THE JOURNAL OF THE ASSOCIATION FOR JEWISH STUDIES
AJS
R
E
V
I
E
W
Kabbalah © 1997 by Mark Podwal, Courtesy of Forum Gallery, New York.
VOL. 33, NO. 2 • NOVEMBER 2009
AJS Review ASSOCIATION FOR JEWISH STUDIES NEW YORK, NEW YORK EDITORS Elisheva Carlebach, Columbia University Robert Goldenberg, SUNY Stony Brook BOOK REVIEW EDITOR Charlotte Fonrobert, Stanford University ASSOCIATE BOOK REVIEW EDITOR Eugene Sheppard, Brandeis University EDITORIAL BOARD Michael Alexander, Temple University Pamela Barmash, Washington University in Saint Louis Yaakov Elman, Yeshiva University Talya Fishman, University of Pennsylvania Gershon David Hundert, McGill University Riv-Ellen Prell, University of Minnesota Jeffrey Rubenstein, New York University Jeffrey Shandler, Rutgers University Magda Teter, Wesleyan University Chava Weissler, Lehigh University MANAGING EDITOR Stanley Mirvis The AJS Review (ISSN 0364-0094) is published twice annually by the Association for Jewish Studies The AJS Review has been subsidized in part by a contribution from the Lucius N. Littauer Foundation. Manuscripts for consideration should be e-mailed as a MS Word or rich text file to the AJS Review managing editor at
[email protected]. Books for review should be sent to Prof. Charlotte Fonrobert, Stanford University, Department of Religious Studies, Building 70, MC 2165, Stanford CA 94305-2165. © 2009 by the Association for Jewish Studies. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, in any form or by any means, electronic, photocopy, or otherwise, without permission in writing from Cambridge University Press. Permission inquiries from the USA, Mexico, and Canada should be addressed to the New York office of Cambridge University Press http://www.cambridge. org/us/information/rights/contacts/newyork.htm; permission inquiries from elsewhere should be addressed to the Cambridge office http://www.cambridge.org/uk/information/rights/contacts/cambridge. htm; permission inquiries from Australia and New Zealand should be addressed to the Melbourne office http://www.cambridge.org/aus/information/contacts_melbourne.htm. Publishing, Subscription, and Advertising Offices: Cambridge University Press, 32 Avenue of the Americas, New York, NY 10013-2473, U.S.A.; or Cambridge University Press, The Edinburgh Building, Shaftesbury Road, Cambridge CB2 8RU, England. Annual subscription rates for Volume 34, 2010: Institutions print and online £105/$179; institutions online only £91/$156; institutions print only £99/$168; single part £54/$93, payable in advance or on receipt of invoice; institutional check or credit card only. Special rates exist for members of the Association for Jewish Studies; membership information can be found at http://www.ajsnet.org. Information relating to AJS Review can be found at http://www.ajsnet.org/ajsreview.htm. AJS Review and all other Cambridge Journals can be found at http://journals.cambridge.org/ Photocopying Information: Permission to copy (for users in the U.S.A.) is available from Copyright Clearance Center, http://www.copyright.com, email:
[email protected]. Specific written permission must be obtained for republication; contact the nearest Cambridge University Press office. Postmaster: Send address changes in the U.S.A., Canada, and Mexico to: AJS Review, Journals Dept., Cambridge University Press, 100 Brook Hill Drive, West Nyack, NY 10994-2133, U.S.A. Send address changes elsewhere to: AJS Review, Journals Dept., Cambridge University Press, The Edinburgh Building, Shaftesbury Road, Cambridge CB2 8RU, England.
THE JOURNAL
AJS Review OF THE
ASSOCIATION
FOR JEWISH
VOLUME 33, NUMBER 2
STUDIES NOVEMBER 2009
TABLE
OF
CONTENTS
ARTICLES Gershon David Hundert The Introduction to Divre binah by Dov Ber of Bolechów: An Unexamined Source for the History of Jews in the Lwów Region in the Second Half of the Eighteenth Century ................................................ 225 Barak Shlomo Cohen In Quest of Babylonian Tannaitic Traditions: The Case of Tanna D'Bei Shmuel ..................................................................................................... 271 Geoffrey Goldberg Mah.azor Ha-H.ayyim: Life-Cycle Celebration in the Song of the Ashkenazic Synagogue ........................................................................................... 305 Rebekah Klein-Pejšová “Abandon Your Role as Exponents of the Magyars”: Contested Jewish Loyalty in Interwar (Czecho) Slovakia ............................................................ 341 Gilead Morahg The Perils of Hybridity: Resisting the Postcolonial Perspective in A. B. Yehoshua’s The Liberating Bride ................................................................... 363 REVIEW ESSAY Jeffrey Veidlinger From Ashkenaz to Zionism: Putting Eastern European Jewish Life in (Alphabetical) Order ................................................................................................. 379 BOOK REVIEWS BIBLICAL STUDIES James W. Watts. Ritual and Rhetoric in Leviticus: From Sacrifice to Scripture WILLIAM K. GILDERS , Emory University .................................................................... 391 Bernard M. Levinson. “The Right Chorale”: Studies in Biblical Law and Interpretation BARUCH J. SCHWARTZ , Hebrew University of Jerusalem ............................................ 393 JEWISH HISTORY AND CULTURE IN LATE ANTIQUITY Gideon Bohak. Ancient Jewish Magic: A History KIMBERLY B. STRATTON , Carleton University ............................................................. 396
MEDIEVAL JEWISH CULTURE Miriam Bodian. Dying in the Law of Moses: Crypto-Jewish Martyrdom in the Iberian World CLAUDE B. STUCZYNSKI , Bar-Ilan University ............................................................. 399 Esperanza Alfonso. Islamic Culture through Jewish Eyes: Al-Andalus from the Tenth to the Twelfth Century MARTIN JACOBS , Washington University in St. Louis ................................................. 404 David Malkiel. Reconstructing Ashkenaz: The Human Face of Franco-German Jewry, 1000–1250 ETHAN ZADOFF, The Graduate Center, City University of New York ........................ 407 MODERN JEWISH THOUGHT AND THEOLOGY Hilary Putnam. Jewish Philosophy as a Guide to Life: Rosenzweig, Buber, Levinas, Wittgenstein ERIC JACOBSON , Roehampton University .................................................................... 410 Mara H. Benjamin. Rosenzweig's Bible: Reinventing Scripture for Jewish Modernity EUGENE R. SHEPPARD , Brandeis University ................................................................ 412 Henry Levin Goldschmidt. The Legacy of German Jewry WILLIAM PLEVAN , Princeton University ...................................................................... 414 Martin Samuel Cohen. The Boy on the Door on the Ox: An Unusual Spiritual Journey through the Strangest Jewish Texts MARTIN S. JAFFEE , University of Washington ............................................................. 417 Michael L. Morgan. Discovering Levinas ARYEH BOTWINICK , Temple University ....................................................................... 419 Benjamin Lazier. God Interrupted: Heresy and the European Imagination between the World Wars BEN WURGAFT, University of California, Berkeley ..................................................... 424 MODERN JEWISH CULTURE
AND
HISTORY
Phyllis Lassner and Lara Trubowitz. Antisemitism and Philosemitism in the Twentieth and Twenty-First Centuries: Representing Jews, Jewishness, and Modern Culture HEIDI KAUFMAN , University of Delaware ................................................................... 427 Julius Novick. Beyond the Golden Door: Jewish American Drama and Jewish American Experience EMILY KOPLEY, Stanford University ............................................................................ 429 YIDDISH LITERATURE Anita Norich. Discovering Exile: Yiddish and American Jewish Culture during the Holocaust TONY MICHELS , University of Wisconsin .................................................................... 432
MODERN HEBREW LITERATURE Gil Z. Hochberg. In Spite of Partition: Jews, Arabs, and the Limits of Separatist Imagination NANCY E. BERG , Washington University in St. Louis ................................................ 435 GENDER STUDIES Tova Hartman. Feminism Encounters Traditional Judaism: Resistance and Accommodation JANE KANAREK , Hebrew College ................................................................................ 437 N. O. Body. Memoirs of a Man's Maiden Years MAX STRASSFELD , Stanford University ....................................................................... 439 HEBREW ARTICLE א................................................................................................................... עמנואל פרידהיים ישראל-עיונים היסטוריים בשאלת ההתמודדות ההלכתית של החכמים עם תרבות יוון ורומא בארץ בימי המשנה והתלמוד
AJS Review 33:2 (November 2009), 225–269 © Association for Jewish Studies, 2009 doi:10.1017/S0364009409990018
T HE I NTRODUCTION TO D IVRE BINAH BY D OV B ER OF B OLECHÓW: A N U NEXAMINED S OURCE FOR THE H ISTORY OF J EWS IN THE LWÓW R EGION IN THE S ECOND H ALF OF THE E IGHTEENTH C ENTURY by
Gershon David Hundert*
Surprisingly, historians have not yet carefully examined the introductory pages of the unpublished manuscript Divre binah (Understanding Words) by Dov Ber Birkenthal.1 Although the evidence of a single witness seldom leads to the revision of historical narratives, the material provided in these introductory pages is quite rich and suggests much about a number of topics that will be of particular interest to students of the eighteenth century. Among these themes are Jewish attitudes to Christianity, to the new Austrian regime in Galicia, to the Enlightenment, and to early Hasidism. The author, an elderly successful businessman, wrote the work in question after retiring to his hometown, Bolechów. His book affords us a glimpse into his way of understanding his society and his time. Dov Ber ben Yehuda Birkenthal (or Brezer, 1723–1805) wrote another book as well. Mark Wischnitzer published some substantial fragments, which are all that survive, of Dov Ber’s Memoirs in 1922.2 Dov Ber’s second book, Divre binah,
*I wrote this article during my tenure (2007–2008) as a fellow of the Institute for Advanced Studies at the Hebrew University in Jerusalem. The institute provided ideal conditions for scholarly work. A number of my colleagues there and elsewhere provided advice and suggestions that were indispensable in the preparation of this study. Many thanks to Marcin Wodziński, Michael Silber, Moshe Rosman, Ada Rapoport-Albert, Yonatan Meir, Zvi Mark, Rachel Manekin, Ze’ev Gries, Arthur Green, Uriel Gellman, Shmuel Feiner, and David Assaf. 1. Jerusalem, Jewish National Library, MS B964: Divre binah, pp. 329, completed 1800. The author explains that the numerical value of the letters in the title of his book (ʿim ha-kolel) is the same as the numerical value of the letters in his name (284). There seems to be a page missing between pp. 174 and 175. 2. London, Jews College, Ms. 31 (I found no differences significant for the present article between the manuscript and the printed version); The Memoirs of Ber of Bolechow (1723–1805), translated from the original Hebrew manuscript, with introduction, notes, and map by M. Vishnitzer (Wischnitzer) (London: Oxford University Press, 1922); Mark Wischnitzer, ed., Zikhronot R’ Dov mi-Bolekhuv ([5]483– [5]565) (Berlin: Klal, 1922). Cf. Pamiętniki reba Dowa z Bolechowa, przekład z języka hebrajskiego, wstęp i przypisy, Roman Marcinkowski (Warszawa: Formica, 1994). On the
225
Gershon David Hundert remains in manuscript. Apparently through the offices of Ber’s son-in-law, Dr. Yakovka (Jacob) Rapoport (1775–1855), the manuscript was placed in Yosef Perl’s library in Tarnopol in 1814. From there, it arrived in Jerusalem after World War I,3 and today the autograph copy of the 329-page book is held by the Manuscript Division of the Jewish National Library.4 Dov Ber notes on the cover page of Divre binah that he completed the book in 1800. This date is presented on the title page as the numerical value of la-yeshuʿa ule-neh.amah (for redemption and consolation). It is apparent, thus, that the first scholar to analyze the manuscript miscalculated the date as 1780; a number of passages in the text support the veracity of the later date.5 For example, there are references to a Hungarian law of 1791 and to the tax on Sabbath candles imposed in 1797. Nonetheless, Joseph II (d. February 1790) is referred to as if he were still alive,6 which suggests that Dov Ber was working from a diary or from notes he
Memoirs, see Roman Marcinkowski, “Dow Ber z Bolechowa: ‘uzupelniać tore wiedza światowa,’” in Żydzi i judaizm we wspólczesnych badaniach polskich, ed. Krzysztof Pilarczyk (Kraków: Księgarnia Akademicka, 1997), 183–90; idem, “Jews in Eastern Galicia in the Light of The Memoirs of Dov Ber of Bolekhov,” Studia Judaica 5, no. 1 (2002): 41–58; Israel Bartal, “Dow m’Bolechów—pamiętnikarz czasów kryzysu Sejmu Czterech Ziem w XVIII stuleciu” [Dov of Bolechow—A diarist of the Council of Four lands in the 18th century], in Żydzi w dawnej Rzeczypospolitej, ed. Andrzej LinkLenczowski and Tomasz Polański (Wrocław: Zakład Narodowy im. Ossolińskich, 1991), 81–84 (in English, Polin 9 [1996]: 183–91). The author refers to his family name as Brezer (Memoirs, 153; Zikhronot, 94). See also A[braham] J. Brawer, “A Posthumous Change of Name (Birkenthal not Bolechower),” Jewish Quarterly Review, new series, 13 (1922): 99–100. A systematic comparison of Divre binah and the Memoirs is certainly a desideratum. The purpose of the present article, however, is to present only the introduction to Divre binah. 3. Shmu’el Werses, “Ginze Yosef Perl bi-yrushalayim ve-gilgulehem,” Ha-Universitah 19 (1974): 40–45 (38–52). Werses describes the impassioned but only partially successful attempts of Avraham Yaʿakov Brawer, Bialik, Agnon, Dov Sadan, and others to rescue the treasures of the Perl collection. The key figure in this effort was a Tarnopol native who worked at the Jewish National Library, Simh.ah Katz (1904–40). See also Werses, “Shivʿim shenot h.eker yetsirato u-foʿalo shel Yosef Perl,” H.uliyot 7 (2002): 327 (321–38). 4. The Perl materials were inaccessible after the War of Independence until they were brought from Mount Scopus in 1958. During the 1980s, the manuscript of Divre binah was misplaced and remained lost until some five years ago, when it was found, misfiled under Djerba (!), and microfilmed. Although I worked with the microfilm, the acting director of the Institute of Microfilmed Hebrew Manuscripts, Dr. Yael Okun, kindly permitted me to examine the original manuscript as well to verify my readings. 5. Avraham Yaʿakov Brawer, Galiz.iyah vi-Yehudeha: Meh.karim be-toledot Galiz.iyah ba-me’ah ha-shemoneh-‘esreh (Jerusalem: Mosad Bialik, 1965), 200. On Brawer (1884–1975), see below. 6. There is another dating problem that is beyond the scope of the present study. On pp. 54–75, the author quotes in Hebrew from She’erit Yisra’el by Menah.em Amelander, citing chapter 26, p. 69. Published originally in Yiddish, the first known published Hebrew version of that book appeared in Lwów in 1804. Moreover, in that Hebrew version, the chapter that Ber quotes is numbered chapter 24, and the wording is quite different. Thus, either Dov Ber used a different translation, unknown to us, or he translated the passages himself. In either case, the passages should be of interest to students of the history of Yiddish.
226
The Introduction to Divre binah by Dov Ber of Bolechów had prepared over the years. Most probably, the final composition of Divre binah followed the writing of the memoirs. Dov Ber intended to publish Divre binah, but the rabbi of Lwów, Z.evi Hirsh Rozanes, refused to grant him an approbation because of the text’s many negative remarks about Christianity; Rozanes advised Dov Ber to correct these. Avraham Yaʿakov Brawer reports this exchange on the basis of correspondence between Dov Ber and Yakovka Rapoport. The letters, however, have not been preserved.7 Dov Ber Birkenthal was born in Bolechów in 1723 and died and was buried there in 1805. His mother, Esther, died on his fifteenth birthday. In a passage virtually unique in his writings for its display of emotion—note the repetition of his mother’s name—the author tells us in his Memoirs: [O]n the sixth of the month of Second Adar, which fell on a Sabbath, my mother, the virtuous and pious marat Esther, daughter of the distinguished R. Mordecai, died at nine o’clock in the evening. She died in the fifty-fourth year of her life after having been greatly afflicted for more than a year with dropsy of the leg. She died peacefully [metah be-neshikah] and without struggle. At the same hour and day, on the same date of the month of Adar, my mother Esther had brought me into the world with great pains of childbirth, as I narrated on page … [there is no such page preserved]. She almost died in giving birth to me; but out of the compassion of Heaven on me, the weak and newly born, there were added to her life, out of Divine favor, fourteen more years, so that she could raise me to obey the Torah, the commandments, and to bind phylacteries.8
Dov Ber married twice, the first time at age sixteen in 1739. This marriage was forced on him, “because of our many sins,” by “the wife of my father, my stepmother, Feige.”9 The young woman “was not suited to me [she-‘eno [sic] hagunah li].” They were together for two and a half years; “she had no issue and I was freed of her by the grace of God, may He be blessed.” Dov Ber subsequently married Leah, who was, he says, his predestined partner.10 Later, he refers to her as exemplary, saying that her upstanding qualities were well known to all, both Jews and Gentiles (le-havdil).11 He also describes a premonitory and foreboding dream before a disastrous attack on Bolechów by bandits. 7. Brawer, Galiz.iyah, 208. In the summer of 1802, Ber had sent the manuscript of his book, in fifteen notebooks, to H.ayyim Kurmash, the former shtadlan of Lwów, asking that he review its contents and consult with others to ensure its accuracy. H.ayyim’s response to this request, which affirms Ber’s accuracy, makes it clear that he expected the book would be published; see N. M. Gelber, “Shalosh teʿudot le-toledot ha-tenuʿah ha-Frankit be-Polin,” Zion 2 (1937): 330 (326–32). 8. Memoirs, 72; Zikhronot, 41. 9. The Memoirs include references, in addition to his stepmother, to two other women whom Dov Ber blames for different unhappy developments—the wife of his partner, and his sister-in-law. Both women are portrayed as responsible for coming between Ber and his fellow. The motif of “the quarrelsome woman” in early modern Jewish literature awaits its researcher. 10. Memoirs, 79 (I have altered Wischnitzer’s translation to make it more literal); Zikhronot, 45. 11. Memoirs, 177; Zikhronot, 110.
227
Gershon David Hundert A dream image “that my wife had severe labor with child” alerted him that something dire was about to happen.12 Dov Ber’s father, Yehuda, like his son after him, was a successful importer of Hungarian wines. Yehuda’s success was attributable, in part, to his knowledge of Polish and Hungarian. Dov Ber himself spent much of his life and conducted business in Lwów, where commercial activities brought him into contact with Polish merchants, nobles, Catholic priests and monks, and businessmen from numerous European states. He learned a number of languages, including Polish, Latin, French, and German. In his Memoirs, Dov Ber explains his acquisition of Polish as follows: I also learned the Polish language to please my father, who wanted me to know it. He kept a tutor in his house, an educated Polish gentleman, who made me conversant with Polish speech and writing. I learned it perfectly in a very short time. Moreover, I studied Latin and understood the principal part of its grammar.13
Not hesitant to record what reflected on him well, Dov Ber also quotes a certain Jacob, who says of him, I know a man who is a Jew and who writes Polish as nobody else can. All the nobles are astonished that he writes so well, and praise him for his fluency in the Polish language… . He is the young R. Ber, the brother of the well-known kaz.in R. Aryeh Loeb of Bolechów.14
In Divre binah, as will be seen, Dov Ber offers a different explanation for having learned Polish and other languages. In the memoirs, he also mentions a Jewish woman, named Khule, who not only spoke Polish but also knew how to receive a nobleman properly (ke-derekh ha-priz.im) in her home and to offer him appropriate wine.15 We learn of a Jew in Kraków in the mid-eighteenth century who knew a number of languages, including Latin.16 Even more noteworthy, the scholar and 12. Memoirs, 95; Zikhronot, 56. 13. Memoirs, 79–80; Zikhronot, 45–46. 14. Memoirs, 65; Zikhronot, 36. 15. Memoirs, 109; Zikhronot, 65. This episode would tempt the imagination of a novelist. Ber sought to deceive a nobleman and persuade him that he was a resident of Lwów. The nobleman, Ber tells us, asked to meet Ber’s wife. So Ber “promptly” sent his Hungarian Jewish assistant to his neighbor’s wife—Khule—to ask her to go to Ber’s house and “to entertain him in the Polish language after the fashion of the nobles [ke-derekh ha-periz.im] and to make him believe that she was my wife. She came to my house, received him as hostess, and ordered a bottle of good wine, which he drank; and he believed her to be my wife.” 16. Adam Kaźimerczyk, “Converted Jews in Kraków, 1650–1763,” Gal-Ed 21 (2007): 28 (17– 52). See also Daniel Stone, “Knowledge of Foreign Languages among Eighteenth-century Polish Jews,” Polin 10 (1997): 200–21; Murray Rosman, The Lords’ Jews: Magnate–Jewish Relations in the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth during the Eighteenth Century (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1990), 174–79.
228
The Introduction to Divre binah by Dov Ber of Bolechów rabbi H.ayyim Reizes, martyred in Lwów in 1728, knew Latin “and other languages of the nations.”17 In other words, though Dov Ber was unusual in his knowledge of languages, he was far from unique among Jews in the PolishLithuanian Commonwealth of his day. Divre binah contains a history of messianic movements and particularly concentrates on the Sabbatian-Frankist episode, focusing on the author’s prominent role, because of his knowledge of Polish, in the debate between the Frankists and the rabbis in Lwów in 1759.18 Dov Ber’s discussion of messianism and its history begins on page 49 and continues to the end of the book. Much space is devoted to quotations from Maʿaseh Tuvyah, She’erit Yisra’el, Kiz.ur tsitsat novel Z.evi, and Mishnat h.akhamim.19 Avraham Yaʿakov Brawer (1884–1975), who saw the manuscript of Divre binah in Tarnopol, published some forty pages of the text in installments in Ha-Shiloah. between 1917 and 1921.20 Brawer’s quotations from the book are drawn almost exclusively from the Frankist episode, and he provides a much too brief summary of the introductory pages of the manuscript. Brawer was convinced that he had copied the only valuable and “original” parts of the book. In fact, he explains in his own memoirs that he blocked publication of the parts of Divre binah that he had not copied.21 Hence, I have chosen to describe and begin to analyze the introductory section—the first forty-eight pages of the book. D OV B ER
ON
C HRISTIANITY
On page 2 of the text, which amounts to a second title page, the author announces his purpose, which is “to cause lying words against our religion to 17. Divre binah, 40 (quoting Moshe Hagiz, Mishnat h.akhamim). See also Hannah Węgrzynek, “The Attitude of the Catholic Church towards Jews in Poland at the Beginning of the Eighteenth Century,” Kwartalnik Historii Żydów 6 (2006): 665 (662–68); Gavri’el ben Z.evi Hirz. (Soh.astov), Maz.evat kodesh: hu zikhron z.adikim ha-nikra bet ya‘akov, sefer zikaron le-khol ge’one u-gedole Yisra’el poh ‘ir Levov, part 4 (Lemberg, 1879), 13–15. 18. See Gershon Hundert, Jews in Poland–Lithuania in the Eighteenth Century (Berkeley: University of California Press, 2004), 154–59 and the references there. 19. Tuvyah ben Moshe Yirmiyahu ha-kohen, Maʿaseh Tuvyah (Venice, 1707); Menah.em Amelander, She’erit Yisra’el (Lwów, 1804); Yaʿakov ben Aharon Sasportas (David ben Rafa’el Meldola), Kiz.ur tsitsat novel Z.evi (Amsterdam, 1737; Altona, 1757); Moshe ben Yisra’el Yaʿakov Hagiz, Mishnat h.akhamim (Wandsbek, 1733). The quotations are not of consecutive pages and are studded with interpolations. For example, he quotes sixteen separate passages from Kiz.ur tsitsat novel Z.evi interspersed with comments and summaries of the elided portions of the work (Divre binah, 75–172). 20. Avraham Yaʿakov Brawer, “Makor h.adash le-toledot Frank ve-siʿato,” Ha-Shiloah. 23 (1917–18), 146–56, 330–42, 439–49; 38 (1921), 231–38. Also published in idem, Galiz.iyah, 197–275. 21. “There appeared in Jerusalem a young scholar who had also been to the Perl Library, found the manuscript [of Divre binah] and copied what I had omitted. He wanted to publish these portions. Professor Simh.ah Assaf asked my opinion and I answered that what I omitted was copied by Dov Ber from Hebrew and Polish books. The Hebrew books were checked—the Polish ones were unavailable in the land [of Israel] then—and it was found that my words were correct. The portions copied by that scholar were not allowed to be published.” Mikha’el Ha-kohen Brawer, Avraham Yaʿakov Brawer, Zikhronot av u-beno (Jerusalem: Mosad ha-rav Kuk, 1966), 404; cf. Brawer, Galiz.iyah, 208–209.
229
Gershon David Hundert disappear.” And, indeed, one of his concerns, which finds expression in the early pages, is the defense of Judaism in general and of the Oral Torah in particular in the face of polemical remarks by Christians. Dov Ber tells us that he spent most of his life in Lwów engaged in the wine business, in the course of which he had frequent contact with, and often entered the homes of, Christian laymen and priests. He notes that “virtually daily” they would demean Judaism, saying that Jews had lost their ancient wisdom: “You are all confused and nothing remains to you but your Talmud which misleads and betrays you; it is full of absurdities and many lies.”22 Dov Ber’s desire to find a way to answer the enemies of Judaism began in his youth. His father, in addition to owning a wine business, operated an inn that attracted people of various nations. “And often the first thing they said was against the Oral Torah.” It was from that time that Dov Ber, he says, resolved to study their languages assiduously in order to be able to read their books. And, indeed, he used his free time for this purpose. Still, as a young person, he was afraid to read the writings of Gentiles because “they [the writings] are much detested among our people.” He was afraid, he says, until he found Leh.em Yehuda by the Sephardic scholar Yehuda Yuda ben Shemu’el Lerma, which is a commentary on the Ethics of the Fathers.23 In his Memoirs, as noted, Dov Ber explains that he learned Polish at the behest of his father. He had to stop, he explains there, because “some of the people in our community began to gossip about me and to suspect my faith … and I had to give up my [secular] studies.”24 The treatment of this matter in Divre binah, however, suggests that he did not cease his reading in European languages. To further justify and support his path, Dov Ber also presents, in addition to the passage from Leh.em Yehuda, the comments of Yitsh.ak Arama, Maimonides, and Abravanel on a well-known passage in Ethics of the Fathers (2:14–15): Rabbi Elazar [ben Arakh] said: Be eager to study the Torah. Know what to respond to a heretic. Know before Whom you toil and Who is your Employer Who shall pay you the reward of your labor. 22. Divre binah, 3. These lines on page 3 of Divre Binah and some of what follows there replicate almost exactly certain passages in Maʿaseh Tuvyah by Tuviyah Kohen (Krakow, 1908), ptih.a, 2: ופוערים פיהם לבלי חק ודוברים עלינו עתק בגאווה ובוז לאמר אין לכם פה להשיב ולא: עמ' ב, פתיחת המחבר,במעשה טוביה ועל.מצח להרים ראש בעניני האמונה וכבר אבדה חכמתכם ובינתכם הקדומה כמו ששמעתי דבת רבים מגור מסביב בימי חרפי והאמת הוא שבעו"ה אנשי ההחכמה אבדו.זה הזהירו אותנו חז"ל באמרם הוי שקוד ללמוד תורה ודע מה שתשיב לאפיקורוס ולכן קמתי אני הצעיר באלפי ונתעוררתי לכבוד ה' אלהי.ואין אתנו יודע להשיב למפקפקים החורפים אותנו תשובה נצחת כראוי ובגאוה ובוז עתק. ולבלי חוק היו פיהם נגדינו פוערים. ומדי יום ממש היו לנו אומרים:3 ' ואלו בדברי בינה עמ. …ישראל ואין עוד לכם. כבר אבדה מכם חכמתכם הקדומה. בעסקי ועניני האמונה. אין לכם פה להשיב ולא ראש להרים. עלינו דוברים על שלא היו בנו איש שדבר. שומעים חרפתם ואינם משיבים. ובני ישראל נעלבים ואינם עולבים:5 ' ובעמ. איש היודע עד מה בתשובה. שישיב להם איזה איש יהודא על ספיקותם.ויען שבקטנותי הבינותי מדבריהם מגמתם.…לשונם בלשון לימודים ניצחת אף נגד דתם…ומאז רוח קנאה לבשתי…אעפ"כ לקרות בספריהם בילדותי יראתי…עד שהגיע לידי …פירוש על .מסכתא אבות …על מאמר ר' אליעזר הוי שקוד ללמוד תורה ודע מה שתשיב לאפיקורס 23. Venice, 1553; 2nd ed., Sabbioneta, 1554. 24. Memoirs, 80; Zikhronot, 46.
230
The Introduction to Divre binah by Dov Ber of Bolechów Dov Ber summarizes the commentators’ views as follows: The intention of the rabbi’s warning is not to demand that a person devote himself exclusively to the study of the Torah. In order to know how to respond to heretics, one must know their books and the source of their error. “And how much more so in our generation … when our Faith is much desecrated among the gentiles, certainly there is no fault if we know how to respond to their questions in their language. Once God had revealed this to me, I determined to take up this simple task; perhaps God’s name will be sanctified by me in this way.”25 The Sephardic commentators to Ethics of the Fathers thus provide Ber with a legitimate rationale for his study of “their books.”26 Although, in this passage, the author presents himself as convinced of the appropriateness of his study of languages, other passages in other contexts in Divre binah suggest a more conventional, isolationist tendency. As will be seen later, he praises Polish Jews for not using a single word of Russian or Polish.27 And in a passage that Dov Ber quotes from Mishnat h.akhamim, the author, Moshe Hagiz, recounts the story of the martyrdom of H.ayyim Reizes in Lwów. According to Hagiz, Reizes attested that he was going to be executed in such a cruel fashion—having his tongue torn out—because he had learned Latin and other languages.28 Dov Ber’s keen desire to find ways to answer the accusations of Christians, however, is unquestionable. There follows a brief recounting of the tradition regarding the transmission of the Oral Torah and a statement of its utter reliability. Indeed, this subject is a leitmotif of the first forty-nine pages of Divre binah.29 The reliability of the chain of transmission of the Torah seems intended to be persuasive evidence of its authority, in contrast to what Dov Ber characterizes as the irrational and forged traditions of other monotheistic faiths. Moreover, the first debate with the Frankists, which takes up much space in the latter pages of Divre binah not considered in the present article, focused on the Talmud and the accusation that it was blasphemous.30 Dov Ber then characterizes Christianity and Islam in a way that is distinguished by its relatively neutral tone. He presents the early Christians as rebels against the rabbis, stating that the first Christians persisted in their ways until “they were driven out and separated themselves” from the community of Israel. 25. Divre binah, 6–8. 26. Cf. “We Jews must know all things, so that there may be realized in us the saying from the Bible: ‘For this is your wisdom and your understanding in the sight of the nations’ [Deuteronomy 4:6]. Although our teachers, be their memories for a blessing, applied this saying to our holy Torah, they also taught that it is good to combine Torah with worldly knowledge; and it is advantageous for every intelligent and educated Jew to have a knowledge of the history of the nations of the world. This will sometimes enable him properly to answer questions directed against the Jewish Law and faith, as has occurred to me several times in my discourses with the nobles and the clergy. In most of the cases I have found the right answer, and it is well-known to all that my replies were always convincing” (Memoirs, 141–42; Zikhronot, 87). 27. Divre binah, 18–19. 28. Ibid., 40. 29. Ibid., 8, 9, 25, 36. 30. Ibid., 194–220.
231
Gershon David Hundert Under the leadership of their priests, they learned some of the commandments of the Torah of Israel, which, until that time, “had been hidden among us from the nations. These Christians took hold only of the Written Torah, the Prophets, and the Writings, and imprisoned them without understanding their meaning.” Indeed, they misinterpreted verses to signify their Redeemer and to strengthen their own religion.31 Somewhat later in the introductory pages, Dov Ber discusses the matter of the sacred texts of Christianity and Islam. He characterizes them as scriptural religions (toraniyim), a term, I believe, previously not used in this sense in writings by rabbinic Jews, at least in Eastern Europe. It is true, on the other hand, that Yaʿakov Emden uses similar terminology, and that Moshe Hagiz, whom Ber quotes extensively,32 seems to take a similar stance.33 Dov Ber says, The Christians have a version of the Torah of Moses and the Prophets in their Bible [bibli’ah]; however, it is not edited but forged from its beginning to its end because they received it from various nations in many languages through their forging priests over a long period of time, almost two thousand years. Each nation in turn added distortions and forgeries until it was completely counterfeit …. So, too, the Ishmaelites of the Mohammedan religion, although there is in their Koran something of the Torah of Moses, it too is forged and mixed with the lies of Mohammed their false prophet.34
On the subject of the Christian Bible (sifre evan gelyon),35 Dov Ber asserts that its books support the Torah of Moses. He notes that the Christian Bible testifies that Jesus came to fulfill the Torah and not to annul it, “as is explained in several places in their books, Matthew chapter 5, verse 17.”36 He asserts that he presented this issue to the priest (Gaudenty) Pikulski, “the author of the book Jewish Malice, in Polish Złość żydowski, and he responds to my question in that book on page 435.”37 The reference is correct; in the second edition of his book, Pikulski 31. Ibid., 4–5. 32. Ibid., 39–42, 176–85. 33. Yaʿakov Emden, Sefer Shimush (Amsterdam [actually Altona], 1758), 20b, refers to the “three leading faiths that have erected their fortresses on the basis of the Torah of Moses” (sheloshet umot [emunot?] rashiyot … she-banu mivz.arehem al yesod torat mrʿ”h). On Hagiz, see Elisheva Carlebach, The Pursuit of Heresy: Rabbi Moses Hagiz and the Sabbatian Controversies (New York: Columbia University Press, 1990), 262–67. See also the summary and extension of Jacob Katz’s work on this subject in Yosef Salmon, “Noz.rim ve-noz.rut be-sifrut ha-pesikah me-shalhey ha-me’ah ha-shemoneh-esreh ve-ʿad ha-mah.az.it ha-sheniyah shel ha-me’ah ha-tesha-esreh,” in Al pi ha-be’er: Meh.karim be-hagut yehudit uve-mah.shavat ha-halakha mugashim le-Yaʿakov Blidstein, ed. Uri Ehrlich, H.ayyim Kreisel and Daniel Lasker (Beer-Sheva: Ben-Gurion University of the Negev Press, 2008), 635–51. 34. Divre binah, 9. 35. E. Carlebach suggests that this is a pun to yield even (wicked) gilyon (scroll). 36. “Do not think that I have come to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I have not come to abolish them but to fulfill them” (Divre binah, 10). And see the citation of this verse in the context of the description of the debate over the Talmud in 1757, ibid., 213–14. 37. Gaudenty Pikulski, Złość żydowska Przeciwko Bogu y bliźniemu Prawdzie y Sumnieniu na obiaśnienie Talmudystów. Na dowód ich zaślepienia, y Religii dalekiey od prawa Boskiego przez Moyżesza danego. Rozdzielona na trzy części opisana (Lwów, 1760 [1st ed., 1758]).
232
The Introduction to Divre binah by Dov Ber of Bolechów does indeed cite a question, attributing it to “ieden Żyd we Lwowie” (a certain Jew in Lwów). Pikulski’s formulation of Ber’s question is, “Let us grant that Christ was the true Messiah and thus all the prophecies were fulfilled in him. He says, however, in Matthew 5:17, ‘I have not come to destroy the Law [of Moses] but to fulfill it.’ Why do you Catholics not fulfill the Law of Moses? You do not keep the Sabbath but Sunday. Either your Christ said these words with a false heart, or you obey neither God nor Christ.”38 According to Ber, Pikulski’s response was foolish, as “there is no answer to my question.”39 Ber’s various objections to Christian teaching, and his knowledge of the New Testament, derive in part from Yiz.h.ak ben Avraham of Troki’s H.izuk emunah, especially “the second part of this book [which includes] translations to the Holy Tongue of many passages in the Evan gelyon and the books of the messengers of Jesus; these are the apostles.”40 He praises this author, of whose Karaite identity he seems unaware, saying that no Jewish opponent of Christianity has ever been his equal in attacking the very foundations of their foolish faith. Still, he notes the usefulness in this regard also of Yom Tov Lipman Mülhausen’s Sefer niz.ah.on,41 and of Maʿaseh Tuvyah. Despite the efforts of these scholars, many could not tolerate the contempt and scorn of the exile at the hands of these “sons of Ham, Put, and Canaan,”42 idol worshippers who daily defame Jews before the rulers “of the states and lands of Europe both in spoken words and in books printed more and more often in order to arouse their hatred against us.”43 Among the lies propagated against Jews was the blood libel. Not surprisingly, Ber goes on at some length about this topic, as the issue had been a central theme at the Lwów confrontation with the Frankists in 1759, to which he alludes briefly. He notes that the libel had been transmitted among priests for centuries, and cites their words: The Jews cannot eat the unleavened bread on Passover without the blood of Christians. For this purpose they kidnap their sons and slaughter them to obtain their blood to eat it with the unleavened bread on the first night of Passover. The reason they give for this is the notion, both stupid and very strange, that the unjustified spilling of the blood of the Christian boy would atone on 38. “Daymy to żeby Chrystus był prawdziwym Messyaszem y o nim wszystkie spełnily Proroctwa; iednakże on się oświadczy u Mateusza w Rozd: 5, w. 17 że: Nieprzyszedł prawa psować (Moyżeszowego) ale go wypełnić. Zacoż wy Katolicy nie pelnicie Prawa Moyżeszowego, nie szanuiecie Sabbaszu, ale Niedziele: albo tedy wasz Chrystus zmyślonym sercem te slowa mowił, albo wy ani Boga, any Chrystusa swego niesłuchacie. Tak mowił zemną ieden Żyd we Lwowie” (ibid., 435–36). On Pikulski, see Gershon David Hundert, “Identity Formation in the Early Modern Polish Commonwealth,” in Citizenship and Identity in a Multinational Commonwealth: Poland–Lithuania in Context, 1550–1772, ed. Karin Friedrich and Barbara Pendzich (Leiden: Brill, 2009), 146–47 (131–47). 39. Divre binah, 11. 40. Ibid. 41. Written in 1390 by Yom Tov Lipman Mülhausen (Altdorf, 1644; Amsterdam, 1709). 42. Chronicles I, 1:8. 43. Divre binah, 12.
233
Gershon David Hundert the Jews’ behalf for the unjustified spilling of the blood of Jesus of Nazareth in Jerusalem.44
The charge of host desecration is another example of the slanderous defamations (ʿalilot shtutot u-bilbule shekarim) that for a thousand and some hundreds of years had led, in the lands and kingdoms of Europe, to the martyrdom of countless great scholars and leaders. This happened “not only in faraway lands, but also in several nearby communities.” Ber says that he feels obliged to recount this suffering, “so that those who come after us will not say that the early days were better than today.”45 Ber asserts that, in particular, the people and rulers of Poland, “together with their priests,” believed the libels. He notes that he has found evidence of this in historical works in Polish, which he has translated into Hebrew.46 Such material is indeed presented in the latter part of the book in connection with the Frankist debate. The wise responses of Rabbi H.ayyim (ben Simh.ah ha-Kohen) Rapoport47 during the Lwów debate in 1759 put this accusation to rest; moreover, Ber states that new trends of thought are now found among scholars of Europe: Great, wise, and learned scholars have arisen lately among the gentiles. They are familiar with many ancient books, and have written much, as a result of their researches, against idol worshippers and, even more, against Christians. They utterly deny the stories of their [the early Christians’] deeds, saying the tales of miracles in their New Testament [toratam ha-h.adashah] … are unbelievable and contrary to Nature.48
Dov Ber’s attitude to Christianity thus includes a measure of respect, but it is, ultimately, somewhat contemptuous. He predicts that Christianity and Christians will disappear and be forgotten, just as idolatry and idolaters have disappeared from human memory.49 D OV B ER
ON THE NEW
A USTRIAN
REGIME
In Dov Ber’s account, the origins of Jewish settlement in Poland began with the arrival of Jews from Ashkenaz. At the time, Poland was a neglected wilderness that lacked precious goods, gold, and silver, so the Jews brought their many treasures in an arrangement with the dukes and leaders of Kraków. He says that Poland had no king then, but was ruled by twelve provincial governors. It was they who accepted the Jews, receiving a huge loan from them and granting them the right of settlement on the condition that they continue to dress in their customary way. Indeed, Jews not only did not imitate the dress of their neighbors, but also did 44. Ibid. 45. Ibid., 12–13. 46. Ibid., 14. 47. The rabbi of Lwów, and the leading representative of the rabbinic side in the disputation with the Frankists, d. 1771. 48. Ibid., 16. 49. Ibid., 4.
234
The Introduction to Divre binah by Dov Ber of Bolechów not adopt their language. “To speak amongst themselves, they used Yiddish [leshon Ashkenazi] without a single word from the ‘Russian’ [perhaps Ruthenian is meant] or Polish languages.” The Polish authorities also permitted Jews to build magnificent and important buildings for their synagogues.50 The First Partition of Poland in 1772 brought much of Galicia, as it was then called, under the sway of Austrian rulers. The author presents contradictory opinions about the new Habsburg regime and its laws affecting Jews. He alludes, for example, to legislation that is not recorded in standard texts on Jews in the Habsburg lands: And now under the rule of our Lord the magnificent pious Joseph II, His majesty the Emperor, whose honor is revealed in all the states of his kingdom [it has been decreed] that all the blood libels against the Jews are false and untrue. No ruler or judge may put faith in such [an accusation] against the Jews on pain of huge fines.51
Although such Habsburg legislation is unknown, a ruling to this effect was, in fact, issued by the Hungarian authorities in 1791: The Jewish community living in this kingdom turned to this Royal Hungarian Lieutenancy Council with the bitter complaint that in most Christians the prejudice according to which Jews need Christian blood to celebrate the holiday of Passover has risen again. Consequently, Jews are severely persecuted, especially by common people. Several instances are mentioned to prove it. Since these views and the like interfere with the peace and security of the Jewish people, the Royal Hungarian Lieutenancy Council deems it necessary to decree that the prejudice of Christian blood sacrifice at Jewish services be erased from the mind of the people with the assistance of priests. The Jewish religion is based on the laws of Moses and the prophetic books, that is, on the Old Testament; therefore, it is not at all worse than the laws of other religions. As a result, if a Jew commits murder, it is not because of their religion. You should not blame the whole Jewish people more than Christians in a similar case. Finally, the Royal Hungarian Lieutenancy Council decrees that those who persecute or abuse Jews are to be punished severely.52 50. Ibid., 18–19; cf. Brawer, Galiz.iyah, 203. 51. Ibid., 16. 52. Budapest, Magyar Zsidó Muzeum, Obudai Iratok (Obuda Documents), 8.007 (old no. 8.145): “Die in diesem Königreich wohnenden Juden, haben gemeinschaftlich bey dieser Königl. Statthalterey darüber bittere Klage geführet, dass sie wegen des bei den meisten Christen wieder aufblühenden Vorutheils, als wenn die Juden zur Feyerung ihres Osterfestes Christenblut bedürften, schwere Verfolgungen, besonders von dem gemeinen Volk erdulden müssen; zum Beweis dessen haben sie auch mehrere Beyspiele angeführet. Damit also die durch dergleichen irrige Meynungen geschwächte Rufe und Sicherheit, dieser Nation verschaft werde, so hat diese Königl. Statthalerey zu verordnen für nöthig befunden, daß man sich angelegen seyn müsse, dieses Vorutheil, daß bey dem Jüdischen Gottesdienst Menschen Blut geopfert werde, auf die schicklichste und den local Umständen angemessen seyn, allenfalls auch durch Beyziehung der Seelsorger als den Gemüthern des Volkes herauszureissen,
235
Gershon David Hundert Presumably Dov Ber, who had strong links to Hungary because of his dealings in the wine trade, heard about this enactment and mistakenly assumed it applied to Galicia as well.53 Dov Ber characterizes other well-known aspects of Habsburg legislation—on taxation and economic activity, for example—more negatively, but his tone is guarded. He notes, among others, the legislation of 1785 limiting rabbinic courts to matters exclusively related to religion and to functioning as a court of arbitration in other spheres: According to the government, may God preserve it, rabbinic courts may not subpoena Jews, although it is explained in the imperial code [ba-sistem mehakʿyr’h] that our rabbis are permitted to function as an arbitration court [la-ʿarokh mishpatim lifnehem be-torat kompromost].54
In Bolechów, Ber explains, the community found a way around this law by having all its members sign and seal the writ of appointment of the rabbi,55 including accepting his right to subpoena them in any matter without appeal to government
und selbe zu belehren, dass dieses verachtungswürdige Laster dem Monarchie Gesetz und den Schriften der Propheten, mithin der ganzen Vorschrift des alten Testaments auf welche sich doch die Jüdische Religion vorzüglich gründet nicht minder als den Gesetzen der übrigen Religionen zuwider sey. Daher könne auch die von dem ein oder andern Juden verübte Mordthat, wenn sichs auch befinden würde, dass solche aus abergläubischen Absichten geschehen, der ganzen Jüdischen Nazion nicht mit mehr Recht zur Last gelegt werden, als man dergleichen Fälle wegen, wenn sie sich unter den Christen ereigneten, auf alle einen Haß werfet. Übrigens soll darüber ernstlich gewachet werden, dass Juden wider die Vorschrift des 38te Artikels der neueren Gesetze auf keine Weise beunruhigt werden, welches durch die gewöhnlichen Curentales dem Volke auf das nachdrücklichste, und unter Bedrohung der schwersten Strafen zu verbiethen, und im Fall einer Verfolgung, oder den Juden zugefügten Beleidigung der Schuldige, zum Beyspiel der anderen auf das schärfeste zu bestrafen ist. Gegeben aus dem Rathe der Königl. Hungs. Statthalterey Ofen, den 24 Juny 1791.” 53. In response to a blood libel in 1844 in Tarnów, the leaders of the community cited this Hungarian legislation and urged that it be applied to Galicia as well. See Gershon Wolf, “Blutbeschuldigungen der Juden,” Jahrbuch für Israeliten 5623 (Wien 1862), 37–38 (30–39). 54. Divre binah, 37. The end of Jewish communal autonomy was legislated in the Judensystem in Galizien (note that Dov Ber uses the term system) promulgated in May 1785 by Joseph II. Cf. Josef Karniel, “Das Toleranzpatent Kaiser Josephs II. Für die Juden Galiziens un Lodomeriens,” Jahrbuch des Instituts für Deutsche Geschichte 11 (1982), 59, 72–74 (55–89). The notion of courts of arbitration chaired by communal rabbis is anticipated in the Allgemeine Ordnung für die gesamte Judenschaft der konigreiche Galizien und Lodomerien promulgated by Maria Theresa in July, 1776, 5:3, which is headed “Von den jüdischen compromissen.” Continuatio edictorum et mandatorum universalium in Regnis Galiciae et Lodomerie (Lwów, 1774–1818), 20:114. See also Oxford, Bodleian Library, MS Michael/448 (F20498); Jerusalem, Central Archives for the History of the Jewish People, PL/617, part 5, item 3. Rachel Manekin notes in an unpublished study that in the discussions between government officials and leading Jews in 1784, the officials emphasized that despite the anticipated disestablishment of Jewish communal courts, the option of arbitration courts would remain available: “wobei es sich jedoch von selbsten verstehet, dass den Parteien immer frei stehet, mit Vorbeigehung des Judicis ordinarii, sich auf ein Compromiss ensulassen.” 55. David Yaʿakov ben Yiz.h.ak Izak Heilperin. Cf. Meir Wunder, Me’ore Galiz.iyah: Entsiklopediah le-h.akhme Galiz.iyah, (Jerusalem: Makhon le-hantsah.at Yahadut Galitsyah, 1982), 2:588.
236
The Introduction to Divre binah by Dov Ber of Bolechów courts (beli shum apelaz.iyeh). It is now, he says, two years since the rabbi assumed his post, and not a single community member has resorted to the courts (of the Gentiles).56 Dov Ber mentions, with regret, the decrees of 1789 forbidding Jews to hold arendas in the villages: For several years now the poor Jews have been deprived and forbidden arendas in the villages, from leasing the mills, the tolls, and from other good monopolies [maʿarufiyot ha-tovim].57
He is unhappier still with the Candle Tax of 1797 and its consequences because the legislation resulted not only in the abolition of the capitation tax but also in the end of government recognition of the kahal. In response, he states, “Our people is left like sheep without a shepherd.”58 Moreover, the Habsburg system had led to the corruption of the rabbinic office. Dov Ber’s response to the situation created by the Habsburg legislation forms part of his more general set of opinions about community leadership. This section of his text begins after his rejection of Kabbalah and his description of the “proper” qualities of the traditional rabbi—namely, that a rabbi ought to be fully occupied with the study of the revealed Torah, Talmud, and halakhah. In this way, rabbis become equipped to respond to questions and can publish them in the form of responsa literature. The study of ethical literature is also deemed important. And those who preach and rebuke the people also ought to be salaried by the communities, as is the case with the rabbis.59 Dov Ber also insists that rabbis must be appointed by the Jews themselves and paid from communal funds so that they can act as impartial judges. He hopes that all communities will find a way to follow the example of the town of Bolechów. Doing so will help Jews resist abrogation of the halakhah and will also fulfill the commandment that states, “You shall appoint for yourself judges” (Deuteronomy 16:18). The words “for yourself,” he claims, mean by yourselves and not by the government. Up to this time, rabbinical appointments had been based on large gifts of cash to government officials. That situation occurred despite the will of the majority of the community, and often resulted in the appointment of unfit persons.60 Ber also quotes a lengthy passage from Mishnat h.akhamim, devoted mainly to condemning the long-standing (“several hundred years”) practice in Poland of the purchase of rabbinical offices.61 56. Divre binah, 37. 57. Ibid. Cf. Karniel, “Das Toleranzpatent Kaiser Josephs II,” 81–82. 58. Ibid., 38. Cf. Bericht über die Verhandlungen des ersten galizisch jüdischen Cultusgemeinde-Tages (Lemberg, 1878), 33. 59. Divre binah, 36. 60. Ibid., 37. 61. Ibid., 39–42; Mishnat h.akhamim, Part 1, Maʿaleh 17, Siman 405. Cf. Rosman, Lords’ Jews, 198–204.
237
Gershon David Hundert In Ber’s understanding, the abrogation of the capitation tax and its replacement by the candle tax had led to the subversion of the Jews’ communal government, leaving them without proper leadership. He prays that Jews living under the emperor will find a way to return to the practice of annually electing “seven good men” by majority vote.62 These men would be empowered to evaluate wealth and assess taxes for communal needs, and would also take counsel together to decide on appropriate “gifts” for government officials. Finally, Dov Ber hopes that the leaders of individual communities will be permitted to form a council of all communities. This would, however, be contrary to the recently promulgated law forbidding just such an institution, and forbidding the expenditure of communal funds to send representatives to Vienna or even to Lwów.63 The importance to Ber of the Council of Four Lands, disestablished by the Polish government in 1764, is made clear in his Memoirs; he states that, while it existed, the council represented “a small redemption and a bit of honor” for Jews. He then asserts that the Confederation of Bar, which culminated in the partition of Poland in 1772, was divine retribution for the abolition of the council.64 D OV B ER
ON THE
E NLIGHTENMENT
To Dov Ber, the times had brought changes other than those the Habsburg regime imposed on its Jewish population: An even worse evil has developed. In these times, some of our people have begun to imitate the unshaven young men of Ashkenaz65 who are accustomed from their youth to pursue the appetites of this world, and they permit themselves [to transgress] several positive and negative commandments, for many have mingled with gentiles. They learned wastefulness from them and to deny everything. Because of our many sins, these are heretics worse than the Sadducees and Boethusians of the days of the Second Temple …. Therefore, I deemed it appropriate to write some [words] about the knowledge of God that I have collected from the holy books of investigation of the wise men among the Sephardim.66
There follow some six pages under the subheading “Knowledge of God, May He Be Blessed.” Ber delves into the inability of the human mind to grasp divinity, and strongly affirms the existence of individual providence (hashgah.ah peratit). We must first study our own souls, he says, before we seek to understand our Creator. This is the teaching of the philosophers (deʿu nafshekhem ve-tedʿu elokekhem). Indeed, a human being is a microcosm of the universe, and the divine 62. The phrase is talmudic (e.g., B. Megillah 26a) and stands for the elected leadership of the community. 63. Divre binah, 38–39. 64. Memoirs, 150; Zikhronot, 92. 65. One wonders whether this passage refers to teachers brought to Galicia by (Naftali) Herz Homberg (1749–1841), and especially to the Pedagogical Seminary he established in Lwów in 1792. 66. Ibid., 42. Cf. Brawer, Galiz.iyah, 204.
238
The Introduction to Divre binah by Dov Ber of Bolechów element is the soul. The Lord is the soul of the world and of nature—and the numerical values of nature (tevaʿ) and the Lord (Elohim) are equivalent (86). Ber then adamantly denies the view of some heretics who claim that the world functions according to its own nature without divine providence.67 D OV B ER
ON EARLY
H ASIDISM
Dov Ber devotes considerable space to the phenomenon of Hasidism, and constructs what can be read as an accounting for the appearance of its growth on the basis of four ingredients: region, changes in the method of study of Talmud, the growing preoccupation with the esoteric (razin de-oraita), and the influence of baʿalei shemot (masters of the Name; akin to shamans).68 Dov Ber associates the beginnings of Hasidism with “Podolia and Ukraine,” a region he characterizes as having been settled originally mainly by the poor who could not find gainful work in older communities. It was in that region also that Cossacks, in each generation, rebelled and murdered many Jews. Dov Ber says that ancient customs are neglected in that area; as examples, he notes the absence of the wearing of a special head covering (braytl ) and jacket (letnik) for prayer in the synagogue: “They do not prepare such garments for prayer in the holy synagogue but pray and study in whatever clothing they wear every day to the market.”69 “Worse than this,” he asserts, “the scholars of our generation have ceased to study the Talmud be-pilpula h.arifta, as was the ancient custom.”70 The abandonment of the traditional ways of studying was precipitated, as Dov Ber presents it, by a spreading preoccupation with the esoteric. He captures this trend 67. Divre binah, 43–44. Cf. Maʿaseh Tuvyah, 1: attacks those Jews who believe that everything happens according to ha-teva u-minhago—natural law—without divine intervention in the world. 68. In the Memoirs, there is virtually no attention to Hasidism. Ber does mention a man—subsequently shown to be a fool—who began to behave in the ways of h.asidut. This, however, seems not to refer to Beshtian Hasidism (Memoirs, 115; Zikhronot, 69). And there is reference to Ber’s contacts with the father and uncle of Yitsh.ak Eisik of (Nagy) Kallo (1751–1821), then a child, and subsequently the Kaliver Rebbe, well known for his songs and most famously “Szól a kakas már.” Dov Ber says of him, “When he grew up his singing made him famous among the Hasidim, as it is ‘said ‘Sing unto the Lord a new song and His praise in the congregation of the saints [h.assidim].’… R. Eisik became famous throughout the county on account of his piety [h.assiduto]. He was diligent in the study of rabbinical authors and became a rabbi and teacher in Israel; to this day he is chief of the bet din in Nagy Kallo” (Memoirs, 130; Zikhronot, 79). On baʿalei shem, see Hundert, Jews in Poland–Lithuania, 142–53. 69. Divre binah, 19–20. 70. Ibid., 21. Here Ber offers a brief portrait of yeshiva study: “I myself, as a young man, saw this with my own eyes… At the beginning of the term I studied a page of gemara selected by the rabbi, chief judge and mara de-atra, with all of its commentaries. Each student tried, in accordance with his own ability, to innovate something on the basis of the text and the commentators. First the rabbi himself stood and explicated his own innovative perspective on the passage with his great expertise and enormous insight. After him all of the advanced students (lomdim) and the students (talmidim) presented their novel insights in accordance with their abilities (kefi hasagato be-pilpulo). The wealthy would invite the advanced students to their homes and entertain them with delicacies and whiskey.” Cf. Elchanan Reiner, “Yeshiva,” YIVO Encyclopedia of Jews in Eastern Europe (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2008), 2:2051–55.
239
Gershon David Hundert in his report of events that occurred in 1742 when the kabbalistic work H.emdat yamim arrived in Tyśmienica, where Dov Ber lived at the time: They purchased the books [H.emdat yamim] for the bet ha-midrash of the holy community of Tyśmienica for three adumim [a high price]. Since the author advocates the study of the books of Kabbalah devoted to the secrets of the divine, the students despaired of studying the Talmud and its commentaries be-pilpula h.arifta.71
The enthusiasm of the young men for this new trend became manifest in the synagogue: I saw with my own eyes several of our people who were possessed by the spirit, and they said it was the spirit of the heretics who had apostatized. They would throw themselves down in the front of the synagogues during the reading of the Torah on the sabbaths and on Mondays and Thursdays. They would pound their chests cruelly with large rocks. No man could suffer, it would seem, the murderous blows I [afflicted on] myself in my youth and in my naïveté.72
Although a major part of this passage was published by Brawer, the latter apparently feared the censor and omitted the reference to the souls of the apostates.73 It is not clear which apostates are meant. One scholar has characterized these possessed “madmen” as having the ability to identify the sins of a person, including those committed alone and those committed in a previous incarnation.74 Perhaps the notion that they had been apostates in a previous life is what is meant here. Dov Ber’s almost bemused comment about his foolishness as a youth is worthy of note. Solomon Maimon, Dov Ber’s considerably younger contemporary (ca. 1753–1800) notes in his autobiography that, as a young man, he became disillusioned with the rabbis because of their pride and was attracted to people “called hassidim” who devoted their entire lives to strict observance of the commandments, ethics, and morality. Young men seeking alternative ways to serve God seem to have been a phenomenon of the period.75 71. Ibid. 72. Ibid., 22. Cf. “The Writer’s [Dov Ber of Liniec’s] Preface” to In Praise of the Baal Shem Tov: “There were also mad people who injured themselves with stones during the reading of the Torah, and who used to reveal people’s sins to them.” See Dan Ben-Amos and Jerome R. Mintz, In Praise of the Baal Shem Tov (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1970), 4; Shivh.e Ha-Besht, ed. Avraham Rubinstein (Jerusalem: Ruben Mass, 1992), 31. 73. Brawer, Galiz.iyah, 203. 74. Zvi Mark, “Dibuk u-devekut be-Shivh.e Ha-Besht: Heʿarot la-fenomenologiyah shel ha-shigaʿon be-reshit ha-h.assidut,” in Be-maʿagale h.assidim: Kovez. meh.karim le-zikhro shel profesor Mordekhai Wilensky, ed. Immanuel Etkes et al. (Jerusalem: Mosad Bialik, 2000), 251 (247–86). 75. Salomon Maimons Lebensgeschichte (München, 1911), 168; H.aye Shelomoh Maimon, trans. Y. L. Barukh (Tel Aviv: Masada, 1953), 120. Cf. Hundert, Jews in Poland–Lithuania, 179–81;
240
The Introduction to Divre binah by Dov Ber of Bolechów The author devotes some six of the forty-eight pages under consideration here to his attempt to demonstrate that it is preferable to avoid study of the esoteric. After asserting that what distinguishes the rabbis and scholars and makes them worthy of praise is their vast knowledge of the revealed Torah, Dov Ber cites Deuteronomy 29:28 (“The secret things belong unto the Lord our God; but the things that are revealed belong unto us and to our children forever”). He then cites a quotation from the Wisdom of Ben Sirach (Ecclesiasticus 3:21) found in the Talmud (B. Hagiga 13a): “Inquire not into that which is too great for thee; and that which is too hard for thee, search not out. That which is too difficult for thee do not know; and that which is concealed from thee do not ask. Attend to that which is permitted to thee; thou hast no business with hidden things.” This is followed by a lengthy (pp. 31–34) quotation from the first chapter of Sefer or ha-h.ayyim, by Yosef Yavez. (Jabez; d. 1507), which “was published first hundreds of years ago and has been issued recently [1791] in Lwów at the order and with the financial support of … Rabbi Yehuda Leib ben Shne’ur of Bolechów, who is now among the leaders of the community of the capital city of Lwów.”76 To lend further support to his argument, Dov Ber quotes from the beginning of the introduction to Ateret zekenim by Yitsh.ak Abravanel, “which was published first in 1557 and a second time in 1739 in Amsterdam.”77 After buttressing his position with these passages, the author offers his own explanation for the neglect of traditional Talmud study: It is because, from the time, long ago, when the Zohar was revealed, many of the lazy forsook and abandoned the study of the interpretation of the Torah revealed to us at Sinai… . They do not study the Talmud and its commentators … some among our people who lack the ability to understand the depths of the Talmud … but wish to be seen as knowledgeable scholars, boast and preen before the people because of their lofty study of the wisdom of Kabbalah and the secrets of the Torah.78
Proper rabbis and leaders, Ber adds, spend their days in the study of halakhah and Talmud. The fourth element in Dov Ber’s account of the rise of Hasidism concerns the popular esteem in which baʿalei shemot were held. People, he says, would praise them and relate stories about their abilities to heal the sick with amulets and to drive evil spirits out of the possessed by invoking the names of the spirits, each of whose name and function they knew. Indeed, the people were so
Zekhariah Mendel of Jarosław, “Igeret ha-kodesh,” at the end of Noʿam Elimelekh (New York: Shulzinger, 1942), 228–30. 76. The book was published in Amsterdam in 1781 as well. The author was a Spanish exile who, in this work, attacks the study of philosophy and those who study it as responsible for the expulsion from Spain. Note that the initiative for republication, and its funding, came from a local scholar. 77. Divre binah, 34. The quotation takes up most of p. 35. 78. Divre binah, 35–36.
241
Gershon David Hundert fearful of the baʿalei shemot and of demons that “they were afraid to go out alone at night.” If they thought a house was haunted, they would seek out these baʿalei shemot to bring them to drive the demons out through the invocation of holy names.79 While still in Lwów, Dov Ber met “one of these baʿalei shemot,” who confessed and told him of deceptions he himself had employed to deceive people and those used by others to put the fear of demons in the masses: In 1758 and 1759, I came to know and to be convinced that we mortals including gentiles have nothing to fear from the influence of demons. Indeed, many ancient scholars had doubts about their existence and some denied it outright, including Maimonides.80
After insisting that one should trust in divine providence rather than be concerned about demons, Dov Ber announces, in what seems to me to be a sardonic, almost Swiftian depiction, that the era of demons has come to an end: It is now some thirty years or more that one has not heard of harm coming to people at the hands of demons. … Mortals have recognized the lies of the baʿalei shemot and their deceitful ways. Since the disappearance of the baʿalei shemot with their many books and their vain secrets and enigmas, the harmful demons have not been seen and not the slightest harm … has been caused to any Jew, great or small, or even to any gentile. For fear of the armies and the numerous soldiers of His Majesty the emperor, the demons have fled entirely from these lands. And the baʿalei shemot have changed their name to Hasidim.81
For Dov Ber, the hasidim thus arose as a new form of baʿalei shemot in the period after “the flight of the demons.” It is difficult to know which date he is implying when he states that “some thirty years ago,” hasidim appeared. Perhaps he is referring to the partition of Poland (and the end of the Bar Confederacy and its accompanying chaotic military battles) in 1772, but he is more likely alluding to the debate with the Frankists in 1759. In any case, Ber has more to say about these newly appeared hasidim, and it may be that the notion proposed in recent historical literature that baʿalei shem were “endowed … with high status in Jewish society,” and that “they had the respect of the scholars even though they themselves often were not scholars,” will have to be reexamined in light of his comments.82 79. Ibid., 22, 24. 80. Ibid., 23. 81. Ibid., 24. Cf. Brawer, Galiz.iyah, 204. 82. Hundert, Jews in Poland–Lithuania, 148. Cf. Moshe J. Rosman, Founder of Hasidism: A Quest for the Historical Baal Shem Tov (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1996); Immanuel Etkes, Baʿal HaShem: HaBesht: Magiyah, mistikah, hanhagah (Jerusalem: Merkaz Shazar, 2000); idem, “Mekomah shel ha-magiyah u-vaʿalei ha-shem ba-h.evrah ha-ashkenazit be-mifneh ha-me’ot ha–17 ha–18,” Zion 60 (1995), 69–104.
242
The Introduction to Divre binah by Dov Ber of Bolechów Before presenting Ber’s characterizations of Hasidism, a more general comment is in order. Because a major subject of Divre binah is messianism, one might think that the devotion of a section of the book to Hasidism implies that the author viewed the movement as messianic. This, however, is not the case, both because the sections in which Hasidism is mentioned precede the author’s turning to the subject of messianism and its history, and because the word messiah does not appear in the paragraphs devoted to Hasidism. What he seems to be doing is sketching the background of his time and emphasizing the problem of the new place of Kabbalah in Jewish culture. While Ber says that the hasidim, as mentioned, had been known formerly as baʿalei shemot, he also notes that they are called mekubalim—kabbalists who teach esoteric secrets of the divine to students who are unprepared for such study:83 Their entire purpose is to know the esoteric and their desire is to study divine secrets. These they reveal to themselves when they gather in one of their large houses to study with [their leader] during the third meal on the Sabbath.84
Ber, however, has ascertained in person from his own encounters with hasidic leaders that they know nothing of Kabbalah: More than a few times, I myself asked several of their great ones who were staying in my house to reveal to me some of the divine secrets. None of them responded in a satisfactory way. Since that time, I have come to know absolutely that they know no divine secrets, just a few hints in kabbalistic books of the rabbi Yisra’el b”s [baʿal shem], z”l [may his memory be a blessing]. And these make no sense [ve-‘en lahem shah.ar].85
The reference to “kabbalistic books of the rabbi Yisra’el b”s” (i.e., the Besht, Yisra’el Baʿal Shem Tov), most likely relates to the books of his school, of his followers. Dov Ber then expresses, with sarcasm, his skepticism that hasidim were 83. “Mi-pi ha-mekubalim hemah ha-h.asidim o baʿale ha-shemot shemi-kedem hayu mityah.asim le-kadmonehem shem zeh” (Divre Binah, 22). In his characterization of the Sabbatian ascetics, Dov Ber says, “they called themselves by the name Kabbalists” (ibid., 187). 84. Ibid., 27. 85. There is sufficient evidence that there were hasidim in Lwów to warrant granting trustworthiness to Dov Ber’s claim. Meshulam ben Shimshon Igra (1742–1801) of Tyśmienica wrote a letter in 1793 at the time of his departure for Pressburg, addressed to the leaders of Brody and Lwów, attacking Hasidism. Yisra’el Loebel, in his German antihasidic tract, published in 1799, reports that two hasidic leaders lived in Lwów in 1798. See Mordecai Wilensky, Hasidim u-mitnaggedim, 2nd ed. (Jerusalem: Mosad Bialik, 1990), 1:178; 2:337, 366. Cf. Entsiklopediyah shel galuyot, Lvov (Tel Aviv, 1956), 4:221, 425. Uriel Gellman kindly brought my attention to the fact that the brother-in-law of the Seer of Lublin was an active hasid in Lwów, and that Uri of Strelisk resided in Lwów for a period of time. He added that there are notes about Hasidism in Lwów before 1800 in Yosef Te’omim, Or Torah (Jerusalem, 1999).
243
Gershon David Hundert qualified to pronounce the kavanot (intentional formulae before prayer) of the kabbalist Isaac Luria with the proper intention.86 Dov Ber claims that the hasidim study neither Aggadah nor the laws derived from the Talmud. They master only the minimum necessary to present themselves to people as following the Shulh.an ’arukh. They also know nothing of the laws (dinim) found in the Zohar, as they do not study them.87 Hasidic leaders justify these practices, claiming that they have no time for study because of their lengthy preparations for prayer and their numerous purifications in the ritual bath. Ber maintains, however, that hasidim all spend time smoking long pipes (lulki), which he compares to offering up smoke to the devil.88 Dov Ber also discusses the amount of time that hasidim devote to prayer. It is true, he says, that the Talmud describes very pious figures who delay their prayers by an hour to prepare themselves (B. Berakhot 32a), but Ber believes that hasidim take this concept too far. He notes that they delay their morning prayers, and finish their afternoon prayers only when the stars come out, “which is contrary to the rulings of the Shulh.an ’arukh.” Ber then expends several lines about the unique authority of Karo’s codification of the halakhah. It is striking that in these lines he does not refer to the work of Moshe Isserles. Returning to the hasidim, Ber is skeptical about the purity of their motivation in neglecting long-established customs: “One wishes that their purpose were for the sake of the fear of heaven and not the prideful performance of their piety.”89 He then describes how hasidic rabbis travel in long caravans with an entourage of attendants. Many students run before them, praising them before the foolish masses and declaring how remarkably pious these leaders are. He states that men, women, and children are attracted to hasidic leaders who claim the ability to reveal secrets, and know what the future will bring: And the masses of the People of Israel whose fear exceeds their wisdom are troubled and afraid because of the sins that each carries. They are afraid that their transgressions will be revealed in public. [Therefore,] they, their wives, and their children, bring gifts and presents and ask for [the leader’s] blessing.90
It is true, he says, that those who lead the prayers of the hasidim have excellent voices.91 And it is admissible to praise a person for this quality because it is 86. Divre binah, 22. 87. Ibid., 25. 88. Ibid. Cf. H.aye Shelomoh Maimon, 122 (Yosef mi-Kletsk). The term lulke is probably related to the seventeenth-century Turkish term Lületaşi (pipe or pipe stone). 89. Divre binah, 26–27. 90. Ibid., 27. 91. Cf. “the communal officials appoint whoever has a sweet voice to pray on the community’s behalf and lead the prayers from the pulpit. This evil custom is especially prevalent in the lands of Ukraine whence it has spread.” Yaʿakov Yisra’el ben Z.evi Hirsh, Sefer shevet mi-yisra’el (Żółkiew: 1772), pt. 2, 9b.
244
The Introduction to Divre binah by Dov Ber of Bolechów evident and visible to all. Other praises that are said of them, however, are forbidden, including those that extol their spiritual prayers, their mortifications, their fasting from Sabbath to Sabbath, the fact that they eat nothing that has been living (she-‘einam okhlim shum davar meha-h.ay),92 and that through many immersions they have renewed themselves and emerged free of all impurity.93 What troubles the author about these praises is their dependence on the faith of the person who hears them. This passage alone contains the word praise (shevah.) fourteen times. The book In Praise of the Baal Shem Tov (Shivh.e ha-Besht) appeared in print more than a decade after Dov Ber completed his own book, but manuscripts of Shivh.e ha-Besht were certainly in circulation long before the text found its way into print. Perhaps this passage in Divre binah is an allusion to that work. Dov Ber grants that many praises were said of the “first” hasidim (i.e., before Beshtian Hasidism), such as for drawing out their prayers for many hours, reciting the kavanot of Isaac Luria, for leading prayers with sweet voices, and for the practice of many penitential acts according to teshuvat ha-kanah.94 These earlier pious persons, however, were humble and modest, and did not attack the authority of any scholar. Dov Ber states that such is not the case of the hasidim of his own time. In recent years, hasidim have come to lack modesty and humility, and do not follow the requirements of penitential practice.95 Most even ignore the fasts authorized by the rabbis and our ancestors. Their prayers are short because they do not recite the kavanot of Isaac Luria;96 they do not study the laws of the Talmud or the rulings of the Shulh.an ’arukh, nor are they interested in midrash or Aggadah and the relevant commentaries, and they avoid the Zohar. In addition, their h.utspah increases daily to the extent that they disparage the rabbis of the communities of Israel.
92. This refers to a penitential practice known as teshuvat ha-kanah. In Sefer ha-kanah (Krakow, 1894 [1st ed., Prague, 1610]), 12a, we read, “One should eat only sufficient bread to sustain life, cut oneself off from social contact, and from meat and from wine and from all living things and things that come from all living things.” On p. 129 of the same book, the author presents “The Secret of Who Is Permitted to Eat Meat.” See Yisra’el Ta-Shma, “Hekhan nith.abru sifre ha-kanah veha-peli’ah?” in Perakim be-toledot ha-h.evrah ha-yehudit bi-mei ha-benayim uva-ʿet ha-h.adashah, ed. I. Etkes et al. (Jerusalem: Magnes Press, 1980), 56–63; Steven Bowman, “Mi h.iber et Sefer ha-kanah, ve-Sefer ha-Peli’ah?” Tarbiz 54 (1985): 150–52; Michal Oron, “Mihu meh.aber Sefer ha-peli’ah ve-Sefer ha-kanah? Tarbiz 54 (1985): 297–98; idem, “Bikoret ha-h.evrah be-sifrut ha-kabbalah,” Masekhet 2 (2004): 133–46. Cf. Salomon Maimons Lebensgechichte, 168, 170–71; H.aye Shelomoh Maimon, 121: the story of a certain scholar who performed teshuvat ha-kanah … and ate nothing that has been living “meat, milk, honey, and the like.” 93. Divre binah, 27–28. 94. Ibid., 27–28. See n. 89 herein. 95. Enam h.osheshim la-sigufim ha-re’uyim le-teshuvat ha-kanah. 96. On the elimination of kavanot in hasidic prayer, see Pinchas Giller, “Between Poland and Jerusalem: Kabbalistic Prayer in Early Modernity,” Modern Judaism 24, no. 3 (2004): 231–35 (226– 50), and the references there.
245
Gershon David Hundert In fact, in some places rabbis had been forced to leave communities. For example, it was solely because of the hasidic presence that the great scholar Meshulam left his post as rabbi of Tyśmienica to accept a position in Pressburg.97 In sum, Dov Ber’s remarks on Hasidism are based in part on personal impressions he gained in Lwów. He clearly perceives that Hasidism is a new phenomenon, although the lines, established by historians, between the old-style hassidim and the Beshtian form are not entirely clear in his presentation. We might say, pending more systematic collection of source evidence, that in the eyes of observers in the last decades of the eighteenth century, the full distinctiveness of Hasidism from other paths had not yet been established.98 A good many of the complaints found in antihasidic literature in the late eighteenth century are not mentioned in Divre binah. There are no references to the hasidic mode of animal slaughter, to ecstatic prayer or separate places of prayer, to the wearing of white robes, or to the bans of excommunication against hasidim. Ber’s complaints focus on the neglect of study of the revealed Torah, disrespect for the learned rabbis, teaching Kabbalah to the uninitiated, frivolity, not praying at the correct time and omitting the kavanot, and failures in penitence for sins. He implies that hasidic leaders are tricksters and confidence men, but he does not elaborate on this characteristic to a great extent. A FTERWORD : D OV B ER
IN CONTEXT
The significance of these first pages of Divre binah, particularly if read along with the author’s Memoirs, is that they give us a window onto the outlook of a well-established and successful merchant in the Lwów region. He writes as a person of advanced years—in his seventies—and displays the conservatism natural to a man of his age and status. Consequently, his views reflect his discomfort with the changes afoot in his time, among them the new Hasidism, and manifestations of disbelief. His preoccupation, from the years of his youth, with defending Judaism and particularly the Oral Tradition against Christian attack is prominent in the material under discussion. Before attempting to determine whether one might justifiably link Dov Ber to the Haskalah or to the early Haskalah,99 perhaps it would be best to analyze his emphases in the introductory pages of Divre binah. There are four central motifs here: the confrontation with Christianity and with Christian attacks on Jews and 97. Ibid., 29–30. The reference is to Meshulam ben Shimshon Igra (1742–1801), who left Tyśmienica in 1793. The move to the much more prestigious Hungarian community may well have been motivated by factors other than the attacks of hasidim. It is true, though, that when he left Galicia, Igra sent a letter to the elders of the communities of Brody and Lwów attacking Hasidism. David of Maków published this letter in his antihasidic tract Shever poshʿim. Wilensky, H.asidim u-mitnaggedim, 1:177– 79. The letter does not say that its author left Tyśmienica because of the hasidim. 98. Cf. Ada Rapoport-Albert, “Hasidism after 1772,” in Hasidism Reappraised (London: Vallentine Mitchell, 1996), 76–140. 99. For this distinction, see, e.g., Shmuel Feiner, “Ha-haskalah ha-mukdemet be-yahadut ha-me’ah ha-shemoneh-esreh,” Tarbiz 67 (1998): 189–240; idem, Mahapekhat ha-ne’orut: Tenuʿat ha-haskalah ha-yehudit ba-me’ah ha-18 (Jerusalem: Merkaz Zalman Shazar, 2002), 39–109.
246
The Introduction to Divre binah by Dov Ber of Bolechów Judaism; the confrontation with the new Austrian regime and Ber’s proposals for restoring communal autonomy; the confrontation with Hasidism in all its forms and with the preoccupation with Kabbalah; and the defense of the tradition and traditional learning in the face of Hasidism, and, more importantly, with various forms of doubt and unbelief. Roughly equivalent amounts of space—about thirteen pages each—are given to each of the latter two motifs. The polemic with Christianity occupies only about nine pages, though these are placed at the beginning of the book.100 In addition, about six pages are devoted to Ber’s suggestions for maintaining both communal autonomy and an independent and powerful Jewish judicial system—the rabbinate.101 The similarity between the early passages in the book and certain lines in Maʿaseh Tuvyah is noted earlier. In Ber’s telling of the attacks of the nations who claim that true wisdom has vanished from among the Jews, he states, without attribution, the words of Tuvyah Kohen. He sets them, however, in a different context, suggesting that these interlocutors focus on the Talmud, and then proceeds to say that ultimately the Christians will vanish from the earth, following the path of idolaters in the past: “neither the nations nor the names of their gods are remembered by any person. The enemies of God who follow lying religions will be forgotten in just the same way.”102 Tuvyah finds that rabbinic literature does not provide a satisfying answer to his Christian challengers—we were weak in our debates with them, he says. This stimulates the Polish-born physician not to rest until he has composed a work that shows how wisdom has been given not only to them, “but … among us also, there are wise men.”103 In contrast, Ber’s stance is quite different, more confident and assertive, and much less given to a feeling of inferiority than Tuvyah’s. For historians wishing to classify the author as a maskil or early maskil, the passage under consideration here presents a set of contradictory behaviors and attitudes. On the one hand, Dov Ber had studied European languages and showed considerable respect for European scholarship. He composed his works in Hebrew in a style unblemished by the heavily ornate and allusive characteristics of some of his contemporaries. He seems to have had special admiration for Sephardic scholars (virtually all the authors he cites are Sephardic).104 And although the passages about Joseph II and the “flight of the demons” might seem to suggest that, to the author, a new era had begun, there is no support for this idea elsewhere in the text. Dov Ber’s remarks on communal organization and the rabbinate, on the other hand, are distinctly conservative. The notion that intellectuals deserve to lead the community alongside or in place of the traditional rabbinate finds no expression here. On the contrary, he wants to free the rabbinate from state interference and restore its traditional role. He expresses no special faith 100. Confrontation with Christianity: 3–7, 9–13; confrontation with Hasidism and Kabbalah: 22–29, 31–36; defense of the tradition and confrontation with unbelief: 17–22, 30, 42–48. 101. Divre binah, 30, 36–42. 102. Divre binah, 4. 103. Maʿaseh Tuvyah, 25. 104. Divre binah, 6, 19, 23, 36, 42.
247
Gershon David Hundert in reason, which is surely the most indispensable criterion for identifying an individual with the Enlightenment. There is, moreover, no hint that Dov Ber advocated programs for educational, economic, or communal reform. In short, the introductory pages of Divre binah reflect the conservative outlook of an elderly, successful merchant who was pained by some of the changes and developments in his society. Unusual, but far from unique, in possessing a knowledge of European languages, Dov Ber wanted to restore traditional values and traditional leadership forms to his contemporaries and was confident that he had the intellectual wherewithal, provided to him by Jewish sources, with which to answer the challenges of Christians and doubting Jews. Thus, something undefined had changed, and he felt himself, consequently, obliged to seek to clarify an agenda for his time. Gershon David Hundert McGill University Montreal, Canada
248
The Introduction to Divre binah by Dov Ber of Bolechów APPENDIX NOTE ON THE TRANSCRIPTION OF THE TEXT The text presented here preserves as exactly as possible the contents of the manuscript. Spelling and grammatical errors have not been corrected. Where they are egregious, I have added (!). I have also preserved both the “punctuation” and the paragraphing of the author. He uses dots placed between words, at the level of the upper-dot in a colon, to indicate some sort of division, usually when the words at the ends of the phrases rhyme. He uses what looks like a colon to mark the end of a paragraph. He is not, however, consistent in these patterns. ספ ר דברי בינה ****תקיף **חילי יגבר * מישרים לדבר 105
*________* **ובעזר *החונן לאדם דעת *יהיו לרצון אמרי פי אוזן שומעת * ויסיר **מאתנו חרון אף וכעס* דברי חדל אישים גבער **מדעת* לבית יעקב תולעת *_________* **שנת *לישועה ולנחמה **לפ"ק **פה באלחוב יצ"ו 2 'עמ ק ר את י שם החיבור הזה דברי בינה ** על כי בראשי תיבות דברי בינה מרומז שמי ** דוב בער וגם כי דברי בינה עם הכולל עולה רפ"ד גימטריא שמי דו"ב בע"ר וכה יוסיף ד' לי דיעה ובינה להבין ולהשכיל להוציא לאמור אזור. אשר העירוני רעיוני. לאור דברי 105. הספריה הלאומית, ירושלים. MS B964.
249
Gershon David Hundert נא כגבור חלציך .לך שנס מתניך .ואל תרף ידיך .מלדבר דבריך .ולכתוב בספר את כל מעשיך למען תאלמנה שפתי שקר – נגד דתינו לפקיר עמ' 3 דברי בינה **** *יתעלה הבורא ויתפאר היוצר* *כל מעודי* בתשבחות ותהלות לאל הרועה אותי מעודי .בכל ההרפתקאות דעלי עברו . במשך ימי שני חיי בנפשי ומאודי .עד הנה עזרוני ד' ברחמיו .ובימי ישישי לא עזבוני חסדיו .והנני יושב בביתי נאוה ק"ק שליו .באין מחסור לי כל טוב .אמרתי עת לעשות לד' שתורתו הפרנו .המעט שמנעורינו למדנו .בגפ"ת מפי הגאונים ז"ל רבותינו בצוקות העתים . וטרדת הזמנים .לא עמד בנו טעמם .ונמר מפינו ריחם: שרוב ימי חיי יצאתי במו"מ יינות הגרים .בק"ק לבוב ברחובות הגוים . ובחצרות ערלים והכומרים .ושם קנאו בנו אותן הנוצרים .ומדי יום ממש היו לנו אומרים .ולבלי חוק היו פיהם נגדינו פוערים . ובגאוה ובוז עתק עלינו דוברים .אין לכם פה להשיב ולא ראש להרים .בעסקי ועניני האמונה .כבר אבדה מכם חכמתכם הקדומה . ואין עוד לכם איש היודע עד מה .בחכמות אלקות וטבעיות .אתם כולם נבוכים .ואין נשאר בכם .כי אם התלמוד לכם .להטעות ולהדיח אתכם .בגוזמאות ורוב דברי שקרים .מדת נוצרים שלדעתם הוא אמונת הישרים: והמה לזה שונאים אותנו טפי ויותר מכל עובדי עבודת עמ' 4 זרים .שמשלו מימות הבריאה בעולם .ולישראל היו מצרים והנה נאבדו עם עובדיהם מן העולם .ושוב לא שמם ולא שם הגוים שעבדו להם .משום אדם אינן מוזכרים .וכן יאבדו כל אויבי ד' המחזקים דתי שקרים: שמקרוב מאלפיים שנה בדו מלבם הנוצרים .תלמידי ישו בן יוסף מעיר נוצר .ולזה מכונים בשם עירו נוצרים .ומלאו לבם אף נגד חז"ל לדבר סרה .עד שגרשו אותם ופרשו עצמם מעדת ישראל תישרה .ונתקו את מוסרותיהן .ושלחו מהם את עבותימו .ויתערבו בגויים ולמדו לשוניהם .עם מנהיגי כומריהם .כדי לגלות ולהורות להם איזו ממצות התורה הקדושה שהיתה עד העת הזאת בינינו מכל הגוים נסתרה .ולנו בכתב ובע"פ ממשה מפי הגבורה .כבת מלכות בבגדי כבודה ורוב תכשיטיה מסורה .במעמד הר סיני שמעו אבותינו קול הד' מדבר מסערה .עשרת הדברות שתלוים בהם כל מצות התורה שכתב משה ולמדה לאבותינו בביאורה .בע"פ להורות להם מהות ואיכות קביעת המצות במועדם וזמנם היא הגמרא .לבוש לתכשיטי' וקישוט' דבת מלך היא התורה שבע"פ .וברצות ד' אבאר עמ' 5
250
The Introduction to Divre binah by Dov Ber of Bolechów למטה משל מובן דומה לנמשל שהשיבותי לשר השואל: והנוצרים אלו תפסו התורה שבכתב ונביאים וכתובים לבדם .לשבי לידם .באין מבין ויודע שפר פירושם .וערומה מאמיתות קבלתם .ומפרשים בהם איזה פסוקים בשיבוש סברתם .על גואלם לחזק דתם .חיברו ספרים הרבה בלשונם ודפוסם בכדי שכל אחד מהם הקורא בהם יוכל לבזות דת בני ישראל ותורתם: והיות שמילדותי נתגדלתי בבית אדוני אבי בית מלון אורחים .לכל האומות שבסביבתינו עוברים ושבים .כבתל שהכל אליו פונים – למצוא מרגוע לנפשם .במאכל ובמשתה ושם לנים .וברוב היו ראשית שיחתם .נגד תורה שבע"פ ועדת ישראל ואמונתם: ובני ישראל נעלבים ואינם עולבים .שומעים חרפתם ואינם משיבים .על שלא היו בנו איש שדבר לשונם בלשון לימודים .דברתי תשובתינו אף שלפעמים נוצחת .מעשיהם לכלום נחשבת .ויען שבקטנותי הבינותי מדבריהם מגמתם .שישיב להם איזה איש יהודא על ספיקותם .בתשובה ניצחת אף נגד דתם .רק שיהי' לפי דרכי לימודם .ולשון שיחתם: ומאז רוח קנאה לבשתי .וגמרתי בלבי ובדעתי .להתאמץ בכל יכולתי .לחקור ולדרוש ללמוד בשלימת לשונם .כדי שאוכל לקרות גם בספריהם שונים .ממחבריהם האחרונים והקדמונים: ואחרי שבאיזה שעות פנויות דימי פגרא בזה יגעתי .תוכן ושורש דקדוקי לשונם מצאתי . אעפ"כ לקרות בספריהם בילדותי עמ' 6 יראתי .על שהם בעיני בני עמינו מאד מאוסים .ונקראים מאתנו ספרי פסולים לאומתם: עד שהגיע לידי ספר לחם יהודא שחיבר החכם הקדמון הרב ר' יהודא יודא בן ר' שמואל לירמה ספרדי ז"ל 106פירוש על מסכתא אבות בראותי הפירוש על מאמר ר' אליעזר הוי שקוד ללמוד תורה ודע מה שתשיב לאפיקורס 107וז"ל פירוש ענין שקידה הוא מלשון הכתוב כי שוקד אני על דברי כלומר מהיר ומשתדל .אז יהי' עניינו הרגל ותמידות וחשיבות כמו לשקוד על דלתותי יום יום .כוונת זה התנא לפרש לנו במשנתו זאת כוונתו במה שאמר למעלה שהדרך הטובה שידבק בה האדם הוא לב טוב ואמר שכוונתו בלב טוב לומר שיהי' לו לב חכם ונבון לב חד וחרוץ לפלפל ,וזה אי אפשר שיהי' כי אם במי שיעשה תורתו קבע ובשקידה רבה יתמיד לימודו וזהו אומרו הוי שקוד ללמוד תורה ואח"כ אמר ודע מה שתשיב לאפיקורס כלומר שאין כוונתו באזהרתו זאת כדי שישים האדם את עצמו במעלות שכליות וחריפות בהוראות התורה בלבד אלא כדי שידע גם כן מה שישיב את האפיקורס הכופר בפינות התוריות ומבזה את דברי חכמים המקיימים אותם צריך לידע מספריהם מקום טעותם ותמצא התשובה בצדה: כמבואר בסנהדרין פרק אחד דיני ממונות דף ל"ח ע"ב אמרו לא שנו שמאמר דר' אליעזר אלא אפיקורס מהאומות אבל אפיקורס ישראל כ"ש דפקיר טפי .אמר ר' יוחנן כל מקום שפקרו הצדוקים 108תשובתן בצדן .ופ' הרי"א ז"ל הוא ר' יצחק ארמעה בעל מחבר ספר עקידת עמ' 7 יצחק ז"ל 109שהסיבה לפי שהאפיקורס מהאומות לא ראה אור התורה ולכן ראוי הוא לחמול עליו ולדבר עמו בחן מליצות לשון לימודים ולהדריכו במעגלי צדק אולי יש תקוה בו .אמנם אפיקורס ישראל שכבר יודע דרכי התורה וכפר אין ראוי לדבר עמו משום ולפני עור לא תתן מכשול 110כי הוא יוסיף על חטאתו פשע .בהתווכחו עמו ויתקצף ויקלל במלכו ואלהיו ולכן מוטב לעזבו: .106ויניציאה :במצות אלויסי בראגאדין ,שי"ג; סביונטה :טוביה פואה ,שי"ד. .107רבי אלעזר ]בן ערך[ אומר :הוי שקוד ללמוד תורה; ודע מה שתשיב לאפיקורוס; ודע לפני מי אתה עמל ,ונאמן הוא בעל מלאכתך שישלם לך שכר פעולתך) .אבות פרק ב ,יד ,טו(. .108צ"ל מינים. .109שאלוניק :נדפס בבית דון יהודה לבית גדליה ,רפ"ב; ויניציאה :דפוס דניאל בומבירגי ,ש"ז; ויניציאה :דפוס אלויזי בראגדין ,שכ"ה; ויניציאה :נדפס בבית זואן דיגאה ,של"ג; פרנקפורט דאדר :דפוס אלמנת פראפעסר גרילא ,תקמ"ה. .110ויקרא יט :יד.
251
Gershon David Hundert ודע לפני מי אתה עמל ר"ל שכוונתו בזה ג"כ בזה שאמר שהדרך הטובה היא לב טוב הוא לומר שתהי' לאדם כזה כוונה טובה ולב טוב עם אלקים ועם אנשים יהודים ולהבדיל עם ערלים ואפיקורסי’ ובויכוחו עמהם תהי' כוונתו וכל מעשיו לשם שמים: ולא יאמר אדם מה תועלת יש לי במה שאפסיד זמני בעסק לימוד מה שאשיב לאפיקורס כ"ש שאני מכניס עצמי בסכנה אם נתוכח עמו ולא תעשה כן אם בעל נפש אתה .דע לשים כנ"ל עיניך לפני מי אתה עמל .שהוא הקב"ה ואם בן חייל אתה אף בטורח גדול לוחם מלחמתו ופירשו המפרשים ומי הוא בעל מלאכתך שהוא כחני ויכול ונאמן שישלם לך שכר פעולתיך: והרמב"ם ז"ל פ' וז"ל הוי שקוד ללמוד ודע מה שתשיב לאפיקורס אמר צריך שתלמוד דברים לפי דעת האומות שתשיב בהן לאפיקורסים מן האומות ותחלוק עליהם ותשיבם אם יקשו לך וכו' – ואמר אעפ" שתלמד דעות האומות לדעת איך תשיב עליהם השמר שלא יעלה בלבך דבר מן הדעות ההם ודע שמי שתעבוד לפניו יודע צפון לבך והוא אומרו ודע עמ' 8 לפני מי אתה עמל ר"ל שיכוון לבו באמונות הש"י עכ"ל הרמבם ז"ל :ופי' הרי"א ז"ל 111ואולי שאמר ודע לפני מי אתה עמל ג"כ על ענין הויכוח שלא יתווכח כי אם לפני דיין או שר ושופט שוה לשני הקצוות כי אז ישפוט בהויכוח צדק ומשפט מישרים ולא באופן אחר .וזהו ודע לפני מי אתה עמל ועם כל זה תבטח בבורא שהוא בעל מלאכתך שיעזרך באותו ויכוח ויתן לך שכר פעולתיך עכ"ל מהרי"א ז"ל: וכן משמע מהגמ' בבא קמא פרק מרודה ד' פ"ב ע"א של בית ר' גמליאל התירו להם לספר בחכמת יונית מפני שקרובים למלכות ומוכח שהוא איסורא כמבואר שם בגמ' שאסרו בארור מי שילמוד חכמת יונית והתירו בשעת הדחק .ומכ"ש וק"ו בדורותינו אלו שאנחנו יתומים מכל חכמה וקטנים מבינת אנשים ואמונתינו בשמו ית' מחולל מאד בגוים אלו בודאי אין שום אשם באם נדע להשיב על שאלתם בלשונם: ומ]א[חר שהודיעני ד' את כל זאת גמרתי בלבי לקרב אל המלאכה הנקלה הזאת אולי יתקדש שמו יתברך על ידי 112המחולל בגוים מכמה מאות שנים אלו הערלים מחללים שם שמים ומוצאים דבה ומחרפים ומגדפים את ספרי התלמוד קבלות האמת ודברי חז"ל הקדושים איש מפי איש מפי משה רבינו ע"ה מפי הגבורה בהר סיני קולו שמעו אבותינו מתוך האש עשרת הדברות ובהם תלוים התרי"ג מצות שבכתב עם כל המצות שבע"פ כולם למדו אבותינו מהר סיני בע"פ .עד אחר חורבן ביהמ"ק השני הוכרח רבינו ר' יהודא הנשיא ז"ל להתחיל לכתוב גם המשנה שהיתה כמה אלפים שנה בע"פ עמ' 9 ואח"ז נכתבו גם הלכות התלמוד מפי חכמינו התנאים ז"ל כמבואר בהרמב"ם ז"ל בסדר הקבלות שלו וגם בספר הקבלות להראב"ד הלוי ז"ל 113:וביותר כבוד הרב הגאון הרמב"ן ז"ל בהקדמתו לפירושו על שיר השירים ביאר בקיצור נמרץ בסדר נכון הקבלות מאדם הראשון עד זמנו בנגלה ובנסתר כאשר קיבל מרבותיו ז"ל .ופירושו זה נדפס בק"ק אלטונא ע"י התורני מהור"ר יצחק במו' שמעון ז"ל בשנת תקכ"ב לפ"ק עיי"ש :וכן שאר מחקרים מחכמינו ז"ל שכתבו לנו סדר קבלות האמתיות מפי אבותינו הקדושים איש מפי איש עד אדם הראשון קבלתינו מאב לבנו ממש :ולא כן אלו הגוים בני אדום והמאמינים בדת נוצרים ובני ישמעאל .111יצחק אברבנאל. .112וראו גם זכרונות ,עמ' :87ואנחנו בני ישראל מחוייבים לידע הכל .שיתקיים בנו מאמר הכתוב 'כי היא חכמתכם ובינתכם לעיני העמים' )דברים ד’ ו"( ואף גם שפסוק זה מפרשים חכז"ל על תורתנו הק' ,אבל אמרו שטוב תורה עם דרך ארץ ,וטוב לכל איש בר ישראל החכם ומבין דבר ,שידע אף ממעשה אומות העולם ,ומתוך זה יתרחש לו לפעמים שיוכל להשיב להם כהוגן על שאלתם נגד הדת והאמונת ישראל ,כאשר הקרה לי כמה פעמים בדברי עם גדולי האומות וכומריהם ,ומצאתי ברוב התשובה בצדו כידוע לכל שתשובתי תמיד נצחת היתה. .113אברהם בן דוד מפושקירה . 1120–1197
252
The Introduction to Divre binah by Dov Ber of Bolechów ודת מחמט שמכונים בשם תורניים על שיש לנוצרים נוסח תורת משה ונביאים בביבליאה שלהם והיא אינה מוגהה ומזוייפת מראשה לסופה באשר שקיבלו אותה מעמים שונים מעותקה מלשונות רבים ע"י זייפנים הכומרים שלהם במשך זמן רב קרוב לשני אלפים שנים וכל עם ועם זייפו בה עד שכולה מזוייפת בידם ערומה ומפושטה מכל פירוש וקבלת אמת :וכן הישמעאלים כת מחמט הנ"ל אף שיש באלקראן שלהם קצת מתורת משה ג"כ מזוייף ומעורב עם לימודי שקרים דמחמט הנביא שקר שלהם .ולפני אלו השנים ישו' ומחמט יצאו מכלל דת עמ' 10 ישראל גחזי 114תלמיד אלישע הנביא כאשר נטרד בקללות רבו הנ"ל התרחק מארץ ישראל והלך עם שלשה בניו למקום שאינן מכירים אותו ובאו עד מדינת פרס ומדי והתייסד שמה אמונת שתי רשויות לעובדים לאש ונתן להם ספר המצות לאמונה זו כאשר מבואר לקמן כל מעשיו ופקודותיו שהעתקתי מספרי האומות מלשונם חול ללשונינו לשון הקודש שיהי' למראה עיני בני ישראל: כאשר דרשתי וחקרתי ביכולתי לדעת כל ספריהם ועיקורי יסודי קבלתיהם לאמונתיהם .הרבה מספריהם בעיני ממש קראתי ומצאתי רובם ככולם שקרים והבלים .מלאים דברי דופי ושטותים גדולים .מספרים שניסים ונפלאות שראו בעיניהם .בכל דור מאנשיהם .שבדרשתם אשר אי אפשר אף לאיש נכרי בר שכל שיאמין בזאת .ובפרט אנחנו בני ישראל מאמינים בני מאמינים ויודעים את ד' מקבלות אמתיות מאבותינו הק' כנ"ל אי אפשר לשום אחד מאתנו אף להקל שבקלים שיכנסו בלבו אלו אמונות הכוזבות: והנה גם אלו ספרי און גליון דהנוצרים עצמם מחזקים תורת משה ומעידים שישו הנוצרי עצמו העיד שהוא בא לקיים תורת משה ולא לבטלו ח"ו כמבואר באיזה מקומות בספריהם הנ"ל. מאטיאש קפיטל ה' פסוק יז 115ושאלתי זאת להכמר פיקולסקי בעל מחבר ספר רשעת 116 היהודים בלשון פוליש זלאסץ זידאווסקי והוא מזכיר שאלתי זו בספרו הנ"ל עמוד תל"ה. והכריח עצמו להשיב על שאלה זו עמ' 11 והגיד להרשיע הרבה דברי שטותים ופתיות באין מענה לשאלתי זו :אשר גם כבר הרב ר' יצחק בן ר' אברהם ז"ל בעל המחבר ספר חיזוק אמונה העתיק בחלק שני מספרו זה ללשון הקודש הרבה מאמרים באון גליון וספרי שלוחי ישו' המה אפאסטאליס כולם מחזקים תורת משה ומצוים לקיים המצות שבה .עיין ותמצא איך הרב המחבר הנ"ל התאסף בכל יכולתו לקרות כל ספרי דתיהם ובודאי מקנאת הד' עשה זאת בכדי שידעו בני ישראל להשיבם .וכן עשה כנראה בספרו חיזוק אמונה הנ"ל שכתוב הרבה טענות חזקות נגדם טעותיהם שמפרשים בספריהם איזה פסוקים מהנביאים על ישו' וממש מיום התחדשות זה הדת הזאת לא עמד איש מאתנו נגדם כמו זה הרב ז"ל המחרפם ומגדפם ומוכיחם על פניהם בפתיות אמונתם מעיקרה: וכן עשה גם הרב ר' ליפמאן בעל המחבר ספר נצחון ברוב בקיאות בספרי חז"ל ולהבדיל באון גליון שלהם נצח הרבה נגדם .ואחריהם גם הרב ר' טובי' הרופא בספרו מעשי טוביה וכן כמה וכמה הקדמונים מחכמינו ז"ל לא יכלו לסבול עול הגלות ובזיונות ושפלות אשר אלו העבדים בני חם פוט וכנען 117כולם המה וכומריהם עובדי פסילים הערלים הטמאים מדי יום מוצאים דבת שקרים על בני ישראל לפני המלכות ושררות ודוכסים המושלים ולפני עם הארצות .114וארבעה אנשים היו ְמֹצָרִעים .זה גחזי ושלשת בניו )סוטה מז ,א( .שלושת הבנים נצטרעו כתוצאה מקללתו של אלישע )מל"ב ה ,כז( .גחזי הוא אחד מארבעה הדיוטות שאין להם חלק לעוה"ב )משנה סנהד' צ ,א(. " .115אל תחשבו שבאתי לבטל את התורה ,או את הנביאים ,לא באתי לבטל כי אם לקיים". 116. Gaudenty Pikulski, Złość żydowska Przeciwko Bogu y bliźniemu Prawdzie y Sumnieniu na obiaśnienie Talmudystów. Na dowód ich zaślepienia, y Religii dalekiey od prawa Boskiego przez Moyżesza danego. Rozdzielona na trzy części opisana (Lwów, 1760). .117דברי הימים א' א:ח.
253
Gershon David Hundert עמ' 12 במדינות והארצות האראפי בדרשם לפניהם בדברים וגם במכתב מדי יום יום מדפיסים הרבה ספרים כדי לעורר שנאת המושלים והמון עם נגדינו: אמנם אחר זה מכמה מאות שנה בדו הכומרים מרוח רעה ורוח שקר שבקרבם איך היהודים אינם יכולים לאכול המצות בפסח לא דם נוצרים .ולזה גונבים את בניהם ושוחטים אותם להוציא דמם ולאכול עם המצה בלילה הראשונה ]![ של פסח ונותנים טעם לזה בסברה נבערה ומאוד זרה שדם הילד נוצרי זה הנשפך חנם יכפר ליהודים על דם ישו הנוצרי שנשפך בירושלים חנם: ויותר מזה היו מעלילים איך שהיהודים קונים הלחם מגואל בדמים יקרים מבית תפלתם .כדי לחרף ולגדף אמונתם .והנוצרי עצמו כאשר המה מאמינים שהלחם זה הוא גופו של ישו' גואל שלהם .ומפני עלילות שטותות ובלבולי שקרים .ומראים כאלו במשך אלף וכמה מאות שנים מעת התיסדות הכומרים בע"ז לאמונתם זאת בארצות ומלכיות בחלק אראפי נהרגו והומתו במיתות משונים וענוים קשים ומרים כמה וכמה רבוי והרבה ורבבות בעוה"ר מגדולי יחוסי גאונים גדולים רבנים מופלגים ראשים וקצינים מבני ישראל הקדושים שסבלו ענוים הקשים והיסורים המשונים מגוים אלו האכזרים ומתו עמ' 13 על קדושת שמו יתברך הגדול והנורא והוא ינקום את דמם וירחם את שארית ישראל אשר לא עשו עולה כזו מעולם לכל הגוים שהיו בארצם מיום הנטשם מעל אדמתם: ומי יוכל לשער גודל הדאגות והצער בשארית בני ישראל השרוים ביגונים ואנחות רבות ובשברי לבבות .על אחיהם העומדים בצרות רעות .אשר גם בימי נעורי מדי יום ממש היו מבהלים אותנו באלו בשורות רעות .ולא טובות השמועות .מקהלות בני עמינו העומדים באלו הסכנות .בדברי אלו בלבולי’ שקרים .המעלילים עליהם כומרי הנוצרים .לא לבד ממקומות רחוקים .אלא אף בכמה קהילות שמאתנו סמוכים רצו הגוים להעליל כזאת ומהשמים נצלו ברוב הפלאות .כאשר אכתוב ברצות הד' כל המאורעות .שהקרו לבני עמינו .במשך ימי חיינו .באלו ארצות עד מקום שידיעתי מגעת אמרתי חובה היא עלינו .להודיע לבני ישראל הבאים אחרינו .מרוב הצרות והתלאות המרות שסבלו בני עמינו באבדם הרבה נפשות יקרות .ואיזה שניצלו בפרוע פרעות .על לא חמס .אודיע לכם כל הקורות .שלא יאמרו הבאים אחרינו בדורות .שהימים הראשונים היו טובים מאלו .לא מחכמה זאת ישאלו .אך בחסרון עמ' 14 ידיעתם .מהמאורעות שהסיבו לאבותם .בימי מגוריהם .תחת ממשלת האומה זו בארצותם . וביותר בדברי אלו הבלבולי שקרים .שזכרתי והאמינו עם הפולין המושלים עם כומריהם – מיום התחדש אמונתם זאת בארצם כאשר מצאתי בספר דברי הימים למלכי פולין בלשון פוליש כתובים כמה מאורעות בלבולי שקרים כאלו מדם ולחם מגואל והעתקתי ללשונינו הקודש בביאור כל אחד מהבלבולים בדמים .מכמה מאות שנים .עד שנת התקי"ט: אחר המאורע המפורסמות שהכריחו רבני ופרנסי בני ישראל לעמוד ולהשיב להפוקר ורשע מפורסם יעקב בן ליב מק"ק קראלוקע ואביב היה בעל מלאכות היין שרף היינו ווייניר כאשר הודה בעצמו לפני הכומרים דההגמון בעיר קאמנעץ כמבואר למטה יעקב פרענקי וסייעתו עדה הרעה הזאת המייחסים את עצמם לכת המאמינים בפוקר הקדמון שלהם שבתי צבי ימ"ש שבגמטריתו עולה מספר אותיותיו תתי"ד והן עולין מספר רו"ח שק"ר וכן נעשה עמו ועם הבאים אחריו ונתוודע לעולם בכל דור ודור שקרותו וכן כל אחד שקמו ברשעתו אחריו המירו דתם בדת מחמט בק"ק סאליניקי כאשר הוא המיר דתו בקוסטנטינא עמ' 15 עד ימי הפוקר יעקב פרענק שאמר שבא בגלגול שבתי צבי הנ"ל והוכרחו כולם להמיר דתם בדת נוצרים כאשר אבאר ואכתוב כל המעשים שבימי ולעיני ממש נעשו לנו ולבני ישראל נסים ונפלאות ותשועות גדולות נגד אלו המשומדים אחרי שאעתיק קודם כל התחלות טעותם דהמאמינים בפוקר הראשון שבתי צבי ימש"ו כאשר מצאתי בספרים שונים שכתבו כמה
254
The Introduction to Divre binah by Dov Ber of Bolechów וכמה מהרבנים הגדולים בכל דור ודור כאשר אזכיר כל אחד בשמו במקומו .בהעתקתי מספרו דכ"א כל המאורעות כסדרן .ורוב ההרפתקאות דעדו להם עמהם בזמניהם: ואיך גם אנחנו בזמנינו ברחמי שמים .נצלו מרשעות ומלשינות שקרים .עלינו ועל ספרי התלמוד הקדושים .שפסקו הכומרים לשרפם ונצלו ברוב חסדי המקום עלינו .ועד היום כל התלמוד עם כל מפרשיו כמאז ומקדם הוא בתקפו בידינו .ולא ימוש מפינו ומפי זרעינו . מעתה ועד עולם: הגם מאז אחרי תשובתו האחרונה דהרב המאוה"ג הגאון כבוד מוהר"ר חיים כ"ץ רפפורט ז"ל אב"ד דק"ק לבוב והגליל יצ"ו על קושייתם האחרונה מאכזריות רשעתם נגד ספרי התלמוד . ומאותה שעה ממש נתוודע ראש הכומרים שקרות עלילות דם על היהודים מה שנראה בחוש מדברי המגומגמים דהמלשינים עצמם .ואחרי שנדפסו תשובת כבוד הרב המאוה"ג הנ"ל בשנת תק"כ לפ"ק בספר רשעת היהודים בלשון עמ' 16 פוליש .הכירו וידעו כל הגוים דעם פולין שעלילות דם על היהודים מעיקרא שקר היו .ומעת הזאת ת"ל לא נשמע יותר במדינות פולין שום דיבור מזה עוד .ואדרבה לחרפת הגוים היא האמונה הזאת להם: ועתה תחת ממשלת אדונינו האדיר החסיד יוזיף השני הק' יר"ה אשר כבודו נתגלה בכל מדינות וממשלת מלכותו שכל עלילת דם על היהודים המה שקרים וכזבים .וחלילה לשום שר ושופט להאמין כזאת על בני ישראל בקנסים עצומים: וגם שכעת קמו מהגוים .חכמים גדולים .ומלומדים מאוד ויודעים מהרבה ספרים קדמונים וישנים .ובגביה חקירתם .כתבו הרבה נגד עכו"ם .וביותר נגד הנוצרים .ומכחישים כל סיפורי מעשיהם .לגמרי באמרם שכל סיפורי הנסים .שבתורתם החדשה שלהם .שקוראים און גליון המה רחוקים להאמין .שנעשו נגד הטבע .וכן גם חז"ל אמרו אין הנס יוצא בדרך הטבע .והנה אם עיקר אמונתם מוכחשה – בודאי כל סכלות סברתם שכוזבה .מעלילות דם וכן מצאו הרבה מעשיות מעלילות אלו ויצאו היהודים זכאים מפי פסקים חרוטים וחתומים ממלכים קדמונים ויועציהם והרבה הגו כבר בפיוסים ות"ל אין שטן ופגע רע לבני עמינו מעת התחלת ממשלת המלכים הנ"ל ,ויתן ד' עד ביאת הגואל לא יאונה לנו שום רע: עמ' 17 אך מדאגה מדבר שבנינו הבאים אחרינו בדורות .לא ידעו ולא יזכירו מהקורות .שסבלנו צרות רבות ותלעות ]![ רעות .מהאומות לגוייהם באלו הארצות .כמה וכמה רבוי רבבות מבני עמינו הפרנסים – צדיקים וחסידים .גאוני ארץ מיוחסים וקצינים .על לא חמס בכפיהם – הוכרחו לעזוב חיי שעה ולילך לחיי עולמים .והומתו ונהרגו במיתות משונות וסבלו עינויים קשים ומרים .ומסרו נפשם על קדושת השם .ולא שמעו לקול הכומרים המסיתים לע"ז ומבטיחים בדברי שטותם עוה"ז ועוה"ב ומאסו בחייהם .ובחרו לעשות רצון קונם וחפץ צורם .באשר כתוב אי"ה למטה בביאור כל אחד איזו בשמם ואיזו במקמם .ובאיזה מהסיב' לבדו כאשר מצאתי בספריהם ספורי דברי הימים שלהם בלשון אשכנז ופוליש .וארשום אצל כל מעשה שם הערל המחבר הכותב: ובכל זאת שמו ית' לא שכחו .ובתורתו דבקו .ולא ויתרו ממנה אות או נקודה אחת מתורה שבכתב ושבע"פ .קיימו וקבלו קדמונינו ז"ל על עצמם ועל הבאים אחריהם כתורה עצמה . ואפילו מנהג הקל שקבלו עליהם קדמונינו ז"ל קיימו וקבלו על עצמם כתורה כמאמר חז"ל מנהג של ישראל הוא כתורה .ולזה לא ויתרו בני ישראל אזהרה קטנה ואפי' חק הקל נזהרו לנהוג בו בלבד שלא יהא כחוקת הגויים .ובפרט במלבושים .ובשאר ענינינו .תמיד היה כוונת קדמונינו .החז"ל להבדיל אותנו מן העמים .שנהי' אנחנו ניכרים .מבין הגוים .אף שתמיד היתה עמ' 18 שאת ההיכרות לבני עמינו לבוז ולשפלות .אבל אף לכפרת עונות .כי זה הוא עיקר הגלות הממרק עונות .בני ישראל כבשורות ד' לאברהם כי גר יהי' זרעך בארץ לא להם בעוה"ר
255
Gershon David Hundert כדי שירשו חיים נצחיים לעוה"ב – גם כמאמר הגמרא יאה גלותא לישראל בורזא סומקא לסוסיא 118 חיורא: ולטעם זה לא שינו בני ישראל לבושיהם בהיותם בגלות ארצות אשכנזי במשך אלף שנים ויותר . עד שיצאו מערי ארצות אלו רובם ברשות עצמם ובחרו להם ארץ פלניא מדינתינו ארץ ציה ושוממה וריקה מכל סחורות יפות ומזהב וכסף ובני ישראל הביאו כל טוב לכאן במטמונות רבות .ובהתפשרם עם דוכסי ושרי יועצי מדינה בק"ק קראקא ואז לא הי' מלך בפולין רק י"ב וויווידס משלו ואלו קבלו את היהודים הראו להם את כל עשרם וגם לוו מהם שלשים מליאן זהב פוליש בתנאי כאשר אבאר לקמן וזה הי' תנאי מפורש שהיהודים ישארו תמיד בתבנית מלבושיהם שבאו לכאן .וכך נהגו עד זמננו זה ובשום דבר לא התערבו בני ישראל במדינה זו בגוים לא לבד במלבושים אף גם בלשונם מאסו לדבר בדברים המיוחדים שביניהם שמשו לשון אשכנזי בלי שום דבר אחד מלשונות רוסיש או פוליש .ובפרט בעסקי עבודות הבורא הבדלנו ד' מכל העמים ברוב חסדיו שרשות ניתן לנו תמיד בכל דור ודור מכל מלכות וממשלה מעמי הארצות שיכולים בני ישראל לעבוד את הבורא לפי דת אמונתינו בכל מקום שיהי' נמצאים שם עשרה אנשים .וגם הורשו כל אחד מהשררות במדינות עמ' 19 פולין לבנות להיהודים בתי כנסיות לתפילות בנינים מפוארים וחשובים הנקראים מאתנו בית המקדש מעט: והורגלו כל קהלות קדושות לבא לאלו בית הכנסתות להתפלל ערבית ושחרית בלבוש מיוחד לתפלה הנקרא מבני עמינו לעטניק ראק ועל ראשו כובע המכונה ברייטיל .ומצאנו בספר ישן ממחבר ספר מעלת המדת קדמון ספרדי הטעם למלבושים אלו הוא על שכל עבודת בית המקדש הגדול שהי’ לנו בירושלים נעשה ע"י הכהנים בני אהרן מלובשים בבגדי כהונה והקריבו את תמידינו וקרבנותינו בבגדי קודש ובצאתם לחוץ מהמקדש לבשו בגדים אחרים לשמושי חול .וכעת שאין לנו לא מקדש ולא מזבח ולא כהן לעבודה תקנו לנו אנשי כנסת הגדולה מאה ועשרים זקינים וביניהם חג]א[י זכרי' ומל]א[כי הנביאים סדר התפילות במקום הקרבנות כידוע לכל יודעי ספר והביה"כ במקום מקדש מעט ולטעם זה נהגו קדושי עמינו ללבוש בעת תפילתם בביה"כ הק' לבוש מיוחד לעטניק עם הברייטיל הנ"ל שיעבוד עבודתו בתפילתו ככהן בלבוש מיוחד לתפלה וכן נהגו כל ישראל במדינות אשכנזי ומעהרין וכל בני ישראל שבקהלות הגדולות שבארץ פולין גדול וקטן במשך כמה מאות שנים עד זמנינו זה קהלות הישנות נוהגין במלבושים אלו כתורה להם שזה חילוקא דרבנן .ועוד אפשר שכשם שבגדי כהונה היו מכפרים כמבואר במדרש ויקרא רבה פי' למה נסמכו בגדי כהונה אצל פרשת הקרבנות לומר לך מה הקרבנות עמ' 20 מכפרין אף בגדי כהונה מכפרים מבואר שם 119כל בגד ובגד על מה הי' מכפר ואם הקרבנות והבגדים מכפרים כשם שהתפלות המה לנו לזכרון במקום הקרבנות כן צריך לנו לאלו הבגדים להתפלל בהם לזכרון בגדי כהונה שהיו מכפרים שנאמר בהם חוקת עולם לדורותם אך כאשר נתיישבו מבני ישראל גם בהרבה מקומות במדינות פאדאלי ואקיריינע הצפונים לארץ פולין שמשם פתחו הרע פעמים ליושביהם מחמת מרידת עם הקאזאקין שבכל דור ודור חמסו ורצחו והרגו כמה ריבוי רבבות מבני ישראל .לכן לא נתיישב שם שום אדם חשוב וספון מבני ישראל כי אם איזה מדלת עם הארץ שלא הי' להם שום מחי' בקהלות הישנות הלכו להם על הבטחות השררות דהמקומות החדשים שנתיישבו ובנו להם בתים ובתי כנסיות לתפלה ובתי מדרשים ללומדי תורה וכן נהגו ולמדו בתוה"ק בגמפ"ת בפלפולים חריפים .118חגיגה טב :יאה עניותא ליהודאי כי ברזא סומקא לסוסיא חיורא. .119מדרש ויקרא רבה ,ערך מרדכי מרגליות )ירושלים תשי"ד( ,רי.ריא )י ,ו(.
256
The Introduction to Divre binah by Dov Ber of Bolechów וחדים וגם במקרא ומשנה עם כל המפרשים הש"ס והמקרא ועם שאר ספרי תוכחות ליראים שבידיהם במשך כל ימי הזקנים תלמידי חכמים שהאריכו ימים שמה אחרי בואם לשם עבדו את ד' כפי מנהגי קהלות ישראל שיצאו משם .ואחריהם קם דור אחר אשר לא ראו ולא ידעו ממנהגי בני ישראל שבקהלות הישנות ועזבו הרבה מהם שהיו לישראל כתורה עצמה אינם חוששין למנהגים אלו ואינם מתקינים לעצמם מלבושים הנ"ל להתפלל בהם בביה"כ הק' אך באיזה בגד שהוא יוצא כל היום לשוק באלו הוא מתפלל עמ' 21 ולומד אם היא בר הכי בלי חלוקא דרבנן הנ"ל: ורעה גדולה מזו שגם פסקו התלמידי חכמים שבדורינו ללמוד התלמוד בפלפולי חריפתא כמנהגם היו מקדמת דנא' .ומאז גם בימי בחרותי בעיני ראיתי .וגם למדתי מפי רבותי ז"ל בכל התחלת הזמן דף גמרא המובחר מהרב אב"ד מרא דאתרא באיזה משיטות התלמוד עם כל מפרשי הש"ס והתאמצו התלמידים כ"א לפי השגתו לחדש איזה דבר בסברות הגמרא והמפרשים .ומתחילה עמד הרב עצמו ודרש לפנינו ברוב בקיאותו .וגודל חריפותו .מה שחידש בסוגיות התלמוד זה הנ"ל .ואחריו כל יתר הלומדים ומהתלמידים חידשו כ"א כפי השגתו בפלפולו .ובני עשירים היו מאספים את כל הלומדים לכבדם בביתיהם במיני מרקחת ומשקה י"ש ונהגו כן בכל תפוצות ישראל הרבה שנים אף במשך ימי חיי בהיותי בבית אבי ז"ל ישב על כסא הרבנות דק"ק באלחוב הרב המאוה"ג הגאון רבינו יעקב המכונה ר' יוקל בהרב המאוה"ג מוהר"ר מאיר זצ"ל הורוויץ ואחריו בנו הרב המאוה"ג הגאון מוהר"ר מרדכי ז"ל .ואחריהם הרב . המאוה"ג מוהר"ר משה סג"ל זצ"ל כלם למדו חילוקים בגמ' כנ"ל .וגם אלו הרבנים שהיו לפניהם החזיקו ישיבות ואף בביאתי אחרי נישואין שלי בשנת תק"ד ]צ"ל תק"ב?[ לפ"ק לק"ק טיסמניץ מצאתי שם עיר מליאה תלמידי חכמים לסופרים ועל גביהם חונה הרב המאוה"ג הגאון מוהר"ר מאנש זצ"ל שהיה מקדם אב"ד עמ' 22 בק"ק פולינאה ומפיו למדתי כמה חילוקים במסכתא כתובות וגיטין: ובאותו הזמן יצא לאור ספר חמדת הימים דפוס קאסטאנטינא 120וקנו אותן הספרים לביהמ"ד דק"ק טיסמניץ בעד שלשה אדומי' 121ועל שזה המחבר מורה לעם סגולות הלימוד בספרי הקבלה ברזין דאורייתא נתייאשו הרבה מהתלמידים מלימוד ש"ס התלמוד ומפרשיהם בפלפולא חריפתא אך אחרי שלמדו קצת מקרא בתורת משה ואפס קצהו מלשון המש' ופוסקים תיכף מתחילים לחקור רזין דאורייתא מפי המקובלים המה החסידים או בעלי השמות שמקדם היו מתייחסים לקדמוניהם שם זה והי' מתפארים אותם ומספרים מהם נסים ונפלאות שפעלו בקבלה מעשיות לרפאות חולים בקמיעות ולגרוש דבוקים רעים מבני אדם בהשבעות הרוחניים של מעלה איך שידעו שמותם ושמושם דכל אחד במשמרתו וכל העם היו יראים מהם ומהיזיקות השדים קטנים וגדולים מפחדים היו לצאת יחידים בלילה כאשר אבאר ברצות ד' איזה מעשיות מזה שאירעו בימינו .ומה שראיתי בעיני כמה אנשים מבני עמינו שנדבקו בהם רוח ואמרו שזה הוא רוח הכופרים שנשתמדו לדת הגוים כאשר מפילים עצמם לפני בתי כנסיות הק' בעת קריאת התורה בשבתות וב"ב ו"ה ומכין את עצמם באבנים גדולים מכות אכזריות על החזה ולפי הנראה אי אפשר לשום אדם לסבול מכות מות כאלו כאשר אני בעצמי בימי בחרותי .מן המתמיהים הייתי: עמ' 23 עד שבהיותי בלבוב פגע בי חד מאלו הבעלי שמות אשר כבר הי' מיודעי ומכירי מקדם והפקיד תחת ידי ארגז או קופערט מלא ספרים וכתבים והתרה באזהרה גדולה למשרתי ואנשי ביתי שלא יגעו ולא יטלטלו הקופערט הנ"ל בכדי שלא יזיק איזה בהם שינהג בזיון להשמות הקדושים שבו .120תצ"ה -תצ"ז )יצא בזולקווא :בתק"ב ותק"ו(. 54 .121זלוטי – סכום גדול.
257
Gershon David Hundert אחר נתוודע לנו שאין בזה ממש ודבריו שקרים כאשר אבאר אי"ה איך שהודה בעצמו וסיפר לי איזה מתחבולותיו שעשה הוא עצמו לרמאות את הבריות וגם הרבה תחבולות שהמצאו שארי בעלי שמות בהשתדלותם להונות את העם להעלות מוראות בלבבם מפחד הזיקות השדים: וזה נתוודע לי בשנת תקי"ח ותקי"ט ונתאמת לי שאין לנו לבני אדם אף לגוים ליראה מהזיקות השדים שהרבה מהקדמונים מסופקים ואיזה מהם גם מכחישים מצאותם כמו הרמב"ם ז"ל ושאר חכמי המחקרים ז"ל מאומתינו בחיבוריהם הרחבים והמרובים אינם מזכירים משום הזיקות לבני אדם מסיבות השדים כמו הרב המחקר החכם הגדול מוהר"ר יצחק בעל עקידה ז"ל ,ורבינו בחיי בחובת הלבבות ויתר המחקרים הקדמונים והאחרונים אינו כותבים לנו שום דבר באיזה מאורע לסכנה לבני אדם מסיבות רוחות רעות ויראה מזה שגם לקדמונינו ז"ל לא הי' שום פחד ודאגה מסיבתם רק מזהירים אותנו להאמין בהשגחות שמו יתברך השומר אותנו מכל מקרה רעה ומי שאינו מאמין בהשגחותו ד' עלינו ועל כל בריאותיו בפרטות הוא כופר מוחלט ומסיר מעצמו השגחות השמים ונעזב למקרים רעים המה אוירים ורוחות המנשבים עמ' 24 122 בארץ בתמידות ובהשגחות השמים המה לרפואה לצדיקים ולסכנה לפושעים כמאמר חז"ל לעתיד אין גיהנם אלא הקב"ה מוציא חמה מנרתיקה ודן בה הרשעים והצדיקים מתעדים בה . וזה הוא שהנביאים מעידים הנה יום ד' בא בוער כתנור וגו' ורבים מישיני אדמת עפר יקיצו אלה לחיי עולם ואלה לדראון ולחרפת עולם ואינו מוזכר משום שד ומזיק – אך אך החטאים גורמים שהאויר יזיק לרשעים ולרפואה לצדיקים: והנה זה קרוב לשלשים שנה או יותר שלא נשמע מנזקי השדים לבני אדם ולא ממצאותם במפולת הבתים הישינים אשר בני אדם הי' יראים לגשת ולקרב לבית המתועב מהם .והרבה שנראה להם כנגע זאת בבית רדפו אחרי אלו הבעלי שמות להביאם בכדי שיגרשו בהשבעות בשמות הקדושים את אלו הקליפות ובחמלת הד' עלינו נפקחו עיני בני אדם ונתוודע בעולם שקרות הבעלי שמות ופעולתם בהם כוזבות .ומאז אחר שנאבדו אלו הבעלי שמות עם ספריהם המרובים ורזיהם וסודותיהם להבל דמו הנה גם השדים המזיקים לא נראו יותר ולא ירעו ולא ישחיתו ולא יזיקו לשום אדם בר ישראל קטן וגדול אף גם משום גוי הארצות לא נראה מהם שום דבר קל אחר .ומעת ממשלת אדוננו האדיר הקיסר יר"ה מפחד שרי צבאותיו .שבאו עם חיילותיו .המרובים ברחו להם השדים כולם לגמרי מאלו הארצות. והבעלי שמות החליפו את שמותם בשם חסידים: עמ' 25 ומרביצים תורתם מהרזין ודברי קבלה שבסודות התורה שבידם לתלמידים שלא למדו ממש כלום מהתורה שנמסרה לנו בע"פ ע"י משה רבינו ע"ה מהר סיני והוא התלמוד הקדוש שבידינו .המקובל מאבותינו .ומפי הגבורה מסיני ואלו אינן חוששין ללימודו .להבין עומקי חכמתו .בהלכותיו ובדברי משליו ומוסריו .בתוכחות מגולות לבני אדם באגדותיו . כאשר ביאר לנו הרבה מזה הרב המאוה"ג המחבר מוהר"ר שמואל אידלש בחיבורו מהרש"א ז"ל בחידושי אגדות שלו ושאר מחברים קדמונים ז"ל הרבה מאוד מפרשים דברי אגדות התלמוד בנגלה ובנסתר בחכמות מפוארות לאין מספר: ובני עמינו החסידים נ"י אינם לומדים מזה .הגם מהלכות הפסוקות לנו מפלפולי התלמוד אינם לומדים מזה כלום לידע מאיסור והיתר רק מה שמוכרחים לידע להראות להבריות שהנהגתם הוא כדת הש"ע וגם אינם יודעים כלום מהדינים הנמצאים בזוהר היות שאינן לומדים בו כלום ולא בשאר ספרי המוסרים והמחקרים הקדמונים והאחרונים שבידינו המפרשים לנו דברי תורתינו ודברי הנביאים והכתובים הקדושות בחכמות מפוארים וקבלות אמתיות שהי' להם בכתב ובע"פ מפי קדמונינו הקדושים: .122משנה עבודה זרה א' ג:ב :דאמר רבי שמעון בן לקיש אין גיהנם לעתיד לבא אלא הקדוש ברוך הוא מוציא חמה מנרתיקה ומקדיר :רשעים נידונין בה וצדיקים מתרפאין בה.
258
The Introduction to Divre binah by Dov Ber of Bolechów וקהל החסידים הראשיים מכמה שנים היו מתנצלים את עצמם שאין להם שעה פנוי' ללמוד מחמת הכנתם לתפילתם בכוונות וטהרות גופם במי מקוה ומחשבתם במקטרתם הוא הלולקי שביד כ"א מקטר ומעלה עשן להס"ם עמ' 26 הוא הקליפה ויצר הרעה המתגרה באלה הגדולים וטעם לזה אבאר ברצות ד' מה שמצאתי בספר ישן שחיבר חכם אחד מחכמי ספרדיים למה רוב העולם יהודים ולהבדיל ערלים קטנים וגדולים מתמידים לקטר תמיד עשב הטבאק .ואף שכוונתם להתנהג כמאמר חז"ל 123הצדיקים הראשונים היו שוהין שעה אחת ואחרי כך מתפללין .ובזה מאחרים לפעמים זמן תפלת שחרית ומנחה גומרים עם צאת הכוכבים מה שהוא נגד פסקי ודיני הש"ע דהרב הב"י קרא ז"ל .אשר כל בני הגולה בכל קצוי הארצות קימו וקיבלו עליהם זה כמה מאות שנים בעודו הרב זה הי' בחיים חיותו נדפסו הארבעה ש"ע שלו בק"ק ווינעציע בדפוס דניאל בומברגי המדפיס הראשון .ומאז ועד עתה לא נוסף ולא נגרע שום דין מהוראותיו ופסקיו .אך כל ישראל נוהגים באורחותיו ומקיימים כל מצות התורה לפי דבריו .כמצווים לנו מהר סיני מפי הגבורה .כאשר הוא האחרון מבעלי הוראות שקדמוהו .כמו הטורים והאלפסי ויתר ספרי הפוסקים הקדמונים .שבידי רבנים המורים בצדק שלנו .ולא וויתר שום אחד דבר קל מדברי הש"ע: הגם הרבה מנהגי ישראל שהמה לנו כתורה ואלו האלופים החסידים אינן רוצים לנהוג בהם ומי יתן והי' גם בזאת כוונתם ליראת שמים ולא להתפאר בחסידותו כאשר הרבה מגדוליהם אלה ברבם ואלה בסוסים הולכים בשיירות גדולות ממשרתים ותלמידים הרבה הרצים לפניהם לשבחם ולפאר אותם בפני עמ' 27 המון עם הסכלים מספרים עליהם איך מופלגים בחסידות .ויוכל להגיד לכל איש שיחו ביודעו העתידות .ולגלות סודות .והמון עם ישראל בני יעקב שיראתם קודמת לחכמתם .יראים ובחלים מעונם שבידם מפחידים שלא יגלו עונם וקלונם לרבים מביאים דורונות ומתנות בסחר לידם ומבקשים ברכתם המה ונשיהם ובניהם אף שאינן יודעים אם אלו החסידים בני תורה המה ושלמים בתורה שבכתב ושבע"פ הנתונה לנו יחד מהר סיני .יען שכל מגמתם לידע נסתרות וחפצם לחקור אחר רזין דאורייתא .אשר מגלים לעצמם בהתאספם יחד לבית הגדול שבהם לשבוע עמו בסעודת שלישית דשבת ואז נתקיים בהם הברכה לשובע ולא לרזון .ובאמת ששום אחד מהם לא יודע עד מה מסודות: וכמה וכמה פעמים אני בקשתי בעצמי מכמה מגדוליהם שהתאכסנו בביתי שיגלה לי איזה מהרזין דאורייתא ולא מצאתי שום מענה מאיזה מהם ומאז נתוודע לי במוחלט שאינם יודעים משום רזין רק מדברים מאיזה רמזים שבסיפרי קבלה מהרב ר' ישראל ב"ש ז"ל ואין להם שחר ומשאר ספרי הקבלה שכתבו מכוונות התפלות דהאר"י ז"ל באשר כולם חפיצים מאוד לכוונות התפילות באם באפשרי יהי' להם לכווין .וביותר מי שקולו ערב ועומד לפני התיבה ודאי תהילתו אמיתית בקהל חסידים כמאמר דוד שירו לד' שיר חדש תהילתו בקהל חסידים .כי שבח זה נראה לעיני כל אמיתתו .אבל שבחים שמשבחים לעצמם כוונות תפילתם ושאר שבחים מסגופים נוראים ותעניתם הקשים משבת לשבת ושאינן אוכלים שום דבר מהחי ,ונזדככים את גופם למטהרים עמ' 28 א"ע מכל טומאה שנטמאו מחטאות נעוריהם ובטבילתם המרובים והתמדיות נתחדש להם גופים 124 חדשים וטהורים מכל טומאה כדכתיב לב טהור ברא לי אלקים וכו':
.123ברכות לב ע"א. .124תה' נא :יב.
259
Gershon David Hundert ובאלה השבחים אסור לספר כמאמר הגמרא 125אל יספר אדם בשבחו של חבירו כי מתוך שבחו יבא לידי גנותו – ויש בזה המאמר לדקדק הרבה בלשון הגמרא .כי הי' לכתוב אל ישבח או יהלל את חבירו או יוכל לומר אל יספר מעלות ומדת טובות של חבירו ולא שבחו – ועוד האיך אפשר המספר שבח שיבוא לידי גנות .אך מאמר חז"ל בגמרא זו מדבר מאותן אנשים ששבחו יוצא מפיו עצמו היינו שצם או סיגף א"ע או שכיוון בתפילתו בטהרת גופו ומחשבתו לזה אמרו אל יספר אדם בשבחו של חבירו שיצא מפי עצמו שבאולי ימצאו אנשים שלא ירצו להאמין לדבריו בכוונותיו וסגופיו ויאמר שהוא זייפון ושקרן ומה לו לגנות גדול מזה לכן אמרו לשון שבחו אל יספר אבל שבח הנראה לעיני הכל יכול לספר להודות ולהלל לד': כל זה נאמר נגד האלופים והרבנים החסידים הראשונים ז"ל שנהגו את עצמם בחסידות ולמדו כוונות האר"י ז"ל והאריכו בתפילתם במשך שלשה שעות ויותר בניגוני זמרה בקולות ערביםלשומעם וגם נהגו בסיגופים נוראים וקשים הראוים לתשובת הקנה כאשר ביארתי לעיל ועכ"פ מדת הענווה היו בהם ועיקרו את הרבנים הגאונים ותלמידי חכמים בכל אתר ואתר ולא העזו פניהם נגד שום אדם תלמיד חכם: עמ' 29 ולא כן חסידי זמנינו זה כמה שנים מקרוב נועדו יחד גם לפרוץ גדר היראה וענווה בפרץ מרובה על העומד .היות שלא לבד שאינן חוששים לסיגופים הראוי' לתשובת הקנה ואף התעניתים המצווים לנו מחז"ל ואבותינו מימות הנביאים קבלו עלינו כתורה זה יותר מאלפיים שנה כל בני הגולה המפורדים ומפוזרים בהרבה ארצות העמים שונים ובני ישראל מקטנים ועד גדולים כולם צמים ומשלימים והמה רובם אינם צמים כלל .והתחילו להתפלל תפלה קצרה באין מזכיר עוד מכוונות האר"י ז"ל ואפשר גם בפירוש המלות אין להם חשש יותר לידע משאר המון עם יושבי הקרנות כנראה מתכלית למודם: בהלכות התלמוד ובפסקי הש"ע אין חפצם .מחיבורי אגדות התלמוד ומפרשים ושאר ספרי המחקרים המפרשים מקראות והתלמודים המלאים מוסרים גדולים במליצות משלי החכמה ותוכחות סגולות אינן יודעים מאומה .ובמאמרי הזוהר הקדוש אין להם עסק כלל כאשר אבאר למטה .ובכל זאת חוצפתם מתרבה בהם מדי יום עד שמלאה לבם לדבר נגד מלכים מאן מלכי רבנן גאוני ארץ היושבים על כסא ההוראות בקהלות ישראל בדברי בזיון וקצף שאין להעלות על הכתב מפני כבוד ישראל ותורתם .ובאיזה מקומות וקהלות העיזו פניהם לחלוק על רבניהם ולתרפם עד שלא יכלו לסבול שבט רשעתם .ועזבו כבוד רבנתם ועזבו דירתם .ופינה הודם וזיוום והדרם מקהלתם .ונתקבלו לממשלת עמ' 30 הרבנות לקהלות אחרים כמו הרב הגאון המפורסם מוהר"ר משולם נ"י אב"ד דק"ק טיסמניץ רק עבורם עזב רבנותו ונתקבל לאב"ד לק"ק פרעשבארג ראש הקהלה במדינת אונגרין וגם שם לכבודו ולתפארתו עלה .ואם בזה נפלה שלהבת גאוותם וטח עיניהם מראות וערל לבם בסכלותם מלהבין גודל המעלות והמדות כבוד הרבנים ותלמידי חכמים והצדיקים נ"י שפאר תהילתם נראה לעיני כולם גודל בקיאתם בחדרי התלמוד והפוסקים הקדמונים והאחרונים והתמדתם המרובים בהם בפלפולים חריפים והורים ומורים הדרך שילכו בה כלל בני הגולה עדת ישראל כדת תורתינו הקדושה הגלויה .ונתונה לנו כדכתיב 126הנסתרות לד' אלקינו והנגלות לנו ולבנינו עד עולם לעשות את כל דברי התורה הזאת וכו' כי היא חיינו – ואורך ימינו .ומפרשי' לעוה"ז ולעוה"ב לזה אין לנו עסק בנסתרות כנראה שאין שום אחד מהקדמונים הגאונים והרבנים ולפניהם התנאים והאמוראים מיום שפסקה הנבואה והנביאים עצמם לא התנבאו דיבור אחד
.125שבת יד ע"א : :לעולם אל יספר אדם בשבחו של חבירו יותר מדאי ,שמתוך טובתו בא לידי גנותו. .126דברים כט:כח.
260
The Introduction to Divre binah by Dov Ber of Bolechów מסודות ומרזין דאורייתא כמו שאי' בתוספתא 127במופלא ממך אל תדרוש במכוסה ממך אל תחקור במה שהרשיתי לך התבונן ודע שאין לך עסק בנסתרות לזה כולם עסקו בתורה מגדולים ועד קטנים בלי הוכרה משום סודות: ולזה כבר קדמון זקן הגאון הגדול החסיד מוהר"ר יוסף יעבץ זצ"ל ה"ה בחיבורו השלישי ספר אורח חיים ]! צ"ל אור החיים[ שנדפס פעם ראשון זה שני מאות שנים וכעת נדפס בלבוב במצות והוצאות הרבני המופלג ונגיד המפורסם כבוד עמ' 31 מוהר"ר יהודא ליב בהרב מוהר"ר שניאור זצ"ל מק"ק באלחוב וכעת הוא מספוני ונגידי ק"ק 128 לבוב הבירה .והספר זה הוא קטן הכמות ורב האיכות וכותב בפרק הראשון שבו בזה הלשון: להודיע כי אין ראוי לטייל בפרדס התורה עד ימלאה תורת ד' ואהבתו .גלוי וידוע לכל יודעי דת ודין כי חכמת תורתינו הקדושה תתחלק לשני חלקים .החלק האחד הוא ידיעת פירוש המצות על אמיתתם .והחלק השני המה סודות התורה .לכן צריך שיוקדם החלק הראשון לחלק השני קדימה הכרחיות כי אי אפשר 129להשיב החלק הב' אם לא קדם ידיעת החלק הראשון .וזה יתבאר מן השכל ומדברי חז"ל ומן הכתובים: אמנם מן השכל כי מלכותא דרקיע כעין מלכותא דארעא .וכמו שאיש כפרי לא ימצא חן בעיני המלך להיות מאנשי סודו .אם לא קדמו לו מעשים נרצים אל המלך .משל לאחד שהי' משרת בבית המלך באמונה במלאכתו חוטב עצים ושואב מים .וכראות המלך טוב לבבו יעליהו למדרגה גדולה מזו יותר .ממדרגה למדרגה עד יבחרהו המלך לשבת עמו ולהיות מאנשי סודו .מצד אשר נמצא נאמן וזריז בכל מלאכת המלך: כן הדבר בסודות התורה כי לא יזכה אליהם אם לא קדם לו מציאת חן בעיני מלך מלכי המלכים הקב"ה .מצד עשיית המצות בלב שלם מאהבה וידיעת תלמודים .וזה שאמר אדון הנביאים אם נא מצאתי חן בעיניך הודיעני ]נא[ את דרכיך 130.ומציאת החן הוא עשיית רצונו ית' בלב שלם כאמור ונח מצא חן בעיני ד' .וכתיב בתר"י אלה תולדות נח נח איש צדיק תמים הי' בדורותיו . והנה עמ' 32 מענותנותו של משה רבינו ע"ה שהזכיר מציאת חן בלשון מסופק אם נא מצאתי וכו' .והשם ית' השיבו בלשון ודאי כי מצאת חן בעיני .והחושב להגיע או להשיג ידיעת חלק הב’ קודם השגתו הא' גדול עונו מנשוא: כי אם המלך נתן לעבדיו שני ספרים .ואמר להם התבוננו בראשון כל תכלית ההבנה .והזהירם על כך באזהרות גדולות .ועל השני צוה השמרו לכם פתוח אותו ונגוע בקצהו עד אומרי אליכם פתחוהו והביננו 131בו .והם עשו להפך ושלחו יד באותו ספר השני והראשון הניחו בקרן זויות ולא ראוהו ולא ידעו מה הוא .אין ספק אלא שחייבו את ראשם למלך .כן אנחנו נצטווינו מפי ממ"ה הקב"ה להתבונן בתלמוד מצותיו ולמדתם אותם וכו' .ושננתם לבניך ודברת בם וכו' . ואחר זה אם נמצא חן בעיניו הוא יגלה לנו ענין הספר השני ואנחנו עושים להפך כי החלק אשר נצטוינו בו רחוק מכליותינו וממחשבותינו ומכש"ק .החלק השני אשר הוזהרנו עליו לבלתי נגוע בקצהו ואנחנו מתפקרים בו וחושבים מחשבות משכלינו הקל בלי שום תענית
.127לא מצאתי בתוספתא .בתלמוד ,חגיגה יג ע"א מצטטטים מספר בן סירא )ג ,יט( :במופלא ממך אל תדרוש ובמכוסה ממך אל תחקור במה שהורשית התבונן ואין לך עסק בנסתרות. .128יוסף יעבץ ,אור החיים ,לבוב תקנ"א .המחבר לא דייק בהעתקתו; רק שינויים משמעותיים יסומנו כאן. .129במקור במקום "אי אפשר" :מנוע. .130שמות לג:יג. .131במקור :והתבוננו.
261
Gershon David Hundert ותפלה להש"ית' שיגלה לנו סודות כאשר עשה אדון הנביאים .ואמר אם נא מצאתי חן וגו' . 132 והמשל הזה לא בדיתיו מלבי כי מצאתיו לחכמים הקדושים ז"ל: נמצא לפי זה כי הדור הזה אשר חרבות שיניו ומאכלות מלתעותיו ואין חסד ואין דעת אלקים בארץ .ואין אדם אשר עושה מצוה לשמה כי אם להתגדל ולתפאר ואין אתנו יודע עד מה . לא שתא סדרי ולא תלתא ולא מסכתא ולא פסק כסדרו .אסור לנו להתבונן בסודות התורה . וחטאנו עם אבינו הראשון אשר נצטווה מכל עץ הגן אכל תאכל ומעץ הדעת וכו' .והוא שלח ידו בו הפך רצון קונו ונקנסה עליו עמ' 33 מיתה .כמו שנקנסה על הדור ]הזה[ כמה צרות קשות מן המות .ד' למען שמו יצילנו מהם. ומדברי חז"ל אע"פ שנראה מיותר כי כל התלמוד מלא מזה ומבואר לתינוקת של בית רבן . אחרי 133עתה עם הארץ המוכים בסנורי גאותם .בחושבם שהשיגו סודות התורה ותעלומותיה מבלי ריח תורה וטעם מצות אביא לך קצת דבריהם: אמרו 134ארבעה נכנסו לפרדס אלישע אחר ור' עקיבא ובן עזאי ובן זומא .אחר קצץ בנטיעות קראו עליו אל תתן את פיך לחטיא את בשרך .בן עזאי הציץ ונפגע קראו עליו דבש מצאת אכול דייך וגו' .בן זומא הציץ ומת קראו עליו יקר בעיני ד' המותה לחסידיו .ר' עקיבא נכנס בשלום ויצא בשלום קראו עליו הביאני המלך חדריו .ואף ר' עקיבא בקשו מלאכי השרת לדוחפו אמר להם הקב"ה הניחו לו לזקן זה ראוי להשתמש בכבודי: הנה רבותי וגאוני הם החסידים היראים את השם החרדים אל דברו כבר אתם רואים בעיניכם כי אלה הארבעה היו גדולי ישראל .חכמים אשר עמהם עוז ותושיה .ספרא וספרי וכולה תלמודא ואחרי כן ערבו אל לבם לגשת אל סודות התורה וקרה להם מה שקרה ולא נמלט מהם איש כי אם ר' עקיבא אשר למד משנה והרביץ תורה בישראל מ' שנה וגדלה נפשו בעיני ד' עד אשר אמר למלאכי השרת הניחו לו וכו': עוד אמרו 135על ר' אליעזר אשר רקא 136עליו טובינא דחכימי והי' מתקרי מריה דארעא דישראל לרוב חכמתו וחסידותו .ואמר לו ר' יוחנן תא ואגמרינך מעשה מרכבה ואמר אכתי לא קשאי אנכי .הנה כי אע"פ שהי' בתכלית השלימות עמ' 34 לא בטח בלבו ללמוד סודות התורה כי לא הי' זקן .כי סודות התורה אין ראוי להשתדל בהם כי אם החסידים הלומדים .המופלגים .כי הם כמו שנתחבר אל המלך ונכנס בחדריו .שאם לא יהיה ראוי ויבוא לחדר המלך דמו בראשו .כמו שנאמר פן יהרסו לראות 137אל ד' ונפל ממנו רב .ודבר הורה על זה מה שאמרו 138הניחו לו לזקן זה ראוי לו שישתמש בכבודי .דומה למה שאמר אם נא מצאתי חן בעיניך ואם תבקש בכל אלו הדברים תמצא כי לא לבד על ידיעת חלק הראשון היו מקפידים .כי גם על זקנה ושיבה וענוה יתירה הצריכה להם לחסידים הרוצים לבוא לסוד ד': ואוי להם לתרבות אנשים חטאים .שועלים קטנים מחבלים כרמים אשר לא טעמו טעם בשר משנה ותלמוד .ולא הריחו ריח יראת שמים .רק לחמו לחם רשע ויין חמס הגאווה שתו עד לשכרה .יען 139הכתובים די לנו מוסר מהאיש משה עניו מאוד אשר הסתיר פניו מהביט אל
.132המחבר דלג כאן על המשפט :אמרו ]חגיגה יג[ במופלא ממך אל תדרוש ובמכוסה ממך אל תחקור במה שהרשית התבונן ואל יהיה לך עסק בנסתרות. .133במקור :אחרי שרבים עתה )שמות ה:ה(. .134חגיגה יד ע"ב. .135כתובות מ ע"א. .136צ"ל קרא .137צ"ל פן יהרסו אל ד' לראות .138המחבר דלג כאן על המילים :במאמר הראשון. .139במקור :ומן.
262
The Introduction to Divre binah by Dov Ber of Bolechów האלקים .ואמרו רז"ל 140בזכות ויסתר זכה לקלסתר שאמר אם נא מצאתי – ודוד ידיד השם אמר 141סוד ד' אל יריאיו 142ובריתו להודיעם .העיד על כל דברי כי לא יוודעו סודות התורה כי אם 143מפי הש"י .למאן די יצבא יודיעם כאומרו בי ד' יתן חכמה מפיו דעת ותבונה. וכבר נשלם החלק הראשון תהלה לאל .ע"כ דברי הרב ר' יוסף יעבץ בספרו אור החיים הנ"ל פרק ראשון .ובאם שירצה איזה קורא לקרות ספרו הנ"ל ימצא הרבה חקירות וביאורים בענין הנ"ל: והנה גם החכם ומחוקק בישראל השר דון יצחק אברבנאל כתב בראשית הקדמתו לחבורו הקטן עטרת זקנים שנדפס פעם ראשון בשנת שי"ז לפ"ק ופעם שנית בשנת תצ"ט לפ"ק באמשטרדם בזה הלשון: עמ' 35 כי שמעתי דבת רבים יודעי דת 144ומביני מדע חדשים וגם ישנים מוצאי דבת אנשים צדיקים וטובים זקני העם ושוטרין מתנבאים במחנה רואי פני המלך ותחת רגליו כמעשה לבנת הספיר . ויוצא דבתם רעה לאמור ברכו אלקים בלבבם ויחפאו אצילי ב"י דברים אשר לא כן אשר לא כדת שגו ברואה וימירו כבודם כבוד אלקים בתבנית אבן דומם נופך ספיר ויהלם .והוא עון פלילה יום תת ד’ ג"שם .פקו פלילה אשר כללה מן הגשמיות 145מה שכללה דברי בד' .ויאמרו איש אל אחיו מן הוא ואיזה הדום רגליו ספיר גזר"תם גזרו אומר עמדו רגליו ביום ההוא על מראה אבן ספיר דמות כסא בחשכה יתהלכו במהמורות בל יקומו .עזבו את ד' ותהי להם חזות הכל חזון נפרץ .ויקומו לצחק ויאכלו וישתו .ואולם בעבור זה בני מות המה נתחייבו כליה ממתים מחלד .ויקרא ד' אלקים ביום ההוא המותה לחסידיו בני תמותה .אם לא כי צורם הצור תמים פעלו הטה אוזן לשמוע אל הרנה ואל התפלה .וציר נאמן לשולחיו בכה ויתחנן לו . לא יומת איש ביום הזה הן עוד היום גדול ממותי תחלואים ימותו ועתה למה נמות לעיניך . ויעתר לו אלקים האריך אפו ביום ההוא .והי' ביום פקדו ספו תמו מן בלהות חזיונו ובאש ד' יבא ותאכל בקצה המחנה החטאים האלה בנפשותם .ע"כ דברי המחבר ע"ז הנ"ל: נחזור לענינינו ונבאר יותר סיבת ביטול תורה בלימוד ופלפולי הגמרא והפוסקים .יען שמאז ומקדם כשנתגלה הזוהר הקדוש כבר התחילו הרבה מהעצלים להתרשל מלעסוק במפרשי התורה בנגלה לנו מסיני בחוקותיה בדקדוקיה ופירושיה בהלכותיה עמ' 36 בע"פ איש מפי איש מאבותינו עד משה רבינו ע"ה אשר רחבה היא מן הים וארוכה מארץ מזה לזה .המתעצלים אינם מכניסים א"ע ללמוד התלמוד ומפרשיו ופלפוליו הגלוים וחריפים הצריכים איש מבין בלב פתוח כאשר חז"ל מחברי התלמוד הקדמונים והאחרונים נראה מחיבוריהם שהיו לבבם פתוחים כפתחו של אולם בתורתינו שבע"פ הק' ואיזה מבני עמינו אשר אין להם לב להבין עמקי התלמוד בהוראותיו בעסקי המצות וקיומם כדת התורה וחפיצים להראות עצמם להמון כתלמידי חכמים מפוארים ומשבחים בפני המון עם את גבוה לימוד חכמת הקבלה בסודות התורה רצים אחרי גדולי החסידים ללמוד ולשמוע מהם רזין וסתרי תורה אף שאין להם ידיעה שלימה בהגלויה אשר ממנה תוצאות חכמה להורים ומורים לנו הלכות פסוקות כמו הרבנים וגאוני ארץ שבכל קהלות ישראל רובם ככולם מבלים ימיהם בהתמדם בלימוד הלכות הגמרא ופוסקים קדמונים ואחרונים בכדי שידעו לשאל ולהשיב על שאלה שיזדמן לפניהם
.140ברכות ז ע"א. .141תהילים כה :יד. .142צ"ל ליראיו .143דלג כאן המחבר על המילים :לאשר קדם לו החלק הראשון ושלא יוודע כי כולם. .144במקור :דעת. .145במקור :גשמות.
263
Gershon David Hundert ומהם יצאו טבעם בעולם בספרי שאלות ותשובות שכתבו הרבנים בעלי הוראות הנ"ל אחרי שפסקו הגאונים: וזולת אלו הרבה מהתלמידים שמו עיונם במקראות ואגדות התלמוד ביגיעת הרבה ושקידות גדולות חוזרים אחרי ספרי המחקרים החכמים הקדמונים שבדבריהם כולם מוסר במשל ומליצה בתוכחות מגולה ואלו הולכים בנתיבתם וחוזרים בעיירות כל קהילות ישראל ונשמעים קולם כשופר המחריד את העם לשמוע חכמה ומוסר השכל במשל ומליצה . ומהראוי היא להחזיק התלמידי חכמים כאלו הרבנים אב"ד הצדק וגם את המוכיחים או מגידי מישרים כאלו בכל מקום שהם נמצאים בקהלת ישראל לפרנסם מקופת הקהל והעדה . יצ"ו: עמ' 37 ובפרט בקהלות שיש להם בתי דינים מחוייבים כל בני ישראל עצמם להתמנות עליהם רב הגון לאב בית דין וב"ד צדק שידונו דין אמת עפ"י תורתינו הק' בנקוב להם שכרם מקופת העדה שלא ישאו פנים לשום אחד ולא גורו משום אחד .ואף שמצד הממשלה יר"ה יע"א ]יגן עליה אלהים[ אין כח ביד ב"ד ורב להזמין את איזה מבני עמינו למשפטם אך שמבואר בסיסטעם מהק’יר"ה שמותר לנו ולרבנינו לערוך משפטים לפניהם בתורת קאמפראמוסט ,היינו זבל"א וזבל"ב והרב הוא השלישי או הראש תמיד על שהוא התמנה בהסכמת כולם בודאי הוא מרוצה לכל העדה: וכן נעשה פה ק"ק באלחוב יע"א קיימו וקבלו על עצמם כל בני קהלתינו יצ"ו וחתמו כתב הרבנות לכבוד הרב המאוהג"ל הגאון מוהר"ר דוד יעקב נ"י בהרב הגאון המנוח באופנים אלו שכל אחד מבני קהלתינו יצ"ו מחוייב לעמוד בכח הזמנתו לפני ב"ד הצדק ולשפוט עם יהי' מי שיהי' בלי שום אפילאציע .ות"ל זה סוף שנה שניה הרב הנ"ל יושב בשלוה על כסאו ההוראה ואין אחד מעדתינו יצ"ו לערכאות לדון אף משפט הקל עם יהודי חבירו במשפטיהם .ואולי יתן ד' גם בלבם של כל בני גולה שארית ישראל שבקהלות מדינות אלו ויסכימו ליתן לכל רב ואב"ד שלהם תוקף ועוז לעשות משפט צדק לבני עמינו עפ"י דת תורתינו הק' וזאת לא לבד שיעלה לעזר מעט נגד גדירות וביטול משפטים אף יקויים מצות עשה .שופטים תתן לך וכו' 146.עפ"י עצמיכם ולא עפ"י שררות המושלים כאשר נהגו עד עתה מי שהרבה מוהר ומתן לשררה נתמנה לרב ומורה אף במעט הסכמות אנשי העדה . ולפעמים נתקבל אף שאינו הגון לאב"ד: עמ' 38 ובפרט כעת נטבע שיבוטל נתינת הגלגולת מראשי בני ישראל .ונתחדש נתינה מנירות שבת . ושוב לא יצטרכו שרי הממשלה להתמנות לנו ראשים היינו רעגירורש שהושיבו עלינו רק לבטחון בגביות מעות הגלגולת הנ"ל .וכשיבוטל הנתינה לא יתנו לנו ראשים .וישארו בני עמינו כצאן בלא רועה ח"ו .יעלה גלות זה מר מכולם .כאשר מדי יום ממש מתאמצים שונאי ישראל גוים עריצים מוצאים דבת רעות ושקרים הרבה על בני עמינו לפני שררות הממשלה בכדי לקעקע ביצת ישראל ולהפר מצות התורה והדת חו"ש .אשר זה כמה שנים היהודים אומללים מסוגרים או מוגבלים מאוראנדיש בכפרים ומחזיקי הרחיים והמכסים ומהרבה מארופיות הטובים .ואין מי יעמוד בעדינו שמו הגדול יעמוד לנו בעת צרה: ויתן ד' בלבם דכל בני גולה עדת ישראל מדינות אדונינו האדיר הק"ירה שיסכימו כולם כאחד לא לבד לבחור להם רב לאב"ד באופנים שבארתי לעיל .אף גם יתרצו ויחפוצו כולם כאחד לחזות מכל העדה אנשי חיל יראי אלקים אנשי אמת שונאי בצע ולבררם עפ"י רוב הסכמות העדה .שבעה אנשים .כאשר מקדמת דנא בכל קהלות ישראל התמנו מדי שנה שבעה טובי עיר עפ"י רוב דיעות והי' להם כח והרשאה מכל העדה לעשות בעסקי הקהל כישר בעיניהם לערוך את כל אחד .כפי משאת הונו מה שיש לו ליתן לכל מאה זה’ להצטרכות הקהלה יצ"ו – ולגבות ממנו .ולהוציאם להצטרכות הקהלה לבנות ולהרוס לנטוע .146דב' טז:יח.
264
The Introduction to Divre binah by Dov Ber of Bolechów ולעקור וליתן מתנות כפי הבנתם למי שיסכימו ברוב דעתם לאיזה שררות מהמושלים עבור איזה השתדלות טובה לכלל הקהלה .הגם באם שיתן ד' שעה מוכשרה ויורשה לנו לעשות אסיפה גדולה מכלל הקהלות .שכעת אסרו לנו שרי הגובערוג יר"ה שלא נעשה מבני ישראל שום עמ' 39 אסיפה .ושלא יוצאו שום פרוטה מקופת הקהל על איזה משולחים לווינא או אף ללבוב . וכשיתמנו בקהלות שבעה טובי עיר .בודאי ימצאו תחבולה מובטחה להתיצב לנוסדו יחד הרוזנים אחד אחד מעיר ובהתאספם כולם בודאי יעלה ביניהם עצה מוצלחה בעצת ד’ שלעולם תעמוד לטובת כלל קהלות ישראל: ומובטחים יהיו שאם יעלה הסכמתם דכלל ישראל להתמנות עליהם רבנים ובתי דינים צדיקים עם מנהיגים וראשי עדה ישרים .ובזה יקויים מצות עשה מפורשה בתורה שופטים ושוטרים תתן לך בכל שעריך אשר ד' אלקיך נותן לך לרשתה .ופירשו רז"ל תתן לך עפ"י עצמך ובהסכמתך ולא .ובזכות זה גם יקויים בנו הברכה השיבה שופטים כבראשונה ויועציםעפ"י שררות המושלים .כבתחילה .ולא כאשר נהגו בני ישראל במדינת פולין מכמה מאות שנים ה ר בה מהם הרבו מוהר ומתן להשררות בכדי שיתמנו לרבנים כאשר כתב מזה הגאון הגדול הרב המופלג חכם הכולל מוהר"ר משה חאגיז ז"ל בספרו משנת חכמים 147שחיבר על מ"ח דברים שהתורה נקנית בהן וז"ל בחלק ראשון מעלה י"ז סימן ת"ה: ומה מאוד תמה אני ורעדה אזרתני איך ימלאום לבם של שום רב לקבל רבנות על פי ממון לשררה .דמלבד מה שאיסורו מבואר מצד הדת והשכל .בפרט אחרי שמעם וראותם מעשה שהי' בק"ק 148לבוב מהצוואה שעשה האב"ד הקדוש מוהר"ר חיים רייצלס זצ"ל בערב שבועות משנת דאשתקד זו שנת תפ"ח היינו פתח ד' אוצרו לקבל נשמת קדוש זה שמימות ר' עקיבא ועד עכשיו לא קם כמוהו .ויוצא ד' כלי זעמו .כי מלאכה היא לד' אלקים צבאות. בכללות ארץ פולין .שכך עלתה בימיהם וימינו .להיות צדיק יסוד עולם מקדש שם שמים ברבים .ולסבול כמה יסורין ועינויים עמ' 40 קשים כקדם מיתה ושרפה שגזרו עליו .והכל קבל עליו בשמחה .והתודה ברבים שמה שצוו לחתוך ידיו הי' מפני שסיפר מעותיו בידו לשררה לקבל הרבנות .ומה שצוו וגזרו לחתוך את לשונו הי' מקבל לעונש מפני שלמד לשון לאטייניש ושאר לשונות העמים .ומה שגזרו עליו לרצות 149את מוחו הי' מקבל עליו לעונש שהי' מדבר 150בדברי העולם ופוסק מדברי תורה . וכן נמי על מה שגזרו עליו להוציא את לבו והוא עודנו חי .כי שאר הגוף לא פלט ולפיכך הי' נדון להשרף .ולכן הי' מצווה לכל בני ישראל להתרחק מן השררות ומן המחלוקת .ומללמד את בניהם שום לשון מלשונות העמים .ושלא לקבל שום רבנות ע"י ממון: ואחר שראה את אחיו החסיד מוהר"ר יהושע זצ"ל שמת בבית האסורין שישב עמו ונגזר עליו לנקוב את ארכובי 151רגליו ולקושרם בזנבי הסוס כדי שילכו הלוך וסחוב שנגרר על כל אשפה וטיט .התפלל מנחה והצדיק עליו את הדין ככל האמור .ויותר מזה כמו שנראה מהצוואה שלו . ומסר עצמו לעינוי ולמיתה משונה ולשריפה כאמור .ויצאה נשמתו באחד .אשריו ואשרי חלקו שזכה לכך .ואוי לו לדור שכך עלה בימיו .כי בעונות הרבים הקול נשמע שיד פושעי ישראל 152 היתה במעל הזה .
.147ונדסבק תצ"ג. .148דלג כאן המחבר על המילים :לעמבורג הנקראת. .149במקור :לרצץ. .150במקור :מהרהר. .151במקור :עקובו. .152מכאן ,דברי דב בר.
265
Gershon David Hundert ובהיותי בק"ק לבוב שמעתי מפי זקן אחד ר' מאיר שמו ז"ל .וסיפר לי איך שהלשינו לפני השררה היינו הסטאראסטי בלבוב איך שאמר הרב הקדוש הנ"ל על הסטאראסטי שהוא עני ודלת למי יכול לשבעו ולמלאות חסרונו בממון .ובשמעו השררה דברי הרב נעשה שונאו שנאת מות להרב ובסיבת זאת העלילו על אלו הרבנים הקדושים הנ"ל איך שהם החזירו מומר יהודי מדת נוצרי לדת יהודית .והביא את המומר והעמידו אותו לפני קהל יהודים ואלו הרבנים הנ"ל עמהם .ולא ידע המומר ולא יכול להכיר את הרבנים .ובראותם הרבנים שהמומר מוכחש בדבריו הכוזבים על הרבנים .והוא אינו מכירם .צווח ככרוכיא מלשון לאטיין פראטעסטר וכשמעו המומר את קול הרב תיכף רץ אליו ואמר עמ' 41 לפני כל הפריצים שהתאספו שמה בבית המשפט זה הוא הרב שהחזיר אותי לדת יהודית .ובסיבת 153 זה נגזרו עליהם מיתה .ומתו על קדושת שמו ית' בעו"ה כנ"ל: אשר ודאי על שמועה רעה כזו .מחוייבים אנו לקרוע סגור לבבינו הערל משמוע אל דבר ד' כי הוא יתברך היודע כמה חרה לי וכמה מהצער ויגון מר ורע נגע אל לבי מכח מעשה זה .ועל הכל דאין אני רואה בדורותינו דור יתם זה מי שיעמוד בפרץ לתקן בתיקון הראוי את הדבר הרע הזה . ולגזור ולהחרים בכל תוקף על כל ק"ק שבגולה בכל אשר צוותה התורה וצווי הקדוש הנזכר . ומי ראה כזאת ומי שמע כאלה ולא ירך לבבו .להיות מואס ברבנות כעין זה המביאו לידי נסיון כזו .על זאת ודאי תאבל הארץ .ויחרד כל לב על מה עשה ד' ככה לארץ הזאת .ומה יהי' באחריתינו בהמשכות הגלות המר הזה עד מתי ד' .כי אין מנחם ואין מנהל לנו .ואין לנו על מי להשען כי אם על אבינו שבשמים .הוא ברחמיו יעשה עמנו אות לטובה .למען שמו הגדול .ויקויים בנו מקרא שכתוב .ואשיבה שופטיך כבראשונה ויועציך כבתחילה: ולדבר הזה וכל כיוצא בו .שאני כותב במלאכה קטנה זו .יסלח ד' ויסלחו לי ארזי הלבנון חכמי רבני ארץ .כי לפניו ית' גלי דלא גבה לבי ולא רמו עיני וגו' .ואם דברתי עד הנה אינו אלא מדאגת לבי שת"ל ית' כיוון שאני מבחוץ אני רואה ושומע דברים אשר לא הייתי רוצה לשמוע בזילותייהו דרבנן ומחילול ד' ותורתו שנעשית שיחתן של ת"ח קלה בפי ההדיוטות ואין לי פה להשיב ולא מצח להרים ראש כנגדם .כי כל אלה הדברים מפיהם הם יוצאין . ולא ידעתי מה להשיב כי אין בפי מענה: יען רואה אנוכי רוח ד’ דבר במהרש"א ז"ל שכתב בשביעי דסוטה ז"ל על מה שכתב עמ' 42 ותו רבי אבוהו אימנו רבנן עליה לממניה ברישא וכו' .אחר שפירש ענין ענוותנותי' ד"ר אבוהו מאי הוא .סיים דבריו אבל ראיתי גודל הסיבה בזה .שהבעלי בתים הם הם הממנים ומבררים להם ראש כפי רצונם .לפי הנאות דכל אחד מהם .וביתר בממון .אבל מן הראוי שהלומדים והרבנים בכל עיר בעצמם .יבחרו להם איש ראוי להיות ראש ב"ד שלהם .כמו שהיתה בדורות הראשונים .כמו שמצאנו בהך עובדא לר' אבוהו דאימנו רבנן עליה לממניה ברישא וכו' .וכן בהך דהוריות דרבן גמליאל וב"ד מינו את ר' אבן חסמא ור"י בן גודגדא לראשים עכ"ל .ויבוא שלום וינוח על משכבותיו .דידע וראה שורש הדבר מכה זו המהלכה .לכך נשכבה בבשתינו .ותכסינו כלימתינו .ואוי נא לנו כי כך עלתה בימינו .המרחם הוא ירחם ויחוס על פלטתינו .וישקיף השקפה לטובה על דלותינו .כי אביט ואין עוזר ואין סומך מפלתינו ואין לנו על מי להשען כי אם על אבינו שבשמים .ויקויים בנו מקרא שכתוב ואשיבה שופטיך כבראשונה וגו' .ע"כ דברי הרב ר' משה חאגיז בעל המחבר ספר משנת חכמים: ועוד רעה גדולה מזו נתהווה .כעת מבני עמינו .איזה שלמדו מבחורי אשכנזים המגולחים . ומורגלים מנעוריהם בתאוות עה"ז .ומוותרים לעצמם כמה ממצות עשה ולא תעשה .שהרבה מהם נתערבו בגוים .ולמדו מהם בטול להכחיש הכל ובעוה"ר אלו פוקרים טפי ויותר
.153חוזר המחבר כאן לצטט ממשנת חכמים.
266
The Introduction to Divre binah by Dov Ber of Bolechów מהצדוקים ובייתוסים שהיו בימי בית שני ונאדרו ונהרגו מן העולם בעת חורבנו .לכן אמרתי מהרואי לכתוב מה מידיעת האל מה שלקטתי מספרי חכמי הספרדיים המחקרים הקדושים: עמ' 43 ידיעת האל יתברך לא שלמה לאדם ידיעת מה ממהות וחכמות הבורא ב"ה .ולא השיג שום אחד מהמחקרים . הענינים הנעלמים .והגלוים על אמיתת ידיעתם .כמאמר הנביא ישעיהו ואל מי תדמיון אל ומה דמות תערכו לו .וכתוב עוד ואל מי תדמיוני ואשוה 154ואם איזו בקשו להשיב דבר אשר לא יושב אולת יחשב להם .ומחלוקותיהם בזה חטא הוא .כי מי יוכל להכריע ביניהם: וראוי לנו לחקור מקדם מהות נפשינו .אשר בקרבינו .טרם שנחקור לדעת מהות יוצרינו .וגם הוא מאמר הפלוסופים .דעו נפשיכם – ותדעו אלקיכם .ועוד אמרו אם הדברים יגעים בענין הנפש שניכרים לנו פעולותיה כ"ש בענין יוצרינו ית' שמו .שאי אפשר לשום אדם להשיג אפס קצת מפעולותיו ולזה אמרו תכלית שנדעך הוא שלא ידעך .וכן כתוב ומבשרי אחזה אלקים .155ופירושו כאשר גוייתינו הוא מארבעה יסודות אש רוח עפר מים .חלקו מעולם השפל .ונפשינו הוא רוחנו .וחלק אלקי ממעל .וכל פעולת אדם וטבעותיו ממנה .לזה מכנים את גוף אדם בשם עולם קטן .ומראים בחלקי גופו ובאדריו כל הדברים ממש הנמצאים בשמים ובארץ .היות שברא את האדם בדמותו ובצלמו כאשר השמים והארץ עם כל העולמות כולם המה גוף אחד .ואלקים ב"ה בהם נשמה .ומשגיח ופועל הכל בהם בטובעותיו .היות שאותיות אלקים ואותיות הטב"ע עולים בגימטריא אחד ומספרם פ"ו .כי אלקים נשמת עולם וטבעותיו הוא אחד קדמון ולא כמו שחושבים איזה פוקרים ימ"ש . ואומרים שטבעת העולם עמ' 44 פועלים בעצמם בלא משגיח חו"ש .זה שקר גמור וכל בקרתם בור רוקים .ואנחנו מאמינים בודאי בלי שום ספק .אחרי כל החקירות שעשינו בשכליות .לדעת את אלקי אבינו .כמצווה לנו דע את אלקי אביך .מצאנו שאלקים זה אשר ברא הכל הוא אחד .קדמון במצאותו בכל העולמות .ומחשיב בהשגחתו .להשפיע לכל שאר הנמצאים טובתו .כנאמר טוב ד' לכל שברא אותם לאות על אחדותו שנאמר ד' אחד .והחל חדשות שניכר חכמתו דכתיב ד' בחכמה יסד ארץ .ויצר יצירות לעד על גבורתו .שנאמר וגבורותיך יגידו: לכן צריכין אנו להאמין ולידע ידיעה בתורה בלי שום ספק ובתמים .שיש אלקים בעולם .והוא אחד ברוך בורא הכל את השמים ושמי שמים וכל צבאם .הארץ וכל אשר עליה .הימים וכל אשר בהם .והוא מחיה את הכל ברוב רחמיו וברוב חסדיו .ולא מטובו קדמו לו בריותיו .כי אם בטובו וחסדיו עליהם .כענין שנאמר טוב ד' לכל ורחמיו על כל מעשיו .ואומר זכור רחמיך וחסדיך כי מעולם המה .וכן הוא אומר מי הקדימני ואשלם .תחת כל השמים לי הוא .ואמרו חז"ל באגדה 156עתיד בת קול להיות מפוצצת בראשי ההרים ואומרת מה העל אל כל מי שפעל עם אל יבוא ויטול שכרו .ורוח הקודש אומר מי הקדמני ואשלם .מי קלס לפני עד שלא נתתי בו נשמה .מי אל לפני עד שלא נתתי לו בן זכר .מי עשה מזוזה לפני עד שלא נתתי לו בית .מי עשה מעקה לפני עד שלא נתתי לו בית וגג .מי עשה סוכה לפני עד שלא נתתי לו חצר .מי הניח לקט שכחה ופיאה עד שלא נתתי לו שדה .מי הפריש לפני תרומה ומעשר עד שלא נתתי עמ' 45
.154ישעיהו מ :י"ח ,כה. .155איוב י"ט:כ"ו –ומבשרי אחזה אלוה. .156מדרש תנחומא ,פרשת אמור ,סימן ז.
267
Gershon David Hundert לו גורן .מי הפריש לפני קרבן עד שלא נתתי לו בהמה .עלי לשלם שכרי .למה תחת כל השמים לי הוא .שהכל שלי ומשל הוא נותן לי .ובכל מקום עלי לשלם שכרו .ואמרו עוד מאי דכתיב והאלקים מלכי מקדם פועל ישועות בקרב הארץ .שהקדים לי שכר פעולתו .עד שלא נבראתי . כיצד גן עדן נברא בשלישי בשבת ואדם בששי .הווי שהקדים לי שכר פעולתו .עד שלא נבראתי .וכן הוא אומר הנה שכרו אתו ופעולתו לפניו .כלומר שהקדים שכרו של אדם עד שלא עשה הפעולה .הואיל והקביל ברא את השמים וכל צבאם .הארץ וכל אשר עליה .הימים וכל אשר בהם .כענין שנאמר בראשית ברא אלקים את השמים ואת הארץ .א"כ צריכין אנו להאמין .שהוא לבדו ברא את העולם בחכמתו וברצונו .ומחדש בכל יום תמיד מעשה בראשית . כענין שנאמר אתה הוא ד' לבדיך .אתה עשית את השמים שמי השמים וכל צבאם הארץ וכל אשר עליה .הימים וכל אשר בהם ואתה מחיה את כולם וצבא השמים לך משתחוים ואין אלקים אחר זולתו .כענין שנאמר אתם עדי נאום ד' ועבדי אשר בחרתי למען תדעו ותאמינו לי ותבינו כי אני הוא .לפני לא נוצר אל ואחרי לא יהי' .ואומר למען תדעו ממזרח שמש וממערב כי אפס בלעדי אני ד' ואין עוד .יוצר אור ובורא חושךעושה שלום ובורא רע אני ד' עושה כל אלה .וכן הוא אומר כה אמר ד' גואלך ויוצרך מבטן אנוכי האל עושה כל נוטה שמים לבדי רוקע הארץ מאתי .ואמרו חכמים באגדה .מי אתי כתוב שלא תאמר מיכאל מותח מכאן וגבריאל מכאן שעדיין לא נבראו המלאכים .לכך עמ' 46 כתוב מאתי כלומר מי הוא שותף עמי במעשה בראשית והלא לא נבראו המלאכים עדיין: לכן צריכין אנו להאמין ולעמוד על הודאי כי אלקים זה אשר ברא הכל הוא אחד ושמו אחד . כענין שנאמר שמע ישראל ד' אלקינו ד' אחד .והשמיעה הזאת היא קבלת הלב שנכוון בלבנו . ונקבל בשכלינו .שהקב"ה נמצא תמיד .כלומר הי' והווה ויהי' הי' קודם שנברא העולם .והווה תמיד בעוד שהעולם מתקיים .ויהי' אחרי שישוב העולם לתוהו ובוהו .וכתוב אלקינו לומר שצריכין אנו לקבל עלינו את אלוהותו .ואחר כתוב אחד לומר שצריכין אנו להאמין שהוא אחד ומיוחד .בכל מין יחוד בלא שיתרץ ובלא דמיון .ולא יצטרך אחר עמו ל… .וגם הוא אחד בלי שום הרכבה משום מעשה .ובלי שום גזירה .כי כל גזירותיו נגזרות וידועות וגלויות לפניו . ואין נמצא בעולם כאחדותו .וכן הזהירנו המקום בתורתו הקדושה שמחוייבים אנו לידע ולבחון בשכלינו את יחוד שמו ית' .כמו שנאמר וידעתם היום והשבות אל לבבך כי ד' הוא האלקים בשמים ממעל ועל הארץ מתחת אין עוד .וכן הוא אומר אתה הראית לדעת .כי ד' הוא האלקים בשמים ממעל ועל הארץ מתחת אין עוד: והוא ברוך הוא ראשון בלי ראשית וקדמון לא קדמו אחר .כמו שנאמר מעונה אלקי קדם .והוא ברוך הוא אחרון בלי אחרית וסוף .שנאמר אני ד' ראשון ואת אחרונים אני הוא .ואומר אני ראשון ואני אחרון ואין בלעדי מושיע והוא חי וקיים לעולמים ולנצח נצחים .ואין חקר ואין מספר לשנותיו .כענין שנאמר הן אל שגיא ולא נדע מספר שניו ולא חקר .ואומר ואתה הוא ושנותיך עמ' 47 וצריכין אנו לידע ולהבין שאין לבורא יתברך לא גוף .ולא גשם ותמונה ולא שום דמות .כמו שנאמר קול דברים אתם שומעים ותמונה אינכם רואים זולתו קול .ועוד כתוב ונשמרתם מאוד לנפשותיכם כי לא ראיתם כל תמונה .ורצה לומר בזה הזהרו במחשבותיכם ורעיוניכם .שלא תמשילוהו לבורא ית' לשום תבנית .ולא תדמוהו לשום דמות ודמיון .מפני שלא הרגשתם בחוש הראות .ומה דמות תערכו לו .והרבה מזה כתבתי לעיל .ע"כ צריך האיש הנולד להטריח נפשו ולהשתדל בכל מאמצי כחו לידע את בוראו מצד סימני מעשיו .ולא מצד הוייתו ועצם כבודו .כי מצד פעולותיו קרוב הוא מכל קרוב .ורחוק רחוק הוא מאוד מצד דמות עצם כבודו ועצמותו .מפני שאי אפשר למצוא ולדעת אותו בזה האופן מצד 157
.157תהילים עד :יב.
268
The Introduction to Divre binah by Dov Ber of Bolechów הוייתו .בלי ספק נמצא ונרגיש אותו מצד פעולותיו ואז יהי' קרוב לנו כאלו לא נפרד ממנו .וזה על דרך משל: במי שטרח להשיג השמש מצד אורו נצוצו וזריחתו ושקיעתו ועלייתו וירידתו ונטיותו זה בודאי יעמוד על מצאותו .ומשתמש לאורו ונהנה מזיבו ומגיע אל הענין המבוקש ממנו .אבל מי שיטריח לחקור על מהותו ולמצאו מצד יגולו ומכווין בענין להביט אל עין השמש בלי ספק תכהינה עינו ויפסיד אורם ולא יהנה מאור השמש .וכל טרדתו לבטלה .וכן יקרה לנו כשנשתדל להשיג מצאות הבורא יתברך .מצד אותות פעולותיו וחכמתו ויכולתו בכל הברואים ונשכיל ונבין בענינו .אז יאיר שכליות בידיעתו ונשיג ממנו כל מה שיש בבת שכליות להשיג .אבל אם נטריד ונטריח שכליות להשיג הוויתו ועצם כבודו ולדמותו ולהמשילו במחשבותינו לשים גוף וגשם בעולם נפסיד שכלינו עמ' 48 והכרתינו ולא נשיג בהם שום דבר .כמו שיקרה לזה שרוצה להביט אל עין השמש וזהרו כדי להשיג מהותו .ולכן צריכין אנו להזהר מאוד בענין זה ולזכרו חקירתינו על מצאות ד' ואחדותו ובקדמותו לדעת כי הוא יתברך איננו גוף ולא כח בגוף ואי אפשר להמשילו לשום דבר:
269
AJS Review 33:2 (November 2009), 271–303 © Association for Jewish Studies, 2009 doi:10.1017/S036400940999002X
I N Q UEST
OF
B ABYLONIAN TANNAITIC T RADITIONS : T HE C ASE OF TANNA D’B EI S HMUEL by
Barak Shlomo Cohen* I The question of the existence of Babylonian rabbinic traditions dating from the mishnaic period (pre-220 CE) has not been thoroughly and methodically addressed in the scholarly literature. Historians have pointed out that several rabbis were active in Babylonia during the mishnaic period; some researchers have even suggested that in this early period, organized rabbinic intellectual activity already existed in cities such as Nisibis,1 Nehardea,2 and Husal.3,4 However, a systematic examination of halakhot whose provenance was Babylonia *I wish to express my gratitude to the Taylor-Schechter Geniza Research Unit of Cambridge University for making available to me their collection of Cairo Geniza fragments. I would especially like to thank Dr. Ben Outhwaite and Dr. Friedrich Niessen of the Taylor-Schechter Unit for their time and assistance. I would also like to thank the Beit Shalom-Kyoto Foundation at Bar-Ilan University for its generous support. 1. See S. Funk, Die Juden in Babylonien 200–500 (Berlin: Poppelauer, 1902), 1:7; J. Bruell, Mavo HaMishnah (Frankfurt, 1836; repr., Jerusalem: Makor, 1970), 30; W. Bacher, Agadot Hatannaim, vol. I, part II (Yaffo: Eitan & Shoshani, 1932), 102; I. Halevy, Dorot Harishonim, (Berlin and Vienna: B. Hertz, 1933), 5:681–88; J. Obermeyer, Die Landschaft Babylonien im Zeitalter des Talmuds und des Gaonats (Frankfurt: I. Kauffmann, 1929), 129; A. Hyman, Toldot Tannaim Veamoraim, (London: Express, 1910), 1:425; A. Neubauer, La Géographie Du Talmud (Hildesheim: G. Olms, 1967), 370; M. Smallwood, The Jews under Roman Rule (Leiden: Brill, 1976), 416; I. Gafni, Yehudei Bavel bitkufat Hatalmud (Jerusalem: Zalman Shazar Letoldot Israel, 1991), 77; A. Oppenheimer, “HaMercaz BeNetzivin Bitkufat Hamishnah,” in Umma Vetoldoteha, ed. M. Stern (Jerusalem: Zalman Shazar Letoldot Israel, 1983), 1:41–150; idem, Babylonia Judaica in the Talmudic Period (Wiesbaden: Reichert, 1983), 331; idem, “Nehardea unetzivim Batkufa Hapartit,” Bar Ilan Annual 26–27 (1995): 117–30; idem, “Batei Midrashot BeBavel Lifnei Hatimat HaMishnah,” in Yeshivot UBatei Midrashot, ed. I. Etkes (Jerusalem: Zalman Shazar Letoldot Israel, 2006), 20–21. 2. On rabbinic activity in Nehardea during the mishnaic period, see M. D. Yudolowitz, Hayyei HaYehudim Bizman Hatalmud: Sefer Nehardea (Jerusalem: Makor, 1971), 30–31; Oppenheimer, Babylonia Judaica, 287–91; idem, “Batei Midrashot,” 23–28. 3. Scholars have posited that Husal was a center of rabbinic activity after the Bar Kokhba revolt. According to this theory, it was in Husal that the Babylonian literary corpus of halakhic midrashim from the academy of R. Ishmael (D’Bei R. Ishmael) was created. See Halevy, Dorot Harishonim, 5:181–93, 678–81; J. N. Epstein, Mevo’ot Lesifrut Hatannaim (Jerusalem and Tel Aviv: Magness Press, 1957), 168–71; J. Neusner, A History of the Jews in Babylonia (Leiden: Brill, 1965), 1:128–35, 179–87; E. Z. Melamed, “Hilkhot Eretz Yisrael Beor Hatnnaim BeBavel,” in Iyyunim Besifrut Hatalmud
271
Barak Shlomo Cohen in the mishnaic period has yet to be undertaken. Most prior attempts to uncover Babylonian rabbinic activity from this period have focused on a few traditions ascribed to Tannaim who had a known connection to Babylonia, such as R. Judah b. Bathyra,5 R. Nathan,6 and R. Hiyya7 (the “Babylonians,” as they are sometimes called in rabbinic literature).8,9 In light of the absence of a systematic study of Babylonian pre-talmudic rabbinic traditions, Gafni came to the following conclusion, one that this paper will support with solid evidence: Even if there was a composed Babylonian halakhic tradition that originated before the end of the mishnaic period, it seems that the Palestinian tradition was accepted as the main tradition of the Babylonian sages already at the beginning of the amoraic period. Moreover, when this tradition penetrated into the Babylonian centers of learning, it seems to have completely pushed
(Jerusalem: Magness Press, 1986), 292. For a reexamination of this evidence and this supposition, see n. 9 herein. 4. Nineteenth-century historians and maskilim tended to push back the development of centers of Torah learning in Babylonia to the beginning of the talmudic period. In contrast, historians who identified with the emerging Orthodox movement tended to stake the opposite claim, namely, that a center of Torah learning in Babylonia was operative from as early as the Second Temple period, and perhaps even earlier. It is clear that both of these tendencies can be tied to the political and religious leanings of the authors, and to the struggle between those historians and intellectuals who placed themselves in the Haskalah Reform camp and those from the traditionalist Orthodox camp. See I. Gafni, “Ben Bavel LeEretz Yisrael: Olam Hatalmud Veimutim Ideologim Behistoriagraphia Shel Haet Hachadashah,” Zion 82 (1997): 213–42. 5. See, e.g., Halevy, Dorot Harishonim, 5:677. 6. See Funk, Die Juden in Babylonien, 1:ii n. 2; Halevy, Dorot Harishonim, 6:178–210; Epstein, Mevo’ot Lesifrut hatannaim, 168–71; Melamed, “Hilkhot Eretz Yisrael Beor Hatnnaim BeBavel,” 292. 7. See, e.g., Hyman, Toldot Tannaim Veamoraim, 1:425. 8. See Gafni, Yehudei Bavel bitkufat Hatalmud, 85 n. 144, 87 n. 154. A further attestation to R. Natan’s Babylonian origins is the fact that R. Sherira Gaon calls R. Natan’s mishnah “matnita deBavlai”; see R. Sherira Gaon, Iggeret R. Sherira Gaon, ed. B. M. Levine (Jerusalem: Makor, 1972), French ascension, 41. The appellation haBavli is attached to R. Hiyya in three passages in the Bavli: Eruvin 90a, Shabbat 60b, and Keritot 8a. For a collection of passages that testify to R. Hiyya’s Babylonian origins and his migration to Israel at a late stage in his life, see O. Meir, R. Yehudah Hanasi: D’yukano shel Manhig Bemasoret Eretz Yisrael UBavel (Tel Aviv: Hakibuts Hameukhad, 1999), 69–70. 9. Most of the evidence that scholars have claimed connects halakhic traditions with Babylonia in the mishnaic period (concerning these three sages) is based on preconceived notions or on tendentious interpretations of sources, as was noted by Gafni, Yehudei Bavel bitkufat Hatalmud, 86–91. Doubtful also are the attempts of several scholars (see Halevy, Dorot Harishonim, 678–79; Epstein, Mevo’ot Lesifrut Hatannaim, 518–20) to identify parts of the Ishmaelian midrashim (such as R. Yonatan, R. Oshaya) as Babylonian. See Gafni, Yehudei Bavel bitkufat Hatalmud, 50–54; M. Kahana, “Maalat Yeshivat Eretz-Yisrael BaMekhilta Devarim,” Tarbiz 72 (1993): 512–13 nn. 50–54; idem, “The Halakhic Midrashim,” in The Literature of the Sages, ed. S. Safrai, Z. Safrai, J. Schwartz, and P. Tomson, part 2 (Van Gorcum: Assen, 2006), 62–63; Oppenheimer, “Batei Midrashot,” 27–28. I wish to thank Professor D. Henshke for directing my attention to Kahana’s remarks on this issue.
272
In Quest of Babylonian Tannaitic Traditions aside other traditions, causing them to become almost untraceable…. This subject still awaits thorough treatment by talmudic researchers, and at this stage we can discuss only the amount of rabbinic intellectual activity that existed in Babylonia before the talmudic period began…. Reason dictates that after the destruction of the Temple and the Bar-Kochba revolt, as sages began to arrive in Babylonia, the basic foundations of the rabbinic activity were established.10
There are some fifty instances in the two Talmuds in which a baraita’ is ascribed to Shmuel through the appellation Tanna D’Bei Shmuel, a “Tanna from the House of Shmuel” (henceforth, TDBS). These compose one of the largest collections of baraitot identified by scholars as representative of pre-talmudic Babylonian halakhah, and as such, they serve as perhaps the best focal point for a study of the issue at hand. In our discussion, we will critically examine the nature of the halakhah presented in this corpus, focusing especially on its connection with Palestinian halakhah. We will reexamine the claim that the content of the halakhot found in TDBS baraitot is Babylonian in origin. As we shall see, most of these halakhot are actually anchored in earlier, tannaitic, Palestinian halakhah. This conclusion will allow us to reopen the larger question of the existence of pre-talmudic Babylonian halakhic traditions and cast some doubt on many scholarly theories—theories that were often not based on a thorough examination of the evidence. In the end, we will have a greater awareness and appreciation of the tremendous influence that Palestinian tannaitic traditions had on Babylonian rabbinic study, even in the early talmudic period. II Shmuel and his influence on Babylonian talmudic halakhah have been the focal points of many scholarly studies.11 In contrast, few studies have focused on the nature and origin of the fifty or so tannaitic traditions ascribed to his 10. Gafni, Yehudei Bavel bitkufat Hatalmud, 90–91. 11. Listed here are just a few of the main studies that deal with this issue: D. Hoffmann, Mar Samuel: Rector der Jüdischen Akademie zu Nehardea in Babylonien: Lebensbild eines Talmudisch, vol. 1 (Leipzig: Leiner, 1873); S. Fessler, Mar Samuel: der bedeutendste Amora: Rektor der Juedischen Akademie zu Nehardia in Babylonien (Halle: E. Franck, 1879); A. Krochmal, “Toldot Shmuel Yarhinai,” Hechalutz 1 (1852): 66–89 (repr., Jerusalem, 1972); H. Graetz, History of the Jews (Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society of America, 1893), 2:518–30; I. Weiss, Dor Dor Vedorshav (Jerusalem and Tel Aviv: Ziv, 1962), 3:146–56; P. R. Weis, “The Controversies of Rab and Samuel and the Tosefta,” Journal of Semitic Studies 3 (1958): 288–97; D. Gordis, “Al Parshanut Rav Ushmuel Lamishnah Ubaraita: Part One: Nimukei Halakhah Veokimtaot” (PhD diss, Jewish Theological Seminary, 1980); Sh. Shilo, Dina Demalkhuta Dina (Jerusalem: Defus Academi, 1975), 4–43; B. M. Bokser, Samuel’s Commentary on the Mishna: Its Nature, Forms, and Content (Leiden: Brill, 1975); idem, Post-Mishnaic Judaism in Transition (Samuel on Berakhot and the Beginnings of Gemara) (Chico, CA, 1980); E. Halivni, Kelalei Pesak Hahalakhah Batalmud (Lod, Haberman Institute, 1999), 84–98, 107; R. Kalmin, “Changing Amoraic Attitudes toward the Authority and Statements of Rav and Shmuel: A Study of the Talmud as a Historical Source,” Hebrew Union College Annual 63 (1992): 83–106. I will make reference to a few other studies later.
273
Barak Shlomo Cohen “academy” in the two Talmuds,12 traditions that are introduced by the terms Tanna D’Bei Shmuel, Tannei Shmuel, or Matnita DeShmuel. While some general remarks have been made about these traditions, it is difficult to glean from these generalities anything specific concerning their origin or nature. David Tzvi Hoffman described this collection of baraitot as “oral traditions from different teachers.”13 So, too, Jacob N. Epstein described the collection as “mostly derived from various ancient sources.”14 According to David Goodblatt, the source of this collection of baraitot remains a mystery.15 Solomon Funk16 and Abraham Goldberg,17 who delved deeper into these traditions, tended to see them as a reflection of Babylonian tannaitic traditions stemming from the pre-talmudic era. Some of these studies even ascribed an interpretive agenda to these baraitot—they were intended to adapt Rabbi Judah Hanasi’s Mishnah, which was, of course, Palestinian in origin, to prior Babylonian tradition. Goldberg, who dedicated an entire study to this topic, came to the following conclusion: 12. This count is based on Epstein’s lists, which he based mainly on the textual evidence gleaned from medieval commentaries; see J. N. Epstein, Mavo Lenusah HaMishnah (Jerusalem: Magness Press, 2000), 1:213–14. It should be noted that Epstein was concerned with the entire corpus of tannaitic traditions, and not merely the tannaitic traditions in TDBS baraitot. The following is the full list: Shabbat 12a (manuscripts), 35b (manuscripts), 54a, 131b; Eruvin 70b, 96a, 99b; Pesahim 3a, 39b (three instances); Rosh Hashanah 16a (manuscripts); Yoma 70a; Sukkah 56b; Betzah 29a; Megillah 4b (manuscripts); 23a (manuscripts), 30a; Moed Katan 18b; Gittin 24b (manuscripts), 66a (manuscripts), 70b (manuscripts); and Bava Metzia 111a (manuscripts). Bacher compiled a list of twelve traditions (W. Bacher, Tradition und Tradenten in den Schulen Palästinas und Babyloniens [Leipzig: Fock, 1914], 225), but this list was based solely on the printed edition of the Talmud. In the Yerushalmi, there are more than twenty cases of baraitot that are introduced with the term Tannei Shmuel or Matnita DeShmuel. The following is a full list of these cases: Berakhot 1:1, 4b; 1:1, 4d; Sheviit 5:1, 35d; Kilayim 8:2, 31c; Shabbat 1:3, 3b (based on the Leiden manuscript); 2:1, 4d; 3:3, 6a; 8:4, 11b; 9:3, 12a; 11:1, 13a; 17:3, 16b; Eruvin 2:5, 20b; 6:7, 23d; 6:8, 24a; Pesahim 9:6, 37a; Rosh Hashanah 1:1, 56b; Betzah 2:5, 61c; Taanit 3:9, 66d; Megillah 1:1, 70b; 2:1, 73a; 3:4, 74b; 4:4, 75b; Hagigah 1:1, 76a; and 1:1, 80b. Concerning the parallel meaning of the terms Tanne Shmuel in the Yerushalmi and Tanna D’Bei Shmuel in the Bavli, see Hoffman, Mar Samuel, 25 n. 3; Bacher, Tradition und Tradenten in den Schulen Palästinas und Babyloniens, 208; idem, “Mishnayot Hitzoniyot Umidrashei Tannaim,” Jerusalem 10 (1914), 68–70; Epstein, Mevo’ot Lesifrut Hatannaim, 212. My analysis of this material serves to strengthen the assumption of the essential identity between the two terms. 13. Hoffman, Mar Samuel, 24. It is difficult to glean any concrete information on our subject from Krochmal’s general remarks; see Krochmal, “Toldot Shmuel Yarhinai,” 78. 14. Epstein, Mavo Lenusah HaMishnah, 213. Rashi (Betzah 29a, s.v. tanna d’bei) explained in a similar fashion. 15. See D. Goodblatt, Rabbinic Instruction in Sassanian Babylonia (Leiden: Brill, 1975), 134. The TDBS baraitot did not merit any discussion in Bokser’s two books (see n. 11 herein) concerning Shmuel’s commentary on tannaitic sources. This absence was noted by E. Segal in his review of Bokser’s book, “Hamaavar Mitkufat HaMishnah el Tekufat Haamoraim,” Tarbiz 51 (1982): 317. 16. Funk, Die Juden in Babylonien, 62. Funk did not present any proof for this claim. 17. A. Goldberg, “Shimusho Shel Rava Ba Tosefta Ube’Tanna D’Bei Shmuel’ LaPerush Hamishnah,” Tarbiz 40 (1971): 144–77. I. H. Weiss, Dor Dor Vedorshav, 150, provided a later date for the editing of this collection and ascribed it to Shmuel: “The great Amoraim of the first generation compiled collections of mishnahs entitled ‘baraitot’ or ‘toseftot’… He too (Shmuel, B.C.) compiled a collection of baraitot and they are introduced with the phrase: Tanna D’Bei Shmuel.”
274
In Quest of Babylonian Tannaitic Traditions What emerges from our study is that the main function of “Tanna D’Bei Shmuel ” is to adapt the Mishnah, in any place possible, to the Babylonian halakhic tradition, even if this requires a forced interpretation of the Mishnah or a slight emendation of its language.18
Goldberg reached this conclusion based on one source alone (Bavli Yoma 70a), in which he found a similarity in halakhah between a baraita’ ascribed to TDBS and tannaitic traditions in the Yerushalmi that he ascribed to Tanna D’Bei R. Yishmael. According to Goldberg, R. Yishmael’s students settled in Babylonia after the Bar Kokhba revolt, and were the source for the Babylonian halakhic tradition found in the TDBS baraita’ in the Bavli.19 Even if we accept Goldberg’s conclusion, in reality, all it does is demonstrate a connection between the halakhah as represented in TDBS sources and a Palestinian halakhic tradition, albeit one that differs from the Mishnah. “This is not a case of ‘Babylonian tradition’ versus ‘Palestinian tradition’ but rather two different Palestinian traditions (the Mishnah and the Tanna D’Bei R. Yishmael baraita, B.C.) that arrived in Babylonia with a gap of only one generation between them.”20 Indeed, as we shall see, there is a deep connection between the baraitot ascribed to TDBS in the Bavli (and to Tannei Shmuel in the Yerushalmi) and other Palestinian tannaitic halakhic traditions, and Goldberg’s work only serves to further demonstrate this. Hanokh Albeck raised a similar claim with regard to the Babylonian provenance of these halakhot, but from a different perspective. Albeck’s research into the TDBS baraitot is part of his larger study of collections of baraitot ascribed to the Amoraim who transmitted them in the two Talmuds (such as Tannei X or “A tanna taught in front of Rabbi X”).21 Based on a few external literary characteristics shared by these collections of baraitot, Albeck concluded as follows, The baraitot transmitted by Amoraim differ from the baraitot that were transmitted anonymously in that the former are usually short, contain no disputes and do not mention the name of any tanna, whereas the latter are longer, contain disputes and mention the names of Tannaim. The content and form of the baraitot transmitted by Amoraim testify that they were later creations and that they were transmitted according to the name of the amora who taught them or arranged them, whereas the anonymously transmitted baraitot 18. Goldberg, “Shimusho Shel Rava Ba Tosefta,” 149–50. 19. Goldberg, “Shimusho Shel Rava Ba Tosefta,” 148. The theory that there was a mass movement of rabbis from Palestine to Babylonia after the Bar Kokhba revolt can be found in a number of studies. Within the framework of this theory, the claim is made that among these rabbis were the students of R. Ishmael. See Halevy, Dorot Harishonim, 674ff.; Neusner, A History of the Jews in Babylonia, 1:141–44; Smallwood, The Jews under Roman Rule, 510–11. This theory was rejected because of a lack of supporting evidence; see Gafni, Yehudei Bavel bitkufat Hatalmud, 82ff.; Kahana, “Maalat Yeshivat Eretz-Yisrael,” 512 n. 50–52. 20. Gafni, Yehudei Bavel bitkufat Hatalmud, 91 n. 175. 21. H. Albeck, Mehkarim Babraita Ubatosefta Veyachasan LaTalmud (Jerusalem: Mosad Harav Kuk, 1970), 15–43; idem, Mavo LaTalmudim (Tel Aviv: Dvir, 1969), 28–39.
275
Barak Shlomo Cohen were older, and they begin with, “Our Rabbis taught,” or just “It was taught.”22
Albeck’s claim that these baraitot are “new, and their origin is not from Tannaim in the mishnaic period”23 is based on general evidence gleaned from an examination of a broad literary corpus of halakhot, and not on a specific examination of the halakhot represented in Shmuel’s baraitot. In about 70 percent of the cases, the halakhah presented in the TDBS baraitot reflects Palestinian tannaitic halakhah,24 even if the literary style of these baraitot (as Albeck noted) or linguistic expression (see below)25 is reflective of late Tannaim or early Amoraim. This finding makes it difficult to accept the claim that the content of the halakhot in TDBS baraitot is late in origin. Rather, we should distinguish between their language and style, which may reflect later editing, and their halakhic content, which is usually faithful to and reflective of earlier Palestinian tannaitic tradition.26 We should note that the same phenomenon exists in general with regard to many baraitot that appear in the Bavli —they are faithful representations of Palestinian halakhah as found in the Tosefta and the Yerushalmi, even though there are significant stylistic and linguistic differences between them and their corresponding Palestinian versions, differences whose origins mostly lie in the editorial activity of later Babylonian tradents.27 We will discuss this phenomenon at greater length.28 22. Albeck, Mavo LaTalmudim, 28. 23. Albeck, Mehkarim Babaraita, 32. 24. See n. 33 herein and the examples discussed in the body of this work. 25. For a concrete example of an expression found in a TDBS baraita’ that is common among late Tannaim or early Amoraim in Palestine and Babylonia, see the discussion below, near note 67, in regard to the term “Leilei” ( )ליליin the TDBS baraita’ (replacing “Or” [ ]אורin the Mishnah). For another such example in which an expression found in a TDBS baraita’ seems to be a later emendation, even though the content of the baraita’ is reflective of tannaitic Palestinian tradition, see S. Friedman, Tosefta Atikta: Masekhet Pesah Rishon (Ramat-Gan: Bar-Ilan University Press, 2003), 230–38. 26. This distinction was drawn by Albeck himself; see his Mavo LaTalmudim, 71–72. 27. There are numerous examples of this phenomenon that have been already noted by talmudic scholars. See M. Moreshet, “Habaraitot Haivriot BaBavli Enan Lashon Hakhamim Aleph,” in Sefer Zikharon LeHanoch Yalon (Ramat-Gan: Bar-Ilan University Press, 1974), 275–314; S. Friedman, Talmud Arukh: Perek Hasokher et Haomanin, Hanusah (Jerusalem: JTS Press, 1997), 12 n. 38; idem, “Habaraitot BaTalmud HaBavli Veyahasan Lemakbiloteihen ShebaTosefta,” in Atara Lehayyim— Mehkarim Besifrut Hatalmudit Veharabanit Likhvod Professor Hayyim Zalman Dimitrovsky, ed. D. Boyarin, M. Hirshman, S. Friedman, M. Shmeltzer, and I. Ta-Shma (Jerusalem: Magness Press, 2000), 166–96, esp. 195–96 and the bibliography, n. 112; B. Katzoff, “Yahas Habaraitot BaTosefta Lemakbiloteihen Hatalmudiyot: Iyyun Mehudash Leor Masekhet Berakhot,” Hebrew Union College Annual 75 (2004): 1–24 (Hebrew section). Also taken into account must be the possibility that the TDBS baraitot reflect an early Babylonian tradition, one that is parallel to the Palestinian tannaitic tradition. See, e.g., Y. Elman, Authority and Tradition: Toseftan Baraitot in Talmudic Babylonia (Hoboken, NJ: Yeshiva University Press, 1994), 277–81; cf. Friedman, Tosefta Atikta: Masekhet Pesah Rishon, 195 n. 112. According to this theory, the TDBS baraitot reflect a Palestinian halakhic tradition that stems from an alternative source, similar to the theory suggested by Goldberg, which I have described earlier. 28. There are scholars who have cast doubt on the reliability of the attribution of statements to specific Amoraim in the Bavli. See William Scott Green, “What’s in a Name? The Problematic of
276
In Quest of Babylonian Tannaitic Traditions There are twenty-five instances in which the Bavli ascribes a baraita’ to Tanna/Tannu + [D]’Bei Shmuel (including instances found only in manuscripts).29 Because the term Bei Rav X in the Bavli refers to the academy headed by Rabbi X,30 the phrase Tanna D’Bei Shmuel should be understood as baraitot taught in the name of Shmuel.31 In more than twenty instances in the Yerushalmi, these baraitot are transmitted with the term Tannei Shmuel or Matnita DeShmuel.32 In thirty of these fifty or so baraitot, the halakhic content is parallel to Palestinian halakhic traditions found in the Tosefta and in the Yerushalmi (about 70 percent of the overall cases).33
Rabbinic ‘Biography,’” in Approaches to Ancient Judaism: Theory and Practice (Missoula, MT: Scholars Press, 1978), 77–96; Jacob Neusner, “Evaluating the Attributions of Sayings to Named Sages in the Rabbinic Literature,” Journal for the Study of Judaism 26 (1995): 93–111. Other scholars, myself among them, do not cast blanket doubt on the accuracy of all such attributions, but rather accept their accuracy unless there are specific reasons not to. Recent research into the Bavli that has focused on issues such as the chronology of the Babylonian sages, the existence of historical layers within sugyot, the Bavli’s terminology, the hierarchical relationship between its sages, the study patterns of the Babylonian Amoraim, and a variety of other such topics has tended to support the general reliability of the attribution of statements to Amoraim in the Talmud, although one must still, of course, be cautious in accepting any given attribution. For a survey of some important studies on this issue, see Y. Elman, “How Should a Talmudic Intellectual History Be Written? A Response to David Kraemer’s Responses,” Jewish Quarterly Review 89 (1999): 378. To Elman’s article, we should add A. Cohen, “Bikoret Hilkhatit Leumat Bikoret Sifrutit Besugyot Hatalmud,” Asufot 3 (1989): 346 n. 75; Richard Kalmin, “Rabbinic Literature of Late Antiquity as a Source for Historical Study,” in Judaism in Late Antiquity, ed. J. Neusner and Alan J. Avery-Peck (Leiden: Brill, 1999), 187–99; Y. Kelman, “Haokimta Haamorait ‘Hakha Bemai Askinan,’ Hamityaheset Lemekorot Hatannaim—Tiva, Ofya Vetzurata” (PhD diss., Bar-Ilan University, 2002), 353–54; A. Cohen, “Was Age the Decisive Criterion of Subordination among the Amoraim?” Jewish Quarterly Review 92 (2002): 289 n. 35; D. Halivni, “Iyyunim Behithavut HaTalmud,” Sidra 20 (2005): 69–70; B. Cohen, “Rav Sheshet Leumat Rav Nahman: Shtei Shitot Parshaniyot Lemekorot Tannaim,” Hebrew Union College Annual 76 (2005): 32; idem, “Rami ber Hama Leumat Rava: Analogiot Parshaniot uPsikatiot Batalmud.” Dine Israel 25 (2008): 184 n. 155; idem, “Nigudim Bedarkhei Halimmud shel Amoraei Nehardea Haaharonim,” Hebrew Union College Annual 78 (forthcoming). 29. The following is the full list: Shabbat 12a (manuscripts), 35b (manuscripts), 54a, 131b; Eruvin 70b, 96a, 99b; Pesahim 3a, 39b (three times); Rosh Hashanah 16a (manuscripts); Yoma 70a; Sukkah 56b; Betzah 29a; Megillah 4b (manuscripts), 23a (manuscripts), 30a; Moed Katan 18b; Gittin 24b (manuscripts); 66a (manuscripts), 70b (manuscripts); Bava Metzia 111b (manuscripts). 30. For a discussion of this term, see Goodblatt, Rabbinic Instruction in Sassanian Babylonia, 149–51; I Gafni, “Hearot Lemaamaro shel Goodblatt,” Zion 46 (1981): 54; J. Rubenstein, “The Rise of the Babylonian Rabbinic Academy—A Reexamination of the Talmudic Evidence,” Jewish Studies, an Internet Journal 1 (2002): 56 n. 6. 31. R. Sherira Gaon, in his talmudic chronology, calls the collection “Baraita D’Bei [Mar (absent in Oxford II)] Shmuel ”; see R. Sherira Gaon, Iggeret Rav Sherira Gaon, 47. Rashi calls this collection “The Tosefta that Shmuel Arranged”; see Rashi, Betzah 29a s.v. tanna d’bei. 32. For a discussion concerning the essential similarity between the different technical terms found in the two Talmuds and their reference to the same collection of baraitot ascribed to Shmuel, see n. 12 herein. A list of the appearance of these terms in the Yerushalmi can also be found there. 33. The following is a complete list of cases in which TDBS baraitot have a parallel in Palestinian tannaitic literature. Bavli: Shabbat 12a (see Yerushalmi Shabbat 6:2, 8b; Tosefta Shabbat 1:2
277
Barak Shlomo Cohen With the exception of one case,34 there are no Palestinian tannaitic traditions that parallel the other TDBS traditions, meaning these traditions neither contradict Palestinian sources nor are affirmed by them. We will examine this through a number of representative examples, culled from both Talmuds.
(1) Bavli Eruvin 89a–b Mishnah:35 All the roofs of a town are considered to be a single domain, provided no roof is ten handbreadths higher or lower [than the neighboring roof], the words of Rabbi Meir. The sages say: each one is its own domain. Gemara: (1) It was stated: Rav said: They may carry only within four cubits, and Shmuel said: It is permitted to carry throughout its area….36 (2) It taught in the mishnah: The sages say: each one is its own domain. (3) This goes well according to Shmuel but it is a difficult for Rav! (4) They said in the House of Rav in the name of Rav: [The mishnah means that] one may not carry an object two cubits on one roof and another two cubits on an adjacent roof. (5) [Is this so?] 37 But didn’t R. Elazar say, “When we were in Babylonia we used to say: The House of Rav in the name of Rav said: ‘They may carry in it only within four cubits,’ whereas those of the House of Shmuel (D’Bei
[ed. Lieberman, 3]; and S. Lieberman, Tosefta Kifshuta, Seder Moed [New York, 1962], 3:9); Shabbat 35b (see Tosefta Sukkah 4:12 [ed. Lieberman, 274–75]; S. Lieberman, Tosefta Kifshuta, 4:894); Shabbat 131b (see D. Henshke, “Tekiat Shofar Beshabbat,” Sidra 8 [1992], 24–25); Eruvin 70b (see Y. Dinnur, Hiddushei HaRitzad, Seder Moed [Jerusalem, 1981], 1:125); Eruvin 96a; Eruvin 89b (see below inside, near footnote n. 35); Pesahim 3a (see below inside, near footnote n. 66); Pesahim 39a (three times) (see Friedman, n. 25 herein); Yoma 70a (see Goldberg, n. 17 herein); Rosh Hashanah 16a (see below inside, near footnote n. 54); Sukkah 56b (see Tosefta Sukkah 4:24 [ed. Lieberman, 277]); Megillah 4b (see Yerushalmi Megillah 1:1, 70b); Moed Katan 18b (see Tosefta Moed Katan 1:10 [ed. Lieberman, 367]; and S. Lieberman, Tosefta Kifshuta, 5:1237]; Gittin 66a (see Yerushalmi Gittin 3:1, 44c); Bava Metzia 111b; Zevahim 12a (see Yerushalmi Shabbat 19:5, 17b). Yerushalmi: Berakhot 1:1, 2b (see L. Ginzberg, Perushim Vehidushim BaYerushalmi [New York, 1941], 1:22– 23); Kilayim 8:2, 31c (see below inside, near footnote n. 82); Shabbat 3:3, 6a (see Bavli Shabbat 40a); Shabbat 8:4, 11b (see Tosefta Shabbat 8:19 [ed. Lieberman, 33]; and Bacher, Tradition und Tradenten in den Schulen Palästinas und Babyloniens, 68 n. 3); Shabbat 19.3, 12a (see below inside, near footnote n. 89); Shabbat 11:1, 13a (see Tosefta Shabbat 10:1 [ed. Lieberman, 41]); Pesahim 9:6, 36a (see Tosefta Pesahim 9:9 [ed. Lieberman, 192]); Megillah 3:4, 74b (see Tosefta Megillah 3:1 [ed. Lieberman, 353]; and Lieberman, Tosefta Kifshuta, 5:1165]; Hagigah 1:1, 90b (see Bavli Moed Katan 4a). To this list, we should add Yerushalmi Berakhot 4:1, 7c (see Epstein [n. 12 herein], 891–92). 34. Bavli Shabbat 54a. This source presents a tannaitic tradition that seems to contradict a halakhah found in the Tosefta. For further analysis, see A. Goldberg, Perush LaMishnah: Masekhet Shabbat (Jerusalem: JTS Press, 1976), 93. 35. The Mishnah, here and in subsequent passages, is quoted from the Kaufman manuscript. 36. This debate between Rav and Shmuel appears also in Yerushalmi Eruvin 9:2, 25c. 37. The part in the brackets is added based on Munich 95, Oxford Opp. ADD. Fol. 23, and Vatican 109.
278
In Quest of Babylonian Tannaitic Traditions Shmuel) taught, ‘they have use only of their own roof.’” (6) What does it mean, “they have use only of their own roof?” Is it not that they are permitted to carry throughout its entire area? (7) Does this have greater force than our Mishnah which we have explained to mean, “That one must not carry an object two cubits on one roof and another two cubits on an adjacent roof,” so too here [we can explain], two cubits on one roof and two cubits on the other.
In section 5, R. Elazar (b. Pedat), a Palestinian Amora of Babylonian origin and a student of Rav and Shmuel,38 presents a tannaitic tradition from the House of Shmuel through use of the words “Those of the House of Shmuel [D’Bei Shmuel] taught [tannu],” where the verb tannu appears after the expression “[of] the house of Shmuel.”39 This expression, parallel to the expression Tanna D’Bei Shmuel,40 appears one other time in the Bavli,41 where it is also employed by an Amora contemporary with “those of the house of Shmuel”—R. Nahman (b. Yaakov), who cites it in front of his student, Rava.42 In contrast, when fourth-generation and later Amoraim (Abbaye, Rava, R. Papa, and Ravina)43 cite baraitot ascribed to Shmuel, they do not use this phrase but rather the more typical Tannei D’Bei Shmuel. In other words, Amoraim chronologically closer to Shmuel44 do not cite a collection of baraitot that they refer to as Tannei D’Bei Shmuel, but rather use traditions ascribed to the members of Shmuel’s house.45 Indeed, it is likely that “those of the House of Shmuel” is not a technical phrase but rather is firsthand testimony of R. Elazar (or R. Nahman) concerning sages from his own generation. 38. See Z. Frankel, Mavo HaYerushalmi (Breslau: Shlater, 1870; facsimile edition: Jerusalem: Omanim, 1967), 111b; Hyman. Toldot Tannaim Veamoraim, 1:192; Albeck, Mavo LaTalmudim, 224. 39. In the Bavli, the term “Be [Rav] X ” refers to the yeshiva or academy that was headed by X; see n. 30 herein. 40. See Bacher, Tradition und Tradenten in den Schulen Palästinas und Babyloniens, 225, n. 10; Goodblatt, Rabbinic Instruction in Sassanian Babylonia, 132 and n. 86. 41. Eruvin 70b. 42. R. Sherira Gaon identifies R. Nahman as Shmuel’s student (Iggeret R. Sherira Gaon, 82) but this claim raises a chronological difficulty. For a discussion of this issue, see A. Cohen, Ravina Vehakhmei Doro: Iyyunim Beseder Hazemanim shel Amoraim Aharonim BeBavel (Ramat-Gan:Bar-Ilan University Press, 2001), 74 n. 46; B. Cohen, “Yeshivot Mekomiot BeBavel Betekufat HaTalmud,” Zion 70 (2005): 449 n. 11; B. S. Cohen, “‘May You Live to One Hundred and Twenty’: The Extraordinary LifeSpan of Several Babylonian Amoraim according to Rashi,” Review of Rabbinic Judaism 10 (2007): 231–33. In any case, the period in which R. Nahman was active, the last half of the third century and the first half of the fourth century, accords with the period of “those of the house of Shmuel,” to whom his comments relate. 43. Abbaye: Shabbat 54a; Betzah 29a. Rava: Rosh Hashanah 16a (see below inside, near footnote n. 54); Yoma 70a; Sukkah 56b; Megillah 23a; Bava Metzia 111b. Rav Papa: Zevahim 12a. Ravina: Pesahim 39b (in this passage, Ravina comes into contact with R. Aha the son of Rava, meaning that this is Ravina the colleague of R. Ashi [see Cohen, Ravina Vehakhmei Doro, 232]). 44. Concerning the dating of R. Nahman and the question of whether he was a student of Shmuel, see n. 42 herein. 45. Bacher understands the expression “those of the house of Shmuel” as referring to “reciters” who were active in Shmuel’s academy and collected baraitot; see Bacher, Tradition und Tradenten in den Schulen Palästinas und Babyloniens, 225 n. 10.
279
Barak Shlomo Cohen The word tannu functions here as a verb and not a technical literary term.46 In sum, only from the fourth generation47 of Amoraim onward did this collection of baraitot become a collection of halakhot that received the appellation Tanna D’Bei Shmuel. The content of the baraita’ ascribed to the House of Shmuel (“they have use only of their own roof”) accurately reflects the most straightforward interpretation of the sages’ opinion in the Mishnah. According to the simple meaning of this mishnah, R. Meir considers all the roofs of the city to be one domain, and therefore allows one to carry vessels from one roof to another roof,48 as long as those vessels are on the roof at the beginning of the Sabbath and the height of the roof is ten handbreadths. In contrast, the other sages view each roof as a separate entity and therefore do not allow one to carry from one roof to another.49 Rav further limits the sages’ opinion, interpreting their statement to mean that one can only carry within a radius of four cubits on any given roof. Rashi explains that according to Rav, “since the rabbis hold that each [roof] is its own domain and each roof is open to one another—each [roof] causes the other to be prohibited, for each is considered a domain completely open to another domain into which it would be forbidden to carry.”50 In contrast, Shmuel, who holds that one can carry within the entire area of any given roof, remains closer to the simple interpretation of the sages’ opinion in the mishnah. Shmuel’s own opinion is identical to that of the tannaitic tradition preserved in the baraita’ ascribed to “those of the House of Shmuel.”51 The similarity between the mishnah’s halakhah, stating that “each one is its own domain,” and Shmuel’s baraita’, claiming that “they have use only of their own roof,” is also confirmed by the attempt of the anonymous voice in sections 5 and 6 (the stam)52 to reject Rav’s interpretation of the mishnah through the use of Shmuel’s baraita’, and in section 7 to resolve 46. Concerning the interpretation of the term tannei/tannu to mean “quote,” “recite,” or “review,” see W. Bacher, Die Exegetische Terminologie der Jüdischen Traditionsliteratur (Leipzig: J. C. Hinrichs, 1899), 238; J. Levy, Wörterbuch über die Talmuds und Midraschim (Darmstadt: Harz, 1963), 4:653; M. Jastrow, A Dictionary of the Targumim, the Talmud Babli and Yerushalmi, and the Midrashic Literature (New York: Pardes, 1971), 1681; M. Sokoloff, A Dictionary of Jewish Babylonian Aramaic of the Talmudic and Geonic Periods (Ramat-Gan and Baltimore: Bar-Ilan University Press, 2002), 1218–19. 47. See n. 43 herein. 48. See Tosefta Eruvin 7:12 (ed. Lieberman, 131). 49. See H. Albeck, Seder Moed: Mefurash Perush Hadash im Mevo’ot Hosafot Vehashlamot (Tel Aviv: Dvir, 1952), 119–20; S. Lieberman, Tosefta Kifshuta, 3:448–49; Goldberg, Perush LaMishnah: Masekhet Eruvin (Jerusalem: Magness Press, 1976), 253–55; see also S. Krauss, Kadmoniyot HaTalmud, vol. I, part 2 (Berlin and Vienna: Moriah, 1934), 417. 50. Rashi, s.v. ele be’arba amot. 51. The stam (the anonymous voice in the Bavli) connects the dispute between Rav and Shmuel with the question of whether to apply a legal concept called “[fictionally] extend its walls (god asik mehitzata).” However, Moscovitz demonstrated that this legal fiction is not actually present in tannaitic sources in Talmudic Reasoning (From Casuistics to Conceptualization) (Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2002), 187–88. 52. See D. Halivni, Makorot Umasorot, Eruvin VePesahim (Jerusalem: Magness Press, 1982), 232–33.
280
In Quest of Babylonian Tannaitic Traditions Rav’s opinion by using the same forced interpretation to Shmuel’s baraita’ that he used when solving the difficulty on Rav brought directly from the mishnah (section 4).53 In sum, the D’Bei Shmuel tannu baraita’ transmits the same content as the mishnah’s halakhah but in language different from that found in the Mishnah itself. The content of the baraita’ does not differ from the simple, unforced interpretation of the sages’ opinion in the mishnah. The halakhic similarity between these two sources provided the stam (the anonymous voice in the Bavli) with a source with which to reject Rav’s more difficult interpretation of the mishnah. (2) Bavli Rosh Hashanah 16a Mishnah: At four set times the world is judged: on Pesah. in respect of the produce; on Atzeret (Shavuot) in respect of the fruits of the tree; on Rosh Hashanah all the people of the world pass before Him like the sons of Meron, as it says, “He who fashions the hearts of them all, who discerns all their doings” (Psalms 33:15); and on the H.ag (Sukkot) they are judged in respect of rain. Gemara: Whose opinion is that in our mishnah? Rava54 said: This Tanna [of our Mishnah] is the Tanna D’Bei Shmuel, since in the House of Shmuel55 it was taught: “At four set times the world is judged, on Pesah. in respect of the produce, on Atzeret (Shavuot) in respect of the fruits of the tree, on the H.ag (Sukkot) they are judged in respect of rain, and man is judged on Rosh Hashanah and his judgment is sealed on Yom Hakkipurim.” And when they taught our mishnah—[it referred to] the beginning of judgment.
In three other places in the Bavli, Rava explains that the halakhah of a mishnah accords with a baraita’ attributed to TDBS,56 as he does here in Rosh Hashanah.57 To limit the scope of our discussion, we will focus on the information 53. See the parallel in the Yerushalmi (above, n. 36), where a difficulty against Rav is raised from the following mishnah (Eruvin 9:2). Like the Bavli, the Yerushalmi also has great difficulty in explaining Rav’s opinion. 54. Munich 140 reads “Ravina.” It seems that the reading “Rava” should be preferred because Rava is the Amora who customarily quotes TDBS baraitot as an explanation of the Mishnah. Concerning this tendency of Rava, see Bacher, Tradition und Tradenten in den Schulen Palästinas und Babyloniens, 225; Epstein, Mavo Lenusah HaMishnah, 213–14; Goldberg, “Shimusho Shel Rava Ba Tosefta,” 144–77. 55. “Tanna D’Bei Shmuel” is the version found in Cambridge T-S F1(2)43 (R. Shmuel), Leningrad-Antonin 502, London Harl. 5508 (400), Munich 95, JTS Rab. 108 (EMC 319), JTS Rab. 218 (EMC 270), and Oxford Opp. Add. Fol 23. This is also the version found in the commentary of R. Hananel; see D. Metzger, ed., Perushei Rabbenu Hananel bar Hushiel LaTalmud (Jerusalem: Vagshal, 1994), 38. In contrast, London Or. 5558A/23, Munich 140, and JTS Rab. 1608 (ENA 850) all read “Tanna D’Bei R. Yishmael.” Concerning the preference of the reading “Tanna D’Bei Shmuel,” see Epstein, Mavo Lenusah HaMishnah, 213; Albeck, Mehkarim Babraita UbaTosefta, 45.
281
Barak Shlomo Cohen found within the TDBS baraita’ itself, and not on Rava’s interpretation of the baraita’, which attempts to draw a parallel between the baraita’ and the mishnah at hand. Shmuel’s baraita’ can be separated into two parts. The first part lists three “set times” in which the world is judged: in respect of produce, the fruit of the tree, and water. This section is identical to the halakhic content of the Mishnah, and also to R. Judah’s opinion in a baraita’ found in the Tosefta quoted below (and in a parallel in the Bavli)58 and to an anonymous baraita’ brought in the Yerushalmi (1:3, 57a).59 The second part of the baraita’ contains some information not found in the Mishnah, namely, that human beings are judged on Rosh Hashanah and that their judgment is sealed on Yom Kippur. Significantly, this same opinion is found in Tosefta Rosh Hashanah 1:13 (ed. Lieberman, p. 308): All are judged on Rosh Hashanah and their decree is sealed on Yom Hakippurim, the words of R. Meir. R. Judah says: All are judged on Rosh Hashanah and each and everyone’s decree is sealed in its time: on Pesah. in respect of the produce; on Atzeret (Shavuot) in respect of the fruits of the tree; on Sukkot in respect of rain and each man’s decree is sealed on Yom Hakippurim. R. Yose says: man is judged every day, as it says, “You inspect him every morning” (Job 7:18).
Despite their dispute, both R. Meir and R. Judah agree that a man is judged on Rosh Hashanah and that his decree is sealed on Yom Hakippurim, as is found in the second half of the TDBS baraita’.60 Shmuel’s opinion is in complete agreement with that of R. Judah’s from the Tosefta, which is also found in the parallel version in the Bavli. It is clear, therefore, that in this case, both parts of the TDBS baraita’ have parallels in Palestinian tannaitic literature. (3) Bavli Shabbat 12a Mishnah: A tailor must not go out with his needle near nightfall lest he forget and go out [after the Sabbath has begun]. Nor a scribe with his quill. And one 56. Bavli Megillah 27a; Sukkah 56b; Bava Metzia 111b (based on manuscript evidence; see Epstein, Mavo Lenusah HaMishnah, 213–14). 57. In another instance (Bavli Sukkah 56b), Rava challenges R. Judah’s opinion based on a tradition found in a TDBS baraita’. 58. Rosh Hashanah 16a. Concerning the connection between Rava and the TDBS baraitot, see n. 54 herein. 59. See A. Goldberg, “Al Shtei Hamishnayot Harishonot shel Masekhet Rosh Hashanah,” Tarbiz 29 (1952): 326 n. 1. Goldberg, basing his comments on the printed edition, treats this case as a Tanna D’Bei R. Yishmael baraita’ (See n. 55 herein). 60. See R. David Pardo, Hasdei David (Jerusalem: Vagshal, 1994), 2:399, s.v. hakol nidonin; R. Yehezkel Avramsky, Tosefta im Perush Hazon Yehezkel, vol. 2, Seder Moed (Jerusalem, 2000), 10–11, s.v. hakol nidonin beR”H; see also J. Tabory, Moadei Yisrael Bitekufat HaMishnah VehaTalmud (Jerusalem: Magness Press, 2000), 220.
282
In Quest of Babylonian Tannaitic Traditions may not search his garments [for lice or fleas], nor read by the light of a lamp. Gemara: Tanna D’Bei Shmuel:61 A man may go out with his tefillin on the eve of Sabbath near nightfall ()עם חשיכה. What’s the reason? Because Rabbah bar R. Huna said: One must check his tefillin every hour, kal vehomer, from [the High Priest’s] diadem. If in the case of the diadem, which contains the Divine Name only once, yet the Torah said, “And it shall always be on his forehead” (Exodus 28:38)—[which means] that he should not divert his mind from it, then with the tefillin, which contain the Divine Name many times, how much more so! Therefore he will remember [that they are on his head and he will not go out with them on Shabbat].
Shmuel’s baraita’ allows one to go out while wearing tefillin close to nightfall on Friday eve. He is not concerned “lest the tefillin stay on his head once it is already dark,” which would be a transgression of the prohibition of carrying in the public domain on the Sabbath.62 The Bavli explains this opinion by citing an amoraic statement according to which “one must check his tefillin every hour … therefore he will remember.” Shmuel’s baraita’ also appears in Yerushalmi Shabbat 6:2, 8b: One may go out63 with tefillin on the eve of Shabbat near nightfall, but one may not go out with a nailed sandal on the eve of Shabbat near nightfall. What is the difference between the two? This one it is his custom to remove, and this one it is not his custom to remove.
According to the Yerushalmi, one is allowed to wear tefillin close to sunset on Friday evening because that is the time of day when people would always remove their tefillin after having worn them all day, as was the custom in those times. Because the tefillin would normally be removed at that time, there was no great concern that he would forget and leave them on and carry them in the public domain on the Sabbath.64 The same halakhah also appears in Tosefta Shabbat 1:11 (ed. Lieberman, p. 3): “They may go out with tefillin near nightfall. 61. This is the version found in JTS ENA 2069.22; R. Hananel (see D. Metzger, ed., Perushei Rabbenu Hananel bar Hushiel LaTalmud [Jerusalem: Vagshal, 1995], 14; Sefer Haitim, ed. Y. Shor [Kraków: Mekizei-Nirdamim, 1903], 7); Tosafot, Menahot 36b, s.v. i’ kasavar; and in the writings of other rishonim. In contrast, Munich 95, Oxford Opp. Add. Fol. 23, Vatican 127, and the printed editions read Tanna D’Bei R. Yishmael. Concerning the preference of the reading Tanna D’Bei Shmuel, see Epstein, Mavo Lenusah HaMishnah, 213; S. Lieberman, Tosefta Kiftshuta, 3: 9. 62. Rashi s.v. im hashekhah. 63. As is well known, the Yerushalmi often does not employ technical terms to introduce tannaitic traditions. See S. Lieberman, Al HeYerushalmi (Jerusalem: Darom, 1929), 29; idem, “Talmuda shel Kesarin,” Musaf Tarbiz 2 (1931): 19; Albeck, Mehkarim Babaraita Ubatosefta, 4; Albeck, Mavo LaTalmudim, 21; B. Katzoff, Hayahas ben HaTosefta VehaYerushalmi Lamasekhet Shabbat (PhD diss., Bar-Ilan University, 2004), 297–99. 64. The P’nei Moshe, s.v. velo haishinan, explains, “since it is customary to remove tefillin at nightfall, he won’t forget them [and carry them into the public domain].” See also Goldberg, Perush LaMishnah, 13.
283
Barak Shlomo Cohen And they may read the Holy Scriptures near nightfall, but they may not read them on the Sabbath eve itself.” Lieberman notes the similarity between the two baraitot, “This baraita (from the Tosefta, B.C.) is brought on Bavli Shabbat 12a in the name of Tanei [D’Bei] Shmuel.” Lieberman even explains the two sources in an identical fashion: There is no doubt that in Palestinian terminology “ ”עם חשיכהmeans close to nightfall… . Here they taught “ ”עם חשיכהwhich means before they lit the Sabbath candles. At that time they would remove their tefillin, and the baraita teaches us that it is permitted to go out with tefillin, to the courtyard and to the public domain, meaning that it is permitted to wear tefillin until right before nightfall, similar to “reading the Holy Scriptures” mentioned immediately after, and there is no fear lest he go out with them to the public domain after dark.65
Like the cases discussed earlier, this case demonstrates the connection between Shmuel’s baraita’ in the Bavli and the Palestinian tannaitic tradition. (4) Bavli Pesahim 2a–3a Mishnah: At the light [or] of the fourteenth [of Nissan] they check for leaven with the light of the candle. Gemara: What is “at the light”? R. Huna says, “At twilight” [naghei]. And R. Judah says, “At night” [leilei]. Come and hear, the House of Shmuel taught (Tanna D’Bei Shmuel):66 On the night [leilei] of the fourteenth they check for leaven with the light of the candle. Therefore, “at the light” refers to “at night.” Rather … all agree that “at the light” refers to “at night,” and they don’t disagree, rather one says according to [the typical way of saying things in] his place and the other according to [the typical way of saying things in] his place. In Rav’s place the call it “twilight” [naghei] and in R. Judah’s place they call it “night” [leilei].
On the exact correspondence between the halakhah in Shmuel’s baraita’ and that found in the mishnah, Shamma Friedman writes, “Shmuel’s baraita is nothing but the language of our mishnah, with one small change, ‘night’ (leilei) instead of ‘light’ (or).”67 Shmuel’s baraita’ is presented by the stammaitic editors68 as decisive proof that or in the mishnah refers to night (as is the opinion of R. Judah), and
65. Lieberman, Tosefta Kifshuta, 3:9; see also Goldberg, Perush LaMishnah, 13. 66. Sasson-Luntzer is the only manuscript that reads D’Bei R. Yishmael. 67. S. Friedman, “Lashon Hamoadim (I): ‘Or Learba Asar,’” in Mehkarim Batalmud Ubamidrash, ed. M. Bar-Asher, J. Levinson, and B. Lifshitz (Jerusalem: Mosad Bialik, 2005), 495. The expression or learba asar from the Mishnah also appears in several parallel passages; see Mekhilta de-Rabbi Shimon bar Yohai, Bo 17 (ed. Epstein-Melamed, 22); Tosefta Pesahim 1:1 (ed. Lieberman, 140). 68. On the late dating of this sugya, see the note 69 below.
284
In Quest of Babylonian Tannaitic Traditions this after nine other proofs failed.69 Indeed, it is indisputable that the meanings of the two expressions are identical.70 There is no doubt that or in rabbinic Hebrew means “night.” Nevertheless, whereas J. N. Epstein claims that the two different expressions, or and leilei, stem from two parallel tannaitic sources,71 Friedman views Shmuel’s leilei as a later revision of the earlier or. He writes, “‘or l …’ is the earlier version, as opposed to ‘leilei’ [which is] a later version, and an expression more commonly found in the words of later Tannaim and even early Amoraim in both Palestine and Babylonia.”72 In any case, even if we accept Friedman’s opinion that the expression in Shmuel’s baraita’ is a later revision of the word or in the Mishnah, the halakhic content found in the TDBS baraita’ is again identical to the Palestinian halakhic tradition. (5) Yerushalmi Shabbat 3:4, 6a73 Mishnah: It once happened that the people of Tiberias conducted a pipe of cold water through an aqueduct of hot springs. The sages said to them: if this happened on the Sabbath, it is like hot water heated on the Sabbath, which is forbidden both for washing and for drinking. If on a festival, it is like water heated on a festival, which is forbidden for washing but permitted for drinking. Gemara: Hot water heated on a festival, and similarly hot water heated on the eve of the Sabbath for the Sabbath: Rav and Shmuel, one says: “One may use it to wash his face, hands and legs,” and the other says, “One may use it to wash his limbs, one limb at a time.” And we do not know which one said this and which one said this. From that which Shmuel taught (tannei): “One may use 69. According to D. Halivni, Makorot Umasorot: Seder Moed, Eruvin VePesahim (Jerusalem: JTS Press, 1982), 376, the stam did not originally use the TDBS at the outset as a “conclusive proof,” because the editors of the sugya were familiar with another version of the TDBS baraita’, a version that was the same as the language of the mishnah (or learba asar), as well as the baraitot in the Tosefta and in the Mekhilta de Rabbi Shimon bar Yohai (see n. 67 herein). Were we to accept Halivni’s theory, our claim here, concerning the connection between Shmuel’s baraita’ and the Palestinian tannaitic tradition, would be strengthened. Nevertheless, Albeck, Mavo LaMishnah (Jerusalem: Mosad Bialik-Dvir, 1959), 173 n. 31, identified the opening sugya of Pesah as a “saboraic” sugya. According to Albeck, the multiplicity of rejected proofs can be explained by the desire of the editors to exhaust all possibilities of explaining or as “evening,” until the final proof could be brought from Shmuel’s baraita’. Concerning the identification of this sugya as saboraic, see A. Weiss, Hayetzirah shel HaSavoraim: (Helkam Beyetzirat HaTalmud) (Jerusalem: Magness Press, 1953), 12, n. 22. On the characteristics of the saboraic literature in the Bavli, see A. Cohen, “The Saboraic Halakhah in Light of bKiddushin 2a–3b and the Geonic Tradition,” Diné Israel 24 (2007): 161–214. 70. Albeck, Mavo LaMishnah, 173 n. 31; see also Epstein, Mevo’ot Lesifrut Hatannaim, 352–54; Friedman “Leshon Hamoadim,” 475. 71. Epstein, Mevo’ot Lesifrut Hatannaim, 236. 72. According to Friedman, “Leshon Hamoadim,” 509, the earlier expression or learba asar was replaced as a result of interpretive concerns. Friedman writes, “The idiomatic style ‘or learba asa’ and phrases similar to it were perceived by late Tannaim and early Amoraim as a style that required explanation, and some even saw fit to replace them with more easily understood expressions.” 73. The text of the Yerushalmi here and in subsequent passages is based on the Leiden manuscript.
285
Barak Shlomo Cohen it to wash his face, hands, and legs,” it can be concluded that Rav was the one who said, “One may use it to wash his limbs, one limb at a time.”
In this parallel, Shmuel’s baraita’ is introduced with the term Tannei Shmuel, a term parallel to Tanna D’Bei Shmuel74 found elsewhere in the Bavli. This baraita’ was used by the editor(s) of the sugya in the reconstruction of the halakhic opinions of Rav and Shmuel,75 under the assumption that Shmuel’s opinion is the same as that found in a baraita’ transmitted under his name.76 The same opinion is ascribed to Shmuel in Bavli Shabbat 40a: “It was stated: Hot water that was heated up on the eve of the Sabbath: Rav says, ‘On the next day one may use it to wash one’s whole body, one limb at a time,’ and Shmuel says, ‘They only allowed one to wash one’s face, hands and legs.’”77 The mishnah prohibits washing (on the Sabbath) with water that has been heated on the Sabbath because this is like cooking, which is prohibited.78 In contrast, the dispute between Rav and Shmuel relates to the question of the use of hot water heated on the eve of the Sabbath. As stated, the opinion of Shmuel matches that found in the baraita’ transmitted under his name, “Shmuel taught: One may use it to wash his face, hands and legs.” This halakhah has a precise parallel in Tosefta Betzah 2:10 (ed. Lieberman, pp. 288–89):79 One may not rinse with hot water heated on the festival, and there is no need to say [that this is prohibited] on the Sabbath. But on the Sabbath one may wash his face, hands and feet with water that was heated on the eve of the Sabbath, 74. See n. 12 herein. 75. Concerning sugyot in which the Yerushalmi transmits amoraic statements without certainty of their attribution, see Frankel, Mavo HaYerushalmi, 38b; Bacher, Tradition und Tradenten in den Schulen Palästinas und Babyloniens, 548–65; D. Halivni, Midrash, Mishnah, and Gemara (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1986), 147 n. 24; Cohen, Ravina, 239 n. 30; Y. Sussman, “‘Torah Shebe’al Peah’ Pshutah Kemashma’a—Koho shel Kotzo Shel Yod,” Mehkarei Talmud (2005), 3: 270–71 n. 38a. We should note that this phenomenon is especially prevalent in the Bavli with regard to disputes between Rav and Shmuel on matters of Aggadah. The Bavli uses the phrase, “Rav and Shmuel dispute the matter, one says … and one says …” See Cohen, Ravina, 233 n. 1. 76. I. Francus, ed., Talmud Yerushalmi: Masekhet Betzah im Perush Ehad Hakadmonim Rabbenu Elazar Azkari Baal Sefer Haredim (New York: JTS Press, 1995), 151, s.v. min mah detanei. The assumption that Shmuel’s own opinions are identical to those found in his baraitot is common in both Talmuds. For a detailed analysis of the relationship between Shmuel and TDBS baraitot, see the addendum at the end of this essay. 77. See also Yafeh Enayim, s.v. hamin shehuchmu; B. Ratner, Ahavat Tzion VeYerushalayim: Masekhet Shabbat (Jerusalem: Makhon Muzal Me’esh, 1967), 50; I. Francus, Mehkarim Beharkavah shel Masekhet Betzah ShebaTalmud HaBavli Ubedarkei Arikhatah (PhD diss., Hebrew University, 1961), 242–43. 78. In contrast to Bavli Shabbat 39b, which connects the explanation with the prohibition of “covering [food to keep it warm],” the context of this mishnah in Chapter 3 and its explanation in the Yerushalmi show that the prohibition stems from a concern that this would look like prohibited cooking. See A. Weiss, “Perushim Vehearot Latext Uleseder HaMishnah shel Masekhet Shabbat,” Horev 7 (1943): 12–13; Goldberg, Perush LaMishnah, 66. 79. Lieberman, Tosefta Kifshuta, 5:952.
286
In Quest of Babylonian Tannaitic Traditions and there is no need to say [that this is permitted] on the festival with water that had been heated on the eve of the festival.
The Tosefta explicitly prohibits one from washing anything more than one’s face, hands, and legs with water that had been heated before the Sabbath, the same halakhic opinion found in Shmuel’s baraita’, and attributed to Shmuel in both Talmuds. The same baraita’ is brought, with some variants, in Bavli Shabbat 40a, as a support for Shmuel’s opinion in the dispute: It was taught in a baraita in accordance with Shmuel: Water that was heated on the eve of the Sabbath, the next day one may use it to wash one’s face, hands and legs, but not one’s whole body, even one limb at a time. And it wasn’t even necessary to state [that this is permitted] with water that was heated on the eve of the festival.80
The Bavli goes on to quote two additional baraitot that also support Shmuel’s opinion and contradict that of Rav.81 Again, as in the other cases, Shmuel’s opinion reflects the halakhic tradition of the Palestinian Tannaim. (6) Yerushalmi Kilayim 8:2, 31c R. Hama bar Ukba82 in the name of R. Yose b. R. Hanina said: One who leads two different animals yoked together [kilayim] is lashed… . But didn’t Shmuel teach [tannei]: If he was standing outside of the city limits and he called it and it came after him, behold this one is exempt. There, it (the animal) goes on its own volition; here it goes against its will.
The passage opens with the opinion of R. Yose bar R. Hanina, a Palestinian Amora of the second generation,83 who holds that leading an animal by voice
80. The text of the baraita’ is based on Oxford Opp. Add. Fol. 23; see Lieberman, Tosefta Kifshuta, 5:952. 81. See Y. Dinnur, Hidushei HaRitzad, 28, s.v. bat’hila, who tries to find some halakhic basis in a tannaitic source for Rav’s words. Dinnur concludes, “Most people prohibited washing one’s whole body, as you can see from the baraitot that were brought here to support Shmuel.” Even so, it is not impossible that the baraita’ found on Bavli Shabbat 39b (and its parallel) relate to water heated on the eve of the Sabbath; see Dinnur, Hidushei HaRitzad, 28; Goldberg (above, n. 65). According to this possibility, Rav’s opinion could match the lenient opinion of R. Shimon in the baraita’. 82. Vatican 33 reads, “Rabbi Nehemiah bar Ukba,” a fourth-generation Babylonian Amora who may have been from the exilarch’s family. See G. Herman, Rashut Hagolah BeBavel Bitkufat HaTalmud (PhD diss., Hebrew University, 2005), 233. R. Hama bar Ukba, on the other hand, is a thirdgeneration Palestinian Amora (see Frankel, Mavo HaYerushalmi, 86a; Albeck, Mavo LaTalmudim, 238–339) who in both Talmuds transmits statements in the name of R. Yose bar Hanina (as in this case; see Bavli Pesahim 52b; Sukkah 37b; Yerushalmi Sheviit 9:1, 38d; Pesahim 7:9, 35a; Ketubbot 2:10, 26d). Hence, this reading seems preferable. 83. See Frankel, Mavo HaYerushalmi, 102b; Albeck, Mavo LaTalmudim, 185–86.
287
Barak Shlomo Cohen alone is considered to be of legal significance,84 and therefore, if one calls out to two animals of different species that were yoked together and they move, he has transgressed the prohibition of kilayim (see Deuteronomy 22:10). Against this opinion, the passage brings Shmuel’s baraita’, according to which one who “calls” an animal that is found outside the Sabbath border into the Sabbath border is exempt from causing his animal to pass through the Sabbath border, because Shmuel holds “the animal comes on its own when it is called … and he doesn’t transgress by the fact that his animal has on its own gone out of its Sabbath border.85 This is what the Yerushalmi means when it explains, “it goes on its own volition.” A similar halakhah appears in a baraita’ on Bavli Shabbat 151a, and in Tosefta Shabbat 17:12, (ed. Lieberman, p. 82): “They may not wait at the Sabbath border [toward the end of Shabbat in order to immediately] fetch an animal.86 If it was outside the border, he may call to it so that it comes.” From this baraita’, it is clear that on the Sabbath, one may call an animal that is outside the Sabbath border if one happens to be there, but he may not go to this border on the Sabbath in order to wait for it to get dark so that he can immediately go out and bring the animal back.87 Lieberman again points out the parallel between Shmuel’s baraita’ and that found in the Tosefta. He writes, “There is no doubt that most of the commentators were correct when they explained that this [Shmuel’s baraita’, B.C.] is the same halakhah as that found in our Tosefta.”88 Just as in the previous two cases, there is a clear correspondence between the halakhah found in Shmuel’s baraita’ in the Yerushalmi and the tannaitic halakhic tradition found in the Tosefta and in the Bavli. (7) Yerushalmi Shabbat 19:3, 12a Mishnah: They may wash a child before his circumcision and after his circumcision and they may sprinkle water on him by hand, but not with a vessel. Gemara: R. Abbahu in the name of R. Yohanan: The halakhah goes according to the one who says that they may wash the child. R. Yose said: You must say that they may wash the child. Shmuel taught [tannei]:89 They [never]90 stop one from putting oil or hot 84. See P’nei Moshe, s.v. vetanei. 85. R. Yehezkel Avramsky, Tosefta im Perush Hazon Yehezkel, vol. 2, Seder Moed (Jerusalem, 2000), 113, s.v. kore lah. From here, we can conclude that if he led the animal by pulling it, he would be liable, as Shmuel implies in the Yerushalmi quoted here; see also, Lieberman, Tosefta Kifshuta, 3:288. 86. See Lieberman, Tosefta Kifshuta, 3:287–88; Goldberg, Perush LaMishnah, 387. Concerning the meaning of the phrase מחשיכין על התחום, see B. Cohen, Mishnah and Tosefta: A Comparative Study—Part 1: Shabat (New York: JTS Press, 1935), 143. 87. Lieberman, Tosefta Kifshuta, 3:287–88; Goldberg, Perush LaMishnah, 387. 88. Lieberman, Tosefta Kifshuta, 3:288. It is possible to explain the TDBS baraita’ as exempting ex post facto one who calls an animal, whereas the Tosefta permits it ab initio. In any case, even if we explain the opinion in the Shmuel baraita’ in this way, it is still anchored in tannaitic halakhah. 89. In a parallel in Genesis Rabbah 80:25 (ed. Theodor-Albeck, 962), the word Shmuel is missing. However, his name is found in another parallel on Yerushalmi Shabbat 9:3, 12a. 90. The bracketed word לעולםis found in the parallel in Yerushalmi Shabbat 9:3, 12a.
288
In Quest of Babylonian Tannaitic Traditions water on a wound on the Sabbath. R. Yose said: R. Zera and R. [Ba]91 would92 always come and say to me, “Recite our mishnah, ‘And not only that, but they may also sprinkle water on a wound on Shabbat.’ If you say that they may wash [the child after] circumcision, what is the difference between the wound of an adult and the wound of a minor?”93
The Tannei Shmuel baraita’ allows any wound to be cleansed with oil or hot water on Shabbat, and not just that of a child after circumcision (see below).94 The baraita’ is brought as proof that the mishnah should not read as, “they may wash the [wound from] circumcision,” rather, “they may wash the child.”95 In his commentary on the Yerushalmi, R. Moshe Margoliot explains, “If you say that the mishnah should read ‘they wash the [wound from] circumcision,’ then what is the difference between the wound of an adult and the wound of a child, and why would the mishnah have specified ‘they wash the [wound from] circumcision,’ for other wounds of adults are washed as well with hot water.”96 According to H. Albeck, the baraita’ quoted by R. Yose, the one that his teacher R. Zera97 told him to recite frequently,98 is the continuation of Shmuel’s baraita’. The intention of this continuation was to expand upon the leniency mentioned before—not only do we not withhold oil or hot water, but we even sprinkle (“”זלף99) it upon the wound.100 It turns out, therefore, that R. Yose’s baraita’ not only matches the halakhah found in Shmuel’s baraita’, but even expands on it.101 This halakhah, which 91. The bracketed word באis absent in the parallel in the Yerushalmi. 92. The bracketed word הוהis found in the parallel in the Yerushalmi Shabbat 9:3, 12a. 93. In the Leiden manuscript, this entire sugya is found in the margins of the manuscript. 94. See also the statement of Rav in the Bavli 134b: “Rav said: they don’t prevent one from putting hot water or oil on a wound on Shabbat.” 95. See Epstein, Mavo Lenusah HaMishnah, 55–56. 96. P’nei Moshe, s.v. amar R. Yose. 97. Concerning the identification of R. Yose, the student of R. Zera, see Frankel, Mavo HaYerushalmi, 111b; Albeck, Mavo LaTalmudim, 334–36. 98. Epstein, Mavo Lenusah HaMishnah, 55 n. 4. This literary style is common for R. Yose in the Yerushalmi; see S. Lieberman, HaYerushalmi Kifshuto, 2nd ed., ed. M. Katz (Jerusalem and New York: JTS Press, 2008), 162. 99. I. Kohut, ed., Arukh Hashalem (New York, 1955), 3:294. The Arukh’s explanation is quoted from the commentary of R. Gershon Meir Hagolah to Moed Katan; see N. Zakash, ed., Kovetz Rishonim Lemasekhet Moed Katan (Jerusalem:Makhon HaTalmud HaIsraeli Hashalem, 1966), 60. Concerning the meaning of the root זל”פin rabbinic Hebrew, see Levy, Wörterbuch über die Talmuds und Midraschim, 1:539; S. Krauss, Talmudische Archäologie (Leipzig, 1910), 1:228; Jastrow, Dictionary of the Targumim, 1:401; E. Ben-Yehuda, Milon Halashon HaIvrit (Jerusalem-New York: T. Yoslof, 1960), 2:1348; Sokoloff, Dictionary of Jewish Babylonian Aramaic), 415. 100. Albeck, Mehkarim Babaraita UbaTosefta, 101. 101. Compare Shmuel’s own opinion, Bavli Shabbat 134b, “And Shmuel said: He can put it on the side of the wound, and it runs down onto the wound.” It is also, of course, possible that the baraita’ transmitted by R. Yose in the name of R. Zera was not meant to be the end of Shmuel’s baraita’ but rather to bolster it through the use of another tannaitic source. In any case, this is not relevant for the issue at hand.
289
Barak Shlomo Cohen allows one to use hot water on Shabbat to take care of a wound, is found in Tosefta Shabbat 15:4102 (ed. Lieberman, 69): And one may sprinkle hot water on [the circumcision wound] and not only that but one may sprinkle hot water on [any] wound.
Lieberman103 and Goldberg104 correctly pointed out that this toseftan baraita’ (and its parallel in the Yerushalmi) relates to the use of hot water on the Sabbath by any person, and not just for the sake of a circumcised child: “That is to say, not just a child who is still weak and the wound was put in a place where there is a threat to his life, but any person can pour hot water on his wound [on the Sabbath].”105 Again, the halakhah found in Shmuel’s baraita’ fully accords with the Palestinian tannaitic halakhah, both that found in the Tosefta and in the baraita’ in the Yerushalmi, which R. Yose quotes in the name of R. Zera. The permission that Shmuel grants to use oil to heal a wound on Shabbat106 is also mentioned in tannaitic literature, in Tosefta Shabbat 12:12 ([ed. Lieberman, 53]; see also Tosefta Terumot 9:12 [ed. Lieberman, 159]): “A person may anoint his wounds with oil, as long as he doesn’t dip it with a cloth or rag.” Lieberman also pointed out that a similar halakhah appears in Mishnah Shabbat 14:4, “The children of royalty may anoint their wounds with rose oil, since it is their practice to anoint themselves thus on weekdays. Rabbi Shimon said: all Israel are royal children.”107 From this mishnah Lieberman concluded, “From here we can see that all agree that one can anoint one’s wounds with regular oil on the Sabbath.” As in all of the previous cases, again the halakhah in Shmuel’s baraita’ that allows anyone to use hot water and oil on the Sabbath in order to care for wounds is anchored in Palestinian tannaitic halakhah. (8) Bavli Bava Metzia 111a Mishnah: The wages of a man or the renting of a beast or the renting of utensils, each is subject to the rules “You must pay him his wages on the same day” (Deut. 24:15) and “You may not retain the wages of a laborer with you until the morning” (Lev. 19:13). When is this so? When [the employee] demanded it, but if he did not demand it [the employer] does not commit a transgression. 102. See also Cohen, Mishnah and Tosefta, 129. 103. Lieberman, Tosefta Kifshuta, 3: 245. 104. Goldberg, Perush LaMishnah, 332. 105. Lieberman, Tosefta Kifshuta 3: 245. 106. Concerning the treatment of a wound with oil, water and other substances during the mishnaic and talmudic periods see, J. Preuss, Biblical and Talmudic Medicine, trans. and ed. F. Rosner (London: Aronson, 1993), 238–39. 107. Lieberman, Tosefta Kifshuta, 2:461. The Tosafot on Bavli Shabbat 134b, s.v. v’ein mon’in, explain, “since it teaches, ‘the children of kings anoint their wounds with rose oil’ we can deduce that for other people it is permitted to put other types of oil on their wound [on the Sabbath].”
290
In Quest of Babylonian Tannaitic Traditions A resident alien is subject to the rule, “You must pay him his wages on the same day,” but he is not subject to the rule, “You may not retain the wages of a laborer.” Gemara: [As] it is taught: “From among your brothers” (Deut. 24:14)—this excludes Gentiles [aherim]; “your stranger”—this refers to a righteous proselyte; “in your gates”—this refers to one who eats carrion. From this I know [the rule only with regard to a man’s wages], how do I know to extend the same rule to beasts and utensils? Scripture says, “in your land,” anything that is in your land. And in respect of all these, one [can] transgress all of these rules. From here they said: The wages of a man or the renting of a beast or the renting of utensils, each is subject to the rules, “You must pay him his wages on the same day” and “You may not retain the wages of a laborer.” R. Jose son of R. Judah said: A resident alien is subject to the rule, “You must pay him his wages on the same day” but not to the rule, “You may not retain [the wages of a laborer].” Animals and utensils are only subject to the rule, “You shall not oppress.”… Rava said: This tanna [of our Mishnah] is a tanna from the House of Shmuel108 [Tanna D’Bei Shmuel], for the House of Shmuel taught: The wages of a man or the renting of a beast or the renting of utensils, each is subject to the rules, “You must pay him his wages on the same day” and “You may not retain [the wages of a laborer].” A resident alien is subject to the rule, “You must pay him his wages on the same day,” but not to the rule, “You may not retain [the wages of a laborer].”
Rava identifies the Mishnah’s halakhah with the TDBS baraita’, both of which are contrasted with the preceding anonymous baraita’ that contains a different halakhah.109 In five other places in the Bavli,110 Rava identifies the Mishnah with a TDBS baraita’. One of these examples was discussed earlier.111 In another case,112 Rava identifies the Mishnah with a tanna of the House of Menashe (Tanna D’Bei Menashe),113 meaning a collection of baraitot identified with Rav Menashya, a third- or fourth-generation Babylonian Amora.114
108. This is the version preserved in the geniza fragment Antonin 1190 (= A. Y. Katz, Ginzei Talmud Bavli [Jerusalem: Reuven Mas, 1979], 2:212), in Munich 95, in Vatican 116–17, and in the Saloniki printed edition. The other printed editions, Hamburg 165, Florence, Ascorial G-I-3, and Vatican 115 all read, “is a tanna from the House of R. Yishmael, for it was taught in the House of R. Yishmael.” Concerning the preference for the version, “Shmuel,” see Epstein, Mavo Lenusah Hamishnah, 1:213; idem, Mevo’ot Lesifrut Hatannaim, 723. Goodblatt also based his discussion on identifying the correct version as “a tanna from the House of Shmuel”; see Rabbinic Instruction, 134 n. 94, and my discussion below. 109. Concerning the contradiction between the mishnah and the anonymous baraita’, see the stammaitic discussion that begins the passage (Bavli Bava Metzia 111a), “Who is our mishnah? Not the first opinion of the ‘of your brother’ [baraita’] nor R. Jose b. R. Judah … !” 110. Altogether, there are five such cases: Rosh Hashanah 16a; Sukkah 56b; Megillah 23a; Ketubbot 49a; Kiddushin 29b. 111. See the discussion near n. 54 herein. 112. Sanhedrin 56b. 113. The version Tanna D’Bei Menashe is found in all manuscripts. Some manuscripts, however, read “R. Papa” instead of “Rava.” 114. See Albeck, Mavo LaTalmudim, 297.
291
Barak Shlomo Cohen Shmuel’s baraita’ is composed of two parts. The first discusses the prohibition of an employer to withhold wages for a laborer or craftsman or to withhold rent due for the use of an animal or utensils. Word for word, this baraita’ is nearly identical to the halakhah found in the Mishnah. Other Tannaim disagree, as is evident by the words of R. Jose, the son of R. Judah, in the anonymous baraita’ that appears at the beginning of the passage: “Animals and utensils are subject only to the rule, ‘You shall not oppress.’”115 So, too, the second half the TDBS baraita’—concerning the prohibition of withholding the wages of a resident alien—is the same as that found in the Mishnah. All five prohibitions that apply to an employer who withholds the wages of his employee (“Do not oppress,” “Do not steal” [counting as two prohibitions],116 “Do not withhold,” “Do not let the sun rise [without paying him his wages]”)117 do not apply, according to the Mishnah and the TDBS baraita’, to the resident alien: “To [the resident alien] the laws of ‘Do not withhold’ … and also ‘Do not oppress’ and ‘Do not steal’ do not apply.”118 Like the halakhah found in the first half of the TDBS baraita’, so, too, do other Tannaim disagree with this halakhah. The baraita’ found earlier in the passage applies all five prohibitions to an employer who withholds wages from a resident alien. In any case, both halves of the TDBS baraita’ contain halakhot identical to the Palestinian tannaitic tradition of the Mishnah. (9) Bavli Moed Katan 18b Mishnah: They may write the following documents during the festival: betrothal of women [documents], divorce documents and receipts, a will of a dying person, a bequest and prozbuls; evaluation certificates and court orders for support, documents of release from Levirate marriage and documents of repudiation [of marriage] and arbitration records; decrees of the court and correspondence. Gemara: Shmuel said: It is permitted to betroth a woman on the intermediate days of a festival, lest someone else precedes him… .119 Come and learn: that the House of Shmuel taught [Tanna D’Bei Shmuel]:120 [During the intermediate days of a festival] one may betroth but not marry, and one may not make 115. See also S. Warhaftig, Dinei Avodah Bamishpat HaIvri (Tel Aviv: Moreshet, 1969), 1:3. 116. Leviticus 19:13; Deuteronomy 24:14. 117. See Tosefta Bava Metzia 10:3 (ed. Lieberman, 117), and parallels. 118. Rashi, s.v. ve’eyn bo. 119. Shmuel’s statement is parallel to his statement in Yerushalmi Betzah 5:2, 63a: “even on the ninth of Av one may betroth lest someone else precede him.” For a discussion comparing the two different versions, see N. Aminoah, Arikhat Masekhtot Sukkah Umoed Katan Batalmud (Tel Aviv: Tel-Aviv University Press, 1989), 392. 120. This is the version preserved in all manuscripts and printed editions. This is also the version preserved in Halakhot Pesukot, ed. N. Danzig (Jerusalem: Ahavat Shalom, 1999), 439. The version preserved in the commentary of R. Hannanel (Perushei R. Hannanel bar Hushiel LaTalmud, ed. D. Metzger [Jerusalem: Vagshal, 1993], 47) and R. Shlomo ben Hayatom (Perush Masekhet Mashkin LeRabbenu Shlomo Hayatom, ed. T. P. Hayot [Berlin: Mekizei Nirdamim, 1910], 96) reads Tanna D’Bei Menashe.
292
In Quest of Babylonian Tannaitic Traditions betrothal feasts, nor may one perform Levirate marriage, for it is a joy to him. Learn from it.
The TDBS baraita’ allows betrothals to take place on the intermediate days of a festival, as does the statement of Shmuel found earlier in the passage and in a parallel statement in the Palestinian Talmud.121 This halakhah is also found in Tosefta Moed Katan 1:10 (ed. Lieberman, p. 367): “One may not betroth women during the intermediate days of the festival. R. Judah permits, lest someone else precedes him.” Albeck,122 Lieberman,123 and Aminoah124 were therefore correct in identifying Shmuel’s amoraic statement and the halakhah found in the TDBS baraita’ with the opinion of R. Judah (b. Ilai) found in the Tosefta, both with regard to the halakhah itself and in the justification for the leniency, “lest someone else precede him.”125 The opinion prohibiting betrothal on these days stems, apparently, from an assumption that the act looks like an acquisition,126 and generally acquisitions are prohibited during the entire festival. Another of the halakhot found in this TDBS baraita’, “one may not perform Levirate marriage,” and its justification, “for it is a joy to him,” is found in Mishnah Moed Katan 1:7: “They may not marry women during the festival, neither virgins nor widows, nor may they perform Levirate marriage, for it is a joy to him.” Again, both halakhot mentioned in the TDBS baraita’ are identical to other halakhot in the Palestinian tannaitic tradition.127 121. Concerning Shmuel’s statement as preserved in the Yerushalmi, see n. 120 herein. 122. Albeck, Mehkarim Babraita Ubatosefta, 112. 123. S. Lieberman, Tosefta Kifshuta, 5:1237. 124. Aminoah, Arikhat Masekhtot Sukkah, 262. 125. According to Albeck, the phrase “betrothals of women” in the Mishnah refers to “all documents related to betrothal, for example a document of arranging the marriage (shidukhim) and its financial considerations (t’naim), or the betrothal document itself, which a man can use to betroth a woman by document” (Albeck, Shisha Sidrei Mishnah [Jerusalem and Tel Aviv, 1958], 2:381; see also idem, “Haerusin Veshtarotehen,” in Kobetz Mada’i Lezekher Moshe Shor [New York, 1947], 12–13). According to this interpretation, Shmuel’s statement and the halakhah in the TDBS baraita’ are both identical with the halakhah found in the Mishnah, from which one can conclude that it is permitted to betroth a woman during the festival (compare this interpretation with that offered by the stam in the earlier section of the passage). 126. S. Lieberman, Tosefta Kifshuta 5:1237. 127. There is no tannaitic tradition that explicitly prohibits having a betrothal feast during the festival. N. Rubin, Simhat Hahayyim (Tel Aviv: Hakibutz Hameukhad, 2004), 148, attempted to conclude indirectly from Mishnah Pesahim 3:7 (“One who goes to slaughter his passover sacrifice, or to circumcise his son or to eat the betrothal feast at his in-laws’ home … ”) that “they arranged betrothal feasts during the festival or during the intermediate days of the festival.” This seemingly contradicts the halakhah found in the TDBS baraita’, according to which one may not make a betrothal feast. However, Rubin did not note that with the exception of Tosefta Pesahim 3:12 (ed. Lieberman, 154), in all of the other tannaitic parallels to this halakhah, the words “to eat the betrothal feast at his in-laws” are absent. See Sifre Deuteronomy 131 (ed. Finkelstein, 188); Mekhilta DeRabbi Shimon bar Yohai 13:6 (ed. Epstein-Melamed, 39–40); Midrash Hagadol Exodus (ed. M. Margoliot, 230). According to both Epstein (Mavo Lenusah Hamishnah, 746) and S. Friedman (Tosefta Atikta: Pesah Rishon [Ramat-Gan: Bar-Ilan University Press, 2002], 33 n. 7) this is not an incidental late omission in some texts. Rather, there are two authentic and contradictory tannaitic traditions concerning this question. Hence, even if
293
Barak Shlomo Cohen (10) Bavli Shabbat 131a–b But was it not taught: The shofar and all its accoutrements supersede the Sabbath, the words of R. Eliezer… .128 From where does R. Eliezer derive this? … The verse says: “A day of blasting it shall be for you” (Num. 29:1) —on that day, and even [if it falls] on the Sabbath. Concerning what [was this stated]? If you say concerning the [shofar] blasts themselves—hasn’t the House of Shmuel taught (Tanna D’Bei Shmuel):129 “All manner of work you shall not do”—this excludes blasting shofar and removing bread [from the oven] which are wisdom and not work! Rather [it concerns] the accoutrements.
According to early tannaitic tradition, when Rosh Hashanah falls on the Sabbath, the shofar should be sounded in the Temple but not outside it. Mishnah Rosh Hashanah 4:1 states, “The festival day of Rosh Hashanah which falls on the Sabbath: in the Temple they would blow [the shofar] but not in the provinces.” According to the Mishnah, after the destruction of the Temple, R. Johanan b. Zakkai130 decreed that the shofar should be sounded even outside the Temple. Scholars have detected in Palestinian tannaitic literature two main halakhic approaches toward R. Johanan’s decree.131 According to the earlier approach, blasting a shofar on the Sabbath is a violation of the Torah,132 and hence it supersedes the Sabbath (outside of the Temple) only in a court of law; “the blasts of Rosh Hashanah supersede the Sabbath in all of the land only in a court of law.”133 The later approach perceived of shofar blasts on Rosh Hashanah as being forbidden only by rabbinic decree.134 According to the halakhah presented in the TDBS baraita’, sounding a shofar on the Sabbath is not prohibited
Rubin is correct, and Shmuel’s baraita’ does contradict the Mishnah, the Mishnah’s opinion is not the only tannaitic opinion. Again, it seems likely that there is tannaitic halakhic precedent for the opinion found in the TDBS baraita’. 128. This baraita’ can also be found in Yerushalmi Shabbat 19:1, 16d. 129. This is the version preserved in all manuscripts of this passage and the parallel in Bavli Rosh Hashanah 29b. In another parallel in Bavli Shabbat 117b, Munich 95 and the printed editions read Tanna D’Bei R. Yishmael. 130. See the above-cited mishnah, Rosh Hashanah 4:1. Concerning the historical background to R. Johanan b. Zakkai’s decree, see G. Alon, Toldot HaYehudim BeEretz Yisrael Bitkufat HaMishnah VehaTalmud (Tel Aviv: Akibutz Hameukhad, 1953), 1:67–68; S. Safrai, Bimei Habayit Ubimei HaMishnah (Jerusalem: Magness Press, 1994), 1:139–42. 131. See I. Heineman, Iyyunei Tefilah (Jerusalem: Magness Press, 1981), 85–89; D. Henshke, “Tekiat Shofar BeShabbat,” Sidra 8 (1992): 19–37; J. Tabori, Moadei Yisrael (Jerusalem: Magness Press, 2000), 247–52. 132. It seems that the original reason that blowing the shofar was prohibited on the Sabbath was because of making noise; see Henshke, “Tekiat Shofar BeShabbat,” 31–36. 133. See Sifra Behar Parsha 2:4, 107a. 134. Concerning the chronological development of this halakhah in tannaitic literature, see Henshke, “Tekiat Shofar BeShabbat,” 22–27.
294
In Quest of Babylonian Tannaitic Traditions by the Torah, for it is not considered to be in the category of “work which is toilsome.”135 Lieberman, Heineman, and Henshke all identified the halakhah in Shmuel’s baraita’ with this later approach, according to which sounding a shofar on the Sabbath is only prohibited by the rabbis, and not by the Torah. This line of thinking is reflected, for instance, in Tosefta Rosh Hashanah 2:16 (ed. Lieberman, p. 320): They may learn to blow [the shofar] on Shabbat, and they need not stop women or children from blowing [the shofar] on Shabbat, and there is no need to say on the festival.
The baraita’ allows women and children who have reached an educable age to blow a shofar on the Sabbath in order to learn. The underlying assumption here is that blowing a shofar on the Sabbath is not prohibited by the Torah, “for if they thought there was a toraitic prohibition in blowing the shofar, there would be no doubt that they would prevent women from blowing.”136 Henshke demonstrates that the same halakhic approach toward blowing the shofar on the Sabbath lies at the heart of a halakhah in Mishnah Hullin 1:7 and its parallel in Tosefta Sukkah 4:13 (ed. Lieberman, p. 275):137 “A festival that falls on the eve of the Sabbath, they blast but they do not recite havdalah; [if it falls] after the Sabbath they recite havdalah, but they do not blast.” Interpreting this mishnah, Henshke writes, This blast, performed on a festival that falls on the eve of the Sabbath in order to announce that henceforth work done in preparation of food would be prohibited, proves that sounding a blast was not considered a labor prohibited by the Torah. Obviously, the need to announce that the Sabbath was beginning could not itself supersede a Sabbath prohibition. Rather, the author of this Mishnah clearly thinks that sounding a blast is only a rabbinic prohibition, and therefore, in order to prevent people from performing prohibited labors on the Sabbath, the rabbis waived the rabbinic prohibition of sounding a blast.
In the Bavli, Rabbah offers an explanation as to why the rabbis prohibited the blowing of the shofar on a Rosh Hashanah that falls on the Sabbath; he states that it was “a rabbinic decree lest someone carry [the shofar] four cubits in the public domain.”138 For our purposes, what is crucial is that, again, the TDBS 135. Rashi, malekhet avodah. Concerning the tendency in tannaitic literature to perceive sages as having the authority to decide what constitutes prohibited Sabbath labor based on their own logical conclusions, see Y. D. Gilat, Mehkarim Behishtalshelut Hahalakhah (Ramat-Gan: Bar-Ilan University Press, 1992), 249–61. 136. J. Tabory, Moadei Yisrael, 250; see also Heineman, Iyyunei Tefilah, 86; S. Lieberman, Tosefta Kifshuta, 5:1061. 137. See Henshke, “Tekiat Shofar BeShabbat,” 26. 138. Bavli Rosh Hashanah 29b; Sukkah 42b. The Bavli commonly phrases Sabbath prohibitions using the words “lest someone does… .” See Goldberg, “Lehitpatchut Hasugya Batalmud HaBavli,” Sefer HaYovel LeRabbi Hanokh Albeck (Jerusalem:Mosad Harav Kuk, 1963), 101–13.
295
Barak Shlomo Cohen baraita’ contains a halakhic tradition identical to that found in the Palestinian tradition. III Analysis of the fifty or so halakhic traditions found in baraitot ascribed to Shmuel in the two Talmuds (Tanna D’Bei Shmuel, Tannei Shmuel, or Matnita DeShmuel) demonstrates that in the majority of cases, the halakhic content of these baraitot reflects Palestinian halakhic tradition.139 These findings preclude us from accepting the scholarly opinion according to which Shmuel’s baraitot reflect a Babylonian halakhic tradition that originated in the pre-talmudic period,140 or even a Babylonian tradition from a later period.141 While it is true that the form and external characteristics of these baraitot differ from typical Palestinian baraitot, as proposed by Albeck (near n. 22)—they tend to be brief, are anonymous, and contain expressions frequently ascribed elsewhere to Tannaim from later generations—this is not sufficient to conclude that the content of these baraitot is Babylonian in origin.142 Identifying the nature and origin of the halakhic material found in the Shmuel baraitot requires systematic examination of the contents of all the halakhot contained in this corpus. It is not sufficient to use a characterization of this material’s external literary style or form as the basis for any proposal as to the time or place of the origin of its content.143 It cannot be coincidental that approximately 70 percent (thirty 139. A surprisingly high percentage of the TDBS baraitot, about 70 percent, are concerned with the Sabbath and festival laws. Bacher, Tradition und Tradenten, 208, already noted this strange phenomenon, and staked the claim that this phenomenon was a result of Shmuel’s or the Talmuds’ selected focus on certain tannaitic material, mostly that found in Seder Moed. Support for this theory can be found in the fact that Shmuel himself demonstrates a tendency to offer interpretations to mishnahs and baraitot from Seder Moed. D. Gordis, who analyzed Rav and Shmuel’s commentaries on tannaitic sources, evaluated more than 250 instances in which one of these two Amoraim contextualized a tannaitic source using a term such as “what are we dealing with here” (hakha bemai askinan), or “it was only taught regarding …” (lo shanu) (Gordis, Al Parshanuet, 340). His conclusion was that Shmuel demonstrates a more pronounced tendency than Rav to deal with tannaitic sources from Moed and Kedoshim (60 percent of all cases). This conclusion may support Bacher’s supposition with regard to the TDBS baraitot. However, a firmer conclusion will only be able to be suggested after a more thorough examination of all of Shmuel’s literature found in both Talmuds. This is a topic I hope to return to in a broader work, one that will deal with the intellectual activity of Shmuel and the other Nehardean sages. 140. As was claimed by S. Funk Die Juden in Babylonien, 62 and Goldberg, “Shimusho Shel Rava Ba Tosefta,” 144–77. 141. As was suggested by Albeck, Albeck, Mehkarim Babraita Ubatosefta, 15–43; idem, Mavo LaTalmudim, 28–39. 142. As was claimed by Albeck, Albeck, Mehkarim Babraita Ubatosefta, 15–43; idem, Mavo LaTalmudim, 28–39. For examples of chronologically late expressions found in TDBS baraitot see above, near footnote n. 25. 143. Concerning the relationship of Shmuel’s baraitot to the Mishnah, Epstein, Mavo Lenusah HaMishnah, 214, writes, “The relationship of this collection of baraitot to the Mishnah is thus: part of it explains the Mishnah … part of it expands upon the Mishnah … and part of it disagrees with the Mishnah.” In order to prove his assertion that Shmuel’s baraitot “disagree with the Mishnah,”
296
In Quest of Babylonian Tannaitic Traditions traditions)144 of the Shmuel baraitot are representative of Palestinian tannaitic halakhah.145 For most of the other traditions (about fifteen), no parallel in Palestinian tannaitic halakhah has been discovered.146 The significance of these findings is that the baraitot transmitted under Shmuel’s name cannot support a general claim as to the existence of an independent corpus of tannaitic halakhah in Babylonia prior to the onset of the amoraic period. Analysis of this corpus, which is one of the largest literary corpuses identified by scholars as reflecting a tannaitic Babylonian halakhic tradition,147 demonstrates just the opposite, namely, the extreme degree of influence that Palestinian tannaitic halakhah had on Babylonian rabbis, even in this early period. We should emphasize how significant it is that this finding analyzes traditions ascribed to Shmuel, a first-generation Babylonian sage who seems never to have learned Torah in Palestine.148 Supposing the existence of
Epstein cites Yoma 70a, discussed at length by Goldberg (see “Shimusho Shel Rava Ba Tosefta,” 144– 77). While it is true that Shmuel’s baraita’ in this passage does present a halakhic tradition that differs from that presented in the Mishnah, Shmuel’s baraita’ does match, as Goldberg noted, the Palestinian tannaitic tradition ascribed to R. Yishmael and his students as it appears in the Yerushalmi. Epstein’s comments are only directed at the relationship between Shmuel’s baraitot and the Mishnah, and not their relationship to the broader scope of Palestinian literature, as is the concern in this article. 144. See n. 33 herein. 145. Sources in both Talmuds reveal that Shmuel’s father, Abba bar Abba, called in the Bavli “Avuha DeShmuel,” also maintained close ties with sages in Palestine, and especially with Rabbi [Judah Hanasi]. In a number of passages, Avuha DeShmuel, who, like Shmuel, lived in Nehardea, is described as sending halakhic questions to Palestine (see Bavli Pesahim 103a; Rosh Hashanah 27b [= Yerushalmi Rosh Hashanah 3:6, 59a]; Rosh Hashanah 28a; Yevamot 104b; Yevamot 105a; Yevamot 115b; Bava Metzia 90a; Yerushalmi Bava Metzia 4:1, 9c). In one of these traditions, Yevamot 115b, Avuha DeShmuel’s connection with Rabbi is so great that the former sends the latter a question with an obvious answer, and Rabbi bothers to answer it “due to the honor of Avuha DeShmuel” (see S. Albeck, Mishpachot Sofrim [Warsaw: Sholdberg, 1903], 22). These traditions demonstrate the close connection between Avuha DeShmuel and the Palestinian halakhic traditions, and also suggest how these traditions may have reached Babylonia in the first generation of Amoraim and how they may have been so familiar to and influential on Shmuel. 146. See the discussion near n. 33 herein. 147. For another group of halakhot that has been identified as being a tannaitic halakhic corpus with some attachment to Babylonia, see nn. 3–7 herein. 148. It is doubtful whether Shmuel ever spent time in Palestine. The main source that has served as the basis for the supposition that he did is an Aggadah found in Bavli Bava Metzia 85b–86a. In this source, Shmuel is called “Rabbi’s doctor”; see Sokoloff, Dictionary of Jewish Babylonian Aramaic, 148. In the story, Rabbi attempts to give Shmuel rabbinic ordination, but his plan is not successful and Shmuel does not receive ordination. Many scholars have seen this as a source for the fact that Shmuel was a disciple of Rabbi [Judah Hanasi]. See Graetz, History of the Jews, 2:518; I. H. Weiss, “The Controversies of Rab and Samuel and the Tosefta,” 164; T. Yaavetz, Toldot Yisrael (Tel Aviv: Am-Olam, 1938), 7:26; Hyman, Toldot Tannaim Veamoraim, 1123. According to D. Hoffman, Mar Samuel, 15, and W. Bacher, “Samuel Yarhina’ah,” Jewish Encyclopedia (New York: Funk and Wagnalls, 1901), 11:29, Shmuel did indeed spend time in Israel but learned mainly from Rabbi’s students in Babylonia. In contrast, S. Rappoport, Erekh Milin (Prague: M. Landa, 1852), 1:222; Frankel, Mavo HaYerushalmi, 124b; and M. Beer, “Samuel,” Encyclopaedia Judaica (Detroit: Macmillan, 2007), 17:757, doubted the historical accuracy of this tradition because of its late, aggadic character. Indeed, there are several other difficulties with this aggadic tradition, which have been pointed out
297
Barak Shlomo Cohen an independent Babylonian halakhic tradition, the most likely Babylonian sage we would expect to be identified with this tradition would be Shmuel. Nevertheless, the facts lead to the exact opposite conclusion. The source of Shmuel’s tradition is the Palestinian halakhic tradition, frequently the same traditions as those found in the Mishnah and the Tosefta, the two great corpuses of Palestinian tannaitic halakhah. The fact that Shmuel’s baraitot always accord with Shmuel’s own halakhic opinions as found in the two Talmuds149 also demonstrates the great influence that the Palestinian halakhah had on Shmuel’s halakhic decision making and talmudic commentary.150
by other scholars. See, e.g., Epstein, Mevo’ot Lesifrut Hatannaim, 200 n. 1; Beer, “Samuel,” 757; D. Halivni, “Iyyunim Behithavut HaTalmud,” 84 and n. 69; and Meir, R. Yehudah Hanasi, 238. Epstein, Mavo Lenusah HaMishnah, 212, cited two other sources that he believed imply that Shmuel spent time in Palestine, but deeper analysis of both of these sources demonstrates that his conclusion is doubtful. The first proof is Shmuel’s statement on Bavli Shabbat 51b, “R. Judah said in the name of Shmuel: In front of Rabbi [Judah Hanasi] they would switch this one with that one.” It seems that Epstein interpreted the phrase “in front of Rabbi [Judah Hanasi] they would switch” as indicating Shmuel’s physical presence in front of Rabbi when he and others would ask questions. However, it is equally possible that Shmuel was merely transmitting a tradition with which he was familiar and not that Shmuel himself was present in front of Rabbi (see D. Halivni, Makorot Umasorot: Shabbat [Jerusalem: JTS Press, 1982], 153). The second proof that Epstein cited is a passage in Bavli Gittin 66b that begins, “Shmuel said in the name of Rabbi.” There are two problems with this proof. First of all, some manuscripts (e.g., Vatican 130, which reads, “Shmuel said”) do not contain the ascription to Rabbi. Even more problematic is that when the first three generations of Babylonian Amoraim cite traditions in the name of Tannaim from Rabbi’s generation, the term “X said in the name of Y” does not necessarily mean that X heard the statement directly from Y. See B. S. Cohen, “How Many R. Hamnunas in the Babylonian Talmud? A Study in Talmudic Chronology,” Review of Rabbinic Judaism 10 (2007): 98 n. 22. 149. See above n. 76 herein. 150. This conclusion is supported by a sample check of a collection of baraitot in the two Talmuds which open with the term, Tanna D’Bei Levi. Levi was a first-generation Babylonian Amora (see Albeck, Mavo LaTalmudim, 153–55) whose center of activity was Nehardea (Bavli Megillah 29a; Ketubbot 103b; Yerushalmi Sukkah 4:3, 54c) and whose close colleagues were Shmuel’s father (Avuha DeShmuel—Bavli Megillah 29a) and Shmuel (see, e.g., Bavli Bava Metzia 38b; Yerushalmi Ketubbot 2:5, 26c). The connection between the Tanna Levi statements and the Tosefta was already sensed by B. Ratner, “Mishnato shel Levi ben Sisi,” in Zikaron LeAvraham Eliyahu Lekh’vod HaRav Hachakham Hamephoar Avraham Eliyahu Harkavi (Peterburg: Z. H. Izkovask; Berlin: Itzkovaski, 1908), 117–18. Our sample check affirms Ratner’s conclusion. The following are the main findings that stem from this examination: (I) The baraitot in the Yerushalmi: Four of the five baraitot ascribed to Levi in the Yerushalmi are consistent with those found in tannaitic halakhah. (1) Gittin 5:3, 46d. See Tosefta Ketubbot 4:17 (ed. Lieberman, 70); see also S. Lieberman, Tosefta Kifshuta, 6:254 n. 103, “And this [Tanna D’Bei Levi] baraita is our Tosefta.” (2) Bava Kamma 5:10, 15b (according to the Escorial manuscript, S. Lieberman, Yerushalmi Nezikin [Jerusalem, 1984], 19). The halakhah in this baraita’ appears in Tosefta Kilayim 1:8 (ed. Lieberman, 204). (3) Bava Batra 4:4, 14c (according to the Escorial manuscript, p. 90). This baraita’ appears in Tosefta Bava Kamma 3:1 (ed. Lieberman, 138); see also S. Lieberman, Tosefta Kifshuta (New York, 1988), 10:362, “It turns our Tosefta is like the House of Levi.” (4) Bava Batra 10:5, 17c. The halakhah in this baraita’ is found in Tosefta Bava Batra 11:9 (ed. Lieberman, 169). (II) The baraitot in the Bavli. For the Bavli, I only examined a sample selection of Tanna D’Bei Levi baraitot from the orders of Moed, Nashim, and Kedoshim: (1) Eruvin 10a. There is a parallel to this baraita’ in Yerushalmi Eruvin 1:1, 18c, where it is transmitted anonymously. (2) Pesahim 17a. The stam connects Levy’s baraita’ with an anonymous baraita’ by using
298
In Quest of Babylonian Tannaitic Traditions In conclusion, the detailed evidence that I have analyzed here and elsewhere supports and leads to the acceptance of Gafni’s proposal that “the Palestinian corpus of traditions was adopted by the Babylonian sages from the beginning of the amoraic period. Moreover, when these traditions reached Babylonia in this period they caused prior traditions, for all intents and purposes, to disappear.”151 A DDENDUM
TO NOTE
76
(Concerning the relationship of Shmuel to the Tanna D’Bei Shmuel baraitot) How did Shmuel himself relate to the halakhot found in the collection of baraitot transmitted under his name—Tanna D’Bei Shmuel? In the entirety of talmudic literature, Shmuel does not once relate directly to this collection of baraitot. Most scholarly inquiry concerning this question has focused on the discussions found in the two Talmuds, discussions that point out the identity between the halakhot transmitted by Shmuel and the halakhot ascribed to Tanna D’Bei Shmuel. My own comparison of Shmuel’s halakhic statements and those found in TDBS baraitot, in cases where the Talmuds themselves do not compare them, leads to a similar conclusion. Furthermore, even in the few cases (four out of nearly fifty cases, representing about 8 percent of the total TDBS baraitot) in which one of the two Talmuds contrasts a halakhic statement by Shmuel with a TDBS baraita’, the case is not one of an explicit halakhic tradition transmitted by Shmuel, but rather an assumption that stems from Shmuel’s words. Subsequently, the assumption that Shmuel disagrees with his own baraita’ is rejected by the Talmud. These findings reveal the significant influence that the Palestinian tannaitic halakhic traditions found in TDBS baraitot had on Shmuel’s own halakhic opinions. This is a broad topic, one that demands a separate discussion, and it is my intention to return to this subject elsewhere. Nevertheless, through the use of representative examples, I shall touch on some of the main points. As I stated earlier, the similarity between Shmuel’s halakhic positions and those in the TDBS baraitot is already noted in talmudic discussions. In three places in the Yerushalmi, the Talmud decides the correct ascription of an opinion in a debate between Rav and Shmuel by using a halakhah found in one of Shmuel’s baraitot. The assumption is clearly that Shmuel’s own opinion should match those found in the TDBS baraitot. The first example of this phenomenon was discussed earlier (near n. 76). In two other cases, the Yerushalmi acts in a similar fashion: “Rav and Shmuel argued … one said … and the other said … and we don’t know who said this and who said that. From that which Shmuel taught [tannei Shmuel]… . We can say that he said …” (Yerushalmi Eruvin 6:7, 23d; ibid 10:7, 26b). The Yerushalmi
the phrase “It was taught in a baraita like Levi ( )תניא כוותיה דלוי.” (3) Ketubbot 96b. This baraita’ is found in Tosefta Ketubbot 11:1 (ed. Lieberman, 92). See also Lieberman, Tosefta Kifshutah, 6:355. (4) Menahot 48b. This baraita’ is found in Tosefta Nezirut 4:9 (ed. Lieberman, 40). See also S. Lieberman, Tosefta Kifshuta 7:554. (5) Hullin 108b. This halakhah is found in Tosefta Makkot 4:7 (ed. Zukermandel, 442). See also Dinnur, Hiddushei HaRitzad, 4:340. 151. Gafni, Yehudei Bavel Bitkufat Hatalmud, 90.
299
Barak Shlomo Cohen also notes the similarity between Shmuel’s own opinions and those in his baraitot by using the phrase “[and Shmuel taught (tannei Shmuel) thus …] and Shmuel taught according to his own opinion (Shmuel tanita keshitateh …” (Yerushalmi Pesahim 9:6, 37a), or by the words, “and Shmuel taught… . Shmuel goes according to his own opinion, for Shmuel said …” (Yerushalmi Megillah 2:1, 73a, according to the Leiden manuscript). In another case discussed earlier (near n. 122), the Bavli presents a proof from a Shmuel baraita concerning Shmuel’s own opinion in a dispute with Rav: “Shmuel said … Come and learn that the House of Shmuel taught (Tanna D’Bei Shmuel)… .” (Bavli Moed Katan 18b). Along with these cases, our critical examination of the material has yielded additional cases in which Shmuel expresses a halakhic opinion similar to that found in his baraitot. In the first case, Shmuel explains the Mishnah in a manner identical to the explanation in a Shmuel baraita’ (near n. 51). In the second case, Shmuel’s halakhic opinion matches the halakhic tradition found in one of his baraitot: “Shmuel said … Tannei Shmuel…” (Yerushalmi Shabbat 8:4, 11b). In addition, there is a case in the Bavli (Bekhorot 37b) where a statement by Shmuel explaining a mishnah is replaced by second- and third-generation Amoraim with a Shmuel baraita’: “R. Tahlifa b. Abudimi said to [R. Hisda]: Thus did Shmuel say: as a sela… . And R. Shmuel b. Judah said: A baraita says this” (= Thus taught Shmuel: as a sela [Epstein, Mavo Lenusah (see n. 12 herein), 213, n. 5]). These examples demonstrate the identity between halakhot ascribed to Shmuel himself and those found in TDBS baraitot, even if the Talmud does not make the identification. In four places, the two Talmuds (Bavli Shabbat 54a; Betzah 29a; Yerushalmi Shabbat 1:3, 3a [according to the Leiden manuscript, see below]; and Eruvin 6:8, 24a) present a halakhic discrepancy between Shmuel’s own halakhic position and that found in a TDBS baraita’. However, analysis of these four cases reveals that these are not truly discrepancies. As we shall see, the Talmud recognizes that Shmuel’s own opinion does not actually disagree with that found in the TDBS baraita’, and the suggestion of a discrepancy is eventually rejected. We will now deal with two of these cases, also pointing out that the very fact that the Talmuds contrast Shmuel’s opinion with that found in TDBS baraitot reveals the underlying assumption that these two sources should be in agreement; otherwise, why bother noting that they disagree?
(1) Yerushalmi Eruvin 6:8, 24a It happened that they were sitting outside in a courtyard when the Sabbath began. The case came in front of Shmuel and he said: Since they began to eat the dish while it was still day it is permissible.152 Shmuel’s statement implies [milta deShmuel amara] that a shittuf must be placed in a house.153 152. This halakhic position is ascribed to Shmuel also in Bavli Bava Batra 130a. 153. A shittuf is a symbolic communal meal that allows one to carry from a courtyard into an alleyway or vice versa.
300
In Quest of Babylonian Tannaitic Traditions Shmuel’s tannaitic teaching (matnita) disagrees with him: they may place the shittuf in a guard house.
In the Yerushalmi, the phrase “X’s statement implies” (milta deShmuel amara) cites a rule that stems from a halakhic tradition stated by X or from a story in which X was involved.154 It is important to emphasize that this halakhic rule was not stated explicitly by X, nor has X stated such a halakhic rule elsewhere. In the foregoing passage, the Yerushalmi concludes from Shmuel’s ruling that in general a shittuf (a symbolic communal meal that allows one to carry from certain domains to others) must occur inside a house. Shmuel only reluctantly counted the meal that they were eating as the shittuf, because they had begun to eat while it was still day. The implication is that in other circumstances, he would not have counted this meal as a shittuf because it was not taking place in a house.155 The Yerushalmi then contrasts Shmuel’s ruling in this case with a tradition found in a matnita deShmuel baraita’. According to the baraita’, even if the meal is placed in a guard house found in the courtyard,156 the meal is considered valid and allows carrying from one place to another.157 The shittuf did not need to be placed in the house. Lieberman had such great difficulty with this passage that he offered a completely different understanding of the phrase “Shmuel’s statement implies that a shittuf must be placed in a house,” one that completely contradicts the normal use158 of this technical term in the Yerushalmi: This is how we must also interpret the phrase “Shmuel’s statement implies that a shittuf must be placed in a house.” This line is not based on the above story, for there they are not speaking about “shitufei mevuot” [communal meals which allow one to carry from an alleyway to a courtyard and vice versa] but rather “shitufei hatzerot” [which allow one to carry from a house into a courtyard and vice versa]. Shmuel allowed them this because they began to eat while it was still day. However, it seems that they also were familiar with another statement by Shmuel from which it is possible to prove that a shittuf [of an alleyway] must be placed in a house.
Even though Lieberman’s suggestion is quite difficult to accept,159 it demonstrates that the Talmud’s conclusion is not simply and straightforwardly derived from Shmuel’s halakhic ruling. It is doubtful, therefore, whether we can use this 154. See, e.g., Bacher, Tradition und Tradenten, 112; S. Lieberman, HaYerushalmi Kifshuto, 415. This is also the more recent conclusion of Leib Moscowitz in his recent book, Haterminologia shel HaYerushalmi: Hamunachim Haikari’im (Jerusalem: Magnes Press, forthcoming). I wish to thank Professor Moscowitz for allowing me to examine a draft of his forthcoming book. 155. See the commentary of R. Moshe Margoliot (Penei Moshe), s.v. miltei deRav. 156. Concerning the identification of the “gate house” in talmudic literature, see S. Kraus, Kadmoniyot HaTalmud (Berlin and Vienna: Moriah, 1924), 1:420–21. 157. See Penei Moshe, s.v. matnita deShmuel. 158. See n. 160 herein. 159. As noted by Moscowitz (n. 155 herein), who writes, “However, this is a difficult interpretation, both in light of the actual words of the term and in light of its typical usage.”
301
Barak Shlomo Cohen example to posit an actual halakhic discrepancy between Shmuel and a baraita’ transmitted under his name. As we shall see, the same is true of the following source.
(2) Yerushalmi Shabbat 1:3, 3b Mishnah: A tailor should not go out with his needle close to darkness [on the eve of the Sabbath] lest he forget and go out [on the Sabbath], nor a scribe with his pen, nor should one check his clothes for lice, nor read by the light of the candle. Gemara: Shmuel said: [That one should not read by the light of the candle] was taught only with regard to one person, but if two [are reading together], since each can protest the other’s [Sabbath violation] it is permitted. Shmuel’s tannaitic teaching [matnita]160 disagrees with him: [It is forbidden to read by the light of] both a lamp that he can tilt and a lamp that he cannot tilt. Ulla bar Ishmael [said] in the name of R. Lazar: Even if it is very [high].161
The mishnah prohibits reading by the light of a lamp lest one tilt the lamp,162 which is considered by the rabbis to be a violation of the Sabbath. Shmuel’s baraita’ adds that the prohibition is in effect in all cases, regardless of whether there is an actual possibility that the reader might tilt the lamp. According to this, once the rabbis prohibited a certain activity, it remained prohibited under all circumstances.163 The Talmud posits that this baraita’ contradicts Shmuel’s own halakhic opinion, which distinguishes between one person reading by the light of the lamp and two. Two people can read together because each will prevent the other from violating the Sabbath by tilting the lamp. According to the Talmud’s reasoning, if activities that are prohibited lest someone violate the Sabbath are prohibited even if a Sabbath violation is unlikely, as was implied in the baraita’, then what does it matter whether his friend will prevent him from reading?164 Hence, the two sources are perceived as contradicting each other. However, the Talmud’s conclusion that the two sources contradict each other is not actually necessary. This was already noted by Lieberman, in an explanation of Ula bar Ismael’s (and perhaps also R. Elazar b. Pedat in the Bavli)165 rejection of the proposed contradiction: 160. This is the version preserved in the Leiden manuscript. Printed editions read, “the Mishnah disagrees with him.” However, Epstein has already demonstrated that this is a printer’s error; see “Medikdukei Yerushalmi,” Tarbiz 5 (1934): 260; idem, Mavo Lenusah HaMishnah, 163; see also S. Lieberman, HaYerushalmi Kifshuto, 32. 161. The word high is an addition based on S. Lieberman’s emendation, HaYerushalmi Kifshuto, 32. 162. See also Tosefta Shabbat 1:13 (ed. Lieberman, 3); Goldberg, Perush LaMishnah, 13. 163. See Abramsky, Tosefta Hazon Yehezkel, Seder Moed, 4, s.v. afilu gavoha. 164. R. David Frankel, Korban Haedah, s.v. meahar sheyekholin limhot. 165. As was suggested by Halivni, Makorot Umasorot, 28–29.
302
In Quest of Babylonian Tannaitic Traditions Shmuel’s baraita is not concerned with a case where another person is with him or when he is alone. Rather it states that it is prohibited to read by the light of the lamp whether the lamp is low and he can tilt it, or whether it is high and he cannot tilt it. However, if two are reading together even Shmuel’s tannaitic source would allow reading.166
Indeed, in the Bavli’s version of this passage (Shabbat 12b), the parallels to the statements of Shmuel and his baraita’ are presented without any suggestion of a contradiction between them. For our purposes, we should again emphasize that the contradiction presented in the Yerushalmi between Shmuel’s statement and his baraita’ is founded on an unnecessary conclusion that was rejected by the Talmud. There is little evidence that the sources themselves actually contradict each other. Furthermore, we can again see that the Talmud expects Shmuel’s own opinions to be in accord with those baraitot transmitted under his name, and that when there seems to be a contradiction, a resolution is offered. Barak Shlomo Cohen Bar-Ilan University Ramat-Gan, Israel
166. S. Lieberman, HaYerushalmi Kifshuto, 32.
303
AJS Review 33:2 (November 2009), 305–339 © Association for Jewish Studies, 2009 doi:10.1017/S0364009409990031
M AH. AZOR H A -H . AYYIM : L IFE -C YCLE C ELEBRATION IN THE S ONG OF THE A SHKENAZIC S YNAGOGUE by
Geoffrey Goldberg
Joyous life-cycle events celebrated by American Ashkenazic Jews, especially those belonging to the more liberal denominations, invariably conclude with the singing of the words siman tov u-mazal tov, yehei lanu u-lekhol yisra’eil (May it bring good luck to us and to all Israel).1 Whether after the long anxious minutes of the berit milah, the struggle of the youngster through the Hebrew text and trope of the haftarah, the calling up of the bridegroom (and the bride as well in most non-Orthodox synagogues) at an aufruf, or the breaking of the glass at a wedding, the spontaneous singing serves as a catharsis to relieve the built-up tensions of the communal ritual event as well as to express an outpouring of joy. The celebration and commemoration of the Jewish life cycle (in Hebrew, mah.azor ha-h.ayyim) has attracted the interest of modern historians, liturgists, and anthropologists. The musical dimension of these ceremonies, however, has often been underplayed by scholars in these disciplines.2 Ethnomusicologists, by contrast, have long recognized the centrality of music in Jewish life-cycle celebrations and have contributed to a growing body of scholarly literature on the subject.3 The vital role of music in such ceremonies was well put by Amnon Shiloah:
1. The song was published in Velvel Pasternak, Songs of the Chassidim (New York: Bloch, 1968), 125, no. 153. 2. Ivan G. Marcus writes that “rituals include words to be read out, chanted, sung (The Jewish Life Cycle: Rites of Passage from Biblical to Modern Times [Seattle: University of Washington Press, 2004], 11), yet as a historian, he makes only three brief references to music in this otherwise excellent comprehensive work. The contributors to chapters on Jewish liturgy in Paul F. Bradshaw and Lawrence A. Hoffman, eds., Life Cycles in Jewish and Christian Worship (Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press, 1996), largely omit references to music. On the other hand, Harvey Goldberg emphasizes the importance of musical elements in a number of life-cycle events in his anthropological study Jewish Passages: Cycles of Jewish Life (Berkeley: University of California Press, 2003). 3. The most recent studies include Susan Weich-Shahak, Judeo-Spanish Moroccan Songs for the Life Cycle: Recordings, Transcriptions and Annotations (Jerusalem: Jewish Music Research Center, 1989); Kay Kaufmann Shelemay, Let Jasmine Rain Down: Song and Remembrance among Syrian Jews (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1998); Yael Shai, “Yemenite Women’s Songs at the Habani Jews’ Wedding Celebrations,” Musica Judaica 15 (2000–2001): 83–96; Miriam Meghani, “Canticas de parida: canti per la madre
305
Geoffrey Goldberg A person’s lifetime, from birth to death, is filled with a succession of outstanding occasions, many of which are celebrated in song and dance. In the past, when means of entertainment were limited, if a family or ethnic group had extensive social ties, the celebration of various ceremonies would extend over several days. … Songs sung at those times reflected the life and happenings in the community; they mirrored the people’s character, culture, way of thinking, beliefs, aspirations, and longings. At such times folk song reaches its fullest expression.4
Ethnomusicologists have primarily researched the rich life-cycle musical traditions of Sephardic Jews and the ‘eidot ha-mizrah.. Yet if we direct our attention to the ceremonies celebrated by Ashkenazic Jews, if the contemporary American scene is our standard, we might legitimately ask whether life-cycle song exists in any meaningful sense. The past, however, reveals a far different story, examination of which shows that Ashkenazic Jewry once developed a rich body of song associated with rituals of passage. This body of song was first expressed through piyyutim that, before the advent of printed prayer books, h.azzanim almost certainly sang aloud in their entirety. Ezra Fleischer countered the widespread impression that early Ashkenazic synagogal poetry only gave voice, through kinot and selih.ot, to national tragedy, collective suffering, and personal sin. He revealed how various types of piyyut, inserted into fixed texts of the liturgy, also gave expression to praise, joy, and celebration.5 More recently, Menahem Schmelzer, in his study of a manuscript collection of Ashkenazic piyyutim, expanded on Fleischer’s fresh perspective.6 Many of the piyyutim in this collection were recited in the synagogue when the bridegroom was called to the Torah on the Sabbath following his wedding (Shabbat Nisu’in), as in the early Middle Ages marriages were conducted on Fridays.7 A number of piyyutim were also recited at circumcisions.8
di um bimbo appena nato” [Canticas de parida: Songs for the mother of a newborn child], in La nascita nella tradizione ebraica, ed. Elena Loewenthal (Livorno: Belforte Salomone, 2005): 154–63. 4. Amnon Shiloah, Jewish Musical Traditions (Detroit: Wayne State University Press, 1992), 170. This is an abridged version of his Ha-moreshet ha-musikalit shel kehillot yisra’eil (Tel-Aviv: Ha-universitah ha-petuhah, 1985). 5. Ezra Fleischer, Shirei ha-kodesh ha-‘ivrit biymei ha-beinayyim (Jerusalem: Keter, 1975), 448–67, esp. 471–73. 6. MS 8972, Jewish Theological Seminary, New York, analyzed by Menahem Schmelzer, “Mashehu ‘al piyyutim le-nisu’im be-’ashkenaz,” in Essays on Hebrew Literature, ed. Zvia Ben-Yosef Ginor (New York: Jewish Theological Seminary, 2003), 31–52. 7. The piyyutim bore superscriptions identifying them for use at weddings and had references to marriage woven into them. They were associated with specific liturgical stations, such nishmat, or were grouped together as insertions in the yoz.er prayer, or in the Torah service when the bridegroom was called up to the Torah; see Schmelzer, “Mashehu,” 33. Piyyutim of this genre are documented in the late eleventh-century Mahzor Vitry; see ibid., 35, referring to Mahzor Vitry, ed. S. Hurwitz (Nuremburg: Y. Bulka, 1923), 593, 599. Schmelzer has now analyzed MS Oxford 1099 listing similar piyyutim embodied within yoz.erot and reshuyyot written between the tenth and thirteenth centuries; see
306
Mah.azor Ha-H.ayyim Ashkenazic life-cycle songs were primarily limited to the synagogue, in contrast to those of Sephardim and ‘eidot ha-mizrah., whose conduits for life-cycle song were paraliturgical piyyutim sung in Hebrew and folk piyyutim sung in the vernacular.9 Ashkenazic synagogue life-cycle song was never eclipsed, at least not in Western and Central Europe, by the later development of folk songs in the Yiddish vernacular.10 The following study of life-cycle songs in the Ashkenazic synagogue focuses on the early modern period. By that time, a number of commonly held practices had coalesced in much of Europe, and one can trace the performance of synagogue-centered liturgical–musical customs within specific communities and regions. The piyyut component became relatively modest, largely because of the cessation of the Sabbath wedding with its special liturgy.11 What gained in importance was the Ashkenazic synagogue practice of elaborating fixed liturgical texts (matbe‘a ha-tefillah) by singing them to special melodies. The focus on the early modern period also reflects the availability of historical sources. Jewish musical traditions are overwhelmingly oral; the notation of Ashkenazic synagogue chants began sporadically only in the late eighteenth century, continuing more systematically in the mid- and late nineteenth century, particularly in Western and Central Europe. For evidence before this time, the historian must draw on literary sources. A particularly and surprisingly useful genre is the minhag book, collections of community and synagogue customs, most of which emanated from German-speaking lands. One such minhagbuch, hitherto little exploited by musicologists, comes from seventeenth-century Worms, composed by Yiptha Yuspa Shamash (1604–78). It constitutes perhaps the most significant source for documenting West European Ashkenazic musical practices in the pre-emancipation
“Piyyutim le-nisu’in le-rishonei h.akhmei ‘ashkenaz,” in Le-’ot zikaron: meh.kharim ba-shirah ha-‛ivrit uve-moreshet yisra’eil: sefer zikaron le-Aharon Mirski, ed. Efraim Hazan and Yosef Yahalom (RamatGan: Bar-Ilan University, 2006), 173–85, esp. 175–79; 175 n. 6 lists additional MSS containing marriage-related piyyutim. The writer is grateful to Professor Schmelzer for his assistance and for drawing my attention to his “Piyyutim le-nisu’in” article. 8. Schmelzer, “Mashehu,” 39 n. 14. 9. Shiloah, Jewish Musical Traditions, 160; Shlomo Hamburger, “Zemer le-h.atan ba‘aliyato la-torah,” in Shorshei minhag ’ashkenaz (Jerusalem: Makhon Moreshet ’Ashkenaz, 2001), 3:369– 72. In Morocco, there was a genre of piyyutim known as ma‘alot ha-torah—an indication of the reverence attached to them—to honor those called to the Torah on this and other special occasions; see Hayyim Zafrani, Ha-shirah ha-‘ivrit be-moroko, ed. Yosef Tobi (Jerusalem: Ben-Zvi Institute, 1984), 144–45. 10. A convenient overview is found in Ruth Rubin, Voices of a People: The Story of Yiddish Folksong (Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 2000, 1974). 11. On the Sabbath of shabbat nisu’in, the bridegroom recited a special, festive haftarah (שוש אשיש, Isaiah 51). Eric Zimmer demonstrated that in France, and somewhat later in Austria, this haftarah frequently took precedence over the talmudic-based prophetic readings for special Sabbaths; see Zimmer, “Keri’at haftarah likhvod h.atan,” in Olam ke-minhago noheig: perakim be-toledot ha-minhagim, halikhoteihem ve-gilguleihem (Jerusalem: Merkaz Zalman Shazar, 1996), 273–80; Fleischer, Shirei ha-kodesh, 153, 472.
307
Geoffrey Goldberg period.12 Judah Löw Kirchheim (d. 1632) also compiled a collection of Worms customs, but provided considerably less information than did Shamash with respect to musical practices.13 Yuspa Shamash’s minhagbuch gives us a convenient starting point for tracing the historical development of many musical aspects. By virtue of the geographic locale of this minhag source, and that of several others, too, the following study largely reflects the musical practices of the western Germanic lands, coterminus with the liturgical (and musical) rite of minhag ’ashkenaz. F ROM B IRTH
TO
D EATH
Birth Some four weeks following the birth of a child, as soon as the mother or yoledet regained strength following her confinement, she attended the synagogue on the Sabbath, a folk custom referred to as shabbat yez.i’at ha-yoledet.14 On this occasion, the child’s father was called to the Torah. While a boy would already have been named at the berit milah, the day the yoledet came to the synagogue was the occasion for a girl to receive her Jewish name. In addition, both boys and girls were given a secular name on this day, an event that took place at home following the Shabbat afternoon meal, with a ceremony known as Hollekreisch. In most German communities, the attendance of the yoledet was an occasion for musical celebration. This embellishment occurred at the end of ’eil ’adon, the second of two poetic sections of the expanded yoz.er blessing recited on the Sabbath.15 Ordinarily, during the winter, to avoid lengthened services in the generally unheated synagogues, these piyyutim were not recited aloud, whereas in the summer, they were chanted responsively, often led by two h.azzanim.16 However, 12. Yiptha Yuspa Shamash, Minhagim de-kehillah kedoshah vermaiza le-rabbi Yuspa Shamash, ed. Benjamin Salomon Hamburger and Eric Zimmer, 2 vols. (Jerusalem: Makhon Yerushalayim, 1988). Seventeenth-century Worms had the fourth-largest Jewish community in Western and Central Europe, after Prague, Frankfurt, and Vienna; see Shamash, Minhagim, introduction by Zimmer, 1:61. 13. Juda Liva Kirchheim, Minhagot vermaiza, ed. Israel Mordecai Peles (Jerusalem: Makhon Yerushalayim, 1987). 14. Shamash described the elaborate folk customs concerning confinement and its termination; Minhagim 2:256–64, section 288. Cross-cultural influences between the Jewish rite of passage for the birth mother and the Christian Ausgegang ritual have recently been examined in Elisheva Baumgarten, “Tiksei nashim: minhag ‘shabbat yez.i’at ha-yoledet’ be-heksheiro ha-tarbuti be-reishit ha‛eit ha-h.adashah,” in Meh.karim be-toledot yehudei ashkenaz: seifer yoveil likhvod yiz.h.ak (eric) z.immer, ed. Gershon Bacon, Daniel Sperber, and Aharon Gaimoni (Ramat-Gan: Bar-Ilan University Press, 2008), 11–28. 15. The poetic expansion of the yoz.er blessing comprises of three sections, starting with ha-kol yodukha. See Reuven Hammer, Or h.adash: A Commentary on Siddur Sim Shalom for Shabbat and Festivals (New York: Rabbinical Assembly, 2003), xxiii. 16. Shamash, Minhagim 1:37, hag. [annotation] to par. 34 (MS Warmaiza). The second h.azzan would have been a lay member of the congregation. For more on the responsorial singing of ha-kol yodukaha and ’eil ’adon, see Geoffrey Goldberg, “H.azzan and Qahal: Responsive Chant in Minhag Ashkenaz,” Hebrew Union College Annual 61 (1990): 211, 214–16.
308
Mah.azor Ha-H.ayyim as Shamash described, on the Sabbath when the yoledet came to the synagogue, irrespective of the season, the h.azzan would sing the concluding verses of ‘eil ’adon, commencing at semeih.im be-z.eitam, to a special festive melody.17 The text depicts the heavenly bodies as animated beings rising and falling to serve their Creator’s will: ,ְֹשֵמִחים ְּבֵצאָתם וְָֹשִֹשים ְּבבוָֹאם עוִֹֹשים ְּבֵאיָמה ְרצוֹן קוֹנָם Rejoicing in rising, gladly setting, They rush to obey their Creator’s Will.18
At some stage in minhag ’ashkenaz, the text was personalized to refer to the rising of the yoledet from her confinement. Later historical sources attest to the widespread practice of this musical custom. For example, according to the statutes of Hamburg-Altona of 1726, the singing of this Lobgesang (Hymn of Praise) was regarded as obligatory, and required the payment of a fee to the h.azzan.19 A similar stipulation, also mentioning remuneration, was included in the statutes of the Hungarian community of Mattersdorf.20 Testimony to the diffusion in Germany of this liturgical–musical custom are references in several early and mid-nineteenth-century synagogue regulations.21 While only two musical notations of semeih.im be-z.eitam appear to be extant, many additional melodies were certainly in use. The first notation is present in the short handbook of life-cycle melodies compiled by Wilhelm Flamm, a h.azzan in Prague.22 Flamm harmonized the melody for choral rendition so that it could be fit for the sophisticated musical tastes of Prague’s Jews in the 1860s. A second melody was published in 1912 in the compendium of south German h.azzanut by Selig Scheuermann (1873–1935); here, the author provided the rubric beim Ausgang einer Wöchnerin (On the Coming Out of the Birth Mother).23 In both examples, the melody was set to the verse quoted earlier and to the verse cited here in example 1:24 17. Shamash, Minhagim 1:119, section 120, annotation in MS of Yair Hayyim Bacharach (1639–1702, rabbi in Worms from 1650) and n. 4 to same by Hamburger. 18. Translation of Jules Harlow, Hammer, Or h.adash, 108. 19. Max Grunwald, “Die Statuten der Hamburger-Altona Gemeinde von 1726,” Mitteilungen der Gesellschaft für jüdische Volkskunde 11, no. 1 (1903): 9, par. 19. For some reason, however, the song was referred to not as semeih.im be-z.eitam but as kara laschemesch, (God summoned the sun, whose light shone forth), a subsequent verse of the text. 20. Max Grunwald, “Mattersdorf,” Mitteilungen der Gesellschaft für Jüdische Volkskunde 26–27 (1924–26): 509. Grunwald did not provide the date of the statutes (takkanot), but by their character, they are unquestionably pre-emancipation. The “festive intoning” of semeih.im be-z.eitam was also recalled in Alfred Fürst’s reminiscence of Eisenstadt in the same region of western Hungary; see Fürst, Sitten und Gebräuche: Einer Judengasse (Minhag Asch.) (Székesfehérvár: E. Singer, 1908), 52. 21. See the section on “The Emancipation and Life-Cycle Song” in this essay. 22. Wilhelm Flamm, Noten-Beilagen zum Handbuch für Cantoren (Prague: Samuel W. Pascheles, 1868), 14–15, no. 9.
309
Geoffrey Goldberg
Example 1. Selig Scheuermann’s Semeih.im be-z.eitam. Selig Scheuermann, Gottesdienstliche Gesänge, 21, section 1/E, no. 14 (Frankfurt: J. Kauffmann, 1912) Berit Milah on Weekdays. The birth of a male child was an occasion for great festivity, especially, but not exclusively, on the day of the berit milah.25 In medieval Europe, it became the norm for circumcision to take place in the synagogue following the shah.arit service.26 Both Shamash and Kirchheim discussed the widespread custom of the moheil, rather than the h.azzan, leading the chanting of the shah.arit service.27 If the moheil were not capable of this task, he would at least lead the closing prayers, starting at la-menaze’ah. (Psalm 20).28 In Frankfurt, however, the moheil was only permitted to lead from la-menaze’ah. on.29 The tradition of the moheil leading shah.arit was widespread also in Poland, where Moses Isserles (1488–1575) mentioned the custom in his glosses to the Shulh.an ‛arukh.30 At the end of the introductory pesukei de-zimrah, both the moheil and the sandak were called upon to recite va-yevarekh david and shirat ha-yam
23. Selig Scheuermann, Die gottesdienstlichen Gesänge der Israeliten für das ganze Jahr (Frankfurt: J. Kauffmann, 1912), 21, section I/E, no. 14. 24. Scheuermann did not indicate whether the remainder of the piyyut was sung to the same melody. Flamm, however, stated that the following verse starting kara la-shemesh was recited (in free style) by the h.azzan, while the third and last verse repeated the opening melody. Both melodies are of relatively recent origin and lack archaic or modal musical elements. 25. Other celebrations included the special festivity (referred to by Shamash as the zakhar) on the preceding Sabbath known as shabbat zakhar. This took place in the home after the Friday night Sabbath meal. 26. Goldberg, Jewish Passages, 45–46. 27. Shamash, Minhagim, 2:67, section 240; Kirchheim, Minhagot Vermaiza, 83. Kirchheim gives an explanation for this honor: the first letters of the Hebrew phrase מוהל יורד לפני התבה, “the moheil leads the service,” spell the word milah (ibid., gloss to Shamash, ')ה. 28. Shamash, Minhagim, 2:67, section 240. In minhag ’ashkenaz, the service began with the opening hymn, ’adon ‘olam; see Mordechai Gumpil, Sefer minhagim de-kehilateinu (Fürth: Hayyim Zevi Hirsch, 1767), 3, par. 7. In some communities, the moheil led from yishtabah onward; see Shamash, Minhagim, 2:47, section 240, n. 50 of Hamburger, quoting David Leib of Lida, Sod ’adoshem, section 39. 29. Joseph Juspa Kosman, Noheig ka-z.on yoseif (Frankfurt, 1718), repr., ed. Judah Miller (Tel Aviv [s.n.], 1969), 51. 30. Shulhan ‘arukh, yoreh dei‘ah, section 265, par. 11.
310
Mah.azor Ha-H.ayyim responsively.31 This practice began, appropriately enough, at the verse ve-kharot ‘imo ha-berit (You made a covenant [of the flesh] with him [Abraham]). Shamash described how, in Worms, the moheil would chant one verse and the sandak the next, up until yishtabah.. If neither could chant or follow these customary divisions, the h.azzan or shamash would stand in their stead.32 Although Joseph Yuspa Kosman of Frankfurt (d. 1758) was of the opinion that the responsorial singing of these verse by the moheil and the sandak was the custom throughout Germany (medinot ’ashkenaz),33 its strongest hold was in the south and southwestern parts of the country.34 Even in Frankfurt, where, as we have noted, the h.azzan led all or most of the service, the tradition became rooted in the early eighteenth century.35 In northeast Germany, including Berlin, the chanting was often led by the moheil alone, with the congregation responding. This was still the practice at a leading Orthodox synagogue in Berlin in the late 1930s.36 Responsorial chanting by the moheil and the sandak was also known in parts of Poland.37 Originally a fluidity prevailed with regard to the division of the verses,38 but a uniform practice soon coalesced, testified to first by R. Ya’ir Bacharach of Worms (1638–1702). Custom soon saw the dividing of verses at every sof pasuk (full close) and every ’etnah.ta (half close).39 This standardized practice of dividing the recitation between the moheil and the sandak is reflected in ‘Avodat yisra’eil, the authoritative edition of the daily prayer book of Seligmann Baer (1825–1897; see example 2).40
31. I Chronicles 29:10–13; Nehemiah 9:6–11; Exodus 14:30–15:19; Psalms 22:29; Ovadiah 1:21; Zekhariah 14:9; Deuteronomy 6:4. 32. Shamash, Minhagim, 2:65, section 240; Kirchheim, Minhagot vermaiza, 82–83. 33. Kosman, Noheig ka-z.on yoseif, 51. Nevertheless, this was not the custom in Fürth (Bavaria), where evidently only the moheil sang ve-kharot, and possibly the subsequent passages as well. See Mordechai Gumpil, Sefer minhagim de-kehilateinu (Fürth: H.ayyim ben Z.vi, 1767), 3, par. 7. 34. Salomon Carlebach, Ratgeber für das jüdische Haus: Ein Führer für Verlobung, Hochzeit und Eheleben (Berlin: Hausfreund, 1918), 66. 35. Salomon Geiger, Seifer divrei kehillot (Frankfurt am Main: J. Kaufmann, 1862), 26, excursus 17; Kosman, Noheig, 108, par. 8. 36. Abraham Baer, Baal T’fillah: oder der practische Vorbeter, 2nd. ed. (Gothenberg: privately printed, 1883; reprinted by Sacred Music Press, Out of Print Classic Series, Vol. 1, 1953), 6, no. 30; Minhagei … kehal ‘adat [Adass] yisra’eil poh berlin (Berlin, 1938), 8. In other parts of northern Germany, at least by the nineteenth century, the h.azzan tended to lead the responsorial chanting of shirat ha-yam; see Carlebach, Ratgeber für das jüdische Haus, 66. 37. Shamash, Minhagim, 2:65, section 240, n. 27 of Hamburger, referring to Magein ’avraham, OH, section 51, par. 9. 38. Shamash, Minhagim, 2:66, section 240, n. 29 of Hamburger; Kirchheim, Minhagot, 82, hag. 7. 39. Shamash, Minhagim, annotation of Havvat ya’ir (Bacharach). Division in the middle of verses was disapproved of by Joseph Kosman of Frankfurt; see Kosman, Noheig, 32, par. 13, 319. Even so, here, too, this later became the practice; see Divrei kehillot, 53, excursus no. 3. 40. Seligmann Baer, ‘Avodat yisra’eil (Rödelheim, 1868; repr., Berlin: Schocken, 1937), 72–74. Somewhat surprisingly, ‘Avodat yisra’eil included irregular breaks in the shorter ve-kharot section of
311
Geoffrey Goldberg
Example 2. Divisions between moheil and sandak in Seligmann Baer’s ‘Avodat yisra’eil (Roedelheim Verlag, 1868) The divisions were somewhat different in the northeast, in Berlin, and in western Poland, as is evident in the cantorial compendium of Abraham Baer (1834–1894; see example 3).41 Kirchheim emphasized that the moheil and sandak were to sing ve-kharot and shirat ha-yam in a beautiful melody (niggun yafeh).42 This melody replaced the regular chant pattern and, in the case of shirat ha-yam, use of the melody of the te‘amim.43 Transcriptions reveal that a number of texts in the shah.arit service were singled out for special musical performance. In south and southwest Germany, a core group of texts was sung to the special berit milah melody, and included not only ve-kharot and shirat ha-yam but also shirah h.adashah and z.ur yisra’eil at the conclusion of the ge’ulah prayer. In more eastern territories (but also in Hürben, Bavaria),44 this practice was expanded to include the opening hymns ’adon ‘olam (Eternal God) or yigdal (Praise the Living God; see example 4).45
va-yevareikh david, a phenomenon also found in all the musical transcriptions of shirat ha-yam for a berit milah. 41. Abraham Baer, Baal T’fillah, 6, nos. 30–32. Comparatively similar divisions were also recorded by Lion Wolff (1835–1934?) of Rostock and Berlin; see Wolff, Liturgisches Handbuch für alle Kasualien von der Wiege bis zum Grabe (Berlin: Louis Hamm, 1914), 10–13. 42. Kirchheim, Minhagot vermaiza, 83. 43. Kosman, Noheig, 31, section 12; Seligmann Baer, ‘Avodat yisra’eil, 73 (rubric to shirat ha-yam); Fabian Ogutsch, Der Frankfurter Kantor: Sammlung der traditionellen Frankfurter Gesänge, ed. J. B. Levy (Frankfurt: J. Kauffmann, 1930), no. 7, starting at tevi’eimo. 44. The transcriptions of the melodies sung in Hürben, transcribed by Isaak Lachmann, sometimes present serious problems because some of them, which he identified as Western European, actually represent Eastern European versions. 45. Abraham Baer, Baal T’fillah, 71, no. 257.
312
Mah.azor Ha-H.ayyim
Example 3. Divisions between sandak/moheil and choir/congregation in Abraham Baer’s Baal T’fillah: oder der practische Vorbeter, 2nd ed. (Gothenberg: privately printed, 1883; reprinted by Sacred Music Press, Out of Print Classic Series, Vol. 1, 1953), nos. 30–32.
313
Geoffrey Goldberg
Example 4. The opening hymn, Yigdal, sung to the special berit milah melody. Abraham Baer, Baal T’fillah: oder der practische Vorbeter, 71, no. 257. Additional portions of the pesukei de-zimrah, such as romemot ’eil (High Praises of God; Psalm 149:6)46 and halleluyah (Psalm 150),47 were sometimes added. Mizmor le-todah (A Song of Thanksgiving; Psalm 100) was also included, a custom, according to Baer, of minhag polin. Cantorial compendia from the midnineteenth to the early twentieth century show the expansion of texts selected for special singing (see Table 1):48 The differences between the musical notations in these texts are essentially only variations of a melody pattern built on a basic musical structure and similar motives. This pattern was also used for chanting the prayers of the berit milah ceremony itself, whence, it would seem, it was transferred to the shah.arit service. Shamash’s statement that shirah h.adashah was sung to the niggun berit milah would seem to confirm this tradition.50 Even though notations of shirah h.adashah reveal a more elaborate, metrical melody, incorporating new thematic material of 46. “A double-edged sword in their hand,” the phrase וחרב פיפיות בידםin this verse was interpreted as referring to the knife used by the moheil. 47. In Frankfurt, according to Moshe Berlove, ’adon ‘olam was sung to the special berit milah melody. See Berlove, “Music and Ritual Practices in the German Synagogue,” Journal of Jewish Music and Liturgy 9 (1986–87): 21. Divrei kehillot and Der Frankfurter Kantor do not, however, provide any corroboration for Berlove’s statement. 48. In the following sources, the shirat ha-yam section is written in bold numbers: (1) Frankfurt: Fabian Ogutsch, Der Frankfurter Kantor, no. 8, 14; (2) Bavaria, Munich: Maier Kohn, Der Vorbeter in der Synagoge von München (Munich, 1839–44), MS, Birnbaum Collection, Hebrew Union College– Jewish Institute of Religion, Cincinnati, Mus. Add. 4, nos. 14–15; (3) Bavaria, Nuremberg: Moritz Rosenhaupt, Schire Ohel Yaakov, Gottesdienstliche Gesänge für Israeliten III, Werktags-Gottesdienst (Leipzig: privately printed, 1895), Anhang, nos. 6–9; (4) Bavaria, Hürben: Isaak Lachmann, Awaudas Jisroeil, I Teil, Wochentags-Gottesdienst (Hürben: privately printed, 1899), nos. 33, 42–45, 58–59; (5) Berlin: Aron Friedmann, Schir Lisch’laumau (Berlin: Deutsche-israelitischer Gemeindebund, 1902), nos. 11, 13, 16, 23 no. 16; (6) Silesia, Breslau: Moritz Deutsch, Vorbeterschule: vollständige Sammlung der altern Synagogen-Intonationem (Breslau: J. Hainauer, 1871), nos. 475–82; (7) Posen, northeast Germany (and northwest Poland): Abraham Baer, Baal T’fillah, 1883, nos. 257 (yigdal), 25, 26, 28, 30–32, 49–51 (third melody); (8) Moravia: Maier Wodak, Hamnazeach: Schule des isr. Cantors (Vienna: privately printed, 1898), nos. 13–17, 21–22 (the core melody pattern), 27–28, 41 (pe’eiro ‘alay). 49. In col. 7, the abbreviation . פ. מstands for minhag polin. 50. Shamash, Minhagim, 2:65–66.
314
Mah.azor Ha-H.ayyim
Table 1. Texts sung to a special berit milah melody (left to right)49
ואני בחסדך מזמור לתודה רוממות הללויה וכרות וכו’ שירה חדשה צור ישראל
יגדל ואני בחסדך מזמור לתודה )מ .פ(. רוממות )מ. פ(. ב ר וך ה’ לעולם אתה הוא/ וכרות וכו’ שירה חדשה צור ישראל
שבת: פארו עלי
יגדל ואני בחסדך רוממות וכרות וכו’ שירה חדשה
מזמור לתודה רוממות הללויה ב ר וך ה’ לעולם אתה הוא/ וכרות וכו’ שירה חדשה צור ישראל
אדון עולם רוממות הללויה ב ר וך ה’ לעולם אתה הוא/ וכרות וכו’ שירה חדשה צור ישראל
וכרות וכו’ ושירת הים )נ’ מהרי”ל( שירה חדשה צור ישראל
וכרות וכו’ שירה חדשה צור ישראל
ומצאת )וכרות וכו’( שירה חדשה צור ישראל
315
8. Moravia
7. Posen/NE Germany
6. Silesia )(Breslau
5. Berlin
4. Bavaria )(Hürben
3. Bavaria )(Nuremberg
2. Bavaria )(Munich
1. Frankfurt am Main
Geoffrey Goldberg
Example 5a. Elaborate setting of Shirah h.adashah by Löb Wolf. Published in 1933. Reprinted by Ktav in 1973. This comes from Idelsohn's Thesaurus volume, The Synagogue Song of the German Jews in the 18th Century, 213, no. 36. later provenance,51 the core niggun berit milah melody pattern returns in the concluding z.ur yisra’eil. The shirah h.adashah melody seems to have been especially popular. It was first transcribed in 1809 by Löb Wolf, a cantor in Berlin, whose setting is elaborate, but lacks text underlay (example 5a–b).52 51. Francis L. Cohen (1862–1934) held that this melody probably coalesced during the eighteenth century; see Cohen, “Shirah H.adashah,” Jewish Encyclopedia, 11:293–94. In support of his contention is the fact that the London version, as transcribed by Cohen, includes a recurring cadential phrase found in numerous Ashkenazic synagogue melodies of the time. See Abraham Z. Idelsohn, The Synagogue Song of the German Jews in the 18th Century, Hebräisch-orientalisicher Melodienschatz 6 (Leipzig: Friderich Hofmeister, 1932), for many examples of this musical phrase. 52. Idelsohn, The Synagogue Song, 213, no. 36. Parts of this setting were probably sung by a boy soprano vocal assistant (singerl) to the h.azzan; see Abraham Baer, Baal T’fillah, 13, nos. 49–50;
316
Mah.azor Ha-H.ayyim
Example 5b. The berit milah melody in Shirah h.adashah and Z.ur yisra’eil (Abraham Baer). Abraham Baer, Baal T’fillah: oder der practische Vorbeter, 13, nos. 49–50. Berit Milah on the Sabbath. The addition of piyyutim provided textual and musical enrichment when a berit milah took place on the Sabbath.53 Shamash described these additions, largely repeating information detailed by R. Jacob
14, no. 5. The melody pattern niggun berit milah was also used in minhag ‘ashkenaz for the chanting of ’elohim z.ivita lididkha, “God, You Commanded Your Beloved,” a piyyut recited following the circumcision at the ritual meal (se‘udah), which was sometimes held in the synagogue or in an adjoining room. The piyyut includes a recurring short refrain, berit ‘olam. See Maier Kohn, Der Vorbeter in der Synagoge 7, no. 16; the melody of Baer, Baal T’fillah, no. 276, is merely according to the customary chant pattern of the birkat ha-mazon. ’Elohim z.ivita lididkha was inserted toward the end of the second blessing of the birkat ha-mazon after [“ לעולם ועדby the mouth of all the living] continually, forever.” Shamash describes how, if two persons had carried out the berit, the moheil and a moz.ez., then both were honored with chanting the piyyut responsively; see Shamash, Minhagim, 2:76, section 241. 53. Shamash, Minhagim, 2:79, section 244, where he writes . מ.( חh.azzan menagein); Kirchheim, Minhagot, 85. Shamash and Kirchheim both use the term menagein to differentiate between the lay precentor and the h.azzan; see Shamash, Minhagim, 2:52–53; Kirchheim, Minhagot, 79. Later, in hasidic circles in Eastern Europe, ba’al menag’n (Yiddish) was used for a h.azzan who composed and introduced new melodies (niggunim).
317
Geoffrey Goldberg
Example 6. The ’ofan ’Azurei ’eimah for Sabbath of a berit milah. Selig Scheuermann, Gottesdienstliche Gesänge, 18, section 1/E, no. 3 (Frankfurt: J. Kauffmann, 1912) Moellin of Mainz (the Maharil; d. 1427), the most influential late medieval authority on minhag.54 In the ensuing centuries, a number of these piyyutim continued to be recited, as evidenced by their inclusion in Baer’s ‘Avodat yisra’eil.55 One such poem, inserted before the h.atimah (conclusion) of the yoz.eir blessing, was ’azurei ’eimah ([The angels] girded with fear). There are four extant musical notations, three from south, southwest, and west-central Germany, and one from eastern France, the last dating from as recently as 1951.56 Each stanza concludes with a varying pizmon refrain (see example 6): . ְמֲהְלִלים ְלזוֵֹכר ַהְּבִרית,וְַעּמוֹ ְּכרוֵּתי ְבִרית But God’s people, cut with the sign of the Covenant Praise the One who remembers the Covenant.
Some h.azzanim also used the occasion of a berit milah to include a special extended melody while singing the passage ‘al ha-rishonim ([Incumbent] upon the Early Generations) within the ge’ulah (Redemption) blessing that follows the shema‘ and leads into the ‘amidah of shah.arit. ‘Al ha-rishonim was only recited elaborately when a piyyut belonging to the category of a zulat was inserted within the ge’ulah blessing. On the occasion of a berit milah the zulat ’ot berit (Sign of the Covenant) was added—hence the special treatment of the ‘al ha-rishonim text that had led into it (see example 7).57 54. Jacob Moellin, Seifer maharil, minhagim, ed. Shlomo Spitzer (Jerusalem: Makhon Yerushalayim, 1989), 486, section 21; Shamash, Minhagim, 2:79, section 244. 55. Seligmann Baer, ‘Avodat yisra’eil, 798–802. For the wider context of change in the liturgical use of piyyut in Ashkenazic communities, see Ruth Langer, To Worship God Properly: Tension between Liturgical Custom and Halakhah in Judaism (Cincinnati: Hebrew Union College Press, 1998), 136–47, 183. 56. The musical example (example 6) is from Scheuermann, Die gottesdienstlichen Gesänge 18, section 1/E, no. 3. Other notations of ’azurei ’eimah include Isaac Lachmann, Awaudas Jisroeil, Mus. Add. 39 (2), Birnbaum Collection, Hebrew Union College, Cincinnati, part 2, 122, no. 271; Bernard Bochner, Schirë David: Recueil des chants et récitations religieux d’après les airs traditionalles alsaciens (Strasbourg, 1951), 294, no. 455.
318
Mah.azor Ha-H.ayyim
Example 7. Elaborate ‘Al ha-rishonim on the Sabbath of a berit milah. Abraham Baer, Baal T’fillah: oder der practische Vorbeter, 127, no. 529.
An expanded kedushah was sung during the musaf service. Following the congregational response, ( אני ה’ אלהיכםI am the Lord, your God), a short poem belonging to a group of piyyutim with the opening word ’eloheikhem was inserted.58 It begins ’eloheikhem ’ani zokher berit (Your God, indeed, am I, who remembers the covenant).59 This poem was included in JTS Library MS 8972; its chanting was referred to by Jacob Moellin, Yuspa Shamash, and the eighteenth-century minhagbuch of Fürth, Bavaria.60 Traces of the musical performance of this piyyut remain in a partial notation by Abraham Baer, but by that time, the h.azzan only sang, in a minor mode, the concluding words.61 In eastern Germany and Central Europe, on the occasion of a Sabbath day circumcision, certain verses in the brazenly anthropomorphic ’an‘im zemirot (Hymn of Glory) were sung responsively to the berit milah melody.62 This occurred in the stanza starting at pe’eiro ‘alay (His glory is upon me), where, in
57. Abraham Baer, Baal T’fillah, 126, no. 529. 58. Fleischer, Shirat ha-kodesh, 448–49; Macy Nulman, The Encyclopedia of Jewish Prayer: Ashkenazic and Sephardic Rites (Northvale, NJ: Jason Aronson, 1996), 127–28. There were eight such ’eloheikhem poems: six for special Sabbaths, and one each for shabbat nisu’in and berit milah. In Worms, they were recited only for two life-cycle occasions and Rosh H.odesh (New Month); see n. 2 of Hamburger, to Shamash, Minhagim, 1:57. 59. For the full text, see Seligmann Baer, ‘Avodat yisra’eil, 244. 60. Schmelzer, “Mashehu,” 38–39; Moellin, Seifer maharil, 486, section 21; Shamash, Minhagim 1:57, section 54, 2:80, section 244; Gumpil, Sefer minhagim de-kehillateinu, 4, par. 12. 61. “Who says unto Zion, ‘Your God reigns brightly’” ( ;)האמר לציון מלך אלהיך זהוריתAbraham Baer, Baal T’fillah, nos. 615–16. In Frankfurt, according to Fabian Ogutsch, the words were sung to the melody used for כבודו מלא עולםin the kedushah; see Ogutsch, Frankfurter Kantor, rubric, 104. 62. Minhagei … kehal ‘adat [adass] yisra’eil poh berlin, 8. There is a possibility that in this Berlin synagogue, the hymn was also recited on weekdays, although this was a rather rare practice. For a musical transcription, see Wodak, Hamnazeach, no. 41.
319
Geoffrey Goldberg the second line, the word ’adom (red) appears three times, an obvious allusion to the blood of the circumcision: ,ַצח וְָאדוֹם ִלְלבוּשוֹ ָאדוֹם .ּפוָּרה ְבָדְרכוֹ ְּבבוֹאוֹ ֵמֱאדוֹם Radiant and bloody, with garments red as wine God punishes sinning nations [Edom] like grapes pulled from a vine.63
The piyyut yom le-yabashah was especially associated with berit milah; its authorship is ascribed to Judah Halevi (1085–1145), and was customarily read at the end of the ge’ulah prayer on Shabbat beshalah. and on the seventh day of Passover, when shirat ha-yam was read from the Torah. In some regions, however, it was also recited at a Sabbath day circumcision. The opening words of the piyyut connect immediately to the verse “The children of Israel walked into the dry land [va-yabashah]” of shirat ha-yam (Exodus 15:19), while the ensuing verse, shirah h.adashah shibbeh.u ge’ulim, quotes the closing section of the ge’ulah prayer: 64
נֶֶהְפכוּ ְמצוִּלים/ יוֹם ְליַָּב ָׁשה : ִׁשְּבחוּ ְגאוִּלים/ ִׁשיָרה ֲח ָֹדָשה
The day the depths turned into dry land Your redeemed people praised You And sang a new song.
The recitation of yom le-yabashah in the synagogue on the occasion of a berit milah can be easily explained. A condition for the full celebration of the first Passover in Egypt and its subsequent observance was circumcision (Exodus 12:44– 48), a requirement referred to in the following stanza of the piyyut: ִּבְבִרית ֹחָתְמָך/ ַהָּבִאים ִע ְּמָך ִׁשיָרה ֲחָֹדָשה ִׁשְּבחוּ ְגאוִּלים: 65 ֵהָּמה נִּמוִֹלים/ וִּמֶּבֶֽטן ְלִׁשְמָך Those who come with You with the covenant of Your seal And from the womb are circumcised for Your name’s sake.
Recitation of yom le-yabashah for a berit milah was mentioned first by Abraham Klausner (late fourteenth century) in his collection of Austrian customs,66 and thereafter, it became a custom of minhag polin rather than minhag ’ashkenaz.67 While 63. Hammer, ’Or h.adash, 186. Edom was the nation descended from Esau, “the ruddy one” ()ַאְדמֹוִני in Genesis 23:25. A literal translation of the second line reads, “When from treading Edom’s winepress he comes”; see Philip Birnbaum, Daily Prayer Book (New York: Hebrew Publishing Company, 1949), 417. 64. The text is in accordance with Yonah Fraenkel, Mah.zor Pesah. le-fi minhagei b’nei ’ashkenaz le-khol ’anafeha (Jerusalem: Koren, 1993), 475–76. 65. In this stanza, there are allusions to Ezekiel 16:8: וָָאבוֹא ִּבְבִרית ֹאָתך, the berakhot of the berit milah ceremony: להכניסו בבריתו של אברהם אבינות, and Genesis 34:22: ַּכֲאֶׁשר ֵהם נִמֹ ִלים. 66. Abraham Klausner, Seifer minhagim le-rabbeinu Avraham Kloizner (minhagei Maharak), ed. Yonah Yosef Disen (Jerusalem: Makhon Yerushalayim, 1978), 12, section 13, par. 3–4. 67. The minhag books of Mainz, Worms, Fürth, and Frankfurt include no references to the recitation of yom le-yabashah.
320
Mah.azor Ha-H.ayyim Seligmann Baer gave the impression that yom le-yabashah, in both its liturgical and life-cycle contexts, was normative in German congregations,68 a contrary opinion was given by Wolf Heidenheim (1757–1832), who published innumerable editions of German prayer books, and more recently, by Yonah Fraenkel.69 Furthermore, Abraham Baer inserted a liturgical–musical rubric in his Baal T’fillah, explicitly classifying recitation of yom le-yabashah for a circumcision as minhag polin.70 Musical settings of yom le-yabashah in various cantorial compendia are, not surprisingly, of eastern German and Central European provenance. They range from a simple one notated by Abraham Baer, in which the h.azzan sang each stanza in a joyous melody in major (example 8a),71 to more elaborate pieces transcribed by Moritz Deutch (Breslau), Aron Friedmann (Berlin), and Maier Wodak (Moravia), each based on various traditional prayer modes of the Ashkenazic synagogue. Similar or recurring refrain lines in the more complex pieces, melodic elements of which were shared in common by Deutsch and Friedmann (whose version is cited here), invited congregational participation at every strophic recurrence of the closing words, shibbeh.u ge’ulim (“the redeemed ones sang”: example 8b).72 Bar Mitzvah The emergence of the bar mitzvah ceremony was a comparatively late development. It was of German origin but only coalesced and became widespread in the late Middle Ages or the early modern period.73 Despite the relatively late emergence of the ceremony, two musical traditions developed. Yuspa Shamash mentioned that in Worms, a special attractive
68. Seligmann Baer, ‘Avodat yisra’eil, 645. 69. “In mehreren deutschen Gemeinden wird יום ליבשהnicht gebetet”; see Wolf Heidenheim, Gebete für das Pessachfest mit deutscher Übersetzung (Rödelheim, 1860), 96. Yonah Fraenkel, Mah.zor Pesah., 474, states that recitation of yom le-yabashah on the seventh day of Passover (which points to its use at berit milah as well) belonged to minhag polin. 70. Abraham Baer, Baal T’fillah, no. 691, annotation. 71. Abraham Baer, Baal T’fillah, no. 647. This melody was also sung on Shabbat beshalah. and on the seventh day of Passover; see annotation to no. 881. However, Baer adds that “In den meisten deutschen Gemeinden fällt יום ליבשהweg,” which leads to the possibility that while some German (minhag ’ashkenaz) communities did recite the piyyut on that day, this was not normally the case when there was a berit milah. 72. Deutsch, Vorbeterschule, nos. 166–70; Friedmann, Schir Lisch’laumau, no. 249; Wodak, Hamnazeach, no. 312, explicitly stating that it was for a berit milah on the Sabbath, as well as other occasions. Deutsch’s setting is in major, but with modulations to the minor mode; that of Friedmann also begins in major, but thereupon expands into the ’Adonai Malakh mode (major with lowered seventh and tenth); Wodak’s setting is in the ’Ahavah Rabbah (augmented second interval between second and third tones and lowered sixth) mode. 73. Marcus, The Jewish Life Cycle, 99. Yuspa Shamash’s use of the words “the bar mitzvah (boy)” points to a recent development; see Marcus, The Jewish Life Cycle, 98, quoting Shamash, Minhagim 2:164, section 289.
321
Geoffrey Goldberg
Example 8a. Baer’s joyous setting of yom le-yabashah for h.azzan alone. Abraham Baer, Baal T’fillah: oder der practische Vorbeter, 150, no. 647. melody was sung for the reshut (invocation) “May God shield and protect,” ve-ya‘azor ve-yagein, recited in the Torah service immediately before the Torah reading. Normally sung by the h.azzan or the Torah reader as a preface to the
Example 8b. Aron Friedmann’s yom le-yabashah. Printed in 1902 under the auspices of Deutcheisraelitischer Gemeindebund (Berlin). Source: Schir Lisch’laumau, no. 249.
322
Mah.azor Ha-H.ayyim first ‘aliyah to the Torah,74 on the occasion of a bar mitzvah, it was recited by the boy himself. In Worms, the same melody was used for this prayer text on Simhat Torah (example 9a):75 This special ve-ya‘azor ve-yagein melody was the custom in Frankfurt as well,76 and it appears to have been restricted to western and southwestern Germany.77 On every other occasion, ve-ya‘azor ve-yagein was chanted in a modal chant of considerable antiquity (based on High Holy Day cantillation), the same mode used in minhag ’ashkenaz for the weekday evening (ma‘ariv) service and the shema‘ and its blessings in the weekday morning (shah.arit) service (see example 9b).78 There was further musical elaboration in Frankfurt on those Sabbaths when a bar mitzvah ceremony occurred. After the seventh ‘aliyah and before the maftir portion when the boy would be called up to the Torah, the “Kaddish over the Torah” (kaddish ‘al ha-torah) was recited. The h.azzan sang the first part, as on a regular Sabbath,79 but to mark the distinctiveness of the day, he departed from the usual melody in the second part of the text, singing it to one of the more recent “popular melodies.”80 Marriage The wedding ceremony was the pinnacle in a cycle of ritualized community festivities both preceding and following it. Perhaps because of the protracted stages involved in contracting marriage and the complexity of the rituals surrounding it, over time, there occurred more far-reaching musical changes than with berit milah. A major factor influencing these developments was the change of the day of the traditional wedding ceremony. Engagement. The cycle leading to marriage began with the engagement (tena’im), known in western Ashkenazic communities as k’nas (legen), and involved a financial settlement (k’nas) incumbent should the wedding be cancelled. On the Sabbath following the k’nas, the h.azzan called up the bridegroom to the Torah with a festive ya’amod (“let [the bridegroom] arise”), and the latter made a charitable contribution.81 This special calling up “with a loud voice” 74. In Germany, this was invariably the same person, as there was no separate Torah reader. The emergence of a separate office in Eastern Europe of the ba‘al keri’ah requires further study. 75. Shamash, Minhagim, 1:222, section 288. The special melody appears in Ogutsch, Frankfurter Kantor, 54, no. 159, ;נגון בר מצוהGeiger, Divrei kehillot. 76. Geiger, Divrei kehillot, 360, section 2. In footnote, no. 19, to Shamash (vol. 1), Hamburger states that in Frankfurt, the h.azzan sang ve-ya‘azor ve-yagein, but Geiger wrote בנגון שמנגן בר מצוה, “in the melody that a bar mitzvah boy uses.” 77. The bar mizvah niggun, at least according to the joyful melody transcribed by Fabian Ogutsch (see n. 75 herein), had a strictly metrical rhythm and was sung in a major key, good indications of its later origin. 78. Abraham Baer, Baal T’fillah, 28, no. 104a. 79. Abraham Baer, Baal T’fillah, 139, no. 590; Ogutsch, Frankfurter Kantor 20, no. 51. 80. Ogutsch, Frankfurter Kantor, 29. Geiger refers to four melodies, all settings of the “Full Kaddish” (nos. 125–28). 81. The donation was made to the hekdeish, probably the hostel for wayfarers; Shamash, Minhagim, 2:2.
323
Geoffrey Goldberg
Example 9a. Ve-ya‘azor ve-yagein melody for a bar mitzvah boy (Frankfurt: J. Kauffmann, 1930). Source: Fabian Ogutsch, Der Frankfurter Kantor: Sammlung der traditionellen Frankfurter Gesänge, 54, no. 159.
Example 9b. Modal chant for Ve-ya‘azor ve-yagein sung on a regular Sabbath. Abraham Baer, Baal T’fillah: oder der practische Vorbeter, 28, no. 104a. (be-kol ram) was regarded as praiseworthy and customary by Yehudah Zelichover, a seventeenth-century h.azzan from Amsterdam.82 The same tune was used on other occasions, such as the Sabbath before (or after) the wedding, for the calling up of a bar mitzvah, and for announcing the h.atan Torah and h.atan Bereishit on Simhat Torah. The melody of the festive ya‘amod, according to the musical notation of Isaak Lachmann (1838–1900), was trumpet-like (see example 10).83 82. Shamash, Minhagim, 2:2; Yehudah Leyb ben Moshe of Zelichov [Zelichover] (d. 1701), Shirei yehudah (Amsterdam: Asher Anshil ben Eliezer, 1696), 26b, be-kol ram. The statement of the author (who originally was from Poland) that this was the practice “in these states” could refer either to the Dutch Republic or to the western Ashkenazic lands in general. Two and a half centuries later, Bruno Stern, in his memoir of small-town life in pre-Holocaust Württemberg, recalled the festive calling up; see Stern, Meine Jugenderinnerungen: an eine württembergische Kleinstadt und ihre jüdische Gemeinde (Stuttgart: W. Kohlhammer, 1968), 122. 83. Isaak Lachmann, Awaudas Jisroeil: Der israelitische Gottesdienst: traditionelle Synagogengesänge des süddeutschen und osteuropäischen Ritus (Hürben, Bavaria, 1898–99), 153, no. 120, Birnbaum Collection, Hebrew Union College, Cincinnati, Mus. Add. 2–3. While the text underlay here is for a bar mitzvah, יעמוד פלוני בן פלוני בר מצוה שלישי חזק, Lachmann signifies that the same melody is used for calling up a bridegroom.
324
Mah.azor Ha-H.ayyim
Example 10. Festive melody for Ya‘amod, notated by Isaak Lachmann. From the Birnbaum Collection, Hebrew Union College–Jewish Institute of Religion (Cincinnati). “Shabbat Weddings” or Shabbat Breilaft. An older medieval custom, in both ’ashkenaz and polin, from at least the time of the First Crusade in 1096, had been for the h.uppah ceremony to be conducted on Friday, even close to the onset of Shabbat, as was the case in Worms.84 In Germany, these “Sabbath weddings” extended into the Sabbath proper. Such weddings were often known as Shabbat Breilaft, although Jacob Moellin did not use, or was unfamiliar with, this name.85 Almost all the special wedding piyyutim included in JTS Library MS 8972 were connected to the ceremonies of Shabbat Breilaft. In the early modern period, however, the day for weddings was transferred to Wednesday, as had been talmudic practice.86 In Frankfurt, Shabbat Breilaft was discontinued around the year 1660, despite a short-lived attempt in 1701 to revive it.87 In Worms, the older practice had already ceased by the time Shamash wrote down his minhagim,88 although he described the former practice in detail. On Saturday morning, when the bridegroom, followed by the bride, was escorted to the synagogue, a special musical elaboration occurred. In Frankfurt, the escorting was even accompanied by music played by Gentile musicians.89 In Worms, the precentor (menagein) of the pesukei de-zimrah halted the shah.arit service before mi yidmeh lakh, “who is like You,” in the nishmat hymn, to permit the escorting of the bridegroom.90 Once the latter had been brought into the synagogue, the precentor would sing mi yidmeh lakh with special emphasis (be-kol ram)—a personalization of the text to “who, indeed, is like you.”91 84. Shamash, Minhagim 2:9–10, section 229, n. 1 of Hamburger; 52–59, section 235 (Shamash’s complete description of Shabbat Breilaft), and n. 18 of Hamburger, quoting Yoseif ’omez.; Kirchheim, Minhagot, 79. The original intent of the “Sabbath wedding” was to save expenses, following the massacres of 1096 and the impoverishment of the Jews. 85. Breiluft, Bruitloft, Brautloft, i.e., “wedding”; see Shamash, Minhagim, 2:52, n. 20 of Hamburger Moellin, Seifer Maharil 464, section 2. 86. M. Ketubot 1:1 (for virgins). 87. Seider ve-hanhagah shel nisu’in ha-h.atunah breilaft ke-minhag frankfurt-de-main ‛im birkat ha-mazon (Frankfurt: John Wust, 1701; repr., Jerusalem: [s.n.], 1992). 88. Shamash, Minhagim 2:9, section 229. 89. Seider ve-hanhagah shel nisu’in 5, par. 5; 7, par. 11. Strangely, this source makes no mention of the bride being escorted with instrumental music from the synagogue. See the section of Shabbat Spinholz for further on the employment of Gentile musicians on the Sabbath. 90. Shamash, Minhagim 2:52, section 235; Kirchheim, Minhagot, 79–80. 91. Kirchheim mentioned the special musical emphasis; Minhagot, 80. R. Yair Hayyim Bacharach was shocked that this had been the custom in Worms because, in other localities, the interruption occurred at “a more appropriate place,” such as before barukh she’amar—where the pesukei de-zimrah
325
Geoffrey Goldberg There was a fairly logical reason why the break for the escorting occurred at mi yidmeh lakh: at this juncture, a piyyut opening with the same words ָּלְך- וִּמי יִ ۟ ְשוֶה/ ָּלך- ִמי יְִדֶמהhad once been inserted. This piyyut was included in JTS Library MS 8972.92 Shamash and Kirchheim apparently did not know this particular piyyut, which, had it once been sung in Worms, had long been discontinued. Nevertheless the escorting on Shabbat Breilaft remained, and the final section of nishmat was given musical emphasis.93 Wedding-related piyyutim inserted into the service listed by Shamash and Kirchheim, and somewhat earlier almost identically by Jacob Moellin, belonged to a smaller and different repertory. These might have represented minhag reinus (Rhineland) as against minhag oystraikh (Austria) represented by JTS Library MS 8972.94 A piyyut from both repertories was ’ataneh shevah.ei, sung after the bridegroom had been called up to the Torah by a special reshut (the same as that sung on Simhat Torah). The piyyut includes references to the h.atan and quotes God’s blessing to Adam and Eve and the commandment and hope for children (Genesis 1:28). According to Moellin, the opening stanza was sung together by the h.azzan and shushvinim, his close friends also “obligated” to be called up on this occasion, indicating that the text and the melody were familiar.95 The Later Mid-Week Wedding. With the transfer of the marriage ceremony to Wednesday, the shah.arit service on the day of the wedding now occasioned far less musical enrichment. The cessation of the Sabbath wedding enabled the
section began—or after nishmat, just before it ended. See Shamash, Minhagim 2:53, n. 26 of Hamburger, quoting Yair Bacharach, Mekor h.ayyim, section 51, par. 5; Moellin, Seifer maharil, 469, section 8, gloss n. 6. 92. Schmelzer, “Mashehu,” 36–37. 93. A similar piyyut in JTS Library MS 8972 was nishmat yesharim, noted for its beauty and simplicity, although it likewise received no mention by Shamash or Kirchheim. Each stanza begins with the word נְִֹשַמת, and its final line concludes with the opening phrase of the second part of the nishmat hymn, ]אוְֹמִרים[ ִאילוּ ִפינוּ ָמֵלאֹ ִשיָרה ִַכיָּם. It makes references to marriage, the bride and groom (through biblical quotations that constitute the last line of each stanza), and friends who participate in the escorting. It was first printed in 1717 in the prayer book of R. Isaiah Horowitz (ca. 1565– 1630), and might have still been sung despite discontinuation of Shabbat Breilaft. The prayer book includes the rubric that the h.azzan was to sing the piyyut before nishmat. See Schmelzer, “Mashehu,” 34–35; R. Isaiah Horowitz, Sha’ar ha-shamayim (Amsterdam: Beit ’aharon di shelomo antonis, 1717), 134. 94. In Mainz and Worms, the insertion of piyyutim commenced immediately before barekhu; see Moellin, Seifer maharil, 469–70, par. 8–9; Shamash, Minhagim, 2:52–57; Kirschner, Minhagot, 80–81. In Austria and in the east, the piyyutim started at the end of nishmat; see Isaac Tyrnau, Seifer ha-minhagim, ed. Shlomo Spitzer (Jerusalem: Makhon Yerushalayim 1979), 163–65. 95. The remainder of ataneh shevah.ei was sung by the h.azzan alone. According to Moellin, it was sung immediately after the Torah reading, but Shamash and Kirchheim say it was sung after ’ashrei; see Moellin, Seifer maharil, 470, par. 9; Davidson, א, 8967; Shamash, Minhagim, 57, section 235; Kirchheim, Minhagot, 81. In Frankfurt (and possibly elsewhere), the h.azzan and his vocal assistants (meshorrerim) also sang ve-ya‘azor ve-yagein בקול נעימה וזימרה, “in a melodious singing tone,” perhaps similar to, or the same as, the niggun bar mizvah; see Seider ve-hanhagah shel nisu’in, 5, par. 6.
326
Mah.azor Ha-H.ayyim avoidance of rabbinic opposition to removing piyyut. Of all the piyyutim once sung on Shabbat Breilaft, by the nineteenth century, only a special ’eloheikhem inserted in the kedushah of the musaf service generally continued to be sung.96 Nevertheless, in Worms, several fixed liturgical texts in the morning service on the day of the wedding received musical embellishment. As with the berit milah, shirah h.adashah, and z.ur yisra’eil, the concluding sections of the ge’ulah prayer, were sung to special melodies. Despite a lack of clarity in Shamash’s description, it is clear that at least one melody was used exclusively for marriages.97 If, for some reason, the marriage ceremony took place on Thursday, even though the “supplication” was omitted, the short passage ’eil ’erekh ’appayim was sung to a “pretty melody.”98 In addition, the bridegroom was called to the Torah.99 Pre-Marriage Rite: Spinholz. The Sabbath before the wedding was known as Spinholz ()שפינהולץ, a rather obscure term whose etymology remains unresolved.100 Then, as now, the bridegroom was called to the Torah, although the term aufruf (calling up) is of later origin.101 Such importance was given in Mainz to the festive character of Shabbat Spinholz that up until the year 1743, kabbalat shabbat was celebrated on this occasion with instrumental music (kelei zemer).102 In the ma‘ariv service, in order to bring attention to the forthcoming wedding, the h.azzan sang two liturgical texts to special melodies. The first was malkhutekha in the ge’ulah prayer, following the mi khamokha response of the congregation.103 This was a popular text for cantors to embellish. For example, the Berlin h.azzan Aaron Beer (1738–1821) composed a different malkhutekha 96. Seligmann Baer, ’Avodat yisra’eil, 244; Abraham Baer, Baal T’fillah, nos. 615–16. On change in Ashkenazic liturgical use of piyyut in the early modern period, see Langer, To Worship God Properly, 183. 97. According to one manuscript source, Shamash explicitly stated that “on the day of the wedding the h.azzan sings shirah h.adashah in the special melody for a wedding day”; see Shamash, Minhagim 2:26, section 231, gloss. Elsewhere, however, he wrote, “the h.azzan sang shirah h.adashah with the melody (for the bridegroom) [of the berit milah] and z.ur yisra’eil with the melody for the berit milah [for the bridegroom].” The seemingly contradictory annotations within square brackets were those of a later manuscript of Shamash; see Minhagim 2:81, long additional note of Shamash to section 245. 98. Ibid., 2:28, section 23; Shamash uses the term teh.inah, rather than the more familiar term tah.anun. 99. Ibid., 2:28, section 231. 100. The word literally means “spinning-wood,” but Marcus argues against any connection between Spinholz and Spindel (distaff, referring to the supposed spinning abilities of the bride); see Marcus, Jewish Life Cycle, 152. In Frankfurt and elsewhere, there were originally two consecutive Spinholz sabbaths; see Shamash, Minhagim 2:4, n. 25 of Hamburger, quoting Yosif ’omez. (1723) of Joseph Yuspa Hahn (1570–1637), section 657. 101. Marcus, Jewish Life Cycle, 152. 102. Shamash, Minhagim 2:4, section 227, n. 29 of Hamburger, quoting ’Eileh divrei ha-berit (Hamburg, 1819), 5. Instrumental music for kabbalat shabbat prior to the onset of the Sabbath was not uncommon in a number of Central European communities in the eighteenth century; see Idelsohn, Jewish Music, 205–207. 103. Shamash, Minhagim 2:4. However, Hamburger points out (4, n. 28) that in one manuscript variant, Shamash does not include malkhutekha.
327
Geoffrey Goldberg for each Sabbath of the year, although, as far as can be ascertained, none was specifically for a life-cycle event.104 On Shabbat Spinholz, the opening words ( מלכותך ראו בניךYour children beheld Your sovereignty) were taken out of context and personalized, with vanekha (your children) directed toward the bridal couple rather than (or in addition) to the Israelites. Unfortunately, no musical transcriptions of this special malkhutekha appear to be extant. According to Scheuermann, it was sung to the same melody as semeh.im be-z.eitam.105 The second text receiving emphasis was hashkiveinu, the second blessing after the evening shema’. In Worms, this special musical treatment began two-thirds of the way through, at ki ’eil shomereinu (For God watches over us), which was also the custom in Alsace and Baden.106 In Amsterdam, while the older practice was to begin at ki ’eil shomereinu, it later became customary for cantors to compose a setting of the entire prayer in honor of the celebration, a practice found also in Frankfurt.107 The similarity between a melody used in Frankfurt for ki ’eil shomereinu on Hanukkah and that of a south German kallalied (bridal song) suggests that this melody might originally have been used on Shabbat Spinholz (see examples 11a–b).108 The next day, almost everywhere (but not, for example, in Fürth),109 the bridegroom would be called to the Torah with the special ya’amod melody at shah.arit. In Worms, however, the bridegroom was called up at minh.ah, possibly so as to be honored at a time closer to the wedding.110 At the musaf service, the h.azzan sang the closing lines of the kaddish shaleim (yehei shelamah rabbah and ‘oseh shalom) to a special melody referred to by Shamash as “the melody for the bridegroom and the bride” (niggun h.atan ve-kallah), suggesting a well-known traditional tune.111 Following the midday se‛udah (obligatory meal), the bride and bridegroom proceeded to the Braut Haus (wedding hall) or the Tantz Haus (dance hall). The 104. Idelsohn, The Synagogue Song of the German Jews, passim. 105. Scheuermann, Gottesdienstlichen Gesänge, 21, section I/E, no. 14. 106. Shamash, Minhagim 2:4, section 227, where he writes hashkiveinu, ki ’eil shomereinu, possibly referring to two separate melodies, but more likely referring to ki ’eil shomereinu within the hashkiveinu; see Freddy Raphael, “Le Mariage juif dans la compagne Alsaciènne dans la deuxième moiti édu XIX siècle,” Folklore Research Center Studies 4 (1974): 190; Scheuermann, Gottesdienstlichen Gesänge 21, section I/E, no. 14. 107. Shamash, Minhagim 2:4, n. 29 of Hamburger (Amsterdam); Kosman, Noheig, 112, par. 2. A full setting of hashkiveinu for when a bridegroom attended the Friday night service before the wedding was included in the unpublished Dutch cantorial collection, transcribed between 1943 and 1945, of Hazzan Louis Frank (1880–1962), section III, 24–26. See Josée Wolff, H.azzanut and Nusah. in the Dutch Ashkenazic Community (master’s thesis, Hebrew Union College–Jewish Institute of Religion, 1991), 73. 108. Ogutsch, Frankfurter Kantor, 102, no. 315; Idelsohn, The Traditional Songs of the South German Jews, 112, no. 325. 109. Gumpil, Sefer minhagim de-kehillateinu, section 100; Shamash, Minhagim 2:6, no. 42 of Hamburger. 110. Shamash, Minhagim 2:5, 8, section 227. The explanation is that suggested by Hamburger, 6, n. 42. 111. Ibid., 6. It is possible that the melody in question was one of the paraliturgical or folk songs sung at the wedding celebrations following the Sabbath meals on Friday night and Saturday morning.
328
Mah.azor Ha-H.ayyim
Example 11a. Fabian Ogutsch’s notation of Ki ’eil shomereinu. Fabian Ogutsch, Der Frankfurter Kantor, ed. J.B. Levy (Frankfurt: J. Kauffmann, 1930).
Example 11b. Maier Kohn’s notation of a South-German kallalied. Published in 1933. Reprinted by Ktav in 1973. Source: Idelsohn, Thesaurus volume, The Traditional Songs of the South German Jews, 112, no. 325. bride was accompanied from her parent’s home with instrumental music played by non-Jewish musicians (leiz.anim). In medieval ’ashkenaz, music played by Gentiles on the Sabbath during the seven days of feasting after the wedding had been quite widespread, and in the early modern period, employment of such musicians was still not uncommon.112 112. Shamash, Minhagim 2:6–8, and nn. 45–49 of Hamburger. For Gentile musicians playing on the Sabbath, see Israel Abrahams, Jewish Life in the Middle Ages (New York: Atheneum, 1973), 197; Hamburger, 7 n. 47, quoting Shenei luh.ot ha-berit, section 2, of R. Isaiah Horowitz, who served in Frankfurt and Prague. In Germany in the seventeenth century, the term leiz.anim had no connection with the role of badh.anim (jesters), while the term ( כלי זמרkelei zemer) referred to the musical instruments, not the instrumentalists ( כליזמריםklezmorim), as in Poland. The latter term only started to be used in Germany in the mid-eighteenth century; see Isaac Rivkind, Kleizmorim: Perek be-toledot ha-‘amamit [Jewish folk musicians: A study in cultural history] (New York: Futuro Press, 1960), 15.
329
Geoffrey Goldberg Pre-Wedding Rite: Mayen. If the bride had not previously been married and was a virgin, a special festivity commenced early in the morning of wedding day. This ceremony was known as the mayen ()מאיין, derived from May Day customs relating to courtship and fertility.113 Before the shah.arit service, the bride and groom were escorted with torches and instrumental music to the mayen, the location of which, in most German communities, was the entrance to the synagogue,114 though in Worms it was held in the Braut Haus.115 There, the people threw wheat (a symbol of fertility) at the bridal couple and called out to them, ְּּפרוּ וְּרבו, “be fruitful and multiply” (Genesis 1:28).116 Then the bridegroom was escorted to the synagogue. One melody (dating from the late eighteenth century) played at the mayen was, in the following century, transferred into the synagogue when marriages were again performed there.117 This melody was known in the Judeo-Deutsch of Alsace as the kale-lid or khuppe-lied, and in Bavaria as the maan (a corruption of mayen) niggun;118 it became one of the most popular folk songs of nineteenthcentury German-speaking Jews. A number of transcriptions of the melody are extant, the first dating from 1832 (see example 12a). A second transcription of the mayen shows that it acquired a text in Alsatian Judeo-Deutsch and German (see example 12b).119 The Paraliturgical Song: ’Eh.ad yah.id u-meyyuh.ad. Most embellishments did not survive the discontinuance of the Shabbat wedding. Nevertheless, the rabbinic ideal of mezamerim ’oto, the obligation to provide song for the couple, helped to prevent the complete eclipse of festive singing.120 Consequently, the
113. Marcus, The Jewish Life Cycle, 150–51; Shamash, Minhagim 2:20, section 231, n. 5, where Hamburger provides a detailed explanation of the origins of the word mayen and its alternative spellings. 114. Moellin, Seifer maharil, 464, section 1; Shamash, Minhagim 2:22, section 231, n. 10 of Hamburger. 115. Moellin, Seifer maharil, 464, section 1; Shamash, Minhagim 2:22, section 235. 116. Shamash, Minhagim 2:20–25, section 231. 117. Geiger, Divrei kehillot, 420. In medieval Mainz, weddings were performed inside the synagogue; see Moellin, Seifer maharil, 465, par. 3; Moses ben Isaac ha-Levi Minz, Teshuvot maharam minz. (1415–80), section 109. However, in the centuries prior to the emancipation, the general custom was to conduct them outside, in the courtyard of the synagogue. Synagogue weddings were reintroduced in Germany in the nineteenth century, this change being arguably less an innovation than a restoration. 118. Daniel Stauben, Scènes da la vie juive en Alsace (Paris: Michel Lévy, 1860), 188; Raphael, “Le Mariage juif,” 192–93; Moritz Rosenhaupt, Schire Ohel Yaakov, vol. 3, Werktags-Gottesdienst (Leipzig: privately printed, 1895), 16. 119. Max Grunwald, “Musik bei jüdischen Hochzeiten,” Jahrbuch für jüdische Volkskunde 1923: 249–51. Grunwald did not identify the name of the 1832 published musical transcription. The triple-time meter fits perfectly into the character of a Ländler, and it bears a strong resemblance to two German ballads; see Walter Salmen, Jüdische Musikanten und Tänzer vom 13. bis. 20 Jahrhundert (Innsbruck: Hebling, 1991), 129. This melody was also used in south Germany at Purim for a verse relating to the hanging of Haman on the gallows (Esther 7:10). See Ogutsch, Frankfurter Kantor 103, no. 317; Scheuermann, Gottesdienstlichen Gesänge, 91, section 5/D, no. 5. 120. Hamburger, “Zemer le-h.atan,” 367.
330
Mah.azor Ha-H.ayyim
Example 12a. Maan-niggun for a wedding processional arranged by Moritz Rosenhaupt. Privately printed in Germany, 1895. Source: Schire Ohel Yaakov, vol. 3, 16.
Example 12b. Kale-lid with Alsatian Judeo-Deutsch and German text (unattributed). From Jahrbuch für jüdische Volkskunde, 1923. tradition of singing a piyyut after the bridegroom was called to the Torah still continued. Rabbi Abraham David Warhman (1771–1841) of Buczacz, Galicia, in his commentary to the Shulh.an ‛arukh, alluded to the singing of a pizmon at this time as if it were a fairly common occurrence.121 He was quite probably alluding to a piyyut that had gained almost universal popularity and survived into modern times: ’eh.ad yah.id u-meyyuh.ad by Avigdor Karo of Prague (d. 1439). Written in Hebrew, but also with a variant in Yiddish, early printings of the Hebrew piyyut, often with the heading zemer na’eh le-h.atan (A Fitting Song for a Bridegroom), were included in publications of the birkat ha-mazon for use at the 121. Eshel ’avraham to Shulhan ‘arukh, Orah h.ayyim, Section 140:1. Strictly speaking, pizmon refers to a piyyut with a refrain, but Wahrman applied it more broadly.
331
Geoffrey Goldberg wedding feast, the earliest dating from 1580.122 Every indication shows, however, that eh.ad yahid u-meyyuh.ad was not sung at the wedding feast, but rather after the h.atan had been called up to the Torah.123 This usually occurred on the Sabbath before the wedding, though in some places it occurred on the Sabbath after the wedding or even following the betrothal (tena’im), while in some communities it was sung on all three occasions.124 .ֶאָחד יִָחיד וְּמיָֻחד ֵאל .נְִדָֹרש ְלַבר ֵלָבבֹשוֵֹאל .ַאְך טוֹב ֱאֹלִהים ְליְִֹש ָרֵאל .ַהֲללוּיָה God, the One and Unique, Sought by the pure in heart who seek, That God acts kindly to Israel, Halleluyah.
Textually, the piyyut has no connection whatsoever with marriage, but deals, instead, with strengthening one’s trust in God, observance of the 613 commandments, invoking God’s blessing on Israel, and inviting anyone of the three monotheistic faiths (ערבי-נוצרי-)יהודי125 to experience the purity of Judaism’s fidelity to the oneness of God. The purely theological character of the piyyut was stressed by Juspa Kosman, who considered the song one of “great praise and a testimony to the principles of the religion.”126 Entry into marriage was a time for forgiveness of sins of the past and for devotion not only to one’s beloved, but also to God. This factor also explains the singing at wedding celebrations of other piyyutim that had no outward connection to marriage, such as yigdal, the poetic paraphrase of the Maimonides’ Thirteen Articles of Faith.127 There are many historical references to the singing of the piyyut. For example, Judah Leib Zelichover extolled the singing of ’eh.ad yah.id for the bridegroom (on shabbat k’nas, the Sabbath after the betrothal) among other customs “in these lands,” the reference being to Amsterdam and the Republic of the United Provinces.128 Rabbi Joseph Juspa Kosman (d. 1758) detailed how, in Frankfurt, the Sabbath before the wedding was a time “to increase joy … to call him [the bridegroom] to the Torah … and sing on this behalf (u-mezamrim lo) ’eh.ad 122. Birkat ha-mazon (Prague, 1580), quoted in Hamburger, “Zemer le-h.atan,” 378 n. 81. 123. Birkat ha-mazon (Amsterdam, 1694), quoted in Hamburger, “Zemer le-h.atan,” 397. 124. Hamburger, “Zemer le-h.atan,” 399–401. 125. Opening of the third stanza. 126. Kosman, Noheig, 112, section 2. 127. Hamburger, “Zemer le-hatan,” 394–97, gives a number of explanations for the connection between yigdal and “rejoicing the bridegroom.” In Worms, guests sang yigdal at celebrations and feasting at the Braut Haus on the night prior to the wedding; see Shamash, Minhagim 2:19, section 230. At the end of the next day, “the men and the boys” sang yigdal again in honor of the newly married couple; see ibid., 44, section 230. 128. Zelichover, Shirei yehudah, 26b.
332
Mah.azor Ha-H.ayyim yah.id.”129 In Frankfurt, meshorerim, the vocal assistants to h.azzanim, played an active role,130 as they did in Prague131 and undoubtedly elsewhere. In postemancipation times, references to singing ’eh.ad yah.id u-meyyuh.ad for the bridegroom were frequently made in descriptions of traditional Jewish life in Western and Central Europe, as well as in autobiographical reminiscences.132 Remarkably, for centuries, ’eh.ad yah.id u-meyyuh.ad was never printed in a standard Ashkenazic prayer book. The only siddur that appears to have eventually included it (and then only the opening stanza) was the Festival prayer book edited in 1866 by Rabbi Michael Sachs of Berlin.133 Seligmann Baer included the entire piyyut in his handbook for Torah readers published that year,134 as did Lion Wolff in his 1914 handbook for cantors.135 The first published musical transcription of the piyyut, like the text itself, emanated from Prague.136 Several notations were included in the collections of nineteenth-century h.azzanim, and Idelsohn provided three versions in his Thesaurus volume of south German melodies (examples 13a–b).137 The absence of ’eh.ad yah.id u-meyyuh.ad from printed siddurim underscores that it functioned as a paraliturgical text transmitted orally by h.azzanim. As a result, much of the text was forgotten, especially in eastern regions of Europe.138 Even in Western Europe, just the opening stanza (or two) was generally sung.139 This process of reduction was noted by Juspa Kossman of Frankfurt, who held that all the stanzas should be sung, “unlike some h.azzanim who sing only one or two.”140 In Central and Eastern Europe, even the first (and only) stanza was
129. Kosman, Noheig 112, section 2. 130. Seder ve-hanhagah shel nisu‘in, 6. 131. Hamburger, “Zemer la-h.atan,” 398. 132. References include Samuel Bloch, “Aus dem ehemaligen Kurhessen,” Mitteilungen zur jüdischen Volkskunde 29 (1926): 588 (Kurhessen); Stern, Meine Jugenderinnerungen, 122 (Niederstetten, Württemberg, where it was sung on the Sabbath after the wedding); Carlebach, Ratgeber für das jüdische Haus, 43 (Lübeck, northern Germany); Fürst, Sitten und Gebräuche, 57 (Eisenstadt, western Hungary, where it was sung on the Sabbath after the wedding). 133. Festgebete der Israeliten, fünfter Theil, Succoth, trans. and ed. Michael Sachs (Berlin: Louis Gerschel), 282. 134. Seligmann Baer, Tikkun ha-sofeir veha-korei (Rödelheim: I. Lehrberger, 1866), xiii. 135. Wolff, Liturgisches Handbuch, 80–81. 136. Flamm, Noten-Beilagen, 5–6, no. 3. 137. Abraham Baer, Baal T’fillah, 206, no. 993 (and liturgical annotation, 139); Isaac Lachmann, Awaudas Jisroeil: Der israelitische Gottesdienst, III Teil, Die Drei Wallfahrtsfeste, hrs. Andor Izsák (Hannover: Europäisches Zentrum für Jüdische Musik, 1993–95), 2:242–44, no. 191; Samuel Bloch, “Aus dem ehemaligen Kurhessen,” 588; Idelsohn, The Traditional Songs of the South German Jews, Hebräisch-orientalisicher Melodienschatz 6 (Leipzig: Friderich Hofmeister, 1933), 126, nos. 356 –58. Baer and Lachmann include rubrics stating that the piyyut was also sung for the h.atan torah and h.atan bereishit on Simhat Torah. 138. Hamburger, “Zemer le-h.atan,” 403–404 (Eastern Europe). 139. Ibid., 406–407. 140. Kosman, Noheig 112, section 2. Yet Kosman only referred to “all four stanzas.” If he was referring to double stanzas, then the complete text would include five, the first possibly serving as a refrain. A more likely explanation is that Kosman only knew of four (single) stanzas, which he took
333
Geoffrey Goldberg
Examples 13a.
Examples 13b. Two versions of ‘Eh.ad yah.id included by Idelsohn in his Thesaurus volume of south German Jewish melodies. Published in 1933, Reprinted by Ktav in 1973. Source: The Traditional Songs of the South German Jews, 126, nos. 356 (a) and 358 (b). corrupted through textual deletions, substitutions, additions, or paraphrases141 to such an extent that among h.aredim in Jerusalem before the Shoah, only a wordless niggun was sung, the melody of which had formerly carried the words of ’eh.ad yah.id.142 Death For mourners, absence of song was an effective means to enable the community to share an individual’s personal loss. In minhag ’ashkenaz, and even in some western regions of minhag polin, such as in Berlin, the h.azzan or ba’al tefillah
to be the complete text. Seligmann Baer, in his handbook for Torah readers, provided the annotation “in many communities only the first stanza is recited.” See Baer, Tikkun ha-sofeir veha-korei, xiii. 141. Hamburger, “Zemer le-h.atan,” 405. 142. Ibid., 406.
334
Mah.azor Ha-H.ayyim commenced the morning service with the recitation of the hymn ’adon ‘olam. On ordinary weekdays, this was usually a simple chant. In Frankfurt, following the death of a member of the community (older than one year of age) and burial had not yet taken place, the chanting of ’adon ‘olam was omitted.143 In this way, without any formal verbal pronouncement of sad news, the community was informed of a person’s death. The Emancipation and Life-Cycle Song In the early nineteenth century, there was a drive in Germany to eliminate, reduce, or at least regulate the singing of melodies associated with life-cycle events in the synagogue. Several factors contributed to this downplaying. The presentation of Judaism as a faith rather than as a way of life led to a minimization of the folk and peoplehood aspects of Jewish life. Attention to individual semah.ot (celebrations) was viewed as a digression from a liturgy whose purpose was to express the universal truths of Judaism. Increased sensitivity to the image of Jews and Judaism in German society influenced attitudes toward the suitability of music for divine worship; an attendant lack of formality surrounding life-cycle song and rituals offended a changed aesthetic on the part of many German Jews who sought something “more akin to ecclesiastical formality” rather than the former “more improvised expression of Jewish worship.”144 Efforts to eliminate or regulate life-cycle folk customs found concrete expression in many Synagogen-Ordnungen, or synagogue regulations, drawn up by German rabbis, and were sometimes authorized by state authorities. They were introduced, mainly in the 1830s and 1840s, by Reformist-leaning rabbis and, for the most part, tended to avoid fundamental halakhic changes. Life-cycle synagogue melodies and piyyutim were brought under especially sharp scrutiny and regarded unfavorably.145 The first Synagogue Regulation issued in 1810 by the Consistory of the Kingdom of Cassel, headed by the early Reform leader Israel Jacobson, ruled that the calling up of a bridegroom should no longer be accompanied by special singing. The special singing of semeih.im be-z.eitam for a bridegroom or a yoledet was also no longer allowed. The Synagogue Regulation of Mittelfranken, Bavaria (1836), issued similar rules, prohibiting special singing when calling up a bar mitzvah or a bridegroom to 143. Geiger, Divrei kehillot, 13. 144. Stephan C. Reif, Judaism and Hebrew Prayer: New Perspectives on Jewish Liturgical History (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1993), 270. 145. Invaluable is the comparative study of the Synagogue Regulations by Steven M. Lowenstein, “The 1840s and the Creation of the German-Jewish Religious Movement,” in Revolution and Evolution in German-Jewish History, ed. Werner E. Mosse (Tübingen: J.C.B. Mohr, 1981), 255–97. Curtailment of piyyutim, except on High Holy Days, was generally favored. This was facilitated by “a general loss of Ashkenazic interest in piyyut”; see Langer, To Worship God Properly, 182–85. For attitudes toward piyyut by leading nineteenth-century German rabbis, see Michael A. Meyer, Response to Modernity: A History of the Reform Movement in Judaism (New York: Oxford University Press, 1988), 88, 106, 124, 150.
335
Geoffrey Goldberg the Torah and forbidding the singing of semeih.im be-z.eitam and malkhutekha for a bridegroom and for women after confinement.146 The Synagogue Regulation of Bamberg, Bavaria, specified that ’eh.ad yah.id u-meyyuh.ad could no longer be sung when a h.atan torah or a bridegroom was called up to the Torah.147 On the other hand, the Synagogue Regulation of the Duchy of Saxe-Weimer continued to permit its singing, if the bridegroom specifically requested it.148 In Württemberg, “inappropriateness” of the melodies was the motivating force in opposing the singing of malkhutekha for the bridal couple, ’eh.ad yah.id u-meyyuh.ad for the bridegroom, and semeih.im be-z.eitam for a woman after confinement.149 Even so, the new legislation intimated that if suitable melodies could be composed, they might be acceptable.150 These various regulations are useful in revealing how, by the nineteenth century, the texts and their melodies had become disconnected from the life-cycle events with which they had been originally associated. Semeih.im be-z.eitam (yoledet) was sometimes also sung for the bridegroom,151 and malkutekha was sometimes sung for a yoledet. It was also not uncommon for eh.ad yah.id to be sung for a bar mitzvah,152 as well as for the h.atan torah and h.atan bereishit. The words of the texts that connected to the life-cycle ceremonies lost their specificity and became generic. By the second part of the century, there were indications of a more positive reevaluation of these practices. For example, the Regulation of Hannover of 1870 sanctioned the recital of ’eh.ad yah.id and, on a Sabbath when there was a berit milah in the synagogue, encouraged the singing of a special piyyut.153 Furthermore, it permitted the special recitation of ve-kharot ‘imo ha-berit, suggesting the continuance of responsive singing of shirat ha-yam, as well as eloheikhem in the kedushah of musaf.154 Examination of the publications of several cantor-composers shows that some degree of life-cycle song in the synagogue not only was retained, but even was sometimes presented in more stylized forms. Three leading nineteenth-century composers of synagogue music, Louis Lewandowski (1823–94), Salomon Sulzer (1804–90), and Samuel Naumbourg (1815–80), composed choral settings for the 146. Synagogen-Ordnung … Mittelfranken, 1838: 7, par. 20. 147. Synagogen-Ordnung der Israelitischen Cultus Gemeinde zu Bamberg (1840s?), 4, par. 15. 148. Allgemeine Zeitung des Judenthums 1/28 1837, 110, par. 22; Jacob Petuchowski, Prayerbook Reform in Europe: The Liturgy of European Liberal and Reform Judaism (New York: World Union for Progressive Judaism, 1968), 126. However, the regulation no longer permitted any dramatic singing of ya‘amod by the h.azzan. 149. Königl. israelitische Oberkirchenbehörde, Gottesdienst-Ordnung für die Synagogen des Königreichs Württemberg (Stuttgart, 1838) 23, par. 22. 150. Ibid. 151. This transference occurred early; see Zelichover, Shirei yehudah, 26b. The occasion was on the Sabbath following the betrothal (Shabbat kenas). 152. Kosman, Noheig, 137, section 9; Minhagei… kehal ‘adat yisra’eil, 12; liturgical rubric in Sachs, Festgebete, 282. 153. The z.ulat, “‘ot berit.” Allgemeine Synagogen-Ordnung für das Königreich Hannover (Hannover, 1916), 79, par. 9. 154. Ibid.
336
Mah.azor Ha-H.ayyim
Example 14. Hirsch Weintraub’s chorale Ve-nismah. be-divrei toratekha u-vemiz.votekha for the evening service of a Sabbath over which a bar mitzvah is being celebrated. Hirsch Weintraub, Schire Beth Adonai oder Tempelgesänge für den Gottesdienst der Israeliten, vol. 1 (Leipzig: Breitkop & Härlel, 1859; reprinted by Sacred Music Press, Out of Print Classic Series, Vol. 19, 1954), 21, no. 10. wedding ceremony.155 Naumbourg, however, also created a choral arrangement of the “traditional” Western European melody of shirah h.adashah and z.ur yisra’eil for a berit milah when it occurred on the Sabbath.156 His melody line for these two pieces continued to be sung in France well into the twentieth century.157
155. Salomon Sulzer, Schir Zion: Gottesdienstliche Gesänge der Israeliten (Vienna, 1840, 1863; New York: Hebrew Union College Sacred Music Press, Out of Print Classics Series, vol. 8, 1954), 357–76, nos. 467–77; Louis Lewandowski, Todah W’simrah, Vierstimmige Chöre und Soli für den israelitischen Gottesdienst, Part 2, Festgesänge (Berlin: Bote and Bock, 1882), 297–315, nos. 262–68; Samuel Naumbourg, Semiroth Israël: Chants Religieux, Les Hymnes, les Psaumes (Paris, 1857; repr., New York: Hebrew Union College Sacred Music Press, Out of Print Classics Series, vol. 15, 1954), 24–52, nos. 26–35. 156. Samuel Naumbourg, Semiroth Israël: Chants Liturgiques de Sabbath (Paris, 1847; repr., New York: Hebrew Union College Sacred Music Press, Out of Print Classics Series, vol. 13, 1954), 60–61, no. 55. 157. Bernard Bocher, Schirë David: Recueil des chants et récitations religieux d’après les airs traditionnels alsaciens (Strasbourg: Consistoire israelite du Bas-Rhin, 1951), 295–96, no. 456.
337
Geoffrey Goldberg
Example 15. Weintraub’s ’Eh.ad yah.id u-meyyuh.ad with a modified text, for a bar mitzvah or marriage ceremony. Hirsch Weintraub, Schire Beth Adonai oder Tempelgesänge für den Gottesdienst der Israeliten, vol. 1, 21, no. 10.
On the other hand, the gifted and eclectic cantor-composer Hirsch Weintraub (1811–81) of Königsberg wrote new melodies specifically for life-cycle ceremonies. These were published in his Schire Beth Adonai (1859) and included choral settings for berit milah, bar mitzvah, the new ceremony of confirmation, and weddings. For the Sabbath preceding marriage and for a bar mitzvah, he composed a new setting of ’eh.ad ỵahid u-meyyuhad (examples 14–15).158 The second of these pieces is of particular interest because the text has been modified. Only the three opening words have been retained, and, most notably, the word ֵאל, has been omitted. The text now reads,
158. Hirsch Weintraub, Schire Beth Adonai oder Tempelgesänge für den Gottesdienst der Israeliten, vol. 1 (Leipzig: Breitkop & Härtel, 1859; repr., Sacred Music Press, Out of Print Classics Series, vol. 19, 1954). The particular items were: (1) ve-nismah. from ’ahavat ‘olam on the eve of a bar mitzvah, 21, no. 10; (2) calling up to the Torah, 60, no. 71; ’eh.ad yah.id u-meyyuh.ad for a h.atan and a bar mitzvah, 60, no. 72; kerah.eim ’av (Psalms 103:12–13, 16–17) for confirmation (for boys), 76, no. 89; romemot ’eil and barkuh ha-ba for a berit milah, 80–81, nos. 93 and 92.
338
Mah.azor Ha-H.ayyim ַהְללוּיָּה, וְנֹאַמר ְלָפנָיוִֹשיָרה ֲחָֹדָשה,ֶאָחד יִָחיד וְּמיָֻחד The one and unique, Before him let us recite a new song, Halleluyah.
Without question, “the one and unique” refers directly to the bar mitzvah or the bridegroom, before whom “a new song was sung.” Weintraub’s setting of ’eh.ad yah.id provides concrete evidence for the personalization of liturgical texts for use at mah.azor ha-h.ayyim celebrations, a customary practice that has been documented throughout this article. C ONCLUSION The revival of synagogal life-cycle song by Hirsch Weintraub was shortlived. It represented the endpoint of many centuries of liturgical and musical creativity in this genre within the European Ashkenazic synagogue. Yet the need to respond to the spiritual needs of the individual within the larger communal context continues. In many contemporary American synagogues, the prayer on behalf of the sick (mi-sheberakh) is no longer hurried through in an undertone, but is often sung to new musical settings, often by the entire congregation, extending for several minutes.159 This American practice seems to be responding to deeply felt personal needs not adequately met in the past. It has become—in addition to the singing of siman tov u-mazal tov—a peak individual “life-cycle” moment supported by the community. Yet the rich development of life-cycle song in the European Ashkenazic synagogue shows that innovations were not primarily for life’s woes, but for life’s celebrations. Geoffrey Goldberg University of Rochester Rochester, New York
159. Examples are the settings of cantor-composers Debbie Friedman and Paul Zim.
339
AJS Review 33:2 (November 2009), 341–362 © Association for Jewish Studies, 2009 doi:10.1017/S0364009409990043
“A BANDON Y OUR R OLE AS E XPONENTS OF THE M AGYARS ”: C ONTESTED J EWISH L OYALTY IN I NTERWAR (C ZECHO )S LOVAKIA by
Rebekah Klein-Pejšová
On the occasion of the eighth anniversary of the founding of Czechoslovakia, October 28, 1926, the Neolog Jewish Community of Bratislava (Pozsony, Pressburg) gathered for a commemorative service led by their chief rabbi, Dr. Samuel Funk. They were joined by representatives of the government administration and other religious confessions. Toward the end of his sermon, an increasingly agitated Rabbi Funk turned and pointed with an angry finger at the members of the assimilationist Union of Slovak Jews (Sväz slovenských židov) in attendance from his position behind the podium. He publicly accused them of destroying Jewish unity and making it impossible for the Jewish Party to win a parliamentary mandate.1 He concluded his sermon by recalling a meeting that he had recently enjoyed with the president of Czechoslovakia, Tomáš Garrigue Masaryk. President Masaryk, Funk related, regarded it as very embarrasing that in spite of the 100,000 votes that the Jewish Party had received in 1925,2 it was not able to obtain even one parliamentary mandate. Funk reported that Masaryk only respected those Jews who declared Jewish as their nationality.3 The Union of Slovak Jews recounted this narrative of events in the grievance they lodged against Funk with the Bratislava police on February 17, 1927. Their action marked the opening of a six-year state investigation of the Neolog Jewish Community of Bratislava centered on the personality of Rabbi Funk. The state took a keen interest in the complaint, as the dispute was a window through 1. These were, in fact, the main arguments of the Jewish national movement in Slovakia against all other Jewish political groups. The Czechoslovak state understood that the Zionist struggle against the Union of Slovak Jews stemmed from the threat that the latter posed to winning a Jewish national mandate in Parliament; see Slovenský národný archív (SNA)/fond Policajné riaditeľstvo (PR)/556/69–70. 2. The Jewish Party received a total of 98,845 votes in 1925; see Manuel statistique de la République Tchécoslovaque III (Prague, 1928), 256, table XI 3, Votes valuables, exprimés aux élections pour la Chambre des Députés, en Tchécoslovaquie, en novembre 1925 et mandates attributes. 3. SNA/PR/kárton 556/1–3. Kongruová náboženská obce židovská v Bratislave—Stažnost sväzu slovenských židov.
341
Rebekah Klein-Pejšová which it could view the swiftly evolving world of modern Jewish politics, and attempt to understand the implications of the conflict between Jewish nationalist and assimilationist positions within Slovak parameters. The first report of the Bratislava police correspondingly framed the utility of the incident: Recently, the Zionist movement in Slovakia has significantly expanded— much greater attention needs to be paid to Jewish movements in Slovakia generally, and from this standpoint the public outburst of Rabbi Dr. Samuel Funk should be evaluated.4
This article considers the dimensions of the loyalty issues faced by the Jewish population in Slovakia during the interwar period through an examination of two long-term Czechoslovak state investigations into Jewish personal and communal, national and linguistic behaviors: the “Funk Affair” and the Budapestbased Heroes’ Temple memorial project. In the Funk Affair, the state initially focused its examination on Funk’s public condemnation of the assimilationist Union of Slovak Jews, considering his attack an expression of less than adequate personal loyalty to Czechoslovakia, rather than of Jewish national conviction. The state later showed greater interest in the dispute between Funk and the leadership of the Neolog Jewish Community of Bratislava, finding the complaints of the community leadership about Funk a result of their own allegedly problematic relationship to Czechoslovakia. The shift in the state’s attention from Funk to the Neolog Jewish community matches the growing ascendancy of transnational security issues over domestic socio-cultural affairs. The Czechoslovak state investigation into the Heroes’ Temple memorial in Budapest, a Hungarian Jewish project intended to commemorate all of the Jewish soldiers from the territory of the former Kingdom of Hungary who had fallen during the First World War, is a striking example of how Czechoslovakia understood connections with Hungary and Hungarian Jewry as an indicator of Slovak Jewish citizens’ loyalty. The Czechoslovak administration closely followed Slovak Jewish participation in the commemoration project, conflating their potential involvement with the irredentist ambitions of the interwar Hungarian regime. In this article, I seek to demonstrate the productivity of loyalty as a means of analyzing problems of Jewish relations with the modern state, an essential key for understanding the development of Jewish history.5 I intend to show how loyalty can be used to locate the active function of nationality and its implications for minority citizenship, especially as it pertains to members of minority religious groups. At the center of my concern is the meaning of “Jewish nationality,” a new category of political nationhood introduced after the First World War, for the state and surrounding Slovak population. 4. SNA/PR/kárton 556/9. 5. Nancy Sinkoff argues in her recent book Out of the Shtetl: Making Jews Modern in the Polish Borderlands (Providence, RI: Brown Judaic Studies, 2004) that nothing is more important than Jewish– state relations for understanding how Jewish history develops.
342
Abandon Your Role as Exponents of the Magyars Jewish nationality in Czechoslovakia was directly tied to larger conceptions of nationality in the new state. The most important of these was the new definition of nationality, used for the first time in the 1919 census of the territory of Slovakia, which challenged prewar methods of counting and classifying the population based on language. Czechoslovakia eliminated linguistic criteria (designated as “mother tongue”) as an equivalent indicator of nationality, deciding instead to define nationality as an “internal conviction,” a subjective state known by the individual, similar to religious conviction. This was the basis for the decision that Jews should have the option of declaring their own Jewish nationality, or the nationality of others, without regard for religious affiliation. The specificity of the Jewish case in turn buttressed the general argument for defining nationality as an internal conviction. The state accepted the contention that despite the fact that Jews in Czechoslovakia had “lost Hebrew as their national tongue, and did not even speak Yiddish, [they] had not ceased to live their own peculiar national life.”6 Czechoslovakia’s innovative approach to the question of nationality, not surprisingly, worked to the advantage of the newly dominant “Czechoslovak” nation. When Jews who traditionally had affiliated with German speakers in Bohemia and Moravia, and with Hungarian speakers in Slovakia, now declared Jewish as their nationality, the number of Germans and Hungarians in the state would statistically decrease. Jewish nationality appealed to the state as an authentic expression of Jewish national belonging. While Czechoslovakia offered the most favorable environment for the Jews of its Eastern and Central European neighbors, renounced antisemitism, and supported Zionism and Jewish national rights, there still remained significant challenges to the Jewish relationship with the state. This was particularly true in Slovakia, where Jews were suspect as potential accomplices to the Hungarian revisionist aims because of their history of alignment with the Hungarian nation, the dominant national group in the former Kingdom of Hungary, of which the territory had been a part.7 The linguistic and political alignment of the Jews of the former Kingdom of Hungary with the Magyars and Magyar nobility had been essential for the maintenance of a slim Magyar majority over the nationalities of the kingdom, including large minorities of Romanians and Slovaks, and had been rewarded by Hungarian governmental protection from popular anti-Semitism as well as tolerant, liberal policies with regard to the Jewish population. This theme forms the cornerstone of the scholarship on Hungarian Jewish history, most recently by Howard N. Lupovitch and others.8
6. Antonín Boháč, “Národnost či materský jazyk?” [Nationality or mother tongue?], ČSV, ročník I (Prague, 1920), 273. Yiddish was not considered to be a viable national language for the Jewish population in Czechoslovakia because its use was not widespread, but remained limited to population blocs in northeastern Slovakia and in Subcarpathian Ruthenia. 7. The northernmost sixteen counties and four municipalities of the former Kingdom of Hungary became, in whole or in part, the territory of Slovakia after the First World War. 8. Howard N. Lupovitch, Jews at the Crossroads: Tradition and Accommodation during the Golden Age of the Hungarian Nobility, 1729–1878 (Budapest, New York: Central European University Press, 2007); Gyurgyák János, A Zsidókérdés Magyarországon, (Budapest: Osiris Kiadó, 2001); Peter
343
Rebekah Klein-Pejšová In the words of Vavro Šrobár, the Czechoslovak minister for the administration of Slovakia, the Jews in Slovakia had been tools of the Magyar government in carrying out the violent policy of magyarization before the war, had been informants and spies during the war, and had worked as Magyar agitators against the newly formed Czechoslovak Republic after the war.9 The Magyar/Jewish symbiosis in pre-1918 political and cultural affairs accounts for the primary difference in the post-war relationship of the Jews in Slovakia with the Czechoslovak state when compared with Jews in Bohemia and Moravia. Despite the predilection of many Jews in Bohemia and Moravia for German language, culture, and education,10 Jews had not comprised an essential constituency in the ranks of the German national movement of the late nineteenth century, and found themselves excluded from the movement as it became increasingly radicalized and espoused an evermore anti-Semitic orientation.11 In addition, the history of a strong Czech–Jewish movement and census declarations of Czech as their language of daily use by more than 54% of Bohemian and Prague Jews by 1900,12 significantly diluted the question of overwhelming Jewish alliance with a formerly dominant nationality turned interwar irredentist actor. Although 34% of the Jewish population in both Bohemia and Moravia declared German as their nationality on the 1921 state-wide Czechoslovak census,13 Kateřina Čapková, in her recent study of Jewish national identity in interwar Bohemia, does not indicate that Jews there found their loyalty to Czechoslovakia questioned by the state. Čapková asserts that German Jews, like all Jewish citizens (though here she makes the exception of communists), were fully loyal to the Czechoslovak state and they knew what problems the German minority caused for the Czech government.14
Haber, Die Anfänge des Zionismus in Ungarn (1897–1904) (Köln Weimar Wien: Böhlau Verlag, 2001); Karády Viktor, Önazonositás, Sorsválasztás: A zsidó csoportazonosság történelmi alakváltozásai Magyarországon (Budapest: Új Mandatum, 2001), William O. McCagg, Jr., A History of Habsburg Jews, 1670–1918 (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1989); William O. McCagg, Jr., Jewish Nobles and Geniuses in Modern Hungary (New York: Distributed by Columbia University Press, 1972). 9. Letter from Vavro Šrobár to the Republique Tchecoslovaque legation à Londres, September 14, 1919. The full text of the document can be found in Aharon Moshe Rabinowicz, “The Jewish Minority,” in The Jews of Czechoslovakia, ed. Livia Rothkirchen (Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society of America, 1968), 226–27. 10. Gary B. Cohen, The Politics of Ethnic Survival: Germans in Prague, 1860–1914 (Princeton University Press, 1981). 11. Ezra Mendelsohn, The Jews of East Central Europe Between the World Wars (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1983), 133–140; and Hillel Kieval, The Making of Czech Jewry: National Conflict and Jewish Society in Bohemia, 1870–1918 (New York: Oxford University Press, 1988). 12. Census data from: Österreichische Statistik, vol. 63, Pt. 3 (1902), 178; on the Czech-Jewish movement: Kieval, The Making of Czech Jewry; Kateřina Čapková, Češi, Němci, Židé? Národní identita Židů v Čechách, 1918–1938 (Praha-Litomyšl: Paseka, 2005), 93–105. 13. Sčítání lidu 1921 (Praha, 1924), 90 část textová, tables 104 and 105 combined: “Israelité československé státní přislušnosti podle národnosti.” 14. Čapková, 71, 93.
344
Abandon Your Role as Exponents of the Magyars The Jews in the territory of Slovakia were organized into three categories of Jewish religious affiliation: Neolog (or Congress), Orthodox, and Status Quo Ante (neither Neolog nor Orthodox), a legacy of the 1868 Congress of the Jews of the Kingdom of Hungary. Jozséf Eötvös, then the Hungarian minister of education and cults, had organized the congress with the intention of creating a centralized state body to handle Jewish affairs on the model of the French Consistory. Instead, the meeting had resulted in a deep division among the Jews of the Kingdom of Hungary, made official in 1871 with Emperor/King Franz Josef’s recognition of Orthodoxy as a separate Jewish religion.15 Hungarian Jewish religious institutional organization carried over to the successor states in all territories that had been part of the Kingdom of Hungary, that is: in Slovakia (Czechoslovakia), Transylvania (Romania), and Vojvodina (Yugoslavia). Jewish communities found it natural to maintain their established religious affiliations. Neolog Judaism is a type of moderate Reform Judaism peculiar to the territories that once comprised the Kingdom of Hungary, which emerged as a means of modernizing Judaism within the Hungarian context, and drawing the Jews closer to the surrounding population. Neolog tendencies began to appear in Hungary in the early nineteenth century, though Neolog Judaism was officially recognized only with the Hungarian Jewish Congress of 1868. It encompassed no radical changes to the traditional liturgy, but allowed for the use of an organ, and moved the bimah from the center to the front of the synagogue, as in reform congregations. Neolog Jews referred to themselves as Hungarians of the Jewish religion, or Hungarians of the Mosaic faith.16 Members of the Neolog branch were considered the most suspect as potential accomplices of the Hungarian revisionist efforts. Neolog Jews tended to have identified themselves more deeply with the Magyar nation and government—that is, to have been “magyarized” in the decades before the war. It is important to distinguish between this form of magyarization and more common patterns of acculturation that were prevalent among the Jews of the Kingdom of Hungary. These included the use of the Magyar language and the declaration of Magyar as one’s mother tongue on the census—both expressions of Hungarian Jewish loyalty to, but not necessarily identification with, the Magyar government. Neolog Jews were more closely watched by the Czechoslovak state than the Orthodox or Status Quo, as well as more strongly courted by Hungary and Hungarian Jewry for the revisionist cause. Unlike the Orthodox majority in the territory of Slovakia, who expressed their acceptance of and loyalty to the new Czechoslovak state by breaking away from the Hungarian statewide Orthodox religious organization in 1920, Neolog communities in Slovakia maintained 15. For a detailed discussion of the organization, proceedings, and implications of the 1868 congress, see Jacob Katz, A House Divided: Orthodoxy and Schism in Nineteenth-Century Central European Jewry, trans. Ziporah Brody (Hanover, NH: University Press of New England, 1998). 16. “Neology (Neologism),” Encyclopedia Judaica (New York: Macmillan, 1971), 951–954; Kinga Frojimovics and Rita Horváth, “Jews and Nationalism in Hungary,” The European Legacy 7, no 5: 642; Leonard Mars, “Discontinuity, Tradition, and Innovation: Anthropological reflections on Jewish Identity in Contemporary Hungary,” Social Compass, 46 (1999): 26.
345
Rebekah Klein-Pejšová institutional ties to Budapest until 1926. Only in 1928 did the Neolog and Status Quo communities join to form a separate organization under the name Ješurun.17 Nevertheless, Jews in Slovakia, no matter their religious affiliation, acknowledged that life was better for them in Czechoslovakia than it was for their coreligionists and former compatriots in neighboring Hungary. The collapse of Austria-Hungary and the subsequent peace settlement were devestating for Hungary and Hungarian Jewry. The Treaty of Trianon dissolved the multinational Kingdom of Hungary and left in its place a nationally homogenous, bitter pariah state that was hostile to its Jews. The series of political upheavals that the state experienced immediately following the First World War further damaged the relationship of the Jewish population to the new postwar Hungary. The most significant upheaval in this respect was the disastrous and shortlived Hungarian Soviet Republic of 1919, which counted among its leadership many communists of Jewish origin. The government of Admiral Miklós Horthy came to power riding a crest of legitimacy stemming from its reaction against the 133-day Soviet Republic. The World War One defeat, subsequent collapse of the Monarchy, and reduction of prewar territorial holdings by more than 70%, combined with post-war revolutionary chaos determined the course of interwar Hungarian politics. As many Hungarians held Jewish traitors responsible for the humiliation of the country,18 a popular connection between anti-Semitism and national security developed in the wake of the Bolshevik regime’s demise, and with it the belief that “anti-Jewish politics [were] justice for a nation wronged.”19 The Hungarian parliament passed the numerus clausus law in 1920, imposing legislation directed against the Jewish population that limited the number of students of each racial and national group admitted to institutions of higher learning according to their share of the population.20 The numerus clausus legislation marked the end of tolerant, liberal pre-war Hungarian government policy toward the Jews and initiated a culture of flourishing anti-Semitism.21 The memory of the Soviet Republic cast a long shadow of suspicion over the Jewish population of post–World War I Hungary, while the numerus clausus emphasized that they were now regarded as racially distinct from the Magyars.
17. “Náboženství a církve,” Deset let československé republiky. Svazek první (Prague, 1928), 442; Vratislav Bušek, “Poměr státu k církvím v Československé republice,” in Bohomil Janda, ed., Československá vlastivěda díl V. Stát (Prague, 1931), 355–56. The 52 Neolog and Status Quo Ante communities came together under the name Svaz židovských náboženských obcí na Slovensku Jeschurun. Out of the 217 Jewish religious communities in Slovakia, 165 belonged to the Organization of Autonomous Orthodox Jewish Communities. 18. Paul A. Hanebrink, In Defense of Christian Hungary: Religion, Nationalism, and Antisemitism, 1890 –1944 (Ithaca, NY, 2006). 19. Paul Hanebrink, “Transnational Culture War: Christianity, Nation, and the Judeo-Bolshevik Myth in Hungary, 1890–1920,” The Journal of Modern History (March 2008): 80. 20. Nathaniel Katzburg, “Hungarian Jewry in Modern Times,” in Hungarian Jewish Studies, ed. Randolph L. Braham (New York: World Federation of Hungarian Jews, 1966), 155. 21. Mária M. Kovács, Liberal Professions and Illiberal Politics: Hungary from the Habsburgs to the Holocaust (New York, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1994), 50, 51, 64.
346
Abandon Your Role as Exponents of the Magyars The great majority of Jews in Slovakia recognized that revising the Treaty of Trianon so as to place the territory of Slovakia under control of the Hungarian government was not in their best interest. They prefered to avail themselves of the possibilities available to them in Czechoslovakia, a parliamentary democracy under the leadership of Masaryk, whom they admired. The Weiss family of Košice (Kassa, Kaschau), for instance, a city that was both a Hungarian national and Neolog Jewish center in the interwar period, took advantage of the opportunities of their Czechoslovak citizenship to bring relatives up from Sátoraljaújhely, a Hungarian town close to the border with Slovakia. As Erzsébet Weiss recalled, “My father brought [my mother’s three younger sisters] to Košice because the standard of living was higher than in Hungary. It was a civic democracy, we lived on an incomparably higher standard than our relatives in Hungary.” Her father arranged for more relatives to come up from Hungary as well.22 To what extent did individual cases such as this soothe the territorial insecurities of interwar Czechoslovakia? The answer is, insignificantly. The Czechoslovak state wanted to see verification of the loyalty of the Jews in Slovkia in very practical terms: by cutting ties with Hungary and Hungarian Jewry. The state wanted to see that Jews in Slovakia did not engage in subversive politics or other activities detrimental to state security. T HE F UNK A FFAIR For this purpose, Rabbi Dr. Samuel Funk was a useful person for the state to follow. He was a well-known eccentric and choleric character whose outspoken opinions often exposed the fault lines in Jewish community politics. By all accounts, Funk used his position as chief Neolog rabbi to proclaim his political judgments and hurl insults from behind the podium. He was a great admirer of Masaryk, whom he habitually quoted and referred to as the “Benefactor of the Jews” (dobrodinca židov). Funk included passages from well-known Czech authors in his sermons, which was said to make members of the congregation who had been raised as Hungarians uncomfortable. In general, Funk’s unpleasant temperament earned him a remarkably small following. Many members of the Neolog community allegedly avoided him at all costs.23 The Bratislava police investigating the case of the grievance of the Union of Slovak Jews against Funk viewed it as characteristic of the local Zionists to allow an irresponsible person like Funk to act as the mouthpiece in their struggle against the Union of Slovak Jews.24 This observation was typical of the investigation’s generally unflattering evaluation of Funk’s personality and behavior. 22. From the interview with Erzsébet Weiss conducted by Éva Kovács in the late 1980s for her 1991 dissertation, “A Kassai Zsidóság Etnikai Identitása A Két Világháborü Között (1918–1938)”, submitted to University of Szeged, Hungary [The ethnic identity of Kassa (Košice) Jewry between the two world wars]. 23. SNA/PR/kárton 556, “Stažnost sväzu slovenských židov,” 4. 24. SNA/PR/kárton/9.
347
Rebekah Klein-Pejšová Funk’s attack on the Union of Slovak Jews put him in an awkward position. Now he had to prove that he was a loyal citizen who did not harbor anti-Slovak feelings. The situation was made more disagreeable by the fact that since his meeting with Masaryk, Funk had trumpeted himself as a confidant whom the president consulted in serious political and cultural matters.25 Things did not look good for Funk. He attempted to clear his name by airing his side of the story in a leading Slovak daily (Slovenský denník), but the editorial board refused his request. He tried to become a member of the Slovak League (Slovenský líga), a prominent Slovak national organization, but found no success. At the consecration ceremony of the new synagogue in Parkaň (Hungarian, Parkány; later renamed Šturovo) close to the border with Hungary, Funk gave his address in the state language, Slovak, instead of his usual German.26 Leo Sipos, a Bratislava lawyer and a leading figure in the Zionist movement in Slovakia, was the only source interviewed in the early phase of the investigation who spoke in support of Funk. Sipos confidentially testified in 1927 that Funk’s attack on the Union of Slovak Jews derived from the rabbi’s belief that the founding of a Slovak Jewish political party would harm Jewish interests and undermine the wishes of Masaryk, who admonished the Jews in Slovakia to “return to the worldview of [their] forefathers, be Jews, and abandon [their] role as exponents of the Magyars.”27 Sipos stressed that Funk condemned Jewish assimilation, and believed it essential for Jews to achieve national independence.28 Sipos’s argument articulated the perceptions of Jewish nationality held by the Jewish national movement. The Jewish national leadership advanced Jewish nationality and Jewish national politics as an inherently anti-assimilationist position, considering it an honest way of remaining “true to ourselves” and expressing the conviction of belonging to “no other people than the Jewish people.”29 By declaring Jewish nationality and pursuing Jewish national politics, they argued, Jews could simply be Jews and avoid the dangers and misunderstandings of national affiliations in the multinational state. As such, it also seemed to be a good means of demonstrating separation from the prewar practice of affiliating with the dominant Magyar nation. Understood in this way, Jewish nationality was an elegant fulfillment of Masayk’s appeal. In the eyes of the state, however, the embrace of Jewish national politics was not compelling evidence of abandoning the role of “exponents of the Magyars.” The state suspected a Magyar subtext to Jewish national politics in Slovakia, revealed in the same anti-assimilationist stance of the Jewish national program that Jews thought cleared them of that suspicion. “Zionism here in the republic 25. SNA/PR/kárton/6. 26. SNA/PR/kárton/6. 27. SNA/PR/kárton/7. 28. SNA/PR/kárton/7. 29. This idea was orginally expressed by Max Brod; see “Orthodoxie, Zionismus, Nationaljudentum,” Jüdische Volkszeitung, November 28, 1919. “Ich bin nichts als Jude. Ich gehöre (bei voller Beobachtung meine staatsbürgerliche Pflichten) keinem andern Volk an als dem jüdischen.”
348
Abandon Your Role as Exponents of the Magyars has a political background,” concluded the 1927 report, “which means that Jews who were brought up in the German or Magyar spirit and who still sympathize with Magyar thinking—they are against any kind of assimilation.” The state believed that Jews in Slovakia who maintained a Magyar orientation found defense against pressures to assimilate into the new Slovak environment under the banner of Jewish politics.30 The Czechoslovak administration concluded its first report on the Funk affair in the year 1927, a year which, not uncoincidently, marked a turning point in the history of the Hungarian movement to revise the borders established by the Treaty of Trianon. In that year, the English Lord Rothmere began his “Justice for Hungary” campaign in his newspaper the Daily Mail, the Hungarian Revisionist League was founded, international financial and military monitors left Hungary, and the Horthy government signed a treaty of friendship and cooperation with Mussolini’s Italy. In addition, the intensification of the Hungarian revisionist campaign coincided with the beginning of the Tuka Affair in Czechoslovakia, in which Vojtěch Tuka was found guilty in 1929 of working for the restoration of the pre-war Kingdom of Hungary as an agent of the Interwar Hungarian government under the guise of struggling for the creation of an independent Slovakia. Together, these events generally heightened Czechoslovak state suspicion of Jews in Slovakia as potential accomplices to Hungarian ambitions, as well as colored its interpretations of Jewish politics. In the case of Bohemia, the greatest analogous suspicion seems to have stemmed not from the side of the state, but from the Czech Jews (Čechožidé). Before the 1920 parliamentary elections, for instance, the Czech Jewish leadership suggested to the Czech National Council that the Jewish National candidate from the Associated Jewish Parties may not be loyal to the Czech nation if elected to parliament. They argued that Zionists with a German or Hungarian past and upbringing may be beholden to the interests of another party than would be representatives of the Czech nation, which could work against Czech interests. Masaryk, Beneš, and other leading governmental figures did not take the advice of the Czech Jews to reject the candidate from the Associated Jewish Parties, but instead supported the Jewish national movement, its leadership and candidates. The Jewish national movement in Bohemia and Moravia reciprocated the continuing support of the government with efforts to make Czech the language of the movement, especially in Moravia, and promoting the use of Czech in Zionist meetings and periodicals. The German language was not used at all at the Zionist Congress in Prague in 1933 as a protest against Nazism. It is worth noting that across Czechoslovakia, it was the Jewish assimilationist movements that stressed the potential disloyalty of the Jewish Nationalists to state. The Funk Affair raised awareness of the variety of Jewish opinion on the question of national affiliation within the Jewish community and within the
30. SNA/PR/556/69–70. Kongruová náboženská obce židovská v Bratislave—Stažnost sväzu slovenských židov.
349
Rebekah Klein-Pejšová population at large. Until then, noted the prominent Slovak daily Národný denník, little was generally known about the activities of the Union of Slovak Jews. Jews were Jews, and that was that. Now, the paper continued, the differences between the Jewish nationalist and Slovak assimilationist camps were becoming visible. The conflict between Funk and the Union of Slovak Jews fueled local Slovak and Czechoslovak state suspicions that the Jewish national movement was in fact a cover for Magyar national activity. Slovak public opinion, not surprisingly, quickly lined up behind the Union of Slovak Jews. Národný denník congratulated itself ten days after Funk’s outburst for having pointed to the Zionists as promoters of magyarization in Slovakia even earlier: it was evident that Jews who opposed the Union of Slovak Jews were Magyar national elements.31 Slovenský denník later called Funk the “Jewish Tuka,”32 a reference to Vojtěch Tuka, who had been found guilty in 1929 of working for the restoration of the prewar Kingdom of Hungary as an agent of the interwar Hungarian government under the guise of struggling for the creation of an independent Slovakia. Slovak authorities, even earlier, tended to view Zionism as a branch of Hungarian revisionist activity in Slovakia. A 1925 preelection report discussing the Zionist candidate from the district chief of Hlohovec in western Slovakia bears out this point: Dr. Eisler is not an excellent speaker and has not learned Slovak well yet. But he is the chairman of the Jewish scouts’ organization and intensively occupies himself with Zionism. These young scouts speak mainly Hungarian or German amongst themselves. They maintain the Hungarian spirit and culture under the veil of Zionism. The Orthodox Jews recognize the government’s interests and also the dangers that the Zionists represent as they deepen the chasm between the Jews and the local population.33
Slovak authorities also carried out a series of investigations of possible Hungarian irredentist activity within Jewish national sport, cultural, and educational associations in Slovakia in 1926, employing language as a basis of inquiry. The police reports expressed offense that these associations carried out their activities in Magyar and German, and offered foreign-language instruction in English, French, and Hebrew, but did not use Slovak, the state language. The investigations, however, did not turn up any concrete evidence of antistate propaganda.34 31. “Sväz slovenských židov,” Národný denník, November 9, 1926. 32. “Pán rabín Funl vo “Slováku,” Slovenský dennik, September 12, 1928. 33. Štátný oblastný archív Bratislave, fond Župný úrad v Bratislave, file 8833/1925, in Marie Crhová, “Jewish Politics in Central Europe: The Case of the Jewish Party in Interwar Czechoslovakia,” in Jewish Studies at the Central European University, vol. 2, 1999–2001, ed. András Kovács and Eszter Andor (Budapest: Jewish Studies Project, Central European University, 2002), 289–90. 34. SNA/PR/kárton 79/836/report submitted in Bratislava, February 25, 1926. The reports concerning possible irredentist activity within Jewish national associations in Slovakia are located in carton 79, and date from 1926.
350
Abandon Your Role as Exponents of the Magyars The police official investigating the branch of the Jewish scout association Ha-Shomer ha-Tsair in Komárno noted that he heard only one word in Slovak: “Pozor!” (attention!).35 On the state level as well as in public opinion, the expression of Slovak suspicions and grievances against Jews converged on the issue of Magyar language use. “There are no Jews in the world like the ones in Slovakia,” acidly remarked the author of a 1929 article in Nitrianské noviny: Jews living in Poland speak Polish, in Germany German, in France French, in Bohemia Czech, in Hungary Magyar—only in Slovakia do we have Jews who speak Magyar. It is a world rarity, which is likely to be what make the Jews such great lords in Slovakia … on the main street in the coffeehouse and in the shops you hear only Magyar spoken. You see [the Jews] reading only Magyar newspapers, they ignore Slovak cultural enterprises. [They] speak only Magyar within the family and in public. … we cannot explain the Jewish mentality in Slovakia in any other way than that the whole nation still regards us a nation of stupid Slovaks who must put up with every insult, like under the Magyar government.36
Using the Slovak language was also regarded as the fulfillment of an obligation both to the Slovak nation and to Czechoslovakia, as seen in the following evaluation of Jewish community education from the Košice-based daily Slovenský východ: The Jewish Orthodox Religious Community in Košice understood its duties not only to the Slovak nation, but also to the republic. The expression of this understanding is that this community established an elementary school on Kazinczy Street with Slovak as the language of instruction. Slovak state teachers provide the instruction. The Neolog Jewish Community in Košice has not forgotten Hungary, though, as we see from the fact that it has its own elementary school in which, as the only such Jewish school in the republic, Magyar is the language of instruction.37 35. SNA/PR/kárton 79/842. Report submitted in Komárno, March 9, 1926. 36. “Židia u nás,” in Nitrianské noviny, April 28, 1929. 37. “Židia v Košiciach,” in Slovenský Východ (Košice), November 19, 1929. Interestingly, the example of the Orthodox elementary school in Košice also shows an auspicious overlap between Slovak linguistic and political pressures and the fulfillment of religious obligation. From the Orthodox Jewish perspective, hiring non-Jewish Slovak teachers ensured that the students at the Orthodox school would never see their Jewish teachers breaking the Sabbath during Saturday classes. A former student of the Orthodox school on Kazinczy Street in Košice, the same school to which the author of the article refers, recalled asking why the teachers at his school were Christian. The answer was that the religious community did not want the children to see their Jewish teachers pick up the chalk and write on the blackboard on Saturday, as they did in the Neolog school. From an interview with Jenő Silber conducted by Éva Kovács for her 1991 thesis, “A Kassai Zsidóság Etnikai Identitása A Két Világháborü Között (1918–1938).”
351
Rebekah Klein-Pejšová From this perspective, there could be no neutral maintenance of the Magyar language among the Jewish population, at the very least for official purposes. The Slovak press sharply criticized Jews who wished to preserve the Magyar language and culture in Slovakia while at the same time putting themselves forth as loyal citizens of the state and declaring their own separate Jewish nationality: The same Jews who cross their fingers in questions like [retaining Magyar street names in Bratislava] have just in the past few days had some congress from which they tossed a speech to the public about loyalty to the Czechoslovak Republic. They will have to forgive us if we give no [credence] to such speeches. … We regard the Jews as fellow citizens in the full sense of the term. That should suffice and should bring them to a better understanding of their duties to this state. It is high time that the Jews put their words into action. And when they now declare for their own nationality, let them do it consistently.38
The seeming inconsistency of the national orientation of Jews who declared Jewish nationality but continued to speak Magyar corroborated the distrust that Slovak state authorities as well as the local Slovak population felt for Jews. They interpreted claims of Jewish nationality accompanied by the continued use of the Hungarian langugage as disingenuous. The Jewish loyalty question was framed in linguistic terms. When the Union of Slovak Jews brought their grievance to the Bratislava police, they struck back at Funk as well as exposed the weaknesses of the Jewish national movement in Slovakia. They also demonstrated their confidence in the validity of their complaint and the correctness of their position regarding the state and the local Slovak population. The 1927 police report shrewdly observed that the real motivation of the Union of Slovak Jews in lodging their grievance against Funk was to pressure the leadership of the Neolog Jewish Community to grant their request to hold Slovak-language services in the Neolog synagogue. “It is an open secret,” the report remarked, “that this request has found no echo with the community board, whose members are primarily Germans and Magyars.”39 The subsequent shift in attention to the leadership of the Neolog Jewish Community of Bratislava from the Union of Slovak Jews led to a dramatic turnaround in the state’s view of the much-maligned Rabbi Funk. By 1932, the state had reversed its perception of Funk from magyarophile element working under the cover of Zionism, to loyal Czechoslovak citizen and advocate of the lower classes. The state instead condemned the community leadership as a disloyal element that behaved in the political interests of Hungary rather than of Czechoslovakia.40 38. “Židia na Slovensku,” in Národný denník, June 2, 1929. 39. SNA/PR/kárton 556/5. 40. SNA/PR/kárton 556. “Neolog žid. cirkevná obec v Bratislave—vnutorné rozpory,” November 12, 1932, 9.
352
Abandon Your Role as Exponents of the Magyars A spate of articles appeared in the statewide press in 1932 (notably in the papers České slovo, A Zet, and Slovenský večerník), drumming up the public’s interest in the question of the national orientation of Slovak Jews.41 The ongoing conflict between Funk and the leadership of the Neolog Jewish community er