Methods
in
Molecular Biology
Series Editor John M. Walker School of Hertfordshire Hatfield, Hertfordshire, AL10 9AB, UK
For other titles published in this series, go to www.springer.com/series/7651
Plant MicroRNAs Methods and Protocols
Edited by
Blake C. Meyers and Pamela J. Green Department of Plant & Soil Sciences, and Delaware Biotechnology Institute, University of Delaware, Newark, DE, USA
Editors Blake C. Meyers Department of Plant & Soil Sciences, and Delaware Biotechnology Institute, University of Delaware, Newark, DE, USA
Pamela J. Green Department of Plant & Soil Sciences, and Delaware Biotechnology Institute, University of Delaware, Newark, DE, USA
ISSN 1064-3745 e-ISSN 1940-6029 ISBN 978-1-60327-004-5 e-ISBN 978-1-60327-005-2 DOI 10.1007/978-1-60327-005-2 Springer New York Dordrecht Heidelberg London Library of Congress Control Number: 2009933463 © Humana Press, a part of Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2010 All rights reserved. This work may not be translated or copied in whole or in part without the written permission of the publisher (Humana Press, c/o Springer Science+Business Media, LLC, 233 Spring Street, New York, NY 10013, USA), except for brief excerpts in connection with reviews or scholarly analysis. Use in connection with any form of information storage and retrieval, electronic adaptation, computer software, or by similar or dissimilar methodology now known or hereafter developed is forbidden. The use in this publication of trade names, trademarks, service marks, and similar terms, even if they are not identified as such, is not to be taken as an expression of opinion as to whether or not they are subject to proprietary rights. While the advice and information in this book are believed to be true and accurate at the date of going to press, neither the authors nor the editors nor the publisher can accept any legal responsibility for any errors or omissions that may be made. The publisher makes no warranty, express or implied, with respect to the material contained herein. Printed on acid-free paper Humana Press is part of Springer Science+Business Media (www.springer.com)
Preface We have assembled a set of protocols that we believe represent the state of the art for laboratory and computational analyses of plant microRNAs (miRNAs). These small, noncoding RNA molecules of about 21 nucleotides have made a grand entrance onto the scientific stage with their discovery in the 1990s and their stunning ascent to stardom in the early years of the current decade. Along the way, it has been demonstrated that miRNAs are simply one of several classes of small RNAs produced in plant cells, albeit a particularly important class given the broad phylogenetic conservation and strong regulatory effects of many miRNAs. Plant miRNAs are uniquely interesting for their ancient evolutionary origins and their strong post-transcriptional regulatory effects. Most chapters of this volume focus on the identification, validation, and characterization of the miRNA class of RNAs. However, a topic that cannot avoid mention is the other classes of small RNAs that are biochemically similar in size and composition (although of somewhat genetically distinct origins). For example, in the cloning and characterization of plant miRNAs, the resulting data set is rich with another significant class of small RNAs, substantially more prevalent in plants than other organisms – the heterochromatic, small, interfering RNAs (heterochromatic siRNAs). As you will see, the methods contained in this volume emphasize miRNA analyses, but include ways to distinguish one class of small RNAs from another. One chapter describes how to characterize candidate members of a unique class of siRNAs (trans-acting siRNAs) that are dependent on the action of miRNAs to initiate their formation. The biogenesis of miRNAs is dependent on an increasingly well-defined set of proteins that include enzymes for the precise excision of the mature miRNA from a longer precursor, as well as the modification of this mature miRNA, export from the nucleus, and interaction with its target. This volume starts with a chapter that clearly lays out the cellular participants in the production of miRNAs and the utility of studying these genes and gene products. Discussions of the genes that encode these proteins are found throughout the volume, as partial or full loss-of-function mutants in these genes are important components in the toolbox for studying miRNAs. One set of chapters describes the standard approaches for purification of the working material for the study of miRNAs: the small RNA component of the transcriptome. While not always easy, depending on the composition and source of the plant tissue that is used, the protocols describe here should cover a broad swath of even the most recalcitrant plant materials, resulting in very high quality RNA that can be used for library construction. An alternative approach described in one of the chapters is the isolation of small RNAs associated with Argonaute proteins. With purified small RNA in hand, one is ready to begin the characterization of small RNAs by any one of numerous experimental approaches, the most common of which is deep sequencing by “next generation” technologies, a process that leads to datasets on the scale of millions of small RNAs per reaction. This volume includes a protocol for the generation of sequencing libraries from purified small RNA. After sequencing, the next significant challenge faced by the experimentalist will be the handling of the data – trimming, mapping, organizing, and analyzing the millions of short sequence reads.
v
vi
Preface
Several chapters describe methods for analyzing miRNA-directed regulation of target RNAs. In its most basic form, the identification of the regulatory targets of plant miRNAs is based on the observation of a near-perfect complementarity between miRNAs and their mRNA targets. This makes computational-based target prediction simpler in plants than in animals. The pairing of miRNAs with an mRNA, in plants, typically results in cleavage of the mRNA target. Such approaches to target prediction in plants are addressed in this volume, as are both standard approaches to validating specific target cleavage events and the exciting development of genome-wide methods to characterize cleaved mRNAs in a single library. This volume includes a series of chapters that discuss approaches to analyzing the functional role of plant miRNAs. This includes computational methods for the prediction of plant miRNA targets and the experimental methods that can supply validation data to support these predictions. Computational methods have also been applied to the study of gene regulatory sequences in promoters, an application that works well to identify promoter elements and potential transcription factor binding motifs in plant miRNA precursors. Regulatory elements contribute to the regulation of expression of miRNAs in response to stresses such as biotic and abiotic stress; under such conditions, miRNAs in turn regulate other transcripts creating variation in both their levels and expression patterns. In situ hybridizations have long been used for the localization of messenger RNAs and proteins, but an exciting recent application of this methodology is the ability to localize miRNAs in plant tissues using a new generation of highly sensitive probes. And when these data have been brought together to infer the function of a miRNA, plants are amenable to an assessment of this predicted function using transient assays. All of these topics are the subjects of chapters in this volume, and we believe that these will provide valuable contributions and useful material for our readers’ experimental work. Interestingly, studies of the biology of plant miRNAs have been somewhat turned on their head with the realization that miRNAs can also be used as tools themselves for the study of the biological function of other genes. A chapter in this volume describes the development of artificial miRNAs, a powerful tool for the investigation of gene function with current applications in both forward and reverse genetics experiments. While most of the initial studies and basic approaches have been developed in Arabidopsis, many exciting advances are sure to come from the application of these and other methods to other plant species. Indeed, our goal in editing this book is to provide the community with a set of protocols that will help advance miRNA research for all plant species. To this end, all or nearly all of the protocols could be used for any plant species of interest. We have included several chapters that will be of particular interest to plant biologists working in non-model species, including a set of approaches for RNA purification from quite diverse species and tissues, as well as an overview of computational methods to handle data from a broad set of species. MicroRNA activities and stability are dependent on a series of modifications and processing. One of the most well-characterized modifications is 3′ methylation, an activity carried out by the HUA ENHANCER 1 methyltransferase, which may stabilize the miRNA by preventing uridylation and by diminishing exonuclease-mediated degradation. One chapter in this volume describes the methods by which 3′ methylation can be assessed. Surely there are many additional advances yet to come in this field, contributing new methods in parallel to making additional strides in our understanding of the biology of small RNAs. As an example, a collaborative effort of many of the labs that contributed to this volume led to an overhaul of the criteria used to define plant miRNAs (1). That manuscript
Preface
vii
came out too late to be fully reflected in this volume, and other rapid changes in the field will keep this as one of the fastest moving fields in plant biology. Much as deep sequencing represented a tremendous advance, dare we say a revolution in the study of small RNAs, there are unquestionably greater things yet to come in the methods for the analysis of plant miRNAs. This may include further advances in understanding the cell specificity, abundance levels, trafficking, modifications, target interactions, or biological roles. In summary, we are excited by the prospect of the experiments that this volume may facilitate or even inspire. As students (broadly speaking), practitioners, or theorists in the field of plant molecular biology, we hope that you will find many or all of these chapters to be of use in your work. The chapters may serve to introduce you to a new field of work, or extend your capabilities in a topic in which you are already quite familiar. While a mastery of the techniques in this volume is not a requisite for success in the field of small RNAs, an incredible group of contributors has contributed a set of protocols. Finally, this book would not have come to fruition without the careful editorial and administrative assistance of Sharon Bancroft, along with additional administrative help by Charlotte McDermitt and Kathy Fleischut. Most of all, we are incredibly grateful to the contributing groups who have taken their time to describe in exquisite detail the methods, tips, and tricks that they use. We hope that you find this unique collection of protocols helpful to your research. Blake C. Meyers Pamela J. Green Newark, DE Reference 1. Meyers BC, Axtell MJ, Bartel B, Bartel DP, Baulcombe D, Bowman JL, Cao X, Carrington JC, Chen X, Green PJ, Griffiths-Jones S, Jacobsen SE, Mallory AC, Martienssen RA, Poethig RS, Qi Y, Vaucheret H, Voinnet O, Watanabe Y, Weigel D, Zhu JK (2008) Criteria for annotation of plant microRNAs. Plant Cell 20:3186–3190
Contents Preface . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Contributors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
v xi
1 Piecing the Puzzle Together: Genetic Requirements for miRNA Biogenesis in Arabidopsis thaliana . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Zhixin Xie
1
2 Prediction of Plant miRNA Genes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Matthew W. Jones-Rhoades 3 Methods for Isolation of Total RNA to Recover miRNAs and Other Small RNAs from Diverse Species . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Monica Accerbi, Skye A. Schmidt, Emanuele De Paoli, Sunhee Park, Dong-Hoon Jeong, and Pamela J. Green
19
31
4 miRNA Target Prediction in Plants . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Noah Fahlgren and James C. Carrington
51
5 A Method to Discover Phased siRNA Loci . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Michael J. Axtell
59
6 Directed Gene Silencing with Artificial MicroRNAs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Rebecca Schwab, Stephan Ossowski, Norman Warthmann, and Detlef Weigel
71
7 Bioinformatics Analysis of Small RNAs in Plants Using Next Generation Sequencing Technologies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Kan Nobuta, Kevin McCormick, Mayumi Nakano, and Blake C. Meyers
89
8 High-Throughput Approaches for miRNA Expression Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 107 Cheng Lu and Frédéric Souret 9 In Situ Detection of miRNAs Using LNA Probes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 127 Zoltán Havelda 10 Analysis of miRNA Modifications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 137 Bin Yu and Xuemei Chen 11 MicroRNA Promoter Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 149 Molly Megraw and Artemis G. Hatzigeorgiou 12 Computational Methods for Comparative Analysis of Plant Small RNAs . . . . . . . 163 Gayathri Mahalingam and Blake C. Meyers 13 Biotic Stress-Associated microRNAs: Identification, Detection, Regulation, and Functional Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 183 Florence Jay, Jean-Pierre Renou, Olivier Voinnet, and Lionel Navarro
ix
x
Contents
14 Abiotic Stress-Associated miRNAs: Detection and Functional Analysis . . . . . . . . . 203 Dong-Hoon Jeong, Marcelo A. German, Linda A. Rymarquis, Shawn R. Thatcher, and Pamela J. Green 15 Processing of miRNA Precursors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 231 Yukio Kurihara and Yuichiro Watanabe 16 Purification of Arabidopsis Argonaute Complexes and Associated Small RNAs . . . 243 Yijun Qi and Shijun Mi 17 Transient Assays for the Analysis of miRNA Processing and Function . . . . . . . . . . 255 Felipe F. de Felippes and Detlef Weigel Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 265
Contributors Monica Accerbi • Delaware Biotechnology Institute, University of Delaware, Newark, DE, USA Michael J. Axtell • Department of Biology, Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA, USA James C. Carrington • Department of Botany and Plant Pathology, Center for Genome Research and Biocomputing, Oregon State University, Corvallis, OR, USA Xuemei Chen • Department of Botany and Plant Sciences, Institute of Integrative Genome Biology, University of California, Riverside, Riverside, CA, USA Felipe F. de Felippes • Max Planck Institute for Developmental Biology, Tübingen, Germany Emanuele De Paoli • Delaware Biotechnology Institute, University of Delaware, Newark, DE, USA Noah Fahlgren • Department of Botany and Plant Pathology, Center for Genome Research and Biocomputing, and Molecular and Cellular Biology Graduate Program, Oregon State University, Corvallis, OR, USA Marcelo A. German • Delaware Biotechnology Institute, University of Delaware, Newark, DE, USA Pamela J. Green • Department of Plant and Soil Sciences, School of Marine Science and Policy, and Delaware Biotechnology Institute, University of Delaware, Newark, DE, USA Artemis G. Hatzigeorgiou • Department of Genetics, Center for Bioinformatics, School of Medicine, Department of Computer and Information Science, School of Engineering, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, USA Institute of Molecular Oncology, Biomedical Sciences Research Center “Alexander Fleming”, Vari-Athens, Greece Zoltán Havelda • Agricultural Biotechnology Center, Gödöllo˝, Hungary Florence Jay • Institut de Biologie Moléculaire des Plantes, CNRS UPR2353 – Université Louis Pasteur, Strasbourg Cedex, France Dong-Hoon Jeong • Delaware Biotechnology Institute, University of Delaware, Newark, DE, USA Matthew W. Jones-Rhoades • Department of Biology, Knox College, Galesburg, IL, USA Yukio Kurihara • Department of Life Sciences, University of Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan Cheng Lu • DuPont Agricultural Biotechnology, RT 141 & Henry Clay, Wilmington, DE, USA Gayathri Mahalingam • Delaware Biotechnology Institute, University of Delaware, Newark, DE, USA Kevin McCormick • Delaware Biotechnology Institute, University of Delaware, Newark, DE, USA
xi
xii
Contributors
Molly Megraw • Department of Genetics, Center for Bioinformatics, School of Medicine, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, USA, Institute for Genome Sciences & Policy, Duke University, Durham, NC, USA Blake C. Meyers • Department of Plant and Soil Sciences, and Delaware Biotechnology Institute, University of Delaware, Newark, DE, USA Shijun Mi • National Institute of Biological Sciences, Beijing, China Mayumi Nakano • Delaware Biotechnology Institute, University of Delaware, Newark, DE, USA Lionel Navarro • Institut de Biologie Moléculaire des Plantes, CNRS UPR2353 – Université Louis Pasteur, Strasbourg Cedex, France Kan Nobuta • Delaware Biotechnology Institute, University of Delaware, Newark, DE, USA Stephan Ossowski • Department of Molecular Biology, Max Planck Institute for Developmental Biology, Tübingen, Germany Sunhee Park • Delaware Biotechnology Institute, University of Delaware, Newark, DE, USA Yijun Qi • National Institute of Biological Sciences, Beijing, China Jean-Pierre Renou • UMR Génomique Végétale INRA-CNRS-UEVE, 2 rue G.Crémieux, Evry, France Linda A. Rymarquis • Delaware Biotechnology Institute, University of Delaware, Newark, DE, USA Skye A. Schmidt • School of Marine Science and Policy and Delaware Biotechnology Institute, University of Delaware, Newark, DE, USA Rebecca Schwab • Institut de Biologie Moléculaire des Plantes (CNRS), Strasbourg Cedex, France FrÉdÉric Souret • Affymetrix Inc., Cleveland, OH, USA Shawn R. Thatcher • Chemistry–Biology Interface Program, Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, and Delaware Biotechnology Institute, University of Delaware, Newark, DE, USA Olivier Voinnet • Institut de Biologie Moléculaire des plantes, CNRS UPR2353–Université Louis Pasteur, Strasbourg Cedex, France Norman Warthmann • Department of Molecular Biology, Max Planck Institute for Developmental Biology, Tübingen, Germany Yuichiro Watanabe • Department of Life Sciences, University of Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan Detlef Weigel • Department of Molecular Biology, Max Planck Institute for Developmental Biology, Tübingen, Germany Zhixin Xie • Department of Biological Sciences, Texas Tech University, Lubbock, TX, USA Bin Yu • Department of Botany and Plant Sciences, Institute of Integrative Genome Biology, University of California, Riverside, Riverside, CA, USA, Center for Plant Science Innovation, University of Nebraska, Lincoln, NE, USA
Chapter 1 Piecing the Puzzle Together: Genetic Requirements for miRNA Biogenesis in Arabidopsis thaliana Zhixin Xie Abstract MicroRNAs (miRNAs) are an important class of endogenous small silencing RNAs in both plants and animals. They regulate the expression of a wide range of target genes that are involved in many important biological processes. Biogenesis of plant miRNAs requires a distinct set of proteins, including members that belong to several highly conserved RNA silencing protein families. The framework for miRNA biogenesis in plants was revealed through genetic and biochemical analyses using mutants that are defective in miRNA accumulation. These general miRNA-deficient mutants constitute a set of invaluable genetic resources for the plant miRNA research community. They could be utilized to experimentally validate the candidate miRNAs that are either predicted by a computational program or recovered from a small RNA deep sequencing effort which is becoming a more affordable and widely used approach for small RNA discovery. Starting with a brief introduction on multiple small RNA pathways in plants, this chapter provides basic experimental procedures for the examination of miRNA accumulation from wild type plants and various mutant lines in Arabidopsis. Key words: miRNA biogenesis, Arabidopsis thaliana, miRNA-deficient mutants, DICER-LIKE1 (DCL1), HUA ENHANCER1 (HEN1), ARGONAUTE1(AGO1), HYPONASTIC LEAVES1 (HYL1), SERRATE (SE), HASTY(HST), miRNA detection
1. Introduction Nearly 7 years have passed since microRNAs (miRNAs) and other endogenous small silencing RNAs were discovered in plants (1–4), shortly after the seminal discovery of silencing-associated small RNAs in plants (5), and the cloning of miRNAs from animals (6–8). Much has been learned about the genomic origin, complexity, biogenesis pathway, biological function, and possible mechanisms of evolution for these small regulatory RNA molecules (reviewed B.C. Meyers and P.J. Green (eds.), Plant MicroRNAs, Methods in Molecular Biology, vol. 592 DOI 10.1007/978-1-60327-005-2_1, © Humana Press, a part of Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2010
1
2
Xie
in (9–12). This chapter will describe the reverse genetics approach and the related experimental procedures that have been used to elucidate the miRNA biogenesis pathway in the model plant Arabidopsis thaliana. Essentially, a generic miRNA pathway gene could be established if the loss-of-function mutation leads to the loss of miRNA production, and therefore to the loss of miRNA accumulation. This approach should also be applicable to other plant species as long as the required genomic and genetic resources are available. The method can be applied to experimentally validate the candidate miRNAs that are either predicted by a computational program or recovered from a small RNA deep sequencing effort which is becoming a more affordable and widely used approach for miRNA discovery (13–17). Since the targeted audience of these methods series are those who are either new to miRNA research or less familiar with the recent development of the field. This chapter will begin with a brief overview of the multiple small RNA pathways in plants. Detailed protocols will follow for polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-based mutant genotyping as well as miRNA detection by northern blot assays. 1.1. The RNA Silencing Machinery in Plants
The generation of small RNAs of 21–24-nucleotides (nt) is a hallmark of RNA silencing, which involves a set of evolutionarily conserved proteins that are found exclusively in eukaryotes (10). The proteins that belong to the families of DICER (DCR) or DICER-LIKE (DCL), ARGONAUTE (AGO), and RNADEPENDENT RNA POLYMERASE (RDR) form the core RNA silencing machinery in plants (9, 10). Both the DCR/DCL and the AGO family proteins are highly conserved across the eukaryotic kingdoms while the RDR family proteins appear to be missing in mammals and insects. Perhaps one of the most remarkable features of the RNA silencing system in plants is the existence of multiple RNA silencing factors that form functionally distinct modules for small RNA generation and function (10, 18). The A. thaliana genome, for example, contains four expressed DCL genes, six RDR genes, and ten AGO genes (9). It has become clear that the high complexity of the regulatory small RNA component in plants is largely attributable to the proliferation and subsequent functional diversification of the RNA silencing machinery on an evolutionary time scale.
1.2. miRNAs and Other Small RNAs in Plants
Although chemically similar, the small silencing RNAs in plants can be classified into two broad categories: miRNAs and small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) (10). The major difference between these two categories lies in their genomic origin and precursor structures. miRNAs arise from defined genetic loci – the MIRNA genes, which are found predominantly within genomic segments previously annotated as intergenic regions (IGRs) (11).
Piecing the Puzzle Together
3
Typically, RNA polymerase II (Pol II) transcription from a MIRNA locus gives rise to a miRNA primary transcript (pri-miRNA) that is capable of forming a characteristic fold-back hairpin structure (19–21). This intra-molecular, imperfect dsRNA structure is recognized and processed by a DCL1-containing complex to give rise to a miRNA/miRNA* duplex, presumably through a multi-step process involving a stem-loop intermediate (pre-miRNA) (19, 22– 24). The fate of each strand in a miRNA/miRNA* duplex, appears to be predetermined by the thermodynamic features of the duplex (25, 26). That is, the miRNA strand is selectively incorporated into an AGO1-containing, RNA-induced silencing complex (RISC) upon unwinding, whereas the miRNA* strand is often short-lived (27–29). Mature plant miRNAs are typically 21-nt in size. They negatively regulate gene expression by guiding target recognition and cleavage through the AGO1-containing miRISC (11). SiRNAs, on the other hand, arise from perfect dsRNA precursors that are formed through various mechanisms, typically involving an RDR activity. The dsRNA precursors are processed into small RNA duplexes by one of the other three DCLs (DCL2, DCL3, or DCL4). Genetic and small RNA deep sequencing analyses have revealed at least three siRNA-generating systems in Arabidopsis, each requiring a distinct set of DCL and RDR proteins (10, 12). (1) Heterochromatin-associated siRNAs: These are typically 24-nt small RNAs associated with genomic repetitive sequences such as transposable elements and pericentromeric repeats (30, 31). Biogenesis and function of these siRNAs require RDR2, DCL3, AGO4, and the plant-specific nuclear RNA polymerase IV (Pol IV) (30–36). The heterochromatin-associated siRNA pathway operates in the nucleus to guide heterochromatin formation (37, 38). (2) Trans-acting siRNAs (ta-siRNAs): Biogenesis of ta-siRNAs is initiated by miRNA-directed cleavage of noncoding RNAs known as TAS primary transcripts (39, 40). RDR6 converts the cleaved TAS RNA into dsRNA, a process that also requires SUPPRESSOR OF GENE SILENCING 3 (SGS3), a coiled-coil protein with unknown function (41, 42). DCL4 processes the dsRNA into phased 21-nt siRNA arrays (43–45). (3) Natural antisense transcript-associated siRNAs (nat-siRNAs): These are siRNAs originating from dsRNAs formed by convergent transcription of two partially overlapping genes (46, 47). The biogenesis of the primary nat-siRNAs appears to be either DCL1- or DCL2-dependent. Both the ta-siRNAs and nat-siRNAs can direct target cleavage. All classes of functional small RNAs characterized so far in plants are 3¢-methylated through the activity of HUA ENHANCER 1 (HEN1), a small RNA methylase (48, 49). The methylation may serve to stabilize small RNAs in vivo by protecting them from nucleolytic activity or other types of terminal modifications (48–50).
4
Xie
1.3. Genetic Requirements for miRNA Biogenesis
Our current knowledge on miRNA biogenesis came mainly from work performed with various miRNA-deficient mutants, a collective effort made by several leading groups. As mentioned earlier, almost all the known miRNA pathway components in plants were identified through this “reverse genetics” approach. DCL1 and HEN1 were among the first genes whose roles in miRNA biogenesis were genetically established (3, 4, 51). Both the dcl1 and the hen1 homozygous mutant plants exhibited severe developmental defects, reflecting the critical roles played by miRNAs in plant development. In fact, multiple dcl1 and hen1 alleles were recovered from genetic screens for mutants that are defective in flower development (51–55). Loss-of-function mutations in AGO1 also cause severe developmental defects (56–59). Similarly, pleiotropic developmental abnormalities have also been observed in mutants harboring loss-of-function mutations in HYPONASTIC LEAVES1 (HYL1) and SERRATE (SE), two proteins required for miRNA processing (23, 24, 60–63). HYL1 belongs to a family of nuclear dsRNA-binding proteins. While HYL1 specifically interacts with DCL1 (64), the DOUBLE-STRANDED RNA-BINDING PROTEIN 4 (DRB4), another member of the HYL1/DRB family appears to interact with DCL4 and function in the ta-siRNA pathway (65, 66), suggesting that members of this family may play distinct roles in plant small RNA biogenesis. SE, a zinc-finger protein, is known to regulate shoot meristem function and leaf polarity in Arabidopsis (62). Recent in vivo evidence shows that DCL1, HYL1, and SE colocalize in nuclear dicing bodies and function in pri-miRNA processing (22, 67). HASTY (HST), an Arabidopsis ortholog of the mammalian Exportin 5, is another protein that has been shown to play a role in plant miRNA biogenesis (39, 68–70). In wild type Arabidopsis, a majority of mature miRNAs accumulate in the cytoplasm. Loss-of-function mutations in HST reduced the accumulation of most miRNAs in the cytoplasm, suggesting its role in miRNA transport from the nucleus to the cytoplasm (69, 70). Information on some published miRNAdeficient mutant alleles is presented in Table 1. Among the miRNA-deficient mutants described above, the dcl1 and the hen1 mutants have been by far the most widely used lines in experimentally validating new miRNAs, although HEN1 also functions in siRNA biogenesis (31, 71). When working with these mutant lines, one potential problem could be the poor seed productivity of the homozygous mutants. Although in most cases a sufficient amount of seeds could still be obtained by propagating the homozygous individuals, there are cases where maintenance through the heterozygous individual is necessary. Homozygous mutants harboring either the dcl1-7 or the dcl1-9 allele (51), for example, often fail to produce any viable seeds. For this reason, a
Locus ID At1g01040 At4g20910
At1g48410
At1g09700 At3g05040 At2g27100
Gene name
DICER-LIKE 1(DCL 1)
HUA ENHANCER1(HEN1)
ARGONAUTE1
HYPONASTIC LEAVES1 (HYL1)
HASTY (HST)
SERRATE (SE)
X-rays T-DNA T-DNA
T-DNA
se-4 (SALK_059424)
Dipoxybutane T-DNA
Col-0
Col-1 Col-3 Col-0
Col-0 Col-0
(62, 63) (62) (62) (63)
(68–70) (39)
(23, 60) (24)
(56) (56) (24, 28, 56) (28, 59) (57) (58) (27) Col-0 Ws Col-0 La-er Col-0 Col-0 Col-0
T-DNA T-DNA EMS Transposon insertion EMS EMS T-DNA
La-er Col-0
(3, 52) (71) (24) (64) La-er Col-0 Col-0 Col-0
EMS EMS T-DNA T-DNA
Transposon insertion T-DNA
(51, 53) (4, 51, 54)
References
La-er La-er
Background
EMS T-DNA
Type of mutation
se-1 se-2 (SAIL_44_G12) se-3 (SALK_083196)
hst-1 hst-15 (SALK_079290)
hyl1-1 hyl1-2 (SALK_064863)
ago1-1 ago1-2 ago1-3 ago1-11and ago1-12 ago1-22 to ago1-24 ago1-25 to ago1-27 ago1-36 (SALK_087076)
hen1-1 hen1-4 hen1-5 (SALK_049197) hen1-6 (SALK_090960)
dcl1-7 dcl1-9
Representative alleles
Table 1 Selected miRNA-deficient mutants in Arabidopsis thaliana
Piecing the Puzzle Together 5
6
Xie
protocol for quick genomic DNA extraction and PCR-based genotyping is included in this chapter, taking the dcl1-7 allele (a point mutation) as an example. For genotyping of T-DNA insertion lines using allele-specific PCR, the readers are directed to a recently published protocol (72).
2. Materials 2.1. Mutant Genotyping
1. dcl1-7 seeds: available for ordering (stock number CS3089 for La-er background and CS6953 for Col-0 background) through the Arabidopsis Biological Resource Center (ABRC) or the Nottingham Arabidopsis Stock Center (NASC). The dcl1-7 allele harbors a single base change (a C to T substitution) at the position 1,429 from the ATG in the genomic DNA, resulting in a missense mutation (P415S) in the DCL1 protein (51, 53). 2. 0.1% agarose in distilled water. Sterilize and store at 4°C. 3. Genomic DNA extraction buffer: 50 mM Tris-Cl, pH 8.0, 10 mM EDTA, pH 8.0, 100 mM NaCl, 1.0% SDS, and 10 mM b-mercaptoethanol (add fresh right before use). 4. Neutralization buffer: 3 M potassium acetate, pH 4.8. 5. Isopropanol. 6. 70% ethanol. Store at −20°C. 7. 1X TE buffer: 10 mM Tris-Cl, pH 7.6, 1 mM EDTA. 8. 10X PCR buffer: 500 mM KCl, 100 mM Tris-Cl, pH 9.0, 1.0% Triton X-100, and 15 mM MgCl2. 9. dNTPs: 2.5 mM each. Store at −20°C. 10. Taq DNA polymerase. Store at −20°C. 11. Custom DNA oligonucleotides: 10 mM. Store at −20°C. For dcl1-7 genotyping: (1) Mlu I-DCL1_1219F (24mer): 5¢-GCCATCTTTGGAATGACTGACGCG-3¢ (2) DCL1_1302R (24mer): 5¢-GAGGTTACGTATCTTTATCGCACA-3¢. 12. Metaphor agarose. 13. DNA size markers: 25 or 50 bp DNA ladder (e.g., Promega catalog number G4511 and G4521, respectively). Store at −20°C. 14. 4X DNA sample loading buffer: 50% glycerol, 0.03% bromophenol blue, 50 mM Tris-Cl, pH 7.7; and 5 mM EDTA. 15. Ethidium bromide: 2 mg/mL. Wrap the bottle with aluminum foil. 16. Mlu I: 10 U/µL. Store at −20°C.
2.2. miRNA Detection by Northern Blot Assay
Piecing the Puzzle Together
7
1. 10% SDS. 2. 95% ethanol. 3. DEPC-treated water. 4. 10X TBE buffer: 900 mM Tris-borate, 20 mM EDTA, pH 8.0. 5. 30% polyacrylamide stock: acrylamide:bis acrylamide = 37.5:1. Wrap the bottle with aluminum foil and store at 4°C. 6. Urea: DNase-, RNase-, and protease-free. 7. 2% agar. 8. TEMED. Store at 4°C. 9. 10% ammonium persulfate: Make fresh. May be kept at 4°C up to 1 month. 10. 4X RNA sample loading buffer: 50% glycerol, 0.03% bromophenol blue, 50 mM Tris-Cl, pH 7.7, and 5 mM EDTA in DEPC-treated water. 11. RNA size markers (21- and 24-nt): 100 µM each. Store at −80°C. 12. Ethidium bromide stock: 2 mg/mL. Wrap the bottle with aluminum foil. 13. PerfectHyb Plus buffer: Sigma, catalog number H7033-1 L. 14. T4 Polynucleotide kinase (PNK): 10 U/µL. 15. 20X SSC: 3 M sodium chloride, 0.3 M sodium citrate, pH 7.0. 16. Custom DNA oligonucleotides for use as radiolabeled probes: 10 µM. 17. ATP (g-32P):~6,000 Ci/mmol, 10 mCi/ml.
3. Methods 3.1. Genotyping for the dcl1-7 Allele 3.1.1. Grow the Mutant Plants
1. Prepare seeds for both the mutant line and the wild type (La-er or Col-0, see Subheading 2.1, item 1) control by immersing the seeds in ~10 ml of 0.1% agarose suspension in 14 ml snap-top tubes. Store the tubes at 4°C for 2 to 3 overnights. 2. Fill a set of 3-inch pots with commercial soil mix (e.g., SunGrow Loose Mix #1; BWI catalog number WPLC1). Completely wet the soil mix with deionized water. Move the pots into a flat with holes at the bottom. If a growth chamber is being used to grow the plants, sit the flat in a second flat with the same dimensions but with no holes at the bottom.
8
Xie
3. Using a P1000 pipetter attached to a wide-bored tip, plant 5–10 mutant seeds in each pot. Make an effort during planting to ensure that the seeds are evenly distributed over the surface to facilitate the subsequent thinning. The number of pots being planted will depend on the experimental needs. To identify heterozygous individuals for seeds propagation, 20 pots will yield an adequate number of the desired genotype. 4. Plant the wild type control in the same way, except that 3–5 seeds may be planted at the center of the pots. 5. Cover each flat with a matching plastic dome to maintain the humidity. Move the flats to a growth chamber or a greenhouse room. A setting with 16 h light (24°C)/8 h dark (22°C) should work fine. 6. Remove the dome shortly after germination. 7. When the seedlings are big enough to allow differentiation between the wild type phenotype and the homozygous mutant phenotypes, thin the seedlings in the mutant flat down to 3–4 wild type-looking plants per pots. Two to three weeks after planting are usually required before the homozygous mutant phenotype can be reliably recognized. 3.1.2. Genomic DNA Extraction
1. From each individual plant to be genotyped, collect 2–3 rosette leaves or flower clusters in a microcentrifuge tube. Samples from the wild type and homozygous mutant plants should also be collected to serve as controls. 2. Add 375 mL of extraction buffer to each tube. 3. Using a plastic Pellet Pestle (VWR; catalog number KT749521-1500) attached to a power drill, homogenize the tissue by several short grindings. 4. Add another 375 mL of extraction buffer to each tube. Mix by brief vortex. 5. Heat the sample tubes in a 65°C water bath for 10 min. 6. Add 150 mL of neutralization buffer and mix. Incubate the tubes on ice for 20 min. 7. Pellet the cell debris by spinning at 14 k rpm for 5 min on a bench top microcentrifuge. 8. Transfer ~700 mL of the aqueous phase into a fresh tube. Add an equal volume of isopropanol and mix. 9. Centrifuge at 14 k rpm for 2 min to pellet the DNA. 10. Carefully pour off the supernatant and wash the pellet with 500 mL of ice-cold 70% ethanol by centrifuge at 14 k rpm for 2 min. 11. Air-dry the pellet by sitting the tubes upside down on a test tube rack for about 15 min. 12. Resuspend the pellet in 30 ~ 50 mL of 1X TE. Store at 4°C.
3.1.3. PCR and Restriction Analysis
Piecing the Puzzle Together
9
The derived cleaved amplified polymorphic sequence (dCAPS) method that is widely used for PCR-based detection of single nucleotide polymorphisms in plants (73) is adopted to detect the dcl1-7 mutation. Briefly, mismatches are introduced into one of the two DCL1-specific primers (Mlu I-DCL1_1219F) such that a Mlu I site is created if the flanking nucleotide is a “T” (in the mutant allele) instead of a “C” (in the wild type allele). Upon Mlu I digestion, the non-cleavable PCR fragments and the Mlu I-cleaved PCR fragments could be resolved by electrophoresis on a 4% metaphor agarose gel. 1. Assemble 25 mL PCR reactions in 200 mL tubes by mixing the following components: –– 10X PCR buffer 2.5 mL –– 2.5 mM dNTPs 2.0 mL –– Primer 1(Mlu I-DCL1_1219F; 10 mM) 1.0 mL –– Primer 2 (DCL1_1302R; 10 mM) 1.0 mL –– Distilled water
16.5 mL
–– Taq DNA polymerase (1 U/mL) 1.0 mL –– Genomic DNA 1.0 mL 2. Run PCR for 25 cycles using the following program: –– Initial denaturation at 96°C for 1 min –– Denaturation at 95°C for 1 min –– Annealing at 58°C for 45 s –– Extension at 72°C for 20 s –– Repeat the cycle 24 more times –– Final extension at 72°C for 5 min –– Hold at 4°C 3. Prepare a 4% metaphor agarose gel. Run a 3–5 mL PCR reaction to confirm successful amplification. A 25 or 50 bp DNA ladder should also be loaded to serve as size markers. A successful amplification should yield a DNA fragment of approximately160 bp in length (Fig. 1a). 4. Digest the PCR products with Mlu I in 20 mL reactions by mixing the following components in microcentrifuge tubes, and incubate in a 37°C water bath for 1 h. –– 10X Reaction buffer 2.0 mL –– Distilled water 7.7 mL –– PCR products 10.0 mL –– Mlu I (10 U/mL) 0.3 mL 5. Prepare a second 4% metaphor agarose gel. Analyze 5–8 mL of the digested PCR reaction on the gel. Mlu I will cut a 20 bpfragment off from the PCR products amplified from the
10
Xie
a
M(bp) 200 175 150 100 75 50 1
b
2
3
4
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
M(bp) 200 175 150 100 75 1
2
5
18
19
Fig. 1. Genotyping of Arabidopsis dcl1-7 mutant using the dCAPS method. (a) The 162 bp DNA fragments amplified from genomic DNA prepared from individual dcl1-7 mutant plants (lanes 3 ~ 9 and 11~17), a wild type control (lane 18), and a homozygous mutant plant (lane 2) were analyzed on a 4% metaphor agarose gel. (b) The same set of PCR products was analyzed on a 4% metaphor agarose gel after digestion with MluI. Notice that lanes 3, 4, 6, 7, and 8 represent the PCR products amplified from heterozygous dcl1-7 mutant plants while lane 5 represents a segregating wild type. A 25 bp DNA ladder (lanes 1, 10, and 19) was used as a size marker on both gels.
mutant, but not the wild type allele. Samples derived from heterozygous mutant plants are therefore expected to display a doublet consisting of a ~140 bp band and a ~160 bp band, respectively, while samples derived from the wild type plant or a homozygous mutant plant shall display a single band of ~160 and ~140 bp in length, respectively (Fig. 1b). 3.2. Detection of miRNAs by Northern Blot Analysis
1. Clean a set of glass plates, spacers, and comb with 10% SDS. Rinse thoroughly with deionized water. Wipe clean with 95% ethanol for quick drying.
3.2.1. Resolve Total RNA by Denaturing Polyacrylamide Gel Electrophoresis (PAGE)
2. Prepare 17% polyacrylamide gel with 7 M urea in 0.5X TBE by mixing the following components in a clean 250 ml Erlenmeyer flask: –– DEPC-treated water 2.0 ml –– 10X TBE 1.5 ml –– 30% polyacrylamide stock 17.0 ml –– Urea 12.6 g 3. Mix the contents by slowly swirling the flask a few times and incubate in a 37°C water bath to dissolve the urea.
Piecing the Puzzle Together
11
4. Assemble the pre-cleaned plates and spacers using a set of 6–8 binder clips. Seal the plates with a thin layer of 2% agar. 5. When the urea is completely dissolved, add 15 µL of TEMED and 125 µL of freshly made 10% ammonium persulfate. Mix the contents immediately by swirling the flask a few times. Cast the gel and insert the comb immediately. Allow the gel to polymerize for at least 30 min. 6. When the gel is fully polymerized, pull the comb out slowly and very carefully to avoid broken wells. Rinse out the wells with 0.5X TBE using a 10 ml syringe with a needle attached. 7. Assemble the electrophoresis apparatus and pre-run the gel at 180 V in 0.5X TBE buffer for at least 20 min. Rinse out the wells again right before loading the samples. 8. Prepare the RNA samples by mixing 5–20 µg of total RNA (see Note 1) with the 4X RNA sample loading buffer in microcentrifuge tubes. Keep the final sample volume below 25 µL for best resolution. 9. Prepare the RNA size markers (see Note 2) in the same way as for sample preparation. 10. Heat the samples at 65°C for 5 min and immediately cool on ice for 2 min. Spin briefly to collect the sample in the bottom of the tube. 11. Load the samples and size markers with gel loading tips so that the samples form a flat band at the very bottom of the well. 12. Run the gel at 180 V in 0.5X TBE buffer until the bromophenol blue dye reaches the bottom of the gel. 3.2.2. Transfer RNA from the Polyacrylamide Gel to Nylon Membrane
1. Disassemble the electrophoresis apparatus and carefully separate the gel slab from the glass plates. Cut off a small triangle from the upper-right corner of the gel to mark the orientation. Stain the gel in 0.5X TBE containing ethidium bromide for 3–5 min. 2. Get the Bio-Rad semi-dry transfer unit ready for later use. Presoak one piece of nylon membrane (see Note 3) and two pieces of Bio-Rad extra-thick blot paper in 0.5X TBE. 3. Destain the gel briefly in 0.5X TBE to remove the excessive ethidium bromide on the gel surface. 4. Lay a fresh piece of plastic wrap over the UV transilluminator of a gel imager. Lay the gel on the plastic wrap. Take a picture of the entire gel under UV. The 5 S rRNA and tRNAs will show up as bright bands near the top of the gel. The RNA size markers should also be visible.
12
Xie
5. Assemble the gel transfer sandwich on the Bio-Rad semi-dry transfer unit. The order should be (from the bottom to top): extra-thick blot paper, nylon membrane, the gel, the second piece of extra-thick blot paper, and the cathode plate. Cut off a small triangle from the upper-right corner of the membrane to mark the orientation. Remove air bubbles that may have been trapped between the gel and the membrane. This can be done by carefully lifting one side of the gel, and then slowly laying it back onto the membrane. 6. Transfer for 1 h under constant current (400 mAmps). 7. Disassemble the gel transfer sandwich. Air-dry the membrane on a piece of clean Whatman paper. 8. Check the gel under UV to confirm a successful transfer. 9. Crosslink the membrane twice in a UV crosslinker under the “auto” setting. 10. Under a portable UV light, mark the position of the RNA size markers on the membrane with a pencil. 3.2.3. Probing the Membrane with RadioLabeled Oligonucleotide Probe
1. Place the membrane in a hybridization bottle, with the sample side facing the center of the bottle. Prehybridize the membrane in 5 ml PerfectHyb Plus buffer (Sigma) at 38°C for 30 min or longer with rotation at a slow mode. 2. End-label an oligonucleotide probe using T4 PNK (see Note 4). Assemble the following labeling reaction in a microcentrifuge tube: –– Distilled water 15.5 µL –– 10X PNK buffer 2.5 µL –– DNA oligonucleotide (10 µM; see Note 5) 1.0 µL –– ATP (g-32P) (~6,000 Ci/mmol; 10 mCi/ml) 5.0 µL –– T4 PNK (10 U/µL) 1.0 µL 3. Incubate the tube at 37°C for 30 min. Inactivate the kinase by incubating at 65°C for 10 min. 4. Purify the probe by passing the reaction through a Bio-Rad P6 spin column to remove the unincorporated ATP (g-32P) (see Note 6). 5. Heat the purified probe to 70ºC for 2 min, then cool on ice for 2 min. Add the probe to the prehybridization buffer. Allow the hybridization to continue overnight (8 ~ 12 h) at 38°C with rotation at a slow mode. 6. Pour off the hybridization buffer into a radioactive liquid waste container. Wash the membrane at 50ºC with rotation at fast mode with preheated buffers: (1) once with 2X SSC, 0.2% SDS for 20 min; (2) once with 1X SSC, 0.1% SDS for 20 min; (3) once with 0.5X SSC, 0.1% SDS for 20 min; (4) once with 0.1X SSC, 0.1% SDS at 50°C for 20 min.
Piecing the Puzzle Together
13
7. Wrap the membrane with plastic wrap. 8. Expose the membrane to X-ray film in an autoradiograph cassette at −80°C with two intensifying screens (see Note 7). Tape the wrapped membrane onto the bottom piece of the intensifying screen to facilitate the alignment between the membrane and the film afterwards. Mark the orientation of the film by cutting off a small triangle from the upper-right corner. The optimal exposure time may vary from a few hours to several overnights, depending on the abundance of the target miRNA as well as the type of the probe.
4. Notes 1. Clean, high quality total RNA extracts can be directly used without further fractionation for low-molecular-weight (LMW) RNAs for miRNA detection by northern blot assays. In the past, the column from the Qiagen RNA/DNA midi kit (catalog number 14142) was used to separate the high-molecularweight (HMW) and LMW RNAs by a stepwise elution procedure, followed by isopropanol precipitation. The recovery of small RNAs through this procedure turned out to be suboptimal and inefficient. However, the column purification step does significantly improve the quality of RNA, especially for samples prepared from polysaccharide-rich tissues. It is therefore still recommended to purify the total RNA extracts using either the Qiagen RNA/DNA midi kit or other alternative methods, but fractionation of LMW RNA is generally unnecessary. 2. RNA size markers serve as a convenient reference for data interpretation. An equal molar mix of 21- and 24-nt synthetic, 5¢ phosphorylated RNA oligonucleotides with a non-plant sequence (e.g., GFP) works well for this purpose. Loading of 250–500 pmol each is usually sufficient for visualizing the marker on the membrane following the gel transfer. 3. For maximum sensitivity, the use of a charged nylon membrane (e.g., Nytran SuPerCharge Membranes by Whatman, formerly Schleider & Schuell; VWR catalog number 28151318) is recommended. 4. The T4 PNK has an intrinsic bias against the efficient labeling of certain oligonucleotides, particularly those with 5¢-C ends. Labeling of such oligonucleotides with T4 PNK could therefore encounter low labeling efficiency. The OptiKinase from USB (catalog number 78334X), which is a modified version of T4 PNK and exhibits little or no base discrimination, could be the choice for solving this problem.
14
Xie
5. For detection of miRNAs with very low abundance, use of oligonucleotides with the locked nucleic acid (LNA) modification instead of regular DNA oligonucleotides could significantly improve the sensitivity of detection (74). 6. The incorporation of the radioactive 32P into the oligonucleotides can be experimentally measured. Take out 0.5 µL of the labeling reaction and make a 1:50 dilution with 1X TE. On each of the two Whatman DE81 circular filter papers (catalog number 3658-325), spot a small aliquot (e.g., 2 µL) of the diluted labeling reaction. Air-dry the filter papers. Set one of the circles aside and wash the other circle twice for 5 min each with 50 ml 0.5 M Na2HPO4 (pH6.8) in a glass beaker with gentle shaking. A final wash in 95% ethanol may be followed to facilitate the air-drying of the filter paper. Transfer each of the filter papers to a scintillation vial containing 5 ml of scintillation cocktail (e.g., Fisher Scientific catalog number SX18-4). Measure the radioactivity retained on each filter paper using a liquid scintillation counter (LSC). The incorporation efficiency can be calculated as follows:
% incorporation = éë(incorporated cpm ) / (total cpm )ùû ´ 100 é(cpm from washed filter ) / ù =ê ú ´ 100 ëê(cpm from unwashed filter )ûú An incorporation efficiency of 50% or higher is often achieved (see Note 4). 7. If possible, check the radioactive signal on a phosphor imager before exposing the blot to film. This serves as a preview to ensure that a satisfactory signal/noise ratio has been achieved. In case of high background or unknown “hot spots”, an extended final wash can be done before exposing the membrane to film.
Acknowledgments I thank Chris Rock for critically reading the manuscript.
References 1. Llave C, Kasschau KD, Rector MA, Carrington JC (2002) Endogenous and silencing-associated small RNAs in plants. Plant Cell 14: 1605– 1619
2. Mette MF, van der Winden J, Matzke M, Matzke AJ (2002) Short RNAs can identify new candidate transposable element families in Arabidopsis. Plant Physiol 130:6–9
3. Park W, Li J, Song R, Messing J, Chen X (2002) CARPEL FACTORY, a Dicer homolog, and HEN1, a novel protein, act in microRNA metabolism in Arabidopsis thaliana. Curr Biol 12:1484–1495 4. Reinhart BJ, Weinstein EG, Rhoades MW, Bartel B, Bartel DP (2002) MicroRNAs in plants. Genes Dev 16:1616–1626 5. Hamilton AJ, Baulcombe DC (1999) A species of small antisense RNA in posttranscriptional gene silencing in plants. Science 286:950–952 6. Lagos-Quintana M, Rauhut R, Lendeckel W, Tuschl T (2001) Identification of novel genes coding for small expressed RNAs. Science 294:853–858 7. Lau NC, Lim EP, Weinstein EG, Bartel DP (2001) An abundant class of tiny RNAs with probable regulatory roles in Caenorhabditis elegans. Science 294:858–862 8. Lee RC, Ambros V (2001) An extensive class of small RNAs in Caenorhabditis elegans. Science 294:862–864 9. Baulcombe D (2004) RNA silencing in plants. Nature 431:356–363 10. Chapman EJ, Carrington JC (2007) Specialization and evolution of endogenous small RNA pathways. Nat Rev Genet 8:884–896 11. Jones-Rhoades MW, Bartel DP, Bartel B (2006) microRNAs and their regulatory roles in plants. Annu Rev Plant Biol 57:19–53 12. Vaucheret H (2006) Post-transcriptional small RNA pathways in plants: mechanisms and regulations. Genes Dev 20:759–771 13. Axtell MJ, Snyder JA, Bartel DP (2007) Common functions for diverse small RNAs of land plants. Plant Cell 19(6):1750–1769 14. Fahlgren N, Howell MD, Kasschau KD, Chapman EJ, Sullivan CM, Cumbie JS, Givan SA, Law TF, Grant SR, Dangl JL, Carrington JC (2007) High-throughput sequencing of Arabidopsis microRNAs: evidence for frequent birth and death of MIRNA genes. PLoS ONE 2:e219 15. Henderson IR, Zhang X, Lu C, Johnson L, Meyers BC, Green PJ, Jacobsen SE (2006) Dissecting Arabidopsis thaliana DICER function in small RNA processing, gene silencing and DNA methylation patterning. Nat Genet 38:721–725 16. Lu C, Tej SS, Luo S, Haudenschild CD, Meyers BC, Green PJ (2005) Elucidation of the small RNA component of the transcriptome. Science 309:1567–1569 17. Rajagopalan R, Vaucheret H, Trejo J, Bartel DP (2006) A diverse and evolutionarily fluid set of microRNAs in Arabidopsis thaliana. Genes Dev 20:3407–3425
Piecing the Puzzle Together
15
18. Xie Z, Qi X (2008) Diverse small RNA-directed silencing pathways in plants. Biochim Biophys Acta – Gene Regulatory Mechanisms 1779 (11):720–724 19. Kurihara Y, Watanabe Y (2004) Arabidopsis micro-RNA biogenesis through Dicer-like 1 protein functions. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 101:12753–12758 20. Parizotto EA, Dunoyer P, Rahm N, Himber C, Voinnet O (2004) In vivo investigation of the transcription, processing, endonucleolytic activity, and functional relevance of the spatial distribution of a plant miRNA. Genes Dev 18:2237–2242 21. Xie Z, Allen E, Fahlgren N, Calamar A, Givan SA, Carrington JC (2005) Expression of Arabidopsis MIRNA genes. Plant Physiol 138: 2145–2154 22. Fang Y, Spector DL (2007) Identification of nuclear dicing bodies containing proteins for microRNA biogenesis in living Arabidopsis plants. Curr Biol 17:818–823 23. Han MH, Goud S, Song L, Fedoroff N (2004) The Arabidopsis double-stranded RNAbinding protein HYL1 plays a role in microRNA-mediated gene regulation. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 101:1093–1098 24. Vazquez F, Gasciolli V, Crete P, Vaucheret H (2004) The nuclear dsRNA binding protein HYL1 is required for microRNA accumulation and plant development, but not posttranscriptional transgene silencing. Curr Biol 14:346–351 25. Khvorova A, Reynolds A, Jayasena SD (2003) Functional siRNAs and miRNAs exhibit strand bias. Cell 115:209–216 26. Schwarz DS, Hutvagner G, Du T, Xu Z, Aronin N, Zamore PD (2003) Asymmetry in the assembly of the RNAi enzyme complex. Cell 115:199–208 27. Baumberger N, Baulcombe DC (2005) Arabidopsis ARGONAUTE1 is an RNA Slicer that selectively recruits microRNAs and short interfering RNAs. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 102:11928–11933 28. Qi Y, Denli AM, Hannon GJ (2005) Biochemical specialization within Arabidopsis RNA silencing pathways. Mol Cell 19:421–428 29. Vaucheret H, Mallory AC, Bartel DP (2006) AGO1 homeostasis entails coexpression of MIR168 and AGO1 and preferential stabilization of miR168 by AGO1. Mol Cell 22: 129–136 30. Hamilton A, Voinnet O, Chappell L, Baulcombe D (2002) Two classes of short interfering RNA in RNA silencing. Embo J 21:4671– 4679
16
Xie
31. Xie Z, Johansen LK, Gustafson AM, Kasschau KD, Lellis AD, Zilberman D, Jacobsen SE, Carrington JC (2004) Genetic and functional diversification of small RNA pathways in plants. PLoS Biol 2:E104 32. Herr AJ, Jensen MB, Dalmay T, Baulcombe DC (2005) RNA polymerase IV directs silencing of endogenous DNA. Science 308:118–120 33. Onodera Y, Haag JR, Ream T, Nunes PC, Pontes O, Pikaard CS (2005) Plant nuclear RNA polymerase IV mediates siRNA and DNA methylation-dependent heterochromatin formation. Cell 120:613–622 34. Pontier D, Yahubyan G, Vega D, Bulski A, Saez-Vasquez J, Hakimi MA, Lerbs-Mache S, Colot V, Lagrange T (2005) Reinforcement of silencing at transposons and highly repeated sequences requires the concerted action of two distinct RNA polymerases IV in Arabidopsis. Genes Dev 19:2030–2040 35. Zhang X, Henderson IR, Lu C, Green PJ, Jacobsen SE (2007) Role of RNA polymerase IV in plant small RNA metabolism. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 104:4536–4541 36. Zilberman D, Cao X, Jacobsen SE (2003) ARGONAUTE4 control of locus-specific siRNA accumulation and DNA and histone methylation. Science 299:716–719 37. Li CF, Pontes O, El-Shami M, Henderson IR, Bernatavichute YV, Chan SW, Lagrange T, Pikaard CS, Jacobsen SE (2006) An ARGONAUTE4-containing nuclear processing center colocalized with Cajal bodies in Arabidopsis thaliana. Cell 126:93–106 38. Pontes O, Li CF, Nunes PC, Haag J, Ream T, Vitins A, Jacobsen SE, Pikaard CS (2006) The Arabidopsis chromatin-modifying nuclear siRNA pathway involves a nucleolar RNA processing center. Cell 126:79–92 39. Allen E, Xie Z, Gustafson AM, Carrington JC (2005) microRNA-directed phasing during trans-acting siRNA biogenesis in plants. Cell 121:207–221 40. Axtell MJ, Jan C, Rajagopalan R, Bartel DP (2006) A two-hit trigger for siRNA biogenesis in plants. Cell 127:565–577 41. Peragine A, Yoshikawa M, Wu G, Albrecht HL, Poethig RS (2004) SGS3 and SGS2/SDE1/ RDR6 are required for juvenile development and the production of trans-acting siRNAs in Arabidopsis. Genes Dev 18:2368–2379 42. Vazquez F, Vaucheret H, Rajagopalan R, Lepers C, Gasciolli V, Mallory AC, Hilbert JL, Bartel DP, Crete P (2004) Endogenous transacting siRNAs regulate the accumulation of Arabidopsis mRNAs. Mol Cell 16:69–79 43. Gasciolli V, Mallory AC, Bartel DP, Vaucheret H (2005) Partially redundant functions of
Arabidopsis DICER-like enzymes and a role for DCL4 in producing trans-acting siRNAs. Curr Biol 15:1494–1500 44. Xie Z, Allen E, Wilken A, Carrington JC (2005) DICER-LIKE 4 functions in trans-acting small interfering RNA biogenesis and vegetative phase change in Arabidopsis thaliana. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 102:12984–12989 45. Yoshikawa M, Peragine A, Park MY, Poethig RS (2005) A pathway for the biogenesis of trans-acting siRNAs in Arabidopsis. Genes Dev 19:2164–2175 46. Borsani O, Zhu J, Verslues PE, Sunkar R, Zhu JK (2005) Endogenous siRNAs derived from a pair of natural cis-antisense transcripts regulate salt tolerance in Arabidopsis. Cell 123: 1279–1291 47. Katiyar-Agarwal S, Morgan R, Dahlbeck D, Borsani O, Villegas A Jr, Zhu JK, Staskawicz BJ, Jin H (2006) A pathogen-inducible endogenous siRNA in plant immunity. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 103:18002–18007 48. Yang Z, Ebright YW, Yu B, Chen X (2006) HEN1 recognizes 21–24 nt small RNA duplexes and deposits a methyl group onto the 2¢ OH of the 3¢ terminal nucleotide. Nucleic Acids Res 34:667–675 49. Yu B, Yang Z, Li J, Minakhina S, Yang M, Padgett RW, Steward R, Chen X (2005) Methylation as a crucial step in plant microRNA biogenesis. Science 307:932–935 50. Li J, Yang Z, Yu B, Liu J, Chen X (2005) Methylation protects miRNAs and siRNAs from a 3¢-end uridylation activity in Arabidopsis. Curr Biol 15:1501–1507 51. Schauer SE, Jacobsen SE, Meinke DW, Ray A (2002) DICER-LIKE1: blind men and elephants in Arabidopsis development. Trends Plant Sci 7:487–491 52. Chen X, Liu J, Cheng Y, Jia D (2002) HEN1 functions pleiotropically in Arabidopsis development and acts in C function in the flower. Development 129:1085–1094 53. Golden TA, Schauer SE, Lang JD, Pien S, Mushegian AR, Grossniklaus U, Meinke DW, Ray A (2002) SHORT INTEGUMENTS1/ SUSPENSOR1/CARPEL FACTORY, a Dicer homolog, is a maternal effect gene required for embryo development in Arabidopsis. Plant Physiol 130:808–822 54. Jacobsen SE, Running MP, Meyerowitz EM (1999) Disruption of an RNA helicase/RNAse III gene in Arabidopsis causes unregulated cell division in floral meristems. Development 126:5231–5243 55. Ray A, Lang JD, Golden T, Ray S (1996) SHORT INTEGUMENTS1 (SIN1), a gene required for ovule development in Arabidopsis,
also controls flowering time. Development 122:2631–2638 56. Bohmert K, Camus I, Bellini C, Bouchez D, Caboche M, Benning C (1998) AGO1 defines a novel locus of Arabidopsis controlling leaf development. Embo J 17:170–180 57. Fagard M, Boutet S, Morel JB, Bellini C, Vaucheret H (2000) AGO1, QDE-2, and RDE-1 are related proteins required for posttranscriptional gene silencing in plants, quelling in fungi, and RNA interference in animals. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 97:11650–11654 58. Morel JB, Godon C, Mourrain P, Beclin C, Boutet S, Feuerbach F, Proux F, Vaucheret H (2002) Fertile hypomorphic ARGONAUTE (ago1) mutants impaired in post-transcriptional gene silencing and virus resistance. Plant Cell 14:629–639 59. Kidner CA, Martienssen RA (2004) Spatially restricted microRNA directs leaf polarity through ARGONAUTE1. Nature 428:81–84 60. Lu C, Fedoroff N (2000) A mutation in the Arabidopsis HYL1 gene encoding a dsRNA binding protein affects responses to abscisic acid, auxin, and cytokinin. Plant Cell 12: 2351–2366 61. Yang L, Liu Z, Lu F, Dong A, Huang H (2006) SERRATE is a novel nuclear regulator in primary microRNA processing in Arabidopsis. Plant J 47:841–850 62. Grigg SP, Canales C, Hay A, Tsiantis M (2005) SERRATE coordinates shoot meristem function and leaf axial patterning in Arabidopsis. Nature 437:1022–1026 63. Lobbes D, Rallapalli G, Schmidt DD, Martin C, Clarke J (2006) SERRATE: a new player on the plant microRNA scene. EMBO Rep 7:1052–1058 64. Kurihara Y, Takashi Y, Watanabe Y (2006) The interaction between DCL1 and HYL1 is important for efficient and precise processing of pri-miRNA in plant microRNA biogenesis. RNA 12:206–212 65. Adenot X, Elmayan T, Lauressergues D, Boutet S, Bouche N, Gasciolli V, Vaucheret H (2006) DRB4-dependent TAS3 trans-acting
Piecing the Puzzle Together
17
siRNAs control leaf morphology through AGO7. Curr Biol 16:927–932 66. Hiraguri A, Itoh R, Kondo N, Nomura Y, Aizawa D, Murai Y, Koiwa H, Seki M, Shinozaki K, Fukuhara T (2005) Specific interactions between Dicer-like proteins and HYL1/DRBfamily dsRNA-binding proteins in Arabidopsis thaliana. Plant Mol Biol 57:173–188 67. Song L, Han MH, Lesicka J, Fedoroff N (2007) Arabidopsis primary microRNA processing proteins HYL1 and DCL1 define a nuclear body distinct from the Cajal body. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 104:5437–5442 68. Telfer A, Poethig RS (1998) HASTY: a gene that regulates the timing of shoot maturation in Arabidopsis thaliana. Development 125: 1889–1898 69. Bollman KM, Aukerman MJ, Park MY, Hunter C, Berardini TZ, Poethig RS (2003) HASTY, the Arabidopsis ortholog of exportin 5/MSN5, regulates phase change and morphogenesis. Development 130:1493–1504 70. Park MY, Wu G, Gonzalez-Sulser A, Vaucheret H, Poethig RS (2005) Nuclear processing and export of microRNAs in Arabidopsis. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 102:3691–3696 71. Boutet S, Vazquez F, Liu J, Beclin C, Fagard M, Gratias A, Morel JB, Crete P, Chen X, Vaucheret H (2003) Arabidopsis HEN1: a genetic link between endogenous miRNA controlling development and siRNA controlling transgene silencing and virus resistance. Curr Biol 13:843–848 72. Stepanova AN, Alonso JM (2006) PCR-based screening for insertional mutants, in: Arabidopsis Protocols (Salinas J and Sanchez-Serrano J, eds) Humana Press, Totowa, NJ. pp. 163–172 73. Neff MM, Neff JD, Chory J, Pepper AE (1998) dCAPS, a simple technique for the genetic analysis of single nucleotide polymorphisms: experimental applications in Arabidopsis thaliana genetics. Plant J 14:387–392 74. Valoczi A, Hornyik C, Varga N, Burgyan J, Kauppinen S, Havelda Z (2004) Sensitive and specific detection of microRNAs by northern blot analysis using LNA-modified oligonucleotide probes. Nucleic Acids Res 32:e175
Chapter 2 Prediction of Plant miRNA Genes Matthew W. Jones-Rhoades Abstract This chapter presents procedures for the computational identification of plant miRNA genes. In the first procedure, homologs of known miRNAs are identified in a database of genomic or cDNA sequence. In the second procedure, previously unidentified miRNA families are predicted through the analysis of secondary structure, evolutionary conservation, and targeting potential. Key words: Gene prediction, microRNA discovery, Comparative genomics
1. Introduction MicroRNAs are short, non-coding, endogenously expressed RNAs that are processed from longer hairpin precursors (see Subheading 2.1, (1) for review). Historically, most plant miRNA genes have been discovered by one of two methods: the molecular cloning of small RNAs (2–8), and computational prediction of miRNA genes based on the conservation of sequence and secondary structure (9–14). While molecular cloning is the most direct way of discovering miRNAs, bioinformatic approaches have provided a useful complement to cloning experiments. For example, as new miRNAs are discovered through molecular cloning, computational approaches can identify homologous miRNAs in databases of genomic or cDNA sequences, thereby establishing the copy number and the range of evolutionary conservation of the miRNAs. Similarly, the accurate identification of known miRNA families in the growing body of genomic and cDNA sequence is critical for the accurate and thorough annotation of gene content in these databases. B.C. Meyers and P.J. Green (eds.), Plant MicroRNAs, Methods in Molecular Biology, vol. 592 DOI 10.1007/978-1-60327-005-2_2, © Humana Press, a part of Springer Science + Business Media, LLC 2010
19
20
Jones-Rhoades
Computational approaches can also complement cloning experi ments by identifying miRNA families that are difficult to clone due to low or highly specific expression. For example, the miR395 and miR399 families, both of which were initially identified (9, 11), are difficult to detect experimentally in Arabidopsis under standard growth conditions, due to low expression levels, but are easily detectable in plants starved for sulfate or phosphate, respectively (11, 15, 16). The changes from the original are (a) replace “through comparative genomics” with “compu tationally” (affer “were initially identified”) (b) insertion of “experimentally” after “to detect” (c) insertion of “due to low expression levels” “after growth conditions”. While the development of high-throughput sequencing technologies have vastly improved the sensitivity of molecular cloning experiments (3, 5, 17, 18), it is still difficult to ensure that all possible tissues, developmental stages, and growth conditions are represented in cloned libraries of small RNAs. Therefore, computational methods will remain useful in the discovery of plant miRNAs. 1.1. Identification of Plant miRNA Homologs
Homologs of a known miRNA can be predicted by identifying genomic regions that have (a) sequence similarity to the known miRNA and (b) the potential to form miRNA hairpin precursors. Because the loop regions of miRNA hairpins can be highly divergent between related miRNAs, the most sensitive means of finding potential homologs is to identify near matches to the mature miRNA. The genomic regions containing these candidates are then screened for the ability to fold into hairpin structures that resemble miRNA precursors. While this procedure is relatively straightforward, care must be taken to avoid the spurious mis-annotation of non-miRNA sequences as miRNAs (see below).
1.2. De Novo Identification of Conserved Plant miRNAs
A more difficult problem is to predict miRNA genes that are unrelated to any miRNA with previous experimental evidence. Typically the first step in such an approach is to typically identify genomic regions with the potential to form hairpin secondary structures with properties similar to known miRNA precursors. However, a typical genome contains thousands of regions with predicted secondary structures that resemble miRNA precursors (11), of which only a low percentage are likely to represent actual miRNA genes. Therefore, it is necessary to use additional criteria to identify the genomic hairpins with a high probability of encoding actual miRNAs. While several groups have addressed this problem in plants (9–11, 13), all have used the evolutionary conservation of stem-loops and the ability to base pair to potential target RNAs as a means of reducing the number of false positive hairpins under consideration.
Prediction of Plant miRNA Genes
21
This chapter describes a procedure that identified 18 of the 20 miRNA families that are conserved between Arabidopsis and rice (11). Because future analyses will probably involve different genomes that are separated by different evolutionary distances, I have attempted to highlight the ways in which this approach could be adapted to other comparisons. 1.3. miRcheck and Supporting Scripts
A central step in the prediction of plant miRNA genes is the analysis of secondary structures to identify candidate hairpin precursors. Plant miRNA hairpins are diverse in terms of the length and extent of base pairing in the loop region (defined here as the sequence connecting the miRNA and miRNA*). However, all well-supported miRNA stem-loops are predicted to have extensive base pairing in the region containing the miRNA and miRNA*. If only a moderate number of putative miRNA loci are to be analyzed, it may be possible to manually evaluate each secondary structure. However, for a genome-wide search involving hundreds or thousands of candidate miRNAs, it is desirable to use an automated method to evaluate the hairpin structures. The miRcheck algorithm has been used to evaluate the miRNA encoding potential of whole genomes (11), to identify miRNA homologs in poplar (12), and to evaluate the miRNA-encoding potential of cloned small RNAs (5, 19). miRcheck compares the local secondary structure of the miRNA/miRNA* against a series of parameters; a putative miRNA will “pass” miRcheck if cutoff values are met for all parameters. The default cutoffs of miRcheck have exhibited a good balance of selectivity and sensitivity in a number of different applications. Although miRcheck was designed based on the characteristics of 11 miRNA families conserved between Arabidopsis and rice, 94% of plant miRNA loci (miRbase 10.0) that are supported by conservation or deep sequencing pass the default parameters. Importantly, the cutoff values for each miRcheck parameter can be adjusted as for the requirements and goals of an analysis dictate. The features analyzed by miRcheck are: 1. A consistent orientation of base pairing within the putative miRNA (i.e., all nucleotides pairing to the miRNA must either all be 5¢ of their partner, or all be 3¢ of their partner). 2. A stem-loop length of at least 54 nucleotides (including putative miRNA and miRNA*). This requirement discriminates against cases in which the putative miRNA and miRNA* are separated by a very short loop, a pattern not observed for well-documented plant miRNA precursors. 3. A maximum of six unpaired nucleotides in the putative miRNA, of which no more than three are consecutive. In addition, no more than two nucleotides within the putative miRNA may be asymmetrically unpaired (i.e., only two
22
Jones-Rhoades
unpaired nucleotides that lack corresponding unpaired nucleotides in the miRNA* are allowed). 4. A maximum of six unpaired nucleotides in the putative miRNA*, of which no more than three are consecutive. 5. The extension of base pairing at least two nucleotides outside of the putative miRNA. This is defined as the existence of an “extended miRNA” (and corresponding “extended miRNA*”) that contains the putative miRNA and which meets all of the above pairing requirements. 6. The extended miRNA* must be no more than three nucleotides longer than the extended miRNA. This requirement discriminates against long bulges in the miRNA*. 7. At least one nucleotide within the extended miRNA or miRNA* must be unpaired. This requirement is designed to discriminate against long, perfect inverted repeats that occur in plant genomes. In addition to miRcheck itself (implemented as a perl module), I have also made available supporting perl scripts that are used in the methods in this chapter. In many cases, these scripts are wrappers that parse an input file, feed the data to another algorithm (such as miRcheck, patscan, or RNAfold), and parse the output into a convenient format. 1.4. Maximizing Sensitivity and Selectivity in miRNA Prediction
In any bioinformatic gene prediction strategy, it is desirable to minimize the number of false negatives (i.e., to correctly identify as many real genes as possible) while also minimizing the number of false positives. In most cases, the investigator must decide how to balance these sometimes opposing goals. In the procedures below, I present methods and cutoffs that I have found to give a good balance of sensitivity and specificity in a variety of different situations. The ideal thresholds and methods for any particular analysis will be dictated by the nature of the search and the goals of the analysis (i.e., exhaustive list of genes vs. highly accurate list of genes). Due diligence and skepticism on the part of the investigator, including the careful consideration of the possibility of false positives, is paramount to achieving the meaningful and useful prediction of miRNA genes. Without careful controls, there is a very real danger of muddling the literature with spuriously annotated sequences that are not authentic miRNA genes.
2. Materials 2.1. Identification of Plant miRNA Homologs
1. A computer with a Unix/Linux/OSX operating system. 2. A file of miRNA sequences in Fasta format. 3. A file of genomic/cDNA sequences in Fasta format.
Prediction of Plant miRNA Genes
23
4. Patscan (available at http://www-unix.mcs.anl.gov/compbio/ PatScan/) should be installed. 5. RNAfold (available at http://www.tbi.univie.ac.at/~ivo/ RNA/RNAfold.html) or other RNA secondary structure prediction software should be installed. 6. miRcheck and supporting scripts (available at http://web. wi.mit.edu/bartel/pub/software.html). 2.2. De Novo Identification of Conserved Plant miRNAs
1. Two or more sets of genomic or cDNA sequences, contained in separate Fasta files. 2. einverted (part of EMBOSS package, available at http:// emboss.sourceforge.net/) should be installed. 3. RNAfold, miRcheck, and supporting perl scripts (as described above).
3. Methods 3.1. Identification of Plant miRNA Homologs
This protocol assumes that the investigator is starting with one or more miRNA sequences to be used as queries in the search, as well as a set of genomic or cDNA sequences in which to search for miRNA homologs.
3.1.1. Identify Pontential Homology Based on Primary Sequence Similarity
% run_patscan.pl miRNAs.fa genome.fa 200 miRNA_matches This script calls patscan to identify matches to known miRNA (contained in miRNAs.fa) in the target genomic sequence (contained in genome.fa) at the specified stringency (in this case, 0–2 substitutions and no insertions/deletions) and output matches to miRNA_matches (see Note 1).
3.1.2. Screen Potential Homologs for miRNA-like Secondary Structure
1. % retrieve_genomic_regions.pl 350 miRNA_matches genome.fa miRNA_matches_g This command retrieves a genomic fragment for each putative miRNA, with 350 flanking nucleotides added to each side of the putative miRNAs (see Note 2). 2. % RNAfold < miRNA_matches_g > miRNA_matches_g_f This command uses RNAfold to predict secondary structures for each putative miRNA locus. 3. % evaluate_miRNA_candidates.pl miRNA_matches_g_f miRNA_ matches_g_f_miRNAs This script calls miRcheck to evaluate the secondary structure of each putative miRNA. The output (miRNA_matches_g_f ) contains the position of the miRNA within the hairpin (5¢ or 3¢) for each candidate that passed miRcheck. Additional output files (miRNA_ matches_g_f_mature and miRNA_matches_g_f_hairpin) contain the genomic coordinates and sequences of the mature miRNAs and miRNA hairpins for candidates that passed miRcheck.
24
Jones-Rhoades
3.1.3. Quality Control for miRNA Homolog Predictions
Due to the rather vague pairing requirements for plant miRNA hairpins, there is the considerable possibility of recovering false positives when predicting miRNA genes. There are several quality control steps that should be applied to the predicted miRNA genes to help gauge the stringency of the predictions. One potential source of false positives is the mis-annotation of miRNA binding sites in target genes as miRNA hairpins. Because most plant miRNAs are highly complementary to target miRNAs, high-quality matches (0–2 nucleotides substitutions) to a miRNA in a plant genome primarily fall into one of two categories: miRNA genes and miRNA complementary sites in target genes. In general, the former will have predicted secondary structures that pass miRcheck while the latter will not. However, due to the rather loose pairing requirements of plant miRNAs precursors, a fraction of miRNA target sites can be expected to spuriously fold into hairpin structures. Therefore, it is advisable to screen putative miRNA homologs for the potential to encode for proteins. A putative miRNA locus that has similarity to the known targets of that miRNA family (e.g., a putative miR164 hairpin that is antisense to a CUC-like gene) is probably a false positive. A useful check on the validity of the predicted miRNAs is to consider the location of each putative miRNA within its hairpin precursor (i.e., on the 5¢ arm or the 3¢ arm of the hairpin). Each miRNA family has a characteristic location in which the mature miRNA is always found. For example, all miR156 hairpins contain the mature miRNA on the 5¢ arm. An analysis that predicts a substantial number of miRNAs that are located on the opposite arms of their precursors relative to their known homologs (i.e., miR156 homologs on 3¢ arms) should be cause for concern. Another useful control is to repeat the analysis in a context in which there should be no true positives. For example, arbitrary sequences, with the same dinucleotide composition as the actual miRNAs, can be used as starting point of the search. The prediction of a substantial number of “homologs” to these arbitrary sequences should be taken as an indication that one or more steps in the procedure are insufficiently stringent.
3.1.4. A Worked Example: Identification of Homologs to Arabidopsis miRNAs in Moss
This protocol was designed to identify homologs of Arabidopsis miRNAs in the poplar genome (12). Testing this procedure against the moss (Physcomitrella patens) genome demonstrates its utility, while also illustrating some pitfalls. The recent deep sequencing of moss small RNAs provides an independent measure of the actual miRNA content in the moss genome (19). Using the set of mature Arabidopsis miRNAs (miRbase 10.0, representing 94 families) as queries, 581 genomic loci with sequence similarity to an Arabidopsis miRNA, were identified of
Prediction of Plant miRNA Genes
25
which 46 passed miRcheck. Thirty-two of the 34 conserved miRNA genes with experimental evidence (representing seven families) were identified. For the 87 Arabidopsis miRNA families without experimental evidence in moss, only nine putative homologs that passed miRcheck were identified, of which only four were on the correct hairpin arm (see Note 3). 3.2. De Novo Identification of Conserved Plant miRNAs
This protocol assumes that the investigator is starting with two or more databases of genomic or cDNA sequences in which to search for miRNA genes. The procedure outlined was developed to discover miRNAs conserved between Arabidopsis and rice. Because a comparison across a different evolutionary distance (e.g., comparing Arabidopsis to poplar, or two species of moss to each other) might require a very different analysis, it is not possible to describe a single procedure that will work well in all cases. Accordingly, the protocol describes approaches that worked well in the monocotdicot analysis so that investigators interested in other analyses can consider adapting them as needed.
3.2.1. Identify Genomic Regions with miRNA-like Secondary Structure
1. % run_einverted.pl genome.fa einverted_output This script calls einverted to identify imperfect inverted repeats in the genomic sequence. Because einverted cannot run efficiently on large sequences, the genomic sequence is broken up into overlapping 2 kb fragments (see Note 4). 2. % fold_inverted_repeats.pl einverted_output genome.fa einverted_output _f For each inverted repeat, this script retrieves the genomic sequence containing the repeat (plus 10 flanking nucleotides on either side) and uses RNAfold to predict the secondary structures of each genomic fragment. Two structures are predicted for each inverted repeat, corresponding to theoretical transcripts from either DNA strand. 3. % extract_einverted_20mers.pl einverted_output _f einverted_ output_20mers For each secondary structure, miRcheck identifies 20-mers with local base pairing patterns that are compatible with those typically found in plant miRNA precursors. Because each 20-mer is considered separately, a single stem-loop may contain numerous 20-mer miRNA candidates. The end result of this step is a list (probably quite lengthy) of candidate miRNA stem-loops and candidate miRNA precursors, with each candidate stem-loop containing one or more candidate mature miRNAs. (In many cases, the reverse complement stemloop will also contain candidate miRNAs.) Unless overly stringent cutoffs have been used, it is likely that only a very small fraction of these candidates are actual miRNAs. Therefore, additional filters are important to improve the selectivity of the miRNA predictions (see Notes 5 and 6).
26
Jones-Rhoades
3.2.2. Test Robustness of miRNA Hairpin Folding
For most well documented plant miRNA genes, the prediction of a hairpin structure by RNAfold is insensitive to the presence or absence of additional flanking nucleotides. This implies that the predicted free energy of the miRNA hairpin is more favorable than that of alternative structures in which the nucleotides of the miRNA hairpin pair with flanking sequences. In the analysis of Arabidopsis and rice genomic hairpins, it was observed that many 20-mers that passed miRcheck when their inverted repeats (as identified by einverted) were “folded” by RNAfold in isolation, no longer passed miRcheck when folded in the context of 240 genomic nucleotides flanking either side of the 20-mer. Therefore, simply re-evaluating the secondary structure of each miRNA candidate, as predicted from a genomic sequence of arbitrary length centered on the 20-mer, can serve as a useful screen against candidates with unstable hairpins.
3.2.3. Analyze Conservation of Putative miRNAs to Other Genomes
Because of the extreme level of conservation of some miRNAs (in several cases, 100% nucleotide identity of mature miRNAs between angiosperms and moss), the identification of candidates with conservation of miRNA sequence and secondary structure in more than one genome can be a powerful method to enrich authentic miRNAs. One drawback, of course, is that any miRNAs not conserved between the genomes under comparison will not be identified. In practical terms, there are two possible schemes for the genome-wide identification of potentially conserved miRNAs. One approach, as was used in the Arabidopsis/rice analysis, is to independently identify candidate miRNAs in each genome being analyzed (i.e., carry out steps given in Subheadings 3.2.1 and 3.2.2 separately for each genome) and then to compare the candidate 20-mers to identify potential homologs. Alternatively, a list of candidate 20-mers could be identified in one genome, and potential homologs in other genomes could then be identified (using, for example, the first protocol in this chapter). Regardless of the scheme used, an important consideration is the degree of similarity required for two candidates to be considered as potential homologs. Most miRNAs conserved between Arabidopsis and rice have zero to two nucleotide substitutions when compared across genomes. Allowing three substitutions between candidate 20-mer homologs is likely to capture a large number of false positives.
3.2.4. Analyze Conservation of Putative miRNA Hairpins in Other Genomes
In an alignment of two homologous miRNA hairpins from different genomes, the mature miRNA sequences are highly conserved, as are the miRNA* sequences in most cases. The loop region between the miRNA and miRNA* is often highly divergent in both sequence and length. However, plant genomes also contain conserved hairpins (of uncharacterized function) that are
Prediction of Plant miRNA Genes
27
uniformly conserved throughout the hairpin. Therefore, depending on the level of background conservation between the genomes being analyzed, it may be possible to enrich for authentic miRNAs by discriminating against putative miRNA homologs that are not more highly conserved than the loop regions of their putative precursors. 3.2.5. Identify Potential Regulatory Targets of Putative miRNAs
The function of a mature miRNA is to guide a RISC complex to a complementary target RNA. Most plant miRNAs have extensive complementarity to their target RNAs, a fact that greatly facilitates the prediction of plant miRNA targets (20). Importantly, this high degree of complementarity has also facilitated discovery of the miRNA genes themselves through the identification of candidate targets for candidate miRNAs (9, 11). A number of algorithms, all of which substantively agree with each other, have been described for the prediction of plant miRNA targets (11, 21, 22). Any of these methods can be used for the analysis of the targeting potential of candidate 20-mers by searching for targets in annotated genes or EST sequences. The combined analysis of miRNA conservation with the analysis of targeting potential (i.e., identifying conserved miRNA candidates that can base pair to homologous target RNAs in each species) is particularly powerful for enriching for conserved miRNAs. As with other steps, choosing thresholds for target prediction that limit the number of false positive predictions is critical to obtaining meaningful results.
3.2.6. Verification of Predicted miRNAs
Due to the high potential for false positives, miRNA families predicted through genomic analyses should be viewed with skepticism until validated by experimental data. There are several types of experiments that are useful in validating the expression of predicted miRNAs. The detection of the predicted miRNAs on a northern blot can be strong evidence for expression. However, it is worth noting that a faint, fuzzy band on a northern blot is not a reliable indication of expression (see Note 7). A PCR-based assay can detect the presence of rare RNAs in a library of adapter ligated small RNAs (11, 23). Importantly, this approach can also map the 5¢ end of the predicted small RNA. Perhaps, the most powerful method of validating a predicted miRNA is to demonstrate an interaction with a predicted target. 5¢ RACE has been used by numerous labs to detect the in vivo miRNA-mediated cleavage of target RNAs (5, 11, 19, 21, 24– 26), which results in a cleaved target with a 5¢ end that aligns to the tenth nucleotide of the miRNA. Ideally, the 5¢ end of the miRNA, as identified by PCR analysis, should agree with the observed position of cleavage in the target RNA.
28
Jones-Rhoades
4. Notes
1. Other search/alignment algorithms (e.g., blast) can be used instead of patscan. Regardless of the search algorithm used, an important consideration is the extent of similarity that a genomic region must possess to the query miRNA in order to be considered as a potential homolog. While different thresholds are likely to be appropriate in different situations, the requirement for an ungapped alignment between the mature miRNA and its putative homologs with no more than two nucleotide substitutions seems to give a good balance of selectivity and sensitivity.
2. Plant miRNA hairpins can be quite long. Many hairpins are 200 to 300 nucleotides long (including the miRNA, loop region, and miRNA*), with a few ranging up to 650 nucleotides. Therefore, it is important to retrieve sufficient flanking sequence on either side of the putative miRNA. Adding additional flanking sequence will increase the computing time needed to predict the secondary structures of the genomic regions, but does not seem to affect the predicted structures of most miRNAs stem-loops.
3. The 12 putative moss miRNA homologs that lacked experimental evidence are illustrative of some of the pitfalls of miRNA prediction. In two cases, the reverse complement to experimentally supported miRNA* sequences, were identified as miRNA candidates. (The actual miRNAs were also identified as candidates in these cases.) The identity of the strand, encoding the actual miRNA, would be ambiguous in these cases without experimental evidence. Three putative members of conserved miRNA families were not detected by the deep sequencing; it is unclear if these are false positives or miRNA genes that were not represented in the library of sequenced small RNAs. Of the nine putative homologs to non-conserved families, seven were to miR414, a miRNA identified through a bioinformatic search (13) that has not been subsequently validated experimentally in any species (3, 5). Because the miR414 sequence is a degenerate triplet repeat (UCA), it has 393 matches with zero to two nucleotide substitutions in the moss genome. With so many matches to a simple sequence, it is not surprising that a few can be predicted to fold into a hairpin structure. The miR414 case illustrates that certain sequences are prone to noise in bioinformatics analyses (which probably contributed to initial mis-annotation of miR414 as a miRNA), and that given a large enough number of spurious potential miRNA homologs, some can be predicted to have potential miRNA precursors.
Prediction of Plant miRNA Genes
29
4. Using einverted parameters trained on conserved angiosperm miRNAs, the program run_einverted.pl identified 990,192 inverted repeats in the moss genome. Included in this set were inverted repeats corresponding to 95% of 205 experimentally supported moss miRNA genes, most of which are not conserved in angiosperms. An alternative to using einverted to identify genomic inverted repeats, could be to use RNAfold to predict secondary structures for genomic fragments that tile the entire genome, which could then be analyzed by miRcheck. This would have the advantage of not potentially losing miRNA loci that are not identified by einverted, but may add considerable computational load and noise to the analysis.
5. The parameters passed to miRcheck will have a large impact on the outcome. In the analysis of miRNAs conserved between rice and Arabidopsis, I found that setting parameters to be stringent, so that ~15–20% of actual miRNAs did not pass miRcheck, was helpful in reducing the number of 20-mers to a workable number (11). The use of the same stringent parameters in moss captured 80% of moss miRNAs with experimental evidence. As mentioned for other steps in this chapter, the details, goals, and available computing power may suggest that other cutoffs are more appropriate for other analyses.
6. Plant genomes contain numerous instances of simple sequence repeats, as well as runs of single nucleotides. Therefore, it may be helpful to remove simple sequences from the analysis. By default, extract_einverted_20mers.pl removes 20-mers that consist primarily any one or two nucleotides.
7. As an example, nine computationally identified miRNA families (miR413–420; miR426) were annotated in miRbase on the basis of weak northern signals (13). Subsequent deep sequencing experiments have not detected evidence for expression of these miRNAs (3, 5).
References 1. Jones-Rhoades M, Bartel D, Bartel B. Micro RNAs and their regulatory roles in plants. Annu Rev Plant Biol. 2006;57:19–53. 2. Llave C, Kasschau KD, Rector MA, Carrington JC. Endogenous and silencing-associated small RNAs in plants. Plant Cell. 2002;14: 1605–1619. 3. Lu C, Kulkarni K, Souret F, MuthuValliappan R, Tej S, Poethig R, et al. MicroRNAs and other small RNAs enriched in the Arabidopsis RNA-dependent RNA polymerase-2 mutant. Genome Res. 2006;16:1276–1288.
4. Park W, Li J, Song R, Messing J, Chen X. CARPEL FACTORY, a Dicer homolog, and HEN1, a novel protein, act in microRNA metabolism in Arabidopsis thaliana. Curr Biol. 2002;12:1484–1495. 5. Rajagopalan R, Vaucheret H, Trejo J, Bartel D. A diverse and evolutionarily fluid set of microRNAs in Arabidopsis thaliana. Genes Dev. 2006;20:3407–3425. 6. Reinhart BJ, Weinstein EG, Rhoades MW, Bartel B, Bartel DP. MicroRNAs in plants. Genes Dev. 2002;16:1616–1626.
30
Jones-Rhoades
7. Sunkar R, Girke T, Jain PK, Zhu JK. Cloning and characterization of microRNAs from rice. Plant Cell. 2005;17:1397–1411. 8. Sunkar R, Zhu JK. Novel and stress-regulated microRNAs and other small RNAs from Arabidopsis. Plant Cell. 2004;16:2001–2019. 9. Adai A, Johnson C, Mlotshwa S, Archer-Evans S, Manocha V, Vance V, et al. Computational prediction of miRNAs in Arabidopsis thaliana. Genome Res. 2005;15:78–91. 10. Bonnet E, Wuyts J, Rouzé P, Van de Peer Y. Detection of 91 potential conserved plant microRNAs in Arabidopsis thaliana and Oryza sativa identifies important target genes. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2004;101: 11511–11516. 11. Jones-Rhoades M, Bartel D. Computational identification of plant microRNAs and their targets, including a stress-induced miRNA. Mol Cell. 2004;14:787–799. 12. Tuskan GA, Difazio S, Jansson S, Bohlmann J, Grigoriev I, Hellsten U, et al. The genome of black cottonwood, Populus trichocarpa (Torr. & Gray). Science. 2006;313:1596–1604. 13. Wang X, Reyes J, Chua N, Gaasterland T. Prediction and identification of Arabidopsis thaliana microRNAs and their mRNA targets. Genome Biol. 2004;5:R65. 14. Xie F, Huang S, Guo K, Xiang A, Zhu Y, Nie L, et al. Computational identification of novel microRNAs and targets in Brassica napus. FEBS Lett. 2007;581:1464–1474. 15. Chiou T, Aung K, Lin S, Wu C, Chiang S, Su C. Regulation of phosphate homeostasis by MicroRNA in Arabidopsis. Plant Cell. 2006;18: 412–421. 16. Fujii H, Chiou T, Lin S, Aung K, Zhu J. A miRNA involved in phosphate-starvation response in Arabidopsis. Curr Biol. 2005;15: 2038–2043.
17. Fahlgren N, Howell M, Kasschau K, Chapman E, Sullivan C, Cumbie J, et al. High-throughput sequencing of Arabidopsis microRNAs: evidence for frequent birth and death of MIRNA genes. PLoS ONE. 2007;2:e219. 18. Lu C, Tej S, Luo S, Haudenschild C, Meyers B, Green P. Elucidation of the small RNA component of the transcriptome. Science. 2005; 309:1567–1569. 19. Axtell M, Snyder J, Bartel D. Common functions for diverse small RNAs of land plants. Plant Cell. 2007;19:1750–1769. 20. Rhoades MW, Reinhart BJ, Lim LP, Burge CB, Bartel B, Bartel DP. Prediction of plant microRNA targets. Cell. 2002;110:513–520. 21. Allen E, Xie Z, Gustafson A, Carrington J. microRNA-directed phasing during transacting siRNA biogenesis in plants. Cell. 2005; 121:207–221. 22. Schwab R, Palatnik J, Riester M, Schommer C, Schmid M, Weigel D. Specific effects of microRNAs on the plant transcriptome. Dev Cell. 2005;8:517–527. 23. Lim LP, Lau NC, Weinstein EG, Abdelhakim A, Yekta S, Rhoades MW, et al. The micro RNAs of Caenorhabditis elegans. Genes Dev. 2003;17:991–1008. 24. Kasschau KD, Xie Z, Allen E, Llave C, Chapman EJ, Krizan KA, et al. P1/HC-Pro, a viral suppressor of RNA silencing, interferes with Arabidopsis development and miRNA function. Dev Cell. 2003;4:205–217. 25. Llave C, Xie Z, Kasschau KD, Carrington JC. Cleavage of Scarecrow-like mRNA targets directed by a class of Arabidopsis miRNA. Science. 2002;297:2053–2056. 26. Palatnik JF, Allen E, Wu X, Schommer C, Schwab R, Carrington JC, et al. Control of leaf morphogenesis by microRNAs. Nature. 2003;425:257–263.
Chapter 3 Methods for Isolation of Total RNA to Recover miRNAs and Other Small RNAs from Diverse Species Monica Accerbi, Skye A. Schmidt, Emanuele De Paoli, Sunhee Park, Dong-Hoon Jeong, and Pamela J. Green Abstract For the experimental analysis of miRNAs and other small RNAs in the 20–25 nucleotide (nt) size range, the first and most important step is the isolation of high-quality total RNA. Because RNA degradation products can mask or dilute the presence of true miRNAs, it is important when choosing a method that it efficiently extracts RNA from tissues in a manner that prevents degradation of RNA of both high and low molecular weight. In addition, the presence of polyphenols, polysaccharides, and secondary metabolites may render nucleic acids insoluble, and hinder the recovery of the miRNAs. Finally, and most importantly, the method chosen must be capable of retaining the small RNA component. In this chapter, we will present a set of total RNA isolation methods that can be used to maximize the recovery of high-quality RNA to be used in miRNA analysis for a large number of plant species and tissue types. Key words: RNA, Total RNA extraction, Small RNA extraction, TriReagent®, TRIzol®, Plant RNA Isolation Reagent®
1. Introduction Plants present a wide range of tissue types, both within and between species, which can often make universal methods for molecular biological techniques difficult to develop. Plant tissue varies greatly, from soft green tissue to dry seeds, flowers, roots, xylem and bark, waxy leaves, spiny needles and hard or juicy fruits.
B.C. Meyers and P.J. Green (eds.), Plant MicroRNAs, Methods in Molecular Biology, vol. 592 DOI 10.1007/978-1-60327-005-2_3, © Humana Press, a part of Springer Science + Business Media, LLC 2010
31
32
Accerbi et al.
Total RNA isolation in plant species is often complicated by the presence of recalcitrant tissue and organic compounds (1–4). While many methods exist to extract high-quality RNA from plant tissues, not all are preferred for miRNA analysis. Ion exchange and silica based separation techniques, including the Qiagen RNeasy spin column, are biased against RNAs less than 200 nt in size, and do not effectively retain the miRNA fraction. Furthermore, while LiCl precipitation is often used for total RNA extraction, this salt is largely incapable of retaining the small RNA population and therefore should be substituted with sodium salt and/or alcohol precipitation (5). The isolation of high-quality RNA depends greatly on the treatment and handling of the tissue prior to RNA extraction. Cellular ribonucleases act quickly and efficiently to degrade RNA upon cell lysis; therefore, tissue frozen in liquid nitrogen and stored at no more than −70°C will provide the best possible material for miRNA analysis. Commercial reagents such as RNAlater® (Ambion) may increase storage stability without compromising the quality or quantity of the recovered RNA, although the methods we describe do not rely on this reagent. The process of RNA isolation preferred for miRNA analysis is carried out in three main steps: lysis and denaturation, organic extraction, and RNA precipitation. A chaotropic denaturing agent such as guanidinium, or sometimes a strong reducing agent like 2-mercaptoethanol, will disrupt RNase activity upon cellular disruption and maintain the integrity of the RNA (6–8). In addition to the denaturing activity achieved by the disruption of disulfide bonds, reducing agents in the extraction buffer will prevent the oxidation of polyphenolics, rendering them incapable of binding to nucleic acids (9, 10). Organic extraction by phenol or acid phenol, and chloroform or 1-bromo-3-chloropropane (BCP), followed by centrifugation, will separate the total RNA from DNA and protein components. Finally, alcohol precipitation of the RNA from the upper aqueous layer is capable of retaining both large and small RNAs. RNA extraction from most green tissues can usually be carried out very successfully using TriReagent® (Molecular Research Center, Inc.) or TRIzol® (Invitrogen): this is the same product marketed by different companies. Based on the key reagent in a method developed by Chomczynski and Sacchi (6), the TriReagent® is a mono-phasic solution of phenol and guanidine isothiocyanate. Upon the addition of chloroform or BCP followed by centrifugation, the solution will separate into an organic and an aqueous phase, the RNA remaining in the clear aqueous phase. This method, when followed by alcohol precipitation, provides a high recovery of the small RNA fraction, as well as high-quality, non-degraded RNA.
Methods for Isolation of Total RNA to Recover miRNAs
33
For plant tissues that contain a high level of polyphenolics, polysaccharides, and fibrous materials (e.g., conifers and seeds), Plant RNA Isolation Reagent® (Invitrogen) (PRIR) is a better choice for RNA extraction. This proprietary reagent, when compared to TRIzol® or TriReagent® extraction of Arabidopsis leaves in parallel, provides RNA with a reduced A230 and a higher A260/A280 ratio. A description of these absorbances and the ratios characteristic of high-quality RNA can be found in Subheading 3.7.2 below. Highly recalcitrant plant tissues often have a high abundance of secondary metabolites that may interfere with guanidinium extraction (11). Another method of RNA isolation we present in this chapter is based on (11), with modifications by M. Perez-Amador (personal communication), and adapted for the recovery of small RNA molecules. In this instance, a highly saline, high-pH extraction buffer is used in place of guanidinium extraction, and is useful in cases such as orange tissue, where secondary metabolites may interfere with normal RNA extraction. In this chapter, we present three RNA extraction protocols that facilitate successful isolation of high-quality total RNA from a variety of representative plant species and tissue types with minimal addition of proprietary materials. The scheme in Fig. 1 can be used to help deduce an appropriate method and possible modifications that may be successful for a given sample. Table 1 lists the methods and modifications that we have used successfully to isolate total RNA that retains small RNA for nearly 100 different plant samples. These details are meant to provide an example of what has worked for a wide range of species and tissues, rather than suggest that these approaches are the only effective ones. While many commercial extraction buffers and published RNA isolation methods are specifically tailored to the type of tissue and use for the RNA desired, the methods outlined below are preferred not only for their universal application to plant species, but also for their relatively low cost in both time and materials. The RNA obtained from any of these methods may be utilized for RT-PCR, gel blotting, and library construction, or to analyze mRNAs, housekeeping RNAs such as rRNAs and tRNAs, and small RNAs such as miRNAs and siRNAs. In addition, the total RNA may be used subsequently to isolate low molecular weight RNA (~200 nt and smaller; an excellent preparation for examining small RNAs with gel blotting) and small RNA (~20–25 nt). Detailed protocols for the isolation of these RNA size fractions and the preparation of small RNA cDNA libraries can be found in Chap. 8 of this volume, and that for detection of small RNAs with gel blotting can be found in Chaps. 13 and 14.
Low Yield
Insoluble Precipitate, Low 260/230
High-Quality RNA
High Salt
Extra Chloroform
LowQuality RNA
High-Quality RNA
LowQuality RNA
Low Yield
Insoluble Precipitate, Low 260/230
Degraded RNA, Low 260/280
High-Quality RNA
Potassium Acetate (+ High Salt)
Extra Chloroform (+Acid Phenol)
II-B. Modified PRIR
LowQuality RNA
High-Quality RNA
III. Guanidinium -Free
Recalcitrant tissue, high levels of secondary metabolites
Isolation Reagent, or (III) Guanidinium-Free. For most green tissues or tissues of unknown properties, the most simple and cost-effective method is the TriReagent Isolation. However, if the RNA from this method is of poor quality, assessed by the characteristics of the resultant RNA, it is possible to determine using the illustrated scheme which method will likely suit the specific tissue. Low-quality RNA can have a variety of characteristics. A low A260/A280 ratio is indicative of protein contamination, whereas a low A260/A230 ratio or an insoluble precipitate indicates polysaccharide, salt, or phenolic contamination. Low yield can be determined by an overall low OD. Although yield is not synonymous with low quality, it can lead to low quality if multiple preparations must be combined and contaminants become too concentrated. Furthermore, degraded RNA can be seen by visual inspection on an agarose gel. As discussed in the text, these methods and modifications should enable the extraction of high-quality RNA from almost any tissue type.
Fig. 1. The isolation of high-quality RNA from most plant tissues can be accomplished using a modified version of one of three extraction methods: (I) TriReagent, (II) Plant RNA
High-Quality RNA
LowQuality RNA
II-A. Basic PRIR
I-B. Modified TriReagent
I-A. Basic TriReagent
Degraded RNA, Low 260/280
High levels of polyphenolics polysaccharides, and fibrous tissue
Green tissue
34 Accerbi et al.
Roots Roots Roots Roots Roots inoculated w/ G. intraradices Roots inoculated w/ M. incognita Roots mock inoculated Roots, stripped Root hairs Nodules 14 dpi Nodules 14 dpi Nodules 21 dpi Stolon Rhizoid
Medicago Soybean Soybean Medicago Soybean Common bean Potato Miscanthus, Zostera
TriReagent TriReagent TriReagent TriReagent PRIR PRIR PRIR PRIR Potassium acetate, high salt
Medicago
Extra chloroform
Common Bean, Rice Marsilea, Medicago, Mimulus Zostera Nuphar Medicago
(continued)
Lettuce, orange, pepper, potato, rice, Silene, soybean, tobacco, wheat Amborella, Aristolochia Marsilea, Pumpkin Cycas, Ginkgo, Grapevine, Maize, Mimulus, Miscanthus, Nuphar, Petunia, Poplar, Sorghum, Switchgrass Banana Avocado Zostera Cotton Spruce
Speciesc
PRIR
TriReagent PRIR PRIR Guanidinium-Free TriReagent
PRIR PRIR PRIR PRIR PRIR PRIR
Leaves Leaves Leaves Leaves Leaves Needles
Radical tissues
High salt
TriReagent TriReagent
Leaves Leaves Extra chloroform Potassium acetate Extra chloroform, high salt Acid phenol, proteinase K, Extra chloroform Extra chloroform
Extra chloroform
Modificationsb
TriReagent
Base methoda,b
Leaves
Foliage tissues
Tissue
Table 1 RNA isolation methods that retain small RNA from plant species
Methods for Isolation of Total RNA to Recover miRNAs 35
Whole flower Whole flower Whole flower Whole flower Whole flower Whole flower Spikelet Ovules Strobilus (cone) Strobilus (cone) Fruit Fruit Fruit Fruit Fruit Grain Seed pod Seeds Seeds Seeds 20 DAA
Reproductive tissues
Tissue
Table 1 (continued)
TriReagent PRIR PRIR PRIR PRIR Guanidinium-free PRIR PRIR PRIR PRIR PRIR PRIR PRIR PRIR Guanidinium-free PRIR PRIR TriReagent PRIR PRIR
Base methoda,b
Potassium acetate, high salt Small scale
Extra chloroform
Extra chloroform Potassium acetate Acid phenol, proteinase K, extra chloroform
Extra chloroform
Extra chloroform Potassium acetate Extra chloroform, high salt
Modificationsb
Lettuce, orange, rice, Silene, soybean, tobacco, pepper Aristolochia, avocado, common bean, petunia, potato Banana, cotton, pumpkin Grapevine Zostera Nuphar Barley, maize, Miscanthus, sorghum, switchgrass, wheat Cycas Cycas, Ginkgo Spruce Avocado Banana Grapevine Pepper Orange Sorghum Tobacco Soybean Common bean Medicago
Speciesc
36 Accerbi et al.
TriReagent PRIR PRIR TriReagent LS TriReagent PRIR PRIR TriReagent Extra chloroform, high salt Extra chloroform
Potassium acetate
Barley Poplar Poplar Pumpkin Chlamydomonas, Volvox Coleochaete, Klebsormidium, Spyrogira, Ulva Chara Porphyra
b
a
PRIR, Plant RNA Isolation Reagent® (Invitrogen); TriReagent® and TriReagent LS® (Molecular Research Center, Inc.) See details in Methods section c See http://smallrna.udel.edu
Seedlings Xylem Xylem, tension Phloem sap Algal thallus Algal thallus Algal thallus Algal thallus
Other tissues
Methods for Isolation of Total RNA to Recover miRNAs 37
38
Accerbi et al.
2. Materials 2.1. General Materials and Reagents Needed to Perform the RNA Extractions Described
1. Instruments: (a) Centrifuge with rotor (15,000 × g) (b) Microcentrifuge (c) Spectrophotometer 2. RNase-free mortars, pestles and spatulas: wrap in foil and bake at 220°C at least 12 hours. 3. RNase-free tips, microcentrifuge tubes and 13 ml sterile centrifuge tubes are commercially available; 30 ml non-disposable centrifuge tubes are treated as follows: (a) Soak tubes in 3% hydrogen peroxide at least 1 h; rinse well with DEPC-water and let air dry. (b) Alternatively, soak tubes in 0.1% DEPC-water overnight and let air dry. (c) Autoclaving is recommended for tubes being used beyond the extraction buffer and organic solvent steps. 4. RNase-free chemicals: solutions must be made with DEPCtreated distilled water and sterilized. 5. DEPC-water: add 0.05% DEPC to distilled water, stir overnight and autoclave. RNase-free water is also available commercially. 6. Liquid nitrogen. 7. Gloves: make sure you are wearing clean gloves at all times when handling RNA solutions.
2.2. Plant RNA Isolation Reagent®
1. Plant RNA Isolation Reagent (PRIR) (Invitrogen, Cat. No. 12322-012).
2.2.1. Materials
2. 5 M NaCl. 3. Chloroform. 4. Isopropyl alcohol. 5. 75% ethanol. 75% ethanol is stored at −20°C and used cold. 6. RNase-free water.
2.2.2. Optional Materials
1. High salt solution: 0.8 M sodium citrate, 1.2 M NaCl. 2. Acid phenol:chloroform:isoamyl alcohol 125:24:1, pH 4.5 (Ambion, Cat. No. AM9720). 3. 2 M Potassium acetate, pH 5.5. 4. Proteinase K 20 mg/ml. 5. SDS 20%. 6. 3 M Sodium acetate, pH 5.2. 7. Ethanol.
2.3. Plant RNA Isolation Reagent®: Small Scale Procedure for Medicago truncatula Developing Seeds (20 Days After Anthesis, DAA)
Methods for Isolation of Total RNA to Recover miRNAs
39
1. PRIR, Invitrogen, Cat. No. 12322-012. 2. 5 M NaCl. 3. Chloroform. 4. 2 M Potassium acetate, pH 5.5. 5. High salt solution: 0.8 M sodium citrate, 1.2 M NaCl. 6. Isopropyl alcohol. 7. 75% ethanol. 8. RNase-free water. 9. 3 M Sodium acetate, pH 5.2. 10. Ethanol.
2.4. TriReagent ® / TRIzol® RNA Isolation
1. TriReagent® (Molecular Research Center, Cat. No. TR-118) or TRIzol® (Invitrogen, Cat. No.15596-018).
2.4.1. Materials
2. Chloroform or 1-bromo-3-chloropropane (BCP). 3. Isopropyl alcohol. 4. 75% ethanol. 5. RNase-free water.
2.4.2. Optional Materials
1. Acid phenol:chloroform:isoamyl alcohol 125:24:1, pH 4.5 (Ambion, Cat. No. AM9720). 2. 3 M Sodium acetate, pH 5.2. 3. Ethanol.
2.5. TriReagent LS ® RNA Isolation
1. TriReagent LS® (Molecular Research Center, Cat. No. TS-120). 2. 20 mg/ml glycogen or Polyacryl Carrier® (Molecular Research Center, Cat. No. PC-152). 3. Chloroform or BCP. 4. Isopropyl alcohol. 5. 75% ethanol. 6. RNase-free water.
2.6. Guanidinium-Free RNA Isolation
1. Extraction buffer: (a) 100 mM TrisHCl, pH 9.0 (b) 200 mM NaCl (c) 15 mM EDTA, pH 8.0 (d) 0.5% Sarkosyl (e) 8 ml/ml 2-mercaptoethanol added just prior to use. 2. Tris-HCl saturated phenol, pH 6.7. 3. Phenol:chloroform:isoamyl alcohol, 25:24:1.
40
Accerbi et al.
4. Chloroform:isoamyl alcohol, 24:1. 5. Isopropyl alcohol. 6. 3 M Sodium acetate, pH 5.2. 7. 70% ethanol. 8. RNase-free water.
3. Methods 3.1. Grinding of Plant Material with Mortar and Pestle in Liquid Nitrogen
The following general guidelines apply to any RNA work described in this chapter. The tissue must remain frozen at all times during grinding to avoid release of ribonucleases. Keep adding liquid nitrogen to the mortar as soon as it evaporates. 1. Freeze mortar and pestle at −80°C for at least 1 h. 2. Working on a clean bench, pour some liquid nitrogen in the mortar to chill it. 3. Add the sample to the mortar and start grinding gently to break the bigger pieces. Increase grinding speed and force as the powder becomes finer. Keep adding liquid nitrogen and grind until no tissue particles are visible; typically, sufficiently ground green tissue appears almost white. 4. Chill an RNase-free spatula in liquid nitrogen and transfer the frozen powder to a tube containing the extraction buffer (see step 1 of chosen method). 5. Immediately close the tube and vortex to dissolve any clumps, no more than a few seconds. 6. Quickly unscrew the tube cap to release any pressure which may have arisen due to the evaporation of residual liquid nitrogen. This step is particularly important if the transferred powder looks wet, indicating that the liquid nitrogen has not completely evaporated. 7. Close the tube and continue vortexing for the amount of time indicated in the method of choice (generally in step 1); make sure no clumps of powder are visible. 8. Proceed with the extraction method of choice, generally starting with step 2.
3.2. Plant RNA Isolation Reagent® 3.2.1. General Information
This procedure is adapted from the manufacturer’s protocol (Invitrogen) “Large-Scale RNA Isolation” with the following changes: 1. If you do not know the weight of the sample, estimate the amount of reagent to use by the sample volume: use about 1 ml of loosely packed ground frozen tissue per 10 ml of reagent.
Methods for Isolation of Total RNA to Recover miRNAs
41
2. All centrifugations are carried out at 10,000–12,000 × g in 13 ml or 30 ml centrifuge tubes. 3. Clarification of the extract is achieved by centrifugation instead of filtering. 3.2.2. Procedure
1. Add the frozen ground tissue to a tube containing PRIR and mix thoroughly by vortexing, about 1 min. 2. Incubate for 5 min at room temperature, laying the tube on its side with gentle shaking. 3. Centrifuge 10 min, 4°C at 12,000 × g to precipitate insoluble material; transfer the clarified supernatant to a clean tube (see Note 1). 4. Per 10 ml of clarified supernatant, add 2 ml of 5 M NaCl and mix by inverting the tube, then add 6 ml of chloroform and mix by vortexing. 5. Centrifuge 10 min, 4°C at 12,000 × g to separate the phases; transfer the top aqueous phase to a clean tube, being careful not to disturb the interface. Recovery should be 8–10 ml (see Note 2). 6. Precipitate the RNA by adding 0.9 volumes of isopropyl alcohol and mix gently by inverting the tube 5–6 times (see Notes 3 and 4). 7. Incubate for 10–15 min at room temperature. 8. Centrifuge 30 min, 4°C at 12,000 × g to precipitate the RNA. Gently decant the supernatant, taking care not to disturb the pellet. 9. Wash the pellet by adding 5–10 ml of cold 75% ethanol and mix by vortexing. 10. Centrifuge 10 min, 4°C at 12,000 × g. 11. Gently decant the ethanol, taking care not to disturb the pellet. Briefly centrifuge to collect all residual liquid and remove it with a pipette; air dry the pellet, but not completely. 12. Dissolve the RNA pellet in RNase-free water and transfer it to a clean microcentrifuge tube (see Notes 5 and 6). 13. Measure the OD of the RNA. Good-quality RNA should have an A260/A280 ratio > 1.7 and an A260/A230 > 1.4 (see Note 6 and Subheading 3.7.2 below).
3.3. Plant RNA Isolation Reagent®: Small Scale Procedure for Medicago truncatula Developing Seeds (20 Days After Anthesis, DAA)
14. Store the RNA at −80°C. With this plant material, the RNA obtained by pooling numerous small scale extractions was of better quality than any single large-scale preparation. 1. Grind about 30 seeds in liquid nitrogen with mortar and pestle.
42
Accerbi et al.
2. Add the frozen ground tissue to a tube containing 6 ml of PRIR (0.5 ml PRIR/0.1 g tissue) and mix thoroughly by vortexing, about 1 min. 3. Incubate for 5 min at room temperature, laying the tube on its side with gentle shaking. 4. Divide the buffer-tissue mix in 0.5 ml aliquots into 1.5 ml microcentrifuge tubes. 5. Centrifuge 5 min, 4°C at 12,000 × g. 6. Transfer the supernatant to clean tubes. 7. To each supernatant, add 100 ml of 5 M NaCl and mix by vortexing, then add 300 ml of chloroform and mix by vortexing. 8. Centrifuge 15 min, 4°C at 12,000 × g. 9. Transfer the upper phase to clean tubes. 10. To the upper phase add an equal volume of 2 M KOAc. 11. Incubate on ice for 1 h. 12. Centrifuge 15 min, 4°C at 12,000 × g. 13. Transfer the supernatant to clean tubes. 14. To each supernatant, add ½ volume high salt solution and mix by inverting the tube, then add ½ volume isopropyl alcohol and mix by inverting the tube. 15. Centrifuge 10 min, 4°C at 12,000 × g. 16. Wash the pellet by adding 0.5 ml of cold 75% ethanol and mix. 17. Centrifuge 3 min, 4°C at 12,000 × g. 18. Gently decant the ethanol, taking care not to disturb the pellet. Briefly centrifuge to collect all residual liquid and remove it with a pipette; air dry the pellet, but not completely. 19. Dissolve RNA in 20 ml of RNase-free water. 20. Pool all the RNA fractions and OD the resulting solution. If the ratios are not optimal (A260/A280 < 1.7 and A260/A230 < 1.4), proceed to step 21; expect 50–60% recovery. 21. To the RNA solution, add 1/10 volume of 3 M NaOAc (pH 5.4) and mix by inverting the tube, then add 2 volumes of ethanol and mix by inverting the tube. 22. Incubate at −80°C for at least 2 h. 23. Centrifuge 20 min, 4°C at 12,000 × g. 24. Wash the pellet by adding 1 ml of cold 75% ethanol and mix. 25. Centrifuge 10 min, 4°C at 12,000 × g. 26. Gently decant the ethanol, taking care not to disturb the pellet. Briefly centrifuge to collect all residual liquid and remove it with a pipette; air dry the pellet, but not completely.
Methods for Isolation of Total RNA to Recover miRNAs
43
27. Dissolve RNA in RNase-free water. For high concentration, dissolve the pellet in less than half the volume in step 19. 3.4. TriReagent ®/ TRIzol ® RNA Isolation
This is an RNA extraction buffer based on phenol and guanidine thiocyanate (6, 8) commercially sold under the names of TriReagent® by Molecular Research Center and TRIzol® by Invitrogen. Use no more than 1 g of tissue per 10 ml of TriReagent®/TRIzol®. 1. Add 1 g of frozen ground tissue to a tube containing 10 ml of TriReagent®/TRIzol® and mix thoroughly by vortexing, about 1 min. 2. Incubate for 5–10 min at room temperature, laying the tube on its side with gentle shaking. 3. Add 1 ml (1/10 volume) of BCP or 2 ml of chloroform and mix by vortexing. 4. Centrifuge 15 min, 4°C at 10,000 × g to separate the phases. 5. Transfer the top aqueous phase to a clean tube, being careful not to disturb the interface. Recovery should be 6–7 ml (see Note 7). 6. Precipitate the RNA by adding 0.9 volumes of isopropyl alcohol and mix gently by inverting the tube 5–6 times. 7. Incubate for 10–15 min at room temperature. 8. Centrifuge 15 min, 4°C at 10,000 × g to precipitate the RNA. Gently decant the supernatant, taking care not to disturb the pellet. 9. Wash the pellet by adding 10 ml of cold 75% ethanol and mix. 10. Centrifuge 10 min, 4°C at 10,000 × g. 11. Gently decant the ethanol, taking care not to disturb the pellet. Briefly centrifuge to collect all residual liquid and remove it with a pipette; air dry the pellet for 1–2 min. 12. Dissolve the RNA pellet in RNase-free water and transfer it to a clean microcentrifuge tube (see Note 8).
3.5. TriReagent LS ® RNA Isolation
TriReagent LS® is a more concentrated version of TriReagent®/ TRIzol® suitable for RNA extraction from liquid samples. Use a volume ratio TriReagent LS®:sample of 3:1. With pumpkin phloem sap, we had the best results when multiple samples were combined before the extraction as described below. 1. Harvest 250 ml of phloem sap directly into 1.5 ml microcentrifuge tubes containing 750 ml of TriReagent LS®; keep the tubes frozen until ready to proceed with the RNA extraction. 2. Thaw the samples by vortexing. 3. Centrifuge 5 min, 4°C at 13,000 × g to precipitate insoluble material. 4. Combine the clarified supernatant from 6 samples in a 13 ml centrifuge tube and add 1 ml of TriReagent LS®; mix well.
44
Accerbi et al.
5. Add 8 ml of glycogen or Polyacryl Carrier® and mix. 6. Add 0.1 ml of BCP per 0.75 ml of TriReagent LS®, about 750 ml, and mix by vortexing. 7. Incubate for 5–15 min at room temperature. 8. Centrifuge 15 min, 4°C at 12,000 × g. 9. Transfer the upper phase to a clean tube, being careful not to disturb the interphase. Recovery should be 60–70% of the original TriReagent LS® volume (3.5–3.8 ml). 10. Precipitate the RNA: to the upper phase, add 0.7 ml of isopropyl alcohol per 0.75 ml of TriReagent LS® (about 4 ml) and mix gently. 11. Incubate for 10–15 min at room temperature. 12. Centrifuge 15 min, 4°C at 10,000 × g to precipitate the RNA. Decant the supernatant gently, taking care not to disturb the pellet. 13. Wash the pellet by adding 7 ml of cold 75% ethanol and mix. 14. Centrifuge 10 min, 4°C at 10,000 × g. 15. Gently decant the ethanol, taking care not to disturb the pellet. Briefly centrifuge to collect all residual liquid and remove it with a pipette; air dry the pellet for 1–2 min. 16. Dissolve the RNA pellet in 30–40 ml of RNase-free water, and transfer it to a clean microcentrifuge tube. 3.6. Guanidinium-Free RNA Isolation
This isolation method is based on (11), with modifications by M. Perez-Amador (personal communication, Instituto de Biologia Molecular y Celular de Plantas, Valencia, Spain), and adapted for the recovery of small RNA molecules. 1. Add 0.5–1 g of frozen ground tissue to a 13 ml tube containing 4 ml of extraction buffer with 2-mercaptoethanol and mix thoroughly by vortexing. 2. Add 4 ml of phenol and mix by vortexing. 3. Add 0.8 ml of chloroform:isoamyl alcohol and mix by vortexing. 4. Add 280 ml of 3 M NaOAc pH 5.2 and mix by vortexing. 5. Incubate for 10–15 min on ice. 6. Centrifuge 10 min, 4°C at 10,000 × g. 7. Transfer the upper phase to a clean tube, being careful not to disturb the interphase. 8. Add 4 ml of phenol:chloroform:isoamyl alcohol and mix by vortexing. 9. Centrifuge 10 min, 4°C at 10,000 × g.
Methods for Isolation of Total RNA to Recover miRNAs
45
10. Transfer the upper phase to a clean tube; if there is still a large interphase, repeat the phenol:chloroform:isoamyl alcohol extraction. 11. Add an equal volume of chloroform:isoamyl alcohol and mix by vortexing. 12. Centrifuge 10 min, 4°C at 10,000 × g. 13. Transfer the upper phase to a clean tube. 14. Add an equal volume of isopropyl alcohol and mix gently. 15. Incubate on ice 30 min to 2 h or at −80°C overnight. 16. Centrifuge 10 min, 4°C at 10,000 × g. 17. Gently decant the supernatant, taking care not to disturb the pellet. 18. Wash the pellet by adding 5 ml of cold 70% ethanol and mix. 19. Centrifuge 10 min, 4°C at 10,000 × g. 20. Gently decant the ethanol, taking care not to disturb the pellet. Briefly centrifuge to collect all residual liquid and remove it with a pipette; air dry the pellet for 1–2 min. 21. Dissolve the RNA pellet in RNase-free water and transfer it to a clean microcentrifuge tube. 3.7. Evaluation of RNA Quality
Plant RNA preparations may contain traces of soluble and/or insoluble contaminants that have escaped the purification process; this happens when the capacity of the extraction buffer is exceeded and the contaminants are carried over through the purification steps. The evaluation of the total RNA quality can be divided into three steps: inspection of the RNA pellet and its resuspension, OD reading, and inspection of the RNA using gel electrophoresis.
3.7.1. Inspection of RNA Pellet and Resuspension
Carry-over of undesirable contaminants can sometimes be recognized from the abnormal size or color of the RNA pellet prior to resuspension. Although soluble anthocyanins and other pigments can still be present at the beginning of the purification process, a colored pellet after isopropyl alcohol precipitation and ethanol wash is often an indication of impure RNA. In particular, brown pellets can result from the oxidation and decomposition of phenolic compounds (12). An RNA pellet rich in polysaccharides dissolves quite easily in RNase-free water, but the solution will be viscous (see Note 4(b), steps (1)-(10)). In addition, presence of polyphenolic compounds makes the RNA pellet difficult to dissolve. In these cases, a freezethaw-centrifuge step (see Note 6) should be taken before further assessing the RNA quality.
46
Accerbi et al.
3.7.2. OD Reading
RNA quality can be evaluated by measuring the UV absorbance of the preparation at different wavelengths. Nucleic acids have a peak of absorbance at 260 nm (A260), proteins at 280 nm (A280) and polysaccharides mostly at 230 nm (A230) (13, 14). The ratios A260/A280 and A260/A230 are generally used as indicators of protein and polysaccharide contamination. Good-quality RNA should have an A260/A280 ratio in the 1.7–2.0 range and an A260/A230 ratio in the 1.4–2.0 range.
3.7.3. Electrophoresis
Running an aliquot of the RNA sample on an agarose gel is the most common method used to evaluate the integrity of total RNA preparations. On non-denaturing 1% agarose gels, partially degraded RNA samples appear as a wide-ranging smear, with no clear bands representing the 28S and 18S rRNA molecules expected in eukaryotic samples. Fully degraded RNA will appear as a very low molecular weight smear. On denaturing agarose gels, it is possible to determine the quality of the RNA by comparing the intensity of the 28S and 18S rRNA bands: in good-quality RNA, the 28S rRNA band should be more intense than the 18S. An alternative to the traditional gel-based approaches is the new microfluidics technology, where electrophoresis is performed on a miniaturized scale on a glass chip (e.g., Agilent 2100 Bioanalyzer, www.agilent.com). These instruments offer high sensitivity, minimal sample consumption, and high resolution. The output is presented as electropherograms and gel-like images, which allow visual inspection of the RNA quality much like an agarose or denaturing gel.
4. Notes 1. If the tissue contains high levels of ribonucleases, a treatment with proteinase K followed by an extraction with acid phenol will help to minimize RNA degradation. Add the following steps before the chloroform extraction, step 4: (a) To the clarified supernatant, add SDS to obtain a final concentration of 0.5%. (b) Add proteinase K to a final concentration of 400– 500 mg/ml. (c) Incubate 15–30 min at 55°C, or according to the proteinase K manufacturer. (d) Add an equal volume of acid phenol:chloroform 5:1 solution, pH 4.5, and mix by vortexing. (e) Centrifuge 10 min, 4°C at 12,000 × g.
Methods for Isolation of Total RNA to Recover miRNAs
47
(f) Transfer the top aqueous phase to a clean tube. (g) Proceed to step 4. 2. Do an extra chloroform extraction if (1) the interphase is thick and/or loose; (2) during transfer, the upper phase gets contaminated with interphase; or (3) you seek to maximize the extraction. Extra chloroform extraction after step 5: (a) To the transferred top aqueous phase add an equal volume of chloroform and mix by vortexing. (b) Centrifuge 10 min, 4°C at 12,000 × g. (c) Transfer the new top aqueous phase to a clean tube. Recovery should be 6–8 ml. (d) Proceed to step 6. 3. For tissues rich in polysaccharides, precipitation of RNA in the presence of high salt will sometimes improve the quality. Replace step 6 with the following step: To the aqueous phase add ½ volume high salt solution, and mix by inverting the tube. Then add ½ volume (aqueous + salt) isopropyl alcohol and mix by inverting the tube. 4. For tissues rich in carbohydrates/polysaccharides, a potassium acetate precipitation will sometimes improve the quality. This precipitation can be done after chloroform extraction (step 5), when RNA of low quality is expected, or after the RNA has been dissolved in DEPC-H2O and its A260/A230 ratio is 1 or less. In the latter case, some RNA will be lost with the precipitation. a. For potassium acetate precipitation after chloroform extraction, replace step 6 with the following: 1. Aliquot the supernatant into two tubes (4–5 ml in each) and add an equal volume of 2 M KOAc. 2. Mix by vortexing. 3. Incubate for 1 h on ice. 4. Centrifuge 30 min, 4°C at 10,000 × g. 5. Transfer the supernatant to new tubes. Some pellet may be visible. 6. To the supernatant add ½ volume of high salt solution and mix by inverting the tube. Then add ½ volume isopropyl alcohol and mix by inverting the tube. b. For potassium acetate precipitation after the RNA has been dissolved, continue with the following after step 14: 1. To the RNA solution add 1/10 volume of 2 M KOAc, pH 5.5 and mix. 2. Incubate for 10 min on ice.
48
Accerbi et al.
3. Centrifuge 15 min, 4°C at 13,000 × g to precipitate insoluble material; transfer the supernatant to a clean tube. 4. Precipitate the RNA by adding 0.9 volumes of isopropyl alcohol and mix gently by inverting the tube 5–6 times. 5. Incubate for 1 h at −20°C. 6. Centrifuge 25 min, 4°C at 13,000 × g to precipitate the RNA. Gently decant the supernatant, taking care not to disturb the pellet. 7. Wash the pellet by adding 1 ml of cold 75% ethanol and mix by vortexing. 8. Centrifuge 10 min, 4°C at 13,000 × g. 9. Gently decant the ethanol, taking care not to disturb the pellet. Briefly centrifuge to collect all residual liquid and remove it with a pipette; air dry the pellet, but not completely. 10. Dissolve the RNA pellet in RNase-free water and transfer it to a clean microcentrifuge tube. 5. We generally resuspend to a final concentration of ~0.5– 1.0 mg/ml. For Arabidopsis leaves, this corresponds to a resuspension volume of about 0.5 ml for a total RNA prep from about 1 g of tissue, although recovery from different tissues and plants can vary considerably. It should be noted that if the recovery is very low, the A260/A280 can be misleading and overestimate the effective yield, presumably because the proportion of background contaminants contributing to the absorption is greater. 6. If insoluble material is visible in the RNA solution, remove it as follows: (a) Freeze the RNA at −80°C for at least 30 min. (b) Thaw by vortexing and centrifuge 10 min, 4°C at 12,000 × g to precipitate insoluble material. (c) Transfer the supernatant to a clean microcentrifuge tube and determine the OD. 7. Extra BCP/chloroform extraction (a) To the transferred top aqueous phase add ½ volume of BCP or an equal volume of chloroform and mix by vortexing. (b) Centrifuge 10 min, 4°C at 10,000 × g. (c) Transfer the upper phase to a clean tube. Recovery should be 5–6 ml. 8. If the RNA quality is less than optimal, an acid phenol extraction should help to improve it.
Methods for Isolation of Total RNA to Recover miRNAs
49
(a) To the RNA solution in a microcentrifuge tube add ½ volume of acid phenol:chloroform:isoamyl alcohol and mix by vortexing. (b) Centrifuge 8 min, 4°C at 13,000 × g. (c) Transfer the upper phase to a clean tube, add ½ volume of acid phenol:chloroform:isoamyl alcohol and mix by vortexing. (d) Centrifuge 8 min, 4°C at 13,000 × g. (e) Transfer the upper phase to a clean tube, add an equal volume of chloroform and mix by vortexing. (f) Centrifuge 8 min, 4°C at 13,000 × g. (g) Transfer the upper phase to a clean tube. If the upper phase is viscous, repeat the chloroform extraction. Otherwise, proceed as follows: add 1/10 volume of 3 M NaOAc pH 5.2 and mix, then add 2 volumes of ethanol and mix. (h) Incubate 15–20 min at −80°C. (i) Centrifuge 20 min, 4°C at 13,000 × g. (j) Wash the pellet with 500 ml of 75% cold ethanol. (k) Centrifuge 8 min, 4°C at 13,000 × g. (l) Gently decant the ethanol, taking care not to disturb the pellet. Briefly centrifuge to collect all residual liquid and remove it with a pipette; air dry the pellet, but not completely. (m) Dissolve RNA in RNase-free water.
Acknowledgments The methods described in this chapter were developed with support from NSF, USDA and DOE.
References 1. Geuna F, Hartings H, Scienza A (1998) A new method for rapid extraction of high quality RNA from recalcitrant tissues in grapevine. Plant Mol Biol Rep 16:61–67 2. Salzman RA, Fugita T, Zhu-Salzman K, Haswgawa PM, Bressman RA (1999) An impr oved RNA isolation method for plant tissues containing high levels of phenolic compound or carbohydrates. Plant Mol Biol Rep 17: 11–17
3. Tai HH, Pelletier C, Beardmore T (2004) Total RNA isolation from Pica mariana dry seed. Plant Mol Biol Rep 22:93a–93e 4. Yeh K, Juang R, Su J (1991) A rapid and efficient method for RNA isolation from plant with high carbohydrate content. Focus 13:102–103 5. Wallace DM (1987) Precipitation of Nucleic Acids. Meth Enzymol 152:41–48 6. Chomczynski P, Sacchi N (1987) Single-step method of RNA isolation by acid guanidinium
50
Accerbi et al.
thiocyanate-phenol-chloroform extraction. Anal Biochem 162:156–159 7. Chomczynski P, Sacchi N (2006) The single-step method of RNA isolation by acid guanidinium sothiocyanate-phenol-chloroformextraction: wenty-something years on. Nat Protoc 1: 581–585 8. Chomczynski P (1993) A reagent for the single-step simultaneous isolation of RNA, DNA, and proteins from cell and tissue samples. BioTechniques 15:532–537 9. Grahm GC (1993) A method of extracting total RNA from Pinus radiata and other conifers. Plant Mol Biol Rep 11:32–37 10. Siju S, Madhubala R, Bhat AI (2006) Sodium sulphite enhances RNA isolation and sensitivity of Cucumber mosaic virus detection by
RT-PCR in black pepper. J Virol Methods 141:107–110 11. Bugos RC, Chiang VL, Zhang XH, Campbell ER, Podila GK, Campbell WH (1995) RNA isolation from plant tissues recalcitrant to extraction in guanidine. BioTechniques 19: 734–737 12. Loomis WD (1974) Overcoming problems of phenolics and quinones in the isolation of plant enzymes and organelles. Meth Enzymol 31:528–544 13. Logemann J, Schell J, Willmitzer L (1987) Improved method for the isolation of RNA from plant tissues. Anal Biochem 163:16–20 14. Manning K (1990) Isolation of nucleic acids from plants by differential solvent precipitation. Anal Biochem 195:45–50
Chapter 4 miRNA Target Prediction in Plants Noah Fahlgren and James C. Carrington Abstract In plants, miRNA bind to target RNAs with a high degree of complementarity. In this chapter, a simple method for computationally predicting plant miRNA targets, using a position-dependent scoring system, is described. Key words: MicroRNA, miRNA, Target prediction, Plant, Database search
1. Introduction miRNAs are key regulators of plant growth, development, and responses to biotic and abiotic stress (1). Plant miRNAs act as guides for effector complexes that usually regulate messenger RNA (mRNA) in a sequence-specific manner. miRNAs of plants typically guide cleavage of target RNAs (1). Cleavage of mRNA requires a high degree of miRNA:target base pairing, especially at the 5¢ and central positions of the duplex relative to the miRNA (2, 3). Figure 1a shows that most mismatches in authentic miRNA:target duplexes in Arabidopsis thaliana are at the first position and after position 13 relative to the 5¢ end of the miRNA. In contrast, positions 2–13 are relatively mismatch-free and contain somewhat fewer G:U base pairs. These base-pairing patterns led to the development of computational methods for predicting plant miRNA targets based on a position-dependent scoring matrix (4, 5). miRNA sequences are first aligned to potential targets using permissive alignment settings to ensure that all possible miRNA:target interactions are captured. Next, miRNA:target alignments are scored. Mismatches and single-nucleotide bulges or gaps are B.C. Meyers and P.J. Green (eds.), Plant MicroRNAs, Methods in Molecular Biology, vol. 592 DOI 10.1007/978-1-60327-005-2_4, © Humana Press, a part of Springer Science + Business Media, LLC 2010
51
Fahlgren and Carrington
a Percent of total base pairs per position
B & W IN PRINT
52
60%
Bulges G:U pairs Mismatches
50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0%
1
2
3 4 5 6 7
8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24
Basepair position relative to the miRNA 5’ end
b
Mismatch: score = 1
G:U base pair: score = 1 (0.5 x 2)
At4g36920: 5’ CUGCAGCAUCAUCAGGAUUCU 3’ |||||||||||||:|||||| ath-miR172a: 3’ UACGUCGUAGUAGUUCUAAGA 5’
Total score = 2
2x Score Penalty Region
Fig. 1. (a) The distribution of mismatches, single-nucleotide bulges, and G:U base pairs along 155 authentic miRNA:target duplexes from A. thaliana. The set of 155 duplexes is made up of unique miRNA sequences from each MIRNA gene family with an experimentally validated target, and unique target site sequences from the same validated target families. Position 1 corresponds to the 5¢ end of the miRNA. Each position shows the percent of total base pairs at that position that are bulged, G:U, and mismatched. (b) Arabidopsis miR172a and a target (At4g36920), illustrating the alignment scoring system used to predict targets. The gray box highlights positions 2 through 13, relative to the miRNA 5¢ end, indicating the region where penalty scores are doubled.
assessed for penalty of +1 while G:U base pairs are assessed for penalty of +0.5. Penalty scores from mismatches, bulges, gaps, and G:U pairs between positions 2 through 13 are doubled due to stricter base-pairing requirements within this region (see Fig. 1b). A maximum score cutoff that balances sensitivity and specificity of the algorithm is selected. Finally, phylogenetic and wet-bench methods can be used to validate computational predictions.
2. Materials (see Note 1) 1. 2× AMD Opteron 285 Dual Core computer with 4 GB of RAM running CentOS 3. 2. PERL, v5.8.0 built for x86_64-thread-multi.
miRNA Target Prediction in Plants
53
3. FASTA34. 4. miRNA sequences. 5. Transcript, EST, and genomic sequences.
3. Methods We generated a PERL script that aligns miRNA to sequences in a target database using FASTA34, parses the FASTA34 alignments, and scores the alignments. Subheadings 3.2 and 3.3 describe these steps in detail. 3.1. Setup of Target Sequence FASTA Database
1. Download transcript, EST, genome, or other sequences of interest (see Note 2). 2. Reformat sequences to FASTA format, if necessary. Example: >AT1G51370.2 | Symbols: | F-box family protein | chr1:1904928319050493 FORWARD ATGGTGGGTGGCAAGAAGAAAACCAAGATATGTGACAAAGTGTCACATGAGGAAGATAGGATAAGCCAGTTACCGGAACCTTTGATATCTGAAATACTTTTTCATCTTTCTACCAAGGACTCTGTCAGAACAAGCGCTTTGTCTACCAAATGGAG… 3. The FASTA-formatted sequences should be stored in a single plain-text file (database.file). This will be used as an input for FASTA34.
3.2. Generation of miRNA:Target Alignments
The program FASTA34 is used to generate alignments between a miRNA sequence and all of the potential target sequences in the database set up in Subheading 3.1 (see Note 3). FASTA34 searches for sequence similarity by identifying direct matches, not base pairing, between two sequences. Therefore, set FASTA34 to align the reverse complement of the miRNA with prospective target sequences, and to accommodate position pairs corresponding to G:U base pairs. Note that this will result in some incorrect G:U pairs that will be disallowed at a later step (see Subheading 3.3). The alignment step is not used as a filtering step, so permissive gap, match, and mismatch settings for FASTA34 are applied. 1. Use the following settings for FASTA34: (a) n (forces the query sequence to be treated as nucleotide) (b) H (suppresses the score distribution histogram from the output) (c) Q (prevents FASTA34 from prompting for input)
54
Fahlgren and Carrington
(d) f (gap opening penalty, set this to –16) (e) r (match reward/mismatch penalty, set this to +15/−10) (f) w (alignment line length, set this to 100) (g) W (additional sequence context length, set this to 25) (h) b (the number of alignments to be included in the output, set this to a number larger than the number of sequences in the target database) (i) i (limits the search to reverse complement alignments only) (j) U (changes the scoring matrix to allow for G:A, T:C, or U:C matches, in other words it allows for G:U base pairs) (k) O (output filename) ktup (the number of seed matches minimally required for the program to build an alignment, set this to 1, see Note 4) 2. Place the miRNA sequence in a FASTA-formatted plain-text file (miRNA.file). This will be used as an input for FASTA34. 3. Run FASTA34 to generate alignments. Example command line setup: fasta34 –n –H –Q –f –16 –r +15/-10 –w 100 –W 25 –b 100000 –i –U –O output.file miRNA.file database.file 1 Note: the number at the end of the command is the ktup value. 3.3. Scoring Alignments
1. For each alignment (see Subheading 3.2), parse out the name of the sequence matched and the miRNA:target duplex sequences. Complement, but do not reverse, the miRNA sequence. 2. Using the parsed sequences, score each alignment using the following position-dependent scoring rules (see Fig. 1b): (a) Mismatches, single-nucleotide gaps or single-nucleotide bulges are assessed for a penalty of +1. (b) G:U base pairs are assessed for a penalty of +0.5. (c) Penalty scores are doubled at positions 2 through 13 relative to the 5¢ end of the miRNA. 3. Additionally, reject alignments that have: (a) More than one single-nucleotide bulge or gap. (b) More than seven total mismatches, G:U base pairs, bulges, and gaps. (c) More than four total mismatches or four total G:U base pairs.
3.4. Assessing Results
The miRNA target prediction method yields prediction scores starting at zero for a perfect miRNA:target duplex and caps at 11, the maximum score possible within the constraints listed above
miRNA Target Prediction in Plants
55
(four mismatches, one bulge or gap, and two G:U base pairs all between positions 2 through 13 relative to the 5¢ end of the miRNA, see Subheading 3.3). A reasonable score cutoff must be used to preserve specificity and maximize sensitivity. Previous work in A. thaliana has shown that a cutoff of 3.5 maintains reasonable sensitivity and specificity (6–8). Decreasing the cutoff will increase specificity but at the expense of sensitivity. To estimate the sensitivity, a set of previously validated targets must be available. 1. Start by predicting targets for miRNA with previously validated targets. 2. The sensitivity is calculated by determining the percentage of targets that fail to be predicted from the known set. Two approaches can be used to estimate specificity. 1. Start by predicting targets for miRNA with previously validated targets. 2. Specificity can be calculated by determining the percentage of the total predicted targets that are not known to be targets. OR Estimate the background signal by iteratively shuffling the miRNA sequences using a dinucleotide-preserving shuffle program (see Note 5) and predict targets (8). Background is the average number of targets predicted for the shuffled miRNA sequences. In addition to determining a prediction score cutoff, other data can be used to enhance predictions (see Note 6). For instance, conserved miRNA targets can be predicted efficiently by using a phylogenetic approach to search for miRNA target site conservation (5). Predicted sites can be validated as miRNA targets using wet-bench methods, such as the 5¢RACE assay, that experimentally detect miRNA-guided cleavage products (9).
4. Notes 1. There are many computer and program configurations that could feasibly substitute for those listed. PERL and FASTA34 are available for many computer operating systems, although necessary configurations may differ for each system. 2. Generally, it is easy to predict targets from a transcript database, but often potential targets (e.g., noncoding RNAs) are not well represented in transcript databases. Therefore, EST databases may contain additional targets. It is also possible to predict targets at the level of the genome to improve sensitivity if transcripts are not well annotated and ESTs are not available.
56
Fahlgren and Carrington
However, target sites that span exon-exon boundaries will be missed. 3. The program PATSCAN has been used in place of FASTA34 by others (5, 8). 4. FASTA34 uses a lookup table to search for sequences in the database that have potential to match the query sequence. The ktup value sets the minimum word size that has to match before FASTA34 will attempt to build an alignment between two sequences. For example, if ktup = 3 then FASTA34 will only align sequences that have at least three consecutive perfect matching nucleotides. Setting ktup = 1 means that each FASTA34 search is sensitive, but slow. 5. An algorithm for permutations that preserve dinucleotide content has been described by Altschul and Erickson (10). 6. Depending on the individual miRNA, other data can be used to enhance target predictions. For deeply conserved miRNA, expression profiling of transcripts in a general miRNA-defective mutant background, such as dcl1-7, can be used to search for targets that are upregulated in the absence of miRNA (3, 4, 6).
Acknowledgments We are grateful that research on miRNA targets in our lab is supported by National Science Foundation Grant MCB-0618433. We thank Christopher M. Sullivan, Scott A. Givan, Kristin D. Kasschau, Edwards Allen and Jason S. Cumbie for productive discussions and advice.
References 1. Jones-Rhoades MW, Bartel DP, Bartel B (2006) MicroRNAs and their regulatory roles in plants. Annu Rev Plant Biol 57:19–53 2. Mallory AC, Reinhart BJ, Jones-Rhoades MW, Tang G, Zamore PD, Barton MK, Bartel DP (2004) MicroRNA control of PHABULOSA in leaf development: Importance of pairing to the microRNA 5’ region. EMBO J 23: 3356–3364 3. Schwab R, Palatnik JF, Riester M, Schommer C, Schmid M, Weigel D (2005) Specific effects of microRNAs on the plant transcriptome. Dev Cell 8:517–527 4. Allen E, Xie Z, Gustafson AM, Carrington JC (2005) MicroRNA-directed phasing during
trans-acting siRNA biogenesis in plants. Cell 121:207–221 5. Jones-Rhoades MW, Bartel DP (2004) Compu tational identification of plant microRNAs and their targets, including a stress-induced miRNA. Mol Cell 14:787–799 6. Fahlgren N, Howell MD, Kasschau KD, Chapman EJ, Sullivan CM, Cumbie JS, Givan SA, Law TF, Grant SR, Dangl JL, Carrington JC (2007) High-throughput sequencing of Arabidopsis microRNAs: Evidence for frequent birth and death of MIRNA genes. PLoS ONE 2:e219 7. Howell MD, Fahlgren N, Chapman EJ, Cumbie JS, Sullivan CM, Givan SA, Kasschau KD,
Carrington JC (2007) Genome-wide analysis of the RNA-DEPENDENT RNA POLYME RASE6/DICER-LIKE4 pathway in Arabidopsis reveals dependency on miRNA- and tasiRNAdirected targeting. Plant Cell 19:926–942 8. Rajagopalan R, Vaucheret H, Trejo J, Bartel DP (2006) A diverse and evolutionarily fluid set of microRNAs in Arabidopsis thaliana. Genes Dev 20:3407–3425
miRNA Target Prediction in Plants
57
9. Llave C, Xie Z, Kasschau KD, Carrington JC (2002) Cleavage of scarecrow-like mRNA targets directed by a class of Arabidopsis miRNA. Science 297:2053–2056 10. Altschul SF, Erickson BW (1985) Significance of nucleotide sequence alignments: A method for random sequence permutation that preserves dinucleotide and codon usage. Mol Biol Evol 2:526–538
Chapter 5 A Method to Discover Phased siRNA Loci Michael J. Axtell Abstract Short, interfering RNAs (siRNAs) arise from the processing of long double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) by Dicer enzymes. Dicers generate siRNA duplexes by successive hydrolysis of both strands of the dsRNA phosphodiester backbone at positions determined by measuring 21–24 nucleotides from an exposed dsRNA terminus. Therefore, a population of dsRNAs with precisely identical termini will produce siRNA spaced in regular, 21–24-nucleotide intervals. This chapter presents an easily customized and generally applicable strategy for identifying loci which produce the “phased” siRNAs diagnostic of such processing. Given the input of a large set of expressed small RNAs and of the corresponding genome or transcriptome from which the small RNAs are derived, the methodology produces a ranking of user-defined loci with respect to their likely production of phased siRNAs. Top ranked loci are candidates for further computational and biological analyses. Key words: siRNA, microRNA, Trans-acting siRNA, Transitivity, Small RNA, Plants, Bioinformatics
1. Introduction Most of the currently known small RNAs expressed by plants can be broadly classified into two groups: those which arise from processing of the stems of single-stranded, stem-loop precursors, including the precisely excised microRNAs (miRNAs; (1–3)) and other less precisely processed stem-loop derived small RNAs (4, 5), and those which arise from processing of long, perfectly doublestranded dsRNA. This latter class comprises the endogenous siRNAs, and they comprise the majority of small RNA expression in wild-type Arabidopsis thaliana (6, 7). siRNA duplexes arise by the successive processing of dsRNA by Dicer enzymes, which in plants have been dubbed “Dicer-Like” (DCL). DCL enzymes “measure” and cleave dsRNA a characteristic distance (21–24 nts, depending upon the DCL in question) from a dsRNA terminus. Thus, for a B.C. Meyers and P.J. Green (eds.), Plant MicroRNAs, Methods in Molecular Biology, vol. 592 DOI 10.1007/978-1-60327-005-2_5, © Humana Press, a part of Springer Science + Business Media, LLC 2010
59
60
Axtell
population of dsRNAs with uniform termini, the population of siRNAs produced by DCL catalysis will be “phased” in consistent registers. Rather than emanating from random positions of the dsRNA precursor, they arise in discrete, periodic positions reflective of successive DCL-catalyzed cleavage from the dsRNA terminus. In plants, such phased siRNA loci have attracted much recent attention due to their combination of siRNA-type biogenesis with the trans targeting capability previously associated only with miRNAs (8–10), their importance in regulating developmental processes (11–17), the implications of their biogenesis for understanding the initiation of dsRNA formation (18), and their role in regulating the expression of rapidly expanding gene families (19). The currently known phased siRNA-generating loci in plants are all associated with small RNA-directed cleavage of a single-stranded precursor. After cleavage, one or the other of the cleaved products is thought to become a substrate for an endogenous RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (chiefly RDR6 in A. thaliana; (8, 9)), thus crea ting dsRNAs with termini precisely defined by the site of small RNA cleavage. Cleavage-stimulated production of dsRNA is especially potent for RNAs with more than one small RNA complementary site (18, 19), but also occurs on a subset of “single-cut” RNAs (7, 18, 20–22). In this chapter, I describe a simple methodology that can be used to discover loci producing siRNAs in “phased” positions indicative of processing from a population of dsRNAs with uniform termini. Rather than present a specific piece of software, a general, step-by-step description of the methodology is given in the form of both a succinct narrative and pseudocode for the critical steps. This method consists of, for a given locus, simply tallying the abundances of small RNAs whose 5¢ ends fall within each of the possible phased registers. For instance, when searching for loci where small RNAs are phased in increments of 21 nts, there are 21 possible registers. Metrics based upon both the proportion of small RNA abundance falling within the dominant register and upon the total amount of small RNA diversity corresponding to the locus are calculated and used to rank loci. Top ranked loci are those for which there are a large number of distinct corresponding small RNAs, of which a substantial proportion fall into a single phasing register. With appropriate cutoffs for the metrics, this simple ranking of loci has worked quite well to discover phased siRNAs from multiple plant species (18), but interested readers may also wish to consult other useful, alternative methods (see Note 1) .
2. Materials 1. A database of expressed small RNA sequences. 2. An abundance measurement for each small RNA sequence (see Note 2).
A Method to Discover Phased siRNA Loci
61
3. A reference database comprising the nuclear genome or transcriptome to which the small RNAs correspond. 4. A computer with NCBI BLAST software installed. 5. A computer with a useful programming language installed, such as PERL or Python (see Note 3).
3. Methods 3.1. Map the Sequenced Small RNAs to the Reference Database
The positions of the reference database that are identical in sequence to small RNAs are determined by simple sequence comparisons. These matching loci within the reference database represent the genomic origins of the expressed small RNAs. Depending on the goals of the experiment, the reference database may consist of an entire assembled genome (for instance the Arabidopsis pseudochromosome sequences), a database of mRNA transcripts, or some subset of similar sequences which might spawn phased siRNAs. Pseudocode: • For each sequenced small RNA: – For each sequence within the reference database: (a) Compare the two sequences (b) For each exact match: * Record the accession number of the matching small RNA * Record the accession number of the matched reference sequence * Record the matching strand of the reference (+ or −) * Record the start coordinate (the position within the matching reference database sequence identical to the 5¢ end of the small RNA) * Record the stop coordinate (the position within the matching reference database sequence identical to the 3¢ end of the small RNA) * Record the abundance value of the small RNA The output may be stored in a tab-delimited flat file, with one line for each small RNA, or in a custom database. Sequence comparisons between small RNAs and reference databases can be performed using BLAST (see Note 4).
3.2. Divide the Mapped Small RNA Coordinates into Intervals/Loci
Before searching for loci that produce abundant, phased siRNAs, the loci themselves must be defined. For instance, in a genome-wide search it might be useful to define each successive 1,000 base pair interval as a query locus, while a transcript-centered search might
62
Axtell
define each transcript as a potential locus. Mapped small RNAs are then associated with each locus or interval of interest, based solely on the position of the 5¢ end of the small RNA. Pseudocode: • For each locus/interval: – Search map data for small RNAs whose 5¢ end (start position) is within the locus – For each matching small RNA: (a) Record the accession number of the matching small RNA (b) Record the matching strand of the locus/interval (+ or −) (c) Record the 5¢ coordinate relative to the locus/interval (d) Record the abundance value of the small RNA The output may be stored in a tab-delimited flat file, with one line for each locus. 3.3. Calculate the Phasing Statistics for Each Locus/ Interval
Steps 1–5 of Subheading 3.3 describe the analysis of each locus/ interval. This protocol assumes a search to find loci phased in 21 nt increments, but can be generalized to searches for other register sizes. Parameters that would need to be modified to enable such alternative searches are noted. Pseudocode: • For each locus/interval: – Analyze matching small RNAs as shown below... 1. Calculate and record the total abundance of all small RNAs which match the locus (see Note 2) and the total number of distinct small RNAs which match the query locus. This includes all matching small RNAs regardless of the small RNA length. Pseudocode: • Calculate total abundance of all small RNAs matching the locus • Calculate the number of distinct small RNAs matching the locus 2. Assign each nucleotide position within the locus to one of 21 possible bins, representing positions which are separated by exactly 21 nts. These bins represent each of the possible phasing registers when searching for loci producing siRNAs at regular 21 nt intervals – searches for siRNAs in other register sizes should modify the number of bins accordingly. The logic behind these bins is illustrated in Fig. 1. Nucleotide position 1 is designated to correspond to bin number 1, position number 2 to bin number 2, and so on until 21 is reached. Nucleotide position 22 is exactly 21 nts distant from position number 1, and is therefore placed in bin number 1. Thus, bin 1 is most closely in a 21 nt phase with bins 21 and 2, while bin 14 is most closely in phase
A Method to Discover Phased siRNA Loci 1 1
3 3
5 5
7 7
9 9
11 11
13 13
15 15
17 17
19 19
21 21
2 23
4 25
6 27
8 29
10 31
12 33
14 35
16 37
18 39
20 41
1 43
3 45
5 47
7 49
9 51
11 53
13 55
15 57
17 59
19 61
21 63
2 65
4 67
5�-AUCGCAUCGAUCAUCGAUUCGAUCGAUCGCCGUAUCGAGAGA GUUCUCUCUAGAUAAUCUCGAGCGG-3� 3�-UAGCGUAGCUAGUAGCUAAGCUAGCUAGCGGCAUAGCUCU CUCAAGAGAGAUCUAUUAGAGCUCGCC-5� Sense small RNA: 5’ position = 43 bin 1
63
BINS NUCLEOTIDE POSITIONS
Antisense small RNA: 5’ position = 61 Adjusted 5’ position = 61 - 18 = 43 bin 1
Fig. 1. Assignment of positions within a locus to “phasing” bins. The absolute position of each nucleotide within a hypothetical double-stranded RNA is shown (“nucleotide positions”). Each position is assigned to one of 21 arbitrary bins (“bins”), which repeat in 21 nt cycles (lines). The assignment of two siRNAs (bold, underlined) to their respective bins is illustrated – see text for details.
with bins 13 and 15. The nucleotide positions within bin number x (where x is an integer between 1 and 21) are x, (x + 21), (x + 21 + 21), (x + 21 + 21 + 21), and so on, until the end of the locus is reached. Pseudocode: • For each nucleotide position within the locus: – Assign position 1 to bin 1, position 2 to bin 2, and so on until position 21 – Assign position 22 to bin 1, position 23 to bin 2, and so on until reaching the next multiple of 21 The result is a table, simple database, or hash where each nucleotide position within the locus is assigned to the appropriate bin, indicative of 21 nt spacing. 3. Assign each small RNA corresponding to the sense strand of the locus to the appropriate bin, based upon the position of the 5¢ nucleotide. For instance, a small RNA matching the sense strand of a query locus whose 5¢ end corresponded to position 43 would be assigned to bin number 1 (Fig. 1). Keep a tally of the small RNA abundances falling within each bin. Pseudocode: • For each small RNA matching the sense strand of the locus: – Get the position within the query locus corresponding to the 5¢ end of the small RNA – Lookup the appropriate bin for that position on the query locus – Add the abundance of that small RNA to the total abundance tallied within the bin 4. Assign each small RNA corresponding to the antisense strand of the locus to the appropriate bin based upon the position of the 5¢ nucleotide after adjusting for the two nucleotide offset produced by DCL-catalyzed siRNA formation.
64
Axtell
Processing of double-stranded RNA by DCL enzymes produces siRNA duplexes with two nucleotide, 3¢ overhangs (Fig. 1). Consequently, the 5¢ end of an antisense small RNA is offset by +18 nucleotides from the 5¢ end of its corresponding sense-strand RNA. Adjusting for this offset is simple: subtract 18 nucleotides from the 5¢ position of antisense small RNAs, and then lookup the bin corresponding to the adjusted position. For example, the antisense strand of the siRNA duplex shown in Fig. 1 is clearly in the same phase as its sense partner, because they form a duplex with the expected two nucleotide, 3¢ overhangs. The 5¢ residue of the antisense small RNA is at position 61 of the locus. Adjusting this position by subtracting 18 gives 43, which corresponds to bin 1 (Fig. 1). One special case where this adjustment becomes problematic is when subtraction of 18 from the absolute position of the 5¢ residue results in a value of zero or less. In this case, simply add 21 and look up the corresponding bin. Add the abundances of each matching small RNA to the tally for the appropriate bin. Pseudocode: • For each small RNA matching the antisense strand of the locus: – Get the position within the query locus corresponding to the 5¢ end of the small RNA – Subtract 18 from the position – If the result is a zero or less, add 21 – Lookup the appropriate bin for the adjusted position on the query locus – Add the abundance of that small RNA to the total abundance tallied within the bin 5. Calculate the “phase ratio” for the locus. The assignment of small RNA abundances to one of 21 possible bins for both sense (see Subheading 3.3, step 3) and antisense (see Subheading 3.3, step 4) small RNAs, results in a table of small RNA abundance by bin (Table 1). These data may also be conveniently displayed as a radial graph (Fig. 2). The phase ratio of a given locus is defined simply as the abundance of the highest bin divided by the abundance of all small RNAs mapping to the locus (see Note 5). In other words, the phase ratio is simply the percentage of small RNAs whose 5¢ ends fall in the most abundant of the 21 different bins. Record the phase ratio for the locus. Pseudocode: • Identify the bin with the highest abundance of 5¢ ends of small RNAs • Calculate the phase ratio by dividing the abundance of the highest bin by the total abundance of small RNAs corresponding to the locus
A Method to Discover Phased siRNA Loci
65
Table 1 Phasing of small RNAs corresponding to the Arabidopsis thaliana TAS1b locus (At1g50055.1) Bin
Abundance
1
1
2
12
3
4
4
1
5
6
6
4
7
6
8
2
9
0
10
3
11
3
12
2
13
24
14
6
15
2
16
4
17
855
18
5
19
2
20
7
21
5
Sum
Phase ratio
954
0.896
The bin with the highest abundance of small RNAs is indicated in bold In this example, small RNA abundances were the combined number of sequence reads observed via sequencing of various wild-type small RNA libraries by (6) (NCBI GEO accessions GSM154361, GSM154370, and GSM154375) and (4) (GSM118372–GSM118375)
66
Axtell 1 21 1000 20
2 3
750
19
4
500
18
5 250
17
6
16
7
15
8 14
9 13
12
11
10
Fig. 2. Display of phased small RNAs using a radial graph. Data from Table 1 were plotted as a radial graph with distance from the center indicating abundance in each of the 21 bins.
3.4. Set Minimum Acceptable Values
Before performing the final ranking of potential phased siRNA loci, it is useful to set up two filters. Steps 1 and 2 of Subheading 3.4 describe these filters. 1. Set a minimum acceptable phase ratio. By chance, a locus producing a random assortment of small RNAs would be expected to have 1/21 (~4.8%) of its small RNAs in any given bin. Thus, it is useful to set a minimum phase ratio significantly higher than 0.048. A value that is generally useful is 0.25 to 0.4. Pseudocode: • Set minimum acceptable phase ratio • Remove from further consideration, loci whose phase ratio is lower than the minimum 2. Set a minimum number of distinct small RNAs matching each locus. Loci with just two or three corresponding small RNAs that happen to fall within the same 21 nt register are quite likely to occur by chance, given the very large datasets of sequenced small RNAs emerging from many species. Practically, a minimum number of five to ten distinct small RNAs is a useful cutoff – any fewer than this and it is difficult to be convinced that the locus truly is a siRNA-producing locus without corroborating evidence (see Note 6). Pseudocode: • Set minimum acceptable number of distinct small RNAs • Remove from further consideration loci which have less than the minimum number of distinct corresponding small RNAs
3.5. Rank the Loci
A Method to Discover Phased siRNA Loci
67
In the final step, each locus passing the filters described in Subheading 3.4 is ranked according to both the phase ratio and the total number of distinct, corresponding small RNAs, as described in steps 1–3 of Subheading 3.5. 1. Rank each locus according to the phase ratio. The locus with the highest ratio is assigned rank 1, the second highest ratio is assigned rank 2, and so on. Pseudocode: • Assign a rank to each locus based on the calculated phase ratio 2. Rank each locus according to the number of distinct corresponding small RNAs. The locus with the highest number of distinct, matching small RNAs is assigned rank 1, the second highest is assigned rank 2, and so on. This rank is independent of that calculated in Subheading 3.5, step 1. Pseudocode: • Assign a rank to each locus based on the number of distinct, matching small RNAs 3. Generate a combined score by adding the two ranks together. This metric gives equal weight to both the proportion of small RNAs in a single phasing register and to the total number of small RNAs deriving from the locus. Loci with the best overall evidence for phased siRNA production will have the lowest scores. An example is shown in Table 2. Pseudocode: • Derive the final metric for each locus by adding the two ranks together • Sort the loci according to this metric – smaller values indicate more likely areas of phased siRNA production
4. Notes 1. Interested readers are also referred to the studies of Chen et al. (23) and of Molnár et al. (24), both of whom use similar ideas to statistically assign confidence values to the phasing of small RNA loci, and the work of Howell et al. (19), who utilize a phase-transform algorithm to estimate the amount of phasing for small RNA generating loci. 2. Typically, the abundance of individual small RNAs is approximated by the number of times it was sequenced in a given small RNA sequencing experiment, and is thus the number of “reads” of a sequence. Abundances can be reported as normalized values (for instance, “transcripts per quarter-million” (7)) for the purposes of cross-library comparisons. Abundances can
AtTAS1c
AtTAS1a
AtTAS1b
AtTAS2
ARF4
AtTAS3a
AFB2
AFB3
AtTAS4
bHLH gene
PPR gene
AtTAS3c
PPR gene
AT2G39675.1
AT2G27400.1
AT1G50055.1
AT2G39681.1
AT5G60450.1
AT3G17185.1
AT3G26810.1
AT1G12820.1
AT3G25790– AT3G25800
AT3G23690.1
AT1G63230.1
AT5G57735.1
AT1G64580.1
0.267
0.500
0.300
0.267
0.500
0.640
0.514
0.282
0.587
0.501
0.896
0.672
0.730
Phase ratio
13
9
10
12
8
4
6
11
5
7
1
3
2
Phase ratio rank
10
6
8
21
14
8
13
133
20
245
86
162
202
# Distinct small RNAs
10
13
11
6
8
11
9
4
7
1
5
3
2
Distinct small RNA rank
23
22
21
18
16
15
15
15
12
8
6
6
4
Final score
The set of loci reported by (4,18,19) as producing phased siRNAs were analyzed, using small RNA abundances derived as in Table 1. Loci with phase ratios of less than 0.25 and/or with five or fewer distinct matching small RNAs were filtered out
Locus
AGI accession
Table 2 Analysis of known Arabidopsis thaliana phased siRNA loci
68 Axtell
A Method to Discover Phased siRNA Loci
69
also be normalized to account for the ambiguity that arises when one small RNA sequence has multiple possible origins within a genome or other reference database. This can be accomplished by dividing the number of “reads” by the number of matches to the genome/reference database (4, 25). 3. The choice of programming language and computational approach will be specific to the goals and expertise of the user. This methodology has been implemented by the author as a series of PERL scripts. 4. One way to accomplish these comparisons is by using standalone NCBI blastall, with the following nondefault parameters: -p blastn -d [reference database] -i [small RNA sequences in DNA form] -e 0.1 -F F -W 6 -m 8 -v 100000 -a 2. The resulting tab-delimited output is then parsed to retain only exact matches (those that have 100% identity, with no gaps, over the entire length of the query small RNA). 5. Some loci produce siRNAs in more than one phase, reflecting distinct, well-defined dsRNA termini (18, 19). Searches for such loci might benefit from using the combined abundances in the top two bins to calculate the phase ratio. In such cases, the minimum phase ratio (Subheading 3.4, step 1) would need to be adjusted upward to account for the fact that, given a random distribution of small RNAs in 21 phasing registers, 2/21 (~9.6%) would be expected to fall into any given bin. 6. In deciding the cutoffs that are useful for the phase ratio and for the minimum number of distinct small RNAs, it may be helpful to include in the analysis loci which are already well known to produce phased siRNAs. If this is possible, then the minimum parameters can be examined to ensure that known phased siRNA loci are still being captured.
References 1. Llave C, Kasschau KD, Rector MA, Carrington JC (2002) Endogenous and silencing-associated small RNAs in plants. Plant Cell 14: 1605–1619 2. Park W, Li J, Song R, Messing J, Chen X (2002) CARPEL FACTORY, a Dicer homolog, and HEN1, a novel protein, act in microRNA metabolism in Arabidopsis thaliana. Curr Biol 12:1484–1495 3. Reinhart BJ, Weinstein EG, Rhoades MW, Bartel B, Bartel DP (2002) MicroRNAs in plants. Genes Dev 16:1616–1626 4. Rajagopalan R, Vaucheret H, Trejo J, Bartel DP (2006) A diverse and evolutionarily fluid
set of microRNAs in Arabidopsis thaliana. Genes Dev 20:3407–3425 5. Zhang X, Henderson IR, Lu C, Green PJ, Jacobsen SE (2007) Role of RNA polymerase IV in plant small RNA metabolism. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 104:4536–4541 6. Kasschau KD, Fahlgren N, Chapman EJ, Sullivan CM, Cumbie JS, Givan SA, Carrington JC (2007) Genome-wide profiling and analysis of Arabidopsis siRNAs. PLoS Biol 5:e57 7. Lu C, Tej SS, Luo S, Haudenschild CD, Meyers BC, Green PJ (2005) Elucidation of the small RNA component of the transcriptome. Science 309:1567–1569
70
Axtell
8. Peragine A, Yoshikawa M, Wu G, Albrecht HL, Poethig RS (2004) SGS3 and SGS2/SDE1/ RDR6 are required for juvenile development and the production of trans-acting siRNAs in Arabidopsis. Genes Dev 18:2368–2379 9. Vazquez F, Vaucheret H, Rajagopalan R, Lepers C, Gasciolli V, Mallory AC, Hilbert JL, Bartel DP, Crete P (2004) Endogenous transacting siRNAs regulate the accumulation of Arabidopsis mRNAs. Mol Cell 16:69–79 10. Williams L, Carles CC, Osmont KS, Fletcher JC (2005) A database analysis method identifies an endogenous trans-acting short-interfering RNA that targets the Arabidopsis ARF2, ARF3, and ARF4 genes. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 102:9703–9708 11. Adenot X, Elmayan T, Lauressergues D, Boutet S, Bouche N, Gasciolli V, Vaucheret H (2006) DRB4-dependent TAS3 trans-acting siRNAs control leaf morphology through AGO7. Curr Biol 16:927–932 12. Fahlgren N, Montgomery TA, Howell MD, Allen E, Dvorak SK, Alexander AL, Carrington JC (2006) Regulation of AUXIN RESPONSE FACTOR3 by TAS3 ta-siRNA affects developmental timing and patterning in Arabidopsis. Curr Biol 16:939–944 13. Garcia D, Collier SA, Byrne ME, Martienssen RA (2006) Specification of leaf polarity in Arabidopsis via the trans-acting siRNA pathway. Curr Biol 16:933–938 14. Hunter C, Willmann MR, Wu G, Yoshikawa M, de la Luz Gutierrez-Nava M, Poethig SR (2006) Trans-acting siRNA-mediated repression of ETTIN and ARF4 regulates heteroblasty in Arabidopsis. Development 133:2973–2981 15. Liu B, Chen Z, Song X, Liu C, Cui X, Zhao X, Fang J, Xu W, Zhang H, Wang X, Chu C, Deng X, Xue Y, Cao X (2007) Oryza sativa Dicer-like4 reveals a key role for small interfering RNA silencing in plant development. Plant Cell 19:2705–2718 16. Nagasaki H, Itoh J, Hayashi K, Hibara K, Satoh-Nagasawa N, Nosaka M, Mukouhata M, Ashikari M, Kitano H, Matsuoka M, Nagato Y, Sato Y (2007) The small interfering RNA production pathway is required for shoot
meristem initiation in rice. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 104:14867–14871 17. Nogueira FT, Madi S, Chitwood DH, Juarez MT, Timmermans MC (2007) Two small regulatory RNAs establish opposing fates of a developmental axis. Genes Dev 21: 750–755 18. Axtell MJ, Jan C, Rajagopalan R, Bartel DP (2006) A two-hit trigger for siRNA biogenesis in plants. Cell 127:565–577 19. Howell MD, Fahlgren N, Chapman EJ, Cumbie JS, Sullivan CM, Givan SA, Kasschau KD, Carrington JC (2007) Genome-wide analysis of the RNA-DEPENDENT RNA POLYMERASE6/DICER-LIKE4 pathway in Arabidopsis reveals dependency on miRNAand tasiRNA-directed targeting. Plant Cell 19: 926–942 20. Allen E, Xie Z, Gustafson AM, Carrington JC (2005) microRNA-directed phasing during trans-acting siRNA biogenesis in plants. Cell 121:207–221 21. Ronemus M, Vaughn MW, Martienssen RA (2006) MicroRNA-targeted and small interfering RNA-mediated mRNA degradation is regulated by argonaute, dicer, and RNAdependent RNA polymerase in Arabidopsis. Plant Cell 18:1559–1574 22. Yoshikawa M, Peragine A, Park MY, Poethig RS (2005) A pathway for the biogenesis of trans-acting siRNAs in Arabidopsis. Genes Dev 19:2164–2175 23. Chen HM, Li YH, Wu SH (2007) Bioinformatic prediction and experimental validation of a microRNA-directed tandem trans-acting siRNA cascade in Arabidopsis. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 104:3318–3323 24. Molnar A, Schwach F, Studholme DJ, Thuenemann EC, Baulcombe DC (2007) miRNAs control gene expression in the singlecell alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. Nature 447:1126–1129 25. Brennecke J, Aravin AA, Stark A, Dus M, Kellis M, Sachidanandam R, Hannon GJ (2007) Discrete small RNA-generating loci as master regulators of transposon activity in Drosophila. Cell 128:1089–1103
Chapter 6 Directed Gene Silencing with Artificial MicroRNAs Rebecca Schwab, Stephan Ossowski, Norman Warthmann, and Detlef Weigel Abstract The characterization of gene function typically includes a detailed analysis of loss-of-function alleles. In model plants, such as Arabidopsis thaliana and rice, sequence-indexed insertion collections provide a large resource of potential null alleles that can often be easily accessed through convenient Web sites (e.g., http://signal.salk.edu). They are, however, not available for nonmodel species, require stacking for knockout of redundant homologs, and do not easily allow for partial or regulated loss of gene function, which is particularly useful when null alleles are lethal. Transgene approaches that employ directed gene silencing can substitute for null alleles and also enable refined studies of gene function, e.g., by tissuespecific and inducible gene-silencing. This chapter describes the generation and application of artificial microRNAs (amiRNAs) as a gene silencing tool in a wide variety of different plant species. Key words: Gene silencing, miRNA, Hairpin, Loss-of-function, Phenotypic complementation
1. Introduction Mediators of transgene-induced gene silencing are single-stranded silencing RNAs (19–23 nucleotides) that bind to target transcripts through complementary base-pairing (1). MicroRNAs (miRNAs), one class of silencing RNAs, originate from a characteristic hairpincontaining transcript. Vectors that contain a hairpin precursor are recognized as second-generation RNAi vectors (2). Their sequence can be modified such that miRNAs of other, defined sequence, called artificial miRNAs (amiRNAs), are produced in planta. These vectors can serve as reverse genetics tools to direct gene silencing, also in nonmodel systems. Among their unique applications are transient and tissue-specific gene silencing, and the simultaneous B.C. Meyers and P.J. Green (eds.), Plant MicroRNAs, Methods in Molecular Biology, vol. 592 DOI 10.1007/978-1-60327-005-2_6, © Humana Press, a part of Springer Science + Business Media, LLC 2010
71
72
Schwab et al.
silencing of several related genes. The latter include closely linked genes (e.g., in tandem repeats) and those that are allele- and splice form-specific, as well. In addition, they provide the possibility of phenotypic complementation with target transgenes that are no longer susceptible to amiRNA-mediated gene regulation after introduction of silent mutations into the target sites. The web application Web MicroRNA Designer (WMD) facilitates the design of suitable amiRNA sequences for a variety of different plant species, as well as the design of primer sequences needed to modify the miRNA vectors. We describe the use of the tool as well as the molecular steps necessary to engineer those vectors and generate transgenic plants.
2. Materials 2.1. Computational Prediction of amiRNA Sequences
1. Identifier (or EST name) and sequence of the target gene(s) that should be silenced.
2.2. Site-Directed Mutagenesis by PCR
1. Six oligonucleotides; two are universal to the vector (A and B; Table 1) and four are specific to the particular modification. Their sequences are the output of the amiRNA design program (3.1). 2. Template plasmid: pRS300 (containing Arabidopsis athMIR319a) or pNW55 (containing rice osa-MIR528).
Table 1 Oligonucleotide sequences Template
Name
Position
Sequence 5¢→3¢
ath-MIR319a
I
amiRNA forward
GA (N)21 T CTC TCT TTT GTA TTC C
II
amiRNA reverse
GA (N)21 T CAA AGA GAA TCA ATG A
III
amiRNA* forward
GA (N)21 T CAC AGG TCG TGA TAT G
IV
amiRNA* reverse
GA (N)21 T CTA CAT ATA TAT TCC T
I
amiRNA forward
AG (N)21 C AGG AGA TTC AGT TTG A
II
amiRNA reverse
TG (N)21 C TGC TGC TGC TAC AGC C
III
amiRNA* forward
CT (N)21 T TCC TGC TGC TAG GCT G
IV
amiRNA* reverse
AA (N)21 A GAG AGG CAA AAG TGA A
A
outside forward
CTG CAA GGC GAT TAA GTT GGG TAA C
B
outside reverse
GCG GAT AAC AAT TTC ACA CAG GAA ACA G
osa- MIR528
Directed Gene Silencing with Artificial MicroRNAs
73
3. Equipment and chemicals to perform PCR, agarose gel electrophoresis, and gel extraction of PCR bands. 2.3. Cloning of aMIRNA Precursors
1. Commercial PCR product ligation kit (e.g., TOPO kits from Invitrogen) or standard cloning plasmid (e.g., pGEM-7Z from Promega, linearized with Sma I), 10 mM ATP, restriction enzyme SmaI. 2. T4 DNA ligase. 3. Competent cells from a standard E. coli strain (e.g., DH5a, TOP10). 4. LB plates containing appropriate antibiotics. 5. Plasmid extraction (Miniprep) solutions or kit (e.g., QIAprep from Qiagen). 6. Restriction enzymes to test for positive clones and subclone aMIRNAs. 7. Binary plasmid containing a promoter of interest and a terminator.
2.4. Plant Transformation and Analysis of Transgenic Plants
1. Standard competent Agrobacterium tumefaciens strain (e.g., GV3101 for A. thaliana, LBA4404 or EHA105 for O. sativa). 2. Standard equipment for the generation of transgenic plants. 3. Selection marker and appropriate antibiotics (e.g., Kanamycin, Hygromycin). 4. TRIzol® reagent (Invitrogen) or commercial RNA extraction kit (e.g., RNeasy from Qiagen). 5. Reverse transcriptase kit (e.g., SuperScript III from Invitrogen) and oligonucleotides for RT-PCR. 6. Optional – Kit for mRNA extraction (e.g., Oligotex from Qiagen) and 5¢ RACE (e.g., GeneRacer from Invitrogen). – Oligonucleotides for site-directed mutagenesis to engineer silent mutations in transgenes containing the target gene(s) for phenotypic complementation.
3. Methods The method section describes in detail the design and construction of amiRNAs to silence one or several related genes of interest in a variety of different plant species. It is subdivided into four main sections: (1) the computer-assisted design of optimal amiRNA sequences, (2) the generation of aMIRNA precursors by site-directed mutagenesis, (3) cloning of aMIRNA precursors, and (4) the generation and analysis of transgenic plants.
74
Schwab et al.
3.1. Design of amiRNA Sequences
Sequences of amiRNAs need to be optimized for both effectiveness and specificity. The optimization for specificity (i.e., predicting and avoiding off-targets) depends on the availability of transcriptome sequence information. We have developed the Web MicroRNA Designer (WMD), which is available at http:// wmd3.weigelworld.org. It predicts suitable amiRNA sequences for gene silencing in a large number of plant species for which a whole-genome annotation or significant EST/cDNA sequence information is available. Note 1 describes how to design artificial miRNA sequences for species that are not yet included in WMD.
3.1.1. Experimental Design
WMD can design amiRNAs to silence single genes as well as design amiRNAs to simultaneously silence multiple genes. These genes need to share regions of high nucleotide sequence similarity. WMD selects amiRNA candidates that are partially complementary to the target gene(s) and ensures that no other annotated gene of the respective genome/transcriptome release (species) fulfills the criteria of productive miRNA target interaction (3–5). These criteria have been empirically determined and are expected to improve as the knowledge on miRNA biology and function grows. It is important to realize that it might not be possible to design an amiRNA against one gene or several highly sequencerelated genes, if all potential target sites to which the amiRNA would bind are also present in other (known) genes. Therefore, a search for highly similar genes is prudent before starting the design process. This can be done by a BLAST search implemented in the WMD webpage. In cases where targeting of highly related genes does not interfere with the experiment, these can be specified as “accepted off-targets” to increase the chances of a successful amiRNA design.
3.1.2. Using the amiRNA Design Tool (WMDDesigner Window)
WMD requires sequence information of the intended target gene(s) as input and selects 21mer amiRNA candidates from the reverse complement(s). To accommodate the different formats of sequence annotations and a variety of amiRNA applications, there are several ways to input “target genes” into the WMDDesigner: 1. Silencing single or multiple genes in fully annotated genomes: For genes that are fully annotated, it is sufficient to provide the gene identifier(s) including splice variants, e.g., At1g23450.1 or Os01g24680.1 for Arabidopsis or rice respectively. Whether all splice forms of a gene are targeted by a specific amiRNA can be quickly tested with the “WMD-Target Search tool” (see Note 2). 2. Silencing single or multiple genes in species for which only EST information is available: Locus identifiers (e.g., EST names) need to be provided, whereby the identifier has to be identical to the identifiers used
Directed Gene Silencing with Artificial MicroRNAs
75
by WMD. The correct names are easily determined by a search with the WMD-BLAST tool. Multiple EST sequences often exist for a single locus. First they all need to be identified with the WMD-BLAST tool , then one of them (preferably the longest) should be used as the target gene (identifier entered in the “Target genes” field), and the identifiers of all others that likely originate from the same locus are entered as “accepted off-targets” (separated by commas). When attempting to silence multiple genes simultaneously, one sequence for each gene is entered in the “Target genes” field, and the others are added to the list of “accepted off-targets.” 3. When none of the redundant ESTs comprises the full-length target transcript, several can be concatenated and serve as target for the amiRNA design. It should be given a custom identifier that distinguishes it from all annotated ESTs, and all redundant ESTs need to be specified as “accepted off-targets.” The concatenated EST needs to be entered into the “Target genes” field in FASTA format. 4. Splice-form specific silencing: If exclusively one splice form is to be targeted, then a DNA sequence (>21 nucleotides, FASTA format) that is unique to the respective splice form should be used as target and the identifier/name of the splice form (e.g., At2g23450.2) should serve as a header. 5. Not annotated genes, and sequence variants: If the gene to be silenced is not contained in the WMD database for the respective species (e.g., GUS, GFP, viral genes, genes that are not yet annotated, etc.), or represents a sequence variant of an annotated gene (e.g., an allele from a different ecotype or cultivar), the target gene sequence(s) should be provided in FASTA format, headed by a custom name that is different from that of any other annotated gene. Silencing of sequence variants also requires the reference allele to be specified as an accepted off-target unless allele-specific silencing is desired. In all cases, the respective plant species/genome release is to be selected from the drop-down menu on the WMD-Designer page to ensure specificity within this set of sequences. Specification of the “minimal number of included targets” is necessary when more than two genes are to be silenced simultaneously. In addition to finding an amiRNA that silences all genes simultaneously, WMD will attempt to generate amiRNAs that target all possible subgroups of sizes greater or equal to the number given in “minimal number of included targets.” The computation of amiRNAs will take between a few minutes and several hours. The results will be emailed to the provided emailaddress with the information entered in “Description” as the subject line.
76
Schwab et al.
Fig. 1. Example of a WMD result page. Candidate amiRNA sequences are listed and ordered by efficiency and specificity criteria. 3.1.3. Processing amiRNA Design Results
The amiRNA result email contains a hyper-link to a results webpage on which the amiRNA candidate sequences are listed (Fig. 1). This list can also be downloaded for future reference (Microsoft Excel format). See Note 3 in case the results page is empty and displays the message “Unfortunately WMD3 could not design any microRNAs”. In principle, all amiRNA sequences returned by WMD fulfill the above described criteria and are expected to silence the predicted target genes successfully. However, they comply differently to the parameters that we consider optimal in terms of base pair composition, hybridization properties to the target gene(s), and specificity criteria (for details, see (6)). The possible amiRNAs are therefore ranked by a respective cumulative score. The highest ranking amiRNA candidates are presented on top of the list. Green color indicates a very favorable score, while orange and red often mark amiRNAs with potentially reduced efficiency or, more often, specificity. It is thus recommended to proceed from top to bottom of this list. The amiRNA sequences in the results page are hyperlinked to visualizations of alignments of the amiRNA to all potential target sequences in the WMD database, ordered by hybridization energy (for illustration see Fig. 2). The intended target gene ideally appears on top of the list. The WMDTarget Search tool can also show genes that align to the amiRNA
Directed Gene Silencing with Artificial MicroRNAs
77
Fig. 2. Alignment of an amiRNA to its target gene. Explanation to the amiRNA-target alignment presented by WMD.
with equal or fewer than five mismatches but do not fulfill other empirical rules, as indicated with respective notes in red bars. For the subsequent selection of one (or more) amiRNAs for further experiments, we recommend the following: 1. It is preferable for all intended target genes to not have mismatches to the amiRNA at positions 2 to 12. 2. AmiRNA candidates with one or two mismatches at the 3¢ end of the amiRNA (positions 18 to 21) should be preferred, since it has been suggested that perfectly matching amiRNAs might trigger so-called transitive siRNA formation, where amplification of sequences adjacent to the binding site is primed by the miRNA. These sequences could in turn themselves serve as silencing triggers and affect other, unintended genes (7). 3. The absolute hybridization energy of the binding between amiRNA and the target sequence should be less than −30 kcal/ mole, and preferable be in the range between −35 and −40 kcal/ mole. 4. The amiRNA binding site should be located within the coding region of the target gene, since UTRs are more likely to be misannotated. At least two amiRNAs per target gene or group of genes should be selected for experimental work. If several are selected, the amiRNAs should bind the target mRNA at different locations, since secondary structure is suspected to influence miRNA efficacy. 3.2. Construction of aMIRNA Precursors by Site-Directed Mutagenesis
While exogenous small RNAs duplices are often directly used to transfect animal cell cultures and induce gene silencing, their accumulation in plants requires the construction and subsequent expression of a precursor RNA. AmiRNAs are engineered into vectors that contain endogenous MIRNA precursors by sitedirected mutagenesis, such that the resulting precursor RNAs are processed by the endogenous miRNA machinery to release the
78
Schwab et al.
amiRNAs. Several Arabidopsis precursor templates have been used successfully in Arabidopsis (4, 8–11) and other plants (8, 26), while rice osa-MIR528 was specifically engineered for amiRNA production in rice (12) and cre-MIR1157 and cre-MIR1162 have been used successfully in the unicellular green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii (24, 25). Please see Note 4 when working with a different plant species. MIRNA precursors fold back on themselves to form a hairpin structure, and it is important to preserve this structure for successful processing. Therefore, engineering of amiRNAs into MIRNA precursor templates not only requires the exchange of the miRNA by the amiRNA sequence, but also of the pairing region in the hairpin, called the (a)miRNA*, such that pairing positions as well as G:U pairs are retained. The WMD software (WMD-Oligo window) thus generates four oligonucleotides per amiRNA sequence input: I and II to engineer the actual amiRNA, and III and IV for the amiRNA* (with wobbles). Currently, the software supports ath-MIR319a, osa-MIR528, and cre-MIR1157 (selected from a dropdown menu) and others will be included as they become available. 3.2.1. The MIRNA Templates
Endogenous MIRNA precursors that have been cloned into plasmids serve as templates for PCR reactions to exchange miRNA and miRNA*. These precursors include the hairpin and short pieces of flanking sequence on either side, which are known to be part of the longer endogenous MIRNA transcript. Plasmids that are currently available contain ath-MIR319a (plasmid pRS300) and osa-MIR528 (plasmid pNW55), which can be obtained upon sending a request to Detlef Weigel (
[email protected]). A schematic representation of these MIRNA containing plasmids is shown in Fig. 3; their complete sequences are available on http://wmd3.weigelworld.org.
3.2.2. Oligonucleotides
Six PCR oligonucleotide primers are needed to produce an aMIRNA transgene. Four primer sequences are generated by WMD (WMD-Oligo window) and are given in 5¢→3¢ orientation. They are 40 nucleotides long and specific for the intended amiRNA. The 5¢ most two and 3¢ most 17 nucleotides match the template MIRNA precursor, while the 21 nucleotides in between do not match and will generate the amiRNA and amiRNA* in the amplicon (see Fig. 4). An additional two general oligonucleotides (A and B; see sequences in Table 1) that match the harboring plasmid (a pBluescript derivative) outside of the MIRNA precursor are also required. They have been placed such that the sizes of the resulting PCR products enable convenient purification and handling. Using the six primers, the aMIRNA precursor is amplified in three pieces (a–c) as shown in Fig. 4. The three pieces are subsequently fused to one amplicon (d) in a single PCR reaction.
Directed Gene Silencing with Artificial MicroRNAs
79
Fig. 3. Template plasmids for construction of the amiRNA precursor, the aMIRNA foldback. (a) Plasmid pRS300 containing the ath-MIR319a precursor in pBluescript SK (cloned via the SmaI site). (b) Plasmid pNW55 containing the osa-MIR528 precursor in pBluescript KS (also cloned via the SmaI site). Complete plasmid sequences are available at http://wmd3. weigelworld.org. Abbreviations: A, B oligonucleotide binding sites; T3, T7 RNA polymerase/oligonucleotide binding sites; Amp Ampicillin resistance gene; MCS multiple cloning site. Sizes of the aMIRNA foldback and surrounding regions are indicated in Fig. 4.
Fig. 4. Schematic representation of PCR reactions that generate aMIRNA precursors. (a) Illustration of the template plasmid (see Fig. 3) with oligonucleotide binding sites indicated. (b) PCR amplicons (a), (b), and (c). (c) (a), (b), and (c) are fused to (d) by PCR. (d) Only the central part encodes the aMIRNA precursor, which is schematically shown at the bottom. Abbreviations: Ath Arabidopsis thaliana; Osa Oryza sativa (rice); A, B, I, II, III, IV oligonucleotide identifiers (see text); MCS multiple cloning site; (a), (b), (c), (d) PCR fragments as indicated in the text.
3.2.3. Generating aMIRNA Precursors by Overlapping PCR
1. Resuspend the template plasmid upon receiving, transform into competent E. coli cells (standard lab strain), spread on ampicillin-containing LB plates, inoculate an overnight culture from a single colony, and isolate the plasmid again using standard plasmid isolation procedures. Prepare a 1:100 dilution.
80
Schwab et al.
Table 2 PCR reactions Template
Forward oligo
Reverse oligo
Template
Length of PCR product (bp)
A
IV
pRS300
272
(b)
III
II
pRS300
171
(c)
I
B
pRS300
298
(d)
A
B
(a) + (b) + (c)
701
(a)
A
II
pNW55
256
(b)
I
IV
pNW55
87
(c)
III
B
pNW55
259
(d)
A
B
(a) + (b) + (c)
555
Reaction
ath-MIR319a (a)
osa-MIR528
2. Setting up PCR reactions (a) to (c). All PCR reactions should preferentially be carried out with a proof-reading polymerase (such as Pfu) to avoid PCR errors. Table 2 shows the oligonucleotide combinations for each PCR reaction together with the expected size of the product (see also Fig. 3). Reactions (a) to (c): 2.0 µl
10× PCR buffer (with ~25 mM Mg++)
2.0 µl
dNTPs (2 mM)
1.0 µl
each oligonucleotide (10 µM; see PCR scheme)
1.0 µl
template DNA (1:100 dilution of template plasmid)
0.2 µl
polymerase
12.8 µl
water
20 µl
total
Protocol: 95° C 2 min ü ï 95° C 30 s ï ï 52° C 30 s ý 35cycles 72° C 40 s ï ï 72° C 7 min þï
Directed Gene Silencing with Artificial MicroRNAs
81
3. Isolate PCR fragments from a 2% agarose gel and purify with standard gel extraction procedures. PCR fragments from reactions (a), (b), and (c) can be pooled already at this step. Elute in 20 µl of water. 4. Reaction (d): fusion of fragments (a), (b), and (c). 2.0 µl
10× PCR buffer (with Mg++)
2.0 µl
dNTPs (2 mM)
1.0 µl
oligonucleotides A and B (10 µM)
0.5 µl
each purified gel fragment (a), (b), and (c) or 1.5 µl of combined gel eluate
0.2 µl
polymerase
12.3 µl
water
Protocol: 95° C 2 min ü ï 95° C 30 s ï ï 52° C 30 s ý 35cycles 72° C 90 s ï ï 72° C 7 min ïþ 5. Isolate PCR fragment from a 1% agarose gel. 3.3. Cloning
To sequence-verify the fusion-PCR product (d), it can be bluntend ligated into a standard cloning vector. It is important to keep in mind that this PCR fragment contains the T3 and T7 primer sites and the Multiple Cloning Sites of the template plasmid (see Fig. 2). Using T3 and/or T7 primers for sequencing may cause failed sequencing reactions, if the vector of choice also contains T3 and/or T7 sites.
3.3.1. Blunt-End Cloning Using Kits or Linearized Plasmids
(See Note 5 for the use of gateway-compatible plasmids.) PCR reactions with proof-reading polymerases generate blunt-ended products. Some companies offer kits to directly clone blunt-ended DNA fragments (e.g., TOPO kits from Invitrogen), and it is recommended to follow the manufacturer’s recommendations. Another simple and cheap protocol to clone blunt-ended PCR products is based on plasmids that are linearized with a restriction enzyme that produces blunt ends (e.g., SmaI). Since PCR products are not 5¢ phosphorylated, the plasmid needs to retain its terminal phospho-groups after restriction and is directly used for ligations without prior dephosphorylation or purification. Re-ligation of the empty plasmid is prevented by addition of SmaI to the ligation mix.
82
Schwab et al.
Ligation Reaction: 1.0 µl
10× reaction buffer for SmaI
0.5 µl
ATP (10 mM)
1.0 µl
plasmid cut with SmaI, not dephosphorylated, and not purified
1.0 µl
T4 DNA ligase (10 U/µl)
0.3 µl
SmaI
6.2 µl
purified PCR fragment
The ligation mix is incubated at 16°C overnight, followed by ~2 h at 30°C (optimal temperature for SmaI restriction) prior to transformation into standard competent E. coli strains. If possible, blue white selection for the presence of an insert is recommended. Single colonies are cultured, and the recovered plasmid DNA should be test digested (e.g., with EcoRI and BamHI to yield a 408 bp band with the ath-MIR319a template, 268 bp with the osa-MIR528 template) prior to sequence verification with standard oligonucleotides (depending on the plasmid) or oligonucleotides A or B. Sequencing at this step is strongly recommended to ensure that the new plasmid is indeed transformed. It may also be useful to know that the miRNAs in the template plasmids harbor uniquely occurring restriction sites – SacI in pRS300 (athMIR319a) and SphI in pNW55 (osa-MIR528) – which should (in most cases) be eliminated after successful PCR mutagenesis. 3.3.2. Sub-cloning into Binary Plasmids
aMIRNA precursors that are generated by site-directed mutagenesis do not contain a promoter or terminator; both need to be added by subsequent sub-cloning steps. For functionality tests in planta and initial characterizations, strong ubiquitous promoters such as cauliflower mosaic virus (35S) have been proven very helpful. More detailed analyses can be carried out with tissue-specific promoters, since amiRNAs function largely cell-autonomously (4). Because amiRNA-mediated gene silencing is quantitative (stronger promoters induce stronger effects), we do not recommend weak promoters when strongly expressed genes should be silenced efficiently. They might, however, become useful when partial silencing is intended. Inducible and transient aMIRNA expression was successful with ethanol and estrogen inducible systems (4, 13). Promoters are often already contained in binary vectors, or are to be inserted with standard cloning techniques. We did not observe remarkable differences in phenotypic effects with different binary plasmids in A. thaliana, and therefore recommend using a plasmid system that is well-established in the respective plant system.
Directed Gene Silencing with Artificial MicroRNAs
83
All restriction sites of the pBluescript Multiple Cloning Sites flanking the aMIRNA precursor in the fusion PCR product (d) can be used to excise the amiRNA precursor (the aMIRNA transcript) from the sequencing plasmid. We frequently use EcoRI and BamHI for the ath-MIR319a backbone, but other enzymes can be used as well. It is, however, necessary to preserve the direction of the aMIRNA precursor, since anti-sense transcripts are not expected to form the same secondary structure. Gatewayassisted cloning is also possible, since the presence of AttB sites adjacent to the amiRNA precursor does not seem to affect its processing (see Note 5). 3.4. Plant Transformation and Analysis of Transgenic Plants 3.4.1. Transformation of Agrobacterium and Plants
3.4.2. Reduced Abundance of Target Transcripts
Most protocols for the generation of transgenic plants rely on an Agrobacterium strain delivering the above-described binary plasmid. Transformation of competent strains (e.g., GV3101 for A. thaliana, LBA4404 or EHA105 for O. sativa) is carried out with standard transformation protocols. Similarly, transfection of plants with the transgenic Agro bacterium strains should be carried out with established protocols, and primary transformants require selection with appropriate selection markers. The observation of phenotypic variation in primary transformants is expected and this might, in some cases, resemble an allelic series of the respective mutant. Gene silencing with transgenes is, in many cases, not complete such that plants resembling null mutants of the respective target gene might not be recovered. See Note 6 in case you do not observe phenotypic changes in primary transformants. To confirm that phenotypic changes are indeed due to reduced abundance of the intended target gene product(s), their levels should be analyzed in pools of primary transformants with similar phenotypes, or in individual plants, and compared to an untransformed or empty-plasmid-transformed control. If available, estimating target protein levels with specific antibodies should be the method of choice. Since plant amiRNAs, like many endogenous miRNAs, typically also affect the accumulation of target mRNA, RT-PCR is often indicative of successful gene silencing. RNA is preferentially isolated from tissues with strong phenotypic effects, either with commercial kits or with TRIzol® reagent (Invitrogen). Commercial reverse transcription kits can be used for cDNA synthesis. RT-PCR products preferentially span the amiRNA-guided cleavage site. See Note 7 when you observe phenotypic abnormalities, but no change in target mRNA levels. To estimate the specificity of gene silencing, it is recommended to also test for the accumulation of closely related transcripts, which contain regions of partial sequence complementarity to the amiRNA (five or fewer mismatches, determined with the WMD-Target search tool; see Note 2). Reduced levels can be the
84
Schwab et al.
result of direct amiRNA targeting, but also of feedback regulation when the two genes participate in the same genetic pathway. To discriminate between the two possibilities, it is necessary to specifically test for the accumulation of cleaved targets by 5¢ RACEPCR, since (a)miRNAs trigger the cleavage of target transcripts – always opposite of positions 10 and 11 of the amiRNA. 3.4.3. Cleavage Site Mapping by RACE-PCR
RACE-PCR typically uses mRNA as a starting material, which can be isolated from total RNA with commercial kits. Standard protocols for 5¢RACE typically start by de-capping full-length mRNAs, whereas this step is omitted for cleavage product detection, and mRNA is directly ligated to the RNA linker oligonucleotide. Reverse transcription is typically carried out with an oligo-dT primer. PCR amplification of cleavage products uses forward oligonucleotides that bind the introduced linker sequence and genespecific reverse oligonucleotides complementary to a region ~200 to 300 nucleotides downstream of the putative amiRNA binding site in the gene of interest. The abundance of cleavage product can be very low, and sometimes a second, nested PCR may be necessary. Amplified products should be ligated into standard cloning vectors and sequenced to determine where the linker had been ligated and hence where the target transcript had been cleaved. Cleavage is predicted to occur at the amiRNA binding site between the two base pairs opposing positions 10 and 11 of the amiRNA.
3.4.4. Genetic Complementation
Since target sites of amiRNAs are small and distinct, it is possible to engineer silent mutations in this region of the target gene, such that the transcript is no longer susceptible to amiRNA-mediated regulation. Introducing this transgene under its endogenous or a stronger promoter should suppress the amiRNA-induced phenotypes. This approach has successfully been used to bypass regulation by endogenous miRNAs (14), and it can provide powerful evidence that the observed phenotypes are caused only by downregulation of the intended target and not by other genes. Silent mutations are typically introduced in as many positions as possible within the amiRNA binding site by PCR-based site-directed mutagenesis, in a similar way as aMIRNAs are produced (3.2.3).
4. Notes 1. When the plant species of interest is not yet included in WMD, but significant sequence information is publicly available, please contact
[email protected] to have the species added to the tool. Obviously, the specificity calculations can only take the available set of sequences into account, so there is always the possibility that amiRNAs affect additional genes
Directed Gene Silencing with Artificial MicroRNAs
85
that are not annotated or only partially annotated in the current sequence release of the respective species. 2. The WMD-Target Search application rapidly identifies target genes for miRNAs and other small RNAs in a given transcript collection/genome annotation. It uses a sequence matching algorithm, based on enhanced suffix arrays (http://vmatch.de (15), and enables the identification of all genes in the collection with a defined number of mismatches to the search sequence. In addition, the WMD-Target Search applies the empirically determined parameters of miRNA target selection (5) to filter for putative target genes. The output includes an alignment of the small RNA (reverse complement) to putative targets as illustrated in Fig. 2. With default settings, WMD-Target Search output lists only one splice form per gene. All splice forms are displayed when the splice form filter is disabled (“Show only one isoform” in Advanced Search Options). This option should be used to examine whether all splice forms are targeted. 3. Failure of WMD to produce suitable aMIRNAs can have several reasons: (a) The input sequence might have been too short to contain suitable target sites. (b) The WMD-Designer is not able to compute a specific amiRNA against a target gene of interest if its nucleotide sequence is very similar to one or several other genes at all potential target sites. The similar gene(s) can be easily identified using WMD-BLAST, and one or several targets will have to be silenced together by adding them as additional targets or as “accepted off-targets.” It might still be possible to conduct conclusive experiments by choosing off-target(s) that do not interfere with the experimental design, or by evaluating the effects of several amiRNA constructs in planta with different off-targets. (c) Some transcript collections contain redundant ESTs, and multiple ESTs might span the locus of interest. Here, all genes/ESTs that are highly related to the gene of interest should be identified with WMD-BLAST and included in the WMD-Designer input as “accepted off-targets.” (d) WMD can only compute a multi-gene amiRNA that targets several genes if they share regions of high nucleotide sequence similarity. Simultaneous silencing of multiple related genes might fail if the genes are not similar enough, or one or more is/are not different enough from other genes (see Note 2). Try to reduce the minimal number of included target genes or silence them individually. 4. A. thaliana MIRNA precursors have successfully been used for amiRNA production in other plants (tomato, tobacco, and
86
Schwab et al.
Physcomitrella, (8, 26)), but precursor functionality across species has not yet been systematically investigated. Therefore, adapting the cloning protocol to MIRNA precursors endogenous to the respective plant species of interest might be the optimal approach. MIRNA precursors have been identified and characterized in several different plants (see miRBase, http://microrna.sanger.ac.uk/, (16), often by homology to known miRNAs. As backbones for amiRNA production, we recommend either using a precursor that has been shown to be expressed and processed, i.e., by northern blot, or – when this information is not available – using a highly conserved precursor, e.g., MIR164 or MIR319. Oligonucleotides I through IV will need to be adapted to reconstruct the proper hairpin structure, such that bulges remain at their respective positions. 5. Cloning with the Gateway® technology seems to not interfere with amiRNA production. In the following, we list possible cloning strategies for using the Gateway® system: (a) The MIRNA precursor fragment can be excised from the sequencing plasmid (3.3.1) with restriction enzymes and ligated into a Gateway® entry plasmid. (b) The fusion product (d) in 3.2.3. can be ligated into a Gateway® entry plasmid as it is. (c) Alternatively, the fusion PCR of the fragments (a), (b), and (c) to (d) in 3.2.3 can be carried out with oligonucleotides that already contain AttB sites at their 5¢ ends. These primers do not necessarily need to bind to the primer binding sites A and B. Primers that bind to sequences in the Multiple Cloning Sites have successfully been used to obtain a short insert and to eliminate undesired restriction sites. The resulting PCR product with AttB sites at both ends can then be ligated into a vector of choice (e.g., pGEM T easy), which then serves as the entry plasmid for a subsequent recombination reaction. 6. Missing phenotypic changes in transgenic plants that (over) express amiRNAs can have several reasons: (a) The phenotypes might not be detectable in the growth conditions tested. (b) The loss-of-function phenotype of the gene of interest might be masked by redundancy. A search for related genes with similar expression patterns (see, e.g., AtGenExpress platform for A. thaliana; http://jsp.weigelworld.org/ expviz/expviz.jsp, (17) might help to identify potentially redundant genes to be used as additional targets. (c) The target gene might not be sufficiently downregulated to detect phenotypic changes. It is critical to achieve
Directed Gene Silencing with Artificial MicroRNAs
87
high amiRNA expression in the tissue(s) of target gene expressions, but even promoters such as the one from the CaMV35 gene are not entirely ubiquitous. A fraction of A. thaliana amiRNAs generated to date (20–25%) does not silence the intended target gene(s), but the reasons are yet to be determined. It is possible that their target sites are not accessible due to extensive local secondary structures, similar to what has been observed for siRNAs in animal systems (19). Ongoing studies address this question, and we are planning to account for this effect by integrating novel tools such as “RNAup” (20) into WMD. When calculating RNA-RNA binding, “RNAup” also considers the folding of the respective RNA molecules to themselves, and can therefore be used to predict the accessibility of the target sites in the target mRNA. At present, we recommend constructing at least two amiRNAs per target gene/group of target genes, with target sites located in different regions of the target transcript(s). (d) If even very potent amiRNAs cause only small effects on the transcript levels, the target genes might be under negative feedback regulation. Those genes may be silenced effectively on a transcriptional level (e.g., by promoter methylation, (18), however not by post-transcriptional gene silencing. 7. Typical (a)miRNA-mediated gene silencing includes the cleavage of target transcripts followed by degradation of the cleavage products, leading to a reduction in transcript abundance, which can be measured by RT-PCR. However, for some endogenous miRNAs, e.g., ath-miR172, translational inhibition is at least as important as miRNA-guided cleavage (21, 22, 27). Thus, phenotypic changes can be present even though mRNA levels might not have appreciably changed. When available, translational effects can be monitored on the protein level, by western blotting with target-specific antibodies. In many published cases, transcripts that were regulated on the translational level were still cleaved by the miRNAs (5, 21–23), and cleavage products were detected by RACE-PCR (see Subheading 3.4.3).
Acknowledgments We thank Markus Riester for his contributions to earlier versions of WMD, Alexis Maizel, Javier Palatnik, Heike Wollmann, and Wolfgang Busch for discussion and sharing technical expertise, and Peter Bommert for comments on the manuscript. Work on small RNAs in the Weigel laboratory is supported by European Community FP6 IP SIROCCO (contract LSHG-CT-2006-037900) and by the Max Planck Society. R.S. is supported by an EMBO Long-term fellowship.
88
Schwab et al.
References 1. Chapman EJ, Carrington JC (2007) Specia lization and evolution of endogenous small RNA pathways. Nat Rev Genet 8:884–896 2. Tang G, Galili G, Zhuang X (2007) RNAi and microRNA: breakthrough technologies for the improvement of plant nutritional value and metabolic engineering. Metabolomics 3:357–369 3. Allen E, Xie Z, Gustafson AM, Carrington JC (2005) MicroRNA-directed phasing during trans-acting siRNA biogenesis in plants. Cell 121:207–221 4. Schwab R, Ossowski S, Riester M, Warthmann N, Weigel D (2006) Highly specific gene silencing by artificial microRNAs in Arabidopsis. Plant Cell 18:1121–1133 5. Schwab R, Palatnik JF, Riester M, Schommer C, Schmid M, Weigel D (2005) Specific effects of microRNAs on the plant transcriptome. Dev Cell 8:517–527 6. Ossowski O, Schwab R, Weigel D (2008) Gene silencing in plants using artificial microRNAs and other small RNAs. Plant J 53(4):674–690 7. Vaucheret H (2005) MicroRNA-dependent trans-acting siRNA production. Sci STKE 2005:pe43 8. Alvarez JP, Pekker I, Goldshmidt A, Blum E, Amsellem Z, Eshed Y (2006) Endogenous and synthetic microRNAs stimulate simultaneous, efficient, and localized regulation of multiple targets in diverse species. Plant Cell 18:1134–1151 9. Niu QW, Lin SS, Reyes JL et al (2006) Expression of artificial microRNAs in transgenic Arabidopsis thaliana confers virus resistance. Nat Biotechnol 24:1420–1428 10. Parizotto EA, Dunoyer P, Rahm N, Himber C, Voinnet O (2004) In vivo investigation of the transcription, processing, endonucleolytic activity, and functional relevance of the spatial distribution of a plant miRNA. Genes Dev 18:2237–2242 11. Qu J, Ye J, Fang R (2007) Artificial miRNAmediated virus resistance in plants. J Virol 81(12):6690–6699 12. Warthmann N, Chen H, Ossowski O, Weigel D, Hervé P. Highly Specific Gene Silencing by Artificial miRNAs in Rice. submitted. 13. Michniewicz M, Zago MK, Abas L et al (2007) Antagonistic regulation of PIN phosphorylation by PP2A and PINOID directs auxin flux. Cell 130:1044–1056 14. Palatnik JF, Allen E, Wu X et al (2003) Control of leaf morphogenesis by microRNAs. Nature 425:257–263
15. Abouelhoda MI, Kurtz S, Ohlebusch E (2004) Replacing suffix trees with enhanced suffix arrays. Journal of Discrete Algorithms 2:53–86 16. Griffiths-Jones S (2004) The microRNA Registry. Nucleic Acids Res 32:D109–D111 17. Schmid M, Davison TS, Henz SR et al (2005) A gene expression map of Arabidopsis thaliana development. Nat Genet 37:501–506 18. Matzke M, Kanno T, Huettel B, Daxinger L, Matzke AJ (2006) RNA-directed DNA methylation and pol IVb in Arabidopsis. Cold Spring Harb Symp Quant Biol 71:449–459 19. Ameres SL, Martinez J, Schroeder R (2007) Molecular basis for target RNA recognition and cleavage by human RISC. Cell 130:101–112 20. Mückstein U, Tafer H, Hackermüller J, Bernhart SH, Stadler PF, Hofacker IL (2006) Thermodynamics of RNA-RNA binding. Bioinformatics 22:1177–1182 21. Aukerman MJ, Sakai H (2003) Regulation of flowering time and floral organ identity by a microRNA and its APETALA2-like target genes. Plant Cell 15:2730–2741 22. Chen X (2004) A microRNA as a translational repressor of APETALA2 in Arabidopsis flower development. Science 303:2022–2025 23. Gandikota M, Birkenbihl RP, Hohmann S, Cardon GH, Saedler H, Huijser P (2007) The miRNA156/157 recognition element in the 3¢ UTR of the Arabidopsis SBP box gene SPL3 prevents early flowering by translational inhibition in seedlings. Plant J 49:683–693 24. Tao Zhao, Wei Wang, Xue Bai and Yijun Qi; Gene silencing by artificial microRNAs in Chlamydomonas; The plant Journal, 2009 25. Attila Molnar, Andrew Bassett, Eva Thuenemann, Frank Schwach, Shantanu Karkare, Stephan Ossowski, Detlef Weigel and David Baulcombe; Highly specific gene silencing by artificial microRNAs in the unicellular alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii; The Plant Journal, 2009 26. Basel Khraiwesh, Stephan Ossowski, Detlef Weigel, Ralf Reski, and Wolfgang Frank; Specific gene silencing by artificial MicroRNAs in Physcomitrella patens: an alternative to targeted gene knockouts. The Plant Journal, 2008. 27. Brodersen P, Sakvarelidze-Achard L, BruunRasmussen M, Dunoyer P, Yamamoto YY, Sieburth L, Voinnet O, Widespread translational inhibition by plant miRNAs and siRNAs., Science. 2008 May 30;320(5880):1185–90
Chapter 7 Bioinformatics Analysis of Small RNAs in Plants Using Next Generation Sequencing Technologies Kan Nobuta, Kevin McCormick, Mayumi Nakano, and Blake C. Meyers Abstract Next-generation sequencing technologies have a substantial impact on a broad range of biological applications. Like many other groups, we use these new technologies, especially SBS (Sequence-By-Synthesis), for deep profiling of small RNA molecules in plants. Small RNAs are 21–24 nucleotides in length and are known to play a major role in the activation of mRNAs and genomic DNAs. We have generated numerous SBS small RNA libraries; each can consist of more than three million signatures of more than 33 nucleotides in length. Here, we describe the challenges and our strategies to handle the very large quantity of small RNA data generated by these next-generation sequencing technologies. Key words: SBS, MPSS, 454, Gene expression, Small RNA, miRNA, siRNA, Signature
1. Introduction 1.1. Small RNA Molecules
The discovery of RNA-based silencing systems has changed our understanding of mechanisms of transcription, translation, and the regulation of gene expression. There are two major classes of these RNA molecules in plants: microRNAs (miRNAs) and small interfering RNAs (siRNAs), which are approximately 21–24 nucleotides in length. In plants, miRNAs are known to regulate mRNAs primarily at the posttranscriptional level by directing mRNA cleavage, while endogenous siRNAs can trigger DNA methylation and histone modifications, leading to gene silencing. Small RNAs have been identified in nearly all eukaryotes, an indication of both the importance and the ancient origin of these regulatory molecules. The pool of small RNAs in plants is highly complex, consisting primarily of a diverse set of low-abundance siRNAs (1). Extensive
B.C. Meyers and P.J. Green (eds.), Plant MicroRNAs, Methods in Molecular Biology, vol. 592 DOI 10.1007/978-1-60327-005-2_7, © Humana Press, a part of Springer Science + Business Media, LLC 2010
89
90
Nobuta et al.
work on the relatively small number of Arabidopsis miRNAs has demonstrated that these RNAs regulate the expression of many genes that play key roles in development and stress responses (2). 1.2. Next Generation Sequencing Technologies
The technology to sequence a large number of DNA molecules in a short period of time and in a cost-effective manner has developed rapidly in the last few years. Massively Parallel Signature Sequencing (MPSS) was the first methodology of this type (although the “cost-effective manner” of that method is debatable), and we have used this technology for both mRNA and small RNA transcriptome profiling (1, 3). Although MPSS generated hundreds of thousands to millions of signatures per library, the sequence length was limited to 17–20 bases (3). Since the length of small RNA molecules is primarily 21–24 bases in plants, MPSS signatures were not able to capture the information of full-length miRNA and siRNA sequences. Unlike MPSS, the sequencing length of the pyrosequencing-based technology from 454 Life Sciences can exceed 100 bases, which is more than long enough to obtain the full-length sequence of small RNA molecules (http://www.454.com). However, the sampling depth of this technology, which recently measured in the hundreds of thousands of reads, is not enough to capture the full complexity of small RNA molecules, particularly in comparison to other, newer technologies. Illumina (http://www.illumina.com) developed a new sequencing technology often referred to by the generic name, sequencing-by-synthesis, or “SBS.” Illumina’s approach uses reversible nucleotide terminators to sequence short DNA fragments (signatures). Although the sequence length of SBS is currently ~33–35 bases and hence not as long as that of 454, it is long enough to capture the full-length sequence of the small RNA molecules. More importantly, SBS can sequence millions of signatures in parallel. This capacity is deep enough to capture almost all the small RNA molecules in a given sample. There are a number of potentially competing technologies emerging, with Applied Biosystems leading the pack with their “SOLiD” sequencing device; however, these machines are only now being put to routine use in the laboratory. In any case, the methods that we describe here are easily adapted for any high through-put shortread DNA sequencing technology.
1.3. SBS Small RNA Expression Database
We have generated numerous small RNA libraries from various organisms, with the libraries sequenced using MPSS, 454, and SBS. Here, as an example, we mainly focus on the databases we created for Arabidopsis and rice small RNA libraries sequenced with Illumina’s SBS technology. The SBS signatures were handled as we describe below and stored in a relational database.
1.3.1. Trimming and Mapping
In order to extract the biologically relevant data from the raw SBS output, it is important to understand how the libraries are constructed.
Bioinformatics Analysis of Small RNAs in Plants
91
The details of the small RNA library construction method are described in Chapter 8 of this volume. Briefly, RNA molecules in the approximate size range of 20–25 nucleotides are recovered from a sample of total RNA; after ligating 5¢ and 3¢ RNA adapters and making cDNA from this, the product is subjected to SBS sequencing. The sequencing reaction reads not only the small RNA molecule, which is flanked by the two adapters (5¢ and 3¢), but also the adapter sequences. Therefore, all the potential adapter sequences have to be removed from the SBS signatures. We look for both 5¢ and 3¢ adapter sequences with up to two mismatches to allow for sequencing errors and reduce the number of untrimmed sequences. We have used the known microRNA sequences, obtained from Sanger registry (4), as a training set, and we optimized the minimum and maximum of bases in the adapter sequences to consider for trimming. As an example, Fig. 1 shows a typical trimming result from an SBS library. As expected, the majority of the signatures had a 3¢ adapter sequence, and more than 90% of the sequences had a relatively long insert (e.g., >18 bp), which was kept for genome matching (Fig. 1). In contrast, a small number of signatures had a 5¢ adapter sequence, and almost all of them were not usable (Fig. 1). After trimming, we map all the SBS signatures to a genomic sequence. Since both Arabidopsis (Col-0) and rice (Oryza sativa ssp. japonica cv. Nipponbare) genomic sequences have very high quality, and materials derived from either of these inbred genotypes are usually highly homozygous, we consider only perfect matches.
no adaptor 27,164
5’ adaptor trimmed 2,192
error 6,818 5’ adaptor 248,222
Orphan signatures 706,344
trimming
SBS library example 3,170,342 3’ adaptor 2,888,138
mapping Insert < 18 bp Match to genome 2,030,543 3’ adaptor trimmed 2,734,695
Fig. 1. An example of trimming and mapping results with an SBS small RNA library: This specific SBS library had 3,170,342 distinct signatures. As expected, our trimming script identified a high proportion of signatures with 3¢ adaptor sequences and fewer than 10% of the signatures with 5¢ adaptor sequence. A very small portion of the signatures had no adaptor sequence or signatures with nonGATC characters (errors). Among the signatures with a 3¢ adaptor sequence, a large proportion of them had a long insert (>18 bp), while fewer than 1% of those with a 5¢ adaptor sequence passed this filter. More than two million trimmed signatures were mapped successfully to the rice genome.
92
Nobuta et al.
The script scans through the chromosomal sequence from the beginning to the end, performing a simple string search. With the same rice example above, we were able to map more than two million SBS signatures (18–33 bp) on the genome (Fig. 1). The remaining signatures (~700,000 “orphans”) could be the result of mismatches, RNA editing, sequences spanning intron/ exon junctions, or derived from gaps in the rice genomic sequence. The details of the trimming and mapping algorithms are described below (see Subheadings 3.1 and 3.3). 1.3.2. Associations with Annotated Genes and Other Genomic Sequences
Plant small RNA libraries represent a complex mixture of several types of molecules, including the following: highly abundant miRNAs that are few in number; weakly expressed siRNAs that number in the millions in terms of sequence diversity; a large number of “contaminating” tRNAs, rRNAs, snRNAs and snoRNAs; and other small classes of small RNAs like trans-acting siRNAs, or natural-antisense transcript siRNAs that we won’t describe here. The tRNAs, rRNAs, snRNAs, and snoRNAs are all major components of small RNA libraries. Since small RNAs derived from these RNAs share characteristics with miRNAs, like high abundances and representation in most libraries, it is important to flag them for removal from later analyses. In order to associate signatures with annotated genes, we first map them to the genome and store all coordinates (chromosome, position, and strand) in a table. Then, we run a gene mapping script that, for each gene, identifies all signatures between its starting and ending coordinates. If a signature is within a “contaminating” sequence, we mark it with a flag, which will be pertinent later on.
1.3.3. Normalization and Summary Table
The total number of signatures sequenced by SBS differs from library to library. In order to compare the expression level of a particular signature across the libraries, the abundance values must be normalized. This calculation is performed for each signature and for each library, based on the total abundance of the libraries. We select a round number that is close to the total number of sequences as the basis for normalization. However, since not all the signatures match to the genomic sequence (presumably, primarily due to errors or gaps in the sequence), we exclude these signatures from the calculation of the total used for normalization. In addition, we exclude the “flagged” signatures described above (t/r/sn/snoRNAs). We then subtract the abundance of these signatures (flagged and non-matching) from the total raw abundance to determine the adjusted total raw abundance. In order to obtain the normalized value for each small RNA, each raw value is divided by the adjusted total raw abundance and multiplied by a normalization factor that is close to the adjusted total raw abundance but is a round number that is typically a multiple of a million or half a million. These normalized values allow us to accurately compare
Bioinformatics Analysis of Small RNAs in Plants
93
the expression levels of signatures across libraries. It is possible to further normalize the expression levels by dividing the normalized value by the total number of locations to which a tag matches; we refer to this as the “hits-normalized abundance” (HNA). 1.4. Genomic Database and Web Interface
Many small RNA analyses are based on comparisons between annotated genes and features of the genome. We use the most recent annotations of Arabidopsis (TAIR7.0) or rice (TIGR5.0) genomes in our analyses, but any sequenced plant genome could be used. We run an XML parser, which is written in Java with SAX, and extract all the necessary information (e.g., gene coordinates, genomic sequence, etc.) from these files. These sets of information are necessary as described above when we associate signatures to annotated genes. After extracting the genomic sequence from the files, we run the programs RepeatMasker (5), and Einverted/ Etandem (6), to identify the repetitive regions in the genome. These data are necessary to construct the small RNA database, flag specific types of small RNAs (mentioned above), and to display SBS data through our web interface (http://mpss.udel.edu). We have adapted for SBS data the interface that we developed previously to display our MPSS data (7). However, we made minor adjustments to accommodate the large data size of SBS. For example, the number of signatures displayed in a certain window is restricted to human readable size instead of displaying all of them at once. The details of our interface and the available tools can be found elsewhere (7).
2. Materials Our servers use Linux 2.6 as an OS and have at least 8 GB of memory with multiple Intel Xeon processors with more than 2 GHz of CPU speed. We took advantage of these configurations and developed various scripts (Perl and Java), which require large memory space but run in a relatively short period. The scripts extract expression data from the sequencing results and store them in a MySQL server as a “Small RNA Expression Database.” Similarly, we extract genomic information from the files provided by various institutes and store them in a MySQL server as a “Genomic Database.” The web interface, mainly written in PHP, extracts the data requested by the user from these two databases and displays the query results in graphical and analytical outputs. 2.1. Small RNA Expression Database
1. As described in chapter 8, small RNAs can be cloned and sequenced using high-throughput parallel methods like SBS, and we have generated numerous small RNA libraries from diverse plant species. A typical library consists of nonredundant signature sequences and corresponding abundance values.
94
Nobuta et al.
These raw data, as well as the data with normalized values, are downloadable from our website for the users who want to perform their own analyses. 2. In addition to the small RNA libraries generated in our lab, we have downloaded libraries that are publicly available from GEO (Gene Expression Omnibus). At the time of the preparation of this manuscript, our Arabidopsis and rice small RNA databases have numerous libraries that were sequenced by MPSS, 454, or SBS. We developed a package of scripts to parse these data, extract the necessary information, and build MySQL small RNA databases. 3. In addition to the signature sequences and their expression levels, the details of each library are stored in this database. Users can find information such as the library developer, the developmental stage and the condition of the plants that were used for small RNA extraction, etc. Furthermore, we record the number of signatures that match to the given genome as well as to tRNA, rRNA, snRNA, and snoRNA genes. These sets of information are useful to determine the quality of the libraries. 2.2. Genomic Database and Web Interface
1. We use genomic assemblies (pseudochromosomes) provided by public genome projects, as well as annotation files provided by such groups. The Arabidopsis and rice annotations can be downloaded in TIGR XML format from TAIR (The Arabidopsis Information resource: http://arabidopsis.org/) and Michigan State University (MSU, http://rice.plantbiology.msu.edu/), respectively. Our Java XML parser extracts necessary information and stores them in relational database such as MySQL. 2. Although the XML files from TAIR and TIGR contain almost all the information necessary for our analyses, we download additional genomic information from other providers, and those data come in a variety of file formats. For example, we obtain miRNA information in gff file format from the Sanger registry (http://microrna.sanger.ac.uk/sequences/). We customize our scripts to parse different file formats and add the information to the genomic database. 3. In order to complete our genomic database, we perform additional analyses with the data extracted from TAIR, TIGR, and other institutes. For example, we run publicly available programs, such as RepeatMasker, Einverted, and Etandem, to identify repetitive sequences on the given genome and store the information in MySQL tables. We associate this information with expression data and distinguish miRNA from siRNA signatures. In addition, we run a miRNA target prediction program developed in our lab using previously described rules (8) to identify potential targets of all known and novel miRNAs.
Bioinformatics Analysis of Small RNAs in Plants
95
4. Based on the analyses above, users can access from our website a brief description of the small RNA MPSS data, links to known microRNAs, inverted repeats, tandem repeats, pericentromeric regions, weakly predicted transposons, and trans-acting siRNAs. Users can simply click the examples to get an idea of our visualization and data access tools. A schema of a database for storing and handling SBS small RNA data is shown in Fig. 2.
3. Methods In this section, we focus on three major steps in the handling of SBS small RNA libraries and the identification of miRNAs from these data: trimming and mapping of the data, updating the database, and identification of miRNAs. We use a rice small RNA data set as an example to describe these steps. 3.1. Trimming of SBS Small RNA Signatures
We start by scanning each raw sequence for both 5¢ and 3¢ adapter sequences. This script allows up to two mismatches to allow for sequencing errors and reduce the number of untrimmed sequences. After the adapters are removed, the identical sequences are collapsed into a single file of nonredundant sequences with an associated abundance. The trimming steps are described below. 1. The script takes a couple of required and optional arguments, so that the users can run the script with their preferred conditions. For example, one of the optional arguments is the number of mismatches. As a default setting, the script looks for 5¢ and/ or 3¢ adapter sequence with up to two mismatches in a given SBS signature. The script does not allow more than two mismatches but allows the users to change it to either zero or one mismatch. 2. The SBS sequencing result is one of the required fields. Many institutes now have an Illumina SBS machine and provide sequencing services. Depending on the institute, the sequencing results are delivered in a range of file formats. Our script assumes that the file consists of nonredundant sequences with an associated abundance in a particular format. If the given file is not in one of our “standard” formats, the file has to be reformatted to a standard format, such as the signature sequence and the associated abundance value delimited by tabs. 3. The adapter sequences are divided into three parts (start, middle, end) and are used as seed sequences. The length of the seed sequences is based on the minimum sequence that can be recognized as an adapter sequence. The script goes through the input file and creates three separate files: (1) signatures with potential 5¢
mRNA data run_master
run_info
expression_raw
run_id
run_id int tag_id int frequency int confidence int
run_id int tag_length int lib_id tinyint stepper int raw_sum int
run_id int tag_id int tag char raw_value int lib_id tinyint stepper int
run_id
Summary
lib_id
tag_id int tag char stepper_chosen int reliable int significant int lib_norm int hits tinyint chr_id tinyint strand enum(’w’,’c’) position int class tinyint gene char model int
library_info library_master tag_id
tag_id int tag char lib_id tinyint norm_2 norm_4
lib_id
lib_id int name char organism char variety char RNA_extract_method char sample_source char description text
library_detail lib_id
lib_id int tag_length int raw_stepper_2_sum double raw_stepper_4_sum double distinct_tags_cnt int total_tags_cnt int
tag_id
tag_master tag_id int tag char length int
Genomic data
tag_class tag_position_id int tag_id_17 int tag_17 char tag_id_20 int tag_20 char chr_id int strand enum('w','c') position int class char gene char model int exon_id int exon_position int
tag_position
tag_hits tag_id int hits int
tag_id
chr_inverted chr_id char * start1 int end1 int start2 int end2 int score int per tinyint gap int dis int avg_len int
tag_position_id int tag_id_17 int tag_17 char tag_id_20 int tag_20 char chr_id int strand enum('w','c') position int gene char model int
tag_position_id
chr_tandem chr_id char * start int* end int* len int score int size int count int per float
chr_repeats chr_id char * start int end int len int SW_score int repeat_id char * repeat_class char *
chr_id
gene
chr_id
gene_master
chromosome_master chr_id int * length int organism varchar lineage varchar seq_group varchar centromere_location int
chr_id
pep_blast
gene
gene varchar subject varchar e-val double
gene char chr_id int strand enum('w','c') coord_start int coord_end int model_cnt int title varchar
gene_position gene char model int exon_id int utr int coord_start int coord_end int
gene
Small RNA data run_master tag char raw_value int lib_id tinyint
tag
tag_position tag
tag char chr_id char strand enum('w','c') position int gene char
library_details lib_id int flag tinyint raw_sum int distinct_tags_cnt int
lib_id
lib_id
library_info
Summary tag char reliable int significant int lib_norm int hits tinyint
run_info lib_id int raw_sum int
lib_id
lib_id int name char organism char variety char RNA_extract_method char sample_source char description text
Schema Fig. 2. Schema of a database for storing and handling SBS small RNA data: The database is designed with three major sets of data. The lines connecting tables indicate one-to-one (simple lines) or one-to-many (branched lines) relationships. The field name above or below the lines indicates the key that connects the tables. Note that not all the fields and the tables are listed in this figure.
Bioinformatics Analysis of Small RNAs in Plants
97
adapter sequences, (2) signatures with potential 3¢ adapter sequences, and (3) signatures with no potential adapter sequence. Pseudocode: • For each SBS signature in sequencing result file: – Compare the three seed sequences of the 5¢ adapter sequence. (a) If it exists, record the following to a new file (file1): signature sequence, associated abundance, and which seed sequence matched to the query sequence. (b) Else, compare the seed sequences of the 3¢ adapter sequence. * If it exists, record the same information as above to a separate file (file2). * Else, record the rest to another file (file3). 4. We next examine file1 to determine if the 5¢ adapter sequence is contained in the SBS signature. Depending on whether the 5¢ adapter sequence is remaining in the SBS signature, we do one of the following with the signature sequence and associated abundance count: (1) keep these data as well as the length of contaminated adapter sequence in a data structure, (2) record them in a file, or (3) send them to an error file. Pseudocode: • For each SBS signature with 5¢ “start” seed sequence, examine the downstream sequence of this seed sequence: – If the downstream sequence matches upstream of the 5¢ “mid” seed sequence (with or without mismatches), send to error file. – Else, record the signature and the count to a new file (file4). • For each SBS signature with 5¢ “end” seed sequence, examine the upstream sequence of this seed sequence: – If the upstream sequence matches downstream of the 5¢ “mid” seed sequence (with or without mismatches), examine the remaining length. (a) If the length is longer than 18 (by default), record the information in hash-of-array (comboHoA): SBS signature → (length of adapter, count). – Else, record the signature and the count to a new file (file4). • For each SBS signature with 5¢ “mid” seed sequence, examine the sequences both upstream and downstream of this seed sequence: – If the upstream and downstream sequences match to the 5¢ “start” and “end” seed sequence (with or without mismatches), respectively, examine the remaining length and either record the information in the hash-of-array or send to the error file, as above.
98
Nobuta et al.
– Else, record the signature and the count to a new file (file4). 5. Examine the signatures in file3 and look for potential 5¢ adapter seed sequences with mismatches. Treat the signature sequences and the associated counts in the same way as above (step 4) based on the location of the identified 5¢ adapter sequence in the SBS signature. 6. Examine file2 and determine the 3¢ adapter sequence contaminated in the SBS signature. A similar algorithm as step 4 was applied here, except the “start” and “end” seed sequences were treated in an opposite way. For example, in this step, signatures with 3¢ adapter “end” and part of “mid” seed sequences were sent to the error file, while in step 4, signatures with 5¢ adapter “start” and part of “mid” seed sequences were sent to the error file. The reason behind this is that, most likely, the signatures with the end of the 3¢ adapter and the start of 5¢ adapter sequence have no or very short inserts between the two adapters. 7. Another difference between step 4 (5¢ adapter trimming) and step 6 (3¢ adapter trimming) is that the signatures that satisfy the conditions in step 6 are trimmed and kept in the final hash table (allH) and not in comboHoA. Pseudocode: • For each SBS signature with 3¢ adapter sequence with up to two mismatches: – If the length of remaining sequence is longer than 18 (by default), trim the adapter sequence off from the signature and record the information in allH. (a) If the trimmed signature exists in allH, add the new count to the old one. (b) Else, add trimmed signature as a key and the count as a value to allH. 8. The signatures in file4 that were generated during step 4 have no identifiable 5¢ adapter sequence. Each signature is subjected to the 3¢ adapter trimming (steps 6 and 7), and all the resulting data are stored either in allH or the error file. Similarly, the signatures in the comboHoA are subjected to the same steps. If the remaining sequence, after trimming 5¢ adapter sequence and 3¢ adapter sequence (if they exist), is longer than 18 bases, the sequence is kept in allH. 9. In the final step, the script parses allH and, after final adjustment, it prints out the trimmed results with associated abundance to a final file. Pseudocode: • For each key (trimmed signature) and the value (summed abundance value):
Bioinformatics Analysis of Small RNAs in Plants
99
– If the signature has more than 75% A’s, send to the error file (as SBS produces A-rich sequences that are noise and not real), otherwise: (a) If the length of the signature is full-length (no identifiable 5¢ or 3¢ adapter), * Examine the last three bases of the signature, and if it ends with one of TCG, TC, or T, trim if off and print out to the final file. Otherwise, simply print out the untrimmed signature and the abundance value. (b) Else, print out the key and the value to the final file. 3.2. Preparing a Genome Database for the Small RNA Data
We make our data visible via a customized web interface. This visualization tool makes the data more accessible to biologists without computational or bioinformatics skills and improves the interpretability of these data. The detail of the construction of the genomic database can be found elsewhere (7). Here, we focus on the genomic information in the database that is specific for small RNA data analyses. 1. The majority of the information is derived from XML files provided by TIGR and TAIR. One of the most important sets of information is the coordinate of the annotated genes. These sets of information allow us to draw the gene structure and the associated small RNA signatures on our web interface. 2. Another important piece of information is the type of annotated genes. Currently, we categorize the genes into eight classes: protein coding gene, pseudogene, TE (Transposable Element), miRNA, tRNA, sRNA, snRNA, and snoRNA. All the classes, especially the last four classes (t/r/sn/snoRNA genes), are particularly important for small RNA analyses. Although almost all the information of these gene classes can be found in the XML files, some of them are not included in these files. For example, we obtained Indica rice snoRNA information (9) and utilized that information after mapping the snoRNA sequences to the Nipponbare genome. Similarly, we regularly obtain the most updated miRNA information from Sanger registry and manually add them to our existing genome database. 3. The t/r/sn/snoRNAs genes are structural RNAs that are constitutively expressed at high levels in many organisms, and thousands of signatures from each library correspond to these genes. Since most likely these signatures are degradation products of t/r/sn/snoRNAs and not regulatory small RNA molecules such as miRNA and siRNAs, we “flag” the t/r/sn/ snoRNA-matching signatures to allow us to easily exclude them from small RNA analyses.
100
Nobuta et al.
4. Another critical piece of information for the genomic database is the repetitive sequence information. Since repetitive sequences are known to be sources of siRNAs, this information helps us to distinguish miRNA signatures from siRNA signatures. Although TAIR and TIGR provide annotated TE information, we use freely available computer programs, such as RepeatMasker (http://repeatmasker.org) (5), Etandem, and Einverted (6), and extract the coordinates of different kinds of repetitive sequences as well as those with low cut-off values (i.e., poorly predicted or poorly annotated repeats) from the genome sequence. The coordinates of the repeat regions and the type of repeats are stored in the MySQL tables and are displayed on our web interface. 3.3. Mapping of Small RNA Sequences to a Genome and Association to Annotated Genes
To facilitate analyses of the data for plant species for which a genome is available, the small RNA sequences are mapped to the genome. We use and record only perfectly matching sequences to avoid complications of small RNAs matching to multiple closelyrelated sequences. There are two important considerations in this step: (1) sequences may match to more than one location in the genome, and may have originated from a subset of those locations; (2) sequences with errors will be ignored in future analyses. We do not consider point #2 to be important, since the depth of these libraries is already substantial. 1. The mapping script performs a simple string search from the start to the end of the given nucleotide (genomic) sequence, which is converted to an array. Since the length of the strings (small RNA signatures) varies from 18 bases to roughly 33 bases, the script splits each signature into a ‘head’ (18 bases) and the ‘tail’ (the remaining) part, and then stores the information in a hash-of-array with the head sequence as the key and the rest of the sequences in an array format. The script slides a ~33 base (full-length) window through the genomic sequence array, and if the head part of this sequence exists in the hash-of-array, the script then compares rest of the sequences. If the entire (head + tail) sequence matches to the genomic sequence, the script records the coordinates (index + 1). Pseudocode: • For each ~33 base (full-length) sequence in the given nucleotide sequence: – If the head part of this sequence exists in hash-of-array, get the ‘tail’ sequences in an array: (a) For each ‘tail’ sequence in the array, construct the ‘head + tail’ sequence. * If the ‘full-length’ starts with this sequence, record the index of genomic sequence array.
Bioinformatics Analysis of Small RNAs in Plants
101
2. Since all the signatures are stored in a hash-of-array, the script requires a relatively large amount of memory. In addition, an array with the genomic sequence requires large memory size as well. However, depending on the available memory space, users can split the genomic sequences into pieces and identify the coordinates of the signatures. After identifying the coordinates on the reading strand, the script goes through similar steps with the reverse complement strand. 3. After mapping the signatures, the coordinates are compared to the information stored in the genome database. This comparison allows us to associate the location of the signatures relative to the annotated genes. With these data, we can identify the origin of the signatures. For example, the information of the signatures that originated from t/r/sn/snoRNA genes are important for our normalization procedure, which is described below. 3.4. Updating the Database with New Libraries
As the cost of SBS sequencing goes down, generating SBS libraries become more affordable, and the frequency increases with which updates are made to the database with new libraries. Since an average small RNA SBS library consists of millions of distinct signatures and associated abundance values, the updating step is time-consuming and requires large amounts of computational power. There are multiple tables that are affected with the arrival of each new library. Here, we focus on the update of the table that holds almost all the information necessary for small RNA analyses. 1. This table consists of SBS signatures as a primary key, the number of hits to the genome, a flag to indicate if the signature originated from a t/r/sn/snoRNA gene, and the normalized abundance level identified in each library. Pseudocode: • For each new library, alter the table and add a new column that stores the normalized abundance level of each signature. – If the signature exists in the table, normalize the raw abundance value and record. – Else, insert the new signature and the normalized abundance value. The rest of the libraries are assigned an abundance value of zero. 2. The basic normalization formula is described above. Also, noted above is the important point that since some small RNA signatures do not match to the genome, and a large proportion of genome-matching small RNA signatures are derived from t/r/sn/snoRNAs, which are not small RNA molecules, we subtract the abundance value of these molecules from the sum of raw abundance before normalization. 3. Known microRNAs are identified in the data set based on their genomic coordinates, although we don’t currently assign a special flag to these sequences.
102
Nobuta et al.
4. At this point, our database is ready to be connected to our website. 3.5. Analyses of miRNAs from Small RNA Datasets
3.5.1. Identification of Regulated miRNAs
One of the primary analysis goals of producing a small RNA data set is to identify regulated small RNAs or to identify new small RNAs. In this section, we describe the approaches that we use for both of these types of analyses. In both Arabidopsis and rice, hundreds of miRNAs have been identified and registered at Sanger registry (http://microrna. sanger.ac.uk/sequences/). Many of these miRNAs are known to regulate genes that have critical functions in various aspects of plant biology. We have generated libraries of various tissues, developmental stages, stress treatments, etc. to compare the abundance of miRNAs and to identify specific sequences (siRNAmatching regions) that have characteristics suggesting that the small RNAs are differentially regulated. 1. Most of the miRNAs are 21 nt in length and are consistently processed from a precursor to generate the same 21-mer. However, the processing is not always exact, and some small RNAs are derived from the precursor but shifted by one or two bases in the 5¢ or 3¢ direction from the annotated miRNA. Therefore, in order to estimate the expression level of miRNAs, we calculate the “sum of the abundance” of all the signatures that correspond to the precursor of a given miRNA, instead of using just the abundance of the exact, annotated miRNA. 2. All the necessary pieces of data are distributed to three tables: gene_master, tag_position, and summary table on our mySQL server. The gene_master table stores the ID (gene name) of all the annotated miRNAs (in addition to annotated proteincoding and other genes). The tag_position table has all the signatures that map to the genome, including those that correspond to each gene, and the summary table has the abundance value of each signature. We join these three tables and calculate the expression level of each miRNA gene. 3. These values are compared among the libraries to identified miRNAs showing evidence of differential expression or regulation under a certain condition. Unfortunately, at the time of preparation, we do not have enough biological replicates to use statistical approaches for the comparison. Therefore, we focus on the miRNAs that show distinct expression differences (>10 times) among the libraries and verify the findings with other biological methods such as RNA gel blots.
3.5.2. Identification of Novel miRNA Candidates
The aim of this analysis is to identify candidates for new miRNAs. Although many miRNAs have been identified by various laboratories using different approaches (experimental and predictive),
Bioinformatics Analysis of Small RNAs in Plants
103
given the breadth of plant species, we are far from having discovered the full set of miRNAs for most plant species. In order to extract candidate miRNAs from deep sequencing small RNA data, we combine genomic approaches and a variety of filters. Known miRNAs are included in the analysis as a positive control, to determine which filters inadvertently catch and remove the known miRNAs. We have previously described the implementation of multiple data filters that capture most known Arabidopsis miRNAs (1). Here, we describe the filters that we apply to annotated genomes, such as rice and Arabidopsis, and an approach to identify candidate plant miRNAs from species for which there is no genomic sequence. A flowchart describing how these filters are implemented is shown in Fig. 3. The filters include metrics for each small RNA that are based on the number of libraries in which it is expressed, sparse clusters, an abundance filter, a paired filter, and a secondary structure filter. These filters are explained in the following steps: 1. The “number of expressed libraries” looks for the signatures that are expressed in the majority (more than half) of the libraries in a database. Although multiple libraries need to be available to apply this filter, we have found that this filter is one of the best filters to identify miRNAs as they are generally
307,064 unique small RNA tags
Sequence in at least half of multiple libraries (4,194) Sequence with abundance ≥ 100 TPQ (351) Sequence hit to rice genome ≥ 20 (97)
Part of known miRNAs (80)
1. Consistent expression across libraries 2. Abundance
Sequence hit to rice genome <20 (254)
Potentially new miRNAs (39)
Detailed analysis: • Foldback consolidation • miRNA* detection
3. Uniqueness
Match to other ncRNA or siRNA loci (135)
4. Folding structure 5. miRNA / miRNA* pair
Fig. 3. Flowchart of analyses used for the identification of miRNAs from plant small RNA libraries. This flowchart and the filters were developed based on the properties of known plant miRNAs. The numbers give a rough idea how we were able to reduce and refine the numbers of small RNAs to the most interesting subset. These can be verified by biologists with various molecular biology approaches (described elsewhere in this volume). The signatures counted in the black boxes represent those that passed the filters.
104
Nobuta et al.
quite consistently expressed (10). In a dataset that includes many libraries (~15 libraries or more), it may be possible to lower the cutoff for this filter to include sequences found in ~ 30% of all libraries and still not identify many siRNAs with this filter. 2. A “sparse cluster” means that only one to ten signatures were found in a region with no additional signatures within 500 bp of the 5¢ or 3¢ ends. The main purpose of this filter is to exclude heterochromatic siRNAs from the candidate list. These siRNAs are typically generated from repetitive regions of the plant genome. This process leads to hundreds of siRNA molecules from a relatively short distance on a genome and, unlike miRNAs, they form a “dense cluster.” miRNAs tend to form clusters of relatively few sequences because the processing from a precursor is so precise (see Note 1). 3. The “paired” filter searches for two small RNAs or “sets” of small RNAs that are located within 20–180 nt on the same strand (the candidate miRNA and miRNA*), and display a difference in abundance of 1:10 or greater; a “set” was defined as the consensus sequence of two or more overlapping signatures with 5¢ ends within two nucleotides of each other. This filter is useful to identify miRNA candidates because their precursors form secondary structures (“hairpins”) that are processed to generate the mature miRNA and semi-complementary molecule (miRNA*) during its biogenesis. Although miRNA* molecules are degraded rapidly, deep sampling with next generation sequencing technologies allows the capture of these molecules, albeit at a lower level than their corresponding miRNA partners. 4. The “abundance” filter identifies small RNAs with a normali zed abundance level in one of the libraries equal to or greater than 25 out of 250,000 sequences (25 TPQ). Most of the known miRNAs are relatively abundant and pass this filter. However, this is a somewhat strict criterion, and some miRNAs are found below those levels. 5. As mentioned above (step 3), miRNA precursors form hairpin structures, so these can be identified in some cases using RNA folding programs. We extract short stretches of sequences that contain the SBS signatures that satisfy the conditions described above, and we then run the program mfold (http:// www.bioinfo.rpi.edu/applications/mfold/) to select regions predicted to form hairpin-like structures. Among those results, we manually assess the quality of the secondary structure to see if there is good pairing of the miRNA and candidate miRNA* in the hairpin structure. If so, we validate these
Bioinformatics Analysis of Small RNAs in Plants
105
miRNA candidates using laboratory techniques described elsewhere in this volume. 6. The filters described above are a very powerful approach to identify miRNA candidates for the plant species that have high-quality genome annotation. Although it is challenging to identify miRNAs for plant species that have not been sequenced, the “abundance” and “number of expressed libraries” filters are both useful in this situation, and it may be possible to identify miRNA candidates based on the conservation of sequences across plant species. This requires multiple libraries from different species, and it may exclude nonconserved miRNAs, particularly if the comparisons are across widely divergent species. Tools that are useful for these types of analyses are described in this volume in Chapter 12. With new applications of next generation sequencing technologies becoming available, it is possible that new techniques for miRNA identification will soon be available for species for which the genomes have not been completely sequenced.
4. Notes Differentially regulated siRNA clusters can be identified by clustering adjacent small RNAs and summing the abundance of these clusters within each library, including sequences on both strands (since siRNAs are not strand-specific). We have previously described our proximity-based algorithm to cluster small RNAs (1). The clusters were dependent only on the distances between small RNAs and were independent of annotated genomic features such as genes. This facilitated the comparison of clusters across libraries while removing the bias that the annotation might introduce. The optimal cluster size was determined by comparing the results of clustering based on joining signatures within 100, 250, or 500 bp of each other for each library. We had found that clusters joining small RNAs within 500 bp of each other were optimal because this size reduced the number of single, unclustered signatures by approximately two-thirds in each library.
Acknowledgments The work on the tools, approaches, and the databases described here were developed with support from the NSF Plant Genome Research Program.
106
Nobuta et al.
References 1. Lu C, Tej SS, Luo S, Haudenschild CD, Meyers BC, Green PJ (2005) Elucidation of the small RNA component of the transcriptome. Science 309:1567–1569 2. Mallory AC, Vaucheret H (2006) Functions of microRNAs and related small RNAs in plants. Nat Genet 38 Suppl:S31–S36 3. Meyers BC, Tej SS, Vu TH, Haudenschild CD, Agrawal V, Edberg SB, Ghazal H, Decola S (2004) The use of MPSS for whole-genome transcriptional analysis in Arabidopsis. Genome Res 14:1641–1653 4. Griffiths-Jones S (2004) The microRNA registry. Nucleic Acids Res 32:D109–D111 5. Smit AFA, Hubley R, Green P (1996–2004) RepeatMasker Open-3.0. http://www.repeatmasker.org 6. Rice P, Longden I, Bleasby A (2000) EMBOSS: the European Molecular Biology Open Software Suite. Trends Genet 16: 276–277
7. Nakano M, Nobuta K, Vemaraju K, Tej SS, Skogen JW, Meyers BC (2006) Plant MPSS databases: signature-based transcriptional resources for analyses of mRNA and small RNA. Nucleic Acids Res 34:D731–D735 8. Jones-Rhoades MW, Bartel DP (2004) Computational identification of plant microRNAs and their targets, including a stressinduced miRNA. Mol Cell 14:787–799 9. Chen CL, Liang D, Zhou H, Zhuo M, Chen YQ, Qu LH (2003) The high diversity of snoRNAs in plants: identification and comparative study of 120 snoRNA genes from Oryza sativa. Nucleic Acids Res 31:2601–2613 10. Lu C, Jeong DH, Kulkarni K, Pillay M, Nobuta K, German R, Thatcher SR, Maher C, Zhang L, Ware D, Liu B, Cao X, Meyers BC, Green PJ (2008) Genome-wide analysis for discovery of rice microRNAs reveals natural antisense microRNAs (nat-miRNAs). Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 105:4951–4956
Chapter 8 High-Throughput Approaches for miRNA Expression Analysis Cheng Lu and Frédéric Souret Abstract miRNAs have emerged as key regulators of gene expression in both plants and animals. These small (generally 21–22 nt) RNA molecules, originated from primary “hairpin” transcripts, can induce translational suppression or direct mRNA cleavage. Similar to regular mRNAs, the expression of miRNAs is highly regulated. Their expression pattern could provide critical clues to understanding miRNA functions. However, many previously identified miRNA families have multiple paralogous loci. Within each family, different members are often closely related and sometimes give rise to identical miRNAs. This poses critical challenges in the analysis of individual miRNA genes. This chapter describes several methods that are commonly used for miRNA expression analysis, including high-throughput sequencing, microarrays, and briefly discusses qRT-PCR, northern blotting, and other approaches used for data validation. Key words: High-throughput sequencing, Microarrays, small RNA library, microRNA, siRNA, qRT-PCR, Northern blotting
1. Introduction miRNAs are a family of noncoding RNAs that negatively regulate gene expression at the posttranscriptional level. Most plant miRNAs have near-perfect pairing to their targets and therefore generally cause mRNA cleavage (1, 2). Numerous studies have demonstrated the critical role of miRNAs in controlling developmental processes and organ identity (3–5). More recently, evidence has emerged from several groups demonstrating a role for miRNAs in abiotic/biotic stress responses and regulation of trans-acting (ta)-siRNA biogenesis (6–10). In keeping with this, many miRNAs
B.C. Meyers and P.J. Green (eds.), Plant MicroRNAs, Methods in Molecular Biology, vol. 592 DOI 10.1007/978-1-60327-005-2_8, © Humana Press, a part of Springer Science + Business Media, LLC 2010
107
108
Lu and Souret
show unique tissue-specific, development-related, and stress-induced expression (4–7, 10). Similar to coding mRNAs, accurate expression profiling of individual miRNA is essential to better understand miRNA function. However, a detailed expression pattern for specific miRNAs is difficult to obtain because of (a) the short length of the mature miRNA, (b) the presence of highly similar miRNA family members, and (c) sometimes the presence of intermediate forms that include the miRNA sequence (e.g., precursors). Northern blotting is still widely used to assess the expression of miRNAs of interest. Combined with denaturing polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, this method provides information about the size and the accumulation level of specific miRNAs. The major disadvantages of the method are its low sensitivity, throughput, cost-effectiveness, and specificity. To overcome the sensitivity obstacle, locked nucleic acid (LNA)-oligonucleotide probes can be used in hybridization. In this case, a tenfold higher sensitivity can generally be achieved with LNA-probes in miRNA northern blotting (11, 12). Microarrays offer another hybridization-based platform for miRNA expression analysis (13–15). Usually, DNA microarrays use a probe set that can cover all the known miRNAs in a genome. Therefore, this technology offers the potential to examine a large number of miRNAs in a single hybridization. Unlike northern blotting, the microarray method does not provide any information regarding the length of the small RNA. Additionally, microarrays inherit the same drawback of low specificity as northern blots. Therefore, microarray data require careful validation and interpretation. New sequencing technologies can greatly improve the identification of miRNAs and provide genome-wide quantitative expression data in a given biological sample. This was first accomplished in Arabidopsis by using Massively Parallel Signature Sequencing (MPSS) (16), and more recently in rice (17, 18). One limitation of MPSS is that only the first 17 nucleotides of the small RNAs were sequenced. The “454” technology, which generates full-length information about small RNAs with moderate depth, has been an alternative approach for high-throughput small RNA sequencing (19–21). Substantial progress has been reported for other nextgeneration sequencing technologies, including Sequencing-BySynthesis (SBS) and Supported Oligo Ligation Detection (SOLiD). With the race for the “$1,000 genome” on, the development of the “next–next” generation of high-throughput sequencing technologies with single-molecule approaches is emerging and could further revolutionize our genomics era. Specific features and characteristics of these new technologies are discussed elsewhere (22). These methods could sequence millions of small RNAs in a single run. Compared with other methods, expression profiling by sequencing offers the best specificity. Members of the same miRNA families that differ by a single nucleotide can be differentiated at
High-Throughput Approaches for miRNA Expression Analysis
109
the sequence level with high accuracy. Another advantage is that sequence knowledge of the miRNAs is not required before the experiment, so it has become a fantastic discovery tool. The cloning frequency of individual small RNAs generally reflects their expression level. However, some bias could arise from differential ligation efficiency at the ends of various small RNAs.
2. Materials All solutions and buffers used in this protocol should be free of RNase and DNase contaminants. All biochemicals should be of the highest quality. RNA adaptors should be resuspended in DEPC-treated water and stored at −80°C until use. DNA oligos should be stored at −20°C until use. 2.1. General Equipment
1. RNase-free mortars, pestles, and spatulas: wrap in foil and bake at 220°C at least 12 h. 2. RNase-free plastic ware: tips, microcentrifuge tubes, and 13 and 30 ml centrifuge tubes.
2.2. Low Molecular Weight (LMW) RNA Isolation
1. RNase-free (DEPC-treated) water: add 0.05% DEPC to distilled water and stir overnight. Autoclave to sterilize the DEPC-treated water. Sterile water should be added to samples during RNA isolation whenever needed. RNase-free sterile water is also available commercially. 2. 50% polyethylene glycol (PEG), MW = 8,000. 3. 5 mg/ml glycogen (Ambion AM9510). 4. 5 M NaCl. 5. Ethanol, 80% and 100%. 6. 1.5% Agarose Gel.
2.3. Purification of 20–30 nt Small RNA
1. 8 M urea/15% polyacrylamide gels (30 ml): 11.8 ml 40% acrylamide stock (Ambion AM9022, Acrylamide/Bis 19:1 solution), 3 ml 10× TBE, 14.4 g urea (powder), 180 ml 10% ammonium persulfate, and 13.8 ml TEMED (add last). 2. 10× TBE. 3. 2× formamide loading buffer: 90% formamide, 1× TBE, xylene cyanol, and bromophenol blue. 4. 10 bp DNA ladder, 1 mg/ml (Invitrogen 10821-015). 5. Ethidium bromide (highly toxic). 6. 0.3 M NaCl. 7. Spin-X filter (Corning 8162).
110
Lu and Souret
2.4. 5′ Adaptor Ligation and Purification
1. 5′ RNA adaptor: 5′ OH-GGU CUU AGU CGC AUC CUG UAG AUG GAUC-OH 3′ (Dharmacon) (see Note 1). 2. 10× RNA ligase buffer (Ambion AM2140). 3. T4 RNA ligase (5 U/µl). 4. 2× loading dye: 90% formamide, 1× TBE, xylene cyanol, and bromophenol blue. 5. 8 M urea/10% polyacrylamide gels. 6. 1× TBE. 7. GlycoBlue™ (15 mg/ml; Ambion AM9515).
2.5. 3¢ Adaptor Ligation and Purification
3′ RNA adaptor. 5′ pUC GUA UGC CGU CUU CUG CUU GidT 3′ where p = phosphate, idT = inverted deoxythymidine (Dharmacon).
2.6. RT-PCR
1. RT-primer: 5′ CAA GCA GAA GAC GGC ATA CGA 3′. 2. 5× first strand buffer (one of the components of Invitrogen 18064-022). 3. dNTP mix, 10 mM (Invitrogen R725-01). 4. DTT, 100 mM. 5. RNaseOUT™ Ribonuclease (RNase) Inhibitor (40 U/µl; Invitrogen 10777-019). 6. Superscript II Reverse Transcriptase (RT) (200 U/µl; Invitrogen 18064-022) and its components. 7. 10× PCR buffer (one of the components of Invitrogen 10342-020). 8. MgCl2, 50 mM. 9. Forward PCR primer. 5′ CAA GCA GAA GAC GGC ATA CGA 3′. 10. Reverse PCR primer. 5′ GGT CTT AGT CGC ATC CTG TAG ATG 3′. 11. Taq DNA polymerase (5 U/µl; Invitrogen 10342-020). 12. 6× loading dye (Promega G1881). 13. 10% TBE-polyacrylamide gel (30 ml). 7.7 ml 40% acrylamide stock (Ambion AM9022, Acrylamide/Bis 19:1 solution), 3 ml 10× TBE, 200 ml 10% ammonium persulfate, and 20 ml TEMED (add last). 14. 10× TBE. 15. Ethidium bromide. 16. 10 bp DNA ladder (1 mg/µl; Invitrogen 10821-015). 17. Buffer saturated phenol, pH 7.9 (Ambion AM9710). 18. Chloroform.
High-Throughput Approaches for miRNA Expression Analysis
111
2.7. P CR Cloning
1. TOPO TA Cloning, pCRII-TOPO version (Invitrogen K4500-01), or pGEM-T (Promega). 2. LB Broth Base (Invitrogen 12780). 3. TOP10 OneShot Cells (Invitrogen K4500-40). 4. X-gal (Invitrogen 15520-034). 5. IPTG (Invitrogen 15529-019).
3. Methods 3.1. Construction of Small RNA cDNA Libraries for HighThroughput Sequencing
To clone small RNAs, RNA adaptors are ligated to the 5′- and 3¢-ends of the small RNA molecules using T4 RNA ligase. This is followed by reverse transcription and PCR amplification. The purified PCR product can then be used for sequencing.
3.1.1. RNA Preparation
Most RNA isolation methods are based on either ethanol precipitation or immobilization on silica-based membrane that may not be suitable for small RNA extraction. Nevertheless, several columnbased methods have now been adapted for small RNA purification (e.g., Qiagen miRNeasy Mini Kit and Invitrogen PureLink™ miRNA Isolation Kit). Trizol reagent (or similar chemicals) has been widely used in RNA isolation for good retention of the small RNA population. A set of detailed protocols for isolation of total RNA that is well-suited for analysis of miRNA can be found in Chap. 3 of this volume. In all the methods described below, the small RNA enrichment step (LMW isolation) is recommended after total RNA isolation. High Molecular weight (HMW) RNAs can be precipitated using 5–10% PEG (MW = 8,000) as outlined below. In the LMW fraction, miRNAs are highly enriched.
3.1.2. Low Molecular Weight RNA Isolation
1. Isolate total RNA according to a protocol in Chap. 3. A yield of 200–400 mg of total RNA is typically used as starting material for the subsequent steps. 2. Dissolve total RNA in sterile DEPC-treated water to a concentration of about 1 mg/ml. 3. Precipitate mRNA and rRNA HMW RNAs by adding 50% PEG (MW = 8,000) to a final concentration of 5%, and 5 M NaCl to a final concentration of 0.5 M. Mix well and put tube on ice for 30 min. 4. To pellet HMW RNAs, spin down at maximum speed in a microcentrifuge (~12 K) for 10 min at 4°C (see Note 2). 5. Transfer supernatant, which contains the LMW RNAs, to a new microcentrifuge tube. Add 2.5 volumes of 100% EtOH, mix well, and place at −20°C for at least 2 h.
112
Lu and Souret
6. To pellet LMW RNAs, spin down at maximum speed in a microcentrifuge for at least 30 min at 4°C. 7. Remove supernatant carefully and wash pellet with 80% EtOH without dislodging. Allow the pellet to air dry. 8. Dissolve the pellet in DEPC-treated water. Use 10 ml of DEPCtreated water per 100 mg of total RNA. 9. To quickly confirm the abundance and integrity of the LMW RNA, run an aliquot of the preparation on a 1.5% agarose gel (see Note 3). 3.1.3. Purification of 20–30 nt Small RNA
Small RNAs ranging from 20 to 30 nt in length are further purified from the LMW fraction using the following protocol: 1. Run the LMW RNAs obtained from 100 to 200 µg of total RNA on an 8 M urea/15% polyacrylamide gel until the dyes are well separated (200 V, ~60 min). 2. Stain the gel with 1× TBE/ethidium bromide for 5 min. 3. After visualization under UV light, cut out a plug of the gel corresponding to the band size of 20–30 nt, put it into a 2 ml tube, and crush the gel thoroughly. 4. Elute RNA with two volumes of 0.3 M NaCl overnight at room temperature. 5. Precipitate the RNA with 2.5 volumes of 100% ethanol and 1 ml of GlycoBlue™ at −80°C for at least 2 h. 6. Allow the RNA pellet to dry, and then dissolve the RNA in 10 ml of DEPC-treated water.
3.1.4. 5¢ Adaptor Ligation and Purification
Unlike most RNA turnover products, miRNAs and siRNAs that are generated by RNaseIII-like endonuclease have 5¢ phosphate and 3¢ hydroxyl termini. This feature is used in the subsequent adaptor ligation reaction that requires the presence of a 5¢ phosphate and a free 3¢ hydroxyl group on the small RNAs. 1. The 5¢ adaptor ligation reaction is carried out in a 10 ml reaction containing 5 ml small RNAs from the previous step, 2 ml 5¢ RNA adaptor (20 mM), 1 ml 10× RNA ligase buffer, and 2 ml T4 RNA ligase (5 U/µl). Incubate the reaction at room temperature for 6 h to overnight. 2. Stop the reaction with 10 ml 2× loading dye. 3. Separate the entire reaction on a 8 M urea/10% polyacrylamide gel at 180 V for about 1 h. 4. Stain the gel with 1× TBE/ethidium bromide for 5 min. 5. Cut out a plug of the gel corresponding to the band size of 50–60 bp. 6. Elute and precipitate ligated RNAs as described in Subheading 3.1.3.
High-Throughput Approaches for miRNA Expression Analysis
113
3.1.5. 3¢ Adaptor Ligation and Purification
The procedures are essentially identical to the steps detailed in Subheading 3.1.4, except that a 3¢ adaptor (2 ml of 20 mM stock) is used in the ligation reaction, and the gel piece corresponding to the band size of 70–80 bp is recovered for RNA elution and precipitation.
3.1.6. RT-PCR
1. Combine 10 ml of purified ligation product, 2 ml of 100 mM RT-primer and 2.5 ml nuclease-free water. Heat at 65°C for 10 min and spin down to cool (put on ice). 2. Add 6 ml of 5× first strand buffer, 2 ml of 10 mM dNTP mix, 3 ml of 100 mM DTT, 1.5 ml RNaseOut, and 3 ml Superscript II RT (200 U/µl). Incubate at 45°C for 1 h, followed by a final incubation at 90°C for 5 min to inactivate the enzyme. 3. PCR is carried out in two 50 ml reaction tubes by combining the following components: 5 ml 10× PCR buffer, 1.5 ml 50 mM MgCl2, 1 ml 10 mM dNTPs, 0.5 ml 100 mM forward PCR primer, 0.5 ml 100 mM reverse PCR primer, 1 ml Taq polymerase (5 U/µl), and 2 ml of RT reaction mixture. The thermal cycler program is as follows: 94°C for 1 min, and 15–20 cycles of 94°C for 45 s, 55°C for 45 s, and 72°C for 45 s. This is followed by a 3 min incubation at 72°C (see Note