity, enzyme proteolysis and surface force measurements confirm this view (Horne and Leaver, 1995). Further support comes from selfconsistent field calculations to determine the segment density function of a polymer model of [~-casein, normal to the adsorbing surface (Dickinson et al., 1997a,b). Similar calculations carried out on C~sl-casein suggest that it can be sub-divided into three blocks, a hydrophobic
Rennet-induced Coagulation of Milk
N-terminal region, a hydrophilic central loop, containing the phosphoseryl clusters which extends out into the aqueous phase on adsorption of the molecule to a hydrophobic surface, and a hydrophobic C-terminal peptide (Dickinson et al., 1997a). Calculations suggest that these hydrophobic regions are entrained close to the adsorbing surface. Such block structures reflect the general distribution of hydrophilic and hydrophobic residues along these casein protein sequences. By analogy, a block polymer structure can be drawn for %2casein, depicting it as having four blocks. Moving from the N- to the C-terminus, these are a hydrophilic N-terminal tail with a phosphoseryl cluster, a hydrophobic train, a hydrophilic loop, containing further clusters of phosphoseryl residues, and finally a second hydrophobic train at its C-terminus. K-Casein is seen to be a mirror image of [3-casein, with a hydrophilic C-terminus, the caseinomacropeptide cleaved off by chymosin, and a hydrophobic N-terminal block preceding the Phel05--Metl06 bond. Importantly, however, the macropeptide has no phosphoseryl cluster. Casein self-assembly Individual caseins in solution exhibit strong tendencies to self-associate, and the shape and topography of the structure adopted reflects the distributions of hydrophobic/hydrophilic residues just described. Thus, [~-casein, which resembles a detergent molecule with a hydrophilic head and a hydrophobic tail, forms detergent-like micelles with the tails forming a central core and the hydrophilic heads sticking out into the aqueous solution like the bristles on a hedgehog (Payens et al., 1969). In like fashion, OLsl-casein selfassociates in solution to form a worm-like chain polymer with the hydrophobic ends of one molecule interacting with those of different molecules (Schmidt, 1970). K-Casein also self-associates in solution, interacting via its hydrophobic C-terminal, exhibiting a monomer ~ micelle equilibrium but, here, polymer growth is also influenced by the intermolecular disulphide linkages produced by reaction of its cysteine residues (Vreeman et al., 1977; Vreeman, 1979). For Otsl- and [~-caseins, it has been demonstrated that the size of the otsl-casein polymer or the [~-casein micelle produced by self-association is dependent on pH and ionic strength, and also sensitively on temperature in the case of [3-casein. Temperature is important for the strength of hydrophobic attraction, but pH and ionic strength govern electrostatic repulsion and its range. The balance of these attractive and repulsive components in the overall interaction free-energy equation thus controls the aggregate size and, more importantly in a local situation, the strength of individual intermolecular bonds.
49
Casein micelle assembly From these concepts, Horne (1998) devised a polymerization scheme for the assembly of casein micelles. Cross-linking of the molecules is envisaged as proceeding via two routes, hydrophobic interactions between groups on different molecules forming one pathway, with more than two molecules possibly joining at such junctions, and a second pathway where chain extension is through calcium phosphate nanoclusters, small calcium phosphate crystallites, the precipitation of which is regulated by the presence of the caseins. A calcium phosphate nanocluster acts as a neutralizing bridge between two phosphoseryl clusters on different molecules of ~Xsl-, OLs2- or [3-casein. Again, more than two casein molecules could be involved with any one calcium phosphate nanocluster. If the casein molecule is [3-casein, further extension of this chain is through a hydrophobic linkage. Both routes permit branching and hence lead to a three-dimensional network structure. K-Casein can link only to a hydrophobic region on another molecule. Because it has no phosphoseryl cluster on the opposite end of the molecule to permit further extension, the polymer chain ends there. No further growth occurs beyond this point. This occurs for each growing chain and hence the proportion of K-casein limits the micelle size. In consequence, the micelle acquires an external coat of K-casein which acts as a steric stabilizer for the micelle. In devising this mechanism for micellar assembly, no new features are ascribed to the casein molecules. The ability to bond and the strength of those bonds is the resultant of a localized favourable balance of attractive hydrophobic interaction and electrostatic repulsion. Reducing that hydrophobic interaction by lowering the temperature, or increasing electrostatic repulsion by dissolving out calcium phosphate but maintaining pH, weakens those bonds and causes (partial) disintegration of the micelle. Casein micelle properties Almost all the casein proteins present in bovine milk are incorporated into the casein micelles, together with a high proportion of the available calcium and inorganic phosphate. These micelles have an average molecular weight of - 1 0 8 Da and a mean diameter of ---100 nm (range 50-600 nm). The micelles are very open, highly hydrated structures with typical hydration values of 2-4 g H20 g-1 protein, depending on the method of measurement. The structure is not rigidly fixed but dynamic. Cooling the milk from the 37 ~ of the udder to storage at refrigeration temperatures brings about solubilization of a significant fraction of [3-casein, some K-casein and much lower levels of %1- and Ots2-caseins from the micelles, and all
50
Rennet-induced Coagulation of Milk
of this is pH-dependent also (Dalgleish and Law, 1988). Raising the temperature back to 37 ~ reverses this process. Almost complete disintegration of the micelles can be achieved either through the addition of a strong calcium sequestrant such as EDTA (Griffin et al., 1988) or through the addition of high concentrations of urea (McGann and Fox, 1974). Dissociation to molecular level is not achieved, and the dissociated species have average diameters of the order of 10-15 nm and are also of variable composition (Aoki et al., 1985). All of these experimentally observed properties, temperature- or reagent-dependent dissociation, variable composition with size, location of K-casein, inverse relationship of micellar size and K-casein content are predicted or are manifest as a consequence of the dualbinding assembly model described above. As far as the mechanism of chymosin-induced aggregation of casein micelles is concerned, the proposed theories largely neglect internal micellar structure or at least regard it as of no consequence to the outcome of the reaction. Whilst we do not deviate from this view, as described below, we feel that internal micellar structure and the modifications to it as a consequence of pH, salt and temperature changes occurring during curd manufacture should also be considered and that these must impact on curd properties.
Micelle stability The casein micelle system is an excellent example of colloidal dispersion. Repulsive forces hold the micelles in suspension until removed by some external influence. Because the casein micelles were negatively charged, resulting in a zeta potential of about - 2 0 mV, and this charge is reduced by ---50% on rennet treatment (Green and Crutchfield, 1971; Pearse, 1976; Darling and Dickson, 1979; Dalgleish, 1984), attempts were made to explain the stability of the casein micelle using the DLVO (Derjaguin-Lamdau-Verwey-Overbeek) theory of the stability of lyophobic colloids (Verwey and Overbeek, 1948). Such concepts envisage stability as arising from the presence of a repulsive energy barrier, the resultant of ubiquitous attractive Van der Waals forces and repulsive electrostatic forces. Unfortunately, as Payens (1979) calculated, this energy barrier is located at such a short inter-surface distance ('--0.1 nm) as to be physically meaningless, lying well within the orbit of surface roughness, the loops and the tails of the protein molecules in the outer micellar regions. Though the complete DLVO theory is rendered inapplicable by the above and other failures related to ionic strength changes, the general concept of micellar stability being due to the presence of a repulsive energy barrier is still valid. It is now accepted that micellar stability arises from the presence of a sterically stabilizing
outer layer of K-casein molecules, the C-terminal portion of which extends out into the solution (Holt, 1975; Walstra, 1979; Holt and Horne, 1996). Repulsion arises due to the increase in free energy brought about when the protein layer of one micelle is brought into contact with (or overlaps) the layer of another micelle. The role of chymosin is to proteolyze K-casein, splitting it at the Phel05mMetl06 bond and thus shave off the hairy layer, so that the subsequently exposed micelle cores begin to aggregate, once sufficient of their K-casein has been hydrolysed. The overall milk clotting process is shown diagrammatically in Fig. 1. Of these stages, only the proteolytic cleavage can be monitored totally independently of the others by following the release of the glycomacropeptide, K-CNf 106-169, or the formation of para-K-casein, residues 1-105. The aggregation reaction of the destabilized micelles is a consequence of this proteolysis. Its rate cannot be separated easily from that of the proteolysis reaction. The aggregation overlaps the proteolysis reaction; the latter is certainly not complete before the aggregation begins. Aggregation leads to bigger and bigger clusters until eventually the system acquires the solid-like nature of the gel. Again, there is a smooth continuum through this point and beyond as the gel matures. As we discuss in greater detail later, the separation into aggregation and gelation stages is largely artificial, driven in most instances by the requirements of the experimental technique or the mechanistic model.
Primary Enzymatic Phase The K-casein molecules provide a steric stabilizing layer with their hydrophilic C-terminal peptides protruding into the aqueous phase. Gel formation is initiated by the proteolysis of the K-casein molecules which is accompanied by the release of a hydrophilic peptide, termed the caseinomacropeptide, into the serum (whey) phase. The remaining N-terminal region of the K-casein, termed the para-K-casein remains bound in the casein network. Gradual loss of the caseinomacropeptide is accompanied by a decrease in the micellar zeta potential which results in destabilization of the micelles and aggregation into a gel. Proteases capable of initiating the required proteolysis of K-casein are aspartic proteinases (EC 3.4.23). Milk clotting enzymes were obtained originally by extraction from the stomachs of ruminants, and calf and adult bovine rennets are widely used in cheese manufacture today. Concerns in the 1960s that world cheese production had increased to such an extent that the production of rennet products derived from
Rennet-induced Coagulation of Milk
51
A) Micelles (O) + enzyme (,)
'0' 0 , , 0 . ,00 0 0 , / , , 0 w'O, 0,0"o
0
0
(B) Partially renneted micelles
(C) Aggregating micelles in small clusters
~d)& co oo o~,8 ~
~
c~'co
0 o
c~~ ~ @0
co @ CK) (D) Percolating clusters
co 0
0
0
(~
)O O0 C~
Figure 1 A schematic description of the various stages envisaged in the enzymatic coagulation of milk, starting from the initial mixture of casein micelles and enzyme (A) and proceeding through proteolysis (B), initial aggregation into small clusters (C) and reaching a gel point at percolation (D).
animal tissue would be insufficient to meet future demand led to the development of alternative products. Rhizomucor miehei, R. pusillus and Cryphonectria parasitica were used to produce aspartic proteinases by fermentation, and these new coagulants were successfully introduced to the market. In the late 1980s, recombinant DNA technology was used to clone the gene for chymosin, the main clotting component of calf rennet. E.coli, Aspergillus niger and Kluveromyces
lactis were used as host organisms (Teuber, 1990; Harboe, 1992). The chymosin products generated are now referred to as fermentation-produced chymosin (FPC). A wide range of clotting agents are now available for cheese manufacture and the use of these coagulants in cheese manufacture has been reviewed extensively (Guinee and Wilkinson, 1992; Wigley, 1996; Fox and McSweeney, 1997; Harboe and Budtz, 1999). Calf rennet and adult bovine rennet still dominate in cheese
52
Rennet-induced Coagulation of Milk
production, but market share for FPC continues to increase, and microbial coagulants derived from R. miehi are the third most commonly used coagulants (Harboe and Budtz, 1999). Chymosin (EC 3.4.23.4) is a gastric proteinase which is secreted in the abomasal mucosa of new-born ruminants and other mammals during the first days of life (Foltmann, 1992). It is the main clotting enzyme in calf rennet. The activity of chymosin differs markedly from that of other gastric aspartic proteinases in that it exhibits low general proteolytic activity but is particularly active in hydrolysis of the Phel05~Metl06 of K-casein. Milk clotting enzymes differ in the rate at which they continue to degrade casein following the hydrolysis to initiate gel formation. Only those enzymes with a high ratio of milk-clotting activity to general proteolytic activity are considered suitable for cheese manufacture. A high level of non-specific proteolysis can lead to a weak gel structure, high losses of protein and fat in the whey and reduced cheese yield. The higher the level of proteolysis, the greater is the reduction in cheese yield. Chymosin activity on K-casein is limited with only formation of the caseinomacrpeptide and para-K-casein, while in the case of fungal proteinases, extensive non-specific hydrolysis of both K-casein and para-K-casein occurs (Shammet et al., 1992). The use of microbial rennets is generally considered to result in reduced cheese yield, compared with calf rennet (Olson, 1977; Emmons et al., 1990a; Lucey and Kelly, 1994). The fermentation-produced chymosins have a high ratio of milk clotting to general proteolytic activity and no significant differences in cheese yield have been reported between recombinant chymosin and calf rennet (Green et al., 1985; Hicks et al., 1988; Ustinol and Hicks, 1990; Emmons et al., 1990b; Banks, 1992; van den Berg, 1992). The properties of chymosin and other aspartic proteinases have been reviewed comprehensively by Chitpinityol and Crabbe (1998) (see 'Rennets: General and Molecular Aspects', Volume 1). Rennet preparations are generally prepared from multiple calf stomachs and are heterogeneous in their chymosin content. Calf chymosin occurs in three forms, A, B and C, chymosin B being the most abundant in natural rennet. Chymosins A and B are allelic variants which differ at only one amino acid position; Asp243 in chymosin A is replaced by Gly243 in chymosin B. Chymosin C appears to be a degradation product of chymosin A which lacks three residues, Asp244-Phe246 (Danley and Geoghegan, 1988). The three variants show differences in clotting activity, and of the three forms, chymosin A has the highest specific clotting activity and chymosin C the lowest. The A and B forms are equally efficient in cheese manufacture (Harboe and Budtz,
1999). The cloned chymosins derived from Aspergillus niger and Kluveromyces lactis are B variants (Harboe and Budtz, 1999). The specificity of chymosin for the PhemMet bond has been studied extensively (see Fox and McSweeney, 1997). The length of the peptide and the sequence around the sectile bond are important determinants of enzyme-substrate interactions. Observations that synthetic di-, tri- or tetra-peptides containing a Phe--Met bond were not susceptible to hydrolysis by chymosin suggested that other residues close to the cleaved bond are also required for the hydrolytic reaction (Visser et al., 1980). Kinetic studies on synthetic peptides indicated that two additional residues at either side of the hydrolysable bond are required for appreciable reaction (Hill, 1968, 1969; Raymond et al., 1972). The sequence of His98--Lys111 includes all the necessary determinants (Visser et al., 1980), and this tetradecapeptide is hydrolysed with a kcat/Km of ca 2M -1 s - 1 which is similar to that of intact K-casein (see Fox and McSweeney, 1997). The Phe and Met residues in the chymosin-sensitive bond of K-caseins are not essential for chymosin action on caseins. The residues in the chymosin-sensitive bond differ across species which suggests that it is the amino acid sequence surrounding this bond rather than the residues in the bond itself, which contain the important determinants of hydrolysis (see Fox and McSweeney, 1997). Porcine pepsin (A and C) and R. miehei proteinase cleave the PhemMet bond in a similar fashion to chymosin but the C. parasitica proteinase cleaves the Serl04--Phe]05 bond (Dronse and Foltmann, 1989). Calf rennet is the standard product against which all other coagulants are assessed. Adult bovine rennet contains a higher proportion of pepsin and therefore a more general proteolytic activity. Rennets extracted from ovine, caprine and porcine stomachs are the most efficient at clotting milk of their own species (Foltmann,
1992). Coagulants extracted from the flowers of the thistle Cynara cardunculus are used in the production of artisanal cheeses in the Iberian peninsula (Sousa et al., 2001). The coagulants are aspartic proteinases and comprise of two enzymes, cardosins A and B. Both enzymes hydrolyse the Phel05--Metl06 bond of K-casein (Esteves et al., 1995). Kinetic parameters of cardosin A are similar to those of chymosin while those for cardosin B are similar to pepsin (Verissimo et al., 1995). The ratio of clotting to proteolytic activity is low compared to chymosin, and non-specific casein hydrolysis results in lower gel firmness compared to that obtained with chymosin (Esteves et al., 2002).
Rennet-induced Coagulation of Milk
Measurement of Clotting Time and Curd-Cutting Time The most easily detected outcome of chymosin proteolysis and rennet clotting is the visible observation of the presence of flocs in a milk sample in a rotating tube. The time taken for their appearance is defined as the rennet coagulation time, and for the cheesemaker interested in the activity of an enzyme preparation, this may be the only quantity of interest. The importance of its determination is reflected in the number of techniques tested over the years (see Lucey, 2002; O'Callaghan et al., 2002, for reviews of these methods). Since the coagulum is cut sometime after the coagulation point when it has attained sufficient firmness, the more technically successful techniques are those which continuously monitor the development of the coagulum with time by measuring changes in some particular physical attribute, such as viscosity (Scott Blair and Oosthuizen, 1961), reflectivity (Hardy and Fanni, 1981; Ustinol et al., 1991), thermal conductivity (Hori, 1985) or ultrasound transmission (Benguigui et al., 1994) to name only a few. Few of these techniques have entered commercial practice for in-vat applications not only because the instruments are often difficult to clean and maintain properly but also because the changing processing conditions and schedules in response to such instrumental readings are not always an attractive option to a large modern cheese factory. In such cases, the standardization of milk protein is the preferred approach, since this minimizes differences in coagulation and it has been observed that cheese yield does not seem to be very sensitive to small changes in gel firmness, at cutting, in such standardized circumstances. Many of the techniques described by Lucey (2002) and O'Callaghan et al. (2002) have also been developed from research tools used to study the influence of reaction variables such as temperature, pH and milk composition and pre-treatment on gel development. The most useful of these techniques are those where the behaviour of the variable of interest can be predicted by a mathematical model based on a mechanistic description of the reaction. Few, if any, techniques provide direct relationships applicable over the entire course of the reaction from micelle to gel. Indeed, this is perhaps one reason why gel formation has been split into primary and secondary phases, since the early aggregation phase can be followed readily by turbidity or light scattering (Payens et al., 1977; Dalgleish et al., 1981a,b; Dalgleish, 1983; Bauer et al., 1995; Lomhoh et al., 1998) whereas the gel formation and development is most easily monitored in the laboratory by rheometry (Tokita et al., 1982; Bohlin et al., 1984; Van Hooydonk
53
and Walstra, 1987; Zoon et al., 1988a,b,c, 1989a,b; Van Vliet et al., 1991; Home, 1995, 1996; Lopez et al., 1998; Mellema et al., 2002). Each technique suffers from limitations. Light scattering requires a dilute dispersion of particles so that only singly scattered photons are collected at the detector. Direct conversion to molecular weight and/or size is also limited by the ratio of particle size to light wavelength. Studies using light scattering are thus limited to early stages of aggregation, where growth of molecular weight or degree of polymerization is obtained as a function of reaction time. Rheological measurements suffer from the opposite failing. There, the limitation is instrument-sensitivity and a detectable signal is realized only after the reaction has progressed to a significant extent. The relationship between measured viscoelasticity and gel structure and bonding is also highly model-dependent, as we shall see, and interpretations are often controversial.
Kinetic Models of Rennet Coagulation The earliest attempt to describe the kinetics of the clotting process was made in the 1870s by Storch and Segeleke (see Fohmann, 1959, 1971). This simply stated that the clotting time was inversely related to the concentration of rennet used to clot the milk. A further refinement was postulated by Holter (1932) and rearranged by Fohmann (1959) to give the familiar equation:
RCT =
k [El
+ A
(1)
where k and A are constants and [E] is the enzyme concentration, R C T being the rennet coagulation time. This relationship is purely empirical, but it is an important relationship which has to be satisfied by any more descriptive mechanistic model, even if only over a restricted range of enzyme concentration and RCT values. The Holter modification separated the coagulation time into two components, an enzyme proteolysis stage and a secondary coagulation phase. The equation assumes that there is no overlap between the proteolysis and the coagulation phases and that the extent of proteolysis is always the same at RCT (Foltmann, 1971). Experimental evidence suggests that the proteolyzed fraction of K-casein is very high. Dalgleish (1979) suggested 60-80% of the K-casein must be hydrolysed, though his plot shows no significant aggregation below 90% proteolysis. Green et al. (1978) found that aggregation did not start until after about 60-80% of the RCT had passed, by which time the
54
Rennet-induced Coagulation of Milk
enzyme action was almost complete. In a separate experiment, Green et al. (1978) found that the viscosity of milk rose sharply when the enzyme reaction was ---86% complete. Other groups have found that viscosity increases well before the visible coagulation time indicated by the presence of flocs (Guthy and Novak, 1977), confirming an inescapable fact that the detection of an aggregation point is determined by the sensitivity of the measuring technique to the presence of aggregates and also that the two processes, proteolysis and subsequent aggregation, overlap in time. The extent of overlap, or the percentage of K-casein proteolyzed before aggregation becomes detectable, is also dependent on milk pH and ionic calcium content, decreasing as pH is decreased (Van Hooydonk et al., 1986; Carlson et al., 1987a,b) or as Ca 2+ content increased (De Kruif, 1999; Horne and McCreight, unpublished observations). The functional description of the overall kinetics of coagulation must therefore take both proteolysis and aggregation reactions into account. The kinetics of the proteolysis reaction has been discussed by Dalgleish (1993) and Hyslop (2003). In milk, the reaction appears to be of first order, but whether the reaction is truly first order throughout or follows standard Michaelis-Menten kinetics for a single-step enzymecatalysed reaction with a relatively high value for the dissociation constant of the chymosin-K-casein complex, where the Michaelis-Menten equation approximates to a first-order picture, is still undecided (Hyslop, 2003). Many attempts have been made to model the aggregation reaction, the models differing in how the aggregation rate constant is modelled and how it depends on the enzymatic proteolysis of K-casein. Beginning with the model calculations of Payens (1976, 1977, 1989), Payens etal. (1977) Payens and Brinkhuis (1986), and Hyslop (2003) has outlined the nuances of the various schemes, highlighting their differences and critically pointing out their shortcomings. Depending on the assumptions made and the experimental circumstances involved, he concluded that three models, step-function (Dalgleish, 1980a,b), energy barrier (Darling and Van Hooydonk, 1981) and functionality theory (Hyslop, 1993; Hyslop and Qvist, 1996) may be used to describe the aggregation reaction. The step-function model (Dalgleish, 1980a,b) is based on the idea of a critical level of proteolysis before aggregation is possible, but does not explain why this should be necessary. A plausible explanation arises if an energy barrier is gradually reduced by rennet proteolysis, leading to a gradually increasing probability of reaction on collision in the aggregation reaction. Introduced by Darling and Van Hooydonk (1981), the
energy barrier model has been tested extensively (Van Hooydonk and Walstra, 1987; Dalgleish, 1988; Hyslop, 1989; Payens, 1989; Hyslop and Qvist, 1996). Energy barrier models are mean-field models. They imply the existence of a uniform repulsive force that decreases gradually with time, and therefore uniform micellar surfaces. Since the K-casein molecules are hydrolysed individually, a more realistic approach might be the creation of attractive patches on the micelle surface by the removal of sufficient macropeptide hairs, as envisaged in the geometric model of Dalgleish and Holt (1988). Continuing removal of K-casein hairs would lead to multiple patches and the creation of conditions necessary for the operation of a polyfunctional model of the Flory-Stockmayer type (Stockmayer, 1943), which gives the rate constant as: kij = K{4 + 2 ( f - 2) (i + j) + ( f - 2) 2 ij}
(2)
where K = proportionality factor; f = number of functional sites (functionality); i,j = number of particles of type i,j. Iff = 1, only dimers are possible, iff = 2, linear polymers are predicted and if f >2, chain-branching occurs and gelation is possible. In the beginning at t = 0, f = 0, the micelles have no reactivity or inclination to aggregate, and a realistic model has to account for the growth of f during the course of the reaction. This is generally done by proposing that f is some function of the degree of proteolysis of K-casein, most frequently linear. A further refinement in this model is to allow the proportionality factor to depend on the energy barrier height (Bauer et al., 1995). All the various models describe essentially the growth in average molar mass of the micellar aggregate with time of reaction. Average molecular weight is most readily measurable by static light-scattering techniques. Due to problems encountered with multiple light scattering, where the detected photon has encountered more than one scatterer in its passage through the suspension, these techniques are applicable only in highly diluted suspensions (Dalgleish et al., 1981a,b; Brinkhuis and Payens, 1984; Bauer etal., 1995), or over very short path lengths, as in the turbidity measurements of Lomholt et al. (1998). Increasing complexity in the models increases the number of parameters the value of which can be varied to fit experimental data. Possibly their most stringent test so far has been carried out by Lomholt et al. (1998) who considered most variations involving energy barriers. They found that they could obtain good representations of the initial stages of renneting, up to aggregates of---5-10 micelles, with plausible values for the variable parameters, energy barrier height for native casein
Rennet-induced Coagulation of Milk
micelles and after completion of rennet proteolysis. They reproduced the growth of aggregate size with time, adequately accounting for the effect of enzyme concentration and to some extent micellar casein concentration. They were, however, unable to differentiate between the different model expressions, all giving equally acceptable fits, and thus were unable to reliably relate experimental data to any particular mechanistic picture. A major disadvantage of these experiments is that they are concerned only with the initial stages of the coagulation reaction, largely because of constraints relating to the experimental techniques. Early lightscattering studies (Dalgleish et al., 1981a,b; Brinkhuis and Payens, 1984) operated in dilute solution because of this but even in the case of the later work of Lomholt et al. (1998) the effects of multiple scattering by large aggregates produced an upper limit to the size which can be extracted from such data (Worning et al., 1998). Consequently, although they operated in a concentration regime where coagulation eventually occurred, Lomholt et al. (1998) were unable to derive any information on the progress of the reaction in this region.
Adhesive Sphere Models and Viscosity Viscometry was one of the techniques used in early attempts to monitor the course of the rennet coagulation reaction (Scott Blair and Oosthuizen, 1961). The relationship between viscosity and molecular weight is rather complex and the results therefore do not lend themselves to ready testing of the theoretical models outlined above. On addition of chymosin to milk, there is an initial decrease in the viscosity which then passes through a minimum before increasing sharply as the coagulation progresses. Rather than interpreting this rise as due to the formation of aggregates and from them a gelling network, De Kruif and coworkers (De Kruif et al., 1992; De Kruif, 1999) have proposed a different mechanism based on treating casein micelles as sterically stabilized hard spheres which become sticky, or adhesive, as the K-casein is proteolyzed. They write the relative viscosity of skim milk as: f i r = 1 + 2.54}+
5.9 +
1.9 ) T
(4)
B2 = 4
B2
(5)
vHs
s=-hkTln([P]~-[P]~[P])
(3)
(6)
where [P] is the concentration of macropeptide released at time t, and the other parameters are defined in Fig. 2, VHS being the hard sphere volume 4/3 "rra3, where a is the effective micelle radius. The only fitting parameter is h, which is of order 2 (De Kruif, 1999). The initial decrease in the viscosity arises because of the decrease in hydrodynamic volume fraction, 4}, as the K-casein hairs are sheared. This decrease in hydrodynamic size has been measured experimentally using dynamic light scattering techniques in both dilute (Walstra et al., 1981) and concentrated (Home and Davidson, 1993) micellar suspensions. In the adhesive sphere model, however, the loss of the K-casein-stabilizing hairs also causes the attractive well depth to increase in proportion to the logarithm of the normalized hair loss. This stickiness then produces the observed increase in viscosity in this model. At later times, however, the viscosity also increases due to aggregation and network formation. Passage to this status is seamless, and with no indication of its occurrence, making realistic assessment of the validity of the model at least problematical. Nevertheless, on its basis, De Kruif (1999) has demonstrated that the micellar system can be flocculated at higher hair density (lower levels of proteolysis) when ionic calcium level is increased and that renneting time can be shortened by the inclusion of increasing amounts of ethanol. A major disadvantage of the adhesive sphere model is that its time dependence relates only to the proteolysis reaction. Indeed, it is confined purely to
,0, o"
4}2
55
.I
I1
~A4
where 4} is the micellar volume fraction and r a stickiness parameter related through the second virial coefficient (B2) to the depth (s) of an attractive square well potential created as the K-casein hairs are proteolyzed. The relevant equations are:
Fi~lure 2 A schematic defining the terminology of the adhesive spnere model. The micelle of diameter (o-) has a hairy layer of thickness (A) equivalent to the width of the square well potential. The depth of this attractive potential (s) deepens as the hairs are proteolyzed by chymosin.
56
Rennet-induced
Coagulation
of
Milk
pre-aggregation events and can say nothing of the kinetics of aggregation and gel formation, highly significant events in the definition of gel properties.
Thus, when 8>45 ~, the viscous component dominates, whereas when 8<45 ~, the sample appears more like an elastic solid. Ideally, measurements should be made in the linear viscoelastic region, i.e., deformation should be proportional to the applied stress. When the gel is very weak in the earliest stages of reaction, it is debatable whether this situation is achievable. Minimum forces must be applied for the instrument to produce a discernible movement in its geometry, or in the case of a constant strain rheometer, the movement has to be detectable but a minimum force will be required to overcome inertia, friction in bearings, etc. This minimum movement or stress may be sufficient to damage the gel at this point in its development. Fortunately, the rennetinduced gel develops viscoelasticity rapidly and so moves into linear response quickly but, nevertheless, the gel point may vary between instruments or instrument settings, and too large applied stresses or strains should be avoided. Figure 3 shows an example of the development of viscoelasticity in a skim milk sample during renneting. The sharp decrease in the phase angle, from close to the 90 ~ of a Newtonian liquid to around 20 ~ coincides approximately with the visible coagulation time. In the same time frame, gel firmness as indicated by the growth of shear moduli, becomes apparent. Although not visible on the scale plotted, G' initially lags on growth of viscosity or viscous modulus, G", but quickly crosses and dominates as gel elasticity rapidly develops, the transition point occurring at 8 = 45 ~ Plots of shear moduli versus reaction time evolve as sigmoidal curves which tend to approach a constant
Development of Rheological Properties during Rennet Coagulation Possibly the most direct way to measure gel formation is to monitor the evolution of rheological properties (Bohlin etal., 1984; Dejmek, 1987; Zoon et al., 1988a; Horne, 1995, 1996). Dynamic rheology applies an oscillatory shear stress (r0) or strain (y0) and measures the response from the developing gel. The measurement yields the elastic or storage modulus (G'), which is a measure of the energy stored per oscillation cycle and reflects how the sample behaves as an elastic solid, and the viscous or loss modulus (G") which is a measure of the energy dissipated per cycle and indicates how much the sample behaves as a viscous liquid. Their ratio is tan 8, the tangent of the phase angle of the response to the applied stress or strain. The shear moduli are defined as follows:
G' = ( r~
a
(7)
( r~ )sin 8 = \7/
(8)
\T0/
G"
tan fi =
G
t!
(9)
G'
90
,
i
i
i
90
i
80
-
80
~ 7o
-
70
~ so
-
60
"0 Oo
~ 5o
-
50
~ 4o
-
40
-
30
-
20
-
10
Q.
~
e-
co 20 ,~,,~' ,..,.,,.,,-.,, 0
--" . . . . . .
0
"_.'::t:~
0.5
I
I
I
I
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
0 3
Time (ks) 3 A typical example of the changes in viscoelastic parameters observed during gel formation, showing increases in shear moduli (G', G") and decreases in phase angle (8) with time after enzyme addition. Figure
Rennet-induced Coagulation of Milk
value appropriate to each milk sample at very long times. In practice, of course, the gel is generally cut at a fixed time after rennet addition or after visible coagulation is noted, perhaps after a period of no more than 30 min. In either instance, the gel firmness is likely to be of the order of 30 Pa and possibly has not passed its maximum rate of firming. A rennet-induced milk gel is described as a viscoelastic solid. In rheological terms, the critical gelation point is often taken as the time at which the elastic modulus exceeds the viscous modulus (Ross Murphy, 1995). Others demand compliance with more stringent conditions, such as the Winter and Chambon (1986) criterion which gives the gelation as occurring at the time when both G' and G" show power-law dependence on oscillation frequency, both dependencies with the same positive exponent. Derived for chemically cross-linked polymers, this time does not necessarily coincide with that for G' and G" cross-over in a single frequency experiment. Depending on the instrument sensitivity and the reaction, it may not even be possible to detect this cross-over. In some concentrated systems, the value of G' may have already exceeded G", whilst in others it may occur early in the reaction below the instrument detection threshold. In the latter circumstance, an acceptable working definition of the gel point would be when instrument response rises above the background noise level. What physically defines the gel point and, beyond that critical point, what defines the dynamic evolution of the viscoelasticity of the gel in terms of a mechanism, describing network, creation and growth are the subjects of the next section.
Theoretical Basis of Viscoelasticity Continuity of structure and permanency of that structure are general features of a gel. We continue to visualize the rennet-induced milk gel as a particle gel. The spatial distribution of the casein micelles (the particles) in the gel network and the strength of the bonding between those elements define the existence and the rheology of the gel. By considering the deformation of the network following application of a shearing force, Van Vliet and Walstra (1985) derived the following equation for the modulus of the network: d2F G = C N ~
dx 2
(10)
where N is the number of stress-bearing strands per unit area in a cross-section perpendicular to x, the direction of the external force or stress, C is a charac-
57
teristic length determining the geometry of the network, dF is the change in Gibbs free energy when the elements are moved apart over a distance dx, and is therefore related to the bond strength in systems where enthalphic effects dominate over entropic, as argued by Van Vliet and Walstra (1985). In the case of particles which are homogeneously distributed over the available space, or at least homogeneously on the length scales of the experimental measuring device, all particles involved in the network will contribute to the network modulus to the same extent. N will then be directly proportional to the volume fraction of particles in the network. In describing the formation of the rennet-induced milk gel, G will be a function of reaction time, and thus the growth of the shear modulus with time will depend on the rate of incorporation of particles into the network and the rate of change of bond strength (or increase in well depth) with time. Two possible scenarios present themselves. In the first, only the well depth is considered as a function of time. This is akin to the adhesive sphere concept of De Kruif and coworkers (1992); De Kruif (1999) and De Kruif and Holt (2003) would assume that all of the casein micelles would be considered as a network from time zero, the point at which K-casein proteolysis is initiated and the attractive well begins to deepen. Dickinson (2003) has emphasized that the hard sphere model operates within the framework of equilibrium statistical mechanics. It therefore describes the gelation for relatively weak, short-range attractions under reversible conditions. That is, the particles are free to dissociate, as well as to associate, the dynamic equilibrium constant or bond lifetime being a function of well depth. With well depth increasing as proteolysis progresses, the bonds become increasingly stronger and could become effectively irreversible within the time-span of the experiment. This bond lifetime or relaxation time has an important bearing on the response of the network in the rheometer geometry, where the lifetime of a bond must be correlated with the oscillation time of the applied deformation. Strong bonds with a high energy content will generally have a long relaxation time. They establish the permanent or elastic character of the gel. Weak bonds generally break and reform spontaneously over much shorter timescales. They contribute to the temporary character of the gel network, appearing as the viscous component. Thus, non-relaxing bonds only contribute to G' whereas rapidly relaxing bonds only contribute to G". Bonds with relaxation times in the timescale of the measurement contribute to both G' and G". Because bond lifetime changes smoothly during proteolysis and gel formation, in this model from very short to
58
Rennet-induced Coagulation of Milk
very long, the gelling system passes monotonically from a viscous liquid to a firm elastic solid and the phase angle, 8, passes through the critical 45 ~ value. Changes in phase angle may therefore more sensitively reflect changes in the nature of the bonds (Roefs, 1985). As Fig. 3 shows, however, during the formation of a rennet-induced milk gel, the phase angle decreases rapidly in the early stages through the gel point but remains substantially constant throughout the main growth period in the shear moduli, as was also observed by Dejmek (1987) and Lopez et al. (1998). This indicates that the nature and strength of the bonds does not change significantly during this growth. It is therefore likely that the increase in gel firmness is caused by an increase in the number of bonds with time, the other time-dependent factor in our theoretical expression for the modulus, G, in equation 10. In the second scenario, the micelles aggregate into clusters and these clusters eventually form the gel network. The kinetics of this aggregation can be viewed as an increase in the number of bonds with time. What point in the time course of the progress of this reaction can be identified as the gel point, and can this be detected experimentally? Again, two extreme scenar-
ios can be envisaged (Fig. 4). The first is a strong gelation where bond energy is > >kT and bond formation is virtually irreversible. As depicted in Fig. 4, gelation corresponds to the achievement of a percolation cluster spanning the container (Stauffer, 1976; DeGennes, 1979). This critical percolation cluster is present only for a very short moment. Gel curing continues as the remaining free particles and clusters are incorporated into the network, creating more stress-carrying strands. This is what is observed as the growth of shear modulus with time. In the second scenario in aggregate growth (Fig. 4b), bonds are weak, aggregation is reversible, and clusters break up as readily as they form. The critical gelation condition is reached when the clusters achieve a pseudoclose-packed arrangement as depicted in Fig. 4b. The majority of potential bonds are satisfied at this juncture, and increases in shear moduli occur as the system rearranges itself in its quest for an equilibrium structure. Can the measured kinetics of gel formation assist in differentiating these two extremes? As is shown in Fig. 5a, gel cure curves, plotted as complex modulus, G*, versus t, are typical for each milk. In the set shown, the same reaction conditions, rheometer settings and
(a)
o ~
c.4o 0
Oo ,_osD
(b)
<
(
.i,
...-.
DO[,c
1
Figure 4 Two different scenarios defining the occurrence of tl~e' gel point. (a) The percolation cluster model where gelation is sensed by the measuring device whenever clusters extend across the container. Note the number of clusters and monomers which have still to be incorporated into the gel, creating more links and strands to carry applied stress. (b) The formation of a weak gel where most particles are weakly linked into the network but reversibility allows rearrangements. The larger circles depict the fractal 'blob' concept where the system is fractal within but closed packed outside.
Rennet-induced Coagulation of Milk
1.5
150
I
I
I
I
I
(a)
I
(b)'
7-"
100
'
'
]
I:,/," ,,'"
75
1.00
,3,"I
i..-, /
.4.,.., o~
&
0.75
.4-=,
/I,/ '
0
E
'
s
-
~
'
1.25
125
13_
59
50
0:I
,'"
L~ -...
i,'! ~ . / 8 l,/ / ,' .7
(5
s
0.50
-
0.25
-
//!/ ,,'..
r--
25
-
I
~176~
,."
-
2.
0
i "J~_ ~r* - .....r'-
0
I
,,~
' I
'
--
0
I
2.0 4.0 6.0 8.0 I0.012.0 14 Time from rennet addition (ks)
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
Reduced time,
3.0
3.5
t/tg
Figure 5 Depiction of the derivation of the master curve plot from a series of gel cure curves obtained by renneting individual milks (1-7) under the same reaction conditions (left-hand plot). The data in the right-hand plot were obtained by dividing the reaction time (time after enzyme addition) by the clotting time (tg) and then normalizing each individual curve against its particular value at 3tg.
chymosin concentration were used in each case but the individual milks exhibit their own gelation times, tg, rates of curd firming and ultimate gel firmness. When these curves are re-plotted against a reduced time, t/tg, and each normalized against its particular value at a low multiple of tg, usually two or three, all curves collapse onto a master curve (Fig. 5b) (Horne, 1995). Such behaviour is known as 'scaling'. The fact that the curves can be scaled has several implications. It implies that the mathematical expression describing the time-dependent growth of the shear modulus of the curve can be factorized into the product of two terms and written as:
(ii)
where G~ is a simple constant, the asymptotic value of the shear modulus at infinite reaction time for a particular milk system. As a constant, it embodies all the static attributes of the gel. The second term, f(tltg), is more complicated, but it is nevertheless a function of a single variable, the reduced time, tltg, and all data sets follow this master function which describes the dynamics of the gel-formation process. It is important to realize the significance of the dependence on the critical gel time, tg. It is defined as the time required to form the critical gel network and is the rate parameter controlling the aggregation reaction leading to that network. Its presence as the parameter also controlling the rate of gel cure indi-
cates that essentially the same kinetics is dominating that reaction. In essence, this is a pointer to the first, the percolation, scenario as being the more true picture, with the further incorporation of micelles and clusters being simply another part of the ongoing aggregation reaction throughout all phases of gel development. The gel-development kinetics clearly depends on the rate of the proteolysis reaction, the rate controlling the achievement of the gel time. Lomholt and Qvist (1997) have raised doubts about this scaling approach, showing that multiplying reaction time by the rate constant for proteolysis, ke, does not produce a master cure curve in a series of experiments conducted with varying enzyme and protein concentrations. Our results use t~-t as the reducing factor, and other groups have found that the product of tg and ke is not always unity, as attempting to consider them equivalent would imply (Tokita etal., 1982). Perhaps the answer lies in the mode of action of the enzyme and how the activation of the micelle towards aggregation comes about. Proteolysis estimates give a global figure for the suspension as a whole which may not relate to the status of individual micelles, whereas gel times are a direct measure of the aggregation behaviour. Further work in this area is undoubtedly required. A further advantage of the scaling approach is the observation that f(t/tg) is a single-valued function, in the sense that any one value of the ratio tltg leads to a single value forf(tltg). That being the case, the value of G at a defined value of the reduced time, say tltg = 3,
60
Rennet-induced Coagulation of Milk
will always be the same fraction of G~. Thus, whilst Go~ is essentially unattainable, all information on its behaviour is accessible through the value of the shear modulus as the multiple of tg selected for comparison purposes. Based on this accessibility to Goo, Horne (1996) has developed a mechanical model for the gel. If it is assumed that each micelle has the potential for forming an average number of bonds, k, with its neighbours, then these will all be fully linked into the network attained at infinite time and will therefore define the value of Goo. With all of the micelles incorporated into the network, the number of bonds will be proportional to the number of micelles present. Hence, according to equation 10, G~ will be proportional to the number of micelles, assuming that all bonds are of equal strength. If the average micelle is of diameter, d, then at a given concentration of c g/ml, the number of micelles is proportional to c/d 3. Hence, this simple model predicts:
Goo oc
C
(12)
d3
and since G at 3tg is a fixed fraction of Goo by the scaling requirements, then C
Gat 3tg oc d 3
(13)
Horne (1996) fractionated casein micelles according to size from individual cow milks using a sequence of eight consecutive centrifugation steps, applying the centrifugation to the supernatant of the previous step, as described in detail by Dalgleish et al. (1989). These pellets were re-suspended in milk ultrafiltrate to the same casein concentration and their average size was measured independently by dynamic light scattering. The micellar suspensions were then renneted under the same incubation conditions. Growth of the elastic modulus was monitored as a function of time. G* at 3tg was found to be inversely proportional to the cube of micelle size, as predicted by equation 13. In a separate experiment, milk from a single source was concentrated by ultrafiltration and then diluted back to give a series of milks of the same micellar size distribution but differing in protein concentration. When these milks were renneted, the value of G* at 2tg was found to be a linear function of the concentration factor, again as predicted by Horne (1996). Niki et al. (1994) also prepared sized fractions separated from skim milk by differential centrifugation. They confirmed that smaller micelles gave firmer gels but not as strongly as the inverse cubic dependence predicted. Their micellar fractions were, however, used as prepared
and not adjusted to a constant protein concentration. Obviously, those fractions from the wings of the size distribution have a lower protein content than those obtained around the mean size. Niki et al. (1994) do not give details of the protein content or composition of their fractions, making it impossible to recalculate their data on the basis of the behaviour predicted by equation 13.
Modelling the Gel-Firming Kinetics Many attempts have been made to produce mathematical equations to predict the growth of gel firmness with time. These range from the purely empirical (Scott Blair and Burnett, 1958) to those rooted in some kinetic mechanism (Tuszynski, 1971; Douillard, 1973; Carlson et al., 1987a; Clark and Amici, 2003). Tested simply on their ability to fit the observed growth curves, some are more successful than others which fail to reproduce salient features. Others have no theoretical basis which makes them less useful as predictive tools. Scott Blair and Burnett (1958) proposed an empirical model of the form:
G(t) = G~exp
(t-
tg)
(14)
to describe the increase in shear modulus (G) with time beyond the gel point occurring at tg, r being a constant characteristic of the sample and determined by fitting. Dejmek (1987) demonstrated that this model provides a good fit to experimentally obtained cure curves but has non-random residuals, indicating that the function may not be appropriate for its intended purpose. Dejmek (1987) also proposed equations relating the parameters of the Scott Blair equation to the value of the experimental cure curve at its inflexion point, obviating the need for measurements at extended times, but relying perhaps too heavily on a few points in that particular region of the cure curve. In favour of this model is the observation that this function shows an acceleratory growth phase immediately following the gel point, that it evinces a maximum rate of firmness and tends to a plateau as t tends to infinity. Against, it is its purely empirical nature which makes prediction of the dependence of its parameters on reaction variables such as temperature, pH or enzyme concentration all but impossible. Arguing that the shape of the growth curve was similar to that for simple autocatalytic reactions, Tuszynski (1971) proposed that the growth kinetics be fitted by the model: dG dt*
-
kG(Ooo -
O)
(15)
Rennet-induced Coagulation of Milk
where t* = t - tg, Goo is the value of the shear modulus at t = oo and k is the rate constant for the process but essentially a fitting parameter. Again, the model provides no indication how changes in reaction variables will influence the gel-firming process. Like the Scott Blair model, it too gives sigmoidal behaviour but it is a symmetric function, predicting that the inflexion occurs when G = 0.SGo~, and this is not observed in practice. Douillard (1973) proposed a model in which the rate of change of shear modulus with time followed first-order kinetics:
dG = k(Goo- G) dr*
t* >- 0
or
t >- tg
(16)
This equation can be integrated to give" G = G~[1 - exp ( - k t * ) ]
(17)
with the initial condition that G = 0 at t = tg. This equation has recurred several times in the history of studies on the rennet coagulation of milk. Tokita etal. (1982) fitted their cure curves to an nth-order reaction equation and determined that the first-order form, the Douillard equation above, gave the best fit. They further demonstrated that the gel time, tg, obtained in these studies varied inversely with enzyme concentration, and that the rate parameter, k, had a power-law dependence on enzyme concentration with an exponent of 0.8. In their discussion, Tokita et al. (1982) extended the consideration of the Smoluchowski equation and its use in the kinetics of polymer gelation by Ziff (1980) and Ziff and Stell (1982) to rennet gel formation. Assuming that 'gel' reacts with 'polymer' in the sol phase and that 'gel' does not cross-link by itself, they show that the concentration of gel is proportional to 1 - e x p ( - e t t ) . With the further assumption that oL is proportional to the rate constant of the Smoluchowski equation and that the elastic modulus is proportional to the concentration of gel, the Douillard equation emerges. Tokita et al. (1982) thus reached the important conclusion that beyond the gel point, most of the growth in gel firmness arises as a result of aggregation between the infinite cluster and the smaller clusters and micelles in the sol phase. In a later paper, Tokita (1989) considered gel formation as a percolation process. In percolation, the bond formation probability is defined by N/Ntotal where N is the number of bonds formed up to that point and Ntotal is the total number of bonds possible in the system. Ntotal is the product of the number of lattice sites multiplied by their functionality, Z, the number of bonds
61
allowed for each site. The percolation probability, P(p), is defined as the probability that a site chosen at random will belong to the infinite cluster. With the assumption that P(p) = 1 - e x p ( - Z p ) for p > pc, the critical percolation probability, he equated G to P(p) and went on to derive the Douillard equation. Fitting his latest data to this equation, Tokita (1989) found that the reaction rate constant was best described as a linear function of the enzyme concentration used, slightly different from their earlier result. The Douillard equation also emerges as a limiting case of the Carlson model (Carlson et al., 1987a) discussed below. Whilst it is thus widely applied, the Douillard equation does not reproduce one of the most significant features experimentally observed in the gel cure curves obtained with modern more sensitive rheometers, namely the acceleratory phase immediately after the gel point, and hence further refinements to it are required. Some of these are to be found in the Carlson model. Carlson et al. (1987a) derived the rather complex model given by:
O=O~
-
k,-kf kf ) e x p ( - k l t * ) ] + ( k l - kf
(18)
where t* = t - tg, kl is the rate constant for the creation of 'active' sites and kf is the rate constant for the destruction of these sites as they are incorporated into the gel network. Essentially, the model envisages 'active' sites being created on micelles, which then go on to react with one another in forming bonds in the gel network. Both reactions, activation and destruction, are considered as first-order processes. Activation requires the enzymatic hydrolysis of K-casein, and therefore kl emerges as proportional to the enzyme concentration. That the site destruction reaction should also be a firstorder process is an empirical observation which fits in well with the idea of the gel network mopping-up smaller clusters and micelles still requiring to be activated beyond the gel point. When the enzyme concentration is large, K-casein hydrolysis is rapid compared to the removal of activated micelles and the Douillard equation is recovered with a rate constant now equal to that for the activation reaction and therefore governed by the enzymatic hydrolysis process. In the hands of the present authors, application of the Carlson model to gel firming curves gave excellent fits with very low standard errors (Horne, unpublished observations). This confirms the views of Esteves et al. (2001) who compared its performance to those of the
62 Rennet-induced Coagulation of Milk Scott Blair and Douillard models, although they finally considered the Scott Blair model superior because it gave a smaller standard error and lower fluctuations in the systematic oscillations of the residuals. Unfortunately, as we commented above, the Scott Blair model has no basis in theory which would permit predictive use of its parameters. Further efforts should therefore be directed to more extensive tests of the Carlson model with perhaps extensions to incorporate the refinements of aggregation models now extant. More quantitative testing of the model would also discover whether the many parameters involved possess realistic values or whether they are merely 'best-fits'. Along yet another avenue, Clark and Amici (2003) have compared the predictions of cascade theory, a random cross-linking polymerization theory, with experimental biopolymer gelation curves. The comparison was made of log (G/G~) versus tg/t, a linear transform of the Scott Blair equation, for calculated and experimental data. For rennet-induced milk gels they obtained reasonable fits when the critical gelling concentration (Co) was set much less than the micellar concentration (C). The calculations require that the ratio C/Co be set, so the experimental data were compared to a series of theoretical curves calculated for a range of these values. Accepting that the fits are not outstanding, Clark and Amici (2003) point out that the cascade model used does not contain any pre-gelation kinetic terms and, in other studies of polymer gelation carried out with this theoretical approach, their inclusion markedly influenced later events beyond the gel point. These theoretical approaches are very interesting and tantalizing but more work is needed to fully explore the implications of their results before a definitive model of the cure curve can be achieved.
Fractal Models of Rennet-Induced Milk Gels and Rearrangements Fractal aggregation theories have been applied to the flocculation of casein particles by Bremer and coworkers (Bremer et al., 1989; Bremer, 1992). Aggregates can be considered fractal if their geometry is scale invariant which implies that their structure is similar when viewed over a reasonably large range of length scales or magnifications. The emphasis of the fractal concept is therefore on structure. It is a mathematical description of the distribution of a particle cluster or network in space. Various models are then used to predict gel or cluster properties based on that structural organization. The number of particles in an aggregate or cluster (Np) is given by:
Np =
(19)
where R is the radius of the floc, a is the primary particle size and Df is the fractal dimension. The latter is usually a non-integer and is always less than the geometric or Euclidean dimension of three. This equation implies that the cluster becomes ever more tenuous as it grows, as verified in computer simulations of aggregation reactions (Kolb et al., 1983; Meakin, 1983) and experimental measurements on dilute colloidal systems (Linet al., 1990). These results demonstrate that extremes of reaction probability give rise to different fractal dimensions, ranging from 1.7 for a diffusionlimited cluster-cluster aggregation to 2.5 for a reaction-limited particle-cluster process. Since the number of particles that could be present in a close-packed cluster is given by:
Nc =
,
(20)
the volume fraction of the cluster is given by:
~bcluster- Nc
(21)
The average volume fraction therefore decreases as the cluster grows. When it reduces to the volume fraction of particles in the system, ~b0, the clusters fill the total space available and the gel is formed. Bremer and coworkers (Bremer et al., 1989; Bremer, 1992) define the gel point by this event which implies that all particles present in the system are incorporated in the clusters. The real question is whether this can be equated to the rheological gel point recognized experimentally but this appears to be the assumption made. The decrease in density can be accomplished only if the growing cluster develops holes or voids of everincreasing size as the cluster grows. This is the meaning of scale invariance. When such a cluster grows to macroscopic size, it should have macroscopic holes on that length scale. No such holes are seen in particle gels, of which rennet-induced milk gels are our exampies. Instead, they appear as a homogeneous, solid-like mass. Brown (1987) circumvented this difficulty by introducing the concept of the fractal blob, suggesting that clusters grow to a size, Rblob , and these then closepack homogeneously to give a uniform volume fraction defined by that of the blob at that point. The picture of the network is then similar to that depicted in Fig. 4b, and at the gel point the volume fraction achieved is again that originally in the suspension, ~b0. With all of the particles (micelles) already bonded into the network at the gel point, the only way in which gel firmness can grow with time thereafter is
Rennet-induced Coagulation of Milk
through rearrangements of the bonds already in the structure, a phenomenon referred to as ageing by Mellema et al. (2002). Various models have been elaborated relating the elastic modulus of the gel to the volume fraction through a power-law equation, with the exponent of this equation written as a simple function of the fractal dimension and other possible parameters (Bremer, 1992). Such models allow the stress-carrying strands to be straight or curved. Further, in the models of Shih et al. (1990), the elasticity of the gels may be determined by the elasticity of the flocs or blobs (strong links between blobs) or dominated by the elastic content of the inter-floc links (weak-link regime). It perhaps should be mentioned here that Shih et al. (1990) categorically state that their models apply well above the gelation threshold. This creates a total of four possible expressions for the exponent, yet the experimentally observed power-law dependence of G' on volume fraction gives a single value. In some instances, model candidates can be eliminated because they yield unphysical values for the fractal dimension. In others, no choice can be selected without other independent information. In a summarizing expression, Mellema (2000) has written the exponent as: c~
where
oz= 2s + 8 + 1
(22)
is the number of junctions or links per strand (0, 1 or 2), and the value of e is set by the dominant type of macroscopic deformation: bending (e = 1) or stretching (~ = 0).
Fusion
63
With this background, Mellema (2000) went on to consider four levels of rearrangement in rennetinduced gels, operating on different length scales. These were intra-micellar rearrangement, individual micelle shifts, strand rearrangements and in the whole gel (syneresis), the latter as a result (mainly) of the previous three categories listed. These possibilities are depicted in Fig. 6. Applying this picture to the cure curves, Mellema (2000) accommodated increases in elastic modulus with time by postulating changes in the parameter o~, as the gel aged. This necessitated assuming that the fractal dimension, Dr, was constant throughout, or that its variation with time was measured independently in separate experiments (Mellema et al., 2000). Gel cure was therefore interpreted as arising from changes in strand thickness, strand conformation and number of linkages depending on how oz was modified but no kinetic mechanism was derived to predict the dynamics of these changes and directly test the speculations, no matter how reasonable.
Milk Processing and Gel Formation Rennet clotting activity as influenced by milk processing
Milk coagulation by rennet can be influenced by a number of processing treatments applied to the milk (Harboe and Budtz, 1999). The gel formation characteristics of high-pressure and heat-treated milks for cheesemaking have been studied extensively in recent years. Interest in these areas will be sustained as both treatments can be used to maximize cheese yield.
Particle shift
Chain rearrangement
Syneresis Figure 6 Diagrams of the various pathways open in rearrangements of the network. These can occur on several length-scales, at internal micellar links where the individual proteins rearrange themselves and allow more and more links to be formed between the original particles, along the chains where particles can detach and reattach forming new links (centre drawing) and the detachment of chains either at one or both ends leaving them to find a new home elsewhere on the network. All three processes contribute to macroscopic syneresis of the maturing curd (adapted from Mellema et aL, 2002).
64
Rennet-induced Coagulation of Milk
High pressure
High pressure treatment influences the coagulation and cheesemaking properties of milk indirectly through a number of effects on milk proteins, including a reduction in the size of casein micelles, denaturation of [3-1actoglobulin and possible interaction of [3lactoglobulin with micellar K-casein (Trujillo etal., 2000, 2002; O'Reilly et al., 2001; Huppertz et al., 2002). Gel firmness and cheese yield can be improved by highpressure treatment of milk through an increased recovery of whey proteins and increased moisture content. Treatment of milk at pressures of up to 200 MPa for 30 min reduces the RCT while higher pressures, up to 600 MPa, result in RCT values similar to those of untreated milk (Lopez-Fandino etal., 1996, 1997; Needs et al., 2000). Changes in RCT observed are associated with changes in both the enzymatic primary phase of coagulation and the secondary phase of aggregation. These changes would be expected to be associated with changes in micelle size resulting from high-pressure treatment. The average casein micelle size is unchanged in reconstituted skim milk treated at pressures of 150-250 MPa (Desobry-Banon et al., 1994; Gaucheron et al., 1997), although one report (Needs et al., 2000) suggests a small increase of 9% in micelle size in raw skim milk using a pressure of 200 MPa. At pressures between 250 and 600 MPa, micelle size is reduced by 40-50% in reconstituted skim milk (Desobry-Banon et al., 1994) or raw skim milk (Needs et al., 2000). The effect of pressure treatment on micelle size in reconstituted skim milk is temperature-dependent (Gaucheron et al., 1997). Pressure treatment of milk at 4 ~ reduced micelle size, at 20 ~ resulted in no change and at 40 ~ causes an increase in micelle size which may be associated with interactions between fragments of casein micelles and denatured whey proteins (Buchheim et al., 1996). Transfer of individual caseins from the colloidal to the soluble phase has been observed at pressures of 100-400 Mpa (Law et al., 1998; Lopez-Fandino et al., 1998). Treatment of raw milk at a pressure of up to 200 MPa for 3 0 m i n reduced the RCT, while further increases in pressures up to 400 MPa resulted in RCT values close to those for untreated milk (LopezFandino et al., 1996, 1997; Needs et al., 2000). The RCT of pressure-treated milk is affected by both the temperature of treatment and the pH of the milk. Treatment at -->200 MPa at 60 ~ or >--300 MPa at 50 ~ inhibits the rennet coagulation of milk (Lopez-Fandino and Olano, 1998). Acidification of milk to pH 5.5 prior to high pressure treatment reduced its RCT whereas increasing pH to 7.0 had the opposite effect (Arias et al., 2000).
The reduced release of CMP during the primary phase for samples treated at 400 MPa or at 300 MPa at >40 ~ has been associated with the interaction of high-pressure-denatured /3-1actoglobulin with glycosylated K-casein, which would hinder the action of chymosin on K-casein (Lopez-Fandino et al., 1997; Lopez-Fandino and Olano, 1998). Blocking agents have been used to show that high pressure effects observed on RCT are associated with sulphydryl interactions which cause the ]3-1actoglobulin to bind to the surface of micelles via interaction with K-casein (Needs et al., 2000). However, Needs et al. (2000) reported that the release of glycosylated CMP was unaffected by high-pressure treatment, and only the second phase of rennet coagulation (rate of micelle aggregation) was affected. Rates of aggregation and gel formation of milk treated at 200 MPa were considerably higher than for untreated milk, but these rates decreased at higher pressures. Samples treated at 400 or 600 MPa produced higher gel strengths than samples treated at 200 MPa or untreated samples. The authors concluded that two opposing mechanisms operate to control the rate of aggregation - there was a direct effect of pressure on the properties of the micelles, which resulted in their rapid aggregation (following the hydrolysis of K-casein), while increasing [3-1actoglobulin denaturation reduced the rate of aggregation. Coagulation time was not related to the degree of K-casein hydrolysis, which suggested that pressure favoured the aggregation stage. Heat treatment
Heat treatment of milk results in a number of changes in physico-chemical properties. These include the denaturation of whey proteins, the interactions between the denatured whey proteins and the casein micelles and the conversion of soluble calcium to the colloidal state. High heat treatment of milk for cheesemaking provides a potential route for maximizing cheese yield by the inclusion of whey proteins in curd (Singh and Waungana, 2001). However, milk which has been heated at a temperature in excess of pasteurization has poor renneting and gel formation characteristics (Morrissey, 1969; Dalgleish, 1992), and a number of studies have explored the extent to which the primary enzymatic and the secondary phases of aggregation are influenced by heat treatment (Van Hooydonk et al., 1987; Dalgleish, 1990; Leaver et al., 1995; Waungana et al., 1996). Thermal denaturation of [3-1actoglobulin is known to affect the cheesemaking properties of milk. It has been claimed that heating milk affects the clotting process by slowing or inhibiting the primary phase of rennet action as K-casein-[3-1actoglobulin cross-linking
Rennet-induced Coagulation of Milk reduces the susceptibility of K-casein to hydrolysis by chymosin (Van Hooydonk et al., 1987; Leaver et al., 1995). The decrease in the rate of gel formation and final gel firmness in heated milks can also be attributed to the association of whey protein aggregates with casein micelle surfaces through the formation of a [3-Lg-K-casein complex which may protrude from the micelle surface (Singh and Waungana, 2001). This association would affect the close approach of the reactive sites formed on the micelles by the action of rennet. Following the hydrolysis of K-casein to paraK-casein, aggregation would occur mostly between micelles not fully covered with 6-Lg, resulting in the formation of fewer bridges with fewer and weaker bonds. The severity of heat treatment will determine the extent of inhibition of either the primary enzymatic phase or the secondary aggregation phase (Singh and Waungana, 2001). The rennet coagulation properties of heated milk can be partially restored either by (i) acidification of heated milks to pH values below 6.2, (ii) acidification of heated milk to low pH values (---5.5) followed by reneutralization to 6.7, which is termed pH cycling or (iii) heating at elevated pH combined with pH cycling and CaC12 addition (see Singh and Waungana, 2001, for a review). Acidification or pH cycling has been used in the manufacture of Cheddar cheese from severely heated milks (Banks et al., 1987, 1993; Banks, 1988; Imafidon and Farkye, 1993). Improvements in cheese yield of up to 4.0% on a dry solids basis were achieved (Banks et al., 1993).
Conclusions Despite intensive research effort, now spanning many decades, there is still no definitive overall description of the kinetics of gel formation which would allow prediction of the cutting time from a knowledge of milk composition and treatment. Even now, we are perhaps only realizing that we can treat the reaction as a continuum and that we have largely forgotten that it was mainly the constraints of earlier theories and methodologies that artificially divided the process and confined studies to particular stages of aggregation and curd development. In rheometry, we now have the instrumentation to directly measure cure curves and as these instruments become ever more sensitive, the effects of possible gel damage in the early stages of the reaction lessen, allowing aggregation and gelation to come seamlessly together instrumentally. Exciting new developments in the fields of microscopy and image analysis allow the potential to
65
follow the mobility of particles through the gel point as they are confined and incorporated into a gel network. This will perhaps settle the question as to whether gel cure is the result of the firming up of a percolated initial structure for the gel as sol material is included into the network or whether the rearrangement process dominates beyond the gel point, as the fractal models demand. The fractal picture is important, however, because it forces us to confront the role of rearrangement in determining gel firmness, particularly the shifts in bonding within the micelle, which we would argue should be considered within the context of the dualbinding model of the micelle described earlier. Whilst the majority of model studies of rennetinduced gelation have been carried out (fortuitously) at high pH where micellar integrity seems assured, many cheesemaking procedures involve a lowering of the pH by straightforward adjustment or by fermentative growth of starter cultures. Lowering the pH leads to a solubilization of calcium phosphate, a consequent decrease in the number of bonds preserving micellar integrity and an increased propensity for rearrangements of protein molecules within and between aggregated micelles. Horne (2001, 2003) has demonstrated the influence of such breakdown in micellar integrity in the context of gel development in studies of model yoghurt systems. The rate at which such processes occur will impact on the rate of increase of the elastic modulus of the gel with time but this aspect is yet to be considered in the context of the dynamics of rennet-induced gel development. Further work in this area is required to assess that impact, perhaps by looking for deviations in the scaling behaviour as the gel cures, perhaps by including terms in the Carlson (1987a,b) model to accommodate reversibility in the removal of activated micelles, or perhaps by considering altogether new models for the network structure and the manner in which the elastic modulus is related to that structure.
References Aoki, T., Toyooka, K. and Kako, Y. (1985). Role of phosphate groups in the calcium sensitivity of Ots2-casein. J. Dairy Sci. 68, 1624-1629. Arias, M., Lopez-Fandino, R. and Olano, A. (2000). Influence of pH on the effects of high pressure on milk proteins. Milchwissenschaft 53, 191-194. Banks, J.M. (1988). Elimination of the development of bitter flavour in Cheddar cheese made from milk containing heatdenatured whey protein. J. Soc. Dairy Technol. 41, 37-41. Banks, J.M. (1992). Yield and quality of Cheddar cheese produced using a fermentation-derived calf chymosin. Milchwissenschaft 40,209-212.
66
Rennet-induced Coagulation of Milk
Banks, J.M., Stewart, G., Muir, D.D. and West, I.G. (1987). Increasing the yield of Cheddar cheese by acidification of milk containing heat denatured whey protein. Milchwissenschaft 42, 212-215. Banks, J.M., Law, A.J.R., Leaver, J. and Home, D.S. (1993). The inclusion of whey proteins in cheese - an overview, in, Cheese Yield and Factors Affecting its Control: Special Issue 940, International Dairy Federation, Brussels. pp. 387-401. Bauer, R., Hansen, M., Hansen, S., g)gendal, L., Lomholt, S., Qvist, K. and Home, D. (1995). The structure of casein aggregates during renneting studied by indirect Fourier transformation and inverse Laplace transformation of static and dynamic light scattering data, respectively. J. Chem. Phys. 103, 2725-2737. Benguigui, L., Emery, J., Durand, D. and Busmel, J.E (1994). Ultrasonic study of milk clotting. Lait 74, 197-206. Bohlin, L., Hegg, E and Ljusberg-Wahren, H. (1984). Viscoelastic properties of coagulating milk. J. Dairy Sci. 67,729-734. Bremer, L.B.G. (1992). Fractal Aggregates in Relation to Formation and Properties of Particle Gels. PhD Thesis, Wageningen Agricultural University, Wageningen, The Netherlands. Bremer, L.B.G., Van Vliet, T. and Walstra, P. (1989). Theoretical and experimental study of the fractal nature of the structure of casein gels, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. 1 85, 3359-3372. Brinkhuis, J. and Payens, T.A.J. (1984). The influence of temperature on the flocculation of renneted casein micelles. Biophys. Chem. 19, 75-81. Brown, W.D. (1987). The Structure and Physical Properties of Flocculating Colloids. PhD Thesis, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK. Buchheim, W., Schrader, K., Mort, C.V., Frede, E. and Schutt, M. (1996). Effect of high pressure on the protein, lipid and mineral phase of milk, in, Heat Treatments and Alternative Methods, Special Issue No. 9602, International Dairy Federation, Brussels. pp. 202-213. Carlson, A., Hill Jr., C.G. and Olson, N.E (1987a). Kinetics of milk coagulation. III. Mathematical modelling of the kinetics of curd formation following enzymatic hydrolysis of K-casein- parameter estimation. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 29, 601-611. Carlson, A., HiII Jr., C.G. and Olson, N.E (1987b). Kinetics of milk coagulation. IV. The kinetics of the gel-firming process. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 29, 612-624. Chaplin, B. and Green, M.L. (1980). Determination of the proportion of K-casein hydrolyzed by rennet on coagulation of skim-milk. J. Dairy Res. 47, 351-358. Chitpinityol, S. and Crabbe, M.J.C. (1998). Chymosin and aspartic proteinases. Food Chem. 61,395-418. Clark, A.H. and Amici, E.H. (2003). The formation and properties of biopolymer gels, in, Food Colloids and Materials, Dickinson, E. and Van Vliet, T. eds, Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge. pp. 35-48. Dalgleish, D.G. (1979). Proteolysis and aggregation of casein micelles treated with immobilized or soluble chymosin. J. Dairy Res. 46, 653-661. Dalgleish, D.G. (1980a). Effect of milk concentration on rennet coagulation time. J. Dairy Res. 47, 231-235.
Dalgleish, D.G. (1980b). A mechanism for the chymosininduced flocculation of casein micelles. Biophys. Chem. 11, 147-155. Dalgleish, D.G. (1983). Coagulation of renneted casein micelles: dependence on temperature, calcium ion concentration and ionic strength. J. Dairy Res. 50, 331-340. Dalgleish, D.G. (1984). Measurement of electrophoretic mobilities and zeta potentials of particles from milk using laser Doppler electrophoresis. J. Dairy Res. 51, 425-438. Dalgleish, D.G. (1988). A new calculation of the kinetics of the renneting reaction. J. Dairy Res. 55,221-228. Dalgleish, D.G. (1990). The effect of denaturation of [3-1actoglobulin on renneting. A quantitative study. Milchwissenschaft 45,491-494. Dalgleish, D.G. (1992). The enzymatic coagulation of milk, in, Advanced Dairy Chemistry: 1. Proteins, Fox, P.E ed., Elsevier Applied Science, London. pp. 579-619. Dalgleish, D.G. (1993). The enzymatic coagulation of milk, in, Cheese: Chemistry, Physics and Microbiology, Vol. 1: General Aspects, Fox, P.E ed., Chapman & Hall, London. pp. 69-100. Dalgleish, D.G. and Holt, C. (1988). A geometric model to describe the initial aggregation of partially renneted casein micelles. J. Colloid Interf. Sci. 123, 80-84. Dalgleish, D.G. and Law, A.J.R. (1988). pH-induced dissociation of bovine casein micelles. 1. Analysis of liberated caseins. J. Dairy Res. 55,529-538. Dalgleish, D.G., Brinkhuis, J. and Payens, T.A.J. (1981a). The coagulation of differently sized micelles by rennet. Eur. J. Biochem. 119,257-261. Dalgleish, D.G., Payens, T.A.J. and Brinkhuis, J. (1981b). The rate constants for the aggregation of rennet-treated casein micelles. Neth. Milk Dairy J. 35,381-383. Dalgleish, D.G., Home, D.S. and Law, A.J.R. (1989). Size related differences in casein micelles. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 991,383-387. Danley, D.E. and Geoghegan, K.E (1988). Structure and mechanism of formation of chymosin C derived from recombinant chymosin A. J. Biol. Chem. 263, 9785-9789. Darling, D.E and Dickson, J. (1979). The determination of the zeta potential of casein micelles, J. Dairy Res. 46, 329-332. Darling, D.E and Van Hooydonk, A.C.M. (1981). Derivation of a mathematical model for the mechanism of casein micelle coagulation by rennet. J. Dairy Res. 48, 189-200. Davies, D.T. and Law, A.J.R. (1980). The content and composition of protein in creamery milks in south-west Scotland. J. Dairy Res. 47, 83-90. DeGennes, P. (1979). Scaling Concepts in Polymer Physics, Cornell University Press, Ithaca, New York. Dejmek, P. (1987). Dynamic rheology of rennet curd. J. Dairy Sci. 70, 1325-1330. De Kruif, C.G. (1999). Casein micelle interactions. Int. Dairy J. 9, 183-188. De Kruif, C.G. and Holt, C. (2003). Casein micelle structure, functions and interactions, in, Advanced Dairy Chemistry. I. Proteins, 3rd edn, Fox, P.E and McSweeney, P.L.H. eds, Kluwer, Dordrecht. pp. 233-276.
Rennet-induced Coagulation of Milk
De Kruif, C.G., Jeurnink, T.J.M. and Zoon, P. (1992). The viscosity of milk during the initial stages of renneting. Neth. Milk Dairy J. 46, 123-137. Desobry-Banon, S., Richard, E and Hardy, J. (1994). Study of acid and rennet coagulation of high pressurized milk. J. Dairy Sci. 77, 3267-3274. Dickinson, E. (2003). Colloidal aggregation: mechanisms and implications, in, Food Colloids: Biopolymers and Materials, Dickinson, E. and Van Vliet, T. eds, Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge. pp. 68-83. Dickinson, E., Horne, D.S., Pinfield, V.J. and Leermakers, EA.M. (1997a). Self-consistent-field modelling of casein adsorption. Comparison of results for OLsl-casein and [B-casein. J. Chem. Soc. Faraday 93,425-432. Dickinson, E., Horne, D.S., Pinfield, V.J. and Leermakers, EA.M. (1997b). Self-consistent-field modelling of casein adsorption. Interactions between two protein-coated surfaces. J. Chem. Soc. Faraday 93, 1785-1790. Douillard, R. (1973). Rheological analysis of curd formation. J. Texture Studies 4, 158-165. Dronse, H.B. and Fohmann, B. (1989). Specificity of milk clotting enzymes towards bovine K-casein. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 995,221-224. Emmons, D.B., Beckett, D.C. and Binns, M. (1990a). Cheese yield experiments and proteolysis by milk-clotting enzymes. J. Dairy Sci. 73, 2028-2043. Emmons, D.B., Beckett, D.C. and Binns, M. (1990b). Milk clotting enzymes. I. Proteolysis during cheesemaking in relation to estimated losses of yield. J. Dairy Sci. 73, 2007-2015. Esteves, C.L., Verissimo, P.C., Faro, C.J. and Pires, E.V. (1995). Biochemical characteristics of the vegetable rennets from the flowers of cardoon: Comparison to calf rennet. J. Dairy Sci. 78 (Suppl. 1), 145. Esteves, C.L.C., Lucey, J.A. and Pires, E.M.V. (2001). Mathematical modelling of the formation of rennet-induced gels by plant coagulants and chymosin. J. Dairy Res. 68, 499-510. Esteves, C.L.C., Lucey, J.A. and Pires, E.M.V. (2002). Rheological properties of milk gels made with coagulants of plant origin and chymosin. Int. Dairy J. 12,427-434. Farrell Jr, H.M., Kumosinski, T.E, Pulaski, E and Thompson, M.P. (1988). Calcium-induced associations of the caseins a thermodynamic linkage approach to precipitation and resolubilization. Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 265,146-158. Farrell Jr, H.M., Wickham, E.D., Unruh, J.J., Qi, P.X. and Hoagland, P.D. (2001). Secondary structural studies of bovine caseins: temperature dependence of [3-casein structure as analyzed by circular dichrosm and FTIR spectroscopy and correlation with micellization. Food Hydrocolloids 15,341-354. Foltmann, B. (1959). On the enzymatic and coagulation stages of the renneting process. Proc. 15th Int. Dairy Congr. (London) 2,655-661. Foltrnann, B. (1971). The biochemistry of prorennin (prochymosin) and rennin (chyrnosin), in, Milk Proteins: Chemistry and Molecular Biology II, McKenzie, H.A. ed., Academic Press, New York. pp. 217-254. (Quotes Segeleke, T. and Storch, V. (1870). Ugeskrift Landmaend, -
67
Ser 3.9, 341. Segeleke, T. and Storch, V. (1874). Milchzeitung 3,997.) Foltmann, B. (1992). Chymosin: A short review on foetal and neonatal gastric proteases. Scand. J. Clin. Lab. Invest. 52 (Suppl. 210), 65-79. Fox, P.E and McSweeney, ELM. (1997). Rennets: their role in milk coagulation and cheese ripening, in, Microbiology and Biochemistry of Cheese and Fermented Milk, 2nd edn, Law, B.A. and Davies, EL. eds, Blackie Academic and Professional, London. pp. 1-48. Gaucheron, E, Famelart, M.H., Mariette, E, Raulot, K., Michel, E and Le Graet, Y. (1997). Combined effects of temperature and high-pressure treatments on physicochemical characteristics of skim milk. Food Chem. 59, 439-447. Green, M.L. and Crutchfield, G. (1971). Density gradient electrophoresis of native and rennet-treated casein micelles.J. Dairy Res. 38, 151-164. Green, M.L. and Grandison, A.S. (1993). Secondary (nonenzymatic) phase of rennet coagulation and post-coagulation phenomenon, in, Cheese: Chemistry, Physics and Microbiology, Fox, P.E ed., Chapman & Hall, London. pp. 101-140. Green, M.L., Hobbs, D.G., Morant, S.V. and Hill, V.A. (1978). Intermicellar relationships in rennet-treated separated milk. II. Process of gel assembly. J. Dairy Res. 45, 413-422. Green, M.L., Angal, S., Lowe, P.A. and Marston, EA.O. (1985). Cheddar cheesemaking with recombinant calf chymosin synthesised in Escherichia coll. J. Dairy Res. 52, 281-286. Griffin, M.C.A., Lyster, R.L.J. and Price, J.C. (1988). The disaggregation of calcium-depleted micelles. Eur. J. Biochem. 174, 339-343. Guinee, T. and Wilkinson, M. (1992). Rennet coagulation and coagulants used in cheese manufacture. J. Soc. Dairy Technol. 45, 94-104. Guthy, K. and Novak, G. (1977). Observations on the primary phase of milk coagulation by rennet under standardized conditions. J. Dairy Res. 44, 363-366. Harboe, M.K. (1992). Chymogen, a chymosin rennet manufactured by fermentation of Aspergillus niger. Bulletin 269, International Dairy Federation, Brussels. pp. 3-7. Harboe, M. and Budtz, P. (1999). The production, action and application of rennet and coagulants, in, Technology of Cheesemaking, Law, B.A. ed., Sheffield Academic Press, UK. pp. 33-65. Hardy, J. and Fanni, J. (1981). Application of reflection photometry to the measurement of milk coagulation. J. Food Sci. 46, 1956-1957. Hicks, C.L., O'Leary, J. and Bucy, J. (1988). Use of recombinant chymosin in the manufacture of Cheddar and Colby cheese.J. Dairy Sci. 71, 1127-1131. Hill, R.D. (1968). The nature of the rennin sensitive bond in casein and its possible relation to sensitive bonds in other proteins. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 33, 659-663. Hill, R.D. (1969). Synthetic peptide and ester substrates for rennin.J. Dairy Res. 36,409-415.
68
Rennet-induced Coagulation of Milk
Holt, C. (1975). The stability of casein micelles, in, Proc. Int. Conf. Colloid Surface Science, Budapest, Vol. 1, Wolfram, E. ed., Akademia Kiado, Budapest. pp. 641-644. Holt, C. and Home, D.S. (1996). The hairy casein micelle: evolution of the concept and its implications for dairy technology. Neth. Milk Dairy J. 50, 85-111. Holt, C. and Sawyer, L. (1993). Caseins as rheomorphic proteins. J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. 83, 2683-2690. Hoher, H. (1932). Uber die labwirkung. Biochem. Z. 255, 160-188. Hori, T. (1985). Objective measurement of the process of curd formation during rennet treatment of milk by the hot wire method. J. Food Sci. 50, 911-917. Home, D.S. (1995). Scaling behaviour of shear moduli during the formation of rennet milk gels, in, Food Macromolecules and Colloids, Dickinson, E. and Lorient, D. eds, Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge. pp. 456-461. Home, D.S. (1996). Aspects of scaling behaviour in the kinetics of particle gel formation. J. Chimie Phys. Phys.chimie Biol., 93,977-986. Home, D.S. (1998). Casein interactions: casting light on the black boxes, the structure in dairy products. Int. Dairy J. 8, 171-177. Home, D.S. (2001). Factors influencing acid-induced gelation of skim milk, in, Food Colloids: Fundamentals of Formulation, Dickinson, E. and Miller, R., eds, Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge. pp. 345-351. Horne, D.S. (2002). Casein structure, self-assembly and gelation. Curr. Opin. Colloid. Interf. Sci. 7,456-461. Home, D.S. (2003). Casein micelles as hard spheres: limitations of the model in acidified gel formation. Colloids Surf. A: Physicochem. Eng. Aspects 213, 255-263. Home, D.S. and Davidson, C.M. (1993). Direct observation of decrease in size of casein micelles during initial stages of renneting of skim milk. Int. Dairy J. 3, 61-71. Home, D.S. and Leaver, J. (1995). Milk proteins on surfaces. Food Hydrocolloids 9, 91-95. Huppertz, T., Kelly, A.L. and Fox, P.E (2002). Effects of high pressure on constituents and properties of milk. Int. Dairy J. 12,561-572. Hyslop, D.B. (1989). Enzymatically initiated coagulation of casein micelles: a kinetic model. Neth. Milk Dairy J. 43, 163-170. Hyslop, D.B. (1993). Enzyme-induced coagulation of casein micelles: a number of different kinetic models. J. Dairy Res. 60, 517-533. Hyslop, D.B. (2003). Enzymatic coagulation of milk, in, Advanced Dairy Chemistry. I. Proteins, 3rd edn, Fox, RE and McSweeney, P.L.H. eds, Kluwer, Dordrecht. pp. 835-874. Hyslop, D.B. and Qvist, K.B. (1996). Application of numerical analysis to a number of models for chymosininduced coagulation of casein micelles. J. Dairy Res. 63, 223-232. Imafidon, G.I. and Farkye, N.Y. (1993). Composition of Cheddar cheese made from high-heat treated milk, in, Cheese Yield and Factors Affecting Its Control: Special Issue 940, International Dairy Federation, Brussels. pp. 433-438. Kolb, M., Botet, R. and Jullien, R. (1983). Scaling of kinetically growing clusters. Phys. Rev. Lett. 51, 1123-1126.
Law, AJ.R., Leaver, J., Felipe, X., Ferragut, V., Pla, R. and Guamis, B. (1998). Comparisons of the effects of high pressure and thermal treatments on the casein micelles in goats milk. J. Agric. Food Chem. 46, 2523-2530. Leaver, J., Law, A.J.R., Home, D.S. and Banks, J.M. (1995). Influence of heating regime and pH on the primary phase of renneting of whole milk. Int. Dairy J. 5,129-140. Lin, H.Y., Lindsay, H.M., Weitz, D.A., Ball, R.C., Klein, R. and Meakin, P. (1990). Universal reaction-limited colloid aggregation. Phys. Rev. A 41, 2005-2020. Lomholt, S.B. and Qvist, K.B. (1997). Relationship between rheological properties and degree of K-casein proteolysis during renneting of milk. J. Dairy Res. 64, 541-549. Lomhoh, S.B. and Qvist, K.B. (1999). The formation of cheese curd, in, The Technology of Cheesemaking, B.A. Law, ed., Sheffield Academic Press, Sheffield, UK. pp. 66-98. Lomholt, S.B., Worning, P., g)gendal, L., Qvist, K.B., Hyslop, D.B. and Bauer, R. (1998). Kinetics of renneting reaction followed by measurement of turbidity as a function of wavelength. J. Dairy Res. 65,545-554. Lopez, M.B., Lomhoh, S.B. and Qvist, K.B. (1998). Rheological properties and cutting time of rennet gels: effect of pH and enzyme concentration. Int. Dairy J. 8, 289-293. Lopez-Fandino, R. and Olano, A. (1998). Effects of high pressures combined with moderate temperatures on the rennet coagulation properties of milk. Int. Dairy J. 8,623-627. Lopez-Fandino, R., Carracosa, A.V. and Olano, A. (1996). The effects of high pressure on whey protein denaturation and cheesemaking properties of raw milk. J. Dairy Sci. 79,929-936. Lopez-Fandino, R., Ramos, M. and Olano, A. (1997). Rennet coagulation of milk subjected to high pressures. J. Agric. Food Chem. 45, 3233-3237. Lopez-Fandino, R., de la Fuente, M.A., Ramos, M. and Olano, A. (1998). Distribution of minerals and proteins between the soluble and colloidal phases of pressurised milks from different species. J. Dairy Res. 65, 69-78. Lucey, J.A. (2002). Formation and physical properties of milk protein gels. J. Dairy Sci. 85,281-294. Lucey, J.A. and Kelly, J. (1994). Cheese yield. J. Soc. Dairy Technol. 47, 1-14. McGann, T.C.A. and Fox, P.E (1974). Physico-chemical properties of casein micelles reformed from urea-treated milk. J. Dairy Res. 41, 45-53. Meakin, P. (1983). Formation of fractal clusters and networks by irreversible diffusion-limited aggregation. Phys. Rev. Lett. 51, 1119-1122. Mellema, M. (2000). Scaling Relations between Structure and Rheology of Ageing Casein Particle Gels. PhD Thesis, Wageningen University, Wageningen, The Netherlands. Mellema, M., Heesakkers, J.W.M., Van Opheusden, J.H.J. and Van Vliet, T. (2000). Structure and scaling behaviour of aging rennet-induced casein gels examined by confocal microscopy and permeametry. Langmuir 16, 6847-6854. Mellema, M., Walstra, P., Van Opheusden, J.H.J. arid Van Vliet, T. (2002). Effects of structural rearrangements on the rheology of rennet-induced casein particle gels. Adv. Colloid Interf. Sci. 98, 25-50.
Rennet-induced Coagulation of Milk
Mercier, J.C. (1981). Phosphorylation of caseins: present evidence for an amino acid triplet code posttranslationally recognized by specific kinases. Biochimie 63, 1-17. Morrissey, P.A. (1969). The rennet hysteresis of heated milk. J. Dairy Res. 36,333-341. Needs, E.C., Stenning, R.A., Gill, A.L., Ferragut, V. and Rich, G.T. (2000). High pressure treatment of milk: effects on casein micelle structure and on enzymic coagulation. J. Dairy Res. 67, 31-42. Niki, R., Kim, G.Y., Kimura, T., Takahashi, K., Kohyama, K. and Nishinari, K. (1994). Physical properties of gels and microstructure of rennet gels from casein micelles of different sizes. Milchwissenschaft 49,325-329. O'Callaghan, D.J., O'Donnell, C.P. and Payne, EA. (2002). Review of systems for monitoring curd setting during cheesemaking. Int. J. Dairy Technol. 55, 65-74. Olson, N.E (1977). Factors affecting cheese yields. Dairy Ind. Int. 42, 14-15, 19. O'Reilly, C.E., Kelly, A., Murphy, P.M. and Beresford, T.P. (2001). High pressure treatment: applications in cheese manufacture and ripening. Trends Food Sci. Technol. 12, 51-59. Parker, T.G. and Dalgleish, D.G. (1981). Binding of calcium ions to bovine [3-casein. J. Dairy Res. 48, 71-76. Payens, T.A.J. (1976). On the enzyme-triggered clotting of casein: a preliminary account. Neth. Milk Dairy J. 30, 55-59. Payens, T.A.J. (1977). On enzymatic clotting processes. II. The colloidal instability of chymosin-treated casein micelles. Biophys. Chem. 6, 263-270. Payens, T.A.J. (1979). Casein micelles: the colloid-chemical approach. J. Dairy Res. 46, 291-306. Payens, T.A.J. (1989). The enzyme-triggered coagulation of casein micelles. Adv. Colloid Interf. Sci. 30, 31-69. Payens, T.A.J. and Brinkhuis, J. (1986). Mean-field kinetics of the enzyme-triggered gelation of casein micelles. Colloids Surf. 20, 31-69. Payens, T.A.J., Brinkhuis, J.A. and Van Markwijk, B.W. (1969). Self-association in non-ideal systems. Combined light-scattering and sedimentation measurements in [3-casein solutions. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 175, 434-437. Payens, T.A.J., Wiersma, A.K. and Brinkhuis, J. (1977). On enzymatic clotting processes. 1. Kinetics of enzymetriggered coagulation reactions. Biophys. Chem. 6, 253-261. Pearse, K.N. (1976). Moving boundary electrophoresis of native and rennet-treated casein micelles. J. Dairy Res. 43, 27-36. Raymond, M.N., Garnier, J., Bricas, E., Cilianu, S., Blasnic, M., Chain, A. and Lefrancier, P. (1972). Studies on the specificity of chymosin (rennin). I. Kinetic parameters of the hydrolysis of synthetic oligopeptide substrates. Biochimie 54, 145-154. Roefs, S.P.EM. (1985). Structure of Acid Casein Gels. PhD Thesis, Wageningen Agricultural University, Wageningen, The Netherlands. Ross Murphy, S.B. (1995). Rheological characterization of gels. J. Texture Studies 26, 391-400. Schmidt, D.G. (1970). The association of C~sl-casein at pH 6.6. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 207, 130-138.
69
Scott Blair, G.W. and Burnett, J. (1958). Physical changes in milk caused by the action of rennet..1. Dairy Res. 25, 297-303. Scott Blair, G.W. and Oosthuizen, J.C. (1961). A viscometric study of the breakdown of casein in milk by rennin and rennet. J. Dairy Res. 28, 165-173. Shammet, K.M., Brown, R.J. and McMahon, D.J. (1992). Proteolytic activity of some milk-clotting enzymes on K-casein. J. Dairy Sci. 75, 1373-1379. Shih, W.H., Shih, W.Y., Kim, S.I., Liu, J. and Aksay, I.A. (1990). Scaling behaviour of the elastic properties of colloidal gels. Phys. Rev. A 42, 4772-4779. Singh, H. and Waungana, A. (2001). Influence of heat treatment of milk on cheesemaking properties. Int. Dairy J. 11, 543-551. Sousa, M.J., Ardo, Y. and McSweeney, P.L.H. (2001). Advances in the study of proteolysis during cheese ripening, Int. Dairy J. 11,327-343. Stauffer, D. (1976). Gelation in concentrated critically branched polymer solutions. Percolation theory of intramolecular bond cycles. J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. II 72, 1354-1364. Stockmayer, W.H. (1943). Theory of molecular size distribution and gel formation in branched chain polymers. J. Chem. Phys. 11, 45-55. Swaisgood, H.E. (1992). Chemistry of the caseins, in, Advanced Dairy Chemistry. 1. Proteins, P.E Fox, ed., Elsevier Applied Science, London. pp. 63-110. Syme, C.D., Blanch, E.W., Holt, C., Jakes, R., Goedert, M., Hecht, L. and Barron, L.D. (2002). A Raman optical activity study of rheomorphism in caseins, synucleins and tau: new insight into the structure and behaviour of natively unfolded proteins. Eur J. Biochem. 269, 148-156. Teuber, M. (1990). Production of chymosin (E.C.3.4.23.4) by microorganisms and its use for cheesemaking. Bulletin 251, International Dairy Federation, Brussels. pp. 3-15. Tokita, M. (1989). Gelation mechanism and percolation. Food Hydrocolloids 3,263-274. Tokita, M.K., Kikichi, R., Niki, R. and Arima, S. (1982). Dynamic viscoelastic studies on the mechanism of milk clotting process. Biorheology 19,209-219. Trujillo, A.J., Capellas, M., Buffa, M., Royo, C., Gervilla, R., Felipe, X., Sendra, E., Saldo, J., Ferragut, V. and Gaumis, B. (2000). Application of high pressure treatment for cheese production. Food Res. Int. 33, 311-316. Trujillo, A.J., Capellas, M., Saldo, J., Gervilla, R. and Guamis, B. (2002). Applications of high-hydrostatic pressure on milk and dairy products - a review. Innov. Food Sci. Emerg Technol. 3,295-307. Tuszynski, W.B. (1971). A kinetic model of the clotting of casein by rennet. J. Dairy Res. 38, 113-125. Ustinol, Z. and Hicks, C.L. (1990). Effect of milk clotting enzymes on cheese yield. J. Dairy Sci. 73, 8-19. Ustinol, Z., Hicks, C.L. and Payne, EA. (1991). Diffuse reflectance profiles of eight milk clotting enzyme preparations. J. Food Sci. 56, 411-415. Van den Berg, G. (1992). Fermentation produced chymosin: technological aspects of its use for cheesemaking. Bulletin 269, International Dairy Federation, Brussels. pp. 13-17.
70
Rennet-induced Coagulation of Milk
Van Hooydonk, A.C.M. and Walstra, P. (1987). Interpretation of the kinetics of the renneting reaction in milk. Neth. Milk DairyJ. 41, 19-47. Van Hooydonk, A.C.M., Boerrigter, IO. and Hagedoorn, H.G. (1986). pH-induced physico-chemical changes of casein micelles in milk and their effect on renneting. 1. Effect of pH on renneting of milk. Neth. Milk Dairy J. 40, 297-313. Van Hooydonk, A.C.M., de Koster, RC. and Boerrigter, IJ. (1987). The renneting properties of heated milk. Neth. Milk Dairy J. 41, 3-18. Van Vliet, T. and Walstra, P. (1985). Note on the shear modulus of rennet-induced milk gels. Neth. Milk DairyJ. 39, 115-118. Van Vliet, T., Van Dijk, HJ.M., Zoon, P. and Walstra, R (1991). Relation between syneresis and rheological properties of particle gels, Colloid Polym. Sci. 269,620-627. Verissimo, RC., Esteves, C.L.C., Faro, CJ.E and Pires, E.M.V. (1995). The vegetable rennet of Cyanara cardunculus L. contains two proteinases with chymosin and pepsin-like specificities. Biotechnol. Lett. 17,621-626. Verwey, EJ.W. and Overbeek, J.Th.G. (1948). Theory of Stability of Lyophobic Colloids, Elsevier, Amsterdam. Visser, S., Van Roijen, pJ. and Slangen, CJ. (1980). Peptide substrates for chymosin (rennin). Isolation and substrate behaviour of two tryptic fragments of bovine K-casein. Eur. J. Biochem. 108,415-421. Vreeman, H.J. (1979). The association of bovine SH-K-casein at pH 7.0. J. Dairy Res. 46, 271-276. Vreeman, H.J., Both, P., Brinkhuis, J.A. and Van der Spek, C. (1977). Purification and some physicochemical properties of bovine K-casein. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 491, 93-103. Vreeman, H.J., Visser, S., Slangen, C.J. and Van Riel, J.A.M. (1986). Characterization of bovine K-casein fractions and the kinetics of chymosin-induced macropeptide release from carbohydrate-free and carbohydrate-containing fractions determined by high performance gel permeation chromatography. Biochem. J. 240, 87-97. Walstra, P. (1979). The voluminosity of casein micelles and some of its implication. J. Dairy Res. 46, 317-323. Walstra, P. and Van Vliet, T. (1986). The physical chemistry of curd making. Neth. Milk Dairy J. 40, 241-259. Walstra, P., Bloomfield, V.A., Wei, G.J. and Jenness, R. (1981). Effect of chymosin action on the hydrodynamic
diameter of casein micelles. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 669, 258-259. Waungana, A., Singh, H. and Bennett, R.J. (1996). Influence of denaturation and aggregation of beta-lactoglobulin on rennet coagulation properties of skim milk and ultrafiltered milk. Food Res. Int. 29,715-721. Whitney, R.McL. (1988). Proteins of milk, in, Fundamentals of Dairy Chemistry, 3rd edn, N.E Wong, ed., Avi Books, Van Norstrand Reinhold, New York. pp. 81-169. Wigley, R.C. (1996). Cheese and whey, in, Industrial Enzymology, 2nd edn, T. Godfrey and S. West, eds, MacMillan Press, London. pp. 133-154. Winter, H.H. and Chambon, E (1986). Analysis of crosslinked polymer at the gel-point. J. Rheology 30, 367-382. Worning, P., Bauer, R., Ogendal, L. and Lomhoh, S. (1998). A novel approach to turbidimetry of dense systems. An investigation of the enzymatic gelation of casein micelles. J. Colloid Interf. Sci. 203,265-277. Zevaco, C. and Ribadeau-Dumas, B. (1984). A study of the carbohydrate binding sites of bovine K-casein using high performance liquid chromatography. Milchwissenschaft 39, 206-210. Ziff, R.M. (1980). Kinetics of polymerization. J. Stat. Phys. 23, 241-263. Ziff, R.M. and Stell, G. (1982). Kinetics of polymer gelation. J. Chem. Phys. 73, 3492-3499. Zoon, P., Van Vliet, T. and Walstra, P. (1988a). Rheological properties of rennet-induced skim milk gels. 1. Introduction. Neth. Milk Dairy J. 42,249-269. Zoon, P., Van Vliet, T. and Walstra, P. (1988b). Rheological properties of rennet-induced skim milk gels. 2. Effect of temperature. Neth. Milk Dairy J. 42,271-294. Zoon, P., Van Vliet, T. and Walstra, P. (1988c). Rheological properties of rennet-induced skim milk gels. 3. Effect of calcium and phosphate. Neth. Milk Dairy J. 42, 295-312. Zoon, E, Van Vliet, T. and Walstra, E (1989a). Rheological properties of rennet-induced skim milk gels. 4. The effect of pH and NaCI. Neth. Milk Dairy J. 43, 17-34. Zoon, E, Van Vliet, T. and Walstra, P. (1989b). Rheological properties of rennet-induced skim milk gels. 5. Behaviour at large deformation. Neth. Milk Dairy J. 43, 35-42.
The Syneresis of Rennet-coagulated Curd P. Dejmek, Department of Food Engineering, Lund University, Lund, Sweden P. Walstra, Department of Agrotechnology and Food Sciences, Wageningen University, Wageningen, The Netherlands
Introduction Gels formed from milk by renneting or acidification under quiescent conditions may subsequently show syneresis, i.e., expel liquid (whey), because the gel (curd) contracts. Under quiescent conditions, a rennetinduced milk gel may lose two-thirds of its volume, and up to 90%, or even more, if external pressure is applied. Often, syneresis is undesired, e.g., during storage of products like yoghurt, sour cream, cream cheese or quark; hence, it is useful to know under what conditions syneresis can be (largely) prevented. In making cheese from renneted or acidified milk, syneresis is an essential step. Consequently, it is useful to understand and quantitatively describe syneresis as a function of milk properties and process conditions, particularly when new methods or process steps are introduced in cheesemaking. This concerns several aspects: 9 regulation of the water content of the cheese implies controlling syneresis; 9 the rate of syneresis affects the method of processing, and thereby the equipment and time needed, and the losses of fat and protein in the whey; 9 rate of syneresis in relation to other changes (e.g., acidification, proteolysis, inactivation of rennet enzymes) affects cheese composition and properties; 9 the way in which syneresis of curd grains proceeds may affect the propensity of the grains to fuse into a continuous mass during shaping and/or pressing; 9 differences in syneresis throughout a mass of curd cause differences in the composition of the cheese between loaves of one batch and between sites in one loaf; 9 after a cheese loaf has been formed, it may still show syneresis and hence loss of moisture.
(based on Chapter 5 in the 2nd edition of 'Cheese: Chemistry, Physics and Microbiology', P.E Fox, ed., Chapman & Hall, London 1993, by P. Walstra, revised and updated by P. Dejmek).
(Note: throughout this chapter we will use the word 'moisture' for any liquid that may move through curd or cheese; it is thus generally an aqueous solution and not just water). Thus, the importance of syneresis is obvious. Accordingly, numerous research reports have been published, providing many important data on the influence of various factors on the rate, and sometimes on the end-point, of syneresis. However, the results vary considerably according to the conditions during the test method employed and are difficult to interpret. Grounds to a deeper understanding of syneresis were laid in the late 1980s and early 1990s (van Dijk, 1982; van den Bijgaart, 1988; Akkerman, 1992; Walstra et al., 1985). Recent overviews were given by van Vliet and Walstra (1994) and Lucey (2001).
Gel Formation and Properties The casein micelle
As shown in 'Rennet-induced Coagulation of Milk', the caseins of milk occur under physiological conditions as large polydisperse aggregates, i.e., casein micelles, up to 0.5 lxm. Details of the internal structure of the micelles are still being discussed, but there is little doubt that the existence of this aggregated state is dependent on hydrophobic interactions and on calcium phosphate nanoclusters connected to the phosphoserines of the individual casein molecules. The solution stability of the micelles is dependent on the presence of charged groups and steric stabilization (Walstra, 1990). Both of these can be manipulated in dairy processing with the aim of destabilizing the micelles and promoting further aggregation of the caseins. The aggregation may lead to a gel and then to gel shrinkage, syneresis. Most of the K-casein of the micelles is at the surface and the strongly hydrophilic C-terminal part of these molecules apparently sticks out from the micelle surface as a flexible chain that perpetually changes its conformation by Brownian motion (Walstra and Jenness, 1984), thereby causing steric repulsion, though only a third of
Cheese: Chemistry, Physics and Microbiology, Third edition - Volume 1: General Aspects ISBN: 0-1226-3652-X Set ISBN: 0-1226-3651-1
Copyright 9 2004 Elsevier Ltd All rights reserved
72 The Syneresis of Rennet-coagulated Curd the surface appears to be covered by K-casein (Dalgleish, 1998). The micelles are thus said to be 'hairy'. They also have a negative charge, causing electrostatic repulsion between them. Steric and electrostatic repulsion provide complete stability of the micelles against aggregation under physiological conditions. There are multiple dynamic equilibria between caseins, and different forms of calcium and phosphate in the micelles and in the solution. The micelles may change considerably due to changes in their environment. At low temperatures, a part of the casein, especially [3-casein, goes into solution and additional 'hairs' of partly protruding [3-casein molecules are presumably formed. A small part of the micellar calcium phosphate also goes into solution. The micelles attain a higher voluminosity (i.e., they swell). These changes are reversible, although it is not quite certain that the micelles regain exactly their native structure after cooling and rewarming. At high temperatures, the amount of micellar calcium phosphate increases somewhat. At temperatures high enough for serum proteins to denature, association of denatured serum proteins with the micelles occurs, to an extent greatly dependent on p H the lower the pH, the stronger the association. Lowering the pH causes considerable change. Some trends are illustrated in Fig. 1; in as far as it concerns properties of a rennet gel, these are discussed later. The main change is that micellar calcium and phosphate go into solution, thereby loosening the bonds keeping the micelles together. This leads to dissolution of casein, especially at low temperature. At still lower pH, electrostatic bonds between positive and negative groups on the caseins keep the micelles together, and at the isoelectric pH, these bonds are quite strong, again. In fact, the casein particles at this pH are very different from the micelles at physiological conditions, although their size distribution has not changed greatly (Roefs et al., 1985). It should also be noted that a lower pH in milk leads to a higher calcium ion activity, which also lowers the negative charge on the micelles. Starting at about pH 5 (Vasbinder et al., 2001) and at not too low a temperature, the casein particles begin to aggregate; electrostatic repulsion is now absent and the K-casein hairs, which provide steric repulsion, are also lost (they are presumably 'curled up'). Addition of calcium at a constant pH to milk reduces the negative charge on the micelles and increases the amount of micellar phosphate. This reduces the stability of the micelles and high levels of added calcium cause their aggregation.
Renneting During the renneting of milk, the proteolytic enzymes in the rennet (mainly chymosin) hydrolyse the K-casein molecules to para-K-casein and soluble caseino-
% 4O1 / 0_ -((mY)
300C
r
lo-
~
,, ~
/ 001
O-
I i
soo
',
20 oc
tan~5 0 . 4 - ~ 0oC [
4.5
T
5.5 pH
1
I
6.5
Figure 1 The proportion of calcium (Ca) and inorganic phosphate (Pin) and the electro-kineticpotential(~) of casein micelles, as wellas the dynamic shear modulus (G', frequency 1 s-l) and the loss tangent (tan 6, frequency 0.01 s -1) of rennet-induced skim milk gels, as a function of pH (from Walstra, 1990).
macropeptides (the C-terminal region), thereby largely removing the hairs and greatly reducing steric and electrostatic repulsion. The micelles can now approach one another closely and it is observed that they flocculate, i.e., remain close together. The kinetics of renneting is intricate since two reactions are involved. The enzymic reaction is essentially first order and the flocculation can be described, in principle, by Smoluchowski kinetics (van Hooydonk and Walstra, 1987). The caseinomacropeptide segments are removed from the micelles one by one (a micelle contains in the order of 1000 K-casein molecules, and the number of micelles is roughly 100 times the number of chymosin molecules normally added to cheese milk). Consequently, the reactivity of the micelles, i.e., the probability that micelles which encounter each other will become flocculated, at first remains low but strongly increases as a greater proportion of the K-casein has been hydrolysed (see also Fig. 2). The reactivity is roughly an inverse exponential function of the concentration of unhydrolysed K-casein molecules on the
The Syneresis of Rennet-coagulated Curd
100
f
0 0
j
I
20
I
40
Time (min)
Figure 2 Approximate example of the changes that occur in milk after adding rennet. Degree of hydrolysis of K-casein (S), aggregation of para-casein micelles as measured by viscosity (V) and shear modulus (G) of the gel formed as a percentage of the values after 40 min, as a function of time.
micelles. As long as less than about 70% is hydrolysed, the flocculation rate is virtually zero, at least at physiological pH and 30 ~ If the pH is lowered, the enzymic reaction becomes much faster and, moreover, flocculation starts at a lower proportion of hydrolysed K-casein molecules (van Hooydonk et al., 1986). It appears that at low pH, the chymosin becomes adsorbed onto the micelles and this causes the hydrolysis of the K-casein to be not quite random any more. Presumably, a chymosin molecule now often makes a 'bare' patch on the micelle before becoming desorbed and diffusing away, to find another (or possibly the same) micelle on which to act. At such a bare spot, the micelle is reactive. This implies that at a lower pH, flocculation starts at a stage where less K-casein has been hydrolysed. The reactivity of fully renneted micelles, i.e., those that are fully converted into paracasein micelles, depends little on pH, increases with Ca 2+ concentration, decreases with increasing ionic strength (NaC1) and increases markedly with temperature, especially from 15 to 30 ~ (Dalgleish, 1983). Above 50 ~ the flocculation rate becomes almost independent of temperature, being roughly equal to that predicted by Smoluchowski's equation for diffusion-controlled coagulation (Dalgleish, 1983). The temperature dependence is often taken as indicative of hydrophobic interactions being responsible for the reaction between the para-casein micelles (Dalgleish, 1983). An alternative explanation is that with decreasing temperature only the activation free energy for flocculation increases, presumably because of protrusion of [3-casein chains. Gel formation
After a while, flocculation leads to the formation of a gel (see Fig. 2). Microscopically, one can observe that aggregates are formed, at first irregular, but often
73
somewhat thread-like; these grow to form large tenuous flocs, until they start to touch and form a continuous network (Mulder etal., 1966; Henstra and Schmidt, 1970; Walstra et al., 1985). Electron microscopy reveals (e.g., Kalab and Harwalkar, 1973; Knoop and Peters, 1975a; Green et al., 1978) that the network can be described as consisting of strands of micelles, 1-4 micelles thick and some 10 micelles long, alternated by thicker nodes of micelles and leaving openings up to 10 I~m in diameter. The essential requirement for gel formation is of course a thermodynamic instability of the system, i.e., an attraction between the particles high enough (relative to thermal energy) to bring about the formation of a condensed phase at the existing particle volume fraction. Gels are typically formed in systems where the range of the interparticle attraction is short compared to particle size. In addition to short range, the attraction needs to be sufficiently strong. A weak attraction allows the particles to asociate and dissociate until they find a position binding with many neighbours, and thus form a compact aggregate. When the attraction is sufficiently large, particles will stick at first contact, and a ramified structure may span the entire system, provided that the kinetics of aggregation is faster than the sedimentation of the aggregates formed. The topology of the resulting network can readily be described by the theory of 'fractal' aggregation (Family and Landau, 1984; Meakin, 1988). For particle gel formation, the fractal mechanism was pointed out in a qualitative sense by Walstra et al. (1985) and quantitatively applied to the flocculation of casein particles by Bremer and coworkers (Bremer et al., 1989, 1990; Walstra et al., 1990; Bremer, 1992). The current view of fractal particle gels in foods was summarized by Walstra (2000). Assuming random aggregation of particles and of aggregates already formed (called cluster-cluster aggregation), computer simulations show the aggregates formed to be stochastic fractals, i.e., structures that are on average scale-invariant at scales larger than that of the primary particles (radius a). The number of particles in an aggregate or floc is given by: Na -
(1)
where R is the radius of the floc and D the fractal dimensionality, which is always smaller than three. This implies that the floc becomes ever more tenuous as it becomes larger; computer simulations show rarefied structures, consisting mainly of long irregular strands of particles, which are in most places only one particle thick. Equation (1) has been shown to hold
74
The Syneresis of Rennet-coagulated Curd
remarkably well over a wide range of R and under many conditions, both in simulations and experiments; colloidal interaction forces and geometrical constraints determine the value of D. The number of particles that could be present in a floc if the particles were closely packed, obviously is:
This implies that the average volume fraction of particles in a floc is given by:
qbfl~ = Na
(3)
The average volume fraction of the flocs thus decreases during flocculation, and when it has reached the volume fraction of particles in the system, qb (for para-casein micelles at 30 ~ about 0.09), the flocs fill the total space available and a gel has formed. It also follows that the average radius of the flocs at the moment of gelation is given by: Rgel = a cJSI/(D- 3)
(4)
In the above derivation, it has been implicitly assumed that flocculation proceeds undisturbed. But if the liquid is stirred during flocculation, gel formation may be hindered. Another disturbance may be appreciable sedimentation of the flocs occurring before a gel can be formed. The casein micelles in milk are small enough, and differ little enough in density from the milk serum, for sedimentation to be negligible. It may thus be assumed that under normal renneting conditions, gel formation occurs unhindered. If equal-sized spherical particles flocculate in Brownian motion and if each encounter leads to lasting contact (so-called diffusion-limited cluster-cluster aggregation), the fractal dimensionality turns out to be about 1.8. Several deviations from this simplest model, for instance a situation (as during renneting) in which only a certain small proportion of the encounters of particles leads to their lasting contact (so-called chemically limited aggregation), or rearrangements occurring in the floc structure, lead to higher D values. Moreover, during gel formation, the flocs interpenetrate to some extent and this also causes a higher dimensionality. One type of change that certainly does occur in the flocs is a rearrangement of just-flocculated particles in such a way that each particle will touch more than two other particles; this leads, in principle, to strands of thickness of
about three particles rather than one (Meakin, 1988). This is in agreement with microscopical observations on casein gels (Bremer, 1992). Such a rearrangement does not detract from the initial fractal nature of the flocs or the gel formed from the flocs. Brownian dynamics is a tool which has been used to probe theoretically how different choices of interaction potentials can affect the properties of the gel network (Bijsterbosch etal., 1995; Bos and van Opheusden, 1996; Mellema et al., 1999; Dickinson, 2000; Rzepiela et al., 2001). The findings modulate the simple irreversible fractal description; the low cut-off of the fractal regime, i.e., the size of the building block typically increases in time, and the fractal dimension may depend on both the interactions and the volume fraction. For low-capture efficiency, the fractal dimensionality tends to 2.35 (Walstra, 2000; Mellema et al., 2002b). For real casein gels, volume fractal dimensions have been determined experimentally by a variety of methods, including wavelength dependence of turbidity, angle dependence of light scattering and analysis of electron or confocal microscopy images. The values most commonly found are D = 2.2-2.4 (Bremer et al., 1989, 1990; de Kruif et al., 1995; Mellema et al., 2000). The experimental values of D obtained are, however, much dependent on the evaluation procedure (Mellema et al., 2000) and the assumptions involved in interpretation of the experimental data (Bushell et al., 2002). Worning et al. (1998) questioned the validity of the turbidity approach, and the same group found by light scattering, D = 2 (Lehner et al., 1999). Assuming the radius of para-casein micelles to be 55 nm and their volume fraction in milk to be 0.09, it is calculated that the average radius of the flocs at the onset of gelation is about 2.5 Ixm and that these flocs contain several thousand para-casein micelles. There is, however, considerable spread in these values within one gel, and the gel is thus fairly inhomogeneous (see Fig. 3). The average pore size in the gel is of the order of Rgel but some pores are larger. Average pore size is related to the permeability, B, in the equation of Darcy:
(5) which relates the superficial velocity, v, of a liquid of viscosity, r/, flowing through the gel due to a pressure gradient Vp. The permeability of a 'fractal' gel is, under some assumptions, given by: B = const, a2qD2/(D-3)
(6)
The constant is not easily calculated; it is much smaller than unity. For D = 2.3, the power of @ is about - 2 . 9
The Syneresis of Rennet-coagulated Curd
~
~
4~.~ .,
75
....
~ '
Figure 3 Optical sections, made by confocal scanning laser microscopy in fluorescent mode, of rennet-induced skim milk gels, aged for 1 h (top) or 18 h at 30 ~ The bars indicate 10 i*m (from Bremer, 1992).
(in agreement with experiments), which implies that the permeability of the gel depends strongly on the initial q5 and thus on casein concentration. A similar strong dependence on q~ holds for some other properties and for the size of the flocs at the onset of flocculation. Above, it has been tacitly assumed that skim milk is renneted. In the presence of fat globules, flocculation and gel formation proceed somewhat differently, but not greatly. The pores in the gel of para-casein micelles are roughly large enough (about 4 Ixm) and sufficient in number (about 2.1016 m -3) to accommodate the fat
globules (average diameter- about 3.4 lxm; number of globules larger than 1 I x m - 3.1015 m-3; Walstra and Jenness, 1984). Nevertheless, the pore size distribution in the gel is, of course, somewhat influenced by the presence of the fat globules, and most fat globules are entrapped in the gel. Rheological characteristics
The discussion will be based mainly on the extensive results of Zoon et al. (1988a,c, 1989a,b). A convenient and easily observed characteristic of a gel is its small
76
The Syneresis of Rennet-coagulated Curd
deformation modulus, i.e., the ratio of the applied stress over the resulting strain (relative deformation). Mostly, the dynamic shear modulus, G, is determined (which implies that the deformation type is simple shear) as a function of the frequency of deformation, a). Most gels are visco-elastic materials and these are characterized by two parameters. The storage modulus, G', is a measure of the true elastic property of the gel, the loss modulus, G", of the viscous property; G'7o) can be seen as a viscosity. We further have G 2 = G '2 + G ''2. In these dynamic measurements, the material is brought under an oscillating small strain, and G' and G" can be determined separately, each as a function of o0; the timescale of the deformation is about o)-1. Values of G are shown in Fig. 1. The moduli were observed to depend generally on a~ and to increase steeply with as, in agreement with the theory of fractal gels (Bremer et al., 1990; Bremer and van Vliet, 1991). The model predictions linking fractal dimensionality to rheological properties need to take into account the topology and the connectivity of the network, information which is not contained in the fractal dimensionality (Roberts and Knackstedt, 1996; Mellema et al., 2002a). An important parameter is the loss tangent (tan 8 = G"/G'), as it is a measure of the preponderance of viscous (or liquid-like) or over-elastic (or solid-like) properties of the gel. It is related to the relaxation of bonds in the gel during its deformation, and therefore it mostly increases with increasing timescale (decreasing oscillation frequency); this is because, in general, a greater proportion of the bonds that are under stress can relax when the timescale is longer. For rennet milk gels at physiological pH and 30 ~ tan ~ = 0.45 - 0.6 at ~o = 10 -3 s -I, i.e., under conditions relevant for syneresis. This implies that a rennet milk gel has a significant viscous component in its rheological behaviour. In accordance with this, it is observed that its relaxation time, i.e., the time needed for the stress to decrease to l/e of its initial value if a certain small deformation is applied to the material, is of the order of only 1 min. The loss tangent does not depend on casein concentration and is virtually independent of the age of the gel once formed. The modulus of the gel strongly increases after it is formed (see Fig. 2). Potentially, the increase could be
a
b
due to two phenomena. One is that additional junctions are formed between casein particles, partly because there are strands of particles that are attached to the gel at only one end, partly because additional casein particles and small clusters thereof become incorporated into the gel. The latter situation will always occur to some extent during the formation of a particulate gel, but more strongly during normal renneting, since at the moment of gel formation not all casein micelles have been fully transformed into paracasein micelles. However, only a negligible amount of free casein was found in the whey from a rennet milk gel quite early in the renneting process, at G less than 10% of its ultimate value (Mellema et al., 2002b), and similar values were found in simulations (Mellema et al. , 1999). The other p h e n o m e n o n is illustrated in Fig. 4, which is derived from electron microscopical studies (Knoop and Peters, 1975b). Any junction', by which is meant a contact region between two original micelles, must contain several bonds, and the number of bonds per junction increases on ageing. One may say that the micelles more or less fuse, and after some hours the original particles making up the gel can no longer be distinguished. If no starter is added and the proteolytic enzymes of milk have been inactivated, the increase in modulus continues for about 24 h (Zoon et al., 1988a). The lower the temperature, the slower and the longer-lasting is the increase in modulus. As mentioned, the increase in the number of bonds does not lead to a significant change in the loss tangent. For deformations (in shear) larger than about 3%, the rheological behaviour of developed rennet milk gels becomes non-linear; during the early stages of gel development, the linear range is wider. In curd-making practice, the stresses applied are often too large for linear behaviour. Figure 5 shows what happens when a relatively large stress is applied (Zoon et al., 1989b). After the instantaneous (elastic) response, the deformation soon becomes virtually viscous, i.e., dT/dt is constant. After some, often fairly long, time, the deformation rate increases and eventually becomes infinite- the gel fractures. Fracture does not mean falling into pieces, but rupture of the gel matrix o n l y - the cleft formed fills
c
d
Figure 4 Schematic picture of the change in conformation of flocculated para-casein micelles during ageing of the gel (from Walstra and van Vliet, 1986).
The Syneresis of Rennet-coagulated Curd
I
I
I
I
I
77
I
2
/
238 Pa
~
Pa
0
0
i
i
100
200
I
-1--
300
Time (s) Figure 5 Deformation in shear (~,) of a gel of renneted skim milk as a function of time, applying a constant stress. Temperature: 30 ~ pH" 6.65, gel aged for 3.5 h. The stress applied is indicated near the curves. At 35 Pa, fracture occurred after 1350 s (from results of Zoon et al., 1989b).
with whey immediately. Presumably, local fracture occurs already at an early stage, as soon as the linear deformation range is exceeded; the small cracks formed increase slowly in size and number, and coalesce until a fracture plane throughout the whole test piece has formed. This implies that long before macroscopic fracture, the gel structure has been altered markedly, which has been confirmed in loading-unloading experiments (Zoon et al., 1989b). Note that the shear at fracture is very large; values between 1 and 5 have been obtained (van Dijk, 1982; Zoon et al., 1989b), according to conditions. It is seen (Fig. 5) that a higher stress leads to smaller deformation at fracture and to a much shorter time than needed for fracture to occur. In other words, at a shorter timescale, the fracture stress is higher. Like the modulus, the fracture stress increases with ageing of the gel. The results of experiments at large deformations depend on the type of test applied (e.g., creep or dynamic), but the same trends are observed. Attempts to gain insights into the causal relationships between the range and the strength of forces between particles and network flow behaviour are being made by simulations (Whittle and Dickinson, 1998; Dickinson, 2000; Rzepiela et al., 2002). Temperature has a big effect on gel properties (Zoon et al., 1988b, 1989b). One should, however, distinguish between temperature of renneting and of measuring rheological properties. If renneting is at a lower temperature, gel formation is much slower and the modulus of the gel may consequently be smaller when measured at the same time, but this is not a true representation of the effect of temperature on gel properties. Lowering the
temperature of a formed rennet milk gel generally causes a very brief decrease in modulus, but the latter subsequently starts to increase to reach a constant higher level after, say, 1 h. At co = 10 -3 s -1, the storage modulus at 20 ~ is about 2.4 times that at 30 ~ From the effect of temperature on the loss tangent it is seen that a rennet milk gel is much more solid-like at lower temperatures; similar behaviour could be seen even in a non-renneted, centrifuged pellet of casein micelles which gels at a low temperature (Horne, 1998). The permeability tends to be higher at higher temperatures; this will be considered later. At large deformations, a higher temperature causes a larger deformation and a lower stress at fracture. Some effects of acidity (Zoon etal., 1989a; Roefs etal., 1990) are shown in Fig. 1. Again, one should distinguish the pH of renneting from that at measurement, since renneting at a lower pH causes faster gelation. Figure 1 gives results obtained several hours after renneting at the pH values indicated, and it is seen that the storage modulus at first increases with decreasing pH, to decrease again at still lower pH values; the loss tangent continues to increase, until the pH range where a 'rennet reinforced acidic gel' (Tranchant et al., 2001) begins to develop. At large deformations, the effects of moderate acidity are not great (Zoon et al., 1989b); the fracture stress is somewhat higher for a lower pH, if determined at the same timescale.
Acid gels The casein particles at pH 4.6 are rather different from those at physiological pH, as is illustrated in Fig. 1. They
78
The Syneresis of Rennet-coagulated Curd
are very prone to aggregation (except at low temperature), they contain no undissolved inorganic phosphate and they have a (presumed) voluminosity at 30 ~ of about 3.4 ml g-1 (leading to 45 = 0.08 in skim milk). Casein particles from strongly heat-treated milk differ significantly in their properties, and due to their associated whey proteins may behave as [~-lactoglobulin during acidification (Vasbinder et al., 2001) and recently it was recognized that thiol cross-linking occurs in acid gels from heat-treated milk (Vasbinder et al., 2003). Unmodified caseins form a gel at temperatures above about 10~ Gel properties have been studied extensively (Roefs and van Vliet, 1990; Roefs et al., 1990a; Lucey et al., 1997a,b) including those of gels made by the combined action of acid and rennet (Roefs et al., 1990b; Lucey et al., 1998, 2000, 2001; Tranchant et al., 2001) and gels from transglutaminase-cross-linked micelles (Schorsch et al., 2000). The gels are in many respects quite comparable to renneted milk gels (Table 1). They are also of a fractal nature and have roughly the same fractal dimensionality and thereby about the same dependence of modulus and of permeability on casein concentration (Bremer et al., 1989, 1990). The absolute value of the permeability is also roughly the same, as is the pore size distribution. The rheological properties are, however, rather different. They are treated separately in
Table 1 Properties of skim milk gels obtained by renneting (aged for about 1 h) or by acidification (aged for 6-16 h). Acid gels are of type 1 (obtained by cold acidification and subsequent warming) or of type 2 (obtained by slow acidification with glucono~-Iactone at 30 ~ Approximate results at 30 ~ (from various sources)
Acid gel Property
Rennet gel
Type 1 Type2
pH G' at ~o= 0.01 rad s-1 (Pa) Tan ~ at ~o = 0.01 rad s-1 Fracture stress a (Pa) Fracture straina ( - ) Permeability B (l~m2) Fractal dimensionality b dB/dt (nm 2 s -1) Initial syneresis rate c
6.65
4.6
4.6
32
180
20
0.55
0.27
0.27
10
100
100
3.0
0.5
1.1
0.25
0.15
0.15
2.23 20
2.39 <1
2.36 -
15
<1
<1
a Loading time 1000 s. b From the relation between concentration and B. c Arbitrary units.
'Formation, Structural Properties and Rheology of Acidcoagulated Milk Gels', Volume 1. Syneresis Mechanism of syneresis
Various mechanisms have been held responsible for syneresis (for an early review, see Walstra et al., 1985). Summarizing, the following types of mechanism were distinguished: 9 A decrease in solvation or water binding of the material making up the gel. For a particulate gel, this way of explaining syneresis does not appear suitable and there is no indication that an ongoing change in solvation is involved. 9 Shrinkage of the building blocks of the gel, i.e., the para-casein micelles in our case. This may happen when the pH is lowered or the temperature increased, but syneresis also occurs under constant conditions. 9 Rearrangement of the network of para-casein micelles. This is the main cause of syneresis. The para-casein particles in the gel form junctions with a limited number (mostly 2-4) of others. (Strictly speaking, this is not true. As mentioned earlier, there is a rapid rearrangement into thicker strands, leading to a higher coordination number. However, one may use the same arguments by considering the 'particles' to be aggregates of, on average, three micelles.) However, the particles are expected to be reactive over their entire surface (or to contain numerous reactive sites smeared out over their surface), and in the initial fractal network, by far the greater part of the surface of each particle does not touch (form bonds with) another one. Rearrangement of the particles into a more compact network would thus increase the number of bonds and hence decrease the total free energy (the counteracting loss in mixing entropy is very small). But the particles cannot easily attain a more compact configuration because they are almost immobilized in the network. In other words, the network has to be deformed locally to form new junctions. Thermal motion of the strands may occasionally bring two particles in different strands close to each other so that a new junction is formed, especially shortly after renneting. This would lead to the build-up of a tensile stress in at least some of the strands. The fusion process illustrated in Fig. 4 may also cause such a stress to develop. As a result, strands may occasionally break, providing a possibility for the formation of more new junctions, thereby tending to make the network contract. These events are illustrated in Fig. 6. Even if
The Syneresis of Rennet-coagulated Curd
/
\
/
/
\
/
\
/
\
~
\
\
\ ~.
79
\
-4- - \
/
,~.
-
_
_
,,.:,/
Figure 6 Schematic representation of strands of para-casein micelles forming new cross-links, leading to breaking of one of the strands (from van Dijk, 1982).
no syneresis would follow, the changes mentioned would cause the strands of particles to become straightened. This is indeed in agreement with the relation found between the modulus and the volume fraction of particles making up the gel (Bremer et al., 1990). The propensity of the strands to break has been carefully studied by van Vliet et al. (1991). They concluded that spontaneous breakage is possible if (1) the bonds in a junction can relax, and (2) the number of bonds in a junction is not too high. If the first condition is met, this is reflected in the loss tangent being fairly high on the timescale considered; the second is met if the strands are (locally) only one-particle thick and the junction zones fairly small (small particles, little fusion). For normal para-casein micelle gels, the critical loss tangent appears to be about 0.4, syneresis being stronger at a higher tan & To say it in other words, the activation free energy for the breaking of bonds should be fairly low for syneresis to be possible. But also the activation free energy for bond formation should be fairly low, since otherwise no new junctions will be formed. Attempts to unify the approach to gel formation and syneresis
It has been earlier recognized that casein gels are transient networks (Bremer, 1992; Bijsterbosch et al., 1995). In the last decade, a unified theoretical framework for the formation of more or less transient particle gels has been proposed (Poon and Haw, 1997; Tanaka, 1999; Prasad et al., 2003), not least due to the convenient experimental system of colloid particles in a noninteracting polymer solution. In such a system, because the centre of gravity of the dissolved polymer is sterically excluded from the region close to the particle surface, i.e., the surface region is depleted of the polymer, an effective attractive short range potential between the particles is created. Both the strength of the attraction (via osmotic pressure of the solution) and its range (via the polymer size) can be manipulated easily.
The framework attempts to unify the description of all phase separation phenomena, including gel formation. The gel is considered as a possible transient phenomenon on the way to full phase separation or to a final arrest of the phase separation process through glass transition. A general theory of viscoelastic phase separation has been developed by Tanaka and collaborators (recently reviewed by Tanaka, 2000). The theory proposes the formation of a transient gel as a possibility in any system in which one of the emerging separating phases has dynamics much slower than the other, covering both polymers and colloidal systems. In this approach, after the initial diffusioncontrolled spinodal decomposition, diffusion is hindered by the viscoelasticity, or more specifically the bulk and the shear moduli of the emerging 'slow' phase. The bulk modulus of the gel phase, which is assumed to include contributions from the excluded volume, the network topology and the particle binding energy, and which need not necessarily scale the same way as the shear modulus, is also the origin of gel contraction, i.e., microscopic syneresis. In very late stages of the process, it becomes once again dominated by the, by then slow, diffusional processes. In simulations, the model correctly predicts the morphology of the resulting gels both in polymers (Araki and Tanaka, 2001) and in colloids (Tanaka et al., 2003). The transient gel model clearly emphasizes that the apparent 'equilibrium' properties of the gel are the consequence of a drastic slowing down of an ongoing process and can thus not be expected to correlate neatly with the thermodynamic state variables such as composition, temperature and pH. There are several attractive features in the viscoelastic phase separation model. One is that it offers a predictive dynamic model which relates the thermodynamic driving force for separation on a molecular level to the relaxation bulk and the shear moduli of the gel. Another is that it allows in the same general framework modelling of both the early stages of the aggregation, where the casein micelles can be treated
80
The Syneresis of Rennet-coagulated Curd
as individual colloid particles, and the late stages where a fused casein phase may be better modelled as a viscoelastic fluid. The thermodynamical driving force, the gradient of free energy of mixing, can be related to independently measurable properties of the system. For renneted casein, the attractive energy has been derived from measurements of viscosity and light scattering, evaluated with the adhesive hard sphere model pioneered in the dairy context by de Kruif (de Kruif et al., 1992, 1995; Mellema et al., 1999) and it should even be accessible to direct measurement in AFM (atomic force microscope). AFM could also give a direct answer to the much-discussed issue of whether a renneted or acidified casein micelle can be regarded as uniformly attractive or as possessing 'hot spots'. As mentioned earlier, attempts have been made to relate the rheological properties of the network to observables such as fractal dimensionality. It has become clear that the fractal dimensionality and volume fraction of the gel phase do not completely determine the rheological properties of the network; further topological assumptions or facts are needed (Roberts and Knackstedt, 1996; Mellema et al., 2002a,b). Confocal scaning microscopy (CSM) can provide topographical information which can then be transformed directly into more model-independent rheological properties (Mellema et al., 2000), or, with time resolved CSM it is possible to evaluate directly the rheological properties of the network based on the observed movement of the network components under thermal (Brownian) excitation (Dinsmore and Weitz, 2002). The above-mentioned hopes for more general predictive theories may be overoptimistic (Walstra, 2003); gels are not homogeneous and relevant phenomena occur on many length scales, involving different types of bonds, and are therefore not easily interpretable by localized studies such as microscopy, and pose formidable problems to Brownian simulations.
After the gel has become firmer, it can withstand a greater disturbance without exhibiting spontaneous syneresis. Usually, it does not show syneresis at the milk surface, either. The composition of the milk surface is not known with certainty. It may be lipid-rich or may be covered by protein, presumably [3-casein (Holt and White, 1999), oriented with its hydrophobic chains towards the air. If this surface layer is bonded to the para-casein matrix, the hydrophobic air interface must be wetted to allow the serum to leave the matrix, and thus the matrix to shrink, thus it is essentially the capillary forces that prevent spontaneous syneresis. As soon as the gel is cut or the surface (locally) wetted, syneresis occurs. This effect permits experimentally starting syneresis at any desired moment after a gel has formed. These observations imply that in a constrained milk gel, no syneresis occurs. However, the processes depicted in Fig. 6 will nevertheless occur; there is no reason to suppose they would not. This implies that on a local scale, the gel network becomes more dense; this has been called microsyneresis (van Dijk, 1982; Walstra et al., 1985). At the same time, the network will become less dense at other sites; these changes are shown in Fig. 3. The surface-weighted average pore size will thus increase and it is indeed observed that the permeability of a constrained gel keeps increasing (see Fig. 7). It may be argued that the rate of change of the permeability, dB/dt, is a measure of the tendency of the gel to exhibit syneresis. Until now, only the inherent or endogenous tendency of a gel to show syneresis has been considered. Exerting a stress on the gel may be expected to speed up greatly the expulsion of whey, because of the increased pressure (see equation 7). Moreover, it may enhance syneresis by
1.5
-
Syneresis of renneted milk
Under typical cheesemaking conditions, if the gel is formed undisturbed and sticks completely to the wall of the vessel in which it is formed (e.g., clean glass), it usually shows no apparent syneresis, at least if the vessel is not too large and has vertical walls, and if the temperature is not too high (e.g., 30~ (van Dijk, 1982). Apparently, the gel is now constrained and cannot shrink. Spontaneous syneresis is observed if the milk is renneted in a conical flask; presumably, the gel tears loose from the glass wall by gravity before it is fully set. Similarly, spontaneous syneresis may occur in a cylindrical glass if it is tilted slightly for a moment during setting.
1.0
-
0.5
-
~~ 5.35
j 5.75
E
::t.
v
m
~
0 0
-
6.33
I
I
I
1
2
3
Time (h)
Figure 7 Permeability, B, of rennet-induced skim milk gels of various pH (indicated near the curves) as a function of time after renneting. Temperature 30 ~ (from results by van den Bijgaart, 1988).
The Syneresis of Rennet-coagulated Curd
bringing strands of the network closer to each other and, perhaps more importantly, it will enhance breaking of strands, thereby providing a greater possibility for the number of junctions to increase. As was discussed above in relation to Fig. 5, deformation of the gel also causes local rupture of the network, thereby increasing its permeability. Indeed, local densification of the structure and the formation of empty holes was predicted in simulations which specifically included imposed deformation (Rzepiela et al., 2002). One-dimensional syneresis at constant conditons
In this section, the detailed investigations by van Dijk, van den Bijgaart and coworkers (van Dijk, 1982; van Dijk et al., 1984; van Dijk and Walstra, 1986; van den Bijgaart, 1988), as complemented by the recent work by Lodaite (2002), Lodaite et al. (2000, 2002), Unger Grundelius (2004) and Unger Grundelius et al. (2000), will be discussed. They studied horizontal slabs of renneted milk, the top of which was moistened at a predetermined time after renneting, after which syneresis was followed by measuring the change in height, h, of the slab; whey could flow out only at the top. The milk was brought to the desired pH and the apparatus was kept at a constant temperature. Examples of results are shown in Fig. 8. The diameter of the cylindrical slabs was much larger than their thickness (mostly 5 mm). In this way, one-dimensional syneresis under constant conditions could be determined. This is, of course, an over-simplification of the situation during actual curdmaking, but it allowed precise and unequivocal determination of syneresis under various conditions, providing insight into the processes occurring, and permitting the development and the testing of a simple mathematical model.
~6 E
g
x:: 4
o
;,
+ Time ('h)
Figure 8 The height of slabs of renneted skim milk of various initial height, h, as a function of time after initiation of syneresis. Temperature 30 ~ pH 6.7. The values at infinite time are from extrapolation of log-log plots (from results by van Dijk, 1982).
81
In parallel experiments, the permeability, B, and its change with time, dB/dt, were determined. Unless stated otherwise, the results pertain to renneted skim milk. Modelling the process The gel can be considered as two inter-penetrating continuous spaces, one consisting of the para-casein matrix and the other of whey. If there is to be macroscopic syneresis, the para-casein matrix must contract and the whey move in the opposite direction. This relative movement is accompanied by a friction force, proportional to the relative velocity between the matrix and the whey. This frictional resistance against flow can be described by the equation of Darcy (equation 5), which is conveniently written as:
(7) where v is the relative superficial velocity of the liquid in the direction of l, the distance over which the liquid has to flow. The pressure causing the syneresis can, in general, be written as:
P = Ps + Pg + Pc
(7a)
which terms are, respectively, the endogenous syneresis pressure, the pressure exerted by the network itself due to gravity and any external pressure applied to the network. Results for Pc = 0 will be discussed first; note that pg varies from zero at the top of the slab to a maximum of g h Ap at the bottom, e.g., 1 Pa for a 1 cm slab (Ap = density difference between the para-casein network itself and the interstitial whey). Attempts to directly measure Ps failed; its value was too small. Only the order of magnitude could be estimated, and it was 1 Pa (van Dijk et al., 1979; van Dijk, 1982). This is a very small p r e s s u r e - it corresponds to the pressure exerted by a water 'column' of 0.1 m m and, as seen in Fig. 8, unaided syneresis is indeed very s l o w - it takes 7 h at 30 ~ for a 6-mm slab to be reduced to 3 mm. Since equation (7) must hold, and since the rate of syneresis, v, B, l and r / c a n be measured, it is possible to determine p indirectly and thereby Ps, because pg can also be calculated. The calculation is, however, very intricate, because: 9 permeability increases with time (Fig. 7); 9 permeability becomes smaller because of syneresis; 9 most likely, endogenous syneresis pressure also varies with ongoing syneresis; 9 pressure due to gravity changes as well; 9 the coordinates change with syneresis.
82 The Syneresis of Rennet-coagulated Curd Consequently, most variables vary with time and location. Syneresis will start in the uppermost layer, thereby altering its permeability, etc., and progressively reach deeper layers. A finite difference model was developed (van Dijk et al., 1984), in which the slab was divided into parallel thin slices, to each of which equation (7) and the equation of continuity were applied to calculate the outflow of liquid in small time intervals. By inserting various values for Ps and comparing the computed results with the observed h as a function of time, the endogenous syneresis pressure could be derived. By assuming p and B to be constant, which may be assumed to be the case at the very beginning of syneresis, an analytical solution can be found (Biot, 1941), which is mathematically equivalent to the solution of the diffusion equation (Tanaka and Fillmore, 1979). This would imply that h changes proportionally to the square root of time and directly yields the initial endogenous syneresis pressure, Ps0. This proved not to be the case. In careful experiments, an initial proportionality with time t, the power of about 3/4 was obtained by van den Bijgaart (1988) and about 1 by Lodaite et al. (2000). The explanation probably is as follows (van den Bijgaart, 1988) - an implicit assumption in the application of equation (7) is that the network can without significant resistance comply with the outflow of whey. But the initial shrinkage rate of the outermost layer would then be very high (the proportionality with square root of time even implies an infinite rate at t = 0) and that is clearly not possible. A significant effort went into the refinement of the model and the numerical fitting to calculate the intrinsic syneresis pressure as a function of time and process conditions, such as in Fig. 9. The observed trends in the intrinsic pressure could be qualitatively explained
_
Q. v
II
0
s s s I
0
I
1
I
I
2
Time ('h)
Figure 9 The endogenous syneresis pressure (Ps) of rennetinduced skim milk gels as a function of the time elapsed after renneting when syneresis was initiated, at various pH (indicated near the curves). Temperature, 30 ~ The broken lines are assumed (from results by van den Bijgaart, 1988).
a posteriori, however, the prediction power of the model remained poor. A possible explanation could lie in the fact that equation (7) is formulated for the liquid space of the network. This means that the forces needed for the deformation of the matrix are not considered explicitly. The intrinic syneresis pressure is thus the observable difference between the balance of the thermodynamic forces attempting to reach a new equilibrium, the eventual external forces and the forces caused by the viscoelastic properties of the matrix. The magnitude of the latter depends on the deformation of the matrix, the deformation rate and the deformation history at each point in time and space. An order of magnitude estimate can be based on Fig. 10. Some 8 Pa external pressure doubled the initial rate of syneresis; thus, the viscoelastic resistance of the matrix would seem to be almost an order of magnitude larger than the observed intrinsic syneresis pressure. While the derived intrinsic pressure is not easily interpreted, one can argue that the same balance of thermodynamic and viscoelastic forces that causes the macrosyneresis is also reflected in microsyneresis, and thus the rate of change of permeability should be a direct index to the intrinsic rate of syneresis. Even in the measurement of permeability there are some caveats. While the observed constrained permeability and its rate of change, measured by the standard tube method was found to be independent of curd column length and driving pressure difference by van Dijk (1982), it was found to depend on both the size of the tube and the driving pressure difference by Unger Grundelius (2004). Some important results are given in Fig. 11. The variables, temperature and pH, affect dB/dt in a similar way, in accordance with the ideas outlined above. All these trends would cause faster syneresis at a higher temperature and lower pH; this is indeed observed. An additional complication, which will lead to syneresis being given an additional dependency on the physical dimensions of the synerising sample, is that rapid syneresis also leads to the rapid formation of a highly shrunken outer layer, which implies that the permeability of that layer becomes very low and its modulus high, thereby slowing down further syneresis. The close correlation between B and dB/dt is presumably due to the latter factor already causing an increase in B before the gel is firm enough to allow the estimation of B. Temperature has a very large effect- below 20 ~ endogenous syneresis is virtually zero. The relations for the effect of concentrating the milk by ultrafihration are different. Naturally, B decreases with increasing concentration, and the network becomes denser. The bonds remain of the same type, however, which is reflected in
The Syneresis of Rennet-coagulated Curd
0.4
-
0.2
-
83
B (pm 2)
dB/dt
X. syn
/
f
/
0 -
I
20
40
I
5.5
I
'
6.5
T (~
pH
, 0
, 0.1
, 1
CaCI 2 (%)
, 2
3
UF
Figure 10 Properties of rennet-induced skim milk gels. Permeability (B), rate of change of permeability (dB/dt), and approximate initial syneresis rate (syn, arbitrary scale) as a function of temperature (T), pH, added quantity of CaCI2 and preconcentration by ultrafiltration (UF, degree of concentration) (mostly from results by van Dijk, 1982; van den Bijgaart, 1988).
tan 8 remaining constant (Zoon et al., 1988a). Nevertheless, dBIdt decreases with increasing concentration. The overall result is that the rate of syneresis decreases with increasing concentration. The relative shrinkage rate, i.e., relative to one minus the volume fraction of para-casein particles in the gel, increases somewhat with increasing concentration (van den Bijgaart, 1988). It also appears that the rate of syneresis of a gel from pre-concentrated milk (by UF) is higher than that of a gel of the same concentration but caused by syneresis; at least part of the explanation is presumably that in the latter case, considerable relaxation of the internal stresses in the network has occurred, implying a lower syneresis pressure.
._m q) C
I I
i O I I I I
11
.
3
3
~
~
11 1
27~
i f fff~
._~ c
~
6
111111
4.0
L_
The effect of adding CaC12 is somewhat puzzling- B and dBIdt are not affected and neither is tan 8 (Zoon et al., 1988b), whereas syneresis rate increases. It should be noticed, however, that the effect of adding CaC12 is rather variable and that the time elapsed between addition and doing the experiments also affects the results (van den Bijgaart, 1988). It would require painstaking investigations to settle these fine points. Some other variables also (slightly) affect endogenous syneresis. The quantity of rennet added has very little effect, provided that the time elapsed after rennet addition has been sufficient to ensure almost complete hydrolysis of the K-casein. Adding NaC1 has very little effect, unless a large quantity is added. Comparison of renneted milk with
~ff
i~
1111 11
1 11
I
~I
i~
~''~'~
I
11 1
Oj.J
f 34 ~
"T
I
20 Temperature (~
I
I
I
I
I
30
2
4
6
8
~/Pe/Pa
Figure 11 Effects of temperature and external pressure (Pe in Pa, indicated near the curves in the left-hand graph) on syneresis of renneted skim milk. pH was 6.68 (filled circles) or 6.33 (open circles) (from results by van den Bijgaart, 1988).
84
The Syneresis of Rennet-coagulated Curd
skim milk shows that the presence of fat globules causes a somewhat lower permeability; dBIdt is not affected, and syneresis is a little slower. As an example, after 5 h a slab had shrunk to 53% of its height, compared to 48% in the case of skim milk (van den Bijgaart, 1988). The effect of ethanol, a less-polar solvent than water, was investigated by Renault etal. (1997). Syneresis decreased in the presence of ethanol, which may suggest that para-casein was more strongly solvated; micellar casein was found to dissociate on heating in the presence of ethanol (O'Connell et al., 2001). Experiments on the influence of an external pressure, Pe, were performed by placing a porous disc on top of the syneresing slab. Some results are shown in Fig. 11. It is seen that the effect is considerable and is about proportional to the square root of pressure. The effect of external pressure cannot be seen as an amplification of syneresis - it is about additive to the endogenous syneresis. These results are in accordance with those of model calculations. Figure 11 also suggests that in the presence of an external pressure, the lowest temperature at which syneresis can occur is lower, the more so for a higher pressure. Although this has not been verified by experiments, the effect must exist at least to some extent. Presumably, syneresis has an endpoint. Eventually, the system will be close-packed. Such an end-point has, however, not been observed. Figure 12 gives some results up to 50-h syneresis. It is seen also that after a long time, the shrinkage is greater for a higher temperature, a lower pH and a higher external pressure. A higher fat content also causes somewhat less shrinkage after long time. It would be of great importance for theory formation to establish the apparent
equilibrium voluminosity of para-casein micelles as a function of pH, temperature and salt content; however, no such work has been reported.
Syneresis during curdmaking After renneting has led to a gel of sufficient firmness, it is usually cut into pieces to promote whey release. For most types of cheese, the mixture of curds and whey is then stirred, often, part of the whey is removed, and it is fairly common to increase the temperature of the mixture after some time (scalding or cooking), all of which are measures aimed at enhancing syneresis. Moreover, during this process of curdmaking, the pH decreases, again enhancing syneresis. An example of the water content of the curd during the course of the process is given in Fig. 13. Note how time, temperature, acidity and pressure affect the water content; the effect of pressure is seen when the curd is taken out of the whey for moulding, by which action the pressure due to gravity increases by a factor of about 30. All these effects are in qualitative agreement with the above results. In this section, the effect of several variables under conditions during actual curdmaking, or conditions more or less mimicking these, will be considered. This is because most published experiments were done in such a way, and methods for estimating syneresis will be reviewed briefly. Some effects of milk composition and pre-treatment will also be discussed.
90
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
'
'
7O
0.4 T (~
Pe (Pa)
pH
30
0
6.67
34
0
6.67
30 30
8 8
6.67 6.33
30
62
6.33
o4
0.3
9-- 0.2
0.1
0
I
I
20
30
I
40 t(h)
50
Figure 12 Effects of temperature (T), external pressure (Pe) and pH on the shrinkage of renneted skim milk. Relative remaining volume (i) as a function of time (t) after renneting. Initial slab height 5 mm (from results by van den Bijgaart, 1988).
50
0
2
4 Time (h)
6
8
Figure 13 Examples of changes in the water content of curd (determined by oven drying) as a function of time after renneting. The gel was cut after 0.5 h and the curd and whey mixture was stirred continually. At two moments (indicated by arrows), curd was removed from the whey and put into a cheese mould. Experiments with (filled line) and without (dashed line) adding starter. Temperature of the whey was 32 ~ throughout, temperature in the mould gradually fell to 20 ~ (recalculated from van de Grootevheen and Geurts, 1977; Kwant et aL, unpublished).
The Syneresis of Rennet-coagulated Curd It goes without saying that curdmaking is aimed at other things besides regulating the rate and the extent of syneresis. The main aspect is that a higher moisture content goes along with a higher sugar content of the curd, which, in turn, leads to a lower pH. This can be modified by 'washing' the curd. A lower pH at the moment of separating curds and whey causes the cheese to contain less calcium phosphate. Other aspects are the limitation of the loss of curd fines, the inclusion and the activity of rennet in the cheese and, in some types, the killing of undesired micro-organisms (caused by scalding).
Methods for estimating syneresis The ultimate result of syneresis is reflected in the water content of the cheese after pressing. Determining only this quantity yields, however, little understanding. It is much more interesting to follow syneresis during the curdmaking process, but it is not easy to do this unequivocally. The various methods and their pros and cons have been reviewed extensively (Walstra et al., 1985); only the salient points will be described here. The methods may be classified as follows: 1. Measuring the shrinkage of the curd, either the height of a slab (as discussed earlier) or the volume or mass of a slab or pieces of curd (in air or in whey). These methods are typically applied in laboratory experiments. 2. Determining the amount of whey expelled. This can be done in two ways: a. determination of the volume of whey drained off. The results strongly depend on conditions, especially the often imprecisely known external pressure. It also may be fairly uncertain how much interstitial whey is left between the curd grains. b. determination of the degree of dilution of an added tracer. This method has an inherent uncertainty, in as much as the tracer may adhere onto or diffuse into the curd. 3. Determination of the dry matter content of curd pieces taken out of the whey. The main uncertainty is the unknown quantity of whey adhering to the curd particles; trying to remove the adhering whey may introduce the opposite error. 4. Determining the density of the curd grains by putting them in solutions of various density. This method is fairly crude, but is hardly biased if carefully executed.
85
the curd, but was not further pursued for syneresis studies. All these methods can, of course, be executed under various conditions that affect syneresis, e.g., temperature, pH and effective pressure, and at various times after renneting or cutting. Most authors have used method 2a, but methods 2b and 3 have also been fairly popular, especially in experiments involving stirring of the curds-whey mixture. Hardly ever have different methods been compared on the same curd. Figure 14 gives an example, and it is seen that the difference is considerable. It may be concluded that absolute values are hard to obtain and that most methods provide only trends. Even then, one has to be careful, since the method may not be linear. In relation to this, it should be realized that at the beginning of syneresis a large amount of whey has to be removed for the moisture content of the curd to become appreciably lower, whereas at the end of the process the opposite is true (see Fig. 15).
Rate equations As was discussed above, even for a very simple model for the case of one-dimensional syneresis under constant conditions, solution of equation (7) in conjunction with the equation of continuity leads to complicated relations. This will be even more so for the situations considered here, where the geometric boundary conditions are more complicated and changing, and where the physico-chemical conditions affecting syneresis are not constant either. Nevertheless, some authors have tried to give simple analytical expressions for the process.
90
N9
v r
~0 ~0~
N
E 80 0 0
"\ 4:o
80
Time (min)
In addition to the classical methods, the use of low-resolution NMR was introduced by Tellier et al. (1993). The method showed great promise, as it was able to monitor both the degree of syneresis and give a quantitative measure of pore size distribution in
Figure 14 Water content of curd from skim milk renneted and kept at 31 ~ as a function of time after cutting, determined from the concentration in the whey of added polyvinyl alcohol (filled circles) and by oven drying of pieces of curd strained off (open circles) (from Kwant et aL, unpublished).
86
T h e S y n e r e s i s of R e n n e t - c o a g u l a t e d Curd
80-
o
.=_
40
0
20
60 % Whey removed
100
Figure 15 Calculated relation between the water content of curd (from whole milk of 12.3% dry matter) and the quantity of whey (6.8% dry matter) expelled as % (w/w) of the original milk.
Kirchmeier (1972) reported that the change in volume, V, of a piece of curd is, under 'constant conditions', given by: V = Vo exp(-Kt)
(8)
where Vo = original volume, t = time after starting syneresis and K would be a first-order rate constant, linearly dependent on temperature. A similar relation, albeit with some 'extra' syneresis immediately after cutting, was observed by Marshall (1982). Apart from the lack of theoretical justification for equation (8), it predicts that V approaches zero for very high t, which is clearly impossible. Weber (1984), therefore, modified equation (8) to: V = Vo [0.15 + 0.85 exp(-Kt)]
(9)
where it was assumed that the curd eventually shrinks to 0.15 times its original volume (actually, Weber used mass rather than volume). A further modification was made by Peri et al. (1985) who introduced the final (relative) volume, Vinf, as a variable and obtained:
1966; Lawrence and Hill, 1974) found that the amount of whey expelled (Vo - V) from pieces of curd was proportional to t u2, and concluded that 'rate of syneresis is substantially diffusion-controlled'. Such a conclusion had also been reached for syneresis in cross-linked polymer gels (Beltman, 1975). The results quoted above are incompatible; for Kt > > 1, equations (8-10) predict that ( V o - V) is proportional to t, n o t tl/2; more generally, different authors find different relations. The only conclusion can be that, under constant conditions, the rate of syneresis ( - d V / d t ) decreases as syneresis proceeds. This need not always be true for the relative rate of syneresis ( - d In V/dt), although this quantity will also eventually approach zero. Effects of curd gram size Cutting the renneted milk gel into pieces creates a free surface through which syneresis can occur. Before cutting, the gel mostly sticks to the wall and its top surface does not show syneresis, unless it is wetted. Moreover, the distance over which the whey has to flow through the curd is greatly reduced. Empirically, cutting strongly enhances syneresis. Tests using the standard cheesemaking procedures, where a body of curd is cut into pieces, compress the curd and can thus induce structural changes or even cracks in the gel. They thus do not allow to differentiate between the effect of size of the curd grains on one hand and the cutting-induced effects on the other. Unger Grundelius et al. (2000) used curd cylinders of different sizes, produced by rennetting in plastic syringes, but even with the best care, initial whey expulsion could not be avoided. An indication of the effect of grain size is given in Fig. 16; the trends agree with the corresponding onedimensional syneresis data. The time for a given (low) o~
10o0o
0 od
V-
Vinf- [(Vo- Vinf)exp(-Kt)]
(10)
0 t~
This would be a correct equation for a simple relaxation process where 1/K is the relaxation time. As we have seen, syneresis can certainly not be considered such a process; nevertheless, Peri etal. (1985) found a good agreement with their results, obtained under a fairly wide range of conditions. The good fit may have been due to equation (10) containing two adjustable parameters. Caron et al. (2001) chose yet another asymptotic twoparameter fit, of the same form as the Michaelis-Menten equation. Daviau et al. (2000c) used two exponential relaxation times, and thus five adjustable parameters. Several workers (Koestler and Petermann, 1936; Stoll,
~-g
1000
O
o'~ Z~ Ill
E 100
i
1
10
100
Slab thickness or 1/2 grain size (mm)
Figure 16 Initial one-dimensional syneresis in curd slabs (lines) and three-dimensional syneresis in curd grains (symbols) as a function of size (from Unger Grundelius etal., 2000 and Lodaite et al., 2000).
T h e S y n e r e s i s of R e n n e t - c o a g u l a t e d
level of initial syneresis scaled more or less proportionally to curd grain size at pH 6.4, but at a power less than one at a lower pH. Small pieces of curd shrink more than large ones. The latter implies that uneven cutting will cause local variations in moisture content and acidity in the fresh cheese.
Stirring Stirring enhances syneresis (see, for example, Fig. 17). The main factor may be the prevention of sedimentation of the curd particles. Although in a sedimented layer the pressure on the curd may be higher, the possibility of the whey flowing out of the curd layer soon becomes small, thereby strongly impeding syneresis (see further below). Another factor is that stirring causes some pressure to be exerted on the curd grains, and external pressure has a large effect (see below), van den Bijgaart (1988) has made some rough calculations. Stirring causes velocity gradients and consequently, according to Bernoulli's law, pressure differences. In laminar flow, these remain fairly small; they may amount to several Pa during curd-making. Mostly, flow will be turbulent and pressures up to 160 Pa were calculated, although these exist only for short times. Collision of curd particles with each other or with the stirrer gives rise to brief pressure bursts of the order of 100 Pa, although the average external pressure will probably be about 10 Pa. It has indeed been observed that more vigorous stirring (Patel et al., 1972) or removing more whey (Lawrence, 1959; Birkkjaer et al., 1961), which causes more frequent collisions between curd grains, hence a higher average pressure, leads to somewhat more whey expulsion. The intermittent deformation of the curd grains occurring during stirring may have another effect. As discussed in relation to Fig. 5, large deformation of a
80 tirring
c-
o~
40
9
'
1
.
'
2
'
3
Time (h) after cutting
Figure 17 The volume of whey expelled (as % of the original milk volume) from curd kept in the whey at 38 ~ as a function of time after cutting, with or without stirring (from Lawrence, 1959).
Curd
87
renneted milk gel causes cracks to be formed in it. Experiments in which an amount of renneted milk gel between two concentric cylinders was brought temporarily under shear and the permeability determined before and afterwards (van Dijk and Walstra, 1986), yielded the following results. Up to a shear of 0.35, B had altered little, a shear of about 0.7 caused an increase by, on average, 20%, and a larger shear could cause a much higher permeability. Unger Grundelius (2004) observed enhanced permeability with time at constant pressure 7.5 kPa/m curd height. It has also been observed (Akkerman, 1992) that an external pressure of the order of 100 Pa can, under certain, not very well-known, conditions cause several small cracks to appear at the outside of shrunken curd grains. (Perhaps the cracks are always formed if the local pressure is high enough, but are often sealed again.) To what extent these phenomena mitigate the strong inhibition of further syneresis due to the formation of a dense outer layer on the curd grains is unknown. Practical conditions of modern curd-making usually allow few opportunities to markedly affect syneresis by varying cutting, stirring, etc. For instance, the size to which the renneted milk gel is cut certainly has an effect on the water content of the cheese, but the effect is small (Sammis et al., 1910; Wurster, 1934; Thome et al., 1958; Kammerlehner, 1974), at the most some 1% water in the cheese (Straatsma and Heijnekamp, 1988). The main reason presumably is that curd size cannot be varied greatly. If the initial particles are very large, they will inevitably be broken into smaller ones during stirring as long as they are still soft. If one tries to make very small particles, a considerable loss of curd fines occurs. Stirring for a longer time causes a lower moisture content (see, e.g., Fig. 13), but a certain minimum duration of stirring is needed to give the particles sufficient firmness. After that, any longer stirring leads to a slope of, for instance, - 0 . 0 4 % water in the cheese per minute stirring for semi-hard cheese (Straatsma and Heijnekamp, 1988). Consequently, other measures should be taken to influence the water content, especially varying the temperature. After stirring, the curd particles are usually allowed to sediment. If they are sufficiently rigid (which implies mainly after they have lost sufficient whey), they will deform and fuse only to a limited extent in the sedimented layer, implying that any additional external pressure leads to a considerable loss of whey. This is illustrated in Fig. 18; the lower pressures in this graph were due to stirring curds and whey, the higher ones due to pressure exerted on the sedimented curd layer, either by the curd itself or by the perforated plates lying on top.
88
The Syneresis of Rennet-coagulated Curd
100
,
effect of heating, presumably because [3-1actoglobulin now reacted primarily with K-casein in the serum during heating, thus affecting the casein micelles less. Ovine milk was less sensitive to heat treatment, and caprine even less so (Calvo and Balcones, 2000).
I /I S
(D (-
50
#
o~
,v..L
0
50
100
10 4
External pressure (Pa)
Figure 18 The amount of whey expelled from curd (as % of the original milk volume) after 2 h at 30 ~ as a function of the external pressure applied to the curd (approximate results, recalculated from van Dijk et al. (1979) (100 Pa = 10 -3 bar)).
Effects of other process variables
Numerous authors have studied the effects of product and process variables on syneresis rate, beginning with Sammis et al. (1910). Other extensive studies were by, successively, Wurster (1934), Koestler and Petermann (1936), van der Waarden (1947), Thom6 et al. (1958), Stoll (1966) and Daviau et al. (2000a,b,c,d). Several others have studied one or a few variables. As will be seen below, the results often vary somewhat. Results that are obviously in error in view of our present understanding have generally been omitted. But even then, differences in the individual milk samples, in the methods used and in the conditions employed, cause variation. Particularly, the stage at which syneresis is measured affects the results. Moreover, the effect of one variable may be influenced greatly by the level of another, and altering one factor often causes other conditions to change also. Heat treatment of the milk
Heat treatment of milk to such an extent that serum proteins are denatured, increasingly diminishes the syneresis rate of renneted milk, according to many authors (Wurster, 1934; van der Waarden, 1947; Dimov and Mineva, 1962; Stoll, 1966; Kammerlehner, 1974; Nilsen, 1982; Pearse et al., 1985; Daviau et al., 2000c). Some found even a slight decrease caused by mild heat treatments (Siegenthaler and FlClckiger, 1964; Stoll, 1966; Nilsen, 1982), but the others did not. Pearse et al. (1985) found the decrease in syneresis to be almost linearly correlated with denaturation of [3-1actoglobulin. Heat treatment of synthetic milk free of serum proteins hardly affected syneresis. Addition of K-casein to milk diminished the detrimental
Homogenization of the milk Homogenization or recombination of milk significantly decreases syneresis rate (Vaikus et al., 1970; Kammerlehner, 1974; Emmons et al., 1980; Humbert et al., 1980; Green et al., 1983; Storry et al., 1983; Ghosh et al., 1994). This is related to the incorporation of micellar casein in the surface coat of the fat globules, which causes the fat globules to become part of the para-casein network, which, in turn, may hinder shrinking of the network. A comparable effect on syneresis was observed if milk had been concentrated by evaporation and diluted again before clotting (Cheeseman and Mabbitt, 1968) which has a similar consequence for the fat globules (Mulder and Walstra, 1974). If fat is homogenized into whey, so that the fat globules do not contain much casein on their surface layers, the detrimental effect of homogenization on syneresis is clearly less (Emmons et al., 1980). Various additions to the milk
Additions meant to modify specific residues of the milk proteins, in order to study the clotting reaction, will not be considered here. Adding sugars, which are fairly unreactive, has been reported to cause no effect (Stoll, 1966; Grandison et al., 1984a), a slight decrease (van der Waarden, 1947) or a slight increase (Cheeseman, 1962) in syneresis rate. About the same holds for addition of up to 10% urea (van der Waarden, 1947; Cheeseman, 1962). In cheesemaking, some CaC12 is frequently added to enhance coagulation. Most authors report that small additions (e.g., up to 10 mM) of CaC12 enhanced syneresis somewhat (Wurster, 1934; van der Waarden, 1947; Stoll, 1966; Kammerlehner, 1974; Lelievre and Creamer, 1978) while others found little or no effect (Lawrence, 1959; Cheeseman, 1962; Emmons etal., 1980); larger additions were generally found to reduce syneresis (Wurster, 1934; Gyr, 1944; Tarodo de la Fuente and Alais, 1975). van der Waarden (1947) clearly showed that the main enhancing effect of CaC12 is due to its lowering the pH; if the pH was kept constant, addition of CaC12 caused syneresis to decrease, while MgC12 caused a marked increase (van der Waarden, 1947; Stoll, 1966; Kovalenko and Bocharova, 1973). Presumably, one has to consider two p o i n t s - increasing of the calcium ion activity (enhancing syneresis) and of the colloidal calcium phosphate (diminishing syneresis). Presumably, Mg 2+
The Syneresis of Rennet-coagulated Curd
act much the same as Ca 2+, whereas Mg-phosphates are much more soluble than Ca-phosphates (addition of MgC12 may thus cause some dissolution of colloidal phosphate). Lowering the pH causes, of course, a dissolution of colloidal phosphate and an increase in Ca 2+ activity. Addition of phosphate, citrate, oxalate or EDTA (van der Waarden, 1947; Stoll, 1966) at constant pH, all reduce syneresis; these additions considerably reduce Ca 2+ activity and adding phosphate also increases colloidal phosphate content. The salt equilibria in milk are intricate, depend on several conditions and often exhibit slow changes, as discussed by, for instance, by Walstra and Jenness (1984). Increasing the ionic strength of milk with univalent ions (e.g., NaC1) has been reported to cause at first no change (Cheeseman, 1962) or a slight increase in syneresis (Stoll, 1966); it tends to reduce the amount of colloidal phosphate and possibly the Ca 2+ activity. A large increase in ionic strength causes a decrease in syneresis (van der Waarden, 1947; Cheeseman, 1962; Stoll, 1966), but then, milk with added salt coagulates very poorly on renneting. Decreased ionic strength increased syneresis (Daviau et al., 2000c). Addition of A1C13 reduces syneresis (Stoll, 1966).
the free surface was kept constant, such disturbance caused syneresis rate to increase by 20-30% in some experiments (Cheeseman and Chapman, 1966). This may have been due to the disturbance affecting the structure of the network. Curd formed solely by acidification shows very little syneresis if left undisturbed. In milk clotted below about pH 5, the presence of rennet was found to enhance syneresis considerably, the more so when the amount of added rennet was increased (Emmons et al., 1959). Presumably, this signifies a gradual change from an acid to a rennetinduced gel and is of importance in the production of fresh cheese types (Weber, 1984).
Temperature Temperature greatly affects syneresis rate of rennet curd; some results are summarized in Fig. 19. All authors agree as to the trend and all results show that the rate of change of syneresis with temperature (Q10 or - d In VIdT) decreases with increasing temperature, but otherwise the results are fairly different. At 25 ~ reported values of Q10 vary from about 2.5 to 15, at 45 ~ from about 1.1 to 1.5.
100
Coagulation Most authors agree that rennet concentration has no effect on syneresis (Sammis et al., 1910; Wurster, 1934; Stoll, 1966; Lelievre, 1977). Others found that more rennet gave a slight increase (Gyr, 1944; Kammerlehner, 1974; Lelievre and Creamer, 1978; Kaytanli et al., 1994) or decrease (Kovalenko and Bocharova, 1973) in syneresis, or observed an optimum concentration (Weber, 1984). These effects should be considered in relation to the time of cutting (Weber, 1984; Stoll, 1966; Lelievre, 1977). As made clear by, for instance, Weber (1984), it is the stage of the coagulation process or the firmness of the curd at the moment of cutting that is the variable; if cutting is very late, syneresis may be somewhat less. It has also been observed that a higher coagulation temperature leads to slightly less syneresis (Straatsma and Heijnekamp, 1988); this may be due to the cutting starting at an effectively later stage. Whether milk is renneted by chymosin or pepsin makes no significant difference (Andersson and Andren, 1990). Renneting with proteolytic enzymes from Rhizornucor rniehei or Gyphonectria parasitica caused somewhat slower syneresis, but curd firming was slower also, and when cutting 45 rather than 30 min after adding the rennet, the syneresis rate was observed to be normal (Gouda and E1-Shabrawy, 1987). Disturbance of the gel during setting may considerably enhance syneresis rate (Wurster, 1934). This was ascribed to the increase of free surface, but also when
89
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. IO j O
fO j
o/
80
60
iiii
(D e-
9
o~ 40
20
0
,
|
20
n
u
u
,
40
i
u
|
,
|
60
Temp. (~
Figure 19 The volume of whey expelled (as % of the original milk volume) from curd set, kept and treated at different (constant) temperatures. Most results were obtained 1 h after cutting (recalculated from 9 Sammis etaL (1910), V Wurster (1934), 9 Koestler and Petermann (1936), 9 Gyr (1944), 9 Lawrence (1959), A Stoll (1966), • Kirchmeier (1972), [] Kammerlehner (1974), + Marshall (1982)).
90
The Syneresis of Rennet-coagulated Curd
The initial rate is increased, but the final amount of syneresis may even decrease, as temperature is raised above 45 ~ (Huber et al., 2001). It appears that the rate at which temperature is changed (dT/dt) does not, as such, affect syneresis (Wurster, 1934; Patel et al., 1972). Keeping the milk for some time at a low temperature before renneting has been reported to have no effect (Johnston etal., 1983), a small detrimental effect on syneresis (Nilsen, 1982) or a considerable e f f e c t holding for 20 h at 5 ~ reduced syneresis by about 30% (Kammerlehner, 1974). Raynal and Remeuf (2000) observed a similar decrease for bovine milk, but no effect on caprine and ovine milk. Any detrimental effect of precooling is probably reversed by prewarming the milk to a fairly high temperature before renneting, as is commonly done in cheesemaking to ensure normal setting.
Acidity If milk has been acidified to a lower pH before renneting, syneresis rate is faster. Some observations are summarized in Fig. 20; other authors have reported similar results (Sammis et al., 1910; Koestler and Petermann,
100
.
.
.
.
.
1936; van der Waarden, 1947; Tarodo de la Fuente and Alais, 1975; Lelievre and Creamer, 1978). Although the observed trends were mostly the same, there were, again, considerable quantitative differences. The deviating relation found by Berridge (1970) is not due to inaccuracy but may be related to the different experimental set-up (syneresis of a cylinder of curd attached to a grid, in air). The inflection points in the curves near pH 6 are also realistic. Stoll (1966) observed that the effect of pH was relatively greater at lower temperature and in the absence of stirring, i.e., if syneresis was slower. There were no appreciable differences according to the acid used (van der Waarden, 1947). If the pH falls during syneresis this may enhance syneresis rate to a greater extent than is found when the pH is previously brought to the same value (Stoll, 1966; van de Grootevheen and Geurts, 1977) because the building blocks of the protein network tend to shrink due to the change in pH. This is also exemplified by some results by Emmons et al. (1959) shown in Fig. 20. Here, the milk contained variable numbers of starter bacteria, and the pH values indicated in the figure are those at the moment of cutting. A higher pH at that stage implies a greater drop in pH after cutting, hence more syneresis. Milk that has already been soured to a very low pH (e.g., 4.5) exhibits only weak syneresis, even after renneting (Sammis et al., 1910).
O
80
60 (D c-
[]
40
XX
20X X X
0
7
,
pH
Figure 20 The volume of whey expelled (as % of the original milk volume) from curd set, kept and treated at different pH; in some cases, pH decreased slightly during the experiment. Most results were obtained 1 h after cutting (recalculated from Wurster (1934), heavy line = average of several experiments; O Gyr (1944); 9 Cheeseman (1962); A Stoll (1966); 9 Berridge (1970); 9 Patel etal. (1972); V Marshall (1982); [] Pearse etal. (1984); + Weber (1984). See text for the results of x Emmons et al. (1959)).
Washing of the curd Washing, i.e., adding water after part of the whey has been removed, has been reported to enhance syneresis (Kammerlehner, 1974), and to give a slightly, possibly insignificantly, lower water content (Casiraghi et al., 1987). However, washing may coincide with a change in temperature and a difference in the effectiveness of stirring, both of which affect syneresis. In studies by van de Grootevheen and Geurts (1977), either water or an equal quantity of whey at the same temperature was added at a certain stage during cheesemaking and the water content of the curd determined at various times. The water content of the curd to which water had been added was up to two percentage units higher, but the difference could be fully explained by taking into account the difference in dry matter content of the moisture (liquid) in the curd. Hence, the osmotic effects of washing are negligible.
Ultraffitration Uhrafihration of cheese milk and renneting the retentate allows the manufacture of curd in such a way that less, or even no, syneresis occurs. The latter, i.e., concentrating the milk to a composition roughly equal to that of the (unsalted) cheese to be made, is feasible only for soft-type cheese; it usually involves
The Syneresis of Rennet-coagulated Curd
diafiltration also. For harder cheeses, partial ultrafiltration can be applied and an important point then is to what extent syneresis is affected. Some results were already given in Fig. 11. The comparison of the conclusions of different studies may be sometimes misleading, as the authors may relate their syneresis rates to the original amount of milk, or the amount of whey to be expelled. Extensive studies were made by Peri et al. (1985), applying equation (10). They concentrated the milk up to 5.2-fold. The rate constant of the first-order equation, which is thus a measure of the rate relative to the amount of whey yet to be removed, varied little with the degree of concentration; clear correlations with pH or extent of diafiltration were not observed either. The extrapolated proportion of whey eventually expelled (Vo - W i n f ) varied roughly linearly with the reciprocal of the degree of concentration. A lower pH resulted in a lower (extrapolated) final moisture content. The effects of diafiltration, pre-acidification and sequestering of Ca were also studied (Casiraghi et al., 1987). When adjusting casein cocentration with UF or MF retentate powders, Caron etal. (2001) found faster syneresis for milks adjusted with MF retentate of preacidified milk. Other workers obtained slightly different results (Green et al., 1983; Storry et al., 1983). This may have been due to variation in the time elapsed after renneting before cutting. When renneting normal milk, about 2% of the K-casein is still unhydrolysed at the moment of cutting, whereas this may be about 12% for a milk concentrated two-fold by uhrafihration (van Hooydonk and van den Berg, 1988); this proportion is higher for a more concentrated milk. Consequently, the early stages of gel formation and syneresis probably proceed somewhat differently, depending on the moment of cutting. High-pressure treatment The effects of high-pressure treatment are twofold, the breakdown of the casein micelles at pressures of about 400 MPa, and denaturation of [3-1actoglobulin at higher pressures, similar to the effects of heating. Casein micelle disruption causes faster aggregation and a finer gel structure with stiffer gels, but syneresis was only affected at pressures above 400 MPa (Needs et al., 2000). Effect of milk composition
Milk composition may clearly affect syneresis, but the effect is usually not large. A higher fat content in the milk on average is accompanied by somewhat slower syneresis (Beeby, 1959; Feagan et al., 1965; Stoll, 1966; Kammerlehner, 1974; Emmons et al., 1980; Storry et al., 1983; Weber, 1984; Grandison et al., 1984a). In practice,
91
milk is usually standardized as to fat content. A higher casein content goes along with a slower absolute rate of syneresis, but a hardly different relative rate (see under Uhrafihration). Minor components may have a larger influence and it must be presumed that the calcium ion activity is an especially important variable. For instance, separate milkings of individual cows may vary by a factor of three in syneresis rate (Koestler and Petermann, 1936; Thome et al., 1958; Kammerlehner, 1974; Grandison e t a l . , 1984a,b), but addition of some CaC12 greatly reduces the variation. Minor variation has been observed with the stage of lactation (Kammerlehner, 1974; Grandison et al., 1984b) and this may possibly be related to the calcium ion activity also. Milk from cows suffering severe mastitis exhibits poor clotting by rennet and somewhat diminished syneresis (Thome and Liljegren, 1959; Kiermeier and Keis, 1964; Kiermeier et al., 1967). Extensive growth of pseudomonads in milk was shown to reduce syneresis markedly (Lelievre et al., 1978). On the other hand, considerable proteolysis caused by plasmin activity hardly affected whey expulsion (Pearse et al., 1986b). The effect of casein composition has been studied. Pearse etal. (1986a) made milk with synthetic micelles of variable casein composition. The proportions of [3- and K-caseins clearly affected clotting time, but syneresis far less. Dephosphorylation of [3-casein caused the clotting time to increase and the syneresis rate to decrease. Interpretation of these results is very difficult without knowing such variables as micelle size and voluminosity, or loss tangent and permeability of the renneted milk. There also appears to be some correlation between syneresis and genetic variants of milk proteins, especially with the [3-1actoglobulin variant (McLean and Schaar, 1989). This may, again, be due to differences in the calcium ion activity, which correlates with the genetic variants. Other conditions being equal, renneted goats' milk exhibited greater syneresis than cows' milk, and ewes' milk syneresed less (Storry et al., 1983). It may be noted that the latter usually has a clearly higher casein content (Walstra and Jenness, 1984). The effect of several variables on syneresis of renneted cows' milk, as discussed above, was often different for either ewes' (Raynal and Remeuf, 2000) or buffaloes' milk (Dimov and Mineva, 1962).
Concluding Remarks The results on syneresis during practical cheesemaking presented here (see also a review by Pearse and Mackinlay, 1989) generally agree with experiments on
92 The Syneresis of Rennet-coagulated Curd undisturbed curd, although only in a qualitative sense. In a practical situation, quantitative predictions on syneresis rate can hardly be made. Nevertheless, it may be concluded that the main variables affecting syneresis rate are: 9 the geometrical constraints (dimension of the curd grain); 9 pressure applied to the curd (grains), where the relative effect is greatest in the low pressure range; 9 pH; 9 temperature, where the relative effect is the greatest in the low temperature range. The effect of the other variables is generally small (with the exception of intense heat treatment) and tends to be relatively smaller when overall syneresis rate is higher. Stoll (1966) observed, for instance, that stirring the curd-whey mixture almost eliminated differences caused by some variables observed when studying syneresis under quiescent conditions. This was explained by van den Bijgaart (1988) from the over-riding effect of the permeability of the outer layer of the curd grains. Any condition leading to very rapid syneresis also causes rapid development of a poorly permeable layer, which then markedly slows down any further syneresis. In a qualitative sense, this has been observed before, e.g., by Koestler and Petermann (1936). Cheesemakers speak of a 'skin' around the curd grains, and it is even assumed that very rapid initial syneresis may lead to an ultimately higher water content in the curd, as compared to a situation where syneresis proceeds more slowly; cf. the high-temperature syneresis results of Huber et al. (2001).
Behaviour of Curd during Processing When the curd grains are sufficiently dry, they are usually allowed to sediment into a 'bed' in the cheese vat or in a drainage pipe. The layer of curd grains compacts, more whey is expelled from the grains and the
Table 2
grains partly fuse to form a coherent mass. Compaction may be due to pressure exerted by the layer itself or by perforated plates laid on top. Effective pressure ranges from about 100-500 Pa. The compaction is either allowed to proceed for a considerable time, after which the curd mass is cut into small pieces ('milling', as for Cheddar types), or, after a short while, blocks of curd are cut from it, which then are subjected to moulding and pressing. The phenomena that occur during compaction and drainage are complicated. At first, compaction occurs due to sedimentation and reorientation of the curd grains. Further events are summarized in Table 2. The different processes are mutually dependent, and especially the deformation of the grains, and the expulsion of whey from them are coupled. Moreover, fusion of curd grains is greatly enhanced when they are deformed. By and large, processes 1 and 2 lead to a lower moisture content, whereas 3 impedes the loss of moisture. Fusion may proceed until the pores between the grains are no longer interconnected, when further drainage virtually stops. On the other hand, some initial fusion will promote drainage, as it can prevent further reorientation of the grains into a denser packing. These conclusions may be true enough, but they are only qualitative and thus not very helpful. To arrive at quantitative relations, the processes were studied in some detail by Akkerman (1992) and Akkerman et al. (1994) for Dutch-type cheese. Lodaite (2002) and Lodaite et al. (2002) studied curd deformation and fusion for the conditions corresponding to soft cheeses. The Akkerman group used whole milk, mostly without added starter, and made curd grains that had been left to synerese to roughly a quarter of their initial volume while Lodaite and collaborators used reconstituted skim milk, and allowed little or no syneresis to occur prior to deformation. The temperature was mostly 35 ~ Expression of single grains, fusion of a collection of grains, compaction of a column and change in pore size (distribution) in a column of grains were studied separately. Because of the many variables of importance, the
Processes occurring during compaction and drainage of a curd-whey column
Process
Results in
Depends on
Expulsion of whey from grains
Lower whey content of grains Grains less deformable Closer packing of grains Narrower pores
Degree of concentration, temperature, pH, effective pressure, free surface area of grains External pressure, pore size distribution (hence, grain size distribution and shape), geometrical constraints Deformability of grains (hence degree of concentration, temperature, pH), external pressure, duration
Drainage of whey from column
Deformation and fusion of grains
Narrower pores Smaller free surface area
The Syneresis of Rennet-coagulated Curd
intricacy of the processes and the experimental difficulties, the results are to some extent uncertain, but they clearly show quantitative trends. Syneresis under pressure
Some results of Akkerman (1992) on uniaxial expression of single grains are shown in Fig. 21. The situation was quite different from that leading to the results in Figs 11 and 12. A synerized curd grain was now involved, which implied that the outer layer was much more dense than the centre. Moreover, when the pressures were generally higher, the curd grain could deform sideways and most of the outflow of whey was in directions perpendicular to the applied force. It is seen that the grain showed an immediate, i.e., elastic, deformation, followed by a viscous one that became ever slower. If the pressure was released within a few seconds, the grain more or less regained its original shape, but after some minutes the deformation was permanent; this agrees with the average relaxation time of renneted milk of about 1 min found earlier (Zoon et al., 1989b, 1990). Analysis of the results led to the conclusion that the deformability of the grain, more precisely its effective biaxial elongational viscosity, was rate-determining, the elongational viscosity markedly depending on (decrease with) the stress applied. Akkerman (1992) defined a pseudo Poisson number, it, as: / x - 0.5
(
v)
1 - dln--~eH
(11)
where V is grain volume and eH is the relative deformation expressed as the Hencky strain. He found, as an average over the first 15 min, /.t = 0.27, almost independent of conditions. This implies that a (nearly) constant part of the decrease in height of the grain is due to shrinkage. The constancy of/x agrees with the deformability (i.e., the rheological properties) of the
6
J
E"
=
0.30 k 00Pa
0
0
500 Time (s)
'
~--~
1000
0
' t=900s
] ]
I
I
2
4
I
Pe (kPa)
Figure 21 Uniaxial compression of curd grains at constant stress, h is the height of the curd grain, t duration of pressing, i the relative remaining volume and Pe the pressure applied (from Akkerman, 1992).
93
curd now being rate-determining. As shown in Fig. 21, the deformation, and thereby the expression of whey, depends on the remaining volume, i, pressure and time. It is little dependent on the grain size. The expression reasonably followed the relation:
( i t - iinf) = e x p ( - K p e sqrt(t)) ( i o - iinf)
(12)
iinf = 0.1 and where the rate constant K = 4 • 10-5 pa-1 s-0.5. Whereas Akkerman (1992) followed compression at various constant pressures, Lodaite (2002) followed the (non-lubricated) compression of non-synerized curd at different constant (Cauchy) deformation rates. Some results are given in Fig. 22. The pressure was seen to increase more or less proportionally with deformation, but not in proportion with the deformation rate. The pressures observed were much lower than what would correspond to the permeability of the curd; this presumably means that during deformation, minute cracks appeared in the curd, vastly increasing its permeability. An empirical formula of the form of Hooke's law, with a compression rate-dependent modulus, described the data: with
p~ = E (1 - i)
(13)
with E = K' (d(1 - i)/dt) 3/4 and K' - 40 kPa s -3/4 The effect of pH was not studied, but in view of the effect of pH on the rheological properties of renneted milk (see e.g., Fig. 1) and cheese, it must be significant. Curd fusion
Akkerman (1992) and Akkerman et al. (1993) evaluated the fusion of curd grains in a curd-whey column by determining the fracture stress when pulling two parts of the column, separated by a perforated plate, away from each other. The force divided by the contact area of the grains was taken as the fracture stress. The pressure and time during which it was applied had a strong effect. At 34 ~ the fracture stress obtained was about 60% higher than at 32 ~ whereas at 36 ~ it was, maybe, somewhat lower again. The less the grains had shrunk prior to the experiment, the higher the fracture stress. Lodaite (2002) and Lodaite et al. (2002) devised a method for measuring fusion on a single grain pressed against a thin layer of curd, allowing the simultaneous measurement of deformation. Fusion pressure, fusion time and syneresis time, temperature, pH (6.0 and 6.4)
94
The Syneresis
of R e n n e t - c o a g u l a t e d
Curd
Compaction
25
The compaction of a curd column was studied (Akkerman, 1992; Akkerman et al., 1994) for radial drainage. The results depended strongly on the geometrical constraints, especially the radius of the column. The curd particles tended to stick to the wall, and leakage along the wall was also of importance. The total pressure exerted was, following Schwartzberg et al. (1985), presumed composed of three terms:
e
20
i , i n
i
15 i m i i e e lip
10 e lad
~"
I
I
u = 0.1 mm min -1 I I I
I
I
I
I
I
Tw
|
|
|
|
|
0.0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
500
13_ mat) m
m .-> mat)
400 300
m ~D Q.
E
200
O
o
100 min-1
1500 1200 900
600 300
Pe = Pc + Pl + Pw
21
0.6
Relative deformation
Figure 22 Uniaxial compression of a curd slab at different constant Cauchy strain rates. The initial slab height = 5 mm, u = linear compression rate (from Lodaite, 2002).
(14)
A part of the pressure is lost by Diction to the wall (subscript w), and the remainder may not only be on the network of curd particles (subscript c), but also on the liquid (subscript 1). As soon as the outflow of whey is hindered by a lack of interconnected pores, the pressure on the liquid increases rapidly. If the pores become completely disconnected, all the pressure is exerted on the liquid (except for Pw) or, in other words, the pressure is isotropic, and expression from the curd grains stops. Some results are shown in Fig. 24. The total pressure exerted appears to be the dominant variable. For a low Pe, the expression increases strongly with pressure, roughly following equation (12). But above a certain Pe, called the threshold pressure, any higher pressure leads to a progressively increasing p]. Also, the pressure loss at the wall, Pw, markedly increases with total pressure, being, for instance, proportional to pe 2.5. Altogether, at a high Pe the effective pressure on the grains, Pc, soon becomes very small and expression (almost) stops. The other results in Fig. 24 speak for themselves; note the very strong decrease of the
in-1 0
of a c u r d c o l u m n
,---, a. m
m
9 0-2 kPa, 500 s 9 1 kPa, 0-1500 s
1.I
.i--,
and casein and rennet concentrations were varied. It was concluded that the total deformation (which is of course dependent on fusion pressure and time) was the best predictor of fusion, and for a given total deformation, the fusion was independent of pH and rennet concentration. The fusion-deformation relationship appears to hold even for the results of Akkerman (1992) and Akkerman et al. (1993) (see Fig. 23). Lodaite et al. (2002) confirmed the strong effect of temperature in the studied range 28-33 ~
~- 0 . 5 ! 0
0
9
tt
9
,
,
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
Relative deformation
Figure 23 Strength of fusion of curd grains in a column expressed as the fracture stress o-f after pressing for various times at various pressures as a function of deformation (recalculated from Equation 12 from results by Akkerman, 1992).
The Syneresis of Rennet-coagulated Curd
I
1
3O E
.9.o
450 2100
0.1
-
530
i
2-
E E v "13 1 -
i
04
E 10-1~
10-12 0
0.5 Time (ks)
Figure 24 Compression of a curd-whey column (radius 6 cm) under uniaxial compression and with radial drainage. Column height (h), volume fraction of pores (#,v), volume- average apparent pore diameter (d) and average radial permeability (B*) calculated as a function of time after applying pressure (indicated near the curves, Pa) (from results by Akkerman, 1992).
permeability of the curd column with time, despite Pe being fairly small. Other variables affecting drainage are the degree of concentration of the curd grains at the beginning, given as i0, and the temperature. For a higher i0 and a higher temperature, the initial rate of compaction is higher, but the threshold pressure mentioned above is lower; in other words, the highest pressure that can be applied for the drainage to proceed satisfactorily is smaller (Akkerman et al., 1996). Threshold pressures are mostly somewhere between 800 and 2000 Pa; they depend considerably on the geometry of the system. The presence of curd fines may strongly lower the
95
drainage rate, as the fine particles tend to block the pores between the grains; the threshold pressure now is much lower. It must be assumed that the curd particle size (average and spread) has some influence, but not a lot within the range studied. The effect of pH was not estimated. Akkerman etal. (1995) further compared the results obtained for single grains with the compaction of a curd column by developing a computer model of the process. Up to pressures of a few hundred Pa, the calculated results agreed reasonably well with the experimental data. He also concluded that at a high Pe the curd grains can, in principle, initially be expressed quite fast, without the pressure on the liquid, P1 becoming substantial. This opens up possibilities for improving the drainage process. In the Wageningen laboratory, some preliminary studies on axial drainage in a curd column were performed under a wider range of conditions (Heerink and Geurts, 1981); actually there may have been considerable radial drainage as well. Curd was made from skim milk, without a starter. After cutting and stirring (and removing some whey), a column of curd and whey, 30 cm high, was taken; the curd sedimented almost immediately to a height of about 20 cm, after which pressure was applied via a perforated disc, and the curd column gradually compressed to a height of, for instance, 5 cm; the compression was allowed to proceed for 90 min. The final moisture content of the curd column was determined and the earlier values were calculated from the change in height and expressed as the mass fraction of moisture (moisture means liquid containing dissolved substances, i.e., whey in this case). The proportion of moisture between the grains was originally about 40%. Also here, very high pressures gave little improvement. At 20 ~ very little whey was expelled from the curd grains, in accordance with the strong dependence of the apparent curd viscosity (Zoon et al., 1988b) and of syneresis on temperature. Some of the conclusions drawn in this section may in a sense be derived from earlier observations (Vas, 1931; Tarodo de la Fuente and Alais, 1975; Lelievre, 1977; Lelievre and Creamer, 1978; Johnston and Murphy, 1984; Grandison et al., 1984a). Especially interesting is the work of Scott Blair and Coppen (1940), who reasoned that firmer curd grains would permit faster drainage of whey from a mass of grains, and made use of this in devising a test method to determine the 'pitching point' of the curd, i.e., the moment at which the grains have lost sufficient moisture, and stirring can cease. A volume of curds and whey is put into a perforated cylinder and allowed to drain for a fixed time; now the 'superficial density' is determined,
96
The Syneresis of Rennet-coagulated Curd
i.e., the weight of curd divided by the height of the curd column. They found a fairly good positive correlation between the water content and the superficial density, indicating that high moisture, and, thus, soft grains deformed rapidly to close the channels between them, thereby greatly hindering further drainage. Firm (i.e., 'dry') grains permitted ongoing drainage, leading to a low superficial density, because the voids between particles now become filled with air. As is to be expected, other factors affect the draining rate. Scott Blair and Coppen (1940) found for the same value of superficial density, a range in water content of about 14 percentage units. There was a tendency for rapid initial syneresis, hence presumably the presence of a more or less rigid 'skin' around the curd grains, to lead to a lower superficial density. Likewise, curd at a lower pH (Cheshire as compared to Cheddar) tended to have a lower superficial density. It would be useful to study these and other variables in greater detail. The water content of cheese
There obviously is a lowest possible water content of (freshly made) c h e e s e - the para-casein particles have a given voluminosity. This aspect was reviewed by Walstra et al. (1985) and it was concluded that few hard conclusions can be drawn. The equilibrium voluminosity of para-casein micelles at room temperature and physiological pH was roughly estimated to correspond to 1.4 g water per g protein; this would come down to a water content of an unsalted full-cream cheese of about 40%. The voluminosity would be lower for a lower pH and a higher temperature. The latter effect is considerable. It is also known that a cheese or curd may take up moisture when the temperature is lowered (e.g., Delbeke arid Naudts (1970), on Herve cheese; results obtained in the Wageningen laboratory on renneted milk uhrafihration retentate at pH 5.2; observations in the Lund laboratory on renneted microfiltration retentates at pH 6, observations in practice on Feta cheese kept in brine). The dependence is corrobated by the results of Teo et al. (1996) on reconstituted renneted casein. Moderate NaC1 concentrations increase the voluminosity of both native (Famelart et al., 1999) and renneted (Creamer, 1985) casein micelles. Electron microscopy observations indicated that the volume of the casein matrix increased, and the volume of the interstitial dilute phase decreased in salt-injected Muenster cheese (Pastorino et al., 2003) and salted non-fat Mozzarella (Paulson et al., 1998). This would appear to be in contradicton to a large number of studies showing that a higher salt content correlates with a lower level of moisture in cheese, but during salting in
brine or in dry salt, cheeses lose water by pseudoosmosis to the highly concentrated brine (Geurts et al., 1974), and thus other things being equal, the more heavily salted the cheese is the more drier it will be. In a cheese, the lowest possible water to protein ratio may be slightly lower for a lower fat content; in practice, a lower fat in dry matter content always goes along with a distinctly lower water to protein ratio, but this presumably is due to faster syneresis. Altogether, the final moisture content of most cheeses is determined primarily by the rate and the duration of the processes causing whey expulsion, rather than by the equilibrium-swelling state of the para-casein. After curd-making and drainage, one of the following procedures is usually applied. 9 Moulding the curd, followed by further drainage under its own weight; this is applied only for fairly soft cheese. 9 Moulding and pressing the curd; this is the common method for semi-hard and several hard cheeses. 9 Letting the curd rest for a considerable time to develop sufficient acidity (often while allowing the curd to flow, e.g., cheddaring) after which the coherent curd mass is cut into fairly small pieces (milling), salted, moulded and pressed. 9 Intensively working the already acidified curd (pH 5.3) at a quite high temperature, as is done in making pasta-filata cheeses. During several of these process steps, the curd may lose considerable moisture. Merely taking the curd out of the whey, allowing further whey to leak out, has already a marked effect; see e.g., Figs I3 and 25. Sometimes, the curd grains are worked after removal from the whey, which leads to a much drier cheese with an open texture (numerous small, irregularly shaped holes). The pastafilata treatment also causes appreciable loss of moisture (high temperature and pressure), although the fairly large size of the lumps of curd formed has a mitigating effect (long distance and relatively small surface area). Pressing of the curd mass is aimed at obtaining a coherent mass with a closed rind. The formation of a rind, i.e., an outer layer in which all the curd grains are fully fused with their neighbours, is greatly favoured by the possibility of rapid removal of moisture from the outer layer, for instance by application of a cloth around the curd mass (Mulder et al., 1966). The closed rind greatly reduces further expression of moisture. Figure 24 shows that the effective permeability of a drained mass of curd is about 10 -12 m 2, which still allows considerable flow of moisture under a pressure of 10-100 kPa, which are common in practice. The permeability in the outer layer may be as low as 10 -16 m 2 or less, and even a layer of a few mm then makes a substantial barrier.
T h e S y n e r e s i s of R e n n e t - c o a g u l a t e d Curd
The effects of moulding, pressing and resting on the moisture content have been carefully studied by Geurts (1978) and some results are shown in Fig. 25. It is seen that the lower the moisture content before pressing, the less the further loss of moisture. The initial water content has other important consequences. First, consider the situation where it is high, say about 55% at the beginning of pressing. Now, pressing at an earlier stage or at a higher pressure leads to a higher water content (more precisely, a less reduced water content); the difference is of the order of 1% water.
60] 50
I
I
I
I
I
The explanation is that a closed rind is formed at an earlier stage or of a greater thickness. Pressing at a higher initial temperature or having a larger loaf of curd led to a lower water content. Although a higher temperature implies a softer curd, and thereby presumably easier rind formation, the overriding effect seems to be the effect of temperature itself on syneresis (see e.g., Fig. 10). A smaller loaf will cool faster and thereby lose less moisture (see Fig. 25). These relations are rather different if the curd mass has a low water content at the beginning of pressing, say 40%. (Such a low water content can be obtained only by prolonged stirring at a high temperature and letting the pH decrease appreciably.) A higher pressure, a smaller loaf and a lower temperature all lead to a lower water content. Presumably, it takes a longer time to obtain a closed rind, the more so for a lower temperature, whereby more moisture can be pressed out of the loaf before the rind is formed. Geurts (1978) also studied the distribution of moisture in unsalted cheese. Some results are shown in Fig. 26. Apart from a thin outer layer, i.e., the rind, which has a slightly reduced water content, the lowest water content is at the centre. This is the region where the temperature has remained highest, especially in a large loaf. It was even observed that the temperature increased in the greater part of a large loaf, undoubtedly due to the heat generated by the growing starter bacteria. If an unsalted cheese is left to rest, the water content tends to become somewhat lower at the bottom side. It may thus be concluded that the moisture moves away from regions where the temperature is higher and/or the pressure higher than elsewhere. Soon, however, the process of fusion of curd grains
- ....... i
4O
0
I
5 Time (h)
0
10
Figure 25 Water content of a loaf of curd as a function of time after moulding. The dotted lines give the assumed course during pressing. Spherical loaves of about 22 cm diameter, except for one of 12 cm (designated S) (from Geurts, 1978).
v
_
9
~
- - -~q~ c'o O .,,_, c-
1-kg CHEESE 9
45 -
9
9
9
_
I
oo
Oo 0
9
9
00
O
e_~_e
0
- - -
0
0
c0 o
97
0 O O
6-kg CHEESE
._~ 0
0 000000~0
O
9
0000
41-
% I
0
I
40
I
I
I
[
80
120
I
I
160
I
I
200
mm
Figure 26 Water distributions in unsalted spherical cheeses (1 and 6 kg), moulded from the same curd, lightly pressed and kept for a few days. The broken lines indicate the average water content (from Geurts, 1978).
98 The Syneresis of Rennet-coagulated Curd becomes complete, say after two days (Luyten, 1988), and the permeability of the cheese mass becomes too low to permit appreciable transport of moisture. In several types of cheese, the drained mass of curd is allowed to spread laterally for a considerable time ('cheddaring'). Olson and Price (1970) found that this led to a higher moisture content (1-2% more water), compared to curd kept for the same time but which was prevented from spreading. Although cheddaring may have caused a slightly lower average temperature, the main cause for the differences was presumably that the flow of curd promoted deformation of the curd grains; hence, closing of pores between grains and hindering drainage of any moisture, still leaving the grains due to syneresis. The water content of the cheese must, to a considerable extent, depend on the amount of syneresis during curd preparation, and the results for syneresis as given earlier, indeed qualitatively, agree with results on the water content of cheese (e.g., Sammis et al., 1910; Whitehead, 1948; Whitehead and Harkness, 1954; Birkkjaer et al., 1961; Feagan et al., 1965; Straatsma and Heijnekamp, 1988). Whether there is exact agreement is uncertain. The water content of cheese always shows considerable random variation (e.g., Straatsma et al., 1984) and this makes exact comparisons difficult. During cheesemaking, conditions usually change, for instance pH, temperature and effective pressure acting on the curd, so that one has to take some kind of average. Moreover, the factors are inter-related; for instance, temperature affects the rate of acidification. The latter is also affected by oxygen content (Gillies,
+2-
c"
0
-
~
1959) and this may explain why some authors found a negative correlation between stirring rate of the curds-whey mixture and the final water content of the cheese (Kiermeier and von Wfillerstorf, 1963); presumably, faster stirring caused a higher oxygen content, hence inhibition of starter bacteria, slower acidification, and consequently le