Iris Murdoch A Literary Life
Priscilla Martin and Anne Rowe
Literary Lives This series offers stimulating accounts of...
38 downloads
1607 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Iris Murdoch A Literary Life
Priscilla Martin and Anne Rowe
Literary Lives This series offers stimulating accounts of the literary careers of the most admired and influential English-language authors. Volumes follow the outline of the writers’ working lives, not in the spirit of traditional biography, but aiming to trace the professional, publishing and social contexts which shaped their writing. Published titles include: Clinton Machann MATTHEW ARNOLD
Tony Sharpe T. S. ELIOT
Jan Fergus JANE AUSTEN
David Rampton WILLIAM FAULKNER
John Beer WILLIAM BLAKE
Harold Pagliaro HENRY FIELDING
Tom Winnifrith and Edward Chitham CHARLOTTE AND EMILY BRONTË
Andrew Hook F. SCOTT FITZGERALD
Sarah Wood ROBERT BROWNING
Mary Lago E. M. FORSTER
Janice Farrar Thaddeus FRANCES BURNEY
Shirley Foster ELIZABETH GASKELL
Caroline Franklin BYRON
Neil Sinyard GRAHAM GREENE
Sarah Gamble ANGELA CARTER
James Gibson THOMAS HARDY
Nancy A. Walker KATE CHOPIN
Linda Wagner-Martin ERNEST HEMINGWAY
Roger Sales JOHN CLARE
Cristina Malcolmson GEORGE HERBERT
Graham Law and Andrew Maunder WILKIE COLLINS
Gerald Roberts GERARD MANLEY HOPKINS
Cedric Watts JOSEPH CONRAD
Neil Roberts TED HUGHES
Grahame Smith CHARLES DICKENS
Kenneth Graham HENRY JAMES
George Parfitt JOHN DONNE
W. David Kaye BEN JONSON
Paul Hammond JOHN DRYDEN
R. S. White JOHN KEATS
Kerry McSweeney GEORGE ELIOT
Phillip Mallett RUDYARD KIPLING
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
Founding Editor: Richard Dutton, Professor of English, Lancaster University
Gary Waller EDMUND SPENSER
William Gray ROBERT LOUIS STEVENSON
Tony Sharpe WALLACE STEVENS
Angela Smith KATHERINE MANSFIELD
Lisa Hopkins BRAM STOKER
Lisa Hopkins CHRISTOPHER MARLOWE
Joseph McMinn JONATHAN SWIFT
Cedric C. Brown JOHN MILTON
William Christie SAMUEL TAYLOR COLERIDGE
Priscilla Martin and Anne Rowe IRIS MURDOCH
Leonée Ormond ALFRED TENNYSON
Peter Davison GEORGE ORWELL
Peter Shillingsburg WILLIAM MAKEPEACE THACKERAY
Linda Wagner-Martin SYLVIA PLATH
David Wykes EVELYN WAUGH
Felicity Rosslyn ALEXANDER POPE
Caroline Franklin MARY WOLLSTONECRAFT
Ira B. Nadel EZRA POUND
John Mepham VIRGINIA WOOLF
Richard Dutton WILLIAM SHAKESPEARE
John Williams WILLIAM WORDSWORTH
John Williams MARY SHELLEY
Alasdair D. F. Macrae W. B. YEATS
Michael O’Neill PERCY BYSSHE SHELLEY
Literary Lives Series Standing Order ISBN 978–0–333–71486–7 Series Standing Order ISBN 978–0–333–80334–9 (outside North America only)
hardcover paperback
You can receive future titles in this series as they are published by placing a standing order. Please contact your bookseller or, in case of difficulty, write to us at the address below with your name and address, the title of the series and one of the ISBNs quoted above. Customer Services Department, Macmillan Distribution Ltd, Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS, England
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
John Worthen D. H. LAWRENCE
A Literary Life Priscilla Martin and
Anne Rowe Director of the Centre for Iris Murdoch Studies
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
Iris Murdoch
All rights reserved. No reproduction, copy or transmission of this publication may be made without written permission. No portion of this publication may be reproduced, copied or transmitted save with written permission or in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, or under the terms of any licence permitting limited copying issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency, Saffron House, 6–10 Kirby Street, London EC1N 8TS. Any person who does any unauthorized act in relation to this publication may be liable to criminal prosecution and civil claims for damages. The authors have asserted their rights to be identified as the authors of this work in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. First published 2010 by PALGRAVE MACMILLAN Palgrave Macmillan in the UK is an imprint of Macmillan Publishers Limited, registered in England, company number 785998, of Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS. Palgrave Macmillan in the US is a division of St Martin’s Press LLC, 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, NY 10010. Palgrave Macmillan is the global academic imprint of the above companies and has companies and representatives throughout the world. Palgrave® and Macmillan® are registered trademarks in the United States, the United Kingdom, Europe and other countries. ISBN 978–1–4039–4850–2 hardback This book is printed on paper suitable for recycling and made from fully managed and sustained forest sources. Logging, pulping and manufacturing processes are expected to conform to the environmental regulations of the country of origin. A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. A catalog record for this book is available from the Library of Congress. 10 19
9 18
8 7 17 16
6 15
5 4 14 13
3 12
2 11
1 10
Printed and bound in Great Britain by CPI Antony Rowe, Chippenham and Eastbourne
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
© Priscilla Martin and Anne Rowe 2010 Cover image © Yevonde Portrait Archive
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
To John Bayley
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
This page intentionally left blank
Preface
viii
Acknowledgements
xii
Notes on References and Abbreviations
xiii
An Iris Murdoch Chronology: Significant Dates and Events
xiv
1
Early Life
2
After the War
1 14
3 Triangles and Polygons
36
4
58
Ireland
5 New Directions, Constant Themes
71
6
The Love Machine
7
Retreats and Returns
117
92
8
The Late Novels
135
9
Afterlife
163
Notes
172
Select Bibliography
190
Index
195
vii
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
Contents
In a letter to the Indian scholar Saguna Ramanathan, Iris Murdoch said that searching for clues in her novels and linking them with each other is not as rewarding as actually studying a given work for itself.1 This study of her 26 novels takes just such an approach. Each novel is discussed in relation to issues and contexts that suggest themselves from a close reading. The structure is chronological so that readers can easily access whichever period of Murdoch’s career is of most interest. They are taken through Murdoch’s literary life from her entry into Badminton School in 1932, which produced her early poetry and polemical writing, through to her final novel, Jackson’s Dilemma, in 1995. Some consideration is given to Murdoch’s first book on philosophy, Sartre: Romantic Rationalist, alongside a detailed account of her first novel, Under the Net, because together they set up structures and themes, such as the dialectic between the ‘saint’ and the ‘artist’, that are to endure throughout the novels. We fall out of chronology slightly to include a chapter on Murdoch’s Irishness and the ‘Irish’ stories – ‘Something Special’, The Unicorn and The Red and the Green – because her Irish heritage was an intrinsic aspect of her literary identity. We do not explore her philosophy in relation to the novels in any systematic way, nor do we rehearse in any detail here her denial of being a philosophical novelist. However, in her book on Sartre, Murdoch paid particular attention to his novels which, she claimed, ‘reveal very clearly the central structure of his philosophy’.2 Similarly, we find her philosophical preoccupations – the death of God, the basis of morality, the problem of free will and the dangers of solipsism – vividly present in her fiction and discuss their varying significance in individual novels. The main purpose of this volume is to focus on the wealth of other influences and fields of knowledge on which Murdoch drew, and to explore relevant social, cultural and political issues that emerge out of the texts. Taking direction from such an abundance of allusions brings peripheral influences, themes and characters freshly into focus. Thus, particular bands of characters offer themselves for comment: the sages, teachers, mentors, viii
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
Preface
ix
priests, civil servants and damaged outsiders. Murdoch’s love of the theatre and of Shakespeare, who she says is present in all her novels, comes to the fore, as does her love of painting and painters – Titian, Rembrandt, Tintoretto, Giorgione and Gainsborough. Her debt to Henry James emerges: like him, she employed the traditional form of the novel, experimented with it and discussed its implications in her theoretical work. As such, we consider her literary theory in relation to the novels. For example, ‘Against Dryness’ sets up the ‘crystalline’ and ‘journalistic’ categories Murdoch applied to fiction, fearing her own attention to the ‘crystalline’, to pattern and form at the expense of character, contingency and freedom. The settings of her novels, London, the Thames, Oxford and the sea, come into focus, as do some hitherto neglected influences: the extent of the role of medieval literature in The Green Knight, for example, and the transformation of traditional Christian doctrines into ‘neo-theological’ Murdochian terms. When questioned as to how far writers should use art for political purposes, Murdoch said that she did not think ‘that an artist should worry about looking after society in his art [...] I wouldn’t regard this as quite being my job as an artist [...] I think as an artist one’s first duty is to the art you practise, and to produce the best kind of work that you know how [...] It’s a novelist’s job to be a good artist, and this will involve telling the truth, and not worrying about social commitment. I think social commitment in so far as it interferes with art, is very often a mistake’.3 In the main, Murdoch’s fiction practises what she preaches, although we have pointed out a number of political analogies: for example, The Flight from the Enchanter is discussed as a novel of the Cold War and The Message to the Planet is described as ‘Millennialist’. Her involvement with the debate surrounding the Vietnam War runs concurrently with the writing of An Accidental Man (in which the War is an integral part of the plot). We have found political influences too in A Word Child by juxtaposing it with her consistent participation in debates on Government Education Policy and we discern more of an imaginative testing of the views she expounded there than previous critics. However, for the most part, the novels focus on how relationships between individuals are affected, but not entirely driven, by the events in the public domain. The political and cultural background seems to fade somewhat in the later books, which become longer, darker
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
Preface
Preface
and denser, more brooding and inward-looking and more mystical. Information on her personal life is only included when it seems either inappropriate or disingenuous to ignore the resonances between her art and her life. The debate on how far the life and work are entwined is ongoing in Murdoch studies and is rehearsed in the final chapter, ‘Afterlife’, which looks at the Murdoch ‘industry’ that developed after her death, at contemporary Murdoch scholarship and the ever-increasing body of biographical information becoming available, which is creating its own challenges for Murdoch scholars. Murdoch passionately wanted the novel to be kept alive and not fail in its inclusiveness and ability to reach the human heart as well as challenge and expand the mind. She called herself a ‘moral psychologist’ and we also look at the ways in which the novels reveal her love of humanity and her just and tolerant presentation of human frailty, which is also a concern for representing human consciousness as accurately as possible in art. Her presentation of the moral dangers of sexual obsession, the terrible familiarity of long-term relationships and the ease with which she confronts homosexuality, sadomasochism and incest are seen against the respect she demands for the joy of sexual desire as a route to goodness. This is far from a definitive study of the myriad influences within Iris Murdoch’s novels; no single work could achieve such a distinction. But we have attempted to give a flavour of her moral and philosophical concerns, of literary influences, social and cultural contexts with which the novels engage and enough biographical information to indicate those actual experiences and people significant enough to seep into her fiction. Chapters indicate the shift in her emotions through ambition, exhilaration, self-doubt, indecision, reassessments, renunciations and finally to the fracturing of identity that was Alzheimer’s. We hope that for new Murdoch readers and seasoned Murdoch scholars alike, this study will instigate a broader interest in Murdoch’s work and its world, enable a deeper understanding of the nature of the creative process and, most of all, provide a means of intensifying the pleasure of her novels. Although Murdoch herself would want her readers to focus on what her novels cannot say too. Her first and last each ends with a reminder of the mystery of the world, that to which language can only point but not explain. In Under
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
x
xi
the Net Jake ponders the genetic diversity of Mrs Tinckham’s odd brood of Siamese/tabby kittens and accepts that they are ‘just one of the wonders of the world’4 and Jackson, in Jackson’s Dilemma, ‘come[s] to a place where there is no road’, walks down, towards the river, crosses a bridge and bids farewell with one last, enigmatic smile.5
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
Preface
We are indebted to Peter Conradi’s Iris Murdoch: A Life and John Bayley’s trilogy of memoirs, most particularly the first volume, Iris: A Memoir of Iris Murdoch, for biographical information referred to in this study. Valerie Purton’s An Iris Murdoch Chronology was also invaluable and we are grateful to Valerie for allowing us to keep our text uncluttered and reference as economically as possible. The Edward Mellen Press kindly gave permission to use material from The Visual Arts and Iris Murdoch freely. Michael Bott at the University of Reading archives gave access to the Chatto Archive and Dr David Smith, librarian at St Anne’s College, Oxford, to the St Anne’s archive. Jane Ruddell, former archivist at Kingston University, and her successor, Katie Giles, provided information on the materials acquired by the Centre for Iris Murdoch Studies. We are grateful to John Bayley, Philippa Foot and Mary Midgley, who shared recollections of Iris Murdoch to Priscilla Martin, and to Marjorie Boulton, who imparted memories and gave access to Murdoch’s correspondence to her. Lawrence N. Hole at the Yevonde Portrait Archive gave permission for use of the cover portrait of Iris Murdoch by Madame Yevonde. The photograph itself is from the private collection of Peter Conradi who kindly made it available and assisted in tracking down copyright. Pamela Osborn and Frances White have provided invaluable editorial help.
xii
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
Acknowledgements
References to the following texts refer to the editions indicated and are abbreviated as follows: Iris Murdoch, Existentialists and Mystics: Writings on Philosophy and Literature, Peter J. Conradi (ed.) (London: Chatto & Windus, 1997): EM Peter J. Conradi, The Saint and The Artist: A Study of the Fiction of Iris Murdoch, 3rd edn (London: HarperCollins, 2001): SA Peter J. Conradi, Iris Murdoch: A Life (London: HarperCollins, 2001): IMAL Gillian Dooley, From a Tiny Corner in the House of Fiction: Conversations with Iris Murdoch (Columbia: University of South Carolina Press, 2003): TCHF Iris Murdoch, Metaphysics as a Guide to Morals (London: Chatto & Windus, 1992): MGM Iris Murdoch, The Sovereignty of Good (London: Routledge, 1970): SG Valerie Purton, An Iris Murdoch Chronology (Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 2007): IMC Anne Rowe (ed.), Iris Murdoch: A Reassessment (Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 2007): IMAR Anne Rowe, The Visual Arts and the Novels of Iris Murdoch (Lampeter: Mellen, 2002): VAIM Editions of Iris Murdoch’s novels used are fully referenced at the first mention in each chapter with the original publication date. Thereafter, page numbers appear in parentheses.
xiii
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
Notes on References and Abbreviations
1919
1925
1926 1931 1932 1938
1939
1942
1944
1945–6
Iris Murdoch born at 59 Blessington Street, North Dublin. She and her mother, Rene, move to 12 Caithness Road, Acton to join her father, Hughes, in November of this year. Attends the expensive Froebel Demonstration School at Colet Gardens in London. Annual holidays are spent in Dun Laoghaire in Ireland. The Murdoch family moves to 4 Eastbourne Road, Chiswick. Murdoch is made Head Girl of the Froebel School. She wins one of the two open scholarships to Badminton School, Bristol. Murdoch goes up to Somerville College, Oxford. She progresses from ‘Mods’, classical languages and literature, to ‘Greats’, ancient history and philosophy. Here she meets Mary Midgley, Philippa Foot, David Hicks, Frank Thompson, M.R.D Foot and others who will feature significantly in her life. She joins the Communist Party and becomes heavily involved in Labour Club activities. The Cherwell magazine publishes Murdoch’s poems and she tours with the Magpie Players, performing set-piece ballads and songs and short dramatic or comic interludes for charity. Becomes a civil servant in London, taking up a post as temporary Assistant Principal to the Treasury. She moves into 5 Seaforth Place, which she later shares with Philippa Foot. She frequents the pubs of Fitzrovia that are to be the haunts of her characters, including the Wheatsheaf and the Pillars of Hercules. Working for the United Nations Relief and Rehabilitation Administration (UNRRA). She grieves deeply at the death of Frank Thompson. Now in Brussels and Innsbruck, where she meets Raymond Queneau. She is deeply affected by the plight of displaced persons in the refugee camps. Her final posting is in Graz. She resigns in July 1946. xiv
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
An Iris Murdoch Chronology: Significant Dates and Events
1947
1948
1951
1953 1954
1956
1957
1958
Takes up Research Studentship in Philosophy at Newnham College, Cambridge. She meets Wittgenstein and his pupil, Elizabeth Anscombe. Becomes Fellow and Tutor in Philosophy at St Anne’s College, Oxford. She teaches moral and political philosophy – Plato, Aristotle, Kant, Descartes, Berkeley and Hume, amongst other philosophers. She begins broadcasting on the BBC and publishing essays. Meets Franz Baermann Steiner, with whom she falls in love. He has a serious heart condition and dies the following year. Murdoch suffers deeply after his death. First book, Sartre: Romantic Rationalist, is published. It is dedicated to Murdoch’s parents. Murdoch meets her future husband, an Oxford don, John Bayley, at a party. She is diagnosed as partially deaf. Under the Net, her first novel, is published by Chatto & Windus, who will first publish all her subsequent novels. Under the Net, dedicated to Raymond Queneau, wins the runner-up prize for the novel at the Cheltenham Literature Festival. Her second novel, The Flight from the Enchanter, is published. The enchanter figure of the novel, Mischa Fox, is based on Elias Canetti. Murdoch marries John Bayley at a registry office ceremony in Oxford. They honeymoon in Italy and later in the year move into their country home in Steeple Aston. ‘Something Special’, a short story, appears in Macmillan’s Winter’s Tales, Volume 3. It is not to be published separately until 1999, after Murdoch’s death. Her third novel, The Sandcastle, dedicated to John Bayley, is published. It is not well reviewed. Murdoch’s father, Hughes, dies at the family home in Chiswick. The Bell is published to favourable reviews. It is a brave novel, dealing with male homosexuality, which was still illegal at the time. Murdoch is now the leading novelist of her generation. She gives radio interviews and writes articles and reviews, but is despondent about the quality of her writing.
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
An Iris Murdoch Chronology: Significant Dates and Events xv
1959
1960 1961
1962
1963
1964
1965
1966 1967
A novel called Jerusalem is abandoned. Murdoch visits America and gives lectures at Yale. She travels to Boston, Washington and New York, but finds America alien. ‘The Sublime and the Good’ is published in the Chicago Review and ‘The Sublime and the Beautiful Revisited’ in the Yale Review. Murdoch prepares a defence of D.H Lawrence’s Lady Chatterley’s Lover for its trial under the Obscene Publications Act. An important essay on the novel ‘Against Dryness’ is published in Encounter. A Severed Head, which includes an incestuous relationship between brother and sister, is published. Murdoch gives a talk, ‘Morality and the Bomb’, for a CND meeting in London. An Unofficial Rose is published in June. She resigns from St Anne’s in December after a near-scandal with a female colleague. The Unicorn is published. The play of A Severed Head, adapted by J.B. Priestley, opens in Bristol. She begins her part-time teaching job at the Royal College of Art in London, teaching philosophy in the General Studies Department. She is made an Honorary Fellow of St Anne’s. Her portrait is painted by Marie-Louise Motesiczky (it still hangs in St Anne’s). In the summer, the play of A Severed Head moves to London. ‘The Idea of Perfection’ is published in the Yale Review. ‘The Moral Decision about Homosexuality’ is published in Man and Society. Murdoch is the first woman to address the Philosophical Society at Trinity College Dublin. A.S. Byatt’s Degrees of Freedom is published. Murdoch’s only novel set specifically in Ireland, The Red and the Green, is also published in October of this year. The Time of the Angels is published. Murdoch’s review ‘The Darkness of Practical Reason’ is published in Encounter. Murdoch and John Bayley travel to Australia and New Zealand with the British Council. Her article against the Vietnam War, ‘Political Morality’, appears in the Listener. She gives ‘The Sovereignty of Good over Other Concepts’ as the Leslie Stephen lecture at Cambridge. The play, The Italian Girl, which was dramatized by James Saunders, opens at the Old Vic in Bristol.
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
xvi An Iris Murdoch Chronology: Significant Dates and Events
1968
1969
1970
1971 1972
1973
1974 1975
1976
The Nice and the Good is published. It had already been made the World Book Club choice. The play of The Italian Girl moves to the Wyndham’s Theatre in London. Murdoch and Bayley travel with the British Council again, this time to Italy and Switzerland. Bruno’s Dream is published. Murdoch and Bayley travel to Japan. ‘On God and Good’ is published in The Anatomy of Knowledge. A Severed Head is made into a film by Dick Clement (starring Claire Bloom as Honour Klein). Murdoch’s essay ‘Existentialists and Mystics’ is published in Essays and Poems Presented to Lord David Cecil. Murdoch rents a flat in 62 Cornwall Gardens in South Kensington. She becomes a member of the Irish Academy. She and her husband attend a party at 10 Downing Street at the invitation of the Prime Minister, Harold Wilson. A Fairly Honourable Defeat is published. The Sovereignty of Good is also published this year. The Servants in the Snow, Murdoch’s exercise in political philosophy, opens at the Greenwich Theatre and flops. An Accidental Man is published. Murdoch buys the top flat in 29 Cornwall Gardens. She makes another British Council tour, this time to Mexico. This trip is followed by a month in the USA. Later she makes the Blashfield address, ‘Salvation by Words’, in New York. The article appears in the New York Review of Books. Murdoch’s play The Three Arrows opens in Cambridge with Ian McKellan in the leading role. The Black Prince is published and wins the James Tait Black Memorial Prize. Murdoch writes a letter to The Times defending selective education. The Sacred and Profane Love Machine is published and wins the Whitbread Literary Award for Fiction. A Word Child is published. An Unofficial Rose is adapted for radio. Murdoch travels with the British Council to Tokyo and Kyoto in Japan. She writes an article on saving grammar schools for the Sunday Telegraph. Henry and Cato is published. Murdoch is interviewed by Malcolm Bradbury and Lorna Sage for the UEA Interviews series. She is awarded the CBE at Buckingham Palace.
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
An Iris Murdoch Chronology: Significant Dates and Events xvii
1977
1978
1979 1980
1981 1982
1983
1984
1985 1986
Murdoch is made an Honorary Fellow of Somerville College. The Fire and the Sun: Why Plato Banished the Artists is published. She is interviewed for the Men and Ideas series by Brian Magee. Delivers a paper, ‘Art is the Imitation of Nature’, at the University of Caen. She travels to the USA. A Year of Birds, a small book of 12 short poems, is published, with engravings by Reynolds Stone. The Sea, The Sea is published and wins the Booker Prize. Murdoch visits China. Two Socratic dialogues, ‘Art and Eros’, written by Murdoch, are presented at the National Theatre, directed by Michael Kustow. Nuns and Soldiers is published. An opera, The Servants, written by the Welsh composer William Matthias and based on Murdoch’s play The Servants in the Snow, opens at the New Theatre, Cardiff. Murdoch spends a semester at the University of California at Berkeley. The Philosopher’s Pupil is published. The Bell is adapted for television. It is popular with viewers. Murdoch gives the Gifford Lectures in Edinburgh. The audience shrinks during the two weeks they are delivered. Murdoch attends a seminar on The Unicorn at the University of Caen. She also takes part in the Virginia Woolf Centenary Conference at Cambridge. She visits ‘The Genius of Venice’ exhibition at the Royal Academy and is deeply affected by Titian’s The Flaying of Marsyas, which is already one of her most revered secular icons. The painter Tom Phillips is commissioned to paint Murdoch’s portrait for the National Gallery. Murdoch spends six months at the University of California at Berkeley. Later in the year she visits Germany with the British Council and the itinerary includes a visit to Auschwitz. Murdoch’s mother, Rene, dies of a stroke. The Good Apprentice is published and is nominated for the Booker Prize. Murdoch and her husband move from Cedar Lodge to 68 Hamilton Road, Summertown, Oxford. Acastos: Two Platonic Dialogues is published and dedicated to Michael Kustow. In an interview in Books and Bookmen, Murdoch acknowledges the influence of her childhood reading, Treasure Island, Alice in
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
xviii An Iris Murdoch Chronology: Significant Dates and Events
1987
1988 1989
1990
1992
1993
Wonderland and Kim. Murdoch is made an Honorary Fellow of Newnham College, Cambridge. An informal symposium on her work is held at the Free University, Amsterdam. While there, she talks about her near-drowning in Dorset. During the MLA Convention in New York, the Iris Murdoch Society is inaugurated. Murdoch becomes a Dame of the British Empire in the New Year Honours list. She attends a conference in Delhi, India. Her portrait by Tom Phillips is put on show at the National Gallery. Her play about a political prisoner, The One Alone, is broadcast on BBC Radio 3. She speaks at Tulane University, New Orleans. The Book and the Brotherhood is published and she gets another nomination for the Booker Prize. Peter Conradi’s The Saint and the Artist is published. Murdoch is interviewed by Jonathan Miller for Granada Television for My God, a programme about religion. Murdoch’s seventieth year. Many newspapers and magazines carry celebratory articles. The BBC produces a Bookmark programme, ‘A Certain Lady’, in her honour. She is interviewed by A.N. Wilson. Penguin and Chatto organize a party. The play of The Black Prince, adapted with the help of Josephine Hart, opens at the Aldwych Theatre in London. Murdoch and her husband move to 30 Charlbury Road, Oxford. Somerville College, Oxford gives a literary lunch in Murdoch’s honour. Murdoch visits Norway with the British Council. The Message to the Planet is published. Murdoch receives the National Arts Club’s Medal of Honour for Literature in New York. She visits Spain with the British Council. The Sea, The Sea is broadcast on BBC Radio 4. Metaphysics as a Guide to Morals (based on the 1982 Gifford Lectures) is published. Murdoch is in Spain again for the British Council. She makes her last trip to Japan and is awarded an honorary degree from Cambridge and from Kingston University. The Green Knight is published. Murdoch’s book on Heidegger (now in the Murdoch Archives at Kingston University) is abandoned at the proof stage.
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
An Iris Murdoch Chronology: Significant Dates and Events xix
1994
1995
1997 1998
1999
2001
2002
2003 2004
A readers’ poll in the Sunday Times places Murdoch as the ‘greatest living novelist in English’. Murdoch attends a conference at the University of Chicago. In an interview for the Sunday Express, she mentions two more experiences of almost drowning – one off the north coast of Ireland and one at Chesil Beach in Dorset. Jackson’s Dilemma, Murdoch’s final novel, is published to respectful but mixed reviews. John Bayley announces that Murdoch is experiencing a ‘slight block’. Murdoch says she is in ‘a very, very bad, quiet place’. Alzheimer’s disease is diagnosed by Dr John Hodges at Addenbroke’s Hospital, Cambridge. John Bayley’s Iris: A Memoir of Iris Murdoch is published. It is widely discussed and causes heated debate in the national press. Murdoch dies at Yale House in Oxford on 8 February with her husband at her side. Her death is given precedence over that of King Hussein of Jordan on the BBC national news that evening. Her writing is appraised by her peers, A.S Byatt, Malcolm Bradbury, Melvyn Bragg and Sebastian Faulks among them. The authorized biography, Iris Murdoch: A Life, by Peter Conradi is published. The details of her unconventional sex life are sensationalized by the press. A conference on Murdoch’s philosophy is held at Brown University in the USA. The first conference of the Iris Murdoch Society is held at St Anne’s College, Oxford. Richard Eyre’s film Iris, starring Kate Winslet and Judi Dench as the young and old Murdoch respectively, is released. A.N. Wilson publishes Iris Murdoch: As I Knew Her. Kingston University, supported by the Iris Murdoch Society, successfully makes a public appeal to buy Murdoch’s heavily annotated Oxford library. In September, the second Iris Murdoch Society Conference, ‘Iris Murdoch: A Reassessment’, is held at Kingston University and the Centre for Iris Murdoch Studies is inaugurated on this occasion by John Bayley.
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
xx An Iris Murdoch Chronology: Significant Dates and Events
2006 2008
Kingston University holds the third Iris Murdoch Conference, ‘Iris Murdoch and Morality’, at Kingston University. Kingston University holds a fourth conference, ‘Iris Murdoch: Intertextuality and Interdisciplinarity’.
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
An Iris Murdoch Chronology: Significant Dates and Events xxi
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
This page intentionally left blank
Early Life
Iris Murdoch’s literary life began publicly in 1932 when, at 13 years old, she won one of the first two open scholarships to the liberal and high-minded Badminton School in Bristol. Her fledgling literary works soon began to appear in the school magazine and their remarkable range demanded a sophisticated understanding of a variety of disciplines, genres and writing conventions. She composed a 13-stanza poem, ‘The Fate of the Daisy Lee’, and others, including ‘Come Pale Feet’, followed.1 Essays began appearing in 1934, ‘To Lowbrows’ and ‘To Highbrows’ in the Spring Term and ‘Unimportant Persons’ in the Summer Term.2 Her political acumen is notable. In 1935, she wrote ‘How I would Govern the Country’, an essay that defends constitutional monarchy and condemns imperialism and totalitarianism. Reviews on speakers, reports on school expeditions and the activities of the League of Nations Junior Branch and the Literary Club also appeared. She made translations of Horace’s Odes and Oedipus at Colonus. Her lifelong interest in music and art is evident: in a solo performance in Pergolesi’s Stabat Mater, an essay on ‘Community Singing’ and linocuts entitled ‘The Prisoner’ and ‘The Piper’, also for the school magazine. Her intellectual versatility and an already impressive range of abilities were clearly evident. Inevitably, prizes began to come her way: joint first prize in 1937 in the magazine of the League of Nations for an essay attacking German attitudes towards Jews and defending democracy, and again the following year, the sole winner this time, for ‘If I were Foreign Secretary’. She was answering queries as to her future emphatically: she wanted to be a writer.3 1
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
1
Her first actual publication came in 1938 when a charity anthology she had edited, Poet Venturers: Poems by Bristol School Boys and Girls, was published and sold in aid of the Chinese Medical Fund. By now Head Girl, she had persuaded W.H. Auden, while on a visit to the school, to write a Foreword. Murdoch contributed two poems herself, ‘Star-Fisher’ and ‘The Phoenix-Hearted’: The Phoenix-Hearted As from the blue, pale flowering wave doth rise Kuan Yin, the goddess, with her still sad eyes. And as the phoenix flame-enraptured dies, Yet with a fiery crest is born anew; So China’s soul lived on. In every age The poet pensive by the torrent, sage Dark-browed with thought in mountain hermitage, Where white peaks pierce the cloudy heavens through, The patient artist striving to confine All nature’s loveliness within a line, The maiden working with a silk so fine Dragons of gold upon a cloth of blue, The founder, toiling through the midnight hours To cast the sonorous bell, the subtle powers Of potters making bowls like fragile flowers The emperor wise, administrator true, The farmer, whom the furrow’s narrow span For centuries contented – through all these there ran Old China’s life-blood. And from these Japan Learnt gentle arts, these tamed the Tartar crew. But now across these peaceful skies Where in the past the poet’s eyes Imagined dragons of the mist and cloud Stream hosts of glittering dragon-flies To fill with dust those quiet eyes
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
2 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
3
And cover ancient beauty with a stormy shroud. But strength in stillness lies. She is not dead. Kuan Yin again shall raise her gracious head, And though it fall in flames of bloody red The phoenix shall arise with plumage proud.4 This is a topical, traditional and prophetic poem. The young Iris, belonging to a generation soon to be caught up in a world war, is already imaginatively stirred by political events, in this case the SinoJapanese war and the culture it was ravaging. The book of poems had been her idea and the obvious poetic influence here is Yeats, who in ‘Lapis Lazuli’, for example, places political crisis against the background of ancient and Chinese art. ‘Lapis Lazuli’, too, proclaims faith in rebirth from bombs and tragedy and contemplates the carving of a landscape with mountains, clouds and musicians whose ‘ancient glittering eyes are gay’.5 Murdoch, born in Dublin in 1919 though brought up in London, felt Irish. She wrote of herself: ‘although most of her life has been spent in England, she still calls herself an Irish writer’ (IMAL, p. 24). Like Yeats (a voice of Ireland who also lived for years in England), she was drawn to Eastern art, philosophy and religion. Her reverence for oriental cultures emerges in the later novels, but also animates this early poem. The kind of people in the poem will appear repeatedly in the novels: writers, sages, artists and administrators. So will a sonorous eponymous bell and an inspirational character called Belfounder. Murdoch was a baby when her parents moved to London. Their home was in Hammersmith, the scene of the mime theatre in Under the Net, and the Thames plays a powerful and sometimes murderous role in several novels, for example, Under the Net, Bruno’s Dream and A Word Child. Though she spent most of her adult life in or near Oxford, London is Murdoch’s favourite setting, the city she celebrates most.6 And apart from Jake, the Bohemian narrator of Under the Net, happiest in Soho or the City, her London characters tend to live in the SW postal district near the river. Before Badminton School, Murdoch attended the experimental pacifist Froebel School, which prized imagination and creativity and prepared her well for Badminton. However, she was nonetheless homesick for her very close and loving parents and said later that her ‘schooldays lacked colour and gaiety’ (IMAL, p. 82). But Badminton
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
Early Life
did provide an excellent education and an idealistic, ecumenical and politically aware atmosphere. She had a very good relationship with the formidable headmistress Beatrice May Baker and continued to see her after she left school, visiting her house, Little Grange, and naming a winning horse after it in Under the Net. In 1938, Murdoch published a poem about Miss Baker, celebrating her in Platonic terms: Pure idealism was what you had to give, Like no one now tells people how to live . . . A sort of universal Ancient Greece, Under whose cool and scrutinizing sun Beauty and Truth and Good were obviously one. But this rational sunlight was hideously threatened: And yet we knew of Hitler and his hell Before most people did, when all those bright Jewish girls kept arriving; they were well Aware of the beginning of the night . . .7 War broke out when Murdoch was an undergraduate. Having displayed such intellectual promise at school, she was unsurprisingly awarded an Open Exhibition to read English at Somerville College, Oxford, in 1938. She soon changed direction, however, moving to the study of Classics and studied ‘Mods’ (Greek and Latin language and literature) and ‘Greats’ (philosophy and ancient history), in which she took a first. Conradi suggests that ‘possibly the English tutor, Mary Lascelles, remembered as hard to please, failed to take to Iris’ (IMAL, p. 85).8 Murdoch loved her work and loved Oxford. Attractive, outwardly if not inwardly confident and energetic, she was loved by almost everyone, male and female, and many fell in love with her. She made friendships which were to last for life: with Somervillians Philippa Foot (née Bosanquet), Mary Midgley (née Scrutton) and Marjorie Boulton. She had eminent and inspiring tutors, such as the great Greek scholar Edouard Fraenkel and the flamboyant Christian philosopher Donald MacKinnon (whose affection for Murdoch was later to trouble his wife). She took part in college and university drama and was keenly politically involved, first in the Labour Club before joining the Communist Party. Many
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
4 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
5
years later The Book and the Brotherhood was to contain a group of people who have been friends since they were left-wing students. One of them has ever since been financed by the others to write a great radical book. Meanwhile, his supporters have abandoned or modified their youthful political views and are nervous about what the argument and influence of the book will be should it ever appear. Murdoch’s own political convictions would change over the years, but now she was a communist and even attracted converts to the Party. One such convert, attracted as much by Murdoch as by Marxism, was Frank Thompson (whose younger brother would become the distinguished left-wing historian E.P. Thompson), who was an exceptionally gifted student reading Classics at New College. It was a wonderful first year at Oxford; she published poems, reviewed for the student magazine, Oxford Forward, and published in the Cherwell,9 threw herself into political campaigns, committees, debates – and parties. The complicated love dances that were to provide the framework for her literary plots began when Frank Thompson fell for Murdoch, and M.R.D. Foot fell for Leonie Marsh, who in turn loved Frank but who later was to have an affair with Leo Pliatsky. Murdoch received no fewer than six marriage proposals in the summer term of 1939. Her interest in drama, which was to feed into the structure and form of her novels, was intensified by her involvement with the Magpie Players, an acting troupe organized by Tom Fletcher of Ruskin College. They travelled in the summer of 1939, performing ballads, sketches and songs in Oxford, Berkshire and Gloucestershire. However, reactions to the entertainment were mixed. The country was preoccupied with, and made anxious by, the imminent threat of war. When in September 1939 the Magpies played in Gloucestershire at an agricultural cooperative set up by a German refugee group, war was declared and Murdoch immediately returned to London and her parents. After the years of anxiety about the threat of Hitler, the international involvement in the Spanish Civil War, the false peace of Munich, it had happened. The prospect was of bombs, military service, bereavement, perhaps defeat, occupation and death. ‘Now we are all more earnest and more timid and no more careless rapture’, wrote Murdoch to Frank Thompson.10 Although students were not supposed to be called up before they were 20, Frank (a year younger than Murdoch) volunteered. They continued their warm relationship
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
Early Life
with long frequent letters (‘a flow of talk’, IMAL, p. 148) until 1944, when Frank, in charge of a Special Operations mission, was executed in Bulgaria with some partisans and villagers who had helped them. Murdoch was to grieve for Frank throughout her life, dreaming about him, thinking that she would have married him. In the last chapter of The Red and the Green, the heroine, now middle-aged and married with a ‘tall son’, looks back on the friends of her youth and a man she loved, who was killed in the Easter Rising: ‘They had been made young and perfect forever, safe from the corruption of time and from those ambiguous second thoughts which dim the brightest face of youth.’11 In her own person, Murdoch expresses similar feelings in a poem written in 1977: ‘Agamemnon Class 1939: In Memoriam Frank Thompson 1920-1944.’ Its time scheme moves from the students in the class, knowing nothing of ‘the spirit’s failure [. . .] of sin or of pain,/The work of the knife and the axe’, anxious about ‘love’s incinerating crippling flame’ and Greek grammar, to a conflated Trojan War and Second World War considered finally from the viewpoint of the survivors: What was it for? Guides tell a garbled tale. The hero’s tomb is a disputed mound. What really happened on the windy plain? The young are bored by stories of the war. And you the other young who stayed there In the land of the past, are courteous and pale, Aloof, holding your fates. We have to tell you it was not in vain. Even grief dates, and even Niobe At last was fed, and you Are all pain and yet without pain As is the way of the dead.12 A simile in one of the novels describes a man before a firing squad trying to concentrate on the thought of the cause he dies for. As Conradi observes, ‘Iris is unusual among liberal novelists in admiring soldiers’ (IMAL, p. 151), perhaps because her ancestors were mainly Irish farmers or soldiers, and this admiration is apparent in the novels. In her representation of soldiers, Murdoch’s writing can exhibit unashamed affection, occasionally even sentimentality. From
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
6 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
7
James Tayper Pace in The Bell, who comes from a military family and leads an unreflectingly virtuous life, to the Buddhist miracle-working General James Appleby in The Sea, The Sea, the soldiers of the novels are courageous, courteous and unselfish. Murdoch’s adored father had served in the First World War and survived partly through the luck of being a cavalry officer – the cavalry having missed the slaughter of the trenches; her husband-to-be, John Bayley, served in the Second World War and, improbably, enjoyed the army. His brother, Brigadier Michael Bayley, was a professional soldier and perhaps (though Murdoch disliked any suggestion that her characters were modelled on actual people) the inspiration for Felix Meecham in An Unofficial Rose. During her years at Oxford, Murdoch was again politically engaged, selling copies of the communist newspaper the Daily Worker on the streets of Blackpool in 1940 when she visited her parents, who had been evacuated there. Later she became chairman of the Communist Oxford University Labour Club. In 1941, she ceased to support pacifism and accepted the need for war. Her literary interests at this time included the poetry of the Pre-Raphaelites, Proust, Shakespeare, Henry James, James Joyce, Mallarmé and Woolf. After graduating, having longed to take a more active part in the War and being jealous of her male contemporaries who did, she became for two years Assistant Principal in the Treasury. She reported ‘Oxford has nothing on the Treasury as far as tradition goes’ (IMAL, p. 135). But, as at Oxford, the proportion of women in the Treasury increased during the War. There are plenty of civil servants in the novels:13 Rupert in A Fairly Honourable Defeat, cultured, affluent, complacent; the narrator of The Black Prince, a retired tax inspector; the narrator of A Word Child, a willing slave to routine. The power struggles of the office are wryly chronicled in The Flight from the Enchanter and A Word Child. Such keen observation of her colleagues was to provide a meditation point for her future unravelling of the complexities of human relationships. In 1943, she wrote to David Hicks, the first man with whom she was seriously romantically involved, of ‘the complexity of human lives and the difficulty of understanding people because of their imperfections and inarticulacy’ (IMC, p. 27). Murdoch shared a flat in Westminster with Philippa Bosanquet in the centre of London in the middle of the War. Unlike some other novelists who lived in London during the Blitz – Elizabeth Bowen,
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
Early Life
Graham Greene, Pamela Hansford Johnson and Muriel Spark – she did not write, at least in her published novels, about this apocalyptic time in London’s history: the sirens, the night raids, the ravaged streets, the sleepers in the Tube. However, despite the full-time job and disturbed nights, she was writing and perhaps some of the early vanished novels drew on this experience.14 Perhaps the nightly blackout and the constant danger contribute to the tenebrous London settings of A Severed Head and The Time of the Angels. Although she was working a full six-day week, she was nonetheless reading avidly, mainly theology, including Martin Buber’s I and Thou, and managed to fit in Pushkin, T.E Lawrence’s The Seven Pillars of Wisdom and the philosophy of Kierkegaard. In 1943, she published reviews in the Adelphi magazine, the first a review of Midnight Hour by Nicodemus, where she had attempted to understand the spiritual pilgrimage within it. In further reviews for the magazine,15 she began to put forward the idea that Christianity must change before it could draw in her own generation and it was here that the foundation for what was later to become her ‘neo-theology’ was laid.16 She kept her affiliation with the Communist Party during this time and, like all members then, was expected to pass on information about her work by dead-letter drop, which she did. Her personal life was becoming more complicated as she corresponded with David Hicks and Frank Thompson, all the while being involved with other men, including M.R.D. Foot and her philosophy tutor, Donald MacKinnon. Reading Henry James in September of this year, she compares herself to one of his heroines, acknowledging that she too might have a wild streak. She had by now begun writing novels herself and had completed her second in the summer of 1944. It was to be rejected later in the year by T.S. Eliot at Faber & Faber. After relishing the heady bohemian London life and frequenting the pubs that were to enrich the realism of her novels (the Pillars of Hercules, the Wheatsheaf, the Fitzroy Tavern and the Black Horse), in 1944 Murdoch moved to the United Nations Relief and Rehabilitation Administration (UNRRA), set up to aid the liberated countries and their refugees. The first months of another office job in London were frustrating, but the next year, when the War ended, she was sent abroad in September for ten months, first to Brussels and then to Austria. Brussels thrilled her after the wartime years when travel had been almost impossible for civilians, and she threw herself into reading
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
8 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
9
French novels, seeing French films and exploring existentialism. In December, she was posted to Innsbruck, beautiful but much less intellectually exciting than Brussels, apart from the visit of Raymond Queneau, whose zany picaresque novel Pierrot Mon Ami Murdoch translated. In March, she was sent to the UNRRA headquarters in Klagenfurt and about a month later to Graz, a camp for refugees who had been accepted by the University of Graz. Despite the suffering they had undergone, the hardship of life on a minimal ration of food and the fear of repatriation, the students had been relatively fortunate and there was plenty of optimism and cultural activity at Graz. Murdoch made some lasting friendships among them and after her return to England continued to give personal, practical and financial help to refugees. They play a major role in her early novel The Flight from the Enchanter and often appear in her later fiction. Willy in The Nice and the Good and Julius in A Fairly Honourable Defeat are survivors of concentration camps. She responded to Simone Weil’s diagnosis of rootlessness as a sickness of modern life and thought that ‘the person who is literally an exile, the refugee, seems an appropriate symbol for the man of the present time’ (IMAL, p. 239).17 Murdoch had danced with the crowds in Piccadilly until the early hours on VE Day in May of 1945, but returning to England in the summer of 1946 was depressing. Although she was not certain that she wanted an academic career, she did apply for a Lectureship in Philosophy at Sheffield, investigated other university posts and put in for a Commonwealth Fellowship to study at the distinguished American Liberal Arts College, Vassar. She won the Fellowship and was accepted at Vassar but, to her bitter disappointment, was refused a US visa because she admitted to having been a member of the Communist Party. Fortunately, she was awarded a studentship in philosophy at Newnham College, Cambridge. A major attraction of Cambridge for Murdoch was Ludwig Wittgenstein, who was to be a permanent influence on her thought and fiction. However, she was just too late to hear his lectures, as he had resigned his Fellowship at Trinity in the summer of 1947 and moved to Ireland in December. Murdoch met him a couple of times and became close friends with some of his pupils, including Elizabeth Anscombe, Georg Kreisel and Yorick Smythies, who inspired the character of Hugo in Under the Net. In 1948, Iris Murdoch returned to Oxford as Fellow in Philosophy at St Anne’s College. A teaching fellowship at Oxford was demanding
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
Early Life
in terms of contact hours with students, faculty participation and college administration. Nonetheless, Murdoch found time to work at her novels. Until she gave up her teaching position and became a full-time writer, her letters to her publishers are punctuated by complaints about the demands of term and examining: ‘I’ll take the thing back to Oxford with me and see what can be done when term has settled down a bit. I’ll try to keep my pupils at bay and not keep you waiting too long’;18 ‘Dreadful beginning of term is on me and girls I have never seen or heard of are turning up and claiming to be, and indeed to have been, my pupils’.19 Despite her dismissive tone, Murdoch was an excellent tutor, committed, tolerant and generous with her time. Many of her pupils became devoted to her and some remained lifelong friends. Although teaching took time, perhaps the difference Murdoch perceived between philosophy and fiction meant that they did not make similar demands on her. She always protested at being called a philosophical novelist (for example, in an interview for the Scotsman with William Foster).20 In another interview, this time with Simon Blow, she eloquently described her sense of the contrast: Philosophy is a counter-natural activity that goes against the bent of the human mind whereas art goes with the bent of the human mind. There’s a myth in Plato about the world being pushed one way by God for a certain period, then God lets go and it rolls back a natural way. I feel that philosophy is pushing the cosmos in a direction which is unnatural to it, and then when you let go you’re back in art as you heave a sigh of relief and you’re flowing with the current and your canoe is careering down the river.21 The professional philosophers in her novels come off rather badly, tending, like Tallis and Rupert in A Fairly Honourable Defeat, to be ineffectual or complacent. However, the term ‘counter-natural’ need not be pejorative. In Plato’s myth, the counter-natural movement is also divinely inspired.22 In some ways, Murdoch had returned to the place she entered in 1938 but, even if the Oxford system and the academic syllabus remained much the same, a great deal had happened during six years of war and its aftermath. It was a time of austerity and innovation. The Labour victory in the General Election of 1945 was a mandate
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
10 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
11
for change and reform. The world had altered too profoundly for too many people during the previous six years for Britain to return to pre-War hierarchies and injustice. The 1944 Education Act had already given bright lower-class children entry to the grammar schools, which would prepare them to gain more places at the universities than ever before. Now major services and industries were nationalized and the National Health Service was introduced. For left-wing intellectuals, such as Murdoch, the new developments were welcome. In 1945, she wrote jubilantly of the Election: ‘Oh wonderful people of Britain! After all the ballyhoo and eyewash, they’ve had the guts to vote against Winston! [. . .] I can’t help feeling that to be young is very heaven!’ (IMAL, p. 211).23 However, in her 1961 essay ‘Against Dryness’, Murdoch would express mixed feelings about the effects of the Welfare State. She describes it as the ‘reward of empiricism in politics’, representing ‘a set of thoroughly desirable but limited ends, which could be conceived in non-theoretical terms [. . .] We have suffered a general loss of concepts, the loss of a moral and political vocabulary’.24 The ends at least were desirable but, as often when ends are achieved, there is an unexpected sense of disappointment. It is a philosopher’s complaint and a moralist’s. The linguistic philosophy central to post-War Oxford rigorously examined moral vocabulary, but also contributed to its loss. Murdoch did not completely fit in. Philippa Foot recalls, ‘We were interested in moral language, she was interested in the moral life’.25 Her first philosophical publications came in the early 1950s, appearing in the annual ‘Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society’ alongside Gilbert Ryle and A.C. Lloyd. She presented her first paper to the Society in June 1952, entitled ‘Nostalgia for the Particular’, which was later published in the ‘Proceedings’, and in the same year she wrote ‘The Existential Political Myth’ for The Socratic Dialogue.26 Her philosophical career, if not yet her literary career, was becoming well established. Yet Murdoch had written several novels – perhaps four, five or even six – before Under the Net (IMAL, p. 170). She came to think that Eliot was right to have turned down the novel she had sent to Faber, but she had no trouble publishing Under the Net. Gwenda David, who worked for Viking, received the typescript, happened to dance with Ian Parsons of Chatto & Windus at a party, mentioned the novel to him and sent it to Norah Smallwood at Chatto in August 1953. Chatto accepted the novel and Viking agreed to co-publish it in the
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
Early Life
USA. All Murdoch’s subsequent novels were first printed in hardback by Chatto and Viking. She was both loyal to Chatto and uninterested in the business side of publication. An undated letter of 1972 to Norah Smallwood denies, with many exclamation marks, that she has received or would accept an offer from Collins: ‘I have no sympathy with you at all! Do you imagine that I have gone potty? [. . .] As if I would write a thriller anyway. (Except the ones I usually write.) And if I did of course you should have it! With much love from your faithful author.’27 However, her fidelity was probably costly. John Bayley recalls a ‘guilty smile’ of Norah’s at the subject of her financial dealings with Murdoch.28 Murdoch and Smallwood became friends, enjoying a very affectionate and harmonious relationship until Smallwood’s death in 1984. By the 1960s, letters begin ‘Dearest Iris’ and ‘Dearest Norah’ However, there is, characteristically, almost no discussion on Murdoch’s side of her novels. She rarely spoke of them to her husband or friends and wrote about them as little as possible to her editors. She is also resistant to their editorial suggestions. While as a new novelist she might have been anxiously eager to please and reconsider, on the contrary she shows this insouciance, refusing ‘quite apart from a total lack of time’ to make alterations. Marshall Best, her American editor at Viking, provides responsive and detailed critiques of the novels as each reaches him, but, to his growing exasperation, Murdoch ignores or refuses to act on them. Norah Smallwood refrains from this thankless endeavour. The pattern is constant: Murdoch finishes a novel and Smallwood receives it with warm enthusiasm and discerning praise. Murdoch agrees to the terms proposed and shows a lively and critical interest in the dust-jacket. The usual correspondence about proofs ensues. With amazing speed Murdoch mentions that she has almost finished another novel and will be sending or delivering it soon. Apart from the practicalities of publication, their letters exchange news of friends, holidays, the odd illness or accident. They both admit to having watched a royal wedding on television. From time to time Murdoch enquires if Smallwood might know of any job for a friend or pupil or read someone’s poems or novel. After Under the Net was accepted, Murdoch’s only indecision seems to have been about its title. Gwenda David writes, ‘Iris Murdoch says she is demented about it’.29 Murdoch submits a list of possibilities such as Dialogue of One, The Looker-On, The Last Word and That’s What
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
12 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
13
I Said. Smallwood likes Waiting for the Echo. Ian Parsons suggests Time’s Fool. Smallwood tells Murdoch that nobody at Chatto is happy about Truth and the Jester.30 One of Murdoch’s impossible titles, If Silent a God, is awkward but haunting. It confers a numinous power on Hugo’s respect for silence and perhaps illuminates Murdoch’s reticence about her writing. The allusion recurs in a later novel, A Severed Head: ‘Remember the legend of Psyche, whose child, if she told about her pregnancy, would be mortal, whereas if she kept silent it would be a god.’31 Eventually the title Under the Net, with its air of inevitable rightness, was contributed by Viking’s Winnie Scott. Under the Net was an immediate success. It won second prize in the First Novel competition at the 1954 Cheltenham Festival of Literature (the first prize went to Brigid Brophy’s Hackenfeller’s Ape) and Lord David Cecil described it as a: surprising amalgam of rollicking farce, philosophic discussion and dreamy lyrical poetry [. . .] each element is fascinating in itself, each bears the mark of a distinguished and original intelligence and is afire with a responsiveness to life at once exuberant and delicate [. . .] a book of pulsating life – life that one feels was in full swing long before the novel begins and which continues on and on in endless convolutions after the last page [. . .] all the people in it are slightly potty, but like true eccentrics, unaware of their own eccentricity. The dizzy world they live in – where money is not earned but won, not spent but lost – to them is perfectly normal.32 The Times Literary Supplement review welcomed a ‘brilliant talent’.33 Kingsley Amis in the Spectator welcomed ‘a distinguished novelist of a rare kind’.34 Iris Murdoch was suddenly an established author and all her future work would be accepted as a matter of course.
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
Early Life
After the War Under the Net (1954) and The Flight from the Enchanter (1956)
In the 1950s, when Murdoch’s novels began to be published, the literary context was largely non-theoretical and untheorized. Much English writing of the fifties displayed a modest or chauvinistic insularity. The powerfully influential literary critic F.R. Leavis concentrated on literature written in English. New Criticism pretended to eschew contextualization.1 New Lines, a collection of verse by a new generation of poets including Philip Larkin, Kingsley Amis, D.J. Enright, Elizabeth Jennings, Thom Gunn, Donald Davie and John Wain, was lucid and proudly unpretentious. The editor, Robert Conquest, explained, ‘it submits to no great systems of theoretical constructs nor agglomeration of unconscious commands. It is free from both mystical and logical compulsions and – like modern philosophy – is empirical in its attitude to all that comes [. . .] [it refuses] to abandon a rational structure and comprehensible language’.2 He was contrasting these poets with their modernist and surrealist predecessors, who were international, experimental, obscure, preoccupied with the unconscious and with myth. The new play that characterized the decade was John Osborne’s realist, ‘fourth-wall’, three-act Look Back in Anger, which was angry largely at a boring and unheroic new era, not the equally successful Waiting for Godot, which was mysterious, theologically haunted, formally original and first written in French. Kingsley Amis’s bestselling first novel, Lucky Jim, had affinities with Osborne’s play. Jimmy Porter’s university is not even red brick, it is white tile, while Jim Dixon lectures at a provincial university and both characters share a contempt for the pretentious, which includes ‘high’ culture. In Amis’s third novel, I Like 14
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
2
15
It Here, a writer is awarded a grant to go to Spain and, unlike both the cosmopolitan modernists and the political authors of the 1930s, fears and suffers from the strangeness of ‘abroad’. Murdoch was to be enduringly committed to tradition, aligning herself with the English Realist tradition that encompassed Jane Austen, Charles Dickens and George Eliot, those writers who demonstrate the ‘truthfulness of great art’ and ‘overcome egoism and fantasy’.3 However, from the start she was also energized and excited by what was going on ‘abroad’. Murdoch’s first three books looked to the European as much as to the English tradition. Like many English intellectuals at the time, Murdoch was in love with France and in the first pages of Under the Net we learn that the hero owns the novels Pierrot mon Ami by Raymond Queneau, to whom the book is dedicated,4 and Murphy by Samuel Beckett, who lived in France and wrote in French as well as English. Under the Net is self-reflexive in that Murdoch, like her first-person narrator, Jake Donaghue, is a fledgling writer trying to work out what kind of novel she wants to write. Her letters to Queneau are full of ideas about the novel form; she had many discussions with him about style and she was excited at the arrival of his Exercises de Style, in which the same event is described in 99 different ways: ‘These games with language, with speech, with beingin-words – thrill me very much’, she said.5 In 1946 she read a book of essays by Rimbaud and disagreed with him about the relative importance of form in the novel. She said that for her, formal perfection came first, but she accepted that she also wished to write about ideas and understood that, as with skiing, one could lose control (IMC, p. 42). In these early post-War novels, both the problems of the age and the problems of making good art are acted out: how far should the writer follow tradition? How far should she experiment with form? And for this particular writer, how exactly should her role as philosopher inform her fiction? Murdoch’s first book was in fact philosophy, not fiction: Sartre: Romantic Rationalist, published in 1953, sprang from her meeting Sartre, her post-War experience of working in Brussels and Innsbruck, visiting Paris and her study of philosophy at Oxford and Cambridge. In 1944 she was writing of the ‘intellectual exaltation’ (IMAL, p. 214) inspired by the French existentialists and she recalled the excitement in her Introduction to the 1980 edition of her book on Sartre: ‘The war was over, Europe was in ruins, we had emerged
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
After the War
from a long captivity, all was to be remade. Sartre’s philosophy was an inspiration to many who felt that they must, and could, make out of all that misery and chaos a better world, for it had been revealed that anything was possible. Existentialism was the new religion, the new salvation.’6 Murdoch had attended Sartre’s lecture in Brussels in 1944 and met him in a café there afterwards.7 Her account of Sartre is not, however, evangelical. Her investigations of his views of language, consciousness, freedom and society lead to an impasse: ‘As a European socialist intellectual with an acute sense of the needs of his time Sartre wishes to affirm the preciousness of the individual and the possibility of a society which is free and democratic in the traditional liberal sense of those terms [. . .]. As a philosopher, however, he finds himself without the materials to construct a system which will hold and justify these values; Sartre believes neither in God nor in Nature nor in History’ (SRR, p. 105). Murdoch’s main problem as a philosopher and an atheist was to justify moral absolutes in a world without God. But she differed from Sartre in perceiving this absence as a painful dilemma and was to question the freedom and solipsism of his lonely godless modern individual. Philosophically, Under the Net is indebted to Sartre, Wittgenstein and Simone Weil. In 1945 Murdoch wrote to David Hicks about the French novel, which she thought was more exciting than the English novel at the time: French writers, ‘probably because of the continuing influence of the Church, [were] still fascinated by the basic struggle between Good and evil’. She explained existentialism to Hicks as a theory of the self and its relations with others and of the self’s attitude to death. She was interested, she said, not so much in the theory itself as in what novelists do with it (IMC, p. 39). Sartre: Romantic Rationalist focuses mainly on Sartre as novelist, rather than as dramatist or philosopher, because ‘the novels [. . .] reveal very clearly the central structure of his philosophy’ (p. 138). The first chapter concerns La Nausée, ‘his most densely philosophical novel’, which ‘contains all his interests except the political ones’ (SRR, p. 39). Its subject is the nausea felt by Roquentin at objects in general and his own existence in particular in the dreary provincial town of Bouville, teaching and trying to write a biography in which he does not believe. Although Sartre’s political interests are manifest in his unfinished tetralogy, Les Chemins de la Liberté, which takes place during the
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
16 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
17
terrible years of the Spanish Civil War, the Munich crisis and the fall of France, Murdoch’s chapter on it concentrates on the lack of relationships and communion between humans, a tenet of Sartre’s philosophy and an enemy of morality in her own. Her own dilemmas and preoccupations are evident in her discussion of those of Sartre. The third chapter, ‘The Sickness of the Language’, is a brief introduction to modernism, which analyses various consequences for literature and philosophy of the loss of faith in the referential quality of language (these are all philosophical issues that find their way into Under the Net. Hugo Belfounder is such a sceptic). Although Murdoch does not accept the logical positivist dichotomy between ‘emotive’ and ‘referential’ language or Sartre’s similar contrast between poetry and prose, these distinctions do bear some relation to her own categories of ‘crystalline’ and ‘journalistic’ novels which she later presented in ‘Against Dryness’.8 Indeed, Sartre is something of a crystalline novelist. In his philosophy the human subject is as questionable as its language, and mutual equal love is an impossibility. A sincere and solipsistic freedom is his ideal. The characters in his novels largely represent viewpoints, one reason why Murdoch considers drama his favoured medium. But she thinks Sartre’s limitations are symptomatic of his time. She concludes: ‘His inability to write a great novel is a tragic symptom of a situation which afflicts us all. We know that the real lesson to be taught is that the human person is precious and unique; but we seem unable to set it forth except in terms of ideology and abstraction’ (SRR, p. 148). So, despite Murdoch’s reservations about his philosophy, Sartre’s first novel is clearly related to her own first novel. Roquentin’s nausea at objects, with their swelling, viscous, complacent particularity, discredits theory and generalization for him: ‘I saw that there was no middle way between non-existence and this swooning abundance. What exists at all must exist to this point, to the point of mouldering, of bulging, of obscenity.’9 Yet is nausea the only, necessary or authentic response to stones, trees, people and pictures? (Murdoch’s own work displays a special fondness for stones.) ‘Why, asks Gabriel Marcel, does Sartre find the contingent over-abundance of the world nauseating rather than glorious?’ (SRR, p. 49). The abundance of the world is glorious in Murdoch’s novels. Respect for contingency is to be vital to her fiction and philosophy.10 Jake, the narrator of Under the Net, is implicitly criticized for his unease with the contingent. Hugo, whom
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
After the War
Jake both reveres and opposes, is a man without theories and he presents Hugo’s view of reality as ‘unutterably particular’.11 Murdoch’s fiction is pervaded by the dialectic between two kinds of characters who have been labelled the ‘saint’ and the ‘artist’ The saint need not be especially saintly nor the artist especially talented or even, though often a painter or a writer, literally an artist. Conversely, the saint can be an artist of a sort. Hugo has been a creator of fireworks and now heads a film company. The terms of saint and artist are shorthand for opposing attitudes towards creativity, egotism, fantasy and fabulation. Jake and Hugo dramatize this opposition in clear and comic terms. They are opposite in many ways. Hugo is a large, clumsy, shambling man with no care for personal dignity. Jake is short, trim, agile and self-aware. Hugo (like Wittgenstein) is very rich and keeps trying to disembarrass himself of his money, but always becomes rich again. Jake is a struggling writer, supporting himself mostly by hackwork, translating novels he despises, and pornography. If he acquires money, it disappears rapidly. During the course of the narrative Jake makes, loses and gives away money, and ends up with almost exactly the same sum in his pocket as at the beginning. The major difference between the ‘saint’ and the ‘artist’ concerns language. Jake perceives Hugo as a man without theories. One of the attractions of fireworks for Hugo is their instant and ephemeral quality; when they inspire criticism, classification and theory, he abandons them for another project. Jake and Hugo first meet when they share a room as guinea pigs at a cold-cure research centre. At first Jake is surly and taciturn and even wonders if the considerate unspeaking Hugo is mentally defective but, when he breaks their silence himself, he is spellbound. Indeed, Hugo is, unlike most of Murdoch’s ‘saints’, oddly charismatic. They fall into a conversation so compulsive that they keep signing up to be experimented on for further weeks until the authorities fear for their health and dismiss them. Among many other subjects, they talk of language. Hugo’s view is that we cannot tell the truth in words. His position is similar to that of Wittgenstein who, in Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus,l2 uses the image of nets, with various patterns of mesh or degrees of fineness, to illustrate the view that our perceptions are organized by language and conceptualization. Hugo finally tells Jake that perhaps one should not talk at all and they laugh together because they have been talking non-stop for weeks. It is literally a reductio ad absurdum. But their
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
18 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
19
laughter implicitly makes the serious point that humans do need language for emotional as well as practical purposes. And, as Jake remarks, there are theories around, such as political theories, with which we ought consciously and responsibly to engage. In action, at least, Hugo does endorse this view: his latest donation of his money and possessions at the end of the novel is to Lefty Todd’s New Independent Socialist Party. Jake, as a writer, is compelled to defend language against Hugo’s attack. With a guilty inevitability, he writes a book on the subject. This begins merely as a private record of their conversations. But Jake finds himself recreating passages he cannot perfectly recall, sharpening arguments, reorganizing their discourse more logically and improving the style. He is, paradoxically, proving Hugo right, producing a ‘falsified’ version of their discourse. His project of transcribing a conversation should be the easiest in which to use language accurately. But even the attempt to turn spoken words into written words proves impossible. Jake regards his book as a travesty and a betrayal which Hugo would justly resent but, when he is approached by a publisher, is unable to resist. The Silencer is a commercial failure and, as soon as it comes out, Jake, unable to face Hugo, drops him without explanation. Hugo, as we learn late in the novel, was interested and not at all annoyed by the book, which he fails to recognize as a spurious representation of his own ideas. Jake was wrong about Hugo’s reactions and this is not his only mistake or illusion. Wittgenstein’s image of the net inspires the title and is quoted in The Silencer: ‘All theorizing is flight. We must be ruled by the situation itself and this is unutterably particular. Indeed, it is something to which we can never get close enough, however hard we may try as it were to crawl under the net’ (p. 80). Unlike Hugo, Jake is a theorist and most of his theories are disconfirmed during the course of the novel. At the beginning he remarks that his friend Finn is always saying that he will go back to Ireland but he never will. Finn does. Jake regularly translates the popular novels of Jean Pierre Breteuil, which he despises until Breteuil wins the Prix Goncourt with a work that Jake recognizes instantly as different and good. When Sadie Quentin, the sister of Anna, the girl with whom Jake was once involved and believes he still loves, tells Jake that Hugo is in love with her and besieges her with unwelcome approaches, Jake decides instead that it is she who is in love with Hugo and he with her sister Anna. Jake
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
After the War
has no evidence for this theory other than his preconceptions that Sadie is a liar and not Hugo’s type, and that Anna, whom he himself loves, is more lovable. Yet many new readers believe Jake, though he has ‘unreliable narrator’ written all over him (he contrasts Finn’s truthfulness with his own subtlety in the first chapter).13 The charm of his style is seductive. Jake and Hugo are both more compelling and attractive than the artists and saints of Murdoch’s later fiction. Murdoch’s first-person narrators (all male) inhabit self-constructed worlds, often locked in or partially released by the experience of falling in love. Although Jake is wilfully deluded (and literally locked in or locked out) for most of the novel, he has a wit and decency which temper his egotism. Plato’s myth of the cave is equally fundamental to the book and also recurs in later novels. In the Republic, Plato likens humans to prisoners in a cave who sit in chains with their backs to the entrance and the sunlight outside.14 A fire behind them is their only source of light. Between the fire and the prisoners, images are carried and their shadows flicker on the back wall of the cave. These – the shadows of copies seen in poor light – the captives take for reality. A note to Cornford’s translation, which Murdoch knew, suggests, ‘A modern Plato would compare his Cave to an underground cinema, where the audience watch the play of shadows thrown by the film passing before a light at their backs. The film itself is only an image of “real” things and events in the world outside the cinema’.15 For Murdoch, in whose synthesis of Freud and Plato the fire figures as the ego, the cinema is also a catalyst of unreality in its production and gratification of fantasy.16 Several of the characters of the novel are involved in this industry. Hugo owns a film company, Sadie is a movie star and so is Mister Mars, the virtuous Alsatian dog kidnapped by Jake. One of Jake’s two meetings with Hugo during the course of the novel takes place on a film set and the plot includes attempts to steal his translation of one of Breteuil’s novels for a film script. Both the ‘outer’ plot of action, intrigue, business and big money and the ‘inner’ plot of love, ideas and ideals are fuelled by fantasy. Yet Plato would presumably not share the value Murdoch places on the contingent and particular. A joke early in Under the Net is a veiled critique of Idealism, Plato’s theory that everything in this life is an imperfect copy of a general Idea. At the opening of the novel, Jake and Finn have just been evicted by Jake’s friend Magdalen, with
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
20 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
21
whom they have been living. Magdalen is both a typist and a model: she is very conventionally pretty. Her hair and make-up follow the fashions suggested by the movies and the magazines but ‘she has not succeeded in rendering herself quite featureless [. . .]. Women think that beauty lies in approximation to a harmonious norm [. . .] they fail to make themselves indistinguishably similar [because] they lack the time and the money and the technique. Film stars, who have all these, are indistinguishably similar’ (p. 10). In the Symposium, Socrates describes the ascent of the soul from the love of a beautiful body to the contemplation of the divine cosmic harmony. The love of one beautiful body leads up to the love of beauty in all bodies and finally to the love of the Idea of beauty. This erotic theology will later inform the ‘inner’ plot of The Black Prince. But Jake prefers the individual and imperfect and, despite his limitations as a narrator and a person, here he speaks for the author.17 There is an authority in Jake’s tone. One feels everyone would agree, except Plato and some typists. Reflection, in its various senses, is a constant theme in Under the Net. Jake manages to track Anna down at a strange mime theatre in Hammersmith and finds his way into a rehearsal: ‘What was going on was not clear to me but it seemed that a huge burly central figure, wearing a mask which expressed a kind of humble yearning stupidity, was being mocked by the other players’ (p. 36). This figure, whom Jake finds powerful and strangely familiar but does not recognize, is Hugo. We may sense analogies with the figure of Christ in the Passion scenes of the Mystery Plays and the holy fool Prince Myshkin in The Idiot, one of Murdoch’s favourite novels. This temple to silence is an odd place to find Anna, who is a singer. Jake realizes that the mime theatre must be Anna’s version of Hugo’s distrust of language but, as with The Silencer, Hugo himself fails to see the connection: ‘It was you reflected in Anna’, Jake later tells him, ‘just as that dialogue was you reflected in me’, but Hugo replies, ‘I don’t recognize the reflections’ (p. 229). Early in the novel, Jake admits that his main enjoyment is in reflection. Perhaps this too refers to Plato, who thought everything in the world a copy or reflection. Reflection is Jake’s refuge from the real, the compulsion and the inability to copy truthfully, and the shadowy copies themselves. His work of translation is a kind of reflection. In Paris, Jake contemplates the fragmented image of Notre Dame in the Seine, suddenly sees Anna, pursues her through crowds
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
After the War
and darkness and then catches up with a prostitute. The real woman has disappeared between the polarized images of Madonna and whore, and Magdalen, with her meretricious and saintly name, reflects the taste of the various men who support her. Jake’s relations with others and his love for them consist largely of reflection and projection. Love and ideas always animate each other in Murdoch’s fiction. In the same way that her life at this time was a confused mixture of intellectualism and intense emotional and sexual imbroglios with both genders, in Under the Net, while Jake meditates on language, theory and art, he pursues both Anna and Hugo, eager to be reunited with the ex-lover as well as the ex-interlocutor. Love is Murdoch’s major theme in all her novels. Like Murdoch, her characters, especially in the later novels, notoriously fall in love instantly or rapidly, inexplicably, absolutely and mutably. With total commitment they suddenly change partners or choose dangerous and impossible partners. Love is crucial to her philosophy because falling headlong into it can turn us into angels or demons. It can strip us of ourselves so that it can make us see others more clearly and thus make us better. Alternatively, it can titillate the fantasy life so that we become sexually obsessed, deluded and irresponsible. Murdoch was not interested in love simply for its romantic plot interest, though she maximizes its comic as well as moral possibilities. Under the Net in fact is romantically far less wild than its successors, though Anna ‘as Hugo so horribly put it [took] one look’ (p. 237), fell in love at first sight and acted wildly thereafter. Hugo rebukes Jake’s incredulity that he can love Sadie rather than Anna with a lame but wise generalization: ‘You know anyone can love anyone, or prefer anyone to anyone.’ Aptly and awkwardly, he sums up the situation: ‘it’s like life, isn’t it? I love Sadie, who’s keen on you, and you love Anna, who’s keen on me’ (p. 227). Indeed, it is like life, but it is also like Shakespearian comedy, a major influence on Murdoch’s work. The characters in A Midsummer Night’s Dream fall in and out of love during the night in the forest, convinced that they are behaving reasonably under the enchantment of the magic juice, which produces a speeded-up version of the passions and inconstancy of the daytime world. (There is even a love potion in The Good Apprentice.) ‘Love looks not with the eyes but with the mind’, says Helena, suggesting that the lover sees not the actual beloved but an image of his or her own desires.18 To use the
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
22 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
23
psychoanalytic term, the lover projects. ‘Anyone can love anyone’, says Hugo to Jake. ‘Anyone will do to play the roles’, says Julius in A Fairly Honourable Defeat. At the end of the novel, Jake is considering transferring his affections from Anna to her sister Sadie. One of the books evicted from Magdalen’s flat with Jake is his copy of Murphy, in which Beckett schematically describes the provisional perversity of romantic passion. ‘“You may sneer,” said Neary, “and you may scoff, but the fact remains that all is dross, for the moment at any rate, that is not Miss Dwyer”19 [. . .] Of such was Neary’s love for Miss Dwyer, who loved a Flight-Lieutenant Elliman, who loved a Miss Farren of Ringsakiddy, who loved a Father Fitt of Ballinclasher, who in all sincerity was bound to acknowledge a certain vocation for a Mrs West of Passage, who loved Neary.’20 Jake’s ownership of this novel is in fact a bow both to modernism and to Ireland. Murphy has a cast of mainly Irish characters adrift in London. Finn is Irish and Jake is of Irish descent. Murphy, like Jake, has to move at the beginning of the novel from one ‘cage’ to another, a negative answer to the question of human freedom which haunts Murdoch’s fiction, and late in the novel takes a job at a mental hospital. Jake finally follows the advice of his philosopher friend, Dave Gellman, and takes a job as an orderly in the hospital next to Dave’s flat (in this he is also echoing Wittgenstein). Murphy finds himself playing a lunatic game of chess with a madman, whose indifference to his partner forces a kind of deterministic reflection of his own moves upon him. For Jake, however, the hospital, with its rules, routine and duties, is a liberating experience. He has more freedom than Murphy and can increase it by his own decisions. Perhaps some change is possible in Murdoch’s world, though not in Beckett’s. Despite the debts to modernist fiction and modern philosophy, Murdoch fulfils her promise to convention and this anti-hero’s progress follows a route familiar from the traditional realist novel, that of moral discovery and development. In Paris, Jake learns that Jean Pierre has won the Prix Goncourt and he resolves to stop translating. This achievement acts as a rebuke to the secondhand. Jake should produce his own work. In Paris it also transpires that Magdalen has arranged for him the offer of a lucrative, permanent and undemanding post as a scriptwriter. Jake complains that this is a sinecure and, when he has defined this term for Magdalen, she says she thought it was what he always wanted. In a Damascene moment, Jake realizes that he does
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
After the War
not want it. He presents his dilemma in the terms of temptation, vocation and choice which the English novel inherited from Christian theology and allegory: ‘I was being offered the key to the world in which money comes easily [. . .] As for my conscience I could catch up with that in a few months. All I had to do was to shut my eyes and walk in. Why did the way in seem so hard?’ Because his life ‘simply doesn’t lie in this direction’ (p. 179). In spite of the frenetic activity of Under the Net, Jake’s pursuit of Hugo and Anna, and his kidnapping of Mars, ‘direction’ seems to be an incongruous word for him to apply to his life. But, after he collapses at Dave’s flat and then takes the job at the hospital, he becomes ‘directed’ in new ways. Jake now lives and works in the ‘contingent’ London he was determined to avoid. And the work is unexpectedly satisfying. It produces a very unfamiliar feeling ‘of having done something’ (p. 208). It occurs to him that he might at some unspecified time in the future take a part-time job as well as writing so that no day could pass fruitlessly. As if to reward this partial sense of purpose, one of Jake’s frustrated purposes is effortlessly achieved. He has sought Hugo in vain throughout the novel. Their one encounter on the film set is broken up (with the film set itself) by a brawl between Lefty Todd’s Independent Socialists and the United Nationalists, followed by the arrival of the police. Now Hugo is delivered to Jake at the hospital with an injury received at another of Lefty’s meetings. Their conversation there is the most illuminating event in the novel. In this exchange Jake learns (what he has already been told) that Hugo loves Sadie and Anna loves Hugo. Anybody can love anybody. He discovers that Hugo likes The Silencer. And he feels surprised and sick at Hugo’s differences with him. ‘“The trouble with you, Jake,” said Hugo, “is that you’re far too impressed by people. You were far too impressed by me”’ (p. 221). Perhaps Jake has been as mistaken about the impressiveness of Hugo as about his feelings. On the other hand, this may confirm rather than disprove Jake’s estimate. It is what a saint would say. There is another ‘trouble’ with Jake. ‘“Some situations can’t be unravelled”, said Hugo, “they just have to be dropped. The trouble with you, Jake, is that you want to understand everything sympathetically. It can’t be done”’ (p. 228). Hugo is speaking of his painful and hopeless relationships with Sadie and Anna. He plans to drop these situations by moving to Nottingham to become a watchmaker. But, like the version of his views in The Silencer, this remark seems by implication to be an
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
24 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
25
attack on the novel itself, the genre most devoted to sympathetic understanding. Despite Murdoch’s expressed admiration for nineteenthcentury novelists, for whom the basis of morality and the moral purpose of the novel is the development of sympathy and understanding, she suspected futility and even danger in the compulsion to understand. In her own novels there would be a dialogue between the conviction that some rules should be followed and the conviction that they should be understood and evaluated. It is a version of the old theological problem of whether God wills the good because it is good or the good is good because God wills it. At the human level, harmful relationships can be promoted and sustained by the desire to comprehend and resolve their problems, which is, among other things, an aesthetic desire for pattern. Hugo’s decision to drop the situation shows a humble acceptance that its story will be unfinished. Jake’s appalled response to their conversation is to question the patterns he has created and, as his images of Anna and of Hugo dissolve, his relationships with them change: ‘for the first time, Anna really existed now as a separate being and not as a part of myself [. . .] Why had I pursued [Hugo]? He had nothing to tell me’ (p. 238). And, the morning after their meeting, Jake questions the patterns made by art: I wanted to hold on, just a little longer, to my last act. A premonition of pain made me delay; the pain that comes after the drama, when the bodies have been carried from the stage and the trumpets are silent and an empty day dawns which will dawn again and again to make mock of our contrived finalities. (p. 239) Tragedy bestows at least the consolations of dignity and completion. But Under the Net would have an open ending. In the final chapter, Jake returns to Mrs Tinckham’s shop, his first refuge after being evicted by Magdalen at the beginning of the novel. There he opens his mail and a parcel of his own manuscripts. Finn amazes him by writing from Ireland. Mrs Tinckham says, ‘“But he must have told you he wanted to go back?” “He did [. . .] but I didn’t believe him” And somehow this phrase had a familiar ring’ (p. 247). The despised Jean Pierre has sent a copy of his prize-winning novel and Jake recognizes its quality. He looks at his manuscripts and his resolve to do his own writing is renewed. A patently duplicitous, charming
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
After the War
and affectionate letter from Sadie contains the offer to buy the ageing, valueless Mister Mars. The payment asked for will leave Jake with about the same amount of money as he had in the first chapter. He accepts and knows that he and Sadie will meet again. She is, as Hugo told him, more intelligent than Anna. Perhaps this is a case of mimetic desire or homosocial rivalry. Perhaps Hugo has given him the idea of loving her. Perhaps he is reflecting Hugo or perhaps Sadie is a reflection of her sister. At any rate, as Julius will observe in A Fairly Honourable Defeat, ‘Human beings are finders of substitutes’.21 But the magic of Anna or of Anna’s art asserts itself when he hears her singing on the radio. Both the song and the resolution to write recall the end of La Nausée. After his sense of nausea and meaninglessness throughout the novel, Roquentin hears a black singer on the radio. He feels that art has form and meaning, even if life does not, and that to write a book will confer a pattern on his own life. Although in her book on Sartre, Murdoch finds this a ‘thin and unsatisfactory conclusion’ (p. 46), she clearly echoes it here, but in a far warmer tone. Murdoch had complained in a radio talk in 1950 that Sartre’s ‘characters are never enchanting – and the worlds in which they live are without magic and without terror’.22 (Her second novel will contain an eponymous ‘enchanter’.) For Roquentin, art is the only way of salvaging the repulsive world which fills him with hatred and nausea. But Anna’s voice means love as well as art to Jake and it magically transfigures the shop, ‘transforming the cats into leopards and Mrs Tinckham into an aged Circe’ (p. 251). The novel closes on this miraculous note. For once Jake abandons theorizing and, unable to explain why two of Maggie’s four kittens should be tabbies and two exactly like their Siamese father, instead of all half-tabby and half-Siamese, admits, ‘I don’t know why it is [. . .] It’s just one of the wonders of the world’ (p. 253). It is a magical ending to a magical novel. After the sheer fun of the helter-skelter picaresque adventures, the comic assurance of the narration and the lyrical descriptions of London and Paris, the equanimity of the last chapter is a perfect close. Jake ends in almost the same place as he began, with about the same amount of money, but in some way better off. It is not certain that he will settle to his own writing or that it will be any good. No predictions can be made with certainty. As Mrs Tinckham observes, in a style resembling Hugo’s clumsy wisdom rather than Jake’s eloquent misjudgements, ‘You never know what you won’t want to do when the time comes’ (p. 248).
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
26 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
27
She sums up the inventive unexpectedness of the novel and the openness of the future beyond the last page. Jake thinks, ‘This too was a beginning. It was the first day of the world’ (p. 251). The epigraph ‘Tis well an Old Age is out,/And time to begin a New’ fits the mood of hope and renewal. It was one response to post-War England. ‘Optimism was in the air’, Mary Warnock writes of Oxford in the early years of peace.23 Under the Net has its sadnesses, but the aftermath of war, the destruction and the austerity are scarcely felt. Only once among the radiant portraits of London do we see the effects of the Blitz on the ruined churches near Cheapside. However, this too is a radiant description, picturesque in celebrating the beauty that remains with the atmospheric enhancements of mutability and loss. This description of the bombed City occurs during the increasingly hilarious and carefree night of the pub crawl and the swim in the Thames, an urban idyll of both camaraderie and non-attachment. It is the evening when Jake meets Lefty, whose New Independent Socialist Party is also part of the ‘New Age’. Lefty has heard that Jake is ‘a talented man who is too lazy to work and that [he holds] left-wing opinions but [takes] no active part in politics’ (p. 96). Although Murdoch herself had been politically active and a member of the Communist Party, she does not present Jake’s detachment as merely irresponsible. Lefty recommends hatred as a spur to action. ‘At the moment I hate nobody”’, Jake replies ‘lazily’ (p. 103). The absence of hatred, even if due to laziness, seems better than its cultivation. In Murdoch’s philosophical system, attitudes as well as actions can be virtuous. She presents the mother who brings herself to ‘see justly and lovingly’ a daughter-in-law she had at first disliked as an example of virtue, even if the daughter-in-law is dead or lives far away and the mother’s change of attitude has no outward effects in practice.24 Jake is as detached from religion as from war and politics. The chapter and the night end with the sound of church bells, ‘perhaps the vanishing bells of St Mary and St Leonard and St Vedast and St Anne and St Nicholas and St John Zachary’ (p. 108). To T.S. Eliot, writing The Waste Land after the earlier World War, the city churches have ‘inexplicable splendour’ and ‘reminiscent bells’ amid the fragments and ruin of Christian civilization. To Jake the bells are ‘vanishing’ and he does not seem to regret them. Unlike Murdoch, he is untormented by the loss of religion, though he differs from the empirical Dave in thinking it would be wonderful to be a natural metaphysician.
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
After the War
Unlike conventional nineteenth-century protagonists, who are rooted in society, heritage and family, Jake travels light. His few possessions are usually at Mrs Tinckham’s shop. Like Roquentin, Pierrot and Murphy, he carries minimal baggage of any kind. We know little of his past life, except for his friendship with Hugo. Hugo, with his German father and his adopted English name, is indeed the only character in Under the Net who seems to have any ancestry. The only family relationship in the novel is that of the sisters Anna and Sadie, who dislike each other. Jake is of Irish descent and a Londoner, but we learn nothing else about his background. He is educated but does not mention a school or university. He has shattered nerves but will not divulge how he got them. He loved Anna once, but we know little of their earlier relationship. The novel begins with the epigraph welcoming a New Age and ends with a lovely openness and optimism on ‘the morning of the first day’. Under the Net is ‘post-War’ in moving on from the past. The Flight from the Enchanter (1956) is ‘post-War’ in the opposite sense. Published two years after Under the Net, it is as effervescent but more melancholy in its drift. The characters are haunted by the War. A number are refugees or displaced persons. Mischa, the enchanter of the title, was born in some unnamed European country, now apparently cut off behind the Iron Curtain, perhaps no longer existing. Since 1953 Murdoch had been having a relationship with the Bulgarian-born Elias Canetti, on whom this character is based, and had fallen under his spell. He was a manipulative, even cruel figure in her life, but one whom she was unable to resist.25 Like a later virtuoso of manipulation, Julius in A Fairly Honourable Defeat, Mischa’s taste for power and ruthlessness in wielding it stems from early suffering. The young dressmaker, Nina, one of his creatures, lives in permanent fear of Mischa and of being deported. So do the sinister and assertive Lusiewicz brothers. In this book, the terror of the world is more present than its magic. When Murdoch worked among refugees for UNRRA in Brussels and then Innsbruck from 1945 to 1946, she saw people deported to almost certain death and survivors who would never return to their homes. She was now developing an interest in Simone Weil, who discusses in The Need for Roots the alienation caused by displacement.26 The rootlessness of Under the Net adds to its exuberance. The night Jake and Mars spend on the Embankment bench, the classic refuge of the homeless, is uncomfortable but cheerful. The mood is closer to
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
28 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
29
‘We’re a couple of swells’ than to Down and Out in Paris and London. The ruined churches and the bombsites of London have their own romance. But the London of new buildings in The Flight from the Enchanter has none. Rainborough, who works for the rootless in SELIB (the Special European Labour Immigration Board), is to lose part of the garden of his family home to a hospital extension. The wisteria which he has loved since his childhood is literally uprooted by his predatory secretary, Miss Casement. Only Annette, the young ‘cosmopolitan ragamuffin’ daughter of a diplomat, finds a zest in rootlessness and this is a kind of luxury.27 Her surname, Cockeyne, suggests a nowhere place free from the problems of ordinary life. Jake’s detachment from politics is also a kind of luxury not available to many of the characters in The Flight from the Enchanter. For some of them, a line drawn on the map of Europe can make the difference between life and death. The heroine, Rosa, is named after the revolutionary Rosa Luxemburg.28 Though she is educated, she works on the assembly line in a factory, like Simone Weil, for whom it was an experience of almost unbearable affliction and a kind of modern slavery. Weil usually found it impossible to keep working on her machine at the speed demanded. Nina has a nightmare in which her sewing machine turns into an unstoppable monster which savages both her and an endless cloth map of all the countries in the world. The machines in Rosa’s factory never stop, day or night. She fears being ‘caught in the machine’ (p. 39). Here she befriends the refugee Lusiewicz brothers, who arrive ‘dejected and colourless, like halfstarved, half-drowned animals’ (p. 43) but who begin to thrive and make their own conquests, including Rosa, whom they share sexually. In the English and domestic contexts, other struggles for power and autonomy are played out. Rosa has inherited from her mother an interest in a feminist journal, the Artemis, now edited by her mother’s brother, Hunter (a suitable name for a servant of the goddess of hunting), which Mischa would mysteriously like to acquire for his empire. This is energetically opposed by the older generation of activists, who are aged, comic and eccentric, but impressively uncompromising suffragettes. Compared with Rosa’s uncertainties, they show an absurd but joyous commitment. They are immune to self-doubt and are unworried by inconsistency. Rosa’s mother combined socialist convictions with ‘an almost uncanny sensitivity to social differences’ (p. 107). The redoubtable Camilla Wingfield is evidently named after
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
After the War
the Amazon warrior in the Aeneid, who might have skimmed over a cornfield as she ran without hurting it. But her egalitarian feminist principles do not apply at home, where she tyrannizes over her companion and housekeeper, Miss Foy. In the world of The Flight from the Enchanter, the personal, like the political, is largely a matter of power relations. The Lusiewicz brothers, who are political casualties, are at first Rosa’s beneficiaries, next her conquerors, then potential invaders of her house and destroyers of her brother. But she herself takes a conqueror’s pleasure in ‘forcing [Peter] to display [his unrequited love] and lay it out for her like a rich cloth’ (p. 38). Power is enjoyable, an end in itself. Rosa thinks that Mischa wants to take over the useless Artemis because it is a small independent thing. The professional and the personal merge for Miss Casement, whose rise to power in SELIB is accompanied by an engagement to Rainborough without his knowing quite how it has happened. When Miss Casement acquires a subordinate, she persecutes the helpless young typist. Power can be malign. However, it is enchanting. Rosa and Annette are both in love with Mischa. The women in this book are heavily involved in its power struggles. (Yet, beyond noting that Murdoch’s narrators were all male, early Murdoch criticism was seldom concerned with her representation of gender roles, though critics are becoming increasingly alert to it.)29 There are, however, more spiritual sources of power. In Under the Net, power is involuntarily and unconsciously invested in the figure of the saint. Hugo chooses not to exercise his power over others and they pursue him. In The Flight from the Enchanter, the ‘artist’ figure is a virtuoso in power and the ‘saint’ a scholar who is a failure in both love and work. Peter Saward loves Rosa in vain and spends his life in a fruitless attempt to decipher the ancient Kastanic script. For Murdoch scholarship, like art, can be an analogue of religion in demanding a patient abnegation of self. Like Ralph Touchett in The Portrait of a Lady, whose fatal illness forces him to love at a distance and observe life rather than participate in it, Peter has tuberculosis. However, his illness has had the ‘effect of making Saward not weaker but more powerful’ (p. 28) and he is ‘strangely gay’ (p. 25). His refusal to compete or to acquire confers a paradoxical freedom which others recognize. Rainborough describes it to himself in a political metaphor: ‘Here was a personality without frontiers’ (p. 31). Like Hugo and Jake, Peter and Mischa are opposites who get along well
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
30 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
31
with each other. Mischa even tries to promote Peter’s cause with Rosa. Peter is the only person whom Mischa does not ‘make mad’ (p. 205). He is also the only person on whom Mischa seems dependent. Mischa’s relationship with him is confiding, even confessional. In a chapter that consists entirely of conversation between the two men, Mischa talks of his childhood as they look at photographs of his home town, which Peter has obtained from the Warburg. Mischa is, very indirectly, responsible for Nina’s death. To force the sale of the Artemis, his henchman, Calvin Blick, tries to blackmail Hunter with compromising photographs of Rosa with the Lusiewicz brothers. Hunter obtains from Rainborough’s office the information that the brothers were born east of the crucial line and have no right to stay in Britain. Hunter is no match for Stefan Lusiewicz but Mischa, when Rosa appeals for his aid and gives him permission to ‘use any methods’ (p. 241), is. Questions are asked in Parliament, investigations begin and Nina, who is also an illegal immigrant but in no real danger of deportation, panics and kills herself. In Under the Net you can lose people, through neglect, distance or deciding to ‘drop’ a ‘situation’, but not destroy them. It shows the peaceful face of the fifties. The Flight from the Enchanter, for all its comedy and romance, is a novel of the Cold War. Some characters are desperately vulnerable, caught in industrial and political machines, and violence can irrupt into the lives of the more fortunate. Calvin’s underground workshop in the cellars of Mischa’s house has the air of a torture chamber and Hunter risks blinding himself with the developing fluid. Stefan Lusiewicz threatens to kill Hunter if he uses his knowledge of their birthplace against them and sets his hair on fire. Jan Lusiewicz threatens to kill Annette’s brother. Rosa attacks Annette in a fit of jealousy over Mischa and throws her out of her house. Annette has lived with Rosa and Hunter for some months but inhabits a different world. She is (so far) invulnerable, a character with a charmed life. She has no scars. She is temporarily so unhappy about Mischa that she attempts suicide, after inviting friends to a party in her hotel room, but accidentally takes only milk of magnesia. It is all harmless, comic and sociable, like a parody of Nina’s solitary and successful death. Annette’s parents act as a deus ex machina. They arrive from nowhere, save her and carry her off to another country. They offer a brief moment of benign (and privileged) power. Annette’s father, a diplomat, deals in peaceful solutions. Her mother rescues
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
After the War
Rainborough from Miss Casement, who is able to detach himself from the relationship by telling her in detail about the secretary’s treatment of her typist, and sends him off to their villa in the south of France. For once, a malign use of power backfires. Our last glimpse of the family is in the south of France as the Orient Express transports the recovered Annette away from the events of the novel to the land of Cockeyne. Rosa’s journey proves to be in the opposite direction. She impulsively travels south herself to join Mischa at his villa in Italy. She feels compelled by the enchanter. Perhaps they can be reunited. His villa is an enchanter’s castle, though it is set in a barren landscape by the sea and life is simple there. But she is persuaded to leave and go home by a conversation with Calvin Blick. He produces the photographs of Rosa with the Lusiewicz brothers, telling her Mischa has seen them, though he told Hunter he had not. ‘You will never know the truth,’ he claims, ‘and you will read the signs in accordance with your deepest wishes. That is what we humans always have to do. Reality is a cipher with many solutions, all of them right ones’ (p. 278). Rosa retorts that this view is a surrender of his power. Perhaps, like the predestinarian John Calvin, he should be expected to deal in absolutes. Perhaps a moral realist like Murdoch cannot rest with this relativism. Calvin Blick next shows Rosa a newspaper report of Nina’s suicide, remarking that ‘someone ought to have explained things to her’ (p. 279). Rosa bears responsibility in two ways. She herself unleashed Mischa’s power, authorizing him, in his sinister phrase, to ‘use any methods’ (p. 241). The end justified the means, the rationale of both Resistance fighters and totalitarian dictators, since she had to protect herself and Hunter from Stefan. And in a more mundane everyday manner, because she was so rapturously abstracted at the thought of seeing Mischa, she failed to attend to Nina’s plea for help. (‘ “I have some problems” said Nina. [. . .] “Life is a series of problems!” said Rosa merrily [. . .] “I would like to ask your advice.” “Never be afraid to ask for advice,” said Rosa, “People try to be far too independent of each other. I’m just going in now to ask Mr Fox’s advice” ’ [p. 238]). Nina has died, in part as a result of Rosa’s inattention, in part because Rosa enlisted Mischa and his methods. It is a moment of unexpected moral crisis, like Jake’s in Paris. Rosa has to leave Mischa. However, unlike Jake’s realization that he must do his own writing rather than accept a Hollywood sinecure, Rosa’s decision is one of pure renunciation. She departs for London,
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
32 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
33
unclear where the balance of power lies between Mischa and Calvin. ‘You know how to protect your own’, she tells Calvin, as though he were the devil and Mischa one of the damned. Nonetheless, Rosa does make one vital gain and discovery. She can choose to be free of Mischa and so recognize herself as a free agent. She says to Calvin, whose name tolls predestination, ‘in the past I always felt that whether I went towards him or away from him I was only doing his will. But perhaps it was all an illusion’ (p. 281). Freedom brings little happiness with it. After the jubilation at the end of the War and the Labour victory in 1945, the age of austerity continued. The closing chapter is melancholy, though it contains good as well as bad news. On her return to rainy London, Rosa goes straight to see Peter. From him she learns that Camilla Wingfield has died, leaving her all the shares of the Artemis and an annual income of £500 if she will edit the journal. The Artemis has been saved from Mischa, and Rosa has been saved from the factory and given a new purpose. A bilingual inscription has been discovered which is a key to the Kastanic script and proves Peter’s work on it to be futile. Peter is stoical: ‘One reads the signs as best one can, and one may be totally misled [. . .] It was worth trying. Now I can go back to my other work in peace. There’s nothing to be sad about, Rosa’ (p. 287). But Rosa is sad. Peter turns down her suggestion of marriage, knowing she does not really want it. The novel ends with Peter showing Rosa the photographs of the lost world of Mischa’s childhood and ‘she saw the pictures through a gathering haze of tears’ (p. 286). Under the Net looks forward, but The Flight from the Enchanter looks back. The first two novels introduce many of the figures, themes and motifs that will be pervasive in Murdoch’s fiction: the saint and the artist, refugees and displaced persons, gurus and enchanters, philosophers, civil servants, sibling rivalry, romantic triangles and polygons. Appearing in the 1950s, both deal, however lightly, with the questions of semiology, pre-empting concerns which will later be central to postmodern fiction and theory. Both novels are set mainly in London, the setting for the majority of the novels. As if echoing Hugo’s view that art should be ephemeral or predicting the ease and speed with which the author would move on from one novel to the next, both books present casual demolitions and disposals of beautiful objects, ambitious constructions and valuable collections. Anna’s mime theatre is abandoned and its props and masks are
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
After the War
whisked away; the film set of ancient Rome collapses in a riot; Hugo donates his paintings to Lefty’s Socialist Party; Annette’s party dress is torn up and she throws her jewels into the Thames. However, some themes which will be central to Murdoch’s later work scarcely appear in the first two novels. Religion is present in Under the Net only as an absence. Finn was always saying he would ‘go back to Ireland to be in a country which really has religion’ (p. 22). In Jake’s London, religion is bombed churches and vanishing bells. In The Flight from the Enchanter it is briefly remembered as a troubling possibility before Nina’s suicide. As she sits on the windowsill, she looks at a crucifix and thinks the idea that death was the end was not ‘senseless blackness’ for Christ, as it will be for her. ‘Then her thought coiled back. If not so for him, then not so for her. If for her, then for him too [. . .] For an instant she felt the terrible weight of a God depending on her will. It was too heavy’ (p. 266). She throws herself out of the window. The novel ends with the words, ‘And here is the cathedral’ (p. 287) as Peter shows Rosa the pictures of the lost pre-War world. One of the other great subjects is totally absent from Under the Net. All the characters are single. Although Murdoch wrote the novel in her thirties, in some ways it represents an undergraduate view of life, in which almost every day offers a heady freedom and a worrying choice of action or inaction unknown to most children or adults, and in which it is a major devastation to discover you did not know with whom your best friend is in love. In The Flight from the Enchanter all the characters are single except Annette’s parents and perhaps their numinous but practical power to solve everyone’s problems is derived from their mysterious married condition. When Murdoch married John Bayley in 1956, her love-life settled down and there was more room for writing. By the time The Flight from the Enchanter was finished, she was full of energy and reassured that her task in life was to write. Her literary career was now securely launched, but there were nonetheless persistent anxieties over the quality of her work. She had written to David Hicks in 1946 that she was weary because in trying to remove herself from her characters she had made them unreal; in addition, she said to Stella Aldwinckle in 1954 that she felt that what she was writing would not do, describing the disorienting experience of having been so deeply involved in the world of the novel to find it disintegrating.
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
34 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
35
Occasionally she regretted neglecting the world of philosophy for the world of the novel, but her love of writing and the joy of having her characters around her, wondering how they would handle the next crisis in the plot, was the stronger pull (IMC, pp. 69 and 42). Her next novel, The Sandcastle, is dedicated to John Bayley and is on the surface a fairly traditional – perhaps too traditional – account of a dreary marriage threatened by the arrival of a younger woman. The major novel which follows it, The Bell, explores the marital, sexual and spiritual problems of its characters in the context of a religious community. Marriage and religion are now major subjects.
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
After the War
Triangles and Polygons The Sandcastle (1957), The Bell (1958), A Severed Head (1961) and An Unofficial Rose (1962)
Murdoch’s reputation as a novelist was undergoing a meteoric rise when The Sandcastle was begun in the autumn of 1955. She was now dividing her time between her family home in Chiswick and teaching at St Anne’s. The book was finally published in 1957 and can be viewed either as a new development in Murdoch’s work or a retreat down well-trodden fictional paths.1 The situation is a familiar one. A man or woman is faced with a choice between a safe but unexciting marriage and a passionate romantic exotic alternative. Obvious examples are Sense and Sensibility, Emma and Mansfield Park, Wuthering Heights, The Golden Bowl or (sequentially and from the viewpoint of the second wife) Rebecca. But Murdoch did not have to look outside her own life to research her plot: during the period in which this novel was conceived, she was heavily involved with John Bayley and increasingly determined to marry, desperately needing security and wanting a release from her complex love-life. Elias Canetti, who was to be an enduring temptation, was a huge romantic and intellectual influence, and Bayley was distressed, on finding her journal of their affair in her flat, to know that she was still involved with him.2 She was also in the throes of an affair with the writer Brigid Brophy, had holidayed with Peter Ady, fallen out with Arnold Momigliano, who was upset by her plan to marry, and was close to the philosophers John Simopoulos and David Pears. The decision to marry was difficult, but after the ceremony at an Oxford registry office in September 1956, Murdoch recorded in her journal the simplicity and joy of her new life. 36
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
3
37
This contest between domestic calm and respectability and the thrill of romantic excitement animates the plot of The Sandcastle. Its moral psychology focuses on the motives that drive infidelity and the pain that either choice engenders for perpetrators and victims alike. Murdoch imaginatively tests her decision to forego sexual intrigue for domesticity, envisaging how a ‘safe’ marriage might stand up to sexual allure and the consequences of the inability to resist. Mor, a middle-aged schoolmaster trapped in a miserable marriage with a nagging disappointed wife and two taciturn rebellious teenage children, falls in love with a young painter, Rain Carter. Mor’s name is symbolic: he wants more. Rain offers the promise of renewal to his waste land, has talent, optimism, money, a house in France and an equal sexual passion for Mor. But an ominous gypsy puts in an occasional appearance, auguring ill. Mor’s colleague, the art master, Bledyard, voices his disapproval in terms central to Murdoch’s moral vision: ‘The gifts of the spirit do not appeal to the imagination’ (p. 213). Using shabby or sinister methods, his wife and children defeat Mor’s will to leave, though Nan has to compromise by letting him stand for Parliament, a desire she has always mocked and blocked. Otherwise, one is tempted to feel, the novel ends unhappily ever after. The claims of the imagination have their own authority. The sandcastle, doomed by the tide, suggests the vulnerable structure of Mor’s marriage and of his love for Rain. Perhaps it also symbolizes the erosion of its own structure, the apparently conventional realist form. Here Murdoch implicitly acknowledges her debt to Henry James and covertly reveals the innovative aesthetics of her style.3 She said that the only writer she is sure she was influenced by was James: ‘he is a pattern maker too.’4 The double subject of this novel is two portraits: one, Rain’s portrait of the retired Headmaster, Demoyte; the other, Murdoch’s literary portrait of Mor. Both Murdoch and her fictional painter seek to portray human character as accurately as possible, both physically and spiritually. Both are torn between a commitment to realism and to formal patterning; both are influenced by a father figure and see that ‘part of [their] task is to cover that surface with a pattern’ (p. 102). Demoyte literally becomes a ‘figure in the carpet’ when Rain paints him against the background of an oriental rug.5 Rain, too, is a figure in a carpet when, as Mor meets her for the first time in Demoyte’s study, she is indistinguishable from the riotous colours of the same oriental
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
Triangles and Polygons
rug on the wall behind her. These playful allusions to figures in carpets suggest that, as with James’s work, readers must attend to the form of the novel as well as the plot to perceive meaning. The book responds to theories of modern art in its attempt to render the inner lives of characters through an expressionistic use of space, perspective and colour. But Murdoch’s quite revolutionary attempt to combine the naturalistic idea of character with an expressionistic use of form was largely misunderstood or not perceived. Critics were baffled, finding the novel ‘puzzling’ or ‘irritating’. A.S. Byatt complained that ‘the tendency of art to impose its own shapes on the stuff of life, criticized by Bledyard in the book, is too much apparent’.6 Such criticism failed to understand how form is being used in the book, that Murdoch’s dealings with it here are part of the novel’s theoretical probing. But literary theory did not have a terminology or a paradigm for what Murdoch was attempting at this time.7 ‘Art is tested by knowledge of the ordinary world and we apply such tests instinctively and sometimes wrongly’, Murdoch has said, ‘as when we dismiss a story as implausible when we have not really understood what kind of story it is’.8 While her enduring desire to be ‘thought of as a realist writer in the sense in which English novelists have been realists in the past’9 remained sacred, she was experimenting with infusing her traditional realism with a brand of linguistic expressionism. The combination of the two continued to be the hallmark of her narrative technique. Critical dissatisfaction with this book was caused partly by a failure to understand her aesthetics10 and by too rigid attempts to read her novels solely from a realist perspective. The omission is particularly significant in this book because its aesthetics reveal its moral. Murdoch soaks the world with colour to subliminally inform the reader of Mor’s moral sickness – his guilt and depression. As the affair with Rain progresses, a cold white light veils the world, evoking the joyless place into which it has been transformed as a result of his deception. The affair conflicts with his strong instinctive moral propriety. Underneath a sultry and oppressive green light filtering through the glass roof of the school squash court, Bledyard pronounces a stinging moral judgement on Mor, triggering his guilt. The boys’ screeching and rain drumming on a glass roof provide a dramatic primitive aural accompaniment. Mor’s self-disgust triggers ‘an unpleasant odour [. . .] in his nostril, as if he could literally
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
38 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
39
smell the sulphur of the pit’ (p. 230). The synaesthetic enterprise is intended to stimulate the readers’ senses to the point that they experience, not merely read about, Mor’s self-disgust. But Murdoch was more cautious from here on in about relying too heavily on expressionism to convey meaning. The superficially light, conventional, romantic plot and this failure to understand its aesthetics caused The Sandcastle to be received with some disappointment. After the brilliance and individuality of the first two novels, it appeared on the surface to be rather drab and commonplace. In her letter accepting The Sandcastle, Norah Smallwood welcomed this contrast: ‘It is, of course, a very different sort of book from either Under the Net or The Flight from the Enchanter but I think that’s a good thing. It will show people that you can write a straight story without any fantasy element & create ordinary people as convincingly as eccentrics.’11 Most reviewers, however, thought the novel too ordinary and found gratuitous fantasy in the gypsy and the children’s attempt to sabotage their father’s affair by witchcraft. The novel was dismissed by some as the stuff of women’s magazines. However, the two most popular women’s magazines, Woman and Woman’s Own, refused it for serialization, stating that it was ‘not suitable’. Presumably they found the treatment of the love affair too sympathetic. This was the reason given more explicitly by John Davies in rejecting The Sandcastle for serialization in John Bull: ‘The theme of the extra-marital love affair is not one we can really take – not at any rate when it is handled as “an advanced study in passion and guilt”.’12 The Sandcastle was, however, read in 12 installments on the BBC radio programme Woman’s Hour in September 1964. Times had changed. The Bell, published in 1958, has always been regarded as one of Murdoch’s best novels. It was her own favourite among her early work. In an interview with Simon Blow in 1976, she said that she now saw her first three published novels as experiments and thought that she had only begun to find herself as a writer with The Bell.13 It was written at a time of great happiness during the early halcyon days of her marriage to John Bayley. The first draft was completed at Cedar Lodge, their country house 14 miles outside Oxford, in the village of Steeple Aston, where they were to remain for the next 30 years. The book was published in November 1958. For the first time, religion is a major theme, as it would continue to be in Murdoch’s fiction. Her family background was Ulster Protestant
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
Triangles and Polygons
and she was confirmed into the Church of England while she was at school, giving her ‘a feeling of communing with God’ (TCHF, p. 209). Throughout her adult life she denied the existence of a personal God, the divinity of Christ and a belief in life after death. However, she was deeply committed to preserving many aspects of Christianity and increasingly borrowed aspects of the Buddhist faith for what she termed her ‘neo-theology’. There was always some tension throughout her life between a denial of God and a desire for God.14 In the late 1940s she made three visits to the Anglican Benedictine Malling Abbey in Kent, which provided the model for Imber Abbey in The Bell. She longed to affirm the absolute moral values which believers imagine to emanate from God. Her last philosophical work, Metaphysics as a Guide to Morals, valorizes religion as an aid to moral enquiry, but she was involved with such issues as early as her days in post-War Oxford, when she was at odds with linguistic philosophers, engaging with the ideas of Wittgenstein and Nietzsche and sharing in the considerable interest in contemporary debates on how Christianity could evolve to accommodate the horror of two World Wars and the Holocaust. In the late 1950s and 1960s there was a move towards ‘religionless Christianity’, but Murdoch realized that although these debates were crucially important for humanity, the specialized discourse of academics and philosophers had little resonance in society. For this reason, The Bell brings to the fore her lifelong commitment to the novel’s place in the discussions of faith, the existence of a personal God, how a good life can be lived without the communal support of traditional worship and without the moral focus that belief systems once provided – all of which are the central themes of The Bell. From The Bell onwards, clergy and religious seekers, former priests, monks and nuns would figure in Murdoch’s novels. Michael in The Bell, for whom prayer is ‘a surrender of himself to the Ground of his being’ (p. 79),15 is an ex-future priest and religious liminality pervades the novel. The Bell is mainly set in Imber Court, a lay Anglican community in Gloucestershire attached to a medieval abbey. The two central characters are Michael Meade and Dora Greenfield. Michael is a member of the community and the owner of the property. His previous career as a schoolmaster and his desire to be ordained were ended by a questionable affection for one of his pupils, Nick, who in an emotional reaction to an evangelical preacher confessed
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
40 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
41
everything (or perhaps more than everything) to the headmaster. Now, years later, Nick, disturbed and drinking heavily, and his twin sister Catherine, awaiting entry to the Abbey as a postulant, are both, to Michael’s dismay, at Imber Court. Dora had left and has now returned to her husband Paul, an art historian temporarily working on manuscripts at Imber. The third character to whose consciousness we have access is the young Toby Gashe, at Imber for the summer before going up to Oxford. Dora and Toby find and raise from the lake a lost and legendary medieval bell, planning to substitute it for a new bell which is to be ceremonially received into the Abbey. Michael, after several drinks, expresses his attraction to Toby, whom Nick forces, in a kind of replay of his own history, to confess the incident. Various tragic consequences ensue and the community is dissolved. Dora, however, has found during her time at Imber the insight and courage to finally leave Paul, to see the world and others more clearly than she did and take a job. The medieval bell was made by ‘Hugh the Belyetere’ or Hugo Belfounder. In Under the Net we are told that when Hugo’s German father moved to England, he took the name ‘Belfounder’, which he found on a tomb in a Cotswold churchyard. As such, the maker of this bell was one of Hugo’s adoptive ancestors and it shares his compelling and mysterious quality. He unwittingly takes after the bell-founder in his decision to become a watchmaker. (This is not the only crossreference between Murdoch’s novels.) Round the rim of the bell is written ‘Vox ego sum Amoris. Gabriel vocor’ (‘I am the voice of Love. I am called Gabriel’).16 Love, in its many guises, is Murdoch’s major theme. She sees falling in love, although so often powered by fantasy and projection, as revelatory, one of life’s most intense experiences and granting the rare sense of another person’s existence and value. It can offer a secular or Christian version of Plato’s ascent of the soul. The wise Abbess tells Michael, ‘God can always show us, if we will, a higher and better way; and we can only learn to love by loving. Remember that all our failures are failures in love. Imperfect love must not be condemned and rejected but made perfect’ (p. 235). In his anguish after Nick’s death, Michael realizes that he should not have avoided him at Imber: ‘Nick had needed love and he should have given him what he had to offer, without fears about its imperfection’ (p. 307). At the heart of the moral debate in the novel are two sermons,17 delivered to the community on successive Sundays by James Tayper
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
Triangles and Polygons
Pace and Michael. Both use the symbol of the bell but in different senses. This could suggest, like Calvin Blick in The Flight from the Enchanter, that ‘you will never know the truth and you will read the signs in accordance with your deepest wishes’18 or that the bell, the voice of love, means and includes both (and more) interpretations. James gives the first sermon. We are told that he has a ‘deep and unquestioning spiritual life’ (p. 84). He comes from a military family and served in the War. He has evident leadership qualities and, if it had met with the approval of the Abbess, Michael would have been glad to surrender his unofficial position as head of the community to him. James believes in following rules. Almost his first words in the novel are ‘The train was punctual for once. We shall just be in time for Compline’ (p. 26). His sermon begins, ‘The chief requirement of the good life is to live without any image of oneself’ (p. 31). He quotes Christ’s command, ‘Be ye therefore perfect’ (p. 131), advocates unquestioning obedience (he has not been in the army for nothing) and deplores analysis and self-examination: ‘Truth is not glorious, it is just enjoined: sodomy is not disgusting, it is just forbidden’ (p. 132). The beauty of the bell is in ‘its simplicity. There is no hidden mechanism’ (p. 135). This is a position for which Murdoch here, and elsewhere, shows respect. She sees virtue as grounded in unselfing. She argues that, except for those who consider moral laws to be entirely subjective, there is considerable general agreement on what they are. But James’s example of the forbidden, sodomy, would not gain general assent. When The Bell was written, almost all educated liberal opinion was in favour of legalizing homosexual acts between consenting adults.19 Murdoch told a friend that she identified with male homosexuals (IMAL, p. 522) and there are likeable and admirable gay characters, such as Michael (including Humphrey Finch in An Unofficial Rose [1962], Uncle Theo in The Nice and the Good [1968], Axel and Simon in A Fairly Honourable Defeat [1970] and Bellamy James in The Green Knight [1993]), in the novels. James acts decisively on learning of Michael’s mild involvement with Toby: he sends Toby away. Michael is appalled and fears that Toby will suffer disproportionate guilt and anxiety, but it seems that James’s action was for the best. As Hugo says in Under the Net, ‘Some situations can’t be unravelled, they just have to be dropped. The trouble with you, Jake, is that you want to understand
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
42 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
43
everything sympathetically’.20 But Jake, like Murdoch, is a writer. Novelists analyse hidden mechanisms and try to understand their characters sympathetically. Murdoch respects James’s position but shows his limitations. While he leads a good life, he is unimaginative and unsympathetic to those who seem to him to act wrongly. Michael’s sermon presents the opposite view to James’s. It opens: ‘The chief requirement of the good life is that one should have some conception of one’s capacities’ (p. 200). Whereas James had celebrated innocence, Michael praises wisdom and self-knowledge. For James, the ‘good man [. . .] does the best thing, breaking through the complexities of situations [. . .] but the man without faith calculates. He finds the world too complicated for the best thing and he does the second best thing’ (p. 132). However, Michael argues that ‘we must not arrogate to ourselves actions which belong to those whose spiritual vision is higher or other than ours. From this attempt, only disaster will come’ (p. 204). He uses the image of the bell very differently, urging his audience to ‘learn to understand the mechanism of [each person’s] spiritual energy’ (p. 204). Members of the community at Imber Court, unlike the nuns at the Abbey, do seem to be aiming at a higher spiritual level than they can sustain. Most dramatically, the motives of Catherine, a kind of spiritual mascot for the community, are revealed to be mental illness and unrequited love. Dora, who dislikes and is rather despised by the community, is the only person to sense that Catherine does not want to enter the Abbey. As soon as his sermon is over, Michael returns to thoughts of his own problems and realizes that ‘it was complicated; it was interesting [a loaded and suspect term in Murdoch’s work] [. . .] he was always engaged in performing what James had called the second best act: the act which goes with exploring one’s personality and estimating the consequences rather than austerely following the rules’ (p. 205). Neither Michael’s moral vision nor James’s vision is adequate to deal with the situation, which ends in Nick’s suicide. While James thinks it was a mistake to admit Nick to Imber and would presumably believe that Michael should follow the rules and keep well away from the ‘tempter’ from his past, Michael is racked after Nick’s suicide by the knowledge that ‘he had concerned himself with keeping his own hands clean’, that ‘Nick needed love and he ought to have given him what he had to offer, without fears about
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
Triangles and Polygons
its imperfection’ (p. 307). Wiser than both James and Michael, the Abbess wanted Nick to be offered what Imber could give and acknowledges the imperfect as a step towards the perfect. Dora, frivolous and hedonistic, is a surprisingly sympathetic character. Before her marriage to domineering Paul, she is a recognizable student of the 1950s, ‘plump’ and fond of ‘big multi-coloured skirts’ (p. 7) and much more docile than the godless rebels Murdoch would teach at the Royal College of Art in the 1960s. Without spiritual pretensions, she learns and develops more than anybody else at Imber Court. Although she has no religious belief, she does have a spiritual experience, not at Imber but in the National Gallery. In her philosophical work, Murdoch argues that art does have a vital role to play in a godless world: contemplation of a work of art can be a version of prayer or provide a spiritual revelation. Dora’s experience is described in religious language: the pictures are ‘shrines at which she had worshipped so often before’ (p. 190). They ‘were something real outside herself, which spoke to her kindly yet in sovereign tones, something superior and good’ (p. 191). Murdoch was later to write a philosophical book called The Sovereignty of Good and Dora, no philosopher, is recognizing the force of the Good. She finds the pictures ‘something real and something perfect. Who had said that about perfection and reality being in the same place?’ (p. 190). It was James, whom Dora finds ‘a bit alarming’ (p. 133), in his sermon. But much earlier, it was also St Anselm in his ontological proof of the existence of God, to which Murdoch devotes a whole chapter in Metaphysics as a Guide to Morals. Dora, no theologian either, has a similar apprehension, even a mystical experience of transcendence and the loss of self, before Gainsborough’s picture of his daughters. The experience passes one of the Church’s tests of a divine vision: it has a beneficial result on her life. She had fled from Imber to see a lover in London. Now she leaves the gallery, hails a taxi and returns to confront and deal with the problems of her marriage. While James’s view might be that fidelity to marital vows is enjoined and unquestionable, it is clear that this marriage has been a mistake, sustained by fear and dependence on Dora’s part and a contemptuous possessiveness on Paul’s. At the end of the novel, Dora has decisively separated from Paul and is painting watercolours of the Abbey, beginning to enjoy classical music, learning to swim (a highly valued activity in Murdoch’s life and novels), having
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
44 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
45
conversations with Mother Clare (the ‘aquatic nun’ who saved her from drowning but whom she had earlier refused to see) and is about to take a teaching job in Bath. Despite Nick’s death and Michael’s despair, the novel ends with a quiet equanimity as Dora rows on the lake at Imber, reconciled at last to the place and willing to move on into the future. The Bell introduces or continues major themes in Murdoch’s work. James and Michael, though not saints or artists, present a version of the saint/artist debate in their sermons. James recommends detachment from self, while Michael advocates an examination of self. Serenely detached from such argument, the works of art – paintings, bell – silently proclaim their own authority. The Freudian compulsions of repetition and substitution animate Michael’s story. He tries to avoid Nick, but both he and Nick repeat their earlier disastrous involvement through the figure of Toby. Later novels will dramatize the theme of repetition with more frequent and polymorphous substitutions. The Bell is a less promiscuous novel and perhaps therefore more powerful and convincing. One obvious substitution, that of a sibling (used in Under the Net, The Flight from the Enchanter, A Severed Head and A Fairly Honourable Defeat), is explicitly, if allusively, ruled out. ‘It might be thought that since Nature by addition had defeated him of Nick, she was now by subtraction offering him Catherine: but this did not occur to Michael except abstractly and as something someone else might have felt’ (p. 109). The allusion is to Shakespeare’s ‘Sonnet XX’, in which the speaker regrets that Nature has added a penis to his male beloved and made him the wrong sex for his ‘purpose’. The Bell is not Twelfth Night. Richard Todd actually attributes the success of the treatment of homosexuality in The Bell to ‘the probability that that this source [Shakespeare] was not, at the time of the writing of The Bell, a prior concern’.21 Nonetheless, the influence of Shakespeare is more diffusely present. As with Shakespeare’s tragedies and comedies, none of Murdoch’s novels is purely tragic or comic. While The Bell (unlike A Fairly Honourable Defeat) does not follow A Midsummer Night’s Dream in suggesting that anybody can fall in love with anybody, it does employ a similar structure to A Midsummer Night’s Dream, As You Like It and The Tempest in removing its characters from the city to a greener world which may both intensify and resolve their problems. Dora exasperates Michael by looking like a character in ‘an absurd
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
Triangles and Polygons
pastoral frolic’ (p. 121). Like The Comedy of Errors, Twelfth Night, Pericles and The Tempest, The Bell contains a rebirth through Dora’s near-death experience of drowning. Like the abbey in The Comedy of Errors, the ‘tomb’ in Much Ado About Nothing and the temple in Pericles, the Abbey is a sacred space which offers wisdom, acceptance of death and restoration. Another writer alluded to in Murdoch’s later novels is the fourteenth-century mystic Julian of Norwich, from whose Revelations of Divine Love Catherine reads to the community at lunch. In this passage Julian recalls that ‘me thought it was impossible that all things should be well, as our Lord showed’ (p. 159), but that the answer was in the ‘Showing of our Lord God [. . .] I shall save my word in all things and I shall make all things well’ (pp. 159–60). Although The Bell does not commit itself to such faith, much of its appeal lies, if not in Christian optimism, in its radiant celebration of the beauty of nature, art, holiness and the vexed comedy of human interaction. To many readers, The Bell seems one of Murdoch’s most ‘real’ novels, dramatizing moral and religious problems through the experiences of sympathetic and credible characters. A.S. Byatt opens her chapter on The Bell in Degrees of Freedom as follows: ‘here we have a novel which has the solid life that Miss Murdoch praises in the great nineteenth-century novels. The characters are not tied up neatly at the end of the book; they have a life of their own which exists beyond it’ (p. 79). But others have found the characters insubstantial. Soon after its publication, in a letter to Peter Calvocoressi at Chatto, refusing to do a short talk on The Bell, John Bowen commented, ‘I don’t think she knows very much about the nature of people, and I think this fault shows up more and more glaringly the more she writes about people and the less about ideas’.22 Despite the opinion of the Spectator that Murdoch was now the foremost novelist of her generation, she was despondent about the quality of her novels and was attempting to find ways of improving her writing. She wrote to Canetti, asking to meet him, feeling the need for an abrasive opinion of her work. He provided it. When they met for lunch in January 1959, he told her that her work so far was weak and sentimental. Such criticism may have sapped her confidence, for the novel she was working on at that time, Jerusalem, which was about idealistic Utopian socialists, was eventually abandoned. She also thought that her attempts at a series of poems were mediocre.
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
46 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
47
In February 1959, she said she was ‘sickened’ by praises for The Bell and felt that she had achieved an easy success. She was determined to improve from what she perceived as a second-class novelist to a first-class one. The potential contrast between ‘ideas’ and ‘characters’ embedded in ‘solid life’ that John Bowen had spotted was one that particularly vexed her. Byatt mentions Murdoch’s praise of nineteenth-century novels, probably referring to ‘Against Dryness’. This essay, written in 1961, was Murdoch’s attempt to clarify her own position and decide where she was heading artistically. Beginning with the context of the Welfare State and modern philosophy, Murdoch considers contemporary fiction and makes a much-quoted distinction between ‘crystalline’ and ‘journalistic’ novels. She writes, ‘the nineteenth-century novel [. . .] was not concerned with “the human condition”, it was concerned with real various individuals struggling in society’ (EM, p. 291) (although she acknowledges that there were exceptions to this rough assessment). The twentieth-century novel is usually either crystalline or journalistic; that is, it is either ‘a small quasi-allegorical object portraying the human condition and not containing “characters” in the nineteenth-century sense, or else it is a large shapeless quasi-documentary object, the degenerate descendant of the nineteenth-century novel, telling, with pale conventional characters, some straightforward story enlivened with empirical facts’ (EM, p. 291). Murdoch does not name any English examples of these sub-genres, but one might call Animal Farm and Lord of the Flies ‘crystalline’ and, though hardly peopled by ‘pale conventional characters’, the early novels of Angus Wilson ‘journalistic’. Although Murdoch thinks that among contemporary novels the crystalline are usually the better, she concludes with a defence of character and contingency: A respect for the contingent is essential to imagination as opposed to fantasy. Our sense of form, which is an aspect of our desire for consolation, can be a danger to our sense of reality as a rich receding background. Against the consolations of form, the clean crystalline work, the simplified fantasy-myth, we must pit the destructive power of the now so unfashionable naturalistic idea of character. Real people are destructive of myth, contingency is destructive of fantasy and opens the way for imagination [. . .]
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
Triangles and Polygons
Too much contingency, of course, may turn art into journalism. But since reality is incomplete, art must not be too afraid of incompleteness. Literature must always represent a battle between real people and images; and what it requires now is a much stronger and more complex sense of the former. (EM, p. 295) This passage presents values central to Murdoch’s thought: her respect for contingency, imagination and the incomplete; and her suspicion of form, fantasy and consolation or of form as generated by fantasy to provide consolation. In Under the Net we may recall Jake’s talent for personal mythology, his discredited fantasies about other characters, his tendency to perceive real people as images, and the fear of contingency which makes him nervous about living in Goldhawk Road. The novelist is subject to similar temptations, hence Murdoch’s praise of ‘incompleteness’. Although it is not clear in what sense, if this world is all we have, ‘reality is incomplete’, it is certainly imperfect and the atheist in Murdoch gives way to the Platonist. Despite Dora’s beneficent vision in the National Gallery, the work of art can offer a false consolation and a semblance of perfection. Rain’s inability to finish the portrait is a sign of grace. The novels usually end with an elegant (‘tonight she would be telling the whole story to Sally’ in The Bell)23 or ragged (‘what next, I wonder?’ in The Sea, The Sea)24 gesture to the future. Even the presence in most novels of minor as well as major characters can be seen as a kind of discrimination against their ‘reality’. In An Accidental Man a chorus of minimal characters pursues its own absorbing affairs in a whirligig of cocktail party chatter. At the end of The Time of the Angels, a person who has been vainly trying to get into the vicarage and the novel since Chapter 1 is identified as a past lover. John Bayley’s critical book The Characters of Love was published in 1960, the year before ‘Against Dryness’. The title seems to anticipate Murdoch’s defence of the ‘naturalistic idea of character’ and, like her, to link it with the experience of love. Bayley said that he had never had a serious conversation with his wife. However, the consonance of The Characters of Love with Murdoch’s own observations on love, character and literature suggests either conversation or a telepathic intellectual compatibility. ‘Everyone recognizes that – whatever you call it – sexual love is for most people the most interesting and memorable aspect of life [. . .] love is preoccupied with the uniqueness of
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
48 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
49
the individual’;25 ‘Love may sometimes give us a marvellous degree of mutual consciousness but it also enforces our most intractable solipsism’ (p. 5); ‘Taking other people’s reality for granted is the first requirement of love. And it is also the first requirement of character creation’ (p. 273); ‘An author’s love for his characters is a delight in their independent existence as other people’ (p. 7); ‘The writers whom we admire today do not appear to love their characters’ (p. 8); ‘We have a passion for understanding what is happening to us, or at least for coining myths and terminologies which seem to present to us a picture of what is happening’ (p. 266). Compare these with Murdoch’s The Fire and the Sun: ‘“Falling in love” [. . .] is for many people the most extraordinary and most revealing experience of their lives, whereby the centre of significance is suddenly ripped out of the self, and the dreamy ego is suddenly shocked into awareness of an entirely separate reality. Love in this form may be a somewhat ambiguous instructor’ (EM, p. 417). Despite Murdoch’s advocacy of the ‘naturalistic idea of character’ over the ‘consolations of form, the clean crystalline work’, the term ‘crystalline’ was to become a weapon used against her by critics. Aptly or ironically, one of her most crystalline novels, A Severed Head, was published in 1961, the same year as ‘Against Dryness’. Echoes of her personal life infiltrate the plot, for she had been reconciled to her Oxford contemporary Philippa Foot in April 1958 after an estrangement which resulted from the triangular relationship between Murdoch, Philippa and M.R.D Foot, whom Philippa eventually married. Now, however, he had fallen in love with his secretary in London and a flurry of letters between the two women re-established their friendship. In February 1959 Murdoch herself recorded in her journal her romantic fascination with a female colleague at St Anne’s. Again, sexual imbroglios were to be at the centre of A Severed Head (1961). In a kind of contemporary Restoration comedy, six affluent and educated characters combine and recombine sexually in almost every possible heterosexual permutation, including incest, and are stirred by homosexual undercurrents (although it can slightly offend one’s sense of symmetry that not every hypothetical coupling takes place). The Times reviewer of the later dramatization of the book used another phrase which re-echoes through criticism of the novels: a ‘sexual square dance’.26 The New York Times reviewer cautioned: ‘I don’t
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
Triangles and Polygons
think she was half so serious about it all as impressionable readers may be led to believe.’27 In a letter to Norah Smallwood, however, Murdoch suggests otherwise: ‘I have weird feelings about this book and can’t be objective about it.’28 The disappointment many readers felt at the conventionality of the plot of The Sandcastle after the exuberance and invention of Under the Net and The Flight from the Enchanter had been dispelled by the satisfactions of The Bell, a novel of ideas embodied in people and places, free from numinous gypsies and magnetic enchanters. It appears to eschew experimentalism and offers the familiar seductions of realism: one can believe in the characters and care what happens to them. By contrast, A Severed Head is highly patterned and the characters, falling passionately in love again and again throughout the novel, seem strangely heartless. The narrator, Martin LynchGibbon, a wine merchant and amateur military historian, loves his beautiful older wife, Antonia, and his young mistress, Georgie, a lecturer at London University. Antonia announces that she is going to leave him for her psychoanalyst, Palmer Anderson, to whom Martin is himself attracted. Martin falls in love suddenly and violently with Palmer’s sister, Honor Klein, a Cambridge anthropologist, whom he at first thoroughly disliked. Finally (or for the time being?) Antonia is with Martin’s sculptor brother Alexander, who always used to steal his girlfriends, Georgie with Palmer and Martin (‘You must take your chance!’ ‘So must you, my dear!’) with Honor.29 Since all the characters act on their desires, there is a great deal of movement. The Lynch-Gibbons’ exquisite possessions shift from place to place with each change of feeling. Crucial meetings, partings and denouements take place at a station and an airport. Martin becomes so disoriented that he almost loses his sense of time. The volatility of relationships seems to herald the permissiveness of the 1960s, enabled or encouraged by the advent of the contraceptive pill and easier divorce laws. The novel can be read as a satire on the ‘best’ of contemporary society. Between them, the cast represent the intelligentsia, scholarship, psychology, art and cultivated leisure. Yet their talents and culture promote rather than prevent self-seeking and self-deceiving hedonism. The characters themselves might say ‘why not?’. There are no children to be damaged and everyone else behaves the same way. Occasionally the novel invites a moral assessment. Martin envies his artist brother for having
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
50 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
51
‘a technique for discovering more about what is real. “So have you” said Alexander, “It is called morality”. I laughed. “Rusted through lack of practice”’ (p. 43). But when Honor Klein asks Martin whether Antonia and Palmer are doing the right thing and he enquires, ‘Do you mean morally?’, she is close to scorn: ‘No, not morally’ (p. 63). Honor is presented as a wise woman whose understanding goes deeper than that of Freud and Christian moralists. In later novels Murdoch quotes or alludes to the maxim ‘All is permitted’, Dostoevsky’s nightmarish summation of moral breakdown if God is dead. This novel, for all its comic and cultured surface, is apocalyptic. Like The Time of the Angels, a vision of demonism after the loss of faith, it takes place largely in half-light or darkness. Unlike The Sandcastle and The Bell, A Severed Head does not present moral conflict in terms of generally accepted ethical views which individuals consider, query, modify, respect or reject on the evidence of their own reason, experience, delusions and desires. It attempts, with ironic elegance, to expose the fragility of civilization and the superficiality of its understanding. Palmer’s confidence that ‘We are civilized people [. . .] [who] must try to be very lucid and very honest’ (p. 28) is soon discredited. Psychoanalysis is only one of various beliefs and mythologies competing in the novel. In January 1959, Harold Solomon, an Oxford postgraduate, committed suicide by gassing himself after he had been undergoing psychoanalysis. Murdoch’s journals reveal that she was deeply affected by his death and, in addition, her entries about psychoanalysis become less favourable. She seems to be experimenting with how the novel form itself could provide a valid and less dangerous place for a more objective meditation on the inner life. The novel begins just before Christmas, but on New Year’s Eve, Palmer and Antonia go to Götterdämmerung,30 observing the death rather than the birth of gods. Despite Palmer’s advocacy of the lucid and the civilized at the beginning of the novel, he later looks to Martin like ‘some half-remembered picture of Dionysus’ (p. 165), the god of frenzy and intoxication. Martin, a wine-dealer, is himself a servant of Dionysus. As military historian he is also, from a safe distance, a servant of Mars. He describes Antonia’s personal faith as less her ‘vestigial Christianity’ than a ‘metaphysic of the drawing room’ (p. 17). Honor arrives in a London fog at Liverpool Street Station, which smells of ‘sulphur and brimstone’ (p. 53) and
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
Triangles and Polygons
reminds Martin of the Inferno. Half-Jewish, she seems to him like the Ark of the Covenant. She is also an expert in Japanese swordsmanship and says that in Martin’s eyes she is a ‘severed head such as primitive tribes and old alchemists used to use’, a ‘terrible object of fascination’ which might be primed to ‘utter prophecies’ (p. 182). Alexander explains this symbol in Freudian terms as ‘the female genitals, feared and desired’, but this is surely a reductive view of its ambiguity (p. 44). The severed head suggests a violent separation of the brain from the body. Are the characters in the novel chattering severed heads or instinctual creatures driven by primordial urges? Martin’s surname Lynch-Gibbon is as double-edged as the samurai sword: does its owner want to sever himself from his evolutionary past and lynch the gibbon or assert the claims of passion against the reason of the Enlightenment and lynch Gibbon? Edward Gibbon’s progressive eighteenth century ended in an orgy of head-severing, a Revolution to inaugurate an age of reason which escalated into a state-sanctioned lynch mob. The novel continually suggests deeper and darker explanations for the erotic whirligig of the ‘civilized’ characters. The psychological account is plausible but inadequate. Palmer asserts that ‘mechanical models’ explain the psyche best (p. 31). Driven by unconscious compulsions, Martin, his older wife and the analyst father-figure form a classic Oedipal triangle; Martin dreams of incest and Palmer and Honor practise it; Martin and Alexander are sibling rivals with a history of wanting the same women. Such textbook Freudian patterns are now too familiar to be very disturbing. Martin experiences a more profound catabasis. He literally descends into a cellar to his crucial unexpected revelatory encounter with Honor Klein. Honor, the most controlled and authoritative character, seems like a priestess of dark gods, aware of violence and unreason beneath the thin polished surface of the urbanity of the others. Afterwards, Martin writes three versions of a letter to her, each less courteous and more direct than the last (‘Dear Dr Klein’, ‘Dear Honor Klein’, ‘Dear Honor’), and restrains himself with difficulty from composing a fourth. These recensions, a device employed in other novels, seem like a microcosm of A Severed Head, in which Martin is forced to confront himself at ever deeper levels. Early in the novel he says ‘It was like being flayed’ (p. 33), a brief allusion to a myth central to Murdoch’s thought, the flaying of the satyr Marsyas by Apollo, in neo-Platonic exegesis an allegory of
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
52 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
53
the agonizing discipline and liberation of the spirit. But the experience of reading the novel should be considerably more devastating than it is. It works far better as satirical comedy than as an exploration of an atheist’s dark night of the soul. Its schematic clarity is formally satisfying, its gestures towards unfathomable mysteries less so. The incongruity between the two is more ironic than revelatory. An Unofficial Rose, Murdoch’s sixth novel, was begun in the autumn of 1960. By now Murdoch’s relationship with a female Oxford don was causing anxiety. She records her despair after their meeting in a pub after her class in November 1961. An Unofficial Rose deals with the loves of three generations and includes a lesbian relationship. The central couple of the middle generation are Ann and Randall Peronett, the ‘saint’ and ‘artist’ of this novel, through whom Murdoch presents one of her central ideas, that goodness is drab and unattractive. The dangerous seductions of the imagination have been vividly exposed in earlier novels, but the negative face of virtue has not. Ann is graceless and unattractive, at least to her husband. They own and manage a rose garden. Ann provides most of the work and Randall a creative genius for horticulture, though he is making a dubious attempt to re-create himself as a writer. He sees Ann as lacking structure, formless, like ‘a bloody dogrose’ destroying his imagination. (‘If you mean Ann is unselfish’ interprets his father.31) Ann tries to live by the principles of her Christian faith and not imagine Randall’s infidelity or, while she is married to him, an alternative future with Felix Meecham, whom she loves and who loves her. Randall, who feels no such scruples, is in love with Lindsay, the beautiful and mercenary companion of the elderly novelist, Emma Sands, with whom his father, Hugh, had once been in love. Hugh, however, had stayed with his wife. The novel opens with her funeral and he now feels free to consider Emma again. Randall leaves Ann, who, despite her misery, begins to feel free to consider Felix. His sister Mildred, companionably married to a homosexual, feels free to consider Hugh. In the youngest generation, the Peronetts’ nephew Penn, visiting from Australia and baffled by the hostilities and reserve of the English family, falls in love with their spiteful daughter Miranda. She has secretly worshipped Felix all her life and succeeds in sabotaging his relationship with Ann. Most of these loves end in disappointment, raising the question of how free any of the characters are to exercise their newfound sense
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
Triangles and Polygons
of freedom. Hugh and Ann, who have been loyal to their marriages, are not given a second chance by death or desertion. The unscrupulous are not much more successful. Randall’s love for Lindsay seems likely to end in disillusionment. Miranda has prevented her mother marrying Felix, but he will now disappear to marry a girlfriend in India. Both Randall and Hugh are dismayed to realize that his affair with Lindsay has initially been willed by Emma. Emma’s final irony is to reveal that she is fatally ill and, had Lindsay stayed with her, would have left the young woman all her money. As in The Sandcastle, the influence of Henry James is pervasive.32 This influence or resemblance can be seen throughout their fiction. (What are Rowland Mallett and Roderick Hudson but the saint and the artist?) In An Unofficial Rose, as in many of James’s novels, the choice of virtue or vice proves equally unfulfilling and the wasted life is a major theme. Hugh admits to Randall that he wishes he had left his wife for Emma. Now it may be (and is) too late. But he can, like some of James’s characters (Rowland Mallett and Ralph Touchett), find vicarious satisfaction in financing another person to live for him or enact his own desires. And (again, how Jamesian) a work of art is crucial to this design, to be traded for love or the hope of love. Randall proposes that Hugh should sell his beloved Tintoretto drawing of Susanna and the Elders (another story of thwarted desire) so that he can buy Lindsay with the proceeds. She will not accept him without money: ‘No dough, no go’ (p. 125). (Kate Croy would not express herself so crudely.) The ripples of calculation spread outward. Hugh, at first shocked and appalled by Randall’s request, does sell the Tintoretto and his motives are not entirely disinterested. Like Rowland in Roderick Hudson or Ralph in The Portrait of a Lady, he can finance his son to do what he could not do himself, to live for him. And perhaps he can still live himself. If Randall takes Lindsay away, he will create a gap in Emma’s life which Hugh can fill (in the event, Emma briskly provides herself with another young female companion). When, quite unconscious of her feelings for him, Hugh appeals to Mildred for advice, she finds herself in a Jamesian kind of dilemma on the sale of the Tintoretto. If Hugh keeps it, Lindsay will stay with Emma, leaving Hugh available for Mildred. If he sells it, Randall will desert Ann, leaving her available for Mildred’s brother Felix. The Jamesian theme of vicarious living is also expressed through deaths, both literal and metaphorical. There is an exchange
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
54 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
55
of vitality such as the narrator of The Sacred Fount obsessively perceives in all the couples around him. Hugh feels revivified by his dead wife: ‘Already he felt, from her death obscurely more alive. She fed him’ (p. 49). On receiving the money, Randall ‘felt as if he had killed his father. The sensation was not unsatisfactory. He was himself the more increased’ (p. 168). The boundaries of conscious awareness or ‘consciousness’, Murdoch said, ‘are hazy’ and some of these outer states are ‘more easily suggested by novelists and poets than described by philosophers’ (MGM, p. 196). The desire to emulate the way that James constructed metaphors for the quality of consciousness of characters produced what some critics judged to be another unsatisfactory novel. In her Jamesian reliance on the metaphorical use of a painting to illustrate inner consciousness and make a moral point, the novel fell short of its mark.33 As a student she wanted to become either a Renaissance art historian or a painter and felt she would have been ‘a moderate painter if [she] had given [her] life to it’.34 But after her work with UNRRA and meeting Sartre in Paris, she decided to take up philosophy instead. Murdoch’s literary, philosophical and artistic interests, however, always overlapped. Her passion for painting spills over into the novels throughout and she upholds the tradition of generations of writers who have drawn on painting for inspiration and exploited painterly devices to expand meaning and enrich form. She said that ‘painting often serves as a kind of explanatory metaphor for the other arts’ (EM, p. 243). The fictitious drawing of Tintoretto’s Susannah Bathing is used to the same ends that James had used the image of the pagoda in The Golden Bowl: as an explanatory metaphor in the form of an image.35 Randall’s and Hugh’s obsessions with Lindsay Rimmer and Emma Sands respectively are conveyed to the reader by proxy, as the psychology of obsession is explored by means of the psychology of the painting rather than a more conventional narration. The painting bears the weight of illustration as the tightly woven curls and Medusa-like coils of Susannah’s golden hair are echoed in descriptions of Lindsay, who also has ‘plaits of hair, with the docility of gold, beaten into a close chain around her head’ (p. 62) and Emma, who has ‘honeyed wit’, hands ‘golden in the sunshine’ and like Susannah the ability to ‘enslave’ (p. 89). Murdoch’s ‘play’ with the painting is audacious, bold and detailed, entwined crucially and extensively into the story
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
Triangles and Polygons
to illustrate its moral centre. For example, when Hugh confesses his obsession with Emma to the wounded Mildred, he paces before the Tintoretto and Murdoch mischievously makes reference to his bald head. As he faces the Tintoretto and ‘threw his tonsured head back’, he becomes the missing figure from the fictional Tintoretto drawing in the novel who appears in the actual painting by Tintoretto. Hugh and the elder become synonymous and he is seen as a silly and deluded man. Mildred on the other hand emerges as the novel’s good person as, in a valiant act of renunciation, she advises Hugh to sell the painting because she realizes it will make him happy. Seeing Hugh truthfully, she refuses to transform reality into illusion, renounces what she desires and is rewarded in the novel by finally winning Hugh for herself. A.S. Byatt was one of the critics who complained about the book, in particular the perfunctory nature of Randall’s character. She felt it to be without depth, as was the nature of his relationship with Lindsay. She found the writing ‘pretentious’ and suggested that a psychological exploration of Randall’s feelings executed with love on Murdoch’s part would have turned this novel into a good one.36 Of course, if Randall’s character is understood in the light of the Tintoretto painting, it offers the emotional and intellectual analysis that the novel fails to provide by more conventional means. The technique may not provide the realism necessary to make the book successful, but it does enable a deeper understanding of both Randall and Hugh – and Murdoch’s narrative technique. The eight years since the publication of Murdoch’s first novel had seen huge successes with her more conventional realist novels but critical unease with, and lack of understanding about, her more experimental novels. Critics ignored the fact that Murdoch had been exposed to the new internationalism of form and perspective in the novel in Paris after the War and that these European influences inevitably led to her experimenting with literary form. To Brian Magee she said: ‘literature, like other arts, involves exploration’ (EM, p. 11). In Metaphysics as a Guide to Morals she expresses the idea that ‘of course, art changes and changes mysteriously, in its unspoken relation with the zeitgeist. Many artists find they cannot do traditional things and must do new things and this is proper to the continued life of art. But this change, this interweaving of old and new is subtle and various, and each artist must find his own way’ (MGM, p. 207).37
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
56 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
57
In the light of such views, it seems odd that she marginalized her experimentation in the many interviews where she aligned herself predominantly with the English Realist tradition. In her next book she was to experiment formally again, this time with an established genre that she had not used before, the Gothic, and her location was to change. For the next two novels, The Unicorn (1963) and The Red and the Green (1965), Murdoch was to return to her roots, Ireland, for her settings, although she had already experimented with a Dublin setting in a very early short story, ‘Something Special’, which was written in the early 1950s. The short story had been published by Macmillan in an anthology, Winter’s Tales, in 1957, and in a small volume in Helsinki, Four Poems and A Story, but was not published as a single volume until 1999, after her death in that year.
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
Triangles and Polygons
Ireland ‘Something Special’ (1999), The Unicorn (1963) and The Red and the Green (1965)
Biographical information on Iris Murdoch usually begins with the fact that she was born in Dublin. She presented – and to some extent misrepresented – herself as Anglo-Irish. Murdoch was indeed born in Dublin, but her claim that she spent her first year or two there was exaggerated. Her father gave a London address on her birth certificate and the family settled permanently in London when she was a baby. Her ancestry on both sides was Irish and both her parents grew up in Ireland. However, her talking of Ireland as ‘my poor native land’ and her proud declaration that ‘of course, I’m not English, I’m Irish’1 might suggest a youth spent in Ireland apart from her time at boarding school and university. In ‘The Irish – Are They Human?’, an amusing undergraduate article written for the student newspaper Cherwell, she purports to speak as ‘we Irish’.2 Her ‘Irishness’ is a question and a problem that has engaged Murdoch scholars. The first chapter of Conradi’s biography is entitled ‘You ask how Irish she is?’ and provides a detailed account of her forebears and family. A.N. Wilson calls a chapter in his memoir ‘Considers herself Irish’ and writes, ‘when I came to attempt my biography of IM, it was over the Irish question that we began to come unstuck’.3 Her nationality was evidently a sensitive area.4 Wilson quotes The Philosopher’s Pupil, where ‘someone says, “you’re just pretend Irish”, only to receive the reply, “all Irish are pretend Irish”’. Wilson comments, ‘this isn’t true. We all know that most Irish are real Irish’ (IMKH, p. 120), implying that Murdoch, ‘pretend Irish’ herself, denied a genuine distinction in favour of an overall myth of self-construction. Her descriptions of her origins show ‘a willingness to mythologize’ (IMAL, p. 26) or are ‘a little voulu’ (IMKH, p. 118). 58
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
4
59
The connotations of ‘Anglo-Irish’, recalling the Ascendancy, great houses and aristocracy, seem misleading to both Conradi and Wilson, though Conradi traces Murdoch’s mother’s family back to the seventeenth-century owners of an estate dissipated in the nineteenth century and finds ‘the phenomenon of downstart Anglo-Irish gentry […] familiar’ (IMAL, p. 18). He recalls Murdoch, the year before her death from Alzheimer’s, saying, ‘Who am I? Well I’m Irish anyway, that’s something’ (IMAL, p. 28). That sense of an Irish identity remained, when so much else was lost. A sense of identity is a psychological fact, irrespective of passports, maternity wards and addresses. In particular, it can persist through the diaspora and descendants of people persecuted, vilified or displaced. Jewishness is one impressive example. An early passage in Nuns and Soldiers lengthily considers the ‘Polishness’ of a character born in England to expatriate Polish parents. Many Americans will proudly describe themselves as Irish (or English or Dutch or French) when their forebears migrated centuries ago and they have never set foot in their ancestral country. Conradi’s analogy, ‘Iris had as valid a claim to call herself Irish as most North Americans have to call themselves American, generally after a shorter time on that continent’ (IMAL, p. 24), seems to get it the wrong way round. Wilson’s statement that she was a tiny babe when she left Dublin and only returned to Dublin Bay for two-week summer holidays with cousins minimizes the powerful imaginative effect of childhood holidays, particularly holidays always spent in the same place. Such experiences inspired Proust to write À la Recherche du Temps Perdu, Woolf to write To the Lighthouse and L.P. Hartley to write The Go-Between. Two of Murdoch’s first-person narrators are Irish by descent but sound dismissive about it. Jake, in Under the Net, says ‘my name is James Donaghue, but you needn’t bother about that, as I was in Dublin only once, on a whiskey blind, and saw daylight only twice, when they let me out of Store Street police station, and then when Finn put me on the boat for Holyhead’.5 Martin Lynch-Gibbon, in A Severed Head, comes from an Anglo-Irish family on his father’s side: ‘I have never lived in Ireland, though I retain a sentimental sense of connection with that poor bitch of a country.’6 Martin’s relation to Ireland is similar to Murdoch’s, but she would not express it thus. These are the characteristic tones of these narrators early in their narratives: Jake’s raffish detachment announcing the rolling stone,
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
Ireland
Martin’s patronizing detachment which is masked as attachment. Jake’s companion, Finn, is a lapsed Catholic who keeps saying he will go back to Ireland, a country with religion, and finally surprises Jake by doing so. Patrick Fenman, in A Message to the Planet, ‘a penniless poet from Ireland whose aim, successfully achieved, was to become a penniless poet in Soho’,7 is in fact a stage Irishman, alcoholic, superstitious and wavering about his rejected Catholicism. Beautiful Joe in Henry and Cato, though scarily powerful, is something of a stage figure too. He is kin to the ex-Catholic thug Pinkie in Brighton Rock. Joe is an unemployed teenage crook from an Irish immigrant family in London, a ‘cheerfully lapsed’ Catholic fascinated by guns and knives, living in fantasies of becoming a pop star or ‘going to Belfast to kill those Protestant shits’8 and is drawn to tease, torment and terrorize the priest, Cato. When Cato visits Joe’s mother, he finds her battered, drinking and filled with hatred for all her sons named after saints Dominic, Francis, Patrick, Benedict and Damien, Joe’s elder brothers are in prison, dead from drugs, pimping or vanished. ‘Fuck off’, she says when Cato speaks to her of Christ and the Church (p. 164). These characters range from the nominally Irish to nearstereotypes. Except for the Irish novels, The Unicorn and The Red and the Green, all of Murdoch’s Irish characters live in England, though a few return to Ireland, and are former or non-Catholics. A 1955 dust-jacket to Under the Net confides, ‘I should like to write about Ireland – but I think I should find it very difficult not to be, in some way, absurdly emotional about it’.9 ‘Something Special’, a short story probably written in 1954, is anything but ‘absurdly emotional’. It is the only short story Murdoch wrote for publication and appeared only in a 1950s anthology until it was rediscovered and published by Chatto after her death in 1999.10 Set in Dublin, it depicts a dull and unromantic city. It recalls Joyce’s The Dubliners with its narrow lives, vague yearnings and ghastly evenings out. Yvonne, a trivial and irritable girl, lives in real poverty above a shop and shares a bed with her mother. Her family urge her to marry Sam, a kind and sensitive Jewish boy who seems a good catch, but Yvonne objects that she wants ‘something special’. Having had her head turned by women’s magazines, romantic novels and a brief fling with an Englishman who brought her flowers and sang to her, she does not appreciate or care for Sam. The working man’s Dublin is at the heart of the story and is evocatively rendered as Yvonne and Sam head into town. Sam wants to
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
60 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
61
watch the mail boat go out and they walk over O’Connell Bridge onto the quays where the Liffey flows ‘oily and glistening, as black as Guinness, bound for Dublin Bay’ (p. 22). Bored, Yvonne lures Sam to Kimball’s, where she refuses to drink in the new ‘saloon lounge’ because it is as ‘quiet as a Church’ and insists on going down to the rowdy bar where ‘nice’ ladies never go. A drunken brawl in the bar results in Yvonne getting everything she dreams of, even the flowers and a serenade. A red rose is pushed down her dress by a brawling drunk. After they have to leave for her safety, the drunk pursues, singing and dousing her with flowers and dirt gouged out of hanging baskets. This is a savage punishment for a rather simple girl from an impoverished and confined environment with not unusual romantic dreams. The savagery is turned on readers at the end of the story when, surely believing the relationship between Yvonne and Sam is utterly unworkable, they witness Yvonne getting into bed beside her mother and languidly telling her that she will indeed marry Sam. Poor Sam. But poor Yvonne too. Yvonne is a dislikeable heroine and her romantic longings seem tawdry and pathetic, but they are poignant as well: with resignation she decides, like so many people, to settle for less than she desires. This drab small-scale abnegation of hope is a rather depressing picture of Ireland and the Irish. Two almost consecutive novels written during the next decade are set in Ireland and dramatize large-scale romantic longings for heroism, sacrifice and martyrdom. The Unicorn (1963), a contemporary but timeless story, takes place in a mythic unidentified Ireland, and The Red and the Green, Murdoch’s only historical novel, is set in and near Dublin during the week of the Easter Rising in 1916. The Unicorn is the first of Murdoch’s experiments with the Gothic form. Avril Horner, the most recent critic to explore Murdoch’s use of the genre, suggests that she uses it in the sense that ‘modern Gothic novelists look into the human psyche and its obsessive desires, murderous impulses and dysfunctional fantasies in order to explore the origins of evil’.11 Mixing Ireland and the Gothic at this time was brave for an established literary writer. Horner notes, ‘at this time Gothic fiction was generally dismissed by academics as popular trash or as the rather puzzling underside of high Romantic art and writing’. However, she suggests that in drawing on Gothic devices and conventions, Murdoch is also calling attention to the seductive power of narrative itself:12 ‘The Unicorn certainly draws attention to itself as a literary artefact by
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
Ireland
referring to other forms of story telling, including myth, legend, the Bible, fairy tales, narrative poetry, Gothic stories and Jacobean and Shakespearean drama.’ In 1978 Murdoch was to say that she would ‘not like to be labelled as a Gothic novelist’,13 but after The Unicorn, she continued to experiment with the genre periodically throughout her oeuvre.14 The Gothic always functions in this double sense: it not only conventionally illustrates the dramatic pull and concrete effects of the desires within the unconscious mind but also alerts her readers to the equally potent and potentially dangerous power of the story itself. The Unicorn begins with the arrival of a governess who is to teach in a castle on an unnamed but obviously Irish coast. The sea is too perilous for swimming. Inland, the landscape is a negative sublime: resistant to the human, barren, dangerous, almost treeless, with treacherous bogs and invisible paths. Like the moors in Jane Eyre and Wuthering Heights, it is a terrain one might die in. This is a feudal, somewhat Yeatsian Ireland, inhabited by the upper classes and their servants, some of whom chatter in their own language. An old woman keens at the death of her son. The novel also uses its Gothic/Irish setting to frame Murdoch’s first meditation on the power of erotic enchantment, its unreality and seductiveness, and how far people themselves have the power to break its hold over them. It centres on Hannah Crean-Smith, lady of the castle and allegorical unicorn for whom the ‘governess’ has, in fact, been employed to be a companion. Seven years before Marian’s arrival, Hannah had an affair with Pip Lejour and allegedly tried to murder her husband, Peter. As in Wuthering Heights there are two contrasting houses which are the scenes of most of the action and the homes of most of the characters. The scholar, Max Lejour, Pip’s father and a wise old Platonist, lives at ‘Riders’, its name aptly suggesting the two horses of the soul in the Phaedrus, which each person must drive and control. ‘Lejour’ is also a Platonic name, recalling the prisoner who escapes from the cave into the light of day but can hardly communicate his clear vision to the captives of illusion. The two houses then symbolically represent enchantment and the possibility of clarity of vision respectively. Since Hannah’s affair, Peter, now living in New York, has kept his wife imprisoned at Gaze, with Gerald Scottow as gaoler and a whole entourage of servants supporting this status quo. Scottow is a Heathcliff-like character who began as a servant but has risen to a sinister position of power over everyone. An attempt to rescue
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
62 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
63
Hannah by one of the entourage, young Jamesie, has resulted only in his enthralment to Gerald. Everyone is enthralled in some sense to the beautiful and tragic Hannah. She attracts worshippers, such as Effingham, who knows that he is suffering from Courtly Love. Pip still gazes at Gaze through binoculars. Hannah is the lady of medieval romance, adored hopelessly from afar, trapped in a castle by an ogre and a wizard, exciting homage and literal prostrations.15 She is described as the ‘princesse lointaine’. Gaze sometimes seems like the spellbound castle of the Sleeping Beauty, with all the others frozen at their tasks. Two conflicting perspectives on Hannah are offered: on the one hand, she is a victim held against her will; on the other hand, she is a dangerous woman who wilfully allows her suffering to be romanticized by those who love her in order to enslave and thus punish them. The ambience of the novel evokes Hannah’s deadly fascination and the unhealthy claustrophobic space of erotic servitude. At the human level, all this enchantment is numbingly boring. Marian and Hannah doze over La Princesse de Clèves, smoke and drink whisky. As in a fairy tale, at the end of seven years the spell may be broken. Peter is about to return. Marian and Effingham plan another rescue which, like Jamesie’s, fails. Hannah is always seen from the outside, gazed at and gazing inwards. The centres of consciousness are Effingham, a regular visitor, and Marian. Like Lockwood in Wuthering Heights, they struggle to understand the dark history of the houses, its present consequences and its spiritual significance, and they leave at the end of the action. The love that everyone feels for Hannah is only one of many loves in the novel. Unlike the courtly lovers of medieval poetry, no one is absolutely faithful. Marian successively or simultaneously loves Geoffrey (from whom she has tried to free herself by leaving England), Hannah, Gerald, Jamesie, Effingham and Denis. Marian is loved by Hannah and approached by Violet, the grim housekeeper who is reminiscent of Mrs Danvers in du Maurier’s Rebecca. Denis, chaste, virtuous and animal-loving, loses his virginity (the custom of the country is to keep it until marriage) to Marian. Alice Lejour, Max’s daughter, loves Effingham and has tried to seduce Denis. Effingham loves Hannah but briefly decides on a more ‘realistic’ love for Alice. Pip still loves Hannah, as perhaps does Peter. Like many of Murdoch’s later novels, the plot of The Unicorn (though not its atmosphere) is easily forgotten. One can feel that
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
Ireland
too much happens to too many people and that much of it does not much matter. But the multiplicity and disposability of the relationships are vital to its meaning. Like the weird and forbidding dolmen on the heath, they are ‘seemingly pointless yet dreadfully significant’.16 All the loves and Hannah’s penitential suffering are open to question. In the Symposium, Plato describes the ascent of the soul from human love, from the first step of the love for one body to the contemplation of the Ideas. But in Murdoch’s erotology, love may be provisional rather than absolute and the lover can go down the steps as well as up. Love can be an approach to a selfless valuing of another or a self-regarding delusion and projection. Effingham’s adoration of Hannah may be the indulgence of feeling without the danger of action, but Max himself proposes an idealistic definition of ‘Courtly Love’: ‘because beauty is a spiritual thing it commands worship rather than arousing desire’ (p. 97). Close to death as he sinks into the bog, Effingham realises that the self is the barrier to love and its loss enables the love of everything else. But the vision fades after his rescue by Denis, almost a Christ-like figure, as he appears out of the gloom with a wild donkey. Hannah may also be taken as a Christfigure, a scapegoat whose suffering is inspiring and redemptive (however, it is the prospect of death, rather than his own or Hannah’s suffering, that produces Effingham’s moment of vision, the most powerful experience in the novel). ‘Crean-Smith’ is an anagram of ‘Christ name’ and the unicorn is a symbol of Christ. Max describes her as ‘our image of the significance of suffering’ (p. 98) but cautions that sacred as well as profane love may deal in illusion: ‘she may be just a sort of enchantress, a Circe, a spiritual Penelope keeping her suitors spellbound and enslaved’ (p. 99). Hannah’s dangerous complicity in the way she enchants others is made clear. Such descriptions, resonating through the novel, may suggest that the author herself is in thrall to a self-indulgent romanticism, but their tenor is really the opposite. The insistence of the symbolism points to the human need to construct or impose meaning and significance. Throughout the novel, Hannah herself is disturbed by others’ interpretations of her, imprisoned in their images as much as in Gaze Castle. The novel ends with the death of Peter, drowned by Denis, while Hannah and Pip commit suicide, indicating the real possibility for tragedy in erotic servitude. Hannah is destroyed in effect by the weight of meanings in her story, and Murdoch, by implication, hints
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
64 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
65
at the magical power of art itself, which seduces both its creator and its client. But life goes on at Riders and Marian survives. After loving so many people and witnessing the Gothic horrors set in motion by faithlessness and jealousy, she has recovered from the relationship she came to Gaze to escape and she leaves on a cheerful, sensible, everyday note: ‘She would dance at Geoffrey’s wedding’ (p. 264). By contrast with the timeless, unplaced, fictive quality of The Unicorn, The Red and the Green confines itself largely to realism, providing detailed and specific accounts of Dublin in the week leading up to the Easter Rising in 1916, when the Irish Volunteer Army brought to fruition its insurrection against English rule in Ireland. It draws on both memory and research. Murdoch said she ‘tried to get everything right – what day a particular article was published on, what day and how they changed the plan for the insurrection, and what the English were doing’.17 The action proceeds day by day towards the fatal Easter Monday, houses are placed in actual streets (including Blessington Street, where Murdoch was born, and Eccles Street, home of Joyce’s Leopold Bloom), the Republican groups and splinter groups are carefully distinguished, and newspaper articles are considered. In a paragraph reminiscent of Ulysses, Barney notes advertisement slogans and, in discomfort, a couple of pages later, recalls irrelevantly ‘Zam-buk the only cure’.18 The book is also specific to saturation point about family relationships. As in Middlemarch, almost everyone is related to everyone else, emphasizing the peculiar agony of a divided society close to civil war. Most of the characters are connected by blood or marriage and even on a second or third reading it is difficult to remember their exact relationships.19 These complex family structures, labelled ‘les cousins et les tantes’ in Nuns and Soldiers,20 are to be a recurring problem in Murdoch’s later novels. Such complex relationships echo the complexity of the dilemmas of Irish politics and emphasize their human cost, but we may, however, recognize within them some characters as stock types in her fiction. There is the enchanter, Pat Dumay, whose fascination compels most of the women and some of the men, and the siren, Millie, another lady with a castle, desired by all the men. It is a weakness of the novel that neither character seems that irresistibly seductive. There is the failed would-be priest and aspiring writer, Barney, whose unconsummated marriage to the drab, virtuous, ‘formless’ Kathleen again sketches the artist/saint opposition.
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
Ireland
Pat Dumay’s dedication to the Irish cause constitutes his power and his limitations. Yeats’s poem ‘Easter 1916’ pervades the novel to emphasize one of its main themes and warns, ‘Too long a sacrifice/ Can make a stone of the heart’. Pat’s absolute need to fight, and perhaps die, for Ireland verges on the abstract: a defining act of will. He cares for nothing else, except his younger, and even more fanatical, brother Cathal and sees this love as the flaw in his armour. In contrast to most of the other characters, Pat is totally assured of his identity as Irish. Hilda Spear notes, however, that the novel is ‘less successful in making readers believe in the depth of emotion that ties Pat to Ireland and to Catholicism than in convincing us of his deep affection for [...] Cathal’.21 Pat’s cousin, the Englishman Andrew Chase-White, has a background similar to Murdoch’s, which creates an ambiguity: ‘Andrew’s family were Anglo-Irish, but he had never lived in Ireland, although he had spent most of his childhood holidays there’ (p. 10). He ‘had grown up in England and more especially in London, and felt himself unreflectively to be English, although equally unreflectively he normally announced himself as Irish’ (p. 10). He becomes a cavalry officer in King Edward’s Horse (Murdoch’s father’s regiment in the First World War) out of a need to emulate his Irish cousins (‘a race of young horsemen, passing him by’ [p. 12]), although he hates and fears horses. Like millions of other young men who served in that War, he is doomed. Yeats’s epitaph for himself concludes: ‘Horseman, pass by!’22 When Andrew dreams of owning a car after the War, ‘a rendezvous in the future with a Vauxhall Prince Henry’ (p. 34) (a divided Prince Hal contrasting with Pat’s mounted Hotspur? [p. 89]), we know that his rendezvous will be, like Yeats’s Irish airman’s, with death. The dark allusions to the Great War also touch the equally doomed Pat, who refuses to serve in it. He ‘cursed them all [Connolly’s engineers] for incompetent oafs’ (p. 97) like Siegfried Sassoon: ‘Now the soldiers he smiled at are most of ’em dead/And we’re cursing his staff for incompetent swine’ (‘The General’). Andrew’s unrequited love for his cousin, Frances, is one of the network of love entanglements that interweave and complicate the political affiliations within the book. ‘Red’ and ‘green’ are not the absolutes and opposites Pat and Cathal assert. Red is associated with the British army, the ‘redcoats’, and green is the national colour of Ireland. Red also traditionally symbolizes blood and green symbolizes nature or growth. The Republicans see Ireland
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
66 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
67
and England as opposites and trust that bloodshed will lead to rebirth. But many points of view and shades of opinion are represented in the novel. Most of the main characters are not purely Irish or English. Like Andrew, some come from England. His mother, Hilda, and her brother, Barney, were brought up in London. Barney, partly under the spell of childhood holidays in Ireland, moved there after Cambridge. Hilda has recently moved to Ireland to escape the Zeppelins. Christopher Bellman, the father of Frances, whom Andrew assumes he will marry, is ‘English, though Irish by adoption through his wife’, an Irish ‘enthusiast’, though he keeps ‘aloof from all politics and controversy’ (p. 28), and undertakes research on Irish antiquities. His is one of the most judicious and impartial voices in the many discussions of Irish politics. But, suddenly and unexpectedly, he tries to join the rebels in the Post Office and is killed by a bullet, from which side nobody knows. Most of the characters are in some sense ‘Anglo-Irish’ and thus, in some sense, Protestant. But in several generations there have been converts to Catholicism, including Kathleen and both her husbands, Brian Dumay and Barney. Pat and Cathal, the children of the first marriage, are therefore cradle Catholics, though their religion seems more a matter of national identity than spiritual conviction. Few of the characters have much conviction. Andrew hears the ‘horrible sounds’ of an evangelical hymn such as Murdoch learned during her Irish holidays and reflects that, if pressed, he would have to choose that ‘appalling vulgarity’ (p. 57) rather than the other, Catholicism. However, religion is a vital force in the individual (though not the shared) lives of Kathleen and Barney, through whom the unbelieving author expresses some of her most deeply felt religious views. The devout and dowdy Kathleen, exhausted by her charitable work, is (in her role as a successor to Ann Peronett in An Unofficial Rose [1962]) condemned by her husband as ‘formless’.23 But this argues a commitment to virtuous action rather than an egotistic absorption in herself. Barney Drumm, like Murdoch, was born a Protestant and was brought up in London but converts to Catholicism and trains for the priesthood. Corrupted by the emotionally voracious Millie and thus unable to become a priest, he prefers self to saints. He has abandoned a book on Irish saints for ‘the more interesting task of self-analysis’ and is writing a memoir. He knows that the work is self-exculpating and untruthful and on Good Friday, after an awareness of God’s presence at Tenebrae, resolves (temporarily) to give up the memoir,
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
Ireland
stop seeing Millie (the cause of his disgrace and departure from the seminary) and confess both infidelities to Kathleen. However (in a scene reminiscent of Jake and Hugo’s hospital conversation in Under the Net), when he tells Kathleen that he is writing a memoir, she merely replies, ‘Sure, why shouldn’t you?’ (p. 223) and says in a matter-of-fact way that she knows he sees Millie. The ‘saint’ frustrates the ‘artist’s’ desire for drama. At the Easter Mass, Barney, who has always found the resurrection rather a disappointment, the risen absent Christ replacing the ‘recognizable victim’ (p. 262), has an insight central to Murdoch’s spirituality. His meditations on the human, suffering Christ have been a kind of self-indulgence. ‘What was required of him was something which lay outside the deeply worked pattern of suffering, the plain possibility of change without drama and even without punishment [. . .] Absence not pain would be the rite of his salvation’ (p. 233). In The Unicorn, when Effingham thinks he is about to drown in the bog, his vision of his impending death and non-being enables a love of all being. Death rather than suffering is ‘salvation’ in Murdoch’s theology – or would be if the realization of death did not rule out a self to be saved. Barney experiences this realization within the pattern of Christianity, but it is an understanding more emphasized in Buddhism. During the last chapters that are set before the Rising, the English and the Irish confront each other in the cousins Andrew and Pat. Pat succeeds in disabling Andrew and Cathal from fighting on their different sides by imprisoning and handcuffing them together, an image of how so many characters are ‘united in the strife that divided them’. He could not have disarmed Andrew without Millie’s help, a whispered revelation – or allegation – of incest in his family, which she will reveal if he does not comply.24 When Frances and her father discover the captives, she explodes in grief and rage at Andrew: ‘Have you forgotten you’re an Army officer? [. . .] you should have shot him as a traitor! You’ve betrayed your King and country. You’ve dishonoured your uniform [. . .] You did it because you were afraid of Pat. You’ve always been afraid of Pat’ (p. 303). Does Frances, who has unexpectedly turned down Andrew’s proposal, condemn him as a coward before his heroic cousin? Is she distraught because he might have prevented the Rising and did not? Does she think that ‘honour’ demands loyalty to one’s own side in any circumstances? The final section modifies and complicates her outburst.
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
68 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
69
The novel concludes with an Epilogue, set in England in 1938, in the home of Frances and her English husband. There is civil war in Spain and the threat of another world war. Frances is full of fear for her son, whose best friend has joined the International Brigade to fight in Spain. Her husband is dismissive about Ireland, the Irish and ‘the nineteen sixteen nonsense [which] made no sense at all’ (p. 316). When he leaves for work, Frances and her son agree that ‘nineteen sixteen was wonderful’, though she doesn’t ‘quite see what good it did’ (p. 316). Her son’s enthusiasm for freedom fighting reminds her of Cathal Dumay. He questions her about the characters involved and receives a roll-call of the dead: her father and Pat Dumay in 1916, Cathal in the civil war of 1921, Andrew, winning an M.C. at Passchendaele in 1917. She describes them as ‘inconceivably brave men’ (p. 318). She reveals, for the first time in the novel, that she was in love with Pat Dumay. She corrects her son’s description of Andrew: ‘He wasn’t English, he was Irish’ (p. 318), mysteriously contradicting her furious Easter 1916 tirade. The Epilogue has been praised and condemned. ‘J.R’ of MetroGoldwyn-Mayer wrote ‘how beautiful and moving is that last elegiac chapter set twenty-five years later. I cannot recall a better done chapter of [its] kind’.25 But both Elizabeth Dipple and Donna Gerstenburger find it a romanticizing volte-face. Dipple comments on the observation that ‘they were inconceivably brave men’ and suggests that ‘these words ring false in terms of Murdoch’s realism’.26 Gerstenburger finds the description of Andrew as Irish ‘meant to be a salute [but] wholly gratuitous’, though she thinks Frances’s ‘overstatement of the Irish cause [. . .] somewhat balanced by the letter she receives from Kathleen [which] speaks to the reality of the situation and implicitly balances out Frances’s uncharacteristic romanticism’.27 She concludes, ‘it is not like Murdoch as a novelist to accept romanticized absolutes about historical events or to see value in such judgments. The familiar irony and distance which have characterized the rest of this novel [. . .] are gone’ (p. 68). But does Frances speak for the author or express her own need to memorialize Andrew as ‘Irish’ and all the dead as heroes? Yeats wrote in ‘Easter 1916’ that they were ‘changed, changed utterly’.28 Here, as in the rest of the novel, a variety of viewpoints – Frances’s, Kathleen’s, Frances’s husband’s – are given, and to recognize the courage of the rebels is not to endorse their cause or condone their methods. The Epilogue is surely less a verdict on the Easter Rising than a sad but accepting recognition
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
Ireland
of the nature of memory and the passage of time. ‘Elegiac’ is the exact word for its sense of a lost and perhaps imaginary age of heroism and a humdrum present. And this strikes chords in readers who were not Irish expatriates remembering the Easter Rising in 1938. Frances’s feeling ‘that these thoughts were always with her, and that she had lived out, in those months, in those weeks, the true and entire history of her heart, and that the rest was a survival’ (p. 318) evokes that mythic power our late teens and twenties retain for many of us. The morning routine in Frances’s kitchen, Kathleen’s account of Millie’s failing health and reduced circumstances are all too convincing to the middle-aged. The Epilogue reminds one of the relatively depressing and plausible Finale to Middlemarch, introduced by the question: ‘Who can quit young lives after being long in company with them, and not desire to know what befell them in their after-years?’29 Perhaps we would rather not know, but the realism as well as the romanticism of Murdoch’s Epilogue must be recognized. The Red and the Green was the only novel Murdoch was ashamed of (IMAL, p. 465). It appeared in 1965, four years before the outbreak of violence in Northern Ireland which was to last the rest of her lifetime. She came to find the admirable even-handedness of the novel too tolerant towards the Republicans. Her sympathies were strongly with the Ulster Protestants and A.N. Wilson recalls her, strident and redfaced, sounding like Ian Paisley in arguments on the subject.30 In The Philosopher’s Pupil, written nearly 30 years after The Red and the Green, the character Emmanuel Scarlett-Taylor reflects some of Murdoch’s own anguish on the subject, though it drives him to reject rather than exaggerate his Irishness: ‘Brought up as a vague Anglican’, singing in his English school choir but loving the Latin mass and ritual, he thought ‘religion was history and history taught tolerance. Then the shooting started’.31 The description of ‘the gratuitous, untimely cause of “United Ireland”’ (p. 126) sounds as much authorial as free indirect discourse. The destruction of Belfast by the IRA and ‘Protestant murderers, as vile as their foes’ gives Emmanuel his first ‘close-up view of human wickedness’ (p. 126). The ‘changed, changed utterly’ heroism of The Red and the Green and the mythic quality of The Unicorn seem far away from the reality of bombed Belfast.
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
70 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
New Directions, Constant Themes The Italian Girl (1964), The Time of the Angels (1966), The Nice and the Good (1968) and Bruno’s Dream (1969)
Harold Wilson famously spoke of a ‘wind of change’ in 1960 and the impetus toward new directions infected Murdoch, who was looking for fresh challenges in the early years of the decade. The 1960s turned out to be politically chaotic for the country and emotionally and creatively turbulent for Murdoch. She was spreading her wings, experimenting with different genres. A 100-page cycle of poems, ‘Conversations with a Prince’, was sent to Norah Smallwood at Chatto (in 1989 they were returned) and she gave the novelist and dramatist J.B. Priestley a draft of a play based on A Severed Head. He disliked it but nonetheless rewrote it and the play opened in Bristol in April 1963. Murdoch was exultant after the opening night. In June the play opened at the Criterion Theatre in London (starring Robert Hardy, Heather Chasen and Sheila Burrell) where it was to run for over 1,000 performances.1 Reviewing the production for the Guardian, Philip Hope-Wallace attributed its lack of depth to the medium itself: ‘Miss Murdoch’s novel is post-Freud Henry James [. . .] what happens is much less important than what a lot of mixed-up people think is happening. It’s all inside their own severed heads. The fun [. . .] in reading the book was the fun of its gruesome surmise. And that quality “surmise” is just what the theatre is least good at.’2 From Under the Net onwards, interest was often expressed in filming Murdoch’s novels and in 1977 she wrote to her theatrical agent, Peggy Ramsey, ‘I’d like to see a decent film of one of those books, in any language, before I die’.3 Although there have been a number of radio and television adaptations, A Severed Head is the only novel to have been made into a film, with Claire Bloom as a cogent 71
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
5
(but too beautiful) Honor. In 1969 Murdoch attended the shooting of the scene of Honor’s arrival at Paddington and was excited by it (Paddington was used rather than Liverpool Street because in the film Honor is, like Murdoch, a don at Oxford rather than Cambridge, a detail which links character and author). But when Murdoch saw the film, she thought it ‘terrible’. Although Murdoch dedicated 1969 to writing plays, she found the process difficult and none emerged that year. Only Priestley’s rewritten dramatization of A Severed Head and an adaptation of The Italian Girl by the young playwright James Saunders came out of this decade. ‘The Italian Girl is A S[evered] H[ead] in reverse, the spell repeated backwards’, she wrote in her journal.4 The Italian Girl itself was written between The Unicorn and The Red and the Green, and is slight and formulaic. It opens with a haunting and beautiful description of the narrator’s homecoming after his mother’s death, but unfolds as a rather obvious Freudian narrative of siblings, splitting and surrogates. Like A Severed Head it is a short, closed and crystalline novel with a first-person male narrator and multiple sexual relationships and attractions between the small cast of characters. It is both a Freudian family romance and a Gothic romance. As in other Murdoch novels, there is a pair of contrasting but connected brothers, both artists, refugee siblings and finders of substitutes. Although Murdoch was an only child, siblings, with their loves, hates, complicity and rivalries, figure largely in her novels. Another recurring motif is the confrontation of two very different men, though Edmund, the narrator, feels that he and his brother Otto are in some way the same person. Edmund is an engraver, belittled by Isabel, his sister-in-law, as dealing in ‘tinification’. He is controlled, almost celibate, teetotal and vegetarian, living in London at a safe remove from his wild family and possessive mother in the north. Otto is a gross, extrovert, violent stonemason. Edmund returns for his mother’s funeral, thinking that it will be his last visit and meaning to depart as soon as possible, but he is drawn into the vortex of his family’s problems. Otto and Isabel are sleeping with (respectively) Elsa and David, another pair of siblings and Russian Jews, and their daughter Flora is pregnant by David. The desperate Isabel strips to the waist for the embarrassed Edmund and he inadvertently puts his arms round Flora. Tinification indeed, but these events lead to a terrible climax of arson and death, to a new freedom for most of the characters and to liberation and commitment
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
72 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
73
for Edmund. All this has been observed by the Italian girl, Maria, the last in a succession of Giulias, Carlottas and Gemmas, scarcely distinguished from them by Edmund but a second mother for him. At last he can see Maria for herself, leaves his family and is off to Rome with her – an ambiguous ending. The Italian Girl is the slightest of Murdoch’s fictions and she did not care whether it was published or not (IMAL, p. 460). It is the only one of her novels with chapter headings and they seem to suggest a slightly satirical second narrator, a distance between the author and her story: ‘Isabel Feeds the Fire’; ‘Edmund is Tempted’; ‘Edmund Runs to Mother’; ‘Lydia’s Sense of Humour’. Both Norah Smallwood and Marshall Best wanted Murdoch to do more work on the book but, as usual, she was resistant to editorial suggestions. The novel received some poor reviews. Elizabth Janeway described it as ‘Cold Comfort Farm rewritten during an unlikely collaboration between Henry James and D.H. Lawrence’.5 However, it was the Book Society alternative choice in September 1964 and James Saunders’s dramatization was put on at the Bristol Old Vic in 1967 and in London at the Wyndham’s Theatre in 1968. Murdoch travelled to Bristol in September 1967 for rehearsals of the play and when it opened at the Bristol Old Vic, like the novel it received very mixed reviews.6 In the early 1970s, two plays, The Three Arrows and The Servants in the Snow, emerged out of this drive towards drama and were published in a composite volume in 1973. But there were no more plays from then until The One Alone, which was broadcast on BBC Radio 3 in February 1987 and Joanna, Joanna, published in 1994.7 However, the last three novels of the 1960s seem to reflect Murdoch’s interest in drama which is in turn linked to her continuing desire for innovation in the novel form. Her enduring worries about the decline of religious belief in the West are also evident, perhaps because they were intensified by contemporary theological debates generated by John Robinson’s Honest to God, published in 1963.8 Throughout this decade, after the unconvincing experimentalism of some of the earlier writing, Murdoch re-emphasized her commitment to nineteenth-century realism, and such a stress obscured those aspects of her novels that continued to enlarge and extend it. In 1960, when she was judging the Prix Formentor, won by the Italian Carlo Emilia Gadda, she cited James’s The Golden Bowl and Tolstoy as influences on her own work. In 1964 she spoke again of her love for George Eliot, Dickens and Henry James, the only writer she claimed
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
New Directions, Constant Themes
to have influenced her. 9 In July 1966 she wrote to her PhD student at the RCA, Rachel Fenner, that she was just an old traditionalist. She was to highlight her commitment to the realist tradition again in 1966 in an interview in Books and Bookmen and in 1967 in an interview in the Listener entitled ‘Talking with a Traditionalist’. In 1968 she pointed out to W.K. Rose that in her early fiction she alternated between ‘open’ and ‘closed’ novels. The ‘open’ novels are those where there are more accidental, separate and free characters, while the ‘closed’ novels are those where the work has a stronger formal intensity and where her own ‘obsessional feeling about a novel draws it together’.10 She highlights the difficulty of reconciling the two styles and would like not to oscillate between them. She achieves a marriage between the two styles most successfully for the first time in The Nice and the Good (1968), but the other two novels which form the focus of this chapter, The Time of the Angels (1966) and Bruno’s Dream (1969), are ‘closed’, driven by her own internal passions. In later novels, where she manages to merge the two styles successfully, she creates the impression of a more traditional realism, although a close reading of these novels does not completely confirm it. In an interview with A.S. Byatt and Ronald Bryden (one of the few critics of the 1960s to appreciate her experimentalism) in the Listener in 1969,11 she equivocated her commitment to traditionalism. Now she was careful to distinguish her work from that of the nineteenthcentury realists rather than align herself with them. She said that while those writers focus on the larger society, her novels are psychologically and mythically centred. The great challenge to the writer as she saw it was to represent the unobservable inner life of characters and it is to this end that her attempts to expand the possibilities of form were directed. She most admires Shakespeare in this sense, drawing on this ability to combine mythical pattern with free characters. In May 1967 she wrote an article (which remained unpublished until it appeared in the Iris Murdoch News Letter in 1999) on her relations with her characters, where she discusses the battle between character and form at the centre of novel writing and says that sadly she always thinks that form wins through, though she would prefer it if character wrecked form. This tension between the necessity of form and the freedom of characters underlies all her work. The convoluted love-plot of A Severed Head (1961), which has intrigue and infidelity at its heart, prophetically echoes the political
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
74 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
75
scandals of the 1960s: in March 1963, the Government minister John Profumo was suspected of having jeopardized national security by sharing a lover, Christine Keeler, with a KGB agent. Profumo claimed his innocence, but was later unmasked and forced to resign. The scandal was to run and run and the infidelities in the upper echelons of British society in A Severed Head, and in the civil service in particular in The Nice and the Good, probably fuelled the popularity of Murdoch’s novels at that time. Murdoch herself was undergoing a precarious balancing act to avoid her own sexual scandal: she resigned her philosophy fellowship at St Anne’s12 partly because a romantic relationship with a female colleague was causing discomfort. Her ostensible reasons were that lecturing made her nervous and that she wanted more time to write. With her wide philosophical and literary interests, she also found the Oxford syllabus rather constrained by the examination requirements. Her move to the Royal College of Art in 1963 to teach philosophy to Art History students (‘a wilder bunch [. . .] than she had ever encountered at Oxford’)13 generated an unwise if not improper relationship with a student there. David Morgan was a quite brilliant but damaged young man to whom Murdoch initially acted as a moral guide; however, she became increasingly drawn into the sexual mêlée that characterized his life. Murdoch’s friendship with him came close to a scandal that could have damaged her career and her personal relationships. Although she continued to write philosophy as well as fiction, was married to a don and spent most of her life in or near Oxford, she did not choose to develop as primarily an ‘academic’ novelist. None of her novels was to be set exclusively in Oxford and her favourite urban location was always to be London.14 She met friends and lovers there and it was there that she undertook the more public aspects of her career, giving lectures and recording discussions and interviews for the BBC. She had, since 1960, set up a permanent London home, renting a small flat at 59 Harcourt Terrace, SW10. On returning to London to teach at the RCA, she spent part of the week at Harcourt Terrace during termtime. The London of the 1960s was of course very different from the wartime London of the 1940s: class barriers were being broken down, traditions and customs were being disregarded and the sex-obsessed bohemianism of the ‘swinging sixties’ was practised by the rebellious RCA students. Murdoch was at once ‘shocked, fascinated, delighted
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
New Directions, Constant Themes
and appalled’ (IMAL, p. 471), and this bohemian environment was to feature in the novels of the 1960s and early 1970s. Oxford figures in the novels only as a place characters are going to, leaving or revisiting, a place of expectation and memory, future or past. Toby in The Bell is spending a summer interlude at Imber before going up to Corpus. Hilary Burde destroys his lover, her unborn child and his Oxford career in a tragic accident on the road to London. The Book and the Brotherhood opens with the reunion of middle-aged friends and former students at an Oxford college Commemoration ball, but the current undergraduate career of Tamar is interrupted by her mother’s spite and envy. However, the novels feature numerous academics, schoolteachers, former and future teachers: Dave Gellman in Under the Net, Peter Saward in The Flight from the Enchanter, most of the characters in The Sandcastle, Michael and Dora in The Bell, Georgie Hands in A Severed Head, Marian and Max Lejour in The Unicorn, Nora in The Time of the Angels, Jessica in The Nice and the Good, Morgan and Julius in A Fairly Honourable Defeat, Hilary and Gunner in A Word Child, Henry Marshalson and John Forbes in Henry and Cato, Rozanov in The Philosopher’s Pupil, Jenkin and Levquist in The Book and the Brotherhood and Marcus Vallar in The Message to the Planet, among others. The Abbess in The Bell describes teaching as one of the few jobs in the modern world which can ‘readily be invested with a spiritual significance’.15 Murdoch valorizes learning, together with love and art, as a means of ‘spiritual’ progress or secular enlightenment: ‘Attention is rewarded by a knowledge of reality’ (EM, p. 373). The relationship between student and teacher is crucial in novels other than The Philosopher’s Pupil. In A Word Child, Hilary Burde’s escape from the abuse and poverty of his childhood to an academic career is enabled by the attention and generosity of his ‘wonderful schoolmaster’16 Mr Osmand, whose later suicide he might have prevented. Years later, at Oxford, his desire for his tutor’s wives results in the deaths of both women. Teaching can be less fatally unrewarding. Murdoch also dramatizes the frustrations and embarrassments of pedagogy in Mor’s evening class and Bledyard’s spiritual but unintentionally hilarious lecture in The Sandcastle. In The Philosopher’s Pupil, the philosopher is exasperated by a devoted and demanding ex-pupil. The Book and the Brotherhood and The Message to the Planet suggest the dangers of an infatuated coterie of disciples.
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
76 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
77
Murdoch continued to teach regularly for another four years. Her part-time position at the Royal College of Art required her to teach one day a week in the General Studies programme. The RCA was a small and distinguished college, including among its graduates David Hockney, Bridget Riley and Ossie Clark. But General Studies, headed by Christopher Cornford, did not fit entirely happily into this ambience. It was unpopular with most of the students and with some of the colleagues in other departments. The Coldstream and Summerson Reports had recommended that all students in higher education should reach a reasonable standard of literacy. At the RCA this was assessed by the requirement for a dissertation supervised by the Department of General Studies, which also provided lecture courses intended to widen the students’ intellectual horizons. Much later, on an interview panel at the RCA in 1977, Murdoch kept repeating, ‘the job of the Department of General Studies is to get artists to read books’ (IMAL, p. 473). But many of the recipients thought this pointless. They wanted to draw, paint and sculpt: ‘anything I thought a waste of time I just ignored. I think perhaps I did half an essay for them’;17 ‘I just managed to escape that thing of being told what books to read and take lectures on philosophy [. . .] I disdained to write a clever thesis or anything like that’.18 Memories of Murdoch’s lectures on philosophy vary. Her students perhaps had an aversion to the intellectual, dealing in the tactile. Yet while some students found the course irrelevant to them, some found it stirring and suggestive. ‘Some felt that attending [her lectures] was like eavesdropping on a soliloquy. She communed aloud with herself, frowning a trifle nervously in a corner about a philosophical problem, while her listeners overheard’ (IMAL, p. 473). Her essay topics were close to her heart and relate to the preoccupations of both her philosophical and fictional work: ‘Discuss in detail any work of literature which seems to you to throw light upon the problem of freedom’; ‘Sartre and Marcel both compare a moral act with a work of art. Discuss this comparison’; ‘Describe and criticize the “good man” as conceived by Sartre’.19 As at St Anne’s, Murdoch was very sympathetic to her students20 and she sometimes bought their paintings. Some, such as David Morgan and Rachel Fenner, became and continued to be friends. Fenner’s dissertation topic, ‘The Imagination as a Moral Tool’, was one of Murdoch’s preoccupations. She also became friends with some colleagues in the General Studies department.
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
New Directions, Constant Themes
Frederic Samson, who taught European Literature and the History of Ideas, was, like some characters in her fiction, a refugee from Nazi Germany, the ‘latest of [her] Jewish teachers’ (IMAL, p. 482). Cornford, whom she already knew, designed the dust-jackets for several of her books. Murdoch’s teaching at the RCA was informed by her own extensive knowledge of and interest in the visual arts, and she had painted herself. The link between the visual arts and the novels becomes a motif after Gainsborough’s The Painter’s Daughters Chasing a Butterfly appears in The Bell. A fictitious drawing of Susannah Bathing by Tintoretto appears in An Unofficial Rose, Bronzino’s Allegory on Venus Cupid Folly and Time mirrors the plot of The Nice and The Good and Titian’s Sacred and Profane Love is alluded to in the title of The Sacred and Profane Love Machine – to name only a few of many associations between what she termed, like James, the ‘sister’ arts.21 She had considerable sympathy with artists. When meeting, among a crowd of academics, a university wife who said ‘I’m an artist’, Murdoch replied ‘God bless you!’22 There are almost as many painters as writers in her fiction and artists inhabit her work from her early novels, years before she taught at the RCA, to her latest: Rain in The Sandcastle, Dora in The Bell, Alexander in A Severed Head, Edmund and Otto in The Italian Girl, Jessica, Tim and Daisy in Nuns and Soldiers, Jesse in The Good Apprentice, Jack and Marcus in The Message to the Planet and Moy in The Green Knight are artists. Paul in The Bell, Simon in A Fairly Honourable Defeat and Henry in Henry and Cato are art historians. Emil in The Green Knight is an art dealer. Some of the creators – Otto, Jesse and Jack – are possessed by the egotism of the ‘artist’ in Murdoch’s familiar contrast. Others (perhaps because they are less talented) are unpretentious. For all her frivolity, Dora can on occasions be very fair and clear-sighted. When her lover, Nick, says that Paul is jealous of her creative powers, she retorts briskly, ‘I haven’t any creative powers. And Paul’s terribly creative’ (p. 185). Dora is much less judgemental than most of the more intelligent educated characters who surround her and her judgement is often better because it is more instinctive. The novels contain a myriad of such references to painters and paintings, delicately enlarging her moral philosophy, hinting at the difference between good and bad art, clarifying the inner life of her characters or simply pointing outwards toward the rich texture of the world outside the benighted consciousness of the characters.
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
78 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
79
Despite the problems of the General Studies’ requirement at the RCA, an art college was a congenial as well as a challenging contrast with Murdoch’s usual academic environment. She often found the students refreshingly creative, sceptical and questioning as well as frustratingly ignorant, rebellious and unreceptive. She described them as ‘utterly different from Oxford students, they don’t accept anything on trust, they question everything [. . .] they’re wild!’ (IMAL, p. 476). She was, however, there at a time when the universities were also becoming wilder. The mythical ‘Sixties’ did not begin in 1960 but in the middle of the decade, and the sex, drugs and anarchy that startled Murdoch at the RCA were exploding at the same time in the university world. Jessica in The Nice and the Good (1968), who learned nothing about the history of painting at art school and makes the children she teaches destroy their work at the end of the lesson, is symptomatic of some of the general educational trends of the time which Murdoch deplored. Like the RCA students (‘religion means nothing to them’ [IMAL, p. 476]) Jessica is ‘entirely outside Christianity’ but her restless need for ‘artistic activity’ is ‘a spiritual hunger’.23 The first draft of The Time of the Angels was begun in April 1965 just after Murdoch had read Heidegger’s Being and Time and after, in June of that year, the United States bombed Hanoi in communist North Vietnam. Murdoch deeply disapproved of American intervention in Vietnam. In October 1964 she had visited Ireland to become the first woman to address the Philosophical Society at Trinity College Dublin, speaking on ‘Job: The Prophet of Nihilism’. The Time of the Angels is a dark novel set in a present of waning faith. It is a time of moral crisis. When Murdoch started to write novels in the 1950s, theologians were aware that, after two World Wars and the Holocaust, Christian faith would have to be redefined or reinterpreted. Her novels offer a workable ‘neo-theology’ that can be integrated into the day-to-day lives of those readers whose faith has lapsed or who feel unable to participate in conventional religious practice. Her books have much to offer to those who might be struggling to live a good life without the traditional concept of God. The Time of the Angels addresses the problem central to Murdoch’s theology: can morality survive without religion? She was born into an Irish Protestant family; ‘I could pray as soon as I could speak and I knew that God was present [. . .] I had a feeling of communing with God’ (TCHF, p. 209). Nonetheless, she consistently
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
New Directions, Constant Themes
denied the existence of a personal God, the divinity of Christ and life after death. She was suspicious of Christian dogma and iconography. Her faith was ‘removed by the image of Karl Marx’ in the 1930s and she joined the Communist Party (TCHF, p. 210). In ‘The Sovereignty of Good’ in 1970, she was to argue that ‘human life has no external point’, ‘we are transient mortal creatures subject to necessity and chance’ and ‘our destiny can be examined but it cannot be justified or totally explained. We are simply here’ (EM, p. 365).24 ‘Neo-theology’ was being popularized in 1960s Britain. John Robinson, Bishop of Woolwich, drawing on the thinking emerging from post-War Germany and German expatriates at this time, published Honest to God in 1963. It was immediately influential and controversial. Although Murdoch later described it as ‘mild tinkerings’ (MGM, p. 455), its questioning of traditional Christianity is similar to her own. Like Murdoch, Robinson argues for a demythologizing of Christian belief – the concept of God as ‘up there’ has gone and so must the concept of a deity ‘out there’ – though he accepts that these pictures have metaphorical and emotional validity. Throughout her work Murdoch presents the necessity for questioning and recreating religious and other images. Both Robinson and Murdoch are indebted to and quote the theologian Paul Tillich. Robinson’s favourite new image for God is Tillich’s, the ‘Ground of our Being’, the title of one of the chapters in Honest to God. Murdoch also uses this phrase in The Bell, the first of her novels to deal centrally with religious experience: Michael’s ‘prayer was [. . .] the surrender of himself [. . .] to the Ground of his being’ (p. 79). Murdoch refers to Tillich several times in Metaphysics as a Guide to Morals, using his terminology of ‘heteronomous’ and ‘autonomous’ morality and twice quoting his remarks on the ontological argument for the existence of God, which he views as limited but important in its appeal to unconditionality. Like Plato’s faith in the Good, this chimes with Murdoch’s desire for absolute and objective values, irrespective of the reality of ‘God’. But, like Robinson, she is moved by and shares Tillich’s appreciation of Psalm 139, a radiant celebration of God’s omnipresence and omniscience. The last paragraph of Metaphysics as a Guide to Morals states, ‘We need a theology which can continue without God’, but the book closes by quoting the psalm: ‘Whither shall I go from thy spirit, whither shall I flee from thy presence? If I ascend into heaven thou art there, if I make my bed in hell, behold thou art there. If I take the wings of
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
80 Iris Murdoch: A Literary Life
81
the morning and dwell in the uttermost parts of the sea, even there shall thy hand lead me, and thy right hand shall hold me.’ This is an unexpected conclusion for an atheist. The central character in The Time of the Angels (1966) is Carel Fisher, a priest who has lost his faith and now lives in a fog-bound rectory with no attendant church in the bombed-out East End of London. Nobody in the novel believes in traditional Christianity, except the simple, uneducated and exploited Pattie, his servant and mistress, who finds her religion a comfort and support. Carel’s brother Marcus is writing a book on the demythologizing of morals, to ‘rescue the idea of the Absolute’ and ‘to eschew both theological metaphor and the crudities of existentialism’,25 a project close to Murdoch’s ‘The Sovereignty of Good’. But he fears the death of Christianity, wants other people to believe in it, is horrified to learn that Carel does not and is thoroughly unnerved by the views of a demythologizing bishop. Muriel and Elizabeth, Carel’s daughter and ‘niece’, ‘at an early age convinced each other that there was no God’ and ‘prided themselves on being theoretical immoralists’ (p. 42). Immorality remains, in Muriel’s case, highly theoretical. Leo, the son of Eugene, Carel’s other servant, is actively amoral. He claims that values are only relative, describes himself as ‘a bit like what’s-his-name, that chap in Dostoevski’ (p. 68) and lies whenever possible to keep his creed in practice. He also steals. The only possession left to the porter, Russian émigré Eugene, after the exile of his rich cultured Russian family and his years in refugee camps and menial jobs is an icon of three angels, representing the Trinity. He has lost almost everything else, including his Orthodox faith. ‘He loved [the icon] as a blank image of goodness from which all personality had been withdrawn’ (p. 57), suggesting the pure and demythologized ideal that replaces the myths of religion in Murdoch’s philosophy. In Carel’s study, after being stolen by Leo and retrieved by Marcus, they look ‘weary with humility and failure’ (p. 175). The horror felt at the theft by the reader and by all the characters who know of it suggests that we are stirred by some pieties: care for another’s pain, the obligations of family relationships and the preservation of individual and cultural history. (Perhaps the response to the beauty of a work of art is another kind of piety.) But for how long, when the faith expressed in the icon has disappeared? Will the moral values taught by Christianity survive it? Leo, representative of
10.1057/9780230282964 - Iris Murdoch, Anne Rowe and Priscilla Martin
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-14
New Directions, Constant Themes
a younger generation, is indifferent to these claims.26 All the other characters, including the ‘immoralist’ Muriel and even the demonic Carel, feel the tug of moral obligation. Carel consciously turns himself into a false God, tries to corrupt the naive and vulnerable Pattie, causes the deaths of his wife and brother, commits incest with one daughter and brutally rejects the other. Yet on the first page of the novel he says, ‘Mind that spider, Pattie. Rescue him, would you’ (p. 7). And even Carel has his soft side: he loves Swan Lake. Murdoch has considerable sympathy with the commonsensical view of the crass headmistress Norah, who says, ‘Goodness is good conduct and we all know what that is’ (p. 94), and is impatient with the abstraction of theology and philosophy: ‘I don’t see any point in denying or affirming that the Good is One. I still ought to pay my bills’ (p. 195). She dismisses Carel as merely ‘batty’ (p. 196). However, batty Carel also expresses some of Murdoch’s views in a dark and despairing vision. God is dead and the fragments of his thought are ‘angels’, meaningless multiplicity in a world governed by chance and power – a world of evil, if such a concept could even survive: ‘Suppose only evil were real, only it was not evil, since it had lost even its name?’ (p. 172). The concept of good is only a more consoling fiction: ‘All altruism feeds the fat ego’ (p. 173). This is a point Murdoch has made herself and Carel essentially quotes her when he asserts, ‘One must be good for nothing, in a world without sense or reward’ (pp. 173–4). But Carel rejects the philosophers along with the theologian