PENAL PRACTICE AND PENAL POLICY IN ANCIENT ROME
This book assesses Roman penal policy through an in-depth examination ...
347 downloads
3057 Views
1MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
PENAL PRACTICE AND PENAL POLICY IN ANCIENT ROME
This book assesses Roman penal policy through an in-depth examination of six high-profile criminal cases, ranging from the Bacchanalian trials in 186 BC to the trials for treason and magic in the fourth century AD. Robinson examines Roman criminal legislation (both that laid down by Justinian and that codified and confirmed by him) as well as Roman attitudes, both juristic and philosophical, to the purposes of punishment, deterrence, retribution, reform and protection of the public, and how these attitudes were modified over time. The author also discusses arguments for fixed as against flexible penalties, the changes made in the actual punishments and in those to whom they were applied. In the absence of any extant general theory of criminal jurisprudence as a basis for proper procedure, assessing Roman morality and values from their penal policy has often been problematic. This book is, therefore, an essential tool for any specialist, student or researcher wishing to know more about Roman values from their approach to crime and punishment. O.F. Robinson is Professor Emeritus of Roman Law at Glasgow University. Her research interests are primarily Roman law and Roman law’s later history. Her most important publications are Ancient Rome: City Planning and Administration (1992) and The Criminal Law of Ancient Rome (1995).
PENAL PRACTICE AND PENAL POLICY IN ANCIENT ROME
O.F. Robinson
First published 2007 by Routledge 2 Park Square, Milton Park, Abingdon, Oxon OX14 4RN Simultaneously published in the USA and Canada by Routledge 270 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10016 Routledge is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group, an informa business
This edition published in the Taylor & Francis e-Library, 2007. “To purchase your own copy of this or any of Taylor & Francis or Routledge’s collection of thousands of eBooks please go to www.eBookstore.tandf.co.uk.” # 2007 O.F. Robinson All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reprinted or reproduced or utilised in any form or by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publishers. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data A catalog record for this book has been requested
ISBN 0-203-96554-X Master e-book ISBN
ISBN10: 0-415-41651-5 (hbk) ISBN10: 0-203-96554-X (ebk) ISBN13: 978-0-415-41651-1 (hbk) ISBN13: 978-0-203-96554-2 (ebk)
CONTENTS
Acknowledgements
1
viii
Introduction
1
The Bacchanalian affair
7
The sources 7 The cult of Bacchus 8 The story 9 The whore with the heart of gold 9 The authorities are informed 11 Hispala’s story 13 The source of the romance 15 The Senate 16 The reactions 18 The Senate’s resolutions 19 Livy on the Senate’s conduct 22 After-shocks 23 Foreign cults 25 Whose plot? 27 2
Cicero, murder and the courts
30
The system of the standing jury-courts 31 The quaestio perpetua de sicariis et veneficis 33 The lack of a state prosecution service and the moral ambivalence of prosecution 34 The Social War and Sulla’s dictatorship 36 The proscriptions 37 pro Roscio Amerino: the case 40 The narrative 42 Parricide and its penalty 44 Cicero’s speech 47 Cicero’s counter-charge 51 v
CONTENTS
The slaves of Roscius 53 Roscius’ estate 54 3
The trial of Cn. Calpurnius Piso in
AD
20
56
The sources 56 Germanicus and Piso 57 After Germanicus’ death 60 Treason 62 Delators 63 The trial 64 Preliminaries to the trial 64 The opening of the trial 66 The prosecution 67 The defence 68 Piso’s end 69 Subsidiary trials 70 The sentences 72 The survival of the standing jury-courts 75 4
Pliny and repetundae trials before the Senate
78
The crime of res repetundae 78 The disappearance of ‘voluntary’ exile 81 The trial of Marius Priscus and his legate 82 The trial of Classicus and his companions 86 Calumny and other procedural crimes 89 Further subsidiary trials 90 The trial of Julius Bassus 91 The trial of Varenus Rufus 94 A trial before the emperor 96 The Senate and the ordo 98 5
Acta Martyrum Christianorum: the extension of torture The sources 100 The background: astrologers and philosophers 101 The different stages of the criminal law concerning Christianity 102 Death and torture, and the links with social status 105 Decius, the gods and the Christians 108 Pionius 111 The lapsed 115 Valerian and the criminalization of Christianity 116 Cyprian 118 The ‘great’ persecution 120 vi
99
CONTENTS
The first edict, and the martyrdom of Felix 121 The later edicts 122 Agape and her companions 124 Some brief accounts: Irenaeus of Sirmium; Phileas of Thmuis; Crispina 125 Popular pressures and the rule of law 127 6
Some trials for treason and magic in the fourth century
130
The historical background 130 Fourth-century issues 132 The sources 135 Constantius and the trials of 359 137 The prohibitions on magic under Constantine and his sons 140 Astrology as science 142 Valentinian I and the trials at Rome for magic and adultery 144 Formalities in the criminal procedure of the fourth century 147 The trials at Antioch in 371–72 149 The origins 149 Theodorus on trial 151 Dangerous writings 153 The resumption of the inquiries 154 The continued prohibition of pagan sacrifices and divination 156 7
Justinian the legislator
158
Justinian and the Corpus Iuris Civilis 158 Justinian’s own legislation in Code, Book 9 159 Justinian’s legislation on criminal matters in his Novels 164 Justinian’s Code and the Theodosian Code 168 Justinian and the jurists 174 8
Crime and punishment
179
The philosophy of punishment 180 Penalties in Republican Rome 184 The growth of the death penalty: punishment in the Empire 187 Law and general ideas of punishment 193 Summary 195 Glossary Bibliography Index of Sources General Index
198 202 228 243
vii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
I am a slow worker. This book has been some ten years in the making; The Criminal Law of Ancient Rome (1995) was a foundation, without which I could not have explored the theme more deeply. I am afraid that I cannot remember all the people who have helped me over this period, but I can give particular thanks to those who have commented and criticized in this last period: John Dillon, Robert Frakes, Jan and Elizabeth Kalbheim, Lawrence Keppie, Adele Scafuro, Catherine Steel, Peter Walsh, Alan Watson and of course my husband, Sebastian. Particular thanks are due to Alan, il mio padrone, who has read all the chapters in draft, sometimes more than once. That I have not always taken his advice is probably due to my inflexible obstinacy, but I am deeply grateful, even when I have had to disagree. I also thank the community at the Leopold-Wenger-Institut in Munich, the University of Glasgow for giving me sabbaticals, my students for asking awkward questions, Jan and Elizabeth for putting up with me, and Sebastian again and always.
viii
INTRODUCTION
This is a book about crime and punishment in ancient Rome rather than a book about Roman criminal law. That is to say, it does not set out to be a textbook, or to describe criminal law generally, or even to be engaged with all aspects of the crimes described.1 Rather it sets out to show what the Romans thought about crime, what they saw as particularly heinous and – if possible – why. It does this by telling a number of stories, ‘famous trials’ so to speak, looking at attitudes, procedures and punishments. (Because they are stories, I have tried to reproduce the flavour of the originals.) It explains the technical details of the law only as far as is necessary for understanding the issues raised in particular trials. The stories chosen have to a large extent been dictated by the sources that survive, literary or legislative. For one thing, if excessive hypothesising is to be avoided, it is necessary to look for a fairly full treatment by the ancient authors. And for another, unusually full treatment of certain episodes suggests that the Romans found them particularly interesting. It does not mean that the cases treated were typical crimes, in the sense of the daily diet of the courts, but it does mean that the treatment was representative of Roman attitudes. The Romans were not, apparently, given to introspection; we must therefore deduce their attitudes from what they found worth reporting at length. Three chapters, chapters 1, 3 and 6, are based primarily on literary sources, historians’ descriptions. Livy gives extraordinary space to the Bacchanalian affair, and the truth of certain aspects of his account is confirmed by the existence of a contemporary inscription recording the Senate’s decisions. The same is true of Tacitus’ lengthy account of the trial of Piso and its background, concerning which the inscription recording the official decision of the Senate was discovered only quite recently. Ammianus seems to have been an eye-witness to the trials of AD 371–72 at Antioch, which he recounts at length, but we have no external control on his version, although 1
I have given a general introduction in my The Criminal Law of Ancient Rome (London and Baltimore, 1995).
1
INTRODUCTION
for this period relevant legislation survives in the Theodosian Code. The Acts of the Christian Martyrs, our main source in chapter 5, are rather different; while not court records, they purport to describe how the noble martyrs faced their bloodthirsty judges. They are not precisely literary sources; their viewpoint is not that of the governing classes, and the stories of the trials had a specific purpose. In chapters 2 and 4, our information is based on a speech of Cicero and some letters of Pliny the Younger. Both were advocates, arguing particular cases on somebody else’s behalf. There is no external check on their version of events; one must rely on their need for plausibility if their speeches were to be effective. Justinian, the subject of chapter 7, was not merely an emperor who enacted legislation of his own, in the Code; he stamped with his authority, and so turned into statute law, the juristic works found in the Digest, thus endorsing criminal law and criminal jurisprudence drawn from a period extending over more than half a millennium. (These successive textual layers inevitably produced inconsistencies, which is, interestingly, one reason why the Corpus Iuris Civilis, and particularly the Digest, was so influential in subsequent centuries, because its users, such as Popes and Emperors, natural lawyers and positivists, could find support for conflicting views.) Justinian’s own projection of himself is to some extent counterbalanced by Procopius’ hostile picture in the Secret History. The first four chapters are focused on the city of Rome. It was on Rome that the judicial process was centred, whatever form it might take. Chapter 4 by definition deals with events in the provinces, abuses of office by provincial governors, but the trials were in Rome and their consequences felt there. In the legal system depicted in chapters 5 and 6, the regular judge was the provincial governor, now commonly described simply as judge (iudex), although his jurisdiction might be superseded by special commissioners. The change is a real one, as Mommsen saw, from an enlarged citystate ruling its provinces to an Empire in which ‘Roman’ is a conceptual rather than a geographical term. And Justinian, of course, ruled this Roman world from Constantinople. Some of the questions raised, if not necessarily fully answered, include: What was behind the apparently sudden decision to persecute the worshippers of Bacchus in 186 BC? And why was the punishment so harsh? Was the violent society described by Cicero in defence of Sextus Roscius of Ameria simply a product of the civil wars? And why were the standard penalties of the Republican courts so – relatively – light? It is certain that Tiberius had real plots to face, as had Augustus before him, but how far did he act as a tyrant, repressing the victims of a system of delation which encouraged groundless charges? Why were links with astrology so damning, even when the prevailing Stoic philosophy saw men’s fates as determined by their stars? Pliny participated in some notable trials for extortion in the provinces; what was the relationship between criminal justice for citizens 2
INTRODUCTION
and for non-citizens? Christians enter the scene. Why were they persecuted? Were their trials subject to due process? Why do we hear so frequently that they were punished with death? In the fourth century treason trials feature again; why, for Christian emperors, were astrology and magic so suspect? Why did penalties appear so arbitrary? Justinian is the great lawgiver, the emperor who left us the Corpus Iuris Civilis. Why did he not legislate more on criminal law? What were his views on punishment? Why is there such a stark contrast between respect for due process and lack of respect for human rights? Why did the Romans go so far in making a spectacle out of punishment? The range of crimes dealt with in this book is restricted. The charges are essentially confined to refusal to conform to the official religion – something which had seditious aspects – murder, treason (with elements of magic), and extortion from provincials. This is partly because we are limited to the information provided by our sources, information which would interest Roman readers, but it is also linked to the definition of crime. For the Romans ‘crime’ meant actions which threatened social well-being and stability; the repression of crime aimed to protect society more than its individual members, who were traditionally expected to be responsible for their own safety. Indeed, as we shall see, self-help remained a valued characteristic of the citizen, even if its exercise was put under limits. The Romans, at least of the Republic and early Empire, perhaps later too, preferred to deal with much that we would call petty crime, particularly crime against individual proprietary rights, by civil process, as delict. This was not unreasonable. In most cases of theft or assault or damage to property, reparation – which is what a civil action provides – is likely to be the first thing the victim wants. While it is true that thieves as a class are unlikely to be able to make reparation, the existence at Rome of noxal liability – the legal responsibility of a paterfamilias or slave-owner for the delicts of his child or slave – meant that the victim would often be able to sue someone who was able to pay up.2 While it may be politically incorrect to say so, it seems very likely that the great majority of petty crimes at Rome were committed by slaves. Not so much because their natural servility of character marked them out to be slaves, as many of the ancients would have had it, but because many slaves must have been treated as nonpersons, something which leads to non-responsibility; others will have been the first in most households to suffer in hard times. The institution of slavery, combined with the delictual liability of owners, thus seems to have made the chances of reparation in ancient Rome somewhat higher than in the modern world. Moreover, where reparation was not sought, most street crime could be dealt with summarily, by the tresviri capitales or the Urban Prefect. These magistrates had virtually unlimited powers to deal with (presumed) slaves or foreigners – one thinks of the negative image of asylum 2
E.g. Albanese (1967), or any Roman law textbook’s treatment of noxal liability.
3
INTRODUCTION
seekers currently put forward by the popular press – who had committed offences on the street; they could lock them up, flog them, or execute them, because such persons were outside the law. The close intervention of the state in the details of its citizens’ – or subjects’ – conduct is an invention of the nineteenth century, of postIndustrial Revolution living; it also depends on the creation of police forces for social control.3 Factory conditions led to Factory Acts, and later Health and Safety Acts; education moved from being a privilege to a requirement, hence truancy; trains, and then the car, led to traffic regulations, and so to drunken driving.4 Taking the long view back, it is the nineteenth and twentieth centuries that are out of step, that are novel. (As for what the ‘war against drugs’ has done to criminalize half a population, the lesson of Prohibition has not been learned.) Sir George Mackenzie in seventeenth-century Scotland could reasonably base his treatise on the Roman model of crime – serious offences that threatened the social order;5 in his day, a gentleman carried a sword to protect himself against individual aggressors. Hume’s understanding of criminal law6 at the end of the eighteenth century represented the early stages of the modern view; he saw it as aimed at protecting the individual. And yet, one of the most interesting points made by a recent study of the history of criminal law in Antiquity is that at Rome there existed a general concept of submission to the law. Not only was there not a criminal class in any meaningful sense, although of course there were many individual criminals, but – unlike the medieval and early modern periods – vendetta and private warfare are absent from the social scene. It was a rougher world than that of twentieth-century Western European countries in peacetime, but it was not so different in expecting the procedures of the courts to settle major disputes.7 Roman attitudes seem reasonably consistent. Religion was something that needed to be controlled by the state. In pagan Rome the Roman gods must be worshipped, and in due form, for the health of Rome. In the Christian Empire the emperors were concerned to repress heretics as well as, or even more than, pagans. Magic was real, and dangerous; it was often linked with astrology. Astrology in its turn was linked with philosophy, Stoic philosophy, which was often linked to opposition, based on Republican principles, to imperial rule. Magic and nocturnal sacrifices were clear signs of a threat to the commonwealth. Another recurring issue is the ambivalent status of 3 4 5 6 7
See L. Farmer, Criminal Law, Tradition and Legal Order: crime and the genius of Scots law, 1747 to the present (CUP, 1997). See O.F. Robinson, T.D. Fergus and W.M. Gordon, European Legal History (2000, 3rd edn, Butterworth/OUP), ch. 17: ‘New trends in law’. G. Mackenzie, The Laws and Customs of Scotland in Matters Criminal (Edinburgh, 1678). D. Hume, Commentaries on the Law of Scotland respecting Crimes (Edinburgh, 1797). Krause (2004), 203–5.
4
INTRODUCTION
informers. In the absence of a public prosecution service, delation was recognized as a necessary civic duty, but it was not admirable and its rewards were tainted, as will be apparent in almost every chapter. The force of popular opinion was important. It came from a smaller segment of the population than nowadays, where there is access to TV, easy-to-read newspapers and the internet, but still it was created by more than just the makers and shakers of Roman society. There was a general lack of respect for human life, human suffering, human rights – as is obvious from the institution of slavery – that was combined, rather oddly to our eyes, with a strong feeling for the dignity of the upper ranks of society. Due process was important, but perhaps more from the perspective of noblesse oblige than the upholding of rights. There was widespread acceptance of harsh punishments, at least for the offender who, the upper ranks felt was not ‘one of us’. Privileges originally linked simply to citizenship became, as the population of the Roman Empire increased, restricted to those of some superior status; at the lowest level of these honestiores were the honourably discharged veterans of the legions, and town councillors (known as decurions or curiales). In turn those privileges became eroded, both by the greater use of physical punishment and by the lessening of respect for status. The spread to the upper classes of the use of torture was slower than the spread of the death penalty, for torture must humiliate, but spread it did. One problem we face is that attitudes in the ancient world cannot be quantified. At best, they can be identified as simply conventional or as realistic. Our sources are too limited, too partial, for any objective, statistically valid, recognition of attitudes. Perhaps, however, this is a positive feature. We have snapshots of attitudes to specific events, and these come from different sources with different perspectives, from different times and different places. By definition, our recorded cases are unusual in themselves; otherwise they would not have been recorded. But this may be strictly a legal, not a social, problem; it means that we cannot tell how the normal crime was prosecuted, how the normal trial was run, and the normal crime punished. Because, however, our chosen trials aroused such interest, they do, or should, give some answers to questions about attitudes, about policy. They do not paint a uniform picture, but they are striking because they represent something of great importance to their recorders. So if the same themes recur, this may be due not to bias in our sources but rather to the continuity of attitudes. Ambiguity remains because attitudes are perceptions of what is significant, of what is criminal, of what society must abhor. The attitudes of the upper ranks explain policy, insofar as there was policy and not simply reaction. Popular opinion, whether in the shape of the ‘crowd’,8 or the curial class, played a part, but the populace, whatever one means by the term, was not in a position directly to reform the law. Our source material limits our 8
Millar (1998).
5
INTRODUCTION
technical understanding, which in turn limits our understanding of what Romans themselves thought was happening and what ought to be happening. But even if we cannot achieve much more than to perceive some facts and some interpretations through a swirling mist, this is an exciting challenge. This book thus provides six glimpses of Roman crimes as seen through the eyes of the Romans themselves, and then a legislator’s view. The final chapter attempts to analyse Roman society’s attitudes to crime and to punishment, and to understand the gap between criminological theory and penal practice. Crime, now as then, is a topic on the margins of various disciplines, giving rise to legal, social and political concerns. For me, as a Roman lawyer, the legal aspect predominates, but all aspects are fascinating for the historian.
6
Chapter 1 THE BACCHANALIAN AFFAIR
Our first case is hardly a matter of criminal law in the strict sense. It is legally interesting because it provided, or was made to provide, a model for some future developments, but it is doubtful if there was any pre-existing legal justification for the actions taken. On the other hand, the episode does undoubtedly reveal Roman attitudes – as much, perhaps, those of the end of the Republic as of the early second century BC – to crime and punishment. We are given by Livy an extraordinarily detailed story, told in highly coloured language, designed to produce reactions of shock, horror, and prurience, and at the same time to show the Senate as the guardian of the Roman people.
The sources In 186 BC there occurred one of the most bizarre events in the domestic history of Rome. The cult of Dionysus or Bacchus was found to be a public danger, and was vigorously suppressed, not only in Rome but also throughout Italy. Interestingly, the name Liber does not appear in Livy’s account, but Liber, a traditional Roman god, had long been identified with Dionysus, and his rites, together with those of his sister Libera, had been celebrated, particularly with theatrical performances – ludi scaenici – probably since the fifth century BC. The Liberalia, largely a plebeian cult, came immediately after the Ides of March, the day when Republican magistrates entered office, and the festival carried a symbolic reference to the freedom that followed the end of the Monarchy, the regifugium, celebrated at the end of February. ‘If the Bacchic cult was to be distinguished from the traditional worship of Liber, some creative reinterpretation was going to be necessary.’1 Our knowledge of the affair comes from a contemporary inscription recording the substance of the Senate’s resolutions, found in southern Italy, 1
Wiseman (1998), 41ff. Tertullian, ap. 6.9–10 (cf. almost identical nat.deorum 1.10.16), whose sources may well have been wider than ours, remarked: ‘Liberum patrem cum mysteriis suis consules senatus auctoritate non modo urbe sed universa Italia eliminaverunt.’
7
T H E B A C C H A N A L I A N A F FA I R
at Tiriolo near Bruttium,2 and from the extraordinarily lengthy account of Livy.3 While we cannot be sure that these two testimonies are completely independent, Livy does not directly quote the senatusconsulta, and so it seems quite likely that he had only heard of them in his sources, not actually seen them. We shall turn first to Livy’s account.
The cult of Bacchus Rumours of some sort were clearly already afoot at the time of the elections for 186, for the new consuls, Spurius Postumius Albinus and Quintus Marcius Philippus, were not assigned to the troublesome and as yet unpacified region of Liguria, as in the previous year, but were both appointed to the investigation of secret conspiracies.4 Livy then gives a background of sorts.5 It began with the arrival in Etruria of an obscure Greek, a petty priest and fortune-teller, not the master of any of those many arts which that most educated people has brought us for the cultivation of our minds and bodies; nor was he someone who, while he might mislead men’s minds, would do so by openly teaching his creed and setting out publicly its benefits and doctrines, but rather the celebrant of secret nocturnal rites. No date is given, but the familiarity with the cult of Bacchus that Plautus assumes in his audiences,6 and the archaeological evidence of the Dionysiac rites, including many vases,7 suggest that this refers to a time around the middle of the third century, and certainly some decades before our story. Livy then moves to what seems to have been the popular perception of these rites.8 2 3 4
5 6
7 8
CIL X 104; ILS 18; FIRA i, no.30. Livy 39.8–19, and some further mentions of the affair. ‘Consulibus ambobus quaestio de clandestinis coniurationibus decreta est’ (Livy 39.8.3). Arcellaschi (1990), 38, dates the first stirrings of a scandal to 190 BC; he also, at p. 41, stresses that the cult was of Liber Pater. Bauman (1990), 338, wonders whether dealing with this problem had been a campaign promise by Postumius and Philippus. FreyburgerGalland (1986), 205, thinks that the production, perhaps in 188, of Plautus’ Bacchides may have helped provoke the affair. Livy 39.8.3–4. E.g. Plautus, Amph. 702ff; Aul. 406–13; Bacch. 52ff; 368ff; Men. 828–41. The stereotype portrait of the Bacchants was hardly favourable, which makes Toynbee (1965), 391f, wonder if popular opinion was turning against them; even, at p. 393, that they may have been seen by the majority of citizens as a nuisance, as some see Carnival or Fasching. Bruhl (1953), 58–69; 70–81 describes Etruscan links; Gruen (1990) 50; Pailler (1988), 3ff on the Bolsena excavations. Livy 39.8.5–6.
8
T H E B A C C H A N A L I A N A F FA I R
There were initiations, at first communicated to only a few, but which then began to be made widely available to both men and women. In order to entice the minds of as many as possible, religion was laced with the pleasures of wine and feasting. When once wine had fired their minds, and darkness and the intermingling of men with women, and of the young with their elders, had extinguished all feelings of shame, then all kinds of depravity began to make their first appearance, since everyone had ready to hand the pleasure suited to gratifying the most susceptible side of his or her nature. Certainly this is roughly what the world at large believed of the Bacchantes and their cult of frenzy. But the Graeco-Roman world tolerated such cults,9 even as they tut-tutted. However, Livy then leads us into stranger territory, bearing little relation to the cult itself. Promiscuous sex involving freeborn men and women was not the only kind of mischief. Perjured witnesses, forged seals, wills and instruments all came from the same workshop; and from it also came poisonings and domestic murders, so that sometimes it was not even possible to find the bodies for burial. The believers dared to commit many crimes by cunning, and not a few by violence. Such violence was regularly concealed by shrieks of worship and the din of drums and cymbals, so no sounds of protest could be heard from those screaming at the rapes and the murders.10 Ululation and loud music were a normal part of Dionysiac worship; it seems that Livy is seeking to blacken everything.
The story The whore with the heart of gold ‘The infection of this evil made its way, like some contagious disease, from Etruria into Rome.’ In fact, as we have remarked, the cult was already widespread in Italy, and many scholars hold that it came from Campania.11 ‘At first the size of the City, with its greater capacity and ability to absorb such evils, concealed them; but eventually evidence reached the consul Postumius in much the following way.’12 And now we get the story of the 9 10 11 12
See Burkert (1987), 8–10, 112–13, on initiation generally. Livy 39.8.7–8. E.g. Frank (1927). Livy 39.9.1.
9
T H E B A C C H A N A L I A N A F FA I R
innocent young man and the (older) whore with the heart of gold. Publius Aebutius, whose father had received his horse at public expense,13 had been orphaned while he was still under puberty. Subsequently, on the death of his tutors, he had been brought up under the guardianship14 of his mother, Duronia, and of his stepfather, Titus Sempronius Rutilius. His mother was besotted with her husband, and the stepfather had so mismanaged the ‘guardianship’ that he could not produce his accounts for it, and thus desired that his pupil either be done away with or be bound to him by some kind of unbreakable tie. The Bacchanalian rites offered one way of corrupting him. Aebutius’ mother summoned the young man and told him that, when he was ill, she had made a vow on his behalf that she would initiate him into the Bacchic cult as soon as he had regained his health, and this oath must now be discharged. He must abstain from sexual relations for ten days, and on the tenth day he would be ritually purified, and be led by her into the shrine.15 Now, Livy goes on, there was a well-known prostitute, Faecenia Hispala, a freedwoman. She had become accustomed to the trade while she was still a slave (though she was too good for it), and she continued to support herself in the same way even after her manumission. Because they were neighbours she developed an intimate friendship with Aebutius, but without doing the slightest harm to the young man’s property or reputation; for she loved and desired him of her own accord. Indeed, because his family were very mean in providing for him, he was supported by the generosity of the courtesan. The influence of their intimacy was such that, after her patron’s death, when she was under no man’s authority, she petitioned the tribunes and praetor for a tutor, and then made a will naming Aebutius as her sole heir. Because they had these assurances of their love, neither of them kept any secrets from the other, and consequently the young man told her light-heartedly not to be surprised if he absented himself for a few nights; he was to be initiated in the Bacchic rites for religious reasons, in discharge of a vow made for his recovery from illness.16 Thus far the romantic background. But when Hispala heard this, she was appalled. ‘Heaven help us!’ she said. It would be better for them both to die rather than for him to do such a thing; and she called down curses and vengeance on the heads of those who had urged him to do it. The young man, astonished both by her language and by the intensity of her distress, told her not to curse, since it was his mother who had ordered him to do it, with the agreement of his stepfather. ‘Then your stepfather’, she said, ‘– for 13 14
15 16
Which meant that he was of equestrian rank, and in the upper range. This must simply mean that, after he reached puberty, he continued to live with and be looked after by his mother, and that his stepfather thus had practical control of his estate. Women did not have the legal capacity to be guardians until the Later Empire. See Livy 39.9.2–4. See Livy 39.9.5–10.2.
10
T H E B A C C H A N A L I A N A F FA I R
it may perhaps not be right to accuse your mother – is working to ruin your honour, your reputation, your hopes, and your life itself.’ He was still more amazed by this and asked her what was the matter. She begged the gods and goddesses for peace and pardon if, impelled by her love for him, she told him things that should remain unspoken. Then she said that when she was a slave she had accompanied her mistress to the Bacchic shrine, but had never visited it since becoming free. She knew that it was the source of every kind of debauchery; and it was well known that for the past two years no-one had been initiated there who was over the age of twenty. As each person was introduced, he or she was handed over to the priests like a sacrificial victim; they were led away to a place which was filled with wailings, blasts of musical instruments, and the throbbing of cymbals and drums in order that the screams of anyone being forcibly raped (cum per vim stuprum inferatur) could not be heard. She therefore besought him to frustrate the plan in any way he could, and not to plunge himself into a situation where he would be compelled first to suffer and then to inflict all kinds of obscene acts. And she did not let the young man go until he had promised that he would refrain from the mysteries.17 One must have doubts about how up to date her information really was, as her attendance (and that only as her mistress’ maid) was explicitly some time before. After Aebutius had returned home, his mother began to talk of what was going to happen so far as the rites were concerned. He said that he was not going to do any of those things, and that he did not intend to be initiated. While he was speaking, his stepfather came in and his mother immediately exclaimed that Aebutius was unable to sleep apart from Hispala even for ten nights; that he was so steeped in the allurements and poisons of that sheviper as to have lost all reverence for his parent, his stepfather and the gods. His mother poured abuse on him from one side, his stepfather from the other, and they drove him with his four slaves out of the house.18 The authorities are informed The family row then took a more public dimension. The young man went to seek refuge with his aunt Aebutia, and explained why he had been thrown out by his mother. On her advice, he reported the matter next day to the consul Postumius,19 with no witnesses present. The consul sent him 17 18 19
See Livy 39.10.2–9. See Livy 39.11.1–2. We hear that it was an earlier Postumius, the dictator successful at the battle of Lake Regillus, whose master of horse was T. Aebutius (Livy 2.19.3), who had vowed a temple to Ceres, Liber and Libera – Hellenized into the Greek gods Demeter, Dionysus and Persephone – (Dion. Hal. 6.17.2), which was consecrated three years later in 493 BC (Dion. Hal. 6.94.3). Bruhl (1953), 31f, describes this as the only official recognition of Dionysus; he also doubts the traditional dating, and thinks the temple was probably of the late fifth century.
11
T H E B A C C H A N A L I A N A F FA I R
away with orders to return in two days’ time, and then asked his mother-inlaw, Sulpicia, a very respectable woman, whether she knew an old lady from the Aventine named Aebutia. When she replied that she knew her to be a virtuous woman of old-fashioned morals, the consul said that he must have a meeting with her; Sulpicia was therefore to send a messenger to Aebutia requesting her to call. Aebutia came promptly; after a short while, the consul, acting as if he had come in by chance, raised the subject of her brother’s son Aebutius. Tears came to the woman’s eyes, and she began to lament what had happened to the young man, who was at present staying with her; he had been robbed of his fortune by those who should least of all have done so, and been thrown out by his mother because, being a virtuous youth, he had refused to be initiated into what – if the gods would excuse her for saying so – were rumoured to be disgusting rites.20 The consul, thinking that Aebutius sounded a reliable source of information, sent Aebutia away, and next asked his mother-in-law to summon to her house the freedwoman Hispala, who also came from the Aventine and was well known in the neighbourhood; she too was someone whom he wished to interrogate. Hispala was alarmed at being summoned to the home of so noble and important a lady without knowing the reason; but then, when she saw the lictors in the anteroom, the consul’s companions and the consul himself, she nearly fainted. She was conducted into the interior of the house where the consul, inviting his mother-in-law to be present, told her that she had no cause for alarm provided that she could bring herself to speak the truth. She should trust either Sulpicia, a woman of high standing, or himself; but she was to give him an account of what was customarily done by the Bacchanalians during their nocturnal rites in the grove of Stimula (or Semele, mother of Bacchus). When Hispala heard this, she was seized with such fear and trembling that for a long time she could not even open her mouth. Finally she pulled herself together and said that she had been initiated as a slave-girl, along with her mistress, when she was still very young; but from the time she was manumitted a number of years ago she had known nothing of what went on there. The consul praised her for not denying that she had herself been initiated, but ordered her to give similarly truthful answers to his other questions. When she denied knowing anything more, he said that if her guilt was proved by the evidence of someone else she would not receive the same pardon or consideration as if she confessed of her own accord; and he added, misleadingly, that the man who had heard the story from her had already given him a full account of it.21 Hispala, having no doubt that this must refer to Aebutius (which was true), fell at Sulpicia’s feet and began to beg her not to let a freedwoman’s conversation with her lover be turned into something so serious, involving a 20 21
See Livy 39.11.3–7. See Livy 39.12.1–8.
12
T H E B A C C H A N A L I A N A F FA I R
capital crime.22 The things which she had said to him had been to frighten him, not because she really knew anything. At this, Postumius flew into a rage, or appeared to – he had already showed himself a skilled interrogator. Did she still think that she was joking with her lover, rather than talking to the consul in the home of a most important lady? Sulpicia helped the frightened woman to her feet, spoke encouraging words to her and soothed the anger of her son-in-law. When at last Hispala had pulled herself together, after fiercely condemning the treachery of Aebutius who had thus repaid her after all she had done for him, she said that her fear of the gods, whose secret initiations she would be revealing, was great, but she was even more afraid of the human beings who might tear her apart as an informer. She therefore begged both Sulpicia and the consul to send her somewhere away from Italy, where she could spend the rest of her life in safety. The consul told her to keep her spirits up; he personally would ensure that she could safely live in Rome. At this, Hispala revealed how the rites had begun.23 Again, one must ask what credence should be given to her account; what did she know, and what did she perhaps believe. As North has remarked,24 ‘had the Roman authorities no better method of finding out how many people attended the meetings of a group they knew to be meeting regularly on the Aventine than to ask a freedwoman of dubious character?’ Some of what follows will certainly have been public knowledge. Hispala’s story At first, Hispala recounted, the place of worship had been reserved for women and it was not the custom for any man to be admitted to it. There were three fixed days a year on which initiations in the Bacchic rites took place, in the daytime, and it was customary for the priesthood to be held by a succession of married women. However, Paculla Annia from Campania, when she held the priesthood, had changed everything, supposedly at the behest of the gods. She had been the first to initiate men – her sons Minius and Herennius Cerrinius – and she had converted the daytime ritual into one at night.25 She also increased the initiation-days from three a year to five a month.26 From the time that the rites were held in common, men 22
23 24 25
26
‘sermonem in rem non seriam modo sed capitalem etiam verti’. Perhaps nocturnal meetings were of themselves capital offences, as Mantovani (1989), 19–21, thinks, but the point is not made elsewhere in the story. See Livy 39.13.1–7. North (1979), 88. These claims of novelty seem untrue, at least for the cult’s practice in Etruria, according to Livy himself (39.8.3–5); it may perhaps have been innovatory at Rome. Cf. Euripides, Bacch. 469 and 485–6, but he of course referred to Thebes and Greece generally. And surely it was always a cult with nocturnal meetings. Bauman (1990), 338, considers it probable that these changes had been made two years before the scandal broke, along with the imposition of an age-limit of twenty for initiations.
13
T H E B A C C H A N A L I A N A F FA I R
mingling with women, and with the freedom of the darkness as well, there was no kind of crime or wrongdoing that they did not commit. The men raped men more than women; any who were less willing to suffer this abuse and less active in wickedness were sacrificed as victims – it is very curious, this obsession with rape.27 The highest principle of their religion was to regard nothing as forbidden. The men, as if their minds were possessed, would convulse their bodies and utter prophecies; the married women, dressed as Bacchants with their hair dishevelled, would rush down to the Tiber carrying blazing torches which they would plunge into the river, then carry them away with their flames still burning, because they contained live sulphur mixed with lime. Some men, who refused to take part in the conspiracy, or to be associated with the crimes or to suffer rape, were said to be ‘carried off by the gods’; they were bound to a machine and whisked out of sight into hidden caves. (This could well be a ritual death and rebirth.28) So far the description of Bacchic worship seems dramatized but not unrelated to the facts as generally understood.29 But she went on to say that the number involved was very large, almost amounting to an alternative state, and included some men and women from noble families.30 If Hispala had not been attending the rites, this must have been mere rumour, and the notion of an alternative state is ridiculous. Within the last two years they had adopted a rule that no one above the age of twenty should be initiated, since they were trying to catch those whose age made them susceptible to error and to corruption.31 But, as Gruen has pointed out,32 this age-limit tends to the consolidation of the numbers of initiates rather than their expansion. He also points out that Hispala had only attended the mysteries with her owner; it was a cult for the respectable rather than the outcasts of society, and the young men initiated were clearly citizens, at least for the most part. What would such persons have to gain by overthrowing the res publica? 27 28 29 30
31 32
Is rape, the use of force, the excuse for enjoyment? Walsh (1994), 5. Pausanias gives an analogous account, 9.39.5–14, of his initiation at the oracle of Trophonios in Boeotia. The blazing torches which survived immersion in water would have been, as Livy in fact described them, previously treated with sulphur and calcium sulphate. Bauman (1990), 341, points out that Livy elsewhere describes the initiates as including not only Aebutius’ mother, Duronia, but also her second husband (the wicked stepfather) Titus Sempronius Rutilius; Bauman links him with a certain Caius Sempronius Rutilius who was tribune in 189 but whose career went no further (he could have died?). Bauman also points out that Marcus and Gaius Atinius, later described as among the leaders of the fellowship, were from a prominent plebeian family, several of whom held the praetorship at the beginning of the second century, and who, furthermore, were linked to the Sempronii. But see Walsh (1996), 186. See Livy 39.13.8–14. Gruen (1990), 53; youthful initiation was certainly normal later. Festugie`re (1954), 95– 96, reckons that this, like infant baptism, was designed to give the god’s protection to the young. Burkert (1987), 52, does wonder about its significance.
14
T H E B A C C H A N A L I A N A F FA I R
When she had finished her evidence, Hispala prostrated herself again at the consul’s feet and begged him, as she had before, to send her abroad. Postumius, however, asked his mother-in-law to clear some part of her house, so that Hispala could move in. Sulpicia made available the attic flat; the stairs leading to the street were blocked off, and the only access was from within the house itself. All Hispala’s belongings were immediately brought here and her household slaves sent for, while Aebutius was ordered to move to the house of one of the consul’s clients.33 The source of the romance All this is given as the background to the consul’s discovery that there was something dangerous going on, and the scene then moves to the Senate. But this is perhaps the point to ask if the romantic story is pure fiction. It is certainly a story typical of the New Comedy, a plot which Plautus could have used: the innocent young man, the scheming stepparent and the weak or wicked real parent, the prostitute with the heart of gold. Where would Livy have taken this from? For it is virtually inconceivable that he would have invented it. One possibility: the worship of Liber seems early to have taken the form of a stage festival,34 and indeed there survives a line of the famous playwright Naevius on it: ‘We speak with a free tongue at the games of Freedom.’35 Wiseman holds that the story came to Livy ultimately from the annalist A. Postumius Albinus, consul in 151 and relative of the consul Sp. Postumius Albinus the protagonist. Further, he thinks that the annalist Postumius may have recorded as fact the details of a play written, perhaps for the games of 185, to assuage plebeian feeling after the Senate’s high-handed conduct in suppressing what was a largely plebeian cult,36 but Livy would not have known that his ultimate source lay in drama. Such plays did exist; Naevius and others had written up real events into stage performances.37 If one accepts this hypothesis, it even becomes possible that the sinister details given by Hispala are a mockery of the alleged crimes; the playwright, whoever he was, may have been ironic, distancing his story and characters from reality. 33 34 35 36
37
See Livy 39.14.1–3. Wiseman (1998), 39. Festus, L. 103: ‘Libera lingua loquimur ludis Liberalibus.’ Wiseman (1998), 47–8; he also sees in Ovid, Fasti 6.485–550 a reference to a similar play subsequent to the suppression of the Bacchanalia, 48–51. Walsh (1994), 10f, can divide Livy’s account into a drama in four acts. See also Walsh (1996), 195ff, and, on the annalist tradition, 192–93 and 201–02, pointing out that all the annalists feature the concept of moral decline, a theme which Livy also stressed. Wiseman (1998), 1ff; 52; Walsh (1996), 200. But these were set well back in the past, and I think one must agree with Fantham (2000) that it was inconceivable that ‘living Roman magistrates or matrons would be shown on the stage’; Keaveney (2003) is also dismissive.
15
T H E B A C C H A N A L I A N A F FA I R
The details given of the Bacchic rites are designed to cause the maximum shock and horror, and to evoke a lubricious reaction; they are what a hostile audience might want to believe. After all, Livy, a historian loyally supportive of the Senate, was concerned to justify the suppression of the cult. But most of the cultic practices, as has been pointed out recently by such as Gruen and North,38 were almost certainly ritual, the formalized re-enactment of an original dark story (to some extent comparable to the Christian eucharist). The romance’s invention, even if Aebutius and Hispala were real people,39 may be explained away with a reasonable degree of plausibility. The difficulty with the story given by Livy concerns, not the sexual elements, whether true or exaggerated for prurience’s sake, but the forgeries and the related crimes. However, Walsh has demonstrated that Livy’s account from the meeting of the Senate onwards is historical; Livy drew on the late annalists Valerius Antias and Claudius Quadrigarius who had had access to the acta senatus.40 The early annalists, writing in Greek, wove a dramatic version of the affair, and they included Postumius Albinus. The middle annalists, writing in Latin, may have sharpened the picture of moral decline – and Livy saw moral decline as general from the early second century – by including conventional crimes such as murder and forgery.41
The Senate So, the consul Postumius (whether or not he had the informers safely under his wing) then reported the affair to the Senate, both the information he had received and the results of his own investigations. Livy tells us that the senators as individuals were much alarmed, both on the public account by fear of social unrest, and also because they feared the involvement of their own families. (This readiness to believe such a thing also suggests that the cult was well-known.) Anyway, the Senate passed a vote of thanks to Postumius, and decreed that the consuls should undertake an extraordinary commission to inquire into the Bacchanalians and their nocturnal rites. They were to see that no harm came to Aebutius and Hispala, and to encourage with rewards other informers. Priests of the cult, male and female, were to be hunted out, not only in Rome but throughout all the towns and districts (per omnia fora et conciliabula), and put in the consuls’ charge. Moreover, edicts were to be issued in Rome and throughout Italy prohibiting initiates from assembling or celebrating their rites. And, above 38 39 40 41
Gruen (1990), 63; North (1979), 88ff. Bauman (1990) tends to credulity. Which seems probable, from Livy’s recording that one of the SCC gave them rewards. Walsh (1994), 8; (1996), 193–94. As Gelzer (1936), 287, suggested. Firmicus Maternus, err. prof. 6.9, believed in the existence of scelera. However, St Augustine (CD 6.9) reports of Varro, who presumably had no axe to grind: ‘ubi Varro ipse confitetur a bacchantibus talia fieri non potuisse nisi mente commota.’
16
T H E B A C C H A N A L I A N A F FA I R
all, investigation was to be made into those who had come together or conspired to commit sexual or other crimes.42 This was truly a quaestio extraordinaria, an extraordinary and unprecedented act by the Senate, assuming jurisdiction not only in Rome and its territory but also throughout Italy. (There had indeed been a quaestio extraordinaria in the previous year, the trial of L. Cornelius Scipio Asiaticus,43 presided over by a praetor appointed to this office by the Senate but this, nevertheless, rested on a lex passed by the people,44 and it did not extend beyond Roman territory.) The consuls then ordered the curule aediles to hunt out all the priests of the cult and hold them under house arrest, ready for interrogation; the plebeian aediles were to prevent any secret celebrations. The tresviri capitales were commanded to place guards throughout the City to make sure there were no night meetings, and to prevent fires;45 the quinqueviri uls cis Tiberim,46 their assistants, were to guard buildings – temples, perhaps – in their respective districts.47 This can only have inflamed the situation; what real threat can have been envisaged? Having given these orders, the consuls then summoned the populace to a contio, an informal assembly, and the consul (Postumius it must be, although his name is not given) addressed them. In this highly emotive speech he accepted that the Bacchic cult was well known to exist in the City48 as well as, over a long period, in Italy, but he sought to arouse their fears by stressing the numbers, the many thousands, of initiates, although he then went on to alleviate these fears somewhat by pointing out that the majority were women – the source of this mischief (primum igitur mulierum magna pars est, et is fons mali huiusce fuit) – and that most of the men were effeminate, debauched, fanatical, stupefied. But the numbers were potentially dangerous, as were all unofficial gatherings, gatherings unsupervised by lawful authority, and when these gatherings were nocturnal, and attended by women as well as men . . . Youths initiated into the cult were not fit to bear arms, to fight for the chastity of Roman wives and children. Yet effeminacy dishonoured only individuals, whereas whatsoever evil had been done in recent years from lust, or fraud, or 42
43 44
45 46 47 48
‘qui coierint coniuraverintve quo stuprum flagitiumve inferretur.’ (Livy 39.14.3–8). Bruhl (1953), 116, points out that the term coniuratio was literally accurate; the Bacchantes took oaths together, as was forbidden by the SC. Called Asiagenes in some MSS. The sources are confused about the charges against him; extortion seems more likely than treason, but politics undoubtedly played a part. Livy 38.54–55. Bauman (1983), 199ff, argues, following Kunkel (1962), 58, that at this period there was no difference between a quaestio created by plebiscitum and one established by the Senate; this must be implausible. Bequignon (1941), 195, argues, also unconvincingly, that the Bacchanalian investigation was founded on a lex. Cf. Robinson (1977). A college of very minor magistrates indeed – see Robinson (1992), 175. See Livy 39.14.9–10. Which ‘makes a nonsense of Livy’s earlier claim that the consuls first got wind of the Bacchanalia through the revelations of Aebutius and Hispala’ (Walsh (1996), 195).
17
T H E B A C C H A N A L I A N A F FA I R
wickedness, sprang from this cult; so far there had only been crimes against individuals, but soon the res publica itself would be at risk. Let the citizens worry about whether their friends had been infected; when the assembly had scattered to its homes, then the cultists might be gathering. While it was reasonable to be wary if wrongdoings were ascribed to the will of the gods, there had been innumerable decrees of the pontiffs, resolutions of the Senate, opinions of the augurs which would free people from scruple about turning against this cult. How often, in days of old, had magistrates forbidden foreign worship, banned petty priests from the Forum, and burned their prophetic books, for men most learned in all human and divine law were accustomed to hold that nothing was so destructive of true service to the gods as where sacrifices were performed not by native but by foreign ritual. The people were therefore not to fear the anger of the gods, the true gods of Rome, when they saw measures being taken against the followers of Bacchus. The Senate had entrusted the investigation of the affair to the consuls, and the consuls would crush the cult, while the lesser magistrates would prevent night assemblies. Individual citizens would do their duty by obeying lawful orders.49 The whole speech suggests that the res publica is in danger, that there is conspiracy, but Postumius carefully avoids any actual mention of sedition, still less treason; it is feared for the future, but has not yet occurred. This limitation is confirmed by Cicero’s reference to the affair.50 It has indeed been suggested that the legal basis for the Senate’s action rested simply on the decemviral prohibition of nocturnal gatherings.51 Before the assembly was dismissed, the decree of the Senate establishing the quaestio extraordinaria was read, rewards were offered for information, help to would-be fugitives was forbidden, and those who failed to respond to a summons, unless for good cause, were warned that they would be condemned in their absence.52 This last was rather different from the situation in developed Roman criminal law. The reactions There followed panic throughout the City, and this spread, as fast as letters could be sent, throughout Italy. This panic is less surprising when one remembers how very traditional was the worship of Liber, and the importance, particularly to the plebeians, of the festival of the Liberalia and its theatrical games.53 49 50
51 52 53
See Livy 39.15.1–14. Cicero, leg. 2.15.37. After approving mystery religions for his ideal state, but not when performed by women at night (leg. 2.14.35), he went on to stress that female reputations must be guarded even during the day, and that the mysteries of Ceres must be firmly traditional, as declared by the severity of the ancient decree of the Senate on the Bacchanals. Cicero, it is generally reckoned, drew on different annalists from Livy. ‘ne qui in urbe coetus nocturnos agitaret’ (XII T 8.26); see Mantovani (1989), 19–21. See Livy 39.16.1–13; 39.17.1–3. On theatrical performances as normative ‘games’, see Robinson (1992), 160–2.
18
T H E B A C C H A N A L I A N A F FA I R
The panic was presumably felt more strongly by the followers of the new form of the cult; it is not clear if the more than 7,000 persons affected, as reported by Livy, all fell into this category. Many people attempted to flee, but many were arrested by the guards the tresviri had placed on the gates. Some people, both men and women, committed suicide after being reported as initiates. The ringleaders, Marcus and Gaius Atinius of the Roman plebeians – new characters – and the Faliscan Lucius Opicernius with the Campanian Minius Cerrinius were all arrested. Hispala’s story had named as the leaders Minius and Herennius Cerrinius, together with their mother, Paculla Annia, but clearly that information was out of date.54 However, so many people had escaped that the praetors, urban and peregrine, acting on the authority of the Senate, declared a iustitium, the adjournment of all court business for thirty days; this strongly suggests that significant numbers of the senatorial and equestrian classes were among those missing. So many had fled, and so few were responding to the summons to report themselves, that the consuls went on circuit around Italy to make investigations and to conduct trials.55 This was an outrageous usurpation of authority, since at this period Rome had no rights over the other Italian cities, who were in theory her free allies. The consuls destroyed all Bacchanalian sites of worship, unless there was an ancient altar or consecrated image.56 The Senate decreed that for the future there should be no Bacchanalia in Rome or Italy. Anyone who considered such a rite to be traditional and necessary, and one which he could not forgo without having to atone for a breach of religious duty, must report this to the Urban Praetor who in turn was to refer the matter to the Senate. If, with not less than one hundred senators present, permission was granted, such a person might carry out the rites, but with no more than five persons taking part in the sacrifice, and there was to be no common fund, and nobody was to be master of the rites or priest.57
The Senate’s resolutions For this we have confirmation from the Bruttium inscription.58 In relation to the issue of the Senate’s jurisdiction, Toynbee discusses the status of the 54 55 56 57
58
See Livy 39.17.4–7. See Livy 39.18.1–2: ‘circa fora profisci ibique quaerere et iudicia exercere’. Livy 39.18.3–7. Livy 39.18.8–9. On this point of the necessity of following one’s traditional religious duties, one could compare the Romans’ reluctant toleration of Judaism (except of course when there was armed revolt). CIL X 104; ILS 18. The translation here is based on that of Walsh (1994). It has been pointed out by Accame (1938), 223, that Livy, following the annalists, is probably closer to the originals than is this inscription.
19
T H E B A C C H A N A L I A N A F FA I R
territory where this particular inscription was found, the ager Teuranus. It, like various other territories, might have been annexed to the ager Romanus after the end of the Hannibalic War; on the other hand we know that Tarentum was not so annexed, and Bacchanalians were pursued there in 184 BC and after.59 Although it is normally referred to as the SC de Bacchanalibus, it is widely agreed that what we have here is not one senatusconsult but a conflation of a number of senatorial resolutions, issued in the form of a letter by the consuls to the local authorities.60 In translation the inscription reads: The consuls Quintus Marcius, son of Lucius, and Spurius Postumus, son of Lucius, consulted the Senate on the seventh day of October in the temple of Bellona. The recording officers were Marcus Claudius, son of Marcus, Lucius Valerius, son of Publius, and Quintus Minucius, son of Gaius. Concerning the Bacchanalia they resolved that this edict be issued to allies bound by treaty.61 ‘Let none of them be minded to conduct a Bacchic rite. If there are some who say it is necessary for them to hold such a rite, they must come to the Urban Praetor at Rome and, when their statement has been heard, our Senate is to decide such matters, provided that no fewer than 100 senators are present when the matter is discussed. Let no person, whether Roman citizen, or one of Latin status, or one of the allies, be minded to attend Bacchic rites without approaching the Urban Praetor, and without his authorisation in compliance with the decision of the Senate, provided that no fewer than 100 senators are present when the matter is discussed.’ Resolved. ‘No man shall be a priest; no man or woman shall be master of ceremonies; none among them shall be minded to administer a common fund. Nor shall they be minded to appoint any man or woman a master or vice-master of ceremonies. Nor shall they be minded henceforward to conspire, make vows together, or make guarantees or promises; nor be minded to pledge their faith with one another. No-one must be minded to celebrate rites in secret;
59 60
61
Toynbee (1965), 120 n. 6; 397 n. 2. On balance, it seems not erected on Roman territory. See particularly Fraenkel (1932), Gelzer (1936), Martina (1998), Albanese (2001). Fraenkel held that there had been a degree of editing by the receiving magistrate, denied by Keil (1933) and Gelzer. Albanese even suggests, not very convincingly, that we have only the second tablet from a longer edict, and that the first part dealt with the physical objects used in the Bacchic cult. Albanese (2001), 7ff, translates foederati differently: ‘that this edict be issued to those sworn to the Bacchanalian cult’, pointing out that the prohibitions are addressed to individuals not communities; this is also the view of Toynbee (1965), 400.
20
T H E B A C C H A N A L I A N A F FA I R
nor let anyone be minded to celebrate them publicly, privately, or outside the City, without approaching the Urban Praetor and without his authorisation in compliance with the decision of the Senate, provided that no fewer than 100 senators are present when the matter is discussed.’ Resolved. ‘Let nobody be minded to celebrate rites in numbers greater than five in all, men and women; more than two men and more than three women must not attend there, unless by the decision of the Urban Praetor and of the Senate, as has been written above.’ Resolved. You [the socii] must proclaim these measures in your assembly at least by the third market-day, and so that you may be aware of the decision of the Senate, it was as follows: ‘If there are any persons who in this matter act otherwise than has been written above, the senators have resolved that a capital charge must be laid against them.’ And the Senate resolved that it be right that you engrave this proclamation on a bronze tablet, and bid it to be nailed up where it can most easily be read; and you are to ensure that any Bacchic object, other than what is sacred there, should be dismantled, as has been written above, within ten days of the tablets being given to you. (In the territory of the Teurani.) There are certain oddities about these decisions. One is the limitation on the number of women present to three; why should there not be five women? Traditionally it was a female cult. This may have been to stress that the celebration of the cult must be a matter of religious necessity, not the excuse for a sodalitas, or even the equivalent of a sociable Mothers’ Union meeting. Then, the capital nature of non-compliance is presented almost as a parenthesis.62 Yet the death penalty seems summary and of an unlimited nature, covering future as well as past deeds – a huge arrogation of power. Nor is there any mention of conventional crimes, flagitia, in the inscription, but they might have been subject to appeal (provocatio), and therefore ignored in a consular edict, that is, if they ever existed. Hardly an oddity, but an ambiguity, is the question of whether the consular letter is to be proclaimed within three weeks, or over a period of three weeks. The cult was to be repressed, but not annihilated. North remarks that it seems re-established by the middle of the second century BC, for its followers, along with others, were expelled from Rome in 139.63 Archaeological
62 63
Strachan-Davidson (1912), I 232f, thinks that this was the original SC at the start of the affair. North (1979), citing Valerius Maximus 1.3.3.
21
T H E B A C C H A N A L I A N A F FA I R
evidence confirms that the cult was widely familiar in Rome of the first century BC; Bruhl refers to the evidence from many statues and paintings of this period.64 Indeed Spartacus had a ‘wife’ who was a Bacchic priestess.65 And the cult continued under the Empire.66 Livy on the Senate’s conduct Let us return to Livy’s account. Those who admitted to having been initiated, to having joined the coniuratio, but who denied that they had committed any crimes, were left in prison,67 but those convicted – by more than rumour? – of stuprum or murder, perjury and false witness, forged seals, substitution of wills and other frauds, were put to death, and we are told by Livy that this group, both men and women, formed the majority. (The absence of provocatio was presumably because no tribune of the people was minded to use his auxilium.68) The women were, if possible, handed over to their families for private execution, which otherwise took place in public.69 These people, therefore, were convicted of specific crimes, not of membership of the cult. Nippel, indeed, sees the affair in simple criminal terms. He sees no sedition, no protest movement. Indeed, despite the evidence of the SC, he sees no evidence for the suppression of a cult, but rather the strengthening of the official cults of the nobility; the stamping of Romanness on foreigners.70 However, there is no mention in the inscription, in the resolutions of the Senate, of any flagitia, which would surely have been the case had they been the main target. So how credible is Livy’s story? If there really were orgiastic murders on any wide scale, then it is not unreasonable to accept the consequent forgery of a victim’s will in some individual cases. But to believe that this was the policy of the cultists stretches my imagination too far. ‘The purpose is to generate funds for the cult.’71 Bauman argues that the prohibition of a common fund was for this end, and that the restriction to five on the
64 65 66
67
68
69 70 71
Bruhl (1953), 119; 145–59. Plut. Vit.Crassus 8. Virgil’s Bucolics, Eclogue 5, like the Villa of the Mysteries at Pompeii, shows some survival of Bacchic worship, but Pailler (1988), 745, holds it to have been diversified and banalised in the course of the centuries; see also Foucher (1981). For how long is not mentioned. Presumably, sooner or later, the tribunes will have used their auxilium for the prisoners’ release, but see Santalucia (1988) and (1999); cf. Eisenhut (1972). Bauman (1990), 338, fn. 11, rather strangely explains that Mommsen justifies the absence of provocatio as being because the crimes were non-political, and Kunkel as because only common law crimes were involved. See Livy 39.18.4–6; Val. Max. 6.3.7. Nippel (1997), 65–73; his position is closer to that of North than of Gruen. Bauman (1990), 342.
22
T H E B A C C H A N A L I A N A F FA I R
numbers permitted to meet for worship72 was to prevent legally valid mancipatory wills. But to make a mancipatory will one needed six adult male citizens, the one known as the libripens and five witnesses,73 so that argument, particularly when the five persons could be of any status or either sex, is very weak. The Senate could not have been thinking in these terms because, in this context, women were non-entities; not even ten women could have made a will. The generation of funds is an explanation that fits modern, especially American, cults, but is unconvincing for Republican Rome, especially as there seems to have been no one centre of worship. Other arguments supporting the reality of the flagitia are also weak. Nocturnal meetings were not previously unknown, and the wholesale effeminisation of men of military age I find totally incredible – most young men in my observation enjoy their virility. As to ‘the initiation of masses of slaves who were already in a state of unrest’, it is indisputable that there was unrest during and after the hardships of the Punic Wars, and this provides an explanation for the insurrections in Apulia and elsewhere throughout the 180s, but Livy’s own evidence argues for relatively few slaves as initiates of the Bacchic rites; the initiates are generally described as of good family, or at least liable for military service. And the presence of slaves as initiates (not in itself necessarily shocking; later collegia had slave as well as free members) would anyway be largely irrelevant to the alleged crimes of stuprum and forgery. Livy seems to have absorbed what had become a tradition concerning the flagitia; he was, as has been remarked already, concerned to justify the Senate’s suppression of the Bacchanals, and to deplore the moral decline of Rome.
After-shocks A further decree of the Senate, proposed by Marcius Philippus, postponed the general consideration of informers until Postumius had completed his investigations and returned to Rome. Marcius had been active in Etruria, where the ‘Bacchic’ version of the cult had originated; Postumius was concerned with suppression in southern Italy,74 where indeed he seems not to have been totally successful. For this was not quite the end of Livy’s account of the affair. In 184 BC Lucius Postumius, pro-praetor with Tarentum as his province, had to deal with a conspiracy of shepherds, after a slave insurrection in Apulia, and he also wound up what was left of the Bacchanalian investigation. Frank thought that these shepherds ‘were probably Tarentine and Locrian slaves who were persecuted because of the worship of Dionysus’;
72 73 74
Livy 39.18.9; ILS 18, ll.19–21. Gaius 2.102–8 for the technicalities of the mancipatory will. Livy 39.20.1 and 39.23.1 and 3.
23
T H E B A C C H A N A L I A N A F FA I R
Toynbee held that ‘shepherds’ was a term of art for Bacchic initiates.75 Lucius Postumius condemned some of those brought before him as Bacchants, and presumably executed them; others he sent to the Senate at Rome where the Urban Praetor, Publius Cornelius, threw them all into the prison.76 Perhaps those held in prison were in due course released, after tribunician intercession; but we hear nothing more. Further, there may or may not be a connection with the fact that in 184 BC there was seen a need to assign a praetor, Quintus Naevius Matho, to investigate cases of poisoning, as well as to his proper province, governing Sardinia; the poisonings were alleged in the City as well as in the municipalities and rural districts, and, if Valerius Antias is to be trusted, says Livy, Naevius condemned some 2,000 persons.77 In 181 BC the praetor, a certain L. Duronius, selected for Apulia, still had Bacchanalians to pursue, seeds left over from former troubles sprouting afresh; he was ordered to extirpate them, so that there should be no further spread.78 It is possible that there was also a Bacchanalian connection to the poisoning inquiries assigned by the Senate to separate praetors for within and outside the City in 180 BC.79 Or it may be that these alleged poisonings were not so much connected with the cult itself as linked to the fraudulent wills and other forgeries described. It was clearly an uneasy time. The Senate also decided that Minius Cerrinius, as a Campanian, should be sent in chains to Ardea, whose magistrates were to keep him under close guard, against suicide as well as escape.80 What eventually happened to him is not recorded, but this suggests strongly that he had not yet been convicted of anything; the Senate, indeed, was primarily concerned with the behaviour of Romans. After Postumius’ return Aebutius and Hispala were given financial rewards by senatorial decree: 100,000 asses each, sufficient to be rated in the first census class, to be given them from the aerarium by the quaestors. The consul would negotiate with the tribunes that they propose to the people that Aebutius be treated as though he had completed his military service, so that he would not have to serve, and the censor would not assign him a public horse; this reward was almost certainly barbed.81
75
76 77 78 79 80 81
Frank (1927), 130; Toynbee (1965), 321, citing Wuilleumier (1939). The connection is accepted by many authors, e.g. Dume´zil (1966), and Bauman (1990), but others, such as Gruen (1990), think the linked tasks mere coincidence. Livy 39.29.8; 39.41.6–7. Livy 39.38.3; 39.41.5–6. Livy 40.19.9–10. Presumably this praetor was some kind of kin to Aebutius’ mother. Livy 40.37.4–7, and 40.43.2–3; also 40.44.6 of 179 BC. Livy 39.19.2. The Senate was prepared to give him the money, but did not actually want him to do his military service and become eligible for a political career; he was tainted by having been an informer. See Watson (2005).
24
T H E B A C C H A N A L I A N A F FA I R
Hispala was granted the right to alienate her property, presumably even against her tutor’s wishes, to marry outside the gens or clan, to choose a tutor, just as though these had been granted by a husband in his will; also, explicitly, she could marry someone freeborn.82 It is not entirely clear what the details mean, but she seems to be being put in the position of someone freeborn and sui iuris; further, she was to be under the protection of the consuls and praetors for her lifetime.83 The people approved all these measures; questions of immunity or reward for other informers were left to the consuls.84 The basic suppression of the cult was on the authority of the Senate alone. These grants do not seem to be anachronistic, but this merely confirms that the romance, if it is a fiction, was constructed close to the time it describes. Foreign cults The factual basis of Livy’s account – we have already considered the romantic story element – is confirmed by the objective evidence of the inscription giving the substance of the texts of the SCC. We can be certain that the Bacchanalian cult was suppressed in 186 BC, and that only carefully limited exemptions from the ban on the cult were permitted, although to traditional worshippers of Liber these must have seemed extremely oppressive. The Romans (like most polytheists) were generally tolerant of people’s private worship and, for the most part, of other public worship. They needed, for the health of their society, the Roman gods to be worshipped in the traditional way in the temples of Rome, but were generally indifferent to other religious practice.85 Yet, as we have seen, Livy records the consul as saying: How often in the times of our fathers and grandfathers was the task assigned to the magistrates of forbidding the introduction of
82
83
84 85
When Hispala was manumitted, her mistress, being a woman, although she could have had full ownership of a slave, could not have been the tutor of her freedwoman; further, all women outside paternal power (patria potestas) needed, at this period, a tutor to supervise quite a wide range of transactions, including the alienation of property classified as res mancipi. A tutor must have been appointed for her at manumission; we do not know why she later found herself without one. The right to marry a freeborn man seems likely to be aimed at Aebutius; at this period it was socially disapproved of but not illegal for an upper-class man to marry a freedwoman, but then Hispala was not a respectable woman of freed status, but an ex-prostitute. The meaning of this grant is obscure partly because it is the only use of the term enuptio gentis; see Watson (1974). Since her social status was low, it is less likely that her reward was double-edged. Livy 39.19.3–7. Robinson (1992), 199, 201. See, however, ch. 5.
25
T H E B A C C H A N A L I A N A F FA I R
foreign cults, of excluding petty priests and fortune-tellers from the Forum, the Circus and the City, of searching out and burning books of prophecies, and of stamping out every method of sacrifice except that performed in the Roman way.86 And indeed there were examples of such repression, both in the period referred to and in Livy’s own time (he died in AD 17).87 The burning of the Pythagorean Books, also known as the books of Numa, took place in 181 88 BC, clearly in the shadow of the Bacchanalian affair. Magi were expelled from Rome and other measures taken against them as early as 213 BC,89 and this happened again in 139 BC.90 In 154 BC, or soon after, the Senate ordered the demolition of the first stone theatre, newly constructed for the ludi Megalenses, the ‘games’ for the Great Mother, because it posed a danger to public morals.91 In 97 BC human sacrifice was formally banned as a religious excess;92 this fits with Plutarch’s story that the Romans were about to punish some barbarian tribe for human sacrifice, but when they heard it had been ancestral custom, they remitted the punishment, although forbidding the practice for the future.93 In Livy’s own time, there were various attacks on the shrines of Isis at Rome.94 Augustus in 28 BC forbade Egyptian rites within the pomerium, and in 21 BC this ban was extended to the suburbs. Druidism was prohibited by both Augustus and Tiberius.95 But this seems pretty well the sum of suppression over approximately 150 years. Repression, whether in the second or first century, was thus relatively unusual. Indeed, in 212 BC, under the guidance of the Sibylline Books, games for Apollo of Delphi, an undoubtedly Greek god, had been officially introduced. In 204 BC an even more foreign cult was introduced, the 86 87
88
89
90 91 92 93 94 95
Livy 39.16.8. Evans (1993) suggests that Livy modelled much of his story on the ‘correct’ view of the Catiline affair, but this concerned sedition rather than religion; nevertheless ‘coniuratio‘ was the link. Livy 40.29.2–14. Dume´zil (1966), 496, links Pythagoreanism and the cult of Bacchus. As the Loeb editors (E.T. Sage and A.C. Schlesinger), p. 91 n. 6, point out, there seems strangely to have been no formal consultation of the pontiffs; the Senate simply relied on the praetor’s oath as to the books’ subversive character. But then, there is no mention of any formal consultation in 186 BC. Livy 25.1.6–12. But in 213 the restrictions were limited to the City, there was no provision for active investigation, and Livy does not report on the results; furthermore, Rome was then still seriously at war, not triumphant as in 186. Val. Max. 1.3.3. Livy epit. 48; Val. Max. 2.4.2. Pliny, HN 30.12, but magic was involved here. Plutarch, Quaestiones romanae (Moralia iv), 83. See Beard (1994), 763, with sources. Val. Max. 1.3.4; Tac. Ann. 2.85; Dio Cassius 53.2.4; 54.6.6; Pliny HN 30.4.13; Suet. Claud. 25.5; Pliny HN 29.12.54.
26
T H E B A C C H A N A L I A N A F FA I R
bringing of the Magna Mater – she turned out to be a black stone – from Phrygia,96 at whose games the curule aediles may have introduced the divisive and bitterly resented segregation of senatorial seats.97 Dionysus of Halicarnassus, in his account of the establishment of Roman religion, is instructive on how the Senate wished to control religious practices. He first remarks that among Roman citizens there are to be seen ‘no ecstatic transports, no Corybantic frenzies, no begging under the colour of religion, no bacchanals or secret mysteries, no all-night vigils of men and women together in the temples, nor any other mummery of this kind’.98 He then reports that there were naturally innumerable peoples coming to Rome under the necessity of practising the worship of their ancestral gods in their traditional ways, yet Rome celebrates them in accordance with her own traditions, after banishing all fabulous claptrap. The rites of Mater Magna are a case in point, for the praetors perform sacrifices and celebrate games in her honour every year, according to Roman customs, but the priest and priestess of the goddess are Phrygians, and it is they who carry her image in procession through the City, begging alms in her name according to their custom, and accompanied by musicians. ‘But by a law and decree of the Senate no native Roman walks in procession through the City, arrayed in a particoloured robe, begging alms or escorted by flute-players, or worships the goddess with Phrygian ceremonies.’99 Thus was a mystery religion tamed. Hence a religious motive for the repression of the Bacchanals is by no means impossible, because it was not exactly a sudden and severe reversal of previous policy, but it seems highly unlikely that it was the sole motive. Yet, as the SC shows, this was the form, whatever the pretext, whatever the hidden agenda, that the repression took. Further, two of those who assisted at the drafting, Valerius Flaccus and Claudius Marcellus, were members of the college of pontiffs; the pontifex maximus at that time was P. Licinius Crassus Dives, consul in 205 with Scipio Africanus. He may well be the learned lawyer referred to by Postumius; he was already a pontiff in 213 BC.
Whose plot? It is widely agreed by most modern scholars that the affair was rigged, and rigged by the Senate rather than individual members of it. For example, as 96 97 98 99
Livy 29.14.5–14. Her temple was consecrated in 191 (Livy 36.36.4). Wiseman (1998), 40. Dion. Hal. 2.19.2. Dion. Hal. 2.19.4–5 – all too undignified! Cf. Val. Max. 7.7.6 on the exile of the slave who castrated himself for the goddess.
27
T H E B A C C H A N A L I A N A F FA I R
Bauman points out, the three men listed as assisting the two consuls in drawing up the Senate’s resolution were ‘L. Valerius Flaccus (cos. 195), mentor and running mate of Cato; M. Claudius Marcellus (cos. 196), an ally of Flaminius; and Q. Minucius Rufus (cos. 197), an ally of Scipio Africanus’.100 There is no mention anywhere in Livy of conflicting opinion; there is no credible opportunity in his account to see separate groups looking to Cato and to the Scipios. Of course, there may have been some level of disagreement, but it was not out in the open. The Senate acted to repress the ‘threat’ to social stability that it had discovered, both in Roman territory and outside it, among the allies. The Senate alone created the quaestio extraordinaria, gave the consuls a mandate to act as they thought fit to implement the Senate’s instructions, and gave powers to punish without any form of appeal. The Senate exercised this jurisdiction over Roman, Latin and other Italian citizens. The populace was informed, but not consulted, and no lex was passed, as the inscription confirms, until after the event. The affair was political rather than legal. As has been said,101 Livy gives us a much better chance of understanding the senatorial propaganda of the period than of reconstructing what actually happened. The Senate was flexing its muscles in the new triumphalism that followed victory in the First and Second Punic wars; the Senate was, as a body, concerned to exercise its control over its individual members for the (relatively speaking) common good.102 This is not to deny that religion was a sincerely held means of expressing, of illuminating, the Senate’s role as the guardian of all things Roman, particularly religious; it was after all the Senate which had played the leading role in the establishment of the Magna Mater. The danger in the Bacchic worship had been that it was both widespread and not under any official control; its priests might, just might, have been up to anything, and hence the particular attack on its priests or other officers.103 Some senators, doubtful of the portrait presented to them, may nevertheless have gone along with the measures against the Bacchanals simply because alien religion was involved, others because firm control had been exercised over a popular cult. So what can we learn here of Roman penal practice or policy? That this was a period too early for there to be criminal law in any meaningful legal sense, although there were constitutional conventions which might or might not be observed. That political aims dominated policy and could create ‘crime’ when it was expedient; in later periods it was really only treason that was so lacking in consistent principle. That the repression of 100 101 102 103
Bauman (1990), 345. North (1979), 87. Gruen (1990), 65ff. This attempt to cut out the ringleaders is also obvious in the persecution of the Christians, see ch. 5. There are other parallels too.
28
T H E B A C C H A N A L I A N A F FA I R
crime was pursued actively by the encouragement of informers to bring the ‘criminals’ to the attention of the authorities, a tendency that was to endure. That women were seen as weak and prone to corruption, but also to be feared as the source of religious unrest, and this in spite of the ringleaders all being male; this view of women as the weaker, but dangerous, sex is indeed a rhetorical topos. That male rape was an issue – throughout Roman history, there was violent disapproval of citizens taking the passive role in homosexual relations, so to force this on a freeborn boy was a huge outrage. It was, and remained, one of the surest ways of stirring up public indignation.104 That forgeries of wills and other documents also cut at the trusted base of upper-class life, and so reports of such doings whipped up feelings among senators and their kin. That, at least on this occasion, punishment was harsh. We may reckon that the report of 7,000 put to death was an exaggeration, but clearly the death penalty was widely imposed.105 At this period, very differently from Polybius’ account of Roman criminal trials some fifty years later, there was evidently no tacit assumption that citizens, or at least upper-class citizens, were immune from physical penalties.106 But although these elements of the affair represent or foreshadow later developments, the essentials of the ‘conspiracy’, what it was, who instigated it and why, who were involved in the rites and what they did, and why the authorities, at a time when the state was not greatly in danger from external forces, should have chosen to indulge in large-scale repression, all remain obscure.107
104
105
106 107
Cf. CTh 9.7.3 (AD 342) and 6 (AD 390). MacCary (1975) thinks this issue, the belief that male initiates must be subjected to homosexual intercourse, was the main reason for the suppression, and indeed Walsh (1996), 200, accepts the idea that there was ‘systematic sexual abuse’. The witchcraft trials of the early modern world make a natural comparison, and perhaps they were even influenced by Livy’s account; see Pailler (1988), 797–816, discussing the influence of the Bacchanalian affair on ‘Europe’s inner demons’. Polybius 6.14.7; and see Robinson (2004b). So also do the practical questions of how, by what method, were those convicted executed? And who carried out the executions of so many?
29
Chapter 2 CICERO, MURDER AND THE COURTS
In this chapter I want to consider one of Cicero’s murder cases, pro Roscio Amerino, making some comparisons, where relevant, with pro Cluentio of some fourteen years later, which is also concerned with death in the upper ranks of municipal life. (In each there is an all-purpose off-stage villain, Chrysogonus in pro Roscio, Oppianicus senior in pro Cluentio. In each Cicero starts by saying that he will prove positively his client’s innocence, but later, quite properly, reverts to throwing the burden of proof on the accuser.) The speech on behalf of Sextus Roscius from Ameria is one of Cicero’s earliest, and his first criminal trial; he was probably twenty-seven years old when he made it in 80 BC.1 (We have one earlier speech surviving, pro Publio Quinctio, delivered the previous year, which dealt with a fairly complicated matter of partnership, inheritance and debt; we do not know the result.2). The charge was not simply murder, but more specifically parricide, the murder by the defendant of his father. Sextus Roscius’ acquittal seems to have made Cicero’s name as a forensic orator.3 All we know about the case comes from this speech of Cicero’s, so there is no external account of it from which we can estimate his truthfulness. Naturally his picture is slanted; he was an advocate appearing for the defence, and it was his duty to make the best possible argument for his client. He argues that the balance of probabilities, which was what a Roman jury had to decide – videtur fecisse/videtur non fecisse – was that Magnus and 1 2
3
Gellius 15.28. I have not included the name of Cicero in my citations of pro Roscio Amerino. Technically it was a causa praeiudicalis, a pre-judicial case to settle the matters really in dispute, concerning possession. Since Cicero does not boast that he won, he presumably lost; Kinsey (1971), 5, as editor of pro Quinctio, describes his success as ‘unlikely’, but Platschek (2005) just leaves it as unknown. Cicero mentions it twice, and acquittal must be inferred. ‘Thus my first criminal case, for Roscius of Ameria, won such favourable comment that I was esteemed as competent to handle any kind of litigation’ (Brut. 90.312). ‘There is particular glory and favour to be won in defending, and so much the more when it comes to the aid of someone who is oppressed by the rich and powerful, like the defence I made when a young man on behalf of Sextus Roscius of Ameria against great influence during the domination of Sulla’ (off. 2.14.51). Plut. Cic. 3.2–4, states explicitly that Sextus Roscius was acquitted.
30
C I C E R O , M U R D E R A N D T H E C O U RT S
Capito, two of the Roscii, one of the leading families, or indeed clans, in Ameria, had brought about Sextus Roscius senior’s death, and certainly the loss of his estate. The first charge does not appear, even on the facts as Cicero gives them, to be at all likely; the second is much more convincing. Cicero’s defence is based, as was common with the Romans, more on character, which was held to be consistent, than on objective evidence. Cicero’s character evidence for Sextus is mostly in the form of a rhetorical topos, a disquisition on the superiority of rural life; his client is represented as a countryman, and so ex hypothesi respectable, but he does at least provide such a laudation.4 Cicero’s reliability in setting out exactly what had happened may be doubted, but he would have been limited by the need for plausibility, particularly as to the kind of facts with which the members of the jury would be well acquainted. To have been caught out in a direct untruth (as opposed to a misdirection) would have damaged his credibility; oratory might be used to make the worse appear the better part, but there were rules to the game. Sextus Roscius junior’s trial, like that of Cluentius, took place before the quaestio perpetua de sicariis et veneficiis;5 both trials reflect a society where the ravages of civil war had undermined social stability and trust, in the Italian municipalities perhaps even more than in Rome. Before looking at the actual trial, I shall give an outline of the court system, and then a rapid survey of the political background.
The system of the standing jury-courts The quaestiones perpetuae were the standing jury-courts, of which the first had been established in 149 BC by the lex Calpurnia de repetundis to deal with extortion in the provinces by Roman magistrates. These courts were in permanent session in the sense that, whenever a relevant accusation was made, the praetor in charge of a particular court for the year in question could proceed at once to the enrolment of a jury, chosen from an album (list), also valid for the year. The list of potential jurors or iudices6 was drawn up annually by the Urban Praetor; the jurors were taken from the upper orders of society, sometimes senators, sometimes equestrians,7 sometimes – and always after 70 BC – from both orders.8 This question of 4 5 6
7 8
In pro Cluentio by contrast, he makes virtually no mention of Cluentius’ personal character, although covering him with the praise of his father. Cicero uses both de veneficis, concerning poisoners, and de veneficiis, concerning poisonings; both forms seem appropriate in the context of the court. The term iudices literally means judges, but in the context of the quaestiones perpetuae is normally translated as jurors; Cicero is usually understood to address the ‘gentlemen of the jury’. The cavalry of early Rome; the class below, and to some extent overlapping, the senators. And sometimes more widely. On post-Sullan juries, see, still, Greenidge (1901), 436–56; Greenidge remains a reliable guide to the procedure of these courts in Cicero’s time, pp. 456–504, ‘The course of the trial’. Augustus relieved senators of the duty.
31
C I C E R O , M U R D E R A N D T H E C O U RT S
the composition of the juries was, for some fifty years after C. Gracchus’ changes in 122 BC an extremely sensitive political question.9 In the 80s Sulla had reversed the Gracchan use of equestrian jurors and in his time the juries were composed exclusively of senators.10 There is a noticeable difference in Cicero’s attitudes to the jurors in pro Roscio and pro Cluentio. In the trial of Sextus Roscius there was a Sullan jury, all senators, comprising perhaps 32 iudices. Cicero speaks respectfully to them as representatives of all that is best in the res publica. In the later trial there was a mixed jury, with probably some 75 iudices, and Cicero could refer to a senatorial jury of 74 BC as having been heavily bribed; this indeed was an important part of his defence of Cluentius. The senatorial members would have had to accept this, because it was a notorious scandal, and the equestrian jurors might have been secretly somewhat amused. During his dictatorship in 82–81 BC only a year or so before the trial of Sextus Roscius, Sulla revised the statutes governing the standing jurycourts, creating for the first time a systematic criminal legal system.11 Each statute defined its crime, and laid down the procedure and the penalty.12 This was the ordo iudiciorum publicorum, or simply the ordo, further and finally regulated by the Emperor Augustus.13 There is no reason to doubt that Sulla did intend the courts to take over the care of public order; otherwise he would hardly have established or re-established them. There were courts, each set up by its own statute, dealing with treason (maiestas), with extortion by governors in the provinces (de repetundis), with the embezzlement of public funds (de peculatu), with the forging of documents and coining (de falsis), with murder (de sicariis et veneficiis), and probably with assault (iniuria) and with electoral corruption (ambitus). The quaestio perpetua de vi (violence, sedition) was post-Sullan; it is unclear whether it was established by the lex Lutatia or the lex Plautia.14 Each court dealt with one crime or group of crimes: for example, the misappropriation of public monies properly received – de residuis – fell 9 10 11 12
13
14
See Brunt (1988), 194–239. For the details of assigning a Sullan jury, see Greenidge (1901), 437–42. Cloud (1994), 530; Robinson (1995b), 2–3. We have nearly the whole of one such statute, the lex on the tabula Bembina, commonly known as the lex Acilia (FIRA i no.7, p. 84; RS I 39–112). It is pre-Sullan, so there may well have been subsequent changes of detail, but it is clear from Cicero’s speeches that it illustrates the normal outline of a trial. The lex Iulia iudiciorum publicorum of 17 BC, a judicature act, as one might say. This is why the establishing statutes are nearly all either a lex Cornelia (from Sulla) or a lex Iulia (from Caesar or Augustus). All other courts deviated from the ordo, and so were described as extra ordinem – extraordinary in a very narrow sense. On the establishment of these courts generally, see Cloud (1994), 512–26; on the statutes on vis, see Vitzthum (1966). Cicero was able to remark that all crimes were covered by these courts (‘cum omnium peccatorum quaestiones sint’, Balb. 28.65), but this was because of the great scope of the delictual actions.
32
C I C E R O , M U R D E R A N D T H E C O U RT S
under the court for the embezzlement of public funds, and the acceptance of bribes by those involved officially in the judicial process was classed as extortion. Each court had a magistrate, normally a praetor but sometimes an ex-aedile – in either case he could be called quaesitor (but the term iudex quaestionis seems restricted to the ex-aediles) – who was appointed, or rather allotted, by the Senate to preside over it for the year of his term of office. It was to him that accusations were made, and it was his duty to decide whether the accusation was competent and should be accepted. There might need to be a preliminary hearing, with a jury, if there were several persons seeking to bring an accusation;15 this was because only one man could speak as the formal accuser, but he was allowed supporters, who were called subscriptores. If there were multiple charges, it was for the praetor, presumably the Urban Praetor, to allot the case as seemed most suitable according to set rules.16 A majority verdict was required for a condemnation.17 The quaestio perpetua de sicariis et veneficis The quaestio perpetua based on the lex Cornelia de sicariis et veneficis had become by Sulla’s time, with the bringing together of two older courts, the single murder court.18 It also had jurisdiction over parricide,19 urban arson,20 and in some cases the corrupt procuring of the condemnation of an innocent person on a capital charge.21 C. Sempronius Gracchus, in whose tribunate all-equestrian juries had been introduced, had had a law – apparently the first on the topic since the Twelve Tables22 – passed against any form of judicial corruption, ne quis in iudicio circumveniatur, which had been 15
16 17
18
19 20 21
22
This was called a divinatio; Cicero won the case against Caecilius to be allowed to prosecute Verres (divinatio in Caecilium); see also Tac. Ann. 3.10.1, considered in chapter 3, where there was competition to prosecute Piso. Quint. inst. or. 3.10.1. Three verdicts were possible in a criminal trial at this period, rather as in Scots law: guilty, not guilty, and non liquet, or no vote; the third Scots verdict is ‘not proven’. For a condemnation, there must be a majority, non liquet counted as an acquittal; the verdict on Oppianicus (treated in pro Cluentio) was clear if close, 17 votes to 15 (Cicero, Caecina 10.29). The rule that an equality of votes for condemnation and acquittal meant acquittal is a limited argument for the acceptance of a presumption of innocence. For an analysis of the statute, see Ferrary (1991). On the content in practice see generally Robinson (1995b), 41–47. I think, contra Cloud (1968) and (1994), that this creation of one murder court, even if it sat in several divisions, was Sulla’s purpose. Further, I agree with Alexander (2002), 187, that the divisions were pragmatic, and that from this time on the same president and the same jurors could hear any form of murder. Since at least 86 BC (Cicero, inv. 2.19.58). Based on XII T 8.10; D 48.8.1pr, Marcian. See also MacCormack (1972). D 48.8.1pr-1, Marcian; PS 5.23.1. Cicero argued in Cluentius’ trial that this section could not at that time apply to a member of the equestrian order since the equestrians had not been eligible to serve (Cic. Clu. 52.144–57.157). XII T 9.3 = Gellius 20.1.7.
33
C I C E R O , M U R D E R A N D T H E C O U RT S
aimed at abuse of official power rather than bribery. This law may originally have had a quaestio of its own,23 but it seems to have been subsumed into Sulla’s murder statute in altered form to fit the new circumstances. Earlier, the quaestio de sicariis had dealt with gangsters (the urban equivalent of rural bandits), professional thugs and killers, which explains why the language used in the statute is apparently more concerned with going about armed in preparation for committing murder or theft than with actual killing; attempts very definitely fell within its scope.24 This kind of behaviour came to be dealt with primarily by the legislation on vis in the 70s and later. The quaestio de veneficiis was at least as old as the century and probably dated back to the 120s BC; there had been several notorious quaestiones extraordinariae earlier in the second century to investigate particularly shocking cases of poisoning.25 The fifth chapter of the lex Cornelia covered making, selling and buying poison, as well as using it or arranging for it to be used.26 The penalty of the law was technically capital, death, but it had become customary, by the middle of the second century BC according to Polybius,27 to allow those condemned in the assembly trials to go into exile, as long as even one century had not voted; this custom seems continued in the quaestiones perpetuae. Julius Caesar was to formalize interdiction from fire and water – outlawry – as the penalty, along with confiscation of half or all the convict’s property. It remains obscure whether this applied to those convicted of crimes not covered by the quaestiones perpetuae. The lack of a state prosecution service and the moral ambivalence of prosecution One of the main features of Roman criminal procedure is that the Romans never had a state prosecution service, although prosecution ex officio by a magistrate or provincial governor was known. For 500 years or more they relied primarily upon crimes being brought before the criminal courts by individuals, normally the victim or his kin, or else (probably) upon private criminal prosecution before the civil courts;28 this was presumably effective while Rome was a small Italian city-state. In matters where the safety of the state was involved, a magistrate would bring a charge before an assembly of the people – such trials were called iudicia populi. But as Rome grew, and urban life became more impersonal, it became normal, particularly after the establishment of the quaestiones perpetuae, to allow any adult (male) citizen in 23 24 25 26 27 28
Strachan-Davidson (1912), II 83. Cloud (1969). 184 BC (Livy 39.38.3); 180 BC (Livy 40.37 and 43); 152 Max. 6.3.8). D 48.8.3pr, Marcian. Polybius 6.14.7; Robinson (2004b). Kunkel (1967), ‘Ein direktes Zeugnis’.
34
BC
(Livy 40.44.6; per. 48; cf. Val.
C I C E R O , M U R D E R A N D T H E C O U RT S
good standing to bring an accusation if he became aware of a crime; indeed, it became something to be encouraged, even rewarded, and it was with the rewards that moral doubts developed. Plautus in one of his plays has a professional parasite (a low character) unwilling to be an informer (neque quadruplari me volo); it was unbecoming to snap up the property of others without personal risk, and the character would like a law making the successful accuser give half his proceeds to the public purse.29 Accusers were technically delators, delatores nominis, since they laid before the president of the relevant court the name of the accused; the term is often translated by ‘informers’. Index, indices in the plural, is another term sometimes used for these men, because they pointed out, indicated, the allegedly guilty, but generally indices were closer to informers in the modern usage of the term; they were likely to be persons on the fringes of the crime under investigation.30 As Cicero said in pro Roscio: It is a useful thing that there should be a number of accusers in the state, so that audacity may be held in check by fear, . . . This is the reason why we are all ready to allow that there should be as many accusers as possible, because an innocent man, if he is accused, can be acquitted, but one who is guilty, unless he is accused, cannot be condemned. For it is more expedient that an innocent man should be acquitted than that a guilty man should not be brought to trial.31 Personal enmity or desire for revenge were considered good moral grounds for prosecuting, whether the prosecutor was the victim of a crime, or connected with him (or her). This was because the Romans held that a degree of self-help was normal and proper in a citizen’s life, although the interests of society might demand the involvement of the authorities. ‘The ordinary Roman had to be his own policeman, but he must have needed a reasonably accessible procedure to deal with capital crimes.’32 To initiate violent action was wrong, and became more so as the Empire developed, but there ought to be a balance in society between the interests of state and individual. (It was perhaps not so very different from the culture of the American West.) The institution of clientage meant that the poor would be under the protection of the powerful, thus making the playing-field more even. There was no police force, as there was not in modern Europe until the eighteenth century at the earliest. (And, as I said in my Introduction, there was not 29 30 31 32
Plautus, Persa, 62–74; this was clearly before the introduction of calumny. On quadruplatores, see Wesener (1963); Camin˜as (1984b); Cloud (1992). See also Robinson (2006). Camin˜as (1983); Cerami (1998a). Rosc. Am. 20.55–56. Lintott (1999), 156; an example is the report of a suspected crime by the missing man’s freedmen in Cic. Clu. 13.38.
35
C I C E R O , M U R D E R A N D T H E C O U RT S
really a criminal law in Rome in the modern sense, but then, neither was there in Europe before the twin forces of the Enlightenment and the Industrial Revolution.33) Self-help was nevertheless approved, not because the forces of law and order were inadequate, but because it was morally good,34 and this particularly applied to domestic offences such as rape and adultery.35 Prosecution was, however, because of its rewards, held to be a morally ambivalent act, which is why Cicero normally appeared for the defence. Sometimes loyalty, whether personal or to a province or city, could justify prosecution, as with his prosecution of Verres.36 And it was not too deplorable for a young advocate at the start of his career, before anyone would ask him to act for the defence, to bring his name into prominence in this way. Yet Cicero viewed with contempt those who made a profession of accusing. This was an attitude widely held. Quintilian, for example, a century later, said that while accusations might be made from either public or private duty, and although the laws would be powerless if nobody prosecuted, yet to live for prosecution and its rewards was brigandage – latrocinium.37 To prosecute for pay was shameful, or even criminal. Because of this system of private prosecution, and in particular because successful prosecution could be lucrative, there developed the offence of calumny under the lex Remnia, perhaps of 91 BC, extended in the Edict of the Urban Praetor.38 This was the bringing of a false charge, from malice, or frivolity, or at least with reckless disregard for the truth. Failing to make good one’s accusation did not of itself infer calumny, but after an acquittal it was the duty of the court to consider the issue.
The Social War and Sulla’s dictatorship To move now to the political and social background to pro Roscio Amerino (and also pro Cluentio).39 Partly as a result of the military burdens laid upon them by Rome’s various wars, the Italian allies of Rome had been desirous of the Roman citizenship – and its freedom from taxation – since at least around the beginning of the first century BC. In 91 BC a revolt broke out 33 34 35 36
37 38 39
Contrast Mackenzie and Hume; see Intro. Lintott (1968), 25; cf. Wesener (1958). Seneca, ira 1.21.3; Quint. inst.or. 7.4.6; Gellius 10.23; Val. Max. 6.1.13. Cf. Manfredini (2001). Pliny, at the end of the first century AD, felt uncomfortable with prosecuting, even where he saw it as his duty. Like Cicero he was much happier acting for the defence (Pliny, Ep. 3.4.8). Quint. inst.or.12.7.1–3. Camin˜as (1984a), summarised (1990), in French; Camin˜as (1994). For a fuller treatment of procedural offences, see ch. 4. For a history of these events, see, for example, Scullard (1982); Gabba (1994); Seager (1994).
36
C I C E R O , M U R D E R A N D T H E C O U RT S
which rapidly escalated into the Social War, the war of the socii or allies, which lasted some three years. It did win the Roman citizenship for all Italians south of the River Po, ‘but at a terrible cost in human lives and suffering; its economic repercussions were serious’.40 Sulla became consul in 88 BC, after the end of the war, and received Asia, and dealing with Mithridates, the ambitious king of Pontus, as his province. The tribune Sulpicius, however, contrary to the conventions of the constitution, carried a law to transfer this command to Marius. Sulla and his army marched on Rome, seized the City and annulled Sulpicius’ laws. Sulpicius, despite his tribunician sacrosanctity, was killed; Marius was declared a public enemy and fled to Africa. Octavius and Cinna, who appeared friendly to Sulla, were elected consuls. Sulla then went off to the East, where he defeated Mithridates and restored Roman power. Cinna’s behaviour was such that Octavius declared him a public enemy, but in vain; Cinna joined Marius, back from Africa, raised armies and took Rome, looting and murdering for five days. Cinna and Marius were elected consuls for 86 BC, but Marius died, and for the next three years there followed what is known as the domination of Cinna in the popularist interest. Cinna, however, was killed in 84 BC, and in 83 BC Sulla returned from the East; open war then broke out again between himself, supported by the party of the optimates, and the younger Marius, leading the populares. A number of senators were slaughtered in Rome on the orders of Marius junior shortly before Sulla reached the City. Sulla was victorious in 82 BC; he showed clemency to those who were swift to submit, but a terrible massacre of those taken prisoner at the battle of the Colline Gate of Rome was the fate of those who resisted.41 The proscriptions Under the lex Valeria of 82 BC Sulla became dictator legibus scribundis et rei publicae constituendae. He then issued an edict, proscribing his enemies.42 ‘Proscription’43 meant in practice publishing a list of those who were held to be enemies of the state; they were deprived of all rights, so that it was no crime to kill them. Indeed, rewards were paid to those who did kill them – 12,000 denarii a head, a literal head, which was to be publicly exposed in Rome; the 12,000 denarii were paid from public funds under proper 40 41
42 43
Scullard (1963), 70. Plut. Sulla 30.2–3; Seneca, clem. 1.12.2. The story goes that Sulla, speaking to the Senate as it met at the Temple of Bellona, where the shrieks of some 6,000 men dying were clearly audible, told the senators not to bother about the criminals being admonished; it was being done at his orders. For the details, see Hinard (1985), particularly pp. 35–51. The literal legal meaning of the term applied only to the confiscations, for it meant the notice of sale of such property. As in cases of bankruptcy, the estate was sold as a whole. However, the term came to be used more loosely for the outlawing of those listed.
37
C I C E R O , M U R D E R A N D T H E C O U RT S
accounting procedures. The reward for slaves was their freedom. Anyone who in any way assisted or helped one of the proscribed was to be capitally punished, as was anyone who failed to betray any of them. Once beheaded, the proscribed were not to be allowed funeral rites, but their bodies were to be dragged by iron hooks and tumbled into the Tiber, in some cases after deliberate mutilation.44 Mourning them was forbidden.45 Their estates were confiscated and auctioned off; we are told that this was for the benefit of the buyers, rather than to raise any serious sums,46 since the rewards were not paid from this source. Their children and grandchildren were deprived of their civic rights; they could not stand for a magistracy, or hold any other honour, and may have been barred from living in Rome or Italy.47 This may have been introduced by the lex Cornelia on the proscribed, a law perhaps entitled lex de proscriptione, perhaps lex de hostibus rei publicae,48 which was subsequent to the edict, and may have been intended to give Sulla’s own supporters knowledge of the extent of the vengeance. A story is told which reveals how people remembered the time of fear: Lucius Catiline had killed his brother before the civil struggle was decided, but he now asked Sulla to proscribe that brother posthumously; Sulla agreed, and in thanks Catiline brought the head of Marcus Marius Gratidianus,49 another of the proscribed, and his own brother-in-law, to Sulla where he sat in the Forum, and then washed his bloody hands there in the lustral water of Apollo.50 Such a background makes more credible Cicero’s list of charges in pro Cluentio against Oppianicus: Oppianicus was the man who was convicted of falsifying with his own hand the public records of his town, who forged a will, who by fraudulent personation secured the seals and signatures of witnesses to a sham will, who murdered the man in whose name it had been signed and sealed, who put to death his own son’s uncle when a slave and a captive, who secured the proscription and death of his own fellow-townsmen, who killed his brother and then married the 44
45 46 47
48 49
50
Cicero himself was to lose his hands, for penning the Philippics against Mark Antony, when he was beheaded in the triumviral proscription of 44 BC (Appian BC 4.4.20; Plut. Cic. 48.4). This was not unusual for those defined as enemies of the state. Cic. off. 2.8.27; 1.14.43. The buyers at auction, the sectores, could then break up the confiscated estates and sell them off piecemeal. If so, this probably applied only to the descendants of senators; there seems to be no attempt to make his continuing residence in Rome a charge against Sextus Roscius junior. Cf. Vell. Pat. 2.28.4. Hinard (1985), 75. The Gratidii, along with the Marii, were the leading families in Arpinum; they were also, unsurprisingly, connected to the Cicerones (see Rawson 1971), 76–79; Gratidianus was celebrated for his reforms of the coinage. Plut. Sulla 32.2; Seneca, ira 3.18.1–2.
38
C I C E R O , M U R D E R A N D T H E C O U RT S
widow, who gave a bribe to procure abortion, who murdered his mother-in-law, murdered his wives, murdered at one and the same time his brother’s wife with her expected children and his brother himself, and finally murdered his own children, and who, intending to give poison to his stepson, was taken in the act [not Oppianicus himself, but his minion, Scamander], and when haled to judgment after the conviction of his tools and accomplices bribed a juror to tamper with the other jurors’ votes. 51 One must remember that (as we shall see in the case of Germanicus in chapter 3) it was very easy to allege that someone had been poisoned, since the Romans had no adequate knowledge of internal diseases. On the other hand, while we do not have to believe that Oppianicus did actually poison so many of his kin, it is clear that Cicero could put forward these allegations without arousing ridicule; the cheapening of life and the coarsening of sensibility brought about by the Social Wars and the period of the proscriptions must have helped make them credible. The lex Cornelia de proscriptione included a further list of proscribed persons, and also confiscated the estates of those who had taken up arms against the res publica – that is, against Sulla and his party – including those who had fallen or would fall in the continuing fighting. The confiscation of estates52 seems to have been fixed to come to an end on 1 June 81, but the non-status of the proscribed was to remain in force for ever and everywhere; they could be sought out and killed wherever they were hiding.53 (Not until the lex Antonia of 49 BC were all the legal effects of the lex Cornelia undone.) The first lists included some 40 senators, 1,600 equestrians, and other country gentlemen of comparable status, men such as Sextus Roscius senior.54 ‘Those who fell victims to political resentment and private hatred were as nothing compared with those who were butchered for the sake of their property.’55
51 52 53
54
55
Cicero, Clu. 44.125. Perhaps now to be sold for the benefit of the aerarium, the state treasury. In 64 BC, when Caesar was praetor for the quaestio de sicariis et veneficiis, he allowed some of the sicarii who had slaughtered the proscribed to be prosecuted as killers before the murder court, even though the lex Cornelia had given them immunity as well as rewards (Suet. Julius 11). Appian, BC 1.11.95–96; later lists included more senators, and men of wealth from among the Italians; elsewhere (BC 1.12.103) Appian gives as a total 90 senators (including 15 consulars) and 2,600 equestrians, not mentioning Italians. Plutarch, Sulla 31.3–5; in this account it began with 80 names, then in the next two days another 440, and more later. Orosius (5.21.1) gives the highest total figure, 9,000; Firmicus Maternus (Math. 1.7.27) reports 7,000. Gardner (1932), 277, gives the total as 4,700. Cic. Clu. 8.25 gives a local example at Larinum.
39
C I C E R O , M U R D E R A N D T H E C O U RT S
The civil strife had ripped apart the social stability of the Italian upper classes. The effects of constant wars ruined much of the Italian peasantry; conscription of adult males led to impoverished or indebted farms, with nobody there to protect them against forcible expropriation. Shortage of labour on the land led to shortages of food, and to the growth of kidnapping; an insufficiently armed traveller might well disappear for ever into the ergastulum of some successful Sullan, as did Marcus Aurius, taken prisoner during the Social War; his whereabouts were eventually discovered, but only in time for him to be put out of the way.56 Unrest among slaves culminated in the rising of Spartacus, which lasted two years (73–71 BC) and harmed much of Italy as his armies ranged over the peninsula. When the rebellion was at last put down by Crassus, 6,000 rebellious slaves were crucified along the length of the via Appia;57 these men too, as has been wryly said, ‘were permanently removed from the labour force’.58 Violence and bloodshed were taken for granted, as was the seizure of one’s enemy’s property, usually but by no means always under the pretext of his being an enemy of the res publica. The trial of Cluentius, some fourteen years after the restoration of legal normality, reveals the continuing harm done to municipal life, for the accusations made by Cicero, while obviously suited to his case, cannot have been totally implausible. But in 80 BC, when the charge of killing his father, parricide in the strict sense, was brought against the younger Sextus Roscius,59 the wars were not quite over – Sulla was still besieging Volaterrae under arms. Parricide might be viewed as a separate crime from murder, with a separate penalty, but it was hardly a common enough crime to justify a court specially assigned to it, so the case was heard before the ordinary murder court, recently re-established by Sulla.
pro Roscio Amerino: the case Cicero opens his case with an explanation of his own appearance as advocate before the court. His very youth and lack of status – he was at this time an equestrian from one of the Italian municipia, in his case Arpinum, someone not so very different from his client – gave him more freedom to appear at a time when men of greater standing might with reason fear the dangers inherent in defending a case which would inevitably raise issues concerning 56
57 58 59
Cicero, Clu. 7.21; he is the ‘slave and captive’ mentioned in Oppianicus’ list of crimes, cited above. It is possible that the Martiales, the public slaves of Mars consecrated to the god by the ancient religious customs of the citizens of Larinum, or some of them, may have been victims of the times (Cicero, Clu. 15.43). It was still a problem under Augustus (Suet. Aug. 32.1). Appian, BC 1.14.120. Brunt (1971), 288. To minimize confusion, I shall usually refer to the elder Sextus Roscius as Roscius, and the younger as Sextus.
40
C I C E R O , M U R D E R A N D T H E C O U RT S
public affairs. Kinsey’s suggestion that a landless refugee client was not worth much effort to the Metelli and Publius Scipio seems credible.60 Nevertheless, Cicero was presumably able to win some sympathy from the iudices by claiming that he was undertaking the defence of Sextus Roscius, not that he might be adequately defended, but to prevent his not being defended at all.61 Cicero then explained to the jurors what he was talking about. The property of Sextus Roscius senior had been valued at 6 million sesterces, and yet Lucius Cornelius Chrysogonus, the freedman and favourite of Sulla, claimed to have bought it, from Sulla, for 2,000 sesterces. Chrysogonus therefore was looking for some way to secure his illegal seizure, and to remove Sextus Roscius junior, the heir, from the scene.62 It was a gross indignity to their senatorial rank that the jurors should be thought capable of aiding such a plot by supporting Chrysogonus with the law when he had so far relied on crime and the sword.63 It was this attack on Chrysogonus that involved some risk to Cicero. An attack on somebody’s freedman was normally construed as an attack on the patron; Sulla had only just stepped down from a bloody dictatorship, able to do so because he had killed or impoverished all his opponents, but still holding the consulship and in control of an army. Moreover, it was almost certain that nearly all the men of continuing influence in Rome, including the jurors, would have benefited from sales of estates under the proscriptions; these were not to be undone. Cicero’s remarks about Sulla’s innocence, while tactful, need not be ironic;64 he was inclined to the party of the optimates in spite of being a fellow-townsman of Marius. There has been some attempt to diminish Cicero’s claim to courage in undertaking this defence, and it seems true that he probably inflated the importance of Chrysogonus and of his influence on Sulla; Chrysogonus is not mentioned in any ancient source independent of Cicero, which surely would have been the case if he had really been ‘at the time perhaps the most powerful young man in the state’.65 However, Cicero’s speech would have been far less effective if Chrysogonus had not been generally seen as a person of considerable influence. The apparent weakness (for we have only Cicero’s word) of the prosecution case could indeed have been due to the accusers not expecting to meet any resolute defence.
60
61 62 63 64 65
Kinsey, (1985a). See Rosc. Am. 28.77, also 10.27; Sulla’s beloved wife was a Metella. Cicero owed a debt to Lucius Crassus (Rawson, (1971), 82f), but may have been encouraged by the Metelli to attack, indirectly, Marcus Crassus, as suggested by Dorey (1960). Rosc. Am. 1.1–2.5. Rosc. Am. 2.6. Rosc. Am. 3.7–8. So Kinsey (1980), despite Buchheit (1975b). Rosc. Am. 2.6: ‘adulescens vel potentissimus hoc tempore nostrae civitatis’.
41
C I C E R O , M U R D E R A N D T H E C O U RT S
The narrative Cicero remarks that this was the first murder trial that had taken place for a long time, although there had been slaughter in plenty, in other words, the proscriptions. This was, of course, because the civil wars had not permitted the ordinary functioning of the courts, which had now been revived by Sulla, and were intended to help restore normality. Cicero then turns to the facts of the case – naturally, as he chooses to give them. Roscius senior had been the leading citizen of the municipium of Ameria, an Umbrian hill town rather more than 50 miles north of Rome. He had also enjoyed formal relations of mutual hospitality (hospitium) with some of the most notable senatorial families in Rome, the Metelli, the Servilii and the Scipiones, and had in addition been personally on excellent terms with these families. They, and Roscius, had largely sided with the optimates, Sulla’s side in the civil wars, and Roscius had defended these families’ interests and those of other optimates in and around Ameria. After the end of the civil wars, he was regularly to be found in Rome, seen in public as one comfortably on the victorious side.66 However, there was a long-standing feud between Sextus Roscius senior and two other Roscii of Ameria, Titus Roscius Capito and Titus Roscius Magnus. Magnus was in court as one of the accusers, while Capito, who was well known, Cicero says, as a cut-throat scoundrel, had recently acquired three of Roscius’ farms. One evening, when Roscius was returning from supper, by implication with one of the senatorial families already mentioned, he was set on and killed close to the Baths of Pallacina, near the Circus Flaminius. At this particular time Magnus was in Rome, whereas Sextus was at home in Ameria, managing his father’s estates.67 The news of Roscius’ death was brought to Ameria by one Mallius Glaucia, described by Cicero as a man of no account, a freedman, and a client and familiar of Magnus, and he brought the news, and also the weapon used, not to the son, but to Capito. Although the murder had been committed at dusk, the messenger reached Ameria at daybreak, covering 56 miles in some ten hours with relays of light vehicles – and that was indeed brisk travelling, particularly in the dark.68 Four days later, the death was reported to Chrysogonus who was in Etruria, in Sulla’s camp at Volaterrae, where the civil war had not yet ended. Roscius’ fortune was known to be large – he owned thirteen good farms in the valley of the Tiber – while his son was isolated from his father’s friends. Magnus and Capito promised Chrysogonus their assistance in putting Sextus out of the way.69 66 67 68
69
Rosc. Am. 6.15–16. Rosc. Am. 6.17–7.18. Kinsey (1980), 176, holds that Cicero’s knowledge of the vehicle and the weapon (telum) must come through Sextus, and that this implies that Capito went, probably at once, to see Sextus. Rosc. Am. 7.19–20.
42
C I C E R O , M U R D E R A N D T H E C O U RT S
Although the proscription was now over, for the lists of the proscribed had been closed on 1 June 81,70 the name of Roscius was retrospectively entered on the lists, despite his having been a supporter of Sulla’s optimates. Chrysogonus now bought Roscius’ estate, an estate worth 6 million, bought for 2,000 sesterces – of course, says Cicero, without Sulla’s knowledge. Sulla was preoccupied with affairs of state; in a large household no man of wealth could be so fortunate as not to have the occasional dishonest slave or freedman. Capito received three of the farms as his reward, and Magnus took possession of the rest, as Chrysogonus’ procurator, ejecting Sextus, who was left penniless, without even a single slave to cook his dinner.71 The inhabitants of Ameria were outraged at what they were seeing, the murder of Roscius and the infamous purchase of his property. The decurions, the town councillors, therefore issued a decree, setting up an embassy of ten leading councillors who were to approach Sulla to tell him of the virtues of Sextus Roscius senior, to complain of the iniquitous conduct of Magnus, and to beg him to see that the reputation of the father and the property of the son were preserved. The decree of the decurions was then read out to the court. This kind of thing was a normal part of municipal life.72 The embassy went to Volaterrae, but Capito apparently was a member of it, which could suggest that he was not generally seen an enemy of Roscius senior.73 Chrysogonus was presumably forewarned, for, in this version of the story, he both came to meet them in person, and also got certain men of rank to beg them not to approach Sulla, for he did not want Sulla to know of his misdeeds. (Sulla might, indeed, have been very angry; he broke with Marcus Crassus, a man of consular family, who joined him with an army in 83 BC, a man far, far above a mere freedman, for having on his own authority proscribed a man at Bruttium, merely to get his property.74) Chrysogonus said he would himself remove Roscius’ name from the lists, and restore his property to the son; Capito guaranteed that this would be done, and the embassy returned to Ameria without ever having seen Sulla. After all, the delegation knew for certain that Roscius had not been killed ‘in the enemy camp’, so they thought they knew that he had been on the lists of the proscribed, and that this listing must have been done in error. Of course, what had been promised did not happen, but since the delegation had heard these promises, the conspirators decided to make sure of their hold on the property by bringing about the death of Sextus.75 When Sextus realized what was going on, on the advice of his friends and relatives he took refuge in Rome at the 70 71 72 73 74 75
There seems to be no other source apart from this speech which gives the date. Rosc. Am. 8.21–3, and 28.77. See Salerno (1990), 175ff. There was similar local support for Cluentius: Cicero, Clu. 69.195–98. Kinsey (1985a). Plut. Crassus 6.6. Rosc. Am. 9.24–26.
43
C I C E R O , M U R D E R A N D T H E C O U RT S
house of Caecilia Metella (sister of the consul of 98 BC and daughter of Q. Caecilius Metellus who had conquered the Balearic Islands during his consulship in 123 BC), one of his father’s grand friends. There he was safe from direct assault. Hence the next stage in the plot as described by Cicero. The other Roscii, Magnus and Capito, whether or not with the connivance of Chrysogonus, decided to have Sextus accused of parricide, saying to themselves that since no trials had been held for so long, the first person charged would be bound to be convicted.76 They thought that nobody would want to talk of such a politically sensitive matter as the selling up of estates, and that the fear of Chrysogonus’ influence and the odiousness of the accusation of parricide would mean that nobody could be found to defend Sextus.77 There were thus three obstacles facing Sextus Roscius junior: the accusation, which was formally brought by one Erucius, the audacity of the other Roscii, and the power of Chrysogonus. Cicero must refute the accusation, but it was for the jurors to resist audacity and malign power.78 Parricide and its penalty It should perhaps be said here that parricide by this period undoubtedly had much the same meaning as in the modern usage, the killing of a father or parent.79 However, the peculiar penalty of the sack (culleus) seems to have been limited to the murder of ascendants.80 Of the cases specifically described as parricide which we hear about, Malleolus was executed in 103 BC for the murder of his mother.81 ‘Not many years ago’, as Cicero tells us in this speech, two sons had been acquitted of murdering their father in Tarracina.82 Sextus was, of course, alleged to have killed his father. Someone who was accused of killing his father appeared before Augustus.83 Other killings within the family may have been viewed as aggravated homicide, but they do not seem to have been punished differently from ordinary murder. Whether parricide in the narrowest sense or something wider, such cases 76 77 78 79
80 81 82 83
Riggsby (1999), 66, thinks this must have been a fiction used by Cicero ‘to introduce the sensitive topic of the proscriptions in a gentler way’. Rosc. Am. 10.27–28. Rosc. Am. 13.35–36. Festus tells us that in regal times there were quaestores parricidii who were established to inquire into killings, for at that time a parricide was one who was said to have killed not his parent but a free man who had not been condemned. Festus, p. 221L; leges regiae, Numa, 12: ‘Si quis hominem liberum dolo sciens morti duit paricidas esto.’ There is a large modern literature on the original nature of parricide. D 48.9.9.1, Modestinus. Rhet. ad Her. 1.13.23; Cicero, inv. 2.50.149; Livy, per. 68. Rosc. Am. 23.64–65; cf. Wiseman (1967). Suet. Aug. 33.1.
44
C I C E R O , M U R D E R A N D T H E C O U RT S
seem to have come before the quaestio de sicariis vel veneficiis, except where extraordinary jurisdiction was the more appropriate, as in the provinces.84 Cicero went on to say that Solon of Athens had not fixed a penalty for parricide because he thought nobody would commit such a crime. The Romans of old were wiser; they had ordained that parricides should be sewn alive into a leather sack, and then thrown into the river.85 The penalty of the sack has been described for us more than once.86 Livy’s epitome says merely: Publicius Malleolus was the first to be sewn up in a sack and thrown into the sea for having killed his mother.87 We are given more details by the anonymous writer ad Herennium.88 The man who is found guilty of killing a parent is veiled, tied up in a sack and thrown into running water. . . . Malleolus was condemned for killing his mother; on his condemnation, his head was immediately wrapped in the skin of a wolf, and wooden soles were bound to his feet, then he was taken to the prison. There those who were defending him brought in tablets and wrote his will for him in his presence, and there were witnesses. Then the penalty was imposed.89 Cicero explains the wooden clogs as preventing the guilty man from running away while the sack is being prepared, but it seems more likely to have been to avoid pollution by preventing contact with the earth.90 In none of these descriptions do we hear of any animals being enclosed with the condemned man in the sack, but they do occur in some later literary 84
85 86
87 88 89 90
When Cicero’s brother Quintus was governor of Asia, he had two Mysians executed by the sack at Smyrna, and Cicero seems to approve his severity, but we are given no details (Cicero, adQ fr. 1.2.5). Rosc. Am. 25.70. Cloud (1971) maintains convincingly that there are jokes in Plautus’ plays which suggest the recent introduction of the penalty of the sack, and offers the case of Lucius Hostius (Plut. Rom. 22) as the occasion, in or shortly after 201 BC. This fits with Lintott (1968), 38–39, who thinks it may have derived, like the human sacrifices of 216, from the Sibylline Books. It is clearly an expiatory ritual, rather than meant as a deterrent; cf. Livy 31.12.8 on the drowning of hermaphrodites in 207 and 200 BC. Val. Max. 1.1.13 claims that the penalty was first imposed by the first Tarquin on M. Atilius, duumvir, for revealing the secrets of the sacred rites, and that it was not until long afterwards used for parricides: ‘culleo insutum in mare abici iussit; idque supplicii genus multo post parricidis lege inrogatum est – iustissime quidem, quia pari vindicta parentum ac deorum violatio expianda est.’ Livy, per. 68. Malleolus must have been the first man to be sacked for killing his mother rather than his father. The context is the dispute over the estate between the testamentary heirs and Malleolus’ brother (also one of his accusers) as nearest agnate, and therefore heir on intestacy. Rhet. ad Her. 1.13.23. It is not specifically said that the sack is of leather. Cic. inv. 2.50.149; otherwise this passage adds nothing new.
45
C I C E R O , M U R D E R A N D T H E C O U RT S
texts; Juvenal, for example, in the later first century AD, mentions an ape and a snake.91 Insofar as the penalty of the sack had its origins in sacral law, there need have been nothing prescriptive about the inclusion of animals;92 they could have a symbolic function which differed from case to case. Some years after the trial of Sextus, probably in 55 BC but possibly 52 BC,93 a lex Pompeia de parricidiis was passed; there is no general agreement on what it laid down. Most likely it defined the relationships that comprised parricide.94 It may also have dealt with the penalty. Ferrini thinks that it abolished the penalty of the culleus, and replaced it by exile, the penalty of the lex Cornelia de sicariis.95 A problem with this theory is the anecdote told of Augustus, when the emperor showed himself anxious to avoid imposing the ancient penalty;96 one possible solution is that the lex Pompeia did not abolish the culleus for a self-confessed parricide, not so much because he had confessed but because the blatant deed clearly required expiation.97 Its wellevidenced use by Claudius was in cognitio proceedings, and justifiable, especially for an antiquarian emperor, as being the ancient penalty.98 So it may have again become the normal penalty, providing titillation for the Roman public, after the desuetude of the quaestio perpetua de sicariis et veneficiis. By Hadrian’s time, even for decurions and others of the upper ranks for whom capital punishment meant deportation, death was the penalty for parricide, in the ‘modern’ form of the simple death penalty.99 Modestinus refers to Hadrian’s substitution of condemnation to the beasts for the sack; he views it as limited to places where there was no access to the sea (or a suitable river).100 It is, however, certain that Constantine enforced the ancient penalty for parricide, forbidding the sword, fire or any other penalty than that of the sack, with the inclusion of serpents.101 91 92 93 94
95 96 97 98 99 100
101
Juvenal 8.212ff; in 13.153ff he mentions only an ape; Seneca talks only of serpents (clem. 1.15.7), and likewise the pseudo-Quintilian (decl. mai. 17.9). Nardi (1980), 126. Perhaps, indeed, it was the antiquarian-minded Emperor Claudius who introduced them. Cloud (1971), 60–62. PS 5.24.1. D 48.9.1 and 3–4, Marcian, gives a rather more extended list; Marcian remarks in fr. 1 that parricide can include the killing of a descendant, as well as an ascendant; cf. 48.9.5, Marcian, where he cites a decision of the Emperor Hadrian, punishing a father for misuse of his paternal power. Ferrini (1902), 389, citing D 48.9.1, Marcian. This would naturally be in the context of the quaestio perpetua de sicariis et veneficiis; it would not necessarily have effect extra ordinem. Suet. Aug. 33.1; Augustus may have felt himself bound by the ordo. Crook (1987). Suet. Claud. 34.1; Seneca, clem. 1.23.1. D 48.19.15, Ven. Sat.; and PS 5.23.1. Parricide for Hadrian may have been limited to ascendants (and presumably patrons) as in 48.9.9.1, Modestinus. D 48.9.9pr, Modestinus. There is also mention of flogging with blood-red rods and the inclusion in the sack of a dog, cock, snake and ape, just as in Inst. 4.18.6, which to me suggests the text is interpolated. CJ 9.17.1 = CTh 9.15.1, AD 319.
46
C I C E R O , M U R D E R A N D T H E C O U RT S
In his speech Cicero avoids detail while concentrating on the horror of depriving the guilty man of sky, sun, earth and water; the body must not be found by wild animals, lest they be rendered more savage; the body, if thrown naked into a river, would pollute even the sea. Thus they live, while life lasts, without being able to draw breath from heaven; they die without earth coming into contact with their bones; they are tossed by the waves without ever being cleansed; they are finally cast ashore without being able to rest, even in death, on the rocks.102
Cicero’s speech Cicero then proceeds to have some rhetorical fun at the expense of Erucius, the prosecutor. However, what all this amounted to was that Sextus was a middle-aged man, with no reputation for violence, not in debt, who lived a simple country life. But Erucius said (said Cicero), that his father disliked him, which was ‘proved’ by Sextus’ now deceased younger brother having been the one who accompanied his father on his many visits to Rome, while Sextus stayed behind running the estate.103 Admittedly, it does sound from what Cicero himself says that the father may have found his elder son uncongenial, a rustic clod with no social life, even in Ameria. Then Cicero tells us Erucius’ other point of accusation:104 Roscius senior had intended to disinherit his son. Cicero feigns not to ask the motive, but only how Erucius could know this. Certainly Sextus had not been disinherited. Disinheritance would indeed have been a serious sign that all was not well between father and son.105 The Romans distinguished between legacies and the inheritance. Legatees received money or individual items of property. Heirs succeeded almost to the personality of the testator, to his (or her) rights and duties, except those that were recognized as specifically personal. Further, the heirs were liable for the continued performance of the family sacra, the worship of the family gods, the lares et penates, and so on. There might be many legacies, so that the heirs did not necessarily receive the bulk of the estate, but it was in the heirs that the family persisted. Disinheritance without explanation raised a prima facie case that the testator had not been in his right mind, and there was a remedy in the querela inofficiosi testamenti.106 102 103 104 105 106
Rosc. Am. 26.72. Cicero later mocked his own flourishes of language (Brut. 30.107). Rosc. Am. 13.38–18.52. Rosc. Am. 18.52–19.54. See Cicero, Clu. 48.135, where a father disinherits his son for taking a bribe to secure Oppianicus’ conviction. Cf. Strachan Davidson (1912), I 85–95. See any textbook on Roman law, such as Buckland (1963) or Nicholas (1962).
47
C I C E R O , M U R D E R A N D T H E C O U RT S
Such feeble accusations, not even attempted to be proven, said Cicero, were an insult to the court. This seems a little rash of him, because at this stage of the trial all that had been heard was the opening speech for the prosecution, giving the general tenor of the charge.107 Witnesses were heard and other evidence led after the defence had replied to the prosecution, and Cicero could not be sure how convincing any testimony would be, regardless of whether it was true or false, particularly as Capito was due to appear as a witness.108 He went on to blacken the prosecution by pointing out that nobody thought there was any personal enmity between Erucius and Roscius, but that Erucius had simply been bought, paid to bring the accusation, and therefore might even be at risk of a conviction for calumny.109 Cicero remarks upon Erucius’ casualness of manner in his prosecution speech, and suggests that he did not think anybody, literally, would reply for the defence.110 He never even thought of me, because I had never pleaded in a criminal case before. . . . At last he concluded and sat down; I got up. He seemed to breathe again . . . he was joking and paid no attention until I mentioned the name of Chrysogonus; as soon as I referred to him my man immediately jumped up; he seemed to be astonished. I understood what had stung him. I mentioned Chrysogonus a second and a third time. After that men continued running hastily hither and thither, I suppose to inform Chrysogonus . . . 111 Some modern scholars agree with Cicero’s estimate that ‘the prosecution miscalculated’.112 Others, rather too elaborately in my view, have held that 107 108 109
110
111 112
Greenidge (1901), 477–78; cf. Strachan Davidson (1912), II 115–24. Rosc. Am. 30.84. Rosc. Am. 19.55. Erucius’ position is in marked contrast to that of Titus Attius, the prosecutor of Cluentius. Attius was an eques from Pisaurum, a town relatively easy of access from Larinum, on the via Flaminia, the easiest if not the shortest route to Rome; his status and this proximity suggests that there were ties of friendship between him and young Oppianicus, the real instigator of the accusation, which would justify his role. See Alexander (2002), 176. Rosc. Am. 21.59. A few modern scholars, such as Humbert (1925), seduced presumably by the speech pro Milone, hold that Cicero’s speeches as given were quite different from what was subsequently published, but most, such as Stroh (1975), Kinsey (1975), Hinard (1985) disagree; see Pliny, ep. 1.20.6–10. Nobody doubts that there will have been a little grammatical polishing, especially as Cicero may well not normally have written his speeches out in full, but in pro Roscio Amerino the very nature of the discrepancies argues for authenticity. Cicero, even as a young man, was surely capable of extemporizing. And a final point, if Pliny is a guide to the practice of Cicero’s day in this, speeches, real speeches, might be read aloud to an invited audience (Pliny, ep. 2.19.1 and 8). Rosc. Am. 21.59–22.60. E.g. Craig (1993), 44.
48
C I C E R O , M U R D E R A N D T H E C O U RT S
the accusers hoped that Sextus, to gain acquittal, would take the desperate argument that killing someone proscribed was not by definition murder; thus he would have been forced into accepting the confiscation of his father’s estate, while ruining his own character and reputation.113 It is to be remarked that in his defence of Cluentius, Cicero never suggests that Oppianicus could have been lawfully killed because of being an outlaw, under interdictio aquae et ignis; this was not a ‘good’ defence. Motive, Cicero went on to argue, was always desirable to prove, but so were other circumstances; with such a serious crime as parricide ‘unmistakable traces of the crime must be forthcoming: Where? How? By whose means? The time at which it was committed? Unless these proofs are many and evident, surely an act so criminal, so atrocious and so wicked cannot be believed.’114 Cicero then recounts what must be, in the context, a true story. Not many years ago, it is said, a certain Titus Caelius, a wellknown citizen of Tarracina, went to bed, after supper, in the same room as his two grown-up sons, and was found dead in the morning with his throat cut. As no slave – or free man – could be found on whom suspicion might have fallen, while the two grown-up sons who slept near their father declared that they had noticed nothing, they were indicted for parricide. What could be so suspicious? That neither of them had noticed anything? That someone had dared to venture into that room, at the very time when the two sons were there, who might so easily have seen the crime and offered resistance? Moreover, there was nobody who might reasonably be suspected. However, when it had been proved to the jurors that the young men had been found asleep when the door was opened – or sleeping with the door open115 – they were acquitted and cleared of all suspicion. There was nobody who thought a man could exist who would be capable of going to sleep immediately after he had violated laws both human and divine by such an impious crime; those who have committed such a deed are not only unable to rest peacefully, but cannot even breathe without fear.116 The Romans do not seem to have recognized the coldness so typical of psychopaths, but certainly nothing seems to have been alleged about Sextus that would put him in this category. 113 114 115
116
Stroh (1975), 61–63; Catherine Steel in a private communication. But Alexander (2002) also finds it over-elaborate. Rosc. Am. 22.62. The Latin, ‘aperto ostio dormientes eos repertos esse’, could equally bear either interpretation; Piso ordered the doors of his bedroom to be shut (Tac. Ann. 3.15.3), which suggests that bedroom doors would not necessarily be closed. Rosc. Am. 23.64–5; Val. Max. 8.1.13. See Wiseman (1967).
49
C I C E R O , M U R D E R A N D T H E C O U RT S
After this, Cicero takes up the issue of how Sextus murdered his father. He cannot have done it in person, for he was 50 miles away. With another series of (potentially risky) rhetorical questions Cicero asks what agents Sextus used, slaves or free men; if free men from Ameria, why have they too not been charged?117 If from Rome, how on earth did Sextus, who for several years never went to Rome, and anyway never stayed there more than three days, make contact? How did he persuade them? If he gave them a bribe, where did the money come from, and how much was it? This is something that one would indeed expect to find in a citizen’s financial accounts; the Romans do seem extraordinarily conscientious on this point.118 And Erucius himself had described Sextus as a country lout, who did not spend a night away, even in Ameria, if he could help it. Cicero prefers the topos of the virtuous country life to that of rustic boorishness, but in either view Sextus was not well placed to hire killers. Alternatively, Sextus committed the crime through the agency of his father’s slaves.119 But Sextus was not in a position to offer these slaves to be examined under torture, since his accusers had possession of them all. Sextus had demanded the return of two of the slaves, the two who had been with his father in Rome, in order that he could have them put to the question, and two senators, presumably both his advocati (influential men giving weight to the defender’s case), Publius Scipio and Marcus Metellus, could testify to this; it would have been their duty to assist at the interrogation.120 But Magnus had refused to hand them over, and they were now in Chrysogonus’ familia. This was presumably a reward to them for not giving evidence that would have exculpated Sextus, and possibly implicated the real killers. ‘Everything in this case, gentlemen, is pitiable and scandalous, but nothing harsher or more unfair than this can be brought forward, that a son should not be allowed to put his father’s slaves to the question in regard to his death.’121 To us it may hardly seem pitiable that slaves could not be tortured, but the Romans did not accept the evidence of slaves except under torture;122 there were attempts to regulate the conduct of such interrogations.123 Slaves were not permitted to incriminate their owners or those in a 117 118 119 120 121 122
123
pro Cluentio shows that accusing accomplices before the principal was not out of order; an accomplice was normally equally liable with the principal. Cf. Pliny, Ep. 2.11.23; 3.9.13. Rosc. Am. 28.77. As we see in Cicero, Clu. 63.176–77; 65.182–84, they might formally witness a statement so gathered. Rosc. Am. 28.78. D 48.18.1.1, Ulpian; cf. 48.18.13, Mod; see generally Robinson (1981), also Strachan Davidson (1912), II 126–28; this was based only on custom, although there was both statutory and juristic development. D 48.18.1pr, Ulpian citing Augustus, an interrogation should not begin with torture; nor, as Hadrian wrote, was evidence given thus always to be believed; 48.18.1.21, Ulpian citing Trajan, condemning the use of leading questions; also 48.18.7, Ulpian; 48.18.20, Paul.
50
C I C E R O , M U R D E R A N D T H E C O U RT S
relation akin to ownership.124 However, it was long accepted that someone could offer his own slaves to prove his innocence;125 it was their torture at the instance of an accuser that was forbidden. An owner could torture his or her own slaves, as Sassia did after Oppianicus’ death, and have witnesses testify to their evidence.126 Also, the slaves of a disputed inheritance could be tortured, because their owner was dead, and they did not yet have a new owner;127 on Magnus’ own argument that Roscius had been proscribed, this would be a relevant argument. Indeed, when an owner of slaves died in mysterious circumstances, the whole slave household was normally put to the question,128 and when it was upon a journey, those slaves who were with him. Cicero’s counter-charge There is one paragraph in the speech which suggests that Erucius added to the murder charge another of peculatus.129 This, I think, must be ironic, since only senators, and senators holding public office at that, would have been liable at this period.130 One must suppose that he was implying that Sextus was withholding some of his father’s property that now was the state’s; the actual liability in such a case would presumably fall under one of the proscription statutes. Cicero then moved on to the attack, suggesting that Magnus and Capito were far more likely than Sextus as the killers of Roscius. Cassius Longinus, consul in 127 BC, had always asked ‘cui bono?’. Well here it is clear, says Cicero. Sextus is reduced to beggary, and Magnus enjoys the fruits of Roscius senior’s property. Magnus had formerly been a poor man, and an enemy of Roscius senior. Now he had become rich by entering into a partnership with a perfect stranger to gain possession of the fortune of a kinsman and fellow-townsman. Who was more likely to kill? The enemy? Or the son? The major weakness of this argument is that at the actual moment of the killing, Sextus would have expected to inherit.131 In the troubles – when of course Sulla had been too busy to know of evil 124
125
126 127 128 129 130 131
D 48.18.1.5 and 16, Ulpian; 48.18.15.2, Call.; PS 1.12.3. An exception was made, because of the usually domestic locus of the crime, for charges of incest during the Republic, and, in later times, of adultery. As did Piso in AD 20 (Tac. Ann. 3.14.2). It is forbidden in D 48.18.18.7, Paul, and in CJ 9.41.7, AD 286, but in this rescript it seems to be feared that they would accuse; in CJ 4.20.8, AD 294, it is permitted. An accuser might not offer slaves from his own household, according to the divi fratres (D 48.18.1.3, Ulpian); presumably the fear here is that they would say what they had been instructed to say. Cicero, Clu. 63.176–77; 65.182–66.186. D 48.18.17.2, Papinian. Cic. ad fam. 4.12.3; this was the custom that lay behind the SC Silanianum of (?) AD 10. Rosc. Am. 29.82. Briefly, Robinson (1995b), 81–82. As pointed out by Kinsey (1985a).
51
C I C E R O , M U R D E R A N D T H E C O U RT S
deeds – men had taken revenge on their enemies and recuperated their fortunes. Cicero could talk at length about that. Not only had Magnus the motive, he also had the opportunity. Roscius was killed in Rome, and Magnus was in Rome; although, Cicero admits, so were many others. Cicero then returns to the facts.132 Roscius was killed in the evening, returning from supper. The news of Roscius’ death was brought to Ameria before daybreak by Mallius Glaucia, Magnus’ client and familiaris. He brought the news to Capito (which certainly exculpates Capito from murder by his own hand), even though Roscius had a house, a wife and children (presumably daughters) at Ameria,133 and many other kinsmen and friends. Glaucia’s was an extremely rapid journey, all through a sleepless night. The distance is more than 50 miles from Rome; Arpinum was somewhat farther, closer to 60 miles, and when travelling comfortably the Cicero household would take three days for that journey.134 Cicero is not – perhaps – accusing Glaucia of personally committing the murder; his concern is with who planned it. But if Glaucia did not do the deed, how did he know about it so quickly? Why should Magnus want Capito informed so soon? Cicero does not know, but, and we are back with innuendo again, Capito is in possession of three of Roscius’ farms. Capito’s murders are notorious – a very vague statement, of course. Further, Capito has been fed his testimony by Erucius; evidence given by one among the accusers is tainted. Looked at objectively, it could well be that Glaucia knew how to find the house of Capito but not that of Roscius; he could have preferred to tell Capito so that a kinsman would break the news to Roscius’ widow. He could have brought the dagger which had done the deed because it might have provided a clue. On the other hand, the extraordinary speed does remain suspicious. There seems to be no need for it, unless a plot had already been made to make use of the death, with the alliance of Chrysogonus, which would suggest very quick, and dishonest, thinking, but does not imply murder by Magnus or at his instance. Then there comes Cicero’s second version of how the news was brought to Chrysogonus at Volaterrae;135 the presumption must be that it was by or through Magnus, still, in this version, four days after the death. Chrysogonus saw to it that Roscius’ property was sold at once, although he had no idea who Roscius was. Who could have told him but some fellow-townsman of the dead man? Betrayal in those days was generally by neighbours and false friends, says Cicero, truthfully enough. Magnus and Capito, like other 132 133
134 135
Rosc. Am. 34.96; he has already said this in 7.19. The widow is not otherwise mentioned. The house in Ameria had been seized. Did she too seek refuge with Caecilia Metella, or did she return to her own family? She was clearly not in court to support her son (or possibly stepson), but at least, unlike Sassia with her son, she was not hostile to him. Shackleton Bailey (1971), 3. Rosc. Am. 36.105–37.108; cf. 7.20–8.21.
52
C I C E R O , M U R D E R A N D T H E C O U RT S
Roscii, had hereditary patrons among the great men of Rome, but they had made themselves clients of Chrysogonus. To whom else did Chrysogonus grant shares in this property? Nobody; it was split three ways. And why should Chrysogonus reward these two if they had not performed a service for him? Then, when the Amerians felt concern about Roscius’ fate, Capito was on the deputation to Sulla. He prevented them getting to Sulla; he revealed their purpose to Chrysogonus; he warned Chrysogonus of the need to safeguard their hold on Roscius’ property; he advised going about things quietly; he guaranteed to his fellow-townsmen that the proscription would be undone.136 What a false friend, what a treacherous mandatary, says Cicero, as much to the rest of the delegation as to Sextus. It seems a little strange that the delegation should have had not the least suspicion of Capito’s wickedness, their fellow decurion, if his hostility to his kinsman Roscius senior was well-known, or if his reputation was as bad as Cicero makes out. But perhaps their courage was failing them in the vicinity of Sulla, or perhaps they were bribed to go away, and they are unlikely to have wanted to risk much for such an unsociable man as Sextus Roscius junior. And Capito may well have been a convincing talker. The slaves of Roscius Cicero returns to the issue of the slaves. The defence had frequently asked for the two slaves to be put to the question. Magnus had always refused, although no interrogation concerning him was proposed, or indeed could lawfully have been conducted. But the request was reasonable, and made by great men, a Scipio and a Metellus. Magnus’ refusal amounted, says Cicero, to a confession. Cicero does not know if they were guilty or innocent, but their ‘honourable’ treatment by Magnus shows that they must know something which would ruin Magnus if revealed.137 For the slaves had been there when Roscius was killed. Anyone who wished them interrogated wanted the truth; someone who refused the interrogation must want the truth concealed.138 Obviously, they cannot have killed the father at the son’s order, or the prosecution would have alleged this. If the death was premeditated, they might have been bribed to kill, or merely not to defend their owner. It is also very possible that Roscius was killed by casual, unidentifiable muggers, and that the slaves were fearful because they had not prevented his death.139 They could have gone at once to Magnus, because he was after all 136 137 138 139
This version, Rosc. Am. 38.109–10, seems more plausible than that in 9.25–26, and explains why Capito should have been given three farms outright. Rosc. Am. 41.119–20. Rosc. Am. 42.123. Certainly after the SC Silanianum, and by custom at this period, they could have been executed for this failure (D 29.5.1.31, Ulpian).
53
C I C E R O , M U R D E R A N D T H E C O U RT S
a kinsman and fellow townsman of Roscius senior, with the news of the killing, whether or not they realised their plight. If Magnus was no murderer but an extremely quick-witted man, who saw at once how to turn the situation to his advantage, then keeping the slaves out of the way would help avoid publicity until the takeover of the farms had been arranged. But I do find the refusal to allow their being put to the question a distinctly suspicious feature of the prosecution’s behaviour. Roscius’ estate Cicero then moves to the third objective in his speech, saving Sextus from the power of Chrysogonus. Chrysogonus bought up Roscius’ estate. How was Roscius’ estate available? Of course, such a sale of the property of an innocent man was always shameful, but it had been happening all the time; Roscius’ case was in this respect no worse than many others – which was undoubtedly true. The law, Valerian or Cornelian, put up for sale the property of those who had been listed as proscribed – of whom Roscius was not one – or who had been killed in adversariorum praesidiis140 – and Roscius had been of the Sullan party. He was killed in time of peace, returning from supper. Only if he was slain in accordance with the law could his property lawfully be sold up. The proscription lists were closed on 1 June 81. Roscius was killed months later. So either the sale was not executed through the public records, in which case it was a purely private enterprise, or it was done through the public records, but only by falsifying them. Sextus was more worried about his life and reputation than his fortune, but it was still a matter worth pursuing. So, why was the property of an optimate sold up? Why was it sold up many months after 1 June? And why was it sold at so low a price? These were clear indications of dirty work at the crossroads. And Chrysogonus was the one with extravagant needs, with his fine house, or rather ‘a manufactory of wickedness and a lodging-house of every sort of crime’.141 Cicero did not find fault with punishing the populares who fought against Sulla, or with rewards to faithful followers, but the war was not fought to enrich the base. Chrysogonus had excessive power, excessive because it was not a power given by the laws, but simply sprang from the influence and wealth of a former slave, a power which the optimates could and should curb. But these arguments were Cicero’s own, not his client’s.142 Sextus cared far more for his reputation and his life than his fortune, Cicero repeated. Further, the statute laid down that their fathers’ properties were not to be restored to the children of the proscribed.143 Sextus’ very 140 141 142 143
‘Within the enemy’s stronghold’ (Rosc. Am. 43.126). ‘officina nequitiae et deversorium flagitiorum omnium’ (Rosc. Am. 46.134). Stressed also by Gruen (1968), 269f. Rosc. Am. 50.145.
54
C I C E R O , M U R D E R A N D T H E C O U RT S
food and clothes were the gift of Caecilia, a gift from one of the nobles, from one of Sulla’s side. Caecilia was caring for his domestic affairs, while young Messalla144 had undertaken the conduct of his affairs in the forum and the court, as far as it was possible for one so young. Sextus’ hope lay in the sense of justice of the jurors hearing this case, senators all. Let them banish cruelty from the state, and restore pity. Cicero’s appeal to the jurors in this speech was based on the need for reconciliation, after such a long series of wars and massacres, of which Sulla’s, as has been pointed out, was only the latest.145 It was also based on the appeal to senators to discourage the influence of a mere freedman, even if he was Sulla’s freedman. The issue of the sack as the penalty for parricide brought out a fine purple passage, which he later acknowledged was rather too purple. The message hammered home, however, was the importance of the rule of law. The case of Sextus Roscius, like that of Cluentius, had the dreadful background of the Social War and the civil wars ending in the Sullan proscriptions; memories impossible to eradicate burned in the hostility between Sextus and his cousins, as between Cluentius and Oppianicus. The legal issues raised by these prosecutions were not irrelevant, but nor was the simple question: whose side were you on? The senators, as leaders of society, could, and should, restore peace, defending due process, and the genuineness of Sulla’s legal reforms. Pro Roscio was a speech tailored for the year. To my mind, it is pretty unlikely that Sextus arranged the murder of his father; his rural isolation, agreed by both sides, and the fact that it was the prosecution which refused to produce the slaves accompanying Roscius senior, weigh heavy. But it seems even less likely that Sextus recovered the whole estate, despite his probable acquittal, since few, if any, courts would be willing to upset the property settlements of the recent years. This was, however, a trial conducted according to the proper formalities, an accused charged with a definable crime, and a defence permitted to be made. It is for us a recognizable world, unlike that of the Bacchanalian affair.
144 145
Depending on which Messalla, he will have been consul in 61 or 53 Hinard (1985), 152.
55
BC.
Chapter 3 THE TRIAL OF CN. CALPURNIUS P I S O I N AD 2 0
The trial before the Senate of Cn. Calpurnius Piso senior for his part in the death of Germanicus and for (other) treasonable activities is the trial recorded at greatest length by Tacitus; unfortunately he omits many details that would have been of the highest legal interest. Nevertheless such extensive treatment is in itself significant for our view of the political nature of Roman attitudes to penal practice and penal policy.
The sources Tacitus is, as usual, concerned in this account to show the dark side of Tiberius’ character, perhaps even to equate him with Domitian.1 Of the first treason trials, it has been said: We cannot avoid the conclusion that in his account of the two maiestas cases in AD 14 Tacitus has so shaped and coloured the description by his own view of later events as to lose all claim to historical objectivity. . . . Where there is room for doubt Tacitus’ procedure is always the same: he admits that it exists, and goes on to write as if it did not.2 In our attempts to weigh the degree of Tacitus’ prejudice, it seems to me relevant that the Piso affair happened when it did, as early as AD 20. While it seems likely that Tiberius did suffer a psychological, or physiological, crisis that turned him from an austere, reserved, conscientious ruler of rather gloomy temperament into a paranoid tyrant, this was not until AD 26, when he retired to Capri, or later (perhaps not even until 31 and the fall of Sejanus, the first senator executed simply at the emperor’s order). Therefore I am 1
2
Syme (1958), 422. One must remember that Tacitus was a senator who reached the consulship, and the governorship of Asia; he knew from first hand how opaque might be the processes of government. His innuendos were not those of a simple or uninformed man. Walker (1960), 91, 108.
56
THE TRIAL OF CN. PISO CALPURNIUS
inclined to look for a normal rather than a sinister interpretation of his actions, and to accept that he was indeed trying to keep separate his private and public persons, and that he truly grieved for Germanicus. This would not exclude the existence of tensions between the emperor and his adopted son, arising perhaps as much from differences of character as of policy. And there is no reason to doubt that there was feminine manoeuvring within the imperial family, that Livia, Augustus’ widow and Tiberius’ mother, favoured Plancina, wife of Piso, and disliked Agrippina, wife of Germanicus,3 and that she brought influence to bear to ensure Plancina’s pardon. Plancina, after all, was only a woman; she was no threat to the wellbeing of the state, and poisoning Germanicus could not be laid at her – or anyone’s – door. In the late 1980s some copies, one almost complete, were found in Baetica (southern Spain) of an inscription recording the resolutions of the Senate on the trial and suicide of Piso and the trials of his son, his wife and his associates, the SC de Cn. Pisone patre (SCPP). This can act as some sort of control on Tacitus’ account, just as epigraphic and literary evidence were paired in the chapter on the Bacchanalian affair. In this case, however, it is safe to infer that Tacitus knew the contents of the original senatusconsultum, so the SCPP is not in that sense independent evidence, but provides a sidelight on Tacitus’ historical methods. Furthermore, the SCPP also has its own sub-text.
Germanicus and Piso To start with an outline of the facts as we are given them by Tacitus. On 10 October AD 19 Germanicus, grandson of Augustus’ wife Livia, nephew and adopted son of Tiberius, and brother of the future emperor Claudius, died in mysterious circumstances while governing the eastern provinces with maius imperium. He was given this office in AD 17 because he was Tiberius’ heir, and it had become customary under Augustus that the emperor’s heir should get experience of government in the eastern part of the Empire; this had been the case for Agrippa, Gaius Caesar, and Tiberius himself. The king of Cappadocia had just died in Rome of natural causes; Cappadocia (in eastern Asia Minor, adjoining Syria, Parthia and Armenia) needed to be integrated into the Roman Empire as a province. Relations with Parthia, the only other great power in the western world, were often tense. Armenia was the buffer state between the two empires, and Germanicus would need to deal with the uneasy political situation there.4 Piso had 3
4
Ann. 2.43.3–6. (In this chapter I shall cite simply Annals, without Tacitus.) Although the brothers, Germanicus and Drusus, were good friends, enmity was also rumoured between Agrippina and Livilla, Drusus’ wife. Ann. 2.43.1–2.
57
THE TRIAL OF CN. CALPURNIUS PISO
at the same time been made governor of Syria, in succession to Creticus Silanus. Silanus had been in post for nearly six years; further, his daughter was betrothed to Germanicus’ son, and so Silanus was unsuitable as a counter-weight to Germanicus, if one were needed. Piso was of distinguished background. His father had been a supporter of the republican party against Julius Caesar and the triumvirate, but Augustus had eventually induced him to accept a consulship in 23 BC. ‘Our’ Piso had shared the consulship with Tiberius in 7 BC. There are various reports of his incautiously independent behaviour in the Senate in AD 15 and 16.5 Tiberius, however, seems to have viewed him as a trusted friend, and as a man of weight. Piso was the emperor’s, not Germanicus’, legatus in Syria, but he was also appointed as Germanicus’ adiutor. Tacitus reports that Piso was certain that the purpose of his appointment was to act as a check on Germanicus;6 this is not impossible, as Tiberius may have been a little apprehensive of Germanicus’ thirst for military glory. It was also rumoured that Plancina, Piso’s wife, was being urged by Livia to make life difficult for Agrippina, wife of Germanicus.7 Tacitus tells us that Piso and Germanicus met briefly on the island of Rhodes, while Piso was on his way to Syria.8 Once on station, in AD 18, Piso is reported as having set to work to destroy military discipline;9 this seems both uncharacteristic and pointless. Furthermore, and less implausibly, Piso was contumacious, if not actually mutinous, for, ordered by Germanicus under his maius imperium to come with part of his army, or to send it with his son, to Armenia, Piso did neither.10 Piso and Germanicus were clearly on bad terms in winter quarters, established that year at Cyrrhus in northern Syria, and this ill-feeling was fanned by some of Germanicus’ friends.11 In the following year, AD 19, Germanicus went off to visit the antiquities of Egypt and nearby parts;12 Tiberius was angered by this breach of the convention established by Augustus that no senator should visit Egypt without specific imperial leave.13 It remains doubtful whether Germanicus thought this covered by his imperium maius, though surely his remit had been made clear,14 or if he simply thought of himself as 5
Ann. 1.74.6; 1.79.5; Dio Cassius 57.15.9; Tac. Ann. 2.35. In the last instance, Piso held that Tiberius’ absence was all the more reason for the Senate not to adjourn, but to conduct business in the public interest. 6 Ann. 2.43.4. 7 Ann. 2.43.3–6. 8 Ann. 2.55.3–4; Tacitus implies there was already deep hostility between them. 9 Ann. 2.55.5–6; Goodyear (1981), ad loc. cit. wonders if Piso had a mental breakdown. 10 Ann. 2.57.1. Piso could have had his reasons. 11 Ann. 2.57.2–4. 12 Ann. 2.59.1; 2.60–61. His fondness for such visits had been amply shown during his journey out to the East (Ann. 2.53–54). See also Hennig (1972); Weingartner (1969). 13 Ann. 2.59.2–3. 14 Weingartner (1969), 33–46.
58
THE TRIAL OF CN. PISO CALPURNIUS
above such rules; in the latter case one sees why Tiberius might have wanted a reliable friend in the vicinity. In his absence Piso altered the disposition of the troops.15 Again, this might be construed as a breach of military discipline, or even sedition, but Piso did have imperium, and the commanderin-chief was away. When Germanicus learned of this, there were violent reciprocal denunciations, and Piso determined to leave Syria; had he done so without authorization he would certainly have been liable under the lex Iulia maiestatis.16 Then Germanicus fell ill while returning from Egypt, and Piso postponed his departure, which would seem to be a proper course of action in the interests of Rome. Having received news of Germanicus’ improvement, Piso moved from Antioch to a town on the coast.17 But then Germanicus had a relapse – aggravated by his belief that Piso had poisoned him. Examination of the floor and walls of his bedroom revealed the remains of human bodies, spells, curses, lead tablets inscribed with the patient’s name, charred and bloody ashes, and other malignant objects which are supposed to consign souls to the powers of the tomb. At the same time agents of Piso were accused of spying on the sickbed.18 Germanicus, however, was well enough to write to Piso, renouncing his friendship,19 and almost certainly ordering him out of the province; at any rate, Piso left Syria for the island of Cos.20 Suetonius’ version extols Germanicus’ leniency:
15 16 17 18
19 20
Ann. 2.69.1. It would amount to deserting imperium exercitumve (D 48.4.3, Marcian). Ann. 2.69.2. Ann. 2.69.3: ‘saevam vim morbi augebat persuasio veneni, a Pisone accepti; et reperiebantur solo ac parietibus erutae humanorum corporum reliquiae, carmina et devotiones, et nomen Germanici plumbeis tabulis insculptum, semusti cineres, ac tabe obliti; aliaque maleficia quis creditur animas numinibus infernis sacrari. simul missi a Pisone incusabantur ut valetudinis adversa rimantes.’ Za¨ch (1972) thinks Dio Cassius (57.18.9–10) more likely to have used the same sources as Tacitus than to have copied him when he says: ‘[Germanicus’] death occurred at Antioch as the result of a plot formed by Piso and Plancina. For human bones that had been buried in the house where he dwelt and sheets of lead containing curses together with his name were found while he was yet alive; and that poison was the means of his carrying off was revealed by the condition of his body, which was brought into the Forum and exhibited to all who were present. Piso later returned to Rome and was brought before the Senate on the charge of murder by Tiberius himself, who thus endeavoured to clear himself of the suspicion of having destroyed Germanicus; but Piso secured a postponement of his trial and committed suicide.’ Ann. 2.70.1 The SCPP, ll. 28–29, remarked that Germanicus ‘non inmerito amicitiam ei renuntiasse’; cf. Rogers (1959). Ann. 2.70.2.
59
THE TRIAL OF CN. CALPURNIUS PISO
[W]hen Piso was annulling [Germanicus’] decrees and maltreating his dependants, he could not make up his mind to break with him, until he found himself assailed also by potions and spells. Even then he went no farther than formally to renounce Piso’s friendship in the traditional fashion (more maiorum), and to bid his household avenge him, in case anything should befall him.21 But Germanicus did not get better. On his deathbed he accused Piso and Plancina of at least hastening, and perhaps of complicity in, his death – killed by a woman’s treachery (muliebri fraude cecidisse). He requested his friends to protest to the Senate and to invoke the law; sympathy would lie with the accusers of Piso, whose defence would be either unbelievable or unforgivable.22 His body was on view before his cremation in Antioch; ‘it is uncertain if the body showed signs of poisoning’.23 After Germanicus’ death The legates and other senators in Germanicus’ entourage then had to resolve the question of who should take over the Syrian command, something which suggests that Piso had indeed left under orders; this was decided in favour of Cn. Sentius Saturninus rather than Gaius Vibius Marsus. Meanwhile, Publius Vitellius, Quintus Veranius and others among Germanicus’ retinue had already begun to prepare charges against Piso and Plancina. ‘At their demand, Sentius dispatched to Rome a woman called Martina, who was notorious in the province as a poisoner; Plancina was very fond of her.’24 Agrippina took ship for Rome with her children and her husband’s ashes.25 Piso was still at Cos when he heard of Germanicus’ death, and he was alleged to have made celebratory sacrifices in the temples there;26 Plancina at that time resumed normal dress after mourning a sister27 – which, to say the least, was bad timing. Piso, we are told, wondered about whether he might return to Syria, urged by numbers of centurions (presumably from the army there), and take back command.28 His son Marcus tried to 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28
Suet. Cal. 3.3. Ann. 2.71. It seems not impossible that Germanicus had a high fever, and may even have been hallucinating. Ann. 2.73.4. Ann. 2.74: ‘isque infamem veneficiis ea in provincia et Plancinae percaram nomine Martinam in urbem misit.’ Ann. 2.75.1. The temples were closed as a sign of mourning; see SCPP, ll. 64–65. Ann. 2.75.2. Ann. 2.76.1. This was a specific offence under the lex Iulia maiestatis – D 48.4.3, Marcian). In view of these centurions, and the many deserters mentioned later (Ann. 2.78.2; 2.80.1) – the army in Syria was in a state of some confusion, if not worse.
60
THE TRIAL OF CN. PISO CALPURNIUS
discourage him from such plans, on the grounds that his quarrel with Germanicus had done nothing so far to earn punishment, only unpopularity, and that his return to the province might well provoke a civil war.29 Domitius Celer, however, one of his closest friends, persuaded him that he was the lawful governor, approved as such by the emperor.30 Piso therefore set out, after writing to Tiberius complaining of Germanicus’ conduct and his own expulsion from his province.31 A warning message from Vibius, second-in-command in Syria, urging him to return to Rome, was treated with disdain; Piso replied that he would appear when cited before the praetor de veneficiis.32 He and Domitius with their troops failed to disturb Sentius, who warned him that his conduct was treasonable;33 Piso was defeated in a minor battle, and sent back to Rome with a naval escort and a safe conduct.34 This seems an excellent illustration of the political sensitivity. Piso had been taken in arms against a Roman army, but he had been Tiberius’ appointment; further, it was normal to do no more than put accused members of the upper classes under house arrest. Even so, Piso’s treatment was obviously respectful; he was able on this voyage to tour Asia and Achaea, and visit Drusus, Germanicus’ younger brother, in Illyricum.35 Meanwhile, at Rome, on the news of Germanicus’ death there were extraordinary scenes of general grief,36 and then many honours were paid to the dead man.37 Tacitus, however, says that Tiberius could hardly conceal his delight at the news; this presumably means that the emperor was his usual taciturn self.38 Before the end of the year Agrippina arrived in Rome, after a dangerous winter voyage and a solemn journey through Italy, with the ashes of her husband.39 The ashes were deposited in the Mausoleum of Augustus; this was not a funeral, and quite properly was not treated as such by the emperor,40 but it gave rise to popular indignation. After this, the
29 30 31 32
33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40
Ann. 2.76.2–3. Ann. 2.77. Ann. 2.78.1. Ann. 2.79.1: ‘Marsusque Vibius nuntiavit Pisoni ‘‘Romam ad dicendam causam veniret’’. Ille eludens respondit ‘‘adfuturum ubi praetor qui de veneficiis quaereret reo atque accusatoribus diem praedixisset’’.’ Ann. 2.79.2–80.2. Ann. 2.80.3–81.3. Ann. 3.7.1; 3.8.1–2; 3.9.1. Ann. 2.82; 3.1–2 and 4–5. It is somewhat reminiscent of the bizarre manifestations of grief over the death of Diana, Princess of Wales. Ann. 2. 83; Suet. Cal. 5–6. The Senate met on 16 December, and then at another session, to decree the formal honours; see Gonzalez (1999). Ann. 3.2.3. Ann. 3.1–2. Ann. 3.3 and 3.6. See Woodman and Martin (1996), 98. The funeral, although sine imaginibus et pompa, had already been held; it would be contrary to sacral law to repeat it.
61
THE TRIAL OF CN. CALPURNIUS PISO
thoughts of many turned to seeking retribution from Piso, who had still not returned to Rome, and was said to be suppressing the proofs of his crimes. ‘For it had become known that the notorious poisoner, Martina, sent to Rome – as I have mentioned – by Sentius, had suddenly died at Brundisium, with poison found hidden in a knot of her hair, and that her body bore no signs of suicide.’41 Piso sent his son, Marcus, on ahead, and himself arrived at Rome, probably in June of AD 20. He voyaged up the Tiber, landed by the Mausoleum, and then went cheerfully with Plancina and a large escort to dine festively at his house overlooking the Forum.42 At this point, before we move to the account of the trial of Piso, it is suitable to consider the crime of which Piso was soon to stand accused.
Treason Treason was undoubtedly the appropriate crime with which to charge Piso. Treason is in one way the fundamental crime; it is an attack on the organisation of society. Naturally it is a crime with a long history at Rome, going back to the time of the kings; it was the crime with which the assembly trials, iudicia populi, were largely concerned. Perduellio was the old term, the term for high treason, such as the betrayal of Rome or things Roman to an enemy in arms; maiestas, more properly crimen laesae maiestatis populi romani, the crime of diminishing the majesty of the Roman people – or of the emperor – was essentially an internal matter. Further, treason is bound to have a political flavour, and this was certainly, and inevitably, true for the way in which the trial of Piso was handled. Treason had moved some way into the field of law with the statutes which established and affirmed the standing jury-court, the quaestio de maiestate, originally by the lex Appuleia, probably of 103 BC, and certainly confirmed by Sulla. Augustus’ lex Iulia of 8 BC superseded all its predecessors, and we have direct citation of some of its sections.43 Treason, as explained in a simple treatise of the late third century, comprised taking up arms against the state, waging war or levying troops without authorization, leading armies into ambush, or desertion; moreover, it covered words as well as deeds.44 The range of crime was wide, from high treason, the deliberate betrayal of one’s country to an enemy, through disloyal behaviour by one in authority, and so to lese-majeste´, the diminishing of the honour of the emperor and his family. Tacitus alleges 41
42 43 44
Ann. 3.7.2: ‘Nam vulgatum erat missam, ut dixi, a Cn. Sentio famosam veneficiis Martinam subita morte Brundisii exstinctam venenumque nodo crinium eius occultatum nec ulla in corpore signa sumpti exitii reperta.’ Ann. 3.9.2–3. The exact site of the house is disputed, but the SCPP, ll. 105–08, ordered the demolition of what Piso had built over the porta Fontinalis to join his private houses. Cloud, (1963). PS 5.29.1. See also Chilton (1955); Bauman (1967) and (1974); Robinson (1995), 74–80.
62
THE TRIAL OF CN. PISO CALPURNIUS
that treason was regularly added as an aggravating charge to such accusations as res repetundae (extortion) or adultery – omnium accusationum complementum.45 Yet in Piso’s case, the focus of the story was more on the ambivalent death of Germanicus than on mutiny, sedition and treason.
Delators46 On the day after Piso’s arrival in Rome, L. Fulcinius Trio, ‘a talented but unscrupulous prosecutor’ who had previously demanded a Senate inquiry into Libo’s astrological interests,47 applied to the consuls for leave to accuse Piso. Trio appears reasonably typical of the tribe of delatores which Tacitus so detested as a pest, even a danger, to society. We have seen in chapter 2 how prosecution was regarded as a necessary but morally dubious activity. The growth in the number of delators seems partly an unintended result of Augustus’ laws supporting marriage and the family, but earlier the Sullan proscriptions must have had something of the same effect.48 These Augustan laws failed to popularize marriage and the raising of families, but increasingly many people were liable to penalties since every household was exposed to informers’ claims. . . . There were spies, encouraged by inducements from the Papian-Poppaean Law, under which failure to earn the advantages of parenthood meant loss of property to the state as universal parent. The spreading encroachments of the informers grievously affected all citizens, whether in Rome, Italy or elsewhere, and caused widespread ruin and universal panic.49 Yet, naturally, both Tacitus and his readership were more concerned with the prosecution of treason than of more domestic lapses. Of the delator
45
46 47
48 49
Ann. 3.38.1. There were other cases in this period. Clutorius Priscus suffered for writing an elegy for Drusus, who was still alive, as well as for Germanicus, who was not (Ann. 3.49–51). An eques called Ennius was charged with treason for melting down a silver statue of the emperor and reusing the silver, but Tiberius stopped the proceedings (Ann. 3.70, probably referred to in D 48.4.4.1, Scaevola), where the statues are described as reprobatas; in 48.4.6, Ven. Sat., however, we find the melting down of a statue that had been consecrated brought under the lex Julia on treason. For recent substantial treatments of delators, see Rutledge (2001); Rivie`re (2002). Ann. 2.28.3 and 2.32.1; Scribonius Libo Drusus was alleged to have plotted to seize the throne after reading various astrological predictions. After his suicide following on a treason charge in AD 16, his property had been divided among his accusers. Libo was almost certainly a fatuous fop rather than a wily plotter, but nevertheless dangerous. Robinson (1995), 100; Robinson (2006); the lex Voconia seems also to have been fruitful for delators; for the earlier period, see, e.g. Cicero, 2 Verr. 1.47.123–24. Tac. Ann. 3.25 and 3.28.3.
63
THE TRIAL OF CN. CALPURNIUS PISO
Romanius Hispo he remarked: ‘Over one man he enjoyed an ascendancy; all others loathed him. His was the precedent which enabled imitators to exchange beggary for wealth, to inspire dread instead of contempt.’50 Another, Domitius Afer, brought accusations against Claudia Pulchra of adultery, attempted poisoning of the emperor, and magic; he was later to accuse her son. ‘After long poverty Afer had made money and misused it, and it surprised no one that he now had further infamous designs.’51 Dio could say that under Tiberius all who accused any persons received money, and large sums too, both from the victims’ estates and from the public treasury, as well as various honours.52 Suetonius praised Titus for dealing severely with delators, who seem in his account to have been excluded from the protection of the lex Iulia de vi;53 although many delators in Tacitus’ portrayal were senators, those suffering under Titus were probably humble delators to the fisc.54 They were a pest under Domitian, so Pliny praises Trajan for having exiled delators rather than senators and filled the punishment islands of the Mediterranean with these scourges,55 but his remarks on the delatores of his day suggest that the problem, although still real, was less concerned with senatorial accusers than it had been.56 However, although the Romans never developed a state prosecution service, attitudes to prosecution did change; there came to be restrictions on the power to make accusations,57 and the presumption was introduced that an informer without a personal interest was a calumniator.58 Further, the disappearance of the ordo as it was replaced by the universal cognitio of provincial governors (and of the Urban Prefect in the City) allowed a governor to act ex officio on a report, or rumour, rather than subsequent to a formal accusation.
The trial Preliminaries to the trial A request such as Trio’s was becoming normal procedure for a trial before the Senate; it echoed the application for permission to prosecute made to the praetor (or other president) of a standing jury-court (quaestio perpetua) – 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58
Tac. Ann. 1.74. Tac. Ann. 4.52.1 and 4.66.1. Dio Cassius 58.4.8. But see Rogers (1934). Suet. Titus 8.5. See Rivie`re (2002). Pliny, Pan. 35.2; cf. 42.1. E.g. Pliny, Ep. 1.5; 5.13.6–8. Under the Tetrarchy in FIRA i 94, p. 458; later, CTh 9.5.1, AD 319–23; 9.7.2, AD 326. See also Giglio (2002). PS 5.13.1–2. In the Later Empire prosecutions might originate with the authorities, but this was linked with what we would call an inquisitorial approach rather than implying the existence of a separate branch of government. See further on procedural offences in ch. 4.
64
THE TRIAL OF CN. PISO CALPURNIUS
the procedure Piso had earlier mocked. Publius Vitellius and Quintus Veranius objected that Trio had no interest; however, they described themselves not as accusers but as witnesses bearing Germanicus’ instructions, despite their having already in Syria begun preparing charges against Piso and Plancina, and having requested that Martina be sent to Rome. Again, it was normal with the ordinary procedure before the quaestiones that, where possible, the principal accuser should be the man with the greatest interest; the rule was that there should be one principal, even if he were to be joined by several associates.59 Trio withdrew his charge – dimissa eius causae delatione, a charge of murder presumably – but obtained leave to accuse Piso of earlier crimes. At this stage the emperor was asked to take over cognizance of the case – cognitionem exciperet,60 but it is not clear at whose initiative – perhaps that of the consuls? (It may even be significant that on two occasions we find Tiberius exercising his detective faculties, once later in the same year, when he interrogated Quirinius’ slaves when Aemilia Lepida was on trial,61 and more dramatically in AD 24, when he visited the scene of the crime after Plautius Silvanus had thrown his wife Apronia out of the window.62) But, whether or not for political reasons, as Tacitus alleges, Tiberius referred the case back to the Senate.63 Piso then set about finding advocates to represent him. Tacitus mentions five men of standing, presumably among the leading orators of the day, who declined on various grounds, but Piso’s brother, L. Calpurnius Piso the augur, with M. Aemilius Lepidus and Livineius Regulus, agreed to support him.64 There then probably followed a gap of several months. The historians have considerable problems about the dating of the whole episode, and indeed about Tacitus’ methods of narrative generally.65 The problem was brought into prominence by the discovery of the SCPP and by its date of 10
59
60 61
62 63
64
65
In the ordo the case was argued before the full quaestio perpetua (Cicero div. Caec. 1.1–2.6; Ps. Asc. p. 99; Cicero II Verr. 1.6.15). Erucius was the principal prosecutor in ch. 2. D 48.2.16, Ulpian, must refer to cognitio. Ann. 3.10.1. Ann. 3.23.2; Tiberius himself seems to have discovered, through interrogation of the slaves, that she tried to poison her husband, as well as introducing a suppositious child into his family. Ann. 4.22.2. Ann. 3.10.3: ‘haud fallebat Tiberium moles cognitionis quaque ipse fama distraheretur, igitur paucis familiarium adhibitis minas accusantium et hinc preces audit integramque causam ad senatum remittit.’ Ann. 3.11.2. It was normal before the quaestiones perpetuae for the accused to be represented by more than one advocate, while the prosecution was primarily conducted by one man; so ordinary procedure is echoed here before the Senate. Woodman and Martin (1996), 67–77. See also Champlin (1999), Talbert (1999) and Flower (1999); Levick (1983), 113f, thinks Tacitus quite capable of jumping six months forward and then back.
65
THE TRIAL OF CN. CALPURNIUS PISO
December, but the length of time which passed is largely irrelevant to the legal issues. An interval of weeks, or even months, would have been normal in a quaestio trial; Cicero had 110 days to collect evidence against Verres. There is no need to doubt that extraordinary procedure before the Senate or emperor commonly mirrored the norms of the ordo. This interval was for both sides to collect their witnesses and assemble their proofs.66 The opening of the trial Finally there came the day of the Senate’s meeting, the first of its meetings for the trial of Piso. Tiberius seems to have been presiding, since he directed the Senate’s attention to the questions they must consider. It is not quite the same as the speech recorded in the SC, a speech which is explicitly stated to have been made after Piso’s death a week or so later. However, it is by no means impossible that Tacitus used the Senate’s records to help construct the speech he narrates. Anyway, at this stage Tiberius said that he, with the authorisation of the Senate, had sent Piso to be Germanicus’ assistant in the administration of the East. Whether Piso had been insubordinate and quarrelsome there, and had rejoiced at Germanicus’ death, or had even brought it about by poison, were the allegations of which the truth must be ascertained;67 the unsurprising implication was that Piso was guilty of something. If Piso had behaved unbecomingly, and rejoiced at the death of his superior, Tiberius would formally renounce his friendship and close his doors against him, but would not use his public powers to avenge private wrongs. If, however, there was evidence of murder, a crime needing vengeance whatever the victim’s rank, it was for the Senate, as a court, to satisfy Germanicus’ children and his parents – that is, the emperor.68 Further, inquiry should be made as to whether Piso had incited his troops to mutiny and rebellion, bribed them, and sought to recover his province by force of arms, or whether these were falsehoods spread and exaggerated by his accusers.69 Tiberius had found the accusers over-zealous; stripping Germanicus’ body and exposing it had only served to encourage the report that he was poisoned, a matter still to be ascertained. While he grieved for his son, and always would, he must not deny the accused every opportunity to prove his own innocence, and indeed any unfairness on the part of Germanicus.70 He finished by urging both defenders and accusers to their best efforts. In only one respect was Germanicus’ case being dealt with outside 66 67 68 69 70
The presence of documents and witnesses is mentioned in the SCPP, ll. 24–25, and Ann. 3.17. Ann. 3.12.1. Ann. 3.12.2. Ann. 3.12.3. See the sections of the lex Iulia maiestatis cited in D 48.4.1.1 and 48.4.2, Ulpian. Ann. 3.12.4–5.
66
THE TRIAL OF CN. PISO CALPURNIUS
the normal course of the law: the trial was before the Senate not a quaestio perpetua.71 By the time of Pliny, as we shall see in the next chapter, cognitio before the Senate had become regulated. The prosecution The prosecution was then allotted two days for the conduct of its case, and the defence, after an interval of six days, three. This was the normal proportion of time allocated to the two sides in trials under the ordo;72 it was still being observed in Pliny’s time in trials before the Senate modelled on the ordo, although modification was possible.73 The Senate’s resolution does not give precise figures.74 However, clearly the trial was extra ordinem; the rules governing trials before the standing jury-courts were being somewhat bent, because Trio opened the prosecution with charges of extortion when Piso was governing Spain years before.75 Tacitus calls these charges old and empty, but attacks on and evidence as to character played an important part in Roman criminal trials; furthermore, while avaritia was a stock charge, ambition was relevant to the present case. This illustrates the main advantage of the cognitio procedure before the Senate – or the emperor, and in due course his delegates. A charge of res repetundae could not, in theory, have been heard before the same quaestio as a charge of treason or of poisoning, for in principle each quaestio perpetua heard only one specific form of charge; thus in this case three separate trials should have been necessary under the ordo.76 (It is, however, probable that the quaestio de maiestate was already falling into desuetude, at least for senators; Libo had been tried for treason before the Senate as early as AD 16.77) Since the charges arose from one set of inter-related acts, justice was more likely to be achieved if they were dealt with at the one trial. Veranius and Vitellius, together with Q. Servaeus (another of Germanicus’ companions in the East), laid accusations against Piso of inciting sedition among his troops, insubordination, and lastly of killing Germanicus by spells and poison (devotionibus et veneno), alleging that then, ‘after his and Plancina’s evil rites and sacrifices (sacra hinc et immolationes nefandas ipsius atque Plancinae)’, he had made war on the res publica.78 Vitellius further argued that Germanicus must have been poisoned since his heart would not 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78
Ann. 3.12.6–7: ‘super leges praestiterimus quod in curia potius quam in foro, apud senatum quam apud iudices de morte eius anquiritur.’ Asconius, in Milon. 36C. Pliny, Ep. 4.9.9. SCPP, ll. 23–24. Ann. 3.13.1: ‘ambitiose avareque habitam Hispaniam’. Cf. D 48.2.14, Paul: ‘the Senate has ruled that a person cannot be charged on account of the same crime under several statutes’. Ann.2.27–32. Ann. 3.13.2; cf. SCPP, ll. 45–57.
67
THE TRIAL OF CN. CALPURNIUS PISO
burn; but Piso’s defence was that neither would organs which were naturally diseased.79 Here, in the acceptance of three prosecutors rather than one, we find a distinct variation from the ordinary procedure of the quaestiones. The defence Tacitus makes no mention of events during the six-day interval, but moves straight from the prosecution’s case to that of the defence. He states that there was no effective defence to the charges of corrupting the troops, harming the province, and insubordination. But the poisoning charge was refuted, particularly the allegation that, at a dinner given by Germanicus, Piso who was sitting next to him, had himself put poison into his host’s food. Piso offered his own slaves for interrogation under torture.80 Tiberius was convinced by now that Piso was guilty of treason, in that he had invaded Syria under arms despite a warning from Sentius, his successor as governor. The Senate remained unconvinced that Germanicus had died naturally, even though the prosecution had failed to prove its case.81 Outside the senate house a mob was demonstrating against Piso, threatening to lynch him and actually dragging his statues to the Gemonian Steps, where the bodies of criminals were rolled into the Tiber,82 but Tiberius had them put back, presumably motivated by the need to maintain public order.83 Piso was given a litter and an escort by a tribune of the Praetorians to get him home safely, or perhaps, as Tacitus says, to see that he died.84 There is a lacuna in the text between Tacitus’ report of the views of the senators and his account of the popular clamour.85 The text suggests that certain letters were being demanded, presumably by the Senate, and not produced, but it is not clear what these were, although the appearance of letters in the trial is confirmed in the SC.86 Quite a few letters had been mentioned in the course of Tacitus’ narrative: Germanicus’ letter to Piso, renouncing his friendship and (presumably) ordering him from his province, Piso’s letters to Tiberius, complaining of Germanicus’ behaviour, Sentius’ letter to Piso, and allegations of ‘secret’ mandates to Piso from Tiberius – as
79
80 81 82 83 84 85 86
Pliny HN 11.71.187. Za¨ch (1972) reports that he sought and obtained confirmation of Piso’s contention from the professor of forensic medicine in Zu¨rich; also the foam from Germanicus’ mouth and the dark spots all over his body, described by Suetonius (Cal.1.2), could equally be symptoms of disease or of poisoning. Ann. 3.14.1–2. We have considered slaves’ evidence, always under torture, in ch. 2. Ann. 3.14.3. E.g. Sejanus and his children (Dio Cassius 58.11.5–6); Vitellius (Dio Cassius 64.21.2). Ann. 3.14.4. Ann. 3.14.5: ‘vario rumore custos saluti an mortis exactor sequeretur’. Woodman and Martin (1996), 159–62. SCPP, ll. 24–25, 38–39.
68
THE TRIAL OF CN. PISO CALPURNIUS
regards the last, it would be surprising if someone sent to govern a province was not given confidential imperial mandates. Of these, the Senate would hardly have demanded to see Tiberius’ private correspondence; Sentius’ letter would have been irrelevant to the murder charge; we are told in the SC that Germanicus’ letters were in fact produced at the trial. Therefore it seems most likely that the letters referred to are Piso’s to the emperor. The Senate hoped that his complaints against Germanicus in these letters would strengthen the murder charge by revealing personal hatred, but Tiberius preferred not to disclose them as they amounted to poison-pen letters. But this can only be conjecture. The SC thanks the princeps because ‘he made available to the Senate everything necessary for seeking out the truth’.87 Piso’s end Whatever had happened, Piso returned to the Senate on the second day allotted to the defence, disheartened, according to Tacitus, by the fact that Plancina, in the expectation of a pardon, had already dissociated herself from her husband.88 Tacitus refers to renewed accusation, hostile voices and universal enmity, but presumably there were further speeches for the defence, since the SC records that the case was argued for several days by the accusers and by Piso himself.89 There was presumably also the examination and cross-examination of witnesses. Tacitus describes the silent emperor, deaf to the emotional appeals of both sides, as terrifying rather than reassuring Piso.90 He returned home in despair at the implacability of his judges, and then, according to the SC, committed suicide; it is not clear whether he did this because of the hostile atmosphere or because the evidence had been damning. Tacitus’ version is more detailed, and loaded. On his return home, he wrote a few words, as though considering the next day’s defence, sealed the note and gave it to a freedman. Then he performed his usual toilet; late at night, when his wife had left the bedroom, he ordered the doors to be shut. At dawn he was found with his throat cut, a sword lying beside him on the ground.91 The normality of his behaviour could be due to his being in shock, or it could well be his adoption of traditional Stoicism, a Stoicism suitable for a Republican of noble birth and achievements. 87 88 89
90 91
SCPP, ll. 15–16. Ann. 3.15.1. Woodman and Martin (1996), 160, hold that this description is due to Tacitus’ impressionism, to be interpreted ‘not as an otherwise unexplained return to the formal prosecution but as a resumption of the personal hostility’. Ann. 3.15.2. Ann. 3.15.3.
69
THE TRIAL OF CN. CALPURNIUS PISO
Tacitus prefers to imply that he was murdered. He reports that it was known that Piso had a document (libellus), which was often seen in his hands, which contained letters from Tiberius with instructions relating to Germanicus; Piso would have disclosed its contents, and thus convicted the emperor, if he had not been deceived by Sejanus.92 The mention of Sejanus is almost certainly merely the start of scene-setting by Tacitus for the next major episode in the Annals. Certainly the political aspect was sensitive. Piso clearly could not make the defence that the emperor had appointed him to check Germanicus, although there was nothing inherently sinister in such an instruction; equally clearly, a transcription would have had little evidentiary value, and ‘in any case the likelihood of Tiberius’ having incriminated himself either in writing or orally is nil’.93 Tiberius himself must have been regretting his bad judgment in that Piso, his old friend, had been his own choice for the job, yet had undoubtedly acted treasonably, and must now be disowned and discarded. But it is not plausible to believe that he had wanted an overt quarrel, involving actual hostilities, between his heir and his friend, because it served no purpose, damaged Roman prestige, and in the event led to a (fortunately very minor) civil war.
Subsidiary trials Despite Piso’s death, the Senate met again, presumably on the following day, the third provided for the defence. It would have seemed pointless to stop the trial at this stage, when the full truth might still emerge.94 Moreover, Marcus and Plancina had also been indicted, as well as certain members of Piso’s staff. Hence the SC records that Tiberius had asked the Senate to give judgment on what case there had seemed to be against Cn. Piso, whether he appeared deservedly to have killed himself, what case there seemed to be against Marcus Piso (to which he added that the senators should be mindful of his own prayers for the young man), what case there seemed to be and on what grounds against Plancina, for whom Tiberius had earlier petitioned, and what should be done with Visellius Karus and Sempronius Bassus, Piso’s companions.95 Tacitus tells us that Tiberius questioned Piso’s son96 on his father’s behaviour during that last day and night. Thereafter he read Piso’s statement 92 93 94
95 96
Ann. 3.16.1; so too Suet. Tib. 52.3. Woodman and Martin (1996), 171; ‘The passive contineri implies that Piso had transcribed any original litterae and mandata into his libellus.’ On the question of whether treason charges ended with the death of the accused, see D 48.4.11, Ulpian, which applies this only to perduellio, not the maiestas of the Julian law; however, armed invasion of a province would indeed appear to be perduellio. SCPP, ll. 4–11. No name is given in Ann. 3.16.2; Cnaeus, the elder son, seems more likely than Marcus, who was not yet a member of the Senate.
70
THE TRIAL OF CN. PISO CALPURNIUS
(codicillos), which must be what Piso had written the previous night, whether as notes for his advocates, or for himself. Piso expressed himself as beset by enemies, falsely charged – he could reasonably play the injured innocent as regards the poisoning, and his own assertion of defence against the treason charges may have been that he had not legally been deprived of his governorship – and always loyal to the emperor and his mother; pleading that loyalty to Augustus’ family, he requested that no harm should come to his older son, Cnaeus, who had been in Rome all the while his father was in the East, nor to Marcus the younger, who had tried to dissuade him from attacking Sentius. No mention was made of Plancina.97 Perhaps at the same session, perhaps later, Tiberius exonerated Marcus, or rather, as the SC specifies, proposed his exoneration from the charge of making civil war, on the grounds that he had a duty to obey his father’s orders. He also expressed regret for the noble family and Piso’s sad end, whether or not it was deserved.98 Two days were spent on the investigation of Plancina; it is not clear whether it was a formal trial. She had originally been protesting loyalty to Piso, but Livia’s promises led her to dissociate herself from him.99 Tacitus here puts in a vicious couple of sentences, accusing Tiberius and Livia of aiming at the destruction of Germanicus’ family, and protecting Plancina. He implies that her trial was a sham,100 with her being assured of pardon. Her sons did not speak on her behalf, despite the emperor’s encouragement,101 so her accusers went unanswered. But clearly there can have been no more proof of poisoning in her case than in Piso’s, and she cannot, as a woman, have been guilty of, or even charged with, his treasonable activities, because, at least under the ordo, such charges were applicable only to men holding office, and their staffs. Yet the SC records that numerous weighty charges had been lodged against her; one must suppose either that the extraordinary procedure allowed consideration of her public conduct, such as attending cavalry exercises,102 or that most of them were irrelevant to the ongoing trial of her husband. The SC also states that Livia used her influence over the Senate very sparingly, but since she had pleaded for Plancina, the punishment of Plancina should be remitted – remittiq[ue] poenam Plancinae. This wording contrasts with the Senate’s conclusion concerning Marcus, to whom inpunitatem . . . dandam esse{t}.103 97
Ann. 3.16.3–4. Cn. Piso junior became consul in 27, and was Urban Prefect at the end of Tiberius’ reign; his son became consul in 57. Marcus incurred no penalty, but disappeared from the view of history. 98 Ann. 3.17.1; SCPP, ll. 100–01. 99 Ann. 3.15.1. 100 Ann. 3.17.3: ‘biduum super hac imagine cognitionis absumptum’. Cf. Marshall (1990). 101 SCPP, ll. 20–22. 102 Ann. 2.55.6. 103 SCPP, ll. 100–01 and 119–20.
71
THE TRIAL OF CN. CALPURNIUS PISO
The sentences Presumably at the end of these two days, one of the consuls, Aurelius Cotta, was asked to make the first recommendation to the Senate; he proposed that Piso’s name should be deleted from the calendar, the fasti consulares, that half his property should be confiscated, with Cn. Piso junior keeping the other, but compelled to change his praenomen – in the event he became Lucius, like his uncle – that Marcus should be deprived of the latus clavus and relegated for ten years but allowed 5 million sesterces, and that, on the plea of Livia, Plancina should be pardoned.104 According to Tacitus – the SC records neither Cotta proposing nor Tiberius intervening – Tiberius mitigated the penalties. He left Piso’s name on the fasti, since even the names of Marcus Antonius, and his son Iullus Antonius, remained there;105 Marcus Piso was not to be stripped of his rank, nor relegated, and was allowed his paternal inheritance. There is a degree of divergence between Tacitus’ account of the penalties and those recorded in the SC. In the SC we find it held that Piso did not suffer as he deserved by dying,106 so the Senate voted that there be no mourning for his death by the women of his family, that his statues and portrait masks, wherever displayed, be removed,107 that no portrait mask of him was to be carried in family funeral processions, that his name be removed from the inscription on the statue of Germanicus in the Campus Martius, and that his property, except the lands in Illyricum (which were to revert – on grounds of ingratitude, presumably – to Tiberius since Augustus had presented them to Piso), was to be confiscated.108 However, half the confiscated property was to be granted to Cnaeus Piso the younger, who was advised, being so favoured, to change his praenomen. Marcus was given immunity, and granted the other half of his father’s estate; 5 million sesterces from the whole estate were reserved for Calpurnia, Piso’s daughter,109 1 million as her dowry, the rest as her personal property (peculi [sic] nomine).110 Finally, the curatores locorum publicorum were to see to the demolition of the structure erected by Piso over the porta Fontinalis to join his private houses.111 104 105
106 107 108 109 110 111
Ann. 3.17.4. Plancina did, however, come to her fate in AD 33 (Ann. 6.26.3). Piso’s name was, however, removed from a record of the celebration of games by Tiberius and Piso as joint consuls (CIL VI 385 with 30751) and perhaps also in the Acta Arvalium (CIL VI 2023a, 21) where there is indeed an erasure, but the name erased could as well have been that of Libo Drusus. SCPP, ll. 71–73. Cf. D 48.19.24, Modestinus; see also Flower (1998). SCPP, ll. 73–90. There is a conflict of opinion among the historians as to her identity; Eck et al. (1996), 83ff and 218ff, and Flower (1999) think she was Piso’s granddaughter. SCPP, ll. 93–105. SCPP, ll. 105–08.
72
THE TRIAL OF CN. PISO CALPURNIUS
The SC, but not Tacitus, also records that Visellius Karus and Sempronius Bassus, two of Piso’s comites, as socii and ministri in all his crimes, were to be exiled, more specifically, ‘that they should be interdicted from fire and water by the praetor who had charge of the jury-court for treason’, and that all their property was to be confiscated.112 This appears to be a case of the Senate advising or instructing a magistrate how he should proceed. There is no need to envisage a jury empanelled; the praetor, as president of the court, could pronounce the sentence laid down by the statute, even when the proof of the crime had been led elsewhere. But this does suggest that the quaestiones perpetuae were still regarded as the normal courts of criminal law, the iudicia publica. The penalty was the statutory one for treason under the lex Iulia, and Roman criminal law normally imposed the same penalty on accomplices as on the principal. Piso was held manifestly to have ignored the authority of one with maius imperium, to have stirred up the enemies of Rome in Armenia, to have attempted civil war by returning under arms to the province of Syria, to have inflicted capital punishment on many whose cases had been unheard, and even to have crucified a centurion who was a Roman citizen,113 to have corrupted military discipline, to have maintained his complaints about Germanicus even after the latter’s death, and to have rejoiced in that death. The evidence for this last was clear to the Senate: in that impious sacrifices (nefaria sacrificia) had been made by him, the ships in which he sailed had been ‘ornatae’ (presumably something like the modern ‘dressed overall’), he had opened temples (at Cos) closed out of piety, he had given money to the messenger who brought the news, and he had given frequent banquets in the days after the news had reached him. Piso was also held guilty of something akin to blasphemy, numen divi Augusti violatum.114 Tiberius vetoed the proposals of Valerius Messallinus and Caecina Severus for a golden statue in the temple of Mars Ultor or for an altar of vengeance, on the grounds that such things were appropriate for foreign victories, not domestic misfortunes. Valerius Messallinus had also proposed formal thanks to Tiberius, Livia, Antonia (Germanicus’ mother), Agrippina (his wife), and Drusus (his brother), for avenging Germanicus; the name of Claudius, Germanicus’ other brother and the future emperor, was added to the family list only when L. Asprenas pointed out the omission.115 This was done, as the SC witnesses, with praises for the justice and restraint of Tiberius, Livia and Drusus. The Senate commended Agrippina, Antonia, Livia the sister of Germanicus, his children, and his brother, as also the conduct of the equestrian order, of the populus, and of those soldiers who had resisted Piso’s 112 113 114 115
SCPP, ll. 120–23: ‘aqua et igne interdicti oportere ab eo praetore qui legem maiestatis quaereret’. Seneca de ira 1.18.3 is presumably recording this occasion, although he does not mention crucifixion as the penalty. SCPP, ll. 68–70. Ann. 3.18.2–3.
73
THE TRIAL OF CN. CALPURNIUS PISO
solicitations and remained faithful to the family of Augustus. Tiberius’ speech to the Senate and the consequent resolution, specifically a single decree,116 were to be inscribed and set up where it should please Tiberius, and also in every leading provincial city and in the winter quarters of each legion. The SC was a carefully drafted document. It ignored any awkward questions, such as Tiberius’ own (indirect) responsibility for Piso’s conduct, and it praised the whole established order, including the Roman people. Yet one could argue that it also recognized the importance of reconciliation, of maintaining the social bonds that held together the orders; despite the individual blot, the Calpurnii Pisones continued to thrive. There is no reason to doubt that there was a deep-rooted fear of the return of the civil wars. It was indeed a whitewash, but it is hard to see what else could have been done.117 Some days later, Tiberius rewarded the three main prosecutors (but not Trio), not of course with Piso’s estate,118 but by putting them forward for priesthoods; Trio he promised to help in his official career (and indeed he became suffect consul in 31), but also warned him to be less aggressive. Thus ended the vengeance for Germanicus, and Drusus left Rome.119 But was Germanicus avenged? The senatorial tradition continued to maintain that Tiberius was hostile to Germanicus’ wife and family.120 Despite Germanicus’ own belief and his own allegations, no proof was ever brought that he was poisoned, and the Senate seems reluctantly to have accepted Piso’s innocence of active harm. The contumely Germanicus had suffered from Piso’s insubordination was avenged, but was that really vengeance? Was his death in fact natural? Poison was often suspected when medical knowledge was insufficient to diagnose internal diseases. Was Martina a red herring? Cursings could have been the work of a disgruntled household slave, or indeed have stemmed from the machinations of Livia. A mystery remains. (As a footnote, the affair may well have contributed to the resolution of the Senate making a governor liable for his wife’s delicts, although the immediate context was probably the trial of Gaius Silius in AD 24.121) 116
117 118
119 120 121
The writing of this SC on 10 December, in the portico of Apollo’s temple on the Palatine – as good a place as any for the Senate to meet – was witnessed by M. Valerius Messallinus, C. Ateius Capito, Sextus Pompeius, M. Pompeius Priscus, C. Arrenus Gallus, and L. Nonius Asprenas and M. Vinucius, the last two being quaestors. 301 senators were present. See Griffin (1997). It is uncertain what the law was on rewards at this time, or indeed whether there was a rule. In AD 16 Libo’s property was divided among his accusers (Ann. 2.32.1); in AD 24, in a repetundae case, Tacitus has M. Lepidus say that the law required that a quarter of a condemned man’s estate should go the prosecutors (Ann. 4.20.2). Ann. 3.19. Not only Tacitus, but also Suet. Tib. 52.3–54; Dio Cassius 57.18.6. Josephus (AJ 18.54) believed that Germanicus was poisoned. D 1.16.4.2, Ulpian, and Ann. 4.18–20 give different occasions for this SC.
74
THE TRIAL OF CN. PISO CALPURNIUS
The survival of the standing jury-courts It is clear that the Empire was sufficiently established for all men to expect the emperor to be concerned with treason charges, even if the Senate was the forum. Nobody suggests, not even Tacitus, that the quaestio de maiestate might have been appropriate. The state must protect itself, and juries were too remote from power, and perhaps still too open to improper influence. The question of the utility of the jury-courts, and their survival, is relevant here. The quaestiones perpetuae had been approved by Augustus, who had even added the adultery court. Tiberius was careful to maintain Augustus’ policies, so we can assume that they continued as a system in his time, even if the Senate became the normal forum for senators accused of crimes (and, of course, for our sources these are the most interesting trials). While all the maiestas and repetundae trials that we hear of from the start of his reign were held in the Senate, that does not prove the disappearance even of these specific quaestiones; they might have continued for subordinate officers and junior officials, persons too unimportant for the historians. We do explicitly hear of the quaestio de sicariis in AD 54, and of the quaestio de falsis in AD 61.122 Business before them must have remained reasonably brisk under the Julio-Claudians, for Augustus had created a fourth decury for the album and Caligula a fifth; Claudius and Galba chose to lengthen the court year.123 Quintilian, who died in 96, speaks of them as a living institution, and there is other possible evidence for their survival under Domitian.124 Pliny’s evidence on the survival of the quaestiones perpetuae is unfortunately unclear.125 Ambiguity remains in the case where a mother, whose son was dead, was accusing the son’s freedmen, who were joint heirs with her to his estate, of poisoning him and forging his will.126 The alleged murder of her son was sufficient to allow a woman to accuse,127 but poisoning and forgery were quite different charges and could not have been made at the same time under the ordo.128 This may be why she took her case to the emperor, who 122 123
124
125
126 127 128
Seneca, apoc. 14.1; Tac. Ann. 14.41. A decury was a group of those qualified by wealth and rank to sit as jurors, from which the numbers selected for the album in a particular year were drawn. Suet. Aug. 32.3; Claud. 23.1; Cal. 16.2; Galba 14.3. Quint. inst. or. 3.10.1; 11.3.130; Pliny, Ep. 3.9.33: ‘tamquam apud iudicem sub Domitiano Salvi Liberalis accusatoribus adfuisset’ (that [Norbanus] had appeared in court under Domitian among the accusers of Salvius Liberalis). The iudices mentioned in Suet. Dom. 8 were almost certainly not the jurors of the criminal courts, but more likely judges-delegate: ‘nummarios iudices cum suo quemque consilio notavit’ ([the emperor] degraded judges taking bribes together with each’s council of advisers). Pliny, ep. 4.29 could be talking of a civil iudex selectus, but Nepos’ reappearance as praetor in ep. 5.9 does suggest a criminal court, since he is a praetor ‘qui legibus quaerit’, and he is issuing an edict for accusatores and reos. Pliny, Ep. 7.6.8–10. D 48.2.1, Pomponius. As Sherwin-White (1966), 409f, pointed out.
75
THE TRIAL OF CN. CALPURNIUS PISO
accepted the accusation, and she obtained Julius Servianus as judge, judgedelegate – impetraverat could mean she had asked for him. Pliny defended the freedmen, and adds: Finem cognitioni quaestio imposuit quae secundum reos dedit. It seems likely that Servianus was deciding whether the alleged offences were so closely linked that they could be heard together; once that was settled, the case may have gone before a quaestio perpetua, which acquitted. Radice translates this as ‘the inquiry was stopped after the court had decided in favour of the defendants’, although her note accepts the two stages. But they could be two stages before the same judge, particularly if the mother asked for him, as a noted figure. Later she went again to the emperor, claiming there was fresh evidence, and Suburanus, Trajan’s first Praetorian Prefect (although he may not have held the office at this time), was ordered to give a rehearing if there was new evidence – which there was not. This argues against the use of a quaestio, since there was no question of an appeal from them, or of setting aside a jury’s verdict; corrupt jurors might be charged, but the verdict stood. It would not be particularly surprising if what happened was that the courts for political crimes disappeared early while those for ordinary offences, such as adultery, forgery and murder, continued for a while. It may be significant that the formula given for an indictment is an accusation of adultery,129 and that so much juristic discussion of adultery is preserved in the Digest. However, Dio’s remark about his finding so many adultery cases awaiting trial when he became consul – his suffect consulship of c. AD 204 – is, if anything, an indication that even that jury-court had fallen into desuetude, for a consul had no role in the operation of the quaestiones perpetuae.130 Even in civil procedure cognitio was replacing the ordo in the course of the second century; the change is likely to have happened faster in criminal matters.131 One possible source of confusion is the changing meaning of the term ‘iudicium publicum’. At some stage it ceased to mean a quaestio perpetua and had come (as in Inst. 4.18) to denote merely a criminal court, or a court hearing a criminal case. Not even Tacitus suggests that the accusations against Piso were unsustainable in the sphere of state action. Even if Piso had been intended to be a check on Germanicus, this would not justify disobedience to a lawful superior – as Tiberius stresses in his plea for Marcus Piso. Suicide was the proper course for a Roman gentleman whom the fates had condemned, and Piso was prepared to go so far as to describe his own actions as pravitas. 129 130 131
D 48.2.3pr, Paul, but Paul also tells us that the ordo had fallen into disuse (D 48.1.8). Dio Cassius 76.16. Garnsey (1967) held the adultery court did survive until the Severans; Brasiello (1962) thought the jury-courts only disappeared under Diocletian. My view is that they went sooner rather than later, and see Robinson (2001) FS Wacke, on the development of civil cognitio.
76
THE TRIAL OF CN. PISO CALPURNIUS
There is no hint of a reign of terror in this trial. The accusers have not benefited from the accused, even if they have been rewarded. Intrigues there may well have been among a small social group, but in spite of Tacitus’ nudges and winks, there seems no reason to find any miscarriage of justice, or appearance of it.
77
Chapter 4 PLINY AND R E P E T U N D A E TRIALS BEFORE THE SENATE
In this chapter, as in the next two, we are looking not at one but at a (linked) series of trials. Here the trials are all for the same offence and before the same court, but the different cases show different aspects of, and development in, both practice and policy. Tacitus probably thought of himself as above all a writer, who also carried out the normal functions of a senator. Pliny, however, was something close to a ‘professional’ advocate. Further, the Pliny we know from the letters seems a conscientious, truthful man, self-important but hard-working, somewhat vain but not ungenerous, clearly not given to self-analysis. In this chapter we are looking at trials in which our author himself took part, where there is no reason to doubt his account, provided one makes the natural allowance for partiality.1 He was writing for publication, true, but in the interests of literary fame, not with an essentially moral objective; unlike Tacitus, he will not invariably have had a sub-text.
The crime of res repetundae In this period, under the Emperor Trajan (AD 98–117), most of the criminal trials of which we hear were before the Senate on the charge of extortion from the provincials, de pecunia repetunda (or de pecuniis repetundis). Even in this brief period there were developments in criminal procedure. This offence had been the subject of the first quaestio perpetua in the mid-second century BC; the definitive statute governing extortion was the lex Iulia repetundarum, passed by Julius Caesar in 59 BC.2 This, like most such statutes, laid down its own procedure and its own penalty, almost certainly interdiction from fire and water,3 and simple restitution from the estate of the 1 2 3
In the dating of these trials, I follow Sherwin-White (1966). Ep., without further amplification, means a letter of Pliny. It was a substantial piece of legislation; Cicero, ad fam. 8.8.3, refers to the one hundred and first section (caput) of the lex. See Fontenay de Pontette (1954); Robinson (1995b), 81–82. When a citizen went into exile, whether voluntarily or not, he would normally be banned from hearth and home, deprived of his rights as a citizen to property and even to life, outlawed.
78
PLINY AND REPETUNDAE TRIALS
convicted man.4 The statute was supplemented under Augustus by the SC Calvisianum, linked with the fifth of the edicts to Cyrene,5 setting up a senatorial commission, but this dealt mainly with the procedure for estimating the damages; it became absorbed into the Senate’s overall jurisdiction. Moreover, the quaestio, the jury-court, seems to have fallen into disuse – at least for senators – by the start of Tiberius’ reign at the latest, and jurisdiction over res repetundae was exercised by the Senate, or occasionally by the emperor. Nevertheless, the terms of the lex Iulia remained the basis of the law throughout the Principate. It covered the making or receiving of any improper exaction from the inhabitants of a province by anyone holding a magistracy or other office in the public service, or any violation of public duty following the acceptance of money;6 the normal element of gain is stressed by the prohibition on usucapion of things acquired contrary to the statute.7 The element of reparation meant that the heirs of an accused remained liable (for a year) for any unjustified enrichment.8 Originally only senators had been liable, but this liability was extended to the entourage (comites) of a governor or other office-holder,9 and then to equestrian office-holders in their own right.10 Under Tiberius, the Senate extended the liability to wives.11 The exaction of monies and other things also came to cover the acceptance of apparently freely offered presents,12 4
On the arguments about the penalty of the lex Iulia, see still Sherwin-White (1949); Henderson (1951); Sherwin-White (1952a); Venturini (1979). 5 FIRA i no. 68, p. 409ff. 6 D 48.11.1pr, Marcian; 48.11.9, Papinian. 7 D 48.11.8, Paul. 8 D 48.11.2, Scaevola; cf. 48.1.6, Marcian, where although the penalty has ceased to be relevant, the judge must deal with pecuniary consequences; 48.2.20, Modestinus. 9 D 48.11.5, Macer; Cicero, Rab.Post. 5.12, of 63 BC, makes clear that equestrians were not then liable. The sons and other close relations of senators were covered, but not equestrian staff until the end of the first century AD. 10 Dio Cassius 61.33.6 refers to an imperial procurator, an equestrian but the man in charge of a province, as possibly liable under Claudius; Tac. Ann. 13.33.1 seems to deal with a quaestor or legate under Nero; D 49.14.46.2, Hermog. dates from the end of the third century. 11 D 1.16.4.2, Ulpian, who ascribes it to AD 20, when it would presumably have been in consequence of Plancina’s conduct (see ch. 3); Tacitus, however, ascribes it to AD 24, after earlier debate in 21 (Ann. 4.20; 3.33–34). 12 The statute excepted presents from very close relatives, second cousins or closer, and wives (D 48.11.1.1, Marcian) – no mention here of the ban on gifts between spouses! But nothing at all, not even the smallest amount, was permissible from others (48.11.7.1, Macer). Presumably Modestinus’ reference (1.18.18) to a plebiscite limiting gifts to the governor to what he could eat or drink within a day or so (rather like President Truman) was a reference to the lex Iulia, but Ulpian, 1.16.6.3, tells us that this was concerned with forage and hospitium, rather than ordinary gifts. Severus and Caracalla allowed moderate presents; by their period many governors were of provincial origin, and there was no ban on officials serving in their province of origin, so there must have been need for some relaxation. In what must be a fairly late development of the law – since the term ‘urban’ is clearly not being restricted to Rome – municipal magistrates were not to receive gifts or favours in any one year worth more than 100 aurei (48.11.6.2, Ven. Sat.).
79
PLINY AND REPETUNDAE TRIALS
taking money for military appointments or other seemingly normal exercises of jurisdiction,13 also engaging in trade, including owning commercial vessels, buying slaves, except as replacements, demanding forage (or allowances in lieu) except when actually on circuit, and other offences of this sort.14 ‘The very length and complexity of the lex Iulia suggest that it dealt fully with innumerable types of illegal enrichment.’15 Julius Caesar had extended the liability so as to overlap with constitutional matters, including treason;16 it already seems to have overlapped with murder in the area of judicial corruption.17 Whether in the statute, or through its extension and interpretation, the abuses of official power included the taking of money to give or withhold a judgment, or taking a bribe to do more or less than one’s duty;18 further, and clearly applicable to private persons, accepting money to give or withhold evidence fell under the statute.19 Where the motive was malice, not gain, there was more likely to be liability under the lex Iulia de vi.20 It seems a convincing explanation that judicial bribery was added to the scope of res repetundae because that quaestio was particularly open to bribery, in view of huge sums that might be involved; this would also explain why corrupt acquittal was covered as well as corrupt condemnation.21 Proper behaviour by provincial governors was a matter of concern to the Roman ruling classes in the Republic. There were various motives: that the overburdened provincials should not be driven to rebellion, that they should not be so overwhelmed by private exactions that their taxes did not benefit the treasury, that Roman senators should maintain a good image. Governors were not expected to be saints, but they should show a decent moderation, and enforce justice; Verres’ behaviour was contrary to the accepted conventions of his class. Various accusations of repetundae were made in the period from 26 BC to the end of Domitian’s reign.22 At some stage in the first century the Senate came to sequestrate the property of somebody convicted of res repetundae so that realistic claims for reparation could be made.23 This 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23
D 48.11.6.2, Ven. Sat.; 48.11.7pr and 2, Macer. D 1.16.6.3, Ulpian; 18.1.46, Marcian; 49.14.46.2, Hermog.; 50.5.3, Macer; 48.11.8.1, Paul; cf. Cicero II Verr. 1.3.7–9; 4.5.9–10. Brunt (1961), 191. Cicero, Pis. 21.50; 37.90; D 1.16.10.1, Ulpian. Fidiculanius Falcula, a senator, was acquitted in the extortion court of having taken a bribe from Cluentius in the capital trial of Oppianicus (Cicero, Clu. 37.104). Cicero, Pis. 36.87; D 48.11.3, Macer, and 4, Ven. Sat. D 48.11.6pr, Ven.Sat. D 48.6.10pr, Ulpian, although in the third century Macer held that the motive of rage could fall under res repetundae (48.11.7.3). Cloud (1994), 514. Brunt (1961), p. 224ff, lists 34. This was done after the conviction of Baebius Massa in AD 93, under Domitian; Ep. 7.33.4. Pliny’s prosecution of him is also briefly mentioned in Ep. 3.4.4 and 6.29.8.
80
PLINY AND REPETUNDAE TRIALS
meant that injured provincials would seem to have greatly improved their chances of recovering damages. The area ruled by the emperors from Rome was being consolidated, and the emperors viewed offences against the provincials as, at least potentially, offences against their good rule, the discipline of their times. This chapter is restricted to those prosecutions brought under Trajan for which we have the evidence of Pliny’s letters, reporting trials in which he had played a leading part as advocate, whether for prosecution or defence; thus we can see something of the inner workings of these cases. The disappearance of ‘voluntary’ exile One significant difference between the Republic and the Empire was the disappearance of the practice of ‘voluntary’ exile and of interdiction from fire and water. It was replaced by the more formal penalty of deportation, always permanent, with loss of citizenship and civil rights.24 Provincial governors did not have the power to deport.25 A milder form of exile was relegation, with retention of civil rights, even if the sentence was in perpetuity.26 Relegation might be accompanied by a fine or by the confiscation of some or all property;27 provincial governors had the power to relegate as well as fine.28 There was no explicit constitutional measure which brought about a change from voluntary exile to deportation, but in the second century forms of exile were able to be classified.29 It had in the old days been enough that exiles must live outside Rome and Italy,30 but Augustus in AD 12 forbade those interdicted from fire and water to live on the mainland, or on any island within 50 miles of it (with certain exceptions), and imposed various other restrictions on exiles’ way of life, such as not having a familia of more than twenty slaves or freedmen, nor being allowed to possess property worth more than half a million sesterces.31 (This shows very clearly that it was a penalty appropriate for the upper ranks of society.) Tiberius removed the capacity to make a will from those interdicted from fire and water;32 this applied subsequently to deportation but not relegation. Augustus’ severity was clearly modified by some later emperor, for we find in these trials under 24
25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32
D 48.22.2, Marcian, although the deportee might be allowed to take some property (under the ius gentium) with him into exile (48.22.15, Marcian); cf. 48.22.16, Marcian, for a touching case of family loyalty. D 48.22.6pr-1, Ulpian. D 48.22.7.3, Ulpian. D 48.22.4, Marcian; 48.22.7.4, Ulpian; cf. 48.22.1, Pomponius citing Trajan. D 48.22.7.1, Ulpian; cf. ss. 5–16 and 19 on the particularities of relegation. D 48.22.5, Marcian. All Italy south of the Po after the Social War; Caesar extended it to Cisalpine Gaul, all Italy from the Alps southward. Dio Cassius 56.27.2 Dio Cassius 57.22.5; cf. PS 3.4A.9 and 14.
81
PLINY AND REPETUNDAE TRIALS
Trajan relegation being again used merely to exclude the condemned from certain places, and, in the juridical sources, their confinement to a particular province or place.33
The trial of Marius Priscus and his legate The first trial to be considered is that of Marius Priscus, former governor of Africa (a province roughly equivalent to present-day Tunisia and the habitable coastland eastward). He was convicted in January 100, but the first stages were earlier; repetundae trials took time, particularly because of the difficulties of collecting distant evidence.34 On being charged – by only one city, Lepcis, but also by some individual provincials35 – before the consuls with simple extortion, probably towards the end of 98, he pleaded guilty, and applied for a commission under the SC Calvisianum to assess the restitution due. By this time it is clear that the Senate was likely to make a judicial inquiry before appointing the commission, and for this purpose advocates needed to be appointed for the provincials. Tacitus and Pliny, somewhat reluctantly, and only after considerable delays, were assigned by the Senate to act as patroni for the Africans.36 However, the two of them informed the Senate that financial compensation was inadequate for the crimes committed, since Priscus had taken bribes to sentence innocent persons to punishment and even to death.37 To change the grounds of the trial in this way was out of order, strictly speaking, in that a capital charge should have been brought by the victims, or their kin or companions. Further, there has been argument among modern scholars as to whether the charge was under the extortion law, or the lex de sicariis, ne quis iudicio circumveniretur, de vi, or even de maiestate,38 but Pliny himself makes it reasonably clear that it was the Julian law on res repetundae because money had been taken to do the deeds. ‘To show that my accusation was covered by the law dealing with the extortion of money I had to base my argument on the analogy of other laws as well.’39 Catius Fronto, acting for the defence, said that the issue should be limited to compensation – after all, the man had 33 34 35 36 37 38
39
D 48.19.4, Marcian; 48.22.5, Marcian; 48.22.6.8–9, Ulpian. Ep. 2.11, which narrates the case; 6.29.9. Cicero had been allowed 110 days to collect his evidence against Verres (Ps. Asc. p. 125). Ep. 3.9.4. Ep. 10.3A.2. Ep. 2.11.2; cf. Suet. Galba 9.1. Such doings were classed as saevitia, intolerable brutality, too serious to be competent under the Calvisian procedure. Fontenay de Pontette (1954), ch. vii, summarizes views to then; subsequently, Bleicken (1962), 37ff. The case would certainly seem to have fitted within the scope of the lex Iulia de vi publica (D 48.6.7, Ulpian; PS 5.26.1). Ep. 2.19.8; the letter does not explicitly refer to the case against Priscus, but both Sherwin-White (1966) and Radice (1969) hold that it must be that speech which Pliny is proposing to read.
82
PLINY AND REPETUNDAE TRIALS
pleaded guilty to this section of the law. There was vehement discussion, ‘one side arguing that the Senate’s judicial powers were limited by law, the other that they were free and unlimited, and that the defendant should be punished to the full extent of his guilt’.40 It is possible that there had not been a full-scale extortion trial since that of Baebius Massa in 93.41 The Senate was already established as having the power to vary the statutory penalties42 – normally reducing them – but it was still guided by the leges.43 Deviation from the norms of the ordo needed to be argued for.44 Julius Ferox, consul-elect, proposed that the commission should provisionally go ahead, but that those alleged to have given the bribes to procure the conviction of the innocent be summoned as witnesses. The Calvisian procedure was limited to calling ten witnesses already present in Italy, that is, it was intended to comprise the provincial delegation bringing the complaint, but this proposal was for a full inquisitio, gathering all kinds of evidence and able to compel witnesses.45 The two procedures had been designed to be mutually exclusive, but the exercise of cognitio permitted such a compromise. Those alleged to have given bribes were Vitellius Honoratus and Flavius Marcianus, the latter, at least, a decurion of Lepcis, the city bringing the charge,46 and they duly came to Rome.47 Honoratus was charged with having bribed Priscus to exile a Roman eques and to put to death seven of his friends for 300,000 sesterces, and Marcianus with having paid 700,000 for which another eques had been flogged, condemned to the mines, and finally strangled in prison.48 Honoratus died (quite likely by suicide), and so escaped justice. Marcianus appeared before the Senate, but in the absence of Priscus, whose right to be present was in suspense since he had confessed to the lesser form of extortion.49 A senator called Tuccius Cerealis proposed that Priscus should be informed, which must have meant, summoned to attend. It was indeed only natural justice, says Pliny, that a charge made against two persons should be defended by both. However, although based on the same facts, the charges will not have been identical, since the repetundae law properly applied only to those who took money while holding office of some sort, and thus to Priscus, while Marcianus had given, not accepted, money and will therefore have been liable to a charge 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49
Ep. 2.11.3–4. Ep. 7.33. Suet. Dom. 8.2 comments on their rarity under Domitian. See Brunt (1961). Tac. Ann. 3.68. E.g. Ep. 4.9.16–17. It was definitely wrong to flout them: 3.9.29–32. Ep. 2.19.8; 3.9.14; 5.20. Cf. 8.14 to Aristo, on a question of procedure in the Senate. Cf. Tac. Ann. 13.43. Ep. 2.11.23. Ep. 2.11.5–8. Ep. 2.11.8. This was normal, but not invariable; see Tac. Ann. 14.18; Ep. 4.9.19. D 48.11.6.1, Ven. Sat., shows infamy as a general penalty. Ep. 2.11.12 shows that he was present at the actual trial.
83
PLINY AND REPETUNDAE TRIALS
either of falsum,50 or of judicial corruption under the murder law, now extended to cover giving, with malicious intent, false evidence leading to a capital condemnation.51 Anyway, the hearing was adjourned until the next meeting of the Senate.52 The emperor, as consul, presided. Pliny spoke nearly five hours, being allowed four water-clocks to add to his original twelve (there were normally four to the hour, but it was possible to regulate them to run slower, which must have been done here). While the governing statute might regulate the times allowed to the advocates for their principal speeches, there was a general rule in criminal trials, going back at least to the lex Pompeia of 55 BC, that the defence had half as long again as the prosecution, normally nine and six hours respectively.53 Pliny was clearly the chief prosecutor; Claudius Marcellinus replied on behalf of Marcianus. After these speeches the case was adjourned. Next day Salvius Liberalis spoke for Priscus; Tacitus then replied for the prosecution, and Fronto finished for the defence, pleading for mercy; these together took up the second day. The hearing of the evidence, given after the main speeches as with the ordo, was accordingly postponed to the third day; such three-day sessions, adds Pliny, were normal in Senate proceedings.54 Cornutus Tertullus, consul-elect, proposed that Priscus be fined the 700,000 he had accepted – Marcianus was fined in that he had no claim to recover what was given turpi causa55 – and that Priscus should be exiled from Rome and Italy, while Marcianus should be exiled from Rome, Italy and Africa. On behalf of the Senate he finished by thanking Pliny and Tacitus for their efforts, a convention we have seen in the SC de Pisone. Senior senators supported him, until another consular proposed56 that Marcianus be banished for five years, which suggests that the earlier proposed sentence was perpetual, or indefinite, and the same fine for Priscus, but no further penalty other than the consequences of conviction under the Calvisian procedure; this more lenient proposal was eventually, however, heavily defeated.57 50
51 52 53
54 55 56 57
As extended by the SCC Messalianum of AD 20 and Geminianum of AD 29: conspiring to ensnare the innocent (D 48.10.1pr, Marcian; 48.10.9.3, Ulpian; 48.10.20, Hermog. PS 5.25.2 and 13). D 48.8.1.1, Marcian; 48.8.3.4, Marcian. Ep. 2.11.9–10. Ep. 4.9.9; Cicero, Flacc. 33.82; 3 and 2 hours in Dio Cassius 40.52.2; see also Cicero, II Verr. 1.25; Tac. Ann. 3.13.1, when the same proportions were observed in the trial of Piso; Tac. Dial. 38.1–2. This allocation only applied to the principal speeches; the production of evidence and the examination and cross-examination of witnesses went on as long as necessary. Ep. 2.11.14–18. D 12.5.3, Paul. There were rules laid down in Augustus’ lex de senatu habendo about the order of making proposals at the more formal stages of the Senate’s procedure; see Talbert (1984), 240–48. Ep. 2.11.19–22.
84
PLINY AND REPETUNDAE TRIALS
That was the end of the principal trial, but Priscus’ legate, Hostilius Firminus, was also implicated. It was proved from Marcianus’ accounts – these were necessarily open to the prosecution’s inspection – as well as from a speech made by Firminus himself before the Lepcis council (which illustrates that there was no problem with hearsay evidence, although it might have less force), that Firminus had aided Priscus in his extortions, and had also bargained with Marcianus for 200,000 for himself – 10,000 of which was paid under the disgraceful entry of ‘cosmetics’ (unguentarii)! But since Firminus, whether from ignorance or guilt, was not present, his case was referred to the next session (a week or so later) of the Senate.58 This too appears to show the Senate taking to itself powers of jurisdiction where no formal accusation had been made. Admittedly his guilt had been proved, but only obiter. Pliny reports that Firminus appeared before the Senate as manifestly guilty, but that there was disagreement between the consuls-elect as to his sentence, one proposing to expel him from the Senate – in effect an exercise of censorial powers rather than a criminal penalty59 – the other to leave him in the Senate but exclude him from the drawing of lots for provinces, meaning all forms of office, not just governorships. The latter prevailed, and Pliny remarked on the apparent leniency and actual severity of losing the privileges (or gains) of senatorial rank but not its duties; nevertheless, he held it wrong for one so censured to remain among those who censured him and to be able to sit in judgment on others accused of offences of which he had himself been found guilty – but then, that was how a majority had voted.60 It could be argued that the Senate had at least taken some steps of its own accord to control the wrongdoing of its members. There is no mention of Priscus’ other two legates, which one would have expected, as three was the normal number for the proconsular provinces of Africa and Asia.61 In a letter following a request for him to give a private recital of what was almost certainly this speech, Pliny explains that he had argued by analogy that crimes under the law on judicial corruption were also covered by the law dealing with the extortion of money. ‘This cannot have any appeal for the ordinary man, but its interest for the professional should be proportionately greater for the lack of it for the layman. It is certainly my intention, if I agree to this reading, to invite all the legal experts.’62 This seems an interesting example, perhaps typical, of senatorial development of the law. 58 59 60 61 62
Ep. 2.11.23–24. Sometimes used by the emperor; Tac. Ann. 2.48.3; 11.25.5–6. Cf. Ann. 3.69.1, for the trial for extortion of Silanus in AD 22. Ep. 2.12.1–5. Sherwin–White (1966), 171; perhaps they were virtuous, perhaps dead. Ep. 2.19.8.
85
PLINY AND REPETUNDAE TRIALS
The trial of Classicus and his companions The next case, not long after, perhaps late in AD 99 or in 100, concerned the complaint of the whole province of Baetica (southern Spain), represented by the concilium provinciae, against Caecilius Classicus.63 Pliny had represented Baetica in 93 against Baebius Massa;64 he seems to have continued to have patronal ties with the Baeticans, and so agreed after some protests to represent them; he also needed imperial leave to be absent from his post as Prefect of the Treasury. He was the more ready to appear for them because Classicus was now dead; Pliny explicitly states that he was much happier about taking the case because of the impossibility of that most painful feature of a criminal trial, the downfall of a senator.65 This also makes clear that the other accused were not senatorial. Pliny felt that his having undertaken three prosecutions, of Baebius Massa, Marius Priscus, and now Classicus, might relieve him from any further duty of prosecution – still a problematic duty.66 Classicus himself could not be prosecuted for extortion, but he had had accomplices in his misdeeds, and they were still alive to answer charges. Classicus had been governor of Baetica in the same year (AD 97–98) as Priscus was governor of Africa; his rapacity was matched only by his brutality. There was a wry Baetican joke: ‘I got as bad as I gave’, since Classicus’ origins were in Africa and Priscus’ in Baetica.67 He seems to have committed suicide to avoid prosecution.68 There never appears to have been any question of using the Calvisian procedure, but his death may have led to a referral back to the provincial council, sometime between September 99 and 100. Despite his death, the Baetici continued their action. The norm was that, while a dead man could not be subjected to a criminal charge – only in cases of treason were criminal charges ever brought against a dead man in the Principate – in the case of repetundae, where the main issue was that of restitution, and a man’s heirs were liable for any unjustified enrichment of his estate, it was good law to allow proof of the crime, although, says Pliny, the practice had lapsed quite a while ago.69 63 64
65 66 67 68 69
Ep. 3.4, and 3.9; 6.29.8. Ep. 7.33.4–8; 6.29.8. Ep. 7.33 tells us that Massa’s property was sequestered after his conviction. When Massa tried to recover it, Senecio, Pliny’s fellow prosecutor, argued the necessity of its custody until the Baetici were satisfied. Massa claimed that Senecio’s prosecution was malicious and threatened an action for calumny, so Pliny said that since he himself was not so threatened, he must be guilty of collusion – neat. Ep. 3.4.7. Ep. 3.4.8. Compare the discussion of prosecution as a duty in ch. 2, and of delators in ch. 3. Ep. 3.9.2–3. Ep. 3.9.5. Ep. 3.9.6; lex Acilia, tab. Bembina, v.29 (FIRA i 7, p. 84); D 48.2.20, Modestinus; cf. 48.11.2, Scaevola.
86
PLINY AND REPETUNDAE TRIALS
The provincials extended their action to bring charges against his comites, and Casta, his wife, as well as Classicus himself. Such liability was no longer exclusively senatorial; equestrian procurators exercising independent command had become liable, just possibly even as early as the time of Tiberius,70 but the prosecution of equestrian cohortes seems new.71 Each charge needed investigation, so a complex and lengthy case ensued. Pliny was chief advocate for the Baeticans, assisted by Lucceius Albinus. Pliny and Albinus feared that ‘the combined influence of the individuals concerned might procure for each the effect of the whole, and, finally, that the influential might make scapegoats of the humble, and so escape at their expense’. Pliny and Albinus therefore arranged that there should be three separate actiones, each occupying a senatorial session, and therefore spread over some four weeks, because of the separation.72 The first essential was to prove Classicus’ guilt, as being necessary for the conviction of accomplices. This was easy as he had left accounts in his own hand, with receipts for business deals and court cases, plus a letter (a file copy presumably) to his mistress in Rome, boasting that he had sold up the Baetici and made 4 million.73 Baebius Probus and Fabius Hispanus, whose names had been coupled with Classicus’ as defenders in the indictment, were more difficult to convict, says Pliny, since they were men of influence, in Rome as well as the province; clearly they were Roman citizens though not senatorial.74 Their defence was superior orders, and Pliny had to prove – successfully in the event – that carrying out wrongful orders was criminal, even by provincials in awe of a governor. This case, he says, set a precedent75 – but is this because the subordinates were equites, not senators, or because this case actually established acting under orders as an insufficient defence? The Senate decreed that all the property which Classicus had owned before his appointment to Baetica was to be set aside, and given to his daughter – there were presumably no other children – while the fruits of his office were – without multiple damages – to be returned to the provincials, even recalling what he had recently paid to his creditors. His creditors must have been seen as beneficiaries of unjustified enrichment, but the process presumably involved in integrum restitutio, so they would be able 70
71 72 73 74 75
Tac. Ann. 4.15 on the conviction in the Senate of a procurator of Asia in AD 24, but he was properly Tiberius’ personal agent and had exceeded his powers; Ann. 13.30 records a prefect of the fleet committing suicide to avoid conviction in 56. Pontius Pilate was sent back to Rome by Vitellius, then governor of Syria, to account to the emperor for his misdeeds, but we do not know if he would have faced formal criminal charges – Josephus AJ 18.88–89. Here; also D 48.11.1pr, Marcian. Ep. 3.9.7–11. Ep. 3.9.13. Four million sesterces was only a tenth of what Verres had extracted from Sicily, but it was still a serious sum. Ep. 3.4.7. They are not otherwise known, except from this case. Ep. 6.29.
87
PLINY AND REPETUNDAE TRIALS
to claim against the estate. Probus and Hispanus were both relegated for five years; this was a fairly serious penalty, particularly as they, and their advocate, had not expected the defence of superior orders to fail.76 Then, a few days later, Claudius Fuscus, Classicus’ son-in-law, and Stilonius Priscus, who had been tribune of a cohort77 under Classicus, were charged; Priscus was relegated from Italy for two years, and Fuscus acquitted.78 There was then an unexpected turn to the proceedings.79 One of the witnesses, presumably from Baetica,80 brought a charge of collusion (praevaricatio) concerning Casta, Classicus’ wife, against Norbanus Licinianus,81 one of the official representatives of Baetica (and clearly someone with influence in Rome) and indeed one of those who had been commissioned to collect evidence.82 While the law laid down that allegations of procedural offences should be heard after the principal crimes had been tried,83 in this case Norbanus’ past history of profitable support for Domitian counted against him; he had been made a commissioner not for his honesty but for his animus against Classicus, by whom indeed he had been relegated after Domitian’s death.84 Perhaps too, the suspicion of collusion had already arisen out of the trial of Classicus’ misdoings, although it was then specifically alleged of Casta’s trial. Norbanus, reasonably, asked for a day to be appointed for his trial, and for specification of the charges, but these were refused him – a serious example of injustice on merely political grounds.85 He was obliged to defend himself on the spot, and against other charges as well as collusion. This put Pliny and Albinus into an awkward position. It was from Norbanus that they, as advocates and patroni, had received their 76 77
78 79 80
81
82
83 84
85
Ep. 3.9.12–17. Which sort of cohort is not specified. Sherwin-White (1966), 234, thinks it refers to another urban cohort, such as those sometimes stationed at Lyons or Carthage (and there were others, judging from their numbering), but the tribunes of these were usually promoted centurions, not likely comites. Ep. 3.9.18. Ep. 3.9.29–32. A hostile witness, says Pliny, hostile whether because annoyed at being compelled to appear (which would imply a prosecution witness), or perhaps because he had been suborned by another defendant to muddy the waters. Technically, as Sherwin-White (1966), 236, pointed out, such a charge only lay against the formal accusers, Pliny and Albinus (SC Calvisianum 98–103). However, the provincials were clearly moving nearer to being able to bring their own prosecutions for themselves, and this could have been a deliberate extension of liability. This had formerly been the duty of the leading prosecutor, but Tac. Ann. 13.43 suggests that it had come to be viewed as a nuisance; its transfer to the provincial delegation may have been unauthorised but seen as acceptable. Lex Acilia v.75 (FIRA i 7, p. 84); D 48.16.1.3 and 6, Marcian. This surely might have made him liable to an accusation of calumny, for bringing a malicious prosecution, but as with iniuria, truth might have been an adequate defence in the circumstances. See Paul, fr.inst. 2 (FIRA ii p. 421); cf. Tac. Hist. 2.10.
88
PLINY AND REPETUNDAE TRIALS
instructions on behalf of the province; if he was guilty of collusion, they needed fresh instructions, so they remained seated throughout his trial.86 Surprise witnesses against him emerged from the Senate, when two consulars brought evidence of his calumniously joining (as subscriptor presumably) in the prosecution of Salvius Liberalis under Domitian. A charge of calumny could be heard together with one of collusion since they both fell under the same senatusconsult, the SC Turpillianum. He was found guilty, and relegated to an island, but was able to attend the remainder of the trial.87 Calumny and other procedural crimes There were risks inevitably inherent in a system of popular accusation, accusation by any adult male citizen, with no requirement that he should have an interest (other than in the reward for a successful prosecution). To counter or mitigate these risks the Romans developed a group of procedural offences: calumny, collusion, and the desertion of an accusation formally laid. They were not free-standing crimes, but abuses of procedure before the ordinary criminal courts; originally they only applied to accusations before the quaestiones perpetuae. Calumny (calumnia) was the bringing of false charges, from malice, or frivolity, or at least with reckless disregard for the truth. Collusion (praevaricatio) was the concealment of genuine charges, in particular by the bringing of false evidence which could readily be disproved. The abandonment of an accusation (tergiversatio) perhaps seems oddly treated as criminal, but – in the absence of a state prosecution service – it might well occur because the accuser had been bribed to drop the case, or intimidated; and then, as now, the court’s time would have been wasted. There was therefore a mechanism, known as abolitio, by which a prosecutor could apply to the court before which he had brought his accusation to have it annulled; if he did not do this he might be presumed guilty of tergiversatio or calumny.88 Calumny had originally been governed by the lex Remnia, perhaps of 91 BC, certainly before 80 BC (since Cicero referred to it in pro Roscio Amerino); its penalty had presumably been infamy, depriving the guilty man of the right to accuse or to act for others, or to become a decurion.89 The branding 86 87
88 89
Ep. 3.9.35. Ep. 3.9.33–35: ‘apud iudicem sub Domitiano Salvi Liberalis accusatoribus adfuisset’: the phrase makes it sound as though the accusation was before one of the quaestiones perpetuae. Senators seem normally to have been tried by their peers, in the Senate, by the middle of the first century, but perhaps a non-political charge, such as adultery with a woman of no importance, would have been competent in the ordinary courts. The appointment of a special judge by the emperor remains a possibility; cf. Ep. 7.6.8 and 10. Robinson (1999) and (2006). Camin˜as (1984a).
89
PLINY AND REPETUNDAE TRIALS
or tattooing of the culprit with a K, threatened by Cicero,90 is not physically evidenced at that period, so one must assume it was metaphorical, entering a K beside the name on the praetor’s album. (Actual branding or tattooing was a penalty at this stage only imposed upon fugitive slaves.91) Claudius, in a speech to the Senate between 42 and 51, tried more generally to regulate accusations,92 but in the event the SC Turpillianum of AD 61 absorbed the statute, and it became the basic source dealing with all three procedural offences: calumny, collusion, tergiversation, and also perjury.93 It did not deal with the question of advocates’ fees. It covered not only the accuser himself, but also one who employed a man of straw to make the accusation;94 certain persons, on the other hand, could make an accusation without fear of calumny, such as a parent pursuing the death of a child,95 or a man making an accusation of adultery by right of being the husband.96 Suitable penalties under the SC Turpillianum might be a fine of 5 pounds of gold,97 a ban on bringing any prosecution (except one where his own interests had been harmed),98 a ban on acting as an advocate for a number of years,99 degradation, i.e. removal from the Senate or the local council,100 or even relegation.101 As we shall see, the concept of calumny changed somewhat in the Later Empire; the courts were much more likely to see any failed accusation as calumnious, and the penalty was often that which would have been imposed on the accused if convicted.102 Further subsidiary trials Thereafter, at the planned third session, several persons – mostly of lesser importance – were charged, including Classicus’ wife, Casta, who was under strong suspicion; however, Pliny had been doubtful if there was enough evidence to convict. Senatorial wives had been liable to charges under the 90
Cic. Rosc. Am., 19.55; 20.57; tab. Hera. v.120 (FIRA i, p. 149); cf. D 22.5.13, Papinian. Jones (1987). 92 FIRA i 44, p. 285. 93 See Robinson (1995), 99–103; Camin˜as (1984a), 113–22; Centola (1999); Puliatti (2002); cf. Robinson (1999). 94 D 48.16.1.13, Marcian; cf. 48.16.15pr, Macer. 95 D 48.1.14, Papinian. 96 D 4.4.37.1, Tryph. 97 D 47.15.3.3, Macer, who says this penalty was laid down in the SC; this fine will have been translated by the compilers into the currency of the Later Empire. In civil procedure the counter-action claiming calumny made the wrongful pursuer liable to the defender for one tenth of the sum at issue (G 4.174–75). 98 D 47.15.5, Ven. Sat.; 48.2.4, Ulpian. 99 Ep. 5.13.5. 100 D 50.2.6.3, Papinian; PS 5.4.11. 101 Tac. Ann. 14.41; PS 5.4.11. 102 D 47.15.6, Paul, citing a rescript of Severus and Caracalla; CJ 9.2.17pr, Honorius and Theodosius. 91
90
PLINY AND REPETUNDAE TRIALS
repetundae law since Tiberius’ reign, as we have seen. Pliny must have felt more hopeful after the conviction of Norbanus for collusion, and in his speech he laid particular emphasis on this damning fact. To his surprise, she was acquitted, even though her accuser had been convicted of collusion with her – a result without precedent.103 Classicus’ daughter, Classica, was also among those charged, but her complete innocence emerged; this seems the only such reference to a daughter being caught up in her father’s crimes, although it was common enough to charge sons. (The Senate had already granted her the property owned by Classicus before his appointment to govern Baetica.) Pliny therefore refrained from pressing the accusation against her, after having checked that the provincials had no substantial case; he consulted the Senate on its views, and thus ran no risk of himself being held liable for tergiversatio. He was confident that her acquittal at the end of the proceedings would not weaken his overall case.104 Of the others, some were acquitted, but the majority were convicted and relegated, either for a fixed term or for life. The Senate again gave hearty thanks to Pliny and Albinus. ‘You can imagine how tired we were after so much continuous speaking, debating, and cross-examining of all the witnesses, and supporting or refuting their replies’, and also evading their friends’ confidential enquiries and open attacks.105 The final chapter in the story was the personal appearance of Salvius Liberalis. He was presumably present simply as a member of the Senate but, spurred on by his grievance against Norbanus, he fiercely attacked the remaining Baetican delegates for not having brought to trial all the persons about whom their province had given them instructions; this will have included Classica. It is not clear whether or not this was a formal accusation – which illustrates the sometimes excessive element of discretion in trials before the Senate. Pliny defended the Baeticans successfully, presumably against a charge of tergiversatio.106
The trial of Julius Bassus The third major trial is that of Julius Bassus, early in AD 103; this time Pliny was for the defence.107 It is not clear for what offence Bassus had been 103
104 105 106 107
Ep. 3.9.34. We know, however, that in adultery cases, it was possible for the accused paramour to be convicted and the woman to be acquitted – D 48.5.18(17).6, Ulpian: ‘therefore the woman will await the passing of sentence on the paramour; if he is acquitted, the woman will win her case through him; if he is condemned, the woman is not thereby condemned, but may defend herself so that she may perhaps be successful, whether by favour or by justice or by the terms of the statute.’ Ep. 3.9.19–21. Ep. 3.9.22–25. Ep. 3.9.36. Ep. 4.9; cf. 6.29.
91
PLINY AND REPETUNDAE TRIALS
tried, and acquitted, in Vespasian’s day, but the fact that he was charged by privati and the case referred to the Senate suggests another charge of extortion. Friendly with, but banished by, Domitian, he was recalled by Nerva – which makes it fairly certain that it was for a political not a vulgarly criminal matter. He became governor of Bithynia (in north-western Asia Minor), perhaps in 100, and was now accused of extortion.108 There is no reference to an inquisitio, or to the presence of witnesses, so presumably any charges of saevitia had been dropped, which would of course be with the permission of the court (or more specifically of the consuls as presidents). The procedure therefore is close to that laid down in the SC Calvisianum. Pliny for the defence had been instructed by his client to say, first, what a distinguished man he, Bassus, was, then to deal with the informers who were plotting to profit (praemia delatorum) in the Bithynian courts, and finally to speak of the reasons for Bassus’ unpopularity with the bad types, the ones stirring up riots.109 But the nub of the accusation, since the charges that sounded more serious had been dropped, was that he had accepted certain gifts from the provincials, thoughtlessly, as their friend, for he had been quaestor there earlier – it depended on your perspective whether this should be described as thieving and plundering, or accepting tokens of friendship.110 But even presents from friends were forbidden by the statute.111 Pliny’s task of defence was tricky. It was impossible to deny a palpable fact, for Bassus had told many people, including the emperor, that he had accepted gifts, but only small ones, and on occasions such as his birthday and during Saturnalia, and that he had usually given something in return. The law was strict, but many senators now had a provincial background, and yet were not forbidden to serve in their home province; this must have made an increasing absurdity of the literal interpretation. Ulpian quoted Severus and Caracalla as having laid down that officials should not be so unmannerly as to refuse all presents, but should be careful to avoid appearing greedy;112 that, however, was nearly a century in the future. For Pliny, to plead for mercy would be to blacken his client by admitting guilt; to attempt to justify his conduct would not help him in the face of the statute, and would expose Pliny to a charge of disrespect for the law. What was Pliny to do? To take a middle course, but how? In the event he seems simply to have made a plea in mitigation. Pomponius Rufus, as senatorial patron, opened for the prosecution, and was followed by Theophanes, representative of the province and indeed the instigator of the prosecution; this seemingly is the first appearance of a 108 109 110 111 112
Ep. 4.9.1–2. Cf. Dio Chrys. or. 43.6–7. Ep. 4.9.4–6. Lex Acilia v.2 (FIRA i 7, p. 84); D 48.11.7.1, Macer, and 48.11.1.1, Marcian. D 1.16.6.3, Ulpian.
92
PLINY AND REPETUNDAE TRIALS
provincial with right of audience before the Senate.113 As with the defence, two speakers were sharing the time allotted for the opening speeches. On the first day Pliny spoke for three and a half hours (for the prosecution was allowed six hours, and the defence nine114) with one and a half to come on the following day, when his fellow advocate would have four hours. Pliny wondered whether to rest his case that evening, but Bassus pleaded with him to finish his speech. Lucceius Albinus then followed, also for the defence.115 Herennius Pollio, apparently the Baeticans’ other patronus, made a forceful and well-reasoned reply – against Bassus – and then Theophanes spoke again, and went on until after dark, when lamps were brought in. On the third day Homullus and Fronto spoke in defence of Bassus; since the principal statement of the defence case had already been made by Pliny and Albinus, what these dealt with is obscure. Perhaps they were commendations of his character. The fourth day was spent on the examination of the probationes – documents and witnesses.116 The defence was clearly unsuccessful in the face of the evidence and Bassus’ own admissions, for Pliny next tells us that Baebius Macer, consulelect, proposed that Bassus was guilty under the lex repetundarum, and should be subject to the penalty of the statute, while Caepio Hispo proposed that he should make reparation as laid down by a commission, but suffer no loss of status. Both proposals were good in law, even though they differed. Macer held to the letter of the law, albeit the Senate not the quaestio was hearing the case, but Caepio took the view that the Senate, when exercising cognitio, had the power (as indeed it has, Pliny adds) to reduce, or increase, the penalty laid down by law; thus mercy could be shown for an act prohibited indeed but not unprecedented.117 This would seem to undo the whole force of the extortion law! Caepio’s proposal was carried comfortably, but Pliny remarks, as he had in the case of Priscus, that some held it wrong for a man who had a penalty assessed against him to retain his seat in the Senate.118 In fact, despite the lack of formal infamy, all Bassus’ acts in Bithynia were rescinded, as we learn from Pliny when he was governor of that province, and anyone affected by any judgment of Bassus was given two years to appeal.119 But Pliny must have decided to avoid mentioning this resolution of the Senate as insufficiently flattering to his powers of advocacy, and not fitting well with the welcome given Bassus by 113 114 115 116 117 118 119
Ep. 4.9.3. Senate procedure was developing all the time. As in Priscus’ trial, supra. Ep. 4.9. 9–13. Ep. 4.9.14–15. Ep. 4.9.16–17. Cf. Ep. 2.11.4; see also Robinson (1996); Bleicken (1962), 37ff. The Senate’s exercise of cognitio remained in touch with the framework of the ordo. Ep. 4.9.18–19. Pliny had been much more forceful on this issue in Priscus’ case (2.12.4), but then he had been prosecuting. Ep. 10.56.4.
93
PLINY AND REPETUNDAE TRIALS
so many after the hearing.120 Elsewhere he says that he defended Bassus as having acted much too imprudently and foolishly but without any criminal intent, and thus Bassus retained his place in the Senate.121 A senator named Valerius Paulinus had agreed with Caepio, but he also proposed that Theophanes should be investigated by the Senate, after he had given an account of the investigative commission’s work, on the grounds that in the course of his accusation he had committed various offences which also fell under res repetundae. This was probably taking money from other Bithynians to accuse;122 it may well also be a reference back to the Bithynian delators who were conspiring for rewards. The consuls, however, despite the general feeling of the Senate, rejected what was in effect an application to prosecute, but Pliny thought it reflected credit on Paulinus.123
The trial of Varenus Rufus The fourth extortion trial in which Pliny took part was that of Varenus Rufus, in AD 106 or 107.124 The Bithynians were here accusing the same man who had been set to prosecute Bassus on their behalf; he had withdrawn from the case, for reasons unstated, which is why Pliny did not mention him in his account of that trial. The provincials were summoned before the Senate, presumably for formal nominis delatio, and to receive senatorial advocates to put forward their charges; they applied for time to collect evidence, thus making it clear that they accused Varenus of saevitia.125 Then Varenus requested that he too should have the right to call witnesses from the province. This action by the accused was without precedent, and the Bithynians objected; the preliminary stages of the case, concerning the inquisitio, were heard at once. Pliny appeared for Varenus126 as he had for Bassus, but says nothing of his own speech. The leading Bithynian prosecutor was the voluble Fonteius Magnus;127 it is noteworthy that the precedent set by Theophanes, of a provincial commissioner having rights of audience before the Senate, seems to have become accepted, just as the provincials’ power to organize the inquisitio had been accepted earlier. Homullus, the other advocate for the defence, replied on behalf of Varenus on the following day; Pliny’s lack of remark on this proves that continuation 120 121 122 123 124 125 126 127
Ep. 4.9.22. Ep. 6.29.10. D 48.11.6.2, Ven. Sat. Ep. 4.9.20–22. Ep. 5.20 describes the preliminary stages, while 6.5, 6.13, 7.6, and 7.10 deal with further procedural manoeuvrings. We never hear of an actual trial. Ep. 5.20.1. Ep. 5.20.2. Ep. 5.20.4–5.
94
PLINY AND REPETUNDAE TRIALS
was commoner than in AD 100. Then Nigrinus, as patron of the Bithynians, made an effective speech for the prosecution in reply. This was a preliminary action, not the trial proper, so the normal time ratio and the order of the speeches could be varied without comment. The consul-elect, Acilius Rufus, proposed that the Bithynians should be allowed to collect their evidence, that is, he allowed the graver form of trial for extortion, but passed over Varenus’ similar plea. The consular Cornelius Priscus proposed that both parties should be granted their requests, and this was carried. ‘So we won our point, not one mentioned in the law or covered by precedent, but none the less equitable.’128 However, a couple of weeks later, at the next meeting of the Senate, Licinius Nepos129 held that the innovation was unjustified; he proposed that the consuls should be asked to consider the law on extortion in the light of that on electoral corruption, and settle whether in future the same powers should be given to the defence as the prosecution in preparing their case. There followed an altercation between him and the jurist Celsus, probably the younger of that name.130 If this right had indeed already been granted in cases of electoral corruption, it would not have been such a novelty, and it is not particularly surprising that the Senate should have accepted it in Varenus’ case. Perhaps as a result of that debate, Pliny next tells us that the Bithynians had dared to approach the consuls to try to have the Senate’s grant of permission to Varenus overturned; they had even petitioned the emperor, who was not in Rome, but he referred them back to the Senate. The Senate, apart from Acilius Rufus and seven others, held that a majority decision had been passed and was binding.131 The next that we hear is the extraordinary fact that the Bithynians were reported to have dropped their case against Varenus.132 Pliny is slightly cautious about this, but an emissary of the province had brought the provincial council’s decree to the emperor, to various leading figures, and to Varenus’ advocates, Pliny and Homullus.133 The council may have been able to reverse its decision because of the absence in Rome of Varenus’ chief enemies. Nevertheless, a certain Magnus, from the first embassy, was harassing Nigrinus, the advocate appointed by the Senate for the Bithynians, to 128
129 130 131 132 133
Ep. 5.20.6–7; see also 6.29.11. Sherwin-White (1966) points out, p. 354, that Quintilian, inst. or. 5.7.9, states explicitly that while both sides could call witnesses, only the prosecution had the power to compel their appearance. He may well, however, have been describing the ordinary procedure before the quaestiones perpetuae; also he was writing ten years or more earlier. Senatorial procedure was changing. He is the man who is possibly to be identified as praetor of a quaestio perpetua in Ep. 4.29 and 5.9.3–5. Ep. 6.5; on the identity of Celsus, Sherwin-White (1966), 360–61. Ep. 6.13; cf. 2.12.5. Ep. 7.6. Ep. 7.6.1.
95
PLINY AND REPETUNDAE TRIALS
get Varenus forced to produce his accounts.134 Nigrinus made the request to the consuls, who asked Pliny what he had to say; he simply suggested that the true representatives of the province be heard. Then Polyaenus, the Bithynian emissary, explained to the Senate their reasons for dropping the prosecution, and asked that no sort of decision be taken before the emperor had held an inquiry into possible tergiversatio. Pliny largely refrained from speaking, and certainly from making any form of speech, since it was important to stress that Varenus was not on trial.135 The consuls granted Polyaenus’ request.136 The emperor, having heard the opposing arguments of Fonteius Magnus and Polyaenus, declared that he would undertake to discover the true wishes of the province.137 The silence of Pliny, or indeed any other source, strongly suggests that the Bithynians were allowed to withdraw their accusations. It is likely that the Bithynians were trying to fight their own internal battles before the Roman Senate, using the repetundae laws as a pretext. The episode suggests that the Senate as a court normally acted autonomously, without imperial intervention, although the emperor was available for breaking an impasse. A trial before the emperor We do hear from Pliny of one other case of misbehaviour in the provinces, in 106 or 107, but this was not a trial before the Senate but before the emperor. Lustricius Bruttianus, a proconsul (but we do not know his province), had detected his comes, Montanius Atticinus, in a number of criminal acts (in multis flagitiis), and had reported these to the emperor; Atticinus then added to his offences by raising a counter-action – seemingly some form of extortion charge, since it reflected on Bruttianus’ integrity – against Bruttianus. Pliny was on the imperial consilium, acting as judicial assessor.138 The procedure was summary – carptim; each party acted for himself,139 dealing with the main items one by one.140 Bruttianus produced his will, written in Atticinus’ hand,141 as proof of his former trust and of the necessity of his present accusations, all clearly proven. The force of Atticinus’ 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 141
Ep. 7.6.2. This had long been normal in such prosecutions: II Verr. 1.36 shows Cicero’s access to Verres’ accounts, and see Ep. 2.11.23 in relation to Priscus’ case. Ep. 7.6.3–7 Ep. 7.6.14. Ep. 7.10. Ep. 6.22; cf. 6.31.1–12. Pliny also sat as assessor for the Prefect of the City (Ep. 6.11.1). Although on another occasion we are told that advocates could and did appear before the emperor (Ep. 6.31.11). Ep. 6.22.1–2. Nero had tried to speed up the administration of justice by replacing continuous pleadings with each party in turn presenting single points (Suet. Nero 15.1). On the curious Roman habit of getting other people, friends or family, to write out one’s will, see Robinson (1992a).
96
PLINY AND REPETUNDAE TRIALS
counter-charges was destroyed when it was revealed that he had bribed a slave belonging to Bruttianus’ scriba, intercepted certain papers and falsified some of them,142 and, worst of all, had diverted against Bruttianus a criminal charge laid against himself.143 Somewhat oddly, it is possible that altering official documents did not fall under the basic law on forgery, the lex Cornelia de falsis, until Severus,144 but it was also classified as treason in chapter 1 of the lex Iulia maiestatis.145 The emperor asked his consilium for a verdict on Atticinus, who was found guilty and relegated to an island.146 The charge against Bruttianus may be presumed dismissed. This case differed from the other extortion trials, because it was between two Romans, perhaps both senators, and not at the instance of a province. This is probably why it was heard before the emperor rather than the Senate, which had normally inherited the jurisdiction of the quaestio perpetua de rebus repetundis.147 This series of trials, described straightforwardly by Pliny, is less informative than one might have hoped on Roman attitudes. For one thing, the only attitudes we really learn of are those of Pliny’s fellow-senators. It does seem that overall the Senate was concerned with the good name of Roman government, and that, whether for moral or political reasons, there was no automatic attempt to cover up alleged abuses of Roman power in the provinces. On the other hand, it is highly unlikely that Pliny’s sentiment of distress at the downfall of a senator was not widely shared. Lesser charges were perhaps more likely to gain a hearing than serious ones, as a general rule. But Pliny and Tacitus had insisted that Priscus’ conduct had been beyond what could be met with mere restitution, that punishment was due. It seems that rough – by which I mean approximate – justice was probably achieved, even against some of the most powerful men in the Empire. But it was also a time when the power and influence of provincial families was growing; Italian families, let alone truly Roman ones, were steadily dwindling in the Senate. It was not merely the governors Bassus and Classicus who came from the provinces; so did the Emperor Trajan. The odds for the injured provincials must have been much more favourable than in the Late Republic.
142 143 144 145 146 147
interciderat (cf. D 11.3.1.5, Ulpian; 48.10.9.3, Ulpian). Ep. 6.22.3–4; it is likely that this charge was of extortion. D 48.10.1.4, Marcian; cf. 48.10.16pr and 2, Paul. D 48.4.2, Ulpian. Ep. 6.22.5. Cf. Ep. 7.6.8–10, dealt with in the section on the decline of the quaestiones perpetuae in ch. 3. In the case referred to there, the later development, with the woman claiming fresh evidence, was before Suburanus, who became Trajan’s first Praetorian Prefect. If it in fact occurred while he held that office, it is the second evidence – after Seneca’s reference to Burrus (clem. 2.1.2) – for the Praetorian Prefect exercising jurisdiction.
97
PLINY AND REPETUNDAE TRIALS
The Senate and the ordo The other aspect which is striking is the usual desire of the Senate to conform to the spirit of the law, the statute, even when not bound by the letter of it. Correct procedure, largely drawn from the ordo iudiciorum of the standing jury-courts, was important, although the Senate was clearly developing its own particular rules. Probably the power to vary the penalty was the most significant of these. At the trial in AD 22 of Gaius Junius Silanus for extortion with brutality when proconsul of Asia (the province of proconsular Asia comprised the greater part of western Asia Minor), it was the presence of Tiberius which most affected the sentence.148 In Trajan’s time, however, the Senate was able to debate freely its own powers to pass sentence; we have seen this in the trials of both Classicus and Bassus.149 Other changes we have noted were the acceptance of provincials as having right of audience, and the right of the defence to compel witnesses.150 In the interests of good government and of the orderly development of the law, justice was imperative, and this included the rules of natural justice. All the members of the Senate will have had some schooling in philosophy, and among the senators were the major jurists. I do not wish to go so far as seeing a golden age here, but this period was probably the nearest approximation to it – as long as one remembers the unfortunate eques who was flogged, condemned to the mines, and then strangled in prison.
148 149 150
Tac. Ann. 3.68. Pliny, Ep. 3.9.29–32; 4.9.16–17. Ep. 4.9.3, on Theophanes, in the trial of Bassus; 5.20, in the trial of Varenus.
98
Chapter 5 ACTA MARTYRUM CHRISTIANORUM: T H E E X T E N S I O N O F T O RT U R E
This chapter does not look at persecution as a topic, although it explains the legal grounds for persecution, but at the legal practice in the various trials (and related happenings) of those punished for Christianity. The first such trials were in the second century, when Christianity was not a ‘crime’ but conduct on occasion deserving repression. In the mid-third century, under Decius, Christianity was still not of itself a crime, but Christians were bound to be seen as criminals because it was ordered that everyone must worship the gods of Rome; Christians were not specified, but it was well known that they would refuse. Then, a few years later under Valerian, and again in the early fourth century, Christianity was criminalized. This chapter, like the first, deals as much with political as juridical issues1 since, for various reasons, the Roman government decided to prosecute Christians for their beliefs, rather than their actions.2 The other trials described in this book concern sedition, murder, treason, extortion from provincials, magic practices, things that have generally been reckoned assaults on society, although the control of worship was also an important issue in the case of the Bacchanalians. I think one can take it that no Christian was convicted of cannibalism3 or incest or other flagitia, and these charges do not actually occur in the records of the persecutions. So Christianity was in one sense a non-offence, as Tertullian said,4 although there are some links with astrology and magic. Yet for long it was an offence in the eyes of the people at large; educated people like Tacitus and Suetonius saw Christians as enemies of the human race.5 1
2 3
4 5
Fogliani (1928), 66. Edward Gibbon’s survey, The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire, (1776, repr.) vol. I, ch. xvi, ‘The conduct of the Roman government towards the Christians, from the reign of Nero to that of Constantine’, still has much to commend it. Despite D 48.19.18, Ulpian: ‘No one is punished for thinking’. Not seemingly an offence in Roman law, where one hears nothing of it, very unlike the Bible. It was misunderstanding of the eucharist that led to this charge, just as accusations of incest were a misunderstanding of the Christian call to brotherly love. Tert. apol. 2.10: ‘Others you torture to make them confess, us to make us deny’. Tac. Ann. 15.44; Suet. Nero 16.2.
99
A C TA M A R T Y R U M C H R I S T I A N O R U M
The sources For the first, and only, time we shall be looking at the administration of justice from a point of view other than that of the governing classes, which is one reason why we must not think of these accounts in the Acta Martyrum Christianorum as law reports (even if one could perhaps call them case-studies). ‘These Acts are not, though they may seem to be, authentic verbal records of the trials of martyrs. But they are ancient literary evocations of those trials.’6 A second reason for caution is that these stories of Christian martyrs were preserved to honour their memories; they are gesta, not court acta, and their purpose was hagiographic, not legal. There were hundreds of Acta Martyrum composed in the fourth and fifth centuries, once Christianity had become first tolerated and then the official religion of the Roman state, in honour of those whose anniversaries were celebrated; almost every see had its own martyrology. Death, in imitation of Christ, was the supreme sign of Christian faith.7 These late Acta, whatever the date of the martyrdom they recount, are of no value at all for weighing the criminal law of the pagan Empire. However, there are some early ones which seem contemporary with the events they describe, even if they may have been embellished later, perhaps with the addition of dreams or visions. But they too were written to exalt those who suffered death for their faith, and that faith itself; this is frequently highlighted by language stressing the cruelty of the mob and of the authorities. The details that are of interest to us in discerning the criminal procedure of the period and the attitudes of the government are incidental to their purpose. There are several modern collections of those Acta which can be reckoned as contemporary, or nearly so, with the events they describe, among which I have followed Musurillo, and also Lanata, and Bastiaensen.8 The problem is that there are few external checks, and no pagan versions of these trials;9 internal consistency and external plausibility do not prove them accurate, even if we must rely on them. Arrest and execution, and perhaps the giving of sentence, would be things witnessed by the martyrs’ companions, but the interrogations are often described as being behind closed doors, in a secretarium. 6
7
8
9
Millar (1993b), 35. Cf. Bisbee (1988), who holds in his Introduction that useful distinctions can be drawn between ‘acta’ based on court records and ‘passiones’ based upon witnesses to the deaths of the martyrs. Confessors, technically, are Christians who bear witness publicly to their faith in circumstances of difficulty and danger, but who do not suffer death for this witness; they were much less important in the fourth-century Christian view. Musurillo (1972); Lanata (1973); Bastiaensen (1987). On problems of authenticity, see Barnes (1968b); Bastiaensen, xxviii–xxx; Musurillo, Introduction; also Bisbee (1988), 81– 87. Apart, in a sense, from Pliny’s correspondence with Trajan on the treatment of Christians in his province of Bithynia, around AD 110 (Ep. 10.96–97).
100
A C TA M A R T Y R U M C H R I S T I A N O R U M
A useful source, apart from the Acta, is the collection of letters from, and to, St Cyprian, bishop of Carthage from at least 249 until his death in 258; the authenticity of almost all of these is unchallenged. Cyprian was an eyewitness, and then a victim, of the persecutions of the mid-third century. His letters are largely official episcopal letters, directed to those within the Church, to his clergy, and to the clergy of other sees, particularly Rome; they were not designed for publication as a collection, but to answer the needs of the moment. They speak warmly of both confessors and martyrs, but are more concerned with the treatment of the lapsed, those whose courage had failed them. Another source, the historian Eusebius, bishop of Caesarea, was an eye-witness to the ‘great’ persecution of Diocletian and Galerius in the Eastern Empire in the early fourth century, but his knowledge of events in the West was not good.10 His Ecclesiastical History has a general purpose different from that of the Acta, the justification of the Christian faith from its beginnings until his own time. It was written by someone familiar with the standards expected (in his day) of a historian; where there is an overlapping account, confirmation from this source gives added weight, even if not certainty. Yet another source, Lactantius, a Christian and author of a work de mortibus persecutorum,11 held the post of professor of (Latin) rhetoric at Nicomedia, Diocletian’s eastern capital, until presumably dismissed under Diocletian’s first edict against Christians; he survived the persecution and died around 320. He was closely involved with court circles. All in all, the sources for this chapter probably have no more bias than does Cicero; in other words, they give much useful information but are not to be swallowed uncritically.
The background: astrologers and philosophers Let us move from our sources to the background. Until the middle of the third century, while the Christians saw Roman authority as hostile, as focused on suppressing them, this was their perception rather than reality.12 From the Roman point of view there were merely times when awkward people, such as astrologers, Jews or Christians, needed to be temporarily
10
11 12
Eusebius (c. AD 260–339) was imprisoned briefly in 309 during the Diocletianic persecution; he became bishop of Caesarea around 313; he attended – perhaps as theological adviser to Constantine – the Council of Nicaea in 325. He made a collection of the lives of the early martyrs, which has not survived, as well as writing a book on the Martyrs of Palestine; his Ecclesiastical History was probably begun – it was subject to various revisions – during or even before the Great Persecution, but it dealt with the big picture, not just persecution. The Deaths of the Persecutors, here abbreviated MP. As I have argued elsewhere: Robinson (1990–92); Robinson (1995) is only a slightly different version.
101
A C TA M A R T Y R U M C H R I S T I A N O R U M
repressed. For example, rhetoricians, philosophers and astrologers formed a loosely linked group: rhetoricians were originally Greek, as were philosophers; Stoic philosophers saw their fate not in themselves but in their stars. As early as 161 BC, rhetoricians and philosophers were banned from Rome by a senatusconsultum, proposed and enforced by the Praetor.13 In 139 BC the peregrine praetor banished astrologers from the City for exciting shallow minds for their own profit.14 In 92 BC the censors passed an edict against rhetoricians since their teachings were contrary to Roman ancestral custom.15 Under Tiberius, around AD 17, a senatusconsultum was passed expelling astrologers from Italy, and some were executed.16 Philosophers were in trouble under Nero,17 and banished again from Rome and Italy by senatusconsult under Domitian.18 Serious penalties were thus imposed, and yet astrologers and rhetoricians had a significant place in the intellectual life of Rome; the aim was to cut them down to size, not to abolish them. We have seen the same approach to foreign cults. Interestingly, our one legal source, specifically dealing with Tiberius’ action, shows that there could be argument as to whether it was the skills of such men or only their public exercise which were to be punished; at the time, the jurists had held that it was only the exercise which was punishable, although this was different by the time the Collatio was compiled, and perhaps already in Ulpian’s time. Knowledge sometimes merged into practice; this was the result of such men’s obstinacy and rashness – per contumaciam et temeritatem.19 A literary source confirms a clear parallel with Christians: those astrologers who recanted, who asked pardon and undertook to make no further predictions, were not punished.20
The different stages of the criminal law concerning Christianity Christians fell into this category of potential subversives, but for a couple of centuries Christianity was not a specific crime. In the pre-Decian period
13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20
Suet. de rhet. i; Gellius NA 15.11.1. Val. Max. 1.3.3. ‘praeter consuetudinem ac morem maiorum fiunt’; Suet. de rhet. i; Gellius NA 15.11.2. Tac. Ann. 2.32; Suet. Tib. 36 and 63; Gellius NA 14.1; Dio 57.15.8; Coll. 15.2.1, citing Ulpian, 7 de off. proconsulis. Philostratus, Vita Ap. 4.35: Nero suspected philosophers of dabbling in magic and of being diviners in disguise, and this brought them before the courts; he issued an edict, before leaving for Greece, that there was to be no public teaching of philosophy in Rome (Vita Ap. 4.47). Gellius NA 15.11.3–5. Coll. 15.2.2; cf. Pliny, Ep. 10.96.3 (‘pertinaciam certe et inflexibilem obstinationem’). Suet. Tib. 36.
102
A C TA M A R T Y R U M C H R I S T I A N O R U M
there was no statutory prohibition of or sustained punishment for the practice of the Christian religion.21 There was repression certainly, sometimes savage, but it was sporadic, as for astrologers. The problem for Christians was probably lack of security, rather than any statistically likely bad happening.22 The attitude that might be taken by the Roman government to Christians in the early second century can be illustrated from Pliny and his exchange of letters with the Emperor Trajan around AD 110.23 Pliny, as provincial governor, with a duty to keep his province (Bithynia) free of bad men,24 was clear that Christians did or could fall into this category, and might be punished; he did not, however, know whether to pardon those who retracted their beliefs. When persons were charged with Christianity in his court, he asked them if they were indeed Christians, and if they admitted it, he repeated the question, sometimes more than once, to give them an opportunity to deny it. If they persisted, he ordered execution for non-citizens, while citizens were to be sent to Rome, for obdurate refusal to conform.25 An anonymous written charge – libellus – had listed many names; some others, named by an informer, had said they had long ceased to be Christians.26 The test, and it was just that, a test, to prove the denial of Christianity was an invocation to the gods, a sacrifice to them before an imperial statue, and an insult to the name of Christ. Pliny had also tortured two slave-women, known as ministrae, to check on the absence of ordinary crime, flagitia.27 Trajan, while approving Pliny’s conduct concerning those formally accused of Christianity, said that there could not be a general rule with a fixed formula. The Christians were not to be hunted out, but if the charge was proved they were to be punished; apostasy secured pardon. But anonymous accusations were not to have any place in trial proceedings; they were 21 22
23 24 25
26 27
Barnes (1968a). It seems quite likely that there were only a couple of hundred Christians put to death for Christianity in the 200 years or so before Decius. Frend (1965), 413, reckons of the undoubted Decian persecutions that ‘Deaths over the whole Empire may probably be numbered in hundreds rather than thousands.’ One could compare the statistical likelihood of being a terrorist victim; it’s minute, but people get worried. See Barnes (1968b); Robinson (1990–92). Pliny, Ep. 10.96–97. There is no space to consider pre-Decian trials, such as those of Polycarp, the martyrs of Lyons, the Scillitan martyrs, or Perpetua and her companions. D 1.18.3, Paul; 1.18.13pr, Ulpian. ‘pertinaciam certe et inflexibilem obstinationem debere puniri’ (Pliny, Ep. 10.96. 1–4). This cannot just be punishment for contumacy (as held by Sherwin-White (1952b), 210– 12, or (1964), 25–26), which is certainly an aggravating circumstance (as it was also with the astrologers), because there had actually been a formal charge – nomen deferre – bringing them before the governor. It is logically impossible to be contumacious before being charged with something to be contumacious about. Some other governors, as we shall see, took a softer line than Pliny’s. Pliny, Ep. 10.96.5–6. Pliny, Ep. 10.96.5 and 8. Quite properly; Pliny clearly had not put any free persons to the torture.
103
A C TA M A R T Y R U M C H R I S T I A N O R U M
an appalling precedent, unsuited to the times.28 From this time on, offering a sacrifice to the gods before the emperor, represented by a statue, seems to have been the normal recognized test of the existence or non-existence of Christian faith. The evidence for persecution in this period is too sparse to be conclusive, but it points to successful propaganda, a rewriting of history, by the Christians of the early fourth century, imposing, for ideological reasons, on the earlier Church the experience of their own day. There is some truth in what Gibbon said: ‘The ecclesiastical writers of the fourth and fifth centuries ascribed to the magistrates of Rome the same degree of implacable and unrelenting zeal which filled their own breasts against the heretics or the idolaters of their own times.’29 In the reign of Decius (249–51) an edict was issued which specifically required all inhabitants of the Empire to offer sacrifice.30 Under Decius, and later, in 257–60 under Valerian (253–60, ruling with his adult son Gallienus, 253–68), there was an effort, throughout the Empire, though not long-sustained, to eliminate the monotheistic practice of Christianity. Here there was legal pressure to conform, which amounted to persecution, not simply repression, policy, not just reaction, but even so its objective fell well short of extirpation.31 According to the trials and deeds of these martyrs and confessors, the Roman authorities remained, usually, satisfied by simple recantation, token sacrifices to the pagan gods. This mid-century period probably coincides with the effective disappearance of known jurists; Modestinus was probably dead. The second and earlier third centuries had been when the great jurists were writing and holding office; it would have been interesting to know their opinions on the cult of Christianity and its proper treatment. Unfortunately these opinions are not known to us, because our juristic sources survive almost entirely through the Digest, which was edited under Justinian in a profoundly Christian environment, and material hostile to Christianity was, presumably, excised.32 28
29 30 31
32
Pliny, Ep. 10.97. ‘Actum quem debuisti, mi Secunde, in executiendis causis eorum qui christiani ad te delati fuerant, secutus es. Neque enim in universum aliquid quod quasi certam formam habeat constitui potest. Conquirendi non sunt; si deferantur et arguantur, puniendi sunt, ita tamen ut, qui negaverit se christianum esse idque re ipsa manifestum fecerit, id est supplicando dis nostris, quamvis suspectus in praeteritum, veniam ex paenitentia impetret. Sine auctore vero propositi libelli nullo crimine locum habere debent. Nam et pessimi exempli nec nostri saeculi est.’ Tert. ap. 2.7, has the gist. Cf. Eusebius, HE 4.9, on the so-called rescript of Hadrian to Minucius Fundanus. Gibbon (1776), 467. See Rives (1999) on the essential importance of cult acts in ancient religion. The Christians selected for martyrdom were either bishops and other clergy, the leaders, whose deaths might recall the laity to the observance of Roman norms or, according to Gibbon (1776), 468, ‘the meanest and most abject . . . whose lives were esteemed of little value, and whose sufferings were viewed by the ancients with too careless an indifference.’ Lactantius div.inst. 5.11.19, records that Ulpian, in de off. proconsulis book 7, ‘rescripta principum nefaria collegit, ut doceret quibus poenis affici oporteret eos qui se cultores Dei confiterentur’. (However, as Alan Watson has frequently said, the odd thing about Justinian’s Corpus is not the excisions, but that Christianity was not introduced more.)
104
A C TA M A R T Y R U M C H R I S T I A N O R U M
The third period of martyrdom came in the ‘great’ persecution of Diocletian and Galerius and their colleagues in the imperial purple. This happened against a background, as described by Lactantius, of multiplied armies, exhausted agricultural resources, and an ever-growing number of interfering and exacting officials.33 This was the last serious attempt to get rid of Christianity, or at least the Christian Church. Around 303–4, four edicts were issued, although we have the texts of none of them, of which the first ordered the destruction of churches, the burning of sacred books, and the loss of legal privileges for those Christians who were of the upper ranks, and the fourth commanded everyone to sacrifice to the traditional gods on pain of death. This was the persecution in which thousands died horrible deaths; nevertheless there were others who suffered but survived, like the Donatus to whom Lactantius addressed his book on The Deaths of the Persecutors, and others still who confessed but hardly suffered at all, such as Eusebius and Lactantius himself. Death and torture, and the links with social status Since the martyrdoms are by definition concerned with death, even if not always its direct infliction,34 it seems appropriate to look at the legal rules on capital punishment at this period. In the second century, 100 or 150 years before the period covered in this chapter, society in the Roman Empire recognized the fundamental division between free persons and slaves, and also a division between citizen and (free) non-citizen; the latter can in general be defined as a distinction between the inhabitants of Italy, together with the ruling group in a fair number of provincial cities, and all the other inhabitants of the provinces. Overlapping these traditional distinctions of legal status was the division, originally social, between the upper ranks (in the Republic those of senatorial or equestrian rank) and all the rest of the population, often called the plebeians. By the middle of the second century this was hardening into a legal division, between the honestiores and the humiliores.35 The former comprised the old upper ranks and also the town councillors – decurions – of the cities of the Empire, with their families, whether they were citizens or not; the latter consisted of the plebeians and the great majority of the provincials.36 After the edict of Caracalla, known as the constitutio Antoniniana, which granted citizenship to (almost) all free 33 34 35 36
Lact. MP 7.2–4. Cf. his account of the census of AD 306 for the further harassment of the inhabitants of the Empire: Lact. MP 23. Such as the death of Pothinus, the aged bishop of Lyons, from pain and exhaustion (Eusebius, HE 5.1.28–31). See Cardascia (1950); Garnsey (1970); Rilinger (1988). See Sherwin-White (1973), esp. ch. xi. Honourably discharged veterans of the legions, along with decurions and certain individuals (such as civically appointed rhetoricians or doctors), made up the lowest level of the honestiores.
105
A C TA M A R T Y R U M C H R I S T I A N O R U M
inhabitants of the Empire, this was the only status distinction of legal consequence, apart from that between free and slave; slaves sometimes counted with humiliores, but were more often rated worse.37 Its significance was particularly to be seen in the criminal law. The traditional penalties for citizens of the late Republic and early Empire had been death, very often effectively commuted into exile enforced by aquae et ignis interdictio, and fines, including confiscation of property. During the first century, most importantly under Claudius,38 the range of penalties was widened, and punishment began to take note of relevant factors, both aggravating and mitigating.39 The ordinary death penalty was decapitation by the sword,40 the only form suitable for honestiores, but there were also aggravated forms, known as summum supplicium: crucifixion, the gallows (furca), the flames, and condemnation to the beasts or the hunting games;41 these were only suitable for humiliores or slaves. From early in the Empire executions were sometimes staged specifically as theatrical entertainment,42 and this remained the case at least until the later second century,43 but we do not find Christians being executed with this sort of elaboration. Such executions should clearly be classed as aggravated forms, but the jurists – at least, as their writings have come down to us – make no mention of them, and might even be understood to have disapproved.44 The status of someone condemned to death and awaiting execution was that of a penal slave; those condemned to the mines were in permanent penal slavery.45 Lesser penalties left civic status unaffected. Corporal punishment, whether in the form of forced labour,46 a flogging47 or something similar, was suitable for humiliores; presumably they might sometimes be fined, if they had sufficient means. Slaves might be confined in fetters.48 It is likely that such punishments were inflicted on Christians, but these might easily be described in the Acta as torture rather than as penalties. 37 38 39 40 41
42 43 44 45 46 47 48
D 48.19.10pr, Macer. Robinson (1998). And see ch. 8. D 48.19.11pr and 2, Marcian; 48.19.13, Ulpian; 48.19.16, Claudius Saturninus. D 48.19.8.1, Ulpian. The sword had replaced the traditional Republican axe, as carried by the lictors, still used early in the Empire (Seneca, ira 2.5.5). Crucifixion ceased to be a legal punishment in the Christian Empire so it is not mentioned in the Digest; cf. Hengel (1977). For the other forms of summum supplicium, see: D 48.19.9.11, Ulpian; 48.19.28pr, Callistratus; 48.19.38.1–2, Paul; 48.19.8.11, Ulpian. Martial, de spectaculis; see Coleman (1990); Vismara (1990). Strabo 6.2.6 is probably the earliest record, describing events around the 30s BC. As witnessed by Apuleius (who was born in c. 124), met. 10.22–23, 29 and 34, and Tertullian, ap. 15.4–5. D 48.19.8.1 and 3, Ulpian; 48.19.25.1, Modestinus. D 48.19.29, Gaius; 48.19.17pr, Marcian. Since they were ownerless, slaves of their penalty, they had no derivative capacity. Pliny, Ep. 10.32.2; Philostratus, Vita Ap. 5.19; D 48.19.8.7, Ulpian. D 48.19.7, Callistratus; 48.19.10pr, Macer; 48.19.28.1, Callistratus. D 48.19.8.13, Ulpian; cf. 48.19.8.9, Ulpian; see also Lovato (1994).
106
A C TA M A R T Y R U M C H R I S T I A N O R U M
Torture49 was an accepted part of the Roman criminal process, but it was recognized as unreliable, and there were some attempts at safeguards – for justice, and for the individual concerned.50 As we have seen in previous chapters, the evidence of slaves could not be taken except under torture. However, citizens were exempt under the Republican lex Porcia, and then the imperial lex Iulia de vi of c.17 BC, from summary flogging, and a priori from torture.51 Exceptions might be made in cases of those under suspicion for treason, but the principle was clear.52 Free persons who were not citizens did not enjoy the protection of the laws; we have seen in the chapter on repetundae trials that their torture was classed as saevitia, and was an undoubted aggravating circumstance when money had been extorted, but it was not illegal. Of course, citizens who had been condemned capitally were no longer citizens, and so could be put to the question.53 However, even a jurist as late as Callistratus held: ‘Interrogation under torture ought not to be applied to a freeman whose evidence is not inconsistent.’54 There were no controls on the actual administration of torture, except that people should not die under it – although it was admitted that they often did.55 It had normally two aspects; it could be applied to somebody under suspicion of a crime in order to make him confess, or it could be used for extracting evidence about some third party. Torture of Christians was in general sui generis, to persuade its victims to do something in accordance with morality or law, that is, to worship the Roman gods.56 The discussions of the jurists on torture, as preserved in the Digest, are preoccupied with slaves to such an extent that it cannot have been normally relevant to free persons, even in the Severan period,57 although one must remember that, in contrast to the emperors, the jurists tended to mull over past issues rather than raising new questions. However, this makes tracing the change in the law very difficult, for by the end of the third century, and 49 50 51 52
53 54 55 56 57
See Brunt (1980); Cerami (1991); Ermann (2000a); Pugliese (1964); Vincenti (1989). D 48.18.1pr–4 and 23–24, Ulpian; 48.18.8pr, Paul; a text from Ulpian – 48.18.1.21 – specifically warns against leading questions. E.g. Paul, Acts 22.24–29. Clearly implicit in D 48.18.12, Ulpian citing a rescript of Hadrian; 48.18.1.13, Ulpian citing Antoninus Pius. Although this has been challenged by Russo Ruggeri (2002); see too Polonen (2004), although this article fails to distinguish adequately between citizens and the many other free persons. D 48.19.29, Gaius; 48.18.21, Paul, citing Hadrian that nobody should be condemned for the purpose of putting him to the torture. D 48.18.15pr, Call: ‘Ex libero homine pro testimonio non vacillante quaestionem haberi non oportet’. D 48.18.7, Ulpian; 48.19.8.3, Ulpian. Tertullian, ap. 2.17: ‘You want him to deny that he is guilty in order to force him to be innocent . . . and even his past is not to count against him.’ D 48.18, de quaestionibus; nor do their remarks in D 22.5, de testibus, envisage the torture of the free.
107
A C TA M A R T Y R U M C H R I S T I A N O R U M
possibly well before, torture had come to be used regularly on free persons, even if the extension was gradual, perhaps starting with freedmen.58 It seems clear that, like the nature of the punishment to be imposed, this was an area where the distinction between honestiores and humiliores became important, and before the constitutio Antoniniana some non-citizens were nevertheless among the honestiores. Torture was undoubtedly applied to humiliores, as is proved by the explicit immunity of honestiores,59 although this came to be waived in cases of treason.60 The persons undergoing torture in the pre-Decian Acta are seemingly all non-citizens, with the exception of Attalus at Lyons,61 and on that occasion it is clear that there were irregularities, so there is no question of its illegal use being official. In the later persecutions most of the Christians were humiliores, but even those who might seem to be among the honestiores were self-confessed members of an illegal organization, and therefore were obviously not entitled to be exempt. The Christians had no complaint founded in law on the issue of torture; the authorities were not acting unlawfully.
Decius, the gods and the Christians Until the mid-third century Christians were only brought before the courts because of popular opinion, which felt that they were alien,62 hostile to the commonwealth and the pleasures of life, even if some specific charge was required to bring them to justice.63 Toleration there was if the Christians themselves did not provoke accusations, but this toleration was political rather than juridical; punishment, discretionary admittedly, but including the aggravated death penalty,64 was often imposed on those brought before 58 59
60 61 62 63 64
CJ 9.41.9, AD 290. CJ 9.41.8pr, Diocletian on soldiers; 9.41.11, Diocletian on the upper ranks below the senatorial and on decurions; Lact., MP 21.3–4, records the removal of their privileges by Galerius. D 48.18.10.1, Arcadius Charisius, who is a very late jurist; CJ 9.41.16.1, AD 376, adds magic (quae nefanda dictu sunt) to treason, as not giving decurions immunity from torture. Eusebius, HE 5.1.43–44 and 50. Tacitus, Ann. 15.44. I suggest that this might have run: ‘Lucius Titius put himself on record as accusing Perpetua of being guilty against the public discipline of ancestral custom, in that she did . . .’. But not always; Tert. ad Scap. 4.3 records the proconsul Vespronius Candidus sending a Christian back to his home town for a punishment which must by definition have been less than capital; another proconsul, Valerius Pudens, refused to try a Christian on the basis of an examining magistrate’s written statement, and released him; Cingius (or Cincius) Severus simply dismissed confessed Christians; all these were in Africa. In Asia, another governor, Arrius Antoninus, exasperated with a crowd of would-be martyrs, executed a few, but told the rest that if they wanted to die they could easily find a rope or a cliff (ad Scap. 5.1). Peregrinus, who became a Christian before turning to Cynic philosophy, was released by the legate of Syria without even a beating, admittedly to avoid his martyrdom making too big a stir (Lucian, Peregrinus, 14). And it is worth remembering that capital punishment could be imposed for repeated hooliganism (D 48.19.28.3, Call.).
108
A C TA M A R T Y R U M C H R I S T I A N O R U M
the courts if they persisted in their confession and refused to provide counter-evidence – it required no more – by performing a sacrifice before a statue of the emperor.65 Sporadic repression never completely ceased.66 During the third century, however, things changed. This was an age of increasing superstition, of belief in the occult, in dreams and visions, for Christians as well as pagans. Oracles became popular again; Diocletian was to consult Apollo of Miletus before embarking on his persecution.67 Miracle-working attracted widespread belief.68 Demons and sorcerers were seen as rife.69 The emperors responsible for the criminalization of Christianity, Decius, and then Valerian, were of traditional, though not Roman or even Italian, senatorial families, brought up to respect the Roman gods and view their cultivation as essential for the well-being of Rome. This respect had been observed in the millennial games of April 248, offered by the Emperor Philip and his son; traditional Rome had done well, and would continue to do well, by following ancestral custom. Further, Rome needed the friendship of the gods in her struggles against the Goths and other barbarians, and the recurrence of plague. Decius had been brought up in this tradition and, in view of the new religious competition, it must have seemed reasonable to him, soon after he came to Rome in late 249,70 to declare a supplicatio by the whole Roman people, all the inhabitants of the Empire,71 a unanimous sacrifice to the gods. Jews, as an identifiable people, following their own mos maiorum, could be exempted from such a requirement,72 but Christians had no such respectability. As Clarke has said: If the rally was to be really effective the leaders of these dissident Christian communities would need to be sought out so that they would bring their flocks with them to the public altars of the gods of Empire (their own god they might continue to worship).73
65 66 67 68 69 70 71
72 73
Pliny, Ep. 10.96.5. E.g. Cyprian, Ep. 39.3, on Celerinus’ martyred uncles and grandmother. Lact. MP 11.7; he also records that Galerius’ mother was highly superstitious and influenced her son. Philostratus, Vita Ap. passim. Flint (1999), 281–92; Alfoldy (1974). Pope Fabian was dead by 20 January 250. This universality is proved from Cyprian, Ep. 15.4 (concerned with treatment of the lapsed), where he refers to ‘qui propinqui et adfines et liberti et domestici esse adseverentur’ of the person receiving the certificate recording that sacrifice had been made; also Ep. 55.13.2 refers to those who sacrificed on behalf of wife, children et domum totam. Cf. Eusebius, Mart. Pal. 9.2, for participation in the sacrifice required from slaves and babies in the Great Persecution. See also Keresztes (1975a). Smallwood (1976), 540; cf. D 50.2.3.3, Ulpian. Clarke (1984), vol. I, p.24.
109
A C TA M A R T Y R U M C H R I S T I A N O R U M
The edict has not survived verbatim, but the libelli, the certificates recording obedience to the edict, record that the recipients ‘make sacrifice, pour libation and taste of the sacrificial victim’, and before witnesses.74 Local authorities were responsible for putting the edict into effect; there was a commission of five prominent citizens together with the city magistrates in Carthage, whereas in the town of Capsa there seems to have been just one magistrate.75 The libelli were fairly clearly part of the original organisation; they seem to have been drafted to a standard formula and were countersigned by a commissioner. Perhaps, as with the Egyptian census, there might have been multiple copies, one kept by the signatory, the other by the relevant authorities.76 It is not, however, clear what lists can have been used by the local officials to tick off the sacrificers; local census returns and tax registers were unlikely to include slaves, and possibly might be limited to adults, or even to adult males. Hence it seems probable that some Christians, perhaps many in some areas, were never called,77 but of course they risked delation by their neighbours, unless they took refuge either in city crowds,78 or in the countryside.79 After the time for the supplication was definitely past, latecomers seem to have been sent before the provincial governor, and it seems quite likely that after twelve months the special commissions were dissolved. At any rate, Bishop Cyprian was planning his public return to Carthage before the end of March 251;80 the persecution arising from the edict seems simply to have petered out.81 After all, if the supplicatio had been designed as one glorious gesture, it would be counter-productive to be too concerned with it a year afterwards. There is no evidence that Decius was particularly hostile to the Christians, and there is enough to indicate that his intentions were positive, for the good of Rome.82 However, it is quite clear that the government suspected that the Christians would be troublesome; the leaders of the churches in the most significant cities were seized early in 74 75 76 77 78
79
80 81 82
E.g. FIRA iii 189, p. 593, taken from the forty-one (all papyri) edited by J.R. Knipfing (1923b). On the fixed time, see Cyprian, de lapsis 3. Cyprian, Ep. 43.3.1; 56.1.1. In Asia we find a temple warden and colleagues (ACM, Pionii, 3.1). Rives (1999), also citing D 50.15.3–4, Ulpian. They are known as the stantes, and were often treated as potential confessors (e.g. Cyprian, Ep. 19.2.2). Cyprian, Ep. 21.4.1; 30.8.1 for those who went to Rome. Others came to Carthage; Cyprian was anxious that they should be properly looked after, and provided the means (Ep. 5.1.2; 7.2; 8.3). Eusebius, HE 6.42.2; Cyprian, Ep. 8.1.1, from the Roman to the African clergy on Cyprian’s withdrawal. See, more generally, Tertullian de fuga, passim. In a later persecution Agape and her companions were to take to the hills, ACM, Agape et al. 1.2. Cyprian, Ep. 43.1.2; 55.3.2–6.1 Celerinus, newly ordained lector, is, among other confessors, under no constraint (Cyprian, Ep. 39.1.1). Pohlsander (1986).
110
A C TA M A R T Y R U M C H R I S T I A N O R U M
250 and put to death, if they had not hidden themselves – Pope Fabian at Rome, Babylas at Antioch, Alexander at Jerusalem, fell into the first category,83 Dionysius of Alexandria84 and Cyprian of Carthage the second.85 And Cyprian’s flight was not unnoticed; he suffered confiscation as a result, whether as a penalty or, more probably, a contumaciously absent accused.86 Pionius Pionius, a priest (presbyter), was arrested in Smyrna87 on 23 February 250, along with a holy woman called Sabina and one Asclepiades; the Acta claims to be based on his own writing, but seems to have been edited to make close the comparison with Polycarp. Polemon, the temple warden, and clearly one of the commission designated to enforce the Decian edict in Smyrna, came with his men to take them, as self-confessed Christians, to the agora to offer sacrifice and taste forbidden meats.88 He led them off without any physical restraint, but they were wearing woven chains around their necks, which Pionius had made for them, to make clear that they were not going to the agora of their own free will, nor intending to apostatize, as others had.89 Once there before the tribunal, Polemon told Pionius he would be wise to offer sacrifice like everyone else, and thus avoid punishment. Pionius was apparently allowed to make a lengthy speech, to an attentive crowd, rebuking both Greeks and Jews, and maintaining the Christian faith. The commissioners attempted persuasion, but to no avail.90 The people here were not hostile (unless this is a passage interpolated from much later when the world was largely Christian), but wished to adjourn to the theatre to hear more. Polemon, however, was warned that this might lead to a riot. Nevertheless there were further attempts to persuade the confessors, with Sabina being cautioned that she risked being put into a brothel (eis porneion); even if 83 84
85 86 87
88
89 90
Eusebius, HE 6.39.1–4. But Fabian was for months the only martyr in Rome – to be deduced from Cyprian Ep. 21, and comment by Clarke (1984), vol. I, p. 314. Eusebius, HE 6.40: a soldier was sent to arrest him in the same hour as the edict was published; in HE 6.41–42 Bishop Dionysius recounts the pogrom in Alexandria in 248, but this was seemingly spontaneous, under no legal authority. A succession of terrible earthquakes had led to a similar unofficial pogrom in Cappadocia c. AD 235 (Cyprian, Ep. 75.10; cf. Eusebius, HE 6.28). Cyprian, Ep. 5; 7.1; 20.1. Cyprian, Ep. 66.4.1 records the public notice, inhibiting his debtors, among other things; cf. D 48.17.5pr and 3, Modestinus. Eusebius, HE 4.15.47; Eusebius places Pionius as a contemporary of Polycarp, but the demands made on him and his companions indicate that it was in the Decian persecution, as ACM, Pionii, 2.1, states. The fullest treatment of this martyrdom is in Robert (1994). St Paul, in 1 Corinthians 8 and 10.14–33, had held that there was no harm in itself in eating foods dedicated to false gods, because they did not exist; the harm lay in the scandal it could cause. ACM, Pion. 2.1–3.7. ACM, Pion. 4.1–6.5.
111
A C TA M A R T Y R U M C H R I S T I A N O R U M
they were Christians, could they not be persuaded to sacrifice to the emperor if not the gods? On their repeated refusal, the notary was brought in, to take down the prisoners’ details for the record; Sabina gave a false name, as she had been cast out by her former mistress when she was converted.91 This is perhaps a suitable place to point out that the provincial governors, like the authorities at Rome, were aided by a significant staff, some attached to them in their capacity of magistrate, others seconded from the local army unit, but in both cases men who were permanently based in a particular province.92 Those whom we find arresting Christians were sometimes from the office staff,93 sometimes soldiers,94 and sometimes from the local city.95 Then there were the officials of the governor’s own judicial staff, among them the commentariensis, a senior post, in charge of criminal proceedings,96 while there were secretaries to write things down;97 criers or heralds98 would also be here. There might also be lawyers at the court.99 There were prison guards,100 soldiers to escort the prisoners,101 and, obviously, torturers. There were those at the amphitheatre, executioners,102 and also gladiators.103 However, the Christian use of technical terms is not always accurate. 91 92
93 94
95 96
97 98 99 100
101 102
103
ACM, Pion. 7.1–9.9. D 12.1.34, Paul; they were therefore not subject to repetundae restrictions, but able to lend money at interest to the provincials. Lopuszanski (1951); Jones (1964); Breeze (1974); Robinson (1992), 191–95. Probably the strator and equistrator who arrested Cyprian, ACM, Cyprian 2.2; Felix, 9; frumentarii in Cyprian, Ep. 81.1.1. The beneficiarii, senior NCOs, who arrested Fructuosus, were also at the amphitheatre (ACM, Fruct. 1.2; 4.1); stationarii, mentioned in Marian 4.3, were soldiers stationed for policing duties at major crossroads and near cities; a stationarius of senior rank arrested Agape and companions (ACM, Agape 3.1). Probably true of the attendants (prosecutores) in Perpetua 3.1; Polemon, the neokoros or temple warden, in Pionius, 3.1; Felix’ deductor was a local decurion (Felix, 22). At least in the Later Empire (Lydus de mag. 3.16) it was his responsibility to see to the arrest and safekeeping of the accused, his production before the governor, the correct recording of the proceedings, the questioning of the accused under torture, and the carrying out of the sentence on conviction. He was present in the amphitheatre for the death of Pionius, 21.1; he is reading the charge to the court in Agape 3.1; and again in Crispina 1.1, where he is also the one to see that her head is shaved, 3.1. As in Pionius 9.1 and 19.1; Crispina 4.1. Found in Polycarp 12.1; the Scillitan martyrs 16. Many in the Acta Phileas (XII/4.1; 5.5; 6.2 and 4; 8.1). In ACM, Perpetua, the chief warder (praepositus carceris), Pudens, who became a Christian, was an optio, roughly a sergeant (9.1); we also hear of ministri cataractariorum [sic] (Perp. 15.5; these are also mentioned in Mont. 17.1). Mont. 4.2; Felix, 31. The confector in Pionius 21.3; the speculator to whom Cyprian gave 25 aurei, ACM, Cyprian 5.4; the carnifex in Marian 12.1 and in Mont. 15.1; the slave Zosimus, whose duties were wider (Agape 5.8 and 6.1), seems to have been the city executioner; simply a minister in Iren. 5.6; carnifices in Acta Phileas 9.3. In Perpetua, 18.9; 19.5; 21.9, the gladiators were venatores, perhaps men condemned to the hunting games.
112
A C TA M A R T Y R U M C H R I S T I A N O R U M
Then Pionius and his two companions were taken to the prison, there to await the arrival of the governor; Polemon pointed out to the now restive crowd that the local authorities did not have jurisdiction. In the prison they found other Christians. Pionius made the gaolers angry by refusing to accept gifts from the visiting faithful; clearly it was normal for those Christians who were not under arrest to bribe the gaolers to allow this, or else for the gaolers to take their share of what was brought. So they were put into the inner prison, dark and stifling, as we know from other sources, but they remained so affable that the prison warden relented, and they were allowed to discourse and to pray, night and day, in the company of many visitors.104 Prisons in the ancient world seem to have been at least as nasty as modern ones, dark places of stifling heat (in our Mediterranean sources; RomanoBritish prisons will undoubtedly have been cold and damp), thirst and hunger.105 We hear little about them in the sources, except for the martyrdoms, where the view is from below; normally prisoners’ very condition made them invisible people. Perhaps on the model of the carcer and the Tullianum at Rome, most prisons seem to have had an outer and an inner area.106 Prison was deliberately a place of terror,107 designed to strip the prisoner of all dignity, and to induce confessions by both physical and psychological means. There were rations,108 but they were minimal, for friends and family were expected to supply prisoners’ wants; there seem to have been few visiting restrictions. Such visits, of course, offered prison guards an opportunity to demand bribes,109 and it is clear that this practice was widely accepted. Only in the Later Empire, perhaps under Christian influence since Christians will have been prepared to acknowledge imprisonment, were there serious attempts to improve prison conditions. Constantine tried to shorten the time spent in prison by speeding the holding of a trial; he forbade ill-treatment by the guards, in particular starving the prisoners. The prisoner brought to court should not be in manacles made of iron that cleave to the bones, but in looser chains, so that there may be no torture and yet the custody may remain secure. When incarcerated he must not suffer the darkness of an inner prison [which was presumably for bandits, or those who 104 105 106 107 108 109
ACM, Pion. 10.1–11.7. There does not seem to be segregation of the sexes in this prison. E.g. Eusebius, HE 5.1.27; Cyprian Ep. 22.2. See generally the essays in BertrandDagenbach (1999); Lovato (1994) is concerned with Romans rather than provincials. E.g. Acts of the Apostles 16.24; ACM, Perp. 3.7; Pion. 11.4; Felix 26; CTh 9.3.1, AD 320. Seneca, ep. 24.3, reckoned imprisonment ranked between exile and death. They were mentioned very unfavourably in Montanus and Lucius 6.2–5; 9.3; 21.12; Irene, in Agape 5.8, was to receive a ration, but of merely one loaf a day. ACM, Perp. 3.7; Pionius, 11.3–5. There is unsuccessful bribery, hoping to be given the bodies to bury, in the Lyons affair, HE 5.1.61.
113
A C TA M A R T Y R U M C H R I S T I A N O R U M
had attempted escape], but he must be kept in good health by the enjoyment of light . . . 110 Proper records were to be kept of those assigned to ‘squalid custody’.111 Sexual segregation was ordered.112 Governors were to inspect prisoners weekly, see to it that food – two or three libellae (a tenth of a denarius, so presumably as much bread as this would buy) – was supplied to those who did not have it, and that they had a weekly bath.113 Another attempt was made by the local officials to persuade them to sacrifice, saying that Euctemon, apostate bishop of Smyrna, and one Lepidus, were asking for them in the temple of Nemesis; Pionius said that they preferred to await the arrival of the proconsul. However, the local cavalry commander (hipparchos) had them brought forcibly – Pionius struggled so hard that six soldiers were needed to carry him – to the agora, and to the temple of Nemesis where Euctemon was still in an attitude of worship, and Lepidus was cursing Christ. Pionius rebuked the authorities for their lack of respect for their own laws: ‘You punish us for disobeying, and yet you too do not obey; you were ordered to punish us, not to force us against our wills.’114 The public slave who was standing there with the sacrificial meat did not dare approach any of the prisoners, but simply ate it himself.115 All were then sent back to the prison, but Pionius was clubbed on the head by one of the soldiers, doubtless in retaliation for the struggle he had put up against the hipparchos’ order.116 The proconsul of Asia, Quintillianus, arrived in due course; Pionius was brought before the tribunal on 12 March, and testified, with minutes being taken down by secretaries. There was a fairly formal exchange between the two men, with Pionius giving his name, identifying himself as a Christian and a presbyter, and refusing to sacrifice, although the proconsul, perhaps not seriously, said that he could sacrifice to the air.117 Then it seems that Pionius was put to the torture, being tortured by his fingernails, but he continued 110 111 112 113
114
115 116 117
CTh 9.3.1, AD 320; cf. 9.1.18, AD 396. CTh 9.3.2, AD 326; 9.3.4, AD 365; 9.3.6, AD 380. CTh 9.3.3, AD 340. CTh 9.3.7, AD 409. Bishops too had a role as prison visitors, to heal the sick, feed the poor and console the innocent, but also to make sure that prisoners were brought before the competent judge and not left to languish (Sirm. 13, AD 419). ACM, Pion. 15.1–16.6; this attitude, and the correct response by the Roman authorities, occurs in ACM, Perp. 18.5–6, and Cyprian 1.5; it is also noteworthy that the authorities do not seem to have wrested the sacred books from Felix. ACM, Pion. 18.5; it will have speeded up the proceedings considerably if the authorities normally provided the already sacrificed and cooked meat, cf. 18.13–14. ACM, Pion. 18.10. ACM, Pion. 19.1–13. D 48.3.6, Marcian, makes clear that a governor must not act as though charges made against a remand prisoner had been proved, but must make an examination ab initio.
114
A C TA M A R T Y R U M C H R I S T I A N O R U M
his refusal to sacrifice. Remarking that volunteer gladiators equally despised death, Quintillianus sentenced him to the fire. ‘The sentence was then read in Latin from a tablet: ‘‘Whereas Pionius has admitted that he is a Christian, we hereby sentence him to be burned alive’’.’118 He went immediately to the amphitheatre, where he was burned together with another Christian, from the Marcionite heresy. The fire seems to have been extinguished before the body was consumed, but there is no mention of any coup de graˆce.119 Rather disappointingly, we hear nothing of the fates of the others; they may even have been released. More likely they were just left in prison, where the confessors could think that the emperor had ordered that they should die from hunger and thirst in the sweltering inner prison.120 The lapsed The Decian persecution petered out, perhaps partly because it had been difficult to administer. But unlike previous, and perhaps later, persecutions, there were very many who had denied their faith and sacrificed121 because, as Christianity had spread more widely, Christians were no longer ‘saints’ but ordinary men and women.122 Some of these were true apostates, but as the letters of St Cyprian show, many had simply not had courage enough to risk their lives and had sacrificed, so to speak, with their fingers crossed.123 As Cyprian wrote, there was a significant difference between one who had volunteered to sacrifice and one who only did so under compulsion,124 118
119
120 121 122 123
124
ACM, Pion. 20.1–7. Reading out the sentence as written on a tablet or a sheet of papyrus seems to have been the proper way of issuing it: cf. the Scillitan Martyrs, Cyprian, Agape and Irene, and Crispina. It is also how Augustus, in the afterlife, gives his sentence on Claudius (Seneca, Apoc. 11). ACM, Pion. 21–22; cf. ACM, Polycarp, ss. 12–16. Gusty winds might make a fire unreliable, and the beasts were not always eager to attack human beings (ACM, Perp. 19.6, and 21; Eusebius, HE 5.1.40). Spectacular executions could go wrong, so it was better to have men at hand who could make sure. Cyprian, Ep. 22.2. Even bishops – as well as Euctemon of Smyrna, described above, two in Spain are mentioned in Cyprian, Ep. 67.1.1. See Cyprian, Ep. 54 on the tares as well as the wheat within the Church. Two women known to Cyprian, Numeria and Candida, had sacrificed, but since then they had been busy meeting refugees and other visitors at Rome’s harbour and escorting them to the city; at the time of writing they had looked after the needs of sixty-five confessors (Cyprian, Ep. 21.4.1). There was a woman named Bona, who was dragged to the temple by her husband; ‘she did not sully her conscience, but they, by holding her hands, thus made the sacrifice themselves. She then started to cry out in protest: ‘‘I did not do it; you have done it.’’ And so she too was exiled’ (Cyprian, Ep. 24.11). Ste Croix (1954) points out that there were no canons on sacrifice and incense at the Council of Arles held in 314, unlike the Council of Ancyra in the East. In the West thurification does not seem to have been considered a very serious lapse.
115
A C TA M A R T Y R U M C H R I S T I A N O R U M
between one who had brought his whole family and one who sacrificed on their behalf, thus protecting them at the cost of endangering his own soul, and similarly between a landowner who had forced his tenants to sacrifice and one who spared them and welcomed refugees.125 Offering incense (thurification) was perhaps a less blameworthy form of sacrifice, since it was not aggravated by the eating of sacrificial meat.126 Others had not sacrificed, but had acquired a libellus recording their conformity. Some of these might have done so by offering payment to avoid what was forbidden;127 others seem to have acquired libelli through proxies.128 These two groups were known as the sacrificati and the libellatici.129 There were also those who, for some reason given a second chance to confess their faith, redeemed themselves by doing so; these seem to have been sent into exile.130 There is no evidence for fresh persecution, but there may have been new delations, perhaps for fulfilling such Christian duties as visiting the sick, burying the dead, helping widows and orphans, visiting and bringing relief to prisoners.131
Valerian and the criminalization of Christianity This problem of dealing with the repentant lapsed took up most of Bishop Cyprian’s energies132 until persecution was resumed in or before August 257 under Valerian. The reasons for this resumption after nearly four years of his reign are obscure, but there had already been fears of persecution under Gallus,133 and the prevalence of plague made people ready to find a scapegoat. One possibility is that the church had become sufficiently wealthy for its property to be attractive to an emperor enmeshed in a financial crisis.134 Another is that in the province of Pontus, the Christians seem to have given aid to the invading Goths.135 But Bishop Dionysius of Alexandria assigned to Macrianus, Valerian’s a rationibus (roughly, chief secretary to 125 126 127 128 129
130 131
132 133 134 135
Cyprian, Ep. 55.13.2. Cyprian, Ep. 55.2.1 and 55.11. Cyprian, Ep. 55.14.1; cf. 21.3.2. Cyprian, Ep. 30.1. The distinction was also made at Rome (Cyprian, Ep. 30.3.1–2). Ste Croix (1954) points out that in the East, in contrast to the West libellaticii were not held blameworthy, as the Ancyra canons show. Cyprian, Ep. 24.1. As in Cyprian, Ep. 8.3; 13.7. It could even be said, by a hostile source, that some went to prison to get to enjoy the luxuries that were brought in (Lucian, Peregrinus, 14); Cyprian had seen this danger, and wrote that drunkenness and debauchery were to be found among soi-disant Christians (Cyprian, Ep. 13.4.1). Eusebius’ two references to Cyprian are both in this context (HE 6.43.3; 7.2.3). Cyprian, Ep. 57.1.2; 58. Bovini (1948), ch. iii. For both these views, see Frend (1965), 422–23.
116
A C TA M A R T Y R U M C H R I S T I A N O R U M
the imperial treasury), a religious motivation for his encouragement of the persecution.136 Whatever its proximate cause, Valerian’s first edict forbade Christians to hold assemblies, including such events as funerals, under pain of capital punishment, and required some recognition of the Roman rites, without going so far as to require worship of the Roman gods, or the abandonment of other gods. On 30 August 257 Cyprian was called, or brought, before the proconsul of Africa, Aspasius Paternus, in private (in secretario). Paternus asked Cyprian, whom he quite likely knew and whose position he certainly knew, what he had to say to the edict. On Cyprian’s replying that he served the one God, and prayed to Him for the health of the emperors, Paternus asked if he would be willing to go as an exile to the town of Curubis (only some 50 kilometres away), and he agreed. Paternus then asked for the names of the presbyters in Carthage, presumably since they too were leaders of the church. Cyprian replied that it was a good and useful provision of the laws that delators were forbidden; therefore he could not give this information. They were living quietly in their communities, ‘since our discipline forbids anyone to surrender voluntarily’, but if they were sought they would be found.137 Paternus then reiterated that the emperors had ordered Christians not to hold meetings or enter cemeteries.138 Temporary exile seems to have been widely applied;139 his discretion, rather than his orders, probably led the legate in Numidia to condemn some clergy to the mines.140 Cyprian remained for a while in Curubis. The legal position is unclear. He was perhaps technically relegated from Carthage,141 but we find him a year later back in Carthage, staying on his own estate.142 Some who were exiled undoubtedly also suffered loss of property, although Cyprian does not seem 136 137
138
139 140 141
142
Eusebius, HE 7.10. ACM, Cyprian 1; Cyprian, Ep. 77.2.1–2. The Early Church was in general hostile to those who actively sought martyrdom because of the risk of recantation; see ACM, Polycarp, 4. Christ himself had left Judaea for Galilee (Ev. John 7.1; 10.39–40). ‘ne in aliquibus locis conciliabula faciant nec coemeteria ingrediantur.’ The concept of a cemetery was a new one, arising from the burial of martyrs close to a church building. Pagan Romans were buried in plots along, for example, the via Appia, or in private land (see FIRA iii 86, p. 276). E.g. Eusebius, HE 7.11.3–11 and 14–17, on Dionysius of Alexandria and some of his clergy. Cyprian Ep. 76.2.2 and 4; 77.3.1; this was technically a capital penalty (D 48.19.28pr, Callistratus). Governors did not have the power to deport – a capital penalty (D 48.19.2.1; 48.22.6.1; 48.22.15.1) – but they could relegate, fine, and sequester or confiscate property (D 48.17.2pr, Macer; 48.17.5, Modestinus; 48.22.4–5, Marcian). At much the same time Dionysius of Alexandria had been recalled from distant Cephro to a town much closer to Alexandria (Eusebius, HE 7.11.10–17). Cyprian will not have returned without permission; in Ep.13.4.1, he rebuked those who did because, if caught, they would now be condemned not as Christians but as criminals. It is just possible that this was a form of house arrest (D 48.22.9, Ulpian, and 10, Marcian).
117
A C TA M A R T Y R U M C H R I S T I A N O R U M
to have fallen into this category;143 he had already suffered some loss of property in the Decian persecution. Cyprian had received advance information from Rome about Valerian’s second edict, for he was expecting to be summoned again before the governor, now Galerius Maximus.144 This second edict, in the form of an oratio to the Senate, and also sent as a mandate to provincial governors, may have sought information on the enforcement of the earlier edict;145 it was published sometime in the summer of 258. It had reached Rome by August, for Pope Sixtus, along with four deacons, was put to death on 6 August in the cemetery of Callistus,146 and the persecution was in full swing under the prefects.147 Bishops, priests and deacons were to be summarily executed, while senators, egregii, such as imperial procurators, and equestrians who persisted in adherence to Christianity were to lose their status and forfeit their property; obduracy would bring capital punishment (probably normally meaning deportation). Matrons, presumably women of senatorial or equestrian rank, were to face confiscation of all property and relegation. Caesariani, most likely meaning those serving as lower officials in the imperial household, perhaps mostly freedmen, who had either confessed earlier or did so now, were to have their goods confiscated and be sent in chains to forced labour on imperial estates.148 We know too that some of those sentenced under the earlier edict were now recalled from exile and executed.149 Cyprian News was brought that Cyprian was to be arrested and taken to Utica (by soldiers – frumentarii – of the proconsul’s officium); he was advised to avoid this by withdrawing temporarily from his country estate. This he did, not to escape his martyrdom, but so that he would not be forced to confess his faith in a city other than that of his own see; the proconsul would soon return from the assize and be back in Carthage.150 He must soon have 143 144 145
146 147 148 149 150
Cyprian, Ep. 19.2.3; 24.1.1. ACM, Cypriani 2. Unlike the reaction to Decius’ edict, which was often cowardly, this first edict of Valerian seems to have been widely and flagrantly flouted. This was not tolerable, but Decius’ universalist approach had been shown to be unworkable. But his informant must have left Rome almost immediately, because there is no mention of Lawrence and his companions who were martyred on 10 August (Cyprian, Ep. 80.1.4). Cyprian uses the plural, perhaps referring to the Urban Prefect assisted by the praefectus vigilum, perhaps to the Praetorian Prefects – see further, Clarke (1975). Cyprian, Ep. 80.1; this letter was written to a fellow African bishop, who had presumably asked if Cyprian could confirm the rumours. Not just Cyprian but, for example, bishops Agapius and Secundinus (ACM, Mar. and Jac. 3). Cyprian, Ep. 81. In this letter to his clergy and laity, Cyprian reiterated his instruction that they were to remain calm, and not stir up trouble by pushing forward for voluntary martyrdom; only if arrested and questioned must a Christian do more than profess his faith, he must confess it.
118
A C TA M A R T Y R U M C H R I S T I A N O R U M
returned, for it was there that, on 13 September, two fairly senior officers151 on the proconsul’s staff arrived at the estate, and took him in a wagon to a suburban estate where Galerius Maximus was nursing his health – in fact, he was to die only a few days after Cyprian’s execution. Cyprian was remanded until the following day, and spent the night at the proconsular palace in Carthage, in the care of the strator. Here all the Christians of the city were able to visit him.152 The proconsul did not come into the city, but remained at the ager Sexti, where Cyprian was arraigned before him in the Sauciolan hall. Galerius Maximus formally checked his identity, and asked if he had performed the required religious rites (under the first edict). On Cyprian’s denial, the proconsul bade him be careful, but Cyprian replied that he should carry out his orders, for in a matter so legally clear there was no need for carefulness.153 Galerius Maximus consulted with his consilium, his advisers, and then spoke reluctantly, condemning, as an example, Cyprian for his persistence in sacrilege, conspiracy and enmity to the gods of Rome. In the customary manner, he read his decision from a tablet: ‘Thascius Cyprian is sentenced to die by the sword’, to which Cyprian replied, ‘Thanks be to God’ (Deo gratias).154 He was led out into the grounds of the estate. He removed his cloak so that he could kneel on it, then removed his dalmatic and gave it to his deacons – so clearly this governor at least was reluctant to execute summarily the lesser clergy – and told his friends to give the executioner (speculator) 25 gold pieces.155 He then himself bound his eyes with his kerchief, although a priest tied the knot for him, and thus he went to his death. His body was laid out nearby and remained there until nightfall, to satisfy the curiosity of the pagans. Then it was taken up by the faithful and buried, openly not secretly.156 It is evident that Galerius Maximus (whose final illness might have affected him either way) was reluctant to impose death 151
152 153 154 155
156
strator and equistrator a custodiis; Lopuszanski (1951). Strator seems to vary between groom and stablemaster via equerry, but always horsy, so why equistrator? Often the rank is clearly sub-clerical, on a par with praecones and standard-bearers, but Symm. Rel. 38 describes a palatine official who seems to be of some standing. ACM, Cypriani 2. ACM, Cypriani 3; ‘in re tam iusta nulla est consultatio.’ ACM, Cypriani 4. D 48.20.6, Ulpian, states that prisoners could keep their own clothes, the small change in their money belts, rings of low value, and so on, right up until they were stripped for execution; the proceeds from such things were not the executioners’ perquisites but kept by the governor as petty cash. It is clear, however, that Cyprian was receiving the special treatment appropriate to someone of the upper ranks. ACM, Cypriani 5, despite this being explicitly forbidden in the first edict. In earlier times the bodies, or the ashes, of those executed were to be delivered to their relatives or friends, except in cases of treason (D 48.24.1, Ulpian, and 3, Paul). See also ACM, Polycarp, ss. 17–18, where this was done, and Lyons, where it was not (Eusebius, HE 5.1.57–62).
119
A C TA M A R T Y R U M C H R I S T I A N O R U M
even on the bishop, the leader of the local church, and that he left alone the other clergy, and made no attempt to interfere with the illegal funeral. After Galerius’ death there were other martyrdoms in Africa, at which again due process seems to have been observed. The prisoners had to wait for several months until the arrival of a new governor, and then they were sentenced to the sword.157 In Numidia we hear of the deaths of Marianus and James and their companions.158 In Spain, in January 259, Bishop Fructuosus of Tarragona was given time to change his slippers for sandals before being led to prison.159 He was questioned by the governor, apparently without torture, and sentenced to the fire.160 The crowd is here portrayed as sympathetic rather than hostile; many persons offered Fructuosus drugged wine to drink. The Christians were able to collect the ashes without hindrance.161 In spite of there now being a general law against the practice of Christianity, its enforcement was clearly going to be sporadic. This persecution too seems to have petered out; it was effectively ended in 261 (after the Persian capture of the Emperor Valerian) by Gallienus who wrote to the bishops of Egypt, not legitimating the church, but restoring to the Christians their places of worship, including cemeteries, and ordering none to molest them.162
The ‘great’ persecution Years of peace and reconstruction followed for the Church, although there were occasional bad moments, such as the martyrdom of Marinus, which arose from his jealous delation by a rival for promotion to the centurionate.163 Then came the ‘great’ persecution, urged by Galerius, at that time 157
158 159 160
161 162 163
ACM, Montani & Lucii; one of the group, whose friends had (falsely) denied that he was a deacon, was only sentenced after convincing the governor of his status (Mont. & Luc. 23.12.3; 23.20). ACM, Mar. & Jac. ACM, Fruct. 1. ACM, Fruct. 2. The governor seems to have enjoyed black humour. He asked Fructuosus if he knew that the (pagan) gods existed, and when the bishop said ‘No’, he responded ‘You will’; when he asked Fructuosus if he was a bishop and received ‘I am’, he replied ‘You were’. ACM, Fruct. 3.1–2; 6.1–2. Eusebius, HE 7.13. Eusebius, HE 7.15. The martyrdom of Maximilian in 295 is obscure. He refused recruitment into the army, on the grounds that Christians could not serve, but this was simply not true, as the proconsul pointed out (ACM Max. 2.9; cf. Juli 2); perhaps he was a member of the Montanist or some similar sect. What seems reasonably certain is that he was refusing conscription; army service was no longer just for volunteers. The change of heart in the same year of the senior centurion Marcellus is also unexplained; it must be relevant that it sprang in both recensions from the celebration of the emperors’ official birthdays (Marc. (M)1.1; (N) 2.1). Both these martyrs were punished under military law rather than for Christianity as such.
120
A C TA M A R T Y R U M C H R I S T I A N O R U M
Diocletian’s Caesar in the East, and agreed to by Diocletian. (It should be noted that this only occurred nearly twenty years after Diocletian’s accession.164) It was prefigured by Diocletian’s edict against the Manichees, perhaps in 297 but more likely 302, which has survived.165 (Manichaeism was, of course, the religion of the Persians, the only external enemy on a par with the Roman Empire.) The Manichaean leaders and their books were to be seized and burned, other adherents of the sect were to suffer simple death and confiscation, and although the lives of honestiores were to be spared, they were to be sent to the mines (which, however, was legally a capital sentence, and was likely to result in physical death) and their estates confiscated. The actual trigger for the persecution of Christians was relatively trivial.166 Eusebius seems to understand the renewal of persecution as a punishment on a church which had succumbed to pride, sloth and sectarian fighting.167 Unfortunately, perhaps because of the natural emotion of one who was for much of the time an eye-witness,168 Eusebius is much less useful on any legal aspects for this period than when he was reporting earlier persecution, often from trial accounts. The first edict, and the martyrdom of Felix There were four edicts against the Christians, which can be fairly safely reconstructed. The first,169 issued at Nicomedia, on 23 February (Lactantius) or March (Eusebius) 303, and also published in the West, said that those who persisted in the faith were to lose any juridical privileges they had enjoyed, becoming subject to torture,170 and that any action could be brought against them in court but that they could not sue for injuries done to them;171 further, all Christian churches were to be destroyed, all sacred 164 165 166
167 168 169 170
171
Baynes (1956), 662–65. Coll. 15.3. Bruce (1983), like Molthagen (1970), argues for the earlier date, Corcoran (1996), 135–36, together with Mommsen (1899), for the later. Lact. MP 10–11, gives the casus; Christians in attendance on the emperor crossed themselves during the consultation of the entrails by the haruspices, and in consequence there were no signs as to the future even after repeated sacrifices; the sign of the Cross was understood both by Christian and pagan as very effective against demons and pagan gods. Eusebius and, according to him, Constantine, could find no rational explanation for the renewal of persecution. Frend (1965), 477–81, thinks it was based on many of the same factors that had motivated Decius, the traditional values of Rome. Eusebius, HE 8.1, especially at 8.1.7. Eusebius, HE 8.9.4. Eusebius HE 8.2.4; 9.10.8; mart. Pal. pr. 1, which says April; Lact. MP 13.1. CJ 9.41.11, Diocletian, cites Marcus Aurelius as having held that the higher equestrian grades, down to and including their grandsons, should not be tortured or given plebeian punishments. This implies that those lower in the social scale were subject to torture, but the borderline may have been elsewhere before the constitutio Antoniniana. For Ulpian (D 50.2.2.2), some fifty years later, the same privilege applied to decurions and their children. Lact. MP 12.
121
A C TA M A R T Y R U M C H R I S T I A N O R U M
books handed over to be burned, and freedmen serving the emperor as officials were to be reduced to slavery.172 Assemblies of Christians were presumably forbidden. (There were different reactions by Christians in West and East to those who handed over the scriptures (traditio); it was not seen as a serious matter in the East, whereas in the West it justified the removal of a man from his clerical status.173) In the West generally the edict was sporadically enforced. The evidence shows Constantius, who was the Caesar controlling Gaul and Britain, ‘contenting himself with the perfunctory demolition of churches’.174 However, Maximian, Augustus of the West, pursued a rather more vigorous policy in Africa, Spain and Italy until his enforced abdication in May 305. In Africa Proconsularis the decree was not promulgated until 5 June 303. In the city of Tibiuca the Christian clergy were summoned, but bishop Felix was away, apparently with the divine books, as his clergy attested; they were remanded in custody. On Felix’ return the following day he was summoned before the curator civitatis;175 as usual, there was a formal identification.176 He refused to hand over whatever books or parchments he had, and was given three days to reconsider, after which he was remanded before the proconsul; his escort (deductor) to Carthage was a decurion. The next day, before the legate, he again refused to surrender the books, and was sent to the inner part of the prison where he stayed sixteen days until the arrival of the proconsul, Anullinus; Felix was then, on his continued refusal, sentenced to be beheaded.177 It is interesting that apparently no attempt was made to wrest the books from the middleaged bishop; as Pionius had said, the governor had lawful power to punish, but not to force men to do things against their will.178 The later edicts Not many months later, disorders in Syria and Armenia led to a second edict which ordered the arrest of all Christian clergy.179 A third edict, of September or November 303, probably linked with Diocletian’s celebration 172 173 174 175
176 177 178 179
Eusebius, HE 8.2.4; other sanctions for continuing to possess the sacred books are not clear. Ste Croix (1954), 84ff, citing the Council of Arles. Ste Croix (1954), 106. The curator, or logistes, of a city was supposed to act as a control on the city’s financial management; at this period it was an imperial appointment, in the fourth century it was to become an elected magistracy. This very reasonable step is recorded quite frequently: e.g. for Polycarp, Pionius, Cyprian, and Fructuosus. ACM, Felicis 23–31. The note on where he was buried (s. 31) suggests that the burial was carried out by fellow-Christians. ACM, Pion. 16.6. Eusebius HE 8.2.5; 8.6.8–9; mart. Pal. pr. 2. The presidents (proedroi) of all the churches were to be imprisoned and then compelled to sacrifice.
122
A C TA M A R T Y R U M C H R I S T I A N O R U M
of his Vicennalia, in view of the authorities’ struggle with the sheer numbers of prisoners, offered amnesty to those who would sacrifice, penalties for those who refused.180 Then, early in 304, during Diocletian’s illness and clearly emanating from Galerius, came the fourth edict, ordering all the Roman world, men, women and children, to sacrifice, on pain of death.181 Eusebius describes how registers of the inhabitants were compiled in 306, throughout Caesarea at least, designed presumably to catch the urban poor, from whom most Christians came, who would not be on the normal tax registers. There were also reports of impersonation, the purchasing of immunity, and even bogus torture sessions.182 ‘It is difficult to decide whether these collusive arrangements testify more strongly to the humanity or the venality of the officials concerned’183 – the officials themselves may not have known. In the West, the complete absence of references to libelli certifying sacrifice, in marked contrast to Decius’ persecution, suggests strongly that Constantius I, now Augustus in succession to Maximian, made no effort to enforce the edict, although he made no attempt to check the persecution in the East.184 In his own sphere there continued to be tolerance, even after his death in 306, since his son Constantine, future emperor and future Christian, ruled in Spain, Gaul and Britain, while Maxentius, who controlled Africa and Italy until overthrown by Constantine in 312, was also tolerant. In the Eastern Empire things were different. Diocletian abdicated on 1 May 305.185 Galerius, who became Augustus in his place, with Maximin Daia as his Caesar, embarked on a policy of cutting away the privileges against torture; he allowed torture to be used not only on decurions, but also on all below the rank of senator, officials and landowners described as egregii or perfectissimi, and even in civil as well as criminal cases.186 To use torture on free men, let alone honestiores, in civil cases was quite unheard of, although it was used on slaves (and infamous persons such as gladiators); it is hard to imagine anything more outrageous to the Roman sense of dignity. The use of fetters (compedes, the kind that cleaved to the bones), and crucifixion as a death penalty, were extended to these honestiores. Females of high rank became liable to be sent to the gynaeceum, forced labour in the imperial 180 181 182 183 184 185 186
Eusebius, HE 8.6.10. In mart. Pal. 1.3–4, Eusebius describes the extraordinary lengths to which the authorities went to be able to class a man as having sacrificed. Eusebius, mart. Pal. 3.1. Eusebius, mart. Pal. 4.6 and 8 and 14; cf. Council of Ancyra, c.1. Ste Croix (1954), 100. Ste Croix (1954), 87. Lact. MP 19. D 22.3.7, Paul; 22.5.21.2, Arcadius; PS 5.16.1 and 2. Senators were clarissimi; high officials, who would normally be of senatorial rank, were spectabiles; the holders of the very highest posts, Urban Prefect, Praetorian Prefect, Quaestor of the Sacred Palace, Magister militum, were illustres.
123
A C TA M A R T Y R U M C H R I S T I A N O R U M
weaving and dyeing establishments.187 Eusebius and other historians see this as an attack on the whole social order of the Roman state. Furthermore, it was at this stage of the persecution that, on grounds of humanity, the emperors abandoned the imposition of the death penalty; instead they passed sentences of deliberate mutilation, in particular the gouging out of an eye and the maiming of a foot.188 This strange understanding of the imperial virtue of clemency was part of Galerius’ character, perhaps even of his policy, until his death; it was not restricted to his dealings with the Christians. Agape and her companions Because the effect of the edicts was cumulative, it is not necessarily clear to us, and may even not have been clear to the governor concerned, which edict was the legal authority for the arrest of these or those Christians. In late March 304 a group of young women from Thessalonika were arrested by a stationarius, a beneficiarius called Cassander, for refusing to eat sacrificial food;189 it seems possible that they were a group of consecrated women who had fled to the hills to evade the first edict, for they still had considerable numbers of sacred books and other writings with them, which they had secretly held on to; these were now to be burned.190 They were brought before Dulcitus, the governor, and the charge was read by the commentariensis, in the presence of both Cassander and the defendants. They were questioned on their refusal to sacrifice or eat the sacrificial meat; and persisted in their rejection. One of them, a widow, was pregnant, and so she was remanded to gaol,191 as were four others because of their youth, but two of them, Agape and Chione, were condemned. The governor read from a sheet that he sentenced them to the fire for ‘adhering to the worthless and obsolete worship of the Christians which is hateful to all religious men’.192 The following day Irene, another of the group, was brought before Dulcitus, and after the possession of sacred books had been dealt with, he described her – obscurely – as guilty even before she ran away, so perhaps she was a fugitive slave; hence her punishment was to be prolonged. She was to be placed naked in the town’s brothel, under the supervision of public notaries and of the town’s executioner, and to receive a ration of only one loaf a day; 187 188
189 190 191 192
Lact. MP 21.3–4; cf. 22.5 on lack of due process. Usually the right eye and the left foot (Eusebius, HE 8.12.10). William the Conqueror similarly was to replace the death penalty with mutilation (blinding and castration) in eleventh-century England (Stubbs (1900), 84–85). ACM, Agape et al. 3.1 ACM, Agape et al. 5–6.1. As had been the similarly situated Felicitas (ACM, Perp. 15; D 1.5.18, Ulpian; 48.19.3, Ulpian; PS 1.12.4). ACM, Agape et al. 3–4.
124
A C TA M A R T Y R U M C H R I S T I A N O R U M
he threatened the notaries and the executioner with severe penalties if she were removed.193 There is sufficient evidence of this being seen as appropriate treatment for obstinately virginal Christians;194 moreover, women condemned to the mines were not expected to work with pick and shovel but to service the miners (in ministerium metallicorum).195 However, we are told that Irene’s chastity was not attacked or even insulted, so she was recalled; the governor asked for a sheet of papyrus and wrote on it that since she had refused to sacrifice she was sentenced (like the other two) to be burned alive.196 Some brief accounts: Irenaeus of Sirmium; Phileas of Thmuis; Crispina A bishop who suffered martyrdom in the spring of 304 was Irenaeus of Sirmium, arrested and brought before the governor of Pannonia. He refused to sacrifice and was put to the torture, and locked up in prison for many days, but still refused.197 The governor then condemned him, around midnight, at first simply to be thrown into the river (in fluvium praecipitari), but Irenaeus made an objection, that he had expected many tortures but then to be put to death with the sword, so the governor altered his sentence to beheading, and it was only the dead body which was thrown into the river.198 Irenaeus was in the right, because there were legal restrictions on the ways in which the death penalty could be imposed. Another bishop who died for his faith was Phileas of Thmuis in Egypt. On his fifth appear