American Rococo, 1750-1775
Arnerican Rococo, 1750-1775: Elegance in Ornament
American Rococo, 1750-1775: Elegance in...
109 downloads
1906 Views
47MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
American Rococo, 1750-1775
Arnerican Rococo, 1750-1775: Elegance in Ornament
American Rococo, 1750-1775: Elegance in Ornament
MO R R ISO N
LESL IE
TH E
LOS
H.
H E CK S CH ER
G REE NE
M ETROPOLITAN
ANGELES
COUNTY
B O WM A N
MUSEUM
MUSEUM
OF
OF
Di stributed by H arry N. Abrams, Inc., N ew York
ART
ART
This book is presented as a benefit of your museum membership. The exhibitions and programs of the Los Angeles County Museum of Art would not be possible without your generous support.
This book has been publish ed in co nju nc tion wi th the ex hibitio n Am ericall Rococo, '750- 1775' Elegance ill O rt/amellt, held at The M etrop ol itan Mu seum of Art, N ew York, fro m 26 J anu ar y to 17 M ay, and at th e Los An geles County Mu seum of A rt from 5 Jul y to 27 Septem ber 1992. Th e ex hib itio n is m ad e po ssibl e b y The H enr y Luce Fo unda tio n, Inc. , and th e N ati on al Endo wment fo r the Arts. T he exhibitio n was o rga n ized by T he M et ropolit an M useum of Art and th e Los An geles Coun ty Museum of A rt. Addit ion al su ppo rt for th e ex hibitio n in N ew Yor k has been provide d by T he Real Estate Counc il of T he M etropolitan M useum of Art. Additio nal su ppo rt for th e ex hib itio n in Los An geles has been pr o vided by the Rob ert and N an cy Daly Fo undatio n . The exhibitio n is also suppo rte d at th e M etrop ol itan Mu seum by grants fro m An nett e d e la R ent a , H . R ich ar d Die t rich, J r. , M r. an d M rs. Antho ny L. Ge ller, M r. and M rs. Rob ert G . Go ele t, Grace Foundati on In c. , M r. an d Mr s . R obert A. Hut , J oulli an & Co ., M r. and Mr s . Geo rge M . K aufman , M rs. Al exand er O . Vi et or, and M r. and Mrs . Erving Wo lf. The book th at acco m pan ies th e ex hibi tio n is ma de possible in part b y a generous gra n t fro m th e Lu ce Fund fo r Scho larsh ip in Am eri can Art , a prog ram of T he H enry Lu ce Found ati on, In c. Additio nal fund in g was received fro m The W ill iam C u llen Br yant Fell o w s o f Th e Am eri can W ing a t th e M etrop olit an Mu seu m , The Ch ips to ne Found ati on, Sothe by's, J ohn L. M ari on , and th e Am eri can Decor at ive Arts Dep artm ent of C hristie's, N ew Yor k .
Cove r-jacke t: Sla b tab le, P h ilad elp h ia, ca. 1770 . Th e M etr op olitan Mu seum of Art , J ohn Stewar t Kenn ed y Fund, 1918 (18.[10.27) Fr onti spie ce : Co ffee po t, ca . 1753, Ph ilip Sy ng , j r,; Phil ad elph ia. Phil adelph ia M useu m of Art , Purchased : J ohn D . Mcilhenn y Fund (6620-1)
Co py rig h t © [992 by The M etr opol it an Mu seum o f Art , N ew Yo rk . All ri ghts reserved . N o part of th is publi cati on m ay be reproduced or transmitt ed in any form o r b y any m ean s, elec tro n ic or mechanical, in clud in g ph o to cop yin g , recordin g . o r any in form ati o n storage and retriev al sys tem , w itho ut w ritt en perm ission fro m the pub lisher. J ohn P. O' Ne ill, Editor ill C hief and Genera! Manager of Publications M ar y-Al ice Rogers, Editor, Th e William C I/llell Bryalll Fellol/'s Publications, Th e A mericall Willg Elizabeth Finger . Designer Helga Lose, Production T yp eset by C raftsma n Type ln c., D ayt on , O hio Colo r reproduction by Rep ro co lor Int ern ation al s. r.l.. M ilan, Italy Pr int ed and bound b y Arti G rafiche M otta, S.p.A ., M ilan, Italy
Libr ar y of Congress Ca talogi ng - in- Publication Da ta Heckscher, M orrison H . Am eri can ro co co , 17 50- [77 5: elega nce in o rna me n t / M o r riso n H . Heckscher, Leslie Greene Bowm an. p. em. Includes bibliographical refere nces and index . ISBN 0-87099-630- 4. - ISBN 0-87099-63 I - 2 (pbk.). - ISBN 0-810964[2-0 (Ab rams) l. De cor at ion an d o rna ment, Roco co-Unit ed States-Exh ibiti ons. 2. D ecor at ion and o rna me nt - Unit ed Sta tes - H isto ry - r Sth centuryExhibition s. I. Bo wm an, Leslie G reene. II. Ti tle . NKI403· 5·H4 199 2 745. 4' 4974'09033074747[ - dc20 9 1- 29595 C IP
CONTENTS
F O HE W O H D
PH E FA C E
AC KNO W LE DG MEN TS
LENDE HS TO TH E E X H I B IT ION
VII
V II I
XI
XV
The Am erican Ro co co A rchi tcctu re
17
En gravin gs
37
Silver
71
Furn iture
133
Cas t Iron, G lass, and Porcelain
2 19
N OT E S
BIB LI O GH APHY
257
E X H I B IT ION C HEC K L IS T
I N D EX
PH O T O GHAPI I C HE D ITS
288
FOREWORD
th e ex h ib itio n h as been provi ded by th e N at ion al End o wm ent fo r th e Art s . At a c r ucia l mome n t , members of t he Vi sitin g Co m mi ttee o f the D ep artm ent of A m erican D eco rativ e Arts at th e M etrop olitan too k u p the cause o f th e proj ect with hand som e indi v idu al g ifts . We are also obliged to th e Wi lliam C u lle n Br yant Fell o w s of T he A m e rican Wing of th e M etr op ol it an Mu seum , w hose ed ito r , M a r y- A lice Ro gers, saw th e book th rou gh to publicat ion . Th e presentati on o f th e ex h ibition in N e w Yo r k is m ad e possibl e in part b y th e fin an cial assistan ce provided by The Heal Est ate Co u nci l o f T he M et rop olitan M useu m of Art . Additi on al su p po rt for th e ex hib itio n in N ew Yo rk has been pro vided b y Ann ette de la Rcn ta, H . Rich ard Diet ric h , J r. , Mr. an d Mrs. Anth on y L. Ge lle r, M r. and M rs. Hobert G . Go ele t , G race Found ati on In c. , M r. an d M rs . Ho b ert A . Hut, J oulli an & Co .; Mr. an d Mrs. Geo rge M . Kaufm an , Mrs. Alexande r O . Vi et o r, an d Mr. and Mrs. Ervi ng Wolf. W e a re furth er o b liga te d to th e Ho b e rt a n d N ancy Da ly Foundati on for its co nt ributio n towa rd th e produ cti on o f the ex hibitio n in Los An geles. W e a re ind ebt ed t o th e Lu cc Fu nd fo r Sc ho la rs hip in Am eri can Art, a pr o g ram o f Th e H enr y Lu ce Foun da tio n , Inc. , for pro vidin g a ge ne ro us gra nt to w ar d the pu bli cati o n o f th e b o ok . Addit ion al fu nd ing was r e ce iv ed fr om Th e C h ips to ne Found ati on, So t he b y ' s, J ohn L. M a r ion , a nd th e Am eri can D e co rati ve Art s D ep artm ent of C h ris t ie's, N ew Yo rk.
T he ro co co sty le was amo ng th e pr im ar y a rtis tic co nt ributio ns o f th e eig hteen t h ce n tu ry . It s m anifest ati on s throu gho u t E u rope h ave been co m p re he n siv ely ac k now ledged and chro n icled , but its in flue nce in Am erica, w he re it was pr obabl y th e ce nt ury's crow ni ng desi gn ac hieveme nt (co m m o nly referred to as th e C h ip pe n da le sty le), has n ever been th oro ug h ly exa m ine d . It w as a la vi sh tast e that found sur p risin gl y fertile g ro u nd in th e co lo nies , w he re affluent m ember s o f society , rejoi cin g in th eir har d- w on pr osper it y, stro ve to adop t Lond on fashi on s. T he ir su ccess in so doin g is ri ch ly de mo ns t ra ted in t he pag es that foll ow and in th e ex hibi tio n that thi s bo o k acco rn pan ies . We are es pecia lly pl eased th at American R O((l ((l, '750- 1775: E lc<s:a llcc ill O n/a IllCII! sho uld be jointl y o rga niz ed by o ur two in stitution s. The u nd ertakin g beg an w it h the d esire of th e Los An geles Co unty Mu seum of Art to m ount an ex hibitio n of Am er ic an C h i p pe n d a le furn itur e in a c ity w he re s uc h o bjects ha ve always b een in sho rt su p ply. Wi t h th e real ization th at th er e had ne ver been a co m pre he ns ive exa m ina tio n o f th e ro co co sty le as it was pr acti ced in th e Am eri can co lo nies , and th at su ch an ex hibi tio n mi ght be of int er est o n th e eas t coas t as well as on th e wes t, th e M etropol itan Museum joine d fo rces wi th Los An geles. This bi co ast al ve n ture results fro m th e effo rts of M orrison H . H eck sch er , C u ra to r, Am eri can Decorati ve Arts, at The M etropolitan Mu seum o f Art, and L esli e G ree ne Bo wm an , C ura to r o f D e cor at iv e Art s a t th e Lo s An gel es Co u n ty Mu seum o f Art. S uc h a pa r rrrcrxh ip ack now le dge s th e cc n -
Mu s eum s h a v e a lways d epc nded for th e ir ver y exi s te nce
t u r y of co m mi t me n t t o Am eri c an d e cor ati v e a r ts a t Th e M etropolitan Mu seum o f Art and the ex trao rd ina ry g ro w t h o f th e Los An gele s Co unty Mu seum o f Art since it s found-
o n th e s po nso rs h ip o f th eir frie n ds a nd bene factors . T hat tan gibl e o u tpo u ring o f ca re and in te res t has never been m ore vital th an it is in th e wo rl d of to day, n o r ha ve we eve r had m ore reason to che rish it.
ing in 1913 . We take pl easure in ex te n d ing o u r g ra tit ude to a number of in stitution s an d individu als for th e ge ne ros ity th at m ad e A merica n R O((l CO p o ssible , p arti cul a rl y Th e H enr y Lu ce Fo u n da ti on, In c . , wh o se gi ft t o w a rd th e boo k in 198 5 launc he d th e undertakin g an d w hose furth er co nt ribut io n in 19 91 m at eriall y ai de d t he en deavor. Additi on al su p po r t fo r
Philippe de M onteb ello , D irector T he M etropolitan Mu seum o f Art Earl A . Po w ell III, D irector Los An geles County Mu seum of Art
V II
PREFACE
Alll cricall R ococo, 1750-1775; E lcoaucc ill O rname nt is a bo ok abo u t a s ty le . In plannin g it an d th e e x h ib itio n it acc o m panies, th e aut ho rs decided o n t w o arbitrary restricti on s: that th e definition o f ro co co b e limited to th e o rna me n tal as pec t o f th e eig htee nt h-century sty le and th at th e w or ks chose n for inclu sion be limited to th o se o f Am eri can m anu facture . O b vio us ly , however , th er e had to be so me flexibi lit y in th e ran g e o f d at es defin ed in t h e titl e . l n additi on, th ou gh a hand ful o f En gli sh-m ad e pi eces are present to illu strat e the esse n tial En gli sh qualit y o f th e sty le as w ell as th e m ann er o f its tr an sm ission to Am er ica, we chose to co nce nt ra te not o n th e ad mix ture of imported an d nativ e-m ad e o bjects th at was th e rea lity o f th e fu rnis h ings of th e co lo nial elite but o n the best exa m ples o f d om esti c crea tivi ty, whi ch w e sel ecte d for th eir ex ception al w orkm an ship an d aes t he tic m erit . A s is always th e case with a lo an ex h ibi tio n, becau se o f co n servation concerns, fin an cial ex ige nc ies, and o the r pr acti cal limitatio ns, we had to for go certa in o bjects we wo u ld o the rw ise hav e chosen. Th e b o ok d o es n ot pu rp o rt to be a survey o f th e arts in Am eri ca in th e third quarter of th e eig htee n th century. Silv er and furniture-in thi s co u n try the t w o categ o ries m ost co ngenial to rococo o rna men ta tio n - form the prin cip al sec tio ns and are th er efore di scu ssed a t grea tes t len gth . Am on g the ave n ues of a rt is t ic e n deavo r we excl u de d a rc Am eri can p ain tin gs (s uc h as mid-centur y portraits b y Blackburn an d th e yo u ng Co p ley) n o w genera lly co ns ide re d t o be o f a ro co co sensi bi lity but h avin g littl e, if any th ing, to do wi th rococo o rn a mc ntat io n. T he incl usio n of ce rtain d o m esti c neo classical p ortraits is j us tifie d b y th eir b ein g en closed in th eir o rig ina l, lu xuriou sly ro co co fram es. Un rep resented are so m e of th e era's m ajor regi on al schoo ls. eithe r becau se their o u t p ut is n ot in th e ro co co m od e (t he fa mo us b ar o qu e bl o ck- and- sh ell fu rn i t u re o f N e wp ort. fo r i ns tance) o r
becau se their in vo cati on of th e sty le is so far removed from th e Englis h so urce as to co ns tit u te a to ta lly differe n t image (furn it ure b y Eliph alct C ha p in of Windsor , Connecticu t-an idi o syn cr ati c o ffs hoo t o f Ph ila delph ia design - im m edi ately co mes to mind). Prim aril y , th e bo ok and th e ex h ib itio n were co nce ived to add ress the fundam ental q ues tio n: Did th e rococo sty le exist in colo n ial Am er ica? The relevan ce o f th at q ues tion became in cr easin gl y a ppa re n t th rou gh o ur lo n g p repara tion by the o m n ip rese n t specter o f J oh n H en ry Belt er . w hose fos te ring o f th e r o co co-r e vi v al s ty le in mid -nin et ee nth- ce n t u r y Am eri ca is so widel y recog nized as to o bfuscate the original ro co co ' s flouri shin g o n th ese sho res. Baroque & R (l( (l( O ; A rch itecture & Decoration, ed ite d b y Anth on y I3lunt (Lo ndon . 1978), a m ajor int ern ati onal survey of th e do m in an t styles of the seve nteen th and eig h tee n t h ce n t uries , never even m entions Eng land's co lo n ies in th e N ew World . A s au t hors. we o w e a debt of in spirati on to R ococo: Art and D esiy n ill H oo arth '5 E nyla nd, an ex h ib itio n at th e V ictoria and Al be rt Mu seum, an d it s acco m pa ny ing ca ta log ue (Lo ndon. 1984 ). w h ich pro vid ed a co rn uco pic view of th e sty le 's pr esen ce in En gland ; it is o ur aim to ac h ieve so me thi ng co mpa rab le for its pr esen ce in Amer ica. The fir st cha pter of th e book, a su m ma ry of th e Euro pean o rig ins and th e Am eri can m anifest ati on s of the rococo. conclu de s with a br ief discuss io n o f fir earm s, w hose ornament co ns ists eq ua lly o f e ng raved m et al an d carve d wood . and textil es, whi ch arc to o few in number to wa rra n t a separa te s t u dy . Th e seco n d c ha p ter is d e v o t ed t o arc hitec ture . Th ou gh littl e o f it survives an d o n ly o ne exa m ple is contain ed in th e ex hib itio n, it pr o vided th e setting for th e style's usc in th e o ther m edium s and in it sel f served as a show p lace fo r th e carve r 's art. Th e res t o f th e boo k is arranged in chapter s acco rd ing to m ed ium (pa pe r; silve r; wood; iron . glass .
V III
g ive n. it is th e g rea test; wher e th er e ar e t w o o r three. unl ess o t he rw ise n oted. th e y a re in o rde r o f hei ght . width . an d depth . For wo rks o n pap er , th e m easurem ent s a re of th e pl ate mark . if it ex is t s. o r of th e im ag e. if it d o es n ot. For o bjects o f w o od . th e se m ico lo n afte r th e prim ar y w o od denotes that th os e that foll o w a re seco n da ry. Th e bibli o graph y (pp. 257-( 3) co nta ins not o nly all refer en ces em ployed in sho rt form in th e text and in th e end no tes but also so urces o f gene ra l importan ce to any in ve sti g ati on o f th e Am erican ro co co .
and cera m ics) . with th e fo cu s o f the text on th e st yle o f an objec t an d w it h m att e rs o f co nst ruc t io n . co n d itio n . an d pr o ven an ce tou ch ed o n o nly insofar as was deemed relevant. O bjects w hose illu strati on s are identified by a number and a b rief ca p tio n are part o f th e ex hi b itio n and are recorded in full in it s chec k lis t (p p. 2 04-75). Th e numb er ap pea rs in bo ldface typ e at th at point in the text w he re th e o bject is di scussed at le ng t h. in a sec tio n se t o ff b y sp ace s. sugges ting w ha t w ould be an en t ry in a sta nda rd ex hibitio n cata log ue . Illu strati ons ide nt ified b y a fig ur e nu mber are o f object s that co u ld n ot b e included in th e ex h ib it io n o r o f im ages th at we re adde d to th e text for co m pa rative purpos es. Dim en sion s are g ive n in inche s. to th e near est eighth o f an in ch. an d i n ce n t i me te rs. Wh er e o n ly o ne dim en s ion is
M orrison H . H eck sch er Leslie G ree ne Bo w m an
IX
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We ow e s p ec ial thank s to th e int ern s an d vo lu n tee rs w ho d evoted th eir ene rg ies to v ar iou s as pec ts o f thi s pr oj ect : Gord on Frey, Eli zab eth J. Kalm an, Floren ce Klein , Andrew J. Kron enberg, J ordan a P om er o y, Lesli e Sy m ing to n , an d Ca rla Yanni. At Los Angel es, we particul arl y app rec iate th e forb ear an ce and su p po rt o f memb ers o f th e decorati ve arts d ep artment : M artin G. Chapm an, J ean ett e H an isce , R o g er E . J on es , M arth a D . Lynn , Jud y And er son, and form er d ep artm ent h ead Timoth y Schr od er , as we ll as d ep artm ent int ern s D eidre Cron cnb ol d , Kath y Go d dard , an d Wend y Wasson . Resear ch assistan ce wa s also pr o vid ed by Eleano r H artm an, Anne Diederick , an d o the r members o f th e librar y staff. Fo r help with g ra n ts, co n t rac ts, an d fu n d - raisi ng, we th ank Ron ald B. Br atton, deput y dir ector; Elizab eth H. Al germissen, assistant director; Julie A. J ohnston , director o f dev elopm ent , and her ass ista n t, T om J acobson; and M ark Mitch ell , bud get man ager. For th eir in valu abl e ass is ta nce with th e ex hibition in Los An geles we acknowledge ass ista nt di rect or Arthur Owens and hi s sta ff m emb er s M ar y Lou ghlin an d Willi am Stahl ; h ead o f ex h ib it io n pr o gram s J ohn P assi , exhibition de sign er Bern ar d Kest er , spec ial eve nts pl ann in g director J anis Dinwiddi e and her sta ff; we also cre dit St even N. Oliver for hi s photo graph y. For ex h ib itio n in st all ati on we are o b liged to R oma Alli son , Lou M assad , Willi e Willi am s, and th ei r sta ffs; fo r regis trarial ass ista nce, Ren ee Mont gomer y an d C ha n d ra Kin g; for co nse r va tio n co n s u lta tio n , Pierer M eyer s, Ste ve Cristin-P ouch er , an d D on Men ve g; for tr avel arra nge me n ts , Jani ce Elli s and Fer oza Vimadalal. We a re indebt ed to o u r co lleag ues at in num er abl e mu seums , librari es, an d historical so cieties for m aki n g th eir co llec tio ns access ib le (a n d in m an y cas es al so fa cilitatin g loan s), for assistin g with resear ch , and for pr ovidin g illu strati on s. In parti cul ar , we sa lu te th e foll owin g in d iv id ua ls and th eir in stituti on s : Alb an y In stitute o f H ist or y an d Art :
An ex h ib itio n of th e sco pe and co m plex ity of Am eri can R O([1CO is po ssible o n ly with the co m b ine d efforts of co un tless pe ople o f div er se talents. We ac k now ledge th e almo st uni ver sal en th us ias m and coo pe ra tio n w ith whi ch w e were gree te d durin g o u r yea rs o f travel and resear ch . Our fir st debt is to Phil ipp e de M onteb ell o and Ea rl A . Powell III, direct or s o f Th e M et rop olitan Mu seum o f Art and th e Los An g eles Co u n ty Museum o f Art, resp ectivel y, for their stea dfas t su p port, w hich m ad e po ssible thi s join t venture of the tw o institution s. At th e M etropolit an, sco res o f indi vidu al s w orked to ma ke Am eri call R O([1 ([1 happen . In th e director's o ffice we ar e pa r t ic u la rly in deb te d t o M ahrukh T ar apor and Marth a D eese; in th e d ev el opm ent o ffice, Em ily Kern an Raffert y, N in a M cN . Di efenbach , and Carol Ehler; for all regi strari al det ails. J ohn Bu chan an an d Nin a S. Maru ca; for ex hibitio n design. David Harvey, for g ra phic design , Jill Hamrncrbcr g. an d for li ghtin g, Z ach Z an oll i; for th e co nse r v atio n o f o bjects, J ohn C ano n ico , Rud olf C o lb an , Sh err y D o y al, Kathr yn J. G ill, H erm es Kn auer, Willi am Lou che, D o roth y Mah o n , Mark Min or, M arj o rie N . Shell ey , Ca t h er ine Turton, Antoin e M . Wilm er in g ; fo r ph oto graph y, Barbara Bri d g e rs, Al ex ander Mikh ail o vi ch , Karin L. Willi s, an d Ca rmel W ilson . Assist an ce was also gracio usly pr ovided by Co lta Iv es , D a vid W . Ki ehl , an d T om R ass icu r of the D ep artm ent of P rints and Ph oto graph s, an d b y C la re LcC o r be ill er , J essi e M cNab , an d Willi am R ied er of th e De partme nt o f Euro pea n Sculpture and Decorative Arts. We are gra te fu l to all o ur co lleag ues in th e Ameri can Win g : J ohn K. Howat , The Lawren ce A . Fleischm an C ha irm an o f th e D epartments of Am eri can Art ; cu rato rs Ali ce Coo ney Frelin ghu y sen, Pet er M . Kenn y , Ameli a P eck , Fr an ces G ru be r Safford , an d es pecia lly Ca the rin e Ho over Voorsan ger; ad m in istra tive assist ants Ellin Ro sen zweig and Sera p h ine Wu ; d ep artm ental te chni ci an s G ary Burn ett, Edwa rd D i Farn ecio. Sea n Farrell , and D on E. T empleton .
XI
Ta m m is K . Groft , C h ri s ti ne Ro bin son ; Am eri can Antiq ua ria n So cie ty : Georgia B. B arnhi ll; The A rt In stitute o f C h icago : And ora M org in son , M il o M . N aev e; Th e Baltim ore Mu se um of Art : We n dy A . Coo pe r , Will iam Vo ss Elder III, D eb or ah A . Fcd er h cn : B o st on M arin e So ci et y : Har old F. Lyn ch ; Bost on Pu bli c Libr ar y: Sinclair Hitchin gs; T he Br o o kl yn Mu seum : Ke vin Stay to n ; Th e J ohn Ca rte r Br o wn Libr ar y : Sus an L. D anfor th, N o rm an Ficr ing ; Burl in gto n Co u n ty Hi st ori cal Socie ty : Rh ett Per n ot: Th e Ca rnegie Museum o f Art : Ph illip M . J ohnston ; The C ha rlesto n Mu seum : C h ris to p he r T. Lo cb lc in: Th e C h ips to ne Fo un da tio n: Luk e Bcck erd ire: St erl in g an d Fr an cin e C la r k A rt In st itute: Beth Ca rve r Wees; Co lo n ia l Willi am sburg : Wallace 13 . G us ler , G ra ha m H ood, Ron ald Hurst , M ar gar et Prit ch ard ; Co lu m bia U nive rsi ty : H oll ce H as w ell, H erbert M it ch ell ; Co n nec t ic u t Hi st or ical Soc ie ty : C h ris to p he r P. B ickfo rd ; Th e Co rn ing Mu seum o f G lass : D wi ght P. Lanm on, J an e S. Sp ill ma n ; D ep art m ent of Sta te : C le me n t Conger, M ar y Itscll , Ga il Serfari: Di ckinson College Lib rary : M ar ie B o oth Ferre, Geo rge Hin g ; The Di etri ch Am eri can Fo u n da tio n : D eb orah M cCrack en Rebu ck ; Essex Institute: Rob ert Weis; Fir st Troop Phil ad elphia Ci ty Cava lry : J ohn C. D ev er eu x ; Fogg Art Mu seum : Loui se T odd Amb ler , M arj orie 13 . Coh n, J an e M ontgom er y; Henry Ford Museum & G ree n field Vi llage: M ich ael J. Ettcma: Ge nea log ica l Soc iet y of Penn syl vani a: Anto inette J. Seg raves; Gi bbes Mu seum of Ar t : An g el a D . M ack ; H e rsh e y M useum : Lesli e A . Bcllais. J am es M cM ah on ; Hi gh Mu seum o f Art : Don ald C. Peirce; Hi stor ic C h arlest on Foundation : J o nath an H . Poston , J. Th om as Savage, Jr . ; H is to r ic C her ry Hill : An n e W. Acker son ; Hi st ori c D eerfield , Inc. : A m and a M crull o , Bru ce M osel y, J anin e Ske rry, Ph ilip Zea: T he H ist o rical Socie ty o f Pen n s yl van ia : Dav id Cassedy ; H o pew ell Fu rn ace Natio na l Hi st o ri c Site: Lee Bo y le, D ian e C ram; In d ep end en ce Na tio nal H istor ic P ar k : Karie Di crh orn , D ori s D . Fanell i;
Librar y Co m pa ny o f Phil ad elphi a : J ohn C. Van H orn e; M arbleh ead Hi stori cal So ciet y : Bette Hunt, M ary Parrish; M ar yl and Hi st ori cal So ci et y: J ennifer F. Go ldsbo ro ug h, G regory Weidm an ; M oravi an H ist ori cal So ciet y : Susa n M . Dr eyd opp el; M ount Vern on Ladi es' Asso ciat ion o f th e Uni on : C h ris t ine M ead ow s; Mu seum o f th e C ity of N ew York : D eborah Dependahl Wat er s, J an S. Ramirez; Mu seu m o f Earl y So u the rn D ecorative Arts: J ohn Bi vin s, J r. , Fra nk L. H orton, M ad el yn M oeller , Br adford L. Rau schen berg , M ar g ar et Vin cent ; Mu seum of Fin e Arts, Bo st on : Elle no r Alc orn, Edwa rd S. C ooke, Jr., J on athan Fairbank s, J eanni ne Falin o , Rach ael M onfred o , J effrey Mun ger , J anice So rkow, Lind a Thom as, J ohn Wool f; Mu seum o f Fine Arts, Hou ston : Mi ch ael K. Br own; N ati on al Trust for Hi stor ic Preservation: J ennifer Esler , Elizab eth M . Laurent , Frank E. Sanchis; T he N ew J er sey Hi stori cal So ciet y : Ro salind Libbey , Wilson E. O 'D onn el l; N ew J er sey Sta te Mu seum : Su zann e Co rlc tte C ri lley, Su san Fink el ; Th e New-York H istorical Socie ty: Tim oth y An glin Burg ard, Nin a R . Gr ay, H oll y H ot ch ner , Wend y Sh ad w ell; Th e N ew York Publi c Librar y: Ro b er ta Waddell ; Phil ad elphia Museum o f Art : Beat rice B. Ga rvan, J ack L. Lind sey, N an cy Qu ailc; Portland Mu seum o f Art : M arth a R . Scv cr ens: Rh od e lslan d Sch o o l of Desig n : Thom as S. Mi chi e, C hristo phe r P. M onkhou se, Frankl in W. Robinson ; The Soc iety for the Preservation of N ew Eng land Antiquiti es: Br o ck J ob e, Ri ch ard N yl ander ; Sta te Mu seum o f Penn s yl v ani a: J am es Mit ch ell; Van Cort la n d t H ou se : Elizabe th 13 . Lecki e; Vir ginia Mu seum o f Fine Arts: William M . S. R asruu sscn : Wad sw orth Athen eum : Wi llia m H osley, Elizabe th Kornhau ser ; W interthur Mu seum: Kenneth Ames, Burt D enk er, N an cy G . Eva ns , D on ald L. Fe n n imo re , E. M cSh er r y Fo wble, Th o m as A . G raves , Paul B. H en sl ey , C har les F. Humm el , Ani zi a K ar m az y n , J ohn Kri ll , Greg Landrcy, Rich ard M cK in str y, Kath arin e M artinez, M ich ael S. Podm ani czk y , Ian M . G . Quimb y , C he ry l Ro b ert so n ,
XII
Willm an Spawn, Laura F. Sprag ue, Pat ricia A . Teter, Gi lbert T. Vin cent, Barb ar a and Gera ld W. R. Ward . At th e M etropolitan Mu seu m , w e ex p ress o u r ap p rec iation to m ember s of th e ed ito rial dep art m ent for th e prod ucti on o f th e b o o k : J ohn P . O'N ei ll, Ed itor in C hief an d Ge nera l M an ager o f Publi cati on s; Barb ara Bu rn , Exe cu tive Editor ; T e resa Ega n, M an ag in g Edito r ; Ken d ra H o , pro ofre ad er ; Su san Br adfo rd , ind exer ; Steffie Kapl an , m echa nica ls art ist; Pet er Anton y an d es pec ia lly H elg a Lo se, produ ction assoc iates. O ur g rea tes t debts, ho w eve r, are to Elizabeth Finger, fo r th e tim el ess beaut y of he r b ook design ; D av id Al liso n , for th e fin e an d se ns itive n e w p ho to g rap h y fo r th e b o ok ; an d Fra nces Br crt cr , fo r her de di cated and m eti culo us assistan ce in all ph ases o f the e xhibitio n. M ar y-Al ice Ro ger s, m aste r wo rds m it h , lab ored un stintin gl y to ach ieve w ha tev er clari t y and elega nce are found in th is vo lu me . Our fin al ac kn o w ledg m e n t is to o u r famili es a nd fri e nd s fo r t he ir ste ad fas t forbearan ce and encou rage m ent .
K ar ol A . Schmi eg el , Su san Sw an , N e vill e Th omp son , R ob ert F. Trent, Philip D. Zimm erm an ; W or cest er Art Mu seum : Sall y R. Fr eitag, Su san E. Stri ckl er ; Yale Uni versit y Art Ga llery: D avid L. Barqu ist, Di ane Hart, Patri cia E. Kan e, Jul es D . Pr own . M any indi vid ua ls also deserve m ention and th ank s: Rob ert Bark er, H enry L. P. Beck with , jr. , Philip H. Br adle y, Ali ce Br aun feld , C h r is to p her Burr , Ma rg ar et B . Ca ldwe ll an d Ca r lo M . Flo re nt ino , M ari an S. Carso n , M r. a n d Mr s . Robert A . D aly , Will iam K. du Pont, Mr. and Mrs. Ca rly le C. Euba nk II , Marth a Ga ndy Fales, J oAnn and Julian Ga nz , Wen dell D . Gar re t t, Robert Geo rge, William H . Guthm an, Mi ch ael H all , Kenn eth H a wkin s, Grego ry A . Hi g gin son, Jam es P. J enkins, Mr. and Mrs. Will iam S. Kilro y , J oe Kindig III , Mr. a n d Mrs . B ern ad ott e P. Lest er, Jr., Bern ard Levy , S. D ean Le v y , Arthu r Li v cr anr , Isr ael Li ver ant , Jo se p h H . M cG ee , Pet e r M an ig ault, Al an Mill er , Ruth M ill er , M r. an d M rs. J am es L. Nu gent , Jr. , M ax P alcv sk y, Arl en e P alm er, Ll o yd A. P ear son , Ad ol ph a n d Bev erle y Pl aczek , D. J. Puffert, R ich ard H . Rand all, Jr. , Mi ch ael Rebi c, Barb ar a Roberts, Alexandra W. Rollins, Al bert Sack , H ar old Sac k , Rob e rt Sack, J eann e Sloa ne, Mi ch ael Sn odin ,
M o rrison H . H cck sch er Leslie G reen e Bo w m an
X I II
LENDERS
TO
THE
Alban y Insrirur c o f Hi sto ry and Art Am erican Antiqu ari an So ciet y Aver y Ar chitectural and Fine Arts Libr ar y, Columbia Uni ver sit y Mrs. Gra ham J ohn Barbcy, Courtesy of th e M ar yland H istorical Socie ty Birdsboro Commu ni ty M em ori al Ce nte r Boston M arine Society M rs. M ur ray Br aun feld Da vid M . , N elson F. , Pet er R., and Ro bert W. Brinckcrhoff, and th eir fami lies T he Brookl yn Museum The J oh n Carte r Br o wn Librar y at Brown Univer sit y Burl in gto n Cou nty H istorical Societ y The Ca rnegie Museum o f Art The C har lesto n Museum Th e C hipsro nc Foundati on C livcdc n, a co-s tew ardship propcrty of th e N ationa l T rust for Hi stori c Pr eservation Th e Colo nial Willi am sburg Fo undation Connec ticut H isto rical Societ y The Co rn ing Museum o f G lass The Rich ard Henry D an a fam ily Dic ki nso n College The Die trich Am eri can Foundation H . Richard D ietrich, J r. D iplo m at ic Recept ion Ro oms, Dep artm ent o f State Wi lliam K. du Pont Geo rge G. M eade Easb y Essex Institute First Sco ts Pr esb yter ian Church, C ha rlesto n Gib bes M useum o f Art Harvard Univer sit y Art Museums Henry Ford Museum & Gr eenfield Vill age Hersh ey Museum Hi gh Museum o f Art
EXHIBITION
Hist ori c C herry Hill Hi storic Deerfi eld, Inc. The Hi stori cal Soc iety o f Penn syl vani a Mr. and Mrs. Geor ge M . Kau fm an Joe Kindig III Rob ert E. Lee M em ori al Association, Inc. , Str atford Hall Plant ation Bern ar d and S. D ean Levy. Inc. The Libr ar y Com pany of Ph iladelph ia Los An geles County M useum of A rt M arbl ehead Hi storical Socie ty Mr. and Mrs. Frank A. M aur i The M etrop olitan Museum of Art M or avian Hi stori cal Soc iety Mu seum o f Art, Rh od e Island School o f Design Museum o f th e C ity o f N ew York M useum of Earl y Southern Decor ati ve Arts M usc um of Fine A rts, Boston T he Na tio na l Societ y o f Colonial Dam es in the St ate o f New York; Van Cortland t H ou se The New Jersey Hi storical Societ y N ew J ersey State Museum The N ew-York Hi storical Socie ty The N ew York Public Lib rar y Eri c N oah Mr. and Mrs. Edwa rd J. Nusr ala Ph iladelphia M useum o f Art The Sta te Museum o f Penn sylvania Philip Van Rensselaer Van Wyck Wad sworth Ath eneum The Winterthur Libr ar y Winterthur Museum Ervin g and J oyce Wolf Wor ccster Art Museum Yale University Art Ga llery Private co llecto rs (six)
xv
THE
A ME R I C A N
R O C O C O
T he wo rd " rococo" was ev ide n tly fir st coi ne d in 179 6 o r 1797 by M auri ce Qu ai" , a pupil ofJ acqu es-L ouis D avid ' s, w ho used it as a pej orative descr ipt ion of th e sty le associated w ith Louis X V . ' Q ua i" was almos t ce rtai nly co rru p ting th e term "rocaille," one o f th e rococo 's cha rac te ristic m oti fs. " Roca il le" was origi na lly u sed t o r efer to th e tortuous ro ck wo r k fabricat ed for arti fic ia l caves o r gro ttoes , th emselves evoca tive of aq ua tic fant asi es, in th e seve n tee n t hce n tury pl easu re garde ns o f th e aristocracy . "Ro co co " lo st its negative co nno ta tio n by the 1840S, and sin ce th at time has bee n u se d t o n am e a sty le that d u r ing th e fi rs t h alf o f the eig h tee n t h cen tu ry p e rm eat ed all br anch es o f ar t is t ic endeavo r in E u ro pe, fro m th e fin e arts to th e d ecorati ve, expressing a n ew, u n con vention al , an d hi ghl y o rna me n ta l sp iri t of fan tasy, elega nce, an d m o vem ent. In it s dep arture from classica l o rde r an d sym met ry, th e ro co co sco rned th e ru le and th e co m pass in favo r of em bellish me nt th at required s k il lfu l free ha nd ren deri ng an d an imagi na tio n th at transcended the bo un ds of acade mic co nve nt ion. Traci ng its o rigins to so urces in Italian bar oque design s, the ro co co was nu rtu red to m at urit y in Fran ce in the [730S, largely at th e h and of the g ifted design er just e-Aurele M eissonn ier (1695 -1750), arc h i tec t, p aint er , sc u lp to r, and silversmi t h, w ho fro m 1726 u nt il h is d eath wa s th e o ffic ia l co u rt des ig ner to Lo ui s XV. 2 Am on g th e ea rl ies t Fr en ch rococo manifesta tio ns arc M eisson ni cr 's des ig ns o f 172 8 for a
scu lp tu ra l ca nd lestick o n w h ich froli ckin g putti intertwine wi th sp ira li ng sc ro ll wo r k ;" h e wen t o n to p rodu ce awide ra nge o f ot her design s for arc hi tec tu re, sculpture , furni ture, and silve r in the r o co co m od e . H is or na me n ta l print s o f arc hi tec tura l ca p rices ami d sur rea l land scap es o f fountain s,
Side chair (No. 147) after Ch ippendale desigll (No. r)
FIGURE I . Ornam ental design , Oel/v re de[us te-A urele M cissonn icr (Paris, ca. '7 50), Plate D22. Engraving on paper , 4V2 x 8 in . ( 11. 4 x 20.3 em .). T he M et rop olitan Museum of Art, Rogers Fund, 1918 ( 18.62·5)
shells . and ro caill e (nc . I ), at tra ct ing co nsi de ra ble atte ntion and wi del y imitat ed . ca me to cha rac te rize th e ~(!CIIl'C pittoresque (the Fre nc h ro co co). As o ne o f hi s co nte m pora ries observed , " Meisso nnie r began to dest ro y all th e stra ig ht lines th at we re o f the o ld u sag e . . . he inv ented co n t ras ts, th at is to say he ban ish ed sy m me try ."4 In Eng la nd , t rad itio n all y dep endent o n Fren ch examp le in matter s o f tast e, th e ado p tio n of th e ~(! e ll /'c pittoresquc wa s fo st ered by a su bs ta n tia l co m m u n ity of Fr en ch Hu gu en ot cra fts me n w ho h ad co me to live in Lond on . T hey in cl uded m an y o f th e best m etalsm ith s. eng ravers, an d woodworke rs who fled th eir co un t ry afte r 1085, w he n Louis X IV revok ed t he Ed ic t o f N ant es. w h ic h h ad pr ote ct ed th e r ight s of Fren ch Protest ants. Co llec tiv ely. w he ther recently arrived or o f a succee d ing ge ne ra t io n, th o se e m igres not o n ly tr an sformed En g li sh d esi gn but also eleva te d sta n dards of cr aft sm an ship to new heights. Amon g th e first ex po ne nts of th e ro co co style an d the ar tisa n w ho subseq ue n tl y exercised g rea t infl ue nce o n En gl ish silve r was Paul de Lam crie ( 168817 Sf). a silve rs m ith born in London o f Hu gu en ot ex traction, wh o se oe uv re d em on stra ted ro co co tend en cies as earl y as 1731 . S E ng lis h e ng rav ing was s imi la rly a ffected by t he Fren ch drafts.man and eng rave r Hubert Gravclo r ( 1099- 1773), wh o a r r i ve d in Lond on in 1732 a nd w hose in fl uen ce ex te nde d well beyond hi s spe cialty. A s a teach er at the Saint M artin 's Lan e A cad em y . th en th e chief sc hool for Englis h ar tists and o ne th at becam e th e ne xu s o f t rainin g in rococo design. G ravelo r intro d uced the ro co co into all bran ch es of Eng lis h art. T he aca de my an d th e o the r schoo ls o f d raw ing th at took up the st yle we re vita l to its develop m ent , for the y ed uc ate d th e draft sm en and th e m odelers w ho su pplied pattern s for carvers. en gr avers, silve rs m iths. and o the r artisa ns. Two d esi gn er s fi gur ed pr omin entl y in th e d ist in ctl y Eng lis h interpret ati on of ro co co o rna me n t th at emerged in t h e 1740s: M atthi as Lo c k a n d Henr y Co plan d . (, Lo c k (d . 17( 5) was a wood-carver w ho be twee n 1744 and 1746 etched seve ra l su ites of d esi gn s for ca rve d furnitu re (fra m es an d tab les). H e also pub lish ed bo okl et s o f o rna me ntal shields, or carrou c hcs, and . abo u t 1746, issu ed T he Principles (~r O runIIl C/II. (l /, the Youtli's G uide 10 Dral Fillg of Foliage. an instru ctio n man ual in drawin g ragged- ed ged aca n th us leaves, know n in ro coco parl an ce as ra ffl es (HG. 2). Co pla nd (d. (753) wa s an acco m p lis he d engraver w ho a lso p u blis he d sui tes of orn am ental p rints . Hi s s ha r p sty le o f eng rav ing and hi s as ym m et r ical a n d fanta sti c sc he mes , co m b iui ng scro lls and roca illc w it h naturalisri c flo w er s and g rasses ( 1'( (;. 3). set t he ton e fo r succee d ing E ng lis h e ng raved o rna me n t. In 175 2. Lo ck and Co p la nd issu ed join tly A Ne ll! B ook 40malllCIIIS w ith T w el ve L eaves. T he ir de sign s. w h ich we re often m ore in vc n tivc, e nerge t ic, a nd b iza rre than Fr en ch prece dents.
?.!,
r I ,.,,,/,.,, Ihill",II;~rR~f. . "
r .
) (1'1'0 '
n,.."r " ,,:,,~.,nll. 1 I II " /''/' 'r /
. ~·o·, ·,,1'
2. Title page. M. Lock. The Principles (~r 0 ,.,,<1 III cnt (London. ca. 1746; reissue. ca. 17( 8). Engraving on paper. 3% x 6 in. (<). 2 x 15.2 cm.). T he Metropolitan Mu seum of Art. Harris Brisbane Dick Fund. 1<)34 (34.<)0. 2)
F IGURE
2
had a lastin g in fl ue nce o n eng ravers an d woo d-ca r ve rs in Eng land and in her co lo nies. Lo ck a n d Co p la n d represent th e t wo c ra fts for whi ch th e rococo was parti cul arl y w ell suited : ca rv ing and eng ravin g (t ho ug h th e t w o we re almos t never em ployed to gether). T he sty le 's o rname nta l n atu re m ad e it imm ed iatel y popular wi th th e craftsme n w ho stood chie fly to gai n fro m its ado ption . E ngrave rs we re u n iquely posi tio ne d to p romo te th e rococo, n ot only in ornamenta l p rints bu t also in p att ern books and print ed ep hemera. T he interpre ta tio n of eng ra ve d designs re q ui red th e sk illed mini strati on s of wood-carve rs, meta l e ngrave rs, and sil ve r chase rs . In ad di tio n to o bj ec ts of silver , eng rave rs e m be llis he d si lve re d brass faces on tall clocks , brass an d silve r m o unts o n fire arm s, and eve n, occa siona lly , pewter. C hase rs ham m ered roco co design s into th e surface of silver; carve rs executed th ree-dim ension al design s in archi tectura l woodwo rk, furni tu re, and pattern s for cas ting or mold ing such dive rge nt ma teria ls as silve r, ir on, and porcelain . The ro co co , mo re th an any p re viou s style, reli ed o n specialized crafts me n to inte r pret co rrectly its dem anding art istic voca b ula ry . T he publicati o ns o f Lock an d Copland we re follo w ed in th e m id-r vy o s b y a spa te of o t her pattern bo ok s in corporating ro co co o rna me nt. O ne Hundr ed and F({t}' Ne ill D esions (175X; (7 6 1) b y Th om as J ohn son , a we ll-k n o w n ca r ver , ca r ried o n Lo ck 's champion ing o f ca rved furniture. In 1762, he too published A Nell' Book of Ornaments. tho ugh hi s was a suite of but six des ig ns (see FIG. ~ X , p . 20 2) . O the r pub licatio ns made t he sty le ava ilable to cabinet- and chair rn ak ers. Thomas C h ip pe nda le's Ge ntleman and Cabinet-Ma ker's Di rertor (1754 ; 1755; 17(2) an d Wi llia m ln ce an d Jo h n M ayh ew' s Unive rse! Sv st cnt o] H oushold Furnit ure ( 1762) we re opul ent fo lios aimed at nobl e clients. C cntcel Housliold Furniture ill the Present Taste (1760; 17 ( 2 ) , by a "Socie ty o f Uph ol st erer s, " and R o b ert M an w ar in g ' s Cabinet an d C hair -Maker's R ea! Friend and Conip anion (1765) we re pocket -sized vo lu mes intended fo r craftsmen, but th eir use soo n ex tended beyond urban centers to the provinces and thence to the co lo nies . C h ip penda le's D irector re q u ires specia l m enti on . Th e larges t, mos t lu xu ri o us, an d IllOSt fa mous of eig h tee n t h ce ntury fu rn it u re pattern book s, Th e Dir ector was probabl y t he m o st b roadl y di ssemin ated . (It wa s wid el y a va ila b le in Ameri ca , th ou gh it s s ty lis tic influ en ce was st ro ng o n ly in P hi lndc lphia .) With it C h ip pe n dale brilliantl y prom oted hi s cabi net sho p in Sai nt M artin's Lan e; wi th it he ina dve rte ntly, bu t inde lib ly , link ed hi s na me to E ng lis h fu rn itu re in the rococo sty le. In th e m id- ni ne teent h ce nt ury, rococo eng ravings by Lo ck and ot he rs w er e in di scr im in atel y att ri bu ted to him. ? and, to th is day , En gli sh and Am eri can rococo furni ture is popula rly called "Ch ippe nda le."
FIGUHE 3. Design for a carrouche, H. Coplan d, A NCII' Book of Omlll/lCllts (London , 1 7~ 6 : znd ed. ca. 1750) . Engraving on paper, 6% x -l'Y. in. ( 16.X x 12./ cm .). The Metropoli tan Mu seum of Art. Harris Brisbane Dick Fund. 19 25 (25. 20)
Design s for chairs, Th omas Chippendale Til e Gentleman and Cab inet-Mateer's Divcctoi
(London, 17 54), Plate XII Engraving on paper, 13Y2 x X·% in. The Metropolitan Museum of Art
Th e Director offered the m o st co m p lete co d ifica tio n o f th e En gli sh ro co co tast e in furn iture. On th e titl e page o f th e 1754 editio n (see N o . 6), th e aut hor pr esented th ree prin cip al m od es o f de si gn: G othi c, C h inese , a n d M od ern . Th e Go t h ic, a w ho lly British co n t rib u tio n e m p loy ing po inted arc hes , trefoil s, quatrefoil s, and ap plied and clu st er co lu m ns (see N o s . 82 , ISO), w as g ive n imp etu s b y H ora ce Walpole ( 17 17- 1797), who between 1747 and 1776 rebuilt in th e G othi c sty le hi s famou s villa , nam ed Str awb err y Hill, at T wi ckcnharn , Middlesex. The C h inese, w ith its pa godalikc roofs, oriental figures, latticework, an d pi er ced frets , was a ro co co expression of ch ino iserie , the O ccident 's long-runnin g fascin ati on w it h the my st eri ou s E ast (see N os . 51, 102) . Thc third m ode, the M odern, was C h ip pe n da le' s de signation for th e Fren ch ro co co , with it s sc ro lls, she lls, and roc aille, int erpret ed b oth in silve r a n d fu rn itu re w it h s in uo us ca b riol e legs, serpen tine ski rts, and elabora te foli at e carv ing (see N os. 88 , (30). After the b o o k ' s pub lication C h ip pe n da le found h im self th e tar g et o f c ritic ism fr om o t her cra fts me n , wh o cla imed that hi s pl at es. "es pec ia lly t hose after th e Go thic k and C hinese M anner , " we re "so m an y specious Draw in gs, imp o ssi b le to be wo rked. " In his preface to th e edit io n of '762, he hotl y deni ed th at charge. The in t ro d u ct io n o f t he ro co co in En gl and in th e 1730S and 1740S co inc ide d w it h th e unp reced ented ex pa ns io n o f a pr o sp er ou s middle class and it s co nco mi ta nt n eed for fas hion abl e p o ssession s to pro claim an d secu re a n c w , w orth y po siti on in society . Ther e we re n o w t w o di stin ct st ra ta o f ro coco patron s. The fir st wa s th e nobility and land ed ge ntry ,
w ho fav ored th e s t yl e fro m it s in cept ion u n t il the 176 0s, w he n it s n o v elt y was u p stag cd b y th e n e w ly fashionable neo classicism int rodu ced by Robert Ad am . The second wa s th e success fu l m er ch ant s an d tr ad esm en o f Lon do n and the lar ger pr ovin cial cities o f Britain , w ho, o nce th e rococo had b ecom e co d ified, c m b race d it until th e lat e 178 0s, w hen Gcor ge Hep pl cwh ir c a n d Thom as Sh er at on to ok u p th e Adam sty le an d , throu gh p attcrn book s, m ad e it accessible to the newl y rich and respe ctable. It is to that secon d g ro up that one mu st lo ok for par allcl s in the Am eri can e xperi en ce . A New En gl and hi st orian ca m c to rh e sa m e co n cl us io n as ea rly as 1725, w he n h e wrote : " [A ] G entl eman from London w o u ld almos t think him self at horn e at Bost on wh en he ob serves th e numbers of pe ople , th eir H ou se s , th eir Furn itu re , th eir T abl es. th eir Dres s an d Co n ve rsa tio n , w h ic h perhap s, is as sple ndid and sho wy, as th at o f th e m o st co ns ide ra b le Trad esm en in Lon don ." x At th at level o f patron age, th er e was no perceptib le lag bet w een th c rim e a sty le becam e fashi o nable in London and in Bost on (o r Philad el phia). The Am er ican ado ptio n of th e rococo fo cu scd almos t cxcl usively on th e style 's o rna me n ta l m oti fs - sh cll s and rocai llc. sc ro llwo rk. aca n th us lea ves (" ra ffles" ), an d o the r flo ra and faun a . o fte n in as y m rn c t r i ca l co m posi t io ns . Th ese wcr e ent hus ias tica lly applied by m an y leadin g ur ban cra ftsmen to th e arc h itect u ra l int crio rs , eng ra vings , silve r , fu rn ishi ng s. and access ories o f cas t ir on. glass. and po rcelain th at are th e su bjec ts o f thi s s t u dy . Th e ca rl ies t indi cati on s of th e style
pi e , a Lo ck an d Co p la n d d es ig n for an el ab or at e c h irn ne ypiece (N O. 2) co n ta ins a robed o rien ta l figure wi thi n an a rc h ite c t u ra l co m pos itio n su r mo un ted by a canop y o f undul atin g ro caill e . O n th e sid e pl at e of a ca st- iro n s to v e fro m Virginia (No . (62 ), th e sam e figurc is th e cen t ra l elem en t, now st an d ing b ehind a p a rap et o f s im ila r rocai lle . M an y o f th e Lond on pattern books we re reissu ed in 1768 in editions th at h ad imm ed iat el y vi si b le effects in Am e rica; a spandrel desi gn from Lock and Copland 's N CJII B ook of O rnaIIIClltS, for ins ta nce , is found in it s en ti re ty in a h ou se built th at same yea r (see FIG . 10 , p. 24).
oc curred in silve r and cng raving in th e 1740S and in furniture and architec t u re in th e 17 50S. Thou gh lar gely su p plan te d b y neoclassicism b y 179 0 , isol at ed exa m ples of hi gh rococ o date fro m t ha t de cade and even la ter, p arti cul arl y in e ng rave d g lass (s ec N o . (6 8) and K cntu ck y rifl es (see N o s . 7, 9 ) . Amcric an ve rs io ns we rc pattern ed almost exclus ively afte r British exa m ples. A co m mo n culture, st rong tics o f kin ship, an d m er ca nt ile reg u la tio ns th at proh ibit cd th e Am cri can co lo nics fro m tr adin g inde pen dc n tly w i t h o t her n ati on s ma de t h a t a rtis t ic d ep end en ce inev itab le . A b out th e on Iy nota b le o bjects fas hio ne d after Contine n ta l protot ypes were fi rca r m s and g las s wares m adc by G c rm an immi gr ant s, p ri m a ril y in Penn s yl v ani a. Co lo n ia l int crprctati on o f th e s ty le , w h ile a lm o s t a lw ays r ca dil y r eco gni zabl e as suc h, rarc ly strays far fr om th e design s o f th e En gli sh m odel. The diffcre nces arc in m at eri als (seco nd ary woo ds in furnitur e, fo r cxa m pl c) . in so m c ti m cs improvi sat ion al co ns t ruc t io n t cc h n i qu es , an d i n th e indi vidu al h an dlin g o f o rn a rn c n t . Ex ce pt io n s, w he re th e bas ic d esi gn h as bee n tr an sform ed in to a un iqu cl y Am cri can ex press io n , include th e fam ou s Ph il ad elph ia hi gh c h es t (see N o s. 136 - 138 ) an d cas t- iro n stoves (sec Nos . 160 , 16 3) . On cc it leav es th e co lo nia l cities, ro co co o rna me n t tak es o n an cngaging, if untutored, inform alit y (see Nos . 19, 4 5, 57). Th c rococo cro sse d th c Atl ant ic by three prin cip al m ean s: e ng ra ved d csign s in prinrcd ep he m e ra a n d p attern b o ok s. impo rt ed objects , and imm ig rant artisa ns. Becau se th e Sai n t M artin' s Lan e A cad em y in Lond on had no Am crican co unte rpa rt to fost er th e sty le, co lonial int erpreters w er e largely reliant o n im po rt ed design so u rces . Probabl y th e first h a r b in g er s of th e n e w tast e were e p hc me ra in th e form o f bookp lates , bill head s, t rad e ca rds, an d co m m e rc ial paper s. A n Eng lish b o okpl at e wa s lik el y th e o rigin o f th e a rm oria l eng ravin g th at is th e o nly ro co co o rna me nt o n a teap ot dated 174 5 (see FI G . 2 8 , p. 84) -th e ea rl ie s t d o cum ented a p pca ran ce o f th e st y le in Am eri can silver. So me yea rs lat er, Paul Revere m o d eled at least o ne of his t rade cards dir ectl y from a Lond o n pro tot yp e (see Nos. 12 , (3). T he in flue nce of pa tter n boo ks is relat ively easy to tra ce. Bo o k sell er s ' ad vcr risc m cn rs. listin g s of p r i vatc a nd pu bli c lib ra rics , a n d in v c n t o r ies o f es ta tes d ivul g e th e n am es o f vo lum es a va ila b le in Am cr ica. Th e vi su al link is cl earl y demo nstra te d in th e Am eri can o bj ects th at repli cat e o r ada pt des ig n s fro m th o se so urces. Th at sai d , exac t co pyi ng w as not pa rt icularly co m mo n . Th e Di rector w as w ide ly ava ilable, ye t eve n in Phil ad elph ia, site of it s g rca tcs t influen ce, o n ly o ne desig n w as d u plicated in toto : a scroll- foo te d cha ir (No. '4 7) b ased o n Pl a rc x II (N o . I ) o f th e 17 54 ed itio n . Wh en d esi gn s we re faithfull y foll ow cd , thc y we re m ore lik cl y to be sing le mo tifs a rrang ed in fres h co m po sitio ns. Fo r exa m -
2
Design for a chim ney piece (detail) M. Lock and H . Co pland A N CII' Book oj O rnaments (London, 17 52) Engraving on paper, 9 % x 7 in. The Metropolitan Museum of Art
5
O n 5 Decembe r [774. J oh n No rman (ca . 1748- [SI7). an engrave r recen tly arr ive d fro m London , adve rtised "Proposals for P rintin g b y s u bscr ip t io n , th e A m eri can edit io n of Swa n's Br it ish Ar chit ect. " 'J Th e vo lume, w it h sixty folio co pper plat es, was ava ilable th e foll o wing June, published by Rob ert Bell , th en Phil ad elphi a' s lead in g pr inter and bookse ller. The firs t arc hitec t ura l b oo k eve r pr inted in A m eri ca. it was a faith fu l co py o f Ab rah am Swan 's British Architect: Or, the Bui lder's Tr easury (~r S tair-Cases, o rig ina lly pu bl ished in Lond on in [74 5 (w he n Lo ck an d Co p lan d we re in th ei r in venti ve pri m e) an d rei ssu ed three tim es. It s popu lar it y in th e co lo nies (see pp . [8- 21) , w he re it was m or e influentia l on Am eri can arc h itec t ure th an C h ip pe nda le was o n Am er ican fu rn itur e, und oubtedl y in spired N orm an 's co py. T he A merican ed itio n w as m ark et ed to su bsc ribe rs in adva nce, as such publi cati on s w er e in London. N orm an 's illu st ration s, w hic h h e tr aced o n to h is cop per pl at es directl y f rom pages in a Lond on ed it io n (N o . 3), are ske tc h ily ren d e red in reve rse (N o . 4) and printed o n t h in ne r pap er ; in execu ting them , he used an etc he r's needl e rather th an an engrave r's bu rin . At th e o u t b rea k of th e R e v oluti on, N o r m an was at wo rk o n a t least t w o ot he r vo lu mes of t he sa me size a nd w ith th e same number o f illu strati on s as T he British Architect, The fir st was Swan 's Co llection <1 Designs in Archi tcaurc, o nly ten pl at es o f w h ic h we re p r odu ced. Th e seco nd was Th e Gc ntlcnian awl Cab inet-Ma ker's Assistant. Of th e latter, on ly the " P ro posa ls " fo r it s publ icati on we re ever pri n ted (N o . 5), b ound into so me co pies o f th e N orm an-B ell edi tion of Th e British A rchitect. The text o f th e pr op osals, da ted 2 0 J une 1775, bear s m ore th an a passin g resemblan ce to th e titl e page o f th e fir st ed itio n o f C hi p pen da le's D irector (N o . 6). W hat was p roposed was evi de n tly a co m plete Am erican C hippendal e. Bell was to hav e been th e publish er an d th e ingenious Phil ad elphi a ca b inet ma ke r J ohn Fol w el l (d . 17 86) was to hav e pr o vided th e designs. When th e publica tion was interrupted b y wa r, Fol w ell turn ed hi s hand to othe r ve h icles of artistic ex press io n , suc h as militar y flags (see n c . 4, p. 14). T he rococo also arrived in th e N e w Worl d in th e form o f imported goods , w he ther specifica lly ordered by co lonists fo r th eir own use or for resa le . Eng lish wa res, highl y prized sy m bo ls of soc ia l po s it ion , pl a yed a m aj o r ro le in g ui di ng Am er ican tast e. Imp o rt ed fu rn it ure an d si lver , along wi th t ablcwa rcs , tex tiles , and pa pe r han g in gs (wa llpa pe rs), were not at all u ncomm on in afflue n t hou seh olds. The A m erican. m ad e objects t ha t are th e subjects of this bo o k ex isted harm oni ou sl y w ith Eng lish co unter pa rts in co lo nia l ho m es and we re u n do u b ted ly ju d g ed on t heir s im ila ri ty to Lon d o n exa m p les . T he d eci sion w he t he r to pur ch ase Eng lish or Am eri can goods was based not o n ly on fash io n but also o n pr acti cal co nsi de ra tio ns. An ythin g o rdered fro m England
""u l .1
3
Desig n for a chim ncy piecc. Abraham Swan The British Architect (London. [745). Plate I.l Engraving on paper. [3% x HI/, in. The Metro politan Museum of Art
6
took from ten m onth s to a yea r to arrive , an d co st w as an ad ded fac tor. Benj amin Fra nk lin, w ho pri or to th e Revolutio n spe n t muc h of his tim e in Lond on as re p rese nta tive o f t he Penn syl v an ia A sse mbl y an d as spo kes ma n for co lo n ia l rig ht s , recei v ed a lett er from h is so n Willi am in Oc to be r 177 2 tha t illus tra tes ho w suc h choices we re m ad e: C a prn . Wi llia m s b ro ught over wi t h him from Engla nd so m e Ma ho gany C hairs w ith H air Bottom s, w hic h cos t him abo ut 22S . St erli ng a Piece , and 3 S . Sterl ing a Piece for M atts , pack in g an d Frieg h t to Ph ilada. I wa n ted th e Wo rkm en here to make me a Dozen li ke them , b ut th o ' Mahog any is considerab ly cheape r her e tha n in Engla nd, I co u ld not ge t any o ne to un de rtake to m ake th em und er 55-'. Cur rency a Piece, and th e y would p ro bably no t be so well finished . I sha ll th e refo re be ob lige d to yo u if yo u wo uld sen d me a Dozen o f suc h kind of C hairs , m ad e in a fash ionable Tas te. . . . P.S . Since W ritin g th e above, I have agreed w ith a Wo rkman for th e C hairs, so yo u need no t send rhem .!"
D es pit e a co ns idera b le t rad e in Eng lis h furni shin g s an d accessories, few E ng lis h pieces survive wi th th eir Am eri can his to ries. T ho ug h that h amp er s direct lin ka ge with Am er ica n objects, a few id entifi abl e rel at ion ship s ex is t. Am on g th em are Paul Rev er e's co ffee pot fo r a Salem client, unmistaka b ly in fl ue nced b y a n En gli s h pot o f sim ila r d esi gn alre ady ow ne d th e re (see Nos . 4 6 , 4 7 ) ; a n E ng lis h c ha i r , dem on st rabl y the p ro to ty pe for a Boston ex am ple (see N os. 10 0, IOI); and im ported pi cture fram es th at inspired sim ilarly ca rved A m e rican frames wi thi n th e sa me set o f famil y port rai ts (see Nos . 103, 104 ) . While no spec ific Eng lis h o bjects can be singl ed o u t as m od els, essays in Am eri can porcelain were un argu abl y pat te rned o n imported wa res w ith w h ich th ey strugg led to co m pe te (see N os. 169, 170) . The th ird mea ns b y w hich th e roco co was introduced to Am erica, and by far th e m o st important, was th e spec ialized imm igra n t a rtisans re q uire d to execu te th e o rna me n ta l int ricacies of th e sty le . Th e Eng lis h g u ild sys te m, with it s rigo rou s ap pren tices hip, provide d th e ne cessar y schooling in eng ravi ng a n d ca rvi ng a nd in the chas ing an d pier cin g o f si lver, b u t ins t r uctio n in th o se specia lties w as n ot re adil y co m e by in t he co lo n ies . In th e 175 05 a n d 17 (,0 5, a ve ri ta b le
wave of highl y ski lled and ambitio us yo ung cra ftsme n, m ost of t hem Lond on tra ined, e m igra ted to Am e rica, drawn b y t he de ma nd for th eir ab ilities an d b y o p po rt u nities for per so na l and social ad vance me nt. T he ir effec t o n th e co lo nial arts w as analogo us to th at o f the Hu gu en ot s' arr iving in Eng land nearl y a cent u ry before: a d rama tic i m p rove me n t in sty lis t ic co nsc io us ness a n d craftsm ansh ip. T he fin est Am eri can rococo eng rav ings came from th e han d s o f Englis h - t ra ined engravers (see No s. 2 1, 32), an d the superio r qu alit y of Phil adelph ia rococo furni t ure
4 D esig n for a chim ney piece J oh n Norm an, afte r Abr ah am Swa n T he British A rchitect (Philadelphia, 177 5), Plate u Engraving o n paper, 13% x 8'h in . T he M etropolitan Museum of Art
7
, PHILADELr Hl A.
l'
R '0
P
0
FOI' rR I NT I NG
",
J I,I'IC! 101h ,
SAL
177S.
S,
SUDS CR I P T, -J.?N,
T H I!
G E N T L E MAN
GEN T L E MAN
AS
A ND
CAB l iN E T - M A i<: E R ' s AS S 1 S T
n
C AB I NE T- M A K E R's
DIRECTOR.
A NT.
1I f.I N G
A great Variety of Ufcful and Orn amental
CO
L
L
A
L _o\ R G t·:
o N
C T
Ii.
HO U S HOLD F U RN ITU RE ; n.
Irhlt
T he
''' Of ,n.,I,."J . ,I,' ., ... ..1, of
DR;\\OI lo; O.
CO
I,
TilE
N
t.e rKIl'iTI·.P
,II
T
o
l'i
...
Elegant and Ufefiil D eligus of Houihold'Furniture GOT H iC, C H INESE und MOD ERN TASTE : InUu.linlt . SlUt
S.
I'IO~e~frl~·p~:n:lTo~:'7~1:':;~I~·;:~:? :~~~t~ ~:~ISI'~~:~;~p~~jf~~elj~'
T Hl El _l h ll ' DII I D . ul SUlle Run •• a' t plu (cd til CoIoIDITU, lOl. the \\ ~ R Jt will be enb' n ed an d put 10 1' l r:Si ,
of
LIB:A~o\~I~ \~~;~ ~~6~~iLES,
I
nUROES, DREAKf AST _T ARLES. DRESSING 10Ild ( 'III !·M-TABLES. n UNA-CASES, II Al\'GIN G· SHEl.VES,
1 " IEIl -G LASS SCONCES SLAB F U \1ES BRACKETS, C..... 'l'DL W T ANUS • CLOCK_CASI:::S, FRE TS. •
P, mljj J..,, /Ii.
AND
a
III. FIfT EE N' SHI.I. LIXGS ~dunct', bt'ing the lirA Pen of lhe SUR'CllII' TIOII_ t~N~ ~~~~::: b:~V~tlr;b.i~:~~i. Subfcnbi ng, Inti T i li RT Y. fI YF. SH II.~
1\'., AI foon II
\"~. ll TY
BOOK-CASE S f.... L II . A R l tl od·ti"~I'" ~ TE A_CHESTS, TRAYS, FIR E-SCRI:::ENS
C AIlINE T· M AKE R·, AUUHIIT, will O ne Ilr~ F. /" Volume, eonu ining Tw o H undred and
J\~'~/I~le~~~ l::'k~U::.l~ ~1' :~~d :~l le~u~~ T Y SIJILLl S C;S
'
s..... 1 ,1.,
II.-lcool~ '"""_ D. .. . . .. ,kt- Ij ..,.....1 ..
c.,,...-I'loon.
D
m::;n~ Et,:tA N
wilh
T~.
are by the inl:t'fli~u, J O HN FO LWELL, C.lbinel·~~ker ; and th e E l
RN
A
~~:;~is ~"7L~~Ti?:~~~~EDS. '
OT Hl:R
MEN
T
&
T O WH tCIi I S P RE F IXED,
A Short EX PLA NAT IO N of the Five O RD ER S of AR CI HT ECT UR E, and RULE S of PER S P ECT I VE;
lPPloKoflhe fli
\ ' . T ht N.lme:tof we SUISCI.IUJ. . 10 this ure(ul WO RK will be print ed,
t7
S.U Il~ C R l r TI O z.; s
PIVf~' D I R ~ CT
are gntefally received
10 :01 f.." execut ing, th... ~I(lR diffic uh Pi",," . l ilt MouldinS' bdn g ah1>iIo.l nw~, ""d the l>irnt nhmu w ex h U ' l l G If (~ibuI :
lIy the CHO.....VU , J Oli N NO R:\-1Ai'l. at his Shop in Slcc:J.StrNt.
Til t
The OI.oI")oIU , JOH N I'O L\ VELL, CoJ6i1ll1- M../;,,.. in F,~"t.Srr'
:II
the Sit " of lh e C I\ .I'l ~T .l R I . I-J;\L L , FDurtb-Slrttt .
Calc ubl~
' " impn:m; anJ rcfilll' Ib.. prof""1 "f A' T. .....1 (uilN I" 1M f..,
1'",funl ;ll all Dq;tn:, of w r...
RO BE RT BEL L, Pr;,,' rr lrId Bodfi lltr, in'fl·irJ-Strtd, PIl IL;\DILr HI.....
{
wn c r. a CO 'l r Rl!ll f SD I!I) IN
One Hundred and Sixty COP PER-PL AT ES, neatly Eogravcd,
W ILLlA :\1 C REE-'l, ~filf"JUld lJ~U.iIlJtr. in :\" IW _ ¥O l l\..
D,,!l i1'it ,,~ilr.fl '
·RO BERT . Qd W IL LI A:\-I UAlle LAY, Slm.N,p"" in BAL1' 1~O.J.l.
L~Jm ·i.
And by RoDP-RT WELLS. B_ fi lJn ,
IIY. 1·f4ft I'''~.
f!«it ... J,uil f:t
T H OiVIAJ'
i QCH ;\ J.t u 1' OW", SoU TU . C .UOLlM .. ,
0 .. I D.
1~1"rI;r~r.
u
W lL Ll A:\-1 A IK M A.~ , IJ.ljtPtr. ill AMlfAr OLI1.
-
H Oi .
-'--'- ' - - ' --
--
C H I P P EN D A L E
o f St. MAR T I N ' s- LAN E. C A B I N E T_ M A K E R.
'
L O N D ON. Pri nl6{ fur 1M AUT HO It, "Kl (old at hi. H (Jwe in St. M A R T I ~ · .. J. '\
lokli:U"., in Holbon'l R. Suu, Prim· S"H. nrll' ~""h"",bnl~:t. II()L*, III It.. S.nn
AJ~ by T . Oll"on , Jk><,kf.II...,
ftlk., ill Fkttlh.....
M.U",
5
Proposals fo r Printino hy S ubscription Th e Ge ntleman and C al,illct-!Vlakcr's A ssistallt (Philadelphia, 1775) Printed pap er , 16 '12 x 9 '12 in . Aver y Libr ar y. Columbia Uni versit y
HAO" "'''~
J.
.00
B AU C H
t""
6 Thomas C hip pendale
Til e G entleman and C aIJillet-Makcr's Director (Lo nd on . '754). titl e page Pr int ed pap er. '7'/4 x II '/Hin , The M et ropolitan Mu seum o f Art
don as to each o t he r. Th eir adop ti ng t he rococo style was th er efo re a res u lt m ore o f th eir ties to Eng land t h an to one
is attributa b le to th e num er ou s forei gn ca b ine t ma ke rs an d carvers worki ng in t h at city (see pp. 182-84) . Th e id entit y and co ntri b u tions of im mig ra n t silvers mi t hs are h ard e r to t race, since m o st of th em wo rked under an American m ast er smit h's m a r k , b ut t heir in fl ue nce is a pparen t n ot o n ly in hig h- rococo o bjects th at would have dema nde d th eir participatio n b ut also in th e v ar iou s n e w s p ap er re fe re nces to fo reign- trained assis ta n ts wo rki ng in th e grea t urban centers (see pp . 74-78). M o reo ver, to launc h ind us trial pr oduction o f fine tabl e g lass and p o rcel ain , en t re p re ne u rs h ad to brin g ex pe rienced wo rkmen over from abroad (see pp. 229 - 34). Craftsmen re lied on t he pa tronage of wea lthy city dwellers w ho made it th eir b usi ness to kee p cur re n t w it h London fashion. T hey included m an y of th e mos t pr ominent fam ilies of each r egi on : in N e w E ng la n d, th e Apth orp s, Derb ys, Fane ui ls, H an co ck s, an d Lees; in N ew York , th e Beekm an s, Co rnells, Sc huy lers, Van Ren ssclacr s, an d Verp lan ck s: in Ph il ad elph ia and ne ig h bori ng M a r yland , th e Cad wa ladcr s , C hews, Dicki nso ns, and Ga lloways. A s a class, they we re well ed uca ted and widely t raveled, and th ey took g rea t p rid e in th e furni shin g of th eir hou ses. In 1764 , Benjamin Fr ankl in began to build a new hou se in Philadelp h ia . T he n e xt year, fr o m Lo nd on , t he bu sy dipl om at atte nde d to every detail of the interiors him sel f. In letter s to h is wi fe, De bo ra h , h e bom barded h e r wi th qu est ion s an d inst r uctions: "Let m e h a v e th e B readth of th e P ier , th at I may ge t a ha n d so m e G lass fo r t h e Pa rlo ur."" A n d agai n, "T he bl ue M oh air S t uff is for th e C u rta ins o f th e Blu e C ha mbe r. The Fas hio n is to m ake o ne C ur ta in o n ly for eac h Wi ndow."12 In the abse nce of b an k s and stock ma rke ts , rea l es ta te and ho u seh o ld possessio ns (es pecia lly silver) were favo re d inves tmen ts, represent in g a far lar g er per centag e o f tot al asse ts than wo u ld be custo ma ry t od a y. W he n wea lt hy P hi ladelp hian J ohn Cadwala de r we n t o ff to fight with th e Revolutio nar y fo rces, he took care to sec ure th e m agnifi cent furn is h ings (see N o s. 153- (56) of hi s Seco n d St ree t hou se. Cadwa lader ac te d th rou gh o ne of h is frie nds, J asp er Yeat es, of Lancaste r, w ho was in Phil ad elphi a at th e tim e an d w ho sen t ins truc tio ns to his wife by p ost : " C ol. J ohn Ca dwalade r has req uested Leave of m e to sto re a part of hi s m ost valu ab le Fu rni ture in o ur H ou se. If it sho uld co me up to yo u in m y Ab sen ce, yo u w ill please to h ave it pu t up in th e Ga rre t & have th e Room lock ed up . "' 3 Only in an d aro un d th e m aj or cities we re th e necessar y ingredie n ts in pl ace to cu lt iva te th e develo pme n t of a n American ro co co sty le: design s, patrons, artisans, and m at erials. T he m ost fert ile areas o f Am erican rococo des ig n w er e Bo st on , N ew Yo rk , Phil adel ph ia, and C ha rles to n, all sea ports and all lin ked as clos ely (pe rha ps m ore close ly) to Lon-
ano ther. B y th e ro co co e ra Bo st o n was en te ri ng th e tw iligh t of her co lo nia l dom in an ce. Economic reversa ls and competitio n with N e w York an d Ph ilad el ph ia combined to a r res t h er grow th, and th ou gh wea lthy Bost on m er chan ts certainly did indul g e in ro coc o excesses, th e city's ex pression of t he tas te was as a w ho le th e m ost co nserva tive of the four u r ban cen te rs . N ew York was th e seco n d lar g est co lo n ia l ci ty and a Lo yalist stro ng ho ld durin g the Revol ut ion ; w he n th e British re lin q uis hed th e ci ty in 17 83 , a th ird of t he popu la tion evacua t ed w i t h th em . A lar g e pe rcentage of New Yo rk ' s ro co co crea t io ns we re d o u btl ess re m o v ed by depa rting Lo y ali st s o r d est ro y ed in th e di sast ro u s fires t ha t accompani ed th e occu pa tio n o f th e ci ty . No netheless, surviving exa m p les d em on st r at e a highl y cos mo po li tan rococo co nscious ness. Co nc u rre ntly, Ph iladelphi a was just reac hing th e apogee o f her ascenda ncy and wea lth . The largest city in the co lo n ies, h er pr o sp erit y and cu lture a ttrac ted immigran t cr aft sm en uniquel y qu alifi ed to provide rococo ornament to her rich est citizens. P redi ct abl y, th e city becam e th e Athens of Am eri ca an d th e ar bi ter of th e new sty le . C ha rlesto n, b y virtu e of her agricu lt ura l t rad e w ith G rea t Britain , was also th riv in g . T he inte rio rs of her hou ses exemplified the rococo fas hio n as mu ch as th o se in Phil ad el ph ia , t h o u gh C ha rlestonian s we re far m ore reli ant o n im po rte d goo ds. The few surviv ing exa m p les o f lo call y mad e ro co co furni ture and silver nev erthel ess sugges t th at th e city cultivated sop his ticate d domesti c interp ret ati o ns o f th e sty le. Th e Am eri can rococo develop ed in de pend entl y in eac h o f th e four citi es, so me t imes wi t h a disti ncti ve regiona l c ha rac ter. In e ng ra vi ngs an d si lver, impo rted examples, m o stl y o f sta nda rd form s, w er e w ide ly ava ilab le and h ighl y in fl ue n t ia l o n d om esti c d esi gn s; lo cal in t e rp ret at ion s are lim it ed . Far less fu rn iture, ho w ever, came into th e co un try, an d what d id vari ed fr om city to city . In Bo ston, fo r exa m ple , wh er e im m ig ra n t craftsmen were n ot welco me d, a n isol at ed o bject was m ore lik ely to set a lo cal style (see N os. 100, 10 1) . By con t ras t, Philad elphia, whe re Lo n do n pa tte rn b o oks an d foreig n- t ra ine d artisa ns held swa v. was fa r less impressed by Eng lish- ma de furnishings. Th e d e velopm ent of th e ro co co sty le in Am er ica m u st be exa m ined in th e co ntex t of th e pol iti cal clim at e, since th e fashion for th e new tast e co inc ide d w ith a dram ati c cha nge in rel ati on s b etween Eng la n d an d h er Am e rica n co lo n ies. The gove rn me n t 's laissez-faire attit ude throu gh out the fir st half o f t he eig h tee n th cen tury , when suc h inco nveniences as restri cti v e tr adin g regul ati on s we re d is cr eetl y ign ored , co n trib uted to co lo nia l p ro sp erity and a sense o f autono my.
9
.._
--
...- -
..
-
-----_.-
e "'~ ~ ~-
7
Flintlocl: rijtc, [ 8 12 - 2 0 J acob Kuntz, Phi ladel phia Maple, iron. br ass. and silver , L.: 591/4 in. Th e Met ro politan Mu seu m of Art
Th e Fr en ch an d Indi an Wa r ( [754- ° 3), durin g w hich British fo rce s we re e m p loye d in co lo nia l d efen se at cons iderable ex pe nse t o th e E ng lis h gove rn me nt, i rrevo cab ly alte red th o se co n ditio ns . Wh en th e w ar en d ed, cab ine t m inis ter s in Lond o n so ug h t to rees ta b lis h th eir au tho rit y a nd, by th e im pos itio n o f tariffs, to ex trac t revenu e fo r pay me nt of war debts. q Wh at foll o w ed w as a se ries of eve nts th at inexor ably led th e co lo nists to revolution . Th ey ran ged from t he Sugar A ct of [7°4 , w h ic h br ou ght in tr ain e n la rged custom s restricti on s, to th e Sta m p A ct of 17° 5, in st ituted to payoff wa r debts by taxin g th e co m me rc ial do cum ents and publication s of m er ch ants an d lawye rs w ho voc ifero us ly opposed th e act and forced it s rep eal, to th e Townshe nd Acts, whi ch in [70 7 impo sed duties o n im po rted glass, lead, pain t, paper, an d tea, all, e xce pt for th e last, British m ad e. T hose events se rved to stim ulate d om esti c m anu factures but also brought abo ut th e fir st reg io na l non importati on ag ree ment, w hereby a Bo st o n to wn m eet in g d etermined n ot to purch ase certain im po rte d w ar es, in cludin g " Ho use ho ld Furn iture, W rou g ht Plat e of all So rts, C h ina War e. "1 5 A g ro u ndswe ll of p ubl ic su ppo rt for t he b o y cott o f British goo ds pe rsuaded an ev er inc reas ing circle o f ur ban m erch ants into bindin g non impo rta tio n ag ree me n ts: in Bost on an d Ne w York , in [70 8-70 ; in Phil adelphia, in [709-70 ; and in C ha rlesto n, in [7° 9-71.
[0
from London o r elsewhe re, o the rw ise w ill requi re no pay. "'7 Th o se effo rts a t factor y pr odu ct ion o f lu x ur y goo ds o n whi ch ro co co decorati on co uld be em p loyed m et w ith stagge ring rev erses when th e nonim portati on ag ree me n ts w er e rep ealed foll owin g th e w ithdrawa l of th e duties impo sed b y th e Town sh end A ct s- all exce p t the dut y o n rc a . Th e co lo nists reacted to that fin al o ut rage by stagi ng th e Bo ston Tea Part y, and revolution w as in evitabl e.
T he ag ree me n ts . w h ic h we re a na t he ma to m er ch ant s w ho reli ed o n tr ad e fo r their liveliho od but a boon to lo cal crafts men co m pe ting wi th British imports, ignited efforts to estab lish a fu ll pan opl y o f d om est ic ind us tries - w hat mi ght be ca lle d a "Bu y Co lo n ial" ca m pa ig n. In 1769, uph ol st erer Pl unk er Flc cson an no u nce d hi s " Am er ican Pap er H an gin gs, M anu factured in Phil adelphia, o f all kinds and co lo urs, not inferio r to th o se ge ne ra lly imported; an d as lo w in pr ice. " 1(, T ha t same yea r, in M anheim, Penn sylvania, Henry Will iam Stiegel fo u n de d hi s Am eri can Flint Gl ass M anufa ctory (see p. 229) ; a year late r, in Phil ad elphia, th e partner s Bonnin and M orris es ta b lishe d th eir C hi na M anufactory (see p. 234) . In 1774, J ohn H ewson o f th at city o pe ne d a "Calicoe Printing M anu fact or y, " promi sin g that "his wo rk sha ll be eq u al in co lo u r, and w i ll s ta n d was h ing, as w ell as a ny import ed
The w ar, with it s sac rifices and pri vati on s, effect ively a rres te d furth er d evel opm ent o f th e Am e ri can r o co co , th ou gh it did n ot sig na l th e introdu cti on o f a repl acem ent style. As securel y dated exa m ples impl y, w ha tever o rna me ntal goods were m ade in Am eri ca du rin g th e wa r years m us t h a ve b een ro co co (see N o s . 60 , 93, 9 4) . Whil e th er e we re s p o r ad ic e x p ress io ns o f roco co de si gn afte r in de pendence
8
Pair ,1j1illtlock pistols,
181 2 - 2 0
J acob Kuntz, Phil ad elphia M apl e, iro n, brass, an d silve r, L. : 14 Y4 in. Pri vat e co llec tion
II
w as achieve d. th e sty le had lost ten yea rs to th e Revol ut io n ; in th e 1780s, w ith th e es ta b lis h me n t o f a ne w co un try. th e rococ o ga ve w ay to neocl assicism . Durin g the glo rio us years o f its reign. the rococo sty le. w ith it s ornamental n ature. was firmly alig ne d with th e decorati ve a rt s. It s principal Am eri can expression s- ar chit ectu ral carving . eng raving s, silve r, and furniture- ar e full y ex plo red in the cha pte rs th at foll o w , as a re dom esti c effo rts to m anufactur e cast ir on. g lass , and porcelain . Oth er m anifest ation s, while out of the m ainstream (fire arms . for exa m ple . or the now e xtremely rare e xamp les of te xtil es) , mu st not be overlooked , sinc e th e y illu strate the ro co co' s per vasi ve nature. Fir earms repr esent b oth the a r t s o f th e e ng rave r a nd carver , th e onl y obj ect s th at do . The Am eri can flintl o ck , o r lon g. rifle, better kn own today as th e Kentu ck y rifl e. was a distinctive form o f wea po n b ased on Europ ean hunt in g pi ece s. Ex ampl es w er e bein g m anufactured in Am eri ca b y mid-centur y . but o n ly afte r th e Revolution wa s an y attention g ive n to th eir ca rve d an d en graved o rna me nt at io n . T he m ajority of Kentu ck ys havin g rococo decorati on we re made in Penn sylv ania b etw een 1780 and 1820 b y g u n s mi ths o f G erm an or Swiss descent . but o t he rs w er e produ ced in Virginia and th e C aro linas . I X On e of the Penn s ylv ani a m aster g u ns mi t hs was J aco b Kunt z ( 1780- 1870) . 13 0rn in Lehi gh Co u n ty, he pro b abl y served his apprenticeship in Phil adelphia. Between 1799 and 1811 he practiced hi s c raft in hi s n ative co u n ty; in 1812 he lo cated in Phil ad elphi a . A rifl e repres ent ati ve o f hi s b est work (N o . 7), signed "J. Kuntz" on top of th e br eech , ha s a cu rly maple stock orn amented with self-contained rococo motifs . The c he e k , or left, sid e (see d et ail ) h as t w o ca rtou ch es flankin g an e ngra v ed silver eig h t- po in te d s tar. Th ough ca rv ed in low relief, ba sicall y sy m me t rica l in d esi gn . an d wrou ght fr om a hard , un yi eld in g w oo d . th e y have a liv el y and ex p ress ive v igo r. The lo ck . or rig h t, sid e (see det ail) is cut o u t with a pat ch bo x, used fo r storing w addin g a n d other p a raph ern ali a for lo adin g th e wea po n . Its hin ged br ass cover wi th pier ced and eng ra ved side plates is a feature uniqu e to Am eri can rifle s. but th e p la te s' scroll s. inh abit ed b y eag les . lion s. a nd hum an allus ion s, a re an en ch antin g pro vin cial echo o f the Eu ropean rococo . Am eri can g u ns m it hs m ad e pi stol s as we ll as ri fles . th ou gh far le ss fr equ entl y . A p air of p ist ol s (N o . 8) b y Kunt z ar e in scribed "Ph ilad a. " and "J. Ko on s " (th e lat ter . t wi ce). a spe lling th at m ay hav e been An gli cized to su it th e Phil adelphia mark et. Th e o rig ina l own er. howeve r . w as a Ge rma n- A m er ican fr om Lehi gh Town ship. N orth amp ton
9
Flintlock rijle, ca. ' 790 Simon Lauck. Winchester. Virginia Maple. iron. brass. and silver. L.: 60 '/2 in. Private collection
12
10
A rms of the Flowcrjamilv, 1765 Elizabeth Flower, Philadelphia Embroide ry on silk, mahogany frame, 111/2 x 1231. in. Collection of Mr. and Mrs. Edwa rd J. Nusrala
a re n ot e w orth y for th eir ro co co orna me n t. Need lework form ed an imp ortant part of a yo ung gi rl's ed uca tio n . M a rria geabl e dau ghter s in well-to-do fami lies we re ex pe cte d to exce l in fan c y sti tc h ing as a mea ns o f imp ressi ng eligib le su ito rs. Eli zab eth Flower ( 174 2- 178 I ) co m p leted an ex quisitel y em broide red silk needl ew o rk pic ture (N o . 10) in 176 5, at the age o f twent y-th ree; I~ her sister, An n , made a sim ilar pi cture in 17 6 3 . 20 Eliza beth and A nn we re t he d au ghter s of th e Phil ad elphi a j oin er Enoc h Flowe r ( 170 5- 177 3) a n d hi s w ife, Ann (b. ' 17(1). Both siste rs ' pi ctures di spl ay th e ar ms o f th e Flower fa mi ly of Phil ad elphi a in a la v ish rococo surround p robabl y co pied directl y from an ar morial eng raving, a n d bo t h were wo r ke d in th e m o st elega n t n eed le w o rk m ateri al s : s il k thread, as we ll as go ld and silve r me ta llic thread s, o n crea m silk m oire. The cip he r o f Eliza be th 's in iti als at th e base of th e desig n wa s cop ied fro m A Ne ll' B ook ofC yphers, a boo k commonly referred to in th e co lo nies . 21
Co u n ty, w hose na me, Geo rge N agle , is eng rave d o n eac h p ist ol. The p ai r m us t h a v e been m ad e in Phil adelphi a not lon g afte r th e g uns m it h m o ved th ere in 1812. The barrels are brass, t he stoc ks a re cu rly m apl e, an d ro co co o rna me n t is limit ed to eng raved brass an d silve r co rn uco p ias above the trigger s and eng raved and chased silve r m ounts o n th e butts. A rifle (N o . 9) marke d a ll th e breech by Simo n Lau ck , o f W in ch est e r , V ir gini a , ex hi b its th e sa me voca b u la ry of desig n m otifs used b y Kuntz, but in a lighter and m or e delica te an d un ifi ed co m pos it io n . On th e c hee k s ide o f the stock, carve d scro lls, sha llow and sinuo us, flo w unimped ed into elega nt silve r-wi re inl ays en circlin g a silver star. O n th e lock side, th e pat ch-bo x co ver is eng raved wi th eq ua lly delicate rococo patt erns. Wh ile no fin e wea v ing indu stry exis te d in America for th e productio n o f rococo-patterned silks, a few domest ic textiles
13
FIGUHE 4 . S tandard of the Philadelphia L i.~ht Horse, 1775. Jo hn Fol w ell and J am es C lay poole. Philadelphia. Paint ing o n silk. 33 x 4 0 in. (83.8 x 10 1.(i cm .). First T ro op Ph iladelphi a Ci ty Cavalry
An o th er isol at ed su rv iva l o f a supe rb Am e ri can ro co co textile is th e lar ge an d impressive sta n dard o f th e Phil ad elphia Light H orse t ro op (FIG. 4), datin g fro m 1775, th e fin est A mer ica n Re v ol ut ion ar y flag in exis te nce. A s tan da rd, o r "colors," se rved to id ent ify a part icul ar m ilita ry unit . " The Revo lu tio na ry s ta n da rds we re ge ne ra lly of s ilk, w h ic h u nfu rle d eas ily in a br eeze , of a so lid co lo r p ainted or embroidere d wi t h ap pro p ria te sy m bols and emble ms. Th e rococo part of th e Light H o rse stan da rd is its central her aldi c carto uchc, strongly asy m me trical and co m posed o f adjoining C-scro lls, w h ich encloses a cen t ra l go lde n kn ot ti ed of thirteen radi atin g ribbon s, sy mbolizing th e united co lo nies. The allegorica l figures of Fame and Am erica (the latter. an Indi an wit h a lib ert y ca p o n a pol e; see also Nos. 34 , 55) flan k th e shield, wi th its cres t of a horse's head over w hich th e tr oop 's initials are in te rt win ed in ro co co st yl e . A sc ro ll ing m orr o ri bbo n b el o w t he ce n tra l e mb le m is em blazo ne d w it h the phrase FOR T IIESE WE STR IVE. The sta ndard survives fro m a pair co m m issio ned in 1775 for th e m ounted tr o op b y its first co m ma nding o ffice r, Ca pta in Ab rah am M arko e. T he o rig ina l bill s for th e t w o do cume n t Ph il ad elph ia desig ne r j ohn Fol w ell as th e cra fts ma n w ho was p aid I: 1-15 fo r "Dra w in g & D es ign in g th e Cou lo urs fo r th e Ligh t H orse" and j am es C lay poo le, o f th e same city , as th e artisa n w ho ea rned 1:8 fo r " pa int ing, gildin g & silve r ing a Device , Union & M otto on 2 C o lo urs for the Troop of Light H orse. " ' 3 Besides bein g a rare inst an ce o f th e rococo in Am er ican text iles, th e sta nda rd . in it s painted decoration, rep resents a typ e o f rococo o rna me nt, o nce co m m on , th at has bee n almos t e n ti re ly lo st. Sim ila r rococo ca rto uc hes decora ted sh ips , sho p sig ns , ca r riages, and fir e buckets . The acco un ts o f j ohn Ca dwala de r in clude an en try for a d o zen fi re bu ck et s C lay poo le p ainted in 1771, w hic h were doubtless rococo in dcsign .:':' Bet w een 17 50 an d 177 5, th e rococo was th e d omin ant sty le in A merica. It is disce rni b le as ea rly as th e m id -1740S an d t races of it rem ain lon g afte r 1775. Pattern ed re.solutely afte r Eng lis h exa m ples, th e Am eri can ro co co was virtu all y re s tricte d to u r b an areas w here p atr on ag e, cra fts ma ns hip. a nd p rosper ity pe r m it te d it s fl o w erin g . A s o ne wo u ld ex pec t. Britain's m aj or wes te rn co lo nies atte m p ted to em ulate London fashio n as fully as possibl e. In thi s, th ey"d iffered littl e fro m suc h o t he r pr o vin cial satellites as Du blin o r Edinburg h . Fo reig n cra ftsme n , Eng lish eng ra vings, and imported fu rnis h ings fost er ed th e sty le in th e co lo n ies. N onimport ation ag reeme n ts brie fly enco uraged the m anu facture o f local pro d uc ts. but the s ty le wo u ld un d ou bt edl y ha v e enjoyed fulle r m at ur it y th ro ug ho ut Am eri ca if th e im per ial-colo nia l con flicts had been resol ved peaceabl y. L GB, MIIII
15
ARCHITECTURE
Not all arc hitec t ura l de corati on in th e rococo style was o f ca rv ed woo d . St ucco is ts co u ld g ive a sim ilar effec t in plast er , and uphol ster er s. w hose activi ties ran ged beyond th e mere covering o f furniture, co uld pr o vid e inex pe ns ive imi tati ons m ad e o f papi er-rn ach e (p ape r pulp p ressed in m old s). Few exa m p les o f ro co co - st yl e wa ll decora tio n s u r viv e in stucco (p las te r), but a numb er o f plas te r- or pa pie r- rnacheo rna me n te d cei lings rem ain in tac t -on ly a sugges tio n of w ha t w as an acce p te d feature o f th e p arl ors an d e n tra nce h all s o f th e m o st fashi on abl e h ou ses o f th e Re v oluti on ar y era. Least well represented in tw entieth-century surviva ls is th e o nc e- u b iq u ito us painted interi or woodwor k, usua lly gra ine d and marbl eized , th ou gh rococo o rna me nt painted o n pan elin g o r plast erwork, kn o wn tod ay in o n ly o ne V irgi nia exa m ple, w as probabl y not un comm on . Another pr o vin ce o f the uphol st er er- on e closely link ed w ith papicr-machc decorati on- w as th e selling and ins ta lling o f paper han gings (as wa llpa pe r was the n called) o fte n fo un d in fine co lo nial interi ors. M ost of th em had printed desig ns with a co n t in u o us ly rep eated p att ern . an d m o st of th e m we re imported . Ther e we re fled glin g effo rts to m anu facture paper h an gin gs in N ew York in 1750 an d 17° 5, an d in 1709. Plunket Fleeson offere d " Am erican Pap er H an gin gs ... M anufactured in Ph ilad elph ia. " so met hing th e lo cal firm o f Ryves and Flet ch er t ried aga in six years later. I No do mes tic exa m p les fr om th e peri od a re k now n . T he p ap e r of ch o ice for th e g ra n des t hou ses o f th e ro co co era and th e ep ito me of th e ro coc o tast e ca me in sets o f lar ge- scale land scap e paintin gs with tr ompe l'o eil carve d fram es. eac h set design ed an d hand painted in En gl and to fit a particul ar ro om . In Am eri can a rc h itect u re, th e fu ll flo w erin g o f th e ro co co sty le oc cur red in th e 1760s an d ea rly 1770s. D at abl e h ou ses ha vin g ro co co o rna me n t are found in Ca m b ridge, M assachu setts. from 1759; in N ew York C ity. from 1763; in Phil ad elphi a, fro m 1764 ; an d in C ha r les to n, fr om 1767. Ex cept for Ca m b ri dge, exa mples m ad e well in to th e ea rly
Th o u gh limited m ainl y to o rna m en ta l hi ghli ghts within plai n . class ica lly co nce ive d spaces . the ro co co sty le in American arc h itec t ure was a sy m bo l o f th e affl ue nce o f the m er canti le elite . Lo yalist and patri ot alike . durin g th e prosperou s d ecad e an d a h alf pri or to th e Re voluti on . T od a y , su ch arc h itec tura l exa m p les th at rem ain are n o less important . Beca use th e y are firml y roo te d in tim e and place, th ey serve as be nc hma rks both for identifyin g regi on al ro coco m anifestati on s an d in d ividu al art isa ns an d for sugges ting the effec t of th e sty le in its to tality . Ar chitectural rococo, m ostl y th e work o f wood-ca rve rs. was em ployed prim ar ily o n th e fir epl ace-the so le so urce o f heat in co lo n ial days and a natural ga the ring place-to establish it as th e vis ua l fo cu s of a roo m . Th ere. ca rv ing was o fte n exec u ted o n w ha t we re ca lle d tru sse s- either sc ro lls buttressing th e sides o f th e fir epl ace o r scr olled co nso les supportin g th e m antel she lf. In th e m o st o rn ate interi ors. o ve rdoor ped im ents ec hoed th e over ma n tel. Th e u se o f ca rved b rack et s at th e o pe n en d o f each tread o f a sta ircase was equa lly co mmo n . R o co co-car ved o rna me n t ap peared in th e spa nd rels o f arc hways . especia lly in th o se sepa rating entran ce h all s fr om stai r h all s, an d in room s w he re arc h ed openin gs flank ed firepl aces or wi ndows. In ch u rc hes, co l u m ns a n d pil ast e rs we re fr equentl y em be llis h ed wi t h ca r ve d ca p itals th at foll owed th e tim ehon o red design s o f th e class ica l o rders (princ ip ally th e Corint hian and th e Co m posi te). with ro co co ca rv ing reserved for im pa rt ing vi su al inter est to th e altar piece and th e pu lpit, th e ecclesiastica l eleme nts to which th e co ng re ga tio n's att ention would naturall y be dr awn .
C hituncv bvcast frO III the [ aIII es Bcelenian house (N o.
II)
17
1770S ca n b e foun d in each o f th o se urban cen te rs . In th e 1780s, afte r th e R ev oluti on , th ere w as a lat e flur ry of ro co co arc hi tec tura l orname n t n ort h o f B o ston , n ot abl y in P ortsmo u th, N ew H am pshire, an d N ewburyport, M assachusetts.
New England
In th e mi d- ei g hteenth cen tury, a vas t p rol ife r ati on o f pu bl icati ons s prea d the doc tri ne o f arc h itec ture based o n the classica l orde rs th r ou gh out th e E ng lis h -s pea k ing wo r ld . Wheth er elega nt engra vcd folio s ad d ressed to n obl e Eng lis h co u ntry-house buil d ers o r crudely printed handb o ok s car ried b y carpe nters , th e publi cati on s fu rn ishe d adv ice o n co ns truction m eth od s a nd o n th e m a k eu p and prop ortionin g o f th e class ica l e le me nts; so me e ve n p r ovided illu strat ion s o f arc hi tec t u ra l o rna m en t. M an y of th e boo ks we re ava ilab le in th e Am e ri can co lon ies. " w he re o ne in p arti cul ar h ad a pron ou n ced in flue nce : T he British A rchitect: O r, the Builder's
A m er e d o zen ex am p les o f r o co co ar chi tec tural car vin g
Treasury of Stair-Cases, b y Ab rah am Swan . Firs t pu bl ish ed in
remain in all N ew Engla nd . That non e are from Bo ston , the regio n's p r eem in ent ci ty, mu st r efl ect in pa r t o n t h e cit y 's
Lon d on in 1745, th e book was rei ssu ed in 17 50 , in 1758, and in t he m id-1 760s . (A me ri ca n e di t io ns o f Swa n 's t r eati se appea re d in Phil ad elphia in 1775 and in B o sto n in 17<)4 .) It
co ns ta n t rebuildin g , for a number o f th e lar g est hou se s surv ive fro m mid-centu r y in Ca m b r idge, across th e Cha rles
was fo r sale b y b o o k sell er s in Phil adelphia an d N ew York in
Ri v er. T he J ohn Vassa ll h ou se , bu ilt on Bratr le Street in
1760 an d in B o st on in 176 3; it was also ava ilab le in subscri pti on lib raries in Phi lad el ph ia . Two arc h itec ts- Pe te r H arri-
17 5<), co n ta ins th e ea rl ies t k nown ro co co-st yl e ornament in New Engla n d arc h itec ture: lighthearted sc ro lle d an d leafage-
so n in N ew E ng la n d an d W illi am Bu ckl and in Virg ini a an d
ca rve d s pa n d re l p an el s in t h e so u t hwest pa rlor. The Vassall h ou se was qu ickl y foll o w ed over th e nex t t w o yea rs by tha t
M ar yl and- ar e k now n to h av e ow ned co p ie s . .l It was th e first arch itec tu ra l to me to fea ture lar g e-scal e illu strat ion s o f r o co co em be ll is hme nt , includin g "St air-C ases .. . W it h a
o f th e Rever en d East Aptho rp, w hose parl o r ret ains its o rig in al carv ed ch im ney p iece (FI(;. 5) w it h des ign elements faith full y b orro w ed fro m Swa n's Brit ish A rchitect: th e tru sses
g rea t Variet y o f cur io us O rna me nts" an d " A grea t Variet y of N ew an d C ur io us C h im ney- P ieces, in th e m o st elega n t and mode rn T ast e, " 4 t he t w o a reas in wh ich th e n e w style
s u p porti ng th e m antel shelf fro m Pl at e XLV I II, t he flankin g o ver ma n t el tru sses fr om Pl at e LlII. s Th e t w o h o u ses, b o th
was m o st o fte n em p loye d by America n b u ilders. Swa n 's
clea rly th e wor k o f th e sa me cra fts me n, s po rt fro n t -do or
pa t terns ex p ressed t h e qu intessential En gli sh ap p licatio n o f
surro u n ds based o n Pl at e
ro co co o rna m en t on to a fir ml y classical fr am ew o rk ; florid in
4 Desions (p u b lished
d eco ration thou gh they we re, th ey n ev er allowed th e o rna -
in B o st on ) , (, b u t w it h swags ca rve d in th e rococo s t y le
me n t to tr an scend th e s u p po r t to w h ic h it was at t ac he d .
repl acin g th e b aroqu e o nes o f th e eng ravi ng.
Des p ite th eir cl assi cism , th e des ig ns in T he British A rchitect have a di stin cti v e characte r of th eir own . Fo r exa m p le , th e
East A pth orp ( 1737- (816) was a d ev o tee of fas hio nab le En gli sh a r chi tect ura l d esi g n . A so n of th e imme n sel y rich
X XX II
in Bat t y Lan gl ey 's Treasury
in Londo n in 17 56 and re adily availab le
chir n ne y p icccs d o n ot in co rp orat e flankin g pi la st er s o r co l-
merchant an d ar m y co n t racto r Cha rles A pr horp ( 10<) 8- '75 8)
umn s o r th e corn ice of a ro om b ut are inde pe nde nt d esi gn s.
o f B o st on , Eas t was a d istin gui sh ed stude n t of rel igi on
T h e ma n te l and ovcrrna n te l are co m posed of larg e- scale eleme n ts in th e h eav y , b a r oqu e t reatm ent associa te d wi t h th e
an d th e classics a t J esu s Co llege , Ca m b ridge Universit y, b etween 17 51 and 17 58. O n th e d eath o f h is fat her , he came
Eng lish arc hi tec t W illi am Kent an d ca rve d de corati on in th e
h om e t o M assa chu sett s , hi s r eturn co inc id ing w it h plans
full, flori d rococo m anner of Lo ck an d Coplan d .
for es ta b lis h ing a n An gli can c h urc h in Ca m br idge, in th e s ha do w of Co ngrega t ion a l H a cT a r d C o llege . Young
Apth orp , w ho was ap po in te d C h r is t C h urc h's fir st re ctor, also sa t o n th e c h u r c h b uil d in g commi t tee t hat c ho se as arc hi tect th e Eng lis h-t rai ned des ig ner Pet er H ar ri son ( 1710177 5) . It h as b e en s ugge s te d th at H arri son , w ho o wned co p ies o f th e Sw an a n d Lan g le y books, h ad a hand in the des ig n of Apr h o r ps o w n h o u se (w h ic h was of a ma g nificence re ma r ked on by J ohn Ad am s), " wi th roco co orn am ent
18
FIGUHE). Parlor cilillll/cypiecc. 17 0 0-01 . the East Apthorp house. Cam bridge. Pho togr aph . ca. I X') O •
Parlor chimncvpiccc, ca. Marbl ehead . Photogr aph . I X')I
FI G UH E 0.
I')
17 0 S.
the Jer emiah Lee hou se.
th at m ay h av e be en e x ecut ed b y Edw ard Burb eck ( [7 15178 5) an d W. Au stin, carve rs for th e chu rch. x Th er e are a few exa m pl es o f ro co co arc hitec tu ra l o rna m ent b y o t he r artisa ns in th e imm ediate env iro ns o f Bo sron ," but th e Apth orp hou se ca rve r mu st also have wo rke d in N ewbu r yp ort, n ear th e present M assachu setts-N e w H ampsh ir e border. Two chim ney pieces fro m 8 Wat er Street , b egun in 17 83 fo r Willi am Coo m bs ( 1736- [8 14), Newburyp ort 's leading im po rt er, have an unusu al and distin cti ve feature also found in th e ch im ney p iece o f th e Apthorp hou se p arl or : b en eath th e ove r ma nte l, a ca r ve d ca ve t to moldin g ex te n d ing at ei t h e r e n d o n w h ic h r est d ecorati v e side tru sses.!"
F[GUR E 7 .
Ph oto gr aph,
S taircase, ca.
17 6 8 ,
For the ultim ate ex press io n o f th e arc hitec tura l rococo in M assachu setts, h owev er , o ne mu st turn to th e Lee hou se in M arbl eh ead , abo u t fifteen miles n ortheast of Bo st o n . With it s seven bays an d three sto ries, it was pr obabl y th e lar gest New Eng land dwelling of it s ge ne ra tion, and was com pleted in [768 by th e patri ot merchant Jer emiah Lee ( [72[ -1775), suppo sedl y to th e desi gn s o f hi s b roth er Sa m ue l." T he ho use. remark abl y w ell pr eserv ed in side and o u t , o ffers th e tw entieth- centur y vi sit or p erh ap s th e m o st au t he n tic p o ssib le ex pe rie nce o f Am eri can ro co co in te riors. Th e arc hi tec tu ral fitt in g s are undi sturb ed . The w all s on b oth fl o or s of the m ain s ta i r h all an d in th e t wo fr o n t cha m be rs h av e their o rigi na l p ap er han gin gs, painted to o rde r in Eng land, with
the Jerem iah Lee hou se, M arblehead .
18 91
20
land scap es in tr ompe l' oeil fram es . Even the ro co co cast-iron fir eba ck s rem ain (see N o . 157). A s is th e case throughout N ew En gl and, the interiors owe a ver y clear debt to Swan's British Architect. In the fully paneled ground-floor parlor ( FIG. 6), th e m oldin g s o f th e entablature ar e carved aft er Plate Xl (the C o rin t h ia n o rd er); the ch im ney piece , with a full compl ement o f trus ses and swags, is an a m a lga m of Plates LI (No.3 ) and LIIl , and , in the hall , the stair bra ckets ( FI G . 7) reprodu ce Pl ate XXXIII. The chimney breast, th ough its projectio n is t o o s lig h t to se t it off effectively from th e surro un ding wall , demon strates unusu ally fine carv ed work. Po rtsm outh, N ew Hampshire, at th e m outh o f th e Pi scata q u a, was th e maj or urb an cen te r north of Boston. It s arc h ite cture s ho ws a ce r ta in indep enden ce within the New En gland idi om. 1 2 Anum ber of g rea t houses remaining from th e peri od demon strat e that th e ro coco flouri shed in Portsmo u t h so m ew ha t later th an in Bo ston . The fir st of them is th e m assive fram e d wellin g built between '7 60 and 1764 for th e shi p cap ta in turned shipo w ner John Moffatt (1692- 1786) . Th e jo ine r was Mi ch ael Whidd en III and the carver wa s E be nezer D earin g ( '7 30 - 1791) o f ne arby Kittery, Maine . In 1761, D ear in g bill ed Moffatt for va rio u s ornam ental carvings , includin g t w o chim ne y pieces (o ne possibl y th at of the dr awing ro om , with it s leaf-carved trusses and central panel) an d th e " 17 Sta re Brak ets " th at st ill g race the main st aircase . ' 3 Th e aca n t h us - scro lle d de si gns were almost certainl y ins p ired b y Swan, but la ck the effe r ves cence of his mature ro co co sty le. The well- k no w n Wentworth-Gardner house, bu ilt abo u t 1760 , is also handsom el y fitted up and looks to be b y th e sa me cra ftsm en . Th e M offatt an d th e Wentworth-Gardner houses are exact co n te m porari es of th e Vass all and A pthorp houses in Ca m bridge an d, though th eir o rna m en tal d et ail s gen er ally lack th at ro coco spi rit, ar e eq ua lly grand. The st yle in its full m aturit y did arrive in Portsmouth, but not until much later, w it h th e John Langdon hous e, whi ch wa s b egun in 1783. Lan gd on ( 1746 - 1819), a merchant and politici an, began to purch ase th e land for hi s hou se in 1775 and married in 1777. Th en w a r int er v ened. Onl y in 178 3 did the actu al work b egin, p erform ed b y the sa me c ra fts m e n Moffatt had e m p loy e d t w ent y yea r s ea r lie r. On 14 De cember 1785, E be neze r D earing a n d his so n W illi am were paid £ 169 for ca rvi ng that must h av e includ ed the m agnificent ch i m neypieces in th e north an d the so ut h parlors (F IG. 8) and the n orth p arlor' s spandrels an d keyston cs.!' B y that tim e, the D earin g s ' st yl e h ad ev o lv ed into a distin ctive rendition of chi m ne y piec e de si gns from Swan : lar ge in scale, with bold carv in g in hi gh reli ef, but with the tru ss es flatten ed out to crea te a vi gorous abstract patt ern ex clus ive to Portsmouth. 15
t:.."""~,, ,:"""""" "
.. ,
, """""
FIGU RE 8. Parlor chimnevpiece, 1783-85, the John Langdon house, Portsmouth
21
New York
In th e va lley of th e Hudson , up to Alba ny, th er e rem ains but a h andful o f exa m p les of rococo a rc h itec t u ra l o rn a me n t , on ly thr ee of wh ich a re int act in th eir orig ina l st r uc t ures. T he 17oos, th e he yd a y o f t he style , saw th e co ns t ructio n o f m an y a g ra nd h o u se , inclu d in g th at of C ha rles Ward Apth orp (bro t he r to Eas t) in upp er M anh attan ( 1704) , th e M or ri s-Jum el hou se, also in M anh a tt an ( 170))' a nd th e Schu yler M an sion , in Alb an y ( 17° 1- ° 4); th e first de molished, th e o the rs rem odele d an d any ro co co woodwo rk dest ro yed. Th ou ghJ am es B eckm an' s M anh attan co u n t ry h ou se a n d Ste p he n Van Ren sse laer ' s Alb an y m an or h ou se are also go ne, frag me n ts o f th em that su rv ive a rc amo ng th e m o st splendi d reminder s o f N ew York 's ro co co heritage. On ly in th e Ph il i p sc M an or h ou se , in Yonk er s; Van Co rt la n d t H ou se, in the Bron x (t he t w o m an o rial es ta tes imm edi at ely n orth o f M anh att a n Isl and ) ; a nd Sa in t Paul ' s C h a p el , o n Bro adway , in lowe r M anh attan , ca n th e ro co co be se en in sit u. The ap o gee o f the N ew Yo rk ro co co can be pinpointed to th e m id-r vo o s b y Saint P aul' s, built b etw een 17°3 an d 17° 7; th e Beekm an hou se, b et w een 17° 3 an d 17°4 ; an d th e Van Ren sselaer m an or hou se, bet w een 170) and 17o H. From w ha t survives at th o se sites so me sen se o f th e ver y hi gh-st yle an d high-qu alit y ro co co interi o rs of co lo n ial N ew York can still be gleaned. The house at Phil ip se M an or , in t he eigh teenth century so me fift een mi les above t he city pr oper , has prob abl y th e ea rl ies t exa m p les of th e arc h itec t ura l ro co co in N ew York. Th e o rigi na l s to ne h ou se w as built b y th e firs t Fred eri ck Phil ip se ( 1626- 1702) in th e 16 Hos. T he t w o-st or y add i t ion , whi ch co n ta ins th e " rococo " ro om s, mu st h ave been built b y Fr ed eri ck Phil ip se I II ( 1720- 17Ho) some time a fter 17)' . w h en h e inh erited t he p rope rt y . and p rob abl y abo ut 17) 0, w he n he m arried Eliza be th (W illia ms) . w ido w of Anth on y Rut ger s. I f , (T he we ig h tiness o f th e ca rv ing sugges ts a tim e well before th e m ature rococo of t he m id-1 700s.) T he t\N O parl o rs hav e el ab orat e fi repl ace wa lls . eac h w ith a full clas-
F IGURE <). Parlor cliimncvp iccc, ca. 1750, Ph ilip se M ano r ho use, Yonkers. Photogra ph. ca. 1<)10
22
sica l o rder (engaged Ioni c co lu m ns 'on that o f th e fir st floor , D o ric pil ast er s o n th at of th e second). The m antel s ar e go ne, b ut th e o vc r m antcl s ha ve m old ed fr am es flanked b y nearl y id enti cal t ru sses from w h ic h eme rge lu xuri ant ga rlan ds o f fruit and flo w er s. "? T he o ve r ma n tel o f th e fir st-fl o or room ( FI G . 9) h as a h e a v y b rok en- scr oll pediment a n d a tablet d ispl ayin g a head of Di an a th e huntress; th at o f th e secondfloo r room has an o pe n pedim ent w ith a fini al o f three clustered fea t he rs and a ro caill e-car vcd fri eze belo w . The three fea t he rs, th e sy m bo l o f th e Prin ce o f Wale s, m ay refer her e to Frede rick ( 1707- 1751), h eir ap pa re n t to Geo rge Il , wh o was an av id patr on o f art and design in th e 1730S and 1740S.IX T he fir st-fl o or room still has its ro coco-enri ch ed ceiling, o ne of th e m o st e la bo ra te fr om co lo nia l Am eri ca and th e on ly o ne le ft i n N e w York . Th e deco ra t io n -sc ro ll wo r k inh abit ed b y bird s, ani ma ls, an d profil e portrait bu st s, all co n ta ine d w it h in a br o ad d e corati v e o u te r b and-h as the charac te ris tic d isj ointed lo ok o f pap ier-m ichc orn am ent: th e puttin g to g eth e r o f a lot o f indi vidu all y mold ed ele me n ts . Sty lis tica lly freer an d m ore pl ayful th an th e firepl ace-wall woo dwo r k, it lo ok s to ha v e b een in st all ed in the 176 0 s. Ph ilip se' s likel y su pplier was Roper D aw son , w ho ad ve rtised " Pa pe r H an gin gs and in Figures, Bass Reli ev e [bas-relief] for Ceili ngs, sec" in th e New- York Gazelle or the Weekly Post-B oy of 3 June 1762. IV J am es Beek m an b uilt M ount Pleasant as a co un t ry est ate at w ha t is no w th e co rne r o f Fift y-first Street and First Av enu e in M anh attan, o n prop erty he acq uire d earl y in 1763 (se e p . ISS). The m ajo r su r viv ing elem ent of th e house is the chim n e y breast g iven b y Be ekman' s de scend ants to The N ewYork Hist orical So ciet y in 1874 (N o . II ; see also ill. opp. p . 17). Lik e thos e at th e Phil ips e M an or house, it is domin ated b y a mo n u men tal an d ri chl y carved sc ro ll- pe d irncn tc d overma n te l flank ed by representati on s o f a class ical o rde r, in this case flut ed D o ri c pil ast er s r estin g di rectl y o n th e mant el shelf. The ca rved rococo ca r tou ch e fram in g th e famil y arm s t ha t o nce hun g w it h in th e pedim ent , w h ile prob abl y co ntem poraneo us wi th t h e ch im ney p iece, was n ot an int eg ral pa r t o f th e d esi gn . In s t r ik ing co n t ras t to th ese h ea v y arc h itec tu ra l features is th e th orou ghl y ro coco ca rved o rnamen t o f th e tru sses and m antel friezc. : " It co ns ists o f rocaille wo rk , pi er ced an d with parall el- gou ged surfaces, and , at th e m id dle o f th e fri e ze, a p addlin g d o g fl ank ed b y s tr ide n t swa ns -a tou ch o f ro co co w h imsy in th e m ann er of th e eng raved design s o f th e London carve r Thomas J ohnson . 21
II
Parlor cliimncv breast, N ew Yor k, 1763-64 From M ount Pleasant , th e J ames Beekman hou se White pine . paint ed. H .: 115 in . Installat ion photogra ph, 1')64 T he New-Yo rk Hi sto rical Society
T he bui ld ing o f th e Van Ren ssel aer m an or hou se, th e g rea test of th e river va lley hou ses of th at tim e, was begun in 176 5
23
E ntrance hall , 1765-68 , Van Rensselaer man o r house, Alban y, as inst alled at T he M et ropolitan Museum o f Art
F IGURE 10 .
24
III terior, Saint Paul's Chapel, New York , 1764-66. Photograph, ca. 1900
FIGURE I I .
d on , 23 exem plify N ew York rococo ca rv ing at it s g ra ndes t . O n ly th e ceilin g is wi tho u t orna men t, an d th at was not th e o rig ina l intent. In 176 8, Phil ip Living st on , Van Ren sselaer 's fa the r- in- la w, w ro te to h im : " I a m told You Intend to gett Stu cco wo rk o n th e Ceiling of Y ou r H all w hic h [ wou ld no t advise Y ou to do , a Pl ain Ceiling is now Esteem ed th e mos t Ge ntee l. "24
an d co m ple ted three yea rs later by St ephen II ( 1742 - 1769; th e eig h t h Van R en s sel aer p at ro on ), w ho m arri ed Ca t he rine Li vi n g st o n in 176 4. Th ou gh th e h ou se was d estr o y ed in 1893, th e architect ura l woodwork and th e pap er han gings of the en trance h all were sa lvaged and ultim atel y reassembled at the Met ropoli ta n Museum, w here they represent th e N ew Yo rk rococo architecrura J inte rior at its mos t comp lete (FIG. 10). T he wa lls are lai d o u t acco rdi ng to t he Ion ic o rde r, as the pi lasters on eit her side of t he archway to th e stai r h all demons trate. T he pl ast er su rfaces be tween dado and co rnice, lik e those of the Lee h ou se in M ar b leh ead , are hun g w it h hand -pa in ted wa ll pa pe rs m ad e in Lo n d o n in 1768 , wh ich fea ture g risai lle land scap es d epi ct in g th e Four Season s an d scenes of class ica l ruin s w it h in tr om pe l'oei l carved ro co co frames .":' T he spa nd rels o f th e arc hway , th ei r scro lled foli age copie d d irec tly fr om a pl at e in Lo ck a n d Co p la n d's Ne u: 8M" (~r O rn anie nt s, w h ic h h ad ju s t b een re iss ue d in Lon-
The o n ly su rv iv ing pub lic str uc tu re bu ilt wi t h rococo o r na men ta tio n is Saint Paul' s C ha pe l. The co r ne rs tone was laid o n 14 M ay 1764 ; th e first service in th e cha pel was held o n 30 Oct ob er 1766 . Th e h e x a g on al pulpit a n d so u n di ng b o ard, to th e left o f th e a ltar (F IG. II), h av e ela bo ra tely ca rved m oldin gs th at in clude an o penwo rk ro co co bol ecti on, b ow s a n d s wags, an d v ines g row in g a ro u n d th e sq ua re balu st er s o f th e pulpit sta ir. Even m ore loosel y handl ed and m o re fully ro co co in man n er is th e m agnificent ca r to uc he abo ve the Palladian w indow behind th e alta r.
25
Pennsylvania
In th e eighteenth cen tury, arch itec tura l carv ing was probabl y m ore co m mo n in Phil ad el ph ia th an in any o t he r Am erican city except po ssibl y C harlesto n. The fair number of ex isting ro co co exa m p les sho w a p eri od of g rea t ac tivi ty b et w een abo u t 1764 an d 177 2. 25 Th e lo cal treatm ent o f ch im neypieces- a heav y tab ern acl e fram e m ounted on the wa ll several in ch es abo ve a m antel she lf o n tru sses- can be found in Swa n (Pla tes XLII-I.) but is n o wher e pr ecisel y co pied. M o st o f th at car ving has been att ributed to Lond on art isa ns: Bcr n ard an d Ju g ie z, in Phil ad el phi a b y 1762, an d H er cules Cour tenay, in Ph ilad elphia b y 1765. 2(' Th e ro co co st y le m a y h av e bee n intro du ced at M ount Pleasant, a m agn ificent stone co un try hou se overloo king the Sc h uylki ll R iv er j us t no rth o f th e city. Ca p ta in John M acPh er son , a Scot m ad e rich throu gh pr iv at ccrin g in th e late 17 50 S, b ou ght th e land an d b eg an th e co ns t r uc tio n o f th e hou se in 1761 . Th e accou n t bo o k of m ast er build er Thoma s N c vell d o cum ent s t h e wo r k o ver th e n ext four yca r s. :'? Ro co co ca rvi ng , co n fine d to th e ch im ney piece in th e fir st flo or parlor and to th e chim ney piece and flankin g cupboards o f t he upst airs d raw in g ro om (F IG. 12) , is in th e m anner o f Bern ard and Ju gi ez . B oth ch i m ney p iec es a re o f an o d d ly in complete de sign . Th e o verm antel fr am e has been so elon gated t hat it rest s n ot o n a m antel she lf but d ir ectl y on the sc ro lle d tru ss es. In th e up st airs ro om , h owever , th e o ve rm antel frame br eak s O llt at th e top into a br ok en-scro ll pedim ent in which is ce n te red a vibrant , flo win g pier ced she ll, perhap s th e ea rlies t ex am p le of the full rococo in Phi ladel phi a architec tu re .:" At C li ve d en , in G erm ant o wn , six mile s n orth of th e city , th e ca rve rs o f Mount Pleasant we re em p loyed to emb ellish t h e s to ne h ou se b egun in 17 6 3 o n th e co u n try esta te of Benj amin C hew ( 1722- 1S10), a not ed jurist and later ch ief justi ce of Penn sylvani a. (T he hou se rem ain s int act and h as mu ch o f it s o rig ina l furnitu re . ) In 17 6 6, Bcrna rd an d
.f
-' .. ji -----.---- .~ :. ;' J..,..I
1' 4. Lo/
FIGURE 12 . Chinincvpiccc, 176 1-65, up stairs d rawing roOI11. M ount Pleasant . th e J ohn M acPh erson hou se. Phil adelph ia
~~~.~
_ , ----, ...,:_;:-::-;.;.,:;;:.::;. ;.~-;:;;:!i ~i!i !~~:i~!i '
Parlor chimncvpiccc, ca. 17 (, 5. from the StampcrBlackwell hous e. Phil adelphi a. as installed at Winterthur Mu seu m
FIGU R E 13 .
27
14. Firep lace wall of ballroom, 1709- 70. the Samuel Powel house. Philadelphia, as installed at the Philadelphia Museum of Art
FIGU RE
J ugi ez recei ved p ay m ent for tw o roca ille-ca rve d tru sses for th e parl or ch im neypiece and ten sma lle r, leaf- carv ed trusses fo r th e o ve rdoo r p ed im ents o f th e p arl or and th e en t ra nce hall. 2y Th e ch im ney p iece design , th e co nsoles su p po rt ing a mantel shelf, is now full y developed .3° Th e genera l d esi gn o f th e C livede nc h im ney p iece an d ove rdoo rs is re pea te d, but g rea tly enr ic he d , in th e parl or (no w at Winterthur) fr om th e Pin e Stree t hou se th ought to h ave b een bu ilt in th e ea rly 1760 s b y th e m er ch ant and mayo r o f Phil ad elphia J ohn St amper and lat er owne d by th e Rever end Robert Bl ack w ell. Th e ro om is th e m ost elaborate of ex ta n t Phil ad elphia int er ior s ( H G . 13). On th e chi rn n eypi ece (its o rna me n t pr obabl y b y H er cul es Co u rte na y), th e ove r ma n tel fr am e is su r ro u n de d b y ca rved frond s an d ga rla n ds; bet w een th e tru sses th at su p po rt th e mantel she lf are three panels carved in landscap e vig ne ttes , th e cente r one afte r a Thom as J ohnson eng rav ing o f 1762. 31 T he fin al s u rv iv i ng m onum ent t o t he r o c o c o in Ph ilad elph ia arc hi tec ture is a brick to wn house at 244 South Thir d Street. Th e o rig ina l buildin g was ere cte d in 1765- 66 by C ha rles Sted ma n ( 1713- 1784), a Sco ts sh ipmas te r turned m er ch ant , an d was pu rchased b y Sam uel r o wel ( 173 S- 17'.!3) , h eir to a g rea t m er cantile fo rt u ne an d la te r a m a yo r o f Phil ad elphi a, afte r return in g fro m hi s gra n d to ur an d fi ve days b efore hi s ma r riage to Eliza be t h W illin g , in A u gu st 1769. Po w el m ad e mass ive altera tio ns to th e interio r in th e n e xt t w o ycar s. v' H e em p loye d th e city's bes t ca rve rs Bern ard and Ju gi ez, H er cul es Co u rtenay , an d J am es Reyn olds (see p. 184,) - for arc h itec tura l wor k th at in clu ded
the o rna me n t o f th e up st airs b ack p arl o r (n o w at t he M etropolitan Museum ) and that o f th e up stairs ballroom (now at th e Ph ilad elphi a Museum of Art; H G . 14), th e latter not abl e fo r th e leaf- and-scr oll ca rvi ng in th e fr ieze after a p la te in S wa n 's D esiyn « i ll A rchitccturc (Lo n d o n , (757) and for th e su pe rb o rna me n ta l pl ast er ce iling b y J am es C low. In M ay 1770, Po we i paid th e Scottish-trained C low, w ho had arr ived in Phil adelphia in 1763, £3 1 fo r "Stu ccoin g a ceiling ." 33 Po w ei was not th e on ly owne r to up gr ade th e int erio r of h is town hou se in th e ea rly I770s, but th e o ther st ru ctures are now all go ne . J ohn Ca dwa lade r, w ho bou ght a hou se on Second Street in 1769 and pr o ceeded to gu t an d re fit it (see p. 185), paid £362 -9 -iI2 for arc h itec tura l carving alo ne- a b ravado di spl ay o f co lo n ial g ra n de u r. T od ay, his fu rn iture, th e m o st ela bo ra te eve r m ad e in Phil ad elphi a , h as b een pla ced in Po wel 's gra nd ballroom (see ill. o pp . p. 133 ) at the Phil adelphia Museum o f Art. On occas io n, th e Phil ad elphi a s ty le of arc h itec ture sp rea d so u t h to De lawa re an d th e East ern Sho re of M ar yland . S wa n 's eng rave d d esi gn s we re u sed at th e Co r b it hou se, be gun in O dessa, D elawar e, in 1772, but witho ut th e ro co co ca rv ing. H Ju st th e o p posite occu rred in tw o hou ses in Qu een Ann es Co u n ty, M ar yland . At C lover field s. built for Willi am H en sley, th ere is a ch im ney piece w ith simi lariti es to th o se at M acPh er son' s Mount Pl easant ; at Ches terto wn. Thomas Rin ggol d, a m er chant w ith close Phil adelph ia ties , h ad a p arl or (no w at th e Balt im ore M use um of Art) wi t h e la bora te o ve r m an te ls and overdoo rs exec u ted in a m ann er not unlike J ohn Sta m per's (see HG. (3).3'
28
The South
T he co lon ial capital o f M aryland , Annapoli s, on th e banks o f the Chesapeake, eme rged as a ve ry pr o sp erou s cit y in th e 1760s an d l77os . M an y o f th e m aj or h ou ses from th at tim e survive. O f so me fourteen erec ted in th e deca de fro m '765 to 177 5, the firs t to p ar ad e ro co co o rn ame n t was th e reside nce J am es B ri ce built o n a lot he inher it ed in 1766. Co nstructio n o f th e sta tely bri ck building was begun in 1767 and too k five yea rs to co m plete. The inte rio rs arc rem ark ab le for their size , the ir m assi ve, ca rved full en tab larures. an d th eir rococo chi m neyp ieces. Thou gh m ore th an one carver 's hand is appa re n t, the prin cip al artisan was clearl y th e o th erw ise unk nown William Bampton, whom Bri ce, in his journal for M ar ch 1770 , credit ed with £40 -0- 1 for " fi n is hi n g large st R o om in m y H ou se th e C ar p en ters and Join ers work & carvi ng C h im ney Pie ce . " 3° H e w as sure ly referrin g to the fi rst-fl o o r n orth w est roo m an d it s ch im ney piece (F IG. 15), w hose somewha t naively carve d tru sses co py Swan's Plate Ll. The lar ge st o f the Annap oli s houses, a three-st ory brick cube , was b egun b y Samu el C hase in 1769 an d pur ch ased unfini sh ed b y th e p atri ot and publi c o fficia l Edward Llo yd I V ( 1744- 1796) in 1771. 37 Willi am Bu ck land ( 173 5- 1774) , a joi n er an d d esi gn er fro m Ri chm ond Co u n ty, Vir gini a, m o v ed to Ann apol is in th at yea r , a p pa re n tly to wo rk for Llo yd , brin gin g w it h him th e Lond on-trained car ve r Thom as H all. Hall is att ributed w ith th e carv ing o f th e m ost ela bo ra te ro om in th e h ou se, n ow the d inin g room, fo r w h ich Llo yd paid Bu ckland £62-0 -6 in '772 and 1773 Y The ap p li q ues o n the fri eze of the ov erdoors (F IG . (6 ), though large in scale and b roadl y co nceived , were probab ly insp ired b y sta ir- b rac ket de si gns in Swan , a bo ok Buckl and owned . Rawling s and Barn es, a pair o f En g lish stu cco ists late from Lond on , did more than £200 w orth o f w ork in th e house, m o stl y neoclassica l in style but includin g the de coration of th e hall cei ling -a ce n t ra l rosette with del icat e roco co sur round s. In M ar ch 1774, the land dire ctl y opp o site Llo yd' s h ou se was pur ch ased b y M atthi as H ammond, for w hom
15. Chimnevpiece, 1767-72, first-floor north west room, the James Brice house, Annapolis. Photograph, ca. 1900 FIG UH E
16. Doorframe, '772-73, dining roo m, the Chase-Lloyd house, Annapolis. Photo graph, ca. 1900
FIGU HE
, . ; ':. .t.
. fj-
;;
'-
I.
';i"
~i..~t1
. '~ .
. '
, }
r-.'"
•/~~'.4 ~... ,#, :I~"V
, I'(~!';/ . ''''''/
_
Plan and elevations, ca. 1 7 (,~ • for ent rance hall. Whiteh all. the Hor atio Sharpe hou se. near Annapolis. 17 (Q-(, Y . Pen cil on paper. 15 x Iy in. US . I x ~ S . J cm. ). Co llectio n of Mr. and Mrs. C ha rles Scarlett. J r.
FI G U R E 17 . 4
FI G UR E
.1 0
IS.
EII(r,lIl CC lial],
Whiteh all.
1 7 (,~-(, Y
Bu ckl and desi gned an eleg an t bri ck house with symm etrical w ings . Th e ri chl y carve d ch im ney p ieces an d the door an d w indow fram es o f th e fir st-floor int eri or s. much in th e m anne r o f th e Llo yd h ou se dinin g ro om . ha ve also be en attribut ed to Th om as Hall. 3~ A fe w m ile s o u t side Ann ap olis , o n th e b ank s of the Se v ern, is Whiteh all , a villa built b y Mar yland' s co lo n ia l go ve rno r, H orati o Sh arpe ( 1718- 1790). The cen t ra l block of th e hou se , w hic h wa s be gun in 1764 and co m p lete d prior to 176 9 , co n ta ins a g rea t en t ra nce hall, o r sa lo o n. The room's de corati ve pro gram is sho w n in an un sign ed drawin g ( FIG . 17) , a uniqu e Am e rican co u n te r p art o f a co m m o n En gli sh arc h itec t u ra l rend erin g, w h ich includ es a refle cted ceiling plan and th e four wall s. The sq ua re ch amber , nearly a cube, has a coved ceiling w hose co rn ers contain hu ge carv ed- w ood ro co co ca rto uc h es that fr am e ma sk s representin g th e Four W inds. Cen te re d in eac h wa ll is a door; o n the front and rear wa lls are lar ge wind ows w ith arc hit raves termin atin g at the d ad o in ca rve d sc ro lls ; affix ed to th e side w all s are mirrors ; and th e em pt y spaces o n all four w alls ar e filled w ith ro co co ga rla nds ( FIG . (8) . There is n othin g els e of quite thi s grand eur fr om co lo n ia l Americ a. Bu ckl an d h as been c re d it ed w ith Whitehall' s ornamental trim .'!" Wh il e th e re is pr ob abl y a g rea te r numb er of fin e preR e vol uti on a r y h ou ses in Vir gini a th an in any oth er state , there is a pa uc ity o f a rc h itec tu ra l ornam ent in the rococo style. N on e ex ists eve n in Willi am sburg, th e co lo nial capital, th ou gh carve rs th er e ar e kn o wn to h ave fabri cated ro co co furnit ur e (see N o . (23 ) . E x cept for papicr-mach e ornaments ad de d abo u t 176 2 to th e front-hall and drawing-room ce ilin g s a t W est o v er , built a bo u t 1731- 3 5 b y William B yrd ( 1674- 174 4) o n the J am es River not far from Willi amsburg,';' there was no co m pe lling fashi on for th e style in th e Tidewater re gi on . For the m o st part, o ne mu st look to the Northe rn N eck o f Vir gini a , on th e bank s o f the Potom ac, for arc hitec tural ro coco . Geo rge W ashin gt on , w ho h ad ac q u ire d hi s es t at e a t M ount V e rn on in 17 54, ove rsaw it s fir st enl arg em ent in 1757- 59, yea rs w he n he rem odel ed th e West Parlor, probabl y
de sign has been faithfully co pied fro m Swa n's Pl at e L, but in a modest scale an d by a heavy and so mew ha t labored han d . As Lund Washin gton , a co usin w ho was supe ri n tending th e work at M ount Vern on for th e ge ne ra l, ca n d id ly w ro te to him : " I think yo u never intended suc h a o ne and m us t h ave b een mi st ak en in th e lo ok o f th e d r au ght o f th e ch im ney pie ce. " '; 2
I'
\; - , --
.. ,~
./
in stalli n g th e exis ti ng h a nd som e chi mney p iece, for w h ic h in
17 57 he o rde re d the land scap e p aintin g that fit s within the overm an tel fr ame . The m antel and overm anrel have ca rved friezes an d flankin g trusses - sirn plifications o f Plates L and LIll in Swan - an d Washin gton ' s famil y a rm s are di spla ycd w it hin a carved roco co car touch e. Year s lat er , in 177 5, durin g hi s second ex pa ns io n o f the h ou se, he hired Willi am Bern ard Sear s, who had worked previ ousl y in Virginia for Bu ckl and , to carve a ne w m antel for hi s sma ll dinin g room (FIG. (9) . In stead of th e u su al whit e pin e , th e mantel is fashi on ed o f walnu t; th e overm an tel , o f pla st er. The whole
FIGURE 1<). Chimneypiece. M ount Vern on
3I
177 5 .
small din ing room,
Between 17 5 5 an d I 759, Washin gton ' s neig h bor th e pl anter an d , later , Revolutionar y sta tes man Ge o rge M ason ( 1725- T792) w as buildin g Gunston H all, a sm all but exquisite Ge orgian hou se . In the ent ra nce h all , th e spa n d re ls of th e arc h way hav e C -sc ro lls w it h p ierced ro caille m antel s, and th e drawin g roo m an d th e dining ro om hav e elabo ra te ca rved moldin g s b ased o n Swan 's D esign s ill A rchitecture. The woodwo rk in the house wa s the resp on sibility of Bu ckland , whom Mason brou ght o ver from London fo r th e occasion; th e carvin g wa s b y Sear s, who is also th ou ght to hav e co me fro m En gland at M ason's requesr .r':' In th is and in subsequent co m m iss io ns, it w as th e efforts o f th o se tw o m en th at acco un t for much of th e roco co in southern archi tec ture. Bu ckl and 's next important co m m issio n, in T76I -64, was for John T aylo e ( 1721- 1779), who w as buildin g M ount Ai ry, a g rea t ston e hou se overl o ok in g th e Rappah annock Riv er , a few mil es so u th o f th e Potom ac. The interiors burned in the nineteenth ce n t u ry, but m an y o f th e pictures an d so me of th e fu rn itu re we re sa ve d. The mo st extraordin ar y of th ese pieces is an elab orate pier table ( FIG. 20) , w hich m ay be co nside re d an ext en si on o f th e int eri or ar chit ectu re of th e house . H Screws are used to secu re th e fram e, and m oldin gs ar e att ached w i t h ex pose d n ail s - te chnique s m or e co m m onl y used b y j oin er s th an b y cab ine tma kers . The carvin g , it s su rface textured with sha llow parallel lin es, h as th e di stin cti ve sty le of Scar s's w ork at Gunston H all. It is thus fair to co n cl ud e that Buckl and an d Sear s d esign ed and bu ilt th e t abl e as a pie ce of w all furnitur e, an int egr al pa rt o f th e M ount Air y interi or. Th e o v e ra ll d esi gn is tak en fr om a "Sideb oard T able" in T he Director (Plate LTx ), a patt ern havin g a pier ced ski rt an d legs o f su ch delic acy th at C hippendale recomm end ed using a woode n top. To support th e we ig hty sto ne , th e leg s of th e Mount Air y ex am p le we re reinforced in th e b ack, effecti vely blockin g th e pierced wo rk , an d th e sk irt w as m ade so lid and o rna me n te d w ith th e sa me g uil loche p attern o f o ve rla p p in g circles found o n window sur rounds in th e dr awing room at G uns to n H all. Midway bet w een th e Potom ac an d the Rapp ah ann o ck rivers , n ot far fr om Fr ederick sburg, lies M armi on , a Fit zhu gh famil y hou se built so metime ar ound th e middl e of th e eig h tee n th cen tury. Th e w alls of it s best parl o r (n ow at th e M etr op olit an Mu seum ) are sh ea the d in pan el in g th at wa s covere d a bo u t 1770, pro ba b ly w h en n ew, w it h the m o s t ex t rav aga n t p aint ed d ecor ative sc he me o f any co lo ni al Am eri can room. The en ta b la tu re, Ionic pil ast er s, and dado paneling are marbleized , and the lar ge w all panels are embellish ed in an alm os t Co nt ine nta l m anner w ith scrolls, swags, and ima gin ative ro coco stands o f fru it ( FIG . 21). In th e wo rld of Am eri can painted deco rati on, it is without peer. 4 5
M ahogallY pier table, ca. 1765, made for M ount Air y, th e J ohn Tayloe hou se, Warsaw . M ahogan y, 33 x .P'/2 x 25 in. (83. 8 x 108 x 63.5 em .)
FIGURE 2 0 .
32
FIGURE 21. Wall ofpar/or, ca . 177 0 , fro m M armion, th e J oh n Fit zhu gh hou se, near Fred eri ck sburg, as ins talled at T he M et ropolitan Museum o f Art
33
Parlor chininevpiece, 17 (j9- 7 0 , the Humphrey Som me rs hous e, C harleston. Photogr aph , ca. 1890
F IGU HE 22 .
34
Ornaments for cielin gs, &, to im ita te Sroco Work . " 5° By far th e su preme instance o f roc o co stucco wo rk in C ha rles to n is th e de cor ati on on th e wa lls of a roo m in w ha t is n o w th e Co lo ne l William Rh ett h ou se , 54 H asell St ree t. 5 1 T he re, ad de d t o th e ove r ma n tel an d ove r do o rs is lar g e, b ol d scro llw ork, rendered in a m ann er th at can be co m pa red with En glish o r Irish w ork .
In C harles ton, So u t h Ca ro li n a, arc h itec tu ra l ca rv ing was pa rtic u larly fas hio na b le. The Eng lish artisa n H enry Burnett su pe rvised th e executio n o f £ I ,0 00 wo rth o f suc h decorative wo r k at Saint Mi ch ael' s C h u rc h b etw een 1757 an d 1760 . W h ile n o recor d exis ts o f w ha t it lo ok ed lik e, so m e dozen exa m p les o f h ous eh old int eriors with o rna me n te d w oodwo rk do su rvive, th e grea tes t co nce n tra tio n in any co lo n ial A me rican city. The vas t m aj orit y o f buildings having rococo arc h itectu ra l d eco rati on w er e bu ilt bet w een 1767 an d 1772. Muc h o f th at wo r k h as b een at t r ib u t ed t o th e ca r v ers T ho mas W o odin , w h o arrived fr om Lo nd on in 1764 an d died in 1774 , an d J ohn Lord, who came from London in 1766 and sta yed in C harleston fo r nin e yea rs. { 6 Am on g th e g ra n des t o f th o se h ou ses is th at o f Mil es Brew to n , 27 K in g St ree t, w hic h was compl eted in 1769. It has a tw o-st ory en tra nce p orti co , a vas t secon d-floo r b allroom wi th a cove d ce iling , an d ya rd up on ya rd o f ela borat el y car v ed m old in g s. O ne of th e prim ary cra fts me n o n th e j o b , an d th e o n ly one n o w kn o wn b y nam e, was Ez ra Wa ite, w ho adve rtise d o n 22 Au gu st 17 69 as a "C iv il Archi tec t, H o use-builder in ge ne ral, and Ca rve r, from London [w ho has] fini sh ed th e arc hi tec ture . . . and carved all the [tabe rnacle fram es] in th e four prin cip al room s .. . o f Mil es Br ew ton , Esquire's H ouse. " { 7 The w ork is stro ng on carved m ol din gs and geometr ic fre two rk, cha racte ristics o f C ha rlest on arc hi tec tu ra l o rna me n t. O f all th e C ha r les to n ch irrineyp ieces in th is sty le, th at fro m th e parl or of th e Humphrey So m me rs h ou se, about 1769- 70, is th e full est ex p ress io n o f the woo d-ca rver's art (F IG . 22 ) . A co ntin uo us co rn ice unites the overma ntel fr am e and flan kin g pil ast ers in a co m pos itio n remini scent o f d esi gn s in R ob ert Morr is ' s Arch itec tura l Remem brancer (Lo n d o n , (7 51) . { 8 O n th e m antel frie ze an d w it h in th e arc h itrav e o f th e ove r ma n te l o f ano t he r ch im ney piece - this one at th e Daniel H eyw ard house-is figureeig h t- pa t te rne d fre two r k n ot unlik e th at found o n mu ch C ha rles to n case fu rn itu re. { Y The cabine tma ke r Thomas Elfe sup plied builders wi th fre two rk by th e foot (fo rty -six feet in Nove mbe r 1772) an d eve n th e occasio na l " fre t t ch im n ey piece .
MHH
.•.
_.-
,.' . ....
l:.1
t.
Newspaper ann ouncement s o f th e p e ri od s how th at
pa pe r hangin g s fro m Lond on we re w ide ly used in C ha rles t o n , th ou gh n o ex ampl es r emain in pl ace. P api er-rn ac he o rna me nt, ho w ever, su rv ives in th e ceiling o f th e down stairs parlo r o f th e Mil es Brewt on h ou se (F IG. 23) . The va rio us mo lde d m otifs- scr oll work , swa gs, an d b order s- ar e delicate in scale an d ar ra n ge d w ith mu ch m ore orde r an d taste tha n are o the r Am erican ex am p les (those at Ph ilip se M anor, for ins ta nce ). T he o rna me n t m ay be th e w ork ofJ ohn Blott, an uphol st er er who arr ive d fro m London in 1764 and advertised in th e So uth Caro li na G aeeue o f II M ay 176 5, " Machec
Parlor ceiling, ca. 1769. th e Mil es Br ew ton hou se, Charleston
FIGU RE 23 .
35
' ~ ~. '
'- . ':J-~
i
.... :r
•
ENGRAVINGS
A s qui ckl y as p r int ed de si gn s a rrive d from England , Am eri can eng rave rs felt free to co py th em, d uplicating them virtua lly lin e for lin e o n occasion, cha nging o nly th e text or, in the case o f b o okpl at es, t h e a rmo ria l. For exam p le, t h e eleg an t trad e ca rd (t he da te 1765 writte n on the reverse) of th e London brass w ir ema ker J osep h Welch (N o . 12) was th e pr ecise m od el for a card m ad e by Paul Revere for th e Boston hard w are m er ch ant W illiam Breck (his co py m arked 1770 on the rev erse) . It was also used fo r an a ll b ut ide ntica l ca rd
In eig htee nt h-cen tury Ameri ca, printed eng ra vings provided t he mo s t wi des p read m anifestati on o f ro co co o r n ame n t. Boo kp lates, tr ad e ca rds o f all sorts , m em ber ship ce rtificates and notificati ons, even th e titl e cartouc hes of m ap s - all we re in fl u en tial in o pe ni ng co lo nia l eyes to th e London fashion . They have ri ghtl y been called th e am bassado rs o f th e rococo style.' Eco nomic co nsi de ratio ns pla yed no s ma ll p art in th at phe no meno n . D ep endin g o n its size, a co ppe r pl at e co uld be ela bora te ly eng raved fo r an inves t men t o f as littl e as t wel ve sh illin gs, w ith th e cos t o f printing a hundred co pies far less. M an y A m erican artisa ns an d sho pkeepe rs (w ho never co u ld have afforded rococo-s ty le silver or furnitur e for th eir own use ) we re th er efo re able to indul ge in the fashionable En gli sh prac tice of owni ng elabo rate bu sin ess ca rds. " Suc h prints, o r ep he me ra, are ex t rao rd ina rily rar e today , o nly occas io na lly p rese rve d a ft e r h a vin g se rve d th eir o r ig ina l, sho rt - lived func tions , pe rh ap s as a bill head, a cra fts ma n's label , o r an invi tation to a lon g-ago eve nt . Bo t h in Eng la n d an d h er co lo nies, desi gn s for ephe m e ra - m o stl y asy m me t r ica l ca r t o u ch cs an d v ari ation s on rec tangu la r fram es - we re b ased o n a rel ati v el y sm all n u m be r o f prototyp es. R ampant co pyi ng w as th e practice. T he ea rl ies t d at ed En gli sh ro co co trad e ca rd was made b y H enr y Co p la n d in 1738. In 1746, he issu ed A Ne w B ook oj Orna m cnrs and M a tt hi as Lo ck eng raved A B ook of S h ields, t w o sui tes o f fu lly ro co co d e corati on , m o stl y ca r to u ch es , w hi ch initiat ed th e develo p me n t o f th e sty le . 3 In 17 52, th e two d esi gn er s co lla bo ra te d o n ano t he r publi cat ion , titl ed A New B ook oj O rnaments wi th T w elve L cavcs, w hic h w as th e vo lume th at fir st m ad e popular a light an d airy n atu rali sm and a tast e for fantasy and whim sy ."
(N o . 13) at tr ibu te d to Revere, m ad e for Wi lliam J ack so n , a B o ston dr y- g o od s m er ch an t and p rominent Tory, who pasted a co py on th e back of a loo king g lass he imported and so ld in 1770. 5 Th e im pr ession illu strat ed h ere was used as a bill for a t rans act ion of 28 Au gust 1773, as insc ribed on the rever se. For printin g o n p ap e r , th e engraver cu t t he d esig n in rev er se o n a co p pe r pl at e . For eac h impress io n , o r co py , required, he inked th e plate, covered it wi th a sheet of paper, an d ran it throu gh a pr ess.(, Fo r eng rav ing on various scientifi c o r m easurin g devi ces-cl o ck dia ls of silve red brass , for exa m p le -a n d th e o rna menta l mo un ts o f fir ea rm s o r o t her w eapons , th e design w as not reversed but eng raved as it was to b e se en, as o n o bjec ts of sil v e r. It was th e refor e n ot uncomm on for eng rave rs t o p ro v id e t heir se rv ices to si lve rs m it hs; a lte rna tively , so me silve rsm it h s, most not abl y Paul Rev er e, we re also ex pe rt engravers . Th e ma in ce n te rs of eng rav ing we re Bos ton an d Philadelphia. N ew York 's p ractitioner s, th ou gh less ac tive, had clo se ti es w ith th eir Ph il ad el phi a peer s, an d, lat e in the ce n t u ry, wh at mi ght b e co ns ide re d a d istin ct i v e regi on al sc hoo l of e ng rave rs flouri sh ed in ce n t ra l Co n nec tic u t. In B o st on , the eng ra ve rs w hose wor k inclu d e d fine rococo o rna men t were Thom as J ohn st on (h is birthp lace unkn o wn) and N athaniel Hurd an d Paul Rever e, both nati ve b o rn. Their wo rk was decorative but o rde rly, havin g sy m me trical ca rto uc hes ma de u p of scrolls, foliage, and o the r m oti fs
H+itillg ccrtijicate, attributed to Abel Buel! (N o . 36 )
37
12
13
Trade card ofJ oseph Welch London, 1760-6 5 Engraving on paper, 6% x 5-% in. The Metropolitan Museum of Art
Trade card of Willialll J acksoll Attributed to Paul Revere. Boston, 176 5-70 Engraving on paper, 7% x 6 1/4 in. American Antiquarian Society
o f th e ro coco rep ert oire . J ohnst on ( 1708- 1767) w as ac tive in B ost on b y 1726 an d adve rt ise d hi s own sho p in 173 2. 7 In his tr ad e ca rd o f th at yea r, he d escrib ed him self as a "jap an er " w ho did j apannin g , varn ishi ng, drawin g , gild ing, paintin g , and eng rav ing . H e was also a h ou sep ainter, a sig n painter, an d an o rga n build er. His success ca n b e m easured by th e subs ta n tial esta te h e had am assed at his death . ~ O f th e m ore th an thirt y kn own eng ravings of hi s, four m ap s, t w o tr ad e ca rds, an d o ne b o o kpl at e in clu de clem ents o f ro co co o rnam ent. Hi s fir st essa y in th e sty le see ms to have been th e titl e car tou ch e o n a m ap h e m ad e in 17 5 3 . T h e p aint e r J ohn Greenwoo d , w ho was ap p re n ticed to J ohn ston fro m abo ut 1742 to 1745, lat er recall ed th at o ne of h is task s durin g th at period was to eng ra ve bo o kplates. ~
Nath an iel Hurd ( 1730- 1777 ) was b orn in Bo s ton and tr ained in silve rs m it hi ng b y h is fathe r, th e highl y regard ed cra fts ma n J acob Hurd (sec p . 84) . The yo u nge r Hurd never di stin gu ish ed him self as a s ilve rs mi t h b u t exce lled in eng raving o n b oth co p pe r an d silver. H e is best kn o wn for hi s heraldi c b ookpl at es, fort y o f w h ic h arc sig ne d by h im and fifteen m o re arc att ri bu ted to h im. W The so u rce for th e her aldic illu str at ion s o n at leas t t w ent y- eight of th e fifty- five pl at es wa s J ohn Guill irns Displ ay 4 H eraldry, th e six th edi tion (Lo nd o n, 1724) " imp ro ved wi th lar ge ad di tio ns of m an y hundred coa ts o f arms." II Wh en Hurd's po rt rait was painted by J ohn Sin gleton Cop ley abo ut 1765 , th e subje ct was seat ed be hi nd a tabl e o n w hic h lay a co p y of th e herald ic ma nual. " B o st on-b orn P aul Re ve re ( 173 5- 18 18) was t rained as a
silve rs m ith by his Fren ch im m ig rant fathe r, Apollos Riv oire, an d t o ok o ve r h is sho p in 17 54-, afte r R i vo i res de ath . Rever e 's career in eng ravi ng g rew ou t o f his silve rs m ithing and re mai ned secon da ry to it. Hi s tw o vo lu mes o f D ay Books . o r led g er s (the fir st coveri ng th e years 1761 - 83; the seco nd, 17 84 - 9 7), d o cum ent h is bu sin ess in b oth sk ills. 13 T h ou gh th e b o ok s record o n ly o u ts ta n d ing ac co u n ts and co nta in no m ention o f w o rks paid for in cas h on delivery o r o f pr oj ect s he initiat ed him self, th ey do cument his produ cti o n o f th e full ran g e of printed ep heme ra , including Massachuse tts cu rre ncy an d me tal- cut illu strations for magazines an d new sp aper s, m any of whi ch h av e b een identified and show ro co co influ en ce . All to ld, Revere is asso ciated wi th ele v en bookpl at es an d a lik e number o f trade ca rds . q Th ou gh as an eng ra ve r h e is best known for patriotic propaga n da print s, es pecia lly hi s representati on o f the Boston M assacr e, a number o f hi s b ookp lat es, tr ad e cards , and certificates are acco m plishe d exa m ples of th e roco co sty le. In 1757, R ev ere m ar ri ed Sar ah O rne ( 1736 - 1773) an d afte r her dea th he m arried Rachel Walk er ( 1745-18 13); eleve n childre n s urvive d fro m th e tw o m arr iag es. A s a p atri ot, Revere, w ho served b rie fly as a lieu te na nt in th e French and In dia n Wa r (1754--63), is fa mous fo r h is Rev o lut ion ar y ac tiv i ties, especia lly th e o ne im m o rt al ized in 1861 b y Lo ng fe llow in The lv[idllig h t R ide oj Paul R ev ere. Re vere em ba rked o n th at rid e on 18 April 1775 as m essen ger for the M assachusetts Com mi ttee o f Correspo nde nce . He w as also a mem be r o f th e Son s o f Lib ert y an d, fr om 1776 to 177 9, lieutenan t co lo ne l o f the M assachu setts Sta te 's Train of Artillery. A p rominent Freem ason, he belon ged to three different lo dges be twee n '760 an d 1810 and w as Grand M ast er of the G rand Lodge o f M assachusetts from 179 5 to 179 7. 15 In Philad elphi a, th e mo st fam ou s en gra vers to work in the ro co co sty le w ere James Turn er , Henry D awkins , and J am es Smith er. All w er e En gli sh immi gr ants who h ad t rai ne d in th e s pecia lty. Th ei r o rna me n ta l w ork, in the Englis h m ann er see n in eng ravings b y Lo ck , Co plan d, and Jo h nso n, has a g rea te r se nse o f m ovem ent , o f asy m met ry, tha n does th at of th e Bo st on engrave rs . Turner (active 1743-
m ap o f the middle Br iti sh colon ies in 1755, J o shu a Fisher's cha rt o f Delaw ar e Bay (No. 38) in 1756, and Nicholas Scull's m ap o f th e Pr ovince o f Penn sylvania in 1758. T u rne r died of sma llpox th e ne xt year. Henry D awkin s (d. (786) worked in New Yo rk as well as in Phil adelphi a . I X T he son ofJ oh n Dawki ns, a Lo n d o n bri ckl ay er , h e w as a p pre n ticed in 1749, after h is fa ther's death, to th e Lond on engrave r J am es Wigley. I') By 1754, he w as in N ew York, w here he eng raved a b ookplat e (No. (8 ) for J ohn Burnet. In 1755, D aw kin s adve rt ised th at he had set up hi s o w n sh o p , "where h e eng raves in all so rts of m etta ls." 2O Short ly afte r ward , he m o v ed to Phi lad elphi a an d th er e, in 1757, m arried Pri scill a Wo od . H e wo r ke d bri efl y for Turn er before an no u nc ing in J anu ar y 17 58 th at h e h ad opened his ow n bu sine ss in neigh bo rin g pr em ises:
d . (7 59) lo cat e d fi rst in t h a t ci ty, where hi s ea rl ies t kn o wn
o r name n ts G u ns a nd P ist o ls , both engraving and in laying
effo rt, a view of Bo ston H arbor, ap pea re d in Th e A merican M ag azin e of 1743, an d ano the r o f th e same su bjec t w as published th e foll owin g yea r. 16 T w o yea rs lat er, he advert ised as a silve rs mi t h an d eng rave r. Hi s views of Bo st on Harb or p roba b ly attra cted th e attention o f th e m ag azin e's Philadelp h ia di stribut or , B enj amin Fr ankl in . Fr ankl in ar ran ge d fu rt he r co m m iss io ns for Turn er and m ay h av e b een th e cause o f his movin g to Phil adelphia, wher e he had settled by 17 54 . 17 Fr anklin ' s influen ce provided Turn er with his th ree m aj or eng ra v ing co m m iss io ns in the city- Lew is Evan s 's
Silver, at th e m o st Reason abl e Rat es. "'4 H e is known bes t fo r t he spectac u la r ro co co advertise men ts of th e Ph ilad elphian s Benj am in Ran d ol p h an d Rob ert Ken ned y (Nos. 32, 3 3) . In 1769, Smith er adver tised " P ro posa ls for o pe ning A Drawin g Sch o ol, Bein g a n ew in st ituti on in th is ci ty ... where yo u ng ge n tle me n an d ladi es sha ll b e ca re fu lly in structed in th at useful art. "' 5 H e m o ved to N ew York in 1777 , sho rt ly b efo re th e S u p re me E x ecuti v e Co u nc il of Penn s yl va n ia accu sed him of th e cri me also co m mi tte d by Dawkins - co unterfeiting currency .
H en r y D awkin s . Engraver from London. W ho lately w ro ug h t wi t h M r. J am es T u rner; hav ing now. ente red in to b us iness for himself. . . engraves all so rts of maps. Shopkeepe rs bills. bills of parcels . coa ts of Arms for gen tlern ens books, coa ts of Arms. cyphers and other devices on Plat e likew ise seals and mourning rings cut after th e neatest manner and at the most reasonable rates.' 1
D awk in s return ed to New Yo rk in 1774, on t he eve of the Revoluti on . Thou gh he was impriso ned for coun terfeiting co lo n ia l b ank n ot es in 1776, two yea rs la te r foun d him engravi ng th e fir st coa t of ar ms for New York State and , in 1780, th e new co u n try's officia l currency. The las t me nt ion o f him is in an adve rt isement o f 3 M ay 1786 in Ph iladelphia's Freeman' s j ournal for th e sa le of "Eig h t el eg antl y eng raved co pper- plates, by D awkin s. " " J am es Smither ( 1741-1797) is th ou ght to h ave tr ain ed in En gland as a maker and orna mcn ter o f fir carrn s. f' Th e fir st notice o f him in Am eri ca was in th e Pennsylvania C hronicle o f 18 Apri l 176 8, where h e an no u nce d th at h e perform ed " All M anner of Engravin g in Go ld, Silve r, Coppe r, Stee l, and all o the r M et als- C oat s of A rm s, and Seals, done in th e neatest M ann er. Lik ewise cu ts St am ps, Br and s, an d m et al C u ts for P rint ers, an d o rna me n ta l Tools fo r B o o k b ind e rs. H e also
39
co lo n is ts , suc h as J am es Lo g an, w hose fu lly ro co co boo kplat e m u st d at e we ll b efor e hi s d e ath , in 17 5 1, h a d t h e ir bookplat es engra ve d in En gl and . 2 ( '
Bookplates
N athani el Hurd s pecia lize d in th e re n deri ng of bookp lates, three-qu arter s o f th em ro co co in sty le , for Bo ston 's elite. 2 7 Th e ea rl ie s t d at ed Am eri can r o co co b o o kp la te (N o . 14) , eng ra ve d w it h th e n am e o f Thom as D erin g ( 1720 - 178 S) an d th e dat e 1749, was m ad e b y Hurd w he n he w as o nly nineteen years o ld . Th e m antlin g , whi ch h e w as to e mp lo y on a numb er of later b o okp lat es, s ig na led th e int ro du ct io n o f ro co co-st yl e eng raved o rna men t to N ew England . T he D er in g famil y is ge ne ra lly ass o cia t e d w it h N e w York , but Th om as w as bo rn in B o ston an d m o ved to Shelter Isl an d , o ff th e eas te rn end of Lon g Isl and , N ew Yo rk, on ly in 17 S0 . Th e a r ms (t h ree s tags ' head s) are lik e th o se of th e D eerin g famil y g iven in G u illi ms D ispl ay oj H eraldry. 2H T he asym m etrical m antl e o f th e b o okplate is co m pose d of C - scr oll s w it h rocaille wo r k fra m ing th e sh ield and sp iky g rasses and flower s proje ctin g fro m e it he r side ; at th e bo t to m, w ater pours fro m an o pening in a she ll.
The dim inu tive b u t e labora te ly e ngraved bo okp la te (w ha t Dawki ns ca lled "coa ts o f A rms fo r ge n tle m en s bo o ks " ) is perh ap s th e best in di cat io n of th e p restige of bo ok s an d th e va lue g iven to t heir o w nershi p in co lo n ial Am er ica. P ast ed o n th e in sid e co ve r of a b ound vo l ume (see N o . 2 1), a b o o kpl at e pr oudl y id enti fi e d its ow ner an d issu e d a t acit warn ing t o th e wo u ld -be b o rr o w e r. Alth ou gh a fe w eig hteen th-cent u ry librari es survi ve m o re or less intact, su ch as th at ofJ am es Lo g an at th e Librar y Compa ny of Ph ilad elphia an d th at o f Isaac N orris at D ick inso n College, Ca rlisle, Pennsylvani a, an d though th ere are listi ngs o f th e co ntents o f o t h e rs in e ig h t e e n t h - ce n tu r y inv ento ri es, o n ly thr ou gh book pla tes can th e lar ge number o f o nce -existing pri vate and publi c lib rar ies b e ide n ti fied . At th e en d of th e nin et eenth ce n tury, w hen it w as fas hio na b le to co llect bo okplat es, th e majori ty of Am eri can exa m p les we re rem oved fr om th eir ho us ings an d m ount ed in a lb u m s . Th ou gh d isemb odi ed , th ey still pr eser ve th e na mes of th o se Am eri can s po ssessin g eno ug h vo lu mes to wa rra nt th e co m m issio ning of a per son al lab el. Of b o o kpl at es ass ig na b le to th e third q uarter of th e eig h tee n t h ce n t u ry, th e grea t p r ep ond er an ce are in th e ro co co sty le . Unlik e any o t her form of printed ephe mera o f th e tim e, m ost survive in multipl e impressions . Bo okplates w er e always per son ali zed w it h th e owne r's n am e o r a r ms . Wh ethe r h e w as en title d to b ear t he latter, acco rd ing to th e Co llege o f H erald s in London , m att er ed not. G u ill i rns D ispl ay o] H eraldry was th e m o st p opul ar so u rce for th e a r rno ria ls. The deco rat ive carto uches or m andi n gs chosen t o su rr o u n d th e armo ria l sh ield we re co pied fr om s tock En gli s h prot ot yp es in spir ed in turn b y th e eng ravi ngs Lo ck a n d Co p la n d publi sh ed in th e 1740 S a nd 1750S. In N ew En gl and , N athani el Hurd , rel yin g heavil y o n G u ill i m, p la y ed th e lea di ng rol e in b o okpl at e d esi gn an d p roduction ; in N ew York and Phil ad elphia, D awkins prob abl y ca me as close as anyo ne to fillin g that po sit ion . Before tr ained eng rave rs w ere ava ila ble in Am er ica, so me bo okish
The ro co co-m antl e d esi gn Hurd u sed fo r T ho m as D erin g was e m p loye d w it h o n ly min o r va ria tions b y T h om as J ohn ston o n a bo okpl at e w ith th e arms of th e O liver family, featu rin g an o uts t re tc he d ar m g ras ping a gro tesquely seve red h and (N o . IS ) . The d es ign is pl a ced lo w o n t he co p p e r , leavin g no ro om fo r th e owner 's n am e. The plate is sa id to have b e en u sed b y And rew O liv er ( 170 6 - 1774) , lieut ena n t gove rno r of th e Pr ovin ce o f M as sa chu sett s Ba y .r'" Th at, h ow ever , is unlikel y ; a no t he r b o o kpl at e wi t h th e O liv er arm s, a t t r ib u te d to P aul R e v ere , promin entl y di s pl a y s O live r's n a m e. v" Th e J ohn st on b o okpl at e, o ne of four he sig ned, is hi s o n ly o ne in th e n e w s ty le . Th e a w k wa rd at tac h me n t of th e ribb on sc ro ll o n th e d esign m a y be e vi den ce that J ohnst on to ok Hurd 's basic pattern and adapted it to acco m moda te th e O live r famil y m otto. P aul R ev ere 's essays in ro co co b o okpl at e des ig n co nsist of three sig ne d plates and four o the rs th at have bee n attributed to him . .11 All hav e th e same m antl in g an d m otto ribbo n and are a slig h tly sq ua tte r, m ore sy m m et rical, and m o re co heren t versi on o f th e Hu rd a nd J o hn s ton m o de l. v'" The b ookpl at e ofE pes Sarge n t ( 172 1- 1779) , th e ar ms a chevron between three dolphin s (N o . 16), ca n be da ted precisel y . In an en t ry o f 27 Septemb er 176 4 in Rever e 's ledg ers, Sargent is c ha rged " To En gra vin g your Arm s o n a Co p pe r Pl at e 0 - 12-0 " and "To ISO P rints at 4S pr Hund . 0 - 6 -0 . " 3 .1 Th at p ro v es h o w in e xp en siv e b o okpl at es were a fte r t he ini ti al inves tm en t in th e engravi ng.
40
14
15
Bookplate of T homas Dering N ath ani el H ur d , Boston , 1749 En gr avin g o n pap er , 2 7/ 8 x 2 Y2 in . Th e M et ro po lit an Museum o f Art
Bookplate w ith Olil'erfami/}' arms Thomas J ohns ton , Bost on , 1755-65 En g ravin g o n pap er, 37/8 x 31/8 in . Ameri can Antiquari an Soc iety
16
17
Bookplate of Epcs
Bookplate of Gardiner C handler
S OI:,?Cll t
Paul Rev ere, Bo ston , ca. 176 5 En gr avin g o n pap er, 3-Y8 x 2'Y, in . Am eri can Antiqu ar ian So ciet y
Paul Revere, Bo st on , 1764 Engraving o n pap er, 3Y4 x 2Y2 in . Am eri can Antiqu arian So ciet y
41
Th e b o okpl at e for Ga rd ine r C ha n dler ( [723 - 17S2), a Bost on m erch ant and Lo yalist (N o . 17), has man tlin g identical to th at o f Ep es Sa rge nt's. It d iffe rs so mew hat, ho w ev er, fro m the m antle th at surro unds th e identical C handl er famil y arm s (t h ree lion s o n a chec ke re d g ro u nd ) on a silve r sa lve r Re ver e su p p lie d to Ga rd iner's sis te r Lu cr eti a (see No. 7[). Reve re see ms ne ver to h av e u sed th e bo o k pl ate m an tl e for any o the r purpose. Th e ea r lie s t kn o wn Am eri can e ngr avi ng b y t h e prolific H enr y Daw k ins is a b o okpl at e (N o . 18) he ma de in 175-+, durin g h is bri ef stay in Ne w York C ity, for J oh n B urn et , a lo cal at to rney . Th e desig n is co m posed ofa prin cipa l cartou ch e e n clos ing th e Bu rn et a r ms (t h ree holl y leaves and a huntin g horn ) and a seco nd , horizontal ca rtouche containin g Burnet 's nam e, th e w hole flan ked by pairs of figures appea rin g in ca re free mu s ical pur suit s . Thi s is on e of th o se rare occas io ns in Am eri can u sag e of th e h um an all usion s comm on in E u ro pea n ro c o co desig n. T he d ou b le- ca rt o u c h e a r ra nge me n t was a we ll- k now n Eng lis h o rnam ental design th at D awk in s re pea te d in a numb er of o ther bookp lates, but ne vc r aga 1l1 w it h th e t e chni cal acco m p li s hment o f thi s exa m ple.
'" ".\ '. 1\.
v~:~
Th e d oubl c-cartou ch c desig n m ad e it s way u p th e H ud so n an d was th e m odel fo r a co pper pl at e (N o . 19) engraved b y th e nati ve-born Andrew Billin gs ( [743- [SoS), of Pou gh keepsie, N e w York. But h o w diffe rent fr o m Dawkins's! While possessed o f a naiv e cha rm, th is is rende ring by a hand unt uto re d in th e ni ceti es of Eng lis h co ppe r- p late eng ra ving . T he book plate, illu strat ed in a twenti eth-century imp ression, w as m ad e fo r Philip Van Ren ssel aer ( [747 - 17CJ S), pr o babl y somet im e bet w een hi s m a rri ag e to M ari a Sa nde rs , in [7(iS, and th e buildin g o f C he r ry Hill , hi s co un t ry hou se on the outski rts o f Alb an y , in [7S(i. Th e copper pl at e, still at C herr y H ill, bears testim o n y to t he rapid t ran sform ati o n from the elega nt and form al rococo of th e ci ty's spe cially trained artisans to th e eng ag ing lin ear pattern s of th e co untry co p yist. O n e o f th e fe w d at ed Am er ican boo k p la te s in t h e ro coco m od e is th at for IEIl, V N, RENSSELAEH (N o . 20), engraved by Elisha G allaudet in [7(il . Th e ab b revia tio ns prob ably refer to J er emi as ( I73 S- 1704) , of th at bra n ch of rhe Van Ren sselae r fa mi ly th e n o cc u py in g th e Lo w er M an o r, on t he east ba nk o f th e Hudson . The boo kp late is of th e standard as ym mc rrical-ca rto u che t y pe , wi th th e fami ly 's qua rtered ar m s (cros s, ba t tle me n t a n d s ta rs, c r o w ns , c hev ro n s) in a de si gn n ot unlike th at Hurd used in N e w Eng la nd (see N o . q ) . Ga lla u dc t , b orn o f Hu gu en ot s to ck in Ne w R o ch ell e , New York, abo u t 1730, w as lo call y tr a in ed . H e m a r ried J ean ne
18
Bookplate of) 01111 Burnet Henry Dawki ns, New York, 1754 Engravi ng on paper, 37/ , x 3 in. The Metrop olitan Museum of A rt
42
19
Platejar Philip Vall Rensselaer bookplate Andrew Billin gs. Pou ghk eep sie. 17(jS-S6 En gr aving on co pper. 3% x 2 7/ H in. Toge ther with recent impression (abo ve) H isto ric Cherr y H ill
R
:ar
·
. ~
20
IE:V: REN.sSELAER.:.-
Bookplate (~fJcrel/lias Val/ Rensselaer Elisha Gall aud ct , N ew Yor k . 17(,1 En gra vin g on paper , 31/2 x 2% in. H istor ic C he rry Hill
43
21
Bookplate oj Isaac N orris J am es Turner. Philadelphia. ca. 17 57 En gr avin g on pap er, 3 'I" x 2-% in. O n inside cove r o f book Dickin son C olle ge
ab roa d as a yo u ng m an led h im to increase m an yfol d th e library he inherit ed fr om hi s farhe r .:'" In Novem be r 1757, he be g an a ca t a log ue o f th e b o ok s ; th at is lik el y th e t im e h e order ed hi s bo okpl ate fr om Turn er. Th e librar y desce n de d to hi s d au ghter M ar y, w ho m arried J ohn Dickinson in 1770. In 178 5, Di ckin son ga ve so me six tee n hun dr ed o f the vo lum es to wh at w as to be nam ed Dick in son College, at C~ r li sl e, where th e y st ill rem ain . Som e four hundred o f them have the Turner bookpl at e, ofte n past ed o n to co lo rful m arbled board s, an evoca tive reminder of a learn ed Am erican 's librar y . J"
Dubo is in 17 5 5 and b y 17 59 was in N ew York C ity , when he was li st ed as a su bscr iber, alo ng wi t h " M r. Furer [Fu et er]' Silvers m it h in Fre nc h C h urch Street," to a series o f eng ra ve d port raits . H In I n l , Ga lla u de r m oved fr om Smith Street t o th e " B roa d - Way near th e B o wling Green ," wher e he carr ied on hi s eng rav ing busin css. v' H is Van Ren ssel aer boo k p la te ill us t ra tes a conside ra b le co m pe te nce , thou gh n o ge n ius, in th e technique o f English eng rave d rococo ornament. A sma ll nu m b er of b o okpl ates eng raved in Phil ad elphi a b y T u rner or Dawk ins exh ib it th e writhin g an d ene rge tic qu ality, th e pi ayfu l irrat ion alit y , o f th e eng raved ro co co d esi gns Loc k and Co p la n d pub li sh ed in Lond on . Turn er , wh o as ea rly as 18 10 was d e s crib ed as "th e b est eng r a ve r w h ic h ap pea re d in t he co lo n ies b efore th e revoluti on , " 3 6 reach ed t he a pogee o f h is t al ent durin g hi s Ph il ad elphia soj ourn o f five or six yea rs be fore hi s d eath , in 17 59. Among hi s fine st wo rk is a bo okplate (N o . 21 ) , m ad e for th e bibliophile Isaac N o r ri s , o f th e do u b le-cartou ch e t yp e: th e upp er part surroun d ing th e N o rr is a r ms (ch ev r o n bet w een three r a vens ' heads) is in Co p la n d's spiky style (see FI G . 3, p . 3); th e vase at t he m iddl e r ig h t w as a m otif mu ch favored b y Phil ad elp hia ca rvers (see N o . 160). N orris ( 1701- 1766) to ok over th e fami ly mercantile business at hi s father 's d eath, in 173 5, and in 17 50 was elec te d to t he firs t o f seve ra l t erm s as Sp e ak er o f th e P enn s yl van ia A ssembl y . A so li d class ica l ed uc at io n an d ex te ns ive trav el
Amon g D awkin s ' s b e st ro co co book p lates is th e o ne h e made for Francis H opkin son (N o . 22 ) . Th e asy m me trica l ca r tou ch e is enliv en ed by a fanta st ic hi s sin g d rago n se t again st a clo udy sky, th e so rt of ca p rice th at is cha rac teris tic of Co p la n d's w ork . H opkin s on ( 17 3 7 - 17 9 1) was b orn in Philad elphia and st u d ied law u n de r Benj am in C hew, at torne y g en er al of th e Pro vin ce o f Pennsyl vania. An au t ho r an d accompli sh ed mu si ci an , H opki n son presum ably ga t hered a siz abl e librar y . The bo okplat e, w ith th e fami ly arms (a chevron an d three sta rs), w as probabl y o rde red so metime arou nd hi s seco n d marri ag e, to Ann Bord en, in 1768 . Ab out 1773 , h e m ov ed t o B ord ent o wn (na me d fo r hi s fa t he r- in - law), N ew Jersey, wher e he rapidl y ac hieved pol iti cal pr ominen ce. He w as a sig ne r o f th e D e clar at ion of Indep end en ce fro m New J ers ey .
22
Bookplate of Francis Hopkinson Henr y D awkins, Phil adelph ia, ca. 1768 Eng ravi ng on pape r, 3 '!~ x 3 in. Am erican Anti qua rian Socie ty
45
Books, M etal Cuts, and
A co mplete A.ss o R T M E NT at th~ UNI VERSAL STORE, or
Bookbindings
Bo ok s o f shee t musi c reprodu ced b y m ean s o f co p pe r- p late eng ravi ngs and w ith eng raved titl e pages are amo ng th e few Am er ican imprints to have fashi on abl e ro coco o rna m en t. A good exa m p le is J am es Lyon 's Urania, or A C hoice Collection (~r Psalm- TIIIlCS, A nt hems, and H YIllIl S (N o . 23). The vo lu me was exec u te d in Philad elphi a in 17°1 b y th e ind e fati gabl e Daw kin s. A h and some ca rto uc he, occas io n ally in vaded b y the lett erin g, fill s t he n arr o w h ori zont al space o f th e title page. Urania w as one o f so me two do zen publicati on s issu ed be t w een 1760 a n d [705 b y Willi am Br adford ( 1722 - 1791), wh o had learn ed th e printin g tr ad e fro m Andrew Br adford , hi s un cle an d th e founder o f th e first newsp ap er in Penn sylva n ia. Mu si c b o ok s lik e th ese we re ex t re mely popul ar. In Boston , between 17 55 and 176o , T ho mas J ohnst on eng ra ve d e it he r thr ee or fou r se ts o f s uc h p la t es . ?" In 17°4 , Rev ere co pie d D awkin s's titl e page alm o st exactly for A Collection (~r T he best Psalm TIIIlCS, ill tw o, three, andfo ur Parts,"? co m piled b y J o si ah Flag g, an almos t unp reced ented case o f Phil ad elphi a en gr avin g having influen ce in Bost on . Illu st rat ion s fo r eig h tee nt h-century new sp ap ers, br o ad sid es, alma na cs, an d pam phl ets we re almos t always m et al cu ts th at is, eng ra v ings o n t ype-m et al (a lead alloy) suitab le for in corporati on in pages o f n ewsprint. The b est do cumented of s uch. wo r k is a g r o u p o f some twe n ty- two b y P aul R e vere , wh o in hi s led ge r referred to th e pro ce ss as " E n g ra vi ng a Leadin g p la te for n e w sp ap er. "4 ' Re vere ' s met al cu ts neve r ev ince th e as pi ra tio n to orn am ent of hi s eng ra vings. Of all th e met al- cut illu strati on s in th e co lo n ial press, o n ly o ne can be 5a id t o aim fo r h igh rococo fas hio n : th e adve rt ise me n t ( FIG. 24) of th e N e w York dr awin g ma st er and m er ch ant Ge ra r d us Du y cki n ck (1723 - 1797), w h ic h ap pea re d in Th e N ew - York Ga zette and the Week ly M ercury from 170 7 to 1769. O n D uycki nc k 's notice, do zen s of rococo raffl es and sc ro lls are link ed to g et he r to crea te a m ir rorlik e fr am e- lo n g a n d na r row t o fit th e sha pe of a n e w sp ap er co lu m n - in w hich to pr ocl aim Du yckinck 's wa res.
FIG UR E 2 4.
Ad vertisem ent of Gera rd us D uy ckinck ,
1767-6'), The New- York Ga zette awl the Weekl y M crcurv, M etal cut o n paper , ')% x 3 in . (23. ') x 7.6 cm. )
------- -_ .- - - --'- =
.. ~'- ---""
~----~-"j
.- ../
23 Title page of Urania H enr y Da wkins , Philadelphia , 1701 En g ravin g on paper , 4 x 81/2 in. American Antiq uar ian Soc iety
Deco ra te d boards o n American bookbindin gs from th e latter part of th e e ig h t ee n t h ce n t u ry a re v e ry r ar e , prim aril y beca use o f a tr end th at began in the 1760s, with th e in creased ava ilabi li ty o f b o o k s , t o s h e lve them upright , with their spines visib le, rather than horizontall y, w ith th e ed ges of the p ag es ex po se d . (Isaac N orris m ad e that shelving sw itc h in 1764.)42 Stored in th e ne w way, the co ve rs we re not vi sibl e an d th er e was n o pu rp o se in de co ratin g th em . The onl y exce p tio ns we re p resentati on volum es, o fte n k ept out o n a table . P erh ap s th e so le Ameri can binder w ho se w ork ever really ac hieved a roco co sensibility was Rob ert Aitken ( 1735(80 2). T rain ed in hi s n ati ve Scotl and, he m ad e a re connaissa nc e v is it to Phi lad el phi a ill th e s u m m e r o f 1769 . In M a y 1771, he se ttle d th er e perm anentl y wi t h hi s famil y; a m onth later he se t up hi s printin g and bindery sho p o n Front Street . Th e was te boo k , o r lo g , o f th at busin ess, whi ch dates fr om th e shop 's incepti on until 180 2, d et ail s it s su ccess. In 1782, Ait ken was described as " ha ving th e m ost tast e o f a printer of an y m an in [Philadelphia]. "4.1 Aitken 's g rea t ro co co ac hieve men t wa s th e spec ial bindin g of a n u m b er o f co pies o f a popul ar Scotti sh w ork , L eet ures 0 11 Rhetoric and B elles L cu res, b y Hu gh l3lai r. Aitk en pu b li shed th e fir st Am eri can ed itio n o f th e b o ok in 1784,
co u n tin g on g oo d sa les to m ak e up fo r th e m on e y h e h ad lost on the so-called Ait ken l3ibl e, an ed ition he had brou ght out in 1782 . Of L ectures 011 Rh etoric, he sa id , " If th e Lit er ati are not blind to th eir own inter est , [th ey] mu st purch ase th is wo rk with g rea t avidity. " ?" O f th e few existing co pies of the thick paper ed iti o n , wi t h its elabo ra te ly to ol ed leat her bindin gs, on e has a hist ory o f havin g bee n pr esented b y an o the rwi s e unid entifi ed G era r d us C la rkso n to hi s so n in 1788, wh en the yo u t h g ra d ua ted fro m N assau H all. That p roven an ce co r res po nds to a bindin g e n t ry in th e was t e b o ok, sec u ring the bind in g 's at t ributi o n .t'" On ano t he r co py (N o . 24 ) , sa id to h av e b el on g ed t o o ne C ha r les Th omp son (C ha rles Th om son , fi r st se cretar y o f the Co n t ine n t a l Co n -
g res s?), th e bindin g is o f smoo t h red m oro cco, ela bo ra te ly tooled in go ld .'!" The spi ne has six pan els, o ne w it h th e title, BLAIR' S / LE CTU RES , eac h o f th e others w it h a cen t ra l o v al and a ribbon . Th e fr ont a n d b a ck cove rs h a v e el abor at e foli at e bord er s d e co rat ed w it h a b ask et an d co lu m ns an d inh abited b y pa r rots, pho eni xes, an d in sect s. Wer e th e d ies for th ese st amp s amo ng th e o r na me n ta l t o ol s for b o okbinders Smither adve rt ise d in 176S? London bindin gs o f th e ea rly 1770S di spl a y a lmos t id enti cal w ild life but a rc more pr ecise!y det ailed . 17
47
24 Back cover o f Lectures Oil Rhetoric and Belles Lcttrcs Rob ert Aitken , Phi ladelphi a, 178-l Red mor occo, go ld tooled , 10% x 8% in. Ameri can Antiquarian Socie ty
Trade Cards and Other Epheme ra
In E ng lan d an d in h er Ameri can co lo n ies, e ng rave rs w er e ca lle d o n to provi de o rna me n ta l prints to be distributed in fu rt hera nce o f ind iv id ua l bu sin esses an d th e activiti es of vario us o rga n iza tio ns . What had bee n an occasio na l ve nt u re in advertising in th e 1730S and 1740S became a co m mo n pr acti ce b y th e [760 s, w he n a n umb er o f lar ge an d h and som e rococo shee ts eng raved in th e fu ll Lon don m anner we re produced in America. T he tr ad e ca rd (sho rt for tr ad esm an 's card) usu all y co nsis te d of an o rname nta l carro uc he deck ed o ut w it h illu str ation s of th e wa res of th e m er ch an t o r th e sho p kee pe r and con tai n ing hi s n am e , add re ss, a n d a de scripti on of hi s inte res ts . Th e y r an g e in s ize fr om little lar g er than a boo k pla teto a fu ll p ag e. In 1774, t w o recentl y a rriv ed London engravers - Jo h n Hutt in N ew Yo rk an d J ohn Norm an in Philad elph ia -u sed almos t pr ecisely th e same lan gu age to adve rtise t he va rie ty o f th eir co m me rc ial ep he me ra , whi ch in cluded shop b ills, b ills of excha nge, bill s o f ladin g , bill s of parcels.! " Th o se distin cti on s no lon ger ha ve mu ch m eaning, tho ug h some of th e few exa m p les th at rem ain, m o stl y in uniqu e im p ress ion s, h a ve ac t ua l acco unts w ritte n on th em . O ther popul ar uses of o rna men ta lly eng raved shee ts we re as cer tifica tes o f m ember ship o r achieveme nt in an o rga niza tio n and as invi ta tio ns to , o r n otifi cati on s o f, an org ani zati on ' s even t. R e v ere ' s led g e r s include num e rou s ch a rges for cng rav ing s ingle pl ates , usuall y a t a cos t o f b et w een t w o an d
t hree pou nds, an d fo r print in g b et w een o ne hundred a n d t w o h u n d red im p ress io ns , at a cos t o f four to six sh illings pe r hundred. O ne o f th e ea rl ies t Am eri can ro co co trad e ca r ds w as engraved in [757 b y Thom as J ohnst on for Bost on hardwar e me rcha n t Lew is D ebl oi s (N o. 25) . The phrase " Bot o f Lewis Deb lois" eng ra ve d b y J ohn st on belo w th e o rna me n t sho ws the exa mp le to have ac tua lly been a bill head, th e lower part of the sheet n o w re moved. Wh at is kn o wn abo ut D eb lo is is
25
T radc card of Lewis D cblois T homas j ohnston, Bost o n , 1757 Eng rav ing on paper, (,.% x 7% in. W in tert h ur Library
49
g lea ne d from hi s adve rtise me n ts in Bo sto n newspapers. In [7 5[ , h e was in p artn e r ship w it h h is b ro ther Gilbert, an importer o f brass an d pe wter; in Septem ber 1757. he was in partn er ship w ith a m an nam ed Wi ckh am at the sign of the Golden E agl e . Before th e en d o f the year, acco rd ing to the tr ad e ca rd, D ebl o is was o n hi s own at the Golden Eagle, in D o ck Squ ar e; in April 17 58, he adve rt ised fro m t her e again . In J anu ar y 1761, "l ately re tu rne d from Lon don ," he o pened a n ew s to re o n Kin g S t ree t , w h e re h e so ld p ap e r h a n g in g s (wa llpa pe r) and fab rics , as w ell as hardwar e. ~ y W hen he und erto ok to mak e D ebl oi s' s card, J ohnston 's on ly previous essays in th e ro co co had been una ssum ing title ca r t o u c he s for fo ur map s h e en gr av ed bet w een 17 5 3 an d 1756. 50 T he card s ho ws him tec hnicall y profi cient but not fu lly comfortab le with th e s ty le . Thou gh th e o rna me n ta l frame work is p erfectl y sy m me t ric al, exce p t a t th e lo w e r middle, th ere is an almos t di scon certing imbalan ce abo ut th e design th at results from th e o ff-cen te r placem ent o f the text. which o ccas io n ally excee ds its b ound s. The ru led line that forms an in effective boun d ar y aro und th e design is contrary to th e se nse o f free do m th at is a n essen tial ele ment of the ro co co . N ath ani el Hurd, b est kn o wn for hi s bookpla tes . also en g ra ve d a var iet y o f bu siness ephe me ra, incl udi ng a furniture label for Benj amin Fr othin gh am (FIG. 32 , p. [30 ) and th e highl y o rna me n ta l orde r bl ank o f th e N ich ol as B ro w n co m pan y o f Providen ce, m ak er s of sp erm acet i cand les (N o . 26 ) . Scro llwork with e mergent folia ge an d ro caill e appears to be g ro w ing ou t o f, and perhaps consumin g, th e st raig h t, mold ed fram e ; wit hi n th e s m all ca rt o uc he o n to p is a vig n ett e of a w h alin g sce ne . T h e leg en d within th e fr am e is given in En glish at t he top and in Fren ch at th e bottom. In t he m idd le, fla nkin g a rep resenta tion of th e mi ght y sper m wh ale , a re s paces , ap p a re n tly for d enotin g th e numb er o f cand les of va rio us sizes to th e pound . The Nich ol as Bro wn co m pa ny w as es ta blis hed in 1762 in Providen ce, Rh od e Is lan d . On e o f th e specia lties of t he firm' s internation al tr ad e was sp erm -w hale o il. A s ea rly as 1748 , ca nd les m ad e from th at o il had been described lo call y as " e x ceed in g all o t he rs for B eaut y , Sw eetn ess of Scent w he n ex tin g u ishe d ; Durati on, bein g m ore th an do uble Tallow Ca nd les o f equal size ; D imens io ns o f Flam e, nearly four Times m ore . " 51 The co m pa ny tr an sform ed th e spe rma ce ti candle bu siness from a hou seh old activ ity to a facto ry setting an d we n t o n to m on op oli ze th e Am eri can m a rk e t. Littl e wonder that the y w ould go to Boston for a bu sin ess card in th e latest internation al sty le. Ab out '7 53, Hurd had eng raved a comparable o rde r b lank for ano th er ca n d lcm aker , J o seph P al me r, of G erman town, ne ar Boston . On th e P alm er
26
T rade card oj Nic holas Brown & CO li/pail}' Nathaniel Hurd, Boston, ca. 1702 Engraving on paper, 6 1/ 4 x 7 7/ 8 in. The John Carter Brown Library, Brown University
So
27
28
Trade card ofJ oseph Webb Paul Revere, Boston , 1765 Engraving on paper, 71/2 x 6 in. American Ant iquarian Society
No tification of meeting Saint Peter's Lodge, Newburyport Paul Revere, Boston, 1772 Engraving on paper, 7% x 61/2 in. American Antiqu arian Society
exa m ple, the o rna menta l m antel had a rectilinear interior and was of a heavier and m ore sta tic design .52
Webb ( 1734- 1787), a m er ch ant and ship cha n d le r, was, lik e Revere, prominent as both a patriot and a Fr eem ason . N ote th e u se o f Mas on ic e m b le ms (a sq ua re , a co m pass ) at th e card 's bottom.
Pa u l Re vere ' s led g ers re cord th e eng rav ing o f so m e dozen shopkeeper's ca rds, o r adve rt ise me n ts . Th e fi v e th at a re k nown to day clea rl y show t ha t Rever e' s ro co co o rna m ental style wa s fu lly matured by th e mid- 1760s . Th e m o st elabora te of th em, th at o f j o seph W ebb (N o . 27 ), is re corded u nde r th e d at e 28 Se p te m be r 176 5: " Mr j o seph Webb Dr se t tled I T o En gravin g a Co p per Pl at e for Ad v erti sem ents 3- 0- 0 I To I S O Ad v erti sem ent s Pr intin g a t 4-1 p er Hdd 0-7-0 . " 53 The ro co co car ro uc he is bestrewed with pots an d ke t tles an d o t he r ite ms o f hardwar e th at Webb purveyed at his sto re near Ol iver's Dock, Bost on . Thou gh m ost of what he so ld was utilit ar ian and pl ain , so me o f th e o rn am en tal ir o n ch imn e yb a ck s for j eremi ah Lee ' s g ra n d Marblehead ho use ca me from him and be ar hi s nam e (see p. 220) . joseph
R e v ere , wh o w as prob abl y t he leadi ng Fr e e m aso n in all N e w En gl and, m ad e eigh t different engravings fo r various Ma son ic g ro u ps, t w o o f w hic h h a v e th e sa me mantl ing d es ign as found o n th e W e b b card . 54 Th e fir st , a p rin ted n otifi cation for Saint Pet er 's Lo d g e in N ew buryp ort (N o . 28), is list ed in hi s led g er en t ry o f I S Se p te m ber 1772:"M r. Sim on Greenleaf N ewbur y-p ort Dr I T o En grav in g a p la te for N otifi cati on 2-8 -0 I To 300 P rints 0-18 -0. " 55 Greenl ea f w as a cha rt er member o f th e Lodg e, which was formed th at yea r. The copy sh o w n w as m ade o u t to an En o ch Pik e in the Masonic yea r 5777 (1777). Th e secon d was d one for o ne of two Saint Andrew's Lod ges in Bost on in 1784. 56
The real eye-catcher amo ng Re vere 's rococo ep heme ra is the ce rt ificate issu ed to th o se wh o at te n ded th e ana to m ica l lectures and surgica l dem on strat ions (fo r th e latt er. read dissection s, not at fir st publicl y co ndo ne d) o f D r. J ohn Wa rre n of Bo ston . In 1780 , Warren so ug h t t o laun ch "a n in ci p ie n t medical sch ool in stituti on, " 57 an am bition th at result ed three yea rs lat er in the foundin g o f the H arvard m edi cal sc hool. where Warren w as professor o f ana to m y an d surge ry. T he ce r tificate, the cos t o f it s eng ra ving und er written b y a subsc riptio n in 1780 , was g ive n to st ude n ts in Warren 's pr ivate co u r ses ( 1780-8 2) o r, la t e r , h is univ er sit y cl asses. Le vi Ba rtle t t ( 1763- 1828), t he re cipient of t hi s exa m ple (N o. 29 ) o n 8 Jun e 178 5, be came a dis ting u is hed ph ysi ci an . O n th e cert ificate, Rever e 's sc ro lled fram e is bo lder and sim pler th an th o s e of the 176 0 s, a nd hi s use of four lar ge im ag es - th e he ad of the se cond - centur y Gr eek ph ysi c ian Ga le n, t w o han gin g sk eleton s, a n d a di ss ecti on in pro gress - h as a gho ulish effe ct. It was not for th e faint of heart. 5 X N ot mu ch r o co co e p he me ra r em ain s from cw Yo r k. Samue l Prin ce ' s furnitur e la bel , pr ob ab l y th e work of a locall y tr ain ed art isa n who 'd id not sig n his name (FI G. 37. p. 1 5~ ) , h as a n in g enu ou s c ha r m. Th e bill head engraved by J o h n H u rt in 1771 for th e uph ol st er er Ri ch ar d Ki p ( FIG. 25) uses the o u tl ine o f a bed st ead (its ca no py co pied from The Dirc{(or) in pl ace o f an o rna men ta l cartouc he. That made for th e Ne w York m athem ati cal in strum entm ak er A nth o n y Lam b (N o . 30), o ne o f th e gra ndest of Am eri can advertising she e ts , is t he work o f H e n r y Dawkin s . Sin ce n o ot her rococo man tling b y D awki ns has quite the o ve rall co he rence and co m petenc e demonst rated b y this ex am ple, it must have bee n co p ied dir e c tl y from on e of man y sim ilar Eng lis h car d s. (T h a t fa cilit y o f Dawk in s ' s wa s t o le ad him int o tem ptation : as alrea dy no ted , he w as imprison ed in 1776 fo r co unte rfeiting. ) Lamb, born about 1703. was m ad e a freem an of th e Ci ty o f N ew York in 17 31 a n d a d ve rt ise d as a ma t he matical in strum entm ak er in 1 7~ 9 and aga in in 1753. T w o years later, o n 25 O ctob er 1755, it was anno unced in The New- York Merwry th at " Henry D awkin s, eng rave r , w ho latel y lived with Mr. Anthon y Lam b. has now se t up hi s [ow n] b us iness . " 5') D awkin s had co me to N ew York abou t 17H and was to m o ve to Phil adelphi a by '757: pr esum ab ly , he executed the Lamb card whil e residin g w ith Lamb and in his em ploy. 29 Certijicate of attendance
Dr. 11~1'TCIl'S anat om ical lectures Paul Revere, Boston . 1780 En gr avin g o n paper. 9 1/4 x 7% in. Am eri can Antiqu aria n Societ y
A noth er N e w York exa m pie o f th e full rococo sty le is the ca rd o f no tificatio n , o r in vit ati on , for m eetin gs of th e H andin- Ha nd Fire Co m pan y (N o . 3 I ). Th e eng ra ving h as bee n at t rib u te d to D awkin s. (. 0 whi ch would m ean th at it too was exec u ted p ri o r to hi s d ep arture for Ph ilad clp h ia . Lik e th e
. . "f- ' - -
.
. .. ~
--
..
f. -
'J
;~;\~ ~/ -6ve;/~~
.• !"'.
"
[, "
.
..
&-- _ .-'-,- - --
\.
,"
(. :.
.
-
------ _
...=i
30
Trade card ofRichard Kip, 17 71 . J ohn H urt, N ew Yo rk . Eng rav ing o n paper. I) x 57/ " in. (22. <) x 14.<) cm .). Rare Books and M anu scripts Di vision, The New York Pub lic Libr ar y, Astor, Len ox , and Tilden Foundati on s
Trade card of Anthonv La mb H enry D awkins, N ew York, ca. 17 5 5 En gr avin g on pap er, II x 7 Jh in . Th e N ew-York H isto rical Soci et y
FIGU RE 25.
53
de sign o f the bill head m ade for Lam b . thi s tripl e car ro uche must have had its origi ns in an En glish prototyp e. T he cit ysc ape vi gn ette. whi ch ca n no t be id entified w ith any site in New York, m a y a lso h ave b e e n copi ed from a n E ng lis h prin t. T he recipi ent o f thi s partic ula r invitation , dated 3 M ar ch 170 2, to a meetin g at th e C ity Arms tavern in th e Br oad w ay.
w as th e se lf-s tyled ca rl of Sterlin g , b orn Wi lliam Ale xand er ( 1720- 1783) in N ew York, wh o wa s ed uca te d in th e cit y and mad e an ad va n tageo us m arriag e w ith th e go ve rno r's sis ter. Dur in g a so jo u rn in En g land b etween 17 50 a n d 170 1, he attempted un success full y to as sert hi s claim to the ear ldo m o f Stirlin g, a titl e he nevertheless ass u med w he n he re turn ed to Ne w York . Am on g a number o f lar ge Lo ndo n- st yle tr ade cards ma de in Ph iladelphia pr ior to th e Re vo lution , tw o by J am es Sm it he r s ta n d o u t as s pec tac u la r repres en tati on s o f th e Am erican ro co co . Hi s ad ve rt ise me n t fo r Benj amin Randolph (N o . 32) w as eng ra ve d in 176 9 to co inc ide w it h t h e ca b ine t ma ke r' s buildin g o f a new hou se an d a sho p nam ed th e Golde n Eag le in C hes tn ut Street , bet w eenThird and Fourth str eets (see p. 18l ) - th e ve ry blo ck w he re Smither had settled o n his arrival fr om Lond on t he pr e viou s year. (" Th is celebra te d im age h as an ar res ti ng ly asy m me t rica l ca r tou ch e lib er all y em bellishcd w ith de si gn s for furnitur e co pied fro m va rio us patt ern book s, includin g Th e Director and H oushold FI/ n1 i tllre . ('~ Wh at di st in gui sh es th is fr om all o t he r tr ad e cards. bot h E ng lish and American. is it s bi zarre juxtap ositi on s: an oversize eag le o n a b ed st e ad t est er , a cloc k on a co lo n na de. an d w ha t is probably a clapboard wa ll w it h plain sq ua re w indows over a m as on r y w al l wh o se a rc he d G othi c o pe n ing is ma rked "B . Rs War e Roo m ." Such irrati on alities are an as pec t of the En glish rococo seldo m ex plo re d in Amer ica.
31
Invitation for the Hand-in-Hand Fire C Oli/pail }' Possibly by Henr y Dawk ins. N ew York . ca. 1755 Engraving on paper. 7 7/ " x ()l/2 in. T he N ew York Public Library
The ad ve rt ise me n t Sm ithe r m ad e fo r th e printer an d pr intse lle r Robert Kenned y (N o . 33 ) is imp ressive fo r its g rand eur of sc a le a n d lo o sen ess a n d inform alit y o f execu tio n . The de sign owes a d ebt to th e ti tl e pa ge o f J ohn so n ' s One H undred and FUry Ne ll' D esig ns ( 1701) , w it h w hic h it shares the di stin ct ive m otif o f a clu st er o f five balu ster s. ('.I Kenn ed y o pe n e d a co p p e r- p la te printin g s ho p in Phil ad elph ia o n Third Street in 170 1; in 176 7. w hile still a t th e same address, he b ran ch ed o u t into se lling prints. In D ecem ber 170 S (t he yea r Smith er ar rive d in the city ), Kenn ed y was in partn e rship w it h his br oth er Thom as. havin g just o pe ned a sepa ra te "Print Sho p. in Seco nd-s t ree t near C hes t n ut-s treet. " (Ll Since th e Smi ther adve r tise me n t gives an add ress at Secon d Street belo w Walnut and m ak es no m ention o f Th om as Kenn ed y. th e b ro t he rs ' pa r tn er ship m us t have been di ssol ved and th e
- - - - - -- - - - -
32 T rade card "j Benjamin Randolph James Smither. Phil adelphia. 17 0 <) Eng raving on pap er , <) x 7 in. Th e Libr ar y C ompan y of Philadelphia
55
33
T rade card of Robert Kennedy J am es Smi ther. Phi ladelphia. ca. J70 y Eng rav ing o n pape r. 10 x 7'14 in . Wint crt hur Museum
34
Certificate of membership New York Mechanick Society Abraham Godwin, N ew York , [786 Engraving on paper, 81/2 x [[ 1/H in. Winterthur Museum
shop m o ve d b y th e time th e eng rav ing w as ord er ed. Thi s exa m ple was o rig ina lly mounted o n th e back o f a print afte r Van D yck 's Co nt inence (~r Scipio, engrave d in Lo ndo n in n oo and fra med in Philadelphia b y Rob ert Kenn ed y.I"
w as in corporated in [792 as th e G en eral So ci et y of M echanics and Tradesm en. At a meetin g o n 2 Au gu st [780, " A co m mi t te e wa s ap po in te d to wa it o n Mr. God win , and to engage him to en gr av e a plate for a ce rt ifica te o f m embersh ip, th e d esi gn an d pri ce h a vin g b een previou sl y ag reed up on ." r. 7 Abrah am G od win ( J703- IX3S), born in Pat er son , N ew j er se y, apprent iced w it h Andrew Billin g s in Pou ghkeep sie, Ne w York . Hi s bill ca me to a total of £23 - [4-8. At th e top, ab o ve a raised arm co n taine d w ith in a circle, is th e m otto " By H amm er & H and , a ll Arts d o sta n d ." Around the ce n t r a l ca r t o uc he, w i t h it s in s cripti on , a re vi gn ett es depicting w orkshops and allegorical landscap es (at the upper left, for exa m p le , Am eri ca, in th e g u ise o f a n Indi an princes s, welc o mes representati on s of Libert y and Indu str y to her sh o res) . This ce rtifica te , th e socie ty 's sea l affi xed to it at th e bottom, w as made out to Seabury C ha m plin , th e organizat io n' s 190th m emb er , b y j on ath an Po st, cha ir m an, o n 3 june 1791.
T o w a rd th e end o f th e eig h tee nt h ce n t ury , m ore and m ore fratern al o rga n iza t io ns we re es ta b lis hed b y th e im po rta n t t rades. T he purp o ses we re social (to in still a se nse o f co m m on id ent it y ) a n d b en e v ol ent (to h elp th e w idows and im p o v eri sh ed fa m il ies o f th e br ethren ) . Lar g e a n d h andso mely eng ra ved ce rt ifica tes of m em ber ship-what mi ght be called" co rpo ra te t rade cards " - rein force d th e importan ce o f be lo n g in g . Us ua lly d iv id ed int o a se ries o f co m part me n ts an d in a lar ge form at su ita ble for fra m ing , the y a re amo ng th e gra nde r Am eri can m anifest ati on s o f th e ro coco sty le and amo ng th e last. O ne of th e ea r lies t of th e o rga n iza tio ns was th e Ne w Yo rk Marin e So ci ety, es ta b lis he d in [700 . It s ce rt i fica te , p rinted in Lond on , h as a series o f v ig ne t tes in th e s p aces su rrou n di ng the ce n t ra l car tou ch e?" a n d mu st b e th e pr otot yp e fo r th e fir st o f it s kind in Am eri ca, th at o f th e N ew York M ech ani ck So ciet y (N o . 34). Founded in [7XS b y represe n ta tives of th irt y-on e di fferen t tr ad es, t he orga niza tio n
Th e ce rt i fi ca te o f th e Bo st on M arin e So ci et y (N o . 35 ), eng raved in [7X9 b y joseph Ca lle n de r, wa s clearly mod eled aft er God win' s d esi gn . r.x Thi s co py was presented o n I N ovemb er [79 2 to Pet er C ha rdo n Bro ok s, lat er a wea lt hy
57
35 Certificate of membership Bosto/l Marine Society Joseph Ca llende r, Bosto n , 17119 En graving on paper , 9V" x 15 in. Boston Marin e Society
Bo ston ban kcr an d po lit ician . Ca ll en de r ( 17 5 I - I X2 1) wa s a native Bo st oni an: o t h er th an th is pie ce, m o st o f th e ep he m era he pr odu ced w ere neocl assical in sty le. A se pa ra te M arine So ci et y w as es ta b lishe d in P ortl and, M a in e, in 179 0. ( ''.j In IX07, it go t its o w n engraved ce rt ifica te. fashi on ed cl o sel y a fte r Ca lle n der 's. So did th e ro co co-st yle d esi gn ca r ryo n in to th e nin et eenth cen tu ry . W ha t mi ght a lmos t be ca lle d a n ati ve sc hool o f engra v ing , w hich em p has ized ro co co o rna men ta t io n, eme rged in cent ral Con nec t icut d ur ing t he 170os. O ne o f it s fir st ex po ne n ts was A be l Buell ( ' 74 2- 1X31 ), b orn in Killin g w orth , wh o, before m ovin g to N ew H aven in 1770, tr ained under his b rother-inlaw , th e go lds m ith Ebe neze r C h itte nde n o f M ad ison. 7° Bu ell eng ra ve d a dipl oma sur ro u n de d b y a m od est rococo m antle for Yale Co llege abo u t 1774. P rob abl y abo u t th e sa me tim e, in associatio n w ith J am es Ri vingr on, a N ew Yo rk pr inter, he pr odu ced this sp le ndi d ce rt ifica te (N o . 36 ; sec also ill. opp. p . 37 ) w it h it s recondite titl e. "Th e Se q uel o f Art s and Sciences . " 7 ' The shee t is bord er ed wi th ro co co ca rto uc hes co ntaining elabo ra tely eng ra ve d vi gn ettes o f va rio us endea vo rs : limn in g an d e ng ra v ing, " mec ha n ic ks, " g lass g ri n d i ng, b ot an y . hu s b an d r y . h at maki ng. a n d p ri n t ing , a lte rna t ing
with callig ra p hic titl es. Wh ile ski llfully execu ted, th e d esign s a re all t aken fro m illu strat ion s in Englis h publi cati on s.?" In thi s co py, its vig ne ttes tinted in wa te rco lo r, th e lar g e ce n t ral space is fil led wi t h "s elect se n te nces" penn ed by Susa n na D arlin g, aged eig h t, o f N ew H aven . O n ly two o ther co p ies a re kn own , bo t h d a t e d 1793 an d th e w ork o f M a tth e w T alc ott znd o f Norwic h . 73
Writillg certificate Attri but ed to Ab el Bu ell N ew H aven, ca. 1775 Eng rav ing on paper , 15-% x 12V2 in. T he N ew-York Hi stor ical Soc iety
Br it ish t ro ops landin g at Bo ston in '7()~. reduced the o rnam ent of th e titl e ' s ca r to uc he to a pa lm tr ee, an image of an Indian , an d o ne o r t w o raffl es. 7' In 1784, a simi larly dras tic tr an sform ati on of ro co co m antlin g , visib le on B ue ll's e ng rav ing o f th e fi rs t map of th e n e wl y fo rmed Un ite d Sta tes (No. 42), impl ies conscious rejection of a decora tive sty le then see n as den oting fealty to Eng land .
Maps
In th e Ge rma nic co mm unities o f Pennsyl van ia, rococo ornam ent was se ldo m employed, an d th en usu all y on ly on special co m m issio n. The d raw ings of th e surveyor an d bui lde r Andr eas H o e g er are a n exce p tion. H o e g er was bo r n in Nuremberg in 17'4 , j oin ed th e M o ravian Church (the United Br ethren , o r Unitas Fr atrum ) in H er rn h ut in '742, and came with a g ro u p of sing le br ethr en to Penn s yl v ani a in 1754. U nt il he left th er e ten yea rs later , H oeger was busy with the ph ysical needs of t he ex pa nd ing eva ngelical sec t, especially at it s three Pen ns yl vani a se t tlemen ts, Be t hle hem, N aza re th , and Lititz.?" Severa l h ighl y finis hed pla ns and a rchitect ura l
The la rg es t and mos t im p ressiv e o f eig h tee nt h -ce n t u ry American engravi ngs are ci ty views , pl an s, an d m ap s, o n w h ic h th e rococo plays o n ly a subsi d iary ro le , if any at all. Becau se th ey wo uld co m pe te wi th th e sce ne de pic te d, lar ge or namen ta l ti tle c a r to u ch es se ldo m occur o n vie ws. O n maps. ho w ever, th ey p ro vide a focal po int and mu ch-need ed vis ua l interest; when th e re is e no ug h space, rococo cartouc hes, sim ilar in size and arra nge men t to t he o rna ment of tra de cards , often enclose ti tles, dedica tio ns, even su bscriptio n lists. Since maps were essen tia l too ls in both com merce and war, t h e decade o f th e 1750S, w h ich ush er ed in th e Fre nch and In d ia n War . was o ne of g rea t cartog ra p hic ac t iv ity in America. Pl a n s of interior lan d s , w here th ere were riva l claims between colo nies as we ll as w it h th e Fr en ch , we re urgently needed, as were reliable cha rts of th e coast, for eve n the major ship pi ng lanes were largely unpl o tt ed . W h ile maps a n d pl an s h ad to be ' prepared in A m erica, t he ir ac tual engravi ng an d pri nti ng were m o re o ften th an not done in E ng la nd. "E ngraved from th e Or ig ina l D ra win g sent over from Ph ilad el ph ia, in th e possess io n of Ca ring ton Bo wl es" is how o ne Lon d on publ ish er inscri be d hi s view o f t h a t city . 74 Whe n a major to p o gr aphi cal s u rvey was engraved and printed o n this si de of t he Atl ant ic, ho w ever , it was sure to be pira ted and co pie d nu m er o us tim es in London and on the Continen t. T ho ugh eac h o f th e four m a p s T ho mas J oh n st on engraved in Bo ston in the 1750S h as a m odestl y de corati ve ro co co titl e ca r to uc he, o n ly in Ph ilad el ph ia, ove r th e ne xt deca de, we re surveys la vi sh ed wi t h elega nt rococo devi ces. T hree of t he m o st imp ort ant o f th es e we re exec u te d b y Turner (sec N o . 3~); o t he r elab orat e exa mp les (see N os. 40, .p ) were pub lis he d by th e tr ad esm an M atthew C lar kso n . ln t he 17()os, w he n resentm ent was m ountin g aga ins t th e m oth er co u ntry's do m ina tio n, t he Eng lis h-s ty le carto uc he bega n to show co lo nia l modi ficat ions. Revere. in a view o f
drawin gs w ith o rna me n ta l titl e ca rto uches h ave been attribu ted to him . 77 Th e " Be t h le he m Tract w it h all the adjacen t Land . '755" (N o . 37) is th e larges t and, th o ugh its paper has da r ke ne d w ith t im e, th e most d ccor ative. ?" T he layout of th e d rawin g as wel l as t he ca re w ith wh ich it was re ndered sugges ts th at it was int en ded to be engraved. Bethleh em, fo rt y-fi v e mi les no rth of Phi ladelp hia, o n th e banks of th e Lehi gh River (o n the map inscribed "Lchey o r th e Wes t Br an ch o f De laware" ), was founded in 1740. H o e g er ' s pl an co n ta ins t hree d iffe rent re p rese ntatio ns: an overa ll pl an o f th e Bethl eh em tr act (top mid dl e) , a p lan of design ated lands (bo tto m ), and a birds- cyc view of th e to w n cen te r with each bu ilding dep ict ed in perspective (to p right). This las t vig ne t te is se t apa rt b y a wo nderfully rococo frame w hose top and b ottom part s lo o k to h ave been inspi red by Eng lis h p attern bo o k s. In a rococo varia t io n o n th e cartog ra p hic co nve n tio n of usi ng t romp e l' o eil sc ro lls to fra me titl es an d o t he r te xt s (see No. 38), H oeg e r h as represented the sides o f hi s frame as havin g dissolve d, leaving th e unp ro tected edges o f th e pap er to appear to cu rl u p . D el a w ar e Ba y, t he wa te r r out e to Phil ad el ph ia, is fu ll o f tr each erous shoa ls and navigati on al hazard s. Until th e publica tio n o f Fis he r 's su rvey in 175(), t he re was no co m p re he nsive, acc u ra te cha rt o f th ose busy wa te rs . The cha rt , almos t four feet wide (N o . 38 ), was in te n de d fo r u se as a n a vi g ation al aid . J oshu a Fish er ( 1707- 1783) began th e survey w h ile a h att er an d fu r tr ad er in h is n ati ve D el a w ar e . In ' 746 , h e m o ved to Phil ad elphi a, w he re h e d evel op ed a flouri sh in g m er cantil e bu siness. Te n years later. enco u raged by Thom as Penn , so n o f th e fi rst proprieto r, and hi s age n t , Ri ch ar d
59
/ -. I:
'.'IT' 0/,,: '?(
. .-4' . . . . .
"': '. .X·..··
. /;i'
~
- .. F--
4"/ .... .... M ....
. ~ /#;u'...r
/
- -,-
,~.
'
l
<
r'
:,¥.-~ ....
./
- --;:-. _ -
TITF
--I . ",<."/.-;;
/
" j,,~
-
_'_1
37
Piall of Bethlehen: T raa Attributed to Andreas H oeg er Bethleh em , Penn syl van ia, 1755 Ink and was h on pap er, 2 4 1/~ x 31-% in . M oravian Hi st ori cal Soc iety
60
Pet er s. Fish er fin all y publi shed hi s char r. ?" It w as executed by J am es Turner. the m ost acco m plishe d Am erican engraver o f th e tim e. w ho m a y re ason abl y be cred ited with th e actua l des ig n o f th e three sp len di d ca r ro uc hes ac ross t he bottom o f th e cha rt. Th at a t th e r ight. und er th e Penn famil y a r ms . co ntai ns th e titl e. th e au tho r 's nam e. and th e dedi cati on " To
C hart of Delaware Bay James Turn er . afte r J o shu a Fisher Phil ad elphia. J750 En gr aving on pa per. 23% x 4 51/. in . The J ohn C arter Bro w n Libra ry. Bro wn University
th e M e r ch ants and In surers of t he C ity o f Philadelphia " ; th at
th e left. a list o f su bsc ribe rs (pilo ts and shipmas rers) to the pu bl icat ion ; th at at th e cen te r. a tid e table . The plan is dat ed 2R Februar y 17 y i. an in au spi ciou s timin g . as it happened. for On ~ M ar ch. Provin c ial G o vern or Ro b ert Hunter M orri s o rde re d it s publi cati on p o stp on ed . A s he wrote to Fish er. "We are in daily ex pec ta tio n o f a Fren ch War .. . if yo ur map of th e Ba y sho u ld be publi sh ed. so me Co pys o f it m ay fall int o ye E nc m ys H and s . " ' 0 Fish er had a lread y delivered a few o f th e charts . but the st rict u re mu st have been gen era lly effective: o nly thi s co py and on e o ther are kn own . to
OJ
.• 1..... ---0 _... . _ ......... • ;
• 1 J ,".'"
/
d-
_j ~, '"
1.'",'''. ,..•.,
I>.~r · I
---:i _~"; ~
'..
J'"l '''
·1
Fish er 's m onum ental char t of 17 56 was not reissued until th e Revolution and th en o n ly in a redu ced form at and showing a lar g er area , all th e way up th e rive r to Phil ad elphi a. While und at ed, it p robabl y was eng raved in 177 5, in an ticipat io n o f arme d co n flict an d in tim e to serve as th e m odel for a spa te of pira te d Lon d on ed itio ns, all d at ed 1776 an d all ac k no w ledg ing th at th e y we r e t ak en fr om th e cha rt pu bl ish ed b y Fi sh e r in Phil ad elph ia . In thi s war , unlik e th at w ith the Fren ch , bo th sides we re to have cha rts! A w ater col or vers io n o f th e seco nd editio n (N o . 39 ) differ s littl e fro m th e eng ra vin g excep t th at th e three ca rto uc hes have been co nso lida te d in to o ne, and the dedicati on , the author's na me , and th e list o f su bscri be rs are o m it te d. In p lace o f th e Penn ar ms are a chev ro n an d thr ee fi sh es, p erh ap s a p u n o n th e a u t ho r's n am e, w hic h h as led to th e specu la tio n t ha t thi s m ay h a ve been Fish er 's own co py .s, The expert ly d raw n carto uc he, in g risa ille exce p t fo r green spiky leaves an d red flo w ers, is a ta me r, m ore sta te ly ve rs io n of th e ro co co th an t ha t T u rner had used tw o decad es befor e.
39 C hart oj D elawavc Bav and R iv er Prob ably by J oshu a Fisher Ph iladelp hia, ca. 177 5 Ink and wa te rcolor on pape r. 17'/" x 27 1/~ in. The H isto rical Soc iety of Pennsylvania
Ni cholas Scull ( 10 87- 170 () was surveyo r ge neral o f the Pr ovince of Penn sylv an ia from 1748 almos t until his death . In th at po sitio n, he was occ u pie d in m ak in g th e m o st im po rta n t m ap s of Phil ad elphi a: in 17 5 2 , o ne o f th e cit y an d " Pa rts A dj acent "; in 17 54 , an " East P ro sp ect " ; in 17 59, o ne of th e w ho le pr ov in ce, eng raved b y Turn er and h avin g a ro co co carto uche. Scu ll di ed in 17°1 , before co m ple ting a det ail ed m ap of Ph iladelph ia based on his surveys o f th e city's streets and lot s, but his dau ghter and exe cu tor , M ary Biddle, saw it to co m ple tio n th e foll o win g yea r. Dedi cat ed to the elec te d o ffi cia ls and free m en of Phil ad elphi a, " T his Pl an of th e improved part o f th e C it y surveyed an d laid d o wn b y th e lat e N icho las Sc u ll Esq r. " (N o . 40 ) was publi sh ed o n 1 N o vem ber 170 2 and so ld by " the Edit ors, " M ar y Biddl e and M atthew Cla rkso n . Cla rkso n was first heard o f in an adve rtisem ent of 17°1, w hich pr oclaim ed: "Copper- Plate Printin g/ B y a wo rk ma n fro m Lond on, / Is pe rfo rm ed , in all it s B r an ches , for M atth ew C la r kso n . s s xz Whil e C la r kso n, a tr ad esm an, ne ver d iv ulged th e nam e o f th e eng ra ve r , th e sk illfu l re n dering of th e t itl e ca rto uc he has th e qu al it y o f Lon d on wo rk . (W ith Turn er dea d, Dawkin s is a likel y cand i d atc . ) Th e ma p is th e fir st th at acc ura te ly record ed th e placement of individua l buildings in Phil adelphia.
40
Plan oj Philadelphia Possibly by Henr y Dawkins, after N icholas Scull, Philadelp hia, 1762 En gravin g on paper, 20 1/H x 26·% in. T he N ew York Pub lic Libr ar y
63
......
......-: <,
<,
C la rkso n was also ed ito r and pu bl ish cr o f a " Ge nera l C ha rt o fa l! th e Co as t o f th e Prov in ce o f Loui sian a" (N o . 41 ) includin g w ha t is now w est Fl o rid a, Ala b am a, an d Mi ssissip pi - fo r w hich he e m p loyed H enry D awkin s as eng raver. A ro co co ca rt o uc he is sq ueeze d int o t h e a va ila b le space at eit he r e n d o f th e long . n a rr o w print. Th at a t th e ri ght encloses th e ti tle; th at at the left, ex ecuted in a m ore sp irite d sty le and with mi lit a ry sta nda rds and drum s pr oj ectin g from behind , co n ta ins a dedi cati on to H enr y Bouq uet, " C ol on el in H is M aj est y ' s Serv ice a n d Lieut. Co lo n el o f th e R o y al Am eri can Re gim ent . " The Swiss- bo rn Bou qu et (1719- '705) receiv ed th e latter ra nk in ' 754, at th e o ut b rea k o f t he Fren ch a n d Indi an Wa r. In ' 7 50 , h e sa ile d for Am eri ca, w he re h e di stin g uish ed h im sel f mi lit ar ily; in 175 R, he was prom ot ed to full co lo ne l. In ' 70 5, then a bri g adi er ge ne ra l. Bouqu et was g ive n co m ma n d of th e enti re so u t he rn d istr ict o f Br iti sh N ort h Am eri ca, includin g th e area of t his chart, w hich was prob ab ly exec u te d n ot lon g b e fore Bouqu et' s la st p rom otion . Str icke n in a fever ep id e m ic, h e d ied at Pen sacol a th at same yea r. After t h e rest o rati on o f peace, In '7R3, th e fir st m ap o f t he n ew Unit ed St at es (N o . 42 ) was th e wor k n ot o f a ski lled London-trai ned eng ra ve r but of a na tiv e o ppo rt u nis t - A bc:! Buell. of N ew H a ven . A s he adve rtise d in th e Co n nec tic u t [o urna! o f 3 ' M ar ch '78 4:" Bucl 's Map O f the Uni ted States
. . ........
41
C hart oj the coast oj L ouisiana
Henr y Dawkins. Philadelphia. ' 700-oS Eng raving on paper. I4 '/~ x -l 0 1/ 2 in. Th e New York Public Library
of Am erica, Laid do w n from th e latest o bserva tio ns and best aut ho rities , agreeable to th e peace o f ' 783, is now publi shed . and read y for subsc ribe rs . [T hi s 1 M ap is .. . th e first ever co m piled, eng ra ved, and fin ish ed b y o ne ma n, and an A m erican . " S J Printed o n fo u r shee ts and m easurin g no t m uch un der four fee t sq ua re, it was inte n de d as a wa ll m ap. While th e ca rtogra p hic features arc all tak en fro m o t her surveys . th e titl e carto uc he in t he lo w e r rig h t corne r is Bu ell 's ow n crea tive effor t. H e has aba ndo ne d his precise engraving style an d slavis h im it at ion of Eng lis h o rigina ls (sec No . 30 ) in favo r of an infor ma l etch ed techniqu e an d Am e ri can sym bol s: th e Am e rican flag; a fri nged ova l co nta ini ng th e arms (t hree gra pevi nes) of Co n nec tic ut; and th e sea te d figure of Li berty h ol din g a staff crow ne d w it h a li b e rt y cap . T he ro co co titl e ca rtouc he - a sy m b o l of Eng land - was do ne away w it h, excep t fo r t w o lar ge raffl es rem aini n g at th e bottom .
~
l I
, I
I I
'11
~.'
~
·0
c " , ' '' '
\
42 M ap 4 the United S tates (:f A lllerica Abel Buell. N ew H aven, 1784 Engravin g on paper , 42'% x 4 8 in . The N ew J er sey H isto rical Societ y
c
p
r
C lock Dials
C loc k dials m ade o f shee t brass engraved wi th rococo ornam ent , w h ile n ot in te n de d for p rinti n g , n ev ert h el ess merit di scu ssion as an adj u nc t to th e mo re com mo n t y pes of eng raving . In tr adition al eig h tee n t h-cen tury tall clocks, the di al , o r face , fro nte d th e clock m o vem ent, w hic h was m ounted in th e bonn et o f th e w ooden case . M ade of brass, wi t h applie d cha pte r rin g (a large circ u lar ban d marked with th e hours and m inutes), s~co n ds rin g , and nam eplate, all silver ed to en ha nce leg ibilit y , it u su all y m easured twelve in ch es to a side . It h ad spa n d re ls fill ed w ith cas t o rnaments and, o ften , an arc hed top co nta ini ng a m oon ph ase. T he dia l, ca lib ra te d for tellin g tim e, h ad to pro claim th e name of the clock m ak er an d th e town w he re h e wor ked. T ha t type of dial was supe rse de d in th e mid-r'rBos by th ose m ade of sheet iron painted w h ite an d h a vin g bl ack num e rals and colo red decorati on . M an y of th e b rass dials, and m ost of th e paint ed , w er e imported, but a nati ve alte rna tive eme rge d abo ut 1770 : a di al co nsis ting o f a sing le fiat bras s sheet o n w hich represe n ta t io ns of ap p lie d cha p te r rin g, n am epl at e, and o t her ele me nts we re eng ra ve d. When silve re d, it was not un like a painted d ial in ap pea ra nce-a d om est ic al terna tive to the " en amell ed di al-plat es" Ph ilad elphi a cloc kmaker J ohn Wood had imported as early as 1773."4 Th e eng raved fac e is n ot o fte n fo u n d o n fine urban clo ck s, th ou gh th er e a re brilliant exce ptio ns (see No . .1-3 ). T he g rea tes t flow erin g of th is bela te d A m e rican rococo ex p ressio n to ok pl ace in Co n nec tic u t (see Nos . 44 , 45), far from th e m ajor sty le cente rs, an d, th ou gh w ith less orig inality, in M ar yland and Virgi nia. "5 T he Am erican engraved clo ck di al m ost closely approx imating t he style o f th e Lond on ro co co (N o . 43 )"6 is sig ned " Burrows Do wdn ey / Phil ad elphia, " a maker abo ut whom n othin g is kn o wn exce p t t ha t du rin g th e yea rs 1768-71 he adve rtised in th e Pcnnsvl vania C hronicle as a wa tc h- and cloc k m aker in Front Stree t. "? O n th e di al of his cloc k, w hich
66
43 D ial of clock Ii)' HII IT OI /l S D ow dnev Phil adel ph ia. ca. ' 770 Br ass. silve red . 16 Y H x 12 in. The D ietrich Ame rican Fo undatio n
has ne ver been resil vere d (in p laces, t he brass sh ows t h ro ug h), t he eng raving, ha vin g th e refi ned precision of the best En gli sh cop pe r-p la te wo rk, is ce rtain ly the work of some m ast e r of th e tec h n iq ue, perh a ps Dawkins . It com b in es pi ctorial re presen ta tio n an d ro co co ornament : in the co rners, raffl es fill t he s pa n d rels ; in th e arc hed to p, hissing ser pe n ts w it h t wi stin g tails flan k th e moo n p hase; in th e ce nte r, Fath er Tim e, holdin g hi s scyt he in hi s left hand and rest in g his right hand o n an hourgl ass, is sea ted on an asy m m etri cal ro co co fr am e; at th e left are ano the r ho urgl ass and scy the; an eag le tries to g ras p th e clo ck-hands' sha nk; raffles ap pea r to g ro w o rga n ica lly o u t o f th e w in d ing ho les and from th e bottom co rne rs of the nam epl at e. The co m bina tio n o f o r na me n t and th e im ages o f eag les , se r pen ts, and Father T im e sugges ts a famili arit y w it h Th om as J ohn so n 's aile Hund red and F[ft y Ne lli D csions. xx In 1774, J ohn N or m a n adve r tise d th at he su p plied "C lock an d Wa tc h Gravin g. " XV but th e style he revea le d in hi s ill us t ratio ns (see NO .4) for th e Phil ad el phi a edi tio n of Swa n's British Architect ( 1775) is so mewha t loo ser th an th at of D o wdneys clock dial. En graved clo ck dials ultim at ely ac hieved grea ter popul arit y in N ew E n g land th an in Penn syl vania. In ' 773, the Engli sh clockma ke r Th om as H arl and se t tle d in No rwich . Connecticut, an d adve rtised " Cl o ck faces eng raved and fini shed for th e tr ad e. " ') 0 H a rl and had a num ber o f ap pr enti ce s. The m o st illu stri ou s o f th em was D aniel Bu rn ap ( 1759- 1838) . wh o, afte r co m ple ti ng hi s indenture, co n ti n ued to wo rk for H arland as a j ourn e ym an until ' 779. It w as fro m H arl and th at Burn ap le arn ed to eng ra ve clo ck faces and to make "chim e" clo ck s-that is, clo ck s th at pl ayed musical tun es.?' In 1780, he es ta b lis he d hi s o wn shop in Eas t Windso r, a few miles north o f Hartford , w he re he ca r ried o n w ha t becam e th e lar g est suc h bu sin ess in th e Co nnec tic u t Vall ey . Of th e d o zen kn own chi me clocks th at we re h is special ty, six arc reco rded in h is surviv ing acco u n t b o ok s. fi ve of t he m bet w een the yea rs 1790 an d 179 5. A d ial (N o . 44 ) with rococo ra ffles in th e spa nd re ls and inte rtwi ned vines looping a ro un d th e insc ri ptions in th e arc h ed top and t he center illu strat es a lat e flo w e rin g of rococo ornamen t in rur al Am eri ca. ')2 A h and in th e a rc h Can be poi nt ed to sel ect an y of th e six tu nes th at th e move me nt is programmed to pla y fo ur times a day . The sou nds produced b y t hese clo cks. incl ud ing suc h favor ites as "A ir b y H an dl e, " can be said to be t he o n ly aut he ntic m us ic th at can be sum mo ned from th e eig h tee n th century .
44
Dial of musical clock Daniel Burnap, maker and engraver East Windsor , Co nnecticut , 17 <)0 - <)4 Brass, silvered, 16 % x 12 in. Historic Deerfield, Inc.
68
An oth er o uts tan d in g en gr av ed d ial fr om Co n nec tic u t (N o . 45) is th at fo r a clo ck m ad e b y Reub en In g rah a m o f Pl ainfield, on th e eastern bo rd er o f the sta te , a few mil es north o f Norwi ch . In perhap s th e on ly in stan ce of an eng rave r 's sig nin g an Am cri can clo ck d ial, J oh n A ver v's n am e ap pea rs in tin y letter s w ithin th e seco nds rin g . Aver y ( 1732- 1794) was a silve rsm ith an d clock m aker in Prest on , near N orw ich . Hi s arr ange me n t of th e na mes of th e m aker and th e town in th e arc he d top, th e sem icircu lar op eni ng for the date rin g, even th e Four Sea so ns as m otifs to fill th e fo ur spa n d re ls, o w e a debt to th e design o f H arland' s di als."! T he ca rto uc hc in th e ar che d top, th e spa n d re l mo tifs, an d 'the v a riou s lay ered co m part me n ts into whi ch t he cen t ra l area is bro k en up are all sur ro u n ded wi t h bo rder s o f sm all-scale sc ro lle d leafage, an eng ag ing , if so mew ha t fu ssy, interpretation o f th e roc o co at th e end o f th e centur y . L GB , M H H
45 Dial of clock by Reuben l no raham Eng raved b y J oh n Aver y Plainfield, Con necticu t , 1785-94 Brass, silve red , \(, x 12 in , Co llec tion o f M r. and M rs . Fr ank A . M aur i
SILVER
Am eri can silver beg an to refl ect th e ro co co sty le in th e late 1740S, in fl ue nced b y printed ep he me ra and silve r imported fro m t he m o th er co u nt ry. D om esti c silve rs m it hs wh o h ad t rai n ed in t he co lo n ies co u ld in teg ra te aspec ts o f th e n e w tast e in to th e ir rep ert oire , but m o st lack ed th e s pecia lize d sc hoo ling req ui red t o crea te th e h ighl y o rna te su rfaces o f full -fledged rococo silve r. Much of th at deco ra tio n was co nt rib ut ed by im m ig ra n t jo u rney me n, o urworke rs , or inde nt u red serva n ts , I w ho h a d b en e fit ed from tr ainin g ab roa d (usua lly in Lon d on) and we re already fami liar wi th th e new style. Silve r was a n urb an lu xur y, pr o du ced in Am eri ca in th e eig h teen t h cen t u ry pr im aril y in Bo st o n , N e w York, Ph ilad e lph ia , an d C ha rles to n. Th e fin est do mes tic ro co co silve r tr aces to a fe w wo r ks ho ps in th o se ci ties, whose ea rliest exa m pi es postd ate the int rodu cti on o f th e style in Lond on b y a t le ast ten yea rs , a ph en om en on a tt r ib u ta b le to soc ia l an d eco no m ic co n d itio ns. In En gland , ro co co tast e en te re d th rou gh a r is t oc ra t ic cir cles an d g ra d u a ll y c a m e w it h in th e re ach o f th e upp e r-middl e class; in Am eri ca, it beca me ava ila b le to pr osperou s m er ch ants as it had to their Lond on co un te r pa rts . Th e fashi on abl e En gli sh imp ort s ap pearing in th e hom es of co lo n ia l m er ch ant prin ce s n aturall y influ en ced lo c al t ast e . E xp ort a nd impo rt reco rds. pe rio d adver t isemen ts , an d surv iv ing exam p les o f British
o w ne d in Sal em in [76 0 (N o . 46 ) . Upl i ft e d o n thre e C sc ro ll-a n d-s he ll fe et, it is a d e p artu re from th e sta n da r d E ng lis h ve rs io n e leva ted o n a pedes ta l foot. Th e trip o d desi gn was a Fr en ch inn o vat io n adop ted on ly selec tively by London silve rs m iths. The pot , crafted in Lo ndo n in th e shop o f Arthur Ann esl e y and marked wit h t he da te letter for 17 59- 60 , was g ive n to M a r y Vial (1737-1802 ) of Bosto n by h er uncl e J on ath an Simpson ( 17 11/ 12- 17 9 5) . probably in hon or o f her m ar riage in 1759 to Edwa rd A . H o lyo ke (1728 (829), a Salem d o cto r. It can be no coincidence that t he on ly tw o t ri pod co ffee pot s k now n in American rococo silver w ere b oth m ade for Sa lem pat ro ns who h ad u ndoub tedly ad m ire d M ar y H ol yok e 's fashio nable Lo ndo n gift. 2 T he t w o Am er ican versi on s s pawne d by th e Ann es lc y po t we re crea te d for se pa ra te m ern bers of th e prom ine nt Derby fami ly o f Salem (see p . 136 ) . An unm ark ed exa m p le was ma de fo r Eli zab eth C ro w n ins h icl d w he n she m ar ri ed Elias H ask e t Derb y , in 1761 ; elev en yea rs la t er . P aul Rev er e s u p p l ie d Eli as 's fath er, Richard, with th e m ost no tewo rt hy Am erican rendition o f th e design (N o . 47 ). 3 N ot e ve ryo ne in th e co lo n ies co u ld a ffo r d to bu y ex pen si v e i m po rte d s ilve r. :' a n d some of th o s e w ho co u ld und oubtedl y preferred n ot t o wait al most a year fo r t he deliv er y o f th ei r goods . T hose co ns ide ra tio ns, toge ther wi th th e nonimp o rt ati on agreements t hat p receded the Re v o lu-
silver wi th provenanccs in eighteen th -ce n t ury Am eri c a le a v e
ti on , c nco u raged th e development of domestically produced
no doub t th at im po rted silver was hi ghl y prize d b y wea lthy colonia ls, who cou ld have th eir o rde rs to London filled an d returned wi thi n ten mont hs to a year. A gra p h ic d e m on strati on o f th e influ en ce o f for ei gn si l ver is p rovided b y an unu su al Lon d on rococo co ffee pot
ro co co silve r. A m eri can patro ns -an eli te and affluen t class - we re n ot rem ot el y inte res ted in e nco u raging loca l silve rs mi t hs to de velo p a un iq ue ly A m er ican inter pretation but co nt in ue d to co m m issio n silve r refl ectin g th e lates t Lo ndon fashio ns. Silve r h as always b ee n assoc ia ted w it h wea lt h. In th e eig htee n t h ce n t ury , o bjects fashi on ed of it we re co llec tively kn own as plat e and se rved as an owner's savings acco unt. an ass e t that co u ld b e liqu id ated a lmost im med ia te ly fo r t he valu e of th e m et al. Becau se th er e were se ve ra l less ex pensive
T caucttlc Oil stand, J oseph R ichardson (No. HH)
71
med iums av ailab le, the usc o f silv er was not a case o f necessity but o f ch oi ce. Silver had no utilitari an relati on to any of th e form s int o w h ic h it was m ad e; th e m crit o f th e fo rm s rest ed in th eir intrin sic wo rth an d th e so cial sta tus they proclaimed o n an o wne r's tabl e. Their value as currc ncy did no t includ e th e cos t o f th e w ork in fashi onin g th em . t he refo re the amo un t o f decoration app lied to th em was purely a matter o f taste an d affo rda b ility . Thou gh th e ro co co did in flu enc e shapes in silve r . th e sty le wa s prim aril y an o rna me nta l co nside ratio n that required co stly addition al lab or for elaborate en gravin g, reli ef chas ing , piercin g, or castings. The d ecor ation on the majority of Ameri can ro co co silver is limited to cngraving and casting on form s th at m ay not themselves ex hib it ro coco influence. Drinkin g and servin g form s cha nged little throughout the period o f th e sty le's d omin ation. but m an y tea a n d co ffee vessel s ado p te d th e double-bellied sha pe th at is a ro co co sig nature . Engraved or cas t de corati on. th e least lab oriou s m ean s of o rna me ntation. entail ed minim al ex t ra cos t to patron s, m o st of whom were pr agm ati c m er ch ant s . E v en if fin an ci al rcv e rscs d id no t demand the co n ve rs io n o f th eir plate to cash, cha ng ing sty les mi ght d ict at e its refashi o nin g . Patron s o rde ring ne w silver o fte n su b m itte d th eir o ld, w h ich w as cr ed ited acco rd ing to its w eight , m elt ed d o wn. and used in th e fabr icatio n of new design s. En gravin g is th e pr o cess o f cu tt ing fin e lin es in to an o bject, th ereb y rem o vin g minute qu antiti es o f m et al. The k ind o f ro co co eng rav ing found m ost fr equ entl y in A m erican silver is an asymmet ri cal ca rro uc he th at o ften encloses the owner ' s a r ms o r initi al s . 5 Engr avin g als o se r ved as a means of identifi cation . If an object w as sto len , it s decoration of initial s or family arm s assi sted imm ea surabl y in it s recovery. as is att ested b y eig h tee n t h-cen t u ry n ew sp ap er ad ve rt isem ents co nta in ing notifications o f mi ssin g silve r and descriptions o f its eng ra ving. This explains w hy silve r was a sa fer means of sto ring sur plus cas h than the coi nage itself A thi ef w ishing to profit from silv er he had sto len had to sell it to a silve rsm ith, w ho was lik el y to recognize it. Cas t ing - t he p ourin g o f m olt en si lve r in to m o ld s of sa n d int o whi ch a p att ern h ad b een imp ressed - w as t he usu al process used to crea te spouts, handles. and finials. Fo r m o st ro co co d esi gn s, s uc h as s po u ts decora te d wi t h shells a n d aca n th us . ca r vcd wooden p atte rn s we re probabl y s u p p lie d b y a lo cal a r tis an " an d co u ld b e u sed re peat edl y , crea ti ng s im ila r a p pe ndages for num er o u s vesse ls . Sil ver smith s we re ex pecte d to have a su p p ly o f pattern s from whi ch th eir patron s co u ld choose w ith out ad di tio na l cost. 7 Onl y wh en th e p att ern s we re p articul arl y o r na te (a nd th e cas t ing co m me ns u ra tely h eav y ) did a p atr on inc ur ex t ra ex pense for th e w eight of th e m etal.
46
Coffee pot, [7 59-60 Arthur Annesley, London Silver. H.: [] '/ 1 in. Essex Institute
72
C has in g and pier cin g. thou gh m ore a p p ro p ria te to ro co co exces ses, w ere als o more extr av agant o rna m en ta tion s. On ela bo ra te exa m p les , th e cos t o f suc h e m b ellis hm ent co uld ap p roach th e cos t of th e m et al. an in co nceivab le ex pe nse exce p t for th e very ri ch . C has ing is t he pro ce ss o f m anipulatin g the metal into bolder . m or e scu lp tura l designs by m ean s of h amm er s a n d b lunt to ol s, wi th n o c u t t ing d e vi ces e m p loye d . In m od ern p ar lan ce, t h e te chniqu e o f deco ra ting th e m et al from th e ex te rio r is still known as chasin g , o r flat chasi ng , but w he n th e m et al is also worked from w it hi n, resultin g in a d esi gn both co n vex an d co nc ave, it is kn o wn as rcp ou sse. Be cau se o f its scu lp t ura l reli ef qual it y , rc po ussc d ecora ti on cha rac ter ize d fu lly d evel oped ro co co silver in b oth Britain and Ameri ca. In th e peri od , ho we ver, it was kn o wn as chas ing; the artisa n w ho accomp lish ed it, a chase r. The spec ialty was descr ib ed in T he Loudon T radesman ( 174 7) as pr actic ed b y o ne of th e "D ep end an ts [of t he ] Go lds m it h . o r , as so me ca ll him. Sil ver smith, " alo ng wit h je w elers . refin er s. burn ish er s, and g ilde rs . amo ng others. " C hased d ecor ati on appe ar s o n pl at e fr om th e three m aj or cen ters o f Am eri can silver prod u ct io n- Bo sto n, N ew Yo rk, and Ph iladelphia- as we ll as o n w o rk from C harlesto n , Baltimo re , Ann ap o li s, Rh od e Isla n d , A lb an y, and La n cas ter. P ie rc ing is j us t as ex u be ra n t as chas ing but mu ch rar er in Am eri can silve r. The techniqu e co ns ists o f layin g o u t a patte rn o n th e s il ver, then drillin g h o les in th e a reas t o b e remo ve d, ex pa n d ing the holes b y m ean s of a sma ll fret saw, and, fin all y, filin g th e ro ug h edges smoo th . Th e ro co co , m or e than a ny precedin g srylc, requ ired spec ia lize d sk ills t h at exceede d th e abiliti es o f t he avera ge Am er ican silvers m it h. R ecent resea rc h in London silve r has d is pe lle d th e m yt h that th e so -ca lle d m ak e r' s mark o n a silve r o bj ec t co uld be int erpreted as the arti st's sig nature and has re vealed th e co m pl c x n et w ork of rcr ail cr s. retai le r- silver smith s, specia lis t-s ilvers m it hs, an d silve r artisans w h o w ere resp on sibl e for th e produ cti on o f any g ive n sho p. 'J T he London Trad esm an , " b e ing a co m pe n d io us vi ew o f all t he tra des" practi ced in London, descr ib ed th e co m plem en t of a silve rs m ith's sho p:
T he Goldsmith em ploys severa l d istinc t Wo rkm en , alm o st as ma ny as th ere are d iffe re n t Art icl es in h is Sh op : fo r in th is g rea t C ity th er e arc H ands th at excel in every B ran ch , and are co n sta n tly em ployed b ur in th at o ne of w hic h th ey are M ast er s . T h is g ives li S an Ad v an t a g e over m an y For ei gn Na tions in thi s Arti cl e, as th e y are o b lige d to employ t h e same H and s in ever y Br an ch of th e Tr ad e . and it is i mposs ib le t o ex pec t th at a M an e m p loye d in suc h an infin ite Va riety can fin is h h is Work to an y Per fecti o n. at leas t , not s o mu ch as h e w ho is cons ta n t ly em plo yed in one Th in g . 10
47 CoIJi'(, pot, 1772 Paul Rever e, Bost on Silver. H . : 12 in . Pri vat e collection
73
On a sma lle r, more pro vin cial sca le, Am eri can silve rs m iths o pe ra te d in th e sam e fash ion , o bta ining o bj ects and services from o ne ano t her. Paul Rev er e's led gers rev eal a net w ork of suc h rel ati on ship s with thirteen o the r siIve rs m iths p rio r to th e R e v oluti on ." Fin e a r mo ria l e ng ra v ing was a t al ent beyond th e rud im cutar y t rain in g of th e ave rage silve rs m ith, and Rever e, an acco m p lis he d eng rave r, su pp lied th at ser vice to a num ber o f his co lleag ues. U
c ra fts m an co u ld ch ea t his clients b y chea pe n ing th e alloy. usin g less s ilve r th an th e s ta n da rd e xp ect ed . ' 3 A m er ican s th er efore tended to pat ronize silvers mi ths of proven re p utati on , a cau tio na ry pract ice th at furth er hinder ed jou rney me n st rugg ling to esta blis h th eir own sho ps, since th ey co uld not re ly o n a gove rn ment hallm ark to g ua ra ntee th e integrit y of th eir m ateri als. In the abs ence o f go ve rn me n ta l regul at ion. a sys te m of tru st de v el op ed b etwe en p atron s a n d th eir sup p liers th a t ser ve d to pr ote ct d om esti c s ilv e rs m iths fr om th eir mos t threat en in g co m pe titio n - foreign crafts me n w ho w ere th oro ug hly ac q ua in te d w ith cur re n t European fas hio n and o ften m or e techn icall y profi ci ent than th e Am eri can s. Th ou g h m an y Briti sh a n d Eur op ean s ilv e rs m iths mi g rat ed to th e co lo n ies . m o st o f th em wo rke d for Am er ican m ast e rs as j ourn eym en , o u t w o rk e r s, o r ind entured se rvan ts. O n ly a few su cce eded in o pe n ing th eir ow n ret ail sho ps, thu s pe rmittin g th em to m ark th eir w ar es an d id entify th ei r con tribution s for posterity . Without mark s or do cum ent ation for m o st of th o se ano ny m o us men, th ey co n stit ute a lar ge. overloo ked g ro up who se experti se und olibt edl y mad e p o ssibl e so me o f th e finest Am eri can silve r o f th e period. Fortunat ely, co nte mporar y n ewsp aper ad ve rt ise me n ts d o cument the ex is te nce of so me o f th em . Thou gh ce rta in ly not co m pr eh en sive. period refer en ces do provid e su ffic ien t eviden ce to sugges t th at th e ado ptio n an d developm ent o f th e ro co co sty le in th e co lonies were directly linked to immigrant art isans w ho had firsth an d kn owl ed g e of th e s ty le as well as th e s pecia lized abi li ty need ed to create its att ribu tes . Their co n tribut io ns hav e been routinel y ass igne d to sho p m ast er s. In the s t u dy o f Am e ri can silve r, th e init ial a nd n a m e m arks sta m ped o n an obj ect have tr aditi on ally been regarded as th e m ean s o f identifyin g th e m ake r. A g ive n silvers m ith's ab ility w as e valua te d on the ba si s o f o bjec ts sta m pe d w ith his m ark. Som e Am eric an silve rs m it hs m a y d eser ve th e reputati on th ey have g arne red as a result o f th at mi sint crpreration , but othe rs w er e almos t ce rta in ly ret ailer-silv ersm iths wh o su pe rv ise d thriving businesse s. Until furth e r resea rc h can untan gl e the we b of the Ameri can silver tr ad e or u nless specific ev idence sugges ts o t he rw ise , th e so -ca lle d m ake r's m ark o n hi gh - st yl e ro coco s ilve r s ho u ld be re g ard ed as a sho p mark onl y- an indi cati on o f w hen: the piece may have been asse m b led and w he re it w as so ld . but no pr oof at all of th e aut ho rship o f th e o rna me n t.
C has ing w as a hi ghl y dem and in g skill, more cha lleng ing th an eng ra ving and o ne th at Am er ican silvers m iths w ere not likely to hav e pr acti ced in th e preceding Qu een Ann e peri od . In v iew o f th e pau cit y o f h oll o w w ar e co m m iss io ns in m o st si lve rs m it hs' produ cti on (re pa irs and s ma ll w o rk mad e up m o st o f th eir tr ad e) an d th e still sma lle r per centage o f co mm ission s ca ll ing fo r suc h ex p ens ive o rna me n t , it is hi ghl y unlik el y th at d om esti c c r a ft s m e n co u ld h av e d e vel op ed chasi ng abilit y o f a qu alit y co m me ns ura te with th e m o st acco m plishe d essays in th e Am eri can ro co co . N ot o n ly did A me r ica n si lve rs m it hs co n t rac t am o ng th em selves fo r spec ialize d se rvices, th ey also em ployed full y tr ain ed silve rs m iths , som e o f w ho m w er e undoubtedl y practi ced in th e techniques. One o f th e least und er st ood area s of Am eri can s ilve r is th e id entit y a n d co n t ri b u tio n of those m en , m o st o f whom w e re jo u rncy mcn -c-silve rs m irhs w orkin g for a m ast er sm ith and under hi s m ark . The term " m aster silvers m it h," d esi gnatin g th e o w ne r o f a silve r wo rk s ho p, h as led t o th e co m mo n mi s con cepti on th at h e was always th e m ost skilled and ex pe rience d cra fts ma n. A m aster to ok o n ap p re n tices when th e y we re thirt een o r fourteen . Th e y were th en b ound to h im fo r a per iod o f abou t se ve n ye a rs until , h av in g se rve d th eir term , th e y b ecam e w ageearni ng jou rney men. The next tr an siti on , from j ourne ym an to m ast er, had less to d o w ith excepti on al abilit y th an w ith access to ca p ita l an d p atr on age a n d was b y n o me an s a foreg on e co n cl us io n . Th e eas ies t way to becom e a m ast er was to be born a m ast er's so n o r to m arr y a m ast er's dau ghter and so inherit tools, sho p, and clien te le. The journ eyma n w ish in g to e m ba rk o n hi s ow n and lackin g famil y co nnect ion s h ad to acc u m u la te s u bs ta n t ia l ca p it al, n ot o n ly to ac q u i re t he fund a m ent al s of h is tr ad e but also to ex te n d cred it to hi s patro n s. In ad d it io n, h e h ad to ea rn th e tru st and respect o f pot ential clients. In t he eigh teen th century, Am e r ic an si lve rs m i t hs fun ct io ned as broker s, tran sformin g t heir clients' asse ts into a di ffer ent k ind of co m mod ity . In Eng la n d , patron s w er e pr otect ed b y st rict go ve rn me n ta l regul ati on s requiri ng th at v irt ua lly eve ry p iece ret ail ed b e test ed a t an assay o ffice . Th o se o f sa tisfac tory alloy we re hallmark ed an d co ul d th en b e o ffe re d for sale . Be cau se n o s uc h o ffic ia l pr o cedur e d e vel op ed in t he No rt h Am eri can co lo nies, a di sh on est
O f th e three silver smithin g cen te rs (Bos to n, N ew York , and Phil adelphi a), Bost on was th e m o st co nse rva tive in rococo interpret ati on . Alth o u gh th e city h ad as mu ch access to th e st yle as did N ew York and Phil adelphia. a flaggin g eco nomy
74
and a shortage of fore ig n- tra ine d specia lists rn ay ex p lain her m o derate res ponse . En g lish rococo silve r can be d o cumented in New E ng land by t he lat e 1740s, q but Bo st onian s seem to ha ve o rdered fa r few er do mes t ic interpret ati on s o f th e n ew ch ased sty le . Eng lis h reco rds reveal th at th e t o t al w ei ght o f s il v e r a rt icles s hip pe d to N e w E ng la nd excee de d th at ex po rte d to Penn syl vani a b etween 1740 and 1758, yea rs o f th e ad o p t io n of t he r o co co in t he co lo n ie s .' .' On e o f th e fir st t r ad es t o be affected b y B o ston' s d eclin e in pr o sp erit y and popul ati on (m ain tain in g at o n ly fift een th ousand thr ou ghout th e ro co co pe r iod) was silve rs m it h ing . Th ou gh in it s prim e durin g th e fir st deca de o f th e 1700S, it h ad lo st mu ch o f it s prom ise by t he 1730S an d , co n seq u en tl y, at t rac te d far fewer ap p ren tices an d immigrant cra fts men . ,(, Forei g n silver worke rs brin gin g new st yles into America we re m o re lik el y t o se t tle in N ew York o r Philadelphia, w he re th e cha nces o f em p loy me n t w er e g rea te r. In co n t r ast w it h Ne w Yo rk, Phil adelph ia , a n d C har les to n ad v e r t isem ents, th o se in N ew Eng lan d new sp ap er s are co ns p icu o us ly la c ki n g in m enti on o f c ra fts me n lat el y fro m London o r tr ain ed in Eu ro pe.'? T he m ajority o f th e city 's silve rs m ith ing s ho p s w e re r u n by Am eric an-b orn m en, as m ight b e ex pec ted . Th e la g g in g eco no m y n otw ith st andin g , Boston s t il l h ad a numb er of a ffl ue n t cit ize ns , la rg ely m erchants. So me o f t he m p atroni zed th e ro co co , an d ch ie f a mo ng th e lo cal si lve rs m it h s w ho s u p p lied th em w it h o bjec ts in th e fu lly d evel oped mode w ere Benj amin Burt , N athaniel Hurd,
FIG URE 2(;. CO .ffCI' pot, 17(;2-(;3. Benjamin Brewood II , l ondon . Silver, H.: 12 in. (30. 5 cm .). Th e Metrop olitan Mu seum of Art , Gift of James Delancey Verplanck and John Bayard Rogers Verplanck, 1942 (42.88)
Sam uel Edwards, Th om as Ed w ard s, and Paul Revere . St yli sticall y, th e rococo work fro m Rever e's sho p surpasses that of th e o thers . P aul Re v ere ( 173 5- 18 18) was tr a in ed b y hi s father, A po llos Ri voire ( 1702- 1754) , a Fren ch Hu gu en ot brou ght to Bo st o n at the ag e of fourteen and ap p ren ticed to J ohn Coney ( 105 5150- 1722) . Re vere, th ou gh st ill a min or in 17 54, w h en he ass u med respo ns ibi lity for hi s fathe r's sho p aft er Ri voirc 's de a t h, h ad beco me a m ast e r g o ld sm it h in B o st on by 17 57 . Re ve re 's ca ree r as a silvers mi t h s pa n s three sty le periods-
17 57 , wh en a n adve rt iseme n t for sto le n s ilver d es crib e s a " chaced Salver , " as w ell as a " ch aced Coffee - Po t ," a mo ng
Q ueen Ann e, ro co co, an d n eocl assical - but hi s m o st impor-
several other pi eces, all o f w hic h were " Ste rl ing Pl at e, h av e a
ta n t wor ks a re fr om th e last t w o . Th e fortuitous surv iva l o f h is Da y B o ok s from 17 (,1 to ' 7Y 7 fac ilita tes a m ore acc u ra te assess ment of th e expense an d in cid en ce o f ro co co wo rk . An acco m p lis he d eng rave r as w ell (see pp . 39 , 40 , 51 for more in form ati on o n R ever e a n d o n th at as pec t of his w ork ) , Rev er e added suc h o rna men t to silve r o f hi s o w n an d o t hers' m akin g. I X New Yo rk' s co m m e r cia l ti es t o E ng la nd , so vit al t o h er g ro vvth , pr odu ced a co sm o p o litan cit y o f wealthy merch ants anxio us an d well able to affo rd to foll o w Lond on fashions.
Lion Sta m pt o n th e B ottom. " I ') Jud ith C ro m mcli n ( 1739 (803 ) an d Samu el ( 1737- 1820) Verp lan ck , who we re ma rr ied in 170 1, o w ne d so me h and som e ro co co pl at e fro m Lond on , includin g a la v ishl y chas ed teak ettl e o n sta n d en su ite w it h a co ffee pot (!'IG. 26), and a pair o f tea cad d ies, all d ate-m arked 1702-0 3. 20 The qu antit y o f Brit ish silve r ex po rte d to New York between 1747 an d 1703 was ge ne ra lly hi gh , av e rag ing 1,0(,8 o u nces a yea r b et w een 1747 a n d 17 58 a n d re achin g a n ave rage o f 3 , 4 87 o u nc es a ye a r betwe en 1759 a n d 17(,2. 2 1 N ew York silv er sm iths see m to h ave b een produ cin g ro co co sil v e r b y th e lat e 1750 S: th e M yers silv e r m ad e for
E ng li sh ro co co s ilve r can b e do cum ented in N ew Yo rk b y
Samuel and Su sann ah Co rne ll (see N o. 82;
75
FI G .
30, p . 123)
m o st likel y d at es fr om t h eir m ar ria g e in 17 56 ; in 17 5X. on e j o seph Pinto advertise d chased silve r milk pots. r' "
bran che s, t h a t co u ld b e h ad in a ny p art o f En gl and . "
0 ')
Be ca use N ew Yo r k was e njoying a p eri od of pro sp e r it y in
The city's n ewsp ap er s d o cum ent t he ex iste nce of forei gn
th e 17 50S an d 17oos, it fo llows t h at th e city was at t rac t ing a
silve rs m ith s throu ghout the period . Th e earliest refer en ce to
larg e nu rn bc r o f for ei gn silversmith s (in cl u d in g at leas t o ne deserter fr om t he B ri ti sh ar my ). 30 wh o . in th eir own shops
o ne o f them . in 17 54. p rob abl y id entifies th e m an responsib le for brin gin g th e sty le to N ew York. D ani el C h rist ian Fueter ( 1720- 17X5) w as b orn an d train ed in Switzerl and an d w o rke d
o r w orkin g for other s , su bs ta n t ially co n tr ib u te d to th e lo cal ro co co sty le.
in Bern before fleein g to Lond on as a politi cal refu g ee. After
N ew York's fin est r o co co silv er is m ark ed n ot o n ly by
at least tw o yea rs in th e Eng lish ca pita l. he emigrat ed in 1754
Fu ctcr but also by Ep hraim Bra sher, Pict cr d e Ri em er. j oh n
to N ew York. re m ai nin g t h er e unti l '769 . when h e ret urned
H eath . M ye r M ye rs . Ni cho la s Roo sev elt . and Ri ch ard Va n D y ck . Of th o se , th e sho p of M y e r M y e r s see ms t o h a ve
to Europ e an d. eve nt ua lly. to B ern . 0 3 Hi s E uropean ba ckg ro u n d probabl y acc o u n ts for h is flu en cy in ro co co interpre-
retailed the larg est pe rcentag e of o u ts ta n d ing exa mples . Bo rn
tation . I n 17 54 , h e a d ve rt is ed hi s a r r iva l in th e
S II OI /I IrCII C
in N ew Yo r k in 17 2 3 t o Dut ch immi gr an t p a rent s , M yer s
fr om Lond on. ad d ing th at he co u ld m ak e "a ll sorts o f Go ld an d Silver w ork . afte r th e ne w est an d n e at est Fashi o n . " 04
was p robab ly ed u ca te d at a sc h oo l m aintain ed b y th e fam ily
Becau se Fuerer su cce ed ed in o pe n ing hi s o w n sho p. h is m ark
sy n a gog ue, t h e C o ng rega t io n S h ea rit h Is rael. Th ou gh h is a p p re n t ices h ip is u nd o cum ent ed, h e is kn o wn t o h a ve
ide n ti fies so m e hi g hl y so p his tica te d ro coc o object s (see Nos.
be com e a fr eem an o f t h e city in 1746 , at t h e age o f t w en t y-
74. XI. X5).' 5 In t he 17 50 S. th e ro co co w as fu ll y m ature an d
three. and th erefo re en titl ed not o n ly to o pen a shop but also
flouri shin g in co n t inenta l Europe . th ou g h it wa s still a relati ve new com er to Am eri can sho res. Fu eter, w ho wo u ld have
to vot e . Hi s fir st m arri age. to Elka lah Co he n ( 1735- 1705),
b een we ll v er sed in th e sty le w he n h e ca me to th e co lo n ies.
d eat h. w as to j o yce Mea rs . in 1707 . Nine chi ld re n sur v ive d
mu st h av e b een in strum ent al in fo st er in g it s p op u lar it y in N ew York .
as a co m m u n it y lead er. h ol d in g o ffices in th e sy nagog ue as
Other forei gn er s pr ofi ci ent in r o co co d e cor at io n a re d o cumented in N e w York in th e 1760 S. In 1703, Ot'to Pari sie n adve rt ise d h im sel f as fr om B erlin a n d procl aim ed hi s
t o ok pl a ce e a rly in th e 175 0 S; h is seco n d . a fte r E lk ala hs from th e tw o marriag es . M yers pro spe red in h is ca reer an d wel l as in the lo cal M aso ni c lod g e . B y 17 55, he was t radin g w it h j ew ish m er chants in Ph iladelp h ia; in 17Xo. h e was cha irm an o f New York' s Go ld an d Silver Smi th 's Socie r y.:" H is
pr ow ess in " all So rts o f Pl at e Work. both p lain a nd chas'd . "0 0 Fu et er in form ed th e p ubli c in 1709 that "Mr. j o h n
sh o p e nj oye d th e p at ron ag e o f so me o f N ew York 's fin est
Anth on y Beau. C ha ise r, fr om Ge ne va, wo r k s w it h him. "
nells, an d th e Phi lip ses. Ex cept durin g th e British occ u pa tion o f the city, w h ic h h e s pen t in Co n nec t ic u t an d in Phil ad el-
07
Beau 's presen ce in N ew York m a y well h ave predated Fu ere r 's an no u nce men t. I f so . Beau m ay h ave been w orkin g for othe r silve rs m iths. possibl y for th at j o seph Pinto . w ho , after
famili es, incl udin g th e Livin g st ons, th e Schu y lc rs, th e Cor-
ph ia. M yer s rem ai ned in N ew York u n til hi s d eath , in 179 5. A n ad ve rt isemen t o f 1701. in w h ich M yer s in fo rmed th e publi c th at hi s E n glish inden tured serva n t, Lewis M ear s. "a
adve r t is ing th e mi lk p ot in 17 58 . we n t o n to o ffer in 170 [ a tureen , ca n d les t ic k s. coffee p ot s an d teap ots . sugar di sh es . w aste b o w ls, sa uce boa ts , all chased. as well as "C hass 'd and
j e w ell er b y Tr ade, an d ca n e ng rave," h ad run away. p ro ves
Pl ain" s ta n ds . mu g s, sa lv e rs , m ilk pot s , a n d w h is t l cs .:"
It ap pea rs t h at M ye rs w as s u pe r v is ing a j ewelry b us iness in
t ha t M yers w as usin g the sk ills o f immi grant silvc rs ru irhs. V
R egret tabl y. n o n e o f t hos e wo r ks a re kn own tod ay. A co n-
add iti on to hi s silver firm . and p o ssibly acce p ting eng ra vi ng
necti on amo ng Pinto , Beau. an d Fu ct cr see ms po ssibl e. Fue -
j ob s as we ll. Som e o f th e fine st e ng r a v ing of th e p eri od
rer, in hi s adve rt ise me n t o f 1769 . also an no u nced th at he h ad m o ved in to the hou se o f Mrs. Pinto, w h ich sugges ts tha t he
g races silve r from hi s sho p (se e N o s . 00 . 72 . 87 ). The large amo u n t o f pi e rced wo rk ascr ibe d to him o n th e b asis of hi s
h ad t ak en o ver h er hu sb and 's silve rs m it h ing sho p. I f Be au
m ark m a y a lso p oint t o th e se r v ices o f a cr afts ma n in hi s
h ad b een wo rk ing fo r Pin to , t h at m a y ex p la in ho w Fuctcr came to hire h im, on . The ap pea l o f fo re ig n- tra ined s p ec ia lis ts is m ad e ap pa ren t in an adve rt ise ment of 1771. in w h ich Bennett an d D ixo n. a p artnership produ cin g jewel ry an d s ma ll silver an d go ld w ork, n ot o n ly iden t ifie d th em sel ves as "from London " but also, foll owin g a list o f th eir wa res , added: " Likew ise for th e better ca r ry ing o n t he j ewell e r y. [sil ver smith] an d lap idar y bu siness. h a ve engaged so me o f th e b est w orkm en in th o se
e m p loy o r a v ai lable to h im . P ie r cin g wa s suc h a hi ghl y acco m p l is he d s p ec ia lty tha t ce rtai n Lond on s ilve rs mit hs su p p lied th e m ajorit y o f En g lish pi erced wa res in th e ro co co p er io d . A n im mig r an t jo u rn eyma n fr om on e of th eir sho ps m ay hav e wo rke d for M yer s. w h ich wo uld ex p lain the pier cin g on so me M ye r s silvcr an d also the ap pea ra nce o f for m s n ot co m mo n ly fo und in th e co lo n ies but routin el y p rodu ced in Lo nd on's s pecialized sho ps : coaste rs . a ba sk et. a di sh rin g . an d a fish slice.
a tea se r vice ( 1744 - 45 ) m ark ed b y Paul de Lam eri e ( FIG . 27), prob abl y a weddin g gi ft fr o m Lond o n rel at ives. H Am o n g Phil ad elphia silvers m it hs im po rti ng pla te were Rich a rd so n , john D avid , Philip Hulb e a rt , R ich a rd Humph re y s , j ohn Lea co ck , an d Edmund M iln e. Sta tis tics of th e per io d reveal th at th e qu antit y o f En gli sh silve r ex po rt ed to Ph ilad elphi a ave raged 581 o u nc es a year be tween 1747 an d 175 8 an d ro se to an ave rag e o f 2,832 o unces a yea r bet w een 1759 and 176 2, re a chin g a hi gh of 5,221 o u nc es in 176 0 . .1 .1 Th e sa me phenomen on alrea dy noted in N ew York points to th e p ro sper it y o f th e tw o cities , a res ult of th e m e rch ants ' lu crati ve
FIGURE
27.
co nt rac ts to su pply goods to th e British army, th en fig htin g the Fren ch and Ind ian War. Ex po rt s to both New York and Philad elphi a d eclin ed afte r 176 2 beca use o f po stwar re ce ssio ns and increasin g tr ad e ten sion s. Phil ad elphi a's dom est ic p rodu cti on o f ro co co si lv er can be dated from th e 1750S (see N os. 62 , 65, 75 , 88). N oti ces o f immi gr ant c ra fts me n ap pea r in cit y new sp aper adve r ti se ments throu ghout the 1760s and 1770s , but o nly tw o m en are mention ed as chase rs, and th ey d o not appea r until 1772 an d 1774 Y ' Th ou gh it is as ye t impos si b le to ide n t ify s pecific forei gn a r tisa ns w ho m a y h a ve be en resp o n sible for s u ch o rna me n t o n Ph il ad elphi a ro c o co s il ve r in th e 17 50 S an d 1760S, th at d o es not bel ie th eir ex is te nce . Am eri can m ast er sm it hs, unle ss th e y we re tr yi n g t o recover an in d entured se rva n t , rar el y publish ed notices of immig ra n t silve rs m it hs in th eir s ho ps . Th e m aj or it y of re fe re nce s to fo rei gn cra fts me n w er e b y th e fo rei g ne rs th em sel ves, adve rt isi ng eit he r th eir se rv ices o r th e se r v ices o f im m igran t a rt isa ns wo rking for th em . In ad d itio n to th o se m ent ion ed above , T hom as Shi eld s an d Phili p S yn g, J r. , are a mo n g P h il adel ph ia s ilvc rsrn i th s tr adition all y ac k now ledge d for t h ei r wo rk in t he r oco co style ; th e t w o wh o ca n b e re gard ed as t he most promi n en t retail er s o f silve r in th e ro co co tast e a re R ich a rd so n a n d Syng. J o seph R ich a rd son ( 1711- 1784) wa s a seco n d- ge ne ra ti on Ameri can a n d sil ve rs mi t h w ho se work s p anned th e Qu een Ann e and th e ro co co peri od s. Born in Ph ilad el ph ia, he was tr ain ed b y his fathe r, Fran cis Ri ch ard son ( 168 1- 1729), w hose tool s and bu sin ess he inherited at the age o f eig hte en . Ri ch ard son b e c am e a p r omin ent Qu a k er silve rs m it h and ci vic le ader, as well as a pr o sp er ou s land o wn er. In 1741, he m arri ed H ann ah Worril , w ho di ed fi ve yea rs lat e r, le avin g him w ith a dau ghter. In 1748, Rich ardson m arried agai n. Hi s seco n d wife , M ar y All en , bo re him three m ore da ug h ters and two so ns, J o seph junio r and N athani el, w ho learn ed th e trad e fr om th eir fath er and ass u me d resp on sibil it y fo r h is busin ess w he n h e retired in 1777 . As a phil anthropi st , Ri ch ardson su ppo rted th e Penn syl van ia H osp ital th rou gh ou t hi s ca reer. H e was a ls o a m em b e r a n d s h a re ho lder of t h e
Tcakcttte 01/ stand, 1744-4 5.
Paul de Lam erie, London . Silve r, H . (handle ex tended ): 14'% in . (37· 5 cm.). The M et ropol itan Mu seum of Art, Gift of George D . W idener and Eleanor W. Di xon (M rs. Wid ener Dixon), 1958 (58.7. 17)
P hi ladel p h ia was t h e f ore m o s t city in th e co lo n ies b y t he beg in ni ng of th e ro co co period . N ot a few a ffl ue n t Ph iladelphian s m aintain ed both city and co untry hou ses, and m o st of th em m ad e a n e ffor t to k eep up w it h th e cu rren t Lond on tast es. Wh ereas Rev ere 's p ro d u c tio n o f te ap ots in Bo st on ave rage d o n e a year bet w een 1761 an d 1767, joseph Rich ard son 's orde rs to Lond on bet w een 1759 an d 1767 ave raged o ut to an an n ua l six , in add itio n to th o se produ ced in his Ph iladelphia sh op . .J.J En gli sh roco co silve r was bein g ex po rte d to Philadelphia by th e la te 1740s, w he n David an d M ar garet Franks received
77
Lib rar y C o m pan y o f Phil ad el ph ia and a resp ect ed lead er in hi s Q ua ker co ng rega t io n . .1 7 Hi s lette r bo ok d o cum ents hi s co ns ide rable imp orti n g bu sin ess w it h Eng lis h si lvers mi t hs an d m erch ant s b et w e en 17 5 11 an d 177 3 , in t e r rupt e d b y peri od s o f eco no m ic declin e and by th e co lo nial nonimportati on ag ree me n ts, w h ic h R ich a rd son su p po rted . .1X Th e su bs ta n tia l q ua n tity of im port o rde rs reco rd ed b y Rich ard son sugges ts th e po ssibi lit y th at he br ou ght in un ma rked Eng lish s il ve r, t o w h ic h h e adde d h is ow n s tamp. Th at th e or y is cas ily re fut ed . E ng lis h si lve r wi t ho u t h allm ark s co uld n o t h a ve bee n ex po rted le g all y, a n d th e s ma ll a mou n t of fees saved by silvers m it hs e vad ing th e assay law s wou ld not have justifi ed th e ris k th ey ran . .1 ') Furth er. peri o d adve rtise me n ts in co lo nia l n e w sp a p ers le a ve n o do u b t th at Lo n do n s ilver identifiabl e by its hallm ar ks had g rea t cac he t. Irish -born Philip Syn g , J r. ( 1703-17119), was also tra ined b y his father, an Eng lis h si lversm it h w ho wo rke d in B ristol. br ou ght h is fa m ily t o Ann ap ol is in 1714 , a nd m o ved to Ph ilad elphi a b y th e en d of th e yea r. Wh en he went back to Ann ap oli s, abo ut 17 24, yo u ng Sy ng ass u me d t he Ph iladel phi a bu sin ess. 4° In 1725, he sai led fo r Lon d on and re t u rned th e next yea r, presum abl y w it h p attern s and tool s. In 173 0, he m arried Eli zabeth Warn er . Lik e Rich ardson , Sy ng too k an act i ve ro le in th e affai rs of th e c ity. H e was a m e mb er o f se ve ra l resp ect ed o rga n iza tio ns, in cludin g the Junto '(Benj am in Fr ankl in' s in te llect ua l circle) an d th e Am e ri can Phil o soph ical So cie t y. H e w as also a direct or o f the Librar y Co m pa ny o f Phil a d elph ia a nd a trus tee of th e Co llege o f Phil ad elphi a . Sy ng h ad ac q ui red th e se r vices of a Lond on eng rave r by 17411, t h e year La wren ce Hu bert adver tised as suc h . 41 In 176 3 , alo n g wi th Rich ard son . he was ap po inte d to se t tle the es ta te o f fell o w si lve rsm ith Phili p Hulbcarr . Wh en h e ret ir ed , in 177 2 . Sy ng rent ed hi s wo r ks ho p to twe n ty t w o - year-ol d Ri ch ard Humphre y s an d reco m me nded h is successo r to his clients in a new sp aper adve rtiseme nt.":' Ri ch ardson was bo rn in Am eri ca and Sy ng imm ig rated at th e age of eleven: both we re tr ain ed in th e co lo nies . Silver bearing th eir m ark s has so me o f th e m o st acco m plished chas ing o f any fro m th e Am eri c an ro co co pe r io d. Th a t eit her Ri ch a rd so n o r Syng, w ho we re schooled durin g th e Qu een Ann e era in a style not kn o wn fo r chased deco ra tio n. co uld h a ve ac q u ire d t he s k ills to execu te th e ir ow n c hasi ng is unlik el y. Be fo re the 17505. when t heir fi nes t wo rks we re cr eat ed, th ei r co mm iss io ns for suc h ex pe ns ive pi eces wo uld h ave been infrequ ent ind eed . Ri ch ard son' s coffee po t (No. (5) an d a m at chin g suga r d is h for t he Pen in g ton s date from aro u n d 1754; hi s teak ett le o n sta nd fo r th e Pl um stc ds (No . XII) was co mple te d b e fore 17 5 5. Syngs coffee po t for th e Ga lloways (No . ()2) p roba b ly dates fro m t heir marriage, in 17 53 ; hi s sa lve r fo r t he Penin gt on s (No. 75) . from aro u nd
17 54 . T ha t impressi ve g ro up co ns ti tutes some of t he earl iest d at a b le Am er ican rococo silver; th at it is a lso among t he m ost hi ghl y develo pe d in sty le arg ues fo r the participation of foreig n chasers. N othin g is kn o w n of j o urn eym an chasers in e it he r man's s hop, but if n eith e r p o ssessed such abi lity amo ng h is e m p loyees, it see ms cer ta in th at he would have contrac te d for it. Eve n if g hos t c hasers for P h ilad elp hia's
finest rococo silver ca n no t ye t be identified . the like lihood of th eir ex iste nce is un de niable . Phi ladelphia's size and prosperit y wo u ld ha ve at t rac te d immi gran t crafts me n and dictated th at he r silver ind us t ry fo llo w closely th e Lo ndon model.
T he fo u rt h major co lo nia l city was C ha rleston. but too little silve r surv ives fro m th e re to d o cum ent it as an eighteenthccn ru r y sitver sm ithi n g ce nter. Wealth y southerners were not m erch ant s wi t h cas h but planters w ith credit in Engla nd; as a co nseq ue nce. th e y imp o rt e d a su bs ta n tial amou nt of their silver d irec tly fro m Lond on . Bet w een 17 SO and 17()9 , exports of Br it ish silver into th e Ca ro linas exceeded th e combined total expo rted into New Eng lan d, N e w Yo r k , and Pen nsylva nia fo r th e sa me pe riod . 4 .\ C ha rles to n 's stro ng economic t ies wi t h Lond on wo u ld h a ve le ssen ed t he demand for lo ca lly p ro du ce d si lver. No ne t heless, Lon d o n- t raine d J o h n PaLlI Gri m ke advertised in 17()0 th at he ha d acqu ired the services of a j ourn eym an chaser and, a yea r lat er. Jo hn Winckler p ro cl aim ed him self a "S ilver-s mi t h and Chaser from Lon d o n . " H M ore o ver, pe riod adve rt iseme nts revea l severa l foreig n si lversmi t hs worki ng in C ha rles to n and five local silversm it h- reta ile rs se lling im po rted silver be tween 176 1 and 177 2 ,4) Th e sole su rv iving exa m ple of ma ture rococo silver fro m C ha rles ton (No. ()4) must represe nt a larger group of hi gh- st yl e domes t ic s ilver th at was converted to cash or dest ro yed in the Civil War.
T he ro co co style was ne ver th e last word in fas hion for all Am eri can pat ro ns . Even in imp o rt ed si lver, orders for o bjects in th e ro co co m od e we re acco m panied by orders for pl ain, un ch ascd p ieces. Th e ro co co was, after all, a sty list ic cho ice, almos t always mo re ex pe nsive tha n the plain er forms o f th e Q uee n Ann e peri od . Th e sty le flo ur ished during the 17 50S and 17()OS, o ne o f th e m o st prosp erou s periods in coloni al hi s tor y , b ut it s prog ress was inte rrupted by one of the m o st tur b ule nt. Re cessio n s in th e wa ke of th e Fr en ch and In di an War. fo llowe d b y co n flicts wi th Eng land over taxes levi ed o n imp ort ed goo ds. cu lm inating in the Re volu tio n. ce rta in ly limi te d and dis rup ted t he n atur al co urse of t he ro co co sty le. By t he resolu tion of th e Wa r of Ind ep en den ce, in 17113, t he n e o cl ass ic al was th e n e w s ty le of c hoice for fashio na ble silver pat rons.
In eig h tee n t h-ce n t u ry A merica, " the te a ce remony, som etim es sim p le, so me times elabo ra te, was th e ve ry co re o f famil y life. " 52 Th e b ever ag e was served by a lady of t he hou seh old sea te d at a tea tabl e, aro und whic h guests mi n-
Tea and Coffee Forms
gled, sit ting o r sta ndi ng. A fully eq uipped tab le hel d a teapot, w ast e bo wl , cream po t, tea canis ter, sugar dis h, suga r ton g s, cu ps an d sa ucers, and teas poons . H ig h society p re ferr ed c u ps-w it ho u t h an d le s fo r te a , wi th hand les for choco la te or coffee -a nd saucers to be of porcelain, bu t th e rem ainder of th e equ ipage was most desirable in silver. The rep ast mi ght have co nsis ted of cakes, pastries, n u ts, sweet mea ts, frui t - de pe ndi ng o n th e ho st 's m ean s. Teatime w as th e m o st socia l time of th e day; besi des fami ly m e mber s, p arti cip ants inclu d ed friends w ho ca lled, vis ito rs in to wn, and ge n tl e me n co u rti ng m ar riag eab le yo ung lad ies. Th e co u r ti ng as pec t co ul d ex te n d th e even t we ll int o th e e ve n i ng, w he n a va r iety of e n te rtai n me n ts we re offe re d. T w o suc h occa sio ns we re record ed b y Nancy S hippe n of Philad elphia in a jou rna l she kept fro m 1783 to 1786:
T he majority of Am erican rococo silve r is rep res en ted by th e for ms cra fted in the co lo n ies beginni ng in th e lat e 174 0 S for a domestic ri tua l th e n rece n tl y im po rt ed from En gl and : th e servi ng o f tea and coffee. Th o se exo tic bev erages, th e fir st intro du ce d t o E urope fro m th e Orie n t; th e seco n d, fr om t he M id e ast (wi t h a th ir d, choco la te, im po r te d fr om th e A mericas), exerc ise d a social influen ce that was palp abl e in Londo n b y th e last qu arter of th e seven tee n t h ce n t ury. In 1660, Sa m ue l Pep y s reco rde d hi s fi rs t tea-tast in g . In 16 5 2 , Lo nd on 's fir st coffee ho use o pe ne d, foll o w ed in 16 7 0 b y th e fi rs t in Bo sr ou .! " Specia lized form s m ad e fo r th e se rv ice o f eac h beve rage a re we ll d o cum en t ed b y 17 0 0 . T ea was beli e v ed t o h a v e m ed ic in al prop e rt ies , w h ile co ffee was ex to lled in a Lond on ad ver tise men t of 1660 as "w ho leso me, preservi ng health until ex t re me o ld age, good fo r clea ri ng th e sig h t [a nd a b le to] m ak e the b od y active an d lu st y . "4 7 Both co nta ine d caffeine, a stim ulus to th e ner vou s sys te m , as did t he less p opu la r choco la te. P rior to th eir int ro d uc tio n, th e gentry had ac hieved th e sa me effec t b y co ns umi ng lar ge a mo u nts of s ugar a t m e al s , a prac t ice th e y aba n do ne d in favor of th e new drin ks.:" B y 17 0 0 , t he m o re pri vil eged Am er ican s we re enjoying tea, coffee, an d choco la te. Th e pa r ta king o f tea, assoc ia te d
Mr s Allen & the Miss C hews drank Tea with me & spent th e eve n'g. T here was half a dozen agreable & sensible men that was of the part y. T he conversation was carried on in th e mos t spr ig htly. agrea ble manner . . . till nine w he n ca rds was proposed, & abo ut ten, refres hments were intro duced which concluded the Evening.. . . Saturd ay night at II o'clock . I had a very large com pany at Tea this Evening . . . . I don't know when I spent a more merry Eveng. We had music, Cards, &c &c. N ot all tea p arti es we re so jocu lar. A s a E uropean vis ito r co m p la in ed: "Th e o n ly th in g you h ear . . . is t he whis tli ng so u n d m ad e b y th e lip s o n edges of th e cu ps . T his mu si c is v ar ied b y th e requ est m ad e to you to h a ve anot he r cu p." For ei gn e r s we re di str ess ed w hen they found themse lves ig no ra n t o f th e pr op e r w ay to p reve nt th ei r hos tess from refillin g th ei r cu ps . A Fr en ch n o bl e m an descri bed h is dilemm a as a g ues t at tea in th e P h il ad e lph ia h om e of t he Signer Rob ert M orris: I part ook of mos t excellent tea and I shou ld be even now still drinking it. I believe. if the [French ] Ambassador had not charitab ly no tified me at the twelfth cup, that I must put my spoo n across it when I wished to finish with this sort of war m water. ... It is almost as ill-bred to refuse a cup of tea when it is offered to you, as it wo uld [bel indiscreet for the mistress of the house to pro pose a fresh one. when the ceremony of the spoon has notified her tha t we no longer wish to partake of it.
w it h a ceremon ial cus to m o rig ina ting in J ap an , w as ado pte d in th e co lo nies, as it had bee n in Eng land, as a hi ghl y important socia l ritu al fre q ue n tly ad m inis te re d b y wo me n.'!" The mos t p opul ar o f th e thre e b e v er ag es , i t was b e comin g in cr easin gl y affor da ble b y th e midd le of th e eig htee n t h century ; in th e yea r 17 59 , m ore th an six tee n th ou sand po unds of tea we re co ns u me d in B o st on alone. 50 In En gl and, w he n Pc p ys fi rs t tast ed it, a p ound o f fin e tea cos t three pound s ten shillings; by 17 0 0, it cos t o nly a pound; b y 17 6 0 , its pri ce had dro p pe d to ten shillings. Thou gh th at was still not in expe nsive w he n co m pared with th e pri ce o f m eat (three pe nce a pound ), it was a m ore affordab le luxury. ·\1
So me tim e lat er, ano t he r Fre nc h vis itor ad mired a clever b u t uniniti at ed fo reign er , w ho. hav in g cons umed repea te d cu ps o f te a, " dec ide d afte r e m p ty ing it to p ut it into h is pocke t until the repl en ishm ents had been co ncluded ."
79
TEA
SETS
Tea se ts-co ns isting va rio us ly of a teap o t, coffee pot. sug ar d ish , crea m pot , an d addi tio na l acco ut rements , all m ade en su ite -were new in the rococo period . Tw o existing English se ts are d o cum ent ed in Ph il ad elphi a. O ne , m ark ed by th e Lond on firm o f Whipham and Wri ght, dat in g from 1763 and eng rave d w it h th e Ll o y d coa t of a r ms, was part of the dow ry o f Elizabeth Llo yd, w ho ma rried J ohn (later General ) Ca dwa lader (see p . (85) in 176 8; th e o the r is known in sur vivi ng pi eces fro m th e Fra n ks fa mi ly silver (see FIG. 2 7, p. 77) . w hic h show th at th ey were part o f a se t marked by Paul de Lam erie in 1744-4 5. 53 Am eri can exa m p les d at in g b e fore th e 179 0 S are rare. J oseph Richard son 's acco unts record th at he supplied a set to Samu el Blun st on in 1737. H A s ea rly as 17 59, Ri ch ard so n o rde red fro m England a list of objects th at inclu ded " 3 Doub le Belli ed Sil ver tea Potts w ith St ands or we ighte rs Neatly C has t " and " 3 D ou bl e Bell ied Sh uga r Dis hes with Covers N eatl y C has t to Sui t th e tea Potts. " A year lat er, his book co n ta ins th e same so rt of o rder, but th at o ne requ est ed two teap ots w ith acco m pa ny ing suga r dish es eng raved instead of chase d an d w ith th e ad d itio n of "2 C ream Pott s or Ewers to Su it th e Ab o ve. " " H o w lit er all y th e Lon don rec ip ien ts of th ose or ders int erpret ed " to sui t" canno t be dete rmi ned . Did th e y s u p p ly se ts w it h ide n t ica l d ecor at io n or pieces with sim ila r deco rati on ? In v iew of Rich ar d son 's repeated ho pe th at his or de rs wo uld be "Shi p t Per firs t O pperrunity, ,,-, 6 it is not illogi cal to ass u me th at m an y o f th e " set s" we re assembled from stoc k o n h an d to sa tisfy Ri ch ar d so n 's continual pl eas for h ast e . Th e ea rl ies t se t reco rd ed in Pau l Revere' s led g er s was made in 1764 fo r Ca p tai n J o seph Goodwin and co nsisted o f a teap ot , suga r dish, and crea m pot. 57 Wh at is t ra di tio na ll y co ns ide red o ne of the ea rliest ex isti ng Am eri can rococo tea sets 5 ~ is marke d b y Pi et er d e Riem er (N o. 48). Its ind iv id ua l elem ents, not ide ntical in decora tion b ut si m ilar in sty le, m ay h ave been entirely co nsistent w ith En gli sh prototyp es of the ki nd im po rte d by Richardson . T he se t's pi eces, if n o t m ad e en s u ite , were ce rtai n ly commissio ne d wi thi n a sho rt per iod of tim e, po ssib ly for a patron w hose ab ra de d, partl y illegi bl e initials, eng raved in Ro m an ca pita ls. are visi b le on the foot riIII of eac h . If they ar c correctl y inte rpre ted as L / PC , the initi al s may be t h o se of Philip Sc h uyler Van Renss elae r's g ra nd paren ts Ph ilip ( 1710(778 ) an d C h ristina (Ten B ro eck ) Livin gsto n ( 1718- r80 1). ,'J (Eac h piece has later engraving of th e initials PS VR and crest o f th e g ra n dso n, born in 1700 .) [f so , th e se t wou ld mo st likel y date be twee n abo ut 1703, w hen Riem er became active. and 1778, th e yea r Livingston d ied .
Ho
T ea set, ca. 17('5- 75 Pict er de Riem er , New York Silver. H .: teap ot . (jY. ill .. suga r bowl. -l'y. ill. • crea m pot, 5 '!~ ill . Mu seum of th e C ity of N ew Yo rk
81
elem ent, though the additi on to t he foo t of a sp ira l flut ed band sugges ts a ro co co co nsc io usness. A s di scu ssed b el o w, the teapot (see p. 85) is a su perb interp retati on o f th e sty le . It is appropriat e that th e coffee pot (see p. 9 7) ranks as th e fin est ro co co exa m p le fr om B o st on , s ince it was cl earl y intended as th e cen te rpiece of th e service . The sauce boa rs, o r butter boats, displa y th e scro lling han dl es and fee t, sca llo ped rim s, and shell kn ee s typi cal of both Eng lis h an d Am er ican exampl es, au g m en te d b y th e eng raved arms . The tea ton gs hav e shell g rips, pi erced fret w ork de rived fr om ch inoise rie desi gn s, and peak ed raffl es eng raved at th e top o f th e ar ms . On the arm s, th e pi e rced fre two rk re la tes to d esi gn s published in Chippend ale' s D irector and also fo un d o n ro co co furnitur e (see N o . [ 21 ) . Sim ilar tea to n g s are referred to in J o seph Ri ch ard son' s lett er b o o k as "Pei rce d Spring tea tongs. ,,63
Pi eter d e R iem er ( 1738- [8 [4) , an A m e rican of Dutch d escent , w as b orn to Cath arine and Steenw yck de Ri emer an d w as b apti zed in th e Reformed Dutch C h urc h in New York in 1739. App renticed to N ew York silversm ith Nicholas Roosevelt, wh o se ex pe rtise in th e ro coc o sty le is discu ssed els ew h e re (se e N o. 77) , he m arried in Alb an y in [763 , the yea r he becam e an active silversmith in N ew York City.6o T he so le doc u me nted Am eri can tea set to su rv ive fr om the ro co co p eri od was p art o f a se rv ice o rd e red from Paul Re vere b y Dr. Will iam Pain e for his bride, Lois Orne (a distant co us in o f Rev er e 's fir st w ife), in 177 3 (N o . 49 ). Paine ( 1750- [833) g ra d ua te d fr om H arvard in 1768 an d es tablis hed a m edi cal practice in Worcester sho rtly thereaft er. A Loyalist, he was fo rced to leave Wo rcest er in 1774 after sig n in g a protes t agains t a resolut ion p assed b y th e to wn meetin g. He we n t to Boston an d joine d th e British army, and the following yea r w ent to Sco tl a n d to co n ti n ue m edi cal st u d ies. In 1778, he returned to Am eri ca as an apo theca ry to the British forces in Rh od e Island and N ew York . (.1 P aine' s co m miss io n o f fort y-fiv e pi eces w as recorded in Re v er e' s led g er s o n 2 Sept emb er 1773 . Not a set but a se rvice, it co ns isted o f a teapot , a co ffee pot; a cream pot, a tan ka rd , a p air of ca n ns, a pair o f butter boat s, a pair o f porr ing e rs, a p air of tea ton g s, t wel ve lar g e sp oo n s , eig h te en teas p oo ns , four sa lt sp oo ns , an d a w o od en case to contain t he se rv ice. Every piece w as en g raved with th e Orne arms, cres t, o r initi al s, so me w ith all three. Rev er e charg ed Paine £74 for th e silve r and £H for his lab or . The service is lar gely intact but for tw el ve spoons (including th e four salt spo o ns), the porringer s, th e crea m pot , and th e w oo de n case .?:' Except for th e spoons, nearl y all the form s in th e service are in th e rococo m ode. Least rococo are the tan kard and th e ca n ns: o n th e t an k a rd , o n ly th e finial and e ng ra ve d a rm s bes pea k th e style; o n th e ca n ns, th e arm s are the sig n atu re
It h as b een noted th at t he teapot ma de fo r Dr. Pain e in 1773 w as o ne o f o n ly t w o re corded in Re v er e' s boo ks between 176 9 an d 177 5, a pau cit y reflecting th e p olitical climate. ('4 Rever e custo marily recorded from o ne to t w o teapots a yea r, but esca lati ng ten sions over t he Town shen d duties impo sed in 1767 and th e Tea A ct of 1773 wo u ld see m to ha ve influen ced not o nly the am o u n t of tea cons u med in Boston but also th e p ro d u ct io n of th e vessels for se rv ing it. As a Loy ali st , Pain e wou ld not have h esi ta ted to o rde r a te ap ot, but hi s ord er sho uld n ot be considered an ex t ravagant procl amat ion of his po litical sympathies, a "mon umental tea service," as has bee n sugges ted .I" T he com m iss io n as a wh ole w as a ge nera l si lver serv ice , co n sis tin g of ea ting, drinkin g , and se rv ing forms , as w ell as t he ac tua l tea an d co ffee vess els. It s com ponen ts suggest not a political sta te m ent but a brideg roo m's des ire to deli gh t his w ife w ith an impressive g ift. It was th e la rgest sin g le o rder reco rde d in Re ver e's led ger s, an d it wo uld have been o nly natural for th e silversmith to tr eat it as th e mas terpiece o f his car eer.
49
Selectionsfro m a Illcddil/g service, 1773 Pa ul Rever e. Bo ston Silve r. H .: co ffee po t, 1 3 Y~ in., tea po t, 6% in., can n, 5 in ., bu tte r boat, 4-% in. , L. : dessert spoon, X·v. in., teasp oon. 5'% in. , tea to ngs, 5'% in . Worcest er Art Museum
83
TEAPOTS Wh eth er p rodu ced in sets or ind ividuall y, holl o w w are form s for th e serv in g o f te a and co ffee were tran sformed in to so m e o f th e most rep resentati ve and m o st lav ish d em on st rati ons of th e sty le in Am e ri can s ilve r. N ot onl y wer e th e y o rna me n te d with ro coco engravin g, chas ing . and casting, but their shape s becam e ro co co as we ll. Th e fo cal p oint of th e te a se r v ice , th e tea pot , beg an as a s ma ll, squ at for m of g lo b ula r or pear shape b ut . as th e ro co co period pro g ressed , evolve d into an apple sha pe rising fr om a stepp ed fo ot. B y th e full m aturit y of the sty le . rococo te apot s h ad b e com e m ore dr am ati c in d esi g n : t all a n d to phea v y, w ith s wo lle n sh o u ld e rs ab o ve s ma ller, roun d ed be llies and w ith d om ed lid s th at p ro vid ed a vi su al co unter pa rt to tho se ful som e elem ents. The m e re reve rs in g of th e simp le pear sha pe re sulted in a su rpr isi ng ly e le ga nt fo r m, w h ich si lv ers mit h s FIG UH E 28. T eapot, 1745. Jacob Hurd , Boston . Silver , H .: 5 in. (13.3 cm .). H ood Mu seum of Art , Dartmouth College; Gift of Lou ise C. and Frank L. H arr in gt on , C lass of 1')24 (M. '}67. 42) 1/ .
d es cr ib ed as " d o u b le belli ed . " Wh en co rr ectly in terpret ed, th e m ass o f th e pot w as elevated w ell above th e sur face o f th e tabl e. g iving th e imp ression of a vess el in graceful defian ce o f gra v ity, an implied ins tab ility th at was cha ra cteristic o f th e ro co co sty le 's pen ch ant fo r floutin g co n ven tio n. Suc h a sha pe co nceded pr actica li t y to aes t he t ics, s in ce th e b est-t a st in g te a req uired a pot expansi ve eno ug h at th e bottom to permit a ma xim um q uantit y o f boilin g wa te r to suffuse th e tea leaves. Engravi ng w as th e aven ue of en try for ro co co design in the co lo n ie s . B y 1745, En gli sh pr int e d e p he m er a, in cludin g b ill heads , tr ad e card s, and boo k pla te s , had begu n to ma ke po pul ar the asy m me tri ca l ca rto u che th at was a s ig n at u re m oti f o f the new sty le . It is therefo re to be exp ect ed th at th e earli est instan ce o f th e ro co co in s ilve r w o uld be th e en grave d a ppli ca ti on o f a read ily ava ilable printed d esign. The first d o cum ented ro co co de coratio n to ap pear in Am erican silve r o cc u r s o n a Bo st on te ap ot (r rc . 28) da ted 1745 and m ark ed b y J acob Hurd ( 1703- 1758).6fo Q uee n An ne in sty le. the co nve n tio na l pot , g lo b u lar and with a flat lid , is ne vert hel ess enli ghten ed wi t h e ngr av in g of as y m me t rical carto uches co mpo sed o f raffl es, C - scro lls, and fo liage th at ap pear o n eithe r side o f the vessel , o n o ne side fra m in g the arm s o f the Payer w earh er famil y o f Bo st on , o n th e o the r enclosi ng the in scrip ti on " T he Gi ft /O F /Edwd Tyn g Esqr / to / H . Fayer w carh er z Decr 1) / 1745 ." (Ha n n ah Fa ye r w e a rh c r was m arri ed o n
10
D e ce m be r 1745 to
Farr Tolm an , a Bo st on bo okb indcr .)"? D espite that roc o co decora tio n . th e engravin g aro u nd the li d of the po t rem ain s baroque. a d ic hoto my th at s u g g es ts th at th e e ng rav e r, po ss ibl y J a m es Turner (see p . 31) )," x co p ie d th e a rmoria l ca rto u ches from an 50 T eapot, ca. 1753 John Cob urn , Boston Silve r, H. : 6 Y2 in. Histor ic Deerfi eld , Inc.
Eng lis h b o okpl at e o r o t h er ro co co e ng rav i ng b u t w as le ss assured in ad ap tin g th e new sty le to th e lid deco ration . A teap ot (N o . 50 ) m ark ed b y J ohn Co b u rn w as co m m iss io ne d b y T ho ma s Welles ( 1692- 17(>7) of Glasto nbury, Co n necticu t. fo r
hi s d a u gh ter M a r y ( 1735- 1814), alon g w ith a silve r c rea m pot an d a sug ar caste r, p robabl y o n the o ccas io n of her m ar riage, in 1753 . " ~ Th e p ot , m o re th an a n inc h in he ig h t ove r th e o ne
Br it ish rococo teap ots; hi s m ean s w o u ld h a ve e na b le d hi m to ord er a p ot simi la r to th e m an d m ore ela b o r a te th an m ost Am eri can ex am ples of th e tim e.?'
m ark ed b y Hu rd , ha s an a p p le- s h a p ed body e leva te d o n a
Th e Ro ss t eap ot illu st r at es th e fu lly d e vel o p ed r o co co
s te p ped , circ u la r fo o t. It s t all e r pro fi le, th ou gh n ot d oubl e bellied , is still inde bted to th e infl uence o f ro coco design, as are th e spo ut wi th its cast scro lled design s, th e d om ed lid , and th e
inte rp ret ati on o f th e fo rm , a do ubl e-belli ed sha pe w ith chased
flam e fin ial. T h e m os t m a tur e sty list ic as pe ct o f th e pot is th e eng raving: ro coco C- scro lls and diapered panels enc ircle th e lid , and the Welles fam ily arms appear o n the bod y in an asy m m etrical carto uchc o f raffle s, scrolls, and fo liag e. T he po t is typi cal o f
de corati on . Th e formula, deri ved from im po rted Briti sh ex am pl es. was co m mo n in En g land but relatively ra re in A m eri can silver. Sin ce th e co m bina tio n was th e m ost ex pensive o f available de si gn s, th at was prob abl y as mu ch a m att er o f cos t as of taste .
num er o us N ew En g land co u nte r p art s, fled glin g in form an d limi ted to su btle en g rav ed decoratio n for th eir fullest ex pressio n o f th e sty le. J o h n Co b u rn ( 170 3- 175 8), a Bo s ton silve rs m it h b orn in Yo rk , M aine, w ho probab ly app rent iced w ith T ho m as Edward s o f Bo ston, is best kn o w n fo r h is tea and ch urch silver. C o bu rn occas io n ally o rde re d silve r o bjects fro m Paul Re ver e an d also co n trac te d for h is ser v ices as a n e n g ra ve r. 7° Thu s, th e Well es tea po t m ay have been eng rav ed b y Revere. Th e best e x am p le o f a New Eng lan d rococo t ea p ot w it h engraved de cora tio n is th e o ne sup plied b y Revere as part o f th e Pai ne service (No. 49). T he pot (see de tail) is doubl e bellied in sh a pe; th e circ u la r fo ot is ele va ted an d ad o rn ed w ith a flut ed ba nd; th e fini al is in the for m of a lar ge, crisp ly det ailed pin eapple. The asy m me t ry o f th e en g rave d car to uc h e, which is m ore flo rid an d ex pa nsi ve th an th at o f the Welles po t , is ac centu ated by a tr ailin g ri b bon , o r m o t to sc ro ll, her e le ft bl ank . Re ver e, w ho is k nown to h ave co pied Eng lish engra vi n gs lin e for lin e (see N o s. 12, 13) , m a y h a ve b o r rowed th e ca r tou che fr om an Eng lis h a rmo rial de vi ce w ith m ot to in tact. In ad ditio n, roco co flourish es, di aper ing , an d C- sc ro lls are engraved o n th e lid an d aro un d th e han d le an d spo u t j un ctur es , w hile th e spo ut is cas t w ith rococo C -scrolls and acanthus leaves. Th e fin est surv iv ing ro co co teap ot fro m Boston is also m ark ed b y Re ver e (N o . 51 ) . Like th e Pain e se t co u n te rpa rt , it is full y r o co co in form an d h as the sa m e cast s po ut d esig n . In ste ad of th e e ngrav ing th at a p pea rs o n th e m aj orit y o f Bo ston ro co co teap ots, ch asing m antl es th e sho ulders an d forms the ca rto uche o n thi s exa m p le. T he icon og raph y of th e pot's deco rat ion is the m o st exo tic o f any o bse rve d o n Boston teap ots. As we ll as th e u su al fl o w e r s , r affles , an d C -sc ro lls, it fea tu res a bird an d a chino ise rie pavilio n (see det ail). The Ro ss fami ly arms eng ra ved o n th e ca r ro uc he are proba bly fo r th e patri ot J ohn Ross ( [720 1800) , a shi p p ing merc han t w ho em igrate d fro m Perth, Scotland . to Ph il ad elph ia in [7 ° 3 a n d lat e r se r ved as p u rc ha sing age n t for th e Co n t in e nt al Co ng re ss . Hi s re ce n t arriv al in Am eri ca wo u ld h ave ens u re d hi s fam ilia rity w it h m ore o rna te
N o. 49 (detail)
51
Teap ) ot . ca . 176 5- 70 I aul Revere . Bo ston S'I 1 ver, H .: 5% in Mu seu m of Fme .Arts, Bo sto n
,-
S6
As wi th B o sto n work, mos t N ew Yo rk rococo teap ots are eng raved, bu t examples w it h chased decorati on su rv ive in numbers co mparab le to t hose k now n fr om N ew En gl and . The fines t of t hese is t h e o ne m ark ed by Pi ct er de Ri em er (No. 48) , wi t h its accompa nying crea m pot an d suga r di sh . Like th e Ro ss fami ly pot su pplied by Revere, it has a ste pped foot. do me d lid , a n d pin e ap pl e fi n ia l; w h ile it la ck s th e othe r's cen tra l ca r to uc he, it h as a m o re ela bora te aca n t h us and-s hell -cast spo u t. The sho ulde rs are o rn ately de corat ed wi t h a fluid, si n uo us d es ign o f fl o w e rs an d raffl e-dr ap ed C -sc ro lls carefu lly proportion ed to t he curve of th e pot. Wi th few exce p tio ns, Ph il ad el p h ia 's exc rn pl ar y rococo teapo ts fa ll s ho rt of th e d oubl e-b elli ed and chased formula observed in Bo ston and N ew York . One o f th e fin est chased Ph iladelph ia teapots (N o . 52) is ap ple-s ha pe d, akin in form to the o ne Co bu rn su pplied fo r th e We lles fam ily . C ra fted in th e shop o f J o seph Ri ch ard son , it s sha pe, ste ppe d fo ot , an d do med lid are co ns ide re d tr ait s o f ea rly rococo teap ots. Full y ma ture . ho w ev er, is its ex u be rant deco rati on o f chased flo w ers , raffles, and C -scro lls, w h ic h ex te n ds n e arl y h alfw a y down th e p ot' s p ro fil e a n d a do rns the s po u t, h andl e j unc ture . and lid. Eq ua lly rococo is th e cas t pinea p ple fini al embe llis hed w it h C-scro lls ben eath furling leaves. En su ite wi t h th e teap ot is a suga r di sh havin g an ide n tica l fini al an d simila r chased dccora tio n. ?" Mos t of the su rv iving doubl e-bell ied teap ots from Ph iladel p hia a re not chased bu t eng raved. Am on g th e fine st is one (N o . 53 ) mar ke d by Ph ili p Sy ng , Jr., w h ic h is e ng rave d w it h t he arms o f th e Bayar d fami ly, possibly fo r' M ar ylandborn but la te r Phil ad elph ian J ohn Bu benheim Bayard ( 17381807 ), me rc ha nt, sta tes ma n, and m ember of th e Co ntine nta l Cong ress from Pennsyl van ia. T he slig htly exaggera te d form of t he pot resu lts fro m t he ex pa nsive swe lli ng-o u t o f th e sho u lders ove r a proport io na te ly sma ll b ell y . Lackin g th e ve rtica l ba lance of th e usual domed lid (t h is lid is lo w an d gen tly curved), th e po t, poise d on its sma ll, tuc ked -i n base, has a horizon tal em p hasis th at accen t ua tes its rococo d efi an ce o f rules .
T he quintesse ntia l Am er ican ro coco teap ot was produ ced in Ba lti mo re (a sa te ll ite o f Ph ilad el phi a p rio r to nati onh o od ) and so m ust be co ns idered a re la tive of P h ilade lphia exa m ples . T he tea po t (N o . 54 ), m ark ed b y Ga b riel Lcw y n , is a su pe r b co mpos itio n of form , prop orti on, and deco ra ti o n . The sumptuous. in teg ra l chased d esi gn, it s fold ed tend ril s traili ng onto the lo w er body in im ita tio n o f nature, ca re fu lly co nforms to t he do ub le -be llie d shape of th e vesse l. A s a res u lt of its spoo l-s haped pe desta l. t he foo t is hi gh er th an
52
T eapot, ca. 1755- 60 Joseph Richardson , Phil adelphia Silver , H .: 6 in. T he Hi stor ical Soc iety of Pennsy lvania
53 T eapot, 1760-70 Ph ilip Syng, J r. , Phil adelphi a Silver , H .: 5If2 in. Department of State
th o se o f it s contemp or ari es . Flutin g o n th e foot r un I S repeated a ro u n d th e lid, w h ic h is cr o wn ed b y a ca st threedimen sion al flo wer- a sc ulpt u ra l elem ent rare in Am eri can ro co co silve r. Am on g the handful o f related fini al s kn o wn a re a flower o n th e Ri ch ard son co ffee p ot (No. 0S) a n d accompan yin g sugar di sh , an d b ird fini als found o n Alban y suga r di sh es, includin g o ne attrib ute d to J acob Gerritse Lansi ng (No . 57) . Al so richl y cas t ar e the she lls , sc ro lls , and foli ag e o f th e s po u t, whi ch is a mo ng th e m o st o rna te of its kind . Littl e is kn o w n a bo u t th e s il ve rs m it h Lcw y n . His wher eab outs are a mys tery befo re [770. w he n he appea red in Ann ap olis a n d in the s a H1C year m o v ed t o B al tim ore. T he
masterl y d esi gn and executio n o f his teap ot sugges t th at he was eit he r tr ain ed abro ad o r h ad access to th e serv ices of a su perb chase r. En gli sh ro co co s ilve r ow ne d in Baltim ore co uld have influen ced th e design ."! Barrist er C ha rles Ca rro ll ( [723 - [8 [7) o f th at city h ad so me ve ry fin e London exa m pl es: a se t o f tea canis te rs d ated [70 3- 04 and a double-bell ied ch ased co ffee pot dated [70 5. 74
S4
Teapot. [700 - 70 Gabriel Lew yn, Baltimore Silver. H .: 0 in . Ph illips Collection. Yale Un iversity
SUGAR
D ISHES
AND
C REA M
POTS
A di scu ssion of tea form s in Am eri can roco co silve r necessa r ily includes th e an cill ar y vesse ls for s uga r a n d c rea m . Perhaps because th ey co ns titu ted less o f an in vestment, suga r di she s a n d cre am pots (as th e y we re ca lle d in p eri od accounts ) o ccurred as se ts th at su rv ive in g rea te r num b er s t han tho se t hat include a te apot, po ssibl y bec au se th ey we re ordered to ac co m pa ny a ch ina t eapot w it h m at chin g cu ps and saucers. Most often, ho w ever, th e y we re m ad e as individ ual forms, as is attest ed b y Pau l Rev er e 's led g ers .I" The de signation "cream pot" or " crea m ewer" is used apart from "milk Potts or Ew er s " in J os eph Ri chard son ' s o r de rs t o Lo ndo n, bu t t he t erms w ere pro b a bl y in ter ch an g e a b le : R ich a r d so n ' s specific ation for th e milk vesse ls , " to wei gh from 3 to 4 oz . , " mat ch es exactly the r an ge o f w ei ght he specifies for cream pots . (In hi s led g er s, Rever e recorded th e sa me r a n g e of we ight for th e sa me form s. ) Doubtless be cause c re a m pots w er e sm a lle r an d le ss ex pe n s ive th an sugar d ishes and th e sugar it self m ore co st ly th an th e more easi ly obtained cream , o rde rs for sing le cre a m pots g rea tly o utn um be r order s for individu al suga r di sh es in Rev ere' s led g ers. Ric hardson routin ely o rd ere d do zen s of crea m pots bu t ordered s u ga r di shes onl y t o acco m pa ny tea o r co ffee po ts . ?" H is ord ers for both fr equ entl y specifie d doub le- o r sing le- be ll ie d shap es , plain, en gr av ed, o r chase d; as w it h t e ap o t s , the most ro coc o an d mo st cos tly o f th em we re double bellied and chased. T he sup erlative Phi ladelphia c rea m p ot is o ne m ark ed b y Philip Hulbearr (N o . 55 ) so m et im e before 17() 3 , the yea r o f his d eath . Despite it s tradi tion al sing le- be llie d form, th e pot is di stinctl y rococo, as seen in th e chased d ecorati on added all over the bod y and in the modifi cati on o f ce r ta in elem en ts of the vessel : the rim more d eepl y sca llo pe d , th e spou t m ore elongated than on ea rlie r exa m ples, and , in pla ce of th e typical cast scro llin g h andle, o ne cre ate d b y th e u se o f a special mold of more intri cat e d esi gn . Furth er sc ro lls an d leafag e adorn t he lower return of th e h andl e , a n d , a t its upp er j u n c t u r c w it h t h e rim , a to p th e u su al C - s c ro ll, th e re a re raffles and sc ro lls th at su p po rt a ves tig ial ca ry at id rel at ed to tho se found on th e handles of late- sev enteenth-century cu ps in En gland an d Am eri ca."? Hulbearr also red esigned th e feet of the pot ; in p la ce o f th e usu a l cab r iol e or scro ll feet, he substitut ed cast In d ian figures , an allegor y for th e Am erican con tinent co m m o n in pe riod iconography (se e FIG. 4, p . 14; No . 34 ) and found in br oad sid e s an d Europe an w ork s in severa l m cdiurn s .?" Su ch human figural references we re part of the s t an da r d vo cabul ar y in E u ro pea n ro co co sil ver but are se ldo m found in Am eri can w ork . The y cha rac te rize th e
55 Crealll pot. ca . 1760 Phili p H ulbcar r. Philadelphia Silver. H .: 4V. in . Phi ladelphi a Mu seum of Art
90
56 S ligar dish and cream pot. 1760-7 5
Myer Myers. New Yor k Silver. H.: sugar dish. 6¥. in.. cream pot. 6¥. in. Collection of the Brinckerhoff family
m ost ebullient Eng lish ro coco form s: for exa m ple, on a ewer o f [74- 2 fro m th e s ho p o f Paul d e Lam cr ie, a fem al e figure form s th e h andl e . 7') On the b od y o f th e Hulbcart pot , the ch as ing is lo o se an d all- enc o m pass ing -a floral design that relates to pattern s o n th e palarnporcs m ade o f co tt o n chintz that we re th en bein g imported from India, xo but with added raffl es and scrolls. Ph ili p Hulb ca rt (d . [7( 3) , so n o f Willi am Hulbeart, o f Bri st ol , Engla nd, w as briefl y a resid ent o f Philadelphia. The ea rl ies t re ference to him in t ha t city is in th e yea r 1701, when h e advertised in th e Pcnn s vl v an ia Gaze tte . X I N othin g is known of his apprentices hi p o r im m ig ra tio n to Ame rica, but he likely came t o join a n u ncle wh o a lrea dy resided in Ph ilad elph ia . Lik e J o seph Ri ch a rd son. H ulb carr e vide n tly impo rted Eng lis h silver. fo r he adve rt ise d it alo ng with th e wo rk of hi s own sho p . When he di ed , in [70 3, Rich ardson and fell ow Phi lad elphi a silve rs mi t h Philip Sy ng , J r. , we re ap po in te d to se t tle h is es ta te . Am on g th e o bjec ts sold , pri ma rily to o the r Phil ad elphia silve rs m iths, we re sho e bu ckles . " a nea t g ilt silver w hi stle and co rc l with eig ht bells , " " a nea t chase d Slo p Bowl ," "a Su g ar Di sh. " " a Cas te r. " and thirteen crea m pots. xz
Tw o s u r v Iv ing N ew York silve r s uga r-a n d -c rea m se ts, marked b y two differ ent silve rs m iths, di spla y va riatio ns in treatment and in de sign. Both se ts illustr at e th e d o ub lcbellied and chased interpret ation of th e form s. The fir st is part of the tea set made b y Pierer de Riem er (No. 4- 1\ ), w hich als o includes a teapot. S l C en te re d o n b oth c re a m p ot an d sugar dish is an asymm etri cal ca rro uc he en velo ped b y flower s and C-scroll s. Each o f th e vessels ha s t ypical New York cha rac te ristic s: th e suga r di sh has th e reel lid ret ain ed fro m th e ea rl ie r Qu een Ann e fashi on an d th e c rea m pot h as th e ped est al foot and twist ed-scroll handl e associa te d w ith N ew York r o c o c o milk p ot s . It is iut c re s t iug to no te t h at th e cr e am pot is end owe d w ith one o f th e r ar e in cid e n ces o f anima l decoration in Am eri can ro co co silver, a lar ge chased bird per ched to the left o f th e ca rto uc he. The seco n d suga r-a nd-crea m set (N o . 56 ) survives w ith an En gli sh co ffee p ot assaye d in 17 01- 02 b y th e Lond on partner ship o f Willi am and Rob ert Pcast on. The suga r dish is m ark ed b y M yer M yers; th e crea m pot, though unm arked, is at t rib uted to his sho p o n th e b asi s of it s sim ila rity to th e sug a r di sh. Assembled as a se t so me time in th e eig h te en th century, all three pie ces are hi ghl y ro co co, are eng raved with
<)[
th e initials DR fo r th eir o rig ina l owne r, Doro thea Rem sen, and descended in her fami ly. T he M yer s pieces are unu sual in th eir display of imb ri cated sca les arra nged in ver tical panels, an Eng lish ro coco m otif associa te d wi t h th e sho p of Paul de Lam eri e in th e 1730sX4 an d v irtua lly abse n t fro m t he America n ro co co voca b u la ry . (T he Peast on coffee po t, lack in g suc h o rn ame n t , do es n ot ap pea r to have been the model for th e Am eri can vessc ls.) Lo gi c p o ints to an Eng lis h-trai ned chase r, fam iliar wi t h th e style in Lon d on . Th e cream po t is of t yp ical rococo s ha pe a n d d eco rati on ; it s ha n d le h as t he cha rac teris tic N ew York t w ist see n On th e Ri em e r version. Th e suga r di sh, h o w e ver. is aty p ica l; it s slim me r and more atte nua te d p roporti on s sugges t t he infl uen ce of an Englis h do ub le- b ellied tea ca d dy, a n eleg an t, elo nga ted form often m ad e in p air s e n s u it e w ith a s ugar di sh o f co nventio na l g lo b u lar form . N o suc h se ts are kn o wn in Am e rican silve r, but at least o ne fro m Lond on was owne d in M ar ylan d by M ar g ar ett a (Tilg h ma n) Ca rro ll (1742- 1783), th e gift of her b rid eg ro om , B ar r ist er C ha rles Car ro ll, to w hom she was m ar~ied in Jun e 1703. Xs Simi lar se ts we re po ssibl y owned in N ew York . Dorothea Rem sen ( 1750- 1834) was ma rried to Abra ham Brin ck er hoff ( 1745- 1823) in 1772. The co u ple resided in New York Ci ty. in a fash ion abl e h o u se o n Br o ad w a y, and h ad th ei r po rtra its painted-h er s by J ohn Trum b ull ; hi s by Gilbert Stua rt. Hr, Abrah am w as th e so n o f th e m erch ant George B rin ck erh off and h is seco n d w ife, th e for m e r M a r ia Van D eu sen . Do ro t hea 's fa ther was Pet e r Rem sen, also of New Yo rk C ity. W h ile th e design o f th e Peaston coffee po t has littl e in comm on w ith any eleme nt of th e M yers suga r-a nd -c ream ensembl e, its bi rd fini al is sim ilar to th at found o n a double -bellied sugar dish (N o . 57 ) attributed to th e shop ofJ aco b Gerri tse Lan sing , of Alb an y. At least three o the r bird fini als ap pea r On surv iv ing sugar d ish es - al so d oubl e b elli ed , t w o of t h e m chased - from Al ban y. X7 Bird fini als arc su ffic iently u ncomm on in Am erican ro co co silve r th at o ne can ass u me that th e Alb an y g ro u p was in flue nce d b y an impo rt ed exa m ple o r by an im m igra n t crafts ma n. T h e Van Ren ssel aer co llec tio ns at th eir fa mi ly es ta te , C he r r y Hill (t he n o u tsi de Al b an y) , in clude d a do ubl e-belli ed and chased Lon don tea po t of 1702 havin g a cast bird finial. xx N ew York C ity sugar di shes often have th e ree l top of th e t yp e see n o n th e sugar d is h of t h e Riem er set (No . 48). T his Alban y sugar di sh is adorned with re lie f chas ing o f C-sc ro lls, flo w ers, an d leafage. Alth o u gh unm ar k ed . it h as lo n g bee n attri b u te d t o Lan s in g on t h e bas is of its p rovena nce . It has th e eng ra ved ini tials F / I L for th e silve rs m ith 's seco nd w ife and co usin, Fem rn etj e Lansing . and for him self, as we ll as the in itials 1'v1/ I L for he r paren ts
57 Sligar dish. Albany. 1760- 75 Attributed to Jacob Gerritse Lansing Silver. H.: 4% in. Albany Institut e of History and Art
1)2
an d Lan sin g 's aunt an d uncl e, M ar ytj e an d Co lo ne l J acob J . Lan sin g . The sim ila rity o f th e bo w l' s chas ing to th at o f two exa m ples h av in g m ark s associa te d w ith Abrah am Schu yler h as s ugg es ted rea ttr ib u t io n o f th e p ie ce to th at Alb an y silve rsmi th. An alter na te ex plana tio n w ould be the existence in Al b an y of a chase r who decorat ed all three di sh es, as w ell as o the r exa m ples o f chased ro co co silve r from Alban y. J acob Ge rr itse Lan sing ( 1736- 180 3) was bo rn in Alban y, so n o f Ger ritse Lan sin g and g ran dso n o f silv ers m it h J a cob G errit se Lan s in g ( 16 8 1- 176 7), p o s sibl y th e b oy' s m aster. Lan sin g m arri ed hi s fir st wife, N celtj c Ro seb oom , in 176 7; hi s secon d , Fcm m ctj c, in 1774. Lan sin g w as evidently highl y regarded b y Alb an y town offi cials, for in 1784 th ey co m m issio ne d him to c ra ft a gold box for pr esentation to General
sio ne d b y silversm ith Benj amin G ree ne ( 174 7- 180 7) for hi s sis te r-i n- law Lucretia C ha nd le r ( 1728 - 17( 8) in h on or of h er m arriag e, in 1761, to J ohn Murra y (d. 1794 ) . Lu cret ia k ept hou se for Greene afte r th e death of his w ife, M ary, Lucret ia's eld est sis ter. The su gar di sh , recorded in Rev ere 's led ger s o n II M ar ch 1762, is invo iced at £4- 17- 8 for th e silve r co ntent of nearl y fourteen o u n ces. Rever e cha rged £ 1 - 12- 0 to m ak e it , bringin g the tot al cos t o f th e dis h to .£6-9-8 . x" (C urio u sly, th ere is no mention o f th e cream p ot in Rev ere 's led g ers.) The cr eam pot illustrates th e doubl e-bellied sha pe ele vated on three feet in pla ce of th e pedest al fo ot co m mo n in N ew York . On the su g ar dish , th e pineappl e finial is o f th e sa me casting found on several o f Revere 's rococo form s. ,,0 Both
Washington .
double-bellied p iece s are orn at ely chase d with ro caill e-cdgcd C- sc ro lls , raffles, acanth us , and flower s, Revere, an en gr av er
The m o st notable cream - and-s uga r ense m ble survivin g from B o ston (N o . 58 ) , m ark ed b y Paul Rev ere, w as co m m is-
him self, probabl y h ad a sk il le d chase r in hi s e m p loy : hi s ledgers record his suppl yin g o t he r silve rs mi t hs with chased silver ,",
58 S ligar dish and cream pot , 17 61 - 6 2 Pau l Rever e, Bo st on Silver, H . : suga r dish, 6 1/ 2 in . , crea m pot , 4-% in . M useum o f Fin e Arts, Bo st on
93
Newport, Rhode Island, though not on e of th e three colo nial silve rs m ith ing ce n te rs , w as a thrivin g urban seaport in th e eighteenth ce n tury, with a pro sp er ou s merch ant class. Silversmith Samuel Casey (ca. 1 72~- ca . 1780) mu st have dr awn so me of his clients from N ewport, though he lived in nearby South Kingstown . A crea m pot with Cas ey 's m ark (N o . 59) ha s becom e a fav orit e a mo ng hi st o rian s of th e America n decor ative art s be cau se o f its cast claw -and-b all feet and their similarit y to tho se found o n contemp orar y Rh o d e Islan d furniture. C law- an d- ba ll feet also occur o n roco co salvers o f t he per iod (se e No s . 01, 73) , but the y are un comm on o n vessel forms . ~o T he elon ga ted talon s and oval ball do ind eed correspo nd to th e regi o nal ch aracteri sti cs of feet on N ewport furniture, and with good reason . Silv er smiths frequ entl y acq uired th eir castin g po sitive s (o r ig ina l mod els from w h ic h th ey made their molds) from ca rvers; the sam e cr aft sm an w ho su pp lied these to C asey was pr ob abl y also ca rv ing full-sized feet for chairs, table s, and case pieces. (T he renderin g o f th e talons is in the mann er o f th e g rea t N ewport cabine tmaker Joh n Goddard .) The sing le- be llied sha pe o f th e Casey cream pot is not unlike th e form o f th e H ulb cart exa m ple (N o . 55), but the hei ght an d n ature o f th e feet g ive it an altoge ther diffe rent aspe ct-less elega n t but m ore liv el y. T he chaser used pun ches to crea te th e effe ct o f ruffled edges tha t contai n a br o ad b and of foli at e sc ro ll s flankin g , und er th e spou t, a ce n t ra l ciph er (I e ) o f a d esi gn d erived fro m a book of ciphers published by Sam ue l Sympson (Londo n, 1720). ~ 3 Casey, pre sumedl y b orn in Newp ort , a ppren t ice d in Boston with Ja cob Hurd (see FI G. 28, p . 8 ~) . In 1 7~ 5 , he was made a freeman in E xeter, Rhode Isl an d , wh er e he firs t es tab lis hed a sil vers m ith in g business . He m oved to So uth Kingstown b y 1750 and within a few year s m arried M artha M ar tin . Despite th e skill and quality manifested in th e cream pot, Case y was a sa d co nt ras t to the man y co lo nia l silve rsm iths who pro spered and becam e civi c lead ers. A se ries of misfortunes led to h is decl ar ation of in solvenc y in 1770 and his subs eque n t imprisonm ent for cou nt erfeiting. In 1779 . his wife su ccess fu lly petiti on ed th e G en er al Assem bl y fo r h is pardon, de scribing him as "forl orn an d forsaken and des titute o f every m ean s o f su p po rt to m ak e hi s life even desi rable, sep ar ated from his wife and o ffspring. " ~-l
59 C ream pot. 1755- 70 Sam uel Casey. Rh od e Island Silver. H .: 4 in. Museum of Fine Arts. Boston
<J4
COFFEE
POTS
Opp o siti on t o th e To wn sh en d A ct s , w h ic h h a d i m pose d duti es o n sever al im p orted co m mod it ies in 1767, res u lte d in bo y cotts o f th e t ax ed items. (T h ree yea rs lat er, th e t ax was re p ea led o n all but tea.) The co n troversy in te nsified w ith th e p assa g e o f th e Tea A ct of 1773, w hic h gave th e E a st Indi a Co m pa ny a v irt ua l m o n op ol y on ex porta t io n o f th e co mm odit y t o the co lo nies. Th e fam ou s B o s t on Tea P art y follo w ed, a n d th e a bs te nt io n fro m te a d rew m ore s u p po rt in Am eri ca. A hum o rou s renun ciation , titled "A Lad y 's Adieu to h e r Tea-Tabl e," a p pea re d in se vera l co lo nial n e w sp ap ers o n th e eve o f th e Re vo lution :
FAREWELL the Tea-boa rd with your gaudy attire, Ye cups and ye saucers that I did admire; To my cream pot and tongs I now bid adieu; T hat pleasure's all fled that l an ce found in you .
Farewe ll prett y chest that so lately did shine , With hyson and congo and best do ub le fine; Many a sweet mo men t by you I have sat, Hearin g girls and old maids to tattle and chat; And the spruce coxco m b laugh at nothing at all, O nly some silly wo rd that mig ht happen to fall. No more shall my teapot so generous be In filling the cups with this pern icious tea, For I'll fill it wi th wa ter and drink out the same, Before I'll lose LI Il EHT Y that dearest name, Because I am taught (and believe it is fact) T hat our ruin is aimed at in the late act, O f im posing a dut y on all foreign Teas, Which detestable stuff we can quit when we please. I.IImn y's the God dess that I do ado re, And I'll maint ain her righ t until my last hour, Before she shall part I will die in the cause, Fo r I'll never be govcrri'd by tyranny's law s.":
There see ms n o d oubt th at th e im b r o glio served to ele va te th e socia l sta tus of coffee as an accep ta b le alter na tive t o th e tr aditional b e verag e in m an y afte rnoo n socia l ga th e rings . A v isi to r to Nomini Hall , th e Virgini a plant ati on o f Colo ne l Robert Ca rt er, noted in hi s j ournal o n a Sunda y in M a y 1774: " After d in ne r w e h a d a G ra n d & ag reea b le Walk in & throu gh th e Ga rde ns - There is g reat pl enty o f Strawberries, so me C he r r ies, Goose berries & c. - Dr ank C o ffee at four, the y a re no w to o patriotic to u se tea. " <)(, Before th e c r is is, co ffee p ot s we re rare e n t r ies in P aul R evere 's led g ers: o n ly t w o were recorded be twee n 1761 a n d 1767 . In 176<) , h owev er , w he n t he Bri ti sh m ilita ry's atte m p t
95
to en fo rce th e duties en raged Bo ston citize ns, six m ore w ere en tered , and an addi tio na l fou r a p pea red in 177 2 an d 177 3 . Th at to ta l o f ten o rde re d bet w een 17 6 9 an d 177 5 is in sha r p co ntras t w ith th e listin g of on ly t w o teap ots in th e sa me sixyear peri od , th ou gh th ey h ad form erl y been p rodu ced at th e rat e of o ne to tw o a year. 'J 7
o unces ; th e teap ot, a t eig h tee n o unces eleven pe nnyweig ht, was less th an half th a t. 101
Coffee, w h ile co ns u me d in the h om e , w as a lso associa te d wi t h th e m a le dom ain o f publi c co ffee ho uses, th o se "cente rs o f political, social an d lit er ar y influen ce as we ll as of co m me rc ia l life , " 'J 'J w here th e b e ver a g e was d isp en sed in ser vi ceabl e tin pots, as it was in mos t co lo n ial hom es; o nly th e m o st a ffl ue nt co u ld a ffo rd silver. Avail abl e at breakfast alo ng wi t h tea , coffee co u ld also be tak en in th e lat e afte rnoo n wi th its orien ta l co us in. Dinner was cus to ma rily se rve d at t w o o'clock. A s C lau de Bl an ch ard , a vis ito r from Fra nce, n ot ed , " [A me rica ns ] d o n o t ta ke co ffee imm edi at el y a fte r d inn er, but it is se rved three o r fo ur h ours afte rwa rds w it h tea; thi s co ffee is wea k and fo ur or five cu ps are not eq ua l to o ne o f o u rs; so th at th ey tak e m an y o f th em. The tea, o n th e co nt ra ry, is ve ry st ro ng . T h is usc of tea and coffee is uni versal in Am eri ca. " ' 00
The Pain e exa m p le (No. 49 , sec det ail), ma de in 1773, is the fin est sur vivi ng doubl e- belli ed rococo co ffee pot from Boston , di stin gui sh ed from its lo c al co u n te r pa rts (including o the rs m ar ked b y Re ver e) by the broa d ba nd of spi ral fluting o n it s fo ot, th e she ll cas ting at its u pper han dl e juncture, its size . an d it s we ig ht. (T he latt er exceeds t h at of mos t of Rev ere' s co ffee pots, w hich are no t m ore th an fo rty ou nces .) Eig ht years lat er, o n a po t (N o . 60) he su ppl ied to Paul D udley Sargent ( 1745- 1828), an officer in th e Revoluti on and later a promin ent M ain e j uris t, Re ver e rep eat ed th e same design w ith o n ly slig h t m odifi cati on s. H e used a di fferent mold for th e pin eapple fini al, di sp en sed wi th the cast she ll at the uppe r h andl e jun cture, an d, o n th e foo t, su bs ti t u ted a gadroo ned rim fo r th e spiral fluted band . A ne w n eo cl assi cal tast e, t races o f w h ic h arc visible in 1774 in Phil ad elph ia silvc r.!":' had begun to influ en ce design in th e decorative arts b y 17 81. T ho ug h Revere started to alter his style in holl o w w ar e as ea rly as 1782,10.1 harbin gers of the new m od e can be see n in th e ca rto uc he o n the Sargen t pot of th e previous yea r. The Sa rgen t arms are g lorio usly engraved in ro co co fas hio n, b ut a closer exa mi na tion reveals that neoclassical m otifs a re intermin gl ed wi t h th e ra ffles, C -scrolls, and fo liage. Th e lo w er half o f th e ca rro uc he is ado rned with asy m me t r ica lly pl a ced p end ent swags of drapery and a bellfl o wer ga rla n d. Th e car to uc he it sel f, w hen compared with o ne Rev ere devi sed in 1764 to surro und the fami ly arms o n a Sa rge n t b o okpl at e ( No. 16 ) , s hows a s imp lified and ti ghten ed co m positio n . W hi le still roco co in sty le, the later int erp ret at ion has less fro th and foli age, th e leaves are trea ted as tw o dis ti nc t b ran ch es, and th e ri ght one is contained in the sugges tio n o f a classical urn .
Coffee p ot s, evo lv ing fr om a cy li n d r ica l, lighth ou se sha pe in to a cu r vi ng bal u st er , m atured in th e rococo peri od into a do u ble- be llied fo rm wi th a ste p pe d dom ed lid b alan cin g the curving lo w e r profi le. Ro co co decorati on , lik e th at of te ap ot s, was ac hieved th rou gh cas t e le me n ts , with th e ad di tio n of chas ing or eng ra ving o r both . O n th e co ffee pot , a fo r m m ore sta tuesq ue th an th e teap ot , th e do u b le-bellie d sha pe was even m o re ar res ting; a fu lly rococo co ffee pot w as an i m p o s i n o, and expensive objec t. A p er fe ct co m pariso n bet w een th e teap ot and th e coffee po t is do cum ented in Paul Revere 's led ger entry fo r th e Paine se rv ice, w hic h incl udes both. Th e t w o pots h ave si mi lar decorati on , as be fits a se t, yet in lab o r alo ne th e cos t fo r "m ak in g an d eng rav ing" t he co ffee po t was .1:7-9-4; fo r t he tea po t , it was on ly 1: 4-12-0. T he real di sp a rit y, h o w ever, was in the si lver co nte nt: t he w eight o f th e coffee pot was record ed as j us t o ver fo rt y- five
Simil ar to th e Pain e an d Sargent po ts is a pat rician exa mple th at prob abl y da tes from th e 1770S. M ad e in Philadelph ia and m a rk ed b y Ri ch a rd Humph re y s, th e p ot (N o . 61 ) differs from th e t w o Rever e m od el s ch ie fly in th e sha pe and placem en t o f th e s po u t, h ere m ount ed lo w on the bel ly and ri sin g a lmos t ve rtica lly be fore c urving o ut a t t h e lip. All three pots have ro co co ar mo rial engraving. but the ar ms on th e Humphre y s po t, con ta ined in a ca rr o uch c, are uniden tifi ed . T hey m a y h ave been th e wo rk o f J am es Sm ith er (see Nos. 32, 33 ), who engra ved a sim ilar ca rro uc he on a tea urn sup plie d b y Humph reys in 1774 for C ha rles Thomson, first secretary o f th e Contine nta l Cong ress . 104 l3e c au s e th e d ou b le - b elli ed coffee p o t wit h eng raved deco rat io n was co m mo n in Eng lis h silve r and was p robab ly im ported int o all th e co lo nial urb an centers , th e simi lari ty of
In ea rly-eig h te en t h-cen t ury Am eri ca, if o bs ervatio ns o f fo re ig ne rs are to be tru st ed, o n ly th e p ri vile ged few had th e tim e to ind u lge in th e lei surel y ritua l of afte rnoo n tea, wi th its porcel ain cu ps an d sa ucers and its silve r se rv ing vessels. B y m id-centur y, h o w e ver , tea. coffee . a n d choco late were co m mo n s ta p les in m o st co lo nia l lard e rs. Naturali st Pet er Kal m , visiting Pen ns yl vani a in 1748, o bse rved th at all three beve rages " at p resent co ns tit u te eve n th e co u n t ry peo p le's dai ly br eak fast , " a rem a rk borne o u t b y th at o f th e hist o rian and aut ho r Isr ael A creliu s a few years late r: " Tea, co ffee, and choco la te are so g e ne ra l as to b e fo u nd in t he m o st rem ote cabins, if not for daily usc, ye t for visito rs , mi xed w ith Muscovado , o r raw suga r. ''')S
0 .49 (detail)
60
Coffee p OI.
1781
Paul Rever e. Boston Silver , H . : 12.7/" in . M useum of Fin e Arts. Bo sto n
61
Coffee p al 01/ stand , 1770- S 0 Richard Humphrey s. Philadelphi a Silver. H . . pot: 13% in .: Di am . . stand: r;% in. Mu seum of Fine Art s. Boston
th e Revere and Humphreys co ffee pots, as well as of certain N ew York ex am p les revealin g the sa me formul a, su p po rts th e co n cl us io n th at th e form' s de si gn h ad it s so u rc e in imported British models. ID S The elon gated shape of all three pots imitates th e increasin gl y atte n ua te d British interpretati on of th e form , whi ch evo lve d in London in th e [760S (see FI G . 26, p. 75). A demon stration of th e influ enc e of foreign silve r is provid ed b y th e trio of tripod coffee pots from Salem (see p. 7[) . An En gli sh model imported into th at cit y (see N o . 46) wa s an unusual design th at spa w ned two American co p ies for another Sal em family (see NO .47), but th e tripod form occ urs no where else in the colonies. Th e Humphre y s p ot is p arti cul arl y unu su al in th at it surv ives w ith it s o r ig in al m at chin g sta n d (see detail ), o f a sca llo pe d ro co co sha pe w ith shell and leaf castings punctuatin g th e ga d roo ne d b order an d with central armorial engravin g th at is n earl y id ent ical t o that o n the pot. j o seph Rich ard son 's import records leave no doubt th at he routinel y o rde red teap ots an d co ffee p ots with sta n ds. (Pe rh a ps th at w as a practi ce ce nte red in Philad elphi a, for it is not on e refl ected in Revere 's led g er s .) Between 175 8 an d 1773, Richard son o rde red thirty teapots, tw ent y-four o f th em with sta n ds, an d twent y-four co ffee pots, tw enty-on e of them sim ilarly acco m pa nied. 10 6 An inventory taken in 1771 o f john Ca dwalade r's silver closet list ed a chocolate pot, a coffee pot, and a teap ot, eac h with a sta nd . 107 Ri ch ard Humph reys (1750- 1832) w as one o f th e leadin g si lve rs m it hs o f Phil ad elphi a. Born in to a di stingui shed Qu aker family in Tort ol a, in th e West Indi es, Humphre ys was o r p ha ne d as a b o y an d pla ced with rel ati ves in Wilmin gton , D el awar e. H e was a pp re n ticed to Quaker silversm ith Ban cr oft Wood co ck (1732- 1817), as noted in part in the minut es o f the Wilmington Monthl y M eetin g from 176 5: " T h is m eetin g recei ved so me lines fr om a few Fri end s in Tortol a d at ed roth yth M onth 1765 sig n ify ing th at Ri chard Humphreys an a p p re n t ice to Ban cr oft Wood co ck , is a Friends so n. " lOX Humphreys ev idently co m pleted his apprenti ceship by 1769, returned to Tortol a for a yea r, an d came b ack t o Wilmin gt on in 1770 . In [771, h e m arried Hannah E llio t t o f Ph il ad elphi a , an d th e foll o win g yea r th e co u p le
m o ved to Phil ad elphia , wh er e Humphrey s rented a hou se an d wo r ks ho p fr om retirin g sil ve rs m it h Philip S yn g , jr. Syn g recomm end ed Humphrey s to hi s clients as a "person qu alified to serve them o n th e best term s, and w hos e fidelit y in th e above bu siness will en gag e their future co n fidence and reg ard . "' O ~ H ann ah Humphre ys died in 1773 an d the n ext yea r the silv ersmith m arried Ann M orris , who bore him five ch ild re n . In [774, wh en h e was tw ent y-four, Humphrey's ca ree r and reputati on as a fin e silvers m ith we re undoubtedl y aid ed b y hi s im po rta n t co m m iss io n from th e Co n tine n tal
99
62
C offee pot, ca. 1753 Phi lip Syng, jr. . Phi lad elph ia Silver, H . : 11 7/ " in. Philadelphia Mu seum of Art
10 0
Cong ress for th e C ha rles Thom son tea urn , an interpret ati on in th e lat est Lond o n tast e. It w as an ex t rao rd ina ry o p port unit y for th e yo ung silve rsm ith, not just becau se of the pat ron bu t beca use of th e gift itself, for th e tea urn is the largest and ra res t h oll o w w ar e form in Am eri can silve r. In 1776 , despite h is Qu ak er reli gi on , Humphreys joine d th e militar y, w he reupon hi s M e etin g di sown ed him . (H e was rein st at ed in 17 8 3.) W he t her hi s prosp erity d eri ved fr om hi s success as a silvers mit h o r fro m th e Tortol a es ta tes he inherited from hi s fam il y, h e d ie d a wea l t hy m an, w it ha fortune v alu ed a t $108,998. 50 . "
0
Ro co co ch asin g is far rare r th an en g rav in g o n b oth co ffee po t s a nd teap ot s. C hasi ng o n co ffee p ot s was pra cti ced almo st e x cl usiv ely in Phil ad elphi a an d it s enviro ns , m ostl y o n po ts of an ea rlie r, sing le- be llied balu ster sha pe . N o co ffee pot havin g suc h relief o rna ment survives fro m N ew York or N ew England, w ith o ne exceptio n .'" A s ea rl y as 176 0 , R ich ard son ' s Lond on im port o rd ers specified " 2 C has t Silver Co ffe Potts to hold 3 w ine Pints, " accom panied b y " 2 C has t Sta nds o r w eig h te rs for D o . with C has t She lls o n th e Bo rder. " Four m onths lat er, he o rde re d fo u r mo re suc h co ffee pots an d sta nds . " 2 Sinc e he w as ca reful to specify "d oubl e bellied " w hen orde ring teap ots, it is lik el y th at th e coffee p ots h e req ue sted we re sing le b elli ed a n d h ad cu rvi n g b alu st er profi le s . Th e fi n est k now n Phi lad elp h ia essay o f thi s t yp e is a pot , m ark ed b y Philip Syng , J r. , made fo r J oseph and Grace (G ro w den) Ga lloway. The Ga lloway pot (N o . 62), virtua lly identical to Briti sh e x a m p les, " 3 is p rob abl y of th e k in d th at Ri ch ard son was im po rt ing. Th ou gh it s s in g le- be llie d form pred at es th e rococo peri od , th e pot is un ar gu abl y rococo b y virtue o f it s lavis h o rna me n t : chas ed C - scr o lls, fo liage , and flo w er s th at en circ le t he upper an d lo w er parts o f th e pot, th e two st ep s of th e dom ed lid , and th e spo u t. Furth er , th e spo ut is di sting u ished by ca st d eco rat ion- sh ell, ca rto uc he , an d aca n th us leaves - as is th e u pp er j unctio n o f th e handl e, w he re th er e is a sculptural shel l. Sim ilar deco rat ion ado rns a salve r (N o . 75) Syn g s u p p lie d in 17 54 to Edwa rd P enin gt on an d Sara h Shoem ak er as par t o f their w eddin g si lver. The co ffee pot is tr ad itiona ll y da ted 17 53, th e yea r o f J o seph Ga llo way's m arria ge to G ra ce G row de n , a su p po s it io n s u p p o r t ed b y th e pot 's affi n ity to th e Pen in gt on salve r of 1754 . Since th e G allo w ay pot an d th e Penin gton sa lve r a re th e o n ly su r viv ing ex am ple s o f suc h ch ased w o r k in Sy ngs oeuv re (and th eir chas ing is am o ng th e m ost refin ed o f th e peri od ), it is lik el y th at th e o rn ame nt was added b y a Lond on-train ed art isan . G rac e G rowd e n (c a . 17 3 2 -1 7 8 2) was th e d au ght er o f Lauren ce G row de n, o f Phil ad elph ia, ow ner o f Trev o se, a five-thou sand- acr e es ta te in Bu cks Count y , and o ne o f o n ly
FIG U R E 29 . Coffee pot , 1755-0 0. John Inch, Annapolis. Silver, H.: II V4 in. (28. 6 cm.). Virginia Museum of Fine Arts, Mu seum Purchase: The Adolph D . and Wilkins C. Williams Fund (5 2 . 20. 1)
e ig h t Ph il adelphi an s to p o ssess a fo ur-w hee led coa c h in 176 0 . ' 14 Th e p oliti call y pr omin ent J o seph Ga lloway ( 1730 180 3), so n o f Pete r Ga lloway, of W h itc 's H all pl antat ion , Ann e Arund el Co u n ty, M ar yl and , w as a w ea lt hy Qu ak er law yer. A lon gtim e m ember o f th e P ro vin cial Assembl y , he was am o ng th e m ore co n t rove rsia l figu re s of th e Am e rican R e v oluti on. A fr i en d of Is a a c N or r is' s a n d B enj a m i n Fr anklirr' s, h e se rved o n the Whi g del egation to th e Co ntinental Co ngress . H e resi gn ed in 177 5 and j oin ed t he Ro yal Arm y in N ew York in th e fo llowi ng yea r, w he reu po n Fr anklin and his o t her Whig friends den ounced him . In 1777, h e wa s se n t to Phil ad elphi a under th e co m ma n d o f G ene ra l Sir Willi am H owe. Wh en th e B ri tish eva cu ated t h e c ity in 1778 , G all o w a y fled to En gland wi t h hi s d au ghter , leaving Grace behind to t r y vainl y to reco ver th ei r es ta te , m u ch of it her dowry . Three o t he r co ffee pots sim ila r in sha pe an d de co rat ion to th e Ga lloway p ot su r v iv e fro m Ann ap oli s a nd Lancast er (b o t h w it h in Ph il adc lp h ias s p he re o f influ en ce) an d fr om C ha rles to n . N othin g is kn own o f th e p r o v cn an ce o f th e Ann ap ol is vessel (rIG. 29) an d littl e is kn o wn o f John In ch , wh o marked it , but it seems lik el y th at he wa s familiar wi th
101
63
Coffee pot, 1760- 7 5 C ha rles H all. Lan caster Silver. H .: 10'1. in . Henr y Ford Mu seum & G reen field Villa ge
10 2
C offee pot. 17 55-(,5
Alexander Petrie. Charleston Silver, H.: 10 '% in. Museum of Early Southern Decorative Arts
ser ving as a lieuten ant in th e lo cal mil iti a, an age n t for co nfiscatin g Br iti sh p roperty, and , in 1778 an d 177'), a Burg ess. H is famil iar it y w it h hi gh- st yl e ro co co m a y h a v e resulted from t he tim e he spe nt in Ph ilad elph ia at his b ro the r's sho p, an d th e chas ing o n hi s pot co u ld be th e wo rk o f a Philad elphi a art isan. C o n ve rsely, chas ing skills m ay have been ava ilab le lo call y , as implied b y th e existence of ano t he r chas ed ro co co silve r form - a tureen- fr om th e wor ks ho p o f a fello w Lan caster silve rsm ith. " ?
Eng lis h exampl es o r po ssib ly w ith th e pot Sy ng sup plied to Ga lloway; th e Ga lloways we re, afte r all, a M ar yland fam ily . T he In ch p ot is h ea vil y ch as ed with ro co co motifs t h at nearl y cover t he surface. Lik e th e Syn g exa m ple, it has a cast s h ell- d eco r a ted s po u t m ount ed hi gh o n t h e b ody an d a stepp ed d om e lid w it h ad ditio na l chas ing sur mo u n te d by a pin eapp le fini al. N o in fo rma tio n sur vives o n th e Lan caster pot (N o . 63) m ark ed by C har les H all. T he In ch pot ap pea rs to co py the Sy ng m odel, but th e H all ver sion ex hib its a su btle variation in sha pe, as illu strat ed by an exa m ina tio n o f the pr ofi les of all three. T ha t o f th e Inch pot is th e m o st co nse rvative, co nfo r m in g to th o se of ea rl ier tr ad iti on al exa m p ies of near ly cy lind rica l form an d w it h a ro u n ded base; th at o f t he Sy ng po t mo re cl o sel y a p p rox ima tes a b alu st er , w it h t h e b ell y pro po rtiona te ly br o ad er th an th e di am eter o f th e neck . (Bo t h po ts flar e o utward from rim to belly and both have roo ts in k now n Eng lis h p r o ro r y p cs. ) Th e profile o f the H al l pot , ev en m ore curvaceo us, is the onl y o ne o f th e three to spo rt a wa is t , vi sible w he re th e bod y n arro w s bet w een th e flarin g rim and the ex pa ns ive be lly . II .' C ha rles H all ( 1742-178 3) is we ll docum ented as a Lan caste r silve rs m it h. " {' Hi s o lder brother D avid wa s a silve rs m ith in Phil ad elphi a a n d in Burlin gt on , N ew J e rse y . C ha r les wo rke d w ith him fo r severa l yea rs but was recor de d in Lancas te r b y 170 3. H e to ok a n ac t ive role in th e Re v o luti on .
A C harlesto n co ffee pot (N o . 64) is th e so le su rvivi ng exa m ple of mature ro co co d om est ic silve r fro m th at city, a p aucity resulti n g partl y fr om th e C ha rles to n ia n preferen ce for Eng lish silve r an d partl y from th e destru cti on o f prop ert y durin g the C ivil War. T he pot, mar ke d b y Al exander Petrie (ac t . 1744 to 170 5-d . [70 S). is conse rva tive in sha pe a n d in profi le clo sely resembles t he Inch exa m ple , tho ug h it lacks t he h igh e r . s te p pe d - lid d es ign found o n all t hre e r el at ed exa m p les from t he Phil adelphi a a rea ( FIG . 2') , p . 101 ; Nos . 0 2, (3 ) . T h u s ,. it is e n t ire ly Qu een Ann e in s ha pe, as a re th ree ot her Petrie co ffee pots. " X all four h avin g spou ts, foot rim s. an d ha nd le so ck et s cas t fr om th e sa me m old s. T h is exa m p le is th e o n ly s u rv iva l o f chased silve r from Petrie ' s s ho p, but the s m it h's pr ob at e inv ent or y incl ud ed chase d te ap ots and coffee pots. w ith s ta n ds, an d" I la rg e C h ase d Co ffee pott 32 1/2 ozs.. " as we ll as imported silve r. I ,,)
10
3
At least o ne an d p o ssibl y t wo chasers are record ed in C ha rlesto n new sp ap er s o f th e pe rio d. j ohn Winc kle r, from Lond on , w ho ma de suc h m enti on in a no tice of 17(,1 , m a y h a ve b een th e jo u rney ma n chase r adve rt ised by j oh n Pau l G rim ke in 17(,0. 120 Petri e hims elf m ay have bee n qu alified in th e s k ill if h e e mig ra te d fro m B rit ain , as is b el ieved . First recorded in C ha rles to n in 1744, he m arr ied Elizabeth H oll and in 1748 an d o ffe re d im po rte d pl at e in 175(, an d 176 1.121 H is prob at e invento ry also in clud ed a slav e silversmi t h n am ed Abrah am , va lue d a t £400, wh o was su bs eq ue n tly so ld to ano t he r C ha rlesto n silve rs m ith. 122 Doubl e-belli ed coffee pots havin g chase d deco ra tio n are even ra rer th an teapots . j o seph Ri ch ard son 's letter book record s seve ra l o rde rs of " ch ast " London co ffee pot s, but non e wi th d oubl e belli es . Phil ad elphi a s ilve rs m it h Ed m u n d M il n e, how ev er , ad ve rt ise d in 1763 th at h e h ad "j us t impo rted in the last ves se ls fr om Lond on , a n elega n t A sso rt m ent of G o lds m it hs and j e w ell r y wa re, co n sis tin g of C hased a nd pl ain doubl e an d sing le be ll v 'd co ffee- po ts. " 123 At leas t one d ou bl e-b elli ed an d c hase d En gl is h exam p ie sur v i ves from Phil ad elphi a , p art of a se t m ad e fo r th e Ll o yd famil y by Whiph am an d Wri ght in 1763 an d ow ne d after 17(,8 by t he C adwaladers (see p . 80). Barrist er C ha rles C arroll of M aryland h ad a s im ilar Lond on-m ad e p ot , m ark ed b y t he d at e lett er for 176 5-(,6 , as did judith an d Sa m u el Verp la nck of N ew York , th eirs dat ed 1762- 63 (see I'IG. 26, p. 75). 12 4 T he sing le Am eri can exam ple o f thi s co m mon Eng lish design is a coffee pot (N o . 65 ) su p p lie d b y j o seph Rich a rd so n as weddin g si lve r fo r E dward P enin gt on an d Sa ra h S hoemak er, wh o we re m arried in 175 4 (see also N o . 75). Th e pot's profile is sim ila r to th at o f th e ea r lier d ou bl e-b ell ied B ri ti sh co ffee pot o f th e lat e 1740S and 1750S, w hich is lo w er and less sta tues q ue th an th e versio n o f t he 1760s. Its unu su al floral finial and she ll-a nd-C-scro ll foot rim relat e to the same models . I 2 .1 A sim ilar fini al occu rs o n a ric h ly chased suga r bo w l m ark ed b y Ri ch ard s on th at is also p art of t he Pe n in g to n silve r. ':" The relie f deco rati on of t he Pen in gton po t, ring in g th e lid , neck , an d spo ut but co ns p ic uo us ly absen t from th e lo w e r body, is m o re lim it ed in a p p lica tion t han t hat found o n th e Sy ng, In ch , H all. and Petrie po ts (N o . (,2; FIG . 29, p. 101; N os. 63, ( 4), as we ll as o n th e En gli sh exam ples. Edward Peni ng to n ( 1726- 17')7) w as th e so n of Isaac and Ann Pe nin gt o n of Ph il ad elphi a . A Qu ak e r m e rc ha nt , h e m arri ed Sa ra h Sho e mak er ( 1729- 1797) o f near b y G e rm an tow n in 1754 . Pen in gt on was a m emb e r of t he Colon ia l A ssembl y in 1761, a j us t ic e in th e co u n t y cour t , a n d a mcm bcr of the Pr o vin cial C o unc il in 1774. A pacifist, he w as amo ng t w ent y Ph ilad elphi a Q ua ke rs exi led to Vir g ini a in 1778 for sus pec ted co llabora tio n w ith th e Bri tish; ': "
65 CoIfee pot, ca. 17 54 Joseph Richardson, Philadelphia Silver, H.: II in. The Historical Society of Pennsylvania
104
Drinking and Serving Forms
TANKARDS T he tan kard , a la rge, circular drink in g vesse l having a hinged li d an d a cas t h andl e, is a ve n era b le form in th e hi stor y o f An gl o-Am e ri c an si lver. Re c ord ed in fourt eenth-cent ury acco u nts in Eng land , where actua l exampl es date from as far back as 15S6, 12 X tankards are also am o ng the earliest holl o w wares m ade in Am eri can silve r, known from -th e last q uarter o f th e se ven tee nt h ce n t ury. In the col onial period, alco holic beverages we re routinel y co ns u m ed in muc h g reater q uantities th an the y a re tod a y . Potabl e w at er wa s far less ea si ly procura ble and spirituo u s drinks were associated with soc ial ga t he r ings, h o sp it alit y, a n d co nv iv ia lity. T a nkard s and canns - the latter a mu g id entical to the tankard but without th e hin ged lid -wer e used for the co nsu m p tio n of ale, beer, and cider. In bot h Eng lan d and Am eri ca, vessels for alco ho licbeve rages were less influ en ced b y th e roco co s ty le t h an o t her fo rm s. In co n t ras t w it h th e eno r mo us effect th e sty le had o n th e mo re status- laden tea and co ffee eq uipage , it m ad e virtua lly n o impr ession o n th e o u tl ines of t anka rd s or can n s . Rather, th e tr adition al cy lind rical shape rem ain ed popular for tankards in New York , as it did in Bost on . The ad vent o f the sty le m a y h a v e e nco u rage d th e ado p t io n of th e cu r v in g ba lus ter sha pe see n o n so me tank ard s and m ore canns fr om the ro co co era. T ha t shape, ho w ever. w as not a ro co co i 11l10 va rio n but o ne introdu ced in th e ea rlier Queen A nne period . T ho ug h th e balu st er had th e st ro nges t influen ce in Phi ladelp hia and ca n also be found in New York, in Boston it was rar el y e m p loye d for tank ard s but reserved primaril y for ca n ns . (" C a n n , " th e p eriod term for the drinking ves se l w he t he r of b alu st er o r cy lin d rica l sha pe , is u sed toda y for th o se o f b alu st er s h a pe ; " m ug , " for tho se cy lin d r ic a l, o r straig ht-s ide d .) The o n ly co ncess io n to the new ta ste in t hese dri nk ing vessels is in their applied eng raving and th e modifi ca tio n of
66 Tankard , ca.
1770
M yer M yer s, N ew York Silve r, H .: 6-Y.. in. Wad sworth Atheneum
l OS
th eir cas t handl es fro m a sing le scro ll to a do u ble, wi th th e chas ing see n o n tea an d co ffee form s n oti ceabl y abse n t. 12 \1 Mu gs and canns outnu m be r tan kards, but all survive in lar ge numbers . (T he P aine se r v ice ca n n [see N o . 49], wit h th e Orn e ar ms eng ra ve d in a ca r to uc he , represen ts th e fulles t ro co co expression o f th e fo rm .) The three tan kards chosen for inclu si on in thi s di scu ssion illus t ra te so me of th e fin est exa m ples of rococo eng rav ing o n th ese o bjec ts.
Ta nkard , New York, 17S0 - SH Attributed to Will iam I3radford, Pew ter, H . : 7'/8 in. Winterth ur M useum
The pr odu cti on o f flat -topped tankard s co n tinued in New York long aft er it w as di scontinued in Bo st on and Phil ad elphi a . An exa m p le m ark ed b y M y er M yer s (N o . 66) h as m ast erl y en gravin g co ns is t ing o f a lar g e ca rtouc he t ha t en closes th e arms of its owne r, Robert Livin gston . Though not ide n tica l in co m po siti on, th e design of th e car ro uc he is sim ilar to th at found o n a M yer s ale j u g (N o . 87 ). M yer s, pr ob abl y not himself th e au tho r of th e de co rat ion , may have em ployed th e sa me eng raver fo r both pieces, possibly Lewis M ear s, th e in de n tu re d se rva n t w it h eng rav ing sk ill for whom Myer s ad v er t ise d in 1761 (see p. 76) . W hoever t he en graver, he eithe r co pied a pr ototyp e faithfully o r was himse lf fa m ilia r wi t h En gl ish h er aldr y, for, usin g standa rd m eth ods, he co rrec tly in di cat ed co lor, here th e vert ical and hori zontal lin es den otin g sable, o r bl ack , in th e back gro un d of th e low er left , o r third , qu art er. 13 0 Suc h specific ity is rare in A me rican ar moria l engravi ng . T he Livings to n arms are un usu al amo ng Am er ican ar moria l d ev ices beca use of th e m ott o scroll an d th e leg en d appea ring o n it. W he n Robert Livin gsto n ([654- [728), th e fir st Livin gsto n to emigrate to Am e rica, survived a s h ipwreck in 1694, th e family was insp ired to alte r th eir cres t to a shi p. '3' T he t ank ard m a y d ate from Li v in g st on 's m arr iag e to M ar y S teve ns , in 1770, as i t bea rs t he cou p le's init ials in triangul ar fo rm at on th e base. Robert Livin gsto n ( 1746- 1813) was a n ati ve of N e w York Ci ty , so n of J udge Ro b e rt R . Liv ingsto n and h is wife , M arg ar et Beek man. H e practic ed law, as d id his fathe r and g ra nd fathe r, and from 177 3 to 177 5 se rve d the Crown as recorde r of th e Ci ty of N ew Yo rk . Di smisse d beca use of h is p at ri ot sym pa t hie s, he was subseq ue n tly elected to t he Co nti nen ta l Cong ress, w here he se rved from 1775 to 1776, from 1779 to [78 1, and from 1784 t o 17 H S . (In 179 0, as ch an cellor o f th e State o f New York , a position h e held from 1777 to 1801, he ad m in iste red the oath o f office t o P resid ent Wash in g ton .) Whe n J effe rso n , who describ ed him as "one of the ables t of A merican law yers, " b ecam e presi de nt o f th e Repub lic in [80 [, he appointed Livings ton m in ist er to France, in w hic h pos t he was inst rume nta l in nego tia tions fo r th e Loui sian a Pu rchase in 1803 . He left publi c service in 1804 and returned to New York .
Jr.
100
Similar in sha p e to the M yer s tankard is an exa m p le (N o . 67) att rib u te d to N e w York pewter er William Bradford , J r., because of its m ark , WB wi th a fleur-de-li s. 'J2 Pewter, mu ch less expens iv e th an silv er, wa s not usu all y used to interpret th e cos tly ro co co sty le. Th e lav ish eng raved ca r to uc he o n th is tank a rd th ere fore m ak es th e vessel a rar e, p o ssibl y uniqu e, su rv iva l o f Am eri can rococo pewter. Since th e pewterer 's trad e d id n ot ca ll fo r an e ng rave r 's sk ill , Bradford m ay have su bcon t rac te d th e ca rto uc he , but it is m ore pr obabl e t ha t th e p atron c o m m iss io n e d it him self later in th e rococo perio d . En g ravin g o n p ewter was eas ily co m e b y : m an y ar tisa ns o r m ast ers wo r king o n silve r also w orked o n pewter. (Fo r exampl e, J oseph Richard son recorded eng ravin g o n the m et al in 1738 and Philip Sy ng , Jr. 's eng rave r-a ssistant, Lawren ce Hubert, advert ised "Engraving on Gold , Silver, o r Pewt e r " in [748 . )' JJ Th e unkn o wn e n g ra ve r o f thi s ca rtou ch e , w h ic h is lar g er an d m ore co m p le x th an m o st ex ,a m p l es kn o w n on s ilv e r, wa s a hi ghl y co m pe te n t m an . Unfortun at el y, th e ide n tity o f th e pat ron, whose initials, C S, form a ce n t ra l o r na me n ta l cip he r in th e en g ra v in g , is also un kn o wn. William Bradford , Jr. ( [688- 1759), w as born in Philad elphi a, th e so n o f a printe r. The fami ly m o ved to N ew York, w here in [7 25 th e se n io r Br adfo rd p u b lis h ed N ew York's firs t ne w sp ap e r. Youn g Br adford learn ed th e p rintin g tr ad e an d th en t r ied th e sa ilo r's li fe. H e se t tled int o m atrim on y wi t h Sy t ie San tvoo r t in 1716 in N e w York . In 1719, he w as ma de a fre e m an o f th e city and was recorded as a pewter er. Hi s so n Co rnelius co ntin ue d in th e tr ad e, sha ring his fath er's sh o p in H an o ve r Sq ua re before lo catin g in Phil ad elphi a b y 1753· A Phil ad elphi a t ank a rd m ar k ed b y J ohn B a yl y (N o . 68 ) demo nst ra tes th e balu st er form with glo rio us en gravin g o f a co m pos itio n w e ll su ite d to its curv ing pr ofil e . Th ou gh the ela bo ra te ar m s elude id entifi cati on, th ey arc notabl e for the a rc h itec t ur a l plin th o n w h ic h th e bird cres t is p erch ed, as well as for th e su g ges tio n o f w at er dripp in g from th e lo w er C -scro lls and r oca illc of th e ca r ro u ch e . J ohn B a yl y adve rt ise d int ermitt entl y in Philadelph ia n e w sp ap er s between [754 and 1783. Th e so n o f a Philad elph ia co rdwa iner (shoem aker) , Bayl y is first recorded in 1750, w hen he m arri ed J an e Watkin . Hi s ea rlies t kn o wn adve rtiseme n t , in th e Pcnn s v l van ia Ga ze tte of 5 Septemb er 17 54 , an no u nce d hi s go lds m it h ing bu sin ess a t th e s ig n o f the teapo t in C he r ry All ey. Lik e m an y o f hi s co lleag ues, Bayl y had o t he r bu sin ess int er est s; in hi s case , a h otel in th e en viro ns o f th e ci t y, in w ha t is n o w C hes te r Spr in g s, th at h e o w ned from 1752 until at least 1773. ,·14
68 T ankard, 1700 - 7 5 J o hn Bayl y. Ph iladelph ia Silve r, H . : 8 in . Wadswo rth Ath eneum
10 7
B OWL S As wi th tan kard s, there is no disc ernible chan ge in the shape of b ow ls in th e rococo p er io d . ' .l 5 Ro co co de co rati on is all th at dis ting uis hes th em fro m earlier counterparts. That de corati o n is usua lly eng raved, as seen on a bowl w ith the arm s of th e Lardn er fami ly (N o . 69 ) m ar ked b y Ph ilip Syn g, Jr. T he elab o rate armo rial ca rro uc he m ight have been don e b y Sy ng or, possibl y, by o ne of Phil adelphia's expert en gr avers. T he arms- t hose of th e Lardn er famil y im pa ling th o se o f th e Bran so ns- ar e fort h e o r igi na l ow ners, Lyn ford and Elizabeth (B ranso n) Lardner, o f Phil adelphia. Lynford Lar dn er ( 1715- 1774) , an Eng lish woo l merchant, em igra ted to Phil ad elphi a in 1740 . Hi s b usines s partn er and b roth er-i n-l aw Ri ch ard Penn , p ro p ri et o r of Penn syl van ia, m ad e him re ce iver ge ne ra l o f th e co lo ny an d a member of th e Governo r' s Pro vin ci al Co u nc il. H is es t ate, Som er set , wa s o n th e D elaw ar e Ri ver near pr esent-day Taco ny, a sub ur b of Ph iladelphia. Lard ne r was well acq ua inte d w ith Phi lip Sy n g , Jr. , as b oth m en we re di rectors of the Lib rary Co m -
69 B OIl'/. 17 50-70
Philip Syn g. j r. . Phi ladelphia Silver, Di am . : <) in . Ph ilad elph ia M useu m of Art
lOX
(see p. 155 ) record ed purch asin g a " Silver cha is d B o wl " from Simon Cooll ey,"!" prob abl y th e si lve rsm ith Simeo n C ool ey, who, spelling his nam e " C ol ey, " adve rt ised him self "from London " in 1767. 140 Wha teve r th e design so urce, Van D y ck w as, or h ad access to, a chase r acco m pl ish ed in this s t y le ; th e same t yp e of d ecor ati on occ urs on two o f Va n D y ck 's tankard s , 14 1 th ou gh suc h d ecor at ion is co mmo n on neither bowl s nor tankards fro m the period. Ver y littl e silv er survives by t he m ak er Ri ch ard Van D yck ( 1717- 1770), so n of th e m or e fam ou s silversmith Pet er Van D yck. Ri ch ard , also kn own as an eng rave r and importer, h ad a sho p in H an o ver Sq ua re. In 1746 , he was comm issio ne d to eng ra ve th e bi lls of credi t used to help fin an ce an ex peditio n int o Canad a duri ng Kin g George's War (1744- 48). Van D y ck ad verti sed im ports in 17 5 3 , in c!udin g wrough t pl at e, lo okin g g lasses , sco nces, pi ctures, and best "Fre nc h oy l. "142 H e m arri ed Eliza be t h St rang, of R ye ; th eir so n Henry w as a g radua te o f Kin g 's Co llege and o ne of th e firs t Epis copal ministers o rda ined after the Revolution . 14 3
pan y o f Phil adelphi a, m embers o f th e Am eri can Philosophical Socie ty , an d tru st ees of th e Co llege o f Philad elphi a. In 1749, Lardner m arri ed Eli zabeth Br an son ( 1732 - 1761), daughter of th e Ph iladelphia Qu aker m er chant Willi am Branson . A pair o f can ns , also m ark ed b y Sy ng, has armo rial eng ra ving si m ilar to th at o f th e b owl, sug ges ting th at all three pi eces were ma de fo r th e co u ple's m arria ge ."!" U ni q u e o n Am eri can b owl s fr om th e ro co co period is th e chas ing foun d o n a N ew York exa m ple m ark ed b y Ri ch ard Van D yck (N o . 70 ). T he bo wl is virtu all y co ver ed b y a flat chase d design co nsis ting o f flowers and ro caillc enha nced b y fin e eng rav ing an d tw o car tou ch es. o ne ce n te red o n eac h side, th e w ho le co n ta ine d w ithin a sha pe d lo w er b order o f C-scrolls and curves . The in iti als C P eng raved in one o f the carto uc hes for th e orig ina l owne r are unidentified . The decorati on h as b een co m pa re d to d el icat e ch as ing found o n an Ir ish silver b owl. 13 7 The protot yp e for th e bo wl , however , m ight h ave b een m ad e in E ng la n d, since the sa me d esi gn occ urs in En gli sh ro co co silve r."!" In 1768 , J ames Beckm an
70 B OIllI. '755- 70
Richar d Van Dyck , New Yo rk Silver, D iarn .: 7% in. Garva n Collection, Yale U ni versit y
109
SALV ERS Eng rav ing also e mbe llis hes th e fi nes t ro co co salvers. "Sa lve r" is th e pe rio d te rm fo r a flat servi ng form , di sting uishe d from a rr a y becau se it is eleva te d either on a base or o n multipl e fee t. A sa lve r (N o . 71) m ad e in the shop of Paul Re ver e for Lu cr eti a C ha n d le r is o f t ypi cal Eng lis h border pat tern an d sha pe an d is en ha nced by th e Chand ler coa t o f ar ms eng ra ved w ith in a ro co co ca rro uc he . The salver, alo ng w it h a suga r di sh an d a crea m p ot m a rked by Reve re (N o . 5g) , was m ad e for Lu cr etia in honor of her we dd ing, in 1761, to J ohn Murray. Althou gh Re ve re also eng raved t he C handl e r ar ms fo r th e b o okp lat e (see N o . 17 ) o f Gardiner Chan dler, b roth e r to Lu c reti a , it is wo r t h n oti n g t h a t th e re he altered slig htly the design o f th e carto uche, Three sa lvers fro m New York , amo ng th e m ost ou tsta nd ing exa m p les of th e for m , illu st rat e three va ria tio ns in bord er d es ign . T he m o st t yp ical is th at o n o ne m ar k ed b y M yer M yers (N o . 72) - a sha ped hexagon al design w ith gadroon ed rim , co m mo n p r io r to th e adve n t of rococo de sign . Wh at se ts th e salve r apa rt is it s ex t rao rd ina ry eng ravi ng. A dep arture fr om th e u su al ca rt o u ch e enclo si ng arm s, it co ve rs almos t th e en tire su r face in an illu st rati o n of an allegorica l s ce n e w i th in a s ha ped s u rro un d over a co mme morative inscri p tion, th e d esign bordered above and bel o w b y Latin phr ase s. !":' Th e sce n e co nsis ts of a n a nge l crownin g a n allego rical fem ale figure sy m bo lizin g justi ce (righteo usness), w h ile a not he r a nge l s howe rs h er w it h go ld from a co rnu copi a, th e w ho le ill u m ina te d b y th e rad ian ce of th e sun (re p rese n t ing th e pr esen ce of Go d ), o n w hic h is engraved " Ps : 34 : 15, Ve, " a re fere nce to th e Psalm depict ed : "The eyes o f th e Lord are up on th e ri ght eou s, an d hi s ears are open unto th eir cry." Th e size, qu al it y, and rococo de sign of the eng rav ing m ak e it th e m o st a rres ting o f a ny o n A m e rican silve r o f thi s peri od . Mi ght th e eng rave r h ave been M yers's ru naway in de n tu red se rva n t of 176 1, Le wi s M ea rs (see p. 76)? Th e salve r was es pec ia lly co m m iss io ned as a g ift to Th co d o ru s Van Wy ck ( 17Ig - 1776), as confirm ed b y it s Eng lish in scription: " In test im on y of exem plary j us tice and as a sma ll ac k nowledg men t for k indn ess rece ive d , th is plate is hu mbl y pr esented to [Theodo rus] Van Wyck b y his friends [Sa m uel ] Sch uyle r, [Willi am] Lupt on an d [C o rn el iu s] Swi ts." T he don ors reco rde d we re all rela ted to Van Wyck , the last t w o b y m arri age to his ni eces J oh ann a and Ca therine Schuyler. In 17 5 2, on t he deat h o f Bran dt Sch uy ler, father o f Sa m ue l, J oh ann a, an d C a t h e rin e , Th eo d o ru s as sis ted hi s sis te r, M agretta Van Wyck Schu yler, in rearin g her children. The salve r was an expression o f th e child ren 's gra titude.
71
ca. 1701 Paul Revere, Boston Silver, Diam .: I] VH in. Museum of Fine Arcs, Boston Sa/Fer ,
11 0
72
Sa /per, ca. 17(,X M yc r M yer s, N ew York Silver , Di arn . : rz in. Collect ion o f Philip Van Ren sselaer Van W yck
II I
73
74
Sa lvcr, 17(,5- 70 J oh n H eath , N ew Yor k Silver, D iam . : 15 '18 in . Winte rt hu r Museum
Sa lva, '7 54-(,') Dan iel C hristian Fuete r. N ew York Silver , Dia m . : 15% in . T he M et ro politan Mu seu m of Art
112
A seco nd New Yor k sa lve r, thi s o ne m ark ed b y J ohn H eath (N o . 73), is di rec tly rela ted to an Eng lish m od el. The bo rde r desig n , not common ly fo u nd in Am er ican silve r, is id entical to t ha t o f a Lon d on sa lve r from t he 170 0S, ma de for th e De Pe yst er famil y of N e w York . It co ns is ts of sta nda rd lob ed gad ro o n in g b u t is em be llis hed by an in ne r bo rde r o f she lllike ru ffl es punctua ted by ro settes alte rna ti ng w ith aca nt hus leaves. Two o th er New Yo rk salve rs also have this unu su al border design . 1.;5 Comple ti ng the salver's ro coco prese nt a ti on arc th e Sch uy le r fa mi ly a r ms, e ngraved in t he ce n te r wit h in a cartou che of C -scro lls , fo liage , and rocai lle . T he salver, lik e th e Eng lish mode l, rest s on fo ur claw-and -ba ll feet. The Schuyler fami ly, fo unde d in t he co lo nies in 10 51, is closely associ ated with Al bany. A mo ng its mos t famo us eig htee n thcen tury members was Major General Phil ip Schuy ler ( 1733IS 04 ), ve tera n of t he revo lu tionary war, mem be r o f th e Continen tal Cong ress, and later a U nited States sena tor. J o hn H ea t h marrie d Edi t h Pell in 1700 and b ecam e a freeman of New Yo rk in 170 1. In 170 3 , H eath adver t ise d a house fo r sa le at " Van Ge lder's alley in th e Broadway," notin g t ha t his s hop was in Wall Stree t. q f> In ad di tio n to thi s salver, a pu nch bo w l survives from his hand , also beauti full y engraved w it h a ro coco ar mo ria l fo r Pi err e Va n Co rtlan d t. Heath's bi ll for t he pu n ch b o wl cha rged Van Cortla nd t one pound ste rling for engraving "A Cot Arm es & a C ris t. " 1.;7 T he th ir d sa lver in th is im p ress ive N e w York gro u p was ma rked by Daniel C h ristian Fuerer (N o . 74) and m ad e for a me mber of t he p rom ine n t P ro vo st fam ily of Fre nc h Hug ue not ex t rac tio n. Of th e three salvers, th is has th e m ost vigo rous borde r, d e fin ed b y bo ld pe a k s an d curves an d rimmed with ga d roo ni ng . T he Pr o vo st fam ily ar ms g race the elabora te cen tra l carto uche. C h ased deco ra tion is ex tre mely rar e o n A m eri can sa lve rs. No t sur pris ing ly, th e o n ly ins ta nces known occur o n t w o examp les from Phil ad elph ia. q K Th e fin e r of th e t w o (N o . 75 ) , dating to T754 a n d m arked by Ph ilip Sy ng, J r. , was , like the R ic hardson coffee po t (No. 05) , p a rt of th e we d d ing si lve r of Edwa rd and Sa ra h Penin gt on (see p . 104 ). Th e sa lver, se t o n th ree cas t sc ro ll feet , is rimmed w it h a hi ghl y in t rica te cas t b o rd e r o f asy m me t rica l raffl es, scro lls , a nd fo liage . Th e interi or sur face is ex q u is ite ly chased wi th raffles, fl o w e r s, lea fag e , C -sc ro lls , a n d di ap er ed pa nels in a broad ban d encircli ng a cent ra l eng raved cipher. So simi lar is t he chase d d ecorat ion to th at of th e Sy ng coffee pot m ad e for th e Ga lloway fam ily (N o . (2) that o ne m ay pres ume th ey were deco ra ted by th e same unidentified chaser.
75
Salver, ca. 1754 Philip Syn g , Jr., Philadelphia Silver, Di am . : 8 1;S in. The H istor ical Societ y of Penns ylvani a
I I]
SAU CEBOATS M ost of th e per iod 's sa uce boa rs resem ble the pair m ade b y Revere fo r the Paine service (see N o . 49), a form est ab lished by Eng lish exa m ples in th e pr ero co co peri od and accommod at ed to th e new style b y th e add ition of she ll and sc ro ll cas t ings at handl e and feet. Th e o u tstanding Ameri can sa uce boa ts are a pair (N o . 76 ) sup plie d b y Richard H u m ph reys to George Em len ( 1741- 18 12) , a wea lt hy Quaker me rcha nt w ho m arried Sara h Fish bo urne (1756-1823 ) in 1775. In st ead of the t ypi cal th ree-fo oted base, each o f th e Humphreys pair is elega n tly upl ift ed on a ped esta l foot hav in g flut ed , curving bo rders. The shaped design of the foot is re pea te d in t he rim of th e vesse l, w here it is edg ed with ga droo ning t o co rres po nd t o th e fl u tin g be low. T he rim resolves into a g rac eful, sc ulp tu ra l scro lled term inal at th e handl e j u nct ure, an d a cas t sc ro lle d han dl e comp lete s th e co m posit io n an d b al an ces th e m ass o f the pour in g s po u t. Su p crbl y pr op orti on ed an d g racefu lIy d esig ned, the tw o sauceboa rs arc furth er enlive ne d b y th e add itio n of engraved ca rtouc hes enclos ing th e sc ri p t in iti als CE, for th e ori gin al owner.
011e oj a pair oj sal/ceboats, 1770 - S 0 Richard Hu mp hreys, Philadelphia Silver . H. : (d 4 in . Pr ivat e collec tion
Iq
Rare Forms
So me o f th e fin est ac hie ve me n ts in A m e rican ro co co si lvc r are ex t re me ly r ar e fo r ms. Thoug h a nu m ber of th e m are relat ed to t he ri tual o f tea and the serving o f mea ls, the y are st ill so sca rce as to wa rrant inclusion he re. Silver dish ri n gs, cake bas ke ts, an d teak ettl es, and gold shoe b uck les and snuff boxes we re lu xuries, even amo ng tho se w ho mig h t regard a silve r teap ot as a social necessity. The very selection of such for ms was an act of conspicuous consumption o n the part of th e owners ; th at the rococo style was chosen for their interpre ta tio n fo llowed in natural progression . It is therefo re " no t su r p ris ing th at e ng rav ing , the most modest kind of ro coco o rna me n t, is, when present , overshadowed by more p re te n tio us, an d m o re expensive, chased, p ie rced, or cas t deco ra tio n. M oreover, it is a mo ng th ese precious, singu la r fo r m s th at th e rar e in cid en ce of go ld is fou n d. In the eig h teent h cent ur y, th e terms "golds mi th" and "s ilvers mi th," referrin g to an a rt isa n wh o wo rke d in p reci ou s m et al s, we re intercha ngea b le. Even in E ng la n d , w here th e titl e o f th e silve rs m iths ' g uild w as th e " Wo rshipful Co m pa ny of Go ld smi ths," m embers se ldo m had t he o p po rt u ni ty to wo rk in so lid gold, more fre q ue n tly using it only in measured q ua ntiti es fo r gi ld ing obje cts of silve r (a tec h niqu e prac ticed infreq ue n tly in th e co lonies). Wi thout exceptio n, eig h teenthce n t ury Am eri can go ld objects a re sma ll, pe rsona l accessor ies, suc h as b u tto n s , shoe buckles, or snuff boxes, attribu tes reser ved fo r th e very wea lthy. On e o f th e m o st engagi ng forms in Am e rican gold is th e w his tle a n d b ell s , an ornament p opul ar in Eur op e in t he seve n tee nt h a n d eig h teen t h ce n turies. M ad e fo r a c hi ld 's am use me nt and co m p lete wi t h a b ran ch o f co ra l (co ns ide red as h a vin g prote cti ve po w e rs) fo r teethin g, it is d epi ct ed in paintin gs han ging fro m th e sma ll owne r's wa ist. 14\) G old and si lve r exa m pi es im ported from Lo nd o n are d o cum ented in co lo n ia l n e w sp ap e r advertisements. I S O J o seph Rich ard so n
I 15
77 WI/istle and bells.
17 55-(j H
N icho las Roosevelt . N ew York Go ld; co ral, H . : (NH in . The Metrop olit an Museum of Art
ll (j
o rd e red both pl ain an d c h ased "Correll & Bells, " usuall y w it h the specifica tio n " 8 Bell s to E ach. " Between 1758 and 1773, he sen t fo r se ven ty -s ix plain and fift y-four "chas e": on 27 Jun e 17 59 , he o rd ere d "2 C hast Co rre ls w it h 8 Bell s G ilt w ith Gold," th e o nly two so speci fied . O ccasion all y, he also req ueste d "Co rrell Pie ces for Whisels & Bell s," evidentl y for to ys m ad e in hi s own sho p. 151 Paul Revere recorded a " Silve r child s Wi sel" in 1762 (t ho ug h th e fo rm is o the rwise virtua lly ab se n t fro m h is led g ers) , an d, o n 18 Au gu st 177 0, Ph il ip Sy ng , Jr. , received fort y sh illi ngs nin epence from J oh n Ca dwalade r for a w histle and bells. P" Onl y fo u r e xa m p les in g o ld b y Am eri can a rtisa ns a re k nown. P:' A g old w histle marked by Ni chol as Roosevelt has sur v ived w itho u t proven an ce, but the luck y recip ien t got an ex t ravaga n t pla ythin g (N o . 77 ) . Su ch trinkets , whether in go ld o r silver, we re u su all y the gift o f a dotin g re lat iv e; '>' often a t th e c h il d 's ch riste n ing . Th e form lend s it self to a style th at se eks to cha r m and am u se. The Ro o sevelt exa m pl e, w h ich retain s six o f it s o rig in al ei ght b ells , is meti cu lou sly decorat ed with ro coco flowers , leafage, ro caille, and a fo u n ta in, o n a s t i p p le d g ro u n d , all framed in p anels an d reserves o f she lls an d C -sc ro lls . A ch ild's pl easure in th ese preci ou s t o y s is re flec te d in Th e Rambl er, w he re Samu el J ohn son rem arked : " Of all th e to ys with which child ren are de lig hte d , I va lued o nly m y co ral. " 155 Ni ch ol as Ro o sevelt ( 1715- 1769) w as b orn in Ne w York an d prob abl y ap p ren ticed to Co rneliu s Wynkoop (b . 1701 ). H e was m ar ried tw ice; fir st to C athe rine Con foort, in 1737, t he n to Eli zab eth Thurm an, in 1754. H e was ac tiv e as a silvers m ith from 173 7 th rou gh 1768 . In J anu ar y 1769, he ad verti sed for let p ro perty o n th e wharf th at in cluded a "ro om y an d co n ve n ient h ou se, w ith seven fir e-pl aces, " as we ll as a silve rs m ith's sho p , to ol s of th e tr ad e, an d "a par cel o f read y m ade silve r . .. w hic h h e w ill sell ve ry reason abl e , as h e intend s d eclinin g bu sin ess, an d to m o ve in th e Co u n t ry in th e spring . " 15(' Nichol as, th e grands o n o f th e fir st Ro os evelt to settle in N ew Am st erd am , w as related to th e pr esid ential Roosevelt s, w ho descended from his brother. A gold shoe bu ckle m ark ed by M yer M yers (N o . 78) furth er ill us t ra tes th e ro co co sty le's suita b ility for ac cen t uatin g th e impor ta nce o f s ma ll, v alu a b le o bjects . Its cas t an d chase d deco ra tio n , fo rm ed vari ou sly o f in te rw o ven leafag e, flower s, and scrolls, w ould have glit tered in th e lig ht, drawin g atte ntion to thi s o rna te , gro und- level accesso ry. Wh ile Am er ican go ld exa m ples are extr emel y rar e, lar ge q uan tities o f silve r bu ckl es we re m ade o n both sid es o f th e Atlan tic for Ameri can bu yer s. A sing le London o rde r placed in 17 59 b y J o seph R ich ard son includ ed 11 0 p air s , but th e p ro d uctio n o f hi s own sho p wo u ld ap pea r to have b een far
Shoe huck lc, 17 5 5-7 5
Myer Myers, New York Gold; steel. L.: 2-% in. Garvan Co llection, Yale Un iversity
I 17
79
Sill/if box. 1755- 75 M ycr M yer s. Ne \~ York Go ld D iarn . : 2 '% 111 . , etr op o I'iran M useum of Art T he M
I I
X
in excess o f that figure. In [7 61, he ord ered seven te en gro ss (2 , 448) o f stee l chapes and tongues in varyin g sizes for m ak-
in g bo t h sho e an d kn ee bu ckl es . 157 The personal qualit y o f th e bu ckle form m ad e it particul arl y suita b le as a gift. The M yer s exa m p le, it s s tee l cha p e and ton gue probably imp ort ed fr om Lond on, is e ng ra ve d "The Gift o f Robt . A rcd eckne Esqr. to D anl. M cCormi ck." M cC ormick (1742[834) was an ill us t rio us New York bank er who later became an alde rma n o f th e East Ward . 15 K An oth er lu xur y was the sn u ff box, a rar e form em plo yed in th e a r is t oc r a t ic pr a cti ce o f inh alin g th e co s tly tob a c coder i ved s u bs ta nce. Am eri c an sn u ff boxes o f go ld ar e ex t re rne ly sca rce, sin ce th eir size required more o f the precio us m etal than sma lle r fo rm s su ch as button s o r bu ckles . Th e e la bo ra te ly chase d exa m p le marked b y Myer M yers (N o . 79 ) was prob abl y cr eat ed as a spec ia l g ift ; its bibli cal icon o gr aph y and M yer s's J ewish heritage sugges t that it may have b een co m m iss io ne d for u se in a sy nagogue with snuff o r p e rh ap s with s p ice, as o n the D ay o f At on e m enr. P ? It s p ri ma ry de cor ati on, a d epi ction o f D avid b efore Saul, reco un te d in I Sa m ue l [6: [7-22 , fill s th e box 's co ve r, unimpe ded b y tr aditi on al p an el s or d ecorat iv e d evi ces ."?" The sce n e i ts e lf is n arr ativ e , but its h igh-relief ch as in g an d a rococo diap ered p anel contain ed within an S-scroll a t th e edge o f t he b ox (abo u t four o 'clock ) sig na ls its st ylistic debt . O n th e b ott om is an unusu al ro co co ca rt o uc h e , in d esi gn vigo ro us a n d ana rc h ic in co m pariso n with typi cal En gli sh exa m ples an d , lik e the unfetter ed co ve r scene , evo ca tive o f Contine nta l int erpret at ion s. M ore En gli sh in stylis tic derivat ion is a silv er sn uff box (N o . So) w it h th e m ark o f J oseph Rich ard son . The pr eciou s vessel fea t u res th e asy m m et rica l ar ra ng em ent ch aracteri stic o f the ma ture rococo style, as illus t ra te d by a ca rto uc he co m po sed of C -sc ro lls en closing a b ask et o f fruit an d surround ed b y more C -sc ro ll s, ra g ged s he lls, an d festo on s, all co n ta in ed w ithi n th e box' s se rpent ine -s ha pe d lid. H ere dem onstrated in m ic rocos m are th e sa me ass u re d h andlin g , fluid compo sitio n, and so ph is tica te d voc abul ary used m ore ex te nsive ly o n a to ur d e fo rce f ro m th e Ri chard son s ho p , th e Plum sted tea ke ttle o n sta nd (No. 88) . In shape and decoration, th e bo x is sim ila r to o ne d o cum ented fr om 17 57, which al so bears Ri ch ard son 's m ark . In [7 59, th e s ilve rs m it h o rde re d fr om Lo n do n three " Ch ast Silver Snuf Bo xes G ilt in sid e with Gold."'61
80 T ho ug h chasi ng cha rac te rizes th e full est ex p ress io n o f th e sty le, pier cin g was an eq ua lly su ita b le form of rococo de cora tio n o n a p p ro p ria te form s. M ore fun ction al than decorative o n ea rlier eig h te ent h -cen t u ry Am eri can siIver - cast er
SIl llJJ box , 1755- 70
J oseph Richard son, Phil ad elphia Silve r. L.: 3 in . Private collect ion
1 1<)
81
Basket,
17 54-6<)
D aniel C hristian Fucter , N ew Yor k Silve r, L.: 14% in. Mu seum of Fine Arts, Boston
12 0
lids, braziers, and strainer (slo tted) spoons-it came into its own w it h th e adve n t of th e rococo . T he gro up of hi ghl y acco mplis he d lu xur y form s th at ens ued have elaborate pier cing t ha t far exceeds any u tilitari an co nce rn. Bask et s, d ish rings, and fish slices, in add itio n to coas te rs and salts, manifest not o n ly th e co n fl ue nce o f sty le an d socia l co nve n tio n bu t also th e inc reas ing pr o sp erit y in t he co lon ies, whi ch enab led pat ron s to co m missio n suc h indul g en ces. Th e tast e fo r lacy han d-pier cin g , ad m ira bly suited to th e intricacie s o f t he ro co co m od e, was ado p ted fir st in E ng la n d, th en ce in Ame rica. Th at m o st Am eri can pi er ced silver was m ad e in New York sugges ts th e ex is te nce of a spec ialis t in suc h w ork th er e: all t he piercin g represented in these pages co mes fro m th at city. T ho ug h th e m aj o rit y is from o ne sho p - t h a t o f M yer M yer s-th e m o st so p h is tica ted pi ece is a b asket (N o . 81 ) ma rked by D an iel C h ris tian Fu ct cr an d m ad e for Ri ch ard H arison , a delegat e to th e Cons titut io nal Con ventio n in 1788 an d a p romin ent N e w Yo rk a tto rney w ho m Wa shin gton ap poi n te d th e fir st United Sta tes di stri ct atto rney for Ne w Yo rk in 1789 . Both in d esi gn and qu al it y o f execu tio n, th e bas ke t - its heav y cas t bord er an d light o pen wo rk bod y serv ing as foil s fo r eac h o t he r; th e move me n t ex p ressed in it s shaped rim rep eat ed in th e fee t and handl es- could easily be mis taken as Lo n don m ad e. Eve ry ele me nt fro m it s cu rv ing feet to its co n to u red ha ndle ex p resses a th em e o f th e ro co co repe rtoi re . The bod y is p ierced wi th a delica te foli at e- and-Csc ro ll des ig n, and c u twork o n th e r im , ha n d le, an d leg ju nc tures is co mplemented w it h intricat e cas tings . The inner sur face of t he bottom is eng raved w ith an elabo ra te ro co co carto uc he co n ta in ing th e H ar ison ar ms (see de ta il). The cas t border deco ra tio n of ro caill c, C-scro lls, and fru it-a nd- flower festoo ns, pe rha ps t he bes t exa m ple o f it s kind in Am er ican ro co co si lver, is r iva le d in achieve me n t on ly b y th e raffl efr am ed fem al e m ask s th at ado rn t he b ask et's h andl e . Th is incidence of figural relief deco rat io n is co m m o n in Europ ean ro co co si lver b u t ra re in Am eri can int erp ret ati on s. Of th e m ore th an fi ft y exam p les of Am eri can s ilve r illu strat ed in th ese pages , on ly r wo di splay hu m an allusio ns: t his b ask et an d the c ream p ot m a rk ed b y Phili p Hulb eart (N o. 55 ). A m o n g th ese a nd o t he r kn o wn d epi cti o n s, in cludin g a che rub o n a w histle and bells also m ark ed b y Fucrer, th e tw o Fuc tc r pi eces illu strat e th e m ost m ast erl y co m ma nd of integra l hum an referen ces in Ameri can rococo silver.! " T ho ug h bas ke ts a p pea re d in Eng lis h s ilve r late in th e 1500s, th e y d id n ot beco me a we ll-k now n table access o ry until th e rococo period, w hen th eir co m binatio n of pi er cin g and cas ting m ad e them an ide al ex po ne nt o f the fro t hy sty le. T he Fuct cr exa m ple is not d issimilar to those m ark ed by th e
Lond on silve rs m ith Paul d e Lam e ri e, th e Fren ch H u g uen ot w hose s ho p is ren o wn ed fo r wo r ks th at c harac ter ize th e fin est E ng lis h ro co co. A t lca sr one La m e r i e bas k et was o wn ed in th e co lo n ies . It was o rde red in 1743 , alo ng w it h o the r we d di ng si lve r, for th e Phil adelphi a m e rch an t D avid Fr ank s an d hi s brid e . 10 3 O t he r Lo n do n - ma de b ask et s w e re o w ned in th e co lo nies b y the H an co ck fami ly o f Bo st on , th e B yrd famil y o f Vir gini a, an d th e Ll o yd fam il y of M ar yland . , 0 4 Fu et er, Europ ean tr ain ed an d arrivi ng fr om London at an au s p ic io us m om ent , p rob abl y in t ro d uced ro co co-st yl e silve r to N ew York. H e m ay also have bee n responsi ble for setting th e fash io n for pier ced decoration in th e city 's silver.
r2 I
82
Basket, ca. 1756 Myer M yers. New York Silver, L.: 14 1/2 in. T he Metropolitan Museum of Art
Th e o n ly o t he r Am eri can ro co co b ask et kn own (N o . 82 ) was su pp lied b y M yer M yer s to Su sannah and Sam uel Co rne ll o f New York , w hose ini tia ls, sse, are eng raved on it s interi or. M yc rs 's co m mi ssion for th e Co rnc lls in clud ed a pier ced d ish rin g, a co ffec pot, a ca n n, an d a pair o f pier ced wi ne coas te rs .": " Th ou gh m ember s o f N ew York 's aris tocracy w ere m ore lik el y t o h ave im p orted si lver suc h as th e bask et and th e di sh ring , th e va rie ty of form s from th c sam c m aker sugges ts th at , like th e Pain e ser vic e (No. 49) from th e sho p of Paul Revere, th ey we re o rde red b y a brid eg room as a gift to hi s bride .'f>(, The theo ry is s u p po rte d b y lat er eng ravi ng o n th e coffcc p ot , w h ic h indi cat es th at Co rnel l gave it to Susa nna h in th e yea r of th eir m ar riage. The knowlcdge th at a thi rd o f th e Ameri can pi er ced wor k su rviv ing fr om th e ro co co period belon ged to th e Co rne lls is a cogen t ill us t ra tio n o f j us t h o w vi ta l th e p atron ag e o f a very few afflue n t fam ilies wa s to th e developm ent of Am er ican rococo silve r. ,67
Samu el Co rnell ( [73 [ - [78r) m arri ed Su sann ah M abso n ( [73 1/32 - [778) in [756 . Co rnell , a wea lthy N ew York me r-
ch ant o f Lo y ali st sy m pa t h ics, m o vcd h is fam il y to N ew Bern , N orth Carolina, ea rly in th e [77 0 S. He was a m em ber o f Hi s M aj est ys Co u nc il o f th at st ate in 177 5 , w hcn he st ro ng ly advi sed th e govc rno r to o u tlaw W h ig m eet in g s. Co rne ll wa s in Eng la nd du rin g th e o u tbrea k of th e Rev olu tion , but he return ed to N ew York and set sail for N ew Bern und er a flag of tru ce . On hi s arri va l, he was deni ed ree ntry an d re u n io n with hi s famil y unl ess h e to ok an oath of alleg ia nce to th e s ta te, the n un d er Whig ru le . H e refused and, w hi le st ill in th e h a rb o r, m ad e an effo r t to save h is p ro pe rty b y d cedin g it to hi s ch ild rc n . H e th cn ob taincd p crrn i ss iont o rem o ve hi s fa mi ly t o N cw York . H is conveya nces of p rop ert y we re n ot h on ored , an d hi s h old in g s were co n fiscated b y th e sta re and so ld.'{,H Unlik e th c Fuet er b ask et, w he re the ma ke r h as used cvc ry m eans o f ro co co d ecorati on at h is co mma nd . t h e
12 2
M yer s bask et relie s so lely on pier cin g for o rna me nta l dram a. It s elabo ra te fil igree b od y is co n ta ine d visu all y betwe en a si m pl e arc h ing handl e an d a circula r foot th at are ro co co in deco ra t io n but n ot in sha pe, an d th e ca st ings a t th e rim, foot , and handle junctures are co m posed of ro utine gadroonin g . The bask et w as crea ted at a tim e w he n suc h exp an ses of o penwork we re v i rt ua lly unkn o wn ; Fu et er, perhap s more acc us to me d to th e technique, tr eated pi er cin g as on e elem ent in a di alo gu e. Wher eas th e M yers exa m ple is an exe m plificat io n o f pi er cin g in Am eri can silver , the Fu ct cr b asket is a trium ph o f ro co co design th at utili zes piercin g. In its cu to u t d ecorat ion , th e M yers b ask et includes th e th ree sty listic va riat ion s o f Eng lish ro co co ex plaine d in Chippe nda le's Dir ector-Fren ch, o r M od ern, C hinese, and Gothic. Reserves o f Fren ch scrollwo rk alte rn ate w ith diapered pan els o f C hinese latti cew ork, a n d the b aseb and is pi erced with a design o f Go t hic qu atrefoil s and di am onds. (T he pier cin g o n t he Fu et er b ask et , less intri cat e , is limited t o the Fren ch tas te.) D ish rin g s, used und e r hot se rv ing d ish es, require piercin g to ventilat e th e heat away fro m th e tabl e. The o nly ex ample know n in Am eri can silve r is o ne M yer s su pplied to th e Co rne lls (F IG . 30), th ou gh w ick er an d p ewt er ex a m p les ar e rccord ed .'?" Th e form , w hic h occu rre d in Eng land ea rly in th e eig h teen t h ce n t ury but was repl aced by th e d ish cross '7° in th e 1740S, remai ned espec ially popul ar in Ireland . On Iri sh rococo exa m p les , th e d esi gn is u su all y n atur ali st ic, w it h chas ing to a rticu la te leaves an d flo w e rs an d with th e occasio na l applica tio n of cas t decorati on . Imported Dublin exa mpl es m ay ha ve co me to th e atte n tio n o f eithe r M ye rs or th e Co rnells, but it is mo re likel y th at M yers co n t rac ted with a fo re ig n p ic rce r w ho may also h ave suggested th e form . A d ish ring was m o re ada p table to th e sizes o f se rv ing di sh es w he n it was co m posed of t w o silv e r circl es o f v ar yin g d ia m et er s, as is th e M y er s exa m p le . Com p le me n ting it s sha pe is a med ial b and o f scro llwork fram ed w it hin G oth ic d ia mo n d-a nd- Io ze nge decora tion . Th e in itia ls for th e
FIGURE 30 .
Dish ring . ca. 17 56. Myer Myers. New York. Silver.
Di arn . : iWx in. (22. 5 cm.): H. : 4'% in. ( 11.1 cm.). Yale Univ ersity Art Gallery. The Mabel Brady Garvan Collection ( 19 36 . 136)
sse
Co rnc lls a re e ng rave d o n an ap p lie d h eart-sh aped sh ie ld; bot h rim and foo t are undecorated. A s does the M yer s ba ske t , th e d ish rin g reli es so le ly o n pi er cin g for it s aes the tic effect. T ho ug h th e M yer s b ask et a nd di sh rin g , b oth excee d ing ly o rna te in th e co ntex t o f Am eri can silve r, are co nse rv ative in co m pa riso n w ith British m odels, th e fish slice w ith M yer s' s mar k (N o . 83) is virt ua lly identica l to exa m ples popul ar in Engla n d in t he 1760s. It s pi er ced d esi gn, co m posed o f di apering and fo liate scrolls enha nce d w ith engraving , is sim ilar to th at foun d o n E ng lish proto types, as is th e splayed she ll
12 3
w it h o pe n w o r k ribs th at ado rn s th e handl e junctu re. In its vi g or an d flar e, th e s he ll represent s a m ark ed pr o gressi on fr om the ti ght , rest rain ed she ll cas tings at th e j unct ures of th e M yer s ba sket. H is sho p pr odu ced at least o ne o ther simi lar slice.'?' but no o the r Am er ican exa m ples are kn own from th e roco co peri od . The form it self, ho w ev er. is docume nted in th e co lo n ies: the re cord s o f Willi am B yrd , of West o ver , Virgini a, m ention a fish slice in 1769, with no in dica tion of its o rig in , and th e Tayl oe s of Virginia had o ne m ad e in Lo ndon in 1767 th at w as eng raved with th e fam ily arms.'72 Am eri can silv er smiths rarel y foll owed th e English prac tice of app ly ing weig h ty , ex pe nsive cas tings purel y for deco ra tio n, but in st ead us ed th e pr o cess where necessar y for ap pe ndages suc h as handles, h andl e j u nc t u res an d te rmin als, rim s, and feet, w hic h required so lid ity and reinforcem ent. A ladl e (N o . 84 ) mark ed b y Pi et er d e Riem er d em on strat es th at u sag e whil e at the sam e time ex plo iting th e ca paci ty for o rna me ntati on inh erent in th e techniqu e. Th e Ri em er ladle , unique in Am eri can si lver an d elaborat e e ven b y English sta n da rds, was probabl y in spi red b y a Co n ti nen ta l exam ple ex h ibi ting th e m ore florid cha rac ter o f th e Fren ch or north ern European ro coco . The flut ed chas ing o f th e bowl is co nve n tio na l, but th e handl e term in al , cas t as a lar g e, imp o sin g carto uc he , is ex t rao rdi na ry. T ho ug h ca rtou ch es decorat e th e handles o f m ost Eng lish flat w are fo rm s, here th e m ak er h as e m p loye d th e d evi ce as a se parate sc u lpt ura l ele me nt b y co m pos ing it of flo w er-str ewn raffles fra mi ng a ce n t r a l rese r v e th at t e rmin at es in a str ik ing ly asy m me t rica l sc ro ll. Pend ent flowers and ro caill e ado rn t he back of th e ca r to uc he (see d etail ), w he re t he initi als R o ver R S are eng raved fo r th e orig ina l o w ne rs, Rich ard ( 17'7/ 1817( 3) and Sar ah (Boga rt) Ray ( 1728- 1781). The sc rip t m on og ra m C R o n the front , in sid e th e carro uc hc, was ad de d for Co rne lius Ray ( 1755-1827) , w ho inherited th e ladl e fro m his paren ts. Its su bseq ue n t descent in th e famil y is recorde d o n th e b ack of the b owl in engra ving adde d abo ut 19 12. '73 T he Ra y fam il y, pr omin ent in N ew York bu sin ess and socie ty. was found ed in Am erica in th e seven tee n t h ce ntury by J ohn Ray. o f Exeter, En gland . A m ore co m p lex u s e o f cas t i ng is to be found on rococo cruet sta nds , as exe m plified by o ne, m ad e for the Van Voo rhi s famil y in t h e s hop o f D ani el C h r is t ia n Fu et er, t h at is decorat ed w it h cast scrolls , she lls, an d ca rto uc hes (N o . 85). Severa l Am er ican rococo c r ue t s ta n ds, m ad e b y b oth Ph ilad elphi a an d N ew Yo rk m aker s, are kn o wn . 174 All have the sa me ge ne ra l desi gn , pattern ed afte r Englis h p rototy pes well d o cum ented in th e co lo nies - pri m ar y d ecorati o n co nsisting of a cas t ce nt ra l car touchc , a sc ro lled ha nd le and legs,
Fish slice. 1755-75 Myer M yers, N ew York Silver. L. : 14 VH in.
Wadsworth Atheneum
12 4
Ladle, ca. 1703 Piet er de Riem er, N ew York Silver , L.: 13% in . Pri vate co llectio n
12
5
an d cas t shell feet. In 175 7, Georg e Washin gton acq uired an exa m p le m ad e by j ab ez D ani el o f Lond on ; ot he r Lon d on m ad e stands w er e ow ne d b y B enj amin Fan eui! and by t he Apth orp s in Bo st on, b y th e Br o wn es in Sa lem, an d by th e C hases in M ar yl and . 17 5 Th e sta n da rd design (k now n as the War wi ck t yp e, p o ssibl y b ecau se o ne m ad e fo r th e ea r l. of Warwi ck in 1715- 16 was o nce thou ght to be th e ea rliest) 17 (' calle d for two g lass crue ts , for vin eg ar and oil, and th ree sil ve r cas te rs, for su g ar , mu st ard , an d p epp er. Th e sta nd therefore co ns isted o f a fram ew ork w ith five adj o ining rings to co n tain th o se vessel s an d tw o sma lle r rin gs at either end to h old th e cr u et cove rs w he n the cru ets were in use . Alth ou gh severa l Am eri can exa m ples of th e for m survive, non e are kn own with dom esti c fittin g s; th o se tha t remai n intact , includin g thi s o ne, h ave Eng lis h cas te rs an d cruets ordered fr om London. A s requ est ed b y th e Ph il ad elp h ia silver smith J o seph Ri ch ard son , th ese we re some times " plain" and so me times " Doub le Bell yed " ; in a lett er of 1760, Ri ch ardson eve n o rd ered a "Silver Cas ter fra me w ith a Sert o f D oubl e Bell ycd Cas ters Neatl y C has t w ith G ro un d Glas s C ru its tipt w ith Silv er. " ' 77 The ea rlies t referen ce to stand s in Rev ere ' s led g er s wa s in 17 81, w he n h e reco rde d a "Si lv er Fram e for Ca srers '" '?" but m ad e n o m ention o f acco mpa nyin g cas te r s. Th e d oubl e-b ellied an d chased cas te rs o n th e Fuet er stand are marked b y Samuel Wood of London and are d at e-mark ed 17 52- 5 3. Th e car to uc hes o n b oth cas ters and stand are engraved with th e Van Voorhis fami ly crest. Onl y two Am eri can sn uffer sta n ds are kn own , one of w hich w as m arked b y Ph ilip Syn g , Jr. (N o . 86); th e o the r, by M yer M y er s . Th e co m p lete form co n sis te d o f a s ta nd, or t ray, holding a pair o f snu ffers, a scisso rslike device used fo r trimmin g th e burn t wick s o n ca n d les." ?" A special ized form of thi s n ature wa s not n ec essa ril y o f si lver; m o st American snu ffers and sta nds were m ad e o f a base m et al. Paul Revere recorded mak in g a "Pr. of Snuffer s & Snu ff Dis h" in 1762; John Ca d w alade r o f Phil ad elphi a, according to an in vento ry o f th e cont ents o f h is silve r cl o set tak en in 1771, owned at least two snu ffers an d sta n d s, one w ith "snu ffers part silver part steel," the o ther " all silvcr. " I S O
Cru et stand, 17 54- 09 Daniel Christian Fue te r, New York
Silver, H.: 10 in. Historic Deerfield, Inc.
Syng's ex am ple, no w without it s snuffers, has a par ticularl y cap ricious air, th e result of th e plenitude of cast decorat ion a p p lie d aro u n d it s hand- wrou ght surface : th e sh aped pr ofile is rimm ed b y C-scrolls an d leafage em be llishe d w ith four rag ged, asymm etri cal she lls, o ne cen tered on each side. Uplifted o n fo u r sc ro lle d pad feet , th e sta nd is me morab le for th e unu su al raffl ed C -scro ll th at sur mo u nts it s sc ro lli ng handle . Th e cas t bord er d ecorati on is si milar to th at foun d o n th e m o st famou s wor k fro m Syn g 's sh o p , an ink stan d co m m issi on ed b y th e Pcnn s yl van ia Assem b ly in 17 52 and
later used by th e sig ne rs o f th e D ecl ar ati on of Indep end en ce and of t he Co n s ritur io n.J'" Th ou gh it is e ng ra ve d in th e ce nter w ith t he cres t of th e H am ilt on fam ily, an d m ay hav e bee n ow ne d by Andre w H amilton , its pr oven an ce is n ot recorded . M o st o f t he rare fo rm s di scu ssed in th ese pages h ave falle n into gro u pings by o rna men t. With th e po ssibl e exc eptio n of the Fue te r bas ke t (No . 8 1), eac h exa m ple h as ex p ress ed th e rococo style prim arily th rou gh o ne of three te chniques: chas ing, piercin g , or cas ting. H oll o w w are form s allowed ro co co silve rs m it hs grea te r latitud e to in teg ra te vario us t yp es o f decora tio n. A s demon strat ed b y th e ba sk et , w he re cas t an d pierced decora t io n a re co m b ine d to s t u n n ing e ffec t , th e res u lts ca n b e eve n g rea te r ex p ress io ns of m ature ro co co des ig n. A n ale j ug m ark ed by M ye r M yer s (N o . 87 ) is a sp lendi d exa m ple of rococo holl o w w are, th ou gh th e fo rm itself is no t a ro co co inno v ati on . H er e, th e co m ma nd ing eleven- inc h he ig h t en ha nces th e effec t o f th e su pe rb eng ra ving and cas tings. T ho ug h j ugs, t ank ard s, an d ca n ns did n ot e cho the do u b lc-be llie d p ro fil es found o n tea and co ffee form s, th e ba lus ter sha pe in tro d uced in th e p revi ou s peri od lent it self grace fu lly to th e ad ditio n o f ro co co o rna me n t. Thi s ju g is engrave d w it h th e a r ms o f D a vid C la r kso n ( 1726- 178.2) o f New York , prob abl y th e " j ug wi t h cove r" refer red to in his will as th e "S ha re" o f hi s d au ghter Ann M ar g ar et C la r k so n .v'" The a r ms a re co n ta ine d w i t h in a lu xuri ant asy m me tr ica l ca rto uc h e sur mo u n te d b y a w inge d-g ri ffi n cres t. The sweep ing curve of th e body is balan ced b y a vi goro us do u b le C -scro ll h andl e m arked b y rococo cas tings at th e u p p er an d lo w e r jun ctures. A th ree-d im en sion al raffl e cocked on th e lid 's hin ge se rves as a thumbpicce and adds to the vis ua l success o f th e vessel. Both the thumbpicce and th e u p pe r h a n dl e j u nc t u re are e la bo ra te ro co co cas ti ngs th at co m pleme nt th e ex pa nsive eng rav ing . An other jug from th e M ye r s s ho p, o f s imi lar size a n d sha pe an d w it h identi c al han dl e and upper juncture, is at th e H enry Fo rd Museum . In its lack o f rococo thumbpicce and ar mo rial eng rav ing, however, it falls sho rt of th e C lar kson exa m ple. , X3 T he mos t m onum ental form produ ced in Am eri can ro coco silve r w as th e te ak e ttl e, o r tea urn, t w o va r ia tio ns o n the sa me th em e. It is su ita b le th at th e o n ly rococo exa m p les k now n are fr om N e w York an d Phil ad elphia, th e t w o ce nters of hi gh-st yl e co lo n ia l sil ver in th e ro co co tast e. , X4 T he ke t tle, design ed to hold h ot wa te r for replenishin g teap ots, was int ro du ced into th e tea eq ui page in En gl and lat e in th e seve ntee nth cen tu ry. M o re co mmo n in base meta ls, th e form tra di tionally incl ude d a sta nd fu rn ishe d w ith a spirit lamp for
86 S l/lIffcr stand , 17 50 - 70
Philip Syng. Jr. . Philadelphia Silver. L.: 7% in. The Metropolitan Museum of Art
127
A lejuo , 17 55-7 5 M ycr M yer s. N ew York Silver. H .: 11 -% in . Pri vat e co llection
12 8
heatin g the wa te r. Int end ed t o b e lift ed for p ourin g , th e vesse l was p r o vid ed w i t h a spo u t an d a swi ng ing h andl e eithe r m ade of wood o r w ra pped wi th w icke r for in sul ati on . In t h e mi d -eig h teen t h ce n t ury, th e teak ettl e b eg an to b e re p lace d b y th e t ea urn in E ng la n d, th ou gh th e transition occ ur red so mewha t lat er in th e co lo nies. (Ja mes Beekman of New York record ed pu rch asin g a " N ew Kettle & Stand " in Ap ril 1766 ; in M ay 177 3, he acq uired a " Tea Urn . " ) I H5 Both ve rs io ns fu lfill ed th e sa me fun cti on , but th e urn differed from th e k ettl e in t ha t it was design ed to rem ain sta tio na ry o n th e tabl e, th e h o t wa ter di sp en sed through on e o r m ore s pigo ts , thu s re lievi ng th e h o st o r ho st ess f ro m lifting a heavy vesse l and directin g its co ntents int o small teapots . A tea urn ma rke d b y E p hra im Br ash er ( FIG. 3 I ) is th e ea rl ies t example o f its k in d in Am eri can silver an d the o n ly rococo o ne kn o wn . T ho ug h suc h three-l eg g ed vesse ls are Fre nc h in o rig in, th ey we re co pied in co n tem po ra ry En glish silver (see N o . 46). T he Brash er urn was pr ob abl y patterned after an Eng lish co ffee pot , und oubtedl y as a co m m issio n for an uni d entifi ed pat ron who se initials, JDW, are fr am ed in a gra nd ca rro uc he eng raved o n th e sid e. The design sug gests th at th e m ak er was neither we ll ve rse d in th e production of suc h urn s n or in p o ssession o f castin g m olds exactl y suited to th em . I SO H e evidentl y b orrowed m olds from m ore co m mo n form s to crea te thi s un iq ue pi ece, its feet co m posed of she lls and scro lls th at were part of the per iod 's casting vo cabular y, its h andl es o f th e t yp e occur ring o n jugs , ewe rs , and tw o-h an dl ed cu ps, and it s fi n ia l t ypi cal o f that found o n co ffee pots, in cluding o ne wi th Br asher 's m ark . ,S 7 T he urn is technicall y co m petent , but becau se it w as not design ed an d crea ted as an integr al pi ece, it betrays an in consiste ncy of sca le and deco rati on , parti cul arl y at the feet an d th e handles. W hen plotted co rrectly, th e lar ge upper cur ve of suc h S-c u rved h andl es swu ng o u t well b eyond the sma ller lower rever se cur ve, th e scroll tip o f the lo w er juncture kept we ll in sid e a ve rtical lin e d ropped from the o u te rmost point of th e upp er cur ve. H e re, h o w eve r, t he sc ro lling terminal s ab u t suc h a lin e . T h e feet a re equ all y di sprop ortionate to suc h a m assi ve vessel. Th e m ak er 's prob abl e unfamiliarit y w it h th e fo rm may ex p lain th e pl acin g of the handles and th e eng ra ving w it ho u t reg ard for th e tripartite a rra nge me n t o f th e feet a n d th e s p igo ts b elo w. I S H Th e urn' s n ai vet e notw it hs ta n d ing, th e cas t ings a n d th e e ng ra v ing are a b ove reproach . The urn its elf is im b ue d with ro co co spirit, m o vem ent , and sp rig h tl iness, and rem ain s o ne o f th e m ost am bitiou s efforts in Am eri can silve r. Ep h ra im Br ash er ( 174 4 - 18 10), a silve rs mi t h o f Dut ch d es cent, was b orn in N e w Yor k a n d wo rke d in th e city thr ou gh out his ca ree r. H e m a rri ed Ann e Gi lbe rt, siste r of New York silvers mi t h Willi am Gi lbe rt , in 1766 , an d w as
FIG U RE 3 1. Tea IInl , 176 5- 7 5 . Ephraim Brasher, New York. Silver, H.: 17 1/4 in. (43.H cm.). The Art Institute of Chicago , Gift of the Antiqu arian Society ( 1959.5H)
12 9
88
Teakettle 0 11 stand, 1745- 55 J oseph Rich ard so n . Ph iladelphi a Silver. H . : q -y. in. Ca rva n Collect ion . Yale U nive rsity
13 0
recorded as a m ember o f th e Gold and Silve r Sm ith's Society in 1786; hi s n am e a ppea re d in th e city direct ories from 1786 t o 180 7 . In 17 9 2, h e was an assaye r fo r th e Unit ed St at es M int .
ment th at is unique in Am eri can rococo silve r, where t he in cide nce o f chased fauna, w hi le mo re common t han th at of hum an refer en ce s, rem ain s a ra ri ty in comparison wi th its frequen cy in En gli sh w ork . O the r occ ur rences repr esent ed in thi s b o ok a re birds o n th e Rie m er cream pot , on a Re v ere teap ot, and o n th e Lan sin g suga r d ish (Nos. 48, 51, 57). The m ak er ma y have o bta ined m olds fo r his ke ttle-on-s tand cast in gs fr om a car ver w ho also exercised hi s o rna men tal talents o n Phil adelph ia ro co co fu rn itu re . It is un lik el y th a t Ri chard son would h ave h ad occas io n to u se m o st o f th o se m old s for another client , w h ic h wo u ld h av e furt her in creased the kettle's ex pe nse.
M ore accom plishe d th an t he Br ash er essay in th e form is th e unp ar alleled teak ettl e o n sta nd m ark ed by J oseph Richardson (N o . 88 ; see also ill. o p p . p . 7 1). Uniqu e in the o e u v re from Ri ch ardson 's sho p, it ranks as th e grea tes t acco m plishm ent in Am eri can rococo silve r. Ever y bit th e eq u al o f outsta n d ing London exa m p les, Ri chard son's teak ettl e on stand is a unifi ed co m pos it io n of form an d o r na me n t , in ever y det ail full y ex p res sive o f the highl y elabo rate sty le. The Ri ch ard son masterpi ece (w h ich is abs ent from his acco un ts an d hi s o rde rs from Lond on ) wa s made for Clemen t Plum st ed ( 1680 - 1745) , form er m ayor o f Philadelphia, or for h is third wife a n d w ido w, M ar y (C ur ry) Plumst ed (d. 1755 ), w ho b equ e ath ed it in h er wi ll to her hu sband 's gra nd da ug hte r Eliza be th Plum ste