Cognitive and Communicative Approaches to Linguistic Analysis
Studies in Functional and Structural Linguistics (SFSL) Taking the broadest and most general definitions of the terms functional and structural, this series aims to present linguistic and interdisciplinary research that relates language structure — at any level of analysis from phonology to discourse — to broader functional considerations, whether cognitive, communicative, pragmatic or sociocultural. Preference will be given to studies that focus on data from actual discourse, whether speech, writing or other nonvocal medium. The series was formerly known as Linguistic & Literary Studies in Eastern Europe (LLSEE).
Founding Editor John Odmark Honorary Editors Eva Hajicˇová
Petr Sgall
Charles University
Charles University
General Editors Yishai Tobin
Ellen Contini-Morava
Ben-Gurion University of the Negev
University of Virginia
Editorial Board Alexandra Y. Aikhenvald
Jim Miller
La Trobe University
University of Auckland
Joan Bybee
Marianne Mithun
University of New Mexico
University of California, at Santa Barbara
Nicholas Evans
Lawrence J. Raphael
University of Melbourne
Emeritus CUNY
Victor A. Friedman
Olga Mišeska Tomic´
University of Chicago
Leiden University
Anatoly Liberman
Olga T. Yokoyama
University of Minnesota
UCLA
James A. Matisoff University of California, Berkeley
Volume 51 Cognitive and Communicative Approaches to Linguistic Analysis Edited by Ellen Contini-Morava, Robert S. Kirsner and Betsy Rodríguez-Bachiller
Cognitive and Communicative Approaches to Linguistic Analysis Edited by
Ellen Contini-Morava University of Virginia
Robert S. Kirsner University of California, Los Angeles
Betsy Rodríguez-Bachiller Kean University
John Benjamins Publishing Company Amsterdam/Philadelphia
8
TM
The paper used in this publication meets the minimum requirements of American National Standard for Information Sciences – Permanence of Paper for Printed Library Materials, ansi z39.48-1984.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data International Columbia School Conference on Linguistics (6th : 1999 : Rutgers University) Cognitive and communicative approaches to linguistic analysis / edited by Ellen Contini-Morava, Robert S. Kirsner and Betsy Rodríguez-Bachiller. p. cm. (Studies in functional and structural linguistics, issn 0165–7712 ; v. 51) Chiefly revisions of papers presented at the 6th International Columbia School Conference on Linguistics held at Rutgers University in Oct. 1999. Includes bibliographical references and index. 1. Linguistic analysis (Linguistics)--Congresses. 2. Cognitive grammar--Congresses. 3. Semantics--Congresses. 4. Semiotics-Congresses. I. Contini-Morava, Ellen, 1948- II. Kirsner, Robert S., 1941III. Rodríguez-Bachiller, Betsy. IV. Title. V. Series. P126.I58 2004 410--dc22 isbn 90 272 1560 X (Eur.) / 1 58811 566 6 (US) (Hb; alk. paper)
2004057066
© 2004 – John Benjamins B.V. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form, by print, photoprint, microfilm, or any other means, without written permission from the publisher. John Benjamins Publishing Co. · P.O. Box 36224 · 1020 me Amsterdam · The Netherlands John Benjamins North America · P.O. Box 27519 · Philadelphia pa 19118-0519 · usa
Contents List of contributors Introduction Robert S. Kirsner
vii
Part I: Cognitive Grammar 1. Form, meaning, and behavior Ronald W. Langacker
2
2. Cataphoric pronouns as mental space designators Michael B. Smith
6
Part II: Theoretical issues in classical sign-based linguistics 3. Monosemy, homonymy and polysemy Wallis Reid 4. On the relationship between form and grammatical meaning in the linguistic sign Mark J. Elson 5. Revisiting the gap between meaning and message Joseph Davis
93
3 55
Part III: Analyses on the level of the classic linguistic sign 6. The givenness of background Zhuo Jing
77
7. The relevance of relevance in linguistic analysis Bob de Jonge
205
8. A sign-based analysis of English pronouns in conjoined expressions Nancy Stern
29
9. Semantic oppositions in the Hebrew verb system Noah Oron and Yishai Tobin
235
10. Grammaticization of ‘to’ and ‘away’ Kumiko Ichihashi-Nakayama
26
vi
Contents
Part IV: Below and above the level of the sign 11. Interaction of physiology and communication in the make-up and distribution of stops in Lucknow Urdu Shabana Hameed
277
12. Between phonology and lexicon Yishai Tobin
289
13. Length of the extra-information phrase as a predictor of word order Ricardo Otheguy, Betsy Rodríguez-Bachiller, and Eulalia Canals
325
14. Word-order variation in spoken Spanish in constructions with a verb, a direct object, and an adverb Francisco Ocampo
34
15. Estrategias discursivas como parámetros para el análisis lingüístico Angelita Martínez
36
Index of names Index of subjects
38 384
List of contributors Eulalia Canals 1517 8th Avenue Brooklyn, NY 11215 USA
[email protected]
Zhuo Jing Heinrich Heine Strasse 64 D-45657 Recklinghausen Germany
[email protected]
Ellen Contini-Morava Department of Anthropology University of Virginia Charlottesville, VA 22906 USA
[email protected]
Bob de Jonge Dept. of Romance Studies Arts Faculty, Groningen University P.O. Box 716 9700 AS Groningen The Netherlands
[email protected]
Joseph Davis School of Education, R6207-A City College New York, NY 10031 USA
[email protected] Mark J. Elson Slavic Languages and Literatures PO Box 400783, 109 Cabell Hall University of Virginia Charlottesville, VA 22904-4783 USA
[email protected] Shabana Hameed “Baitul Hameed” 4/1407 Medical College Road Aligarh – 202002 U.P. India shabhameed@rediffmail.com Kumiko Ichihashi-Nakayama 1-29-78 Tama-cho Fuchu-shi, Tokyo 183-0002 Japan
[email protected]
Robert S. Kirsner Department of Germanic Languages 212 Royce Hall – UCLA Los Angeles, CA 90095-1539 USA
[email protected] Ronald Langacker Linguistics, 0108 University of California, San Diego La Jolla, CA 92093-0108 USA
[email protected] Angelita Martínez Juncal 655, Primer piso – A 1062 Buenos Aires Argentina angema@filo.uba.ar Francisco Ocampo University of Minnesota Department of Spanish and Portuguese 37 Folwell Hall, 9 Pleasant St. S.E. Minneapolis, MN 55455 USA
[email protected]
viii
List of contributors
Noah Oron Department of Foreign Literatures & Department of Behavioral Sciences Ben-Gurion University of the Negev P.O. Box 653 84105 Be’er Sheva Israel
[email protected] Ricardo Otheguy Graduate Center, CUNY 365 Fifth Avenue New York, NY 10016 USA
[email protected] Wallis Reid Graduate School of Education Rutgers University New Brunswick, NJ 08903 USA
[email protected] Betsy Rodríguez-Bachiller Department of English Kean University Union, NJ 07083 USA
[email protected]
Michael B. Smith Department of Linguistics 320 O’Dowd Hall Oakland University Rochester, MI 48309 USA
[email protected] Nancy Stern School of Education, R6/207B City College New York, NY 10031 USA
[email protected] Yishai Tobin Department of Foreign Literatures and Department of Behavioral Sciences Ben-Gurion University of the Negev P.O. Box 653 84105 Be’er Sheva Israel
[email protected]
Introduction On paradigms, analyses, and dialogue Robert S. Kirsner University of California, Los Angeles
He who knows only his own side of the case knows little of that. His reasons may be good, and no one may have been able to refute them. But if he is equally unable to refute the reasons on the opposite side, if he does not so much as know what they are, he has no ground for preferring either opinion. John Stuart Mill, On Liberty
The majority of the fifteen chapters included in this volume are revised and expanded versions of talks originally presented at the Sixth International Columbia School Conference held at Rutgers University in October 1999. This conference was notable for attempting to bring about not only an exchange of ideas between various sign-based linguists — Columbia School, Guillaumean, and others — but also, and perhaps more importantly, a dialogue between sign-based linguists and representatives of Cognitive linguistics.¹ Significantly, one of the plenary speakers was Ronald W. Langacker who, together with George Lakoff, founded the movement in linguistics which has come to be known as Cognitive Grammar. The title of this volume — opposing Cognitive and Communicative — refers to the fact that while Cognitive linguistics views language as an example of cognition and invokes such notions as concepts, thoughts, and imagery in all their richness (Langacker 1991: Chapter 1), sign-based linguistics, in particular the Columbia School, draws a rather strict line between the linguistic system itself as a purely communicative instrument (one which may offer only the sparsest and roughest hints towards the message the speaker wishes to convey) and that message itself and how it is conceptualized by and dealt with by language users. As Contini-Morava puts it (1995: 8): Thus the main distinguishing characteristic of sign based grammatical theory is the principle of one form — one meaning. This principle, like the linguistic sign itself, follows from the function of language as a communicative instrument. The most efficient communicative instrument is one in which there is a one-to-one correspondence between the signaling units and the things signaled. It therefore makes sense, if one is beginning with a functional orientation, to use this as an initial methodological assumption when beginning a linguistic analysis. Of course, the extent to which the one-form — one-meaning principle holds in a given case is an empirical question since . . . neither forms nor meanings are given in advance of an analysis.
2
Robert S. Kirsner
Consider in this vein also the characterization of the Columbia School as a “minimalist” linguistics versus Cognitive Grammar as a “maximalist” linguistics in Kirsner (1993: 81–82) and the suggestion that the two approaches are at least in part complementary. The chapters contained in this volume testify that dialogue between sign-based linguistics and Cognitive Grammar is indeed possible. To be sure, the individual members of the various approaches represented are not necessarily ready to abandon their own frameworks. Nevertheless, they demonstrated a willingness to consider the perspectives on language and linguistic data which other frameworks can provide. This book constitutes an invitation to the reader to undertake the same sort of critical comparison. What is learned from one approach which is not learned from the other, and vice-versa? What are the strengths and weaknesses of each approach? While it seems simply silly to compare and contrast entities as dissimilar as apples, paperclips, and kangaroos, it is possible to compare apples, grapes, and oranges. Similarly, while a comparison of Columbia School Linguistics with Generative Grammar might be of little use, because of the tremendous differences in the two schools’ orienting premises,² comparison and contrast between Cognitive Grammar and the Columbia School is potentially fruitful; cf. Langacker’s assertion (1987: 4) that there is a “natural affinity” between Cognitive Grammar and the Columbia School. In spite of the fact that some Columbia School linguists have felt otherwise (e.g. Contini-Morava 1989: 35–44; Huffman 1997: 21–23, 329–333), one can suggest that each school ignores the criticism of the other only at its own peril: cf. Kirsner (1993: 103–107; 2003). There are perhaps two ways of introducing these chapters. The first might be in terms of style of argument and presentation. The chapters by Langacker and Reid may both be called examples of “interparadigmatic dialogue” in that, in addition to presenting an illustrative analysis, each discusses and evaluates the other’s theoretical framework. (Because of the importance of this dialogue, I shall discuss these two chapters in more detail than the others.) Davis’s chapter, in contrast, may be considered “intraparadigmatic dialogue” in that it suggests a refinement within Columbia School theory, taking issue with earlier Columbia School analyses, but without comparing that theory with others. The remaining chapters are all “paradigmatic monologues.” Each presents an analysis within a single theoretical paradigm, arguing against previous traditional or generative analyses of the relevant phenomena, but without directly taking issue with either the Columbia School or Cognitive Grammar. Each analysis itself is to be taken as a demonstration of how its theoretical framework can be applied and as a recommendation to the reader to consider seriously the specific theoretical principles which underlie the analysis. The only chapter which might not to seem to fit here is Ocampo’s, but his might perhaps be viewed as a useful example of “the agnostic paradigm of paradigmlessness”; i.e., as illustrating a largely a-theoretical search for patterns in data. The second and perhaps more direct and transparent way of introducing the chapters is to survey them simply as listed in the Table of Contents, where — purely
Paradigms, analyses, and dialogue
for the sake of convenience — they are sorted into four categories, depending on whether they (a) focus on Cognitive linguistics, (b) present theoretical and methodological discussions within sign-based linguistics, (c) present analyses of units the “size” of or at the level of the classical linguistic sign, or (d) discuss units or combinations of units at other levels above or below the analytical level of the classical linguistic sign (in traditional terms: phonology, morphology, “syntax”, and discourse). A second principle for ordering the chapters, used within (b) and (c), was to proceed from the central or most paradigmatic examples of Columbia School work to approaches taking issue with it or mixing it with other approaches. To begin at the beginning, then: Part I, containing two chapters, focuses on Cognitive linguistics. Ronald W. Langacker’s “Form, meaning, and behavior: The Cognitive Grammar analysis of double subject constructions” first succinctly reviews the basic conceptual apparatus of Cognitive Grammar, from which it is immediately apparent that this approach embraces many notions such as construction and constituency, subject and topic which have no clear counterpart in the Columbia School. Langacker’s subsequent discussion of double subject constructions in a number of languages raises a crucial issue for all sign-based linguists and certainly for Columbia School linguists. How legitimate is it to apply the very same term — double subject — to widely different languages with different morphologies? From a Columbia School perspective, very different signal-meaning units are utilized in the different languages, with substantively very different meanings, and different oppositional structures among those meanings, and different inferential routines made possible by the different meanings. Langacker argues that the striking similarity in semantic-pragmatic mechanisms underlying the use of such constructions across many languages forces the linguist to recognize double subjects as a genuine linguistic phenomenon requiring a unified analysis. In other words, the functional similarities are judged as outweighing, are more important than, the structural differences between the languages. In the final section of his chapter, Langacker presents a critique of the Columbia School. With considerable wit, he discusses various Columbia School concepts (e.g., strategies for the communicative exploitation of a meaning as something separate from that meaning) and forms of Columbia School argumentation, such as the “slippery-slope” rhetoric invoked to refute the notion of polysemous signs.³ Confronted with reasoning like “If X is allowed, there will be a natural progression to Y”, where Y is a totally arbitrary stopping point, to be rejected because of its very arbitrariness,⁴ Langacker offers the observation that “by refusing to descend a slippery slope one does not succeed in making the landscape flat.” He asserts that the “where does one stop?” question does in fact have an answer if one makes use of the Cognitive Grammar concepts of entrenchment, conventionalization and the notion of structured polysemy (cf. Nikiforidou 1991). An additional point which Langacker raises repeatedly is the relatively limited scope of phenomena for which the Columbia School takes analytical responsibility: “The more narrowly linguists define their own work, the less they will contribute to the global enterprise of figuring out how
3
4
Robert S. Kirsner
language works.” All in all, Langacker has done Columbia School linguists a great service by familiarizing himself with their approach and crafting a reasoned and provocative rebuttal to some of its concepts and argumentation. Nevertheless, areas of disagreement will remain. One point in Langacker’s chapter that Columbia School linguists would vigorously dispute is his claim that Columbia School theory involves “a tacit assumption that the meaning of a whole is merely the sum of the abstract meanings of its parts (i.e. the component lexical items), and that anything beyond this is attributable to contextual interpretation based on communicative strategies and other ‘human factors’”. In particular, Langacker asserts that a Columbia School analysis would have no way to explain the difference in interpretation between The big dog frightened a tiny cat and A big cat frightened the tiny dog because they consist of the same lexical items. This is not the case. A Columbia School account of these English sentences would invoke not only the meanings of the lexical items, but also two explicit word-order signals: the order AdjectiveNoun, a signal within the grammatical system of DIFFERENTIATION, and the order Participant1-Event-Participant2, a signal within the grammatical system DEGREE OF CONTROL.⁵ Of course, the Columbia School does not treat all orderings of words as explicit grammatical signals. The question of which orderings of which elements are to be taken as explicit signals in a given language as well as the question of how to explain the effects of word order when it cannot be considered a signal are analytical problems which must be handled on a case by case basis; see Otheguy et al, and Ocampo, this volume, for discussion. However, it must also be acknowledged that word order phenomena have not been a major focus of Columbia School research. Whether this is a weakness returns us to the question, explicit or implicit in all the chapters in this volume, of how the linguist defines the object of study. The second chapter exemplifying the Cognitive Grammar approach, Michael B. Smith’s “Cataphoric pronouns as mental-space designators,” utilizes Giles Fauconnier’s theory of mental spaces and concepts of iconicity developed by John Haiman to analyze sentences in English, German, and Russian such as We abhor it that the mayor absconded with the money versus We know that the mayor absconded with the money versus * We know it that the mayor absconded with the money. Smith argues that English it, German es, and Russian tot refer to the mental space (or “knowledge structure”) created by certain “structure-building” verbs: in these examples, the referent of the subordinate clause. On the one hand, such “prefiguring” of the subordinate clause with an it, es, or tot can increase the conceptual distance between the verb and the clause. Its presence or absence seems to correlate with whether the event or state of affairs referred to by the clause is viewed as unfavorable or not (so that the speaker would want to “distance” himself from it); cf. abhor versus know above. In other instances, the cataphoric pronoun, providing an additional reference to the content of the subordinate clause, communicates a foregrounding of, or emphasis on, that content. For example, with verbs which can communicate either cerebral knowledge or sensory experience, presence of a cataphoric pronoun favors the “sensory experience” reading. Compare Henry loves to read timetables. He even
Paradigms, analyses, and dialogue
knows when the Pennsylvania train arrives versus If you live near the Santa Monica Airport, you (really) know it when the planes land. Why the whole house vibrates! Theoretical issues which arise in “classical” sign-based analysis are the focus of Part II of the volume. Presenting an analysis of the English prepositions in, on, and at, Wallis Reid’s “Monosemy, homonymy, and polysemy” provides an articulate and vigorous defense of what John Taylor, in a number of publications, has called the “two-level” model or the “semiotic model” (2003), one which — as the Columbia School does — rigorously distinguishes between “a linguistic-semantic level of meaning, and an essentially non-linguistic, conceptual level of interpretation” (Taylor 1995b: 3–13). This two-level model, in contrast to Langacker’s network model of meaning (1988), rejects the concept of polysemy as a pre-theoretical folk notion. The first argument Reid offers for this rejection is that the concept of polysemy does not fit with the Columbia School’s view of linguistic meaning as instrumental rather than necessarily representational: cf. Huffman (1997). Whether language is in fact representational is an empirical issue, to be decided by actual analyses, and one should not adopt a richer theory before first seeing if a sparser theory works. If the message communicated with an utterance is in fact not built up in a water-tight manner from meanings acting like little semantic building blocks or Lego pieces, but is instead inferred from meanings envisaged as rough hints (which taken together comprise the barest “semantic skeleton” consonant with the message), then various contrasts in extra-linguistic reality need not be viewed as being built into the language itself. In other words, an analysis of in as a purely linguistic signal — a hint rather than a picture of a scene — need not differentiate between the different sorts of physical locations of the referents of bird, bullet, coffee, and crack in There’s a bird in the tree ( ’ in the tree’s branches), There’s a bullet in the tree ( ’ in the tree’s trunk), There is coffee in the cup ( ’ in the hollow cavity formed by the glass or plastic or bronze making up the cup), and There’s a crack in the cup ( ’ in the material out of which the cup is formed, creating the above mentioned cavity, but probably not the material making up the handle).⁶ More crucial for the consideration of English as a communicative instrument (rather than a representational device) are the contrasts, the oppositions, between the prepositions in Hank met Nancy at/on/in the street or The lumberjack is at the tree (’ standing at the base of the vertical tree, waiting to begin work), The lumberjack is in the tree (’ standing among and enveloped by the branches, sawing off the smaller branches before the larger ones and before attacking the trunk), and The lumberjack is on the tree (’ standing on top of the upper surface of the now sawed-down tree, which is lying horizontally on the ground). A second reason Reid offers for rejecting polysemy, first articulated by Ruhl (1989), is that many signs appear to be polysemous only because they are analyzed by linguists relying on their own intuitions and contemplating artificial data separated from any context. That way, one simply cannot see the contribution of the context to the message communicated with the word. Once one examines large numbers of attested uses of the word in full context, as in Ruhl (2002), what at first appeared to be clearly distinct isolated senses, with “spaces in between,” merge into a continuum
5
6
Robert S. Kirsner
which cannot be chopped up on a principled basis into distinct, discrete units.⁷ Ockham’s razor then requires one to at least consider a monosemic analysis. Without recapitulating Reid’s analysis here, we draw attention to the fact that he uses several concepts analogous to those invoked by Cognitive Grammar but accords them a different theoretical status. Reid discusses conceptualization at length, but views different conceptualizations as different extralinguistic strategies for the use of a (monosemic) meaning rather than different (polysemous) meanings in themselves. For example, Reid proposes that there is a conventionalized trajectory strategy for the use of on, based on the use of on for linear location (The bird is on the telephone wire) and linear movement (The plain is on course), which accounts for the difference between get in the car and get on the bus. Buses, as part of a public transportation system, follow a known sequence — a fixed trajectory — of scheduled stops; private cars do not. (Of course one can say Pete got in the bus, but the message probably involves a private bus, perhaps a Volkswagen Minibus. And if you do say He got on the minibus, you are suggesting that the minibus in question is now following a known trajectory; perhaps it is a shuttle bus, picking up people at their homes but taking them all to a fixed destination, such as the airport.)⁸ A crucial point is that for Reid, conventionalized strategies for exploiting meanings, based on specific conceptualizations of reality, are no more a part of the communicative instrument called a language than Bach fugues are a part of the musical instrument called a harpsichord. Just as it takes years of practice for a harpsichordist to learn to meld individual notes into a product understood as music by an audience, so does it take years of practice for the language user to learn to manipulate the individual meanings signaled by the individual signals of the language to produce utterances which are understood as communicating something by his or her interlocutor. What Reid is suggesting is that an analysis of a language as a communicative instrument (illustrated here with in, on and at) should concern itself primarily if not exclusively with what is in the instrument itself, what its structure is, and nothing else, just as the analysis of a harpsichord should lay out the strings and the bridge and the nut and the registers and the keyboard, etc., but not discuss the musical styles of Johann Sebastian Bach or Theolonius Monk or the set of skills which a competent harpsichordist needs to have acquired. The problem which now presents itself is really nothing less than that of the very purpose of linguistics. How immediately “useful” should a linguistic theory be and in what ways? How much of the usage of a language is it the linguist’s obligation to explain and describe and how much is the responsibility of other disciplines? Should the linguistic analysis of a language be instantly and directly convertible into a textbook for learning that language, as the Cognitivist’s reluctance to separate linguistic from cultural and encyclopedic knowledge might suggest? We may perhaps advance the discussion by extending the musical instrument analogy introduced above just a bit more. If one is a harpsichord expert, then one can accomplish something with a barebones technical description of a given harpsichord — perhaps compare different
Paradigms, analyses, and dialogue
harpsichords made by different craftsmen. Furthermore, armed with an analysis, a blueprint, of a harpsichord, the expert can proceed to take the harpsichord apart, separate the individual pieces on the floor of a warehouse, and verify independently and intersubjectively, by inviting in other experts, that the description of each part is precisely what the blueprint says it is. And he or she can then reassemble the harpsichord in the way shown by the blueprint and verify that, by hitting this particular key, a different noise is produced than by hitting that particular key. And then the expert can pick up a musical score, note that the musical score is really not in the harpsichord itself, and learn how to play the harpsichord to mimic the score. None of this is possible with language. A Columbia School analysis without a detailed discussion of the data on which the analysis is based (e.g. Reid’s analysis of in, on, at presented without his consideration of strategies) is roughly like the harpsichord expert’s technical description of a harpsichord, which would be useless to someone who, never having even seen a harpsichord before, having perhaps only heard a Bach fugue once, now wants to learn how to play one. Furthermore, there is no way to lay out the parts of a language on the floor of a warehouse the way one can lay out the keyboard, strings, etc. of a harpsichord and hence no way to be sure that one can really separate the harpsichord of language (the semiotic instrument) from the music it produces or the talents of the harpsichordist. Cognitivists will undoubtedly suspect that, in the case of language, there is in fact no separate or intersubjectively separable “harpsichord,” no purely semiotic level. Given that such a situation is not inconceivable, it might be nothing more than a relatively fruitless cerebral and ultimately purely esthetic exercise to attempt to partition the phenomena of language into an individual “harpsichord”, with individual strings and bridges etc., producing individual notes, all of this entirely separate from, on a different level from the subject and answer and countersubject composing a fugue played on it. What Reid is really attempting to do is to take the music produced by the initially unanalyzed complex of “harpsichord + harpsichordist + musical score” and use performed fugues (perceived messages of texts and conversations) to deduce what the blueprint of the harpsichord is, how the strings and keys and other constituents are arranged. As I have suggested earlier (Kirsner 2002), this kind of approach might not appeal to folks who want to learn how fugues are played.⁹ But, Columbia School linguists will counter that any analysis which does not attempt to separate some sort of relatively parsimonious “harpsichord of language” from the complex of “harpsichord + harpsichordist + musical score” is doomed to remain eternally programmatic, making perhaps attractive majestic and ambitious claims about the mind, but never actually delivering on its promises. At this point it is up to the reader to judge how productive these two approaches to linguistics — the cognitive and the communicative — ultimately are. In any case, the merit of Langacker’s chapter and of Reid’s chapter is that they have demonstrated how each of their approaches is utilized in a linguistic analysis and have discussed where they agree and where they disagree. We may perhaps even perceive modest signs of convergence: First of all, there is Reid’s approval of analyses of the
7
8
Robert S. Kirsner
kind outlined in George Lakoff and Mark Johnson’s book Metaphors We Live By. Second, Reid’s own verbal discussion of how one strategy (linear location) can lead to another (the trajectory strategy) could possibly be viewed as a notational variant of nodes in a conceptual network if not an orthodox semantic network. At the same time, we may observe a recent desire among cognitivists to once again take up Ockham’s razor, recognize the open-endedness of all contexts and the ongoing creativity of language users, and thereby reduce the degree of crystallized, fixed, conventionalized polysemy postulated in their analyses; cf. Janssen (2003) for stimulating discussion. And, as was already indicated above in endnote 7, Tyler and Evans’s Cognitive analysis of over (2003), clearly concerned with reining in the “rampant polysemy” (Taylor 1993b: 13) found in earlier Cognitive linguistic works, makes use of some notions with clear counterparts in Columbia School linguistics. Mark Elson’s tightly-wrought chapter “On the relationship between form and grammatical meaning in the linguistic sign” challenges the widely held assumption that the inflectional ending of a word (i.e. the desinence) explicitly signals all of the grammatical meaning(s) associated with the word. Utilizing data from the history and dialects of Slavic and Romance languages, Elson proposes that oppositional relationships within paradigms — specifically between hierarchically organized subparadigms — permit endings to communicate far more than they may be shown to actually signal. The theoretical merit of this chapter is its demonstration that the kind of distinction the Columbia School makes between meaning and message (cf. Contini-Morava 1995: 5–7) applies not only to phenomena traditionally subsumed under the term “syntax” but also within the word, to morphology as well. Elson’s command of his data, together with his relentlessly semiotic argumentation, should induce many contemporary morphologists to rethink their positions. Joseph Davis’s “Revisiting the gap between meaning and message” argues against the theoretical construct of a strategy for the communicative exploitation of a meaning, a construct first introduced into Columbia School thought in García (1975), made use of in e.g. Kirsner (1979), Sussman Goldberg (1995), discussed at length in Reid (1995), and appealed to by Reid in the present volume. Davis suggests that the very notion of “strategy” is an illegitimate reification of an aspect of the inferential process whereby a message is “leapt to” from a meaning. In strict Columbia School thought (and in direct opposition to what is envisaged in Cognitive Grammar), this process — in reality involving multiple factors and cues — is held to be outside the data for which the analyst can reasonably claim analytical responsibility. Accordingly, Davis urges linguists to dispense with the concept of “strategy.” Text counts and other quantitative data (a basic pillar of Columbia School validation techniques going back to Diver 1969) should be viewed not as tests of a hypothesized “strategy” but as a test of the hypothesized meaning of the signal being studied. One predicts statistical skewings in the use of the signal on the basis of (i) the hypothesized meaning and (ii) the general expectation that, for communication to be possible at all, meanings will tend to be used coherently, synergistically, with most cues to the message “pointing in the same direction.”
Paradigms, analyses, and dialogue
Readers concerned with the status of linguistics as a science (and hence with the precise role of Popperian falsifiability in linguistic analyses; cf. Kirsner (1989) and the discussion of Karl Popper in Chalmers (1999) ) will find much to think about in Davis’s assertion that “A CS [Columbia School ] signal-meaning hypothesis can be neither proved nor disproved; it can be only accepted or rejected.”¹⁰ Another crucial issue is the possibility that, by jettisoning the concept of strategy, Davis may be further restricting the scope of phenomena for which a Columbia School linguistic analysis would claim responsibility, thereby making the Columbia School approach more vulnerable to Langacker’s criticism that it attempts to explain too little about Language to be interesting. The idea that there might be a finite number of conventionalized strategies made possible by — motivated by — the meaning of a signal, yet underdetermined by that meaning, allows one to explain crucial “negative data” — why a signal is not used in all the imaginable ways which might be compatible with its hypothesized meaning. As Langacker notes, strategies have been one way in which the Columbia School has dealt with data which Cognitive Grammar would treat by invoking polysemy. It would seem to be such data which at least have the potential of inducing Columbia School linguists to abandon their initial, plausible hypothesis that language is a sparse communicative tool and accept the view that it is (at least in part) a richer, representational system.¹¹ Note that Reid’s chapter explicitly raises this possibility. To the extent that Davis’s rejection of the concept of strategy narrows the empirical scope of Columbia School analyses (namely by focusing analyses on only data which actually occur and not on conceptually possible data which do not occur), it could be viewed as elevating the idea of sparse purely hint-like meanings from a hypothesis to a dogma. This issue is the subject of vigorous current debate among Columbia School linguists. In any case, if Davis’s proposal were to be accepted, many earlier Columbia School analyses making use of the concept of strategy, including those by the movement’s founder William Diver, would have to be rethought and redone. Part III presents five analyses: three of Indo-European languages, one of a Semitic language, and one of a Yuman language. The analyses by Jing, de Jonge, and Stern are primarily influenced by Columbia School theory. Oron and Tobin meld Columbia School theory with a Jakobsonian style of semantic analysis, especially as further extended by van Schooneveld (cf. Tobin 1990: 74–77). Finally, IchihashiNakayama invokes Grammaticalization Theory (cf. Hopper and Traugott 1993) and, implicitly, the possibility of a network analysis linking the different senses of the forms which developed at different times.¹² Zhuo Jing’s chapter “The givenness of background: A semantic-pragmatic study of two Modern German subordinating conjunctions” demonstrates that the standard reference and pedagogical grammars’ characterization of both wenn ‘if, when’ and als ‘if ’ as massively polysemous is fundamentally flawed. First, such a characterization suggests erroneously that the two forms can be synonymous, which is never the case. Neither does it explain why als is never used with reference to future time. Drawing on the Columbia School view that the meaning signaled by a
9
0
Robert S. Kirsner
form can be an instruction to the hearer rather than a description, Jing proposes that als signals BACKGROUND GIVEN while wenn signals BACKGROUND NOT GIVEN. She demonstrates in detail how these apparently sparse meanings can be used in rich discourse contexts to guide the hearer’s interpretation, buttressing her analysis with textual examples and frequency counts from both fiction and non-fiction (philosophic) texts. Another good example of the Columbia School approach to linguistic analysis is Bob de Jonge’s “The relevance of relevance in linguistic analysis: Spanish subjunctive mood”. This chapter presents a semantic analysis of the Spanish subjunctive endeavoring to explain both (a) its obligatory use in subordinate clauses with certain verbs and certain conjunctions and (b) its variable use in other environments, where it competes with the indicative. His fundamental claim is that the subjunctive, in all its uses, indicates CONTEXTUAL RELEVANCE OF AN ALTERNATIVE FOR THE OCCURRENCE EXPRESSED BY THE VERB and he offers both qualitative data (examination of examples in context) and text counts using different contextual variables in defense of this hypothesis.¹³ Nancy Stern’s “Sign-based analysis of English pronouns in conjoined expressions” investigates the use of simple pronouns and their corresponding self- forms in collocations such as the huge gap between herself and Stefan versus the intimate connection between her and Stefan. One of her empirical findings is that -self is used where there is conceptual distance between the conjuncts while the simple form is used where there is conceptual closeness. These and other observations support her analysis of -self as signaling INSISTENCE ON AN ENTITY. By urging the hearer to focus specifically on one member of the two entities referred to in the between phrase, by insisting that the hearer focus on that entity as opposed to others, the speaker hints to the hearer that the two entities are somehow unequal, that there is a distinction to be made between them and, hence, that they do not form a unified pair. The converse is shown by what Stern calls the “conspiratorial” tone of between you and me in such utterances as Between you and me, she’s an awful singer, in which the speaker invites the hearer to share his opinion that the singer stinks; cf. the unidiomatic ?Between you and myself, she’s an awful singer. An additional merit of Stern’s chapter is its underscoring of the fact that the use of the self-forms is multiply-determined. In other contexts, factors other than conceptual distance between conjuncts may influence the speaker’s choice of a bare pronoun or its corresponding self-form. Noah Oron and Yishai Tobin’s “Semantic oppositions in the Hebrew verb system: A sign-oriented approach” takes as its starting point the analysis of the Hebrew verb laid out in Tobin (1995) and presents a detailed discussion of two derivational infix patterns or binyanim: the (traditional simple) PAAL pattern exemplified by katav ‘(he) wrote,’ based on the triconsonantal root k-t-v ‘writing,’ and the corresponding (traditional reflexive) HITPAEL pattern exemplified by hitkatev ‘(he) corresponded.’ They argue convincingly that preceding traditional and modern sentence-based analyses of the Hebrew verb, which do not postulate single invariant
Paradigms, analyses, and dialogue
meanings for each of the patterns, all ultimately degenerate into relatively unhelpful lists of heterogeneous uses. They present evidence that the binyan system is not frozen, as is sometimes thought, but is exploited for neologisms. The heart of the chapter is a demonstration that the differences between such varied PAAL forms as ‘ran,’ ‘breathed,’ ‘cried,’ and ‘was furious’ and the corresponding HITPAEL forms ‘ran back and forth,’ ‘panted,’ ‘whined,’ and ‘became furious’ can best be understood as examples of the opposition between the meaning SINGLE PERCEPTION OF ACTIONS, STATES OR EVENTS and the meaning MULTIPLE PERCEPTION OF ACTIONS, STATES OR EVENTS. Of particular merit, I believe, is the authors’ statement that the meaning of a HITPAEL form cannot be mechanically predicted from the meaning of the corresponding PAAL form but is rather motivated by it. One can still detect the semantic ingredients contributed by the HITPAEL pattern (to the meaning of the root as seen in the PAAL pattern) even if the verb-form in question has gone on to develop new, specialized idiosyncratic or idiomatic usages.¹⁴ Kumiko Ichihashi-Nakayama’s contribution, “Grammaticalization of ‘to’ and ‘away’: A unified account of -k and -m in Hualapai,” grapples with a classic problem in American Indian linguistics. She argues that the morphemes -k and -m in the Hualapai language, each of which is associated with a number of different “functions,” each has a single basic meaning. The morpheme -k signals INSIDE/TOWARDS FOCAL POINT and -m signals OUTSIDE/AWAY FROM FOCAL POINT. In different linguistic contexts, such as with nouns referring to places, with motion verbs, and in sentence-final position, the morphemes are associated with different specific messages: allative versus ablative, towards speaker versus away from speaker, speaker does or does not vouch for the statement, same subject across two clauses versus different subject, discontinuous events in different times and places versus iteration of one activity at a single time and place.¹⁵ Particularly stimulating is the issue Ichihashi-Nakayama raises concerning the best explanation for the wide range of uses of the forms, synchronic or diachronic. From the vantage point of Grammaticalization Theory, the various functions can be seen as representing distinct diachronic stages. Turning now to the final section of the volume, Part IV, we may note that Shabana Hameed’s chapter, “Interaction of physiology and communication in the makeup and distribution of stops in Lucknow Urdu,” is the only one in the volume dealing with phonology and the only one illustrating William Diver’s uniquely quantitative approach to phonology: Phonology as Human Behavior.¹⁶ Rather than classifying consonants in the customary textbook way, in terms of points of articulation, Hameed analyzes them according to the articulators producing them and devotes considerable discussion to the ranking of articulators on a scale of adroitness. Physiological factors interact with communicative ones in such a way that, while there is a tendency toward full combination of the five separate Urdu articulators with both aspiration and voice, there are various asymmetries in the distribution of stops in word-initial and word-final position. Previously, most studies in Phonology as Human Behavior have dealt with Romance, West Germanic, Scandinavian, Slavic
2
Robert S. Kirsner
and Semitic languages: cf. Tobin (2002). The present chapter shows what can be learned about phonology from an Indic language with much more complex phonological units. The data were obtained during several years of field work. The second chapter in this final section concerns an intriguing problem in (sub) morphemic analysis. Yishai Tobin’s “Between phonology and lexicon: The Hebrew triconsonantal (CCC) root system revolving around /r/ (C-r-C)” constitutes the initial stage of an attempt to find semantic subsystems within tri-consonantal Hebrew roots. Here Tobin outlines the hypothesis that C-r-C roots, containing the trilled /r/ phoneme, communicate the general notion of ‘a change in structure,’ which may be specified further in individual cases. This chapter might remind readers both of Bolinger’s discussion (1950 a, b) of phonesthemes and also of Tobin’s earlier work on word systems in Modern Hebrew (Aphek and Tobin 1988). Clearly, such an intriguing hypothesis will have to be tested by comparison with C-C-C roots containing other medial consonants. Furthermore, the notion ‘change of structure’ will have to be operationalized so that different analysts can agree as to what does and what does not fall under this rubric. The observable word orders of a language may profitably be viewed as the “vector sum” of a number of different influences. Where word order is not used as a fixed sign, i.e. an invariant signal of an invariant meaning, it may be open to more general communicative influences, such as the strategy of placing given information before new. The chapters by Otheguy, Rodríguez-Bachiller, and Canals on the one hand and by Ocampo on the other illustrate, respectively, the Columbia School approach and an eclectic approach to word-order variation. Otheguy, Rodríguez-Bachiller and Canals’s chapter, “Length of the extra information phrase as a predictor of word order: A cross-language comparison” is best characterized as an experiment. The presence or absence of dedicated word-order signals in a language is treated as the independent variable and the observable word order of certain other constituents in that language is treated as the dependent variable. The chapter asks if there should be a difference in the placing of prepositional phrases and adverbs modifying verbs (thereby providing “extra information” about the event) in one language where the relative order of subject, object, and verb is a dedicated sign of participancy (Degree of Control) in the event (English) and two where it is not (Spanish, Catalan). In other words, how does the presence or absence of a word-order signal in a language interact with other factors or principles influencing word order? The authors propose a cognitive-iconic principle — Group together signals whose meanings form cognitive units: keep together what goes together — according to which conceptually related constituents (such as verbs and adverbs) should tend to be grouped together.¹⁷ In English this principle clearly conflicts with the placement of the lower controller (“direct object”) immediately following the verb. Meticulous use of translations (from English to Spanish and from Spanish and Catalan to English) provide an analytical control. Various quantitative predictions are made about the placement and relative “bulk” of the extra information. These are largely confirmed with frequency counts from texts.
Paradigms, analyses, and dialogue
Ocampo’s “Word order variation in spoken Spanish in constructions with a verb, a direct object, and an adverb” attempts to delineate the syntactic, cognitive (including iconic), pragmatic, and prosodic features which correlate with different aspects of word order in cases where the relative order of verb, direct object, and adverb cannot be (or at least has never been) considered a sign, i.e. an invariant signal of an invariant meaning. The merit of this chapter is that it teases apart the influence of a number of different factors on word order (including “higher order” ones, such as the general communicative technique of putting given information before new), and also attempts to come to grips with the simultaneous influence of more than one factor. Furthermore, as Columbia School papers have almost always dealt with written languages, it is therapeutic to confront the different kind of complexity which spoken language data provide.¹⁸ The last chapter in the volume, Angelita Martinez’s “Variación sintáctica y estrategias discursivas,” discusses the variable use of the Spanish clitic pronouns lo, la and le in regions in Argentina with a Quechua substrate. The main thesis of her chapter is that, under the influence of discourse strategies in Quechua (made possible by the particular signals and meanings of that language), speakers manipulate the Spanish dative versus accusative contrast (signaling greater versus lesser “potency” of participants in events; cf. García (1975)) in ways not seen in other dialect areas to create expectations and suspense in narratives. It is now time for the cartographer to put away his tools and for the headwaiter to take his menu (and even his tray of hors d’oeuvres) back to the kitchen. As it is never possible for the map to be the territory or the menu to be the meal, the reader is now invited to turn from these brief and hopefully enticing remarks to the chapters themselves.
Notes * I want to thank my fellow editors Ellen Contini-Morava and Betsy Rodríguez Bachiller for critical feedback on an earlier version of this Introduction. I also wish to acknowledge the support of Grant 2964 from the Faculty Grants Program of the Committee on Research, Academic Senate, University of California, Los Angeles. 1. For earlier volumes which developed out of such conferences, see Contini-Morava and Sussman Goldberg eds. (1995) and Reid, Otheguy, and Stern eds. (2002). 2. For earlier critiques of Generative Grammar from a sign-based perspective, see Garcia (1975), Kirsner (1979), and Huffman (1997). 3. See, for example, Huffman’s discussion of Smyth’s (1920) treatment of the Greek dative (1997: 16–17). 4. I have adopted this characterization from Williams (1995). Note that Shermer (1997: 58) explicitly classifies the slippery slope argument as a fallacy. 5. For more on the System of DIFFERENTIATION in English, see Diver (1984: 23–28). For a Columbia School discussion of adjective-noun order in Spanish, see Klein-Andreu (1983).
3
4
Robert S. Kirsner For a brief presentation of the System of DEGREE OF CONTROL in English (where CONTROL is not to be confused with the use of the word control in Generative Grammar), see Reid (1991: 174–178). Huffman (1997: 294–298) compares CONTROL systems in English and French. In the present volume, Otheguy, Rodríguez-Bachiller, and Canals contrast English , which has an explicit System of of DEGREE OF CONTROL, with Spanish, which does not. 6. I have taken the liberty of choosing different (and perhaps more “extreme”) lexical items than Reid’s to underscore his point that he is viewing language as a purely communicative rather than a fully representational system. All in says here is that the associated lexical item is to be taken as a location and that three dimensions are relevant rather than none (at) or a number of dimensions greater than zero and less than three (on). Conceptualizing the actual physical relationship involved in locating the item in question requires real-world knowledge of the properties and uses of the nouns’ referents. (Birds are capable of sitting on the branches of a tree, while kites can become entangled in those branches without sitting in them, and a bullet can do neither.) 7. See now also the last chapter of Sampson (2001), entitled “Meaning and the limits of science,” where it is argued that word meanings are essentially indeterminate. Here, of course, Cognitivists would argue, first, that the kind of general meanings proposed by Ruhl are so ethereal, so ineffable, as to be communicatively — and analytically — useless (cf. Taylor 1995a: 267). Second, they would suggest that there are indeed principled bases for segmenting the apparent message continuum without ending up with unconstrained, infinite polysemy. In their analysis of the English preposition over, Tyler and Evans (2003) suggest that previous treatments (by Brugman and by Dewell) have been “too fine-grained,” (postulate too many distinct nodes and paths) and that it is possible to distinguish intersubjectively between senses, (which are linguistic and stored in memory) and “constructed meanings” (which involve conceptual and online processes.) What is exciting for the Columbia School linguist here is that Tyler and Evans’s argument invokes (2003: 145–6) — without saying so explicitly — both the notion of semantic opposition and the idea that the speaker selects that particular preposition (from a closed system of prepositions) which “fits best” with the scene being described. Compare the Columbia School notion of “the least inappropriate meaning relative to a given message” in Kirsner (1979: 32–33). 8. Note the importance of lexical domains here and knowledge of the properties and social use of referents in the world. When physical enclosure by the transporting device is not possible, in is less likely to be used and on is used in the linear location sense without suggesting a fixed trajectory. One gets on a horse, on a bicycle but not usually on the 5:30 horse or the 7AM bicycle to the station even though one gets on a train. The possibility of salient enclosure seems to be the relevant variable in such cases as She was sitting on a stool/on a chair/ in an easy chair/ in a wheelchair. She was sitting on a wheelchair seems to suggest that the wheelchair is not functional as a wheelchair, perhaps because it has tipped over on its side. 9. For further discussion of how different the aims of a Columbia School analysis are from those of other theoretical frameworks and why they are different, see Chapter 10 of Reid (1991) as well as Reid (2002). There is a danger, of course, that if the theoretical constructs of the Columbia School cannot eventually be “triangulated” (cf. Wolpert 1992: 124–5) by other disciplines such as psychology and cannot prove themselves to be useful, outside of linguistics, to people attempting to understand language from other vantage points, it will suffer the fate of typewriters when the personal computer (with word-processing programs) was developed. As Verhagen (1992: 302–3) points out in his argument for the superiority of
Paradigms, analyses, and dialogue Cognitive Grammar over Generative Grammar, computers did not “scientifically disprove” typewriters. They just allowed people to do much more than they ever could with a typewriter while also performing the functions of one, so that eventually most people, except for a Luddite or two, “simply” stopped using typewriters. 10. For a thorough discussion of what has been called falsificationism, see Chapters 5 through 6 in Chalmers (1999). For further material on the scientific status of linguistics, see Chapter 9 of Reid (1991) and also Cognitive Linguist Laura Janda’s discussion of prediction in linguistics (2000: 5). She makes the interesting argument that the notion that linguistics is (or should be) an exact science is actually a folk theory of science, not unlike the conduit metaphor of language mentioned by Reid in his chapter in the present volume. 11. Columbia School linguists do, of course, accept the concept of iconicity — for example the idea that, in the absence of any additional information such as that provided by the explicit signals before and after, the very order of mention of events (and hence the processing of that order in interpretation) usually reflects (represents?) their extralinguistic order in time: He entered the room, put on his jacket, and straightened his tie refers to a different sequence of activities than He straightened his tie, put on his jacket, and entered the room. 12. For detailed discussion of the possibility of recognizing semiotic networks within a fundamentally Columbia School analysis (while preserving the theoretical differences between the Columbia School and Cognitive Grammar), see Contini-Morava (2002). 13. A historical note: De Jonge’s analysis is similar to an unpublished analysis of the Latin subjunctive once presented by William Diver in his “Structure of Latin” courses at Columbia University in the mid-1960s. At one point Diver argued that the Latin subjunctive indicated OCCURRENCE QUESTIONED while the indicative signaled only OCCURRENCE. To question an occurrence (but without asking someone whether it actually happened or not) is to raise the possibility of alternatives — of the event not happening or happening differently, which seems close to De Jonge’s postulated meaning. 14. Tobin and Oron’s contrasting “motivation” to “prediction” is quite compatible with Langacker’s use of these same terms; cf. Langacker (1991: 517) and elsewhere. 15. Readers familiar with Contini-Morava (1991) might wonder if the meaning signaled by -m, associated with event discontinuity, could not be analyzed as having a deictic component. 16. For a full explanation of the theory as well as its clinical application to the treatment of children with speech disorders, see Tobin (1997). 17. This principle appears to have been first enunciated by Otto Behagel in the 1920s: “Das oberste Gesetz ist dieses, daß das geistig eng Zusammengehörige auch eng zusammengestellt wird.” or “What belongs together mentally is placed together syntactically.” (This citation and its translation are from Slobin 1985: 228). 18. An exception is Klein-Andreu (1989).
References Aphek, Edna and Tobin, Yishai. 1988. Word Systems in Modern Hebrew: Implications and Applications. Leiden and New York: E. J. Brill. Bolinger, Dwight. 1950a. “Rhyme, assonance, and morpheme analysis.” Word 6: 117–136.
5
6
Robert S. Kirsner Bolinger, Dwight. 1950b. “Shivaree and the phonestheme.” American Speech 25: 134–5. Brugman, Claudia. 1981. The story of over. Berkeley: M. A. Thesis, Linguistics Department, University of California. Published [1988] as The Story of Over: Polysemy, Semantics, and the Structure of the Lexicon. New York: Garland Press. Chalmers, A. F. 1999. What is This Thing Called Science? Third edition. Indianapolis/Cambridge: Hackett Publishing Company. Contini-Morava, Ellen. 1989. Discourse Pragmatics and Semantic Categorization: The Case of Negation and Tense-Aspect with Special Reference to Swahili. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. Contini-Morava, Ellen. 1991. “Deictic explicitness and event continuity in Swahili discourse.” Lingua 83: 277–318. Contini-Morava, Ellen. 1995. “Introduction: On linguistic sign theory.” In Contini-Morava and Sussman Goldberg (eds.), 1–39. Contini-Morava, Ellen. 2002. “(What) do noun class markers mean?” In Reid, Otheguy, and Stern (eds.), 3–64. Contini-Morava, Ellen and Sussman Goldberg, Barbara (eds.) 1995. Meaning as Explanation: Advances in Linguistic Sign Theory. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. Dewell, Robert, 1994. “Over again: image-schema transformations in semantic analysis. Cognitive Linguistics 5 (4): 351–380. Diver, William. 1969. “The system of Relevance of the Homeric verb.” Acta Linguistica Hafniensia 12 (1):45–68. Diver, William. 1984. The Grammar of Modern English. Unpublished textbook for Linguistics G6801, Columbia University. Fauconnier, Gilles. 1985. Mental Spaces. Aspects of Meaning Construction in Natural Language. Cambridge: MIT Press. García, Erica. 1975. The Role of Theory in Linguistic Analysis: The Spanish Pronoun System. Amsterdam: North-Holland. Goldberg, Barbara Sussman. 1995.“The -ra and -se opposition in Spanish.” In Contini-Morava and Sussman Goldberg (eds.), 381–404. Hopper, Paul J. and Traugott, Elizabeth Closs. 1993. Grammaticalization. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Huffman, Alan. 1997. The Categories of Grammar: French lui and le. Amsterdam/Philadelphia: John Benjamins. Janda, Laura. 2002. “Cognitive linguistics.” SLING2K February 2000. Manuscript. Revised version forthcoming in Fowler, George (ed.) Slavic Linguistics 2000. Bloomington: Slavica. Janssen, Theo. A. J. M. 2003. “Monosemy versus polysemy.” In Cognitive Approaches to Lexical Semantics [Cognitive Linguistics Research 23], Cuykens, Hubert; Dirven, René; and Taylor, John R. (eds.), 93–122. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. Kirsner, Robert S. 1979. The Problem of Presentative Sentences in Modern Dutch. Amsterdam: North-Holland. Kirsner, Robert S. 1989. “Does sign-oriented linguistics have a future?: On sign, text, and the falsifiability of theoretical constructs.” In Tobin (ed.), 161–178. Kirsner, Robert S. 1993. “From meaning to message in two theories: Cognitive and Saussurean views of the Modern Dutch demonstratives.” In Conceptualizations and Mental Processing in Language [Cognitive Linguistics Research 3], Geiger, Richard A. and Rudzka-Ostyn, Brygida (eds.), 81–114. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter.
Paradigms, analyses, and dialogue Kirsner, Robert S. 2002.“The future of a minimalist linguistics in a maximalist world.” In Reid, Otheguy, and Stern (eds.), 339–371. Klein-Andreu, Flora. 1983. “Grammar in style: Spanish adjective placement.” In Discourse Perspectives on Syntax, Flora Klein-Andreu (ed.), 143–179. New York: Academic Press. Klein-Andreu, Flora. 1989. “Why speech seems ungrammatical.” In Tobin (ed.), 25–44. Lakoff, George and Johnson, Mark. 1980. Metaphors We Live By. Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press. Langacker, Ronald W. 1987. Foundations of Cognitive Grammar. Volume I. Theoretical Prerequisites. Stanford: Stanford. University Press. Langacker, Ronald W. 1988.“A usage-based model.” In Topics in Cognitive Linguistics [Current Issues in Linguistics 50], Rudzka-Ostyn, Brygida (ed.), 127–161. Amsterdam/Philadelphia: John Benjamins. Langacker, Ronald W. 1991. Foundations of Cognitive Grammar. Volume II. Descriptive Application. Stanford, California: Stanford University Press. Nerlich, Brigitte; Tood, Zazie; Herman, Vimala; and Clarke, David D. (eds.) 2003. Polysemy: Flexible Patterns of Meaning in Mind and Language. Berlin and New York: Mouton de Gruyter. Nikiforidou, Kiki. 1991 “The meanings of the genitive: A case study in semantic structure and semantic change.” Cognitive Linguistics 2 (2):149–205. Reid, Wallis. 1991. Verb & Noun Number in English: A Functional Explanation. London and New York: Longman. Reid, Wallis. 1995. “Quantitative analysis in Columbia School theory.” In Contini-Morava and Goldberg (eds.), 115–152. Reid, Wallis. 2002. “Introduction: Sign-Based Linguistics.” In Reid, Otheguy, and Stern (eds.), ix-xxi. Reid, Wallis; Otheguy, Ricardo; and Stern, Nancy. (eds). 2002. Signal, Meaning, and Message: Perspectives on Sign-Based Linguistics. [Studies in Functional and Structural Linguistics 48]. Amsterdam/Philadelphia: John Benjamins. Ruhl, Charles. 1989. On Monosemy: A Study in Linguistic Semantics. Albany: State University of New York Press. Ruhl, Charles. 2002. “Data, comprehensiveness, monosemy.” In Reid, Otheguy, and Stern (eds.), 171–189. Sampson, Geoffrey. 2001. Empirical Linguistics. London and New York: Continuum. Shermer, Michael. 1997. Why People Believe Weird Things. Pseudoscience, Superstition, and Other Confusions of Our Time. New York: W. H. Freeman and Company. Slobin, Dan. I. 1985. “The child as linguistic icon-maker.” In Iconicity in Syntax. [Typological Studies in Language 6], Haiman, John (ed.), 221–248. Amsterdam/Philadelphia: John Benjamins. Smyth, Herbert Weir. 1920. Greek Grammar. Cambridge: Harvard University Press. Taylor, John R. 1995a. Linguistic Categorization: Prototypes in Linguistic Theory. Second edition. Oxford: Clarendon Press. Taylor, John R. 1995b. “Models of word meaning in comparison: The two-level model (Manfred Bierwisch) and the network model (Ronald Langacker).” In Current Approaches to the Lexicon. [Duisburger Arbeiten zur Sprach- und Kulturwissenschaft 24)], Dirven, René and Vanparys, Johan (eds.), 3–26. Frankfurt am Main: Peter Lang. Taylor, John R. 1999. “Cognitive semantics and structural semantics.” In Historical Semantics and Cognition [Cognitive Linguistics Research 13], Blank, Andreas and Koch, Peter (eds.), 17–48. Berlin and New York: Mouton de Gruyter.
7
8
Robert S. Kirsner Taylor, John R. 2003. “Cognitive models of polysemy.” In Nerlich, Tood, Herman, and Clarke (eds.), 31–48. Tobin, Yishai. (ed.) 1989. From Sign To Text: A Semiotic View Of Communication. Amsterdam/ Philadelphia: John Benjamins. Tobin, Yishai. 1990. Semiotics and Linguistics. London and New York: Longman. Tobin, Yishai. 1995. Invariance, Markedness and Distinctive Feature Analysis: A Contrastive Study of Sign Systems in English and Hebrew. Amsterdam/Philadelphia: John Benjamins and Be’er Sheva: Ben Gurion University Press. Tobin, Yishai. 1997. Phonology as Human Behavior: Theoretical Implications and Clinical Applications. Durham: Duke University Press. Tobin, Yishai. 2002. “Phonology as human behavior. Initital consonant clusters across languages.” In Reid, Otheguy, and Stern (eds.), 191–255. Tyler, Andrea and Evans, Vyvyan. 2003. “Reconsidering prepositional polysemy networks: the case of over.” In Nerlich, Tood, Herman, and Clarke (eds.), 95–159. Verhagen, Arie. 2002.“Praxis of linguistics: Passives in Dutch.” Cognitive Linguistics 3(3): 301– 342. Williams, Bernard. 1995. “Which slopes are slippery?” In Making Sense of Humanity and Other Philosophical Papers 1982–1993. Williams, Bernard, 213–223. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Wolpert, Lewis. 1992. The Unnatural Nature of Science. London: Faber and Faber Ltd.
PART I
Cognitive Grammar
CHAPTER 1
Form, meaning, and behavior The Cognitive Grammar analysis of double subject constructions Ronald W. Langacker University of California, San Diego
Having long been aware of Columbia School work and its insights into language, I am pleased to have this occasion to assess its relationship to Cognitive linguistics. I will first outline some basic notions of Cognitive Grammar and then show its application to a particular grammatical phenomenon, namely double subject constructions. This will function as a substantive background for discussing similarities and differences between the Columbia School (CS) and Cognitive Grammar (CG) frameworks.
1 Cognitive Grammar The basic framework of CG has existed for well over two decades and endured without essential change. It has however been progressively refined, articulated, and empirically tested by application to a wide range of representative phenomena in diverse languages.¹ Here I can offer only a brief introductory sketch.
1.1. Basic principles My title reflects the theme of this volume: form, meaning, and behavior. Form and meaning figure in the central claim of CG, namely that lexicon, morphology, and syntax make up a continuum consisting solely of assemblies of symbolic structures. A symbolic structure is defined as the pairing between a form (i.e. a phonological structure) and a meaning (a conceptualization, in the broadest sense). It follows that all elements validly posited in grammatical description have some kind of meaning (often quite schematic). Note that the form referred to here is specifically phonological. What is commonly called “grammatical form” is analyzed in this framework as consisting in schematic symbolic assemblies, i.e. abstracted patterns of symbolization that are immanent in particular complex expressions. Grammatical markers, grammatical classes, and grammatical constructions are all inherently meaningful. Hence the architecture of the framework directly reflects the semiological func-
22
Ronald W. Langacker
tion of language, that of allowing conceptual structures to be symbolized by sound structures. Grammar is the schematic systematicity inherent in this symbolizing activity, patterns for combining symbols into complex expressions, characterized as symbolic assemblies. I take this view as being both natural and desirable from the methodological standpoint. To fulfill its semiological function, a language must at least comprise semantic structures, phonological structures, and symbolic links between the two. CG claims that only these elements are necessary. It thus achieves a substantial conceptual unification — the unification of grammar with lexicon — as well as their reduction to something more fundamental. This reduction does not however imply that grammar does not exist.² Conventional grammatical patterns have to be specifically learned by speakers and explicitly described by linguists. The framework is constrained and theoretically austere owing to the content requirement. This requirement specifies that the only elements ascribable to a linguistic system are: (i) semantic, phonological, and symbolic structures that are (part of) overtly occurring expressions (hence directly apprehended); (ii) abstractions (schematizations) of permitted structures; and (iii) categorizing relationships between permitted structures (e.g. the relationship between a schema and a specific structure that instantiates it). In phonology, for example, particular sounds like [f], [θ], and [s] can be posited by virtue of occurring in actual expressions; the schematic characterization [voiceless fricative] is permitted as an abstraction of these elements; and also permitted is the categorization of each sound as an instantiation of this schema. Options allowed in the postulation of semantic and grammatical elements are similarly constrained. Thereby precluded are such devices as “filters” (reflecting what cannot occur), derivations from underlying structures, and purely formal devices with no semantic or phonological content (e.g. syntactic tree structures as viewed in the generative tradition). Consequently, nothing is posited unless it is directly manifested in actual expressions, or else is capable of emerging from this data by the basic cognitive phenomena of abstraction (schematization) and/or categorization. This is one respect in which CG merits the label “cognitive”. Cognitive linguistics and CG are also “cognitive” in the sense that, insofar as possible, linguistic structure is analyzed in terms of more basic systems and abilities (e.g. perception, attention, categorization) from which it cannot be dissociated. This point can be illustrated by the strategy I have used in adopting and motivating some basic descriptive constructs. The strategy consists of seeking converging evidence from three sources: (i) a particular construct is shown necessary for the adequate semantic description of multiple phenomena in various languages; (ii) this construct is related to an independently observable cognitive ability; and (iii) this same construct proves critical for the explicit characterization of varied grammatical phenomena. With respect to the volume’s theme, this strategy assumes that some of the same cognitive abilities manifested in non-linguistic behavior are also crucial factors in linguistic meaning (and hence in grammar). Let me give three examples, which will serve to introduce some basic constructs I will need in the subsequent analysis.
Cognitive Grammar and double subject constructions
1.2. Profiling The first construct is what I call profiling. An expression evokes a certain array of conceptual content, called its conceptual base, as the basis for its meaning. Within this base, the expression profiles (i.e. refers to) a particular substructure. For instance, as sketched in Figure 1, the term hypotenuse evokes as its base the conception of a right triangle, within which it profiles the side opposite the right angle. Likewise, aunt profiles a human female characterized by position in a kinship network relative to a reference individual (ego). Note that profiling is indicated diagrammatically by heavy lines. a. hypotenuse
b. aunt
ego Figure 1.
Just from the standpoint of semantic description, there is ample motivation for adopting this construct — I see no way to properly characterize and distinguish linguistic meanings without it (or something with comparable effect). This is especially clear in cases where alternate profiles are imposed on the same base, so that the difference in meaning cannot be ascribed to a difference in conceptual content. Some examples are presented in Figure 2. Husband and wife have the same conceptual base, comprising a male (M) and a female (F) united in a particular way (represented by a horizontal line). Since the terms share this conceptual content, the semantic contrast between them must reside in their choice of profile within it.³ In Figure 2(b), the dashed arrow represents a mental relationship in which a sentient creature bears a particular positive attitude toward another entity.⁴ The
M b
husband
Base
a.
F
M
wife F
admire
Base tr
Figure 2.
M
F admirer
lm
23
24
Ronald W. Langacker
verb admire profiles the relationship itself (and since the conception of a relationship presupposes and incorporates the conception of its participants, these are included in the profile). By contrast, the noun admirer profiles only the participant who maintains the attitude in question. The two expressions have the same overall conceptual content: admire makes intrinsic conceptual reference to the individual holding the attitude, and admirer necessarily evokes the relationship coded by the verb. They are non-synonymous by virtue of the alternate profiles they impose on the same conceptual base. Considerations like these provide semantic evidence for adopting profiling as a descriptive construct. What about psychological evidence? It seems apparent that profiling is a focusing of attention within a conceived situation. In non-linguistic cognition, it has both perceptual and more abstract mental analogs: looking at one particular person in a group; focusing on a particular lineman making a block (amidst the welter of activity constituting a play in football); or — in the case of linguists — thinking of one particular node in a syntactic tree structure. The focusing of attention is such a basic psychological phenomenon that it is hard to imagine it not having a basic linguistic manifestation. While there may be many kinds and levels of attention, it is clear at the very least that profiling is reasonably considered one of them. So just for purposes of semantic description — independently of grammar — one could justify the construct of profiling and see it as the linguistic application of a broader, more fundamental cognitive phenomenon. Grammar provides a further check, a third source of evidence. It turns out that, once expressions are properly described in purely semantic terms, profiling is just what is needed for the characterization of various grammatical notions. Let us briefly consider four applications. Each deserves extended discussion, but here I can only offer succinct illustration. First, an expression’s grammatical class is determined by the nature of its profile (not by its overall conceptual content). Expressions can profile either things or relationships, these terms being defined quite abstractly.⁵ A noun profiles a thing. A verb profiles a process, defined as a relationship whose evolution through time is rendered salient. Classes like adjectives and prepositions involve the profiling of non-processual relations. With respect to Figure 2(b), for example, admire is a verb because it profiles a relationship portrayed as extending or unfolding through time, whereas admirer is a noun because it profiles a thing; admirer evokes the process of admiring as its conceptual base but profiles only the sentient participant. By the same token, a relationship is crucial to the semantic content of aunt, which is nonetheless a noun because its profile (or conceptual referent) is a thing (Figure 1(b)). Second, the imposition of a particular profile constitutes the essential meaning of certain grammatical markers. For instance, the effect of the derivational suffix -er (in its prototypical sense) is to profile a thing characterized by its active role in the process designated by the verb stem it combines with. Admirer thus designates the active participant in the process admire. The meaning of -er resides precisely in the imposition of this profile (and the concomitant change of grammatical class).
Cognitive Grammar and double subject constructions
Third, a head (at a given level of structural organization) can be characterized as the element whose profile is inherited by the structure as a whole (at that level). By this definition, -er is the head within the V+er construction, since its profile (rather than that of the verb) is inherited as that of the expression as a whole, making admirer a noun rather than a verb. Likewise, a preposition is the head in a prepositional phrase construction, since the phrase as a whole profiles the non-processual relation designated by the preposition, rather than the thing profiled by its nominal object. The conceptual referent of near Chicago, for example, is a relationship of spatial proximity, not the city of Chicago. Fourth, a subordinate clause is one whose profile is overridden at a higher level of grammatical organization. Here I will merely observe that (1)a — taken as a whole — profiles the process of admiring, not that of pole-vaulting, while (1)b profiles an act of deciding (not buying) at the highest level of organization. (1) a. I admire anyone [who can pole-vault 16 feet]. b. She decided [to buy a new car]. The examples in (2) further illustrate how the constructs profile and base prove useful for both semantic and grammatical description. They make it possible to specify, in an explicit and principled manner, the precise nature of the similarities and differences among certain closely related but non-equivalent expressions. The diagrams in Figure 3 correspond respectively to the boldface elements in (2), i.e. the verb melt, the participle melted, and the adjective liquid. (2) a. b. c. d. e.
I melted it. It melted easily. It melted in the heat. It is finally melted. It is now liquid.
The verb melt in (2)a profiles a force-dynamic interaction (Talmy 1988) resulting in a change of state. One participant (represented by a small circle) functions as a source of energy or influence (double arrow) directed at a second participant (large circle), which thereby undergoes a transition (single arrow) into the state (given as a box) of a. tr c.
L tr
L
b.
L
lm d.
tr L tr Figure 3.
e.
L tr
25
26
Ronald W. Langacker
being liquid (L). The transitive melt profiles this entire chain of events. By contrast, the intransitive melt in (2)b–c profiles only the second participant’s change and resulting state. The force responsible for this change, as well as its source, are evoked with varying degrees of salience as unprofiled facets of the expression’s conceptual base. In (2)b, the adverb easily evokes the agent’s role by specifying the degree of difficulty the agent encounters. In (2)c there is no agent, although the heat is readily construed as a causing influence in addition to its portrayal as an abstract location. At the extreme, the conception of external influence may be entirely absent. As a stative-adjectival participle, melted in (2)d does not profile any change, but merely the relationship of its single participant exhibiting the property of being liquid. However, it does evoke the change-of-state process as part of its base: something can only be described as melted by virtue of its having undergone the process of melting. Grammatically, this type of participle qualifies as an adjective because it conforms to the schematic conceptual characterization of this class (namely, it profiles a non-processual relation whose single profiled participant is a thing). The same is true of the adjectival sense of liquid, in (2)e. The contrast between melted and liquid is that the latter does not necessarily evoke a change-of-state process. Something can perfectly well be described as liquid even if it has never melted (e.g. it might result from the liquefaction of a gas).
1.3. Trajector and landmark To further illustrate the strategy of converging evidence, we can best start with a contrasting pair of relational expressions, e.g. above and below, sketched in Figure 4. Above profiles a non-processual relationship involving two participants in the domain of space organized in terms of horizontal and vertical dimensions. Given as a double-headed arrow, the profiled relationship specifies that one participant occupies a higher position along the vertical axis than does the other. Note, however, that exactly the same is true for below, which evokes the same conceptual elements and profiles the same relationship (referentially, an above relationship is also a below relationship). The semantic contrast does not reside in either the conceptual content evoked (the base) or the profiling imposed on it. We therefore need some other a. above
b. below tr
lm
lm
tr Figure 4.
Cognitive Grammar and double subject constructions
descriptive construct, just to achieve a minimally adequate semantic characterization — one that successfully distinguishes the meanings of above and below (and likewise for many other such pairs). It seems evident that the contrast has to do with the relational participants. When a relationship is profiled, its participants are accorded varying degrees of prominence. There is usually a primary focal participant, termed the trajector (tr), and often a secondary focal participant, called a landmark (lm). The trajector is the entity the expression seeks to locate, track, assess, or characterize, and a landmark (when present) is another salient entity evoked for this purpose. In the case of above, the trajector is located in the vertical dimension with respect to a landmark found at a lower point along this axis, whereas below reverses these specifications and situates its trajector with respect to a landmark found at a higher point. Trajector/landmark alignment was also shown in previous diagrams. In Figure 2(b), the sentient individual functions as a trajector characterized as having a mental attitude toward some other entity, the landmark. In Figure 3(a), the agent or energy source functions as trajector, since the transitive melt tracks its activity, in particular the effect it has on the patient, which is therefore put in focus as a landmark. Observe that if there is only one participant, it must have primary focal prominence, making it a trajector; the secondary focal prominence of a landmark is only possible relative to another element with primary focus. Consequently, since there is only one profiled participant in Diagrams (3)b–e, it is necessarily the trajector even when construed as a patient. What about non-linguistic manifestations of this ability to variably impose focal prominence in conceptualizing a relationship? I suggest that the relative prominence accorded to relational participants is very much akin to the figure/ground organization observed in Gestalt psychology, with alternate choices of trajector being analogous to figure/ground reversal. But can we speak of two degrees of figure status, a “primary figure” and a “secondary figure”, corresponding to the constructs trajector and landmark? I believe so. We certainly do have the ability — independently of language — to focus selectively on one participant in an interaction. If I watch a boxing match, for example, I can focus on one particular boxer, observing his techniques, which hand he favors, his footwork, even the number of blows he absorbs (this is analogous to a passive construal). Moreover, as I do so the other boxer naturally becomes a kind of secondary focus: I am following boxer1 mostly in relation to his interaction with boxer2, and am only in a peripheral way concerned with his corner, the referee, or the audience. We thus have good reason to think that the kind of cognitive ability being appealed to does in fact exist. I therefore posit trajector/landmark alignment for purposes of viable semantic description, and would argue for its psychological validity. Does it also have grammatical import? I claim that a subject, at a given level of grammatical organization, is properly characterized as a nominal element which specifies the trajector of the relationship profiled at that level. Likewise, an object is a nominal element which specifies the landmark at a given level. I have argued extensively that this concep-
27
28
Ronald W. Langacker
tual characterization is both viable and well supported (see Langacker 1991: 7.3, 1999c, 2001). As a first step in making it more precise, we need to consider the nature of grammatical constructions. A construction is a symbolic assembly comprising a set of component symbolic structures and a composite symbolic structure, linked by correspondences. An initial (simplified) example is given in Figure 5, representing constructions at two levels of organization. At the lower level of organization, the component structures admires and Bill are integrated to form the composite structure admires Bill. Observe that the nominal expression Bill profiles a thing (B stands for its various semantic specifications, e.g. that it refers to a male human), which corresponds to the schematic thing functioning as the landmark of admires (correspondences are indicated by dotted lines). By merging the specifications of the corresponding elements, we obtain the composite structure admires Bill. At this level admires is the head, or profile determinant (marked by a heavy-line box), because its profile — not that of Bill — is inherited as the profile of the composite expression. In the second construction, at a higher level of organization, the component structures are Alice and admires Bill, the profile of the former corresponding to the schematic trajector of the latter. The profile determinant at this level is admires Bill, since the entire clause designates the process of admiring rather than Alice. Observe that a kind of constituency emerges when the composite structure at one level of organization happens to be invoked as a component structure at a higher level. Constituency is not, however, either fundamental or essential in this framework (Langacker 1997). In particular, it is not used for the characterization of grammatical dependencies, such as the subject and object relations. Instead, a nominal Alice admires Bill A
Alice
tr
B
lm
tr
A
tr
B
lm admires Figure 5.
lm
admires Bill
B Bill
Cognitive Grammar and double subject constructions
expression qualifies as a subject if its profile (a thing) corresponds to the trajector of a profiled relationship, and as an object if its profile corresponds to a landmark. With respect to Figure 5, therefore, Alice is the subject of admires, admires Bill, and Alice admires Bill, as seen by tracing both “horizontal” and “vertical” correspondences. Bill is likewise the object at all three levels. Part of the conceptual unification achieved in CG is that grammatical patterns (or “rules”) have the same basic nature as the expressions which instantiate them. Like expressions, they consist in assemblies of symbolic structures, except that some or all of their elements are schematic rather than specific. Grammatical patterns can thus be described as constructional schemas, which serve as templates governing the formation of novel expressions. An expression like Alice admires Bill, as seen in Figure 5, instantiates a number of constructional schemas pertaining to different levels and facets of linguistic structure.
1.4. Reference points We come now to the final example of using converging evidence to justify a descriptive construct. It involves our basic cognitive ability to invoke the conception of one entity as a conceptual reference point (R) to establish “mental contact” with another entity (i.e. to single it out for individual conscious awareness). An entity accessed via a reference point is called a target (T). A reference point’s dominion (D) is the set of potential targets to which it gives access. The diagrammatic representation in Figure 6 will prove convenient. This general cognitive ability has both perceptual and more abstract manifestations. It provides the coherence of sequences like the following: (3) a.
Do you see that large boulder about half-way up the mountain? There’s a climber just above it. b. Do you remember the lawyer who got disbarred? His daughter is in my ethics class.
In each case the first sentence evokes a reference point (the boulder or the lawyer), which the second sentence uses as a basis for directing attention to the intended target (the climber or the daughter).
R D C Figure 6.
T
29
30
Ronald W. Langacker
Semantically, a reference point relationship is my candidate for a viable description of possessive constructions (Langacker 1993, 1995a; Taylor 1996). It is sufficiently abstract to account for the wide range of specific possessive uses, such as those in (4)a. At the same time, owing to its inherent directionality (the target being accessed via the reference point), it accounts for the usual irreversibility of possessive expressions, as seen in (4)b. (4) a.
the doctor’s wallet; the dog’s tail; Bill’s uncle; the cat’s fleas; her anxiety; the teacher’s situation; our bus; your candidate; Lincoln’s assassination b. *the wallet’s doctor; *the tail’s dog; *the situation’s teacher; *the assassination’s Lincoln
Grammatically, I take a reference point relationship as providing the abstract conceptual content of the possessive element ’s. Figure 7 illustrates its use in a basic possessive construction. Following Taylor, I assume that ’s profiles the target (although this is not essential). At the first level of organization, Bill elaborates the schematic reference point of ’s, producing Bill’s. The schematic target is then elaborated by knife, which functions as head (profile determinant), to form the noun phrase Bill’s knife. Bill’s knife R
T K
B D
Bill’s
B
T
R
K D
R
T
B D Bill
’s Figure 7.
knife
Cognitive Grammar and double subject constructions
T R
C Figure 8.
I believe our reference point ability has numerous linguistic manifestations pertaining to different levels and dimensions of organization. Within a noun phrase, a possessive relation holds between two things. At the discourse level, I consider a topic to be a reference point whose target is a proposition, as sketched in Figure 8.⁶ There are topics at various levels of discourse organization. In (50)a–c, we observe a topic in force over the span of a “paragraph”, a complex sentence, and a single clause. As the stretch of discourse over which a topic holds sway becomes smaller, its degree of structural integration with the proposition becomes tighter. In (5)a, the topic is introduced in a separate sentence, and is not explicitly mentioned in every proposition brought into its dominion. The topic in (5)b is internal to the sentence but set off as a separate intonational unit. In (5)c, where the sentence in question has just one clause, the topic is still clause-external both structurally and intonationally, yet normally the clause contains a pronoun referring back to it. Finally, in (5)d that wedding is clause-internal, functioning simultaneously as discourse topic and clausal object. (5) a.
Let’s talk about the wedding. June would be a good month. I don’t want to invite too many guests. Do you think we should have it outdoors? We really ought to have it recorded on video tape b. That wedding, I’m really looking forward to it, but I don’t want to buy a tuxedo, since I would never use it again. c. That wedding, I’m really looking forward to it. d. That wedding I’m really looking forward to.
More controversially, I suggest that subject and object are also reference point notions. This is a further elucidation of their characterization as nominal expressions that respectively correspond to the trajector and the landmark of a profiled relationship, i.e. the primary and secondary focal participants. To see this, observe that a relationship is conceptually dependent, in the sense that its own conception presupposes and incorporates the conception of its central participants. To the extent that this is so, the participants provide mental access to a relational conception, and as such are reference points with respect to it. A certain amount of evidence suggests that the primary and secondary focal prominence of trajector and land-
3
32
Ronald W. Langacker
a.
b. T
T R
R
C
C Figure 9.
mark reside in their being the first and second reference points accessed in building up to the full conception of a relationship (see Langacker 1999c, 2001). Figure 9(a) depicts the reference point relation between a participant and a relationship mentally accessed through it. The latter is given by a solid arrow, the box indicating (as in Figure 8) that the relationship as a whole — including its focal participant — functions as target. It is by virtue of “anchoring” the conception of the profiled relationship that this participant constitutes its trajector. The dominion (D) comprises the innumerable relationships that this reference point could potentially anchor, the target being the one that happens to be evoked and profiled. Let me offer just one bit of evidence for this characterization, out of many. We need to explain the cross-linguistic prevalence of possessive constructions being used to specify the central participants of nominalized verbs, e.g. Lincoln’s assassination [by Booth] or Booth’s assassination [of Lincoln]. This common periphrastic device is actually predicted given the conceptual characterizations independently proposed for possessives, for trajector/landmark alignment, and for nominalization. This latter involves conceptual reification, such that a relationship is reconceptualized as an abstract thing. The effect of nominalization is shown in Figure 9, where the box in 9(a) becomes an ellipse (representing a thing) in 9(b). If — as claimed — an event’s participants function as reference points with respect to it, and nominalization creates an abstract thing, then the relation a participant bears to the reified event constitutes a reference point relation between two things. That is precisely the definition proposed for possessives (Figure 6). How does a subject relate to a topic? Both are characterized as reference point relationships between a thing and a proposition (i.e. a profiled process). The difference is seen by comparing Figures 8 and 9(a). In the case of a topic, the reference point relationship is extrinsic to the clausal conception, a matter of discourse contingency. It is possible to conceptualize the profiled relationship in the absence of a reference point relation at the discourse level. In the case of a subject, on the other hand, the reference point relationship is intrinsic, i.e. inherent in the very conception of the clausal proposition. This follows from the conceptual dependence of a relationship on its focal participants. Although I will not pursue the matter, I believe these characterizations give us a good handle on how topic constructions might
Cognitive Grammar and double subject constructions
evolve historically into subject constructions, and why it is sometimes hard to distinguish them.
2 Double subject constructions The intimate association of topic and subject is especially evident in double subject constructions (Langacker 1999a). I will first present some typical data, to be followed by a description and then some discussion.
2.1. Data Double subject constructions are not at all uncommon cross-linguistically. Some cases I am aware of are exemplified in (6)–(15).⁷ (6) Taroo-ga hana-ga hikui. Taro-SUBJ nose-SUBJ low ‘Taro has a flat nose.’
[Japanese]
(7) Nihonzin-ga kome-ga syusyoku-da. Japanese-SUBJ rice-SUBJ staple.food-be ‘The Japanese have rice as their staple food.’ (8) Na pay aphu-ta. I stomach ache-ASSR ‘My stomach aches.’
[Korean]
(9) Na ku salam coh-ta. I the man likable-ASSR ‘I like the man.’ (10) Tā dùzi è. he stomach hungry ‘He is hungry.’
[Mandarin]
(11) Tā tóu téng. he head painful ‘He has a headache.’ (12) Wa khicaa-yaake bhugin chama du. the dog-COM fly one exist ‘There’s a fly on the dog.’ (13) Ji-ta wa baanlaa. I-DAT she beautiful ‘I think she’s beautiful.’
[Newari]
33
34
Ronald W. Langacker
(14) Noo=n no-puush konoknish. I=1s:PRES my-eye green ‘I have green eyes.’
[Luiseño]
(15) Noo=up no-te’ tiiwu-q. I=3s:PRES my-stomach hurt-PRES ‘I have a stomach ache.’ The basic phenomenon is the existence of sentences having roughly the form in (16). They are headed by two NP’s, each of which has some claim to being a subject. NP2 and the predicate appear to form a clause by themselves, yet the entire sequence also functions as a single clause.⁸ NP1 appears to be a topic with respect to the inner clause. It is often a possessor with respect to NP2 or some other element of the inner clause. Body-part relationships between NP1 and NP2 are the most frequent, evidently the prototype for this kind of construction, which can however be extended to many other sorts of situations. It is common for NP1 to be an experiencer with respect to the inner clause. Finally, there is a strong tendency for these sentences to be stative. Often they translate naturally with have even though they contain no such verb. (16) [ NP1 [NP2 PREDICATE]] ________________ inner clause _____________________ full clause
2.2. Analysis Though problematic from certain theoretical perspectives, this type of construction is quite straightforwardly described in CG. Its description requires nothing whatever that is not independently established, and most points have already been presented. Just three additional observations are needed, all independent of double subject constructions: (i) Reference point relationships are often signalled by simple juxtaposition (not by any separate morphological element). (ii) A verb or a clause can profile a reference point relationship. (iii) An expression’s composite structure can profile an entity not profiled by either component structure. In regard to point (i), we can observe that certain kinds of relationships are so basic and conceptually non-elaborate that they are commonly signalled linguistically by indirect means, rather than by specific morphological material. Two such cases are identity and reference point relations. These are exemplified by her and president in (17)a, and by them and a package in (17)b, respectively. (17) a. They elected her president. b. We sent them a package.
Cognitive Grammar and double subject constructions
Marking by mere juxtaposition (which can be considered iconic) is especially common for nominal possessive constructions, as in (18): (18) jakare ruguai crocodile tail ‘the crocodile’s tail’
[Guaraní]
If English worked this way, so that we said Bill knife instead of Bill’s knife, it would have the structure shown in Figure 10 (cf. Figure 7). The reference point relation need not be strongly invoked by either of the juxtaposed component elements, considered separately (though it may be in particular cases). It is rather a function of the overall construction, evoked as conceptual base at the composite structure level. Bill corresponds to the reference point (making it the possessor), and knife to the target, which is profiled by the overall expression. Note that despite their different modes of assembly, the composite structures of Figures 7 and 10 are the same. Bill’s knife R
T K
B D
B
K
Bill
knife Figure 10.
Point (ii), that a reference point relation can be profiled, is illustrated by a possessive verb like have. While such a verb has many uses and may have more specific senses, the schematic value — that of profiling a reference point relationship — is what it arguably shares in all its uses. Examples like (19)b-e show that any notion like ownership or control is too specific to apply to all uses. At the extreme, the subject comes very close to merely serving as a point of reference for specifying the object’s location. (19) a. b. c. d. e.
She has three dogs. I have the spaghetti. [customer to waiter holding the spaghetti] The US has a high ratio of prisoners to total population. He has freckles. We have a lot of skunks around here.
35
36
Ronald W. Langacker
have tr
lm K
B D Figure 11.
In its most schematic value, a verb like have is diagrammed in Figure 11, where the dashed arrows represent the conceptualizer’s path of mental access. On occasion, even a clausal reference point relationship can be coded by mere juxtaposition, as exemplified in (20): (20) Inepo kari-ne. I house-FUT ‘I will have a house.’
[Yaqui]
In this Yaqui example, there is no overt verb, yet a clausal process is evoked and marked for future tense. Although the tense suffix appears on the possessed noun, it is the process of possessing it (a specific instantiation of a reference point relation) that occurs in the future. This expression also illustrates point (iii), namely that a composite structure sometimes profiles an entity not profiled by either component structure (i.e. some constructions are exocentric). In the case at hand, diagrammed in Figure 12, the component structures profile things, while the expression as a whole designates the possessive relationship.
inepo kari tr I R
D
lm K T
I
K
inepo
kari Figure 12.
Cognitive Grammar and double subject constructions
Further illustrating the marking of a reference point relation by simple juxtaposition is a regular topic construction, e.g. (21): (21) The lottery, I never have any luck. To keep things simple, I have taken an example where the comment clause makes no overt reference to the topic. The basic organization of such an expression is sketched in Figure 13. The two component structures respectively profile a thing (X) and a proposition (Y V). The topic relationship emerges only at the composite structure level, being signalled by the adjacency and temporal ordering of these two elements. My assumption is that the overall expression inherits its profile from the comment clause. X, Y V R X
T
tr
Y
D
X
Y
X
YV
tr
Figure 13.
Given the points just established, a double subject construction can be seen as resulting from a specific way of applying them. In particular, a double subject construction results when (i) a reference point relationship is signalled by mere juxtaposition; (ii) the target is a clause (rather than a noun phrase); and (iii) the reference point relationship — not profiled by either component structure — is nonetheless profiled at the composite structure level. The basic structure is diagrammed in Figure 14. At the lower level of organization, NP2 combines with a predicate to form the inner clause. At the higher level, NP1 and the inner clause are juxtaposed, producing a composite structure that profiles a reference point relation between them. Not profiled by either component structure, this reference point relation has a clausal proposition for its target. This is very much like a topic construction, as in Figure 13, except that the reference point relationship created at the composite structure level is profiled, resulting in a single-clause structure with a clausal complement. It also resembles the possessive construction in Figure 12, except that the target is a proposition rather than a thing. Like the possessive construction, it is exocentric, since the reference point
37
38
Ronald W. Langacker
Full clause tr
T
X R
NP1
lm Y
D
X
Y
tr
Inner clause
tr
X
Y
NP2
Predicate
Figure 14.
relationship it profiles is not inherited from either component structure. Given this profiling, it is automatic that the reference point itself (NP1) functions as trajector, hence subject. Recall that a trajector was characterized as the first reference point accessed in building up to the conception of a profiled relationship. It follows that when the reference point relationship is itself put in profile, the reference point should be its trajector.
2.3. Discussion Why does this type of construction exist? Indeed, why is it cross-linguistically prevalent? It is not an idiosyncrasy of one language, or even one linguistic area, so it must have some functional motivation. Its function, I suggest, resembles that of so-called “raising” constructions, which provide a means for naturally salient entities to occur in grammatically salient positions (notably clausal subject): (22) a. For the prime minister to resign is unlikely. b. The prime minister is unlikely to resign. I have argued (Langacker 1995b) that “raising” is a matter of metonymy in the choice of relational participants, metonymy being another reference point phenomenon. It enables us to evoke one entity by explicitly mentioning another that is cognitively salient or easier to encode. It is well known, of course, that certain kinds of entities make “better” subjects than others. Certainly humans outrank clauses in regard to “topicality” and “subjectworthiness”.
Cognitive Grammar and double subject constructions
I believe double subject constructions serve a similar function, by means of a different grammatical device, albeit one that still relies on a reference point relation. Many grammatical phenomena conspire to ensure that elements with intrinsic cognitive salience appear in positions that are structurally prominent. People in particular are cognitively salient and naturally taken as reference points. Structurally, a subject is highly prominent, whereas a possessor — as a modifier, inside a noun phrase — is not. The double subject examples reveal that NP1 is typically human, whereas NP2, which would otherwise be the subject, is less topical. Often it designates a body part, which in any case is most naturally accessed via the conception of the person it belongs to. The double subject construction straightens things out and lets us access NP2 via NP1, which as trajector of the profiled relationship is the point of access for the entire complex expression. It allows an intrinsically salient possessor (often the speaker) to appear in a maximally prominent position, as subject of a higher-level clause. Let me summarize by reviewing the various properties of a double subject construction. These properties are reflected in the structure proposed and directly related to its function. • Double subject sentences are normally stative. Active sentences are likely to have agentive, inherently topical subjects. The functional desideratum of superseding a non-topical subject is more likely to arise in stative expressions. • NP2 and the predicate can themselves constitute a clause. This is because the construction builds on a clause, adding another level of organization with topic-like function. • The entire structure also has clausal status. It is by building a higher-level clause, with a new trajector, that subject status is shifted to an inherently more topical participant. • NP1 and NP2 both have some claim to subjecthood. They are subjects (i.e. correspondents of profiled trajectors) at different levels of organization. • NP1 is a topic with respect to the inner clause. This is because the higher-level relationship grafted onto the inner clause is precisely a reference point relationship between NP1 and that clause. • NP1 is typically a possessor with respect to NP2. This makes NP1 a reference point for NP2, which in turn — as trajector — is a reference point with respect to the predicate. Hence this circumstance is optimal for purposes of NP1 being adopted as reference point with respect to the inner clause. • Body-part relationships between NP1 and NP2 are prototypical. Such relationships are prototypical for possessives, and also involve the requisite asymmetry in cognitive salience (a person being inherently more topical than a body part). • NP1 is commonly an experiencer with respect to the inner clause. This goes along with body-part possessive relationships, as well as the construction’s stativity. • Double subject sentences often translate naturally with have, despite the absence of a possessive verb. That is because they are reference point constructions, and have itself profiles a reference point relation.
39
40
Ronald W. Langacker
3 Comparison of CG and CS I will now turn to some general observations and a few comparisons of Cognitive Grammar with the Columbia School approach. It should come as no great shock that I subscribe to the former rather than the latter. They do however have a lot in common, and the points of difference — though substantial — are not necessarily so drastic as they might appear.
3.1. In defense of CG By way of defending my preference, let me start by emphasizing the extent to which the architecture, the constructs, and the specific descriptions of CG are principled in nature. In the course of the discussion I have pointed out the following: (i) CG posits only semantic structures, phonological structures, and symbolic structures (pairings of the other two). It is thus congruent with the basic semiological function of language, that of allowing meanings to be symbolized by sounds. (ii) The theory achieves conceptual unification and theoretical austerity. (iii) It relies solely on mental abilities and phenomena whose existence is independently demonstrable. (iv) Converging evidence is required for the adoption of basic descriptive constructs. (v) CG avoids the imposition of artificial boundaries that, despite being traditionally assumed, have always proved problematic in practice. Examples include lexicon vs. grammar, morphology vs. syntax, and semantics vs. pragmatics. In each case the distinction is seen as being a matter of degree. (vi) Independently justified constructs and phenomena come together to provide straightforward descriptions of constructions that are problematic from other perspectives. I have shown this in detail for the particular case of double subject constructions. (vii) Such descriptions are successful in explaining, in conceptual and functional terms, the existence and specific properties of grammatical constructions. In his excellent monograph on French lui and le, Huffman (1997) expends considerable effort in contrasting CS and CG. Though his criticisms of the latter are thoughtful and substantial, I naturally believe them to be a bit off the mark. A brief response may be useful as a way of correcting some misconceptions that tend to exaggerate the actual differences between the two frameworks. I will examine four issues, in each case starting with a quote from Huffman’s book. • Unified analyses. Alternatively, lui might represent a network of interconnecting values, each one related at least indirectly to the others, and with one perhaps being ‘prototypical’, but with no central factor directly uniting them all; this kind of relationship is often posited by analyses in Cognitive Grammar. However, if an analysis can demonstrate that there is a unifying factor on the basis of which the appearance of lui in all cases can be accounted for, then this analysis clearly presents the stronger case. Analyses that overlook such a unifying factor miss the point of what actually motivates speakers to use the form. [p. 17]
Cognitive Grammar and double subject constructions
This pertains to my network model of complex categories (Langacker 1987: ch. 10), as applied to the meanings of linguistic elements, where polysemy is taken as being quite common. Huffman implies that a polysemous account is incompatible with finding and stating a unifying factor. But there is no such incompatibility. A highly schematic meaning unifying all uses is always to be sought, and is posited in CG when one can be found. The network model of complex categories recognizes the axis of schematicity and instantiation, as well as that of prototypicality and central tendencies; it makes no a priori claims as to which axis will prove most important, in a particular case or in general. CS-type meanings are often adopted, and the specific meanings posited in the CS literature generally seem plausible to me and very much on the right track. At the most schematic level, I would probably accept Huffman’s characterization of lui in terms of mid-level control, which can easily be incorporated in a CG analysis. Two critical issues remain, however: (i) Is a unifying schematic meaning exhaustive of what one has to say to adequately describe a particular element? (ii) To what extent does such a meaning actually “account for” the range of uses? We will return to these matters. • Distribution. The problem on which Columbia school focuses attention — occurrences of morphemes — is not directly addressed by their work [p. 22] This is in reference to Wierzbicka and myself, inter alia. In regard to Wierzbicka (e.g. 1988, 1996), I wonder how it squares with Huffman’s comment on the very next page that her goal is “to specify the precise set of semantic formulae which can generate no more and no less than the entire range of dative sentences acceptable in a given language”. This is representative of Wierzbicka’s strategy in general, and she takes it very seriously.⁹ As for myself, the whole point of positing complex categories (modeled as networks) is to handle the problem of distribution. There is elaborate discussion in my work (e.g. 1988, 1999b: ch. 4) of the usage-based conception, why it is necessary, and precisely how distribution and judgments of well-/ill-formedness arise. It might be argued that a simpler account is possible than Wierzbicka’s or mine (i.e. that a single schematic meaning will do the job), but it is unfair to say that our work does not directly address occurrences of morphemes. • Advance knowledge about cognition. Cognitive Grammar sets out to apply to language a body of preestablished knowledge about cognition . . . A great deal must be known in advance about cognition for grammatical analysis to be possible; so much, in fact, that the writing of a complete cognitive grammar is presently unfeasible . . . A Columbia-school analysis starts with much less: morphemes and their observed occurrences . . . Columbia-school linguists thus allow the feasibility of writing complete grammars, and in fact attempt to do so. [pp. 329–331] This gives a very inaccurate impression. Most of what I think I know about cognition was inspired by linguistic analysis, and the same is true of Cognitive linguistics
4
42
Ronald W. Langacker
generally.¹⁰ Cognitive linguistic research involves an intricate dialectic, using linguistic facts to suggest the need for particular descriptive constructs, and using independent knowledge about cognition as a check on the plausibility of what is posited. The test is whether a consistent, revelatory overall picture eventually emerges, one which is adequate and supported from both the linguistic and the psychological standpoints. As for the writing of complete grammars, CS linguists have the advantage because, as a matter of theoretical principle, they eliminate from what they call “language” the vast majority of what Cognitive linguists feel obliged to study. It is thus a wholly erroneous comparison. • Relation to traditional grammar. In spite of the promise of something new and different offered by Cognitive Grammar, its most fundamental categories are identical with those of the traditional canon . . . In Columbia-school theory, no category of grammar is ‘beyond dispute’. On the contrary, every category must withstand rigorous testing and earn its way into the grammar. [pp. 331–332] Adopted in CG are certain traditional notions like subject, object, noun, verb, possessive, count vs. mass, and subordinate clause. I did not retain such notions by virtue of conservatism, but rather because — from decades of work with diverse languages — I see the need to employ them in comprehensive linguistic descriptions. Morever, they are not just taken over from tradition. Rather, I have redefined them in what I believe are more viable terms (e.g. what I call a “noun” is far more inclusive than in traditional usage) and in each case offered a highly schematic conceptual characterization that I believe is compatible with all their manifestations. Is this not in the CS spirit? Indeed, my characterization of trajector (in terms of which subjects are defined) as “primary focal participant” is very much akin to the Diverian “central focus”, and not at all comparable to traditional definitions. If only because they could not understand it, most linguists recognized that CG was quite new and different when first proposed.¹¹ I do admit to believing that a few basic notions from the previous history of linguistics might prove potentially useful and thus worthy of retention (given proper clarification and characterization). So if it seems important I will gladly cede to CS (apparently not guilty of that sin) the privilege of being considered the most “radical”.
3.2. Some similarities and non-differences A number of similarities between CS and CG are evident enough that I will merely list them without discussion: (i) There is a common desire to describe language — and to describe each individual language — in its own terms, rather than imposing on it an elaborate set of preconceptions. (ii) They are both functionalist approaches concerned with the communicative role of language and how this function is achieved. (iii) Differences in form are not taken as arbitrary, but as having some communicative import that needs to be discovered and characterized. (iv)
Cognitive Grammar and double subject constructions
In contrast to some functionalist approaches, they are both interested in cognitive issues and actually attempt to characterize meanings. (v) In both cases, in fact, meaning is seen as the key to understanding grammar.¹² (vi) Both recognize the need to posit meanings that are highly abstract (or schematic). At a basic level, therefore, CS has much in common with CG (and with Cognitive linguistics generally). Even certain apparent contrasts turn out to be only apparent. Rather than differences in principle, they are best described as matters of emphasis or historical accident (in regard to which problems investigators have gotten around to tackling). My overall impression is that the true differences are rather few, and perhaps less vital than they seem. One apparent contrast which proves to be just a matter of degree is the CS emphasis on empirical evidence of a quantitative sort, notably from text counts. Cognitive linguists can certainly profit here from the methods developed by Reid (1991), Huffman (1997), and others. Quantitative methods, especially in the form of experiments and corpus searches, are however becoming increasingly common in Cognitive linguistics (as well as in the discipline at large). But regardless of their current prevalence, there is no disagreement about their importance. CS places considerable emphasis on systems of oppositions. This is admittedly a facet of linguistic organization that Cognitive linguistics and CG have not put much stress on. That it is a factor — that often an element’s value derives at least in part from its opposition to others — is something that is readily accepted.¹³ Systems of oppositions obviously have a far more central role in the CS perspective. Still, Cognitive linguistics should have little trouble accepting and accommodating them to whatever extent proves justified. A final point of non-disagreement is the distinction between “meaning” and “message” (Kirsner and Thompson 1976), and the role of inferencing (“communicative strategies”) in bridging the gap. On this point I am often misinterpreted and wrongly portrayed. For instance, Levinson (1997: 18–19) lumps me with Jackendoff, both of us being “stubborn ostriches” who “refuse to countenance the existence of pragmatics”. I would not presume to speak for Jackendoff, but in my case the characterization is erroneous if not irresponsible. What I actually said is the following: “The distinction between semantics and pragmatics (or between linguistic and extra-linguistic knowledge) is largely artifactual, and the only viable conception of linguistic semantics is one that avoids such false dichotomies” (Langacker 1987: 154). While these words do, unfortunately, leave room for alternate interpretations, Levinson’s confident and unqualified extrapolation is nonetheless quite gratuitous. My claim is that semantics and pragmatics form a gradation, there being no particular point where one can draw a sharp and rigid line of demarcation. What is being denied, then, is the situation depicted in Figure 15(a), where semantics and pragmatics are discrete, non-overlapping “components” with a specific boundary between them. That denial is compatible with the alternatives shown in 15(b)–(d). For his own polemic purposes, Levinson portrays me as subscribing to either of two
43
44
Ronald W. Langacker
a. b. c.
Semantics Semantics
Pragmatics Pragmatics
Gradation Non-existence
Semantics
d.
Separate components
Semantics/Pragmatics
Non-differentiation
Figure 15.
untenable positions: that pragmatics does not exist at all (15(c)), or that the entire spectrum of semantic/pragmatic phenomena is undifferentiated, with no distinction at all between the two sorts (15(d)). My actual position, however, is 15(b). Semantics and pragmatics grade into one another, so that any specific line of demarcation would be arbitrary. Phenomena drawn from opposite ends of the spectrum will of course be quite different in nature, and those lying toward either pole can for all practical purposes be considered exclusively semantic or exclusively pragmatic. Let me state quite explicitly, then, that what we understand from an expression — on the basis of context, implicature, or interpretive strategies — is often (if not always) more extensive than anything we could reasonably identify with its linguistic meaning, even in a broad sense. That is a definite point of agreement with CS, and for that matter with just about everybody else. As I understand it, however, CS practitioners would opt for Figure 15(a) instead of 15(b), with the semantics box being quite small in relation to the pragmatics box.
3.3. Divergence The place where disagreement sets in is when we ask how much of our total understanding of expressions — how much of the overall message — constitutes linguistic meaning. Here CS opts for a minimalist view of meaning. It is limited to what is derivable from the meanings of component elements, where these in turn are seen as quite schematic, the abstract characterizations valid for all uses of these elements. Any postulation of multiple senses (polysemy) is strongly resisted, and specific values which instantiate the abstract meanings are denied any status in the “language,” even if they are frequently and consistently used within a speech community. All aspects of an expression’s interpretation that go beyond the schematic meanings of its component elements are ascribed to the efforts of speakers employing particular “communicative strategies” as well as the full range of their interpretive abilities. By contrast, Cognitive linguists recognize polysemy as the usual state of affairs. Lexical and grammatical elements tend to have a variety of familiar and conventionally established values, or “senses,” often centered on a prototype. New senses
Cognitive Grammar and double subject constructions
arise as extensions from the prototype (or from other established senses) to the extent that specific interpretations — originally due to speakers’ interpretive efforts in context — recur with sufficient frequency that they become “entrenched” in the minds of individuals and conventional within a speech community.¹⁴ In the network model adopted in CG, extension to encompass a wider range of values engenders the extraction of a schema that embodies their abstract commonality. Often (but not necessarily always), a highly abstract schema emerges which all other senses instantiate as special cases. If we look beyond the labels to see what is actually being posited (or at least contemplated) as part of a comprehensive view of language and its use, the two models are not fundamentally incompatible. The abstract, monosemous meanings of CS are comparable to the highest level schemas posited in CG. Both frameworks recognize that, in actual use, expressions are understood in specific ways determined by context, communicative strategies, and interpretive abilities. Particular motivations for extension that are recognized in Cognitive linguistics, such as metaphor and metonymy, are presumably allowed in CS as possible strategies of interpretation. If it is further accepted in CS that particular interpretations are sometimes learned by speakers and established in a speech community, the two models can be seen as basically congruent (in principle, if not in practice). In comparing the two frameworks, therefore, a pivotal question is whether CS does in fact accept the learning and conventionalization of certain communicative strategies and interpretations. There does not appear to be unanimity in this regard. As I read Huffman (1997), he tacitly denies this possibility, describing even totally invariant applications of lui and le as being decided by speakers de novo on every occasion of their use. By contrast, Reid (1995: 149) describes the problematic, intermediate status of communicative strategies: [I]n García’s work a communicative strategy became the crucial mediating link between a meaning and the distribution of its signal. However the precise theoretical status of a communicative strategy is still an open question. Is a strategy a theoretical construct on a par with a meaning? It does not seem appropriate to regard strategies as a part of langue because they are not completely arbitrary. On the other hand to say they are part of parole makes them sound too idiosyncratic.
Reid has also described speakers as having decades-long experience in solving particular communicative problems, commonly resulting in packaged solutions. On this crucial issue, Contini-Morava (1995: 19) is quite explicit and fully in agreement with CG: A ‘strategy’ is a routinized exploitation of a given meaning, so that it is regularly used to suggest/infer a particular type of message. A postulation of such conventionalized patterns of inference is justified by appeal to the human preference for habit or routine . . .
In my view, there is no doubt at all about the matter. I fully concur with Janssen (1995: 266), who states it quite succinctly:
45
46
Ronald W. Langacker [T]he language user has highly detailed knowledge of when certain linguistic elements can be employed and when they cannot. And it is this very kind of knowledge that any language learner needs to have. The abstract description is obviously not enough to prevent him from making mistakes.
In other words, the set of maximally schematic meanings taken in CS as constituting the “linguistic system” come nowhere near being exhaustive of the conventionally established information required for a person to speak a language fluently and correctly. The function of the networks posited in CG is precisely to specify the requisite information. They specify the full range of conventional uses of elements, which are nothing other than packaged solutions to communicative problems. But is this really necessary? Is it not the case, as consistently maintained in the CS rhetoric, that a single schematic meaning accounts for all the uses of an element? That depends on what is meant by “account for”. What a CS analysis typically does — revealingly and persuasively — is to show how the abstract meaning posited can be reconciled with each attested use via some interpretive process. I regard this as a non-trivial accomplishment and a valid contribution. What a CS analysis does not, however, do (in my own experience and judgment) is to show how the specific, actual range of uses follows inexorably from the abstract characterization, so that this alone would exhaust the information a speaker needs in order to use the element correctly (i.e. in accordance with the conventional expectations of the speech community). Our interpretive capacities are extraordinarily flexible and multifaceted. Starting from any single meaning — especially one that is highly abstract — a speaker or a linguist can find some plausible rationale for using an element in an extremely wide variety of conceivable ways, only some of which are conventionally exploited. A substantial part of knowing how to speak a language is knowing which of these uses (or interpretive solutions) are in fact conventional, and which ones not.¹⁵ To be sure, speakers are always stretching the limits of convention, but to appreciate how and why they are doing this we need some idea of what those limits are. If it is granted that at least some communicative strategies and interpretive solutions are learned and conventionalized, the CS and CG positions on these issues are much less different than they first appear. Both acknowledge the entities and developments sketched in Figure 16. In 16(a), the larger box represents the linguistic system as it stands at a given time. One element of the system is an expression (say a lexical item) with a single basic meaning, A.¹⁶ These are also enclosed in boxes, indicating that they have been learned by speakers as conventional linguistic units. Further depicted in 16(a) is a novel usage in which the expression is understood — via some interpretive process — as having a distinct or more elaborate value, labeled B. The boxes surrounding B and the overall interpretive process are given with rounded corners, to indicate their novelty. Suppose, however, that this same expression — interpreted as having the contextual value B — proves efficacious for some purpose and is thus repeatedly used in this way. The interpretive process, as well as the extended value it produces, can then be learned by speakers and conventionally
Cognitive Grammar and double subject constructions
a. Basic meaning A expression
Interpretation
Contextual value B
Novel usage
Linguistic system b. Basic meaning A expression
Interpretation
Extended meaning B
Learned, conventional usage
Linguistic system (narrow definition) Linguistic system (broad definition) Figure 16.
established in the speech community. The boxes enclosing them are shown in 16(b) with square (rather than rounded) corners to mark their resultant status as learned, conventional units. Accepting this scenario, the pertinent difference between CS and CG comes down to the terminological issue of how we choose to use terms such as “language,” “linguistic system,” and “meaning.” CS adopts narrow definitions, thereby excluding from what it calls “language” both the interpretive process and the extended semantic value it creates, which would not be called a “meaning” but just a “message.” CG adopts broader definitions. A semantic, phonological, or symbolic unit is defined as part of the “language” or “linguistic system” to the extent that it is entrenched in the minds of speakers and conventional in a speech community. Once established, an extended semantic value is a “meaning,” no longer just a “message,” despite its pragmatic origin. The interpretation deriving this new meaning remains in the language as a representation of its motivation by the basic unit. It constitutes one link in the network describing the expression’s related senses. A difference in terminology — if it is merely terminological — has no substantive import. If all the phenomena depicted in Figure 16 are accepted as part of the
47
48
Ronald W. Langacker
total story of language and language use, no real importance attaches to what part of it we choose to call “language.”¹⁷ But perhaps additional considerations could be introduced that would motivate using the term in either a broad or a narrow sense. Let us examine a number of actual and potential arguments of this sort. A standard CS argument against the broad conception of a linguistic system, ascribing multiple (related) senses to a single element, is the difficulty in determining precisely which ones should be posited. For a certain range of uses, how many distinct senses are needed? Two? Three? Thirty-five? Are they really all discretely different? How can we be sure which particular sense is being employed on a particular occasion? We can best resolve these problems, the argument goes, by assuming that there is only one, highly abstract meaning which accounts for all the uses. This is not a valid argument. It is analogous to asserting that, since it is hard to count the stripes on a zebra, a zebra must have only one.¹⁸ There is to be sure a certain intellectual comfort in having a clear, definite answer to the question of how many senses to posit (the number one being especially attractive). We have no reason to believe, however, that language was designed with the comfort of the analyst in mind. Nor is it valid here to claim that positing one meaning is simpler than positing multiple senses. To the extent that speakers learn a conventionally sanctioned range of uses, the same complexity exists in the overall account of language and language use, regardless of how we label it. I would not deny that the network model faces real problems at both the descriptive and theoretical levels. Clear grounds for positing a specific number of distinct senses are not always evident. It seems quite likely, in fact, that the network metaphor is seriously misleading, precisely because it is too discrete. Instead, we might distort things less by comparing an element’s range of meanings to a mountain range, which occupies a continuous expanse but is very uneven owing to rises, depressions, peaks, and valleys. Counting the senses of a lexical item would then be analogous to counting the peaks in a mountain range: how many there are depends on how salient they have to be before we count them, and they appear discrete in the first place only because we ignore how they grade into one another at lower altitudes. The uncertainty we sometimes experience in determining which particular sense an expression instantiates on a given occasion is then to be expected. The uses in question are like points in the valley between two peaks. It is essentially an arbitrary matter whether we assign such points to one peak, to the other, to both, or to neither. Another CS argument against defining “language” broadly reduces to an oft-repeated slogan: “Where does one stop?” If we go beyond a single abstract meaning, allowing more specific senses into the “linguistic system,” how far down should we go? If we start accepting specific interpretations as linguistic meanings, do we not lose the vital distinction between meaning and message? Surely (the argument continues) we should not — as linguists — be expected to descend this slippery slope. How can we describe a language if we are forced to deal with the interpretive process in all its complexity, accommodating every conceivable interpretation in every conceivable context?
Cognitive Grammar and double subject constructions
Of course, by refusing to descend a slippery slope one does not succeed in making the landscape flat. The overall problem of language use and interpretation remains to be dealt with irrespective of how linguists write their job description. The more narrowly linguists define their own task (and CS scholars define it quite narrowly indeed), the less they contribute to the global enterprise of figuring out how language works.¹⁹ Still, it is not the case that by venturing down the slope we stumble into a bottomless pit. Even with a broad definition, there is a natural way of defining a “language” that does indeed offer a principled basis for stopping at a certain place. In CG, what counts as the “linguistic system” is delimited by the dual factors of psychological entrenchment and conventionalization within a speech community. A linguistic structure is reasonably considered part of a “language” to the extent that speakers learn it and can use it as a prepackaged unit (an established cognitive routine), and can count on other speakers knowing it as well. Because both entrenchment and conventionalization are matters of degree, we should not expect to find a sharp and rigid line of demarcation. There is rather a gradation, as in Figure 15(b), with indisputably linguistic structures and indisputably non-linguistic structures lying toward opposite ends of the spectrum, separated by a zone of intermediate cases. Under this definition, of course, the place one stops in describing a linguistic system is not a determinate point but an ever-fluctuating region reflecting the vicissitudes of ongoing language use. Nonetheless, the descriptive task does not go on forever — the defining factors impose both practical and theoretical limits. These factors are, moreover, subject to empirical verification. In principle, degree of entrenchment can be measured experimentally (e.g. in terms of response latency), and degree of conventionalization by corpus-based methods. In practice it may not prove easy to measure them, but neither is there any overwhelming need to do so. The point is that a linguistic system (however vast) is bounded (however fuzzily), and for a very good functional reason. Beyond a certain level, there is a trade-off between specificity and differentiation, on the one hand, and utility on the other: as structures become more and more specific and finely articulated, they have less and less likelihood of being used with enough frequency to be entrenched or conventionalized. A further CS argument is that specific senses would be different in nature from abstract meanings and thus inappropriate as part of the language per se. Recall, for instance, Reid’ s statement: “It does not seem appropriate to regard strategies as a part of langue because they are not completely arbitrary” (1995: 149). But a language comprises many kinds of elements whose nature is even more drastically distinct — sounds and meanings, for instance, or within phonology, a segment and a stress alternation. Who is authorized to say, on an a priori basis, that linguistic elements have to be homogeneous, or that a particular sort of difference is automatically disqualifying? With respect to Reid’s comment, can complete arbitrariness really be taken as criterial for inclusion in the linguistic system? If so there may be virtually nothing in the system. Even the form-meaning pairings of individual mor-
49
50
Ronald W. Langacker
phemes have some degree of non-arbitrariness. For example, the more schematic meanings of grammatical elements bear a natural affinity to their phonologically more attenuated symbolization (vis-à-vis lexical items). To support the privileged status of a system of highly abstract meanings, an obvious strategy is to look for independent evidence that these in particular have a special role in behavior and cognition. One might, for example, study language acquisition to see whether abstract meanings develop first, as a necessary basis for the later emergence of more specific senses. Or one might turn to psycholinguistic experimentation, to see what role schematic meanings play in language processing. At the very least there ought to be a coherent story of how processing, development, and structure fit together in a comprehensive account of language. I quite understand the hesitation of linguists, qua linguists, to get involved with the complex issues in these vast and difficult fields of inquiry. Even so, the apparent CS reluctance to engage them (if not the conscious decision to avoid them altogether) is rather striking. It precludes a possible source of external evidence that could support the framework and show its potential as a realistic model of linguistic knowledge.²⁰ Given their critical reliance on communicative strategies and “human factors” more generally, it is surprising that CS practitioners are not engaged in large scale efforts to study them systematically. Even if they lie outside of “language” (narrowly defined), these factors are being appealed to for bridging the very large gap between abstract “linguistic” meanings and the panoply of more specific senses that Cognitive linguists feel obliged to posit. I usually find plausible both the abstract meanings proposed in CS and the account of how human and communicative factors give rise to specific interpretations. These explanations sometimes give the impression, however, of being ad hoc and unconstrained. In the absence of rigorous, detailed investigation, how can one be sure that the factors appealed to will invariably function in just the required way, to produce the precise patterns of uses and interpretations found in the data? To validate their own ideas, CS scholars might consider the strategy of Cognitive linguists, who feel compelled to learn all they can about phenomena like metaphor, metonymy, mental spaces, blending, prototypes, and basic level categories. Even though these are not specifically or uniquely linguistic, they are crucial to understanding how particular interpretations arise, and thus to an overall account of language, wherever we draw the line.
3.4. Complex expressions If one purports to have a theory of language, and wants it to be taken seriously, something cogent has to be said about the related problems of grammar (i.e. morphology and syntax) and semantic composition. It is not enough to bemoan the inadequacies of traditional grammar and the sins of generative grammar, egregious though these may be. The task remains of describing the formation of complex expressions and how their meanings relate to the meanings of their parts. A conceivable position is that there is in fact nothing to describe at the level of langue, that
Cognitive Grammar and double subject constructions
a language comprises nothing other than individual elements and their abstract meanings. This may well be the CS position. If so, it nonetheless has to be shown in detail how grammatical patterns and composite meanings emerge extra-linguistically through interpretive processes, or alternatively, why virtually every other linguistic tradition is simply mistaken in believing that they exist. One aspect of grammar that CS does explicitly address is the abstract meanings of individual grammatical elements. I generally like the meanings proposed, and in the case of grammar I suspect that the most schematic values are often the most important. While I myself see a gradation, the elements linguists consider “grammatical” (as opposed to “lexical”) are precisely those whose meanings are more schematic. The semantic import of grammar resides primarily in the construal imposed on lexical content, and one dimension of construal consists of various kinds of prominence (e.g. profiling, trajector/landmark alignment). I would not disagree with the following description by Diver (1995: 103): . . . the discovery, in language after language, of a semantic substance that may be characterized in general as ‘Concentration of Attention . . .’ This communicative problem appears to be the single most important factor in determining the makeup of grammatical systems.
For a specific example of grammatical structure, let us focus on prenominal possessives in English, marked by ’s and its variants. The abstract meaning I ascribe to ’s consists in a reference point relation between two things, i.e. the dynamic process of directing attention first to a reference point and then to a target accessible through it (Figure 6). This schematic meaning is comparable (at least in degree of abstractness) to those adopted in CS. Moreover, it accounts in part for the morpheme’s range of uses. It is sufficiently abstract to accommodate the wide variety of possessive locutions, as in (4)a. Yet, owing to the inherent asymmetry of a reference point relationship, it accounts for the usual irreversibility of such expressions, as seen in (4)b. This too is in the CS spirit. But is that sufficient? Is this single abstract meaning all we need to say about ’s and the prenominal possessive construction in our description of English grammar? In the CG perspective, it is also necessary to include a range of more specific senses, reflecting certain kinds of uses common enough to become entrenched and conventionalized.²¹ Among these are prototypical instantiations of possessive relationships, notably ownership, kinship, and whole-part relations. Examples of more peripheral senses are those pertaining to modes of transport (e.g. our bus), emotional states (her anxiety), and the focal participants in a reified event (the army’s destruction [of the city], the city’s destruction [by the army]). As noted previously, how many senses we posit is largely dependent on how salient we require them to be, which in turn depends on our purpose. The important point is that a particular range of uses — out of all the conceivable ones — stand out as being familiar and conventional. As such they constitute packaged solutions to particular interpretive and communicative problems, one facet of knowing how to speak the lan-
5
52
Ronald W. Langacker
guage. Hence they are part of the “linguistic system,” under the broad definition (Figure 16). From the abstract meaning alone, one cannot predict exactly what the conventional range of uses might be (cf. Nikiforidou 1991). For instance, we can imagine a language just like English except that prenominal possessives could not be used for emotional states, or could only be used for the trajector of a reified event (not its landmark). But whether a single meaning is posited or a family of related meanings, we have not yet described the grammatical construction. The possessive morpheme’s meaning, in and of itself, will not tell us everything we need to know in order to use it correctly in complex expressions. For instance, it has to be specified that ’s occurs on the possessor noun phrase (e.g. Bill’s knife), and not on the possessed noun (*Bill knife’s), on both (*Bill’s knife’s), or on neither (*Bill knife). It has to be specified that the possessor nominal precedes rather than follows the possessed noun (*knife Bill’s). It has to be specified that, in the case of complex possessor nominals, ’s attaches phonologically to the last word of the nominal, which retains its contiguity (the King of France’s wig); it does not attach to the head noun (*the King’s of France wig), nor can a modifier be postposed (*the King’s wig of France). But even when the marker is borne by another element, e.g. France in the King of France’s wig, the possessor (or reference point) is still identified with the entity profiled by the head noun (and thus by the nominal as a whole). Suppose you knew nothing about English possessives other than the form and abstract meaning of the possessive marker. From this information, you could not predict all the details just listed, nor the countless other details required for conventional possessive use in the language. For this reason, a full description of English — even as langue — has to include an explicit characterization of the prenominal possessive construction. In CG this is done by means of constructional schemas, i.e. schematic symbolic assemblies which embody the abstract organizational commonality inherent over a range of complex expressions. Prenominal possessives, for instance, would be described by a symbolic assembly analogous to Figure 7, except for containing schematic nominal elements rather than specific ones.²² The one explicit discussion of this issue I have encountered in the CS literature actually amounts to a proscription of constructional schemas: . . . If combinations of signs can themselves be signs, then there is no principled way to put limits on the system and make it discrete . . . The limitless, infinitely recursive Saussurean sign, then, is the sponsor of maximalist linguistics . . . In both [Saussure and Langacker], the inventory of units is ill-defined, making it very easy to attribute to the conceptual inventory of the language what would be more reasonably confined to the ever-shifting conceptual set of communication. (Otheguy 1995: 232–233)
A symbolic structure is a sign, and an assembly of symbolic structures is a combination of signs. It is not, however, true that recognizing constructions and constructional schemas results in an infinite regress. It is wrong to claim that in a maxi-
Cognitive Grammar and double subject constructions
malist view there are no limits and no principled grounds for delimitation. The basis for delimitation is the same as for the senses of a lexical item: the joint factors of entrenchment and conventionalization. These are matters of degree, so there is no sharp cut-off point, but rather a gradation. But they do impose limits, since structures with zero entrenchment and conventionalization are totally “outside” the linguistic system.²³ It is true that the inventory of complex signs is nonetheless very large, so that actually writing a complete grammar is not a realistic task. This is not a valid argument against the maximalist view, however, any more than the impossibility of fully describing the brain (describing every neuron and every neural connection) is an argument that the brain does not exist. Large numbers of constructional schemas have to be recognized in a minimally adequate description of the conventional patterns speakers employ in putting together complex expressions. On grounds of theoretical preference, one can certainly make an a priori decision to exclude such patterns from the “linguistic system,” but only at the cost of omitting a large proportion of the conventional knowledge one needs to learn in order to speak a language. We cannot just attribute grammatical patterns “to the ever-shifting conceptual set of communication” and let it go at that — whatever their degree of conceptual and communicative motivation, the specific patterns conventionally employed in a language have to be learned by speakers and explicitly described by linguists. Nor does the fact that speakers often stray from these patterns, through negligence or creative innovation, constitute an argument against their existence. It is only by acknowledging and elucidating the patterns that we can recognize and characterize such behavior.²⁴ Grammatical patterns are further necessary for an account of semantic composition, which concerns the relation between the meaning of a complex expression and the meanings of its parts. I have not detected in CS any systematic attempt to deal with this fundamental linguistic problem, or even an explicit recognition that the problem exists. In practice, there often seems to be a tacit assumption that the meaning of a whole is merely the sum of the abstract meanings of its parts (i.e. the component lexical items), and that anything beyond this is attributable to contextual interpretation based on communicative strategies and other “human factors.” That is not however a viable assumption. If it were true, then a pair of sentences like (23)a-b would have the same linguistic meaning, since they consist of the same lexical items: (23) a. The big dog frightened a tiny cat. b. A big cat frightened the tiny dog. A complex expression’s meaning is not just a pile of semantic features, nor an unordered set of lexical meanings, but rather a structured conceptualization in which conceptual elements fit together in very specific ways. In (23)a, for instance, the property ‘big’ is ascribed to the dog, and the property ‘tiny’ to the cat — it is not the reverse, nor are these properties assigned to other entities evident in the discourse context.²⁵
53
54
Ronald W. Langacker
These specifications and others (e.g. the ascription of agentivity and of definiteness to the dog rather than the cat in (23)a) are totally determined by structural relationships enshrined in linguistic convention. They are not left for individual speakers to figure out de novo subject to the vicissitudes of an “ever-shifting conceptual set of communication”. Nor do they follow inexorably from human factors or functional principles. It might be suggested, for instance, that contiguity is such a strong factor in cognitive processing that big is necessarily attributed to dog in (23)a, and tiny to cat, as the invariable and automatic outcome of interpretive processes. This strategy is simply not adequate, however. There are languages which do not require contiguity between a head and its modifiers. More generally, cognitive, communicative, and functional considerations are notorious for their underdetermination of linguistic structure — that is why languages differ synchronically and diverge diachronically, even though such factors are largely universal. Without denying the strong and pervasive influence of functional motivation, the fact remains that language structure includes large inventories of learned, conventional grammatical constructions. In CG, these constructions take the form of symbolic assemblies which specify how component elements are integrated semantically and phonologically (see Figures 5, 7, 10, 12–14).²⁶ Although grammatical constructions are a central concern of CG, and are seemingly proscribed in CS, I would like to suggest that the contrast is not absolute. I believe in fact that the notion of a grammatical construction is already implicit in CS. It inheres in the recognition that certain abstract meanings are symbolized by position rather than by a separate morphological element. A case in point is central focus (or trajector) in a language which marks it by means of word order. In a sentence like Alice admires Bill, for instance, position before the predicate is what tells us that Alice, and not Bill, is the central focus. As it stands, however, this description is quite vague. It presupposes a number of very specific relationships that need to be made explicit in any full or rigorous characterization of the sign. Phonologically, what the sign consists of is the relative position in the speech stream of two other signs, namely Alice and admires Bill (or just admires — the choice is immaterial to the argument). If we state this in general terms (not just for the sentence in question), the sign consists of the relation between two other phonological structures, call them X and Y, such that X and Y are contiguous in the dimension of speech time (T) and X precedes Y. This is shown in Figure 17(a). Semantically, a central focus does not exist in isolation; we can only speak of a central focus with respect to the situation described by a verb or clausal predicate. Using CG terminology (for sake of ready comparison), we can call this situation a process and represent it with an arrow, as shown on the right in 17(b). The central focus — or trajector — is some participant in this process, represented as a circle. The predicate, however, does not itself identify this entity (except through its role in the process). Its identification is effected by the accompanying nominal expression, e.g. Alice in Alice admires Bill. In particular, the focused entity is the one that is designated — or in CG terms, profiled — by this nominal as a whole. This is
Cognitive Grammar and double subject constructions
shown on the left in 17(b). The dotted correspondence line makes it explicit that the predicate’s trajector and the nominal’s profile are equated. We also need to be explicit concerning the relation between the phonological structures in Figure 17(a) and the semantic structures in 17(b). Namely, the process whose central focus is at issue is specifically the one symbolized by the phonological structure given as Y, and the nominal whose referent functions as its central focus is specifically the one symbolized by X. These connections are shown in 17(c), which depicts the semantic and phonological relationships between two component signs, characterized as a nominal expression and a predicate. The overall configuration amounts to a complex sign consisting of a combination of signs — supposedly proscribed in CS. Yet there is nothing here that is not essential to making precise and explicit the notion that a concept like “central focus” can be symbolized by relative position in the speech stream. I suggest, then, that the proscription of signs consisting of other signs has to be abandoned even on grounds internal to CS, to avoid contradiction. This should not be regarded as problematic, since (pace Otheguy) it does not in fact lead to infinite recursion; complex signs need only be recognized as part of the linguistic system to the extent that they are entrenched and conventionalized. And if complex signs are allowed in CS in the guise of meanings marked by relative position, why not allow them for other purposes as well? In particular, they would permit CS to say something substantive about grammatical patterns and semantic composition (which are currently just ignored, if not denied). Accepting complex signs would lend CS greater credibility as a viable theory of language structure. This would also move CS in the direction of CG, because there is no difference in principle between a complex sign and an assembly of symbolic structures. It should be evident that a structure like Figure 17(c) is equivalent to a CG constructional schema describing a grammatical pattern. Using the representational format adopted in this chapter, 17(c) can be reformulated as shown in 17(d). a.
X
tr
b.
Y
T tr
c. X
tr
d.
XY
Y tr
T X Figure 17.
Y
55
56
Ronald W. Langacker
The two component signs in 17(c) appear as the component symbolic structures in 17(d). The composite structure, shown at the top in 17(d), simply makes explicit the result of combining the component signs. The arrow for speech time in 17(c) is omitted in 17(d) just for sake of diagrammatic convenience. The differences, in short, are merely notational.
4 Conclusion I hope this critique of CS has been fair and constructive. While I obviously disagree with CS doctrine on certain fundamental issues, there are many points on which we agree, and grounds for much broader agreement should CS practitioners be willing to reconsider some basic tenets adopted for reasons that might be viewed as suspect. Theory aside, however, I usually find the analyses proposed in CS to be both insightful and revelatory. Linguists of other persuasions will profit by carefully examining CS descriptions and the methodology used to support them. At the same time, CS would benefit from greater awareness of work in Cognitive linguistics dealing with problems crucial to an overall account of language. Even under a narrow definition of “language,” interpretive phenomena have to be carefully investigated and thoroughly understood, since these are being relied on to make up the difference. Only by studying such phenomena systematically (rather than just appealing to them) can one show a narrow construal of “language” to be principled and viable. The bottom line is that I perceive the differences between CS and CG as being less fundamental and less important than they might appear to be on superficial examination. This has the consequence — like it or not — that I consider CS to be part of Cognitive linguistics, and one place I can regularly look to for insight into language. I hope nobody objects too strongly.
Notes 1. See Langacker 1987, 1990, 1991, 1999b, and the references cited therein. 2. Analogously, the reduction expressed by the formula H2O fails to imply the non-existence of water. 3. We thus avoid the circularity of defining husband as ‘one who has a wife’, and wife as ‘one who has a husband’. 4. The relational participants are given as circles. The labels tr and lm stand for “trajector” and “landmark”, discussed in the following section. 5. In diagrams, I normally use circles to represent things, and various kinds of lines and arrows for relationships. 6. Expressed by a clause, the proposition is represented mnemonically by a circle and an arrow, to indicate a thing participating in a process. The box is simply meant to show that the proposition as a whole functions as target.
Cognitive Grammar and double subject constructions 7. Examples from the five languages represented are taken respectively from Kumashiro 2000; informal notes by Kee-Dong Lee; Teng 1974; Cook 1988 and Hung 1988; and Steele 1977. The following abbreviations are used: SUBJ = subject marker; ASSR = assertive; COM = comitative; DAT = dative; PRES = present; 1/3s = first/third person singular. In his very detailed description of this phenomenon in Japanese, Kumashiro provides strong evidence that there are two basic construction types, the type illustrated in (6) being reanalyzed as having a complex predicate with a single subject. For present purposes we can ignore this further development. 8. Evidence for these points depends on the language. In Japanese, for instance, both NP1 and NP2 can take the subject marker ga, at least under certain conditions. In Luiseño, the clitic agreeing with the subject appears as the first person singular =n in (14), agreeing with NP1, and as the third person singular =up in (15), agreeing with NP2. There is no intonation break, and since the clitic in Luiseño occurs in second position within a clause, its placement after NP1 indicates the single-clause nature of these examples. 9. It is suggestive that this highly eminent lexicographer should believe that long, elaborate definitions are needed (and also polysemy, sparingly used) if they are to do the job of properly predicting occurrences. 10. For instance, the theories of metaphor, mental spaces, and conceptual blending give a radically different view of cognition than anything preestablished or generally assumed in psychology. See Lakoff and Johnson 1980; Lakoff and Turner 1989; Fauconnier 1985, 1997; Fauconnier and Turner 1998. 11. It seems less radical today, since “mainstream” linguistics has steadily evolved in its direction. 12. Note the title Meaning as Explanation (Contini-Morava and Goldberg 1995). 13. It comes to the fore in my study (with Eugene Casad) of the u/a opposition in Cora locatives (Langacker 1990: ch. 2). Also, maximal opposition figures in the characterization of prototypes and basic level concepts (Rosch 1978). 14. A new sense can either deviate from the one that spawns it (implying some conflict in semantic specifications) or else elaborate it (by incorporating additional content or spelling it out in finer-grained detail). 15. Note that I am not demanding absolute predictability of an element’s range of uses. In fact, its non-predictability is precisely why I adopt the network model. I further believe that the method of ex post facto rationalization employed in CS descriptions is quite appropriate (notwithstanding the pretentious rhetoric of prediction standard among linguistic theorists). I am merely proposing what I consider a realistic assessment of what a single abstract meaning can do, even granting its correctness. 16. For present purposes this basic meaning can be taken as either a prototype (more likely in CG) or an abstract schema (as in CS). 17. I realize, of course, that proponents of every theory would like to impose their own definition of “language” in order to enhance the perceived importance of their own work. 18. Presumably the pattern of stripes we see on a zebra would not be a property of the zebra per se, but the result of using “visual strategies”. 19. This is not to deny the value of limited, focused contributions. The issue, rather, is whether there are sound arguments for the particular limitations imposed by CS doctrine.
57
58
Ronald W. Langacker 20. Of course, the evidence might point in the opposite direction. It seems clear, for example, that children first use words in fairly specific circumstances, and that the general direction of development is from concrete to abstract. In claiming that highly schematic meanings are the only ones which count as “language,” CS scholars will be more credible if they indicate how their view can be reconciled with the developmental facts. 21. It does not matter whether we talk about multiple senses of the morpheme or multiple variants of the grammatical construction in which it occurs. In CG these are two sides of the same coin (Langacker 1999b: ch. 4). 22. Naturally, Figure 7 is only illustrative, hence significantly oversimplified. Moreover, to fully describe a construction — and capture the kinds of details listed in the text — requires not just one but a family of related constructional schemas (analogous to the family of related senses of a lexical item). 23. I reiterate that these factors can in principle be scientifically investigated and measured (e.g. by text counts for conventionalization, by psychological experiments for entrenchment), and that the maximalist position is adopted (reluctantly) for the purpose of achieving adequate descriptions. Counter to Otheguy’ s statements, positing units is not done just on the basis of “felt stability” of a group (1995: 234) or because a group “struck the analyst as unitary” (232). 24. Beyond grammatical patterns, a vast number of specific complex expressions are learned and stored as units. Typically they incorporate a measure of idiosyncrasy that has to be recognized as part of their conventionally established value. If CS wishes to deny the existence of signs consisting of other signs, it needs to confront the massive amount of evidence to the contrary adduced in the construction grammar literature (e.g. Fillmore et al. 1988; Goldberg 1995; Michaelis and Lambrecht 1996). 25. I realize that word order is recognized in CS as a signalling device. However, it is posited for only a small fraction of the structural and semantic relationships that need to be accommodated (notably for what are traditionally called “subject” and “object” relations), and I see no way to make it work for the full range of cases. Moreover, positing a word-order sign does not per se make explicit the nature of the structured conceptualization emerging from the ordered elements. I suggest below that making this explicit (as it has to be) amounts to the adoption of grammatical constructions in the CG sense. 26. Cognitive linguists do not claim that semantics is fully compositional, only that patterns of composition (as embodied in constructional schemas) are one, crucial factor in “meaning construction”.
References Contini-Morava, E. 1995. “Introduction: On linguistic sign theory.” In Contini-Morava and Goldberg, 1–39. Contini-Morava, E., and Goldberg, B. S. (eds.). 1995. Meaning as Explanation: Advances in Linguistic Sign Theory. Berlin/New York: Mouton de Gruyter. Cook, K.W. 1988.“The semantics of Newari case-marking distinctions.” Linguistic Notes from La Jolla 14: 42–56. Diver, W. 1995. “Theory.” In Contini-Morava and Goldberg, 43–114. Fauconnier, G. 1985. Mental Spaces: Aspects of Meaning Construction in Natural Language. Cambridge, MA/London: MIT Press/Bradford.
Cognitive Grammar and double subject constructions Fauconnier, G. 1997. Mappings in Thought and Language. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Fauconnier, G., and Turner, M. 1998. “Conceptual integration networks.” Cognitive Science 22: 133–187. Fillmore, C. J., Kay, P., and O’Connor, M. C. 1988.“Regularity and idiomaticity in grammatical constructions: The case of let alone.” Language 64: 501–538. Goldberg, A. E. 1995. Constructions: A Construction Grammar Approach to Argument Structure. Chicago/London: University of Chicago Press. Huffman, A. 1997. The Categories of Grammar: French lui and le. Amsterdam/Philadelphia: John Benjamins. Hung, T. 1988. “Case and role in Newari: A Cognitive Grammar approach.” Linguistic Notes from La Jolla 14: 95–107. Janssen, T. 1995. “Deixis from a cognitive point of view.” In Contini-Morava and Goldberg, 245–270. Kirsner, R. S., and Thompson, S. A. 1976. “The role of pragmatic inference in semantics: A study of sensory verb complements in English.” Glossa 10: 200–240. Kumashiro, T. 2000. The Conceptual Basis of Grammar: A Cognitive Approach to Japanese Clause Structure. San Diego: University of California doctoral dissertation. Lakoff, G., and Johnson, M. 1980. Metaphors We Live By. Chicago/London: University of Chicago Press. Lakoff, G., and Turner, M. 1989. More Than Cool Reason: A Field Guide to Poetic Metaphor. Chicago/London: University of Chicago Press. Langacker, R.W. 1987. Foundations of Cognitive Grammar, vol. 1, Theoretical Prerequisites. Stanford: Stanford University Press. Langacker, R.W. 1988. “A usage-based model.” In Topics in Cognitive Linguistics, B. RudzkaOstyn (ed.), 127–161. Amsterdam/Philadelphia: John Benjamins. Langacker, R.W. 1990. Concept, Image, and Symbol: The Cognitive Basis of Grammar. Berlin/ New York: Mouton de Gruyter. Langacker, R.W. 1991. Foundations of Cognitive Grammar, vol. 2, Descriptive Application. Stanford: Stanford University Press. Langacker, R.W. 1993. “Reference-point constructions.” Cognitive Linguistics 4: 1–38. Langacker, R.W. 1995a. “Possession and possessive constructions.” In Language and the Cognitive Construal of the World, J. R. Taylor and R. E. MacLaury (eds.), 51–79. Berlin/New York: Mouton de Gruyter. Langacker, R.W. 1995b. “Raising and transparency.” Language 71: 1–62. Langacker, R.W. 1997. “Constituency, dependency, and conceptual grouping.” Cognitive Linguistics 8: 1–32. Langacker, R.W. 1999a. “Double-Subject Constructions.” In Linguistics in the Morning Calm 4, S.-Y. Bak (ed.), 83–104. Seoul: Hanshin. Langacker, R.W. 1999b. Grammar and Conceptualization. Berlin/New York: Mouton de Gruyter. Langacker, R.W. 1999c.“Assessing the cognitive linguistic enterprise.” In Cognitive Linguistics: Foundations, Scope, and Methodology, T. Janssen and G. Redeker (eds.), 13–59. Berlin/ New York: Mouton de Gruyter. Langacker, R.W. 2001. “Topic, Subject, and Possessor.” In A Cognitive Approach to the Verb: Morphological and Constructional Perspectives, H. G. Simonsen and R. T. Endresen (eds.), 11–48. Berlin/New York: Mouton de Gruyter.
59
60
Ronald W. Langacker Levinson, S. C. 1997. “From outer to inner space: Linguistic categories and non-linguistic thinking.” In Language and Conceptualization, J. Nuyts and E. Pederson (eds.), 13–45. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Michaelis, L. A., and Lambrecht, K. 1996. “Toward a construction-based theory of language function: The case of nominal extraposition.” Language 72: 215–247. Nikiforidou, K. 1991. “The meanings of the genitive: A case study in semantic structure and semantic change.” Cognitive Linguistics 2: 149–205. Otheguy, R. 1995. “When contact speakers talk, linguistic theory listens.” In Contini-Morava and Goldberg, 213–242. Reid, W. 1991. Verb and Noun Number in English: A Functional Explanation. London/New York: Longman. Reid, W. 1995. “Quantitative analysis in Columbia School theory.” In Contini-Morava and Goldberg, 115–152. Rosch, E. 1978. “Principles of categorization.” In Cognition and Categorization, E. Rosch and B. B. Lloyd (eds.), 27–47. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum. Steele, S. M. 1977. “On being possessed.” Berkeley Linguistics Society 3: 114–131. Talmy, L. 1988. “Force dynamics in language and cognition.” Cognitive Science 12: 49–100. Taylor, J. R. 1996. Possessives in English: An Exploration in Cognitive Grammar. Oxford: Oxford University Press/Clarendon. Teng, S.-H. 1974. “Double nominatives in Chinese.” Language 50: 455–473. Wierzbicka, A. 1988. The Semantics of Grammar. Amsterdam/Philadelphia: John Benjamins. Wierzbicka, A. 1996. Semantics: Primes and Universals. Oxford/New York: Oxford University Press.
CHAPTER 2
Cataphoric pronouns as mental space designators Their conceptual import and discourse function Michael B. Smith Oakland University, Rochester, Michigan
Building on Fauconnier’s mental space theory (1985), I argue that some languages have mental space designators, morphosyntactic elements which designate the mental spaces set up by linguistic expressions called space builders. Cataphoric pronouns can serve this function as forward referring devices that link with a discourse entity not yet overtly mentioned, as illustrated by the pronoun it in the sentence I despise it that John voted for the governor. Their discourse function is to anticipate the mental spaces set up by space builders (such as despise) by grammatically designating the spaces themselves, which are then elaborated with linguistically expressed propositions (e.g. that John voted for the governor). Evidence for this analysis includes English space building verbs evoking negative feelings which require cataphoric object it (cf. dislike, resent), where the cataphor’s overt mention of the space itself accentuates the conceptual distance (cf. Haiman 1983, 1985a, b) between the matrix subject and the undesirable relation(s) holding within the spaces by iconically distancing — in the grammar — the matrix subject from the subordinate clause describing those relations. The cataphor can also accentuate the salience of the space’s boundaries as a setting for an event, e.g. You know (it) when the train goes by. Cataphoric it forces a reading emphasizing the train’s physical effect on the setting prefigured by it, and thus accentuates the sense of know which evokes knowledge gained by the senses; omission of cataphoric it emphasizes someone’s intellectual knowledge of the time when the train goes by, and thus accentuates the sense of know which evokes purely intellectual knowledge. The discussion will support a view of grammar in which there is an iconic link between the forms and the meanings conveyed by the forms in these constructions.
1. Introduction to the issue: anaphora vs. cataphora This chapter is concerned with investigating a grammatical phenomenon which is only infrequently discussed in the linguistic literature: the meaning and function of
62
Michael B. Smith
cataphoric pronouns like those occurring postverbally in the following English (1a) and German (1b) sentences and after the adjective uveren “sure” in the Russian sentence (1c) (the optionality of some of these pronouns will be addressed presently). (1) a. I despise it that John voted for the governor. b. Wir bedauern (es), daß Hans so dumm ist. we regret it that Hans so dumb is ‘We regret (it) that Hans is so stupid.’ c. Ja uveren (v tom), čto on sderžit svojo slovo. I sure in that, that he keep his word ‘I’m sure that he will keep his word.’ Note that the pronouns in these examples, English it, German es “it”, and Russian tom “that” (the prepositional case form of the neuter singular demonstrative pronoun to) are not anaphors, because they clearly have no antecedents within the clause to which they can refer. Consequently, their occurrence seems, at least at first glance, grammatically and semantically arbitrary and/or superfluous, their functional motivation is unclear, and their meaning contribution to the clause (if any) is obscure. This is because, in contrast to backward referring anaphoric pronouns which are clearly linked with previously mentioned entities in the discourse, cataphoric pronouns are forward referring devices, i.e. their function is to anticipate some aspect of the discourse which follows their occurrence. As noted by Greenberg, In anaphora there is coreferentiality between the anaphoric substitute and the antecedent which precedes and is therefore identified. If we reverse this, the cataphoric substitute cannot be coreferential at the moment it is used because we do not yet know what it refers to. After the cataphor has been mentioned we can then in retrospect say that it is coreferential or that when the substitute is used it is proleptically cataphoric. (Greenberg 1985: 283)
The forward referring nature of cataphors means that a cataphor must, presumably, be linked with an entity of some sort which has not yet been overtly mentioned. The question before us, then, is to investigate the nature of this yet-to-be-mentioned entity, which will lead to a discussion of whether cataphoric pronouns like those illustrated in (1) are semantically motivated, or whether they are just arbitrary grammatical elements without semantic significance. I will argue that it is possible to support the claim that cataphors of this kind do have semantic content when a sufficiently sophisticated view of meaning is taken into account.¹
2. Some theoretical background It is not an exaggeration to say that linguistic theory has devoted relatively little attention to the syntactic and semantic properties of cataphoric pronouns in comparison to their more familiar anaphoric counterparts. “The difficulty of finding true examples of cataphora, and the commonplace nature of anaphora suggests the
Cataphoric pronouns as mental space designators
unmarked status of the latter”, notes Greenberg (1985: 284), which is probably related to the fact that cataphors are appreciably less common than anaphors. Few introductory textbooks on syntax and semantics even mention cataphoric pronouns, though they usually devote a great deal of space to accounting for the intricacies of anaphoric relationships in various languages (cf. such books as Cook and Newson (1996), Haegeman (1994), Sag and Wasow (1999), Van Valin, Jr. and LaPolla (1997), Radford (1997), and Culicover (1997) to name but a few). This neglect of cataphoric pronouns even extends to scholarly monographs on syntax and semantics. One need only reflect on the central importance of the binding theory in one recently (and still) popular syntactic framework as evidence for this (cf. Chomsky 1981, 1986), and a perusal of some other influential theoretical syntactic frameworks that have arisen in recent years confirms this general neglect (cf. the articles in Bresnan (1982) on lexical-functional grammar; studies in Perlmutter (1983) and Perlmutter and Rosen (1984) on relational grammar; and papers in Webelhuth (1995) on the minimalist program, etc.). A descriptive monograph by Pütz (1986) on the syntax of German es is a notable exception to this generalization in devoting several sections to a consideration of the function of es in constructions like those in (1b) above. But, unfortunately, Pütz does not explicitly refer to this kind of es as a cataphor, nor does he offer any kind of semantic characterization for its occurrence with some verbs but not with others (indeed he rejects the very possibility of a semantic explanation) (cf. Pütz 1986: 142). Some traditional German grammars also mention this sort of cataphoric use of es in their descriptive surveys, noting its anticipatory function in contexts like those exemplified in (1b) above, but they too fail to fully consider the role of this morpheme in the grammar (see Pütz (1986: 55–56) for a summary of these descriptions). Even recent functional approaches to language, including cognitive grammar (Langacker 1987, 1991a, b), have had little to say to date about the use and meaning of cataphoric pronouns, though they are potentially well-suited to the task. Nevertheless, Givón (1990, 1995) has investigated the differences between what he calls anaphoric (backward) grounding and cataphoric (anticipatory) grounding in discourse. Evoking Gernsbacher (1990), he notes that the former “has been studied much more extensively . . . [i]t involves connecting incoming new information chunks to some existing mental representation”, whereas the latter “has been studied in much less detail . . . [i]t involves the opening of pending connections in yetto-be completed structure, in anticipation of a text that is in the process of being constructed” (Givón 1995: 347). As will become clear in the following paragraphs, this conception of cataphora is compatible in spirit to the approach I will adopt and attempt to make more explicit in this chapter. The analysis I will propose will be grounded within the cognitive linguistic approach to language as described in works by Langacker (1987, 1991a, 1991b), Lakoff (1987), and Fauconnier (1985, 1997), all of which emphasize investigating the symbolic nature of grammar and the meaningfulness of grammatical constructs.² A theoretical construct in this framework which will prove particularly relevant in
63
64
Michael B. Smith
explaining the occurrence of cataphoric pronouns is the notion of mental spaces, which have been shown independently by Fauconnier (1985) and studies in Fauconnier and Sweetser (1996) to be insightful in analyzing a wide array of classic problems in semantics, including opaque-transparent ambiguities associated with propositional attitude verbs, the projection problem with presuppositions, and the interpretation of counterfactuals, to name but a few. Because the notion of a mental space will play a crucial role in this chapter, I will briefly outline its substance below and provide a couple of short examples adapted from Fauconnier’s work to illustrate the concept’s validity as a theoretical construct in linguistics. Space limitations preclude a detailed presentation of the many arguments in favor of mental spaces, which can be found in Fauconnier’s works. Let us first consider some preliminary background. The relevant literature (cited above) holds that the notion of a mental space evokes the intuitively natural idea that various aspects of sentence structure — both lexical and grammatical — set up “cognitive constructions” which help organize the processing of meaning within individual sentences and the flow of information between sentences in a larger discourse (cf. Fauconnier and Sweetser 1996). Fauconnier and Sweetser identify a number of such cognitive constructions, including metaphoric projection, frame organization (Goffman 1974, Fillmore 1985), roles, figure ground configurations, metonymic pragmatic functions (Nunberg 1978), cognitive schemas, and cultural models (Fauconnier and Sweetser 1996: 8). Mental space research, they note, is one line of investigation within cognitive linguistics which addresses the question of what kinds of cognitive entities or mental representations are involved in meaning construction in language. This research program represents an attempt to develop “a detailed model of the meaning construction that takes place under pressure from language forms, context, structured background knowledge, and other pragmatic factors” (Fauconnier and Sweetser 1996: 10). Fundamentally, mental spaces are theoretical constructs within cognitive linguistics posited to facilitate important aspects of meaning construction. In effect, they are conceived to be mental “places” or frames, usually triggered by certain lexical or grammatical devices, that are created in certain contexts and within which semantico-pragmatic information is located and organized relative to aspects of background knowledge (as mentioned above). Often the real world itself (or the speaker’s conception of what that world is like) is represented as reality space. The following quote from Fauconnier and Sweetser gives a representative idea of their conception of mental spaces: The dynamics of mental space construction and space linking are technically abstract, but conceptually straightforward. The basic idea is that, as we think and talk, mental spaces are set up, structured, and linked under pressure from grammar, context, and culture. The effect is to create a network of spaces through which we move as discourse unfolds. (Fauconnier and Sweetser 1996: 11)
From this perspective, then, note that part of the meaning of a propositional attitude verb such as believe involves opening up a new domain or knowledge struc-
Cataphoric pronouns as mental space designators
ture within the prevailing or current context that is “set up to contain structured information and inferences ‘about’ beliefs” (Fauconnier and Sweetser 1996: 10). This knowledge structure is a mental space. According to Fauconnier, mental spaces play an important role in the dynamic aspects of meaning construction, which he defines as “high level, complex mental operations that apply within and across domains when we think, act, or communicate” (1997: 1). These domains are mental structures (Langacker has called them “conceived worlds” (1991b: 71)), i.e. “partial structures that proliferate when we think and talk, allowing a fine-grained partitioning of our discourse and knowledge structures” (Fauconnier 1997: 11).³ Mental spaces are internally structured by frames and cognitive models which are akin to Lakoff ’s idealized cognitive models (1987). Much of Fauconnier’s work focuses on motivating mental space mappings, “which link mental spaces set up in discourse” (1997: 12) by means of connectors (pragmatically induced links or functions) that “relate . . . structures across spaces” (1997: 39) (see also Fauconnier (1985: 3ff.)).⁴ Fauconnier claims that mental spaces are “constructs distinct from linguistic structures [my emphasis] but built up in any discourse according to guidelines provided by the linguistic expressions” (1985: 16). They can be built up in discourse by certain kinds of linguistic expressions called space builders, such as prepositional phrases (in Dali’s painting), adverbs (possibly), connectives (if . . . then), subject-verb complexes (Harry believes), and also subject-adjective complexes in Russian (Ja uveren “I’m sure” in (1c)). Space builders are “overt mechanisms which speakers can use to induce the hearer to set up a new mental space” (Fauconnier and Sweetser 1996: 10); i.e. they “will typically establish new spaces, elements within them, and relations holding between the elements” (Fauconnier 1985: 17).⁵ Note that the criteria used to discern which kinds of linguistic elements set up mental spaces is primarily semantic in nature. In effect, we are making a theoretical assumption that certain linguistic expressions set up mental spaces by virtue of the kinds of meanings they evoke, as will be seen in more detail in the discussion to follow.⁶ As mentioned earlier, the positing of mental spaces can elegantly facilitate the interpretation of opaque-transparent ambiguities associated with propositional attitude verbs, as illustrated in sentence (2), in which the verb believe sets up a mental (belief) space M along side of reality space R (representing the world as it is) against which the interpretation of the indefinite noun phrase a governor can be disambiguated. (2) John believes that a governor will win the presidency. The nominal a governor can be interpreted as referring either to a governor in John’s belief space which is the same as a particular governor in R (the transparent or specific reading sketched in the top diagram in Figure 1), or it can be interpreted as referring to an entity in M (John’s belief space) that has no counterpart in R (the opaque or nonspecific reading sketched in the lower diagram in Figure 1). Fauconnier notes that, according to this analysis, the existence of two different readings for
65
66
Michael B. Smith
x1: a real governor
x2: a governor in John’s belief space
x1
x2
R
M (“John believes ______”)
Transparent (specific) reading x2: a governor in John’s belief space x2
R
M
Opaque (nonspecific) reading Figure 1. Transparent vs. opaque ambiguities associated with verbs of propositional attitude (cf. Fauconnier 1985: 28)
this sentence “is purely a consequence of the discourse processing involved (construction of spaces, connectors, etc.); it is not linked to any structural ambiguity of the linguistic form at deep, semantic, or logical levels” (1985: 28–29). Mental spaces also provide a straightforward way of dealing with intricate and complex ambiguities involving anaphoric pronouns and their antecedents which cannot be represented easily by coindexing, especially in cases where “a pronoun with an antecedent in one space can freely identify its counterpart in another, connected space” (Fauconnier 1985: 35). Consider as an example a scenario (adapted and simplified from one discussed by Fauconnier (1985: 36–37)) in which someone makes a movie about Alfred Hitchcock’s life, with an actor playing the role of Hitchcock, but that Hitchcock himself plays a minor role (as he always did in his own films). Suppose further that in the movie’s script the character of the movie Hitchcock accidentally hurts himself in some way and that the real Hitchcock also actually hurt himself while playing the minor role in the movie. Then sentence (3) in this context is multiply ambiguous with respect to what the reflexive anaphor
Cataphoric pronouns as mental space designators
himself refers to (i.e. designates in the real or some possible world), in contrast to the apparent single reference of himself suggested by the traditional coindexing of the reflexive anaphor with its linguistic antecedent. (3) Hitchcocki hurt himselfi in that movie. Though coindexing adequately represents the anaphoric relationship between the anaphor and antecedent, it fails to indicate that this relationship is open to multiple interpretations which are not overtly distinguished by the linguistic expressions themselves, since the anaphor’s interpretation depends upon which referent of the proper noun Hitchcock is intended. A mental space analysis clarifies the matter in the following way. Note first that this sentence involves two different, connected, mental spaces: speaker reality R, in which both the real Hitchcock exists (r1) and also an actor exists (r2) who is playing him in the movie, and the movie space M set up by the prepositional phrase in that movie, which contains the minor character played by Hitchcock himself (m1) and the character of Hitchcock (m2) which is being played by the other actor. Positing the existence of mental spaces provides a simple account of the range of possible interpretations for sentence (3). The anaphor could refer to (designate) either the real Hitchcock (r1) in R (with the interpretation that the real Hitchcock hurt himself while making the movie), or to the cameo character Hitchcock is playing in the connected M space (m1) (with the interpretation that the minor character Hitchcock is playing hurts himself as part of the movie’s plot). Or the anaphor could refer to (designate) the character of Hitchcock which is being played by another actor (m2) in M (Fauconnier suggested Orson Welles could have played the part). The latter reading would have the interpretation that the Hitchcock character being played by Welles hurts himself as part of the plot. The point is that these three different interpretations of sentence (3) can be readily disambiguated by setting up different counterparts for the proper noun Hitchcock in two different mental spaces which the anaphor can refer to. Now that we have gotten a glimpse into how the notion of mental spaces can prove useful in dealing with problems in linguistic semantics, I will henceforth take it for granted that mental spaces are plausible theoretical constructs and turn now to the main claim of the chapter.
3. Mental space designators Up to this point we have focused on the idea that certain linguistic expressions set up or build mental spaces (space builders), but have not yet considered the possibility that in some cases these spaces might be overtly represented in grammatical structure itself. My central aim in this chapter is to present evidence that some languages not only have space builders, but also expressions I will call space designators, i.e. elements which actually designate — in the morphosyntax — the mental spaces
67
68
Michael B. Smith
themselves which are set up by the space builders (as opposed to forms which describe relations holding within such spaces). Fauconnier apparently makes no reference to this kind of construct in his work, but I will claim that the facts from English, German, and Russian support its viability and that the theory of mental spaces should be expanded to include it. Specifically, I argue that at least some uses of cataphoric pronouns serve this space-designating function, as illustrated by the anticipatory object pronouns in (1) above and the additional English (4), German (6), and Russian (7) sentences below. Consider first the cataphoric it which functions as the direct object of the matrix verbs in the English examples in (4) below. (4) a. b. c. d.
We abhor it that the mayor absconded with the money. She resents it that the class starts so early. They dislike it that the weather is so cold here. He detests it that Clinton was impeached.
Note that the matrix verbs in each example express different kinds of mental attitudes about the propositions which follow in the subordinate clauses. These propositional attitude verbs are therefore assumed to create mental spaces that represent new domains of knowledge within the prevailing or current context. The subordinate propositions are located conceptually within these spaces and are thus interpreted relative to the structured information and inferences about each kind of propositional attitude residing within each space. The cataphor it is either obligatory or highly preferred with the above space building verbs in English, but it is generally not tolerated with such space builders as believe, promise, feel, hope, know, think, etc., as shown in (5) below. A reason for this difference will be suggested in Section 5 below. (5) a. b. c. d.
*Mary believes it that the senator will lose. *The governor promised it that she would sign the bill. *They know it that there will likely be a drought this year. *She thinks it that the baby is crying.
In German, cataphoric es “it” may also appear either optionally or obligatorily with certain space building verbs, as shown by the data in (6) below. (6) a.
Ich wage (es) nicht, meinen Vater zu fragen. I dare it not my father to ask ‘I don’t dare ask my father.’ b. Paul vergißt (es), daß Inge kommt. Paul forgets it that Inge comes ‘Paul forgets that Inge’s coming.’ c. Peter lehnt *(es) ab, daß die Sozialisten gewonnen haben. Peter leans it from that the socialists won have ‘Peter refuses [to admit] that the socialists won.’
Cataphoric pronouns as mental space designators
d. Ich kann *(es) kaum ertragen, daß Hans gewonnen hat. I can it hardly bear that Hans won has ‘I can hardly stand it that Hans won.’ Cataphoric es is generally not allowed after such German verbs as wissen “know”, annehmen “accept”, behaupten “assert”, empfehlen “recommend”, denken “think”, glauben “believe”, fühlen “feel”, etc. (see Pütz (1986: 70) for a more complete list). The evidence suggests that there is a basic distinction in German between space builders which require cataphoric es (cf. (6c) and (6d) above) and those with which its occurrence is either optional or generally not allowed (cf. (6a) and (6b) above) (cf. Pütz 1986: 58–88 for detailed discussion).⁷ The determining factors for its optionality likely reside in the idiosyncratic meanings of each verb and go beyond the scope of this chapter (indeed they have not yet been adequately studied, as is noted by Pütz). Thus, in many instances it is not possible to predict whether the cataphoric es will or will not appear with a particular space builder, as is the case with verbs like vergessen “forget” in (6b) above. But the data are usually quite clear with respect to which verbs require the cataphor vs. those which do not, so I will focus on trying to account for the difference between these two main sets. I will propose a reason for the basic distinction between the two classes of verbs in Section 5 below.⁸ As noted above, a similar kind of cataphoric function is apparently served in Russian by a form of the demonstrative pronoun to ”that” in the following correlative constructions (where the differences in the pronoun’s phonological form reflects different cases) (cf. Leed, Nakhimovsky, and Nakhimovsky 1982: 150–151).⁹ (7) a.
Mne nravitsja (to), čto on vypolnjaet svoi obeščanija. me pleases that that he keeps REFL promises ‘I like the fact that he keeps his promises.’ b. Ja somnevajus’ (v tom), čto on skazal eto. I doubt in that that he said that ‘I doubt that he said that.’ c. Petja privyk (k tomy), čto kritiki ego vsegda xvaljat. Pete used to that that critics him always praise ‘Pete is used to critics always praising him.’ d. Ivan načal s togo, čto lično poznakomilsja so vsemi. Ivan began from that that personally acquainted with all ‘Ivan began by getting personally acquainted with everybody.’
We see from these data that, in addition to verbs and the other kinds of linguistic expressions mentioned previously, short form adjectives such as privyk “accustomed, used (to)” and uveren “sure” (from (1c)) can also serve as space builders in Russian. What might motivate the appearance of cataphors as mental space designators in constructions of this type? A natural explanation for the function of the cataphoric pronouns in discourse in these examples is to anticipate the mental spaces set up by space builders, such as despise in (1a), bedauern “regret” in (1b), and uv-
69
70
Michael B. Smith
Propositional attitude predicate prefigures a mental space (cataphoric pronoun accentuates space’s boundaries by actually designating space) I despise . . . it Wir bedauern . . . es Ja uveren v . . . tom
that . . . S dass . . . S čto . . . S
Figure 2.
eren “sure” in (1c), by actually designating the spaces themselves in the grammar. They often link the propositional attitude (or some action) of a matrix clause entity — usually the matrix subject — with particular relationships associated with that entity. The mental spaces are then subsequently elaborated by propositions expressed by “linguistic clauses, which typically. . .predicate relations holding between space elements” (Fauconnier 1985: 17). The sketch shown in Figure 2 gives a rough idea of how this works: the mental space set up by the space building verb or adjective that is designated by the cataphor is represented by the circle, and the clauses which fill in the space are shown inside the circle to indicate that they are inside the mental space. Under this analysis, the English space builder despise in (1a) sets up a mental space anticipated and designated by it, in which the proposition that John’s vote for the governor is negatively appraised. Similarly, in (1b) the German matrix verb bedauern “regret” sets up a mental space designated by the pronominal es, which is then elaborated by the clause stating the proposition that Hans is stupid. And in (1c) the Russian space builder uveren “sure” sets up a mental space which is then elaborated by a proposition expressed by subordinate clausal elements which describe what the matrix subject is “sure” (uveren) about. Similar descriptions could be given for the other data in (4), (6) and (7) above. In a nutshell, the proposed model is that the cataphor designates a space set up by a space building verb or adjective which is then elaborated with a subordinate proposition expressed by a linguistic expression. This latter proposition is then interpreted relative to the knowledge structures evoked in each space (i.e. with respect to despising something (1a), being regretful about something (1b), or being sure about something (1c)). Before proceeding further, it is worth mentioning that an apparently similar kind of function is proposed for such English “abstract and nonspecific nouns” as fact, idea, problem, rumor, advantage, claim, thing, point, etc. in a paper by Schmid (1999: 111), as illustrated by sentences like the following (which I have constructed to take the place of his longer examples extracted from corpus data).
Cataphoric pronouns as mental space designators
(8) a. b. c. d.
The fact was that we ran out of time. The idea was that we would go together to the concert. The problem was that they forgot to bring along any money. The rumor was that they were having an affair.
Schmid suggests that such nouns, which he calls “shell nouns”, function to provide “conceptual shells” (1999: 113) in the discourse which are subsequently elaborated by different contents that are expressed by the subordinate clauses which follow them.¹⁰ He goes on to note that “isolated uses of shell nouns do not activate conceptualisations that are experienced as saturated thoughts . . . Therefore speakers must link them to clauses or even longer stretches of text” (1999: 114). But each noun’s lexical content, however abstract it might be, does “have some potential for the characterisation of cognitive content” which influences the way in which the information to be supplied in the shell is construed (1999: 114). The use of the shell nouns problem in (8c) and rumor in (8d), for example, shade the interpretation of the subordinate clauses which follow their occurrence by labeling the content as being either negative or hypothetical in some way, respectively. Schmid notes that the conceptual shells set up by shell nouns are remarkably similar to Fauconnier’s notion of mental spaces, though Fauconnier does not seem to consider nouns as possible space builders (Schmid 1999: 115). Among the more interesting “cognitive effects” or functions of shell nouns noted by Schmid include their use in conceptual packaging, whereby they effect the “temporary reification of complex cognitive content as a thing” (1999: 122). That is, shell nouns are a linguistic means of packaging information economically and compactly into “unsaturated” (conceptually unelaborated) concepts which are then elaborated by “saturated thoughts” (conceptually elaborated concepts) that are ordinarily packaged less economically by linguistic clauses describing events or relations (Schmid 1999: 120). By using a shell noun, a speaker can more easily link the information referred to by the noun to other kinds of conceptualizations, since nouns prototypically designate things, and things are conceptually simpler and more efficient to manipulate than clauses designating events or relations. Schmid also observes that the shell-content pattern like that illustrated in (8) above effects the interpretation that “the information provided by [the shell nouns] is construed as given, and marked as being accessible” or taken for granted (i.e. topicalized), and that “the shell contents are highlighted for attention” and construed as “new and particularly noteworthy” or in focus (1999: 127–128). Schmid’s paper is interesting in the present context because it convincingly argues that mental spaces can be constructed by relatively abstract nominal entities (shell nouns) which are apparently more semantically abstract than Fauconnier’s space builders, but several degrees less abstract than cataphoric pronouns, plausibly the most abstract nominal elements of all. I would argue that his analysis supports my own claim that cataphoric pronouns can designate mental spaces, in that it suggests the possibility of the existence of a continuum of linguistic entities ranging
7
72
Michael B. Smith
from highly concrete expressions such as verbs, which set up mental spaces but do not designate them, to the more abstract space building shell nouns, to cataphoric pronouns which, I argue, do not so much create spaces as designate the spaces set up by more concrete clausal elements. Crucially, Schmid does not claim that shell nouns designate the mental spaces which they set up, but that they act very much like other kinds of more semantically concrete space builders in creating such spaces. If my own analysis is correct, then it is likely that cataphoric pronouns represent an extreme degree of grammaticalization and abstraction of this general process.¹¹ At this point let us stop to consider possible objections to an analysis that treats cataphors as space designators and even consider a possible counter-analysis. Some readers might claim that a linguistic construct with this kind of function really does not make any substantial meaning contribution to the clause, since the cataphor’s lexical content is essentially null, and that its proposed use in these sentences is nothing more than an arbitrary grammatical marker without semantic significance. Indeed, Greenberg alludes to this possibility when he notes that “a normally anaphoric marker used in this way cannot usually be anymore than a sign that some identification will follow, very much as an opening quotation mark tells us that a quotation is coming without it yet being known. For this reason it is always redundant from the specifically referential point of view” (1985: 283). While cognitive grammar does not deny the possibility that “such elements are, so to speak, grammaticized” (Greenberg 1985: 283), their regular and predictable grammatical function and apparently “redundant” contribution to the referential meaning of the clause does not necessarily mean that they are completely devoid of meaning. Indeed, the suggested function of cataphoric pronouns in the examples above can be viewed as reflecting the importance of the cognitive grammar notion of imagery in linguistic semantics, whereby each grammatical construction is conceived to impose a particular kind of conceptual organization on a conceived situation (cf. Langacker 1987, 1991a, 1991b), and the meaning of a linguistic expression involves not only its objective content but also how that content is construed. What this means is that, in spite of their apparent meaninglessness, the presence of cataphors in some constructions might provide a particular way of construing a scene or of organizing the elements in a given conceptualization which, at least in some instances, is semantically relevant. I will present evidence for this later in the chapter. Alternatively, it might be claimed that these pronouns are not cataphors at all, but that they are in fact actually “anaphoric, since what will follow has already been mentioned and the apparently cataphoric element is really coreferential with something that preceded and is simply about to give us an additional characterization or identification” (Greenberg 1985: 283). While I know of no way to prove conclusively that the pronominal elements in question are cataphors and not just anaphors in disguise (so to speak), I would simply note that it seems perfectly acceptable to use any of the English sentences in (4) above to start a conversation about a relevant topic, without the information which
Cataphoric pronouns as mental space designators
appears in the subordinate clauses necessarily already having been mentioned in previous discourse or even being part of the common ground. For example, it would be completely natural for me to change the topic of a conversation about a mutual friend of ours which had nothing at all to do with a class’s starting time by uttering (4b), and a similar point could be made about (4c) (repeated below). (4) b. She resents it that the class starts so early. c. They dislike it that the weather is so cold here. Notice that neither sentence would sound right if it were uttered in a context which had previously had nothing to do with someone resenting or disliking something and the subordinate clause following the pronoun were omitted, but both sound fine in such a context when the subordinate clause follows the pronoun. This suggests strongly that it is the matrix space building verbs which create the context for the pronouns, not some previous discourse context, and that they cataphorically prefigure (i.e. designate) the mental spaces set up by these verbs. Finally, note also the possibility that these pronouns may refer cataphorically not only to the spaces set up by the space builders, but also to the clauses themselves which explicitly describe the relations involved within those spaces. But, even if this is true, when the pronouns are first encountered by the hearer, they can refer to nothing yet introduced into the context but the expectation of information to come (propositions in the examples under discussion) which is prefigured by the space builders, as was mentioned earlier. Interpreting this expectation as the establishment of a mental space that is designated by the cataphoric pronoun seems to be a natural explanation for its occurrence. Characterizing cataphoric pronouns (vs. some other kind of linguistic item) as space designators therefore seems intuitively appealing due, at least in part, to their highly schematic meanings in this kind of usage and the fact that the meanings of pronouns in general (if they are attributed any meaning at all) are usually considered to be more grammatical than lexical in nature. But, to support an analysis claiming that cataphoric pronouns can designate mental spaces, it is necessary to show that the pronouns in question are polysemous, i.e. they have a number of distinct but interrelated senses — usually radiating from a prototypical sense — which can be plausibly related to one another via meaning chains motivated by semantic extensions of various kinds (see Taylor (1995) and Lakoff (1987) for extensive discussion). The reason for this is that in its use as a space designator we are attributing to the pronoun a sense/use which is clearly distinct from its more familiar anaphoric function. Unless these different uses can be linked in some way, there is no explanation for why a pronoun can be used as a space designator, and thus the use of what otherwise looks like an ordinary anaphoric pronoun to designate mental spaces would be arbitrary. In the next section, I will discuss how the use of cataphoric pronouns as abstract mental space (abstract setting) designators follows naturally from some of their more prototypical uses/senses as anaphors, focusing on the evidence from English and German.¹²
73
74
Michael B. Smith
4. Evidence for the mental space senses of English it and German es In this section I show how the various senses of German es can be related to each other as members of a complex conceptual category centering around its prototypical sense as a pronominal anaphor. For the most part, the senses of English it are essentially parallel to those of es, as will be clear from the English translations of the German sentences, so I will combine the discussion for both languages where possible (cf. Smith (2002) for more detailed argumentation).
4.1. German es and English it as pronominal anaphors Prototypically, these pronouns refer to an earlier 3rd person singular entity (thing) in the discourse (which is also specified as grammatically neuter in German), as shown in (9) below. The anaphoric relation is indicated by the usual subscript notation in the following examples. (9) a.
Ich kaufte [ein Buch]i und habe esi mit mir gebracht. I bought [a book and have it with me brought ‘I bought [a book]i and I’ve brought iti with me.’ b. Ist das [Ihr Kind]i? Bitte nimm esi weg von hier! is that [your child please take it away from here ‘Is that [your child]i? Please take iti away from here!’
It is evident that English it has an analogous function in this kind of sentence which requires no further discussion.
4.2. German es as an anaphor for other types of things German es, though apparently not English it, can also refer to non-neuter noun phrases (10), have a plural noun phrase antecedent (11), or be used as a general kind of indeterminate accusative object pronoun (called a “bloßes formales Objekt” in many German grammars), in which it does not refer to any particular antecedent, but rather to some unspecified thing or concept (12). Clearly, each of these uses represents a separate extension (and resulting sense) for es which is slightly different from the prototype exemplified in (9) above.¹³ (10) Ich kannte [seinen Bruder]i. Esi/eri war ein guter Arzt. I knew his brother it/he was a good doctor ‘I knew [his brother]i. Hei was a good doctor.’ (11) An der Ecke standen [ein Mädchen und ein Junge]i. Esi/siei waren seine on the corner stood a girl and a boy it/they were his Kinder. children ‘On the corner stood [a girl and a boy]i. Theyi were his children.’
Cataphoric pronouns as mental space designators
(12) a.
Er nimmt es mit jedem auf. he takes it with each up ‘He’s a match for everyone.’ b. Er hat es weit gebracht. he has it far brought ‘He’s gotten on (succeeded) in the world’.
These data show that German es is susceptible to semantic bleaching even in its basic anaphoric sense (cf. Sweetser 1988), in which, first, its erstwhile neuter gender specification is lost (10), then its number specification may be lost (11), and then, in a further extension, it may come to designate no more than some unspecified thing which has no apparent antecedent in the discourse (12).
4.3. German es and English it as anaphors for relations and reified clauses As a crucial way-station toward its more grammaticalized uses (as a cataphor, for example), German es can be anaphoric for relational predications (and not just for individual noun phrases mentioned previously in the discourse). In both (13) and (14) below, es refers back to the atemporal relations (i.e. adjectives) arm “poor” and angenehm “pleasant”, respectively. English it doesn’t seem to have this particular function. (13) Er ist armi, du bist esi auch. he is poor you are it [i.e. poor] too ‘He’s poor, (and) you are too.’ (14) Peter ist mir angenehmi. Aber Paul ist esi mir nicht. Peter is me pleasant but Paul is it me not ‘Peter is pleasant to me. But Paul is not (i.e. pleasant to me).’ And, in a further semantic extension, in (15) and (16) below, German es and English it appear to be anaphoric for an entire proposition, in which a clause (a linguistic representation of an entire proposition) has been reified as a kind of abstract thing. For example, in sentence (15) below the process of someone’s reciting has been reified (as indicated in the gloss) in order to serve as the antecedent for es and it in the following clause. The reification of an act of theft is likewise the antecedent for es and it in sentence (16). (15) [Wir haben ihn wieder deklamieren gehört]i. [we have him again recite heard Esi war ein verbales Schlachtfest. it was a verbal slaughter ‘[We’ve heard him recite again]i. Iti [the reciting process] was a verbal slaughter (lit. a ‘slaughter-fest’ in German).’
75
76
Michael B. Smith
(16) [In der Klasse ist gestohlen worden]i, [in the class(room) is stolen become aber keiner will esi getan haben. but no.one wants it done have ‘[Something was stolen in the classroom]i, but no one claims to have done iti.’ The evidence shows so far that es and it can be used as anaphors for anything from a thing construed as a participant in a given event to a reification of a full clause. I claim that this latter sense provides the bridge for its use to designate settings of various sorts.
4.4. German es and English it profiling mental spaces (abstract settings) There is a plausible conceptual mechanism by which es and it can be extended in use from designating individual entities (or relations) previously mentioned in the discourse to designate mental spaces or abstract settings (cf. note 4) of various kinds within which participants are conceived to interact. The conceptual mechanism in question is facilitated by the use of the pronouns in data like that in (15–16) above, where they designate reified clauses previously mentioned in the discourse. The semantic extension in question probably comes about via a kind of metonymy in which the pronouns lose their association with individual participants (however indeterminate) or reifications of an event itself (cf. 15–16) and instead come to be associated with the setting or space in which the action or state transpires.¹⁴ This may be a kind of whole for the part metonymy, as opposed to the more frequent part for the whole metonymy illustrated in a sentence like (17), in which the person who ate the sandwich is indirectly designated by referring to an entity with which the person was closely identified in the given context (cf. Lakoff and Johnson 1980: 35–40). (17) The ham sandwich left without paying. A metonymic analysis of the proposed semantic extension is completely reasonable when one considers that events are integrally associated with the settings in which they occur. Indeed, a setting often serves as a kind of reference point with respect to which the event in question can be located (cf. Langacker 1991b: 351, Langacker 1993, and note 4). Langacker notes, for example, that elements like it and there in English, in their use in designating abstract settings (cf. the setting subject designated by there in the sentence There’s a lamp on the table), “should probably be thought of as abstract presentational frames serving to announce the intention of subsequently introducing something in those frames. With such an analysis, it is perfectly understandable that it and there should serve as reference points: a setting constitutes a natural and obvious reference point for the elements that occur within it” (Langacker 2000: 347).
Cataphoric pronouns as mental space designators
It is not surprising, then, that the sense exhibited by the pronouns when they are used as anaphors for a reified clause could be extended to a related sense in which the pronouns designate the setting in which the clause is construed to take place. The additional conceptual leap required to go from the one use to the other is not appreciably greater than that needed previously to justify the extension of their meaning from an anaphor for a relation (13–14) to an anaphor for a reified clause (15)–(16). Each of these semantic extensions from the prototype reflects a further step toward abstractness, with the setting (mental space) sense representing the most abstract use of all, i.e. the use which is usually viewed as a meaningless grammatical marker in many frameworks. On the basis of the material in Section 4, I will now assume that cataphoric pronouns can be used to designate mental spaces prefigured by certain space builders.
5. Additional evidence that cataphors can designate mental spaces In this section I will present three kinds of additional evidence that cataphoric pronouns can designate mental spaces prefigured by space building predicates of various kinds.
5.1. The use of cataphors to accentuate conceptual distance As shown in (1a) and (4) above, the class of space building verbs in English requiring cataphoric object it is, in general, semantically restricted to those involving negative, uncertain, or otherwise undesirable feelings (as expressed by such verbs as dislike, resent, loathe, abhor, detest, hate, etc.). The same is true for German (6), though the class of German space builders either allowing or requiring the space designator es is apparently broader than that in English. German seems to be more tolerant of allowing cataphoric es to prefigure spaces construed either as important or especially desirable (18), or not yet accomplished or incomplete (19).¹⁵ (18) a.
Wir loben es, daß Sie das gemacht haben. we praise it that you that done have ‘We praise (it) that you did that.’ b. Meine Eltern lieben (es), am Wochenende an einen See zu my parents love it on-the weekend on a lake to fahren. drive ‘My parents love to drive to the lake on the weekend.’
(19) a.
Er kann es kaum erwarten, seine Braut wiederzusehen. he can it hardly wait his bride again-to-see ‘He can hardly wait to see his bride again.’
77
78
Michael B. Smith
b. Er gönnt es mir nicht, im Sommer nach Italien zu fahren. he allows it me not in-the summer to Italy to travel ‘He grudges my traveling to Italy in the summer.’ Also, cataphoric es is possible in German after verbs of permitting (something not yet done). (20) a.
Ich erlaube es dir, meine Schreibmaschine zu benützen. I permit it you my typewriter to use ‘I permit you to use my typewriter.’ b. Ich überlasse es dir, morgen zu kommen oder nicht. I leave it you tomorrow to come or not ‘I leave it to you to come tomorrow or not.’
In all such cases, I suggest that overt mention of the space itself by the pronoun accentuates (for whatever reason) the conceptual distance judged to exist between the matrix subject and the relation(s) holding within the spaces by iconically distancing — in the grammar — the matrix subject from the subordinate clause describing those relations (cf. Haiman (1983, 1985a, 1985b) for detailed discussion of the notion of conceptual distance and examples of the phenomenon from other languages). The use of cataphoric pronouns to accentuate the conceptual distance between the matrix subject and the proposition in the subordinate clause is likely a manifestation of a spatialization metaphor closely related to one identified in Lakoff and Johnson (1980) to the effect that closeness is strength of effect, as illustrated by the following examples (from Lakoff and Johnson (1980: 130)). (21) a. Harry is not happy. b. Harry is unhappy. (22) a. I taught Greek to Harry. b. I taught Harry Greek. Lakoff and Johnson note that (21a), in which the negative morpheme not is a separate word, could be neutral with respect to whether Harry is fundamentally happy or sad, even though it indicates that at the present time he is not happy. (21b), on the other hand, in which the negative morpheme is more closely attached to the word happy as a prefix, implies a stronger negative in which Harry is definitely sad. And, in (22a), in which Harry is separated from Greek by the preposition to, Harry may not have learned what I tried to teach him, whereas in (22b) the lack of any element separating Harry and Greek yields the clear implication of a stronger effect in which Harry did actually learn Greek. Lakoff and Johnson observe that spatial metaphors can “apply directly to the form of a sentence. . .. [t]his can provide automatic direct links between form and content, based on general metaphors in our conceptual system” (1980: 126). Thus, part of a sentence’s meaning can stem from the precise form the sentence takes due
Cataphoric pronouns as mental space designators
to this nonarbitrary linking between form and meaning, and “[l]inguistic forms are themselves endowed with content by virtue of spatialization metaphors” (Lakoff and Johnson 1980: 126). It should be stressed that there may be multiple semantic motivations for using cataphoric pronouns to accentuate conceptual distance in the grammar. Many occurrences of the German and English cataphoric pronouns under investigation here seem to reflect a related (and possibly inverted) form of the above spatialization metaphor in which distance is weakness of effect. In other words, the appearance of a cataphoric pronoun space designator after space builders signifying negative feelings about events or states (and in other circumstances in German) serves to distance the matrix subject from those events or states, which is not surprising, since it is natural for humans to avoid or distance themselves from negativelyconstrued situations in the hope that their effect will be weaker if they are kept as far away as possible. Alternatively, there is ordinarily no need to distance states or events from the matrix subject which are construed in mildly favorable or neutral terms, which explains why cataphors are generally not found after such English space builders as believe, think, hope, know, etc., or after such German space builders as wissen “know”, annehmen “accept”, behaupten “assert”, empfehlen “recommend”, denken “think”, glauben “believe”, fühlen “feel”, etc. (a fuller list can be found in Pütz 1986: 70). But extending this metaphor to other situations that can be construed as distant in some way from the matrix subject is also natural and not necessarily contradictory when the motivating factors are properly taken into account. Thus, space designators can also be used in German not only to distance an undesirable event from the matrix subject, as discussed in the above paragraph, but also to iconically accentuate the separation between this subject and something conceived by that entity to be especially important or desirable beyond ordinary circumstances (18) (as though putting it on a pedestal). The space designating function of cataphoric pronouns can also accentuate the separation between the matrix subject’s expectation of some event and its fulfillment (19), or his permitting something and the subsequent realization of what is permitted (20), all of which are construed as distant from the state of affairs assumed to hold for the matrix subject.¹⁶ The following additional data illustrate the meaning differences conveyed by the same space building German verbs when the cataphoric anticipatory-object pronouns are present vs. absent (from Pütz 1986: 88). (23) Ich schätze (*es), daß Peter wohl bald wieder gesund wird. I think (it that Peter definitely soon again healthy become ‘I think that Peter will definitely be well again.’ (24) Ich schätze *(es), daß du gekommen bist. I value (it that you come are ‘I value (esteem highly) that you have come.’
79
80
Michael B. Smith
In (23) the more neutral sense of schätzen “think” does not allow es, whereas its more positive sense in (24) “value, esteem” does require it, thereby accentuating what is valued by distancing it from the matrix subject by overt designation of the mental space by the pronoun. Note that the use of cataphoric pronouns in (18) and (24) above after matrix verbs designating highly positive feelings or emotions is just as motivated as its use after verbs designating highly negative feelings and emotions (though each for different reasons), because it is natural in either case to accentuate the distance between the matrix subjects and the subordinate propositions. The different reasons for either motivation have already been discussed above, and it is important to see that they are not contradictory from the perspective of cognitive grammar. What is likely going on is that in German (and to some extent also in English, as mentioned in note 15) there is a scale along which matrix verbs can be seen to lie with respect to their proclivity to co-occur with a following cataphoric pronoun. At the one extreme we find those designating highly negative feelings (detest, hate) and at the other we find those designating highly positive feelings (love, admire). As one moves away from either extreme it is less likely for the pronoun to occur, and for verbs in the middle which do not evoke strong feelings either way (think, believe) the cataphor generally does not occur, because there are no strong motivating factors for separating the matrix subject from the subordinate proposition with these verbs. It is not possible to strongly predict where the cut-off point for using the pronoun is from either extreme, and indeed, in some instances, as with the verb enjoy in English, the use of the cataphor is optional, with its optionality an indication of the gradation inherent in the scale.
5.2. The use of cataphors to indicate difference in emphasis Now that we have examined evidence based on conceptual distance that cataphoric pronouns can designate mental spaces in the grammar, let us turn to another kind of closely related evidence: the optional occurrence of cataphors after verbs (with which they usually do not occur) when the speaker wishes to emphasize the propositional content of the subordinate clause. The following set of sentences shows how a difference in emphasis can be accentuated by es after wissen “know” in German, where es normally does not occur (cf. Lederer 1969: 202). (25) Ich weiß, daß er morgen kommt. I know that he tomorrow comes ‘I know that he’s coming tomorrow.’ Apparently, wissen can be used with object es if special emphasis is placed on the clausal object.
Cataphoric pronouns as mental space designators
(26) Ich weiß es sicher, daß er morgen kommt. I know it certain that he tomorrow comes ‘I know for certain that he’s coming tomorrow.’ (27) Peter hat es doch gewußt, daß ich das getan hatte! Peter has it EMPHATIC known that I that done had ‘Peter knew [emphasis] that I had done that!’ Note that there is also a possible English translation of (26) in which cataphoric it can be used for emphasis, which suggests that this use of the cataphor is relevant in English as well, since it can also be used after other verbs of knowing, such as understand, realize, etc. (28) I know (it) for certain that he’s coming tomorrow. The cataphor’s evocation of special emphasis in these situations is likely due to the fact that overt designation of the mental space set up by the matrix verb draws more attention to the proposition contained in and characterized specifically by the knowledge structures inherent in that space than if the pronoun were absent. Also, by momentarily delaying mention of the subordinate clause by the use of the pronoun the speaker creates an air of anticipation in the flow of discourse about what is to follow which can heighten the hearer’s interest in the subsequent information (again evoking another kind of conceptual distance). Related to this is that the use of the cataphor in effect results in a kind of double-mention in which the space designated by the pronoun metonymically relates to the proposition located conceptually within that space by prefiguring the space grammatically. Finally, in each of (26–28) it is also evident that the information construed as known, which is specified within the mental space designated by the cataphoric pronoun, is already in the realm of discourse, thus accentuating its independent existence apart from the matrix subject’s musings, and motivating the use of es or it to anticipate its specific mention in the following subordinate clause.¹⁷ Another pair of German sentences illustrating how a difference in emphasis can be characterized by including the cataphor is given below (from Pütz 1986: 60). (29) Ich sage nicht, daß ich Hans verleumdet habe. ich say not that I Hans slandered have ‘I’m not saying that I slandered Hans.’ (30) Ich sage es ja auch gar nicht, daß ich Hans verleumdet habe. I say it yes (EMPH.) also at-all not that I Hans slandered have ‘I’m not at all saying that I slandered Hans.’ Sentence (29) is relatively neutral with respect to the speaker’s saying that he did not slander someone, whereas (30) more forcefully emphasizes this claim, as shown by the addition of the emphatic particle ja.
8
82
Michael B. Smith
5.3. The use of cataphors to accentuate the importance of a space’s physical boundaries The evidence presented so far has suggested that overt mention of a mental space itself by the cataphoric pronoun in English and German can be exploited to play up the importance of the space’s boundaries with certain matrix verbs (cf. Figure 2 above), which further accentuates the “mental” distance between the matrix subject and what is conceptualized by that subject. We have also seen how the cataphor’s designation of the mental space set up by a space building matrix verb can evoke emphasis in some cases. A slightly different kind of cataphoric it in English which evokes the enhanced relevance of a space’s boundaries is especially evident in minimal pairs like the following, with matrix verbs which usually evoke mental knowledge and/or some kinds of typical sensory experience. In these examples, rather than invoking a mental space’s boundaries to accentuate the conceptual distance between the matrix subject and what is conceptualized (or possibly intellectual emphasis on the subordinate concept per se), this kind of it highlights the relevant space’s boundaries to play up the importance of the space as a physical setting for some kind of event which is construed to have a physical rather than intellectual effect on the matrix subject. (31) a. You know it when the train goes by. b. You know _____ when the train goes by. (32) a. Did you hear it when the train arrived? b. Did you hear _____ when the train arrived? (33) a. She was aware of it when the plane landed. b. She was aware of _____ when the plane landed. (34) a. The psychic could feel it when the UFO landed. b. The psychic could feel _____ when the UFO landed. In each sentence in (31–34) the use of cataphoric it in the (a) examples forces a reading that clearly accentuates the effect of the vehicle’s action within a physical space or setting prefigured by it and that action’s effect on the matrix subject within that setting, whereas the lack of it in the (b) examples more likely evokes a reading in which a statement is made about a person’s intellectual knowledge or awareness of the time at which the vehicle went by, with little if any emphasis on the action’s strong physical effect on the setting. This can be seen in (31), for example, where the most likely interpretation of (31a) evokes the sense of the train’s having a physical effect on the surrounding environment and the people in it as it speeds by. Such an interpretation, while possible, is unlikely in (31b), where the lack of a cataphor and its evocation of the setting emphasizes a reading in which the train’s physical effect on bystanders is less important than the matrix subject’s mental awareness of the time at which it goes by. Note also how (34a) accentuates the psychic’s
Cataphoric pronouns as mental space designators
physical awareness of the effect of the UFO’s landing (as if he were actually there), whereas (34b) plays up the psychic’s mental ability to perceive the time when the UFO landed, without his being physically present or affected by the landing (which is presumably possible if the person is a decent psychic).¹⁸ Before going on it is imperative to understand and reiterate the patterning in these data, which gives an important clue about their explanation with respect to the function of the cataphor. The (a) examples in (31)–(34) strongly evoke the sense that the actions described in the subordinate clauses prefigured by cataphoric it have some kind of physical effect on the matrix subjects above and beyond whatever mental effects they might produce; it is difficult, if not impossible, to interpret them as meaning only that the matrix subjects have some kind of intellectual or mental understanding of the subordinate clause events. The (b) examples, on the other hand, while tolerating the interpretation that the subordinate clauses exert a physical effect on the matrix subjects, are much more naturally interpreted as meaning that the subordinate events are comprehended intellectually by the matrix subjects. Significantly, the (b) examples do not contain cataphoric pronouns which separate the matrix clause subjects from the subordinate clause events. We have assumed within mental space theory that emotionally neutral verbs evoking intellectual activity, like know and believe, set up mental spaces which are not ordinarily designated by cataphoric pronouns except under circumstances of special emphasis, as in example (28) above. And, even in cases of emphasis, the emphasis is usually of a purely intellectual kind. Nor do the other matrix predicates in (31–34) above ordinarily occur with cataphoric it when their meanings evoke purely intellectual activity. A moment’s reflection, however, confirms that in these data the meanings of the matrix verbs when used with cataphoric pronouns in the (a) examples are somewhat different from the meanings of these verbs in the (b) examples (when cataphors do not occur): they have been extended in the (a) examples to the perception or understanding of events in the concrete physical domain from their likely more basic senses in the abstract domain of purely intellectual activity which is typically reflected in the (b) examples. But my claim is that even in this extended meaning the matrix verbs are still space builders, with the proviso that the mental spaces set up by the matrix verbs now evoke knowledge structures relevant to the perception of physical events in addition to the usual knowledge structures associated with purely intellectual events. Thus, when the speaker wants to focus attention on perception of an event in the physical domain or setting (by using know, be aware of, etc.) he can accentuate the influence of that event’s occurrence in (and possibly on) the setting in which it occurs by designating the mental space set up by that verb (or verbal construction in the case of be aware of) with cataphoric it. The use of it to designate the space set up by the space builder highlights the importance of the physical location of the event with these verbs and thus the event’s effect on the matrix subject. Clearly, this sense can also be obtained without the use of the pronoun, but this latter reading is dispreferred in favor of the one evoking perception in the mental domain. For example,
83
84
Michael B. Smith
in the context of (31a) the matrix verb know means something like “be physically (as opposed to intellectually) aware of something in the physical domain”, and so the cataphoric pronoun it‘s designation of the boundaries of the space set up by the verb is now understood as much in physical terms as intellectual terms in its evocation of the actual boundaries of the physical location in which action occurs. This is why the (a) examples in (31–34) evoke so clearly the idea that the events described in the subordinate clauses have some kind of physical effect on the matrix subject, whereas in the (b) examples the relationships between the entities is purely mental in nature (under the usual interpretation). These observations are confirmed in the following additional examples. Note that in (35a) emphasis is placed on the traveler’s actually being present when the plane landed (with the traveler’s physical awareness of the landing event accentuated), whereas in (35b) the cataphor is impossible if the seeing focuses on the traveler’s intellectually ascertaining, by visual means, the time at which the flight landed. (35) a. The traveler could see it when the flight landed. b. By using the timetable the traveler could see (*it) when the flight landed. A similar distinction is found in another example with hear, as shown below in sentence (36): (36) a. The passengers were able to hear it when the train arrived. b. By listening to announcements over the loudspeaker the passengers could hear (*it) when the train arrived. Here, too, the cataphor is only possible when emphasis is placed on the physical effect of the train’s arrival on the passengers (36a). When the context is changed to emphasize the intellectual understanding of the time at which the train arrives, cataphoric it is impossible, since the relevance of the physical setting in this case (prefigured by the mental space designated by it) is less important.
6. The potential space designating function of another kind of cataphor As is well known, both English it and German es occur as so-called expletive (extraposition) syntactic-subject pronominals in constructions like those illustrated in (37) and (38) below. (37) a. It is likely that the governor will run for president. b. It is certain that Gore and Bush will have a close race. (38) a.
Es ist sicher, daß Inge morgen ankommt. it is certain that Inge tomorrow arrives ‘It’s certain that Inge will arrive tomorrow.’
Cataphoric pronouns as mental space designators
b. Es ist interessant, daß Hans sein Auto verkauft hat. it is interesting that Hans his car sold has ‘It’s interesting that Hans sold his car.’ I think that analyzing these cataphoric pronouns as mental space designators similar to those which prefigure spaces built up by propositional attitude predicates (such as verbs and adjectives) helps explain their semantic function in these clauses, and provides an argument against the usual view that they are just meaningless syntactic place-holders. While it is likely true that their syntactic-subject place-holding function is due in part to heavy noun phrase shift (reflecting phonological constraints on the length of sentential subjects), these pronouns may serve the additional semantico-discourse function of delaying overt mention of a clause designating a proposition which describes the relationships holding in a mental space (which might otherwise appear as a sentential subject) by setting up mental spaces (which they also designate) as semantic placeholders that remain empty until the speaker’s attitude toward or belief about those relationships is specified by the following adjectives. For example, in (37a) above the cataphor it would be analyzed as setting up a mental space which is then “tagged”, so to speak, with the speaker’s judgment about the likelihood of the following proposition taking place. In effect, a kind of “likelihood” space is created. By affording speakers the option of mentioning their attitude about a proposition before uttering the proposition itself, this construction type may reflect — in the grammar — a self-centered human tendency to rank one’s opinions about events as just as important (if not more so) as the events themselves. Undoubtedly, much more can and should be investigated along these lines, but space limitations preclude this here.
7. Concluding remarks I have argued in this chapter that the idea of analyzing cataphoric pronouns as mental space designators in English, German, and Russian leads to a revealing account of their meaning and function in grammar and discourse which has eluded discovery until now. The resulting conclusion is that cataphors are not arbitrary, meaningless grammatical devices, but are rather semantically motivated elements in the grammar. The chapter thus contributes additional evidence for the growing realization that many hitherto unnoticed aspects of grammar manifest iconic links between the linguistic forms and the meanings conveyed by the forms (cf. Haiman 1983, 1985a, 1985b, Givón 1990, 1995, and Greenberg 1985 for more discussion). Clearly, more work needs to be done to make the analysis begun here more detailed and convincing. This would include finding additional data in English and German to further support the points made in the earlier sections of the chapter, and to find arguments for the analysis in Russian which go beyond its intuitive
85
86
Michael B. Smith
appeal and apparent fit with the meanings of the matrix predicates presented in (7) above. More work also needs to be done to further justify applying the analysis to the cataphoric subject pronouns exemplified by the English and German extraposition data in the preceding section. And, finally, data from other languages with cataphoric pronouns should be investigated to see whether they, too, might be insightfully characterized in the way I have suggested here.
Notes 1. I would like to acknowledge the valuable contribution of both the editors of this volume and several anonymous referees, whose suggestions have greatly improved the final version of this chapter. Unfortunately, time and space limitations have prevented me from following all of their advice. Consequently, I assume full responsibility for any errors remaining in the finished product. 2. In this respect, cognitive linguistics owes a lot to the Saussurean approach to grammar known as the “Columbia School” and is largely compatible with its basic tenets. Some representative works in this framework include Diver (1975), Garcia (1977), and Kirsner’s monograph on Dutch presentative sentences (1979). More recently, Huffman (1997) deals specifically with pronouns. 3. This quotation is the closest language approximating an actual formal definition of a mental space that I can find in Fauconnier’s work. I think he felt, as do I, that the notion is an intuitively natural one within the general cognitive approach to linguistics. 4. Mental spaces are theoretically similar to Langacker’s notion of abstract settings(1991b), which have been shown to play an important role in linguistic semantics (cf. Langacker’s discussion of existential there-clauses in English (1991b: 352–355), analyses of German and Russian impersonal setting-subject constructions found in Smith (1985a, 1985b, 1993a, 1993b, 1994) and parts of Smith (1987)). These analyses build on Langacker’s basic insight that the setting in which a state or event is conceived to occur can sometimes be accorded grammatical status via coding as the clausal subject (Langacker 1991b: 345ff.), as in such English sentences as Tiger Stadium has witnessed many exciting baseball games and My dog is crawling with fleas, in which the setting subjects are relatively concrete. A somewhat more abstract setting subject is exemplified by the German sentence Es regnet heute and its English translation “It’s raining today”, in which the pronominal subjects es and it, respectively, designate the setting construed as the surrounding environment within which the weather is conceived to occur. Mental spaces extend this notion to the logical extreme in which the setting and/or space is a purely mental construct. See also Kirsner’s classic work on Dutch presentative sentences (1979). 5. Note that mental space researchers typically use any of the following terms to refer to the creation of a mental space by a space builder: build, create, set up, construct, etc. These terms and their synonyms should be interpreted by the reader as signifying the same kind of process, i.e. the creation of a mental space by a space builder. 6. An anonymous reviewer wondered if there are any kinds of objective tests or evidence that certain expressions build mental spaces. My understanding of the concept as employed in mental space research is that the theory assumes that an expression which evokes an appropriate meaning involving some kind of relevant knowledge structure or domain builds
Cataphoric pronouns as mental space designators a corresponding space to represent that structure, and that the validation of invoking the notion of mental spaces resides in their usefulness in explicating a wide range of linguistic phenomena in an intuitively natural way. 7. As noted earlier, Pütz (1986) presents evidence for just such a division, but does not explain the factors determining which verb belongs to which class. I will return to this question later in the chapter. 8. Readers who are familiar with German grammar might wonder whether the phenomenon under investigation in this chapter extends to constructions in which the subordinate clause functions syntactically as a prepositional object. German has many complex verbal constructions in which the verb co-occurs with a lexically-determined preposition (and in some cases also a reflexive (REFL) pronoun that is coreferential with the subject), e.g. sich freuen auf “look forward to”, sich verlassen auf “rely on”, sich erinnern an “remember”, denken an “think of ”, etc. When these verbs take sentential objects, the pronominal element da (not es) cataphorically anticipates the subordinate clause and is attached phonologically to the preposition in question. Here is an example of such a da-compound: (i) Ich habe mich darüber sehr gefreut, daß Peter gekommen ist. I have REFL it-over very been-happy that Peter come is ‘I was very happy (about the fact) that Peter arrived.’ It would appear that da in this kind of prepositional object construction is serving the same function as es in data like that in (6) above, with the main difference the fact that the da-compounds are generally not omissible, in contrast to es in some circumstances. Due to space limitations I will not mention da-compounds further in this chapter. 9. While it is true that the pronoun in example (7d) seems to be required by the presence of a preposition which would otherwise be stranded without an object, this specific grammatical function of the pronoun need not preclude its possible cataphoric discourse function, as well. It should also be noted that, as is often the case, there may be differences of opinion among native speakers as to whether the pronouns (and their sometime accompanying prepositions) in (7a–c) are required, or not. My claim is that, if the pronouns appear, they are cataphoric and designate mental spaces. 10. Schmid considers a larger variety of construction types containing shell nouns than I will discuss in this chapter. My use of the basic type illustrated in (8) will be sufficient to relate this concept to my own notion of mental space designators. 11. An anonymous reviewer suggests that the cataphoric pronouns also seem to effect the kind of temporary reification like that mentioned by Schmid and I would tend to agree. 12. I will not deal further with the Russian data, primarily for reasons of space, but also because I do not yet have arguments for the mental space designator analysis in Russian which are as convincing as those I have found for English and German. Nevertheless, I am convinced that the analysis can be extended to Russian and to other languages, as well, and that the Russian data presented here exemplify cataphoric pronouns that function as mental space designators. 13. An anonymous reviewer notes that “there will be discourse differences between Es war ein guter Arzt and Er war ein guter Arzt” in example (10) (and similarly between es and sie in example (11)). While this may be true, the difference is not relevant to my present argument. The point of the possibility of using es in place of er or sie in these examples is that the meaning of es has been extended to include these non-prototypical kinds of reference.
87
88
Michael B. Smith 14. Cf. one of the senses of -er in a word like kegger, where the usually agentive suffix is used to derive a noun from a noun whose meaning is associated — by a similar process — with a reified event, not a participant in the event. (A kegger is a kind of party event often put together by college students in the United States in which the consumption of beer — which comes in kegs — is conspicuously prodigious.) An example involving an actual setting sense of -er would be the noun sleeper in its sense as a car on a passenger train (hence a location or setting) in which people sleep. 15. English also occasionally tolerates cataphoric it when the following subordinate clause is construed as especially desirable, as in sentences like I love it when she really prepares her speeches and He enjoys it when the students participate. 16. It should be clarified here that, under the proposed analysis, space builders invariably set up mental spaces, whether the spaces are designated by cataphoric pronouns or not. What the cataphors are proposed to do is to highlight, for some reason, the salience of a mental space which has been introduced into the discourse by the space builders. 17. Interestingly, this suggests that in (26–28) the pronouns may be serving both anaphoric and cataphoric functions in the same sentence. It should also be kept in mind that there may often be multiple motivations for conceptual distancing which will depend on the meanings of the matrix verbs. Note, for example, that the distancing of a subordinate clause with es because it is construed as particularly desirable or noteworthy (as if putting it on a pedestal), which was described in the context of (18) above, could also be motivated as a kind of emphasis, as well. In most cases it is difficult (and perhaps not all that important) to tease apart these mutually supporting motivations for using the cataphor to distance the subordinate proposition from the matrix subject, since they mutually support one another. 18. Apparently the only wh-word that can be used to introduce the subordinate clause in these examples is when, which creates a context which, together with the cataphoric pronoun, brings about the interpretation that the action designated by the clause has an effect on the matrix subject. Note that substituting any other wh-word in place of when in the sentences in (31–34) does not have this effect. While this may be a minor, possibly idiosyncratic, fact about English, the examples can still be used to make the point that the cataphors in these expressions designate mental spaces.
References Bresnan, Joan (ed.) 1982. The Mental Representation of Grammatical Relations. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Chomsky, Noam. 1981. Lectures on Government and Binding. The Pisa Lectures. DordrechtHolland/Cinnaminson-USA: Foris. Chomsky, Noam. 1986. Knowledge of language. Its nature, origin, and use. New York: Praeger. Cook, V.J. and Mark Newson, (eds.). 1996. Chomsky’sUniversal Grammar. An Introduction. 2nd edition. Oxford: Blackwell. Culicover, Peter W. 1997. Principles and Parameters: An Introduction to Syntactic Theory. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Diver, William. 1975. “Introduction.” In Columbia University Working Papers in Linguistics 2, William Diver (ed.), 1–20. New York: Columbia University. [Corrected reprint 1980]
Cataphoric pronouns as mental space designators Fauconnier, Gilles. 1985. Mental Spaces: Aspects of Meaning Construction in Natural Language. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press/Bradford. Fauconnier, Gilles. 1997. Mappings in Thought and Language. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Fauconnier, Gilles and Eve Sweetser (eds.). 1996. Spaces, Worlds, and Grammar. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Fillmore, Charles J. 1985. “Frames and the semantics of understanding.” Quaderni di Semantica 6(2): 222–254. Garcia, Erica. 1977. “On the practical consequences of theoretical principles.” Lingua 43: 129– 170. Gernsbacher, M.A. 1990. Language Comprehension as Structure Building. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum. Givón, T. 1990. Syntax: A Functional-Typological Introduction, vol. 2. Amsterdam/Philadelphia: John Benjamins. Givón, T. 1995. Functionalism and Grammar. Amsterdam/Philadelphia: John Benjamins. Goffman, Erving. 1974. Frame Analysis. New York: Harper and Row. Greenberg, Joseph H. 1985. “Some iconic relationships among place, time, and discourse deixis.” In Haiman (ed.) 1985a, 271–287. Haegeman, Liliane. 1994. Introduction to government and binding theory. 2nd edition. Oxford/Cambridge: Blackwell. Haiman, John. 1983. “Iconic and economic motivation.” Language 59: 781–819. Haiman, John. (ed.). 1985a. Iconicity in Syntax. Amsterdam/Philadelphia: John Benjamins. Haiman, John. 1985b. Natural Syntax. Iconicity and Erosion. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Huffman, Alan. 1997. The Categories of Grammar: French lui and le. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Kirsner, Robert S. 1979. The problem of Presentative Sentences in Modern Dutch. [North-Holland Linguistic Series43]. Amsterdam/New York: North-Holland. Lakoff, George. 1987. Women, Fire, and Dangerous Things: What Categories Reveal About the Mind. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press. Lakoff, George and Mark Johnson. 1980. Metaphors We Live By. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press. Langacker, Ronald W. 1987. Foundations of Cognitive Grammar, vol. 1: Theoretical Prerequisites. Stanford: Stanford University Press. Langacker, Ronald W. 1991a. Concept, Image, and Symbol. The Cognitive Basis of Grammar. [Cognitive Linguistics Research1]. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. Langacker, Ronald W. 1991b. Foundations of Cognitive Grammar, vol. 2: Descriptive Application. Stanford: Stanford University Press. Langacker, Ronald W. 1993. “Reference-point constructions.” Cognitive Linguistics 4: 1–38. Langacker, Ronald W. 2000. Grammar and Conceptualization. [Cognitive Linguistics Research 14]. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. Lederer, Herbert. 1969. Reference Grammar of the German Language. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons. Leed, Richard, Alexander Nakhimovsky and Alice Nakhimovsky. 1982. Beginning Russian, Volume 2. Columbus, OH: Slavica Publishers. Nunberg, Geoffrey. 1978. The Pragmatics of Reference. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Linguistics Club.
89
90
Michael B. Smith Perlmutter, David M. (ed.) 1983. Studies in relational grammar 1. Chicago and London: The University of Chicago Press. Perlmutter, David M. and Carol G. Rosen (eds.) 1984. Studies in Relational Grammar 2. Chicago and London: The University of Chicago Press. Pütz, Herbert. 1986. Über die Syntax der Pronominalform es im modernen Deutsch. Tübingen: Gunter Narr Verlag. Radford, Andrew. 1997. Syntactic Theory and the Structure of English: A Minimalist Approach. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Sag, Ivan A. and Thomas Wasow. 1999. Syntactic Theory: A Formal Introduction. Stanford: CSLI Publications. Schmid, Hans-Jörg. 1999. “Cognitive effects of shell nouns.” In Discourse studies in cognitive linguistics, Karen van Hoek, Andrej A. Kibrik, and Leo Noordman (eds), 111–132. Amsterdam/Philadelphia: John Benjamins. Smith, Michael B. 1985a. “An analysis of German dummy subject constructions in cognitive grammar.” In Proceedings of the First Annual Meeting of the Pacific Linguistics Conference, Scott Delancey and Russell S. Tomlin (eds), 412–425. Eugene, OR: Department of Linguistics, University of Oregon. Smith, Michael B. 1985b. “Event chains, grammatical relations, and the semantics of case in German.” Papers from the Twenty-First Regional Meeting of the Chicago Linguistic Society, 388–407. Chicago: Chicago Linguistic Society. Smith, Michael B. 1987. The Semantics of Dative and Accusative in German: An Investigation in Cognitive Grammar. Ph.D dissertation, University of California at San Diego. Smith, Michael B. 1993a. “Aspects of German clause structure from a Cognitive Grammar perspective.” Studi Italiani di Linguistica: Teorica e Applicata 22: 601–638. Smith, Michael B. 1993b. “Cases as conceptual categories: Evidence from German.” In Conceptualizations and Mental Processing in Language. [Cognitive Linguistics Research 2], Richard A. Geiger and Brygida Rudzka-Ostyn (eds), 531–565. Berlin/New York: Mouton de Gruyter. Smith, Michael B. 1994. “Agreement and iconicity in Russian impersonal constructions.” Cognitive Linguistics 5: 5–56. Smith, Michael B. 2002. “The Polysemy of German es, iconicity, and the notion of conceptual distance.” Cognitive Linguistics 13: 67–112. Sweetser, Eve. E. 1988. “Grammaticalization and semantic bleaching.” Berkeley Linguistics Society 14: 389–405. Taylor, John R. 1995. Linguistic Categorization: Prototypes in Linguistic Theory. 2nd edition. New York: Clarendon Press/Oxford. Van Valin, Jr., Robert D. and Randy J. LaPolla. 1997. Syntax: Structure, Meaning, and Function. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Webelhuth, Gert (ed.) 1995. Government and Binding Theory and the Minimalist Program. Principles and Parameters in Syntactic Theory. Oxford: Blackwell.
PART II
Theoretical issues in classical sign-based linguistics
CHAPTER 3
Monosemy, homonymy and polysemy* Wallis Reid Rutgers University
1. Introduction Linguistic tradition has a three-way typology for describing the outcome of the semantic analysis of a lexical or grammatical form. The analysis may posit a single meaning for the form, as one would do for the English word barn, ‘a large wooden structure on farms for animals’. Charles Ruhl (l989) has dubbed this monosemy. Alternatively, the analysis may treat the form as two or more independent linguistic units and posit distinct and unrelated meanings for each. The traditional name for this is homonymy, and a classic example is the two English words seal the animal, and seal the stamp. Finally, the analysis may treat a form as a single linguistic unit and posit a series of semantically related meanings, or senses, for it. John Taylor (1995: 103) cites the word neck, meaning both ‘neck of a human body’ and ‘neck of a bottle’ as a clear example of what is traditionally called polysemy. Columbia School analysts have posited monosemy and homonymy, but not polysemy.¹ How so? In this chapter I will sketch out an answer. But explaining why one is not doing something puts one in an unavoidably defensive position. Better to keep theory to a minimum at first and illustrate how a Columbia School analysis handles as monosemy data that would seem to call for polysemic treatment. The body of this chapter will thus consist of a monosemic analysis of three semantically related English words. I will make theoretical points foreshadowing my case against polysemy in passing, but will postpone a direct discussion of the issue until the end of the chapter. One theoretical point must be made at the outset, however, precisely because the existence of polysemy is sometimes not recognized as a theoretical issue. “Any dunce can see that neck has two senses” some might say. But this is because we have internalized the practical but unprincipled dictionary treatment of words at an early age. Embracing that tradition as a linguist, however, commits one to a particular view of language. To be sure, speakers can interpret an utterance holistically without theoretical commitments. But determining the precise semantic contribution of each lexical and grammatical form to that interpretation is an act of linguistic analysis, not observation.²
94
Wallis Reid
Polysemy appears to be a directly observable phenomenon only if one makes two familiar assumptions about the essential nature of language. The first is that language is a representational system of sentential meaning.³ The second assumption is the compositional view of sentence meaning. In the compositional view, the literal meaning of a sentence is assumed to consist of the meanings of the individual words amalgamated in a way determined by the grammatical structure of the sentence. In short, the semantic whole must equal the sum of its semantic parts.⁴ Adhering to the representational view of language and the compositional view of meaning obliges the analyst to attribute every notional fraction of a completed interpretation to some specific form. This requirement can only be met by assigning multiple semantic values to most forms. So, for example, in his wrinkly neck was sunburned and she grabbed the bottle by its neck, neck must necessarily be assigned two different values if the meaning of those sentences is to be totally derived from their contributing words, among them neck. By contrast, Columbia School makes neither of these two assumptions. It begins with the fact that language functions as a communicative system but leaves open to empirical investigation whether or not it does so by virtue of semantically representing individual communications. This means the Columbia School analyst is not committed at the outset to making the semantic parts equal a semantic whole; they may or they may not. Analytical experience has led us to the conclusion that the communicated whole — the message — is always more than its semantic parts. Language functions not by formally representing the message but by providing hearers with notional fragments, clues, hints, and prompts for them to synthesize against the background of their unique cognitive, linguistic and life experience. This synthesis is a creative interpretive act, one that is not reducible to a mechanical algorithm. Alan Huffman (1997: 16–19) has dubbed this an instrumental concept of meaning. The meanings of linguistic forms contribute in various ways to the communication of a message without collectively composing it. Returning to the problematic word neck, the Columbia School analyst must decide whether a meaning can be posited for it that could serve to refer to both a body part and a bottle part; or, alternatively, decide to treat the word as two (or more) independent semantic units — two linguistic signs — each with its own meaning. But this decision is guided not by representational and compositional assumptions but by the general principle underlying all theory construction: namely, posit only as many theoretical constructs as required to account for the observations.
2. English IN, AT, and ON Regretfully, I currently have no solution to offer for neck. Instead, I will present an analysis of in, at and on, three words that allow a more extensive exploration of the issues raised in the introduction above. Appearing below is an initial hypothesis of the semantic values of in, at and on.⁵
Monosemy, homonymy and polysemy
in = three-dimensional location at = point-like location on = linear or planar location In, at and on all signal spatial location, but with differences. In designates location in three-dimensional space. At designates location at a point. And on designates location on a line or plane. Consider examples (1), (2) and (3); (1) He lives in New Brunswick. (= three dimensional location) (2) He stopped at the traffic light. (= point-like location) (3) He was shopping on Main Street. (= linear or flat location) A city is clearly three-dimensional; a traffic light is reasonably point-like; and a street is flat and linear. In examples (1), (2) and (3), in, at and on seem to be echoing information already implied by the words light, street and New Brunswick. In examples (4), (5) and (6) the three words function non-redundantly, making us focus on different aspects of a car all by themselves: (4) She left her briefcase in the car. (5) She left her briefcase on the car. (6) She left her briefcase at the car. We understand a briefcase left in the car to be inside the car, a three-dimensional location. On the car suggests the hood or roof of the car, both planes. At the car suggests next to the car, on the ground perhaps, but not inside and not on the roof. Why so? The explanation begins with the fact that an automobile is not actually pointlike; it’s an object unmistakably occupying three-dimensional space. At, by designating a point-like location, implies that the dimensional extensions of the car are irrelevant to the message being communicated, thus disfavoring the ‘inside’ and ‘hood’ interpretations. Operative here is the systemic aspect of these three words. Because of the availability of all three options, the choice of one implies the inappropriateness of the other two. We don’t understand ‘at the car’ as including the seat or roof, because if the briefcase were in either of those two places, one would have said so. At work here is the Gricean Maxim of Quantity: “make your contribution as informative as is required (for the current purposes of the exchange)” (Grice 1967: 45). In brief, at implies ‘not an in-like location and not an on-like location’. This interrelatedness of at, on and in is best captured by putting them into a system, shown in Figure 1. At, on and in are in a single system because their meanings contrast with each other along a single semantic parameter: number of dimensions; and because the existence of each affects the use and interpretation of the others. Note that both at and in are precise in their dimensional meanings. But on is imprecise; it designates a range of dimensions, those falling between zero and three. And since zero and three dimensions are the meanings of at and in, this makes on quite literally ‘not at
95
96
Wallis Reid
Number of DIMENSIONS OF LOCATION
at: ZERO (0) on: MORE THAN ZERO AND LESS THAN THREE (0 < _< 3) in: THREE (3) Figure 1.
and not in’. Defining on relationally this way would not be feasible if on were being treated in isolation, independent of its relation to at and in. Here, of course, one could question the attractiveness of such a definition in the first place. Its appeal for the polysemy-shunning Columbia School analyst is clear. In my first, informal characterization of on I said it designated location on a line or a plane. That made it sound as if on has two meanings. My more formal characterization — a location falling between zero and three dimensions — succeeds in positing a single, albeit imprecise, meaning for on. But why should one imprecise meaning be preferable to two precise meanings? Let me answer somewhat obliquely for the moment, postponing the fuller discussion for later. Imprecision is inescapable in language because no definition specifies along all possible descriptive parameters. Consider (7) and (8): (7) He threw the keys on the grass. (8) He threw the keys in the grass. Asked how they differ, informants usually say that the grass in (7) is short, a lawn perhaps, while the grass in (8) is tall, a field perhaps. Does the word grass have two senses, ‘tall grass’ and ‘short grass’? I suspect most linguists would feel uneasy about positing two different senses for grass and opt instead to say that grass doesn’t specify any particular height as part of its meaning; it is neutral for height. Moreover, my analysis of on and in offers a plausible explanation for the different interpretations of grass. Tall grass is unmistakably three-dimensional, whereas the height of short grass can be overlooked, making a well-mown lawn appear to be flat. And the difference between a three-dimensional location and a two-dimensional location is the semantic boundary between in and on according to Figure 1. What this means then, is that specifications of ‘grass’ come from elsewhere in the context. The meanings of in and on are shaping its interpretation, fleshing out detail that is not inherent in the word grass itself. In the case of grass, at any rate, an imprecise meaning not marked for height seems intuitively right. To be sure, an alternative formal treatment is possible. Posit two senses for grass and then have the meanings of in and on select the appropriate sense. This is an ideal solution if one were writing a mechanical translation program because it capitalizes on something a computer can do very well, store and select. But as a picture of how natural language works it is less satisfactory because it fails to capitalize on something human beings can do very well: solve problems and make sense of things, such
Monosemy, homonymy and polysemy
as figuring out that one way grass can be a three-dimensional location is to be tall. By contrast, the mechanical solution, so appropriate for the computer, is quite literally ‘mindless’. Returning now to the issue at hand, the meaning posited for on in Figure 1 does not distinguish between one and two dimensions. The rationale is the same in spirit as that for making grass unspecified for height: assigning two different meanings, or senses, to on would be building precision into the language at the wrong place. Whether an on-like location is interpreted as a line (‘the bird on the wire’) or a plane (‘the cat on the mat’) is always decided by something else in the context. On by itself merely signals the semantic outer boundaries of its interpretation — constraining its interpretation without determining it — which is precisely the value assigned to it in Figure 1.
3. The Role of conceptualization In examples (1)–(8) in, at and on have functioned as close as language gets to objective description of the physical world. But in truth, the connection between language and the world is always mediated by a particular conceptualization by the speaker, even when speaking about the physical world.⁶ The role of speaker conceptualization is illustrated in the examples below: (9) Ricardo grew up in Cuba. (10) Ricardo grew up on the island of Cuba. Example (9)