ION CHANNELS: FROM ATOMIC RESOLUTION PHYSIOLOGY TO FUNCTIONAL GENOMICS
The Novartis Foundation is an international sc...
20 downloads
1035 Views
24MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
ION CHANNELS: FROM ATOMIC RESOLUTION PHYSIOLOGY TO FUNCTIONAL GENOMICS
The Novartis Foundation is an international scientific and educational charity (UK Registered Charity No. 313574). Known until September 1997 as the Ciba Foundation, it was established in 1947 by the CIBA company of Basle, which merged with Sandoz in 1996, to form Novartis. The Foundation operates independently in London under English trust law. It was formally opened on 22 June 1949. The Foundation promotes the study and general knowledge of science and in particular encourages international co-operation in scientific research. To this end, it organizes internationally acclaimed meetings (typically eight symposia and allied open meetings and 15-20 discussion meetings each year) and publishes eight books per year featuring the presented papers and discussions from the symposia. Although primarily an operational rather than a grant-making foundation, it awards bursaries to young scientists to attend the symposia and afterwards work with one of the other participants. The Foundation's headquarters at 41 Portland Place, London W1B 1BN, provide library facilities, open to graduates in science and allied disciplines. Media relations are fostered by regular press conferences and by articles prepared by the Foundation's Science Writer in Residence. The Foundation offers accommodation and meeting facilities to visiting scientists and their
Information on all Foundation activities can be found at http://www.novartisfound.org.uk
Novartis Foundation Symposium 245
ION CHANNELS: FROM ATOMIC RESOLUTION PHYSIOLOGY TO FUNCTIONAL GENOMICS
2002
JOHN WILEY & SONS, LTD
Copyright © Novartis Foundation 2002 Published in 2002 by John Wiley & Sons Ltd, Baffins Lane, Chichester, West Sussex PO19 1UD, England National 01243 779777 International (+44) 1243779777 e-mail (for orders and customer service enquiries): cs-books@ wiley.co.uk Visit our Home Page on http://www.wiley.co.uk or http://www.wiley.com All Rights Reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, scanning or otherwise, except under the terms of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 or under the terms of a licence issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency, 90 Tottenham Court Road, London, W1P 9HE, UK, without the permission in writing of the publisher. Other Wiley Editorial Offices John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 605 Third Avenue, New York, NY 10158-0012, USA WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH, Pappelallee 3, D-69469 Weinheim, Germany John Wiley & Sons Australia, Ltd, 33 Park Road, Milton, Queensland 4064, Australia John Wiley & Sons (Asia) Pte Ltd, 2 Clementi Loop #02-01, Jin Xing Distripark, Singapore 129809 John Wiley & Sons (Canada) Ltd, 22 Worcester Road, Rexdale, Ontario M9W1L1, Canada Novartis Foundation Symposium 245 ix+273 pages, 67 figures, 11 tables
British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British LibraryISBN 0 470 84375 6 Typeset in 10/2 on 121/2 pt Garamond by DobbieTypesetting Limited,Tavistock, Devon. Printed and bound in Great Britain by Biddies Ltd, Guildford and King's Lynn. This book is printed on acid-free paper responsibly manufactured from sustainable forestry, in which at least two trees are planted for each one used for paper production.
Contents Symposium on Ion channels: from atomic resolution physiology tofunctional genomes, held at the Novartis Foundation, London, 12-14 June 2001 Editors: Gregory Bock (Organizer) and Jamie A. Goode This symposium is based on a proposal made by Mark, Sansom Mark S. P. Sansom Introduction: stretching the envelope in structure —function studies of ion channels 1 Nigel Unwin Structure of the acetylcholine-gated channel Discussion 15
5
Katjusa Brejc, Willem J. van Dijk, August B. Smit and Titia K. Sixma The 2.7 A structure of AChBP, homologue of the ligand-binding domain of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor 22 Discussion 29 Alok K. Mitra, Gang Ren, Vijay S. Reddy, Anchi Cheng and Alexandrine Froger The architecture of a water-selective pore in the lipid bilayer visuali2ed by electron crystallography in vitreous ice 33 Discussion 46 Dax Fu, Andrew Libson and Robert Stroud conducting channel 51 Discussion 61
The structure of GlpF, a glycerol
Mark S. P. Sansom, Peter Bond, Oliver Beckstein, Philip C. Biggin, Jose Faraldo-Gomez, Richard J. Law, George Patargias and D. Peter Tieleman Water in ion channels and pores — simulation studies 66 Discussion 79 Benoit Roux What can be deduced about the structure of Shaker from available data? 84 Discussion 101
CONTENTS Stefano Garofoli, Gennady Miloshevsky, Vladimir L. Dorman and Peter C. Jordan Permeation energetics in a model potassium channel Discussion 122 Jacqueline M. Gulbis safety switch? 127 Discussion 142
109
The b subunit of Kvl channels: voltage-gated enzyme or
E. Perozo, L. G. Cuello, D. M. Cortes, Y.- S. Liu and P. Sompornpisut EPR approaches to ion channel structure and function 146 Discussion 158 General discussion I
From structure to channel physiology 165
Senyon Choe, Susan Cushman, Kent A. Baker and Paul Pfaffinger Excitability is mediated by theTl domain of the voltage-gated potassium channel 169 Discussion 175 Diane M. Papazian, William R. Silverman, Meng-chin A. Lin, Seema K. Tiwari-Woodruff and Chih-YungTang Structural organization of the voltage sensor in voltage-dependent potassium channels 178 Discussion 190 Michelle M. Pirruccello, Nikolaus Grigorieff and Joseph A. Mindell Electron diffraction of a bacterial CIC-type chloride channel 193 Discussion 203 John B. C. Findlay and Michael A. Harrison A protein chemical approach to channel structure and function: the proton channel of the vacuolar H+-ATPase 207 Discussion 218 Anthony Auerbach Discussion 234
Acetylcholine receptors, between closed and open
223
David B. Sattelle, Emmanuel Culetto, Marta Grauso, Valerie Raymond, Christopher Franks and Paula lowers Functional genomics of ionotropic acetylcholine receptors in Caenorhabditiselegans and Drosophila melanogaster 240 Discussion 257 Final general discussion Index of contributors Subject index
267
265
261
Participants Frances Ashcroft (Chair) University of Oxford, University Laboratory of Physiology, Parks Road, Oxford OX1 3PT, UK Anthony Auerbach Department of Physiology and Biophysics, State University of New York, 324 Gary Hall, South Campus, Buffalo, NY 14214, USA Senyon Choe The Salk Institute for Biological Studies, 10010 North Torrey Pines Road, Lajolla, CA 92037-1099, USA Pierre-Jean Corringer Neurobiologie Moleculaire, Institut Pasteur, 25, rue du Dr Roux, F-75015 Paris, France Declan Doyle Laboratory of Molecular Biophysics, The Rex Richards Building, Department of Biochemistry, University of Oxford, South Parks Road, Oxford 0X1 3QU, UK John Findlay School of Biochemistry & Molecular Biology, Faculty of Biological Sciences, University of Leeds, Leeds, LS2 9JT, UK Dax Fu Biology Department, Building 463, 50 Bell Avenue, Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, NY 11973, USA Jacqueline Gulbis The Walter and Eliza Hall Institute of Medical Research, Post Office, The Royal Melbourne Hospital, Melbourne, VIC 3050, Australia Peter Jordan Department of Chemistry MS-015, Brandeis University, PO Box 549110, Waltham, MA 02454-9110, USA Jeremy Lambert Department of Pharmacology and Neuroscience, University of Dundee, Dundee DD1 4HN, UK Alistair Mathie Biophysics Group, Blackett Laboratory, Imperial College, Prince Consort Road, London SW7 2BZ, UK
viii
PARTICIPANTS
Keith Miller Harvard Medical School, Massachusetts General Hospital, Department of Anaesthesia, Fruit Street, Edwards 505, Boston, MA 02114, USA Joseph Mindell Department of Biochemistry, Brandeis University, 415 South Street,Waltham, MA 02454-9110, USA Alok Mitra Department of Cell Biology, The Scripps Research Institute, Mail Stop MB21,10550 North Torrey Pines Rd, Lajolla, CA 92037, USA Diane Papazian Department of Physiology, UCLA School of Medicine, 405 Hilgard Avenue, Box 951751, Los Angeles, CA 90095-1361, USA Eduardo Perozo Department of Molecular Physiology and Biological Physics, University of Virginia, POBox 800736, Charlottesville,VA 22908-0736, USA Chris Poll Novartis Horsham Research Centre, Wimblehurst Road, Horsham RH12 SAB, UK Benoit Roux Department of Biochemistry, Weill Medical College of Cornell University, 1300 York Ave, Box #63, Room W-220, New York, NY 10021, USA Mark Sansom Laboratory of Molecular Biophysics, Department of Biochemistry, Rex Richards Building, University of Oxford, South Parks Road, Oxford OX1 3QU, UK David Sattelle MRC Functional Genetics Unit, Department of Human Anatomy and Genetics, University of Oxford, South Parks Road, Oxford 0X1 3QX, UK Tilman Schirmer University of Basel Biozentrum, Abteilung Strukturbiologie, Klingelbergstrasse 70, Basel, CH-4056, Switzerland Hildgund Schrempf Universitat Osnabriick, Fachbereich Biologie/Chemie, Barbarastr. 11, D-49069 Osnabriick, Germany Titia Sixma Netherlands Cancer Institute, Division of Molecular Carcinogenesis, Plesmanlaan 121,1066 CX Amsterdam,The Netherlands Kenton Swartz Molecular Physiology and Biophysics Unit, NINDS Building 36, Room 2C19,36 Convent Drive, MSC 4066, Bethesda, MD 20892-4066, USA
PARTICIPANTS
ix
Peter Tieleman Department of Biological Sciences, University of Calgary, 2500 University Drive NW, Calgary, Alberta, CanadaT2N 1N4 Nigel Unwin MRC Laboratory of Molecular Biology, Hills Road, Cambridge CB2 2QH, UK Bonnie A.Wallace School of Crystallography, Birkbeck College, University of London, Malet Street, London WC1E 7HX, UK Su Li Novartis Horsham Research Centre, Wimblehurst Road, Horsham RH12 SAB, UK John Westwick Novartis Horsham Research Centre, Wimblehurst Road, Horsham RH12 5AB, UK
This page intentionally left blank
Introduction: stretching the envelope in structure-function studies of ion channels Mark S. P. Sansom Laboratory of Molecular Biophysics, Department of Biochemistry, Rex Richards Building, University of Oxford, South Parks Road, Oxford OX1 3Q U, UK
This meeting has provided a timely opportunity to review progress in understanding the relationship between structure and function of ion channels. However, before considering this progress in more detail, it is important to consider why ion channels are of interest to investigators ranging from structural biologists and biophysicists to pharmacologists and physiologists. It is now recognized that mutations in ion channels can result in a wide range of diseases (Ashcroft 2000). Furthermore, it has been suggested that ion channels may make up some 25% of the potential targets for new drugs (Terstappen & Reggiani 2001). In addition to their biomedical importance, ion channels have for a long time been at the cutting edge of biophysical studies of membranes (Hille 1992). They now provide us with a real chance of linking up descriptions of membrane proteins at the genomic, structural and physiological levels. For the past 30 years or so, there have been almost continuous methodological advances for studying the function and structure of ion channel proteins. The development of the patch clamp technique (Neher & Sakmann 1976) allowed ionic currents flowing through single channel molecules to be measured with unique precision. This enabled more fine-grained dissection of the functional properties of different species of channel than had previously been possible, and also allowed detailed kinetic modelling of the conformational changes underlying channel gating (Colquhoun & Hawkes 1981). The 1980s saw the emergence of the first amino acid sequences of channel proteins (Noda et al 1982). The combination of these molecular insights with patch clamp recording techniques and in vitro mutation of channels resulted in a flourishing of molecular physiology studies that enabled assignment of physiological function to distinct regions within a channel sequence (Miller 1991). However, in the absence of three-dimensional structures for channel proteins, the precise relationships between structure and function often remained tantalisingly out of reach. The
2
SANSOM
solution to this problem lay in the discovery of a bacterial homologue (KcsA) of mammalian K+ channels (Schrempf et al 1995). The breakthrough structure of KcsA (Doyle et al 1998) provided a paradigm for how a high resolution X-ray structure can inform functional studies. We are now witnessing a new phase of channel research, combining the search for new channel structures with poststructural studies using new approaches from spectroscopy, simulation, bioinformatics and genomics. We hope that this book will capture some of the excitement of these developments. A number of themes run through this meeting. The first is that of the continuing progress in determining structures of ion channels. Ongoing structural advances include: the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (Unwin 2000); an acetylcholine binding protein (Brejc et al 2001); Cl- channels (Mindell et al 2001); regulatory subunits of voltage-gated K+ channels (Gulbis et al 1999); and also two channellike transporter proteins from the aquaporin family, namely GlpF (Fu et al 2000) and AQP1 (Ren et al 2001). In addition to such (essentially static) structures from X-ray and electron microscopy methods, significant advances are being made in understanding the conformational dynamics of channel proteins, using methods such as electroparamagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy (Perozo et al 1999), molecular simulations and related computational approaches (Roux et al 2000, Sansom et al 2000) and detailed analysis of the effects of mutations on channel gating (Grosman et al 2000, Tiwari-Woodruff et al 2000). All of these approaches are moving us away from the picture of a rigid static pore through which ions flow, towards a more dynamic model of channel structure and function. A second theme is that of studying function at the microscopic (i.e. atomic resolution) level. This is an area where physiological and biophysical chemistry studies of ion channels converge. Obtaining a precise description of how selected ions flow through a channel at near diffusion-limited rates is an challenging problem in biophysical chemistry (Jordan 1999), and may provide a paradigm for theoretical studies of other, more complex, membrane transport proteins. In some respects it is chastening that we still do not possess a complete quantitative theory of why a K+ channel is K+ selective. However, at least we have now an X-ray structure to help us make substantial progress towards the Holy Grail of describing single-channel function in atomistic detail (Fig. 1). Similar approaches will have to be adopted for other pore-like transporters such as AQP1 and GlpF. A third theme is that of the challenges posed to ion channel research by genomics. For example, the genome sequence of a 'simple' animal, Caenorhabditis e/egans, has revealed a surprisingly large number of e.g. K+ channel genes (Bargmann 1998). It will be of considerable interest to see how these are related to the physiology of the animal as a whole (Davis et al 1999). And so, coming full circle, as genomics reveals a diversity of channel genes, a major challenge for the
INTRODUCTION: STRETCHING THE ENVELOPE
FIG. 1. Diagram of the central challenge facing research on channels: how can we relate channel structure (left) to channel physiology (right)? The channel structure is a model of the pore domain of Kir6,2 (Capener et al 2000); the single channel recording is also from Kir6.2 (diagram courtesy of F. M. Ashcroft).
pharmaceutical industry will be to devise compounds that exploit this diversity in terms of drugs exhibiting selective interactions with specific ion channel proteins. What of the challenges of the future? There are many. From a biomedical perspective, a pressing challenge is to arrive at a more integrated view of channel structure and function ('from atom to animal...'). In particular, one would like to see better integration of data from genomics, bioinformatics, mutation and structural studies of channels. From a fundamental biophysical point of view, it should be possible to extend our emergent understanding of channel structurefunction relationships both to a wider range of ion channels and to other more complex transporters (e.g. AQP1, GlpF and H+-translocating ATPases).
References Ashcroft FM 2000 Ion channels and disease. Academic Press, San Diego Bargmann CI 1998 Neurobiology of the Caenorhabditis elegans genome. Science 282:2028-2033 Brejc K, van Dijk WJ, Klaassen RV et al 2001 Crystal structure of an ACh-binding protein reveals the ligand-binding domain of nicotinic receptors. Nature 411:269-276 Capener CE, Shrivastava IH, Ranatunga KM, Forrest LR, Smith GR, Sansom MSP 2000 Homology modeling and molecular dynamics simulation studies of an inward rectifier potassium channel. Biophys J 78:2929-2942 Colquhoun D, Hawkes AG 1981 On the stochastic properties of single ion channels. Proc R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 211:205-235 Davis MW, Fleischhauer R, Dent LA, Joho RH, Avery L 1999 A mutation in the C. elegans EXP2 potassium channel that alters feeding behavior. Science 286:2501-2504
4
SANSOM
Doyle DA, Cabral JM, Pfuetzner RA et al 1998 The structure of the potassium channel: molecular basis of K+ conduction and selectivity. Science 280:69-77 Fu D, Libson A, Miercke LJW et al 2000 Structure of a glycerol-conducting channel and the basis of its selectivity. Science 290:481-486 Grosman C, Zhou M, Auerbach A 2000 Mapping the conformational wave of acetylcholine receptor channel gating. Nature 403:773-776 Gulbis J, Mann S, MacKinnon R 1999 Structure of a voltage-dependent K* channel b subunit. Cell 97:943-952 Hille B 1992 Ionic Channels of Excitable Membranes, 2nd edn. Sinauer Associates, Sunderland, MA Jordan PC 1999 Ion permeation and chemical kinetics. J Gen Physiol 114:601-604 Miller C 1991 1990: annus mirabilis of potassium channels. Science 252:1092-1096 Mindell J A, Maduke M, Miller C, GrigorieffN 2001 Projection structure of a CIC-type chloride channel at 6.5 A resolution. Nature 409:219-223 Neher E, Sakmann B 1976 Single-channel currents recorded from membrane of denervated frog muscle fibres. Nature 260:799-802 Noda M, Takahashi H, Tanabe T et al 1982 Primary structure of alpha-subunit precursor of Torpedo calif arnica acetylcholine receptor deduced from cDNA sequence. Nature 299:793-797 Perozo E, Cortes DM, Cuello LG 1999 Structural rearrangements underlying K + -channel activation gating. Science 285:73-78 Ren G, Reddy VS, Cheng A, Melnyk P, Mitra AK 2001 Visualization of a water-selective pore by electron crystallography in vitreous ice. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 98:1398-1403 Roux B, Berneche S, Im W 2000 Ion channels, permeation and electrostatics: insight into the function of KcsA. Biochemistry 39:13295-13306 Sansom MSP, Shrivastava IH, Ranatunga KM, Smith GR 2000 Simulations of ion channels — watching ions and water move. Trends Biochem Sci 25:368-374 Schrempf H, Schmidt O, Kummerlen R et al 1995 A prokaryotic potassium ion channel with two predicted transmembrane segments from Steptomyces lividans. EMBO J 14:5170-5178 Terstappen GC, Reggiani A 2001 In silico research in drug discovery. Trends Pharmacol Sci 22:23-26 Tiwari-Woodruff SK, Lin MC, Schulteis CT, Papazian DM 2000 Voltage-dependent structural interactions in the Shaker K+ channel. J Gen Physiol 115:123-138 Unwin N 2000 The Croonian Lecture 2000. Nicotinic acetylcholine receptor and the structural basis of fast synaptic transmission. Phil Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 355:1813-1829
Structure of the acetylcholine-gated channel Nigel Unwin MRC Laboratory of Molecular Biology, Hills Road, Cambridge CB2 2QH, UK
A bstract. The structure of the acetylcholine-gated channel, trapped in open as well as closed states, has been analysed by electron crystallographic methods. The channel has large vestibules extending from the membrane which shape the acetylcholine-binding pockets and facilitate selective transport of cations across a narrow membrane-spanning pore. When acetylcholine enters these pockets it triggers a concerted conformational change that opens the pore by destabilizing a gate in the middle of the membrane made by a ring of pore-lining a-helical segments. The alternative 'open' configuration of porelining segments reshapes the lumen and creates new surfaces, allowing the ions to pass through. Recent results, at nearly 4 A resolution, have defined more precisely the structure of the pore and the design of the vestibular entrances. 2002 Ion channels—from atomic resolution physiology to functional genomics. Wiley, Chichester ( Novartis Foundation Symposium 245) p 5-21
The acetylcholine-gated channel, or ACh receptor, is a model neurotransmittergated ion channel found at the nerve/muscle synapse and in the electric organs of fish. Its structure has been explored extensively by electron crystallographic experiments, using postsynaptic membranes from the Torpedo ray. Based on this work, we now know what it looks like to nearly 4 A resolution, and have an elementary picture of how the channel opens. Descriptions of the acetylcholine-gated channel, in both the closed and open forms, have been given in recent publications (Unwin 1995, 2000, Miyazawa et al 1999). My intention here is to focus on the structure of the ion-conducting pathway. I will discuss our present understanding of the gate and the gating mechanism, and of how the channel is designed to achieve efficient, yet highly selective transport of cations across the membrane. The structural principles of gating and ion selectivity, as they apply to this channel, may be pertinent also to other examples discussed in this volume. Basic architecture The acetylcholine-gated channel is a ~ 300 kDa glycoprotein made from a ring of five rod-shaped membrane-spanning subunits (Fig. 1). These tilt by ~ 10° around
6
UNWIN
the central axis, so that the whole complex has a slightly right-handed, coiled configuration. Each subunit is comprised of a large extracellular N-terminal domain, four predicted transmembrane regions (Ml—M4), and an extended M3M4 cytoplasmic loop. There are two ACh-binding a subunits, which have the same amino acid sequence, and three others, b,g and d, which are similar to the as. The ACh-binding pockets lie about midway between the membrane surface and the extracellular end of the complex (Fig. 1, asterisks). The five subunits together delineate a central, ~120A long ion-conducting pathway, which is divided into three parts: a narrow membrane-spanning pore and, on either side, large water-filled vestibules (Fig. 1). Two important functional regions lie within the pore: the gate, which is located near the middle of the membrane (see Fig. 3); and the constriction zone of the open pore, which is close to the cytoplasmic membrane surface (see Fig. 4). The two vestibules are quite
FIG. 1. Outline of whole channel, emphasizing features of the central ion-conducting pathway within, and on either side of the narrow membrane-spanning pore. The extracellular vestibule has a cylindrical shape whereas the cytoplasmic vestibule is nearly spherical, with narrow openings, or 'windows' lying directly under the membrane surface. The positions of the AChbinding pockets are indicated by asterisks; the bent helices in the membrane represent the M2 segments in the closed configuration; the gate is where they come closest to the axis of the pore.
ACETYLCHOLINE-GATED CHANNEL
7
different, the extracellular one being essentially a ~ 65 A long by ~ 20 A diameter cylinder, and the cytoplasmic one a ~ 20 A diameter sphere. A special feature of the cytoplasmic vestibule is that it does not open directly into the cell interior. Instead, the ions have to pass through narrow (<8-9A wide) lateral openings lying directly under the membrane surface. These lateral 'windows' are shaped by ahelical segments projecting from the individual subunits and coming together at the base of the receptor to form an inverted pentagonal cone.
Role of the vestibules The walls of the vestibules together make up more than 70% of the mass of the channel. Much of this mass may be involved in shaping the ACh-binding pockets and sites of attachment for regulatory molecules and other proteins (e.g. rapsyn) that are concentrated at the synapse. However another likely physiological function of the vestibules is to serve as pre-selectivity filters, making use of charged groups at their entrances and on their inner walls to electrostatically guide and concentrate the ions which are selected for while screening out ions which are discriminated against. Rings of negative charge located at the mouths of the narrow membrane-spanning pore have been shown by mutation studies to be significant determinants of channel conductance (Imoto et al 1988). The modification of the ionic environment achieved by the vestibules may be thought of as providing an additional means for increasing the efficiency of cation transport. The extracellular vestibule provides a route which is narrow enough for the charged groups on the inner wall to influence ions at the centre, yet not too narrow to restrict their diffusion — and so is designed such that weak electrostatic interactions, distributed over a considerable distance, could combine to achieve a strong overall effect. In fact, the extracellular wall has a high net negative charge: on average — lle/subunit, based on amino acid composition (Unwin 1989). This charge is the same as that for the fast-acting enzyme, acetylcholinesterase (Nolte et al 1980, Ripoll et al 1993), where the whole protein surface plays a role in producing an electrostatic field that guides the positively charged ACh substrate to the active site. It is easy to imagine that the channel uses its predominantly negatively charged extracellular surface to guide, in a similar manner, inorganic cations to the pore (see also Adcock et al 1998). Similar principles are likely to apply to the cytoplasmic vestibule, since electrophysiological experiments have shown that there is no marked preference for cations to go in one direction across the membrane. Indeed, the a-helical segments shaping the 'windows' can be identified with the stretch of sequence containing heptad repeats of negatively charged residues, denoted MA (Miyazawa et al 1999), and once thought to be lining the membrane-spanning
UNWIN
AChR
a
b g
I
A
E
"
I
A
E
Q
I
A
K
S
M
K
S
L
E
T
K
D
E
E
K
A
S
E
F
E
Q
N
D
S
S
N
A
D
D
L
G
S
E
S
A
E
E
W
K
K
D
W
N
E
N
W
8
I
V
K
Q
I
K
E
K
N
A
Y
D
E
E
V
G
N
W
5HT3 A
I
R
H
F
L
E
K
R
D
E
M
R
E
V
A
R
D
W
a1 M
R
K
L
F
I
Q
R
A
K
K
I
D
K
I
S
R
I
|
A
K
S
A
T
I
E
P
K
E
V
K
P
E
T
K
P
Gly
GABAA
a1
FIG. 2. Sequence comparison of aligned MA stretches involved in shaping the cytoplasmic windows. Presumed framing residues are boxed, and charged residues (E,D: negative; R,K: positive) are in bold. The acetylcholine- and 5-HT 3 gated channels are cation selective; the glycine- and GABAA-gated channels are anion selective.
pore (Finer-Moore & Stroud 1984). This identification, in turn, suggests that the windows do not merely function as molecular sieves, preventing impermeant cytoplasmic molecules from reaching the vicinity of the pore, but also make use of the negative charge to help to concentrate cations in the vestibule. Passing ions would be strongly influenced by negatively charged side-chains framing the windows, which are narrower for the most part than the diameter of an ion including its first hydration shell. Figure 2 shows the stretches along MA which, from tentative fitting to the threedimensional densities, appear to be involved in shaping the windows. This figure also shows aligned sequences from other channels in the ACh receptor family. There are several features consistent with the idea that these stretches may play a general role in pre-selecting ions. First, the presumed framing residues (boxed regions) are grouped in pairs, spaced seven residues apart: they therefore lie along lines on opposite faces of each helix, making an included angle of 100C, which closely matches the angle made by adjacent windows (ideally 108c). Second, there is a clear distinction between the cation-selective (AChR, 5-HT3) and the anion-selective (Gly, GABAA) channels in terms of the framing residues being predominantly negatively charged in the former case and positively charged in the latter. Third, it is only the a subunit which uses both faces to shape the three main windows of the acetylcholine-gated channel (Miyazawa et al 1999) and, appropriately, this helix is the most negatively charged. Closed pore The pore of the acetylcholine-gated channel is shaped mainly by the membranespanning segments, M2, one contributed by each of the encircling subunits (for a review, see Lester 1992). These segments are a helical, but bend inwards near the
ACETYLCHO LINE-GATED CHANNEL
9
middle of the membrane to form the gate of the closed channel (Unwin 1993, Miyazawa et al 1999; see Fig. 1). The precise nature of the gate — whether it forms a physical occlusion, or is better described as a zone of low polarizability that reinforces the dielectric barrier to ion permeation — has not yet been clarified. Earlier studies had emphasised the likely importance of a ring of conserved leucine residues (aLeu251), and had suggested they might project inwards from the M2 segments, associating side-to-side to form an occluding gate (Unwin 1993). But the side-chain densities in the most recent ~ 4 A map do not come close enough to the pore axis to account for such a simple arrangement. Apparently there is a hole of ~ 3.5 A radius along the central axis of the pore where the gate is located. This is only slightly smaller than the radius of a Na+ or K+ ion having a single hydration shell. Therefore, to be effective in preventing ion permeation, the gate should counter any opportunity for electrostatic stabilization, which could liberate ions from their hydration shells, by forming a completely hydrophobic girdle around the hole. Two rings of hydrophobic residues are likely to be part of this girdle: one including the conserved leucine and the other including a valine (aVal255; also highly conserved in ACh receptors), one turn of a helix away. Residues in both these rings can be labelled by small uncharged photoactivable compounds when the channel is closed (White & Cohen 1992, Blanton et al 1998). The higher resolution map suggests that the leucines may interact side-to-side with alanine/ serine residues on neighbouring M2 segments, rather than with each other, to form the girdle (Fig. 3). Since the M2 segments are not closely packed and draw away from the pore axis (and hence from each other on either side of the bend), the interaction implicating aLeu251 may be the only one between these segments. The resulting limited stability of the structure would ensure its easy disruption and reassembly by conformational changes initiated at the binding sites. Other pentameric structures composed of bundles of a helices, such as phospholamban (Adams et al 1995), COMP (Malashkevich et al 1996) and the mechanosensitive channel (Chang et al 1998), all contain rings of hydrophobic side chains lying closer to the pore axis than those of the receptor. These side chains could function as occluding gates. However, the a-helical bundle structures involve more extensive side-to-side interactions, increasing their stability and making them less suited for rapid conversion between two widely distinct and precisely defined states. Open pore The structure of the open pore has been determined to 9 A resolution by spraying ACh onto postsynaptic membranes on the microscope grid and freezing the grid
10
UNWIN
FIG. 3. The higher resolution maps suggest that the gate may be made by leucine and valine side-chains creating a hydrophobic girdle around the pore. The hydrophobic surface, in providing no electrostatic stabilization, would counter liberation of the ion from its hydration shell, and the central hole would be too narrow for a hydrated ion to pass through.
within 5 ms to trap the reaction before significant desensitization can take place (Berriman & Unwin 1994, Unwin 1995). The M2 segments encircling the open pore have a different configuration from those encircling the closed pore, being further apart near the middle of the membrane and coming together instead at the cytoplasmic membrane surface (Fig. 4A). The open pore is consequently narrowest at the cytoplasmic membrane surface, forming a constriction zone — where direct interaction between the hydrated ions and encircling protein determines most critically whether or not the ions can go through. A tentative alignment of the three-dimensional densities with the cytoplasmic portion of the M2 sequence (Unwin 1995) suggested that a line of small polar (serine or threonine) residues would lie almost parallel to the axis of the pore when the channel opens (Fig. 4B), an orientation that should stabilize the passing ions by providing an environment of high polarizability. The gating action
A simple mechanistic picture of the gating action, suggested by comparison of the ACh-activated structure with the structure obtained in the absence of ACh, would
ACETYLCHOLINE-GATED CHANNEL
11
FIG. 4. Transient configuration of M2 rods around the open pore, and interpretation at 9 A (Unwin 1995). (a) A barrel of a-helical segments, having a pronounced twist, forms in the cytoplasmic leaflet of the bilayer, constricting the pore maximally at the cytoplasmic membrane surface. The bend in the rods is at the same level as for the closed pore, but instead of pointing inwards has rotated over to the side, opening up the pore in the middle of the membrane, (b) Schematic representation of the most distant three rods. A tentative alignment of the amino acid sequence with the densities suggests that a line of polar residues should be facing the open pore (from Unwin 1995).
12
UNWIN
be as follows. First, ACh triggers localized disturbances at the two binding sites. Second, the effects of these disturbances are communicated, through 'twisting' rotations of the a subunits, to the structure in the membrane. Third, the M2 segments in the membrane transmit the rotations to the gate-forming side chains, drawing them away from the central axis; the mode of association near the middle of the membrane (Fig. 3) is thereby disfavoured, and the segments switch to the alternative side-to-side mode of association (Fig. 4), creating an open pore. The bend near the middle of the M2 segment, where the helix is partially unfolded, may play a crucial role in facilitating the rapid switch between the closed and open pore. In acting as a point of flexure, it would allow this critical part of the receptor to move economically within the rest of the membranespanning structure (which does not change significantly), so that there is no direct influence on the motion by the surrounding lipids. Interestingly, molecular dynamics simulations of isolated a helices in water show that those composed of the M2 stretch of amino acids have a propensity for localized flexure in their middle portion. The M2 helix unfolds in this region, in the simulations, allowing the bend to act as a molecular swivel, or hinge (Law et al 2000). Relation to mutagenesis experiments Mutagenesis combined with electrophysiological study of function has been a valuable approach for exploring the nature of the membrane-spanning pore and identifying the likely roles played by individual M2 side chains in affecting ion permeation. Several such experiments have highlighted the uniqueness of the conserved leucine residue in relation to the gating mechanism. For example, replacement of successive leucines by serines (Labarca et al 1995), or by threonines (Filatov & White 1995) markedly increased, by uniform increments, the opening sensitivity of the channel. An analysis of the influence of mutations on the binding of the open channel blocker, QX222, is consistent with the structural evidence that the open pore tapers towards the cytoplasmic end of M2 and that the line of polar pore-facing residues shown in Fig. 4B is likely to play an important role (Charnet et al 1990). The threonine at the point of maximum constriction (aThr244), when substituted by other residues of different volume, has a pronounced effect on ion flow, as if it is in the narrowest part of the open pore (Imoto et al 1991, Villarroel et al 1991). The critical nature of the cytoplasmic end of M2, including the preceding loop region, has been reinforced more recently by experiments investigating anion versus cation selectivity, carried out on other channels in the ACh receptor family (Corringer et al 1999, Keramidas et al 2000, Gunthorpe & Lummis 2001).
ACETYLCHOLINE-GATED CHANNEL
13
Cysteine scanning mutagenesis has also been applied extensively to the ACh receptor, and other members of the family, to probe the organization of residues composing M2, and other membrane-spanning segments, around the pore. Some of these experiments lead to a similar picture of the pore to the structural results, while others suggest there could be discrepancies, for example in the exact location of the gate (Wilson & Karlin 2001). One disadvantage of the mutagenesis approach is that amino acid substitutions often alter the local structure in an unknown and unpredictable way. This makes interpretation difficult, particularly when it comes to the key functional components. Mutation experiments also tend to over-emphasize the importance of a small number of identified amino acid residues, whereas weak interactions by many, widely distributed residues can combine to produce strong overall effects. The structure, as I have described, strongly suggests that this latter principle is an important one in determining the physiological properties achieved by the acetylcholine-gated channel.
Conclusions The electron crystallographic experiments have provided an elementary picture of the ion-conducting pathway of the acetylcholine-gated channel, showing how it is designed and suggesting how it functions. The vestibules appear to play a significant role in pre-selecting for cations and concentrating them at the mouth of the narrow membrane-spanning pore, thereby enhancing the overall efficiency of cation transport. The gate of the channel, near the middle of the membrane, appears to be made by hydrophobic side-chains creating a girdle around the pore. In the absence of polar groups to provide electrostatic stabilization, the ion will retain its hydration shell and then be too large to pass through the central hole. The close-to-open transition of the channel is mediated by a twisting of the a subunits between the binding pockets and the membrane. This weakens the stability of the gate, favouring the alternative 'open' configuration of M2 segments, where the pore is wider near the middle of the membrane and most constricted at the cytoplasmic membrane surface. The constriction zone, at the cytoplasmic membrane surface, appears to be shaped largely by polar residues and/or backbone groups. The polar surfaces in this region, and nearby charged groups, provide a polarizing environment that should facilitate selective transport by stabilizing passing cations.
14
UNWIN
Acknorvledgements The staff of the Marine Station at Roscoff, France are warmly thanked for their continued interest and for the frequent supply of Torpedo marmorata electric rays. The research has been supported in part by grants from the National Institutes of Health (GM-61941) and the European Commission (BIO4-CT98-0110), and by funds from the Louis Jeantet Foundation.
References Adams PD, Arkin IT, Engelman DM, Brunger AT 1995 Computational searching and mutagenesis suggest a structure for the pentameric transmembrane domain of phospholamban. Nat Struct Biol 2:154-162 Adcock C, Smith GR, Sansom MSP 1998 Electrostatics and ion selectivity of ligand-gated channels. Biophys J 75:1211-1222 Berriman J, Unwin N 1994 Analysis of transient structures by cryo-microscopy combined with rapid mixing of spray droplets. Ultramicroscopy 56:241-252 Blanton MP, Dangott LJ, Raja SK, Lala AK, Cohen JB 1998 Probing the structure of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor ion channel with the uncharged photoactivable compound [3H]diazofluorene. J Biol Chem 273:8659-8668 Chang G, Spencer RH, Lee AT, Barclay MT, Rees DC 1998 Structure of the MscL homolog from Mycobacterium tuberculosis: a gated mechanosensitive ion channel. Science 282:2220-2226 Charnet P, Labarca C, Leonard RJ et al 1990 An open-channel blocker interacts with adjacent turns of a-helices in the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor. Neuron 4:87-95 Corringer PJ, Bertrand S, Galzi JL, Devillers-Thiery A, Changeux JP, Bertrand D 1999 Mutational analysis of the charge selectivity filter of the a7 nicotinic acetylcholine receptor. Neuron 22:831-843 Filatov GN, White MM 1995 The role of conserved leucines in the M2 domain of the acetylcholine receptor in channel gating. Mol Pharmacol 48:379-384 Finer-Moore J, Stroud RM 1984 Amphipathic analysis and possible formation of the ion channel in an acetylcholine receptor. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 81:155-159 Gunthorpe MJ, Lummis SC 2001 Conversion of the ion selectivity of the 5-HT3A receptor from cationic to anionic reveals a conserved feature of the ligand-gated ion channel superfamily. J Biol Chem 276:10977-10983 Imoto K, Busch C, Sakmann B et al 1988 Rings of negatively charged amino acids determine the acetylcholine receptor channel conductance. Nature 335:645-648 Imoto K, Konno T, Nakai J, Wang F, Mishina M, Numa S 1991 A ring of uncharged polar amino acids as a component of channel constriction in the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor. FEES Lett 289:193-200 Keramidas A, Moorhouse AJ, French CR, Schofield PR, Barry PH 2000 M2 pore mutations convert the glycine receptor channel from being anion- to cation-selective. Biophys J 79:247-259 Labarca C, Nowak MW, Zhang H, Tang L, Deshpande P, Lester HA 1995 Channel gating governed symmetrically by conserved leucine residues in the M2 domain of nicotinic receptors. Nature 376:514-516 Law RJ, Forrest LR, Ranatunga KM, La Rocca P, Tieleman P, Sansom SP 2000 Structure and dynamics of the pore-lining helix of the nicotinic receptor: MD simulations in water, lipid bilayers and transbilayer bundles. Proteins 39:47-55 Lester HA 1992 The permeation pathway of neurotransmitter-gated ion channels. Annu Rey Biophys Biomol Struct 21:267-292 Malashkevich VN, Kammerer R A, Efimov VP, Schulthess T, Engel J 1996 The crystal structure of a five-stranded coiled coil in COMP: a prototype ion channel? Science 274:761-765
ACETYLCHOLINE-GATED CHANNEL
15
Miyazawa A, Fujiyoshi Y, Stowell M, Unwin N 1999 Nicotinic acetylcholine receptor at 4.6 A resolution: transverse tunnels in the channel wall. J Mol Biol 288:765-786 Nolte HJ, Rosenberry TL, Neumann E1980 Effective charge on acetylcholinesterase active sites determined from the ionic strength dependence of association rate constants with cationic ligands. Biochemistry 19:3705-3711 Ripoll DR, Faerman CH, Axelsen PH, Silman I, Sussman JL 1993 An electrostatic mechanism for substrate guidance down the aromatic gorge of acetylcholinesterase. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 90:5128-5132 Unwin N 1989 The structure of ion channels in membranes of excitable cells. Neuron 3:665-676 Unwin N 1993 Nicotinic acetylcholine receptor at 9A resolution. J Mol Biol 229:1101-1124 Unwin N 1995 Acetylcholine receptor channel imaged in the open state. Nature 373:37-43 Unwin N 2000 The Croonian Lecture 2000. Nicotinic acetylcholine receptor and the structural basis of fast synaptic transmission. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 355:1813-1829 Villarroel, A, Herlitze S, Koenen M, Sakmann B 1991 Location of a threonine residue in the asubunit M2 transmembrane segment that determines the ion flow through the acetylcholine receptor channel. Proc R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 243:69-74 White BH, Cohen JB 1992 Agonist-induced changes in the structure of the acetylcholine receptor M2 regions revealed by photoincorporation of an uncharged nicotinic competitive antagonist. J Biol Chem 267:15770-15783 Wilson GG, Karlin A 2001 Acetylcholine receptor channel structure in the resting, open, and desensitized states probed with the substituted-cysteine-accessibility method. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 98:1241 1248
DISCUSSION Roux: I am a little puzzled about the relationship between the charge distribution in the pore and how this channel is functioning. I would expect it to carry an inward current of cations normally. So why would negative charge far on the intracellular side be functionally useful? Unwin: Ions do go through in both directions. When the channel first opens, the driving force is mainly for Na+ to go towards the interior of the cell. But as the voltage changes across the membrane, there is an increasingly strong driving force for K+ to go in the opposite direction. The negative charge is relevant for encouraging K+ to go more efficiently through the channel. I suspect that there is an analogous process operating in the extracellular domain. Of course, you notice that it is a long cylinder 20 A in diameter; this means that residues lining the extracellular wall will have an effect on ions going through. One knows from looking at the sequences that each of the subunits contains on average about the same net negative charge on their extracellular surfaces as acetylcholinesterase. The negative charges on acetylcholinesterase are very important for bringing the acetylcholine cation into the active site. One could imagine the negative charges on the extracellular surface of the receptor, doing a similar thing to encourage cations to go in that direction as well. Lambert: The M3/M4 loop in the GABA receptor usually has some putative phosphorylation sites. Could these also interfere with cation conduction?
16
DISCUSSION
Unwin: I don't know the GABA receptor well enough to know exactly where they are. If the phosphorylation sites are located close to those windows, you would imagine they could have a pronounced effect. Corringer: I have a question about the location of the ACh binding site. If I understood you correctly, you see the binding site within the subunits, whereas in the ACh binding protein (AChBP) structure the binding site appeared to be at the interface between the subunits. Could the cavities seen in your images correspond to the cavities that are within the subunits in the AChBP structure, but which are not actually the acetylcholine binding sites? Unwin: Certainly, in Titia Sixma's structure, the binding site appears to be close to the interface, although we haven't seen ACh in the binding site yet. We assumed that the cavities in a subunits were the binding sites. In the light of Titia's structure, this may not be entirely accurate. There are definitely pronounced cavities in the a subunits, but it looks like the actual binding site is closer to the interface than we thought. Corringer: Perhaps they are not. We just compared the pictures, and the cavities within the AChBP subunits seem to fit nicely with the cavities you see in the a subunits by electron microscopy. Unwin: The cavities in the a subunits of the receptor are opened relative to those in AChBP. We know this because when we fit the polypeptide chains on one side of the cavity, those on the other side start moving into the cavity. However, when you look at the subunit found between the a subunits the fit is better, and this hasn't got much of a cavity at all. Sixma: Do you think this could be because we have HEPES bound and you are looking at something without anything bound, so we are looking at different states? Or is this an intrinsic difference between the nicotinic receptor and AChBP? Unwin: One could say that you are looking at the desensitized state and we are looking at the closed state. This is the analogy we would use. Perozo: Perhaps it looks different to the trained eye, but I can also see cavities in the other subunits, not only in the a subunits. Unwin: It is all a matter of degree. The a subunits have cavities with water in. They are about as prominent as the windows into the cytoplasmic vestibule, and we know that ions have to go through the windows otherwise the channel wouldn't work. The a subunit cavities are about 8 A across, and they probably have at least 10 water molecules in them. The cavity on the subunit that runs between the a subunits may have no water at all. The other two subunits do not really have cavities; they are more like grooves. We think that the cavities may be used for allowing ACh to access the binding site, because it will be drawn into the extracellular vestibule along with the other cations. Sixma: I think that is unlikely.
ACETYLCHOLINE-GATED CHANNEL
17
Unwin: I don't think you can say it is unlikely, because the structure is different in this region from that of the AChBP. Matbie: In the channel you are looking at, the muscle-type nicotinic receptors, the ions go equally well into the channel as they do out of the channel. But this is not true of some of the neuronal nicotinic receptors, which rectify and therefore don't carry ions outwards as easily. Do you think the cytoplasmic vestibules would be the best place to look for regions of the channel where there is this differential effect? Unwin: Yes, because individual residues can have a big influence here. Mindell: Related to that question, you hinted that there are not many sitedirected mutagenesis data in these areas, in the basket strands. Are there any mutations that have an effect? One would predict that there should be individual mutations of charged residues that have profound effects on ion conduction, and this may make a more strongly rectifying channel. Miller: Dr Sine's group (Bouzat et al 1994) have shown that changing the MA region from the gamma subunit sequence into that of the epsilon subunit changes channel lifetime. Unwin: If you don't see any effect, you could argue that there may be a lot of weak interactions adding up to produce a big overall effect. Mutation of just one residue may not do much. You may need to do a number of mutations at once, but this could of course change the structure of the channel and make the results uninterpretable. Sansom: Comparing your closed-state structure with your open model, what sort of change in radius do you see? Is it about 7 A in diameter in the narrowest region of the closed model? It looked a little bit larger in the open-state structure. Unwin: I reckon that it increases its diameter by about 4 A in the middle of the membrane when this channel opens. This makes it similar to the cavity in the K+ channel. Roux: If the closed channel has a pore of 7 A lined by hydrophobic residues, this wouldn't create an insurmountable barrier to permeation. This means that if a large potential was applied, there should be some detectable current. Has this been observed? Sansom: At least in simple models, I'm not even sure that water would enter, if the channel is purely hydrophobic and 8 A long. Roux: But even if the pore is 7 A wide? Sansom: Yes.
Perozo: Wouldn't you see streaming potentials? Mindell: If ions aren't going through, then perhaps you wouldn't see streaming potentials, but you should see water permeability. Jordan: Going back to the windows, are you saying that you think that when the ion actually passes through the window, it loses part of its hydration shell, or is
18
DISCUSSION
there concerted movement of the residues so that it can maintain its hydration shell? Unwin: When we fit the helices there, we know that the windows are very narrow. The widest part of the widest one is about 9 A. The other two are 8 A or less, so it seems that the ions do have to lose some of their hydration shell. Choe: I have a question about the outer rim. If we imagine we have b-stranded sheets here, the length of the transmembrane b sheets will require you to have more crossings, unless you tilt your strands sideways. How do you reconcile this with the fact that you have only three crossings to make based on sequences? If these are b strands how would they fit with your structure? Also, you mentioned that two molecules are disulfide-bonded in the tube sample: are these natural disulfide bonds? Unwin: Yes, in Torpedo disulfide bonds are naturally formed between the d subunit of neighbouring receptors — I don't think human muscle has them. The strands going through Ml probably fold about three times. This fits very well with the enterotoxin structure that Titia Sixma solved a long time ago in the bottom part of the membrane. If you fit this into the densities, the a helices in the two structures superimpose to within an angstrom or so. Corringer: From Coen's work it seems that M3 and M4 are predominantly coiled in an a helix. Can you see any rod-shaped structures in the transmembrane regions? Ijnwin: In the top part of the membrane there may be a bit of a helix. We don't really know. Miller: It is not just photolabelling that suggests that M4 is an a helix. LasaldeDominicci and McNamee (Tamamizu et al 2000) have recently performed tryptophan scanning of M4 and their results fit pretty well with the structure being an a helix. I don't recall anyone reporting an alternating pattern such as one might expect from a b sheet. Lambert: You mentioned that the a subunits appeared to have rotated clockwise in the open conformation. Do the other subunits also move? Are all of them going clockwise? I ask because Myles Akabas interpreted his results, in a model of the GABAA receptor, as indicating that one of the subunits moved clockwise and the other four subunits moved anticlockwise (Horenstein et al 2001). Do you have any information on the movement of the other subunits in the open conformation? Unwin: What we observed was that all the subunits change at the level of the binding sites, and then from the binding sites down to the membrane, the two a subunits seem to behave differently to the others. They seem to have rotations in the order of 4° clockwise. The other showed no significant change. Perozo: Do you detect any accommodation from the surrounding transmembrane segments? In the b barrel are you proposing that the structure also changes around the M2 helices?
ACETYLCHOLINE-GATED CHANNEL
19
Unwin: We couldn't detect any changes in the b barrel between the two. We had poor resolution and we took a fivefold average. I haven't looked closely at the structure before it was averaged, so there could have been some localized changes that got smeared out. Corringer: 1 have a question about the transition of activation and desensitization. Do you see any change in the structure of the cytoplasmic domain upon desensitization or activation? Unwin: Not on activation. We haven't looked in great detail, though. Corringer: So it could be a gating mechanism as well. There could therefore be two selectivity filters. Unwin: That is possible. Papazian: This question goes back to one that was asked earlier. If, as you propose, the outer rim of the transmembrane segment of the receptor is b structure, given what you know about the internal structure would you care to speculate about the number of strands that might be required to surround that structure? Unwin: It fits about the same number as enterotoxin. Choe: You mentioned the disulfide-bonded pentamers. Where would the disulfide bond be? Is it in the transmembrane domain? Unwin: No. Jean-Luc Popot and Don Engelman showed it to be on the extracellular side. It is at the cytoplasmic end of the d subunits. It is a very floppy linkage: we are often looking at dimers of receptors, and they can be 100 A apart, yet they are still dimers. Choe: Have you tried putting the entire pentamer into your electron density map? Unwin: No, we haven't tried this. Miller: Could you comment on Karlin's cysteine scanning and your model of how the helices swing and open? Unwin: There have been a number of different interpretations of the cysteine scanning mutagenesis experiments. One that fits our results very well is Paul Slesinger's analysis of the 5-HT3 receptor. As far as I can see this is 100% consistent, except they seem to have a helix going on a bit beyond the threonine 244 in their case. Mitra: According to Karlin's model the position of the gate is somewhat different from the location of the critical leucine in your model. Unwin: I think he agrees that this is a flexible part of the structure. He wouldn't agree that it is where the gate is located. They think that the gate for the closed channel is at the cytoplasmic surface. There was a recent paper in which they have done the cysteine scanning on the desensitized structure (Wilson & Karlin 2001). In the desensitized structure they have another gate that extends from the cytoplasmic surface up to that leucine. This is a critical region of the protein;
20
DISCUSSION
whatever you do to it will change things more than just simply substituting the residue. That leucine is the only part in our structure where the M2 helices come close to each other. It is a sensitive part of the structure. Miller: There is lots of space around the M2 helices in your model. If you were photolabelling with a hydrophobic agent like TID (3-[trifluoromethyl]-3-[miodophenyl]diazirine), would you expect to get labelling in the regions behind M2 or, as is observed, just the residues in the channel lumen? Unwin: Parts of the M2 segment have got water behind them, which does complicate things. Fu: I have a hard time understanding the channel gate. Does the channel gating process require bending a helices to open up an aqueous pore? As we know, the geometries of a helices are determined by a hydrogen-bonding network made by main chain carbonyl oxygens and nitrogens. When you distort a helices by disputing hydrogen bonds, you may have to disrupt the entire H-bonding network, not just a few local bonds. This means that channel gating may need a huge amount of activation energy in order to rearrange all H bonds in the distorted helices. Unwin: It is like a swivel. Sansom: Firstly, you might not have to actually break the H bonds to give a distortion of the helix. You could have a cumulative small change in several residues, which would at least give a banana-shaped helix. Also, if there is some water floating around there, then the cost of breaking a hydrogen bond in the helix is not going to be so large, as an alternative H-bond to a water may be formed. Choe: That gating does not involve breaking or reforming the helical H bonds. The helix is rotating in and out of the pore, so the helical H bonds have nothing to do with the gating energies. Unwin: I think it is a swivel. I would say that the residues are probably facing in the same direction in either case. Miller: You are drawing that essentially as a V-shaped helix in the cartoon. Is the axis of rotation along one of the edges of the V? Unwin: It is complicated. The top half moves backwards slightly, and the bottom half swivels inwards. Sansom: The other thing that might be consistent with the hinge is the profound effect of putting a proline in, as is seen in the slow channel syndrome. One of these mutations is a proline, just above where the leucine is (Ohno et al 1995). This has a pronounced effect on gating that would be consistent with having a hinge in that region. Tieleman: Do you have any idea which part of the protein interacts with the M2 helix? Unwin: We don't know. Presumably Ml, M3 and M4!
ACETYLCHOLINE-GATED CHANNEL
21
References Bouzat C, Bren N, Sine SM 1994 Structural basis of the different gating kinetics of fetal and adult acetylcholine receptors. Neuron 13:1395-1402 Horenstein J, Wagner DA, Czajkowski C, Akabas MH 2001 Protein mobility and GABAinduced conformational changes in GABAA receptor pore-lining M2 segments. Nat Neurosci 4:477-485 Ohno K, Hutchinson DO, Milone M et al 1995 Congenital myasthenic syndrome caused by prolonged acetylcholine receptor channel opening due to a mutation in the M2 domain of the e subunit. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 92:758-762 Tamamizu S, Guzman GR, Santiago J, Rojas LV, McNamee MG, Lasalde-Dominicci JA 2000 Functional effects of periodic tryptophan substitutions in the alpha M4 transmembrane domain of the Torpedo californica nicotinic acetylcholine receptor. Biochemistry 39:4666-4673 Wilson G, Karlin A 2001 Acetylcholine receptor channel structure in the resting, open, and desensitized states probed with the substituted-cysteine-accessibility method. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 98:1241 4248
The 2.7 A structure of AChBP, homologue of the ligand-binding domain of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor Katjusa Brejc*, Willem J. van Dijk*, August B. Smitt and Titia K. Sixma*1 * Division of Molecular Carcinogenesis, Netherlands Cancer Institute, Plesmanlaan 121, 1066 CXA msterdam, and' Department of Molecular and Cellular Neurobiology, Research Institute Neurosciences Vrije Universiteit, Faculty of Biology, De Boelelaan 1087, 1081 HV A msterdam, The Netherlands
A bstract. Acetylcholine binding protein (AChBP) is a novel protein with high similarity to the extracellular domain of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor. It is secreted from glia cells in the freshwater snail, Lymnaeastagna/is, where it modulates neuronal transmission. AChBP forms homopentamers with pharmacology that resembles the a7 nicotinic receptors. In the crystal structure of AChBP at 2.7 A, each protomer has a modified immunoglobulin fold. Almost all residues shown to be involved in ligand binding in the nicotinic receptor are found in a pocket at the subunit interface. This pocket is lined with aromatic residues, and filled with a HEPES buffer molecule. The AChBP crystal structure explains many of the biochemical studies on the nicotinic acetylcholine receptors. Surprisingly the interface between protomers is relatively weakly conserved between family members in the superfamily of pentameric ligand-gated ion channels. The lack of conservation has implications for the mechanism of gating of the ion channels. 2002 Ion channels—from atomic resolution physiology to functionalgenomics. Wiley, Chichester (Novartis Foundation Symposium 245) p 22-32
The nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (nAChR) has long been the prototype of ligand-gated ion channels, also known as Cys-loop receptors. This superfamily also includes the GABAA and GABAC, the glycine and the 5-HT3 serotonin receptors (Corringer et al 2000). These transmembrane receptors form pentamers of related subunits, in which each subunit consists of an N-terminal ligand-binding domain, four membrane spanning regions (M1-M4) and a short intracellular 1 This chapter was presented at the symposium by Titia Sixma, to whom correspondence should be addressed.
22
THE 2.7 A STRUCTURE OF AChBP
23
region (Corringer et al 2000). Extensive biochemical studies have defined the complicated ligand-binding sites that are found at the subunit interface. The binding of ligands goes through a complex cycle of activation and desensitization (Karlin & Akabas 1995, Changeux & Edelstein 2001). Structurally the proteins are well defined by the work of Nigel Unwin and colleagues, who have studied the Torpedo receptor up to a resolution of 4.6 A (Miyazawa et al 1999, Unwin 2000), but an atomic model has been lacking. In Guus Smit's group, at the Free University in Amsterdam, the fresh water snail Lymnaea stagnates is studied as a model system. It has large neurons that have been characterized very extensively. This precise knowledge allows the in vitro culture of specific, cholinergic synapses (Feng et al 1997). Upon electrophysiological analysis of such an in vitro system an interesting effect was observed when the synapse was cultured in the presence of glia cells. It was found that glia cells suppress the synaptic transmission (Smit et al 2001). After an extensive series of studies Smit et al (2001) showed that this is mediated by secretion of a novel protein, called acetylcholine binding protein (AChBP). The AChBP protomer contains 210 residues and shows high homology (~ 24% sequence identity) with the N-terminal domain of the a subunits of the nAChRs, but it lacks the transmembrane region entirely (Smit et al 2001). The conserved regions are the hallmarks of the superfamily of ligand-gated ion channels (15-20% sequence identity with e.g. GABA and 5-HT3 serotonin receptors). The recombinant AChBP protein, expressed in yeast Pichia pasforis, assembles into stable homopentamers. Furthermore, AChBP contains all the arnino acid residues needed for the ligand binding, showing pharmacology that is similar to a homopentameric nAChR, such as the neuronal a7 receptor (Anand et al 1993). Thus it binds better to nicotine than to acetylcholine (ACh) and binds very well to epibatidine. Nicotinic antagonists are binding as expected, but it also binds to some of the muscarinic antagonists (Smit et al 2001), an effect that has also been observed for the homopentameric a9 receptor (Elgoyhen et al 1994). We can therefore conclude that AChBP is a soluble homologue of a ligand-binding domain of the nicotinic receptors. The recombinant AChBP has been crystallized and its structure was determined with phases from multi-wavelength anomalous diffraction on a Pb-derivative in two different crystal forms (Brejc et al 2001). The electron density was improved by non-crystallographic and multi-crystal averaging across three different crystal forms. The AChBP model was refined in the P422}2 crystal form with one pentamer per asymmetric unit at 2.7 A resolution. The AChBP homopentamer, composed of five protomers, forms a doughnutlike structure with a radius of 80 A and height of 62 A (Fig. 1), conforming to the electron microscopy data for the nAChR (Miyazawa et al 1999). Each AChBP protomer has a modified imrnunoglobulin (Ig) topology (Fig. 2A) with relatively
24
BREJC ET AL
FIG. 1. Pentamer of AChBP, viewed along the fivefold axis. Possible subunit organization for the Torpedo nAChR is indicated.
long and twisted strands. Both b sheets have at least one extra b strand compared to the standard Ig fold (Fig. 2B). An Ig fold was predicted by Le Novere et al (1999) and Corringer et al (2000), but the additional strands were not predicted and the binding site is in a different location. Where the Ig fold has a so-called 'tyrosine cornerstone', a residue that is conserved across different Ig families (Bork et al 1994), a disulfide bridge (Cysl23-Cysl36) is found in AChBP. This disulfide bond is absolutely conserved in the superfamily of pentameric ligand-gated ion channels and has importance for the stabilization of the fold as shown by Blount & Merlie (1990) and Green & Wanamaker (1997). Its structural similarity to the Ig 'tyrosine cornerstone' may indicate that this disulfide bond has a structural role in keeping the two b sheets together. The residues involved in ligand binding in the muscle and Torpedo nAChR subtypes have been extensively investigated, and are found at the interface between an a subunit and a neighbouring subunit, forming primary and
THE 2.7 A STRUCTURE OF AChBP
FIG. 2. (A) Protomer fold of AChBP. The protein has an N-terminal helix followed by a b sandwich. The C-terminal residue would be the start of the transmembrane receptor in nAChRs. (B) Similar orientation of the immunoglobulin chain. Note the location of the 'tyrosine cornerstone'. This residue is not present in AChBP, but is replaced by the conserved disulfide bridge.
complementary parts of the binding pocket, respectively (Corringer et al 2000). The a-subunit residues important for binding are clustered in 'loop' regions, A (Galzi et al 1990), B (Dennis et al 1988) and C (Dennis et al 1988, Kao et al 1984, Sine et al 1994). The a subunit contributes the primary binding site, consisting of loop A, B and C. The neighbouring subunit, g or d, contributes 'loops' D (Chiara & Cohen 1997), E (Chiara & Cohen 1997, Chiara et al 1999, Sine 1997) and F (Czajkowski & Karlin 1995) (Table 1); in homopentamers the equivalent loops will be contributed by a subunits. In the AChBP structure all these 'loop' regions are indeed found to form a single pocket region at the subunit interface, with 'loops' A—C contributed from one subunit and D-F from another (Fig. 3). 'Loops' A, B, C and F are indeed
26
BREJCET AL TABLE 1 Numbering of ligand binding residues in AChBP, compared to Torpedo and muscle a1, g and d and human a7-subunits Loop
ACbBP
a7
A
Tyr89 Trpl43 Tyrl85 Cysl87
Tyr93 Trpl49 Tyrl90 Cysl92
Cysl88 Tyrl92
Cysl93 Tyrl98
B C
D
Trp53
E
Gln55 Argl04 Vall 06 Leull2 Metll4
F
7
d
a-
Tyr93 Trpl49 Tyrl88 Cysl90
Trp55 Glu57 Leu 109
Tyrlll Tyrll7
Trp57 Thr59 Leulll
Cysl91 Tyrl95 Trp55 Gln57 Leu 109 Asn111
Leull9
Argll 3 Thrl19 Leu 121
Gln117 Leull9
Aspl74
Asp 180
Asp 164
Tyrl64
structural loops in the structure, but the residues, contributed from 'loops' D and E are found on b strands. The pocket is lined by aromatic residues of loop A-D, while the hydrophobic components of the residues in loop E form the lid of the pocket. The Tyrl64 that is contributed from the loop F region is not conserved, and the variation in length and sequence in this area indicates that the region may form a somewhat different fold in other family members, contributing another residue to the binding site. In the experimental electron density extra features were observed in the ligandbinding site. This density was attributed to a HEPES buffer molecule that was used in crystallization. HEPES was found to bind with an IC50 of 100 mM, which could cause partial occupancy at the concentrations used. The HEPES buffer has a positive charged nitrogen atom, similar to acetylcholine (ACh). This atom stacks on Trpl43, in a similar fashion as expected for acetylcholine stacking on the equivalent Trpl49 in nAChR (Zhong et al 1998). The position of the HEPES molecule could not be unambiguously refined. It is likely that the lack of specific hydrogen bonds to this weakly binding molecule causes variability in position, while the site is not fully occupied as well. However, its general position presents a reasonable preliminary model for the ACh binding. The HEPES molecule is almost entirely buried in the structure, with both subunits contributing equal interface areas.
THE 2.7 A STRUCTURE OF AChBP
FIG. 3. Stereo representation of the ligand binding site of AChBP, principal side in light grey, complementary side in dark grey. For the equivalent residues in other receptors see Table 1.
The crystal structure of AChBP adds some additional data to the ongoing debate on the relative arrangement of subunits in the muscle and Torpedo form of the nAChR (Umvin 2000). According to our structure, the location of the binding site is such that any principal binding site has its complementary binding site in the anticlockwise direction (Fig. 1). There is considerable sequence conservation in the superfamily of ligand-gated ion channels (LGICs). The conserved residues are mostly found within the protomer, contributing hydrophobic residues to the core and hydrophilic residues to structurally important sites. This conserved core structure indicates that the overall fold of the other family members will greatly resemble the AChBP fold. The only conserved regions that are lacking in AChBP are the residues that form the so-called Cys loop. This region, connecting the absolutely conserved cysteines (123—136 in AChBP, 128—142 in Torpedo receptor) is a conserved hydrophobic region in the LGIC superfamily, but in AChBP it is one residue shorter and mostly hydrophilic. The loop is found on the membrane facing side (see Fig. 2) of AChBP, and probably interacts with the transrnembrane domain in the receptor, a region that is absent in AChBP. A major surprise in the structure is the lack of conservation of the subunit interface across the superfamily of LGICs. The residues that are forming the subunit interface in AChBP vary between superfamily members, including changes in character from charged to hydrophobic and vice versa, without the necessary complementary changes. Thus it can be concluded that the precise interactions in the interface are not very important for preserving the pentamer
28
BREJC ET AL
formation. Moreover they are apparently not essential for maintaining the mechanism of opening a channel in response to a ligand binding. This has implications for the possible mechanism of gating. Once a ligand is bound to the extracellular domain of the receptor, this will have to cause a signal that is relayed to the transmembrane domain. One possible mechanism is a pivoting motion about the ligand-binding site of the entire protomer. Such a rigid body motion would presumably cause a rearrangement in the transmembrane domain. Other mechanisms can be imagined, but the lack of conservation of the subunit interface would seem to imply that they may well be found in the protomer. Possibilities involve a movement of the 'loop' C b hairpin and a rearrangement of the b sandwich structure. It will be interesting to see whether AChBP itself will be useful as a model to study such ligand-dependent movements. AChBP does not have a transmembrane domain, and presumably would not need such a movement for its function. Further studies are needed to show whether this will be the case. However, the crystal structure of AChBP will undoubtedly be a starting point for studying such movements since it shows which regions of the sequence are found at certain sites in the structure and thus will provide new ideas for experiments. References Anand R, Peng X, Lindstrom J 1993 Homomeric and native a7 acetylcholine receptors exhibit remarkably similar but non-identical pharmacological properties, suggesting that the native receptor is a heteromeric protein complex. FEES Lett 327:241-246 Blount P, Merlie JP 1990 Mutational analysis of muscle nicotinic acetylcholine receptor subunit assembly. J Cell Biol 111:2613-2622 Bork P, Holm L, Sander C 1994 The immunoglobulin fold. Structural classification, sequence patterns and common core. J Mol Biol 242:309-320 Brejc K, van Dijk WJ, Klaassen RV et al 2001 Crystal structure of an ACh-binding protein reveals the ligand-binding domain of nicotinic receptors. Nature 411:269-276 Changeux JP, Edestein SJ 2001 Allosteric mechanism in normal and pathological nicotinic acetylcholine receptors. Curr Opin Neurobiol 11:369-377 Chiara DC, Cohen JB 1997 Identification of amino acids contributing to high and low affinity dtubocurarine sites in Torpedo nicotinic acetylcholine receptor. J Biol Chem 272:32940-32950 Chiara DC, Xie Y, Cohen JB 1999 Structure of the agonist-binding sites of the Torpedo nicotinic acetylcholine receptor: affinity-labeling and mutational analyses identify gTyr-111 dArg-113 as antagonist affinity determinants. Biochemistry 38:6689-6698 Corringer PJ, Le Novere N, Changeux JP 2000 Nicotinic receptors at the amino-acid level. Annu Rev Pharmacol Toxicol 40:431-458 Czajkowski C, Karlin A 1995 Structure of the nicotinic receptor acetylcholine-binding site. Identification of acidic residues in the d subunit within 0.9 nm of the a subunit-binding site disulfide. J Biol Chem 270:3160-3164 Dennis M, Giraudat J, Kotzyba-Hibert F et al 1988 Amino acids of the Torpedo marmorata acetylcholine receptor alpha subunit labeled by a photoaffinity ligand for the acetylcholine binding site. Biochemistry 27:2346-2357
THE 2.7 A STRUCTURE OF AChBP
29
Elgoyhen AB, Johnson DS, Boulter J, Vetter DE, Heinemann S 1994 Alpha 9: an acetylcholine receptor with novel pharmacological properties expressed in rat cochlear hair cells. Cell 79:705-715 Feng ZP, Klumperman J, Lukowiak K, Syed NI 1997 In vitro synaptogenesis between the somata of identified Lymnaea neurons requires protein synthesis but not extrinsic growth factors or substrate adhesion molecules. J Neurosci 17:7839-7849 Galzi JL, Revah F, Black D et al 1990 Identification of a novel amino acid alpha-tyrosine 93 within the cholinergic ligands-binding sites of the acetylcholine receptor by photoaffinity labeling. Additional evidence for a three-loop model of the cholinergic ligands-binding sites. J Biol Chem 265:10430-10437 Green WN, Wanamaker CP 1997 The role of the cysteine loop in acetylcholine receptor assembly. J Biol Chem 272:20945-20953 Kao PN, Dwork AJ, Kaldany RR et al 1984 Identification of the alpha subunit half-cystine specifically labeled by an affinity reagent for the acetylcholine receptor binding site. J Biol Chem 259: 11662-11665 Karlin A, Akabas MH 1995 Toward a structural basis for the function of nicotinic acetylcholine receptors and their cousins. Neuron 15:1231—1244 Le Novere N, Corringer PJ, Changeux JP 1999 Improved secondary structure predictions for a nicotinic receptor subunit: incorporation of solvent accessibility and experimental data into a two-dimensional representation. Biophys J 76:2329-2345 Miyazawa A, Fujiyoshi Y, Stowell M, Unwin N 1999 Nicotinic acetylcholine receptor at 4.6 A resolution: transverse tunnels in the channel wall. J Mol Biol 288: 765-786 Sine SM 1997 Identification of equivalent residues in the 7,g,dand e subunits of the nicotinic receptor that contribute to a-bungarotoxin binding. J Biol Chem 38:23521—23527 Sine SM, Quiram P, Papanikolaou F, Kreienkarnp HJ, Taylor P 1994 Conserved tyrosines in the alpha subunit of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor stabilize quaternary ammonium groups of agonists and curariform antagonists. J Biol Chem 269:8808-8816 Smit AB, Syed NI, Schaap D et al 2001 A glia-derived acetylcholine-binding protein that modulates synaptic transmission. Nature 411:261-268 Unwin N 2000 The Croonian Lecture 2000. Nicotinic acetylcholine receptor and the structural basis of fast synaptic transmission. Phil Trans R Soc Lond B 355:1813-1829 Zhong W, Gallivan JP, Zhang Y et al 1998 From ab initio quantum mechanics to molecular neurobiology: a cation-pi binding site in the nicotinic receptor. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 90:90319035
DISCUSSION Wallace: Does AChBP show the toxin binding specificity of the neuronal or the neuromuscular channel, and have you tried to look at toxin binding? Sixma: We haven't looked very carefully with all the different conotoxins yet. We are collaborating with a group in Israel on bungarotoxin binding, and they have a nice peptide structure of the C-loop contacts with this toxin (Harel et al 2001). It seems to fit well with our structure. Mindell: Now that you know about the AChBP in snails, when you look back at the genomes that have been solved can you find homologues in other phyla? Sixma: My collaborator, Guus Smit, has looked at this and tells me that it is difficult because the databases are not always curated particularly carefully. One is
30
DISCUSSION
never sure whether something is a bona fide N-terminal domain alone. So far we haven't found it. Schrempf: Have you any results that prove an interaction with another nicotinic receptor in the membrane? Sixma: No, we have not. It is possible, but we don't need to invoke such a mechanism to see the results we have obtained. There are nicotinic receptors in the glial cells that secrete AChBP in Guus Smit's in vitro assays. In addition, the glial cells themselves have nicotinic receptors. FM: How do the binding sites of your AChBP compare with acetylcholinesterase? This binding site also has many side chains. Sixma: The size of the cavity is roughly similar, but all the residues are different. I had a hard time deciding how to superimpose it. I decided on the tryptophan that stacks the positive ion. Then you see that the size of the cavity is the same and all the residues come from different sides. Choe: I have difficulty in understanding how you decide the subunit assembly arrangements, in order to predict the ACh receptor subunits. The ACh receptors are not homopentameric, and you mentioned that there is no high sequence conservation at the interface, yet your model is relying on the a subunit sequences in segregating principal sites and complementary sites. This doesn't exist in a common receptor channel, so you have to decide which one you want to keep as the interface. Sixma: In our structure, every subunit has both a principal and a complementary site. In modelling the arrangement, I tried to show the two most commonly debated models. The only thing we can do is exclude models that have the position of the ligand binding site clockwise with respect to its a subunit. I am not trying to predict anything about where a g or a d subunit should be; we are just using literature data. The only thing we are saying is that any model that has the binding site clockwise to an a subunit can not be true. Choe: That preserves the principal site as the ligand binding site. Sixma: Yes, that is the definition of the principal site. Sattelle: It appears that the secreted AChBP is acting as some sort of ACh sponge, mopping up extracellular ACh. Is much known about the dissociation kinetics of the protein compared with native receptors? Sixma: We don't have very detailed kinetic data yet. Choe: Thinking about the AChBP versus the ACh receptor, the physiological role of the binding protein is not necessarily transmitting conformational change, it is just soaking up the ligand. If you soak out HEPES and replace it with some other buffers, would you expect to see conformational changes? Sixma: With the Hill coefficients being less than 1, you would expect it to be different from the receptor, because there is no cooperativity (at least in this region). On the other hand, there is no transmembrane region, and this could
THE 2.7 A STRUCTURE OF AChBP
31
transmit the cooperativity in the receptor. We don't know whether AChBP will show similar changes. Choe: Have you tried soaking out HEPES or replacing it with other buffers? Six ma: We can grow the crystals in the absence of HEPES and in the absence of Ca2+. They grow in a similar way. Perozo: How good a ligand is HEPES for the ACh receptor? Sixma: I don't know. Umvin: What is the occupancy of the HEPES? Sixma: I think it is not fully occupied. The density is variable around the peritamer. We are trying crystallization experiments with ligands, but we are stuck with terrible twinning problems of the crystals. Unwin: The reason I ask is because if it is only partly there, and the structure changes when it is not there, you might expect to see some disordered regions in the electron density maps. Sixma: We do see a little bit of disorder in the C-loop that is not fully resolved. But not a lot. On the other hand, in this 20+10+5-fold averaged structure, we can follow the run of the main chain pretty well. There is not a lot of disorder in this structure. C3n the other hand, if 20-30% of the molecules were disordered, I am not sure you would lose that density entirely. It is hard to tell. Miller: I don't recollect that anyone has reported that HEPES activates ACh receptors. The known structure-activity relationships would make it unlikely to be an agonist or competitive antagonist. Have you tried to put something as large as an N-methyl group into the putative acetylcholine-binding pocket, and if so, can you make any conclusions about the orientation of the binding? Sixma: I have avoided this because I thought everyone else would do it. I think it is a similar size to HEPES, so it should fit. For bigger ligands, I think things would have to open up, which requires conformational changes. Miller: There is a prediction from NMR experiments that the angle formed between the CH2-NMe3 bond of acetylcholine and the membrane is 40° in the desensitized form of the receptor (Williamson et al 2001). This might provide a useful constraint for modelling. Roux: I am intrigued by the evolutionary origin of AChBP. How did it occur? Did a part of the gene for the ACh receptor just separate and assume an independent role? Sixma: Guus Smit and his group are trying to address this. They have cloned a whole series of ACh receptors from Lymnaeastagualis. It seems that AChBP is more similar to Lymnaea receptors than to other receptors, which would make sense. It is very similar to the superfamily, and most similar to the nicotinic receptors. Roux: If this is just an AChBP binding domain that arose de novo, it would just have to bind ACh; in other respects it could be completely different.
32
DISCUSSION
Sixma: It is definitely a family member because it is also well related to the 5-HT3 serotonin, the GABA and the glycine receptors. Sansom: On the percentage identities to different types of nicotinic subunits, Nigel Unwin was suggesting in the structure that the AChBP seemed to match the non-a more than the a. At the sequence level, does it show a higher percentage identity to a or to non-a? Sixma: It is closer to a, particularly because it has the principal ligand binding residues. Gulbis: Is MetlH at the top of the ligand-binding pocket in the protein present in the ACh receptor, and is there any evidence that it oxidises? Sixma: It is not necessarily a methionine. It is just contacting the HEPES by the hydrophobic part of the residue. Gulbis: In view of its similarity to choline, the bound HEPES molecule could be taken to indicate the position and orientation adopted by acetylcholine. Sixma: It is certainly not preserved as a methionine throughout the family, so I don't think it is likely to be that essential. Mathie: Is there an ion permeation pathway through the AChBP? Can you get information about how ions are passed through the central pore? Sixma: It is a wide pore of 18 A, so anything should pass through. It is lined with charged residues. If you compare it with other members of the superfamily, and if you just look at residues that are actually lining the pore, their position and order changes a lot. There is a slight excess of charges that fits with the type of ions that go through between the different channels, but I am not so sure that this is meaningful, I haven't really looked at the width and where they are located. The channel isn't equally wide all the time, there is a bit of an indentation in the middle. References Harel M, Kasher R, Nicolas A et al 2001 The binding site of acetylcholine receptor as visualized in the X-ray structure of a complex between a-bungarotoxin and a mimotope peptide. Neuron 32:265-275 Williamson PTF, Watts JA, Addona GH, Miller KW, Watts A 2001 Dynamics and orientation of N+ (CD3)3-bromoacetylcholine bound to its binding site on the acetylcholine receptor. Proc Nad Acad Sci USA 98:2346-2351
The architecture of a water-selective pore in the lipid bilayer visualized by electron crystallography in vitreous ice Alok K. Mitra*, Gang Ren*, Vijay S. Reddyt, Anchi Cheng* and Alexandrine Froger* *Department of Cell Biology and Department of Molecular Biology, The Scripps Research Institute, 10550 North Torrey Pines Road, Lajolla, CA 92037, USA
Abstract. The water-selective pathway through aquaporin 1 (AQP1) membrane channel has been visualized by fitting an atomic model to a 3.7 A resolution three-dimensional density map. This map was determined by analysing images and electron diffraction patterns of lipid-reconstituted two-dimensional crystals of AQP1 preserved in vitrified buffer in the absence of any additive. The aqueous pathway in a monomer is characterized by a size-selective, ~ 4.0 ±0.5 A wide pore that spans a length of ~ 18 A and bends by ~ 25° as it traverses the bilayer. This narrow pore is connected by wide, funnel-shaped openings at the extracellular and cytoplasmic faces, and is outlined mostly by hydrophobic residues interspersed with short stretches of polar amino acids, which results in relatively inert pathway conducive to diffusion-limited water flow. Although not visible at the current resolution, the 3D structure suggests putative binding sites for water molecules in the size-selective pore. 2002 Ion channels—from atomic resolution physiology to functional genomics. Wiley, Chichester (Novartis Foundation Symposium 245) p 33 50
In all living organisms, the entry and exit of water across the lipid biiayer membrane is a fundamental physiological process. Several observations over many decades (see Agre et al 1993, Verkman et al 1996, for review) suggested the presence of water-specific channels or pores in certain membranes in order to account for very high osmotic permeability for water that could not be explained based on ubiquitous passive diffusion. Agre and colleagues (Denker et al 1988) first made the biochemical identification of such a water channel upon isolation and characterization of a very abundant 28 kDa integral membrane protein (CHIP28) from human red blood cell membranes. CHIP28 was later renamed AQP1 (Agre 1997) to signify it as an archetypal member of the rapidly growing aquaporin family of proteins, whose members have been identified both in eukaryotes and prokaryotes. Aquaporins belong to the larger MIP (major intrinsic protein of eye lens) superfamily (Pao et al 1991) of integral membrane proteins. MIP members 33
34
MITRA ET AL
display diversity in the nature of the osmotic-gradient driven diffusion of molecules which include apart from water (in aquaporins), glycerol, purines, pyrimidines and other neutral solutes (in the aquaglycerporins) (Verkman & Mitra 2000, for review). The polypeptide sequences of MIP members are characterized by six major hydrophobic, membrane-spanning domains and homologous N- and C-terminal halves, each containing a highly conserved AsnPro-Ala tripeptide motif. The internal sequence homology probably arose by a tandem, intragenic duplication event (Wistow et al 1991). There is a general consensus that the AQP1 channel is permeated only by water, and excludes, for instance, small chemical species such as H+ and NH3 (Zeidel et al 1992,1994, van Hoek & Verkman 1992). However recent reports have implicated permeability to CO2 (Prasad et al 1998) and cation conductance (Yool et al 1996) that await detailed scrutiny. In vivo, AQP1 organizes as tetramers (Verbavatz et al 1993); but, several lines of evidence (see Verkman et al 1996) indicate that each monomer is a functional channel. The osmo-regulated, bi-directional passage of water through AQP1 is diffusion limited and corresponds to the flow of about 2-5 x 109 water molecules/second per monomer (Zeidel et al 1992, Engel et al 1994). Residues adjacent to the two NPA motifs have been linked to function in AQP1 (as also in other aquaporins) based on site-directed mutagenesis experiments (Jung et al 1994). For instance, Cysl89 in the second, extracellular NPA loop is the site of binding of mercurial reagents that leads to reversible blockage of water transport (Preston et al 1993). We describe here the 3.7 A resolution atomic model of AQP1 water channel in the membrane bilayer determined by electron cryo-crystallography. For this purpose, fully hydrated, vitrified two-dimensional crystals of AQP1, which were generated in synthetic lipid bilayers, were used to acquire crystallographic data. The three-dimensional structure reveals the architecture of the channel and provides insight into elements in the structure and the polypeptide sequence that may confer its exquisite selectivity for water. An atomic-level understanding of the rapid, trans-bilayer water flow through AQP1 not only elucidates a basic mechanism of membrane transport at the structural level but also provides a paradigm for understanding more complex channels such as the voltage-gated and ligand-gated channels. Materials and methods Fully hydrated, 2D crystals of deglycosylated, purified AQP1, while embedded in vitrified, crystallization buffer (20 mM NaH2PO4/Na2HPO4, 100 mM NaCl, 0.1 mM EDTA, and 0.025% NaN3, pH 7.1) (Mitra et al 1995) were examined at -180 °C in Philips CM12 and CM200FEG microscopes. 3D electron crystallographic data (amplitudes and phases) to 3.7 A resolution were extracted
ATOMIC MODEL OF HUMAN AQP1 WATER CHANNEL
35
by processing images and diffraction patterns of many tilted (up to 60°) views of the 2D crystal (Ren et al 2000a, 2001). Uniformly sampled values of structure-factor amplitudes and phases along least-squares fitted curves for the continuous transform normal to the 2D crystal plane were used to synthesize a 3D density map after weighting the amplitudes by the figure of merit (cosine of the estimated error in phase). The statistics of the electron crystallographic data are provided in Table 1. Based on the topology reported in Ren et al (200()a), an initial model was fitted to the experimentally determined 3D density map using the program O (Jones et al 1991). The model was refined against the 3D diffraction amplitudes (Grigorieff et al 1996) using the positional refinement protocol in XPLOR (Brunger et al 1987). The Rfree (Brunger et al 1987) and the free-phase residual (j free ) (Grigorieff et al 1996) were used to monitor the course of the refinement. In order to improve the map, a SIGMA A (Read 1986)-weighted 2FO-FC map was calculated that was expected to be devoid of the model bias in the side chain positions of the original best-fitted model (Ren et al 2001) and was used for optimization of side chain orientations. Results and discussion Based on the processed image areas, the phases used for calculating the density map were determined from an averaged view of ~ 7 x 105 tetramers (~ 3 million AQP1 monomers). The observed, overall, low phase residual of 25.7° and the good statistics of the diffraction data (Table 1) led to a density map whose quality was sufficiently reliable to allow the delineation of an atomic model (Fig. 1). Hitherto, all investigations to derive atomic or near-atomic resolution structures using electron crystallography have exclusively employed specimens preserved in sugars, such as tannic acid, trehalose or glucose, including the recent study of AQP1 structure reported by Murata et al (2000). Therefore, our 3.7 A resolution electron-crystallographic analysis represents the first investigation in which fully hyclrated specimens embedded in vitreous ice were used to arrive at an atomicresolution model allowing a delineation of the unperturbed, close to in vivo structure. The atomic model presented includes residues L9 to A232. No continuous densities for the rest of the residues were visible in the map. The 2Fo-Fc map calculated at the final stage (see Methods section) helped to improve locations of some of the side chains (Fig. 1A,B). Elaborate refinements of smoothed B-factor along the helices and along individual residues (Grigorieff et al 1996) or lipid positions seen in projection (Ren et al 2000b) were not attempted. The tandemly repeating N- and C-terminal halves of AQP1 are each comprised of three tilted transmembrane a helices and a short a helix adjacent to the NPA
MITRA ET A I.
36
TABLE 1 Electron crystallographic data Two-side plane group
P4212
Unit cell dimension
a = b = 99.58 ± 0.50 A, c = 100 A
Number of observed amplitudes
48037 19839
Number of observed phases Number of structure factors and overall completeness (100-3.7 A) In-plane resolution and estimated resolution normal to the bilaverb
3
2947, 63%
3.7 A, 6 A
Electron diffraction Resolution limit Maximum tilt Number of patterns
3.3 A 57.5 44 6.7-28.9%(15.8%>) 15.4-47.3% (27.5%)
Image
Resolution limit Maximum tilt Number of images Phase residuale in resolution Zones Overall
3.7 A 60.2C 72 (100-7.0 A) 20.0c (7-4.0 A) 39.7c (4.0 3.7 A) 557c (100-3.7A) 25.7c
Refinement statistics Rfactorf
35.0%,
Rfree f,g
45.1%
jfree
62.4C
a
With figure of merit >0.27. Maximum completeness for data up to 60" tilt is 83%. Based on calculation of point-spread function (Unger & Schertler 1995) for the experimental map.
b
e
Weighting based on amplitudes. Using electron diffraction amplitudes (> 2s) between 24—3.7 A. Calculation based on 5% of significant reflections not used in refinement. h Averaged difference between phases calculated from the model and the observed phases with figure of merit > 0.50. f
g
ATOMIC MODEL OF HUMAN AQP1 WATER CHANNEL
FIG. 1. A representative section of the 3D density map defining the density for the transmembrane helix TM6 in the (A) experimental and the corresponding (B) calculated, 2Fo-Fc map. (C) Stereo view of another section of the 2Fo-Fc map showing the region around the cytoplasmic edges of the transmembrane helix TM3 and the short a helix H1 in the first NPA loop. Some of the amino acid residues are marked. The maps in this and in the other figures were rendered at 1.0s of the mean density and were generated using the program AVS (Upson et al 1989).
38
MITRA ET AL
motif (TM1, TM2, TM3, H1 and TM4, TM5, TM6, H3, Fig. 2A). This is similar to the fold described in the two other reported, atomic-resolution structural studies of aquaporins (Murata et al 2000, Fu et al 2000). The long 3-4 inter-helix linker (Fig. 3A) containing a short a helix (H2) at the extracellular edge of TM3 connects the two halves. The TM3-TM4 linker dips in from the extracellular side towards the second NPA loop and at this location, highly conserved R195 (in all MIP sequence NPAR, except NPAV in g-TIP) is stabilized by a hydrogen bond with conserved N127 and a salt-bridge with D128 of the 3-4 loop (Fig. 3B). The observation of clear and continuous density for this trans-bilayer loop, possibly due to enhanced contrast (water versus protein in our case as against sugar versus protein in traditional high-resolution electron crystallography) proved to be very important in correctly defining the polypeptide topology based on our earlier, lower 4 A resolution, density map (Ren et al 2000a). The AQP1 monomers organize as tetramers as in vivo, consistent with the p4212 two-sided plane group of symmetry of the 2D crystal (Fig. 4A). The transmembrane helices in a monomer pack with an atypical right-handed twist (Walz et al 1997, Cheng et al 1997), whereas those at the monomer interface (TM4, TM5 of one monomer and TM1, TM2 of an adjacent monomer) in the tetramer are arranged with the more commonly observed left-handed packing. The spatial dispositions of the two halves of the monomer are according to an approximate, in-plane twofold axis of symmetry (Cheng et al 1997, Ren et al 2000a). The symmetry places the two short, transmembrane a helices TM2 (N-terminal half) and TM5 (C-terminal half) proximal near the fourfold axis and the two NPA loops, which are approximately, mutually orthogonal, vertically apposed and on the two sides of the symmetry axis. TM1, TM2, TM4 and TM5 define the interior of the monomer while TM6 and TM3, define the lipid-exposed exterior face (Fig. 2A). Adjacent helices in a monomer display elaborate hydrophobic packing interactions involving in some cases residues that are conserved in the aquaporin family. These include F18 (highly conserved) of TM1 with V107 of TM3; V50of TM2 with LI81 (conserved) of TM5; L139,1143 and L147 of TM4 with 1211, G215 (conserved), and G219, and A223 of TM6, respectively. The aqueous pathway through an AQP1 monomer is outlined by residues from TM1, TM2, TM4, TM5 and the short a helices H1 and H3. Figure 3B identifies schematically, residues that line or point into the channel. In Fig. 4B, the architecture of the monomeric channel is illustrated thorough a surface-rendered view of a transverse section through an AQP1 tetramer (Fig. 4A). The aqueous pathway is wide on both the extracellular and the cytoplasmic edges and tapers down like a funnel from both sides to form a narrow curved pore with an approximately uniform diameter of ~4.0db0.5 A and spans a distance of ~ 18 A through the interior of a monomer. The cytoplasmic and extracellular constrictions defining the two edges of this pore are ~ 9 A away from the
ATOMIC MODEL OF HUMAN AQP1 WATER C H A N N E L
FIG. 2. (A) Ribbon diagram for the polypeptide fold of an AQP1 monomer viewed from the extracellular face. The six transmembrane helices TM1 to TM6 and the short cytoplasmic (H1) and extracellular (H3) a helices in the two NPA loops and that (H2) at the extracellular edge of TM3 are indicated. (B) Demarcation of the polypeptide sequence of AQP1 into the observed a helices. Amino acids, whose side chains either line or point into the monomeric channel, are shaded. The mercurial-sensitive C189 and the analogous A73 are indicated.
40
MITRA FT AL
FIG. 3. (A) The extracellular density in the experimental map corresponding to the segment connecting the two halves of the monomer—the linker between helices TM3 and TM4. (B) Stereo view of the pocket around the highly conserved R195 in helix H3 indicating stabilizing interactions with residues N127 (conserved) and D128 in the TM3-TM4 linker.
locations of the NPA motifs, an observation that disagrees with results reported by Murata et al (2000). This narrow pore, which acts as the size-selective filter to exclude small solutes, bends by ~25° as it traverses the bilayer (Fig. 4B). The apex of the curvilinear pathway is close to the middle of the bilayer where the inplane pseudo twofold axis of symmetry is also located. Thus, the ~ 18 A long, narrow part of the channel includes a region of the molecule where the approximate twofold symmetry is the strongest (Cheng et al 1997, Ren et al 2000a), leading to a symmetrical environment that is consistent with observed bidirectional water flow (Meinild et al 1998). Such a curved pathway can also promote an increase in strain and/or disruption of hydrogen-bonded network of permeating water molecules. This in effect enhances the possibility that
ATOMIC MODEL OF HUMAN AQP1 WATER CHANNEL
41
FIG. 4. (A) A ribbon diagram for the quaternary organization of the AQP1 monomer viewed from the extracellular side. (B) Surface-rendered illustration of the AQP1 tetramer sliced through the middle (through the fourfold axis) revealing the curved water-selective pathway in the two adjacent monomers and the region around the fourfold axis as viewed parallel to the bilayer. Top is the extracellular side. The ~25° bend of the size-selective pore as it traverses the bilayer is indicated by arrows. The MSMS (Sanner et al 1996) program was used for surface rendering of the atomic model.
42
MITRA ET A I.
neighbouring residues in the surrounding protein, e.g. N76 and N192, could compete for hydrogen bonds (Murata et al 2000) with adjacent water molecules in the pore, thereby aborting H+ (Stilinger 1998) or OH~ conduction. Whereas mostly polar or charged residues line the entrances to the AQPl channel, the majority of the residues (~75%) outlining the ~ 18 A narrow part of the channel are hydrophobic (Fig. 2B) interspersed with polar residues, namely, N76, N192, HislSO, His74 and Ser28. Therefore, the surface presented to permeant water molecules in the interior, size-selective part of the channel is largely hydrophobic but with small polar regions to overcome the energy barrier. Such an arrangement results in a relatively non-interacting pathway for rapid diffusion in the absence of attractive energy minima that accompany an overall, polar environment. The dispositions of the two short a-helices (H1 and H3 in the two NPA loops, Fig. 2A) in the narrow pore are reminiscent of the pore helices in the structure of the K+ channel from Streptomyceslividans (Doyle et al 1998). In that channel, these helices are oriented so that the helix dipole moments act to attract K* near the centre of the bilayer. However, in AQPl, the orientation of each of the short helices is opposite to that in the K+ channel and will repel a cation near the bilayer centre. Also, the absence of an extensive polar lining in the AQPl channel means that it will be energetically expensive to locate a desolvated ion at the channel entrance while a hydrated ion including H3O+ and anions, which are almost always hydrated, are too big to pass through. In the cell milieu, water is the most concentrated species — the physiological concentration of water is ~ 55 M, many times higher than any other component, including common ions which occur in milli- to micromolar range. This fact alone will lead to a preference for osmotically driven flow of water through a size-selective pore that is designed for the passage of uncharged small solutes restricted by its diameter (~4.0±0.5A). Apart from the pores in each monomer, the region around the fourfold axis (i.e. at the centre of the tetramer) also represents a putative trans-bilayer pathway (Fig. 4B). In fact, on the basis of a 2.2 A resolution X-ray crystallographic structure determination of an aquaglyceroporin — the bacterial glycerol transporter GlpF — Fu et al (2000) have suggested that the pore at the centre of the tetramer transporter could act as a cation channel. They observed density peaks along the fourfold axis, which were assigned to two Mg2+ ions, one of which (at the extracellular face) was chelated by four symmetry-related glutamate (Glu43) residues. This region, bounded by symmetry-related mates of TM2 and TM5, has an irregular shape in the AQPl structure and, because of different inclinations of these two helices, has the largest diameter near the centre of the bilayer (Fig. 4B). The mouth of this pore is wider on the cytoplasmic side than on the extracellular side. At the extracellular side four symmetry-related Gln47 residues of TM2, which are in close apposition, constrict the diameter to
ATOMIC MODEL OF HUMAN AQP1 WATER CHANNEL
43
< ~3 A. The interior of this pore has a very hydrophobic environment, but includes LysSl of TM2 (analogous to Glu43 of GlpF), presumably protonated (raised pKa) or chelating an anion not resolved in the 3.7 A density map. Interestingly, Lys5l has been implicated in proper folding of AQP1 during maturation in the Golgi (Foster et al 2000). Currently, the exact functional role of the pathway around the fourfold axis in AQP1 awaits further, detailed analysis. Although, at 3.7 A resolution we cannot visualize permeant water molecules in the AQP1 channel, we can speculate on possible binding sites. In analogy with the situation in the 2.2 A resolution structure of GlpF (Fu et al 2000) one putative site is shown in Fig. 5A. At the extracellular face, Arg206, Trp48 and Phe200 form a glycerol-binding pocket in GlpF (Fig. 5B) and were suggested to comprise the selectivity filter (Fu et al 2000). The analogous pocket in AQP1 located at the extracellular constriction of the channel (Fig. 4B) contains similar highly conserved Argl95, and the aromatic Phe56, but now includes Hisl80, and Phe2()0 is replaced by mercurial sensitive Cysl89. We note that Hisl80 is conserved in mammalian homologues AQP0 and primarily water-transporting members AQP2, AQP4, AQP5 and AQP6 but is a variable non-polar residue in aquaglyceroporins (e.g. Gly in GlpF, AQP3 and AQP7, Val in Nod26). We suggest that Hisl 80 is an important residue which contributes to the selection of water over glycerol at this putative binding site in AQP1 that is slightly larger and relatively more polar than the aforementioned glycerol binding pocket in GlpF. Near the centre of the bilayer, a cluster of hydrophobic residues surrounding the absolutely conserved, polar Asn76 and Asnl92 characterize the middle of the sizeselective pore (Fig. 4B). Interestingly, a similar hydrophobic cavity in the retroGCN4 leucine-zipper structure (Mittl et al 2000) has been observed. Here, a wall of Leu and Val residues define the hydrophobic interior and two symmetry-related Asn residues are the only polar side chains that point into the core sequestering a pair of water molecules. It is possible that Asn76 and Asnl92 in AQP1 also participate in forming a similar binding site for water molecules (Murata et al 2000). Conclusions An atomic model of the human AQP1 water channel in the membrane bilayer was determined at 3.7 A resolution by electron cryo-crystallography of 2D crystals preserved in vitreous ice. The fully hydrated, unperturbed, close to in vivo structure reveals the architecture of the water-selective pathway through an AQP1 monomer. The aqueous pathway is characterized by a ~4.0+0.5 A wide, size-selective pore that spans a length of ~ 18 A and bends by ~ 25° as it traverses the bilayer. This narrow pore, outlined mostly by hydrophobic residues with short stretches of polar amino acids widens into funnel-shaped openings at both the
44
MITRA FT AL
FIG. 5. (A) Putative binding site for water molecules in AQP1 at the extracellular edge of the size-selective pore in the monomer. His 180 conserved in primarily, water-transporting mammalian aquaporins is suggested to have an important role in preferential binding of water. (B) The corresponding glycerol-binding site observed by Fu et al (2000) in the X-ray structure of bacterial glycerol transporter GlpF.
extracellular and cytoplasmic faces. Such an arrangement results in a relatively inert pathway conducive to diffusion-limited water flow. The atomic model suggests putative, water-selective binding sites at the extracellular constriction of the aqueous pathway and near the middle of the bilayer. The atomic-resolution structure of AQP1 provides a rational framework for not only exploring sitedirected, mutagenesis-driven experiments to fully understand selectivity but also for embarking on identification of pharmacologically useful modulators of
ATOMIC MODEL OF HUMAN AQP1 WATER CHANNEL
45
function though structure-based drug design and high-throughput screening of combinatorial drug libraries.
Acknowledgements We are indebted to M. Pique for generating the figures depicting pertinent features of the 3D density map. The research was supported by a grant from the National Institutes of Health, in part by a grant from the National Science Foundation and a special fellowship from the Cystic Fibrosis Research Foundation to AKM. AC and GR were supported by a post-doctoral fellowship from the American Heart Association Western Affiliate. VSR was supported by the MMTSB research resource RR12255 of NIH to TSRI. AKM is an Established Investigator with the American Heart Association.
References Agre P 1997 Molecular physiology of water transport: aquaporin nomenclature workshop. Mammalian aquaporins. Biol Cell 89:255—257 Agre P, Preston GM, Smith BL et al 1993 Aquaporin CHIP: the archetypal molecular water channel Am J Physiol 265:F463-F476 Brunger AT, Kuriyan J, Karplus M 1987 Crystallographic R factor refinement by molecular dynamics. Science 235:458-460 Cheng A, van Hoek AN, Yeager M, Verkman AS, Mitra AK 1997 Three-dimensional organization of a human water channel. Nature 387:627-630 Denker BM, Smith BL, Kiihajda FP, Agre P 1988 Identification, purification, and partial characterization of a novel Mr 28,000 integral membrane protein from erythrocytes and renal tubules. J Biol Chem 263:15634-15642 Doyle DA, Morais Cabral J, Pfuentzer RA et al 1998 The structure of the potassium channel: molecular basis of K+ conduction and selectivity. Science 280:69-77 Engel A, Walz T, Agre P 1994 The aquaporin family of membrane water channels. Curr Opin Struct Biol 4:545-553 Foster W, Helm A, Turnbull I et al 2000 Identification of sequence determinants that direct different intracellular folding pathways for aquaporin-1 and aquaporin-4. J Biol Chem 275: 34157-34165 Fu D, Libson A, Miercke LJW et al 2000 Structure of a glycerol-conducting channel and the basis for its selectivity. Science 290:481-486 Grigorieff N, Ceska TA, Downing KH, Baldwin JM, Henderson R 1996 Electroncry stallographic refinement of the structure of bacteriorhodopsin. J Mol Biol 259:393-421 Jones TA, Zou J-Y, Cowans S W, Kjeldgaard M 1991 Improved methods for building protein models in electron density maps and the location of errors in these models. Acta Crystallogr A 47:110 119 Jung JS, Preston GM, Smith BL, Guggino WB, Agre P 1994 Molecular structure of the water channel through aquaporin CHIP. The hourglass model. J Biol Chem 269:14648-14654 Meinild DA, Klaerke DA, Zeuthen T 1998 Bidirectional water fluxes and specificity for small hydrophilic molecules in aquaporins 0-5. J Biol Chem 273:32446-32451 Mitra AK, van Hoek AN, Wiener MC, Verkman AS, Yeager M 1995 The CHIP28 water channel visualized in ice by electron crystallography. Nat Struct Biol 2:726-729 Mittl PRE, Deillon C, Sargent D et al 2000 The retro-GCN4 leucine zipper sequence forms a stable three-dimensional structure. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 97:2562-2566
46
DISCUSSION
Murata K, Mitsuoka K, Hirai T et al 2000 Structural determinants of water permeation through aquaporin-1. Nature 407:599-605 Pao GM, Wu LF, Johnson KD et al 1991 Evolution of the MIP family of integral membrane transport proteins. Mol Microbiol 5:33-37 Prasad GV, Coury LA, Finn F, Zeidel ML 1998 Reconstituted aquaporin 1 water channels transport co2 across membranes. J Biol Chem 273:33123-33126 Read RJ 1986 Improved fourier coefficients for maps using phases from partial structures with errors. Acta Crystallogr A 42:140-149 Ren G, Cheng A, Reddy V, Melnyk P, Mitra, AK 2000a Three-dimensional fold of the human AQP1 water channel determined at 4 A resolution by electron crystallography of twodimensional crystals embedded in ice. J Mol Biol 301:369 387 Ren G, Cheng A, Melnyk P, Mitra AK 2000b Polymorphism in the packing of aquaporin-1 tetramers in 2D crystals. J Struct Biol 130:45-53 Ren G, Reddy VS, Cheng A, Melnyk P, Mitra AK 2001 Visualization of a water-selective pore by electron crystallography in vitreous ice. Proc Nad Acad Sci USA 98:1398-1403 Sanner M, Olson AJ, Spehner JC 1996 Reduced surface: an efficient way to compute molecular surfaces. Biopolymers 38:305-320 Stillinger FH 1980 Water revisited. Science 209:451-457 Unger VM, Schertler GF 1995 Low resolution structure of bovine rhodopsin determined by electron cryo-microscopy. Biophys J 68:1776-1786 Upson C, Faulheber TJr, Kamins D et al 1989 The application visualization system: A computational environment for scientific visualization. IFIEE Comput Graphic Appl 9:30-42 van Hoek AN, Verkman AS 1992 Functional reconstitution of the isolated erythrocyte water channel CHIP28. J Biol Chem 267:18267-18269 Verbavatz JM, Brown D, Sabolic I et al 1993 Tetrameric assembly of CHIP28 water channels in liposomes and cell membranes: a freeze-fracture study. J Cell Biol 123:605 618 Verkman AS, Mitra AK 2000 Structure and function of aquaporin water channels. Am J Physiol 278:F13-F28 Verkman AS, van Hoek AN, MaTetal 1996 Water transport across mammalian cell membranes. Am J Physiol 270-.C12-C30 Walz T, Hirai T, Murata K et al 1997 The three-dimensional structure of aquaporin-1. Nature 387:624-627 Wistow GJ, Pisano MM, Chepelinsky AB 1991 Tandem sequence repeats in transmembrane channel proteins. Trends Biochem Sci 16:170-171 Yool AJ, Stamer WD, Regan JW 1996 Forskolin stimulation of water and cation permeability in aquaporin 1 water channels. Science 273:1216 1218 Zeidel ML, Ambudkar SV, Smith BL, Agre P 1992 Reconstitution of functional water channels in liposomes containing purified red cell CHIP28 protein. Biochemistry 31:7436- 7440 Zeidel ML, Nielsen S, Smith BL, Ambudkar SV, Maunsbach AB, Agre P 1994 Ultrastructure, pharmacologic inhibition, and transport selectivity of aquaporin channel-forming integral protein in proteoliposomes. Biochemistry 33:1606—1615
DISCUSSION Tieleman: You gave a very accurate picture of the side-chains, but your resolution is only 3.7 A. How can you justify the detail in your pictures? Mitra: I wouldn't say that the side-chain positions are equally clear throughout the map. In the regions that I showed, the density is pretty clear and defines the
ATOMIC MODEL OF HUMAN AQP1 WATER CHANNEL
47
side-chain orientations well. At 3.7 A we can't be absolutely sure about the orientations, but we can make optimal models. Doyle: Structurally this channel is a tetramer, but functionally it is a monomer. Is there a reason why this is actually tetrameric? Mitra: It is not uncommon to have monomeric functional units in an oligomeric membrane protein. Bacteriorhodopsin is an example; it organizes as a trimer but individual monomers photocycle. GlpF has been shown to be functional even in a monomeric state. It could be that because the lengths of TM2 and TM5 in AQP1 are particularly short and insufficient to span the bilayer it is necessary to form an oligomer in order to sequester these helices away from the lipid. Also the tetramer formation may have an indirect structural role in the correct architecture of the monomeric pores. Perozo: I have always been fascinated by the size of the cavity in the fourfold axis symmetry, and this is blocked by this residue 47. An obvious experiment would be to mutate it and see whether the cavity then conducts either water or ions. Mitra: The role of this region is a matter of considerable interest in the MIP field. Unpublished experiments (A. van Hoek, personal communication) on AQP1 suggested that after inhibition by mercurials there is an onset of leaky pathway which, for instance, could be the cavity along the fourfold axis. Recently, Agre and colleagues (Saparov et al 2001) showed that in planar lipid bilayers containing AQP1, cGMP-induced ion conductance is elicited that is not blocked by pCMBS, presumably implicating an alternate pathway. Actually, ion conductance properties were first reported in 1996 by Yool and colleagues from the University of Arizona, work that was unfortunately received with a lot of suspicion. The conclusion is that the region around the fourfold axis may serve as another solute or ion pathway; however the exact role awaits careful investigation. Umvin: I have Dr Yoshi Fujiyoshi's structure in the back of my mind. I got the impression that their pore that the water goes through is shorter. You seem to have a long, narrow tube. Could there be a difference because of the glucose in their case and the water in yours? Mitra: I am not quite sure about the full, transverse nature of the pore in their structure. Unwin: I felt happy with the shorter pore because the protein is designed to be as efficient a water transporter as possible. You have this long tube which the water goes down. Mitra: In their model, the critical region is the narrow part near the bilayer centre. Unwin: The tube is quite wide further up, and presumably there is no problem with water transport there because the surfaces have polar groups on them.
48
DISCUSSION
Mitra: At least in the mouth of the pore, definitely. Auerbach: I am trying to relate this to Nigel Unwin's idea of a hydrophobic ring being a permeation barrier in the ACh receptor. You have a more extensive structure in the hydrophobic region. What are the dimensions of this region? Mitra: As I mentioned, there is uncertainty in the orientation of some of the side chains and therefore we present the pore diameter to be ~ 4 ±0.5 A. Mindell: Is there a continuous line of polar residues all the way down your pore which would be in contrast to Nigel Unwin's structure? Mitra: No, a majority of the side chains lining the narrow pore are hydrophobic, interspersed with some polar residues. For instance, Asn76 and Asnl92 lie in the middle of the bilayer surrounded by hydrophobic residues and analogous to a very similar arrangement seen in the retro-GCN4 structure (Mittl et al 2000). It is a fourhelix bundle with a very hydrophobic core but has two symmetry-related Asn residues binding two water molecules. Mindell: Outside that critical point, are there places where there are only hydrophobic residues all the way around the circumference of the pore? Mitra: Yes. Mindell: Roughly what percentage of the distance that a water molecule would have to traverse do they cover? Mitra: The total length on either side is about 9 A, so I would say 5—6 A. Miller: The other way to look at this is that you say that ions do not go through this pore, so it has to be hydrophobic in certain places, simply to act as a gate. Was this 4 A a radius or diameter? Mitra: Diameter. I would like to add that the way we were looking at the reasons behind selectivity was wrong. We were only thinking about what it could be that was making the channel selective for water. Instead, it appears that we should have been asking what it is that is making it deselective for other solutes. For instance, the two short NPA loop helices are oriented with their N-terminal pointing towards the middle, so that the centre of the bilayer is repulsive to cations. Anions are almost always hydrated, so they are too big to go through. In the physiological milieu, the highest concentration of anything present is water. It is almost a reverse way of looking at it. Jordan: How long is the narrow part of the pore? Mitra: It is narrow for about 18 A. Schrempf: How do you envisage the transport of ions in those members of the family that can transport water, glycerol and ammonium ions? Mitra: We carried out modest homology modelling for Nodulin 26, which is the subset of channels you mention. Nod26 is not quite a glycerol facilitator and not quite a water channel, but somewhere in the middle. In the model, there are some interesting differences, although overall, the nature of the residues lining
ATOMIC MODEL OF HUMAN AQP1 WATER CHANNEL
49
the selectivity pore is very similar. However there are hints as to residues that might be responsible for differences in transport properties. Schrempf: Many organisms have a set of several channel genes in parallel. Could you exclude the possibility that, as each monomer seems to act individually, there might be a heteromeric composition of several types of these subfamily members? Mitra: I suppose you are referring to the situation as in the case of gap junctions. It is an interesting idea, but I haven't thought about it. Choe: What do you think is filling up the cavity at the fourfold axis? In nature there cannot be a vacuum in the middle of a membrane. Mitra: Presumably, but we don't know: there could be bound detergent, or lipids, or even vacuum. Choe: It could be a space-buffering zone. Mitra: I can't say what the situation is in vivo, Mindell: Peter's ion channel aquaporins seem to be anion channels. I am intrigued that you see this lysine right in the central pore. Is that lysine conserved among the whole family? Mitra: No, it is not. For instance, it is a glutamate in GlpF, which in the X-ray structure binds to a putative Mg2+ ion. It has been shown that Lys5l, at least in the context of AQP1, might be important for proper folding. Foster et al (2000) showed that in the endoplasmic reticulurn (ER), AQP1 does not have the traditional four-transmembrane topology. When they swapped a small analogous segment from AQP4, where this residue is leucine, AQP4 displayed similar abnormal topology in ER. Mindell: Does AQP6 also have the lysine? Mitra: No, this residue is glutamine: interestingly AQP6 was shown to be an anion channel from experiments in oocytes. Fu: In your electron density map, did you see channel-like cavity in the centre of the tetramer, which would suggest AQP1 may have a tetrameric channel? Mitra: At the current resolution we did not see any resolved density for candidate ions. Ashcroft: We heard earlier that the acetylcholine channel is closed by a hydrophobic gate. In the discussion there was an argument about whether water could go through this gate or not, and the feeling was that it didn't. Here we have another hydrophobic section: why is the water going through in this case? Sansom: It is not as hydrophobic. I don't want to disagree with Alok, but it would seem that the water channel and the GlpF channel are rather more amphipathic, in that if you cut sections through the channel, in most regions there is a polar side chain somewhere along it. Unwin: The acetylcholine has an extensive region of hydrophobicity that is about 8 or 9 A in length.
50
DISCUSSION
Mitra: Ours is not that long. We expected that as water goes through, there should be polar residues. From this point of view we were quite surprised to find the hydrophobic regions. Sansom: One hesitates to extrapolate from simulations to the real world, but maybe if you have something that is highly polar it is more likely to bind water. As you said, in this pore the water is barely pausing on its way through. If you only do a calculation of the geometry of the pore with water going in at diffusion-limited rates, it can barely match the rate of water going through AQP. Mathie: Is the channel gated at all? Mitra: Anthony et al (2000) have indicated in oocyte experiments that cloned AQP1 displays gating by cGMP, although the result has not been widely accepted. There are other members that have been shown to be regulated by phosphorylation or by pH. Mathie: In that case, would you imagine that the hydrophobicity of the pore region should be changed when it is gated? Mitra: I doubt that. For example, in Nod26, the site of phosphorylation is on the very flexible C-terminus. It is intriguing how it affects the channel. Sattelle: In the aquaporins, are there any naturally occurring mutations in the channel-lining residues? In the nicotinic receptors such mutations have been very instructive; they include mutations responsible for congenital myasthenias and one form of epilepsy. Mitra: AQP2 is one aquaporin that is directly implicated in the disesase nephrogenic diabetes insipidus. Different single-site mutations have been considered to be responsible for this disease. One such residue is Argl87 analogous to Argl95 which is at the extracellular mouth of the selectivity pore in AQP1. References Anthony TL, Brooks HL, Boassa D et al 2000 Cloned human aquaporin-1 is a cyclic GMP-gated ion channel. Mol Pharmacol 57:576-588 Foster W, Helm A, Turnbull et al 2000 Identification of sequence determinants that direct different intracellular folding pathways for aquaporin-1 and aquaporin-4. J Biol Chem 275:34157-34165 Mittl PR, Deillon C, Sargent D et al 2000 The retro-GCN4 leucine zipper sequence forms a stable three-dimensional structure. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 97:2562-2566 Saparov SM, Kozono D, Rothe U, Agre P, Pohl P 2001 Water and ion permeation of aquaporin1 in planar lipid bilayers. Major differences in structural determinants and stoichiometry. I Biol Chem 276:31515-31520
The structure of GlpF, a glycerol conducting channel Dax Fu, Andrew Libson* and Robert Stroud* Biology Department, Bmlding463, 50 Bell Avenue, Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, NY 11973 and *Macromolecular Structure Group, Department of Biochemistry and Biophysics, Room S-964, Box 0448, University of California San Francisco, San Francisco, CA 94143-0448, USA
Abstract. The passage of water or small neutral solutes across the cell membrane in animals, plants and bacteria is facilitated by a family of homologous membrane channels, variously known as aquaporins though perhaps more correctly as aquaglyceroporins. The glycerol facilitator (GlpF) is a 28 kDa aquaglyceroporin that catalyses transmembrane diffusion of glycerol and certain linear polyhydric alcohols in Escherichia coli. X-ray crystallographic analysis of GlpF to 2.2 A resolution revealed an a-barrel structure, surrounded by six full-length transmembrane helices and two halfspanning helices that are joined head-to-head in the middle of the membrane. These helices are arranged to a quasi twofold manner relative to the central membrane plane, where highly conserved residues make helix-to-helix contacts that stabilize the relative position and orientation of the helices in the structure. This sequence-structure correlation suggests that the evolutionary divergence of aquaporins and aquaglyceroporins is constrained by a conserved structural framework within which specialized function may be developed. Three glycerol molecules were resolved in the central channel through the GlpF monomer, thereby defining a transmembrane channel for glycerol permeation. The structure of glycerol—GlpF complex provides insight into the chemical basis for transmembrane selective permeability. 2002 Ion channels — from atomic resolution physiology to functional genomics. Wiley, Cbtchester ( Novartis Foundation Symposium 245) p 51-65
Fluid balance is a ubiquitous biological process in all living organisms. The molecular basis of the rapid transmembrane flux of water and small nonelectrolytes remained elusive until the recent discovery of a superfamily of fluidtransporting membrane channels (Preston & Agre 1991, Preston etal 1992). On the basis of their permeability properties, these channels are subdivided into aquaporins — a subfamily of strict water-selective channels, and aquaglyceroporins — a homologous subfamily of less selective channels with permeability for small neutral solutes such as glycerol (Borgnia et al 1999a). 51
52
FU ET AL
The fundamental importance of aquaporins and aquaglyceroporins is attested by their strong genetic conservation from bacteria to plants and humans (Park & Saier 1996, Heymann & Engel 2000). More than 180 aquaporins and aquaglyceroporins have been identified in organisms ranging from bacteria to mammals, including 10 human isoforms (AQPO-9). The Escherichia coli aquaporin AQPZ and aquaglyceroporin GlpF share 20-25% pair-wise sequence identity with each other, and with all human isoforms identified thus far (Unger 2000, Beitz & Schultz 1999). This extensive sequence similarity indicates that AQPZ and GlpF are part of the development that leads to the human evolutionary tree. Functional studies of human aquaporins and aquaglyceroporins have been facilitated by the use of homologous E. coli isoforms. AQPZ and GlpF have been overexpressed, extracted from the membrane using non-ionic detergents and then purified to homogeneity in detergent micelles (Borgnia & Agre 2001). At the protein level, reconstitution of pure AQPZ or GlpF into liposomes makes it possible to examine transmembrane fluxes of water or glycerol by monitoring swelling or shrinkage of membrane vesicles in response to a transmembrane osmotic gradient (Agre et al 1999, Verkman 2000a). The rates of solute fluxes through these channels are diffusion limited, suggesting that AQPZ and GlpF function as channels rather than transporters. The channel selectivity was also examined, showing that AQPZ specifically increases water osmotic permeability (Calamita et al 1995) whereas GlpF increases glycerol (Maurel et al 1994) and water (Borgnia & Agre 2001) permeability. In addition, GlpF is permeable to certain polyols and antimonite (Heller et al 1980, Sanders et al 1997). At the organ level, the physiological significance of human aquaporins was implicated by phenotype analysis of aquaporin knockout mice and by pathophysiological studies of human aquaporin deficient diseases such as nephrogenic diabetes insipidus (Verkman et al 2000, Verkman 1999, Agre 1998). It is evident that human aquaporins can facilitate near iso-osmolar transepithelial fluid absorption and secretion, as well as rapid water movement driven by osmotic gradients (Verkman 2000b). Recent cloning of AQP8 from adipose tissue suggests that aquaglyceroporin is involved in glycerol release and body energy balance that may be relevant to obesity (Kishida et al 2000). Structural analysis has led to the determination of the general channel architectures of AQP1 (Cheng et al 1997, Walz et al 1997, Murata et al 2000) and GlpF (Braun et al 2000, Fu et al 2000). The structure of human red cell AQP1 was determined to 3.8x6.5 A resolution by electron crystallography (Murata et al 2000). More recently, we determined the structure of GlpF by X-ray crystallography to 2.2 A resolution (Fu et al 2000). Arrangements of amino acid side chains and chemical groups along the GlpF transmembrane channel are revealed at this higher resolution, together with three bound glycerol molecules. AQP1 and GlpF are strikingly similar structures. Both crystallize as tetramers, with
STR UCTURE OF GlpF
53
FIG. 1. Ribbon representation of GlpF monomer (from a perspective viewed in parallel to the membrane plane) with two glycerol molecules bound in the middle of the channel.
each monomeric subunit as an asymmetric unit. The monomers are folded as an a-barrel structure, with a central channel surrounded by six full-length transmembrane helices and two half-spanning helices that are joined head-tohead in the middle of the membrane to give the appearance of a kinked transmembrane span (Fig. 1). In both AQP1 and GlpF, an internal quasi-twofold symmetry is evident. Superimposition of main chains of two halves of the GlpF
54
FIG. 2. xylitol.
FU ET A L
Stereo arrangements of OH groups with respect to the alkyl backbones of ribitol and
showed a close match with a root-mean-square deviation of 1.4 A. The arrangement of the two halves in the structure creates an overall symmetrical relationship with respect to a quasi-twofold axis in the central membrane plane. This quasi-twofold structure corresponds to the two tandem repeats in the linear sequence that may have arisen from an intragenic gene duplication event (Wistow etal1991).
Channel permeability and selectivity Fluxes of water and polyols through AQPZ or GlpF channels have been monitored in real time using stopped-flow light scattering measurements (Borgnia et al 1999b, Borgnia & Agre 2001, Fu et al 2000). Permeability through the AQPZ channel was only observed for water, but not for any other neutral solutes. By comparison, GlpF was found to be permeable to a range of linear polyols of different chain lengths and to water at a slower rate compared with the rate through AQPZ (Borgnia & Agre 2001). In light of this flexibility for different sizes of polyols, it came as a surprise to find that the rate of ribitol flux was sevenfold faster than that of its stereoisomer xylitol (Heller et al 1980). The only difference between ribitol and xylitol is the stereo configuration of one OH group with respect to the alkyl backbone (Fig. 2). This result showed that GlpF is selective for one stereoisomer over another. The GlpF structure explains how permeability to multiple solutes can be reconciled with stringent stereo-selectivity (Fu et al 2000). The channel lining is strongly amphipathic, with oxygens and nitrogens lined up on one side and carbons on the opposite side of the lumen surface. This amphipathic channel uniquely matches the chemical structure of glycerol and other polyols, which are composites of the polar hydroxyl group arranged on a non-polar alkyl backbone. Of particular interest is the exquisite hydrogen bonding network seen at the narrowest constriction of the channel, where two consecutive OH groups of a polyol molecule are oriented with ideal geometry with respect to the donors and acceptors from within the channel, thus positioning the donor-acceptor pairs at
STRUCTURE OF GlpF
55
FIG. 3. Schematic diagram showing the process of stereo selective permeation. A polyol molecule passes through the narrowest constriction of the GlpF channel where each of two consecutive OH groups satisfies the double hydrogen bonding geometry imposed by the hydrogen donor and acceptor groups located on the hydrophilic side of the GlpF channel.
about 120° in relation to each of two successive OH groups of the polyol (Fig. 3). As a polyol proceeds through the channel, each pair of successive OH groups has to satisfy this double H-bonding geometry. Thus, the narrowest constriction imposes a stereo selection upon the relative orientation of OHs, regardless of the chain length. This structure satisfactorily explains why ribitol is more permeable than xylitol, because all OHs in ribitol are on one side of the alkyl backbone (Fig. 3), matching with the arriphipathic channel, whereas in xylitol one OH is on the opposite side of the backbone. Common to AQPZ and GlpF is the absolute exclusion of ions (Fu et al 2000, Murata et al 2000). The first barrier against ion entry is made by electrostatic repulsion between NHs of the guanidimurn group of R206 and the carbonyl oxygens of G199 and F200 at the narrowest constriction of the channel. The negative charges on carbonyls are enhanced by a buried carboxyl of El 52 that interacts with main chain nitrogens of G199 and F200. These charge pairs are lined up at a 4 A-wide constriction, thus only allowing passage of dipoles that can interact with positive and negative charges simultaneously. Neither a cation nor an anion can fulfil this dual role of polarization. Both R206 and El 52 are
56
FU ET AL
invariant, suggesting that these residues are conserved across all aquaporins and aquaglyceroporins to exclude ions. The second barrier of ionic exclusion is imposed by an insurmountable activation energy for removing water of hydration from a passing ion in the hydrophobic sector of the membrane, where the cross-section of GlpF channel is only large enough to fit one fully dehydrated ion, but the hydrophobic side of the lumen provides no replacement for water of hydration on the entire hydrophobic face. By comparison, the K + -conducting channel (KcsA) contains a stack of carbonyl rings at its narrowest constriction, thus affording negatively charged oxygens to coordinate with a passing potassium ion and replace its water of hydration (Doyle et al 1998, Roux et al 1999). The GlpF structure at 2.2 A resolution provides the first structural and chemical clues as to the mechanism of channel-selective permeability. This crystal structure represents a snapshot in the permeation process that could be hypothesized as follows. Upon entry to the channel on the extracellular side, a glycerol molecule first meets with three highly constrained carbonyl oxygens and two nitrogens at the narrowest constriction, followed by two nitrogens in the centre of the channel, and then another set of three carbonyl oxygens on the cytoplasmic side. These two sets of carbonyl triplets and two central nitrogens are arranged in a closely spaced sequential order, serving as surrogate waters to form H-bonds with OH groups of a passing glycerol (Fig. 4). It is not clear how these H-bond acceptors and donors interact with waters before a glycerol molecule enters the channel. Furthermore, we do not know the sequential order of transmembrane events that occur in the permeation process. A glycerol molecule might move down the channel in a stepwise fashion by exchanging one set of H-bonds with the next in line. Alternatively, permeation may be carried out as a series of thermally activated jumps along several distinct binding sites in the channel (Lauger & Apell 1982). These hypotheses could be clarified by further crystallographic analysis of GlpF in complex with water and other polyols. Conserved structure framework The heritage of sequence conservation in the aquaporins and aquaglyceroporins is well preserved in protein structure from bacteria to mammals. Superposing peptide backbones of GlpF and human AQP1 shows a close alignment with a root-mean-square deviation of 1.8 A, indicating that GlpF and AQP1 are essentially built upon a common structural framework. The GlpF structure reveals how tertiary interactions hold together the structural framework. The building block for GlpF is made of a helices with regular geometry as seen in many other proteins. What makes GlpF unique is the inter-helix crossing-over packing that determines the positions and orientations of helices in the structure. Crossing contacts in GlpF occur within helical bundles of M2-M1-M4—M3 and
STRUCTURE OF GlpF
57
FIG. 4. Atomic interactions in the GlpF channel reveal the structural basis of selective permeation.
M6-M5-M8-M7 (Fu et al 2000). These two bundles are joined by an anti-parallel interaction between M2 and M6 on one side of the channel. On the other side, the two half-spanning helices M3 and M7 close up the channel by a head-to-head interaction at the conjunction of two NPA motifs (Fig. 1). Furthermore, constrained by the quasi-twofold internal symmetry, all crossing contacts in GlpF are coplanar with the quasi-twofold axis in the central membrane plane
58
FU
ET AL
FIG. 5. The conserved structure framework in aquaporin and aquaglyceroporin superfamily. All interhelical contacts in GlpF are localized to the central membrane plane. Highly conserved residues involved in helix-helix contacts are shown in CPK representation.
(Fig. 5). Outward from this plane, helices diverge to form the two vestibules on each side of the membrane (Fu et al 2000). The GlpF structure suggests that the transmembrane architecture of aquaporins and aquaglyceroporins are strongly constrained by a few key tertiary interactions that are localized to the central membrane plane. Structure—sequence correlation shows that most inter-helix contacts in GlpF are made by invariant or highly conserved resides, including four glycines, G49, G96, Gl 84 and G243. Far from the usual role in disrupting a helices, these glycines allow the closest approach of helices in the central membrane plane. Perpendicular to the membrane plane is the transmembrane channel, which contains seven functional
STRUCTURE OF GlpF
59
determinant residues, including G199, G64, N68, N203 and three charged residues, R206, El 4 and El 52. All these residues are extremely conserved from bacteria to mammals. These locations of highly conserved residues suggest that aquaporins and aquaglyceroporins are related and probably descend from a common evolutionary origin. The evolutionary divergence has been constrained by an almost absolute conservation in helix-to-helix contacts and in positions that are principal determinants for transmembrane function. Therefore, human isoforms may be built upon a conserved structural framework. Specialized functions may be developed through natural selection of mutational drifts of non-structural components. The structure of GlpF could be used as a template to model human isoforms with adequate treatments of side chain rotamers.
Future studies The crystal structure of GlpF provides the first snapshot of the transmembrane permeation process in aquaporins, and unveiled a conserved structural framework within which specialized functions may be developed in human isoforms. Molecular dynamic simulations may reveal a detailed picture of atomic motions in the process of transmembrane selective permeation. Structure—function studies may lead to identification of functional determinants in human isoforms. The assignment of functional roles to key residues in sequences of human channels is crucial to understand the genetic consequences of human polymorphisms in aquaporins and aquaglyceroporins, thereby providing the structural basis for genetic diagnosis of disease or disease risk caused by genetic variations of certain human determinant residues.
Acknowledgements We thank T. Earnest for help and support at the Advanced Light Source (ALS), Lawrence Berkley National Library, J. Krucinski for assistance in crystallization, L. Miercke for assistance in protein purification, and Drs P. Maloney, S. Sine and P. Freimuth for discussion. This work was supported by an NIH grant GM24485 to RMSDF and AL received postdoctoral support from NIH.
References Agre P 1998 Aquaporin null phenotypes: the importance of classical physiology. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 95:9061-9063 Agre P, Mathai JC, Smith BL, Preston GM 1999 Functional analyses of aquaporin water channel proteins. Methods Enzymol 294:550-572 Beitz E, Schultz JE1999 The mammalian aquaporin water channel family: a promising new drug target. Curr Med Chem 6:457-467
60
FU ET AL
Borgnia MJ, Agre P 2001 Reconstitution and functional comparison of purified GlpF and AqpZ, the glycerol and water channels from Escherichia coli. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 98:2888-2893 Borgnia MJ, Nielsen S, Engel A, Agre P 1999a Cellular and molecular biology of the aquaporin water channels. Annu Rev Biochem 68:425-458 Borgnia MJ, Kozono D, Calamita G, Maloney PC, Agre P 1999b Functional reconstitution and characterization of AqpZ, the E. coli water channel protein. J Mol Biol 291:1169-1179 Braun T, Philippsen A, Wirtz S et al 2000 The 3.7A projection map of the glycerol facilitator GlpF: a variant of the aquaporin tetramer. EMBO Rep 1:183-189 Calamita G, Bishai WR, Preston GM, Guggino WB, Agre P 1995 Molecular cloning and characterization of AqpZ, a water channel from Escherichia coli. J Biol Chem 270:29063-29066 Cheng A, van Hoek AN, Yeager M, Verkman AS, Mitra AK 1997 Three-dimensional organization of a human water channel. Nature 387:627-630 Doyle DA, Morais Cabral J, Pfuetzner RA et al 1998 The structure of the potassium channel: molecular basis of K+ conduction and selectivity. Science 280:69-77 Fu D, Libson A, Miercke LJ et al 2000 Structure of a glycerol-conducting channel and the basis for its selectivity. Science 290:481-486 Heller KB, Lin EC, Wilson TH 1980 Substrate specificity and transport properties of the glycerol facilitator of Escherichia coli. J Bacteriol 144:274-278 Hermann JB, Engel A 2000 Structural clues in the sequences of the aquaporins. J Mol Biol 295:1039-1053 Kishida K, Kuriyama H, Funahashi T et al 2000 Aquaporin adipose, a putative glycerol channel in adipocytes. J Biol Chem 275:20896-20902 Lauger P, Apell HJ 1982 Jumping frequencies in membrane channels. Comparison between stochastic molecular dynamics simulation and rate theory. Biophys Chem 16:209-221 Maurel C, Reizer J, Schroeder JI, Chrispeels MJ, Saier MH Jr 1994 Functional characterization of the Escherichia coli glycerol facilitator, GlpF, in Xenopus oocytes. J Biol Chem 269:1186911872 Murata K, Mitsuoka K, Hirai T et al 2000 Structural determinants of water permeation through aquaporin-1. Nature 407:599-605 Park JH, Saier MH Jr 1996 Phylogenetic characterization of the MIP family of transmembrane channel proteins. J Membr Biol 153:171-180 Preston GM, Agre P 1991 Isolation of the cDNA for erythrocyte integral membrane protein of 28 kilodaltons: member of an ancient channel family. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 88: 11110-11114 Preston GM, Carroll TP, Guggino WB, Agre P 1992 Appearance of water channels in Xenopus oocytes expressing red cell CHIP28 protein. Science 256:385-387 Roux B, MacKinnon R 1999 The cavity and pore helices in the KcsA K+ channel: electrostatic stabilization of monovalent cations. Science 285:100-102 Sanders OI, Rensing C, Kuroda M, Mitra B, Rosen BP 1997 Antimonite is accumulated by the glycerol facilitator GlpF in Escherichia coli. J Bacteriol 179:3365-3367 Unger VM 2000 Fraternal twins: AQP1 and GlpF. Nat Struct Biol 7:1082-1084 Verkman AS 1999 Lessons on renal physiology from transgenic mice lacking aquaporin water channels. J Am Soc Nephrol 10:1126-1135 Verkman AS 2000b Physiological importance of aquaporins: lessons from knockout mice. Curr Opin Nephrol Hypertens 9:517-522 Verkman AS 2000a Water permeability measurement in living cells and complex tissues. J Membr Biol 173:73-87 Verkman AS, Yang B, Song Y, Manley GT, Ma T 2000 Role of water channels in fluid transport studied by phenotype analysis of aquaporin knockout mice. Exp Physiol 85:233S-241S
STRUCTURE OF GlpF
61
Walz T, Hirai T, Murata K et al 1997 The three-dimensional structure of aquaporin-1. Nature 387:624-627 Wistow GJ, Pisano MM, Chepelinsky AB 1991 Tandem sequence repeats in transmembrane channel proteins. Trends Biochem Sci 16:170-171
DISCUSSION Mindell: You talked about the conservation of these channels. Are there specific sequence differences that would explain this dramatically different selectivity? Fu: AQPs and GlpF have about 25% sequence similarity. But if we look at the channel-lining residues, they are highly conserved with the only exception at position 200. The GlpF has a Phe while AQP1 has a Cys at this position. Despite this strong similarity, there is no clear indication of the source of the water/glycerol selectivity. Mitra: This is debatable. Different labs do experiments differently. Some labs have claimed that GlpF does not conduct water very well at all. If you compare it with the sequence of AQP3 in mammals (which is a glycerol transporter), it does not have a phenylalanine in that place, but a slightly polar tyrosine. In fact, at this position only GlpF has a phenylalanine. All the others have tyrosine there. We think Hisl80 in AQP1 at the analogous site is important, but at that position, 180, it is glycine/valine for aquaglyceroporins. The additional polar residue there, in addition to phenylalanine versus cysteine, might act together to provide that occlusion of glycerol or transport of water. Sansom: You said that it might be the extracellular mouth that contributes to the selectivity. Where in the sequence does this occur? Fu: It is the only part that is not conserved. The selectivity is largely contributed by the linking group between the two halves of the protein. Mitra: This is between helices 3 and 4. Sansom: Has anyone tried making chimeras in which they switch these? Mitra: Bai et al (1996) have done switching between AQP2 and AQP1 in the hydrophilic loops. These resulted in chimeras with permeability similar to the wild-types. On the other hand an AQP2 chimera in which a fragment of 3—4 loop of GlpF replaced a corresponding segment of AQP2 displayed significantly reduced water permeability. Doyle: GlpF also has the conserved NP A residues. This probably has a role in the water movement, but does it have any role in the movement of glycerol? Fu: Yes, the two NPA tripeptide sequences are located in the middle of the channel. The Asp206 and Asp68 form H-bonds with two OH groups of a glycerol molecule that is bound in the middle of the channel. Choe: I would predict that the main chain phi, psi angles of glycine 199 are positive.
62
DISCUSSION
Fu: I have checked the geometries. All the main chain, with the exception of F200, is located in the allowed areas of the Ramachandran plot. Sansom: So is your suggestion that the El 52 is aiding that distortion? Or do you think that it might be polarizing the carbonyl oxygen? Fu: The entire side chain of El52 is embedded in a highly hydrophobic environment. The only way that El52 could gain access to the aqueous channel is through hydrogen bonding interaction with the main chain nitrogen. This side chain—main chain interaction could strongly polarize carbonyl oxygens in the vicinity. Jordan: I am having a hard time seeing what it is about the interior of this channel that makes it difficult for water to get inside. Otherwise I worry about glycerol getting in there and just being stuck. What is it that keeps the water out? Fu: This is also a problem I have! People used to think that GlpF was only permeable to glycerol. I kept asking myself how this channel could be only permeable to glycerol but not water. Andy Libson and I came up with the following explanation. When a water molecule moves down the channel, the water itself has to be dehydrated because waters in aqueous solution are linked together by hydrogen bonds. Moving a water molecule through a narrow channel therefore requires removal of its hydration shell first. Further, to satisfy hydrogen donor and acceptor groups lining the hydrophilic face of the channel, at least two water molecules are required to be in a line. However, a string of water molecules does not have a non-polar backbone to satisfy the hydrophobic face of the channel. Jordan: So what you are saying is that you think that there might be a genuine free energy barrier for water to enter, because you have to break up the water structure. The glycerol is nicely designed to be solvated by the channel. Fu: Yes. Sansom: We should remember that structure is solved at low temperature (100 K). Things might move a little bit. Choe: I thought that the polarity of the molecule with respect to the membrane was strikingly clear. Is this the case for all aquaporin channels? Fu: Like other membrane proteins in general, GlpF follows the positive inside rule. There are 16 excess positive charges on the cytoplasmic face. But I do not think that all these charges are conserved. Choe: In other membrane proteins the polarity is not as distinct as in yours. Fu: There are two rings of charged side chains, forming two layers of charges which sandwich two layers of aromatic side chains that are located on the polarnon-polar interface of the membrane. These aromatic rings seem to be a common feature in membrane proteins. Choe: What is the membrane potential of the inner membrane of E. coli?
STRUCTURE OF GlpF
63
Fu: I would guess it is — 30 to — 70 mV. Mindell: I have usually heard it quoted as —200 mV. It is a very high potential. Choe: It could therefore be more pronounced for E. coll water channels to have that stability by creating higher polarity. Roux: People say 'stability', but you don't expect a membrane protein to tumble over (i.e. with the intracellular side pointing outward). The presence of positively charged amino acids on the intracellular side may have more to do with the folding and trafficking than the stability of the folded protein itself. Fu: I think this dipole probably helps to orientate GlpF in the membrane. The protein is formed by two halves that have strong sequence similarities, and the dipole means that they can only organize in the membrane in the correct way. Mitra: In many cases the charge on one leaflet of the bilayer is different from the other. This also acts to orient the membrane protein in a particular way. Choe: Do you also have a similar level of polarity in your model? Mitra: I have not checked it in detail. Ashcroft: How long a molecule can go through the channel? Fu: Probably 20 A. A shcroft: Is it possible for something to span the channel? Fu: Yes, if you have a polyol of 5 or 6 carbons, this will be much longer than the pore. Choe: But these sugars are rings, not long chains. If you build that stereochemistry, the hydroxyl groups are all on one side. In one of your stereotypical variants, some are on the other side, but it had only sevenfold less permeability. Fu: This is because we were depicting things in two dimensions. If you view a three-dimensional molecule, the stereo arrangement of the OH groups is not so much different. Choe: It occurs to me that your sugar may linearize in order to cross over. As a ring you can't force it through the pore. Fu: People have used ring sugars to examine the permeability of the GlpF channel. Mindell: My impression was that those weren't sugars, they were polyalcohols. Fu: Yes. They don't form rings. Wallace: Physiologically, what is the main role of this channel? Is it to transport polyalcohols, glycerol, water or something else? Fu: These proteins can be induced in the presence of glycerol. This is an inducible glycerol-permeable channel. People believe that this channel is involved in glycerol uptake. When the channel is knocked out the bacteria grow much slower. Ashcroft: At the beginning of your presentation you showed four pores, one in each monomer, and you also had a channel in the centre, which you haven't said anything about.
64
DISCUSSION
Fu: That putative channel was surprisingly empty along the fourfold axis. We do not know the physiological function of this fourfold pore. This channel has a small hydrophobic constriction on the cytoplasmic side, which is too small to allow permeation of any type of ion or water. Choe: When you isolate your protein, is it a stable tetramer? Does it ever monomerize or dimerize? Fu: When I purify the protein it is not stable. We have spent a long time trying to work out why. Perozo: What do you mean when you say that it isn't stable? Fu: This is a typical problem with membrane proteins. Then one day, by accident we found that if we added Ca2+ or Mg2+, it made the GlpF more stable. After the structure was solved, it became clear that Ca2+ or Mg2+ could help in stabilizing the formation of tetramer. In the absence of divalent cations, GlpF may be in either a tetrameric or monomeric form. Choe: At low concentrations do you ever see monomers? They have to go to monomers at some point if you keep diluting. Fu: But how can we determine this? The protein is in the detergent and it is very hard to determine the precise molecular weight. Choe: It is hard, but it is probably doable if you know how much detergent is bound in the complex. Schrempf: Has anyone done mutagenesis to prevent the contacts among the monomers? This would address the question. Mttra: There are some unpublished reports from the French group in Rennes that the amount of detergent in the purification cocktail can also modulate the oligomeric state. At low concentration of octyl glucoside (~ 1%), they claim that more of GlpF is in monomeric state, and as the detergent concentration is increased (~10%) the proportion of tetrameric structure increases. This is somewhat counterintuitive. Fu: I suspect that tetramer formation may be essential for the stability of the protein. Two transmembrane-spanning helices in GlpF are located close to the tetramer fourfold axis, each is approximately 20 A in length. They are apparently not long enough to cross the membrane if not forming the tetramer. By forming the tetramer, GlpF shields the short helices from the hydrophobic core of the membrane. Mitra: Couldn't this be done by dimers? Fu: That is possible. Papazian: What about the results of something simple such as sucrose gradients? Does the protein migrate as a single species? Fu: This will depend on how many detergent molecules are binding to a protein. The protein can go just about anywhere. One way to estimate detergent number per micelle would be to use radioactive detergent. This will allow one to calculate
STRUCTURE OF GlpF
65
how many detergent molecules are bound per protein, and then it is possible to estimate their contribution to the apparent molecular weight of the proteindetergent micelle. Choe: Even with the analytical centrifuge you need to account for how much detergent is present in the complex. The lipid density is significantly different from protein density. Reference Bai L, Fushimi K, Sasaki S, Marumo F1996 Structure of aquaporin-2 vasopressin water channel. J Biol Chem 271:5171-5176
Water in ion channels and pores — simulation studies Mark S.P. Sansom, Peter Bond, Oliver Beckstein, Philip C. Biggin, Jose Faraldo-Gomez, Richard J. Law, George Patargias and D. Peter Tieleman* Laboratory of Molecular Biophysics, Department of Biochemistry, Rex Richards Building, University of Oxford, South Parks Road, Oxford, OX1 3QU, UK and * Department of Biological Sciences, University of Calgary, 2500 University Drive NW, Calgary, Alberta, Canada T2N 1N4
Abstract. The microscopic properties of water in narrow pores are relevant to the function of ion channels and related membrane transport proteins. The emergence of several high-resolution structures allows one to perform molecular dynamics simulation studies of water in such pores. Simulations of bundles of parallel a-helical peptides (e.g. alamethicin) have enabled development of methodologies and concepts appropriate to such investigations. In the narrow channels formed by such bundles, water molecules exhibit reduced rotational and translation motion. This reduction in water mobility may be a general property of narrow pores. We have used simplified channel models to explore the role of hydrophobicity/hydrophilicity in the entry of water into pores. Narrow pores with a hydrophobic lining, although physically open, may not admit water molecules, acting as a 'hydrophobic gate' that prevents water and ion permeation. Such a gate can be opened either by widening the pore or making its lining more polar. Simulations have been used to explore the behaviour of water in GlpF, a member of the aquaporin family of water pores, and OmpA, a bacterial outer membrane protein. Preliminary results suggest that a continuous water wire is not formed within the amphipathic GlpF pore. Simulations of OmpA, in which polar residues line the channel, indicate that a small conformational change in one of the channel lining side chains may open the channel. In summary, comparison of the behaviour of water in different narrow transmembrane pores suggests that an amphipathic pore is ideal for water permeation, and that either a highly hydrophobic pore lining or a charged pore-lining region can act as a gate. 2002 Ion channels—from atomic resolution physiology to functional genomics. Wiley, Chichester ( Novartis Foundation Symposium 245) p 66-83
Ion channels and related integral membrane proteins form transbilayer pores through which ions and/or other small molecules (e.g. water) may pass in a rapid (c. 108 s-1) but selective fashion. In order to understand the physical basis of rapid permeation of ions and/or water through such pores (Tieleman et al 2001) it is important that we fully understand the properties of solvent (i.e. water) 66
WATER IN CHANNELS AND PORES
67
FIG. 1. (A) Schematic diagram of a pore/channel formed by a transmembrane protein (dark grey) in a lipid bilayer membrane (cross-hatched). The water properties within the pore (p) are perturbed relative to those of bulk water (b), the degree of perturbation being indicated by the depth of the shading. (B) An example of a transbilayer pore, namely that formed by the bacterial protein GlpF (Fu et al 2000). The protein is shown in 'ribbons' format, with the approximate extent of the lipid bilayer indicated by the horizontal lines. The inner of surface of the pore is shown. Calculated using HOLE (Smart et al 1997,1993).
molecules within the pore, and how they may differ from those of water in its bulk state (i.e. on either side of the cell membrane). This is especially true for water pores (aquaporins). For ion channels, an understanding of pore water is an essential first step to understanding the dynamics and electrostatics of ions in the pore. Consider the structure of a 'typical' channel protein (Fig. 1A). The structures of a number of membrane proteins are known from X-ray crystallographic and electron microscopic studies of membrane proteins (see http:|| indigo1.biop.ox.ac.uk/membraneproteins.html for a summary). These include: (i) several porins from bacterial outer membranes (Schirmer 1998); (ii) bacterial potassium (KcsA; Doyle et al 1998) and mechanosensitive (MscL; Chang et al 1998) channels; (iii) the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor channel (nAChR; Unwin 2000); and (iv) two members (GlpF [Fig. 1B] and AQP1; Fu et al 2000, Murata et al 2000, Ren et al 2001) of the aquaporin family of water pores. From these we may generalize that a 'typical' pore is c, 3 nm long and has a radius which varies along the length of the pore, but which may be as low as c. 0.2nm in places (n.b. the radius of a water molecule is c. 0.l5nm, and that of a K+ ion is c. 0.13nm). From this it is evident that the pore dimensions are comparable to the size of the transported molecules and/or ions. It has been known for some time, from both experimental and
68
SANSOM ET AL
theoretical studies, that liquids behave differently when confined in pores, slits and cavities of molecular dimensions relative to the same liquids in the bulk state (Granick 1991). Thus we would expect non-bulk properties of water within transbilayer pores. Of particular importance to channel and related pore proteins are the dynamic behaviour of water (e.g. diffusion coefficient) and also its electrostatic properties (e.g. local dielectric constant) (Roux et al 2000, Tieleman et al 2001). It is somewhat difficult to address these local microscopic properties experimentally, especially for biological pores. However, simulations provide ready access to information on the structural dynamics of water in association with proteins (Daggett & Levitt 1993). There is a considerable literature on the use of molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to explore the structure and dynamics of water, and a number of water models have been developed for use in such simulations (Jorgensen et al 1983, Levitt et al 1997). Although none of these models is perfect, comparison of the simulated properties of water in pores with water in bulk enables one to explore how the molecular environment provided by a pore alters the behaviour of the solvent. Recent years have witnessed an increase in the level of detail included in models of pores used in simulations. Initial studies employed either highly idealized models (e.g. smooth cylindrical pores [LyndenBell & Rasaiah 1996] or cavities [Sansom et al 1996]) or model peptides that capture some of the essential features of more complex ion channels (Chiu et al 1999, Roux & Karplus 1994, Tieleman et al 1999). More recently it has been possible to simulate complex channel and pore proteins, embedded in either an explicit lipid bilayer (Berneche & Roux 2000, Shrivastava & Sansom 2000) or a bilayer mimetic octane slab (Guidoni et al 2000). An example of a study of a model system is provided by simulations of pores formed by the peptide alamethicin (Sansom 1993). Water molecules diffused more slowly within the pore, and were non-randomly oriented relative to the pore axis. Initial studies used models of solvated alamethicin helix bundles in vacuo (Breed et al 1996). These were extended to alamethicin channels embedded in a fully solvated phospholipid bilayer (Tieleman et al 1998). Encouragingly, similar results were obtained from both sets of simulations, and from simulations on a slightly different peptide channel model (Mitton & Sansom 1996, Randa et al 1999). By combining results from simulations on a variety of systems performed by a number of research groups (reviewed in Tieleman et al 2001) it has been possible to analyse how DPORE /D B U L K (i.e.the ratio of the diffusion coefficient in the pore to that in bulk solution) varies as a function of (local) pore radius. For both water molecules and for simple monovalent ions a similar pattern emerges. Namely, that for radii above c. 0.8—1.0 nm the behaviour of water in the pore matches that of bulk water, whereas for narrower pores the value ofD P O R E / D B U L Kdecreases
WATER IN CHANNELS AND PORES
69
progressively until, at a radius of c. 0.2nm or less, it is not clear whether one is justified in describing water and/or ion motions in term of 'diffusion'. In this paper we examine three specific aspects of the behaviour of water in transbilayer pores: (i) water in a narrow hydrophobic 'gate'; (ii) water in the amphipathic pores formed by a member of the aquaporin family; and (iii) water within a highly charged pore-like cavity in the bacterial outer membrane protein OmpA.
Methods MD simulations were run using Gromacs v2.0 (http://www,gromacs.org/). The water model used was simple point charge (SPC) (Hermans et al 1984, van Gunsteren et al 1996). The time step used in all simulations was 2fs. NPT (i.e. constant number of particles, temperature and pressure) conditions were applied, with a constant pressure of 1 bar maintained independently in all three directions via a coupling constant of Tp = l.0ps (Berendsenet al 1984). Where present, water, lipid or octane, and protein were coupled separately to a temperature bath at 300 K with a coupling constant of tT = 0.1 ps. The LINCS algorithm (Hess et al 1997) was used to constrain bond lengths. Octane parameters were from GROMOS96 (van Gunsteren et al 1996). Long-range interactions were treated via PME (Darden et al 1993) using a cut-off of 0.9 nm for the direct space non-bonded calculations. Other simulation details were as described in Tieleman et al (2000). Analysis of simulation results was performed using GROMACS and/or locally written code. Pore radius profiles were analysed using HOLE (Smart et al 1997, 1993). Diagrams were drawn using RasMol (Sayle & Milner-White 1995), VMD (Humphrey et al 1996), MOLSCRIPT (Kraulis 1991) and Raster3d (Merritt & Bacon 1997).
Results Ahydrophobic gate Most ion channels are gated, i.e. they switch between an open state and a closed state. Gating can occur on a wide range of timescales and can be intrinsic (i.e. presumed to be due to random thermal motions of a channel protein) or can be coupled to allosteric modulation of channel protein conformation by ligand binding and/or voltage driven conformational changes. Structural studies on a number of channels suggest that a gate may be formed by a ring of side chains that form a narrow, hydrophobic region within a channel through which ions cannot pass. For example, in the nAChR it is suggested that a ring of conserved leucine side chains forms a hydrophobic region of length c. 0.8nm and radius c. 0.35 nm (Unwin 2000). In MscL there are two rings of hydrophobic side chains
70
SANSOM ET AL
FIG. 2. (A) Diagram of a simplified model of a pore in a membrane mimetic. The pore (p) is shown as semi-transparent space-filling spheres, and the water molecules (w) as 'sticks'. The membrane mimetic (m) is omitted for clarity. The pore radius is 4.5 A, the mouth radius is 18 A, and two parallel dipoles (each of magnitude 2 x 10 -29 Cm) were present in the pore lining. (B) Average degree of openness (FO) vs. pore radius (Rp) for hydrophobic pores with various radius 18 A (solid line) and for equivalent pores with two parallel dipoles in the pore lining (broken line). Simulation times were 1 ns per data point.
that narrow the pore in the closed state of the channel, whereas in KcsA a ring of valine side chains forms a hydrophobic gate at the intracellular mouth of the pore. In this context, it is of interest to explore the pore dimensions and degree of hydrophobicity that are consistent with formation of a (closed) gate. In the longer term one should look at gating in terms of the energetics of ion permeation (Biggin et al 2001). Here, we explore gating of water entry into a pore. We assume that if water is excluded from a gate region then so will ions. A simplified model of a pore in a membrane was used in these simulations (Fig. 2A). Both the pore and the membrane were constructed from methane-like atoms, subject to positional restraints during the simulations. The dimensions of the pore region were adjusted to explore the effect of different pore and mouth radii on water behaviour. In the first set of simulations the pore lining atoms were apolar, i.e. their partial atomic charges were zero. In a second set of simulations, small dipoles were added to the pore lining by adding suitable partial charges to the pore-lining atoms. For the various pore configurations, 1 ns MD simulations were performed in the presence of SPC waters on either side of the pore. Water molecules were free to enter/exit the pore, and the penetration of water molecules into the pore (i.e. 'wetting') was measured. The openness of a given pore was defined as the time averaged density of water within the pore relative to the bulk density of water.
WATER IN CHANNELS AND PORES
71
The openness of simple hydrophobic pores depends strongly on the pore geometry. As the pore radius is increased there is a clear transition between a closed pore (i.e. one from which water is excluded) and an open pore (i.e. filled with water; Fig. 2B). The exact pore radius for the transition is influenced by other aspects of the pore geometry (Beckstein et al 2001), e.g. the mouth radius, but typically is c. 0.45 nm. A radius of 0.45 nm is in excess of that necessary to accommodate water molecules from a simple steric perspective. Thus a geometrically open (i.e. unoccluded) pore can remain functionally closed (i.e. exclude water molecules) if it is sufficiently hydrophobic. Adding two parallel dipoles (magnitude 2 x 10 - 2 9 Cm) to the pore lining was sufficient to open a pore that was otherwise closed (Fig. 2B). Again, the exact behaviour depended on the geometry of the pore but the trend was the same in all simulations, namely that making a narrow pore more polar can open it to entry of water molecules. Thus these simplified model channel simulations provide a proof of the principle of hydrophobic gating, i.e. a hydrophobic region in a pore can completely exclude water molecules even if it is not sterically occluded. This 'gate' can then be opened either by increasing the local pore radius and/or increasing the polarity of the pore lining. Aquaporins The aquaporins are a ubiquitous family of water permeable pores, found in organisms ranging from bacteria to animals and plants. Aquaporins per se are selective for water permeation whereas glyceroaquaporins also permit glycerol permeation (Borgnia & Agre 2001). Structures are known for AQP1 (at medium resolution by electron microscopy; Murata et al 2000, Ren et al 2001) and for GlpF (at 0.22 nm resolution, by X-ray diffraction; Fu et al 2000). In both cases the protein forms a six-helix bundle spanning the membrane. The bundle contains two porelining NPA-motif containing loops that help to line a central pore. The pore has an average radius of c. 0.2nm (Fig. 1B) and is amphipathic, i.e. it is lined by both hydrophobic and polar amino acids. A 5 ns duration simulation has been run for a GlpF monomer embedded in a bilayer mimetic octane slab in order to study the behaviour of water molecules within pores of this family. The protein conformation does not change significantly during the course of this simulation (Fig. 3A,B). Comparing the structures at the start and end of the simulation, the Ca RMSD is c. 0.2nm, which is typical for a simulation of a membrane protein based on an X-ray structure. Furthermore, the change in structure over the course of the simulation is substantially less for the TM a helices and for the NPA loops than is suggested by this overall figure, as structural fluctuations are greatest for the surface-exposed inter-helical loops. Based on simple considerations of the single molecule water
72
SANSOM ET AL
FIG. 3. (A,B) Superimposed Ca traces of the GlpF molecule at the start (thin black line) and end (thick grey line) of a 5 ns simulation, viewed perpendicular (A) and down (B) the pore axis. (C) Snapshots from a simulation of GlpF in a membrane mimetic octane slab. The diagrams show just the water molecules within and at either mouth of the pore. The orientation is the same as that in Fig. 1B, i.e. with the extracellular mouth of the pore uppermost. Snapshots are shown at t = 0-5ns.
permeability of aquaporin (c. 3 x 109 waters s -1; Murata et al 2000) and the relative permeability of GlpF and aquaporin to water (c. 1:6; Borgnia & Agre 2001) one arrives at a mean time spent by a water molecule in GlpF of c. 3 ns. Thus one might expect to see one or two water permeation events in a 5 ns simulation. Some care was taken to ensure that the GlpF pore was fully solvated at the start of the simulation. Thus, at the start of the simulation the pore accommodated c. 26 water molecules. Snapshots of the water molecules within the pore taken during the simulation (Fig. 3C) indicate that the initially continuous column of waters is
WATER IN CHANNELS AND PORES
73
not stable but breaks during the course of the simulation. Analysis of the number density of water along the pore axis, averaged in 0.5 ns blocks indicates that during the simulation the water density falls to almost zero at various positions along the pore despite the absence of any significant changes in pore radius profile during the course of the simulation. At the end of the 5 ns the number of waters within the pore is c. 17. Diffusion coefficients of water molecules within the pore are lowered (c. threefold) relative to bulk water—this is perhaps a smaller decrease than might have been expected on the basis of the pore dimensions. By following the trajectories of those water molecules that spend at least 30% of their time within the pore one can see the water molecules that enter and leave the pore. One water molecule undergoes a 'permeation event' i.e. it enters one mouth of the pore, remains within for c, 2 ns and then leaves via the opposite mouth. Thus simulations of this duration begin to probe water permeation. Water movement within the pore does not appear to occur in a strict single-filing fashion. On the basis of these simulations we may conclude that water molecules penetrate the GlpF pore but do not form a continuous H-bonded chain throughout the simulation. Rather, a fluctuating and discontinuous chain of water molecules appears to be formed. This is in some respects similar to the behaviour of water in the simple model pore described above when the latter has a polar pore lining such that the average degree of openness FO c. 0.5. In this case the time-dependent density of water within the pore fluctuates between c. 0 and c. 1 relative to bulk density (Beckstein et al 2001). Interestingly, in long (>50ns) simulations of water in a carbon nanotube, Hummer et al (2001) observe water flux through the pore to occur in a pulsatory fashion, with fluctuations on a timescale of c. 4 ns. Thus, it may be a general property of water permeable pores that the water density within such pores fluctuates. Indeed, recent theoretical studies have emphasised the relationship of fluctuations in number of particles within a pore to its geometry (Bezrukov et al 2000). OmpA OmpA is a small outer membrane protein from Escherichiacoli. The structure of the N-terminal transmembrane domain (residues 1-171) of this protein has been solved by X-ray diffraction (Pautsch & Schulz 2000) and by NMR (Arora et al 2001). The protein forms an eight-stranded anti-parallel b barrel. There is some debate as to whether or not the OmpA protein can form a channel. On the one hand, the X-ray structure failed to reveal a continuous pore through the centre of the barrel. Instead there are three internal clusters of bound water molecules, containing four (extracellular cluster), eight (central cluster) and eight (periplasmic cluster) waters (Fig. 4A), separated from one another by salt bridges formed between ionic side chains in the protein interior. On the other hand,
74
SANSOM ET AL
FIG. 4. (A) Structure of OmpA (shown as a trace of the polypeptide backbone) with the internal water molecules shown as spheres. The horizontal lines indicate the approximate location of the bilayer, and the region of the E52/R138 'gate' is labelled 'g'. (B) Trajectories, projected onto the pore (z) axis, of water molecules within an OmpA molecule embedded in a DMPC bilayer over the course of a 5 ns MD simulation. The location of the aromatic bands (presumed to correspond to the approximate extent of the bilayer) are shown by the arrows and the extent of the 'gate' region is labelled 'g'.
functional measurements have consistently revealed channel formation by OmpA (Arora et al 2000) and by related proteins (Brinkman et al 2000, Saint et al 2000) reconstituted into artificial lipid bilayers. For refolded OmpA, two different conductance levels are observed (Arora et al 2000). The lower conductance level (c. 60 pS in 1 M KC1) is consistent with a pore formed by an eight-stranded barrel. Thus, it is of some interest to examine the simulated dynamics of water molecules within OmpA, with the protein embedded in either an octane slab or a phospholipid bilayer (Bond et al 2001). The results of a 5 ns simulation of the 'closed' form of OmpA (i.e. that seen in the crystal structure) embedded in a DMPC bilayer are summarised in Fig. 4B in the form of trajectories of the internal water coordinates projected onto the barrel (i.e. z) axis. From this it is evident that water molecules show some movement within a cluster on a 5 ns timescale. This and other simulations of OmpA have revealed waters to exchange between the bulk and the two outer clusters, i.e. through the
WATER IN CHANNELS AND PORES
75
FIG. 5. Schematic of three classes of pore. (A) Hydrophobic pore (dark grey) in a hydrophobic membrane (dark grey). Water molecules (stippled grey) are present on either side of the pore but fail to enter. (B) Amphipathic pore (light grey) with dipolar side chains (arrows), and filled by water. (C) Polar pore (light grey) penetrated by waters but gated by a side chain ion pair in the centre of the pore.
76
SANSOM ET AL
inner and outer 'mouths' of the pore. However, water was not observed to exchange across the 'gate' region (formed by side chains E52 and R138), i.e. between the central cluster and the periplasmic cluster. Hence, at least on a 5 ns timescale, the OmpA protein remains in a 'closed' conformation. By combining model building and further simulation studies (data not shown; Bond et al 2002) we have shown that a minor rearrangement of salt bridges between side chains within the interior of the molecule can 'open' the pore, at least to water molecules. Thus, it is tempting to identify the E52/R138 side chain pair with the gate of the OmpA channel.
Conclusions What may one conclude from these studies? Firstly it is evident that simulations can provide detailed insights into the dynamic behaviour of water within transbilayer pores. Of course there are limitations to such simulations, including their relative short duration (up to c. 10ns) so that statistical sampling is poor for longer timescale (e.g. permeation) events. Furthermore, there are concerns about the approximations implicit in the simulation forcefields employed. However, by combining simulations with suitable reality checks wherever possible one may start to realise some atomistic level detail of the dynamics of pores. On the basis of the results presented in this paper one may draw a tentative conclusion concerning the relationship between hydrophobicity/polarity of the pore lining and water permeability (Fig. 5). Note that these conclusions apply to pores of radius comparable to that of one or two water molecules. A completely hydrophobic pore (region) can act as a gate by resisting 'wetting'. A highly charged pore lining can also act as a gate by providing regions of the pore that form salt bridges and so exclude waters. In between these two extremes an amphipathic pore appears to be optimal for water permeation, as found in the AQP family of water pore proteins. Acknowledgements Research in MSPS's laboratory is supported by the Wellcome Trust. Studentships were provided by the Wellcome Trust (OB), MRC (RL), EPSRC & La Caixa Foundation (JFG), and State Scholarship Foundation (Greece) (GP). DPT is an AHMFR Scholar. We thank the Oxford Supercomputing Centre for computing support. Our thanks to Dax Fu and Alok Mitra for their interest in this work and for stimulating discussions concerning aquaporins.
References Arora A, Rinehart D, Szabo G, Tamm LK 2000 Refolded outer membrane protein A of Escherichia coli forms ion channels with two conductance states in planar lipid bilayers. J BiolChem 275:1594-1600
WATER IN CHANNELS AND PORES
77
Arora A, Abildgaard F, Bushweller JH, Tamm LK 2001 Structure of outer membrane protein A transmembrane domain by NMR spectroscopy. Nat Struct Biol 8:334-338 Beckstein O, Biggin PC, Sansom MSP 2001 A hydrophobic gating mechanism for nanopores. J Phys Chem B 105:12902-12905 Berendsen HJC, Postma JPM, van Gunsteren WF, DiNola A, Haak JR 1984 Molecular dynamics with coupling to an external bath. J Chem Phys 81:3684—3690 Berneche S, Roux B 2000 Molecular dynamics of the KcsA K+ channel in a bilayer membrane. BiophysJ 78:2900-2917 Bezrukov SM, Berezhkovskii AM, Pustovoit MA, Szabo A 2000 Particle number fluctuations in a membrane channel. J Chem Phys 113:8206-8211 Biggin PC, Smith GR, Shrivastava 1H, Choe S, Sansom MS 2001 Potassium and sodium ions in a potassium channel studied by molecular dynamics simulations. Biochim Biophys Acta 1510:1 9 Bond P, Faraldo-Gomez J, Sansom MSP 2002 OmpA— A pore or not a pore? Simulation and modelling studies. Biophys J, in press Borgnia MJ, Agre P 2001 Reconstitution and functional comparison of purified GlpF and AqpZ, the glycerol and water channels from Escherichia coli. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA 98:2888-2893 ' Breed J, Sankararamakrishnan R, Kerr ID, Sansom MS 1996 Molecular dynamics simulations of water within models of ion channels. Biophys J 70:1643—1661 Brinkman FSL, Bains M, Hancock RE, 2000 The amino terminus of P seudomonas aeruginosa outer membrane protein OprF forms channels in lipid bilayer membranes: correlation with a three dimensional model. J Bacteriol 182:5251-5255 Chang G, Spencer RH, Lee AT, Barclay MT, Rees DC 1998 Structure of the MscL homolog from Mjcobacterium tuberculosis: a gated mechanosensitive ion channel. Science 282:2220-2226 Chiu SW, Subramaniam S, Jakobsson E 1999 Simulation study of a gramicidin/lipid bilayer system in excess water and lipid. I. Structure of the molecular complex. Biophys J 76:19291938 Daggett V, Levitt M 1993 Realistic simulations of native-protein dynamics in solution and beyond. Annu Rev Biophys Biomol Struct 22:353-380 Darden T, York D, Pedersen L 1993 Particle mesh Ewald — an N.log(N) method for Ewald sums in large systems. J Chem Phys 98:10089-10092 Doyle DA, Morais Cabral J, Pfuetzner RA et al 1998 The structure of the potassium channel: molecular basis of K+ conduction and selectivity. Science 280:69—77 Fu D, Libson A, Miercke LJ et al 2000 Structure of a glycerol-conducting channel and the basis for its selectivity. Science 290:481-486 Granick S 1991 Motions and relaxations of confined liquids. Science 253:1374-1379 Guidoni L, Torre V, Carloni P 2000 Water and potassium dynamics in the KcsA K+ channel. FEES Lett 477:37-42 Hermans J, Berendsen HJC, van Gunsteren WF, Postma JPM 1984 A consistent empirical potential for water-protein interactions. Biopolymers 23:1513-1518 Hess B, Bekker H, Berendsen HJC, Fraaije JGEM 1997 LINGS: a linear constraint solver for molecular simulations. J Comp Chem 18:1463-1472 Hummer G, Rasaiah JC, Noworyta JP 2001 Water conduction through the hydrophobic channel of carbon nanotube. Nature 414:188-190 Humphrey W, Dalke A, Schulten K 1996 VMD: visual molecular dynamics. J Mol Graph 14:33 38 Jorgensen WL, Chandresekhar J, Madura JD, Impey RW, Klein ML 1983 Comparison of simple potential functions for simulating liquid water. J Chem Phys 79:926—935 Kraulis PJ 1991 MOLSCRIPT: a program to produce both detailed and schematic plots of protein structures. J Appl Cryst 24:946-950
78
SANSOM ET AL
Levitt M, Hirshberg M, Sharon R, Laidig KE, Daggett V 1997 Calibration and testing of a water model for simulation of the molecular dynamics of proteins and nucleic acids in solution. ] Phys Chem B 101:5051-5061 Lynden-Bell R, Rasaiah JC 1996 Mobility and solvation of ions in channels. J Chem Phys 105:9266-9280 Merritt EA, Bacon DJ 1997 Raster3D: Photorealistic molecular graphics. Methods Enzymol 277:505-524 Mitton P, Sansom MSP 1996 Molecular dynamics simulations of ion channels formed by bundles of amphipathic a-helical peptides. Eur Biophys J 25:139-150 Murata K, Mitsuoaka K, Hirai T et al 2000 Structural determinants of water permeation through aquaporin-1. Nature 407:599-605 Pautsch A, Schulz GE 2000 High-resolution structure of the OmpA membrane domain. J Mol Biol 298:273-282 Randa HS, Forrest LR, Voth GA, Sansom MSP 1999 Molecular dynamics of synthetic leucineserine ion channels in a phospholipid membrane. Biophys J 77:2400-2410 Ren G, Reddy VS, Cheng A, Melnyk P, Mitra AK 2001 Visualization of a water-selective pore by electron crystallography in vitreous ice. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 98:1398-1403 Roux B, Karplus M 1994 Molecular dynamics simulations of the gramicidin channel. Ann Rev Biophys Biomol Struct 23:731-761 Roux B, Berneche S, Im W 2000 Ion channels, permeation and electrostatics: insight into the function of KcsA. Biochemistry 39:13295-13306 Saint N, El Hamel C, De E, Molle G 2000 Ion channel formation by N-terminal domain: a common feature of OprFs of P seudomonas and OmpA of Escherichia coli. FEMS Microbiol Lett 190:261-265 Sansom MS 1993 Structure and function of channel-forming peptaibols. Quart Rev Biophys 26:365-421 Sansom MSP, Kerr ID, Breed J, Sankararamakrishnan R 1996 Water in channel-like cavities: structure and dynamics. Biophys J 70:693-702 Sayle RA, Milner-White EJ 1995 RASMOL: biomolecular graphics for all. Trends Biochem Sci 20:374-376 Schirmer T 1998 General and specific porins from bacterial outer membranes. J Struct Biol 121:101-109 Shrivastava IH, Sansom MSP 2000 Simulations of ion permeation through a potassium channel: molecular dynamics of KcsA in a phospholipid bilayer. Biophys J 78:557-570 Smart OS, Goodfellow JM, Wallace BA 1993 The pore dimensions of gramicidin A. Biophys J 65:2455-2460 Smart OS, Breed J, Smith GR, Sansom MSP 1997 A novel method for structure-based prediction of ion channel conductance properties. Biophys J 72:1109-1126 Tieleman DP, Breed J, Berendsen HJC, Sansom MSP 1998 Alamethicin channels in a membrane: molecular dynamics simulations. Faraday Discuss 111:209-223 Tieleman DP, Berendsen HJC, Sansom MSP 1999 An alamethicin channel in a lipid bilayer:molecular dynamics simulations. Biophys J 76:1757-1769 Tieleman DP, Berendsen HJC, Sansom MSP 2000 Voltage-dependent insertion of alamethicin at phospholipid/water and octane/water interfaces. Biophys J 80:331-346 Tieleman DP, Biggin PC, Smith GR, Sansom MSP 2001 Simulation approaches to ion channel structure-function relationships. Quart Rev Biophys 34:473-561 Unwin N 2000 The Croonian Lecture 2000. Nicotinic acetylcholine receptor and the structural basis of fast synaptic transmission. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 355:1813-1829 van Gunsteren WF, Kruger P, Billeter SR et al 1996 Biomolecular Simulation: The GROMOS96 Manual and User Guide. Biomos & Hochschulverlag AG an der ETH Zurich, Groningen & Zurich
WATER IN CHANNELS AND PORES
79
DISCUSSION Roux: A hydrophobic pore, made of completely non-polar side chains could be different. The backbone of proteins is quite polar. Sansom: I guess it depends on the exact geometry of the side chains. Roux: But the backbone is polar: water molecules inside cavities are almost never more than 3 or 4 A away from the backbone. Sixma: But in a helix it is not polar all along the helix. Roux: That doesn't matter. A water molecule inside a non-polar cavity in the interior of a protein will usually find a way to hydrogen bond on the side of a backbone carbonyl group of a helix. It doesn't perturb the helix structure very much to allow such a hydrogen bond (Roux et al 1996). Sansom: That is going to depend on how densely packed the rings of hydrophobia side chains are. I am trying to visualize Nigel Unwin's acetylcholine receptor structure. Unwin: Looking at it, I can't see how water could get close to those polar groups. There is too much protection from the hydrophobic side chains. Roux: How many layers of side chains are there? Sansom: Three: leucine, valine and another leucine. I guess the thing to do is to calculate a solvent-accessible surface. Roux: As an example, we have tried simulations of KcsA in the 'open' state. If you take KcsA and slightly open the inner helices at the bottom, there are residues 101, 106 and 109 making three layers of non-polar amino acids. You just have to push these helices by about 3 A and then you get this stable tube of water (Roux et al 2000). Sansom: I agree; it is going to be very sensitive to the exact structure. Hummer et al (2001) have been doing some simulations on nanotubes, and depending on how they tune the van der Waals interactions water either enters or leaves the pore. Perozo: If you are going to assign a gain you want it to be very sensitive. You want a polar barrier that is easily lowered so that ions and water can go through. Sansom: When one tries to build an open model of KcsA the gate is increased to c.4 A . Roux: I think it is a 3—4 A radius. Perozo: It depends where you look, because it is a scissor-like motion. The distance change decreases as you approach residue 107, which we think forms a 'pivot' for the gate. Roux: It may be 6 A diameter in the narrowest part. Sansom: That seems a bit narrow. Roux: Even at 6 A there is penetration of water. Unwin: What length? Roux: Three amino acids, which is about 10 A.
80
DISCUSSION
Sansom: Even in the simple model calculations there is some sensitivity to the geometry at the mouth of the channel. Roux: Protein material itself has a dielectric constant of 4 or 5, whereas your system is a slab of non-polar spheres with a dielectric constant of 1. From an electrostatic point of view this is equivalent to vacuum. Sansom: No, it is not the slab of vacuum; it has non-polar atoms for the slab as well. Roux: If one thinks in term of the Born (1920) model of solvation, the free energy of stabilization of an ion depends sensitively on the dielectric constant of the surrounding. Already for a dielectric constant around 4, one gets a large stabilization free energy, nearly 75% of the free energy that one gets for a dielectric constant of 80. Mindell: I am intrigued by the stripes of order that you see. It is not clear to me, however, that this would have a dramatic effect on the diffusion coefficient. Does it affect the diffusion in those models? Sansom: We were a bit nervous about trying to calculate the diffusion coefficient when we can see something moving in a stepwise fashion, so we haven't done this. I think people have suggested such arrangements of water in a number of calculations, e.g. of water in idealized narrow tubes (Allen et al 1999) where water clusters form distorted pentameric rings. Choe: You mentioned that the waters that were placed in the middle of the core tend to drift away only in one direction. Sansom: There does seem to be some asymmetry. I'm not sure why this is. It may reflect an asymmetry in the exact pattern of hydrophobicity in the surface lining the pore. We haven't looked at this properly yet. We would like to compare this effect for aquaporin, for example, where there are subtle differences in the nature of the residues lining the pore. Choe: How much does the electric field contribute to this behaviour? Sansom: We haven't yet estimated the field strength. In principle we could cancel it out by using an asymmetric bilayer. I am fairly certain that there is not such a marked dipole across AQP1 as there is across GlpF. Schrempf: Taking the biological data into consideration, I am surprised you are not using glycerol for your simulations for GlpF. Sansom: We are. If one believes the data in the Borgnia et al (2001) paper (and I know there is some discussion about it), the argument is not that GlpF has massive selectivity against water, so much as AQP has a massive selectivity against glycerol. Schrempf: The biological data clearly indicate that this is a glycerol-transporting protein. If you make Escberichia coli mutants and disrupt the gene it can also be tested. Sansom: But it lets water through. It allows water through at near its diffusionlimited rate (Borgnia et al 2001).
WATER IN CHANNELS AND PORES
81
Mathie: You showed one water molecule diffusing right across the membrane and you said that it took about 2ns. The other ones that you showed here are staying in the pore much longer than that and are settling half way through the pore. Is this just random? Sansom: I think so. To make this a bit simpler to present, we have chosen four waters that spend the longest time in the pore. We see a large number of waters entering and coming back in. This happens to be the one we have seen, in the absence of any concentration gradient of water, that goes all the way across. At equilibrium you would expect a large number to enter and then to exit again and this is what we see. Mathie: If you were to change the osmolarity in your models you would presumably push water through. Sansom: That is non-trivial to do, but in principle, yes. Mindell: Why is it so hard to make an osmolar gradient? Can't you just exclude water from part of the volume? Sansom: We have a finite simulation box with periodic boundaries at the edges, so the computational trick used is that if a water wanders out at the bottom it reappears at the top. Putting any asymmetry across the system is a bit challenging. There are ways to do it. Roux: A possible approach is to apply an external perturbative force (not necessarily having the form of an electric field though). According to KuboZwanzig Linear Response Theory (Hansen & McDonald 1986), the equilibrium response function can be extracted using any small perturbative force. For example, one could apply a generic force inducing a flux of water across the membrane. Sansom: Or you could drag one or more water molecules through the pore. Mindell: What if you just fill one box with some volume-occupying spheres? This would reduce the net number of water molecules on that side. Roux: You would have to restrain them in space somehow, because they would diffuse. Or you could have two membranes and have the gradient between them. Sansom: It is similar to the problem of how to put a voltage across the membrane. Asbcroft: You showed single-channel currents for OmpA, but you didn't tell us which ion was carrying the current. You also talked about water moving through this channel, but you didn't say that your simulation predicted whether the water could move. Sansom: We haven't done that yet. As to which ion goes through, I don't think this was mentioned. The experiment was in KC1 (Arora et al 2000). Miller: A simple question. Water has a dipole and can hydrogen bond. How is this allowed for in the molecular dynamics calculations?
82
DISCUSSION
Sansom: You have got partial charges on the water. This is just a three-point charge model, so there aren't any lone pairs to put on the oxygen. Miller: You have your rings of water which satisfy the hydrogen bonding requirement: why are they all parallel to the bilayer and not tilted? Sansom: I am still unsure about these. It is peculiar, and I wouldn't have shown it if other people hadn't seen it as well. It may just be an artefact, but it is a consistent one, and it fits in with the general scheme that even if you have water penetrating a narrow hydrophobic pore it may behave in a very different fashion from bulk water. Miller: Presumably you don't see hydrodynamic effects in something that small. Ashcroft: Can I go back to the toy model of the acetylcholine receptor pore? You said that at 3.5 A radius, if it was lined by hydrophobic residues, the pore was essentially closed. However, if these are replaced with charged residues the pore opens. The critical leucine has been mutated a lot in the ACh receptor. What do you see in your model if you substitute this leucine with other residues? Do you get the same effect as is found for the channel? Sansom: With this toy model it would be difficult to do exactly the same. Corringer: It doesn't open. If you mutate the leucine to a threonine, you don't get spontaneous opening. Unwin: It depends on how many mutations you do. Corringer: If you do all five you see a few percent of channels opening spontaneously, but most are closed. Unwin: If we are talking about water going through this narrow hole, that is different. You are talking about the channel opening via a conformational change. Corringer: What I am saying is that the closed conformation is maintained. Unwin: I would expect that. If you are changing a leucine you probably should change the valines on the next ring up at the same time. Corringer: I should do both together. We have a very complex phenotype that I don't understand yet. We have increments that we interpret as spontaneous opening, but perhaps we have impaired the gate. Sansom: How would you distinguish between a spontaneous opening and an impaired gate? Corringer: A spontaneous opening can be reversed using an antagonist. Perhaps we have an impaired gate. In the double mutant the phenotype is very complicated. Unwin: I don't think people have ever measured how much water goes through the acetylcholine receptor. It may be reasonably impermeable to water. Sansom: The coupling between water and ions has been measured using streaming potentials. This is shown in some older work by Dani & Levitt (1990). Choe: As I was looking at this graph I was thinking of the bottom half of the KcsA pore, which is quite hydrophobic in the narrow part. The calculation
WATER IN CHANNELS AND PORES
83
seems to suggest that the conformational change should be from 2 A to about 4-5 A. This is quite a significant change. Perozo: It is not a linear change. The helices move away at the base, so the distance change that we see is about 10 A at the base, and this narrows out to about 2 A in the narrowest portion. Sansom: So what you are saying is that this would expand to about 5 A radius. Choe: That is more than the diameter of the helix. References Allen TW, Kuyucak S, Chung SH 1999 The effect of hydrophobia and hydrophilic channel walls on the structure and diffusion of water and ions. J Chern Phys 111:7985-7999 Arora A, Rinehart D, Szabo G, Tamm LK 2000 Refolded outer membrane protein A of Escherichia coli forms ion channels with two conductance states in planar lipid bilayers. J BiolChem 275:1594-1600 Borgnia MJ, Agre P 2001 Reconstitution and functional comparison of purified GlpF and AqpZ, the glycerol and water channels from Escherichia coli. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA 98:2888-2893 Born M 1920 Volumen und Hydratationswarme der lonen. Z Phys 1:45-48 Dani JA, Levitt DG 1990 Diffusion and kinetic approaches to describe permeation in ionic channels. J Theor Biol 146:289-301 Hansen JP, McDonald IR 1986 Theory of simple liquids, 2nd edn. Academic Press, London Hummer G, Rasaiah JC, Noworyta JP 2001 Water conduction through the hydrophobic channel of a carbon nanotube. Nature 414:188-190 Roux B, Nina M, Pomes R, Smith JC 1996 Thermodynamic stability of water molecules in the bacteriorhodopsin proton channel: a molecular dynamics free energy perturbation study. Biophys J 71:670-681 Roux B, Berneche S, Im W 2000 Ion channels, permeation, and electrostatics: insight into the function of KcsA. Biochemistry 39:13295-13306
What can be deduced about the structure of Shaker from available data? Benoit Roux Weill Medical College of Cornell University, 1300 York An, New York, NY 10021, USA
Abstract. Voltage-gated K+ channels are transmembrane proteins that control and regulate the flow of K+ ions across cell membranes in response to changes in membrane potential and are essential for the propagation of action potentials in the nervous system. One of the most studied voltage-gated channels is Shaker. Available experimental results clearly provide specific constraints on the structure of the channel, even though the direct translation of the available information into 3D structures is not trivial. The goal of this work is to develop a computational approach to construct and refine 3D models of Shaker by incorporating and integrating available experimental data. Our approach is based on comparative modelization and global conformational optimization using energy restraints extracted from experimental data. 2002 Ion channels—from atomic resolution physiology to functional genomics. Wiley, Chichester (Novartis Foundation Symposium 245) p 84-108
The activity of voltage-gated ion channels is the basic molecular mechanism underlying the electrical excitability of nerves and muscles (Hodgkin & Huxley 1952). These channels are specialized transmembrane proteins, which control and regulate the flow of ions across cell membranes by opening and closing ('gating') in response to changes in membrane potential (Hille 1992). The first identified and best-studied voltage-gated channel is the Shaker K+ channel from the fruitfly Drosophilia melanogaster (Tempel et al 1987); the corresponding voltage-gated K+ (Kv) channels in mammals are KV1.1-KV1.7 (Jan & Jan 1997). Normally closed at hyperpolarized resting potentials, Shaker K+ channels undergo a conformational transition from a closed to an open state at depolarization potentials (Cha et al 1999, Glauneretall999). Studies have shown that Shaker and all the channels in the Kv family are structurally and functionally similar. They are formed by four identical or homologous domains, or subunits (MacKinnon 1991). Analysis of the amino acid sequence suggests that each subunit contains six putative transmembrane (TM) segments, S1 to S6 (Jan & Jan 1997, Tempel et al 1987). The second (S2) 84
THE STRUCTURE OF SHAKER
85
and fourth (S4) segments contain several charged residues, which are affected by changes in membrane potential and form part of the voltage sensor that controls the gating of the channel (Aggarwal & MacKinnon 1996, Bezanilla 2000, Liman et al 1991, Logothetis et al 1992, Papazian et al 1991, Seoh et al 1996, Yellen 1998). The part of the protein forming the pore region responsible for the selectivity and conduction of K+ ions is located between segments S5 and S6 of a subunit in the region containing the essential amino acid 'signature sequence' TTVGYGD common to all K+ channels (Heginbotham et al 1992,1994). Although a growing body of information is available for Shaker and other voltage-activated channels in the Kv family, the only ion channel for which a structure at atomic resolution is currently available is the KcsA channel from Streptomyces lividans (Doyle et al 1998). The main features of the crystallographic structure are shown in Fig. 1. The channel is made of four identical subunits disposed symmetrically around a common axis corresponding to the pore (only two are shown in Fig. 1). Although the monomer of KcsA is formed by only two transmembrane helices, the amino acid sequence is, in fact, very similar to that of segment S5—S6, which is conserved in eukaryotic voltage-gated channels such as Shaker (Cortes & Perozo 1997, Doyle et al 1998, Schrempf et al 1995). Furthermore, a combination of structural and functional data with neurotoxin from scorpion indicates the extracellular vestibule of KcsA is structurally very similar to Shaker (MacKinnon et al 1998). In the absence of a detailed atomic structure, extensive studies using a variety of experimental approaches including electrophysiology, site-directed mutagenesis, resonance energy transfer and electron microscopy, have been used to probe the structure and function of the Shaker K+ channel. Undoubtedly, many of the experimental results obtained so far put very specific constraints on the structure of Shaker, though often indirectly. Nonetheless, the direct translation of all the available information into a 3D structure is not straightforward. The purpose of the present work is to develop a computational approach to construct and refine 3D models of Shaker by incorporating and integrating all available experimental data. The approach that we use is based on comparative modelization and global conformational optimization using energy restraints extracted from experimental data. Given the limited amount of information presently available, we do not expect to converge towards a unique 'best' model of Shaker. Instead, we seek to delineate and clarify, as objectively as possible, the current state of the knowledge about Shaker by generating an ensemble of plausible models which are consistent with the available data. Our hope is that such an ensemble of 3D models can play a useful role in the design of future experiments by indicating the areas of greatest uncertainty in the structure, by helping to examine the spatial relationship between functionally important residues, and by revealing inconsistencies between different experimental results.
86
ROUX
FIG. 1. Schematic view of the KcsA channel (only two of the four monomers are shown). The extracellular side is at the top and the intracellular side is at the bottom. The main structural elements are: the outer helix corresponding to S5 in voltage-gated K+ channels (residues by A391 to E418); the P loop formed by the pore helix and the selectivity filter which contains the signature sequence TTVGYGD (residues 1429 to T441); and the inner helix corresponding to S6 (residues G452 to N482).
Assumptions
The general topology of a Shaker subunit is illustrated schematically in Fig. 2. In particular, it is assumed that the segments S1-S4 are in an a-helical conformation and that the central pore formed by S5-P-S6 is structurally very similar to the crystallographic structure of the KcsA K+ channel. Although these assumptions are reasonable and currently supported by experimental evidence, some of them might turn out to be incorrect in the future. Nonetheless, such simplifications are necessary at this point.
THE STRUCTURE OF SHAKER
87
FIG. 2. Schematic view of one subunit of Shaker with its six transmembrane segments. It is assumed that S1 to S4 are in an a-helical conformation and that the central pore formed by S5—P-S6 is structurally similar to the crystallographic structure of the KcsA K+ channel shown in Fig. 1.
Helical conformation of the transmembrane segments S1-S4 It is assumed that the TM segments S1—S4, S1 (226-247): ARVVAIISVFVILLSIVIFCLE S2 (279-300): FFLIETLCIIWFTFELTVRFLA S3 (311-332): VMNVIDIIAIIPYFITLATVVA S4 (358-380): LAILRVIRLVRVFRIFKLSRHSK are in an a-helical conformation and are roughly perpendicular to the membrane plane, though some tilting of the helix axis is possible. This hypothesis is supported by a number of observations. Experimental studies have established that an isolated fragment corresponding to S4 adopts a predominantly a-helical conformation in methanol and in lipid membranes (Halsall & Dempsey 1999, Haris et al 1994, Mulvey et al 1989). The structure is a random coil in aqueous solution (Haris et al 1994). Similar studies with TM segments of the Na+ channel have shown that they adopt a-helical structures in detergent micelles (Doak et al 1996). There are also strong indications that the SI to S4 segments are a helical in the channel structure. Ala- (Li-Smerin et al 2000a) and Trp-scanning (Hong & Miller 2000, Monks et al 1999) mutagenesis studies suggest that S1 and S2 are amphipathic membrane spanning a helices that
88
ROUX
interface directly with the lipid membrane. Helical periodicity of functional alteration in the voltage-activation curves and gating kinetics were observed throughout S1 and S2. Trp-tolerant positions in the Shaker K+ channel are clustered on approximately half the a helix surface, as if the side chains are exposed to the hydrocarbon region of the lipid bilayer (Hong & Miller 2000, Monks et all 999). Similarly, Ala-scanning mutagenesis in the drkl K+ channel of S1 and S2 suggest that these segments are relatively simple amphipathic helices that span the full width of the membrane and make extensive contacts with the lipid membrane (Li-Smerin et al 2000a). The observations for the S3 and S4 segments are more complex. In the case of S3, the distribution of Trp-tolerant position is roughly consistent with a helical secondary structure, although the results are not as clear towards the extracellular side (Hong & Miller 2000). Results from Ala(Li-Smerin et al 2000a) and Lys-scanning (Li-Smerin & Swartz 2001) with the drkl K+ channel suggest that the S3 segment is entirely helical, but that the N-terminal region interfaces with both lipid and protein, whereas the C-terminal region interfaces with water. It has been speculated that a conserved proline at position 322 might induce a kink in the helical segment. Ala scanning of S4 reveals helical periodicity in only the C-terminal region (Li-Smerin et al 2000a). However, it seems likely that the absence of helical character in the N-terminal portion, which is exposed to the intracellular side, results from complexities in the aqueous and protein environment surrounding the segment. Structure of the centralpore S5-P-S6
It is assumed that the conformation of the central pore of Shaker, formed by the S5-P-S6 segment, is very similar to the crystallographic structure of KcsA (Doyle et al 1998). This is a very reasonable assumption given the high sequence similarity of the core of Shaker and the KcsA bacterial channel (Fig. 3). For 93 residues, the sequence identity is 31 for a global sequence similarity of 49%. This high similarity makes Shaker an excellent candidate for successful comparative modelling using the KcsA structure as a template (Fiser et al 2000). The structural similarity of Shaker relative to KcsA is also supported by experiments: AgTx2 binds to the KcsA channel, demonstrating that this prokaryotic K+ channel has the same pore structure as that of Shaker (MacKinnon et al 1998), and the chemical modifications of cysteines located along S6 by soluble thiol agents are generally consistent with the accessibility of the corresponding residues in KcsA (Liu et al 1997). Because the KcsA K+ channel is in a closed conformation (Roux et al 2000), the crystallographic structure is probably a better model for the closed state of Shaker. Nonetheless, although it appears to be very reasonable, the assumption that
THE STRUCTURE OF SHAKER
FIG. 3.
89
Sequence similarity between the KcsA and Shaker channels.
the S5—P—S6 core of Shaker is structurally similar to KcsA can be wrong for some regions of the structure. In particular, the sequence similarity is much smaller near the end of S6, which may indicate that the structure of this region differs from that of KcsA. In particular, S6 contains the motif Pro-ValPro at position 473-474-475, which is known to perturb a helices considerably (Barlow & Thornton 1988, von Heijne 1991). In addition, recent results from blocker protection in the pore of a voltage-gated K+ channel suggests that the structure of Kv channels differs from that of the KcsA by the introduction of a sharp bend in the S6 helices (del Camino et al 2000). Experimental data Intragenic suppression
Using an intragenic suppression strategy, Tiwari-Woodruff et al (1997) showed that charge reversal mutations of E283 in S2 and K374 in S4 disrupt maturation of the protein. Maturation was specifically and efficiently rescued by second-site charge reversal mutations, indicating that electrostatic interactions exist between E283 in S2 and R368 and R371 in S4, and between K374 in S4, E293 in S2, and D316 in S3. Further investigation of those mutants showed that the interaction between K374 in S4 and E293 in S3 and D316 in S3 is important for the closed state whereas the interaction between E283 in S2 and R368 and R371 in S4 is probably important for the open state (Tiwari-Woodruff et al 2000). Resonance energy transfer
Using lanthanide-based resonance energy transfer (LRET) to measure distances between Shaker K+ channel subunits at specific residues, Cha et al (1999) determined the distance between site-specific labelled monomers. Specific sites in the channel were fluorescently labelled by substituting cysteine for particular residues and attaching a cysteine-reactive compound of either a donor (a terbium-chelate maleimide, TbM) or an acceptor (fluorescein maleimide, FM). The intersubunit distances were evaluated using the relaxation time constant of acceptor-sensitized emission and donor emission without an acceptor. The
90
ROUX
distances estimated with this method are accurate because the lanthanide donor is in fast orientational averaging. For example, the distance measured across the pore at F425 is in excellent accord with the distance between the carbon a for the corresponding residue in the X-ray structure of KcsA. Furthermore, it was shown that the distances deduced independently from the energy transfer between the nearest and opposite subunits in the tetramer were consistent with Pythagoras' theorem. The most important distances measured between two monomers on opposite sides of the tetramer were 46 A for D273, which is located near the extracellular end of S2, 41 A for N353 near the extracellular end of S4, and 45 A for V363 in the middle of S4. Tethered pore blackers
Blaustein et al (2000) have used a clever method based on a series of compounds of varying length ending with a quaternary ammonium (QA) pore blocker. To locate the S1—S4 segments relative to the central pore these compounds were tethered to specific test residues using site-directed cysteine mutations. By examining the probability of blockade as a function of the length of the compounds, it was shown that the extracellular ends of S1 and S3 are approximately 30 A from the external opening of the pore while the S3-S4 linker is at 17-18 A from the pore. Scanning mutagenesis
Miller and co-workers have performed site-directed substitution of all residues in S1, S2 and S3, probing for significant functional changes (Hong & Miller 2000, Monks et al 1999). The function of the channel was significantly affected after substitution of Trp at the positions: A226, R227, V229, A230, S233, V234,1237, L238, S240,1241,1243, F244 and C245 for S1; E283, C286,1287, F290, E293, L294, R297 and A300 for S2; and M312, N313, 1315, D316, A319, 1320, P322, Y323, F324, L327, V330 and V331 for S3. The function of the channel was not affected by similar substitutions at other positions. Helical periodicity of functional alteration in the voltage activation curves and gating kinetics were observed throughout S1 and S2. A similar result was obtained with S3, although the distribution of Trp-tolerant position is not as clear towards the extracellular side. The Trp-tolerant positions are clustered roughly on one face of the putative a-helical segments, as if those side chains were exposed to the hydrocarbon region of the lipid bilayer. The results are consistent with Ala scanning mutagenesis studies on a related Kv channel (Li-Smerin et al 2000a, Li-Smerin & Swartz 2001). Interestingly, comparison of the amino acid sequence of several channels in the Kv family showed that the Trp-tolerant sites exhibit a high level of sequence variability, whereas the Trp-intolerant sites are highly conserved. This
THE STRUCTURE OF SHAKER
91
observation further reinforces the suggestion that Trp-tolerant residues are exposed to the lipid hydrocarbons, while the Trp-intolerant residues are involved in protein—protein contacts. Single-particle electron microscopy
Recently Sokolova et al (2001) obtained the 3D structure of the complete Shaker channel at 25 A resolution using single-particle electron microscopy. The 3D map clearly shows that the Shaker channel has a two-domain architecture with a transmembrane domain, corresponding to S1—S6, and a soluble domain corresponding to the Tl domain attached to the transmembrane domain by thin connectors. This two-domain architecture is consistent with the 'hanging gondola' model proposed by Kobertz et al (2000). Although the image is still at very low resolution, it shows that the transmembrane section of the channel has the shape of a compact square with sides of roughly 70 A. Modelization procedure The TM segments S1-S4 The S1—S4 segments were constructed as ideal a helices and then further refined by energy minimization. A rather conservative definition of helical segments S1 to S3, with only 21—22 residues, was used in the modelization to avoid 'over' constraining the system with long a-helical TM segments. In the case of S4, the helical segment was constructed as an a helix from residue 350 to 380 based on the mutagenesis results of Gonzalez et al (2000). Planar energy restraints were applied to keep the ends of the TM segments outside a 30 A thick hydrophobic slab and maintain the orientation of the helical segments. It is implemented as a half-harmonic potential with a force constant of 10kcal/mol-A 2 . This energy restraint keeps the helices roughly perpendicular to the membrane while allowing some tilting of the helices, in agreement with the orientation of TM helices in membrane proteins of known structure (Bowie 1997). For the sake of simplicity, the S1-S2 (31 residues), S2—S3 (10 residues), S3-S4 (17 residues), and S4— S5 (10 residues) linkers between the TM segments were not included explicitly. Instead, a simple half-quadratic restraint of 10 kcal/mol-A2 was used to limit the maximum distance between the C- and N-terminals of the ends of adjacent TM segments (S1—S2, S2— S3, S3—S4, and S4— S5). A maximum distance of 25 A was used for the S1—S2 linker while a distance of 10 A used for the other loops. Experimental studies have shown that the S3—S4 linker can be shortened from 17 to the five amino acids closest to S4 without disrupting the function and the gating of the channel (Sorensen et al 2000), indicating that the C- and N-terminals of the helices are probably located close to each other.
92
ROUX
The central pore
The 3D model of the central pore of Shaker was constructed on the basis of its sequence similarity with KcsA for which there is a crystallographic structure. The program MODELLLER v4 (Sali & Blundell 1993) was used to produce 3D homology-based models by satisfaction of spatial restraints. Its ability to produce high quality 3D atomic structures based on sequence similarity has been evaluated (Sali et al 1995). The segment S6 was modelled as a straight helix, even though there are indications of a sharp bend (del Camino et al 2000). The ideal fourfold symmetry of the tetrameric channel model was imposed with energy restraints. Fifty 3D models were generated. The best model was kept and then further refined with energy minimization of the side chains. Distance energy restraints
Several pieces of information can be translated as constraints on the range of allowed distances between different parts of the structure. This information is incorporated into the model as artificial distance-energy restraints which take the form of a quadratic function. All the restraints that were used are given in Table 1 . Energy restraints corresponding to the salt bridge between E293 in S2, D316 in S3 and K374 in S4 were applied (Tiwari- Woodruff et al 1997, 2000). A maximum distance of 3 A between the side chain atoms having the ability to form the salt bridge was applied with a harmonic force constant of 20kcal/mol-A2. Restraints corresponding to the salt bridge between E283 in S2 and R368 and R371 in S4 were also included. Because those salt bridges formed only in the open state (TiwariWoodruff et al 2000), weaker restraints with a force constant of 5 kcal/mol-A 2 and allowing for a maximum distance of 6 A were used. The LRET restraints are all applied between subunits A and D, and between subunits B and C. Because the linker residues between the TM segments are not included for the sake of simplicity, the LRET restraint measured for D273 which is part of the S1-S2 linker was transferred to F279 at the end of S2. Lipid-exposed residues
A directional energy restraint was applied to force the orientation of S1— S3 such that the Trp-tolerant residue points away from the core of the structure towards the lipid hydrocarbon region. The energy restraint takes the form of a pseudo dihedral angle, E expo (f) = Kexpocos(f-180) where f is the angle between the centre of mass of the lipid-exposed residues and the protein-exposed residues projected onto the XY plane. The restraint was
THE STRUCTURE OF SHAKER TABLE 1
93
Distance energy restraints
Inter-segment loops (for all submits) E247 CA
F247 CA
<25A
A300 CA A332 CA
V311 CA E358 CA
K380 CA
A391 CA
<10A <10A <10A
RE T measurements (all between submit A andD, and between submit B and C) V363 CB
V363 CB
F279 CB
F279 CB
Within 44-46 A
N353 CB
R371 CB
Within 36-40 A
Within 44-46 A
Salt bridge (distance takenfrom the nearest pair of any subunit) E293 OE*
K374NZ
<3A
D3160D
K374 NZ
<3A
E283 OE*
R368 NH*
E283 OE*
R371 NH*
<6 A <6 A
Planar restraints on ends of helices (for all subunits) A226 all atoms
z
< -15 A
E247 all atoms
z
> +15 A
F279 all atoms
z
>+15A z<-15A
A300 all atoms V311 all atoms
z
A332 all atoms
z
< - 15 A > +15 A
L358 all atoms
z>+15A
K380 all atoms
z<-15A
applied to all side chain atoms of the buried and exposed residues to ensure proper orientation with respect to the core structure S5—S6. The force constant of the pseudo-dihedral energy restraint Kexpo was 10 kcal/mol/rad2. An energy restraint based on a rigorous calculation of the solvent-accessible surface area (SASA) could be used in the later stage of the structural refinement. However, the calculation of the exact SASA (Richards 1977) is computationally much more expensive than the approximation used here, and is unnecessary at this stage.
94
ROUX
Conformational sampling and simulated annealing procedure
Initially, S1-S4 are disposed around the central pore in arbitrary positions and orientations to insure a thorough exploration of all conformational possibilities. To obtain a starting position, each TM segment is rotated around its axis using a randomly picked angle. The orientation of S1-S3 is chosen within a 10° window centred approximately to direct the Trp-tolerant residues away from the core of the structure whereas the orientation of S4 is completely randomized over 360o. The initial position of S1—S4 is then chosen randomly within a distance of 20-55 A away from the axis of the pore (with S4 between 20-25 A, S3 between 30-35 A, S2 between 40-45 A, and S1 between 50-55 A) as well as distributed within a 180 quadrant centred on their respective monomer. The random initial models were refined with cycles of molecular dynamics (MD) simulations at 600 K during 100 ps. To maintain constant temperature, the systems were simulated with Langevin dynamics with a friction constant corresponding to a velocity relation time of 1 ps - 1 . Electrostatic interactions were not included and van der Waals interactions were truncated at 5 A to reduce the computational cost. To maintain the helical conformation of the S1 to S4 segments an energy restraint based on the root-mean-square deviation was applied on all the backbone atoms (RMSD restraint). The backbone of the central core S5-P-S6 was fixed in space, but the side chains were allowed to move dynamically. The fourfold symmetry of the tetrameric channel was maintained during the simulated annealing procedure using energy restraints. To reduce the steric clashes and accelerate the convergence, the atoms were allowed to move along an unphysical 4th dimension w, i.e. the interatomic distances were calculated as r= x2 + y2 + z2 + w2 (van Schaik et al 1993). A harmonic restraint potential with the form 1/2K4Dw2 was used to progressively project the coordinates back onto the physical three-dimensional space. Lastly, the configuration was refined in 3D for l0ps at a reduced temperature of 300 K followed by 200 steps of energy minimization. Generating and refining one Shaker model took approximately 2 h on a Pentium III 850 MHz.
Results and discussion A general pattern rapidly emerged from preliminary conformational searches. In particular, it was observed that the S4 segment was localized near the groove between adjacent subunits to satisfy the distance of 45 A between V363 across the tetramer obtained by LRET (Cha et al 1999). The LRET restraints distance on F279 and N353 also contributed to this trend. In addition, it was observed that S2 and S3 were generally adjacent to one another, covering S4, and that the position of S1 relative to the rest of the structure was largely undetermined due to the long S1-S2 linker and the lack of distance constraints. The models have
THE STRUCTURE OF SHAKER
FIG. 4. search.
95
Example of the random initial configurations of S1 to S4 used in the conformational
extended structures, and S1 is often quite distant from the rest, which is most certainly incorrect. According to a low-resolution electron microscopy map (Sokolova et al 2001), Shaker should have a compact square structure of roughly 70 A on the side. To form a compact structure, S1 should be in proximity to the other segments S2— S4. Furthermore, all the charged residues of S4 cannot be shielded from the lipid environment by only S2 and S3. Because it is unlikely that charged residues would be exposed directly to the hydrocarbon of the membrane, S1 must also be involved in shielding the charges of S4. Lastly, although the interhelical linkers are sufficiently long to allow a 'scrambling' of the TM segments from adjacent subunits, surveys of membrane proteins show that TM helices generally pack against neighbours in the sequence (Bowie 1997). In order to generate a family of plausible models, we introduced one artificial restraint imposing that the centre of S1 is no more than 10 A away from the centre of S4. On the basis of these preliminary results, 100 models were generated according to three plausible topologies shown in Fig. 4. The initial position of S4 was chosen within a +10° window centred along the groove between adjacent subunits of the
96
FIG. 5. search.
ROUX
Example of the structural models of Fig. 4 after refinement with the conformational
central core to accelerate the conformational search. The position of S1-S3 is designed to cover S4 from the lipid hydrocarbon: S1-S2-S3, S2-S3-S1, S3-S2Sl and S1-S3-S2. The 100 models were refined with a simulated annealing procedure. One typical model of each type is shown in shown in Fig. 5. The 100 models are all equally plausible on the grounds of available information. Clearly, the spatial arrangement of S1—S3 cannot be determined without further information from further experiments. In the case of the S4 segment, the situation is slightly better and some general trends are emerging. Fig. 6 shows a superposition of the S4 segments from all 100 models with the central pore. The overall root-mean-square deviation on the backbone of all S4 is around 4—5 A. Although the orientation of the helix along its main axis is undefined at such resolution, the overall position of S4 is more or less determined by the modelization. In order to propose useful directions in mutagenesis studies of Shaker, we searched for pairs of residues between S4 and S5-P-S6 which are in frequent
THE STRUCTURE OF SHAKER
FIG. 6.
97
Superposition of the S4 segments from the 100 models with the central pore.
contact in the 100 generated models (a contact is defined as an interatomic distance less than 5 A). The results are given in Table 2. More contacts were observed near the extracellular side than on the intracellular side. This is, in part, due to the conical (inverted tepee) shape of the pore domain. This pattern of contact suggests that experiments searching for correlated interactions between S4 and the central core might have more success by focusing on the region near the extracellular side. Remarkably, several of the residues observed to be in contact with S4 were previously noted in the mutagenesis study of Li-Smerin et al (2000b). In their study, they examined the residue at the 'surface' of the central core S5--P-S6 constructed according to the KcsA crystallographic structure. The mutants producing large changes in gating were found to cluster near the interface between adjacent pore domain subunits. It was concluded that the voltage sensor machinery must be in contact with this region of the central pore. This is consistent with the present finding that S4 is located in this region. The positively charged residues in S4 (R362, R365, R368, and R371) are separated by two residues and would not all face the same side of an a helix. This suggests that some arginine residues must face the central core formed by S5-P—S6. Interestingly, a large number of possible contacts between S4 and aromatic side chains are observed in Table 2, such as R362 with F433, W434 and W454. It is known that positively charged side chains (Arg, Lys, His) can associate very favourably with an aromatic side chains (Phe, Tyr or Trp) (Gallivan & Dougherty 1999). The interaction between isolated arginine and phenylalanine side chains (without the backbone) is about —10 kcal/mol, a value similar to that of simple cations with benzene in the gas phase (Sunner et al 1981). Interestingly, mutation of F433 significantly affects gating (Li-Smerin et al 2000b). One may also
98
ROUX
TABLE 2 Residue contacts between S4 and S5-P-S6 from the Shaker models
S5 and S6
S4
L358 A359 I360 L361
P430 P430
D431
F433 F433 W434
W434 F453
F453 W454
W454 I457
K456
I457
W434 F453
F453 W454
W454 I457
K456
I457
I457
V458
S460
L461
S460 L461 L461 L461 F404
W454 L461 L461 L461 L461 I464 I464 I464 I464
F373 L375 R377
P430 F433 F433 F433 1457 F404 F404 F404 F404 F404 I400 F404 L468 L396 M393
R394
G397
H378 S379 K380
M393 M393 M393
N480 E395
N480
R362 V363 I364 R365 L366 V367 R368 V369 F370 R371
W434 I457 S460 I457
I464
note that R362 is the only position in S4 which, upon substitution by a histidine, transforms the voltage sensor into a proton channel when Shaker is in its closed state (F. Bezanilla, personal communication). Other important aromatic residues in the interface between adjacent subunits could be F404, W434, F453 and W454. Substitution of W434 by a phenylalanine transforms the channel into a nonconducting mutant (Perozo et al 1993). Because of the uncertainty in the 3D models, any of the residues R365, R368 and R371 could be in proximity of F404. Summary We have developed a general protocol based on a restrained molecular dynamics conformational search procedure for incorporating various kind of experimental information in the modelization of the Shaker K+ channel. We have generated 100 atomic models of Shaker in the closed inactivated state using the currently available data. The main result of the restrained conformational search is that S4 is probably
THE STRUCTURE OF SHAKER
99
located at the interface between adjacent subunits of the central pore. This is largely consistent with the mutagenesis results of Li-Smerin et al (2000b). Specific contacts between S4 and S5-P-S6 were found using the models generated by the conformational search which could be used to design future mutagenesis experiments. It is hoped that the present approach will help better define the 3D structure of Shaker as more experimental information becomes available. References Aggarwal SK, MacKinnon R 1996 Contribution of the S4 segment to gating charge in the Shaker K+ channel. Neuron 16:1169-1177 Barlow DJ, Thornton JM 1988 Helix geometry in proteins. J Mol Biol 201:601-619 Bezanilla F 2000 The voltage sensor in voltage-dependent ion channels. Physiol Rev 80:555-592 Blaustein RO, Cole PA, Williams C, Miller C 2000 Tethered blockers as molecular 'tape measures' for a voltage-gated K+ channel. Nat Struct Biol 7:309-311 Bowie JU 1997 Helix packing in membrane proteins. J Mol Biol 272:780-789 Cha A, Snyder GE, Selvin PR, Bezanilla F 1999 Atomic scale movement of the voltage-sensing region in a potassium channel measured via spectroscopy. Nature 402:809-813 Cortes DM, Perozo E 1997 Structural dynamics of the Streptomyces lividans K+ channel (SKC1): oligomeric stochiometry and stability. Biochemistry 36:10343—10352 del Camino D, Holmgren M, Liu Y, Yellen G 2000 Blocker protection in the pore of a voltagegated K+ channel and its structural implications. Nature 403:321-325 Doak DG, Mulvey D, Kawaguchi K, Villalain J, Campbell ID 1996 Structural studies of synthetic peptides dissected from the voltage-gated sodium channel. J Mol Biol 258:672-687 Doyle DA, Morais Cabral J, Pfuetzner RA et al 1998 The structure of the potassium channel: molecular basis of K+ conduction and selectivity. Science 280:69-77 Fiser A, Sanchez R, Melo F, Sali A 2000 Comparative protein structure modeling. In: MacKerrel AD, Roux B, Watanabe M (eds) Biological membranes: a molecular perspective from computation and experiment. Marcel Dekker, New York p 275—312 Gallivan JP, Dougherty DA 1999 Cation-pi interactions in structural biology. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 96:9459-9464 Glauner KS, Mannuzzu LM, Gandhi CS, Isacoff EY 1999 Spectroscopic mapping of voltage sensor movement in the Shaker potassium channel. Nature 402:813-817 Gonzalez C, Rosenman E, Bezanilla F, Alvarez O, Latorre R 2000 Modulation of the Sbaker K+ channel gating kinetics by the S3-S4 linker. J Gen Physiol 115:193-208 Halsall A, Dempsey CE 1999 Intrinsic helical propensities and stable secondary structure in a membrane-bound fragment (S4) of the shaker potassium channel. J Mol Biol 293:901-915 Haris PI, Ramesh B, Brazier S, Chapman D 1994 The conformational analysis of a synthetic S4 peptide corresponding to a voltage-gated potassium ion channel protein. FEBS Lett 349:371-374 Heginbotham L, Abramson T, MacKinnon R 1992 A functional connection between the pores of distantly related ion channels as revealed by mutant K+ channels. Science 258:1152-1155 Heginbotham L, Lu Z, Abramson T, Mackinnon R 1994 Mutations in the K+ channel signature sequence. Biophys J 66:1061-1067 Hille B 1992 Ionic Channels of Excitable Membranes, 2nd edn. Sinauer, Sunderland, MA Hodgkin AL, Huxley AF 1952 A quantitative description of membrane current and its application to conduction and excitation of nerve. J Physiol 117:500—544 Hong KH, Miller C 2000 The lipid-protein interface of a Shaker K+ channel. J Gen Physio! 115:51-58
100
ROUX
Jan LY, Jan YN 1997 Cloned potassium channels from eukaryotes and prokaryotes. Annu Rev Neurosci 20:91-123 Kobertz WR, Williams C, Miller C 2000 Hanging gondola structure of the Tl domain in a voltage-gated K+ channel. Biochemistry 39:10347-10352 Li-Smerin Y, Swartz KJ 2001 Helical structure of the COOH terminus of S3 and its contribution to the gating modifier toxin receptor in voltage-gated ion channels. ] Gen Physiol 117:205-218 Li-Smerin Y, Hackos DH, Swartz KJ 2000a Alpha-helical structural elements within the voltage-sensing domains of a K* channel. J Gen Physiol 115:33-50 Li-Smerin Y, Hackos DH, Swartz KJ 2000b A localized interaction surface for voltage-sensing domains on the pore domain of a K+ channel. Neuron 25:411-423 Liman ER, Hess P, Weaver F, Koren G 1991 Voltage-sensing residues in the S4 region of a mammalian K+ channel. Nature 353:752-756 Liu Y, Holmgren M, Jurman ME, Yellen G 1997 Gated access to the pore of a voltagedependent K+ channel. Neuron 19:175-184 Logothetis DE, Movahedi S, Satler C, Lindpaintner K, Nadal-Ginard B 1992 Incremental reductions of positive charge within the S4 region of a voltage-gated K+ channel result in corresponding decreases in gating charge. Neuron 8:531-540 MacKinnon R 1991 Determination of the subunit stoichiometry of a voltage-activated potassium channel. Nature 350:232-235 MacKinnon R, Cohen SL, Kuo A, Lee A, Chait BT 1998 Structural conservation in prokaryotic and eukariotic potassium channels. Science 280:106-109 Monks SA, Needleman DJ, Miller C 1999 Helical structure and packing orientation of the S2 segment in the Shaker K+ channel. J Gen Physiol 113:415-423 Mulvey D, King GF, Cooke RM, Doak DG, Harvey TS, Campbell ID 1989 High resolution 1H NMR study of the solution structure of the S4 segment of the sodium channel protein. FEBS Lett 257:113-117 Papazian DM, Timpe LC, Jan YN, Jan LY 1991 Alteration of voltage-dependence of Shaker potassium channel by mutations in the S4 sequence. Nature 349:305-310 Perozo E, MacKinnon R, Bezanilla F, Stefani E 1993 Gating currents from a nonconducting mutant reveal open-closed conformations in Shaker K+ channels. Neuron 11:353-358 Richards FM 1977 Areas, volumes, packing and protein structure. Annu Rev Biophys Bioeng 6:151-176 Roux B, Berneche S, Im W 2000 Ion channels, permeation and electrostatics: insight into the function of KcsA. Biochemistry 39:13295-13306 Sali A, Blundell TL 1993 Comparative protein modelling by satisfaction of spatial restraints. JMolBiol 234:779-815 Sali A, Potterton L, Yuan F, van Vlijmen H, Karplus M 1995 Evaluation of comparative protein modeling by MODELLER. Proteins 23:318-326 Schrempf H, Schmidt O, Kummerlen R et al 1995 A prokaryotic potassium ion channel with two predicted transmembrane segments from streptomyces lividans. EMBO J 14: 5170-5178 Seoh SA, Sigg D, Papazian DM, Bezanilla F 1996 Voltage-sensing residues in the S2 and S4 segments of the Shaker K+ channel. Neuron 16:1159-1167 Sokolova O, Kolmakova-Partensky L, Grigorieff N 2001 Three-dimensional structure of a voltage-gated potassium channel at 2.5 nm resolution. Structure 9:215-220 Sorensen JB, Cha A, Latorre R, Rosenman E, Bezanilla F 2000 Deletion of the S3-S4 linker in the Shaker potassium channel reveals two quenching groups near the outside of S4. J Gen Physiol 115:209-222 Sunner J, Nishizawa K, Kebarle P 1981 Ion-solvent molecule interactions in the gas phase. The potassium ion and benzene. J Phys Chem 85:1814-1820
THE STRUCTURE OF SHAKER
101
Tempel BL, Papazian DM, Schwarz TL, Jan YN, Jan LY 1987 Sequence of a probable potassium channel component encoded at Shaker locus of Drosophila. Science 237:770-775 Tiwari-Woodruff SK, Schulteis CT, Mock AF, Papazian DM 1997 Electrostatic interactions between transmembrane segments mediate folding of Shaker K+ channel subunits. Biophys J 72:1489 1500 Tiwari-Woodruff SK, Lin MA, Schulteis CT, Papazian DM 2000 Voltage-dependent structural interactions in the Shaker K+ channel. J Gen Physiol 115:123-138 van Schaik RC, Berendsen HJC, Torda AE, van Gunsteren WF 1993 A structure refinement method based on molecular dynamics in four spatial dimensions. J Mol Biol 234:751-762 von Heijne G 1991 Proline kinks in transmembrane alpha-helices. J Mol Biol 218:499-503 Yellen G 1998 The moving parts of voltage-gated ion channels. Q Rev Biophys 31:239-295
DISCUSSION Swartz: In terms of the location of S4 you propose, it seems that you are putting a tremendous amount of weight on the LRET (luminescence resonance energy transfer) distances from Bezanilla's group. The LRET distances they have from labelling a range of locations are all 45 A. The numbers were all the same whether they tagged the outer part of S2, the outer part of S3 or the outer part of S4. The question is, do these distances really constrain the location of S4? Roux: Cha et al (1999) reported several distances, ranging from 26-46 A. The measurements were done using LRET with lanthanides as donors and organic dyes as acceptors. The method yields distance estimates that are quite accurate because the influence of the anisotropy factors, normally important in conventional FRET (fluorescence energy transfer), are greatly reduced in lanthanide-based LRET. In fact, the main source of uncertainty in the measurements is the variability of the fluorophore's position with respect to the labelled residue because of the length of the cysteine-maleimide linker. The measurements are validated in the following way: by design, the channels that generate sensitized emission have three terbium-labelled subunits and one fluorescein-labelled subunit. The donor and acceptor can be between subunits that are either on opposite sides of the tetramer or are near neighbours, yielding two possible distances obeying the Pythagorean equation, and correspondingly, two possible decay rates for the energy transfer. Independent fitting of the decay rates shows that the two possible donor—acceptor distances obey the Pythagorean relation, which demonstrates the precision of the measured distances. For example, a distance of 30 A was measured across the tetramer between subunits labelled at Phe425, in excellent accord with the distance of 29 A between the corresponding residues (Gln58) in the KcsA crystallographic structure. Swartz: My initial reaction was that we all know it has to be 45 A or greater, on the basis of the structure of KcsA. Roux: Yes, if we measured S4 with a distance of say 39 A, we would feel this is too close.
102
DISCUSSION
I should have mentioned that with the tethered quaternary ammonium of Blaustein et al (2000), the top of S4 was labelled. The estimated distances are highly consistent. In the paper they said that the loop of S4 is probably leaning on top of the core, as if there is no groove. But such a distance is possible if S4 lies in the groove. Papazian: There is now an additional constraint between S2 and S3 that comes from a different channel, ether-a-go-go (eag). eag has a metal ion binding site formed by two acidic residues, one in S2 and one in S3 (Silverman et al 2000). This constraint should be very helpful for modelling the Shaker channel. Ken Swartz' lab have put forward a convincing argument that the voltage sensor must pack in the groove. When he plotted his data from perturbation analysis of the Shaker pore domain onto the KcsA structure, the highest impact residues mapped right into that stripe between the subunits. Roux: I looked very carefully at this paper, and you did not conclude with certainty that S4 was there. Swartz: That's correct. I don't think we know where S4 is located. S3 could be there. If I interpret what you are saying correctly, you are betting even-thing on LRET distances. I am not quite convinced that this is such a solid constraint. Roux: S5/S6 looks a bit like a clover-leaf with the four subunits. If you start to build S4 anywhere but in the groove, there is no way that you can shield such a polar helix with S1, S2 and S3. The only way to do this is to put S4 in the groove with the three other helices on top, covering it. Swartz: Yes, but S3 has a lot of complexities to it also. What is unique about S1 and S2 is that they have really well defined faces where you can make radical substitutions to hydrophobic residues, and they are well tolerated. Both S3 and S4 have much more complex patterns, as if they are more buried. I believe S1 and S2 are located in the periphery of the complex. If you think S4 is a helix, you mutate every residue to alanine, and look at the energetic perturbation in gating, there are significant patches where those mutations are very well tolerated. So S4 could also have some lipid-exposed surfaces. Roux: It could be exposed to an aqueous pore. There is quite a bit of space around S4, and this is because of the tepee shape of the KcsA-like S5-S6 (Doyle et al 1998). On the extracellular side it is packed tight, but on the intracellular side there is quite a bit of space around S4. If you mutate amino acids to alanine there, you may find that they are tolerated. This doesn't imply that they are exposed to the lipid. Mindell: Rod MacKinnon's work on cysteine accessibility in S4 (Aggarwal & MacKinnon 1996) and Pancho Bezanilla's histidine mutagenesis (Starace & Bezanilla 2001) also suggest that water is getting quite a significant way up or down S4. Sansom: It might be interesting to step back and think a bit about the methodology here. One of the problems in trying to think about future
THE STRUCTURE OF SHAKER
103
experiments is the ratio of observations to parameters. Essentially, there are a lot of restraint data from different experimental approaches. We want to know how many restraints we need in order to hit the right target. Comparable situations that have been explored in the past, where we know what the target is, are bacteriorhodopsin and rhodopsin (Herzyk & Hubbard 1995). Could one take a cluster of three helices from either of these structures and then let the other four pack in around them? Roux: That's a good idea. One could take the bacteriorhodopsin structure and just come up with a small number of restraints. Sansom: I think that for rhodopsin, for example, the sort of data already exist comparable to the soft data that the physiology generates. You could see how many data you would have to include to get within a certain root-mean-square deviation of the known crystal structure. Roux: You could simulate the entire thing: you could take the bacteriorhodopsin structure, find which residues are exposed to the lipid, and then you could have some distance restraints between a few amino acids. You could even insert some wrong distances, just to see how robust it is. Sansom: This is going to be a problem that will come up time and again with different proteins. One wants a feel for what the radius of convergence is. A uerbach: What exactly have we learned? You started with S4 in the groove; there is a face of S4 that you can pack into the protein. Do we know where the S1/S2/S3 ordering is? Roux: No, not really. Auerbach: So S1/S2/S3 could be in any order on the outside. Roux: Pretty much, although I don't think that S1 is between S2 and S3. Perozo: So there are three key constraints: the overall dimensions of the molecule, Diane Papazian's electrostatics, and five distances. Roux: There is also lipid exposure from the tryptophan scanning. Perozo: What specific data do you need to converge into a more reliable model? Roux: If I had as few as five distances between S4 and S5/S6, you would see something coming out. We built the AgTx2/Shaker complex with nine constraints. Ashcroft: This goes back to what Mark was saying: if you have some indication of how many restraints you need to produce a reliable model of something for which the structure is already known, then you can come back to the experimentalists with a list. Roux: On the basis of the AgTx2/Shaker complex it is clear that if we have about a dozen constraints, we will be OK. With two restraints you can already be in the right ballpark. Sansom: But, of course, we don't know the answer for AgTx2, as we don't have the crystal structure of the channel—toxin complex.
104
DISCUSSION
Roux: We did the barstar—barnase complex with the same method. With six or seven distances we got to about 1.7 A relative to the crystallograpic structure. Sansom: Essentially you are doing a jack-knifing test: can you take out data from the barstar—barnase, and see as you take more and more out, how much worse it gets? You need some sort of calibration. Roux: There are so many ways this can be done. In the current methodology the problem is not how accurate the model becomes with a certain number of restraints; rather, it is a matter of which restraints are fooling us because they were deduced from functional effects that we misunderstand. Sansom: In secondary structure prediction based on any pattern-learning approach, it is standard to take out the data and test how they match several times. Roux: It is clear that if I try to fold bacteriorhodopsin with too few restraints, I won't get the structure of bacteriorhodopsin. I am basically resolving the rough position of one helix here: I am saying that S4 must be at the interface between the subunits. Sixma: Compared to the toxin binding, how many variables do you have here, and how many did you have in the toxin? Now you have four independent units moving, whereas in the toxin there was just one. Roux: That is true, although in S1 to S4 they only have the angular rotation, whereas in the case of AgTx2 there is a full three-body rotation in three dimensions. Sixma: But the AgTx2 is moving as one element, whereas the subunits are moving independently, you may have many more variables. Roux: It is hard to tell, because the side chains are not rigid. Perozo: Diane Papazian, you also have a model of how S4 fits relative to the other subunits. Your proposal is that S4 is tilted relative to the membrane, whereas in Benoit Roux's model it is quite perpendicular. How do you explain this difference? Papazian: The tilt on our model came from trying to fit the S2-S4 constraints simultaneously in Shaker. However, we used extended side chains in our model. If you let the side chains rotate, the tilt can be much less. Mindell: But Benoit also constrained his helices to be perpendicular to the membrane. Roux: To a degree. The hydrophilic amino acids must be outside a slab of 30 A thick, which permits some tilting of the helices. Perozo: But you used the same set of data and your results are quite different. Roux: I am trying to generate a representative ensemble of models, which satisfy a number of established constraints about the structure of Shaker. The results should not be viewed as 'my model of Shaker', but rather as reflecting the present state of available structural information about Shaker. I believe that this approach will get us further in terms of defining what is known about the structure of Shaker. In my opinion, constructing and considering a single model (which satisfies known
THE STRUCTURE OF SHAKER
105
constraints) can be quite misleading because it can be very biased. Generating 100 models more or less randomly which have to satisfy a number of experimentally determined constraints is a sobering exercise. In particular, they show where the 'holes' are in the available information. That may not be a pleasant fact, but it makes it harder to delude oneself with one's favourite model. Also, it points in the direction where experimental data are most needed. On the other hand, when some structural feature appears to be recurrent, then one knows with confidence that it represents meaningful and robust knowledge about Shaker. Mindell: Once you are doing this kind of thing, is there a rule for trying to incorporate constraints based on sequence homologies? Roux: Before the tryptophan scan of Miller and his co-workers (Monks et al 1999, Hong & Miller 2000), people were tempted to just look for hypervariable regions and conclude that these must be exposed to the lipid. Once you have the tryptophan scan correlating to this, you don't really need anything more. What else would you use? Mindell: I would be looking more for things that are conserved, or that co-vary. Roux: Lockless & Ranganathan (1999) are doing this. If they find correlation between S5/S6 and S4, they will let me know. Swartz: We have done this, but we were unable to find any patterns. Perozo: Several studies in the mid-1990s looked for structural correlations within families of related proteins. With the exception of a few salt bridges, the general consensus is that this approach is not sensitive enough to pick up most compensating mutations. Papazian: If you look at divergent channels, covariance analysis would not necessarily pick out the structural constraints that we have identified in the Shaker voltage sensor. Sansom: If we relax the restraints on the S6 helix and let it bend a bit, how much would S4 then jiggle about? Roux: It is complicated to bend it, because S5 is in the way. I wasn't able to do this. In Gary Yellen's model, S6 is quite bent, and of course S4 will be influenced by this (del Camino et al 2000). Sansom: When we have tried to bend S6 at all, it is very difficult to maintain the KcsA-like packing. Roux: The S4 seems to be mostly packed against the core at the top, in the upper third of the structure. Choe: It would probably cost a lot more if you want to tilt it, because of the tepee shape of the core domain. Here's a hypothetical model: if you have KcsA sequences for the core domain S5/S6, but the rest is a Shaker sequence like you have, would you expect S4 to be in a similar conformation? Roux: 1 don't think it would make a large difference at the present level of modelizations.
106
DISCUSSION
Auerbach: I know that you still have a lot of wiggle room in terms of the position of S4, but do you have a sense of whether residues of S4 are equally likely to interact with S5 or S6? Roux: Because S1 /S2/S3 is so underdetermined, by the time you have considered all these possibilities, S4 has almost gone round full circle. In the end you get a large number of amino acids of S4 that could possibly touch S5 or S6. Auerbach: Almost all the numbers in S5/S6 that you are picking out are in S5. Roux: One observation that could be a little discomforting is that some of the contacts suggested by the models were residues that did not have a large impact on the gating of Shaker upon mutation (Li-Smerin et al 2000). Swartz: There is an important qualification worth mentioning. The measurements you refer to are sensitive to perturbations at any step in the activation pathway. That is they don't distinguish between effects on the voltagesensor, the gate or the interaction between the two. We have now looked at the effects of pore domain shell mutations on charge translocation within the voltage-sensors by measuring perturbations in the charge versus voltage relations. These patterns are quite different than those we previously observed for perturbation of the conductance-voltage relations. My view is that, at least from our work, the position of S4 in relation to the core region (S5-S6) is a completely open question. Roux: I am not proposing any particular orientation of S4. I believe that somewhere among these pairs of amino acids, there are a few that could be experimentally verified. Auerbach: In the AgTx2, one of the double-mutant cycle analyses was well off. Do you have an explanation for this? Roux: We haven't finished this work, so what I can say is limited. Apparently, there is an effective coupling between Serll (of AgTx2) and Asp431 (of Shaker) (Ranganathan et al 1996) despite the fact that the two residues are not close in space. The coupling might arise because the toxin is very rigid and a coupling can be transmitted through the structure. Nonetheless, this case is an exception. Generally, most of the double mutants that appear to be coupled are indeed close in space (Schreiber & Fersht 1995, Buckle et al 1994). This is the basis for using these couplings as distance restraints in trying to derive a structural model. Mindell: Between yours and Rod's data on the toxin, it looks great that the outsides of the channels are the same, but how much constraint does that put on the other side? Gary's data argue that there are differences. Do you have a lot of freedom in there? Roux: In fact, even the turrets of Shaker are probably not much like KcsA. When we finally had our structure, we did an alanine scan of AgTx2 in the computer. We predicted that a few amino acids should affect the binding. In fact, they were
THE STRUCTURE OF SHAKER
107
mutated in the past. Some of them don't have a big effect, and they are involved with the turrets. Mindell: It seems that a lot of arguments of detail come from the interactions on the cytoplasmic end of this little notch. Roux: The precise structure near the tip of KcsA does not influence very much, except if there was this big kink in S6, then S4 might want to pack slightly differently. Miller: What is the sensitivity of the model to the size of the constraint? Let's say that the LRET is not very accurate, and the real constraint is 50 A and not 43 A. What happens to the predictions of your model? Roux: Then things would get quite undetermined. Instead of being +2 A I put my constraints as being +10 A, everything goes away. But the accuracy of LRET is better than that (Burmeister Getz et al 1998). Samom: In the context of hard versus soft restraints, you said you wanted to put a distance restraint for closed state versus open state. One was about 3 A and one was about 6 A. My back of the envelope calculation suggests that this might be a bit optimistic. If the LRET data suggesting quite a substantial rotation in S4 are accurate, then 6 A is a bit on the short side. I think the change is more like 20 A, if there are two side chains pointing towards one another and then you rotate both of them. Roux: Only one segment is thought to rotate, the S4. There is no evidence of S1, S2 or S3 undergoing significant rotations. References Aggarwal SK, MacKinnon R 1996 Contribution of the S4 segment to gating charge in the Shaker K+ channel. Neuron 16:1169-1177 Blaustein RO, Cole PA, Williams C, Miller C 2000 Tethered blockers as molecular 'tape measures' for a voltage-gated K+ channel. Nat Struct Biol 7:309—311 Buckle AM, Schreiber G, Fersht AR 1994 Protein-protein recognition: crystal structural analysis of a barnase— barstar complex at 2.0 A resolution. Biochemistry 33:8878-8889 Burmeister Getz E, Cooke R, Selvin PR 1998 Luminescence resonance energy transfer measurements in myosin. Biophys J 74:2451—2458 Cha A, Snyder GE, Selvin PR, Bezanilla F 1999 Atomic scale movement of the voltage-sensing region in a potassium channel measured via spectroscopy. Nature 402:809-813 del Camino D, Holmgren M, Liu Y, Yellen G 2000 Blocker protection in the pore of a voltagegated K+ channel and its structural implications. Nature 403:321-325 Doyle DA, Morais Cabral J, Pfuetzner RA et al 1998 The structure of the potassium channel: molecular basis of K+ conduction and selectivity. Science 280:69-77 Herzyk P, Hubbard RE 1995 Automated method for modeling 7-helix transmembrane receptors from experimental-data. Biophys J 69:2419-2442 Hong KH, Miller C 2000 The lipid-protein interface of a Shaker K+ channel. J Gen Physiol 115:51-58 Li-Smerin Y, Hackos DH, Swartz KJ 2000 A localized interaction surface for voltage-sensing domains on the pore domain of a K+ channel. Neuron 25:411-423
108
DISCUSSION
Lockless SW, Ranganathan R 1999 Evolutionarily conserved pathways of energetic connectivity in protein families. Science 286:295-299 Monks SA, Needleman DJ, Miller C 1999 Helical structure and packing orientation of the S2 segment in the Shaker K+ channel. J Gen Physiol 113:415-423 Ranganathan R, Lewis JH, MacKinnon R 1996 Spatial localization of the K+ channel selectivity filter by mutant cycle-based structure analysis. Neuron 16:131 139 Schreiber G, Fersht AR 1995 Energetics of protein-protein interactions: analysis of the barnase barstar interface by single mutations and double mutant cycles. J Mol Biol 248:478 486 Silverman WR, Tang CY, Mock AF, Huh KB, Papazian DM 2000 Mg2+ modulates voltagedependent activation in ether-a-go-go potassium channels by binding between transmembrane segments S2 and S3. J Gen Physiol 116:663-678 Starace DM, Bezanilla F 2001 Histidine scanning mutagenesis of basic residues of the S4 segment of the shaker K+ channel. J Gen Physiol 117:469-490
Permeation energetics in a model potassium channel Stefano Garofoli, Gennady Miloshevsky, Vladimir L. Dorman and Peter C. Jordan 1 Department of Chemistry, MS-015, Brandeis University, PO Box 549110, Waltham, MA 02454-9110,USA
Abstract. Known structures of selective ion channels share a common property: a narrow constriction, presumably crucial for ionic discrimination. This region can be fairly long, imposing single file motion on waters and ion(s). We apply the semi-microscopic Monte Carlo approach to study permeation in the KcsA channel, decomposing energetics into a three-step process: cation dehydration; ion transfer into a uniform low £ dielectric; and transfer from the uniform dielectric into the channel. The influence of individual channel structural features is separately assessed. The aqueous cavity has only a modest stabilizing effect on nearby ions in the filter. Ionic solvation in the filter reflects the combined influence of the single file waters, the binding pockets' carbonyls, the a helices directed at the cavity and the negative residues near the extracellular surface of the channel; no one feature dominates. At all sites along the permeation pathway there is substantial discrimination favouring K+ over Na + ; conversely, there is little discrimination among the larger alkali cations. Selectivity for K+ over Na+ appears due to the inability of the filter's carbonyl oxygens to ideally coordinate Na + . 2002 Ion channels—from atomic resolution physiology to functional genomics. Wiley, Chichester (Novartis Foundation Symposium 245) p 109-126
Until recently theoretical study of ionic interaction with ion channel proteins was either based on structural speculations or limited to considering the model system gramicidin (see Roux & Karplus 1994). The situation is now dramatically different. Four distinct selective channel systems have been solved to atomic level resolution: a K+ channel from Streptomyceslividans (KcsA; Doyle et al 1998), a stretch-activated channel from Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Tb-McsL; Chang et al 1998), human red cell aquaporin 1 (AQP1; Murata et al 2000) and the Escherichia coli glycerol facilitator (GlpF; Fu et al 2000). All share a common feature, a constricted region where the transported species must lose much of its surrounding water and pass in close proximity to the channel protein. In KcsA the constriction is This paper was presented at the symposium by Peter Jordan, to whom correspondence should be addressed.
110
GAROFOLIETAL
visible from the X-ray structure and is associated with a single file domain like that in gramicidin (Wallace 1999), but substantially shorter, some 10-15 A long. A similar feature may be integral to the function of AQP1 (Murata et al 2000). The structure of KcsA confirmed many electrophysiological inferences, investing kinetic models of the multi-ion permeation pathway (Hille & Schwartz 1978, Neyton & Miller 1988) with structural reality (Doyle et al 1998). It also revealed some unexpected architectural details: the carbonyl binding pockets, the mid-channel aqueous cavity and the a helices aimed at the cavity. The AQP1 structure, with a helices pointed at the constriction, rationalizes how this protein forms water channels and simultaneously blocks proton transport. Nonetheless, questions remain. In KcsA, what creates essentially barrier-less free energy profiles for permeant ion transport, i.e. why are K+ channel conductances so high? What accounts for essentially insurmountable energetic obstructions to the flow of similar competing species, i.e. why is the K + /Na + permeability ratio so high? How do individual structural features affect permeation energetics? Which features simply lead to superposable static fields and which induce major dielectric reorientation? This chapter examines these issues, describing the effect of individual structural features on the permeation free energy profile, and suggesting reasons for certain aspects of channel design. We extend the approach to compare permeation energetics among the alkali cations, emphasizing the importance of hydration energetics. Modelling ion channels Many theoretical approaches illuminate structure-function relationships in ion channels. Gramicidin has been their proving ground (Roux & Karplus 1994, Dorman et al 1996, Woolf & Roux 1997, Chiu et al 1991, Jakobsson & Chiu 1987). Using the X-ray structure of KcsA as a guide, insight has been gained from electrostatic analysis (Roux & MacKinnon 1999), Brownian dynamics (BD) (Chung et al 1999) and molecular dynamics (MD) (Aqvist & Luzhkov 2000, Shrivastava & Sansom 2000, Berneche & Roux 2000, Guidoni et al 2000, Biggin et al 2001). In MD, the computational models hew closely to the known structure and provide a wealth of information. Among the simulational results are: a model for the permeation duty cycle (Aqvist & Luzhkov 2000); evidence for the permeant ions' role in structurally stabilizing the channel (Shrivastava & Sansom 2000); a detailed picture for the functional permeating assembly (Berneche & Roux 2000); identification of a possible secondary influence of the oriented a helices (Guidoni et al 2000); and a novel hypothesis for the origin of K + / N