Flat and Curved Space-Times SECOND EDITION George F. R. Ellis Distinguished Professor of Complex Systems Mathematics Dep...
146 downloads
2539 Views
4MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Flat and Curved Space-Times SECOND EDITION George F. R. Ellis Distinguished Professor of Complex Systems Mathematics Department, University of Cape Town
and
Ruth M. Williams Fellow and Lecturer in Mathematics Girton College and Assistant Director of Research, Department of Applied Mathematics and Theoretical Physics, University of Cambridge
Diagrams by
Mauro Carfora Department of Nuclear and Theoretical Physics, University of Pavia
OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS
OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS Great Clarendon Street, Oxford OX2 6DP Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford. It furthers the University's objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education by publishing worldwide in
Oxford New York
Athens Auckland Bangkok Bogota Buenos Aires Calcutta Cape Town Chennai Dar es Salaam Delhi Florence Hong Kong Istanbul Karachi Kuala Lumpur Madrid Melbourne Mexico City Mumbai Nairobi Paris Sao Paulo Singapore Taipei Tokyo Toronto Warsaw with associated companies in Berlin Ibadan.
Oxford is a registered trade mark of Oxford University Press in the UK and in certain other countries
Published in the United States by Oxford University Press Inc., New York © George F. R. Ellis and Ruth M. Williams 1988, 2000 The moral rights of the author have been asserted Database right Oxford University Press (maker) First edition 1988 Second edition 2000
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, without the prior permission in writing of Oxford University Press, or as expressly permitted by law, or under terms agreed with the appropriate reprographics rights organization. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside the scope of the above should be sent to the Rights Department, Oxford University Press, at the address above
You must not circulate this book in any other binding or cover and you must impose this same condition on any acquirer A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data (Data available) ISBN 0-19-850657-0 Hardback ISBN 0-19-850656-2 Paperback
Typeset by Newgen Imaging Systems (P) Ltd., Chennai, India Printed in Great Britain on acid-free paper by T.J. International Ltd, Padstow, Cornwall
Preface This book grew out of a series of lectures and a summer school course given by one of us (G.F.R.E.) at the University of Cape Town. A series of notes taken by a student (Gavin Hough) was useful in preparing the text, the major part of which was completed while G.F.R.E. was at the University of Texas and R.M.W. at the
Institute for Advanced Study, Princeton. We thank Marilyn Brink, Colin Myburgh, Sasha Loncarevic, and Clive Khouny for useful criticisms of a draft of
the text. We decided to turn the notes into an introductory book because we believed that, despite the proliferation of books on relativity theory, there was no equivalent text available. We hope that the book will make a solid understanding of flat and curved space-times accessible to a wider audience than hitherto.
We are extremely grateful to Dr Mauro Carfora for combining his artistic skills with his knowledge of relativity to produce the diagrams in the book. Relativity may at first seem to the reader to be an abstract theory, far removed from the reality of everyday life. By the end of the book, we will have demonstrated that this theory is of fundamental importance not only for elementary particle physics and astronomy, but also in the way it affects conditions of life in the world around us. We shall also see that the cover photograph, showing an eclipse of the Sun by the Earth, as seen from an Apollo spacecraft, illustrates several features of relativity. [Editor's note: the front cover of the second edition has a different photograph; it shows the galaxy NGC 3377, which is believed to have a black hole at its centre. As we shall see, this also illustrates several features of relativity.] October 1987
G.F.R.E. R.M.W.
Preface to the Second Edition We have been very pleased to prepare a second edition of this book, at the request of Oxford University Press, in order to bring this presentation of relativity theory up to date (and allowing us to correct some errors and areas of lack of clarity that have been pointed out by readers). While the foundations of the subject remain the same as ever, there has been marked progress in some areas of application of relativity theory, particularly because of the vast explosion of new astronomical data from powerful new ground-based telescopes such as Keck, and a series of satellite observatories: IRAS (infra-red astronomical satellite), COBE (cosmic background radiation explorer), the Hubble space telescope, ROSAT (X-ray),
and so on. Also, for example, gravitation radiation detectors have made enormous strides, and major new-generation gravitational wave observatories will come on line in the next five years or so, opening up a new astronomical channel of observation. The observational situation is being transformed. Thus this revision presents a substantial amount of new material that takes
these developments into account. However, we have not altered the basic structure of the book, despite critical comments by some reviewers. The prime cause of dissatisfaction to some is that we take so long to reach the Lorentz transformation-traditionally, an early part of many presentations. This policy of ours is deliberate. We believe it is essential to get the grounding right first, and
that takes a long time and considerable thought; it should not be rushed. It is possible to move quickly to the Lorentz transformations, and learn to manipulate
them mechanically, but that does not mean that what they represent is understood in a serious way. Our aim is to solidly lay the foundations, first deriving all the main relativity results in a simple and well-grounded way, and only then use the Lorentz transformations as a device for summarizing concisely what has been discovered.
The other way of presentation (effectively starting with the Lorentz transformation) is right for some readers; ours is right for many others, as readers' comments testify. So the basic presentation is the same as before. We hope that you will find it enlightening. July 2000
G.F.R.E.
R.M.W.
We dedicate this book to our daughters Margaret Ellis and Miriam Saxl
Contents Introduction
1. Space-time diagrams and the foundations of special relativity 1.1 The concept of a space-time 1.2 Causality and the speed of light 1.3 Relative motion in special relativity
1
5 5
12
24
2. Fundamentals of measurement 2.1 Time 2.2 Distance 2.3 Simultaneity 2.4 World maps, world pictures, and radar maps
35 35 37 41
3,. Measurements in flat space-times 3.1 The Doppler effect 3.2 Relative velocity 3.3 Simultaneity 3.4 Time dilation 3.5 Length contraction 3.6 The whole package of kinematic effects 3.7 Relativistic dynamics 3.8 The consistency of physics
49 49 59 70 76 88 96 102 120
4. The Lorentz transformation and the invariant interval 4.1 The Lorentz transformation 4.2 Space-time separation invariants 4.3 Some flat-space universes
122 122 139 162
5. Curved space-times 5.1 The general concept 5.2 Acceleration and gravitation: the principle of equivalence 5.3 Freely falling motion and the meaning of geodesics
186 186
44
189 195
x
Contents
5.4 5.5 5.6 5.7 5.8 5.9 5.10 5.11 5.12
The metric form and the metric tensor The field equations Light rays Causality Parallel propagation along a curve Further tests of Einstein's theory Gravitational waves Detection of gravitational waves Alternative theories and approaches
201
206 209 217 219 222 226 229 232
6. Spherical and stellar collapse The Schwarzschild solution 6.1 Spherical collapse to black holes 6.2 More general black holes 6.3 Black hole evaporation and thermodynamics 6.4 Black hole candidates and ways of detecting them 6.5
240 240 249 255 257 260
7. Simple cosmological models Space-time geometry 7.1 The evolution of the universe 7.2 Observable quantities 7.3
264 264
7.4 7.5 7.6 7.7 7.8 7.9
New observational data The light cone, observational limits, and horizons Steady-state and inflationary universes Small universes Alternative universes Observational tests
271
277 284 293 301 305 308 311
8. Finale
313
Afterword
315
Appendices Line integrals A. B.
C.
Four-vectors and relativistic dynamics Four-vectors, electromagnetism, and energymomentum conservation
318 325 341
Symbols used
368
Index
369
Introduction The aim of this book is to demonstrate the unifying power of the concept of a space-time in understanding the nature of the physical world. It will do so firstly by giving a good understanding of the nature and meaning of the flat space-time of the special theory of relativity, and features of that theory such as length contraction, time dilation, and the twin paradox. Secondly it will provide an introduction to the nature and meaning of the curved space-times of the general theory of relativity, including the concept of the expanding universe and the nature of black holes. Both of these theories of relativity are due to Albert Einstein (Fig. 0.1), the special theory being completed in 1905 and the general theory in 1916.
Einstein's theories of relativity and their dramatic revelations of the unexpected nature of space-time are among the major scientific discoveries of this century, replacing the ideas about space and time that had been believed since Galileo and Newton. It is fundamental in approaching these topics that the reader be prepared to drop his/her preconceived. ideas about the nature of distance measurements, time measurements, simultaneity, and causality. This is perhaps Einstein's greatest single contribution to the understanding of spacetime: teaching us to question the commonplace ideas about these concepts. The resulting revolution in understanding, leading to the discovery of length contraction, time dilation ('a moving clock goes slow'), the relativity of simultaneity, and the fact that space-time geometry and causality are determined by the matter in it, will be explored in depth in this book. One should note that the kinematic effects discussed here are only dramatic when speeds near the speed of light are involved; they are negligible in ordinary everyday life. That is why we do not understand these effects intuitively as `the way things are'. However, many of the consequences of special relativity are significant in situations that do not involve high-speed motion; in particular, the nature of magnetic forces and the possibility of nuclear power are two such consequences of considerable-importance. The concept of space-time presented here is a model of reality used with great success by theoretical physicists. It summarizes the nature of spatial and time relationships in a concise way, and is a very good illustration of the use of geometry in understanding physics. The point of a geometrical picture is that it represents in a concise way many analytical relationships that are tedious to describe in full, and are difficult to understand when they are written out in detail. These pictures enable to understand in a direct way the results of distance and
2
Introduction
Fig. 0.1 Albert Einstein, who proposed the special theory of relativity in 1905 and the
general theory of relativity in 1916 thereby bringing the study of flat and curved space-
times into the main-stream of physics. (the photograph shows Einstein in 1933.) (Photograph from the Amercian Institute of Physics.)
time measurements and so are a very useful tool in making predictions about the results of physical experiments. One should remember that the space-time view embodied in relativity theory is a model of reality which has been tested by many physical experiments, and depicts more correctly than other models the results of these experiments. It is thus a way of summarizing much of what we know about
the physical universe. The understanding obtained through the concept of a
Introduction
3
space-time shows how various features that we at first may regard as independent
of each other are in fact manifestations of the same underlying physical phenomena. Thus this concept is not merely a tool to use in making predictions efficiently, but also provides a way of understanding a deeper unity in nature than is obvious on the surface. Being able to understand fully the concept of a space-time implies being able to calculate the results of measurements in particular space-times. We shall show
how this can be done without employing more than school-level mathematics plus the simple concept of a line integral (explained in Appendix A). Thus we believe that anyone with a good grasp of school algebra, some trigonometry, and
the concept of a function should be able to follow our detailed argument including the calculations (in this respect our book is similar to Lilley's book Discovering Relativity for Yourself, Cambridge University Press, 1981, which gives a more extended introduction to the actual details of calculation than we do here). In a few restricted places in the main text, the idea of a derivative is also needed; omitting these sections will not impair understanding of the major thrust of our argument. We recommend that the serious reader should indeed try to follow all the calculations presented in the main text and attempt at least some of the examples, both for the satisfaction this will afford and because this is the way to fullest understanding of the concepts presented. Restrictions on the length of
the book meant that we were not able to include solutions to the exercises. However, a set of notes containing a mixture of complete solutions, hints, and answers to the problems may be obtained separately from the authors (please write to Dr R. M. Williams). For fun, we have included some examples involving
writing programs for a microcomputer; these examples enable a good visual presentation of some of the ideas, and are amusing to carry out, but again they are not essential to understanding the text. We suggest that, if at any time you feel that you are becoming stuck in detailed argument or calculations, you should just note the general ideas presented and go on to the next section. An acquaintance with school level physics will make the argument easier to follow at some places, but a lack of this background will not prevent the'reader
from grasping the main ideas. We show how the concepts of energy and momentum are united through the concept of a space-time four-vector, leading to the famous result E = mcz (Appendix B); and how electricity and magnetism are united in a space-time tensor, leading to the fundamental understanding of a magnetic field as being essentially an electric field viewed from a relatively moving frame (Appendix Q. These topics have been separated from the main text because their full development requires somewhat more mathematics than the main text (full appreciation of Appendix C requires sufficient knowledge of partial derivatives to understand Maxwell's equations in vector notation). Thus
while this material will be interesting and useful to anyone who wishes to understand these dynamical applications of relativity theory, it is not essential to the understanding of the kinematics described in the main part of the book. With these appendices, the book describes sufficient material on special relativity to give adequate understanding for most first-year university physics courses on the subject; however, the main text should be accessible to a wider circle of readers,
4
Introduction
namely, any interested person with a reasonable knowledge of school mathematics, and the will to follow the argument through (and indeed could serve as a text for courses such as described by T. A. Roman in `General relativity, black holes and cosmology: a course for non-scientists', American Journal of Physics 54, 144, 1986). Should you not have a background in physics but wish to follow through some of the physics arguments a bit further, the book Time, Space and Things by B. K. Ridley (Cambridge, 1984) might be a good starting point. This book focuses particularly on understanding relativity from a geometrical viewpoint (perhaps the most similar other approaches being those in Geroch's book General Relativity from A to B, University of Chicago Press, 1978, and in Lilley's book mentioned above). We make particular use of Bondi's K-calculus to determine the results of calculations in flat space-time (Hermann Bondi used this
approach in a successful BBC television series on relativity, and published accounts of it in his books Relativity and Common Sense, Anchor Books, 1964,
and Assumption and Myth in Physical Theory, Cambridge University Press, 1967). Instead of starting off with the Lorentz transformation as the basis of the argument, we arrive at this concept fairly late in our presentation, when it appears as a convenient unified way of summarizing relationships we have previously derived by use of the K-calculus. Our presentation of the nature of simple curved
space-times centres on showing the reader how he or she may deduce many properties of these space-times directly from their interval. Further reading is suggested in the concluding section of the main text ('Afterword'), and the reader will find that the Index has been carefully prepared as a guide to the terms used and ideas presented throughout the book. While we have endeavoured to present the material covered thoroughly, we have also tried to do so concisely so that the overall size of the volume will not be excessive or daunting. The first part of the book may seem to some to be rather leisurely, because all the detail is spelt out. This is a conscious decision on our part: we feel that the average textbook goes too fast through the fundamentals. The serious student will probably be able to read the first few chapters fairly quickly, but will benefit from this thorough grounding; he/she will find the main increment of difficulty is in the Appendices, whose inclusion results in covering what is needed for a first university course in relativity. On the other hand readers for whom they are too technical may well omit these appendices. We believe that in their case the book will provide a good opportunity for the interested non-specialist reader or early student to understand the nature of flat and curved space-times, and how they determine physical measurements of time, distances, and instantaneity, without becoming bogged down in mathematical formalism. Thus the reader will become familiar with one of the foundations of our modern understanding of the nature of the physical world.
1
Space-time diagrams and the foundations of special relativity 1.1
The concept of a space-time
Space and time are notions familiar to everyone. We shall explore the way in
which they form a single entity called space-time, firstly according to the ordinary everyday view of how events occur (i.e. according to Newtonian theory). In later sections we shall examine the space-time description of relativity theory.
Space-time according to a single observer Consider a cine camera set up above a billiard table, pointing directly down to take a series of photographs of the billiard balls on the table (Fig. 1.1a). We may use x and y coordinates to express the position of each of the balls, and could even
make these coordinates explicit by marking a coordinate grid on the billiard table. Suppose that one of the balls moves as time progresses, while the rest are stationary. Then the x and y coordinates of this ball will change with time according to this motion, and this will be reflected in the photographs. Now imagine cutting the cine film to separate the images (Fig. 1.1 b) and then stacking these photographs one above the other in their correct time sequence, with the earliest photograph at the bottom and the latest at the top (Fig. l.lc). The position of each ball at any time t = t' is represented by the position of its image in the corresponding photograph, with its successive positions at later times recorded in the subsequent photographs higher up in the stack. Thus a glance at this stack of pictures will show the way the arrangement of the balls '
changes with time; in particular it will show how one ball moves and the others are all stationary. This stack of photographs already contains the essential idea of a space-time,
namely the presentation of a time sequence of images one above the other showing the successive positions of objects in the space considered (here, the surface of the table). However, there is one problem: the stack of photographs is very frail: one sneeze will destroy its order. To remedy this, imagine taking the
stack of photographs and fusing them together in an oven, to obtain a solid, durable space-time (Fig. 1.1 d). This is a three-dimensional space-time, with the vertical axis depicting time, represented by a coordinate t (measured by a clock), and the horizontal axes depicting spatial position on the surface of the table,
represented by coordinates x and y (measured by rulers). The space-time represents the histories of all objects in the two-dimensional space. Thus the
6
Space-time diagrams and the foundations of special relativity
x (b)
(a)
y t
t1
x (c)
(d)
Fig.1.1 Constructing a space-time. (a) A cine camera takes photographs of billiard balls on a table. One ball moves relative to the others. (b) A series of photographs from the film. (c) The photographs stacked together, later ones above the earlier ones. (d) The photographs fused together to form a `space-time', with time coordinate t and spatial coordinates x, y.
histories of the stationary billiard balls are represented by vertical tubes in the space-time, while the history of a ball moving to the left is represented by a tube sloping over to the left. To recover the detailed history of motions of objects in the space, simply consider a series of horizontal sections of the space-time (surfaces
of instantaneity) at later and later times. These sections intersect the tubes representing the histories of the stationary balls at x and y coordinate positions that stay constant (showing that they are indeed stationary), and intersect the tube representing the ball moving to the left in positions that are successively more to the left (showing it does indeed move to the left). In effect, by considering a succession of time slices in this way one can reconstruct a series of images
corresponding to the photographs from which the space-time was initially constructed, and then by considering these in turn one can visualize the motion of the particles as in a cine film. The space-time therefore completely represents these motions.
The space-time we have constructed is three-dimensional, representing the
histories of objects in a two-dimensional space (the surface of the table).
1.1
The concept of a space
7
Of course, real space-time is four-dimensional, with three space dimensions (described by coordinates x, y, z) and one time dimension (described by the coordinate t), representing the histories of all objects in three-dimensional space.
We cannot easily represent this in a single picture. However a study of threedimensional (or even two-dimensional) space-times will enable us to understand
many of the properties of the full four-dimensional space-time. We will demonstrate this in the rest of this book.
Space-time according to different observers
Different observers will in general have different views of the space-time. Returning to consider the billiard table discussed above, we suppose now that in addition to a camera A held fixed above the billiard table, (Fig. 1.2a), there is a second camera B, which moves with the moving ball (Fig. 1.2b).* To simplify matters suppose that the ball moves parallel to the x-axis; then the camera will also move parallel to the x axis at the same speed as the ball, directly above it, so that the ball stays at a fixed position in the viewfinder. Then in the space-time model constructed from the pictures obtained by A (exactly as described above) the history of the moving ball is a tube slanted to the left (Fig. 1.2c), while in the space-time model constructed by B (again, exactly as above) the history of this ball is a vertical tube (Fig. 1.2d). This is because the ball moves to the left relative to the coordinate x corresponding to A's view, but stays fixed in the coordinate x' corresponding to B's view. Thus we have two different views of the same set of happenings. These are the same space-time described from different viewpoints. This illustrates one of the major issues that arises in understanding spacetimes: one can use different coordinate systems, corresponding to making different sets of observations, to study the same physical system. The space-time representations arising will apparently be different, but can in fact be transformed into each other by making the appropriate changes of coordinates. Later we will determine the mathematical transformations that relate the viewpoints of the two observers. For the present, we simply note that when we consider the
series of photographs from which the space-time representations are constructed, the relation is a simple one. Suppose that before we fuse A's set of photographs together, we slide them carefully. sideways until the images of the moving ball are directly above each other (Fig. 1.3); then A's and B's representation of the same set of physical events will be the same. By this means, the view obtained by the first camera has been transformed into the same as that obtained by the second.
*If you feel that the labels A and B for the different cameras and the corresponding observers are antiseptically impersonal, you might like to substitute names such as Alfred or Angela for A, Barbara or Bernard for B. While such labelling may well initially help the beginner to grasp what is happening, ultimately it becomes an annoying distraction. We have chosen to use the more convenient abstract labels from the beginning.
Space-time diagrams and the foundations of special relativity
(a)
(b)
t,
(c)
Fig. 1.2 Effect of the observer's motion on the space-time picture. (a) Camera A is fixed above the billard table. (b) Camera B moves with the moving Billiard ball. (c) The
space-time view of the ball's history, constructed from A's photographs. (d) The space-time constructed from B's photographs. As view
B's view
t
x
x'
slide fuse }
4-
same view
Fig. 1.3 Although they look different, A's and B's space-time views are equivalent: sliding A's pictures sideways before fusing them together will give the same space-time view as B's.
1.1
The concept of a space
9
Fig. 1.4 A planet in circular motion around the Sun, describing a helix in space-time.
Examples of space-times The ideas explained so far should become quite clear on carefully considering two examples. (A) A planet in circular motion around a sun. In the sun's frame of reference, the sun is at rest in the spatial coordinates used, while the planet circles around it, describing a helix in space-time (Fig. 1.4). To see that this is the correct spacetime picture, consider later and later time sections of the space-time; the positions of the planet in the successive surfaces of instantaneity trace out a circle around the sun, as required. (B) A circular wave in a pond. Consider dropping a stone into a large pond at
some time t1, producing a spreading spherical ripple in the pond (Fig. 1.5a). Photographs of the crest of the spherically spreading wave taken from a camera stationary above the point of impact (Fig. 1.5b) produce a space-time picture in which the spreading wave is depicted as a cone with apex at time t = tl (Fig. 1.5c). Again considering later and later surfaces of instantaneity in the space-time, we recover the series of images depicting the spherically spreading wave, starting from the centre at time ti.
Points in space-time are called events. An event represents a particular position in the physical world at a particular time, the set of all events representing the spatial and temporal locations of all possible physical occurrences. A world-line is the path traced out in space-time by the events representing the history of a particular particle or light ray. For example the helix in example (A) is the world-line of the planet as it orbits around the sun. Not all lines in space-time are possible world-lines; for example, if a line reaches a maximum time and then
slopes down again (Fig. 1.6), it does not represent a possible world-line of a massive body, because time would start to go backwards along such a world-line, where it slopes down. We shall discover further restrictions on allowable world lines after considering the limiting role played by the speed of light in relativity.
Summary
Space-time represents the histories of objects in space. When the space represented is two-dimensional, the space-time is three-dimensional (three
10
Space-time diagrams and the foundations of special relativity stone
(b)
x (c)
Fig. 1.5
(a) Circular ripples produced by a stone thrown into a pond. (b) A succession of photographs of the spreading wave. (c) A space-time view of the spreading wave. t
Fig. 1.6
Curves in space-time: A is a possible particle history, or world-line; B is not.
coordinates are needed to characterize all events: the two spatial coordinates x and y depicting the spatial position of the event, and the coordinate t representing the time of the event). The full space-time needed to represent all events in the real
physical world is four-dimensional (with one time coordinate and three spatial coordinates). Each surface (t = constant) tells us where each object was at the
1.1
The concept of a space
11
time t, according to an observer using a particular coordinate system, say (x, y, z);
these surfaces are slices of instantaneity or simultaneity in the space-time (Fig. 1.7).
t1
Fig. 1.7 A { t = constant} slice of a space-time; this represents a surface of simultaneity.
Exercises 1.1 An observer 0 watches the engine of a train shunting on a straight track; he chooses the x coordinate to measure distance along the track. Plot the world-line of the engine in the (t, x) plane if, starting at a distance of 50 in from the observer, (i) it moves at 10 m/sec away from the observer for 5 seconds; (ii) then it is stationary for 7 seconds; (iii) then it moves at 5 m/sec towards the observer for 8 seconds. 1.2 The motion of a rocket relative to observer A is shown in Fig. 1.8. What is the distance of the rocket from A at t = 0 seconds? at t = 10 seconds? What is the speed of motion of the rocket relative to A?
Fig. 1.8 1.3 Draw a space-time diagram representing the motion of the Moon about the Earth (stating carefully what reference frame you are using). Indicate approximate time and spatial scales on your diagram. 1.4 Suppose a particle in an accelerator moves in a circular orbit of radius 25 in, speeding up all the time as it moves. Sketch a space-time diagram of its motion. 1.5 Two cars A and B, watched by a person C waiting to cross the street, collide and
then bounce apart. Sketch the world-lines of A, B, and C as seen by (i) the driver of one of
12
Space-time diagrams and the foundations of special relativity
the cars; (ii) the driver of the other car; (iii) the person waiting to cross the street. [The drivers are each securely seat-belted into their respective cars.]
So far, our discussion of space-times has been based on the everyday ideas of Newtonian theory. The concept of a space-time applies equally in the case of relativity theory, provided we take into account important relativity principles which we examine in the next two sections.
1.2
Causality and the speed of light
The speed at which light travels is very large but nevertheless is finite. It is measured to be approximately 3 x 1010 cm/sec = 3 x 108 m/sec = 300 000 km/sec. Thus, for example, light travels 30 km in 10-4 sec = (1/10 000) sec, and 300 km in 10-3 sec = (1/1000) sec. According to the Newtonian view of space-time, there is nothing special about the speed of light, and physical influences (e.g. changes in a gravitational field) can propagate faster: indeed, in principle they can influence
distant regions instantaneously. According to relativity theory, the situation is quite different.
The limiting nature of the speed of light One of the basic principles of Einstein's special theory of relativity is that the speed of light is a limiting speed for all communication and for all motion of massive bodies; indeed it is a limiting speed for propagation of all causal influences. One should note here that this speed is the speed of travel of all electromagnetic radiation, not merely light; it is the speed of travel of infrared and ultraviolet radiation, of radio waves and X-rays, as well as visible light (because these are all forms of electromagnetic radiation, at different wavelengths). Further, it will be the speed of travel of any particles of zero rest mass there may be, e.g. gravitons (packets of gravitational energy) and massless neutrinos as well as photons (packets of electromagnetic energy). Thus one can send signals at the speed of light in many ways, but there is no way one can send a signal faster. Any massive object, e.g. a rocket, a meteorite, a human being, cannot travel as fast as light. There is experimental evidence for this principle from many sources. On the one hand, no particle or signal has ever been measured to move faster than this speed. On the other, attempts to accelerate objects to higher speeds fail. For example, suppose one accelerates particles in a linear accelerator, and then plots the square of the resulting speed against the energy given to the particles. Newtonian theory predicts that no matter how high the speed, the resulting graph will be a straight line because the kinetic energy of the particle is proportional to the square of its speed of motion; in particular, there should be no barrier to accel-
erating particles to move faster than light. In practice it turns out that the Newtonian prediction is correct at low speeds, but at higher speeds the experimental results deviate from this prediction:.the speed attained is less than that
1.2
Causality and the speed of light
13
V2
Energy
Fig.1.9 A graph of the square of the speed of a particle against the energy of motion given to it, showing the experimental result and the prediction of Newtonian theory. No matter how much energy is given to the particle, the speed of light c is a limit to the speed it attains.
predicted by Newtonian theory. This happens in such a way that no matter how much energy one imparts it is not possible to accelerate particles to move faster than the speed of light (Fig. 1.9). The amount of energy needed to accelerate fast-
moving particles to higher speeds becomes larger and larger as the speed increases; smaller and smaller speed increments result from each doubling of the energy, and the speed of light is never reached. This is an experimental result that has been proved many times over at a cost of many billions of dollars (since that is the cost of the high energy particle accelerators now in use). One has to invest large sums of money in accelerators to produce an observable effect, because the speed of light is so large: the speed-of-light limit certainly does not act as a factor restricting the speed of cars, aircraft, or other vehicles on the earth!
The need to allow for the speed of light The time delay between lightning and thunder reminds us to allow for the speed of sound, but that is not the only allowance we should make! The limiting nature of the speed of light in special relativity means that one should always allow for light travel time in analysing any physical phenomenon. As an example, any photograph will, in general, include images of objects at various distances and so various light travel times. This means the images in a photograph will represent the states of the objects pictured at different times in the past. Thus a photograph of the Moon framed by trees represents the state of the moon 1.27 seconds earlier
than that of the trees; a photograph of distant galaxies with foreground stars (Fig. 1.10) represents delays of millions of years in the state of the galaxies relative to the stars (the stars will typically be at distances for which the light travel time is
thousands of years but the galaxies at distances for which the light travel time is millions of years). In each case we see the object at the instant when the light was emitted; the camera therefore necessarily records the resulting time delays. The front cover of this book shows galaxy NGC 3377, which is approximately
14
Space-time diagrams and the foundations of special relativity
Fig. 1.10 Distant galaxies and foreground stars. The foreground stars all belong to our own galaxy, which is a spiral system of stars and dust like the galaxy M81 shown here. The four `nearby' galaxies visible in the photograph are at a distance of some millions of light years from us (three fainter galaxies are even more distant) but the individual stars seen are within a few thousand light years. The photograph dramatically illustrates the time delays necessarily involved in all our observations of distant objects: we are seeing conditions at the galaxies millions of years ago, and those in the stars up to a few thousand years ago. Thus the images represent these objects as they were at times differing by millions of years. (Photograph from the Hale Observatory.)
32 million light years from us, and so the image show the galaxy as it was 32 million years ago. The back cover shows the COBE image (see p. 59) of the surface of last scattering of light in the very early universe, approximately 1010 years ago. The light that made this image has been travelling towards us for that enormous time.
1.2
shortest
pond;
Causality and the speed of light
\d2
d1
15
longer
I
(a)
(b)
(c)
Photos distort
r_--Ir - A Of use
t=tl
photo
(d)
Fig. 1.11
(a) A camera above the centre of a pond: the distance d1 to the centre is clearly
shorter than the distance d2 to a point further out. Consequently, light arriving at the camera from the centre set out later than light arriving at the same instant from the edge. (b) Circles of constant imaging time on a photograph PI of the pond, the larger circles corresponding to earlier times. (c) Surfaces of simultaneity in a stack of photographs of the pond (viewed edge-on, showing the finite thickness of each photograph). The photograph PI is shown shaded. (d) Distortion of the stack of photographs before fusing, to represent correctly surfaces of simultaneity as exactly horizontal sections of space-time.
To explore this effect further, consider a camera 3 metres above the centre of a circular pond of diameter 8 metres (Fig. 1.11 a). The light has to travel a distance of 3 metres from the centre of the pond to the camera, taking (3 m)/(3 x 108 m/ sec) = 10-8 seconds to do so, but light from the edge of the pond has to travel a distance of 5 metres, taking (5 m)/(3 x 108 m/sec) = 3 x 10-8 seconds to do so. Thus light from the edge takes 3 x 10-8 seconds more to reach the camera than light from the centre. A photograph records one instant when light reaches the camera from different places within its field of view; if these places are at various distances from the camera, the image obtained will represent the different times
when the light set out towards the camera. Hence, when the camera takes a
16
Space-time diagrams and the foundations of special relativity
photograph of the pond, one will obtain images of the situation in different areas of the pond at different times: light from the edge has to travel further and so has to set out earlier in order to reach the lens at the same time as light from the centre. If we sketch lines of exact simultaneity on a photo PI of the pond taken by the camera, they will form circles with the outer circle depicting the situation at the pond earliest, say at a time t1, and the central point the situation at a time t2 which
is 0.667 x 10-8 seconds later than t1 (Fig. 1.llb). A photograph taken by the camera is not an instantaneous photograph of the pond! Hence, on stacking a succession of photographs together and fusing them to obtain a representation of space-time, horizontal sections will not represent exact simultaneity:* as one moves out from the centre on a horizontal slice of space-time (which will be one of the photographic images), the situation represented will be earlier and earlier the further one is from the centre. There will be an earlier photo P° in which the situation at the central point is depicted at the time tl; this photograph will lie below P1 in the stack (because later photographs lie above earlier ones). It follows that exact surfaces of simultaneity in the space-time (e.g. ti is constant) will be lowest at the centre and will curve up as one moves from the centre to the edge (Fig. I. I lc). To correct this, i.e. to obtain a space-time representation in which horizontal sections are indeed exactly simultaneous sections of the space-time, one will have to distort the photographs of the pond by bending their outer regions downwards before stacking them and fusing them together (Fig. 1.11 d). One could in this
way allow for the light travel time, and obtain a space-time picture correctly representing simultaneity as exactly horizontal surfaces. In this particular case, the effect is negligible in practice. However, this will not always be true. Consider, for example, the delays implied from the centre to the edge of the photographic image where an observer in a spacecraft photographs the disc of a galaxy from a distance of 30 000 light years above the centre of the galaxy. If the galaxy has a radius of 40 000 light years, the delay represented in the photograph will be 20 000 year, i.e. the situation at the centre will be depicted 20 000 years after that at the edge of the disc.
Light rays in space-time In flat space, light travels in straight lines; as it travels at the constant speed c, the path traced out in space-time by light (strictly, by a photon, that is, a light particle)
will also be a straight line. Each light ray in space-time represents travelling a distance din a time t given by t = d/c, where the symbol c is used to represent the speed of light (so c = 3 x 1010 cm/sec). For example, if a light ray is emitted in
the x direction at the event 0 with coordinate values x = y = z = 0 with t = 0, then in 1 second it will be at the position x = 1 c cm = 3 x 1010 cm with y = z = 0; at the time t = 2 seconds, it will be at the position x = 2c cm = 6 x 1010 cm with y = z = 0 and so on (Fig. 1.12a). It is convenient to measure spatial distances in *In Section 1.1, we ignored light travel time and so regarded horizontal slices as exactly simultaneous. This will be a good approximation for slowly moving objects considered at everyday time and length scales.
1.2
Causality and the speed of light
t
17
t j(sec)
(sec)
light ray
3
light ray
3
2
2
1
1
X
X 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
6 9
(1010cm)
(a)
2
3
4
(light-sec)
(b)
Fig. 1.12 (a) A light ray travelling in x-direction after emission at the event 0 (x = 0, t = 0). Its space-time position is shown at t = 1 and t = 2. (b) The same light ray depicted using a spatial coordinate X = x/c (with units of light-seconds).
terms of coordinates X = x/c, Y = y/c, Z = z/c which are just the previous spatial coordinates divided by the speed of light; they are the same distances but measured in terms of 'light-times' (light-seconds, light-years, etc.). Then in
I second the light would be at the position x = 1 c cm, y = z = 0, so X = (1 c cm) / (c cm/sec) = 1 light-second, Y = Z = 0; at the time t = 2 seconds, it will be at the position X = (2c cm) /(c cm/sec) = 2 light-seconds, Y = Z = 0; and so
on. At an arbitrary time t, it will be at the position X = (ct)/c = t light-sec, Y = Z = 0 (Fig. 1.12b). The relation between this and the previous representation is easily obtained on remembering that I light-second = (1 sec) x (c cm/ sec) = 3 x 101 ° cm = 300 000 km. Another way of thinking of the coordinates X, Y, Z is that when they are used, we have effectively chosen units of measurement
for spatial distances so that the speed of light is 1 (because then light travels a distance of 1 light-second in 1 second, etc). In flat space, initially parallel light rays never meet each other because the spatial distance between them stays constant (Fig. 1.13a); consequently in spacetime diagrams, they are represented by parallel straight lines that remain a constant distance apart (Fig. 1.13b). We shall see later that this is not true in a curved space-time. The light cone and causal regions The future light cone of an event 0 is the set of all light rays through that event
(Fig. 1.14). This represents the space-time paths of light rays emitted in all directions from that place and time. It may conveniently be thought of as the history in space-time of a flash of light emitted in all directions at the position and instant corresponding to the event 0; thus one can imagine a flash bulb going off at this place and time, resulting in a sphere of light spreading out in all directions
at the speed of light. At a time t after the flash was emitted, the light forms a sphere at distance d = ct from the source position (Fig. 1.15a). For definiteness, let us assume the event 0 is (x = y = z = 0, t = 0). It is difficult torepresent the full light cone in a diagram, so we restrict our attention to a fixed value of z, say z = 0, obtaining the projection of this spreading
18
Space-time diagrams and the foundations of special relativity
t
x (b)
Fig. 1.13
(a) Parallel light rays in a three-space with coordinates (x, y, z). (b) These rays are represented by parallel straight lines in space-time.
Fig. 1.14 The future light cone of the event 0 is the set of all future-directed light rays
through 0.
light in a two-dimensional plane. The light will spread out circularly in this plane,
which is described by coordinates x and y. This is exactly analogous to the spherical wave in the pond (Example (B) above). By exactly the same reasoning as
used in that example (leading to Fig. 1.5c), a three-dimensional space-time diagram representing the spread of the light will show the wave front as a cone originating at (x = y = 0, t = 0) and with radius ct at time t (Fig. 1.15b). As the future light cone of the event 0 obtained in this way represents light travelling out in all directions from the emission event 0, it is generated by all the future light rays that pass through 0. To represent this situation in a clear, standard way, it is convenient to use the
coordinates X = x/c, Y = y/c, Z = z/c introduced above. Their use has the advantage that in these units the spatial distance travelled is equal to the time elapsed (the effective speed of light is 1); for example, after a time of 1 second, the
1.2
Causality and the speed of light
19
t4
x (a)
(b)
(a) A sphere of light spreading out from a flashbulb. (b) Representation of the spherical light wave in a three-dimensional space-time diagram, giving the future light cone of 0. Fig. 1.15
light has spread to a sphere of radius 1 light-second. Consequently the light cone
makes an angle of 45° with the vertical axis, representing the fact that a unit horizontal distance in these diagrams is traversed in a unit time; this makes it particularly easy to draw the light cones when these units are used (Fig. 1.15b was drawn using this convention). It is often convenient to restrict our attention even further to a fixed value of Y (say Y = 0) as well as a fixed value of Z. The light then spreads out in a onedimensional space with X as the spatial coordinate (this situation might be realized, for example, if a pair of optical fibres convey the light from the flashbulb in
the positive and negative X directions, Fig. 1.16a). The corresponding twodimensional space-time diagram shows the light emitted from the event 0 as travelling on lines at ±45° to the t axis (Fig. 1.16b); these are the two light rays through 0, because such lines are precisely those in which a unit (vertical) change in time corresponds to a unit (horizontal) change in distance. This diagram is a two-dimensional section (with one time and one space dimension represented)
of the three-dimensional Fig. 1.15b (representing one time and two space dimensions). In this diagram we have extended the light rays to the past of 0; the light rays converging on 0 from the past generate its past light cone, representing converging light pulses that arrive at the position (X = Y = Z = 0) at the time t = 0. The importance of the light cone of any event derives from the fact that it limits the region of space-time which can be causally affected from that event. For example, suppose President Lugarnev of Transylvania receives information at noon that at 3:00 p.m. a nuclear missile is to be launched towards his castle on the earth from a secret base on Mars. He instantly presses the button firing his SuperZ lasers at the base on Mars, but he is too late: the energy bolts he has released, travelling at the speed of light, will take 4 hours to reach Mars and so will destroy the rocket launching pad 1 hour. after the missile has left. Let the event where he receives the information be 0; this event (specified by a time and spatial position) is then noon at his castle. The light cone of 0 is depicted in Fig. 1.17, where, for
20
Space-time diagrams and the foundations of special relativity bulb light
light
IFF
fibre
fibre
(a) t
X
past light cone
(b)
Fig. 1.16 (a) Light spreading from a flashbulb one-dimensionally along optical fibres. (b) Representation of these light rays in a two-dimensional space-time diagram, generating the future light cone of O. The past light cone of 0 (i.e. light rays converging to O) is also shown.
convenience, time is measured in hours from 0 and spatial distances in lighthours from 0 (so 0 has the coordinates t = 0, X = 0). Then the event where the missiles are to be launched is P, given by t = 3, X = 4. The light cone clearly shows that the laser beam emitted at 0 will arrive at Mars too late to influence P. One cannot influence P from 0, because it is outside O's light cone. The reason for this limitation, of course, is the limiting nature of the speed of light. The angle of a particle's world-line in space-time from the vertical depends on rate of change along the world-line of spatial distance with respect to time, and so represents the speed of motion of the particle relative to the chosen coordinate system (Fig. 1.18). Therefore, the limiting nature of the speed of light means that no world-line can make a greater angle with the vertical than the light cone; using the coordinates (X, Y, Z), no world-line can make an angle larger than 45 ° with the vertical axis. Further, one can only send light or radio signals from any event to events on its future light cone. Considering this, it becomes clear that an observer at an event 0 cannot influence any event that lies outside the future light cone of 0 (to do so would involve causally influencing events along paths representing motion at speeds greater than the speed of light). This is a fundamental limitation on all communication, implied by special relativity theory. It follows that given any event P, we may divide space-time into five distinct causal regions (Fig. 1.19). The interior of the future light cone C+(P) is that region
1.2
Causality and the speed of light 21
(a)
[EARTH]
[MARS] (b)
Fig.1.17 (a) A space-time diagram showing the event P (t = 3, X = 4) where missiles are launched from Mars towards the Earth. At the time t = 0 on the earth (at X = 0), it is already too late to prevent the launching of these missiles; this is because a laser pulse emitted at this event 0 will reach Mars at the event R (t = 4, X = 4), an hour after the missiles were launched. (b) Depiction of this series of events by a sequence of instantaneous spatial views. At t = 0, the castle fires a bolt towards the missile base; at t = 3, the base fires a missile while the bolt is still a light-hour away from it; at t = 4, the base is destroyed but the missile is on its way to the castle. Note the direct correspondence between these spatial views and the space-time diagram. The reason event P cannot be influenced from event 0 is because P is outside O's future light cone (the light ray OR lies on this light cone).
which can be influenced by objects travelling from the event P at less than the speed of light; the future light cone itself can be influenced from P by signals travelling at the speed of light. The past light cone represents the set of events in space-time from which signals sent at the speed of light arrive at the spatial position and time represented by event P. Thus in a photograph of an object taken at P, the light arriving at P records the situation at the instant where the object's world-line intersects our past light cone (Fig. 1.20); the camera necessarily records the resulting time delays (as in the cover photograph). The interior of the past light cone C-(P) is the region in space-time from which the event P can be influenced by objects travelling at less than the speed of light. The exterior of the
22
Space-time diagrams and the foundations of special relativity
Fig. 1.18 A straight world-line passing through 0 and P represents motion relative to the reference frame (t, X) at a speed v in the X-direction; at time t, it is at position X = x/c = vt/c. The angle a of this world-line to the vertical is given by tan a = X/ t = v/c. For a light ray, v = c and tan a = 1.
Fig.1.19 The future and past light cones C + (P), C - (P) of an event P determine the future of P (the interior of the future light cone), and the past of P (the interior of the past light cone). Events outside these light cones cannot be influenced from P or influence what happens there.
light cones is the region which cannot be influenced by P and which cannot influence P.
One can illustrate the latter feature by considering a particular event on the surface of the Earth, when an astronaut on the Moon is observed through an
1.2
Causality and the speed of light
23
Fig. 1.20 A photograph taken by observer A at the event P depicts the event R in B's history, where B's world-line intersects the past light cone of P.
Fig.1.21 The past and future light cones of an event 0 in the history of an observer A on the Earth, who (at the event 0) sees event e (a threatening boulder starting to roll down) in the history of an astronaut B on the Moon. Observer A immediately sends a warning signal to B; but this arrives at event r, after the boulder has just hit the astronaut at the event b in his history. Because b is outside the future light cone of 0, the observer at 0 cannot influence what happens there.
ultrapowerful telescope. Suppose that at this time one were to observe a boulder rolling down a slope towards the astronaut. Since light takes 1.27 seconds to reach the Earth from the Moon, we are observing an event 1.27 light-seconds away and 1.27 light-seconds to the past, on the past light cone (Fig. 1.21). It is
already too late to radio a warning to the astronaut if the boulder will take 2 seconds to reach him, because the event where the bolder will reach him is outside the causal future of the reception event. Given the restrictions on
24
Space-time diagrams and the foundations of special relativity
communication resulting from the limiting nature of the speed of light, there is no method of sending a warning signal in time.
The causal limitations discussed here are fundamental, but will not significantly affect ordinary everyday life in an obvious way because the speed of light is so large: in the context of cars, aircraft, etc. on or near the surface of the Earth, the resulting delays in communication are negligible. They become significant either when large distances or times are involved, or if the time-scales involved in some process are such that the speed of light is a significant limiting factor. One example is supercomputers: an ultimate limit is imposed on their possible speed of calculation because information cannot be conveyed from one part of the computer to another at speeds greater than the speed of light; this limits the number of calculations that can be performed per second. For
this reason, distances between their components must be kept small; thus supercomputers of the future will be small machines. Exercises 1.6 A satellite takes survey pictures of a square region of the Earth, 800 km in width, from 300 km above the Earth's surface. What is the delay from the centre of the image to the edge? (Regard the Earth's surface as flat in order to simplify the calculation). 1.7 Suppose that a `mind reader' in London claims to know what his twin brother in New Zealand says at any moment, within less than one-hundredth of a second after a word is uttered. Is there anything extraordinary about this claim? [The radius of the Earth is about 6000 km.]. 1.8 A rocket R moves in the z direction relative to an observer A on Mars, at a speed v where v/c = z; their positions coincide at t = 0. Plot the world-lines of A and R in a (t, Z) diagram. The rocket emits light signals in both the forward and backward directions at t = 2 sec; draw the corresponding light rays in your space-time diagram. The observer A signals to the rocket at the time t = 1 sec; what is the earliest time he can expect to get a reply? [All distances and times are measured in the reference frame of the observer A.] 1.9 Draw a diagram to illustrate the fact that the `past' (i.e. the past light cone and its interior) of any point P on any world-line, always includes the `past' of any earlier point Q on that world-line. Interpret this result in physical terms.
Computer Exercise 1 Write a program that will either (a) take as input a spatial distance D (in miles or km) and give as output the time T (in seconds, minutes, or hours) for light to travel that distance; or (b) take as input a light travel time T, and give as output the corresponding distance D. Try the program for suitable distances on the Earth, and in the solar system.
Now alter the program to print out additionally the rescaled distance D1 = D/c, where c is the speed of light. Notice the simplification achieved. [This corresponds to use of
coordinates X, Y, Z discussed above, for which the speed of light is unity. Your output should always state the units of time and distance being used.]
1.3
Relative motion in special relativity
We have seen that even in Newtonian theory, two observers in relative motion will, in general, have different views of space-time. We have also seen how such
1.3
Relative motion in special relativity 25
differing Newtonian views may be reconciled. According to Einstein's special theory of relativity there are some basic features which are common to observers using different reference frames. These are described in the special principle of relativity: The laws of physics are the same for all non-accelerating observers.
In the Newtonian theory, this result is well established as far as the laws of
dynamics are concerned: there is no way for an experimenter to determine absolute uniform motion by any dynamical experiment. For example, if one carried out a series of experiments involving measuring the motion of colliding billiard balls, timing pendulums, etc. in a compartment in a uniformly moving train, the results are independent of the speed of motion of the train. Therefore, one cannot determine the speed of motion of the train by any such experiments, as they are not affected by this speed; indeed, the results of the experiments will be exactly the same as if the train is at rest. Similarly, the results would be the same if the experiments were done in the Concorde airliner flying smoothly at twice the speed of sound. This set of results establishes the Newtonian principle of relativity, that the laws of dynamics of particles and rigid bodies are the same in all non-accelerating frames. The genius of Einstein lay in extending this principle to all the laws of physics (it applies e.g. to optics, thermodynamics, electromagnetic effects, and elementary particle physics). Thus, the special principle of relativity implies .that no physical experiment whatever can establish the absolute motion of any uniformly moving body (one can easily establish motion relative to other bodies, but that is not the issue: the point is that we cannot determine the motion of the Earth at some instant as being say 350 km/sec in any particular direction, in an absolute sense). This is because no experiment can detect such absolute motion; and that is because the laws of physics are unaffected by any absolute uniform motion. One can rephrase the principle of relativity as stating the equivalence of all inertial reference frames. The set of coordinates used by an observer to describe space-time, with himself at the origin (x = y = z = 0), constitutes his reference
frame. A reference frame is said to be inertial if it is non-rotating and nonaccelerating. Newton's laws of motion imply that a body experiences an acceleration relative to an inertial reference frame if and only if forces caused by other bodies act on it; indeed this feature may be used to characterize inertial frames. If one frame is inertial, any other frame moving uniformly relative to it is also inertial. The claim then is that one may use any inertial reference frame and the laws of physics will be unchanged. At first this principle seems obscure, but after we have encountered it in various contexts and seen its implications, its nature will become obvious. It is a powerful unifying principle underlying all known laws of physics. It is already clear that it is useful in the following sense: it implies that if a body is in uniform motion, we do not have to specify that state of motion before being able to apply the laws of physics to it. For example, the operation of the electric generators and motors in an aircraft are unaffected by the motion of the aircraft, if it is moving
26
Space-time diagrams and the foundations of special relativity
uniformly. Therefore we do not have to design the motors to take the speed of operation into account; an electric motor that works on the surface of the earth will work equally well in a rocket moving uniformly at 25 000 miles an hour relative to the surface of the Earth. Engineering would be very difficult indeed if this were not so.
Invariance of the speed of light
A major implication of the relativity principle is Einstein's principle of the invariance of the speed of light:
The speed of light in empty space is the same for all observers, independent of the motion of the source and of the observer. If the speed of light were not independent of the motion of the observer, we could detect absolute motion by measuring the speed of light in different directions, so contradicting the principle of relativity. Given this invariance it is then clear that the speed of light must be independent of the motion of the source also, or else its absolute motion could be detected by measuring the speed of light it has emitted
(which would be measured to be the same by all observers). This principle is supported by all available experimental evidence, in particular, by the famous Michelson-Morley experiment which showed that the speed of light emitted by distant stars is the same when measured from the Earth, whether the Earth in its orbit around the Sun is moving towards or away from the stars (Fig. 1.22). In addition, this principle is also a consequence of the relativity principle applied to
particle dynamics, because the speed of light is a limiting speed for particle motion (cf. the previous section). This implies that if the speed of light were different in different frames, it would be possible to use dynamical experiments (aimed at determining the limiting velocity of motion) to determine the absolute motion of each reference frame. Given the validity of this result, it becomes starkly clear that we will have to revise our ideas about many features we have previously taken for granted. To see this, we consider three important effects of special relativity.
The problem of velocity addition
Consider an observer A stationary on the ground watching a rocket, which is passing by at 150 000 km/sec, as it emits a light signal in its direction of motion (Fig. 1.23a). The observer A will measure the speed of this light to be 300 000 km/ sec. If she works out on the basis of ordinary Newtonian theory the speed of motion of the light that would be measured by an observer B on the rocket, she will argue as follows: `I measure the light to be moving past me at 300 000 km/sec and the rocket to be moving past me in the same direction at 150 000 km/sec.
Therefore observer B on the rocket will measure the speed of the light to be (300 000 -150 000) km/sec = 150 000 km/sec'. But viewing the situation from the
frame of observer B (Fig. 1.23b), the speed of this light is measured to be 300 000 km/sec, as it must be by the principle of invariance of the speed of light,
1.3
Relative motion in special relativity
27
star
Earth
Fig. 1.22 In the Michelson-Morley experiment, the speed of light emitted by a star is measured both when the Earth in its orbit around the Sun is moving towards the star and away from it. The same result is obtained for the speed of light in both cases: this speed is independent of the relative motion of the source and the observer.
rocket
signal .ivwvvy
-
3000oo km/sec
15Q000 km/sec
(a)
(b)
Fig.1.23 (a) An observer at rest on the Earth measuring the speed of a light signal emitted from a fast-moving rocket. (b) The same situation but viewed from the rest frame of the rocket.
in dramatic contrast to the result calculated by A. The Newtonian law of velocity addition is drastically wrong when the velocities involved are comparable with the speed of light; it must be replaced by a new law that is compatible with the principles of special relativity. The Newtonian law of velocity addition is wrong because it is based on incorrect ideas about length and time measurements that do
not adequately take into account the principle of special relativity. We will determine the correct relativity velocity addition law in Section 3.2.
The dependence of relative clock rates on relative motion It is clear that something strange happens to the measurement of time in relativity theory, because of the following simple 'thought-experiment' due to Einstein. Suppose one watches a large clock (such as that on the tower in the central square
28
Space-time diagrams and the foundations of special relativity
in Berne) through a powerful telescope, as one moves away from it in a very fast tram (!) that passes the clock at exactly midday. If the tram could move at the speed of light, an observer on it would see the clock appear to stand still-because
the light emitted by the clock at midday would be travelling away from it at exactly the same speed as the tram, and light emitted at later times could not catch up with the observer. Thus on using his telescope, he would always see the clock
hands stand at 12 o'clock. Indeed all other happenings next to the clock tower would also be seen by him exactly as they were at midday, because the light he receives from the tower at all later times is the light that left it then. If one could move as fast as light, time would appear to stand still! To analyse further how time behaves according to special relativity theory, we must consider how it is measured by a clock. In general, a clock is a complex mechanism that is difficult to analyse. Conceptually the simplest is a'light clock', constructed by means of a light source that emits signals which travel a distance do
and are then reflected back to the source (Fig. 1.24). The time interval between emission and return of the signals to the mirror define the `ticks' of such a clock; they occur a time 2t apart where 2t = 2do/c
t = do/c
(1.1)
(because the signals travel at the speed of light). Suppose such a light clock is attached to a rocket (Fig. 1.25a); seen from the rocket's frame, the time measured will be given by eqn (1.1) independently of its state of motion (because of the principle of relativity). Now suppose the rocket moves past an identical clock on the ground, at a speed v (Fig. 1.25b). Considered from the ground, the light always travels at the same speed; therefore the interval between emission and reception of light by the clock on the rocket is measured from the ground to be 2t', where the distance travelled by the light is given by Pythagoras' theorem, so
c2t2 t
= vt+ 2'Z do Z
Fig. 1.24 A `light clock' consisting of two mirrors held at a fixed distance by a rigid rod, and a pulsed lights ource. The `ticks' of the clock are each time the pulse of light is reflected by the bottom mirror.
1.3
Relative motion in special relativity
29
rocket (at rest)
moving clock
(length of arm exaggerated)
(length of arm exaggerated)
(a)
(b)
Fig. 1.25
(a) A light clock fixed to a rocket, viewed from the rest-frame of the rocket. The light is reflected from a mirror at a distance do, and is received back after a time 2t. (b) A light clock aboard a rocket moving at speed v relative to an identical clock on the ground. An observer on the ground sees the light received back by the rocket after a time 2t'.
This implies ti2(c2
- v2) = do
ti2(1 - v2/c2) = do /c2.
Taking the square root and dividing by (1 - v2/c2)z gives (do/c)/(1 - v2/c2)Z.
But the rate of the clock on the ground is given by (1.1). Thus
t' = t/(1 - v2/c2)12.
(1.2a)
We see that even with identical light clocks, the ticks of clocks in relative motion measure time at different rates. Since t' is larger than t, the moving clock is seen from the ground to `run slow' in the ratio
t'/t = 1/(1 - v2/c2)z.
(1.2b)
This effect is significant when motion is at speeds near the speed of light. We shall rederive this result in Section 3.4, and discuss its experimental verification in that section and in Section 3.6.
The `twin paradox' An interesting example of this effect is the so-called `twin paradox'. Suppose that one of a pair of twins (i.e. siblings born on the same day) goes on a long journey at very high speeds in a rocket ship, while the other stays at home (Fig. 1.26a). The twins are inequivalent because the one experiences varying accelerations associated with the changing speed of the rocket in which she is travelling, whereas the other does not. The biological systems of the moving twin will be measured by the stationary twin to run slowly. Age is measured by means of ideal clocks each twin carries with him or her, and they will not be the same age when they meet again;
the one who stayed at home will be older. This different aging, evidenced in biological processes, will be confirmed by mechanical or electrical clocks the
30
Space-time diagrams and the foundations of special relativity
Twins
-x
E (b)
(c)
Fig.1.26
The `twin paradox'. (a) Twin A stays at home while twin B goes on a long return journey at high speed. (b) A clock actually measures time along its world-line in space-time (each `tick' can be thought of as a marker on the world-line). (c) A space-time diagram of
the twins' histories: twin A's clock measures time t along his world-line, while twin B's clock measures time t' along her world-line.
twins carry with them. For the effect to be significant, the relative motion must take place at close to the speed of light. This effect is not really surprising when one asks what a measurement of `time' means in space-time. Remembering that clocks are mechanisms whose history is represented by a world-line in space-time, we see that it is plausible that what they really measure is `distance in space-time' along the world-lines representing their history (Fig. 1.26b). Because the twins have followed different space-time paths between the events when they are together initially and finally (Fig. 1.26c), it is not too surprising that they have lived for different times. A similar effect occurs on the surface of a table. The distance d from P to Q along the curve C is different than that along the route C' (Fig. 1.27a); the `twin paradox' is the analogous effect in space-time. There is, however, a significant difference in the two effects: from this analogy one might at first expect that the time measured by the twin who moves out and back would be longer, as her world-line looks longer in Fig. 1.26c; but the actual sign of the effect is the opposite. We must be careful; while such a space-time diagram accurately represents instantaneous relative spatial positions and time measurements made by a single observer, we must not jump to conclusions about what spatial or time measurements will be made by other observers. In this case the diagram represents accurately measurements made by the stay-at-home twin A, but does not in an obvious way represent measurements made by the traveller B. What is clear from the diagram is that we may expect
1.3
Relative motion in special relativity
31
0 (a)
(b)
Fig.1.27 (a) Two paths between points P and Q on the surface of a table. The straight-line path C is of length d, while the curved path C' is of length d'. (b) Four routes from town Q to town P lying on opposite sides of the city C. Travel time is longest on route a through the city centre; and is shortest on the apparently longer route d, a freeway that avoids even the outer suburbs of the city. This provides a good analogy to the situation in Fig. 1.26c.
B's time measurements to differ from those of A, but we must not jump to conclusions as to how they differ.
An analogy to the situation represented by the space-time diagram can be given as follows: imagine towns P and Q lying respectively to the north and south of an ancient city C. The roads of this city are very congested by heavy traffic passing through narrow streets, so the closer one travels to the city centre the slower travel by car is. One can choose routes from P to Q through the centre of the city, through inner suburbs, through outer suburbs, or on a ring road that avoids the city altogether; these further-out routes from P to Q of course involve travelling a
longer distance, as is at once apparent from a map (Fig. 1.27b). However, the travel time from P to Q is shortest on the ring road and longest on the road through the city centre. The map represents accurately the different possible paths from P to Q, but not the different times it will take to travel on these routes; the shortest travel time from the initial to the final points is associated with the path that looks longest on the map. This gives us a good analogy to the spacetime situation represented in Fig. 1.26c. One can crudely understand the sign of the effect in that case by remembering the example of the observer watching a clock from a tram, which suggests that the nearer to the speed of light a clock moves relative to an observer A, the slower it will appear to him that it is running. We shall discuss the time dilation effect and `twin paradox' fully in Section 3.4.
The dependence of simultaneity on the reference frame One of the most important features of relativity theory is that observers in relative motion will disagree about simultaneity. As an example consider, as before, two
32
Space-time diagrams and the foundations of special relativity
observers A and B viewing a billiard table from above, the one being stationary above the centre of the table and the other moving to the left (cf. Fig. 1.2). Now suppose red and green billiard balls R and G fall into pockets at opposite edges of the table, at exactly the same instant (as measured by an observer stationary relative to the table). Light waves recording these events are emitted from the two edges of the table at the same instant (as seen from the table). Let this instant be when A and B coincide (Fig. 1.28a); thus, the light is emitted equidistant from both A and B. Both waves reach A at the same instant T (Fig. 1.28b). Since A is equidistant from the two edges, he deduces that the billiard balls were pocketed simultaneously (cf. the discussion above of simultaneity in the photograph of the pond). However, when the waves reach A, then B's motion will ensure that the wave from the left has already passed him while the wave from the right has yet to catch up with him. Thus, B observes that the red ball was pocketed before the green one. Therefore, observers in relative motion disagree about simultaneity. This will be manifested in photographs taken by the observers: they will represent the same spatial regions viewed at different time slices. For example, A's picture taken at T shows R and G being pocketed simultaneously, whereas B's picture shows R already in the pocket and G still approaching the edge. If two photographs taken by A and B show the left-hand edge at the same time, B's photograph will show the right-hand edge at an earlier time than A's. Thus a surface of simultaneity in space-time for B will be tilted relative to a surface of simultaneity for A (Fig. 1.29). The conclusion is that observers in relative motion determine
(a)
(b)
Fig. 1.28 (a) Two cameras A and B over a billiard table: A is stationary above the centre, and B is moving to the left. Light rays are emitted from the sides of the table as two balls R and G are simultaneously pocketed; at the same instant, A and B coincide. (b) Both light rays reach A at the same instant, but B receives the light from the left before the light from
the right. Thus he sees R fall into a pocket before G.
1.3
Relative motion in special relativity
33
simultaneous for A
t
x
simultaneous for B (a)
(b)
(a) Surfaces of simultaneity for A and B, showing how relatively moving observers determine different space-sections of space-time as being instantaneous. Fig. 1.29
(b) Cross-section (y = constant) of Figure (a). The surface of simultaneity for A is parallel to the x-axis, but that for B is tilted relative to it.
different splittings of space-time into space and time. Space-time is a unit which unifies space and time, but does so in different ways for different observers. The
argument above is indicative of the fundamental feature that simultaneity is determined relative to the motion of the observer, but does not enable one to understand the issues fully. A full technical examination of simultaneity and how to measure it follows, see Section 3.3. Exercises 1.10 Which of the following properties would you expect for a correct relativistic velocity addition law, combining parallel velocities vl and v2 to produce a resultant velocity v3?
(i) {vlIC <<1,v2/c<<1}=vl+v2,:;v3; (ii) {viIC >2,V2/C>2}=V3/C> 1; (iii) {v,/c<2,v21CG v31CG1. (« means `much less than'.) 1.11 A certain type of elementary particle is unstable: when at rest in the laboratory, it is measured to decay on average after 10-5 seconds. Such particles are made to travel at a speed of c in a linear accelerator. What will their average lifetime then appear to be to a stationarys observer?
1.12 A passenger A sitting in the middle of a coach in a moving train observes that lightning strikes both ends of the coach at exactly the same time. At the instant when he receives the light signals, he passes a stationary observer B standing near the railway track. Which end of the coach does the lightning strike first, according to B? If the coach is moving at 30 m/sec and is measured by the stationary observer to be 100m long, what time difference does he measure between the two lightning strikes? [Note that B is precisely midway between the ends of the coach when he receives the signals.]
Computer Exercise 2 Write a program that takes as input a value V representing speed of relative motion as a fraction of the speed of light, and a time Tmeasured by a stationary observer; and gives .
34
Space-time diagrams and the foundations of special relativity
as output the corresponding time T' measured by the moving observer (see eqn (1.2)). Make sure your program will only accept values of V with magnitude less than 1. Verify from your program (a) that T' < T for all non-zero values of V (positive or negative); (b) for any given T, T' --> 0 as V --> 1. What value do you find for T'lT when V= 0? Interpret your results physically.
These various effects of relative velocity warn us to be cautious in interpreting
space-time diagrams. Suppose that a space-time diagram is drawn from A's viewpoint; then the coordinates (t, X, Y, Z) represent the results of A's measurements, and we can read the results of his measurements directly from the diagram. Without further investigation, we cannot assume that we know the results of measurements made by other observers. In particular, we cannot read off directly the results of time or space measurements made by an observer B
moving relative to A, because the diagram does not represent the relation between A's and B's measurements of space or time in a simple way. We can indeed use the diagram to understand these relationships, as we shall see later, but must be careful in the way we do so and we must avoid preconceptions.
Conclusion Space-time diagrams give a very convenient description of spatial and temporal relations, which enable us to clarify important features such as the nature of causal relationships. The examples given so far show that in order to understand relativity theory properly, and the way space-time represents space and time measurements for different observers, we need to rethink carefully the nature of space and time measurements. We shall do so in Chapter 2, and then work out systematically the consequences for the geometry of the space-time of special
relativity in Chapter 3 (studying there in depth the concepts introduced in this Chapter). The unifying theme of a space-time interval will be introduced in Chapter 4, and used in later chapters to study some basic ideas of curved space-times. While all the preceding material is necessary for a full understanding of the later chapters, so that ideally one should read them in sequence, nevertheless a reader who wishes to proceed directly to the main ideas of curved space-times can
do so now by reading Chapter 5. However, understanding of the interesting applications in Chapters 6 and 7 will be greatly benefited by a perusal at least of the flat-space universes discussed in Section 4.3. Although we shall mention it again in the Afterword, let us recommend as an additional source of discussion and examples the book Space-Time Physics by E. F. Taylor and J. A. Wheeler (Second edition: Freeman, 1992); this describes
special relativity (and a little beyond) in a highly readable way, with lots of examples and pictures, and provides a useful parallel text which could be read in conjunction with Chapters 1-4 of this book.
2
Fundamentals of measurement To build a proper foundation for understanding relativity theory we need to consider in turn the bases of measurement of time, distance, and instantaneity, because these are the fundamentals on which other kinematic measurements, such as velocity measurements, depend.
2.1
Time
We assume the existence of ideal clocks which measure time accurately along their world-lines. These clocks may for example be mechanical (e.g. based on an escapement mechanism controlling the rate at which a spring unwinds), atomic (e.g. depending on the half-life of a radioactive substance), electromechanical (e.g. based on a crystal), or electronic (based on an electronic oscillator). The notion of perfect measurement of time along a world-line is important because it implies the universality of time measurement in the following sense. The equations determining the mechanical response of a body involve time, as do the equations of electromagnetism and of atomic and nuclear structure. Until we have investigated further, we are not entitled to assume that these and the times in other physical laws are the same, or even simply related to each other. However, to the accuracy so far measured, it turns out that the relevant time is the same for all physical systems: we do not have to allow for different time variables in mechanical systems, thermal systems, atomic systems, etc. Therefore, we do not have to specify the kind of clock to be used by an observer: the universality of time
allows him to base his clock on any physical principle he chooses. Ideal clocks constructed on the basis of any physical laws will all agree with each other.
The further point of importance to be emphasized is that a clock by itself cannot determine a time measurement at some point away from itself (I cannot obtain a reading from a clock remote from me unless transmitting and. receiving mechanisms are used to transfer data from it to where I am). Thus, clocks by themselves cannot establish surfaces of instantaneity in space-time, but rather measure time along a world-line (namely, the world-line of the clock in spacetime, Fig. 2.1). There is no implication here that the same time will be measured from an initial to a final point along different world-lines, and indeed, in relativity theory this is not expected to be true (cf. Fig. 1.26 and the discussion in Section 1.3). Experimental evidence shows that special relativity is correct: ideal clocks have been flown around the world in airliners and compared with identical clocks stationary on the ground. Their readings differ, in agreement with the prediction
36
Fundamentals of measurement
of special relativity. Thus the Newtonian idea of a uniform flow of time that is the same for all observers, is wrong. Given any world-line, then, there is a unique time measured along that world-
line by any ideal clock moving along it. This is called proper time along that world-line. All direct time measurements are measurements ofproper time along some world-line or other. To relate proper times measured along different world-
lines implies use of signalling devices that can transfer information between distant observers; we shall deal with this in Section 2.3 below. Given this understanding, there is one particular `time' that needs clarification: namely, what is the significance of the time coordinate t specified in the standard coordinates (t, X, Y, Z) used to describe space-time by an observer A (cf. Section 1.1)? The answer is that it is the proper time measured by that observer along his own world-line in space-time, which is the line (X= Y= Z = 0) in those coordinates
(Fig. 2.2). It does not directly indicate time measured along other arbitrary world-lines. However, as we shall see later, it will correctly give the time measured
by any observer who is at rest in this coordinate system, i.e. who is stationary relative to A.
x
Fig. 2.1
Measurement of time is based on the fact that a clock measures time t' along its own world-line in space-time.
x
Fig. 2.2
The time t in the standard coordinate system of an observer A is time measured
by a clock stationary relative to him. It measures time along his world-line (the line X= Y= 0, which is the origin of the spatial coordinates in his reference frame).
2.2
Distance
37
Exercise 2.1 The period of rotation of the earth as measured by an electromagnetic crystal clock is found to be increasing. Does this imply that (a) dynamical time (as measured by the fundamental laws controlling the Earth's rotation) is different from electromagnetic time, or (b) that the Earth's rotation is an imperfect clock for some reason?
2.2
Distance
In texts on elementary physics it is often stated that rulers or `rigid rods' are the basis of measurement of distances. However, they are very imperfect measures of distance; the length of a ruler varies with temperature, for example, and will be different if it is held horizontally or vertically in a gravitational field (because of the elastic response to stresses induced by gravity). Therefore, `corrections'' must be made to allow for the fact that a ruler does not in fact measure a constant distance under all conditions. Further, it is impracticable to use a ruler (or series of rulers) to measure accurately the distance from Rome to Venice or Dover to Calais, let alone
from the Earth to the Moon or Mars. Some more practical method must exist. Measuring the distance of one object from another which is far from it implies sending signals or information between these objects. The invariance of the speed
of light means that electromagnetic radiation is the best basis for standard measuring devices in space-time. This is true in particular for the measurement of
distance. Thus, the proper basis for measuring distance in special relativity is radar. This works as follows: to measure the distance between points P and Q, an electromagnetic signal is emitted by a transmitter at P and reflected back to P from Q (Fig. 2.3). The emission time t1 and reception time t2 of the signals are measured by an ideal clock at P. Let the difference between these times be t t2 - t1; this is then the light travel time for the outward and return journeys. If the distance between
P and Q is d, the distance travelled by the light is 2d. But light travels at the invariant speed c; so t = 2d/c, and the distance measured is half the light travel time:
transmitter
d
reflect
and
receiver
Fig. 2.3 A device to measure the distance between P and Q: a radar signal (usually a radio wave) is sent from P at the time t1, reflected at Q, and the echo received by Pat time t2. The distance d then follows from the light travel time t2 - t1.
38
Fundamentals of measurement
As an example, if the light is emitted at 12:01 and received at 12:03 then tl = 12:01, t2 = 12:03, r = 2 minutes, and the distance is light1
minute = 60 light-seconds = 60 sec x 300 000 km/sec = 18 000 000 km. By contrast, if r = 2 µsec = 2 x 10-6 sec, then d= 1 µsec = 300 metres. This use of radar to measure distance, apart from being the fastest method, is in most cases the only practical method. It is for example the basis of accurate measurement of distance for mapping purposes by surveyors (e.g. through a device called a Tellumat, see Fig. 2.4). It has been used to measure the distance to the Moon and to Mars with unprecedented accuracy. It is routinely used by ships and aircraft to determine distances to other ships and aircraft. Also, because of the problems with defining
Fig. 2.4 The Tellumat, an advanced distance measuring device based on the radar principle. This instrument uses microwave radiation to measure distances between 20 in and 25 km to within an accuracy of 5 mm. The distance measured appears directly as a digital read-out on the hand-held control unit. (Photograph from Plessey plc.)
2.2
Distance
39
a length standard by means of a `rigid rod', the metre is now defined as the distance light travels in a given time; thus the constancy of the speed of light-the
basis of radar-is also the basis now used to define the length in a laboratory. From now on, in this book we shall assume that radar is the practical means of measuring distance. A space-time diagram of the use of radar to measure distance is given in Fig. 2.5. Unless otherwise stated, we shall from now on use the coordinates (t, X, Y, Z) introduced in the last chapter, scaled so that the speed of light is 1 (because lengths are measured in light travel times) and the light cone is at 45 ° to
the vertical in space-time diagrams. Then all world-lines of massive particles must make an angle of less than 45 ° to the vertical in these diagrams, because they cannot move faster than light. This convention has been used in Fig. 2.5. When
radar is used to measure distance, it is very natural to describe distances in terms of light travel times (e.g. µsec, sec, years). To convert to ordinary units, one just has to multiply by the speed of light. For example, 1 µsec is (10-6 sec) x (3 x 1010 cm/sec) = 3 x 104 cm = 300 metres; 1 msec is 300 km; 1 sec
is 300 000 km. In these units, the mean distance from the Earth to the Moon (381 550 km) is 1.27 sec; the mean distance from the Earth to the Sun
(149 600 000 km) is 8.31 minutes; the distance to the nearest star is 4.27 light-years. We can now give a direct meaning to the standard spatial coordinates (X, Y, Z) in an observer's space-time picture. Along the coordinate axes, they are just the
distances measured by him by radar from his world-line (X = Y = Z = 0) to the event in question (Fig. 2.6), in units of light-travel time; for a general point, the distance measured is d = (X2 + Y2 + Z2)z. As in the case of time measure-
ments, one cannot assume that one can read distances measured by other
Q
light
t=t1-remission
Fig. 2.5 A space-time diagram of the measuring procedure in Fig. 2.3.
40
Fundamentals of measurement
t t=2
P
t=I t=o X
t=I
t= x=D
X=1
X=2
Fig. 2.6 The coordinate X in the standard coordinate system of an observer P is radar distance measured by him from his position. Thus a series of radar signals establishes the lines X = 0, X = 1, X = 2, etc. in space-time (X = 0 being his own world-line).
observers directly from the space-time diagram, since they are in general not directly represented by the coordinates X, Y, Z. An important feature of distance measurement by radar is that an observer at P can measure the distance to Q purely by observations at his own position; he does not have to go himself to Q, or attain any active collaboration from Q, to make the measurement. Instead he sends light or radio waves to Q; all that is required is that they are reflected back to P by some object at Q. This feature is what makes radar so important in navigation and in military applications. Finally, having defined distance in terms of radar, we can now understand the common use of rulers to measure distances on scales of between 10-3 metres and 10-2 metres as being due to their being reasonably good approximations to `rigid rods' (rods of constant length) in many circumstances. Ifany conflict were ever to arise between ruler and radar measurements of distance, we would reject the ruler result in favor of that determined by radar. Exercises 2.2 Find the light travel time between the following locations: (i) your feet and your eyes; (ii) Cambridge and London (90 km apart); (iii) the Earth and the planet Pluto (mean distance 5900 million km). Calculate the distance in kilometres to astronomical objects which are (1) one light-hour away, (2) one light-day away, (3) one light-year away. 2.3 A fighter aircraft sends out a signal that is reflected from a bomber aircraft; the echo signal is received by the fighter after an elapse of 20 µsec. One second after sending the first signal the fighter sends another signal; the echo signal is received after 15 µsec. Deduce the distance measured by the fighter to the bomber on each occasion, and hence find the relative speed of approach of the two aircraft.
2.3
2.3
Simultaneity
41
Simultaneity
In order to synchronize a clock at a distant point Q with a clock at P, one has to send information to Q about the state of the clock at P (or vice versa). An initial
suggestion might be that one should send an ideal clock C from P to Q, after synchronizing C with P's clock; this will then enable synchronization of Q's
clock with C, and so with P (Fig. 2.7a). However, this will not work. This is because, as we have already seen, the result obtained will depend on the path through space-time taken by C from P to Q (Fig. 2.7b), that is, on the speed with which C is moved from P to Q. Thus one cannot set up a consistent synchronization system this way that will give the same answer no matter how the clock C is
moved from P to Q (in mathematical terms, proper time is not an integrable variable). As in the case of distance measurement, one must turn to the use of electromagnetic signals ('light') to convey adequately the information needed for synchronization from P to Q. In fact, determining which events are simultaneous with particular events in the history of an inertial observer P is again best achieved by radar.
P
C
®O t
T (a)
(b)
Fig. 2.7 (a) A conceivable process for synchronizing distant clocks at P and Q by transporting a third clock C between them, and a space-time diagram of this process. (b)
This procedure will not work, because the result is ambiguous: another clock C', synchronized with C at P, will in general disagree with C on arrival at Q after traveling from P to Q. Thus the result of such a synchronization process is arbitrary.
42
Fundamentals of measurement
Fig. 2.8 The synchronization of clocks at P and Q using a radar signal. Because light takes the same time to travel out and back, the reflection event r at Q must be simultaneous with the event q at P half-way between emission and reception of the signal.
Suppose P sends out an electromagnetic signal at a time tl to Q and records the time t2 at which the echo pulse is reflected back from Q. Because P knows that the speed of light is constant, he will deduce that half the light travel time was taken
up by the outward journey and half by the return journey, so he will judge that the reflection event rat Q is simultaneous with the time Tin his history precisely half-way between when the signal was sent and when the echo was received (Fig. 2.8). This is given by adding half the light travel time to the time the light was emitted, i.e.
T = tl + 2 (t2 - t1) = (t1 + t2).
(2.2)
2
This is a practical way of determining simultaneity, and so of synchronizing clocks even if they are very far apart. For example if P is on the surface of the Earth and Q on the Moon, they can synchronize their clocks by the following procedure: observer P sends a radar signal to Q. He measures the times tl and t2, determines T from eqn (2.2), and transmits this value to Q. Observer Q records the time t' of the reflection event r according to his initial watch setting. After receiving the signal from P, he resets his watch by the amount T - t', which is the difference between the time T assigned to event r by A and the time t' assigned to r by his own watch. Each observer can use this method to define simultaneity in space-time. If they
are in relative motion, they will disagree on simultaneity (as has already been
pointed out in Section 1.3). This does not matter: each obtains a perfectly unambiguous definition of the meaning of simultaneity for him, that corresponds
2.3
Simultaneity 43
precisely with our ordinary, everyday notion of simultaneity. An example may help to clarify this. Imagine two police cars patrolling a straight road between two police stations A and B. The drivers are instructed to go immediately to whichever station calls first, unless both call at the same time, in which case station A has priority. At a particular time, both cars are midway between the stations, with car 1 stationary and car 2 traveling towards station B. At that precise moment, according to car 1, both stations send out a call. Car 1 proceeds to station A, while car 2 proceeds to station B, having received a call from there before that from A. Who is correct? The answer, of course, is that both are correct (see Fig. 2.9). Simultaneity is not absolute but is affected by relative motion (cf. Fig. 1.29). We shall study this further in the next chapter. The key concept that enables this analysis to be made is due to Einstein: it is that one should give an operational definition of simultaneity, i.e. a definition in terms of the results of possible experiments. The rest of the analysis then follows on noting the invariance of the speed of light for all observers. One should note that when the standard coordinates (t, X, Y, Z) are used by an observer P in flat space-time, according to the definition given here the surfaces {t = constant} are precisely surfaces of simultaneity for P, whose world-line is (X = Y = Z = 0). For example, if P sends out a signal at t = -1 (Fig. 2.10), which is reflected at the event r with coordinates (t = 0, X = 1), then it is received again by P at t = 1.
The mid-time T (calculated from formula (2.2)) is measured by P to be T = (-1 + 1) = 0; so P determines the event r to be simultaneous with the event q: (t 2= T = 0, X = 0) in his own history. Similarly each event for which t = 0 is measured by him to be simultaneous with q. Thus, in flat space-time, the standard time coordinate t does indeed (as would be expected) indicate the way clocks would be synchronized (using radar) by the observer who set up the coordinate system. Any other observer who is at rest in this coordinate system, i.e. who is
station A t4
car 1
station B
X
Fig. 2.9 Police car 1 is stationary relative to police stations A and B, but car 2 is approaching B. Signals sent out simultaneously (as measured by car 1) from A and B at events a and b will be received at the same time by car 1 at event p, but car 2 will receive the
signal from station B first (at event q) and the signal from station A second (at event r). Thus car 2 will detect the emission event b before the emission event a.
44
Fundamentals of measurement
surface simultaneous with q: to ti
X
Fig. 2.10 The surface of events in space-time simultaneous for the observer P (stationary in the chosen coordinate system) with the event q at the origin of coordinates. P has to use a whole series of radar signals (e.g. those shown establishing simultaneity of r and r' with q) to determine this surface.
stationary relative to P, will determine the same surfaces of simultaneity. How-
ever, an observer who is in relative motion, again using (2.2) to determine simultaneity, will disagree. We will explore this further in the next chapter.
2.4
World maps, world pictures, and radar maps
Now that the concept of simultaneity as determined by radar has been carefully defined, it is useful to distinguish between three different possible observational views of a space-time. A world map is the idea we inherit from Newtonian theory: it is a view of objects in a space-time at an instant, i.e. a map representing where the objects are in an
instantaneous space section {t = constant} of the space-time (Fig. 2.1 la).
Unfortunately, it is difficult for an observer to obtain such a view of space-time at some time to observationally (cf. Fig. 1.11). The reason is that the further out a point in the surface { t = to } is, the earlier must be the emission of the radar pulse and the later the reception of the echo pulse (cf. Fig. 2.10); hence this map can only be observationally determined by a whole series of radar measurements involving sending out a series of radar pulses. By contrast, a world picture is a view of objects in space-time on the past light cone of the point of observation (Fig. 2.11b). Any photograph or other observation of distant objects by simply detecting incoming radiation from them* is a *e.g. by a radio or X-ray telescope (see The New Astronomy by N. Henbest and M. Marten
Cambridge University Press, 1983), or by the human eye.
2.4
World maps, world pictures, and radar maps 45
t
(b)
(a)
tT (sec)
(c)
(d)
Fig. 2.11 (a) A world map depicts the position of each object in the surface of simultaneity of some event t = to on the observer's world-line. (b) A world picture depicts the position of each object in the past light cone of some event t = to on the observer's world-line (e.g. when a photograph was taken). (c) A radar map depicts the position of each object in the future light cone of an event t = to on the observer's world-line (when a
radar pulse was emitted). (d) When ordinary units are used to describe everyday occurrences, the light cones are extremely flat and so the three views are very similar, because the spatial position of an object cannot change much between the events r and s where its world-line intersects these light cones (except if the object viewed is moving at close to the speed of light).
representation of these objects on our past light cone, inevitably therefore representing the associated time delays (cf. the discussion in Section 1.2.). The problem is that what we directly obtain is a two-dimensional representation of these objects (the photograph itself), with images of objects all projected onto the same image plane no matter how different their distances (cf. Fig. 1.10). How far away they are is then not at all obvious; indeed, for many decades astronomers debated whether `spiral nebulae' were clouds of dust in our own galaxy, or distant galaxies equal in size to our own galaxy; the latter eventually turned out to be the correct answer. To determine how far away objects are we need further analysis, e.g. determination of distances by measuring apparent sizes, apparent luminosities, or redshifts. Use of such methods of estimating distances (discussed in the following chapters) allows an observer to construct his world picture at any time
46
Fundamentals of measurement
to in his history. The particular advantage of this method of observation is that it can be used out to extremely large distances. Finally, a radar map is the natural picture obtained directly by a radar set as commonly used in aircraft, on ships, in airport control towers, etc. (see Fig. 2.12.) We can conceive of a radar pulse being sent out at some time to, echo pulses received from objects at various distances, and the radar display being constructed from these echoes, representing the distance of each object according to the delay time for the corresponding echo. The implication is that this is a picture of the position of each object on the future light cone of the event to (Fig. 2.1 lc). This picture has the great advantage that it is directly obtained and immediately displayed, but the disadvantage that it cannot be used out to very large distances, because the light travel time out to the object and back becomes too large. However, this is a real limitation only in the context of astronomical observations; it will not be a serious restriction on the earth. It is clear that the representation of positions of objects in space-time obtained in each case is conceptually quite different (cf. Figs 2.lla, b, c). However, the resulting maps will differ substantially only if the objects depicted move appreciably on the relevant time-scale. In the context of measurements in ordinary everyday life, the speed of light is very high, so if we use ordinary units of measurement, the light cones are extremely flat and the three maps obtained will differ very little (Fig. 2.11d). Thus, for the purposes of distance measurements in
everyday life, radar provides a very adequate and convenient picture of the relative positions of objects giving a good approximation to the instantaneous view of a world map. Exercises 2.4 Explain what practical problems will occur in using radar over very long distances, and estimate the maximum distance over which radar is a practical distance-measuring device. 2.5 Taking into account special relativity principles and the limiting nature of the
speed of light, see if you can propose some other method of determining simultaneity at a distance. If you do so, convince yourself whether it is essentially equivalent to the radar definition, or not. 2.6 Two volcanoes 100 km apart on lo (a satellite of Jupiter) are seen by an observer A at rest on lo to erupt simultaneously. Observer B is the pilot of a rocket which according to A is 10 km directly above the first volcano when it explodes, flying towards the second at a speed of c. What will B see as happening at the second volcano at the moment when he sees the first explode? 2.7 According to a nuclear treaty between two superpowers, if either strikes first the second is entitled to destroy the first completely. The superpowers deploy two ships A and B which move at a very high speed towards each other. Ship A sends off radar signals at one-second intervals which are reflected back by B. At t = 0 in its coordinates, A fires a weapon at B. At t = 4, A receives back the signal sent at t = -6, which detects B firing at A. What can A conclude about who fired first? [In Chapter 3 we will consider if B would reach the same conclusion.] 2.8 Ask various friends what time interval appropriately corresponds to various distance measures: e.g. 1 cm; l metre; 1 kilometre. [In principle it is not possible to make such
A
Fig. 2.12 Radar used to control the movements of aircraft. (top) The radar antenna. Pulses are transmitted and received by the unit at the focus of the curved antenna, which rotates to cover all directions around the airfield. (bottom) The display (a `radar map'), directly showing the spatial positions of aircraft relative to the airfield. (Photograph from Plessey plc.)
48
Fundamentals of measurement
a comparison, but in practice most people are able to make a reasonable correspondence on the basis of their experience in daily life, e.g. using the speed of walking or driving to set the relative scales.] Try to draw past and future light cones in space-time using `natural units' (e.g. minutes and metres). Observe from this how the light cones closely define a `surface of simultaneity' in everyday life.
Computer Exercise 3 Write a program that accepts as input from a radar set trained on a UFO, (a) the time TI at which a radar pulse is transmitted towards the UFO, (b) the time T2 at which an echo is received from it; and gives as output, (i) the distance D measured to the UFO, (b) the time TR at which the radar pulse was reflected by it.
Suppose the radar set sends out a regular train of pulses a time T apart. What condition should Tsatisfy to avoid confusion between different echo pulses? Modify your program to print out also the relative speed of approach of the UFO as determined by the echo pulses received from it. Ensure your program prints out a special warning message if
the speed determination for the UFO appears to violate a special relativity condition. What might be an appropriate phrasing of this warning message?
Conclusion
We have now determined methods for measuring the fundamental quantities (time, distance, simultaneity) needed as a basis for all other kinematic measurements, and have done this taking the limiting nature of the speed of light into account. It is important to realize that (in view of the principle of relativity) every observer is equivalent and so all will use the same method to determine time, to measure distance, and to determine simultaneity, as outlined above. In the next chapter, we will determine the consequences of these methods of measurement.
3
Measurements in flat space-times We shall now make quantitative the properties of the space-time of special relativity introduced in the previous chapters. To do so we shall use a simple formalism introduced by Herman Bondi, called the K -calculus. We can represent faithfully all physical effects in these flat space-times, except gravity. To repre-
sent gravity properly, we need to use curved space-times; we discuss these in Chapter 5. The major features of special relativity which we shall look at in turn are its kinematic features, namely (1) the Doppler effect, (2) relativistic velocity addition, (3) the relativity of simultaneity, (4) time dilation and the `twin paradox', and (5) length contraction; and its dynamic features, such as (6) the effective dependence of mass on relative velocity, and the equivalence of mass and energy. While each of these effects may be regarded as important in its own right, we shall emphasize that they only make sense as a total package in which they all occur together. In the next chapter we will look at compact ways of representing this total package.
3.1
The Doppler effect
The first feature we examine is the effect of relative motion on the observed relative rate of progression of time. The basic idea is as follows. Suppose astronaut B is in a rocket moving uniformly at c away from space station A towards the star Alpha Centauri. Once a year on thes 13th of March the space station sends birthday greetings to B. Suppose the radio message carrying this greeting in the year 2010 is measured by the space station to travel a distance of light-year to z reach the rocket, taking a time T = z year to do this. The next message is sent exactly a year later. When this radio message has travelled for 1 a year to where the astronaut received the previous signal, the rocket has moved light-year further s in fact the time on, so this signal has to travel longer to catch up the rocket;
measured by A when the signal reaches the rocket is years after it was emitted (Fig. 3.1). Thus according to A, the birthday greetings asent yearly will be received by B at intervals of one and a quarter years! This does not directly tell us what interval B will measure between receiving the signals (note the warnings in the last chapter!), but it does indicate that this time will not be one year. A similar effect will occur for all light or radio signals from B to A. Accordingly we expect the rate of happenings at the space station as seen by the astronaut to differ from the rate
50
Measurements in flat space-times
Fig. 3.1 Two radio signals sent out 1 year apart by space station A, as seen in A's coordinates (the time t = 0 is chosen to be midday on 13 March 2010). The first signal is received by astronaut B at the event a, whose coordinates are t = 0.5, X = 0.5. The second is received by Bat the event b, whose coordinates are t = 1.75, Z = 0.75. Thus according to A, the time interval between B's reception of these signals is 1.25 years. We are unable to determine directly from this diagram the time interval B measures between these events.
Fig. 3.2 Light signals sent at an interval T by observer A, as measured by his clock, to observer B moving relative to A. The signals are received by B at an interval T' as measured by his clock; K is defined by the relation T' = KT.
of those happenings as measured at the space station. This is the effect we now investigate. Consider two inertial observers A and B in relative motion. A emits a light signal, waits a time interval T as measured by his clock, and then sends a second signal. B measures the time interval between reception of these signals to be T' (Fig. 3.2). A quantity K is then defined as the ratio of these proper times:
K = T'/T
T' = KT.
(3.1)
3.1
The Doppler effect
51
We shall see below that, when the speed of relative motion is non-zero, the time
intervals are different, i.e. K is unequal to 1. (The formulae relating K to the relative velocity of the observers are (3.9) and (3.10) below.)
In principle, one can easily measure K directly from definition (3.1). For example, if A's `vehicle' (be it a spacecraft, aircraft, the earth, or whatever) has attached to it a radio beacon that emits signals at known regular intervals (say every minute), B merely has to receive these signals and measure the time interval between them to determine K. Thus, if B measures the time interval between reception of the signals to be one and a half minutes, then T = 1 minute and T' = 1.5 minutes, so K = 1.5/1 = 1.5. More hypothetically, suppose A and B each possess identical accurate clocks, and B has a very powerful telescope through which he can observe A's clock. He then merely has to watch A's clock through the telescope, and compare the time it registers with that registered by his own clock (e.g. noting the time interval T' elapsing according to his own clock every time A's clock registers that an hour has passed; then K follows from (3.1) with T = 1 hour). This is nothing other than the `thought experiment' mentioned in Section 1.3, where an observer in the tram watched the clock tower in Berne. That thought experiment already tells us that we expect K to get unboundedly large if the relative velocities of the observers approaches the speed of light.
Redshift
Often the easiest practical way to measure the quantity K is by measuring the observed wavelength of light, radio waves, or other electromagnetic radiation emitted by the source, provided the intrinsic wavelength of this radiation is known. This is the basis of the redshift measurements that are our major tool in investigating the expansion of the universe. Suppose that A emits electromagnetic radiation at wavelength AE. Then* the period ATE of this radiation (the time for one full oscillation, cf. Fig. 3.3a) is given by AE = czTE. By eqn (3.1), the period of the radiation received by B is measured by him to be ATO = KATE (Fig. 3.3b). The wavelength Ao that B observes for the light is related to its period by the relation AO = cATO. Therefore
the wavelength of the received radiation is related to the wavelength of the emitted radiation by AO = KAE.
(3.2)
This change in wavelength is easy to measure direct from the spectrum of received light. One identifies in the observed spectrum a line of known wavelength at the
source (e.g. the `alpha line' of wavelength 1215 angstroms in the spectrum of hydrogen), measures its received wavelength, and so determines Kfrom eqn (3.2). It is common to express the result of such measurements in terms of the redshift *You can omit the details of the following derivation if you are prepared to accept eqn. (3.3b) as correct.
52
Measurements in flat space-times
(a)
(b)
Fig. 3.3 (a) The amplitude of an electric field plotted against time, showing the period ATE (the time for one full oscillation). (b) An observer B measures a period Oro for a signal emitted by observer A with period ATE.
parameter z, the fractional change in wavelength. Formally, z is defined by the relation z = (change in wavelength)/ (emitted wavelength) _ (Ao - AE)/AE = Ao/AE - 1.
(3.3a)
It then follows that
l+z=Ao/)E=K.
(3.3b)
Redshifts for distant galaxies are routinely measured by astronomers from their spectra, and used to determine their speed of recession (Fig. 3.4; we will cover the relation of redshift to velocity in Sections 3.2 and 4.3). The name `redshift' is used because light in distant receding galaxies is observed to be displaced towards the red end of the spectrum. This is because if z > 0, then K > 1 and the received wavelength is longer than the emitted wavelength. The colour of light is directly determined by its wavelength as follows: in units of 10-5 cm, the wavelength of red light is between 7.5 and 6.3, orange 6.3 to 5.9, yellow 5.9 to 5.3, green 5.3 to 4.9, blue 4.9 to 4.5, indigo 4.5 to 4.3, and violet 4.2 to 3.9, while infra-red is above 7.5 and ultraviolet is below 3.9. Thus, light emitted as blue may be seen as green, that emitted as green may be seen as yellow, and so on, cf. Fig. 3.5a; so the light is displaced towards the red end of the spectrum, as claimed. On the other hand if -1 < z < 0, then 0 < K < 1, the received wavelength is shorter than the emitted wavelength, and the light is blueshifted (light emitted as yellow may be seen as green, light emitted as green may be seen as blue, and so on; see Fig. 3.5b).
3.1 CLUSTER NEBULA IN
DISTANCE IN LIGHT-YEARS
The Doppler effect
53
RED-SHIFTS
7,500,000
750 MILES PER SECOND
VIRGO
100,000,000 9,300 MILES PER SECOND
URSA MAJOR
D
130,000,000
CORONA BOREALIS
13,400 MILES PER SECOND
BOOTES
24,400 MILES PER SECOND
X11
!II
i
11
i
38,000 MILES PER SECOND
HYDRA
Fig. 3.4 The relation between distance and redshift for distant galaxies. In each case the galaxy spectrum is presented between reference laboratory spectra; redshifts are measured
directly from the frequency shift in the K and H lines of calcium between the spectra, indicated here by arrows. The redshifts are then expressed as velocities (by use of the Doppler shift formula). The distances of the galaxies are estimated from their apparent luminosities, and expressed in light-years (one light-year is about 6 x 1012 miles). The relation between redshift and distance seen here is usually taken as evidence for the expansion of the universe (see Chapter 7). (Photograph from the Hale Observatories.)
The effect, of course, applies to all electromagnetic radiation. If, for example, A is broadcasting by radio and B is moving relative to A, then B will have to retune his radio in order to receive the transmission if K is significantly different from 1. As an example, suppose a transmitter sends out a signal at a frequency of 2 kHz. Frequency v is related to wavelength A by the relation c = v,\, so eqn (3.2) shows
vo = vE/K
(3.4)
54
Measurements in flat space-times observed:
V
V
B
G
Y
0
R
B
G
Y
0
R
//////REDSHIFT I
I
emitted: (a)
observed:
V
I
B
G
Y
B
G
Y
0
BLUESHIFT\\\ \ \ V
I
R
0 R emitted:
E
(b)
Fig. 3.5
(a) Redshift: the observed wavelength of light of different colours (red, orange, yellow, green, blue, indigo, violet) is longer than that of the emitted wavelength, so the colours appear to be shifted towards the red end of the spectrum. (b) Blueshift: the observed wavelength of light is shorter than that of the emitted wavelength.
Say for definiteness that K = 2; then B will receive the signals at 1 kHz. Clearly, K
can be measured directly from the amount of retuning required. Because the effect is essentially the same as that occurring in the Doppler shift of sound waves (when sounds from a moving source are heard at a different frequency from their emitted frequency), the parameter Kcan appropriately be called the Doppler shift
factor.
Uniformity of K The first basic assumption we shall make about K (defined by eqn (3.1)) is that when A and B are inertial observers, K is independent of T and constant in time. Firstly, Kis assumed independent of T, thus for example the same Doppler factor will be measured whether the signals are emitted one second or one hour apart. This implies that the spectral shift observed for a single source (eqns (3.2-4)) is the same for all wavelengths. This is the hallmark of the effect: the same redshift must be observed for all spectral lines in an observed spectrum. If the value measured for z from light from a single source varies depending on which line is measured, the change of wavelength is not due to the simple Doppler shift effect; some other explanation must be found. Secondly, Kis assumed constant in time ifboth A and B are moving inertially; thus the value obtained for Kwill be the same at 1 o'clock and 4 o'clock if the relative speed is constant. One can invert this: suppose that the source A is moving inertially in the flat space-time of special relativity. Then one can test whether B is moving inertially or not (that is, whether the sources are in relative uniform motion) by seeing if K is constant in time. (Note that the results mentioned here are true in the special theory of relativity; they do not always hold true in the curved space-times of the general theory of relativity, as we shall see in Chapter 5.) An illustration of this result is as follows: suppose that an observer B moves uniformly relative to observer A, and observes a K-factor of 2; B passes A at the event 0, and A sends signals to B at the event 0 and then at 1-second intervals for 10 seconds (see Fig. 3.6a). Then B will receive these signals regularly at 2-second intervals; hence the whole period T1 of transmission recorded by A (10 seconds) is related to the whole period T2 of reception of the signals by B (20 seconds) by the relation T2 = 2T1, that is, T2 = KT1 (see Fig. 3.6b).
3.1
The Doppler effect
55
(b)
(a)
Fig. 3.6 (a) An observer A sends regular signals for 10 seconds, which are received by observer B during a period of 20 seconds because the K-factor is 2. (b) In general in this situation, T2 = KTI.
(a)
(b)
Relative motion at speed v for observers A and B, seen (a) in A's rest frame (A is at rest and B moves to the right at speed v), and (b) in B's rest frame (B is at rest and A moves to the left at speed v). Fig. 3.7
Reciprocity of K The second basic assumption about K is a consequence of the principle of relativity. Suppose that as well as A sending signals to B, the observer B sends signals to A. Then there is no intrinsic difference between the two situations: in each case the source merely sends signals to the observer, who is in motion relative to the source (see Fig. 3.7). In special relativity the factor Kis simply a result of relative motion in flat space-time. Since this space-time is isotropic (i.e. the same in all
56
Measurements in flat space-times
directions), light propagation is the same in all directions. Because of the equivalence of all inertial observers, the two K-factors measured must be the same: KAB = KBA
(3.5)
where KAB is the K-factor for light emitted from A and received at B, and KBA is the K-factor for light emitted from B and received at A. If this were not so, there
would be some intrinsic difference between light propagation from A to B and from B to A, contrary to the relativity assumption; this intrinsic difference would enable us to measure absolute motion. Thus the Doppler shift effect is completely reciprocal: whatever relative time change is detected by B in observations of A, is also detected by A in observations of B. If A measures a factor-2 increase in the
wavelengths of all light received from B, then B will also measure a factor-2 increase in the wavelengths of all light received from A. So A will have to retune his receiver by a factor 2 to receive signals from B, and B will also have to retune his receiver by a factor 2 to receive signals from A. The observer B will see A's clock running slow by a factor of 2, and A will observe B's clock to be running slow by a factor of 2. This symmetry allows us to omit the subscript `AB' from KAB when the context makes it clear which observers are concerned (see Fig. 3.8).
Measuring K by radar A useful feature results from the symmetry relation (3.5): suppose A sends out two pulses separated by a time interval T, which are reflected by B and received again by A with a time separation T" (Fig. 3.9). By the definition of K, the time between these pulses measured by B will be T' = KT, and then T" = KT' = K2 T. Thus, A merely has to observe the ratio T"/T to determine K from the relation
K = /(T"/T).
(3.6)
The significance of this derives from the fact that to use relations (3.1-4) to determine K, the observer A has to receive radiation emitted by B where this radiation has to be of a known wavelength (or frequency). Thus, either the signal
Fig. 3.8 Signals sent by Bat an interval T' (as measured by his clock) and received by A at
an interval T" (as measured by his clock). By the relativity principle, T" = KT'.
3.1
Fig. 3.9
The Doppler effect
57
Signals sent by A at an interval T, reflected by B at an interval T', and received by A at an interval T".
has to be deliberately transmitted at a specific frequency, or the frequency must be deduced from the received radiation (which indicates physical conditions at the source), e.g. by recognizing specific spectral lines. However, using reflected
pulses and relation (3.6), A can determine K even if B is not emitting any radiation. This enables him to measure the speed of motion of B relative to himself, as well as B's distance, purely on the basis of measurements at his own position, without the collaboration of B or any detailed knowledge about B. Summary The discussion we have given shows that when K > 1 (which will be the case when A and B are moving apart, as we shall see in the next section) the factor Kgives the relative time increase observed by B in all phenomena at A, and observed by A in all phenomena at B. The fact that we commonly refer to this effect in terms of the
redshifting of light is just because this happens to be easy to observe. The timeshift observed for all other effects will be the same. For example, suppose we observe the radiation received from a quasi-stellar object at great distance to have a redshift z = 3, and to vary in brightness on a time-scale of 8 hours. Then (since K = z + 1 = 4) in fact these variations must have taken place on a time-scale of 2 hours at the source. Exercises 3.1 A space-traveller moving away from the Earth at speed such that K = 2 tunes into a television show transmitted from the Earth. In what way will the K-factor affect the display he obtains and the way he receives it? 3.2 In order to perform a complicated docking manoeuvre, it is essential that two spacecraft can be held at rest relative to each other. Devise a simple experiment to check that this is so.
Computer Exercise 4 Write a programme that will accept as input (a) either a value for K or a value of z due to relative motion of two observers, and (b) a time period T, a wavelength L, or a frequency F
58
Measurements in flat space-times
measured by one of them; and give as output the corresponding time period T', wavelength L' or frequency F' (as appropriate) measured by the other (given by eqns (3.1-4)). Now modify your programme to accept as input a letter representing the colour of emitted light (e.g. `B' for `blue') and to print out the colour of this light as seen by the relatively moving observer. [Note that for high values of z, some light will be shifted out of the visual range and some radiation into this range.]
If your computer has colour graphics, apply this change to any colour image you have available to see visually the effect of redshifting (K > 1) or blueshifting (K < 1) an image.
Redshift and background radiation From quantum theory, we know that the energy of a photon is proportional to its frequency: E = hv, where the frequency is the number of oscillations per second, and so is just the inverse of the period: v = I/ AT. Thus (see p. 51) frequency is inversely proportional to wavelength, with proportionality constant the speed of
light: v = c/). Putting this together with (3.3b), the observed frequency of radiation and hence the measured energy per photon varies as the inverse of the redshift factor (1 + z):
Eo_vo_AE_ EE
vE
Ao
1
1 +z'
(3.7)
Now the rate at which photons are emitted by a source will be seen by an observer moving away to be slowed by a factor (1 + z), so the rate at which energy is emitted by a source will be related to the rate energy is received from the source by Z)2:
a factor (1 +
(3.8)
C\dT/E(1 +z)2 This determines the effect of motion on flux of radiation received from distant objects (see eqns (4.35) and (7.11) below, and Fig. 7.13, for the cosmological application). They look fainter if they are receding from us and brighter if they are approaching.
Now we live in a universe bathed in cosmic background radiation ('CBR'), the relic radiation from the `Hot Big Bang'; that is, black body radiation at a temperature of 2.75 K (see pp. 272-4 below). This radiation is isotropic (i.e. is measured to be the same in all directions) for any observer at rest relative to the matter that emitted that radiation-that is, who is moving at the average velocity of all the matter in the universe. The implication of the above relation is that we can detect any motion of our own Galaxy or Sun relative to the universe by measuring a dipole anisotropy in this radiation-a higher temperature in one part of the sky (the direction towards which we are moving) and lower in the opposite part of the sky (the direction away from which we are moving). Actually the effect is even stronger: the instruments we use measure intensity of radiation
(that is, flux of radiation received in a unit solid angle from many sources of radiation), rather than flux from a single source; this brings in two more factors of redshift (see (4.36) and (7.11,12) below), enhancing the dipole anisotropy effect predicted.
3.2
Relative velocity
59
Fig. 3.10 The cosmic background radiation temperature anisotropy as measured in all directions in the sky (the oval shape represents the entire sky). The section surrounded by
the lightest region is hotter by one part in a thousand than the dark section (which is the opposite direction in the sky). This is caused by our motion relative to the rest frame of the universe. The radiation was emitted at a redshift of about 1100.
This kind of anisotropy is precisely what we measure: there is a difference in the measured CBR temperature of one part in 103 in opposite directions in the sky, as measured for example by the COBE satellite (Fig. 3.10). This suggests we are moving at a speed of 300 km/sec relative to the rest frame defined by this background radiation. If we transform to that frame (the rest frame of the universe), this dipole anisotropy will be removed. The resulting CBR anisotropy is then very small indeed; it is isotropic to the astonishing accuracy of one part in 105 (Fig. 3.11), the remnant fluctuations arising from the very small inhomogeneities in the very early universe at the time of decoupling of matter and radiation, that later grow into clusters of galaxies. (Figures 3.10 and 3.11 are reproduced in colour on the back cover.) [Note: this section refers forward to the cosmology parts of the book. This is deliberate: the idea is to make the reader aware that those parts will be reached in due course and will be interesting. The CBR anisotropy is mentioned again on p. 274].
3.2
Relative velocity
In special relativity theory, the Doppler shift factor K depends simply on the relative motion of the source and the observer. We first determine that relation in the simple case of radial relative motion, and then derive the special relativity law of addition of parallel velocities.
The relation between K and relative radial velocity
Consider two observers A and B moving directly away from each other at a uniform speed v. For simplicity, let their positions coincide at the time t = 0 as
60
Measurements in flat space-times
Fig. 3.11 (a) The residual anisotropy once the dipole has been removed. Apart from the major lane across the sky due to sources in our own galaxy, the anisotropy is only one part
in a hundred thousand. (b) The remnant anisotropy once the galaxy signal has been subtracted. The primordial fluctuations detected represent inhomogeneities at the surface of last scattering of the Cosmic Background Radiation. They provide the seeds for growth of large-scale structures at much later times, such as the clusters of galaxies we see at the present time, and the matter in them is the most distant matter we can detect by any form
of electromagnetic radiation (they form our visual horizon). (Images 3.10 and 3.11 reproduced by permission of the NASA Goddard Space Flight Center and the COBE Science Working Group.)
measured by both their clocks; we can regard them as signalling to each other by
radio at that time (the distance is zero, so communication is instantaneous). Suppose that a radio pulse is then emitted by A at a time T as measured by his clock, which is reflected by B at a time T' as measured by B's clock, and received
again by A at a time T" measured by A's clock (Fig. 3.12). Remembering the
3.2
Relative velocity
61
Fig. 3.12 Observer A emits a radio signal at time T, and observer B receives it at time T' at event p. It is reflected back to A who receives it at time T". A measures the event q at time
2(T + T") to be simultaneous with p.
definition (3.1) of Kand the reciprocity relation (3.5), we find (cf. Fig. 3.6 and the derivation of eqn (3.6)) that
T' = KT, T"=KT'=K2T. According to A, the travel time for the radio pulse is therefore
T"-T=K2T-T=(K2-1)T. By eqn (2.1) the radar distance measured by A between B and A is thus
D = c(K2 - 1)T.
(3.9)
Z
To determine the velocity of B as measured by A, we must find out when A measures B to be this far away. By the definition of simultaneity (Section 2.3), A determines the reflection event p to be simultaneous with the event q in his history which is half-way between the times of transmission and of reception. By eqn (2.2), the time measured by A's clock at q is
tq =2(T"+T) =2(K2+1)T.
(3.10)
Now, A and B coincided at the time t = 0 measured by A's clock. A therefore concludes that B has moved a distance D (given by (3.9)) in the time tq (given by (3.10)), so the speed of B relative to A, as measured by A, is
v = D/tq = {1c(K2 - 1)T}/{2 ' (K2 + 1)T}.
62
Measurements in flat space-times
Multiplying numerator and denominator by 2/T shows that
v = (K2 - 1)c/(K2 + 1).
(3.1 la)
Therefore K, which is directly measurable in various ways (see Section 3.1), directly determines the relative speed of separation of A and B. (Note that the results would be more complex if the motion were non-radial, i.e. if A and B were not moving directly towards or away from each other; we will only consider radial motion here.) Just as we introduced the rescaled coordinates (X, Y, Z) to simplify distance measurements relative to the speed of light, so now it is convenient to rescale our velocity measurements. We do so by defining V = v/c. The quantity V is dimensionless; it is simply the velocity v rescaled relative to the speed of light. In these units, the speed of light is ±1 (if v = c then V = c/c = 1; if v = -c, then
V =-1). The final result is then
V = (v/c) = (K2 - 1)/(K2 + 1).
(3.llb)
We can solve eqn (3.l lb) for K2 in terms of V by multiplying through by K2 + 1 and collecting terms. We find
V(K2+1)=(K2-1)
K2(V-1)=-(V+1),
so
K2=-(V+1)/(V-1)=(1+V)/(1- V). On taking the square root of this relation, the sign ambiguity is resolved because Kmust always be positive (if B observes A's clock through a telescope, he will not see it run backwards!) Thus the Doppler shift factor K resulting from a relative radial velocity v is found to be
1+V K= (1-V) For example, if v = c, then V = I, so 1+ V = 4, 1 - V= 4. Thus K2 4 K = (3)z= 1.291. Similarly, if v =1 c
then K = 32 = 1.732;
ifv=4c
then K=7'=2.646;
ifv = io c
then K = 192'= 4.359;
ifv = 100 c
then K = 199' = 14.107.
(3.12a)
and
Thus, as expected, high relative speeds cause large K-factors, and so large ratios between times measured by two observers.
3.2
Relative velocity
63
Approach and recession The calculation above was done for a relative speed of recession v of A and B, and
assumed v > 0. If we consider the case when A and B approach each other at relative speed v (Fig. 3.13), the resulting formulae will be identical except that v
is replaced by -v, and V by -V. Therefore, we can use the same formulae (3.11-12) for both approach and recession if we introduce the sign convention: v will be positive whenever A and B recede from each other, and negative whenever
they approach each other. We adopt this sign convention from now on; then (3.11) and (3.12) apply to relative radial motion whether it represents relative approach or recession of the observers. With this sign convention, the reciprocity of the relation is apparent: KAB = KBA
VAB = VBA,
(3.12b)
that is, receding observers each measure the other to be receding at the same speed, and approaching observers each measure the other to be approaching at the same speed. This result is in fact just a consequence of Einstein's relativity principle, that physics should be the same for both inertial observers, since this leads to the expressions (3.9-12) which treat both observers on exactly the same footing. If this were untrue (e.g. if you measure me to be receding at 500 km/sec, but I measure you to be receding at 250 km/sec) relative velocities would be very difficult indeed to deal with. As in the case of K, we will omit the subscript `AB' from vAB whenever no confusion results.
Fig. 3.13 A situation similar to that depicted in Fig. 3.12 but with the observers approaching each other rather than receding. A sends a signal at time T" before the observers meet and receives it back a time T before they meet, after B has reflected it at V.
64
Measurements in flat space-times
Suppose V = 0; then (3.12a) shows K = 1. Similarly if K = 1, then (3.11) shows V = 0. Thus the relations we have derived show
K=1 q v = 0
V = 0,
i.e. there is no Doppler shift effect if and only if the relative velocity is zero. Considering now the relation of v to Kand z implied by (3.3, 11, 12), we find that K > 1 (a relative slowing down of time is observed) when observers recede from
each other, and K < 1 (a relative speeding up of time is observed) when they approach each other: Relative approach -1 < V < 0 No relative motion V = 0 Relative recession 0 < V < 1
0
-1 < z < 0 (light blueshifted)
1< K
z> 0
z=0
(no Doppler effect) (light redshifted)
Basically, this follows because when receding, each observes the other to be positioned at steadily increasing distances and so light travelling either way has to travel larger and larger distances; so we then expect the time intervals observed at the receiver to be longer than the time intervals at the emitter, i.e. > K > 1 (cf.
Fig. 3.1). Similarly, when approaching, light travelling either way will travel shorter and shorter distances so the observed time intervals at the receiver will be shorter than those at the emitter, i.e. K < 1. Figure 3.14 shows the relation between v/c and K; one can read off the relation either way from this graph (e.g. one can find the K-value corresponding to any
v/c, or the v/c value corresponding to any K). It is clear from this graph (and follows from eqns (3,11,12)) that as the relative speed of motion approaches the speed of light, the relative time-change observed increases without limit. In the case of relative approach,
v/c- -1 s> K-0,
Fig. 3.14
The relation between K and V = v/c.
3.2
Relative velocity
65
i.e. a time interval AT at A is observed by B in an indefinitely short time period. In the case of relative recession, v/c - 1
K
oo,
i.e. a time interval AT at A is observed by B to last an indefinitely long time period.
This is the result Einstein realized by thinking about observing the clock in the square at Berne through a telescope (see Section 1.3 above): as v - c, time appears to stand still. Exercise 3.3 (i) What relative radial velocity V corresponds to a K-factor of 3? Determine the corresponding velocity v = cV in km/sec. (ii)
What relative radial velocity V corresponds to a K-factor of 3? Determine the
corresponding velocity v = cV in km/sec. (iii) If A recedes radially from B at a speed v = 3 c, what is the K-factor observed by A? What is the K-factor observed by B? (iv) If A approaches B radially at a speed v = c, what is the K-factor observed by A? 3 What is the K-factor observed by B?
The change in K during a fly-by
Consider an observer B approaching A at a speed v, and another observer C receding from A at the same speed. Then VAB = -VAC,
VAC > 0,
(3.13)
where VAB is the speed of B relative to A and VAC is the speed of C relative to A measured as a fraction of the speed of light (we are using the sign conventions just introduced). Therefore (3.12a) shows that KAC = {(1 + VAC)/(1 - VAC)}! = {(1 - VAB)/(l + VAB)}2 = 1/KAB
Thus the K-factors for B and C relative to A are related by KAB = l /KAC,
KAC > 1.
(3.14)
We have just proved that (3.13) implies (3.14). Similarly, one can show from eqn (3.11) that (3.14) implies (3.13); that is, two K-factors are reciprocal to each other if and only if the corresponding relative velocities are the same in magnitude but opposite in sign (one corresponding to approach and the other to recession). This is precisely the situation that will occur during a 'fly-by' (see Fig. 3.15a). For example, suppose that B flies past A at a constant speed of c. While B is 5 approaching A, we have vAB/c = -5 and K = Z. After B has reached A and is receding, vAB/c = +5 and K = 2. As B passes A, the K-factor suddenly changes to its reciprocal (in this case, from to 2. There are good physical reasons for this z change: initially A points his receiving antenna to the left (B is approaching from that side). As B passes, A has to swing the antenna round to receive signals from B,
66
Measurements in flat space-times
A
approaching
le receding
Fig. 3.15 A'fly-by'. (a) A watches B approaching from the left and then receding to the right. (b) A space-time situation, showing the light rays by which A observes B when he is
approaching and receding.
which now come from the right. A then receives signals from B on a different family of light rays than the family of light rays on which the signals were initially travelling (Fig. 3.15b). As a consequence, A will also have to retune his receiver as B passes; e.g. if B transmits radio signals at a wavelength of 1 metre, A will receive the signals at a wavelength of 0.5 metres while B is approaching but at 2 metres while B is receding. This is closely analogous to the corresponding effect in the case of sound waves: as a train or car passes a stationary observer while emitting a warning note, the tone heard drops from a high pitch to a low pitch. The Doppler shift factor again changes discontinuously as approach changes to recession.
Exercise 3.4 Show that (3.14) implies (3.13), that is, reciprocal K -factors imply that the measured radial speeds of approach and recession are the same.
The relativity law of addition of parallel velocities Consider now three inertial (non-accelerating) observers A, B, and C in motion relative to each other in the same direction (Fig. 3.16). Then their relative velocities are parallel, and we can choose coordinates so that all the motion takes A
B
C
Fig. 3.16
Observers A, B, C in relative motion, all moving in the same direction.
3.2
Relative velocity
67
place in the x direction and their world-lines in a space-time diagram lie in the (t, X) plane. Figure 3.17 is such a diagram drawn from the viewpoint of A. We can
immediately read off the relative velocities vAB and VAC from this diagram, because the axes are marked off according to the measurements made by A; but we cannot read off vBC, because it is not apparent from this diagram how the time and space measurements made by B or C relate to those made by A.
Fig. 3.17
The world-lines of the observers A, B, C, seen from A's reference frame.
To determine VBC, suppose that A emits light signals separated by a time interval T, and B and C measure the time intervals between reception of these signals as T' and T" respectively (Fig. 3.18). Then by the definition of the K-factor,
T' = KABT,
T" = KACT.
(3.15a,b)
However, we can also consider B emitting light signals a time T' apart. Then T" = KBCT'.
(3.15c)
Combining (3.15c) and (3.15a) shows that T" = KBCKABT. Comparing with (3.15b) and noting that these relations hold for all values of T, one finds KAC = KABKBC,
(3.16)
Fig. 3.18 A emits signals separated by a time interval T; they are received by B separated by T', and by C separated by T".
68
Measurements in flat space-times
the composition law for Doppler shift factors K. Squaring relation (3.16) to obtain KAC = KABKsC and using formula (3.12a), we obtain
_
1+VAC
(1-VAC)
1+VAB
1+VBCI
(1-VAB)(1-VBC/
which may be solved for VAC as follows: multiply through by the product of the denominators to obtain (1 + VAC)(1 - VAB) (I - VBC) _ (1 + VAB)(1 + VBC)(1 - VAC).
Now multiply out, cancel terms, and collect terms in VAC to give
VAC(1+VABVBC)=(VAB+VBc) Dividing by 1 + VAB VBC, VAC = (VAB + VBC)/(1 + VAB VBc),
(3.17a)
that is, VAB + VBC VAC
(3.17b)
+ vABVBC/C2 '
the relativistic velocity addition law for parallel velocities. When the speeds
involved are very small compared with the speed of light c (vAB/c) « 1, IvBC/cJ K 1) the denominator is very nearly equal to 1 and this reduces to the Newtonian result VAC = vAB + VBC.
(3.18)
However, for larger speeds the results given by eqns (3.17,18) differ considerably. For example, suppose vAB = vBC = c. Then the relativity result is 2 VAC = (2 c + 2 c) /(1 + 2 x 2) = 5 c, from (3.17), while the Newtonian result is VAC = c + c = c, from (3.18). Similarly if VAB =vBC = c, the relativity result 2
is VAC =
2 a c/(1 + 1) =c/=c= (0.96) c while the Newtonian result is
i VAC = 1.5c.
The speed of light as an invariant limiting speed In the example above, the relativity velocity addition law shows the relative speed
of A and C is less than the speed of light, although a simple velocity addition suggests it would be greater (cf. Section 1.3). This is no accident; relation (3.17) is of a form which guarantees that as long as vAB and vBC are both less than the speed of light, so is VAC. This is an important feature, since it is necessary in order to have consistency with the principle that no observer should measure a massive object to move as fast as the speed of light (Section 1.2). Further, the limit of this
law as v - c is just what we would wish. Indeed, suppose we put VBc = 1 in (3.17a). Then
VAC=(VAB+1)/(1+VAB)=1, no matter what the value of VAB. Thus taking the limit as VBC - c in (3.17), we confirm that this velocity addition law implies Einstein's principle of invariance of the speed of light, because, if B measures a particle C to move at the speed of
3.2
Relative velocity
69
light, so will A, no matter what the relative velocity of A and B is. This resolves the
velocity-addition problem we encountered in Section 1.2. Finally, we note that if we consider situations where the relative motion of B and C is not parallel to that of A and B, the relativistic result is more complex than that derived here, but still guarantees consistency with the principle of invariance of the speed of light (and so with the limiting nature of the speed of light for motion of massive particles). The theory is self-consistent! Exercises 3.5 Let rocket A move away from B to the left at c, and rocket C move away from B to a the right at c. Draw a space-time diagram of this situation from B's viewpoint, and show a diagram B can determine the relative separation of A and C to be increasing that from this at a rate 1 c. How is this consistent with the fact that the relative speed of motion measured by two observers for each other cannot exceed the speed of light? What relative velocity will A measure for C? 3.6 (i) Consider eqn (3.16) in the case when KBC = 1. Explain the situation occurring. Is the result obtained reasonable? What particular conclusion can you draw ifKAB = 1 also? (ii) Consider eqn (3.16) in the case when KAC = 1. Explain the situation occurring, and hence rederive the result that K is replaced by 1 /K when a speed of approach v is replaced by a speed of recession of the same magnitude. 3.7 (i) What value of K corresponds to a relative speed of approach of 1000 km/hr? (a typical speed of approach of airliners). Is this measurable? (ii) What is the value of Kif v is 500 km/sec? (typical of the relative motions of galaxies in our cluster). (iii) If K is measured to be 5, what is the corresponding speed of relative motion? (iv) A traffic officer measures a car 150 m from him to be travelling towards him at 100 km/hr in a 60 km/hr speed zone. How long does the radar echo take to reach him? If the pulses emitted by his radar set are separated by 3 psec, what is the separation measured by his radar set between the echo pulses? 3.8 Prove from (3.17) that if I VABI < 1 and VBcI < 1, then I VACS < 1. [Hint: prove that(1 - VAB)/(1 - VBC)/(l + VABVBC) = 1 - VACandasimilarexpressionforl + VAC.]
Computer Exercises 5. Write a program that will either (a) accept as input a value for a radial relative velocity V and compute the corresponding K-factor (from eqn (3.12)), or (b) accept as input a K-factor and compute the corresponding radial relative velocity V (from eqn (3.11)). [Ensure that your program accepts only relative speeds less than the speed of light, and values of K greater than zero.] Use your program to confirm (i) the form of Fig. 3.14, and (ii) the reciprocal K-relation (3.14) for equal speeds of approach and recession. 6. Write a program that will accept as input speeds VAB and VBC of relative motion, and print out VAC, the speed of relative motion measured by A for C (calculated from eqn (3.17); restrict the inputs to physically acceptable values). Use your program to verify that VAC does not exceed the speed of light. Adjust the program to print out the error if VAC is estimated by the corresponding Newtonian value (3.18), and hence check that the Newtonian value is acceptably good in ordinary everyday circumstances.
70
3.3
Measurements in flat space-times
Simultaneity
We have already seen in Section 1.3 that the surfaces of simultaneity or instantaneity for observers A and B in space-time depend on their motion. This is a key feature: most of the `paradoxes' of relativity theory require an understanding of the relativity of instantaneity for their resolution. We now examine this issue.
Simultaneity in the observer's rest frame To have in mind a specific example, one can consider setting up a standard time system throughout the solar system in order to facilitate communication between space ships and assist space navigation. Initially the plan is to extend Greenwich
Mean Time out as far as Mars. The way to do this is for an observer A at Greenwich to set up a standard clock, and then to use the concept of simultaneity determined by radar (as explained in Section 2.3) to extend time measured by this clock to other points in the solar system. Just as one would intuitively expect, when the space-time is represented using the standard coordinates (t, X) of A's reference frame, the surfaces of instantaneity he determines by use of radar are the surfaces It = constant} (Fig. 3.19a). For example, if A emits a light signal at tl = -1 and receives its echo at t2 = +1, then since light moves at unit speed in these coordinates the reflection event P has
coordinates t = 0, X = 1. By eqn (2.2), A measures P to occur at the time T = 1(-1 + 1) = 0. Thus P is measured by A to be simultaneous with the event 0 (at t = 0, X = 0) in his history (Fig. 3.19b). Similarly emitting light at t = -2 and
receiving it at t = +2, A determines the event Q at It = 0, X = 2} also to be simultaneous with 0; and in fact A determines all points for which t = 0 to be simultaneous with each other. This is not an accident; use of simultaneity (as defined by radar) is the natural way observer A extends clock readings from his world-line to other points in space-time, so he will naturally define the surfaces tt
A tt
-A
t=+i
Q(t=o,X\=2)
0
y
p (t=o,X=1)
t=o
X
t=-
surfaces of simultaneity
for A (a)
(b)
Fig. 3.19 (a) The surfaces of simultaneity for an observer A (who is, by definition, stationary in his own coordinate system (t, X)). (b) Observer A determines the event P at (0, 1) to be simultaneous with 0 because light emitted by A at t = -1 is reflected at P and received back by A at t = 1. Similarly A can determine Q at (0, 2) to be simultaneous with O.
3.3
Simultaneity
71
It = constant} to denote simultaneity with clock readings along his own worldline. Essentially, we have simply verified that this natural interpretation is correct.
The effect of relative motion
Continuing our specific example, suppose now a rival commercial enterprise decides to set up an alternative time standard for space navigation. Being forward-looking, they decide to base this on the standard of rest defined by the galactic centre. Because of the rotation of our galaxy, the Earth is moving at a speed of about 350 km/sec relative to this standard of rest. The question is how one would relate times determined in the two reference frames. To do so, consider the reference frame of an observer B moving past the observer A at a relative speed v. To simplify the calculation, we assume their positions coincide at an event 0 to which each assigns the time 0; then in terms of
proper time t' measured by B along his world-line, to = 0. Using the standard radar procedure for determining simultaneity (see Section 2.3), observer B will measure a reflection event P' to be simultaneous with 0 if 0 is the half-time between emission and reception of light reflected at P'; since P' is simultaneous with 0, then also ti,, = 0. We do not yet know how t' relates to the coordinate time t. However, one can see (because of the constancy of the K-factor when relative motion is uniform) that equal time intervals measured by B will be represented in the space-time diagram by equal distances along his world-line (cf.
Fig. 3.6). Thus, the light by which B determines simultaneity with 0 must be emitted and received at events E and R represented at equal distances from 0 along his world-line in a space-time diagram (Fig. 3.20). Because light travels at 45°, it is clear from Fig. 3.20 that an event P' measured by B to be simultaneous with 0 will lie above the surface It = 0} in space-time, if B is moving towards the spatial position of that event; so tp, > 0. Thus, in this case, although B measures 0 and P' to occur simultaneously, A will determine P' to occur after 0 (tp, > to). If B moves away from the spatial position of P', then A will determine P' to occur
before 0.
Fig. 3.20 Observer B, moving relative to A, determines the event P' to be simultaneous with 0 because 0 coincides with the point half-way between E, where B emitted a signal, and R, when the signal was received back after reflection at P.
72
Measurements in flat space-times
The equal-angle rule
Consider the situation above, as represented in Fig. 3.21. Examination of the geometry implied by the equality of the distances OE and OR, plus the fact that the segments EP' and RP' are at 45° to the vertical, shows that the shaded triangles ORS and OP'V are congruent to each other. One can convince oneself of this result experimentally (for various values of the angle SOR, draw equal line segments OE and OR accurately and then determine P' as the intersection of lines at 45° from R and E), or by formal geometric proof based on ordinary Euclidean geometry (such a proof is given at the end of this section). Consequently, the angles SOR and VOP' are the same. This implies a simple rule characterizing surfaces of simultaneity in space-time (Fig. 3.22): if a world-line A makes an angle a with the vertical in a space-time diagram, surfaces of instantaneity for an observer with world-line A tilt up by an angle a toward A.
Fig. 3.21
Fig. 3.22
Figure 3.20 redrawn to illustrate the fact that triangles ORS and OP'V are congruent.
The angle a between the surfaces of simultaneity for A and B is the same as the angle between their world-lines in a space-time diagram drawn from A's viewpoint.
3.3
Simultaneity
73
Fig. 3.23 A point (to, Xo) on B's world-line, where Xo = Vt0, and a point (t1, X1) on B's surface of simultaneity. Because of the equal-angle rule (Fig. 3.22), tl /Xi = X0/to =tan a.
The simultaneity equation The preceding result enables us to derive a simple formula for these surfaces of simultaneity. Because B is moving at a speed v relative to A, we see that B's world-
line is given by x = vt, so X = x/c = vt/c = (v/c)t = Vt (on remembering that X = x/c, V = v/c). Thus at the time to (measured by A) B will lie at a coordinate position X0 = Vt0 (measured by A; see Fig. 3.23). Therefore the angle a of the world-line A with the vertical is given by tan a = X0/to = (Vto)/to = V. On the
other hand if (t1, XI) is a point on the surface of instantaneity for B where Xl = xl /c, then the angle a of this surface from the horizontal is given by tan a = tl/Xi. Equating these values for tan a shows
ti=VXi=vxilc
2
(3.19)
which is the equation for B's surface of instantaneity in terms of the variables measured by A. Two examples As a first example, consider the observer A to be on the surface of the Earth; B is in a rocket moving past at a speed 1 c in the direction of the planet Mars, at a time when the distance to Mars is 4 light-hours. Then Fig. 3.23 applies with v/c = 2, XI = xl /c = 4 hours, and tl =1 x 4 = 2 hours (from eqn (3.17)). Thus, the event P in Mars' history that A measures to be simultaneous with the event 0 when A
and B pass each other, is 2 hours prior to the event P' in Mars' history that B measures to be simultaneous with O. As a second example, the Andromeda Nebula is about 2 190 000 light years from the Earth. Consider simultaneity between events on the Earth and at Andromeda as measured by an observer A on the surface of the Earth, and an observer B in an airliner flying at 300 km/hr above the Earth in the direction of
Andromeda. The relativespeed of motion of these observers is V = v/c = (300 km/hr) x (1 /3600 hr/sec)/ (300 000 km/sec) = 1/3600000, so by (3.19)
74
Measurements in flat space-times
the difference in time between events at Andromeda they measure to be simultaneous with a single event on the Earth is tl = (2 190 000/3 600 000) = 0.61 years. Similarly, if observer C travels on a bus at 30 km/hr towards Andromeda, he will disagree with A about simultaneity on Andromeda by 22 days. Conclusion This analysis confirms what we discovered previously, namely that space-time is a unit which is split into space (surfaces of simultaneity) and time in different ways by different observers (Fig. 3.24). The splitting depends on their relative velocities; it is given by eqn (3.19), which is the analytic form of the simple `equal tilt' result illustrated in Fig. 3.22. The analysis is inevitable once we have decided to base the concept of simultaneity on measurable effects, and recognize that it is
best to do so on the basis of the speed of light because of the fundamental importance of this speed in nature. As is the case for all relativity effects, the relativity of simultaneity is completely reciprocal: viewed from B's reference frame, his surfaces of simultaneity are horizontal and it is A's surfaces of simultaneity that are tilted, inclining up towards A's world-line (see Fig. 3.25, which is just Fig. 3.22 redrawn from B's viewpoint). Finally we note that for small values of Ivx/c21 the effect is very small; in particular, it is negligible in everyday life (the differences for simultaneity of
different observers are in the region of 10-5 tsec). On the other hand, as v increases towards c, ti -> x1 /c: that is, events simultaneous with 0 approach closer and closer to the future light cone. Figure 3.22 shows that v increases, a -> 45° and B's surface of simultaneity in space-time approaches closer and closer to his world-line. If the limit when v/c = 1 could be attained, B's world-line would be contained in his surface of simultaneity: time would cease to flow for him. This corresponds to the fact that in this situation, if B attempted to use radar
simultaneity for A
Fig. 3.24 Space-time split differently into space (surfaces of simultaneity) and time (measured along world-lines) for observers A and B in relative motion.
3.3
Fig. 3.25
Simultaneity
75
Figure 3.22 redrawn from B's viewpoint.
to determine simultaneity at distant regions in his direction of motion, he could not do so: having emitted a radar signal for this purpose, he would arrive at these regions at the same time as the signal he was attempting to use to determine simultaneity there! Further, on observing backwards, wave fronts emitted along ago from regions he had already passed would perpetually be moving with him, informing him that conditions there were unchanging. Luckily, these strange situations cannot happen for real observers, since they cannot move at the speed of light. Exercises 3.9 An airliner flies at 500 km/hr towards a destination 1000 km away. What is the resulting difference in simultaneity for the aircraft and the control tower at the destination? Does the pilot have to allow for it? 3.10 Twin A on the Earth maintains radio contact with Twin B who is in a rocketship
moving away from him at a speed of c. They decide to blow out candles on cakes z (their birthday). At that moment the distance simultaneously at midday on January 10th between them, as measured by A, will be 2 light-years. What difference will there be between the times they each consider the appropriate moment for each to blow out the
candles? B turns around when her distance from A is measured by A to be 3 light-years, and starts returning at a speed z c. Let P be the event in A's history that B measures to occur immediately before the turn-around, and Q be the event in A's history that B measures to
occur immediately after the turn-around (for simplicity take this to happen instantaneously). What difference in time does A measure between the events P and Q? 3.11 Return to consideration of Exercise 2.7. Determine what instant in B's history she measures to be simultaneous with the event when A fired at her. Does B reach the same conclusion as A about who fires first?
Computer Exercise 7 Write a program that will accept as input (a) the relative speed of motion V of two observers, and (b) a distance D; and will then print out the difference in simultaneity DT measured by these observers at the distance D (given by eqn (3.19)). Verify the negligible nature of the effect for everyday speeds of motion on the Earth.
76
Measurements in flat space-times
Modify your program so that it can also calculate D from DT, given V, or V from D and DT. Hence find, for example, what relative speed will cause a difference of simultaneity of one hour at a distance of four light-hours. What limit can you deduce on the possible magnitude of DT at this distance? What is the general form of the limit on the magnitude on D T, given D?
Appendix: Geometric proof of the congruent triangle result Consider Fig. 3.26, which is an extension of Fig. 3.21. By sending out a light signal in the opposite direction to P', the observer B would determine the event Q' also to be simultaneous with O. Now, parallelogram EP'RQ' is formed from light rays all at 45° to the vertical. Thus it is a rectangle and its diagonals, which bisect each other at 0, must be equal. Hence the length of OP' is equal to those of OE and OR. Looking now at angles, we see that
02 = 03 (triangle OP'E is isosceles); a2 + ,02 = 45° (the angle OTU exterior to triangle OET is equal to the sum of the interior angles); and similarly a3 + 03 = 45°.
These three equations show that a2 = a3. We also have ai = a2 (opposite angles are equal), therefore al = a3. We see now that triangles ORS and OP'V are congruent with equal sides (OR and OP') and two pairs of equal angles (a1 and a3, and the two right angles OSR and OVP').
3.4
Time dilation
We have seen that a relatively moving observer will measure time differently from a stationary observer (Section 1.3); and have emphasized that consequently one
Fig. 3.26 Figure to prove congruence of the two shaded triangles in Fig. 3.21 (see text). Light emitted at event E in B's history is reflected at events Q' and P' and returns to event R in B's history.
3.4
Time dilation
77
Fig. 3.27 Observers A and B in relative motion. By sending a light signal at T and receiving in back at T", the observer A determines the event Q to be simultaneous with the reflection event P, which is at time T' according to B's clock.
cannot directly measure proper time t' for an observer B from a space-time diagram drawn from the viewpoint of an observer A, because this diagram will be calibrated in terms of A's variables (t, X, Y, Z), and we are not entitled simply to assume what the relation between t and t' is. However, we can easily calculate this
relation (cf. the derivation of eqn (1.2)). In this section we shall work out the magnitude of the time dilation effect in terms of the Doppler shift factor K and in terms of the relative velocity v, consider direct evidence for time dilation, discuss the symmetry of the time dilation effect, and investigate the `twin paradox'.
The comparison of clock readings by radar Consider again the situation described at the beginning of Section 3.2, where observer B moves past A at a speed v (see Fig. 3.27). Both observers set their clocks to zero at the time they pass each other; thus the event 0 where their worldlines coincide is given by to = 0, to = 0. After emitting a radar pulse at time T, the observer A determines the reflection event P on B's world-line to be simultaneous
with the event Q on his world-line: i.e. tp - tQ = 0. Then from eqn (3.10), tp = tQ = z (K2 + 1) T. On the other hand, for B, we have t' = T'KT. Because both A and B set the time at 0 to zero, the ratio of the time from 0 to P as measured by A to the time from 0 to P as measured by B is given by
tp/t,=Z(K2+1)T/KT. Cancelling the factor T, we find that
tp/t' = (K2 + 1)/2K - ry(K)
(3.20)
means `identically equal to'). This is the relativity effect of time dilation, showing how times t' measured by B relate to times t measured by A when they
are compared by synchronization of clocks (i.e. using radar to determine simultaneity).
78
Measurements in flat space-times
The K-factor and the -y-factor Equation (3.20) defines the time dilation factor -y ('gamma') in terms of the Doppler
shift factor K, measured by A directly observing an apparent slowing down or speeding up of time in the image of events at B (as discussed in Section 3.1). It is easy to get confused over these two effects (the time dilation effect and the Doppler shift
effect), so we now note their major distinctions. Essentially, the K-factor relates time at the observer to clock rates at the object as directly observed (e.g. through a telescope). Thus it compares clock rates then (at the time of emission) to now (at
the time of observation). On the other hand, -y relates clock times as related by instantaneity. Thus it is based on the concept of `simultaneity' or `now', and compares the rates at which clocks at the observer and object are both running now. Considering these two situations, it becomes clear that the crucial difference is that direct measurements of the K-factor involve light travelling only one way, from an object to the observer (Fig. 3.28a); thus one only needs a receiver to carry
out the observations. By contrast, radar measurements (such as those used to determine -y by clock synchronization) depend on light travelling both ways between the object and observer, as pulses travel from the observer to the object and back again (Fig. 3.28b), so one needs both a transmitter and receiver to carry out the observations. The K-factor observations are essentially simpler, requiring only analysis of a received signal. Through them, we only obtain information about conditions at the object at the time the light was emitted, which could be a very long time ago; indeed we have measured redshifts in light from distant objects using radiation
(a)
Fig. 3.28
(b)
(c)
The distinction between K and y: (a) The K-factor relates observers' clocks by observed Doppler shifts and depends on light signals travelling only in one direction. (b) The 'y-factor relates the observers' clocks by simultaneity determined by radar, and depends on signals travelling both ways between the observers. (c) A situation where information is conveyed by a one-way signal from A to B, but that information was determined by previous radar measurements using reflected (two-way) signals andso is based on the y-factor.
3.4
Time dilation
79
that has been travelling towards us for over a thousand million years. We do not obtain information about the object `now'. We can make these measurements to such great distances because the object itself (perhaps a galaxy or quasi-stellar object) provides the power supply for the signal. The information is relatively easy to obtain, but is also relatively limited; in particular, neither distance nor simultaneity are directly deducible from measurements of the K-factor.
By contrast, observations to determine directly the -y-factor depend on obtaining a echo pulse; the experiments are essentially more complex, requiring coordinated measurement of emitted and received signals. Correspondingly, they give more information (distance and simultaneity can be deduced directly, and indeed the Doppler shift factor is also directly measurable from a series of radar pulses, see eqn (3.6)). The distance to which radar can be used is more limited, both because of limits on practicalities of observing time delays, and because of limits on power requirements, since we provide the power for the signal detected. Unless either the radiation is emitted parallel (i.e. non-spreading) to very high accuracy, or the target actively aids the process by amplifying and rebroadcasting the signal, the power needed goes up as the fourth power of the distance because of the need to obtain an echo pulse. It is hardly practical to use radar to measure
distances of more than a few light-years; at present, the maximum distance measured by radar is about 8 light-hours. Clearly, the same limits will apply to the use of radar for clock synchronization.
Finally, we note that in any complex situation one may have to consider carefully before deciding which is the real effect in operation. As an example, suppose observer A tracks a uniformly moving spacecraft B by radar for some time, and then after suitable computations sends a message: `When you receive this message, the time will be 12:00 noon' (Fig. 3.28c). Now, the final message is one-way from A to B, so one could conceivably think that the information sent was essentially a deduction from the K-factor effect. However, this would be incorrect; the data sent is based on the two-way radar observations by A that took place initially, the final signal merely transferring from A to B the results of these previous measurements. The information B receives in this case is not about conditions at the time of transmission, but rather about what conditions will be at the time of reception: at that time, A's clock will simultaneously read 12:00 (where simultaneity is measured by A). Thus the information sent is about radarbased determination of simultaneity, and the relative time dilation measured by such observations will be determined by the -y-factor. The inverse relation and the symmetry of -y One can solve relation (3.20) for Kin terms of -y, obtaining
K = y±('Y2-1)2. The plus sign will correspond to relative recession (when K > 1), and the minus sign to relative approach of the two observers (when 0 < K < 1). As examples of the relation between the Doppler-shift and time-dilation factors, eqn (3.20) shows
K= 1 z* -y= 1, K=2 z* -y=4, K=3 z* -y=3.
80
Measurements in flat space-times
These examples are all for observers receding from each other. The same formula (3.20) holds if they approach each other. As examples,
K=2 = ry=4, K=4 = 7=3. These results suggest that the same value of -y are obtained for 1 /K as for K, and indeed eqn (3.20) confirms this:
7(1/K) = (1/K) 2)
1
=
K2K 1
= 7(K)
We already know (Section 3.2) that K -> 1/K corresponds to changing from approach to recession (or vice versa) at the same relative speed of motion. Thus, we have shown that the time dilation effect (determined by radar comparison of clock setting) is the same for relative approach or recession at the same
speed. The above examples suggest, and further investigation confirms, that ry > 1. Thus B's clock (moving past A) is measured by A to run slow relative to A's clock (at rest in the chosen coordinate system), whether they are approaching or receding from each other. Essentially, this symmetry is because the light used
to make the measurements travels both ways between A and B. It contrasts with the Doppler shift effect, where A observes B's clock to be running slow if B recedes, but to be running fast if B approaches; the difference between observed
consequences of approach and recession in this case is possible because the light used to make the measurement travels only one way (either from A to B or from B to A).
The relation to relative velocity
By substituting from eqn (3.12a) in (3.20) we can re-express the time dilation factor ry in terms of V = v/c instead of K. We find
/ l+V+l)/2(l+V) ={(1-V)(1+V)}-2. z
ry= I Therefore
ry = 1/(l - V2)z = 1/(1 - v2/c2)2,
(3.21)
which confirms the result already obtained by other means (eqn (1.2)). As examples, if v/c = 4, then 1 - V2 = i6, (1 Similarly,
- V2)z = 0.97, and ry = 1/0.97 = 1.033.
if v/c = 2 if v/c = 4
then ry = 1/0.866 = 1.155;
if v/c = to
then ry = 1/0.436 = 2.294;
then ry = 1/0.661 = 1.512;
if v/c =l o then ry = 1/0.141 = 7.089.
3.4
Time dilation
81
rA
3
2
Fig. 3.29 A graph of the -y-factor against V = v/c, plotted from eqn (3.21). Note that ry becomes arbitrarily large as the relative speed approaches the speed of light.
Thus, as expected, high relative speeds cause large -y-factors and so large observed time dilations.
It follows immediately from eqn (3.21) that (a) the effect is always one of an observed slowing down of the moving clock (-y > 1); (b) it vanishes if and only if there is no relative motion of the object and observer:
ry= 1 # v=0; and (c) the time dilation becomes indefinitely large as the relative speed approaches the speed of light: ry
oo
(v/c)2
1.
It also confirms (d) that time dilation depends only on the magnitude of the relative velocity, not whether it is a speed of approach or recession: 'y(-v) = ('y(v). All these features are clear in the graph of 'y as a function of v/c shown in Fig. 3.29 (plotted from eqn (3.21)).
Direct evidence for time dilation The time dilation effect is at first quite unexpected, so it is important to determine
experimentally if it actually occurs or not. It has indeed been confirmed by a classic experiment. The basic idea is to (a) synchronize two atomic clocks; (b) leave one on the ground while the other travels on a jet aircraft; then (c) compare the times measured by the clocks when the aircraft returns. If the Earth's surface could be regarded as an inertial frame for this purpose, then, after allowance has been made for accelerations during the jet's journey, the clock on the jet should have run slow by a factor -y. The experiment of Hafele and Keating in 1972 used
two aircraft going round the Earth in opposite directions. The time dilation
82
Measurements in flat space-times
recorded by the clocks showed remarkable agreement with the theoretical predictions, after allowance had been made for such features as the rotation of the Earth. The interested reader will find a fuller description of the experiment in Science 177, p. 166 (1972). We will discuss a different way of verifying the time dilation effect in Section 3.6.
The symmetry of time dilation Perhaps the most difficult thing to understand about the time dilation effect is that, like all the other relativity effects discussed here, it is completely symmetrical. Thus not only does observer A measure B's clock to run slow by a factor 'y, but also B measures A's clock to run slow by a factor 'y. As an illustrative example, consider a Transylvanian spacecraft travelling at very high speed outwards from
its home base on Earth towards the star Aldebaran, having left home on the first of January. In order to make sure the crew of the spacecraft celebrate the President's birthday (on the 1st of June) at the appropriate time, the base uses radar
to track the progress of the spacecraft, and their computer transmits a radio signal ('Today is the day!') timed so that it will arrive at the spacecraft at precisely midday on June 1st as measured on the ground. According to their accurate clock
and carefully kept calendar, the crew of the spacecraft receive this signal at midday on April 1st. The discrepancy arises because when viewed from the frame of the earth, the moving clock (in the spacecraft) goes slow. Now, by a curious coincidence, the birthday of the captain of the spacecraft is also the 1st of June. The crew of the spacecraft use the same tactics as the home base: they track the position of the Earth by radar, and transmit a celebratory radio signal timed to
arrive at the home base precisely at midday on June 1st (according to their calendar). This signal also arrives at the home base at midday on 1st April. This is because the situation is completely reciprocal: according to measurements made
by the spacecraft, the clock on Earth (moving relative to the spacecraft) goes slow. The two. reference frames (assumed here both to be inertial) are equivalent, and each finds the other's clock to go slow by the same amount.
There are various ways to understand this feature. One is to note that in the derivation above of the time dilation result, there was nothing special whatever about A as opposed to B; they were simply two inertial observers in relative motion. To determine what B measures, we simply need to relabel A and B; the whole calculation (with an implied relabelling of the coordinates) remains valid. That the reciprocity of the result must be true, is thus simply a consequence of the basic relativity principle. While this proves the result desired, it does not explain the relation between the two sets of observations. To consider this, start with Fig. 3.30a (drawn from A's
viewpoint). As we have seen above, A measures Q on his world-line to be simultaneous with P on B's world-line, and so determines that tQ = 'yip,
(3.22a)
where 'y is given by (3.21). Hence tQ > tP: although OP looks longer than OQ, the segment OP in the space-time diagram represents a smaller time measured by B,
3.4
Time dilation
83
(c)
Fig. 3.30
(a) Observer A measures the point Q on his world-line to be simultaneous with
P on B's world-line. (b) Observer B measures the point R on A's world-line to be simultaneous with P on his world-line. Event R precedes event Q. (c) The same situation redrawn in B's rest frame.
than the time A measures from 0 to Q (cf. Fig. 1.27b). A measures B's clock to be running slow. How can B also measure A's clock to be running slow? The key feature is that B does not measure Q on A's world-line to be simultaneous with P on his world-line. Rather, from what we have learned in Section 3.3, B measures a point R on A's world-line to be simultaneous with P, where R precedes Q: i.e. tR = tP with tR < tQ (Fig. 3.30b). Exactly analogously to (3.22a), B's analysis shows that tP = rytR,
(3.22b)
showing that B measures A's clock to be running slow. There is no contradiction between these results; rather (3.22a, b) show that tQ ='y2tR
confirming the result tQ > tR, as required for consistency.
(3.22c)
84
Measurements in flat space-times
Hence, the key to understanding the way the time dilation effect can be reciprocal is to note that A measures Q and P to be simultaneous, but B measures R and P to be simultaneous. Finally, we note that Fig. 3.30b is drawn from A's viewpoint. To understand fully the reciprocity, consider Fig. 3.30c which is the
identical space-time situation drawn from B's viewpoint. Relations (3.22) therefore hold for Fig. 3.30c, just as they do for Fig. 3.30b. Note that one can directly read off proper times t' measured by B from Fig. 3.30c, because it is calibrated in terms of his variables (t', X', Y', Z'); however, one cannot directly read off times measured by A from this diagram. Later (in Section 4.2) we shall find out how to represent a time along B's world-line equal to the time OQ measured by A. The `twin paradox' We have already referred to the `twin paradox' (Section 1.3). The question that now arises is, how can it be compatible with the symmetry between inertial observers which we have just established? To examine the issue, consider a specific example. Let A be an observer who stays at rest in an inertial frame while B travels away from A at a speed v = 5 c for 6 years, as measured by B's clock, and then returns at the same speed for 6 years. Thus B measures a total duration for the trip of 12 years. What does A measure? Figure 3.3la is a space-time diagram of the situation. On the outward journey,
A and B recede from each other at v/c = 5, and by eqn (3.12) K2 = (1 + / 5) (1 - 5) = 9, so K = 3. On the return journey, A and B approach each other;
v/c = - 5, and K = 3 (as expected, the inverse of Kfor the outward trip). Let 0 be the event in A's history when B leaves, S the event where A sends a signal to B that arrives at the event U when B turns around, and P the event when B arrives back at A. The relation toU = Ktos follows from the definition of K; as to'U = 6 and K = 3, the time tos measured by A from 0 to S is 2 years. Similarly tu'p = Ktsp, where now tU , = 6 years and K = 3. Therefore, the time tsp measured by A from
S to P is 18 years. Thus, the total time measured for the trip by A is top = tos + tsp = 20 years. This illustrates the twin paradox: after the journey, A will have aged by 8 years more than B. An alternative way of obtaining this result is to note that on both the outward and return journey, from (3.21), ly = {1 - (5)2}-z = 3. Thus, if we consider the
event W in A's history simultaneous with U (Fig. 3.31b) then tow= Ytou = 3 x 6 = 10 years; similarly twp = ytUp = 10 years. Thus, A measures a total travel time for B of top = tow + twp = 20 years, as before. How do we reconcile this difference in the times measured by A and B from 0 to P, if the time dilation effect is reciprocal between inertial observers? In a nutshell, the point is that B does not move inertially, but A does. Thus, B is not an inertial observer. Rather, her history consists of inertial segments joined by a period of acceleration. In order that this acceleration take place (when B's direction of motion reverses), she has to fire a rocket, experience elastic forces, or in some other way break her inertial motion; if she does not do so, the two observers are equivalent and their distance apart increases indefinitely. Acceleration is
3.4
Time dilation
85
18
years
2yearn
(a)
(b)
Fig. 3.31 The `twin paradox'. (a) Twin B travels at speed v for 6 years, and then returns at the same speed to rejoin A, who has remained at rest (in an inertial reference frame) during B's journey. A light signal emitted by A at S is received by B at U, when she turns around. (b) Twin A measures the event W on his world-line to be simultaneous with the event U on B's world-line.
Fig. 3.32 An acceleration detector, consisting of a weight held between springs fitted with detectors that record movement of the weight relative to the sides of the framework.
demanded in order that they meet again. This acceleration is physically detectable. Suppose each observer has with him or her an acceleration detector consisting of a weight constrained to move within a framework by springs which are fitted with strain detectors (Fig. 3.32). Since A moves inertially, his detector will register no forces, but B's will; this shows that the distinction between their
86
Measurements in flat space-times
Fig. 3.33 Various world-lines between events 0 and P. The straight-line path A is the one
with the longest proper time. It is uniquely characterized by the fact that an acceleration detector will measure no acceleration along this path.
motions has clear-cut measurable physical consequences. The symmetry of the
time dilation effect holds only between inertially moving observers. In the example, B does not move inertially between the events 0 and P, but A does, and that is the source of the asymmetry whereby A measures a longer proper time between 0 and P than B does. It is the time dilation effect that makes it clear that we should properly regard
time as a quantity measured along world-lines from their initial to their final points, that is, a line integral along the world-lines (see Appendix A for a brief discussion of the concept of a line integral). Then the asymmetry in the `twin paradox' has a particularly clear interpretation (Fig. 3.33). Consider any two events 0 and P in space-time that are time-like separated, that is, that are such that a particle can move from 0 to P without exceeding the speed of light. Then one can show that the unique path from 0 to P along which a clock will measure the longest time is that representing inertial (free-fall) motion. This is a straight line in space-time from 0 to P. Thus, it is precisely the inertial observer who will-
have aged the most when two observers meet again, no matter what path the other has taken through space-time from 0 to P (i.e. no matter what accelerations he has undergone). In the example above, this singles out the observer A as unique compared to all others who pass through both events 0 and P.
Conclusion In summary, `a moving clock goes slow' in a way that is completely reciprocal for any pair of inertial observers (each measures the other's clock to be going slowly). This is consistent because they disagree about simultaneity. This time dilation
effect refers to a comparison of times measured by both clocks `now', i.e. it is based on the idea of simultaneity. It must not be confused with the Doppler shift effect relating observed times, which is also completely reciprocal, but relates
3.4
Time dilation
87
time measured by the observer now to time at the source of the radiation when this radiation was emitted (which could be a very long time ago). Time dilation gives rise to the `twin paradox': any observer who moves away from an inertial observer and then back again will find he has experienced a smaller increase in time than the inertial observer. This feature has been observed experimentally by comparison of a clock in an aircraft with a clock stationary on the surface of the Earth (the Hafele-Keating experiment described above). Exercises 3.12 Consider the `twin paradox' example above (Fig. 3.31). (1) Let light emitted by B at the event U be received by A at an event V. Using the K-
factor, determine the times A measures from 0 to V and from V to P; hence deduce the total
time measured by A from 0 to P. (2) What event in A's history does B determine to be simultaneous with U, (a) just before she turns around, (b) just after she turns around? Use the -y-factor based on B's view of space-time during her inertial segments of motion to determine the time intervals in A's history between 0, these events, and P. Hence confirm that B can also use -y to determine
the time A measures from 0 to P. (3) Suppose A and B each observe the other by radar. Find the relative motions each determines for the other. [This reveals a quite unexpected motion that B measures for A, and so sharply shows the distinction between them.] 3.13 Let the world-line of an inertial observer Ago from a space-time event 0 to P. Let observer D move inertially from 0 to some event Q, and then inertially to P. Show that D measures a shorter time interval from 0 to P than A does. [Hint: find the time in A's history he measures to be simultaneous with Q; then use the relevant 'y-factors separately for the outward and return journey of D.] Generalize to show that if D moves on any finite number of inertial segments from 0 to P,; he measures a shorter time interval from 0 to P than A does (unless he moves in an unbroken geodesic from 0 to P, when he moves exactly as A and therefore measures the same time interval). 3.14 Suppose that a spaceship cruises at v = c. Assuming that you may neglect the a times for acceleration and deceleration, find how much the earth will have aged during an outward and return journey which takes 50 years as measured by the astronauts on board. How far from the earth will the space-ship have travelled? What limits does this suggest to what may be achieved in space travel? 3.15 The relation between velocity and K (and so redshift) considered so far has been
for the case of radial motion (the source moving directly towards or away from the observer). Now consider the case of transverse motion; the source is moving at right angles
to the line of sight from the observer (Fig. 3.34). Then the distance between the source and observer is unchanging instantaneously. Calculate the K-factor for light emitted by the source and received by the observer, and hence the redshift measured in this case. [Hint: the K-factor is simply due to the time dilation effect (3.21) in this case]. How large will be
Light Observer
Fig. 3.34
Source
88
Measurements in flat space-times
the resultant effect on the measured CBR temperature in those direction? (See the discussion of redshift and background radiation at the end of Section 3.1.)
Computer Exercise 8 Write a program which will accept as input any one of the three parameters: velocity V(= v/c), time dilation factor G(= y), Doppler shift factor K; and prints out the other two. Use your program to plot carefully a graph of y and Kagainst V for all allowed values of V.
Modify your program (a) to print out additionally the `slow-motion' approximations G1 = 1 +1 V2 and K1 = 1 + V. Find out for what ranges of V G1 and Kl are good approximations to G and K respectively. (b) Repeat this for the fast motion approximations G2 = l/ (2e) and K2 = (2/e) where e is defined by V = 1 - E.
3.5
Length contraction
The final major kinematic effect of special relativity is length contraction. Just as
time measurements depend on relative motion, so we might expect the same general kind of effect to hold for length measurements. As an example, suppose a Special Interstellar Shuttle requires 15 miles of surface to land safely, so a runway
of this length has been constructed for it in the Mojave desert. As the pilot approaches at very high speed, he checks the length of the runway by radar, and measures it to be only 7 miles long-apparently far too short for a safe landing! This is due to the relativity length contraction effect; when he makes his final approach at low speed, he will measure its length to be about 15 miles, so he can make a safe landing. In general, the length measurements made by two relatively moving observers are related by length contraction, which is the companion to time dilation, and is similar in many ways. In particular, it is also a reciprocal relation because of the relativity of simultaneity. In this section, we calculate how relative motion affects lengths measured by radar, consider how length contraction can be a reciprocal effect, mention the lack of a width contraction effect, and discuss the relation of these results to photographic images of objects.
The determination of lengths by radar
The crucial feature about measuring the length of a rigid ruler, rod, or other object is that it is a measurement of length at an instant. To understand the implications of this statement, it is important to realize that the space-time representation of the history of a rod is a ribbon in space-time, bounded by two time-like lines. To see this, consider a straight rod with ends u and w (Fig. 3.35a) Suppose that it is at rest in A's reference frame; for simplicity, we take u to be at the ori gin ofA's coordinates. The world-lines of the left-hand end of the rod (u) and the right-hand end (w) are then lines atfixed Xvalues, as shown in Fig. 3.35b. Obviously, the central point v in the rod lies between u and w, so its history will be represented by a world-line between those of u and w; similarly, the history of each point in the rod will be represented by a world-line between u and w. Thus, the material of the rod occupies the entire region between these world-lines (Fig. 3.35b).
3.5 1
2
3
4
Length contraction
89
5
III II II IIIIIII III IIIII II II II
U
V
w
(a)
w
X (b)
Fig. 3.35 (a) A ruler with ends u and w and mid-point v. (b) A space-time diagram of the ruler at rest in the reference frame of an observer A, showing the world-lines of the ends u
and w and of the mid-point v. Clearly, the entire strip between the world-lines of u and w will represent histories of particles comprising the ruler. A surface of simultaneity for A is horizontal in this diagram.
A measurement of the length of the rod is a measurement by radar of the distance between u and w (Fig. 3.35a) `at an instant'. Thus, when A measures the length of the rod from u to w, this is the distance between their respective worldlines in a surface of simultaneity for A (Fig. 3.35b).
The effect of relative motion on measured lengths As usual, we consider an inertial observer B moving past the inertial observer A at a relative speed v. Given a space-time diagram drawn from A's viewpoint (and
calibrated by A's coordinates), we can directly read off from it distances measured by A, but cannot directly read off distance measurements made by B. As simultaneity differs for A and B, when each uses radar to measure the length of the rod they are measuring somewhat different aspects of its space-time history
(Fig. 3.36a), so it is hardly surprising that they obtain different results. This diagram shows the situation from A's viewpoint; Figure 3.36b shows the same situation as seen by B. The detailed examination that follows leads to the length contraction formula (3.24). To simplify the comparison, consider the measurements made so that A and B both use the same light rays to determine the length of the rod. (Fig. 3.37). B emits a light signal at P; this is reflected from the end w of the rod at W, and it is received back by B at R. Let the event on B's world-line half-way between the emission and reception of the signal as measuredby his own clock be 0. Suppose that B chooses the event P so that he coincides with the end u of the rod at the event 0; then
(a)
(b)
Fig. 3.36 (a) Observer A measures the instantaneous length of the ruler to be L, while observer B (moving relative to A) measures the length L' in his surfaces of simultaneity. (b) The same situation drawn in B's rest frame.
Fig. 3.37 Observers A and B both determine the length of the rod by radar, A emitting a signal at Q and receiving the echo at S, while B emits a signal at P and receives the echo at R.
A measures U and W to be simultaneous, while B measures 0 and W as simultaneous (OP and OR represent equal times).
3.5
Length contraction 91
top = toR and B determines 0 and W to be simultaneous. The light travel time is T' = 2toP = 2tO'R, and the length of the rod is measured by B to be
L' = i cT'.
(3.23a)
Let the light emitted at the event P by B reach A's world-line at the event Q. Suppose that A emits a light signal at the event Q. This light is reflected at the event W and received back by A at the event S. Let Ki be the K-factor for a relative
speed of approach v; this relates the time t,O to tQo, so the time measured by A from Q to 0 is tQo = Ki x 1T'. Let K2 be the K-factor for a relative speed of recession v; this relates the time tOR to tos, so the time measured by A from 0 to S is tos = K2 x br'. Let the total light travel time measured by A be T. Then T = tQs = tQo + tos = (K1 + K2) x ZT'.
Now, K2 = 1/Ki because they relate approach and recession at the same speed. Then
(Ki + 1/Ki)(T'/2)
{(Kl + 1)/2Ki}T' = ryT',
(3.23b)
by (3.20). The length of the rod is measured by A to be L = 2 cT.
(3.23c)
Hence the ratio of the length of the rod measured by A to the length of the rod measured by B is
L/L' = T/T' = y
(3.24)
by eqns (3.23) where y is expressed in terms of v by equation (3.21). (Note that ry is
the same for Ki and K2, as they represent approach and recession at the same speed, so the same result is obtained if we replace Ki by K2 in (3.23b).) Thus the length of the rod measured by A (for whom the rod is at rest) is greater than the length of the rod measured by B (for whom the rod moves at a speed v) by a factor -y. In brief, moving objects are measured to be shorter than stationary objects by a
factor 1/'y = (1 - v2/c2)Z.
As an example, consider an interstellar rocket that is measured by its crew to be 500 m = 0.5 km long. Suppose it is viewed from a planet which it passes at a speed v = 0.9c. Then 1/-y = {1 - (0.9)2}20.44. Hence the length measured from the
ground is L' = L/-yi
(0.44)(0.5) = 0.22 km. Now suppose v = 0.99c. Then
0.14 and the measured length is L' 0.07 km = 70 m. A graph of the length-contraction quantity 1/'y is given in Fig. 3.38. It has properties corresponding to those of -y (cf. the previous section), i.e. (1) it is L/-y = { 1 - (0.99)2}2
always less than or equal to 1; (2) it is only 1 if the speed of relative motion is zero; (3) it goes to 0 as (v/cJ --+ 1; and (4) it is the same for approach (v positive) and
92
Measurements in flat space-times
Fig. 3.38 A graph of the length-contraction factor 1 /-y against V = v/c.
recession (v negative). Thus, the effect is negligible at speeds of relative motion low compared to that of light, but at speeds close to the speed of light the length of a moving object as measured by radar goes to zero. As indicated above, we may regard the basic cause of the length-contraction effect as being that B measures the length of the rod at the `instant' represented by the surface of simultaneity OW (Fig. 3.37), whereas A measures its length at the `instant' represented by the surface of simultaneity WU, where U is midway between Q and S on A's worldline; this surface appears horizontal in A's space-time diagram. Although OW is apparently a longer line than UW, it represents a shorter length measured by radar by B. In Section 4.2 we will derive a precise representation of how lengths measured along different surfaces of instantaneity relate to each other.
The symmetry of length contraction
Just as in the case of time dilation, the effect is completely reciprocal: each observer measures objects at rest in the other's frame to be short by a factor 1 As in the previous case, one can see this by noting that there is no intrinsic difference between A and B, so in the analysis above we could equally well have changed the labels of A and B to determine the length contraction observed by B
for objects moving with A. Thus, the reciprocity is a result of the relativity principle. However, this does not completely account for how the reciprocity can be consistently possible. To see this, we need to consider measurements made by both A and B of rigid rods moving with each of them. Figure 3.39 is a space-time diagram drawn from A's viewpoint, showing a rod RA with end-points u and w at rest in A's frame and a rod RB with endpoints u' and w' at rest in B's frame. The rods are chosen to be such that the length mea-
sured by A for both of them is the same: the world-lines u and u' coincide at the event U and the world-lines w and w' coincide at the event W, where U and
3.5
Length contraction 93
Fig. 3.39 Measurement of two rods RA, with end-points u and w, and RB with endpoints' and w'. Observer A measures both to have length L (the distance between events U and W).
Observer B measures them to have the lengths L' (between U and N) and L" (between U and M) in his surface of simultaneity UM.
W are instantaneous for A, so A measures the same length L (the radar distance
measured by him between U and W) for both of them. Now, using radar, B measures lengths in his surface of instantaneity, which is indicated as the line UNM in the diagram, where N lies on the world-line of w and M on the world-line of w'. He measures the length of RA as the radar distance L" between U and N,
and the length of RB as the radar distance L' between U and M. By the results above, A measures the relatively moving rod RB short by a factor -y: L" = ryL,
L" > L.
(3.25a)
Also, B measures the relatively moving rod RA short by a factor -y:
L = 'yL', L > L.
(3.25b)
These results are consistent with each other. Indeed, they show that L" = ry2L'
(3.25c)
consistent with the feature that L" > L' (apparent because the segment UM is longer than UN). In view of this reciprocity, it is apparent that given any rigid object, it will appear longest to an observer for whom it is at rest (i.e. who moves at the same speed as the object). We may use the name proper length to denote the length of the object as measured by such an observer. Then every observer moving relative to the rod will measure the length to be less than its proper length.
Transverse measurements The length contraction effect is a longitudinal effect: that is, it is observed in the direction of relative motion of the object (in the above calculation, the relative
94
Measurements in flat space-times
motion was in the X-direction and the length contraction occurred in the length of the object measured in that direction). No change of size is measured in directions perpendicular to the motion, because there is no change of relative distances in those directions. Thus, radar sets aligned along the Y and Z axes by A and B will give the same measurements of distances along these axes, and one will find the size of objects measured in the Yand Z directions unaffected by relative motion in the X-direction. A body moving past will therefore be measured to be distorted
in shape, having the same Y and Z dimensions as when stationary but being contracted in the X-direction. Photographic images The length contraction effect refers to measurements made by radar. This does
not mean that a photographic image will show the length contraction in an obvious way, because such an image does not represent the state of the object `at an instant'. To work out what the image will show, one must allow for the light travel time from different parts of the object to the camera, and this works in the opposite way to the length contraction. In general, the result is complex to work out, but a simple example will make the principle clear. This detailed study is peripheral to our main line of argument, and so may be omitted at a first reading. Consider a rigid rod RB with edges u' and w' moving towards the observer A (Fig. 3.40). As in the previous example, denote the proper length of the rod by L" and the length A measures for it by L; these quantities are then related by (3.25a). In the following, unless otherwise stated, all distances will be scaled according to A's coordinate X, which is used to calibrate the x-axis in Fig. 3.40 and is normalized so that the speed of light is 1. At event R, observer A takes a photograph of RB. The light arriving at the event R has travelled up its past light cone; we denote by U the event where this light left the edge u, and by W the event where it
Fig. 3.40 A photograph being taken by an observer A of a ruler with end-points u' and w' moving towards the camera. The events U at u and W at w are recorded by the camera at event R. By the time the light ray leaves W, the ruler is a distance d nearer the camera so its apparent length is Lo = L + d.
3.5
Length contraction
95
left the edge w. Suppose RB moves a distance d towards A while the light travels from U to W; since RB is moving at a speed v/c towards A, we have (dl = TJv/cJ where Tis the time the light takes to travel from U to W. Remembering our sign convention for v, a speed of approach is represented by a negative value of v, so d = -Tv/c. When the light arrives at W it has travelled a distance L + d towards
A, so T = L + d; consequently d = -(L + d)v/c. Solving for d shows that
d = {-(v/c)/(1 +v/c)}L.
(3.26a)
Now the effective length of RB in A's photograph is Lo = L + d, because this is the distance between the ends u and w apparent in the photograph (for example, if the rod slides over a scale with distances from A marked off, the event U where A's photograph depicts the end u will be shown by this scale to be a distance L + d from the event W where A's photograph depicts the end w). From (3.26a), then
Lo = L/(1 +v/c).
(3.26b)
Now, using (3.25a) and the expression (3.21) for ly and simplifying, we can show that Lo = {(1 - v/c)/(l + v/c)}zL".
But by (3.12) this is just
Lo = (11K)L";
(3.27)
the effective length of RB observed by A in a photograph is related to its proper length not by the length contraction factor ly but by the inverse of the Doppler shift factor K! This is actually not surprising: the situation is analogous to the way the timescale difference measured in Doppler shift observations is given by K rather than y. In both cases the occurrence of K is essentially because light travels only one way in that observation, rather than both ways as when radar is used to determine lengths or simultaneity. Equivalently, K occurs because the measurement related magnitudes of quantities `then' and `now', rather than measured `at an instant'. As in the case of Doppler shifts, the sign of the effect depends on whether the relative motion is one of approach or recession. If the object approaches, it will appear to be longer by a factor 1 /K than its rest length (then v < 0 and K < 1); if it recedes, it will appear shorter by a factor 1/K (in this case, v > 0 and K > 1). The above example calculates the effective length of RB seen in a photograph when it travels directly towards or away from A (admittedly it would be rather difficult actually to demonstrate this relation because of the motion of the object being directly toward the camera). More complex effects occur when the object moves transversely to the line of sight. It will in fact appear undistorted when viewed from a long way off, in this case the length-contraction and light travel effects just cancel (but a careful examination of the way light travels from the object to camera shows that it will then appear to be rotated!).
96
Measurements in flat space-times
Conclusion
In conclusion, the `length contraction' effect discussed in this section, with magnitude determined by the factor 1 /-y, represents the behaviour of distance measurements made at an instant, for example by radar. It will not directly represent measurements determined from photographs, where light travel times have to be taken into account and the image obtained does not represent the situation `at an instant'. Given this understanding, the basic feature is simple: an observer will measure the length of an object moving radially towards or away from him to be shorter than that of an identical object that is stationary, by precisely a factor 1 /-y.
Exercises 3.16 A section of the surface of a road has pressure studs laid into it, connected to a measurement centre by cables that are all exactly the same length. A series of lights at the centre indicate which studs are loaded by a vehicle in the road. An articulated lorry passes over them at high speed. When the lorry is at rest, its length is measured to be 30 metres.
What length would this apparatus measure for the lorry, if its speed of travel were v = 0.01c? 3.17 To measure the length of a high-speed train, an observer measures the time T it takes to pass a fixed point on the track, and then determines its length L' from its speed of motion v (which he also measures) by the relation L' = vT. Show that the length-contraction formula (3.24) relates L' to the (proper) length L measured for the train by an observer moving with it.
3.18 A science-fiction story features a moon-buggy which has continuous contact with the ground (via caterpillar tracks) and has its weight distributed uniformly along its 10-metre length. What is the upper limit to the speed at which it can travel directly across a 4-metre-wide chasm without falling into it? For speeds greater than this critical speed, explain how it is possible, from the point of view of someone travelling in the buggy, for it to fall into the chasm.
Computer Exercise 9 Write a program that will accept as input a relative velocity V(= v/c) and a proper length L, and prints out the measured length L' given by eqn (3.24). Also print out the approximate value L1' = L(1 - z Vz), and find for what range of V, the estimate L1' is a good approximation to L. Apply your program (a) to a Concorde airliner at maximum speed, (b) a space shuttle.
3.6
The whole package of kinematic effects
We have now considered the basic principles of special relativity-the equivalence of all inertial observers, and the invariance and limiting nature of the speed of light-and four major phenomena resulting from these principles: time dilation, length contraction, the relativity of simultaneity, and the relativity velocity
addition law. It is important to realize that these phenomena are intimately related to each other. Any one of them only makes sense if the others also operate; only the whole package is consistent. We shall illustrate this through two
3.6
The whole package of kinematic effects
97
v/c -D.99
atmosphere .
.
.
.
.
.
muon at
.
. rest
v/c No.99 (a)
(b)
(a) Cosmic rays colliding with particles in the Earth's atmosphere to produce muons which then decay into other particles. The muons travel at a speed of about 0.99c relative to the Earth. (b) The same situation from the viewpoint of the muons, with the Earth approaching at high speed.
Fig. 3.41
illuminating examples, and will then consider how one can express the essential features either through a single unified relation (the Lorentz transformation) or through the concept of an invariant (the space-time interval), both of which will be discussed in detail in Chapter 4.
Example (a): muon decay Cosmic rays are particles that arrive at the Earth from space at extremely high relative speeds v (often Iv/cl 0.99). Their origin, and where they get such great energy from, is still something of a mystery. At a height of about 20 km above sea level they collide with atoms in the Earth's atmosphere, and among the particles resulting from these collisions are particles called muons (Fig. 3.41a). These also move very rapidly towards the ground (their mean speed being nearly the same as that of the incoming cosmic rays), but they are unstable, decaying rapidly to less massive particles (electrons and neutrinos). One can measure this decay rate in the laboratory; the mean lifetime of a muon at rest is ti where ti
2.2 x 10-6 sec.
(3.28a)
Their mean flight time through the Earth's atmosphere, from where they are created, to sea level is t2, given by
t2 _- 20 km/(0.99 x 3 x 105 km/sec) _- 6.7 x 10-5 sec.
(3.28b)
Defining f by
f - (mean time of flight)/(mean lifetime),
(3.28c)
we find that f = t2/ti _ (6.7 x 10-5)/(2.2 x 10-6) ^ 30. Now a statistical analysis shows that during one mean lifetime ti, the proportion of muons surviving will be about I /e, where e is the transcendental number occurring in natural logarithms (e , 2.71828...); and during the time t2, the fraction surviving should
98
Measurements in flat space-times
be about e-f - e-30 - 10-13. However, when measurements are made of the number of muons created high in the atmosphere and those arriving at sea level it turns out that a much higher fraction arrive at sea level: about 1% = 10-2 of the total number created. Thus, the prediction is entirely wrong: enormously more particles survive than expected on the basis of this simple calculation. What has gone wrong? The essential point is that we have failed to take time dilation into account. In
considering any physical situation, one should make a definite decision as to which frame will be used for the analysis, and then stick to this decision; mixing results of measurements by two different observers will usually lead to incorrect results. We first choose to look at the situation from the viewpoint of an observer on the ground. Then eqn (3.28a) is an incorrect estimate of the measured muon lifetime, because it is the lifetime measured by an observer moving with the muon. The lifetime tl measured by an observer stationary on the ground will differ by a factor y, where
y = (1 -
V2/C2)-1
= {1 -
(0.99)2}_2
7.1
(3.29a)
so
tl = yti = 1.5 x 10-5 sec.
(3.29b)
Equation (3.28b) is a correct estimate of the time of flight measured by an observer stationary on the ground. In evaluating (3.28c), we must use values measured by the same observer (in this case, an observer stationary on the ground) for the numerator and denominator. Thus we find
f = t2/t1 ^_ 4.2,
(3.29c)
(a factor 1/y times our previous estimate). Hence e-f - e-4.2 _ 0.015, an estimate of the fraction surviving which is in good agreement with the experiment. The time dilation effect therefore reconciles the theoretical and experimental results in the Earth's frame; the observations in fact provide an experimental verification of the time dilation effect. However, a problem is apparent if we consider the situation from the viewpoint of an observer travelling with the muon. This is because in that frame there is no time dilation effect for the decay: the muon is stationary in the observer's reference frame (Fig. 3.41b), and has the lifetime (3.28a). The previous analysis, which gave an incorrect answer, appears to apply. The resolution in this case is provided by remembering that we must apply all the special relativity results in analyzing our observations. Seen from the muon's
reference frame (Fig. 3.41b), the Earth is approaching at the same speed v (Iv/c) _- 0.99) as the observer on the Earth measured for the muon, because both observers agree about the relative rate of approach (see eqn (3.12b)). However, from this viewpoint the atmosphere is also moving by at high speed, so the path through the atmosphere is measured to be much shorter because of the length-contraction effect. In fact, the moving observer would measure the path
3.6
The whole package of kinematic effects
99
through the atmosphere, from creation of the muon until it is hit by the surface of the Earth, to have a length of 20/y km 20 x 0.141 2.8 km, instead of the 20 km measured by an observer on the Earth (at rest relative to the atmosphere). Thus, for the moving observer the muon traverses this path in a time t, given by
t2 = 2.8 km/(0.99 x 3 x 105 km/sec) - 9.4 x
10-6
sec = t2/y.
(3.30a)
Hence, evaluating both terms in (3.28c) in the muon's reference frame,
f = t2'/ti = (t2/'Y)/(t1/'Y) = t2/t1
(3.30b)
and we obtain exactly the same result (3.29c) as before. In the muon's reference frame, we reconcile the theoretical and experimental results by use of the lengthcontraction effect, and the experiment serves as a verification of this effect. This analysis shows very clearly why one must consider length contraction and time dilation together: they are the same phenomenon seen from different points of view. From the stationary frame, theory and experiment agree because of time dilation; from the moving frame, because of length contraction; the analysis would
be inconsistent if only one of the effects occurred. The experimental data for muon decay serves to verify that both effects occur in the real physical world. The interested reader will find more details about how the experiment is performed in the book Special Relativity by A. P. French (published by the MIT Press).
Example (b): tied rockets
Imagine an observer B watching two identical stationary rockets C and A a distance d = 400 in apart, joined by an inextensible rope of length d (so the rope is
stretched tautly between them). As measured by B, at an instant to they ignite their engines simultaneously and start moving parallel to the rope with their engines at full thrust, with A leading C (Fig. 3.42a). Since they are identical, their speeds relative to the observer B are identical, and he will therefore measure them to remain precisely a distance d apart. At the time t1 as measured by B, they both turn off their engines and continue moving inertially at a speed v = s c relative to him. His measurement of the distance between them is still 400 in. To simplify the problem, we will assume the rocket engines are very powerful and fast burning, giving very brief but strong impulses to the rockets that accelerate them up to their final speed. Thus, we will assume that ti is a negligibly short time after to. A spacetime diagram of this situation (drawn from B's viewpoint) is given in Fig. 3.42b. Now, an observer moving with the rocket A will measure rocket C to be stationary relative to himself both at early and at late times. What will he measure the final distance between A and C to be? Denote this distance by D. According to
the length-contraction formula, D/d = y (see eqn (3.24)); D corresponds to L, since this is the distance measured in A's rest frame, while d corresponds to L' measured by the observer B moving relative to that frame, who will measure the distance to be shorter. Therefore
D=-yd= {l -Q )2}
zd=4d=
500m.
100
Measurements in flat space-times
(a)
t=to=tl s
s
simeous
simultaneous for A,C initially
forB
f X
(b)
(c)
Fig. 3.42 (a) Observer B sees two rockets, A and C, accelerate simultaneously in the same direction. The distance dbetween them stays constant because they accelerate identically. (b) An idealized space-time diagram of the situation as seen by observer B. Very powerful engines are switched on just before events s and s' and switched off just after these events. (c) Initially the surfaces of simultaneity of A and C coincide with those of B, but after they
have finished accelerating they are tilted relative to those of B. Thus, just after he has completed accelerating (at event s), A determines the event f' in C's history (before C started accelerating) to be simultaneous with s. Thus his measurements show that, at that instant, C is still to start accelerating.
If the rope still joins the two rockets, it is at rest relative to them; this must then be its length (measured in its own rest frame). But it is inextensible; it cannot stretch to this length. It will therefore have broken.
The problem arises when one considers how this can have happened. As established above, B observed both rockets to accelerate in precisely the same way. This seems to imply that the distance between them could not change, and therefore that the rope did not break. They accelerated identically; how can the distance between them have changed from 400 in (as measured by A initially) to 500 in (as measured by A finally)? Does the rope actually break or not? As before, the problem is that we have not taken all the relativity effects into
account. The apparent paradox is resolved by considering the relativity of simultaneity. Specifically, instantaneous surfaces in space-time for A and C when they are moving at their final speed are tilted relative to their initial surfaces of instantaneity, which coincide with those of B (see Fig. 3.42c). Thus, consider events as determined by A. Just before he starts to fire his rocket engine (at the
3.6
The whole package of kinematic effects
101
event s in his history), C is also just about to start his (at the events). At this stage,
A and C both measure their distance apart to be 400 in, and they agree about simultaneity. But, when A has finished firing his engine (just after the event s), C has not yet started firing his (since A measures s to be simultaneous with the event f' in C's history, which precedes s'). At this stage, A determines that he is moving away from C, because he has finished accelerating but C has not yet begun to accelerate. The distance between them increases and the rope snaps. C then begins accelerating (just before the events' in his history, measured by A to be simultaneous with the event fin A's history). Finally, C ceases accelerating just after the event s'. Both A and C now measure their distance apart to be 500 m, and they agree about simultaneity. This explains why their final distance apart
is greater than their initial distance apart, which of course means that the rope must break. As before, we see that consistency of the special relativity effects depends on taking all of them into account; the puzzling `paradoxes' of relativity usually result from ignoring one or other of them. The most difficult to appreciate initially is the relativity of simultaneity; indeed, a rough rule of thumb is that when a problem appears particularly paradoxical, it is usually because this effect has been forgotten. Exercises 3.19 Particles called pions decay into other particles at a rate such that (when measured in their rest frame) on average half the number of pions present decay in 18 x 10-9 sec. Suppose now that in a high-energy collision experiment, pions are produced with a speed 0.99c. How long will it take on average, as measured by a stationary observer, for half their number to decay? How far will they have travelled in this time? [Compare with the distance travelled by the muons described in the text.]
3.20 A car 5 metres long drives into a garage 4 metres long at a speed v = s c. According to a stationary observer, the length of the car will appear to be reduced by a factor of 1/-y to 4 metres and so it will fit into the garage exactly. On the other hand the driver of the car will perceive the length of the garage to be reduced by 1 /-Y to 3.2 metres so the car will not fit in. How would you resolve this apparent paradox? What wording in its statement is not sufficiently precise? 3.21 Construct a space-time diagram to illustrate the possibility of causal paradox if tachyons (particles travelling faster than light) were to exist. Observer A is at rest while observer B moves past at relative speeds c. Draw in the surfaces showing which events are simultaneous, according to B, with the events on A's world-line at t = 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5. Suppose that at t = 1, A were to send a signal toward B with speed 3 c. Show that B will determine that A sent the signal at a time when B had already received it. Hence according to his (radar) measure of instantaneity, B could transmit an answer to the signal before it had been sent! [Moral: consistency of relativity theory forbids sending signals faster than light.] 3.22 Our analysis above of Example (b) (tied rockets) referred to instantaneous distances as deduced by A, B, and C from their surfaces of simultaneity. In practice, they would measure their separation by radar signals which are not instantaneous measurements; e.g. the surface of simultaneity (sf') would be determined by A from signals sent out before event S and received after s.
102
Measurements in flat space-times
Work out in detail the separation A would measure for C by radar measurements of distance (cf. Example 3.12; note that this is a lengthy but interesting exercise).
The whole package: unifying viewpoints
We have seen now, through these examples, that the whole set of relativity kinematic effects must be taken into account if one is to get a consistent description of what is happening. Their inextricable intertwining is made clear by the fact that what appears to be a length contraction in one frame of reference may turn out to be time dilation in another. Thus, we are naturally led to consider if there is some way of writing the theory so as to bring out this unity, and present a unified view of space-time measurements and geometry.
This can be done: indeed, there are two separate ways of going about the problem. The first approach relies on working out in detail how all space and time measurements alter when one changes from one reference frame to another. Thus we are led to the idea of a Lorentz transformation. The second approach takes what is in effect an opposite viewpoint. We have established that various features (length, time differences, simultaneity) that we previously believed were invariant when one changes reference frame, are not immutable after all. We can now ask: given our new insights, is there any feature of the space-time that is unchanged by an arbitrary change of reference frame? That is, are there any significant invariant features of space-time? We shall find that there are various such quantities. One
in particular the (metric form) summarizes in a compact way the results of measurements of spatial distances and time differences. The next chapter will look at each of these approaches in turn. Before we turn to this, however, we consider briefly the nature of relativistic dynamics, and the relation of the relativity principle to the rest of physics: the `whole package' that must be consistent includes all physical laws, and so in particular the laws of dynamics.
3.7
Relativistic dynamics
If the Newtonian laws of particle motion were correct, one could accelerate a particle to move faster than the speed of light, thus violating one of the basic assumptions of relativity theory, and contradicting the experimental evidence (see Section 1.2). Thus, the laws of particle motion in relativity theory must be different from those of Newtonian theory. Similarly the laws of energy and momentum conservation must also be different. When one takes into account the four-dimensional nature of space-time, the real nature of the concepts `mass', `momentum', `energy', and `force' turns out to be somewhat different than in Newtonian theory. A four-dimensional formulation of these topics is presented in Appendix B. Here we will simply summarize in a three-dimensional form the revised laws of dynamics that result. These form the basis of a dynamical theory that is consistent with the relativistic kinematical results we have established, and so establish a consistent relativity theory of motion of particles and massive bodies which has many important practical consequences (such as providing the theoretical basis for the extraction
3.7
Relativistic dynamics
103
of nuclear energy, and for understanding the processes taking place in the Sun). The topics dealt with in this section are an important part of special relativity theory, but are not essential for understanding the nature of space-time geometry or measurements. Thus, the reader who wishes to concentrate on the geometry of space-times can omit this section.
A: Mass Just as we had to be prepared to question all our preconceived ideas about spacetime measurements, so we must also be prepared to revise our ideas about the basic quantities involved in dynamics. In Newtonian theory, the mass of an object is a quantity of considerable importance, since the energy and momentum of any
body are proportional to its mass. Thus, the mass of a rocket determines the amount of energy needed to place it in an orbit around the Earth at a particular distance; the mass of a meteorite determines the amount of kinetic energy it dissipates when it crashes into the Moon at a particular speed and forms a new crater; the masses of elementary particles determine the final speed each attains after a collision: the mass of a car of given power determines the time it takes to accelerate from rest to a speed of 100 km/hr. In Newtonian theory, the mass m of an object is independent of the motion of the observer who measures it. In relativity theory we must be prepared to question whether this is still true or not. Accordingly, we will denote by m0 the mass measured for an object by an observer when it is at rest relative to him. It will then be an experimental question whether or not he should still regard its mass as m0, when the body is in relative motion. It will turn out that the effective relativistic mass m does indeed depend on relative motion (eqn (3.34) below). The second important feature is that in Newtonian theory, total mass is conserved in interactions; for example, if 10 kg of hydrogen and 80 kg of oxygen burn to form water, it is predicted that the mass of water produced will be 90 kg. We shall see below that mass conservation remains true in relativity theory, but in an extended sense: mass can be converted to energy and energy to mass; it is the total of mass and energy that is conserved.
B: Momentum
In Newtonian theory, the momentum of an object is its mass multiplied by its velocity. The importance of momentum is that it underlies the basic conservation laws of dynamical motion: (M1) when no forces act on a body, its momentum is conserved; (M2) when a collision takes place between particles or massive bodies, the total momentum of all the objects involved in the collision is conserved. Consider, for example, a space station of mass 100 tons and a meteorite of mass 50 tons approaching each other. In the reference frame of an inertial observer B the space station is initially moving in the +X-direction at a speed 10 c and the meteorite in the -X-direction at a speed c (Fig. 3.43a). The initial momentum of 2 as implied by the positive sign), and the the rocket is 100 x io c 1 Oc (to the right, initial momentum of the meteorite is 50 x (-z) c = -25c (to the left, as implied by
104
Measurements in flat space-times --01/10 C
loo tons
50 tons X (a)
M tons X (b)
Fig. 3.43 (a) A space station moves right at v = io c while a meteorite moves left at v = ? c. (b) After they collide and fuse together, the wreckage moves at speed v' in the +X-direction.
the negative sign). As no forces are acting on them, by (M1) these momenta stay
constant; they therefore continue approaching each other at constant speeds.
They then collide, generate considerable heat, and fuse together. Let the wreckage have mass M and speed v' in the +X-direction (Fig. 3.43b). The total final momentum of the material involved is Mv'. By (M2), this is equal to the
total initial momentum of the space station plus the meteorite, which is 10c + (-25c) = -15c. Thus conservation of momentum tells us Mv' = -15c, so the final speed is v' = -15c/M. Now in Newtonian theory, total mass is conserved so the final mass of the wreckage is equal to the mass of the space station plus the meteorite, i.e. M = 100 + 50 = 150. Thus v' _ -15c/150 = - io c; that is, the wreckage moves to the left at io the speed of light (v'/c = -0.1). In this example, the situation was particularly simple because all motion took place parallel to the Xaxis. If the motion is in a general direction, we can write the velocity vector v in terms of its components (vx, vy, vZ) parallel to the X, Y, and Z axes respectively; then the components (px, py, pZ) of the momentum vector p parallel to these axes are given by px = mvx, Py = mvy, Pz = mvZ. (3.31 a)
We can conveniently combine these three relations in the single vector equation p=my (3.31b) giving the momentum p measured by an observer B for a particle of mass m moving with velocity v. According to Newtonian theory, B will measure each component (3.31a) of total momentum to be conserved when collisions take place. In relativity theory, on examining momentum conservation from a space-time viewpoint (see Appendix B), it turns out that the quantity conserved is notp but rather a vector ir, the relativistic three-momentum, defined by n = mo'y(v)v (3.32a)
3.7
Relativistic dynamics
105
with components 7rX = mo7(v)vx,
try = mo'Y(v)vy,
7rz = mo'Y(v)vz,
(3.32b)
where mo is a mass associated with the particle (which we later identify as its rest mass') and 7(v) = { 1 - (v/c)2}-z (see eqn (3.21)). Given this definition, the relativity-theory prediction is that momentum it is conserved in collisions:
(total initial momentum r) = (total final momentum n),
(3.33)
and from this one can work out the effects of collisions in relativity theory almost identically to the way one does in Newtonian theory.
To see this, consider again the space station and meteorite in the example above. We naturally assume that the masses stated previously are rest masses.
Relative to the observer B, the 7-factor for the space station is 7(IOc) _ = 1.005 so the x component of its initial momentum {1 - (i0)2}-z = (l0)-2
is ir, = mo7(v)vx = 100 x 1.005 x io c = 10.05c. The 7-factor for the meteorite is 7(Z C) = (1 - (Z)2)-z = (4)-z = 1.155, so the x component of its initial momen-
tum 50 x 1.155 x (-1)c = -28.868c. The total initial momentum is therefore 10.05c - 28.868c = -18.818c, which will be equal to the total final momentum, so
Mo7(v')v' = -18.818c
(*)
where Mo is the rest mass of the wreckage. Completion of the calculation to find v' demands that we work out the final total mass Mo. According to Newtonian theory, total mass is conserved. Can we generalize this result in a simple way? This depends on identifying a conserved quantity that we should call `mass' in relativity theory. Now, on comparing (3.31) and (3.32) it becomes clear that if we define the mass m of a moving particle by
m = 7(v)mo = mo{l - (v/c)2}-2
(3.34)
so that (3.32) can be rewritten in the form Or = mv}
{7rx = mvx, Try = mvy, 7rZ = mvZ},
(3.35)
then the Newtonian and relativistic equations both take the same form: the conserved momentum is given by `momentum = mass x velocity'. Further, given this definition of a mass m that depends on the velocity relative to the observer (mo being independent of this velocity), the four-dimensional momentum conservation equation shows that m is conserved in collisions (Appendix B). From
now on, we refer to m (determined from the rest mass and relative speed by equation (3.34)) as the `mass' of an object, both because the momentum equations then preserve their form (cf. (3.31), (3.35)) and because this quantity is conserved in collisions:
(total initial mass m) = (total final mass m).
(3.36)
106
Measurements in flat space-times
When the body is at rest relative to the observer, (3.34) shows m = mo, hence the name `rest mass' for mo. Clearly m > mo, with m = mo if and only if the body is at rest relative to the observer.
Returning to our example, the initial mass of the space station relative to the observer was mo-y = 100 x 10.05 = 100.5 tons, and the initial mass of the meteorite was 50 x 1.155 = 57.75 tons. Thus, the total initial mass was 100.5 + 57.75 = 158.25 tons. Provided that no mass has been lost any other way, it follows that, by conservation of relativistic mass, this will be the final mass M also; so
M = Mo-y(v') = 158.25.
(**)
Dividing this into the relation (*) above, v'/c = - 18.818/158.25 = -0.119; then substituting this value back into (**) shows Mo = 158.25/ry(0.119c) = 158.25/1.0071 = 157.13 tons, 7 tons more than the total rest mass of the bodies that collided! The source of the extra rest mass would be conversion of some of the kinetic energy of the two bodies into mass, as we shall discuss later in this section. We shall then also see that the collision as discussed so far is oversimplified; in practice radiation would be given off which we need to take into account to get the full picture. Exercise 3.23 Consider the example above when the mass of the meteorite is taken to be 20 tons, all other conditions remaining unchanged. Show that then, according to Newtonian theory,
after the collision the wreckage remains at rest in the rest frame of Observer B, but according to relativity theory this is not so. What is the final total rest mass in this case?
As a second example, suppose an observer sees a particle of rest mass mo approach from the left at a speed v =1 c and collide with a particle which approaches from the right at speed v = a c; after the collision they both remain stationary relative to the observer. What was the rest mass of the second particle? Suppose this mass is Mo. The total final momentum is zero, so the total initial momentum is zero. Hence, the initial momentum to the right of the one body is equal to that to the left of the other:
mo'y(Ic) x2c=Moy(4c) x4c mo/2{l - (2)2}Z = Mo/4{l
-
(4)2}Z.
Thus mo/(a)2 = Mo/2( 6)2, i.e. Mo = 2mo(3 x i)Z = 2mo(4)2 = 2.236mo. By contrast, conservation of energy according to Newtonian theory would give mo x 1 c = Mo x c, i.e. Mo = 2mo, which gives an error of about 11 per cent a relativistic result. compared with the We have now seen how to calculate the consequences of relativistic mass and momentum conservation. Are these laws actually correct, i.e. do they describe the real world? This has to be determined by experiment. Major particle accelerators
3.7
Relativistic dynamics
107
88888 __ooya
V
,
ooa e
(
888PB
E field Charged' plates
Fig. 3.44
Acceleration of a charged particle by an electric field (e.g. in a television display tube).
are used daily to produce particle collisions at very high energies, and many thousands of such collisions have been analysed on the basis of conservation of relativistic momentum (eqn (3.33)) and mass (eqn 3.36)). The theory enables us to
understand the collisions in each case, so these are among the best-tested laws in physics.
C: Force
In Newtonian theory, if a force F acts on a body with momentum p the rate of change of momentum is equal to the force acting: that is,*
{F = dp/dt} a {Fx = dpx/dt, F., = dp.,/dt, FZ = dpZ/dt}.
(3.37a)
This determines the motion of the body when acted on by any force. For example, the electrons which generate the display in a television set are initially accelerated from rest by an electric field. To analyse this, note that if a particle with electric charge e moves non-relativistically in a uniform electric field E, parallel to the field, the force exerted by the field on the particle will be F = eE (Fig. 3.44). If the x axis is chosen parallel to the field, then since p = my the motion of the particle is determined by the equation eE = m dv/dt for the velocity component v in the x direction with solution v = (eE/m) t if it starts from rest. In principle, the particle can eventually reach arbitrarily high speeds if it moves in a uniform electric field long enough. In relativity theory, the same equation of motion is valid; again
force = rate of change of momentum,
*Here dp/dt (the `derivative of p with respect to t') means the rate of change of p as time t evolves; for example the velocity v is the rate of change of position, v = dxldt, and acceleration a is rate of change of velocity, a=dv/dt. If you have not learnt about derivatives in calculus courses, you will simply have to accept as correct some of the results we quote below.
108
Measurements in flat space-times
however, here `momentum' is now the relativistic momentum (3.32). Thus the equations of motion are -
IF = dir/dt}
IF, = d7rx/dt, Fy = d7ry/dt, FZ = d7r,/dt}.
(3.37b)
This again determines the motion of a body acted on by any force, but now correctly takes relativistic effects into account. Reconsidering the example above, the equation for v now becomes
eE = mod{v/(1 - v2/c2)z}/dt. This leads to the relation v/{ 1 - (v/c)2}2i = eEt/mo, which can be solved for v/c, giving the result
v/c = (eEt/moc)/{1 + (eEt/moc)2}Z.
In this case, even an arbitrarily long acceleration period will not enable the particle to exceed the speed of light (Fig. 3.45). Again the question is: does the relativity force-law (3.37b) describe accurately the effects of a force acting on a particle? The answer is similar to the previous
one: this force law has been tested many thousands of times up to very high energies in many particle accelerators, and is a very well-established law of motion in accord with all the experimental data. The essential difference
An observer B will measure the inertial mass of a body by experiments based either on momentum conservation or on the force law (e.g. he will estimate the mass of an elementary particle by measuring the change in its speed when momentum is given to it in a collision). Thus, since the mass m defined by (3.34) is
the quantity that directly enters the momentum definition (3.35) and so the momentum conservation equation (3.33) and the force-law equation (3.37b), it is
indeed the quantity that he will measure as its effective inertial mass. For example, the response of an electron in a particle accelerator to the force acting
v/c
t
Fig. 3.45
The speed of motion of the charged particle as a function of time. No matter how long the particle accelerates, it does not exceed the speed of light.
3.7
Relativistic dynamics
109
will be that expected of a particle of mass m (rather than mo). Hence the effective mass of a particle moving relative to B will be measured by him to vary with its relative speed of motion.
Clearly, the form of the momentum and force equations is very similar in Newtonian theory and relativity theory; indeed, we can regard the only difference as being that the effective mass m in the relativistic theory depends on the speed of motion of the body relative to the observer according to formula (3.34), while in Newtonian theory it is independent of this motion. Despite this close similarity in form, variation of m with speed v results in a fundamental difference between the Newtonian and relativistic cases. In Newtonian theory, m is a constant and there is nothing special about the speed of light. In relativity theory, m is related v by (3.34); the relation is shown in Fig. 3.46. The crucial feature is that the effective
mass m diverges as V -+ ±1 (i.e. as v ± c) and so the momentum n (given by (3.35)) diverges then also; a graph of the magnitude of the momentum against the magnitude of the relative velocity v is given in Fig. 3.47. The consequence is that as one imparts more and more momentum to an object, either through collisions or through exerting forces on it, it moves closer and closer to the speed of light as its momentum increases, but never reaches that speed because the inertial mass increases without limit and so the force needed to increase its speed by some given
amount also increases without limit. Thus, one cannot accelerate a particle to faster than light in a particle accelerator, no matter how large the accelerator is (see Fig. 3.45), nor can one accelerate a rocket to faster than light no matter how much fuel one burns or how powerful the rocket motor is. To see this in a specific case, suppose a projectile is moving at v/c = 5; then = 3, so its effective mass is 3 mo and its momentum has magnitude Y = (1 = my = 3 mo (5) c = moc. If its momentum is now doubled, then it = 8 moc. 25)-Z
3
m
MO 3
2
1
\
Fig. 3.46 A graph of m/mo, the ratio of effective mass m to rest mass mo, against relative speed of motion V = v/c.
110
Measurements in flat space-times A
J7J
MO 3
2
y1
l.
V/
Fig. 3.47 A graph of 1n/mo l, the ratio of the magnitude of relativistic momentum to rest mass against V= v/c.
The new speed of motion v' is related to the momentum by 7r = 8 m0c = v'7'(v')m0 = v'{ 1 - (v'/c)2}-2mo; solving for v' shows (v'/c)2 3 (8)2/ {1 + (8)2} = 63 so v'/c = (63)2 = 0.936. Successively doubling the momentum, we find
7 = 3 rn0 = V = v/c = (z) 7r =
8
m0 = V = v/c =
0.800,
(63)2= 0.936,
7r = 3 m0 = V = v/c = (z6s)1= 0.983,
7r = 33 m0 = V = VC = 7r =
34
m0 = V = v/C =
(1033)2- 0.996,
(1:409-'056)12
4105) Z= 0.999,
showing that less and less return is gained for each doubling of momentum and the speed of light is not attained. Because the effective mass diverges at the speed of light, one cannot by any physical process accelerate a real object so that its final speed exceeds the speed of light. Thus, the dynamical theory of special relativity is in agreement with the
basic assumption that the speed of light is a limiting speed for motion of all massive bodies, and indeed ensures that this condition is fulfilled. There is no inconsistency between the kinematics and dynamics of special relativity; they form a consistent whole together, as long as we do not omit any of the relativistic effects.
Computer Exercises 10.
Write a program that accepts as input the rest mass MO and speed of motion V1 of a
particle moving relative to an observer B in the X-direction of his reference frame, and
3.7
Relativistic dynamics
111
prints out its relativistic mass Ml and momentum P1. Use this program to verify the forms
of Figs 3.46 and 3.47, and so to check that no matter how much momentum may be imparted to a particle its speed will not exceed the speed of light. Print out also the slow-motion approximation MI = Mo(1 +2 (VI/c)2), and find out for what ranges of VI this is a good approximation to Ml.
11. Write a program that will accept as inputs the rest masses M0(I) and speeds of motion VI (I) of two particles labelled 1(1= 1, 2) which collide in a particle accelerator and are converted to two new particles (labeled J, J = 3, 4) in this collision, all particles moving in the X-direction of the chosen coordinate axes. The program should additionally accept as inputs the measured speeds V2(J) of the product particles, and then calculate and print
out their rest masses M0(J). [Find the total momentum and rest mass of the initial particles, use the mass and momentum conservation equations, and then solve for the final rest masses.] What happens if you enter a value of V2(J) greater than the speed of light? What happens for a value equal to the speed of light?
D: Energy and mass One of the fundamental features of Newtonian theory is the principle of energy conservation. For example, when the engine of a rocket accelerates it, energy is supplied to the rocket by the fuel it burns, the rate at which work is done being equal to the rate at which energy is supplied by the fuel. Similarly in the case of relativity theory one can calculate the rate at which work is done by a force acting on a body; this turns out to be proportional to the rate of change of its mass m (see Appendix B). Thus if we assume the rate of working is again equal to the rate of change of energy of that body, we deduce that the rate of change of energy is proportional to the rate of change of mass, suggesting a relation between mass and energy. Further, if a body of rest mass m moves slowly relative to the observer so that (v/c)2 << 1, one can approximate expression (3.34) by
m = m0/{1 - (v/c)2}2 = m0{ I + 2 (v/c)2 + terms of order (v/C)4}, that is,
m = mo + Zmov2/c2 + (small terms that can be neglected).
(3.38a)
This shows that the Newtonian kinetic energy EK = move contributes an 2 the small terms and amount EK/c2 to the effective mass of the body. Dropping multiplying by the constant c2, we find that approximately
mc2 = m0c2 + EK.
(3.38b)
Thus one is again led to the idea that mass and energy are closely related to each other.
On the basis of these kinds of arguments, Einstein proposed that mass and energy are different aspects of the same fundamental physical quantity. Mathematically, this is expressed in the famous relation E = mc2
(3.39)
112
Measurements in flat space-times
where the constant factor c2 is required so that the dimensions of the equation are correct; the fact that this conversion factor is required to relate mass and energy
units is evident from (3.38). This relation immediately implies that the mass conservation law (3.36) also expresses conservation of energy during particle interactions: (total final energy) = (total initial energy).
(3.40)
Conservation of energy is a necessity because on taking a relativity viewpoint (see
Appendix B), it is clear that the (three-dimensional) law of momentum conservation (3.33) and (one-dimensional) law of energy conservation (3.40) can be written as a single (four-dimensional) law of energy-momentum conservation; what appears to be momentum conservation in one frame will be energy conservation in another, and vice versa. These are then absolute laws that hold in all interactions as viewed by all observers; because of (3.39), the law of mass conservation (3.36) is implied as well. Before exploring the meaning of these relations, we define the concepts of restmass energy and kinetic energy in relativity theory. Putting v = 0 in eqn (3.39), we find the energy of a body at rest relative to the observer, that is, the energy E= Eo associated with its rest mass. Since -y = 1 in this case, then m = mo and we find
Eo = moc2 = (the particle's'rest-mass energy').
(3.41)
Using eqns (3.34) and (3.41) in (3.39) shows that the total energy is E = mo-y(v)c2 = Eo'y(v).
(3.42)
We now define the relativistic kinetic energy EK from the rest-mass energy Eo and
the total energy E by the relation
E=Eo+EK
(3.43)
that is, the kinetic energy EK is defined to be precisely that part of the total energy E due to motion of the body relative to the observer. Using the definitions (3.39), (3.41) we recover eqn (3.38b) as a relation that is exactly true in relativity theory. Also using (3.42) and (3.21), eqn (3.43) shows that EK = mocZ
1
{1 - (v/c)Z}z
-1
(3.44)
is the exact relativity expression for kinetic energy. In the case of slow motion this reduces to EK = mov2+ (small terms that may be neglected), thus recovering the 2 Newtonian expression z move as a good approximation to the kinetic energy when (v/cj << 1. When low speeds are involved, we may use either expression for kinetic energy, for the difference between them will be negligible; when high speeds are
involved, we must use the relativity expressions for energy, or we shall obtain wrong answers. Summing up, in relativity theory, eqn (3.43) splits the total
3.7
Relativistic dynamics
113
energy E into its rest-mass energy E0, that part of the total energy independent of the motion of the body, and its kinetic energy EK, the part solely dependent on that motion. Eo is given by (3.41) and EK by (3.44). These ideas are of fundamental importance in physics. We do not have space to
consider all their implications in detail, but will outline some of the most important consequences.
The conservation of mass and energy Einstein's vision was to see that these relations apply to all forms of energy, this total energy being conserved. In Newtonian theory, provided one accounts for all
forms of energy, total mass and total energy are separately conserved when complex interactions take place between bodies or systems of particles. In relativity theory these two laws are replaced by a single conservation law, the law of conservation of relativistic energy, which accounts for all forms of energy and simultaneously represents conservation of mass (because mass and energy are just different aspects of the same quantity). The implications are profound. Consider two billiard balls colliding. In the real world, while most of their kinetic energy will be regained in the rebound of the balls after the collision, some of this energy will be expended in heating the balls up. Thus the final kinetic energy will be less than the initial kinetic energy, the difference being accounted for by the heat energy gained by the balls (resulting in
their final temperatures being higher than their initial temperatures). Total energy is conserved, so we can calculate the change in heat energy, which will result in the balls finally having a larger rest mass than before the collision. As a specific example, suppose two identical balls of rest mass kg are seen by z an observer to approach each other symmetrically, each moving at a speed
v = z c, collide, and then separate at a speed v' = a c (Fig. 3.48). The total momentum is zero initially and therefore is zero finally, as momentum is conserved. It follows that the final rest masses are equal (which is also clear by the symmetry of the situation). The initial total energy is
2xzx Y(zc)=(1-()2)z=(4) V= C/2
V=C/2
A
e
1/2Kg
z=1.155.
1/2Kg IN- X
Initial state
-
V= CA
V=C/4
©
e
MO
M0
V-X Final
state
Fig. 3.48 Two balls of mass 0.5 kg approach each other, each moving at a speed z c relative to an observer B, and then move apart after colliding, each moving at a speed
c.
a
114
Measurements in flat space-times
If the final rest mass of each ball is Mo, the final total energy is 1
1
2 x Mo x -y(4c) = 2Mo{1 - (4)2} 2= 2Mo(15) 2= 2.066 Mo. Since these energies are equal, then Mo = 1.155/2.066 = 0.559 kg, an amount of 0.059 kg more than before the collision. By definition, this is the mass an observer moving with each ball will measure for it; how can the rest mass of the ball have increased? The answer is that the ball has more energy in it finally than initially because it has heated up, and this results in an increase in the ball's rest mass because of the equivalence of mass and energy.
The inertia of energy This example illustrates the fact that a hot ball will have a larger inertial mass than an identical ball which is cold. By (3.32) its momentum at a given velocity will also increase; heat energy has inertia! Thus one will, for example, have to impart more momentum to the hot ball to increase its speed from rest to 30 km/hr than in the case of the cold ball. The same applies to all forms of energy, for (3.41) shows that if there is any increase in energy of a body (e.g. if it is heated up, if a battery is charged, if a spring is wound up), its rest mass will increase. Thus, all forms of energy (e.g. the chemical energy in a charged battery, the mechanical energy in a
wound spring) contribute to the inertia of a moving body, increasing the force
required to accelerate it to a given speed and the momentum it carries at that speed. As is often the case, this effect will be negligible in everyday life; in our illustrative example we took the billiard balls to approach at half the speed of light in order to demonstrate a substantial effect, but it is of course totally impossible to achieve this on an ordinary billiard table! However, relativistic speeds (i.e. speeds close to the speed of light) are attainable in many physical situations, and the effect then becomes very important as the fraction of momentum due to internal energy, rather than rest-mass energy, increases. The most dramatic example is in the case of zero-rest-mass particles: these are particles that, although they have no rest mass, have non-zero internal energy and consequently non-zero momentum. To see the properties of these particles, we note that from equations (3.21) (3.32) and (3.42) one can prove the relations E2
- 7r2'c2 = moc4,
n = (E/c2)v,
c2 = E2v2/c2
(3.45)
(3.46)
where ire and v2 are respectively the squared magnitudes of the momentum and velocity vectors (see Exercise 3.27). This in turn implies the equation
E2(l - v2/c2) = moc4.
(3.47)
These equations hold for any particle or body. The idea now is to take the limit MO -* 0 while E remains non-zero. From (3.46) and (3.47) we find {mo = 0,
E
Of = {v 2= c2, it = E/c},
(3.48)
3.7
Relativistic dynamics
115
showing that zero-rest-mass particles must move at the speed of light, and their
energy and momentum are the same (up to a factor of c required to convert dimensions between these quantities). Thus, we can consistently conceive of particles which have finite energy and carry finite momentum for which (3.32), (3.42), (3.45), and (3.46) hold in a limiting form where (3.48) is true. Such particles do indeed exist, for example the photon, which is the particle associated with light (and so must of necessity move at the speed of light, as required by (3.48)). As is familiar, photons are able to carry energy between distant points, e.g. one can destroy a satellite in space by use of a suitable laser on the earth which focuses light on the satellite; the photons which carry the energy from the laser to the satellite will also carry momentum, so the laser will recoil as it is fired and the satellite wreckage will be pushed into a new orbit by this momentum. This kind of effect will occur for every collision involving zero-rest-mass particles. Suppose for example that a photon with energy 1 MeV collides with a stationary electron with rest mass 0.511 MeV. After the collision it is observed
that the photon has been deflected through an angle of 45°. Suppose that its energy and momentum are then E' and n', and those of the electron are E" and n".
Now Ijt = E'/c, and conservation of energy gives
1+0.511 =E'+E". Conservation of momentum shows
n=X, +X", where it is the initial momentum of the photon. Rearranging the last equation and taking the squared magnitude, we obtain In-H,I2= IX"I2,
giving InI2+In)I2-2n.
=
In)'I2.
Noting that the magnitude of n is 1/c (from (3.48)) and that n
_
Inj In') cos 45°, we find that
(1/c)2 + (E' /c)2 - 2(E'/c2) cos45° = In,'I2 = (1/c2){(E")2 - (0.511)2}
from (3.45). Substitution for E" from the equation of conservation of energy leads to
1+(E')2-2x2E',/2=(1.511-E')2-(0.511)2. Solving this equation gives E' = 0.636 MeV and we see that the photon has lost energy as a result of the collision. The existence of zero-rest-mass particles leads to significant changes to the equation of state of matter at very high temperatures, which in turn affects such features as the equilibrium states of massive stars and the rate of expansion of the
116
Measurements in flat space-times
early universe. As a specific example: because the temperatures there are so high, the interior of a star like the Sun contains vast numbers of high-energy photons. The gravitational forces trying to cause the sun to collapse are prevented from doing so primarily by radiation pressure exerted by these photons because of the momentum they necessarily carry (eqn (3.48)). Thus, this is one of the features making a long life possible for stars like the Sun; it makes possible the stability of the Sun, which in turn makes life possible on the Earth.
The conversion of mass to energy and vice versa While total energy is conserved in relativity theory, (3.41) suggests the possibility of converting rest mass to energy or vice versa. This can indeed be done in different ways. Because of the very large constant c2 in this relation, a very large amount of energy is obtained by conversion of a very small amount of matter. The major processes whereby mass is converted to energy are fusion, fission, and pair annihilation; we briefly discuss these in turn. Fusion In the example above of a collision between a space station and meteorite, we found that the total final mass was higher than the initial mass; and are now able to interpret this increase as being the mass equivalent of heat energy
of the wreckage. Suppose now that this heat radiates off to space until the wreckage is cold: all the heat energy is gone. What would be the rest mass then? Initially one might think this would be exactly equal to the mass of the components, i.e. 150 tons. However, this cannot be correct, for the following reason. The material of the satellite and meteorite are fused together into a solid whole, which is stable (it does not spontaneously break apart). This means one would
have to supply some energy in order to break it up into its constituent parts; because of this extra energy, which will increase the mass of the components, the total masses of these parts would be more than the mass of the wreckage. Thus the cold wreckage must weigh less than 150 tons. An exactly analogous effect occurs in atomic nuclei. The nucleus of an atom
consists of protons and neutrons ('nucleons') tightly bound together. Energy is needed to break a stable nucleus up into its constituent parts; the amount of energy needed to do this is its binding energy. If the nucleus were to be assembled from its elementary constituents, this amount of energy would be given off as they
bind together to form the nucleus (Fig. 3.49). But, by (3.41) this energy loss implies a mass loss: so all nuclei have masses less than the masses of their constituent nuclei. For example, the mass of a proton is 1.007825 a.m.u.* and the mass of a neutron is 1.008665 a.m.u, so the total mass of a proton and a neutron is 2.016490 a.m.u. However, the mass of a deuterium nucleus, formed by fusing together a proton and a neutron, is 2.014102 a.m.u., less than the masses of its constituents by 0.002388 a.m.u. This mass difference, known as the mass defect, is directly measurable. The binding energy of deuterium is also directly measurable, and is found to be 2.224 MeV which is just the energy equivalent of 0.002388 a.m.u. Thus equation (3.41) can be directly verified by these delicate experiments. * 1 a.m.u. ='atomic mass unit'= 1.6605 x 10-27kg. Its energy equivalent is 931.5 MeV.
3.7 mp
Relativistic dynamics
117
Mn
D 0 approach binding energy radiated
v
deuteron
nucleus
Fig. 3.49 A proton and a neutron fuse together, giving off energy, to form a deuteron nucleus with mass less than the total mass of the constituent particles.
For most nuclei the binding energy per nucleon is about 8 MeV; the nucleus with the largest binding energy per nucleon is iron, which is therefore the most stable nucleus. Some of the lighter elements can give off energy by fusion, when they combine to make heavier elements. A dramatic demonstration is the fusion (in a series of steps) of hydrogen to helium, releasing the binding energy of the helium; this is the process occurring in the hydrogen bomb, and is also the main source of energy in the Sun. This is an immensely important consequence of special relativity theory, because the Sun is the source of all the energy that enables life to exist on the Earth. The stars in galaxy NGC 3377 on the cover of this book would be invisible were it not for the release of fusion energy, not to mention the fact that neither the photographer nor the reader would exist in the absence of this process!
Elements heavier than iron have a lower binding energy per nucleon than iron, and so can give off energy by fission, as they split to make lighter Fission
elements. The most famous example of this is when uranium 235 splits into two nuclei, giving off the difference in binding energy between the initial uranium nucleus and the two final nuclei. This is the process occurring in the original atomic bomb, and the source of energy in many nuclear reactors used to supply electricity. Thus, the tiny mass differences corresponding to the binding energy of nuclei have very important consequences in the modern world.
Pair annihilation and creation In pair annihilation, an electron and its antiparticle,* a positron, annihilate entirely and all their rest mass plus their kinetic energy is converted to energy carried off in the form of electromagnetic radiation
(in the form of particles of light, i.e. photons). The rest mass of an electron is mOC2 = 0.511 MeV, so an energy greater than 1.022 MeV is released per electron-
positron pair annihilated. This process may be a powerful source of energy in various astrophysical processes. *A particle with equal mass but opposite values of other quantities such as charge.
118
Measurements in flat space-times
The converse process of pair creation is also possible. If two photons collide with a total energy greater than the threshold energy of 1.022 MeV, sufficient energy is present to provide the rest mass of an electron-positron pair, so such a pair can be created where none existed before. This does not violate the law of conservation of mass, because energy has been turned into mass, and it is the total of mass and energy that is conserved in the reaction. Similarly, a single photon of sufficient energy can create an electron-positron pair, provided there is a nucleus nearby to allow conservation of energy and momentum. The creation of matter
out of pure radiation is perhaps the most dramatic demonstration of the massenergy relation. It has been demonstrated many hundreds of thousands of times in particle-accelerator experiments; Figure. 3.50 shows the creation of an electron-positron pair in a bubble chamber, where a high-energy photon enters the chamber from the left and produces the pair near a nucleus which allows balancing of total energy and momentum. Neither the photon nor the nucleus leaves a visible track in the chamber, so the tracks of the electron-positron pair seem to appear out of nothing. The relativistic basis
These consequences of special relativity all follow naturally from the fourdimensional view of energy and momentum that results when we consider dynamics from a space-time viewpoint, leading naturally to equations (3.32) and (3.42). It is perhaps useful to conclude this section by indicating how this happens (details being given in Appendix B). Our basic ideas of kinetic energy and momentum lead us to believe that in both Newtonian and relativistic theory, when the relative velocity is zero, an observer will measure both quantities to be zero; thus in the relativity case,
{v=0} = {7r=0,EK=0,E=Eo}
(3.49)
(the equality of E and E0 following from (3.43)). Thus, if an observer moves with a particle, all he will measure will be its rest-mass energy. Now change to another frame so that the particle is in relative motion at speed v; equations (3.32) for the momentum and (3.42) for the mass then follow. The latter provides the basis for (3.38) and so for (3.39).
Conclusion
We have seen how the application of relativity theory to dynamics leads to the
understanding of many important phenomena: the velocity-dependence of effective mass, the equivalence of mass and energy, the inertia of all forms of energy, the concept of `rest mass', and the possibility of converting mass to energy and vice versa. While many of the consequences of relativity theory are important
only when high speed motion or large distances are involved, some of the dynamical phenomena are important in everyday life; for example, nuclear fission is a source of power for many cities at the present time.
Fig. 3.50 Conversion of energy to matter according to Einstein's famous formula E = mcz illustrated by pair production. A very energetic photon provides the energy needed to create the rest masses of an electron-positron pair. The photon does not make a visible track, but the tracks of the electron and positron after their creation are visible as they move to the right in spiral tracks in the Brookhaven bubble chamber. (Photograph provided by Brookhaven National Laboratory.)
120
Measurements in flat space-times
Exercises 3.24 Suppose that a particle moves with speed (i) 10-6c (ii) 10-2c (iii) c. Find in z each case the ratio of the kinetic energy to the rest energy. particle with rest mass M° and speeds c collides with a stationary particle of rest 3.25A mass Mo. They coalesce to form a new particle. Find its rest mass and speed of motion. a particle of rest mass M° is moving with speed 13 cat time t = 0. It is subject to a 3.26A constant force of magnitude iz Mo c parallel to its direction of motion. Find its speed when t = 1. How inaccurate would the Newtonian result be in this case? 3.27 Obtain the energy-momentum relation for zero-rest-mass particles as follows. (i) Square equation (3.32a). (ii) Square equation (3.42). (iii) Obtain equation (3.45), and solve for E. (iv) Take the limit of this expression as m° --+ 0. (v) Obtain from (3.46) from (3.45), and so show the speed v = c allows non-zero values for 7r and E even through m° is zero. [Note that relations (3.32) and (3.42) are indeterminate in this case.] 3.28 The energy received from the Sun at the Earth is 8 x 107 erg/cmz-min on a surface perpendicular to the rays of the Sun. At what rate (in kg per minute) is hydrogen
consumed in the Sun, in a chain of reactions fusing 4 protons (i.e. hydrogen nuclei) together to form one helium nucleus, to provide this radiated energy? What does this suggest about the lifetime of the Sun? [Hint: (i) Find in a.m.u. the energy released when 4 protons form a helium nucleus (the mass of a helium nucleus is 4.002603 a.m.u.). Convert this to ergs, using the relation
la.m.u. = 1.4916 x 10-3 ergs. (ii) Find the surface area (4irrz) of a sphere with radius equal to the Earth-Sun distance of 1.496 x 1013 cm. (iii) Find the total energy falling on this sphere per minute if 8 x 107 ergs fall on each cm2 of the sphere per minute. (iv) Determine how many fusion events will be needed per minute to produce this energy. (v) Convert the total mass of hydrogen needed per minute into kilograms. (vi) Estimate the
maximum lifetime of the Sun if all its mass (1.989 x 1030 kg) is used up in the fusion process.] 3.29 How much energy is released in the fission of a radium nucleus (consisting of 224 nucleons with an average binding energy of 7.5 MeV per nucleon) into 4 iron nuclei (each with 56, nucleons with an average binding energy of 8.6 MeV per nucleon)? 3.30 What energy is released in annihilation of a proton-antiproton pair? What is the threshold energy a pair of photons require in order to create a proton-antiproton pair? [A proton has a rest mass 1836.1 larger than the rest mass of an electron.]
3.8
The consistency of physics
We have discussed how the whole package of the kinematic and dynamical ideas
of relativity theory must be consistent, and have important physical consequences. But Einstein's requirement goes further than this: all of physics must be consistent with the relativity principle. This central idea has many important consequences. It implies that relativity kinematics must obey the relativity principle and be consistent; we discussed this
in Section 3.6. It implies that the laws of dynamics must obey the relativity principle, and be consistent with relativistic kinematics; we discussed this in Section 3.7. When applied to quantum mechanics, it led Dirac to predict the
3.8
The consistency of physics
121
existence of antiparticles long before they were observed experimentally. We will close this section by considering briefly one of the most successful of the classical physical theories, namely the theory of electromagnetism. What happens when we consider this from the viewpoint of relativity theory? The answer is perhaps rather surprising: this classical theory is completely compatible with relativity. Unlike the case of classical dynamics, where a reformulation was required and dramatic new results were found when relativity was taken into account, in this case it was discovered that the principle of relativity was already deeply imbedded in the classical theory; indeed, it forms the foundation of the well-known relation between electricity and magnetism. This will be discussed briefly in Appendix C.
Because of this unity of physics and the compatibility of all physics with relativity theory, we do not have to rely on delicate measurements of clock times
(as in the Hafele-Keating experiment) or of the speed of light (as in the Michelson-Morley experiment) to verify that special relativity is correct. Rather,
we can prove its validity by the accuracy of the predictions of relativistic momentum conservation, verified many hundreds of thousands of times in highenergy accelerators, and by the existence of nuclear reactors and the demon-
stration of pair production and annihilation, as discussed in Section 3.7. Therefore, special relativity is in fact one of the best tested of all physical theories.
As mentioned above, even the cover photograph of the book is evidence for special relativity theory, because the stars shine as a result of the conversion of mass to energy as outlined in Exercise 3.28. Computer-Graphics Exercise 1 Write a program that will draw on the screen the (t, X) axes of an observer A. It should then contain subroutines to do the following: (a) Accept as input the speed of motion v of an observer B relative to A, and the spatial position Xo of B at the time t = 0 as measured by A; and then draw on the screen B's worldline. [Note: Iv/c) < 1.] (b) Accept as input a time to as measured by A, and then indicate the point P in B's
history that corresponds to that time. (c)
Draw a surface of simultaneity for B through any designated point Q on his
world-line. (d) Draw the future and past light cones of any designated space-time point Q (with coordinates (t1, X1)). (e) Draw a series of light rays from A to B emitted at regular time intervals TO, and print out the interval of reception of signals by B as measured by A [found directly from tcoordinate values], and as measured by B [determined by use of the K-factor]. (f) Draw a radar signal sent from A to B at some time t1 and reflected back to A. Use your program to depict (1) an observer A receiving radiation at some instant to from a distant galaxy, indicating clearly the time t1 in the galaxy's history that is observable by A at the time to; (2) the front and back ends of a rocket B moving past A, measured by A to be of length L, showing surfaces of simultaneity for A and for B; (3) observer B moving away from observer A and then back at speed v, while A keeps track of his motion by radar. [You should be able to think of many other elaborations and uses for this graphics program.]
4
The Lorentz transformation and the invariant interval To examine the unifying ideas set out in Section 3.6, we look in turn at Lorentz transformations, at simple quantities invariant under these transformations, and at the invariant interval of flat space-time. We complete our examination of flat space-times by looking at three universe models based on these space-times.
An understanding of the invariant interval and its meaning (presented in Section 4.2) is important for a full appreciation of the properties of the curved space-times discussed in Chapters 6 and 7. From the viewpoint of this book, the primary importance of the Lorentz-transformation discussion (in Section 4.1) is that it enables us to prove (in Section 4.2) that the space-time interval is an invariant, i.e. is the same for all observers.
4.1
The Lorentz transformation
Some people would claim that man's destiny, if he does not destroy himself before he has time to attain it, is to explore the Galaxy. As always, in venturing into the unknown, accurate surveying and mapping will be of vital importance for the safety of those engaged in this enterprise. Thus, it will be necessary to collate observations from many observatories, space stations, and spacecraft to give an overall picture of the regions that have been explored.* However, many of these observations will be made by observers moving relative to each other, so we must know how to reduce to a common reference frame observations made by relatively moving observers. The essential problem is to derive a relationship between the space-time views obtained by any two observers. Once obtained, this will unify the fundamental special-relativity results of time dilation, length contraction, and the relativity of simultaneity, in a single relation. We determine this relation, the Lorentz transformation, in this section.
The two coordinate systems Consider inertial observers A and B moving at speed v relative to each other, with their space-time positions coinciding at an event 0; for concreteness, one might
consider say A as being in a control tower at an airport, and B in an aircraft flying past. *See `Navigation between the planets', W. G. Melbourne. Scientific American 234, June 1976, 58.
4.1
The Lorentz transformation
123
A's coordinates
Observer A defines a time coordinate t and spatial coordinates (x, y, z) in the standard way. Essentially, he (i) measures proper time t along his world-line by using an ideal clock; (ii) determines surfaces of simultaneity in space-time by use of radar; these are the surfaces {t = constant}, extending his time measurements from his world-line to the rest of space-time; and (iii) determines a set of non-rotating orthogonal directions along his world-line by local dynamical experiments (use of ideal gyroscopes, pendulums, etc), and measures spatial distances (x, y, z) along these axes by radar. This implies that he chooses (x, y, z) so that his own position at all times is at the origin (0, 0, 0). (iv) Surfaces {x = constant, y = constant, z = constant} in space-time can be determined by radar observations of distances at arbitrary angles 9 and 0 relative to these coordinate axes and use of standard trigonometry, thus extending the distance measurements along the axes to the rest of space-time (the relationships involved here are somewhat complex to write out in full, and do not particularly illuminate the nature of special relativity theory, so we shall omit the details of this procedure). It is then convenient (v) to define new coordinates (X, Y, Z) by
the relations (X = x/c, Y = y/c, Z = z/c) to obtain a geometrical picture of space-time where the light cone is at 45° to the vertical; physically, he has then chosen distance units that set the speed of light to 1 (see Sections 1.2 and 2.2). When he has done this, he has effectively covered space-time by a coordinate grid that labels each event P by coordinates (t, X, Y, Z) in the standard way (see Fig. 4.la). One should note particularly that, by their nature, these coordinates represent specific time and distance measurements as outlined above. The time coordinate of any point is measured along the time lines (parallel to A's world-
line) from the surface of simultaneity {t = 0}; in particular t specifies time measured by any observer whose world-line is the coordinate axis {X = Y = Z = 0}. The surfaces {t=constant} are surfaces of instantaneity for such an observer, and (X, Y, Z) are spatial distance coordinates for him in these surfaces from the origin {X = Y = Z = 0}. Thus, the position of a general point P can be represented as a combination of a spatial displacement in a surface { t = constant} and a time displacement along a line {X, Y, Z constant}, where one
may make these displacements in either order. We need four coordinates to describe the set of all events because space-time is four-dimensional, so precisely
four numbers are needed to locate each happening in space and time. For example, a collision between two aircraft is located precisely if we are told it took place at 4:00 p.m. (Greenwich mean time) on 19 November 1986, at the height of
10000 metres above the earth's surface and at latitude 40°30'20", longitude 10°23'34". More coordinates would be inconsistent or redundant; less would be
insufficient to completely tell us `where and when'-i.e. at what space-time point-it took place. It is often convenient to use a superscript notation for coordinates. Thus instead of writing (t, X, Y, Z) we can write (x°, xi , x2, x3) where we have defined x° - t, xl = X, x2 = Y, x3 Z. For brevity, we write the whole sequence of four coordinates as (x°), where the coordinate index (or label) a is understood to run through the values 0, 1, 2, 3; so (xa) = (x°, xl, x2, x3). We may avoid possible
conflict between `the coordinate x2' and `the square of the coordinate x' by
U
x lN
- - - - - - - - - - -- - -
C
j Q
x
x Y
O O 0 O
4.1
The Lorentz transformation
125
writing the latter as (x)2; and similarly for other powers of x that may occur. However, in the context of using the coordinate names t, X, Y, Z we continue to denote the squares simply by t2, X2, Y2, Z2, when no confusion will arise. We refer to A's coordinate system (Xa) determined in this way as his reference frame and denote it by the single letter F. B's coordinates Observer B defines his coordinates (t', X', Y', Z') = (xa') in the identical way, by use of ideal clocks and radar. Then he has covered space-time by a second coordinate grid that labels each event P by coordinates (t', X', Y', Z') (Fig. 4.lb). In this case, the position of a point P is represented by a combination of a spatial displacement in a surface of instantaneity { t'= constant} (tilted at some angle a relative to the surface of constant time t) and a time displacement
along a line {X', Y', Z' constant} parallel to B's world-line (tilted at the same angle a relative to A's world-line, cf. Fig. 3.20). Again one may make these displacements in either order. We refer to B's coordinate system (xa') as his reference
frame P. The relationship between the two coordinate systems
Now the crucial point is that the same set of events are described by the two coordinate systems (xa) and (xa') (Fig. 4.1c). The relationship between the two observers' space-time measurements is contained in the relation between these two coordinate systems. This relation can be simplified greatly by making two choices: (i) A and B each rotate their spatial axes so that the direction of relative motion lies in the X direction and X' direction respectively, with their Y and Y' and their Z and Z' axes respectively coincident, and (ii) A and B each choose the origin of their time coordinates so that the event 0 where they meet is at the time t = 0 and t' = 0 respectively; that is, the origins of their coordinates coincide then. From now on we shall assume these simplifications have been made. Our task then is to determine the relationships between the two coordinate systems, and hence between measurements made by the two observers. The derivation that follows is somewhat involved; if you find yourself getting bogged down in the next few paragraphs on a first reading, we recommend turning to the formulae themselves (4.3, 5) and their consequences (4.6-14). Consider the event E labelled (t, X, Y, Z) by A and (t', X', Y', Z') by B. As the
relative motion is in the X (or X') direction, measurements in the Y and Z directions are unaffected (see Section 3.5), so Y= Y' and Z=Z' for all t (or t'). Thus we need to concentrate only on the relation between (t, X) and (t', X'). These two pairs of coordinates are drawn from A's viewpoint in Fig. 4.2. Because B's surfaces of simultaneity are tilted up by the same angle as his world-line is tilted over from vertical (Section 3.3), the triangles OCF and EKJ in Fig. 4.2 are identical to each other (formally: they are congruent); and similarly, the triangles OHJ and EGF are identical to each other. This is clear from the diagram; a formal
proof is given in the appendix to this section. Since E has coordinates (t', X') according to B, the displacements OF and JE both represent the distance X' measured by B and OJ and FE both represent the time t' measured by B. Let J have the coordinates (to, Xo) in A's frame; then the displacements OH and GE
126
The Lorentz transformation and the invariant interval
Fig. 4.2 The event E has coordinates (t, X) in A's frame and coordinates (t', X') in B's frame. Lines IE and OD are simultaneous for A, while JE and OF are simultaneous for B. Observer A measures DE to be at constant distance from his world-line 01, while observer B measures EF to be at constant distance from his world-line OJ. The lines FG and JH are parallel to the X-axis, and the lines CF and JK are parallel to the t-axis.
both represent times to measured by A, and HJ and FG both represent distances Xo measured by A. Similarly let F have the coordinates (ti, Xl) in A's frame; then the displacements OC and KE both represent a distance Xl measured by A, and JK and CF both represent times tl measured by A. We now use some earlier results to relate these different coordinate values.
(a) Time dilation (3.18, 20) for the time measured from 0 to J gives to = -y(v)t',
(4.1a)
where -y(v) is given by (3.19).
(b) Length contraction (3.22, 23) for the distance measured from 0 to F gives
Xl = -y(v)X'.
(4.1b)
(c) Since B moves at the speed v relative to A, the distance Xo represented by HJ is
related to the time to represented by OH by Xo = xo/c = vto/c = (v/c)to = Vto.
(4.1c)
(d) Because the angle HOJ is equal to the angle COF, we have HJ/HO = FC/CO, that is, Xo/to = t1/Xi; so, using (4.1c), we obtain ti = XOX3/to = VX1
(4.1d)
(which is essentially the simultaneity result (3.17)).
This information now lets us determine the lengths of the sides of the large rectangle DIED. Firstly,. OD = OC + CD = OC + FG = OC + HJ (because triangles OHJ, EGF are congruent). But OD = X, OC = X1, and HJ = X0.
4.1
The Lorentz transformation
127
Hence
X = X, + Xp = 'y(v)X' + V'y(v) t' from (4.1b,a,c); that is, X = -Y(V) (X' + Vt').
4.2a)
Similarly, OI = OH + HI = OH + JK = OH + CF (because triangles OCF and EKJ are congruent). Therefore t = to + t, = ly(v)t' + Vly(v)X' by (4.1a,d,b); that is,
t = -y(v) (t' + VX').
(4.2b)
Finally, as we have already seen,
Y=Y', Z=Z'.
(4.2c)
Equations (4.2a-c) are called the Lorentz transformation resulting from a change of velocity in the x direction (sometimes called a `boost'). They give A's
coordinates for the event E in terms of B's coordinates for that event. The equations are usually written in terms of the coordinates x, y, z and x', y', z':
t = -y(v)(t' +vx'/c2),
(4.3a)
X = -y(v) (x' + vt'),
(4.3b)
y = y', z = z',
(4.3c)
where
'y(v) = (1 - v2/c2)-z.
(4.4)
This is the required set of equations relating two observers' coordinates for the same event. As an example of their use, suppose observer B is in a rocket moving uniformly
at speed v = s c away from observer A at a base on the Earth, both observers agreeing to measure time from the instant when B passed A at the space-time event O. After a while B observes a tremendous explosion on a planet he is observing by radar. He measures the coordinates of the event P where the explosion took place to be (Xa') = (5, 1, 3, 0), that is, t' = 5, X' = 1, Y' = 3, Z' = 0. He radios back to A, `Danger! Radioactive debris at position (1, 3, 0) because of explosion at time t' = 5' (in this example, units are assumed to be years
and light-years). Standard coordinates are based on A's position and motion. What coordinates should A assign to this event when broadcasting a warning to other spacecraft?
128
The Lorentz transformation and the invariant interval
In this case, V = 5 and so, by (4.4), ly = -y(45) = {1 - (5)2} 4 = 3; thus eqns (4.3) become
t= (5+Ax 1) 3
=3x 59
5
39
x-3(1+5x5) =3x5= 35,
y=3, z=0. Thus the coordinates A finds for the event P are (xa) = (3 , 3, 3, 0). i.e. t = X = 35, Y = 3, Z = 0. In brief we can write this as, (Xa')
= (5, 1, 3, 0) = (Xa) = (3 , 3 , 3, 0)
,
3
(*)
showing the different coordinates allocated by the two observers to the explosion at this event.
The inverse transformation Relations (4.2, 3) are completely reciprocal (as are all relativity formulae); that is, the transformation from A's coordinates to B's also has the form (4.3). In fact, one can solve eqns (4.3) for t' and x', finding
t' = ry(v)(t - vx/c2), x' = y(v) (x - Vt), Y' = y,
z' = Z.
(4.5a) (4.5b)
(4.5c)
As an example, suppose the coordinates A finds for an event P are (Xa) = (3 , 3 , 3, 0). i.e. t = 39, X = 3 , Y = 3, Z = 0, and the speed of motion of B relative to A is v = 5 c (so V = 5). Then use of (4.5) will show (just as in the above example) that observer B measures the coordinates of the event P to be (Xa)
(5, 1, 3, 0), that is, t' = 5, X' = 1, Y' = 3, Z' = 0. In brief, we can write this as
(xa) _ 39' 3 , 31 0)
(xa')) = (5, 1, 3, 0),
(**)
showing the different coordinates allocated by the two observers to the same event P. This result is of course just the inverse of (*) above, as it must be because (4.5) is the inverse of (4.3).
Equations (4.5) are identical in form to (4.3) except for the minus sign preceding v. The reason for the sign is as follows: according to A, the origin of B's reference frame (the point X' = Y' = Z' = 0) moves in the positive x-direction at a speed v; according to B, the origin of A's reference frame (the point X = Y = Z = 0) moves in the negative x'-direction at the same speed. The Lorentz transformation formulae (4.3, 5) are valid when A and B are approaching each other for t, t' < 0 and receding from each other for t, t' > 0, i.e. when B moves in the +x-direction as measured by A. However, we would find the opposite sign for v if we calculated the result for B moving in the negative x-direction relative to A.
The Lorentz transformation
4.1
129
Therefore, the convention for the sign of v implied in the Lorentz transformation formula is that v will be positive when the relative motion is in the +x-direction and negative when it is in the -x-direction. Given this understanding (which is different from that implied in the K-factor formulae above in Sections 3.1 and 3.2), eqns (4.5) are precisely what we would expect to determine B's coordinates from those of A. This equivalence of the formulae is a direct consequence of the relativity principle (each observer is equivalent to the other, so there must be no essential difference in the transformation formulae between them).
Consequences of the Lorentz transformation The forward and inverse Lorentz transformation formulae (4.3, 5) for the relatively moving observers A and B determine each observer's coordinates for any
event from the other's coordinates for that event. They can be used to find relations between any space, time, or velocity measurements made by the observers. For example, as we shall see shortly, one can derive the length contraction, time dilation, relativity of simultaneity, and special-relativity velocity addition laws directly from these relations. We shall now explore briefly the main consequences of the Lorentz transformations. A: The Newtonian limit It is important to note that when the speeds involved are small compared to the speed of light and distances small relative to the times involved, the Lorentz transformation reduces to the usual Newtonian results. For example, if v = 300 km/sec (a very large speed by daily standards!) then
V = v/c = 300/300000 = 1/1000 so from (4.4), ry(v) = {1 - (1/1000)2}-12 = (1 10-6)-2 - 1+(1/2) 10-6 , a value extremely close to 1; so for most purposes we can accurately approximate 'yin (4.3) and (4.5) by 1. If, further, the distance x involved is less than 10 000 km, then x/c < 10 000 km/300 000 km/sec =
1/30 sec, so (v/c)(x/c) < (1/1000)(1/30) = 1/3 x
10_4
sec; so t - vx/c2
t if
t >> 10-4 sec. Thus, in these circumstances, all the characteristic relativity terms are so small that they can be ignored, and the transformation (4.3) becomes
t^-,t' x_x'+300t', y=y',
z=z',
where x is measured in kilometres and t in seconds. More generally, {w/c) << 1, Jx/cJ < t}
t',
t'r_-t,
y(v) ^_ 1
Y=Y',
z=z',
(4.6)
X1^_x-_Xy'=y, z'=z.
which are just the usual relations we intuitively understand through our experiences of everyday life, that have been formalized in Newtonian theory. Thus, the standard results of Newtonian theory will be valid when slow motion (i.e. speeds slow relative to the speed of light) takes place and the length scales involved are everyday lengths; relativistic effects will only show up when large velocities or light travel times are involved, but they will then be important. We now turn to these effects.
130
The Lorentz transformation and the invariant interval
B: Time dilation Firstly, consider the transformation for a point Q on B's world-line (x' = y' = z' = 0). Thus (see Fig. 4.3) we set x' = 0 in (4.2), finding t = 7y(v)t',
(4.7a)
x = ^y(v)vt' = Vt.
(4.7b)
The second result confirms that the quantity `v' is indeed the velocity measured for B in the +x-direction by A; and the first is the standard time-dilation effect (3.20) for B's clock as measured by A. For example, if v = c so that ^y = 5, then s is seen from (4.7a) a time of 5 years measured by B (t' = 5) along his world-line
to be equivalent to a time t = 3 x 5 = 35 years measured by A (using radar to determine simultaneity in B's history with events on his own world-line). Similarly, setting x = 0 in (4.5) will give the reciprocal results when B observes A.
B:x=o
A:X=o
(Eo)
t
X X
(c)
Fig. 4.3 (a) A point Q on B's world-line has coordinates (t, X) in A's frame and coordinates (t', 0) in B's frame; t and t' are related by the time dilation factor. (b) A point R on B's surface of events simultaneous with the origin 0 has coordinates (t, X) in A's frame and (0, X') in B's frame; X and X' are related by the length contraction factor. (c) For both
observers A and B, light rays have the same speed; according to A their equation is t = x/c = X, and according to B it is t' = x'/c = X'.
4.1
The Lorentz transformation
131
C: Length contraction and the relativity of simultaneity Secondly, consider the
transformation for a point R in the surface {t' = 0} defining simultaneity, as measured by B, with the event 0. Thus (see Fig. 4.3b) we set t' = 0 in (4.3), finding
x = -y(v)x',
(4.8a)
t = 7y(v)vx'/c2 = vx/c2.
(4.8b)
The first result relates the distance from 0 to R as measured by A to the same distance measured by B, and shows the standard length-contraction effect (3.23) for B moving past A. The second is the formula (3.17) giving A's coordinates for an arbitrary point R in B's surface of simultaneity with 0. For example, if v = c s so that ^y = 3a length of 1 light-year measured instantaneously by B (x' = 1) for an object at rest relative to him parallel to v will correspond by (4.8a) to a length of 3 x 1 = 3 light-years measured by A; also by (4.8b), A and B will disagree about
simultaneity over that distance by an amount (v/c)(x/c) = s x 1 = s years. Again the reciprocal results follow on setting t = 0 in (4.5).
D: Invariance of the speed of light Thirdly, both observers should agree about motion at the speed of light. We check this for light moving in the +x-direction by setting t' _ +x'/c in (4.3), finding x = 7y(v)x'(1 + v/c) and t = y(v)(x'/c)(1 + v/c) = x/c; thus
t' = +x'/c = t = +x/c,
(4.9a)
confirming that if B measures the speed of light in the +x-direction, then A agrees (Fig. 4.3c). For example, if v = c so that ^y = then, after 1 year, B will measure
light emitted at 0 (t' = 0, X' s= 0) to be at 3event P (t' = 1, X' = 1). A will determine the coordinates for event 0 to be It = 0, X = 0} and the coordinates for the event P to be {t = x 1 x 5= 3 years, X= 3 x 1 x 5= 3 light-years}, 3 confirming that A measures this light to be travelling at the speed c. Similarly,
t' = -x'/c = t = -x/c,
(4.9b)
showing that A agrees with B about the speed of light in the -x-direction. E. Relativistic velocity addition Fourthly, suppose a third observer C moves
past B at a speed v' in the +x'-direction (Fig. 4.4). Let C's coordinates (t", x", y", z ") be aligned in the standard way. Then (applying the results above for B observing C) B's coordinates are related to C's by
t' = 'y(v) (t" + v x"/c2),
(4. l Oa)
X, = -y(v') (x" + v t"), y/=Y11, z'=z",
(4.1Ob) (4.l Oc)
where
7(v') = {1 - (v )2/c2}-z.
(4.11)
132
The Lorentz transformation and the invariant interval Y
Y A
B
X
-
X,
B
C
X, V.
Fig. 4.4 Three observers in relative motion: A has coordinate system (t, X, Y, Z); observer B has coordinate system (t', X', Y, Z') and is moving at speed v relative to A in the X-direction; C has coordinates (t", X", Y", Z") and is moving with speed v' relative to B in the X'-direction (which is parallel to the X-direction).
Now, the relation between A's and C's coordinates should again be a Lorentz transformation of the form (4.3), because A and C are just two inertial observers whose coordinates are related in the standard way. Indeed this is so: one can substitute (4.10, 11) into (4.3, 5) and simplify, obtaining eventually (after some tedious algebra)
t = y(v")(t " + v'x "/c2), ) (xIt + v"t"), x = y(v
y' = y"
z' = z"
(4.12a) (4.12b) (4.12c)
where 'Y(v'")
= {1 - (v")2/c2}-z,
(4.13)
the quantity v" being defined by
v" = (v+v')/(1 +vv'/c2).
(4.14)
This indeed shows that measurements made by A and C are related in the standard way, with the relative velocity of A and C given by (4.14). Thus, we have confirmed that if A measures B to move at a speed v in the x-direction, and B measures C to move at a speed v' in the (parallel) x'-direction, then A measures C to move at a speed v" in the x-direction where v" is given by the special-relativity
velocity addition formula (3.15). For example, if v = c and v' = c, then s 5 1 + v'/c2 = 1 + 5 x 5 - 25 so v" = (5 + 5)c x 29 = 9 c (which is less than c, as required).
4.1
The Lorentz transformation
133
Reprise
We have now determined the Lorentz-transformation equations (4.3) and (4.5) relating the measurements made by two observers with different velocities in the x-direction, and verified that we can derive the standard kinematic results of special relativity from them, thus confirming that these formulae do indeed encapsulate in a compact form the kinematics of special relativity. In the next section we turn to looking for quantities invariant under Lorentz transformations; the present section concludes by giving a worked example of the use of the Lorentz transformation, and showing how these transformations may be viewed in an active sense rather than the passive sense used so far. This is useful later on in constructing simple universe models.
An example Suppose that a rocket of length 100 in travels horizontally above the ground at a speed of 107 m/sec. At a certain moment, a light signal is emitted from the front end of the rocket. Let us compare the times the signal takes to reach the tail end of the rocket according to (i) an observer travelling on the rocket, and (ii) a stationary observer on the ground. For the observer travelling in the rocket, the length of the rocket is of course 100 in. Thus (i) the time taken is this length divided by the speed of light, i.e. 100 m/(3 x 108 m/sec) = 0.33 x 10-6 sec. (ii) Suppose that in this observer's reference frame the light is emitted at event A with coordinates to = XA = 0, and received at event B with time tB as calculated above and distance XB = 100 m. Then, in the frame of the stationary observer, who moves with the relative speed v = 107 m/sec in the x-direction, eqn (4.5a) gives
V'/C')-
to = 0,
tg = Y(v)(tB - vxB/CZ) = (1 -
tB{(1 - v/c)/(1 + v/c)}z
tB{(1-30)/(1+so)1Z- 2309- tB-0.32x 10-6sec.
Notice that the result cannot be obtained naively from either the length contraction factor or the time dilation factor, because neither the length of the rocket nor the rate of a moving clock is directly at issue.
Active transformations So far, we have regarded the Lorentz transformation in a passive sense: it relates the reference frames of different observers, and so determines how their different coordinates for the same, event are related. However, it can also be regarded in an active sense. To see how this works, consider first an ordinary rotation of axes in Euclidean 2-space (Fig._ 4.5a). Changing from reference frame F (with coor-
dinates (x, y)) to reference frame F' (with coordinates (x', y')), we find the
wl trt
acs` a
X=const.
X'=const.
(a)
(b)
(c)
Fig. 4.5
(d)
(a) A rotation of axes in the Euclidean two-plane changes the coordinates (X, Y) of the point P to coordinates (X', Y'). This i9, a passive transformation: the points in the space remain fixed, but the reference frame changes. (b) In an active rotation, the point P moves with the axes and coordinates to a new point P. (c) The image point P' has the same coordinates relative to the new coordinate system, as the initial point P had relative to the old coordinates. (d) The movement of points in the Euclidean plane generated by an active rotation.
4.1
The Lorentz transformation
135
coordinates of the same point P in the two frames are related by
x' = xcos9+ysin9, y' = -xsin9+ycos9 (which is completely analogous to (4.5)). This is what we refer to as a passive transformation: each point in the space is simply being referred to in two different coordinate systems F and F', with F' related to F by a rotation. By contrast, in an active transformation the space as a whole rotates relative to the fixed coordinate axes of the initial frame F, the rotation of the reference frame F' dragging the points of the space with it, i.e. moving the points so as to preserve their coordinate values (Fig. 4.5b). For example the point P at {x = O, y = 11 is dragged along with the rotation of axes to the point P' given by {x' = 0, y' = 11, see Fig. 4.5c. Similarly, each point P is mapped by the transformation into the point P' which has the same coordinate values relative to the new frame as the old point had relative to the old frame. In precisely the same way, we can regard the Lorentz transformation as either a passive -or an active transformation. Previously we have regarded eqns (4.5) as representing a passive transformation (referring to the same fixed space-time points in two different coordinate systems). Now suppose we start with two reference frames A and B at rest with respect to each other, representing spacetime in terms of coordinates (t, x, y, z) and (t', x', y', z') respectively. Initially these coordinates are identical (t = t', x = x', y = y', z = z') because the frames are at rest with respect to each other. Now we set frame B in motion so that it is moving relative to frame A at a speed v in the +x direction; we may refer to this as giving the frame B a boost through +v. We regard space-time events as dragged
along with the frame B when we apply the boost (but the frame A as fixed, unaffected by it). Thus, the effect of the boost is to move each point P from an initial position given relative to both A's and B's frames by the coordinates (x', y', z', t'), to a final position given relative to B's frame by the same values (x', y', z', t') (see Fig. 4.6a). Relative to A's frame the final coordinates (t, x, y, z) will be determined from (t', x', y', z') through eqns (4.3). For example, the event Q' a unit time along B's time axis { t' = 1, x' = y' = z' = 0} is then found to have coordinates
t = y(v), x = vy(v), y = 0,
z=0
(4.15)
according to A (cf. eqn (4.7)). This event was initially a unit time along both
A's and B's axes. Thus, if we take the event Q at It = 1, x = y = z = 0} in A's frame and give it a boost through +v, it will end up at Q' with coordinates (4.15). By this construction, it is clear that length and time measurements are preserved under an active Lorentz transformation (e.g. a unit time measurement in B's frame remains a unit time measurement, as the boost is performed). From this viewpoint, this is in fact the defining property of Lorentz transformations, which move points in space-time as shown in Fig. 4.6b. If we keep on repeating the boost for a particular relative velocity v, we will
get an infinite series of frames each related to the previous one by (4.3),
136
The Lorentz transformation and the invariant interval to
(a)
(b)
Fig. 4.6 An active Lorentz transformation moving the points of two-dimensional flat space-time into each other. (a) The effect of a boost on specific points P, Q, R, moving each
point (t,X) into a new point with new coordinates t' = t, X' = X. (b) The pattern of motion generated by the boost (this is the exact analogue of Fig. 4.5d).
representing a relative velocity +v in the x-direction. If we sketch these frames in a single space-time diagram, the result is Fig. 4.7. We can regard this as showing how repeated application of a boost through +v will move the unit time vector of A's frame (i.e. the vector OT, where T has coordinates (1, 0, 0, 0) in A's frame) into a succession of vectors, each representing a unit time displacement for an observer moving relative to A. These unit time vectors each represent the relevant
observer measuring 1 unit of time from the space-time event O. Thus, these arrows all represent unit clock measurements made by observers moving at different velocities relative to A; and the surface they define is a surface at unit proper time from 0 (where this time is measured along the straight line from 0).
4.1
The Lorentz transformation
137
vectors at distance=+i O
X
Fig. 4.7 The effect of a repeated series of boosts on the unit time-like and space-like vectors along the axes of the reference frame of an observer A. The image vectors can be thought of as the unit time and space vectors along the axes of the reference frames of a series of relatively moving observers. They define the surfaces at unit time and unit spatial distance from the origin 0.
This surface enables one to compare the units of time on different lines through the origin representing the uniform motion of particles at different speeds, all passing 0 at time t = 0. Similarly, repeatedly boosting the displacement It = 0, x,= I, y = 0, z = 0} representing a unit spatial displacement will give a series of vectors representing instantaneous unit spatial measurements by this family of observers, defining a surface at unit spatial distance from 0 (measured along the straight line from 0). This surface enables one to compare the units of spatial distance along different space-like lines all passing through the origin. These two surfaces are the space-time equivalent of a unit circle in the Euclidean plane (since that is the surface at constant unit distance from the origin 0, measured ak g the straight line from 0; there is in that case no distinction between timelike and space-like curves or measurements). Figure 4.7 also displays how, as the relative velocity v tends towards c, the frames of the other observers (viewed from A) appear to collapse towards the light cone. This is a consequence of the limiting nature of the speed of light in special relativity. Exercises 4.1 Deduce explicitly transformation (**) following (4.5) from the general Lorentz transformation formula (4.5). 4.2 Consider two events A and B defined in some frame of reference by coordinates to = XA = YA = ZA = 0 and tB = 1, XB = 2c, yB = ZB = 0. What are their coordinates in a frame moving with speed c in the x direction relative to the first frame? What has a on transformation between the two frames? What aspect happened to their time ordering of the relationship between A and B makes this feature possible?
138
The Lorentz transformation and the invariant interval
4.3 Suppose that two events are connected by a time-like line in one reference frame. Show that their time order is the same in all reference frames. 4.4 A passenger on a train moving with speed v watches a girl stationary on the ground throw a ball at speed 2v at an angle of 60° to the horizontal, in the direction parallel to the train's motion. According to the girl the path of the ball is given by
x=vt, y=\/3vt-zgt2, where x and y measure horizontal and vertical distances. Find the path according to the passenger on the train. 4.5 A spaceship with a top speed of c pursues one with a top speed of c. An observer s light-year apart. How much later, on a nearby planet observes them to be one s according to the observer on the planet, will the slower one be caught? What will this time difference be (i) according to an observer on the slower spaceship, (ii) according to an observer on the faster ship? 4.6 Apply a boost with parameter v to the following events described by their (t, X) coordinates: (a) (-1,2), (b) (0,V3), (c) (1, 2), (d) (e) (1,1), (f) (2,-1), (g) (,/3, 0), (h) (2, 1). Plot the old and new points on a space-time diagram for v = 5c/13, and draw in what lines of constant distance from the origin are needed to show the effect of the boost on these points. 4.7/ The group property [this example presumes you know the mathematical definition of a group]. Show that a combination of any number of Lorentz transformations of the standard form (with parallel velocities) will lead to a final Lorentz transformation of the same form, for some appropriate velocity. Consider, for example, a family of observers A1, A2, A3, ..., each moving at the speed v relative to the previous member of the family (A2 moves at a speed v relative to A1; A3 moves at a speed v relative to A2; and so on). The resulting series of coordinate axes are shown in Fig. 4.7. This shows the unit time-like vectors (from the origin {t = 0, x = Of to the point {t = 1, x = Of on each observer's
world-line) and space-like vectors (from the origin {t = 0, x = 0}) to the point
{ t = 0, x/c = 11 in each rest frame) for this family of observers, as seen from A's reference frame. Then every pair of reference frames in this family is related by a Lorentz transformation of the form given in eqn (4.3), with v replaced by the relevant value for the relative velocity (derived by repeating the relativity velocity addition law the appropriate number of times). The identity transformation is a Lorentz transformation (put v = 0 in (4.3)), and the inverse transformation to any Lorentz transformation is also a Lorentz transformation (in fact (4.5) is the inverse of (4.3)). Prove that, together with the composition property discussed above, the (t, x) Lorentz transformation form a group of transformations. Computer Exercise 12 Write a program that will accept as input (a) a speed V(= v/c), (b) coordinates (t, x, y, z) of a point P measured by an observer A, and will print as output coordinates (t', x', y', z') of P measured by an observer B, given by the Lorentz-transformation equations (4.5). Make sure that your program allows repeated Lorentz transformations, i.e. having made one transformation, unless new data is fed in the output of the previous transformation is automatically the input for the next one. Get your program (c) to print out additionally the result of the Newtonian transformations (4.6), and so experiment to see when these are a good approximation to the Lorentz transformation; (d) to print out the quantity Q = -t2 + X2 + Y2 + Z2. What is the change in this quantity each time you perform a Lorentz transformation?
4.2
Space-time separation invariants
139
Computer Graphics Exercise 2 Write a program that draws a set of axes (t, X), and then shows the effect on a space-time diagram of moving a chosen point P with coordinates (t, X) to the point P' with coordinates (t', X') given by the Lorentz-transformation formula (4.5) for a specified speed V(= v/c) [arrange for an arrow to be drawn on the screen from P to the new point P'; this exercise regards the Lorentz transformation as an active transformation, but you may use the program from Computer exercise 12 to perform your calculations]. Try the effect of repeated transformations on the points (1) t = 1, X = 0; (2) t = 1, X = 1; (3) t = 0, X = 1;
(4) t = -1, X = -1.
Modify the program (a) to show the effect of the transformation in moving several chosen points simultaneously; (b) to show its effect on a line through the origin, as follows: given a specification of a point Q, (i) draw the straight line through the origin 0 (t = 0, X = 0) and Q; (ii) mark off on this line the series of points Q; where Q1 is Q, the point Q2 is twice as far from 0 along the line as Q, the point Q3 is three times as far from 0 along this
line, etc., until the edge of your diagram has been reached; (ii) show the effect of the transformation on all of the points Q;, and draw the new straight line through the origin that they move into. Try this program on the set of points (1)-(4) listed above.
Appendix: geometric proof of congruence of triangles in Fig. 4.2 By construction, OFEJ is a parallelogram and so OJ = FE. The angles HOJ and COF are equal (see Section 3.3). Angles KEJ and COF are equal (the parallel lines JE and OF are at the same angle to the horizontal). Similarly angles HOJ and GEF are equal (the parallel lines OJ and FE are at the same angles to the vertical). Angles OHJ, JKE, EGF and OCF are all right angles by construction. Therefore, triangles OCF and EKJ are congruent (with equal sides OF and JE and two pairs of equal angles COF and KEJ, and OCF and EKJ). Similarly, triangles OHJ and EGF are congruent (with equal sides OJ and FE, and two pairs of equal angles HOJ and GEF, and OHJ and EGF).
4.2
Space-time separation invariants
We have seen that many features of space-time, which we previously took for granted to be unchanging, in fact change according to the relative motion of observers. It would be very useful if we could find quantities that are invariant, i.e. independent of the reference frame chosen. Then all observers will agree on their values, so communication will be simpler, and physical laws may be expected to take a simpler form, if expressed in terms of such invariants. Their independence
of the state of motion implies that such quantities are of particular physical or geometrical significance: they reflect some deeper underlying structure, which is independent of the reference frame or coordinate systems used to describe it. A simple example to keep in mind is that of rotations in Euclidean space. When different axes are used, different coordinates (x, y) are assigned to the same point (Fig. 4.5a). However, the distance d from the origin, defined by d = (x2 + y2)2 , is calculated to be the same no matter what coordinates are used, since it is invariant under rotations of the (x, y) axes. Thus, it is very useful to be able to talk about the
140
The Lorentz transformation and the invariant interval
distance between two points, because this is an invariant quantity: all observers agree about its value no matter what choice of coordinates they have made, and so it is appropriate to characterize the geometry of Euclidean space in terms of distances between points. We seek analogous quantities in space-time. We shall consider here three invariants related to distance and time measurements in flat space-time: the functions S2 and OS2, and the infinitesimal ds2.
Although the argument is sometimes an involved one, it is worth following through, because it provides the basis for understanding the invariant interval of curved space-times which we consider in the following chapter. These quantities characterize how clock measurements behave and how light travels in spacetime, and so also determine instantaneity and spatial distance measurements. The invariant S2 characterizes these properties relative to the origin in flat spacetime, while OS2 characterizes them for any two points in flat space-time. By contrast, ds2 determines these properties for any two neighbouring points in
space-time; the properties of curved spaces and space-times are built up by knowing the local distances between any pair of neighbouring points in the space, and this is described by ds2.
The space-time invariant S2 We have already seen that the speed of light is an invariant. Other invariants may be built up from entities which by themselves change from frame to frame, but are combined in such a way that the resulting quantity is unchanging. An important example is the quantity S2, defined in terms of the coordinates (t, X, Y, Z) of an
observer A, where X= x/c, Y = y/c, Z = z/c, by
S2=-t2+x2+Y2+Z2.
(4.16)
(It is important to note here that although this is written, for historical reasons, as `S squared', it is not necessarily positive. This will become clear in the following discussion.) When an observer B using coordinates (t', X', Y, Z') evaluates this quantity, by its definition (4.16) he will evaluate Si2 = -ti2 + X12 + Y12 + Zi2.
(4.17)
Suppose B moves at a speed v relative to A in the +x-direction. Using the relation (4.5), he finds
Si2 = -{'y(v)(t
- Vx)}2 +
{'y(v)(X - Vt)}2 + Y2 + z2.
where we have set V = v/c. On multiplying out and using the expression (4.4) for 'y, this becomes
si2 = {-t2(l
- V2) +x2(1 - V2)}/(l - V2) + Y2+Z2.
On cancelling the factor 1 - V2, we find that s2
=
S2;
(4.18)
4.2
Space-time separation invariants
141
that is, both observers obtain the same value for this expression (whatever their speed of relative motion). Thus S2 an invariant under change of velocity in the X-direction. It is also invariant under any spatial rotation of the X, Y, Z axes, because t and X2 + Y2 + Z2 are separately invariant under such rotations. It is therefore invariant under any velocity change whatever (a spatial rotation can
bring any change of velocity to a change of velocity in the x-direction); so S2is an invariant-it will be found to have the same value by all inertial observers.
As an example, suppose in A's coordinate system an event P is given by =-(39)2+(35)2+32+02=-$91+695+9=-15. (Xa)=(39, 35, 3, 0); then S2 Now if B moves relative to A at a speed v = s c, then B's coordinates for the event P will be (x°') = (5, 1, 3, 0) see eqn (**) in the previous section). Thus the value of S2 calculated by B is S'2 = -(5)2 + (1)2 + (3) + (0)2 = -25 + 1 + 9 = -15, the same value as before, confirming that S2 is an invariant in this particular case. When we remember that many other quantities we previously believed to be invariant have turned out not to be so, it is clear that this quantity must have some special meaning. What is the meaning? It is just `the square of the space-time
distance' from the origin 0 with coordinates (0, 0, 0, 0) to the point P with coordinates (t, X, Y, Z). Thus it is a natural generalization to the space-time situation of r 2 - x2 + y2 + z2, the square of the spatial distance from the origin 0 with coordinates (0, 0, 0) to the point P with coordinates (x, y, z) in Euclidean three-dimensional space. However, there is an important difference: r2 is nonnegative: r2 > 0, but because of the minus sign in (4.16), S2 may take negative, positive, or zero values, with slightly different interpretations in each case. We shall consider them in turn. In examining these meanings, it is convenient to rewrite (4.16) in the form S2
= -t2 + R2,
(4.19)
where R2 = X2 + Y2 + Z2 is the square of the spatial distance from 0 to P measured by A, in units such that the speed of light is 1 (and so is non-negative: R2 > 0). We define V = R/t, the measured speed of motion of an object moving on the straight line from 0 to P.
Negative values of S2 Suppose that S2 < 0. Then there is some positive real number T such that S2 = -T 2. Consider the set of points seen by an observer A to be given by t > 0 and S2 = - T2 (Fig. 4.8a). Choose any point P on this surface. By eqn (4.19), A finds the time t and distance R of P from 0 to be related by
S2<0
R2
V2=(R/t)2<1;
that is, the straight line OP from 0 to P represents motion at less than the speed of light relative to A. Therefore OP can be the world-line of an observer B moving inertially between 0 and P. If we change to B's coordinates (t', X', Y', Z'), this world-line will be given by (X' = Y' = Z' = 0), so P will be given by the coordinates (t', 0, 0, 0) for some time t'; 0 will again have coordinates (0, 0, 0, 0) (Fig. 4.8b). In this frame, S2 will take the value S42
= -t12 + 0 + 0 + 0 = -t12,
(4.20a)
142
The Lorentz transformation and the invariant interval
(a)
(b)
Fig. 4.8
(a) The set of points seen by an observer A to satisfy S2 = -T2. An observer B moving relative to A measures the time from the origin 0 to this surface to be T.
(b) The same situation drawn from the viewpoint of observer B.
from (4.17). But S2 is an invariant, so
Si2=S2=-T2.
(4.20b)
Equations (4.20) show that t' = T (time goes the same way for A and B, so we reject the alternative solution t' = -T). That is, in terms of his standard coordinates (t', X', Y', Z'), B will assign coordinates (T, 0, 0, 0) to P. But this means that he will measure a time Tfrom 0 to P, using a standard ideal clock (since this is just the meaning of the coordinate t). This will of course also be true in Fig. 4.8a, which represents the identical space-time situation. Hence, each point P on the surface S2 = -T2 will be found to be a time T away from the origin 0 by an observer moving inertially from 0 to P. This is thus the set of points in space-time at proper time T from 0 (to the future of 0), as measured by inertial observers. Similarly if t < 0 we find the surfaces at proper time T from 0 to the past. With this understanding, it is easy to use this invariant to work out proper-time
measurements made by inertial observers. For example, consider the point P measured by A to be at {t = 5 sec, X = 3 light-sec, Y= Z = 0}. Then he calculates S2 = -52 + 32 = -25 + 9 = -16 = -42, so P lies in the surface `proper time = 4 seconds' to the future of 0. Thus, an observer B moving from 0 to P will move in
the +x-direction at speed v/c = V = X/t = s relative to A and will measure a proper time of 4 seconds from 0 to P. A particular case of significance is when T = 1; we obtain then the surface S2 = -1, representing unit proper time from 0. This surface provides the information we have needed all along but lacked in order to compare proper times measured along different world-lines: where each world-line intersects this surface establishes a unit time interval along that world-line, from which all other
4.2
Space-time separation invariants
143
time measurements along that world-line are obtained by simple scaling (two time units will be twice as far from 0 along the line, and so on; see Fig. 4.9). Thus, this surface calibrates the way time is measured along different inertial world-lines through 0 (which is not immediately obvious from the relative distances on the diagram, as has been emphasized all along). We can thus categorize the surfaces {S2 = constant < 0} as `1 second', `2 seconds', etc., representing graphically the relation between proper times along the different world-lines. The invariant S2 also helps interpret the meaning of Fig. 4.7: if a series of boosts is applied to the unit time-vector in any observer's reference frame, it will remain a unit vector and so will always join the origin 0 to a point Pin the surface S2 = -1; indeed all the arrows in Fig. 4.7 do lie in such a surface (cf. Fig. 4.9). Similarly, it allows us to see easily what event in A's history corresponds to the time t' measured by a moving observer B, so providing the last bit of information missing in our discussion of time dilation (Fig. 4.10). In particular this makes clear that a given proper time along the stationary observer's axis will be represented in these diagrams by a longer distance along the moving observer's world-line.
"two seconds"
Fig. 4.9
Surfaces in space-time at one unit and two units of proper time from the origin.
To find what event in A's history corresponds to the time is in B's history, we draw the surface S2 = -t'2.Observer B's world-line intersects this at the event P, which is at the time t in A's frame. Fig. 4.10
144
The Lorentz transformation and the invariant interval
(a)
(b)
Fig. 4.11 (a) The set of events seen by observer A to satisfy S2 = Dz. An observer B moving relative to A measures the event Q, simultaneous with the origin 0 in his reference frame, to be at a distance D from 0. (b) The same situation redrawn in the reference frame of observer B.
Positive values of S2 Suppose S2 > 0. Then there is some positive real number D such that S2 = D2. Consider the set of points given by S2 = D2 viewed from the frame of an observer A (Fig. 4.11 a), and any event Q on this surface. Then there is a straight line from the origin 0 to Q; we rotate the spatial axes so that y and z are
constant along this line, i.e. so that its spatial direction is the x-direction. By eqn (4.19), A finds the time t and distance R of Q from 0 to be related by S2
>0
?
R2 > t2
?
V2 = (R/t)2 > 1;
that is, the straight line OQ from 0 to Q represents motion at greater than the speed of light relative to A. Therefore OQ cannot be the world-line of any observer B moving inertially between 0 and Q. In the (t, X) plane, this line will make some angle a with the horizontal axis (Fig. 4.11 a); the line at the angle a from the vertical axis towards Q is then the world-line of an observer B for whom
the events 0 and Q are simultaneous, i.e. the line OQ lies in his surface of instantaneity. Change to B's frame of reference by a suitable Lorentz transformation; then the events 0 and Q will both lie in his surface of instantaneity ft, = 0} (Fig. 4.11 b). His coordinates (t', X', Y', Z') for Q will then be (0, X', 0, 0). Evaluating S12 for this point shows Si2 = X12 But, since this is an invariant, S12 = S2 = D2; so X' = D. This means that B measures Q to be a distance D from O (at the instant t' = 0). This is also true in Fig. 4.11 a, which just represents the same set of events in a different reference frame; thus every point in the surface S2 = D2 is at a distance D from 0 when measured by any observer for whom this displacement is instantaneous. We can therefore characterize these surfaces as lying at `1 light-second', `2 light-seconds', etc., distance from O. As an example, consider A to measure the event Q to be at { t = 3 sec, X = 5 light-sec, Y= Z = 0}. Then S2 = -32 + 52 = -9 + 25 = 16 = 42; so Q lies in .
4.2
Fig. 4.12
Space-time separation invariants
145
Surfaces at one unit and two units of spatial distance from the origin 0.
the surface `4 light-seconds distant from 0'. An observer B moving at V = v/c = s in +x direction will measure 0 and Q to be simultaneous and separated by a spatial distance of 4 light-seconds. Again, the surface S2 = 1 at unit spatial distance has special significance, for this gives the scaling of distances along different surfaces of instantaneity in a space-time diagram by setting the unit distance scale along each of these spatial
sections (Fig. 4.12). The invariance of unit spatial vectors under boosts is apparent in Fig. 4.7, because when any one such vector undergoes a Lorentz transformation it remains in the surface {S2 = constant} in which it lay initially. This invariant also provides the last piece of information we need to understand completely the length-contraction effect, for it shows what length is measured by the stationary observer A to be the same as the `contracted' length measured by a moving observer B (Fig. 4.13).
Vanishing values of S2 Suppose now S2 = 0. Let L be any point on this surface. By eqn (4.19), A finds the time t and distance R of L from 0 to be
related by
52=0
R2=t2
V2=(RIt)2=1;
that is, the straight line OL from 0 to L represents motion at the speed of light relative to A. Thus this surface is just the light cone measured by A for the event 0. Since S2 invariant, any other observer B will also find Sr2 = 0: this set of events
will also be the light cone he determines for the event O. That is, invariance of S2 = 0 for different observers is just Einstein's principle of the invariance of the speed of light for all observers.
146
The Lorentz transformation and the invariant interval
Fig. 4.13 A rigid rod, stationary relative to the observer A, has end-points u and w. It is measured by the relatively moving observer B to have a length X'. To find the length the observer A will measure for the rod, we draw the surface S2 = Xi2. This intersects B's surface of simultaneity through 0 at Q, which is a distance X from the origin in A's reference frame. Therefore A measures the length of the rod to be X.
Fig. 4.14 The surfaces {S2 = constant} at constant space-time distance from the origin 0
drawn in a space-time diagram. The surfaces S2 = 0 are the light cone of the origin.
Summary All observers will agree on the value of the invariant S2. The surfaces S2 = constant are drawn in Fig. 4.14; they represent proper times from 0 (when S2 is negative), instantaneous spatial distances from 0 (when S2 is positive), and the light cone C+(0) of 0 (when S2 zero). It is convenient to
4.2
Space-time separation invariants
147
refer to the latter as being at zero (space-time) distance from 0, for the following reason. Taking the limit as a point Q approaches C+(O), Q is simultaneous with 0 and the spatial distance OQ goes to zero (if approached from the region where S2 > 0) or the measured proper time OQ goes to zero (if
approached from the region where S2 < 0). One can use this invariant to compare easily the spatial distance and proper time measurements made by different inertial observers who pass through the event O. Exercises 4.8 Calculate explicitly the quantity S2 for the cases (a) t = 4, X = 2, Y = 3, Z = 0; (b) t = 2, X = 4, Y = 0, Z = 5; (c) t = 5, X = 3, Y = 0, Z = 4. In each case interpret your results in terms of the relation between the origin of coordinates 0 and the point P with the stated coordinates. Use equations (4.5) to prove explicitly the invariance of S2 in these cases if v/c = 2. 4.9 If the light cone is projected into the (t, X) plane by setting y = Z = 0, S2 = 0 becomes t2 - X2 = 0. Deduce that the solution is t = ±X. Show explicitly that these rays are invariant under (4.5). 4.10 Suppose that a light signal is emitted at the space-time event 0 (t = 0, X = 0) and absorbed at the space-time event B (t = 1, X = 1). Is S2 zero for B? Suppose now the light is reflected by a mirror at B and absorbed when at the event C (t = 2, X = 0). Is S2 zero for C? 4.11 Consider again the discussion of muon decay in Section 3.6. Calculate from quantities given in the Earth's frame the proper time taken by the muons to move through the Earth's atmosphere. Use this time to predict the fraction of muons surviving at sea level.
The invariant OS2 We have seen that the invariant S2 determines surfaces in space time `at constant distance' from the point 0 with coordinates (0, 0, 0, 0), thereby determining clock measurements on inertial paths through 0, spatial measurements on surfaces of
simultaneity, and the directions of light rays from that event. Can we find a similar invariant telling us about such measurements based on an arbitrary space-time point Q? An example will be useful in suggesting the way to go. Suppose that scout ships
have established that a star exploded in a massive supernova explosion at the event Q given in standard galactic coordinates by (xQ) _ (2, 3, 1, 0) and that dinosaurs became extinct in a catastrophic event P on a planet of a nearby star, the coordinates of P being (4P) = (3, 1, 2, 0). The question is: could the supernova
explosion possibly have been responsible for the extinction of the dinosaurs? A way to arrive at the answer is to notice that the displacement from Q to P (Fig. 4.15) has coordinates (ya) _ (3 - 2, 1 - 3,2 - 1, 0 - 0) = (1, -2, 1, 0), i.e. these are the components of the position of P relative to Q. Thus, if we regard Q as the origin of coordinates, we can work out the corresponding invariant OS2 for
this displacement by using eqn (4.16) but with the left-hand side being now denoted OS2 (which just stands for the interval based on Q rather than 0) and the
148
The Lorentz transformation and the invariant interval
Fig. 4.15 A supernova explosion occurred at event Q and dinosaurs became extinct on a neighbouring planet at event P. The time coordinates t of these events differ by At, and the spatial coordinates X by X.
right-hand side evaluated for the displacement components (1, -2, 1, 0) from Q to P. Explicitly,
AS2=-12+(-2)2+12+02=-1+4+1 =+4. Because this is positive, the displacement from Q to P is space-like (it represents a spatial distance of 2 light-years); therefore no causal effect spreading from Q, travelling at less than or at the speed of light, could influence what happened at P. The extinction of the dinosaurs was not caused by the supernova explosion. This example makes clear that it is useful focusing on the displacement from Q to P (with components (y°) in the above example). To consider this more generally, consider two points P and Q in space-time, to whom an inertial observer A assigns coordinates (tp, Xp, Yp, Zp) and (tQ, XQ, YQ, ZQ) (as in Fig. 4.15). When we make a Lorentz transformation (4.2) to the frame of a second observer B, these points will then be assigned coordinates (t', XP, YP, Z p) and (t6, XQ, Y'' , ZQ) respectively. It is straightforward to work out how the displacement from Q to P behaves; the result is (4.21c), leading to the invariant distance between these points (4.22). The details are as follows. The old and new coordinates of P are related by
tp ='y(v)(tP + VXX),
Yp = Y'p,
XP ='y(v)(XX + Vt.),
ZP = ZP,
tQ ='y(v)(t' + VXQ),
YQ = YQ
XQ = ry(v)(XQ + Vt6),
ZQ = Z.
and those of Q by
Subtracting these equations shows that
tp-tQ=ry(V){(tP-tQ)+V(XP-XQ)},
YP - YQ= YP - YQ,
XP -XQ=y(v){(xx-xQ)+V(t' -t6)}, Zp-ZQ=ZP -ZQ.
4.2
Space-time separation invariants
149
This is somewhat clumsy to deal with, so we use the notation that 0 represents the change in a quantity between Q and P. Then
At=tp-tQ, OX-XP-XQ, DY-YP-YQ, OZ=ZP-ZQ, (4.21 a)
Ot'=tP-t6, OX'=XP-XQ,
AY'
YP - YQ,
OZ'ZP-ZQ, (4.21b)
are the changes in the coordinates (t, X, Y, Z) and (t', X', Y', Z') between Q and P; and we find finally
Ot = ry(v)(Ot' + VOX'), AY=Ay" OX = ry(v)(OX' + VOt'),
OZ = OZ'.
(4.21c)
This again has exactly the Lorentz-transformation form (4.2), but with X replaced by OX, etc. Now given the definition (4.16), the invariance result (4.18) was a direct result of (4.2). In exactly the same way, define OS2
_(At)2 + (OX )2 + (A y)2 + (OZ)2
(4.22)
Then it follows from (4.21c) that this is an invariant: for any change of reference frame, OS'2 = OS2.
(4.23)
What this result shows is that the space-time distance of the point P from the point Q, is invariant. Thus, just as before, we can draw surfaces of constant distance about the point Q, which is an arbitrary point in the space-time, and interpret the result exactly as before except with 0 replaced by Q (see Fig. 4.16a). Specifically, if OS2 < 0, then the displacement QP represents motion at less than the speed of light, and so is a possible history of a massive particle or observer (Fig. 4.16b); we shall then call it time-like. If OS2 = 0, it represents motion at the speed of light, and so is a possible path of a zero-rest-mass particle (e.g. a photon); we. shall then
call it null or light-like. If OS2 > 0, it cannot represent motion of any particle, since it would be motion at greater than the speed of light; rather, it represents an instantaneous spatial displacement for some observer. We then call it space-like. These are a more general form of the previous results; in fact, the previous calculations will follow on choosing Q to be 0 (with coordinates (0, 0, 0, 0)) here, cf. Example 4.12.
The new formulation has several advantages. One is that it is clear that expression (4.22) is invariant not only under boosts and rotations of the axes, but also under translations: that is if we change the origin of coordinates, setting
t'=t+to, X'=X+Xo, Y'=Y+Yo, Z'=Z+Zo, for some choice of constants to, Xo, Yo, Zo, the values (4.21 a,b) will be unchanged
and so will the value (4.22). Thus the quantity OS2, the space-time separation
150
The Lorentz transformation and the invariant interval
(a)
(b)
Fig. 4.16 (a) The surfaces JAS' = constant} representing constant space-time distance from the event Q. (b) Time-like displacements from Q (possible world-lines of observers or massive particles) are those for which A S2 < 0; null displacements (representing motion at the speed of light) are those for which A S2 = 0; and space-like displacements those for
which / S2 > 0.
between Q and P, is invariant under translations, boosts, and rotations. It enables us to work out the spatial or time differences measured by any inertial observer between any two points in the space-time from measurements made in A's frame,
without having to make an explicit change of coordinates to that observer's frame. As an example, suppose that a particle B passes through the event Q with
4.2
(a)
Space-time separation invariants
151
(b)
(a) In a flat space-time given in standard coordinates, the light cones at each point are parallel to each other. (b) The future of a point Q which lies on the future null cone C+(P) of a point P, lies in the future of P; the null cones of Q are tangent to the null cone of P. Fig. 4.17
coordinates measured by A (in units of seconds) to be (5, 1, 1, 1) and then through
the event P with coordinates (7,2,2,2); what time interval does B measure
between these events? We find immediately that At = 7 - 5 = 2, AX =
AY=AZ=2-1=1;thus zS2=-4+1+1+1=-1=-12.Hence this is
indeed a possible particle path (since the result is negative) and the time measured between Q and P by the particle is 1 second. Also, the quantity AS2 enables us to
characterize the speed of light at any event Q by determining those events P around Q for which AS2 = 0. If we do this for many different choices of Q, we can see how the light cones at these different points relate to each other; in the case of the flat space-time of special relativity which we are examining at present, these light cones are parallel to each other (Fig. 4.17a).
Exercises 4.12 We are free to choose any point in space-time as the origin 0 of our coordinates. Choose the origin as the point Q in the calculation above. Then (XQ) _ (0), i.e. tQ = XQ =
YQ = ZQ = 0 by definition. Verify that (XQ) = (0), i.e. tQ = XQ = YQ = ZQ = 0, and that therefore the calculation above leading to (4.23) reduces precisely to the previous calculation leading to (4.18). Deduce that all the results following (4.18) for positive, negative, and zero values of S2, understood as a measure of separation from 0, also hold for / S2 understood as a measure of separation from Q. 4.13 The light cone C+(P) of an event P is generated by the light rays through P. Show that the light cones of each point Q on these light rays are tangent to C+ (P) (Fig. 4.17b) by deducing (a) that the interior of C+ (Q) lies in the interior of C+ (P); (b) that the interior of
C-(Q) lies outside C+ (P); and (c) that the light cones C+ (Q), C-(Q) intersect C+ (P)
152
The Lorentz transformation and the invariant interval
precisely in the light ray from P through Q. [It will be important later that these features remain true in curved space-times.]
The metric form So far, we have determined the invariant AS2 for the straight line in space-time between any points Q and P. We now wish to generalize our results to any path from Q to P, so that we can for example determine the time measured between events Q, P by an arbitrarily accelerating observer. We generalize our results by first considering a piecewise straight path from Q to P, and then a general curved path between them. Consider a path in space-time made up of connected straight line segments (Fig. 4.18a). We will assume that all these segments are time-like, i.e. AS2 < 0.
Then they each represent possible inertial (i.e. unaccelerated) motion of an observer or particle, so the whole path represents the history of an observer who moves inertially except for a finite number of times when he suddenly accelerates to a different velocity (e.g. by firing a very powerful rocket). On each inertial segment the proper time OT measured by the observer is AT = (-OS2)z, where OS2 is given by (4.22). In the idealization which we are considering, no proper time elapses during the accelerations (which we regard as instantaneous). Thus the total proper time T measured to elapse along the path is T=
Y(-OS2)z =
(Ot2
- AX2 - AY2 - OZ2)1,
(4.24)
where the sign E represents summation of the expression over all the inertial segments (that is, the total proper time along the path is just obtained by adding up the proper times measured along each of these segments); here and in the sequel, 'Ot2' means (Ot)2, etc. This is clearly an invariant (since each term in the t
0
(a)
Fig. 4.18 (a) A time-like path made up of time-like straight (inertial) segments. (b) Paths made up of smaller and smaller straight (and therefore inertial) segments. (c) The limit of
these paths is a smooth time-like path.
4.2
Space-time separation invariants
153
sum is an invariant). As an example, consider again the motion of the twins discussed in the `twin paradox' (Section 3.4). Seen by A, twin B moves away for 10 years at a speed of c to a distance of 8 light-years, and returns in a further s on a broken geodesic where (t, X) goes from (0, 0) to 10 years. Thus she moves (10, 8) to (20, 0) (we ignore Y and Z, since they remain constant and so do not
contribute to OS2). On the first leg At = 10 - 0 = 10 and OX = 8 - 0 = 8. On the second leg At = 20 - 10 = 10 and OX = 0 - 8 = -8. Thus
T=(102-82)2+{102-(-8)2}2=(100-64)1+(100+64)1 _
(36)1 + (36)2 = 6 + 6 = 12
years, confirming our previous results. On the direct path between the initial and
final points travelled by A, we have At = 20 - 0 = 20 and OX = 0 - 0 = 0; so .T= (202 - 02)2 = 20, as expected. Expression (4.24) enables us to determine what clock measurements would be along any time-like path in space-time made up of a finite number of inertial
segments. However, general paths may have a direction that is continuously varying, and we wish to determine proper time along any feasible path of an observer. To do this, we consider piecewise inertial paths from Q to P with smaller and smaller inertial segments (Fig. 4.18b). In the limit as these segments shrink to
zero, we obtain a smooth time-like path C (Fig. 4.18c). As long as the limiting
value for OS2 remains negative for each segment as we take the limit, this represents a possible motion of an observer from Q to P, and the proper time T measured by an observer moving along the path is the limit of the expression (4.24). It is conventional to write this limit as a line integral: T = f(-ds2)1,
(4.25a)
ds2 - -d t2 + dX2 + dY2 + dZ2,
(4.25b)
ds2 = -d t2 + (dx2 + dye + dz2)/c2,
(4.25c)
where
or equivalently,
where'd t2, means (dt)2, etc. (It would be more in line with the notation we have used previously to write dS2 instead of ds2; however, it is an almost universal convention to use the notation ds2, so we shall do so here.) This is nothing other than a formalism for the limit of expression (4.24) as all the inertial segments are shrunk to indefinitely small lengths and the piecewise inertial path tends to the smooth world-line C. We may interpret this as representing the path C from Q to
P as made up of `infinitesimal' segments, each consisting of a displacement (dt, dX, d Y, dZ) from a point P, with coordinates (t, X, Y, Z) to a point Pj with coordinates (t + dt, X+ dX, Y+ d Y, Z + dZ) (Fig. 4.19), each of which (by 4.24) contributes a proper time dT = (-ds2)2 (given by (4.25b)) to the total time T.
154
The Lorentz transformation and the invariant interval
Fig. 4.19 Two points Pi and Pj on a smooth time-like curve, with coordinates differing by dt and dX.
(a)
Y
y=constant
0
rP x
x+dx
0 (b)
Fig. 4.20 (a) A curve C in the Euclidean two-plane between points P and Q. Neighbouring points have coordinates differing by dx and dy, and the distance between them can be found by Pythagoras' theorem. (b) A curve such that dy = 0 (that is, y = constant) has x as a curve parameter.
Then (4.25a) simply states that the total time measured along the path is the sum
of all these contributions (cf. Appendix A). Invariant expressions such as (4.25b,c) are known as metric forms or intervals.
The Euclidean two plane This concept is illustrated now by considering how one measures length along an arbitrary curve C in the ordinary Euclidean twoplane. First consider using standard Cartesian coordinates (x, y) (Fig. 4.20a).
4.2
Space-time separation invariants
155
This length can then be written as
L = f(ds2)2
(4.26a)
ds 2 = dx2 + dy2.
(4.26b)
where
(It is not appropriate to `take the square root' in (4.26a), as the entity in the bracket is really the full expression ds2 given by (4.26b).) Again we are regarding
the total length as made up of contributions from segments representing displacements from (x, y) to (x + dx, y + dy), of length (ds2)" where ds2 is given by (4.26b). This expression is a line integral evaluating the length of any curve in the plane (similarly, expression (4.25) is a line integral evaluating the proper time along any time-like path in space-time). Again it is an invariant agreed on by all observers (as each of the infinitesimal contributions ds2 is an invariant); in fact this is nothing other than repeatedly using Pythagoras' theorem (4.26b) applied to small line elements to estimate the length of the whole line.
Expression (4.26) tells us the length along any curve segment (dx, dy). In understanding its meaning, it is useful to consider first the specialization of this expression to curve segments on which only x or only y varies. Take the first case: if only x varies along the curve, then y is constant and so dy = 0 all along the curve (Fig. 4.20b). The expression (4.26) then reduces to
L = f(dx2 + 0)Z =
J
dx = xp - xQ;
that is, distance along this curve is simply measured by the change in the coordinate x, so (4.26) tells us that x is indeed a coordinate directly representing distance along the lines {y = constant}. Similarly, y is a coordinate directly representing distance along the lines {x = constant}. This will not be true for more general coordinates. As an example, change to plane polar coordinates (r, 0), where r is the distance from the origin and 0 is the angle from the x axis (Fig. 4.21). Now (4.26b) will be replaced by the expression ds2 = dr2 + r2 d02.
(4.27)
To see that this is correct, note that along the lines {r only varies} the coordinate 0 is constant; so dO = 0 along this line. Then (4.27) shows ds 2 = dr 2 + 0 = dr 2 ;
but this is the square of the distance travelled. Thus r directly measures distance along these curves (as required by its definition). On the other hand, along the curves {O only varies} the coordinate r is constant so dr = 0 along these curves.
156
The Lorentz transformation and the invariant interval Y
P
Fig. 4.21 The same curve as in Fig. 4.20(a) but now described by polar coordinates r and 0. The distance between neighbouring points is now given by Pythagoras' theorem from orthogonal displacements dr and dB, through distances dr and r dO respectively.
Then (4.27) shows
ds2=0+r2dB2=r2dB2; that is, distance along the curve element defined by dO is r dB, and, because r is constant and so is the same for all the curve elements, distance along the curve will be given by r(Op - OQ) rather than just Op - OQ. This is precisely in accord with
our usual understanding of the definition of an angle (measured in radians). Finally, for a general displacement, (4.27) says that the final result is given by Pythagoras' theorem from its components along the r and 0 directions. Clearly the total distance determined by this formula between two points P and Q along some curve from P to Q depends on the choice of this curve. Euclidean three-space As a further example, the geometry of Euclidean threespace is given in terms of Cartesian coordinates (x, y, z) by the expression ds 2 = dx2 + dye + dz2,
(4.28a)
generalizing (4.26b) in an obvious way to three dimensions. However, in many cases a geometrical or physical situation may display spherical symmetry, and so one may wish to use spherical polar coordinates instead (Fig. 4.22a). If we use such coordinates (r, 0, 0) instead of the coordinates (x, y, z), the corresponding expression describing the Euclidean geometry is ds2 = dr2 + r2(d02 + sin 2 0d02).
(4.28b)
One can read off directly from this form that (1) the coordinate r directly represents distance travelled along the curves {r only varies}, that is, the curves {0, 0 constant}; however, (2) a coordinate increment dO represents a distance r dO along the curves {O only varies}, that is, Jr, 0 constant}, and (3) a coordinate
4.2
Space-time separation invariants
157
rsined(p (a)
(b)
Fig. 4.22 (a) Spherical polar coordinates r, 0, and 0 in Euclidean three-space. Here r describes radial distance, 0 is the angle between the radial, direction and the z axis, and 0 describes rotation about this axis. (b) The distance between neighbouring points described in spherical polars is given by Pythagoras' theorem from orthogonal displacements dr, dB, and do through distances dr, r dB, and r sin 0 do respectively.
increment do represents a distance r sing do along the curves {q only varies}, that is, the curves {r, 0 constant}. This is indeed precisely the way distances relate to
standard polar coordinates (see Fig. 4.22b). Of course, the spatial geometries represented by (4.28a) and (4.28b) are the same-it is the coordinates use that differ.
The important point to notice here is that when general coordinates are used, they will not directly represent distances even along these coordinate curves, but the relation between a coordinate increment and the actual distance travelled can be read off from the interval (in this case, from (4.28b)). Distances travelled along any curves will be given by (4.26a). Actually working out these expressions in the case of a general curved line may be complex (but if it is a coordinate line, the expression can often be evaluated without trouble). More details on the concept of a line integral needed to evaluate these distances are given in Appendix A. Exercise 4.14 The circle C given by Jr = R = constant} passes through the point P at {r = R, 0 = 0} and the point Q at {r = R, 0 = 7r}. Show that (a) the straight line L from P to Q has length 2R, (b) the segment of C joining P to Q for 0 < B < 7r has length irR. [Apply (4.26a), (4.27) first to the straight line joining P and Q, and then to the curve r = R.] Deduce that this circle has radius R, diameter 2R, and circumference 27rR.
Space-time
These examples have simply considered Euclidean spaces, where ds2 > 0, described by different coordinate systems. In space-time, ds2 is not constrained to be > 0 because of the minus sign in (4.25b). As intimated above, it will in this
158
The Lorentz transformation and the invariant interval t (t+dt,x+dx) dt
(t,X)
0
X
dX
Fig. 4.23 Neighbouring points in a space-time diagram, with coordinates differing by dt and dX.
case represent in one quantity time measurements, spatial distance measurements, and the speed of light, according as ds2 is negative, positive, or zero for the displacement (dt, dX, d Y, dZ) considered (Fig. 4.23). In particular, when ds2 < 0, its magnitude is the square of proper time dr measured along that displacement: ds2 = -drZ. Equation (4.25a) now enables us to calculate proper time measured along any world-line in space-time (even if it is accelerated, i.e. represents non-inertial motion). As an example, on the curve {x = y = z = 0}, which is the world-line of the observer who set up the coordinates, the equations dx = dy = dz = 0 hold, so (4.25b) reduces to ds2 = -dt2, and (4.25a) shows that the coordinate t does indeed measure proper time along this particular world-
line. Further, when ds2 = 0 we have a displacement along the light cone, i.e. motion at the speed of light. Since all other kinematic quantities, e.g. spatial distances and K-factors, can be calculated from these basic elements, the form ds2 enables us to make all the basic space-time measurements we may wish. When standard coordinates are used, ds2 will be given by (4.25c), but if other coordinates are used it will be given by some other expression. For example, if we use spherical polar coordinates, the spatial part (4.28a) will be replaced by (4.28b). Then
ds2 = -dt2 + {dr2 + r2(d02 + sin 2 OdO2)}/c2
(4.29)
This enables us to work out measured time intervals along any world-line, in terms of these coordinates, from expression (4.25a). As in the spatial case, the time interval measured along a time-like curve from P to Q will depend on the choice of that curve, and this is the source of the `twin paradox'. As a final example of use of the form ds2, suppose observer A sees a particle move past at a speed v. Let n = (dt, dx, d Y, dZ) be a displacement along the particle world-line in standard rectangular coordinates (Fig. 4.24a). Then the corresponding proper time experienced by the particle is
dr = (-ds2)z = (dt2 - dX2 - dY2 - dZZ)z = (dt2 - drZ/c2)z = {l - (dr/dt)Z/c2}z dt
4.2
Space-time separation invariants
159
t
/particle
AI
(dt,dX)
N.- X
0
(b)
(a)
t
X (d)
(c)
Fig. 4.24 (a) A displacement (dt, dX) along the world-line of a particle moving at speed v relative to the observer A. The corresponding proper time d'r, measured by a clock moving
with the particle along this displacement, is related to dt by the time-dilation relation dt = y(v) dr, which shows dt > dr with dt = d-r if and only if v = 0. (b) Several piecewise inertial paths joining two time-like separated points P and Q. The longest time will be measured along the path A, the straight line path between them. (c) The same situation as seen by an observer B moving inertially between Q and P. Clearly (from (a)) proper time along each inertial segment on y and A' will correspond to a longer time as measured by B; thus proper time from Q to P along these paths will be less than along the single inertial path A. (d) Displacements ni and rte in space-time. Their scalar product is defined by eqn (4.31).
where dr 2 = dx2 + dye + dzZ = c2 (dX2 + d Y2 + dZ2) gives the spatial distance measured by A along n. Now v = (change of distance)/(change of time) = dr/dt, so
d,r = (1 - v2/c2)2 dt
dt = y(v) dr,
(4.30)
160
The Lorentz transformation and the invariant interval
and we have regained the time-dilation result (3.20) directly from ds2 (Strictly speaking, one should integrate this result up to determine relative clock measurements for finite time intervals along the world-lines, but the meaning of (4.30) in terms of `infinitesimal displacements' is quite clear.) Now consider two points P and Q whose separation is time-like. Let A be the time-like straight line j oining them and T be the proper time from P to Q measured by an observer whose world-line is A. From an examination of (4.24) and (4.30) it
then becomes clear that a shorter time will be measured by any observer whose history is any other piecewise straight line joining P and Q (cf. Fig. 4.24b). Taking the limit, as in (4.25), it becomes clear that a shorter time than T is measured along every other time-like line from P to Q. Thus the longest time between P and Q is measured by an observer who moves uniformly, that is, without acceleration, between P and Q (cf. the discussion of the `twin paradox' in Section 3.4 above). The space-time diagram from his viewpoint is shown in Fig. 4.24c.
The scalar product A generalization of the invariant metric form is the scalar product between two displacements. Let ill = (dtl, dXl, d Yl, dZl) and 112 = (dt2, dX2, d Y2, dZ2) be any two displacements (Fig. 4.24d). Their scalar product is then the quantity 111 '112 = -dtldt2 + dX1 dX2 + d Y1 d Y2 + dZ1 dZ2.
(4.31)
As in the case of ds2, this is easily seen to be an invariant by use of (4.21c); it generalizes ds2 because ds2 = ill . ill. However, it gives us further interesting information; for example, if an observer moves along a world-line segment characterized by the displacement ill, the displacement ill is instantaneous for him if and only if ill -ill = 0. This may easily be seen by choosing the rest frame of
the observer, so that ill = (dt1, 0, 0, 0); then this invariant relation becomes dtldt2 = 0 which implies dt2 = 0, so ill is indeed an instantaneous displacement (for that observer). By the same method it can be shown that if ill is time-like and rig time-like or null, then ill ill < 0. We have given the scalar product here only when standard (Minkowski) coordinates are used; the generalization to any coordinates is given in Appendix B.
Having defined the scalar product, we are now able to prove analytically the result of Exercise 4.13 as follows. Take a point T inside C+ (Q). The displacement PT equals PQ + QT. Then (PT)2
= (PQ + QT)2 = (PQ)2 + 2PQ QT + (QT)2
Now (PQ)2 is zero and PQ - QT and (QT)2 are both negative. Hence (PT)2 is negative and T lies inside C+ (P). Conclusion In this section, we have looked at the invariants related directly to measurements of time and distance in space-time. There are other important invariants we have
4.2
Space-time separation invariants
161
not considered here, related to energy, momentum, and the electromagnetic field;
they are most easily constructed by using the tensor formalism discussed in Appendix B. Some of those invariants are introduced there and in Appendix C. Exercises 4.15 (i) In the Euclidean two-plane, consider a path as shown in Fig. 4.25a, joining {x = 0, y = -a} and {x = 0, y = a} via the point {x = Aa, y = 0}. Find the length L (given by (4.26a)) of the path, and show that the shortest path (i.e. minimum value of L) corresponds to A = 0.
(ii) Now in a two-dimensional space-time consider a path as shown in Fig. 4.25b, joining {t = -a, x = 0} and { t = +a, x = 0} via the point (t = 0, x = Aa). Find the proper time -r (given by (4.25)) along the path, and show that the longest proper time (i.e. the maximum value of T) corresponds to A = 0. 4.16 Illustrate how you would use the metric form to determine the K-factor for two observers in relative motion by working through the following exercise. Suppose that the metric form in a two-dimensional space-time is
ds2 = -a2 dt2 + b2 dx2 where a and b are positive constants. Observer A is at rest at x = 0 and emits light signals at t = t1 and t = t2. Observer B moves at speed v relative to A passing him at t = 0. Calculate, (i) the equations of the light rays sent by A; (ii) the coordinates of the points where B receives the signals; (iii) the interval As1 between the emission events, and the interval Os2 between the reception events; (iv) the ratio K = Os2/Os1. 4.17 (a) Prove that the scalar product (4.31) is an invariant. (b) Suppose that an observer 0 determines both the displacements n1 and n2 to be instantaneous. Show that the scalar product (4.31) then reduces to the expression
n1'n2=dX1dX2+dY1dY2+dZ1dZ2 which determines both distances and angles in Euclidean space (e.g. if n1 n2 = 0 then the displacements are orthogonal to each other).
y y=a
y=-a (a)
(b)
Fig. 4.25
162 4.18
The Lorentz transformation and the invariant interval Two-dimensional flat space-time has the metric form ds2 = -dt2 + dX2
(obtained from (4.25b) by setting d Y = dZ = 0). On choosing a new coordinate v defined
by v = t + X instead of t, then dv = dt + dX and in terms of the coordinates (v, X) the interval becomes ds2
= -dv2+2dvdX.
(*)
Deduce from this that a curve {v=constant} is a light ray, but a curve (X= constant} is time-like. Sketch these curves in a space-time diagram. On further choosing the coordinate
w = t - X instead of X, then dw = dt - dX and in terms of the coordinates (v, w) the metric form becomes
ds2 = -dvdw.
(**)
Show from this that the curves {v = constant} and the curves {w = constant} are light rays (for this reason, these coordinates are called null coordinates). Sketch these curves in a
space-time diagram. Check that if we define a new null coordinates u = -v, the metric form becomes
ds2 = dudw.
(***)
Computer Exercise 13 Write a program that will accept as input (a) coordinates (TP, XP) and (TQ, XQ) for the initial point P and final point Q of a time-like curve, (b) an integer Nindicating the number of intermediate points to be specified, (c) coordinates T(I) and X(I) for each of these
intermediate points R(I) (I=1 to N). It should give as output the total proper time T measured by an observer moving from P to Q along the piecewise inertial path (N) --+ Q. [The program must check that the total path and --+ R(N) (2) P --+ R(l) (1) --+ R(2) each of these segments is indeed time-like.] A curve of uniform acceleration between the point P with coordinates (t = -3, X = 5)
and Q with coordinates (t = 3, X = 5) satisfies the equation t2 - XZ = -16. Choose a series of Npoints R(I) on this curve (I= 1 to N) between P and Q and determine the proper time T from P to Q along the piecewise inertial path defined by these points. Show that as N
gets larger and larger, T tends to a limit TL, the proper time from P to Q along the uniformly accelerated path. [One way to choose the points is to choose a set of values for T (-5 < T < 5) and then solve the equation X2 = TZ + 16 for X.]
4.3
Some flat-space universes
We shall. now illustrate some of the ideas of the previous sections by looking briefly at three cosmologies in flat space-time. These examples are included to show some intriguing possibilities that arise in the case of special relativity (when gravitational effects are negligible). Similar effects occur in the curved spacetimes of general relativity, considered in the following chapters (when gravity is
taken properly into account). For the sake of simplicity, we will concentrate mainly on two-dimensional examples which show the major features of full fourdimensional versions of these space-times. If you find the details heavy-going, then omit them at a first reading and turn to the discussion of curved space-times.
4.3
Some flat-space universes
163
Matter in the universe In the real universe, we observe matter (stars and dust) clustered into galaxies and clusters of galaxies (Fig. 1.10) which are measured to have systematically increasing redshifts as their distance from us increases (Fig. 3.4). This suggests there is a well-defined average motion of matter in each region in the universe (e.g.
in our local region of the universe, the motion of our supercluster of galaxies). Therefore, a model of the universe must specify both the space-time itself and this average motion of matter. We will call a space-time a model universe when a family of preferred world-lines is specified in it,* representing the average motion of matter at each point in space-time (Fig. 4.26). These world-lines, which we call fundamental world-lines, then represent the history of galaxies or observers moving precisely with the average motion of matter at each point (not all matter will move in this way; for example, cosmic rays will be moving at high speed relative to most matter). We refer to observers moving with precisely this average velocity as fundamental observers, and analyse the behaviour of the universe model in terms of the observations of presumed fundamental galaxies (moving with the preferred velocity) made by such (idealized) fundamental observers. Given a universe model, we can test how good a representation of the real universe it is by comparing observations of galaxies in the real universe with the observations predicted by that model for fundamental observers.
Fig. 4.26 A model universe is a space-time together with a family of world-lines representing the average motion of matter at each space-time point. An observer moving with this average motion is called a fundamental observer.
*In a complete cosmological model we will also have to specify many other physical features of the matter in the universe, but in this book we examine only the space-time geometry of these universe models.
164
The Lorentz transformation and the invariant interval
As has been mentioned above, the universe models we look at here do not attempt to represent the nature of gravity (which will be discussed in the next section). Instead they are based on the symmetries of flat space-time, which define a structure for space-time that picks out particular classes of world-lines as `naturally preferred', so we choose these for the world-lines of the fundamental observers. We look at three such models: the Minkowski universe, the Rindler
universe, which has many properties similar to those of a black hole, and the Milne universe, which is a simple expanding universe model. We will discuss curved-space universe models of the black-hole type and the expanding type, in Chapters 6 and 7 respectively. Minkowski universes
We first consider a two-dimensional version of this universe model, and then a four-dimensional version. A two-dimensional Minkowski universe This is just the two-dimensional flat space-time of special relativity with the metric form given in terms of coordinates (t, X) by
ds2 = -d t2 + dX2,
(4.32a)
the world-lines of the fundamental observers being lines {X= constant}, and the number density of galaxies being uniform in the surfaces {t=constant}, which are surfaces of instantaneity for all the fundamental observers (Fig. 4.27a). This
universe model is based on the translation invariance of the space-time: the world-lines are moved into themselves by the time-translation symmetry
t' = t + t0,
XI=X,
(4.33a)
where to is any constant. This, in particular, implies that the world-lines stay a constant distance from each other. They are moved into each other by the spatial translation symmetry
X' = X + Xo,
t' = t,
(4.33b)
where Xo is any constant. This implies spatial homogeneity; in particular, the symmetry leaves invariant the density of matter in the spatial surfaces {t= constant}. Note that (4.33) are space-time symmetries because the form (4.32) is clearly invariant under them (cf. (4.22) and the following comments). The static, uniform distribution of matter We can think of this universe either in the continuum approximation where a world-line is defined through every space-time point, or we can conveniently think of it in discrete terms, where there are still an infinite set of uniformly distributed world-lines, but not one through every point. Then we start with the world-line L passing through the event 0 {X = 0, t = 0}, and generate all the other world-lines (see Fig. 4.27b) by (i) repeatedly applying a spatial translation (4.33b) to it for some suitable value of Xo to determine the events 0 where the world-lines intersect the initial
Some flat-space universes
4.3 t J
165
x=const
f world-lines /of matter
x=o
~t=const /
surfaces
of h omogenei t y t=o
00 X
translational invariance (a)
(a)
The Minkowski universe. (a) The world-lines of the fundamental observers, representing the average motion of matter in the universe, are {X=constant} and their Fig. 4.27
surfaces of instantaneity are {t=constant}. (b) Construction of the universe by (i) repeatedly applying a spatial translation through a distance Xo to the world-line L through the origin to determine the initial points of these world-lines in the surface t = 0, and (ii) applying time translations to these events for all values to to determine the worldlines in space-time. By this construction, the density of matter measured in the surfaces {t = constant} is uniform.
surface {t = 0}; (ii) applying the time-translation (4.33a) to determine the world-lines Lr, in space-time from these initial events. The distribution of world-lines so created is necessarily time-invariant (since it is defined by a time translation which is a space-time symmetry). It is also spatially homogeneous in the initial surface {t = constant} by construction (the world-lines are all the
same distance Xo apart from each other in this surface), and will remain spatially homogeneous when the time translation (4.33a) is applied to determine it elsewhere in space-time, because the initial symmetry is preserved by this time-invariance symmetry (the distance Xo between the world-lines is maintained at all later times). Because of the spatial homogeneity, the density
166
The Lorentz transformation and the invariant interval
function representing the number of galaxies per unit spatial distance will be spatially constant; because of the time symmetry, this density is also constant in time. A four-dimensional Minkowski universe This is the four-dimensional flat space-time of special relativity with the invariant metric form given in terms of coordinates (t, X, Y, Z) by ds2 = -d t2 + dX2 + d Y2 + dZ2,
(4.32b)
the world-lines of the fundamental observers being lines {X, Y, Z constant}, and
the number density of galaxies being uniform in the surfaces It = constant}, which are surfaces of instantaneity for all the fundamental observers. The properties of this space-time are clear immediately from the discussion above of the two-dimensional version (which is just the section of the full four-dimensional
space-time obtained on setting Y = Z = constant in (4.32b)). This is the simplest kind of universe model: a static, uniform distribution of matter in a flat space-time, without beginning or end and without spatial limit. It is rather uninteresting: there are no observed redshifts or blueshifts, and the density of matter in the universe is uniform in time and space. The model does not correspond to the real universe, where systematic galactic redshifts are observed; we include it mainly for contrast with the other two to follow, and to illustrate in a familiar context some of the methods we will use in the rest of this section. There is a universe model with curved space-time, the Einstein static universe, which is similar to the Minkowski universe discussed here; we will discuss it in Chapter 7. We conclude examination of this universe model by considering briefly three conceivable methods of estimating the distance of an object in such a space-time: distance by apparent angle, by apparent luminosity, and by apparent brightness. This detailed material is included because similar methods will be used later in
examining the properties of curved space-times; it may be omitted on a first reading.
Apparent size
To determine how apparent sizes will appear in these universes,
we change to spherical polar coordinates (r, 0, 0) so that the metric form becomes
ds2 = -dt2 + dr2 + r2(d02 + sin 2 0dg2)
(4.32c)
(cf. (4.29); we have chosen units for the radial coordinate r that set the speed of light to unity) where now the fundamental world-lines are the lines Jr, 0, 0 constant}. It follows immediately from this form that r measures directly the distance from the origin along the radial curves It, 0, 0 constant}. Now consider
a linear object of length D lying transverse to this radial line at distance r (Fig. 4.28a); without loss of generality we can choose the polar coordinates so that the object lies in a surface {0 = constant}, with its ends at 0 = 01 and 0 = 02 respectively. The interval along the rod measured at an instant It = constant} by a fundamental observer is then ds2 = r2 d02 (from (4.32c) on setting dt = 0 =
dr = do). Its length is then given by D = r(02 - 01). Thus on defining the
4.3
Some flat-space universes
167
D
(a)
Fig. 4.28
(b)
(a) A rod of length D lying perpendicular to the line of sight from the observer at
a distance r. The apparent angular size of the rod is a (b) We estimate the distances of objects such as cars by observing their apparent angle a, and deducing the distance to them because we know approximately what their length is.
apparent angular size of the object as a = 02 - 01, this is related to the length of the object by
a = D/r
(4.34)
showing that the apparent size of the object is proportional to its length D and inversely proportional to its distance r. It is effectively through this equation that we estimate distance of objects in everyday life: for example our eye estimates the apparent angle of a car as it passes (Fig. 4.28b), we know the approximate size D
of the car, so our brain can estimate the distance r to it (in effect by using eqn (4.34)). If the object is not at rest relative to the observer, or does not lie transverse to the line of sight, the calculation becomes more complex but still follows directly from (4.32). Apparent luminosity We wish to calculate the rate at which energy is received by
an observer at a distance r from a star. For generality, we will not assume the observer is at rest relative to the star. To be precise, we will assume that the star is at rest at the origin r = 0 of coordinates for which the metric form is (4.32c), and
the observer is moving radially outwards so as to measure a redshift z for the received radiation (Fig. 4.29a). Suppose the star is measured in its rest frame to emit radiation uniformly in all directions at a rate L ergs/sec. This radiation is carried by photons, the energy of
each photon being E = by where h is a constant and v is the frequency of the radiation, related to its wavelength A by c = v\. The rate at which photons are emitted by the star will then be L/E = L/hv photons per second. Assuming that photons are conserved, after travelling a distance r from the star (as measured in the star's frame) they will all arrive at the observer, at which distance they will be spread over a sphere of area 47rr 2 (Fig. 4.29b). Because of the K-factor effect (see the redshift relations (3.3, 4)) the rate at which these photons arrive will be a
168
The Lorentz transformation and the invariant interval
O star
light
to bserver
k
redshift z
observer
(a)
(b)
(measured by observer) (c)
Fig. 4.29 (a) An observer moving relative to a star in flat space-time measures a redshift z in radiation received from the star. (b) When radiation from the star arrives at the distance rat which the observer is situated, it has spread out over an area 47rr2. (c) The solid angle 1 is the apparent size of the object as seen by the observer; it can be thought of as the amount of sky covered by the star.
factor 1 + z slower, in the observer's rest frame, than the rate at which they were emitted in the rest frame of the star; thus the rate at which photons arrive per unit area will be measured by the observer as
R = (L/hv)(1/47rr2){1/(1 +z)}. Now the energy per photon measured by the observer is hv' where v' is the fre-
quency measured by the observer, related to v by v'/v = 1/(1 + z). Consequently the flux of radiation (i.e. the energy received per unit area per unit time) measured by the observer from the star is
F = Rhv' = (L/47r)/{r(1 +z)}2.
(4.35)
This is the basis of measurement of distance by apparent luminosity. We can measure the flux F and redshift z by use of telescopes and appropriate detectors. If we are able to estimate the intrinsic luminosity L of the star (e.g. by our knowledge of the luminosity of other stars whose distance can be determined by other means) then we can find the distance r of the star from (4.35). This method of distance estimation is widely used in astronomy, e.g. to estimate the distance of distant galaxies. In the Minkowski universe, the flux measured by a fundamental observer will be given by this equation with z = 0, which is nothing other than the inverse-square law for the flux of light received from an object (since Fis then simply proportional to 1/r2).
4.3
Apparent brightness
Some flat-space universes
169
The flux Fis the total radiation emitted by an object. When
observing an extended object such as a galaxy, what our instruments directly record is actually its apparent brightness, i.e. flux received per unit solid angle, in the wavelength band lying in its range of sensitivity (for example, this is what is recorded by our eye or by a photographic plate). The solid angle SZ is the amount
of the sky covered by the image of the object. It is defined by the equation S = rr2c where S is the cross-section area of the star, and r' is the distance measured to the object by the observer (Fig. 4.29c). The observed intensity of radiation I (the brightness at all wavelengths) is the flux received per unit solid angle, i.e
I = F/1 = Fri2/S.
(4.36a)
Now the relation between r (the distance measured between the object and observer by someone stationary relative to the star) and r' (the same distance measured by the observer) is r' = r/ (1 + z), which is effectively eqn (3.25) applied
to the present situation (it is clear that these distances must be related by K = 1 + z rather than y because the light we are concerned with travels one way, from the source to the observer, rather than both ways; the solid angle is the solid angle subtended by the source at the time of observation, not at the present time as deduced by radar). Combining this result with (4.35) and (4.36a) shows that
I = Io/(l +z)4,
(4.36b)
where Io = L/(47rS) is the surface brightness of the star. This shows that in flat space-time, the observed intensity of radiation from a given source is independent of the distance between the observer and the source; it depends only on their relative motion. In the case of the Minkowski universe, a fundamental observer will measure the same intensity of radiation from a source, no matter how far he is from it (as z = 0 then). Thus, it is not possible to use observed intensity (or surface brightness, i.e. the measured intensity in restricted wavelength bands) alone to estimate distance of an observed object. Exercise 4.19 In a Minkowski universe every past light ray from an event P would eventually intersect a star. Prove that the redshift observed by a fundamental observer is zero for every star (assuming each star moves at the fundamental velocity). Deduce from eqn (4.36b) that if the stars shone continuously in such a universe, the entire night sky would be as bright as the surface of a star, contrary to our experience that the sky is dark at night (this is Olber's paradox). What conservation law shows stars cannot shine continuously (i.e. puts a limit on the possible lifetime of a star?)
The two-dimensional Rindler universe Although this model universe is based on flat space-time, it displays some of the
essential features of a black hole (which we shall examine in Section 6.2). It is based on the `boost'-invariance of flat space-time, and may most easily be
170
The Lorentz transformation and the invariant interval
Fig. 4.30 The Rindler universe. The world-lines L of the fundamental observers are obtained by boosts (see Fig. 4.6(b)) applied to their initial positions at equal distances along the surface { t = 0}. The boosts move the surface { t = 0} into the surfaces {O = Oo }, {i3 = 2001,..., in terms of the parameter 0 (eqn (4.44)),
constructed as in the previous example. Start with flat space-time given in terms
of coordinates (t, X) and with ds2 from (4.32a). Use the spatial translations (4.33b) to determine the initial positions of a family of world-lines in the surface
{t = 0} through the origin 0, resulting in an initially uniform distribution of matter as in the previous case. We now use the boosts about 0 (eqn (4.37a) below) to determine the world-lines elsewhere from their initial positions (Fig. 4.30). As discussed above (cf. (4.23)) the interval is invariant, so this determines the world-
lines in such a way that the distance X0 between them in their surfaces of instantaneity remains constant at all later times. The result is clearly different from the Minkowski universe. Explicitly, a general point P on each line L is obtained from the initial event (X', t') by a boost
X = y(V)(X' + Vt'),
t = y(V)(t' + VX')
(4.37a)
for some value V for the relevant change of velocity, where y(V) = (1 - V2)-Z; thus V (I V I < 1) serves as a parameter along the world-line L. For every value of
V, the boost preserves the invariant S2 giving the distance from 0 to P (see eqns (4.16-18)) which on each world-line L takes the value at the initial point:
-t2+X2 = p2,
p2 = constant
(4.37b)
This is therefore the equation for the fundamental world-lines. These curves are sketched in Fig. 4.31; they are all asymptotic to the light cone through 0 at large
4.3
Some flat-space universes
171
Fig. 4.31 The world-lines S2 = p2 in the Rindler universe, and their surfaces of simultaneity which are also surfaces of homogeneity (i.e. of constant density).
values of IX!. As the world-line L passes through the point {t' = 0, X' = p}, a general point on L can be expressed in terms of this initial point via eqn (4.37a) as X = -Y(V)P,
t = -Y(V) VP.
(4.37c)
In this form, V is a parameter along the curve that is labelled by the value p. Note
that the point 0 is a fixed point of these boosts, so this procedure does not generate a world-line through 0 itself; for later purposes it will be convenient to define the world-line Lo to be given by {X = 0}. These universe models have many interesting properties, which we will investigate in turn.
(A) Constant relative distances By construction, the world-lines are invariant under the Lorentz transformations (boosts) about 0; therefore, they maintain a constant distance from each other at all times. This does not at first appear to be