HANDBOOK ON RADIATION PROBING, GAUGING, IMAGING AND ANALYSIS
This page intentionally left blank
Handbook on Radiation Probing,
Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
Volume II:
Applications and Design
by
ESAM M.A. HUSSEIN Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of New Brunswick, Fredericton, New Brunswick, Canada
KLUWER ACADEMIC PUBLISHERS NEW YORK, BOSTON, DORDRECHT, LONDON, MOSCOW
eBook ISBN: Print ISBN:
0-306-48403-X 1-4020-1295-0
©2004 Kluwer Academic Publishers New York, Boston, Dordrecht, London, Moscow Print ©2003 Kluwer Academic Publishers Dordrecht All rights reserved No part of this eBook may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, recording, or otherwise, without written consent from the Publisher Created in the United States of America Visit Kluwer Online at: and Kluwer's eBookstore at:
http://kluweronline.com http://ebooks.kluweronline.com
Dedicated in memory of my Father Mahmoud, my Uncle Roshdi, and my Aunt Alia.
This page intentionally left blank
Contents
Preface Acknowledgments
xix xxi
Foreword
xxiii
VOLUME TWO: APPLICATIONS AND DESIGN
441
PART III:
443
APPLICATIONS
10. PROBING, INSPECTION AND MONITORING 10.1 Surface Condition 10.2 Damage and Flaw Detection 10.3 Residual Stresses 10.4 Flow Obstruction 10.5 Monitors 10.5.1 Process Monitoring 10.5.2 Smoke Detectors 10.5.3 Radon 10.5.4 Other Gases 10.6 Hidden Materials 10.6.1 Industrial Materials 10.6.2 Radioactive Materials 10.6.3 Illicit Materials
447 447 454 456 457 458 458 460 460 462 463 463 463 464
11. GAUGING 11.1 Bulk Density 11.1.1 Alpha-Particle Transmission
465 465 466
vii
viii
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
11.2
11.3 11.4 11.5
11.6
11.1.2 Beta-Particle Transmission 11.1.3 Beta-Particle Scattering 11.1.4 Photon-Based Methods Thickness 11.2.1 Charged Particles 11.2.2 Photon Transmission 11.2.3 Photon Scattering 11.2.4 X-ray Emission 11.2.5 Neutrons 11.2.6 Composition-Independent Porosity and Voidage Water (Moisture) Content Measurements in Fluid Flow 11.5.1 Density 11.5.2 Flow-Rate by Radiotracers 11.5.3 Gas Flow-Rate by Ionization 11.5.4 Flow-Rate by Pulsed-Neutron Activation
11.5.5 Level Measurement 11.5.6 Liquid-Liquid Interface 11.5.7 Leak Detection 11.5.8 Volume 11.5.9 Gas Properties 11.5.10 Flow Distribution 11.5.11 Void Fraction 11.5.12 Multiphase Flow 11.5.13 Isotope Hydrology Dating
12. ELEMENTAL AND CONTENT ANALYSIS 12.1 Nucleus-Based Analysis 12.1.1 Activation Analysis 12.1.2 Passive Emission 12.1.3 Resonance Effects 12.1.4 Fast-Neutron Scatteroscopy 12.1.5 Charged-Particle Scatteroscopy 12.2 Atom-Based Analysis 12.2.1 Fluoroscopic Excitation 12.2.2 Composition Indication 12.3 Hydrogen Measurement 12.3.1 Neutron Slowing-Down 12.3.2 Scattering into Resonances 12.3.3 Beta Particles 12.3.4 Compton Scattering 12.3.5 Cold Neutrons
467 468 468 474 475 476 478 479 482 482 483 484 489 490 491 494 494 495 502 503 506 507 510 511 515 517 518 521 522 522 544 549 553 554 556 556 562 571 574 579 582 584 585
Contents
ix
12.4 Material Content Analysis 12.4.1 Alpha Particles 12.4.2 Beta Particles 12.4.3 Photons 12.4.4 Neutrons 12.4.5 X-ray Fluoroscopic Emission 12.4.6 Mössbauer Spectroscopy 12.4.7 Natural Radioactivity 12.4.8 Combined Techniques
585
586
587
591
595
603
604
604
604
13. IMAGING 13.1 Photon Radiography 13.1.1 Film Radiography 13.1.2 Radioscopy 13.1.3 Flash Radiography 13.1.4 Microfocus Radiography 13.1.5 Megavoltage Radiography 13.1.6 Low-Energy Radiography 13.1.7 Bremsstrahlung Radiography 13.1.8 Laminography 13.1.9 Scatterography 13.1.10 Emission Imaging 13.1.11 Diffraction Imaging 13.2 Neutron Radiography 13.3 Charged-Particle Radiography 13.3.1 Autoradiography 13.4 Tomography 13.4.1 Photon Tomography 13.4.2 Neutron Tomography 13.4.3 Scatter Imaging 13.4.4 Emission Tomography 13.4.5 Proton Tomography 13.5 Imaging for Material Content 13.5.1 Dual-Energy Imaging 13.5.2 Critical-Edge Tomography 13.5.3 Transmission/Scatter Imaging 13.5.4 Photon Coherent-Scatter Imaging 13.5.5 Emission Imaging
607
607
607
608
611
612
613
614
615
615
617
619
621
621
628
630
633
633
638
639
640
640
641
641
641
642
643
644
PART IV:
DESIGN
14. PERFORMANCE PARAMETERS AND DESIGN ASPECTS 14.1 Performance Parameters
647
653
653
x
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
14.2 Statistical Optimization 14.3 Design Objectives 14.4 Source Selection 14.4.1 Radiotracers 14.4.2 Source Generation 14.4.3 Source Energy 14.4.4 Interfering Radiation 14.5 Selection of Technique 14.6 Detection System 14.6.1 Detector Selection 14.6.2 Electronics 14.6.3 Detector Collimation 14.6.4 Filtration
659
662
663
665
666
667
670
671
673
673
674
675
678
15. SOURCE MODULATION 15.1 Source Collimation 15.1.1 Design Parameters 15.1.2 Geometry 15.1.3 Beam Profile 15.1.4 Divergence and Alignment 15.1.5 Collimation of Charged-Particles 15.1.6 Photon Collimation 15.1.7 Fast-Neutron Collimation 15.1.8 Collimation of Thermal-Neutrons 15.2 Filtering 15.2.1 X-Rays 15.2.2 Neutrons 15.3 Neutron Moderation 15.3.1 Moderating Materials 15.3.2 Moderating by Containment 15.3.3 Block Moderation 15.3.4 Moderation by Reflection 15.4 Neutron Multiplication
681
681
681
683
686
687
688
688
689
692
695
695
699
705
705
710
712
714
716
16. DESIGN CALCULATIONS 16.1 Design Parameters 16.2 Monte Carlo Simulation 16.3 Shielding 16.3.1 General 16.3.2 X-Ray Machines 16.3.3 Isotopic Gamma Sources 16.3.4 Neutrons 16.3.5 Computer Codes
719
719
720
728
728
732
734
735
735
Contents
xi
17. EXPERIMENTS 17.1 Experimental Aspects
17.2 Licensing
17.2.1 General
17.2.2 X-Ray Machines
17.2.3 Radioisotopes
17.2.4 Particle Accelerators
17.3 Background Reduction
17.3.1 Definition and Origin of Background
17.3.2 In Transmission
17.3.3 In Scattering
17.3.4 In Emission
17.4 Dynamic Analysis
17.4.1 Expected-Value Analysis
17.4.2 Frequency Analysis
17.4.3 Movement
739 739 742 742 746 748 749 751 751 752 754 756 757 758 759 761
18. FINALIZATION 18.1 Prototyping
18.2 Intellectual Property Protection
763 763 766
A.
Basic Units and Constants
xxvii
B.
List of Elements and Natural Isotopes
xxix
C.
Relativistic Mechanics
xxxv
D.
Quantum Mechanics D.1 Preliminaries D.2 Schrödinger Equation D.3 Concept of Cross-Section D.4 Quantum Electrodynamics
E.
Nuclear/Atomic Parameters for Compounds and Mixtures E.1 Atomic Density E.2 Electron Density E.3 Macroscopic Cross-Section E.4 Effective Mass and Atomic Numbers E.4.1 Electron-Density Based E.4.2 Reaction Cross-Section Based E.4.3 React ion-Ratio Based
F.
Effective Energy F.1 Mean Energy
xxxix xxxix xli xlvi l liii liii liv lv lvii lvii lvii lviii
lxi lxi
xii
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
F.2 Most Probable Energy F.3 Cross-Section Dependent F.4 Best Match G.
Radiation Counting Statistics G.1 Poisson Statistics G.1.1 Mean and Variance G.1.2 Population Statistics G.2 Gross/Background Count Rates G.2.1 Net Count Rate G.2.2 Number of Measurements and Counting Period G.3 Goodness of Data G.4 Current-Mode Statistics G.5 Elemental Error
References
lxii
lxii
lxii
lxv lxv
lxvi
lxvii
lxviii
lxviii
lxix
lxx
lxxii
lxxv
lxxvii
About the Author
clxxxvii
Application Index
clxxxix
Index
cxcix
Contents
Preface Acknowledgments
xix
xxi
Foreword
xxiii
VOLUME ONE: BASICS AND TECHNIQUES
1
1. INTRODUCTION 1.1 Why Radiation 1.2 Nondestructive Examination (NDE) 1.3 Conventional NDE Methods 1.4 Elements of NDE 1.5 Intricacy of Radiation Methods
3
3
4
6
9
10
PART I:
15
BASICS
2. RADIATION TYPES AND SOURCES 2.1 Charged Particles 2.1.1 Alpha Particles 2.1.2 Beta Particles 2.1.3 Discrete-Energy Electrons 2.1.4 Positrons 2.1.5 Heavy-Charged Particles 2.2 Photons 2.2.1 X-ray Machines 2.2.2 Low-Energy Photon Sources 2.2.3 Primary Gamma Rays 2.2.4 Indirect Gamma Rays 2.3 Neutrons 2.3.1 Fast Neutrons 2.3.2 Intermediate-Energy Neutrons 2.3.3 Slow Neutrons 2.3.4 Cold Neutrons 2.4 Natural Sources
xiii
19
19
19
21
25
26
29
30
31
36
44
46
46
48
55
56
58
59
xiv
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
3. MODIFYING PHYSICS 3.1 General 3.2 Cross Sections 3.2.1 Microscopic Cross-Section 3.2.2 Differential Cross-Section 3.2.3 Macroscopic Cross-Section 3.3 Charged Particles 3.3.1 Alpha Particles 3.3.2 Beta Particles 3.4 Photons 3.4.1 Photoelectric Absorption 3.4.2 Incoherent/Inelastic (Compton) Scattering 3.4.3 Coherent/Elastic Scattering 3.4.4 Pair Production 3.4.5 Photo-nuclear Interactions 3.5 Neutrons 3.5.1 Elastic Scattering 3.5.2 Inelastic Interactions 3.5.3 Absorption 3.5.4 Fission and Multiplicity Reactions 3.5.5 Coherent Scattering 3.5.6 Cross Sections 3.6 Radiation Transport 3.6.1 Classical Laws of Conservation 3.6.2 Divergence Law 3.6.3 Attenuation Law 3.6.4 Diffusion Theory 3.6.5 Transport of Charged-Particles 3.7 Radioactive Decay 3.7.1 Kinetics of Decay 3.7.2 Parent / Daughter Decay 3.7.3 Equilibrium 3.7.4 Decay Chains
63
63
66
66
67
67
70
71
75
78
81
82
92
95
99
99
100
103
105
105
106
108
122
125
127
129
130
132
133
133
134
135
137
4. DETECTION METHODS 4.1 Introduction 4.2 Charged-Particle Detectors 4.2.1 Detection by Chemical Reactions 4.2.2 Detection by Direct Ionization 4.2.3 Detection by Scintillation 4.2.4 Semiconductor Detectors 4.3 Photon Detectors 4.3.1 Gas-Ionization Detectors 4.3.2 Scintillation Detectors 4.3.3 Semiconductor Detectors 4.3.4 Radiographic Films 4.3.5 Electrostatic Plates 4.4 Neutrons Detectors
139
139
142
142
144
159
165
171
173
175
182
188
188
189
Contents
xv
4.4.1 4.4.2 4.4.3 Signal 4.5.1 4.5.2 4.5.3 4.5.4 4.5.5 4.5.6 4.5.7
Gas Detectors Scintillation Detectors Other Detection Methods Processing and Analysis Basic Components Pulse-Mode Counting Current-Mode Operation Energy Spectroscopy Timing Measurements Statistics Problems in Pulse Analysis
189
204
216
218
219
224
226
227
228
232
235
5. RADIATION SAFETY 5.1 Introduction 5.2 Principles and Definitions 5.3 Principles of Radiation Protection 5.4 Monitoring and Dosimetry
243
243
244
247
248
4.5
PART II:
TECHNIQUES
253
6. TRANSMISSION METHODS 6.1 Measurement Model 6.2 Pencil-Beam Probing 6.3 Radiography 6.3.1 Film Radiography 6.3.2 Variations of Film Radiography 6.4 Tomography 6.4.1 Problem Formulation 6.4.2 Back-Projection 6.4.3 Successive Approximation 6.4.4 Modal Approximation 6.4.5 Filtered Back-Projection 6.4.6 Image Quality 6.5 Special Methods 6.5.1 Combined with Scattering 6.5.2 Region-of-Interest Imaging 6.5.3 Dual Transmission 6.5.4 Resonance Mapping 6.5.5 Mössbauer Spectrometry 6.6 Charged-Particle Transmission 6.6.1 Alpha Particles 6.6.2 Beta Particles 6.6.3 Electron Radiography
259
259
265
269
270
279
282
282
286
287
295
298
299
302
302
303
303
305
306
307
308
309
309
7. SCATTERING METHODS 7.1 Introduction 7.2 Measurement Model
311
311
312
xvi
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
7.3
7.4 7.5
7.6 7.7
7.8 7.9 7.10
7.2.1 Model for Compton Scattering 7.2.2 Model for Neutron-Elastic Scattering Point Probing 7.3.1 Neglected Attenuation 7.3.2 Signal Modulation 7.3.3 Attenuation Averaging 7.3.4 Constant-Transmission 7.3.5 Normalized Scattering and Transmission 7.3.6 Single Low-Energy Source Transmission-Assisted 7.3.7 Two-Source Transmission-Assisted 7.3.8 Dual-Energy: Special Case 7.3.9 Dual-Energy: General Case 7.3.10 Coherent-Scatter Probing 7.3.11 Probing with Neutrons Multi-Point Probing and Analysis Scatterometry 7.5.1 Measurement Model 7.5.2 Linear Response 7.5.3 Variable Source-to-Detector Distance Method 7.5.4 Ratio Method 7.5.5 Saturated Scattering 7.5.6 Energy Spectrum 7.5.7 Combined Bulk and Probing Measurements Scatterography Reconstructed Scatter-Imaging 7.7.1 Point-by-Point Scanning 7.7.2 Integration Method 7.7.3 Nonlinear Solution 7.7.4 Coherent-Scatter Imaging X-Ray Diffraction and Refraction 7.8.1 X-Ray Diffraction 7.8.2 Refraction Neutron Diffraction Scattering of Charged-Particles 7.10.1 Scattering of Alpha-Particles 7.10.2 Scattering of Beta-Particles 7.10.3 Scattering of Ions
8. EMISSION METHODS 8.1 Gamma-Ray Emission by Neutron Activation 8.1.1 Measurement Model 8.1.2 Thermal-Neutron Activation 8.1.3 Epithermal-Neutron Activation 8.1.4 Fast-Neutron Activation 8.2 Gamma-Ray Emission by Charged-Particle Activation 8.3 Gamma-Ray Emission by Photon Activation 8.4 Gamma-Ray Emission by Positronium Decay
316
318
320
321
322
322
323
325
326
328
329
331
334
335
338
342
344
345
345
346
346
347
350
350
355
356
359
359
361
363
363
363
364
365
366
367
368
371
372
374
377
384
385
392
395
398
Contents
xvii
8.5
399
400
401
8.6
8.7
8.8
Charged-Particles Emission 8.5.1 Charged-Particle Emission by Photon Activation 8.5.2 Charged-Particles Emission by Neutron Activation 8.5.3 Charged-Particle Emission by Charged-Particle
Activation Neutron Emission 8.6.1 Neutron Emission by Gamma-Ray Activation 8.6.2 Neutron Emission by Charged-Particle Activation 8.6.3 Neutron Emission by Neutron Activation X-Ray Emission
8.7.1 Excitation by Isotopic Sources
8.7.2 X-Ray Excitation
8.7.3 Charged-Particle Excitation
Emission from Internal Sources
8.8.1 Radiotracing 8.8.2 Radioactive Materials 8.8.3 Emission Imaging 8.8.4 Gamma Cameras
9. ABSORPTION METHODS
9.1 Absorption of Charged Particles
9.2 Photon Absorption Methods
9.3 Neutron Flux Depression Method
9.4 Decay-Time of Neutrons
402
404
404
405
406
407 408 414 415 417 418 420 425 430 433 433 435 436 439
A.
Basic Units and Constants
xxvii
B.
List of Elements and Natural Isotopes
xxix
C.
Relativistic Mechanics
xxxv
D.
Quantum Mechanics D.1 Preliminaries D.2 Schrödinger Equation D.3 Concept of Cross-Section D.4 Quantum Electrodynamics
E.
Nuclear/Atomic Parameters for Compounds and Mixtures E.1 Atomic Density E.2 Electron Density E.3 Macroscopic Cross-Section E.4 Effective Mass and Atomic Numbers E.4.1 Electron-Density Based E.4.2 Reaction Cross-Section Based E.4.3 Reaction-Ratio Based
xxxix xxxix xli xlvi l liii liii liv lv lvii lvii lvii lviii
xviii
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
F.
Effective Energy F.1 Mean Energy F.2 Most Probable Energy F.3 Cross-Section Dependent F.4 Best Match
G.
Radiation Counting Statistics G.1 Poisson Statistics G.1.1 Mean and Variance G.1.2 Population Statistics G.2 Gross/Background Count Rates G.2.1 Net Count Rate G.2.2 Number of Measurements and Counting Period G.3 Goodness of Data G.4 Current-Mode Statistics G.5 Elemental Error
References
lxi lxi lxii lxii lxii lxv lxv lxvi lxvii lxviii lxviii lxix lxx lxxii lxxv lxxvii
About the Author
clxxxvi
Application Index
clxxxix
Index
cxcix
Preface
The need for this book arose from my teaching, engineering, and research experience in the non-power aspects of nuclear technology. The lack of a comprehensive textbook in industrial applications of radiation frustrated my students, who had to resort to a multitude of textbooks and research publications to familiarize themselves with the fundamental and practical aspects of radiation technology. As an engineer, I had to acquire the design aspects of radiation devices by trial-and-error, and often by accidental reading of a precious publication. As a researcher and a supervisor of graduate students, I found that the needed literature was either hard to find, or too scattered and diverse. More than once, I discovered that what appeared to be an exciting new idea was an old concept that was tried a few decades earlier during the golden era of “Atom for Peace”. I am hoping, therefore, that this book will serve as a single comprehensive reference source in a growing field that I expect will continue to expand. This book is directed to both neophytes and experts, and is written to combine the old and the new, the basic and the advanced, the simple and the complex. It is anticipated that this book will be of help in reviving older concepts, improving and expanding existing techniques and promoting the development of new ones. Hopefully, the consolidation of this material in one book will incite wider use and application of this powerful and useful technology. Therefore, the book is intended to be a single handy source of information for students, instructors, current and potential users of radiation technology, and its design engineers and researchers. The book is divided into four parts to accommodate a wide spectrum of readers. Part I deals with the fundamental aspects of radiation sources, physics and detection, and is particularly helpful for students who are not familiar with nuclear and atomic radiation. Part II is dixix
xx
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
rected to industrial physicists and engineers, as it provides an exposition of the different ways (techniques) by which radiation can be used to meet industrial measurement needs. Part III presents a large number of specific industrial applications. In order to assist the reader, an application index is given at the end of the book, identifying the areas in which radiation techniques are utilized. Those who would like to design a new device, or improve or alter an existing system, can refer to Part IV. This book can serve both as a reference book and as a textbook. To assist readers in searching and locating specific information, two separate indices are provided, paragraphs are given titles, and wide use is made of cross-referencing. Extensive literature is cited, and references are listed in detail. Three one-semester courses can be based on this book. The first part of the book, along with appendices C, D, E and G, can be used in an introductory course on radiation fundamentals to students with no or little background in atomic and nuclear physics. Part II, introduced by Chapter 1 and supplemented by appendix F, can serve as a course on nondestructive examination and imaging with radiation, assisted by example applications from Part III. A design course can be based on Part IV, with design projects assigned for systems described in Part III. For a set of problems and solutions, instructors can contact the author by e-mail at
[email protected]. The author welcomes any comments and suggestions for inclusion in future revisions of this book. ESAM M. A. HUSSEIN
Acknowledgments
Dr. John H. Hubbell has given me the great honor of writing the “Foreword” to the book, and provided viable comments and suggestions. Dr. Hubbell needs no introduction; researchers, practitioners and students of x- and gamma-rays are all familiar with his comprehensive work and tables on photon cross sections. The concept of this work was formulated through discussions with esteemed colleagues: Dr. Ned Kondic (formerly with the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission) in the late 1980’s, and Dr. Richard C. Lanza (Massachusetts Institute of Technology) and Prof. Nares Chankow (Chulalongkorn University, Thailand) in the nineties. Although writing this manuscript was a solo endeavor, it would not have been possible without the effort of all the authors whose work is cited in the book. Mr. P. Jacob Arsenault, Mr. Hassan A. Jama, Dr. Edward J. Waller and Dr. Ilan Yaar, of the Laboratory for Threat Material Detection at University of New Brunswick (UNB), thankfully read some chapters and provided useful suggestions. The prompt and professional response of the staff of the UNB Libraries, particularly at the Engineering Library and the Document Delivery Department, made it possible for me to readily access the based on needed literature. This book was written using platform, with WinTex 2000 as the interfacing editor. Finally a personal note to my wonderful children Mahmoud and Amina: without your love, forbearance, patience and understanding, the completion of this work would not have been possible.
xxi
This page intentionally left blank
Foreword
In browsing through a draft copy of this two-volume “how-to” desk reference on virtually all aspects of the use of photon and corpuscular radiations in the interrogation of materials and structures, I found the presentation format to be unique and useful. Although the variety and comprehensiveness is akin to a topical encyclopedia, the presentation reminded me of a thesaurus, in which the subtopics are not sequenced alphabetically, but, similar to in a thesaurus, are sequenced in a logical progression. Then, going “Roget” one better, at the end of the book are found not one, but two alphabetized indexes, first an “application index” and finally a conventional index alphabetically listing key words and their page numbers from throughout the text. In Volume One (Basics and Techniques), following a brief Chapter 1 (Introduction) surveying the unique features of radiation interrogation, often the only available tool for some NDE (nondestructive evaluation) challenges, Part I (Basics) begins this logical progression, in Chapter 2 (Radiation Types and Sources), with the definitions and nature of the various available radiations and how they can be obtained, then progressing in Chapter 3 (Modifying Physics) to the basic underlying physical processes by which these different radiations interact with atoms and with bulk materials. Part I concludes with a virtual Baedeker to the many types of radiation detectors and their underlying principles in Chapter 4 (Detection Methods) and a briefer Chapter 5 (Radiation Safety) addressing both common-sense and mandatory regulatory concerns. In Part II (Techniques) the logical topical progression continues in Chapter 6 (Transmission Methods) with a comprehensive array of topics ranging from time-honored film radiography to the mathematical intricacies of tomography to the esoteric application of Mössbauer spectrometry. Chapters 7 (Scattering Methods), 8 (Emission Methods) and xxiii
xxiv
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
9 (Absorption Methods) similarly provide encyclopedic coverage of the available methods and techniques in each of these categories. Volume Two (Applications and Design) brings the above wealth of “why?” and “how-to” information “into the real world” beginning in Part III (Applications) with an introductory Chapter 10 (Probing, Inspection and Monitoring) with topics ranging from the function of the alpha-particle sources in most smoke detectors (such as the ones in my home) to monitoring package-filling in opaque containers. This is followed by Chapter 11 (Gauging) listing and exhaustively discussing the otherwise-difficult-or-impossible interrogations of bulk density, thickness, porosity and voidage, moisture content, fluid flow and finally dating including with carbon-14 (geological time scales), tritium (short term, such as for ground waters) and the use of thermoluminescence for TL dating (archeological time scales). Chapter 12 (Elemental and Content Analysis) continues the logical progression of subtopics including nucleus-based analysis (e.g., activation analysis), atom-based analysis (e.g., x-ray fluorescence spectroscopy, XRFS), hydrogen measurement (mostly by neutrons), and material content analysis (e.g., applications of the above-mentioned Mössbauer spectroscopy). Concluding Part III, Chapter 13 (Imaging) catalogs and provides detailed information on the many different kinds of photon radiography, on neutron and charged-particle radiography, on tomography and on imaging for material content such as in dual-energy imaging. Finally, in Part IV (Design) the author shares the experiences and knowledge accumulated in his long and distinguished teaching and research career, much of it involved in synthesizing the above material into the invention, production and putting into practice a significant fraction of the above principles and devices for carrying out NDE tasks. Thus, Chapter 14 (Performance Parameters and Design Aspects) opens Part IV with material on performance parameters, statistical optimization, design objectives, and source, technique, and detection system selections, followed by Chapter 15 (Source Modulation) with collimation considerations, filtration, and for neutrons, both moderation and multiplication. The book’s logical topical progression continues in Chapter 16 (Design Calculations) with subtopics on Monte Carlo simulations, and shielding requirements in the differing cases of x-ray machines, isotopic gamma sources, and for neutron sources. Finally, Chapter 17 (Experiments) treats the important considerations of licensing, background reduction and dynamic analysis to verify that the device will indeed perform its intended function, and the brief Chapter 18 (Finalization) discusses prototyping and intellectual property protection (trade secrets, copyright, trademarks and patents).
xxv
Volume Two closes with several appendices providing valuable information including (A) Basic Units and Constants, (B) List (alphabetically) of Elements and Natural Isotopes, (C) Relativistic Mechanics, (D) Quantum Mechanics, including the Schrödinger equation and the concept of cross-section, (E) Nuclear/Atomic Parameters for Compounds and Mixtures, (F) Effective Energy, and finally (G) Radiation Counting Statistics, including Poisson statistics, mean and variance. Following the appendices is the listing of the 1373 references including full titles and inclusive page numbers, followed in turn by the two indexes mentioned, an Application Index and a conventional Index concluding this monumental and uniquely useful “encyclopedic/thesauric” guide and companion through the thickets of radiation nondestructive probing, gauging, imaging and analysis. John H. Hubbell Ionizing Radiation Division “Emeritus” National Institute of Standards and Technology Gaithersburg, Maryland USA October 31, 2002
This page intentionally left blank
VOLUME TWO:
APPLICATIONS AND
DESIGN
This page intentionally left blank
PART III: APPLICATIONS
This page intentionally left blank
Applications
445
This Part of the book presents examples of industrial applications, classified according to the nature of their indication: probing, inspection, monitoring, gauging, elemental/composition analysis, or imaging. These examination processes, defined in chapter 1, are analogous to those performed by medical physicians when examining patients. A general practitioner “propes” a patient by verbal questioning or by examining certain localized body sites to identify any abnormalities. Since verbal interrogation of objects is not possible, probing in industrial applications refers to the process of searching (on “spot-check basis”) for changes in an object via a series of localized examinations. A physician also attempts to diagnose a disease or a condition via general “inspection” of the patient for signs and symptoms. Patients are also connected to devices to monitor their vital signs. Quantitative measurements (“gauging”) of body parameters, such as blood pressure, body temperature, heart-beat rate, etc. also assist the physician in making a diagnosis. A general practitioner, or a medical specialist, may also order blood tests or bioassay for elemental or composition “analysis”. Medical doctors also acquire radiological, ultrasonic or magnetic-resonance “images” to facilitate the diagnosis process. All these examinations are used to provide proper diagnosis, or for health-monitoring purposes. Industrial examinations aim at the same objectives, assuring the integrity, quality, or condition of an object, material, a part, a structure or a process. To aid readers in findings a particular application in a certain field, or circumstances, an application index is given at the end of the book (page ??). Some applications require a combination of a number of indications and techniques. Therefore, while Part II of this book presented mainly methods based on a single physical indication (e.g. transmission, scattering, emission or absorption), Part III presents some methods that combine more than one indication. Such combination may be required to neutralize the effect of a particular physical parameter, or may be needed to provide supplementary or confirmatory indications.
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 10 PROBING‚ INSPECTION‚ MONITORING
Probing‚ as defined in chapter 1‚ is the investigation of a particular location. Inspection provides an overall assessment that need not be location-specific. Monitoring is a passive process of probing or inspection. The probing process is particularly helpful in detecting discontinuities caused by abnormal changes in the examined material. Unlike gauging and elemental analysis‚ probing and inspection do not necessarily provide quantified information. Therefore‚ probing and inspection can be seen as assessment tools for diagnosing the condition of an industrial object or a process. Therefore‚ the applications in this chapter are classified by the overall nature of the provided diagnostic information.
10.1.
Surface Condition
The surface condition of industrial components can be affected by deposition and erosion. For example‚ corrosion on the inside walls of pipelines and vessels can cause the condition of internal walls to deteriorate‚ creating safety and operational concerns. While deposition causes the addition of undesirable material‚ erosion results in the loss of primary material. Therefore‚ both processes change the apparent thickness and density of affected walls‚ or in other words‚ the areal density (density × thickness). This makes such measurements particularly amenable to the radiation transmission method discussed in section 6.2. Transmission Probing. With a narrow (well-collimated) beam‚ a rapid scan of a wall can be performed to detect changes in the transmission signal‚ which can be an indication of the occurrence of deposition. Gamma-radiation is particularly useful for such applications due to its high penetrability‚ ease of collimation‚ portability (due to the small size 447
448
Radiation Probing‚ Gauging‚ Imaging and Analysis
of gamma-sources) and mobility (due to the self-powered nature of isotopic sources). Example applications of gamma-transmission using a source include: the inspection of tubes in the radiant section of a cracker furnace for coke deposits‚ and the deposition of powder in the tubes of a serpentine cooler of hot powdered pigment [286]. Severe corrosion or erosion‚ that can result in wall thinning‚ can also be probed by gamma-ray transmission measurements. For example‚ the transmission of photons emitted from an source was used to “spot-check” for thinning in the tubes of heat exchangers by inserting a source in one tube and a miniature Geiger-Müller tube in an adjacent tube [286]. Scatter Probing. When accessibility to two opposite sides of an object is not possible‚ probing by radiation scattering can be employed. Also while probing with radiation-transmission provides indications along the line connecting a source to a detector‚ scattering probes a volume defined by the intersection of the fields-of-view of the source and the detector‚ as discussed in section 7.7.1. Therefore‚ by source and detector collimation‚ the inspected volume can be confined to a small zone‚ providing point-by-point scanning. On the other hand‚ relaxing the collimation of either the source or the detector or both‚ widens the size of the zone of inspection. Since gamma-rays can be readily collimated and have a good penetration depth‚ they are usually used for probing purposes‚ in the backscattering modality‚ to permit one-side inspection. For example‚ the back scattering of photons was used for detecting the corrosion of cast-iron pipelines (so-called graphitization) [287]. Steel rust buildup under insulation was also measured and quantified with backscattering of 160 kV x-rays [288]. Neutrons. Although neutrons are more difficult to collimate than gamma-rays‚ they are useful for probing hydrogenous materials. Neutron scattering is also used to avoid the collimation process required to define a transmission beam. However‚ the lack of collimation produces a larger inspection volume‚ thus neutrons are useful in probing for bulk changes. For example‚ neutron scattering was used to detect the deposition of heavy hydrocarbons at the bottom of pipelines or storage vessels‚ or the fouling of flarestack by ice deposits under severe cold-weather conditions [289]. Charged-Particle Scattering. The backscattering of low-energy (<10 keV) light-ions‚ see section 7.10.3‚ is also used to study surfacedependent phenomena‚ such as chemical catalysis‚ adhesion‚ insulators and electron emission from cathode tubes‚ as well as for studying the
Probing‚ Inspection and Monitoring
449
surface composition of alloys [240]. The backscattering of higher-energy ions‚ in particular ions‚ was used to detect surface impurities of a carbon substrate containing a surface layer of O‚ Si and Au (with 2 MeV ions )‚ silicon samples uniformly doped with As (with 1.8 MeV and to investigate a semiconductor ion-implementation process for depth of implementation‚ damage and impurities [290]. The backscattering of in the MeV range) was also used to monenergetic alpha-particles itor the surface smoothness of rough and polished silicon surfaces [291]. Radiotracer Dilution. Volume measurements‚ using the radiotracer dilution method discussed in section 11.5.8‚ can also be employed to determine the amount of material deposited at the bottom of a tank. For example‚ fluid volume measurements with a radiotracer was used to determine the overall amount of sludge deposited at the bottom of crude oil stock tanks with a tracer in the form of paradiobromobenzene diluted in the oil [277]. The thickness of deposits left over in a vacated tank can also be deduced from volume measurements of the air in the tank by using the dilution of a radiotracer gas‚ such as A similar concept was used to determine the amount of salt deposits on the inside walls of a steam superheater (hideout) by injecting a sodium carbonate solution‚ labeled with into the feed-water and scanning along the outside of the superheater using a collimated detector to determine the location of the hideout [1]. Radiotracers. Radiotracers can also be strategically implanted on surfaces to monitor their deterioration. For example‚ a dual-source method was used to monitor the wear rate of refractory linand ing in steel converters‚ and blast furnaces by embedding a small amount of the source in holes drilled in the refractory bricks‚ and monitoring the radioactivity in samples extracted from molten iron whenever the wear front reaches a source position [292]. Selective radiotracing can also be achieved by electroplating a thin radioactivated layer of material on the surface of the object. This approach has the advantage of reducing the overall amount of used radioactivity‚ while introducing only the radioactivity of choice. For example‚ in studying the corrosion of steel‚ the electroplated layer can be doped with eliminating all the other interfering radioisotopes that would result if the entire object is the low energy activated. Alternatively‚ steel can be doped with x-rays associated with its decay can be recorded on a radiographic film to provide a detailed picture of the status of corrosion. The low energy of these x-rays is advantageous in such radiograhic process as it enables localized imaging of the emission due to its limited penetrability. Such
450
Radiation Probing‚ Gauging‚ Imaging and Analysis
process was used to study the initial stages of corrosion of steel surfaces with corrosive solutions [179]. Another method of selective radiotracing was used for monitoring the deterioration of the wear of the lining of at selected points on blast furnaces by mounting small sources of the lining and monitoring the high-energy photons (1.33 and 1.17 MeV) outside of the furnace. The absence of this activity would then be indicative of sever wear conditions [179]. The high photon-energy of gammas makes it possible to detect the radioactivity from the outside of the furnace‚ while its relatively long half-life (5.27 years) allows the monitoring of lining wear for many years. However‚ the total source activity should be small‚ so that the disappearing source does not introduce a level of activity larger than that allowed in steel. Neutron Activation. The above probing methods are capable of detecting corrosion or erosion only when the amount of material loss is large enough to cause a detectable change in the material’s density or thickness. However‚ to detect a small amount of erosion‚ neutron activation (see section 8.1) can be used. By activating an entire component‚ or portion of the component‚ and monitoring the level of activity in the fluid causing erosion‚ the presence of erosion and its extent can be determined. The activation products act‚ in effect‚ as a radiotracer of the eroded material. No localized information can‚ however‚ be obtained‚ unless only a localized portion of a component is activated. In order to obtain a quantitative indication of the extent of corrosion‚ a correction needs to be made for the decay of the radiotracer‚ or alternatively‚ the measured activity should be compared to that obtained from a similar object not subjected to corrosion. Steel Corrosion/Erosion. Neutron activation is particularly useful for studying the corrosion/erosion of steel. When irradiated with thermal-neutrons‚ the iron in the steel produces (2.73 year) and (44.5 days)‚ with the half-lives given in brackets. The isotope has no gamma-emission‚ but decays by electron-capture emitting x-rays with a maximum energy of 5.19 keV. This long half-life is advantageous for long-term corrosion studies‚ but the low energy of its x-ray emission makes it necessarily to separate the wear debris from the eroding fluid‚ in order to make it possible to detect this poorly penetrating radiation [238]. Therefore‚ is the isotope that is usually monitored‚ as it emits both beta-particles (0.455‚ 0.273 keV‚ maximum) and gammaparticularly the rays (1.099‚ 1.291 MeV‚ . . . ) . The activity level of easily detectable gamma-emission‚ can be measured in the fluid causing corrosion‚ by sampling or by on-line detection of the highly penetrating
Probing‚ Inspection and Monitoring
451
gamma-rays of the resulting The half-life of is reasonably long to allow monitoring the corrosion process over a few months‚ after allowing for the decay of any short-lived isotopes that may result from any other minute elements that may be present in the steel. However‚ some long-lived isotopes may still remain in the steel producing residual activity‚ in particular (5.27 years) that results from the activation which may be present in steel. Neutron activation was used to of study the wear of piston rings in combustion engines [238]. Other applications of this steel activation process include examining the effect of various types of oils and oil additives on the corrosion/erosion process‚ and the detection of the erosion of oil risers by placing an irradiated steel coupon at the bottom of the riser and monitoring the activity in the extracted oil; and for the investigation of corrosion of heat exchangers using activated ferrules inserted into the heat exchangers tubes [277]. Wear. Another example of the use of activation tracers is in studying the wear of a cutting-tool [179]‚ made with tungsten carbide to impart hardness to the tool’s cutting edge. The neutron activating of tungsten in the tool produces a beta-emitter (626.6 keV‚ 1.3 MeV‚ maximum energy) and a gamma-emitter (685.7 keV‚ 479.55 keV) with a half-life of 23.72 h. Both isotopes are transferred to chips produced by the cutting tool. The short-range of beta-particles enables measuring the activity on one side of the chip‚ the surface sheared by the tool. Thus chips emerging on each side of the tool can be independently monitored‚ to determine the extent of the wear in each side. Gamma-emission‚ on the other hand‚ can be performed on a larger amount of chips‚ thus providing a higher count rate‚ and hence better measurement accuracy. Charged-Particle Activation. Localized probing can be achieved by charged-particle activation‚ see section 8.5‚ since a beam of chargedparticles can be focused on a certain spot of the surface. Another advantage of charged-particle activation is the poor penetrability of the charged-particles‚ which limits the activation to within a short distance beneath the surface‚ where corrosion or erosion are likely to take place anyway. This limited range of irradiation also reduces the overall radioactivity‚ by avoiding the activation of the entire object just to inspect the erosion of its surface. This process is known as thin-layer involves the activation (TLA) [277]. For steel‚ the reaction activation of the most abundant natural isotope of iron (91.72%)‚ unlike neutron activation that affects the isotope of lowest abundant isotope‚ (0.28%)‚ or (5.9%). The resulting isotope‚ has a rea-
452
Radiation Probing‚ Gauging‚ Imaging and Analysis
sonable half-life of 77.2 days with the emission of high-energy gammas‚ mainly at 846.77 keV and 1.238 MeV; it is also a positron emitter that can be monitored by the 511 keV gamma-rays associated with positron annihilation. This TLA process has been used in a number of corrosion studies involving the placement of activated coupons into flow components through specially designed gland systems [277]. Implantation of radioactive ions‚ such as and into a surface allows sensitive wear measurements by monitoring the worn away gamma activity of the implanted radioisotope [293]. Mössbauer Spectroscopy. As discussed in section 6.5.5‚ Mössbauer spectroscopy is particularly useful in iron studies‚ since natural iron contains 2.1% and the latter isotope has a strong recoilless absorption of gamma-rays at room temperature. Therefore‚ the technique was used to study corrosion [178]. The shape of the Mössbauer spectrum is affected by the presence of iron oxide and hydroxide compounds that are usually present in the corrosion products. The nature of corrosion can also be identified by this technique. For instance‚ electrochemical corrosion of steel results in the formation of which produces a characteristic peak in the Mössbauer spectrum‚ while atmospheric corrosion results in iron oxides and hydroxides that manifest themselves also as characteristic peaks [178]. Moreover‚ the particle size distribution of iron oxides and other corrosion components also affect the shape of the spectrum and can be useful in archeological‚ geological and artifact studies. Note‚ however‚ that this technique requires the extraction of a small amount of material for analysis. Positrons. Positroniums‚ see section 8.4‚ can also be used for surface analysis of porous media‚ taking advantage of the fact that positroniums tend to travel towards free surfaces. As a positron is captured by an electron in the medium‚ it gives the medium a net positive electrostatic charge‚ that repulses subsequent positrons. The positrons are consequently repulsed away from matter towards void spaces that are devoid of such repulsive force. Positrons tend to travel towards volumes free of electrons‚ such as internal cavities and free surfaces. This in turn provides a unique method for surface analysis‚ from the outside in‚ rather than from the outside to the inside as in other surface probing methods. Positrons traveling towards these void spaces will in turn pick up electrons along the way‚ forming positroniums. The lifetime (or decay constant) of positroniums is‚ therefore‚ useful for probing the surfaces of porous media [261]. Moreover‚ the intensity of measured positroniums is indicative of the total surface area.
Probing‚ Inspection and Monitoring
453
Diffraction. Neutron diffraction can also used to detect surface and near surface inclusions. A sphere of radius causes a small angular deviation of a cold neutron beam by an angle: where is the neutron wavelength [38]. Therefore‚ the diffraction angle is inversely proportional to the particle size‚ offering the possibility of detection of precipitate and corrosion products in alloys [74]. This small-angle scattering technique is used for detecting material inhomogeneity‚ such as in studying the topography of a turbine blade [294]‚ the structure of carbon-black elastomer (rubber) composites [295]‚ and the precipitation of various alloys [296‚ 297‚ 298‚ 299‚ 300]. Refraction. X-ray refraction‚ see section 7.8.2‚ is also used to characterize surfaces and interfaces in high performance ceramics‚ composites and other low density non-metallic materials down to nanometer dimensions [67]. X-ray refraction is caused by the interference‚ and subsequent phase-shift‚ by ultra-small angles‚ of x-ray scattered by objects above 100 nm in size. Therefore‚ the technique was useful in the examination of sinter glass ceramics and carbon fiber-reinforced plastic (CFPR) laminates [67]‚
Reflection. The reflection of cold neutrons (see sections 7.9 and 3.5.5.2) is useful in studying surfaces and interfaces. It has been used for investigating surface chemistry and films‚ such as in studying the adsorption of surfactants‚ polymers and fatty acids and air-liquid‚ liquid-liquid and liquid-solid interfaces [76]. In addition‚ the neutron refractive index of spin-polarized neutrons1 is sensitive to ferromagnetic materials‚ making it possible to study surface magnetism [301]. Industrial applications include [73] studying polymers and polymer blends‚ thin amorphous carbon films‚ Langmuir-Blodgett films2 and semiconductor materials and magnetic multilayers. An interesting application of neutron specular reflection includes substituting (deuterium) atoms for in atoms in has a bound scattering-length‚ of hydrogenous materials. While -3.7406 fm‚ the value of for is 6.671 fm [77]. The large and positive affects the refractive index‚ see Eq. (3.88)‚ making it value of for possible to use selective deuteration to contrast the presence of hydrogen molecules in hydrogenous materials‚ such as polymers. This feature has been used to study‚ with specular neutron reflection‚ the process of 1 The neutron has a spin of and a magnetic moment of Therefore‚ when subjected to a strong magnetic field‚ it can be polarized into a particular direction. 2 Langmuir-Blodgett films are one-molecule thick layers of liquids that float on water‚ transferred to a solid substrate by slowly passing the substrate through the air/water interface. These films may become useful in future molecular electronic and bioelectronic devices
454
Radiation Probing‚ Gauging‚ Imaging and Analysis
adsorption at the interface between a solute and a solvent‚ by substitution of in either phase. The method was used to examine the adsorption of mixed surfactants at the air-water interface [76].
10.2.
Damage and Flaw Detection
Detection of damage or a flaw in an object is the common goal of all techniques. Radiography is the most widely used radiation method in this regard‚ as discussed in section 13.1. However‚ other probing techniques are employed for this purpose; particularly when the application of radiography is not viable; e.g. when it is not possible to radiograph the entire inspected object as in the case of extended or large structures. Gamma-rays are usually employed because of their good penetrability. However‚ alpha- and beta-particles are also used. Beta-particles were utilized for the detection of faults in conventional explosive fuses using a beta-source [302]‚ while an accelerated (2 MeV) and collimated alpha-particles‚ directed close to the axis and planes of a crystal‚ were used to examine lattice damage by monitoring the backscattering of the particles. This method was also used for probing the crystal structure of a Si/SiGe superlattice and an Sb-implanted silicon sample [242]. NDE
Gamma Transmission. Gamma-ray beam transmission is useful for scanning for flaws or defects in a large object‚ such as the multi-stage process columns frequently encountered in the chemical industry. Gammatransmission can be used to monitor the performance of each stage in the column. Example applications of this approach are reported in reference [286] for the detection of tray-fouling of a fractionation column in a phenol plant that led to liquid flooding of some trays‚ and for inspecting distillation and absorption columns for loss of the demister-pad‚ foaming‚ liquid carry-over and tray flooding or damage. A flaw can also be characterized as a deviation from design dimensional tolerances. For instance‚ tight construction and operation tolerances are demanded in satellite and optical systems‚ and microelectronic‚ microsurgical and micromachinery tools. Imaging methods typically lack the spatial resolution required for such precise inspection. Reference [303] suggested the reliance on a template-machine procedure to detect if and where internal components are misaligned‚ and a modelfitting procedure to measure the deviation of out-of-line components. The procedure was demonstrated for the location of wires embedded in a regular array within a uniform fill material‚ using the transmission of xray beams along with a pattern-deviation procedure [303]. The method was devised to determine whether the sense wires in a gas-filled detector are at their intended locations (within a precision of 35 [304‚305].
Probing‚ Inspection and Monitoring
455
Photon Scattering. Gamma-ray backscattering was used to in-situ examine vessels and linings for the presence of voids‚ holes or gaps. For example‚ the method was used to examine the integrity of foamedinjected thermal insulation of pipework [287]. The same method was also used to check location of pipe joints and pipe ends in the downhole pipework associated with wells [287]. An 320 kV x-ray tube was also used to detect density variation between the cogs of synchronization rings produced by powdered metallurgy and used in the automotive industry [306]. Compton scattering was also utilized to detect flaws in near-surface cracks in steel plates under weld deposited cladding [307]‚ to detect defects in the labyrinth of coolant in metal-casted jet-engine turbine blades [308]‚ and to scan aluminum blocks for void [309]‚ Gammarays scattering is also useful in detecting debonding in composite aluminum joints [310]‚ assess impact damage in quasi-isotropic laminated composites [311]‚ and for void and density variations within food materials [312]. Using a source‚ scattering was used for the detection of corrosion pitting in underwater offshore oil risers [313]. Point probing with Compton scattering‚ discussed in section 7.3‚ was applied for detecting surface imperfections‚ up to 1.6 mm‚ in aluminum with the 90° scattering of the 662 keV photons of a source [314]. A similar technique‚ using was applied to locate groups of termite-damages sleepers during continuous scans of a railway track [315]‚ and for locating void and rebars in reinforced concrete blocks and determining their size and position [316‚ 317‚ 318‚ 319]. Scattering at 90° with a source was used to detect the presence‚ position and the amount of obstruction of paraffin (condensed petroleum) deposited in the inner walls of pipelines carrying oil in deep-water (off-shore) exploration [320]. Reference [321] reported measurements using the scattering of the 662 keV photons at different angles to detect and determine the size and location of flaws. The scattering of the 60 keV photons of an source was used for detecting hidden corrosion‚ disbonding‚ macro-cracks‚ and voids near the surface of an aircraft structure [322]. An interesting application of photon scattering is in determining the spatial orientation of fractures in formation rock by measuring the energy spectrum of a radiotracer‚ (0.889 and 1.112 keV)‚ which is significantly altered by scattering in the formation [323]. Neutrons. Neutron scattering was used for the detection of voidage in subsea grouting and cement casing and for the detection of loss of concrete lining of subsea pipes [289]. A method was proposed for measuring the local-density at a certain point in a pipe containing boiling water flow was introduced in reference [205]. The essence of the method
456
Radiation Probing‚ Gauging‚ Imaging and Analysis
is presented in section 7.3.11.1. Small-angle scattering of cold neutrons (see sections 3.5.5.2 and 7.9) is employed in the characterization of flaws that appear as small-particle inclusions‚ such as precipitates in alloys‚ impurities in silicon wafers‚ density fluctuations in polymers and pore sizes in silicas and cement [73]. Positrons. Positron trapping inside lattice defects enables the studying of lattice dislocations. Doppler-broadening of 511 keV gamma emission‚ associated with the annihilation of the positrons‚ was used to evaluate the dislocation structure of deformed thin copper sheets subjected source [324]. to positrons emitted from a Mössbauer spectrum. As discussed in section 6.5.5‚ the Mössbauer spectrum is affected by lattice defects‚ and is useful to study lattice damage in alloys. For example‚ the technique was used for studying radiation damage and aging of aluminum-iron alloys to distinguish between different phases of steel‚ such as ferromagnetic ferrite and paramagnetic austenite phases‚ or different steel alloys [178].
10.3.
Residual Stresses
Residual stresses exist in a material in the absence of an external force‚ and can be due to metal formation and fabrication processes. Residual stresses‚ or for that matter any stresses‚ are not measurable directly‚ but are determined by the corresponding material strain. The strain‚ in turn‚ affects the lattice space‚ the distance in Bragg’s law of diffraction‚ Eq. (3.66). Therefore‚ x-ray diffraction has been for many years the common method for measuring residual stresses‚ see for example references [325]‚ [326] and [327]. However‚ diffractable (cold) neutrons are more penetrating than x-rays‚ making them more appealing for use in industrial applications to measure sub-surface stresses. Neutron diffraction‚ discussed in section 3.5.5.1‚ has established itself as a mature technique for residual stress measurement‚ see reference [236]‚ Residual stress measurement has been made in many engineering components‚ such as a weldment [328]‚ pipes [329]‚ railway rails [330]‚ bent bars [331]‚ turbine components [332]‚ diamond compacts [333]‚ and metal matrix composites [334‚ 335]. Phase transformation during manufacturing affects the material’s mechanical properties and often is the cause behind the creation of residual stresses. Neutron diffraction is‚ therefore‚ used to study phase transformation‚ and its evolution with time‚ as it results in change in the crystallization pattern of materials. The technique has also been applied to study phase transformation in metal alloy composites and joints [336‚ 337‚ 338‚ 339‚ 340‚ 341‚ 342].
Probing‚ Inspection and Monitoring
10.4.
457
Flow Obstruction
Fluid flow can be obstructed by a foreign solid object inadvertently introduced into the flow stream‚ by the solidification of a flowing liquid‚ by the clustering of particulates‚ or by some other means. The direct way for detecting flow blockage is to mount a small sealed gamma-source‚ such as or and a floater that will move with the flow until it is halted by the object blocking the flow. The the position of blockage is then determined by monitoring the radiation level outside the flow container. Flow Area. Flow obstruction can also be determined by measuring the actual flow area. The flow area can be determined using a pulse of a radiotracer‚ if the inlet volumetric flow rate‚ is known and the is measured using a radiotracer‚ say by pulse time‚ as flow velocity‚ described in section 11.5.2.1‚ then flow area‚ A can be calculated as In a vessel‚ the flow volume‚ V‚ can be estimated from the time-of-travel‚ of a radiotracer pulse from the inlet to the exit of the vessel‚ as Reduction in either the value‚ A or in comparison to the nominal (design) values‚ or previously measured values‚ would then indicate the presence of a flow obstruction. Although this method does not provide a localized indication of the obstruction‚ monitoring the arrival of a radiotracer pulse between different stations along the flow can determine the extend of obstruction in the section between two consecutive stations. Also‚ an overall reduction in the flow area can indicate the need to clean-up the flow stream. This method was used to determine the extent of deposition of a polymeric by-product material in an organic chemical organic unit [277]. Thickness. The thickness measurement techniques‚ described in section 11.2‚ can also be used to detect the presence of a flow obstruction‚ by observing any increase in the measured thickness. Gamma-transmission‚ source‚ was used to detect partial blockage by powder coawith a lescence in the tubes of a serpentine cooler of hot powdered pigment by thickness measurements at various stations [286]. Gamma-transmission was also utilized for the detection of flow restrictions caused by deposition of water vapor‚ under cold weather conditions‚ in an overland pipeline carrying hydrogen gas [286]. The neutron slowing-down method for hydrogen detection‚ described in section 12.3.1‚ was used to determine the thickness of water deposition at the bottom of a tank or a pipe [287]. Since the density of hydrogen in the liquid phase is much higher than that in the gas phase‚ most of the slowing-down of neutrons would be caused by the liquid phase‚ and hence the amount of
Radiation Probing‚ Gauging‚ Imaging and Analysis
458
slowing-down‚ measured by backscattering of fast-neutrons‚ is indicative of the amount of water deposited at the bottom of a pipe or a container. Neutron slowing-down (backscattering) was also used to inspect a plant flarestack for ice blockage due to condensation of flare gases in severe cold weather conditions [289]. Reference [343] reported the use of a similar device to measure the moisture content in the medium of percolating filters used in waste-water treatment‚ to detect‚ particularly in winter‚ any material accumulation that can block the flow. Radiolabeling. Sealed radioactive sources can be used to track a moving object‚ such the ‘pigs’ used in pipelines. Cleaning or instrumentation pigs are often used in pipelines carrying gas‚ chemical and oil‚ but they can occasionally become stuck on the pipeline. Locating a stuck pig can often be a tedious and time-consuming process. However‚ if the pig is equipped with a small sealed and short-lived isotope‚ the location of the pig can be easily detected from the outside of the pipe with a radiation detector. The motion of such radioisotope-labeled pig can be also monitored a different stations along the line. The isotopes often used are (2.6 h half life‚ 847 keV main gamma) and (15 h half life‚ 1.369 MeV and 2.754 MeV main gammas). Such radioisotope-labeled pigs have been used in variety of pipelines [277].
10.5. 10.5.1.
Monitors Process Monitoring
Radiotracers are useful for monitoring and optimizing the performance of industrial processes‚ in particular mixing and fluid flow in chemical reactors‚ tanks and pipelines. Some of these applications are discussed in section 11.5‚ and some other example applications are given here. The pyrochemical process of copper production in Poland was optimized using reactor-produced radiotracers: (1.6 MeV gamma‚ 40.2 hour) and (0.5 MeV‚ 12.7 hour)‚ where the numbers in brackets refer‚ respectively‚ to the energy of the emitted gamma-rays and the half-life of the radioisotope [344]. Reference [345] analyzed the use of small quantities of ore irradiated in a reactor to study grinding systems in mills. Adsorption processes in milling plants can also be determined with radiotracers [346]. Seepage in a dike were studied using a pulse of [347]. The efficiency of sewage-treatment plants is determined using for the solid phase and or for the liquid phase [348]. The same isotopes were used to trace factory-waste causing ocean pollution‚ and to trace sand movement in river beds and and ocean floors [349]. Costal erosion was also studied using
Probing‚ Inspection and Monitoring
459
to label sand [349]. The behavior of heavy metal components in effluents from mining waste water were also examined using and radiotracers [349]. Sewage and liquid waste was investigated with tritiated water. The progress of grout‚ up the side of insert piles on offshore oil production platform‚ was monitored using in the form of glass powder suitably matched to cement [348]. The inventory (holdup) of process material (zirconium) in a solvent extraction column was determined using as a radiotracer [350]. The determination of the effectiveness dephosphorization of steel during manufacturing (to reduce its brittleness or to maintain its high phosphorus content to improve its casting properties) was done with the aid of (14 day half-life‚ 1.71 MeV pure beta-emitter) diluted into an open-hearth furnace. [351]. In blast furnaces‚ and radiotracer are used together in blast furnaces to study and measure their furnace performance [349]. The radiotracer dilution technique was a used to study the efficiency (2.69 days halfof electrolytic tanks of aluminum furnaces using life) [352]. Diffraction patterns of cold neutrons (see section 7.9) taken at different stages of the discharge of a commercial battery were utilized to study changes in its lattice structure. Neutron diffraction is also useful in the studying of liquids‚ such as lubricants and refrigerant liquids‚ and when combined with reflectometery (see section 3.5.5.2) diffraction was used to determine the effectiveness of surfactants in detergents [73]. Another interesting application is monitoring the natural process of rain formation. Cosmic-rays produce (37. 3 min‚ half- life)‚ (55 min) and (15 hr) by the spallation of argon in the atmosphere. These cosmogenic radionuclides “label” natural aerosols‚ and can be used as tracers of in-cloud scavenging. These isotopes were measured in rain water samples during storms to study the mechanisms of in-cloud precipitation formation and scavenging processes [353]. Neutron absorption is used to determine the reactive capacity (titration) of a chemical solution. If the active component in the solution contains a thermal-neutron absorbing isotope and if that component is separable from the solution in a different phase‚ the concentration of the titrand can be measured by observing its effect on the flux of thermal-neutrons. The relationship between the neutron flux and the concentration can be then used to determine the end-point of the reaction in precipitation or extraction processes. Solutions containing Cd‚ B‚ Hg‚ In and Ag can employed in this process [24].
Radiation Probing‚ Gauging‚ Imaging and Analysis
460
10.5.2.
Smoke Detectors
Ionization smoke detectors‚ widely used in homes and offices as fire alarms‚ rely on the ionization technique described in section 9.1. A small alpha-source‚ about 30 is used to ionize the air (oxygen and nitrogen) inside an ionization chamber consisting of two plates [14]. The electric charge resulting from the ionization process is collected by applying a voltage across the two plates‚ using a small battery. This current continues to flow as long as the battery is alive. When smoke particles enter the chamber they neutralize the positive charge of the ions by attaching themselves to them. This results in a decrease in the magnitude of the current flowing between the plates‚ which is sensed by the electronics of the detector‚ setting off an alarm. Once the smoke ceases to enter the chamber‚ a fresh supply of air will provide a fresh source of ions‚ and an uninterrupted electric current will flow‚ resetting the alarm. The current can also drop if the voltage supplied by the battery is below a certain preset value‚ which results in a continuous alarm until the battery is replaced. Note that in the absence of a battery‚ there will be no energy supply to power the alarm. Smoke detectors‚ based on this ionization process‚ are capable of detecting a small amount of smoke‚ such as that produced by fire flames‚ oil evaporation‚ or smoldering. It is worth mentioning that there are smoke alarms that do not use a nuclear source; the most common of which rely on light scattering. Photocell alarms (also called photoelectric detectors) are triggered by the scattering of light towards a photo-sensor located off‚ and shielded from‚ the direct path of a light source. Light can only reach the detector if a significant amount of smoke is present within the detector’s volume to scatter light towards the detector and set off an alarm. These photoelectric detectors are best suited for sensing smoky fires‚ such as that produced by a smoldering mattress [354].
10.5.3.
Radon
Radon is a noble radioactive gas‚ a daughter of radium; the latter is one of the members of the decay series of uranium‚ see section 2.4. It seeps from the ground to buildings‚ forming a potential radioactive hazard. Although radium occurs in uranium ores and certain rock types‚ its presence is more widely distributed because it forms water-soluble compounds. The presence of low levels of radon in buildings has been of some concern. The detection of radon relies on measuring the alpha-particles associated with its decay‚ or the alpha‚ beta and gamma-radiation produced by its decay products etc.). To measure radon‚
Probing‚ Inspection and Monitoring
461
a grab sample needs to be collected‚ or air has to continuously flow through a measurement chamber. Grab samples are collected in the field in a container or trapped on activated carbon3‚ then transferred to the laboratory for analysis. References [355] and [356] provide a description of sampling methods and protocols. Grab samples can be analyzed using an ionization chamber‚ with the sample transferred into the chamber with a forming gas (85% N and 15% H) through a platinum black catalyst [357]. Alternatively‚ the sample is transferred into a scintillation cell with a carrier gas. The most widely used method of detecting a low-level of radon is based on the scintillation cell of Lucas [358‚ 359]. This cell consists of a vessel with a transparent window‚ to which radon is transferred by a carrier gas. The inner walls of the cell are covered with a scintillator‚ typically ZnS(Ag) powder. The scintillation light caused by the alpha-decay of radon and its daughters is detected by a photomultiplier tube facing the window. Radon can also be measured by electrostatic collection of the chargedparticles emitted by radon and its progenies. The charged-particles can be collected on a photographic plate [360]‚ scintillator and a photomultiplier tube [361]‚ or a solid-state surface barrier or diffused junction detector [362‚ 357]. With the latter detector‚ the energy of the alphaparticle can be measured‚ allowing rapid monitoring of the 6.0 MeV and 7.7 MeV alpha-particles‚ respectively‚ of the short-lived isotopes (3.10 min‚ half-life) and half-life)‚ two daughters of radon [363]. In addition‚ measuring the 6.8 MeV alpha-particles of of (0.145 s) and the 8.8 MeV alpha-particles of the thorium decay chain‚ allows monitoring thoron in air. The device described in reference [363] has also a moisture correction sensor‚ a noble metal film whose impedance changes when water interacts with the thin film‚ along with a software correction mechanism that accounts for previous alpha particle deposition in the detector. Filter papers were also used to collect uranium particulate in air that may be present in a uranium enrichment plant under upset condition [364]. The alpha particles precipitating on such a filter paper were detected with a diffused junction silicon detector. Long-term accumulation of radon and radon progeny can be measured by passive integration of counts using nuclear-track detectors‚ such as cellulose nitrate and diglycol carbonate plastic films [357]. The density of the tracks left on such films are indicative of the number of alpha3Activated
carbon refers here to the highly adsorbent powdered or granular carbon‚ used in gas purification and chemical extraction.
462
Radiation Probing‚ Gauging‚ Imaging and Analysis
particles to which the film is exposed‚ hence to the cumulative density of radon and radon progeny. A conducting plastic chamber with an electrode at the bottom and a filtered inlet at the top is also used; the ions formed inside the chamber causes the surface voltage of the electrode to drop in proportion to the integrated radon concentration [357]. Solidstate detectors are also used to count the alpha-particles of radon and radon progeny diffused through a filter. For a period of a week or less‚ activated collectors are used‚ on which radon is adsorbed onto activated carbon. The alpha‚ beta and gamma-radiation emitted from the collectors can then be counted [357]‚ Also thermoluminescent (LTD) chips are used for measuring the alpha-particles from radon progeny introduced by an air flow into a filtered-head assembly [357]. An interesting method for determining the cumulative radon concentration over a number of years‚ hence assessing its radiological burden‚ is to measure the activity of radon daughters plated out‚ by their recoil energy‚ on hard materials such as stone or glass [365]. Radon particles and its daughters in the air tend to stick by electrostatic force to solid objects‚ such a vitreous glass. One of the radon daughters has a very short half-life and decays to This alpha-decay gives kinetic energy to causing it to recoil into the glass surface‚ to within about skin depth. The buried nuclei forms in effect an alpha-source‚ as it decays with 22.3 y half-life to The long half-life of enables the glass or stone‚ on which it is plated out‚ to act as a “memory ” of the airborne radon activity over many decades. The activity of is an indicator of the radon concentration. This alpha-decay activity can be measured using an ionization chamber or a track-etch detector [366‚ 367].
10.5.4.
Other Gases
Low-energy beta-sources‚ acting as electron sources‚ are also used in ion chambers to monitor gases entering a chamber. When a gas with high affinity to absorbing electrons‚ enters the chamber‚ it decrease the magnitude of the flowing current. This method is‚ therefore‚ used for the detection of hydrogen and carbon tetrachloride and nitro compounds (including explosives) in air‚ sulphur hexafluoride‚ solvent fume in degreasing operations‚ halogens in pesticides in and gas leaks [368]. Beta and source used in such electron-capture chambersinclude Electron-capture instruments are often connected to a gas chromatography column to measure specific components. A beta-source‚ 18.5 GBq of is used to provide in-flight warning of low rotor-blade gas pressure in a helicopter. Under normal pressure‚ the source is kept shielded. When the pressure drops‚ the source moves to an unshielded position‚
Probing‚ Inspection and Monitoring
463
allowing its beta-particles to reach a fuselage-mounted detector and provide a warning signal in the cockpit [369]. The system is known as in Flight Blade Inspection System (IBIS) [369] A smaller source (1.85 GBq of is used as an ice detector probe [369]‚ with the ice buildup blocking the passage of beta-particles to a detector. Beta-emitters‚ such as (a few to a few tens of GBq) or (about 1 GBq) are also utilized as nighttime markers of equipment (such as parachutes) or exits. [369]
10.6. 10.6.1.
Hidden Materials Industrial Materials
It is sometimes needed in industrial situations to determine whether a specific material‚ hidden from direct view‚ is in its appropriate place. The methods used for level measurement‚ see section 11.5.5‚ are also applied as fill gauges to determine whether a package of a product is filled to the appropriate level. By setting a gauge at a the required fill level‚ the gauge’s response would be abruptly perturbed when the filling material reaches a preset level. That change in response during filling can be used to signal that the package has reached the desired level‚ or when monitoring a pre-filled package to determine whether the package is under-filled. The approach was used to monitor the filling of rail tankers [287]‚ fluid (fruit juice‚ beer‚ etc.) level in cans in assembly lines [238]‚ and the filling level of soap‚ detergent and pharmaceutical packages [179]. Level gauging was also used to guard against boiling dryout in a steam generator [179]‚ and to detect failure due to slumping or collapse of catalyst-bed support in a column. Using a moving beam of well-collimated x-rays‚ individual pellets in nuclear-reactor fresh fuel elements can be inspected for position and length [7].
10.6.2.
Radioactive Materials
The presence of fissile materials in nuclear warheads‚ for treaty verification or in smuggled goods‚ can be detected by monitoring gamma-rays emitted in the energy range from 0.2 to 6.4 MeV [370]. The concept of a hodoscope‚ a battery of detectors‚ was also used to image and detect radioactive objects (such as nuclear fuel within test capsules) and monitor their movements‚ [371‚ 372]. A hodoscope detects neutrons and/or gamma-rays emitted from the material using an array of detectors‚ but can be used also to detect transmitted radiation. The process is referred to as cineradiography [373]. The applicability of this method to the counting and discrimination of nuclear warheads and the monitoring of rocket motors enclosed in their canisters is discussed in reference [374].
464
Radiation Probing‚ Gauging‚ Imaging and Analysis
Nuclear assaying is also used to provide elemental analysis of nuclear materials‚ see chapter 12. One of environmental concerns is that radioactive materials may enter the recycling process as scrap metal. Some metal processing facilities are becoming concerned with this problem and began to consider installing systems for detecting incoming scrap for radioactive materials [375]. Isotopes of concern are and [376]. These isotopes can be detected by their gamma emissions.
10.6.3.
Illicit Materials
Photon backscattering was used for detecting contraband materials‚ mainly drugs‚ hidden in spare automobile tires‚ vehicle walls‚ truck trailer walls‚ etc. [377]. The device known as the “Buster” consists (3.7 MBq) and a CdZnTe detector‚ housed in a small of a small hand-held container. The device is equipped with a microprocessor that provides both a digital display and an audio alert when the inspected object is not empty. A similar device was developed for detecting visually obscured objects hidden within extended walls [378]. Elemental and composition analysis methods are also used for detecting contraband materials‚ see chapter 12.
Chapter 11 GAUGING
Gauging aims at providing a metered (quantified) indication of a quantity of engineering interest, such as density, thickness, porosity and moisture. Fluid properties and flow measurements are also included in this category, as well as age measurement (dating) of archeological and aging objects. Usually gauging does not provide localized (probing) indications, and does not pertain to composition or elemental analysis. In addition, no imaging information are given by gauging. References [206], [379] and [380] provided a survey of radiation gauging devices in a number of industrial fields.
11.1.
Bulk Density
The macroscopic cross-section, as shown in section (3.2.3), is dependent on the material’s density, which indicates that all radiation interactions are density-dependent. However, the macroscopic crosssection also depends on the elemental composition of the material, see Eq. (E.14) in Appendix E. Therefore, for radiation interactions to provide density indications, dependence on material composition must be eliminated or compensated for. Obviously, if one is monitoring density changes of a certain material with a fixed composition, any type of radiation interaction will provide a density-dependent indication. However, if the material composition is not known, or if it changes, one has to rely on composition-independent interactions. Such interactions occur when radiation interacts with the free electrons of the matter, since then material is seen by radiation as merely a “sea” of electrons. For most materials (except hydrogen) the atomic-number, Z, is about half the mass-number, A, hence the electron density is directly proportional to the mass-density as can be deduced from Eq. (E.9). Therefore, 465
466
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
Compton scattering of photons is well-suited for obtaining compositionindependent density measurements. Since for most materials, Compton scattering is the dominant mode of interaction at photon energies from 50 keV to 1.5 MeV, many of the radiation sources listed in section 2.10 are suited for this purpose. However, charged-particles, alpha- and betaparticles, are also useful in density measurement, particularly for small quantities of low-density materials, where the interaction rate of photons is too low to provide a sufficiently strong indication. The application of these various radiation types and interactions are discussed in the following sections.
11.1.1.
Alpha-Particle Transmission
The limited range of alpha-particles makes their use restricted to measuring the density of gases. This can be done by passing the gas between an alpha-source and a charged-particle detector, such as an ionization chamber. As the density of the gas increases, the energy of the transmitted alpha-particles decreases. The energy carried by the transmitted particles is determined by the value of their stopping power, which is a function of the material density, as discussed in section 3.3. An energysensitive detector, such as a surface-barrier detector, can be used to measure the energy of particles emitted from monoenergetic sources as those listed in Table 2.1. Since the stopping power is a linearized estimate of the average energy decrement per unit length, alpha-particles transmitted through a material do not have a monoenergetic energy, even if the source energy is monoenergetic. However, the most probable energy of the transmitted particles (i.e. that corresponding to the peak of the recorded energy distribution) can be related to the material’s density [238]. The transmitted alpha-particles can also be measured with an ionization chamber operating in the current mode, since the current is proportional to the amount of ionization, hence energy, of alpha-particles incident on the chamber (see section 4.5.3). Obviously, the thickness of the material has to be less than the particle’s range, for the detector to provide the proper response. On the other hand, the range itself can be used to measure the material’s density, since as Eq. (3.14) indicates, the range is a function of density. The range can be measured by a detector operating in the pulse mode, such as an ionization chamber, or a GeigerMüller tube, to provide a count rate. However, as Eq. (3.14) indicates, the range of an alpha-particle is proportional to the mass-number of the gas. Therefore, the density indication is dependent on the type of gas used. Another range-based method relies on the use of a thick alpha-source, which due to self-absorption will produce particles of different energies,
Gauging
467
hence different ranges [238]. When these alpha-particles pass through the inspected medium, lower energy particles will be absorbed while higher-energy ones will penetrate the medium. The number of alphaparticles transmitted will decrease with increasing material density. This thick-source concept in effect resembles a transmission mechanism similar to that attained by beta-particles or gamma-rays. All the above [179]. methods are suited only for very thin layers, about Therefore, any container material present between the alpha-source and the detector can absorb most, if not all, the source particles. These methods are not, therefore, suited for measuring the density of gases in a container, a pipe or a pressure vessel. Alpha-particles are, however, useful for measuring the density of gases, fire flames, smoke, etc..
11.1.2.
Beta-Particle Transmission
Beta-particles can also be used to measure density. Since there are more penetrating than alpha-particles, beta-radiation is useful for measuring the density of materials that are more dense than gases, and for thin objects. In the transmission modality, the intensity of betaparticles, as Eq. (3.23) shows, decreases exponentially with the material thickness and its attenuation coefficient, with the latter being density dependent as reflected by Eq. (3.24). Therefore, to perform a density measurement, the material’s size has to be kept constant. This is readily achievable in a process that produces products of a fixed thickness, such as paper products. Liquid samples should also be enclosed in thin containers, or a container equipped with a window through which betaparticles can pass. When used with materials with low atomic-number, Z, as in the case of most liquids, the attenuation-coefficient becomes independent of composition, except for the materials containing a significant amount of hydrogen. For low-Z elements, beta-particles interact primarily with the electrons of the atoms. The microscopic cross-section for such reaction, as Eq. (3.26) indicates, is a function of Z. The macroscopic cross-section, i.e. the attenuation-coefficient, becomes then dependent on where A is the mass-number of the element which scatters the beta-particles, see Eq. (E.14). Since for all elements, except hydrogen, density measurement by beta-particle transmission is reasonably independent of composition. However, in the presence of a significant amount of hydrogen, the estimated density would be overestimated, due to the increased value of from 0.5 to 1.0. If the concentration of hydrogen is known, a correction factor can be applied to the measurement. Alternatively, a calibration curve of density versus count rate can be used. One must keep in mind that the material thickness, while kept constant, should be less than
468
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
the range of beta-particle in the inspected material at the maximum energy of the source’s particles, otherwise no beta-particles will be able to penetrate the object. Both the energy and intensity of the transmitted beta-particles are indicative of the materials attenuation effect, hence its density at a given thickness. Beta transmission is useful for liquiddensity measurement, and was used to determine the density of tobacco in cigarette packing [238].
11.1.3.
Beta-Particle Scattering
Backscattering also offers the ability to perform one-side surface and near-surface measurements. Although, as Eq. (3.28) indicates, the scattering probability of beta-particles is higher in the forward direction, the limited range of the particles does not facilitate performing forwardscatter measurements. Nevertheless, forward scattering has been used to measure the density of air at different altitudes (30 to 60 km), using a low-energy electron source incorporated into a parachute [381]. A similar measurement was reported in reference [238] using a radioisotopic source, Other backscattering density measurements include: measurement of frost density distribution on the surface of a vertical pipe, automatic monitoring of aerosol samples, and measurement of evaporation rate through turgid tobacco leaf [237].
11.1.4.
Photon-Based Methods
Density measurements are most often performed by gamma-ray transmission and scattering, not only to take advantage of the penetrability of gamma-rays, but also to obtain composition-independent density measurements as explained earlier in this section. Although x-rays are more convenient to use than gamma-rays, since their emission can be turned off, the continuous energy spectrum of x-rays contains a large portion of low-energy photons. This makes density measurements with x-rays vulnerable to photoelectric absorption, which limits the penetration depth and makes the measurements strongly dependent on chemical composition. Transmission. In a transmission arrangement, the thickness of the inspected object has to be kept fixed, or be known in advance. According to the transmission measurement model, e.g. that of Eq. (6.1), the strength of the transmission signal depends on both the macroscopic cross-section of the material (which is density dependent when Compton scattering is the dominant mode of interaction) and the thickness of the material traversed by radiation. However, the thickness of the object in transmission measurements should be equal to for optimum
Gauging
469
counting statistics, according to the optimization method discussed in section 14.2. A larger thickness will cause severe degradation of the radiation intensity, and increases the build-up effect (see section 6.1). Section 11.5.1 lists some of the applications of the technique in fluid density measurements. Other applications include the measurement of the density of cement raw meal (to determine the content of solid particles in suspension), the density of cement in rotary kilns, and the density of building materials [179]. The concentration of mud (slit) in water streams can also be measured with gamma-transmission by inserting a forked frame, holding the source on one arm and the detector on the other [179]. Using a collimated beam of photons, one can scan a vessel to determine the density distribution of its contents. This density profiling process has been used to check the packing of catalyst beds and absorption columns [286]. Gamma-transmission was also used to measure density inhomogeneities within compacted powders to monitor the packing uniformity of powder in the pharmaceutical industry [382]. The kinetics of the thermal decomposition of wood and plastic was studied by density measurements using the transmission of photons [383]. Using a number of small gamma-sources distributed across the width of a conveyor belt, multi-transmission was used to measure the density of iron ore on the belt [384]. The use of many sources minimizes the effect of the change in the photon-transmission length by lateral segregation in the ore. Weight Scale. Gamma transmission, as the transmission model of Eq. (6.1) shows, is in effect a measurement of where is the thickness of the material traversed by the radiation. Since in Compton scattering, is equal to with being a the mass-attenuation coefficient which depends on the source energy, transmission provides a measure of the so-called areal density. Now for a constant detection area, the transmission measurement becomes in effect a measure of the mass (or weight) of the material through which the transmitted radiation passes. This is the essence of radiation weight scales that are particularly useful for the nonintrusive measurement of the weight of materials on conveyor belts. The mass flow rate of the material on the belt can be easily deduced from its speed. This no-contact method of weighing can be used at high temperature, and in harsh industrial environments. Scattering. The dependency on thickness in the transmission technique can be overcome by relying instead on photon scattering. This process is schematically shown in Figure 11.1 for two scatterometer arrangements. In the first configuration, Figure 11.1a, both the source and
470
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
the detector are located outside the inspected medium, while in configuration 11.1b, the source-detector assembly is inserted within the medium, perhaps through a guide tube. In both arrangements, the detector is shielded from direct exposure to the source radiation by a metal (usually lead) block. Although arrangement 11.1b involves intrusion through the medium, it is useful for inspecting soil and ground formations where such intrusions are tolerated. Configuration 11.1b also permits studying the change of density with depth as the device is driven deeper inside the medium. The configuration of 11.1a is particularly suited for oneside inspection, when access to two opposite sides of the object is not possible. The measurement model is the same for both configurations of Figure 11.1, since in both cases the source photons encounter a number of collisions before reaching the detector. However, in Figure 11.1a only a smaller fraction of the source particles are utilized as a significant portion of the source photons are not directed towards the medium; al-
Gauging
471
though some of the photons scattered by the walls of the shielding may reach the medium. In either case, some of the scattered photons will succeed in reaching the detector, thus providing an indication of the material density of the volume covered by the photons. The number of scattered photons depends on the macroscopic cross-section of Compton scattering, which is in turn proportional to the material’s density (as explained above). However, Compton scattering is also a removal (attenuation) process of photons, as it can scatter photons away from the detector. The two competing effects of photon scattering and removal can be represented by the following measurement model:
where S is the detector’s response, K is some system constant that incorporates the source strength, detector’s efficiency and system geometry, is the Compton scattering macroscopic cross-section of the material averaged over all scattered photons (as photons continuously lose energy according to Eq. (3.37)), L is an equivalent path-length of photons from the source to the detector, is the material density and is the mass attenuation-coefficient of the medium. The value of L depends on the source-to-detector distance, while the value of is a function of the source energy. The estimated value of according to the model of Eq. (11.1) is the average density of the region covered by the scattered photons. This averaging effect is caused by the many collision encountered by the photons over a wide area before reaching the detector. Therefore, if the medium is not homogeneous, the estimated density will correspond to that of an equivalent homogeneous medium. The model of Eq. (11.1) indicates that the detector response will increase with increasing density, until the density is sufficiently high for the attenuation effect to dominate the scattering effect, then the detectors counts will decrease with increasing density. Therefore, the detector response reaches a maximum value at some density, before decreasing with with density. This maximum density is a function of L and the latter depending on the source energy. Accordingly, for the same detector response, two estimates of the density can be obtained; one from the ascending portion of the response and the other from the descending side. However, to avoid ambiguity, the device can be designed to function on one side of the response curve of Eq. (11.1) by choosing a proper source energy and source–to-detector distance. Devices for measuring the soil density are normally designed to function in the descending side of the response curve. The model of Eq. (11.1), by setting the Compton scattering cross-section equal to the attenuation coefficient (in the argument of the exponential term), ascertains that the Compton effect is the
472
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
dominant process of removing photons. However, as photons lose energy, the photoelectric effect becomes prominent. Since the cross-section of the photoelectric effect is strongly dependent on the atomic-number, see Eq. (3.30), the device can become sensitive to changes in the material composition. This dependence can, however, be diminished by electronically discriminating against low-energy photons, see section 4.5. Applications of this density measurement with photon scattering include the measurement of the density of soil [179, 215, 238]. Compton scattering density measurements was also performed on concrete structures [385, 386]. Reference [387] suggested the use of the backscattering of 50 kV x-rays to rapidly measure the density of an organic material on a steel conveyor belt. The scattering of gamma-rays emitted from a was used to measure the density of coal seams in neutron source water-filled boreholes. An interesting early application of this scattering technique was in the determination of the water content in snow on the ground by measuring its density [179]. Reference [287] reported an application involving the use of the backscattering of photons to detect the extent of a form of corrosion of cast-iron pipes called “graphitization”. This process results when the liquid or the gas in the pipe dissolves iron from the metal cast, allowing the liquid or the gas to diffuse through the pipe walls, reducing in effect the density of the wall. Backscattering is particularly suited for this application, not only because it allows the inspection of buried pipes, by having only access to one side of the pipe, but also because the amount of density change is too small to allow inspection with a transmission technique (even if access to two opposite sides of the pipe was possible). Although reference [287] reported the use of the technique for inspecting pipes carrying river water, to cool a power plant, the technique can also be applied for the inspection of gas pipelines. Backscattering of photons was also used for measuring the density of a layer, or thin-lift, of known and constant thickness on a planar substrate, such as in the repaving of roadways and bridges. Two measurements are required, one before the layer is applied, and one after [388]. A backscattering gauge was also developed for monitoring and control of material conditions in a steel sintering plant by measuring the density of plant material [389]. In coal exploration, gamma-ray scattering is used to detect the position of the interface between coal and underlying rock strata [390]. Also, since ash content is directly related to the mineral content, which in turn is related to density, gamma-scattering can be used an indicator of the ash content [390]. In the oil industry gamma-scattering is used to measure the density, of a formation, which along the speed of sound in the formation gives
Gauging
473
useful seismic information [40]. An x-ray generator (an electron linear accelerator) was considered to provide higher source intensity and improve the detection sensitivity [391, 392, 393, 394]. In well-logging (or wireline logging)1 gamma-scattering is used to determine the density of various layers of the strata as the probe is lowered deep into the ground. Note that the speed, of a longitudinal wave of sound in a where Y is the modulus of elasticity of the solid material is equal to material. Therefore, by measuring with gamma backscattering and with an acoustic method, the value of Y can be determined, indicating the strength of the structure. Measurements are performed in a well-log ) and with a tool containing a gamma-source (typically or one or two gamma-ray scintillation detectors, with the source separated from the detector by some distance. To ensure that the detectors are monitoring Compton scattering, the electronics are set to discriminate against low-energy photons, where the photoelectric effect is dominant. The device is then driven through the borehole and butted against its wall by a spring to reduce the effect of the mud-cake (the residue of drilling mud deposited on the borehole wall) on the measurements. The mud-cake will scatter some photons towards the detector, while preventing other from reaching the detector. However, by viewing the problem of density formation as a problem of two unknowns: the bulk density of and the change in recorded density due to the mudthe formation, then using two measurements, a solution can be found for cake, the two unknowns, thus correcting for the effect of the mud-cake. Two scattering detectors are used for this purpose, one near the source and the second away from the source [40]. Each detector in effect views a different region of the formation and the mud-cake, thus providing two independent measurements. Calibration curves are then employed to determine both and using the count rate provided by the two detectors. Dual-Energy. The dual-energy Compton scattering method, discussed in section 12.2.2.5, was used for the determination of density of a substance enclosed within another substance [395], using the 41 keV source. The method relies and 100 keV photons emitted from a on estimating in advance effective values for the total cross-section of
1 Well-logging, or wireline logging, is the term used in oil exploration to record a log, i.e. a graph of the response versus depth of an instrument (also called a sonde) driven down a hole (called a borehole) at a certain logging speed, to measure some property of the formation through which the borehole is drilled. Measurements can also be performed while drilling by equipping sections of the drillpipe with proper instruments.
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
474
the two substances (as a weighted value at the incident and scattering energies), and by knowing the total distance of travel of radiation from the source to the detector. The problem then has only three unknowns, the density of the central material (causing the scattering), and the total distances traveled by radiation in each of the two material. The three problem unknowns can then be determined from the two scattering measurements, in addition to the fact that the total distance traveled by singly-scattered radiation remains constant and is known in advance. The method was investigated for measuring the electron densities of and consolidated volumes of potassium hydrogen phosphate calcium chloride polystyrene and plexiglass immersed in water. Although the method was developed for use in the human body (e.g. bone surrounded by tissue), the method can be used in industrial applications to measure the density and size of material inclusion within an otherwise uniform medium. Positron Annihilation. Another interesting method suitable for measuring low-density materials, 10 to (such as foam materials, polystyrene and polyurethane) relies on measuring, in coincidence, with two opposite detectors, the two (511 keV) photons produced by the annihilation of a positron. A fixed positron source inserted into the investigated medium can be used for this purpose. Reference [396] reported the use of a (3.08 h half-life, 1.044 MeV maximum energy) source. The measured count rate, recorded at a distance from the source, was experimentally shown to follow the relationship:
where K is a system constant that depends on the strength of the is a factor that depends positron source and the detector efficiency, on the relative size of one detector with respect to the other, hence size and type of the detectors, while and are parameters that describe the attenuation of the count rate with distance from the source.
11.2.
Thickness
Thickness measurements by nuclear methods are useful when noncontact gauging is to be performed within a short time, or when direct access to the material is not possible, such as in measuring the thickness of deposits on the inner walls of a tube. The transmission techniques described in section 11.1.1 for beta-particles and gamma-rays can be used for this purpose, since for a given material and radiation type (i.e. constant total cross-section, transmission will provide the value of the thickness, see Eq. (6.1). The poor penetrability of alpha-particles
Gauging
475
limits their use to thin and light materials. X-ray fluoroscopic emissions and neutrons can also be employed in thickness measurements. A number of standards have been developed for thickness measurement with radiation [397, 398]. The following sections discuss some of the thickness measurement applications classified by the technique used.
11.2.1.
Charged Particles
Alpha Particles. The limited penetration of alpha-particles makes them suitable for measuring the thickness of thin and/or light materials, such as liquid and gas films, gases, papers, plastic coating on paper, ions) etc. The absorption and backscattering of alpha-particles was used for measuring the thickness of aluminum, nickel, silver and gold films in the thickness range of to [399]. Rutherford backscattering was shown to provide higher accuracy than optical methods, in addition to providing indications of film contamination (change in composition). The aperture area of optical diaphragms was also measured by alpha-particle scattering [400].
Beta Particles. The sightly higher penetrability of beta-particles, than most other charged-particles, makes them suitable for measuring thicker or more dense materials, such as paper and plastic sheets and metallic foils, rubberized fabric and coatings on metallic sheets [238, 179]. The transmission of beta-particles not only offers more penetration, but its thickness indications are easier to interpret as they follow empirically the exponential relationship of Eq. (3.23). Beta-particle transmission, as described in section 11.1.2, can used for measuring the thickness of sheet materials of areal densities of typically about This corresponds to a steel sheet of about 0.4 mm in thickness, or an aluminum sheet of 1 mm thick. Table 11.1 provides a guide for selecting a beta-source for a given areal density range. Reference [401] described a method for measuring the thickness, and uniformity, of large area sheets of paper, aluminum, nickel and gold, using a source. An on-line gauge used in the cellulose and paper industry employed a double-transmission technique for improved sensitivity, by magnetically deflecting, by 180°, transmitted particles back through the object [402]. A system employing was also used to monitor and control the production of plastic foils in the 20 to thickness range. The backscattering of beta-particles is most useful in measuring sheet and coating thickness. The detector’s response can be expressed by Eq. (7.72). Thickness gauging with scattered beta-particles is very common; in spite of the fact that the measurements are affected by many parameters. The scattering response is affected by changes in the source-
476
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
to-object and object-to-detector distances, geometry of object, dirt deposits, vibrations, etc. The short range of beta-particles makes them vulnerable to such changes, and may necessitate frequent calibration and or adjustment. Applications of beta-particle scattering include: monitoring of thin oil films in compressors, measurement of thin organic films on optical lenses, and measuring thickness of tin and zinc coatings on steel, of precious metals coatings on printed circuitry and of jewelry and mirror coatings [287]. Reference [237] reported the use of thickness gauging with scattered beta-particles for measuring the thickness of high quality polymer sheets for the predictability and control of layflatness in calendering, on-line measurement of thin organic films on metallic aluminum and steel substrates; and thickness measurement of glass and aluminum containers. An interesting application of beta scattering for thickness measurements is in measuring the thickness, hence strength, of an intact eggshell to determine the effect of pesticides on bird population [24]; a thinner eggshell is indicative of loss of calcium that may be due to exposure to pesticides. Reference [403] provides recommendations for the calibration of commercial backscatter instruments, the choice of electronic equipment for representation of the results, and the operation of the beta detector.
11.2.2.
Photon Transmission
Gamma transmission is also useful in thickness measurements, using the same concept discussed in section 11.1.4, provided that the material density is known. The ability of gamma-rays to penetrate deep into matter makes the technique useful for measuring a large thickness in a dense material. However, the measurement of thickness, as in the case with i the total where density measurements, is optimum when cross-section of the material at the source’s photon energy and is the
Gauging
477
thickness, see section 14.2. This limitation ensures good utilization of the source photons, by allowing a significant amount of photons (about 13.5% of those incident on the object) to reach the detector, while reducing the effect of buildup (photon scattering) on the detector [238]. source, which emits photons with an average enFor example, for a ergy of about 1.25 MeV, is equal to in steel of density of [19], allowing the measurement of a sheet of steel 47.83 mm thick. One can still apply the technique outside this optimum range, and substitute for the lost sensitivity by increasing the source strength and/or the counting time. Therefore, is used for steel thickness up and are applied to steel thickness of up to 150 mm, while to 100 mm and 10 mm, respectively [286]. Gamma-transmission was used for measuring the thickness of hot rolled strip and plate steel [286]. Reference [286] describes a device for pipe-thickness scanning consisting of a source and detector mounted on the opposite ends of an adjustable metal yoke that can be clamped gauge on the outside surface of a pipe or a vessel. An was used to monitor and control the production of rubber strips, from 3 to 40 mm in thickness [404]. Tube thinning produced by corrosion of the tubes of a heat-exchanger, inspected during plant shutdown, was also measured with gamma transmission [286]. A small gamma-source for thin tubes and for thick tubes) is inserted in one tube, while a miniature Geiger-Müller tube is introduced simultaneously in an adjacent tube so that it resides at a location opposite to that of the source. The intensity of the transmitted signal should remain constant unless corrosion thinning occurs in the tube walls between the source and detector. This method is reported to be sensitive to as low as 0.1 mm tube thinning. Although non-radiation techniques such as eddy current and ultrasonics are also used in such applications, radiation transmission offers measurements that are easy to interpret, suitable for use with any type of alloy composition, not dependent on the surface condition and can be rapidly implemented. Reference [157] described a gamma-transmission thickness measurement device that was used to determine the dimensions, shape and weight per unit length, of steel products, such as beams, rails, tubes, etc. The system consists of a triangle-like arrangement, at each edge of which a fan-shaped gamma source is located. Along each side of the triangle a bank of collimated scintillator detectors is positioned to measure the photons transmitted through an object positioned at the center of the triangle. The intensity of the transmitted radiation is used to measure the thickness of the product along the source-detector trajectory. The shape of the inspected object is determined from the dis-
478
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
tribution of the transmitted photons. The product is then moved along an axis normal to the plane of the measurement triangle to provide three-dimensional information, from which the weight per unit length can be determined. This three-beam arrangement can be viewed as a limited-projection tomography. Buildup. To overcome the effect of scattering (buildup) in transmission measurements of thick and dense objects, such as steel plates, reference [405] suggested using a total cross-section in the transmission model of Eq. (6.1) that is a function of the thickness so that:
where is the material’s total cross-section and and are positive constants that are determined experimentally. For a small thickness, in Eq. (11.3) approaches as would be expected since the buildup effect becomes negligible. As the thickness increases, the value of decreases, to compensate for the increased contribution of scattering. Divergence. In applying an exponential transmission model, such as that of Eq. (6.1), the source-to-detector distance should be kept constant, since the model ignores the divergence of the source radiation. However, divergence is inevitable even if the source is well-collimated, see section 15.1. By maintaining the source-to-detector distance constant, the amount of this divergence is kept unchanged at a fixed value. This may be difficult to attain in practice, as it is the case when scanning an irregular object. Reference [406] suggested the use of a dual-beam method, with each beam having a different energy [406]. The ratio of the two transmission measurements then eliminates the divergence effect, if the two sources utilize the same collimator. Reference [406] used (60 keV) and (81 keV) sources to measure the thickness profile of medieval weapons (sword and helmet).
11.2.3.
Photon Scattering
The photon-scattering technique described in section 11.1.4 can also be used in thickness measurements. Backscattering is particularly useful for objects that are too thick to be measured by charged-particles, but are too thin to significantly affect the intensity of transmitted photons. By choosing a source with an energy at which Compton scattering is the dominant mode of interaction in the object material, the measurement model of Eq. (7.10) becomes applicable. With a small thickness (less than one mean-free-path of the source photons) the contribution
Gauging
479
of multiple scattering becomes negligible, further validating the use of the single-scattering model of Eq. (7.10). For a certain material and a given photon source energy, and with all other source-detector parameters fixed, the intensity of the scattered radiation will depend on the thickness, via the exponential attenuation factors and of Eqs. (7.2) As the thickness increases, and (7.7), and the scattering volume, increases, but both and decrease, due to the increased attenuation. The increase in being linear, will originally dominate until the thickness becomes large enough for the attenuation effect to begin to decrease the scattering response. Since this technique is aimed at nottoo-thick objects, the source energy can be chosen, for the maximum thickness expected, so that the scattering response coincides with the ascending portion of the response curve. This simplifies the response of the device and ensures the determination of a unique thickness value system based on this principle was for a recorded measurement. A designed for measuring steel-tube wall-thickness [238]. Reference [287] reported the use of the technique to determine the thickness of a spherical steel vessel, which was thought, after ultrasonic inspection, to have developed apparent thinning, due to the presence of harmless surface interfaces created by impurities or internal crystal boundaries. Such interference would reflect prematurely ultrasonic waves, before they reach the other end of the tube wall, thus giving the mistaken impression of a reduced thickness. Photons, on the other hand, are not affected by such interfaces, and therefore give accurate determination of the thickness. Scattering measurements also enable the inspection of one side of the vessel, unlike transmission measurements which would cover both sides of the vessel. The scattering of 22 keV x-rays at an angle of 135°, showed a nearly linear relationship with wood density, over a wide range of wood densities [407]. The thickness of glass and aluminum containers was measured with backscattering using (136 keV) and (60 keV) and x-rays [408], while reference [409] reported the use of gamma scattering for concrete, carbon blocks and wood thickness-measurement. Compton scattering was also used for coal mining to provide information on the correspondence of strata in regions adjacent to boreholes and to indicate the thickness of particular coal strata and the presence of “dirt bands” within the strata [390].
11.2.4.
X-ray Emission
The X-ray fluoroscopic emission method (discussed in section 8.7) is also useful in thickness measurements. Since these emissions are isotropic, they can be monitored from the same side as the source, which makes the method particularly suited for measuring objects that are only
480
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
accessible from one side. Since x-ray fluoroscopy (XRF) requires the excitation of an atomic shell, its emission probability is highest in elements with many occupied electron orbits and high electron density, i.e. in metals. Therefore, this thickness measurement method is particularly useful for use with thin metal layers and metal coatings. XRF emission is acclaimed to be the most accurate and reliable technique to measure thin metal coatings [410]. Table 8.14 lists some of the isotopic sources that can be used for this purpose, along with the elements that they can excite. The characteristic energy of the emitted photons is used to identify the excited element, hence one can distinguish between emissions from say a coating material and a substrate. By monitoring emitted photons at these energies, one can also discriminate against source radiation that may reach the detector, as well as background radiation. The intensity of emitted x-rays can be estimated using Eq. (8.12), leading to the measurement model:
where C is the recorded count rate at the XRF energy, K is a system constant that incorporates the source intensity, system geometry and and are the attenuation-coefficients of the indetection efficiency, cident and emitted radiation, respectively, is the XRF emission total cross-section (including the emission yield), and is the thickness of the material emitting the fluorescent x-rays. The two exponential terms in Eq. (11.4) account, respectively, for the attenuation of the incident and emitted radiation before and after reaching a depth within the inspected layer, while is the probability of XRF emission within a around Emissions, if they exist, from other surrounding distance material such the substrate under a coating, does not affect the count rate, since it is recorded at an energy different from that of the material of interest. The model of Eq. (11.4), when plotted, will show an exponential increase in the count rate with thickness, to a saturation value of beyond which the count rate will be insensitive to changes in thickness. Therefore, thickness measurements have to be performed at some count rate below the saturation value. The “saturation” thickness can be taken to be equal to i.e. the thickness at which the count rate reaches about 86% of the saturation count rate. Given that metals have large total cross-sections at the low energies of excitation and emission (see Table 8.13), the measurable thickness with XRF is quite small. Also instead of monitoring the K x-rays, one can monitor the lower energy L x-rays, which further reduces the value of enabling the measurement of even smaller thickness. This method is suited for
Gauging
481
measuring thin coatings in the order of micrometers. Therefore, this method was used for measuring the thickness of chromium plates deposited on nickel and tin, cadmium and silver plates [411]. Standards for coating thickness measurement with this method are available [397], while reference [412] discusses the practicality of these standards. Double Transmission. Another approach is to monitor x-ray emissions at the XRF energies of the substrate. One would then have in effect a double-transmission system: source radiation transmitted through the coating layer, with a total cross-section of and XRF radiation transmitted in its way out through the same layer, with a transmission coefficient The measurement model for this double-transmission system would then be: where C is the recorded count rate at the energy of the substrate, is a system constant, and is the coating thickness. The model of Eq. (11.5) assumes that the substrate is a reasonably thick layer so that the XRF emission from the substrate is saturated (reached its maximum value). This method is advantageous only if the energy of XRF emission from the substrate has a lower energy than that of the coating, enabling the measurement of smaller thickness of the coating material. For example, while the K x-ray energy of tin (Sn) is 29.2 keV, that for iron (Fe) is only 7.1 keV [268]. Therefore, for tin coatings on steel, it is advantageous to use the double transmission method over the method depicted by Eq. (11.4) for measuring thin layers [411]. Note that the latter method could be used for even a smaller thickness by monitoring the L x-ray emissions from Sn, of about 4 keV, but the yield is also lower. Ratio Method. Reference [413] reported the use of the ratio between the intensities of various x-ray fluorescence lines for measuring coating thickness, using one of three options: (1) the ratio between the characteristic x-ray lines of the base (substrate); (2) the ratio between the characteristic x-ray lines of the coating; or (3) the ratio between Xradiation emitted by the base and that emitted by the coating. The last method was found to provide the best resolution for Au on Ag, while the first method may be advantageous when x-rays are difficult to detect, as in the case of a light-element coating. X-ray emission induced by a 280 keV proton beam was used for film thickness measurement of very thin layers (5 to 500 nm thick of copper platinum carbon and silicon [414]). The thicknesses of single, double, and triple layered films of Cu, Bi and Au on Mylar substrates were mea-
482
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
sured using the excitations produced by a source, to a minimum thickness of 70 nm for Cu and Bi and 40 nm for Au [415]. The attenuation of x-ray fluorescence was used to measure the thickness of layers of varnish (10 to on the inside and outside of aluminum tubes. Reference [416] described a simple and quick method for measuring thin metallic layers using a source and a proportional counter.
11.2.5.
Neutrons
Neutron absorption techniques (see chapter 9) are useful for measuring the thickness of materials of high absorption cross-section. In addition to the elements of high thermal-neutron absorption cross sections, elements that exhibit cross-section resonances in the epi-cadmium energy range of 0.5 to 2.5 eV, or so, can also be examined with neutron absorption. The suitable elements are indium, hafnium, gold, gadolinium, cadmium, europium, dysprosium, cobalt, manganese, rhodium, samarium, silver, uranium and tantalum [24]. Silver, gold, rhodium and cadmium are elements often used for coating materials. The thickness of such coatings can be determined by measuring their effect on the absorption of thermal or epi-cadmium neutrons, using any of the techniques described in chapter 9. A neutron backscattering technique, employing a moderated source and a detector, was proposed for measuring changes in wall thickness due to corrosion and scale deposits in desalination and chemical plants, for up to 50 mm in iron and more than 100 mm in concrete, aluminum and glass [417].
11.2.6.
Composition-Independent
Thickness measurement with radiation is inevitably compositiondependent, since it is affected by the material cross-section of the radiation used. When composition variations in the measured material are expected, the use of more than one measurement technique becomes necessary, in order to compensate for, or eliminate, composition dependence. An additional measurement can be obtained by using another source energy, or a different type of radiation, that interacts with the inspected material in a manner different from that of the first source. In this regard, reference [418] reported the use of a beta-source, and a or an x-ray machine, to monitor varilow-energy photon source, ation in the composition of aluminum strips, up to 2 mm in thickness. An alternative method to providing composition-independent thickness measurement is to employ two different types of indications for the same source, such as transmission and scattering. This approach was used for
Gauging
483
providing thickness measurement of aluminum strips that are independent of the alloy composition [419, 420].
11.3.
Porosity and Voidage
Porosity and Permeability. Pores are hollow passages into a solid material, or among solid particulates, that allow the passage of a fluid. Porosity and permeability are the terms used to describe the amount of available void space that permit liquids or gases to pass through. Unlike isolated void space, porosity can be measured by detecting the fluid passing through the pores. For instance, in rocks porosity can be indicated by the presence of water or other hydrogenous materials (such as oil). Therefore, porosity in well-logging is determined by measuring the hydrogen content, typically using neutron slowing-down, as explained in section 12.3. Reference [421] describes some of the basic physics of borehole logging using neutron slowing-down, for both static and dynamic measurements, while reference [422] suggested combining the measurement of thermalized neutrons with that of epithermal neutrons and prompt gamma-rays resulting from neutron activation, to improve sensitivity to porosity variation and minimize dependence on salinity. Porosity of closed structures and rock cavities can also be measured with the aid of a gaseous radiotracer, such as by measuring the amount of gas that can seep through the structure from one side to another. This method was used for determining the permeability of rock strata surrounding a hole in the center of a mountain, intended for use as a site for a rock vessel reactor [179], Note that being a rare gas, krypton is chemically inert and thus has low toxicity and low contamination risk. The permeability of rocks can also be estimated in well-logging by measuring the natural radioactivity in the formation. Clay and shale show a higher level of natural activity than sandstone and limestone, and such indication can be correlated to permeability [40, 179, 323]. Voidage. While porosity usually refers to interconnected void that allows fluid flow, voidage is any form of empty (or almost empty) space within a medium. In general, voidage represents air pockets that reduce the overall density of a material. Therefore, the void content of a certain material can be deduced by comparing its measured density (using any of the techniques of section 11.1) to the material’s nominal density. Voidage can also be viewed as a reduction in the thickness of the material that attenuates radiation. Accordingly, the thickness measurement techniques described in section 11.2 can also be used to measure the thickness of the “filling” (non-void) material, and compare the measured thickness to the apparent (geometric) thickness. For ex-
484
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
ample, gamma-ray transmission is applied to detect cavities in a rolled steel, voids between stress-ducts in concrete structures and voids in refractory lining of pipes [286]. Voidage is also measured by gamma-ray backscattering, when access to two opposite sides of the object is not possible, or when the amount of voidage is not large enough to affect a transmission signal. For example, the backscattering of photons from an source was used for the detection of voidage in foamed thermal insulation of pipes, introduced by injecting a foam mixture into a gap created around the pipe by an aluminum alloy cladding [286]. Vapor in steam and gases in multi-phase flows are also seen as void, due to their low density. Methods for measuring the void volume-fraction are discussed in section 11.5.11 and 11.5.12. A substantial proportion of free volume (void) is present in polymers, either as holes, a few tens of a nanometer in size, or larger voids due to packing irregularities [423]. The amount of free volume per gram determines the polymer’s viscosity, hence voidage is an important parameter that affects the utilization of polymers in industrial applications. The characterization of such microscopic holes is very difficult, except with positron annihilation. Positrons and in turn positroniums, see section 8.4, are trapped in holes and cavities. The lifetime of positroniums in a hole depends on the size of the hole; the larger the size, the longer the lifetime of the positronium, due to the increased isolation from the adjacent medium. Therefore, the average size of a free hole (radius if assumed spherical) can be determined from the lifetime (or decay constant) of the orthopositroniums, see section 8.4. This method was used for determining the hole size in epoxy polymers and zeolites [261]. The total fraction of the free volume can be determined from the intensity of the decayed positroniums [424]. Moreover, the shape of the decay curve is also indicative of the distribution of the free volume, which can change with pressure and temperature.
11.4.
Water (Moisture) Content
Water as moisture and wetness appears in many industrial situations. Moisture, defined here as the content of diffused or condensed liquid water, is a quantity of interest in may industrial fields. Knowing the amount of moisture in soil is important in agriculture, soil mechanics and hydrology. It is also often required to measure the moisture content of coke and sinter mix (fed to blast furnaces), clay, concrete (particularly ready-mix concrete), textiles, wool, cotton, plastics, aerosols, gases, wood chips, wood fuel, and other materials, used for manufacturing or processing industrial products. The hydrogen content is an indicator of the moisture content, when water is the dominant source of hydrogen in
Gauging
485
the material. The methods discussed in section 12.3 can then be used for measuring the moisture content. However, by using hydrogen as an indicator of moisture content, no distinction is made between free water that seeps into the material as a moisture, and bound water that is an inherent constituent of the material. Bound water is present in the crystal lattice of some minerals (such as carnallite, limonite gypsum and potash), and within the plate structure of clays [40]. If a significant amount of hydrogen is present in a form other than water, it then becomes necessary to account for the non-water hydrogen by knowing the material composition, either in advance or by some other means. In addition, strong neutron absorbers, such as chlorine, lithium and boron, will also affect the response of moisture content devices based on neutron slowing-down, as they obviously affect the neutron population and its distribution within the inspected medium. In a thin medium, a beta-particle gauge can be used, due to the increase in the attenuation coefficient of beta-particles with the atomic-to-mass number ratio, which is equal to about half for most materials and is equal to unity for hydrogen. Beta-particles were used for measuring the surface wetness of a leaf [425], the frost density distribution on the surface of a vertical pipe [426], and variations in the moisture content of a paper web [179]. Interestingly, it is reported that the intensity of natural background gamma-rays (assumed to be terrestrial gamma-rays) can be related to the moisture content of shallow soil to within ±20% accuracy [427] Reference [289] reports an interesting application of neutron gauging for the detection of water flooding into tabular-tube supports of offshore platforms. Water seepage into these tubes is usually an indication of structure flaws. The neutron-moderation method for hydrogen detection, described in section 12.3, is particularly suited for this purpose, since neutron slowing-down is hardly affected by metallic materials that are often found in these structures. Therefore, a neutron backscattering device was used for this purpose. When the tube is empty, neutron scattering would arise only from the surrounding water. This background signal can be reduced by surrounding the detector surface (except for the portion facing the tube) with cadmium to cut-off the slow-neutron scattered by the surrounding water. Then, when the tube is flooded (filled with water), a high count rate would be observed. Hydrogen as an indicator of moisture water is employed in irrigation management using the neutron slowing-down method [343, 428]. The neutron source, usually Am/Be, is positioned on the surface of the soil, while a thermal-neutron detector is lowered into a hole in the soil. The measured count rate is calibrated against the volume concentration of “free water”; with the latter defined as the water released by drying
486
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
the soil at 105°C. The relationship between the count rate and the water content is typically linear, but the sensitivity of the device, i.e. the slope of the linear curve, depends on the type of soil. The same detectorinsertion approach is used for in-situ measurement of moisture content of wood chips in piles or hoppers, and for determining the moisture in coal and coke [343]. The ratio of the intensity of the 2.223 MeV gamma-rays resulting from the capture of thermal-neutrons by hydrogen and the thermal neutron flux produced by slowing-down fast-neutrons were shown to provide good accuracy and low sensitivity to the elemental composition for measuring the hydrogen content of coal [429]. The moisture content of moulding sands in foundries was also measured with this method, under the harsh working conditions of such operations (high temperature, dust and vibrations) [24], The same reference also reported the use of the technique to control the moisture content in high grade-glasswork to an accuracy of about ±0.1 % at 3 to 5 weight percent concentration, scintillator. A portable gauge using an Am/Be source and a was also designed for the detection and measurement of water infiltration (to as low as in reinforced concrete flat roofs using the backscattering of moderated neutrons [430]. Neutron backscattering was also used to determine the moisture content of iron ore samples to within 0.5% moisture [431]. A system for measuring the moisture content in an underground nuclear waste storage facility is described in reference [432]. The system employed a source and two detectors, one located near the source and the other far from the detector, with the three housed in a core penetrameter that can be inserted into a waste tank. The ratio of the readings of the two detectors (Near/Far) was shown to be indicative of the hydrogen content in the waste. By surrounding the detectors with a thin layer of cadmium, the near-to-far ratio was less sensitive to the presence of neutron absorbing materials, since epi-cadmium (above 0.5 eV in energy) neutrons are not as vulnerable to neutron absorption as thermal-neutrons. The detectors were also shown to be quite stable under the high temperature and the high radiation levels encountered in waste tanks. Inserting a detector within a medium provides a very effective indication, since every neutron that reaches the detector would have traveled through the interrogated medium. However, when it not possible to insert an instrument within the inspected object, the detector can be located outside the object. Then, provisions must be made to minimize the direct exposure of the detector to the source neutrons, see section 17.3.3. Nevertheless, surface-mounted gauges, that include both the source and detector, have been used for measuring the moisture content in concrete
Gauging
487
and building materials, in thermal-insulation layers, in iron ore samples, in live trees, agriculture products, fireclay, plaster and lactose used in pharmaceutical products [24]. Neutron moderation was used for measuring the moisture content of blast-furnace coke [433], and the consistency and fiber density of pulpwood-water slurries [434]. Although neutron scattering and the associated slowing-down process is the most common method of moisture detection, its sphere of influence (sensitive volume) is limited to a small region around the detector’s site, due to the low total cross-section of slow-neutrons. Transmission of fast-neutrons overcomes this difficulty, since the intensity of the transmitted neutrons is also affected by the number of slowed-down neutrons, scattered and removed from the incident beam. The difficulty of fast-neutron transmission is in obtaining a well-collimated beam of fast-neutrons, since the collimation process performed with the help of a moderating material also slows-down the fast-neutrons. Collimation is essential for applying the simple exponential measurement model manifested by Eq. (6.2). Moreover, fast-neutron detectors are less efficient than slow-neutron detectors, as discussed in section 4.4. Nevertheless, neutron transmission was used for measuring, on a conveyor belt, the moisture content in a sinter mix of constant thickness (120 mm) of materials used in iron making [433]. As the measurement model of Eq. (6.2) shows, the transmission measurement is also affected by the material density, via the macroscopic cross-section and the thickness of the material traversed by the neutron beam. In materials of variable density and thickness, a concurrent gamma-transmission measurement can be used to correct for these changes, see section 6.5.3. This so called Neugat (neutron-gamma transmission) method was used for measuring the moisture content in soil and marine sediment, in coke emerging from a weight hopper in iron-processing plants or transported in a conveyor belt, in wood chips and in wheat [343]. Another interesting application of neutron slowing-down is in the measurement of snow accumulation by monitoring the slowing-down of atmospheric neutrons, produced by cosmic-ray protons. Although this neutron flux is quite low, it is measurable, (about over land [343]. The presence of snow (a neutron moderating material) increases the count rate of thermal-neutrons in a detector located at the snow level, due to the scattering and subsequent slowing-down of the atmospheric neutrons. Via the same process, the snow layer will shield a detector located at the ground surface from the atmospheric neutrons. Then, the combined relative change of the thermal flux at two locations, one below the snow layer and the other above it, becomes indicative of the thickness of the snow layer in between the two locations. The ratio
488
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
is indicative of the thickness of the snow layer [343]: where C refers to the count rate of the detector above the snow layer, G, to that below the snow layer and the subscripted variables refer to the count rate recorded at the same detector locations in the absence of the snow. This measurement method is useful for remote monitoring of snow covers in isolated areas, with the recorded count rate continually transmitted via satellite or radio signals. It is also worth noting that reference [435] pointed out that rainfall results in a significant reduction in the number of atmospheric neutrons recorded from 3 m above the ground to 0.40 m underground. It was also noticed that the recovery time to the initial neutron flux, before rainfall, depended on the soil’s moisture content, offering the possibility of remotely and passively measuring soil moisture following rainfall with neutron counting. Gamma-transmission was also used for measuring the moisture content in soil samples. Water resides in the void (pores) of the soil, and the maximum amount of water in soil is that which fills the pores, i.e. saturates the soil. The saturation level, S, is defined as the volume of water, to the volume of void in the soil, that is:
where M and V refer, respectively, to mass and volume, is the void volume fraction, is the nominal density of water and is the “apparent” (or bulk) density of water in soil. The latter density is what determines the degree of attenuation of a gamma-ray beam passing through a sample, which in accordance to the transmission model of Eq. (6.1), and making use of Eq. (11.6), can be written as:
where I is the intensity of the beam passing through a sample of thickness is the total cross-section per unit mass of water, is the intensity of the beam when it passes through a dry sample, i.e. at S = 0, and is a calibration constant that depends on the source energy, soil type and porosity and the sample thickness. Gamma-transmission is particularly suited for measuring the moisture content in a limited volume of soil and in soil columns [436, 437], a process that is difficult to accomplish with neutrons due to the small amount of moderating material. To overcome the dependency of measurements
Gauging
489
on the compactness of the soil sample, a dual-energy gamma-ray transmission method was suggested for measuring the water content in soil tubes [438]. For a sample of constant thickness, the transmission of highsource) provides an indication of energy photons (662 keV from a the mass-density (as Compton scattering dominates), while the transmission of low-energy photons (60 keV from is sensitive to the atomic-number due to the photoelectric effect. The effect of density on the transmission of low-energy photons can then be accounted for using the transmission of high-energy photons, resulting in an indication that is a function of the composition of the soil/water mixture. Thus for a given soil type, and a known transmission thickness, the water content can be estimated. A method for measuring moisture in radioactive wastes was proposed in reference [439], using the scattering of neutrons from a source (Am/Be, inserted into the medium. Subsequent thermalization Pu/Be or causes the activation of a copper probe. Counting the gamma-rays emitted from activated (12.7 h half-life) becomes then indicative of the amount of neutron slowing-down, hence hydrogen content. Copper replaces conventional neutron detectors that are overwhelmed by the high gamma-radiation of the nuclear waste. Such measurements are not, however, real-time, since the activated copper needs to be removed from the inspected medium to measure its activation.
11.5.
Measurements in Fluid Flow
Fluids in the form of liquids, molten materials, and gases of various compounds are encountered in many industrial applications. Measurement of parameters pertaining to the physical properties of these liquids and gases are often required. Although many conventional techniques are available for performing such measurements, most of these methods are intrusive, require direct contact with the flow container, or cannot function in the presence of thick metallic walls associated with highpressure systems. Radiation techniques overcome these difficulties by enabling the performance of non-contact measurements. Thus radiation methods can be the only viable choice for measurements at high pressure and temperature and in harsh industrial environments; although in large vessels it may be necessary to introduce the source, and/or the detector, within the vessel, if the vessel diameter is too large to allow for external inspection. This section shows that many fluid-related properties are measured with radiation methods.
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
490
11.5.1.
Density
The density of a fluid or a gas is a fundamental quantity in fluid and gas dynamics. The density of a fluid varies with temperature and pressure, or when phase transformation (e.g. from liquid to gas) occurs. The density measurement techniques discussed in section 11.1 can be applied to fluids. However, measurements under flow conditions often require rapid sampling, necessitating sometimes the use of detectors that can function in the current mode (see section 4.5) when conventional pulsecounting methods are not statistically adequate. The penetrability of gamma-rays and the direct relationship between their Compton scattering cross-section and density makes them particularly useful for measuring fluids in pipes and vessels. Therefore, the gamma-transmission method is used for measuring the density of a fluid in a pipe, usually by transmitting source photons across the cross-section of the pipe, in a device known as the gamma densitometer [440]. The source and detector fields-of-view should cover the entire section of the pipe to provide a representative indication of the bulk density of the fluid in the pipe. Reference [441] also proposed the use of a wide (strip) source that covers the entire cross-sectional area of the pipe, along with a set of collimated detectors that measure the transmitted radiation. By collimating the source into a pencil beam, and confining the detector field-of-view to receive this beam upon transmission through a pipe or a vessel (so that the contribution of scattered photons is minimized), one can scan the flow to obtain a profile of the density distribution in the vessel. Reference [179] reported the use of gamma-transmission in the petroleum refining industry to distinguish between various grades of oil; determine the concentration of dissolved gases in liquid; detect condensation in different parts of steam boiler; and to measure the particle concentration in fluidized beds, and the concentration of sodium hydroxide in caustic-soda evaporators. Gamma-transmission is also used for the detection, by density changes, of frothing and foaming, liquidliquid interfaces, bubbling and gas slugs [286]. The same reference describes in some detail a nonintrusive radiation transmission method for scanning distillation columns (which can vary in diameter from 0.3 to 8 m) to measure the density profile of a column along its length, using or sources. Such measurements are useful for ensuring that the column’s metallic components are in their proper place and none is missing, for the detection of undesirable foaming or flooding, and for overall confirmation that the liquid and vapor phases in the columns are distributed as required by design. When access to two opposite sides of a pipe or a vessel is not available, and it is not permitted to insert a source or a detector inside the fluid
Gauging
491
enclosure, gamma-scattering measurements become handy. For example, the scattering of high-energy photons, extracted from a reactor was used for dynamic density measurement of boiling water [442], while in situ density measurement in aqueous solutions was performed by the gamma backscattering method [443]. Thermal-expansion coefficient. Density measurements can be used to determine the thermal-expansion coefficient, defined as:
where V is the volume of a material of mass T is its temperature and is its density. According to Eq. (11.8), by measuring the density of material at different temperatures, the value of can be obtained. This method was used to measure the thermal-expansion coefficient for a light oil contained in a vessel at high pressure (13.8 MPa), with the aid of a gamma densitometer [444].
11.5.2.
Flow-Rate by Radiotracers
The mass flow-rate, W, is defined as:
where refers to mass, to time, to density, A to flow area, to distance along flow direction, is mean fluid velocity, and is the volumetric flow rate. The expression of Eq. (11.9) assumes that the liquid is moving in one direction at a constant speed and density, at least within the measurement time. With the flow assumed to be constant and equal to the area of the duct within which a fluid moves, the mass-flow measurement is reduced to a measurement of density and velocity. While density measurements can be conducted as discussed in section 11.5.1, velocity measurement are more difficult to perform non-intrusively. However, radiotracers can be used for this purpose. Although radiotracer-based flow measurements are more accurate than other methods, their non-continuous nature prevents their use in routine measurements. Therefore, they are mainly used to verify or calibrate measurements obtained with conventional methods, or when it is not possible to employ a conventional device. 11.5.2.1 Pulse Timing The most straightforward method for flow measurement involves the injection of a pulse (over a short period of time) of a suitable radioactive
492
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
material at some point in the system, and monitoring the arrival of radioactivity at two different positions separated by some distance downstream from the injection point. As the radiotracer arrives at the first point of detection, the amount of radioactivity emitted from the tracer will rise as the radiotracer approaches the detector, reaching a maximum, at time when the radioactive material is closest to the detector, then it would fall as the radioactivity travels. The same trend will develop at the second detector, but at some later time, Then, the mean velocity, is simply estimated as: Alternatively, one detector can be used, if the pulse injection time is measured. This simple method is suited for turbulent flows, where good mixing of the injected tracer occurs. The detector has also to be placed at some distance from the injection point to allow the mixing process to fully develop. This method is known as the pulse velocity, or peak-to-peak, method. Reference [445] reported the use of this pulse-timing method for measuring the flow rate in feed-water lines of boilers flow to the absorption unit of an adipic-acid2 plant sulfuric acid flow in the reticulation system of an alkalination plant natural gas flow and in flow gas distribution systems the rain pipelines dioisotope employed is given in brackets. Radiotracers were used for measuring the inlet and outlet flows in pulp and paper mills [179].
11.5.2.2
Total Count
Instead of timing the signal, the detector integrated count rate can be used as flow-rate indicator. A detector monitors radiation emitted from a certain volume, V, of the flow. The counts registered by the detector depend on the time spent by the radiotracer within the volume V, assuming that the radiotracer is detected after it has been fully mixed to a certain concentration level. The time, the radiotracer spends that within V is in turn inversely proportional to the fluid’s velocity is, the slower the flow, the more chance the radiotracer has to register a count in the detector. Therefore, the inverse of the time-integrated count rate of the detector becomes indicative of the flow rate. Since no timing measurement is required, this total count method does not require a sharp pulse, as in the case of the peak-to-peak method. The gas flow-rate in chemical processes and steam flow as tritiated water) were measured by the total-count method.
2
Adipic acid,
is a crystal used in the manufacturing of nylon.
Gauging
11.5.2.3
493
Constant-Rate Injection
The pulsing approach can be replaced altogether by continuous injection of the radiotracer. If a radiotracer of a known specific activity (activity per unit volume of the flow material), is introduced into the flow system, through an injection line, at a known volumetric flow rate of it will generate activity at a rate of If there is no leak in the system, there is no reason for the activity to change. However, when the radiotracer enters the system, it will be transported at a volumetric flow rate of where is the flow rate of the fluid. Then, the specific activity of the radiotracer will be reduced to Since and are controlled and known, by measuring the specific activity in the flow material, one can determine its volumetric flow rate, The specific activity of the flow material can be determined by withdrawing a sample, of a certain volume, at a position sufficiently away from the point of injection, and recording the count rate it produces in a detector. Many samples can be analyzed, either to improve the accuracy of measurements, or to detect changes in the flow rate. The volumetric flow rate, is related to the mass Thus, if the fluid’s density, flow rate, W, by the density, is known, or is measured separately, then, W can be determined from This is easier than calculating W using the fluid velocity, since the latter requires knowing the flow area, A, as Eq. (11.9) indicates. Therefore, this so-called constant-rate injection method is suited for applications in which the flow area changes, or is not known. The method is, therefore, suitable for use in containers of irregular geometries, and in open channels and rivers (where a sample can be withdrawn easily for counting) [445]. Under steady state conditions, the radiotracer can be injected only over a limited amount of time, and the method becomes known as the dilution method. Using the dilution method was used to study the fate of contaminants released into the flooded Magela Creek system in Northern Territory of Australia as a consequence of nearby uranium mining operations [446]. The method was also used to measure the efficiency of aluminum-reduction furnaces using [352, 447], and for measuring the flow in water turbines [179]. The constant-rate injection method was also utilized for measuring the water flow rate during the acceptance and performance testing of cooling water pumps in fossil-fired power plants and in the turbine of hydroelectric power stations [348]. The constant-rate injection method was applied to the measurement of organic liquid flowing from a stock tank to calibrate an orifice meter as para-dibromobenzene); effluent discharge from chemical plants to the environment; and gas flow rate in chemical processes [445].
494
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
The method was also utilized in measuring the flow of cooling water in oil refineries [179]
11.5.3.
Gas Flow-Rate by Ionization
The ionization of a gas can be used to measure its flow rate, with the aid of an ionization chamber, see section 9.1. The essence of the method is that a moving gas will remove some of the gas molecules from the domain of the applied electric field, hence reduce the magnitude of the ionization current. The higher the rate of removal, the less time the gas atoms will be exposed to radiation, the lower the ionization current. Therefore, the ionization current decreases as the flow rate increases. However, if the flow rate is too high, so that most of the ions are carried away, or if number of gas atoms ionized is not sufficient, or if the ionization process is too slow to be affected by the movement of the gas, then it may be difficult to obtain measurable indications of the flow rate. The flow rate of the gas must be within an order of magnitude of the velocity of the ions in the electric field [24]; though the latter can be controlled by the magnitude of the applied field. Note, however, that the pressure and temperature of the gas must also be taken into account, as they affect the ionization current, since they affect the gas density, hence the ionization cross-section, defined in Eq. (9.1). Flow rate measurements in pipes can be accomplished by mounting a source of alpha-particles on the inner surface of the tube, held at a positive voltage, with an ammeter connected by wire coaxially mounted on the outside surface of the tube [24]. Alternatively, a source of beta-particles (which is more penetrating than an alpha-particle source) can be mounted on the outside of the pipe, and pulsed with the aid of a movable shutter. The arrival of the ionized atoms at two different stations downstream of the beta-particle source can be monitored with the aid of two pairs of electrodes mounted inside the pipe, with each pair recording a current pulse. The time delay between these two pulses is inversely proportional to the flow rate of the gas [24].
11.5.4.
Flow-Rate by Pulsed-Neutron Activation
The flow rate of a fluid can be measured by activating the fluid material with a short pulse of neutrons and detecting the gamma radiation emitted from the activated nuclei at a known distance downstream from the activation point. Pulsed 14 MeV neutrons are suited for this purpose, as they produce in oxygen-containing fluids (such as water) high-energy photons by the reaction: with the product nuclei decaying with a 7.32 s half-life and giving rise to 6.13 MeV gammas. For
Gauging
495
molten fluids containing sodium, 14 MeV neutrons induce the reaction with the latter nucleus emitting 1.633 MeV gamma as it decays with a 11.0 s half-life. The number of photons detected, C, within a period of time, is related to the flow rate by the relationship:
where is the number per unit time of fluid nuclei of velocity activated by the source neutrons at is the decay-constant of the activated element, is the probability that the nuclei of the activated element will decay before reaching the detection volume, and P is the probability that the decaying nuclei are present in the detection volume within the counting period, If the detection volume has a thickness along the direction of the flow velocity, then P can be estimated as:
The measured velocity can then be related to the average velocity, hence the flow rate. References [158] and [448] provide more comprehensive measurement modeling and analysis of this flow measurement method, while references [449] and [450] discuss the application of this method for flow measurement in sodium and water. The applicability of the technique to two-phase flow measurements is addressed in references [451], [452] and [453]. The technique has also been used to monitor and measure the water flow behind and in wellbore casings, for mechanicalintegrity testing of water injection and disposal wells [454]. Pulsed photon activation, using high-intensity gamma-rays produced from the bremsstrahlung target of an electron linear accelerator [455] can also be used in flow measurements. Photons with an energy greater than 15.7 MeV result in the reaction which can be used to tag oxygen in a water flow. The decay of (122 half-life) produces a positron, which annihilates generating two 511 keV photons, emitted in opposite directions. Monitoring the arrival time of these annihilation photons downstream of the activation location enables the calculation of the speed, hence flow rate, of the water (or boiling water).
11.5.5.
Level Measurement
The measurement of fluid level in a tank or a container is one of the most common applications of radiation gauging. Although other conventional methods of level measurement are available, the non-contact and continuous nature of radiation methods makes them attractive for
496
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
on-line and harsh-environment applications. A number of measurement arrangements are possible, as schematically shown in Figure 11.2. Each of these configurations is discussed below. 11.5.5.1
Photon Transmission
Gamma-ray transmission is the method commonly used in level measurements, since they have the ability to penetrate large tanks, and because it is easy to interpret the indications of the transmission modality. The most common setup is the transverse arrangement (beam parallel to fluid level, Figure 11.2.a), which involves sending a radiation beam horizontally from one side of the tank and receiving the radiation with a detector on the other side of the tank, at the same elevation. If radiation passes through the air (or gas-layer, if any) on the top of the fluid in the tank, a strong transmission measurement would be recorded, otherwise the detector would register a lower count rate as it passes through the fluid. The source-detector assembly can be located at one position for level monitoring purposes, i.e. to determine whether fluid level is above or below a certain value. The transverse transmission measurement is essentially a binary measurement that distinguishes between high or low intensities. Therefore, the count rate obtained from a simple detector, such as Geiger-Müller tube, can be used, which reduces the cost of the device due to the simplicity of the associated electronics. However, if the fluid level is to be monitored at various levels across the tank, many transmission measurements have to be taken at different elevations. Then, the elevation at which the count rate increases to the level corresponding to an empty space determines the level of the fluid in the tank. This is a tedious process, if performed with a one source-detector set. Not only because many measurements need to be taken, but also because proper alignment of the source and the detector, to be at the same elevation, can be difficult, particularly for level measurement in large tanks. A motorized mechanism can be used to move both the source and detector to the different measurement stations, while maintaining their alignment. Alternatively, many source/detector assemblies can be employed. However, if a fan-shaped beam is used, with a width it will cover a larger area of the tank. By blocking the top half angle and placing a long detector, or a set of of the fan beam (from 0 to detectors, opposite to this source, on the other side of tank, the transmission of the other half of the beam (from 0 to can be monitored. Then, the fluid level can be monitored simultaneously over a wider range of levels. Typically the angle is less than 20° [286], since for fan beams wider than this, the distance of travel across the tank, along with the
Gauging
497
498
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
increased divergence of the source photons (see section 3.6.2), would weaken significantly the strength of the transmitted signal. Transverse transmission is used for level measurement in chemical plant vessels [286]; for example to determine the catalyst bed-level in the columns of amines and methanol plants, and to measure the rate of catalyst attrition (to determine whether recharging or regeneration of the catalyst is required). To avoid the complications of the transverse-transmission technique, longitudinal (beam normal to fluid level, Figure 11.2.b) transmission can be performed, say by placing the source at the bottom of the tank (if possible) and the detector at its top. In this arrangement, the source and detector can be fixed in place, ensuring proper alignment, and the liquid level can be continuously monitored. However, the response of the detector will change as the fluid level varies, as demonstrated schematically in Figure 11.2.b. This requires the intensity of the transmitted radiation to be quantified with the aid of a measurement model. Due to the large amount of fluid usually involved in such measurement, the simple model of transmission represented by Eq. (6.1) is not usually adequate, since it is inevitable that scattered radiation would reach the detector. Therefore, the model of Eq. (6.5), which includes the buildup factor should be applied for the longitudinal-transmission technique. Alternatively, a calibration curve for the change of the transmission intensity with fluid level should be established. The build-up factor itself also requires calibration measurements. Reference [456] suggested the use of the attenuation of the intensity of cosmic rays (above 3 MeV to eliminate gamma-rays from natural environmental nuclides) to measure levels in very large storage tanks, and to determine the height of snow piles. 11.5.5.2 Photon Scattering Gamma-ray backscattering can also be used for level measurement. This offers a one-side measurement that does not require access to two opposite sides of the container, and does not require a very strict alignment process. The device can also be manufactured in a single package containing the source and the detector, for portability and mobility. The alignment in scattering is not that crucial, since as schematically demonstrated in Figure 11.2.c, the detector measures radiation scattered by the fluid, when present, at various locations. The response of the detector will tend to be constant as long as its field-of-view within the tank is completely filled with liquid. As the source approaches a location near the top level of the fluid, some of the source photons will escape prior to encountering any scattering with liquid, the detector’s field-o-view will also be partially occupied by the air (or gas if present) on top of
Gauging
499
the fluid. Of course, as the source is moved away into positions corresponding to the voided portion of the tank, the detector response will drop quickly to the background level, since it will only receive photons scattered by the wall of the tank and the surrounding shielding, and if close to the liquid top, by radiation reflected by the liquid. Due to this gradual change in response, exact determination of the liquid level may not be possible, but a good indication can be obtained with prior calibration of the device. For non-hydrogenous liquids, such as chlorine gamma-ray backscattering is used for or titanium tetrachloride level measurement, as an alternative to gamma-ray transmission [287]. Gamma-ray backscattering was also used to monitor on-line continuous flow of the feed to a blast furnace [179]. Although this gamma-ray backscattering method is quite attractive for the reasons discussed above, it has a fundamental drawback that limits it applicability: scattering emerges from a small volume (domain of influence) around the detector. This limited inspection-volume is attributed to the fact that photons scatter in all directions, and the scattered photons have a lower energy than the source radiation, as such very few photons scattered deep inside the container will reach the detector. While this limited domain-of-influence makes the response independent of the vessel diameter, if the latter is larger than the domain of influence, it has some important implications. First, the monitored volume may not be representative of the overall situation in the container, if the liquid distribution is not uniform, e.g. if a flow vortex or an obstruction in the medium elevates the liquid in the vicinity of the device. Secondly, if the container has a thick metallic wall, the wall’s contribution can be quite significant compared to that of the liquid, because of the high density, hence high scattering probability of metals. For instance, for source, 622 keV photons, a steel wall (density of a 10 mm thick would represent the equivalent of 78.6 mm of liquid water at atmospheric pressure density). This obviously reduces the sensitivity of the device. Thermal insulation materials, if present, can also occupy a significant portion of the inspection volume. Although it has a low density, thermal insulation displaces, in effect, the device’s domain of influence. For a 662 keV photons, gamma-ray backscattering becomes practically “blind” to level changes at steel thickness of 32 mm, or a thermal insulation 50 mm thick [287]. Elevating the photon energy, say by using a source, increases the size of the domain of influence of the device, but this comes at the expense of increased divergence of the scattered photons due to increased distance from the collisions sites to the detector (see section 3.6.2). Another problem with using a source with higher energy is the increased shielding requirement
500
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
for both biological purposes and for protecting the detector from direct exposure to the source photons, which increases the size and weight of the device. Neutron backscattering is a more practical way to overcoming the limitations of gamma-ray backscattering, in hydrogenous liquids. 11.5.5.3
Neutron Scattering
Utilizing a neutron source in the system configuration of Figure 11.2.c enables the performance of level measurements using backscattering with all the advantages mentioned in section 11.5.5.2. In addition, neutrons can accommodate thicker metallic walls; up to 130 mm of steel under ideal conditions and practically up to 40 mm thickness [287]. This neutron technique is mainly used with hydrogenous liquids, since it functions by monitoring the slowing-down of fast-neutrons. Therefore, a fastneutron source, such as or Am/Be, is used in conjunction with a thermal-neutron detector or While the hydrogen in the liquid effectively slows-down the neutrons, see section 3.5, the metal hardly affects the energy of the neutrons. Theretofore, the metallic walls of the container have very small effect on the detected neutrons, except that a thick wall effectively occupies a larger portion of the device’s domain of influence, reducing its sensitivity to the presence of the liquid as mentioned in section 11.5.5.2. The presence of a thick thermal-insulation material has also a similar effect. In addition, hydrogen that may be present in the texture of the insulating material, or when the material is wet, can affect the response of the device by giving a false appearance of the presence of liquid. Applications of this technique include measuring the liquid level of liquid ammonia in railway tankers and other vessels carrying hazardous hydrogenous materials; the liquid level in the shell-side of a heat exchanger; and the liquid level in the downcomers of a distillation column [287], particularly during accident emergencies. A continuous neutron backscattering level gauge was also developed for the level measurement of hydrogenous, as well as non-hydrogenous materials (for solid and liquid levels) [431]. In the latter case, although no-significant number of neutrons would be slowed-down, a good number of neutrons would scatter back as fast neutrons. When the device faces a voided space, the response of the detector would decrease due to the lack of a scattering medium. A neutron-scattering device in a nonhydrogenous medium would, therefore, function as a density indicator, in the same fashion as a gamma-ray scattering system. 11.5.5.4
Radioactive Media
For radioactive material in a vessel (such as fission products in solution), a level gauge consisting only of a radiation detector can be used.
Gauging
501
Reference [457] indicated that the detector can be located at the top of the container, but in containers of small diameter-to-height ratio, the detector should be located within the tank along its axis. In very large diameter-to-height ratio containers, it is advantageous to locate an additional detector along its off-center axis. Reactor Level. The liquid level in the pressure vessel of a nuclear reactor (liquid cooled) can also be measured by the effect of radiation on detectors embedded within the vessel, or even detectors located outside the reactor core. Reference [458] demonstrated that the response of a cadmium-covered gas-filled fission chamber located at different elevations outside the reactor core is sensitive to voiding in the upper portion of a pressurized-water reactor. The number of fastneutrons escaping the reactor tend to increase as the water level in the core decreases, due to the lower density of the vapor. Fast-neutrons have a higher probability of leaking from the reactor, than thermal neutrons, and thus provide a better indication of the condition of the core. The response of in-core neutron detectors in water-cooled reactors also changes significantly when the detectors cease to be covered with liquid water, due to the corresponding decrease in neutron collisions, hence neutron flux, around the detector. Therefore, such in-core detectors can be used to determine the liquid level in a reactor vessel during a loss-of-coolant accident [459]. Gamma-radiation inside a reactor core also deposits energy in metals, causing their temperature to increase. This allows the use of gamma-ray calorimetry to monitor conditions within the reactor. The calorimeter is simply a steel rod, equipped with thermocouples along its axis. When the rod is inserted inside a reactor vessel, a certain temperature profile will be established along the rod axis, as long as the rod is fully immersed in water. The temperature profile is recorded electronically. When part of the rod becomes uncovered, i.e. exposed to steam, the temperature of the corresponding thermocouples will increase due to the poor cooling by the steam. The position of these thermocouples will then be indicative of the liquid level [460]. Note, however, a mixture of steam and water provides good cooling, lowering the temperature of the corresponding thermocouples. A similar concept used a heated junction thermocouple, adjacent to another unheated junction, with the two enclosed in a common sheath [461]. The two thermocouples are enclosed in the same sheath and electrically connected to record their temperature difference, which is indicative of the heat-transfer coefficient of the surrounding medium. In the presence of liquid, the good heat-transfer between the two junctions will keep their temperature difference small. On the other
502
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
hand, when the sensor becomes uncovered, the temperature difference will increase due to the poor heat-transfer of steam. In addition, the temperature of the unheated thermocouple acts as a calorimeter.
11.5.6.
Liquid-Liquid Interface
Liquids interface with each other in vessels, atop each another, or in pipelines one following the other. When the two interfacing liquids differ significantly in density, one of the density measuring techniques described in section 11.1 can be used to detect their interface. Gamma-radiation is usually employed because of its high penetrability. The gamma-transmission method for density determination, see section 11.1.4, can be employed for this purpose. Transmission measurements can be performed intrusively, if the size of the flow-container and its wall thickness and density are not prohibitively large to the extent that they suppress the passage of a detectable amount of radiation within a reasonable counting time. This method was employed for detecting the interface between a sweeping liquid propane and a denser mixture of carbon products in a 100 mm pipeline, to enable segregation of the two products at the end of the line [286]. Alternatively, in a large vessel, the source, or both the source and detector, can be gradually inserted inside the vessel. This internal gamma-transmission setup was used for monitoring the density profiles of packed-bed reactors (with an inserted source) and for the measurement of silt densities of lakes and rivers (with an inserted fork carrying the source and the detector at opposite ends) [286]. Gamma-ray backscattering was also employed in well logging, where a compact device containing the source and the detector (separated by a shield) is driven up and down inside a well to locate the interface between liquids in underground storage cavities containing various materials [287]. The gamma source (83.79 d half-life, and 0.889 and 1.120 MeV), activated in a nuclear reactor in the form of scandium oxide, is usually preferred for use in well-logging. The relatively high energy of the source gives a reasonably large distance of penetration, so that it provides a density averaged over a reasonable volume, while its short-half life is a safety feature; in the event that the source is lost within the well. When the two interfacing liquids are similar in density, as may be the case with hydrocarbon products, the change in their elemental content can be used to distinguish between the two liquids. The hydrogencontent measuring methods discussed in section 12.3 can be used for this purpose. For example, the interface between an aqueous (mainly water) and organic water in an effluent holding tank in a plastics manufacturing plant was measured with the aid of the neutron backscattering method
Gauging
503
described in section 12.3.1 [289]. The same reference reported the use of the technique to detect the interface between oil and water in a separator vessel, employing an array of neutron sources and detectors spanning a height of about 450 mm. Gamma-ray transmission, with a source, was also applied to the interzone-layer separating two fluids in an extraction tower, by taken advantage of the density gradient between the two separated fluids at the top and bottom of the tower [462]. Another interesting interface measurement is that utilized to determine the brine/product interface in underground cavities used to store chemicals, such as ethylene, propylene, natural gas and nitrogen. These cavities are typically formed in underground salt layers, about 0.5 km deep, by brine extraction (solution mining). The position of the interface between the brine and the product changes as the product is introduced into or extracted from the cavity. Compton scattering was used to determine this interface by lowering a probe, consisting of a gamma-source, and a gamma detector, and measuring the backscattered photons [287]. An abrupt change in the amount of detected photons is indicative of the presence of an interface due to the change in density of the surrounding medium. Neutron backscattering for level measurement, see section 11.5.5.3, which mainly depends on the hydrogen content, can be used to detect the interface between two liquids with different hydrogen content. For example, the method has been used to monitor the interface between an aqueous solution and an organic liquid in an effluent holding tank and an oil-water separator in a plastic manufacturing operation [287].
11.5.7.
Leak Detection
Radiotracers are the obvious choice for leak detection of fluids, as they can follow the movement of the fluid and determine its flow rate, as explained in section 11.5.2. Under steady-state conditions, the flow rate remains the same at any location along the flow stream. Therefore, by measuring the flow rate at any two points along the flow one can detect any flow imbalance, which can be indicative of the presence of a leak. Also by injecting a radiotracer upstream of an isolation valve, or a relief valve, and determining the flow rate past the valve (which should be zero), any leakage through the valve can be detected and the rate of leakage can be determined. However, the most direct way for leakage detection by radiotracers is to detect the presence of the radiotracer outside the flow system. The radiotracer accompanying the leaked fluid will produce radioactivity outside the flow system. Such radioactivity will be concentrated in a location close to the point of leakage. Therefore,
504
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
the presence of this radioactivity and its location enable the detection of a leak and the determination of its position. Reference [463] discussed a number of case histories in industrial installations in which radiotracers were utilized for lead detection. The (gas), (776.5 keV main gamma radiotracers used included and 35.3 h half-life) in the form of p-dibromobenzene or potassium bromide or ammonium bromide, as a sodium carbonate, and as a tritiated water. Note that is a beta-particle emitter, thus its radiation has limited penetrability, but is can be detected in a flow sample. Argon-41 was also used to find out whether heat exchangers in a nitric acid plant were leaking [464], by injecting a radiotracer at the inlet of the high pressure side of the exchangers and placing detectors at the outlet of the low pressure side (assuming that argon behaves the same way as the process medium). Reference [463] reported the use of radiotracers produced by neutron activation of In, V, Co, Mn and I, elements that were present in a water draining system; these radiotracers were also detected by sampling. Sealed components can be tested for leakage by exposing them externally to a radioactive gas, such as then removing the component away from the exposure and testing them for the presence of radioactivity, which would be then indicative of poor sealing. This concept was used for inspecting hermetically sealed components, such as valves, for gas-tightness [179]. Leak detection is also useful in studying ventilation systems, particularly those designed to carry hazardous gases. By monitoring the radioactivity emitted from the radiotracer, the flow passages of the ventilation system can be determined and any undesirable leakage can be found. Reported applications of radiotracers include studying the flow of gases in coal mines [179], and testing the ventilation system of a newly constructed unit producing a highly toxic chemical [277]. Moreover, in a closed system, the renewal time of ventilation gas can be measured by inserting a pulse of radioactivity and measuring the time it takes to return to the point of origin. The latter was used for determining the renewal time of air in laboratories and houses with the aid of krypton and xenon isotopes, and in metallurgical heat treatment furnaces [179]. 11.5.7.1
Buried Pipelines
Leaks in underground pipelines can be detected by injecting into them a radiotracer and measuring the presence of radioactivity in the adjacent soil medium. This can be done either by sampling of material from the soil and subsequent off-site counting, or by direct monitoring of radioactivity. Pulsed injection of the radiotracer is often used for leak detection. However, it is also possible to utilize continuous leak detection
Gauging
505
for continual monitoring of leakage. Continuous injection can also be useful for locating buried pipelines by monitoring the radioactivity on the surface of the ground. In addition, leak detection under no-flow (static) conditions is also possible, by filling under pressure the pipeline with a liquid or a gas containing the radiotracer then draining it after allowing some time for the radiotracer to seep through any holes or cracks to the adjacent soil medium. For a large leak due to a broken pipe, tracing the radiation emitted from a sealed source mounted on a sealed floating ‘pig’ can determine the location of the leak as the ‘pig’ will stop when there is no flow in the pipe after the break. For buried pipelines containing a radiotracer, the measured activity at the ground surface would be maximum at locations directly perpendicular to the pipeline and would drop rapidly, due to radiation attenuation and divergence, as the detector moves laterally away from the pipeline, unless their is a leak. In the presence of a leak, the level of radioactivity would become high at locations away from the direct location on the surface of the ground above the pipeline, because the radiotracer is no longer confined within the pipe walls but would disperse, along with leaked fluid, in the surrounding ground. In order for radiation to be able to penetrate soil and reach the ground surface, it must have a large penetration ability, while at the same time it should have a short half-life so that the leaked radiation decays quickly, leaving no adverse effect on the environment. is often used [463], as it emits high-energy Therefore, a source like (2.754 MeV) photons and has a half-life (15 h) that is long enough for practical use but is short enough to decay within a reasonable period of time. Another useful source is which emits, as indicated in Table 2.17, several high energy gamma-rays, but its half life of 2.58 h limits its usefulness to shorter pipelines. Also, (2.168 and 1.643 MeV gamma, 37.24 min half-life) is a useful radiotracer for tracking leakage in water mains [179]). For gas tracers, though mainly a beta-particle source, see Table 2.2, also emits gamma-rays in the keV range (mainly 151.2 and 304.9 keV, 4.480 h half-life). Other suitable gases are: (a beta emitter with 5.243 d half-life, useful for sample analysis), in the form of methyl bromide, radon 458, 571, 649 keV gamma, 2.4 h half-life) and (1.294 MeV gamma, 109.34 min half-life) [179]. Aside from the obvious advantage of being able to use krypton as a tracer with gas flows, it also enables the inspection of dry pipes. As a gas, argon can seep through the soil to the ground surface faster than a liquid, allowing a quicker inspection time [463]. For a
source, the total cross-section is about 4.15 × which results in a macroscopic cross-section of for a soil density of Assuming an exponential attenuation
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
506
(that is ignoring the effect of buildup by scattering, see section 6.1), then a distance of 0.86 m will attenuate the radiation to Beyond this distance, for practical purposes, the intensity of the source can be considered to have been fully attenuated. Therefore, depending on soil conditions, the maximum depth of burial of pipelines beyond which the radiation emitted from a radiotracer can be detected is about one meter. At a deeper depth of burial, the radiation detector will need to be inserted in boreholes at some selected locations. An alternative approach is to monitor the radioactivity internally by installing a detector on a ‘pig’ carried by the flow, and sending the recorded measurement by telemetry. By introducing the ‘pig’ into the flow stream, some time after the injection of a radioactive solution [463], the detector would only register a high count rate if it encounters residual radioactivity deposited in the adjacent soil due to fluid leakage. The position of the ‘pig’ along the flow stream where the high count rate is registered defines the location of the leak, such position can be determined electronically (say using a global positioning signal), or mechanically, if the ‘pig’ is cable-driven into the pipe (say by a crane).
11.5.8.
Volume
In regularly shaped vessels, the volume of liquid in the vessel can be inferred from a level measurement, see section 11.5.5. However, when access to the container is not possible, or when the enclosure has a complex geometry (e.g. due to internal intrusions), or when it consists of many interconnected volumes, then the dilution of radiotracers is a powerful technique for volume measurement. The principle of volume determination is based on the conservation of mass, i.e. the mass of the radiotracer. If a radiotracer of measured total activity, is added of the same type of liquid contained in the to a known volume, vessel, it will result in a concentration of Now, if this injected radiotracer is allowed to mix well with a liquid of unknown volume, V, in the vessel, conservation of mass will dilute the concentration of the radiotracer to a value C such that: By taking a sample of volume, of the liquid from the vessel and measuring an activity, say one can determine the diluted concentration Then the unknown volume V can be calculated as For statistical validation, the measurements should be taken over more than one sample. Applications of this radiotracer-balance method for volume determination include: the measurement of inventory of mercury in chlorineisotope (279 keV gamma, 46.41 days); producing cells using an
Gauging
507
the quantity of sludge in crude oil stock tanks with (see Table 2.17) in the form of paradibromobenzene; the volume of a residual chemicalwaste deposits left on the side walls and bottom of a storage tank by indirectly measuring the vacant volume in the tank using a gas tracer (1.294 MeV gamma, 109.34 min half-life); and the volume of palladium catalyst deposits on the walls of a chemical reactor with a source (88 keV gamma, 13.7 h) [277]. The technique is also useful for the determination of the amount of molten metal in an ore-refining process [238]; a task difficult to perform in any other way.
11.5.9.
Gas Properties
Alpha and beta particles are more suited than other types of radiation for the inspection of gases, because of the low density of gases. As these charged-particles travel through a gas, they lose energy and intensity, and in the process can ionize the gas. All these features can be used to determine the density and pressure of a gas, as discussed in section 9.1. Note, however, that these parameters are related, e.g. for an ideal gas where refers to pressure, to density, M to the molecular weight (or mass number), T to temperature and to the universal gas The advantage of nuclear methods over constant; conventional methods is that they provide rapid response in the form of an electrical signal that can be monitored remotely. A charged-particle source, particularly, a beta emitter, can be seen as a replacement of the hot filament (cathode) used in conventional ionization gauge (also called ionization manometers) for vacuum pressure measurements. Such devices rely on the fact that any residual gas atoms left in a vacuum system are subject to ionization by electrons emitted from the filament as they collide with the gas atoms. However, the probability of ionization depends on the type of gas, since the stopping power of a material depends on the atomic-number, as discussed in section 9.1. The ionized atoms are collected with an applied voltage between the filament and an electrode. If the applied voltage, hence electron energy is sufficiently high, each electron is unlikely to collide more than once with the gas atoms at it travels towards the electrode. Then, the amount of ionization current will be directly proportional to the gas density, the more gas atoms the higher the chance that an emitted electron will collide with the gas atoms. Replacing the electron-emitting filament with a source of alpha or beta particles offers some advantages [238]: a stable rate of emission with a long half-life source; eliminating a heat source (hot filament) that stimulates chemical reactions between the gas and the filament and can lead to gas molecular decomposition; and long life-
508
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
time, since there is no filament to burn out. The filament can also burn out if the voltage is increased to allow measurements at higher pressure. In addition, with an isotopic source, there is no need to apply high voltage to accelerate charged-particles, as they are already emitted with high energy. The higher energy also enables the measurement of gas pressure at elevated values. The short range of alpha-particles makes them the preferred source for such applications, as they produce the required ionization within a reasonable distance, allowing the placement of the source and the collecting electrodes close to each other, hence the construction of a compact device. At higher pressure, the effects of ion recombination, ion mobility, etc., play a more prominent role, as in the case of the gas-based detectors, discussed in section 4.2.2. These factors affect the linear relationship between the ionization current and gas pressure, making it more difficult to interpret the results, since these factors are difficult to predict. Nevertheless, the dependence of those factors, as well as the stopping power of the gas, on its composition and atomic-number makes it possible to use the ionization current as an indicator of the composition of a binary mixture of gases, at the same pressure. Reference [238] reported the use of this ionization method for measuring the relative content of an ammonia-argon mixture and a methane-air mixture (in coal-mine atmospheres). The method was used to measure the vapor pressure of fourteen different chemical compounds, enabling the determination of their latent heats of evaporation or sublimation alpha-source [465]. using a The energy lost by charged-particles, after traversing a gas, is also a function of the gas density and its nature. This energy loss can be determined by measuring the remaining energy of a beam after its transmission through gas. Measuring the particle energy requires the use of an energy-sensitive detector, such as surface-barrier semiconductor (see section 4.2.4), and recording and analysis of the measured particle spectrum. This method was used for measuring temperature changes at atmospheric pressure and the density of gaseous flames with alpha sources [238]. Reference [466] presented a method of gas composition indication by iteratively searching for the best fit between experimental and calculated alpha-particle spectra. The range of charged-particles is relatively easy to measure, as it is the distance at which all the particles are absorbed. Therefore, by placing a charged-particle source and a detector within a gas, at some distance from each other, and increasing that distance until the detector’s count rate practically drops to zero, the range of these charged-particles in the gas can be determined. Since the range is a function of the gas den-
Gauging
509
sity, as indicated by Eqs. (3.14), (3.21), the density of gas, or changes in density, can be determined. Changing the distance between the source and the detector can be a tedious task. Therefore, an alternative arrangement is preferred. With beta-radiation, use can be made of the exponential nature of its attention, Eq. (3.23), to measure the intensity of the transmitted radiation and relate it to density. The exponential nature of beta-particle attenuation is due to the wide and continuous distribution of its emission energy, as discussed in section 3.3.2. However, due to the relatively long range of beta-particles in gases, sources of alpha-particles are preferred as they allow the placement of the source and detector within a reasonable distance from each other, for device compactness. Although alpha-sources are monoenergetic (see Table 2.1), their emission can be given, like beta-particles, a wide and continuous energy distribution by using a thick source, where self-absorption within the source material results in the emission of alpha-particles over a wide range; nearly full energy from the surface of the source, minimum energy from the center, and intermediate energies from in between. With a thick alpha-source, the intensity of transmitted radiation can be used to measure gas density (or pressure). At a constant pressure, the intensity of the transmitted radiation can be utilized to determine the relative content of a binary gas mixture, taking advantage of the dependence of the particle range on the atomic-number of the gas, see Eq. (3.14). The attenuation of a thick alpha-particle source was used for measuring the atmospheric air pressure at different altitude and for determining the relative content of a helium-oxygen gas mixture [238]. In spite of their long range, the forward scattering of beta-particles was also used for measuring the density of air at high altitudes, taking advantage of the dependence of the scattering probability of beta-particles on density, as discussed in section 11.1.3. At constant pressure, the density of the gas becomes indicative of its temperature (or more accurately its inverse temperature since for an ideal gas). Then, the gas temperature can monitored by radiation transmission. Using this principle, the transmission of beta-particles was used for measuring the flame temperature in an oxygen steel furnace [179]. The longer range of a beta-particles allows positioning the source and detector away from each other and from the flame, a desirable situation under these high temperature condition. This is a unique way for performing nonintrusive measurements under such harsh conditions. Air humidity can be measured with an ionization chamber that uses atmospheric air as its ionizing gas. To induce ionization, an alphaparticle source is located within the chamber; alpha-particles are used as a source to provide a high ionization current. Humidity introduces
510
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
liquid (water) particles into the air passing through the chamber, which act as recombination centers that decrease the ionization current. Reference [467] reported the use of a double ionization arrangement to enhance the sensitivity of the ionization current to changes in humidity. Each chamber had its ionization source but both shared the same ion collecting electrodes. While one chamber had many small holes to allow atmospheric air through, the other chamber was sealed at atmospheric pressure and kept dry by means of calcium chloride particles. The effect of changes in atmospheric pressure and temperature were minimized by applying a reverse potential voltage in one channel, relative to the other, with the magnitude of voltage bias adjusted so that when the atmospheric air was dry, the cumulative current of the two chambers was zero. Therefore, increased humidity of the air entering the unsealed chamber leads to an imbalance in the voltage of the double chamber, which produces a current, the magnitude of which increases with humidity. Humidity was measured to an accuracy of ±5% with this method [467]. The dew-point can also be obtained from humidity measurements, since the-dew point is normally reached at a relative humidity of atmospheric air of 100 % (i.e. at saturation). The temperature corresponding to this saturation level is the dew-point, i.e. the temperature at which water vapor condenses from air into liquid or solid, forming dew, frost rain or snow. Note that when the dew-point is below the freezing temperature, it is called the frost-point.
11.5.10.
Flow Distribution
Radiotracers provide a direct method for examining the distribution of flow across a plant or open channels. By monitoring the intensity and time of arrival of a tracer at designated points, the flow pattern can be determined. Indications of flow distribution can be obtained by studying the travel time (also called the residence time) of a radiotracer pulse. Early applications of flow-pattern investigations included the study of sewage discharge into the ocean, using and as radiotracers. The method was also used to study the distribution of potential leakage of petroleum products or toxic chemicals into a river, and the subsequent arrival at a water treatment plant [277]. The deep ocean sewage outfalls off Sydney Australia were also evaluated using and or [447]. The spread of subterranean termite colonies either in both forested and urban areas was traced with or in an inert form, by inserting them in a feeding location of a wooden dowel [468]. The retention and migration in a wastewater treatment plant of fiber components containing polyacrylate polymer (used in a number of absorbent consumer products) was studied by tagging of the polymer
Gauging
511
of fiber introduced into the treatment unit [469]. The flow pattern in the leaching tank of a nitrate production process was studied by injecting a pulse of at the inlet of the tank and measuring the activity of samples extracted at the outlet of the tank [470]. The existences of a dead-volume (where solution may be retained) in the corner of the and radiotracer tank was also studied with the aid of simultaneously injected into two corners of the tank [470]. When separate flow passages are present, direct flow-rate measurements, using the methods discussed in section 11.5.2, can be used to determine the flow distribution. Such measurements were used to determine the water flow distribution among the branches of a waste-heat tracer; for studying the flow dispersion of sulfuric acid boiler using a as a tracer; in the reticulation system of an alkylation plant with and for studying the flow distribution in gas distribution networks [445]. Radiotracers have also been used to measure the diffusion coefficient of one substance within another [471]. The diffusion of a radiotracer introduced into a medium will increase the count rate of the radiation emitted from the radiotracer with time as follows:
where N is the count rate at time is that recorded at count zero is the saturation concentration, is a constant related to the and diffusion coefficient where D is the diffusion coefficient in a diffusion cell of length L [471]. The sliding cell method described in reference [471] allows smooth introduction of the tracer material from one cell to another to establish the diffusion process. The same reference described the measurement of self-diffusion in an tracer, by diffusing a radioactive solution into a system, using a non-radioactive one.
11.5.11.
Void Fraction
The gas phase in a multiphase flow is generally viewed as representing a ‘void’ due to its low density. This makes the volume fraction of the gas phase, called the void fraction, particularly amenable to measurement by penetrating radiation, due the negligible effect the gas phase has on radiation, in comparison to liquid or solid. Beta-particle transmission was used for void-fraction measurement, see for example reference [472]. However, this method is limited to high void content, e.g. dispersed water in steam, and the low penetrability of beta-particles necessitates a special thin-window arrangement, restricting its use to low-pressure systems. Gamma transmission is the most common method used for
512
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
void-fraction measurement, in a process known as “densitomtery”, as it in effect measures the density of the non-void phase in the flow. The density-dependence stems from the use of radiation sources with photon energies where Compton scattering dominates, such as see Table 2.10 for energies and half-lives. At lower photon and Tm, energy, and in the presence of metal, the photoelectric effect can slightly alter the dependence of the device on density. Using the transmission model of Eq. (6.2), assuming linear density-dependence of the total crossaccording to section and expressing it in terms of the void-fraction, Eq. (E.16), the void fraction in a pipe can be estimated as:
where I refers to the intensity of the transmitted radiation and the and designate the intensity measured when the pipe is subscripts and are determined full of liquid or gas, respectively. The values of in-situ, to directly account for the attenuation of pipe walls and changes in the source intensity by radioactive decay. This gamma-transmission method is widely applied for void-fraction measurement of gas-liquid two-phase flow in tubes, annuli, rod bundles and nozzles [473]. The measurement model of Eq. (11.13) is based on the transmission model of Eq. (6.2), which requires a narrow-beam so that the buildup of radiation by scattering is negligible. A narrow-beam passing through one chord provides an estimate of the void condition only in that chord. If the flow is not homogeneous, then the estimated void-fraction will not be representative of the entire flow condition within the monitored channel. A wide-beam can be used for this purpose, with provisions made to account for the uneven distribution of the beam profile. This broad-beam approach is, however, limited to small pipes (about 13 mm in diameter), since for larger pipes the transmission response from one end of the pipe can considerably differ from that at its center, thus complicating the interpretation of results [238], which may also be further affected by the contribution of multiple scattering. To overcome this problem, a multi-beam densitometer is employed [473]. This is typically done using one source housed in a shielding container equipped with beam ports (long holes acting as collimators), directed towards the flow channel, typically three [474]. These ports provide in essence multiple beams emanating from the same point (source location), but traverses the flow channels at three different locations along the same section of the channel. Transmission along each beam is recorded, and Eq. (11.13) is applied to each measurement to estimate the void fraction along each beam. The average of the obtained values provides an estimate of the
Gauging
513
overall (global) void fraction within the flow channel, while the variability of the measurements provides an indication of the distribution of the void, or the so-called flow regime. X-ray multi-beam systems were also devised [473]. An interesting x-ray transmission method was reported in reference [475], where the metal walls of the pipe were used to generate x-rays, by bombarding it with beta-particles emitted from a pure betaThe transmission of the generated bremsstrahlung source x-rays was then measured and used to determine the void fraction in a vapor-water mixture. The generated x-rays have an energy that depends on the thickness of the target, but with an effective energy of less that 20 keV. This limits the technique to small tubes, to a maximum of about 8 mm in diameter. The method is also limited to metal walls thickness of about 0.65 mm of steel (or the equivalent), since beyond that thickness the generated x-rays are self-absorbed within the wall. However, such a technique can be useful for studying the flow in small tubes, where conventional sources of x-rays and gamma-rays generate too high a photon energy. Another way to overcome the limitations of single-beam transmission is to employ a scattering technique. Photons are Compton-scattered mainly by the liquid phase, consequently the number of scattered photons is proportional to the liquid content. With high-energy photons, the number of scatters can be limited to one per source particle, making it relatively easy to interpret the results. Reference [212] reported the use of a collimated beam of 9 MeV photons produced by neutron bombardment inside a reactor with a 3 kg nickel target (via the thermal neutron capture with The photons were made incident on a 25 mm plastic tube, and the scattered photons were measured with a NaI(Tl) detector at angle of 20° with the beam. The scattering intensity, at a void-fraction, was modeled (see section 7.5), assuming single scattering, by the relationship:
where is the scattering cross-section for the liquid phase, Reference [476] showed also that information on the spatial distribution of the two phases can be obtained from scattering measurements. A very intense beam, as that extracted from a reactor using a large target, is required to compensate for the fact that most liquids are low in density and as such are not very effective Compton scattering targets. This lowprobability of scattering is also further suppressed if the pipe walls are made of a metal, since metals are more effective Compton-scattering material; as Eq. (3.40) indicates. Photon scattering from the surrounding
514
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
shielding and collimator material further increases the competing background signal. Therefore, the signal (from the liquid) to background ratio tends to be small, necessitating very long counting periods, even with a considerably large source. The backscattering of x-rays from 40 mm diameter steel tube (2.5 mm thick) was used for measuring the void-fraction in air-water flow [477], using four detectors and a wide fan-beam, with the stream line of the flow parallel to the plane of the fan-beam. Reference [478] presented a system that employs an source and cadmium zinc telluride (CdZnTe) detectors to measure radiation at 17 different positions around an aluminum pipe (80 mm inner diameter and 5 mm thick). With energy discrimination, the photon scattering component, with energy less than the source’s 60 keV, can be separated from the uncollided (transmission) radiation. The scattering, along with the transmission detector responses, were used to determine the void fraction and identify the flow regime in oil-gas mixtures. Activation techniques can also be used to produce secondary radiation emitted from the liquid in all directions. Nuclear activation can be useful for this purpose, but the generally low activation cross-section of neutrons in most flow materials results in a low count rate, or demands the use of an intense source. However, photon-activation was employed with heavy-water flows, taking advantage of the photoneutron reaction, see section 12.1.1.2. A photon source of energy above 1.67 MeV can be used to trigger neutron emission from the deuterons of the heavy water. The the amount of emitted neutrons would then be proportional to the density of the boiling heavywater flow, hence to the void fraction [479]. In high-pressure systems, where thick-metallic walls are used, the contribution of the metal to the detector response can far exceed that of the fluid, due to the higher electron density, hence high macroscopic cross-section, of metal. Neutrons, on the other hand, are generally less affected by metals than photons. Therefore, thermal-neutrons extracted from a reactor were initially used for void-fraction measurement, in a beam-transmission arrangement [480, 481, 482, 483]. Thermal-neutron beams obtained from the slowing-down of neutrons emitted from isotopic neutron-sources were also used [484]. Since the efficiency of the neutron slowing-down process is not every high, due to the loss of neutrons in the moderation process, some workers took advantage of the slowing-down ability of the hydrogenous liquids to provide such moderation. The first attempt in this regard measured the transmission of fast-neutrons emitted from an Sb/Be neutron source (see Table 2.17 for properties) with a thermal-neutron detector, and dissolved boron in the fluid to increase its absorption cross-section [485]. The detected thermal-neutron count
Gauging
515
becomes then dependent on the amount of boron in the pipe, hence the liquid, and in turn the void fraction. This technique requires sufficient amount of hydrogenous liquid for the incident fast-neutrons to be slowed-down by liquid, then absorbed by the boron. Therefore, this slowing-down/absorption, technique was applied to water pipes of diameters ranging from 76 to 200 mm in diameter. However, by proper pre-moderation of the incident source neutrons, the need to use boron can be eliminated, and direct scattering of neutrons can be used for void fraction measurement, see reference [213]. This technique, called neutron scatterometry, has been applied for measuring the void fraction of boiling-water in high pressure metallic pipes as small as 22 mm in internal diameter, I.D., (3 mm thick) [486] to as a large as 100 mm I.D. (10 mm thick) [487] and 113 mm in I.D. (7.1 mm thick) [488], and in a rod bundle channel (44.8 mm internal diameter, 4 mm wall thickness, with seven solid metallic rods, each 13.1 mm in diameter) [489, 490]. Phase-distribution information was also deduced from the pattern of the scattering measurements change with time [491]. Fast-neutron scattering was also used for measuring the gas content in a degassing unit used to entrain an inflammable hydrocarbon gas in a plastics intermediates plant [289]. Measuring the interfacial area between the phases of a multiphase flow is a challenging task. One approach to applying radiation to this measurement problem is to place a beta-source in one phase and a scintillating material in the other phase. The number of beta-particles crossing the interface, and causing scintillation in the other phase, will be proportional to the interfacial area, if the beta-particles are absorbed within a short range within the scintillating phase. The intensity of the emitted light becomes, therefore, a measure of the overall interfacial area between the phases. This concept was experimentally verified using an aqueous being the beta-source), interfacing with solid tritium solution (with and liquid scintillators [492]. This concept proved, however, not to be practical, due to the difficulty of limiting the presence or solubility of the materials of the beta-source and/or the scintillator within a single phase.
11.5.12.
Multiphase Flow
Although gamma-ray transmission can be used to measure the overall density of a multiphase flow, as the applications in section 11.1.4 showed, it cannot distinguish between the phases. However, the dualenergy gamma-ray transmission method, discussed in section 6.5.3, can be used to provide such information. It was, therefore, used to measure oil, water and gas volume fractions [493, 494, 495, 496, 497]. While a
516
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
high-energy source, such as (662 keV) or (356 keV), can be used to measure the density of the fluid, a low-energy source, such as provides effective atomic-number (composition) information. The three-phase oil relative permeability can also be deduced from such measurements [498]. Using this technique, it becomes possible to determine the fluid saturation distribution as a function of the volume of gas injected; with the aid of three-phase oil relative permeability curves deduced from oil saturation profiles using analytical calculations. The saturation of nonaqueous-phase liquid in water within sandy porous media and soil was measured with dual-energy gamma-radiation systems [499, 500, 501, 502]. Measurement of the cross-correlation between gamma-transmission measurements of the two gauges, one downstream of the other, can be used to determine the flow velocity [494, 495]. A multi-energy photon-transmission system was also used to account for the change in water salinity in such three-phase flow systems [503]. The diffraction pattern, discussed in section 7.7.4, was also used to measure the oil-to-water ratio, taking advantage of the difference of the diffraction pattern of oil and water. With a 70 kV tungsten x-ray, the diffraction profile for oil (kerosene), when normalized to water, peaks between 15 to 25 keV and is minimum between 32 to 45 keV [504]. The ratio of the diffraction intensity at these energies provides, therefore, an index indicative of the oil-to-water content. In the presence of void that may be present in a multiphase (oil-water-vapor) flow, the scatter-ratio is corrected by the ratio of the logarithm of the transmission measurements obtained at these energy windows, since each transmission measurement is mainly affected by the presence of void and becomes a function of the liquid fraction. The ratio between the two transmission measurements eliminates the effect of void, as one can deduce form the measurement model of Eq. (6.1). It should be kept in mind, however, that a small container of non-metallic material should be used to allow for photon penetration; reference [504] utilized a polypropylene vessel, 60 mm in diameter and 1 mm thick. Talking advantage of the salinity of underground water, and the subsequent increase in its neutron absorption cross-section of thermalneutrons (due to the presence of chlorine), reference [505] reported the use of the transmission and scattering of fast-neutrons from an Am/Be source. The gas-fraction is determined from the transmission measurement, since it is mainly a fast-neutron measurement that is affected most by the absence of material (void). The relative oil-to-water measurement is then determined from the normalization of a slow-neutron scattering measurement, corrected for void fraction, since the scattering from water
Gauging
517
of slow-neutrons is reduced by the absorption in chorine. The method requires, however, a priori knowledge of the level of salinity in water.
11.5.13.
Isotope Hydrology
Isotope hydrology is the term that describes the use of environmental isotopes (see section 8.8.2) to study the hydrological cycle of the waters of the Earth and its interaction with the environment. A good number of studies have been conducted using radioisotopes, a few of which are mentioned here. References [506] and [507] describes how environmental isotopes are used to study ground-water pollution problems, while reference [508] is a good source for information on the use of environmental isotopes (and related tracers) in a variety of applications in hydrology, geology, and biology. A few representative applications are given here. Some isotopes can be used as tracers of water, nutrient, or solute sources. The concentration of tritium can reveal the occurrence of recent ground-water recharge (over the past few decades, due to its limited half-life of 12.43 years), which is indicative of the increased potential of contamination as the ground-water would not have sufficient residence time for the water to become absorbed in the aquifer matrix. The concentration of uranium and thorium (and the activity emitted by their daughters), is useful for studying the movement (pathways) of underground water. The natural fractionization of the even uranium isotopes and by the alpha-decay of the latter, is useful for studying dynamic processes in the hydrosphere. The spatial and temporal variation of the ratio of the concentration in underground water (or disequilibrium) is used for studying ground-water formation and circulation, and for modeling the hydrogeological conditions in mountains areas during floods [509]. Naturally occurring isotopes in the environment are also used to estimate the age of very old ground-water [510], using Reference [511] covers many of the applications of environmental isotopes in hydrology. Radiotracers (such as were also used for measuring the flow rate of ground water [512]. Beryllium-10 (a beta-only emitter with half-life ) is one of the comsogenic nuclides produced by cosmic-rays (spallation of O and N). It exists as a solution in the slightly acidic rain-water, and upon precipitates out of solution as the reaching the ground surface, can be used water becomes more alkaline. The accumulation of to study soil erosion and formation. The shorter-lived cosmogenic (53.28 day, half-life) can be measured in the ground as evidence of recent rainfall, as well as in stream-water to determine the direct contribution of rainfall. References [513] and [514] provide more details on the applications of cosmogenic nuclides in hydrology and related fields.
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
518
11.6.
Dating
Dating is the process of finding the age of an object. Long-lived radioisotopes are particularly suited for this process, since their concentration varies with time. It is, however, necessary to know the initial concentration of the radioisotope, in Eq. (3.156), to relate it to the current concentration, N, hence determine the lifetime, using Eq. (3.156), knowing the decay constant (or half-life) of the radioisotope. A number of radioisotopes are suitable for use in dating studies as discussed below. Atmospheric cosmic-rays produce via the reaction: The generated is rapidly oxidized to form which enters plant life (via photosynthesis) and animal and humane life (via the food chain). An equilibrium between the concentration of and non-radioactive carbon exists in living biological cells. There is one atoms of in living material. As soon as atom for every terra a living-organism dies, the metabolic function of carbon uptake ceases, and no fresh supply of carbon is provided. The concentration of then begins to decline by radioactive decay, with a half-life of 5715 y. The concentration of relative to the equilibrium concentration is, therefore, indicative of the time passed since the death of the livingbecomes organism. After about 10 half-lives, the concentration of very small, practically undetectable. Therefore, carbon-dating is limited to a maximum of 50 to 60 thousand years. The decay of results in the release of beta-particles with a maximum energy of 157 keV (with is, therefore, measured no gamma emission). The concentration of by beta-particle counting. Since the presence of carbon is usually associated with biological processes, any material that contains carbon may be dated. Reference [515] lists some of the types of carbonaceous samples that have been commonly dated using These are: charcoal, wood, twigs and seeds; bone; marine, estuarine and riverine shell; leather; peat; coprolites; lake muds (gyttja) and sediments; soil; ice cores; pollen; hair; pottery; metal casting ores; wall paintings and rock art works; iron and meteorites; avian eggshell; corals and foraminifera; speleothems; tufa; blood residues; textiles and fabrics; paper and parchment; fish remains; insect remains; resins and glues; antler and horn; and water. The same reference [515] presents also an impressive list of the fields in which carbon-dating has been applied. Theses include: archaeology (Dead Sea Scrolls), oceanography (ocean sediments), palaeoenvironmental studies (palaeovegetational reconstruction of the North and South American continents), dendrochronology (ancient bristlecone pine), palaeoclimaCarbon-14.
Gauging
519
tology (palaeoclimates and solar variation) and meteorology (examination of Martian Meteorites); Tritium. Cosmic radiation produces tritium in the upper atmosphere, supplying a constant, though low, quantity of tritium to all precipitation (rain and snow). Therefore, tritium is used to date water that seeps underground, where it becomes protected from exposure to cosmic rays. Tritium dating is achieved by measuring the concentration of tritium in water [179] and comparing it to the equilibrium concentration. However, because of the relatively short half-life of (12.32 y), the method is limited to a maximum age of about 50 years. Thus tritium dating is used to determine the age of “young” ground-water. It should be kept in mind that some excess tritium may be present in water due to the thermonuclear weapon explosions that were performed during and following World War II. Cosmogenic Nuclides. In addition to other cosmogenic nuclides (see section 2.4) can be used for dating. Such include (a pure and (a positron and a gamma beta emitter, half-life These nuclides are produced in quartz crystals of emitter, rock and sand, and found in lakes and rivers due to rock erosion. The longer the rocks are exposed to cosmic rays, the higher the concentration of these radionuclides in the rock, and consequently in river and lake sediments. These isotopes can, therefore, be used for dating river terrace sediments [516]. Other isotopes that can be employed in radioactive dating include, half-life) and (22.6 y, half-life). The long halflife of makes it useful for measuring the age of water for up to 2 million years, since chorine is usually present in water. While is used to date layers of sand and soil up to 80 years [349]. Thermoluminescence. Natural activity, from naturally radioactive materials as well as from cosmic-rays, excites buried crystalline materials. Most of the excited electrons return quickly to their stable state, but a few become trapped for a long time within the crystal and stay at the excited state. These trapped electrons retain a “memory” of the history of their radiation exposure, which can be tapped into by heating the crystal to a temperature high enough to release the excitation energy stored in the crystal with a subsequence emission of luminescence light. If the crystal is cooled and then re-heated, this excess energy will be liberated, and no subsequent light emission can be released. This effect is known as thermoluminescence (TL); it is the same process utilized in
520
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
badges used to monitor personnel exposure to radiation. The intensity of emitted light peaks at temperatures that produce thermal energies sufficient to release the excited electrons from their various traps. The intensity of these TL peaks increases as radiation exposure increases, and thus can be used to determine the age of the crystal, in a process known as TL dating [517]. The age of material is determined from the radiation dose corresponding to the intensity of the recorded light and the average annual radiation dose. Materials which may be dated with this methods are flint (or stone), stalagmitic calcite, sediments and ceramics [518]. Thus the method is used in archeological studies [519] as in the dating of Egyptian pottery [520], volcanic materials [521], sediments [522], bricks structure [523], and even space planets [524], and for investigating the irradiation history of dates and nuts [525]. Various ceramic materials (pottery, bricks, cooked clays, bronze clay-cores) have been also dated by thermoluminescence using the emitted natural radiation [526]. The technique is also used in forensic dosimetry after a radiation accident. For example, this method was used to measure the external exposure dose in the contaminated area near the Chernobyl Nuclear Power Station by measuring the thermoluminescence of quartz in bricks [527].
Chapter 12 ELEMENTAL AND CONTENT ANALYSIS
Elemental analysis is the ability to identify all elements, or some of the elements, present in a material. Content analysis, on the other hand, refers to determining the relative content of known materials in a mixture. For example, determining the elemental composition of soil means identifying the elements in the soil (oxygen, silicon, etc.) and their weight fractions. Also determining how much hydrogen in the soil (say due to water moisture) can be considered as elemental analysis concerned with the detection of one-element (hydrogen). On the other hand, determining the amount of water and soil in mud is considered to be content analysis, since it is known in advance that the mixture contains water and soil, but their relative content is not known. Note that radiation methods in general do not provide explicitly the chemical composition (formulae) of a material, since radiation interacts with either individual electrons or nuclei or their fields, as discussed in chapter 3. Therefore, the effect of chemical bonds on radiation interactions is not very prominent. Molecular information can, however, be extracted when radiation is sensitive to the thermal motion of individual molecules, or possess wave properties that are influenced by the molecular structure of a material, or when the radiation energy is quite low to be affected by electronic (chemical) bonding. Therefore, when the term “composition” is used in this chapter, it refers in general to the overall elemental or material composition of matter, rather than its explicit chemical form. An element can be identified as a nuclide (i.e. by its nuclear properties) or as or as an atom (i.e. by its atomic electrons). While nuclear methods are more specific and can distinguish between two different isotopes of the same elements, atomic methods are also useful in some applications, particularly when the primary interest is in the overall chemical nature of 521
522
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
material. Nuclear methods require radiation that can reach or is affected by the nucleus, thus they utilize the techniques discussed in sections 12.1 and 12.2. Since the number of elements to examine is too enormous to consider one element at a time, this chapter classifies the applications in terms of the technique used. However, the measurement of hydrogen, being one of the most common elements in nature, is discussed in a separate section (12.3). The process of content analysis is discussed in section 12.4.
12.1. Nucleus-Based Analysis 12.1.1. Activation Analysis Activation analysis is perhaps the most definite method for multielemental analysis, since each element provides its own characteristic nuclear emission, regardless of its chemical composition. Though activation analysis is often performed in nuclear reactors or with the aid of large accelerator facilities, it can also be done in situ, using isotopic sources or portable generators. While delayed emissions are often monitored in reactors, prompt emissions are used in applications requiring on-line analysis. The high accuracy of activation analysis and its ability to detect trace amounts of elements adds to the viability of the technique. However, activation by certain types of radiation are more suitable than others. Some methods offer low activation cross-sections, while in others interference between various elements present in an object can obscure a desired indication. This section presents some of the applications in which various techniques have proved to be useful. The techniques are classified primarily in terms of their radiation sources; unlike in chapter 8 where the methods were categorized first by the nature of emitted radiation.
12.1.1.1
Neutron Activation
The ability of neutrons to easily penetrate the nucleus makes them very useful in many elemental-analysis applications by neutron activation, as discussed in this section.
Thermal-Neutron In – Prompt-Gamma Out . Prompt-gamma neutron-activation analysis requires immediate counting of emitted radiation. This necessitates a system arrangement in which the interrogated object and a gamma detector are present at the same time and place, thus prompt-gamma neutron activation cannot be performed within a reactor core or inside a neutron-thermalization assembly. Since there are no direct sources of thermal-neutrons, these neutrons have to be ex-
Elemental and Content Analysis
523
tracted from a reactor, a neutron moderation-assembly that includes an isotopic neutron source, or a neutron generator. A collimator is then used to extract a neutron beam of thermal-neutrons that is directed to the investigated object. The design aspects of these collimators and moderation assemblies are discussed in sections 15.1 and 15.3, respectively. References [528] and [529] describes some of the reactor-based facilities available around the world for performing prompt-gamma activation analysis. Sub-thermal (cold) neutrons can also be used for promptgamma activation. Reference [530] presents a data-set that provides the energy of prompt gamma-rays induced in 79 elements resulting from the activation by sub-thermal (cold) neutrons. A variety of photon detectors can be used for detecting the emitted radiation. Obviously the detector has to be able to measure the energy of the emitted photons, to uniquely identify the originating element. The detector used has also to be resistant to neutron damage and insensitive to neutrons, since even if the detector is well-shielded from the source neutrons, some neutrons may scatter off the object and reach the detector. In this regard, and in NaI(Tl) detectors become activated to and respectively. While the decay of results in two emits many prominent gamma-ray energies at 1.369 and 2.754 MeV, weak gamma-rays ranging in energy from 3.770 keV to 1.434 MeV. These internally emitted photons further scatter within the detector, creating a background component that can interfere with the measured spectrum of photons incident on the detector. While a BGO detector is not as susceptible to neutron internal activation, its casing can be activated, causing interference with the detector response. Such interference can be quite severe at high neutron flux. Semiconductor detectors, such as Ge(Li) and HPGe detectors, are also subject to crystal damage at high neutron flux. Prompt thermal-neutron activation (TNA) can been used for the detection and measurement of the concentration of many elements, see section Table 8.3. A unique feature of this activation method is its ability to detect cadmium and mercury, two of the toxic elements that evade delayedneutron activation analysis [247]. Although (12.22% abundance) is the cadmium isotope with the highest thermal-neutron capture crosssection (20.6 kb), it produces upon neutron absorption a stable isotope, However, the reaction produces 0.559 MeV photons, see Table 8.3. Similarly, although is the isotope of mercury that has the highest capture cross-section (2.2 kb), it produces a stable isotope, while emitting a prompt gamma energy of 0.3681 keV. Therefore, the technique is useful for the measurement of cadmium and mercury in environmental samples. Other example industrial ap-
524
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
plications include the detection of boron in semiconductors and glass, analysis of archeological samples, and on-line analysis of coal and minerals. The technique was also used in mineral exploration and welllogging [247, 256]. The thermal-neutron prompt-gamma technique has been used to determine the concentration of major elements in coal (H, C, N, S), ash (Al, Si, Ca, Fe) [531, 532, 533], limestone (used in manufacturing cement (H, C, Ca, Fe) [532] and a raw glass mixture (for Na, Si and Ca) [533]. The viability of using the same technique was also investigated for offbelt bulk analysis of coal to optimize production, processing and quality operations in coal mines [534]. The technique was also used for the determination of ash, Fe, Si, and Al of coal seams in water-filled boreholes [535]. The percentage of Al, Si and Fe in core were correlated to the deformation temperature and the slagging index of coal1 [535]. In well-logging thermal-neutron activation is utilized for the detection of chlorine, which is usually present in the saline underground water, for localizing oil-water contacts, with the water and oil supplying the thermal-neutrons by slowing-down fast-neutrons emitted from a fastneutron source, such as Am/Be, Pu/Be [40], or a 14 MeV neutron generator. Natural chlorine produces high-energy activation-gamma peaks in the range from 6.6 to 8.6 MeV [246], which are easily detectable. The hydrogen content can also be detected by its 2.223 MeV gammarays, to provide an indication of the shale content and porosity (see section 12.3.1) that can be used to correct for the dependence of salinity on these two factors. The activation peaks from silicon (3.54, 6.38 MeV) and calcium (4.42 and 6.42 MeV) are also useful indications in formation lithology2; though silicon is also detectable by fast-neutron elastic scattering, see Tables 8.5 and 8.6. The salt and sulfur content, relative to that of hydrogen, in a flow stream of crude oil, was determined using an Am/Be source and monitoring the activation gamma-rays of Cl and sulfur, using two characteristics gamma-energies, and hydrogen at 2.223 MeV [536]. The overlapping of the activation gamma-rays from Cl and S, as well as from other elements, were accounted for via a calibration process. The prompt-gamma emitted from the thermal-neutron capture reactions (7.64 MeV gamma) and (1.78 MeV 1
The slagging and fouling of coals during combustion can be predicted by heating a laboratory prepared coal ash in a controlled atmosphere. Initial, deformation softening, hemisphere and f luid (flow) temperatures are recorded. The slagging index is defined in reference [535] as 2 Lithology is the study of stones, rocks or rock formation, in terms of composition, color, texture and structure.
Elemental and Content Analysis
525
gamma) was used for continuous determination of, respectively, iron and alumina in iron ores, using a moderated source [384]. Since does not decay promptly, it has a half-life of 2.3 minutes, a detector down-stream of that used for detecting the prompt-gammas of was employed. The iron ore was placed on an auxiliary conveyor belt moving at speed of less than 3 m/minute to allow the detection of the gammas before they significantly decay. The reaction was also used for determining the aluminum content in bauxite and coal samples with a well-thermalized source [384] A similar application is reported for manganese-grade well-logging [537], and for the elemental analysis of diabase rock (a rock similar to that found under the ocean) [538]. Reference [539] reported the use of this technique to investigate the elemental composition of a phosphate ore. Thermal-neutron activation was used for in situ survey of water pollution by elements such as Hg, Ni, Cl, Fe, Cu, Mn, Cr, Ag, Pb and Zn [540, 541, 542] and for mineral exploration in sea bed [543]. Thermal-neutron activation was also proposed for detecting explosives in airline passenger luggage [544, 545]. Nitro explosives are rich in nitrogen, which is indicated by the emission of a 10.829 MeV gammarays [246]. A similar approach with a source, was used for confirming the presence of a landmine detected by another conventional method (metal detector, ground probing radar and infrared imaging) [546]. Reference [547] assessed the suitability of various neutron sources for use in reaction, showing that a neulandmine detection via the tron generator based on the He reaction and a source are most suited for this purpose. Narcotics, on the other hand, are rich in chlorine, which can be detected by the many gamma-ray peaks it produces [246]. Therefore, thermal-neutron activation was also considered for detecting drugs concealed in cars, trucks and large cargo containers [548]. Such a system can be used for “inspection before an unloaded cargo container from a ship is moved to temporary storage, inspection of trucks unloaded from a ferry, or inspection of vehicles parked close to Federal building or military bases”. The thermal neutrons used in theses techniques are produced by slowing-down neutrons emitted from an isotopic source, namely, or neutron generators [549]. Thermal-Neutron In – Delayed-Gamma Out. This is perhaps the most widely used activation-analysis technique. It can be applied to almost 50 elements. Since the irradiation and counting processes are performed separately, the precautions required to protect a detector against neutron exposure in prompt-gamma activation are not needed in delayed activation. The separation of irradiation and detection allows the per-
526
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
formance of the latter under a low background field, thus improving the statistical confidences in the measurements, see appendix G. Statistical uncertainty can also be further enhanced by increasing the irradiation time and/or the counting time. It also becomes possible to position an object within the neutron field, i.e. within a reactor or a moderation assembly; an efficient way of using the neutron source, by eliminating the need for neutron extraction and collimation. However, this “in-core” irradiation makes it difficult to use the method in on-line or in situ analysis. On the other hand, in-core analysis is limited to small sample sizes and is not suited for heat-sensitive, volatile and unstable materials. Nevertheless, the ability of the technique to provide accurate determination of the elemental concentration of even trace amounts, makes it a very attractive technique for non-destructive analysis of small samples, that may be extracted from a larger object without affecting its usefulness. The detectors used in this method are similar to those employed in prompt thermal-neuron activation, i.e. detectors that are capable of measuring the photon-energy spectrum. The applications of delayed neutron-activation are too many to detail here, but a few representative examples are presented. An on-line system was developed for detecting the presence of vanadium (a highly corroding element) in crude oil and in heavy distillate fuel: via the reaction The latter element decays with a 3.76 minute half-life, emitting 1.434 MeV photons [550]. The thermal neutrons required for this reaction were produced using a moderated source, and the irradiated liquid was transferred to a detection unit with the aid of rubber tubing and a pump. Delayed neutron-activation analysis, with a high resolution gamma (germanium) detector was also applied in well-logging to provide elemental analysis for Na, Mg, Mn and V [551]. In-core (reactor) thermal-neutron activation analysis is used for measuring the concentration of a wide variety of elements in samples, see Table 8.2. Metal alloys, semiconductors, concrete, pottery, glass, bones, plants, forensic samples (e.g. gunshot residues and hair), greases, wood, soils, drugs, plastics, pesticidal residue, cigarettes, oil, rice flower rubber, paper, putty, inks, whiskey and paints are some of the materials analyzed by this method [50, 249]. The reaction (2.414 minutes half-life, and 1.78 MeV gamma energy ) was used to determine the aluminum content in coal [390], and in iron ores [384]. However, the production of by the thermal-neutron activation of via can interfere with the (n,p) reaction or the thermal activation of thermal-activation of Manganese-56 decays with a 2.58 hour halflife and emits 1.81 MeV gammas that may interfere with the 1.78 MeV of also emits 0.874 and 2.11 MeV gammas that can be easily
Elemental and Content Analysis
527
discriminated against. The effect of the reaction can be reduced by ensuring the use of a well-thermalized neutron field, but the interference of the reaction must be taken into consideration when detecting aluminum in manganese-rich iron ores. This can be via its 0.874 and achieved either by detecting the concentration of 2.11 MeV gammas or by waiting until decays, then measuring the strength of the 1.78 MeV gamma peak. While the reaction complicates the measurement of aluminum in manganese ores, it can be used for determining the manganese content. The decay of (2.5789 hour half-life) results in a number of gamma-rays, one of which is 2.113 MeV (14.3% yield) which can be used to detect manganese, while another one (1.81 MeV, 27.2% yield) can interfere with the 1.78 MeV resulting from the reaction, due to the presence of aluminum in the ore. Therefore, the contribution of derived from the 2.113 MeV peak must be first subtracted from the 1.81 MeV peak before the determination of aluminum concentration, to avoid any overlapping between these two closely spaced 1.81 and 1.78 MeV peaks [384] (unless of course a high-resolution detector is used). Thermal-activation analysis using moderated isotopic sources has been also used for determining the concentration of trace impurities in and in iron ore, and in tar sand, and minerals in coal) [552]. The technique was also used for the elemental analysis of a phosphate ore [539]. Reference [553] investigated the use of the technique for the detection of sodium and aluminum in “green liquor”, a mixture of sodium hydroxide and alumina dissolved in water present in the refining process of aluminum at the stage in which the liquor is supersaturated in aluminum prior to precipitation. Sodium can be detected by the gamma of its (1.368 and 2.754 MeV, 14.96 h half-life) (1.779 MeV, 2.25 min half-life). Activation can be achieved by and discrete sampling, where a neutron source is placed at the middle of a sample tank for a certain time then removed, allowing measurement of the activated gamma-rays after a certain decay time. Alternatively continuous sampling can be used by activating the sample in one tank and allowing the activated material to flow into another tank, shielded from the first, where radiation activity is detected. Epithermal-Neutron In – Delayed-Gamma Out. Epithermal neutrons are defined here as neutrons with energy above the cadmium cut-off energy of about 0.5 eV, and below about 1 MeV; an energy range that spans the cross-section resonances, when present. Lower energy neutrons are removed with cadmium filters (1 mm thick or so) and/or borated (boron-containing) materials. Exposure to higher-energy neu-
528
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
trons can be reduced by slightly moderating the source neutrons. Epithermal neutron analysis is favored over thermal-neutron analysis when thermal-neutron absorbers are present, and to overcome interferences from elements emitting similar gamma-ray energies (such as and A number of reactions can be employed in epithermal-activation. Inelastic scattering, though has a lower cross-section, tends to produce nuclides with shorter half-lives (and consequently higher activity) and with lower energy (leading to higher detection efficiency), due to the formation of metastable isomeric states. For example, the reaction leads to the formation of which has a half-life of 42.6 min and produces a 158.30 keV gammas (52.3% yield) [12]. The same parameters for are 7.73 s, 279.00 keV (70.9%) and for are 67.2 min, 899.15 keV (99.17%). This enables fast determination of these elements. It also offers the ability to determine the lead content, since neutron absorption by natural lead produces stable nuclides, or a betaemitter The reaction can be used of for the detection of Br, Sr, Y, Cd, In, Ba, Hf, Os, Au, Hg, Pb, and has been used for rapid determination of Hg, Au and Pb. The transmutation (n,p) and reactions are particularly useful in dealing with interferences between elements, by producing nuclides with different emission characteristics. For example, Si can be activated with and reactions. This redundancy both the can be used to compensate for interferences from nuclides producing the and same activation produces; in this case In addition, some nuclides can only be activated by these reactions, such as O, P and Si. The elements O, F, Na, Mg, Al, Si, S, K, Ca, Ti, V, Fe, Co, Ni, Zn, Ge, As, Nb can be analyzed by the (n,p) reaction, and have been used for the analysis of rocks, pottery, plants, bones and reaction was also used to determine the glass [248]. The silicon concentration in iron and bauxite ores [384]. Epithermal-neutron activation by the reaction is suitable for the detection of Ni, Zn, As, Se, Br, Rb, Sr, Mo, Sb, Cs, Ba, Sm, Tb, Hf, Ta, W, Th, U; thus it has been used for the analysis of coal and fly ash and geological samples [248].
Fast-Neutron In – Prompt-Gamma Out. Since readily available sources emit fast-neutrons, efficient utilization of these sources requires their use directly without moderation or collimation; processes which lead to wastage of neutrons by absorption and divergence. Although, the activation cross-section generally decreases with increasing neutron energy, the direct use of a source enables in situ and on-line activation.
Elemental and Content Analysis
529
The lower activation cross-section can be compensated for by using intense neutron generators. Inelastic scattering is often the reaction of choice in fast-neutron activation. Elements that can be analyzed with this reaction are given in Table 8.6. This reaction has a threshold-energy of 5 MeV or more, see section 8.1.4.2. Therefore, 14-MeV neutron generators are the favored source for use in this technique. Nevertheless, the high-energy tail of the spectrum of neutrons emitted by isotopic sources has been used for this purpose. For example, a source (producing neutrons/s) was used [554, 555] for analyzing carbon coal by measuring the 4.439 MeV gamma associated with the inelastic scattering of fastThe low-energy tail of the spectrum, which is readily neutrons by further reduced in energy by slowing-down by the coal’s hydrogen, was also utilized to determine the hydrogen content of coal via the 2.223 MeV gamma associated with neutron-capture by hydrogen. Prompt-gamma activation analysis in coal exploration or in effluent has been also reported [556]. Some of the other elements analyzed by this method are Al and Si in soil and Cr and Ni in metals [256]. Fast-neutron activation using a 14 MeV neutron generator was also reported for in situ detection of carbon in soil [557]. Reference [558] studied 81 gamma-ray energies arising from the inelastic scattering of fast-neutrons produced by an by 21 elements commonly found in minerals; isotopic source reporting that with a source emitting neutrons/s, element concentration larger than 1% (weight) can be determined in samples weighing 10 to 100 kg. Fast-neutron activation is also used for the determination of carbon-to-oxygen ratio in oil reservoirs,. This ratio is a means of detecting and evaluating oil, since gas/light-oil zones have a low C/O ratio, while heavy oil has a high value [40]. Reference [559] reported the standardization of based probe for assessment of masonry by measuring the water and soluble salt (NaCl) via the prompt gamma-ray emitted form H and Cl. On-line control of raw-mill feed composition is a key factor in the improved control of cement plants. An elemental analyzer for a cement raw-mill feed on a conveyor belt was developed and tested successfully on highly segregated material with a depth range of 100 to 180 mm [560]. The device, based on neutron inelastic-scattering showed, under dynamic in-plant testing, analyzer total errors of 0.49, 0.52, 0.38 and 0.23 weight percent for CaO, and respectively, over 10 minute counting periods. Analysis, on-line, of hot reduced iron ores was also performed by inelastic-scattering, using an neutron source [555, 561]. The iron, oxygen, carbon and silica contents of the ore were determined using the neutron inelastic scattering gamma-rays
530
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
at 0.85, 6.13, 4.43 and 1.78 MeV, respectively, to within 2.2 , 0.6 , 0.5, 1.0 % (weight), respectively. Fast-neutron activation analysis using inelastic gamma-rays has been also considered for the detection of contraband materials in passenger luggage [562, 563, 564] and cargo containers [565]. Of particular interest is the detection of explosive materials and narcotics. Detection of nitrogen-based explosives requires the determination of the relative ratio of the concentration of N, O , C and H [566]. For narcotics, the detection of chlorine is also needed. The characteristic gamma-rays from the reaction utilized for this purpose are: 4.439 MeV for 2.31, 1.64 and 0.72 MeV for 6.13 MeV for 1.22,1.76, 2.65, 2.69, 3.16 for and 3.09, 3.10 MeV for Hydrogen is not detectable by fast-neutron activation. However, fast-neutrons incident on the object will be slowed-down by the hydrogen that may be present, enabling the detection of H by thermal-neutron activation. In order to reduce the background signal produced by the activation of surrounding material, reference [562] suggested the use of pulsed neutrons, of an energy not exceeding 8 MeV, and monitoring the gamma-rays associated with the elements of interest within a short period following the pulse. By closing the detection window when the source neutrons activate the surrounding shielding and structural material, the background component is greatly reduced. With the detector collimated to view a small volume along the direction of the incident neutron beam, the density of and in that voxel can be determined. In the work of reference [565], a pulsed (30 bursts) 14 MeV neutron generator was employed. In addition to the inelastic gamma-radiation collected during the duration of the pulse, gamma-rays emitted between the bursts are also measured as it provides an indication of the thermal-capture of neutrons within the inspected cargo, assuming that the cargo contains sufficient neutron slowing-down material. The inelastic fast-neutron-induced gamma-rays are used to determine the C/O ratio within the inspected voxel, while the thermal-neutron capture gamma is used to determine the Cl/H ratio. These ratios are sufficient to distinguish narcotics from other innocuous materials. Reference [567] discussed the physical factors affecting this pulsed fast-neutron analysis (PFNA) technique. These include the attenuation of incident neutrons as they penetrate matter and the associated neutron scattering, which expands the size of the activated volume. The application of PFNA to drug and explosive detection in cargo containers is discussed in references [568] and [569]. The fast-neutron activation technique is also useful for detecting the presence of chemical weapons and special nuclear materials in cargo and trucks [570, 571]. Reference [572] suggested also the use of the technique,
Elemental and Content Analysis
531
with a source, to determine the composition of space (e.g. Lunar) bodies. The PFNA concept is further extended by detecting, not only the prompt gammas from inelastic-scattering and thermal-neutron activation reactions, but also the delayed-neutrons from the reactions: and (n,p), etc. [573]. While prompt-capture gamma-rays are detected between neutron pulses, during which inelastic gamma-rays are measured, every few hundred pulses the neutron beam is turned off for a few millisecond, to allow for the detection of delayed-gamma emissions. While inelastic prompt-gammas enable the detection of elements such as C, N and O, and prompt-gamma capture identifies H, N, Cl and Fe, delayed-neutron activation is useful for measuring the concentration of O, Si, F and P. The field-of-view, defined by the collimation of gamma-ray detectors, determines the volume from which gamma-rays are emitted. This multi-mode analysis makes the technique suitable for a variety of applications, including: contraband detection [574] (explosives [575, 576] and narcotics [577] ), and on-line elemental analysis of coal and cement [578, 579, 580, 581]. This technique is often refereed to as PELAN (Pulsed Elemental Analysis with Neutrons). An alternative to the use of pulsed neutrons is to time-tag emitted neutrons as well as emitted photons [582], using the alpha-particle associated with neutrons produced by the reaction, (see section 2.3.1.3). In this reaction, in addition to the 14 MeV produced, an alpha-particle emerges in the opposite direction carrying an energy of 3.5 MeV. In a specially designed neutron generator, the emitted alphaparticles, detected using a position-sensitive detector, can be used to tag the direction of the emitted neutrons, which has to be traveling in the opposite direction and originating from the target. At 14 MeV, the emitted neutrons will travel at a speed of about 0.05 m/ns, while the emitted inelastic gamma-rays travel at the speed of light (about 0.30 m/ns). Therefore, using the measured time of emission of the neutron (by its associated alpha-particle) and the time of arrival of the emitted inelastic gamma-rays, along with the direction of the incident neutron, the position of emission of the inelastic gamma-ray from the target can be determined [583, 584]. The time-of-flight, therefore, can be “gated” to probe a particular position (range) within the interrogated object [585], thus enhancing the signal-to-noise ratio by eliminating the detection of emission from outside the range. The energy of the emitted inelastic gamma-rays, as discussed in section 8.1.4.2, can be used to identify the emitting elements. Therefore, an element-by-element image of the target can be obtained. The spectra of the gamma-rays resulting from neutron inelastic-scattering reactions can be used to identify ele-
532
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
ments associated with chemicals in chemical warfare agents, explosives, and narcotics, as well as many pollutants and fissile and fertile nuclear materials [583, 586]. This combined associated-particle, neutron timeof-flight, and inelastic gamma-ray spectroscopy method was also used to investigate the caloric value of coal by measuring its carbon content and even the coal’s via the 4.439 MeV of the reaction with sulphur content via its 1.79, 2.77, 2.23 MeV gammas [585]. The same reference reported the use of the technique to assay the kerogen (organic component) and silicon (from quartz) content and in oil shales; with the latter determined using its 1.779 MeV inelastic gamma [564]). This probing technique was also proposed for detecting drugs, via their carbon and oxygen content, and explosive materials through their nitrogen, oxygen and carbon content [585]. Inelastic scattering with a radioisotope is also used for determining the contents of munition, by the inelastic gamma-ray rays from As, B, Ca, Cl, Fe, H, K, Na, P, S, Ti and Zn [587]. A portable system, known as PINS (portable isotopic neutron spectroscopy) is used by the US Army to detect, among other things, artillery shells and chemicalweapon containers (such as mustard gas) [588]. Pulsed neutrons generated by the interaction of high-energy photons (resulting from the bremsstrahlung radiation of a 6.5 MeV electron accelerator) were also used for elemental analysis by monitoring the gamma-ray emitted as soon as after each bremsstrahlung pulse [589]. Fast-Neutron In – Delayed-Gamma Out. A number of applications have taken advantage of the favorable conditions of delayed-gamma emission analysis, i.e. the ability to prolong irradiation time and perform measurements off-line in a low-background environment, combined with the capability to directly employ a neutron source in situ without the bulky configuration associated with moderated assemblies. Cyclic analysis can also be used with delayed-gamma analysis, to enhance the activation process for short-lived activation products. With a pulsed neutron generator, cycling can be achieved by repeated pulsing. The material content of elements listed in Table 8.5 can be detected by this method, enabling the analysis of metal alloys, minerals, oil, lubricants, and other organic materials. Reference [243] discussed many of the applications of this technique. Oxygen, an element that is difficult to measure by other methods, is wellsuited for fast-neutron activation, via the reaction. Since oxygen is not activated below 9.63 MeV neutron energy, a 14 MeV neutron generator is required. The high energy of emitted photons (6.13 MeV) makes it possible to study oxygen content in metals: steel,
Elemental and Content Analysis
533
titanium, aluminum, beryllium, copper, iron, nickel, chromium, zirconium, tantalum, molybdenum, niobium and cesium. The technique has also been used for the measurement of oxygen content in rocks and organic compounds. Reference [590] reported the use of this reaction to determine the amount of oxygen that may be present in Li-Si alloys in thermally-activated batteries. If air or water is introthe form of duced into the battery, it dioxides the lithium, degrading the battery’s performance [590]. Oxygen activation has also been used to detect water flow in producing and injection wells, to ensure that oil and gas production does not contaminate potable water supplies [323, 591]. Nitrogen can also be measured, via the positron-emitting reaction-product, if it is present in significant quantities, such as in plant materials (e.g. grain products), explosives and propellants, and rubber and fertilizers. Aluminum is also one of the elements that are quite amenable to fastneutron activation, particularly by the 0.84 MeV of the activation product (9.458 min, half-life), and thus the reaction was used for determining the aluminum concentration in bauxite and coal samples [384]. Some other reported applications include the determination of aluminum content in aircraft hydraulic systems (caused by metallic wear) and in engine oil, measurement of aluminum in composite propellants containing ammonium perchlorate, in minerals on the ocean bottom, and in copper and steel alloys. Copper is another element analyzed by this technique, as its activation produces the positron emitter Therefore, copper content in lubricating oils, ores, and brass alloys has been determined by this technique. The most abundant isotope of iron, a unique identifier of when activated by fast-neutrons produces iron. This is used for measuring iron in oil additives, hydraulic fluids, ocean-floor sediments and in bituminous coal samples. Neutron In – Charged-Particle Out. Neutron-absorption can lead to the production of charged-particles, via the or (n,p) reactions. Usually, the decay of the reaction products by gamma-emission is what is utilized in elemental applications. However, in some cases the emitted charged-particles themselves are detected and used to study the depth profile of the neutron-absorbing material. As indicated in section 8.5.2, this techniques requires a high neutron-flux to produce a high level of sensitivity, thus demands a neutron beam extracted from a nuclear reactor. Because of the short range of emitted charged-particles, the technique is limited to studying thin layers and films or in near-surface analysis (by detecting backscattered particles). The sample and the detector must also be enclosed within a vacuum chamber for charged-particles to maintain their energy of emission. The main elements studied by this
534
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
technique are and other elements are listed in Table 8.10. The main application of this technique is in analyzing boron content in semiconductor wafers, borophosphislicate glass and insulators of integrated circuits [264]. Boron is used as a doping material in microelectronic materials, and this technique enables studying the boron concentration and distribution. The method is also used to study the thickness of the boron layer in borophosphislicate glass, deposited as an insulating layer on dense integrated circuits. The technique has been employed for studying the distribution of light elements implanted in heavy matrix materials, such as Li in Nb, He in Nb and Mo [592]. Thermal-Neutron In – Neutrons Out. Neutron fission is the most obvious manifestation of a neutron producing more neutrons by activating, or in effect splitting, the target nucleus into many radioactive fragments. This process can be used for the detection of thorium, uranium and plutonium, by monitoring the delayed-neutrons emitted as a result of the decay of fission products, as explained in section 8.6.3. Thermalneutrons cause fission in both and while fast-neutrons cause fission in and Therefore, thermal-neutrons can be used to determine the concentration of which in natural materials is a direct indication of the total uranium content. Then, if this natural material, such as a geological sample, is exposed to a fast-neutron can be source, the amount of delayed-neutron emission caused by This method of calculated, with the excess count attributed to double irradiation is more readily accomplished by exposing the material first to a mixed source of thermal and fast neutrons, then to epithermal neutrons obtained by covering the material with cadmium or boron. The first exposure provides an indication of the total content of all fissionable materials, and the second exposure gives only the content of elements that are fissionable by fast-neutrons. This method is used for determining the to ratio in enriched or depleted uranium, the uranium-to-plutonium ratio in mixtures and in irradiated nuclear fuel [265]. Reference [593] described a system for measuring the content of fissile elements (in particular and in spent (irradiated) fuel rods of a light-water breeder reactor that utilized a (binary) fuel. A source was used to induce fission in the fuel rod. The source was surrounded with nickel metal (which has a high macroscopic elasticscattering cross-section) and moderated with polyethylene. An In/Cd foil was used to remove low-energy neutrons, since faster neutrons are less susceptible to self-attenuation within the fuel than slower neutrons.
Elemental and Content Analysis
535
Nevertheless, neutron-absorption within an interrogated fuel rod is compensated for by measuring the transmission of source neutrons within the rod, using a (miniature) fission counter (see section 4.4.1.3) to obtain an absorption indication similar to that provided by the fissile material in the fuel, shielded from the gamma-rays of the irradiated fuel with a lead shield. After activation, the rod is removed from the source region and the amount of delayed-neutrons resulting from fission are counted, using a proportional counter. The concentration of the fission products is measured by monitoring its gamma-emission energy (662 keV), using a collimated HPGe detector (see section 4.3.3), and the measured concentration is used to correct for neutron absorption by the fuel’s fission products. Delayed-neutron emission can also be used in principle for the measurement of and by the delayed-neutron precursors (178.3 ms) and (4.175 s half-life). Both the and by fast-neutrons (above 8.2 MeV reactions produce for the former reaction and above 10.5 MeV for the latter). However, can be due to the double reaction: folproduction of lowed by which is caused by thermal-neutron absorption. but the very short halfLithium-9 is produced by the reaction life of makes it difficult to detect with delayed-neutron analysis. Delayed-neutron activation has, however, been used for determining the oxygen and lithium content [265]. Emitted delayed-neutrons are fast-neutrons, but their detection is usually performed with thermal-neutron detectors covered with a moderated material, to increase the detection efficiency. Since neutron exposure can also lead to the release of gamma-rays by activating some elements in the sample, detectors that are not too sensitive to gamma-rays, such and detectors, are employed; preferably shielded by a lead as sleeve to further reduce gamma exposure. To detect delayed-neutrons, the inspected object has to be removed from direct exposure to source neutrons. This can be done by transferring the object out of the exposure zone, or applying a burst (pulse) or neutrons.
Non-thermal Neutron In - Fission-Neutrons Out. Fissionneutrons can also be distinguished, from incident slower neutrons, by their energy, as fission-neutrons have higher energy (2 MeV average energy, 0.72 MeV most probable energy). This process was used for the using, a photoneutron assay of fissile materials, particularly source. Either a or a photon source can be employed, along with a beryllium target, to produce relatively low-energy neutrons (see source, the average energy of the emitted section 2.17). For an
536
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
neurons is 26 keV and 4% of the neutrons are produced at a maximum source produces neutrons of an energy of about 360 keV, while a average energy of about 200 keV. The neutron energies of either sources are below the 1.2 MeV threshold-energy for fission of Therefore, source can be used for the detection of the neutrons of an which undergoes fission at any energy, in a fuel containing and such as an enriched or natural uranium. Reference [594] presented an assembly for use in the assay of reactor fuel rods and small samples of fissile material. This cylindrical assembly had a central hole within which a test sample is introduced. The central test channel is lined with cadmium to remove any thermal-neutrons that may reach the test object. The hole is surrounded with a beryllium layer (14 mm thick) within sources are located at two opposite sides of the sample which two for symmetric irradiation. The beryllium core is surrounded by nickel or titanium (20 to 30 mm), which act as filters (see section 6.46) that selectively reflect (by elastic scattering) source neutrons 26 keV) back to the test channel, while absorbing low-energy thermal-neutrons. The higher energy fission-neutrons are transmitted through towards detectors, assembled radially behind the filter layer. These detectors are source, shielded by lead (70 mm thick) from the gamma-rays of the and those of irradiated fuel rods. A 50 mm layer of iron was used as a reflector around the detector, to increase their count rate by redirecting the neutrons back towards the detectors. The entire assembly was shielded with a borated paraffin shield (about 145 mm thick). The uranium concentration in geological formation was also measured by inducing fission with a neutron source, by the fast-neutron and the thermal-neutron fission of The delayed neufission of trons accompanying the fission process are detected, after their slowingdown, and are distinguished from the source neutrons by their timedelay [595, 596, 597]. Alternatively, prompt fission-neutrons can be detected after they are slowed-down in the formation following the issuing of a pulse of neutrons from a neutron generator [595, 598]. The thermalneutron count rate in the delayed-neutron time-frame (i.e. following the decay of the source pulse) was shown to be greater in the presence of uranium [595]. The die-away time of fast/epithermal neutrons was also shown to be longer in the presence of uranium, that is, the neutron density decreases more slowly due to the production of fast-neutrons by fission [595]. The intensity of the detected fast and epithermal neutrons, following the issuing of the neutron pulse was shown to be directly proportional to the uranium grade (weight per cent). Another application of die-away is determining the degree of purity of graphite, since
Elemental and Content Analysis
537
neutron-absorbing impurities affect the decay-constant of the neutron pulse [599]. Fission induced by a neutron source, such as is used to detect the presence of plutonium in containers [600, 601], when the amount of fissile material is too small to produce sufficient spontaneous-fission and gamma-rays to permit passive assay (see section 12.1.2). The “shuffler” technique is used for this purpose, where a source is placed near the material to be inspected then quickly withdrawn. Delayed-neutron counting is then used to detect the presence and amount of fissile material [602, 603, 604, 605, 606]. The same concept is used to assess the criticality of fissile systems by source-driven noise analysis, since a small change in the fissile system affects the amount of fission introduced by the source and consequently the amount of delayed-neutrons and associated neutron noise after the withdrawal of the source [607]. Neutrons emitted from the spontaneous fission source can be time-tagged by monitoring the fission fragments associated with neutron emission. Such timing information is useful for distinguishing between source neutrons transmitted without interactions in the object and those scattered within the object, or generated by fission if the object contains a fissionable material. This concept is used in a system for nuclear weapon detection, which also analyzed gamma-emissions with time and frequency [608]. A similar approach was used to characterize large uranyl fluoride deposits on the pipes of a former uranium enrichment (gaseous diffusion) plant [609]. Analysis of neutron induced by a source in a subcritical assembly was also used to measure reactivity (degree of subcriticality) of assemblies. [610, 611, 612, 613, 614, 615]. Coincidence measurement of fission neutrons and gamma-rays, induced by an external of neutrons, is also used in fissile-material assaying [616].
12.1.1.2
Photon Activation
Photon In – Photon Out. In spite of the low cross-section of photonuclear reactions, and the fact that they requires the use of a highenergy electron accelerators to produce high-energy photons (tens of MeV’s), photon-activation analysis is particularly competitive over other analysis methods for the following elements: Na, Mg, Ti, V, Cr, Mn, Fe, Co, Zr, Y and Pb [617], see Table 8.9. It is also suited for O, C, N and F. Since photons offer good penetrability, the method can be used for bulk analysis of large objects. The emission of photons is usually the result of the decay of a reaction product, but photoexciation, the reaction,
538
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
is also possible, though not as useful as the other emission mechanisms for elemental determination. The application of photon activation analysis spans many fields. A comprehensive list of applications is given in reference [258], classified as environmental, biological, geological, industrial, archaeological and forensic. Reference [259] mentioned a number of applications. Multielemental analysis of garden soil, rocks, deep-sea sediments, and atmospheric particulate material was performed with this technique. Photon activation was employed for the detection of light-elements in high-purity metals and semiconductor material. Carbon and nitrogen contents in iron, cobalt and chromium, were also measured with the technique. Other detected elements include iodine in soil, nickel in geological material, carbon and trace elements in coal, and selenium in animal feed stuffs. Reference [259] also reported the use of photon activation to measure the protein content of cereals and vegetables. The technique was also used to analyze the composition of medieval iron-based sword and helmet using 30 MeV and 16 MeV bremsstrahlung radiation [406]. Photon-activation was also used in the assay of fission products in spent nuclear fuel assemblies, by the excitation of the fission product to its 4.5 h half-life metastable state and the subsequent counting of the 336 keV transition energy [618]. The gamma-rays (above 1.078 MeV) inducing activation are produced by the decay of the relatively long-lived fission products and Photon In – Neutron Out. Neutron emission by photon-activation can be either prompt or delayed, as discussed in section 8.6.1. Both techniques are suited for the analysis of and The ability to generate prompt neutrons at reasonably low photon-energies from interactions with make it feasible to detect deuterium and beryllium with isotopic sources, with photon energies above 1.67 MeV and 2.33 MeV, respectively. In the case of beryllium, being a solid, the reaction is used as a source of neutrons, see Table 2.17, while photon interactions with deuterium in nuclear reactors (such as CANDU reactors) present an additional source of reactivity. In NDE applications, the radioisotopic sources (2.754 MeV, 99.94% yield) and (2.091 MeV, 5.51% yield) can both be used for detecting while the former is required for detecting In the presence of both elements simultaneously, can be used first to measure the content, and a source is used to measure the total content of both elements. Using photons from a source, the concentration of heavy water in light water [619], and in soil moisture [619, 620], was determined by measuring the neutrons produced via
Elemental and Content Analysis
539
the reaction The same process was used to monitor tritiated water, using as a tag [621]. In addition to these isotopic sources, accelerators can be used to provide a higher photon flux, and hence lower detection limits [259]. Reference [26] suggested the use of the 6.13 and 7.12 MeV gamma-rays produced by the decay of (see section 2.2.4) to detect fissile materials (by the induced photofission [622]), as well as and (considered special nuclear materials) by the reaction. A similar approach is described in reference [623], using a transposable electron accelerator producing 6, 9 and 8 MeV pulsed electron beams (with a pulse duration). repetition rate between 10 to 300 Hz and a 4.5 Another application of photoneutron emission is in the detection of and [624]. Photofisthe fissionable elements: sion occurs when these elements are bombarded by high-energy photos, resulting in a neutron yield much higher than the photoneutron production by other elements. This makes it possible to detect these elements even if they are embedded within another material (as in the case of nuclear waste casks) or encased within cladding (as in the case of fuel rods) [259]. However, the need to use photons of energy in excess of 5 MeV, makes it necessary to employ an accelerator. The penetrability of both incident photons and the fission fast-neutrons makes it also possible to analyze a large volume of material. The analysis of these elements can either be done by monitoring the prompt emission of neutrons by the reaction and by the subsequent fission introduced by the resulting neutrons, or by monitoring the delayed neutrons resulting from the decay of fission produces. In prompt analysis, the background neutron count rate can be high due to neutron production by the reaction with other elements in the inspected object, or with the surrounding shielding and structure material. Delayed-neutron analysis reduces this background signal and can be accomplished by simply turning off the photon-producing accelerator. Neutrons from the photoneutron reaction may also be used to induce neutron activation. For example, by introducing a beryllium photoneutron converter into spent-fuel assemblies, neutrons will be produced by photons from the decay of fission products which emit photons with an energy greater than 1.67 MeV. This mechanism was used to assay spent nuclear fuel assemblies for these fission products by neutron activation of the fission product producing that decays with a 54.1 min giving 417, 1097, 1293 and 2112 keV decay gamma-rays [618]. Delayed-neutron emission, following photon-activation, is also useful for the detection of boron, oxygen and fluorine by the production of the fast-decaying (about 1 s half-life) neutron emitters and as
540
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
explained in section 8.6.1. The short half-life of the these isotopes enables on-line detection of these elements [259]. Also the high energy of incident photons and emitted neutrons makes it possible to analyze an entire object, rather than a small sample of material. The reaction (16.3 MeV threshold-energy) can be used to measure the concentration of by monitoring the delayed-neutrons emitted from the (15.7 MeV threshold-energy) is also useful for latter. The measuring the concentration of by monitoring the 511 keV gamma(a positron emitter, 122.24 s halfrays associated with the decay of life). These two reactions were used for measuring the isotopic concentration ratios of these two oxygen isotopes [625]. The isotope is also useful as a radiotracer for studying the deposition of oxygen. The reaction can be used for measuring the nitrogen concentration, hence the detection of nitrogen-rich explosives [626, 627]. The product isotope, is a positron emitter, with a half-life of 9.97 minutes [13]. The positrons are annihilated by the surrounding electrons of the medium, producing two 511 keV photons emitted into opposite directions. The intensity of these photons is a direct indication of the nitrogen concentration in the material within which is produced. The production of this isotope requires photons of energy of at least 13.5 MeV, which can be produced with a linear accelerator [627]. At this energy, not too many other elements produce positrons, or if produced would have very short or very long half-life. Note also that other positron emitting isotopes can be produced by photon activation: at at and at where is the gamma-ray energy [628]. Although the emitted photoneutrons are fast-neutrons, a thermaldetector, can be used for their detecneutron detector, such as the tion, in spite of its low efficiency, as it is less sensitive than other types of neutron detectors to gamma-rays (see section 4.4). Another approach to neutron detection, particularly suited for this application, is to use a manganese bath to slow-down neutrons and hence increase their crossThe many gamma-rays (ranging section for the reaction in energy from 26.6 keV to 7.4 MeV [12]) emitted by the decay of (2.58 h, half-life) can then be detected with a Na(I) detector [259]. This allows the detection of prompt-neutrons after the source is turned-off, which in turn reduces the effect of source photons and the associated background signal produced by photon scattering in the surroundings.
Photon In – Charged-Particle Out. As indicated in section 8.5, on one hand a high photon-energy is required to induce charged-particles; on the other hand, charged-particles have limited penetrability in mat-
Elemental and Content Analysis
541
ter. The latter fact necessitates the use of thin objects, to allow emitted particles to escape. However, for such a thin object, high-energy photons would hardly interact. Therefore, this interaction modality is not quite useful for elemental analysis, except when high-energy beta-emitters or positrons are produced. However, the technique has been used to measure the concentration of lithium, beryllium and sulfur. The three useful reactions in this regard, as indicated in section 8.5 are: (beta, 3.51 MeV, 0.81 s half-life), (beta, 13 MeV, 0.84 s), and (positron, 4.39 MeV, 2.56 s); where the values in brackets indicate, respectively, the type of particle emitted, its maximum positron energy and the half-life of its originating nucleus. The high energy of emitted particles and their low mass enables them to penetrate thicker objects. The increased thickness also enhances the probability of interaction of the incident high-energy photons. However, the short half-life of the isotopes resulting from these photonuclear reactions necessitates the use of a very rapid mechanism to remove the object, and isolate it, for subsequent delayed-emission analysis. Although these short half-lives makes it possible in principle to perform on-line analysis, the high-energy of incident photons (above 12 MeV) can overwhelm the detection system, since high-energy electrons are produced by the Compton scattering of these photons with the surrounding material. At higher photon energy is produced by the photon activation of Boron-12 (> 50 MeV), has a half life of 20 ms and decays by emitting high-energy electrons. The bremsstrahlung radiation associated with these electrons may be used to detect nitrogen, say in explosives
12.1.1.3
Charged-Particle Activation
The poor penetrability of charged-particles limits their use to nearsurface analysis. On the other hand, their unique feature of losing energy continuously provides them with the ability to determine the spatial distribution of element concentration, i.e. depth profiling. Some specific applications are discussed below. Charged-Particle In – Charged-Particle Out.
As discussed in
section 8.5.3, the energy of emitted charged-particles, for a given source energy, not only indicates whether a particular reaction has taken place, but also it uniquely determines the direction of emission, hence the location of scattering, Eq. (8.9). Therefore, charged-particle spectrometry has been used to measure the distribution of a number of light elements implanted in a heavier matrix material [257]. This analysis has, however, to be performed in vacuum, so that the detected charged-particles do not lose energy after emission from the inspected object. Table 8.11
542
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
lists some of the useful reactions for this technique. The depth profile of hydrogen, deuterium, or helium implanted in metals, was measured with this reaction. Other depth-profile measurements include those of beryllium in nickel alloys, boron in semiconductor (silicon) wafers and glass, and carbon in tantalum carbide films, thin plastic sheets, and organic materials. The depth profile of nitrogen in glass, silicon wafers, steel, organic materials (such as seeds) and human tooth dentine, was also measured with this reaction. The positrons arising from the decay of (66 s, half-life), with the latter produced by the reaction was used to determine the nitrogen content in diamond [629]. The distribution of oxygen in a metal is determined by the reaction since the proton reaction with is endoergic. (0.20%) is compensated for by the The low natural abundance of reactively high cross-section of the reaction for incident protons of energy in the range of 600 to 800 keV. This method is used to examine the oxygen profile in niobium and in steel exposed to moist carbon dioxide Reference [630] reported the use of this reaction, with labeled with as a tracer, to measure the oxygen profile in rutile and sapphire. Most commonly though, a deuteron beam is used for analysis, either with the (d,p) or the reactions, both are exoergic reactions, but the (d,p) reaction is preferred because of the longer range of protons. Therefore, the (n,p) reaction with was utilized for determining the oxygen distribution in silicon wafers and tooth enamel. The reactions and were also used to study the oxygen profile, in particular in the analysis of pellets exposed to a leachant comparable to thermal granite ground water [630]. The distribution of heavy elements embedded in a matrix of other heavy elements has also been studied with charged-particle spectroscopy. Reference [257] reported the determination of the profiles of silicon in metals, chromium in thin layers on metal substrate, and nickel on substrates of metal (copper), while reference [630] discussed the use of the technique for investigating the carbon content of ceramic substrates utilized in high-performance packaging technology, the sulfur diffusion in bulk CdTe and CdTe/CdSi thin-film hetrojunction solar cells, and the silicon diffusion from a thin Si film into polycrystalline gold foils. The reaction induced by 3 MeV ions, was used to detect carbon impurities introduced in the manufacturing of HgCdMnTe semiconductors; is a positron emitter with a 20.38 min half-life [631]. The reaction also takes place, enabling the detection of the oxygen concentration by the annihilation of the positrons emitted by the decay of with a 109.72 min half-life.
Elemental and Content Analysis
543
The superb selectivity and high counting efficiency of coincidence measurement of the two reaction products emitted by charged-particle activation, see section 8.5.3, is particularly useful for detecting trace or small amounts of elements. The method has been used for the determination of trace amounts of hydrogen in aluminum, titanium, uranium and in polyester plastics films [257]. The selectivity of the coincide method makes it also attractive for the isotopic composition determination of lithium and boron [257]. The reaction is utilized in an alpha-proton-x-ray spectrometer (APXs) to analyze in situ the composition of the surface of Mars in the Pathfinder mission [632, 633, 634] and in the Surveyor lunar missions [635], see section 12.1.5. The reactions provided data on light elements (carbon to iron), while the x-rays (produced as a result of atomic excitation by the alpha-source) enables the detection of elements heavier than silicon. Charged-Particle In – Photon Out. This method is often referred to as PIGME, for particle-induced gamma emission. Some elements that can be detected by this technique are given in Table 8.7, and many others are cataloged in reference [257]. The limited range of incident charged-particles makes it possible to confine elemental analysis to near the surface of an object. This makes the technique particularly useful for analyzing small samples, or for studying the distribution of elements implanted in metals to improve their surface quality. The method can monitor either the gamma-rays promptly emitted with the activation reaction or the delayed photons produced as the activation products decay. The former method is known as PIPPS (particle-induced prompt photon spectrometry), as it involves measuring the energy of the emitted gamma-rays to identify the characteristic emission of the elements of interest. The prompt gamma-emission method has been used in many applications [257]. Fluorine was measured in glass, air, cement ores and food samples. Sulfur in coal, magnesium in vegetation, beryllium in air-born dust and in boron carbide, were also measured with the technique. The method was also used for determining the elemental content of chalcogenide glasses (S, As, Ge and Te), and for analyzing archeological artifacts for B, F, Na, Mg, Al, Si, Cu. Geological samples were also analyzed for Li, F, Na, Mg, Al, Ti, Mn and Te. The C, O, Si, Cr, Co, V and Mo content of in steel and the B, Li, F, Na content of niobium was also evaluated. The method was also used for the isotopic analysis of enriched boron. Delayed gamma-emission is mainly used for the detection of light elements (B, C, N and O) in metals and semiconductor materials [255].
544
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
Charged-Particle In – Neutron out. This technique is suitable for measuring light elements: Li, B, C, N, Ca and O. Neutron mission by charged-particle activation has been also used in some applications, in spite of the relatively complex process of measuring the spectrum of neutrons [257]. The technique has been used for the measurement of deuterium concentration in gases (housed in a thin nickel window). Nitrogen in gases and steel, and oxygen in gases and metals, were also measured. The isotopic content of calcium enriched with or were also determined by this method. In the case of oxygen, it can The threshold energy for be measured via the reaction this reaction is only 0.6992 MeV, allowing the use of one of the isotopic sources listed in Table 2.1. Reference [257] reported the utilization of a source for this purpose. Note also that the Be reaction is commonly employed in neutron sources (see section 2.3), because of the low coulomb barrier of beryllium. Therefore, beryllium can be readily detected with the reaction, using either an isotopic source or a ion beam.
12.1.2.
Passive Emission
As indicated in section 8.8.2, radioactive isotopes in a nuclear materials and radioactive waste are identified by their emitted characteristic gamma-rays. Gamma spectroscopy is routinely used for this purpose in nuclear facilities and in nuclear-weapons verification. Radiation emission is also used for detecting tritium in air [636], water [637] and aqueous solutions [638] of nuclear power plants employing heavy water as a coolant, by detecting the beta-rays (18 keV maximum energy) emitted from the decay of (12.3 year, half-life); produced by neutron-absorption by the deuterium of heavy water. Natural emission of radiation is also used in well-logging. Below the surface of the Earth, gamma activity is high in oil-bearing shales, medium for sand, and low for dense carbonates and anhydrites. Naturalradioactivity logs are, therefore, used to locate oil and natural gas. This can be done either by measuring the total radioactivity, including all sources of natural radiation, or by performing gamma-ray spectroscopy to determine the content of U, Th or the U/Th ratio. As indicated in section 8.8.2, the high penetrability of gamma-rays makes them more suited than charged-particles (alpha and beta particles) for use in applications involved large objects, such as the surroundings of a borehole. At any rate, alpha and beta natural emissions are quite weak to be of a practical use in well-logging. The well-logging device for natural emission is simply a photon detector, housed in a steel casing to protect it against hydrostatic pressure.
Elemental and Content Analysis
545
The detector can be hanged by a cable in wireline arrangement, or incorporated into the drill pipe to perform measurements while a well is drilled. In either case, measurements can be stored in a computer chip and sent to the surface through telemetry. Any of the gamma-ray detectors described in chapter 4 can be used for this purpose. However, scintillator detectors have the advantage of high efficiency, which makes it possible to use smaller detectors. In well-logging, a small detector provides a smaller vertical spatial resolution, as it enables the recordings of more measurement points in the log as the tool is driven down a borehole. Geiger-Müller tubes, though less sensitive than scintillators, and have a slower response-time, are inexpensive and simple to operate (as they produce large pulses, and as such require no amplification), but typically large-size tubes are required. Ionization-chambers are large in size and less efficient than scintillation detectors, but are relatively simple since their charge-carriers are collected directly, without the use of fragile photomultiplier tubes as is the case with scintillators. The count rate of a well-logging tool measuring the total natural radioactivity can be modeled as [40]:
where C is the total measurable gamma-radiation signal, is the bulk density of the formation in which the borehole is drilled, is the density of the radioactive mineral or element present in the formation at and is an activity factor characterizing the ravolume fraction dioactivity of mineral or element The model of Eq. (12.1) reflects the fact that the gamma-count rate will depend on the concentration of the radioactive material in the medium, i.e. to the summation of the density of the individual radioactive isotopes However, the density of since the activity per unit each isotope is weighted by the factor, weight of one isotope is different from the others. The factor is typically given relative to the gamma-ray activity per unit weight of where the subscript refers to the element involved. Subsequently, for thorium, [40]. In spite and for uranium of its low relative contribution, contributes significantly (typically about 50%) to the gamma count, as it is more abundant than thorium (28%) and uranium (24%). The bulk density of the formation, is included in the model of Eq. (12.1) to account for the fact that the emitted radiation signal is modified by absorption by the material of the formation. Therefore, a radioactive material present at a certain abundance in a dense formation would give rise to a radiation count lower than that obtained for the same abundance in a lighter formation.
546
Radiation Probing, Gauging, Imaging and Analysis
The measurement model of Eq. (12.1) indicates that, if the total count rate is measured (giving only one piece of information), neither the nature of the active elements nor their relative contribution can be determined. However, the overall level of activity is indicative of shaliness, since shales are the most common radioactive rocks. When the energy spectrum of emitted radiation is measured, typically using a scintillation detector, such NaI(Tl), the intensity of emissions from and the daughters of can be quantified. Since rocks year of age or older are considered to be in secular equilibrium, see section 3.7, the concentration of all members of the decay series of thorium or uranium can be calculated, if the concentration of one of the members of the decay series is measured. Therefore, it is sufficient to measure the at 2.62 MeV concentration of one of the daughters of thorium gamma) and one of the daughters of at 1.76 MeV gamma), see section 8.8.2. Potassium-40 is detected by its unique gamma-emission at 1.46 MeV. Therefore, typically the radiation intensity corresponding to these three energy bins are used to calculate the concentration of the corresponding elements. However, a certain energy bin corresponding to one isotopes is also sensitive to the presence of other isotopes, due to the emission and subsequent scattering within the detector of photons by other daughters isotopes of thorium and uranium. Therefore, the count rate, at an energy bin is generally expressed as [40]:
where and are coefficients for energy bin obtained from calibration. Calibration is initially performed in a special pit containing known concentrations of the three radioactive elements, potassium, thorium and uranium. In the field, a block of material of known concentration of radioactivity (such as monazite) is used to check and adjust the positioning of the energy bins of the spectrum [40]. More than three energy bins can also be monitored, including bins at lower energies (resulting from Compton scattering of higher energy photons within the detector, as well as from lower energy emissions from the daughters of and This also helps reduce the effect of the detector’s escape peaks, resulting from pair-production interactions in the detector (see section 4.3). The use of additional energy bins overdetermines the problem, enabling a least-squares solution that minimizes the effect of statistical variations on the measurements. This is particularly helpful in spectroscopy measurements at lower count rates. Many spectrum measurements can be obtained as a detector is lowered into a borehole. It is then desirable to filter the acquired measurements to reduce the effect of statistical variability on the results, see section 4.5.7.1. Another prob-
Elemental and Content Analysis
547
lem that can degrade the quality of spectral data is detector drifting, due to temperature changes. This is overcome by employing stabilizing electronics, see also section 4.5.7.1. A number of other pa