$/(6$1'58'8 8
520Æ1,$Ì1,6725,$6(&2/8/8,;;
(GLWXUD)XQGD LHL5RPkQLDG...
34 downloads
706 Views
1MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
$/(6$1'58'8 8
520Æ1,$Ì1,6725,$6(&2/8/8,;;
(GLWXUD)XQGD LHL5RPkQLDGH0kLQH (GLWXU DFUHGLWDW GH0LQLVWHUXO(GXFD LHLúL&HUFHW ULL SULQ&RQVLOLXO1D LRQDODO&HUFHW ULLùWLLQ LILFH GLQÌQY PkQWXO6XSHULRU
'HVFULHUHD&,3D%LEOLRWHFLL1D LRQDOHD5RPkQLHL '8 8$/(6$1'58 5RPkQLDvQLVWRULDVHFROXOXL;;$OHVDQGUX'X X ±%XFXUHúWL (GLWXUD)XQGD LHL5RPkQLHLGH0kLQH ,6%1 ´ ´ 5HSURGXFHUHDLQWHJUDO VDXIUDJPHQWDU SULQRULFHIRUP úLSULQRULFH PLMORDFHWHKQLFHHVWHVWULFWLQWHU]LV úLVHSHGHSVHúWHFRQIRUPOHJLL 5 VSXQGHUHDSHQWUXFRQ LQXWXOúLRULJLQDOLWDWHDWH[WXOXL UHYLQHH[FOXVLYDXWRUXOXLDXWRULORU 5HGDFWRU &ODXGLD)ORUHQWLQD'2%5( 7HKQRUHGDFWRU /DXUHQ LX&R]PD78'26( &RSHUWD &RUQHOLD352'$1 %XQGHWLSDU &ROLWLSDU )RUPDW [ (GLWXUD)XQGD LHL5RPkQLDGH0kLQH %XOHYDUGXO7LPLúRDUDQUVHFWRU 7HO)D[ ZZZ6SLUX+DUHWUR HPDLO FRQWDFW#HGLWXUDURPDQLDGHPDLQHUR
81,9(56,7$7($63,58+$5(7
$/(6$1'58'8 8
(',785$)81'$ ,(,520Æ1,$'(0Æ,1( %XFXUHúWL
&835,16
,QWURGXFHUH««««««««««««««««««««««
,6LWXD LDJHRSROLWLF D5RPkQLHLODvQFHSXWXOVHFROXOXL;;« &RQVLGHUD LLJHQHUDOH««««««««««««««««« 5RPkQLDúLFUL]DERVQLDF «««««««««««« 3R]L LD5RPkQLHLID GHU ]ERDLHOHEDOFDQLFH «« 5RPkQLDúL3ULPXO5 ]ERL0RQGLDO «««««« ) XULUHDVWDWXOXLQD LRQDOXQLWDUURPkQ ««««««« $S UDUHDúLFRQILUPDUHDLQWHUQD LRQDO D0DULL8QLUL ,,5RPkQLDvQFRQWH[WXOJHRSROLWLFLQWHUEHOLF«««««««« 5RPkQLDúL0LFDÌQ HOHJHUH«««««««««««««« 5HOD LLOHFX3RORQLD««««««««««««««««« 5HOD LLOHFX)UDQ D«««««««««««««««««« 5HOD LLOHFX,WDOLD«««««««««««««««««« 5HOD LLOHFX8QLXQHD6RYLHWLF ««««««««««««« 5RPkQLDúLVHFXULWDWHDHXURSHDQ «««««««««««« 5RPkQLDúLÌQ HOHJHUHD%DOFDQLF «««««««««««« 3R]L LDID GHHYHQLPHQWHúLFUL]HGLSORPDWLFHúLPLOLWDUHGLQ GHFHQLXO««««««««««««««««««««« 5HFUXGHVFHQ DUHYL]LRQLVPXOXLXQJDUEXOJDUúLVRYLHWLF««« 6FKLPEDUHDSROLWLFLLH[WHUQH«««««««««««««« ,,,5DSWXULOHWHULWRULDOHODFDUHDIRVWVXSXV 5RPkQLDvQ 2FXSDUHD %DVDUDELHL úL D QRUGXOXL %XFRYLQHL GH F WUH 8QLXQHD 6RYLHWLF «««««««««««««««««««««« 2FXSDUHDS U LLGHQRUGYHVWD5RPkQLHLGHF WUH8QJDULD«« 2FXSDUHDS U LLGHVXGD'REURJHLGHF WUH%XOJDULD«««« &RQVHFLQ HOHUDSWXULORUWHULWRULDOH«««««««««««« ,9ÌQYkOWRDUHDFHOXLGHDO'RLOHD5 ]ERL0RQGLDO««««« 3UHOLPLQDULL««««««««««««««««««««« 3DUWLFLSDUHDOD&DPSDQLDGLQ(VW ««««««« 3UHOLPLQDULLGHDUPLVWL LX«««««««««««««««
7UHFHUHD 5RPkQLHL GH SDUWHD 1D LXQLORU 8QLWH úL SDUWLFLSDUHD OD &DPSDQLDGLQ9HVW «««««««««« 1RXOVWDWXWMXULGLFLQWHUQD LRQDODO5RPkQLHL«««««««« 6XESRYDUDDUPLVWL LXOXL«««««««««««««««« 6SHUDQ HvPSOLQLULúLGH]LOX]LLURPkQHúWLvQWLPSXOU ]ERLXOXL«
95RPkQLDvQSULPLLDQLDL5 ]ERLXOXL5HFH «« ÌQWUHDUPLVWL LXúLSDFH«««««««««««««««« 3UREOHPHURPkQHúWLOD&RQIHULQ DGHSDFHGLQ úLSULQFLSDOHOH SUHYHGHULDOH7UDWDWXOXLGHSDFH««««««««««««« 9,5RPkQLDvQFRQWH[WXOJHRSROLWLFHXURSHDQ ««« 6XEWXWHOD0RVFRYHL «««««««««««« 5RPkQLDúL7UDWDWXOGHOD9DUúRYLD««««««««««« 5HWUDJHUHDWUXSHORUVRYLHWLFHúLDFRQVLOLHULORUPLOLWDUL«««« 'HODUHYLULPHQWXOSROLWLFLLH[WHUQHODL]RODUHDLQWHUQD LRQDO « 9,,5RPkQLDvQFRQWH[WXOLQWHUQD LRQDOSRVWUHYROX LRQDU $GHUDUHDOD1$72«««««««««««««««« $GHUDUHDOD8QLXQHD(XURSHDQ ««««««««««««« 9,,,&DUDFWHULVWLFLDOHYLH LLSROLWLFH««««««««««« )RUPHGHJXYHUQ PkQW([HUFLWDUHDSXWHULORUvQVWDW5HJLPXULúL SDUWLGHSROLWLFHGHPRFUDWLFH«««««««««««««« 5HJLPXOGHDXWRULWDWHPRQDUKLF DOUHJHOXL&DURODO,,OHD«« 5HJLPXOGLFWDWRULDOLQVWDXUDWGH,RQ$QWRQHVFX««««««« 5HJLPXOSROLWLFWRWDOLWDUGLQSHULRDGDDXJXVW GHFHPEULH ««««««««««««««««««««««« 5HJLPXOVRFLDOLVWWRWDOLWDUFRPXQLVW «««««« 5HYROX LD5RPkQ GLQ'HFHPEULH úLFRQVHFLQ HOHVDOH««« ,;&DUDFWHULVWLFLDOHHFRQRPLHLúLVWUXFWXULLVRFLDOH««««« (FRQRPLD««««««««««««««««««««« 6WUXFWXUDVRFLDO ««««««««««««««««««« ;5HDOL] ULDOHúWLLQ HLFXOWXULLúLVSRUWXOXL«««««««« ùWLLQ DúLFXOWXUD««««««««««««««««««« 6SRUWXO««««««««««««««««««««««
%LEOLRJUDILH««««««««««««««««««««««
,1752'8&(5(
ÌQ vQYROEXUDWXO VHFRO ;; 5RPkQLD D SDUFXUV PDL PXOWH HWDSH LVWRULFH ILHFDUHFXRELHFWLYHOHHLVSHFLILFHFXUHDOL] ULOHúLQHvPSOLQLULOHHL 'H OD VWDGLXO GH VWDW QD LRQDO PRGHUQ úL LQGHSHQGHQW PLF OD QLYHO HXURSHDQGDUFHOPDLPDUHúLPDLERJDWGLQVXGHVWXO(XURSHL FXWRDWHF R SDUWHDWHULWRULXOXLV XORFXLWGHFLUFDRWUHLPHGLQQD LXQHDURPkQ VHDIOD VXEGLYHUVHVW SkQLULVWU LQH VLWXDWvQWUHGRX PDULSXWHULHXURSHQHULYDOH± $XVWUR8QJDULD úL 5XVLD DPEHOH DYkQG vQ FRPSXQHUH WHULWRULL URPkQHúWL úL LQWHUHVH SULYLQG LQVWLWXLUHD VDX FRQVROLGDUHD GRPLQD LHL vQ ]RQ 5RPkQLD D DMXQV vQ LVWRULFXO DQ vQ XUPD GHV YkUúLULL XQLW LL QD LRQDO VWDWDOH FRQILUPDW SH SODQ LQWHUQD LRQDO SULQ WUDWDWHOH GH SDFH vQFKHLDWH vQ FDGUXO &RQIHULQ HL GH OD 3DULV GLQ XQ VWDW QD LRQDO XQLWDU GH P ULPH PLMORFLH ODQLYHOHXURSHDQ 'DF SkQ vQ RELHFWLYXO SULRULWDU DO QD LXQLL URPkQH IXVHVH GHV YkUúLUHD XQLW LL QD LRQDO VWDWDOH GXS UHDOL]DUHD 0DULL 8QLUL JXYHUQHOH URPkQH DX SURPRYDW vQ SODQ H[WHUQ R SROLWLF GH DS UDUH D LQGHSHQGHQ HL VXYHUDQLW LL QD LRQDOH úL LQWHJULW LL WHULWRULDOH GH FUHDUH D XQXL FOLPDW GH HJDOLWDWH vQWUH VWDWH LQGHSHQGHQWH úL VXYHUDQH LQGLIHUHQW GH P ULPHD WHULWRULDO úLDXQXLVLVWHPGHVHFXULWDWHvQVWDUHV DVLJXUHSDFHDvQ]RQ úLvQ (XURSDvQFRQIRUPLWDWHFXSULQFLSLLOHvQVFULVHvQ3DFWXO6RFLHW LL1D LXQLORU &D XUPDUH vQWUHJXO VLVWHP GH DOLDQ H SROLWLFRPLOLWDU URPkQHVF D DYXW XQ FDUDFWHUGHIHQVLYFRQFUHWL]DWSULQWUDWDWHúLvQ HOHJHULELODWHUDOH FX3RORQLD± PDUWLH )UDQ D ± LXQLH ,WDOLD ± VHSWHPEULH úL PXOWLODWHUDOH vQ FDGUXO 0LFLL ÌQ HOHJHUL ± DOLDQ FX &HKRVORYDFLDDSULOLH úL ,XJRVODYLDLXQLH ± úL ÌQ HOHJHULL %DOFDQLFH ± DOLDQ FX *UHFLD ,XJRVODYLD úL 7XUFLDIHEUXDULH VDX vQ FDGUXO 6RFLHW LL 1D LXQLORU /D DFHVWHD VD DG XJDW VWDELOLUHD GH UHOD LL GLSORPDWLFH FX 8QLXQHD 6RYLHWLF
7UDQVLOYDQLD %DQDWXO &ULúDQD úL 0DUDPXUHúXO vQFRUSRUDWH 8QJDULHL vQ FDGUXO,PSHULXOXLDXVWURXQJDU %XFRYLQDvQFDGUXODFHOXLDúL,PSHULXGHSLQ]kQG GLUHFWGHJXYHUQXOGHOD9LHQD %DVDUDELDJXEHUQLHvQFDGUXO,PSHULXOXL DULVW 6HPQDW úL GH UHSUH]HQWDQ LL 5RPkQLHL vQF GH OD HODERUDUH LXQLH
LXQLH úL vQFHUFDUHD GH D VHPQDFXDFHDVW DU XQSDFWGHDVLVWHQ PXWXDO SDUWLFLSDUHDODHODERUDUHDXQXLQRXWUDWDWDO6WUkPWRULORU0 ULL1HJUH OD&RQIHULQ DGHOD0RQWUHDX[ LXQLHLXOLH ODvQFKHLHUHDDFRUGXOXLGHOD 6DORQLF GLQWUH VWDWHOH ÌQ HOHJHULL %DOFDQLFH úL %XOJDULD LXOLH SUHFXPúLDDFRUGXOXLURPkQRLXJRVODYRXQJDUGHOD%OHG DXJXVW ± WRDWHILLQGGHVWLQDWHV DVLJXUHVHFXULWDWHDQD LRQDO úLVWDWXWXOV XWHULWRULDO &X WRDWH DFHVWHD vQ YDUD DQXOXL OD VFXUW WLPS GXS vQIUkQJHUHD )UDQ HL5RPkQLDVDDIODWvQWURVLWXD LHH[WUHPGHGLILFLO SLHU]kQGvQWUXQ WLPSH[WUHPGHVFXUWVXESUHVLXQHúLúDQWDMFLUFDNPSúL GH ORFXLWRUL FDUH DX LQWUDW SULQ SUHVLXQH úL GLFWDW vQ FRPSRQHQ D 8QLXQLL 6RYLHWLFH8QJDULHLúL%XOJDULHL ÌQWUXQDVHPHQHDFRQWH[W5RPkQLDDDGHUDWODQRLHPEULH SULQ GHFL]LDJHQHUDOXOXL,RQ$QWRQHVFXGHYHQLWODVHSWHPEULH &RQGXF WRU DO 6WDWXOXL OD 3DFWXO 7ULSDUWLW úL D IRVW DQJDMDW DSRL OD LXQLH WRW SULQGHFL]LDOXL,RQ$QWRQHVFXvQFHOGHDO'RLOHD5 ]ERL0RQGLDODO WXULGH *HUPDQLD vPSRWULYD 8QLXQLL 6RYLHWLFH PRELOXO SULQFLSDO DO DF LXQLL URPkQHúWLILLQGHOLEHUDUHD%DVDUDELHLúLDQRUGXOXL%XFRYLQHL 'XS vPSOLQLUHD DFHVWXL RELHFWLY OD LXOLH DUPDWD URPkQ D FRQWLQXDW SDUWLFLSDUHD OD U ]ERL vQ DGkQFLPHD WHULWRULXOXL VRYLHWLF SkQ OD 6WDOLQJUDGúLvQ&DXFD]DSRLvQUHWUDJHUHSkQ vQSULP YDUDDQXOXL FkQG IURQWXO D DMXQV GLQ QRX SH WHULWRULXO QD LRQDO vQ HVWXO ULL &RQWLQXDUHD SDUWLFLS ULL OD U ]ERL úL GXS UHVWDELOLUHD VXYHUDQLW LL QD LRQDOH DVXSUD %DVDUDELHL úL QRUGXOXL %XFRYLQHL D SXV vQ GHFHPEULH DUD vQ VWDUH GH U ]ERLúLFX0DUHD%ULWDQLH6WDWHOH8QLWHDOH$PHULFLLSUHFXPúLFXDOWHVWDWH FDUH FRQVWLWXLVHU FRDOL LD DQWLKLWOHULVW úL FDUH LDX FHUXW DSRL FX LQVLVWHQ FDSLWXODUHDQHFRQGL LRQDW ÌQ XUPD HúX ULL SUHOLPLQDULLORU GH DUPLVWL LX úL D UXSHULL GLVSR]LWLYXOXL GH OXSW GLQ HVWXO ULL vQ XUPD RSHUD LHL Ä,DúL&KLúLQ X´ UHJHOH 0LKDL , vQ DFRUGFXOLGHULLSDUWLGHORUFDUHFRQVWLWXLVHU %ORFXO1D LRQDO'HPRFUDWúLFX RSDUWHDFRUSXOXLGHFRPDQG DODUPDWHLDGHFLVODDXJXVW DUHVWDUHD PDUHúDOXOXL ,RQ $QWRQHVFX FRQVWLWXLUHD XQXL QRX JXYHUQ úL WUHFHUHD 5RPkQLHLGHSDUWHD1D LXQLORU8QLWH,PHGLDWI U QLFLRGHIHF LXQH5RPkQLD D SXV OD GLVSR]L LD DOLD LORU D VRYLHWLFLORU vQ VSHFLDO XQ vQVHPQDW SRWHQ LDO PLOLWDUúLOHDDGXVPDULDYDQWDMHVWUDWHJLFHSROLWLFHúLORJLVWLFH&RQFRPLWHQW VD UHXúLW vQ SULQFLSDO SULQ IRU H SURSULL V VH HOLPLQH SUH]HQ D PLOLWDU JHUPDQ GHSHWHULWRULXODIODWVXEMXULVGLF LDJXYHUQXOXLURPkQúLGXS DFHHD vQFRRSHUDUHFXWUXSHOHVRYLHWLFHV VHHOLEHUH]HSkQ ODRFWRPEULH SDUWHDGHQRUGYHVWD ULLRFXSDW vQ GH8QJDULD$SRLDFRQWLQXDWV úL vQGHSOLQHDVF REOLJD LLOHGLQ&RQYHQ LDGHDUPLVWL LXGLQVHSWHPEULH
3DUWLGXO1D LRQDO U QHVF3DUWLGXO1D LRQDO/LEHUDO3DUWLGXO6RFLDO 'HPRFUDWúL3DUWLGXO&RPXQLVW5RPkQ
SDUWLFLSkQGODU ]ERLSHWHULWRULLOH8QJDULHL&HKRVORYDFLHLúL$XVWULHLvQWUXQ VSD LXHXURSHDQGHDQYHUJXU SHGLUHF LD%XFXUHúWL%XGDSHVWD9LHQD3UDJD SkQ ODVIkUúLWXOU ]ERLXOXL &XWRDWHDFHVWHDOD&RQIHULQ DGHSDFHGHOD3DULVGLQ 5RPkQLDD IRVWWUDWDW FD DU vQYLQV vQU ]ERLQHDFRUGkQGXLVHVWDWXWXOELQHPHULWDWGH DU FREHOLJHUDQW &RUHODWFXSODVDUHD ULLvQVIHUDGHGRPLQD LHVRYLHWLF vQ XUPD DFRUGXOXL GH SURFHQWDM VWDELOLW vQ RFWRPEULH vQWUH :LQVWRQ &KXUFKLOOúL,96WDOLQ DFHVWIDSWúLDSXVSXWHUQLFDPSUHQWDDVXSUDVLWXD LHL XOWHULRDUHD5RPkQLHLLQIOXHQ kQGXLQHJDWLYHYROX LD 'XS SUHOXDUHD vQWUHJLL SXWHUL SROLWLFH GH F WUH FRPXQLúWL vQ 5RPkQLDDLQWUDWWRWDOVXEWXWHOD0RVFRYHLGLQFDUHVDGHVSULQVSDU LDOPDL DOHVvQGRPHQLXOSROLWLFLLH[WHUQHvQFHSkQGFXDQXO ÌQDFHVWFRQWH[WVD GHFODQúDW XQ SURFHV GH UHFRQFLOLHUH FX VWDWHOH RFFLGHQWDOH LQWHUHVDWH vQ VXEPLQDUHDXQLW LL7UDWDWXOXLGHOD9DUúRYLDFXSUHF GHUHvQFDGUXOF UXLD 5RPkQLDGHYHQLVHXQDOLDWLQFRPRGSHQWUXVRYLHWLFL FDUHDXRIHULWIDFLOLW L vQ GRPHQLXO HFRQRPLF WHKQRORJLF ILQDQFLDU úL vQ FHO DO LPDJLQLL FKLDU úL SHQWUX FRQGXF WRULL FRPXQLúWL DL ULL &RQFRPLWHQW SROLWLFD H[WHUQ URPkQHDVF VDLQGLYLGXDOL]DWvQFDGUXO2UJDQL]D LHL1D LXQLORU8QLWH /DvQFHSXWXODQLORU¶SHP VXUDDFFHQWX ULLFUL]HLLQWHUQHvQFRQGL LLOH QHUHVSHFW ULLSUHYHGHULORU$FWXOXLILQDOGHOD+HOVLQNL SULYLQGGUHSWXULOH RPXOXL úL DOH VFKLPE ULL UDSRUWXOXL GH IRU H vQ SODQ LQWHUQD LRQDO VLWXD LD H[WHUQ D5RPkQLHLDvQFHSXWV GHYLQ SUHFDU 1LFRODH&HDXúHVFXLQWUkQGvQ FRQIOLFW FX FRQGXFHULOH 68$ úL 8566 FHOH PDL PDUL SXWHUL DOH OXPLL 5RPkQLDDIRVWSXV DVWIHOvQWURVWDUHGHL]RODUHLQWHUQD LRQDO GLQFHvQFHPDL DFFHQWXDW GLQFDUHDLHúLWDELDvQXUPD5HYROX LHLGLQGHFHPEULH 'LQDFHOPRPHQWvQSRILGDLPSDFWXOXLQHJDWLYSHFDUHODXDYXWXQHOH HYHQLPHQWH SROLWLFH LQWHUQH 5RPkQLD úLD DVXPDW YDORULOH GHPRFUDWLFH RFFLGHQWDOHúLVDUDFRUGDWUDSLGSURFHVXOXLGHPRGHUQL]DUHvQWUHUXSWvQPRG EUXWDO GH F WUH VRYLHWLFL vQ GHYHQLQG PHPEU FX GUHSWXUL GHSOLQH D $OLDQ HL 1RUG$WODQWLFH PDUWLH úL PHPEU D 8QLXQLL (XURSHQH LDQXDULH
,6,78$ ,$*(232/,7,& $520Æ1,(, /$Ì1&(3878/6(&2/8/8,;; &RQVLGHUD LLJHQHUDOH
/DvQFHSXWXOVHFROXOXL;;5RPkQLDI FHDSDUWHGLQ7ULSOD$OLDQ XQD GLQ FHOH GRX PDUL EORFXUL SROLWLFRPLOLWDUH DOH YUHPLL 6HPQkQG WUDWDWXO VHFUHW FX $XVWUR8QJDULD OD RFWRPEULH JXYHUQXO URPkQ QX D DEDQGRQDW vQV OXSWD SHQWUX vPSOLQLUHD LGHDOXOXL XQLW LL QD LRQDOHúLVWDWDOHIDSWVHVL]DWvQPDUWLHGHPLQLVWUXODXVWURXQJDUOD %XFXUHúWL FDUH D DSUHFLDW F GHFL]LD JXYHUQXOXL URPkQ GH DGHUDUH OD DOLDQ DFX$XVWUR8QJDULDDYHDÄXQFDUDFWHUGHRSRUWXQLWDWHSROLWLF ´úLF WUDWDWXOÄYDILPHQ LQXWGRDUSkQ FkQGRFRQMXQFWXU IDYRUDELO YDSHU PLWH URPkQLORU V VH ULGLFH vPSRWULYD PRQDUKLHL DXVWURKDEVEXUJLFH´ (YHQLPHQWHOH XOWHULRDUH GLQ úL PDL DOHV GLQ DYHDX V L FRQILUPHSUHYL]LXQHD 6FKLPE ULOHLQWHUYHQLWHvQUDSRUWXOGHIRU HvQSODQHXURSHDQSROL WLFDFRQWUDGLFWRULHDPDULORUSXWHULID GH%DOFDQLúLPDLDOHVQHvQ HOHJH ULOHGLQWUHHOHDXI FXWFDJXYHUQXOURPkQV LQ VHDPDGHQRLOHUHDOLW L SROLWLFH GLSORPDWLFH úL HXURSHQH úL V FRQWLQXH D DF LRQD SHQWUX PHQ L QHUHDVWDWXTXRXOXLWHULWRULDOvQVSD LXOEDOFDQLF2DWHQ LHGHRVHELW VD DFRUGDW SROLWLFLL %XOJDULHL FDUH OD IHO FD 6HUELD úL *UHFLD XUP UHD V úL VSRUHDVF VXSUDID D ULL SULQ DQH[DUHD WHULWRULLORU GLQ ,PSHULXO 2WRPDQ ORFXLWHGHFRQD LRQDOLúLQXQXPDL ÌQWURDVHPHQHDVLWXD LHSHQWUXDFRQWUDEDODQVDRvQW ULUHSUHDPDUH D%XOJDULHL5RPkQLDDOXDWvQFDOFXOFKLDURLQWHUYHQ LHPLOLWDU ODVXGGH 'XQ UH úL D VROLFLWDW FRPSHQVD LL WHULWRULDOH vQ VSHFLDO vQ &DGULODWHU ÌQ FD] GH DWDF UXVHVF D FHUXW VSULMLQ GLQ SDUWHD $XVWUR8QJDULHL SHQWUX DFHDVWDVROLFLWkQGXVHI U VXFFHVvQ FXSULOHMXOUHvQQRLULLWUDWDWXOXL
3HODUJ *KHRUJKH1LFRODH& ]DQùHUEDQ5 GXOHVFX=RQHU5RPkQLD úL7ULSOD$OLDQ %XFXUHúWL 3DUWHDGHVXGD'REURJHLLVWRULFH
GH DOLDQ LQWURGXFHUHD XQHL FODX]H QRL FDUH V H[WLQG FRQGL LLOH GH DSOLFDUH D VLWXD LHL GH ÄFDVXV IRHGHULV´ úL vQ HYHQWXDOLWDWHD XQXL FRQIOLFW DUPDWFX%XOJDULD $FXWL]DUHD FRQIOLFWHORU GLQ %DOFDQL GLQWUH 0DFHGRQLD úL %XOJDULD U VFRDOD GLQ 0DFHGRQLD GLQ UHSUHVLXQHD WXUFHDVF úL FRQFHQWUDUHD WUXSHORU EXOJDUH OD IURQWLHUD FX ,PSHULXO 2WRPDQ HWF DX GHWHUPLQDW GLQ QRX GLSORPD LD GH OD %XFXUHúWL V GHFODUH F 5RPkQLD QX YD U PkQH LQGLIHUHQW vQ FD] GH PRGLILFDUH D VWDWXTXRXOXL WHULWRULDO vQ %DOFDQL 6LWXD LDDYHDV VHFRPSOLFHSULQIDSWXOF $XVWUR8QJDULDDOLDWD5RPkQLHL QXúLDGHFODUDW FHOSX LQ QHXWUDOLWDWHDFLDI FXWFXQRVFXWIDSWXOF vQFD] GHLQWHUYHQ LHURPkQHDVF ODVXGGH'XQ UHYDVSULMLQL%XOJDULD &X WRDWH DFHVWHD JXYHUQXO URPkQ D DGRSWDW R DWLWXGLQH QHSURYRFDWRDUH UHIX]kQG V vQFKHLH R DOLDQ DQWLEXOJDU VROLFLWDW GH ,PSHULXO2WRPDQ$FHDVW SROLWLF VDGRYHGLWDILvQ HOHDSW GHRDUHFHvQ DFHO PRPHQW 3RDUWD VH FRQIUXQWD FX PDUL SUREOHPH LQWHUQH úL H[WHUQH GHWHUPLQDWH GH VWUXFWXULOH SROLWLFRDGPLQLVWUDWLYH vQYHFKLWH GH OXSWD GH HPDQFLSDUHDQD LRQDOLW LORUFRQORFXLWRDUHGHLQWHUHVHOHH[WUHPGHDFXWH úL GLYHUJHQWH DOH VWDWHORU GLQ ]RQ úL DOH PDULORU SXWHUL FDUH SXWHDX RULFkQG V PRGLILFH HFKLOLEUXO WHULWRULDO EDOFDQLF HWF 2UL WRFPDL DFHVW OXFUX QX HUD GRULW GH F WUH JXYHUQXO URPkQ FDUH D SULYLW FX VLPSDWLH UHYROX LD ÄMXQLORU WXUFL´ GHFODQúDW OD LXOLH FDUH úLD SURSXV PRGHUQL]DUHD,PSHULXOXL2WRPDQ &RQFRPLWHQW JXYHUQXO URPkQ D XUP ULW vPEXQ W LUHD VLWXD LHL PDWHULDOH úL FXOWXUDOH D DURPkQLORU GLQ 0DFHGRQLD ÌQ DFHVW VFRS FX VSULMLQXO *HUPDQLHL ± FDUH GRUHD VROX LRQDUHD IDYRUDELO D WUDWDWLYHORU SHQWUX FRQFHVLRQDUHD WHUHQXULORU SHWUROLIHUH GLQ 5RPkQLD F WUH JUXSXO
%XOJDULD 6HUELD 0XQWHQHJUX úL *UHFLD XUP UHDX DOLSLUHD WHULWRULLORU GLQ,PSHULXO2WRPDQvQFDUHORFXLDXFRQD LRQDOL * +DQRWDX[ XQ FRQWHPSRUDQ DO HYHQLPHQWHORU DSUHFLD Ä $ DWLQJH 7XUFLDvQVHPQDDDWLQJH*HUPDQLD%XOJDULD6HUELD5RPkQLD3HUVLD(JLSWXO $IULFDPXVXOPDQ FLQHSRDWHúWL"ùLLPHGLDW$XVWULD,WDOLD*HUPDQLD5XVLD $QJOLDVHSXQvQJDUG EDODQ DHFKLOLEUXOXLHVWHDPHQLQ DW ´ Ä1LFL XQ RP SROLWLF ± UHOHYD vQ 7DNH ,RQHVFX ± QX DVSLU V DQH[H]H 0DFHGRQLD QLFL V IRUPH]H DFROR XQ VWDW URPkQHVF LQHP vQV FD QD LRQDOLWDWHDURPkQLORUGLQ0DFHGRQLDV ILHSURWHMDW úLHLV DLE JDUDQ LDF YRUSXWHDV VHFXOWLYHvQOLPEDORUFXWRDW OLEHUWDWHD´
ILQDQFLDU 'HXWVFKH %DQN ± VD UHXúLW vQ V VH LPSXQ VXOWDQXOXL SURPXOJDUHDXQHLLUDGHOH GHFUHW LPSHULDOHSULQFDUHDURPkQLLSULPHDX FHOSX LQWHRUHWLFGUHSWXULHJDOHFXFHOHDOHFHORUODOWHQD LRQDOLW LFUHúWLQH GLQLPSHULX 1HvQ HOHJHULOHFX*UHFLDDXGHWHUPLQDW5RPkQLDV GHQXQ H RFWRPEULH &RQYHQ LDURPkQRHOHQ GLQ úLSURWRFROXODQH[ úL V UXS UHOD LLOHGLSORPDWLFHFXJXYHUQXOGHOD$WHQD SkQ vQ )D GHFRQIOLFWXOUXVRMDSRQH]GLQ 5RPkQLDDDGRSW OD LQVLVWHQ HOH *HUPDQLHL FDUH XUP UHD R DSURSLHUH GH 5XVLD SHQWUX D DQLKLODSROLWLFDHQJOH] RDWLWXGLQHIDYRUDELO 3HWHUVEXUJXOXL$SRLvQ VSHUDQ DF WHQGLQ HOHH[SDQVLRQLVWHDOH$XVWUR8QJDULHLúL5XVLHLVHYRU DQLKLODVDXGLPLQXDUHFLSURFDXUP ULWUHDOL]DUHDXQXLHFKLOLEUXvQFHHDFH SULYHúWHSROLWLFD9LHQHLúLD3HWHUVEXUJXOXLvQ%DOFDQL 5RPkQLDúLFUL]DERVQLDF ÌQ VLWXD LD GLQ %DOFDQL D H[SORGDW GLQ QRX SULQ GHFODQúDUHD FUL]HLERVQLDFHvQXUPDDQH[ ULL RFWRPEULH GHF WUH$XVWUR8QJDULDD %RVQLHL úL +HU HJRYLQHL SURYLQFLL DIODWH VXE VX]HUDQLWDWHD QRPLQDO D VXOWDQXOXLGDUFDUHSULQDUWDOWUDWDWXOXLGHOD%HUOLQGLQIXVHVHU SXVHVXEDGPLQLVWUD LDJXYHUQXOXLGHOD9LHQD 'DF 6HUELDFHDPDLDIHFWDW GHDQH[LXQHD%RVQLHLúL+HU HJRYLQHL VDGRYHGLWDILúLFHDPDLDPHQLQ DW úLPDLÄDJLWDW ´FRQVLGHUkQGDFWXO FD SH ÄR FDWDVWURI QD LRQDO ´ FX FRQVHFLQ H IDWDOH SHQWUX SDFHD vQ %DOFDQL JXYHUQXO URPkQ FRQYLQV F 5XVLD QX YD LQWHUYHQL vQ VSULMLQXO
1HPXO XPL LGHIDSWXOF WUDWDWLYHOHQXVDXvQFKHLDWIDYRUDELOJHUPDQLL QXDXPDLVSULMLQLW5RPkQLDvQFRQIOLFWXOFX*UHFLDVROGDWFXUXSHUHDUHOD LLORU GLSORPDWLFH ÌQUHSOLF ODDQH[LXQHDDXVWURXQJDU 6HUELDDVROLFLWDWODVIDWXO5XVLHL FRPSHQVD LL WHULWRULDOH R SRU LXQH GH WHUHQ vQ OXQJXO IURQWLHUHL GH QRUG D VDQJHDFXOXL1RYL3D]DU SHQWUXDVHUHDOL]DRJUDQL FRPXQ FX0XQWHQHJUXD VHSDUD VDQJHDFXO GH $XVWUR8QJDULD úL D F S WD LHúLUH OD 0DUHD $GULDWLF ÌQ VLWXD LD vQ FDUH JXYHUQXO GH OD 9LHQD QX DU IL IRVW GH DFRUG úL QX D IRVW FX DFHVWH SURSXQHUL %HOJUDGXO D FHUXW FD FHOH GRX SURYLQFLL V ILH SURFODPDWH DXWRQRPH 3HQWUX D IDFH ID XQHL HYHQWXDOH DJUHVLXQL úL DVXSUD SURSULXOXL WHULWRULX vQ RFWRPEULH 6HUELD úL 0XQWHQHJUX DX vQFKHLDW XQ WUDWDW GH DOLDQ ELODWHUDO
6HUELHLDSULYLWHYHQLPHQWHOHFXPXOWFDOPúLFXOXFLGLWDWHvQGHPQkQG JXYHUQXOGHOD%HOJUDGODPRGHUD LH&RQVLGHUkQGH[LVWHQ D6HUELHLFDXQ IDFWRULPSRUWDQWvQPHQ LQHUHDHFKLOLEUXOXLEDOFDQLF5RPkQLDDFRQWLQXDW V PHQ LQ FX DUDYHFLQ UHOD LLHFRQRPLFHúLFRPHUFLDOHSHFDUHFKLDUOH DLQWHQVLILFDW%XFXUHúWLLDXLQIRUPDWvQV 3HWHUVEXUJXOF QXYRUVSULMLQL 6HUELDvQFD]GHFRQIOLFWDUPDW/DUkQGXLRSLQLDSXEOLF URPkQHDVF D PDQLIHVWDWRVWLOLWDWHID GHSROLWLFDJXYHUQHORUGHOD9LHQDúL%XGDSHVWD úLVROLGDULWDWHID GHSRSRUXOVkUE )D GH SURFODPDUHD LQGHSHQGHQ HL %XOJDULHL RFWRPEULH ,,&%U WLDQXDVDOXWDWDFWXOvQ3DUODPHQWúLDSUHFL]DWvQF RGDW SR]L LD 5RPkQLD ID GH QRXD FUL] EDOFDQLF QHDQJDMDUHD vQ FRQIOLFW DUPDW VXV LQHUHDVWDWXTXRXOXLWHULWRULDOúLDS FLLvQ%DOFDQL 3ULQXUPDUHvQWLPSXOFUL]HLERVQLDFHSROLWLFDH[WHUQ D5RPkQLHL VD SODVDW SH DOWH FRRUGRQDWH GHFkW FHOH DOH DOLDWXOXL GH OD 9LHQD &RQWH[WXOLQWHUQD LRQDOH[WUHPGHFRPSOLFDWúLLQVWDELOvQFDUHLPSHULXO DXVWURXQJDUFRQWLQXDV ILHSXWHUQLFDI FXWFDJXYHUQXOURPkQV QXúL VFKLPEH UDGLFDO GLUHF LLOH SROLWLFLL GH DOLDQ FRQVROLGkQG vQV vQ FDGUXO DFHVWHLD UHOD LLOH FX *HUPDQLD FX WRDWH F WUDWDWXO GLQ GHYHQLVH DQDFURQLF $QDOL]kQGvQPRGUHDOLVWVFKLPE ULOHLQWHUYHQLWHvQUDSRUWXOGHIRU H vQSODQLQWHUQD LRQDOúLPDLDOHV]RQDOGLSORPD LDURPkQ DFRQWLQXDWV XUP UHDVF FX DWHQ LH SROLWLFD JXYHUQXOXL EXOJDU XQGH XQHOH FHUFXUL SROLWLFHúLPLOLWDUHUHYHQGLFDXGLQFHvQFHPDLGHVFKLV'REURJHD6LWXD LD VDDJUDYDWSULQJDUDQ LLOHSULPLWHGH%XOJDULDGLQSDUWHD$XVWUR8QJDULHL vQ HYHQWXDOLWDWHD XQXL DWDF GLQ SDUWHD 6HUELHL vQ WLPSXOXL SUHFRQL]DWXOXL U ]ERLFX,PSHULXO2WRPDQÌQJULMRU ULOHJXYHUQDQ LORUURPkQLFUHúWHDXúL ID GH R HYHQWXDO DGHUDUH VDX FKLDU DWUDJHUH D %XOJDULHL OD 7ULSOD $OLDQ IDSW XUP ULW FX LQVLVWHQ GH GLSORPD LL GH OD 9LHQD ÌQ DFHDVW VLWXD LHLQWHUHVXO3XWHULORU&HQWUDOHID GH5RPkQLDVHGLPLQXDVLP LWRU
/D QRLHPEULH ,,&%U WLDQXGHFODUDvQ3DUODPHQWF JXYHUQXO URPkQGRUHDvQ%DOFDQLÄHFKLOLEUXSHED]DVWDWXTXRXOXLWHULWRULDO´GH]YROWDUHD SDúQLF D VWDWHORU GLQ ]RQ ÄI U MLJQLUHD QLFL XQXL LQWHUHV úL QLFL XQXL GUHSW OHJLWLPDOQRVWUX´ 'XS YL]LWD vQWUHSULQV vQ 5RPkQLD vQ DSULOLH SHQWUX D vQPkQD UHJHOXL&DURO,EDVWRQXOGHIHOGPDUHúDODODUPDWHLJHUPDQHSULQ XOPRúWHQLWRU :LOKHOPDLQIRUPDWDXWRULW LOHGHOD%HUOLQF ÄvQFD]GHU ]ERL5RPkQLDYD UHIX]DvQFHOPDLEXQFD]V úLvQGHSOLQHDVF REOLJD LLOHGHDOLDWGDF QXVHYD GHFLGHFKLDUDVHDO WXUDS U LLDGYHUVH´
3HQWUX D IDFH ID VLWXD LHL vQWUHY ]kQG úL XQ FRQIOLFW EXOJDUR RWRPDQ ,,& %U WLDQX D ULGLFDW GLQ QRX I U VXFFHV vQV OD 9LHQD úL %HUOLQ SUREOHPD H[WLQGHULL VLWXD LHL GH ÄFDVXV IHRGHULV´ GLQ WUDWDWXO GLQ /D UkQGXL UHJHOH &DURO , D GHFODUDW vQ LXOLH PLQLVWUXOXL 5XVLHL OD %XFXUHúWL F YD DUXQFD ÄVDELD vQ EDODQ vQ PRPHQWXO vQ FDUH HFKLOLEUXOGLQ%DOFDQLDUILWXOEXUDWGHYUHXQDGLQWUHS U L´ 6FKLPE ULOHLQWHUYHQLWHvQUDSRUWXOGHIRU HVXGHVWHXURSHDQGXS DQH[DUHD%RVQLHLúL+HU HJRYLQHL GHF WUH$XVWUR8QJDULDSUHFXP úLSROLWLFDEDOFDQLF DJXYHUQXOXLGHOD9LHQDFDUHXUP UHDPRGLILFDUHD VWDWXTXRXOXLWHULWRULDOGLQ]RQ DXLPSULPDWXQQRXFRQ LQXWUDSRUWXULORU 5RPkQLHL FX 7ULSOD $OLDQ vQ VSHFLDO FX $XVWUR8QJDULD OD DFHDVWD FRQWULEXLQG úL DFFHQWXDUHD SROLWLFLL GH GH]QD LRQDOL]DUH D SRSXOD LHL URPkQHúWLGLQ7UDQVLOYDQLDGXV GHF WUHJXYHUQXOGHOD%XGDSHVWD 'DF LQL LDO 3XWHULOH &HQWUDOH UHSXUWDVHU XQ VXFFHV GLSORPDWLF vQ FUL]DERVQLDF VLWXD LDDYHDV VHVFKLPEHODVFXUWWLPSGHRDUHFH5XVLD úLDUHI FXWUDSLGLQIOXHQ DvQ]RQ GXS FHDSUHOXDWvQLDQXDULH GDWRULLOH GH U ]ERL DOH %XOJDULHL ID GH ,PSHULXO 2WRPDQ GHWHUPLQkQG 6RILDV UHYLQ ODUHOD LLPDLFRUGLDOHúLFX3HWHUVEXUJXO /D DFHDVWD VD DG XJDW SROLWLFD ,WDOLHL QHPXO XPLW GH FUHúWHUHD LQIOXHQ HL $XVWUR8QJDULHL vQ VSD LXO EDOFDQLF JXYHUQXO GH OD 5RPD vQFKHLQG FX FHO GH OD 3HWHUVEXUJ DFRUGXO GH OD 5DFFRQLJL GLQ LDQXDULH SULQFDUHFHOHGRX S U LVHREOLJDXV FRQWULEXLHODPHQ LQHUHDVWDWX TXRXOXLvQ%DOFDQLV VHRSXQ RULF UHLGRPLQD LLVWU LQHvQ]RQ úLV QX vQFKHLH QLFL XQ DFRUG FX R WHU SXWHUH vQ FHHD FH SULYHúWH Ä(XURSD 2ULHQWDO ´vQVLWXD LDvQFDUHVDUILGHFODQúDWXQFRQIOLFWDUPDW3HQWUXD HYLWDGHVSULQGHUHD,WDOLHLGLQ7ULSOLF $XVWUR8QJDULDDSURPLV,WDOLHLF QX YD SURFHGD OD DOWH DQH[LXQL WHULWRULDOH vQ %DOFDQL vQDLQWH GH D vQFKHLD FX JXYHUQXOLWDOLDQÄXQDFRUGSUHDODELOED]DWSHSULQFLSLXOXQHLFRPSHQVD LL´
/D vQFHSXW GH VHFRO UHOD LLOH GLSORPDWLFH EXOJDURUXVH VH U FLVHU vQ XUPD UHIX]XOXL 5XVLHL DQJDMDW vQ ([WUHPXO 2ULHQW GH D VSULMLQL DVSLUD LLOH UHYL]LRQLVWHEXOJDUH ÌQ VFKLPEXO EXQ YRLQ HL UXVHúWL ID GH LQWHUHVHOH LWDOLHQH vQ 7ULSROLWDQLDúL&LUHQDLFDLWDOLHQLLVHREOLJDXV DGRSWHRSR]L LHVLPLODU ID GH ÄLQWHUHVHOHUXVHúWL´vQSUREOHPD6WUkPWRULORU ÌQ HOHJHUHDDYHDV ILHFRQILUPDW FXSULOHMXOUHvQQRLULWUDWDWHORUvQWUH VWDWHOHFDUHFRQVWLWXLDX7ULSOD$OLDQ ODGHFHPEULH
3R]L LD5RPkQLHLID GHU ]ERDLHOHEDOFDQLFH &UL]DERVQLDF DFRQWULEXLWvQWUHDOWHOHODDSURSLHUHD VXELPSXOVXO 5XVLHL D VWDWHORU GLQ %DOFDQL 6HUELD %XOJDULD *UHFLD úL 0XQWHQHJUX FDUH GXS FH DX vQFKHLDW DOLDQ H ELODWHUDOH FX XQ HYLGHQW FDUDFWHU DQWLRWRPDQDXPRELOL]DWWUXSHOH VHSWHPEULH úLDXvQPkQDW ,PSHULXOXL2WRPDQR1RW XOWLPDWLY VHSWHPEULHRFWRPEULH SULQFDUHVHFHUHDXUHIRUPHSHQWUXFRQD LRQDOLúLGHPRELOL]DUHDWUXSHORU RWRPDQHGLQ]RQD$GULDQRSROXOXL 3ULPXOU ]ERLEDOFDQLFÌQDFHVWFRQWH[WODRFWRPEULH D IRVW GHFODQúDW SULPXO U ]ERL EDOFDQLF ID GH FDUH 5RPkQLD D DGRSWDW R SR]L LH GH QHXWUDOLWDWH FX FRQGL LD GH D QX VH SURGXFH PRGLILF UL WHULWRULDOHFDUHV DIHFWH]HGUHSWXULOHLVWRULFHúLLQWHUHVHOHSRSRDUHORUGLQ %DOFDQLúLFDQLFLXQXOGLQWUHVWDWHOHDQJDMDWHV DPHQLQ HVHFXULWDWHD ULL úLV QXúLLQVWLWXLHKHJHPRQLDvQ]RQ 3R]L LDVDDYHDV ILHDSUHFLDW GH PDMRULWDWHDVWDWHORUHXURSHQH &RQFRPLWHQW D FRQWLQXDW V DFRUGH LPSRUWDQ GLVFX LLORU FX EXOJDULLvQQRLHPEULH DYkQGORFQRLWUDWDWLYHvQFDGUXOF URUDVD GHFLV vQFKHLHUHD XQXL DFRUG SULYLQG GUHSWXULOH DURPkQLORU úL VD DGPLV UHFWLILFDUHDIURQWLHUHLGREURJHQHI U DLQFOXGHvQV 6LOLVWUD'XS HúHFXO WUDWDWLYHORUELODWHUDOHGHOD/RQGUDvQFRQWH[WXOvQFDUHEXOJDULLDXI FXW DSHOODPHGLHUHD5XVLHLJXYHUQXOURPkQDDQXQ DWF YDOXDVXEFRQWURO OLQLD7XUWXFDLD%DOFLFI U GHFODUD LHGHU ]ERL 'HRDUHFHODLDQXDULH 5XVLDDDYHUWL]DW5RPkQLDF QX YDU PkQHLQGLIHUHQW GDF YDLQWHUYHQLvQ%XOJDULDUHJHOH&DURO,DGHFLV V UHvQQRLDVF WUDWDWXO FX $XVWUR8QJDULD OD IHEUXDULH úL V O UDWLILFH GXS FH SULQ XO )UVWHQEHUJ D DWHQ LRQDW F GXEOD PRQDUKLH DU SXWHDV úLVFKLPEHSROLWLFDID GH5RPkQLD6I WXLWGHJXYHUQHOHUXVúL DXVWURXQJDU V QX UHFXUJ OD IRU D DUPHORU JXYHUQXO URPkQ D DFFHSWDW UHOXDUHDGLVFX LLORUFXJXYHUQXOEXOJDUQLFLGHDFHDVW QHDMXQJkQGXVHOD XQ DFRUG &D XUPDUHH VD vQFKHLDW XQ SURFHVYHUEDO vQ FDUH VDX WUHFXW I U FRPHQWDULLSURSXQHULOHFHORUGRX S U L
9H]L úL 1LFRODH ,VDU ,VWRULD PRGHUQ D URPkQLORU %XFXUHúWLSS ÌQWUH 7LWX 0DLRUHVFX SULPXOPLQLVWUX DO 5RPkQLHL úL 6WRLDQ 'DQHY SUHúHGLQWHOH6REUDQHLEXOJDUH 3XUWDWHGH7DNH,RQHVFXúL1LFRODH0LúXGLQSDUWHD5RPkQLHL
'LVSXWDURPkQREXOJDU DIRVWDQDOL]DW úLGHDPEDVDGRULLPDULORU SXWHULFDUHDXvQFKHLDW DSULOLH PDL 3URWRFROXOGHOD3HWHUVEXUJ SULQFDUHVHUHFXQRúWHDDSDUWHQHQ D6LOLVWUHLFXRUD] H[WHULRDU GHNP OD 5RPkQLD &X WRDWH F GHFL]LD UHSUH]HQWDQ LORU PDULORU SXWHUL QX D VDWLVI FXW vQ WRWDOLWDWH JXYHUQXO URPkQ 3DUODPHQWXO GH OD %XFXUHúWL D DSUREDW vQ PDL WUHFHUHD OD H[HFXWDUHD GHFL]LLORU GH OD 3HWHUVEXUJ ÌQFHSXWHODLXQLH GLVFX LLOHSHQWUXGHOLPLWDUHDWHULWRULXOXLVDX vQFKHLDWODLXQLHLXOLHGHRDUHFHEXOJDULLGRUHDXV PHQ LQ ORFDOLWDWHD vQE WDLDWXQXULORUFXWUDJHUHGLUHFW $O GRLOHD U ]ERL EDOFDQLF 7HQGLQ HOH KHJHPRQLFH SH FDUH OH PDQLIHVWD%XOJDULDvQ]RQ úLVSULMLQXOWRWPDLGHVFKLVSHFDUHDFHDVWDvO SULPHD GLQ SDUWHD $XVWUR8QJDULHL DX GHWHUPLQDW *UHFLD úL 6HUELD V vQFKHLH PDLLXQLH XQWUDWDWVHFUHWFXFDUDFWHUGHIHQVLYSULQ FDUH XUPDX V úL DFRUGH VSULMLQ UHFLSURF vQ FD] GH DWDF EXOJDU FDUH VD SURGXVGHDOWIHOvQQRDSWHDGH VSUHLXQLH 'DW ILLQG SR]L LD VWUDWHJLF VLWXD LD HFRQRPLF úL PLOLWDU úL DOWH GLVSRQLELOLW L GH FDUH GLVSXQHD 5RPkQLD DPEHOH WDEHUH LDX I FXW SURSXQHUL GH DOLHUH vQF vQDLQWH GH GHFODQúDUHD FRQIOLFWXOXL ,QL LDO JXYHUQXO GH OD %XFXUHúWL QX D GDW FXUV VROLFLW ULL SHQWUX D QX vQU XW L VLWXD LD DSRL PDL LXQLH D I FXW FXQRVFXW F R DJUDYDUH HYHQWXDO DVLWXD LHLvQ%DOFDQLQXDUSXWHDO VDLQGLIHUHQW 5RPkQLD &KLDUúLPDULOHSXWHULDXvQFHUFDWV LLQIOXHQ H]HDWLWXGLQHD)UDQ D úL5XVLDODXVI WXLWLQL LDOV S VWUH]HQHXWUDOLWDWHD$SRLvQJULMRUDWHGH VRDUWD6HUELHLDXO VDWOXFUXULOHV HYROXH]HGHODVLQH$XVWUR8QJDULDD XUP ULWODvQFHSXWDSURSLHUHDURPkQREXOJDU DSRLDOXDWvQFDOFXOFKLDU GHVFKLGHUHD XQXL IURQW vPSRWULYD 5RPkQLHL GDF DFHDVWD DU IL GHFODQúDW U ]ERLXO HOLEHUDWRU vQ 7UDQVLOYDQLD *HUPDQLD D vQFHUFDW V VWRSH]H WHQGLQ HOH U ]ERLQLFH DOH DOLDWXOXL DXVWURXQJDU UHDILUPkQGXúL VSULMLQXO OLPLWDW SHQWUX 5RPkQLD ,WDOLD VD SURQXQ DW SHQWUX R DSURSLHUH vQWUH 5RPkQLD6HUELDúL*UHFLD
'HFL]LDGHOD3HWHUVEXUJDIRVWFkWGHFkWIDYRUDELO 5RPkQLHLGDWRULW VSULMLQXOXLSXWHULORUFDUHFRQVWLWXLDX7ULSOD$OLDQ &RORQLúWLLEXOJDULFDUHGRUHDX V S U VHDVF ]RQDHUDXGHVS JXEL LGHVWDWXOURPkQDPEHOH ULREOLJkQGXVHV QXULGLFHIRUWLILFD LLvQDSURSLHUHDRUDúXOXL
ÌQIUkQJHULOHvQUHJLVWUDWHGHWUXSHOHEXOJDUHOD%UHJDQL DúLvQDOWHORFXUL DXGHWHUPLQDWRJUDY FUL] SROLWLF VROGDW FXF GHUHDJXYHUQXOXL6WRLDQ 'DQHY LXOLH
ÌQ ID D PDQLIHVW ULORU KHJHPRQLFH EXOJDUH JXYHUQXO URPkQ D PRELOL]DW DUPDWD LXQLH LXOLH VSUH LXQLH LXOLH úLD UHFKHPDW DPEDVDGRUXO GH OD 6RILD LXQLH LXOLH úL D I FXW SXEOLF IDSWXO F WUXSHOH URPkQH YRU WUHFH 'XQ UHD GDF IRU HOH EXOJDUH QX vQFHWHD] DF LXQLOH PLOLWDUH vPSRWULYD FHORU VkUEHúWL úL JUHFHúWL 'HRDUHFH %XOJDULD QX VD FRQIRUPDW D XUPDW vQPkQDUHD GHFODUD LHL GH U ]ERL WUHFHUHD 'XQ ULLGHF WUHWUXSHOHURPkQH LXOLH úLvQDLQWDUHDVSUH6RILDI U D VHDMXQJHvQV ODFRQIUXQW ULPLOLWDUH&RQFRPLWHQW0LQLVWHUXO$IDFHULORU 6WU LQH D I FXW FXQRVFXW F 5RPkQLD QX GXFHD R SROLWLF GH FXFHULUL WHULWRULDOHFLGRDUUHVWDELOLUHDS FLLvQ]RQ úLvPSLHGLFDUHD%XOJDULHLGHD úLLPSXQHKHJHPRQLDvQ]RQ ÌQPRPHQWXOvQFDUH DUXOEXOJDU)HUGLQDQG,GH&REXUJDVROLFLWDW UHJHOXL&DURO, LXOLH V RSUHDVF RIHQVLYDDUPDWHLURPkQHúL V vQFKHLH SDFH VHSDUDW UHJHOH URPkQ D FRQGL LRQDW DFHVW OXFUX GH vQFKHLHUHDXQXLDUPLVWL LXJHQHUDO3HQWUXDSUHYHQLLQWHUYHQ LDPDULORU SXWHULODLXOLHGXS FH&DGULODWHUXOWUHFXVHVXEDXWRULWDWHPLOLWDU URPkQHDVF &DURO , D RUGRQDW vQFHWDUHD vQDLQW ULL DUPDWHL URPkQH vQ %XOJDULD úL D FHUXW OD UkQGXL VXYHUDQLORU *UHFLHL 6HUELHL úL 0XQWHQHJUXOXL V GLVSXQ RSULUHD RSHUD LLORU PLOLWDUH úL vQFHSHUHD QHJRFLHULORUGHSDFH ÌQDFHVWFRQWH[WFRPSOHWDWFXYLFWRULLOHWUXSHORUVkUEHúWLúLJUHFHúWL úL FX LQWUDUHD 7XUFLHL vQ U ]ERL úL RFXSDUHD $GULDQRSROXOXL JXYHUQXO EXOJDU D GHFLV FDSLWXODUHD %XOJDULHL úL WULPLWHUHD UHSUH]HQWDQ LORU OD 1LV XQGH VH DGXQDVHU GHOHJD LL PLOLWDUL DL FHORUODOWH VWDWH SDUWLFLSDQWH OD U ]ERL ÌQILQDO&RQIHULQ DGHSDFHFDUHúLDGHVFKLVOXFU ULOHOD%XFXUHúWL LXOLH VXE SUHúHGLQ LD SULPXOXLPLQLVWUX URPkQ 7LWX 0DLRUHVFX D GHFLV vQFKHLHUHD XQXL DUPLVWL LX GH FLQFL ]LOH vQFHSkQG FX LXOLH úL D WUDWDWXOXL GH SDFH LXOLH DXJXVW vQWUH 5RPkQLD 6HUELD*UHFLDúL0XQWHQHJUXSHGHRSDUWHúL%XOJDULDSHGHDOW SDUWH
6HUELHL
%XOJDULL GRUHDX V FRQWLQXH RSHUD LLOH PLOLWDUH vPSRWULYD *UHFLHL úL
'LQSDUWHD5RPkQLHLDXSDUWLFLSDWJHQHUDOXO&RQVWDQWLQ&RDQG FRORQHOXO &RQVWDQWLQ&ULVWHVFXúLORFRWHQHQWFRORQHOXO+HQUL&LKRVNL /DLXOLHDXJXVWDUPLVWL LXODIRVWSUHOXQJLWSHQWUXWUHL]LOHDSRLSH WHUPHQQHOLPLWDWSkQ ODvQFKHLHUHDWUDWDWXOXLGHSDFH
&XDFHOSULOHMSDUWHDGHVXGD'REURJHL &DGULODWHUXO FXRVXSUDID GH NPS úL SHVWH GH ORFXLWRUL D LQWUDW vQ FRPSRQHQ D 5RPkQLHL JXYHUQXO EXOJDU REOLJkQGXVH V G UkPH WRDWH IRUWLILFD LLOH GLQ]RQ &XDFHODúLSULOHM0DFHGRQLDDIRVWvPS U LW vQWUH6HUELD*UHFLD úL %XOJDULD VDQJHDFXO 1RYL 3D]DU D IRVW RIHULW 6HUELHL úL 0XQWHQHJUXOXLLDU7UDFLDGHYHVWFX.DYDOOD*UHFLHL/DVFXUWWLPS LXQLH DXJXVW LXOLHDXJXVW úL LXOLH DXJXVW vQWUH 5RPkQLD%XOJDULDúL*UHFLDDXIRVWvQFKHLDWHDFRUGXULSULYLQGJDUDQ WDUHDDXWRQRPLHLúFROLORUúLELVHULFLORUDURPkQLORUGLQ0DFHGRQLD ÌQFKHLDW SHQWUXSULPDGDW I U SDUWLFLSDUHDPDULORUSXWHULSDFHD GLQ D SURYRFDW UHDF LD DFHVWRUD $XVWUR8QJDULD úL 5XVLD VD SURQXQ DWSHQWUXUHYL]XLUHDGHFL]LLORUGHOD%XFXUHúWL$QJOLDúL*HUPDQLD DXPDQLIHVWDWUH]HUYHDQXODWHvQILQDOGHF WUHGLSORPD LDIUDQFH] FDUHD GHWHUPLQDW úL 5XVLD V úL VFKLPEH SR]L LD 3XV vQ PLQRULWDWH $XVWUR 8QJDULDDDFFHSWDWúLHDQRXDVWDUHGHOXFUXULFXDWkWPDLPXOWFXFkWOD VFXUWWLPSFRQWH[WXDOLQWHUQD LRQDOVDVFKLPEDWGLQQRX ÌQDQVDPEOXHYHQLPHQWHOHGLQ DXGRYHGLWF 5RPkQLD VH EXFXUD GH XQ UHDOSUHVWLJLXvQVXGHVWXO(XURSHLúLFKLDUSHSODQPDL ODUJ HXURSHDQ 'H DVHPHQHD VD GRYHGLW vQF RGDW F vQ SRILGD DVLJXU ULORU GH ORLDOLWDWH ID GH 3XWHULOH &HQWUDOH vQWUH 5RPkQLD úL $XVWUR8QJDULD H[LVWDX GLIHUHQ H GH YHGHUL vQ PXOWH SULYLQ H vQ DIDUD SUREOHPHLHVHQ LDOHDURPkQLORUDVXSUL LGLQLPSHULXvQVSHFLDOvQFHHDFH SULYHúWHVLWXD LD6HUELHLúLSROLWLFDVXGGXQ UHDQ DJXYHUQXOXLGHOD9LHQD DWUDJHUHD%XOJDULHLvQ7ULSOLF
&RQIRUPDUWQRXDIURQWLHU URPkQREXOJDU vQFHSHDGHOD'XQ UH OkQJ 7XUNúPLO NP vQ DPRQWH GH 7XUWXFDLD FRQWLQXD SHVWH SODWRXO .LOOL 5DGLúLDMXQJHDOD0DUHD1HDJU ODVXGGH(NUHQH SURWRFROXOGHGHOLPLWDUHD IURQWLHUHLvQWRFPLWGHF WUHRFRPLVLHPL[W DIRVWvQFKHLDWODQRLHPEULH GHFHPEULH
$UPDWD EXOJDU WUHEXLD V ILH GHPRELOL]DW D GRXD ]L GXS VHPQDUHDWUDWDWXOXLGHSDFHLDUDUPDWHOHIRVWHDOLDWHV HYDFXH]HWHULWRULXO EXOJDUODGRX V SW PkQLGXS DFHDVWD SUL]RQLHULLGHU ]ERLXUPDXV ILH HOLEHUD LUHFLSURF
3H ODUJ SHQWUX SULPXO úL FHO GHDO GRLOHD U ]ERL EDOFDQLF ,VWRULD PLOLWDU DSRSRUXOXLURPkQYRO9%XFXUHúWL SS
5RPkQLDúLSULPXOU ]ERLPRQGLDO 3UHOLPLQDULL (YHQLPHQWHOH GLQ WLPSXO FHOXL GHDO GRLOHD U ]ERL EDOFDQLFDXUHOHYDWFDSDFLWDWHDURPkQLORUGHDJHVWLRQDVLWXD LLOHGHFUL] GLQ]RQ úLGHDIDFHID SUHVLXQLORUSXWHUQLFXOXLDOLDWDXVWURXQJDU0DL PXOW UHJHOH &DURO , JXYHUQXO úL GLSORPD LD URPkQ vQ DFRUG FX RSLQLD SXEOLF DX FRQWLQXDW V FHDU GLQ FH vQ FH PDL LQVLVWHQW PRGLILFDUHD SR]L LHLJXYHUQXOXLXQJDUID GHURPkQLLGLQWHULWRULLOHORFXLWHPDMRULWDU GH DFHúWLD ÌQ DFHODúL VFRS D DF LRQDW úL GLSORPD LD JHUPDQ úL FKLDU DXVWULDF SULQQXPHURDVHOHGHPHUVXULI FXWHSHOkQJ JXYHUQXOPDJKLDU vQVSHFLDOSHOkQJ SULPXOPLQLVWUX7LV]D 3URILWkQGGHDFHDVW FRQMXQFWXU IDYRUDELO GLSORPD LD$QWDQWHLúL D LQWHQVLILFDW GHPHUVXULOH SHQWUX VFRDWHUHD 5RPkQLHL GLQ 7ULSOD $OLDQ ,QWHUHVDW VDGRYHGLWDILúLGLSORPD LDURPkQ FDUHDVRQGDWWHUHQXOPDL DOHV vQ FHHD FH SULYHúWH SR]L LD 5XVLHL FX SULOHMXO YL]LWHL vQWUHSULQV GH DUXO1LFRODHDO,,OHDOD&RQVWDQ DODLXQLH vQWLPSXOFUL]HL GH OD 6DUDMHYR &X DFHO SULOHM 5XVLD úLD UHvQQRLW JDUDQ LD SHQWUX PHQ LQHUHDWUDWDWXOXLGHOD%XFXUHúWLGLQ úLVDDQJDMDWV FRODERUH]H ODPHQ LQHUHDS FLLúLHFKLOLEUXOXLvQ%DOFDQL ([WUHP GH LPSRUWDQWH DX IRVW úL GLVFX LLOH GLQWUH PLQLúWULL GH ([WHUQH,,&%U WLDQXúL6'6D]RQRYGLSORPDWXOUXVLQWHUHVkQGXVHGH DOLDQ HOH 5RPkQLHL úL GH DWLWXGLQHD SH FDUH DFHDVWD DU DGRSWDR vQ HYHQWXDOLWDWHD XQXL U ]ERL UXVRDXVWULDF ÌQ PRG GLSORPDWLF PLQLVWUXO URPkQ GH ([WHUQH D U VSXQV F vQWUR DVHPHQHD VLWXD LH 5RPkQLD YD XUP UL GRDU VDWLVIDFHUHD SURSULLORU VDOH LQWHUHVH 9L]LWD DUXOXL OD &RQVWDQ DDDODUPDWGLSORPD LDDXVWURXQJDU úLDLULWDWSHFHDJHUPDQ FHDLWDOLDQ ILLQGvQ HOHJ WRDUH $FHVWHLDF LXQLGLSORPDWLFHLVDUDOLDWúLRSLQLDSXEOLF LQWHUQ FDUH HUD SRWULYQLF $XVWUR8QJDULHL PDL DOHV GXS HúXDUHD WUDWDWLYHORU GH OD %XGDSHVWD GLQWUH UHSUH]HQWDQ LL JXYHUQXOXL XQJDU úL UHSUH]HQWDQ LL 3DUWLGXOXL 1D LRQDO 5RPkQ úL D LQWHQVLILF ULL OXSWHL SHQWUX vPSOLQLUHD
&X SX LQ WLPS vQDLQWH vQ PDUWLH SHUHFKHD SULQFLDU URPkQ YL]LWDVH3HWHUVEXUJXOXLSULOHMFXFDUHVDGLVFXWDWGHVSUHF V WRULDOXL&DUROFX XQDGLQSULQFLSHVHOHUXVH &RQVWDQWLQ 1X X 5RPkQLD vQ DQLL QHXWUDOLW LL (GLWXUD ùWLLQ LILF %XFXUHúWL S
LGHDOXOXL QD LRQDO úL SHQWUX GHV YkUúLUHD XQLW LL VWDWDOH SURFHV D F UXL vQI SWXLUHVHVSHUDDILUHDOL]DW FXVSULMLQXO$QWDQWHL3HQWUXDFHDVWDvQV WUHEXLDUHDOL]DW UHRULHQWDUHDSROLWLFLLH[WHUQHD ULLI U DVHSURYRFDR FUL] FRQVWLWX LRQDO GDW ILLQG IHUPD RULHQWDUH SURJHUPDQ D UHJHOXL &DURO , úL I U D SXQH vQ SHULFRO H[LVWHQ D ULL vQ FRQWH[WXO GHFODQú ULL SULPXOXLU ]ERLPRQGLDO &RQúWLHQW GH DJUDYDUHD VLWXD LHL LQWHUQD LRQDOH vQ XUPD DWHQWDWXOXL GH OD 6DUDMHYR LXQLH F UXLD LD F ]XW YLFWLP SULQFLSHOH )HUGLQDQG GH +DEVEXUJ PRúWHQLWRU DO PRQDUKLHL DXVWURXQJDUH úL D XOWLPDWXPXOXLDGUHVDW6HUELHLGHF WUH$XVWUR8QJDULD LXOLH JXYHUQXO URPkQ vQ DFRUG FX UHJHOH &DURO , D GHVI úXUDW R LQWHQV DFWLYLWDWHGLSORPDWLF SHQWUXDDVLJXUDPHQ LQHUHDLQWHJULW LLWHULWRULDOHD 5RPkQLHL vPSOLQLUHD OD PRPHQWXO RSRUWXQ D GH]LGHUDWXOXL QD LRQDO DO XQLULL WXWXURU URPkQLORU úL GDF HUD SRVLELO HYLWDUHD GHFODQú ULL úL JHQHUDOL] ULL U ]ERLXOXL &D XUPDUH D DFHVWHL SR]L LL 6' 6D]RQRY PLQLVWUXOUXVGH([WHUQHDFHUXWJXYHUQXOXLURPkQV LQWHUYLQ OD9LHQD SHQWUXDWHQXDUHDXQRUDGLQSUHYHGHULOHH[FHVLYHDOHXOWLPDWXPXOXLDGUHVDW 6HUELHLSUHFXPúLOD%HOJUDGSHQWUXDGHWHUPLQDJXYHUQXOVkUEV ILHPDL FRQFLOLDQW ,QWUDQVLJHQ DPDQLIHVWDW GH$XVWUR8QJDULDVXV LQXW GH*HUPDQLD D SXV SH RILFLDOLL URPkQL vQWUR VLWXD LH GLILFLO DFHúWLD WUHEXLQG V IDF ID úL SXWHUQLFHORU SUHVLXQL DOH UHSUH]HQWDQ LORU 3XWHULORU &HQWUDOH vQ YHGHUHDSXQHULLvQDSOLFDUHDSUHYHGHULORUWUDWDWXOXLGHDOLDQ GLQ ÄvQGHS UW ULL´ GH 6HUELD vQFHW ULL PDQLIHVWD LLORU vPSRWULYD $XVWUR 8QJDULHL /XkQG vQ FDOFXO VLWXD LD URPkQLORU DVXSUL L GLQ $XVWUR8QJDULD vQ VSHFLDOEUXWDODSROLWLF GHGH]QD LRQDOL]DUHSURPRYDW GHJXYHUQXOGHOD %XGDSHVWD úL SR]L LD RSLQLHL SXEOLFH GLQ DU JXYHUQXO GH OD %XFXUHúWL vQWUXQLW OD 6LQDLD vQ VHDUD ]LOHL GH LXOLH GXS FH D DIODW F
3HQWUX (XURSD vQ SULPXO U ]ERL PRQGLDO YH]L úL 6RULQ &ULVWHVFX 5HOD LLSROLWLFRGLSORPDWLFHúLPLOLWDUHHXURSHQH(GLWXUD)XQGD LHL5RPkQLDGH 0kLQH%XFXUHúWLSS 3HODUJ 1LFRODH,VDU,VWRULDPRGHUQ DURPkQLORU %XFXUHúWLSS 5RPkQLDvQDQLLSULPXOXLU ]ERLPRQGLDOYRO %XFXUHúWL SS ,RQ$JULJRURDLHL3R]L LDPDULORUSXWHUL ID GH 5RPkQLD vQ 5RPkQLL vQ LVWRULD XQLYHUVDO YRO ,DúL SS
$XVWUR8QJDULD I U V LQIRUPH]H5RPkQLD DGHFODUDWU ]ERL6HUELHLD DMXQV OD FRQFOX]LD F 5RPkQLD QX SXWHD V VH DO WXUH DOLDWXOXL DXVWUR XQJDU FX DWkW PDL PXOW FX FkW QX HUDX vQGHSOLQLWH FRQGL LLOH GH ÄFDVXV IRHGHULV´SUHY ]XWHvQWUDWDWXOGLQ 3UHVLXQLOHúLFHUHULOHXOWLPDWLYHDGUHVDWHVXYHUDQXOXLURPkQGHF WUH vPS UD LL :LOKHOP DO ,,OHD úL )UDQFLVF ,RVLI , LXOLH LXOLH DXJXVW HWF DXU PDVI U HFRXvQSRILGDIDSWXOXLF XOWLPXOG GHD DVLJXU ULF %XOJDULDQXYDLQWHUYHQLvPSRWULYD5RPkQLHL 1HXWUDOLWDWHD $QDOL]kQG FX OXFLGLWDWH LQWHUHVHOH IXQGDPHQWDOH DOH ULLúLSRVLELOLW LOHGHvQI SWXLUHDDFHVWRUDJXYHUQXOURPkQVDSURQXQ DW LXOLH SHQWUXQHXWUDOLWDWHDWLWXGLQHDRILFLDO ILLQGVWDELOLW GH F WUH &RQVLOLXO GH &RURDQ vQWUXQLW OD 6LQDLD LXOLH DXJXVW SULOHMFXFDUHDIRVWI FXWSXEOLFúLWUDWDWXOGHDOLDQ GLQ ÌQ SRILGD SR]L LHL H[SULPDWH GH UHJHOH &DURO , FDUH VD SURQXQ DW SHQWUX SXQHUHD vQ YLJRDUH D WUDWDWXOXL GH DOLDQ FX $XVWUR8QJDULD úL SHQWUX FRQVWLWXLUHD XQXL JXYHUQ GH FRQFHQWUDUH QD LRQDO FHLODO L SDUWLFLSDQ L FX H[FHS LD OXL 33 &DUS DX VROLFLWDW úL DX GHFLV vQ ILQDO S VWUDUHDSR]L LHLGHQHXWUDOLWDWH6ROX LDÄHVSHFWDWLYHLDUPDWHDIURQWLH UHORU´FRQILUPDW RILFLDOvQDFHHDúL]LGHF WUH&RQVLOLXOGH0LQLúWULVD GRYHGLW D IL vQ DFRUG FX VHQWLPHQWHOH SRSRUXOXL URPkQ FX LQWHUHVHOH GH PRPHQWDOH ULL ÌQSRILGDIDSWXOXLF DWkWUHJHOH&DURO,FkWúLSULPXOPLQLVWUX,,& %U WLDQXDXI FXWFXQRVFXWRILFLDODXWRULW LORUJHUPDQHúLDXVWURXQJDUH F DGRSWkQG QHXWUDOLWDWHD 5RPkQLD GRUHD GRDU V FkúWLJH WLPS SHQWUX UHRULHQWDUHD RSLQLHL SXEOLFH úL vQW ULUHD IRU HORU DUPDWH SHQWUX WRDW OXPHDLQFOXVLYSHQWUXGLSORPD LLVWDWHORUGLQ7ULSOD$OLDQ HUDFODUF vQ SROLWLFD H[WHUQ D ULL VH SURGXVHVHU VFKLPE UL HVHQ LDOH F JXYHUQXO URPkQ DúWHSWD GRDU PRPHQWXO IDYRUDELO SROLWLF úL PLOLWDU SHQWUX D QHJRFLDFXJXYHUQHOHVWDWHORUGLQ$QWDQW GHSHSR]L LLFkWPDLIDYRUDELOH UHFXQRDúWHUHDQHFHVLW LLvPSOLQLULLGH]LGHUDWHORUQD LRQDOH
/DVFXUWWLPSGXS FH$XVWUR8QJDULDDGHFODUDWU ]ERL6HUELHL LXOLH FRQIODJUD LDDYHDV VHJHQHUDOL]H]HGXS FH*HUPDQLDDGHFODUDWúL HD U ]ERL 5XVLHL LXOLH DXJXVW )UDQ HL LXOLH DXJXVW %HOJLHL LXOLH DXJXVW GXS FH 0DUHD %ULWDQLH úL GRPLQLRDQHOH DX GHFODUDW U ]ERL *HUPDQLHL LXOLH DXJXVW 0XQWHQHJUXO $XVWUR8QJDULHL LXOLH DXJXVW )UDQ DúL0DUHD%ULWDQLH$XVWUR8QJDULHL LXOLHDXJXVWUHVSHFWLY LXOLHDXJXVW LDU-DSRQLD*HUPDQLHL DXJXVW
5HFHSWkQGLPSRUWDQ DVWUDWHJLF D5RPkQLHL VWDWHOHFDUHFRQVWLWX LDX$QWDQWDDXDFFHSWDWQHXWUDOLWDWHDSURFODPDW GHJXYHUQXOURPkQFDúL FHOHGLQ7ULSOD$OLDQ FXWRDWHF DFHVWRUDGLQXUP OHDUILFRQYHQLWPDL ELQHDQJDMDUHDLPHGLDW vQOXSW D5RPkQLHLGHSDUWHDORU&KLDUGDF QX DXUHXúLWDFHVWOXFUX*HUPDQLDúL$XVWUR8QJDULDDXUHFXQRVFXWLQYLROD ELOLWDWHD IURQWLHUHORU URPkQHúWL úL VWDWXWXO GH QHXWUDOLWDWH I FkQG vQV WRW SRVLELOXOSHQWUXDRUHDGXFHvQDOLDQ VDXFHOSX LQSHQWUXDRvQFDGUDvQWU XQ ÄEORF EDOFDQLF´ vPSUHXQ FX %XOJDULD úL 7XUFLD SHQWUX D OH RSXQH 5XVLHL 6SUH D DWUDJH 5RPkQLD vQ U ]ERL :LOKHOP DO ,,OHD D SURSXV VDWLVIDFHUHDXQRUDGLQWUHUHYHQGLF ULOHURPkQHúWLOHJLWLPHúLRUJDQL]DUHD DXWRQRP D7UDQVLOYDQLHLvQV SULPXOPLQLVWUXXQJDUQXDDFFHSWDWGHFkW XQHOH ÄUHFWLILF UL GH JUDQL ´ vQ %XFRYLQD 7RW FX HúHF VDX VROGDW úL GLVFX LLOH DYXWH GH F WUH 7LV]D FX ,XOLX 0DQLX $OH[DQGUX 9DLGD úL 7KHRGRU 0LKDOL vQ VHSWHPEULH FkQG SULPXOPLQLVWUX XQJDU D SURPLV vQ VFKLPEXO FRRSHU ULL DFWLYH D 5RPkQLHL OD U ]ERL DO WXUL GH 3XWHULOH &HQWUDOH GRDU UHYL]XLUHD OHJLL úFRODUH D OXL $SSRQ\LL úL PRGLILFDUHD OHJLL HOHFWRUDOH ,QIOH[LELO D U PDV 7LV]D úL OD SUHVLXQLOH GLSORPD LHL JHUPDQH úL DXVWULHFH SULYLQG DFRUGDUHD DPQLVWLHL VLVW ULL SURFHVHORUGHSUHV vPSRWULYDURPkQLORUDFFHSW ULLQXPLULLXQXLPLQLVWUX URPkQ vQ JXYHUQXO GH OD %XGDSHVWD úL S WUXQGHULL WUXSHORU URPkQH vQ 7UDQVLOYDQLD vQ PRG SDúQLF SHQWUX D SURWHMD SURYLQFLD GH WUXSHOH UXVH &KLDU GDF XUP UHD úL HO PHQ LQHUHD 5RPkQLHL vQ 7ULSOD $OLDQ 7LV]D GRUHDV VHUHDOL]D]HDFHVWOXFUXI U QLFLRFRQFHVLHFLGRDUSULQSUHVLXQL I FXWHLQFOXVLYGH%XOJDULDFDUHULGLFDVHSUREOHPDUHYL]XLULLWUDWDWXOXLGH OD %XFXUHúWL ÌQ ILQDO SR]L LD ULJLG DGRSWDW GH DXWRULW LOH GH OD %XGDSHVWD ID GH 5RPkQLD DYHD V DFFHOHUH]H RULHQWDUHD SROLWLFLL JXYHUQXOXLGHOD%XFXUHúWLVSUH$QWDQW
Ä&KHLDYLFWRULHLvPSRWULYD5XVLHL±DSUHFLDvPS UDWXOJHUPDQ:LOKHOP DO ,,OHD OD VHSWHPEULH ± VH DIO vQ PkLQLOH 5RPkQLHL´ vQ WLPS FH FDQFHODUXO 7KHREDOG YRQ %HWPDQQ +ROOZHJ FRQVLGHUD OD DXJXVW VHSWHPEULH F R HYHQWXDO DSURSLHUH D 5RPkQLHL GH 5XVLD DU IL FRPSURPLVJUDYÄVLWXD LDJHQHUDO DWkWvQ*DOL LDFkWúLvQ%DOFDQL´ *HUPDQLD SURPLWHD 5RPkQLHL DFRUGDUHD DXWRQRPLHL SHQWUX URPkQLL GLQ 7UDQVLOYDQLD VDX D XQXL ÄVWDWXW SROLWLF´ %DVDUDELD úL VXGXO %XFRYLQHL ]RQHOH6XFHDYDúL5 G X L
7UDWDWLYHOH FX $QWDQWD ,QL LDO DSURSLHUHD VD I FXW GH 5XVLD 6'6D]RQRYvQDLQWkQGODVFXUWWLPSGXS úHGLQ D&RQVLOLXOXLGH&RURDQ GH OD 6LQDLD WH[WXO XQXL SURLHFW GH FRQYHQ LH VHFUHW UXVRURPkQ vQ UHDOLWDWH D IRVW YRUED GH XQ VFKLPE GH VFULVRUL SULQ FDUH 5XVLD JDUDQWD LQWHJULWDWHD WHULWRULDO D 5RPkQLHL vQ VFKLPEXO FRRSHU ULL PLOLWDUH FX $QWDQWD ,QYRFkQG IDSWXO F DQJDMDUHD 5RPkQLHL vQ U ]ERL FRQWUDYHQHD KRW UkULORU DGRSWDWH GH &RQVLOLXO GH &RURDQ OXkQG vQ FDOFXO SR]L LD GLIHULW D JXYHUQHORU IUDQFH] úL HQJOH] F URUD OH FRQYHQHD QHXWUDOLWDWHD 5RPkQLHL DFRUGXULOH VHFUHWH vQFKHLDWH vQWUH DFHVWHD úL 5XVLD vQWUH *HUPDQLD úL $XVWULD FX %XOJDULD úL 7XUFLD SUHFXP úL LQVXILFLHQWD SUHJ WLUHD ULLúLDDUPDWHL,,&%U WLDQXDUHIX]DWV DQJDMH]HLPHGLDW DUDvQU ]ERLQHUHQXQ kQGvQV ODWUDWDWLYHOHSXUWDWHFX5XVLDúLFXFHLODO L SDUWHQHULDLDFHVWHLDGLQ$QWDQW 'HDOWIHOODVFXUWWLPSvQFRQWH[WXOYLFWRULLORUUXVHúWLGHSHIURQWXO GLQ *DOL LD úL GLQ %XFRYLQD 3HWHUVEXUJXO DYHD V úL VFKLPEH SR]L LD )LLQGXL GH DMXQV vQ DFHO FRQWH[W GRDU QHXWUDOLWDWHD ELQHYRLWRDUH D 5RPkQLHL JXYHUQXO UXV D DFFHSWDW FKLDU SULQ $FRUGXO VHFUHW GLQ VHSWHPEULH RFWRPEULH GUHSWXO 5RPkQLHL GH D UHXQL ÄS U LOH GLQ $XVWUR8QJDULDORFXLWHGHURPkQL´vQPRPHQWXOSHFDUHOÄYDFRQVLGHUD RSRUWXQ´úLVHREOLJDV VHRSXQ RULF UHLvQFHUF ULGHvQF OFDUHDVWDWX TXRXOXLWHULWRULDODO5RPkQLHLvQOLPLWHOHIURQWLHUHORUH[LVWHQWHODDFHDGDW ÌQSRILGDFDUDFWHUXOXLOLPLWDWDOvQ HOHJHULLURPkQRUXVHGLQWRDPQD DQXOXL DSROLWLFLLGXSOLFLWDUHDXQRUDGLQWUHFHUFXULOHSROLWLFH DULVWH
)UDQ D úL $QJOLD DFFHSWDVHU FHUHULOH 5XVLHL SULYLQG VW SkQLUHD &RQVWDQWLQRSROXOXL úL D 6WUkPWRULORU FX FRQGL LD DFFHSW ULL ÄGUHSWXULORU IUDQFH]HúLHQJOH]HvQ2ULHQWXO$SURSLDW´ 3ULQ QHXWUDOLWDWHD ELQHYRLWRDUH D 5RPkQLHL 3HWURJUDGXO vQ HOHJHD VLVWDUHD WUDQ]LWXOXL GH DUPDPHQW úL PDWHULL SULPH JHUPDQH F WUH %XOJDULD úL 7XUFLD OLPLWDUHD OD PD[LPXP D DSURYL]LRQ ULORU URPkQHúWL F WUH VWDWHOH 3XWHULORU &HQWUDOH IDFLOLWDUHD WUDQVSRUWXULORU GH DUPH HFKLSDPHQW úL DOWH PDWHULDOHUXVHF WUH6HUELD 3HODUJ 5RPkQLDvQSULPXOU ]ERLPRQGLDOYRO%XFXUHúWLSS 3HWHUVEXJXODSURSXVFDGHOLPLWDUHDWHULWRULXOXL%XFRYLQHLvQWUH5XVLD úL5RPkQLDV VHIDF SHED]DSULQFLSLXOXLQD LRQDOLW LORU &XSULOHMXOvQDLQW ULLDFRUGXOXL6'6D]RQRYDI FXWFXQRVFXWF 5XVLD YDDS UDLQWHJULWDWHDWHULWRULDO D5RPkQLHLGRDUSULQPLMORDFHGLSORPDWLFH
F URUDOHFRQYHQHDR8QJDULHSXWHUQLF vQORFXOXQHLÄ5RPkQLLP ULWH´úL FKLDU D XQRUD GLQWUH SROLWLFLHQLL HQJOH]L FDUH GRUHDX PHQ LQHUHD $XVWUR 8QJDULHLFDR]RQ ÄWDPSRQ´vQFDOHH[SDQVLXQLLVODYLVPXOXLGLSORPD LD URPkQHDVF DRE LQXWXQVXFFHVGHRVHELWvQVHSWHPEULH 5HOD LLOH FX ,WDOLD $OLDWH SkQ vQ vQ FDGUXO 7ULSOHL $OLDQ H 5RPkQLDúL,WDOLDDXvQFKHLDWODVHSWHPEULH XQDFRUGVHFUHW ELODWHUDOSULQFDUHVHDQJDMDXV S VWUH]HQHXWUDOLWDWHDV QRS U VHDVF vQDLQWH GH D VH LQIRUPD UHFLSURF FX FHO SX LQ RSW ]LOH vQDLQWH úL V VH FRQVXOWHvQVLWXD LDvQFDUHVHVFKLPEDFRQWH[WXOLQWHUQD LRQDO&XDFHODúL SULOHM ,WDOLD D UHFXQRVFXW GUHSWXULOH LVWRULFH DOH 5RPkQLHL DVXSUD 7UDQVLOYDQLHL &RQVXOW ULOHvQWUHUHSUH]HQWDQ LLFHORUGRX JXYHUQHDXFRQWLQXDW vQ LDQXDULH FkQG ,,&%U WLDQX D SURSXV vQFKHLHUHD XQXL SDFW GH DVLVWHQ PXWXDO UHFLSURF &X WRDWH F DXWRULW LOH GH OD 5RPD DX FRQVLGHUDWDFHVWGHPHUVFDSUHPDWXUODIHEUXDULH GLQLQL LDWLY LWDOLDQ D IRVW vQFKHLDW XQ QRX DFRUG LWDORURPkQ SHQWUX LQIRUPDUH UHFLSURF úLDVLVWHQ PXWXDO vQFD]GHDWDFDXVWURXQJDUQHSURYRFDW &RQVLGHUkQGXVHÄPDUHSXWHUH´,WDOLDQXDUHVSHFWDWLQWHJUDOXQHOH SUHYHGHUL DOH DFRUGXULORU vQFKHLDWH FX 5RPkQLD PDL DOHV SH DFHOHD UHIHULWRDUH OD LQIRUPDUHD UHFLSURF vQFKHLQG OD DSULOLH OD /RQGUD XQ DFRUG VHFUHW FX $QWDQWD I U FD JXYHUQXO URPkQ V ILH LQIRUPDW VDX FRQVXOWDW *HVWXO JXYHUQXOXL GH OD 5RPD úL DWLWXGLQHD VWDWHORU FDUH FRPSXQHDX $QWDQWD DX DWUDV úL PDL PXOW DWHQ LD SULPXOXL PLQLVWUX URPkQ ,,&%U WLDQX DVXSUD SUXGHQ HL FX FDUH WUHEXLD V DF LRQH]HvQUHOD LLOHFXYLLWRULLDOLD L 1RLQHJRFLHULFX$QWDQWDÌQSULP YDUDDQXOXL FkQGVWDWHOH $QWDQWHL DX I FXW 5RPkQLHL QRL SURSXQHUL GH FRODERUDUH PLOLWDU ,,&%U WLDQX VD DU WDW vQ SULQFLSLX GH DFRUG vQV D I FXW FXQRVFXW DSULOLHPDL F 5RPkQLDQXYDLQWUDvQU ]ERLvQDLQWHGHDLVH
3HODUJ 5RPkQLDvQSULPXOU ]ERLPRQGLDOYROSS /D VFXUW WLPS GXS vQFKHLHUHD DFRUGXOXL ELODWHUDO FRORQHOXO 9DVLOH 5XGHDQX VD GHSODVDW OD 5RPD XQGH D I FXW FXQRVFXW GRULQ D JXYHUQXOXL URPkQ GH D VH FRQVXOWD vQ WRDWH SUREOHPHOH FX JXYHUQXO LWDOLDQ úL D LQWUD FRQFRPLWHQWvQU ]ERLGHSDUWHD$QWDQWHL&XDFHODúLSULOHMJHQHUDOXOURPkQD DERUGDWSUREOHPDDSURYL]LRQ ULLDUPDWHLURPkQHFXDUPDPHQWúLPXQL LL &XWRDWHDFHVWHDUHJHOH,WDOLHLDLQWHUYHQLWOD3DULVúL3HWURJUDGSHQWUX DFFHSWDUHDUHYHQGLF ULORUURPkQHúWL
JDUDQWDGHF WUH$QWDQW XQLUHDFX5RPkQLDD%XFRYLQHLSkQ OD3UXWD 7UDQVLOYDQLHLúL%DQDWXOXLvQvQWUHJLPHSUHFXPúLDXQXLWHULWRULXORFXLW GH URPkQL vQ YHVW SkQ vQ DSURSLHUH GH 6HJKHGLQ úL GH D L VH DVLJXUD PXQL LLOHQHFHVDUH ÌQFRQWH[WXOvQFDUHLQWUDUHD,WDOLHLvQU ]ERLHUDFDúL DVLJXUDW JXYHUQXO UXV QX VD PDL DU WDW vQV LQWHUHVDW GH DQJDMDUHD LPHGLDW D 5RPkQLHL vQ OXSW FL GRDU vQ PHQ LQHUHD QHXWUDOLW LL úL SULYDUHD*HUPDQLHLGHLPSRUWXULOHURPkQHúWL ÌQIUkQJHULOH vQUHJLVWUDWH GH WUXSHOH UXVH vQ *DOL LD úL SUHVLXQLOH H[HUFLWDWH GH JXYHUQHOH RFFLGHQWDOH GH FHO IUDQFH] vQ VSHFLDO DX GHWHUPLQDW JXYHUQXO GH OD 3HWHUVEXUJ V VH GHFODUH GH DFRUG PDL LXQLH FXUHVWDELOLUHDIURQWLHUHLGLQ%XFRYLQDSH3UXWvQVFKLPEXO LQWU ULL LPHGLDWH D 5RPkQLHL vQ U ]ERL PRGDOLW LOH GH DSURYL]LRQDUH FX DUPDPHQWúLPXQL LLXUPkQGDILVWDELOLWHXOWHULRUvPSUHXQ FX)UDQ DúL 0DUHD%ULWDQLH 5 VSXQVXO JXYHUQXOXL URPkQ D IRVW GDW OD LXQLH FkQG ,,&%U WLDQXDSUHFL]DWF 5RPkQLDHUDJDWDÄV VHDQJDMH]HGHILQLWLY´ vPSRWULYD $XVWUR8QJDULHL vQ FHO PXOW GRX OXQL GH OD VHPQDUHD FRQYHQ LHLSROLWLFHFXVWDWHOH$QWDQWHLúLDFRQYHQ LHLPLOLWDUHFDUHWUHEXLD V SUHFL]H]H PRGDOLW LOH GH FRRSHUDUH vQ OXSW úL GH DSURYL]LRQDUH FX PXQL LL /D LQVLVWHQ HOH JXYHUQXOXL IUDQFH] 3HWHUVEXUJXO VD GHFODUDW GH DFRUG LXOLHDXJXVW FXvQFKHLHUHDFHORUGRX FRQYHQ LLFHUXWH GHSULPXOPLQLVWUXURPkQFXXUP WRDUHOHFRQGL LL VLVWDUHDDSURYL]LRQ ULORU F WUH VWDWHOH 3XWHULORU &HQWUDOH 5XVLD XUPkQG V YHJKH]H DVXSUD DFHVWHLREOLJD LL WULPLWHUHDXQXLGHOHJDWPLOLWDUURPkQOD0DUHOH&DUWLHU *HQHUDO UXV SHQWUX HODERUDUHD FRQYHQ LHL PLOLWDUH vQ FDUH V VH SUHYDG GDWD úL FRQGL LLOH DQJDM ULL DUPDWHL URPkQH vQ U ]ERL 1RXO FRQWH[W SROL WLFRPLOLWDUDGHWHUPLQDWJXYHUQXOURPkQV VROLFLWHDPkQDUHDDQJDM ULL
5RPkQLDvQSULPXOU ]ERLPRQGLDOYROS /D DSULOLH ,WDOLD D VHPQDW OD /RQGUD XQ WUDWDW VHFUHW FX $QWDQWD D GHQXQ DW OD PDL WUDWDWXO FX 3XWHULOH &HQWUDOH GHFODUkQG U ]ERL $XVWUR8QJDULHLODPDL /D PDL 5D\PRQG3RLQFDUpSUHúHGLQWHOH)UDQ HLDDSUHFLDW F VSULMLQXO5RPkQLHLFRQVWLWXLDÄRQHFHVLWDWHSHQWUXDOLD LLQRúWUL´ 3HVWHFkWHYD]LOHDUHGXVDFHVWWHUPHQODFLQFLV SW PkQL ÌQIUkQJHULOHGH]DVWUXRDVHGHSHIURQWúLLPLQHQWDDQJDMDUHD%XOJDULHL GHSDUWHD3XWHULORU&HQWUDOH IDSWXODYHDV VHSURGXF ODDXJXVWVHSWHP EULH SULQVHPQDUHDWUDWDWXOXLGHDOLDQ úLGHDQJDMDUHDWUXSHORUEXOJDUHvQ OXSWHROXQ PDLWkU]LX
ULL vQ U ]ERL IDSW DFFHSWDW LXOLH DXJXVW GH VWDWHOH $QWDQWHL SULQ 1RWD UHGDFWDW GH ORUGXO (GZDUG *UH\ PLQLVWUXO GH ([WHUQHEULWDQLF +RW UkW V SURPRYH]H R SROLWLF DQWDQWRILO vQ SRILGD YLFWRULLORU vQUHJLVWUDWH SH IURQW GH DUPDWHOH 3XWHULORU &HQWUDOH ,,& %U WLDQX D GHFODUDW vQQRLHPEULH PLQLVWUXOXLEULWDQLFOD%XFXUHúWLF 5RPkQLD YDSHUPLWHWUDQ]LWDUHDWHULWRULXOXLURPkQHVFGHF WUHWUXSHOHUXVHSHQWUXD YHQL vQ DMXWRUXO 6HUELHL GDF PDULOH SXWHUL VH DQJDMDX V RIHUH JDUDQ LL vPSRWULYDHYHQWXDOHORUUHSUHVDOLLJHUPDQHDXVWURXQJDUHúLEXOJDUHFDUH V ILH FRQVHPQDWH vQWUR FRQYHQ LH VSHFLDO &RQFRPLWHQW LQWUDUHD 5RPkQLHL vQ 5 ]ERL D IRVW FRQGL LRQDW GH GLVORFDUHD D GH PLOLWDULIUDQFH]LúLHQJOH]LvQ]RQD6DORQLFGHGHFODQúDUHDXQHLRIHQVLYH UXVHúWL vQ *DOL LD úL %XFRYLQD GH PDVDUHD GH WUXSH UXVH vQ %DVDUDELD SHQWUXDILvQP VXU V GHVFXUDMH]H%XOJDULDúLV LQWHUYLQ HYHQWXDOvQ 'REURJHD ÌQDIDU GHYDJLSURPLVLXQLDOLD LLQXDXRIHULWQLPLFFRQFUHW DUXO 1LFRODHDO,,OHDUHFXQRVFkQGODVIkUúLWXODQXOXL F DUILRJUHúHDO DQJDMDUHD5RPkQLHLvQU ]ERLvQFRQGL LLOHvQFDUHDUPDWDUXV QXHUDvQ P VXU V UHLDRIHQVLYD/DDFHDVWDVDXDG XJDWGLYHUJHQ HOHIUDQFRUXVH SULYLQGDQJDMDUHD5RPkQLHLvQOXSW 5HWLFHQ D ÌQDOWXOXL FRPDQGDPHQW UXV GH D WULPLWH GH PLOLWDUL vQ 'REURJHD SHQWUX D VXV LQH HIRUWXO DUPDWHL URPkQH vQ FD] GH DWDF EXOJDU D I FXW FD vQ SULP YDUD DQXOXL WUDWDWLYHOH
5RPkQLDvQSULPXOU ]ERLPRQGLDOYROS ÌQ WLPS FH JHQHUDOXO UXV 09 $OH[HHY úHIXO 0DUHOXL &DUWLHU *HQHUDO UXVGRUHDFD5RPkQLDV úLPHQ LQ QHXWUDOLWDWHDSHQWUXDQXGLVSHUVDSUHDPXOW WUXSHOHUXVHJHQHUDOXOIUDQFH]-RVHI-RIIUHXUP UHDFXLQVLVWHQ vQFRQWH[WXOvQ FDUH WUXSHOH JHUPDQH DVDOWDVHU 9HUGXQXO OD IHEUXDULH DWUDJHUHD úL FKLDU REOLJDUHD DFHVWHLD V LQWUH vQ U ]ERL /D UkQGXL SUHúHGLQWHOH 5D\PRQG 3RLQFDUpVHDGUHVDDVWIHO DUXOXL1LFRODHDO,,OHDODIHEUXDULHPDUWLH Ä)UDQ DHVWHGLVSXV V IDF WRWFHGHSLQGHGHHDSHQWUXDGHWHUPLQDLQWUDUHDvQ DF LXQHD5RPkQLHL´5 VSXQ]kQGXL DUXOG GHDDVLJXU ULF ÄYDIDFHWRWFHHD FHvLYDVWDvQSXWHUHSHQWUXDDSODQDGLILFXOW LOHFDUHRSUHVFvQFKHLHUHDDFRUGXOXL PLOLWDUFX5RPkQLD´
URPkQRUXVHV LQWUHvQLPSDVI U DILvQWUHUXSWHvQV (OHDYHDXV ILH UHOXDWH vQ YDU vQ FRQWH[WXO SUHVLXQLORU H[HUFLWDWH GH )UDQ D úL $QJOLD DWkW DVXSUD 5RPkQLHL FkW úL DVXSUD 5XVLHL úL DYHUVPHQWXOXL RILFLDOLW LORU GH OD 3HWHUVEXUJ LXQLH LXOLH F GDF JXYHUQXO URPkQ QX DQJDMD DUD vQ U ]ERL XUPDX D IL DQXODWH WRDWH vQ HOHJHULOHDQWHULRDUHLQFOXVLYFHOHWHULWRULDOH ÌQ DFHVWH FRQGL LL ,,& %U WLDQX D I FXW FXQRVFXW F 5RPkQLD YD LQWUD vQ U ]ERL QXPDL vPSRWULYD $XVWUR8QJDULHL vQ XUP WRDUHOH FRQGL LL DOLD LLV LDVLJXUHRDSURYL]LRQDUHFRQVWDQW FXDUPDPHQWúL PXQL LL SH vQWUHJXO SDUFXUV DO U ]ERLXOXL SULPXOWUHQFXPXQL LL WRQH XUPkQG D IL OD JUDQL vQ ]LXD PRELOL] ULL V GHFODQúH]H R RIHQVLY FRQFHQWULF DUPDWD UXV V DVLJXUH vQ *DOL LD úL %XFRYLQD FHO SX LQ DOLQLDPHQWXO GLQ LXOLH V FRQFHQWUH]H vQ %DVDUDELD úL 'REURJHDFHOSX LQGHRDPHQL WUXSHOHDOLDWHV UHLDRIHQVLYD SHIURQWXOGHOD6DORQLF V QXVHvQFKHLHSDFHVHSDUDW ÌQXUPDXQRUQRLSUHVLXQLIUDQFH]HUHYHQGLF ULOHURPkQHúWLDXIRVW DFFHSWDWHGHJXYHUQXOGHOD3HWHUVEXUJODDXJXVW ILLQGVHPQD WHOD%XFXUHúWLWUDWDWXOSROLWLFúLFRQYHQ LDPLOLWDU 3UHYHGHULOH WUDWDWXOXL SROLWLF úL DOH &RQYHQ LHL PLOLWDUH 7UDWDWXO SROLWLF JDUDQWD LQWHJULWDWHD WHULWRULDO D 5RPkQLHL úL SUHYHGHD LQWUDUHD DFHVWHLDvQU ]ERLvPSRWULYD$XVWUR8QJDULHLSkQ ODDXJXVW FHOH SDWUX SXWHUL ± )UDQ D $QJOLD 5XVLD úL ,WDOLD ± UHFXQRVFkQG GUHSWXO 5RPkQLHLGHDXQLWHULWRULLOHORFXLWHGHURPkQLGLQ$XVWUR8QJDULD$UW
ÌQFDGUXOSROLWLFLLSUXGHQWHSHFDUHRGXFHD,,&%U WLDQXDGHFODUDW XUP WRDUHOH OD DSULOLH PDL ÄÌQ FH SULYHúWH LQWUDUHD 5RPkQLHL vQ FRQIOLFWXOHXURSHDQSULQFLSLLOHPHOHGLUHFWRDUHVXQWPHUHXDFHOHDSHFDUHOH DPH[SXVGHMD4DGUXSOHL$OLDQ H 1XYUHDXV IDFU ]ERLSHWHULWRULXOPHX 1X YUHDX V IDF U ]ERL SH WHULWRULXO EXOJDULORU 1X YUHDX V IDF U ]ERL vQDLQWHGHDYHGHDFXRFKLLPHLFHHDFHPLVDSURPLVGHDDYHDPXQL LLFDUH vPL VXQW QHFHVDUH úL WUXSH UXVH FDUH vPL VXQW LQGLVSHQVDELOH vQ 'REURJHD SHQWUXDP SURWHMDFRQWUDXQHLDJUHVLXQLEXOJDUHvQWLPSFHHXYRLILRFXSDW vQ DOW SDUWH 9RL LQWUD vQ U ]ERL DWXQFL FkQG YRL DYHD úDQVH GH D QX IL ]GURELW´
VWDELOHD YLLWRDUHOH JUDQL H DOH 5RPkQLHL DUW SUHYHGHD REOLJD LD DPEHORUS U LGHDQXvQFKHLDSDFHVHSDUDW LDUDUWHJDOLWDWHDvQGUHSWXUL D5RPkQLHLFXVWDWHOH$QWDQWHLvQWLPSXOSUHOLPLQDULLORUúLWUDWDWLYHORUGH SDFH &RQYHQ LDPLOLWDU VWDELOHDF 5RPkQLDYDSDUWLFLSDODU ]ERLQXPDL vPSRWULYD $XVWUR8QJDULHL SUHYHGHD FRQGL LLOH FRRSHU ULL PLOLWDUH úL QHFHVLWDWHD GHFL]LHL FRPXQH vQ FD]XO vQFKHLHULL XQXL HYHQWXDO DUPLVWL LX 3ULQVHPQDUHDDFHVWXLGRFXPHQWDOLD LLUHFXQRúWHDXLQGHSHQGHQ DRUJDQL ]DWRULF úL GH FRPDQGDPHQW D DUPDWHL URPkQH FRQ LQXWXO úL RULHQW ULOH SODQXOXLGHFDPSDQLHURPkQvúLOXDXDQJDMDPHQWXOGHDVSULMLQLRIHQVLYD DUPDWHLURPkQHvQ7UDQVLOYDQLD DF LRQkQGHQHUJLFSHIURQWXODXVWULDFFX WUHLGLYL]LL SUHFXPúLRSHUD LLOHGHSHFXUVXO'XQ ULLúLGLQ'REURJHDGH DGHFODQúDRSXWHUQLF RIHQVLY vQ%DOFDQLSHIURQWXOGHOD6DORQLFFXRSW ]LOH vQDLQWH GH LQWUDUHD 5RPkQLHL vQ U ]ERL úL GH D IXUQL]D FRQWUDFRVW PXQL LLúLPDWHULDOGHU ]ERL WRQHSH]L 'HRVHELW GH LPSRUWDQW SHQWUX 5RPkQLD D IRVW úL IDSWXO F $OLD LL UHFXQRúWHDXGUHSWXOURPkQLORUGHDSDUWLFLSDSHED] GHHJDOLWDWHODWRDWH FRQVI WXLULOH GH FRPDQGDPHQW FDUH DYHDX FD URO V GHFLG GLUHF LLOH JHQHUDOH GH DF LXQH SH WHDWUHOH GH DF LXQL PLOLWDUH GLQ (XURSD 3HQWUX DVLJXUDUHDFRODERU ULLúLFRRSHU ULLHILFLHQWH5RPkQLDúLSXWHULOH$QWDQWHL
$FHVWHDHUDXGHILQLWHDVWIHO Ä/LQLDGHGHPDUFD LHYDvQFHSHSH3UXW vQWUXQSXQFWDODFWXDOHLIURQWLHUHvQWUH5XVLDúL5RPkQLDvQDSURSLHUHGH1RXD 6XOL úLYDXUFDGLQQRXGHDOXQJXODFHVWXLIOXYLXSkQ ODIURQWLHUD*DOL LHLOD FRQIOXHQ D3UXWXOXLFX&HUHPXúÌQFRQWLQXDUHHDYDXUPDIURQWLHUD*DOL LHLúLD %XFRYLQHLúLFHDD*DOL LHLúLD8QJDULHLSkQ ODSXQFWXO6WRJFRWD GH DLFLHDYDXUPDOLQLDGHVHSDUD LHDDSHORU7LVDúL9LúHXSHQWUXDDWLQJH7LVDvQ VHFWRUXO7UHEXVDvQDPRQWHGHSXQFWXOXQGHHDVHXQHúWHFX9LúHX'LQDFHVW SXQFWHDYDFRERUvSHWDOYHJXO7LVHLSkQ ODNPvQDYDOGHFRQIOXHQ DVDFX 6RPHúXOO VkQGVDWXO9DVDUVQDPHQ\5RPkQLHL(DYDFRQWLQXDDSRLvQGLUHF LD VXGVXGYHVWSkQ ODXQSXQFWVLWXDWODNPHVWGHRUDúXO'HEUH LQ'LQDFHVW SXQFWHDYDDWLQJH&ULúXOODNPvQDYDOGHFRQIOXHQ DFHORUGRLDIOXHQ LDLV L &ULúXO $OE úL &ULúXO 5HSHGH (D VH YD vPSUHXQD DSRL FX 7LVD OD vQ O LPHD VDWXOXL $OJ\R OD QRUG GH 6HJKHGLQ WUHFkQG OD YHVW GH VDWHOH 2URVKD]D úL %HNHUVDPVRQODNPGHFDUHHDYDIRUPDRPLF FXUE 'HOD$OJ\ROLQLDYD FRERUvSHWDOYHJXO7LVHLSkQ ODFRQIOXHQ DDFHVWHLDFX'XQ UHDúLvQVIkUúLWYD XUPDWDOYHJXO'XQ ULLSkQ ODDFWXDODIURQWLHU D5RPkQLHL´ $SXG5RPkQLDvQ SULPXOU ]ERLPRQGLDOYROS
XUPDX V GHWDúH]H UHFLSURF SH OkQJ PDULOH FDUWLHUH JHQHUDOH PLVLXQL PLOLWDUHGHOHJ WXU úLVWDWPDMRU $WkW WUDWDWXO SROLWLF FkW úL FRQYHQ LD PLOLWDU DX UHSUH]HQWDW XQ VXFFHV SROLWLF GHRVHELW SHQWUX GLSORPD LD URPkQ vQ JHQHUDO úL SHQWUX SULPXOPLQLVWUX,,&%U WLDQXvQVSHFLDO0DUHD%ULWDQLH)UDQ D5XVLD úL,WDOLDDFFHSWkQGDSURDSHWRDWHUHYHQGLF ULOHURPkQHúWLLQFOXVLYGUHSWXO SRSRUXOXLURPkQODUHvQWUHJLUHQD LRQDO úLQRLOHJUDQL HÌQDIDUDRE LQHULL FRQWULEX LHLURPkQHúWLODU ]ERLILHFDUHvQV GLQWUHPDULOHSXWHULDYL]DWúL DOWHRELHFWLYHFRUHVSXQ] WRDUHSODQXULORULPHGLDWHúLGHSHUVSHFWLY $QJOLD ±FRQVWLWXLUHDXQXLREVWDFROvQFDOHDH[SDQVLXQLL5XVLHLvQ%DOFDQL)UDQ D± UHDOL]DUHD XQXL REVWDFRO vQ FDOHD SHQHWUD LHL JHUPDQH vQ %DOFDQL ,WDOLD ± RE LQHUHD XQXL DOLDW vPSRWULYD VODYLORU GLQ %DOFDQL 5XVLD ± VFRDWHUHD 5RPkQLHLGHVXELQIOXHQ DJHUPDQ $QJDMDUHD 5RPkQLHL vQ U ]ERL 3DUWLFLSDUHD URPkQHDVF OD SULPD FRQIODJUD LH PRQGLDO D DYXW XQ FDUDFWHU GUHSW GH HOLEHUDUH SURIXQG QD LRQDO úL SRSXODU GHFODQúDUHD RSHUD LLORU PLOLWDUH vQ SRGLúXO WUDQVLOYDQ GHWHUPLQkQGXQSXWHUQLFHFRXvQ DU úLvQWRDWHWHULWRULLOHORFXLWHGHURPkQL SURYRFkQG XQ LPSDFW GHRVHELW vQ HYROX LD HYHQLPHQWHORU SROLWLFRPLOLWDUH LQWHUQD LRQDOH IDYRUDELO VWDWHORU $QWDQWHL ,PHGLDW vQV DUD VD DIODW vQ FRQIOLFWúLFX*HUPDQLDFDUHLDGHFODUDWU ]ERLODDXJXVW FX 7XUFLD DXJXVW úL%XOJDULD DXJXVWVHSWHPEULHGXS FHDFHDVWD DWDFDVHvQ'REURJHD VLWXD LD ULLvQU XW LQGXVHúLSULQGLVORFDUHDGHF WUH 3XWHULOH &HQWUDOH D XQRU LPSRUWDQWH IRU H PLOLWDUH SH IURQWXO URPkQHVF GDWRULW OLSVHLGHUHDF LHDVWDWHORU$QWDQWHL 'HVI úXUDW vQ FRQIRUPLWDWH FX SUHYHGHULOH SODQXOXL GH FDPSDQLH RIHQVLYD VWUDWHJLF vQ 7UDQVLOYDQLD D IRVW vQFXQXQDW LQL LDO FX VXFFHV WUXSHOH URPkQH GLQ IRU D FRPEDWLY D ULL DMXQJkQG SH FXUVXO PLMORFLXDO0XUHúXOXLúLSHFHOVXSHULRUDO2OWXOXL 6LWXD LD GLILFLO GH SH IURQWXO GH VXG RIHQVLYD LQDPLF GLQ 'REURJHD vQIUkQJHUHD GH OD 7XUWXFDLD HúHFXO PDQHYUHL GHOD) PkQGD SHULFROXOFHSODQDDVXSUD&DSLWDOHLHWF LQDFWLYLWDWHDDOLD LORUSHIURQWXO GHOD6DORQLFQHUHVSHFWDUHDLQWHJUDO DDQJDMDPHQWHORUOXDWHGHDFHúWLDúL DO LIDFWRULDXI FXWFDvQDLQWDUHDvQSRGLúXOWUDQVLOYDQV ILHRSULW WUXSHOH URPkQHILLQGUHVSLQVHDSRLvQWUHF WRULOHPRQWDQHXQGHDXIRVWDQJDMDWH DPSOHúLDSULJLE W OLLFRQWLQXDWHODVXGGHPXQ LúLvQ'REURJHD &X WRDWH F R PDUH SDUWH D WHULWRULXOXL QD LRQDO SHVWH NPS'REURJHD 2OWHQLD 0XQWHQLD LQFOXVLY &DSLWDOD FX SHVWH PLOL
RDQHGHORFXLWRUL DIRVWRFXSDW GHF WUHLQDPLF3XWHULOH&HQWUDOHQXDX UHXúLW V VFRDW 5RPkQLD GLQ U ]ERL GHRDUHFH UHJHOH JXYHUQXO DXWR ULW LOH LQVWLWX LLOH SULQFLSDOH DOH VWDWXOXL DUPDWD URPkQ úL R SDUWH GLQ SRSXOD LHVDXUHWUDVvQ0ROGRYD vQFHSkQGFXQRLHPEULHGHFHPEULH XQGHIURQWXODIRVWVWDELOL]DW 5HGXV OD WHULWRULXO 0ROGRYHL GLQWUH &DUSD L úL 3UXW 5RPkQLD D FRQWLQXDW V U PkQ SXWHUH EHOLJHUDQW KRW UkW úL UH]LVWH úL V UHLD OD PRPHQWXO RSRUWXQ DF LXQLOH RIHQVLYH HOLEHUDWRDUH GHúL WHULWRULXO OLEHU UHGXVFDVXSUDID VHDIODvQWURVLWXD LHH[WUHPGHGLILFLO PDUHDJORPH UDUHGHLQVWLWX LLvQWUHSULQGHULHYDFXDWHDUPDWDUHGXV FLUFDGH PLOLWDUL SHVWH PLOLRDQH GH UHIXJLD L DSURDSH GH PLOLWDUL UXúLHSLGHPLHWLIRVH[DQWHPDWLFúLDOWHEROLFDUHDXSURYRFDWVXWHGHPLL GHSLHUGHULGHYLH LRPHQHúWL &X WRDWH DFHVWHD UHJHOH )HUGLQDQG , JXYHUQXO úL ÌQDOWXO FRPDQGDPHQW URPkQ DX GHFODQúDW R DPSO DF LXQH GH UHRUJDQL]DUH D DUPDWHL FX VSULMLQXO 0LVLXQLL 0LOLWDUH )UDQFH]H FRQGXV GH JHQHUDOXO +0 %HUWKHORW úL GH SUHJ WLUH D YLLWRDUHORU RSHUD LL PLOLWDUH RIHQVLYH 3ODQXULOH DX IRVW LQIOXHQ DWH vQV GH HYHQLPHQWHOH GLQ 5XVLD GLQ IHEUXDULHPDUWLH FkQGDIRVWvQO WXUDWUHJLPXO DULVWQRXOJXYHUQúL Ä6WDYND´ OLPLWkQG úL FKLDU DPkQkQG GHFODQúDUHD DF LXQLORU RIHQVLYH GH DPSORDUH ÌQ ILQDO FRQIRUP 3ODQXOXL GH FDPSDQLH SHQWUX VD GHVI úXUDW RSHUD LD RIHQVLY GH OD 0 U úWL LXOLH ± LXOLH DXJXVW ILQDOL]DW FX R YLFWRULH VWU OXFLWRDUH FX LPSRUWDQWH XUP ULVWUDWHJLFHSHQWUXGHVI úXUDUHDXOWHULRDU DFDPSDQLHLSHIURQWXO URPkQHVFÌQWUHDFHVWHDVDVLWXDWúLGHFL]LDFRPDQGDPHQWXOXLLQDPLF GHDVFRDWH5RPkQLDGLQU ]ERLSULQGRX ORYLWXULVWUDWHJLFHRULHQWDWH FRQYHUJHQW GLQVSUH VXG úL QRUG UH]XOWkQG DVWIHO SHQWUX URPkQL RSHUD LLOHGHDS UDUHGHOD0 U úHúWL LXOLHDXJXVW± DXJXVW úL 2LWX] LXOLH DXJXVW ± DXJXVW DPEHOH ILQDOL]DWHPDJLVWUDO
5HIHULQGXVHODDFHVWOXFUXJHQHUDOXO/XGHQGRUIIFRQVHPQD Ä1RLDP E WXW DUPDWD URPkQ GDU QDP SXWXW VR QLPLFLP &X WRDW YLFWRULD QRDVWU DVXSUD DUPDWHL URPkQH QRL HUDP PDL VODEL FD vQDLQWH vQ FHHD FH SULYHúWH GHVI úXUDUHDJHQHUDO DU ]ERLXOXL´
ÌQVHPQ WDWHD VWU OXFLWHORU YLFWRULL URPkQHúWL GLQ YDUD DQXOXL LHVHPDLELQHvQHYLGHQ GDF OHUDSRUW PODSODQXULOHJHUPDQR UXVRDXVWURXQJDUH GLQ FDGUXO GLVFX LLORU VHFUHWH SHQWUX vQFKHLHUHD S FLLFDUHSUHYHGHDXvPS U LUHD5RPkQLHLvQWUH$XVWUR8QJDULD5XVLD úL %XOJDULD DVWIHO vQFkW DFHDVWD V U PkQ FRQIRUP DSUHFLHULL OXL 2WWRNDU&]HUQLQÄXQVWDWPLFX GXS PRGHOXO0RQDFRXOXL´ODJXULOH 'XQ ULL 2FXSD LD 3XWHULORU &HQWUDOH ÌQ XUPD vQIUkQJHULORU PLOLWDUH vQUH JLVWUDWHSHIURQWvQ úLDUHWUDJHULLJXYHUQXOXLúLDXWRULW LORUURPkQH vQ 0ROGRYD vQ WHULWRULXO RFXSDW GH OD VXG GH 6LUHW &RPDQGDPHQWXO 0DFNHQVHQ FDUH VW SkQHD WUHL S WULPL GLQ VXSUDID D 5RPkQLHL D WUHFXW UDSLG OD VXERUGRQDUHD DXWRULW LORU ORFDOH úL OD H[SORDWDUHD ULL FRQ GXFHUHD HIHFWLY D DGPLQLVWUD LHL GH RFXSD LH ILLQG vQFUHGLQ DW OD GHFHPEULH JHQHUDOXOXL7OIIYRQ7VFKHSSHXQG:HLGHQEDFKFDUHD FRODERUDWFXFkWHXQUHSUH]HQWDQWDO$XVWUR8QJDULHL%XOJDULHLúL7XUFLHL 'LQSXQFWGHYHGHUHDGPLQLVWUDWLYWHULWRULXOURPkQHVFRFXSDWD IRVW vPS U LW vQ SDWUX ]RQH PLOLWDUH WHULWRULXO DGPLQLVWUD LHL JHUPDQH 2OWHQLD úL 0XQWHQLD PDL SX LQ MXGH HOH %X] X %U LOD úL 5kPQLFX 6 UDW ]RQDHWDSHORU vQOXQJXOUkXOXL%X] XGHOD&XUEXUD&DUSD LORU SkQ OD 'XQ UH FX URO GH DSURYL]LRQDUH D WUXSHORU GH SH IURQW ]RQD $UPDWHL GHRSHUD LL MXGH HOH%X] X3XWQDúL%U LOD 'REURJHD FX DGPLQLVWUD LHVHSDUDW FRQGXV VXEIRUP GHFRQGRPLQLXPJHUPDQR DXVWURXQJDUEXOJDUúLWXUF
5HIHULQGXVH OD DFHOHDúL SODQXUL DQH[LRQLVWH 2WWRNDU &]HUQLQ PDL FRQVHPQDXUP WRDUHOHvQWUXQ0HPRULXWULPLVvQPDL vPS UDWXOXL&DURO Ä 1RL WUHEXLH V RE LQHP 5RPkQLD 9RP OXD 0XQWHQLD úL WRDW 0ROGRYD SkQ OD 6LUHW3DUWHDGHU V ULWD0ROGRYHLYRLPVRRIHULP5XVLHLúLvQDFHDVWDY GHXR XúXUDUHDS FLL'REURJHDYHFKHWUHEXLHV UHYLQ %XOJDULHLLDUPLFDSRU LXQHFH PDLU PkQHRO V P5RPkQLHL&XDFHDVWDvPSOLQLPvQGRLWXOVFRSFDV YkUkPR SDQ vQWUH5XVLDúL%XOJDULDúLV QHDS U PVW SkQLUHDJXULORU'XQ ULL´ 3HODUJ 5RPkQLDvQSULPXOU ]ERLPRQGLDOYROSS
ÌQFHLGRLDQLGHRFXSD LHJHUPDQ DYX LDQD LRQDO DIRVWMHIXLW VLVWHPDWLF LDU SRSXOD LD OLSVLW GH FHOH PDL HOHPHQWDUH GUHSWXUL FHW HQHúWL 7RDWHDFHVWHDDXGHFODQúDWúLLQWHQVLILFDWOXSWDURPkQLORUSHQWUX DúL UHFkúWLJD OLEHUWDWHD úL vQ ILQDO DúL GHV YkUúL XQLWDWHD QD LRQDO VWDWDO $úWHSWkQGPRPHQWXOUHLQWU ULLvQOXSW DO WXULGHDOLD LDXWRULW LOH URPkQHDXGHVI úXUDW±VXEVWULFWDVXSUDYHJKHUHDLQDPLFXOXL±RLQWHQV DFWLYLWDWHGHFRQVHUYDUHDIRU HLGHDS UDUHD ULLúLGHSUHJ WLUHvQYHGHUHD
2UJDQHOHVSHFLDOHGHFRQGXFHUHDDFHVWRU]RQH 6WDWXOPDMRUHFRQRPLF &RPLVLDHFRQRPLF PL[W GLQ5RPkQLD3ROL LDDGPLQLVWUDWLY PLOLWDU úD úLDX SUHOXDWDWULEX LLOHFXUDSLGLWDWHHPL kQGRUGRQDQ HFXFDUDFWHUREOLJDWRULXXUPDWH vQFD]GHQHvQGHSOLQLUHGHVDQF LXQLDVSUH DPHQ]LvQFKLVRDUHúLFKLDUSHGHDSVD FDSLWDO WUHFkQG FRQFRPLWHQW OD H[SORDWDUHD HFRQRPLF D WHULWRULXOXL URPkQHVF RFXSDW OD SUHOXDUHD ERJ LLORU úL H[SHGLHUHD ORU vQ *HUPDQLD FX SUHF GHUH OD LQWHQVLILFDUHD SURGXF LHL vQ VSHFLDO vQ GRPHQLXO DJUDU SHWUROLIHU úL FDUERQLIHU SULQIRORVLUHDPXQFLLIRU DWHúLDSUL]RQLHULORUGHU ]ERL úLODWULPLWHUHDEXQXULORU vQ 5HLFK &RQFRPLWHQW DX IRVW VHFKHVWUDWH ULGLFDWH úL WUDQVSRUWDWH WRW vQ *HUPDQLDLQVWDOD LLLQGXVWULDOHPDWHULLSULPHúLSURGXVHILQLWHÌQFDGUXODFHOXLDúL SURFHV GH H[SORDWDUH HFRQRPLF D 5RPkQLHL DX IRVW KU QLWH WUXSHOH RSHUDWLYH DIODWH vQ DU GH RDPHQL vQ 7HULWRULXO URPkQHVF D PDL IRVW H[SORDWDW úL SULQ HPLWHUHD GH QRL EDQFQRWH OHL GH RFXSD LH GH F WUH %DQFD *HUPDQ GLQ%XFXUHúWL GHYHQLW vQUHDOLWDWHRILOLDO DE QFLLJHQHUDOHÄ'LVNRQWR *HVHOOVFKDIW´GLQ%HUOLQ I U DFRSHULUHvQDXUIDSWFDUHDGH]RUJDQL]DWFLUFXOD LH PRQHWDU úL D DFFHQWXDW LQIOD LD vQ SHULRDGD SRVWEHOLF ÌQ DFWLYLWDWHD ORU WUXSHOH JHUPDQH DX LQWHUYHQLW EUXWDO úL vQ YLD D SXEOLF D DXWRULW LORU úL FHW HQLORU RUDúHORU úL VDWHORU URPkQHúWL VXVSHQGkQG WHPSRUDU FXUVXULOH GLQ vQY PkQWXO HOHPHQWDUPHGLXúLVXSHULRUúLDXUHFKL]L LRQDWORFDOXULOHúFROLORUúLIDFXOW LORU DXHYDFXDWU QL LLúLEROQDYLLURPkQLGLQVSLWDOHOHURPkQHúWLWUDQVIRUPkQGXOHvQ OD]DUHWHJHUPDQH&RQFRPLWHQWSRSXOD LDFLYLO GHODDQLvQVXVDIRVWREOLJDW V VHSUH]LQWHOXQDUSHQWUXFRQWUROúLYL] ODELURXULVSHFLDOHvQFD]FRQWUDUILLQG VXSXV OD SODWD XQHL DPHQ]L GH GH P UFL VDX OD vQFKLVRDUH GH SkQ OD OXQL3HQWUX D VXSUDYHJKHD FkW PDL ELQH DFWLYLWDWHD SRSXOD LHL URPkQHúWL úL D FHQ]XUD SUHVD WLS ULWXULOH ILOPHOH úL SLHVHOH GH WHDWUX DGPLQLVWUD LD PLOLWDU JHUPDQ DGLVSXVGHXQDSDUDWSROL LHQHVFXUEDQúLUXUDOFDUHDDF LRQDWLQFOXVLY vQ GRPHQLXO SROLWLF VSLRQkQG DUHVWkQG úL MXGHFkQG vQ WULEXQDOH VSHFLDOH SHUVRDQHOH FDUH VH RSXQHDX RFXSD LHL VDX DYHDX R DWLWXGLQH úL PDQLIHVW UL DQWDQWRILOH 3HQWUX SHUVRDQHOH FLYLOH DUHVWDWH SUL]RQLHULL GH U ]ERL URPkQL úL D DOWRUFDWHJRULLDXIRVWFRQVWLWXLWHúDSWHODJ UHSULQFLSDOHúLVHFXQGDUH
vPSOLQLULL GH]LGHUDWHORU QD LRQDOH SUHY ]XWH vQ WUDWDWXO SROLWLF GLQ ÌQWUH IRUPHOH GH UH]LVWHQ ID GH RFXSD LD JHUPDQ VDX QXP UDW QHVXSXQHUHD OD LQVWLWXLUHD PXQFLL IRU DWH PDMRULWDWHD FHORU GH SHUVRDQH DPHQGDWH DUHVWDWH VDX FRQGDPQDWH OD vQFKLVRDUH I FkQGXVH YLQRYDWH GH DFHVW OXFUX VDERWDUHD SURGXF LHL úL DSURYL]LRQ ULL WUXSHORU JHUPDQHLQFHQGLHUHDXQRUGHSR]LWHVDXXQLW LHFRQRPLFRLQGXVWULDOHLP SRUWDQWH SHQWUX LQDPLF UHIX]XO GH D SUHGD SURGXVHOH VXSXVH UHFKL]L LRQ ULLGLVWUXJHUHDOLQLLORUGHFDOHIHUDW DOLQLLORUWHOHJUDILFHVDX WHOHIRQLFHDWLWXGLQHDRVWLO ID GHRFXSDQWúLDF LXQLGHSURWHVWXQHOHGH DPSORDUHDF LXQLDOHJUXSHORUGHSDWULR LúLOXSWDGHSDUWL]DQLHWFWRDWH DFHVWHD FRQWULEXLQG OD VXV LQHUHD PRUDOXOXL QD LXQLL URPkQH úL OD VXEPLQDUHDRFXSD LHLJHUPDQH $UPLVWL LXO GH OD )RFúDQL 'HFL]LD JXYHUQXOXL VRYLHWLF UH]XOWDW vQ XUPD YLFWRULHL UHYROX LHL EROúHYLFH GLQ RFWRPEULH RFWRPEULH QRLHPEULH GH D VHPQD FX *HUPDQLD úL DOLD LL HL DUPLVWL LXO GH OD %UHVW/LWRYVN QRLHPEULHGHFHPEULH úLGHDvQFHSHGLVFX LLOH SHQWUXvQFKHLHUHDWUDWDWXOXLGHSDFHvQDFHHDúLORFDOLWDWH GHFHPEULH DFUHDWXQGH]HFKLOLEUXvQWUH$QWDQW úL3XWHULOH&HQWUDOHúLDI FXW FD5RPkQLDV ILHL]RODW GHDOLD LV GHYLQ GHSHQGHQW GHGHSR]LWHOHGH SURYL]LLúLPXQL LLGLQ8FUDLQDFDUHODUkQGXL FDúL5XVLD vLHUDRVWLO ÌQ SOXV vQ 0ROGRYD JXYHUQXO URPkQ HUD FRQIUXQWDW FX DFWHOH DQDUKLFHDOHWUXSHORUUXVHDIODWHvQUHWUDJHUH FLUFDGHPLOLWDUL SUHFXP úL FX H[WLQGHUHD FRQIOLFWHORU DUPDWH vQWUH VXV LQ WRULL QRLL SXWHUL VRYLHWLFH úL DGYHUVDULL HL 0DL PXOW JHQHUDOXO '*6FHUEDFHY FRPDQGDQWXODGMXQFWDO)URQWXOXLURPkQDDQXQ DWSHUHJHOH)HUGLQDQG, úL SH ,,&%U WLDQX F D FRQYHQLW FX IHOGPDUHúDOXO $XJXVW YRQ 0DFNHQVHQ vQFKHLHUHD RILFLDO D VW ULL GH U ]ERL vQWUH WUXSHOH UXVH úL JHUPDQHSHIURQWXOGLQ0ROGRYD ÌQWUXQDVHPHQHDFRQWH[WODFDUHVDXDG XJDWFRQVRO ULOHW FHUHD VDX DPHQLQ ULOH DOLD LORU JXYHUQXO URPkQ VD Y ]XW REOLJDW V DFFHSWH vQFHWDUHD YUHPHOQLF D DF LXQLORU PLOLWDUH KRW UkQG vQ XQDQLPLWDWH QRLHPEULHGHFHPEULH F ÄDUPLVWL LXOHVWHLPSXVGHXQFD]GHIRU PDMRU úLF HOYDDYHDXQFDUDFWHUSXUPLOLWDUúLQXSROLWLF´&XSX LQWLPS vQDLQWH QRLHPEULH ,,&%U WLDQXSUHFL]DVHvQWUXQ0HPRULX vQDLQWDWDOLD LORUF vQWURDVHPHQHDHYHQWXDOLWDWH5RPkQLDYDFRQWLQXDV
5RPkQLDvQSULPXOU ]ERLPRQGLDOYROS
VH FRQVLGHUH DOLDWD DFHVWRUD F OD PRPHQWXO RSRUWXQ DUPDWD URPkQ YD UHOXDOXSWD3HQWUXDQXILDQJDMDWGLUHFWvQWUDWDWLYHUHJHOH)HUGLQDQG,D vQFUHGLQ DWSURYL]RULXFRPDQGDDUPDWHLJHQHUDOXOXL&RQVWDQWLQ3UH]DQúL DVWDELOLWFRPSRQHQ DGHOHJD LHLFDUHXUPDV QHJRFLH]HFXUHSUH]HQWDQ LL 3XWHULORU&HQWUDOH ÌQFHSXWHOD7HFXFL QRLHPEULHGHFHPEULH QHJRFLHULOHDX IRVWILQDOL]DWHOD)RFúDQL QRLHPEULH GHFHPEULH XQGHVDGHFLV FDDUPDWDURPkQ V vQFKHLHXQDUPLVWL LXSURYL]RULXFXDFHHDúLGXUDW GH YDODELOLWDWHFDúLFHOvQFKHLDWvQWUHIRU HOHUXVHúLJHUPDQRDXVWURXQJDUH $UPLVWL LXO D SURYRFDW QHPXO XPLUHD JXYHUQHORU DOLDWH FDUH QX DX vQ HOHVLQL LDOVLWXD LDJUHDvQFDUHVHDIOD5RPkQLD0DLPXOWHOHDXI FXW SUHVLXQL SHQWUX UHWUDJHUHD DUPDWHL URPkQH úL FRQWLQXDUHD OXSWHL vQ VXGXO 5XVLHLvQFRODERUDUHFXWUXSHOHDIODWHODGLVSR]L LD5DGHLXFUDLQHQHúLFX WUXSHOH UXVH FRQWUDUHYROX LRQDUH FRQIRUP SODQXOXL VFKL DW GH JHQHUDOXO +0%HUWKHORW $FHDVWDvQSRILGDIDSWXOXLF UHSUH]HQWDQ LL)UDQ HL$QJOLHL,WDOLHL úL6WDWHORU8QLWHDOH$PHULFLLvQ5RPkQLDSUHFL]DXvQWUR1RW FROHFWLY F 5RPkQLDÄúLDvQGHSOLQLWFXORLDOLWDWHDQJDMDPHQWHOH´0DLPXOWPLQLV WUXO IUDQFH] 3LFKRQ D vQúWLLQ DW JXYHUQXO URPkQ F ÄWRDWH DQJDMDPHQWHOH OXDWHvQPRPHQWXOLQWU ULLVDOHvQU ]ERLYRUILPHQ LQXWH´ 'HOD$UPLVWL LXOD3DFH5HVSLQJkQGDFHVWHFHUHULDOHDOLD LORUFDUH SXQHDXvQSHULFROILLQ DVWDWDO úLSURFHVXOGHI XULUHDXQLW LLQD LRQDOH vQWUXQ FRQWH[W vQ FDUH PLúFDUHD XQLRQLVW GLQ %DVDUDELD OXD DYkQW &RQVLOLXOGH&RURDQ DGHFLVODGHFHPEULH LDQXDULH FD WUXSHOH V úL FRQVROLGH]H SR]L LLOH GH LQXWH SH WHULWRULXO QD LRQDO úL V VH SUHJ WHDVF SHQWUXFRQWLQXDUHDOXSWHL ÌQWUH WLPS DX FRQWLQXDW SUHVLXQLOH 3XWHULORU &HQWUDOH DVXSUD 5RPkQLHLFDúLSHULFROXOGLQSDUWHDWUXSHORUUXVHFDUHVHFRQIUXQWDXvQWUH HOHvQFRQWH[WXOU ]ERLXOXLFLYLOIDSWFDUHDGHWHUPLQDWJXYHUQXOURPkQV LD P VXUL GH HYDFXDUH D DFHVWRUD úL GH LQVWLWXLUH D FRQWUROXOXL GHSOLQ DVXSUDWHULWRULXOXLURPkQHVFGLQ0ROGRYD
3UHWHQ LLOH8FUDLQHLID GHWHULWRULLOHURPkQHúWLGLQHVWXO ULLI FHDX LPSRVLELO RDVHPHQHDFRRSHUDUH ,QVLVWkQGSHDFHDVWDWHP IUDQFH]LLúLHQJOH]LLDXVHPQDWOD3DULVOD GHFHPEULH RFRQYHQ LHSULQFDUH)UDQ DVHDQJDMDV RUJDQL]H]HUH]LVWHQ D 5RPkQLHLvQVXGXO5XVLHL
&RQVLGHUkQG DFHDVW P VXU GH DXWRDS UDUH FD ILLQG vQGUHSWDW vPSRWULYDUHYROX LHLUXVHJXYHUQXOVRYLHWLFDWULPLVJXYHUQXOXLURPkQOD GHFHPEULH LDQXDULH R 1RW XOWLPDWLY FDUH DYHD FDUDFWHUXO XQHL GHFODUD LL GH U ]ERL XUPDW GH DUHVWDUHD WHPSRUDU D PLQLVWUXOXLURPkQOD3HWURJUDG&RQVWDQWLQ'LDPDQG\úLDUHVWXOXLSHUVR QDOXOXLGLSORPDWLFúLPLOLWDUURPkQ &kWHYD]LOHPDLWkU]LX LDQXDULH &RQVLOLXO&RPLVDULORU SRSRUXOXL D GHFLV ÄvQWUHUXSHUHD´ WHPSRUDU D UHOD LLORU GLSORPDWLFH FX 5RPkQLDWULPLWHUHDvQ DU DSHUVRQDOXOXLGLSORPDWLFúLPLOLWDUúLVHFKHV WUDUHDÄIRQGXOXLURPkQHVFGHDXU´ WH]DXUXO GHSXVOD0RVFRYDvQED]D XQRU FRQYHQ LL vQFKHLDWH FX JXYHUQXO UXV vQ &RQFRPLWHQW D IRVW vQFKLV úL &RQVXODWXO URPkQ GH OD 2GHVVD VHFKHVWUDWH EXQXULOH URPkQHúWLGLQRUDúúLLQWHU]LV H[SHGLHUHDDYDJRDQHFXDUPDPHQWúL PXQL LLDIODWHvQGUXPVSUH5RPkQLD ÌQ DFHODúL WLPS OD IHEUXDULH 5XPFHURGXO ± RUJDQLVP SROLWLFFDUHUHSUH]HQWDSXWHUHDVRYLHWLF vQ8FUDLQD±DWULPLVJXYHUQXOXL URPkQ XQ 8OWLPDWXP SULQ FDUH FHUHD UHWUDJHUHD vQ GH RUH D WUXSHORU URPkQHÄFDUHDXRFXSDWWHULWRULXO5HSXEOLFLL)HGHUD LHL5XVH´FXWRDWHF 5RPkQLD QX DYHD JUDQL FRPXQ FX DFHDVWD FL FX 5HSXEOLFD 'HPRFUDWLF 0ROGRYHQHDVF SURFODPDW ODLDQXDULHIHEUXDULH GH6IDWXO ULLVWDWLQGHSHQGHQWúLVXYHUDQ /D WRDWH DFHVWHD VDX DG XJDW SUHVLXQLOH 3XWHULORU &HQWUDOH SHQWUX vQFKHLHUHD XQHL S FL VHSDUDWH FX 5RPkQLD úL OLSVD GH vQ HOHJHUH vQ DFHVW VHQVDJXYHUQHORUDOLDWHFDUHQXUHFXQRúWHDXVLWXD LDGUDPDWLF vQFDUHVH DIOD5RPkQLDvQDFHOHPRPHQWHúLFRQVLGHUDXF IURQWXOGLQVXGXO5XVLHL SXWHDILvQF PHQ LQXW ÌQ DFHVW FRQWH[W ,,&%U WLDQX D I FXW FXQRVFXW JHQHUDOXOXL +0 %HUWKHORW LDQXDULH IHEUXDULH F GHúL R HYHQWXDO SDFH FX 3XWHULOH&HQWUDOHvLUHSXJQDQXDYHDDOW VROX LHGHFkWÄDLQWUDvQQHJRFLHUL FX*HUPDQLDúLDOHIDFHV GXUH]HFkWPDLPXOWSRVLELO´vQDúWHSWDUHDXQXL HYHQLPHQWQRXFDUHV SHUPLW UHOXDUHDOXSWHLDO WXULGHDOLD L$OWIHOPDL SUHFL]DSULPXOPLQLVWUXURPkQvQWUHDJD DU DUILIRVWRFXSDW GHJHUPDQL U PkQkQG ÄR 5RPkQLD DQHPLF I U GUHSWXUL I U JXYHUQ IDYRUDELO $QWDQWHLvQPkLQLOHJHUPDQRILOLORUU PDúLOD%XFXUHúWL´
3HUVRQDOXOGLSORPDWLFúLPLOLWDUURPkQDIRVWHOLEHUDWSHVWHGRX ]LOH FDXUPDUHDSURWHVWXOXLPLVLXQLORUGLSORPDWLFHVWU LQHGHOD3HWURJUDG
/D VFXUW WLPS LDQXDULH IHEUXDULH 3XWHULOH &HQWUDOH DX vQDLQWDW JXYHUQXOXL URPkQ XQ 8OWLPDWXP SULQ FDUH FHUHDX vQFHSHUHD vQ GHFXUVGHSDWUX]LOHDQHJRFLHULORUvQYHGHUHDvQFKHLHULLXQHLS FLVHSDUDWH 3HQWUX D WHUJLYHUVD WULPLWHUHD U VSXQVXOXL OD XOWLPDWXPXO PHQ LRQDW ,,&%U WLDQX D GHPLVLRQDW OD LDQXDULH IHEUXDULH 1RXO JXYHUQFRQGXVGHJHQHUDOXO$OH[DQGUX$YHUHVFXDOXDWFXQRúWLQ vQWUH IHEUXDULH GLQGLVFX LLOHDYXWHOD%XIWHDFX$XJXVWYRQ 0DFNHQVHQ 2WWRNDU &]HUQLF úL 5LVFKDUG YRQ .KOPDQQ GH FRQGL LLOH H[WUHPGHGXUHSXVHGHDFHúWLDvQWUHFDUHSHSULPSODQVDVLWXDWFHGDUHD 'REURJHL 6LWXD LD 5RPkQLHL D IRVW DJUDYDW úL SULQ IDSWXO F vQ Ä&HOH SXQFWH´GLQGHFHPEULH LDQXDULH SUHúHGLQWHOHDPHULFDQ :RRGURZ :LOVRQ QX D DPLQWLW QLPLF GHVSUH GUHSWXULOH OHJLWLPH DOH URPkQLORU GLQ $XVWUR8QJDULD 0DL PXOW QHGRULQG V úL LD DQJDMDPHQWH ID GH 5RPkQLD JXYHUQXO DPHULFDQ D UHIX]DW OD IHEUXDULH V DGHUHODGHFODUD LDFRPXQ LQL LDW GH)UDQ DúLGH $QJOLD SULQ FDUH V VH UHFXQRDVF vQF RGDW SURPLVLXQLOH I FXWH 5RPkQLHLvQ /XkQGvQFRQVLGHUDUHIDSWXOF vQFD]GHUHIX]DUPDWDURPkQ QXDU PDLILSXWXWRSXQHGHFkWÄRVFXUW UH]LVWHQ ´DúDFXPDSUHFLDJHQHUDOXO $OH[DQGUX $YHUHVFX F PXQL LLOH úL VXE]LVWHQ HOH HUDX FX WRWXO LQVXILFLHQWH&RQVLOLXOGH&RURDQ vQWUXQLWODIHEUXDULHPDUWLHúL IHEUXDULHPDUWLHDGHFLVODSURSXQHUHDOXL,,&%U WLDQXV DFFHSWHÄvQ EORF´ FRQGL LLOH ÄS FLL´ LPSXVH GH 3XWHULOH &HQWUDOH SHQWUX DL VXEOLQLD PDLPXOWFDUDFWHUXOGHGLFWDW ÌQFRQWH[WXOvQFDUHUHSUH]HQWDQ LL3XWHULORU&HQWUDOHDXvQDLQWDWQRL FHUHUL XOWLPDWLYH H[WUHP GH JUHOH UHFWLILF UL GH JUDQL VSUH $XVWUR 8QJDULDGHPRELOL]DUHDDFLQFLGLYL]LLURPkQHHWF &RQVLOLXOGH&RURDQ vQWUXQLWGLQQRXOD IHEUXDULHPDUWLH DGHFLVFDSDFHDV QXILH
6LWXD LD D GHYHQLW GUDPDWLF GXS vQFKHLHUHD WUDWDWHORU GH SDFH FX 8FUDLQD LDQXDULH IHEUXDULH úL 5HSXEOLFD 6RYLHWLF )HGHUDWLY 5XV IHEUXDULHPDUWLH IDSWFDUHDGHWHUPLQDWS WUXQGHUHDWUXSHORU JHUPDQH vQ DGkQFLPHD WHULWRULXOXL VRYLHWLF vQ VSDWHOH GLVSR]LWLYXOXL GH OXSW URPkQHVF 8OWHULRUSURJUDPXOSUHúHGLQWHOXL:LOVRQDVXIHULWPRGLILF ULvQVHQVXO UHFXQRDúWHULLGUHSWXOXLGHDXWRGHWHUPLQDUHDURPkQLORUGLQ$XVWUR8QJDULD
QHJRFLDW UHJHOH)HUGLQDQGV QXVHPQH]HWUDWDWXOFHXUPDV ILHvQFKHLDW LDU 3DUODPHQWXO V QXO UDWLILFH $VWIHO D GRXD ]L IHEUXDULH PDUWLH DXIRVWVHPQDWHSUHOLPLQDULLOHGHÄSDFH´GHOD%XIWHDLDUOD PDUWLH SHQWUX D QX DQJDMD JXYHUQXO URPkQ GLQ WHULWRULXO OLEHU VD FRQVWLWXLW XQ QRX JXYHUQ vQ IUXQWH FX $OH[DQGUX 0DUJKLORPDQ FDUH D VHPQDWODDSULOLHPDL ÄSDFHD´GHOD%XFXUHúWL 7UDWDWXOGHSDFHGHOD%XFXUHúWL3UHYHGHULOHWUDWDWXOXLGHSDFH vQUHDOLWDWHXQDGHY UDWGLFWDWDO3XWHULORU&HQWUDOHSXQHDXvQSHULFRO vQV úL H[LVWHQ D QD LRQDO D 5RPkQLHL vQ FRQWH[WXO vQ FDUH $XVWUR 8QJDULDSULPHDvQWUHJXOODQ DO&DUSD LORUúLNPSGLQVXGHVWXO %XFRYLQHL %XOJDULD RE LQHD &DGULODWHUXO úL R SRU LXQH GLQ VXGXO MXGH XOXL&RQVWDQ DUHVWXO'REURJHLILLQGRFXSDWGHFHOHSDWUXSXWHUL úLRUJDQL]DWVXEIRUP GHFRQGRPLQLXP5RPkQLHLO VkQGXLVHRFDOH GH DFFHV VSUH &RQVWDQ D FDUH D GHYHQLW ÄSRUWOLEHU´ FRQWURODW GH JHUPDQL%RJ LLOH ULLPDLDOHVSHWUROXOFHUHDOHOHS GXULOHDXLQWUDW VXE FRQWUROXO SXWHULORU RFXSDQWH vQ VSHFLDO DO *HUPDQLHL &RQFRPLWHQW5RPkQLHLLVDXPDLLPSXVJUHOHGHVS JXELULGHU ]ERL vQJKH DUHDSHFLQFLDQLDGHSR]LWHORU% QFLL1D LRQDOHDIODWHvQ%DQFD LPSHULDO JHUPDQ YLQGHUHD F WUH *HUPDQLD úL $XVWUR8QJDULD D SULVRVXOXL GH FHUHDOH úL YLWH HWF DQXODUHD GUHSWXOXL GH DúL GLULMD FRPHU XO H[WHULRU &X DFHODúL SULOHM *HUPDQLD D PDL RE LQXW GUHSWXO H[FOXVLYGHDIRORVLWRDWHWHUHQXULOHVWDWXOXLURPkQSHQWUXH[SORDWDUHD úL SUHOXFUDUHD L HLXOXL SH GH DQL FX SRVLELOLWDWH GH SUHOXQJLUH SH vQF GHDQL/DUkQGXOORUSUHYHGHULOHFXFDUDFWHUPLOLWDUDXYL]DW VO ELUHDFDSDFLW LLGHUH]LVWHQ D5RPkQLHLvQDúDIHOvQFkWDFHDVWDV QXPDLILHvQP VXU DVHRSXQHUHJLPXOXLGXUGHRFXSD LH ÌQ SRILGD SUHVLXQLORU 3XWHULORU &HQWUDOH vQ YHGHUHD UDWLILF ULL úL DSOLF ULL LQWHJUDOH D SUHYHGHULORU WUDWDWXOXL GH SDFH FKLDU úL $OH[DQGUX 0DUJKLORPDQDDF LRQDWSHQWUXUHYL]XLUHDOXLúLPHQ LQHUHDXQRUUDSRUWXUL QRUPDOHFX$QWDQWDÌQDFHVWVHQVHODUHVSLQVFHUHUHD3XWHULORU&HQWUDOH FD DUPDWD URPkQ V LQWUH vQ OXSW vPSRWULYD IRúWLORU DOLD L ÌQ FDGUXO DF LXQLL GH HOXGDUH D SUHYHGHULORU WUDWDWXOXL GH SDFH RUJDQHOH GH FRQGXFHUHDOHDUPDWHLURPkQHDXvQFHUFDWV PHQ LQ VXEDUPHHIHFWLYH
'LPLQXDUHD HIHFWLYHORU FHORU RSW GLYL]LL GLQ 0ROGRYD úL DOWRU XQLW L URPkQHDVWIHOvQFkWV U PkQ VXEDUPHQXPDLGHPLOLWDUL
FkWPDLPDUL FKLDUSHSR]L LLOHGHSHOLQLD6LUHWXOXLúLV DSOLFHFkWPDL vQFHWGHPRELOL]DUHDDUPDWHL Ä$FWSURYL]RULX´DúDFXPvOFRQVLGHUDFKLDUúL33&DUSWUDWDWXOGH SDFHGHOD%XFXUHúWLúLDSLHUGXWYDODELOLWDWHDvQWRDPQDDQXOXL FkQG vQ QRXO FRQWH[W VWUDWHJLF GHWHUPLQDW GH RIHQVLYD DOLDW GLQ %DOFDQL úL GH WUHFHUH D 'XQ ULL UHJHOH )HUGLQDQG , D FHUXW OD RFWRPEULH QRLHP EULHGHPLVLDJXYHUQXOXL0DUJKLORPDQúLDGL]ROYDWFRUSXULOHOHJLXLWRDUH GHFODUkQGOXFU ULOHORUÄQXOHúLQHDYHQLWH´ 5HLQWUDUHD5RPkQLHLvQU ]ERLÌQQRXOFRQWH[WSROLWLFRPLOLWDUGLQ WRDPQD DQXOXL DOLD LL DX GHFLV V FRUHOH]H DF LXQHD DUPDWHORU GH 6DORQLF úL GH 'XQ UH FX FHD D DUPDWHL URPkQH vQ FDUH VFRS JHQHUDOXO +0%HUWKHORW D SULPLW PLVLXQHD GLQ SDUWHD JXYHUQXOXL IUDQFH] VHSWHPEULHRFWRPEULH GHDGHWHUPLQDÄLQWUDUHDGLQQRXD5RPkQLHLvQ U ]ERL GH SDUWHD SXWHULORU $QWDQWHL´ 3ODQXO IUDQFH] WUDQVPLV RILFLDOLORU URPkQLGHOD,DúLGHF WUH9LFWRU$QWRQHVFXPLQLVWUXO5RPkQLHLOD3DULV SUHYHGHD F DUPDWD URPkQ UHPRELOL]DW SH OLQLD 6LUHWXOXL WUHEXLD V vQDLQWH]H VSUH VXGYHVW SHQWUX D IDFH MRQF LXQHD vQ ]RQD 3ORLHúWL FX $UPDWD GH 'XQ UH FRPDQGDW GH JHQHUDOXO +0%HUWKHORW SHQWUX D FRQVWLWXLRJUXSDUHGHIRU HODIODQFXOGUHSWDODUPDWHLDOLDWHFRPDQGDWHGH JHQHUDOXO)UDQFKHWG¶(VSHUH\ &XWRDWHF DUPDWDURPkQ VHDIODvQWURVLWXD LDGLILFLO PDLDOHV GLQ SXQFWXO GH YHGHUH DO vQ]HVWU ULL úL HFKLS ULL UHJHOH )HUGLQDQG , D DSUREDW SODQXO úL P VXULOH GH UHPRELOL]DUH LDU GXS GHPLVLD JXYHUQXOXL 0DUJKLORPDQ RFWRPEULHQRLHPEULH DGDWR3URFODPD LHF WUH DU RFWRPEULH QRLHPEULH SULQ FDUH DQXQ D UHIRUPD FRQVWLWX LRQDO YRWXOXQLYHUVDOúLvPSURSULHW ULUHD$GRXD]L RFWRPEULH QRLHPEULH QRXOJXYHUQURPkQDDGUHVDWXQ8OWLPDWXPIHOGPDUHúDOXOXL$XJXVWYRQ 0DFNHQVHQ FRPDQGDQWXO WUXSHORU JHUPDQH GH RFXSD LH GLYL]LL JHUPDQH SULQFDUHLVDFHUXWV RUGRQHUHWUDJHUHDDUPDWHLGHSHWHULWRULXO
3ULQ GHWDú UL SH OkQJ DXWRULW LOH FLYLOH úL OD GHSR]LWH VSRULUHD QXP UXOXLRUGRQDQ HORU 6DUHXúLWDVWIHOFDODVHSWHPEULH HIHFWLYHOHDUPDWHLV ILHGH PLOLWDULFXSHVWHPDLPXOWGHFkWSUHYHGHULOHWUDWDWXOXL
5RPkQLHL &RQFRPLWHQW VD RUGRQDW PRELOL]DUHD DUPDWHL SkQ OD FRQWLQJHQWXO LQFOXVLY3UHJ WLW GLQWLPSúLFXGLVFUH LHDF LXQHD URPkQHDVF DVXUSULQVFRPDQGDPHQWXOJHUPDQGHRFXSD LH 5HLQWUDUHD5RPkQLHvQOXSW DIRVWvQOHVQLW GHFDSLWXODUHD%XOJDULHL VHSWHPEULH OD 6DORQLF 7XUFLHL RFWRPEULH OD 0XGURV úL $XVWUR8QJDULHL RFWRPEULHQRLHPEULHOD9LOOD*LXVWL SUHFXPúLGH IRU DUHD 'XQ ULL GH F WUH DUPDWD DOLDW FRPDQGDW GH JHQHUDOXO +0%HUWKHORW RFWRPEULHQRLHPEULH ,PHGLDWGXS PRELOL]DUHDXIRVWGHFODQúDWHSULPHOHDF LXQLGHOXSW RFWRPEULH QRLHPEULH VSUH RFWRPEULH QRLHPEULH SHQWUX HOLPLQDUHDSUH]HQ HLPLOLWDUHLQDPLFHGLQ'REURJHD0XQWHQLDúLFKLDUGLQ 7UDQVLOYDQLD XQGH DYDQJ U]LOH GLYL]LLORU LQIDQWHULH úL YkQ WRUL DX WUHFXW PXQ LL vQWUH RFWRPEULH QRLHPEULH QRLHPEULH FRQFHQWUkQGXVH vQ ]RQD 7RSOL D 'LWU X *KHRUJKLHQL 6kQGRPLQLF ' QHúWL 0LHUFXUHD &LXF OD VXG GH DOLQLDPHQWXO VWDELOLW SULQ DUPLVWL LXO GLQ RFWRPEULH QRLHPEULH vQFKHLDW OD %HOJUDG vQWUH UHSUH]HQ WDQ L DL $QWDQWHL úL DL JXYHUQXOXL XQJDU I U vQúWLLQ DUHD úL DVHQWLPHQWXO JXYHUQXOXLURPkQ DúDFXPSUHYHGHDWUDWDWXOGLQ VDXD&RQVLOLXOXL 1D LRQDO5RPkQGLQ7UDQVLOYDQLD 5HLQWUDUHD 5RPkQLHL vQ OXSW DO WXUL GH $OLD L vQ vQ HOHJHUH FX DFHúWLDvQDLQWHDFDSLWXO ULL*HUPDQLHL RFWRPEULHQRLHPEULH D FRQILUPDW vQF RGDW GHFL]LD JXYHUQXOXL URPkQ GH DúL vQGHSOLQL REOLJD LLOH DVXPDWH ID GH DFHúWLD úL QHFHVLWDWHD FD VWDWHOH $QWDQWHL V WUDWH]H5RPkQLDFDDOLDWODYLLWRDUHDFRQIHULQ GHSDFH 3HQWUX5RPkQLDDOXDWDVWIHOVIkUúLWRSHULRDG H[WUHPGHFRPSOH[ GLQLVWRULDVDGRPLQDW GHSDUWLFLSDUHDODSULPXOU ]ERLPRQGLDOvQFDUH DXIRVWUXOD LFLUFDGHPLOLWDULURPkQLvQFDUHVDXvQUHJLVWUDW YLFWRULLVWU OXFLWHGDUúLvQIUkQJHULXPLOLWRDUHSLHUGHULOHXPDQHULGLFkQGX VH OD SHVWH GH PLOLWDUL úL FLYLOL PRU L U QL L úL GLVS UX L DGLF FLUFDGLQSRSXOD LD ULL
8OWLPXOGHWDúDPHQWJHUPDQDWUHFXW0XQ LL&DUSD LODQRLHPEULH GHFHPEULH ÌQ DFHO PRPHQW DUPDWD URPkQ DYHD vQ FRPSXQHUH FRUSXUL GH DUPDW GLYL]LLGHLQIDQWHULHGLYL]LLGHFDYDOHULHXQLW LGHDUWLOHULHJUHD DHURQDXWLF PDULQ vQWRWDOXQHIHFWLYGHPLOLWDUL &RQYHQ LDPLOLWDU GHOD%HOJUDGVWDELOHDFXUVXO0XUHúXOXLFDOLQLHGH GHPDUFD LH URPkQRXQJDU vQ SRILGD ÄWXWXURU SULQFLSLLORU HWQRJUDILFH JHRJUDILFHúLVWUDWHJLFHFXQRVFXWH´DúDFXPDSUHFLD5:6HWRQ:DWVRQ
) XULUHDVWDWXOXLQD LRQDOXQLWDUURPkQ ,QWHQVLILFDUHDOXSWHLGHHOLEHUDUHQD LRQDO DURPkQLORUGLQSURYLQ FLLOH RFXSDWH /D vQFHSXWXO VHFROXOXL ;; OXSWD GH HOLEHUDUH D URPkQLORU GLQ WHULWRULLOH DIODWH VXE RFXSD LH VWU LQ VD LQWHQVLILFDW LQWUkQG vQ ID] GHFLVLY vQ PRPHQWXO vQ FDUH D vQFHSXW SURFHVXO GH GH]PHPEUDUH D LPSHULLOHFRWURSLWRDUH ÌQ7UDQVLOYDQLDDF LXQHDXQLRQLVW DURPkQLORUDIRVWUHYLJRUDW OD PLMORFXO SULPXOXL GHFHQLX DO VHFROXOXL SULQ UHIRUPDUHD DFWLYLW LL SURJUDPXOXL 3DUWLGXOXL 1D LRQDO 5RPkQ FDUH D SXV SH SULP SODQ DFWLYLVPXO SROLWLF GLQ vQ YHGHUHD UHFXQRDúWHULL LQGLYLGXDOLW LL SROLWLFHDQD LXQLLURPkQHvQFHW ULLDF LXQLLGHGH]QD LRQDOL]DUHIRORVLULL OLPELL PDWHUQH vQ DGPLQLVWUD LH MXVWL LH DUPDW úL úFRDO UHGREkQGLULL DXWRQRPLHL GHSOLQH D WXWXURU FRQIHVLXQLORU DOHJHULL IXQF LRQDULORU GLQ UkQGXO SRSXOD LHL PDMRULWDUH LQWURGXFHULL YRWXOXL XQLYHUVDO JDUDQW ULL GUHSWXOXL OD vQWUXQLUH DVRFLHUH DVLJXU ULL OLEHUW LL SUHVHL úL D PLQLPXOXL GH SURSULHWDWH vPSURSULHW ULULL UDQLORU GLQ VXSUDIH HOH GH LQXWH GH VWDW HWF ÌQYHGHUHDvQGHSOLQLULLDFHVWRUGH]LGHUDWH3DUWLGXO1D LRQDO5RPkQ DFRODERUDWPDLDFWLYFX6HF LDURPkQ D3DUWLGXOXL6RFLDO'HPRFUDWGLQ $UGHDO úL %DQDW FRQVWLWXLW OD /XJRM vQ úL D GHPDVFDW SULQ SURSULL GHSXWD LvQ3DUODPHQWXOGHOD%XGDSHVWDUHJLPXOGHRSUHVLXQHQD LRQDO LQFOXVLY FRQVHFLQ HOH QHIDVWH DOH /HJLL $SSRQ\L GLQ UHIHULWRDUH OD RUJDQL]DUHD vQY PkQWXOXL úL IRORVLUHD OXL FD PLMORF GH úWHUJHUH D LGHQWLW LLURPkQHúWL
ÌQILLQ DWODPDLOD6LELX ,RQ$OH[DQGUHVFX,RQ%XOHL,RQ0DPLQD,RDQ6FXUWX(QFLFORSHGLD SDUWLGHORU SROLWLFH GLQ 5RPkQLD (GLWXUD 0(',$35,17 %XFXUHúWL S /D PDUWLHDSULOLHúLDSULOLH PDL 3DUODPHQWXOPDJKLDUD YRWDW OHJLOH úFRODUH $SSRQ\L UHIHULWRDUH OD GHVILLQ DUHD úFROLORU FRQIHVLRQDOH URPkQHúWLVORYDFHúLVkUEHúLvQORFXLUHDORUFXúFROLGHVWDWFXOLPEDGHSUHGDUH PDJKLDU ÌQ ED]D ORU vQ SHULRDGD DX IRVW GHVILLQ DWH úFROL URPkQHúWL &RUHODWH FX P VXULOH DQWHULRDUH DFHDVW GHFL]LH D I FXW FD vQ GLQ SRSXOD LD 7UDQVLOYDQLHL úL GLQ FH D 0DUDPXUHúXOXL V QX úWLH FDUWH ,VWRULD5RPkQLHLvQGDWH(GLWXUD(QFLFORSHGLF %XFXUHúWLS
'LQ LQL LDWLYD 3DUWLGXOXL 1D LRQDO 5RPkQ DX DYXW ORF QXPHURDVH vQWUXQLULSRSXODUH vQWRDPQDDQXOXL OD%UDúRY$UDG2UDGHD6LELX 'HYD7LPLúRDUD/XJRMHWF vQFDUHVDOXDWSR]L LHvPSRWULYDSROLWLFLLGH GH]QD LRQDOL]DUH D DEX]XULORU úL VDPDYROQLFLLORU DXWRULW LORU vPSRWULYD URPkQLORU D VLVWHPXOXL GH vQY PkQW GDU úL D UHOD LLORU GLQWUH SURSULHWDUL úL PXQFLWRULL DJULFROL DIHFWDWH SULQ OHJHD 'DUDQ\L DSULOLH FDUH DVLJXUD GUHSWXUL QHOLPLWDWH DVXSUD DUJD LORU PDMRULWDWHD URPkQL vPSRWULYD SURLHFWXOXL XQJDU GH UHIRUP HOHFWRUDO SULQ FDUH VH UHGXFHDQXP UXODOHJ WRULORUURPkQLFX )D GH WRDWH DFHVWHD OD VHSWHPEULH IUXQWDúLL SROLWLFL DUGHOHQL DX vQDLQWDW JXYHUQXOXL GH OD %XGDSHVWD XQ 0HPRULX vQ GH SXQFWHSULQFDUHVHVROLFLWDXUHFXQRDúWHUHDIXQF LRQ ULLFRQVWLWX LRQDOHD 3DUWLGXOXL 1D LRQDO 5RPkQ OHJLIHUDUHD YRWXOXL XQLYHUVDO HJDO GLUHFW úL VHFUHW IRORVLUHD OLPELL URPkQH vQ DGPLQLVWUD LH úL MXVWL LH GUHSW GH vQWUXQLUH úL GH RUJDQL]DUH SHQWUX WR L FHW HQLL UHVSHFWDUHD DXWRQRPLHL ELVHULFLORUURPkQHvQY PkQWvQOLPEDPDWHUQ vQWRDWHúFROLOHSULPDUHúL FHOSX LQWUHLJLPQD]LLGHVWDWFXOLPEDGHSUHGDUHURPkQ JUD LHUHDFRQ GDPQD LORUSROLWLFLVLVWDUHDSURFHVHORUSROLWLFHHWF&k LYDDQLPDLWkU]LX vQWUH LDQXDULH úL IHEUXDULH WRW HL DX GXV WUDWDWLYH FX UHSUH]HQWDQ L DL JXYHUQXOXL XQJDU SULYLQG VLWXD LD URPkQLORU GLQ 7UDQVLOYDQLD úL PRGDOLW LOH GH vPEXQ W LUH D DFHVWHLD VROGDWH vQV FX HúHFÌQXUPDUHIX]XOXLGHDUHFXQRDúWHSRSRUXOURPkQFDLQGLYLGXDOLWDWH SROLWLF úL D DVLJXUD GH]YROWDUHD VD OD IHEUXDULH FRQGXFHUHD 3DUWLGXOXL1D LRQDO5RPkQDvQWUHUXSWOHJ WXULOHFXJXYHUQXOPDJKLDUGH OD%XGDSHVWDLDUODGHFHPEULHLDQXDULH 3R]L LH ID GH SHUVHFXWDUHD URPkQLORU WUDQVLOY QHQL D DGRSWDW úL SULPXOPLQLVWUX URPkQ ,,& %U WLDQX FDUH OD DYHUWL]DW YHUEDO vQ LDQXDULH SH $/ YRQ $HKUHQWKDO PLQLVWUXO GH ([WHUQH DO $XVWUR
/D QRLHPEULH OD PDUHD vQWUXQLUH OD /XJRM GH SDUWL FLSDQ L VDX DGRSWDW GHFL]LL LPSRUWDQWH UHFXQRDúWHUHD QD LRQDOLW LL URPkQH SURPRYDUHD FXOWXULL úL OLPELL URPkQH HWF SHQWUX OXSWD QD LRQDO D URPkQLORU GLQ$XVWUR8QJDULD 'RLDQLPDLWkU]LXOD$OED,XOLDODvQFHSXWXOOXQLLLXQLH SHVWH GH UHSUH]HQWDQ L DL URPkQLORU GLQ 7UDQVLOYDQLD DX DGRSWDW R 0R LXQH GH SURWHVWvPSRWULYDSURLHFWXOXLGHvQILLQ DUHDHSLVFRSLHLJUHFRFDWROLFHPDJKLDUH úLDXFRQVWLWXLWXQ&RPLWHWFDUHV LDP VXULOHJDOHúLQHFHVDUHSHQWUXDS UDUHD GUHSWXULORUDXWRQRPHDOH%LVHULFLLJUHFRFDWROLFHURPkQH
8QJDULHL F DFHDVW VLWXD LH YD DYHD FRQVHFLQ H SROLWLFH GHIDYRUDELOH LPSHULXOXL/DUkQGXL/LJDFXOWXUDO GLQ%XFXUHúWLDRUJDQL]DWOD PDUWLH vQ VDOD 'DFLD XQ PDUH PLWLQJ GH SURWHVW ID GH DVXSULUHD QD LRQDO D URPkQLORU GLQ ,PSHULXO DXVWURXQJDU LDU OD VHSWHPEULH RFWRPEULH UHSUH]HQWDQ LL DQWDQWLúWL DL 3DUWLGXOXL &RQVHUYDWRU 1LFRODH )LOLSHVFX 3DUWLGXOXL &RQVHUYDWRU'HPRFUDW 7DNH ,RQHVFX úL DL WUDQVLOY QHQLORU DIOD L OD %XFXUHúWL FDUH PLOLWDX SHQWUX UHDOL]DUHD XQLW LLSROLWLFHDXvQILLQ DW)HGHUD LDXQLRQLVW 6HPQLILFDWLY SHQWUX VHQVXO OXSWHL QD LRQDOH D URPkQLORU HVWH úL GHFL]LDGLQGHFHPEULH D&RQJUHVXOXL/LJLLQD LRQDOHSHQWUX XQLWDWHD FXOWXUDO D WXWXURU URPkQLORU SULYLQG VFKLPEDUHD QXPHOXL vQ /LJDSHQWUXXQLWDWHDSROLWLF DWXWXURUURPkQLORU'HFODUD LDGHU ]ERL vPSRWULYD PRQDUKLHL DXVWURXQJDUH VHPQDW OD ,DúL OD LDQXDULH GHF WUH&RPLWHWXOQD LRQDODOURPkQLORUHPLJUDQ LGLQ$XVWUR 8QJDULDSOHFDUHDODDSULOLH OD:DVKLQJWRQDXQHLGHOHJD LL D URPkQLORU WUDQVLOY QHQL vQ IUXQWH FX 9DVLOH /XFDFLX SUHúHGLQWHOH /LJLL&XOWXUDOHSHQWUXDIDFHFXQRVFXWHJXYHUQXOXLúLRSLQLHLSXEOLFH DPHULFDQHUHYHQGLF ULOHURPkQLORUDUGHOHQLvQILLQ DUHDvQYDUDDQXOXL OD/RQGUDD6RFLHW LLDQJORURPkQ FDUHvúLSURSXQHDV IDF FXQRVFXW RSLQLHL SXEOLFH EULWDQLFH MXVWH HD OXSWHL URPkQLORU SHQWUX XQLWDWH QD LRQDO SUHFXP úL FRQVWLWXLUHD OD 3DULV OD DSULOLH D &RPLWHWXOXL QD LRQDO DO URPkQLORU GLQ 7UDQVLOYDQLD úL %XFRYLQD VXESUHúHGLQ LDOXL7UDLDQ9XLDDSRLDGU,&DQWDFX]LQR FDUH D PLOLWDW LQL LDO SHQWUX LQGHSHQGHQ D 7UDQVLOYDQLHL DSRL SHQWUX XQLUHDDFHVWHLDFX5RPkQLD *ODVGHSURWHVWvPSRWULYDSROLWLFLLGHGH]QD LRQDOL]DUH úLDVXSULUH SURPRYDW GH DFHDVW GDW GH DXWRULW LOH KDEVEXUJLFH DX ULGLFDW úL URPkQLL GLQ %XFRYLQD SURYLQFLH URPkQHDVF vQFRUSRUDW GH ,PSHULX +DEVEXUJLFvQFKLDUGDF DXIRVWPRPHQWHFkQGPLúFDUHDQD LRQDO úLDGLPLQXDWDFWLYLWDWHDVDXDIRVWvQIUkQW FHOSX LQODQLYHOXOSDUWLGHORU
'LQ GH ORFXLWRUL DL %XFRYLQHL OD vQFHSXWXO VHFROXOXL ;; FRQIRUP UHFHQV PkQWXOXL I FXW GH +DEVEXUJL HUDX URPkQL UXWHQL úL DOWH QD LRQDOLW L &RPSDUD LD FX VLWXD LD GLQ FkQG URPkQLL HUDX FHL PDL QXPHURúL ORFXLWRUL DL SURYLQFLHL UHOHY SROLWLFD GH LPSODQWDUHDHOHPHQWXOXLVWU LQvQSURYLQFLHPDLDOHVDFHOXLUXWHDQ
SROLWLFHH[LVWHQWHvQSURYLQFLH8QUROLPSRUWDQWvQDFHVWGLQXUP DVSHFW ODXDYXWúLGLVHQVLXQLOHDS UXWHvQWUHURPkQLXQLLGLQWUHIUXQWDúLLSROLWLFL GLQ 3DUWLGXO 6RFLDO'HPRFUDW 5RPkQ GLQ %XFRYLQD FRQVWLWXLW vQ LXOLH OD &HUQ X L GDU úL GLQ DOWH SDUWLGH SURQXQ kQGXVH SHQWUX FUHDUHD XQHL&RQIHGHUD LLGHPRFUDWLFHDSRSRDUHORUGLQ,PSHULX&XWRDWHDFHVWHD WR L DX UHYHQGLFDW SHQWUX URPkQLL EXFRYLQHQL GUHSWXO OD úFROL SURSULL IRORVLUHDOLPELLURPkQHvQvQY PkQWSUHV MXVWL LHHWF 8QUROLPSRUWDQWvQFDGUXODF LXQLLSHQWUXXQLWDWHQD LRQDO ODDYXW FRQVWLWXLUHDvQ SHOkQJ 8QLYHUVLWDWHDGLQ&HUQ X LDXQHL&DWHGUH GHLVWRULHQD LRQDO FRQGXV GH,RQ1LVWRUFDUHODRFWRPEULH D LQDXJXUDW FXUVXO ÄÌQVHPQ WDWHD LVWRULF D URPkQLORU úL vQFHSXWXULOH RUJDQL] ULLORUGHVWDW´ 8Q SURFHV DVHP Q WRU VD vQUHJLVWUDW úL vQ %DVDUDELD PDL DOHV OD &KLúLQ X XQGH FD XUPDUH D OXSWHL GXVH GH ]LDUXO Ä%DVDUDELD´ SHQWUX SURPRYDUHDOLPELLURPkQHvQúFRDO úLELVHULF VDUHGHVFKLV7LSRJUDILD HSDUKLDO SHQWUX WLS ULUHD F U LORU UHOLJLRDVH vQ OLPED URPkQ DSULOLH VD FRQVWLWXLW 6RFLHWDWHD PROGRYHQHDVF SHQWUX U VSkQGLUHD FXOWXULLQD LRQDOH RFWRPEULHQRLHPEULH 7RWOD&KLúLQ XDXDS UXWRVHULHGH]LDUHúLUHYLVWHFDUHDXFRQWULEXLW XQHOHFKLDUGDF SHQWUXVFXUWWLPS ODUHGHúWHSWDUHDQD LRQDO URPkQHDVF Ä%DVDUDELD´ PDL ± IHEUXDULH FDUH D PLOLWDW SHQWUX OLEHUW L GHPRFUDWLFH LQWURGXFHUHD OLPELL URPkQH vQ úFROLOH GH VWDW úL DXWRQRPLH SHQWUXvQWUHDJDSURYLQFLH Ä9LD D%DVDUDELHL´ DSULOLHPDL WLS ULWFX OLWHUHFKLULOLFHúLODWLQH UHYLVWDÄ/XPLQ WRUXO´ LDQXDULH FDUHD FRQWULEXLWODFXOWLYDUHDOLPELLURPkQHODWUH]LUHDúLvQW ULUHDVHQWLPHQWXOXL QD LRQDO JD]HWDÄ&XYkQWPROGRYHQHVF´ PDL HWF
ÌQIUkQJHUHD 3DUWLGXOXL 3RSRUDO 1D LRQDO 5RPkQ GLQ %XFRYLQD vQ DOHJHULOH GLQ úL GL]ROYDUHD WHPSRUDU D DFHVWXLD SkQ vQ LDQXDULH FkQG úLD UHOXDW QXPHOH SULQ VFKLPEDUHD GHQXPLULL 3DUWLGXOXL &UHúWLQ 6RFLDO 5RPkQGLQ%XFRYLQD vQILLQ DWODRFWRPEULH /DFHUHUHDFOHUXOXLEDVDUDEHDQGLQRFWRPEULH 6LQRGXOUXVD DSUREDWODGHFHPEULH SUHGDUHDOLPELLURPkQH FDRELHFWGHVWXGLX QHREOLJDWRULX OD6HPLQDUXOWHRORJLFGLQ&KLúLQ X ÌQ XOWLPXO QXP U D SXEOLFDW SRH]LD Ä'HúWHDSW WH URPkQH´ &RQFRPLWHQW vQ MXUXO JD]HWHL VD FRQVWLWXLW QXFOHXO 3DUWLGXOXL 1D LRQDO 'HPRFUDWFDUHDPLOLWDWSHQWUXVW YLOLUHDUXVLILF ULLURPkQLORUEDVDUDEHQL
$F LXQLORU GHVI úXUDWH vQ SURYLQFLLOH FRWURSLWH úL vQ 5HJDW OL VDX DG XJDW PDQLIHVW ULOH HPLJUD LHL FDUH SULQ SXEOLFD LL UHPDUFDELOH Ä/D 5RXPDQLH´ OD 3DULV Ä6WHDXD 5RPkQ ´ OD 1HZ
3ULPXO FRQJUHV D DYXW ORF vQWUH DSULOLH DSULOLH VROLFLWkQGXVHDXWRQRPLDDGPLQLVWUDWLY UHOLJLRDV LQWHOHFWXDO úLHFRQRPLF D %DVDUDELHL FRQVWLWXLUHD XQXL RUJDQ OHJLVODWLY ± 6IDWXO ULL ± vQY PkQW vQ OLPED PDWHUQ HIHFWXDUHD VHUYLFLXOXL PLOLWDU QXPDL vQ %DVDUDELD vQFHWDUHD FRORQL] ULORUvQ%DVDUDELDOLEHUW LQD LRQDOHSHQWUXURPkQLLGHSHVWH3UXWHWF 'HVI úXUDWH vQ SHULRDGD DSULOLHLXQLH FRQJUHVHOH vQY WRULORU EDVDUDEHQLDXDGRSWDWXQSURJUDPGHGH]YROWDUHDDvQY PkQWXOXLQD LRQDOFX DOIDEHW ODWLQ SUHGDUHD vQ OLPED PDWHUQ LQFOXVLY VXV LQHUHD VHUYLFLXOXL GLYLQ &X DFHODúL SULOHM VD FRQVWLWXLW úL $VRFLD LD vQY WRULORU PROGRYHQL GLQ %DVDUDELD úL GH GLQFROR GH 1LVWUX FDUH D DGRSWDW FD SULQFLSDO PLVLXQH VROX LRQDUHDSUREOHPHORUVWULQJHQWHDOHúFROLLQD LRQDOH 3ULPDDGXQDUHDSUHR LORUúLPLUHQLORUEDVDUDEHQLDDYXWORFvQSHULRDGD DSULOLH±PDL VROLFLWkQGXVHDXWRQRPLD%DVDUDELHLFRQVWLWXLUHD XQXL &RQVLOLX VXSUHP VWXGLHUHD OLPELL PDWHUQH D SRSXOD LHL PDMRULWDUH IRORVLUHD OLPELL PDWHUQH vQ DGPLQLVWUD LH MXGHF WRULH ELVHULF UHVSHFWDUHD GUHSWXULORUPLQRULW LORUQD LRQDOH
MXGH HQL FX UHSUH]HQWDQ L DL EDVDUDEHQLORU QXPLUHD XQXL URPkQ EDVDUDEHDQ vQ IXQF LD GH FRPLVDU JXEHUQLDO úL FKLDU FRQYRFDUHD OD &KLúLQ X SH ED] SURSRU LRQDO D 6IDWXOXL ULL FDUH V SURFODPH DXWRQRPLD%DVDUDELHLSHWHPHLQD LRQDOúLWHULWRULDO,PSRUWDQWHDXIRVWúL GHFL]LLOH &RQJUHVXOXL RVW úHúF vQWUXQLW OD &KLúLQ X RFWRPEULH QRLHPEULH±RFWRPEULHQRLHPEULH FDUHDSURFODPDWDXWRQRPLD WHULWRULDO úLSROLWLF D%DVDUDELHLúLFRQVWLWXLUHD6IDWXOXL ULL &DXUPDUHvQWUXQLWvQWUHQRLHPEULHGHFHPEULHGHFHPEULH 6IDWXO ULL ± RUJDQ VXSUHP DO SXWHULL GH VWDW vQ %DVDUDELD úL 7UDQVQLVWULD ± D SURFODPDW %DVDUDELD OD GHFHPEULH 5HSXEOLFD 'HPRFUDWLF 0ROGRYHQHDVF vQ FRPSXQHUHD 5HSXEOLFLL )HGHUDWLYH 'HPRFUDWLFH 5XVH 'HFODUD LD DGRSWDW SUHYHGHD FRQYRFDUHD $GXQ ULL 3RSXODUH D 5HSXEOLFLL 'HPRFUDWLFH 0ROGRYHQHúWL vPS U LUHD HJDO D S PkQWXOXLOD UDQLI U SODW ]LXDGHOXFUXGHRUHOLEHUWDWHDFXYkQ WXOXLSUHVHLGUHSWXULHJDOHSHQWUXWR LFRQORFXLWRULL3XWHUHDH[HFXWLY D IRVW vQFUHGLQ DW &RQVLOLXOXL 'LUHFWRULORU *HQHUDOL FRQVWLWXLW OD GHFHPEULH FDUHODGHFHPEULH DGHFLVWULPLWHUHDOD,DúLDXQHL GHOHJD LL FDUH V FHDU JXYHUQXOXL URPkQ úL UHSUH]HQWDQ LORU SXWHULORU $QWDQWHLDMXWRUPLOLWDUSHQWUXDSXQHFDS WMDIXULORUúLDVDVLQDWHORUFRPLVH GH JUXSXULOH EROúHYLFH úL RVWDúLL UXúL 8QLUHD URPkQLORU GH SH DPEHOH PDOXUL DOH 3UXWXOXL D IRVW FHUXW úL GH URPkQLL WUDQVQLVWUHQL vQWUXQL L vQ FRQJUHVOD7LUDVRSROvQWUH±GHFHPEULH 2QRX HWDS vQSURFHVXOXQLULLDDYXWORFODLDQXDULHIHEUXDULH ]L VLPEROLF SHQWUX URPkQL FkQG 6IDWXO ULL D YRWDW vQ XQDQL PLWDWH LQGHSHQGHQ D 5HSXEOLFLL 'HPRFUDWLFH 0ROGRYHQHúWL LDU SXWHUHD H[HFXWLY DIRVWvQFUHGLQ DW XQXL&RQVLOLXOGH0LQLúWUL vQORFXO&RQVLOLXO 'LUHFWRULORUFDUHVDGL]ROYDW
$OF WXLWGLQ GHSXWD L URPkQLúLDLPLQRULW LORU DOHúLSULQ DOHJHUL LQGLUHFWH GH F WUH FRPLWHWHOH RU úHQHúWL U QHúWL PXQFLWRUHúWL úL GH FRUSRUD LLOHSURIHVLRQDOHFRQVWLWXLWH ,VWRULD5RPkQLHLvQGDWH(GLWXUD(QFLFORSHGLF %XFXUHúWLSS &X DFHO SULOHM DX IRVW DOHúL FDQGLGD L WUDQVQLVWUHQL SHQWUX DOHJHULOH SHQWUXSDUODPHQWXO5HSXEOLFLL8FUDLQHQHGHFDUHGHSLQGHDXGLQSXQFWGHYHGHUH DGPLQLVWUDWLYORFDOLW LOHGLQVWkQJD1LVWUXOXL
0RPHQWXO ILQDO D DYXW ORF OD PDUWLH DSULOLH FkQG SULQ ULL Ä5HSXEOLFD 'HPRFUDWLF 0ROGRYHQHDVF GHFL]LD 6IDWXOXL %DVDUDELD vQKRWDUHOHHLGLQWUH3UXW1LVWUX'XQ UHúL0DUHD1HDJU úL YHFKLOHJUDQL HFX$XVWULDUXSW GH5XVLDDFXPRVXW úLPDLELQHGHDQL GLQ WUXSXO YHFKLL 0ROGRYH vQ SXWHUHD GUHSWXOXL LVWRULF úL D GUHSWXOXL GH QHDPSHED]DSULQFLSLXOXLF QRURDGHOHVLQJXUHV úLKRW UDVF VRDUWDORU GH D]L vQDLQWH úL SHQWUX WRWGHDXQD VH XQHúWH FX 5RPkQLD´ &X DFHODúL SULOHM VD GHFLV FD 6IDWXO ULL FHO H[LVWHQW V úL FRQWLQXH PDL GHSDUWH DFWLYLWDWHDSHQWUXÄUH]ROYDUHDúLUHDOL]DUHDUHIRUPHLDJUDUHGXS QHYRLOH úLFHUHULOHQRURGXOXL´ %DVDUDELDV úLS VWUH]HÄDXWRQRPLDSURYLQFLDO ´ DYkQGXQ6IDWDO ULL 'LHW DOHVvQYLLWRUSULQYRWXQLYHUVDOHJDOGLUHFW úL VHFUHW UHFUXWDUHD DUPDWHL V VH IDF vQ SULQFLSLX SH ED]H WHULWRULDOH OHJLOHvQYLJRDUHV U PkQ vQYLJRDUHSkQ FH3DUODPHQWXOURPkQOHYD VFKLPED FXSDUWLFLSDUHDUHSUH]HQWDQ LORU%DVDUDELHL UHVSHFWDUHDGUHSWX ULORU PLQRULW LORU GLQ %DVDUDELD LQFOXGHUHD D GRL UHSUH]HQWDQ L DL %DVDUDELHLvQJXYHUQXOURPkQGHOD%XFXUHúWL GHVHPQD LGH6IDWXO ULL WULPLWHUHD vQ 3DUODPHQWXO URPkQ D XQXL QXP U GH UHSUH]HQWDQ L SURSRU LRQDOFXSRSXOD LDúLDOHúLSHED]DYRWXOXLXQLYHUVDOHJDOGLUHFWúL VHFUHW GHVI úXUDUHD vQ %DVDUDELD D WXWXURU DOHJHULORU SH ED]D YRWXOXL XQLYHUVDOVHFUHWúLGLUHFW DVLJXUDUHDSULQ&RQVWLWX LHDOLEHUW LLSHUVRQDOH WLSDUXOXL FXYkQWXOXL úL FUHGLQ HL DPQLVWLHUHD WXWXURU F OF ULORU GH OHJH I FXWH GLQ PRWLYH SROLWLFH vQ YUHPXULOH WXOEXUL DOH SUHIDFHULL GLQ XUP ´ 7RDWHFHOHGHPDLVXVXUPDXV ILHLQFOXVHvQ&RQVWLWX LHFDUHXUPDV ILH HODERUDW GH &RQVWLWXDQWD FH WUHEXLD D IL FRQYRFDW ÄQHvQWkU]LDW´ úL GLQ FDUH XUPDX V IDF SDUWH SURSRU LRQDO FX SRSXOD LD úL UHSUH]HQWDQ LL %DVDUDELHLDOHúLSULQYRWXQLYHUVDOHJDOGLUHFWúLVHFUHW $XUPDWSURPXOJDUHD'HFUHWXOXL5HJDOGLQQUGLQ DSULOLH úL'HFODUD LDSUHúHGLQWHOXL&RQVLOLXOXLGH0LQLúWULSULQFDUHVDOXDW DFWGHGHFL]LD6IDWXOXL ULLGHOD&KLúLQ XSULYLQGXQLUHD%DVDUDELHLFX
%DVDUDELD VD XQLW FX 5RPkQLD FX YRW PDMRULWDU YRWXUL SHQWUX XQLUHFRQWUDúLDE LQHUL ,RDQ6FXUWX5RPkQLDúL0DULOH3XWHUL (GLWXUD)XQGD LHL 5RPkQLDGH0kLQH%XFXUHúWL SS
5RPkQLD DGRSWDUHD /HJLL GLQ DSULOLH PDL FX SULYLUH OD DGPLQLVWUDUHD%DVDUDELHL SUHYHGHDXQLILFDUHDDGPLQLVWUDWLY úLOHJLVODWLY DDFHVWHLDvQFRPSRQHQ D5RPkQLHL YRWDUHDGHF WUH6IDWXO ULLOD QRLHPEULH GHFHPEULH D /HJLL DJUDUH SHQWUX %DVDUDELD UHQXQ DUHD GH F WUH 6IDWXO ULL OD QRLHPEULH GHFHPEULH OD FRQGL LLOHGHXQLUHVWLSXODWHvQDFWXOGLQPDUWLH úLGHFODUDUHDXQLULL QHFRQGL LRQDWHFX5RPkQLD 8QLUHD%XFRYLQHL/DVIkUúLWXODQXOXL FkQGHUDFODUF ]LOHOH ,PSHULXOXLDXVWURXQJDUHUDXQXP UDWH$GXQDUHD&RQVWLWXDQW FRQYRFDW OD &HUQ X L RFWRPEULH OD LQVLVWHQ HOH LQWHOHFWXDOLW LL URPkQHúWL GLQ %XFRYLQD D YRWDW R 5H]ROX LH FDUH SUHYHGHD ÄXQLUHD %XFRYLQHL LQWHJUDOH FX FHOHODOWH UL URPkQHúWL vQWUXQ VWDW QD LRQDO LQGHSHQGHQW´ &X DFHODúL SULOHM VD FRQVWLWXLW XQ &RQVLOLX 1D LRQDO VLQJXUXO vQ P VXU ÄD KRW Uv VDX WUDWD DVXSUD SRSRUXOXL URPkQ GLQ %XFRYLQD´/DUkQGXL&RQVLOLXO1D LRQDODLQVWLWXLWXQJXYHUQIRUPDWGLQ VHFUHWDULGHVWDWvQIUXQWHFX,DQFX)ORQGRUFDUHDFHUXWJXYHUQDWRUXOXL DXVWULDF V L WUDQVPLW vQWUHDJD SXWHUH vQ %XFRYLQD úL D I FXW FXQRVFXW JXYHUQXOXLURPkQGHFL]LLOH&RQVWLWXDQWHL ÌQXUPDGHYDVW ULORUV YkUúLWHGHEDQGHOHGHXFUDLQHQLúLGHWUXSHOH DXVWULHFH DIODWH vQ UHWUDJHUH D FOLPDWXOXL GH WHURDUH LQVWLWXLW vPSRWULYD URPkQLORU úL D SUHWHQ LLORU VHSDUDWLVWH DOH RILFLDOLORU XFUDLQHQL FDUH DX RFXSDW FKLDU 3DODWXO 1D LRQDO GLQ &HUQ X L FRQVWLWXLQG XQ JXYHUQ &RQVLOLXO 1D LRQDO D FHUXW OD RFWRPEULH QRLHPEULH DMXWRU PLOLWDUJXYHUQXOXLURPkQ&DXUPDUH'LYL]LDLQIDQWHULHFRPDQGDW GH JHQHUDOXO ,DNRE =DGLN D LQWUDW RFWRPEULH QRLHPEULH vQ HQWX]LDVPXOSRSXOD LHLvQ&HUQ X LSHUPL kQG&RQVLOLXOXL1D LRQDOV úL DVXPH vQWUHDJD SXWHUH vQ VWDW 3X LQ PDL WkU]LX &RQJUHVXO JHQHUDO DO
/D GHFHPEULH $GXQDUHD'HSXWD LORUúL6HQDWXO5RPkQLHLDX UDWLILFDW'HFUHWXOOHJHQUGLQ DSULOLH SULYLWRUODXQLUHD%DVDUDELHL FX5RPkQLD /HJHD SUHYHGHD H[SURSULHUHD LQWHJUDO D WXWXURU S PkQWXULORU FDUH DSDU LQHDXFRURDQHL5XVLHL XGHOXUL VWDWXOXL% QFLL U QHúWLúLP Q VWLULORU ]HPVWYHORU SHUVRDQHORU IL]LFH MXULGLFH S PkQWXULORU RUDúHORU SHUVRDQHORU VWU LQH6XEVROXULOHWHUHQXULORUH[SURSULDWHU PkQHDXvQSURSULHWDWHDVWDWXOXL$ IRVWUDWLILFDW SULQ'HFUHWHOHUHJDOHGLQúL GHFHPEULH /D PDUWLH 3DUODPHQWXO5RPkQLHLDDGRSWDWvQXQDQLPLWDWH/HJHDUHIRUPHL DJUDUHSHQWUX%DVDUDELD
%XFRYLQHL vQWUXQLW OD QRLHPEULH D FRQVWDWDW F FHDVXO ÄD VXQDW´ úL ÄvQ QXPHOH VXYHUDQLW LL QD LRQDOH´ D GHFLV Ä8QLUHD QHFRQGL LRQDW úL SHQWUX YHFLH D %XFRYLQHL vQ YHFKLOH HL KRWDUH SkQ OD &HUHPXú&RODFLQúL1LVWUXFX5HJDWXO5RPkQLHL´ 'HFL]LD OLEHU FRQVLP LW D URPkQLORU EXFRYLQHQL D IRVW UDWLILFDW SULQ 'HFUHWUHJDO OD GHFHPEULH úL FRQILUPDW GH F WUH 3DUODPHQWXOGHOD%XFXUHúWLOD GHFHPEULH ÌQDQXOXUP WRUOD LXQLH &RQVLOLXO 1D LRQDO 3RORQH] GLQ %XFRYLQD úLD H[SULPDW DGH]LXQHDODDFWXOGHXQLUHDO%XFRYLQHLFX5RPkQLD 8QLUHD 7UDQVLOYDQLHL 0DUDPXUHúXOXL &ULúDQHL úL %DQDWXOXL ÌQWU XQFRQWH[WLQWHUQD LRQDODVHP Q WRUVDXLQWHQVLILFDWúLDF LXQLOHXQLRQLVWH vQ 7UDQVLOYDQLD 0DUDPXUHú &ULúDQD úL %DQDW 3HQWUX D IDFH FXQRVFXW RSLQLHL SXEOLFH PRQGLDOH UHYHQGLF ULOH URPkQLORU GH SHVWH PXQ L úL MXVWH HDOXSWHLSHQWUXFDX]DQD LRQDO DURPkQLORURGHOHJD LHDURPkQLORU WUDQVLOY QHQLvQIUXQWHFX9DVLOH/XFDFLXSUHúHGLQWHOH/LJLL&XOWXUDOHD SOHFDWODDSULOLH OD:DVKLQJWRQÌQDFHODúLVFRSOD/RQGUDVD vQILLQ DW vQ YDUD DQXOXL 6RFLHWDWHD DQJORURPkQ LDU OD 3DULV OD DSULOLH &RPLWHWXO 1D LRQDO DO URPkQLORU GLQ 7UDQVLOYDQLD úL %XFRYLQDVXESUHúHGLQ LDOXL7UDLDQ9XLDDSRLDGU,&DQWDFX]LQRFDUH D PLOLWDW SHQWUX DFRUGDUHD LQGHSHQGHQ HL 7UDQVLOYDQLHL úL DSRL SHQWUX XQLUHDDFHVWHLDFX5RPkQLD /D VHSWHPEULH RFWRPEULH &RPLWHWXO ([HFXWLY DO 3DUWLGXOXL1D LRQDO5RPkQGLQ7UDQVLOYDQLDvQWUXQLWOD2UDGHDDDGRSWDWvQ XQDQLPLWDWH'HFODUD LDGHLQGHSHQGHQ FDUHDQHJDWGUHSWXO3DUODPHQWXOXL úL JXYHUQXOXL XQJDU GH D PDL GHFLGH vQ QXPHOH URPkQLORU úL GH DL UHSUH]HQWD OD &RQIHULQ D GH SDFH SUHFL]kQG F DFHVW DWULEXW UHYHQHD UHSUH]HQWDQ LORU DOHúL GH SURSULD $GXQDUH 1D LRQDO &LWLW GH $OH[DQGUX 9DLGDvQ3DUODPHQWXOGHOD%XGDSHVWD RFWRPEULH 'HFODUD LDGH OD 2UDGHD D UHSUH]HQWDW XQ GRFXPHQW I U SUHFHGHQW vQ FDGUXO GXEOHL PRQDUKLLILLQGSULPLW FXHQWX]LDVPGHURPkQLLGHSUHWXWLQGHQLvQVSHFLDO GH URPkQLL GLQ SURYLQFLLOH URPkQHúWL DOH LPSHULXOXL FDUH DX vQFHSXW V DUERUH]H WULFRORUXO QD LRQDO V LQWRQH]H FkQWHFH SDWULRWLFH V LQWURGXF OLPEDURPkQ vQúFROLúLDGPLQLVWUD LH'RFXPHQWXODFRQVWLWXLWvQDFHODúL WLPSúLXQU VSXQVFODUODPDQLIHVWXOÄ& WUHSRSRDUHOHPHOHFUHGLQFLRDVH´
,RDQ6FXUWX5RPkQLDúL0DULOH3XWHUL (GLWXUD)XQGD LHL 5RPkQLDGH0kLQH%XFXUHúWL S
HPLVGHvPS UDWXO&DURO,GH+DEVEXUJ RFWRPEULH SULQFDUHVH SURSXQHD UHRUJDQL]DUHD $XVWUR8QJDULHL vQWUR FRQIHGHUD LH IRUPDW GLQ úDVH VWDWH ÄLQGHSHQGHQWH´ DXVWULDF XQJDU FHK LXJRVODY SRORQH] úL XFUDLQHDQ 3ULQ XUPDUH 7UDQVLOYDQLD XUPD V U PkQ vQ FRQWLQXDUH vQ FRPSRQHQ D 8QJDULHL LDU SDUWHD GH QRUGYHVW D %XFRYLQHL FX RUDúHOH &HUQ X L6WRURMLQH úL6LUHWvQFHDD8FUDLQHL 'UHSWXO PRQDUKLHL DXVWURXQJDUH GH D GHFLGH VRDUWD URPkQLORU GLQ $XVWUR8QJDULD D IRVW FRQWHVWDW úL GH &RPLWHWXO QD LRQDO DO URPkQLORU HPLJUD LGLQ$XVWUR8QJDULDFDUHDDGRSWDWOD,DúL RFWRPEULH R 'HFODUD LH SRWULYQLF 8Q U VSXQV IHUP D GDW vPS UDWXOXL &DURO , GH +DEVEXUJ RFWRPEULH úL &RUSXO YROXQWDULORU WUDQVLOY QHQL úL EXFRYLQHQL FDUH D DGRSWDW R 'HFODUD LH SULQ FDUH VH SURFODPD GH]OLSLUHD SURYLQFLLORUURPkQHúWL7UDQVLOYDQLD%DQDWXO0DUDPXUHúXOúL%XFRYLQDGH $XVWUR8QJDULDúLXQLUHDORUFX5RPkQLD 'XS FHOD RFWRPEULH VRFLDOLúWLLURPkQLWUDQVLOY QHQLDX SURSXV FRQGXFHULL 3DUWLGXOXL 1D LRQDO 5RPkQ IRUPDUHD XQXL &RQVLOLX 1D LRQDO DO URPkQLORU FDUH ÄV SUHLD FRQGXFHUHD WHULWRULLORU ORFXLWH GH URPkQL´ODRFWRPEULH VDFRQVWLWXLW&RQVLOLXO1D LRQDO5RPkQ &HQWUDO FD XQLF RUJDQ GH FRQGXFHUH D URPkQLORU WUDQVLOY QHQL FRQGL LH DVXPDW SULQSURFODPD LD& WUHQD LXQHDURPkQ GLQRFWRPEULH 3HQWUX S VWUDUHD OLQLúWLL vQ ]RQHOH ORFXLWH GH URPkQL úL D IDFH ID UHSUHVDOLLORU DXWRULW LORU úL WUXSHORU XQJDUH &RQVLOLXO 1D LRQDO 5RPkQ &HQWUDO D GHFLV RFWRPEULH QRLHPEULH vQILLQ DUHD GH J U]L QD LRQDOH úL GH J U]L FLYLOH V WHúWL SH vQWUHJ WHULWRULXO ORFXLW GH URPkQL vQ 7UDQVLOYDQLDúL8QJDULD 'XS HúXDUHDWUDWDWLYHORUGHOD$UDG RFWRPEULHQRLHPEULH± QRLHPEULH FXUHSUH]HQWDQ LL&RQVLOLXOXL1D LRQDO0DJKLDUúLDL JXYHUQXOXL.iURO\LFDUHXUP UHDXV VDOYH]H8QJDULD0DUHúLV FUHH]H GLQ7UDQVLOYDQLDRDXWRQRPLHFDQWRQDO GHWLSHOYH LDQ&RQVLOLXO1D LRQDO 5RPkQ &HQWUDO D I FXW FXQRVFXW QRLHPEULH vQ XUPD FRQVXOW ULORU DYXWH FX UHSUH]HQWDQ LL DXWRULW LORU URPkQH GH OD ,DúL FRQYRFDUHD$GXQ UL1D LRQDOHGHOD$OED,XOLD $VWIHOODQRLHPEULHGHFHPEULH vQVDOD&DVLQHLGLQ$OED ,XOLDDXDYXWORFOXFU ULOH$GXQ ULL1D LRQDOHODFDUHDXSDUWLFLSDW GH GHOHJD L DOHúL vQ FLUFXPVFULS LLOH HOHFWRUDOH úL GH GLIHULWH LQVWLWX LL úL RUJDQL]D LL SROLWLFH FXOWXUDOH SURIHVLRQDOH GH vQY PkQW UHOLJLRDVH PLOLWDUHGHIHPHLVLQGLFDWHWF'XS OX ULGHFXYkQWHQWX]LDVWH5H]ROX LD
$GXQ ULL 1D LRQDOH D GHFUHWDW XQLUHD FX 5RPkQLD D UH]HUYDW WHULWRULLORU URPkQHúWL XQLWH FX DUD ÄDXWRQRPLH SURYL]RULH SkQ OD vQWUXQLUHD &RQVWLWXDQWHLDOHDV SHED]DYRWXOXLXQLYHUVDO´úLDSURFODPDW ÄGUHSWXO LQDOLHQDELODOQD LXQLLURPkQHODvQWUHJ%DQDWXOFXSULQVvQWUH0XUHú7LVD úL 'XQ UH´ ÄGHSOLQD OLEHUWDWH QD LRQDO SHQWUX WRDWH SRSRDUHOH FRQOR FXLWRDUH´ ÄHJDOD vQGUHSW LUH úL GHSOLQD OLEHUWDWH DXWRQRP FRQIHVLRQDO SHQWUXWRDWHFRQIHVLXQLOHGLQVWDW´ÄvQI SWXLUHDGHV YkUúLW DXQXLUHJLP FXUDWGHPRFUDWLFSHWRDWHWHUHQHOHYLH LLSXEOLFH´ÄGHV YkUúLWDOLEHUWDWHGH SUHV DVRFLHUH úL vQWUXQLUH´ ÄUHIRUPD DJUDU UDGLFDO ´ HWF &X DFHODúL SULOHM $GXQDUHD 1D LRQDO D VDOXWDW FX ÄLXELUH úL HQWX]LDVP OLEHUDUHD QD LXQLORU VXEMXJDWH SkQ DLFL GH PRQDUKLD DXVWURXQJDU ´ úL D GHFLV FRQVWLWXLUHD0DUHOXL6IDW1D LRQDO5RPkQ FRPSXVGLQGHPHPEUL GLQWUH FDUH DX IRVW DOHúL LPHGLDW FDUH OD UkQGXL D QXPLW &RQVLOLXO 'LULJHQW JXYHUQXOSURYL]RULX 'HFL]LLOHLVWRULFHGHOD$OED,XOLDFDUHDX ILQDOL]DWSURFHVXOLVWRULFGHI XULUHDVWDWXOXLQD LRQDOXQLWDUURPkQDXIRVW DFODPDWH FX HQWX]LDVP GH F WUH FHL SHVWH GH SDUWLFLSDQ L SH &kPSXOOXL+RUHD $GRXD]LGXS DGRSWDUHD5H]ROX LHLGHXQLUH0DUHOH6IDW1D LRQDO úLDGHVHPQDWSUHúHGLQWHOHvQSHUVRDQDOXL*KHRUJKH3RSGH% VHúWLúLD DOHV &RQVLOLXO 'LULJHQW FRQGXV GH ,XOLX 0DQLX 3X LQ PDL WkU]LX GHFHPEULH UHJHOH )HUGLQDG , D HPLV 'HFUHWXOOHJH GH XQLUH D 7UDQVLOYDQLHL &ULúDQHL 0DUDPXUHúXOXL úL %DQDWXOXL FX 5RPkQLD úL 'HFUHWXO GH RUJDQL]DUH SURYL]RULH D 7UDQVLOYDQLHL FRQIRUP F UXLD VHUYLFLLOH SXEOLFH U PkQHDX VXE FRQGXFHUHD &RQVLOLXOXL 'LULJHQW LDU DUPDWD DIDFHULOH VWU LQH F LOH IHUDWH SRúWHOH WHOHJUDIXO WHOHIRDQHOH FLUFXOD LD ILQDQFLDU Y PLOH vPSUXPXWXULOH SXEOLFH úL VLJXUDQ D VWDWXOXL WUHFHDX vQ DGPLQLVWUD LD JXYHUQXOXL GH OD %XFXUHúWL vQ FDGUXO F UXLD 7UDQVLOYDQLDXUPDV ILHUHSUH]HQWDW SULQPLQLúWULI U SRUWRIROLX$SRL OD DFWXO XQLULL DX DGHUDW úL VDúLL GHFHPEULH LDQXDULH HYUHLL PDUWLH úLúYDELL DXJXVW &HOH WUHL GHFL]LL LVWRULFH GH OD &HUQ X L &KLúLQ X úL $OED ,XOLD FRQFUHWL]DUH SULQ XQLUHD FX SDWULDPDP D WXWXURU SURYLQFLLORU LVWRULFH URPkQHúWL DIODWH VXE GRPLQD LH VWU LQ DX vPSOLQLW YLVXO VH VHFROH DO
,RDQ6FXUWXRSFLWS &RQVLOLXO'LULJHQWDO7UDQVLOYDQLHLDIRVWGHVILLQ DWODDSULOLH DWULEX LLOHVDOHWUHFkQGDVXSUDJXYHUQXOXLGHOD%XFXUHúWL
WXWXURU URPkQLORU WRDWH OD XQ ORF FRQVWLWXLQG FHHD FH 1LFRODH ,RUJD GHQXPHDÄFHDPDLPDUHIDSW GLQWRDW YLD DQHDPXOXLURPkQHVF´ 'HV YkUúLUHD XQLW LL QD LRQDO VWDWDOH D URPkQLORU vQ LVWRULFXO DQ QX D IRVW XQ IHQRPHQ L]RODW FL D I FXW SDUWH GLQWUXQ SURFHV PXOW PDLDPSOXGHUXODWvQvQWUHJXOVSD LXFHQWUDOHVWLFúLVXGHVWLFHXURSHDQvQ FRQWH[WXO GHVWU P ULL LPSHULLORU DULVW úL DXVWURXQJDU FRQFUHWL]DW SULQ FRQVWLWXLUHD&HKRVORYDFLHL± RFWRPEULH 8QJDULHL±QRLHPEULH 3RORQLHL±QRLHPEULH$XVWULHL±QRLHPEULH5HJDWXOXL6kUER&URDWR 6ORYHQ±QRLHPEULH $S UDUHDúLFRQILUPDUHDLQWHUQD LRQDO D0DULL8QLUL $S UDUHD 0DULL 8QLUL +RW UkULOH LVWRULFH GH OD $OED ,XOLD DX IRVW SXVHvQSHULFROGHSUHYHGHULOH&RQYHQ LHLGHDUPLVWL LXGHOD%HOJUDGGLQ RFWRPEULH QRLHPEULH vQFKHLDW GH F WUH JHQHUDOXO )UDQFKHW GeVSHUH\ vQQXPHOHWUXSHORUDOLDWH FXJXYHUQXOXQJDUSULQFDUHFXUVXO 0XUHúXOXLHUDVWDELOLWvQPRGDUELWUDU úLvQFRQWUDGLF LHFXWUDWDWXOSROLWLF úLFRQYHQ LDPLOLWDU vQFKHLDW vQ FX5RPkQLD FDOLQLDGHGHPDUFD LH vQWUH WUXSHOH DOLDWH úL DUPDWD XQJDU &D XUPDUH vQVHPQDWH S U L GLQ 7UDQVLOYDQLD %DQDW &ULúDQD úL 0DUDPXUHú HUDX O VDWH VXE DXWRULWDWHD JXYHUQXOXLGHOD%XGDSHVWD 'XS PXOWHFRQWHVWD LLúLWUDWDWLYHFXJHQHUDOXO)UDQFKHWGeVSHUH\ úL FX VSULMLQXO JHQHUDOXOXL +0%HUWKHORW WUXSHOH URPkQH DX SULPLW OD GHFHPEULH SHUPLVLXQHD GH D GHS úL OLQLD GH GHPDUFD LH D 0XUHúXOXLúLDGHYHQLvQVSULMLQXOSRSXOD LHLURPkQHúWLVXSXV YLROHQ HORU DXWRULW LORUPDJKLDUH&XWRDWHF WUXSHOHURPkQHDXSXWXWS WUXQGHDVWIHO vQ &OXM &ULúDQD úL %DQDWXO DX FRQWLQXDW V U PkQ vQ DIDUD JUDQL HORU 5RPkQLHLFKLDUGDF ODIHEUXDULH &RQVLOLXO0LOLWDU,QWHUDOLDWD DSUREDW FD WUXSHOH URPkQH V vQDLQWH]H SkQ SH DOLQLDPHQWXO 6DWX 0DUH &DUHL2UDGHD6DORQWD$UDG GLQFROR GH FDUH VD FRQVWLWXLW OD IHEUXDULH RÄ]RQ QHXWU ´ vQWUH5RPkQLDúL8QJDULD FDUHXUPDV ILHRFXSDW GHWUXSHIUDQFH]HHQJOH]HLWDOLHQHHYHQWXDODPHULFDQH
Ä1HDPXO URPkQHVF´ GLQ QRLHPEULH Ä3HQWUX QRL ± FRQWLQXD LOXVWUXO VDYDQW ± H R QHFHVLWDWH LVWRULF DMXQV OD UHFXQRDúWHUH úL R VXIHULQ PkQJkLDW RPXQF FHúLJ VHúWHU VSODWDùLDVWIHODYHPGUHSWXOGHDFUHGH DFHVWIDSWGHILQLWLYúLHWHUQ´
5HIX]XO5HSXEOLFLL8QJDUHD6IDWXULORUSURFODPDW ODPDUWLH PRELOL]DUHD PLOLWDU GHFUHWDW GH QRXO JXYHUQ GH OD %XGDSHVWD GHFODUD LDF 8QJDULDVHDIODvQVWDUHGHU ]ERLFXÄWRDWHVWDWHOHYHFLQHGH OD FDUH DUH FHYD GH UHYHQGLFDW´ úL DWDFXO GHFODQúDW OD DSULOLH vPSRWULYD 5RPkQLHL DX SURYRFDW ULSRVWD FRPDQGDPHQWXOXL úL WUXSHORU URPkQH vQWUH úL DSULOLH DFFHSWDW GH F WUH FRPDQGDPHQWXO DOLDW FDUH DX vQDLQWDW SkQ OD OLPLWD YHVWLF D Ä]RQHL QHXWUH´ úL DSRL GDWRULW LPSHUDWLYHORU GH RUGLQ PLOLWDU SkQ SH FXUVXO 7LVHL PDL I U FD DFHDVWDV GHWHUPLQHJXYHUQXOXQJDUV UHQXQ HODLQWHQ LLOHVDOHDJUHVLYH SXVHGLQQRXvQSUDFWLF ODLXOLH FkQGDUPDWDPDJKLDU DDWDFDW SHIURQWXO7LVHLUHVSLQJkQGWUXSHOHURPkQH) U V PDLDúWHSWHDSUREDUHD VDXDMXWRUXO&RQVLOLXOXL6XSUHP,QWHUDOLDWDUPDWDURPkQ DFRQWUDDWDFDW ODLXOLHIRU kQGLDU7LVD LXOLH úLvQDLQWkQGVSUH%XGDSHVWDvQFDUH DXS WUXQVODDXJXVW 3UH]HQ D WHPSRUDU D DUPDWHL URPkQH SH WHULWRULXO 8QJDULHL vQ WLPSXO F UHLD PLOLWDULL URPkQL DX JDUDQWDW OLQLúWHD DYXWXO úL YLD D FHW HQLORUQHLQWHUYHQLQGvQYLD DSROLWLF DDYXWXQFDUDFWHUSXUPLOLWDU OXkQG VIkUúLW vQ QRLHPEULH FkQG WUXSHOH URPkQH DX vQFHSXW V VH UHWUDJ GLQ 8QJDULD /D GRX ]LOH GXS FH PLOLWDULL URPkQL DX S U VLW %XGDSHVWD QRLHPEULH IRU HOH DOLDWH DX SHUPLV LQWUDUHD vQ FDSLWDOD 8QJDULHLDWUXSHORUFRPDQGDWHGHDPLUDOXO+RUWK\0LNORV &RQFRPLWHQW WUXSHOH URPkQH DX LQWHUYHQLW SHQWUX DS UDUHD QRLORU IURQWLHUHGLQHVWXOúLQRUGHVWXO ULLvQ%DVDUDELDúL%XFRYLQDvPSRWULYD DWDFXULORUúLSURYRF ULORUUXVHúWLúLXFUDLQLHQH &RQILUPDUHD LQWHUQD LRQDO &RQFRPLWHQW FX DS UDUHD 0DULL8QLUL SULQ IRU D DUPHORU JXYHUQXO URPkQ D GHVI úXUDW R VXV LQXW DFWLYLWDWH GLSORPDWLF SHQWUXFRQILUPDUHDLQWHUQD LRQDO DDFHVWHLDSULQWUDWDWHOHFDUH VHSUHJ WHDXvQFDGUXO&RQIHULQ HLGHSDFHFDUHúLDGHVFKLVOXFU ULOHOD
%pOOD
3UHúHGLQWHDIRVWGHVHPQDW*DUEDL6iQGRULDUPLQLVWUXGH([WHUQH.XQ
ÌQFHSkQG FX DSULOLH 5RPkQLD D DGRSWDW FDOHQGDUXO JUHJRULDQ ]LXDGHDSULOLHVWLOYHFKLGHYHQLQGDSULOLHVWLOQRX .XQ%pOODDS U VLW%XGDSHVWDUHIXJLLQGXVHOD9LHQD 3HODUJ 'XPLWUX3UHGD9DVLOH$OH[DQGUHVFX&RVWLF 3URGDQÌQ DS UDUHD5RPkQLHL0DUL&DPSDQLDDUPDWHLURPkQHGLQ (GLWXUD (QFLFORSHGLF %XFXUHúWL
3DULV OD LDQXDULH 3ULQWUH FHOH GH VWDWH FDUH úLDX WULPLV GHOHJD LLOD&RQIHULQ DS FLLVDDIODWúL5RPkQLDSODVDW SULQWUH ULOHFX ÄLQWHUHVH OLPLWDWHVSHFLDOH´ vQ SRILGD WUDWDWXOXL SROLWLF GLQ úL D IDSWXOXLF ODVIkUúLWXOU ]ERLXOXLDI FXWSDUWHGLQJUXSXOFHORUGHVWDWH vQYLQJ WRDUH &D XUPDUH vQ WLPSXO OXFU ULORU IRUXPXOXL PRQGLDO ,,&%U WLDQX úHIXO GHOHJD LHL URPkQH D SURWHVWDW GHVHRUL ID GH WUDWDPHQWXO GLVFULPLQDWRULX DSOLFDW 5RPkQLHL úL FHORUODOWH VWDWH PLFL úL PLMORFLL D SUH]HQWDWHIRUWXOGHU ]ERLDO ULL OD LDQXDULHIHEUXDULH DI FXW HIRUWXUL GHRVHELWH SHQWUX FD LQWHUHVHOH HL QD LRQDOH V ILH VDWLVI FXWH vQ YLUWXWHDGUHSWXOXLLVWRULF ÌQ ILQDO &RQIHULQ D D FRQVDFUDW SULQ WUDWDWHOH GH SDFH vQFKHLDWH DFWHOH XQLULL URPkQLORU GLQ XQLUHD %XFRYLQHL ± SULQ WUDWDWXO FX $XVWULDGHOD6DLQW*HUPDLQ VHSWHPEULH úLXQLUHD7UDQVLOYDQLHL %DQDWXOXL &ULúDQHL úL 0DUDPXUHúXOXL ± SULQ WUDWDWXO FX 8QJDULD GH OD 7ULDQRQ LXQLH JUDQL DURPkQREXOJDU VWDELOLW SULQWUDWDWXOGHOD %XFXUHúWLGLQDXJXVW DIRVWUHFRQILUPDW SULQWUDWDWXOFX%XOJDULDGH OD 1HXLOO\ VXU 6HLQH QRLHPEULH &RQFRPLWHQW 7UDWDWXO IURQWLHUHORU GH OD 6HYUHV vQFKHLDW vQWUH SULQFLSDOHOH SXWHUL $OLDWH úL $VRFLDWH SH GH R SDUWH úL 3RORQLD &HKRVORYDFLD 5RPkQLD úL 5HJDWXO 6kUER&URDWR6ORYHQSHGHDOW SDUWHDUHFRQILUPDWVXYHUDQLWDWHDDFHVWRU VWDWH DVXSUD WHULWRULLORU GHVHPQDWH GH &RQIHULQ D GH SDFH )URQWLHUHOH 5RPkQLHL DYHDX V PDL ILH UHFXQRVFXWH úL SULQ WUDWDWXO GH OD /DXVDQQH vQFKHLDWFX7XUFLDODLXOLH FDUHDvQORFXLWWUDWDWXOGHOD6HYUHVGLQ ÌQ DEVHQ D 5XVLHL 6RYLHWLFH GH OD OXFU ULOH FRQIHULQ HL GH SDFH ÄVXYHUDQLWDWHD5RPkQLHLDVXSUDWHULWRULXOXL%DVDUDELHL´DIRVWUHFXQRVFXW SULQ WUDWDWXO GH SDFH GH OD 3DULV GLQ RFWRPEULH VHPQDW GH 5RPkQLDSHGHRSDUWHúL0DUHD%ULWDQLH)UDQ D,WDOLDúL-DSRQLDSHGH DOW SDUWH vQ ED]D GHFODUD LHL GLQ PDUWLH D &RQVLOLXOXL 6XSUHP $OLDW
&DUH vQVR HD WUDWDWXO GH SDFH FX 7XUFLD vQFKHLDW OD DFHHDúL GDW vQ DFHHDúLORFDOLWDWH $UW úL SUHFL]DX IURQWLHUHOH 5RPkQLHL FX VWDWHOH YHFLQH FRQVHPQkQGSXQFWHOHPDLLPSRUWDQWHGHJUDQL
&RQVDFUDUHDLQWHUQD LRQDO DJUDQL HORU5RPkQLHLVDI FXWFXPDUL GLILFXOW LGDWRULW LQWHUHVHORUVWUDWHJLFHúLHFRQRPLFH DOHPDULORUSXWHUL QHFXQRDúWHULLDGHY UDWHLUHDOLW LLVWRULFHHWQLFHúLJHRJUDILFHvQFHUF ULORU GHOHJD LHL XQJDUH vQ VSHFLDO GH D PHQ LQH KRWDUHOH IRVWXOXL ,PSHULX DO 6IkQWXOXL ùWHIDQ ÌQ DFHVW VHQV vQ JXYHUQXO XQJDU DWU JkQGXúL VSULMLQXOXQRUSROLWLFLHQLúLRDPHQLGHDIDFHULIUDQFH]LúLHQJOH]LDODQVDW LGHHD FRQVWLWXLULL XQHL &RQIHGHUD LL D VWDWHORU GDQXELHQH FRPE WXW YLUXOHQWGHF WUHJXYHUQHOH5RPkQLHL&HKRVORYDFLHLúL,XJRVODYLHLFDUH DX UHXúLW vQ V GHWHUPLQH JXYHUQHOH GH OD 3DULV úL /RQGUD V DEDQGRQH]HDFHDVW LGHH ÌQ FRQWH[WXO vQ FDUH R PDUH SDUWHDWHULWRULXOXLURPkQHVFVHDIODVH VXE RFXSD LH JHUPDQ WLPS GH DSURDSH GRL DQL SDJXEHOH vQUHJLVWUDWH ULGLFkQGXVH OD PLOLDUGH OHL DXU GHOHJD LD URPkQ D VROLFLWDW UHSDUD LLOHFRUHVSXQ] WRDUHQHDFRUGDWHvQV GHPDULOHSXWHULGHFkWvQWUR IRDUWHPLF P VXU ÌQDEVHQ DGHOHJD LHLURPkQHFRQIHULQ DGHOD6SDGLQ DUHSDUWL]DW5RPkQLHLRFRW GHQXPDLGLQUHSDUD LLOHJHUPDQHúL GH GLQ FHOH RULHQWDOH DGLF PXOW SUHD SX LQ ID GH SLHUGHULOH vQUHJLVWUDWH úL GH HIRUWXO FRPXQ OD RE LQHUHD YLFWRULHL 'LQ DFHVW PRWLY JXYHUQXOURPkQDYHDV UHIX]HSURFHQWXOLQILPDFRUGDW'XS QXPHURDVH LQVLVWHQ HGHOHJD LLURPkQLDXIRVWSULPL LOD&RQIHULQ DLQWHUDOLDW GHOD /RQGUD LXOLHDXJXVW úL OD FRQIHULQ D PLQLúWULORU GH ILQDQ H GH OD 3DULV LDQXDULH XOWLPD DWULEXLQG 5RPkQLHL GLQ UHSDUD LLOH JHUPDQHúLGLQSULPDMXP WDWHDFHORURULHQWDOHúLGLQFHDGHDGRXD MXP WDWHDFHORURULHQWDOH ÌQILQDO5RPkQLDQXDYHDV EHQHILFLH]HQLFL GHDFHDVW PLF SDUWHDWULEXLW
5HOHYkQGDFHVWOXFUX,,&%U WLDQXFRQVHPQDvQLXQLH Ä1XQH SXWHP IDFH LOX]LL QH DIO P vQ ID D DSHWLWXULORU WUXVWXULORU FDUH KRW U VF vQ VSDWHOHOXL:LOVRQ´/DUkQGXLÄ9LLWRUXO´GLQLXQLH FRQVHPQD Ä'DF GHOHJD LDQRDVWU DUILIRVWPDLFXODQW vQFKHVWLDSHWUROXOXLPXOWHXOWLPDWXPXUL QDPILSULPLWúLPXOWHDUWLFROHGHJD]HW LQMXULRDVHvPSRWULYDQRDVWU QXVDUIL VFULVvQWURDQXPLW SUHV GLQ$PHULFDúLGLQ$QJOLD´ (PLOLDQ%ROG9DOHULX)ORULQ'REULQHVFX&RQIHULQ DGHSDFHGHOD3DULV vQ5RPkQLLvQLVWRULDXQLYHUVDO YRO,DúL SS ,ELGHPS ,RQ $JULJRURDLHL 5ROXO úL ORFXO 5RPkQLHL vQ UHOD LLOH LQWHUQD LRQDOH GLQ SHULRDGD LQWHUEHOLF vQ 5RPkQLL vQ LVWRULD XQLYHUVDO YRO ,DúL S
2 DOW SUREOHP FX FDUH VD FRQIUXQWDW GHOHJD LD URPkQ OD FRQIHULQ DGHSDFHGHOD3DULVVDUHIHULWODvQVFULHUHDvQWUDWDWHOHvQFKHLDWH vQVSHFLDOvQFHOFX$XVWULDúLvQFHODOÄPLQRULW LORU´DXQRUFODX]HFDUHV QX OH]H]H VXYHUDQLWDWHD úL LQGHSHQGHQ D VWDWXOXL URPkQ 3URWHVWHORU UHSHWDWH úL YHKHPHQWH I FXWH GH ,,&%U WLDQX UHSUH]HQWDQ LL PDULORU SXWHUL OHDX U VSXQV FX SUHVLXQL úL DPHQLQ UL UHIHULWRDUH FKLDU OD UHFXQRDúWHUHDDSDUWHQHQ HL%XFRYLQHLOD5RPkQLD5H]LVWHQ DURPkQHDVF ODDFHVWHDPHQLQ UL QXDvQFHWDWQLFLGXS UHWUDJHUHDúHIXOXLGHOHJD LHL URPkQHGHOD&RQIHULQ DGHSDFHúLGHPLVLDJXYHUQXOXLSHFDUHvOSUH]LGD *UDY D IRVW IDSWXO F QX DX vQFHWDW QLFL P VXULOH UHVWULFWLYH DOH PDULORU SXWHUL LPSRUWXULOH URPkQHúWL ILLQG SUDFWLF EORFDWH 3ULQ QXPHURDVH XOWLPDWXPXUL JXYHUQXO URPkQ D IRVW DWHQ LRQDW F GDF QXúL UHWULPLWHDGHOHJD LLOD3DULVSHQWUXDVHPQDFHOHGRX WUDWDWH DUDXUPDV ILHH[FOXV GLQUkQGXOSXWHULORUDOLDWHúLDVRFLDWH ÌQWUXQDVHPHQHDFRQWH[WOD GHFHPEULH GHOHJD LDURPkQ FRQGXV GH QRXO SULPPLQLVWUX $OH[DQGUX 9DLGD9RHYRG D UHYHQLW OD 3DULVXQGHDVHPQDWWUDWDWXOGHOD6DLQW*HUPDQLQHQ/D\HFX$XVWULDúL GH OD 1HXLOO\ VXU 6HLQH FX %XOJDULD &X DFHODúL SULOHM D IRVW VHPQDW úL 7UDWDWXOPLQRULW LORUUHIRUPXODWSULQVXSULPDUHDUHIHULULORUOD7UDWDWXOGH OD%HUOLQGLQFXSULYLUHODLQGHSHQGHQ DFRQGL LRQDW D5RPkQLHLúL D DUW úL FDUH SUHYHGHDX OHJL VSHFLDOH SHQWUX HYUHL XOWLPHOH GRX ILLQGvQORFXLWHSULQWUXQDOLQLDWSULQFDUHVHOXDDFWGH'HFUHWXOOHJHGLQ QRLHPEULH FDUHFRQIHUHDDFHVWHLPLQRULW LDFHOHDúLGUHSWXULFXFHOH DOHSRSXOD LHLURPkQH 0RGLILF ULOHRE LQXWHGHF WUHGHOHJD LDURPkQ QXDXvQO WXUDWvQV FRPSOHWSRVLELOLW LOHGHLQWHUYHQ LHDOHPDULORUSXWHUL vQSUREOHPHOHLQWHUQHDOH5RPkQLHL
5HIHULQGXVH OD SR]L LD UHSUH]HQWDQ LORU PDULORU SXWHUL ID GH SUR EOHPHOHULGLFDWHGHGHOHJD LLURPkQL7DNH,RQHVFXFRQVHPQD Ä)UDQFH]LLRIWHD ] FXQRLGDUYRWHD] FX$QJOLDúLPDLDOHVFX$PHULFD´ Ä0RGXO FXP &RQVLOLXO 6XSUHP D WUDWDW VDX PDL ELQH ]LV D PDOWUDWDW 5RPkQLD ± UHFXQRúWHD 5D\PRQG 3RLQFDUp ± HVWH R SURE F GLSORPD LL GHPRFUD LGHGXS U ]ERLDL3XWHULORUPDULvQWRFPDLFDLPSHULDOLúWLLGLQDLQWHGH U ]ERLQDXIRVWODvQ O LPHDWLPSXULORU´ 3UHDPEXOXO 7UDWDWXOXL PLQRULW LORU SUHYHGHD GH DFHDVW GDW F WUD WDWXOÄQXHUDLPSXVFLGLVFXWDWúLFRQYHQLW´vQWUHPDULOHSXWHULúL5RPkQLDIDSW FDUHDQXODFDUDFWHUXOREOLJDWRULXDODFFHSW ULLDQWLFLSDWHDFODX]HORUSUHY ]XWHvQ DUWDOWUDWDWXOXLFX$XVWULD
,,520Æ1,$Ì1&217(;78/ *(232/,7,&,17(5%(/,&
'XS 0DUHD8QLUHGLQ 5RPkQLDDSURPRYDWvQSODQH[WHUQR SROLWLF DFWLY FDUHDYL]DWDS UDUHDLQGHSHQGHQ HLúLVXYHUDQLW LLQD LR QDOHDLQWHJULW LLWHULWRULDOHúLFUHDUHDXQXLFOLPDWGHVHFXULWDWHvQVWDUHV DVLJXUHSDFHDvQ]RQ úLvQ(XURSDvQFRQIRUPLWDWHFXSULQFLSLLOHvQVFULVH vQ3DFWXO6RFLHW LL1D LXQLORUVHPQDWúLGHUHSUH]HQWDQ LL5RPkQLHLvQF GHODHODERUDUH LXQLH vQFKHLQGvQDFHVWVFRSWUDWDWHGHDOLDQ ELúLPXOWLODWHUDOHFXFDUDFWHUGHIHQVLY 5RPkQLDúL0LFDÌQ HOHJHUH ÌQFDGUXOSUHRFXS ULORUSHQWUXDS UDUHDLQGHSHQGHQ HLQD LRQDOHúLD LQWHJULW LL WHULWRULDOH DPHQLQ DWH GH UHYL]LRQLVPXO VWDWHORU QHPXO XPLWH GHGHFL]LLOHRUJDQHORUGHFRQGXFHUHD&RQIHULQ HLGHSDFHGHOD3DULVúLvQ FRQWH[WXOvQFDUHXQHOHFHUFXULSROLWLFHúLHFRQRPLFHIUDQFH]HSUHFRQL]DX FRQVWLWXLUHD XQHL &RQIHGHUD LL GDQXELHQH vQ FDGUXO F UHLD 8QJDULD DU IL XUPDWDDYHDXQVWDWXWSULYLOHJLDWGHOHJD LLOHFHKRVORYDF LXJRVODY úL
3HODUJ9LRULFD0RLVXF,VWRULDUHOD LLORULQWHUQD LRQDOH3kQ ODPLMORFXO VHFROXOXLDO;;OHD(GLWXUD)XQGD LHL5RPkQLDGH0kLQH%XFXUHúWL 0LKDL 5HWHJDQÌQEDODQ DIRU HORU(GLWXUD6(01(%XFXUHúWL $OH[DQGUX2úFD 0DQDJHPHQWXO FUL]HORU UHJLRQDOH (GLWXUD $FDGHPLHL GH ÌQDOWH 6WXGLL 0LOLWDUH %XUHúWL *XYHUQXOXQJDUDvQFUHGLQ DWJUXSXOXLIUDQFH]Ä&UHXVRW´H[SORDWDUHD UH HOHL GH F L IHUDWH XQJDUH úL OXFU ULOH GH UHJXODUL]DUH D FXUVXOXL 'XQ ULL $ SUHWLQV vQ VFKLPE FD 5RPkQLD &HKRVORYDFLD úL ,XJRVODYLD V ILH FRQYLQVH V FHGH]HLQGXVWULHLXQJDUHPDWHULLOHSULPHQHFHVDUHúLV DFFHSWHWDULIHVF ]XWHOD PLMORDFHOH GH WUDQVSRUW FDUH XUPDX D IL VWDELOLWH GH F WUH R FRPLVLH PL[W FX VHGLXO OD %XGDSHVWD ÌQJULMRUDWH JXYHUQHOH URPkQ FHKRVORYDF úL LXJRVODY DX FRPE WXWFXYLJRDUHDFHVWSODQ
URPkQ DX GLVFXWDW FKLDU vQ FDSLWDOD )UDQ HL SUREOHPD FRQVWLWXLULL XQHL DOLDQ H GHIHQVLYH HVWHXURSHQH /D UkQGXOH Y ]kQG vQ DFHDVW LQL LDWLY XQYLLWRUSHULFROSHQWUXLQWHJULWDWHDWHULWRULDO DVWDWHORUORUJXYHUQHOHGH OD3UDJDúL%HOJUDGDXvQFKHLDWODDXJXVW RFRQYHQ LHGHDOLDQ GHIHQVLY GXS FDUH LPHGLDW (GXDUG %HQHã VD GHSODVDW OD %XFXUHúWL SURSXQkQGDGHUDUHD5RPkQLHL &X WRDWH F 7DNH ,RQHVFX PLQLVWUXO GH ([WHUQH URPkQ GRUHD vQFKHLHUHDXQHLDOLDQ HPXOWPDLFXSULQ] WRDUHFDUHV LQFOXG úL3RORQLD úL *UHFLD vQ ILQDO FD XUPDUH D vQFHUF ULL H[vPS UDWXOXL &DURO GH +DEVEXUJ GH D UHYHQL vQ 8QJDULD vQ PDUWLH VSUH DúL UHF S WD WURQXO OD DSULOLH OD %XFXUHúWL D IRVW vQFKHLDW &RQYHQ LD GH DOLDQ GHIHQVLY URPkQRFHKRVORYDF 'RFXPHQWXOSUHYHGHDF ÄvQFD]XOXQXLDWDFQHSURYRFDWGLQSDUWHD 8QJDULHLvPSRWULYDXQHLDGLQÌQDOWHOH3 U L&RQWUDFWDQWHFHDODOW 3DUWHVH DQJDMDV FRQWULEXLHODDS UDUHD3 U LLDWDFDWH´vQFKLSXOGHWHUPLQDWSULQ DQJDMDPHQWXO´FRQIRUPSUHYHGHULORUXQHL&RQYHQ LLPLOLWDUHFDUHXUPDV ILH vQFKHLDW XOWHULRU &X DFHODúL SULOHM FHOH GRX JXYHUQH úLDX OXDW
3HODUJ(OL]D&DPSXV5RPkQLDúL0LFDÌQ HOHJHUH%XFXUHúWL ÌQ YL]LXQHD OXL 7DNH ,RQHVFX DOLDQ D ÄvQ FLQFL´ FRQVWLWXLW vQWUH 5RPkQLD&HKRVORYDFLD,XJRVODYLD3RORQLDúL*UHFLDWUHEXLDV UHSUH]LQWHR EDULHU vPSRWULYD H[SDQVLRQLVPXOXL JHUPDQ vQ (XURSD GH HVW ÌQ DFHVW VHQV D RE LQXW úL DVHQWLPHQWXO JXYHUQHORU GH OD 3DULV )UDQ D FRQVLGHUD 5RPkQLD ÄHOHPHQWXOFHOPDLLPSRUWDQWOD5 V ULW´ 5RPD/RQGUD 0DUHD%ULWDQLHDYHD XQHOHUH]HUYHID GHSDUWLFLSDUHD3RORQLHLSHQWUXDQXVSRULSUHDPXOWLQIOXHQ D IUDQFH] vQ ]RQ 3UDJD %HOJUDG &RQFRPLWHQW D vQFHUFDW V FRQFLOLH]H QHvQ HOHJHULOH SRORQRFHKRVORYDFH ÌQ ILQDO GHRDUHFH 3RORQLD D GRULW V VH DOLH]HQXPDLFX5RPkQLDQXúLFX&HKRVORYDFLDSODQXOOXL7DNH,RQHVFXDIRVW DEDQGRQDW GHFHPEULH GHFL]kQGXVHFD0LFDÌQ HOHJHUHV VHFRQVWLWXLH ÄSHHWDSH´ 5RPkQLD &HKRVORYDFLD úL ,XJRVODYLD DX SURWHVWDW HQHUJLF ID GH DFHDVW SRVLELOLWDWH GHWHUPLQkQG &RQIHULQ D DPEDVDGRULORU GH OD 3DULV V DGRSWH OD PDUWLH R UH]ROX LH SULQ FDUH LQYLWD JXYHUQXO XQJDU V UHVSHFWH KRW UkUHD &RQIHULQ HL GH SDFH GLQ IHEUXDULH SULQ FDUH VH VWDELOLVH F UHVWDXUDUHD +DEVEXUJLORU HUD vQ GLVFRUGDQ FX GHFL]LLOH 3XWHULORU $OLDWHúL$VRFLDWH&RQFRPLWHQWJXYHUQHOHFHORUWUHLVWDWHPHQ LRQDWHDXFHUXW JXYHUQXOXL XQJDU V O vQGHS UWH]H SH IRVWXO vPS UDW ÌQ DFHVW FRQWH[W 3DUODPHQWXOGHOD%XGDSHVWDDDQXODWGUHSWXOGHVXFFHVLXQHODWURQDO&DVHLGH $XVWULD&DUROGH+DEVEXUJILLQGHVFRUWDWvQLQVXOD0DGHLUDGLQ$WODQWLFXQGHD GHFHGDWODDXJXVW
REOLJD LDGHDQXvQFKHLDÄYUHRDOLDQ FXRDWUHLD3XWHUHI U DvQúWLLQ D SUHDODELOFHDODOW 3DUWH´ DUW úLGHDVHVI WXLÄDVXSUDSUREOHPHORUGH SROLWLF H[WHUQ UHODWLYHODUDSRUWXULOHORUFX8QJDULD´ DUW &XWRDWHF vQWUH5RPkQLDúL,XJRVODYLDH[LVWDXXQHOHQHvQ HOHJHULvQ SUREOHPD ELVHULFLORU úL úFROLORU URPkQH GLQ %DQDWXO VkUEHVF OD LXQLH WRW OD %XFXUHúWL D IRVW VHPQDW &RQYHQ LD GH DOLDQ GHIHQVLY URPkQRLXJRVODY FX XQ FRQ LQXW DVHP Q WRU FHOHL GLQWUH 5RPkQLD úL &HKRVORYDFLD FX GHRVHELUHD F GH DFHDVW GDW DOLDQ D IXQF LRQD úL vQ FD]XOXQXLÄDWDFQHSURYRFDW´GLQSDUWHD%XOJDULHL 3ULQ XUPDUH DOLDQ D GLQWUH 5RPkQLD &HKRVORYDFLD úL ,XJRVODYLD 0LFDÌQ HOHJHUH DDYXWGHODvQFHSXWXQFDUDFWHUGHIHQVLYILLQGFRQVWL WXLW FDXQLQVWUXPHQWGHDS UDUHDVWDWXTXRXOXLWHULWRULDOHVWHXURSHDQR UHSOLF ODPDQLIHVW ULOHUHYL]LRQLVWHDOH8QJDULHLvQSULPXOUkQG (DQXDSXWXWILUHDOL]DW ÄvQFLQFL´GHRDUHFH3RORQLDDYHDGLIHUHQGH WHULWRULDOH FX &HKRVORYDFLD ]RQD 7HVFKHQ úL UHOD LL EXQH FX 8QJDULD vQ GHWULPHQWXO VWDWHORU YHFLQH DFHVWHLD &RQFRPLWHQW JXYHUQXO GH OD 9DUúRYLD D DSUHFLDW F DOLDQ D FX )UDQ D IHEUXDULH vL HUD VXILFLHQW SHQWUX VHFXULWDWHD JUDQL HL GH DSXV LDU FHD FX 5RPkQLD PDUWLH SHQWUXFHDGHU V ULW/DUkQGXL*UHFLDQXVDSXWXWLPSOLFD GDWRULW U ]ERLXOXLGXVvPSRWULYD7XUFLHL ÌQU XW LUHD VLWXD LHL LQWHUQD LRQDOH D GHWHUPLQDW FRQGXFHULOH FHORU WUHL VWDWH FDUH FRQVWLWXLDX 0LFD ÌQ HOHJHUH V SURFHGH]H OD UHRUJDQL]DUHD VWUXFWXULORUSROLWLFHúLPLOLWDUHSHQWUXDOHIDFHPDLHILFLHQWH 0DLvQWkLFDXUPDUHDDF LXQLORU,WDOLHLFDUHSULQVLVWHPXOGHWUDWDWH vQFKHLDWH vQFHUFD V L]ROH]H ,XJRVODYLD úL V FUHH]H SUREOHPH 0LFLL ÌQ HOHJHUL VWDWHOH FDUH FRPSXQHDX 0LFD ÌQ HOHJHUH DX vQFHUFDW OD ,RDNLPRY PDL V VWDELOHDVF PLMORDFHOH úL F LOH SHQWUX DWUDJHUHD vQ DOLDQ D 8QJDULHL 5RPkQLD VI WXLQG WRWRGDW ,XJRVODYLD
S
,RDQ6FXUWX5RPkQLDúL0DULOH3XWHUL %XFXUHúWL
&X WRDWH DFHVWHD OD QRLHPEULH 3RORQLD úL &HKRVORYDFLD DX vQFKHLDW R &RQYHQ LH GHIHQVLY 8OWHULRU OD OXFU ULOH XQRUD GLQWUH VHVLXQLOH 0LFLLÌQ HOHJHULDSDUWLFLSDWúLFkWHXQUHSUH]HQWDQWDO3RORQLHL /D VHSWHPEULH FX 5RPkQLD OD QRLHPEULH úL QRLHPEULH FX$OEDQLDODDSULOLH FX8QJDULD 3HQWUXDHYLWDDFHVWOXFUX)UDQ DDvQFKHLDWXQWUDWDWFX,XJRVODYLDOD QRLHPEULH
VSUH VDWLVIDF LD )UDQ HL V GHD GRYDG GH PRGHUD LH &RQFRPLWHQW OD ,RDNLPRYVDGLVFXWDWSUREOHPDVWUkQJHULLOHJ WXULORUHFRQRPLFH GLQWUH FHOH WUHL VWDWH SUHFXP úL GLQWUH 0DULOH 6WDWH 0DMRUH 2 FRQVHFLQ LPH GLDW DFRQIHULQ HLDFRQVWDWvQDPHOLRUDUHDUHOD LLORULXJRVODYRLWDOLHQH $SRL OD IHEUXDULH FD XUPDUH D SODQXULORU DQJORIUDQFH]H GH RUJDQL]DUH HFRQRPLF D (XURSHL FHQWUDOH SULQ UHIDFHUHD XQLW LL HFRQRPLFH D IRVWXOXL ,PSHULX DXVWURXQJDU VWDWHOH 0LFLL ÌQ HOHJHUL DX vQFHUFDW V SXQ ED]HOH SHQWUX R FRODERUDUH HFRQRPLF PDL HILFLHQW úL EHQHILF 'XS FH OD PDL OD %HOJUDG DX IRVW VHPQDWH SURWRFRDOH UHIHULWRDUHODSUHOXQJLUHDFHORUWUHLWUDWDWHGHDOLDQ ODLXQLH OD 6WUEVNp 3OHVVR D IRVW vQFKHLDW XQ DFRUG FRPSOHPHQWDU OD WUDWDWHOH GH DPLFL LHúLGHDOLDQ H[LVWHQWHDUWDODFHVWXLDSUHY ]kQGF vQIXQF LH GHVLWXD LHFHLWUHLPLQLúWULGH([WHUQHSXWHDXGHFLGHGHFRPXQDFRUGFD ÄvQWUR FKHVWLXQH GHWHUPLQDW UHSUH]HQWDUHD VDX DS UDUHD XQXL SXQFW GH YHGHUH V SRDW IL vQFUHGLQ DW VDX XQXL VLQJXU GHOHJDW VDX XQXL VLQJXU VWDW´ &KLDU GDF vQ HOHJHULOH YL]DX PDL PXOW SUREOHPH HFRQRPLFH FDUH GDWRULW FUL]HLHFRQRPLFHQXVDXDSOLFDWGHFL]LLOHGHOD6WUEVNp3OHVVRD UHSUH]HQWDWSULPXODFRUGFRPXQDO0LFLLÌQ HOHJHUL 8QDQPDLWkU]LXODPDL UHSUH]HQWDQ LLFHORUWUHLVWDWHDX VHPQDWR&RQYHQ LDPLOLWDU FDUHSUHFL]DODDUW;,F vQVLWXD LDvQFDUH XQXOGLQWUHVWDWHOHSHFDUHOHUHSUH]HQWDXVDUILJ VLWÄvQVWDUHGHU ]ERLFX LQGLIHUHQWFHVWDW´FHOHODOWHGRX VHDQJDMDXÄGHDO VDV WUHDF úLGHD XúXUD WUDQVSRUWXO PLMORDFHORU SH WHULWRULXO ORU FX GHVWLQD LD VSUH DFHD SXWHUH´
0LQLVWUXOGH([WHUQHLXJRVODYVDGHFODUDWJDWDV vQFKHLHRFRQYHQ LH FRPHUFLDO FX5RPkQLDúLV vQFHDS QHJRFLHULvQDFHODúLVHQVFX&HKRVORYDFLD ÌQ LXQLH D SUH]HQWDW XQ $LGHPpPRLUH SHQWUX FRQVWLWXLUHD XQXL FRPLWHW FDUHV DVLJXUHFRRSHUDUHDHFRQRPLF 6LWXD LDGLIHULW DGH]YROW ULLHFRQRPLFHDGHWHUPLQDWXQHOHSURSXQHUL FDUHOHDXVLWXDWSHSR]L LLGHRVHELWHÌQWLPSFH&HKRVORYDFLDGHH[HPSOXD HODERUDWXQSURLHFWQHRILFLDOGHFUHDUHDXQHLYDVWHvQWUHSULQGHULGHH[SORDWDUHD 'XQ ULLFDUHDUILGXVODLQWHUQD LRQDOL]DUHDIOXYLXOXLDF LXQHDXUPkQGDSRLV SHUPLW FRQVWLWXLUHD XQHL FRQIHGHUD LL GDQXELHQH FX SDUWLFLSDUHD 7XUFLHL VWDW ULYHUDQ0 ULL1HJUH5RPkQLDúL,XJRVODYLDDXSUHIHUDWWUDQVSXQHUHDvQSUDFWLF DGHFL]LLORUOXDWHOD%XFXUHúWLvQ SULYLQGUHDOL]DUHDLPHGLDW DXQXLVLVWHP SUHIHUHQ LDOvQIDYRDUHDSURGXVHORUDJULFROH,QWHUHVHOHHFRQRPLFHDOHFHORUWUHL DOLD LDXI FXWFDDFHVWHSODQXULV QXSRDW ILWUDQVSXVHvQUHDOLWDWH
$SRL OD PLMORFXO OXQLL GHFHPEULH PLQLúWULL GH ([WHUQH DL 5RPkQLHL &HKRVORYDFLHL úL ,XJRVODYLHL DX GHFLV OD %HOJUDG ÄSHUIHF LR QDUHD úL UHRUJDQL]DUHD 0LFLL ÌQ HOHJHUL´ SULQ FUHDUHD XQXL &RQVLOLX FD RUJDQSHUPDQHQWFDUHXUPDV VHvQWUXQHDVF GHWUHLRULSHDQSUHFXPúL DXQXL6HFUHWDULDWSHUPDQHQWFXVHGLXOOD*HQHYD'LVFX LLOHvQYHGHUHD UHRUJDQL] ULLDXIRVWDFFHOHUDWHGHLQFLGHQWXOGHOD+LUWHQEXUJGLQLDQXDULH FkQGVDGHVFRSHULWXQWUDQVSRUWGHDUPHGLQ,WDOLDOLYUDWH8QJDULHL SULQ$XVWULDSUHFXPúLGHSUHOXDUHDSXWHULLvQ*HUPDQLDGHF WUH+LWOHU 5HOXDWH OD úL IHEUXDULH OD *HQHYD GLVFX LLOH DX YL]DW WUDQVIRUPDUHD 0LFLL ÌQ HOHJHUL vQWUXQ RUJDQLVP LQWHUQD LRQDO XQLILFDW ÄGHVFKLVHYHQWXDOúLDOWRUVWDWH´ 3DFWXO GH RUJDQL]DUH DO 0LFLL ÌQ HOHJHUL SXEOLFDW OD IHEUXDULH SUHYHGHDODDUWFRQVWLWXLUHDXQXL&RQVLOLX3HUPDQHQWFRPSXV GLQPLQLúWULLGH([WHUQHDLFHORUWUHLVWDWHVDXGLQGHOHJD LVSHFLDOLFD ÄRUJDQ GLUHFWRU DO SROLWLFLL FRPXQH´ KRW UkULOH XUPkQG D IL OXDWH vQ XQDQLPLWDWH ÌQ DIDUD ÄUDSRUWXULORU VDOH UHJXODWH SH FDOH GLSORPDWLF ´ &RQVLOLXO3HUPDQHQWXUPDV VHvQWUXQHDVF ÄvQPRGREOLJDWRULX´GHFHO SX LQWUHLRULSHDQ$UWSUHYHGHDSULQFLSLXOÄHJDOLW LLDEVROXWH´DFHORU WUHLVWDWHvQOXDUHDGHFL]LLORUúLvQUDSRUWXULOHFXWHU LLLDUDUWVWDELOHDF vQ IXQF LH GH VLWXD LH &RQVLOLXO 3HUPDQHQW SXWHD V GHFLG FD vQWUR DQXPLW SUREOHP ÄUHSUH]HQWD LXQHDVDXDS UDUHDSXQFWXOXLGHYHGHUHDO VWDWHORU 0LFLL ÌQ HOHJHUL V ILH vQFUHGLQ DW XQXL VLQJXU GHOHJDW VDX GHOHJD LXQLL XQXL VLQJXU VWDW´ &X DFHODúL SULOHM D IRVW FRQVWLWXLW XQ &RQVLOLX (FRQRPLF DO VWDWHORU 0LFLL ÌQ HOHJHUL SHQWUX ÄFRRUGRQDUHD SURJUHVLY DLQWHUHVHORUHFRQRPLFH´DOHFHORUWUHL ULILHvQWUHHOHILHvQ UDSRUWXULOH FX VWDWH WHU H SUHFXP úL XQ 6HFUHWDULDW DO &RQVLOLXOXL
&XDFHOSULOHM(GXDUG%HQHãDFHUXWFD0LFDÌQ HOHJHUHV úLVFKLPEH QXPHOH vQ /LJD SHQWUX (XURSD &HQWUDO vQ FDUH V SRDW LQWUD úL DOWH VWDWH SUHFXP 3RORQLD ÌQ FDGUXO GLVFX LLORU %HQHV úL -HIWLF DX PDL SUHFRQL]DW UHDOL]DUHD XQHL HFRQRPLL GLULMDWH FDUH V IDF GLQ 0LFD ÌQ HOHJHUH ÄXQ EORF LQGLYL]LELO´SHQWUXDSHUPLWHDGHUDUHDúLD8QJDULHLúL$XVWULHL$FHVWOXFUXDUIL GXV OD vQF OFDUHD VXYHUDQLW LL VWDWHORU FRPSRQHQWH IDSW UHVSLQV GH 1LFRODH 7LWXOHVFX 3UREOHPH DX DS UXW úL GDWRULW HFRQRPLHL SUHSRQGHUHQW DJUDUH D 5RPkQLHLúL,XJRVODYLHLúLLQGXVWULDOHD&HKRVORYDFLHL ,RDQ6FXUWXRSFLWSS )XQF LD GH 3UHúHGLQWH DO &RQVLOLXOXL 3HUPDQHQW HUD vQGHSOLQLW GH PLQLVWUXOGH([WHUQHDOVWDWXOXLvQFDUHVH LQHDvQWUXQLUHDREOLJDWRULHDQXDO
3HUPDQHQW([WUHPGHLPSRUWDQWHHUDXúLSUHYHGHULOHDUWFDUHVWLSXODX F ÄSROLWLFDFRPXQ D&RQVLOLXOXL3HUPDQHQW´WUHEXLDV ILHLQVSLUDW GH SULQFLSLLOHJHQHUDOHFXSULQVHvQ3DFWXO6RFLHW LL1D LXQLORU3DFWXOGHOD 3DULV $FWXO JHQHUDO GH DUELWUDM úL vQ DOWH GRFXPHQWH DGRSWDWH GH FRPXQLWDWHDLQWHUQD LRQDO 8QLWDWHD 0LFLL ÌQ HOHJHUL úL GRULQ D GH SDFH D DFHVWHLD DX IRVW HYLGHQ LDWH GLQ QRX OD GHFHPEULH OD .RãLFH GH 1LFRODH 7LWXOHVFXúL(GXDUG%HQHã$SRLDPSOLILFDUHDFDPSDQLHLUHYL]LRQLVWHDX GHWHUPLQDW VWDWHOH 0LFLL ÌQ HOHJHUL V GHFLG OD =DJUHE OD LDQXDULH DGRSWDUHDXQHLWDFWLFLRIHQVLYHDWkWGLQSXQFWGHYHGHUHSROLWLFFkW úLSURSDJDQGLVWLF&RQFRPLWHQW5RPvQLD&HKRVORYDFLDúL,XJRVODYLDDX F ]XW GH DFRUG DVXSUD SULQFLSLLORU GH ED] SULYLQG FRQVWLWXLUHD XQHL QRL RUJDQL]D LL GHIHQVLYH UHJLRQDOH ± ÌQ HOHJHUHD %DOFDQLF ± úL DVXSUD QHFHVLW LLQRUPDOL] ULLUHOD LLORUFX8QLXQHD6RYLHWLF 5HOD LLOHFX3RORQLD ÌQ FDGUXO SUHRFXS ULORU GH JDUDQWDUH D LQWHJULW LL WHULWRULDOH OD JUDQL DGHHVWJXYHUQXOURPkQDvQFKHLDWODPDUWLH OD%XFXUHúWLR &RQYHQ LH GH DOLDQ GHIHQVLY FX 3RORQLD SULQ FDUH FHOH GRX VWDWH VH DQJDMDXÄV VHDMXWHUHFLSURFvQFD]XOFkQGXQDGLQWUHHOHDUILDWDFDW I U SURYRFD LXQH GLQ SDUWHL OD IURQWLHUHOH VDOH RULHQWDOH DFWXDOH´ ÌQWUR DVHPHQHDVLWXD LHVWDWXOQHDWDFDWXUPDV VHFRQVLGHUHÄvQVWDUHGHU ]ERL úLL YD GD FRQFXUV vQDUPDW´ FRQIRUP FHORU VWDELOLWH SULQ &RQYHQ LD PLOLWDU FH XUPD D IL vQFKHLDW $UW SUHYHGHD REOLJD LD FRQVXOW ULORU UHFLSURFHvQSUREOHPHGHSROLWLF H[WHUQ vQFHHDFHSULYHúWHÄUDSRUWXULOH ORU ID GH YHFLQXO GH OD HVW´ ÌQ VLWXD LD vQ FDUH ÄFRQWUDU VIRU ULORU ORU SDúQLFH´FHOHGRX VWDWHVDUILDIODWvQVWDUHGHÄU ]ERLGHIHQVLY´FRQIRUP SUHYHGHULORU PHQ LRQDWH vQ DUW HOH VH DQJDMDX ÄV QX WUDWH]H úL V QX vQFKHLHQLFLDUPLVWL LXOQLFLSDFHDXQDI U DOWD´&RQIRUPDUWQLFLXQD GLQWUHS U LQXSXWHDV vQFKHLHÄYUHRDOLDQ FXDWUHLDSXWHUHI U V VH FRQVXOWHvQSUHDODELOFXFHDODOW ´
,RDQ6FXUWX5RPkQLDúL0DULOH3XWHUL SS ,RDQ6FXUWXRSFLWS
/D PDUWLH &RQYHQ LD GH DOLDQ SRORQRURPkQ D IRVW UHvQQRLW DUWSUHFL]kQGF 5RPkQLDúL3RORQLDVHREOLJDXÄDUHVSHFWDvQ FKLS UHFLSURF úL D PHQ LQH FRQWUD RULF UHL DJUHVLXQL LQWHJULWDWHD ORU WHULWRULDO DFWXDO úLLQGHSHQGHQ DSROLWLF SUH]HQW ´ÌQVLWXD LDvQFDUHDU ILIRVWDWDFDWHÄI U SURYRFDUHGLQSDUWHOH´VHDQJDMDXV úLGHDÄLPHGLDW DMXWRU úL VSULMLQ´ 3ULQ XUPDUH DQJDMDPHQWHOH UHFLSURFH GH VSULMLQ DX IRVWO UJLWHODIRUPXODÄHUJDRPQHV´vQV DFHVWOXFUXQXDIRVWFRQVHPQDW úLvQFRQYHQ LLOHPLOLWDUH ÌQFHUFkQG V FDXWH QRL PLMORDFH GH DS UDUH vQ ID D SULPHMGLHL UHYL]LRQLVWH5RPkQLDDXUP ULWvQPDUWLH VWUkQJHUHDOHJ WXULORUFX 3RORQLDSUHFXPúLJ VLUHDGHQRLPLMORDFHGHvQ HOHJHUHvQWUHDFHDVWDúL &HKRVORYDFLD EHQHILFLLQG vQ DFHVW GHPHUV úL GH VSULMLQXO )UDQ HL ÌQFHUF ULOHQXDXDYXWVXFFHVGDWRULW RULHQW ULLSROLWLFLLJXYHUQXOXLGHOD 9DUúRYLD VSUH *HUPDQLD FX FDUH DYHD V vQFKHLD XQ SDFW ELODWHUDO vQ LDQXDULH ÌQ SHULRDGD vQ UHOD LLOH URPkQRSRORQH VD SURGXV XQ SURFHV GH UHGUHVDUH I U V VH DMXQJ vQV OD DUPRQL]DUHD FRPSOHW D SR]L LLORULQWHUQD LRQDOHDOHFHORUGRX VWDWH 5HOD LLOHFX)UDQ D 8UP ULQGDQJDMDUHD)UDQ HLvQSURFHVXOGHJDUDQWDUHúLDVLJXUDUHD VWDWXTXRXOXL WHULWRULDO DO 5RPkQLHL vQ FD]XO XQXL DWDF QHSURYRFDW GLSORPD LL URPkQL DX vQFHSXW vQF GLQ PDUWLH GLVFX LL FX RPRORJLL IUDQFH]L SHQWUX vQFKHLHUHD XQXL WUDWDW GH DOLDQ ELODWHUDO &RQFRPLWHQW JXYHUQXOIUDQFH]DIRVWUXJDWV LQWHUYLQ OD0RVFRYDSHQWUXFDDFHDVWDV UHFXQRDVF VWDWXTXRXO WHULWRULDO DO 5RPkQLHL DGLF úL DSDUWHQHQ D %DVDUDELHL OD VWDWXO URPkQ 1HGRULQG V VXSHUH *HUPDQLD úL 0DUHD %ULWDQLH DQJDMDWH GHMD vQ GLVFX LL SHQWUX vQFKHLHUHD XQXL SDFW GH VHFXULWDWH UKHQDQ 3DULVXO D DPkQDW ILQDOL]DUHD GLVFX LLORU FX %XFXUHúWLL IDSW FDUH D SURYRFDW vQ &DSLWDOD 5RPkQLHL QHvQFUHGHUH GH]DP JLUH úL VXVSLFLXQH
,ELGHPSS *XYHUQXOIUDQFH]úWLDF 0DUHD%ULWDQLHQXGRUHDH[WLQGHUHDLQIOXHQ HLIUDQFH]HvQHVWXO(XURSHLúLQLFLH[WLQGHUHDJDUDQ LLORUGHVHFXULWDWHDVXSUD VWDWHORUGLQDFHDVW ]RQ JHRJUDILF
$ELD vQ vQ FRQWH[WXO vQ FDUH XUP UHD V RE LQ VSULMLQXO VWDWHORU HVWHXURSHQH OD &RQIHULQ D GH]DUP ULL GH OD *HQHYD úL V FRQWUDFDUH]HSROLWLFDSURLWDOLDQ DJXYHUQXO$YHUHVFXJXYHUQXOIUDQFH]D GHFLV V VHPQH]H OD 3DULV OD LXQLH GDWRULW FUL]HL GH JXYHUQ GLQ )UDQ D GRFXPHQWXO D IRVW DQWHGDWDW LXQLH WUDWDWXO GH SULHWHQLH FX 5RPkQLD ÌQ HVHQ GRFXPHQWXO UHSHWD DúD FXP SUHFL]D 1LFRODH 7LWXOHVFX PXOWH GLQ SUHYHGHULOH 3DFWXOXL 6RFLHW LL 1D LXQLORU SUHY ]kQG REOLJD LD S U LORU VHPQDWDUH GH D VH vQ HOHJH DVXSUD ÄP VXULORU GH OXDW vQ FRPXQ SHQWUXDS UDUHDORU´vQFD]GHSHULFROXUPkQGDúLDFRUGDVSULMLQÄSROLWLFúL GLSORPDWLF´ (YHQWXDOHOH QHvQ HOHJHUL ELODWHUDOH QHVROX LRQDWH vQWUH S U L XUPDXV ILHVXSXVHSURFHGXULORUGHÄFRQFLOLHUHVDXGHDUELWUDM´7UDWDWXO GH SULHWHQLH D IRVW FRPSOHWDW FX XQ SURWRFRODQH[ FDUH FXSULQGHD R GHFODUD LH XQLODWHUDO FDUH UHFRQILUPD DQJDMDPHQWXO ÄSHUPDQHQW GH QHDJUHVLXQHID GH8566ED]DWSHVWDWXTXR´I FXWODPDL OD &RQIHULQ DGHOD*HQRYDGHF WUH,,&%U WLDQX ÌQDEVHQ DXQHLDOLDQ HSROLWLFRPLOLWDU HIHFWLYHFDUHV SUHFL]H]H FRQGL LLOH FRQFUHWH GH DMXWRU WUDWDWXO FX )UDQ D QX D FUHDW XQ SOXV GH VHFXULWDWH SHQWUX VWDWXTXRXO WHULWRULDO URPkQHVF $MXWRUXO SH FDUH PL]D JXYHUQXOURPkQvQFD]GHSHULFRODFRQVWDWPDLPXOWSHGHFODUD LLWHRUHWLFH GHSULQFLSLLU PkQkQGvQVIHUDGH]LGHUDWXOXLDGRULQ HLÌQPRGFXWRWXO GH QHvQ HOHV GLSORPD LD GH OD %XFXUHúWL D LJQRUDW SUHFL] ULOH I FXWH GH 0LQLVWHUXO GH ([WHUQH GH OD 3DULV vQF GLQ F )UDQ D QX VH YD DQJUHQDvQSROLWLFDVWDWHORUPLFL PDLDOHVGDF DFHVWHDQXDUILDF LRQDWFX SUXGHQ SHQWUXDQXILDQJDMDW vQFRQIOLFWHFRQWUDGLFWRULLFXLQWHUHVHOH VDOH
&KLDUúLvQDFHOPRPHQWIUDQFH]LLDXFHUXWV VHS VWUH]HW FHUHD 5RPkQLD vúL OXD REOLJD LD ÄGH D QX DWDFD 5XVLD FX WUXSHOH VDOH UHJXODWH´úLÄGHDQXWROHUDIRUPD LXQHDSHWHULWRULXOHLGHWUXSHQHUHJXODWHGH DWDFFRQWUD5XVLHL´&RQFRPLWHQW5RPkQLDVHGHFODUDDILJDWDV H[WLQG DFHVW DQJDMDPHQWODWR LYHFLQLLV L ,RDQ6FXUWXRSFLWS )UDQFH]LL DX DFFHSWDW LGHHD vQFKHLHULL XQXL DFRUG OD QLYHO GH FRPDQGDPHQWH PLOLWDUH H[FOX]kQG vQV WULPLWHUHD GH WUXSH vQ DMXWRUXO 5RPkQLHL vQWUHFDX]HOHFDUHDXGXVODQHvQFKHLHUHDXQHL&RQYHQ LLPLOLWDUHVD VLWXDWúLVLWXD LDSUHFDU DSUHJ WLULLPLOLWDUHD5RPkQLHL Ä&XVDXI U WUDWDW±DSUHFLD1LFRODH7LWXOHVFX±)UDQ DWUHEXLHV QH DMXWH HDSHQRLúLQRLSHHD´
3HQWUX WRDW OXPHD HUD FODU PDL DOHV GXS vQFKHLHUHD SDFWXOXL UKHQDQF 3DULVXOQXGRUHDV VXSHUHGLSORPD LDúLDXWRULW LOHGHOD%HUOLQ úL0RVFRYDDGLF WRFPDLSHDFHLDFDUHSXWHDXV DWHQWH]HODLQWHJULWDWHD WHULWRULDO D5RPkQLHLÌQFRQWH[WXOvQFDUH)UDQ DQXSXWHDV LQWHUYLQ vQ VSULMLQXOVWDWHORUGLQVXGHVWXO(XURSHLFKLDUGDF DUILYUXWI U VSULMLQ EULWDQLF GXSOLFLWDWHD SROLWLFLL IUDQFH]H ID GH DFHVWHD VD DFFHQWXDW SH P VXUD DPSOLILF ULL GH]LQWHUHVXOXL EULWDQLF ID GH VLWXD LD GH OD HVW GH 5KLQ ÌQ SRILGD IDSWXOXL F URPkQLL DX FUH]XW F DYHDX FX IUDQFH]LL R ÄUHOD LH VSHFLDO ´ vQ UHDOLWDWHDúDFXPSUHFL]D1DH,RQHVFXQXDIRVW YRUEDGHFkWGHÄROHJ WXU GHGUDJRVWHXQLODWHUDO ´ &XWRDWHDFHVWHDvQFKHLHUHDWUDWDWXOXLGHSULHWHQLHURPkQRIUDQFH]D LULWDW 0RVFRYD FDUH vQ PRG QHIRQGDW D UHSURúDW 3DULVXOXL F D SURPLV %XFXUHúWLORUVSULMLQQHFRQGL LRQDWvQSUREOHPD%DVDUDELHL ÌQGHFHQLXOSHQWUXDSXWHDIDFHID PDLELQHSHULFROHORUSURYRFDWH GH SROLWLFD úL DF LXQLOH VWDWHORU UHYL]LRQLVWH úHILL FHORU WUHL VWDWH FDUH FRQVWLWXLDX 0LFD ÌQ HOHJHUH DX F ]XW GH DFRUG LXQLH DVXSUD vQFKHLHULL XQXL SDFW GH DOLDQ vQWUH )UDQ D úL 0LFD ÌQ HOHJHUH vPSRWULYD RULF UXL DJUHVRU $SRL GXS vQFKHLHUHD WUDWDWHORU LXJRVODYREXOJDU úL LXJRVODYRLWDOLDQ 3DULVXO D SURSXV FD 5RPkQLD úL ,XJRVODYLD V vQFKHLHXQSDFWGHDVLVWHQ PXWXDO FX)UDQ DÌQILQDOLGHHDDIRVWUHVSLQV GH,XJRVODYLDSHQWUXDQXSURYRFD*HUPDQLDúL,WDOLD 3R]L LD)UDQ HLDIRVWOXDW vQFRQVLGHUD LHúLvQPRPHQWXOvQFDUHVD SXVSUREOHPDvQFKHLHULLXQXLSDFWGHDVLVWHQ PXWXDO vQWUHVWDWHOH0LFLL ÌQ HOHJHUL SURSXV GH &HKRVORYDFLD 1HGRULQG FD R HYHQWXDO DWLWXGLQH IDYRUDELO V ILH LQWHUSUHWDW FD JHVW vPSRWULYD *HUPDQLHL úL ,WDOLHL JXYHUQXO IUDQFH] VD DE LQXW V VH SURQXQ H VI WXLQG vQ DFHVW VHQV úL JXYHUQXOURPkQ
1LFRODH7LWXOHVFXFRQVLGHUDF ÄDWXQFLFkQGHVWHYRUEDGH)UDQ DúL 5RPkQLDHVWHJUHXV GHVSDU LLQLPDGHUD LXQH´ /DLXOLHJXYHUQXOURPkQúLDUHFRQILUPDWSR]L LDvQDFHVWVHQV ÌQFKHLHUHD XQRU DFRUGXUL GH DVLVWHQ PXWXDO vQWUH )UDQ D úL VWDWHOH 0LFLL ÌQ HOHJHUL úL ÌQ HOHJHULL %DOFDQLFH D PDL IRVW GLVFXWDW OD VHVLXQHD &RQVLOLXOXL 3HUPDQHQW DO 0LFLL ÌQ HOHJHUL GH OD 6LQDLD GLQ DXJXVW FkQGVDFRQVLGHUDWF ÄQXHUDPRPHQWXOSULHOQLFSHQWUXDFFHSWDUHDSURSXQHULL´ 'H DOWIHO vQ SHULRDGD XUP WRDUH QLFL )UDQ D FDUH VH RULHQWD VSUH FRQFLOLHUH FX *HUPDQLDQXDPDLULGLFDWSUREOHPD
5HOD LLOHFX,WDOLD ÌQ DFHODúL VFRS DO FRQVROLG ULL VHFXULW LL WHULWRULDOH D 5RPkQLHL JXYHUQXOURPkQDOXDWvQFDOFXOvQFKHLHUHDXQXLWUDWDWGHDOLDQ FX,WDOLD vQDLQWkQGODIHEUXDULH XQSURLHFWFXFDUH%HQLWR0XVVROLQLDIRVW GHDFRUGILLQGFKLDUGLVSXVV OvQW UHDVF FXXQDFRUGPLOLWDUVHFUHW$ FRQGL LRQDWDFHVWOXFUXGHQHvQFKHLUHDXQHLDOLDQ HURPkQRIUDQFH]HIDSW H[FOXVvQV GH([HFXWLYXOGHOD%XFXUHúWL3HQWUXDúLGRYHGLORLDOLWDWHD ID GH ,WDOLD QRXO SULPPLQLVWUX $OH[DQGUX $YHUHVFX D FRPXQLFDW FRQILGHQ LDO PLQLVWUXOXL LWDOLDQ OD %XFXUHúWL WH[WXO WUDWDWXOXL vQFKHLDW FX )UDQ DFXWRDWHF GRFXPHQWXOQXIXVHVHSXEOLFDW ÌQ ILQDO 7UDWDWXO GH SULHWHQLH úL FRODERUDUH FRUGLDO DYHD V ILH VHPQDWODVHSWHPEULH OD5RPD&RQIRUPDUWFHOHGRX S U LVH REOLJDX UHFLSURF V úL GHD ÄVSULMLQ PXWXDO úL FRODERUDUH FRUGLDO SHQWUX S VWUDUHD RUGLQHL LQWHUQD LRQDOH FkW úL SHQWUX UHVSHFWDUHD úL vQGHSOLQLUHD REOLJD LXQLORU VWLSXODWH SULQ WUDWDWHOH DL F URU VHPQDWDUL VXQW S U LOH´ ÌQ FD]GHÄFRPSOLFD LLLQWHUQD LRQDOH´úLGDF FHOHGRX S U LHUDXGHDFRUG F ÄLQWHUHVHOHORUFRPXQHVXQWRULDUSXWHDILDPHQLQ DWH´HOHVHREOLJDX ÄV VHvQ HOHDJ DVXSUDP VXULORUGHOXDWvQFRPXQSHQWUXDS UDUHDORU´ DUW &HYD PDL SUHFLV GDU WRWXúL QHEXORV HUD FRQ LQXWXO DUW FDUH SUHYHGHDF vQVLWXD LDvQFDUHÄVLJXUDQ DúLLQWHUHVHOH´XQHLDGLQWUHS U L HUDX DPHQLQ DWH vQ XUPD ÄXQRU LQFXUVLXQL YLROHQWH GLQ DIDU ´ FHDODOW SDUWHVHREOLJDV LGHDÄRGDW FXELQHYRLWRUXOVSULMLQDMXWRUXOV XSROLWLF úLGLSORPDWLFvQVFRSGHDIDFHV vQFHWH]HFDX]DH[WHUQ DDFHOHLDPHQLQ UL´$VHPHQHDWUDWDWXOXLFX)UDQ DúLFHOFX,WDOLDSUHYHGHDODDUWF SUREOHPHOHÄFHOHDUGHVS U LHYHQWXDOúLFDUHQDXSXWXWILUH]ROYDWHSULQ SURFHGHHOH GLSORPDWLFH RELúQXLWH´ XUPDX V ILH VXSXVH SURFHGXULL GH FRQFLOLHUHúLDUELWUDM
%HQLWR0XVVROLQLDDILUPDWF ÄRDOLDQ LWDORURPkQ H[FOXGHRDOLDQ IUDQFRURPkQ ´ÌQSRILGDvQFOLQD LHLSURLWDOLHQHDSULPXOXLPLQLVWUX$OH[DQGUX $YHUHVFX,RQ0LWLOLQHXPLQLVWUXO$IDFHULORU6WU LQHDGHFODUDWPLQLVWUXOXLLWDOLDQ OD%XFXUHúWLF vQSROLWLFDH[WHUQ D5RPkQLHLQXYDLQWHUYHQLQLFLRPRGLILFDUHúL F JXYHUQXOURPkQYDVHPQDWUDWDWXOGHDOLDQ FX)UDQ D ,RDQ6FXUWXRSFLWS
3ULQXUPDUHDIRVWYRUEDGHXQSDFWGHDPLFL LHúLQXGHDOLDQ &X WRDWHDFHVWHDSDFWXOúLVFULVRULOHVHFUHWHUHFXQRúWHDXVWDWXWXOWHULWRULDODO 5RPkQLHL 'DF SULQ vQFKHLHUHD WUDWDWXOXL 5RPkQLD D XUP ULW V úL FRQVROLGH]H VHFXULWDWHD WHULWRULDO ,WDOLD D YL]DW GLPLQXDUHD LQIOXHQ HL IUDQFH]HvQVXGHVWXO(XURSHLúLvQ%DOFDQLVHSDUDUHD5RPkQLHLGHDOLD LL V LLQFOXVLYGH)UDQ DúLRE LQHUHDGHDYDQWDMHHFRQRPLFH vQGRPHQLXO SHWUROXOXLvQGLJXLULLULJD LLHOHFWULILFDUH ÌQFKHLHUHD GRFXPHQWXOXL D SURYRFDW UHDF LD 8QJDULHL FDUH FRQVL GHUDF LVHPLFúRUDXúDQVHOHGHVXFFHVvQHYHQWXDOLWDWHDXQXLFRQIOLFWFX 5RPkQLDGDUúLD,XJRVODYLHLFDUHDDSUHFLDWQHIRQGDWF DVWIHO5RPkQLD VHvQGHS UWDGH0LFDÌQ HOHJHUH (IHFWHOHEHQHILFHDOHWUDWDWXOXLURPkQRLWDOLDQDXIRVWGLPLQXDWHGH SROLWLFD UHYL]LRQLVW D JXYHUQXOXL LWDOLDQ úL GH VHPQDUHD WUDWDWXOXL GH SULHWHQLH LWDORXQJDU GLQ DSULOLH HYHQLPHQW FDUH D DYXW ORF vQ FRQWH[WXOGHVILLQ ULL&RPLVLHLLQWHUDOLDWHGHFRQWUROPLOLWDUGLQ8QJDULD 5HOD LLOHFX8QLXQHD6RYLHWLF 8UP ULQGvQSHUPDQHQ V VHPHQ LQ vQDIDUDVW ULORUFRQIOLFWXDOH JXYHUQXO URPkQ QX D DQJDMDW DUD vQ FRQIOLFW FX 5XVLD 6RYLHWLF vQ DQLL úL vQ SRILGD IDSWXOXL F DFHDVWD UXSVHVH OD LDQXDULH UHOD LLOHGLSORPDWLFHFX5RPkQLDúLKRW UkVHFRQILVFDUHDWH]DXUXOXL URPkQHVF GHSXV OD 0RVFRYD vQ ED]D XQRU DFRUGXUL RILFLDOH ÌQ OXDUHD GHFL]LHLGHQHLQWHUYHQ LHvPSRWULYD5XVLHL6RYLHWLFHJXYHUQXOURPkQQXD LQXWVHDPDQLFLGHSUHVLXQLOHI FXWHGHXQHOHFHUFXULSROLWLFHúLPLOLWDUH IUDQFH]H FDUH LDX SURSXV WHULWRULL QRUGSRQWLFH vQ VFKLPEXO LQWHUYHQ LHL PLOLWDUHVDXDVSULMLQLULL3RORQLHL +RW UkW V úL S VWUH]H SR]L LD GH QHXWUDOLWDWH I FkQG GHPHUVXUL SHQWUXVWDELOLUHDXQRUUHOD LLGHEXQ YHFLQ WDWHFXVWDWXOGHODU V ULWFX WRDWHF DFHVWDQXUHFXQRVFXVHXQLUHDILUHDVF D%DVDUDELHLFX5RPkQLD
,QWUDW vQ YLJRDUH vQ LXOLH FX R GXUDW GH DQL SDFWXO D IRVW SUHOXQJLWSkQ ODLDQXDULH GLQ FkQG%HQLWR0XVVROLQLDGHFODUDW ÄQXOH úL QHDYHQLWH´ VFULVRULOH VHFUHWH SDFWXO QX D PDL DYXW QLFL R YDORDUH ,QWHUHVHOH HFRQRPLFH DX I FXW FD ,WDOLD V vQFKHLH FX 5RPkQLD OD LDQXDULH XQWUDWDWFRPHUFLDO
vQ ([HFXWLYXO GH OD %XFXUHúWL D GHFLV V UHDF LRQH]H GRDU GDF 5RPkQLDDUILIRVWDWDFDW 3HDFHHDúLOLQLHGHEXQ YHFLQ WDWHGHOHJD LD URPkQ OD&RQIHULQ DGHOD*HQRYDDOXDWODPDL vQPRGXQLOD WHUDO XQ DQJDMDPHQW SHUPDQHQW GH QHDJUHVLXQH ID GH 5XVLD 6RYLHWLF UHFRQILUPDWGHJXYHUQXOURPkQODLXQLH vQVR LWGHSUHFL]DUHDF 5RPkQLD QX YD WROHUD SH WHULWRULXO V X ÄWUXSH QHUHJXODWH GH DWDF FRQWUD 5XVLHL´&RQVLGHUkQGF DWkW%DVDUDELDFkWúLWH]DXUXODSDU LQHDXGHGUHSW úLGHIDSWVWDWXOXLURPkQJXYHUQXOGHOD%XFXUHúWLDFRQWLQXDWV PDQL IHVWHIHUPLWDWHvQUHOD LLOHFXYHFLQXOGHODU V ULWUHVSLQJkQGSURSXQHULOH DFHVWXLD GH UHQXQ DUH OD WH]DXU vQ VFKLPEXO UHFXQRDúWHULL VXYHUDQLW LL DVXSUD%DVDUDELHL $FHHDúLSR]L LHDIRVWPHQ LQXW úLvQPDUWLH FkQGVDXGHV FKLV OXFU ULOH FRQIHULQ HL ELODWHUDOH GH OD 9LHQD FkQG ,,& %U WLDQX D FHUXW úHIXOXL GHOHJD LHL URPkQH &RQVWDQWLQ /DQJD5 úFDQX GHVS U LUHD SUREOHPHL %DVDUDELHL GH FHD D WH]DXUXOXL VWDELOLUHD JUDQL HL úL GHFL UHFXQRDúWHUHD8QLULLI U QLFLRGLVFX LHUHWURFHGDUHDWH]DXUXOXLLQL LDOFHO SX LQDGHSR]LWHORUSDUWLFXODUHúLDDUKLYHORUUHVSLQJHUHDSOHELVFLWXOXLHWF /D UkQGXL 11 .UHVWLQVNL úHIXO GHOHJD LHL VRYLHWLFH D I FXW FXQRVFXW F JXYHUQXO GH OD 0RVFRYD QX D FRQVLP LW ÄvQFRUSRUDUHD %DVDUDELHLOD5RPkQLD´úLFRQVLGHUkQGXQLUHDGLQ GUHSWÄRFXSDUH´ SULQÄIRU úLYLROHQ ´GHF WUHWUXSHOHURPkQH ÌQDFHVWFRQWH[WvQFDUHSR]L LLOHHUDXFRQWUDGLFWRULLFRQIHULQ DGHOD 9LHQD D HúXDW UHOD LLOH URPkQRVRYLHWLFH vQU XW LQGXVH VLP LWRU JXYHU QXOGHOD0RVFRYDOXkQGvQGLVFX LHFKLDU WRDPQDDQXOXL XQDWDF DUPDWDVXSUD5RPkQLHL RUJDQL]DUHDU VFRDOHLGHOD7DWDUEXQDUGLQVXGXO %DVDUDELHLvQWUR]RQ FXSRSXOD LHPDMRULWDUQHURPkQHDVF ÌQDFHHDúL GLUHF LH GH DF LXQH VDX VLWXDW SURWHVWHOH ID GH vQFKHLHUHD WUDWDWXOXL IUDQFRURPkQ SUHVLXQLOH I FXWH OD 5RPD SHQWUX D VH vQWkU]LD UDWLILFDUHD 3URWRFROXOXL GLQ RFWRPEULH UHIHULWRU OD %DVDUDELD LQIOXHQ DUHD-DSRQLHLSHQWUXDQXUDWLILFDDFHODúLWUDWDWHWF ÌQ SHULRDGD XUP WRDUH UHOD LLOH URPkQRVRYLHWLFH VDX vPEXQ W LW WUHSWDW OD DXJXVW úL IHEUXDULH DPEHOH VWDWH OXkQGXúL DQJDMDPHQWHUHFLSURFHGHQHDJUHVLXQHvQFDGUXOSDFWXOXL%ULDQG.HOORJúL
5HOHYkQG DFHVW OXFUX 9, /HQLQ D GHFODUDW Ä$X U PDV vQV XQHOH VWDWHFD5RPkQLDFDUHQXDXvQFHUFDWV OXSWHvPSRWULYD5XVLHL´
3URWRFROXOXLGHOD0RVFRYD$FHDVWDQXDvQVHPQDWvQV F DXWRULW LOHGH OD.UHPOLQDXUHQXQ DWODLGHHDUHDQH[ ULL%DVDUDELHL 3R]L LDFHORUGRX JXYHUQHDIRVWVRQGDW vQGHFHPEULH vQFDGUXO WUDWDWLYHORU SXUWDWH SHQWUX vQFKHLHUHD SDFWXOXL GH QHDJUHVLXQH SRORQR VRYLHWLFFRQWH[WvQFDUHJXYHUQXOGHOD9DUúRYLDDFRQGL LRQDWUHVSHFWLYXO SDFW GH vQFKHLHUHD XQXLD VLPLODU vQWUH 8QLXQHD 6RYLHWLF úL 5RPkQLD 3UHFL]kQG SR]L LD JXYHUQXOXL URPkQ PLQLVWUXO $IDFHULORU 6WU LQH DO 5RPkQLHL 'LPLWULH *KLFD D SUHFL]DW RPRORJXOXL SRORQH] F SHQWUX D DFFHSWDvQFKHLHUHDXQXLDVHPHQHDSDFWvQWUH5RPkQLDúL8QLXQHD6RYLHWLF FRQ LQXWXO DFHVWXLD WUHEXLD ÄV QX LQILUPH QLFL V PRGLILFH vQWUXQ QLPLF IRORDVHOHSDFWXOXL%ULDQG.HOORJúLDOHSURWRFROXOXL/LWYLQRY´V SUHFL]H]H F ÄRULFH DWLQJHUH D LQWHJULW LL WHULWRULDOH DFWXDOH DU IL FRQVLGHUDW FD R DJUHVLXQH´ V VH H[FOXG GLQWUH SUREOHPHOH FDUH DU SXWHD IL VXSXVH XQHL SURFHGXULDUELWUDUHVDXGHFRQFLOLD LXQHDFHHDDÄJUDQL HLQRDVWUHGHHVW´úL V H[LVWH ÄLQWHUGHSHQGHQ DEVROXW ´ vQWUH LQWUDUHD vQ YLJRDUH D WUDWDWXOXL URPkQRVRYLHWLFFXFHOSRORQRVRYLHWLFVSUHÄDQXVHDGXFHQLFLRúWLUELUH DOLDQ HL QRDVWUH´ 3ULQ XUPDUH VH XUP UHD H[FOXGHUHD SRVLELOLW LL RULF UHL GLVFX LLDVXSUDLQWHJULW LLJUDQL HLGHU V ULWD5RPkQLHL 'HRDUHFHJXYHUQXOVRYLHWLFDI FXWFXQRVFXWF GRUHDGRDUQHJRFLHUL GLUHFWHFXJXYHUQXOURPkQODLQL LDWLYDDFHVWXLDODLQVLVWHQ HOHJXYHUQHORU IUDQFH] úL SRORQH] DXWRULW LOH GH OD %XFXUHúWL DX GDW LQVWUXF LXQL vQV UFLQDWXOXLURPkQGHOD5LJDV QHJRFLH]HDGUHIHUHQGXPWULPL kQGXLúL XQSURLHFWGHQHDJUHVLXQHvQWRFPLWSHED]DSURLHFWXOXLSRORQH]PRGLILFDWúL D VLWXD LHL VSHFLILFH D UDSRUWXULORU URPkQRVRYLHWLFH /D LDQXDULH %6WRPRQLDNRY D LQIRUPDW SH vQV UFLQDWXO URPkQ GH OD 5LJD F JXYHUQXO VRYLHWLFQXYDvQFKHLDQLFLRGDW YUHXQSDFWFX5RPkQLDI U FDvQDFHVWDV ILH FRQVHPQDW SR]L LD 0RVFRYHL ID GH %DVDUDELD VDX FD DFHVWD V FRQVHPQH]HFXYLQWHOHLQWHJULWDWHLQYLRODELOLWDWHúLVXYHUDQLWDWH 3UREOHPD UHJOHPHQW ULL UHOD LLORU URPkQRVRYLHWLFH DYHD V ILH UHOXDW FHYDPDLWkU]LXLQL LDOvQWLPSXOvQWkOQLULLGLQWUH1LFRODH7LWXOHVFX úL(GXDUG%HQHãOD.RãLFH GHFHPEULH úLvQWLPSXOVHVLXQLL0LFLL ÌQ HOHJHUL GH OD =DJUHE LDQXDULH DSRL GLUHFW vQ FDGUXO GLV
&HLWUHLPLQLúWULGH([WHUQH±17LWXOHVFX(%HQHãúL%-HWYLF±DX FRQVLGHUDW F VRVLVH PRPHQWXO SHQWUX UHOXDUHD UHOD LLORU GLQWUH VWDWHOH 0LFLL ÌQ HOHJHUL úL 8566 úL DX VWDELOLW V SURFHGH]H DVWIHO DWXQFL FkQG ÄUHOD LLOH GLSORPDWLFH SH FDUH OH UHFODP LQWHUHVHOH ILHF UXLD GLQWUH FHOH WUHL UL YRU IL vQWUXQLWH´ 1LFRODH7LWXOHVFX'RFXPHQWHGLSORPDWLFH%XFXUHúWL S
FX LLORUSXUWDWHvQWUH1LFRODH7LWXOHVFXúL00/LWYLQRYvQFDGUXOF URUD PLQLVWUXOVRYLHWLFGH([WHUQHDUHFXQRVFXWVXYHUDQLWDWHD5RPkQLHLDVXSUD %DVDUDELHL &RQVLGHUDW VDWLVI F WRU GH F WUH UHJHOH &DURO DO ,,OHD úL GH F WUH SULPXOPLQLVWUX *KHRUJKH 7 W UHVFX FRQ LQXWXO GLVFX LLORU 7LWXOHVFX /LWYLQRYDIRVWDSUREDWOD LXQLH HIHFWXkQGXVHXQVFKLPEUHFLSURF GH VFULVRUL vQWUH FHL GRL PLQLúWUL GH ([WHUQH úL GH 1RWH GLSORPDWLFH FX FRQ LQXW LGHQWLF SULQ FDUH VH SUHFL]D F FHOH GRX JXYHUQH vúL JDUDQWDX PXWXDOvQPRGUHFLSURFÄvQWUHJXOUHVSHFWDOVXYHUDQLW LL´ILHF UXLDGLQWUH VWDWH úL DE LQHUHD GH OD RULFH LPL[WLXQH GLUHFW VDX LQGLUHFW vQ DIDFHULOH LQWHUQH ÌQ DFHVW FRQWH[W OD QRLHPEULH OD %XFXUHúWL D VRVLW SULPXO UHSUH]HQWDQW DO 8QLXQLL 6RYLHWLFH XUPDW OD GHFHPEULH GH PLQLVWUXO 0LKDLO 2VWURYVNL /D VFXUW WLPS OD GHFHPEULH PLQLVWUXO URPkQ(GPRQG&LXQWXDSOHFDWODUkQGXLVSUH0RVFRYD&XSX LQWLPS vQDLQWH vQ VHSWHPEULH &RQVLOLLOH 3HUPDQHQWH DO ÌQ HOHJHULL %DOFDQLFHúL0LFLLÌQ HOHJHULvQWUXQLWHVHSDUDWOD*HQHYDDXGHFLVFDFHOH FLQFL VWDWH V YRWH]H SHQWUX LQWUDUHD 8QLXQLL 6RYLHWLFH vQ 6RFLHWDWHD 1D LXQLORUIDSWvPSOLQLWODVHSWHPEULH 5HOXDUHD UHOD LLORU GLSORPDWLFH FX 8566 D IRVW SULYLW vQ PRG GLIHULWGHRDPHQLLSROLWLFLURPkQL*KHRUJKH%U WLDQX$OH[DQGUX9DLGD 9RLHYRG2FWDYLDQ*RJD0LKDLO0DQRLOHVFXOHJLRQDULLvQJHQHUDOFHLFX RULHQW ULGHGUHDSWDPDQLIHVWkQGXúLRVWLOLWDWHD ÌQDFHHDúL]L LXQLH DXIRVWUHVWDELOLWHúLUHOD LLOHGLSORPDWLFH GLQWUH8566úL&HKRVORYDFLD'HRDUHFH,XJRVODYLDQXDUHFXQRVFXWGH MXUH8QLXQHD6RYLHWLF UHOD LLOHGLSORPDWLFHGLQWUHFHOHGRX VWDWHDYHDX V ILHUHOXDWHPDLWkU]LX
&RQFRPLWHQWFHOHGRX JXYHUQHVHPDLREOLJDXV QXFUHH]HVXV LQ VDX DXWRUL]H]H úHGHUHD SH WHULWRULXO ORU D ÄRUJDQL]D LLORU FDUH úLDU SURSXQH FD VFRS OXSWD DUPDW FRQWUD FHOXLODOW VWDW VDX DWHQWDWH SULQ IRU OD UHJLPXO OXL SROLWLFRULVRFLDOVDXSURYRFkQGDFWHGHWHURULVPRULSUHSDUkQGDVHPHQHDDFWH FRQWUDUHSUH]HQWDQ LORUOXLRILFLDOLSUHFXPQLFLDRUJDQL]D LLORUFDUHúLDUDWULEXL UROXOGHJXYHUQDOFHOXLODOWVWDWVDXDXQHLS U LGLQWHULWRULXOOXL´ÌQDFHODúLWLPS VH LQWHU]LFHD UHFUXWDUHD úL WUDQ]LWDUHD SH WHULWRULXO FHORU GRX VWDWH D ÄIRU HORU DUPDWHDUPHORUDPXQL LXQLORUDHFKLSDPHQWXOXLúLDORULF UXLIHOGHPDWHULDO GHVWLQDW DFHVWRU RUJDQL]D LL´ ,RDQ 6FXUWX 5RPkQLD úL 0DULOH 3XWHUL %XFXUHúWLS
'XS FH8QLXQHD6RYLHWLF DvQFKHLDWSDFWXOGHDVLVWHQ PXWXDO FX)UDQ DJXYHUQXOURPkQDvPSXWHUQLFLWODVIDWXO0DULL%ULWDQLLvQLXOLH SH 1LFRODH 7LWXOHVFX V DQJDMH]H FRQYRUELUL RILFLDOH FX UHSUH]HQ WDQ LL8566vQYHGHUHDvQFKHLHULLXQXLSDFWGHDVLVWHQ PXWXDO ÌQ XUPD GLVFX LLORU DYXWH FX 00 /LWYLQRY úL GXS UHvQQRLUHD vPSXWHUQLFLULORU GLQ SDUWHD JXYHUQXOXL URPkQ LXOLH 1LFRODH 7LWXOHVFX úL RPRORJXO VRYLHWLF DX F ]XW GH DFRUG OD 0RQWUHDX[ OD LXOLH DVXSUDSULQFLSLLORUGHED] DOHYLLWRUXOXLWUDWDWURPkQRVRYLHWLF vQVFULLQGXOHvQWUXQSURWRFROvQSDWUXSXQFWHFDUHDIRVWSDUDIDWúLVHPQDW $UW SUHYHGHD F FHOH GRX VWDWH XUPDX V úL DFRUGH DVLVWHQ D PXWXDO vQFDGUXO6RFLHW LL1D LXQLORUFDUHV QXYL]H]HÄvQPRGVSHFLDO XQ VWDW FL vQ JHQHUDO RULFH DJUHVRU HXURSHDQ´ ,QWUDUHD vQ DF LXQH D ILHF UHLD GLQ FHOH GRX UL ± PHQ LRQD DUW ± XUPD V VH IDF ÄQXPDL FkQG )UDQ D YD IL LQWUDW vQ DF LXQH´ &RQIRUP DUW JXYHUQXO VRYLHWLF UHFXQRúWHD F ÄvQ YLUWXWHD GLIHULWHORU VDOH REOLJD LL GH DVLVWHQ WUXSHOH VRYLHWLFH QX YRU SXWHD WUHFH QLFLRGDW 1LVWUXO I U R FHUHUH IRUPDO vQ DFHVWVHQVGLQSDUWHDJXYHUQXOXLUHJDODO5RPkQLHL´/DUkQGXLJXYHUQXO URPkQUHFXQRúWHDF ÄWUXSHOHURPkQHQXYRUSXWHDWUHFHQLFLRGDW 1LVWUXO vQ8566I U RFHUHUHIRUPDO DJXYHUQXOXL8566´/DFHUHUHDFHORU GRX JXYHUQH WUXSHOH FHORU GRX VWDWH XUPDX V úL UHWUDJ LPHGLDW FRQIRUPDUWWUXSHOHODHVWUHVSHFWLYODYHVWGH1LVWUX3ULQXUPDUH JXYHUQXOVRYLHWLFUHFXQRúWHDIDSWXOF JUDQL DGLQWUH8566úL5RPkQLD HUDFRQVWLWXLW GH1LVWUX /D FHUHUHD OXL 00/LWYLQRY VHPQDUHD WUDWDWXOXL D IRVW DPkQDW SkQ vQVHSWHPEULH DSRLDIRVWDQXODW vQXUPDGHPLWHULLOXL1LFRODH 7LWXOHVFXGLQIUXQWHD0LQLVWHUXOXL$IDFHULORU6WU LQHOD DXJXVWDFHODúL
ÌQVHSWHPEULH OD*HQHYD1LFRODH7LWXOHVFXDSURSXVFDYLLWRUXO WUDWDWV FXSULQG SUHYHGHUHDFDvQFD]XOvQFDUH5RPkQLDDUILGHYHQLWYLFWLPD XQHLDJUHVLXQL QHQRPLQDOL]DW 8566V JDUDQWH]HLQGHSHQGHQ DQD LRQDO úL LQWHJULWDWHD WHULWRULDO D ULL LQFOXVLY D DOLD LORU HL ÌQ DFHOHDúL FRQGL LL PLQLVWUXOURPkQGH([WHUQHDOXDWvQFDOFXOúLvQFKHLHUHDXQXLWUDWDWVLPLODUFX *HUPDQLD ,QL LDO00/LWYLQRYQXDDFFHSWDWSURSXQHULOHOXL1LFRODH7LWXOHVFX DSUHFLLQG F 5RPkQLD HUD FHD GLQWkL H[SXV XQXL DWDF JHUPDQ LDU vQ VLWXD LD DWDF ULL8QLXQLL6RYLHWLFHVSULMLQXOURPkQHVFQXHUDFRQVLVWHQW ,RDQ6FXUWX5RPkQLDúL0DULOH3XWHUL %XFXUHúWL S
DQ&RQVLGHUkQGvQORFXLUHDOXL1LFRODH7LWXOHVFXGLQIUXQWHDGLSORPD LHL URPkQHúWL GUHSW R VFKLPEDUH vQ SROLWLFD H[WHUQ 00/LWYLQRY D FRPXQLFDWOXL7LWXOHVFX vQVHSWHPEULH F DFRUGXOGHOD0RQWUHDX[ QXPDLHUDYDODELO ÌQ SODQ LQWHUQ vPSRWULYD SDFWXOXL URPkQRVRYLHWLF VDX SURQXQ DW *KHRUJKH %U WLDQX $OH[DQGUX 9DLGD9RLHYRG &RQVWDQWLQ $UJHWRLDQX 2FWDYLDQ*RJD$&&X]D&RUQHOLX=HOHD&RGUHDQXúLDO LL /D PLMORFXO DQXOXL FUL]D GH QHvQFUHGHUH vQ UHOD LLOH URPkQR VRYLHWLFH FRQWLQXD V ILH YL]LELO ÌQ WLPS FH JXYHUQXO URPkQ GRUHD vQFKHLHUHDXQXLDFRUGELODWHUDOFDUHV UHJOHPHQWH]HSUREOHPD%DVDUDELHL vQ VHQVXO GHFL]LHL 6IDWXOXL ULL GLQ úL HYLWDUHD DERUG ULL vQFKHLHULL XQXLWUDWDWGHDVLVWHQ PXWXDO vQFRQGL LLOHvQFDUHDFHVWDQXDUILLQFOXV SUHYHGHUL UHIHULWRDUH OD VWDWXTXRXO V X WHULWRULDO JXYHUQXO VRYLHWLF D FRQWLQXDW V FRQVLGHUH F %DVDUDELD HUD ÄRFXSDW GH 5RPkQLD´ úL V UHVSLQJ RULFHGRFXPHQWFDUHDUILLQFOXVUHFXQRDúWHUHDGHMXUHDIURQWLHUHL SH 1LVWUX /D DFX]D LLOH I FXWH GH 2VWURYVNL OD LXOLH F ÄURPkQLL VDX vQK PDW GHILQLWLY OD FDUXO DQWLVRYLHWLF DO OXL %HFN´ *KHRUJKH 7 W UHVFX SULPXOPLQLVWUX URPkQ D UHSOLFDW F ÄDU IL XQ QRQVHQVúLRFULP GLQSDUWHDJXYHUQXOXLURPkQV YL]H]HODRDJUHVLXQH vPSRWULYD6RYLHWHORUVLQJXUVDXvQEORFPDLDOHVGDF SDUWHQHUvQDFHVW EORFLDUIL3RORQLD´ $SRLODvQFHSXWXODQXOXL vQJULMRUDWGHH[SDQVLXQHDJHUPDQ VSUHFHQWUXOúLHVWXO(XURSHLJXYHUQXOVRYLHWLFúLDPDQLIHVWDWVDWLVIDF LD ID GH SR]L LD GH UH]LVWHQ DGRSWDW GH JXYHUQXO URPkQ vQ UHOD LLOH FX
/LGHULL 3DUWLGXOXL 1D LRQDO &UHúWLQ 2FWDYLDQ *RJD úL $&&X]D DX FRQVLGHUDWSDFWXOFDRÄLGHHQHQRURFLW ´GHVWLQDW ÄV WUDQVIRUPH5RPkQLDvQ DYDQJDUGDDUPDWHORUEROúHYLFHFXWRDWHFRQVHFLQ HOHSHFDUHOHFRPSRUWD´ ([SULPkQG SR]L LD .UHPOLQXOXL ID GH %DVDUDELD vQ DFHO PRPHQW 00/LWYLQRYPHQ LRQDGXS GLVFX LDDYXW FX9LFWRU$QWRQHVFXODVIkUúLWXO OXQLLPDL OD*HQHYD Ä1RLQXULGLF PSUHWHQ LLFXDWkWPDLPXOWWUHEXLHV WDF 5RPkQLDúLDFHDVWDvQSURSULXOV XLQWHUHV´&XSX LQWLPSvQDLQWHDFHODúL 00/LWYLQRYGHFODUDVHOXL1LFRODH7LWXOHVFXOD7DOORLUHV Ä5RPkQLDUHSHW± vQ]DGDUVSXQH LFRQWUDULXO±úLDVFKLPEDWSROLWLFDH[WHUQ 9UHPFDSRWHQ LDOXO SHFDUHvOUHSUH]LQW %DVDUDELDV GHYLQ UXVúLQXJHUPDQ'HDFHHD LQV Y FRPXQLFF YRPvQFHUFDV UHOX P%DVDUDELDSULQWRDWHPLMORDFHOHMXULGLFHúL PLOLWDUHFDUHQHYRUILSRVLELOH´
5HLFKXO úL D I FXW FXQRVFXW SH GLIHULWH FDQDOH F ([HFXWLYXO GH OD %XFXUHúWL SXWHD FRQWD SH VSULMLQXO V X ÌQWUXQ DVHPHQHD FRQWH[W OD FDUHVDXDG XJDWvQFHUF ULOHGHUHGUHVDUHDUHOD LLORUURPkQRSRORQHVD UHQXQ DWODLGHHDSDFWXOXLGHDVLVWHQ PXWXDO 'DW ILLQGSR]L LD.UHPOLQXOXLvQHVWXO(XURSHLUHJHOH&DURODO,, OHDFDUHDYHDXQFXYkQWGHFLVLYGHVSXVvQSROLWLFDH[WHUQ D5RPkQLHLD DSUHFLDW F UHOD LLOH 5RPkQLHL ID GH 8QLXQHD 6RYLHWLF WUHEXLDX V ILH ÄFRUHFWH FKLDU SROLWLFRDVH´ GHRDUHFH DFHDVWD HUD ÄXQ YHFLQ FX FDUH QX SR LILGXúP QRV´&RQFRPLWHQWVXYHUDQXOURPkQPDLFRQVLGHUDF ÄLQWH UHVHOHSHUPDQHQWHDOH5RPkQLHL´FHUHDXÄV QXILPQLFLSUHDSULHWHQL´ 3HDFHDVW OLQLHGHFRQGXLW JXYHUQXOURPkQDPHQ LQXWID GHFHO VRYLHWLF R DWLWXGLQH SUXGHQW úL SUHYHQLWRDUH vQFHUFkQG FKLDU vQ LDUQD RRDUHFDUHvPEXQ W LUHDUHOD LLORUELODWHUDOH 5RPkQLDúLVHFXULWDWHDHXURSHDQ ÌQF GHODvQILLQ DUHD6RFLHW LL1D LXQLORUGDUPDLDOHVvQSHULRDGD vQ FDUH PLQLVWUX GH ([WHUQH DO 5RPkQLHL D IRVW 1LFRODH 7LWXOHVFX UHSUH]HQWDQ LL 5RPkQLHL DX IRVW R SUH]HQ DFWLY vQ FDGUXO OXFU ULORU IRUXPXOXLPRQGLDOILLQGLPSOLFD LvQFDGUXOVHVLXQLORU$GXQ ULL*HQHUDOH D 6RFLHW LL 1D LXQLORU VDX vQ RUJDQLVPHOH GH OXFUX DOH DFHVWHLD DYkQG LQL LDWLYH SURPRYkQG VROX LL SDúQLFH úL FRQVWUXFWLYH vQ FRQFRUGDQ FX SROLWLFDH[WHUQ D ULL 'XS FH vQ 5RPkQLD D IRVW SULPXO VWDW FDUH D SURSXV vQ FDGUXO /LJLL 1D LXQLORU HODERUDUHD XQHL FRQYHQ LL SHQWUX UHSULPDUHD WHURULVPXOXL 5RPkQLD D DGHUDW OD VHSWHPEULH OD 7UDWDWXO PXOWLODWHUDO GH UHQXQ DUH OD U ]ERL FD LQVWUXPHQW GH SROLWLF QD LRQDO Ä3DFWXO %ULDQG.HORJJ´ VHPQDW OD 3DULV OD DXJXVW GH F WUH
6HVL]kQGDFHVWOXFUX*ULJRUH*DIHQFXVDDGUHVDWDVWIHOOXL:LOKHOP )DEULFLXVODIHEUXDULH Ä1LVHSDUHF 0RVFRYDVHLQWHUHVHD] GLQQRX úLQXI U RRDUHFDUHEXQ YRLQ GHVRDUWDúLGHVLJXUDQ DQRDVWU ´ /DIHODXSURFHGDWúLIDFWRULLUHVSRQVDELOLGHOD3DULVúL/RQGUDIDSW FDUHDLULWDWvQV úLPDLPXOWFRQGXFHUHDGHOD%HUOLQFDUHDSXVGLQFHvQFH PDLPXOW5RPkQLDVXEÄREVHUYD LH´ 9H]L0DULD*HRUJHVFX5RPkQLD)UDQ DúLVHFXULWDWHDHXURSHDQ vQ DQLL6SHUDQ HúLLOX]LL%XFXUHúWL
68$)UDQ D*HUPDQLD0DUHD%ULWDQLH,WDOLD-DSRQLD%HOJLD3RORQLD úL &HKRVORYDFLD FKLDU GDF DFHVWD QX GHILQHD DJUHVRUXO úL QX LQGLFD VROX LL úL P VXUL SHQWUX FRPEDWHUHD XQHL HYHQWXDOH DJUHVLXQL SUHYHGHD GRDUREOLJD LLFXFDUDFWHUPRUDO $SRLOD IHEUXDULH UHSUH]HQWDQ LL 5RPkQLHL DX VHPQDW Ä3URWRFROXO GH OD 0RVFRYD´ DO WXUL GH 8QLXQHD 6RYLHWLF 3RORQLD/HWRQLD(VWRQLDúL/LWXDQLDSULQFDUHFHOHúDVHVWDWH VHDQJDMDXV SXQ vQDSOLFDUHÄ3DFWXO%ULDQG.HOORJ´vQDLQWHFDDFHVWDV ILHUDWLILFDWGHF WUHWRDWHVWDWHOHVHPQDWDUH ÌPSUHXQ FX&HKRVORYDFLDúL,XJRVODYLD5RPkQLDúLDH[SULPDWFX SULOHMXOFRQIHULQ HLGHOD%HOJUDGGLQ GHFHPEULH vQJULMRUDUHDID GH LQVLVWHQ D *HUPDQLHL vQ FHHD FH SULYHúWH SULPLUHD ÄHJDOLW LL vQ GUHSWXUL´ LQFOXVLYvQvQDUPDUH IDSWDFFHSWDWGH0DUHD%ULWDQLHúLFKLDU GHF WUH)UDQ DODGHFHPEULH UHSUH]HQWDQ LLFHORUFLQFLPDULSX WHUL HODERUkQG GHMD R UH]ROX LH DSUREDW DSRL GH FRQIHULQ D GH]DUP ULL SULQFDUHVHUHFXQRúWHDF XQXOGLQVFRSXULOHGH]DUP ULLFRQVWDvQDFRU GDUHDHJDOLW LLvQGUHSWXULÄSXWHULORUGH]DUPDWHvQYLUWXWHDWUDWDWHORU´ 3UHRFXSDW GH SDFHD (XURSHL 5RPkQLD D DQDOL]DW úL D DGHUDW vPSUHXQ FXDOLD LLGLQ0LFDÌQ HOHJHUH ODFRQ LQXWXOGHILQLULLDJUHVLXQLL SURSXV GH00/LWYLQRYODIHEUXDULH vQFDGUXOFHOHLGHDD VHVLXQL D &RQIHULQ HL GH]DUP ULL GH OD *HQHYD FDUH DYHD GUHSW FRQVHFLQ UHVSHFWDUHD VWDWXTXRXOXL WHULWRULDO úL D WUDWDWHORU H[LVWHQWH $FHVW OXFUX D SHUPLV VHPQDUHD OD /RQGUD OD LXOLH D FRQYHQ LLORUSHQWUXGHILQLUHDDJUHVLXQLLvQWUH8566úLRVHULHGHVWDWH LQFOXVLYFHOHYHFLQHvQWUHFDUHúL5RPkQLD
8UPDUHDDIRVWF ODVFXUWWLPS.RQVWDQWLQYRQ1HXUDWKPLQLVWUXOGH ([WHUQHDO*HUPDQLHLDILUPDvQWUXQLQWHUYLXDFRUGDW]LDUXOXLÄ/H7HPSV´F VHFXULWDWHD VH UHIHUHD GRDU OD SUREOHPHOH FX FDUDFWHU PLOLWDU QX úL OD FHOH FX FDUDFWHUWHULWRULDO 3URSXQHUHDVRYLHWLF GHILQHDFDDJUHVRUVWDWXOFDUHYDGHFODUDU ]ERL DOWXL VWDW úL YD Q Y OL FX IRU HOH DUPDWH FKLDU I U GHFODUD LH GH U ]ERL SH WHULWRULXO DOWXL VWDW VLWXD LD LQWHUQ GLQ LQWHULRUXO XQXL VWDW QX PRWLYD DJUH VLXQHD H[FOXGHD U ]ERLXO FD PRG GH VROX LRQDUH D GLIHUHQGHORU GLQWUH VWDWH SUHYHGHD úL R GHILQLUH D WHULWRULXOXL DULD WHULWRULDO DVXSUD F UXLD XQ VWDW vúL H[HUFLW VXYHUDQLWDWHD 'HF WUHUHSUH]HQWDQ LL8566(VWRQLHL/LWXDQLHL3RORQLHL7XUFLHL 5RPkQLHL/HWRQLHL3HUVLHL$IJDQLVWDQXOXL&HKRVORYDFLHLúL,XJRVODYLHL $FHVWOXFUXDFRQVWLWXLWRSUHPLHU vQSHULRDGDLQWHUEHOLF vQFHHDFH SULYHúWHUHOD LLOHURPkQRVRYLHWLFH
3H DFHHDúL GLUHF LH GH DF LXQH SHQWUX DVLJXUDUHD VWDWXTXRXOXL WHULWRULDO úL D RE LQHULL GH JDUDQ LL ID GH SROLWLFD UHYL]LRQLVW vQ DSULOLH 1LFRODH 7LWXOHVFX D WUDQVPLV DGH]LXQHD 5RPkQLHL úL D WXWXURU VWDWHORU0LFLLÌQ HOHJHULúLÌQ HOHJHULL%DOFDQLFHOD3DFWXOGHQHDJUHVLXQHúL FRQFLOLD LXQH VHPQDW OD RFWRPEULH OD 5LR GH -DQHLUR vQWUH %UD]LOLD úL $UJHQWLQD FD R FRPSOHWDUH OD 3DFWXO %ULDQG.HOORJ FDUH QX IXVHVHVHPQDWGHF WUHVWDWHOHODWLQRDPHULFDQH &ODU úL FRUHFW D IRVW úL SR]L LD ID GH VHFXULWDWHD HXURSHDQ GH]DUPDUHúLGHILQLUHDDJUHVRUXOXLÌQFRQFHS LDOXL7LWXOHVFXVHFXULWDWHD HXURSHDQ UHSUH]HQWDXQVLVWHPSROLWLFúLMXULGLFODED]DF UXLDWUHEXLDV VWHD 3DFWXO 6RFLHW LL 1D LXQLORU úL VLVWHPXO WUDWDWHORU GH OD 9HUVDLOOHV DFRUGXULOH DVXSUD GH]DUP ULL úL GHILQLUHD DJUHVRUXOXL WUDWDWHOH UHJLRQDOH SDFWXO %ULDQG.HOORJ úL DOWH LQVWUXPHQWH LQWHUQD LRQDOH 6HFXULWDWHD vQ FRQFHS LDPDUHOXLGLSORPDWURPkQWUHEXLDV SRUQHDVF GHODSULQFLSLLOH ÄLQGLYL]LELOLW L úL JHQHUDOLW LL S FLL´ RULFH DJUHVLXQH UHSUH]HQWkQG R vQF OFDUHDS FLLJHQHUDOHV DLE XQFDUDFWHUSUHYHQWLYV VHED]H]HSH LQWHU]LFHUHD IRU HL úL DPHQLQ ULL FX IRU D vQ UHOD LLOH LQWHUQD LRQDOH SULQ VFRDWHUHDU ]ERLXOXLúLDJUHVLXQLLvQDIDUDOHJLLV VHLPSOLFHvQVWDELOLUHD úLGH]YROWDUHDGHUHOD LLDPLFDOHvQWUHWRDWHVWDWHOHFRQWLQHQWXOXL &RQFRPLWHQW 1LFRODH 7LWXOHVFX D I FXW SURSXQHUL FRQFUHWH OD FRQIHULQ D GH]DUP ULL GLQ SHQWUX UHDOL]DUHD GH]DUP ULL SH HWDSHúLSULQWUXQFRQWUROLQWHUQD LRQDOSHUPDQHQW DVXV LQXWSURSXQHUHD I FXW GH00/LWYLQRYUHIHULWRDUHODGHILQLUHDDJUHVRUXOXLvPEXQ W LQG WHUPHQXO SURLHFWXOXL SULQ SUHFL] UL LPSRUWDQWH DGXVH WHUPHQXOXL GH WHULWRULX SR]L LD VD D IRVW XUPDW GH UHSUH]HQWDQ LL FHORUODOWH VWDWH GLQ 0LFD ÌQ HOHJHUH úL QX QXPDL D UHOHYDW UROXO MXFDW GH PDULOH SXWHUL vQ HúHFXO OXFU ULORU &RQIHULQ HL SHQWUX UHGXFHUHD úL OLPLWDUHD DUPDPHQ WHORUúLDQXPHURDVHORUSUREOHPHFDUHDXDS UXWvQUHOD LLOHLQWHUQD LR
Ä&kQG SDFHD HVWH DPHQLQ DW QX VH U VSXQGH FX U ]ERL´ GHFODUD 1LFRODH7LWXOHVFXvQ3DUODPHQWXO5RPkQLHLvQ ÌQ PDUWLH D GHFODUDW XUP WRDUHOH OXL -RKQ 6LPRQ PLQLVWUXO GH ([WHUQHDO0DULL%ULWDQLL Ä6 ILPIUDQFLFHHDFHvPSLHGLF PHUVXOQRUPDODO OXFUXULORU VXQW FRPSOLFD LLOH GH LQWHUHVH vQWUH PDULOH SXWHUL FRQIOLFWXO IUDQFR JHUPDQFRQIOLFWXOLWDORIUDQFH]FRQIOLFWXOIUDQFRHQJOH]/DHOHVHPDLDGDXJ FRQIOLFWXO vQWUH R PDUH SXWHUH úL R PLF SXWHUH GH SLOG FRQIOLFWXO JHUPDQR SRORQH] úL LWDORLXJRVODY 2UL GH FkWH RUL HVWH YRUED GH XQ FRQIOLFW JUDY FDUH vPSLHGLF GH]YROWDUHDQRUPDO DOXFUXULORUHVWHYRUEDGHRPDUHSXWHUH´
QDOH DFRPE WXWSROLWLFDGHUHYL]XLULWHULWRULDOHDPLOLWDWSHQWUXHJDOL WDWHDVWDWHORUPDULVDXPLFLÄDúDGHJUHXFkúWLJDW ´ 7RW 1LFRODH 7LWXOHVFX D FRQGXV vQ FRQFRPLWHQW 0LFD ÌQ HOHJHUH úL ÌQ HOHJHUHD %DOFDQLF D IRVW LQL LDWRUXO UHVWDELOLULL UHOD LLORU GLSORPDWLFHFX8566vQ DVSULMLQLWSURSXQHUHDDGPLWHULL8566 vQ 6RFLHWDWHD 1D LXQLORU úL úLD H[SULPDW DFRUGXO FX DWULEXLUHD UHSUH]HQ WDQWXOXLVRYLHWLFDXQXLORFSHUPDQHQWvQ&RQVLOLXO6RFLHW LL1D LXQLORUD VHVL]DWúLDI FXWSXEOLFOHJ WXUDGLQWUHWHURULVPúLUHYL]LRQLVP'LSORPDW GH YDORDUH XQLYHUVDO HO D SXV vQWRWGHDXQD vQ SULP SODQ LQWHUHVHOH 5RPkQLHL &DRUHFXQRDúWHUHDUROXOXLDFWLYDO5RPkQLHLvQSODQLQWHUQD LRQDO vQ úL 1LFRODH7LWXOHVFXDIRVWDOHVSUHúHGLQWHDOFHORUGHD;,D úLD;,,DVHVLXQLDOH$GXQ ULL*HQHUDOHD6RFLHW LL1D LXQLORU&XFk LYD DQLvQDLQWHvQ ,*'XFDPLQLVWUXOGH([WHUQHDO5RPkQLHLIXVHVH DOHVSUHúHGLQWHDO&RPLVLHLGHGH]DUPDUH &XWRDWHDFHVWHDOD DXJXVW LOXVWUXOGLSORPDWURPkQDIRVW GHPLVGLQJXYHUQ&DX]HOHDXIRVWPXOWLSOHHOHFRQVWkQGvQRVWLOLWDWHDSH SODQ LQWHUQ D PXOWRUD GLQWUH RDPHQLL SROLWLFL URPkQL GH UHJXO GH RULHQWDUH GH GUHDSWD SUHFXP úL vQ GRULQ D UHJHOXL &DURO DO ,,OHD GH D SUHOXDSHUVRQDOFRQGXFHUHDSROLWLFLLH[WHUQHURPkQHúWL/DDFHDVWDVD
ÌQ 1LFRODH 7LWXOHVFX DSUHFLD Ä5HYL]XLUHD QX HVWH SHQWUX 5RPkQLD QXPDL DPSXWDUHD PRúLHL VWU PRúHúWL 5HYL]XLUHD HVWH DPSXWDUHD DWULEX LXQLORU LVWRULFH DOH QHDPXOXL QRVWUX WRFPDL vQ FOLSD vQ FDUH HO úLD GHV YkUúLWXQLWDWHD´ 2FWDYLDQ *RJDLPSXWDPDUHOXLGLSORPDWURPkQF DFFHSWDVHÄUH HWHOH´ 3DULVXOXL ÄEUXVFkQG UDSRUWXULOH´ FX 5RPD ÄU FLQGXOH´ SH FHOH FX 9DUúRYLD úL ÄUHVSLQJkQGXOH´ SH FHOH FX %HOJUDGXO 5HFRPDQGD ÄRSHU GH DGDSWDUH OD vPSUHMXU UL´ 3HVWH GHFHQLL LGHHD D IRVW UHOXDW GH LVWRULFXO 9DOHULX )ORULQ 'REULQHVFXFDUHFRQVLGHUDP VXUDFDILLQGOXDW GLQÄUHDOLVPSROLWLF´/DUkQGXL 9LRULFD0RLVXFDSUHFLD] F DIRVWYRUEDGHÄDGDSWDUHD´ODQRXOFRQWH[WLQWHUQD LRQDOvQvQFHUFDUHDGHDVHF XWDÄPLMORDFHúLPHWRGHQRLSHSODQGLSORPDWLFúL PLOLWDU FDUH V SHUPLW FRQWUDFDUDUHD SHULFROHORU HYLGHQWH OD DGUHVD VHFXULW LL VWDWXTXRXOXL WHULWRULDO DO ULL D LQGHSHQGHQ HL VDOH QD LRQDOH FH GHFXUJHDX GLQ HúXDUHD VHFXULW LL FROHFWLYH FD XUPDUH D DILUP ULL GHVFKLVH D UHYL]LRQLVPXOXL úL UHYDQúLVPXOXLJHUPDQDSROLWLFLLFRQFLOLDQWHDPDULORUDOLD LRFFLGHQWDOL$QJOLDúL )UDQ DDSROLWLFLLGHL]RODUHSUDFWLFDW GH6WDWHOH8QLWHDOH$PHULFLL´ &DURO DO ,,OHD D LQYRFDW IDSWXO F 1LFRODH 7LWXOHVFX GHYHQLVH ÄLQFRPRGúLLQGH]LUDELOFKLDUúLOD/RQGUDúL3DULV´
DG XJDW DWPRVIHUD DQWLWLWXOHVFLDQ vQWUH LQXW SHUPDQHQW OD %HUOLQ 5RPD 9DUúRYLD úL %XGDSHVWD FX SUHF GHUH SUHFXP úL VXVSLFLXQLOH SULYLQGUHOD LLOHVWUkQVHGLQWUH7LWXOHVFXúL/LWYLQRYHWF*XYHUQXOOLEHUDO úLDPRWLYDWJHVWXOSULQQHFHVLWDWHDFRQVWLWXLULLXQXLFDELQHWGHSDUWLGúLD vPEXQ W LULLUHOD LLORUFX,WDOLDúL3RORQLD 0RGDOLWDWHD GHPLWHULL D IRVW EUXWDO úL QHPHULWDW SHQWUX PDUHOH GLSORPDW 1LFRODH 7LWXOHVFX vQO WXUDUHD VD SURGXFkQG PDUL UHJUHWH vQ FRPXQLWDWHDLQWHUQD LRQDO GHPRFUDWLF 1RXO PLQLVWUX URPkQ GH ([WHUQH 9LFWRU $QWRQHVFX D DVLJXUDW OD vQFHSXWXO OXQLL VHSWHPEULH 6RFLHWDWHD 1D LXQLORU úL FHOHODOWH VWDWH HXURSHQH LQFOXVLY 8QLXQHD 6RYLHWLF F QX VH YD SURGXFH QLFL R VFKLPEDUHHVHQ LDO vQSROLWLFDH[WHUQ URPkQHDVF $FHDVW SR]L LHDIRVW UHDILUPDW úLGHF WUH&RQVLOLXO3HUPDQHQWDO0LFLLÌQ HOHJHULvQWUXQLWOD úL VHSWHPEULH OD %UDWLVODYD SULOHM FX FDUH D IRVW UHDILUPDW DWDúDPHQWXO ID GH SROLWLFD GH VHFXULWDWH úL vQFUHGHUHD vQ 6RFLHWDWHD 1D LXQLORU 3R]L LD LQWHUQD LRQDO D 5RPkQLHL úL D VWDWHORU DOLDWH DYHD V ILH LQIOXHQ DW QHJDWLY vQ SHULRDGD XUP WRDUH GH FRQVWLWXLUHD $[HL 5RPD %HUOLQ RFWRPEULH GH VHPQDUHD 3DFWXOXL DQWLFRPLQWHUQ vQWUH *HUPDQLD úL -DSRQLD QRLHPEULH úL GH DF LXQLOH UHYL]LRQLVWH úL UHYDQúDUGHLQL LDWHGH*HUPDQLDvQVSHFLDOGDUúLGHF WUH,WDOLD8QJDULD %XOJDULD LDU vQ ILQDO GH F WUH 8566 FDUH DX XUP ULW vQ SHUPDQHQ UHYL]XLUHDWUDWDWHORUGHOD3DULVGLQ PRGLILFDUHDVWDWXTXRXOXL WHULWRULDOHXURSHDQSUHFXPúLGHVWU PDUHD0LFLLÌQ HOHJHULúLDÌQ HOHJHULL %DOFDQLFH'LQDFHVWXOWLPSXQFWGHYHGHUH*HUPDQLDDvQFHUFDWV DWUDJ GHSDUWHDVD,XJRVODYLDúL5RPkQLD
8QHOHFHUFXULQD]LVWHDXOXDWvQFDOFXOVXSULPDUHDPDUHOXLGLSORPDW 3ROLWLFDH[WHUQ SURPRYDW GH1LFRODH7LWXOHVFXQXDIRVWDJUHDW vQ 3RORQLDvQVXúL-%HFNPLQLVWUXOGH([WHUQHILLQGDXWRUXODQXPHURDVHDUWLFROH RVWLOH 5HVSLQJkQGDFX]D LLOHFHORUFDUHvLLPSXWDXRSUHDPDUHLQVLVWHQ vQ vQFKHLHUHD XQXL DVHPHQHD SURWRFRO 1LFRODH 7LWXOHVFX SUHFL]D Ä1X VXQW FRPXQLVW QDP vPS UW úLW QLFLRGDW DFHDVW GRFWULQ &RQVLGHU vQV F R DSURSLHUHSHW UkPXOSROLWLFLLH[WHUQHFX8566FDUHHVWHDOLDWDDOLD LORUQRúWUL ±)UDQ D&HKRVORYDFLD7XUFLD±HVWHFHOPDLEXQPLMORFGHDSHUPLWHWUDWDWHORU QRDVWUHH[LVWHQWHGHDOLDQ V úLGHDGHSOLQDHILFDFLWDWH´
6FKLPE UL SURIXQGH vQ SROLWLFD H[WHUQ URPkQHDVF QX DX DS UXW QLFL GXS LQVWDXUDUHD JXYHUQXOXL GH GUHDSWD FRQGXV GH 2FWDYLDQ *RJD GHFHPEULH %XFXUHúWLL vQFHUFkQG vQ SHULRDGD XUP WRDUH V PHQ LQ vQFUHGHUHDSXWHULORURFFLGHQWDOHúLV HYLWHDQJDMDUHDXQXLGLDORJ GHVFKLVFX*HUPDQLDvQVSHFLDOvQFHHDFHSULYHúWHvQFKHLHUHDXQHLDOLDQ H SROLWLFRPLOLWDUHÌQDFHVWVHQVODvQFHSXWXODQXOXL SULPXOPLQLVWUX D I FXW FXQRVFXW IDSWXO F SROLWLFD H[WHUQ D 5RPkQLHL VH YD ED]D vQ FRQWLQXDUHSH6RFLHWDWHD1D LXQLORUF 5RPkQLDYDU PkQHILGHO )UDQ HL úLVLVWHPXOXLGHDOLDQ HGLQFDUHI FHDSDUWH 0LFDÌQ HOHJHUHúLÌQ HOHJHUHD %DOFDQLF &RQFRPLWHQW GLSORPD LD URPkQ VD DE LQXW GH OD DFWH RVWLOHúLSURYRFDWRDUHID GH8QLXQHD6RYLHWLF 5RPkQLDúLÌQ HOHJHUHD%DOFDQLF 3UHOLPLQDULL ÌQF GH OD WHUPLQDUHD SULPXOXL U ]ERL PRQGLDO 5RPkQLDDPLOLWDWSHQWUXUHDOL]DUHDvQ HOHJHULLúLS FLLvQWUHSRSRDUHOHGLQ 3HQLQVXOD%DOFDQLF ÌQDFHVWVHQVvQ DXUP ULWSULQDF LXQHD PLQLVWUXOXL GH ([WHUQH 7DNH ,RQHVFX FRQVWLWXLUHD ÄDOLDQ HL vQ FLQFL´ IRUPDW GLQ3RORQLD&HKRVORYDFLD5RPkQLD,XJRVODYLDúL*UHFLD,GHHD DIRVWDJUHDW ODXQPRPHQWGDWúLGHSUHPLHUXO%XOJDULHL6WDPEROLVNL vQV QHvQ HOHJHULOHGLQWUHVWDWHOHEDOFDQLFH GLQWUH%XOJDULDúL,XJRVODYLD PXOWHLQL LDWHúLFRQGXVHGHRUJDQL]D LDWHURULVW PDFHGRQHDQ ,052 GLQWUH *UHFLD úL ,XJRVODYLD vQ FHHD FH SULYHD VLWXD LD PLQRULW LL EXOJDUH GLQ,XJRVODYLDúLUHJLPXOF LLIHUDWH*KHYJKHOLMD6DORQLFGLQWUH*UHFLD
3HQWUX D HOLPLQD RULFH VXVSLFLXQL ,VWUDWH 0LFHVFX PLQLVWUXO GH ([WHUQH D SUHFL]DW OD 3UDJD F Ä5RPkQLD vQ HOHJH V VH VSULMLQH SH 0LFD ÌQ HOHJHUH vQ HJDO FRODERUDUHD FX HD vQ WRDWH FKHVWLXQLOH FDUH LQWHUHVHD] ED]LQXO GXQ UHDQ´ /D %HOJUDG D RE LQXW GLQ SDUWHD OXL 0LODQ 6WRLDGLQRYLü UHvQQRLUHDDQJDMDPHQWHORU,XJRVODYLHLvQFDGUXOÌQ HOHJHULL%DOFDQLFH ÌQ WHPkQGXVHF 0LFDÌQ HOHJHUHDUILIRVWvQGUHSWDW vPSRWULYD %XOJDULHL 6WDPEROLVNL D I FXW FXQRVFXW GRULQ D JXYHUQXOXL GH OD 6RILD GH D DGHUDODUHVSHFWLYDDOLDQ vQORFXO*UHFLHL *XYHUQXOGHOD%HOJUDGGRUHDFD]RQDOLEHU 6DORQLFV ILHFRQVLGHUDW ]RQ GHIURQWLHU LXJRVODY úLFDOLQLDGHFDOHIHUDW *KHYJKHOLMD6DORQLFV ILH DGPLQLVWUDW GHLXJRVODYL1HvQ HOHJHULXOWHULRDUHDXDS UXWvQFHHDFHSULYHúWH SURSXQHUHD IUDQFH] GLQ SULYLQG VROX LRQDUHD SUREOHPHORU SULQ DUELWUDM REOLJDWRULX DFFHSWDW GH *UHFLD GDU UHVSLQV GH ,XJRVODYLD FDUH FRQVLGHUDF QHvQ HOHJHULOH WUHEXLDX VROX LRQDWH SULQ GLVFX LL GLUHFWH ELODWHUDOH )D GH QHvQ HOHJHULOHLXJRVODYRHOHQH5RPkQLDDDGRSWDWRDWLWXGLQHGHHVSHFWDWLY
úL7XUFLDODFDUHVDXDG XJDWFRQVHFLQ HOHORYLWXULLGHVWDWGLQ%XOJDULD GHOD LXQLH vQF OFDUHDWUDWDWXOXLGHOD1HXLOO\VXU6HLQHGHF WUH %XOJDULDSULQvQURO ULVXSOLPHQWDUHGHPLOLWDULúLUHIX]XOILQDODODFHVWHL ULGHDSDUWLFLSDODFRQVWLWXLUHDSDFWXOXLEDOFDQLFDJLWD LLOHGLQ*UHFLDvQ SULYLQ D RS LXQLL GLQWUH UHJLPXO UHSXEOLFDQ úL FHO PRQDUKLF UH LQHULOH LQL LDOHDOH7XUFLHLvQFHHDFHSULYHúWHUHOD LLOHFX5RPkQLDGHWHDPDGHD QX IL DQJUHQDW vQWUXQ HYHQWXDO U ]ERL FX 8566 HWF DX I FXW FD GH]LGHUDWXO vPSOLQLULL XQXL VLVWHP GH DOLDQ H vQWUH VWDWHOH EDOFDQLFH V VH vPSOLQHDVF PXOW PDL WkU]LX vQ vQ SRILGD HIRUWXULORU GHSXVH GH GLSORPD LDGHOD%XFXUHúWLSHQWUXQHWH]LUHDDVSHULW LORUGLQWUHHOH 6LWXD LD VD FRPSOLFDW úL GDWRULW LQWHUYHQ LHL PDULORU SXWHUL FDUH GH LQHDX LQIOXHQ D vQ ]RQ VDX GRUHD V R RE LQ $VWIHO LPHGLDW GXS DGRSWDUHDSDFWXOXLUKHQDQOD/RFDUQRvQ ,WDOLDDvQFHUFDWSHGLYHUVH F L V úL LPSXQ GRPLQD LD vQ *UHFLD ,XJRVODYLD 5RPkQLD úL FKLDU vQ %XOJDULD vQFKHLQG FX DFHVWHD WUDWDWH GH SULHWHQLH úL vQFHUFkQG V OH FRQWUDSXQ XQD DOWRUD /D UkQGXL )UDQ D D vQFHUFDW V FRQWUDFDUH]H DF LXQLOHLWDOLHQHvQDLQWkQGPLQLVWUXOXLURPkQOD3DULVODDXJXVW PXOWDúWHSWDWXOSURLHFWDOWUDWDWXOXLGHSULHWHQLHFX5RPkQLD 3X LQ PDL WkU]LX QRLHPEULH 0DUHD %ULWDQLH D UHOXDW LGHHD PLQLVWUXOXLGH([WHUQHDO*UHFLHL 5HQWLV UHIHULWRDUHODDUELWUDMXOREOLJD WRULX XUPDW GH XQ SDFW GH JDUDQ LH vQ FDGUXO 6RFLHW LL 1D LXQLORU $FFHSWDW GH F WUH *UHFLD SODQXO PLQLVWUXOXL GH ([WHUQH HQJOH] $XVWLQ &KDPEHUODLQDLULWDWvQV JXYHUQXOGHOD3DULVILLQGUHIX]DWGH,XJRVODYLD FDUH GRUHD PDL vQWkL VROX LRQDUHD SUREOHPHL OLWLJLRDVH D ]RQHL OLEHUH GLQ SRUWXO6DORQLFÌQFDGUXODFHORUDúLULYDOLW LGLQWUHPDULOHSXWHULvQFHUFkQG V FRQWUROH]HFHOSX LQLQIOXHQ DLWDOLDQ vQ%DOFDQL vQFXUDMDW GLQFXOLVH GHF WUHHQJOH]L )UDQ DDSURSXV,WDOLHLvQFKHLHUHDXQXLSDFWIUDQFRLWDOR LXJRVODYIDSWUHIX]DWGHJXYHUQXOGHOD5RPD7UHFkQGSHVWHWRDWHDFHVWH LQWHUHVHGLYHUJHQWHPDULOHSXWHULDXVWDELOLWvQWUHHOHvQ HOHJHULFDUHFRQ
*UHFLD QX D UDWLILFDW DFRUGXO GH OD $QNDUD ÌQ GLVFX LH PDL HUDX GHVS JXELULOHFHWUHEXLDXSO WLWHSURSULHWDULORUPXVXOPDQLHPLJUD LGLQ*UHFLD vQDLQWHGHGHFHPEULHSUHFXPúLSUREOHPDvQWRDUFHULLOD&RQVWDQWLQRSRO DFHORUGHSHUVRDQHUHIXJLDWHvQWLPSXOXOWLPXOXLU ]ERLJUHFRWXUF )DSW FRPE WXW GH FRQIHULQ D 0LFLL ÌQ HOHJHUL GH OD %HOJUDG GLQ QRLHPEULH /DXQPRPHQWGDW0DUHD%ULWDQLHDDFFHSWDWLGHHDSDFWXOXLEDOFDQLF GDUI U 7XUFLDSHFDUHRFRQVLGHUDSXWHUHDVLDWLF
WUDYHQHDX XQRUD GLQWUH VWDWHOH GLQ ]RQ VHPQLILFDWLY vQ DFHVW VHQV ILLQG DFRUGXODQJORLWDOLDQFKLDUGDF DFHVWDQXFRQYHQHDLQWHUHVHORUIUDQFH]H $PkQDUHD vQFKHLHULL SDFWXOXL EDOFDQLF VD GDWRUDW úL SR]L LLORU GLIHULWH DOH VWDWHORU GLQ ]RQ ID GH XQD VDX DOWD GLQ SUREOHPHOH FDUH WUHEXLDX VROX LRQDWH $VWIHO OD XQ PRPHQW GDW *UHFLD D DGHUDW OD LGHHD EULWDQLF D vQFKHLHULL SDFWXOXL I U 7XUFLD D GRULW úL LQFOXGHUHD $OEDQLHL IDSW UHVSLQV GH ,XJRVODYLD ,XJRVODYLD D GRULW vQFKHLHUHD DOLDQ HL GRDU GXS VROX LRQDUHD GLIHUHQGHORU FX *UHFLD ÌQ SULP YDUD DQXOXL 5RPkQLD *UHFLD úL ,XJRVODYLD WHPkQGXVH GH vQWUHUXSHUHD SO LL GHVS JXELULORUGHU ]ERLGHF WUHJXYHUQXOGHOD6RILDDXFRQGL LRQDWDFRUGDUHD XQXL vPSUXPXW %XOJDULHL GH F WUH 6RFLHWDWHD 1D LXQLORU GH FRQVXOWDUHD JXYHUQHORU GH OD %XFXUHúWL %HOJUDG úL $WHQD úL GH FRQWUROXO IRORVLULL DFHVWXLD ÌQ GRULQ D GH D UHDOL]D R vQ HOHJHUH VWDWHOH EDOFDQLFH VDX DU WDW GLVSXVHV IDF XQHOHFRQFHVLLDXvQFKHLDWvQWUHHOHDFRUGXULúLSDFWHGH DPLFL LH úLDXI FXWQXPHURDVHSURSXQHULSHQWUXvQFKHLHUHDSDFWXOXL
,QL LDO ,XJRVODYLD VD RSXV LDU 5RPkQLD D FRQGL LRQDW DFRUGDUHD vPSUXPXWXOXLGHIRORVLUHDOXLQXPDLSHQWUXUHIXJLD LLEXOJDUL *UHFLDVDDU WDWGLVSXV V GXEOH]HVDXFKLDUV WULSOH]HFDOHDIHUDW VSUH6DORQLFDFFHSWkQGúLVXSUDYHJKHUHDWUDILFXOXLGHF WUHXQIXQF LRQDUHOHQ úLVkUE SHQWUXDvQOHVQLWUDQ]LWXOLXJRVODYVSUH0DUHD(JHH 7RWHDVDDU WDW GLVSXV V UH]ROYH SUREOHPD LHúLULL %XOJDULHL OD 0DUHD (JHH GDF DúD FXP SUHFL]DSULPXOPLQLVWUX7VDOGDULVVHP UJLQHúWHODXQGHEXúHXFRPHUFLDOSULQ &DYDOD ÌQPDUWLH SDFWXOGHQHDJUHVLXQHúLDUELWUDMvQWUH5RPkQLDúL*UHFLD vQ VHSWHPEULH SDFWXO GH SULHWHQLH úL QHDJUHVLXQH JUHFRWXUF vQ RFWRPEULH WUDWDWXOGHDPLFL LHQHDJUHVLXQHDUELWUDMúLFRQFLOLD LXQHURPkQRWXUF *UHFLD D SURSXV SULQ PLQLVWUXO GH ([WHUQH 5HQWLV DGRSWDUHD DUELWUDMXOXLREOLJDWRULXXUPDWGHvQFKHLHUHDXQRUWUDWDWHGHQHDJUHVLXQHvQWUHWRDWH VWDWHOHEDOFDQLFH 0DUHD%ULWDQLHDUHOXDWLGHHDOXL5HQWLVúLVDSURQXQ DW SHQWUXFRQVWLWXLUHDXQXL/RFDUQREDOFDQLF 7XUFLDDVRQGDW5RPkQLDGDF GRUHDV VHDOLH]HSHED]DXQXLDFRUGEDOFDQLFGHQHDJUHVLXQHúLGHDUELWUDMI U RVWLOLWDWH FRQWUD 8QLXQLL 6RYLHWLFH *UHFLD D ULGLFDW SUREOHPD vQILLQ ULL XQHL6RFLHW LD1D LXQLORU%DOFDQLFHFXVHGLXOOD&RQVWDQWLQRSRO 7XUFLDD SURSXV SULQ PLQLVWUXO GH ([WHUQH 7YILN 5VW$UDV vQFKHLHUHD XQXL SDFW vQWUH 5RPkQLD,XJRVODYLD*UHFLDúL7XUFLDFDUHV QXILHSDWURQDWGHF WUHQLFLRPDUH SXWHUH úL V QX ILH vQGUHSWDW vPSRWULYD FXLYD 7XUFLD D SURSXV DGHUDUHD VWDWHORUEDOFDQLFHOD3URWRFROXOGHOD0RVFRYDúLUHOXDUHDUHOD LLORUGLSORPDWLFHFX 8566 1LFRODH 7LWXOHVFX D SURSXV %XOJDULHL vQFKHLHUHD XQXL SDFW vQ FLQFL
8WLOHSHQWUXSUHJ WLUHDWHUHQXOXLvQYHGHUHDvQFKHLHULLSDFWXOXLEDOFDQLFV DX GRYHGLW D IL úL FRQIHULQ HOH EDOFDQLFH LQL LDWH GH *UHFLD vQ FDGUXO F URUD DX IRVW GLVFXWDWH SH OkQJ SUREOHPHOH HFRQRPLFH úL QXPHURDVH DVSHFWHSROLWLFH 'HPHUVXUL D I FXW úL PLQLVWUXO GH ([WHUQH URPkQ vQ RFWRPEULH FX SULOHMXO YL]LWHL OD 6RILD QG D SURSXV vQFKHLHUHD XQXL SDFW EDOFDQLF PXOWLODWHUDO úL D XQRU vQ HOHJHUL ELODWHUDOH vQ SUREOHPHOH GLYHUJHQWHFXH[FHS LDFHORUFHYL]DXUHYL]XLULOHWHULWRULDOH3UREOHPD DIRVWULGLFDW GH1LFRODH7LWXOHVFXúLvQWLPSXOYL]LWHORUI FXWHOD$WHQD $QNDUDúL%HOJUDGFDUHDXDYXWXQPDUHHFRXLQWHUQD LRQDOSUHFXPúLvQ &RQVLOLXO3HUPDQHQWDO0LFLLÌQ HOHJHULGHOD=DJUHEGLQLDQXDULH 3UREOHPDSDFWXOXLEDOFDQLFDIRVWGLVFXWDW úLvQFDGUXOFRQIHULQ HORU 0LFLLÌQ HOHJHUL IHEUXDULH OD7LPLúRDUDLXQLH OD%OHG PDL OD ,RDNLPRY GHFHPEULH OD %HOJUDG IHEUXDULH OD*HQHYDVHSWHPEULH OD6LQDLDLDQXDULH OD=DJUHE *XYHUQXOEXOJDUQXDGRULWvQV V VHDQJDMH]HvQUHVSHFWDUHDVWDWX TXRXOXLWHULWRULDOSURSXQkQGSULQSULPXOPLQLVWUX0XúDQRYvQFKHLHUHD XQRUSDFWHELODWHUDOHGHQHDJUHVLXQH 3UHYHGHULOH SDFWXOXL ÌQ HOHJHULL %DOFDQLFH /D IHEUXDULH PLQLúWULL GH ([WHUQH DL 5RPkQLHL *UHFLHL 7XUFLHL úL ,XJRVODYLHL DX VHPQDWOD$WHQD3DFWXOÌQ HOHJHULL%DOFDQLFHRUJDQL]D LHGHVHFXULWDWHúL FRODERUDUH GLQ %DOFDQL SULQ FDUH FHOH SDWUX VWDWH vúL JDUDQWDX PXWXDO
3ULPDFRQIHULQ VDGHVI úXUDWOD$WHQDvQWUHúLRFWRPEULH D GRXD OD ,VWDQEXO vQWUH úL RFWRPEULH vQ FDGUXO F UHLD VH GLVFXW XQ DQWHSURLHFWJUHF DWUHLDOD%XFXUHúWLvQWUHúL RFWRPEULH FDUHDGRSW WH[WXOSDFWXOXLEDOFDQLFvQDEVHQ DGHOHJD LORUEXOJDULvQV DSDWUDOD6DORQLFvQWUH úLQRLHPEULH SULOHMFXFDUHSDFWXOEDOFDQLFHVWHYRWDWvQXQDQLPLWDWH úL GH F WUH GHOHJD LD EXOJDU $ D IRVW DPkQDW VLQH GLH FRQVLGHUkQGXVH F SUREOHPHOHSXWHDXILVROX LRQDWHPDLELQHvQFDGUXOÌQ HOHJHULL%DOFDQLFHúLGH ODJXYHUQODJXYHUQ ) U UH]XOWDWHGHRVHELWHDU PDVúLvQWkOQLUHDGLQWUH&DURODO,,OHDúL %RULVDO,,,OHDSHYDVXOÄùWHIDQFHO0DUH´ 6D GHFLV F FHOH WUHL VWDWH HUDX ÄVLQFHU LQWHUHVDWH vQ VWDELOLUHD XQRU EXQHUDSRUWXULFX%XOJDULDQHDYkQGQLFLXQLQWHUHVGHDQXF XWDVWDWRUQLFLUHD XQRU DWDUL UDSRUWXUL´ 3ULQ XUPDUH GLQ SXQFWXO GH YHGHUH DO 0LFLL ÌQ HOHJHUL %XOJDULDSXWHDSDUWLFLSDODRULFHSDFWUHJLRQDO]RQDOGDF UHVSHFWDVWDWXTXRXO WHULWRULDOH[LVWHQW
ÄVLJXUDQ DWXWXURUIUXQWDULLORUORUEDOFDQLFH´REOLJkQGXVHV VHVI WXLDVF DVXSUD ÄP VXULORU GH OXDW vQ ID D XQRU vPSUHMXU UL FH DU SXWHD DWLQJH LQWHUHVHOHORU´([WUHPGHLPSRUWDQW DIRVWúLSUHFL]DUHDGLQDUWLFROHOHúL GLQ3DFWSULQFDUHFHOHSDWUXVWDWHVHREOLJDXÄV QXvQWUHSULQG QLFLR DF LXQH SROLWLF ID GH RULFH DU EDOFDQLF QHVHPQDWDU D SUH]HQWXOXL DFRUGI U DYL]XOPXWXDOSUHDODELOúLV QXLDQLFLRREOLJD LHSROLWLF ID GHRULFHDOW DU EDOFDQLF I U FRQVLP PkQWXOFHORUODOWH3 U L&RQWUDF WDQWH´ UHVSHFWLY F 3DFWXO ÄYD IL GHVFKLV RULF UHL DOWH UL EDOFDQLFH D F UHLDGHUDUHYDIDFHRELHFWXOXQHLFHUFHW ULIDYRUDELOHGLQSDUWHDS U LORU &RQWUDFWDQWHúLYDDYHDHIHFWGHvQGDW FHFHOHODOWH ULVHPQDWDUHvúLYRUIL QRWLILFDWDVHQWLPHQWXO´ 3URWRFROXO DQH[ SDUWH D 3DFWXOXL SUHFL]D vQF RGDW F DOLDQ D EDOFDQLF QX HUD vQGUHSWDW vPSRWULYD YUHXQHL SXWHUL F FHOH SDWUX VWDWH DOLDWH XUPDX V UHDF LRQH]H GRDU vQ FD]XO XQHL DJUHVLXQL GLQ SDUWHD XQHL UL EDOFDQLFH ÌQ VLWXD LD vQ FDUH XQ VWDW DOLDW HUD DJUHVDW GH XQ VWDW QHEDOFDQLFFXSDUWLFLSDUHDXQXLVWDWEDOFDQLF3DFWXOLQWUDvQDF LXQHID GH DUD EDOFDQLF DJUHVRDUH ÌQ VLWXD LD vQ FDUH DJUHVRUXO HUD XQXO GLQ VWDWHOHSDUWHODSDFWDFHVWDQXLQWUDvQYLJRDUHùLGHDFHDVW GDW 7XUFLDD ULGLFDW ÄFODX]D VRYLHWLF ´ PLQLVWUXO GH ([WHUQH WXUF LPSXQkQG R 'HFODUD LHSDUWHGLQ3DFWSULQFDUHVHSUHFL]DF DUDVDQXYDSDUWLFLSDOD XQU ]ERLvPSRWULYD8QLXQLL6RYLHWLFH$FHDVW SR]L LHFDúLDOWHOHDYHDX V FRQVWLWXLHXQXOGLQSXQFWHOHVODEHDOHQRLLRUJDQL]D LLSROLWLFRPLOLWDUH GHDS UDUH &DUDFWHUXO GHIHQVLY DO ÌQ HOHJHULL %DOFDQLFH FD úL DO 0LFLL ÌQ HOHJHUL UH]XOWD úL GLQ IDSWXO F WRDWH VWDWHOH PHPEUH VHPQDVHU 3DFWXO %ULDQG.HOORJ Ä3DFWXO´ GH OD 3DULV SULYLQG UHQXQ DUHD OD
,RDQ6FXUWX5RPkQLDúL0DULOH3XWHUL S ÌQ PRG FRQFUHW VH YL]D R HYHQWXDO DJUHVLXQH GLQ SDUWHD %XOJDULHL FDUH DYHD SUHWHQ LL WHULWRULDOH ID GH ILHFDUH VWDW SDUWLFLSDQW OD ÌQ HOHJHUHD %DOFDQLF 2SXQkQGXVHvQFKHLHULLÌQ HOHJHULL%DOFDQLFH%XOJDULDDSURSXVXQ VLVWHPGHvQ HOHJHUHED]DWQXPDLSHSDFWHELODWHUDOH /D RFWRPEULH D IRVW DGRSWDW 6WDWXWXO GH RUJDQL]DUH DO ÌQ HOHJHULL%DOFDQLFHSULQFDUHDXIRVWFRQVWLWXLWH &RQVLOLXO3HUPDQHQWIRUPDW GLQPLQLúWULLGH([WHUQH&RQVLOLXO(FRQRPLF&RQVXOWDWLYIRUPDWGLQVSHFLDOLúWL GLQGRPHQLXOHFRQRPLFFRPHUFLDOúLILQDQFLDUSUHFXPúL&RPLVLLSHGLYHUVH SUREOHPH
U ]ERL DXJXVW úL &RQYHQ LLOH GH GHILQLUH D DJUHVLXQLL GH OD /RQGUD LXOLH ÌQ HOHJHUHD %DOFDQLF úLD GRYHGLW XQLWDWHD úL vQ vQ FRQWH[WXOvQFDUHUHYL]LRQLúWLLEXOJDULSURILWkQGGHVLWXD LDWXOEXUHGLQ *UHFLD GH OD PDUWLH PLúFDUHD UHSXEOLFDQ vPSRWULYD SDUWL]DQLORU UHVWDXU ULL PRQDUKLHL VDX GHFODUDW JDWD V DWDFH 7UDFLD JUHFHDVF &KLDUGDF RILFLDOJXYHUQXOEXOJDUDDGRSWDWÄRDWLWXGLQHSUXGHQW úL UHDOLVW ´ 1LFRODH 7LWXOHVFX vQ FDOLWDWHD GH SUHúHGLQWH vQ H[HUFL LX DO ÌQ HOHJHULL%DOFDQLFHDDWUDVDWHQ LDJXYHUQXOXLGHOD6RILDvQDFRUGFX JXYHUQHOHGHOD$WHQDúL$QNDUDF vQVLWXD LDvQFDUHWUXSHOHEXOJDUH DU IL S WUXQV SH WHULWRULXO JUHF SDFWXO EDOFDQLF DU IL LQWUDW DXWRPDW vQ IXQF LXQH 3R]L LDID GHHYHQLPHQWHúLFUL]HGLSORPDWLFHúLPLOLWDUH GLQGHFHQLXO ÌQ FRQWH[WXO DFXWL] ULL SROLWLFLL UHYL]LRQLVWH úL UHYDQúDUGH vQ GHFHQLXODOVHFROXOXL;;5RPkQLDúLDOLD LLV LGLQ0LFDÌQ HOHJHUHúL ÌQ HOHJHUHD %DOFDQLF DX DGRSWDW R SR]L LH IHUP GH UHVSLQJHUH WXWXURU SODQXULORU FDUH YL]DX vQWUR IRUP VDX DOWD PRGLILFDUHD VWDWXTXRXOXL WHULWRULDOVWDELOLWSULQWUDWDWHOHGHSDFHGHOD3DULVGLQ 8QLXQHD YDPDO $úD VD SURFHGDW vQ FD]XO SODQXOXL GH XQLXQH YDPDO SURSXVGH)UDQ DSHQWUX]RQDGXQ UHDQ FDUHDIRVWUHVSLQVvQPDL
Ä&DúL0LFDÌQ HOHJHUH±UHOHYDODDSULOLH 1LFRODH7LWXOHVFX± ÌQ HOHJHUHD%DOFDQLF HVWHRDVRFLD LHFKHPDW DúLYDORULILFDULWPLFFRH]LXQHD vQSUH]HQ DJUHXW LLYLH LLGHWRDWH]LOHOHLDUQXQXPDLFDDOLDQ HOHWUHFXWHDúL vQFHUFDSXWHULOHvQPRPHQWHGHFUL] ´ Ä1XPDL JUD LH DFHVWXL SDFW ÌQ HOHJHUHD %DOFDQLF ± QQ ± UHOHYD Ä-RXUQDO GH 0RVFRX´ ± HYHQLPHQWHOH GLQ *UHFLD QX DX GHJHQHUDW vQ FRQIOLFW LQWHUQD LRQDOFXGH]YROW ULQHSUHY ]XWH´/DUkQGXL1LFRODH7LWXOHVFXUHOHYDOD PDUWLH Ä*UHFLDDSXWXWV úLSO WHDVF OX[XOXQHLUHYROX LLODDG SRVWXO SDFWXOXLEDOFDQLFI U V VHWHDP RVLQJXU FOLS F LQWHJULWDWHDHLWHULWRULDO DU SXWHDILDPHQLQ DW ´
GH 5RPkQLD &HKRVORYDFLD úL ,XJRVODYLD &X DFHODúL SULOHM VDX GLVFXWDW úL SURSXQHULOH I FXWH GH (GXDUG %HQHã DVHP Q WRDUH FHORU FXSULQVH vQ SODQXO IUDQFH] FDUH YL]DX DVRFLHUHD PLFLORU VWDWH FX WRDWH SXWHULOHLQWHUHVDWHGHED]LQXOGXQ UHDQFHQWUDO )UDQ D*HUPDQLD,WDOLD úLVROX LRQDUHDFUL]HLSULQSDUWLFLSDUHDWXWXURUVWDWHORUHXURSHQH 3ODQXO 7DUGLHX ÌQ VWDWHOH 0LFLL ÌQ HOHJHUL DX PDQLIHVWDW XQ HQWX]LDVPPRGHUDWID GHSODQXO7DUGLHX SULQFDUHVHSURSXQHDFDFHOH FLQFL VWDWH GDQXELHQH V UHQXQ H vQWUH HOH OD FODX]D QD LXQLL FHOHL PDL IDYRUL]DWH VWDELOLQG WDULIH SUHIHUHQ LDOH GH LQL LDO GHVILLQ DUHD UHVWULF LLORU SHQWUX FRPHU úL VFKLPE FX HYHQWXDOLWDWHD XQHL PRQHGH FRPXQH HWF úL DX GHFLV V O VXV LQ GDF DFHVWD VH UHIHUHD GRDU OD SUREOHPHOHHFRQRPLFHDOHUHJLXQLLGDQXELHQHúLQXDERUGDúLSUREOHPHOH SROLWLFHLQFOXVLYSHFHOHDOHFRQVWLWXLULLXQHLFRQIHGHUD LLGDQXELHQH 'LUHFWRUDWXOHXURSHDQÌQSULP YDUDDQXOXL FHOHWUHLVWDWHGLQ 0LFD ÌQ HOHJHUH DX UHVSLQV SURLHFWXO LQL LDW GH %HQLWR 0XVVROLQL GHFHPEULH SULYLQG RUJDQL]DUHD FRQWLQHQWXOXL HXURSHDQ VXE HJLGD *HUPDQLHL )UDQ HL 0DULL %ULWDQLL úL ,WDOLHL FDUH FRQ LQHD HYLGHQWH SUHYHGHULUHYL]LRQLVWHÌQDFHDVW GLUHF LH&RQIHULQ D0LFLLÌQ HOHJHULGLQ PDUWLH D I FXW FXQRVFXW F QLFL XQ VWDW QX SXWHD GLVSXQH GH WHULWRULXODOWXLVWDWÄQLFLGLUHFWQLFLLQGLUHFW´F SULQFLSLLOHGHFXUJkQGGLQ 3DFWXO6RFLHW LL1D LXQLORUWUHEXLDXUHVSHFWDWHF VWDWHOH0LFLLÌQ HOHJHUL VHRSXQHDXUHYL]XLULLWUDWDWHORUÌPSRWULYDUHYL]XLULLWUDWDWHORUDPLOLWDWvQ DSULOLH OD 3DULV úL 1LFRODH 7LWXOHVFX 'XS FH vQ XUPD LQWHUYHQ LHL )UDQ HL FRQ LQXWXO SDFWXOXL TYDGUXSOX D IRVW PRGLILFDW SULQ HOLPLQDUHD SUHYHGHULORU SULYLQG PRGLILFDUHD 3DFWXOXL 6RFLHW LL 1D LXQLORU úL SULQ LQWURGXFHUHD XQHL FODX]H DQWLUHYL]LRQLVWH 5RPkQLD &HKRVORYDFLD úL ,XJRVODYLD VDX GHFODUDW GH DFRUG FX QRXO WH[W DO SDFWXOXL VHPQDW OD
3ODQXOIUDQFH]SUHYHGHD RSXQHUHDODXQLXQHDYDPDO HODERUDUHDXQXL SODQ FRQVWUXFWLY SHQWUX XúXUDUHD VLWXD LHL HFRQRPLFH D *HUPDQLHL úL $XVWULHL FODULILFDUHDFKHVWLXQLLSULYLQGVFXUJHUHDFHUHDOHORUGLQVWDWHOHDJUDUH VWXGLHUHD SRVLELOLW LORUGHDVROX LRQDOLSVDGHFDSLWDOúLGHFUHGLWD(XURSHLFHQWUDOHúLvQ VSHFLDOD$XVWULHL HODERUDUHDXQXLUHJLPSUHIHUHQ LDODXQRUvQ HOHJHULLQGXV WULDOH úL DJULFROH LQWHUQD LRQDOH LQVWLWXLUHD XQXL RUJDQLVP FRPXQ GH YkQ]DUH FXPS UDUHDO ULORUDJULFROH LQVWLWXLUHDXQHLDVLVWHQ HILQDQFLDUHLQWHUQD LRQDOH IRUPXODUHD XQXLUHJLPSUHIHUHQ LDOSHQWUXVWDWHOHDJULFROHSDUDOHOFXDOXQXLD SHQWUX$XVWULD
5RPDODLXQLH &XWRDWHDFHVWHD*HUPDQLDúL,WDOLDDXFRQWLQXDW SROLWLFDUHYL]LRQLVW 3DFWXO 2ULHQWDO ÌQ VHSWHPEULH VWDWHOH 0LFLL ÌQ HOHJHUL úL ÌQ HOHJHULL%DOFDQLFHVDXSURQXQ DWIDYRUDELOID GHvQFKHLHUHD3DFWXOXL 2ULHQWDO vQWUH )UDQ D 8QLXQHD 6RYLHWLF *HUPDQLD &HKRVORYDFLD 3RORQLDúLVWDWHOHEDOWLFHFDXQDFRUGUHJLRQDOGHFRQVXOWDUHQHDJUHVLXQH úL GH DVLVWHQ PXWXDO vPSRWULYD RULF UHL DJUHVLXQL vQ FDGUXO F UXLD )UDQ D DU IL JDUDQWDW IURQWLHUHOH YHVWLFH DOH 8566 LDU DFHDVWD SH FHOH HVWLFHDOH)UDQ HL 'DWRULW UHIX]XOXL *HUPDQLHL D LQYRFDW OR]LQFD ÄDQWLEROúHYLV PXOXL´ REVWDFROHORUDS UXWHGXS FULPDGHOD0DUVLOLDGLQ RFWRPEULH DVDVLQDUHD UHJHOXL $OH[DQGUX DO ,XJRVODYLHL úL D SULPXOPLQLVWUX IUDQFH] /RXLV %DUWKRX úL SR]L LHL QHJDWLYH D JXYHUQXOXL GH OD 9DUúRYLD QXGRUHDV SHUPLW WUXSHORUVRYLHWLFHV LWUDQ]LWH]HWHULWR ULXO SODQXO D HúXDW vQI SWXLQGXVH GRDU SDU LDO SULQ VHPQDUHD WUDWDWXOXL IUDQFRVRYLHWLFGHDVLVWHQ PXWXDO PDL úLDFHOXLVRYLHWRFH KRVORYDF PDL
,PHGLDW GXS DWHQWDWXOXL GH OD 0DUVLOLD VWDWHOH 0LFLL ÌQ HOHJHUL úL ÌQ HOHJHULL %DOFDQLFH DX SURWHVWDW YHKHPHQW ID GH DFHVW DFW WHURULVW LDU vQ QRLHPEULH 5RPkQLD úL &HKRVORYDFLD DX VXV LQXW OD *HQHYD SOkQJHUHD ,XJRVODYLHL vPSRWULYD 8QJDULHL FDUH DG SRVWLVH úL DMXWDVH SH WHURULúWLL FURD L FDUHDVDVLQDVHU SHUHJHOH$OH[DQGUXúLSH/RXLV%DUWKRX$WLWXGLQHD)UDQ HL FDUH QX GRUHD V VXSHUH ,WDOLD SHQWUX D R DYHD DOLDW vPSRWULYD *HUPDQLHL SR]L LD0DULL%ULWDQLLúLFKLDUD,XJRVODYLHL GXS YL]LWDSULQ XOXLUHJHQW3DXOOD /RQGUD DXI FXWFDvQWLPSXOGH]EDWHULORUGHOD*HQHYDQXPHOH,WDOLHLV QXILH PHQ LRQDWVFR kQGXVHvQHYLGHQ ODLQVLVWHQ DVWDWHORU0LFLLÌQ HOHJHULGRDU ÄQHJOLMHQ D´FRQGDPQDELO D8QJDULHL 3HQWUXDFkúWLJDWLPSJXYHUQXOSRORQH]DFRQGL LRQDWDGHUDUHDODSDFWXO RULHQWDOGHFRQVXOWDUHD5RPkQLHLFXWRDWHF vLFXQRúWHDGHMDSR]L LDIDYRUDELO ÌQ HVHQ WUDWDWXO GH DVLVWHQ PXWXDO IUDQFRVRYLHWLF SUHYHGHD F FHOHGRX VWDWHVHDQJDMDXV úLDFRUGHDMXWRUúLDVLVWHQ UHFLSURF vQVLWXD LDvQ FDUHXQXOGLQWUHHOHDUILGHYHQLWÄRELHFWXOXQHLDJUHVLXQLQHSURYRFDWHGLQSDUWHD XQXL VWDW HXURSHDQ´ 6HPQDUHD OXL D IRVW JU ELW GH DQXQ DUHD RILFLDO D FRQVWLWXLULLDYLD LHLPLOLWDUHJHUPDQH PDUWLH úLLQWURGXFHUHDVHUYLFLXOXL PLOLWDUREOLJDWRULX PDUWLH 8QLXQHD 6RYLHWLF úL &HKRVORYDFLD VDX DQJDMDW V úL DFRUGH UHFLSURF DMXWRUvQVLWXD LDvQFDUHXQDGLQWUHHOHDUILGHYHQLWYLFWLPDXQHLDJUHVLXQLH[WHUQH 3URWRFROXODGL LRQDOVHFUHWSUHYHGHDvQV F REOLJD LLOHGHDVLVWHQ PXWXDO HUDX YDODELOH QXPDL vQ VLWXD LD vQ FDUH HUDX vQGHSOLQLWH SUHYHGHULOH WUDWDWXOXL IUDQFR VRYLHWLFúLÄQXPDLvQFD]XOvQFDUH)UDQ DYDGDDMXWRUYLFWLPHLXQHLDJUHVLXQL´
&RQVLOLXO 3HUPDQHQW DO ÌQ HOHJHULL %DOFDQLFH D VDOXWDW VHPQDUHD SDFWXOXL IUDQFRVRYLHWLF PDL FRQVLGHUkQGXO ÄED]D YLLWRDUHL RUJDQL] UL D VHFXULW LL vQ (XURSD RULHQWDO ´ $YkQG R FRQWULEX LH LPSRUWDQW OD HODERUDUHD GRFXPHQWXOXL 1LFRODH 7LWXOHVFX D DSUHFLDW F vQWUXQWLPSVFXUW(XURSDYDILÄDFRSHULW GHRUH HDGHDFRUGXULUHJLRQDOH GH DVLVWHQ PXWXDO ´ FDUH YRU SHUPLWH FD YLLWRUXO V ILH vQWUHY ]XW FX ÄPXOW vQFUHGHUH´ 3DFWXO PHGLWHUDQHDQ 2 SR]L LH IDYRUDELO DX DGRSWDW vQ VWDWHOHGLQÌQ HOHJHUHD%DOFDQLF ID GHSURLHFXOSDFWXOXLPHGLWHUDQHDQ FDUH vQ FRQFHS LD ORU WUHEXLD V FXSULQG XQ SDFW GH QHDJUHVLXQH vQWUH VWDWHOH ÌQ HOHJHULL %DOFDQLFH úL ,WDOLD úL FRQYHQ LL PLOLWDUH GH DVLVWHQ PXWXDO vQWUHVWDWHOHÌQ HOHJHULL%DOFDQLFHvPSRWULYDRULF UXLDFWDJUHVLY ÌQ DFHVW FD] SDFWXO PHGLWHUDQHDQ SXWHD IL VHPQDW LQGHSHQGHQW GH SDUWLFLSDUHDFHORUSDWUXVWDWHODSDFWXOGHDVLVWHQ /DYDO0XVVROLQLGLQ LDQXDULH ÌQFDGUXOGLVFX LLORUVDPDLVROLFLWDWFD,WDOLDV vQFHWH]H SURSDJDQGD UHYL]LRQLVW úL V RIHUH OD UkQGXO V X DVLVWHQ PXWXDO ÌQ ILQDO GDWRULW ULYDOLW LORU GLQWUH PDULOH SXWHUL 3DFWXO 0HGLWHUDQHDQ QX D IRVWvQFKHLDW 3DFWXO GDQXELDQ ÌQFHUFkQG V UHFRQFLOLH]H UHOD LLOH GLQWUH VWDWHOH GLQ ]RQD GDQXELDQ &RQVLOLXO 3HUPDQHQW DO 0LFLL ÌQ HOHJHUL vQWUXQLW OD %OHG DXJXVW VD GHFODUDW vQ SULQFLSLX GH DFRUG FX SDUWLFLSDUHDDO WXULGH)UDQ DúLGH,WDOLDODXQSDFWGDQXELDQFDUHWUHEXLD V JDUDQWH]H LQWHJULWDWHD $XVWULHL 'DWRULW VFKLPE ULL SR]L LHL ,WDOLHL LQWHUHVDW GHVSULMLQXOJHUPDQvQYHGHUHDYLLWRUXOXLU ]ERLGLQ(WLRSLDQLFL DFHVWSDFWQXDIRVWvQFKHLDW 'HFL]LLOH GH OD 6WUHVVD 0DUL QHPXO XPLUL DX SURGXV VWDWHORU FDUH FRQVWLWXLDX0LFDÌQ HOHJHUHúLÌQ HOHJHUHD%DOFDQLF GHFL]LLOHDGRSWDWHOD 6WUHVVD DSULOLH GHF WUH0DUHD%ULWDQLH)UDQ DúL,WDOLDúLPDL DOHVUHFRPDQG ULOHI FXWHvQSUREOHPDUHvQDUP ULL%XOJDULHL8QJDULHLúL
6SUH GHRVHELUH GH 1LFRODH 7LWXOHVFX :LQVWRQ &KXUFKLOO DSUHFLD F SDFWXOIUDQFRVRYLHWLFFDUHQXHUDvQVR LWGHRFRQYHQ LHPLOLWDU QXFRQVWLWXLD XQIDFWRUGHVWDELOLWDWHHXURSHDQ GHRDUHFHÄQXDQJDMDQLFLXQDGLQWUHFHOHGRX S U LvQFD]GHDJUHVLXQHJHUPDQ ´&XWRDWHDFHVWDHODFRQWULEXLWODDQJDMDUHD 8566vQSROLWLFDHXURSHDQ *UHFLDúLDUH]HUYDWGUHSWXOGHDQXSDUWLFLSDODSDFWXO/DYDO0XVVROLQLúLOD FHO GH QHLPL[WLXQH vQ VFKLPEXO REOLJD LHL GH D GD DVLVWHQ PLOLWDU vQ FDGUXO SDFWXOXLPHGLWHUDQHDQU PkQkQGvQYLJRDUHúLREOLJD LLOHVDOHDQWHULRDUH
$XVWULHLFDUHDXIRVWFRQVLGHUDWHDILH[WUHPGHSHULFXORDVHSHQWUXSDFHD úL HFKLOLEUXO HXURSHDQ VWDWXDW OD 3DULV SULQ WUDWDWHOH GLQ ÌQWUXQL L OD *HQHYD DSULOLH VXE SUHúHGHQ LD OXL 1LFRODH 7LWXOHVFXUHSUH]HQWDQ LLFHORUFLQFLVWDWHDXDSUHFLDWF YLLWRDUHOHP VXUL FHXUPDXDILOXDWHvQDFHVWVHQVWUHEXLDXV ILHVWUkQVFRQGL LRQDWHGHÄQRL JDUDQ LL GH VHFXULWDWH´ vQ FRQWH[WXO vQ FDUH 8QJDULD úL %XOJDULD QX UHQXQ DVHU ODUHYL]LRQLVP $JUHVLXQHD LWDOLDQ vQ $ELVLQLD 6WDWHOH 0LFLL ÌQ HOHJHUL úL ÌQ HOHJHULL %DOFDQLFH DX FRQGDPQDW úL DJUHVLXQHD LWDOLDQ vQ $ELVLQLD GHFODQúDW OD RFWRPEULH úL VDX SURQXQ DW SHQWUX UHVSHFWDUHD LQWHJUDO D3DFWXOXL6RFLHW LL1D LXQLORU&XWRDWHF vQUHJLVWUDSLHUGHUL HFRQRPLFH OD RFWRPEULH JXYHUQXO URPkQ D GHFLV V SXQ vQ YLJRDUHVDQF LXQLOHGLFWDWHGH6RFLHWDWHD1D LXQLORUvPSRWULYD,WDOLHLOD RFWRPEULH 8OWHULRUvQIHEUXDULH DVHPHQHDvQWUHJLL(XURSH VWDWHOH$QWDQWHL%DOFDQLFHúLDXUHYL]XLWSR]L LDFRQVLGHUkQGF ÄSUREOHPD (WLRSLHLDGHYHQLWLQH[LVWHQW ´úLSHQWUXHOH
6XJHVWLY vQDFHVWVHQVHVWHSR]L LDH[SULPDW GH1LFRODH7LWXOHVFX OD DSULOLH Ä&HHD FH HVWH LPRUDO HVWH FD XQHOH VWDWH V DFRUGH HJDOLWDWHDGHGUHSWXULvQVFKLPEXOXQXLVSRUGHVHFXULWDWHLDU0LFLLÌQ HOHJHUL V LVHFHDU HJDOLWDWHvQGUHSWXULvQVFKLPEXOXQHLGLPLQX ULGHVHFXULWDWH´ùL WRW HO vQWUHED UHWRULF Ä&LQH RIHU 0LFLL ÌQ HOHJHUL XQ SOXV GH VHFXULWDWH vQ FD]XOvQDUP ULL$XVWULHL8QJDULHLúL%XOJDULHL"´ 'H OD WULEXQD /LJLL 1D LXQLORU 1LFRODH 7LWXOHVFX D OXDW DWLWXGLQH IHUP vQOHJ WXU FXSR]L LDLQWROHUDELO D]LDULúWLORULWDOLHQLID GHvPS UDWXO (WLRSLHL úL D LQVLVWDW SHQWUX SXQHUHD vQ DSOLFDUH D VDQF LXQLORU HFRQRPLFH úL ILQDQFLDUH RFWRPEULH vQSRILGDSR]L LLORUDGRSWDWHGHUHSUH]HQWDQ LL )UDQ HLúL0DULL%ULWDQLL 3ULQ 'HFUHW JXYHUQDPHQWDO VD LQWHU]LV RULFH vPSUXPXW GLUHFW VDX LQGLUHFW F WUH JXYHUQXO LWDOLDQ RULFH VXEVFULHUL OD vPSUXPXWXUL HPLVH vQ ,WDOLD VDX DOWXQGHYD GLUHFW VDX LQGLUHFW GH F WUH JXYHUQXO GH OD 5RPD SUHFXP úL RULFH FUHGLWH EDQFDUH GHVWLQDWH ,WDOLHL &RQFRPLWHQW GHFUHWXO LQWHU]LFHD LPSRUWXOUHH[SRUWXOúLWUDQ]LWXOGHDUPHPXQL LLúLPDWHULDOGHU ]ERLGHVWLQDWH ,WDOLHL 3X LQ PDL WkU]LX DX IRVW LQWHU]LVH LPSRUWXO H[SRUWXO UHH[SRUWXO úL WUDQ]LWXO RULF URU P UIXUL DOWHOH GHFkW OLQJRXUL úL PRQHGH GH DXU úL DUJLQW SURYHQLWH GLQ ,WDOLD VDX GHVWLQDWH ,WDOLHL úL SRVHVLXQLORU VDOH /D LQVLVWHQ D SULPXOXLPLQLVWUX*KHRUJKH7 W UHVFXDYHDXV ILHI FXWHXQHOHH[FHS LLGHOD P VXULOHDGRSWDWH
2FXSDUHD]RQHLGHPLOLWDUL]DWHUKHQDQH0DUHvQJULMRUDUHDSURGXV OD%XFXUHúWLRFXSDUHDGHF WUHJHUPDQLDD]RQHLGHPLOLWDUL]DWHUKHQDQH PDUWLH vQ WRWDO GH]DFRUG FX SUHYHGHULOH WUDWDWHORU GH OD9HUVDLOOHV úL /RFDUQR ,PHGLDW UHJHOH &DURO DO ,,OHD D FRQYRFDW &RQVLOLXO6XSHULRUDO$S U ULL ULL PDUWLH vQFDGUXOF UXLDVD GHFLVXUJHQWDUHDP VXULORUFDUHYL]DXFRQVROLGDUHDFDSDFLW LLGHDS UDUH vQ FD] GH FRQIOLFW JHQHUDOL]DW $GRSWDUHD vQ XQDQLPLWDWH GH F WUH &RQVLOLXO SXWHULORU ORFDUQLHQH vQWUXQLW OD /RQGUD PDUWLH D SURLHFWXOXL GH UH]ROX LH SURSXV GH )UDQ D úL GH %HOJLD SULQ FDUH VH FRQVWDWDX GRDU IDSWHOH úL QX VH FRQGDPQD DJUHVLXQHD JHUPDQ D PDUFDW vQV XQ QRX SDV SH FDOHD SROLWLFLL FRQFLOLDWRULVWH ID GH DF LXQLOH FDUH YL]DX UHYL]XLUHD WUDWDWHORU LQWHUQD LRQDOH úL D GLPLQXDW úL PDL PXOW vQFUHGHUHDVWDWHORUPLFLúLPLMORFLLPDLDOHVvQFDSDFLWDWHDGHUHDF LHúLGH GHFL]LHDFRPXQLW LLLQWHUQD LRQDOH 6WDWXWXO'XQ ULL)DSWXOF 5RPkQLDHUD DU GXQ UHDQ úLULYHUDQ D 0 ULL 1HJUH D I FXW FD GLSORPD LD GH OD %XFXUHúWL V DFRUGH R LPSRUWDQ GHRVHELW SUREOHPHORU 'XQ ULL VHPQkQG LXOLH &RQYHQ LD UHIHULWRDUH OD VWDWXWXO 'XQ ULL FDUH SUHYHGHD F QDYLJD LD SH IOXYLXHVWHOLEHU úLGHVFKLV vQFRQGL LLGHHJDOLWDWHSHQWUXWRDWHVWDWHOHúL FRQILUPD &RPLVLHL (XURSHQH D 'XQ ULL &(' XQHOH GUHSWXUL úL LPXQLW LFDUHFRQWUDYHQHDXVXYHUDQLW LLURPkQHúWL 'XS FH JXYHUQXO JHUPDQ D I FXW FXQRVFXW LXQLH F GRUHúWH V GLVFXWH SUREOHPD UHJLPXOXL 'XQ ULL GLSORPD LL URPkQL DX VWDELOLW OLQLLOH GLUHFWRDUH DOH SROLWLFLL URPkQHúWL vQ DFHVW GRPHQLX PHQ LQHUHD $QJOLHL )UDQ HL úL ,WDOLHL vQ RUJDQLVPHOH LQWHUQD LRQDOH DOH 'XQ ULL SHQWUX UHDOL]DUHD XQXL HFKLOLEUX vQWUH *HUPDQLD úL VWDWHOH ULYHUDQH PHQ LQHUHD &(' FX DGPLWHUHD *HUPDQLHL PHQ LQHUHD
&KLDU GLQ SULPD ]L D DJUHVLXQLL JHUPDQH 1LFRODH 7LWXOHVFX PLQLVWUXO URPkQGH([WHUQHFRPXQLFDVHPLQLVWUXOXLIUDQFH]OD%XFXUHúWLG¶2PHUVVRQF DJUHVLXQHD WUHEXLD V ILH XUPDW GH P VXUL IHUPH úL HILFLHQWH GLQ SDUWHD FRPXQLW LL LQWHUQD LRQDOH 7RW HO OD PDUWLH vQ FDOLWDWH GH SUHúHGLQWH vQ IXQF LXQHDO0LFLLÌQ HOHJHULDHPLVXQ&RPXQLFDWSULQFDUHVWDWHOHFRPSRQHQWH DOH0LFLLÌQ HOHJHULúLÌQ HOHJHULL%DOFDQLFHI FHDXFXQRVFXWF ÄvQ HOHJV DSHUH SULQWRDWHPLMORDFHOHWUDWDWHOHLQFOXVLYSHFHOGHOD/RFDUQR´/DVFXUWWLPSvQV SDUWHQHULL GLQ ÌQ HOHJHUHD %DOFDQLF ,XJRVODYLD *UHFLD úL 7XUFLD VDX GHVROLGDUL]DWGHPRGXOIHUPvQFDUHIXVHVHFRQFHSXW&RPXQLFDWXO &RPSXV GLQ)UDQ D0DUHD%ULWDQLH,WDOLDúL5RPkQLD
&RPLVLHL,QWHUQD LRQDOHD'XQ ULLUHVSLQJHUHDSURSXQHULORUJHUPDQHGH UHJOHPHQWDUH D UHJLPXOXL 'XQ ULL SULQ DFRUGXUL ELODWHUDOH &HYD PDL WkU]LXODDXJXVW OD%OHG&RQVLOLXO3HUPDQHQWDO0LFLLÌQ HOHJHUL VDGHFODUDWGHDFRUGFXLQWUDUHD*HUPDQLHLvQWRDWHFRPLVLLOHGXQ UHQHúL D VXEOLQLDW vQF RGDW QHFHVLWDWHD PHQ LQHULL OLEHUW LL GH QDYLJD LH D HJDOLW LL GH WUDWDPHQW úL D UHVSHFWXOXL VXYHUDQLW LL VWDWHORU ULYHUDQH ÌQ ILQDO *HUPDQLD D IRVW DFFHSWDW vQ &(' vQ XUPD DFRUGXOXL VHPQDW GH UHSUH]HQWDQ LL5RPkQLHL0DULL%ULWDQLL)UDQ HL,WDOLHLúL*HUPDQLHL 5HJLPXO'XQ ULLPDULWLPHDIRVWVWDELOLWvQWUHúLDXJXVW GHF WUHUHSUH]HQWDQ LL)UDQ HL0DULL%ULWDQLLúL5RPkQLHLSULOHMFXFDUH VD VHPQDW XQ DUDQMDPHQW UHIHULWRU OD vQFHWDUHD H[HUFLW ULL SXWHULORU VSHFLDOHFHUHYHQHDX&('FXSULYLUHODQDYLJD LDSH'XQ UHDPDULWLP SUHURJDWLYHOH WUHFHDX vQ FRPSHWHQ D VWDWXOXL URPkQ vQFHWDUHD LQWHUQD LRQDOL] ULL SRUWXOXL 6XOLQD H[HUFLWDUHD SXWHULL MXGHF WRUHúWL GH F WUH VWDWXO URPkQ FDUH H[HFXWD úL OXFU ULOH WHKQLFH vQ DFHVW VFRS JXYHUQXO URPkQ WUHEXLD V vQILLQ H]H 'LUHF LXQHD 'XQ ULL 0DULWLPH vQWRFPLUHD UHJXODPHQWXOXL GH QDYLJD LH úL SROL LH GH F WUH &(' SH ED]D SURSXQHULORU URPkQHúWL úL DSOLFDUHD OXL GH F WUH VWDWXO URPkQ WUHFHUHD EXQXULORU &(' vQ SRVHVLD VWDWXOXL URPkQ FDUH SUHOXD úL GDWRULLOH DFHVWHLD HWF $VWIHO HUDX vPSOLQLWH FHD PDL PDUH SDUWH D GH]LGHUDWHORUURPkQHúWLSULYLQG'XQ UHDPDULWLP 3UREOHPD 6WUkPWRULORU 2 DWHQ LH GHRVHELW D GDW JXYHUQXO GH OD %XFXUHúWLúLSUREOHPHL6WUkPWRULORU0 ULL1HJUHVWDWXDW vQF GLQ SULQ &RQYHQ LD GH OD /DXVDQQH vQFKHLDW FX 7XUFLD LQkQG VHDPD GH VFKLPE ULOHLQWHUYHQLWHvQFOLPDWXOSROLWLFHXURSHDQFDXUPDUHDRFXS ULL ]RQHL GHPLOLWDUL]DWH UKHQDQH GH F WUH *HUPDQLD JXYHUQXO URPkQ D U VSXQVSR]LWLY DSULOLH FHUHULL7XUFLHL GLQDSULOLH GHD VHUHGLVFXWDUHJLPXO6WUkPWRULORUÄvQFRQGL LLGHVHFXULWDWHLQGLVSHQVDELOH
ÌQSHULRDGDLXQLHLXOLH PHPEULL&('DXGHFLVVXSULPDUHD DUW GLQ WUDWDWXO GH OD %HUOLQ FDUH SUHYHGHD IXQF LRQDUHD &(' vQWUR WRWDO LQGHSHQGHQ ID GH DXWRULW LOH ORFDOH VXSULPDUHD LQWHUQD LRQDOL] ULL SRUWXOXL 6XOLQD H[HFXWDUHDOXFU ULORUGHODJXULOH'XQ ULLúLDVHUYLFLXOXLVDQLWDUQXPDLGH F WUH 5RPkQLD WUHFHUHD EUD XOXL &KLOLD VXE MXULVGLF LD H[FOXVLY D 5RPkQLHL UHWURFHGDUHD F WUH 5RPkQLD D IDUXULORU GH OD 6XOLQD 6I *KHRUJKH HWF ,QVSHFWRUDWXOGHQDYLJD LHV GHYLQ H[FOXVLYURPkQHVF
SHQWUX LQYLRODELOLWDWHD WHULWRULDO D VWDWXOXL WXUF´ 2 SR]L LH DVHP Q WRDUH VD DGRSWDW úL vQ FDGUXO VHVLXQLL &RQVLOLXOXL 3HUPDQHQW DO ÌQ HOHJHULL%DOFDQLFHGHOD%HOJUDG PDL SUHFXPúLvQúHGLQ D &RQVLOLXOXL3HUPDQHQWDO0LFLLÌQ HOHJHULGHOD%XFXUHúWL PDL 3H DFHVWH FRRUGRQDWH GH DF LXQH OD GHVFKLGHUHD VHVLXQLL GH OD 0RQWUHDX[ GHOHJD LD URPkQ DO WXUL GH FHOH DOH FHORUODOWH VWDWH DOH ÌQ HOHJHULL %DOFDQLFH D VXV LQXW SURLHFWXO WXUF vQ SRILGD RELHF LLORU 0DULL%ULWDQLLFDUHVDSURQXQ DWSHQWUXHJDOLWDWHDGLQWUHVWDWHOHULYHUDQH úL FHOH QHULYHUDQH SUH]HQWkQG vQ DFHVW VHQV XQ DOW SURLHFW ÌQ ILQDO FD XUPDUHúLDSR]L LHLDGRSWDWHGHURPkQLFRQYHQ LDDGRSWDW OD0RQWUHDX[ OD LXOLH D FRQVROLGDW VHFXULWDWHD 7XUFLHL úL D VWDWHORU ULYHUDQH 0 ULL1HJUHFDUHDXF S WDWRVHULHGHDYDQWDMHID GHFHOHQHULYHUDQHúL DSHUPLVUHPLOLWDUL]DUHD6WUkPWRULORU&RQFRPLWHQWvQSRILGDvPSRWULYLULL GHOHJD LLORUIUDQFH] úLEULWDQLF DIRVWGL]ROYDW &RPLVLD,QWHUQD LRQDO D 6WUkPWRULORUDWULEX LLOHDFHVWHLDWUHFkQGvQFRPSHWHQ DJXYHUQXOXLWXUF 5 ]ERLXOFLYLOGLQ6SDQLDÌQF GHODGHFODQúDUHDU ]ERLXOXLFLYLOGLQ 6SDQLDvQWUHIUDQFKLúWLLUHEHOLúLJXYHUQXOVSDQLROUHSXEOLFDQ LXOLH JXYHUQXOURPkQDDGHUDWOD&RQYHQ LDLQL LDW GH)UDQ DúL0DUHD%ULWDQLH DVXSUD QHLQWHUYHQ LHL vQ U ]ERLXO FLYLO VSDQLRO PHQLW V vPSLHGLFH LPL[WLXQHDGLYHUVHORUVWDWHvQDIDFHULOHLQWHUQHGLQ6SDQLDúLV FRPSOLFH VLWXD LD LQWHUQD LRQDO $GH]LXQHD URPkQHDVF HUD GHWHUPLQDW vQ FRQFHS LD OXL 1LFRODH 7LWXOHVFX DXJXVW GH ÄXQ FD] SDUWLFXODU
ÌQPRGFRQFUHW7XUFLDGRUHDV LVHVXSULPHWRDWHUHVWULF LLOHGHRUGLQ PLOLWDU FH vL IXVHVHU LPSXVH SULQ WUDWDWXO GH SDFH GH OD /DXVDQQH FHHD FH LPSOLFD GUHSWXO GH D UHPLOLWDUL]D 6WUkPWRULOH 'DUGDQHOH úL %RVIRU úL GH D FHUH GHVILLQ DUHD&RPLVLHL,QWHUQD LRQDOHD6WUkPWRULORU 1LFRODH7LWXOHVFXFRQVLGHUD F Ä6WUkPWRULOHVXQWvQV úLLQLPD7XUFLHL´úLDSUHFLDF ÄHOHVXQWvQDFHODúLWLPS úL SO PkQLL 5RPkQLHL´ *XYHUQXO WXUF PDL VROLFLWD OLPLWDUHD WRQDMXOXL QRWLILFDUHDSUHDODELO DWUHFHULLSULQ6WUkPWRULúLOLPLWDUHDWLPSXOXLGHúHGHUHvQ 0DUHD 1HDJU ÌQ DFHODúL WLPS VH SURQXQ D SHQWUX PHQ LQHUHD SULQFLSLXOXL OLEHUW LLGHSOLQHDQDYLJD LHLFRPHUFLDOHSULQ6WUkPWRUL ÌQFD]XOvQFDUHDUILIRVWDGRSWDWSURLHFWXOvQDLQWDWGH7XUFLDSR]L LD VWUDWHJLF D DFHVWHLD DOLDWD 5RPkQLHL úL D FHORUODOWH VWDWH GLQ ÌQ HOHJHUHD %DOFDQLF VDILFRQVROLGDWHDSXWkQGFRQWULEXLPDLELQHODDS UDUHD]RQHLvQ FD]GHDJUHVLXQH &X WRDWH DFHVWHD *HUPDQLD ,WDOLD úL 8QLXQHD 6RYLHWLF DYHDX V VH LPSOLFHIRDUWHPXOWvQU ]ERLXOFLYLOúLV WUDQVIRUPHS PkQWXOVSDQLROvQWHDWUX GHFRQIUXQW ULDUPDWHvQFDUHúLDXVRQGDWSRWHQ LDOXOPLOLWDU
FDUHQXSRDWHFUHDXQSUHFHGHQWúLFDUHQXLPSOLF SHQWUXJXYHUQXOURPkQ REOLJD LXQHD GH D UHFXQRDúWH SULQFLSLXO F XQ JXYHUQ OHJDO QX SRDWH RE LQHODFHUHUHDOXLXQDMXWRUGHODDOWJXYHUQvPSRWULYDUHEHOLXQLL´ÌQ FRQWH[WXO HVFDODG ULL FRQIOLFWXOXL JXYHUQXO URPkQ D DGHUDW LPHGLDW OD SURSXQHULOH&RPLWHWXOXLGHQHLQWHUYHQ LHSULYLQGLQWHU]LFHUHDS WUXQGHULL YROXQWDULORU vQ 6SDQLD I U FD DFHDVW P VXU V vPSLHGLFH SUH]HQ D OD DF LXQLOHPLOLWDUHúLDGLYHUVHORUGHWDúDPHQWHGHYROXQWDULURPkQLIRUPDWH vQVSHFLDOGLQFRPXQLúWLúLOHJLRQDUL 3DFWXO LXJRVODYREXOJDU 6IkUúLWXO DQXOXL D FRQVHPQDW XQ SURFHV GH DSURSLHUH vQWUH VWDWHOH ÌQ HOHJHULL %DOFDQLFH úL %XOJDULD SURFHVDFFHSWDWúLGHJXYHUQXOGHOD6RILDFDUHúLDH[SULPDWDWLWXGLQHD SULQ GHFODUD LD SUHPLHUXOXL .LRVHLYDQRY Ä1RL U PkQHP OD IRUPXOD QRDVWU FXEORFXOEDOFDQLFGDUQXvQEORFXOEDOFDQLF´ÌQSRILGDSUHYH GHULORUSDFWXOXLvQFKHLDWvQIHEUXDULH FDUHSUHYHGHDFRQVXOWDUHDvQWUH DOLD LvQWRDWHSUREOHPHOHH[WHUQHúLRE LQHUHDDVHQWLPHQWXOXLSUHDODELOvQ DGRSWDUHDGHFL]LLORULPSRUWDQWHODLDQXDULH ,XJRVODYLDDvQFKHLDW FX%XOJDULDXQDFRUGSROLWLFHFRQRPLFúLPLOLWDUFRQVILQ LWSULQWUXQWUDWDW GHSULHWHQLHYHúQLF &KLDUGDF vQHVHQ DVDSDFWXOLXJRVODYREXOJDUQXDWLQJHDFXQLPLF FRQIRUP GHFODUD LHL I FXWH GH 0LODQ 6WRLDGLQRYLü REOLJD LLOH ,XJRVODYLHL ID GH DOLD LL EDOFDQLFL vQFKHLHUHD VD I U DVHQWLPHQWXO SUHDODELO DO DOLD LORU D vQF OFDW SULQFLSLXO VROLGDULW LL SXV OD ED]D IXQF LRQ ULLÌQ HOHJHULL%DOFDQLFHúLQXDHOLPLQDWvQGRLHOLOHGRYDG vQ
ÌQDFHVWVHQVvQSRILGDRSR]L LHLUHJHOXL&DURODO,,OHDúLDJXYHUQXOXL PLQLVWUXO URPkQ GH ([WHUQH VD DU WDW GLVSXV OD VIkUúLWXO OXQLL DXJXVW V OLYUH]H5HSXEOLFLLVSDQLROHGHWXQXULúLDYLRDQHSHFDUH([HFXWLYXOURPkQ OH FRPDQGDVH vQ )UDQ D R SDUWH GLQWUH DFHVWHD DX IRVW OLYUDWH UHSXEOLFDQLORU VSDQLROL ÌQWUH7XUFLDúL%XOJDULDH[LVWDXUDSRUWXULDPLFDOHvQVSLULWXOSDFWHORU GH QHDJUHVLXQH vQFKHLDWH vQWUH JXYHUQHOH FHORU GRX UL 0XO XPLW GH UDSRUWXULOHFX6RILDVHPDQLIHVWDúL%HOJUDGXO 5HOHYkQG VHPQLILFD LD SDFWXOXL LXJRVODYREXOJDU 6WRLDGLQRYLü D GHFODUDWXUP WRDUHOHODLDQXDULH ÄÌQORFXOUH HOHLGHVkUP JKLPSDW H[LVWHQWH D]L VH LQVWDOHD] DQJDMDPHQWXO LXJRVODYREXOJDU FDUH YD S VWUD DFHDVW IURQWLHU DPLFDO ´ 5RPkQLD úL *UHFLD GRUHDX FD XQ DVHPHQHD WUDWDW V ILH vQFKHLDW FRQFRPLWHQWFXWRDWHVWDWHOHÌQ HOHJHULL%DOFDQLFHúLQXPDLGXS FHSUREOHPDDU ILIRVWDQDOL]DW vQ&RQVLOLXO3HUPDQHQWDODOLDQ HL/DDFHDVWDVHDGDXJ IDSWXO
DFHVW VHQV ILLQG úL GHFODUD LLOH GHOHJD LLORU *UHFLHL úL 7XUFLHL F YRU SURFHGDODIRUWLILFDUHD]RQHL$GULDQRSROúLDIURQWLHUHLFRPXQH 3HQWUXDQXFUHDSUREOHPHIXQF LRQ ULLSDFWXOXLEDOFDQLF5RPkQLD ODDFFHSWDW LQkQGVHDPDGHSR]L LDIDYRUDELO DFHORUODO LDOLD LEDOFDQLFL GH FHD D JXYHUQHORU GH OD /RQGUD úL 0RVFRYD SUHFXP úL GH FHD D &HKRVORYDFLHL FDUH GRUHD DWUDJHUHD %XOJDULHL vQ ÌQ HOHJHUHD %DOFDQLF SHQWUXDRVXVWUDJHLQIOXHQ HLJHUPDQH *HUPDQLDúL,WDOLDDXPDQLIHVWDW VLPSDWLHúLVDWLVIDF LHGRFXPHQWXOUHVSHFWLYILLQGFRQVLGHUDWOD%HUOLQFD ÄSULPXOSDVVSUHRDXWRQRPLHD%DOFDQLORUIDYRUDELO SROLWLFLLJHUPDQH´ ÌQ )UDQ D S UHULOH DX IRVW vPS U LWH PXO L DQDOLúWL FRQVLGHUkQG SDFWXO FD QHJDWLYSHQWUXÌQ HOHJHUHD%DOFDQLF úLFKLDUSHQWUX0LFDÌQ HOHJHUH 3DFWXO LWDORLXJRVODY 3X LQ PDL WkU]LX OD PDUWLH ,XJRVODYLDúLDSXVGLQQRXDOLD LLEDOFDQLFLvQID DIDSWXOXLvPSOLQLWSULQ vQFKHLHUHD SDFWXOXL LWDORLXJRVODY WH[WXO DFHVWXLD QHILLQG vQPkQDW DQWHULRU VSUH VWXGLX FRQIRUP SUHYHGHULORU SDFWXOXL EDOFDQLF 'H DFHDVW GDW 0LODQ 6WRLDGLQRYLü D LQYRFDW QHFHVLWDWHD VSULMLQXOXL LWDOLDQ vQ FRQGL LLOHvQFDUHJXYHUQXOGHOD5RPDUHFXQRVFXVHLQWHJULWDWHDWHULWRULDO D,XJRVODYLHL úLIDSWXOF VHVI WXLVHFXUHSUH]HQWDQ LDLJXYHUQXOXLGHOD /RQGUD 'HúL QX IXVHVHU FRQVXOWDWH JXYHUQHOH GH OD $WHQD úL $QNDUD DX FRQVLGHUDWF SDFWXOFRQVROLGDSDFHDGLQVXGHVWXO(XURSHL5RPkQLDOD FULWLFDWFRQVLGHUkQGXORQRX DF LXQHXQLODWHUDO D,XJRVODYLHLvQV QXO DFRQGDPQDWSUHDPXOWDSUHFLLQGF HUDGHVWLQDWPHQ LQHULLVWDWXTXRXOXL &XWRDWHDFHVWHDQHvQFUHGHUHDvQWUHVWDWHOHDOLDWHGLQÌQ HOHJHUHD%DOFDQLF VDDFFHQWXDWFXDWkWPDLPXOWFXFkWQRXOSDFWQXI FHDQLFLRUHIHULUHOD 6RFLHWDWHD1D LXQLORUúLLQFOXGHDUHFXQRDúWHUHDDQH[ ULLGHMXUHúLGHIDFWR D DQH[ ULL (WLRSLHL GH F WUH ,WDOLD 1HOLQLúWL DX DS UXW úL vQ FDGUXO 0LFLL ÌQ HOHJHUL &XWRDWHF FHOHGRX SDFWHvQFKHLDWHXQLODWHUDOGHF WUH,XJRVODYLD OD vQFHSXWXO DQXOXL DX DIHFWDW VROLGDULWDWHD ÌQ HOHJHULL %DOFDQLFH vQ FRQGL LLOH vQ FDUHJXYHUQXO GH OD %HOJUDG vúL RULHQWD SROLWLFD GLQ FH vQ FH
F SUHYHGHULOHQRXOXLSDFWHUDXvQGH]DFRUGFXXQHOHGLQSUHYHGHULOH&RQYHQ LHL PLOLWDUHURPkQRLXJRVODYHGLQ 3DFWXO PDL FRQ LQHD WUHL FRQYHQ LL VHFUHWH SULYLQG PLQRULW LOH LXJRVODYHGLQ,WDOLDSUREOHPD$OEDQLHLúLFHDDFRQVSLUDWRULORUFRQWUDVWDWXOXL LXJRVODYGLQ,WDOLD
PDL PXOW VSUH %HUOLQ 0LODQ 6WRLDGLQRYLü QX D GLVRFLDW ,XJRVODYLD GH SDFWXOEDOFDQLFGHFDUHDYHDQHYRLH $QVFKOXVVXO 6LWXD LD LQWHUQD LRQDO D 5RPkQLHL VD DJUDYDW FRQVLGHUDELO vQ SULP YDUD DQXOXL FkQG *HUPDQLD D RFXSDW $XVWULD PDUWLH úLDGHFODQúDWDF LXQHDGHH[SDQVLXQHVSUHFHQWUXOúLHVWXO (XURSHL ) FkQGFXQRVFXW SR]L LD ULL*KHRUJKH7 W UHVFXDGHFODUDW OD PDUWLH PLQLVWUXOXL IUDQFH] OD %XFXUHúWL $GULHQ 7KLHUU\ F GHúL $QVFKOXVVXO QX UHSUH]HQWD SHQWUX 5RPkQLD DFHODúL SHULFRO FD úL UHVWDXUD LD +DEVEXUJLORU RFXSDUHD $XVWULHL SXQHD vQ SHULFRO ÄvQWUHJXO VWDWXTXR GLQ UHJLXQHD GXQ UHDQ ´ &D XUPDUH VH LPSXQHD FD PDULOH SXWHUL GHPRFUDWLFH V DGRSWH ÄR DWLWXGLQH HQHUJLF ´ ÌQ FD] FRQWUDU DYHUWL]D SULPXOPLQLVWUX URPkQ 5RPkQLD YD IL REOLJDW ÄV FDXWH vQWUR DSURSLHUHFX*HUPDQLDPLMORFXOGHDDWHQXDULJRULOHGHVWLQXOXLHL´$SRL vQWUXQ FRQWH[W vQ FDUH vQ PDMRULWDWHD FDSLWDOHORU HXURSHQH VH PDQLIHVWD SUHDPXOWFDOPúLOLQLúWH *KHRUJKH7 W UHVFXDvQFHUFDWV FRQYRDFHOD %XFXUHúWLSHUHSUH]HQWDQ LL0LFLLÌQ HOHJHUL$F LXQHDDHúXDW 5RPkQLD QHILLQG vQ VLWXD LD GH D SXWHD RUJDQL]D úL FRQGXFH UHSOLFD HXURSHDQ OD DF LXQHDGHIRU JHUPDQ
&RPXQLFDWXOILQDOHPLVGHJXYHUQXOLXJRVODYGXS YL]LWDOD%HOJUDGD PLQLVWUXOXLJHUPDQGH([WHUQH.RQVWDQWLQ1HXUDWKvQLXQLH FRQVHPQDF DPEHOH S U L DX FRQVWDWDW ÄR LGHQWLWDWH GH YHGHUL DVXSUD VLWXD LHL SROLWLFH DMXQJkQGXVHODFRQYLQJHUHDUHFLSURF F SROLWLFDDPEHORUJXYHUQHWLQGHVSUH DFHODúLRELHFWLY´3URILWkQGúLGHIDSWXOF OD%HOJUDGFXDFHODúLSULOHMDXIRVW DUHVWD L FHL FDUH VWULJDVHU Ä7U LDVF )UDQ D´ JXYHUQXO GH OD 3DULV D LQYLWDW ,XJRVODYLDÄV úLUHYL]XLDVF LQWHUHVHOHI U vQWkU]LHUH´ ÌQ WLPSXO vQWkOQLULL FX 0HWD[DV GLQ LQVXOD &RUIX 6WRLDGLQRYLFL D GHFODUDWF HUDÄIHUPDWDúDWGHÌQ HOHJHUHD%DOFDQLF ´ /DPDUWLH $GULHQ7KLHUU\PLQLVWUXO)UDQ HLOD%XFXUHúWLD LQIRUPDW3DULVXOF HYHQLPHQWHOHGLQ$XVWULDÄDXFDX]DWvQ5RPkQLDRYHULWD ELO VWXSRDUHODFDUHVHDGDXJ XQSXWHUQLFVHQWLPHQWGHvQJULMRUDUH´ *XYHUQHOHGHOD3DULV/RQGUDúL5RPDDXDFFHSWDWUDSLGDFWXOGHIRU JHUPDQ 0DLPXOWODPDUWLH 0LODQ6WRLDGLQRYLüDGHFODUDWF ÄvQQLFL XQFD]DUPDWDLXJRVODY QXDUSXWHDDS UDKRWDUHOH&HKRVORYDFLHLDPHQLQ DWH HYHQWXDOGH*HUPDQLD´ 5HIHULQGXVH OD DFHVW OXFUX DWDúDWXO PLOLWDU IUDQFH] OD %XFXUHúWL FRORQHOXO'HOPDVFRQFKLGHDUHWRULF Ä6HSRDWHRDUHDúWHSWDGHOD5RPkQLDFD QHDPHQLQ DW GLUHFW V LD VLQJXU vQ (XURSD FHQWUDO R SR]L LH RVWLO ID GH *HUPDQLDvQDIDUDXQHLFRDOL LLSXWHUQLFH"´
3H IRQGXO LQGLIHUHQ HL GLSORPD LHL RFFLGHQWDOH JXYHUQXO JHUPDQ D VSHFXODW FX PXOW DELOLWDWH DVSLUD LLOH UHYDQúDUGH DOH 8QJDULHL úL SUHWHQ LLOHWHULWRULDOHSHFDUHOHPDQLIHVWDID GH&HKRVORYDFLDJXYHUQXO GHOD9DUúRYLD)D GH5RPkQLDJXYHUQXOGHOD%HUOLQDDGRSWDWWDFWLFD SURPLVLXQLORUúLRIHUWHORUÄSULHWHQHúWL´LQFOXVLYGHJDUDQWDUHDJUDQL HORU vQVR LWH GH DPHQLQ UL vQFHUFkQG V VSHFXOH]H GLILFXOW LOH DS UXWH vQ UHOD LLOHHFRQRPLFHURPkQRIUDQFH]HúLURPkQRHQJOH]H $JUHVLXQHD JHUPDQ vPSRWULYD $XVWULHL D IRVW FRQGDPQDW GH PDMRULWDWHDSDUWLGHORUSROLWLFHGLQ DU GHvQWUHJXOSRSRUURPkQFDUHúLD PDQLIHVWDWDWDúDPHQWXOID GHSRSRUXODXVWULDFJUHXvQFHUFDW 5HvQDUPDUHD %XOJDULHL 3UREOHPD UHvQDUP ULL %XOJDULHL D IRVW GLVFXWDW FX SULOHMXO &RQVI WXLULL &RQVLOLXOXL 3HUPDQHQW DO ÌQ HOHJHULL %DOFDQLFHGHOD$QNDUD IHEUXDULH FkQG,RDQQLV0HWD[DV V DDU WDWGLVSXVV IDF úLXQHOHFRQFHVLL 3X LQPDLWkU]LXvQYDUDDQXOXL OD LQL LDWLYD 7XUFLHL FX JULM SHQWUX D QX VXS UD *HUPDQLD úL ,WDOLD FDUHDSURSXVV VHSHUPLW UHvQDUPDUHD%XOJDULHLvQVFKLPEXOXQHL GHFODUD LLGHDPLFL LHID GHVWDWHOHÌQ HOHJHULL%DOFDQLFHFHLSDWUXDOLD L DXOXDWvQGLVFX LHSUREOHPDXQHLvQ HOHJHULFRQFUHWHFX%XOJDULD5HOD LL
/D VFXUW WLPS GXS $QVFKOXVV JXYHUQXO XQJDU úLD H[SULPDW DWDúDPHQWXO ID GH 5HLFK úL D WUDQVPLV OXL +LWOHU ÄFHOH PDL F OGXURDVH IHOLFLW UL´ 5HOHYkQG YLLWRDUHOH FRQVHFLQ H DOH $QVFKOXVVXOXL 1LFRODH ,RUJD FRQFKLGHDvQÄ7LPSXO´GLQPDL Ä$XVWULDHVWHXQSXQFWGHSOHFDUH´úL DWHQ LRQD Ä)HUHúWHWHSRSRUDOPHXF FLPDULSULPHMGLL LVHSUHJ WHVF´ 0HWD[DVDSUHFLDF DF LXQHDHUDPHQLW V ÄvPSLHGLFH%XOJDULDGHDVH OHJDGHRPDUHSXWHUHFXPDUIL*HUPDQLDúLGHDGHYHQLLQVWUXPHQWXOHL´ &X DFHO SULOHM VD GHFLV V QX ILH UHFXQRVFXW JXYHUQXO OXL )UDQFR ILHFDUH VWDW SXWkQG VWDELOL vQV UHOD LL RILFLDOH 5XVWX $UDVDI FXWFXQRVFXWF 7XUFLDúL*UHFLDQHILLQGQXPDLVWDWHEDOFDQLFHGRUHDXV úLH[WLQG FRODERUDUHD úLGLQFRORGHVIHUDEDOFDQLF 5RPkQLDúL,XJRVODYLDDXIRVWGHDFRUG 3 UHUL GLIHULWH DX IRVW ID GH UHFXQRDúWHUHD ,PSHULXOXL LWDOLDQ GLQ (WLRSLD 5RPkQLD QHDQJDMkQGXVHODRUHFXQRDúWHUHGHMXUHDDFHVWXLD5RPkQLDDSURSXVDOLD LORU V LD R DWLWXGLQH FRPXQ SHQWUX LQWHU]LFHUHD 6RFLHW LL 1D LXQLORU GH D VH DPHVWHFD vQ WUHEXULOH LQWHUQH DOH VWDWHORU PHPEUH VH UHIHUHD OD SUREOHPD PLQRULW LORU ÌQDFHOPRPHQW*HUPDQLDGLVSXQHDGHGLQLQWHUHVHOHLQGXVWULDOH VWU LQHGLQ7XUFLDGH LQkQGSULPXOORFvQFRPHU XOH[WHULRUúLDYkQGFLUFD GHVSHFLDOLúWLXWLOL]D LGHVWDWXOWXUF
DPLFDOHFX%XOJDULDGRUHDúL5RPkQLDGDUSULQvQFKHLHUHDXQXLSDFWGH QHDJUHVLXQH FX WRDWH VWDWHOH FDUH FRQVWLWXLDX ÌQ HOHJHUHD %DOFDQLF FRQIRUPSULQFLSLLORUVWDWXDWHvQSDFWXO6RFLHW LL1D LXQLORU ÌQILQDOGXS QXPHURDVHGLVFX LLDFRUGXODIRVWVHPQDWOD6DORQLF OD LXOLH ÌQ DIDUD DEROLULL FODX]HORU PLOLWDUH DOH WUDWDWXOXL GH OD 1HXLOO\úLDFODX]HORUUHIHULWRDUHODGHPLOLWDUL]DUHDIURQWLHUHLWXUFREXOJDUH GLQ &RQYHQ LD GH OD /DXVDQQH GLQ GRFXPHQWXO PDL PHQ LRQD DWDúDPHQWXO %XOJDULHL ID GH SROLWLFD GH vQW ULUH D S FLL vQ %DOFDQL GRULQ D DFHVWHLD GH D vQWUH LQH FX VWDWHOH YHFLQH UDSRUWXUL GH EXQ YHFLQ WDWH úL DQJDMDPHQWXO WXWXURU VWDWHORU VHPQDWDUH GH D VH DE LQH vQ UHOD LLOH ORU PXWXDOH GH OD RULFH UHFXUJHUH OD IRU vQ FRQIRUPLWDWH FX DFRUGXULOHGHQHDJUHVLXQHSHFDUHILHFDUHOHDVHPQDW 5HvQDUPDUHD8QJDULHL&RQFRPLWHQWFXLQL LHUHDGLVFX LLORUSULYLQG DFFHSWDUHD UHvQDUP ULL %XOJDULHL &RQVLOLXO 3HUPDQHQW DO ÌQ HOHJHULL %DOFDQLFHvQWUXQLWOD$QNDUD IHEUXDULH DGHFLVFDJXYHUQXO URPkQ vQ QXPHOH FHORU WUHL JXYHUQH DOH VWDWHORU 0LFLL ÌQ HOHJHUL V SURSXQ JXYHUQXOXL GH OD %XGDSHVWD V DFFHSWH UHOXDUHD QHJRFLHULORU vQ YHGHUHD vPEXQ W LULL UHOD LLORU FX 8QJDULD ÌQ DFHVW VHQV OD PDUWLH ([HFXWLYXO GH OD %XFXUHúWL D vQDLQWDW XQ VHW GH SURSXQHUL FDUH FXSULQGHDXSURLHFWXOXQHLGHFODUD LLGHQHUHFXUJHUHODIRU úLUHFXQRDúWHUH D HJDOLW LL vQ GRPHQLXO vQDUP ULORU SHQWUX 8QJDULD úL SURLHFWXO XQHL GHFODUD LL LGHQWLFH XQLODWHUDOH D ILHF UXLD GLQ FHOH SDWUX JXYHUQH FDUH VH DQJDMDX V LD WRDWH P VXULOH DGPLQLVWUDWLYH GH QDWXU V vQO WXUH ÄRULFH SLHGLF vQFDOHDGH]YROW ULLUHOD LLORUDPLFDOH´GLQWUHHOH ,QWXLQG VLWXD LD GLILFLO vQ FDUH DYHD V ILH SXV &HKRVORYDFLD %XGDSHVWDDIRVWGHDFRUGGRDUFXUHDOL]DUHDXQRUvQ HOHJHULFXJXYHUQHOH GH OD %XFXUHúWL úL %HOJUDG IDSW QHDFFHSWDW GH F WUH GLSORPD LD URPkQ FDUH QX GRUHD V WU GH]H DOLDWXO FHKRVORYDF &X WRDWH DFHVWHD UHSUH]HQWDQ LL0LFLLÌQ HOHJHULvQWUXQL LOD6LQDLDODúLPDL úLDX H[SULPDWGRULQ DGHDVHFRQWLQXDQHJRFLHULOHvQFXUVvQVFRSXOLQVWLWXLULL ÄXQXL UHJLP GH vQ HOHJHUH úL vQFUHGHUH vQ ED]LQXO 'XQ ULL´ ÌQ DFHODúL VSLULW UHJHOH &DURO DO ,,OHD VH DU WD GLVSXV V DFRUGH QRL IDFLOLW L PLQRULW LLPDJKLDUHGLQ7UDQVLOYDQLD
$FRUGXODIRVW5DWLILFDWGH%XOJDULDODQRLHPEULHGH*UHFLDOD QRLHPEULHúLGH5RPkQLDODQRLHPEULH
ÌQ ILQDO OD %OHGODDXJXVW &RQVLOLXO3HUPDQHQWDO0LFLL ÌQ HOHJHUL D GLVFXWDW SURLHFWXO GH SURWRFRO DGL LRQDO OD FDUH vúL G GXVHU GHMDDFRUGXO5RPkQLD,XJRVODYLDúL8QJDULD SUHFXPúLGHFODUD LDDVXSUD PLQRULW LORU SURSXV GH PLQLVWUXO FHKRVORYDF GH ([WHUQH úL D GHFLV UHFXQRDúWHUHD GH F WUH FHOH WUHL VWDWH FDUH FRQVWLWXLDX 0LFD ÌQ HOHJHUH D HJDOLW LL GH GUHSWXUL SHQWUX 8QJDULD vQ SULYLQ D vQDUP ULL UHQXQ DUHD UHFLSURF ODRULFHUHFXUJHUHODIRU &UL]D6RFLHW LL1D LXQLORUÌQ 6RFLHWDWHD1D LXQLORUFDUH VHGRYHGLVHQHSXWLQFLRV úLLQFDSDELO V IDF ID JUDYHORUSUREOHPH FX FDUH VH FRQIUXQWD RPHQLUHD VH DIOD OD VIkUúLWXO DFWLYLW LL VDOH FRPSURPL kQGXVH úL PDL PXOW SULQ YRWDUHD GH F WUH $GXQDUHD *HQHUDO vQ VHSWHPEULH D SURSXQHULL HQJOH]H SULYLQG VXVSHQ GDUHD SUHYHGHULORU 3DFWXOXL /LJLL SULYLQG UHVSLQJHUHD vQ FRPXQ D DJUHVLXQLL ([WUHP GH JUDY DFHDVW GHFL]LH D PDUFDW HúHFXO WRWDO DO SROLWLFLLGHVHFXULWDWHFROHFWLY O VkQG ULOHPHPEUHV VHDSHUHSULQ IRU HSURSULL/XkQGSR]L LH&RQVLOLXO3HUPDQHQWDOÌQ HOHJHULL%DOFDQLFH vQWUXQLW OD *HQHYD D FRQVLGHUDW OD VHSWHPEULH FD ILLQG QHRSRUWXQ PRGLILFDUHD3DFWXOXL6RFLHW LL1D LXQLORU 'H]PHPEUDUHD &HKRVORYDFLHL ÌQDLQWH FKLDU GH LQWHQVLILFDUHD SUHVLXQLORUJHUPDQHúLXQJDUHúLSRORQH]HDVXSUD&HKRVORYDFLHLJXYHUQXO URPkQ VD SURQXQ DW FX IHUPLWDWH SHQWUX UHVSHFWDUHD LQGHSHQGHQ HL úL LQWHJULW LLDFHVWHLDÌQDFHVWVFRSGLSORPD LLURPkQLDXI FXWQXPHURDVH LQWHUYHQ LL GLSORPDWLFH vQ PDULOH FDSLWDOH DOH (XURSHL UHOHYkQG F 5RPkQLD HUD GLVSXV V DFFHSWH úL VXUYROXO WHULWRULXOXL QD LRQDO GHF WUH DYLRDQHOH VRYLHWLFH vQ VLWXD LD vQ FDUH 8QLXQHD 6RYLHWLF VDU IL DU WDW GLVSXV V LQWHUYLQ vQVSULMLQXO&HKRVORYDFLHL 3UHWHQ LLOH WHULWRULDOH XQJDUH OD DGUHVD 5RPkQLHL DX GHWHUPLQDW JXYHUQXO URPkQ V ILH vQV SUXGHQW vQ UHOD LLOH FX DXWRULW LOH GH OD %HUOLQúLV DGRSWHODVXJHVWLDDFHVWRUDRDWLWXGLQHFkWPDLQHXWU ID
ÌQ SRILGD SURWHVWHORU JHUPDQH JXYHUQXO GH OD %XFXUHúWL D DXWRUL]DW VXUYRODUHDVSD LXOXLDHULDQDO5RPkQLHLGHF WUHDYLRDQHOHVRYLHWLFHFXPS UDWH GHF WUHJXYHUQXOGHOD3UDJDúLDI FXWGHPHUVXULSHOkQJ JXYHUQXOLXJRVODY SHQWUXvQGHSOLQLUHDREOLJD LLORUDVXPDWHSULQSDFWXO0LFLLÌQ HOHJHULvQVLWXD LD vQFDUH8QJDULDDUILDWDFDW&HKRVOYRDFLD 3HUFHSkQG VLWXD LD GLILFLO D 5RPkQLHL úL ,XJRVODYLHL +HUPDQQ *|ULQJ D GHFODUDW PLQLVWUXOXL LXJRVODY OD %HUOLQ F *HUPDQLD HUD JDWD V JDUDQWH]H LQWHJULWDWHD WHULWRULDO D FHORU GRX UL GDF DFHVWHD DU IL DGRSWDW R SROLWLF GHQHXWUDOLWDWHúLDVI WXLWFDÄRFKLLFHORUGRX ULV QXPDLDOXQHFH FkQGVSUH0RVFRYDFkQGVSUH3DULV´
GHHYHQLPHQWHOHLQWHUQD LRQDOH$úDVDSURFHGDWFHOSX LQRILFLDOGXS GLFWDWXOJHUPDQRLWDORIUDQFRHQJOH]GHOD0QFKHQ VSUHVHSWHP EULH SULQFDUH*HUPDQLDDvQFRUSRUDW]RQDVXGHW FHKRVORYDF 2SR]L LDDVHP Q WRDUHDXDGRSWDWúLDOLD LLGLQÌQ HOHJHUHD%DOFDQLF WR L ILLQG FRQYLQúL F VLQJXUD SRVLELOLWDWH GH DúL VDOYD LQWHJULWDWHD WHULWRULDO FRQVWDvQQHLPSOLFDUHGLUHFW vQVROLGDULWDWHúLXQLUH &XWRDWHDFHVWHDJXYHUQXOúLGLSORPD LDURPkQ DXI FXWWRWXODúD FXP SUHFL]D 1LFRODH 3HWUHVFX&RPQHQ PLQLVWUX GH ([WHUQH FD Ä&HKRVORYDFLD V VXSUDYLH XLDVF V GHYLQ YLDELO úL V U PkQ DOLDWD QRDVWU ´ &RQFRPLWHQW GLSORPD LL URPkQL OD /RQGUD 3DULV 5RPD úL %HUOLQ DX DF LRQDW SHQWUX D GHWHUPLQD JXYHUQHOH ULORU UHVSHFWLYH V úL DVXPH ÄJDUDQ LD QRXOXL VWDWXW WHULWRULDO DO &HKRVORYDFLHL´ 'HúL HUD FRQúWLHQW GH ULVFXULOH SH FDUH úL OH DVXPD JXYHUQXO URPkQ D VSULMLQLW vQ SHUPDQHQ DOLDWXO FHKRVORYDF DU WkQGXVH GLVSXV V DFFHSWH WDFLW WUDQ]LWXO VSD LXOXL DHULDQ GH F WUH DYLD LD VRYLHWLF úL FKLDU DO WUXSHORU WHUHVWUH vQ VLWXD LD vQ FDUH 8QLXQHD 6RYLHWLF DU IL GRULW V LQWHUYLQ vQ VSULMLQXO&HKRVORYDFLHL /DPDUWLH GXS FHFXR]LvQDLQWH6ORYDFLDvúLSURFODPDVH LQGHSHQGHQ D *HUPDQLD D RFXSDW FH PDL U P VHVH GLQ &HKRVORYDFLD FRQVWLWXLQG3URWHFWRUDWXO%RKHPLHLúL0RUDYLHL&RQFRPLWHQW8QJDULDD RFXSDWWRDW 8FUDLQD6XEFDUSDWLF UHDOL]kQGJUDQL FRPXQ FX3RORQLD úLDSRLFKLDUWHULWRULLGLQVXGXO6ORYDFLHLÄLQGHSHQGHQWH´ $WLWXGLQHD FRUHFW D 5RPkQLHL D IRVW UHFXQRVFXW GH RILFLDOLL FHKRVORYDFLLQFOXVLYOD&RQIHULQ DGHSDFHGHOD3DULVGLQ 8FUDLQD 6XEFDUSDWLF ÌQ SULP YDUD DQXOXL vQWUR VLWXD LH H[WUHP GH GLILFLO VH DIOD úL 8FUDLQD 6XEFDUSDWLF WHULWRULX FHKRVORYDF SURFODPDW OD PDUWLH VWDW LQGHSHQGHQW FD úL 6ORYDFLD ÌQ ID D LQWHQVLILF ULLSUHVLXQLORUXQJDUHPRQVHQLRUXOGU$XJXVWLQ9RORúLQDFHUXW
$QDOL]kQG FRQVHFLQ HOH 0QFKHQXOXL 0DXULFH &UHX]HX DILUPD Ä(FKLOLEUXO HXURSHDQ IXVHVH ]GUXQFLQDW vQ IDYRDUHD *HUPDQLHL 6HFXULWDWHD FROHFWLY HVWHXFLV ´/DUkQGXL:LQVWRQ&KXUFKLOOGHFODUDF Ä$QJOLDDVXIHULW RvQIUkQJHUHI U U ]ERL´LDU3DXO%RQFRXUSUHFL]DOXL993HOODF Ä6LQJXUD IRUPXO U PkQHD6RFLHWDWHD1D LXQLORU´ 5HOHYkQGDFHDVW SR]L LHPLQLVWUXOFHKRVORYDFDO$IDFHULORU6WU LQH )UDQWãHN &KYDONRYVN\ úLD H[SULPDW JUDWLWXGLQHD JXYHUQXOXL V X SHQWUX SR]L LDDGRSWDW GHJXYHUQXOúLGHVSULMLQXOSRSRUXOXLURPkQFDUHDSULPLWFX SULHWHQLHúLRVSLWDOLWDWHSHUHIXJLD LLFHKLúLVORYDFL
SURWHF LD *HUPDQLHL FDUH QX D U VSXQV IDYRUDELO &D XUPDUH 9RORúLQ D SURSXV LQFOXGHUHD 8FUDLQHL 6XEFDUSDWLFH vQ FRPSRQHQ D 5RPkQLHL IDSW UHVSLQV GH JXYHUQXO URPkQ úL D UXJDW JXYHUQXO IUDQFH] V LQWHUYLQ OD %XGDSHVWDSHQWUXDRSULLQYD]LDWUXSHORUXQJDUHúLDVHUHJOHPHQWDVLWXD LD ULLSHFDOHGLSORPDWLF &RQFRPLWHQW FX FRQGDPQDUHD DJUHVLXQLORU JHUPDQH úL XQJDUH GH F WUHJXYHUQXOURPkQ&RQVLOLXOGH&RURDQ DGHFLVODPDUWLH vQ XQDQLPLWDWH OXDUHD XQRU P VXUL PLOLWDUH PDL DPSOH FDUH V GXF OD ÄDS UDUHDLQWHUHVHORUQD LRQDOH´ ÌQFHUF ULGHDUHYLWDOL]DÌQ HOHJHUHD%DOFDQLF 3HP VXUDVO ELULL 0LFLL ÌQ HOHJHUL úL PDL DOHV GXS GHVILLQ DUHD DFHVWHLD vQ XUPD GH]PHPEU ULL &HKRVORYDFLHL 5RPkQLD D I FXW QXPHURDVH vQFHUF UL SHQWUXDFRQVROLGDÌQ HOHJHUHD%DOFDQLF úLGHDFUHDFRQGL LLOHSHQWUXFD DFHDVWD V SRDW DF LRQD FD R JUXSDUH LQGHSHQGHQW vQ VWDUH V SRDW LQWHUYHQLvQRULFHPRPHQWDO WXULGH0DUHD%ULWDQLHúL)UDQ D,QFOXVLYvQ WLPSXO &RQIHULQ HL GH OD %XFXUHúWL IHEUXDULH FkQG VSUH VXUSULQGHUHDPXOWRUDFHOHSDWUXVWDWHDOLDWHDXGHFLVSUHOXQJLUHDSHúDSWH DQLDSDFWXOXLEDOFDQLFúLFRQWLQXDUHDSROLWLFLLGHFRODERUDUHDFX%XOJDULD vQ SRILGD SROLWLFLL UHYDQúDUGH D PXOWRU FHUFXUL UHYL]LRQLVWH LQFOXVLY D SUHVHL $FHODúL VFRS DO vQW ULULL DOLDQ HL EDOFDQLFH OD DYXW vQFHUFDUHD OXL *ULJRUH *DIHQFX GH D DWUDJH 3RORQLD OD SROLWLFD ÌQ HOHJHULL %DOFDQLFH vQ WLPSXO YL]LWHL I FXWH vQ PDUWLH OD 9DUúRYLD 3ROLWLFD SURPRYDW GH -RVHSK%HFNDI FXWFDDFHVWGH]LGHUDWV HúXH]H6LWXD LDVDDJUDYDWGLQ YDUD DQXOXL RGDW FX DFFHQWXDUHD GH]LQWHUHVXOXL GLQ FH vQ FH PDL SURQXQ DWDO8QLXQLL6RYLHWLFHID GHVLWXD LDGLQ%DOFDQLFKLDUGDF OD VHSWHPEULH vQ PRPHQWXO vQ FDUH D DWDFDW 3RORQLD 0RVFRYD D I FXWFXQRVFXWF vúLPHQ LQHQHXWUDOLWDWHDvQUHOD LLOHFXVWDWHOHEDOFDQLFH
6HVL]kQG HVHQ D HYHQLPHQWHORU úL SHULFROHOH FH SODQDX DVXSUD 5RPkQLHL $UPDQG & OLQHVFX SULPXOPLQLVWUX URPkQ FRQVHPQD Ä$P DVLVWDW OD vQF R HWDS D PLúF ULL GH vQDLQWDUH JHUPDQ 0LMORFXO ± SURYRFDUHD GH]LQWHJU ULLLQWHUQHSHFDUHDvQFHSXWRVSUHDL]ROD%RKHPLDúLDRvQJKL L2 QRX HWDS SRDWHILVXEMXJDUHD5RPkQLHL0LMORDFHOH±SURYRFDUHDXQXLFRQIOLFW PLOLWDUFX8QJDULDúLFXPLQRULW LOHJHUPDQH'DF O V P*HUPDQLHLLQL LDWLYD GH PDQHYU YRP F GHD VLJXU 5HDF LXQHD QRDVWU PLOLWDU QX HVWH SRVLELO 6SULMLQPLOLWDUGLQDSXVH[FOXV&RQIODJUD LHJHQHUDO vQGRLHOQLF ´
,QWHQVLILFDUHD SUHVLXQLORU JHUPDQH 2SR]L LD 5RPkQLHL ID GH H[WLQGHUHD SURFHVXOXL GH GH]PHPEUDUH D &HKRVORYDFLHL úL H[WHUPLQDUHD GLQ RUGLQXO UHJHOXL &DURO DO ,,OHD D JUXSXOXL &RUQHOLX &RGUHDQX D GHWHUPLQDWDXWRULW LOHGHOD%HUOLQV IDF SUHVLXQLGLQFHvQFHPDLPDUL DVXSUD JXYHUQXOXL URPkQ FDUH vQ ID D OLSVHL GH UHDF LH D 3DULVXOXL úL /RQGUHLúLDFRQYLQJHULLF FHOSX LQSHQWUXRSHULRDG GHWLPS5RPkQLD QX SXWHD FRQWD SH VSULMLQXO )UDQ HL úL 0DULL %ULWDQLL D vQFHSXW V IDF XQHOH FRQFHVLL HFRQRPLFH 5HLFKXOXL úL V úL PDQLIHVWH LQWHQ LD GH D vPEXQ W L UHOD LLOH FX %HUOLQXO VSHUkQG FD DFHVWD V QX vQFXUDMH]H 8QJDULDúL%XOJDULDvQvPSOLQLUHDGH]LGHUDWHORUORUUHYL]LRQLVWH/DUkQGX L JXYHUQXO GH OD %HUOLQ D vQFHUFDW V RE LQ QRL SR]L LL vQ UHOD LLOH HFRQRPLFHFX5RPkQLDúLV LVFKLPEHGLUHF LLOHGHSROLWLF H[WHUQ &XWRDWHDFHVWHD5RPkQLDDFRQWLQXDWV úLvPEXQ W HDVF UHOD LLOH FX )UDQ D úL 0DUHD %ULWDQLH SUHFXP úL FX DOLD LL EDOFDQLFL D vQFHUFDW V GHS úHDVF FUL]D GLQ UHOD LLOH FX *HUPDQLD GHFODUkQGXúL
6HPQLILFDWLY vQDFHVWVFRSHVWHQXPLUHDODGHFHPEULH DOXL *ULJRUH*DIHQFXvQIUXQWHD0LQLVWHUXOXL$IDFHULORU6WU LQHULGLFDUHD/HJD LHL URPkQH GH OD 3DULV OD UDQJ GH DPEDVDG GHFHPEULH úL QXPLUHD FD DPEDVDGRU H[WUDRUGLQDU úL SOHQLSRWHQ LDU D OXL *KHRUJKH 7 W UHVFX &X SX LQ WLPSvQDLQWHODQRLHPEULH JXYHUQXOGHOD3DULVGHFLVHVHúLHOV ULGLFH /HJD LDGHOD%XFXUHúWLWRWODQLYHOGHDPEDVDG úLDI FXWFXQRVFXWF 5RPkQLD FRQVWLWXLD ÄVLQJXUXO UHD]HP UHDO FH UH LQH GHVFLQGHUHD *HUPDQLHL VSUH JXULOH 'XQ ULLúLVSUH%RVIRU´ &X WRDWH F OD VIkUúLWXO DQXOXL JXYHUQXO HQJOH] D PDQLIHVWDW R DWLWXGLQH IDYRUDELO ID GH 5RPkQLD DFHDVWD QX D IRVW H[SULPDW SXEOLF úL FRQFUHWL]DW ODQLYHOXOFHORUVWDELOLWHGHRDUHFH1HYLOOH&KDPEHUODLQQXGRUHDV VXSHUH*HUPDQLD6SHUkQGvQVSULMLQXOEULWDQLFFDúLFHOHODOWHVWDWHEDOFDQLFHGH DOWIHOJXYHUQXOURPkQDRE LQXWvQIHEUXDULH SURPLVLXQHDUHJHOXL*HRUJH DO9,OHDF FHUHULOH%XFXUHúWLORUYRUILVROX LRQDWHÄFXVXFFHV´0DLH[SOLFLWD IRVW SUHPLHUXO 1HYLOOH &KDPEHUODLQ FDUH D GHFODUDW QRXOXL PLQLVWUX URPkQ OD /RQGUD 99 7LOHD F 0DUHD %ULWDQLH QX VH YD RSXQH FD VWDWHOH GLQ HVWXO (XURSHLÄV IDF FRPHU FX*HUPDQLD´GDUQLFLQXYRUDGPLWHFDDFHVWHDÄV GHYLQ GRPLQDWHúLFRQWURODWH´GLQSXQFWGHYHGHUHHFRQRPLFGH*HUPDQLDÌQ DFHVW VSLULW vQ IHEUXDULH D IRVW RUJDQL]DW 6RFLHWDWHD %ULWLVK5XPDQLDQ &RUSRUDWLRQ /WG 3HQWUX SURPRYDUHD FRPHU XOXL URPkQRHQJOH] LDU *UXSXO URPkQ FRQGXV GH 0D[ $XVFKQLWW D RE LQXW FUHWH SH WHUPHQ GH DQL SHQWUX GH OLUH VWHUOLQH &RQFRPLWHQW /RQGUD D PDQLIHVWDW LQWHUHV SHQWUX FRQVROLGDUHDÌQ HOHJHULL%DOFDQLFHúLSHQWUXDWUDJHUHD%XOJDULHL /DLDQXDULH /HJD LLOHURPkQHGHOD%HOJUDG$QNDUDúL$WHQD DXIRVWULGLFDWHODUDQJGHDPEDVDG
LQWHQ LD GH D vQFKHLD FX DFHDVWD XQ DFRUG HFRQRPLF SH WHUPHQ OXQJ ÌQ DFHVW VFRS OD vQFHSXWXO OXQLL IHEUXDULH vQ 5RPkQLD D VRVLW R GHOHJD LH HFRQRPLF vQ IUXQWH FX +KHOPXWK :RKOWKDW URPkQLL WHUJLYHU VkQGQHJRFLHULOHSkQ GXS GH]PHPEUDUHD&HKRVORYDFLHLFkQGSUHVLXQLOH JHUPDQHDXDWLQVDSRJHXO ÌQ DFHVW FRQWH[W vQ FDUH QX SXWHD FRQWD SH XQ VSULMLQ FRQFUHW GLQ SDUWHDDOWRUSXWHULúLVSHUkQGV FkúWLJHWLPSSHQWUXDúLFRQVROLGDDS UD UHDJXYHUQXOURPkQDGHFLVV VHPQH]HODPDUWLH WUDWDWXOHFRQR PLF FX *HUPDQLD FDUH DGXFHD JUDYH SUHMXGLFLL HFRQRPLFH úL SROLWLFH 5RPkQLHL&XWRDWHDFHVWHD DUDDU PDVSHQWUXvQF XQDQGLQSXQFWGH YHGHUHSROLWLFvQRUELWDSXWHULORUGHPRFUDWLFHRFFLGHQWDOH *DUDQ LLOHDQJORIUDQFH]HÌQFRQGL LLOHvQFDUHSULQFLSDOXODOLDWDO 5RPkQLHL GLQ 0LFD ÌQ HOHJHUH &HKRVORYDFLD GLVS UXVH GH SH KDUWD (XURSHL5RPkQLDDYHDQHDS UDW QHYRLHGHVSULMLQGLSORPDWLFGLQSDUWH PDULORUSXWHULGHPRFUDWLFHDOHFRQWLQHQWXOXLSUHFXPúLVSULMLQHFRQRPLF úLILQDQFLDUvQYHGHUHDvQ]HVWU ULLDUPDWHLFXDUPDPHQWDF LXQHSHULFOLWDW GH IDSWXO F PDMRULWDWHD FRPHQ]LORU URPkQHúWL IXVHVHU FRQWUDFWDWH FX ILUPHFHKRVORYDFH ÌQ XUPD GHPHUVXOXL vQWUHSULQV GH 997LOHD PLQLVWUXO URPkQ OD /RQGUDJXYHUQHOHIUDQFH]úLHQJOH]úLDXH[SULPDWGLVSRQLELOLWDWHDvQ FHHD FH SULYHúWH DMXWRUXO FH XUPD V ILH DFRUGDW vQ WLPS FH 00
/D PDUWLH DFHVWD OD LQIRUPDW SH 6LU 2UPH 6DUJHQW VXEVHFUHDWDUGHVWDWOD)RUHLJQ2IILFHF JXYHUQXOJHUPDQVROLFLWDVHJXYHUQXOXL URPkQÄV úLGHDDFRUGXOODPRQRSROXODFHVWXLDDVXSUDH[SRUWXULORUURPkQHúWLúL V DFFHSWH XQHOH UHVWULF LL LQGXVWULDOH SH WHULWRULXO 5RPkQLHL vQ LQWHUHVXO JHUPDQLORU´ vQVFKLPE*HUPDQLDXUPDV JDUDQWH]HÄIURQWLHUHOH5RPkQLHL´ &X DFHODúL SULOHM D SUHFL]DW F ÄJXYHUQXO URPkQ HUD GLVSXV V YDG vQ DFHDVWD XQ XOWLPDWXP´úLDVROLFLWDWJXYHUQXOXLEULWDQLFV úLSUHFL]H]HSR]L LDvQFD]XOvQFDUH Ä5RPkQLDGHYLQHYLFWLP DDJUHVLXQLLJHUPDQLORU´3HQWUXDQXWHQVLRQDúLPDL PXOWGHMDvQFRUGDWHOHUHOD LLURPkQRJHUPDQHJXYHUQXOURPkQDQHJDWH[LVWHQ D XQXLXOWLPDWXPJHUPDQSURSULX]LVGDUQXúLFHUHULOHLQDFFHSWDELOHDOH%HUOLQXOXL úLDVROLFLWDWVSULMLQHQJOH]úLIUDQFH] /D PDUWLH ([HFXWLYXO GH OD /RQGUD D vQWUHEDW vQV RILFLDO JXYHUQXO GH OD $QNDUD GDF HUD GLVSXV V DMXWH 5RPkQLD ([HFXWLYXO GH OD ,VWDQEXO FD úL FHO GH OD $WHQD D U VSXQV F QX VH SXWHDX DQJDMD vQ DIDUD SUHYHGHULORU3DFWXOXL%DOFDQLF/DUkQGXLJXYHUQXOLXJRVODYDUHFRPDQGDWV VHS VWUH]HUHOD LLDPLFDOHFX*HUPDQLDFDUHQXWUHEXLDSURYRFDW vQQLFLXQIHO ÌQDFHVWFRQWH[W*HRJHV%RQQHWDU VSXQVOXL*KHRUJKH7 W UHVFXF Ä)UDQ D VLQJXU QX YD SXWHD DFRUGD XQ DVWIHOGHDMXWRUúLF WUHEXLHFODULILFDW SR]L LD DOWRUVWDWHLQWHUHVDWHSULQWUHFDUHúL8566´
/LWYLQRY D SURSXV FRQYRFDUHD LPHGLDW D XQHL FRQVI WXLUL vQWUH UHSUH]HQWDQ LL 8566 )UDQ HL 3RORQLHL úL 5RPkQLHL /RUGXO +DOLID[ D FRQVLGHUDW vQV SUHPDWXU FRQYRFDUHD FRQIHULQ HL úL D SURSXV OD UkQGXL DGRSWDUHD úL SXEOLFDUHD XQHL GHFODUD LL GH F WUH JXYHUQHOH 8566 )UDQ HL0DULL%ULWDQLLúL3RORQLHLGLQFDUHV UH]XOWHF SXWHULOHUHVSHFWLYH HUDXLQWHUHVDWHvQPHQ LQHUHDLQGHSHQGHQ HLVWDWHORUGLQHVWXOúLVXGHVWXO (XURSHL&KLDUGDF HUDWRWDOQHDQJDMDQW SURSXQHUHDHQJOH] QXDIRVW DGRSWDW GHRDUHFH 3RORQLD D UHIX]DW V VHPQH]H R DVHPHQHD GHFODUD LH DO WXULGH8QLXQHD6RYLHWLF ÌQ DFHVW FRQWH[W OD úL PDUWLH IUDQFH]LL DX SURSXV HQJOH]LORUV úLDVXPHvQFRPXQREOLJD LLIHUPHFKLDUúLPLOLWDUHID GH 5RPkQLDúL3RORQLDSHQWUXDILVLJXUF DFHVWHDYRUSDUWLFLSDODRHYHQWXDO UH]LVWHQ DQWLJHUPDQ 7HPkQGXVH GH UHDF LD JHUPDQ úL QHGRULQG VR SURYRDFH$UPDQG& OLQHVFXDSULPLWFXUH]HUYHLQWHQ LDIUDQFRHQJOH] GH vQFKHLHUH D XQXL SDFW GH DVLVWHQ PXWXDO FX 5RPkQLD úL D VXJHUDW DGRSWDUHDXQRUGHFODUD LLXQLODWHUDOHGHJDUDQWDUHDVHFXULW LL5RPkQLHL ÌQWUH WLPS SHQWUX D IDFH PDL ELQH FXQRVFXW SR]L LD 5RPkQLHL *ULJRUH*DIHQFXDHIHFWXDWWXUQHHGLSORPDWLFHOD,VWDQEXO DSULOLH úL vQ PDL PXOWH FDSLWDOH RFFLGHQWDOH %HUOLQ 3DULV 5RPD /RQGUD XQGH D SOHGDW SHQWUX VSRULUHD LQWHUHVXOXL FHUFXULORU ILQDQFLDUH úL HFRQRPLFH EULWDQLFH vQ VSHFLDO SHQWUX 5RPkQLD úL SHQWUX FRQVROLGDUHD VHFXULW LL 5RPkQLHL úL D %DOFDQLORU ÌQ DFHVW VFRS FRQVLGHUD F VH LPSXQHD úL VSULMLQXO8QLXQLL6RYLHWLFH3HQWUXDQXLULWD%HUOLQXOPLQLVWUXOURPkQGH ([WHUQHDI FXWFXQRVFXWF JXYHUQXOURPkQQXGRUHDV ILHLPSOLFDWvQ YUHXQIHOvQQHJRFLHULOHIUDQFRDQJORVRYLHWLFHvQSUREOHPDJDUDQ LLORUGH VHFXULWDWH úL F QX GRUHD vQFKHLHUHD XQXL SDFW GH DVLVWHQ PXWXDO URPkQRVRYLHWLF ÌQ ILQDO GXS FH OD PDUWLH D IRVW vQFKHLDW XQ DFRUG HFRQRPLF URPkQRIUDQFH] FRQFRPLWHQW FX DFRUGDUHD GH JDUDQ LL IUDQFRHQJOH]H F WUH 3RORQLD )UDQ D úL 0DUHD %ULWDQLH DX DFRUGDW DSULOLH JDUDQ LLSROLWLFHFRPXQH5RPkQLHL úL*UHFLHL ([SULPkQG SR]L LD *HUPDQLHL +HUPDQQ *|ULQJ OHD DSUHFLDW FD ÄLOX]RULL´ úL ÄSULPHMGLRDVH´GLQSXQFWGHYHGHUHSROLWLFGHRDUHFHÄ5HLFKXOQXYUHDV VHODVHvQFHUFXLW´
/DPDL DIRVWvQFKHLDWúLXQDFRUGHFRQRPLFURPkQRHQJOH]
*DUDQWkQG LQGHSHQGHQ D 5RPkQLHL úL QX LQWHJULWDWHD WHULWRULDO 0DUHD%ULWDQLHúL)UDQ DúLDXXUP ULWúLSURSULLOHLQWHUHVHvQ]RQ &X WRDWH DFHVWHD JDUDQ LLOH DX HYLWDW SHQWUX PRPHQW L]RODUHD GHSOLQ D 5RPkQLHL VXSXV SHUPDQHQW XQHL SUHVLXQL úL DPHQLQ UL JHUPDQH úL XQJDUHvQVSHFLDO 1HJRFLHULOHDQJORIUDQFRWXUFH&RQVLGHUkQGF XQHYHQWXDODFRUG vQWUH$QJOLDúL7XUFLDDUILIRVWEHQHILFSHQWUXFRQVROLGDUHDVHFXULW LLvQ ]RQD %DOFDQLORU úL vQ HVWXO 0HGLWHUDQHL GLSORPD LD URPkQ D VSULMLQLW GHPHUVXULOH UHVSHFWLYH VI WXLQG WRWRGDW ,XJRVODYLD V QX DGRSWH R DWLWXGLQH REVWUXF LRQLVW FDUH DU IL GXV OD GH]LQWHJUDUHD ÌQ HOHJHULL %DOFDQLFH 'XS ILQDOL]DUHD DFRUGXOXL DQJORWXUF JXYHUQXO GH OD %XFXUHúWL D Y ]XW vQ vQ HOHJHUHD UHVSHFWLY R QRX JDUDQ LH GLQ SDUWHD SXWHULORURFFLGHQWDOH3URWRFROXOVHFUHWDQH[DWWUDWDWXOXLDQJORIUDQFRWXUF OD RFWRPEULH SUHYHGHD vQV DMXWRU úL DVLVWHQ F WUH 7XUFLD ÄLPHGLDW FH R RIHQVLY PLOLWDU GHFODQúDW GH R SXWHUH HXURSHDQ DU DMXQJH OD IURQWLHUHOH %XOJDULHL VDX *UHFLHL´ GHFL SHVWH WHULWRULXO 5RPkQLHL 1HJRFLHULOH DQJORIUDQFRVRYLHWLFH ÌQFHSXWH RDUHFXP SURPL WRU QHJRFLHULOHWULSDUWLWHGHOD0RVFRYDGLQYDUDDQXOXL DXLQWUDWWUHSWDW vQLPSDVGDWRULW LQWHUHVHORUGLYHUJHQWHGLQWUH0DUHD%ULWDQLH)UDQ DúL 8QLXQHD 6RYLHWLF ILHFDUH vQFHUFkQG V úL LPSXQ SXQFWHOH GH YHGHUH
6XJHVWLY ILLQG vQ DFHVW VHQV HVWH GHFODUD LD I FXW GH 'XII &RRSHU Ä'DF DPJDUDQWDW3RORQLD*UHFLDúL5RPkQLDQXDPI FXWRSHQWUXF VLP LP SHQWUX SRORQH]L URPkQL VDX JUHFL YUHR SDUWLFXODU WDQGUH H vQ FRPSDUD LH FX HWLRSLHQLLVDXDOEDQH]LLFLSHQWUXF DPvQ HOHVF LQWHUHVHOHQRDVWUHYLWDOHVXQW LQWLP OHJDWH FX HL úL F XQ DFW GH DJUHVLXQH FRQWUD XQXLD HVWH XQ DFW FRQWUD WXWXURU´ ÌQPDLúLLXQLH 7XUFLDDvQFKHLDWDFRUGXULRILFLDOHFX)UDQ DúLFX $QJOLD FDUH QX DX IRVW SULYLWH FX RFKL EXQL vQ ,XJRVODYLD FDUH VH WHPHD GH *HUPDQLDúL,WDOLD/DUkQGXL*HUPDQLDDFRQVLGHUDWF SULQDOLDQ D7XUFLHLFX FHOHGRX VWDWHGHPRFUDWLFHRFFLGHQWDOH6WUkPWRULOHDXIRVWSXVHODGLVSR]L LD DFHVWRUD GLQ XUP ,QWHQ LD *HUPDQLHL GH D FRQWUROD %DOFDQLL D UH]XOWDW úL GLQ SURSXQHUHDI FXW GHYRQ3DSHQOXL1XPDQ0HQHPHQFLRJOXODPDL FD ,WDOLD GHYHQLW VWDW EDOFDQLF SULQ RFXSDUHD $OEDQLHL DSULOLH V ILH SULPLW vQÌQ HOHJHUHD%DOFDQLF 5HLFKXOXUPkQGDJDUDQWD7XUFLHLLQWHJULWDWHD WHULWRULDO
FDUHV OHVDWLVIDF LQWHUHVHOHLPHGLDWHúLGHSHUVSHFWLY /DDFHDVWDVD DG XJDW QHvQFUHGHUHD úL FKLDU WU GDUHD UHFLSURF GLQ PRPHQW FH DWkW HQJOH]LL FkW úL VRYLHWLFLL DX QHJRFLDW FRQFRPLWHQW FX JHUPDQLL FkW úL GLILFXOW LOH SULYLQG RE LQHUHD DFRUGXOXL JXYHUQHORU GH OD 9DUúRYLD úL %XFXUHúWL SULYLQG WUHFHUHD WUXSHORU VRYLHWLFH SH WHULWRULLOH 3RORQLHL úL 5RPkQLHLvQVLWXD LDvQFDUHDUILWUHEXLWV LQWUHvQDF LXQHvPSRWULYDXQHL DJUHVLXQLJHUPDQH 3HQWUXJXYHUQXOURPkQvQV vQFRQGL LLOHvQFDUHJXYHUQXOVRYLHWLF QX UHFXQRúWHD GH MXUH VXYHUDQLWDWHD URPkQHDVF DVXSUD %DVDUDELHL DFFHSWDUHD WUHFHULL 1LVWUXOXL GH F WUH WUXSHOH VRYLHWLFH HUD LQDFFHSWDELO 'HDOWIHOFXQRVFkQGDFHDVW VLWXD LHúLSR]L LD.UHPOLQXOXLJXYHUQHOHGH OD3DULVúL/RQGUDQLFLQXDXPDLLQIRUPDWJXYHUQXOGHOD%XFXUHúWLGDF DFFHSW VDX QX WUHFHUHD WUXSHORU VRYLHWLFH &KLDU GDF DYHD JUDQL D U V ULWHDQ UHFXQRVFXW GHJXYHUQXOVRYLHWLF3RORQLDQXDDFFHSWDWQLFLHD S WUXQGHUHD WUXSHORU VRYLHWLFH SH WHULWRULXO QD LRQDO LQYRFkQG QHvQFUHGHUHD vQ SROLWLFD JXYHUQXOXL GH OD 0RVFRYD úL SUDFWLFL PDL YHFKL DOHWUXSHORUVRYLHWLFHÌQDFHVWFRQWH[WWUDWDWLYHOHWULSDUWLWHGHOD0RVFRYD DXIRVWvQWUHUXSWHODDXJXVW 1HXWUDOLWDWHDÌQFRQWH[WXOLVWRULFH[WUHPGHFRPSOH[GHWHUPLQDWGH GHFODQúDUHD FHOXL GHDO GRLOHD U ]ERL PRQGLDO SULQ DWDFDUHD 3RORQLHL GH F WUH *HUPDQLD VHSWHPEULH úL SULQ DQJDMDUHD vQ FRQIODJUD LH D 0DULL%ULWDQLLD)UDQ HL VHSWHPEULH úLDDOWRUVWDWH5RPkQLDD GHFLV OD VHSWHPEULH úL VXE SUHVLXQH JHUPDQ V DGRSWH R SR]L LH GH QHXWUDOLWDWH 'HFL]LD &RQVLOLXOXL GH &RURDQ QX FRQWUDYHQHD YUHXQHL DOWH REOLJD LL LQWHUQD LRQDOH D 5RPkQLHL úL VH vQVFULD vQ ODUJXO FXUHQW
6RYLHWLFLLDXFHUXWJDUDQWDUHDvQWUHJXOXLVSD LXGLQWUH0DUHD%DOWLF úL 0DUHD1HDJU GHFLLQFOXVLYD)LQODQGHL/HWRQLHLúL(VWRQLHL FRQVLGHUkQGF JHUPDQLLSXWHDXDWDFDúLGHSHWHULWRULXODFHVWRUVWDWH OXFUXQHGRULWGHHQJOH]L 'HFL]LD D IRVW OXDW GH F WUH &RQVLOLXO GH &RURDQ úL D IRVW I FXW SXEOLF SULQ&RPXQLFDWXOQUDO&DVHL5HJDOH$GRXD]L*ULJRUH*DIHQFXD I FXW FXQRVFXW F 5RPkQLD U PkQHD QHXWU SkQ FkQG U ]ERLXO DU IL DWLQV´ GLUHFW LQGHSHQGHQ D úL LQWHJULWDWHD HL LQWHUHVHOH GH YLD DOH SULHWHQLORU HL GLQ ÌQ HOHJHUHD%DOFDQLF ´ *DUDQ LLOHDFRUGDWHGH)UDQ DúL0DUHD%ULWDQLH5RPkQLHLODDSULOLH HUDXXQLODWHUDOHLDUDOLDQ DFX3RORQLDGLQ QXIXQF LRQDGHFkWvQFD] GH DJUHVLXQH VRYLHWLF GHFODQúDW OD VHSWHPEULH GDU OD FHUHUHD JXYHUQXOXLGHOD9DUúRYLDFDUHQXDvQWUHSULQVDFHVWGHPHUV
QHXWUDOLVWGLQHSRF ÌQSRILGDRELHF LLORUJHUPDQHQHXWUDOLWDWHD5RPkQLHL DIRVWELQHYRLWRDUHID GH3RORQLDJXYHUQXOURPkQSHUPL kQGWUDQ]LWDUHD WH]DXUXOXLDUPDWHLJXYHUQXOXLSRORQH]úLDFLYLOLORUVSUHDOWHVWDWHúLFKLDU U PkQHUHDPXOWRUDvQ DU 5RPkQLDúL%ORFXOQHXWULORU/DVFXUWWLPSGXS GHFODQúDUHDFHOXL GHDOGRLOHDU ]ERLPRQGLDOJXYHUQXOURPkQDLQL LDWGHPHUVXULSHOkQJ JXYHUQHOH JUHF WXUF úL LXJRVODY SHQWUX FRQVROLGDUHD OHJ WXULORU GLQWUH VWDWHOH ÌQ HOHJHULL %DOFDQLFH úL DWUDJHUHD %XOJDULHL OD LGHHD RUJDQL] ULL XQXL EORF FDUH V SHUPLW FRQVWLWXLUHD XQHL ]RQH QHXWUH vQ %DOFDQL ÌQ DFHVW VFRS JXYHUQXO GH OD %HOJUDG D SURSXV vQFKHLHUHD XQRU WUDWDWH GH QHDJUHVLXQH úL QHXWUDOLWDWH vQWUH WRDWH VWDWHOH EDOFDQLFH VDX LQWUDUHD %XOJDULHL vQ ÌQ HOHJHUHD %DOFDQLF JXYHUQXO URPkQ D RSWDW SHQWUX DGRSWDUHDXQHLGHFODUD LLFRPXQHSULQFDUHFHOHFLQFLVWDWHVHDQJDMDXV U PkQ QHXWUH vQ WLPS FH JXYHUQXO GH OD $WHQD VD SURQXQ DW SHQWUX R ÄQHXWUDOLWDWH SXU I U QLFL R PHQ LXQH GH UHYL]XLUH´ ÌQ SRILGD SR]L LHL DGRSWDW GHF WUHJXYHUQXOHOHQ*ULJRUH*DIHQFXúL&LQþDU0DUFRYLüDX DFFHSWDWOD-HEHO VHSWHPEULH SRVLELOLWDWHDUHYL]XLULLIURQWLHUHORU vQIDYRDUHD%XOJDULHLvQVLWXD LDvQFDUH%XOJDULDDUILDGHUDWODÌQ HOHJHUHD %DOFDQLF úLVDUILVXSXVWXWXURUDQJDMDPHQWHORUúLREOLJD LLORUSHFDUHOH DYHDX FHOHODOWH VWDWH PHPEUH GDF DU IL FHGDW WHULWRULL WRDWH VWDWHOH ÌQ HOHJHULL%DOFDQLFHúLGDF JXYHUQXOEXOJDUDUILIRVWÄH[SUHVLDRSLQLHL SXEOLFHvQDQVDPEOXOV XvQVFRSXOGHDHYLWDFXUHQWHFRQWUDULLFDUHDUIL SXWXW FRPSURPLWH RSHUD GH vQ HOHJHUH R GDW UHDOL]DW ´ ,GHHD EORFXOXL EDOFDQLFDFRQYHQLWúL)UDQ HLúL0DULL%ULWDQLLFDUHVDXDU WDWGLVSXVHV DFFHSWHFKLDUVXSUHPD LD,WDOLHLvQFDGUXODFHVWXLDFXFRQGL LDFDDFHDVWD V U PkQ QHXWU ÌQWUXQDVHPHQHDFRQWH[WODRFWRPEULH JXYHUQXOURPkQD IRUPXODW FDUH V VWHD OD ED]D FRQVWLWXLULL EORFXOXL QHXWULORU vQ VXGHVWXO (XURSHL 1HXWUDOLWDWH GHV YkUúLW vQ FDGUXO U ]ERLXOXL vQ GHVI úXUDUH 1HDJUHVLXQHvQWUHVWDWHOHFDUHDUILFRQVWLWXLWEORFXO 3 VWUDUHDXQHL QHXWUDOLW L ELQHYRLWRDUH ID GH VWDWXO FDUH DU IL IRVW HYHQWXDO DWDFDW
5RPkQLDDDFRUGDWD]LOODFLUFDGHHPLJUDQ LSRORQH]L vQWUH FDUH GH PLOLWDUL úL D SHUPLV WUDQ]LWDUHD D SHVWH NJ DXU GLQ WH]DXUXOQD LRQDO 2EOLJD LLOHGHDVLVWHQ PXWXDO GLQWUHXQHOHVWDWHSDUWLFLSDQWHODEORF U PkQHDXvQYLJRDUHvQFD]GHDJUHVLXQH
/XDUHD GH FRPXQ DFRUG D GHFL]LLORU vQ YHGHUHD QRUPDOL] ULL VLWXD LHL PLOLWDUH OD IURQWLHUHOH FRPXQH 6WDELOLUHD XQXL FRQWDFW GLUHFW vQWUH PLQLúWULL$IDFHULORU6WU LQHDLVWDWHORUUHVSHFWLYHúLVFKLPEGHLQIRUPD LL SROLWLFH úL HFRQRPLFH vQWUH JXYHUQH $GRSWDUHD XQRU P VXUL GH RUGLQ HFRQRPLF vQ ED]D FRPXQLW LL GH LQWHUHVH 3ULQ XUPDUH SURLHFWXO URPkQHVFYL]DPHQ LQHUHDDOLDQ HORUH[LVWHQWH úLFKLDUO UJLUHDDFHVWRUD D VWDWXTXRXOXL WHULWRULDO úL D S FLL vQ ]RQ QHILLQG vQGUHSWDW vPSRWULYD QLP QXL 7HDPD GH UHDF LD %HUOLQXOXL vQ VSHFLDO D I FXW FD vQ VFXUW WLPS DOLD LL EDOFDQLFL DL 5RPkQLHL V úL SLDUG HQWX]LDVPXO ID GH LGHHD EORFXOXLQHXWULORUFKLDUúLvQWURIRUP UHVWUkQV ODVWDWHOHFDUHFRQVWLWXLDX ÌQ HOHJHUHD %DOFDQLF ,QVLVWkQG vQ DFHDVW GLQ XUP GLUHF LH *ULJRUH *DIHQFXDPLOLWDWvQWLPSXOVHVLXQLLRUGLQDUHD&RQVLOLXOXL3HUPDQHQWDO ÌQ HOHJHULL %DOFDQLFH GH OD%HOJUDG IHEUXDULH SHQWUXVROLGDUL WDWHDVWDWHORUPHPEUHúLSHQWUXDGRSWDUHDGHF WUHDFHVWHDDXQHLQHXWUD OLW LDFWLYHvQVHQVXODS U ULLvQFRPXQD]RQHLFKLDUvQDIDUDREOLJD LLORU FRQWUDFWXDOH vQ FD]XO XQHL HYHQWXDOH DJUHVLXQL H[WUDEDOFDQLFH (YROX LD VLWXD LHLLQWHUQD LRQDOHDI FXWFDDFHDVW LQL LDWLY V U PkQ ODVWDGLXOGH GH]LGHUDW 5HFUXGHVFHQ DUHYL]LRQLVPXOXLXQJDUEXOJDUúLVRYLHWLF 5HYL]LRQLVPXOXQJDU'DWRULW QHUHFXQRDúWHULLGHF WUHJXYHUQHOHGH OD %XGDSHVWD D SUHYHGHULORU 7UDWDWXOXL GH OD 7ULDQRQ GLQ UHOD LLOH URPkQRXQJDUH DX IRVW WHQVLRQDWH vQ WRDW SHULRDGD LQWHUEHOLF ÌQ DFHVW VHQV vQ DXJXVW /iV]OR %iUGRVV\ PLQLVWUXO XQJDU OD %XFXUHúWL D SUH]HQWDWOD6LQDLDOXL9LFWRU$QWRQHVFXSXQFWXOGHYHGHUHDOJXYHUQXOXL XQJDU UHIHULWRU OD UHOD LLOH FX VWDWHOH 0LFLL ÌQ HOHJHUL vQFKHLHUHD XQXL SURWRFRO SULQ FDUH V VH UHFXQRDVF FDGXFLWDWHD FODX]HORU PLOLWDUH DOH WUDWDWXOXLGHOD7ULDQRQUHFXQRDúWHUHDHJDOLW LLvQGUHSWXULD8QJDULHLvQ GRPHQLXOvQDUP ULLúLRVLWXD LHVSHFLDO SHQWUXPLQRULW LOHPDJKLDUHGLQ
&KLDUGDF VDGHFLVSUHOXQJLUHDSDFWXOXLFXvQF DQL vQFHSkQGFX IHEUXDULH UHXQLXQHDGHOD%HOJUDGGLQIHEUXDULH VDGRYHGLWDILúL XOWLPDÌQ HOHJHUHD%DOFDQLF GHVWU PkQGXVHODVFXUWWLPSGDWRULW HYHQLPHQ WHORULQWHUQD LRQDOHFDUHDXXUPDW
FHOH WUHL VWDWH ÌQ VFKLPE 8QJDULD VH DQJDMD V QX UHFXUJ OD IRU vQ UHOD LLOH FX 5RPkQLD ,XJRVODYLD úL &HKRVORYDFLD &RQVLGHUkQG SURSXQH ULOH PDJKLDUH GUHSW DPHVWHF vQ WUHEXULOH LQWHUQH 9LFWRU $QWRQHVFX D GHFODUDW F SUREOHPD PLQRULW LORU HUD GH FRPSHWHQ D ILHF UXL JXYHUQ QD LRQDOúLQXGHFHDDFHOXLGHOD%XGDSHVWD$SRLGXS vQWkOQLUHDGLQWUH +LWOHUúLORUGXO+DOLID[GLQ QRLHPEULH FkQG)KUHUXODF S WDW PkQ OLEHU vQ (XURSD FHQWUDO JXYHUQXO GH OD %XGDSHVWD LQWHUHVDW vQ PRGLILFDUHD VWDWXTXRXOXL WHULWRULDO SRVWEHOLF QX D PDL GRULW R YUHPH QHJRFLHULFXVWDWHOH0LFLLÌQ HOHJHULLDUDWXQFLFkQGDDFFHSWDWV OHSRDUWH DXUP ULWGHUHJXO VDWLVIDFHUHDUHYHQGLF ULORUUHYL]LRQLVWH $SRLvQLDQXDULH FXSULOHMXOYL]LWHLOD%HUOLQDXQHLGHOHJD LLD JXYHUQXOXL GH OD %XGDSHVWD SURILWkQG GH DJUDYDUHD VLWXD LHL LQWHUQD LR QDOH LQFOXVLY D SR]L LHL 5RPkQLHL PLQLVWUXO GH ([WHUQH XQJDU ,VWYiQ &ViN\DSURSXVFRQVWLWXLUHDÄXQXLQRXVWDWWUDQVLOY QHDQLQGHSHQGHQW´vQ VSHUDQ DF DFHVWDDUILSXWXWILLQWHJUDWPDLXúRU8QJDULHLÌQFRQGL LLOHvQ FDUHJHUPDQLLQXDXIRVWGHDFRUGJXYHUQXOGHOD%XGDSHVWDDSXVvQOXQD XUP WRDUHSUREOHPDXQHLUHYL]XLULDIURQWLHUHORUvQXUPDF UHLD8QJDULD DU IL RE LQXW XQHOH WHULWRULL URPkQHúWL GH JUDQL &RQFRPLWHQW SULPXO PLQLVWUX7HOHNL3iODFRQFHSXWXQSURLHFWGHFRQVWLWXLUHDXQXLÄFRULGRU´ VSUHWHULWRULXOVHFXLHVFúLDXQRUFDQWRDQH FDWHULWRULLQD LRQDOHVXYHUDQH 3HQWUX WUDQVSXQHUHD vQ SUDFWLF D DFHVWRU SODQXUL OD PLMORFXO OXQLL PDUWLH FRQFRPLWHQW FX RFXSDUHD 8FUDLQHL 6XEFDUSDWLFH JXYHUQXO XQJDUDPDVDWLPSRUWDQWHIRU HPLOLWDUHODJUDQL DFX5RPkQLDGHWHUPL QkQGJXYHUQXOURPkQV GHFODUHPRELOL]DUHDJHQHUDO /D VFXUW WLPS GXS GH]PHPEUDUHD &HKRVORYDFLHL úL GXS FH RFXSDVH vQWUHDJD 8FUDLQ 6XEFDUSDWLF PDUWLH úL S U VLVH 6RFLHWDWHD1D LXQLORU DSULOLH SULPXOPLQLVWUXXQJDU7HOHNL3iO DGHFODUDWF ÄUHYHQGLFDUHD7UDQVLOYDQLHLU PkQHvQSULPSODQXOSUHRFXS ULORUSROLWLFLL8QJDULHL´úLF ÄDQH[DUHDHLYDDYHDORFPDLFXUkQGVDXPDL WkU]LX´LDUvQWUHúLDSULOLHOD5RPDDvQDLQWDWPLQLVWUXOXLLWDOLDQGH ([WHUQH&LDQRXQPHPRULXvQVR LWGHRKDUW FXSURSXQHULGHÄVROX LR QDUH´ÌQDFHODúLVFRSvQSODQPLOLWDUODvQFHSXWXOOXQLLPDL JHQH
5HOLHIkQG LQWHQ LLOH DJUHVLYH XQJDUH *ULJRUH *DIHQFX LQIRUPD UHSUH]HQWDQ HOH URPkQHúWL GH SHVWH KRWDUH Ä8QJDULD QXWUHúWH VHQWLPHQWH UHYL ]LRQLVWHSHFDUHvQYUHPXULOHGLQXUP OHDPDQLIHVWDWSHID SULQFDPSDQLL GHSUHV úLvQWUXQLUL´
UDOXO:HUWK+HQULNúHIXO0DUHOXL6WDW0DMRUXQJDUDvQDLQWDWPHPEULORU JXYHUQXOXL XQ SURLHFW GH RSHUD LL PLOLWDUH vPSRWULYD 5RPkQLHL DSUREDW DSRL úL GH UHVSRQVDELOLL SROLWLFL FDUH YL]D vQ DIDUD SUREOHPHORU PLOLWDUH SURSULX]LVH úL PRGXO vQ FDUH XUPD V VH GHVI úRDUH DFWLYLWDWHD GH SURSDJDQG úLVDERWDMvQWHULWRULXOURPkQHVFÌQSODQGLSORPDWLFJXYHUQXO GH OD %XGDSHVWD D vQFHSXW V SXQ GLQ FH vQ FH PDL DFXW SUREOHPD 7UDQVLOYDQLHLvQUDSRUWXULOHLQWHUQD LRQDOHvQVSHFLDOvQUHOD LLOHFX$QJOLD 3UHVLXQLOHXQJDUHDVXSUD5RPkQLHLVDXDFFHQWXDWGXS VHPQDUHDOD DXJXVW D SDFWXOXL GH QHDJUHVLXQH JHUPDQRVRYLHWLF 'H DOWIHO GXS FH OD vQGHPQ JHUPDQ 8QJDULD GLVORFDVH QRL WUXSH OD JUDQL D FX 5RPkQLD FKLDU vQ ]LXD vQ FDUH HUD vQFKHLDW VLQLVWUXO SDFW &ViN\ ,VWYiQ WULPLWHD JXYHUQXOXL URPkQ R 1RW VHYHU SULQ FDUH LQYRFD PRELOL]DUHD PLOLWDU XQJDU FDXQU VSXQVODFHDVLPLODU URPkQ GHúLFDX]HOHHUDXFX WRWXODOWHOHÌQFHUFkQGFRQFLOLHUHDJXYHUQXOURPkQDSURSXVODDXJXVW SULQ *ULJRUH *DIHQFX vQFKHLHUHD XQXL WUDWDW GH QHDJUHVLXQH vQV RIHUWD D IRVW UHVSLQV LQYRFkQGXVH ÄSUHVLXQHD DUPHORU´ GLQ SDUWHD 5RPkQLHL 'XS GHFODQúDUHD FHOXL GHDO GRLOHD U ]ERL PRQGLDO UHOD LLOH URPkQRXQJDUHDXU PDVWRWvQFRUGDWHvQSRILGDIDSWXOXLF DYkQGQHYRLH GHSHWUROXOURPkQHVFúLGHOLQLúWHvQ]RQ 5LEEHQWURSDFHUXWOXL&ViN\FD 8QJDULD V QX DWDFH5RPkQLDúLV VHÄPXO XPHDVF FXVWDUHDDFWXDO ´ &D XUPDUH JXYHUQXO GH OD %XGDSHVWD D DFFHSWDW V vQFKHLH FX JXYHUQXO URPkQXQDFRUGUHIHULWRUODUHGXFHUHDUHFLSURF úLVLPXOWDQ DHIHFWLYHORU PLOLWDUH GH OD JUDQL D FRPXQ 3HVWH SX LQ WLPS vQV &RQVLOLXO PLOLWDU XQJDU DYHD V FRQFUHWL]H]H vQWUH úL GHFHPEULH XQ SODQ GH LQWHUYHQ LH PLOLWDU vPSRWULYD 5RPkQLHL %XGDSHVWD FRQWkQG úL SH VXV LQHUHD GHFODUDW DO %HUOLQXOXL F UXLD LD FHUXW vQ PDUWLH
$JUHVLXQHDXQJDU XUPDV VHSURGXF LPHGLDWvQVLWXD LLOHvQFDUHvQ 5RPkQLD DU IL L]EXFQLW UHYROX LH úL DUPDWD VDU IL GHVWU PDW GDF PLQRULWDWHD PDJKLDU GLQ$UGHDODUILIRVWSULPHMGXLW VDXGDF JXYHUQXOGHOD%XFXUHúWLDU IL I FXW FRQFHVLL WHULWRULDOH 8QLXQLL 6RYLHWLFH VDX %XOJDULHL &X SX LQ WLPS vQDLQWH úHIXO SUHVHL XQJDUH 8OOHLQ 5HYLF]N\ GHFODUDVH Ä3ROLWLFD H[WHUQ D 8QJDULHL DUH R VLQJXU SUREOHP $UGHDOXO $FHDVW SUREOHP R UH]ROY P vQ RULFHvPSUHMXUDUHúLFXRULFHSUH ´ /DLDQXDULH JHQHUDOXO7LSSHONLUFKúHIXO6HF LHLHYLGHQ GLQ 0DUHOH6WDW0DMRU*HUPDQDGHFODUDWJHQHUDOXOXL8MV]iV]\,VWYiQúHIXO6HF LHL FRQWUDVSLRQDM DO DUPDWHL XQJDUH F SHQWUX DúL DVLJXUD FRQWUROXO DVXSUD ] F PLQWHORUGHSHWURODOH5RPkQLHL*HUPDQLDFRQWDSHLQWHUYHQ LD8QJDULHL
VSULMLQ SHQWUX VDWLVIDFHUHD LPHGLDW D UHYHQGLF ULORU WHULWRULDOH DVXSUD 5RPkQLHL7HPkQGXVHF RHYHQWXDO LQWHUYHQ LHXQJDU DUILGHVWDELOL]DW VLWXD LDGLQ]RQ úLDUILIRVWIDYRUDELO HQJOH]LORU +LWOHUDUHVSLQVSHQWUX PRPHQW SUHWHQ LLOH XQJDUH &X WRDWH DFHVWHD JXYHUQXO XQJDU DúWHSWD FX QHU EGDUHSULOHMXOSHQWUXDLQWHUYHQLPRELOL]kQGFXDQWLFLSD LHODPLMOR FXOOXQLLPDLGRX FRUSXULGHDUPDW úLEULJ ]LOHUDSLGH$SRLODLXQLH ODQXPDLR]LGXS FHJXYHUQXOVRYLHWLFDvQDLQWDWJXYHUQXOXLURPkQ 1RWD XOWLPDWLY SULQ FDUH FHUHD FHGDUHD %DVDUDELHL úL D QRUGXOXL %XFRYLQHL %XGDSHVWD D vQDLQWDW %HUOLQXOXL R 1RW SULQ FDUH DU WD F 8QJDULD GRUHD V úL vQGHSOLQHDVF úLHDSUHWHQ LLOHID GH5RPkQLDSULQ LQWHUPHGLXOvQ HOHJHULORUFXSXWHULOH$[HLÌQDFHHDúL]LJXYHUQXOXQJDUD DGRSWDW R GHFODUD LH SULQ FDUH VH PHQ LRQD F 5RPkQLD WUHEXLD ÄFRQVWUkQV ´ V VDWLVIDF SUHWHQ LLOH WHULWRULDOH XQJDUH LDU &RQVLOLXO 6XSUHPDO$S U ULL1D LRQDOHDGHFUHWDWPRELOL]DUHDDUPDWHLúLGLVORFDUHD SURJUHVLY D XQLW LORU úL PDULORU XQLW L VSUH JUDQL D GH HVW 3HQWUX D FRQWURODVLWXD LDJXYHUQXOJHUPDQDDYHUWL]DWJXYHUQXOGHOD%XGDSHVWDV QX DWDFH 5RPkQLD SURPL kQGXL WRWRGDW F SUREOHPD UHYL]XLULL YD IL VROX LRQDW GHF WUHVWDWHOH$[HL 5HYL]LRQLVPXO EXOJDU ÌQ SRILGD GHFODUD LLORU OLQLúWLWRDUH I FXWH XQHRULGHJXYHUQXOGHOD6RILDUHYL]LRQLVPXOEXOJDUDOXDWRDPSORDUHGLQ FH vQ FH PDL PDUH GHWHUPLQkQG UHDF LD *UHFLHL FDUH úLD SURFODPDW GLQ QRX SULQ,RDQQLV0HWD[DV LQYLRODELOLWDWHDIURQWLHUHORUODSDFHúLU ]ERL úL D 5RPkQLHL FDUH D GHFODUDW SULQ *ULJRUH *DIHQFX F DWkWD WLPS FkW %XOJDULD QX YD DFFHSWD V LQWUH vQ ÌQ HOHJHUHD EDOFDQLF úL QX VH YD VROLGDUL]D FX SROLWLFD GH SDFH D YHFLQLORU ÄQX L VH SRDWH IDFH QLFL R FRQFHVLHGHRUGLQSROLWLFQHFXPGHRUGLQWHULWRULDO´ 5HYL]LRQLVPXOVRYLHWLF'XS FHúLDvPS U LWVIHUHOHGHLQIOXHQ FX *HUPDQLDODDXJXVW 8QLXQHD6RYLHWLF DULGLFDWGLQFHvQFHPDL DPHQLQ WRU SUREOHPD %DVDUDELHL ÄLQFLGHQWHOH GH IURQWLHU ´ SXVH GH F WUH VRYLHWLFL SH VHDPD URPkQLORU vQPXO LQGXVH vQ PRG VLP LWRU ÌQ SHULRDGDXUP WRDUHGLSORPD LLJHUPDQLDXLQIRUPDWSHFHLURPkQLGHVSUH
ÌQ RFWRPEULH 00 0RORWRY D GHFODUDW PLQLVWUXOXL WXUF GH ([WHUQH 6DUDFLRJOX F 0RVFRYD VH JkQGHD ÄV úL UHIDF IURQWLHUD GLQ ´ $SRL .UHPOLQXO D SURSXV %XOJDULHL V SUHWLQG vQWUHDJD 'REURJH F R YD VXV LQHÌQDFHHDúLGLUHF LHGHDF LXQHODGHFHPEULH 3RWHPNLQDGHFODUDW DPEDVDGRUXOXLIUDQFH]OD0RVNRYDF 2GHVVDGHYHQLVHÄXQSRUWPRUWGHFkQGD SLHUGXWKLQWHUODQGXO%DVDUDELHL´
GHFODUD LLOH UHYL]LRQLVWH VRYLHWLFH /D GHFHPEULH GH H[HPSOX :LOKHOP)DEULFLXVDDWHQ LRQDWSH*ULJRUH*DIHQFXF GDF U ]ERLXOVHYD LQWHQVLILFDvQYHVWXO(XURSHLÄ5XVLD6RYLHWLF QXYDSXWHDILvPSLHGLFDW V úL UHDOL]H]H DQXPLWH SODQXUL´ $SRL GXS FH OD GHFHPEULH &DUO &ORGLXV D GHFODUDW OXL (UQHVW 8UG UHDQX F *HUPDQLD QX YD DS UD 5RPkQLDÄvQPRPHQWXOFkQG6RYLHWHOHYRUWUHFH1LVWUXO´DPEDVDGRUXO JHUPDQ OD 5RPD +DQV *HRUJ YRQ 0DFNHQVHQ D SXQFWDW úL HO OD PDUWLH vQWURGLVFX LHFX5DRXO%RVV\FDUHvQFHUFDV LH[SOLFHF vQFD]GHDWDFVRYLHWLFURPkQLLVHYRUDS UDFDILQODQGH]LL Ä1LPHQLQX YUHDFDUXúLLV DMXQJ vQ%DOFDQLGDUvQJHQHUDOVHVRFRWHúWHF %DOFDQLL vQFHS OD 3UXW´ 3HQWUX FD WRWXO V ILH FODU GLSORPDWXO JHUPDQ D DG XJDW Ä3HQWUX%DVDUDELDQXVHYDOXSWDQLPHQL'HDFHHDFUHGSHUVRQDOF DU WUHEXL V Y vQ HOHJH L FX UXúLL GDF ULGLF FKHVWLXQHD %DVDUDELHL´ Ä&KHVWLXQHD´DYHDV ILHULGLFDW vQWUDGHY UGHF WUH900RORWRYOD PDUWLH DFHODúL DQ FkQG FRPLVDUXO VRYLHWLF DO $IDFHULORU ([WHUQH D LQIRUPDW6RYLHWXO6XSUHPF vQWUH8QLXQHD6RYLHWLF úL5RPkQLDH[LVWDR ÄFKHVWLXQHOLWLJLRDV QHUH]ROYDW DFHHDD%DVDUDELHL´ 6FKLPEDUHDSROLWLFLLH[WHUQH ÌQ SULP YDUD DQXOXL FD XUPDUH D QRLORU HYHQLPHQWH LQWHUQD LRQDOH DJUHVLXQHD*HUPDQLHLvQYHVWXO(XURSHL 5RPkQLDVDY ]XWL]RODW GLQ FH vQ FH PDL PXOW vQ SODQ LQWHUQD LRQDO ÌQFHUFkQG V VRQGH]H SR]L LD *HUPDQLHL OD PDL *ULJRUH *DIHQFX D VROLFLWDW OXL :LOKHOP )DEULFLXV ÄXQHOH O PXULUL FX SULYLUH OD SROLWLFD RULHQWDO D JXYHUQXOXL JHUPDQ´ 6SUH VWXSHIDF LD PLQLVWUXOXL URPkQ DO $IDFHULORU 6WU LQH RPRORJXOJHUPDQDU VSXQVF ÄSDFHDúLOLQLúWHD5RPkQLHLDWkUQ vQEXQ SDUWHGHvQ HOHJHUHDGHSOLQ ODFDUHDUSXWHDDMXQJH5RPkQLDFXYHFLQLLV L´
&RUHODWH FX FDSLWXODUHD %HOJLHL úL vQIUkQJHULOH vQUHJLVWUDWH SH IURQW GH F WUH WUXSHOH IUDQFH]H úL HQJOH]H FX UHFUXGHVFHQ D UHYL]LRQLVPXOXLVRYLHWLFXQJDUúLJHUPDQQRLOHGHFODUD LLúLSUHVLXQL JHUPDQHDXGXVODVFKLPEDUHDFXUVXOXLSROLWLFLLH[WHUQHD ULLOD PDL SULPXOPLQLVWUX *KHRUJKH 7 W UHVFX LQIRUPkQG SH :LOKHOP
3HODUJ $OHVDQGUX'X X0DULD,JQDWRSFLW
)DEULFLXV F JXYHUQXO URPkQ GRUHD V O PXUHDVF FX FHO JHUPDQ ÄFDGUXO FRODERU ULL SULHWHQHúWL FX JXYHUQXO 5HLFKXOXL´ 3HQWUX D vQOHVQL DFHVW OXFUX *ULJRUH *DIHQFX úLD SUH]HQWDW GHPLVLD ILLQG vQORFXLW FX ILORJHUPDQXO ,RQ *LJXUWX &X WRDWH DFHVWHD OD LXQLH JXYHUQXO JHUPDQ D FRQGL LRQDW GLQ QRX vPEXQ W LUHD UHOD LLORU ELODWHUDOHGHOXDUHDvQFRQVLGHUDUHDHYHQWXDOHORUÄFHUHULGHUHYL]XLUL DOHYHFLQLORU´ÌQFHUFkQGV vPEXQH]H%HUOLQXO*KHRUJKH7 W UHVFX DU VSXQVODLXQLHI FkQGFXQRVFXW KRW UkUHDJXYHUQXOXLURPkQ GHÄDvQW ULúLH[WLQGHFRODERUDUHDGLQWUH5RPkQLDúL*HUPDQLD´ ÌQQRLOHFRQGL LLJHRSROLWLFHúLVWUDWHJLFHGHWHUPLQDWHGHFDSLWXODUHD )UDQ HL úL GH SLHUGHUHD %DVDUDELHL úL D QRUGXOXL %XFRYLQHL JXYHUQXO URPkQ D UHQXQ DW OD LXQLH OD JDUDQ LLOH DQJORIUDQFH]H GLQ DSULOLH GXS FDUH OD LXOLH QRXO SULPPLQLVWUX ,RQ *LJXUWX D DQXQ DW GHFL]LD GH D XUPD R SROLWLF GH ÄLQWHJUDUH´ VLQFHU vQ VLVWHPXO $[HL2V SW PkQ PDLWkU]LXODLXOLHVDI FXWSXEOLF úLGHFL]LDGH LHúLUHGLQ6RFLHWDWHD1D LXQLORU
,,,5$3785,/(7(5,725,$/( /$&$5($)26768386 520Æ1,$Ì1
ÌQYDUDDQXOXL ODVFXUWWLPSGXS vQIUkQJHUHD)UDQ HL5RPkQLD VDDIODWvQWURVLWXD LHH[WUHPGHGLILFLO SLHU]kQGvQWUXQWLPSH[WUHPGH VFXUWFLUFDNPSúLGHORFXLWRULFDUHDXLQWUDWSULQSUH VLXQHúLGLFWDWvQFRPSRQHQ D8QLXQLL6RYLHWLFH8QJDULHLúL%XOJDULHL $FHDVWDvQSRILGDIDSWXOXLF vQSHULRDGDLQWHUEHOLF GLSORPD LDURPkQ XUP ULQG PHQ LQHUHD LQWHJULW LL LQGHSHQGHQ HL úL VXYHUDQLW LL VWDWXOXL QD LRQDOXQLWDUDSURPRYDWRSROLWLF GHSDFHúLSULHWHQLHFXWRDWHVWDWHOH YHFLQHQHULGLFkQGYUHRGDW YUHRSUHWHQ LHWHULWRULDO ID GHDFHVWHD &X WRDWH DFHVWHD SUHVLXQLOH úL DPHQLQ ULOH VWDWHORU UHYL]LRQLVWH OD DGUHVDLQWHJULW LLWHULWRULDOHD5RPkQLHLDYHDXV VHLQWHQVLILFHvQVSHFLDO GXS FH*HUPDQLDDGHFODQúDWSURFHVXOGHS WUXQGHUHVSUHFHQWUXOúLHVWXO (XURSHL RFXSkQG $XVWULD &HKRVORYDFLD úL 3RORQLD úL vQFKHLQG OD DXJXVW SDFWXOGHQHDJUHVLXQHFX8QLXQHD6RYLHWLF DOF UXLSURWRFRO VHFUHW PHQ LRQD OD DUW LQWHUHVXO VWDWXOXL VRYLHWLF SHQWUX %DVDUDELD úL GH]LQWHUHVXO 5HLFKXOXL SHQWUX DFHODúL WHULWRULX 3UHVLXQL DVXSUD ULL DX PDLI FXWDWkW8QJDULDFkWúL%XOJDULD
3HODUJ $OHVDQGUX'X X0DULD,JQDW 'UDPD5RPkQLHL5DSW úL XPLOLQ %XFXUHúWL *LXUF ,RQ 'UDPD 5RPkQLHL 0DUL %XFXUHúWL 0XúDW0LUFHD$UGHOHDQX,RQ'UDPD5RPkQLHL0DUL%XFXUHúWL 9H]LúL$OHVDQGUX'X X0RGLILFDUHDVWDWXTXRXOXLWHULWRULDOHXURSHDQ 3UHOLPLQDULLFRQ LQXWúLFRQVHFLQ H%XFXUHúWL 3H ODUJ 0RLVXF 9LRULFD 3UHPLVHOH L]RO ULL SROLWLFH D 5RPkQLHL %XFXUHúWL ,RDQ7DOSHú'LSORPD LHúLDS UDUH&RRUGRQDWH DOHSROLWLFLLH[WHUQHURPkQHúWL %XFXUHúWL 0LKDL5HWHJDQÌQ EDODQ DIRU HORU$OLDQ HOHPLOLWDUHURPkQHúWLLQWHUEHOLFH%XFXUHúWL /D LDQXDULH SXUW WRUXO GH FXYkQW DO JXYHUQXOXL GH OD %XGDSHVWDDGHFODUDWF ÄSROLWLFDH[WHUQ D8QJDULHLDUHRVLQJXU SUREOHP $UGHDOXO´
6HVL]kQG SHULFROXO FH SODQD DVXSUD ULL JXYHUQXO URPDQ D FHUXW JXYHUQHORUDOLDWHV OLQIRUPH]HGDF SXWHDFRQWDSHVSULMLQXOORUvQFD]XO XQHLDJUHVLXQLDVXSUDWHULWRULXOXLV XQD LRQDO5 VSXQVXODIRVWGH]DP JLWRU DOLD LLGLQÌQ HOHJHUHD%DOFDQLF VI WXLQG5RPkQLDV VHMHUWIHDVF ÄvQ LQWHUHVXO S FLL´ DúD FXP FRQVHPQD SULPXOPLQLVWUX *KHRUJKH 7 W UHVFX) U HIHFWDVXSUDLQWHJULW LLWHULWRULDOHD5RPkQLHLDXU PDVúL JDUDQ LLOHRIHULWHGH)UDQ DúL0DUHD%ULWDQLH 2FXSDUHD%DVDUDELHLúLDQRUGXOXL%XFRYLQHL GHF WUH8QLXQHD6RYLHWLF 3ULPHOH WHULWRULL URPkQHúWL SLHUGXWH vQ GUDPDWLFXO DQ DX IRVW %DVDUDELDúLQRUGXO%XFRYLQHLDF URUXQLUHFXSDWULDPDP vQ QXD IRVW UHFXQRVFXW GH F WUH 8QLXQHD 6RYLHWLF Ä3UREOHPD´ EDVDUDEHDQ D IRVWULGLFDW GLUHFWGHF WUH900RORWRYOD PDUWLH GXS YLFWR ULD DVXSUD )LQODQGHL FkQG FRPLVDUXO VRYLHWLF DO $IDFHULORU ([WHUQH D LQIRUPDW6RYLHWXO6XSUHPF vQWUH8QLXQHD6RYLHWLF úL5RPkQLDH[LVWDR ÄFKHVWLXQH OLWLJLRDV QHUH]ROYDW DFHHD D %DVDUDELHL´ $SRL GXS FH JXYHUQXOJHUPDQvQWUHEDVHJXYHUQXOURPkQODLXQLHSULQWURFRPXQLFD UH YHUEDO WUDQVPLV GH PLQLVWUXO 5HLFKXOXL OD %XFXUHúWL :LOKHOP )DEULFLXVGDF úLvQFHP VXU HUDGLVSXVÄDWUDWDSULYLWRUODRFHUHUHGH UHYL]XLUH D YHFLQLORU V L FD GH H[HPSOX D 8566 vQ FKHVWLXQHD %DVDUDELHL´ 90 0RORWRY D I FXW FXQRVFXW OD LXQLH OXL )ULHGULFK :HUQHU YRQ 6FKXOHQEXUJ DPEDVDGRUXO JHUPDQ OD 0RVFRYD F ÄUH]RO YDUHDSUREOHPHLEDVDUDEHQHQXPDLVXIHU DPkQDUH´F JXYHUQXOVRYLHWLF HUDKRW UkWÄV IRORVHDVF IRU DvQFD]XOvQFDUHJXYHUQXOURPDQUHIX] R vQ HOHJHUHSDúQLF ´6SUHVWXSHIDF LDDPEDVDGRUXOXLJHUPDQúLDSRLDOXL +LWOHU900RORWRYDDG XJDWF FHUHUHDVRYLHWLF VHH[WLQGHDúLDVXSUD %XFRYLQHL 3HQWUX FD WRWXO V ILH FODU úL V QX DSDU YUHR VXUSUL] GLQ SDUWHD %HUOLQXOXL GLSORPDWXO VRYLHWLF D PDL SUHFL]DW F 0RVFRYD ÄFRQ WHD] SHIDSWXOF *HUPDQLDQXYDLQFRPRGDDF LXQHDVRYLHWLF FLRYD VSULMLQL´ ÌQ VFKLPE .UHPOLQXO YD IDFH WRWXO SHQWUX ÄD DS UD LQWHUHVHOH JHUPDQH vQ5RPkQLD´Ä7kUJXO´DIRVWDVWIHOvQFKHLDWUDSLGODLXQLH -RDFNLP YRQ 5LEEHQWURS FRQILUPkQG DFRUGXO *HUPDQLHL ID GH FHUHULOH VRYLHWLFHúLVROLFLWkQGOXL):YRQ6FKXOHQEXUJV FRPXQLFHOXL90 0RORWRYF JXYHUQXOV XQXPDQLIHVWDÄQLFLXQLQWHUHV´ID GH%DVDUDELD GDUF vQUHVWXO5RPkQLHL5HLFKXODYHDLQWHUHVHHFRQRPLFHÄGHRVHELWGH
LPSRUWDQWH´ FDUH LQFOXGHDX ÄWHUHQXULOH SHWUROLIHUH FkW úL WHUHQXULOH DJULFROH´ 3ULQ XUPDUH %HUOLQXO GRUHD R ÄVROX LRQDUH SDúQLF ´ D SUREOH PHLVI WXLQGDSRLvQDFHVWVHQVJXYHUQXOURPkQÌQDFHHDúL]LPXO XPLQG SHQWUX ÄDWLWXGLQHD vQ HOHJ WRDUH´ úL SHQWUX ÄEXQ YRLQ D´ JXYHUQXOXL JHU PDQ900RORWRYDSUHFL]DWOXL):YRQ6FKXOHQEXUJF SUREOHPDHUD ÄH[WUHP GH XUJHQW ´ úL QX SXWHD VXIHUL ÄQLFL R DPkQDUH´ 8QHOH FRQWUR YHUVHVDXPDQLIHVWDWvQSULYLQ D%XFRYLQHLGDUvQILQDOPLQLVWUXOVRYLHWLF GHH[WHUQHQXDH[FOXVSRVLELOLWDWHDUHQXQ ULLODDFHDVW FHUHUHvQFXUVXO WUDWDWLYHORUFXJXYHUQXOURPkQ /DUkQGXLODLXQLHXUP ULQGV QXGHWHULRUH]HUHOD LLOHVRYLHWR JHUPDQHGDUQLFLV QXGHDGRYDG GHVO ELFLXQH,96WDOLQDUHFXUVOD FRPSURPLV FHUkQG OXL 90 0RORWRY V O LQIRUPH]H SH ): YRQ 6FKXOHQEXUJ F JXYHUQXO VRYLHWLF D GHFLV ÄV úL OLPLWH]H FHUHULOH DVXSUD S U LLQRUGLFHD%XFRYLQHLvPSUHXQ FXRUDúXO&HUQ X L´ ÌQFRQWLQXD UHFHLGRLGLSORPD LDXF ]XWGHDFRUGDVXSUDPRGXOXLvQFDUHXUPDV VH SURFHGH]H vQWLPSFHJXYHUQXOVRYLHWLFDYHDV VXSXQ FHUHUHDvQDFHHDúL VHDU PLQLVWUXOXL SOHQLSRWHQ LDU URPkQ OD 0RVFRYD JXYHUQXO JHUPDQ WUHEXLD V VI WXLDVF ÄGH XUJHQ ´ JXYHUQXO GH OD %XFXUHúWL ÄV FDG GH DFRUG´DOWIHOÄU ]ERLXODUILLQHYLWDELO´ &RQIRUPSODQXOXLVWDELOLWvQVHDUD]LOHLGHLXQLHODRUD90 0RORWRY D vQPkQDW OXL *KHRUJKH 'DYLGHVFX vQ QXPHOH JXYHUQXOXL VRYLHWLF R 1RW XOWLPDWLY SOLQ GH QHDGHY UXUL LVWRULFH SULQ FDUH VH SURSXQHDJXYHUQXOXLURPkQÄV vQDSRLH]HFXRULFHSUH 8QLXQLL6RYLHWLFH %DVDUDELD´ úL V ÄWUDQVPLW ´ SDUWHD GH QRUG D %XFRYLQHL 5 VSXQVXO HUD DúWHSWDW vQ FXUVXO ]LOHL GH LXQLH 'XS FH D SUH]HQWDW I U VXFFHV DUJXPHQWHGHOXDWvQVHDP SHQWUXQHWHPHLQLFLDDFX]D LLORUVRYLHWLFHGLQ 1RWD XOWLPDWLY DPEDVDGRUXO URPkQ D DU WDW F WHUPHQXO IL[DW HUD
ÌQFHUFkQG V RE LQ R FRPSHQVD LH SHQWUX 5RPkQLD DPEDVDGRUXO JHUPDQ D DSUHFLDW F VH SXWHD DMXQJH PDL XúRU OD ÄR VROX LRQDUH SDúQLF ´ vQ VLWXD LDvQFDUHJXYHUQXOVRYLHWLFÄDUvQDSRLDUH]HUYDGHDXUD% QFLL1D LRQDOHD 5RPkQLHL´ WH]DXUXO URPkQHVF GHSXV VSUH S VWUDUH OD 0RVFRYD vQ WLPSXO SULPXOXLU ]ERLPRQGLDO±QQ900RORWRYDU VSXQVvQV F DFHDVW SUR EOHP ÄQLFLQXVHPDLSXQHGHRDUHFH5RPkQLDDH[SORDWDWXQWLPSvQGHOXQJDW %DVDUDELD´ 3HKDUWDvQPkQDW ÄQRLOHIURQWLHUH´HUDXPDUFDWHSULQWUROLQLHJURDV WUDVDW FX FUHLRQ URúX XUPD DFHVWXLD DFRSHULQG DúD FXP UHOHYD $OH[DQGUX &UHW]LDQXRSRU LXQHFRUHVSXQ] WRDUHÄXQXLWHULWRULXGHPLOH´DVWIHOvQFkWHUD IRDUWHJUHXGHVWDELOLWvQFDUHSDUWHHUDXXQHOHORFDOLW L0DLPXOWOLQLDWUHFHDúL SHVWHXQWHULWRULX UHJLXQHD+HU D FDUHQXHUDPHQ LRQDWvQXOWLPDWXP
ÄLQVXILFLHQW´ SHQWUX FD JXYHUQXO URPkQ V SRDW GHFLGH vQWUR SUREOHP DWkW GH LPSRUWDQW ,QIOH[LELO PLQLVWUXO VRYLHWLFGH([WHUQHDUHSOLFDWF GDF QXVHYDU VSXQGHDILUPDWLYvQWHUPHQXOIL[DWDWDFXOVRYLHWLFVHYD SURGXFHvQVHDUD]LOHLXUP WRDUH ,QIRUPDW GHVSUH FRQ LQXWXO XOWLPDWXPXOXL GXS FH DIODVH GH OD :LOKHOP)DEULFLXVF UHYHQGLFDUHD%DVDUDELHLGHF WUHVRYLHWLFLHUDÄELQH vQWHPHLDW ´UHJHOH&DURODO,,OHDDFRQYRFDWODDXJXVW&RQVLOLXOGH &RURDQ FDUHDDSUREDWKRW UkUHDJXYHUQXOXLURPkQGHDFHUHJXYHUQXOXL VRYLHWLF ÄV IL[H]H ORFXO úL GDWD XQGH DU SXWHD V DLE ORF vQWkOQLUHD GHOHJD LORU DPEHORU JXYHUQH SHQWUX D OXD vQ GLVFX LXQH 1RWD VRYLHWLF ´ 6HDUDDFHLDúL&RQVLOLXDYHDV VHSURQXQ HvPSRWULYDUH]LVWHQ HLDUPDWHvQ FD] GH DJUHVLXQH VRYLHWLF 'XS WHUPLQDUHD GH]EDWHULORU JXYHUQXO URPkQDFHUXWvQF RGDW FHOXLVRYLHWLFV LQGLFHÄORFXOúLGDWDFHGRUHúWH V IL[H]H´ SHQWUX WUDWDWLYH 0RVFRYD QX GRUHD vQV DFHVW OXFUX /D IHO %HUOLQXO GH XQGH -RDFNLP YRQ 5LEEHQWURS D VI WXLW GLQ QRX JXYHUQXO URPkQV DFFHSWHFHUHULOHUXVHúWLÄI U QLFLRUH]HUY ´ &RQVLGHUkQG U VSXQVXO JXYHUQXOXL URPkQ FD ÄLPSUHFLV´ 90 0RORWRYDvQPkQDWOXL*KHRUJKH'DYLGHVFXODLXQLHRUDXQQRX XOWLPDWXPSULQFDUHVHFHUHDFDvQSDWUX]LOHV VHHYDFXH]HWHULWRULXO %DVDUDELHL úL %XFRYLQHL GH WUXSHOH URPkQH vQ DFHODúL WLPS WHULWRULXO PHQ LRQDW XUPkQG D IL RFXSDW GH WUXSHOH VRYLHWLFH OD LXQLH DFHVWHD WUHEXLDXV LQWUHvQ&HUQ X L&KLúLQ XúL&HWDWHD$OE &XRRU vQDLQWH GHWHUPHQXOIL[DWDPEDVDGRUXOURPkQDUHPLVQRXOU VSXQVDOJXYHUQXOXL URPkQSULQFDUHDFHVWDSUHFL]DF ÄSHQWUXDHYLWDJUDYHOHXUP ULSHFDUH OHDUDYHDUHFXUJHUHDODIRU úLGHVFKLGHUHDRVWLOLW LORUvQDFHDVW SDUWHD (XURSHL VH YHGH VLOLW V SULPHDVF FRQGL LLOH GH HYDFXDUH VXEOLQLHUHD DXWRUXOXL VSHFLILFDWH vQ U VSXQVXO VRYLHWLF´ ,QYRFkQGXVH FRQGL LLOH PHWHRúLVLWXD LDF LORUGHFRPXQLFD LHVDVROLFLWDWSUHOXQJLUHDWHUPHQXOXL GH HYDFXDUH /D IHO GH SURPSW 90 0RORWRY D LQIRUPDW F vQDLQWDUHD WUXSHORUVRYLHWLFHXUPDV vQFHDS ODRUHOHF vQVLWXD LDvQFDUHÄGLQ PRWLYHWHKQLFH´VDUILLPSXVXQHOHSUHOXQJLULGHWHUPHQGHÄFkWHYDRUH´ DFHVW OXFUX XUPD V ILH GHFLV GH JHQHUDOLL .RVORY úL %ROGLQ &D ORF GH vQWkOQLUHDGHOHJD LORUURPkQLúLVRYLHWLFLDSURSXVRUDúXO2GHVVD
'XS FXPDYHDV FRQVHPQH]HDSRL&DURODO,,OHDGRDUGLQFHL SUH]HQ L OD úHGLQ VDX SURQXQ DW SHQWUX UH]LVWHQ 1LFRODH ,RUJD 9LFWRU ,DPDQGL6LOYLX'UDJRPLU´7UDLDQ3RSùWHIDQ&LREDQX(UQHVW8UG UHDQX ÌQFHSkQGFXRUHOHGXS RUD0RVFRYHL
ÌQ UHDOLWDWH vQDLQWH GH SULPLUHD U VSXQVXOXL GLQ SDUWHD JXYHUQXOXL URPkQWUXSHVRYLHWLFHDXIRU DW1LVWUXvQGLIHULWH]RQHúLDXOXDWSR]L LL GH OXSW vQ ID D FHORU URPkQH /D RUD S WUXQGHDX GHMD vQ &HUQ X L RFXSD LD ILLQG ILQDOL]DW vQDLQWHD WHUPHQXOXL VWDELOLW $FHVW OXFUX D FUHDW PDULGLILFXOW LDXWRULW LORUURPkQHvQGLULMDUHDSURFHVXOXLGHHYDFXDUHúL PDLDOHVSRSXOD LHLFLYLOHFDUHVHUHIXJLD'DF SHUIHFWDGHY UDWHVWHIDSWXO F UHWUDJHUHD GLQ %DVDUDELD úL QRUGXO %XFRYLQHL QX VD I FXW vQ FRQGL LL QRUPDOH GLQ FDX]D WUXSHORU VRYLHWLFH FDUH QX DX DúWHSWDW FD DXWRULW LOH FLYLOHúLPLOLWDUHV S U VHDVF WHULWRULXOWRWDWkWGHDGHY UDWHVWHúLIDSWXO F QXPHURDVHOHGHIHF LXQLDS UXWHvQWLPSXOHYDFX ULLLVWRULFHORUSURYLQFLL URPkQHúWLVDGDWRUDWPRGXOXLvQFDUHDFHVWHDLQFOXVLYXQLW LOHPLOLWDUH DXDF LRQDW 2FXSDUHDS U LLGHQRUGYHVWD5RPkQLHLGHF WUH8QJDULD &RQFRPLWHQWFXDJUHVLXQHDVRYLHWLF 8QJDULDúLDLQWHQVLILFDWúLHD SUHVLXQLOH SHQWUX RFXSDUHD XQHL FkW PDL PDUL S U L GLQ 7UDQVLOYDQLD 0RPHQWXO SURSLFH D IRVW FRQVLGHUDW D IL VRVLW vQ LXQLH vQ WLPSXO FUL]HLURPkQRVRYLHWLFHFkQGvQFDGUXOFRQWDFWHORUGLSORPDWLFHJXYHUQXO GH OD %XGDSHVWD D UHXúLW V RE LQ UHFRQILUPDUHD DMXWRUXOXL GLQ SDUWHD JXYHUQHORUGHOD%HUOLQ5RPDúL0RVFRYD ÌQvQFHUFDUHDGHDHYLWDXQDWDFúLGLQSDUWHD8QJDULHLúL%XOJDULHL &DURODO,,OHDDFHUXWODLXQLH FD*HUPDQLDV H[HUFLWHÄRLQIOX HQ PRGHUDWRDUH´DVXSUDDFHVWRUD/DUkQGXLvQDFHHDúL]LDPEDVDGRUXO XQJDU OD %HUOLQ D vQDLQWDW OXL (UQVW :RHUPDQQ GLUHFWRU PLQLVWHULDO OD 'HSDUWDPHQWXOSROLWLFDO0LQLVWHUXOXLGH([WHUQHJHUPDQXQ0HPRUDQ GXPvQFDUHVHDU WDF vQFRQGL LLOHvQFDUH5RPkQLDDUILI FXWFRQFHVLL WHULWRULDOH 8QLXQLL 6RYLHWLFH JXYHUQXO XQJDU FRQVLGHUD DFHVW OXFUX GUHSW
5HOHYDQWvQDFHVWVHQVHVWHGRFXPHQWXOHODERUDWODLXOLH GH F WUHúHIXO0DUHOXL6WDW0DMRUURPkQFDUHFRQGDPQDFXLQGLJQDUHIDSWXOF ÄXQLLRIL HULVDXO VDWLQVXOWD LGH]DUPD LúLFKLDUGHJUDGD LGHEDQGHFLYLOH I U V VFKL H]H XQ JHVW GH UHDF LXQH´ 6FX]HOH F DFHDVW DWLWXGLQH D IRVW SURYRFDW GHGRULQ DGHÄDQXSURYRFDLQFLGHQWHFXWUXSHOHVRYLHWLFH´QXDX IRVW OXDWH vQ FRQVLGHUDUH GH F WUH JHQHUDOXO )ORUHD HQHVFX GHRDUHFH FRQVL GHUDHOÄQLPHQLQXSRDWHGDXQRUGLQFDRQRDUHDV QXILHDS UDW ´
ÄRGLVFULPLQDUHIODJUDQW vPSRWULYD8QJDULHLDOF UXLHIHFWSHQWUXRSLQLD SXEOLF YD GXFH FKLDU OD FRQVHFLQ H LPSUHYL]LELOH´ ÌQ SRILGD VIDWXOXL RIHULWGH-RDFNLPYRQ5LEEHQWURSGHDÄS VWUDSDFHD´JXYHUQXOXQJDUD GHFLV PRELOL]DUHD JHQHUDO úL D VSRULW IRU HOH FRQFHQWUDWH OD IURQWLHUD FX 5RPkQLD /DLXOLH GXS FH8QLXQHD6RYLHWLF DRFXSDW%DVDUDELDúL SDUWHDGHQRUGD%XFRYLQHL+LWOHUDVXJHUDWOXL&DURODO,,OHDV vQFHDS QHJRFLHUL FX 8QJDULD úL %XOJDULD vQ SUREOHPD ÄUHYL]XLULORU WHULWRULDOH´ 5 VSXQ]kQG)KUHUXOXLODLXOLHUHJHOHURPkQDDU WDWF HUDGHDFRUG FXÄLQL LHUHDQHJRFLHULORU´FXJXYHUQHOHXQJDUúLEXOJDUSURQXQ kQGXVH SHQWUXÄRVWU PXWDUHUHFLSURF H[WHQVLY GHSRSXOD LL´SHSULQFLSLXOHWQLF vQ FRQGL LL ELQH GHWHUPLQDWH 1HPXO XPLW GH DFHVW U VSXQV +LWOHU D UH SOLFDWGXUODLXOLHFkQGDI FXWFXQRVFXWF RULFHvQFHUFDUHGHDÄHYLWD SHULFROHOH´ FDUH SODQDX DVXSUD 5RPkQLHL SULQ ÄPDQHYUH WDFWLFH GH RULFH IHO´HUDVRUWLW HúHFXOXLÄ0DLGHYUHPHVDXPDLWkU]LX±SUHFL]DFDQFHODUXO JHUPDQ±úLSUREDELOvQWUXQWLPSIRDUWHVFXUWUH]XOWDWXODUSXWHDILFKLDU GLVWUXJHUHD 5RPkQLHL´ 5HFRPDQGkQG vPS FDUHD ÄGH EXQ FUHGLQ ´ FX 8QJDULDúL%XOJDULDHODILUPDDSRLF ÄRUHYL]XLUHDGHYHQLWLQHYLWDELO ´úL DDWUDVDWHQ LDF vQFD]GHUHIX]*HUPDQLDÄQXYDPDLPDQLIHVWDQLFLXQ LQWHUHV ID GH GH]YROWDUHD XOWHULRDU D HYHQLPHQWHORU GLQ VXGHVWXO (XURSHL´ 5 VSXQVXOOXL&DURODO,,OHDúLLPSOLFLWDOJXYHUQXOXLURPkQDIRVW WUDQVPLVODLXOLH FXSULOHMXOYL]LWHLSHFDUH,RQ*LJXUWXSULPXO PLQLVWUXúL0LKDLO0DQRLOHVFXPLQLVWUXO$IDFHULORU6WU LQHDXI FXWRvQ *HUPDQLD &X DFHO SULOHM UHJHOH URPkQ VXJHUD vQ VFULVRDUHD DGUHVDW )KUHUXOXL F UHJOHPHQWDUHD GLIHUHQGHORU GLQWUH 5RPkQLD 8QJDULD úL %XOJDULD WUHEXLD V VH IDF ÄVLPXOWDQ FX WRDWH FHOHODOWH DUDQMDPHQWH FH VXQWvQSHUVSHFWLY vQHVWXOHXURSHDQúLFDUHVXQWGHVWLQDWHvQFRQFHS LD $[HLV UHDOL]H]HXQHFKLOLEUXPDLGUHSWúLPDLGXUDELOvQDFHDVW SDUWHD OXPLL´ &RQVLGHUkQG F vQ DERUGDUHD DFHVWRU SUREOHPH WUHEXLD V SUHGR PLQHSXQFWXOGHYHGHUHDOÄGUHSW LLILHF UXLSRSRU´&DURODO,,OHDI FHD FXQRVFXW F 5RPkQLD QX VH SXWHD DEDWH QLFL R FOLS GH OD ÄSULQFLSLXO HWQLF´ FDUH SXWHD IL VROX LRQDW vQ PDUH P VXU SULQ ÄVFKLPEXUL GH SRSXOD LH´vQDFHVWVFRSILLQGQHFHVDU ÄLQWHUYHQ LD´SHUPDQHQW DSXWH ULORU$[HLúLQXÄDUELWUDMXO´DFHVWRUDSHFDUHJXYHUQXOURPkQQXOGRUHD &RQIRUP 1RWHL vQWRFPLW GH 3DXO 6FKPLGW WUDQVODWRUXO OXL +LWOHU SUHV WD LDFHORUGRLGHPQLWDULURPkQLvQGLVFX LDDYXW FX+LWOHUDIRVWODPHQ
WDELO ,RQ*LJXUWXGHFODUkQGF 5RPkQLDHUDÄSUHJ WLW SHQWUXFRQFHVLL´ F JXYHUQXOURPkQVSHUDFDFHLGRLYHFLQLUHYL]LRQLúWLV ILHÄUH]RQDELOL´ úL V úL IRUPXOH]H SUHWHQ LLOH ÄvQ QLúWH OLPLWH FDUH V SHUPLW RE LQHUHD XQHLVW ULGHSDFHvQ%DOFDQL´ÌQWUHEDWFHVXSUDID HUDSUHJ WLWJXYHUQXO URPDQV FHGH]H8QJDULHL,RQ*LJXUWXDURVWLWFLIUDGHNPS 3HUFHSkQG DGHY UDWXO VHQV DO PHVDMXOXL JHUPDQ &DURO DO ,,OHD D GHFLV OD DXJXVW V vQFHDS QHJRFLHULOH FX %XGDSHVWD SRUQLQG GH OD SULQFLSLXOF QXVHYDDGPLWHÄRHYHQWXDO PRGLILFDUHDVLWXD LHLDFWXDOH GHFkWED]DW SHSULQFLSLXOXQXLVFKLPEGHSRSXOD LHvQED]DF UXLDQLFLXQ URPkQQXDUXUPDV WUHDF VXEVW SkQLUHDXQJXUHDVF ´ÌQDFHHDúL]LvQV 7HOHNL 3iO D vQDLQWDW XQ 3UR0HPRULD OXL %HQLWR 0XVVROLQL SULQ FDUH VH I FHDFXQRVFXWF 8QJDULDUHVSLQJHDLGHHDRULF UXLVFKLPEGHSRSXOD LH FX5RPkQLDúLFHUHDVSULMLQLWDOLDQSHQWUXÄDQH[DUHDvQWUHJLL7UDQVLOYDQLL úLVWDELOLUHDIURQWLHUHLGLQWUH5RPkQLDúL8QJDULDSHvQWUHJXODUFFDUSDWLF´ Ä*UDQL D&DUSD LORU±PDLPHQ LRQDSULPXOPLQLVWUXXQJDUFDúLFXPVDU ILUHIHULWODFXUVXO7LVHL±HVWHGHQHVFKLPEDW´2V SW PkQ PDLWkU]LX +RUW\0LNORVDYHDV GHFODUHúLHOOXL+LWOHU Ä6W SkQLUHD&DUSD LORUHVWH SHQWUX QRL R SUREOHP YLWDO ´ ùWLLQG SUHFLV FH GRUHD úL XUP ULQG FX IHUPLWDWHvQGHSOLQLUHDRELHFWLYHORUJXYHUQXOGHOD%XGDSHVWDDGHFODUDWF UHOD LLOHFXJXYHUQXOURPkQQXHUDXGHQDWXU ÄPLQRULWDU ´FLÄWHULWRULDO ´ úL D UHVSLQV GH OD vQFHSXW LGHHD VFKLPEXOXL GH SRSXOD LH FX FDUH VD DP JLW R YUHPH JXYHUQXO URPkQ &RQFRPLWHQW GLSORPD LD XQJDU D DFUHGLWDWLGHHDF vQUHOD LLOHFXURPkQLLQXVHSXWHDGLVFXWDGHFkWÄSULQ IRU ´ $FHVW OXFUX D UHLHúLW FX FODULWDWH úL GLQ $LGH0pPRLUHXO vQDLQWDW JXYHUQXOXL URPkQ OD DXJXVW vQWRFPLW úL GDWDW vQV DXJXVW DFHODúLDQvQWLPSXOYL]LWHLGHOD%XGDSHVWDDOXL5DRXO%RVV\ SOLQGH QHDGHY UXUL LVWRULFH úL MLJQLWRU OD DGUHVD 5RPkQLHL SULQ FDUH VH DU WD F ÄQX YD IL SDFH úL vQ HOHJHUH VLQFHU vQWUH 8QJDULD úL 5RPkQLD I U UH]ROYDUHDSUREOHPHORUWHULWRULDOH´ÌQDFHVWVHQV8QJDULDHUDGLVSXV ÄV IDF VDFULILFLL IRDUWH VHULRDVH´ úL V DFFHSWH DSRL LGHHD ÄVFKLPEXOXL GH SRSXOD LH´ XQJXULLúLURPkQLL GHSHvQWUHJXOFXSULQVDOFHORUGRX VWDWH DIOD LvQDFHDVW VLWXD LHXUPkQGV ILHFRQVXOWD LúLV úLH[SULPHGRULQ D vQFDUH DU GRUHDXV ORFXLDVF vQFRQWLQXDUH ÌQGRFXPHQWXOVLPLODUvQWRFPLWvQDFHHDúL]L DXJXVW JXYHUQXO URPkQDDSUHFLDWF ÄGHSODVDUHDGHIURQWLHU QXSRDWHILRSRUWXQ GHFkWvQ P VXUD vQ FDU SRDWH P UL VSD LXO YLWDO DO VWDWHORU FDUH DX GH UHSDWULDW vQ FDGUXOORUWHULWRULDOFRQD LRQDOLFDUHVDUDIODvQFDGUXOWHULWRULDODOXQXLDOW
VWDW´'HRDUHFHDFHVWFULWHULXIDYRUL]D8QJDULDJXYHUQXOGHOD%XGDSHVWD ODDFFHSWDWúLDI FXWFXQRVFXWDGRXD]LF DFFHSW GLVFX LLOHELODWHUDOH ÌQFHSXWH OD DXJXVW OD 7XUQX 6HYHULQ WUDWDWLYHOH URPkQR XQJDUH DX LQWUDW vQ LPSDV GH OD vQFHSXW GHRDUHFH +RU\ $QGUiV úHIXO GHOHJD LHL XQJDUH D SUH]HQWDW XQ DOW $LGH0pPRLUH SULQ FDUH JXYHUQXO XQJDUSURSXQHDÄRvPS U LUHDWHULWRULXOXLvQOLWLJLX´8QJDULHLXUPkQGV L UHYLQ FRQIRUPK U LLDQH[DWH NPS WUHLS WULPLGLQ7UDQVLOYDQLD ORFXL L GH GH ORFXLWRUL GLQ FDUH HUDX URPkQL 5HVSLQJkQG DFHDVW ÄQHEXQHDVF ´ GXS 0LKDLO 0DQRLOHVFX SURSXQHUH XQJDU 9DOHU 3RS úHIXO GHOHJD LHL URPkQH D SURSXV vQWUHUXSHUHD GLVFX LLORU SkQ OD DXJXVW /D UHOXDUHD DFHVWRUD D I FXW FXQRVFXW F PHPRULXO XQJDU GLQ DXJXVW GRYHGHD ÄLQFRPSDWLELOLWDWHD WRWDO ´ D FRQFHS LHLXQJDUHFXFHDURPkQ F SURSXQHUHDXQJDU YL]DRIURQWLHU ÄFXWRWXODUELWUDU ´FDUHQXGHFXUJHDÄGLQQLFLXQSULQFLSLX´&RQVLGHUkQG FHUHUHDXQJDU FDILLQGÄH[RUELWDQW ´úHIXOGHOHJD LHLURPkQHDVXV LQXW SULQFLSLXOÄVFKLPEXOXLGHSRSXOD LH´/DUHOXDUH+RU\$QGUiVDVXV LQXW SXQFWXO GH YHGHUH DO JXYHUQXOXL XQJDU GHFODUkQG F I U PRGLILFDUHD IURQWLHUHL ÄRULFH GLVFX LH DU IL OLSVLW GH HOHPHQWHOH LQGLVSHQVDELOH XQHL QHJRFLHUL XWLOH úL VHULRDVH´ ÌQ UHSOLF 9DOHU 3RS D UHDILUPDW F GDF JXYHUQXOXQJDUGRUHDÄUHSDWULHUHDXQJXULORUGLQ$UGHDO´GLVFX LLOHSXWHDX FRQWLQXD $OWIHO QX F FL ÄFkW YUHPH H[LVW R 5RPkQLH úL R DUPDW URPkQ WH]HOH WHULWRULDOH QX VH GLVFXW úL QLFL S PkQW URPkQHVF QX VH FHGHD] -DPDLV i WRXW MDPDLV´ /D vQFHUFDUHD OXL +RU\ $QGUiV GH D VH GLVFXWD FHO SX LQ DVXSUD WHULWRULXOXL ORFXLW GH VHFXL úHIXO GHOHJD LHL URPkQHDGHFODUDWF úLDFHDVWDÄIDFHSDUWHvQPRGRUJDQLFGLQS PkQWXO URPkQHVFúLDVXSUDFHG ULLOXLQXVHSRDWHQLFLQHJRFLDQLFLDMXQJHODXQ DFRUGQLFLRGDW ´'DF vQV %XGDSHVWDGRUHDV LDLE SHVHFXLSXWHDV L LQFOXG vQSUREOHPDVFKLPEXOXLGHSRSXOD LH,QVLVWkQGDVXSUDPRGLILF ULL IURQWLHUHLURPkQRXQJDUHúHIXOGHOHJD LHLXQJDUHDUXJDWvQDLQWHGHDVH GHSODVD OD %XGDSHVWD SHQWUX LQIRUPDUHD JXYHUQXOXL V X V L VH GHD FHO SX LQ ÄR YDJ LPDJLQH´ DVXSUD QRXOXL FRQWXU DO DFHVWHLD vQ XUPD VFKLPEXOXLGHSRSXOD LH,VDU VSXQVF DFHVWOXFUXVHSXWHDúWLÄvQPDL SX LQGHGHRUH´GXS FH8QJDULDYDDFFHSWDGHILQLWLYSULQFLSLXOHWQLF úLYDIDFHFXQRVFXWQXP UXOGHXQJXULSHFDUHGRUHDV OSULPHDVF GLQ $UGHDO 5HYHQLWOD%XFXUHúWLPLQLVWUXOSOHQLSRWHQ LDOJHUPDQDGHFODUDWOXL 9DOHU3RSúL0LKDLO0DQRLOHVFXODDXJXVWF SHQWUX5RPkQLDH[LVWDX
GRDU GRX VROX LL XQD PLQLPDO ± FHGDUHD D FLUFD NPS I U MXGH XO $UDG DOWD PD[LPDO ± FLUFD NPS FX MXGH XO $UDG 5RPkQLL DX U VSXQV F DPEHOH VROX LL HUDX H[DJHUDWH ÌQ DFHHDúL ]L OD %HOJUDG PLQLVWUXO SOHQLSRWHQ LDO XQJDU D vQWUHEDW GLUHFW GDF %XGDSHVWD SXWHD FRQWD SH QHXWUDOLWDWHD ELQHYRLWRDUH D ,XJRVODYLHL vQ FD]XO XQXL FRQIOLFWDUPDWFX5RPkQLD ÌQWRUV úL HO GH OD %XGDSHVWD +RU\ $QGUiV D I FXW FXQRVFXW OD DXJXVWOD7XUQX6HYHULQOXL9DOHU3RSF JXYHUQXOXQJDUÄQXYUHDQLFL QXSRDWHIDFHV HPLJUH]HVHFXLLGHODYHWUHOHORUQLFLRGDW úLVXEQLFLR FRQGL LH´ $SRL D vQWUHEDW WUDQúDQW GDF 5RPkQLD GRUHúWH VDX QX V ÄGHVHPQH]HWHULWRULLOHSHFDUHHVWHJDWDDOHUHWURFHGD8QJDULHL´vQFD]GH UHIX]QHJRFLHULOHQHPDLDYkQGXúLURVWXO/DIHOGHIHUPDIRVWúLU VSXQVXO OXL9DOHU3RSFDUHDGHFODUDWvQFRQIRUPLWDWHFXGHFL]LD&RQVLOLXOXLGH &RURDQ GLQDXJXVW Ä1XSXWHPOXDvQFRQVLGHUD LHQLFLDVW ]LúLQLFL vQYLLWRUSURSXQHULFDUHWUHFVXEVW SkQLUHVWU LQ FKLDUúLQXPDLXQVLQJXU URPDQ´ ÌQFHUFkQG V RE LQ FRQWLQXDUHD GLVFX LLORU PLQLVWUXO URPkQ GH ([WHUQHDFHUXWOXL9DOHU3RSV ILHPDLFRQFLOLDQWúLV FRPXQLFHOXL+RU\ $QGUiVF vQFXUkQGSDUWHDURPkQ YDSUH]HQWDSURSXQHULFRQFUHWHúLvQ FHHDFHSULYHDWHULWRULXOFHXUPDV ILHFHGDW'XS PDLPXOWHGLVFX LLvQ FRQWUDGLFWRULX 0LKDLO 0DQRLOHVFX D DFFHSWDW SXQFWXO GH YHGHUH VXV LQXW GH9DOHU3RSvQGLVFX LLOHFX+RU\$QGUiV7RWXúLFXSULOHMXOUHvQWkOQLULL GLQWUH FHL GRL QHJRFLDWRUL 9DOHU 3RS D IRUPXODW R QRX SURSXQHUH URPkQHDVF vQXUP WRULLWHUPHQL Ä*XYHUQXOURPkQHVWHGLVSXVDIDFHR SURSXQHUH vQVR LW GH R KDUW FX LQGLFDUHD IURQWLHUHL UH]XOWkQG GLQ DSOLFDUHDVFKLPEXOXLGHSRSXOD LHSHQWUXWR LXQJXULLGLQ$UGHDOvQDIDU GHVHFXLÌQWLQGHUHDWHULWRULDO DSURSXQHULL5RPkQLHLHVWHvQPRGDEVROXW FRQGL LRQDW GH HIHFWLYD GHSODVDUH D DFHVWRU XQJXUL GLQ $UGHDO I U GH FDUHFRQWUDSURSXQHUHDQRDVWU QXDUHQLFLXQVHQVúLQLFLRYDODELOLWDWH´ÌQ ILQDOODGRULQ DGHOHJDWXOXLXQJDUGLVFX LLOHDXIRVWGHFODUDWHvQFKLVHFHOH GRX GHOHJD LLS U VLQGvQFXUVXOQRS LLGHVSUHDXJXVWRUDúXO7XUQX 6HYHULQ 3UHRFXSDW vQV GH FXUVXO SH FDUH XUPD V O LD ÄFRQWURYHUVD´ URPkQRXQJDU úL GRULQG ÄV HYLWH FX RULFH SUH R FUL] vQ %DOFDQL´ -RDFNLPYRQ5LEEHQWURSDSURSXVOXL*DOHD]]R&LDQRODDXJXVWV ILH FRQYRFD LOD9LHQDPLQLúWULLGH([WHUQHURPkQúLXQJDUXQGHV OLVHGHD ÄVIDWXULOH DPLFDOH´ DOH $[HL vQ YHGHUHD J VLULL XQHL VROX LL 'LSORPDWXO JHUPDQDPDLSUHFL]DWF RIHUWDWUHEXLDvQVR LW úLGHXQÄDYHUWLVPHQW´vQ
VHQVXOF ÄFHOFDUHQXDFFHSW VIDWXOLDDVXSUDVDvQWUHDJDUHVSRQVDELOLWDWH D FRQVHFLQ HORU YLLWRDUH´ &XQRVFkQG LQWHUHVXO *HUPDQLHL SHQWUX PHQ LQHUHD OLQLúWLL vQ HVWXO (XURSHL úL GkQGXúL VHDPD F SUHWHQ LLOH %XGDSHVWHLQXVHSXWHDXUHDOL]DGHFkWSULQWUXQDUELWUDMGLFWDWDOSXWHULORU $[HL 8QJDULD D UHFXUV OD úDQWDM O VkQG V VH vQ HOHDJ F YD DWDFD 5RPkQLD 3HQWUX D LQFLWD VSLULWHOH DYLRDQH XQJDUH DX ]EXUDW GHDVXSUD WHULWRULXOXLURPkQHVFSkQ OD%UDúRY &RQFRPLWHQW FRQYRFDW GH XUJHQ vQ *HUPDQLD OD DXJXVW :LOKHOP )DEULFLXV D LQGLFDW OXL -RDFNLP YRQ 5LEEHQWURS R OLQLH GH GHPDUFD LHURPkQRXQJDU SULQFDUH5RPkQLDSLHUGHDXQHOHUHJLXQLGHOD JUDQL D YHVWLF &RQVLGHUkQG F WHULWRULXO RIHULW 8QJDULHL HUD SUHD PLF PLQLVWUXO GH ([WHUQH JHUPDQ D DG XJDW úL RUDúXO &OXM GXS FDUH &DUO &ORGLXVDSXOVDWSHQWUX8QJDULDUHXúLQGV úLFRQYLQJ LQWHUORFXWRULLF úL UHJLXQHD VHFXLDVF WUHEXLD ÄV DSDU LQ QHDS UDW 8QJDULHL´ 3XQkQG SH SULPSODQLQWHUHVHOHJHUPDQH+LWOHUDYHDV GHFLG vQILQDOF QRXDOLQLH GH GHPDUFD LH URPkQRXQJDU WUHEXLD V DVLJXUH VW SkQLUHD SULQ LQWHUPHGLXO8QJDULHL DFUHVWHORU&DUSD LORU2ULHQWDOLS WUXQGHUHDSkQ vQ DSURSLHUH GH %UDúRY SHQWUX D ÄSURWHMD´ ]RQD SHWUROLIHU &RQFRPLWHQW 8QJDULD úL 5RPkQLD WUHEXLDX GH]ELQDWH vQ DúD IHO vQFkW V ILH LQXWH FD ÄGRX EXF L GH ILHU LQFDQGHVFHQWH úL GH D OH PRGHOD vQ LQWHUHVXO *HUPDQLHL´DúDFXPDYHDV UHFXQRDVF úL-RDFNLPYRQ5LEEHQWURSÌQ DFHVWVFRSVDGHFLVV QXVHSRDUWHGLVFX LLFXQLFLXQDGLQWUHFHOHGRX GHOHJD LL FL ÄOD XQ PRPHQW GDW´ V OL VH VXSXQ ÄR KDUW FRPXQ JHUPDQRLWDOLDQ ´ FX OLQLD GH GHPDUFD LH FDUH ÄV QX PDL FRQVWLWXLH XQ VXELHFWGHGLVFX LH´2GDW VWDELOLW SURFHGXUDFHLGRLPLQLúWULGH([WHUQH DL$[HLDXvPSDFKHWDWKDUWDúLVDXGHSODVDWvQVHDUD]LOHLFXDYLRQXOVSUH 9LHQD3HQWUXDVHHYLWDRULFHVXUSUL] *HUPDQLDDLQWHQVLILFDWSUHJ WLULOH PLOLWDUH ÌQDOWXO FRPDQGDPHQW DO :HKUPDFKWXOXL RUGRQkQG vQ FRQIRUPLWDWHFXGLUHFWLYHOHGDWHGH+LWOHUODDXJXVWFDvQWUHL]LOHV ILH SUHJ WLWH SDWUX GLYL]LL EOLQGDWH GRX GLYL]LL PRWRUL]DWH XQLW L GH SDUDúXWLúWL úL WUXSH DHURSXUWDWH SHQWUX D RFXSD ]RQD SHWUROLIHU GH OD 3ORLHúWL ÌQDFHHDúL]LDXJXVWPLQLVWUXOURPkQGH([WHUQHDIRVWLQYLWDW V SDUWLFLSHOD VHSWHPEULHOD9LHQDODÄRFRQYRUELUH´DVXSUDUHOD LLORU URPkQRXQJDUHSHQWUXDFHDVWDWUHEXLQGV ILHvQV UFLQDWFXGHSOLQHSXWHUL &RQYLQVF OD9LHQDXUPDXV DLE ORFQHJRFLHUL&DURODO,,OHDDFHUXW GHOHJD LHL URPkQH V DF LRQH]H SHQWUX DSOLFDUHD SULQFLSLXOXL HWQLF úL D
VFKLPEXOXL GH SRSXOD LH OXkQG vQ FDOFXO úL OLPLWHOH HYHQWXDOHL FHG UL WHULWRULDOH vQWUHúLNPS ÌQ GXS DPLD]D ]LOHL GH DXJXVW OD 9LHQD -RDFNLP YRQ 5LEEHQWURSDSURSXVOXL0LKDLO0DQRLOHVFXV DFFHSWHDUELWUDMXOSXWHULORU $[HL SURFHGXU QHVROLFLWDW GH JXYHUQXO URPkQ GXS FDUH vQ WHUPHQL ÄLPSUHVLRQDQ LGHDS VD L´DYRUELWGHÄDWDFXOFRQFRPLWHQW´DO5XVLHLúLDO 8QJDULHLFDGHÄXQOXFUXFHDUILvQ HOHVvQWUHDFHúWLD´úLDDWUDVDWHQ LDF GDF UHJHOH&DURODO,,OHDÄDUILU XVI WXLWúLQXDUSULPLDFHVWDUELWUDM DWXQFLDUILvQFkWHYD]LOHVIkUúLWXO5RPkQLHL´$SRLDSUHFL]DWFDJXYHUQXO URPkQV QXLQWHUSUHWH]HDFHVWOXFUXFDSHÄXQEOXISHQWUXF )KUHUXOQX IDFH EOXI´ /D UkQGXL *DOHD]]R &LDQR D SUHFL]DW úL HO F D IRVW vPSXWHUQLFLWGH%HQLWR0XVVROLQLV IDF FXQRVFXWF GDF 5RPkQLDQXDU DFFHSWD DUELWUDMXO DWXQFL YD IL VRFRWLW SULQWUH ÄGXúPDQLL´ $[HL &RQVWLWXLDXWRDWHDFHVWHDDPHQLQ ULGLUHFWHDúDFXPDIRVWúLGHFODUD LD I FXW GH:LOKHOP)DEULFLXVOXL9DOHU3RSF vQFD]GHU ]ERL*HUPDQLD úL ,WDOLD XUPDX V ILH GH SDUWHD 8QJDULHL 'XS FH 0LKDLO 0DQRLOHVFX D UHVSLQVvQF RGDW LGHHDDUELWUDMXOXL-RDFNLPYRQ5LEHQWURSDUHSOLFDWF VROX LDODFDUHWUHEXLDV VHDMXQJ WUHEXLDV ILHÄRVLQWH] vQWUHSULQFLSLXO WHULWRULDOúLSULQFLSLXOHWQLF´úLDSUHFL]DWF WHULWRULXOFHWUHEXLDFHGDWGH F WUH 5RPkQLD VH VLWXD vQWUH NPS FkW D FHUXW 8QJDULD úL NPSFkWDRIHULW5RPkQLD/DSUHFL]DUHDPLQLVWUXOXLURPkQDO$IDFHULORU 6WU LQHF ÄQRLQDPYRUELWQLFLRGDW GHDúDFHYD´RPRORJXOJHUPDQD VSXV F ÄvQ FD] FRQWUDU YH L IDFH U ]ERL úL YH L SLHUGH WRDW 7UDQVLOYDQLD´ ÌQ ILQDO DúD FXP DYHD V SUHFL]H]H PDL WkU]LX 0LKDLO 0DQRLOHDVFXÄDUELWULL´DXSXVXUP WRDUHDDOWHUQDWLY Ä6DXSULPLPDUEL WUDMXODVW ]LVDXFHOPDLWkU]LXvQFXUVXOQRS LLDúDFDPkLQHV VHSRDW GD KRW UkUHD úL vQ FD]XO DFHVWD QH YRP EXFXUD GH JDUDQ LD DEVROXW D SXWHULORU$[HLSHQWUXLQWHJULWDWHD5RPkQLHLvPSRWULYDWXWXURUFKLDUúLOD 5 V ULWVDXGDF QXSULPLPYRPILPkLQHDWDFD LGH8QJDULDúL5XVLDúL YDILVIkUúLWXO5RPkQLHL´ ÌQWUXQ DVHPHQHD FRQWH[W OD %XFXUHúWL &RQVLOLXO GH &RURDQ vQWUXQLW GXS PLH]XO QRS LL D GHFLV FX GH YRWXUL DFFHSWDUHD
(URDUHD OXL -RDFNLP YRQ 5LEEHQWURS SULYLQG VXSUDID D GH WHULWRULX NPS SH FDUH DU IL IRVW GLVSXV JXYHUQXO URPkQ V R FHGH]H D IRVW UHFXQRVFXW GH:LOKHOP)DEULFLXVvQFXUVXOQRS LL
ÄDUELWUDMXOXL´ vQ UHDOLWDWH D GLFWDWXOXL SXWHULORU $[HL GHFL]LD ILLQG FRPXQLFDW OD9LHQDODRUD&HDXUPDWDIRVWRVLPSO IRUPDOLWDWH 'HOHJD LLORUURPkQ úLXQJDU OHDDIRVWSUH]HQWDWWH[WXOGRFXPHQWXOXLGH ÄDUELWUDM´ úL KDUWD FDUH GHOLPLWD WHULWRULXO URPkQ FDUH IXVHVH RIHULW SULQ SUHVLXQH úL GLFWDW 8QJDULHL 'RFXPHQWXO LPSXV PDL SUHFL]D GHOLPL WDUHDSHWHUHQDYLLWRDUHLÄIURQWLHUH´HUDvQFUHGLQ DW XQHLFRPLVLLURPkQR XQJDUH WHULWRULXO RIHULW 8QJDULHL XUPD V ILH HYDFXDW GH F WUH WUXSHOH URPkQHvQWUXQWHUPHQGH]LOHúLSUHGDWÄvQVWDUHDGHRUGLQHFXYHQLW ´ HWDSHOHHYDFX ULLúLRFXS ULLHWFXUPkQGDILVWDELOLWHGHF WUHRFRPLVLH URPkQRXQJDU úLDVHGHVI úXUDvQÄSHUIHFW OLQLúWHúLRUGLQH´VXEDWHQWD VXSUDYHJKHUHDFHORUGRX JXYHUQH WR LFHW HQLLURPkQLDIOD LvQWHULWRULXO ÄFHGDW´XUPDXV GREkQGHDVF GHGUHSWFHW HQLDXQJDU HLSXWkQGRSWD vQOXQLSHQWUXFHW HQLDURPkQ úLV UHYLQ DSRLvQ5RPkQLDvQWUXQDQ OXkQG DVXSUD ORU DYHUHD PRELO úL SXWkQG V OLFKLGH]H DYHUHD LPRELOLDU S VWUkQG VXPHOH UH]XOWDWH ÌQ VLWXD LD vQ FDUH QX SXWHDX V úL OLFKLGH]H DYHUHD LPRELO XUPDX V ILH GHVS JXEL L GH F WUH 8QJDULD FHW HQLL URPkQLGHHWQLHPDJKLDU FDUHQXORFXLDXvQWHULWRULXOÄFHGDW´SXWHDXV RSWH]HSHQWUXFHW HQLDPDJKLDU vQOXQLXUPkQGDEHQHILFLDGHDFHOHDúL GUHSWXUL FD úL FHW HQLL GH HWQLH URPkQ GLQ VLWXD LD H[SXV PDL VXV SUREOHPHOHDS UXWHvQH[HFXWDUHDSUHYHGHULORUÄDUELWUDMXOXL´XUPDXV ILH VROX LRQDWHGLUHFWGHF WUHJXYHUQHOHURPkQúLXQJDUvQFD]GHGH]DFRUG DVXSUDYUHXQHLFKHVWLXQLDFHDVWDXUPkQGDILVXSXV JXYHUQHORUJHUPDQúL LWDOLDQ FDUH YRU DGRSWD ÄGHFL]LL GHILQLWLYH´ &X DFHODúL SULOHM JXYHUQHOH JHUPDQ úL LWDOLDQ DX JDUDQWDW ÄLQYLRODELOLWDWHD úL LQWHJULWDWHD´ VWDWXOXL URPkQU úOXLWÄÌQIHOXODFHVWDSULQIUDXG úLSULQVXUSULQGHUHFDGHWkOKDUL vQPLH]GHFRGUX±FXPDYHDV FRQVHPQH]H5DRXO%RVV\vQPHPRULLOH VDOH±DIRVWYUHPHOQLFXFLV 5RPkQLD0DUHPDLvQWkLGH6WDOLQDSRLGH +LWOHUúL0XVVROLQLSULQXQHOWHOHORU5LEEHQWURSúL&LDQR´ $IOkQGSULQUDGLRFRQ LQXWXOGLFWDWXOXLGHOD9LHQD]HFLGHPLLGH FHW HQLURPkQLDXLHúLWSHVWU ]LVFDQGkQG Ä1LFLXQSHWLFGHS PkQW´
ÌPSRWULYD GLFWDWXOXL VDX SURQXQ DW &,& %U WLDQX ,RQ 0LKDODFKH 0LKDLO3RSRYLFL9LFWRU,DPDQGL9LFWRU$QWRQHVFX$&&X]D$UWKXU9 LWRLDQX GU&RQVWDQWLQ$QJHOHVFX6LOYLX'UDJRPLUPLWURSROLWXO1LFRODH% ODQ ÌQPRPHQWXOvQFDUHDY ]XWWUDVHXOQRLLOLQLLGHGHPDUFD LHURPkQR XQJDUH0LKDLO0DQRLOHVFXúLDSLHUGXWFRQRúWLQ D$SRLDVHPQDWGRFXPHQWXO I U V LPDLFLWHDVF FRQ LQXWXO
Ä9UHP V PXULP DS UkQGXQH IUXQWDULLOH RQRDUHD úL GHPQLWDWHD QD LR QDO ´Ä$UGHDOXOV QXILHFLXQWLW´HWF3HQWUXDSUHYHQLHYHQWXDOLWDWHDFD QHPXO XPLUHD SRSXOD LHL úL PLOLWDULORU V QX GHJHQHUH]H JHQHUDOXO *KHRUJKH0LKDLOúHIXO0DUHOXL6WDW0DMRUDHPLVXQRUGLQJHQHUDOSULQ FDUH D FHUXW FD ILHFDUH URPkQ V vQ HOHDJ F ÄYLD D úL LVWRULD QHDPXOXL URPkQHVFQXVHWHUPLQ ODDFHVWH]LOH´F SHQWUXPRPHQWÄWUHEXLHV QH UHVHPQ PúLV DúWHSW PFXOLQLúWHúLvQFUHGHUHGHVWLQHOHQHDPXOXL´ 2FXSDUHDS U LLGHVXGD'REURJHLGHF WUH%XOJDULD /DIHOFDúLJXYHUQXOXQJDUJXYHUQXOEXOJDUSURILWkQGGHVLWXD LD H[WUHP GH GLILFLO vQ FDUH VH DIOD 5RPkQLD vQ YDUD DQXOXL úLD LQWHQVLILFDWúLHOSUHVLXQLOHFXWRDWHF vQSHULRDGDLQWHUEHOLF SURPRYDVH R SROLWLF H[WHUQ SUXGHQW GLQ FDUH QX DX OLSVLW vQV PDQLIHVW ULOH UHYL]LRQLVWH 6LWXD LD 5RPkQLHL VD DJUDYDW úL GDWRULW IDSWXOXL F UHYHQGLF ULOH EXOJDUH VDX EXFXUDW GH VSULMLQXO *HUPDQLHL úL 8QLXQLL 6RYLHWLFHÌQFXUDMDWUHJHOH%RULVDO,,,OHDúLDH[SULPDWVSHUDQ DODPDL vQWUR GLVFX LH DYXW FX &DUO &ORGLXV vPSXWHUQLFLWXO HFRQRPLF DO 5HLFKXOXL SHQWUX VXGHVWXO (XURSHL F %XOJDULD vúL SXWHD vQGHSOLQL ÄRELHFWLYHOHQD LRQDOH´QXPDLDO WXULGH*HUPDQLDF U ]ERLXOQXVHYD WHUPLQDI U vPSOLQLUHDDFHVWRURELHFWLYH$FHDVW WHQGLQ DIRVWVHVL]DW GLQ WLPS GH F WUH DQDOLúWLL PLOLWDUL URPkQL FDUH DX LQIRUPDW RUJDQHOH GH GHFL]LH VXSHULRDU F ÄQX HVWH H[FOXV FD %XOJDULD V SXQ SH WDSHW FKHVWLXQHDUHYHQGLF ULORUWHULWRULDOHDVXSUD'REURJHL´ ÌQWUXQ DVHPHQHD FRQWH[W OD LXQLH 3DUYDQ 'UDJDQRY PLQLVWUXO%XOJDULHLOD%HUOLQDI FXWFXQRVFXWOXL(UQVW:|HUPDQQF D SULPLWLQVWUXF LXQLGLQSDUWHDJXYHUQXOXLV XÄV vQWUHSULQG LQYHVWLJD LLvQ OHJ WXU FX GH]YROWDUHD FUL]HL EDVDUDEHQH´ úL V DIOH SXQFWXO GH YHGHUH JHUPDQ FX SULYLUH OD ÄVDWLVIDFHUHD XOWHULRDU D UHYHQGLF ULORU %XOJDULHL´ 'H]DP JLWGHU VSXQVXOSULPLWGLSORPDWXOEXOJDUDSUHFL]DWF UHJHOHúL JXYHUQXOGHOD6RILDÄVDUDIODvQWURVLWXD LHH[WUHPGHGLILFLO GDF QXDU SURILWDGHVLWXD LDDFWXDO ´úLDLQVLVWDWV LVHGHDÄXQHOHDVLJXU ULSHQWUX YLLWRU´vQVHQVXOF *HUPDQLDDYHDV UHFXQRDVF ÄMXVWH HDUHYHQGLF ULORU
ÌQ LXOLH DWDúDWXOPLOLWDUURPkQOD6RILDDSUHFLDF vQ%XOJDULD SUREOHPD %DVDUDELHL HUD ÄSULYLW FX VLPSDWLH I FkQGXVH R DQDORJLH vQWUH DFHDVW VLWXD LHúLFKHVWLXQHD&DGULODWHUXOXL´
EXOJDUHDVXSUD'REURJHLúLV SURPLW VDWLVIDFHUHDORUDWXQFLFkQGYDVRVL PRPHQWXO´ 5 VSXQVXO RILFLDO DO GLSORPD LHL JHUPDQH D IRVW GDW GXS RFXSDUHD%DVDUDELHLúLDS U LLGHQRUGD%XFRYLQHLGHF WUHVRYLHWLFLFkQG -RDFNLP YRQ 5LEEHQWURS D FRPXQLFDW /HJD LHL JHUPDQH GH OD 6RILD F JXYHUQXO GH OD %HUOLQ PDQLIHVWD ÄR vQ HOHJHUH GHSOLQ ID GH GRULQ HOH UHYL]LRQLVWHDOH%XOJDULHLID GH5RPkQLD´GDUF DFHVWOXFUXWUHEXLDUHD OL]DWLQFOXVLYFXLQIOXHQ JHUPDQ GXS ÄUHVWDXUDUHDS FLLvQ(XURSD´ /D VFXUW WLPS OD LXOLH vQWRUV GH OD %HUOLQ :LOKHOP )DEULFLXV D LQIRUPDW SH 0LKDLO 0DQRLOHVFX GHVSUH GHFL]LD )KUHUXOXL SULYLQG ÄUHWURFHGDUHD 'REURJHL GH VXG vQ JUDQL D GH OD LQFOXVLY 6LOLVWUDúL%DOFLFXO´EXOJDULLILLQGVI WXL LGHMDÄV QXSUHWLQG PDLPXOW´ 'XS FH D FHUXW OD DXJXVW DPEDVDGRUXOXL URPkQ OD %HOJUDG 9LFWRU & GHUH V VH GHSODVH]H OD 6RILD SHQWUX D GLVFXWD FX RPRORJXO EXOJDU SUREOHPHOHJDWHGHvQFHSHUHDRILFLDO DWUDWDWLYHORUvQSUREOHPD'REURJHL PLQLVWUXO URPkQ DO $IDFHULORU 6WU LQH D vQDLQWDW OD DXJXVW FkWH XQ 0HPRUDQGXPOXL-RDFNLPYRQ5LEEHQWURSSULQFDUHvQFHUFDV VFKLPEH GHFL]LDJHUPDQ vQSUREOHPD&DGULODWHUXOXL,ULWD LVXEDOWHUQLLPLQLVWUXOXL JHUPDQ GH H[WHUQH DX UHIX]DW V SULPHDVF GRFXPHQWXO úL DX I FXW FXQRVFXWF ÄDUILFXWRWXOvPSRWULYDLQWHUHVHORU5RPkQLHL´GDF JXYHUQXO URPkQ DU PDL VW UXL vQ DFHDVW FKHVWLXQH vQ FDUH Ä+LWOHU úLD VSXV FXYkQWXO´ ,QWUDQVLJHQ LEXOJDULLDXI FXWFXQRVFXWRILFLDOODDXJXVWF QX DFFHSW vQFHSHUHD WUDWDWLYHORU GHFkW GXS FH URPkQLL GHFODU F VXQW GH DFRUGFXFHGDUHDLQWHJUDO D&DGULODWHUXOXLÌQFHUFkQGV RE LQ ÄRFkW GH PLF GRYDG D SULHWHQLHL´ EXOJDUH 0LKDLO 0DQRLOHVFX D FHUXW OD DXJXVW OXL (XJHQ )LORWWL PLQLVWUXO URPkQ OD 6RILD V UHDPLQWHDVF UHJHOXL%RULVDO,,,OHDÄJHVWXOI FXWGHUHJHOH&DURO,FDUHDUHQXQ DWvQ OD R JUDQL PDL ODUJ SHQWUX D FUX D FDVWHOXO UHJDO GH OD (X[LQRGUDG´O VkQGV VHvQ HOHDJ F vQDFHOHPRPHQWHURPkQLLDYHDX GUHSWXOODXQWUDWDPHQWDVHP Q WRUÌQVLWXD LDvQFDUHFDVWHOXOUHJDOGHOD %DOFLF DU IL IRVW GHILQLWLY SLHUGXW PLQLVWUXO URPkQ DO $IDFHULORU 6WU LQH
ÌQGLVFX LLOHGHOD6RILD9LFWRU& GHUHDFFHSWDVHvQSULQFLSLXDFHVW OXFUXFXFRQGL LDS VWU ULL6LOLVWUHLúLDXQHLSRU LXQLGHWHULWRULXGHFLUFD NPSFXSULQV vQWUHYHFKHDIURQWLHU OLWRUDOXO0 ULL1HJUHúLROLQLHQRUGVXGGH ODYHVWGH%DOFLFSkQ ODYHFKHDIURQWLHU FDUHDUILSHUPLVS VWUDUHD&DOLDFUHL &DYDUQHLúL%DOFLFXOXLFXOLWRUDOXO
SURSXQHDFDDFHVWDvPSUHXQ FX&DSHODHURLORUURPkQLGHOD3OHYQDV ILH FRQVLGHUDW FD R DQH[ D /HJD LHL URPkQH GH OD 6RILD ÌQ DFHVW VHQV DPEDVDGRUXO URPkQ D vQDLQWDW XQ $LGH0pPRLUH PLQLVWUXOXL EXOJDU GH ([WHUQH $ GRXD ]L DXJXVW UHJHOH EXOJDU úLD H[SULPDW ÄWRDW vQ HOHJHUHD´SHQWUXSR]L LDJXYHUQXOXLURPkQGDUDGHFODUDWF ÄQXSRDWH GHFkWPHQ LQHSXQFWXDOGHYHGHUH´FRPXQLFDWDQWHULRUGHF WUHJXYHUQXO GH OD 6RILD GHRDUHFH ÄLGHHD UHVWLWX LHL LQWHJUDOH D SULQV DúD U G FLQL vQ VXIOHWXOSRSRUXOXLEXOJDUvQFkWQLFLRVROX LHSDU LDO QXPDLHVWHSRVLELO ´ 3HVWHGRX ]LOHOD DXJXVWOD&UDLRYDDYHDXV vQFHDS GLVFX LLOH URPkQREXOJDUH FHOH GRX GHOHJD LL ILLQG FRQGXVH GH $OH[DQGUX &UHW]LDQXUHVSHFWLY6YHWRVODY3RPPHQRY &XWRDWHF vQWUXQGLVFXUV ÄJODFLDO´úHIXOGHOHJD LHLURPkQHDUHSURúDWLQWHUORFXWRULORULQWUDQVLJHQ D PDQLIHVWDW vQSUREOHPDWHULWRULDO WUDWDWLYHOHDYHDXV FRQWLQXHURPkQLL DFFHSWkQGFHGDUHDLQWHJUDO D&DGULODWHUXOXLÌQDFHVWFRQWH[WGLVFX LLOHV DXD[DWDVXSUDPRGDOLW LORUGHHYDFXDUHODDXJXVWFHOHGRX GHOHJD LL vQFKHLQG XQ $FRUG vQ DFHVW VHQV R 'HFODUD LH FX SULYLUH OD DFRUG úL DX PDUFDW SH R KDUW OD VFDUD FHOH SDWUX ]RQH GH WUDQVIHU úL HYDFXDUHUHVSHFWLYGHRFXSDUHGHF WUHWUXSHOHEXOJDUH ÌQ ILQDO OD VHSWHPEULH $OH[DQGUX &UHW]LDQX úL +HQUL *HRUJHV 0HLWDQL SHQWUX 5RPkQLD úL 6YHWRVODY 3RPHQRY úL 7KHRNKDU 3DSD]RY SHQWUX%XOJDULDDXVHPQDWWUDWDWXOURPkQREXOJDUFDUHSULQDUWVWDELOHD QRXD IURQWLHU vQ VHFWRUXO GREURJHDQ FRQIRUP F UHLD &DGULODWHUXO MXGH HOH &DOLDFUD úL 'XURVWRU vQWUDX vQ FRPSRQHQ D %XOJDULHL ÌQ ED]D DUWFHOHGRX S U LFRQVLGHUDXYLLWRDUHDIURQWLHU FDILLQGÄGHILQLWLY úL SHUSHWX ´ úL vúL OXDX DQJDMDPHQWXO FD QLFL XQD V QX PDL IRUPXOH]H YUHRGDW ÄYUHR SUHWHQ LXQH GH RUGLQ WHULWRULDO vPSRWULYD FHOHLODOWH ÌQDOWH S U L FRQWUDFWDQWH´ $UW SUHYHGHD FD vQWUXQ WHUPHQ GH WUHL OXQL GH OD VFKLPEXOLQVWUXPHQWHORUGHUDWLILFDUH5RPkQLDúL%XOJDULDVHREOLJDXV SURFHGH]HODÄVFKLPEXOREOLJDWRULXGLQWUHVXSXúLLURPkQLGHRULJLQHHWQLF EXOJDU GLQMXGH HOH7XOFHDúL&RQVWDQ D DFHVWDGLQXUP vQGHOLPLWDUHD GLQDLQWHGHLXQLH úLVXSXúLLURPkQLGHRULJLQHHWQLF URPkQ GLQ
3HQWUX LVWRULFXO SUREOHPHL GREURJHQH YH]L *KHRUJKH =EXFKHD 7UDWDWXOGHOD&UDLRYD±SDUWHLQWHJUDQW DGLFWDWXOXLGHOD9LHQDvQÄ'RFXPHQW %XOHWLQXO$UKLYHORU0LOLWDUH5RPkQH´QUSS ÌQ GLQ SRSXOD LD &DGULODWHUXOXL HUD IRUPDW GLQ URPkQL GLQEXOJDULLDUUHVWXOGLQDOWHQD LRQDOLW L
MXGH HOH'XURVWRUúL&DOLDFUD´&HLODO LFHW HQLURPkQLúLEXOJDULSXWHDX LPLJUDvQPRGIDFXOWDWLYÄvQ DUDORUGHDILQLWDWHHWQLF vQWLPSGHXQDQGH ODVFKLPEXOLQVWUXPHQWHORUGHUDWLILFDUH´*XYHUQXOURPkQSXWHDGHFUHWD ÄHPLJUDUHD REOLJDWRULH´ vQ %XOJDULD D XQXL QXP U GH VXSXúL URPkQL GH RULJLQHHWQLF EXOJDU HJDOFXDFHODDOVXSXúLORUEXOJDULGHRULJLQHHWQLF URPkQ FDUH DU IL GRULW V HPLJUH]H JXYHUQXO EXOJDU ILLQG REOLJDW V L SULPHDVF 3UREOHPHOHWHKQLFHUHIHULWRDUHODPRGDOLW LOHGHHYDFXDUHúLOD WUDQVIHUXOGHSRSXOD LHHUDXUHJOHPHQWDWHSULQDFRUGXULVSHFLDOHDQH[ OD WUDWDWXOGHED] &RQVHFLQ HOHUDSWXULORUWHULWRULDOH 5DSWXULOH WHULWRULDOH V YkUúLWH GH 8QLXQHD 6RYLHWLF 8QJDULD úL %XOJDULDODDGUHVD5RPkQLHLvQ DXDYXWFRQVHFLQ HH[WUHPGHJUDYH SHQWUX DU VWDWXO QD LRQDO XQLWDU URPkQ UHvQWUHJLW vQ LVWRULFXO DQ SLHU]kQG FLUFDGHNPSúLPLOLRDQHGHORFXLWRULDGLF DSUR[L PDWLY GLQ WHULWRULX úL GLQ SRSXOD LH SUHFXP úL LPHQVH YDORUL PDWHULDOHúLVSLULWXDOHILLQGGLVWUXVHVDXvQVXúLWHGHF WUHFHLF URUDQXOH DSDU LQHDX ÌQ XUPD XOWLPDWXPXULORU GLQ LXQLH 8QLXQHD 6RYLHWLF D DQH[DWNPSúL GHORFXLWRULvQ%DVDUDELDúLNPSúL GH ORFXLWRUL vQ QRUGXO %XFRYLQHL 3ULQ GLFWDWXO GH OD 9LHQD 8QJDULDúLDvQVXúLW NPSúL ORFXLWRULvQWLPSFHSULQ WUDWDWXOGHOD&UDLRYD%XOJDULDDvQFRUSRUDWXQWHULWRULXFXRVXSUDID GH NPSúLORFXLWRUL 'DWRULW UHJLPXOXL H[WUHP GH GXU DSOLFDW GH F WUH RFXSDQ L úL D RS LXQLL URPkQLORU GLQ WHULWRULLOH vQFRUSRUDWH SULQ IRU SkQ OD VIkUúLWXO
'LQWUH DFHúWLD HUDX URPkQL PDJKLDUL JHUPDQL HYUHLUXWHQLDOWHQD LRQDOLW L /XFU ULOH GH LVWRULH úL VXUVHOH DUKLYLVWLFH PHQ LRQHD] FLIUH GLIHULWH SULYLQGVXSUDID DRFXSDW úLSRSXOD LDURPkQHDVF vQFRUSRUDW GHF WUH8QLXQHD 6RYLHWLF 8QJDULDúL%XOJDULD 3HODUJ ,RDQ6FXUWX&RQVWDQWLQ+OLKRU$QXO 'UDPDURPkQLORU GLQWUH3UXWúL1LVWUX%XFXUHúWL *KHRUJKH,%RGHD9DVLOH76XFLX,OLH , 3XúFDú , $GPLQLVWUD LD PLOLWDU IDVFLVW vQ QRUGYHVWXO 5RPkQLHL VHSWHPEULHQRLHPEULH &OXM1DSRFD
DQXOXL GLQ %DVDUDELD úL QRUGXO %XFRYLQHL VDX UHIXJLDW ORFXLWRULvQWLPSFHGLQ7UDQVLOYDQLDVDXUHIXJLDWSkQ ODDSULOLH ÌQ&DGULODWHUvQFDGUXODF LXQLLGHHYDFXDUHDXSOHFDW GH URPkQLvQWLPSFHvQ5RPkQLDDXU PDV GHEXOJDULGLQFDUHDX SOHFDWSkQ ODRFWRPEULH 1XPHURDVHDXIRVWúLSLHUGHULOH PDWHULDOHvQVSHFLDOvQ7UDQVLOYDQLDXQGHVXSUDID DRFXSDW GH8QJDULD LQFOXGHD GHvQWUHSULQGHULPDULPLQHOHGHDXUDUJLQWFXSUXF UEXQH EDX[LW HWFFDUHLQFOXGHDXGLQUH]HUYHOHGHDXU &DX]HOHFDUHDXLPSXVSLHUGHUHDWHULWRULLORUURPkQHúWLDXIRVWPXO WLSOHILLQGGHWHUPLQDWHvQSULPXOUkQGGHSROLWLFDDJUHVLY UHYL]LRQLVW D FHORUWUHLVWDWHDJUHVRDUHGHFRQWH[WXOLQWHUQD LRQDOQHIDYRUDELO5RPkQLHL GDU úL GH IDFWRUL LQWHUQL FDUH DX I FXW FD SRSRUXO URPkQ V ILH SXV vQ VLWXD LDGHDúLDS UDFXDUPDvQPkQ DúDFXPDGRULWJOLDVWU EXQ
,9Ì19Æ/72$5($ &(/8,'($/'2,/($5 =%2,021',$/ 3UHOLPLQDULL $GHUDUHD OD $[ 'XS UDSWXULOH WHULWRULDOH GLQ YDUD DQXOXL 5RPkQLDDIODW GHMDvQVIHUDGHGRPLQD LHD*HUPDQLHL±FDUHJDUDQWDVH OD DXJXVW QRLOH IURQWLHUH DOH VWDWXOXL URPkQ úL D LPSXV OD VHSWHPEULH DEGLFDUHD UHJHOXL &DURO DO ,,OHD úL SUHOXDUHD SXWHULL HIHFWLYHvQVWDWGHF WUHJHQHUDOXO,RQ$QWRQHVFX±DDFFHSWDWGLQLQL LD WLYD SHUVRQDO D QRXOXL FRQGXF WRU DO VWDWXOXL VRVLUHD vQ DU D 0LVLXQLL 0LOLWDUHúLDWUXSHORUJHUPDQH RFWRPEULH úLDDGHUDWGLQSURSULH LQL LDWLY OD 3DFWXO 7ULSDUWLW QRLHPEULH &RQFRPLWHQW vQ 5RPkQLD DX VRVLW úL WUXSH LWDOLHQH GH YkQ WRUL DOSLQL úL PDULQ LQFOXVLY
0LVLXQHD UHDO D WUXSHORU JHUPDQH GLQ 5RPkQLD FDUH D IRVW LQXW VHFUHW DWkWSHQWUXURPkQLFkWúLSHQWUXJHUPDQLDIRVWDVWIHOSUHFL]DW GHF WUH JHQHUDOXO:LOKHOP.HLWHOúHIXOÌQDOWXOXLFRPDQGDPHQWDO:HKUPDFKWXOXL ÄD V DSHUHFkPSXULOHSHWUROLIHUHGHDILDFDSDUDWHGHRWHU SXWHUHVDXGHODGLVWUXJHUH E V GHDSRVLELOLWDWHDDUPDWHLURPkQHGHDHIHFWXDVDUFLQLGLIHULWHFRUHVSXQ] WRU XQXLSODQHODERUDWHIHFWLYvQIDYRDUHDLQWHUHVHORU*HUPDQLHL F vQFD]XOvQFDUH YRPILVLOL LODXQU ]ERLFX5XVLD6RYLHWLF V VHSUHJ WHDVF SHQWUXDQJDMDUHD IRU HORUJHUPDQHúLURPkQHGLQGLUHF LD5RPkQLHL´ÌQDFHVWVHQVWUXSHOHJHUPDQH DXIRVWGLVORFDWHFXSULRULWDWHvQ]RQHOH6LELX%DF X&RQVWDQ D*LXUJLXDGLF vQ ]RQDVWUDWHJLF FHQWUDO D5RPkQLHLGHXQGHSXWHDXDF LRQDvQPDLPXOWHGLUHF LL 0LVLXQHDDSDUHQW PDLSUHFL]DRILFLDOXOPLOLWDUJHUPDQHUDGHÄDDMXWD5RPkQLD SULHWHQ QRX vQFHSULYHúWHRUJDQL]DUHDúLSUHJ WLUHDIRU HORUHLDUPDWH´$YkQG vQYHGHUHLPSRUWDQ D5RPkQLHLvQSODQXULOHGHSHUVSHFWLY DOH5HLFKXOXL+LWOHUD FHUXW OD RFWRPEULH ÄV VH HYLWH úL FHD PDL PLF DSDUHQ GH RFXSD LH PLOLWDU D5RPkQLHLúLV VHGHDGHODvQFHSXWWUDQVIHUXOXLGHXQLW LPLOLWDUHvQ DFHDVW DU FDUDFWHUXOXQHLWULPLWHULGHPLVLXQHD:HKUPDFKWXOXLDYkQGWUXSHOH GHLQVWUXF LHQHFHVDUH´1XP UXOWUXSHORUJHUPDQHVRVLWHvQ5RPkQLDDDMXQVvQ IHEUXDULH vQDLQWHD WUHFHULL 'XQ ULL vQ YHGHUHD DWDF ULL *UHFLHL OD FLUFD 6HPQDWvQWUH*HUPDQLD,WDOLDúL-DSRQLDOD%HUOLQODVHSWHPEULH
DYLDWRUL GLVORFDWH SH 9DOHD 3UDKRYHL úL OD %U LOD SUHFXP úL R 0LVLXQH PLOLWDU 'LQSULPXOPRPHQW,RQ$QWRQHVFXDGHFLVV PHDUJ ÄVXW ODVXW SkQ OD PRDUWH DO WXUL GH $[ ´ FRPSURPL kQG UHOD LLOH SROLWLFRPLOL WDUHFXDOLD LLWUDGL LRQDOLDL5RPkQLHL0DLPXOWDQWLFLSkQGYLLWRUXOU ]ERL JHUPDQRVRYLHWLF vQDLQWH FKLDU FD +LWOHU V O LQIRUPH]HGHVSUHDFHVWDD GHFODUDWvQF GLQWRDPQDDQXOXL F YDSXQHODGLVSR]L LD*HUPDQLHL ÄWRDWH IRU HOH DX[LOLDUH SROLWLFH PLOLWDUH úL VRFLDOH DOH 5RPkQLHL´ F GRUHúWHV OXSWHDFWLYvPSRWULYD8QLXQLL6RYLHWLFHÄGLQSULPD]L´úLF YD IDFHWRWXOSHQWUXÄDvQGHSOLQLFXVXFFHVPLVLXQLOHFHLUHYLQ´ &KLDUGDF IRUPDOLQGHSHQGHQ DúLVXYHUDQLWDWHDVWDWXOXLURPkQDX IRVW PHQ LQXWH OLEHUWDWHD GH GHFL]LH D RUJDQHORU SXWHULL GH VWDW ± PRQDUKXOÄFRQGXF WRUXOVWDWXOXL´JXYHUQXO±DIRVWPXOWvQJU GLW &KLDU úLDOXL,RQ$QWRQHVFXGHúLDFHVWDQXDUHFXQRVFXWQLFLRGDW 7RDWHDFHVWHD GDUPDLDOHVVRVLUHDWUXSHORUJHUPDQHvQ5RPkQLDúL VSRULUHD QXP UXOXL ORU DX I FXW FD UHOD LLOH H[WHUQH DOH 5RPkQLHL V VH UHGXF FRQVLGHUDELO PDL DOHV GXS FH OD IHEUXDULH 0DUHD %ULWDQLH D UXSW UHOD LLOH GLSORPDWLFH FX 5RPkQLD ,PHGLDW OD FHUHUHD *HUPDQLHL 5RPkQLD D vQWUHUXSW RILFLDO UHOD LLOH GLSORPDWLFH FX %HOJLD IHEUXDULH 2ODQGD IHEUXDULH 1RUYHJLD IHEUXDULH /D VFXUW WLPS JXYHUQXO URPkQ D WUDQVIRUPDW DPEDVDGD GH OD %HOJUDG vQ OHJD LH úL D VWDELOLW UHOD LL GLSORPDWLFH OD QLYHO GH OHJD LH FX VWDWXO0DQFLNRDIODWVXEFRQWUROXO-DSRQLHL PDUWLH
2GHFODUD LHDVHP Q WRDUHDI FXWúLGXS HOLPLQDUHDOHJLRQDULORUGH OD JXYHUQDUH vQ LDQXDULH FkQG D GHFODUDW Ä5RPkQLD PHUJH I U QLFL R úRY LUHDO WXULGH$[ GHPDUHOH)KUHUúLGHGRPQXO0XVVROLQL´ ÌQ SODQ FXOWXUDODUWLVWLF vQFHSkQG FX RFWRPEULH D IRVW LQWURGXV Ä2UD*HUPDQLHL´ PLHUFXUHDGHODRUD vQILLQ DW,QVWLWXWXO*HUPDQ GLQ %XFXUHúWL RUJDQL]DWH H[SR]L LL GH FDUWH FRQIHULQ H FX FDUDFWHU úWLLQ LILF ILOR]RILF OLWHUDU HWF &RQFRPLWHQW vQFHSkQG FX QRLHPEULH *UXSXO (WQLF *HUPDQ GLQ 5RPkQLD D GHYHQLW SHUVRDQ MXULGLF GH GUHSW SXEOLF FX SRVLELOLWDWHD GH D HPLWH GLVSR]L LL FX FDUDFWHU GH REOLJDWLYLWDWH SHQWUX WR L PHPEULLV L3ULQDFHDVW GHFL]LHHWQLFLLJHUPDQLDXIRVWVFRúLGHVXEDXWRULWDWHD VWDWXOXL URPkQ SXWkQG DUERUD OHJDO GUDSHOXO JHUPDQ OkQJ FHO URPkQHVF ÌQ DFHHDúL ]L D IRVW DXWRUL]DW V IXQF LRQH]H 3DUWLGXO 0XQFLWRUHVF 1D LRQDO 6RFLDOLVW*HUPDQDOJUXSXOXL(WQLF*HUPDQGLQ5RPkQLD 0LQLVWUXO 0DULL %ULWDQLL OD %XFXUHúWL VLU 5HJLQDOG +RDUH úL SHUVRQDOXO /HJD LHL DX S U VLW 5RPkQLD LQYRFkQG VSRULUHD FRQVLGHUDELO D QXP UXOXL WUXSHORU JHUPDQH FDUH VH SUHJ WHDX V WUHDF vQ %XOJDULD SHQWUX D DWDFD*UHFLD
3R]L LD ID GH DJUHVLXQHD JHUPDQ vQ ,XJRVODYLD /D DSULOLH FkQG:HKUPDFKWXODDWDFDW,XJRVODYLD5RPkQLDQXDIRVWDQJDMDW vQU ]ERLXOGXVvPSRWULYD ULLYHFLQH GHúL,RQ$QWRQHVFXDWHQ LRQDVH SHIHOGPDUHúDOXO:DOWKHUYRQ%UDXWFKLVFKúHIXO2.+XOXLF DUPDWD URPkQ QXYDU PkQHSDVLY GDF WUXSHOHXQJDUHDUILS WUXQVvQ%DQDWXO LXJRVODY 8UPDUHD D IRVW F JHUPDQLL úLDX PRGLILFDW SODQXULOH SULYLQG vPS U LUHD,XJRVODYLHL%DQDWXOLXJRVODYILLQGSXVVXERFXSD LHJHUPDQ &XWRDWHDFHVWHDODDSULOLH ,RQ$QWRQHVFXDGHFODUDWvQ&RQVLOLXO GH0LQLúWULF 5RPkQLDQXUHQXQ ODÄGUHSWXULOHúLGDWRULDSHFDUHRDUH V UHLQWHJUH]H %DQDWXO´ /D UkQGXL 0LKDL $QWRQHVFX PLQLVWUX GH ([WHUQH DU WD vQWUXQ 0HPRUDQGXP WULPLV vQ QXPHOH JXYHUQXOXL URPkQ JXYHUQHORU SXWHULORU $[HL DSULOLH F vQ FRQWH[WXO vQ FDUH %HUOLQXO I FXVH PDUL FRQFHVLL WHULWRULDOH 8QJDULHL úL %XOJDULHL 5RPkQLD FHUHDRUHYL]XLUHJHQHUDO DIURQWLHUHORUGLQVXGHVWXO(XURSHLÌQID D UHIX]XOXL OXL +LWOHU FDUH DYHD DOWH SODQXUL úL SHQWUX VXGHVWXO (XURSHL 0LKDL$QWRQHVFXDSURSXVvQV UFLQDWXOXLGHDIDFHULLWDOLDQODPDL I U VXFFHV FD ,WDOLD V GHVFKLG XQ FRULGRU URPkQHVF SULQ YDOHD 7LPRFXOXLSkQ ODQRXDIURQWLHU D$OEDQLHLSHQWUXDVHFUHDÄREDULHU ODWLQ ªvQWHULWRULXOSRSRDUHORUVODYH 'XS FHODvQFHSXWXOOXQLLPDL JXYHUQXOLXJRVODYGLQH[LOD UXSWUHOD LLOHGLSORPDWLFHFX5RPkQLDJXYHUQXOURPkQDUHFXQRVFXWOD PDL Ä6WDWXO FURDW LQGHSHQGHQW´ SURFODPDW OD DSULOLH $SRL GXS RFXSDUHD *UHFLHL GH F WUH *HUPDQLD D vQWUHUXSW UHOD LLOH GLSORPDWLFHúLFXVWDWXOHOHQ
+LWOHUDRIHULW5RPkQLHLvQWLPSXOFDPSDQLHLGLQ%DOFDQLXQUROGH SURWHMDUHDIODQFXOXLVWkQJvPSRWULYDXQXLHYHQWXDODWDFVRYLHWLF $X IRVW DYDQVDWH XUP WRDUHOH VROX LL DOWHUQDWLYH D 2 0DFHGRQLH OLEHU FDUH DU JUXSD SRSXOD LLOH URPkQH GLQ %DOFDQL E 8Q WHULWRULX URPkQ DXWRQRPUHFXQRVFXWSRSXOD LHLURPkQHGLQ9DOHD7LPRFXOXLSkQ OD9DUGDU F 8Q FRQGRPLQLXP R FRPXQLWDWH JHUPDQRURPkQ LWDOLDQ HYHQWXDO EXOJDU SHQWUX UHJLXQHD 7LPRFXOXL DGLF R IkúLH GHD OXQJXO JUDQL HL EXOJDUH DFWXDOH SkQ OD %HOJUDG 1LV 6NRSOMH úL vQ MRV VSUH 6DORQLF $SXG ùWHIDQ /DFKH RS FLWSS ùWHIDQ/DFKHRSFLWS ,QWHUHVHOHLXJRVODYHvQ5RPkQLDDXIRVWUHSUH]HQWDWHvQFRQWLQXDUHGH /HJD LD6WDWHORU8QLWHDOH$PHULFLL /HJD LD URPkQ GH OD $WHQD D FRQWLQXDW V IXQF LRQH]H SkQ OD LXQLH FkQGDIRVWWUDQVIRUPDW vQFRQVXODWJHQHUDO
3DUWLFLSDUHDOD&DPSDQLDGLQ(VW (OLEHUDUHD%DVDUDELHLúLDS U LLGHQRUGD%XFRYLQHL/DLXQLH FkQG *HUPDQLD D DWDFDW 8QLXQHD 6RYLHWLF ,RQ $QWRQHVFX úLD DVXPDW VLQJXU UHVSRQVDELOLWDWHD DQJDM ULL ULL vQ U ]ERL úL D FHUXW PLOLWDULORUURPkQLSULQFHOHEUXORUGLQÄ2VWDúLY RUGRQ WUHFH L3UXWXO´ V GH]UREHDVF GLQÄMXJXOURúXDOEROúHYLVPXOXLSHIUD LLQRúWULFRWURSL L´ úLV UHDGXF vQWUHKRWDUHOHQD LRQDOHÄJOLDVWU EXQ D%DVDUDELHLúLFRGULL YRLHYRGDOLDL%XFRYLQHL´$QJDMDW VDXPDLSUHFLVDQJDMkQGXVHvQID]D LQL LDO vQWUXQU ]ERLFDUHLDIRVWLPSXVSULQEUXWDOXOXOWLPDWXPVRYLHWLF GLQLXQLH 5RPkQLDQXDYL]DW HOXULDQH[LRQLVWHGHFRWURSLUHDXQRU WHULWRULLFDUHQXvLDSDU LQHDXFLGRDUUHvQWUHJLUHDQD LRQDO /D LXOLH SULQ OXSWD D FLUFD GH PLOLWDUL URPkQL %DVDUDELD úL QRUGXO %XFRYLQHL VWU YHFKL SURYLQFLL URPkQHúWL DX IRVW HOLEHUDWH&DPSDQLDHOLEHUDWRDUHDIRVWVSULMLQLW GHPDMRULWDWHDSRSRUXOXL GHSDUWLGHOHSROLWLFHúLGHUHJHOH0LKDL, 3DUWLFLSDUHD OD U ]ERL SH WHULWRULXO 8QLXQLL 6RYLHWLFH3HP VXUD vQGHSOLQLULLPLVLXQLORUGHOXSW SHWHULWRULXOQD LRQDOGLQHVWXO ULLWUXSHOH URPkQHDXFRQWLQXDWSDUWLFLSDUHDODU ]ERLDO WXULGH*HUPDQLDvQFDGUXO U ]ERLXOXL GH FRDOL LH vQ DGkQFLPHD WHULWRULXOXL VRYLHWLF vQ FRQWH[WXO vQ FDUH8QLXQHD6RYLHWLF QXHUDQLFLSHGHSDUWHvQIUkQW vQFDUH8QJDULDFX FDUHHUDvQWURFRPSHWL LHFRQWLQX SHQWUXvQFUHGHUHD%HUOLQXOXLFRQWLQXD OXSWDDO WXULGH5HLFKLDU%XOJDULDVW WHDvQHVSHFWDWLY ,PSXV GHFRQVL GHUHQWHVWUDWHJLFHGHFHULQ HOHDVLJXU ULLVHFXULW LLJUDQL HLU V ULWHQHGH SH 1LVWUX KRW UkUHD FRQGXF WRUXOXL VWDWXOXL URPkQ D IRVW FRQWHVWDW vQ HSRF GH GLIHULWH SHUVRQDOLW L SROLWLFH FX SUHF GHUH GH ,XOLX 0DQLX úL &,& %U WLDQX S UHULOH FRQWUDGLFWRULL FRQWLQXkQG V VH PDQLIHVWH úL vQ ]LOHOHQRDVWUH 7UHFkQGVXFFHVLY1LVWUXOvQFHSkQGFXLXOLH IRU HOHPLOLWDUH URPkQH DX GHVI úXUDW vQ FRRSHUDUH FX FHOH JHUPDQH DPSOH RSHUD LL PLOLWDUHSkQ OD1LSUXúLvQ]RQD2GHVVDDSRLODQRUGGH0DUHDGH$]RY vQ&ULPHHDODVXGGH+DUNRYvQ]RQD6WDOLQJUDG vQ&RWXO'RQXOXLúLvQ 6WHSD .DOPXN vQ SHQLQVXOD 7DPDQ vQ .XEDQ úL vQ &DXFD] SkQ vQ
3H ODUJ 'LQX &*LXUHVFX 5RPkQLD vQ DO GRLOHD U ]ERL PRQGLDO %XFXUHúWL $OHVDQGUX 'X X ÌQWUH :HKUPDFKW úL $UPDWD 5RúLH%XFXUHúWLSS
DSURSLHUH GH *UR]QkL DQJDMkQG QXPHURDVH IRU H URPkQH OD R PDUH GHS UWDUH GH JUDQL HOH ULL vQUHJLVWUkQG YLFWRULL PDL PXOW VDX PDL SX LQ FRVWLVLWRDUH 2GHVVDvQSULPXOFD]RIHQVLYD$UPDWHLVSUH1LSUXOXSWHOH GLQ&ULPHHD7DPDQ.XEDQ&DXFD]vQFHOGHDOGRLOHD GDUúLvQIUkQJHUL FDWDVWURIDOH 6WDOLQJUDG FDUHDXSXVvQSHULFROIRU DFRPEDWLY PLOLWDU D 5RPkQLHL FLUFD GH PLOLWDULPRU L U QL L úL GLVS UX L QXPDL vQ &RWXO'RQXOXLúLvQ6WHSD.DOPXN &X WRDWH F GH]DP JLUHD úL GH]LOX]LD SRSRUXOXL URPkQ DWLQVHVHU FRWH PD[LPH 5RPkQLD D FRQWLQXDW V OXSWH DO WXUL GH *HUPDQLD V úL vQGHSOLQHDVF REOLJD LLOH GH DOLDW vQ WLPSXO UHWUDJHULL GH OD 6WDOLQJUDG úL GLQ&DXFD]vQFDSXOGHSRGGLQ.XEDQvQ&ULPHHDúLSHOLWRUDOXOQRUGLF DO0 ULL1HJUHSUHFXPúLvQ%DVDUDELD%XFRYLQDúL0ROGRYDGLQPDUWLH SDUWHD GH HVW D WHULWRULXOXL QD LRQDO GHYHQLQG GLQ QRX WHDWUX GH RSHUD LLPLOLWDUH &RQWLQXDUHD SDUWLFLS ULL OD U ]ERL úL GXS UHVWDELOLUHD VXYHUDQLW LL URPkQHúWLDVXSUD%DVDUDELHLúL%XFRYLQHLDDYXWFRQVHFLQ HLPSRUWDQWHQX QXPDLvQSODQLQWHUQFLúLvQSULYLQ DUHOD LLORUH[WHUQHDOH5RPkQLHL DUD ILLQG SXV vQ PRG IRUPDO vQ VWDUH GH U ]ERL FX 0DUHD %ULWDQLH GHFHPEULH ODLQVLVWHQ DJXYHUQXOXLVRYLHWLF 6WDWHOH8QLWHDOH$PHULFLL GHFHPEULH SULQ GHFODUD LD URPkQ GH U ]ERL úL SULQFRQWUDGHFODUD LD GHU ]ERLVHPQDW GHSUHúHGLQWHOHDPHULFDQODLXQLH &DQDGDúL 1RXD=HHQODQG GHFHPEULH $XVWUDOLDúL8QLXQHD6XG$IULFDQ GHFHPEULH DSRLúLFX1LFDUDJXD GHFHPEULH +DLWL GHFHPEULH /X[HPEXUJ VHSWHPEULH %ROLYLD GHFHPEULH &HKRVORYDFLD UHSUH]HQWDW SULQJXYHUQXOGLQH[LOODIHEUXDULH &RQFRPLWHQW DX PDL IRVW vQWUHUXSWH UHOD LLOH GLSORPDWLFH FX 5HSXEOLFD &KLQD LXOLH ,UDQ RFWRPEULH (JLSW GHFHPEULH 9HQH]XHOD GHFHPEULH 0H[LF GHFHPEULH %UD]LOLD PDUWLH &RVWD 5LFD PDL &XED VHSWHPEULH &KLOH PDL úLVDXVWDELOLWUHOD LLGLSORPDWLFH
,ELGHPSS /DQRLHPEULH JXYHUQXOHQJOH]DvQDLQWDWJXYHUQXOXLURPkQR 1RW XOWLPDWLY SULQLQWHUPHGLXO/HJD LHL68$ SULQFDUHI FHDFXQRVFXWF GDF SkQ ODGHFHPEULHQXYDRSULRSHUD LLOHPLOLWDUHúLQXYDvQFHWDÄRULFH SDUWLFLSDUH DFWLY OD RVWLOLW L´ 0DUHD %ULWDQLH YD GHFODUD U ]ERL 5RPkQLHL Ä8QLYHUVXO´GLQ GHFHPEULH
FX JXYHUQXO SURMDSRQH] GH OD 1DQMLQJ LXOLH ÌQ XUPD WUHFHULL ,WDOLHLGHSDUWHD1D LXQLORU8QLWH VHSWHPEULH JXYHUQXOURPkQ DUHFXQRVFXWODVHSWHPEULH JXYHUQXOIDVFLVWUHSXEOLFDQFRQGXV GH %HQLWR 0XVVROLQL 5HSXEOLFD GH OD 6DOR GDU D FRQWLQXDW V PHQ LQ UHOD LLúLFXJXYHUQXO%DGRJOLRPHQ LQkQGOD%XFXUHúWLSHUHSUH]HQWDQWXO DFHVWXLD5HQDWR%RYD6RSSD 3ULQXUPDUHSkQ ODDXJXVW 5RPkQLDVDDIODWvQU ]ERLFX VWDWHDvQWUHUXSWUHOD LLOHGLSORPDWLFHFXVWDWHúLDvQWUH LQXWUHOD LL GLSORPDWLFHFX UL %XOJDULD&URD LD'DQHPDUFD(OYH LD)LQODQGD )UDQ D *HUPDQLD ,WDOLD -DSRQLD 3RUWXJDOLD 6SDQLD 6XHGLD 6ORYDFLD 8QJDULD7XUFLD9DWLFDQ &RQFRPLWHQWOD%XFXUHúWLVDXDIODWvQPLVLXQH RILFLDO DWDúD LPLOLWDULGLQ%XOJDULD&URD LD)UDQ D)LQODQGD*HUPDQLD ,WDOLD-DSRQLD6ORYDFLD6SDQLD7XUFLDúL8QJDULD 6LWXD LD ULL VD DJUDYDW úL SULQ IDSWXO F UHFXQRVFkQG JUDQL HOH HVWLFHDOH8QLXQLL6RYLHWLFHH[LVWHQWHvQ 0DUHD%ULWDQLHúL6WDWHOH 8QLWHDOH$PHULFLLDXDFFHSWDWLPSOLFLWU PkQHUHD%DVDUDELHLúLDS U LLGH QRUGD%XFRYLQHLvQFRPSXQHUHD8QLXQLL6RYLHWLFH 3UHOLPLQDULLGHDUPLVWL LX 'XS GH]DVWUXOGHOD6WDOLQJUDGFkQGDXIRVWSLHUGX LFLUFD GHPLOLWDUL PRU LU QL LúLGLVS UX L ,RQ$QWRQHVFXúLÄRSR]L LD´UHSUH ]HQWDW vQVSHFLDOGHFRQGXF WRULLFHORUGRX SDUWLGHLVWRULFHDXvQWUHSULQV QXPHURDVH GDU LQIUXFWXRDVH SUHOLPLQDULL GH DUPLVWL LX vQGUHSWkQGXúL
$UPLVWL LXODIRVWSXEOLFDWODVHSWHPEULH 9DOHULX )ORULQ 'REULQHVFX 5RPkQLD úL RUJDQL]DUHD SRVWEHOLF D OXPLL %XFXUHúWL S ,QL LDOVDXVWDELOLWOHJ WXULvQFDSLWDOHOHXQRUVWDWHQHXWUH OD/LVDERQD FX UHSUH]HQWDQ LL 0DULL %ULWDQLL ± GH F WUH ,RQ 3DQJDO IRVW PLQLVWUX vQ FDSLWDOD OXVLWDQ &DPLO 'HPHWUHVFX VHFUHWDU GH OHJD LH úL 9LFWRU & GHUH HPLVDUXO OXL 0LKDL $QWRQHVFX 0DGULG FX &DUOWRQ +D\HV DPEDVDGRUXO 68$ GH F WUH 6FDUODW *ULJRULX SULPXO VHFUHWDU DO /HJD LHL URPkQH GLQ FDSLWDOD 6SDQLHL OD %HUQD FX /HODQG +DUUULVRQ PLQLVWUXO 68$ GH F WUH 1LFRODH /DKRYDU\ úL 9HVSDVLDQ3HOODWLWXODULL/HJD LHLURPkQH*ULJRUH*DIHQFX5LFKDUG)UDQDVRYLFL úD OD5RPDFXUHSUH]HQWDQ LL9DWLFDQXOXLHWF DSRLGLQWRDPQDDQXOXL DX IRVW LQL LDWH WUDWDWLYH FX VRYLHWLFLL OD 6WRFNKROP FX $OH[DQGUD .ROORQWDL DPEDVDGRDUHD 8566 GH F WUH )UHGHULF 1DQX úHIXO /HJD LHL 5RPkQH úL *HRUJH 'XFD FRQVLOLHU GH OHJD LH úL UHSUH]HQWDQWXO ÄRSR]L LHL´ LDU GLQ PDUWLH OD&DLUR FXUHSUH]HQWDQ LLWXWXURUDOLD LORUGHF WUHGLSORPDWXO$OH[DQGUX &UHW]LDQXúL%DUEXùWLUEH\úL&RQVWDQWLQ9LúRLDQXUHSUH]HQWDQ LLÄRSR]L LHL´
DWHQ LDVSUHSXWHULOHRFFLGHQWDOHvQSRILGDIDSWXOXLF DFHVWHDDXSUHFL]DW GHODvQFHSXWIRDUWHFODUúLIHUPF URPkQLLWUHEXLDXV VHvQ HOHDJ PDL vQWkL FX VRYLHWLFLL F URUD OHD IRVW UHFXQRVFXW SUHSRQGHUHQ D vQ VROX LR QDUHDSUREOHPHORUVWDWHORUHVWHXURSHQH (úHFXOVFHQDULLORUSUHFRQL]DWHVDGDWRUDWXQRUFDX]HRELHFWLYHGDU úLVXELHFWLYHLQWHUQHGDUúLH[WHUQH 8Q URO LPSRUWDQW vQ HúHFXO GLVFX LLORU SUHOLPLQDUH ODX DYXW ± SH OkQJ H[LJHQ HOHURPkQHúWLvQFHHDFHSULYHúWHUHFXQRDúWHUHDGHF WUHDOLD L DJUDQL HLSH1LVWUXúLvQH]LW ULOHGHDVHDQJDMDvQGLVFX LLFXVRYLHWLFLL± KRW UkUHD6WDWHORU8QLWHDOH$PHULFLLúL0DULL%ULWDQLLGHDGLVFXWDQXPDL vQFRQGL LLOHFDSLWXO ULLQHFRQGL LRQDWHSULQFLSLXDGRSWDWODFRQIHULQ DGH OD&DVDEODQFDvQLDQXDULH úLUHSHWDWPHUHXSkQ ODDXJXVW &X WRDWH DFHVWHD JXYHUQXO URPkQ úL ÄRSR]L LD´ DX SXV QXPHURDVH FRQGL LL vQ WLPSXO GLVFX LLORU SH FDOH OHDX DYXW SULQ GLYHUúL HPLVDUL FX UHSUH]HQWDQ LLDOLD LORU ÌQ VLQWH] DFHVWHD DX IRVW XUP WRDUHOH GHEDUFDUH DQJORDPHULFDQ ÄVHULRDV ´vQ%DOFDQLSHGLUHF LD5RPkQLHLúLLQWUDUHD7XUFLHLvQU ]ERL DO WXUL GH DOLD L DPEHOH FHULQ H DX IRVW UHVSLQVH OD 7HKHUDQ DVLJXUDUHD LQGHSHQGHQ HL 5RPkQLHL DFFHSWDW GH DQJORDPHULFDQL úL FKLDU GH F WUH VRYLHWLFL FDUH QX DYHDX V VH LQ GH FXYkQW UHVSHFWDUHD GUHSWXULORU WHULWRULDOH UHLQWHJUDUHD vQWUHJLL 7UDQVLOYDQLL GH QRUG úL D %DVDUDELHLvQ XOWLPXO FD] OXkQGXVH vQ FDOFXO FKLDU DFFHSWDUHD SOHELVFLWXOXLW DFRU GDUHDFDOLW LLGHVWDWFREHOLJHUDQW FHUHUHDFFHSWDW ODXQPRPHQWGDWGH F WUHXQLLGLQWUHPLOLWDULLúLGLSORPD LLDPHULFDQLFDUHDXDSUHFLDWF DFHVW OXFUX XUPD V DLE ÄR LPSRUWDQ GHRVHELW vQ HYROX LD YLLWRDUH D U ]ERLXOXL´ DúDFXPVDúLvQWkPSODWGHIDSW DMXWRUDOLDWvQFD]GHDWDF XQJDUúLEXOJDU LGHHDFFHSWDW GDUFXSUHFL]DUHDF ÄQXVHYDWROHUDYUHXQ
ÌQ OHJ WXU FX DFHVW OXFUX DOLD LL RFFLGHQWDOL DX DSUHFLDW SUREOHPD 7UDQVLOYDQLHLFDILLQGÄFRPSOLFDW úLVHULRDV ´SURQXQ kQGXVHSHQWUXVROX LR QDUHD HL vQ FDGUXO UHJOHPHQW ULORU WHULWRULDOH SRVWEHOLFH ÌQ FHHD FH SULYHúWH %DVDUDELD VRYLHWLFLL VDX SURQXQ DW SHQWUX vQFRUSRUDUHD DFHVWHLD 8QLXQLL 6RYLHWLFHSXQFWXOORUGHYHGHUHILLQGVXV LQXWúLGHDQJORDPHULFDQL $O L GLSORPD L DPHULFDQL FRQVLGHUDX F DFHVW OXFUX WUHEXLD DFFHSWDW ÄQXPDLSHQWUXWHULWRULXOURPkQHVF GLQDFHOPRPHQW úLFXVFRSXOGHDLDOXQJD SH QHP L GLQ 5RPkQLD´ QHDGPL kQG ÄQLFL R RSHUD LXQH vQ DIDUD JUDQL HORU 5RPkQLHL´U úOXLWH SHQWUX FD WUXSHOH URPkQH V QX S WUXQG vQ 7UDQVLOYDQLD RFXSDW GH8QJDULDvQ 8QLLIXQF LRQDULDL'HSDUWDPHQWXOXLGH6WDWQXDX DGPLVvQWRDUFHUHDDUPHORUúLSDUWLFLSDUHDODU ]ERLvPSRWULYD*HUPDQLHLSkQ OD vQIUkQJHUHDDFHVWHLD
DWDF DUPDW vPSRWULYD DFHVWRU UL´ SULQ XUPDUH QLFL RIHQVLY SHQWUX HOLEHUDUHD 7UDQVLOYDQLHL GHEDUFDUH DOLDW OD &RQVWDQ D SXWHD IL úL VRYLHWLF vQDFHVWVFRSFKLDUGXS DXJXVWVDXWULPLVJDUQLWXULGHWUHQ vQ ]RQ úL WUXSH DHURSXUWDWH SHQWUX D RUJDQL]D UH]LVWHQ D vQ 2OWHQLD úL %DQDW VSUHDVHSXWHDIDFHPDLXúRUOHJ WXUDFXUH]LVWHQ DLXJRVODY LQIRUPDUHD JHUPDQLORU GHVSUH vQFKHLHUHD DUPLVWL LXOXL úL GHFODUDUHD U ]ERLXOXLYDULDQWD0DQLXVDXHPLWHUHDXQXLXOWLPDWXPGH]LOHF WUH WUXSHOH JHUPDQH SHQWUX D HYDFXD WHULWRULXO 5RPkQLHL vQ FD] FRQWUDU DUPDWD URPkQ XUPkQG V VH DO WXUH $UPDWHL 5RúLL YDULDQWD 1DQX vQ VLWXD LD vQ FDUH WUXSHOH JHUPDQH S U VHDX 5RPkQLD vQ ]LOH VRYLHWLFLL DFFHSWDXúLYDULDQWDQHXWUDOLW LL5RPkQLHL LQWHUGLF LDSHQWUXRULFHWUXSH VWU LQH VRYLHWLFH vQ VSHFLDO GH D S WUXQGH I U R FHUHUH H[SUHV D JXYHUQXOXL URPkQ vQ 0XQWHQLD 2OWHQLD 'REURJHD %DQDW úL vQ VXGXO 7UDQVLOYDQLHL úL &ULúDQHL GHFL SH vQWUHJXO WHULWRULX DIODW DWXQFL VXE DXWRULWDWHD JXYHUQXOXL URPkQ FDUH XUPD V ILH PHQ LQXW VXE FRQWURO GH F WUHDUPDWDURPkQ YDULDQWD0DQLX 3ULQ1DQXJXYHUQXOVDGHFODUDW GH DFRUG FX GHSODVDUHD QHVWLQJKHULW D WUXSHORU VRYLHWLFH SH WHULWRULXO 5RPkQLHL FX FRQGL LD FD DGPLQLVWUD LD V U PkQ URPkQHDVF DFHODúL OXFUXUHIHULWRUODDGPLQLVWUD LHvOFHUXVHúL0DQLX UH]HUYDUHDXQHL]RQH SHQWUX DGPLQLVWUD LD URPkQHDVF FHQWUDO JXYHUQ I U WUXSH VWU LQH YDULDQWD 1DQX UHVSLQV GH F WUH VRYLHWLFL DQJDMDPHQWXO JXYHUQHORU HQJOH]DPHULFDQúLVRYLHWLF SULQWURGHFODUD LHRILFLDO F VHDE LQGHOD RULFHDPHVWHFvQWUHEXULOHLQWHUQHDOH5RPkQLHL FRQVWLWXLUHDXQXLJXYHUQ URPkQFRQGXVGH,XOLX0DQLXvQQRUGHVWXO0ROGRYHLRFXSDWGHWUXSHOH VRYLHWLFH vQ VLWXD LD vQ FDUH ,RQ $QWRQHVFX DU IL UHIX]DW V vQFKHLH DUPLVWL LXO úL QX DU IL SXWXW IL U VWXUQDW GH OD SXWHUH ID GH DFHVW SURSXQHUH LQH[SOLFDELO WR L DOLD LL úLDX GHFODUDW DFRUGXO H[HFXWDUHD XQHLÄPLúF UL´FKLDUSHIURQWúLQXvQLQWHULRUXO ULL,XOLX0DQLXI FkQG FXQRVFXWF DYHDSURPLVVSULMLQXOXQRUJHQHUDOL LQWHUGLF LDSHQWUXIRU HOH DOLDWHGHDRFXSDWHULWRULLOHURPkQHúWLFDUHQXGHYHQHDX]RQ GHRSHUD LL vQDSRLHUHD F WUH JXYHUQXO URPkQ D IRQGXULORU % QFLL 1D LRQDOH D 5RPkQLHL FRQILVFDWH GH F WUH JHUPDQL GHEORFDUHD IRQGXULORU JXYHUQD PHQWDOH URPkQHúWL VHFKHVWUDWH vQ 0DUHD %ULWDQLH úL 68$ RIHQVLY ÄPDVLY ´ VRYLHWLF SH IURQWXO GLQ 0ROGRYD OD FHO WkU]LX GH RUH GXS VFKLPEDUHDJXYHUQXOXLvQ5RPkQLD WULPLWHUHDDWUHLEULJ ]LDHURSXUWDWHúL D GH SDUDúXWLúWL VLPXOWDQ FX VFKLPEDUHD JXYHUQXOXL SUHFXP úL DUPDPHQWXOXL QHFHVDU vQDUP ULL D GH PHPEULL DL IRUPD LXQLORU
,GHHD QHHILFLHQW GH DOWIHO D IRVW OXDW vQ FDOFXO úL GH 1LFRODH &HDXúHVFXvQ vQWLPSXOFUL]HLFHKRVORYDFH
SDWULRWLFH vQYDULDQWD0DQLXGDUúL$QWRQHVFXvQXOWLPXOFD]PDUHúDOXO QHI FkQG YUHR UHIHULUH OD J U]LOH SDWULRWLFH ERPEDUGDPHQWH DOLDWH VLPXOWDQH FX VFKLPEDUHD JXYHUQXOXL DVXSUD GLVSR]LWLYHORU JHUPDQH GLQ 5RPkQLD DVXSUD SXQFWHORU SULQ FDUH DFHVWHD SXWHDX S WUXQGH vQ DU úL DVXSUDF LORUGHFRPXQLFD LH IDSWDFFHSWDWúLFKLDUHIHFWXDWODDXJXVW vQ ]RQD 2WRSHQL % QHDVD GLVFXWDUHD FXDQWXPXOXL GHVS JXELULORU GH U ]ERL YDULDQWD JXYHUQXOXL SULQ 1DQX VRYLHWLFLL ILLQG GH DFRUG WULPLWHUHD SHVWH OLQLD IURQWXOXL D XQHL GHOHJD LL SHQWUX D GLVFXWD FX VRYLHWLFLLGHILQLWLYDUHDúLVHPQDUHDDFRUGXOXL VXJHVWLDOXL1DQXDFFHSWDW GHF WUHVRYLHWLFL VDSUHJ WLWWULPLWHUHDJHQHUDOXOXL$XUHO$OGHD SUHOXD UHD GHVS JXELULORU GH U ]ERL FHUXWH GH F WUH JXYHUQXO VRYLHWLF GH F WUH JXYHUQHOHDPHULFDQúLHQJOH]vQVFKLPEXORULF URUFRQFHVLLSULYLQGLQGXV WULLOHGHSHWUROPLQLHU IRUHVWLHU HWF YDULDQWD,RQ$QWRQHVFX $OLD LL DX UHVSLQV PDMRULWDWHD DFHVWRU FHUHUL URPkQHúWL FDUH vQ FD] GHDFFHSWDUHDUILVHUYLWLQWHUHVXOQD LRQDOQHI FkQGQLFLRUHIHULUHODYUHR GRULQ VDX LQWHQ LH GH D VH RSUL VDX P FDU GH D VH vQFHWLQL ULWPXO vQDLQW ULL VRYLHWLFH VSUH FHQWUXO (XURSHL 0DL PXOW DQJORDPHULFDQLL DX VROLFLWDW GH ILHFDUH GDW vQ PRG LPSHUDWLY LQFOXVLY SULQ PDQLIHVWHOH DUXQFDWH DVXSUD WHULWRULXOXL URPkQHVF FRQFRPLWHQW FX ERPEHOH GLQ SULP YDUDúLYDUDDQXOXL FDSLWXODUHDLPHGLDW vQWRDUFHUHDDUPHORU úLÄVXSXQHUHD´vQID DIRU HORUVRYLHWLFHÄI U QLFLRFRQGL LH´ WULPLWHUHD SHIURQWODVRYLHWLFLDXQXLHPLVDUSHQWUXDVWDELOLPRPHQWXOúLORFXOvQ FDUHIRU HOHURPkQHWUHEXLDXV WUHDF ODDF LXQH &RQFRPLWHQW DX VWDELOLW GH SULQFLSLL FDUH WUHEXLDX LPSXVH 5RPkQLHL FX SULOHMXO VHPQ ULL DFWXOXL GH FDSLWXODUH SULQFLSLL FDUH VH UHJ VHVFúLvQGRFXPHQWHOHHPLVHGH'HSDUWDPHQWXOGH6WDWvQLDQXDULH IHEUXDULH FDUHSUHFRQL]DXvQ5RPkQLDXQUHJLPGHRFXSD LHH[WUHP GH GXU SRDWH PDL GXU GHFkW SUHYHGHULOH &RQYHQ LHL GH DUPLVWL LX GLQ VHSWHPEULH
(ORFYHQWvQDFHVWVHQVHVWH3URLHFWXO'HSDUWDPHQWXOXLGH6WDWDO68$ GLQLDQXDULH UHIHULWRUODÄVWDELOLUHDFRPSRQHQ HLIRU HORUGHRFXSD LHúL FDUDFWHUXO SUREOHPHORU GH QDWXU FLYLO GXS FDSLWXODUHD QHFRQGL LRQDW D 5RPkQLHL´ 'XS FH DPLQWHD GH 'HFODUD LD FRPXQ DGRSWDW GH UHSUH]HQWDQ LL 8566 68$ úL 0DULL %ULWDQLL OD 0RVFRYD OD QRLHPEULH XQGH VH F ]XVH GH DFRUG V VH ÄDF LRQH]H vPSUHXQ vQ WRDWH SUREOHPHOH OHJDWH GH FDSLWXODUHD úL GH]DUPDUHD 5RPkQLHL´ GRFXPHQWXO VH UHIHUHD OD QHFHVLWDWHD FD ÄvQDLQWH GH FDSLWXODUHD 5RPkQLHL úL RFXSDUHD WHULWRULXOXL 5RPkQLHL´ FHOH WUHL JXYHUQH WUHEXLDX V UHDOL]H]H ÄXQ DFRUG UHIHULWRU OD GLPHQVLXQHD úL FDUDFWHUXO
/DUkQGXOHVRYLHWLFLLDXFHUXWODDSULOLH SULQSURSXQHULOH PLQLPDOHGHDUPLVWL LXvQDLQWDWHOD&DLUR úLUHSHWDWHDSRLOD6WRFNKROP FDSLWXODUHD WUXSHORU URPkQH DIODWH OD HVW GH 1LVWUX VDX DWDFDUHD GH F WUH DFHVWHDDVSDWHOXLGLVSR]LWLYXOXLJHUPDQ vQDFHVWFD]JXYHUQXOVRYLHWLFVH REOLJDV OHFRPSOHWH]HDUPDPHQWXOúLV OHSXQ ODGLVSR]L LDPDUHúDOXOXL ,RQ $QWRQHVFX úL D OXL ,XOLX 0DQLX UXSHUHD UHOD LLORU FX JHUPDQLL úL GXFHUHDGHRSHUD LLFRPXQHFX$OLD LLvPSRWULYD:HKUPDFKWXOXLvQVFR SXOÄUHVWDXU ULLLQGHSHQGHQ HLúLVXYHUDQLW LL5RPkQLHL´ UHVWDELOLUHDJUD QL HLURPkQRVRYLHWLFHvQFRQFRUGDQ FXÄDFRUGXO´GLQ GHVS JXELUL GHU ]ERL UHSDWULHUHDSUL]RQLHULORUGHU ]ERLDOLD LúLDSHUVRDQHORUVWU LQH LQWHUQDWHvQ5RPkQLD OLEHUWDWHGHPLúFDUHQHvQJU GLW SHvQWUHJWHULWRULXO 5RPkQLHLSHQWUXWUXSHOHVRYLHWLFHGDF RSHUD LXQLOHPLOLWDUHRYRUFHUH FRRSHUDUHPLOLWDU URPkQRVRYLHWLF vPSRWULYDWUXSHORUJHUPDQHúLXQJDUH SHQWUXFDÄvQWUHDJD7UDQVLOYDQLHVDXFHDPDLPDUHSDUWH´DDFHVWHLDV ILH vQDSRLDW 5RPkQLHL VWDELOLUHD OD GRULQ D S U LL URPkQH D XQHL OHJ WXUL SROLWLFHúLPLOLWDUHFXSDUWHDVRYLHWLF
SDUWLFLS ULLILHF UXLDODRFXSD LDúLDGPLQLVWUD LDPLOLWDU DSUREOHPHORUGHQDWXU FLYLO D 5RPkQLHL´ &D VROX LL DOWHUQDWLYH VDX DYXW vQ YHGHUH Ä$ 2FXSD LD VRYLHWLF FX R FRPLVLH LQWHUDOLDW GH FRQWURO VDX R FRPLVLH SROLWLF FRQVXOWDWLY WULSDUWLW ´ Ä% 3DUWLFLSDUHD VLPEROLF D IRU HORU DPHULFDQH OD RFXSDUHD úL FRQGXFHUHD PLOLWDU ´ Ä& &RQGXFHUHD PLOLWDU úL GH RFXSD LH VRYLHWLF FX R PLVLXQH PLOLWDU DQJORDPHULFDQ DWDúDW SH OkQJ FRPDQGDQWXO úHI VRYLHWLF SHQWUX OHJ WXU úL REVHUYDUH´ Ä' *XYHUQ PLOLWDU úL GH RFXSD LH GRDU VRYLHWLF´ Ä(&RQGXFHUHPLOLWDU úLGHRFXSD LHPL[W IRUPDW GLQIRU HVRYLHWLFHEULWDQLFH úLDPHULFDQH´ ÌQFRPSOHWDUHDDFHVWRUSUREOHPHGHSULQFLSLXODIHEUXDULH -DPHV &OHPHQWGLUHFWRUXO6HF LHLSHQWUXDIDFHULHXURSHQHD'HSDUWDPHQWXOXLGH6WDW I FHD FXQRVFXW DPEDVDGRUXOXL 68$ vQ 0DUHD %ULWDQLH -RKQ * :LQDQW SUHYHGHULOHFDUHXUPDXV ILHLPSXVH5RPkQLHLvQPRPHQWXOFDSLWXO ULLJkQGLWH ÄvQSULQFLSDOSHQWUXDVLJXUDUHDVHFXULW LLúLFRQWLQX ULLPDLGHSDUWHDU ]ERLXOXL vPSRWULYD*HUPDQLHLúLFDUHDXLPSRUWDQWHLPSOLFD LLSROLWLFH´$FHVWHDWUHEXLDX ÄV ILH LPSXVH´ OD GRULQ D FHORU WUHL PDUL SXWHUL FDUH UHSUH]HQWDX 1D LXQLOH 8QLWH5RPkQLDÄQHDYkQGSRVLELOLWDWHDGHDOHJHUHOLEHU GHDFRQVLP LVDXQX´ (OH VH UHIHUHDX OD ÄFDSLWXODUHD QHFRQGL LRQDW ´ ÄGHPRELOL]DUH úL GH]DUPDUH´ ÄSUHGDUHD PDWHULDOHORU GH U ]ERL´ ÄRFXSD LH´ ÄFRQWUROXO SUHVHL UDGLRXOXL úL SRúWHL´ ÄFULPLQDOLL GH U ]ERL´ ÄFRQWUROXO PLúF ULL SRSXOD LHL´ ÄGHVS JXELUL´ ÄRUJDQL]D LLURPkQHúWLLQGH]LUDELOH´ÄFKHOWXLHOLQHFHVLWDWHGHRFXSD LH´ÄGXUDWD úLLQWUDUHDvQYLJRDUHDLQVWUXPHQWXOXLGHFDSLWXODUH´HWF
5HIHULQGXVH OD DFHVWH FRQGL LL VRYLHWLFH JHQHUDOXO *60DUVFKDOO FRPDQGDQWXO0DUHOXL6WDW0DMRUDO$UPDWHL68$DSUHFLDF vQVLWXD LD vQ FDUH JXYHUQXO GH OD %XFXUHúWL OHDU DFFHSWD DWXQFL 5RPkQLD ÄDU OXD DVXSUDVDVWDWXWXOGHFREHOLJHUDQ ´ 6SHUkQG F YD RE LQH FRQGL LL PDL DYDQWDMRDVH GLQ SDUWHD DQJOR DPHULFDQLORU,RQ$QWRQHVFXDFRQVLGHUDWSURSXQHULOHVRYLHWLFLORUFDILLQG QHVDWLVI F WRDUH úL D GHFLV WHUJLYHUVDUHD GLVFX LLORU /D IHO D SURFHGDW úL ,XOLX0DQLXÌQILQDOvQV OLGHUXOQD LRQDO U QLVWDDFFHSWDWODLXQLH GXS FRQVWLWXLUHD %ORFXOXL 1D LRQDO 'HPRFUDW V vQFKHLH DUPLVWL LXO SH ED]DSURSXQHULORUÄIRUPXODWHGHDOLD L´I U DVHSUHFL]DODFDUHYDULDQW VHUHIHUHDGHúLGXS vQ HOHJHUHDDQJORVRYLHWLF GLQPDL UHIHULWRUOD SUHSRQGHUHQ D 0RVFRYHL vQ SUREOHPHOH URPkQHúWL úL FKLDU vQDLQWH GH GHEDUFDUHDDOLDW GLQ1RUPDQGLDDOLD LLGHFLVHVHU ODLXQLHV vQWUHUXS RULFH FRQWDFWH FX SDUWHD URPkQ FRQVLGHUkQG SURSXQHULOH YDJL úL QHUHDOLVWH ([LJHQ HOHURPkQHúWLGHUHFXQRDúWHUHDJUDQL HLSH1LVWUXúLH]LW ULOH vQDVHDQJDMDvQGLVFX LLVHULRDVHFXVRYLHWLFLLFDUHSULPLVHU GHODDQJOR DPHULFDQL DVHQWLPHQWXO GH D WUDWD FX URPkQLL SUREOHPD LHúLULL ULL GLQ $[ KRW UkUHD6WDWHORU8QLWHDOH$PHULFLLúL0DULL%ULWDQLLGHDGLVFXWD QXPDLvQFRQGL LLOHFDSLWXO ULLQHFRQGL LRQDWH DGRSWDW OD&DVDEODQFDvQ LDQXDULH úLUHIX]XODFHVWRUDGHDDFRUGDDVLVWHQ SROLWLF úLPLOLWDU 5RPkQLHL VDX FKLDU XQHOH JDUDQ LL vQ PRPHQWXO WUHFHULL GH SDUWHD 1D LXQLORU 8QLWH DX IRVW GRDU XQLL IDFWRUL RELHFWLYL úL VXELHFWLYL FDUH DX I FXWFDSUHOLPLQDULLOHGHDUPLVWL LXV HúXH]H %RPEDUGDPHQWHOH DHULHQH HIHFWXDWH GH DYLD LD DQJORDPHULFDQ DVXSUDWHULWRULXOXLQD LRQDOvQVSHFLDOvQSULP YDUDúLYDUDDQXOXL DX GH]DP JLWúLVSXOEHUDWúLHOHVSHUDQ HOHURPkQLORUSULYLQGUHDOL]DUHDXQHL vQ HOHJHULGRDUFXUHSUH]HQWDQ LLSXWHULORURFFLGHQWDOH 7UHFHUHD5RPkQLHLGHSDUWHD1D LXQLORU8QLWH úLSDUWLFLSDUHDOD&DPSDQLDGLQ9HVW ÌQ YDUD DQXOXL vQWUR VLWXD LH VWUDWHJLF H[WUDRUGLQDU GH FRPSOH[ vQ FDUH IURQWXULOH úL XFUDLQLHQH UXSVHVHU GLVSR]LWLYXO GH OXSW GLQHVWXO ULLvQFDGUXORSHUD LHLÄ,DúL&KLúLQ X´UHJHOH0LKDL,vQ
DFRUGFXSDUWLGHOHFDUHFRQVWLWXLVHU %ORFXO1D LRQDO'HPRFUDW 3DUWLGXO 1D LRQDO U QHVF3DUWLGXO1D LRQDO/LEHUDO3DUWLGXO6RFLDO'HPRFUDWúL 3DUWLGXO&RPXQLVW5RPkQ úLRSDUWHGLQFRUSXOGHFRPDQG DODUPDWHLD GHFLVODDXJXVWDUHVWDUHDPDUHúDOXOXL,RQ$QWRQHVFXFRQVWLWXLUHDXQXL QRX JXYHUQ úL WUHFHUHD 5RPkQLHL GH SDUWHD 1D LXQLORU 8QLWH &RQVLGHUDW GH ,XOLX 0DQLX FD ÄR ORYLWXU GH VWDW HJDO FX R PDUH UHYROX LH´ DFWXO URPkQHVFGHODDXJXVW DIRVWUHFHSWDWvQHSRF GUHSWXQDFWGH VXYHUDQLWDWH úL GHPQLWDWH QD LRQDO PHQLW V VDOYH]H DUD GLQ VLWXD LD GLILFLO vQFDUHVHDIODúLV GXF ODFUHDUHDFRQGL LLORUQHFHVDUHHOLEHU ULL S U LLGHQRUGYHVWD ULLRFXSDW GH8QJDULDvQ ,PHGLDW I U QLFL R FRQGL LH VDX GHIHF LXQH 5RPkQLD D SXV OD GLVSR]L LD DOLD LORU VRYLHWLFLORU vQ VSHFLDO XQ vQVHPQDW SRWHQ LDO PLOLWDU GLQ SRSXOD LD ULL LQWURGXFkQG vQ OXSW SkQ OD RFWRPEULH FkQG D IRVW UHvQWUHJLW JUDQL D GH YHVW D ULL SHVWH GH PLOLWDULFRQWLQXkQGDSRLDúDFXPSURFHGDVHúLGXS HOLEHUDUHD%DVDUDELHL úLDS U LLGHQRUGD%XFRYLQHLvQLXOLH V úLvQGHSOLQHDVF REOLJD LLOH DVXPDWH SULQ &RQYHQ LD GH DUPLVWL LX GLQ VHSWHPEULH FDUH DX LQFOXV SDUWLFLSDUHD DUPDWHL URPkQH OD RSHUD LLOH PLOLWDUH GHVI úXUDWH SH WHULWRULLOH8QJDULHL&HKRVORYDFLHLúL$XVWULHLvQWUXQVSD LXHXURSHDQGH DQYHUJXU SHGLUHF LD%XFXUHúWL±%XGDSHVWD±9LHQD±3UDJD SkQ OD VIkUúLWXOU ]ERLXOXL $SUHFLLQGDSRUWXOURPkQHVFODvQIUkQJHUHD5HLFKXOXLvQDOWHSHUVR QDOLW L úL RILFLDOLW L SROLWLFH úL VWDWDOH DOH PDULORU SXWHUL DOLDWH DQDOLúWL SROLWLFL úL PLOLWDUL QX DX H]LWDW V DILUPH F 5RPkQLD ÄD DGXV SULQ FRQWULEX LD HL R VFXUWDUH D U ]ERLXOXL GH FHO SX LQ úDVH OXQL´ F SULQ HIHFWLYHOHSHFDUHOHDYHDDQJDMDWHvQOXSW vQLDQXDULH VHVLWXDÄvQDO SDWUXOHDUkQGvQFHHDFHSULYHúWHQXP UXOGHVROGD LFXFDUHSDUWLFLS OD E W OLDSHQWUXGLVWUXJHUHDQD]LVPXOXL´ ÌQWUH FHOH PDL LPSRUWDQWH DYDQWDMH VWUDWHJLFH SH FDUH OHD DGXV 5RPkQLDúLDUPDWDVD1D LXQLORU8QLWHGXS DXJXVW VDXVLWXDW FRQWULEX LHHVHQ LDO ODSU EXúLUHDGHIHQVLYHLJHUPDQHODIODQFXOVXGLFDO IURQWXOXL HVW HXURSHDQ úL OD SXOYHUL]DUHD GLVSR]LWLYXOXL GH OXSW DO :HKUPDFKWXOXLvQ3HQLQVXOD%DOFDQLF GHVFKLGHUHDÄSRU LL´)RFúDQLORU úL SULQ DFHDVWD D ÄSRU LORU´ (XURSHL FHQWUDOH SH YDOHD 'XQ ULL úL DOH (XURSHLGHVXGHVWSHQWUXvQDLQWDUHDDUPDWHORUVRYLHWLFHDúDFXPFHUXVHU LQVLVWHQWUHSUH]HQWDQ LL68$úL0DULL%ULWDQLLvQDLQWHGHDXJXVW UHDOL]DUHD vQWUXQ WLPS VFXUW D XQHL PDUL WUDQVOD LL D IURQWXOXL VXGHVW
HXURSHDQI U HJDOvQLVWRULDFHOXLGHDOGRLOHDU ]ERLPRQGLDO vQWUH úL NP vQ ]LOH PRGLILFDUH LPSRUWDQW vQEDODQ DGHIRU HDFHORU GRX PDUL FRDOL LL GH IRU H DIODWH vQ OXSW SULQ SXQHUHD OD GLVSR]L LD 1D LXQLORU8QLWHDSHVWHGHPLOLWDULURPkQLPRELOL]D L LPSDFW QHJDWLYDVXSUDPDúLQLLGHU ]ERLJHUPDQHSULQVLVWDUHDLPHGLDW DRULF UHL DSURYL]LRQ UL GLQ 5RPkQLD FX SURGXVH GH ED] SHQWUX FRQWLQXDUHD U ]ERLXOXL vQVSHFLDOSHWUROúLFHUHDOH SURYRFDUHXQXLDGHY UDWVHLVPvQ VLVWHPXOSROLWLFGRPLQDWGH$[ FRQWULEX LHPLOLWDU FRQWLQX úLHILFLHQW SkQ OD VIkUúLWXO U ]ERLXOXL SH R GLUHF LH LPSRUWDQW GH S WUXQGHUH VSUH FHQWUXO(XURSHL DPSOXHIRUWHFRQRPLFED]DWSHSURSULLOHSRVLELOLW LDOH ULL úL GHVI úXUDW FRQFRPLWHQW FX vQGHSOLQLUHD XQRU vPSRY U WRDUH REOLJD LLDVXPDWHSULQ&RQYHQ LDGHDUPLVWL LXGLQVHSWHPEULH 'LQ PRPHQWXO vQ FDUH D WUHFXW GH SDUWHD 1D LXQLORU 8QLWH OD DXJXVW 5RPkQLD D DGXV R FRQWULEX LH LPSRUWDQW OD vQIUkQJHUHD *HUPDQLHLúL8QJDULHLSODVkQGXVHSHIURQWXOHVWHXURSHDQSHORFXOGRL GXS 8QLXQHD 6RYLHWLF úL DVLJXUkQGXúL SULQ DFHDVWD VWDWXWXO GH VWDW FREHOLJHUDQWFXWRDWHF QXDIRVWSULPLW vQFRDOL LDDQWLKLWOHULVW 6HPQLILFDWLY SHQWUX FDUDFWHUXO LQHGLW DO DF LXQLL URPkQHúWL ± DSUHFLDW FDILLQGI U SUHFHGHQWvQLVWRULDXQLYHUVDO ±HVWHFRPSDUD LDFX DOWH VWDWH DIODWH vQWUR VLWXD LH VLPLODU ,WDOLD GH H[HPSOX D vQFKHLDW DUPLVWL LX FX 1D LXQLOH 8QLWH OD VHSWHPEULH I FXW SXEOLF OD VHSWHPEULH vQV GRDURPLF SDUWHGLQGLYL]LLOHVDOHDXWUHFXWGHSDUWHD $OLD LORU I U D OXSWD LPHGLDW vPSRWULYD *HUPDQLHL F UHLD L VD GHFODUDW U ]ERL DELD OD RFWRPEULH &X WRDWH DFHVWHD L VD UHFXQRVFXW FDOLWDWHD GH FREHOLJHUDQW %XOJDULD D vQWUHUXSW UHOD LLOH FX *HUPDQLD OD VHSWHPEULH GDUPDULOHVDOHXQLW LQXDXGHFODQúDWLPHGLDWOXSWD vPSRWULYD :HKUPDFKWXOXL )LQODQGD D vQFKHLDW DUPLVWL LXO FX 1D LXQLOH 8QLWHOD VHSWHPEULH GDUQXúLDDVXPDWQLFLRREOLJD LHGHOXSW vPSRWULYD WUXSHORU JHUPDQH 8QJDULD GHúL D VHPQDW DUPLVWL LX OD LDQXDULH FkQGFHDPDLPDUHSDUWHDWHULWRULXOXLV XHUDHOLEHUDWúL VDREOLJDWV LQWURGXF vQOXSW GLYL]LLQXDSDUWLFLSDWODHIRUWXOFRPXQ DO1D LXQLORU8QLWHFXQLFLRXQLWDWHIRU HOHVDOHFRQWLQXkQGOXSWDDO WXUL GH:HKUPDFKWSkQ ODvQIUkQJHUHDGHILQLWLY DDFHVWXLDGLQPDL 5RPkQLDDSXVvQVFKLPEODGLVSR]L LD$OLD LORULPHGLDWúLI U QLFL R FRQGL LH XQ vQVHPQDW SRWHQ LDO PLOLWDU GLQ SRSXOD LD ULL WRWDOLWDWHD RUJDQLVPXOXL PLOLWDU FDUH DYHD R FRQGXFHUH FHQWUDOL]DW VWUXFWXUL ELQH GHILQLWH úL FDUH GLVSXQHD GH GLYL]LL RSHUDWLYH úL GH
LQVWUXF LHHVFDGULOHGHDYLD LHFXDYLRDQH GHOXSW QDYH GHU ]ERLIOXYLDOHúLPDULWLPHPDLLPSRUWDQWH3HSDUFXUVXOU ]ERLXOXLGXV DO WXULGH1D LXQLOH8QLWHFXDQWXPXOIRU HORUPLOLWDUHURPkQHDRVFLODWvQ IXQF LH GH SUHYHGHULOH &RQYHQ LHL GH DUPLVWL LX GLQ VHSWHPEULH DOH 3URWRFROXOXL PLOLWDU URPkQRVRYLHWLF GLQ RFWRPEULH úL DOH DOWRU H[LJHQ H DOH &RPLVLHL $OLDWH GH &RQWURO SDUWHD VRYLHWLF GDU QLFLRGDW QX D IRVW LQIHULRU DQJDMDPHQWHORU DVXPDWH GH DU ÌQ QLFL XQ PRPHQW vQ 5RPkQLD UHSUH]HQWDQ LL DOLD LORU QX DX LQWHUYHQLW SHQWUX vQILLQ DUHDGHXQLW LPLOLWDUHFDUHV LQWUHvQOXSW GHRDUHFHvQSHUPDQHQ SRWHQ LDOXOPLOLWDUGLVSRQLELODIRVWSXVODGLVSR]L LDIURQWXOXL $QDOL]kQG LPSRUWDQWD FRQWULEX LH URPkQHDVF OD U ]ERL GHSXWDWXO ODEXULVW HQJOH] ,YRU 7KRPDV GHFODUD vQ &DPHUD &RPXQHORU OD VIkUúLWXO DQXOXL Ä'HYUHPHFH5RPkQLDHVWHDSDWUD DU FDHIHFWLYSHIURQW vPSRWULYD*HUPDQLHLDUILFD]XOGHDVHSURSXQHV LVHDFRUGHXQVWDWXWGH FREHOLJHUDQ ´ 1RXOVWDWXOMXULGLFLQWHUQD LRQDODO5RPkQLHL /DVFXUWWLPSGXS WUHFHUHDGHSDUWHD1D LXQLORU8QLWHODDXJXVW QRXO JXYHUQ URPkQ D LQIRUPDW UHSUH]HQWDQ LL JXYHUQHORU 68$ 8566úL0DULL%ULWDQLLOD$QNDUDGHVSUHQRXDVLWXD LHSROLWLFRPLOLWDU GLQ DU úLDOXDWDFWGHGHFODUD LDFRPLVDUXOXLSHQWUXDIDFHULOH([WHUQHDO 8QLXQLL 6RYLHWLFH 90 0RORWRY GLQ DXJXVW SULQ FDUH DFHVWD UHvQQRLDGHFODUD LLOHJXYHUQXOXLVRYLHWLFGLQDSULOLH FRQIRUPF URUD 0RVFRYD VH DQJDMD V QX DQH[H]H WHULWRULL URPkQHúWL VDX V VFKLPEH UHJLPXO SROLWLF H[LVWHQW &RQFRPLWHQW GLSORPDWXO VRYLHWLF D SUHFL]DW F GDF DUPDWD URPkQ vQWRUFHD DUPHOH ÄvPSRWULYD FRWURSLWRULORU JHUPDQL´ IDSWvPSOLQLWODDFHDGDW ±QQ úLSDUWLFLSDODOXSWDvPSRWULYDWUXSHORU JHUPDQHúLXQJDUH5RPkQLDÄYDDYHDVSULMLQXOWRWDODO8QLXQLL6RYLHWLFH´ /D DXJXVW vQ ED]D DQJDM ULL WRWDOH D DUPDWHL URPkQH vQ OXSWD vPSRWULYD WUXSHORU JHUPDQH GLQ 5RPkQLD GLQ VHDUD ]LOHL GH DXJXVW úLDGHFODU ULLVW ULLGHU ]ERL*HUPDQLHL DXJXVW PLQLVWUXO$IDFHULORU6WU LQH*ULJRUH1LFXOHVFX%X]HúWLDI FXWFXQRVFXW DPEDVDGRULORU68$úL0DULL%ULWDQLLGHOD$QNDUDF ÄJXYHUQXOURPkQ FDUHGHDFXPvQDLQWHVHDIO vQVLWXD LDGHIDFWRGHFREHOLJHUDQWGRUHúWHFD 1D LXQLOH8QLWHV OUHFXQRDVF GUHSWDOLDW´
$SRL OD DXJXVW JXYHUQXO URPkQ D GHFLV V QX PDL UHFXQRDVF &URD LD6ORYDFLDúL5HSXEOLFD6RFLDO ,WDOLDQ FRQVLGHUDWH DILÄFUHD LXQLDUWLILFLDOHDOHUHJLPXOXLQD]LVW´úLDUXSWUHOD LLOHGLSORPD WLFH FX 8QJDULD QHOXkQG vQV LQL LDWLYD GHFODU ULL VW ULL GH U ]ERL DFHV WHLD&RQFRPLWHQWDUHFXQRVFXWJXYHUQXOSURYL]RULXIUDQFH]FRQGXVGH JHQHUDOXO&KDUOHVGH*DXOOHúLDI FXWFXQRVFXWF GRUHúWHV vQWUH LQ FX DFHVWD ÄUHOD LLOH FHOH PDL FRUGLDOH vQ VSLULWXO YHFKLL úL QHGH]PLQ LWHL DPLFL LL´ /DVHSWHPEULH GXS FHWUXSHOHXQJDUHúLJHUPDQHDXDWDFDW VHSWHPEULH ODVXGGHOLQLDYUHPHOQLF GHGHPDUFD LHLPSXV OD DXJXVW JXYHUQXO URPkQ D FRQVWDWDW SULQ GHFODUD LD PLQLVWUXOXL $IDFHULORU 6WU LQH *ULJRUH 1LFXOHVFX%X]HúWL F 8QJDULD VD SXV vQ ÄVWDUHGHU ]ERLFX5RPkQLD´ ÌQ SRILGD DYDQWDMHORU SH FDUH OH DGXVHVH 1D LXQLORU 8QLWH SULQ WUHFHUHDGHSDUWHDDFHVWRUDODDXJXVW úLDOXSWHLSHFDUHDUPDWD URPkQ R GXFHD DO WXUL GH $UPDWD 5RúLH vPSRWULYD WUXSHORU JHUPDQH úL XQJDUHODVHSWHPEULH 5RPkQLHLLDIRVWLPSXV &RQYHQ LDGHDU PLVWL LXFDUHÄUHJOHPHQWD´SUREOHPHFHGHS úHDXFDUDFWHUXOXQXLDVHPH QHD GRFXPHQW DERUGkQG úL DVSHFWH SROLWLFH WHULWRULDOH HFRQRPLFH DGPLQLVWUDWLYH HWF 3UDFWLF 5RPkQLHL L VD LPSXV FDSLWXODUHD QHFRQGL LR QDW GHFLV FXPXOWWLPSvQDLQWHGHPDULOHSXWHULILLQGFRQVLGHUDW XQVWDW vQYLQV IRVW LQDPLF , VD UHIX]DW GH DVHPHQHD FDOLWDWHD GH DOLDW VDX FHO SX LQGHFREHOLJHUDQW &DXUPDUHDLPSXQHULLUHJLPXOXLGXUGHDUPLVWL LXSROLWLFDH[WHUQ D 5RPkQLHL VD GHVI úXUDW VXE VWULFWD VXSUDYHJKHUH úL LPL[WLXQH D
&RQVWLWXLW vQ,WDOLDGHQRUGODVHSWHPEULH GXS HOLEHUDUHDOXL %HQLWR 0XVVROLQL OD VHSWHPEULH GH F WUH XQ GHWDúDPHQW GH SDUDúXWLúWL JHUPDQL ÌQUHDOLWDWHUHOD LLOHvQFHWDVHU LPHGLDWGXS DXJXVW 6D LQXWVHDPDúLGHDFFHSWDUHDGHF WUH0DULOH3XWHULDFDUDFWHUXOXL QHMXVWDOGLFWDWXOXLGHOD9LHQDGLQDXJXVW /DRFWRPEULH DXIRVWUXSWHUHOD LLOHGLSORPDWLFHFX-DSRQLDúL FXJXYHUQXOFKLQH]SURMDSRQH]GHOD1DQMLQJ &RQYHQ LD GH DUPLVWL LX UHVWDELOHD ÄIURQWLHUD´ URPkQRVRYLHWLF LPSXV ODLXQLH &RQVLGHUDvQV KRW UkULOHGLFWDWXOXLGHOD9LHQDGLQ DXJXVW úL GHFLGHD FD Ä7UDQVLOYDQLD VDX FHD PDL PDUH SDUWH D HL V ILH UHVWLWXLW 5RPkQLHLVXEFRQGL LDFRQILUP ULLWUDWDWXOXLGHSDFH´
JXYHUQXOXL VRYLHWLF úL D S U LL VRYLHWLFH D &RPLVLHL $OLDWH GH &RQWURO FDUHDIXQF LRQDWvQFRQIRUPLWDWHFXSUHYHGHULOH&RQYHQ LHLGHDUPLVWL LX GLQVHSWHPEULH SkQ ODQRLHPEULH ÌQDFHVWFRQWH[WFKLDU UHOD LLOH GLSORPDWLFH DOH 5RPkQLHL FX 68$ úL 0DUHD %ULWDQLH DX IRVW UHJOHPHQWDWHSULQLQWHUPHGLXODFHVWH&RPLVLL 6LWXD LD ULL VD DJUDYDW vQ RFWRPEULH vQ XUPD DFRUGXOXL GH SURFHQWDMVWDELOLWvQWUH:LQVWRQ&KXUFKLOOúL,96WDOLQSULQFDUH5RPkQLDD IRVW SODVDW vQ SURSRU LH GH vQ VIHUD GH LQIOXHQ VRYLHWLF 'LQ DFHO PRPHQW0RVFRYDúLDLQWHQVLILFDWDF LXQHDGHLPSXQHUHDSURSULXOUHJLP SROLWLFúLDGLUHF LRQDWSROLWLFDH[WHUQ URPkQHDVF LQWUkQGFKLDUvQFRQIOLFW FX DOLD LL 6WDWHOH 8QLWH úL 0DUHD %ULWDQLH GXS FH DFHúWLD DX UHIX]DW V UHFXQRDVF JXYHUQXOGU3HWUX*UR]DLPSXVGH0RVFRYDODPDUWLH 'HDOWIHODYkQGQHYRLHGHVSULMLQXOPLOLWDUVRYLHWLFSHIURQWXOGH(VW 68$úL0DUHD%ULWDQLHDXO VDWVRYLHWLFLORUV vQ HOHDJ vQDLQWHFKLDUGH LPSXQHUHD&RQYHQ LHLGHDUPLVWL LXF YRUDYHDSULRULWDWHvQVROX LRQDUHD WXWXURU SUREOHPHORU DIODWH vQ GLVSXW FX 5RPkQLD ÌQ DFHVW VHQV vQF GLQ PDUWLH $QWKRQ\(GHQPLQLVWUXOGHH[WHUQHEULWDQLFGHFODUD Ä3ROLWLFD QRDVWU ID GH5RPkQLDHVWHVXERUGRQDW UHOD LLORUFX8566úLQRLQX YUHPV DFFHSW PQLFLXQDQJDMDPHQWVDXV vQWUHSULQGHPYUHRDF LXQH I U GHSOLQDFXQRúWLQ úLFRQVLP PkQWXOJXYHUQXOXLVRYLHWLF´$SRLOD PDL DFHODúL $QWKRQ\ (GHQ vQ ED]D LQVWUXF LXQLORU OXL :LQVWRQ &KXUFKLOODSURSXVDPEDVDGRUXOXLVRYLHWLFOD/RQGUDFD8566V DLE SULQFLSDODUHVSRQVDELOLWDWHvQSUREOHPHOHURPkQHúWLLDU0DUHD%ULWDQLHvQ FHOHJUHFHúWL/DIHOVDSURFHGDWúLGXS VHPQDUHD&RQYHQ LHLGHDUPLVWL LX FX 5RPkQLD OD VHSWHPEULH FkQG OD RFWRPEULH :LQVWRQ &KXUFKLOOLDSURSXVOXL,96WDOLQPRQVWUXRVXODFRUGGHSURFHQWDMI U FD FLQHYDGLQFRQGXFHUHD5RPkQLHLV ILHLQIRUPDW ÌQED]DVLQLVWUHLvQ HOHJHULJXYHUQHOHGHOD/RQGUD FXSUHF GHUH úL :DVKLQJWRQ DX O VDW PkQ OLEHU VRYLHWLFLORU UHSUH]HQ DQ LL FHORU GRX PDULSXWHULQHLPSOLFkQGXVHvQDFWLYLW LOH&RPLVLHL$OLDWHGH&RQWUROQLFL FHOSX LQvQFDGUXOOLPLWDWVWDELOLWGHODvQFHSXW0DLPXOWOLVDFHUXWV QX GHSXQ SUHD PXOW ]HO úL V ODVH PDUHúDOXOXL 5,0DOLQRYVNL ÄDXWRULWDWH GHSOLQ ´ vQ FRQGXFHUHD WUHEXULORU GLQ 5RPkQLD 3HQWUX D IL úL PDL FODU
)XQF LDGHSUHúHGLQWHDO&RPLVLHL$OLDWHGH&RQWURODIRVWvQFUHGLQ DW PDUHúDOXOXL VRYLHWLF 5, 0DOLQRYVNL 68$ DX IRVW UHSUH]HQWDWH GH JHQHUDOXO &RUWODQG56FKD\OHULDU0DUHD%ULWDQLHGHYLFHDPLUDOXO'RQDOG)6WHYHQVRY
:LQVWRQ&KXUFLOODGHFODUDWODQRLHPEULH Ä$WkWDWLPSFkWUXúLLQH ODV PkQ OLEHU vQ*UHFLDQXSXWHPIDFHPDLPXOWGHFkWV ILPVSHFWDWRUL ODFHHDFHVHvQWkPSO vQ5RPkQLD´ ÌQPRPHQWXOvQFDUHHUDFODUF VRYLHWLFLLHUDXGHFLúLV LPSXQ SULQ IRU XQ JXYHUQ SURFRPXQLVW UHSUH]HQWDQ LL FHORU GRX PDUL SXWHUL GHPRFUDWLFHvQ&RPLVLD$OLDW GH&RQWUROGRULQGVWDELOLWDWHvQ5RPkQLDDX SURWHVWDW OD IHEUXDULH 'RULQG VWDELOLWDWH vQ 5RPkQLD GHOHJD LL FHORU GRX VWDWH DX SURWHVWDW SH OkQJ JHQHUDOXO 9LQRJUDGRY ORF LLWRUXO PDUHúDOXOXL 5,0DOLQRYVNL ID GH GHPRQVWUD LLOH YLROHQWH GH VWUDG RUJDQL]DWH GH F WUH FRPXQLúWL FHUkQG V ILH PHQ LQXW XQ JXYHUQ UHSUH ]HQWDWLYGHFRDOL LH3HVWHFkWHYD]LOHODIHEUXDULH 'HSDUWDPHQWXO GH6WDWDO68$VDSURQXQ DWSHQWUX LQGHSHQGHQ D5RPkQLHL JXYHUQGH FRDOL LH UHSUH]HQWDW GH WRDWH FDWHJRULLOH SROLWLFH úL VRFLDOH vPSRWULYD IRORVLULL IRU HL VDX úLFDQHORU SROLWLFH SHQWUX DGXFHUHD OD SXWHUH D RULF UXL JUXS SROLWLF vPSRWULYD vQFHUF ULORU GH VFKLPEDUH SULQ ÄPLMORDFH GH GH]RUGLQH´SULQÄXWLOL]DUHDIRU HL´VDXSULQÄLQWLPLG UL´ SHQWUXDOHJHULOR FDOHúLJHQHUDOHSHED]DÄYRWXOXLOLEHUúLVHFUHW´VDXSHQWUXDOWHÄPLMORDFH GHPRFUDWLFH´ SHQWUXPHQ LQHUHDRUGLQLLLQWHUQHGHF WUHDXWRULW L&RQFR PLWHQW D UHFRQILUPDW VSULMLQXO DFRUGDW UHJHOXL 0LKDL , D FRQVLGHUDW F GRULQ D JXYHUQXOXL URPkQ GH D VH DFRUGD 5RPkQLHL VWDWXWXO GH FREHOL JHUDQ WUHEXLD SULYLW FX ÄVLPSDWLH´ OD IHO FD úL H[WLQGHUHD DGPLQLVWUD LHL URPkQHúWLvQQRUGYHVWXO ULLvQV GXS WHUPLQDUHDU ]ERLXOXL&XDFHODúL SULOHMDPHULFDQLLVDXSURQXQ DWSHQWUXÄROLEHUWDWHUHDO DSUHVHL´OLPLWDW GRDU OD ÄFHQ]XUD PRWLYDW PLOLWDU´ SUHFXP úL SHQWUX UHOXDUHD FRPHU XOXL H[WHULRUDWXQFLFkQGÄFRQGL LLOHRYRUSHUPLWH´3HP VXUDDFXWL] ULLFUL]HL SROLWLFH GLQ DU OD IHEUXDULH FRQVLGHUkQG F HYHQLPHQWHOH GLQ 5RPkQLD FRQWUDYHQHDX KRW UkULORU GH OD ,DOWD 'HSDUWDPHQWXO GH 6WDW DPHULFDQ D FHUXW DPEDVDGRUXOXL $+DULPDQQ V VROLFLWH LQWHUYHQ LD 0RVFRYHLSHQWUXPHQ LQHUHDXQXLJXYHUQGHFRDOL LHFkWPDLUHSUH]HQWDWLY vQ 5RPkQLD &HUHUHD DGUHVDW OXL $,9vúLQVNL GH UHSUH]HQWDQ LL 68$ úL 0DULL%ULWDQLLvQ&RPLVLD$OLDW GH&RQWUROGLQIHEUXDULH SULYLQG ÄRFRQVXOWDUHSUHDODELO ´DU PDVI U HFRXGHRDUHFHvQFRQIRUPLWDWHFX vQ HOHJHULOHGHOD0RVFRYDGLQRFWRPEULH UHSUH]HQWDQWXOJXYHUQXOXL
/DPDUWLH UHSUH]HQWDQWXOEULWDQLFvQ5RPkQLD0DUMRULEDQNV OD LQIRUPDW SH $,9vúLQVNL F JXYHUQXO EULWDQLF GRUHD XQ JXYHUQ ÄOLEHU´ vQ 5RPkQLDúLQXXQÄUHJLPVLQGLFDOLVW´
VRYLHWLFDUHSOLFDWF JXYHUQXOV XQXVDDPHVWHFDWvQ*UHFLDúLF 8566 DúWHDSW FDvQ5RPkQLDÄV ILHVSULMLQLW LDUQXI FXW V HúXH]HGHF WUH UHSUH]HQWDQ LLEULWDQLFL´,PHGLDWGLSORPDWXOEULWDQLFDUHFXQRVFXWÄLQWHUH VHOHVSHFLDOHDOH8566vQ5RPkQLD´GXS FDUHDPDLSUHFL]DWvQF RGDW F JXYHUQXOEULWDQLFGRUHDLQVWLWXLUHDXQXLJXYHUQGHFRDOL LHFXUHSUH]HQ WDUHDFRUHFW DSDUWLGHORUSROLWLFHFRQGXVGHXQQHXWUX 3HQWUXDQXO VDYUHRvQGRLDO DVXSUDGRULQ HLJXYHUQXOXLHQJOH]GH DUHVSHFWDvQ HOHJHULOHFXFHOVRYLHWLFODPDUWLH :LQVWRQ&KXUFKLOO D WULPLV XQ PHVDM DPEDVDGRUXOXL EULWDQLF OD 0RVFRYD &ODUN .OHUU SULQ FDUHLDFHUXWV WUDQVPLW OXL900RORWRYF 0DUHD%ULWDQLHFRQWLQX V DFFHSWHÄSUHSRQGHUHQ DVRYLHWLF vQ5RPkQLDGDUF GRUHúWHFRQVXOW UL FRPXQH vQ VSLULWXO vQ HOHJHULORU GH OD ,DOWD $SRL OD PDUWLH D UHDPLQWLW OXL $QWKRQ\ (GHQ F URPkQLL úL EXOJDULL ÄDX IRVW GXúPDQLL´ 0DULL %ULWDQLL F JXYHUQXO EULWDQLF QX WUHEXLD V úL DVXPH ÄDFHOHDúL ULVFXULSHQWUXHLDúDFXPDPI FXWRSHQWUX*UHFLDúL3RORQLD´'HWHDP FD ,96WDOLQ V QXL UHSURúH]H ÄvQF OFDUHD vQ HOHJHULL´ FX SULYLUH OD 5RPkQLDvQWUXQPRPHQWvQFDUHÄGLVSXWDSHQWUX3RORQLDGHYLQHFULWLF ´ SULPXOPLQLVWUXEULWDQLFDDWUDVDWHQ LDF ÄWUHEXLDV QH LQHPGHFXYkQW RULFkW GH GXUHURV DU IL´ ÌQ DFHHDúL ]L vQ FRQIRUPLWDWH FX DFHVW PRG GH DSUHFLHUHDVLWXD LHLGLQ5RPkQLD:LQVWRQ&KXUFKLOODUHYHQLWGHDFHDVW GDW PXOW PDL FODU Ä1X DYHP vQWUDGHY U QLFL R MXVWLILFDUH SHQWUX D LQWHUYHQLvQDFHVWFKLSH[WUDRUGLQDUGHYLJXURVSHQWUXIRúWLLQRúWULLQDPLFL URPkQL FRPSURPL kQG DVWIHO SR]L LD QRDVWU vQ 3RORQLD úL LULWkQGXL SH UXúL FDUH DFFHSWDVHU vQGHOXQJDWD QRDVWU OXSW OD $WHQD 'DF YRP FRQWLQXDDVWIHOQLVHYDVSXQHQXI U GUHSWDWHF DPF OFDWFXYkQWXOvQ 5RPkQLD GXS FH DP IRORVLW SR]L LD QRDVWU vQ *UHFLD úL DFHDVWD YD FRPSURPLWHSR]L LDSHFDUHDPOXDWROD,DOWDvQSULYLQ D3RORQLHL&UHGF WUHEXLHWULPLVHLQVWUXF LXQLVWULFWHUHSUH]HQWDQ LORUQRúWULvQ5RPkQLDV QX GH]YROWH DFROR XQ IURQW SROLWLF DQWLUXV (L IDF DFHVW OXFUX FX HQHUJLH LQRSRUWXQ I U V vQ HOHDJ FHHVWHvQMRFvQDOWHGRPHQLL´ /DUkQGXLODPDUWLH :$+DULPDQQDPEDVDGRUXODPHULFDQ OD 0RVFRYD D SURSXV OXL 900RORWRY FD UHSUH]HQWDQ LL FHORU WUHL PDUL SXWHULV GLVFXWHVLWXD LDGLQ5RPkQLD/DUkQGXLSUHúHGLQWHOHDPHULFDQD DWUDV OD PDUWLH DWHQ LD OXL ,96WDOLQ F vQ 5RPkQLD úL %XOJDULD H[LVWDX UHJLPXUL FDUH QX DVLJXUDX WXWXURU HOHPHQWHORU GHPRFUDWLFH DOH SRSRUXOXLÄGUHSWXOGHDúLH[SULPDOLEHUS UHUHD´úLFDUHSULQVLVWHPXOGH JXYHUQDUH QX UHSUH]HQWDX ÄYRLQ D SRSRUXOXL´ ÌQ DFHHDúL ]L :LQVWRQ
&KXUFKLOO D WUDQVPLV OXL )' 5RRVHYHOW F ,9 6WDOLQ WUHEXLD LQIRUPDW GHVSUHÄPkKQLUHDQRDVWU ID GHHYHQLPHQWHOHFDUHDXGXVODLQVWDODUHDSULQ IRU DXQXLJXYHUQDOPLQRULW LLFRPXQLVWHvQ5RPkQLDGHRDUHFHDFHDVWDVH DIO vQFRQIOLFWFXFRQFOX]LLOH'HFODUD LHLSULYLQG(XURSDHOLEHUDW DVXSUD F UHLDDPIRVWGHDFRUGOD&RQIHULQ DGLQ&ULPHHD´5 VSXQ]kQGXLOD PDUWLH )'5RRVHYHOWDDU WDWF HUDÄvQWUXWRWXOKRW UkW´V QXODVHFD ÄEXQHOHGHFL]LLVWDELOLWHvQ&ULPHHDV QXVHVFXUJ SULQWUHGHJHWH´úLF YD IDFH WRW FH SRDWH SHQWUX DO GHWHUPLQD SH ,9 6WDOLQ ÄV OH vQGHSOLQHDVF RQHVW´$FFHSWkQGúLHOIDSWXOF ÄUXúLLDXLQVWDODWXQJXYHUQPLQRULWDUSH SURSULXOJXVW´SUHúHGLQWHOHDPHULFDQDDWUDVDWHQ LDF Ä5RPkQLDQXHVWH XQORFSHQWUXWHVWDUH´UXúLLDYkQGDLFLGHODvQFHSXWÄFRQWUROXOLQGLVFXWDELO´ F GDWRULW VLWX ULL 5RPkQLHL ÄGHD FXUPH]LúXO F LORU GH FRPXQLFD LH UXVHúWL´ HUD GLILFLO ÄV VH FRQWHVWH SUHWH[WXO QHFHVLW LL PLOLWDUH úL DO VHFXULW LLIRORVLWGHHLSHQWUXDMXVWLILFDDF LXQHDORU´ *XYHUQXOVRYLHWLFDFRQVLGHUDWúLGXS FRQVWLWXLUHDJXYHUQXOXLGU 3HWUH *UR]D SURSXQHULOH GLSORPD LORU DPHULFDQL úL HQJOH]L SULYLQG QHFHVLWDWHDGLVFXW ULLVLWXD LHLGLQ5RPkQLDFDILLQGQHIRQGDWH 8Q DOW PDUH DEX] V YkUúLW GH &RPLVLD $OLDW GH &RQWURO SDUWHD VRYLHWLF vQ 5RPkQLD OD UHSUH]HQWDW WUHFHUHD QRLHPEULH vQ GH]DFRUGFXSUHYHGHULOH&RQYHQ LHLGHDUPLVWL LXGLQVHSWHPEULH WHULWRULXOXL 7UDQVLOYDQLHL HOLEHUDWH vQ FDUH vQWUH WLPS VH UHLQVWDXUDVH DGPLQLVWUD LD URPkQHDVF VXE DGPLQLVWUD LH PLOLWDU VRYLHWLF &HUHULOH JXYHUQXOXLURPkQSULYLQGUHLQVWDXUDUHDDGPLQLVWUD LHLURPkQHúWLvQDFHVW WHULWRULXDXU PDVI U HFRXSkQ OD PDUWLH FkQG0RVFRYDDGHFLV V RIHUH XQ ÄEDORQ GH R[LJHQ´ JXYHUQXOXL GU 3HWUX *UR]D SHUPL kQG LQVWDXUDUHDDGPLQLVWUD LHLURPkQHúWLvQWRDW 7UDQVLOYDQLD 6XESRYDUDDUPLVWL LXOXL ÌQWUXQDVHPHQHDFRQWH[W5RPkQLDDWUHEXLWV IDF ID XQXLFUXQW UHJLP GH DUPLVWL LX LPSXV SULQ &RQYHQ LD GLQ VHSWHPEULH vQ PXOWH SULYLQ H SUHYHGHULOH GRFXPHQWXOXL ILLQG DJUDYDWH SULQ P VXULOH DEX]LYHDOH&RPLVLHL$OLDWHGH&RQWURO SDUWHDVRYLHWLF FDUHDSURILWDWGH DWLWXGLQHDSDVLY FKLDULQGLIHUHQW DUHSUH]HQWDQ LORUDPHULFDQLúLHQJOH]L
3HODUJ ùWHIDQ/DFKHRSFLWSS
'HúLDUWDO&RQYHQ LHLGHDUPLVWL LXQXVHUHIHUHDODPDULOHXQLW L FDUH QX SDUWLFLSDX QHPLMORFLW OD RSHUD LLOH PLOLWDUH &RPLVLD $OLDW GH &RQWUROSDUWHDVRYLHWLF DGHFODQúDWRVXV LQXW FDPSDQLHGHGHVWUXFWX UDUH D DUPDWHL URPkQH QHRSHUDWLYH ÌQ SRILGD UH]LVWHQ HL úHILORU 0DUHOXL 6WDW0DMRUVRYLHWLFLLDXUHXúLWV úLLPSXQ SXQFWHOHGHYHGHUHREOLJkQG SH JHQHUDOXO 1LFRODH 5 GHVFX V VHPQH]H 3URWRFROXO PLOLWDU GLQ RFWRPEULH SULQ FDUH DX IRVW GHVILLQ DWH SkQ OD GHFHPEULH XQ FRPDQGDPHQW GH DUPDW SDWUX FRPDQGDPHQWH GH FRUS GH DUPDW GLYL]LLúLDOWHPDULXQLW LURPkQH6DSHUPLVGRDUPHQ LQHUHDvQ DU FX HIHFWLYHGHSDFHDGRX FRPDQGDPHQWHGHFRUSGHDUPDW úLDWUHLGLYL]LL GH LQIDQWHULH VDX PXQWH $UJXPHQWXO KRW UkWRU DGXV GH JHQHUDOXO 9LQRJUDGRYORF LLWRUXOSUHúHGLQWHOXL&RPLVLHL$OLDWHGH&RQWURODIRVWF HOH[HFXW RUGLQHOHPDUHúDOXOXL5,0DOLQRYVNLúLLQVWUXF LXQLOHJXYHUQX OXLVRYLHWLF ÌQ DIDUD FDGUXOXL JHQHUDO DO RúWLULL P VXULOH YH[DWRULL LPSXVH DUPDWHLURPkQHDXYL]DWúLVLVWHPXOGHPRELOL]DUHGHvQY PkQWFDSDFL W LOH GH SURGXF LH PLOLWDU 3URWHVWkQG vPSRWULYD DFHVWRU SUDFWLFL JHQH UDOXO1LFRODH5 GHVFXúHIXO0DUHOXL6WDW0DMRUURPkQDWU JHDDWHQ LDF HOH UHSUH]LQW DWLQJHUL DGXVH DWkW VXYHUDQLW LL FkW úL LQGHSHQGHQ HL QD LRQDOH 5H]XOWDWHOHDXIRVWUDSLGHGDUGLQS FDWHFDWDVWURIDOHSHQWUXDUPDW úL GHPRODWRDUH SHQWUX FRUSXO GH FRPDQG DO DFHVWHLD ÌQWUR SHULRDG H[WUHPGHVFXUW GHODWUHFHUHD5RPkQLHLGHSDUWHD1D LXQLORU8QLWHSkQ ODvQFKHLHUHDúLUDWLILFDUHD7UDWDWXOXLGHSDFHvQ QXP UXOGLYL]LLORU URPkQH D IRVW UHGXV GH OD RSHUDWLYH úL GH LQVWUXF LH OD DXJXVW
3URWHVWHOH JHQHUDOXOXL &RQVWDQWLQ 6 Q WHVFX SULPXOPLQLVWUX DO JXYHUQXOXLúLDOHJHQHUDOXOXL1LFRODH5 GHVFXúHIXO0DUHOXL6WDW0DMRUQXDX PDLDYXWvQDFHVWFRQWH[WQLFLRXUPDUHSUDFWLF 3HQWUXFDVLWXD LDV ILHúLPDL FODU JHQHUDOXO 9DVLOLHY D GHFODUDW XUP WRDUHOH OD RFWRPEULH Ä6XQW vQV UFLQDW V IDF FXQRVFXW F SURWRFROXO HVWH GHILQLWLY úL QHVHPQDUHD OXL SRDWH GXFHODXQHOHUH]XOWDWHVHULRDVHSkQ FKLDUODGHPRELOL]DUHDúLGHVILLQ DUHD±SULQ IRU D$UPDWHL6RYLHWLFH±DWXWXURUPDULORUXQLW LFDUHQXSDUWLFLS ODRSHUD LXQL SRWULYLW SUHYHGHULORU &RQYHQ LHL GH $UPLVWL LX´ 6XE DFHVWH DPHQLQ UL GLUHFWH FDUH SXWHDX IL SXVH RULFkQG vQ SUDFWLF JHQHUDOXO 1LFRODH 5 GHVFX D WUHEXLW V DFFHSWH3URWRFROXOQXvQDLQWHGHDLDG XJDR1RW DGL LRQDO vQFDUHFRQVHPQD Ä3URWRFROXO vO VHPQH] FD ILLQGXQH LPSXV GH &RPLVLD $OLDW VRYLHWLF GH &RQWUROúLvQVFRSXOGHDHYLWDFRQVHFLQ HG XQ WRDUHRSHUD LLORUFRPXQHFRQWUD *HUPDQLHLúL8QJDULHL´
ODQXPDLúDSWHvQ LDUFXDQWXPXOHIHFWLYHORUGHOD GHPLOLWDULODDXJXVW ODVWDELOL LSULQ7UDWDWXOGHSDFH 0RELOXULOHDFHVWHLSROLWLFLQXDXIRVWvQWkPSO WRDUH(OHDXYL]DWFX FODULWDWH OLSVLUHD JXYHUQHORU URPkQH GH SkQ OD PDUWLH GH IRU D DUPDW SHFDUHDUILSXWXWRIRORVLSHQWUXVW YLOLUHDLPL[WLXQLORUvQSROLWLFD LQWHUQ D ULL 1X vQWkPSO WRU VXFFHVLYHOH GHVILLQ UL GH GLYL]LL úL UHJLPHQWHURPkQHDXIRVWXUPDWHGHDGXFHUHDvQ5RPkQLDvQGHFHPEULH DWUHLGLYL]LLVRYLHWLFHFXHIHFWLYHGHU ]ERLFDUHDXIRVWGLVORFDWHvQ ]RQHOH LPSRUWDQWH DOH ULL ± %XFXUHúWL 6LELX 3HWURúDQL 7LPLúRDUD 0 VXUD D IRVW XUPDW FX SX LQ WLPS vQDLQWH GH LPSXQHUHD OD SXWHUH D JXYHUQXOXL GU 3HWUX *UR]D OD PDUWLH GH WULPLWHUHD SH IURQW D 5HJLPHQWXOXL FDUH GH OXSW úL GH GH]DUPDUHD PLOLWDULORU URPkQL FDUH DVLJXUDX SD]D SULQFLSDOHORU FRPDQGDPHQWH úL LQVWLWX LL PLOLWDUH úL FLYLOH GLQ%XFXUHúWL 5HGXFHUHDUDSLG DFDGUXOXLRUJDQL]DWRULFúLDHIHFWLYHORUDUPDWHLV DI FXWSDUDOHOFXSURFHVXOGHGHFDSLWDUHDRúWLULLGHFDGUHOHGHFRQGXFHUH VXSHULRDU SULQ P VXUL DSDUHQW OHJDOH ± UHGXFHUL GH HIHFWLYH LPSXVH GH GHVILLQ ULOHGHXQLW LúLPDULXQLW LSULQFUHDUHDÄFDGUXOXLGLVSRQLELO´úL WUHFHUHD XOWHULRDU vQ UH]HUY úL vQ UHWUDJHUH FX SUHF GHUH D RIL HULORU VXSHULRUL GHODJUDGXOGHPDLRUvQVXV FkWúLSULQP VXULFDWHJRULFLOHJDOH ± DUHVW UL úL vQWHPQL UL IRDUWH PXOWH I U MXGHFDW LQFOXVLY vQ UkQGXULOH FHORUFDUHVHDIODXSHIURQWH[HUFLWkQGXúLGDWRULDID GH DU 'LQDFHVW SXQFW GH YHGHUH FRUSXO GH FRPDQG DO DUPDWHL URPkQH D VXIHULW R DGHY UDW GUDP FXDWkWPDLPXOWFXFkWPXOWRUDGLQWUHJHQHUDOLQXOLVDX FRPXQLFDW PRWLYHOH SULY ULL GH OLEHUWDWH FDUH vQ XQHOH FD]XUL QX HUDX FXQRVFXWHQLFLGHF WUHFHLFHHUDXSXúLV LMXGHFH 7RDWHDFHVWHDVHSHWUHFHDXvQFRQGL LLOHvQFDUH5RPkQLDvQGHSOLQHD LQWHJUDO SUHYHGHULOH DUW DO &RQYHQ LHL FRQIRUP F URUD JXYHUQXO úL ÌQDOWXOFRPDQGDPHQWURPkQVHREOLJDÄV LDP VXULOHSHQWUXGH]DUPDUHD
3URWHVWkQG vPSRWULYD DFHVWRU P VXUL ÄvQMRVLWRDUH SHQWUX DUPDWD URPkQ ´ JHQHUDOXO &RQVWDQWLQ 6 Q WHVFX DSUHFLD F HOH DYHDX ÄFRQVHFLQ HOH FHOH PDL JUDYH DVXSUD PRUDOXOXL vQWUHJLL SRSXOD LL FkW úL DVXSUD DUPDWHL´ $FHODúLúHIDO0DUHOXL6WDW0DMRUDSUHFLDF DUPDWDQRDVWU ÄQXSRDWHILVXSXV XQXL WUDWDPHQW DWkW GH FRQWUDGLFWRULX úL DQXPH SH IURQW FDPDUDG GH OXSW F UXLDLVHFHUHIRUWXULFRQWLQXLLDUSHSURSULXOHLWHULWRULXRELHFWGHFDSWXU GH GH]DUPDUHúLYH[D LXQH´
úLLQWHUQDUHDIRU HORUDUPDWHDOH*HUPDQLHLúL8QJDULHLDIODWHSHWHULWRULXO 5RPkQLHLFDúLSHQWUXLQWHUQDUHDFHW HQLORUFHORUGRX VWDWHPHQ LRQDWH FDUHvúLDXUHúHGLQ DDFROR´ 0XOWLSOHLPSOLFD LLDVXSUDIXQF LRQ ULLVRFLHW LLURPkQHúWLDDYXWúL FRQ LQXWXO DUW DO &RQYHQ LHL FDUH SUHYHGHD REOLJD LD GH D DVLJXUD IRU HORUVRYLHWLFHúLDOHFHORUODO LDOLD LÄvQOHVQLULSHQWUXOLEHUDORUPLúFDUH SHWHULWRULXO5RPkQLHLvQRULFHGLUHF LHGDF HVWHFHUXWGHVLWXD LDPLOL WDU ´JXYHUQXOURPkQWUHEXLQGV SXQ ODGLVSR]L LDÌQDOWXOXLFRPDQGD PHQWDOLDWVRYLHWLFÄSHQWUXGHSOLQDIRORVLQ FXPYDVRFRWLGHFXYLLQ SH WRDW GXUDWD DUPLVWL LXOXL D WXWXURU FRQVWUXF LLORU úL LQVWDOD LXQLORU URPk QHúWLPLOLWDUHDHULHQHúLQDYDOHSRUWXULFKHLXULFD] UPLPDJD]LLFkP SXUL GH DYLD LH PLMORDFH GH FRPXQLFD LH VWD LXQL PHWHRURORJLFH FDUH DU SXWHDILFHUXWHSHQWUXQHYRLPLOLWDUHvQGHV YkUúLW VWDUHúLFXSHUVRQDOXO QHFHVDUSHQWUXvQWUH LQHUHDORU´ 2DOW SUREOHP FXFDUDFWHUPLOLWDUúLQXQXPDLFDUHDSURYRFDW PDUL GH]LOX]LL D UH]XOWDW GLQ FRQ LQXWXO DUW UHIHULWRU OD UHVWDELOLUHD IURQWLHUHLGHVWDWvQWUH8QLXQHD6RYLHWLF úL5RPkQLDvQFRQIRUPLWDWHFX DúD]LVXO DFRUG VRYLHWRURPkQ GLQ LXQLH ÌQ FRQWH[WXO vQ FDUH VLWXD LD SROLWLF úL VWUDWHJLF GRYHGHD FODU F vQ DFHO PRPHQW QX VH PDL SXWHD ULGLFD SUREOHPD JUDQL HL SH 1LVWUX 0DUHOH 6WDW 0DMRU URPkQ vQ XUPD OHJ WXULL OXDW FX &RPDQGDPHQWXO VRYLHWLF vQ RFWRPEULH D WULPLVXQLW LOHGHJU QLFHULV DVLJXUHSD]DSHUkXO3UXWÌQPRGVXUSULQ ] WRU DXWRULW LOH VRYLHWLFH GLQ &RPLVLD $OLDW GH &RQWURO QX DX SHUPLV DFHVW OXFUX FHUkQG OD RFWRPEULH UHWUDJHUHD DFHVWRUD úL FRPXQLFkQGF UHVWDELOLUHDVHUYLFLXOXLGHSD] XUPDV VHIDF XOWHULRUvQ XUPDXQHLFRQYHQ LLVSHFLDOH/DQRLHPEULHDFHODúLDQDXLQYRFDWIDSWXO F IRUPDOLW LOHGHIURQWLHU úLGHLQVWDODUHDJU QLFHULORUURPkQLVWLQJKH UHDXOLEHUDPLúFDUHDWUXSHORUVRYLHWLFHSHWHULWRULXO5RPkQLHLFHHDFHDU ILvQVHPQDWRvQF OFDUHDSUHYHGHULORUDUWGLQ&RQYHQ LDGHDUPLVWL LX $FHVWSUHWH[WDF ]XWvQPRGHYLGHQWGXS WHUPLQDUHDU ]ERLXOXLFkQG OLEHUWDWHD GH PLúFDUH VRYLHWLF QX D PDL IRVW MXVWLILFDW GLQ SXQFW GH
$F LXQHD GH GH]DUPDUH vQFHSXVH LPHGLDW GXS DQXQ DUHD WUHFHULL 5RPkQLHL GH SDUWHD 1D LXQLORU 8QLWH SkQ OD DXJXVW ILLQG FDSWXUD L SULQ OXSWH GH PLOLWDUL LQDPLFL PDMRULWDWHD JHUPDQL LDU SkQ OD VIkUúLWXO U ]ERLXOXL SLHUGHULOHWRWDOHSURYRFDWHLQDPLFXOXLSkQ OD PDL LQFOXVLYPLOLWDULLXFLúLvQOXSWHVDXFLIUDWOD PLOLWDUL
YHGHUHDOHIRUWXOXLPLOLWDUGDUVLWXD LDQXVDVFKLPEDWGHFkWIRDUWHWkU]LX vQ FRPDQGDPHQWXO VRYLHWLF UHIX]kQG PHUHX UHSHWDWHOH FHUHUL DOH FRPDQGDPHQWHORUURPkQH 3H OkQJ REOLJD LD ILUHDVF FH UHYHQHD VWDWXOXL URPkQ GXS DXJXVW vQ OHJ WXU FX SUHGDUHD WXWXURU SUL]RQLHULORU GH U ]ERL VRYLHWLFLúLDOLD LDUWDSUHY ]XWFDUHSDWULHUHDV ILHI FXW SHFKHOWXLDOD JXYHUQXOXL URPkQ FDUH WUHEXLD V OH DVLJXUH vQ DIDUD PLMORDFHORU GH WUDQVSRUWúLKUDQDvPEU F PLQWHDúLDVLVWHQ DVDQLWDU QHFHVDUH 2 SUREOHP GHRVHELW D ULGLFDW UHSDWULHUHD EDVDUDEHQLORU úL EXFRYL QHQLORU vQ QRLHPEULH UHSUH]HQWDQ LL VRYLHWLFL GLQ &RPLVLD $OLDW GH &RQWUROFHUkQGFDWR LDFHúWLDLQGLIHUHQWGDF DXYHQLWVDXQXGHEXQ YRLH V VHvQWRDUF ODORFXLQ HOHORU3URWHVWHOH&RPLVLHLURPkQHSHQWUXDSOLFDUHD DUPLVWL LXOXL FDUH D LQYRFDW GUHSWXO GH RS LXQH FRQVILQ LW vQ FRQYHQ LLOH LQWHUQD LRQDOHvQVLWXD LLOHGHGH]PHPEU ULGHWHULWRULLQXDXIRVWOXDWHvQ FRQVLGHUDUHGHFkWvQSX LQHFD]XULLQGLYLGXDOHÌQGH]DFRUGFXSUHYHGHULOH &RQYHQ LHLGHDUPLVWL LXODPDL &RPLVLD$OLDW GH&RQWURO SDUWHD VRYLHWLF D VROLFLWDW JXYHUQXOXL URPkQ V UHSDWULH]H úL GHFL V DVLJXUH PLMORDFH GH WUDQVSRUW KUDQ úL vPEU F PLQWH úL SHQWUX FHW HQLL VRYLHWLFL GHSRUWD L vQ WLPSXO U ]ERLXOXL vQ $XVWULD 8QJDULD úL vQ DOWH UL FDUH VH vQWRUFHDXvQ8QLXQHD6RYLHWLF vQJUXSXULQHRUJDQL]DWH &RQFRPLWHQWFXVXV LQHUHDHIRUWXOXLGHU ]ERL5RPkQLDDvQFHSXW vQFDGUXODUWSODWDGHVS JXELULORUF WUH8QLXQHD6RYLHWLF vQYDORDUH GH 68$ OD SDULWDWHD DYXW vQ PRPHQWXO VHPQ ULL &RQYHQ LHL±SHQWUXRXQFLHGHDXU FDUHXUPDXDILRIHUL LvQGHFXUV GHDQLvQP UIXUL SURGXVHSHWUROLIHUHFHUHDOHPDWHULDOHOHPQRDVHYDVH
ÌQ DFHVW GRPHQLX JXYHUQXO URPkQ OXDVH GHMD vQDLQWHD VHPQ ULL &RQYHQ LHLP VXULOHQHFHVDUHSHQWUXHOLEHUDUHDSUL]RQLHULORUFDUHvQFHSkQGFX DXJXVWDXIRVWSXúLODGLVSR]L LDDXWRULW LORUVRYLHWLFHDPHULFDQHúLHQJOH]H ILLQG WUDQVSRUWD L vQ ULOH UHVSHFWLYH GH SUL]RQLHUL VRYLHWLFL SUL]RQLHULDPHULFDQL SUL]RQLHULHQJOH]LúL SUL]RQLHULLWDOLHQL3kQ OD LXQLH VDXUHSDWULDWvQ8QLXQHD6RYLHWLF GHUHIXJLD LGLQ%DVDUDELD úL SHUVRDQH VWU PXWDWH GLQ WRWDOXO GH vQVFULVH vQ HYLGHQ H DFHVWRUD SO WLQGXOLVH GH F WUH VWDWXO URPkQ DORFD LL SHQWUX KUDQ úL vQWUH LQHUH LQGHPQL]D LLGHHFKLSDUHHWF 3kQ OD LXQLH DX IRVW WUDQ]LWD L SULQ 5RPkQLD FHW HQL VRYLHWLFL VRVL L GLQ *HUPDQLD 8QJDULD úL $XVWULD ÌQWUR VLWXD LH VLPLODU VDXDIODWúLFHW HQLDPHULFDQLLWDOLHQLúLSRORQH]L
PDULQH úL IOXYLDOH PDúLQL HWF úL SHQWUX vQGHSOLQLUHD DUW FDUH VH UHIHUHDODUHVWLWXLUHDvQEXQ VWDUHDWXWXURUYDORULORUúLPDWHULDOHORUOXDWH vQ FXUVXO U ]ERLXOXL GH SH WHULWRULXO 8QLXQLL 6RYLHWLFH 3UREOHPH PDL GHRVHELWHDULGLFDWVWDELOLUHDEXQXULORUFRQVXPDWHVDXFRQVXPDELOH 6XJHVWLY SHQWUX UHOHYDUHD HIRUWXOXL HFRQRPLFRILQDQFLDU I FXW GH VWDWXOURPkQvQSHULRDGDVHSWHPEULH ±LXOLH HVWHIDSWXOF GLQFKHOWXLHOLDXIRVWI FXWHSHQWUXDUPLVWL LXúLSHQWUXDGPLQLVWUD LH úLSHQWUXDUPDW ([WUHPGHGXUHDXIRVWúLSUHYHGHULOHDUWDO&RQYHQ LHLUHIHULWRU ODDFWLYLWDWHDHGLWRULDO úLFXOWXUDODUWLVWLF ÌQFDGUXOGLVSR]L LLORUGDWHGH &RPLVLD $OLDW GH &RQWURO SDUWHD VRYLHWLF VD KRW UkW UHWUDJHUHD GLQ FLUFXOD LHDWXWXURUSXEOLFD LLORUWLS ULWHvQWUHLDQXDULH úLDXJXVW FDUH SULQ FXSULQVXO ORU DU IL SXWXW G XQD vQ DFFHS LD VRYLHWLF EXQHORU UDSRUWXUL FX 1D LXQLORU 8QLWH 3kQ OD LXOLH DX IRVW SXEOLFDWHOLVWHFXDFHVWHSXEOLFD LLúLVDGLVSXVUHWUDJHUHDGLQFLUFXOD LH úL GLVWUXJHUHD K U LORU PHGDOLLORU LQVLJQHORU UHSURGXFHULORU JUDILFH GLVFXULORU úL SDUWLWXULORU PX]LFDOH FRQVLGHUDWH F DX VHUYLW SURSDJDQGD IDVFLVW OHJLRQDU VDX DQWRQHVFLDQ VDX F DU G XQD DFHORUDúL EXQH UDSRUWXUL$XSULPLWGUHSWGHS VWUDUHDSXEOLFD LLORULQWHU]LVH±LQYHQWD ULDWHúLvQFKLVHvQvQF SHULVSHFLDOH±GRDUELEOLRWHFLOHFXGUHSWGHGHSR]LW OHJDO úL ELEOLRWHFLOH LQVWLWX LLORU GH vQY PkQW VXSHULRU FRQVXOWDUHD OXFU ULORUSXWkQGXVHIDFHGRDUFXDXWRUL]D LDVSHFLDO DúHILORULQVWLWX LLORU UHVSHFWLYH úL SH SURSULD ORU U VSXQGHUH 0DQXDOHOH GLGDFWLFH DX IRVW UHYL]XLWH GH R FRPLVLH VSHFLDO LQVWLWXLW SH OkQJ 0LQLVWHUXO (GXFD LHL 1D LRQDOH 3UHVD úL SXEOLFD LLOH SHULRGLFH FRWLGLHQH UHYLVWH DS UHDX FX DXWRUL]D LD SUHDODELO D &HQ]XULL &HQWUDOH D 3UHVHL FX DJUHPHQWXO &RPLVLHL$OLDWHGH&RQWURO'XS DSDUL LHSHULRGLFHOHGLQSURYLQFLHHUDX REOLJDWHV WULPLW 'LUHF LHLSUHVHLFkWHH[HPSODUHGLQILHFDUHQXP U LDU FHOH GLQ &DSLWDO FkW PDL PXOWH DFHDVWD H[SHGLLQG R SDUWH GLQ HOH &RPLVLHL $OLDWH GH &RQWURO 6DQF LXQLOH SHQWUX HYHQWXDOHOH DEDWHUL VH G GHDXGHF WUHDXWRULW LOHURPkQHODFHUHDRUJDQHORUVRYLHWLFHDELOLWDWH 'H DFHOHDúL DSURE UL DYHDX QHYRLH úL SXEOLFD LLOH QHSHULRGLFH F U L EURúXULHWF HGLWXULOHILLQGREOLJDWHvQDLQWHGHDOHSXQHvQFLUFXOD LHV WULPLW H[HPSODUH OD 'LUHF LD SUHVHL FDUH OH WULPLWHD VSUH DSUREDUH &RPLVLHL $OLDWH GH &RQWURO 3XEOLFD LLOH LPSRUWDQWH WUHEXLDX VXSXVH FRQWUROXOXL&HQ]XULLVRYLHWLFHGHSHOkQJ 'LUHF LD&HQWUDO D3RúWHORUúLD
&HQ]XULL PLOLWDUH URPkQH 6SHFWDFROHOH WHDWUDOH HUDX SUH]HQWDWH GXS DSUREDUHDFHQ]XULLURPkQHúWLOLEUHWHOHUHYLVWHORUXUPkQGDILFHQ]XUDWHGH RUJDQHOHFHQWUDOHGLQ&DSLWDO úLDSUREDWHGH&RPLVLD$OLDW GH&RQWURO )LOPHOH HUDX VXSXVH úL HOH DQDOL]HL &RPLVLHL GH &HQ]XU GH SH OkQJ 0LQLVWHUXO3URSDJDQGHLFHOHJHUPDQHILLQGLQWHU]LVH&HOHDGPLVHWUHEX LDXDYL]DWHGHXQGHOHJDWVSHFLDODODFHOHLDúL&RPLVLL$OLDWHGH&RQWURO 'HRULFHFHQ]XU HUDXVFXWLWHILOPHOHDGXVHGHDUPDWDVRYLHWLF 6XSXV FHQ]XULLURPkQHúLVRYLHWLFHDIRVWúLvQWUHDJDFRUHVSRQGHQ SRúWDO LQFOXVLYFHDRILFLDO úLPLOLWDU LQWHUQ VDXH[WHUQ 7HOHJUDPHOH GHSUHV SHQWUXVWU LQ WDWHHUDXFHQ]XUDWHGH6HF LXQHDSROLWLF D&RPLVLHL $OLDWHGH&RQWUROLDUFRUHVSRQGHQ DFLIUDW VDXFRQYHQ LRQDO DWkWSHQWUX LQWHULRU FkW úL SHQWUX H[WHULRU D IRVW LQWHU]LV 1X D IRVW DXWRUL]DW QLFL WUDQVPLWHUHD vQ VWU LQ WDWH SULQ FXULHU D FRUHVSRQGHQ HL GLSORPDWLFH URPkQH0DLPXOWDQH[DODDUWQXSHUPLWHDQLFLFRUHVSRQGHQ DFLIUDW úL SULQ FXULHU D DJHQ LLORU GLSORPDWLFH úL FRQVXODUH VWU LQH DFUHGLWDWH vQ 5RPkQLD &RUHVSRQGHQ D vQ FODU WHOHJUDILF SRúWDO VDX WHOHIRQLF D DFHVWRURILFLLHUDVXSXV FHQ]XULLVRYLHWLFH 7UDQVPLVLXQLOHUDGLRIRQLFHDOH6RFLHW LL5RPkQHGH5DGLRGLIX]LXQH VH I FHDX SH SURSULD U VSXQGHUH D LQVWLWX LHL SH ED]D DFHORUDúL QRUPH VWDELOLWHGH&RPLVLD$OLDW GH&RQWUROSHQWUXSXEOLFD LLOHSHULRGLFHF UHLDvL HUD GHSXV PDWHULDOXO GLIX]DW D GRXD ]L GXS HPLVLH 3HQWUX SUREOHPH GH RUGLQ WHKQLF SH OkQJ 6RFLHWDWHD GH 5DGLRGLIX]LXQH FD úL SH OkQJ 6RFLHWDWHD$QRQLP GH7HOHIRDQHIXQF LRQDXQGHOHJDWVRYLHWLF ÌQFHUFkQG V UHPHGLH]H XQHOH GLQ DFHVWH VW UL GH OXFUXUL LQDGPL VLELOH vQ VLWXD LD XQXL VWDW FDUH DGXVHVH R FRQWULEX LH LPSRUWDQW OD RE LQHUHD PDULL YLFWRULL GH OD PDL &RPLVLD 5RPkQ SHQWUX $SOLFDUHD $UPLVWL LXOXL D vQDLQWDW OD LXQLH &RPLVLHL $OLDWH GH &RQWUROR1RW SULQFDUHFHUHDDQXODUHDUHVWULF LLORUFDUHGHFXUVHVHU GLQ VWDUHD GH U ]ERL UHSXQHUHD ÌQDOWXOXL FRPDQGDPHQW URPkQ ÄvQ SOHQLWX GLQHD DWULEX LXQLORU VDOH´ úL UHH[DPLQDUHD DSOLF ULL &RQYHQ LHL GH DUPLVWL LX GLQ VHSWHPEULH 6D FHUXW úL FX DFHDVW RFD]LH UHH[DPLQDUHD VLWXD LHL IORWHL GH U ]ERL D SUREOHPHL WUDQVSRUWXULORU úL UHVWULF LLORU LPSXVH SULQ 3URWRFROXO GLQ RFWRPEULH LQVWDODUHD JU QLFHULORUSHIURQWLHU DGXFHUHDvQ DU DSUL]RQLHULORUGHU ]ERLURPkQL DIOD L vQF vQ FDSWLYLWDWH SUHFXP úL VROX LRQDUHD PXOWRU SUREOHPH FX FDUDFWHUSROLWLF&kWHYD]LOHPDLWkU]LXODLXQLH0LKDLO*KHOPHJHDQX SUHúHGLQWHOH DFHVWXL RUJDQLVP SURSXQHD vQFKHLHUHD XQHL FRQYHQ LL vQ
OHJ WXU FX VWD LRQDUHD WUXSHORU VRYLHWLFH SH WHULWRULXO 5RPkQLHL FDUH IXVHVHU GLVORFDWHvQ]RQHOH2UDGHD±$UDG±$OED,XOLD±'HM7LPLúRDUD ± 7XUQX 6HYHULQ ± 6ODWLQD ± &DUDFDO ± 'HYD 7kUJRYLúWH ± *LXUJLX ± 3LWHúWL%UDúRY3ORLHúWL±%kUODG±)RFúDQL 6ROX LRQDUHDDFHVWRUDDYHDV vQWkPSLQHvQV vQFRQWLQXDUHPDULGLILFXOW L $QDOL]DPRGXOXLvQFDUHDXIRVWvQGHSOLQLWHSUHYHGHULOH&RQYHQ LHL GH DUPLVWL LX GLQ VHSWHPEULH vQ SHULRDGD FDUH D XUPDW SkQ OD vQFKHLHUHDU ]ERLXOXLUHOHY I U QLFLRvQGRLDO IDSWXOF 5RPkQLDúLD vQGHSOLQLW REOLJD LLOH DVXPDWH vQ PXOWH SULYLQ H GHS úLQGXOH FKLDU vQ FRQGL LLvQFDUHUHJLPXOGXUGHDUPLVWL LXDIRVWVLPLODUvQPXOWHVLWXD LL FX XQ DGHY UDW UHJLP GH RFXSD LH vQ FDUH DWULEXWHOH GH FRQGXFHUH DOH JXYHUQHORU URPkQH DX IRVW DQXODWH VDX OLPLWDWH OD GRPHQLL QHVHPQLILFD WLYHGHH[HFX LH 6SHUDQ HvPSOLQLULúLGH]LOX]LLURPkQHúWLvQWLPSXOU ]ERLXOXL 1HXUP ULQG HOXUL DQH[LRQLVWH DVXSUD XQRU WHULWRULL FDUH QX vL DSDU LQHDX5RPkQLDDSDUWLFLSDWODFHOGHDOGRLOHDU ]ERLPRQGLDODWkWOD &DPSDQLDGLQHVW DO WXULGH$[ FkWúLOD&DPSDQLDGLQYHVW DO WXUL GH 1D LXQLOH 8QLWH SHQWUX UHIDFHUHD LQWHJULW LL WHULWRULDOH JUDY DIHFWDW vQ YDUD úL WRDPQD DQXOXL ÌQ DQVDPEOXO U ]ERLXOXLDUPDWDURPkQ DDQJDMDWvQOXSWHFLUFDGHPLOLWDULvQ HVWúLvQYHVWSLHU]kQG PLOLWDUL vQ(VWúL vQ9HVW GLQFDUH PRU L U QL LúL GLVS UX L 3DUWLFLSDUHDODU ]ERLGLQFRORGHKRWDUHOH ULLDIRVWGHWHUPLQDW GH H[LJHQ HOHU ]ERLXOXLGHFRDOL LHúLGHQHFHVLWDWHDFRQVROLG ULLUHvQWUHJLULL WHULWRULDOH /D vQFHSXW UHvQWUHJLUH vQ HVW SH 1LVWUX FDUH VD GRYHGLW D IL vQV GRDU WHPSRUDU SkQ vQ PDUWLH FkQG DUPDWHOH VRYLHWLFH DX S WUXQVGLQQRXSHWHULWRULXOURPkQHVFDSRLUHvQWUHJLUHvQSDUWHGHQRUG YHVWSkQ ODJUDQL DDGHY UDW GHGLQFRORGHOLQLD6DWX0DUH&DUHL$UDG 7LPLúRDUDFDUHDVDGRYHGLWDILGHILQLWLY ILLQGFRQILUPDW GH7UDWDWXO GHSDFHvQFKHLDWOD3DULVODIHEUXDULH
3H ODUJ $OHVDQGUX 'X X ÌQWUH :HKUPDFK úL $UPDWD 5RúLH %XFXUHúWL
'HILHFDUHGDW SDUWLFLSDUHDURPkQHDVF ODU ]ERLDIRVWLQIOXHQ DW GHDEVHQ DXQRUWUDWDWHúLFRQYHQ LLPLOLWDUHFDUHV FRQVHPQH]HGUHSWXULOH úLREOLJD LLOHSDUWHQHULORUFXDWkWPDLPXOWFXFkWGLQSXQFWXOGHYHGHUHDO SRWHQ LDOXOXLGHOXSW 5RPkQLDHUDGHIDYRUL]DW GHODvQFHSXWDWkWID GH *HUPDQLDFkWúLID GH8QLXQHD6RYLHWLF 1DWXUD UHOD LLORU SROLWLFH úL PLOLWDUH FX *HUPDQLD úL 8QLXQHD 6RYLHWLF FDUHúLDXLPSXVGHODvQFHSXWSXQFWHOHGHYHGHUHvQPDMRULWDWHD SUREOHPHORUGHLPSRUWDQ VWUDWHJLF úLRSHUDWLY VXEIRUPHGLIHULWHvQV DLQIOXHQ DWvQPRGKRW UkWRUDFWLYLWDWHD0DUHOXL&DUWLHU*HQHUDOURPkQ D 0DUHOXL 6WDW 0DMRU FXP VD QXPLW vQ DQXPLWH SHULRDGH GLPLQXkQGXL DWULEXWHOH GH FRQFHS LH úL FRQGXFHUH SH WHDWUHOH GH RSHUD LL PLOLWDUH &D XUPDUHvQFHDPDLPDUHSDUWHDU ]ERLXOXL0DUHOH&DUWLHU*HQHUDOURPkQ QX D DYXW SRVLELOLWDWHD V FRQFHDS vQ PRG LQGHSHQGHQW SODQXUL GH FDPSDQLHúLQLFLV FRQGXF HIHFWLYDUPDWHOHURPkQHvQRSHUD LLPLOLWDUH GHFkWvQSHULRDGDGHvQFHSXWDU ]ERLXOXLvQ]RQHúLSHGLUHF LLOLPLWDWHvQ VSD LX vQ VXGXO %DVDUDELHL úL OD 2GHVVD vQWUH LXQLH ± RFWRPEULH vQ IkúLD GH DF LXQH D $UPDWHL úL DWXQFL FX VXJHVWLL úL LQIOXHQ H JHUPDQH 6LQJXUD SHULRDG vQ FDUH 0DUHOH 6WDW 0DMRU D FRQGXV IRU HOH DUPDWH URPkQH vQ PRG LQGHSHQGHQW D IRVW vQWUH DXJXVW FkQG 5RPkQLDDWUHFXWGHSDUWHD1D LXQLORU8QLWHúLVHSWHPEULH FkQG )URQWXOXFUDLQHDQúLDVXERUGRQDWDUPDWHOHURPkQHRSHUDWLYH ,QWHJUDUHDWRWPDLDFFHQWXDW DPDULORUXQLW LURPkQHvQVWUXFWXULOH GH FRPDQGDPHQW JHUPDQH úL VRYLHWLFH D DQXODW SUDFWLF DWULEXWHOH GH FRQGXFHUHDVWUDWHJLF VDXRSHUDWLYHDOH0DUHOXL6WDW0DMRUFDUHDU PDV QXPDL FX VDUFLQL GH RUJDQL]DUH GRWDUH LQVWUXLUH DSURYL]LRQDUH HWF LDU GXS VHSWHPEULH úLGHH[HFX LHDKRW UkULORU&RPLVLHL$OLDWHGH &RQWURO SDUWHDVRYLHWLF SHQWUXGLYHUVHSUREOHPHFXFDUDFWHUPLOLWDUÌQ SRILGD DFHVWHL VLWXD LL úHILL 0DUHOXL 6WDW 0DMRU JHQHUDOLL ,RVLI ,DFRELFL ,OLHùWHIOHD*KHRUJKH0LKDLO1LFRODH5 GHVFXúL&RQVWDQWLQ6 Q WHVFX QX DX H]LWDW V úL H[SULPH SR]L LLOH úL SXQFWHOH GH YHGHUH vQ FHHD FH SULYHúWH VLWXD LD VWUDWHJLF úL RSHUDWLY vQ FDUH HUDX SXVH V DF LRQH]H WUXSHOHURPkQHúLV FHDU vPEXQ W LUHDFRQGL LLORUGHOXSW ÌQ DQVDPEOXO U ]ERLXOXL ± úL vQ FD]XO *HUPDQLHL GDU PDL DOHV vQ FD]XO 8QLXQLL 6RYLHWLFH ± VD DGHYHULW GLQ QRX SUDFWLFD VXSUHPD LHL SDUWHQHUXOXLPDLSXWHUQLFFDUHDUHXúLWV úLLPSXQ FRQFHS LDGHGXFHUHD OXSWHL V H[HUFLWH FRQWUROXO DVXSUD SDUWHQHUXOXL PDL VODE 6D DMXQV GHVHRULODVLWXD LDvQFDUHLQWHUHVHOHURPkQHúWLDXIRVWQHJOLMDWHLJQRUDWHúL
SUHMXGLFLDWHSURGXFkQGXVHQHQXP UDWHQHvQ HOHJHULFRQWUDGLF LLúLFKLDU FRQIOLFWH VROX LRQDWH GH FHOH PDL PXOWH RUL SULQ FRPSURPLVXUL GDWRULW QHFHVLW LL VDWLVIDFHULL LQWHUHVHORU UHFLSURFH 'HúL vQ HVHQ D ORU UHOD LLOH PLOLWDUH URPkQRJHUPDQH úL URPkQRVRYLHWLFH QX DX IRVW LGLOLFH QX DX OLSVLW QLFL PRPHQWHOH GH vQ HOHJHUH ÌQ DQVDPEOX vQV VD DMXQV OD LPSXQHUHDVXSUHPD LHLJHUPDQHDFFHSWDW GH,RQ$QWRQHVFX FKLDUGDF QX D UHFXQRVFXW úL OD KHJHPRQLD úL GLFWDWXO VRYLHWLF DFFHSWDWH GH FRQGXFHUHDVWDWDO úLSROLWLF URPkQHDVF LQVWDODW ODDXJXVW vQ VSHUDQ DF VLWXD LDDYHDV ILHWHPSRUDU &DWHJRULF HVWH IDSWXO F QXPHURDVH GH]LOX]LL DX DS UXW SHQWUX SRSRUXOURPkQúLDUPDWDVDúLvQWLPSXODOLDQ HLFX*HUPDQLDvQVSHFLDOvQ PRPHQWHOHJUHOHGHSHIURQWvQVSHFLDOGLQWRDPQDDQXOXL 'H]LOX]LL SURYRFDWH GH SUHOXQJLUHD U ]ERLXOXL GH VSRULUHD QXP UXOXL GH PLOLWDUL URPkQL XFLúL SH IURQW GH FRPSRUWDUHD PLOLWDULORU JHUPDQL vQ DU úL SH IURQWHWF
&HOHPDLPDULGH]LOX]LLDXDS UXWvQV ODVFXUWWLPSGXS DXJXVW ILLQG GHWHUPLQDWH GH PRGXO GH FRPSRUWDUH D QRXOXL DOLDW VRYLHWLF GH IHOXO vQ FDUH &RPLVLD $OLDW GH &RQWURO SDUWHD VRYLHWLF DLPSXVH[HFXWDUHD&RQYHQ LHLGHDUPLVWL LXvQFKHLDW OD VHSWHPEULH SUHFXPúLGHDWLWXGLQHDSDVLY D6WDWHORU8QLWH DOH$PHULFLLúL0DULL%ULWDQLL
3HQWUX FRPDQGDPHQWHOH URPkQH UHOD LLOH FX FRPDQGDPHQWHOH VRYLHWLFH QX DX IRVW GRDU R SUREOHP GH SUHVWLJLX FL úL R QHFHVLWDWH VWULQJHQW SHQWUX HILFLHQ D DF LXQLORU PLOLWDUH 8UP ULQG vQGHSOLQLUHD PLVLXQLORU FX SLHUGHUL FkW PDL SX LQH 0DUHOH 6WDW 0DMRU QX D vQFHWDW R FOLS V GHSXQ WRDWHHIRUWXULOHSHQWUXDVFRDWHDFHDVW FRRSHUDUHGHVXE LPSHULXO DUELWUDMXOXL úL DO EXQXOXL SODF SURSXQkQG QRUPH GH FRODERUDUH DGHFYDWH UHDOLW LL FkPSXOXL GH OXSW 0DMRULWDWHD VXJHVWLLORU úL LQL LDWL YHORUDXU PDVI U U VSXQVFRPDQGDPHQWHOHVRYLHWLFHUH]HUYkQGXúLGH UHJXO QXPDLGUHSWXULID GHWUXSHOHURPkQHI U DúLDVXPDvQWRWDOLWDWH úL REOLJD LLOH QHFHVDUH 0DL PXOW DX FRQWLQXDW V FRPLW DEX]XUL úL V LPSXQ XQPRGGHFRQGXFHUHúLGHVI úXUDUHDDF LXQLORUPLOLWDUHFDUHQX HUDXvQFRQFRUGDQ FXFRQFHS LDFRPDQGDPHQWHORUURPkQH 'UDPDWLF DIRVWVLWXD LD ULLGLQSXQFWXOGHYHGHUHDOUHLQWHJU ULLvQ FRPXQLWDWHD LQWHUQD LRQDO GHRDUHFHSODVDUHDHL vQRFWRPEULH SULQ DFRUGXO GH SURFHQWDM VWDELOLW vQWUH :LQVWRQ &KXUFKLOO úL ,9 6WDOLQ
FRQILUPDW DSRL GH FRQIHULQ D GH OD ,DOWD GLQ IHEUXDULH vQ VIHUD GH LQIOXHQ VRYLHWLF vQ SURSRU LH GH FD SROLWLFD H[WHUQ ILLQGXL GLUHF LRQDW úLFRQWURODW GHODvQFHSXWGH0RVFRYD6LWXD LDVDDJUDYDW vQSULP YDUDDQXOXL FkQG6WDWHOH8QLWHúL0DUHD%ULWDQLHDXUHIX]DW V UHFXQRDVF JXYHUQXOGU3HWUX*UR]DLPSXVGH0RVFRYDODPDUWLH2 DWDUHVWDUHGHOXFUXULDSXVvQSHULFROvQV úLSDUWLFLSDUHDGHOHJD LHLURPkQH OD YLLWRDUHD FRQIHULQ GH SDFH FDUH DYHD V UHJOHPHQWH]H SUREOHPH HXURSHQHúLPRQGLDOHSRVWEHOLFHLQFOXVLYSHFHOHDOH5RPkQLHL6LWXD LDV DUHJOHPHQWDWvQWUXFkWYDSULQUHOXDUHDUHOD LLORUGLSORPDWLFHFXFHOHGRX PDUL SXWHUL RFFLGHQWDOH vQ IHEUXDULH &X WRDWH DFHVWHD DFFHOHUDUHD U ]ERLXOXLUHFHúLLQWHQVLILFDUHDGRPLQD LHLVRYLHWLFHDI FXWFD5RPkQLD V U PkQ L]RODW GH FRPXQLWDWHD LQWHUQD LRQDO GHPRFUDWLF 0DUL GH]LOX]LLSHQWUXSRSRUXOURPkQDXIRVWGHWHUPLQDWHúLGHPRGXOvQFDUHD IRVWWUDWDW 5RPkQLDOD&RQIHULQ DGHSDFHGHOD3DULVGLQ SUHFXPúL GHPXOWHGLQSUHYHGHULOH7UDWDWXOXLGHSDFHGLQIHEUXDULH
3HODUJ ùWHIDQ/DFKHRSFLWSS
9520Æ1,$Ì135,0,,$1, $,5 =%2,8/8,5(&( ÌQWUHDUPLVWL LXúLSDFH
9LFWRULDDVXSUD*HUPDQLHLGHOD PDL DSXVFDS WFHOXLGHDO GRLOHD U ]ERL PRQGLDO vQ (XURSD GDU QX D VROX LRQDW úL SUREOHPHOH LQWHUQD LRQDOH DS UXWH vQ ID]D ILQDO D FRQIODJUD LHL GHWHUPLQDWH GH LQWHUHVHOHPXOWLSOHDOHPDULORUSXWHUL IRVWHDOLDWH GHQRXOUDSRUWGHIRU H SRVWEHOLF GH IDSWXO F 8QLXQHD 6RYLHWLF D RE LQXW PkQ OLEHU vQ 5RPkQLD%XOJDULDúLSDU LDOvQ8QJDULDvQF vQDLQWHGHVIkUúLWXOU ]ERLXOXL úLDUHXúLWV LPSXQ UHJLPXULSROLWLFHSURFRPXQLVWHvQVIHUDGHLQIOXHQ VWDELOLW GH FRPXQ DFRUG FX SUHPLHUXO EULWDQLF :LQVWRQ &KXUFKLOO OD RFWRPEULH &D]XO5RPkQLHLXQGHODPDUWLH DIRVWLPSXVJXYHUQXOGU 3HWUX*UR]DHVWHFRQFOXGHQWvQDFHVWVHQVúLFRQVWLWXLHXQSULPSXQFWGH SRUQLUH D YLLWRDUHORU FRQIOLFWH vQWUH IRúWLL DOLD L vQDLQWH FKLDU GH VIkUúLWXO U ]ERLXOXLvQGLVFRUGDQ FXvQ HOHJHULOHGHOD,DOWD IHEUXDULH XQGH VDX vQ HOHV DVXSUD VROX LRQ ULL SUREOHPHL RUJDQL] ULL SRVWEHOLFH D (XURSHLHOLEHUDWHÌQDFHVWVHQVPDULOHSXWHULVDXDQJDMDWSULQ'HFODUD LD DVXSUD (XURSHL HOLEHUDWH V DMXWH VWDWHOH DIODWH vQ DFHDVW VLWXD LH SULQ FRQVWLWXLUHD GH DXWRULW L JXYHUQDPHQWDOH SURYL]RULL UHSUH]HQWDWLYH DOH ÄWXWXURU IRUPD LXQLORU GHPRFUDWLFH´ FDUH V RUJDQL]H]H FkW PDL UDSLG DOHJHUL OLEHUH vQ YHGHUHD FRQVWLWXLULL XQRU JXYHUQH FDUH V ILH ÄH[SUHVLD YRLQ HL SRSRDUHORU´ ÌQ VLWXD LD vQ FDUH DS UHDX SUREOHPH FHOH WUHL PDUL SXWHULWUHEXLDXV VHFRQVXOWHvQWUHHOH $F LXQLOH vQ IRU GHVI úXUDWH GH F WUH VRYLHWLFL vQ 5RPkQLD OD vQFHSXWXO OXQLL PDUWLH DX GHQDWXUDW ÄOLWHUD úL VSLULWXO ,DOWHL´ $, 9vúLQVNL GHFODUkQG Ä,DOWD VXQW HX´ /D UkQGXOH FRQGXF WRULL 0DULL
%ULWDQLLúL68$DXDSUHFLDWSHEXQ GUHSWDWHF VRYLHWLFLLDXvQF OFDW SULQFLSLLOHVWDELOLWHGHFRPXQDFRUGOD,DOWD ÌQ DF LXQLOH ORU VRYLHWLFLL VDX ED]DW SH QRXO UDSRUW GH IRU H HXURSHDQFDUHOHHUDGHMDIDYRUDELO3DXO+HQUL6SDDNSULPXOPLQLVWUX úL PLQLVWUXO GH H[WHUQH DO %HOJLHL DSUHFLLQG OD VFXUW WLPS GXS FDSLWXODUHD *HUPDQLHL QD]LVWH F ÄR VLQJXU PDUH SXWHUH D LHúLW GLQ U ]ERLFXFHULQGDOWHWHULWRULLúLDFHDVW SXWHUHHVWH8QLXQHD6RYLHWLF ´ $ILUPD LD GLSORPDWXOXL EHOJLDQ HUD FRQILUPDW GH DQH[DUHD (VWRQLHL /HWRQLHL/LWXDQLHLúLDXQRUS U LLPSRUWDQWHGLQ)LQODQGD5RPkQLD 3RORQLD*HUPDQLDúL&HKRVORYDFLDÌQWRWDOGHNPSFXSHVWH GH ORFXLWRUL /D VFXUW WLPS DFHDVW H[SDQVLXQH WHULWRULDO DYHDV ILHFRQVROLGDW SULQVWDELOLUHD]RQHORUGHLQIOXHQ úLFRQWUROvQ $OEDQLD %XOJDULD 5RPkQLD 3RORQLD &HKRVORYDFLD 8QJDULD úL vQ SDUWHD HVWLF D *HUPDQLHL XQGH DX IRVW LQVWDODWH SkQ vQ JXYHUQH úL UHJLPXUL FRPXQLVWH SURVRYLHWLFH 6DX DG XJDW vQFHUF ULOH GH LQFOXGHUH D FRPXQLúWLORU vQ JXYHUQXO JUHF LQWHUHVHOH VRYLHWLFH vQ 7DQJHUúL/LELDGRULQ DGHDDQH[DGRX SURYLQFLLDOH7XUFLHLúLGHD FRQWURODVWUkPWRULOH0 ULL1HJUH ÌQWUXQDVHPHQHDFRQWH[WúLSHQWUXUHOD LLORUH[WHUQHURPkQHúWLD XUPDWRSHULRDG H[WUHPGHDJLWDW &KLDUúLvQWUHDOLD LDPHULFDQLL SURSXQkQGVRYLHWLFLORUFRQVWLWXLUHDXQHL&RPLVLLFRPXQHOD%XFXUHúWL FDUHV YHJKH]HODDSOLFDUHDSULQFLSLLORUFXSULQVHvQ'HFODUD LDSHQWUX (XURSDHOLEHUDW DGRSWDW OD,DOWDvQIHEUXDULH
/D PDUWLH :LQVWRQ &KXUFKXOO VD GHFODUDW ÄPkKQLW´ ID GH HYHQLPHQWHOH GLQ 5RPkQLD vQ FXUVXO F URUD VRYLHWLFLL UHXúLVHU ÄV FDOFH vQ SLFLRDUH´ SULQFLSLLOH GH OD ,DOWD úL ÄV VWDELOHDVF FRQGXFHUHD XQHL PLQRULW L FRPXQLVWH SULQ IRU úL SULQ IDOVH GHFODUD LXQL´ /D UkQGXL )' 5RRVHYHOW OD DVLJXUDWSH:LQVWRQ&KXUFKLOOODPDUWLH F HUDKRW UkWFDÄEXQHOHGHFL]LL VWDELOLWHvQ&ULPHHDV QXVHVFXUJ SULQWUHGHJHWH´úLF YDIDFHWRWFHVHSRDWH SHQWUX DO GHWHUPLQD SH ,9 6WDOLQ ÄV OH vQGHSOLQHDVF RQHVW´ &RQFRPLWHQW SUHúHGLQWHOHDPHULFDQDDSUHFLDWF VRYLHWLFLLDXLQVWDODWvQ5RPkQLDÄXQJXYHUQ PLQRULWDUSHSURSULXOORUJXVW´GDUDDWUDVDWHQ LDF ÄQXHVWHXQORFEXQSHQWUXR WHVWDUH´GHRDUHFHÄUXúLLDXDYXWGHODvQFHSXWFRQWUROXOLQFRQWHVWDELO´ILLQGGLILFLO ÄV VHFRQWHVWHSUHWH[WXOQHFHVLW LLPLOLWDUHúLDOVHFXULW LLIRORVLWGHHLSHQWUXD MXVWLILFDDF LXQHDORU´FXDWkWPDLPXOWFXFkW5RPkQLDÄVHDIO GHDFXUPH]LúXO F LORUGHFRPXQLFD LHUXVHúWL´ 3HODUJ 9DOHULX)ORULQ'REULQHVFX5RPkQLDúLRUJDQL]DUHDSRVWEH OLF DOXPLL %XFXUHúWL
3HQWUX DúL SXQH IRúWLL DOLD L vQ ID D IDSWXOXL vPSOLQLW JXYHUQXO VRYLHWLFDGHFLVODDXJXVW UHVWDELOLUHDUHOD LLORUGLSORPDWLFHFX 5RPkQLDúLULGLFDUHDUHSUH]HQWDQ HORUODQLYHOGHDPEDVDG DXJXVW /D VFXUW WLPS JXYHUQHOH GH OD :DVKLQJWRQ úL /RQGUD DX UHFRQILUPDW OD UHVSHFWLY DXJXVW QHUHFXQRúWHUHD JXYHUQXOXLGU3HWUX*UR]DDSUHFLLQGF DFHVWDHUDÄQHUHSUH]HQWDWLY´ úL QX UHSUH]HQWD ÄRSLQLD SXEOLF GHPRFUDWLF GLQ DU ´ $SRL OD DXJXVW UHJHOH 0LKDL , vQFXUDMDW GH UHSUH]HQWDQ LL 68$ úL 0DULL %ULWDQLL OD %XFXUHúWL D FHUXW JXYHUQXOXL GU 3HWUX *UR]D V GHPLVLRQH]HúLDvQWUHUXSWXQLODWHUDORULFHOHJ WXULFXDFHVWD DXJXVW GHFODQúkQGDúDQXPLWDÄJUHY UHJDO ´ 6LWXD LD D IRVW VROX LRQDW vQ XUPD GHFL]LHL &RQIHULQ HL GH OD 0RVFRYD D PLQLúWULORU $IDFHULORU ([WHUQH DL 8566 68$ úL 0DULL %ULWDQLL GHFHPEULH SULYLQGUHFXQRDúWHUHDGHF WUH68$úL 0DUHD %ULWDQLH D JXYHUQXOXL FRQGXV GH GU 3HWUX *UR]D FX FRQGL LD LQFOXGHULL vQ ([HFXWLY D FkWH XQXL UHSUH]HQWDQW DO 3DUWLGXOXL 1D LRQDO U QHVF úL 3DUWLGXOXL 1D LRQDO /LEHUDO &D XUPDUH OD LDQXDULH UHJHOH0LKDL,DUHOXDWOHJ WXULOHFXJXYHUQXOODIHEUXDULH UHSUH ]HQWDQ LLSROLWLFLDL68$úL0DULL%ULWDQLLOD%XFXUHúWLDXFRPXQLFDWF JXYHUQHOHORUVXQWJDWDV UHLDUHOD LLOHGLSORPDWLFHFXJXYHUQXOURPkQOD QLYHO GH OHJD LH LDU OD IHEUXDULH DFHVWD GLQ XUP úLD H[SULPDW VDWLVIDF LDID GHGHFL]LD:DVKLQJWRQXOXLúL/RQGUHL &RQFRPLWHQW vQ FDGUXO QRLORU UHDOLW L ]RQDOH JHRVWUDWHJLFH 5RPkQLD D UHOXDW UHOD LLOH FX ,XJRVODYLD LDQXDULH OD QLYHO GH UHSUH]HQWDQ GLSORPDWLF úL OD PDUWLH OD QLYHO GH DPEDVDG )UDQ D PDUWLH ODQLYHOGHUHSUH]HQWDQ SROLWLF úLODDSULOLH OD QLYHO GH OHJD LH &HKRVORYDFLD LXQLH OD QLYHO GH UHSUH]HQWDQ SROLWLF RFWRPEULH ODQLYHOGHOHJD LHúLGHFHPEULH OD QLYHO GH DPEDVDG 2ODQGD IHEUXDULH OD QLYHO GH OHJD LH 1RUYHJLD PDL ODQLYHOGHOHJD LH ,UDQ LXQLH OD QLYHO GH OHJD LH %HOJLD úL 0DUHOH 'XFDW DO /X[HPEXUJXOXL LXOLH OD QLYHO GH OHJD LH $UJHQWLQD RFWRPEULH OD QLYHO GH OHJD LH $XVWULD RFWRPEULH OD QLYHO GH UHSUH]HQWDQ SROLWLF 8QJDULD QRLHPEULH ODQLYHOGHOHJD LH DULGLFDWUHOD LLOHODQLYHO
/DVHSWHPEULH JXYHUQHOHURPkQúLHQJOH]DXGHFLVGHFRPXQ DFRUGWUDQVIRUPDUHDUHSUH]HQWDQ HORUSROLWLFHvQOHJD LL
GHDPEDVDG FX3RORQLD QRLHPEULH úL7XUFLD PDUWLH D UXSW UHOD LLOH GLSORPDWLFH FX 6SDQLD IUDQFKLVW DSULOLH D UHFXQRVFXWJXYHUQXOVSDQLROvQH[LO PDL úLDVWDELOLWFXDFHVWD UHOD LLODQLYHOGHOHJD LH RFWRPEULH LDUODQRLHPEULH D UXSWUHOD LLOHGLSORPDWLFHFX3RUWXJDOLD/D GHFHPEULH 5RPkQLD D VHPQDW Ä7UDWDWXO GH SULHWHQLH FRODERUDUH úL DVLVWHQ PXWXDO ´ FX ,XJRVODYLDDFHVWDILLQGSULPXODFWLQWHUQD LRQDOvQFKHLDWGXS LQWUDUHDvQ YLJRDUHDWUDWDWXOXLGHSDFH 3UREOHPHURPkQHúWLOD&RQIHULQ DGHSDFHGLQ úLSULQFLSDOHOHSUHYHGHULDOH7UDWDWXOXLGHSDFH 5HOXDUHD UHOD LLORU GLSORPDWLFH FX 68$ úL 0DUHD %ULWDQLH vQ IHEUXDULH DIRVWEHQHILF GHRDUHFHDFHVWOXFUXDSHUPLVPLQLúWULORUGH ([WHUQH DL FHORU SDWUX PDUL SXWHUL vQWUXQL L vQ úHGLQ OD 3DULV vQWUH DSULOLH úL LXOLH V WUHDF OD HODERUDUHD SURLHFWHORU WUDWDWHORU GH SDFHFX5RPkQLD 3URLHFWHOHWUDWDWHORUGHSDFHFX5RPkQLD8QJDULD%XOJDULD,WDOLD úL)LQODQGDDXIRVWGH]E WXWHOD3DULVvQFDGUXO&RQIHULQ HLGHSDFHFDUH úLD GHVFKLV OXFU ULOH OD LXOLH 5HSUH]HQWDQ LL VWDWHORU FRQVLGHUDWH D IL vQYLQVH vQ U ]ERL DX DYXW GRDU GUHSWXO V úL H[SULPH SXQFWHOH GH YHGHUH DWXQFL FkQG DX IRVW VROLFLWD L V GHD O PXULUL úL H[SOLFD LLV vQDLQWH]HFRQIHULQ HLPHPRULLúLREVHUYD LLFDUHQXSXWHDXIL OXDWHvQFRQVLGHUD LHGHFkWGDF HUDXFRQVLGHUDWHFDDPHQGDPHQWHSURSULL GHXQDGLQGHOHJD LLOHVWDWHORUFDUHUHSUH]HQWDX3XWHULOH$OLDWHúL$VRFLDWH
9H]LúLùWHIDQ/DFKHRSFLWSS /D FRQIHULQ DX SDUWLFLSDW GH VWDWH vPS U LWH vQ WUHL JUXSH 68$ 8566 0DUHD %ULWDQLH )UDQ D úL &KLQD FRQVLGHUDWH D IL PDUL SXWHUL FX GUHSWXUL GHSOLQH GH GHFL]LH vQ VSHFLDO SULPHOH WUHL $XVWUDOLD %HOJLD 566 %LHORUXV %UD]LOLD &DQDGD (WKLRSLD *UHFLD ,QGLD 1RXD =HHODQG 1RUYHJLD 2ODQGD 3RORQLD &HKRVORYDFLD 8QLXQHD 6XG$IULFDQ 5668FUDLQHDQ úL,XJRVODYLD FXGUHSWGHDIRUPXODREVHUYD LLúLSURSXQHUL %XOJDULD)LQODQGD,WDOLD8QJDULDúL5RPkQLD FRQVLGHUDWHDILIRVWvQYLQVH vQU ]ERL6WDWHOHGLQSULPHOHGRX JUXSHDXIRVWUHXQLWHVXEQXPHOHGH3XWHULOH DOLDWH úL $VRFLDWH &X WLWOX FRQVXOWDWLY DX PDL SDUWLFLSDW 0H[LF &XED (JLSW ,UDQ$OEDQLDúL$XVWULD
'HDOWIHOQLFLFKLDU&RQIHULQ DQXDDYXWGUHSWXOV LDGHFL]LLGHILQLWLYHFL GRDU V IDF UHFRPDQG UL &RQVLOLXOXL PLQLúWULORU GH ([WHUQH DO PDULORU SXWHUL 'XS FHSURLHFWXO7UDWDWXOXLGHSDFHFX5RPkQLDDIRVWSXEOLFDW LXOLH VLPXOWDQ OD /RQGUD 3DULV 0RVFRYD úL :DVKLQJWRQ JXYHUQXOIUDQFH]DLQYLWDWJXYHUQXOURPkQ vQQXPHOH3XWHULORU$OLDWHúL $VRFLDWH V SDUWLFLSHOD&RQIHULQ DGHSDFHÌQXUPDDQDOL]HLFRQ LQXWXOXL GRFXPHQWXOXL DXJXVW ([HFXWLYXO GH OD %XFXUHúWL D VWDELOLW FRPSRQHQ DGHOHJD LHLURPkQHúLDIRUPXODWREVHUYD LLúLFHUHULFDUHDX YL]DWUHFXQRDúWHUHDFDOLW LLGHVWDWFREHOLJHUDQWvPEXQ W LUHDFODX]HORU PLOLWDUH úL HFRQRPLFH HWF WRDWH SUHFL]DWH vQ GRFXPHQWXO LQWLWXODW $WLWXGLQHD JXYHUQXOXL URPkQ ID GH &RQIHULQ D GH SDFH SUH]HQWDW úL VXV LQXW OD 3DULV OD DXJXVW vQ SOHQXO FRQIHULQ HL GH F WUH *KHRUJKH 7 W UHVFXPLQLVWUXO$IDFHULORU6WU LQHúLúHIXOGHOHJD LHLURPkQHÌQXUPD XQHLvQ HOHJHULFXGHOHJD LDVRYLHWLF VDVWDELOLWFDSUREOHPHOHUHIHULWRDUH OD UHOD LLOH URPkQRVRYLHWLFH úL HYHQWXDOHOH GROHDQ H URPkQH V ILH GLVFXWDWHúLVROX LRQDWHSULQGLVFX LLELODWHUDOHúLQXvQFDGUXO&RQIHULQ HL ÌQ DFHVW FDGUX GHOHJD LD URPkQ QX D ULGLFDW SUREOHPH UHIHULWRDUH OD %DVDUDELD%XFRYLQDúLODDOWHDVSHFWHFDUHDIHFWDXJUDYVLWXD LDSROLWLF HFRQRPLF úLFXOWXUDO D ULL 3DUDOHOFXDFWLYLWDWHDGHOHJD LHLJXYHUQDPHQWDOHURPkQHRDFWLYLWDWH LQWHQV DX GHVI úXUDW OD 3DULV UHSUH]HQWDQ LL HPLJUD LHL $OH[DQGUX &UHW]LDQX &RQVWDQWLQ 9LúRLDQX *ULJRUH 1LFXOHVFX%X]HúWL 997LOHD *ULJUH *DIHQFX úD FDUH DX SUH]HQWDW &RQIHULQ HL DXJXVW PHPRULXOLQWLWXODW5RPkQLDvQID D&RQIHULQ HLGHSDFHSULQFDUHDXFHUXW UHVWDELOLUHD LQGHSHQGHQ HL SROLWLFH úL D VXYHUDQLW LL 5RPvQLHL DVXSUD
,VWRULD SROLWLFLL H[WHUQH URPkQHúWL vQ GDWH FRRUGRQDWRU ,RQ &DODIHWHDQX %XFXUHúWLSS ÌQ5RPkQLDDIRVWSXEOLFDWODDXJXVW 'HOHJD LD URPkQ FRPSXV GLQ GH PHPEUL D IRVW VWUXFWXUDW OD 3DULV vQ SDWUX FRPLVLL WHULWRULDO úL SROLWLF HFRQRPLF PLOLWDU úL MXULGLF úL LQIRUPDWLY ,RQ *KHRUJKH 0DXUHU D FRPXQLFDW PHPEULORU GHOHJD LHL URPkQH OD &RQIHULQ DS FLLF ODFHUHUHDOXL0RORWRYVDDFFHSWDWFDÄWRDWHFRQWDFWHOHFX GHOHJD LLOHRFFLGHQWDOHYRUWUHEXLV vQFHWH]HPDLDOHVFXGHOHJD LLOH68$úL 0DULL %ULWDQLL GDF QX VD FHUXW PDL vQDLQWH SHUPLVLXQHD SHQWUX DVWIHO GH FRQYRUELULúLHDQXDIRVWDFRUGDW ´
vQWUHJXOXL WHULWRULX QD LRQDO LQWHJUDUHD HFRQRPLHL URPkQHúWL vQ FLUFXLWXO HFRQRPLF PRQGLDO VROX LRQDUHD HFKLWDELO D SUREOHPHL UHSDUD LLORU UHSDWULHUHDSUL]RQLHULORUGHU ]ERLHWF5HVWDELOLUHDLQWHJULW LLWHULWRULDOH D5RPkQLHLúLODJUDQL DGHHVW LJQRUDW GHGHOHJD LDRILFLDO D5RPkQLHL D IRVW ULGLFDW OD RFWRPEULH úL GH *ULJRUH *DIHQFX vQ PHPRULXO LQWLWXODW 2EVHUYD LL DVXSUD SURLHFWXOXL GH 7UDWDW GH 3DFH FX 5RPkQLD 2EVHUYD LLJHQHUDOH ÌQWUHSUREOHPHOHLPSRUWDQWHULGLFDWHGHGHOHJD LDURPkQ VDVLWXDW FHD D FREHOLJHUDQ HL VXV LQXW SULQ LPSRUWDQWD FRQWULEX LH DGXV OD YLFWRULDILQDO DVXSUDIDVFLVPXOXLvQXOWLPHOH OXQLGHU ]ERL3UREOHPDD IRVW GLVFXWDW RILFLDO OD DXJXVW vQ FDGUXO úHGLQ HL &RPLVLHL SROLWLFHúLWHULWRULDOHSHQWUX5RPkQLDFRQVWLWXLW GLQGHSHUVRDQHGLQ VWDWH 6XV LQXW GH '0DQXLOVNL UHSUH]HQWDQWXO 8FUDLQHL úL GH +3LND GHOHJDWXO &HKRVORYDFLHL FHUHUHD GHOHJD LHL URPkQH D IRVW DFFHSWDW GRDU GH SDWUX GHOHJD L FHL DL %LHORUXVLHL &HKRVORYDFLHL 8FUDLQHLúL)UDQ HL 5HVSLQJHUHDDFHVWHLFHUHULILUHúWLúLGHF WUH&RQVLOLXOPLQLúWULORUGH ([WHUQHDLPDULORUSXWHULvQWLPSXOGH]EDWHULORUGHOD1HZ
,VWRULD SROLWLFLL H[WHUQH URPkQHúWL vQ GDWH FRRUGRQDWRU ,RQ &DODIHWHDQX %XFXUHúWLS ùWHIDQ/DFKHRSFLWSS $XVWUDOLD%LHORUXVLD&DQDGD68$)UDQ D,QGLD1RXD=HHODQG 0DUHD %ULWDQLH &HKRVORYDFLD 8FUDLQD 8QLXQHD 6XG$IULFDQ úL 8QLXQHD 6RYLHWLF *HQHUDOXO IUDQFH] &RWURX[ D YRWDW SHQWUX ILLQG FRQYLQV F DúD YRU SURFHGDúLUHSUH]HQWDQ LL68$8566úL0DULL%ULWDQLL$XYRWDWvPSRWULY GHOHJD LLGLQ$XVWUDOLD&DQDGD0DUHD%ULWDQLH,QGLD1RXD=HHODQG 68$ 8QLXQHD6XG$IULFDQ úL8566
GLFWDWXOXLGHOD9LHQDGLQDXJXVW 6LWXD LDvQDFHVWFD]HUDH[WUHP GH VWULQJHQW úL SHULFXORDV GHRDUHFH FHUFXULOH SROLWLFH úL PLOLWDUH GH OD %XGDSHVWD QX DX UHQXQ DW OD LQWHQ LLOH GH D FXFHUL vQWUHDJD 7UDQVLOYDQLH QLFLGXS WUHFHUHD5RPkQLHLGHSDUWHD1D LXQLORU8QLWHODDXJXVW (GLILFDWRDUH vQ DFHVW VHQV VXQW FRQWUDRIHQVLYHOH GHFODQúDWH OD úL VHSWHPEULH vQ SRGLúXO WUDQVLOYDQ vQ &ULúDQD úL %DQDW SUHFXP úL QXPHURDVHOHGHPHUVXULI FXWHGHJXYHUQXOGHOD%XGDSHVWDOD0RVFRYD :DVKLQJWRQúL/RQGUDGXS WHUPLQDUHDU ]ERLXOXLSHQWUXDRE LQHVSULMLQ vQDFHDVW SULYLQ *XYHUQXOXQJDUDFRQWHVWDWFKLDUFRQFOX]LDPLQLúWULORUGH([WHUQHDL PDULORUSXWHULGLQPDL F GLFWDWXOGHOD9LHQDGLQDXJXVW HUD QXO úL QHDYHQLW SUHFXP úL GHFL]LD GLQ PDL FRQIRUP F UHL IURQWLHUD GLQWUH 5RPkQLD úL 8QJDULD HUD VWDELOLW SH WUDVHXO H[LVWHQW vQDLQWHDGLFWDWXOXLÌQDFHVWVHQVODDXJXVW PLQLVWUXOGH([WHUQH DO 8QJDULHL D VROLFLWDW &RQIHULQ HL GH SDFH FHGDUHD F WUH 8QJDULD D XQXL WHULWRULXURPkQHVFGHNPSSUHWHQ LLOHXQJDUHILLQGGLPLQXDWHOD DXJXVW GH F WUH PLQLVWUXO XQJDU OD 3DULV OD FLUFD NPS /D VHSWHPEULH &RPLVLD SROLWLF úL WHULWRULDO SHQWUX 5RPkQLD VD SURQXQ DW vQV SHQWUX PHQ LQHUHD KRW UkULL &RQVLOLXOXL PLQLúWULORU $IDFHULORU([WHUQHDLPDULORUSXWHULSULYLQGPHQ LQHUHDJUDQL HLURPkQR XQJDUH SH WUDVHXO DQWHULRU GLFWDWXOXL GH OD 9LHQD GLQ DXJXVW +RW UkUHDIRUXPXOXLPRQGLDOLQFOXV vQWUDWDWXOGHSDFHGLQIHEUXDULH DUHSUH]HQWDWXQDFWGHMXVWL LHÄ/H0RQGH´DSUHFLLQGF HDDIRVW ÄRVROX LHHFKLWDELO SUREOHPHLQD LRQDOHúLWHULWRULDOHD7UDQVLOYDQLHL´ ÌQILQDOODRFWRPEULH &RQIHULQ DGHSDFHDDSUREDWWH[WXO vQWUHJXOXLWUDWDWGHSDFHFX5RPkQLDGHILQLWLYDWGH&RQVLOLXO0LQLúWULORU $IDFHULORU([WHUQHDLPDULORUSXWHULvQWUXQLWvQFRQIHULQ OD1HZ
3HQWUXFHOHODOWHSUREOHPHURPkQHúWLDERUGDWHGH&RQIHULQ DGH3DFH YH]LùWHIDQ/DFKHRSFLWSS
vQYLQV úL 3XWHULOH $OLDWH úL $VRFLDWH D FRQ LQXW DúD FXP DSUHFLD *KHRUJKH 7 W UHVFX FODX]H ÄSXUW WRDUH GH JULML úL GH SRYHUL´ GDU úL ÄSXUW WRDUHGHOXPLQ úLQ GHMGL´ ÌQWUH SULPHOH GHWHUPLQDWH GH QHDFRUGDUHD FDOLW LL ELQHPHULWDWH GH VWDWFREHOLJHUDQWvQXOWLPDSDUWHDU ]ERLXOXLVDXVLWXDWvPSRY U WRDUHOH FODX]HHFRQRPLFH úLPLOLWDUHRILFLDOL]DUHDVWD LRQ ULLWUXSHORUVRYLHWLFH SH WHULWRULXO QD LRQDO SHQWUX ÄPHQ LQHUHD OLQLLORU GH FRPXQLFD LH DOH $UPDWHL6RYLHWLFHFX]RQDVRYLHWLF GHRFXSD LHGLQ$XVWULD´ VWDELOLUHD JUDQL HL FX 8QLXQHD 6RYLHWLF SH WUDVHXO UH]XOWDW vQ XUPD XOWLPDWXPXOXL VRYLHWLF GLQ LXQLH úL D DFRUGXOXL VRYLHWRFHKRVORYDF GLQ LXQLH úLDFHOHLFX%XOJDULDFRQIRUPWUDWDWXOXLURPkQREXOJDUGLQ VHSWHPEULH HWF &RQFRPLWHQW DX IRVW SLHUGXWH úL FkWHYD RVWURDYH GHSHEUD XO&KLOLD ÌQWUH ÄS U LOH OXPLQRDVH´ VDX DIODW vQ SULPXO UkQG DQXODUHD FRQVHFLQ HORUWHULWRULDOHDOHGLFWDWXOXLGHOD9LHQDGLQDXJXVW úL FRQILUPDUHD UHYHQLULL GH MXUH D vQWUHJLL 7UDQVLOYDQLL OD 5RPkQLD SURFODPDUHD vQFHW ULL VW ULL GH U ]ERL úL GH DUPLVWL LX GLQWUH 5RPkQLD úL 1D LXQLOH 8QLWH úL FUHDUHD ED]HL MXULGLFH SHQWUX GH]YROWDUHD UHOD LLORU H[WHUQHDOH5RPkQLHLvQFRQIRUPLWDWHFXSULQFLSLLOH218
ùWHIDQ/DFKHRSFLWSS 'HVS JXELULOH GH U ]ERL DX IRVW HYDOXDWH OD PLOLRDQH GRODUL 68$ ODSDULWDWHDGHGRODULSHQWUXRXQFLHGHDXU FDUHWUHEXLDXSO WLWHvQ DQLvQFHSkQGGHODVHSWHPEULH 5RPkQLDSLHUGHDDVWIHO%DVDUDELDQRUGXO%XFRYLQHLúL LQXWXO+HU D ) U &DGULODWHU
9,520Æ1,$Ì1&217(;78/*(2675$7(*,& (8523($1Ì17,038/5(*,08/8,&2081,67
6XEWXWHOD0RVFRYHL 'XS LPSXQHUHD UHJLPXOXL FRPXQLVW OD vQFHSXWXO DQXOXL 5RPkQLDDFRQWLQXDWV XUPH]HvQPRGREHGLHQWvQSODQLQWHUQúLLQWHU QD LRQDOSROLWLFD0RVFRYHLSkQ vQSULP YDUDDQXOXL FkQGDSUR FODPDW GHVFKLV QRL SULQFLSLL GH SROLWLF H[WHUQ I U FD DFHVWD V H[SUL PHúLGRULQ DVDXLQWHQ LDGHDLHúLGLQVLVWHPXOFRPXQLVW ,QL LDOvQFRQIRUPLWDWHFXÄVIDWXULOH´0RVFRYHLGLSORPD LDURPkQ D vQWUH LQXW UHOD LL H[WHUQH FX SULRULWDWH vQ FDGUXO VLVWHPXOXL VRFLDOLVWFRPXQLVW WRWDOLWDU vQ SHULRDGD GHFHPEULH LDQXDULH vQFKHLQGXVHWUDWDWHELODWHUDOHGHSULHWHQLHFRODERUDUHúLDVLVWHQ PXWXDO FX 8QLXQHD 6RYLHWLF %XOJDULD &HKRVORYDFLD 3RORQLD 8QJDULD úL ,XJRVODYLD 8Q3URWRFRODQH[ DO7UDWDWXOXLURPkQRVRYLHWLFFRQVHPQD úLJUDQL HOHGLQWUHFHOHGRX VWDWHSUHFL]kQGvQGH]DFRUGFXSUHYHGHULOH 7UDWDWXOXLGHSDFHGLQIHEUXDULH F LQVXODùHUSLORU KD LQWUD vQFRPSRQHQ D85663UHGDUHDSURSULX]LV VDI FXWODPDL vQ ED]DXQXLVLPSOXSURFHVYHUEDOVHPQDWGHUHSUH]HQWDQ LDLPLQLVWHUHORUGH ([WHUQH ÌQDFHHDúLSHULRDG FDXUPDUHDKRW UkULL%LURXOXL,QIRUPDWLY DO SDUWLGHORU FRPXQLVWH úL PXQFLWRUHúWL GH OD %XFXUHúWL GLQ LXQLH SULYLQG EODPDUHD DFWLYLW LL FRQGXFHULL SROLWLFH D 53),XJRVODYLD UHOD LLOHURPkQRLXJRVODYHVDXGHWHULRUDWUDSLGDMXQJkQGXVHODGHQXQ D UHDGHF WUHURPkQLODRFWRPEULH D7UDWDWXOXLGHSULHWHQLHFROD ERUDUHúLDVLVWHQ PXWXDO GLQ 7RWvQSODQXOUHOD LLORULQWHUQD LRQDOHSkQ ODDGPLWHUHDvQ218 5RPkQLD D SDUWLFLSDW LXOLHDXJXVW OD VWDELOLUHD QRXOXL UHJLP DO QDYLJD LHLSH'XQ UH vQWUH8OPúL0DUHD1HDJU SULQEUD XO6XOLQD D
/D GHFHPEULH FX,XJRVODYLDLDQXDULH FX%XOJDULDOD IHEUXDULH FX8QLXQHD6RYLHWLF ODLXQLH FX8QJDULDODLXOLH FX&HKRVORYDFLDODLDQXDULH FX3RORQLD 'XS GHVWU PDUHD 8566 ,QVXOD ùHUSLORU D WUHFXW vQ FRPSRQHQ D 8FUDLQHL
UHVWDELOLW UHOD LL GLSORPDWLFH OD QLYHO GH OHJD LH FX ,QGLD GHFHPEULH 5'* RFWRPEULH 530RQJRO DSULOLH $XVWULD DXJXVW 6LULD DXJXVW úL GH DPEDVDG FX 8QJDULD IHEUXDULH 5HSXEOLFD 'HPRFUDW *HUPDQ 5'* RFWRPEULH $OEDQLD 53&KLQH] RFWRPEULH 5'9LHWQDP IHEUXDULH ,XJRVODYLD LXQLH $UXSWvQV UHOD LLOHFX9DWLFDQXO LXOLH &RQFRPLWHQWDJ ]GXLWFHOGHDO,,,OHDIHVWLYDOPRQGLDODO WLQHUHWXOXL úL VWXGHQ LORU SHQWUX SDFH úL SULHWHQLH DXJXVW D RIHULW DMXWRU QHUDPEXUVDELO 53'&RUHHQH SHQWUX UHIDFHUHD HFRQRPLHL RFWRPEULH DVHPQDWDFRUGXULFRPHUFLDOHúLGHSO LFXVWDWHOHGLQ VLVWHPXO FRPXQLVW GDU úL FX ,QGLD (JLSW 7XUFLD *UHFLD ,QGRQH]LD 7RWvQSODQGLSORPDWLFDDSUHFLDWLQWHUYHQ LDDPHULFDQ vQ&RUHHD GUHSWRDJUHVLXQHFDUHDGXFHDRJUDY DWLQJHUHS FLLVDSURQXQ DWSHQWUX vQI SWXLUHDVHFXULW LLSHFRQWLQHQWúLSHQWUXVROX LRQDUHDSHFDOHSDúQLF D SUREOHPHORUOLWLJLRDVH DDSUHFLDWQD LRQDOL]DUHD&DQDOXOXL6XH]FD XQDFWOHJDOúLOHJLWLPGLQSDUWHDJXYHUQXOXLHJLSWHDQ DXJXVW úLD FRQVLGHUDW F U ]ERLXO DQJORIUDQFRLVUDHOLDQ vPSRWULYD (JLSWXOXL FRQVWLWXLD R JUDY ORYLWXU SHQWUX SDFHD PRQGLDO QRLHPEULH FRQGDPQkQGÄDJUHVLXQHDLPSHULDOLVW ´vPSRWULYD(JLSWXOXL QRLHPEULH ÌQDFHODúLWLPSDUHFXQRVFXWÄQHXWUDOLWDWHDSHUPDQHQW ´D$XVWULHL GHFHPEULH D VDOXWDW UHVWDELOLUHD S FLL vQ ,QGRFKLQD DXJXVW GDU VD GHFODUDW GH DFRUG LQWHUYHQ LD DUPDW VRYLHWLF SHQWUX vQ EXúLUHD UHYROX LHL SRSRUXOXL XQJDU RFWRPEULH &RQFRPLWHQW SULQDGRSWDUHD PDUWLH GHF WUH3UH]LGLXO0DULL$GXQ UL1D LRQDOH DGHFUHWXOXLSULYLQGvQFHWDUHDVW ULLGHU ]ERLFX*HUPDQLD%XFXUHúWLLDX I FXWXQSDVLPSRUWDQWVSUHvPEXQ W LUHDUHOD LLORUFX5HSXEOLFD)HGHUDO D*HUPDQLHL 5)* ÌQ SODQ HFRQRPLF FRODERUDUHD GLQWUH VWDWHOH DIODWH VXE LQIOXHQ D 0RVFRYHLVDGHVI úXUDWPXOW YUHPHFXSULRULWDWHvQFDGUXO&RQVLOLXOXL (FRQRPLF GH $MXWRU 5HFLSURF &$(5 vQILLQ DW vQ LDQXDULH vQ XUPD GHFL]LHL &RQVI WXLULL HFRQRPLFH D UHSUH]HQWDQ LORU JXYHUQHORU %XOJDULHL&HKRVORYDFLHL3RORQLHL5RPkQLHL8QJDULHLúL8566GHV I úXUDW OD0RVFRYD %HQHILF SHQWUXHFRQRPLDURPkQHDVF DIRVWGHV ILLQ DUHDVRYURPXULORU
/D&$(5DPDLDGHUDW$OEDQLD vQIHEUXDULH SkQ vQ 5'* VHSWHPEULH 0RQJROLD LXQLH &XED LXOLH úL 5'9LHWQDP LXQLH /D DFWLYLWDWHD XQRUD GLQWUH VWUXFWXULOH &$(5 D SDUWLFLSDWGLQVHSWHPEULH úL,XJRVODYLD
'XS vQFKHLHUHDWUDWDWXOXLGHSDFHGLQIHEUXDULH GLSORPD LD URPkQ DI FXWGHQHQXP UDWHRULQXPHURDVHGHPHUVXULSHQWUXSULPLUHD vQ 218 IDSW vPSOLQLW OD GHFHPEULH FkQG &RQVLOLXO GH 6HFXULWDWH D UHFRPDQGDW FD 5RPkQLD V ILH DGPLV VLPXOWDQ vPSUHXQ FXDOWHVWDWH vQIRUXPXOPRQGLDO5HFRPDQGDUHDDIRVW DQDOL]DW vQDFHHDúL]LGH$GXQDUHDJHQHUDO D218FDUHDDSUREDWRFX GH YRWXUL SHQWUX FRQWUD úL DE LQHUL &X WRDWH DFHVWHD R EXQ SHULRDG GH WLPS UHSUH]HQWDQ LL 5RPkQLHL DX FRQWLQXDW V VXV LQ QHFRQGL LRQDWSROLWLFD0RVFRYHL 5RPkQLDúL7UDWDWXOGHOD9DUúRYLD 2 VLWXD LD DSDUWH D DYXW 5RPkQLD vQ FDGUXO 7UDWDWXOXL GH OD 9DUúRYLDFRQVWLWXLWODPDL FXUROGHLQVWUXPHQWSROLWLFRPLOLWDU OD vQGHPkQD 0RVFRYHL vQ FRQIUXQWDUHD FX 2UJDQL]D LD $WODQWLFXOXL GH 1RUG 1$72 vQFDGUXOU ]ERLXOXLUHFHGDUúLGH LQHUHVXEFRQWUROD ÄDOLD LORU´FDUHvQFHUFDXV VHHPDQFLSH]HGHVXEWXWHODVRYLHWLF 'HRDUHFH FRQGXFHUHD VRYLHWLF QX D DSOLFDW vQWRFPDL SULQFLSLLOH úL SUHYHGHULOHGRFXPHQWXOXLGHFRQVWLWXLUHD7UDWDWXOXL UHVSHFWDUHDLQGHSHQ
)RUPDW GLQ %HOJLD %UD]LOLD &KLQD7DLZDQ )UDQ D ,UDQ 1RXD =HHODQG 3HUX7XUFLD85660DUHD%ULWDQLHúL68$ $XYRWDWSHQWUXSULPLUHD5RPkQLHLvQ218UHSUH]HQWDQ LLD VWDWH GLQ &RQVLOLXO GH 6HFXULWDWH VDX DE LQXW UHSUH]HQWDQ LL 68$ úL DL &KLQHL 7DLZDQ $OEDQLD,RUGDQLD,UODQGD3RUWXJDOLD8QJDULD,WDOLD$XVWULD%XOJDULD )LQODQGD&H\ORQ1HSDO/LELD&DPERGJLD/DRV6SDQLD $XIRVWvPSRWULY &KLQD7DLZDQúL&XEDVDXDE LQXW2ODQGD)LOLSLQH 68$5HSXEOLFD'RPLQLFDQ úL*UHFLD 7LPS GH DSURDSH R MXP WDWH GH VHFRO FHOH GRX EORFXUL PLOLWDUH ± 1$72 úL 7UDWDWXO GH OD 9DUúRYLD ± DX UHSUH]HQWDW LQVWUXPHQWH DOH FRQIUXQW ULLPLOLWDUHvQWUH(VWúL9HVWvQVSHFLDOvQFHQWUXO(XURSHLvQ*HUPDQLD HOHDIOkQGXVHID vQID 'HODGRFWULQDUHSUHVDOLLORUPDVLYHGLQSHULRDGD ± 1$72DWUHFXWODGRFWULQDULSRVWHLJUDGDWH6FKLPE ULDXLQWHUYHQLWúL vQGRFWULQD7UDWDWXOXLGHOD9DUúRYLDvQVSHFLDOGXS FkQGODFRQGXFHUHD 8566DYHQLW06*RUEDFLRYÌQILQDO8QLXQHD6RYLHWLF DDGRSWDWGRFWULQD Ä6LQDWUD´ID GHVDWHOL LSHUPL kQGILHF UXLDV úLDOHDJ SURSULXOGUXP$IRVW I FXW SRVLELO DVWIHO XQLILFDUHD JHUPDQ RFWRPEULH úL DFFHVXO UHVWXOXL VWDWHORUIRVWHVRFLDOLVWHVSUHLQGHSHQGHQ
GHQ HL úL VXYHUDQLW LL VWDWHORU PHPEUH QHDPHVWHFXO vQ WUHEXULOH LQWHUQH HWF ODVFXUWWLPSDXvQFHSXWV DSDU úLÄUHEHOLL´/DvQFHSXW8QJDULDúL 3RORQLD UHYROWDWH vQ ÄSDFLILFDWH´ LPHGLDW úL UHDGXVH OD ÄRUGLQH´ SULQIRU VDXDPHQLQ DUH$SRL$OEDQLDFDUHGLQ QXDPDLSDUWLFLSDW OD DFWLYLW LOH 7UDWDWXOXL úL FDUH vQ úLD I FXW FXQRVFXW GHFL]LD GH UHWUDJHUHGLQ7UDWDW /DUkQGXL5RPkQLDFDUHvQFHSXVHV VHPDQLIHVWHPDLÄOLEHU´GXS UHWUDJHUHD WUXSHORU VRYLHWLFH GLQ DU úL FKLDU ÄV ULGLFH FDSXO´ GXS DGRSWDUHD'HFODUD LHLGLQDSULOLH DGHYHQLWDOLDWÄUHEHO´GXS DJUHVLXQHDIRU HORUVRYLHWLFHVXV LQXWHGHWUXSHSRORQH]HXQJDUHEXOJDUH úLHVWJHUPDQHvPSRWULYD&HKRVORYDFLHL ) U V SXQ YUHRGDW FD vQ FD]XO XQJXULORU úL DOEDQH]LORU SUR EOHPDS U VLULL7UDWDWXOXLGHOD9DUúRYLDSHP VXUDDFFHQWX ULLSROLWLFLL GH GHVSULQGHUH GH VXE WXWHOD 0RVFRYHL FRQGXFHUHD GH SDUWLG GH VWDW úL PLOLWDU D5RPkQLHLDvQFHSXWV LDWRWPDLGHVFKLVSR]L LHID GHPRGXO vQFDUHRUJDQHOHGHFRQGXFHUHDOH7UDWDWXOXLGHOD9DUúRYLD vQFDGUDWH±vQ IXQF LLOHSULQFLSDOH±QXPDLFXPDUHúDOLJHQHUDOLúLRIL HULVRYLHWLFL WUDWDX PLQLVWHUHOH$S U ULL úLFKLDUJXYHUQHOH VWDWHORUSDUWLFLSDQWHOD7UDWDW ,QYRFkQGSUHYHGHULOHDUWúLGLQ7UDWDWFDUHSUHYHGHDXFRQVXO WDUHD VWDWHORU VHPQDWDUH vQ FHHD FH SULYHúWH SUREOHPHOH LQWHUQD LRQDOH LPSRUWDQWHFDUHDIHFWDXLQWHUHVHOHFRPXQHúLP VXULOHFHWUHEXLDXOXDWHGH FRPXQDFRUGSHQWUXUHDOL]DUHDS FLLúLVHFXULW LLLQWHUQD LRQDOHURPkQLL DSUHFLDX vQF GLQ F DX H[LVWDW VLWXD LL JUDYH SH SODQ LQWHU QD LRQDO FkQG SUREOHPHOH QX DX IRVW DQDOL]DWH vQ FDGUXO &RPLWHWXOXL 3ROLWLF&RQVXOWDWLYLDUP VXULOHDXIRVWDGRSWDWHI U FRQVXOWDUHDSUHDOD ELO DJXYHUQHORUVWDWHORUSDUWLFLSDQWHOD7UDWDWXOGHOD9DUúRYLDFXWRDWH F SUREOHPHOH UHVSHFWLYH DIHFWDX vQ PRG GLUHFW VHFXULWDWHD QD LRQDO D VWDWHORUPHPEUHÌQWUXQDVHPHQHDFRQWH[WvQ FRQGXFHUHDPLOLWDU
3ROLWLFD ÄSDúLORU P UXQ L´ VD LQWHQVLILFDW GXS SOHFDUHD WUXSHORU VRYLHWLFH ILLQG FRQFUHWL]DW LQL LDO SULQ UHLQWURGXFHUHD XQRU VWUXFWXUL PLOLWDUH WUDGL LRQDOHUHYHQLUHDODRELFHLXULúLSUDFWLFLQD LRQDOHvQSURFHVXOGHLQVWUXLUHúL HGXFDUH D WUXSHORU HWF 3URFHVXO D IRVW vQV OHQW XQLL ]LF F VD SURFHGDW FX ÄGLSORPD LH´ PDQLIHVW ULOHGHGHPQLWDWHDOWHUQkQGFXFHOHGHRSRUWXQLVPÌQ SURILWkQG GH FRQWH[WXO LQWHUQD LRQDO úL GH GLILFXOW LOH HFRQRPLFH DOH VWDWXOXLVRYLHWLFVDUHXúLWV VHGHWHUPLQHJXYHUQXOGHOD0RVFRYDV úLUHWUDJ WUXSHOH GLQ 5RPkQLD HYHQLPHQWXO U PkQkQG VLQJXODU vQ FDGUXO VLVWHPXOXL VRFLDOLVWSkQ ODGHVILLQ DUHD7UDWDWXOXLGHOD9DUúRYLDvQ
D5RPkQLHLDSXVSUREOHPDUHYL]XLULLVWDWXWXOXLRUJDQHORUGHFRQGXFHUHD 7UDWDWXOXL GH OD 9DUúRYLD DGRSWDW vQ úL J VLUHD DOWRU PRGDOLW L GH FRODERUDUH&DXUPDUHvQSHULRDGDXUP WRDUHDUH]XOWDWFHHDFHLVWRULFLL DXGHQXPLWGHMDÄE W OLDVWDWXWHORU´ILQDOL]DW vQPDUWLH SULQDGRS WDUHDVWDWXWHORUSULQFLSDOHORUFRPDQGDPHQWHDOH7UDWDWXOXLFDUHDXLQFOXV úLXQHOHGLQH[LJHQ HOHURPkQHúWL $JUHVLXQHD DVXSUD &HKRVORYDFLHL OD FDUH 5RPkQLD QX D SDUWLFLSDWDGRYHGLWF URPkQLLDYXVHVHU GUHSWDWHDWXQFLFkQGLQVLVWDVHU SHQWUXLQVWLWXLUHDXQRUSURFHGHHGHPRFUDWLFHGHDGRSWDUHDGHFL]LLORUvQ FDGUXO7UDWDWXOXLSHQWUXUHVSHFWDUHDLQGHSHQGHQ HLúLVXYHUDQLW LLVWDWHORU PHPEUH &XQRVFXWD úL LQFDOLILFDELOD DJUHVLXQH D VSRULW H[LJHQ HOH URPk QLORU FDUH SHQWUX D IDFH ID SUHVLXQLORU VSRULWH DOH VRYLHWLFLORU úL FKLDU DPHQLQ ULORUGLUHFWHVDXLQGLUHFWH DXDGRSWDWODQLYHOQD LRQDORVHULHGH GHFL]LLPHQLWHV FUHH]HFDGUXOOHJDOFRQVWLWX LRQDOUHVSLQJHULLFHUHULORU FDUHDWHQWDXODLQGHSHQGHQ DúLVXYHUDQLWDWHDQD LRQDO 'HWHDPDUHSHW ULLWULVWHLH[SHULHQ HFHKRVORYDFHFRQGXFHUHDGHOD %XFXUHúWL QX D PDL IRVW GH DFRUG FD SH WHULWRULXO 5RPkQLHL V VH GHVI úRDUH DSOLFD LL FX WUXSH VWU LQH úL QLFL QXDPDLSHUPLVSDUWLFLSDUHD WUXSHORUURPkQHODDSOLFD LLOHGHVI úXUDWHSHWHULWRULLOHDOWRUVWDWHDOLDWH$ FRQGL LRQDW GH DVHPHQHD GHSODVDUHD GLVORFDUHD VDX VWD LRQDUHD WHPSRUDU GHWUXSHVRYLHWLFHSHWHULWRULXOURPkQHVFúLDFHORUURPkQHSH WHULWRULXO%XOJDULHL úLFKLDUSDUWLFLSDUHDXQRUFRPDQGDPHQWHVRYLHWLFHúL EXOJDUHI U WUXSHODDSOLFD LLSHKDUW H[HFXWDWHvQ5RPkQLD GHVHPQDUHD XQRUFRQYHQ LLJXYHUQDPHQWDOHURPkQRVRYLHWLFHúLURPkQREXOJDUH
&HD PDL LPSRUWDQW D IRVW GHFL]LD DGRSWDW GH 0DUHD $GXQDUH 1D LRQDO FRQIRUP F UHLD VWD LRQDUHD úL WUDQ]LWDUHD RULF URU WUXSH DOLDWH SH WHULWRULXO 5RPkQLHL WUHEXLD V DLE DFRUGXO IRUXOXL OHJLVODWLY URPkQ úL V ILH UH]XOWDWXO SDUODPHQW ULORU vQWUH FRQGXFHULOH VWDWHORU UHVSHFWLYH 7RW GLQ ÄH[HPSOXO´ FHKRVORYDF D GHFXUV ÄvQF S kQDUHD´ OXL 1LFRODH &HDXúHVFX FD ÄVWDUHDGHSHULFRO´V ILHDSUHFLDW GHÄWRDWH´JXYHUQHOHVWDWHORUSDUWLFLSDQWHOD WUDWDW úL QX GRDU GH XQHOH FRPDQGDQWXO VXSUHP DO )RU HORU $UPDWH 8QLWH )$8 XUPkQG D GD LQGLFD LLUHFRPDQG UL SULYLQG GLVORFDUHD úL UHGLVORFDUHD )$8 QXPDL FX DFRUGXO JXYHUQHORU QD LRQDOH $FHVW IDSW OD GHWHUPLQDW SH PDUHúDOXO$$*UHFLNRV DWUDJ DWHQ LDF QXYDDFFHSWDFDGLQFRPDQGDQW± VXSUHP V DMXQJ ÄYRUELWRU± VXSUHP´ /D UkQGXL úHIXO 6WDWXOXL 0DMRU DO )$8 PDUHúDOXO ùWHPHQNR QX D H]LWDW V IRUPXOH]H FKLDU DPHQLQ UL DWHQ LRQkQGF SH$'XEFHNQXODvQWUHEDWQLPHQLFkQGWUXSHOH7UDWDWXOXLGHOD 9DUúRYLDDXLQYDGDW&HKRVORYDFLD
&X WRDWH F QHvQ HOHJHULOH URPkQRVRYLHWLFH DX FRQWLQXDW V H[LVWH SkQ ODGHVILLQ DUHD7UDWDWXOXLGHOD9DUúRYLDFRQGXFHUHDSROLWLF úLPLOL WDU URPkQHDVF QXúLDSXVQLFLRGDW SUREOHPDS U VLULL7UDWDWXOXLGHOD 9DUúRYLD DúD FXP I FXVHU 8QJXULL vQ QX D SXV OD vQGRLDO QHFHVLWDWHDWUDWDWXOXLPDLPXOWGkQGDVLJXU ULF 5RPkQLDvúLYDvQGHSOLQL REOLJD LLOH vQ FD] GH DJUHVLXQH ÄLPSHULDOLVW ´ 3ULQ XUPDUH FKLDU GDF D IRVW vQ DQXPLWH SHULRDGH XQ DOLDW ÄUHEHO´ vQ 7UDWDWXO GH OD 9DUúRYLD 5RPkQLD D IRVW vQ SHUPDQHQ XQ DOLDW ÄILGHO´ DO DFHVWXLD SkQ OD GHVILLQ DUHDVDvQ 5HWUDJHUHDWUXSHORUVRYLHWLFHúLDFRQVLOLHULORUPLOLWDUL 3UH]HQ DWUXSHORUVRYLHWLFHSHWHULWRULXOURPkQHVFDGHYHQLWLQXWLO GXS FH6WDWHOH8QLWHDOH$PHULFLL8QLXQHD6RYLHWLF 0DUHD%ULWDQLHúL )UDQ DDXVHPQDWODPDL 7UDWDWXOGHVWDWFX$XVWULDúLGXS FHOD VHSWHPEULHDFHODúLDQXOWLPHOHWUXSHVRYLHWLFHVDXUHWUDVGLQDFHDVW DU ÌQFHUFkQGV YDORULILFHDFHVWSULOHMúLRSRUWXQLWDWHDPRPHQWXOXLFUHDW GH6XPPLWXOFHORUSDWUXPDULSXWHUL 856668$0DUHD%ULWDQLHúL )UDQ D GH OD *HQHYD GLQ SHULRDGD LXOLH SHUFHSXW FD R VSHUDQ GH GHVWLQGHUH vQ (XURSD SUHFXP úL GH UHGXFHULOH GH HIHFWLYH FHUXWHGH0RVFRYD%LURXO3ROLWLFDO&&DO305 DGHFLVvQDXJXVW FD16+UXúFLRYV ILHFRQVXOWDWvQOHJ WXU FXUHWUDJHUHDWUXSHORU VRYLHWLFH/XDWSULQVXUSULQGHUHDFHVWDLDDFX]DWLQL LDOSHURPkQLGH QD LRQDOLVP úL DQWLVRYLHWLVP vQV GXS GH]EDWHUL vQ FDGUXO vQWUHJLL FRQGXFHUL SROLWLFH GH OD 0RVFRYD D GHFLV V úL UHWUDJ WUXSHOH GLQ 5RPkQLD
3HODUJ &RQVWDQWLQ2OWHDQX5RPkQLD2YRFHGLVWLQFW vQ7UDWDWXO GH OD 9DUúRYLD %XFXUHúWL &RQVWDQWLQ 2OWHDQX $OHVDQGUX 'X X &RQVWDQWLQ $QWLS 5RPkQLD úL 7UDWDWXO GH OD 9DUúRYLD ,VWRULF 0 UWXULL 'RFXPHQWH &URQRORJLH %XFXUHúWL (GLWXUD 3URKLVWRULD S $OHD[DQGUX2úFD9DVLOH3RSD5RPkQLD±RIHUHDVWU GHVFKLV vQFRUWLQDGH ILHU)RFúDQL(GLWXUD9ODKLH && DO 305 D SURSXV FD SUREOHPD V ILH ULGLFDW GH *KHRUJKH *KHRUJKLX'HM 6SUH VXUSULQGHUHD WXWXURU DFHVWD VD GHUREDW úL OD GHOHJDW SH (PLO%RGQ UDú
5HDF LDGXU D0RVFRYHLID GHÄH[SOR]LD´GLQ8QJDULDGLQWRDP QD DQXOXL ÄD vQJKH DW´ GLVFX LLOH SULYLQG UHWUDJHUHD WUXSHORU VRYLHWLFH OD vQFHSXWXO OXQLL GHFHPEULH FRQVLGHUkQGXVH GH FRPXQ DFRUGF VWD LRQDUHDYUHPHOQLF DXQLW LORUPLOLWDUHVRYLHWLFHSHWHULWRULXO 5RPkQLHL HUD LQGLFDW vQ HOHJHUHD ILLQG FRQFUHWL]DW SULQ $FRUGXO GLQ DSULOLH FDUH UHJOHPHQWD VWDWXWXO MXULGLF DO WUXSHORU VRYLHWLFH VWD LRQDWHWHPSRUDUvQ5RPkQLD ÌQSULP YDUDDQXOXLXUP WRU16+UXúFLRYDDSUHFLDWODDSULOLH vQWURVFULVRDUHDGUHVDW OXL*KHRUJKH*KHRUJKLX'HMF vQQRXOFRQWH[W LQWHUQD LRQDO FDUDFWHUL]DW SULQ ÄR RDUHFDUH VO ELUH D vQFRUG ULL LQWHUQD LRQDOH´ úL vQ VLWXD LD vQ FDUH 5RPkQLD GLVSXQHD GHMD GH ÄIRU H vQDUPDWHGHQ GHMGHFDSDELOHV GHDRULSRVW SURYRF ULORULPSHULDOLúWLORU V DSHUH FXFHULULOH VRFLDOLVWH DOH SRSRUXOXL URPkQ úL V úL DGXF FRQWULEX LD OD FDX]D DS U ULL LQWHUHVHORU FRPXQH DOH ODJ UXOXL VRFLDOLVW´ 8QLXQHD 6RYLHWLF FRQVLGHUD F ÄQX PDL HVWH QHFHVDU úHGHUHD WUXSHORU VRYLHWLFH SH WHULWRULXO 5HSXEOLFLL 3RSXODUH 5RPkQH´ $FFHSWXO %XFXUHúWLORU D IRVW I FXW FXQRVFXW OD DSULOLH *KHRUJKH
$UWDOGRFXPHQWXOXLSUHYHGHDF WUXSHOHVRYLHWLFHVWD LRQDWHWHPSRUDU vQ5RPkQLDÄQXDIHFWHD] vQQLFLXQIHOVXYHUDQLWDWHD6WDWXOXLURPkQ´F DFHVWHD ÄQX VH DPHVWHF vQ WUHEXULOH LQWHUQH DOH 5HSXEOLFLL 3RSXODUH 5RPkQH´ ILLQG REOLJDWHÄV UHVSHFWHúLV VHFRQIRUPH]HSUHYHGHULORUOHJLORUURPkQHúWL´(IHFWL YHOHúLORFXULOHGHGLVORFDUHXUPDXV ILHVWDELOLWHSULQFRQYHQ LLVSHFLDOHvQFKHLDWH ODQLYHOGHJXYHUQ'HSODVDUHDDSOLFD LLOHúLPDQHYUHOHWUXSHORUVRYLHWLFHvQDIDUD ORFXULORU GH GLVORFDUH QHFHVLWD SHQWUX ILHFDUH FD] vQ SDUWH FRQVLP PkQWXO JXYHUQXOXL URPkQ VDX DO DXWRULW LORU vPSXWHUQLFLWH GH DFHVWD 3HQWUX UH]ROYDUHD SUREOHPHORU OHJDWH GH LQWHUSUHWDUHD VDX DSOLFDUHD $FRUGXOXL úL D FRQYHQ LLORU VXSOLPHQWDUH D IRVW FRQVWLWXLW R &RPLVLH PL[W URPkQRVRYLHWLF FRPSXV GLQ WUHL SHUVRDQH GH ILHFDUH SDUWH FX VHGLXO OD %XFXUHúWL $FRUGXO XUPD V LQWUH vQ YLJRDUH vQ XUPD VFKLPE ULL LQVWUXPHQWHORU GH UDWLILFDUH FH XUPD D DYHD ORF OD 0RVFRYD ÌQ DFFHS LD FRQGXFHULL GH OD .UHPOLQ DF LXQHD XUPD V FRQVWLWXLH ÄvQF R GRYDG FRQFUHW úL FRQYLQJ WRDUH D SROLWLFLL GH SDFH D 8QLXQLL 6RYLHWLFH D 5HSXEOLFLL 3RSXODUH 5RPkQH úL D vQWUHJXOXL ODJ U VRFLDOLVW D WHQGLQ HLQRDVWUHFRPXQHGHDRE LQHQXvQFXYLQWHFLvQIDSWHRGHVWLQGHUHD vQFRUG ULL LQWHUQD LRQDOH 8Q DVHPHQHD DFW YD OLSVL FHUFXULOH LPSHULDOLVWH GH XQXOGLQDUJXPHQWHOHLPSRUWDQWHSHFDUHOHIRORVHVFSHQWUXMXVWLILFDUHDSROLWLFLL GHSUHJ WLULPLOLWDUHúLYDFRQWULEXLODXQLUHDIRU HORUFDUHVHSURQXQ SHQWUX PHQ LQHUHDS FLLSHQWUXFRH[LVWHQ DSDúQLF DVWDWHORU´
*KHRUJKLX'HMGkQGDVLJXU ULF IRU HOHDUPDWHURPkQHÄYRUIDFHID FX FLQVWHvQRULFHvPSUHMXU ULvQGDWRULULORUFDUHOHUHYLQvQFDGUXOODJ UXOXL VRFLDOLVW´ $ GRXD ]L PDL &RPLWHWXO 3ROLWLF &RQVXOWDWLY DO VWDWHORU PHPEUH DOH 7UDWDWXOXL GH OD 9DUúRYLD D DSUREDW ÄSURSXQHUHD 8QLXQLL 6RYLHWLFH SXV GH DFRUG FX JXYHUQXO 5HSXEOLFLL 3RSXODUH 5RPkQH FX SULYLUH OD UHWUDJHUHD vQ YLLWRUXO DSURSLDW GH SH WHULWRULXO 5HSXEOLFLL 3RSXODUH5RPkQHDWUXSHORUVRYLHWLFHFDUHVHDIO DFRORvQFRQIRUPLWDWH FX WUDWDWXO GH OD 9DUúRYLD´ ,QGLIHUHQW GH XQHOH LQH[DFWLW L FXSULQVH vQ DFHDVW IRUPXODUHHYHQLPHQWXODUHSUH]HQWDWRSHUIRUPDQ DGLSORPD LHL URPkQH FDUH D DYXW XUP UL EHQHILFH SHQWUX PDQLIHVWDUHD FUHVFkQG D VXYHUDQLW LL QD LRQDOH &X DFHODúL SULOHM VD GHFLV FD VWDWHOH PHPEUH DOH 7UDWDWXOXLGHOD9DUúRYLDV úLUHGXF HIHFWLYHOHvQ FX GH PLOLWDUL 5HWUDJHUHD VD I FXW vQ FRQIRUPLWDWH FX SUHYHGHULOH XQXL $FRUG ELODWHUDOvQYDUDDQXOXL HYHQLPHQWXODDYXWXQODUJHFRXLQWHUQúL LQWHUQD LRQDO &RQFRPLWHQWDXvQFHSXWV ILHUHWUDúLúLFRQVLOLHULLPLOLWDULVRYLHWLFL DIOD L SH WHULWRULXO 5RPkQLHL GLQ 0RVFRYD DSUHFLLQG OD LDQXDULH F vQ DFHO PRPHQW úHGHUHD SHUPDQHQW D FRQVLOLHULORU PLOLWDULVRYLHWLFLvQ5RPkQLDÄQXPDLFRUHVSXQGHLQWHUHVHORUFDX]HL´úLvúL I FHD FXQRVFXW GLVSRQLELOLWDWHD GH ÄD DFRUGD úL SH YLLWRU vQ P VXUD QHFHVLW LL XQ DMXWRU IU HVF SULQ VSHFLDOLúWL 5HSXEOLFLL 3RSXODUH 5RPkQH´ 2IHUWD GH UHWUDJHUH D FRQVLOLHULORU D IRVW DFFHSWDW LPHGLDW GH FRQGXFHUHD GH OD %XFXUHúWL OD IHEUXDULH && DO 305 U VSXQ]kQG F vPS UW úHúWH ÄSH GHSOLQ´ SURSXQHUHD && DO 3&86 3UREOHPD UHWUDJHULL WXWXURU FRQVLOLHULORU úL D ÄUHGXFHULL PD[LPH´ D VSHFLDOLúWLORUVRYLHWLFLDIRVWUHOXDW GH&&DO3&86OD VHSWHPEULH vQWUR VFULVRDUH DGUHVDW && DO 305 vQ FDUH VH DU WD F VRYLHWLFLORU OH HUD JUHX V LQ vQ FkPSXO YL]XDO DFWLYLWDWHD ILHF UXL VSHFLDOLVW FDUH QX vQWRWGHDXQD VH GHVFXUFD ELQH vQ ÄVLWXD LD SROLWLF úL SDUWLFXODULW LOH QD LRQDOH´ URPkQHúWL $FRUGXO URPkQHVF D IRVW H[SULPDW ODVHSWHPEULHGHF WUH*KHRUJKH*KHRUJKLX'HMFDUHúLDPDQLIHVWDW
&RQVLOLHULLPLOLWDULVRYLHWLFLHUDXUHSDUWL]D LODWRDWHVWUXFWXULOHPLOLWDUH URPkQHSkQ ODHúDORDQHOHUHJLPHQWúLEULJ ]LLQGHSHQGHQWHSULQFLSDODORUPLVL XQH FRQVWkQG vQ XUP ULUHD vQGHDSURDSH D HYROX LHL DUPDWHL URPkQH úL WUDQVIRU PDUHDDFHVWHLDGXS PRGHOVRYLHWLF
vQVFULVRDUHDGHU VSXQVFRQYLQJHUHDF ÄGH]YROWDUHDIRUPHORUYDULDWHDOH VFKLPEXOXL GH H[SHULHQ vQ VSHFLDO WULPLWHUHD GH VSHFLDOLúWL SHQWUX VWXGLHUHD H[SHULHQ HL GRPHQLXO HFRQRPLHL FXOWXULL DS U ULL SUHFXP úL WULPLWHUHD UHFLSURF GH WLQHUL vQ LQVWLWX LLOH GH vQY PkQW VXSHULRU YD FRQWULEXLODFRQWLQXDGH]YROWDUHDFRODERU ULLIU HúWLGLQWUH ULOHQRDVWUH´ 3HDFHDVW OLQLHGHFRQGXLW ODLDQXDULH SULPXOVHFUHWDUDO &&DO305DUXJDWSH16+UXúFLRYV ILHGHDFRUGFXWULPLWHUHDvQ 5RPkQLD D FLQFL VSHFLDOLúWL VRYLHWLFL SHQWUX ÄQHYRLOH GH SUHJ WLUH úL SHUIHF LRQDUH´DOHDUPDWHLURPkQHFDUHV FRQVLOLH]HFRQGXFHUHDDUPDWHL vQSUREOHPHGHVWDWPDMRU RSHUD LLRUJDQL]DUHPRELOL]DUH SUHJ WLUHGH OXSW DDUPDWHLGHXVFDW GHSUHIHULQ ODWDQFXULúLPHFDQL]DWH DS UDUH DQWLDHULDQ PDULQ UDGLRWHKQLF /D VFXUW WLPS PDUHúDOXO ,9.RQHY D U VSXQVI FkQGFXQRVFXWQXPHOHDVSHFLDOLúWLPLOLWDULVRYLHWLFL8OWHULRU &RPLWHWXO 3ROLWLF &RQVXOWDWLY D GHFLV OD PDUWLH FD ORFXO FRQVLOLHULORU PLOLWDUL vQ DUPDWHOH VWDWHORU SDUWLFLSDQWH OD 7UDWDWXO GH OD 9DUúRYLDV ILHOXDWGHF WUHUHSUH]HQWDQ LDLFRPDQGDQWXOXLVXSUHPHúHI DO)RU HORU$UPDWH8QLWHÌQED]DDFHVWHLGHFL]LLDIRVWHODERUDWúLXQVWDWXW VSHFLDODODFHVWRUD 5HWUDJHUHDWUXSHORUVRYLHWLFHúLDFRQVLOLHULORU PLOLWDULúLFLYLOL GLQ 5RPkQLD D FRQVWLWXLW XQ PRPHQW GH EXFXULH SHQWUX VRFLHWDWHD URPkQHDVF 'HFL]LD 0RVFRYHL D IRVW SULPD GH DFHVW JHQ GLQ FDGUXO ÄLPSHULXOXL H[WHULRU´ VRYLHWLF ILLQG GHWHUPLQDW vQ PRG HYLGHQW GH vQFHUFDUHD .UHPOLQXOXL GH DúL UHIDFH LPDJLQHD H[WUHPGHúLIRQDW GXS LQWHUYHQ LD EUXWDO GLQ 8QJDULD ÌQ DIDUD LQWHUHVHORU SURSDJDQGLVWLFH P VXUD D IRVW GHWHUPLQDW úL GH LQWHUHVH HFRQRPLFH ± HIHFWXDUHD GH HFRQRPLL úL SROLWLFH ± FkúWLJDUHD ÄEXQ YRLQ HL´ XQRUD GLQ VDWHOL L vQWUH FDUH úL SH FHD D URPkQLORU SH FDUH ,96WDOLQ vL WUDWDVH ÄIRDUWH GXU´ GLFWkQGXOH ÄYRLQ D VD´ DúD FXP UHFXQRúWHD vQVXúL 16 +UXúFLRY vQ PHPRULLOH VDOH 6O ELUHD vQFRUG ULL LQWHUQD LRQDOH úL VSRULUHD IRU HL GH OXSW DDUPDWHLVRYLHWLFHvQSRILGDUHGXFHULORUGHSHUVRQDOvQVSHFLDOvQ GRPHQLXOQXFOHDUSUHFXPúLIDSWXOF 5RPkQLDQXDYHDJUDQL FRPXQ FX ULOHFDUHI FHDXSDUWHGLQRUJDQL]D LD3DFWXOXL1RUG$WODQWLFVDXFX YUHR DU FDSLWDOLVW DXI FXWFDSULQDFHDVW P VXU VRYLHWLFLLV QXULúWH SUDFWLFQLPLF 5HWUDJHUHD WUXSHORU VRYLHWLFH GLQ 5RPkQLD úL DGRSWDUHD vQ DSULOLH GHF WUH3ODQDUDO UJLW D&&DO305D'HFODUD LHLFXSULYLUHOD SR]L LD3DUWLGXOXL0XQFLWRUHVF5RPkQvQSUREOHPHOHPLúF ULLFRPXQLVWH
úL PXQFLWRUHúWL LQWHUQD LRQDOH DX SHUPLV FRQGXFHULL GH OD %XFXUHúWL V GHVI úRDUH vQ SHULRDGD XUP WRDUH R SROLWLF DFWLY vQ SODQ LQWHUQD LRQDO I U V PDL UHFXQRDVF SR]L LD GH KHJHPRQ DO VWDWXOXL VRYLHWLF úL UROXO FRQGXF WRUDO3DUWLGXOXL&RPXQLVWDO8QLXQLL6RYLHWLFH 'HODUHYLULPHQWXOSROLWLFLLH[WHUQH ODL]RODUHDLQWHUQD LRQDO 'HVSULQGHUHD GH SROLWLFD H[WHUQ D 0RVFRYHL FRPSOHWDW DSURDSH FRQFRPLWHQWGHRULHQWDUHDVSUHVWDWHOHGLQRFFLGHQWXO(XURSHLvQFHSXW vQ DQLL VDDFFHQWXDWGXS LQWHUYHQ LDWUXSHORUVRYLHWLFH úLDDOWRU FLQFLVWDWHGLQ7UDWDWXOGHOD9DUúRYLD vQ&HKRVORYDFLDvQDXJXVW ÌQ DFHOHPRPHQWHWUDJLFHvQV úL5RPkQLDVDDIODWODXQSDVGHDILLQYDGDW OD JUDQL HOH VDOH VHPQDOkQGXVH ÄPLúF UL QHRELúQXLWH´ 'HúL D QHJDW LQWHQ LD GH D LQYDGD úL WHULWRULXO 5RPkQLHL JXYHUQXO VRYLHWLF D OXDW FX VLJXUDQ vQ FDOFXO DYHUWLVPHQWXO DPHULFDQ F vQWUR DVHPHQHD VLWXD LH UHDF LDRSLQLHLSXEOLFHDPHULFDQHYDILJUHXGHFRQWURODW ÌQ DFHVW FRQWH[W DX IRVW vQUHJLVWUDWH VFKLPE UL HVHQ LDOH vQ SROLWLFD H[WHUQ D 5RPkQLHL SULQWUH UHDOL] ULOH GH VHDP vQUHJLVWUkQGXVH PHGLHUHDFRQIOLFWXOXLVRYLHWRFKLQH]ODvQFHSXWXODQLORU VWDELOLUHDGH UHOD LL GLSORPDWLFH OD QLYHO GH DPEDVDG FX 5)* LDQXDULH UHOD LL SULHWHQHúWL FKLDU FRUGLDOH FX ,XJRVODYLD UHVWDELOLWH vQ S VWUDUHD UHOD LLORU GLSORPDWLFH FX ,VUDHOXO vQ XUPD U ]ERLXOXL GH ]LOH GLQWUH (JLSW ,RUGDQLD 6LULD úL ,VUDHO LXQLH VLQJXUD DU VRFLDOLVW GLQ(XURSDFDUHDSURFHGDWDVWIHO QHLQWHUYHQ LDDUPDW vQ&HKRVORYDFLD vQ úL FRQGDPQDUHD LQYD]LHL VRYLHWLFH úL D WUXSHORU DOWRU VWDWH GLQ 7UDWDWXO GH OD 9DUúRYLD VLQJXUD DU GLQ 7UDWDW FDUH D SURFHGDW DVWIHO RE LQHUHD FODX]HL QD LXQLL FHOHL PDL IDYRUL]DWH GLQ SDUWHD 68$ PHGLHUHD vQ FDGUXO GLVFX LLORU DUDERLVUDHOLHQH ILQDOL]DWH FX DFRUGXO GH OD &DPS 'DYLV68$ PHGLHUHD vQ VWDELOLUHD UHOD LLORU GLSORPDWLFHGLQWUH68$úL&KLQD HWF &RQFRPLWHQWSROLWLFDH[WHUQ URPkQHDVF VDLQGLYLGXDOL]DWGLQFH vQFHPDLPXOWvQFDGUXO2UJDQL]D LHL1D LXQLORU8QLWHPXOWHSURLHFWHGH UH]ROX LL LQL LDWH GH 5RPkQLD ILLQG DGRSWDWH GH $GXQDUHD *HQHUDO D RUJDQL]D LHLPRQGLDOH 3ULPXOSURLHFWGHUH]ROX LHSURSXV vPSUHXQ FX0H[LF úLDGRSWDW ODQRLHPEULH VDUHIHULWODED]HOHFRRSHU ULLHFRQRPLFHLQWHUQD
LRQDOH$XXUPDWDOWHOHUHIHULWRDUHOD GH]YROWDUHDvQY PkQWXOXLSULPDU vQWHULWRULLOHQHDXWRQRPHGHVXEWXWHOD218IRVWHFRORQLL GHFHPEULH SRVLELOLW LOH GH FRRSHUDUH vQ PDWHULH GH GH]YROWDUH D LQGXVWULHL SHWUROLHUH vQ ULOH vQ FXUV GH GH]YROWDUH GHFHPEULH LQL LDW GH 5RPkQLDúLSUH]HQWDW vPSUHXQ FX$OEDQLD&HKRVORYDFLDúL8UXJXD\ SURPRYDUHDvQUkQGXULOHWLQHUHWXOXLDLGHDOXULORUS FLLUHVSHFWXOXLUHFLSURF úL vQ HOHJHULL vQWUH SRSRDUH GHFHPEULH GHFHPEULH GHFHPEULH FRRSHUDUHD HFRQRPLF LQWHUQD LRQDO GHFHPEULH QHFHVLWDWHDHODERU ULLXQXL7UDWDWLQWHUQD LRQDODVXSUDSULQFLSLLORU FDUH V JXYHUQH]H DFWLYLWDWHD úL XWLOL]DUHD VSD LXOXL H[WUDDWPRVIHULF GHFHPEULH 5RPkQLDILLQGFRDXWRDUH FRQVHFLQ HOHHFRQRPLFH úLVRFLDOHDOHFXUVHLvQDUP ULORUúLHIHFWHOHVDOHSURIXQGG XQ WRDUHDVXSUD S FLL úL VHFXULW LL vQ OXPH úL UROXO úWLLQ HL úL WHKQRORJLHL PRGHUQH vQ GH]YROWDUHD QD LXQLORU úL QHFHVLWDWHD vQW ULULL FRRSHU ULL HFRQRPLFH úL WHKQLFRúWLLQ LILFHvQWUHVWDWH GHFHPEULH FUHúWHUHDUROXOXL218 vQPHQ LQHUHDúLvQW ULUHDS FLLúLVHFXULW LLLQWHUQD LRQDOHvQGH]YROWDUHD FRODERU ULLvQWUHWRDWHQD LXQLOHvQSURPRYDUHDGUHSWXOXLLQWHUQD LRQDOvQ UHOD LLOH GLQWUH VWDWH QRLHPEULH UHJOHPHQWDUHD SULQ PLMORDFH SDúQLFH D GLIHUHQGHORU GLQWUH VWDWH úL GH]YROWDUHD úL FRQVROLGDUHD EXQHL YHFLQ W LvQWUHVWDWH GHFHPEULH GHFHPEULH UHGXFHUHD EXJHWHORU PLOLWDUH úL D FRQVHFLQ HORU HFRQRPLFH úL VRFLDOH DOH FXUVHL vQDUP ULORU úL FKHOWXLHOLORU PLOLWDUH GHFHPEULH GHFHPEULH GHFHPEULH GH]YROWDUHD úL vQW ULUHD EXQHL YHFLQ W L GHFHPEULH U VSXQGHUHDVWDWHORUSHQWUXSURWHF LDPHGLXOXLvQFRQMX U WRU úL SUHYHQLUHD SROX ULL DFHVWXLD FD XUPDUH D FXPXO ULL GH UH]LGXXUL WR[LFHúLSHULFXORDVHúLvQW ULUHDFRRSHU ULLLQWHUQD LRQDOHSHQWUXVROX LR QDUHDDFHVWHLSUREOHPH GHFHPEULH HWF $OWH LQL LDWLYH URPkQHúWL DX YL]DW FRQYRFDUHD XQHL FRQIHULQ H OD QLYHOvQDOWSHQWUXUHDOL]DUHDXQHLvQ HOHJHULPXOWLODWHUDOHúLvQFKHLHUHDXQXL WUDWDWGHWUDQVIRUPDUHD%DOFDQLORUvQWUR]RQ DS FLLúLSULHWHQLHL VHS WHPEULH FUHDUHDvQ%DOFDQLDXQHL]RQHI U DUPHQXFOHDUH LX QLH HOLPLQDUHD GLQ PDQXDOHOH úFRODUH D RULF UHL SURSDJDQGH
3URSXQHUHI FXW JXYHUQHORU$OEDQLHL%XOJDULHL*UHFLHL,XJRVODYLHL úL7XUFLHL 3URSXQHUHDXUPDV ILHDQDOL]DW vQWLPSXOvQWkOQLULLúHILORUGHJXYHUQH GLQVWDWHOHEDOFDQLFH
DJUHVLYH GH U ]ERL úL GH GLVFULPLQDUH UDVLDO IHEUXDULH ± PDUWLH UHFXQRDúWHUHDGUHSWXOXLOHJLWLPDO&KLQHLGHDILDGPLV vQ218 VHSWHPEULH GHFHPEULH QRLHPEULH vQFHWDUHD SROHPLFLL SXEOLFH vQWUH 8566 úL &KLQD úL vQWUH 3&86 úL 3DUWLGXO &RPXQLVW &KLQH] úL UH]ROYDUHD GLYHUJHQ HORU SH FDOHD QHJRFL HULORU IHEUXDULH PHGLHUHD FRQIOLFWXOXL LGHRORJLF úL SROLWLF FKLQR VRYLHWLF PDUWLH úLLXOLH vQFHWDUHDLPHGLDW D DF LXQLORUPLOLWDUHGLQ2ULHQWXO$SURSLDWUHWUDJHUHDWUXSHORULVUDHOLHQHGLQ WHULWRULLOH RFXSDWH HWF LXQLH vQFHWDUHD ERPEDUGDPHQWHORU DVXSUD9LHWQDPXOXLúLVWLQJHUHDFRQIOLFWXOXLSHFDOHGLSORPDWLF LXQLH vPEXQ W LUHD SURLHFWXOXL GH WUDWDW GH QHSUROLIHUDUH D DUPHORU QXFOHDUH RFWRPEULH GHVHPQDUHD SHULRDGHL GUHSW Ä'HFHQLXOGH]DUP ULL´ DSULOLH SUHYHQLUHDúLUHSULPDUHDWHURULV PXOXLLQWHUQD LRQDO DXJXVW RSULUHDDPSODV ULLGHQRLUDFKHWHFX UD] PHGLH GH DF LXQH úL UHWUDJHUHD FHORU H[LVWHQWH QRLHPEULH QRLHPEULH ±úLGLVWUXJHUHDFHORUH[LVWHQWHPDUWLH RFWRPEULH RSULUHD FXUVHL vQDUP ULORU úL WUHFHUHD OD UHDOL]DUHD GH]DUP ULL vQ SULPXO UkQG D FHOHL QXFOHDUH LXQLH UHJOHPHQWDUHD SDúQLF D GLIHUHQGHORU LQWHUQD LRQDOH QRLHPEULH vQFHWDUHD I U vQWkU]LHUH D DF LXQLORU DUPDWH VROX LRQDUHD SUREOHPHORU
ÌQFDGUXOFHOHLGHD;9DVHVLXQLD$GXQ ULL*HQHUDOHD218 6FULVRDUHDGHVFKLV DGUHVDW 6HFUHWDUXOXLJHQHUDO21887KDQWGH F WUH UHSUH]HQWDQWXO SHUPDQHQW DO 5RPkQLHL OD 218 vQ FDUH VH DU WD F JXYHUQXOURPkQVHDVRFLD] vQFDOLWDWHGHFRDXWRUODFHUHUHDJXYHUQXOXLUHJDO DO&DPERGJLHLGHDVHvQVFULHSHRUGLQHDGH]LÄ5HVWDELOLUHDGUHSWXULORUOHJLWLPH DOH53&KLQH]HOD218´ ÌQWLPSXOYL]LWHLXQHLGHOHJD LLD&&DO305vQ&KLQDIRUPDW GLQ (PLO%RGQ UDú1LFRODH&HDXúHVFXúL&KLYX6WRLFD ÌQWLPSXOGLVFX LHLGLQWUH,RQ*KHRUJKH0DXUHUúL16+UXúFLRY 6XJHVWLHI FXW GH,RQ*KHRUJKH0DXUHUOXL/\QGRQ%-RKQVRQ $SHODGRSWDWGH0DUHD$GXQDUH1D LRQDO F WUHSDUODPHQWHOHJXYHU QHOHúLSRSRDUHOHVWDWHORUHXURSHQHDOH68$úL&DQDGHL $SHODO0DULL$GXQ UL1D LRQDOHF WUHSDUODPHQWHOHúLSDUODPHQWDULL VWDWHORUHXURSHQH68$úL&DQDGHLSULQFDUHVHFHUHDRSULUHDDPSODV ULLRULF UHL UDFKHWHvQ(XURSDúLWUHFHUHDODGLVWUXJHUHDWXWXURUDUPHORUQXFOHDUH $SHO VHPQDW GH GH URPkQL DGUHVDW VHVLXQLL VSHFLDOH D 218FRQVDFUDWGH]DUP ULL$IRVWDGRSWDWFDGRFXPHQWRILFLDODO218OD LXQLH
GLQWUHVWDWHOHvQFRQIOLFWSHFDOHDWUDWDWLYHORUDQJDMDPHQWXOVWDWHORUPHP EUH 218 GH D UHJOHPHQWD VW ULOH GH vQFRUGDUH úL FRQIOLFW GLIHUHQGHOH H[LVWHQWH SH FDOH SROLWLF GH D VH RE LQH GH OD IRORVLUHD IRU HL úL DPH QLQ ULL FX IRU D GH OD RULFH LQWHUYHQ LH vQ WUHEXULOH LQWHUQH DOH DOWRU VWDWH UHGXFHUHDGHF WUH5RPkQLDFXDDUPDPHQWHORUHIHFWLYHORUúL FKHOWXLHOLORU PLOLWDUH RFWRPEULH VROX LRQDUHD JOREDO D GDWRULHL H[WHUQH úL GREkQ]LORU H[FHVLYH SULQ úWHUJHUHD VDX UHGXFHUHD VXEVWDQ LDO DDFHVWRUD VHSWHPEULH HWF &RQFRPLWHQWUHSUH]HQWDQ LL5RPkQLHLDXIRVWDOHúLvQIUXQWHDXQRU LPSRUWDQWHVWUXFWXULDO218SUHFXP YLFHSUHúHGLQWHDOFHOHLGHD;,9 D VHVLXQL RUGLQDUH D $GXQ ULL *HQHUDOH D 218 VHSWHPEULH SUHúHGLQWH DO VHVLXQLL &RPLVLHL HFRQRPLFH D 218 SHQWUX (XURSD DSULOLH SUHúHGLQWHDO&RPLWHWXOXLSROLWLFVSHFLDO VHSWHPEULH SUHúHGLQWHDOFHOHLGHD;;,,DVHVLXQLD$GXQ ULLJHQHUDOHD218 VHSWHPEULH VHSWHPEULH &RUQHOLX0 QHVFX SUHúHGLQWHDO &RPLWHWXOXLSHQWUXSUREOHPHHFRQRPLFHúLILQDQFLDUHDFHOHLGHD;;,9 DVHVLXQLD$GXQ ULL*HQHUDOHD218 VHSWHPEULH SUHúHGLQWH DOFHOHLGHDDVHVLXQLD&RPLVLHLHFRQRPLFHD218SHQWUX(XURSD DSULOLH HWF ÌQ DFHODúL WLPS VD GHFODQúDW XQ DPSOX SURFHV GH UHFRQFLOLHUH FX VWDWHOHRFFLGHQWDOHLQWHUHVDWHvQDSURGXFHILVXULvQFDGUXO7UDWDWXOXLGHOD 9DUúRYLD úL D VLVWHPXOXL FRPXQLVW FDUH DX RIHULW IDFLOLW L vQ GRPHQLXO HFRQRPLF WHKQRORJLF ILQDQFLDU úL vQ FHO DO LPDJLQLL FKLDU úL SHQWUX FRQGXF WRULLFRPXQLúWLDL ULL ,QWHUHVVDPDQLIHVWDWúLGLQSDUWHD5RPkQLHLHPLVDUXOILLQGPXOW YUHPH,RQ*KHRUJKH0DXUHUFDUHVDvQWkOQLWODPDL OD3DULV
$SHO VROHPQ DGRSWDW GH $GXQDUHD *HQHUDO 218 OD LQL LDWLYD 5RPkQLHL +RW UkUHD3OHQDUHL&&DO3&5/DUHIHUHQGXPXOFRQYRFDWvQDFHVW VHQVODQRLHPEULH vQWUHDJDSRSXOD LHD5RPkQLHLDU VSXQV'$ 3URSXQHUH I FXW GH PLQLVWUXO URPkQ GH )LQDQ H OD VHVLXQHD DQXDO FRPXQ D)0,úL%,5' )RUXPXOPRQGLDODDOHVSHQWUXSULPDGDW XQUHSUH]HQWDQWDOXQHL UL VRFLDOLVWHvQDFHDVW IXQF LH /DUHvQWRDUFHUHDGLQYL]LWDRILFLDO HIHFWXDW vQ$UJHQWLQD
FX 5HQp &RW\ SUHúHGLQWHOH 5HSXEOLFLL )UDQFH]H 3HVWH Fk LYD DQL vQ SUHúHGLQWHOH&KDUOHVGH*DXOOHDRIHULW5RPkQLHLVSULMLQIUDQFH]vQ FD]XO XQXL HYHQWXDO ERLFRW HFRQRPLF GLQ SDUWHD VWDWHORU PHPEUH &$(5(ILFLHQWHDXIRVWúLYL]LWHOHHIHFWXDWHDSRLúLGHPLQLúWULLGH ([WHUQH &RUQHOLX 0 QHVFX OD vQFHSXWXO DQLORU úL ùWHIDQ $QGUHL OD vQFHSXWXODQLORU ÌQ FHHD FH SULYHúWH UHOD LLOH FX 68$ GXS SULPHOH FRQWDFWH URPkQRDPHULFDQHGHVWLQDWHUHJOHPHQW ULLSUREOHPHORUHFRQRPLFRILQDQ FLDUH RGHOHJD LHJXYHUQDPHQWDO URPkQ DWUDWDWOD:DVKLQJWRQvQWUH PDL ± LXQLH SUREOHPH UHIHULWRDUH OD vPEXQ W LUHD UHOD LLORU GLQWUHFHOHGRX VWDWH$SRL,RQ*KHRUJKH0DXUHUDDERUGDWODLXQLH vQ GLVFX LD DYXW FX SUHúHGLQWHOH 68$ /\QGRQ % -RKQVRQ SRVLELOLW LOH GH GH]YROWDUH D UHOD LLORU URPkQRDPHULFDQH úL HYROX LD VLWXD LHL LQWHUQD LRQDOH vQ VSHFLDO D U ]ERLXOXL GLQ 9LHWQDP $ XUPDW VSULMLQXO GLSORPDWLF DPHULFDQ OD VIkUúLWXO OXQLL DXJXVW DFRUGDUHD FODX]HLQD LXQLLFHOHLPDLIDYRUL]DWH úLDOWHFRODERU ULHFRQRPLFH úL GH DOW QDWXU SkQ OD PLMORFXO DQLORU FkQG SROLWLFD LQWHUQ D OXL 1LFRODH &HDXúHVFX QX D PDL IRVW DFFHSWDW GH DXWRULW LOH GH OD :DVKLQJWRQ %HQHILFH DX IRVW SHQWUX LPDJLQHD ULL vQ VWU LQ WDWH úL YL]LWHOH HIHFWXDWH GH 1LFRODH &HDXúHVFX vQ )UDQ D LXQLH 68$ RFWRPEULH GHFHPEULH ± DSULOLH
,RQ *KHRUJKH 0DXUHU SULPXOPLQLVWUX DO JXYHUQXOXL D PDL YL]LWDW $XVWULD QRLHPEULH 'DQHPDUFD DXJXVW *UHFLD DXJXVW±VHSWHPEULH 2ODQGD LXOLH 9DWLFDQXO LDQXDULH DIRVWSULPLWGHSDSD3DXODO9,, )LQODQGD PDUWLH±DSULOLH 6XHGLD ±DSULOLH %HOJLD ±QRLHPEULH 0DUHD%ULWDQLH QRLHPEULH D IRVW SULPLW GH UHJLQD (OLVDEHWD D ,,D úL D DYXW FRQYRUELULFXSULPXOPLQLVWUX+DUROG:LOVRQ 5)* LXQLH HWF ÌQWLPSXOYL]LWHLOXL,RQ*KHRUJKH0DXUHUvQ)UDQ D ÌQSHULRDGDRFWRPEULH±QRLHPEULH $GLVFXWDWFXSUHúHGLQWHOH*HRUJHV3RPSLGRXSUREOHPHSULYLQGFRR SHUDUHDHFRQRPLF úLO UJLUHDVFKLPEXULORUvQGRPHQLLOHFRPHUFLDOúWLLQ LILFúL WHKQLF 6DX UHDOL]DW PDL PXOWH vQ HOHJHUL FX ILUPH DPHULFDQH SULYLQG FRRSHUDUHDFXILUPHGLQ5RPkQLDLQFOXVLYGHFRRSHUDUHvQSURGXF LHvQFDGUXO XQRUVRFLHW LPL[WHURPkQRDPHULFDQH
5HJDWXO8QLWDO0DULL%ULWDQLLúL,UODQGHLGH1RUG LXQLH 6SDQLD PDL )UDQ D LXOLH 6XHGLD QRLHPEULH 'DQHPDUFD QRLHPEULH 1RUYHJLD QRLHPEULH $XVWULD LXQLH &DQDGD DSULOLH ODFDUHVHDGDXJ YL]LWHOHHIHFWXDWHvQQXPHURDVHVWDWHGLQ$IULFD$PH ULFDGHVXG$VLDHWF 3H OkQJ SUREOHPH GH SROLWLF H[WHUQ GHOHJD LLOH JXYHUQDPHQWDOH URPkQH DX PDL GLVFXWDW FX DXWRULW LOH GLQ VWDWHOH RFFLGHQWDOH SRVLELOLW L GHFRRSHUDUHHFRQRPLF úLFXOWXUDO GLQDFHVWSXQFWGHYHGHUHvQDQLL vQUHJLVWUkQGXVHRvQYLRUDUHDVFKLPEXULORUFXOWXUDOHFX2FFLGHQWXO ILOPH H[SR]L LLF U LSLHVHGHWHDWUX]LDUHWXULúWLHWF $VWIHODIRVWSRVLELO GHVFKLGHUHD %LEOLRWHFLL DPHULFDQH OD %XFXUHúWL LDQXDULH D &HQWUXOXL LWDORURPkQ GH VWXGLL LVWRULFH GH OD 0LODQR LXOLH D %LEOLRWHFLLURPkQH LDQXDULH HWF&XWRDWHDFHVWHDFRODERUDUHDFX VWDWHOH GLQ 2FFLGHQW vQ GRPHQLXO FXOWXULL úL úWLLQ HL D IRVW VXE QLYHOXO PLQLPDOSRVLELOLW LORUúLFHULQ HORUHSRFLLLVWRULFH ,PSRUWDQWH DX IRVW úL YL]LWHOH HIHFWXDWH vQ 5RPkQLD GH vQDOWH SHUVRQDOLW LVWDWDOHSROLWLFHúLFXOWXUDOHHXURSHQHúLPRQGLDOHSUHFXP 8¶7KDQ VHFUHWDUXO JHQHUDO DO 218 PDL %UXQR .UHLVN\ PLQLVWUXO GH ([WHUQH DO $XVWULHL LXQLH :LOO\ %UDQGW YLFHFDQFHODUXO5)*úLPLQLVWUXIHGHUDODO$IDFHULORU([WHUQH DXJXVW ,QGLUD*DQGKLSULPXOPLQLVWUXDO,QGLHL RFWRPEULH &KDUOHV GH *DXOOH PDL SULPD YL]LW D XQXL úHI GH VWDW IUDQFH] 5LFKDUG1L[RQ DXJXVW SULPXOSUHúHGLQWHDPHULFDQ
&XDFHOSULOHM1LFRODH&HDXúHVFXúL(OHQD&HDXúHVFXDXIRVWSULPL L GHUHJLQD(OLVDEHWDD,,DúLGHGXFHOHGH(GLQEXUJKÌQXUPDFRQYRUELULORUFX SULPXOPLQLVWUX -DPHV &DOODJKDQ D IRVW VHPQDW XQ 0HPRUDQGXP SULYLQG FRRSHUDUHD vQ LQGXVWULD DHURQDXWLF úL FRRSHUDUHD WHKQRORJLF vQ GRPHQLXO H[SORDW ULLúLH[SORU ULLPDULWLPHGHSHWUROúLJD]H $XIRVWvQFKHLDWHDFRUGXULGHFRODERUDUHFXOWXUDO úLúWLLQ LILF ÌQ DXJXVW DXWRULW LOH URPkQH DX GHFLV vQFHWDUHD EUXLHULL HPLVLXQLORU vQ OLPED URPkQ DOH SRVWXULORU GH UDGLR RFFLGHQWDOH ÌQ DQLL EUXLHUHDDIRVWUHOXDW vQV FXúLPDLPXOW LQWHQVLWDWH 6DX GLVFXWDW SUREOHPH SULYLQG FRRSHUDUHD HFRQRPLF WHKQLF úL úWLLQ LILF úLVDGHFLVvQILLQ DUHDGHELEOLRWHFLOD3DULVúL%XFXUHúWLSUHFXPúL FHQWUHGHGRFXPHQWDUHúWLLQ LILF
FDUH YL]LWHD] 5RPkQLDúL SULPD DU VRFLDOLVW DVWURQDX LL DPHULFDQL &KDUOHV &RQUDG 5LFKDUG *RUGRQ úL $ODQ %HDQ PHPEULL DL HFKLSDMXOXL QDYHL VSD LDOH Ä$SROOR´ IHEUXDULH PDUWLH *XVWDY +HLQHPDQQSUHúHGLQWHOH5)* PDL +HQU\$.LVVLQJHU VHFUHWDU GH VWDW DPHULFDQ QRLHPEULH -DFTXHV &KLUDF SULP PLQLVWUX DO )UDQ HL LXOLH *HUDOG 5 )RUG SUHúHGLQWHOH 68$ DXJXVW 0DUJDUHW 7KDWFKHU OLGHUXO 3DUWLGXOXL &RQVHUYDWRUGLQ0DUHD%ULWDQLH DXJXVWVHSWHPEULH +HOPXW .RKO SUHúHGLQWHOH 8QLXQLL &UHúWLQ'HPRFUDWH GLQ 5)* LXQLH GU 5XGROI .LUNKVFKOlJHU SUHúHGLQWHOH IHGHUDO DO $XVWULHL QRLHPEULH 9DOpU\ *LVFDUG G¶(VWDLQJ SUHúHGLQWHOH 5HSXEOLFLL )UDQFH]H PDUWLH .XUW :DOGKHLP VHFUHWDUXO JHQHUDO DO 218 LXOLH SULQ XO PRúWHQLWRU DO -DSRQLHL $NLKLWR úL SULQ HVD0LFKLNRvQFDOLWDWHGHUHSUH]HQWDQWDOvPS UDWXOXL+LURKLWR RFWRPEULH )UDQoRLV 0LWWHUDQG SUHúHGLQWHOH 3DUWLGXOXL 6RFLDOLVW )UDQFH] QRLHPEULH $OH[DQGHU +DLJ VHFUHWDUXO GH VWDW DO 68$ IHEUXDULH 5LFKDUG1L[RQIRVWSUHúHGLQWHDO68$ LXQLH -DYLHU3pUH]GH&XpOODUVHFUHWDUXOJHQHUDODO218 LXOLH *HRUJH %XVK YLFHSUHúHGLQWH DO 68$ VHSWHPEULH 3LHUUH(OOLRWW7UXGHDXSULPXOPLQLVWUXDO&DQDGHL IHEUXDULH -XDQ&DUORV,UHJHOH6SDQLHLúLUHJLQD6RILD PDL *HRUJH6KXOW]VHFUHWDUGHVWDWDO68$ GHFHPEULH HWF $FHVWRUDOLVDXDG XJDWDO LúHILGHVWDWúLGLSORPD LGLQ]HFLGHVWDWH GH SH WRDWH FRQWLQHQWHOH 3H P VXU FH GXULWDWHD UHJLPXOXL VRFLDOLVWFRPXQLVWWRWDOLWDUVHDFFHQWXDYL]LWHOHHIHFWXDWHGHSHUVRQDOLW LOH PDUFDQWH DOH OXPLL vQ 5RPkQLD VDX U ULW DUD GHYHQLQG L]RODW vQ SODQ LQWHUQD LRQDOODVIkUúLWXODQLORU /D VFXUW WLPS GXS FH D IRVW SULPLW vQ 218 5RPkQLD D IRVW LQFOXV úLvQQXPHURDVHVWUXFWXULLQWHUQD LRQDOHvQWUHDFHVWHDVLWXkQGXVH
6DVXEOLQLDWQHFHVLWDWHDVWDELOLULLXQRUUHOD LLvQWUHVWDWHDYkQGODED] SULQFLSLLOHLQGHSHQGHQ HLúLVXYHUDQLW LLQD LRQDOHHOLPLQDUHDSROLWLFLLGHGLFWDW úLDPHVWHFvQWUHEXULOHLQWHUQHDOHDOWRUDLQVWDXUDUHDXQHLHJDOLW LGHSOLQHvQWUH QD LXQL &RQFRPLWHQW VD GHFLV vQILLQ DUHD D FkWH XQHL ELEOLRWHFL DPHULFDQH OD %XFXUHúWLUHVSHFWLYURPkQHOD:DVKLQJWRQ 6DXVHPQDWSURWRFRDOHSULYLQGFRRSHUDUHDvQGRPHQLLOHWHKQLFLLDXGLR YL]XDOH DHURQDXWLFLL HOHFWURQLFLL úL LQIRUPDWLFLL LQGXVWULHL GH DXWRYHKLFXOH úL HFRQRPLF
2UJDQL]D LD 1D LXQLORU 8QLWH SHQWUX (GXFD LH ùWLLQ úL &XOWXU ± 81(6&2 LXOLH &RQVLOLXO*XYHUQDWRULORU$JHQ LHL,QWHUQD LRQDOH SHQWUX(QHUJLHDWRPLF RFWRPEULH &RQVLOLXOGHDGPLQLVWUD LHDO 2UJDQL]D LHL ,QWHUQD LRQDOH D 0XQFLL LXQLH &RQVLOLXO GH 6HFXULWDWH SHQWUXXQDQFDPHPEUXQHSHUPDQHQWvQ &RPLWHWXO FHORU VWDWH SHQWUX GH]DUPDUH RUJDQLVP GH QHJRFLHUL )$2 ± RUJDQL]D LH D 218 SHQWUX $OLPHQWD LH úL $JULFXOWXU QRLHPEULH &RPLVLDVSHFLDO 218GHHODERUDUHDSULQFLSLLORUGH GUHSWLQWHUQD LRQDOUHIHULWRDUHODUHOD LLOHSULHWHQHúWLúLGHFRRSHUDUHvQWUH VWDWH IHEUXDULH 2UJDQL]D LD,QWHUJXYHUQDPHQWDO SHQWUX1DYLJD LH 0DULWLP PDUWLH 2UJDQL]D LD $YLD LHL &LYLOH ,QWHUQD LRQDOH DSULOLH 2UJDQL]D LD 1D LXQLORU 8QLWH SHQWUX 'H]YROWDUH ,QGXVWULDO ±218', LDQXDULH $OLDQ D,QWHUQD LRQDO GH7XULVP $FRUGXO*HQHUDOSHQWUX7DULIHúL&RPHU ±*$77 QRLHPEULH Ä*UXSXOFHORU´ LDQXDULH &RQVLOLXOXL(FRQRPLFúL6RFLDO DO 218 ± (&262& RFWRPEULH &RPLVLD 218 SHQWUX DúH] ULXPDQHSHSHULRDGD QRLHPEULH HWF &RQFRPLWHQW FDSLWDOD 5RPkQLHL D GHYHQL ORFXO GH GHVI úXUDUH D QXPHURDVHPDQLIHVW ULúWLLQ LILFHLQWHUQD LRQDOHODFDUHDXSDUWLFLSDWVXWH GH VDYDQ L úL RDPHQL GH úWLLQ VWU LQL úL URPkQL OD XQHOH FKLDU SHVWH DO ;9,OHD &RQJUHV LQWHUQD LRQDO GH )L]LF Ä$PSHUH´ VHSWHPEULH DO OHD &RQJUHV LQWHUQD LRQDO GH FKLPLH LQGXVWULDO VHSWHPEULH DO ,9OHD &RQJUHV LQWHUQD LRQDO GH ORJLF PHWRGRORJLH úL ILOR]RILH D úWLLQ HL DXJXVW ± VHSWHPEULH DO ;,9OHD &RQJUHV LQWHUQD LRQDO GH VWXGLL EL]DQWLQH OD %XFXUHúWL 6H GHVFKLGHH[SR]L LD&XOWXUDEL]DQWLQ vQ5RPkQLD VHSWHPEULH D ,,,D &RQIHULQ PRQGLDO GH FHUFHWDUH D YLLWRUXOXL VHSWHPEULH &RQJUHVXO )HGHUD LHL ,QWHUQD LRQDOH GH 0DUNHWLQJ LXQLH &RQIHULQ DPRQGLDO DSRSXOD LHLVXEHJLGD218 DXJXVW
$OHDV ODGHFHPEULH $FWLYLWDWHDDvQFHSXWODPDUWLH GDUDW U J QDWH[WUHPGHPXOW ÌQILLQ DW OD/RQGUDODPDUWLH 2UJDQL]D LH LQWHUJXYHUQDPHQWDO FUHDW OD &KLFDJR OD GHFHPEULH DvQFHSXWV IXQF LRQH]HODDSULOLH
FXSDUWLFLSDUHDVHFUHWDUXOXLJHQHUDO218.XUW:DOGKHLP DO ,,,OHD&RQJUHVLQWHUQD LRQDOGHVWXGLLVXGHVWHXURSHQH VHSWHPEULH D;;,&RQIHULQ HXURSHDQ DFRPLWHWHORUQD LRQDOHDOH)RQGXOXL 1D LXQLORU 8QLWH SHQWUX &RSLL81,&() LXQLH DO ,,,OHD &RQJUHV LQWHUQD LRQDO GH FLEHUQHWLF úL VLVWHPH DXJXVW DO ,9OHD FRQJUHV LQWHUQD LRQDO GH KLVWRFKLPLH úL FLWRFKLPLH DXJXVW VHSWHPEULH DO,,OHDFRQJUHVODWLQGHUHXPDWRORJLH VHSWHP EULH DO 9,,, &RQJUHV PRQGLDO SHQWUX SUHYHQLUHD DFFLGHQWHORU GH PXQF úLDEROLORUSURIHVLRQDOH PDL &RQIHULQ DLQWHUQD LR QDO GHVSHFWURVFRSLH0RVVEDXHU VHSWHPEULH DO9,,,OHD&RQ JUHVHXURSHDQGHJHURQWRORJLHFOLQLF VHSWHPEULH D;;,,D &RQIHULQ LQWHUQD LRQDO D FUXFLL URúLL VHSWHPEULH UHXQLXQHD PLQLVWHULDO D Ä*UXSXOXL FHORU ´ FRQVDFUDW SUHJ WLULL &RQIHULQ HL218SHQWUXúWLLQ úLWHKQRORJLHvQSUREOHPHOHGH]YROW ULL DXJXVW DO ;OHD &RQJUHV PRQGLDO DO SHWUROXOXL VHSWHPEULH DO OHDFRQJUHVLQWHUQD LRQDOGHEURQKRSQHXPRORJLH LXQLH IHVWLYDOXOLQWHUQD LRQDOÄ&RSLLLOXPLLGRUHVFSDFHD´ LXOLH DO;9OHDFRQJUHVLQWHUQD LRQDOGHúWLLQ HLVWRULFH DXJXVW DO ;9,OHD &RQJUHV LQWHUQD LRQDO GH LVWRULH D úWLLQ HL DXJXVW VHSWHPEULH UHXQLXQHD LQWHUQD LRQDO D ]LDULúWLORU SHQWUX GH]DUPDUHVHFXULWDWHúLSDFH IHEUXDULH FRQIHULQ DLQWHUQD LRQDO 0DJQHWLVPXO S PkQWXULORU UDUH úL DO DFWLQLGHORU VHSWHPEULH UHXQLXQHD JUXSXOXL FHORU SULYLQG FRRSHUDUHD HFRQRPLF vQ GRPHQLXO DOLPHQWD LHL úL DJULFXOWXULL PDUWLH FRQIHULQ D LQWHUQD LRQDO GH LVWRULH PLOLWDU RUJDQL]DW GH &RPLVLD 5RPkQ GH ,VWRULH0LOLWDU vQFRODERUDUHFX&ROHJLXO%URXNOLQGLQ1HZ
$X SDUWLFLSDW FLUFD GH GHOHJD L GLQ GH UL úL SHVWH LQVWLWX LLVSHFLDOL]DWHRUJDQL]D LLJXYHUQDPHQWDOHúLQHJXYHUQDPHQWDOH
PRQGLDOH vQ VSHFLDO GXS YHQLUHD OD SXWHUH vQ 8566 D OXL 06*RUEDFLRY FDUH D SURPRYDW SROLWLFD GH JODVQRVW WUDQVSDUHQ úL SHUHVWURLND UHFRQVWUXF LH SURPL kQG OXL *HRUJH %XVK SUHúHGLQWHOH 68$F QXYDLQWHUYHQLPLOLWDUvQVLWXD LDvQFDUHvQ ULOHVRFLDOLVWHVH YRU SURGXFH WUDQVIRUP UL VRFLDOH úL HFRQRPLFH 1LFRODH &HDXúHVFX D DGRSWDWRSROLWLF REWX] UHQXQ kQG ODÄFODX]DQD LXQLLFHOHLPDL IDYRUL]DWH´úLSXQkQG5RPkQLDvQWURVLWXD LHGHL]RODUHLQWHUQD LRQDO GLQ FHvQFHPDLDFFHQWXDW GLQFDUH DUDDLHúLWDELDvQXUPD5HYROX LHLGLQ GHFHPEULH
9,,520Æ1,$Ì1&217(;78/,17(51$ ,21$/ 32675(92/8 ,21$5
'XS UHYROX LD GLQ GHFHPEULH úL GL]ROYDUHD RILFLDO D VWUXFWXULORU PLOLWDUH úL SROLWLFH D 7UDWDWXOXL GH OD 9DUúRYLD 5RPkQLD úLD DVXPDW YDORULOH GHPRFUDWLFH RFFLGHQWDOH úL VD UDFRUGDW UDSLG OD DPSOXO SURFHV GH PRGHUQL]DUH vQWUHUXSW vQ PRG EUXWDO GH F WUH VRYLHWLFL OD VIkUúLWXO FHOXL GHDO GRLOHD U ]ERL PRQGLDO SULQFLSDOHOH RELHFWLYH DOH SROLWLFLL H[WHUQH URPkQHúWL GLQ DFHDVW SHULRDG ILLQG DGHUDUHDOD1$72úL8QLXQHD(XURSHDQ $GHUDUHDOD1$72 $GHUDUHD OD VWUXFWXULOH GH VHFXULWDWH HXURSHQH úL HXURDWODQWLFH VD EXFXUDWGHFRQVHQVXOWXWXURUIRU HORUSROLWLFHúLGHVSULMLQXOODUJDORSLQLHL SXEOLFH FRQVWLWXLQG R SUHRFXSDUH SULRULWDU D WXWXURU LQVWLWX LLORU VWDWXOXL 8Q PRPHQW LPSRUWDQW DO DFHVWXL SURFHV OD UHSUH]HQWDW DGHUDUHD OD 3DUWHQHULDWXOSHQWUX3DFH LDQXDULH úLODWRDWHLQL LDWLYHOHODQVDWHvQ FDGUXODFHVWXLDIDSWFDUHDI FXWFD5RPkQLDV DF LRQH]HFDXQPHPEUXGH IDFWR DO $OLDQ HL QRUGDWODQWLFH $FHVW IDSW D LPSXV GH OD vQFHSXW DQJDMDPHQWH SULYLQG UHIRUPD RUJDQLVPXOXL PLOLWDU SHQWUX WUDQVIRUPDUHD DFHVWXLD vQ FRQFRUGDQ FX VWDQGDUGHOH 1$72 úL LQVWUXLUHD VSHFLILF D IRU HORUGHVWLQDWHPLVLXQLORUPXOWLQD LRQDOHGHPHQ LQHUHDS FLL (OHPHQWXO PDMRU SH ED]D F UXLD DX IRVW LGHQWLILFDWH SUHJ WLWH úL HYDOXDWH IRU HOH PLMORDFHOH úL IDFLOLW LOH SXVH OD GLVSR]L LH SHQWUX SDUWLFLSDUHDODPLVLXQLDO WXULGH1$72DIRVW3URFHVXOGH3ODQLILFDUH úL $QDOL] 3$53 LQL LDW vQ GHFHPEULH FDUH VD GHVI úXUDW SH FLFOXUL GH OXFUX XUP ULQG DWLQJHUHD XQRU RELHFWLYH GH LQWHURSHUDELOLWDWH
5RPkQLD1$72 3DUWHQHULDW úL FRRSHUDUH (GLWXUD 0LOLWDU %XFXUHúWL
SULQVFKLPEGHLQIRUPD LLvQWUHSDUWHQHULúLDOLD LSULQFRQVXOWDQ DRIHULW GHVSHFLDOLúWL1$72 ÌQSHULRDGDRFWRPEULH ±VHSWHPEULH5RPkQLDDSDUFXUV FLQFLFLFOXULDOH3ODQXOXLGH$F LXQHSHQWUX$GHUDUH 0HPEHUVKLS$FWLRQ 3ODQ±0$3 DGRSWDWOD6XPPLWXO1$72GHOD:DVKLQJWRQGLQDQXO SHQWUX ULOHU PDVHvQFXUVDSHQWUXDGHUDUHPHQLWV VSULMLQHVWDWHOH FDQGLGDWH vQ SURFHVXO GH SUHJ WLUH SHQWUX LQWHJUDUHD vQ $OLDQ V UHDOL]H]H VWUXFWXUL D IRU HL UHGXVH QXPHULF IOH[LELO LQWHURSHUDELO úL FRPSDWLELO FXIRU HOHúLVWUXFWXULOH1$72GRYHGLQGF SRWFRQWULEXL DFWLYODUHDOL]DUHDRELHFWLYHORU$OLDQ HL 'XS GHFL]LD LVWRULF GH OD 3UDJD QRLHPEULH FkQG úHILL GH VWDWH úL GH JXYHUQH GLQ VWDWHOH PHPEUH 1$72 DX LQYLWDW 5RPkQLDV vQFHDS QHJRFLHULOHGHDGHUDUHOD$OLDQ DUDDGHYHQLWOD PDUWLH vPSUHXQ FX DOWH VWDWH FDQGLGDWH %XOJDULD (VWRQLD /HWRQLD 6ORYDFLD úL 6ORYHQLD PHPEUH FX GUHSWXUL GHSOLQH DOH $OLDQ HL 1RUG$WODQWLFH /DVFXUWWLPSODDSULOLHODVHGLXO1$72GLQ%UX[HOOHVD DYXW ORF FHUHPRQLDOXO GH DUERUDUH D GUDSHOHORU QD LRQDOH DOH FHORU úDSWH VWDWH QRL PHPEUH DOH $OLDQ HL QRUGDWODQWLFH &RQFRPLWHQW OD %XFXUHúWLvQID D3DODWXOXL3DUODPHQWXOXLDYHDORFFHUHPRQLDGHvQ O DUHD GUDSHOXOXL1$72
0$3DRIHULW ULORUFDQGLGDWHROLVW GHGRPHQLLGHDF LXQHSHED]D F UHLD ILHFDUH VWDW FDQGLGDW úLD HODERUDW SURSULXO 3ODQ QD LRQDO GH SUHJ WLUH 31$ FXSULQ]kQG DFHOH RELHFWLYH SH FDUH OHD FRQVLGHUDW QHFHVDUH úL UHDOL]DELOH &X DFHO SULOHM SUHúHGLQWHOH *HRUJH %XVK D GHFODUDW Ä$OLDQ D 1$72YDDUERUDGHD]LvQDLQWHúDSWHVWHDJXULQRLúLVHYDvQWLQGHGHOD*ROIXO %LVFDLDSkQ OD0DUHD1HDJU (XURSDFDUHDIRVWRGDW VXUV DXQRUFRQIOLFWH JOREDOHHVWHDFXPRVXUV GHSDFHúLGHOLEHUWDWH´ /D VFXUW WLPS vQ FDGUXO UHXQLXQLL VSHFLDOH D PLQLúWULORU $IDFHULORU ([WHUQH DL VWDWHORU PHPEUH DOH $OLDQ HL -DDS GH +RRS 6FKHIIHU VHFUHWDUXO JHQHUDODO1$72DDILUPDW Ä'HDFXPvQDLQWHGHDOLD LYRUILUHXQL LvQ DQJDMDPHQWXOGHDVHDS UDXQLLSHDO LL$FHVWDHVWHFHOPDLSXWHUQLFFHOPDL VROHPQDQJDMDPHQWSHFDUHvOSRWOXDQD LXQLOH´ &X DFHO SULOHM SUHúHGLQWHOH ,RQ ,OLHVFX D DILUPDW Ä3ULQ QRXO QRVWUX VWDWXWGH DU PHPEU 1$72DYHPQXGRDUJDUDQ LLGHVHFXULWDWHGDUúL REOLJD LD GH D DS UD DFHVWH YDORUL úL GH D IL VROLGDUL FX FHLODO L PHPEUL DL 2UJDQL]D LHL7UHEXLHV ILPSUHJ WL LV IDFHPID FHULQ HORU$OLDQ HLV QH DVXP PFXGHPQLWDWHúLGHWHUPLQDUHREOLJD LLOHFDUHQHUHYLQ´
&RQFRPLWHQW 5RPkQLD D SDUWLFLSDW úL SDUWLFLS OD RSHUD LXQL úL PLVLXQL PXOWLQD LRQDOH GH PHQ LQHUH D S FLL DVLVWHQ XPDQLWDU VDX GH REVHUYDUH úL YHULILFDUH OD LQL LDWLYH UHJLRQDOH GH VHFXULWDWH SUHFXP úL OD HIRUWXULOH FRPXQLW LL LQWHUQD LRQDOH GH FRPEDWHUH D QRLORU ULVFXUL vQ SULQFLSDO OD OXSWD vPSRWULYD WHURULVPXOXL ÌQ DFHODúL WLPS IRU HOH DUPDWH URPkQH SDUWLFLS OD PLVLXQL PXOWLQD LRQDOH VXE HJLGD 218 26&( 8(úL1$72vQFRDOL LLPXOWLQD LRQDOHvQWHDWUHOHGHRSHUD LLGLQ,UDN $IJDQLVWDQ %RVQLD+HU HJRYLQD .RVRYR úL vQ *HRUJLD 5HSXEOLFD 'HPRFUDW &RQJR(WLRSLDúL(ULWUHHD&RDVWDGH)LOGHú/LEHULD6XGDQ 1HSDOHWF $GHUDUHDOD8QLXQHD(XURSHDQ $F LXQLOH GHVI úXUDWH vQ YHGHUHD DGHU ULL OD 1$72 VDX GHVI úXUDW FRQFRPLWHQW FX FHOH SHQWUX DGHUDUHD OD 8QLXQHD (XURSHDQ IRVW &RPXQLWDWHD (XURSHDQ SkQ vQ &D SDúL SUHPHUJ WRUL DL SURFHVXOXL VDX VLWXDW H[SULPDUHD GRULQ HL LDQXDULH &RQVLOLXOXL )URQWXOXL 6DOY ULL 1D LRQDOH GH D VWDELOL FRQWDFWH FX &RPXQLWDWHD (XURSHDQ úLFHDDJXYHUQXOXLURPkQ PDUWLH FD5RPkQLDV ILHSULPLW vQ&RQVLOLXO(XURSHL(YHQLPHQWHOHSROLWLFHLQWHUQHvQVSHFLDO PLQHULDGHOH GLQ úL GLQ SHULRDGD XUP WRDUH DX GHWHUPLQDW &RPXQLWDWHD(XURSHDQ V úLUHWUDJ WHPSRUDUVSULMLQXOSHQWUX5RPkQLD /D VFXUW WLPS DSULOLH 'HSDUWDPHQWXO GH 6WDW DO 68$ úLD H[SULPDWúLHOvQJULMRUDUHDSHQWUXPRGXOvQFDUHVHGHVI úXUDSURFHVXOGH GHPRFUDWL]DUHvQ5RPkQLDvQWLPSFH&RPLVLD(XURSHDQ DDQXQ DWOD VHSWHPEULH vQ WLPSXO XQHLD GLQWUH PLQHULDGH DPkQDUHD QHJRFL HULORUFX5RPkQLDSHQWUXvQFKHLHUHD$FRUGXOXLGHDVRFLHUH &X WRDWH DFHVWHD DX XUPDW PDL PXOWH UXQGH GH QHJRFLHUL vQ PDL PXOWHGRPHQLL ODIHEUXDULH ILLQGVHPQDW$FRUGXOGHDVRFLHUHD 5RPkQLHL OD &RPXQLWDWHD (XURSHDQ FHUHUHD RILFLDO GH DGHUDUH ILLQG vQDLQWDW GH UHSUH]HQWDQ LL 5RPkQLHL OD LXQLH vPSUHXQ FX 6WUDWHJLD QD LRQDO GH SUHJ WLUH D DGHU ULL 5RPkQLHL OD 8QLXQHD
/D PDUWLH D IRVW WULPLV SULPXO DPEDVDGRU URPkQ SH OkQJ &RPXQLWDWHD(XURSHDQ
(XURSHDQ $SRL GXS DOWH UXQGH GH QHJRFLHUL vQ FXUVXO F URUD VDX I FXWQXPHURDVHUHFRPDQG UL&RQVLOLXO(XURSHDQDDFRUGDW5RPkQLHLvQ GHFHPEULH VWDWXWXOGHFDQGLGDWODDGHUDUHúLDODQVDWvQGHFHPEULH LQYLWD LDGHDvQFHSHQHJRFLHULOHGHDGHUDUHÌQPRGRILFLDOSURFHVXO GH QHJRFLHUH D DGHU ULL D IRVW ODQVDW OD IHEUXDULH FX SULOHMXO &RQIHULQ HL ,QWHUJXYHUQDPHQWDOH 5RPkQLD8QLXQHD (XURSHDQ úL D IRVW ILQDOL]DW OD DSULOLH FkQG D IRVW VHPQDW 7UDWDWXO GH DGHUDUH ,QWHJUDUHD FX GUHSWXUL GHSOLQH VD SURGXV OD LDQXDULH SHQWUX 5RPkQLDvQFHSkQGRQRX SDJLQ GHLVWRULH
'HFODUD LH SROLWLF VHPQDW OD 6QDJRY OD LXQLH GH F WUH OLGHULLSDUWLGHORUSDUODPHQWDUHSUHúHGLQ LLFHORUGRX &DPHUHDOHSDUODPHQWXOXL SULPXOPLQLVWUXSUHúHGLQWHOH5RPkQLHLúLSUHúHGLQWHOH&RPLVLHLGHHODERUDUHD VWUDWHJLHL &X DFHO SULOHM SUHúHGLQWHOH 7UDLDQ % VHVFX D SUHFL]DW Ä3HQWUX QRL FDOLWDWHD GH PHPEUX DO 8QLXQLL (XURSHQH YD UHSUH]HQWD vQGHSOLQLUHD XQXL YLV YHFKLGHRMXP WDWHGHVHFROGHDGHS úLWRDWHEDULHUHOHúLGHDGHYHQLSDUWHD FRPXQLW LLHXURSHQHGHYDORULSURVSHULWDWHúLVHFXULWDWH´
9,,,&$5$&7(5,67,&,$/(9,( ,,32/,7,&( )RUPHGHJXYHUQ PkQW([HUFLWDUHDSXWHULORUvQVWDW 5HJLPXULúLSDUWLGHSROLWLFHGHPRFUDWLFH ÌQ SULPD MXP WDWH D VHFROXOXL DFWLYLWDWHD JXYHUQDPHQWDO D LQVWLWX LLORUVWDWXOXLúLDSDUWLGHORUSROLWLFHVDGHVI úXUDWvQFRQIRUPLWDWH FXSUHYHGHULOH&RQVWLWX LHLGLQ HODERUDW GXS PRGHOEHOJLDQ ±XQD GLQFHOHPDLDYDQVDWHGLQ(XURSDDFHORUDQL±FDUHDFRQVDFUDWRILFLDOúL QXPHOH ULL±5RPkQLD0RGLILFDW vQLXOLH DFHDVWDDIRVWvQORFXLW OD PDUWLH FX DOWD FDUH SUHOXD vQ PDUH SDUWH SULQFLSLLOH úL FKLDU WH[WXO FHOHL YHFKL úL FRQVILQ HD QRXO FDGUX SROLWLFRVWDWDO DO 5RPkQLHL ÌQWUHJLWHSUHFXPúLQRLOHGUHSWXULúLOLEHUW LFHW HQHúWLGHFDUHEHQHILFLD SRSRUXOURPkQ ÌQ DFHVW FRQWH[W FRQIRUP SULQFLSLXOXL VHSDU ULL SXWHULORU vQ VWDW VWDWXDWSULQOHJHDIXQGDPHQWDO D ULLSXWHUHDOHJLVODWLY DIRVWH[HUFLWDW GHUHJHúLGH3DUODPHQWXOWLPDLQVWLWX LHUHSUH]HQWkQGQD LXQHD/HJLOH± LQL LDWH GH &DPHUD 'HSXWD LORU 6HQDW VDX GH 5HJH ± HUDX GLVFXWDWH úL YRWDWH vQ 5HSUH]HQWDQ D 1D LRQDO VDQF LRQDWH GH PRQDUK úL SXEOLFDWH DSRLvQÄ0RQLWRUXO2ILFLDO´VXEVHPQ WXUDVXYHUDQXOXLúLDXQXLDGLQWUH PLQLúWULDFHVWDGHYHQLQGUHVSRQVDELOID GHFRQ LQXWXODFWXOXLUHVSHFWLY 3XWHUHD H[HFXWLY D IRVW H[HUFLWDW GH F WUH JXYHUQ vQ QXPHOH UHJHOXL FDUHQXPHDSHSULPXOPLQLVWUXDFHVWDDOF WXLQGOLVWDPLQLúWULORUSHFDUHR vQDLQWD VXYHUDQXOXL FDUH R VDQF LRQD SULQ GHFUHW vQ YLUWXWHD IDSWXOXL F PRQDUKXO HUD ÄFDSXO SXWHULL DUPDWH´ úL F PLOLWDULL QX I FHDX SROLWLF PLQLVWUXO $S U ULL 1D LRQDOH5 ]ERL HUD SURSXV GH F WUH UHJH 3XWHUHD MXGHF WRUHDVF HUDH[HFXWDW SULQRUJDQHVSHFLILFH±FXU LúLWULEXQDOH± KRW UkULOHúLVHQWLQ HOHSURQXQ kQGXVHvQYLUWXWHDOHJLORUúLH[HFXWkQGXVH vQQXPHOHUHJHOXL'LQDFHVWSXQFWGHYHGHUHVHSRDWHDSUHFLDF 5RPkQLD VDVLWXDWSkQ vQ SULQWUHFHOHPDLDYDQVDWHVWDWHHXURSHQHGLQSXQFW GHYHGHUHFRQVWLWX LRQDO
3H ODUJ ,RDQ 6FXUWX *KHRUJKH %X]DWX ,VWRULD 5RPkQLHL vQ VHFROXO ;;%XFXUHúWL SS
ÌQSHULRDGDPRQDUKLHLFRQVWLWX LRQDOHUHJLLDXEHQHILFLDWGHDWULEX LL LPSRUWDQWHSHFDUHOHDXIRORVLWGLQSOLQvQVSHFLDO&DURO,FDUHVD GRYHGLW D IL DXWRULWDU úL ULJXURV vQ vQGHSOLQLUHD DWULEX LLORU UHJDOH +RW UkUHD VD GH D UHVSHFWD OHJLOH ULL FD úL GHVHOH PDQLIHVWD LL DQWLPRQDUKLFH ODX I FXW V UHQXQ H OD WHQWD LD GH D VSRULL UROXO SXWHULL H[HFXWLYHUHJDOHvQGHWULPHQWXOFHLOHJLVODWLYHVHPQkQGvQWRWGHDXQDOHJLOH FHLDXIRVWvQDLQWDWHVSUHDSUREDUHúLVLWXkQGXVHGHFHOHPDLPXOWHRUL SHSR]L LDGHÄDUELWUX´vQWUHSDUWLGHGHúLPXOW YUHPHDSUHIHUDWGLQSXQFW GH YHGHUH SROLWLF SH FRQVHUYDWRUL &RQFRPLWHQW D vQ HOHV QHFHVLWDWHD GH]YROW ULL úL PRGHUQL] ULL VRFLHW LL URPkQHúWL DFFHSWkQG UHIRUPH úL LPSOLFkQGXVHFXUHDOLVPvQGLULMDUHDSROLWLFLLH[WHUQHURPkQHúWLÌQ vQPRPHQWXOGHFODQú ULLSULPXOXLU ]ERLPRQGLDOQXDUHXúLWV úLLPSXQ SXQFWXOGHYHGHUHvQFHHDFHSULYHúWHDQJDMDUHD5RPkQLHLvQFRQIODJUD LH DO WXULGH3XWHULOH&HQWUDOHVSHUkQGvQVDWLVIDFHUHDGH]LGHUDWXOXLQD LRQDO FXVSULMLQXODFHVWRUD'RYHGLQGXVHDILXQUHJHFRQVWLWX LRQDODDFFHSWDW vQ SRILGD YRLQ HL VDOH GHFL]LD &RQVLOLXOXL GH &RURDQ GLQ LXOLH DXJXVW SULYLQGDGRSWDUHDQHXWUDOLW LL 9LD D SROLWLF vQ 5RPkQLD D IRVW GRPLQDW GH 3DUWLGXO 1D LRQDO /LEHUDO vQILLQ DWODPDL UHSUH]HQWDQWvQSULQFLSDODOEXUJKH]LHL úL GH 3DUWLGXO &RQVHUYDWRU FRQVWLWXLW OD IHEUXDULH FDUH D SURPRYDWFXSULRULWDWHLQWHUHVHOHPDULORUSURSULHWDULIXQFLDUL&HOHGRX SDUWLGHSROLWLFHVDXVXFFHGDWODJXYHUQDUHFRQIRUPSULQFLSLXOXLÄURWDWLYHL JXYHUQDPHQWDOH´ SkQ OD SULPXO U ]ERL PRQGLDO DVWIHO OLEHUDOLL vQWUH úL GLQ LDU FRQVHUYDWRULL vQWUH 0DLELQHRUJDQL]DWúLPDLGLVFLSOLQDWGDW ILLQGSXWHUHDHFRQRPLFR ILQDQFLDU úL SHUVRQDOLWDWHD GHRVHELW D OLGHULORU D OXL ,,& %U WLDQX vQ VSHFLDO±FKLDUGDF DXPDLIXQF LRQDWúLXQHOHJUXS ULGL]LGHQ H ÄGUDSH OLúWLL´9HUQHVFXúD 3DUWLGXO1D LRQDO/LEHUDOVDSURQXQ DWúLDDF LRQDW SHQWUX GH]YROWDUHD ULL SULQ ÄPLMORDFH SURSULL´ SHQWUX FRQVROLGDUHD UHJLPXOXL SDUODPHQWDU GHPRFUDWLF SULQ DFRUGDUHD PDL PXOWRU GUHSWXUL
ÌQ SRILGD IDSWXOXL F PXOWH GLQ GHFL]LLOH ORU WUHEXLDX V ILH VXSXVH LQL LDO GH]EDWHULL 3DUODPHQWXOXL úL DSUREDWH GH F WUH DFHVWD vQ XQHOH GRPHQLL VXYHUDQLLQXSXWHDXV LQWHUYLQ ,QL LDO D IRVW GRPQLWRU DO 5RPkQLHL OD PDL DSRL UHJH OD PDUWLH
FHW HQHúWL SHQWUX GHVILLQ DUHD YRWXOXL FHQVLWDU LQWURGXFHUHD YRWXOXL XQLYHUVDOvQI SWXLUHDXQHLUHIRUPHDJUDUHPDLUDGLFDOHFUHúWHUHDSRQGHULL SURSULHWDULORUPLFLúLPLMORFLLHWF &X WRDWH F HUD PDL GLYL]DW ÄMXQLPLúWL´ ÄWDNLúWL´ ÄFRQVHUYDWRUL SXUL´ HWF 3DUWLGXO &RQVHUYDWRU EHQHILFLDU DO YRWXOXL FHQVLWDU FX R ERJDW H[SHULHQ SROLWLF úLFXúHILH[SHULPHQWD LúLGHRVHELWGHSUHJ WL L 33&DUS7LWX0DLRUHVFX$OH[DQGUX0DUJKLORPDQúD RFXSDvQF OD vQFHSXWGHVHFROSR]L LLLPSRUWDQWHvQIRUXULOHOHJLVODWLYHúLH[HFXWLYHDOH ULLFXWRDWHF vQVSHFLDOÄFRQVHUYDWRULLSXUL´ ÄMXQLPLúWLL´DYHDXRS LX QL PDL OLEHUDOH DS UDX YHFKLOH UDSRUWXUL GH SURSULHWDWH úL VH SURQXQ DX SHQWUXGH]YROWDUHDFXSULRULWDWHDUDPXULORUúLVXEUDPXULORULQGXVWULHLFDUH SUHOXFUDXSURGXVHOHVROXOXL ÌQSROLWLFDH[WHUQ GDWILLQGSHULFROXO DULVWDPEHOHSDUWLGHDXRSWDW OD vQFHSXW SHQWUX DOLDQ D FX 3XWHULOH &HQWUDOH FRQVLGHUkQG F SUREOHPD 7UDQVLOYDQLHL %DQDWXOXL &ULúDQHL 0DUDPXUHúXOXL úL %XFRYLQHL SXWHD IL VROX LRQDW SHFDOHGLSORPDWLF FXVSULMLQXO*HUPDQLHLvQVSHFLDOÌQXUPD FHOXL GHDO GRLOHD U ]ERL EDOFDQLF 3DUWLGXO 1D LRQDO /LEHUDO úLD RULHQWDW RS LXQLOH VSUH $QWDQW FX WRDWH F GHFODQúDUHD SULPXOXL U ]ERL PRQGLDO DLPSXVSkQ vQ SROLWLFDGHQHXWUDOLWDWH ÌQDIDUDFHORUGRX PDULIRUPD LXQLSROLWLFHDXPDLDFWLYDW3DUWLGXO 1D LRQDOLVW'HPRFUDW 1LFRODH ,RUJD 3DUWLGXO &RQVHUYDWRU 'HPRFUDW 7DNH,RQHVFX 8QLXQHD6RFLDOLVW GLQ5RPkQLD WUDQVIRUPDW vQ3DUWLGXO6RFLDO'HPRFUDWGLQ5RPkQLD FRQWLQXDWRU DO 3DUWLGXOXL 6RFLDO'HPRFUDW DO 0XQFLWRULORU GLQ 5RPkQLD úDFDUHGHúLVHJ VHDXvQFHHDFHSULYHVFSUREOHPHOHVRFLDOHFRQRPLFH SH SR]L LL GLIHULWH DX DF LRQDW vQ JHQHUDO XQLWDU vQ FHHD FH SULYHúWH VROX LRQDUHDRELHFWLYXOXLQD LRQDODOGHV YkUúLULLXQLW LLQD LRQDOVWDWDOH 6HPQLILFDWLY SHQWUX YLD D SROLWLF URPkQHDVF OD vQFHSXW GH VHFRO HVWHúLIDSWXOF vQSRILGDREVWUXF LLORUVRFLDOHúLQD LRQDOHúLDSROLWLFLLGH GH]QD LRQDOL]DUH OD FDUH HUDX VXSXúL URPkQLL DIOD L VXE VW SkQLUH VWU LQ úLDX RUJDQL]DW úL HL SDUWLGH SROLWLFH FHOH PDL DFWLYH úL PDL LPSRUWDQWH ILLQG3DUWLGXO1D LRQDO5RPkQGLQ7UDQVLOYDQLD 3DUWLGXO1D LRQDO 5RPkQ GLQ %XFRYLQD úD FDUH DX DYXW XQ URO LPSRUWDQW vQ RUJDQL]DUHD OXSWHL SHQWUX UHvQWUHJLUH VWDWDO FRODERUkQG GHVHRUL FX DXWRULW LOH úL SDUWLGHOH SROLWLH GLQ 5HJDW ÌQ %DVDUDELD DX IXQF LRQDW JUXS ULSROLWLFHFXFDUDFWHUQD LRQDOFDUHDXWLS ULWvQ ]LDUXOÄ&XYkQW 0ROGRYHQHVF´WULEXQ GHVXV LQHUHDGUHSWXULORUQD LRQDOHURPkQHúWL
'XS vQFHWDUHD GLQ YLD D UHJHOXL &DURO , VHSWHPEULH RFWRPEULH FDOLWDWHD GH VXYHUDQ DO 5RPkQLHL D UHYHQLW QHSRWXOXL V X SULQFLSHOH PRúWHQLWRU )HUGLQDQG VRVLW vQ DU OD DSULOLH PDL 1XPHOHV XU PkQHvQLVWRULDURPkQLORUúLDPRQDUKLHLFDúLFHODO UHJLQHL0DULDVWUkQVOHJDWGHvPSOLQLUHDGH]LGHUDWXOXLQD LRQDODOUHXQLULL OD SDWULDPDP D WXWXURU SURYLQFLLORU URPkQHúWL DIODWH VXE GRPLQD LHVWU LQ ÌQ WLPSXO SULPXOXL U ]ERL PRQGLDO SDUWLGHOH úL JUXS ULOH SROLWLFH URPkQHúWLDXDF LRQDWSHQWUXvPSOLQLUHDLGHDOXOXLQD LRQDODOXQLULLWXWXURU URPkQLORU LQL LDO DFFHSWkQG QHXWUDOLWDWHD úL SURQXQ kQGXVH DSRL GLQ WRDPQDDQXOXL vQFRQVHQVFXRSLQLDSXEOLF SHQWUXDGHUDUHD ULLOD $QWDQW úL LQWUDUHD vQ U ]ERLXO HOLEHUDWRU IDSW vPSOLQLW OD DXJXVW 'XS U ]ERLXOPRQGLDOSR]L LDPRQDUKLHLvQVWDWDIRVW]GUXQFLQDW GHFRPSRUWDUHDSULQFLSHOXLPRúWHQLWRU&DUROFDUHDUHQXQ DWGHPDLPXOWH RULODREOLJD LLOHFHLUHYHQHDX úL S U VLQGFKLDU DUDúL SURYRFkQGRJUDY FUL] GLQDVWLF ÌQ DFHVW FRQWH[W OD GHFHPEULH &RQVLOLXO GH &RURDQ LD DFFHSWDW UHQXQ DUHD OD SUHURJDWLYHOH GH PRúWHQLWRU DO WURQXOXL LDU OD LDQXDULH $GXQDUHD 1D LRQDO &RQVWLWXDQW OD SURFODPDW VXFFHVRU SH 0LKDL ILXO V X 'HRDUHFH DFHVWD HUD PLQRU VD GHFLV LQVWLWXLUHD XQHL 5HJHQ H FRQVWLWXLW GLQ SULQFLSHOH 1LFRODH OLSVLW GH RULFH DPEL LH úL DSWLWXGLQL SROLWLFH SDWULDUKXO 0LURQ &ULVWHD úL *KHRUJKH %X]GXJDQ SULPSUHúHGLQWH DO ÌQDOWHL &XU L GH &DVD LH úL -XVWL LH $IODW VXE LQIOXHQ DOLEHUDOLORUVXEPLQDW GHGRULQ HOHUHJLQHL0DULDGHDúLLPSXQH úLvQDFHDVW VWUXFWXU DXWRULWDWHDSUHFXPúLGHDF LXQLOHFXUHQWXOXLFDUOLVW vQ WRDWH SDUWLGHOH SROLWLFH LQFOXVLY vQ DUPDW 5HJHQ D VD GRYHGLW LQFDSDELO V úLH[HUFLWHSUHURJDWLYHOHFRQVWLWX LRQDOH /HJHD HOHFWRUDO GLQ LQWURGXFHUHD YRWXOXL XQLYHUVDO FDUH DX VSRULW QXP UXO GH DOHJ WRUL PRGLILFkQG UDGLFDO PRGXO GH GHVI úXUDUH D FDPSDQLLORUHOHFWRUDOHUHDOL]DUHD0DULL8QLULGLQ DXFRQVWLWXLWGRDU Fk LYD IDFWRUL FDUH DX I FXW FD vQ YLD D SXEOLF SRVWEHOLF V LQWUH QRL
5HJHQ DDLQWUDWvQIXQF LXQHODLXOLH vQXUPDGHFHVXOXLUHJHOXL )HUGLQDG, ÌQ XUPD GHFHVXOXL OXL *KHRUJKH %X]GXJDQ OD RFWRPEULH vQ UHJHQ DLQWUDW&RQVWDQWLQ6 U HDQX
SDUWLGH úL IRUPD LXQL SROLWLFH FHOH PDL DFWLYH ILLQG /LJD3DUWLGXO 3RSRUXOXL JHQHUDOXO $OH[DQGUX $YHUHVFX 3DUWLGXO U QHVF ,RQ 0LKDODFKH FDUH RFWRPEULH D IX]LRQDW FX 3DUWLGXO 1D LRQDOVXEGHQXPLUHDGH3DUWLGXO1D LRQDO U QHVFUH]XOWkQGDOGRLOHD PDUHSDUWLGDO ULL 'XS YLD D SROLWLF URPkQHDVF D GHYHQLW PDL GLQDPLF QXP UXOSDUWLGHORUVSRULQGGHOD vQ ODvQ LQFOXVLYGLQ UkQGXO PLQRULW LORU QD LRQDOHL 3DUWLGXO 0DJKLDU 3DUWLGXO *HUPDQ 8QLXQHD (YUHLORU GLQ 5RPkQLD HWF PDMRULWDWHD GHVI úXUkQGXúL DFWLYLWDWHD OD QLYHOXO vQWUHJLL UL OXkQGXúL GHQXPLUL ÄGHPRFUDWLFH´ ÄSRSXODUH´ÄUDGLFDOH´Ä U QHúWL´úD ÌQGHFHQLXOFDXUPDUHDPDQHYUHORUUHJHOXL&DURODO,,OHDFDUH XUP UHD V úL LPSXQ SXWHUHD WRWDO vQ VWDW DX FRQWLQXDW V DS U GL]LGHQ H vQ VSHFLDO GLQ UkQGXO 3DUWLGXOXL 1D LRQDO U QHVF ÌQ FDGUXO HYDQWDLXOXLODUJDOSDUWLGHORUúLIRU HORUSROLWLFHPDMRULWDWHDDXDYXWRS LXQL GHPRFUDWLFHDF LRQkQGSHQWUXGH]YROWDUHDOLEHU D ULLúLPRGHUQL]DUHDHL SHQWUX R SROLWLF H[WHUQ FDUH V GXF OD PHQ LQHUHD LQGHSHQGHQ HL QD LRQDOHúLDLQWHJULW LLWHULWRULDOH &RQFRPLWHQWvQYLD DSROLWLF URPkQHDVF DXH[LVWDWvQV úLSDUWLGH úLIRUPD LXQLH[WUHPLVWH±GHVWkQJD 3DUWLGXO&RPXQLVWGLQ5RPkQLDGLQ úLGHGUHDSWD /LJDÄ$UKDQJKHOXOXL0LKDLO´GLQ FDUHDYHDV DFWLYH]H VXFFHVLY VXE GHQXPLUHD GH *DUGD GH )LHU *UXSDUHD Ä&RUQHOLX &RGUHDQX´3DUWLGXO7RWXOSHQWUX DU 0LúFDUHD/HJLRQDU %HQHILFLLQG GHVSULMLQH[WHUQDO8QLXQLL6RYLHWLFHUHVSHFWLYDO*HUPDQLHLDFHVWHDDX UHXúLW V úL WULPLW UHSUH]HQWDQ L vQ 3DUODPHQW FRPXQLúWLL vQ OHJLRQDULL vQ &X WRDWH DFHVWHD DWkW FRPXQLVPXO FkW úL IDVFLVPXOQXDXUHXúLWvQSHULRDGDLQWHUEHOLF V VHLPSXQ vQ5RPkQLD 5HYHQLW vQ DU OD LXQLH SULQFLSHOH &DURO D IRVW SURFODPDW UHJHGHF WUHFRUSXULOHOHJLXLWRDUH LXQLH VXEQXPHOHGH&DURODO,, OHD ILXOXL V X 0LKDL ILLQGXL DWULEXLW WLWOXO GH Ä0DUH 9RHYRG GH $OED ,XOLD´$YkQGDOW ILUHúLDOWFDUDFWHUSURILWkQGGHVO ELFLXQHDSDUWLGHORU SROLWLFH GH RSRUWXQLVPXO FRQGXF WRULORU &DURO DO ,,OHD VD LPSXV GHOD vQFHSXW vQ YLD D SROLWLF D ULL I U D VFKLPED LQL LDO IRUPD GH JXYHUQ PkQWúLUHJLPXOSROLWLFFRQVROLGkQGDWULEX LLOHSXWHULLH[HFXWLYH SH FDUH R FRQWUROD SULQ LQWHUPHGLXO SULPXOXLPLQLVWUX ± *KHRUJKH 7 W UHVFX±úLDFDPDULOHL
&XWRDWHF vQPRGQRUPDOvQFHLGHDQLLQWHUEHOLFLWUHEXLDXV VH GHVI úRDUH FDPSDQLLHOHFWRUDOHúLV VHVFKLPEHWRWDWkWHDJXYHUQH HOHFWRUDWXODIRVWFRQYRFDWGHGHRUL vQDQLL úL FRQVWLWXLQGXVHvQWUH LDQXDULH úLIHEUXDULH GHJXYHUQH FHOHPDLPXOWHvQSHULRDGHOH úL DGLF PDLPXOWGHFLQFLJXYHUQHSHQWUXILHFDUH SHULRDG OHJDO GHSDWUXDQL'LQWUHWRDWHGRDUGRX JXYHUQHIRUPDWH GH3DUWLGXO1D LRQDO/LEHUDOVDXPHQ LQXWODSXWHUHDQL vQSHULRDGHOH LDQXDULH ± PDUWLH úL QRLHPEULH GHFHPEULH &XWRDWHDFHVWHDvQSHULRDGD vQ5RPkQLDDIXQF LRQDW XQUHJLPGHPRFUDWLFLQFOXVLYDOWHUQDQ DODSXWHUH 'H FDUHQ HOH UHJLPXOXL GHPRFUDWLF URPkQHVF LQWHUEHOLF D SURILWDW UHJHOH &DURO DO ,,OHD FDUH D UHXúLW V GHVWDELOL]H]H YLD D SROLWLF GHPRFUDWLF úLGHDLPSXQHXQUHJLPGHFRQGXFHUHSHUVRQDO DXWRULWDU 3HQWUX DúL DWLQJH HOXULOH PRQDUKXO D LQIOXHQ DW úL D DWUDV GH SDUWHD VD OLGHUL WLQHUL úL LQIOXHQ L DL SDUWLGHORU GHPRFUDWH vQ VSHFLDO GLQ 3DUWLGXO 1D LRQDO/LEHUDO *KHRUJKH7 W UHVFXúD úL3DUWLGXO1D LRQDO U QHVF $UPDQG & OLQHVFX úD SURPRYkQGXL vQ FHOH PDL vQDOWH IXQF LL H[HFXWLYH GH vQDOW GHFL]LH vQ VWDW &RQFRPLWHQW SHQWUX D GH]ELQD úL GLPLQXDXQLWDWHDGHDF LXQHDFHORUGRX PDULSDUWLGHDOH ULLOHDSURPLV F OH YD DGXFH OD SXWHUH 3DUWLGXOXL 1D LRQDO U QHVF vQ VSHFLDO FRQGL LRQkQG DFHVW OXFUX GH FRODERU UL SROLWLFH GH QHDFFHSWDW GH F WUH DFHVWHD ÌQ DFHODúL VFRS D vQFHUFDW V vQORFXLDVF JXYHUQHOHGHSDUWLGFX FHOH ÄQD LRQDOH´ GH ÄWHKQLFLHQL´ VDX GH FRDOL LH FRQGXVH GH RDPHQL GHYRWD L I U REOLJD LL SROLWLFH D LQWURGXV vQ JXYHUQH SHUVRDQH GH vQFUHGHUH D SURYRFDW GHVHRUL FUL]H GH JXYHUQ vQF OFkQG UHJXOLOH FRQVWLWX LRQDOHUHXúLQGGHVHRULDFHVWOXFUXFKLDUGDF DDYXWSHUPDQHQW XQDGYHUVDUUHGXWDELOvQ,XOLX0DQLXFDUHVDSURQXQ DWSHQWUXPHQ LQHUHD VLVWHPXOXL SDUODPHQWDU úL UHVSHFWDUHD SUHYHGHULORU &RQVWLWX LHL
$O*6DYX'LFWDWXUDUHJDO (GLWXUD3ROLWLF %XFXUHúWL SS ÌQ QRLHPEULH D FHUXW OXL ,RQ 0LKDODFKH V FRODERUH]H FX $OH[DQGUX 9DLGD9RHYRG GXS FDUH D GHFODQúDW FUL]D GH JXYHUQ vQFHSkQG FRQVXOWD LL FX OLGHULL SROLWLFL I U D FHUH GHPLVLD OXL *KHRUJKH 7 W UHVFX 'LQ IUXQWHD([HFXWLYXOXL$SRLODvQV UFLQDWGLQQRXWRWSH*KHRUJKH7 W UHVFXV IRUPH]HXQQRXJXYHUQ
'HVHPQkQG OD QRLHPEULH WRW SH *KHRUJKH 7 W UHVFX FX FRQVWLWXLUHDQRXOXLJXYHUQUHJHOH&DURODO,,OHDDSXVFDS WSULQFLSLXOXL ÄURWDWLYHL JXYHUQDPHQWDOH´ vQF OFkQG GLQ QRX X]DQ HOH úL WUDGL LD SDUODPHQWDU 6LWXD LD SROLWLF GLQ 5RPkQLD VD DJUDYDW GXS DOHJHULOH SDUODPHQWDUHGLQGHFHPEULH FkQGQLFLXQSDUWLGSROLWLFQXDUHXúLWV RE LQ PDMRULWDWHD GH YRWXUL FHUXW GH SULPD HOHFWRUDO FRQIRUP /HJLL HOHFWRUDOH GLQ 2E LQkQG SHQWUX SULPD GDW vQ LVWRULD DOHJHULORUSDUODPHQWDUHGRDU GLQRS LXQLOHHOHFWRUDWXOXLJXYHUQXO D IRVW vQIUkQW vQ DOHJHUL 7RW SHQWUX SULPD GDW EHQHILFLLQG úL GH SDFWXO HOHFWRUDO GH QHDJUHVLXQH GLQ QRLHPEULH vQFKHLDW FX 3DUWLGXO 1D LRQDO U QHVF *DUGD GH )LHU VD VLWXDW SH ORFXO WUHL FX GLQ YRWXUL3DUWLGXO1D LRQDO U QHVFFDUHDRE LQXWGLQYRWXULVD VLWXDWGRDUSHORFXOGRLQHSXWkQGLPSXQHUHJHOXL&DURODO,,OHDDGXFHUHD ODJXYHUQDUH ÌQDFHVWFRQWH[WODGHFHPEULH UHJHOH&DURODO,,OHDI U V PDL DúWHSWH SUH]HQWDUHD RILFLDO D UH]XOWDWHORU DOHJHULORU úL I U V FRQVXOWHSUHúHGLQ LLGHSDUWLGHDSULPLWGHPLVLDOXL*KHRUJKH7 W UHVFXúL D vQV UFLQDW SH 2FWDYLDQ *RJD FX IRUPDUHD QRXOXL JXYHUQ FKLDU GDF 3DUWLGXO 1D LRQDO&UHúWLQ SH FDUH DFHVWD vO FRQGXFHD RE LQXVH vQ DOHJHUL GRDU GLQYRWXUL3ULQDFHDVWDUHJHOHDVILGDWSULQFLSLLOHVLVWHPXOXL SDUODPHQWDU úL UHJXOLOH FRQVWLWX LRQDOH D GDW R SXWHUQLF ORYLWXUD VLVWHPXOXL GHPRFUDWLF FRQVWLWX LRQDO (YHQLPHQWXO DYHD V SURGXF vQ VFXUW WLPS úL DOWH LPSRUWDQWH VFKLPE UL vQ VLVWHPXO SROLWLF GHPRFUDWLF URPkQHVF
'RFXPHQWXO SUHYHGHD REOLJD LD PLúF ULL OHJLRQDUH D 3DUWLGXOXL 1D LRQDO U QHVFúLD3DUWLGXOXL1D LRQDO/LEHUDO±*KHRUJKH%U WLDQX FDUHD DGHUDWOD3DFW GHÄDDS UDOLEHUWDWHDúLGHDDVLJXUDFRUHFWLWXGLQHDDOHJHULORU´úL VWLSXODF vQ HOHJHUHDÄQXvPSLHGLF DILUPDUHDLGHRORJLHLSURSULLúLGLVFX LDGH EXQ FUHGLQ ´ Ä'UHSWDWHD´ GLQ QRLHPEULH &KLDU GDF DFRUGXO UHDOL]DW QX D vQVHPQDW DGHUDUHD OLGHUXOXL QD LRQDO U QLVW ,XOLX 0DQLX OD LGHRORJLD* U]LLGH)LHUFLGRDURDOLDQ WHPSRUDU SHQWUXvQO WXUDUHDOLEHUDOL ORUGHODJXYHUQQHXWUDOL]DUHDOHJLRQDULORUúLDFFHGHUHDODSXWHUHHODDYXWXQ LPSDFWQHJDWLYDVXSUDRSLQLHLSXEOLFHURPkQHúWLDVXSUDHOHFWRUDWXOXLvQVSHFLDO FUHkQGFRQIX]LLúLGHWHUPLQkQGvQPDUHP VXU DVFHQVLXQHDOHJLRQDULORU &RQFRPLWHQW HO D HOLPLQDW SRVLELOLWDWHD LQWURGXFHULL OHJLRQDULORU vQ JXYHUQúLvPSOLQLUHDGH]LGHUDWHORUDOWRUJUXS ULSROLWLFHGHH[WUHP GUHDSWD
3URILWkQG GH IDSWXO F QRXO JXYHUQ QX DYHD R ED] SDUODPHQWDU GDU úL GH UHDF LD LQWHUQD LRQDO QHJDWLY FDX]DW vQ VSHFLDO GH P VXULOH DQWLVHPLWH DGRSWDWH OD VFXUW WLPS GXS LQVWDXUDUH úL GH DSURSLHUHD GH *HUPDQLDúL,WDOLD&DURODO,,OHDDGHFLVODLDQXDULH GL]ROYDUHD 3DUODPHQWXOXLDOHV vQDLQWHFKLDUFDDFHVWDV VHILvQWUXQLW úLDDQXQ DWQRL DOHJHUL SHQWUX $GXQDUHD 'HSXWD LORU PDUWLH úL 6HQDW PDUWLH ,QYRFkQG QXPHURDVHOH DFWH GH YLROHQ FDUH SXWHDX GHJHQHUD vQ U ]ERL FLYLOVXYHUDQXODFHUXWOXL$UPDQG& OLQHVFXPLQLVWUXGH,QWHUQHV IDF X]GHDUPHvPSRWULYDFHORUFDUHWXOEXUDXRUGLQHDSXEOLF FHLYL]D LILLQG vQVSHFLDOOHJLRQDULLÌQWUXQDVHPHQHDFRQWH[W&RUQHOLX=HOHD&RGUHDQX DUHWUDV vQXUPDXQHLGLVFX LLDYXWHFX2FWDYLDQ*RJD *DUGDGH)LHUGLQ DOHJHULOHJLRQDULLXUPkQGV YRWH]HOLVWHOH3DUWLGXOXL1D LRQDO&UHúWLQ 5HJLPXOGHDXWRULWDWHPRQDUKLF DOUHJHOXL&DURODO,,OHD /DIHEUXDULH &DURODO,,OHDDYDORULILFDWGLQQRXFRQWH[WXO LQWHUQ LQFDSDFLWDWHDSDUWLGHORUSROLWLFHGHPRFUDWLFHGHDFkúWLJDDOHJHULOH úLGHDJXYHUQDGHJULQJRODGDDFHVWRUD úLLQWHUQD LRQDO SHUFHS LDQHJDWLY D QRXOXL JXYHUQ vQ PDMRULWDWHD VWDWHORU HXURSHQH GHPRFUDWH vQ VSHFLDO GDWRULW P VXULORU DQWLVHPLWH OXDWH VDX SUHFRQL]DWH VXSULPDUHD ]LDUHORU FDUHFRQWUDYHQHDXSROLWLFLLFL]LVWHÄURPkQL] ULL´SUHVHLHWF SURYRFkQG RFUL] JXYHUQDPHQWDO vQXUPDF UHLD2FWDYLDQ*RJDúLDGDWGHPLVLD ,PHGLDW UHJHOH D QXPLW vQ IUXQWHD JXYHUQXOXL SH SDWULDUKXO 0LURQ &ULVWHD$SRLvQGLVFX LDDYXW FXIRúWLLSULPPLQLúWULúLFXúHILLXQRUD GLQWUH SDUWLGHOH SROLWLFH D SURSXV UHYRFDUHD FRQYRF ULL FRUSXULORU HOHFWRUDOHUHYL]XLUHDXQRUSUHYHGHULDOH&RQVWLWX LHLHWF&XDFHODúLSULOHM D VROLFLWDW VXVSHQGDUHD WHPSRUDU D DFWLYLW LL SDUWLGHORU SROLWLFH &KLDU GDF QX OHDX FRQYHQLW P VXULOH DQXQ DWH GH UHJH FHL FRQVXOWD L PXOWH SHUVRQDOLW LSROLWLFHUHPDUFDELOHVDXDQJDMDWV VSULMLQHQRXOUHJLPVDX V QXLIDF SUREOHPH FD]XOOXL,XOLX0DQLX
/D VXJHVWLD UHJHOXL OD IHEUXDULH $UPDQG & OLQHVFX úL ,RQ *LJXUWXDXGHPLVLRQDWLQYRFkQGLPSRVLELOLWDWHDFRODERU ULLFXPHPEULLJUXS ULL FX]LVWHGLQJXYHUQ 3ULQ DFHDVWD &DURO DO ,,OHD I FHD FXQRVFXW LQWHQ LD GH D JXYHUQD RE LQkQG WRWRGDW DGH]LXQHD %LVHULFLL OD QRXO UHJLP SUHFRQL]DW OLQLúWLUHD FHUFXULORUSROLWLFHLQWHUQD LRQDOHHWF
ÌQDFHHDúL]LDLQVWLWXLWXQUHJLPPRQDUKLFDXWRULWDUGHFODQúkQGXVH SURFHVXOGHOLPLWDUHGUDVWLF DGUHSWXULORUúLOLEHUW LORUFHW HQHúWL LQWUR GXFHUHDVW ULLGHDVHGLXDPkQDUHDDOHJHULORUDQLKLODUHDSDUWLGHORUSROLWLFH HWF FDUH DYHD V VH DJUDYH]H úL V VH H[WLQG SH SDUFXUVXO D SHVWH R MXP WDWHGHVHFROSkQ OD5HYROX LDGLQGHFHPEULH &KLDUGDF QRXD&RQVWLWX LHSURPXOJDW ODIHEUXDULH VD UHIHULW OD XQHOH SULQFLSLL GHPRFUDWLFH VXYHUDQLWDWHD QD LRQDO VHSDUD LD SXWHULORU vQ VWDW HWF úL GUHSWXUL FHW HQHúWL HJDOLWDWHD vQ ID D OHJLORU OLEHUWDWHD LQGLYLGXDO LQYLRODELOLWDWHD GRPLFLOLXOXL HWF SULQ QRLOH SXWHUL DWULEXLWHUHJHOXLHDDVFKLPEDWUDGLFDOUDSRUWXOGLQWUHSXWHUHDOHJLVODWLY úL FHDH[HFXWLY vQIDYRDUHDXOWLPHL3DUODPHQWXO*XYHUQXOúLFKLDU-XVWL LD ILLQG VXERUGRQDWH vQ PDUH P VXU PRQDUKXOXL GHFODUDW GH DFHDVW GDW RILFLDOÄFDSXOVWDWXOXL´3ULQIDSWXOF JXYHUQXOHUDQXPLWGLUHFWGHF WUH VXYHUDQ PLQLúWULL QX PDL DYHDX R ED] SDUODPHQWDU ILLQG UHVSRQVDELOL GRDUID GHFHOFDUHLDSURSXOVDWvQ([HFXWLY0DLPXOWUHJHOHSXWHD GH DFHDVW GDW V UHIX]H VDQF LRQDUHD OHJLORU DGRSWDWH GH 3DUODPHQW V GL]ROYH&DPHUDúL6HQDWXOV HPLW vQLQWHUYDOXOGLQWUHVHVLXQLGHFUHWHFX SXWHUH GH OHJH V VHPQH]H WUDWDWH SROLWLFH úL PLOLWDUH I U DSUREDUHD 3DUODPHQWXOXL ILLQG DEVROYLW GH RULFH U VSXQGHUH 3ULQ XUPDUH QRXD &RQVWLWX LH D vQORFXLW SULQFLSLXO VXYHUDQLW LL QD LRQDOH úL DO UHJLPXOXL UHSUH]HQWDWLY FX FHO DO VXSUHPD LHL UHJDOH UHGXFkQG GUDVWLF DWULEX LLOH 3DUODPHQWXOXLvQGHIDYRDUHDDWULEX LLORUUHJDOH3UDFWLFUHJHOH&DURODO,, OHDDWUHFXWúLODÄJXYHUQDUHD´ ULL ÌQ SODQ SROLWLF vQ SHULRDGD XUP WRDUHDIRVWLQWHU]LV ÄGHMXUH´ DFWLYLWDWHD SDUWLGHORU JUXS ULORU úL DVRFLD LLORU SROLWLFH PDUWLH GHRDUHFH QX DX IRVW GL]ROYDWH DFHVWHD úLDX FRQWLQXDW ÄGH IDFWR´ vQ DQXPLWHOLPLWHDFWLYLWDWHD DFOXEXULORUúLORFDOXULORUGHvQWUXQLULDOHDFHV
/DIHEUXDULH QRXD&RQVWLWX LHDIRVWDSUREDW SULQSOHELVFLW GH GHFHW HQLGLQFHLSDUWLFLSDQ LODYRW &KLDU vQDLQWH GH LQVWDXUDUHD UHJLPXOXL DXWRULWDU PRQDUKLF &DURO DO ,,OHDvLUHDPLQWLVHOXL$UPDQG& OLQHVFX Ä(úWLPLQLVWUXOPHXGH,QWHUQH´ 3HODUJ $O*6DYXRSFLWSS /DPDUWLH DIRVWFRQVWLWXLWI U FRQVXOWDUHDUHSUH]HQWDQ LORU SDUWLGHORU SROLWLFH XQ QRX JXYHUQ 0LURQ &ULVWHD FRQVWLWXLW vQ SULQFLSDO GLQ DSURSLD L DL JUXS ULORU SROLWLFH FRQGXVH GH $UPDQG & OLQHVFX úL *KHRUJKH 7 W UHVFXLDUODPDUWLH DOWXOFRQGXVGH$UPDQG& OLQHVFX
WRUD DSULOLH SUHFXPúLSUHVDGHSDUWLG ]LDUHOHFDUHDXFRQWLQXDW V DSDU VDXSURFODPDWÄLQGHSHQGHQWH´ 5HJLPXOGHPRFUDWLFDVXIHULWORYLWXULúLSULQLQVWLWXLUHDFHQ]XULLúLD VW ULLGHDVHGLXSHvQWUHJWHULWRULXO ULL IHEUXDULH DGRSWDUHDXQHL QRL OHJL HOHFWRUDOH PDL FKLDU GDF SHQWUX SULPD GDW IHPHLOH SULPHDX GUHSW GH YRW &RQFRPLWHQW DX PDL IRVW GL]ROYDWH VLQGLFDWHOH úL FRQVWLWXLWH EUHVOHOH FD RUJDQL]D LL SURIHVLRQDOH RFWRPEULH vQILLQ DW Ä6WUDMD ULL´ GHFHPEULH SHQWUXDWUDJHUHDWLQHUHWXOXL HODERUDW RQRX UHIRUP DGPLQLVWUDWLY DXJXVW SULQFDUHDO WXUL GHFRPXQ SODV úLMXGH DPDLIRVWLQVWLWXLW LQXWXOúLDXIRVWOXDWHP VXUL GXUH vPSRWULYD OHJLRQDULORU vQ ED]D OHJLL SHQWUX DS UDUHD RUGLQLL SXEOLFHvQVWDWGLQDSULOLH PXOWHF SHWHQLLILLQGDUHVWDWHMXGHFD WH FRQGDPQDWH PDL úL FKLDU H[HFXWDWH QRLHPEULH LQFOXVLY &RUQHOLX =HOHD &RGUHDQX 8Q DQ PDL WkU]LX OD VHSWHPEULH XQ FRPDQGR OHJLRQDU DYHD V DVDVLQH]H SH $UPDQG & OLQHVFX SULPXOPLQLVWUXDO ULL 7RW vQ SODQ SROLWLF OD GHFHPEULH D IRVW vQILLQ DW )URQWXO 5HQDúWHULL1D LRQDOHFRQGXVGLUHFWGHUHJHFDÄXQLF RUJDQL]D LHSROLWLF vQVWDW´FXPHPEULGHFRQGXFHUHQXPL LúLQXDOHúL&XDFHOSULOHMÄRULFH DOW DFWLYLWDWHSROLWLF ´DIRVWFRQVLGHUDW FODQGHVWLQ LDUDXWRULLHLSHGHS VL L FX GHJUDGDUH FLYLF SH WHUPHQ GH OD SkQ OD DQL &RQFRPLWHQW )51 D GHYHQLW VLQJXUD RUJDQL]D LH FDUH SXWHD GHSXQH FDQGLGD L vQ DOHJHULOH SDUODPHQWDUH DGPLQLVWUDWLYH úL SURIHVLRQDOH 3ULQ vQWUHJXO PRGGHRUJDQL]DUHúLGHDFWLYLWDWH)URQWXO5HQDúWHULL1D LRQDOHvQSRILGD PDVLYXOXL VSULMLQ UHJDO QX D F S WDW DGHUHQ OD PDVH ILLQG ERLFRWDW GH PHPEULL SDUWLGHORU ÄLVWRULFH´ FDUH FKLDU GDF DX DGHUDW OD QRXD IRUPD LXQH SROLWLF DX PHQ LQXW OHJ WXULOH FX SDUWLGHOH GLQ FDUH SURYHQHDX ÌQ DFHVW FRQWH[W vQFHUF ULOH UHJHOXL &DURO DO ,,OHD GH UHFRQFLOLHUH WRDPQD DQXOXL FX SDUWLGHOH SROLWLFH GLQ DU DX HúXDW OD IHO FD úL UHRUJDQL]DUHD)URQWXOXL5HQDúWHULL1D LRQDOHGLQLDQXDULH FkQGVD
3HQWUXDHYLWDDF LXQLOHUHSUHVLYHDOHSXWHULL&RUQHOLX=HOHD&RGUHDQX GHFLVHVHvQF GHODIHEUXDULH vQFHWDUHDDFWLYLW LLSDUWLGXOXL7RWXOSHQWUX DU $O*6DYXRSFLWSS &HL PDL UHFHSWLYL OD SURSXQHULOH UHJHOXL VDX GRYHGLW D IL OHJLRQDULL FDUHDXIRVWHOLEHUD LvQPDV
GHFLVHOLJLELOLWDWHDRUJDQHORUGHFRQGXFHUHSkQ OD LQXWúLDOHJHUHDXQHL QRLFRQGXFHULFHQWUDOHvQIUXQWHFX$OH[DQGUX9DLGD9RHYRG 'XS FDSLWXODUHD)UDQ HLvQFHUFkQGV DGDSWH]HúLPDLPXOWVLWXD LD GLQ 5RPkQLD QRXOXL FRQWH[W LQWHUQD LRQDO GRPLQDW vQ WRWDOLWDWH GH F WUH *HUPDQLDQD]LVW &DURODO,,OHDDGHFLVODLXQLH WUDQVIRUPDUHD )URQWXOXL5HQDúWHULL1D LRQDOHvQ3DUWLGXO1D LXQLLGHFODUDWúLHOÄSDUWLG XQLF úL WRWDOLWDU´ DIODW VXE FRPDQGD VXSUHP D UHJHOXL ÌQ DFHHDúL ]L SULQ GHFUHWUHJDO D IRVW GHFODUDW ÄRUGLQHD SROLWLF XQLF úL WRWDOLWDU D VWDWXOXLURPkQ´LQWURGXFkQGXVHSHGHSVHDVSUHID GHFHLFDUHDUILI FXW SURSDJDQG SHQWUXVFKLPEDUHDRUJDQL] ULLSROLWLFHDVWDWXOXLURPkQ ÌQ QRXO FRQWH[W LQWHUQD LRQDO DJUDYDW úL GH XOWLPDWXPXULOH 0RVFRYHL *DUGD GH )LHU D GHYHQLW OD LXQLH IRU SROLWLF GH JXYHUQ PkQWLDU+RULD6LPDQRXOúHIDOOHJLRQDULORUPHPEUXDO([HFXWL YXOXL 3HVWH SX LQ WLPS DFHVWD DYHD V FHDU UHJHOXL V vQFUHGLQ H]H vQWUHDJDSXWHUHOHJLRQDULORU 6LWXD LD UHJLPXOXL PRQDUKLF GH DXWRULWDWH FDUH HYROXDVH GHMD VSUH WRWDOLWDULVP ODLXOLH&RUSXULOH/HJLXLWRDUHDXIRVWGL]ROYDWHOD DXJXVW DIRVWDGRSWDWGHFUHWXOOHJHUHIHULWRUODVWDUHDMXULGLF DORFXLWRULORUHYUHL GLQ5RPkQLDSULQFDUHDQWLVHPLWLVPXODIRVWULGLFDWODSROLWLF GHVWDW VD DJUDYDW vQ XUPD UDSWXULORU WHULWRULDOH GLQ YDUD DQXOXL SULQ FDUH 8QLXQHD 6RYLHWLF 8QJDULD úL %XOJDULD DX RFXSDW FLUFD R WUHLPH GLQ WHULWRULXOQD LRQDOI FkQGFDLQGLJQDUHDSRSXODU V DWLQJ FRWHPD[LPH ÌQ SRILGD JUDYHL FUL]H JXYHUQDPHQWDOH D UHJLPXOXL úL D PRQDUKLHL SDUWLGHOH SROLWLFH GHPRFUDWLFH QX DX UHXúLW vQV V LPSXQ UHYHQLUHD OD UHJLPXOSROLWLFGHPRFUDWLF 5HJLPXOGLFWDWRULDOLQVWDXUDWGH,RQ$QWRQHVFX ÌQVSHUDQ DF vúLYDVDOYDWURQXO&DURODO,,OHDDDSHODW vQXUPD UHIX]XOXLSDUWLGHORUSROLWLFHGHDFRODERUDODJXYHUQDUH ODJHQHUDOXO,RQ $QWRQHVFX DJUHDW úL GH F WUH úHILL SDUWLGHORU ÄLVWRULFH´ vQ SRILGD
PDQ
&DURODO,,OHDXUP UHDSULQDFHDVWDúLQHXWUDOL]DUHDWRWDO DOHJLRQDULORU /D VXJHVWLD OXL 9DOHU 3RS LQVSLUDW OD UkQGXL GH F WUH /HJD LD JHU
IDSWXOXL F SkQ QX GHPXOW DYXVHVH FX DFHVWD QXPHURDVH FRQIOLFWH 'XS FH GXVHVH vQWUH úL VHSWHPEULH WUDWDWLYH FX ,XOLX 0DQLX &,& %U WLDQX úL +RULD 6LPD vQ YHGHUH FRQVWLWXLULL XQXL JXYHUQ GH ÄXQLXQHQD LRQDO ´,RQ$QWRQHVFXLQYHVWLWODVHSWHPEULHFXFRQVWLWXLUHD XQXL QRX JXYHUQ D VROLFLWDW LPHGLDW SXWHUL GHSOLQH SHQWUX FRQGXFHUHD VWDWXOXL 6XE SUHVLXQHD OHJLRQDULORU FDUH H[HFXWDVHU OD VHSWHPEULH XQHOH DWDFXUL DUPDWH vPSRWULYD DXWRULW LORU GH VWDW úL FKLDU DVXSUD XQRU XQLW L PLOLWDUH UHJHOH D vQFUHGLQ DW OXL ,RQ $QWRQHVFX OD VHSWHPEULH RUHOH ÄGHSOLQH SXWHUL SHQWUX FRQGXFHUHD VWDWXOXL URPkQ´ VXVSHQGkQG WRWRGDW &RQVWLWX LD GLQ IHEUXDULH GL]ROYkQG 3DUODPHQWXO úL GLPLQXkQG SUHURJDWLYHOH UHJDOH /D UkQGXL ,RQ $QWRQHVFX D VROLFLWDW VXYHUDQXOXL vQ VHDUD ]LOHL OD RUHOH V DEGLFH DFHVW OXFUX ILLQG GRULW DWkW GH OLGHULL SULQFLSDOHORU SDUWLGH SROLWLFH GHPRFUDWLFH FkW úL GH OHJLRQDUL úLGHJHUPDQL ,]RODWúLS U VLWGHPDMRULWDWHDFRODERUDWRULORUDSURSLD L FHLU PDúL ILGHOL DX IRVW QHXWUDOL]D L GH F WUH ,RQ $QWRQHVFX VXE SUHVLXQHD PDQLIHVWD LLORU GH VWUDG RUJDQL]DWH GH OHJLRQDUL FDUH DX WUDV IRFXUL GH DUP vQMXUXO3DODWXOXL5HJDO&DURODO,,OHDDIRVWREOLJDWV DEGLFHvQ GLPLQHD D]LOHLGHVHSWHPEULH ODRUHOH S U VLQGDGRXD]LvQPDUH JUDE úL FX PXOWH SHULSH LL 5RPkQLD XUP ULW GH OHJLRQDUL $VWIHO OXD VIkUúLWUHJLPXODXWRULWDULQVWLWXLWvQIHEUXDULH
/DVHSWHPEULH ,XOLX0DQLXVDvQWkOQLWFX,RQ$QWRQHVFXOD 3ORLHúWLVWDELOLQGV UHIX]HXQHYHQWXDOPDQGDWGLQSDUWHDUHJHOXLGHDFRQVWLWXL JXYHUQXOV SDUWLFLSHODJXYHUQDUHGDF PRQDUKXODUILDEGLFDWLDUGDF DFHVW OXFUXQXVHvQWkPSODV VHSUH]LQWHOD3DODWSHVWHSDWUX]LOHSHQWUXDVROLFLWDOXL &DURO DO ,,OHD V UHQXQ H OD WURQ ÌQ FDGUXO DXGLHQ HL OD UHJH OD VROLFLWDUHD VXYHUDQXOXL ,RQ$QWRQHVFXDDFFHSWDWV GLVFXWHGHVSUHFRPSRQHQ DYLLWRUXOXL JXYHUQGHÄXQLXQHQD LRQDO ´I U DVROLFLWDDEGLFDUHD $GYHUVDUvQYHUúXQDWDOOXL&DURODO,,JHQHUDOXO,RQ$QWRQHVFXIXVHVH FKLDU LQWHUQDW vQ YDUD DQXOXL OD P Q VWLUHD %LVWUL D 9kOFHD GH XQGH D VWDELOLWOHJ WXULFX:LOKHOP)DEULFLXVPLQLVWUXO*HUPDQLHLOD%XFXUHúWL $XULF 6LPLRQ5HJLPXOSROLWLFGLQ5RPkQLDvQSHULRDGDVHSWHPEULH LDQXDULH (GLWXUD'DFLD&OXM1DSRFD S /DVHSWHPEULH RUHOH,RQ$QWRQHVFXDFHUXWXOWLPDWLY UHJHOXL V DEGLFH I FkQG FXQRVFXW F vQ FD] GH UHIX] QX vL PDL JDUDQWD VHFXULWDWHDSHUVRQDO úLDDQWXUDMXOXL/DSOHFDUHDFHUXWV DLE XQU VSXQVSkQ ODRUHOHGLQ]LXDXUP WRDUH
3UHOXDUHDSXWHULLGHF WUHJHQHUDOXO,RQ$QWRQHVFXSULQWURORYLWXU GHVWDWDDWUDVGXS VLQHPRGLILF ULLPSRUWDQWHvQFHHDFHSULYHúWHIRUPD GH JXYHUQ PkQW QRXO UHJH 0LKDL , U PkQkQG GRDU FX DWULEX LL RQRULILFHLJQRUDWHGHVHRULGHF WUHQRXOÄFRQGXF WRUDOVWDWXOXL´FDUHD OLPLWDWGLQFHvQFHPDLPXOWUROXOPRQDUKLHL ÌQ FDGUXO QRXOXL JXYHUQ FRQVWLWXLW OD VHSWHPEULH GXS QHJRFLHULGLILFLOHúLFXLPSRUWDQWHVXJHVWLLJHUPDQHDXLQWUDWUH SUH]HQWDQ LDL* U]LLGH)LHU PDMRULWDWHD PLOLWDULFLYLOLQHDQJDMD LSROLWLF úL WHKQLFLHQL DL SULQFLSDOHORU SDUWLGH SROLWLFH EXUJKH]H &RQFRPLWHQW 5RPkQLD D IRVW SURFODPDW ÄVWDW QD LRQDOOHJLRQDU´ vQ FDGUXO F UXLD ,RQ $QWRQHVFX HUD ÄFRQGXF WRUXO VWDWXOXL´ úL úHIXO ÄUHJLPXOXL OHJLRQDU´ LDU +RULD 6LPD ÄFRQGXF WRUXO PLúF ULL OHJLRQDUH´ $VWIHO VD RILFLDOL]DW XQ QRXUHJLPGLFWDWRULDO OHJLRQDURDQWRQHVFLDQDF UXLED] SROLWLF DIRVW UHSUH]HQWDW GH*DUGDGH)LHU 'HYHQLW VLQJXU SDUWLG GH JXYHUQ PkQW úL WRW VLQJXUXO FDUH DYHD GUHSWXOV DFWLYH]HOHJDO*DUGDGH)LHUDSUHOXDWVXEFRQWUROúLRSDUWHGLQ DSDUDWXO GH VWDW GHYHQLQG ED]D SROLWLF D UHJLPXOXL FRQGXV GH ,RQ
1RXOUHJHDGHSXVMXU PkQWXOODVHSWHPEULH RUHOHvQ3DODWXO 5HJDO vQ SUH]HQ D OXL ,RQ $QWRQHVFX D SDWULDUKXOXL 1LFRGLP 0XQWHDQX úL D SULPXOXLSUHúHGLQWHDOÌQDOWHL&XU LGH&DVD LHúL-XVWL LH'*K/XSX ,QVWDODUHDRILFLDO DQRXOXLUHJH0LKDL,DIRVWI FXW ODVHSWHPEULH vQ DIDUD FHUHPRQLDOXOXL RELúQXLW FX DFHO SULOHM VWDELOLQGXVH úL R QRX IRUPXO GHMXU PkQW Ä-XUFUHGLQ 1D LXQLLURPkQH-XUV S ]HVFFXVILQ HQLH OHJLOHVWDWXOXL-XUV S ]HVFúLV DS UILLQ DVWDWXOXLúLLQWHJULWDWHDWHULWRULXOXL 5RPkQLHL $úD V PL DMXWH 'XPQH]HX´ Ä7LPSXO´ GLQ VHSWHPEULH 'XS GH D VSRULW SULQWUXQ QRX GHFUHW DWULEXWHOH OXL ,RQ $QWRQHVFX´ UHJHOH 0LKDL,DU PDVGRDUFXXUP WRDUHOHSUHURJDWLYH FDSDORúWLULL GUHSWXOGHDEDWH PRQHG FRQIHULUHDGHGHFRUD LLURPkQH SULPLUHDúLDFUHGLWDUHDGHDPEDVDGRUL úL PLQLúWUL SOHQLSRWHQ LDUL QXPLUHD SULPXOXL PLQLVWUX vQV UFLQDW FX GHSOLQH SXWHUL GUHSWGHDPQLVWLHúLJUD LHUH ,RQ$QWRQHVFXvQGHSOLQHDIXQF LLOHGHSULPPLQLVWUXúLGHPLQLVWUXDO $S U ULL 1D LRQDOH LDU +RULD 6LPD IXQF LD GH YLFHSUHúHGLQWH DO 3UHúHGLQ LHL &RQVLOLXOXLGH0LQLúWUL ,QL LDO ,RQ $QWRQHVFX D GRULW XQ JXYHUQ GH ÄXQLXQH QD LRQDO ´ FRQVWLWXLW GLQ UHSUH]HQWDQ L DL SDUWLGHORU SROLWLFH GHPRFUDWLFH DFHúWLD VDX GHFODUDWvQV vQÄRSR]L LH´ úLDL* U]LLGH)LHU DGRULWV GRPLQHJXYHUQXOúL FKLDUV FRQGXF VLQJXU ÌQLVWRULRJUDILDURPkQ QRXOUHJLPDIRVWFDUDFWHUL]DWvQGLYHUVHPR GXUL ÄGLFWDWXU IDVFLVW ´ÄGLFWDWXU PLOLWDU IDVFLVW ´ÄGLFWDWXU DQWRQHVFLDQ ´ ÄUHJLPDQWRQHVFLDQ´HWF
$QWRQHVFX ÌQFHUFkQG V úL H[WLQG LQIOXHQ D SULQ GHPDJRJLH VRFLDO úL QD LRQDO OHJLRQDULL DX DSOLFDW WHURDUHD FD SROLWLF GH VWDW DX RUJDQL]DW IRUPD LXQLSDUDPLOLWDUH DXFRPLVFULPHvPSRWULYDDGYHUVDULORUSROLWLFL LQGLIHUHQWGHRULHQWDUHSROLWLF úLQXQXPDL SULQWUHQXPHURDVHOHYLFWLPH QXP UkQGXVHVDYDQWXO1LFRODH,RUJDúLHFRQRPLVWXO9LUJLO0DGJHDUXúD úLFKLDUPDVDFUHvQPDV &RQFRPLWHQWDXGHFODQúDWWHURDUHDvPSRWULYD HYUHLORU vQ FDGUXO SROLWLFLL DQWLVHPLWH vQVFULLQGXVH úL P VXULOH GH URPkQL]DUHDSHUVRQDOXOXLGLQvQWUHSULQGHUL /D UkQGXL ,RQ$QWRQHVFXDLQWHU]LVPDQLIHVWD LLOHúLvQWUXQLULOHD GHVILLQ DW GHPQLWDWHD GH FRQVLOLHU UHJDO úL &RQVLOLXO GH &RURDQ VHSWHPEULH RUJDQL]D LD 6WUDMD ULL VHSWHPEULH 3DUWLGXO 1D LXQLL úL J U]LOH DFHVWXLD VHSWHPEULH EUHVOHOH D GHFUHWDW FRQWUROXO DYHULORU IRúWLORUGHPQLWDULDLVWDWXOXLGLQXOWLPLLDQL VHSWHPEULH DPLOLWDUL]DW vQWUHSULQGHULOH GH VWDW úL SDUWLFXODUH D LQWURGXV OHJL IRDUWH DVSUH SHQWUX QHVXERUGRQDUH D LPSXV GRPLFLOLX REOLJDWRULX SHQWUX QXPHURDVH SHUVRQDOLW LSROLWLFHúLPLOLWDUH ÌQILQDOvQFHUFDUHDJHQHUDOXOXL,RQ$QWRQHVFXGHDUHDOL]DRDOLDQ FX OHJLRQDULL SH FDUH D YUXW V úLL VXERUGRQH]H D HúXDW OXSWD SHQWUX SXWHUH GXFkQG OD GLYHUJHQ H úL DSRL OD FRQIOLFW DUPDW vQWUH úL LDQXDULH FkQGUHEHOLXQHDOHJLRQDU DIRVWUHSULPDW FXDMXWRUXO DUPDWHL úL FX DSUREDUHD JHUPDQLORU ÌQ WLPSXO DFHORU WUDJLFH
Ä5 ]OH LL´&RUSXOPXQFLWRUHVFOHJLRQDU$MXWRUXOOHJLRQDU9HVWLWRULL FHUFXO VWXGHQ HVF &RQFRPLWHQW SROL LD OHJLRQDU VH VXSUDSXQHD FX SROL LD VWDWXOXL ÌQQRDSWHDGHVSUHQRLHPEULH PDLPXOWHHFKLSHGHOHJLRQDUL DX XFLV OD vQFKLVRDUHD -LODYD GH GH LQX L SULQWUH FDUH VDX DIODW JHQHUDOXO *KHRUJKH $UJHúDQX IRVW SULPPLQLVWUX 9LFWRU ,DPDQGL IRVW PLQLVWUX GH -XVWL LH JHQHUDOXO*DEULHO0DULQHVFX IRVWSUHIHFWDO3ROL LHL&DSLWDOHLúLPLQLVWUX GH,QWHUQH JHQHUDOXO,RQ%HQJOLX IRVWLQVSHFWRUJHQHUDODO-DQGDUPHULHL 0LKDLO 0RUX]RY IRVWGLUHFWRUDO6HUYLFLXOXL6HFUHWGH,QIRUPD LL úD ÌQDFHVWVHQVODVHSWHPEULH DPRGLILFDW&RGXO-XVWL LHL0LOLWDUH ÌQFHHDFHSULYHúWHUROXOGH LQXWvQVWDWPHWRGHOHúLULWPXOGHLPSX QHUHDSROLWLFLL ,QL LDOOHJLRQDULLDXvQFHUFDWV GHVI úRDUHDFWLYLW LúLvQFDGUXODUPDWHL EHQHILFLLQG vQ DFHVW VHQV GH SR]L LD IDYRUDELO D JHQHUDOXOXL ,RQ $QWRQHVFX ÌQ PRPHQWXO vQ FDUH úLD GDW VHDPD F DFHúWLD XUP UHDX FX WRWXO DOWH VFRSXUL ,RQ $QWRQHVFXDRUGRQDWOD RFWRPEULH Ä&LQHHVWHvQDUPDW U PkQHDFROR úLFLQHHVWHODFXLEOHJLRQDU±QQODIHO$UPDWDWUHEXLHV VHPHQ LQ vQVSLULWXO RVW úHVF´ &D XUPDUH VDX OXDW P VXUL SHQWUX VWRSDUHD LQILOWU ULL SURSDJDQGHL OHJLRQDUHvQRúWLUHP VXUDILLQGDFFHSWDW úLGHPLOLWDULFDUHIXVHVHU úLHLPDUWRULL
HYHQLPHQWHDXIRVWDVDVLQD LúLU QL LVXWHGHFHW HQL PXO LHYUHLGDUúL PLOLWDUL ÌQO WXUDW GHODFRQGXFHUHDVWDWXOXL*DUGDGH)LHUDvQFHWDWV PDL ILH R RUJDQL]D LH SROLWLF PXO L OHJLRQDUL IXJLQG vQ *HUPDQLD VDX ILLQG DUHVWD L MXGHFD L úL FRQGDPQD L OD vQFKLVRDUH SH GLIHULWH WHUPHQH GLQ GLVSR]L LDJHQHUDOXOXL,RQ$QWRQHVFX0XO LGLQWUHDXWRULLDVDVLQDWHORUGLQ QRLHPEULH DXIRVWFRQGDPQD LODPRDUWH vQSRILGDVIDWXULORUGDWHGH F WUHJHUPDQL ùHILLOHJLRQDULvQWUHFDUHúL+RULD6LPDVDXUHIXJLDWFX VSULMLQXO%HUOLQXOXLvQ*HUPDQLDILLQGIRORVL LFDÄIRU GHUH]HUY ´ID GH,RQ$QWRQHVFX /D LDQXDULH I U V FRQVXOWH SH UHJHOH 0LKDL , ,RQ $QWRQHVFX D LQVWLWXLW XQ QRX JXYHUQ IRUPDW GLQ PLOLWDUL úL FLYLOL XQLYHUVLWDULVDXIXQF LRQDULGHFDULHU QHvQUHJLPHQWD LSROLWLF SUHOXkQG LQWHJUDOSXWHUHDvQVWDWúLFRQWLQXkQGV LDVLQJXUGHFL]LLOHLPSRUWDQWHvQ VSHFLDOvQSUREOHPHGHSROLWLF H[WHUQ &RQFRPLWHQWDQXPLWQRLSUHIHF L GLQUkQGXOPLOLWDULORULDUODIHEUXDULH DDEURJDWGHFUHWXOGLQ VHSWHPEULH SULQ FDUH 5RPkQLD IXVHVH SURFODPDW ÄVWDW QD LRQDO OHJLRQDU´ 1LFL GH DFHDVW GDW QX D SHUPLV IXQF LRQDUHD OHJDO D SDUWL GHORU SROLWLFH GHPRFUDWLFH $ FRQWLQXDW V DFWLYH]H OHJDO GRDU *UXSXO (WQLFJHUPDQGLQ5RPkQLDUHFXQRVFXWFDSHUVRDQ MXULGLF ODQRLHP EULH úL VWUXFWXUD SROLWLF D DFHVWXLD 3DUWLGXO 0XQFLWRUHVF 1D LRQDO 6RFLDOLVW *HUPDQ DPEHOH FRQGXVH GH $QGUHDV 6FKPLGW QXPLW GH F WUH JXYHUQXOGHOD%HUOLQ
QXPHURDVHORUDEX]XULFRPLVHGHOHJLRQDULFDUHDVDVLQDVHU FKLDUSHXQLLJHQHUDOL úLRIL HULVXSHULRULÌQDFHVWFRQWH[WvQLDQXDULH DUPDWDDU VSXQVI U H]LWDUH ODRUGLQXOJHQHUDOXOXL,RQ$QWRQHVFXGHDUHSULPDUHEHOLXQHDúLDDQLKLODWHQWDWLYH * U]LL GH )LHU GH D SUHOXD SXWHUHD WRWDO vQ VWDW ÌQ DFHVW FRQIOLFW DUPDW VDX vQUHJLVWUDWGHPRU LúLGHU QL LGLQWUHPLOLWDUL ,VWRULDPLOLWDU DSRSRUXOXL URPkQ9,SS 'DF 66XO D SUHIHUDW SH OHJLRQDUL +LWOHU úL :HKUPDFKWXO VDX VLWXDWGHSDUWHDJHQHUDOXOXL,RQ$QWRQHVFXSHUFHSXWOD%HUOLQFDILLQGVLQJXUXO vQ VWDUH V DVLJXUH OLQLúWHD vQ 5RPkQLD H[WUHP GH QHFHVDU SHQWUX vPSOLQLUHD RELHFWLYHORUPLOLWDUHúLHFRQRPLFHGHPRPHQW U ]ERLXOvPSRWULYD*UHFLHL úL GH SHUVSHFWLY DWDFDUHD 8QLXQLL 6RYLHWLFH DOH 5HLFKXOXL &X WRDWH DFHVWHD JHUPDQLLQXDXDEDQGRQDWSHOHJLRQDULGXS vQIUkQJHUHDUHEHOLXQLL+RULD6LPD úL DO L FRQGXF WRUL DL * U]LL GH )LHU J VLQGXúL UHIXJLX vQ *HUPDQLD XQGH DX IRVWIRORVL LDSRLFDPLMORFGHSUHVLXQHvPSRWULYDOXL,RQ$QWRQHVFX
ÌQO WXUDUHDOHJLRQDULORUGHODSXWHUHúLFRQVWLWXLUHDQRXOXLJXYHUQDX IRVW SULYLWH IDYRUDELO GH RSLQLD SXEOLF úL GH OLGHULL SDUWLGHORU SROLWLFH GHPRFUDWLFHFDUHDXGHFODUDWF YRUGDQRXOXL([HFXWLYúLJHQHUDOXOXL $QWRQHVFX ÄFHO PDL GHV YkUúLW FRQFXUV WHKQLF´ I U D SDUWLFLSD vQV OD JXYHUQDUH&RQFRPLWHQWDWkW&,&%U WLDQXFkWúL,XOLX0DQLXDXFHUXW GHVHRUL OXL ,RQ $QWRQHVFX V VH UHYLQ OD UHJLPXO SDUODPHQWDU úL V VH SHUPLW UHOXDUHDDFWLYLW LLSDUWLGHORUSROLWLFHvQPRGOHJDO ÌQ FDGUXO UHJLPXOXL SHUVRQDO GH WLS WRWDOLWDUGLFWDWRULDO ÄFRQGXF WRUXO VWDWXOXL´ D FRQWLQXDW V LQWHU]LF GHVI úXUDUHD YLH LL SROLWLFH VXE DPHQLQ DUHDXQRUDSULJHVDQF LXQL±SkQ ODDQLPXQF VLOQLF OLGHULL SULQFLSDOHORU SDUWLGH SROLWLFH ,XOLX 0DQLX úL &,&%U WLDQX FX SUHF GHUH EHQHILFLLQG WRWXúL GH R DQXPLW OLEHUWDWH GH DF LXQH LQWHUQ GDU úL H[WHUQ /D UkQGXOH DFHúWLD DX VSULMLQLW vQ DQXPLWH PRPHQWH DFWLYLWDWHD JXYHUQDPHQWDO H[SULPkQGXúL GHVHRUL GH]DFRUGXO ID GH XQHOH GHFL]LL vQ VSHFLDO vQ FHHD FH SULYHúWH PRGDOLW LOH GH JXYHUQDUH úL UDSRUWXULOHHFRQRPLFHFX*HUPDQLD 'HYHQLW FHO PDL LPSRUWDQW RP vQ VWDW ,RQ $QWRQHVFX LQYHVWLW FX GHPQLWDWHDGHPDUHúDODO5RPkQLHLODDXJXVW DJXYHUQDWvQPRG DXWRULWDUGLFWDWRULDO GHFL]LLOH VDOH QHSXWkQG IL MXGHFDWH VDX FHQ]XUDWH ÌQ WLPSXOSDUWLFLS ULL5RPkQLHLODU ]ERL vQSHULRDGHOHvQFDUH ,RQ$QWRQHVFXVDDIODWSHIURQWÄDWULEX LLOHFRQGXFHULLJXYHUQXOXL´DXIRVW H[HUFLWDWHGHF WUH0LKDL$QWRQHVFXQXPLWYLFHSUHúHGLQWHDO&RQVLOLXOXL GH0LQLúWUL ,RQ$QWRQHVFXDSURPRYDWRGXU SROLWLF DQWLVHPLW &KLDUGDF QX D IRVW DGRSWDW ÄVROX LD ILQDO ´ H[WHUPLQDUHD HYUHLORU FHUXW GH +LWOHU HYUHLL DX VXIHULW úL DX PXULW DWkW vQ 5RPkQLD IRVWXO 5HJDW FkW úL PDL DOHV vQ %DVDUDELD %XFRYLQD úL 7UDQVQLVWULD vQ XOWLPD SURYLQFLH ILLQG H[SXO]D L vQ WRDPQD DQXOXL FLUFD GH HYUHL GLQ %DVDUDELD %XFRYLQDúLQRUGXO0ROGRYHL ) U DDQXODUHVSRQVDELOLWDWHDFHORUFDUH DX FRQWULEXLW OD DFHVWH IDSWH UHSUREDELOH úL DOWHOH PDL JUDYH LQFOXVLY
/D IHEUXDULH &,& %U WLDQX FRQVLGHUD F IRUPXOD QRXOXL H[HFXWLYFRQVWLWXLDÄFHDPDLEXQ VROX LHFHVHSXWHDGDFUL]HLDFWXDOH´F ,RQ $QWRQHVFXHUDÄVLQJXUXOFDUHSRDWHJXYHUQD DUDvQFRQGL LLOHH[WHUQHúLLQWHUQH GH DVW ]L ÌL GDWRU P WRW FRQFXUVXO FHO SXWHP GD vQGHSOLQLQGXQH R GDWRULH SDWULRWLF ´2SR]L LHDVHP Q WRDUHDDYXW,XOLX0DQLX $XFRQVLGHUDWF 5RPkQLDHUDR DU RFXSDW GH*HUPDQLD
XFLGHUL VH LPSXQH D IL SUHFL]DW IDSWXO F vQ SHULRDGD XQHOH DXWRULW LúLLQVWLWX LLURPkQHDXFRQWULEXLWODVDOYDUHDDPLLGHHYUHLGLQ QRUGXO7UDQVLOYDQLHLRFXSDWHGH8QJDULDvQ ([WUHPGHGXUDIRVWúLUHJLPXOPXQFLLSHQWUXWR LORFXLWRULL ULLOD PDL LQVWLWXLQGXVH FDWHJRULD VDODULD LORU ÄPRELOL]D L SH ORF´ SUHFXPúLSUDFWLFDUHFKL]L LRQ ULORUSHQWUXPXQF GLQUkQGXOSHUVRDQHORU FDUH QX DYHDX REOLJD LL PLOLWDUH FRQFRPLWHQW VDX OXDW P VXUL GUDVWLFH SHQWUX FRPEDWHUHD VDERWDMHORU HFRQRPLFH úL D VSHFXOHL LQFOXVLY SHQWUX UHSULPDUHDDGYHUVDULORUSROLWLFL 5HJLPXOSROLWLFWRWDOLWDU GLQSHULRDGDDXJXVW GHFHPEULH /D DXJXVW vQWUXQ FRQWH[W SROLWLFRPLOLWDU GUDPDWLF GHWHUPLQDW GH vQIUkQJHULOH vQUHJLVWUDWH SH IURQW SULQWUXQ PDUH DFW GH FXUDMUHJHOH0LKDL,vQvQ HOHJHUHFXRODUJ FRDOL LHGHIRU HSROLWLFHúLFX UHSUH]HQWDQ LDLDUPDWHLDRUGRQDWDUHVWDUHDPDUHúDOXOXL,RQ$QWRQHVFX FRQVWLWXLUHD XQXL QRX JXYHUQ GHPRFUDWLF úL WUHFHUHD 5RPkQLHL GH SDUWHD 1D LXQLORU8QLWH$FWXODFRQVROLGDWSR]L LDPRQDUKLHLFHOSX LQGLQSXQFW GHYHGHUHPRUDOúLDI FXWV VHUHYLQ ODPRQDUKLDFRQVWLWX LRQDO úLOD UHJLPXOGHPRFUDWLF SHQWUXIRDUWHSX LQWLPSvQV 'HFUHWXOGLQDXJXVW D UHSXV vQ YLJRDUH &RQVWLWX LD GLQ SUHY ]kQG F SXWHUHD OHJLVODWLY V ILH H[HUFLWDW GH F WUH UHJH SkQ OD RUJDQL]DUHD 5HSUH]HQWDQ HL1D LRQDOH 5HOXkQGXúLDFWLYLWDWHD vQOHJDOLWDWH SDUWLGHOHSROLWLFHDXDF LRQDW vQ FRQVHQV vQF GLQ LXQLH 3DUWLGXO 1D LRQDO U QHVF 3DUWLGXO 1D LRQDO /LEHUDO 3DUWLGXO &RPXQLVW GLQ 5RPkQ úL 3DUWLGXO 6RFLDO 'HPRFUDWFRQVWLWXLVHU %ORFXO1D LRQDO'HPRFUDWFXSULQFLSDODPLVLXQH GHDSUHJ WLWUHFHUHD ULLGHSDUWHD1D LXQLORU8QLWHúLGHDvQO WXUDGHOD SXWHUHSHJHQHUDOXO,RQ$QWRQHVFX vQFHHDFHSULYHúWHVXV LQHUHDHIRUWXOXL GHU ]ERLDQWLKLWOHULVWvQFDGUXOF UXLDHOLEHUDUHDS U LLGHQRUGYHVWD ULL RFXSDW GH8QJDULDvQ UHSUH]HQWDRELHFWLYXOSULQFLSDOúLSHQWUXvQGH SOLQLUHDSUHYHGHULORU&RQYHQ LHLGHDUPLVWL LXGLQVHSWHPEULH
'LQX&*LXUHVFX5RPkQLDvQDOGRLOHDU ]ERLPRQGLDO %XFXUHúWL
&RQFRPLWHQW VD GHFODQúDW R DSULJ OXSW SROLWLF SHQWUX FXFHULUHD SXWHULLvQFDUHIRU HOHGHVWkQJDvQIUXQWHFXSDUWLGXOFRPXQLVWVXV LQXWH GH IRU HOH GH RFXSD LH VRYLHWLFH DX FRQVWLWXLW R QRX DOLDQ SROLWLF ± )URQWXO1D LRQDO'HPRFUDWLF/DPDUWLH VXESUHVLXQHVRYLHWLF VD UHXúLWV VHLPSXQ JXYHUQXOGU3HWUX*UR]DvQFDUHFRPXQLúWLLDYHDXXQ URO GHFLVLY 0 VXULOH DGRSWDWH vQ SHULRDGD FDUH D XUPDW DX I FXW FD VSHUDQ DSRSRUXOXLURPkQGHDWU LvQGHPRFUD LHV QXVHvPSOLQHDVF 3HQWUXSRSRUXOURPkQDXUPDWXQDGLQFHOHPDLJUHOHSHULRDGHGLQ LVWRULDVD ÌQ SRILGD PDULL PDQLIHVWD LL DQWLJXYHUQDPHQWDOH GLQ QRLHPEULH D DOWRU DF LXQL DQWLFRPXQLVWH úL DQWLVRYLHWLFH SUHFXP úL D GHFODQú ULL0LúF ULL1D LRQDOHGH5H]LVWHQ FRPXQLúWLLURPkQLLPSXúLOD SXWHUHDXSUHOXDWWUHSWDWFRQGXFHUHDvQVWDWLPSXQkQGRVHULHGHP VXUL FDUH DX SUHJ WLW VFKLPEDUHD UDGLFDO D IRUPHL GH JXYHUQ PkQW úL D UHJLPXOXL SROLWLF IDOVLILFDUHD DOHJHULORU GLQ QRLHPEULH vQILLQ DUHD ÄRILFLLORULQGXVWULDOH´FDUHvQUHDOLWDWHUHSUH]HQWDXPLMORDFHGHvQGUXPDUH DDFWLYLW LLHFRQRPLFHDWkWvQVHFWRUXOGHVWDWFkWúLvQFHOSDUWLFXODU PDL vQJU GLUHD DFWLYLW LL SDUWLGHORU EXUJKH]H úL vQWHPQL DUHD FDGUHORU GHED] GHVILLQ DUHD3DUWLGXOXL1D LRQDO U QHVF LXOLH vQXUPD vQFHUF ULLOXL,RQ0LKDODFKHGHDS U VL DUDLXOLH úLGHDFRQVWLWXL XQJXYHUQvQH[LO vQDXJXVW &RQVWDQWLQ,&%U WLDQXDIRVWREOLJDW V VXVSHQGH DFWLYLWDWHD SDUWLGXOXL 1D LRQDO/LEHUDO UHIRUPD PRQHWDU DXJXVW HOLPLQDUHD XOWLPLORU UHSUH]HQWDQ L DL SDUWLGHORU EXUJKH]HGLQJXYHUQ JUXSDUHDOLEHUDO FRQGXV GH*KHRUJKH7 W UHVFX OD QRLHPEULH IDSW FDUH D I FXW FD vQ ([HFXWLY V U PkQ GRDU UHSUH]HQWDQ LDLSDUWLGXOXLFRPXQLVWúLDLDOLD LORUV L vQJU GLUHDDFWLYLW LL UHJHOXL0LKDL,úLvQILQDOREOLJDUHDDFHVWXLDGHDDEGLFDODGHFHPEULH PRQDUKLD ILLQG DVWIHO DEROLW úL LQVWDXUDW R QRX IRUP GH JXYHUQDUH±5HSXEOLFD3RSXODU 5RPkQLDILLQGSkQ DWXQFLVLQJXUD DU GLQVIHUDGHLQIOXHQ RFXSD LHVRYLHWLF vQFDUHPDLH[LVWDPRQDUKLD 5HJLPXOVRFLDOLVWWRWDOLWDUFRPXQLVW 3UHOXDUHD vQWUHJLL SXWHUL SROLWLFH vQ VWDW GH F WUH SDUWLGXO FRPXQLVW vQIHEUXDULH FkQGDDYXWORFúL&RQJUHVXOGHXQLILFDUHD3DUWLGXOXL &RPXQLVW 5RPkQ FX 3DUWLGXO 6RFLDO'HPRFUDW UH]XOWkQG 3DUWLGXO
0XQFLWRUHVF5RPkQFDUHvQ DOXDWGHQXPLUHDGH3DUWLGXO&RPXQLVW 5RPkQ úLVFKLPEDUHDUHJLPXOXLSROLWLFDXIRVWXUPDWHGHDGRSWDUHDXQHL QRL &RQVWLWX LL DSULOLH SULQ FDUH VD UHQXQ DW OD SULQFLSLXO GHPRFUDWLFDOVHSDU ULLSXWHULORUvQVWDWvQWUHDJDSXWHUHILLQGH[HUFLWDW GH 0DUHD$GXQDUH1D LRQDO &RQFRPLWHQW &RQVWLWX LD D FRQVILQ LW QRXD IRUP GH VWDW úL GH JXYHUQ PkQW ± 5HSXEOLFD ± úL QRXO FRQ LQXW DO SXWHULL SUHY ]kQG F 5HSXEOLFD 3RSXODU 5RPkQ ± QRXD GHQXPLUH D VWDWXOXL ± HUD ÄXQ VWDW SRSXODUXQLWDUúLVXYHUDQ´vQFDUHvQWUHDJDSXWHUHHPDQDÄGHODSRSRU´úL DSDU LQHDÄSRSRUXOXL´DSURFODPDWGUHSWXULúLOLEHUW LFHW HQHúWLFDUHvQ FHDPDLPDUHSDUWHQXDXIRVWDSOLFDWH )RUPDUHD JXYHUQXOXL ± RUJDQXO VXSUHP H[HFXWLY ± D GHYHQLW DWULEXWXO0DULL$GXQ UL1D LRQDOHvQID DF UHLDDFHVWDHUDUHVSRQVDELOvQ SHULRDGDGLQWUHVHVLXQLSXWHUHDILLQGH[HUFLWDW GHXQ3UH]LGLXPDOHVSH DQLSUHúHGLQ LLDFHVWXLDILLQGVXFFHVLYDFDG&RQVWDQWLQ,3DUKRQ ± GU3HWUX*UR]D ± úL,RQ*KHRUJKH0DXUHU ± 3XWHUHDRUJDQL]DUHDMXGHF WRUHDVF HUDDOF WXLW GLQ&XUWHDVXSUH P FXU LWULEXQDOHúLOXFUXQRXMXGHF WRULLSRSXODUHFRQWURODWHúLHOHGH F WUH0DUHD$GXQDUH1D LRQDO 7RW vQ SUHPLHU &RQVWLWX LD GLQ D FUHDW SRVLELOLWDWHD H[SURSULHULORU úL D OLFKLG ULL SURSULHW LL FDSLWDOLVWH SULQ WUHFHUHD vQ SURSULHWDWHDVWDWXOXLDPLMORDFHORUGHSURGXF LHE QFLORUSURSULHW LORUGH DVLJXUDUHHWF &RQFRPLWHQW vQ QRXO FDGUX SROLWLFRVWDWDO VD WUHFXW úL OD UHRUJD QL]DUHD DSDUDWXOXL GH VWDW vQ DXJXVW GHVILLQ kQGXVH RUJDQHOH GH 6LJXUDQ úL vQILLQ kQGXVH DSRL 6HFXULWDWHD DXJXVW FDUH D GHVI úXUDWRVXV LQXW DFWLYLWDWHDUHSUHVLY vPSRWULYDRSRQHQ LORUQRXOXLUHJLP FDUHDXIRVWDUHVWD LMXGHFD LVDXQXúLFRQGDPQD LODDQLJUHLGHWHPQL FHD PDL PDUH SDUWH GLQWUH HL ILLQG QHYLQRYD L DWULEX LLOH UHSUHVLYH DOH 6HFXULW LLúLDOHDSDUDWXOXLGHVWDWDXIRVWGLPLQXDWHWUHSWDWvQ ILLQG HOLEHUD LSULQWURODUJ DPQLVWLHXOWLPLLGH LQX LSROLWLFL XOWHULRUWHURDUHD DVXSUDRSRQHQ LORUUHJLPXOXLFRPXQLVWDYHDV VHLQWHQVLILFHGLQQRX /D VFXUW WLPS vQ LDQXDULH -DQGDUPHULD úL 3ROL LD DX IRVW vQORFXLWHGHF WUH0LOL LD3RSXODU ÌQVHSWHPEULH DXDS UXWQRXW L úL vQ FHHD FH SULYHúWH vPS U LUHD DGPLQLVWUDWLY WHULWRULDO WHULWRULXO ULL ILLQGvPS U LWvQUHJLXQLUDLRDQHúLFRPXQH vQIHEUXDULH UHJLXQLOHúL
UDLRDQHOH DYHDX V ILH GHVILLQ DWH úL vQORFXLWH FX MXGH H SOXV 0XQLFLSLXO %XFXUHúWL vQ VDvQILLQ DWúL6HFWRUXO$JULFRO,OIRY 6FKLPE ULOHUDGLFDOHLQWHUYHQLWHvQUHJLPXOXLSROLWLFúLvQVRFLHWDWHD URPkQHDVF DX I FXW FD OD VHSWHPEULH V ILH DGRSWDW R QRX &RQVWLWX LHFDUHDFRQVDFUDWSHQWUXSULPDGDW UROXOFRQGXF WRUvQVWDWDO XQXLSDUWLGSROLWLF±3DUWLGXO0XQFLWRUHVF5RPkQ'HIDSWWUHSWDWWUHSWDW DFHVWD DYHD V U PkQ VLQJXUXO SDUWLG GLQ 5RPkQLD vQ SHULRDGD FHOHODOWH IRUPD LXQL SROLWLFH vQFHWkQGXúL DFWLYLWDWHD WUHFkQGXVH OD VLVWHPXO PRQRSDUWLGLVW SkQ OD VIkUúLWXO DQXOXL FkQG 5HYROX LD URPkQ DSHUPLVUHYHQLUHDODVLVWHPXOGHPRFUDWLFSOXULSDUWLG 'RULQG V úL LPSXQ FkW PDL UHSHGH SR]L LD vQ VWDW úL V RE LQ vQFUHGHUHDWRWDO DJXYHUQXOXLVRYLHWLFRUJDQHOHGHFRQGXFHUHGHSDUWLGúL GHVWDWURPkQHDXDFFHSWDWvQ DU SUH]HQ DDPLLGHFRQVLOLHULVRYLHWLFLúL DJHQ L1.9'úLDXGHVI úXUDWRLQWHQV DFWLYLWDWHUHSUHVLY vPSRWULYD FHORU FDUH OL VH RSXQHDX VDX QX OH DJUHDX SROLWLFD DUHVWkQG MXGHFkQG vQWUH LQkQG vQ UHJLP GH H[WHUPLQDUH ]HFL GH PLL GH RDPHQL PXO L QHYLQRYD L IRúWLOLGHULDLSDUWLGHORUSROLWLFHúLJHQHUDOLDLDUPDWHLURPkQH HSLVFRSL FDWROLFL LQWHOHFWXDOL HWF GHSRUWkQG vQ % U JDQ ]HFL GH PLL GH HWQLFLJHUPDQLúLVkUELDUHVWkQGFLUFDGH UDQLFDUHUHIX]DXV VH vQVFULHvQ*RVSRG ULLOH$JULFROH&ROHFWLYH DOWH]HFLGHPLLGHSHUVRDQH DX IRVW UHHGXFDWH SULQ PXQF IRU DW ÌQ SRILGD P VXULORU UHSUHVLYH URPkQLL DX GHVI úXUDW R VXV LQXW PLúFDUH GH UH]LVWHQ DQWLFRPXQLVW úL DQWLVRYLHWLF DúWHSWkQG DMXWRUXO RFFLGHQWDOLORU FDUH D LQFOXV úL OXSWD DUPDW vQPXQ LUHSULPDW vQV SkQ vQ ÌQ WRW DFHVW WLPS OXSWD SHQWUX SXWHUH D GHYHQLW R FRQVWDQW vQ FRQGXFHUHD 3DUWLGXOXL 0XQFLWRUHVF 5RPkQ vQ VSHFLDO vQ GHFHQLXO VXFFHVLY ILLQG HOLPLQDW JUXSXO $QD 3DXNHU ± 9DVLOH /XFD ± 7HRKDUL *HRUJHVFX XFLV /XFUH LX 3 WU úFDQX úL vQO WXUD L 0LURQ &RQVWDQWLQHVFXúL,RVLI&KLúLQHYVFKL &RQVROLGkQGXúL SXWHUHD úL UHXúLQG V GHWHUPLQH SH VRYLHWLFL V úL UHWUDJ WUXSHOH GLQ DU LQFOXVLY FRQVLOLHULL PLOLWDUL 5RPkQLD ILLQG GLQ DFHVW SXQFW GH YHGHUH VLQJXUD DU GLQ VLVWHPXO VRFLDOLVW *KHRUJKH *KHRUJKLX'HMI U V UHIRUPH]HvQYUHXQIHOUHJLPXOLQWHUQDGHFODQúDW SURFHVXO GH GHVSULQGHUH GLQ RUELWD 0RVFRYHL RSXQkQGXVH SROLWLFLL GH LQWHJUDUHHFRQRPLF SURPRYDW GH16+UXúFLRY
,RDQ6FXUWX,VWRULDFRQWHPSRUDQ D5RPkQLHL (GLWXUD )XQGD LHL5RPkQLDGH0kLQH%XFXUHúWL
,QWHUHVH SROLWLFH úL GH VWDW DX GHWHUPLQDW OD PDUWLH PRGLILFDUHD&RQVWLWX LHLORFXO3UH]LGLXOXL0DULL$GXQ UL1D LRQDOHILLQG OXDWGH&RQVLOLXOGH6WDWFDRUJDQVXSUHPDOSXWHULLGHVWDWFXDFWLYLWDWH SHUPDQHQW VXERUGRQDW0DULL$GXQ UL1D LRQDOH)XQF LDGHSUHúHGLQWH DODFHVWHLVWUXFWXULDIRVWvQFUHGLQ DW OXL*KHRUJKH*KHRUJKLX'HMSULP VHFUHWDUDO&RPLWHWXOXL&HQWUDODO3DUWLGXOXL0XQFLWRUHVF5RPkQSkQ vQ PDUWLH FkQG vQ XUPD GHFHVXOXL DFHVWXLD IXQF LLOH vQ SDUWLG PDUWLH úLvQVWDWDXIRVWSUHOXDWHGHF WUH1LFRODH&HDXúHVFX 8OWHULRU OD DXJXVW vQ XUPD PRGLILF ULORU LQWHUYHQLWH vQ YLD DVRFLDOSROLWLF D ULLFDXUPDUHDvQFKHLHULLSURFHVXOXLGHFRRSHUD WLYL]DUHDDJULFXOWXULL PDUWLH D'HFODUD LHL&RPLWHWXOXL&HQWUDODO 3DUWLGXOXL 0XQFLWRUHVF 5RPkQ GLQ DSULOLH HWF 0DUHD $GXQDUH 1D LRQDO DDGRSWDWRQRX &RQVWLWX LHFDUHDSUHY ]XWF vQ5HSXEOLFD 6RFLDOLVW 5RPkQLD ± QRXD GHQXPLUH D ULL ± ÄIRU D SROLWLF FRQGXF WRDUH´HUDUHSUH]HQWDW GH3DUWLGXO&RPXQLVW5RPkQ0RGLILFDW ODPDUWLH &RQVWLWX LDDSUHY ]XWLQVWLWXLUHDIXQF LHLGHSUHúHGLQWH DO 5HSXEOLFLL 6RFLDOLVWH 5RPkQLD FDUH HUD úL úHI DO VWDWXOXL DFHVWD ILLQG DOHVODSURSXQHUHD&RPLWHWXOXL&HQWUDODO3DUWLGXOXL&RPXQLVW5RPkQúL DO )URQWXOXL 8QLW LL 6RFLDOLVWH vQ SHUVRDQD OXL 1LFRODH &HDXúHVFX VHFUHWDUXO JHQHUDO DO 3DUWLGXOXL &RPXQLVW 5RPkQ FDUH OD GHFHPEULH IXVHVHDOHVúLvQIXQF LDGHSUHúHGLQWHDO&RQVLOLXOXLGH6WDW $MXQV vQ IUXQWHD VWDWXOXL URPkQ 1LFRODH &HDXúHVFX D GHFODQúDW DF LXQHDGHUHRUJDQL]DUHDDFWLYLW LLSDUWLGXOXLFRPXQLVWFRQWLQXkQGSR OLWLFDGHOLEHUDOL]DUHDDFWLYLW LORUHFRQRPLFHúLFKLDUSROLWLFHGHVI úXUDWH vQ DU DVRFLLQGXúL OD FRQGXFHUH RDPHQL QRL GHYRWD L SULQWUH FDUH VD DIODWúLVR LDVD(OHQD&HDXúHVFXDOHDV VXFFHVLYvQFHOHPDLvQDOWHIXQF LL GHSDUWLGúLGHVWDW&RQFRPLWHQWSHQWUXDúLFRQVROLGDSR]L LDúLvQSODQ H[WHUQDDF LRQDWSHQWUXUHQXQ DUHDODÄPRGHOXOXQLF´LPSXVSkQ DWXQFL GHF WUHVRYLHWLFL ÌQFDGUXODúD]LVHLOHJDOLW LVRFLDOLVWHDGHPDVFDWvQDSULOLH R SDUWH GLQ DEX]XULOH V YkUúLWH vQ WLPSXO OXL *KHRUJKH *KHRUJKLX'HM OD FDUH SDUWLFLSDVH úL HO GH DOWIHO UHDELOLWkQG SH XQLL DFWLYLúWL DL SDUWLGXOXL vQWUH FDUH VD DIODW úL /XFUH LX 3 WU úFDQX ,QL LDO D vPEXQ W LW UHOD LLOH
'HQQLV 'HOHWDQW 5RPkQLD VXE UHJLPXO FRPXQLVW )XQGD LD $FDGHPLD&LYLF %XFXUHúWL
GLQWUH VWDW úL ELVHULF SULQ vQILLQ DUHD D PDL PXOWH VHPLQDULL WHRORJLFH VSRULUHDIDFXOW LORUGHWHRORJLHúLUHQRYDUHDXQRUELVHULFLúLP Q VWLUL /DVFXUWWLPSvQV SUHOXkQGWRDWHIXQF LLOHGHFRQGXFHUHvQSDUWLGúL vQ VWDW 1LFRODH &HDXúHVFX D SURPRYDW XQ VXV LQXW FXOW DO SHUVRQDOLW LL UHIX]kQG RULFH VFKLPEDUH FkW GH FkW VHULRDV vQ FDGUXO UHJLPXOXL SROLWLF LQWHUQILLQGvQO WXUDWGHODSXWHUHODGHFHPEULH 5HYROX LD5RPkQ GLQ'HFHPEULH úLFRQVHFLQ HOHVDOH 6SUHGHRVHELUHGHVLWXD LDGLQFHOHODOWHVWDWHDIODWHODHVWGHÄFRUWLQD GHILHU´ vQ5RPkQLDQXDIRVWSRVLELO vQO WXUDUHDUHJLPXOXLVRFLDOLVW WRWDOLWDUFRPXQLVW SH FDOH SDúQLF GHRDUHFH 1LFRODH &HDXúHVFX VD FUDPSRQDW GH SXWHUH úL D UHVSLQV FDWHJRULF LGHHD HIHFWX ULL GH UHIRUPH GHPRFUDWLFHvQVRFLHWDWHDURPkQHDVF &D XUPDUH vQ FDGUXO SURFHVXOXL UHYROX LRQDU HVWHXURSHDQ úL D VFHQDULLORU H[WHUQH SULYLQG vQO WXUDUHD GH OD SXWHUH D OXL 1LFRODH &HDXúHVFX úL D UHJLPXOXL SH FDUH DFHVWD vO SDWURQD OD PLMORFXO OXQLL GHFHPEULH GXS vQFHUFDUHDGHUHYROW SRSXODU HúXDW GHOD,DúL GHFHPEULH URPkQLL VDX UHYROWDW úL HL LHúLQG vQ VWUDG PDL vQWkL OD 7LPLúRDUD GHFHPEULH DSRL OD $UDG /XJRM &OXM HWF VFDQGkQG Ä/LEHUWDWH´-RVGLFWDWXUD´-RV&HDXúHVFX´HWFvQIUXQWkQGUHSUHVLXQHD VWUXFWXULORUGHIRU DOHUHJLPXOXLFDUHODRUGLQXOúHIXOXLVWDWXOXLQXDX H]LWDWV WUDJ úLV SURYRDFHPRU LúLU QL LVSUHLQGLJQDUHDvQWUHJLLOXPL FDUHVDVROLGDUL]DWFXOXSWDORUHURLF 'XS FLQFL ]LOH vQ FDUH DX vQIUXQWDW VLQJXUL VWUXFWXULOH UHJLPXOXL WLPLúRUHQLL DX LHúLW GLQ QRX OD GHFHPEULH FX ]HFLOH GH PLL vQ VWUDG DXGHFODQúDWJUHYDJHQHUDO úLDXFRQVWLWXLW)URQWXO'HPRFUDW LF 5RPkQFDUHDIRUPXODWSULPXOSURJUDPDOUHYROX LHLURPkQHSULQFDUHVH FHUHDX RUJDQL]DUHD GH DOHJHUL OLEHUH DFRUGDUHD GH GUHSWXUL úL OLEHUW L
,RDQ 6FXUWX 5HYROX LD 5RPkQ GLQ 'HFHPEULH vQ FRQWH[W LQWHUQD LRQDO(GLWXUD(QFLFORSHGLF (GLWXUD,QVWLWXWXOXL5HYROX LHL5RPkQH GLQ'HFHPEULH %XFXUHúWL $OHVDQGUX 'X X 5HYROX LD GLQ 'HFHPEULH &URQRORJLH (GLWXUD,QVWLWXWXOXL5HYROX LHL5RPkQHGLQ'HFHPEULH %XFXUHúWL
FHW HQHúWL UHIRUPD SROLWLFH HFRQRPLFH úL VRFLDOH HOLEHUDUHD GH LQX LORU SROLWLFLúLDFHORUDUHVWD LLOHJDOHWF $ XUPDW OD GHFHPEULH úL UHYROWD EXFXUHúWHQLORU UHSUHVLXQHDGLQQRDSWHDGHVSUHGHFHPEULHGHOD,QWHUFRQWLQHQWDO´ LHúLUHDvQVWUDG D]HFLORUGHPLLGHFHW HQLDL&DSLWDOHL GHFHPEULH XUPDW GHvQO WXUDUHDGHODSXWHUHDOXL1LFRODH&HDXúHVFXúLFRQVWLWXLUHD )URQWXOXL 6ODY ULL 1D LRQDOH vQ VHDUD ]LOHL GH GHFHPEULH DO F UXL &RQVLOLXDI FXWFXQRVFXW ULLOD7HOHYL]LXQHVHDUDWkU]LX&RPXQLFDWXO F WUH DU FHO PDL UDGLFDO GRFXPHQW DO UHYROX LHL &X DFHO SULOHM ,RQ ,OLHVFXDDQXQ DWDDQXQ DWGHPLWHUHDJXYHUQXOXLúLGL]ROYDUHDVWUXFWXULORU GH SXWHUH DOH YHFKLXOXL UHJLP SUHOXDUHD SXWHULL GH F WUH &RQVLOLXO )URQWXOXL6DOY ULL1D LRQDOHDEDQGRQDUHDUROXOXLFRQGXF WRUDOSDUWLGXOXL FRPXQLVW VWDWRUQLFLUHD XQXL VLVWHPGHPRFUDWLFSOXUDOLVWGHJXYHUQ PkQW HWF 'RFXPHQWXO PDL SUHFL]D F RELHFWLYXO SULQFLSDO DO )61 FRQVWD vQ ÄLQVWDXUDUHDGHPRFUD LHLOLEHUW LLúLGUHSWXULORUSRSRUXOXLURPkQ´F vQ YLLWRU DUDVHYDQXPL5RPkQLD &XSX LQWLPSvQDLQWHvQV IRU HU PDVHQHFXQRVFXWHDXGHFODQúDW DWDFXULWHURULVWHFDUHDXSURYRFDWQXPHURDVHYLFWLPHXPDQHPDWHULDOHúL VSLULWXDOH FRQFRPLWHQW 5RPkQLD D IRVW VXSXV úL XQXL LQWHQV U ]ERL HOHFWURQLF6LWXD LDVDVWDELOL]DWODVFXUWWLPSGXS ÄMXGHFDUHD´úLH[HFX LD OXL 1LFRODH &HDXúHVFX úL D VR LHL VDOH OD GHFHPEULH 3HQWUX YLFWRULD5HYROX LHLURPkQHVDXMHUWILWFHW HQLGLQFDUHDXIRVW PLOLWDUL&RQFRPLWHQWDXIRVWU QL L PLOLWDUL 9LFWRULD UHYROX LHL D DYXW LPSRUWDQWH FRQVHFLQ H SROLWLFH HFRQRPLFHVRFLDOHHWF/DVFXWWLPSDXIRVWUHFRQVWLWXLWHSDUWLGHOHLVWRULFH GHVILLQ DWH OD vQFHSXWXO UHJLPXOXL FRPXQLVW úL FRQVWLWXLWH DOWHOH QRL DMXQJkQGXVHFKLDUODRDGHY UDW ÄLQIOD LH´GHSDUWLGHSROLWLFHQXP UXO DFHVWRUD DMXQJkQG vQ PDL OD /XSWD SHQWUX SXWHUH vQWUH )URQWXO 6DOY ULL 1D LRQDOH WUDQVIRUPDW vQ SDUWLG SROLWLF OD IHEUXDULH úL RSR]L LD JUXSDW vQ MXUXO IRVWHORU SDUWLGH LVWRULFH UHFRQVWLWXLWH FX SX LQ WLPS vQDLQWH D I FXW FD YLD D SROLWLF URPkQHDVF V GHYLQ H[WUHP GH DJLWDW
$UPDWD URPkQ vQ 5HYROX LD GLQ 'HFHPEULH 6WXGLX GRFXPHQWDU (GL LD D ,,D UHY ]XW úL DG XJLW (GLWXUD 0LOLWDU %XFXUHúWL S
&XWRDWHDFHVWHDDFWLYLWDWHDJXYHUQDPHQWDO ODGHFHPEULH vQ IXQF LD GH SULPPLQLVWUX D IRVW QXPLW 3HWUH 5RPDQ VD GHVI úXUDW FRQIRUP SULQFLSLLORU DQXQ DWH SULQ &RPXQLFDWXO &RQVLOLXOXL )URQWXOXL 6DOY ULL 1D LRQDOH OD IHO FD úL FHD OHJLVODWLY FDUH D IRVW SUHOXDW OD IHEUXDULH GHF WUH&RQVLOLXO3URYL]RULXDO8QLW LL1D LRQDOH /HJHD SULYLQG DOHJHULOH SDUODPHQWDUH úL SUH]LGHQ LDOH DGRSWDW GH DFHVWD GLQ XUP OD PDUWLH D SUHY ]XW F ÄSXWHUHD SROLWLF vQ 5RPkQLD DSDU LQH SRSRUXOXL úL VH H[HUFLW SRWULYLW SULQFLSLLORU GHPRFUD LHLOLEHUW LLúLDVLJXU ULLGHPQLW LLXPDQHLQYLRODELOLW LLúLLQDOLHQDELOL W LL GUHSWXULORU IXQGDPHQWDOH DOH RPXOXL´ JXYHUQDUHD XUPkQG V VH UHDOL]H]HSHED]DÄVLVWHPXOXLGHPRFUDWLFSOXUDOLVWSUHFXPúLDVHSDUD LHL SXWHULORUOHJLVODWLY H[HFXWLY úLMXGHF WRUHDVF ´ 3ULPDFDPSDQLHHOHFWRUDO SRVWGHFHPEULVW VDGHVI úXUDWúLHDvQ FDGUXOXQHLDJLWDWHOXSWHSHQWUXSXWHUHDGHUHQ LLRSR]L LHLRFXSkQGOD DSULOLH 3LD D8QLYHUVLW LLSHFDUHDXGHFODUDWRÄ]RQ OLEHU GHQHR FRPXQLVP´ÄNLORPHWUXODOGHPRFUD LHL´HWFFHUkQGVFRDWHUHDvQDIDUD OHJLL D SDUWLGHORU GH WLS QHRFRPXQLVW VH YL]D vQ SULPXO UkQG )URQWXO 6DOY ULL 1D LRQDOH vQO WXUDUHD GLQ IXQF LLOH GH FRQGXFHUH D FHORU FDUH I FXVHU SDUWHGLQQRPHQFODWXUDFRPXQLVW OXDUHDGUHSWXOXLGHDFDQGLGD DFHORUFDUHDYXVHVHU IXQF LLvQFDGUXO3DUWLGXOXL&RPXQLVW5RPkQ HUD YL]DWvQVSHFLDO,RQ,OLHVFXIRVWVHFUHWDUDO&&DO3&5 úL6HFXULWDWHHWF ÌQ ILQDO DOHJHULOH GLQ PDL FkúWLJDWH GH F WUH )URQWXO 6DOY ULL 1D LRQDOH FX SHQWUX $GXQDUHD 'HSXWD LORU úL SHQWUX6HQDW DXGDWQDúWHUHSULPXOXL3DUODPHQWSOXULSDUWLGLVW ODLXQLH 3DUODPHQWXODvQYHVWLWJXYHUQXOPRQRFRORUDO)URQWXOXL6DOY ULL1D LRQDOH vQIUXQWHFX3HWUH5RPDQ FXUROGH$GXQDUH&RQVWLWXDQW vQFDUHDXIRVW UHSUH]HQWDWH FLUFD GH IRUPD LXQL SROLWLFH ÌQ IXQF LD GH SUHúHGLQWH DO 5RPkQLHLDIRVWDOHVFXGLQYRWXUL,RQ,OLHVFX $GRSWDUHD &RQVWLWX LHL 5RPkQLHL OD QRLHPEULH FRQVDFUDW úLSULQUHIHUHQGXPQD LRQDOODGHFHPEULH DSXVFDS W ÄSURYL]RUDWXOXL SROLWLF´ vQ 5RPkQLD GDU QX úL LQVWDELOLW LL SROLWLFH VFLQG ULGHSDUWLGHGL]LGHQ HSROLWLFHPLJUD LLSDUODPHQWDUHHWF FUL]HORU JXYHUQDPHQWDOH vQVHSWHPEULH SUHPLHUXO3HWUH5RPDQIRWGHPLVvQ XUPD XQHL QRL VRVLULDGXFHUL D PLQHULORU GLQ 9DOHD -LXOXL vQ %XFXUHúWL VRFLDOH JUHYHPDQLIHVWD LLHWF (URGDUHD ÄUHJLPXOXL ,OLHVFX´ FDUH D FkúWLJDW úL DOHJHULOH GLQ VHSWHPEULH GXS DQLGHJXYHUQDUHDI FXWFDDOHJHULOHGLQQR
LHPEULH V ILHFkúWLJDWHGHRSR]L LDUHSUH]HQWDW vQSULQFLSDOGHF WUH &RQYHQ LD 'HPRFUDWLF GLQ 5RPkQLD FRQVWLWXLW OD LXQLH vQ ORFXO &RQYHQ LHL 'HPRFUDWLFHvQILLQ DW OD QRLHPEULH LDU FHOH SUH]LGHQ LDOH GH F WUH (PLO &RQVWDQWLQHVFX 1LFL GH DFHDVW GDW SURPLVLXQLOHHOHFWRUDOHQXDXIRVWvQGHSOLQLWH VLWXD LDHFRQRPLF D ULLV D GHWHULRUDW úRPDMXO D FUHVFXW QLYHOXO GH WUDL D VF ]XW DUD QX D IRVW SULPLW vQ1$72úDQVHOHGHDGHUDUHOD8QLXQHD(XURSHDQ DXVF ]XW HWF $FHVW OXFUX D IRVW ÄWD[DW´ GH F WUH DOHJ WRUL FX SULOHMXO DOHJHULORU SDUODPHQWDUHGLQQRLHPEULHFkQG3DUWLGXO'HPRFUD LHL6RFLDOH GLQ5RPkQLDúLDOLD LLV LDXUHYHQLWODJXYHUQDUH$OHJHULOHSUH]LGHQ LDOH DX IRVW FkúWLJDWH GH F WUH ,RQ ,OLHVFX vQ DO GRLOHD WXU GH VFUXWLQ OD GHFHPEULH ÌQ SRILGD GLVIXQF LXQLORU SROLWLFH úL JXYHUQDPHQWDOH D vQWkU]LHULL HIHFWX ULL UHIRUPHORU HFRQRPLFH úL D WUDQ]L LHL vQ JHQHUDO vQ FHL DQL FDUHDXXUPDW5HYROX LHLGLQ'HFHPEULH XOWLPLLDLVHFROXOXL;; 5RPkQLDDXUPDW vQSRILGDGLILFXOW LORUWUDQ]L LHLúLDJUHúHOLORUI FXWH XQFXUVDVFHQGHQWvQWRDWHGRPHQLLOHvQSODQLQWHUQúLH[WHUQ
,;&$5$&7(5,67,&,$/((&2120,(, ù,6758&785,,62&,$/( (FRQRPLD
%HQHILFLLQGGHFRQVHFLQ HOHSROLWLFLLGHvQFXUDMDUHFXSUHF GHUHD LQGXVWULHL LQL LDW SULQ OHJHD GLQ SURPRYDW vQGHRVHEL GH 3DUWLGXO 1D LRQDO/LEHUDOGDUDFFHSWDW úLGHFHOHODOWHSDUWLGHSROLWLFHFKLDUúLGH FHOHFRQVHUYDWRDUHúLGHP VXULOHHFRQRPLFHSURWHF LRQLVWH OHJHDYDPDO GLQ LQFOXVLY vQ FHHD FH SULYHúWH GH]YROWDUHD FDSLWDOXOXL DXWRKWRQ HFRQRPLD URPkQHDVF D vQUHJLVWUDW SURJUHVH OD vQFHSXW GH VHFRO I U V DMXQJ OD VWDQGDUGHOH DWLQVH úL FHUXWH GH GH]YROWDUHD HXURSHDQ 0XOW YUHPH5RPkQLDDU PDVXQVWDWFXSUHF GHUHDJUDU ÌQ GRPHQLXO LQGXVWULDO EHQHILFLLQGXVH GH DYDQWDMHOH SURWHF LRQLV PXOXLOHJLVODWLYVDXvQUHJLVWUDWSURJUHVHvQGRPHQLXOLQGXVWULHLXúRDUHúL GHFRQVWUXF LL±GHPRU ULW]DK UKkUWLHOHPQFLPHQW±SUHFXPúLvQFHD H[WUDFWLY 5RPkQLDDMXQJkQGvQ DOWUHLOHDSURGXF WRUPRQGLDOGH SHWUROGXS 6WDWHOH8QLWHDOH$PHULFLLúL5XVLDFXRSURGXF LHDQXDO GH WRQH GH SHVWH RUL PDL PXOW FD vQ 3URJUHVH D vQUHJLVWUDW úL LQGXVWULD SUHOXFU WRDUH XúRDU úL DOLPHQWDU 0DL OHQW VD GH]YROWDWLQGXVWULDWH[WLO SURGXF LDGHWLSPDQXIDFWXULHUGH LQkQGvQF XQ URO LPSRUWDQW vQ HFRQRPLD ULL ÌQ OLSVD XQHL LQGXVWULL FRQVWUXFWRDUH GH PDúLQL GLQLQVWDOD LLOHWHKQLFHúLSURGXVHOHVHPLIDEULFDWHQHFH VDUHXWLOL] ULLvQWUHSULQGHULORUDXIRVWLPSRUWDWHGLQVWDWHOHLQGXVWULDOL]DWH 5DPXU GHED] DHFRQRPLHLURPkQHúWLDJULFXOWXUDLQFOXGHDSHVWH GLQSRSXOD LD ULLÌQSRILGDFUHúWHULLSURGXF LHLDJULFROHvQVSHFLDO ODFHUHDOHFDUHDFRSHUHDXvQ FLUFDGLQWHUHQXOFXOWLYDWSRUXP EXOVLWXkQGXVHSHSULPXOORFDQWUHQDUHDDFHVWHLDvQFLUFXLWXOHFRQRPLHL GHSLD úLPRGHUQL]DUHDHLDXIRVWvQWkU]LDWHGHSHUVLVWHQ DXQRUVWUXFWXUL GH SURSULHWDWH úL UHOD LL GH SURGXF LH DQDFURQLFH FDUH QX vQFXUDMDX DFWLYLWDWHD SURGXFWLY &DX]D SULQFLSDO D UHSUH]HQWDWR OLSVD GH S PkQW
&RQFRPLWHQWvQ DU VHH[WU JHDXúLLPSRUWDQWHFDQWLW LGHF UEXQH
SHQWUX SULQFLSDOLL SURGXF WRUL vQ QXPDL vQ 5HJDW H[LVWkQG SHVWH GHIDPLOLL U QHúWLI U S PkQWvQWLPSFH PRúLHULFXSHVWH KDVW SkQHDXGLQWHUHQXODUDELOLDU GH UDQLFXSkQ ODKDGH LQHDX 0DULOH SLHUGHUL vQUHJLVWUDWH vQ WLPSXO SULPXOXL U ]ERL PRQGLDO úL MDIXO SUDFWLFDW GH WUXSHOH JHUPDQH DXVWURXQJDUH EXOJDUH úL WXUFH GH RFXSD LH DXI FXWFDvQ QLYHOXOHFRQRPLHLURPkQHúWLV ILHPDLPLFFXID GHSURGXF LDGLQ DMXQJkQGXVHFDGLQ DU H[SRUWDWRDUHGHFHUHDOH5RPkQLDV GHYLQ LPSRUWDWRDUH ) XULUHD5RPkQLHLÌQWUHJLWHvQ FDUHDDGXVGXS VLQHúLVSR ULUHD úL GLYHUVLILFDUHD VXUVHORU GH PDWHULL SULPH D LQIOXHQ DW SR]LWLY HYROX LDHFRQRPLF D5RPkQLHL3DUWLGXO1D LRQDO/LEHUDOFRQWLQXkQGV VH SURQXQ H PDL DOHV vQ SULPXO GHFHQLX LQWHUEHOLF SHQWUX SROLWLFD ÄSULQ QRLvQúLQH´PDQLIHVWDW SULQDSOLFDUHDXQRUOHJLFDUHDXIDYRUL]DWIDFWRUXO LQWHUQvQGH]YROWDUHDLQGXVWULHL OHJLOHPLQHORUHQHUJLHLFRPHUFLDOL] ULLúL FRQWUROXOXLvQWUHSULQGHULORUHFRQRPLFHHWF úLSULQDGRSWDUHDXQRUWDULIH YDPDOHSURWHF LRQLVWH 3ULQ HIRUWXUL GHRVHELWH VD DMXQV vQ vQ FDGUXO SURFHVXOXL GH UHFRQVWUXF LH OD UHIDFHUHD SRWHQ LDOXOXL HFRQRPLF úL DSRL OD VSRULUHD DFHVWXLD ÌQWUH WLPS IXVHVH VROX LRQDW úL OLSVD GH S PkQW SULQ UHIRUPD DJUDU GLQ ± XQD GLQ FHOH PDL FXSULQ] WRDUH OHJLIHUDW SH SODQ LQWHUQD LRQDO GXS SULPXO U ]ERL PRQGLDO ± ILLQG H[SURSULDWH KDS PkQWDUDELO GLQVXSUDID DPDULORUPRúLL &XWRDWHDFHVWHD OLSVD PLMORDFHORU DJULFROH PRGHUQH I UkPL DUHD SURSULHW LORU GDWRULW ÄH[SOR]LHL GHPRJUDILFH´ OD VDWH úL D DOWRU IDFWRUL DX I FXW FD SUREOHPD U QHDVF V QX ILH VROX LRQDW ÌQ DQVDPEOX vQV FUHúWHUHD VXSUDIH HL DJULFROHD ULLFDXUPDUHDUHDOL] ULL0DULL8QLUL PLOLRDQHKDID GH PLOLRDQH KD vQ IDEULFDUHD GH EDWR]H VHP Q WRUL úL DOWH PDúLQL DJULFROH D GHWHUPLQDW VSRULUHD SURGXF LHL DJULFROH PLOLRDQH WRQHFHUHDOHvQ IDSWFDUHVLWXD5RPkQLDSHSULPHOHORFXULvQOXPHOD H[SRUWXOGHFHUHDOHvQVSHFLDOSRUXPERU]JUkX FKLDUGDF vQ]HVWUDUHD WHKQLF vQ VSHFLDO OD SOXJXUL D U PDV GHILFLWDU vQ OD XQ SOXJ UHYHQHDX KDWHUHQDUDELO
3kQ vQ DXSULPLWS PkQW FDSLGHIDPLOLHY GXYHGH U ]ERLVDXPRELOL]D L
ÌQ 5RPkQLDDLQWUDWvQWURSURIXQG FUL] HFRQRPLF DJUDYDW GHFRQWH[WXOLQWHUQD LRQDOGHVWUXFWXUDDJULFRO D ULLGHSUH XOULGLFDWDO P UIXULORU LPSRUWDWH ± FRPSDUDWLY FX FHOH H[SRUWDWH ± GH VF GHUHD SUH XOXL SURGXVHORU DJULFROH SHWUROLHUH SH SLD D H[WHUQ GH FUHúWHUHD GDWRULHLH[WHUQHúLGHGRPLQD LDPRQRSROXULORUVWU LQHFDUHGH LQHDXSHVWH GLQ HFRQRPLD QD LRQDO ÌQ FRQGL LLOH SHQXULHL GH FDSLWDO DXWRKWRQ 3DUWLGXO 1D LRQDO U QHVF FDUH D JXYHUQDW DUD vQ DFHDVW SHULRDG D DSOLFDWSROLWLFDÄSRU LORUGHVFKLVH´XUP ULQGDWUDJHUHDFDSLWDOXOXLVWU LQ 'LQ HFRQRPLD URPkQHDVF VD UHYLWDOL]DW GLQ QRX SkQ vQ FkQGDDWLQVSXQFWXOPD[LPGLQSHULRDGDLQWHUEHOLF ÌQDFHVWWLPSD FUHVFXWúLLQWHUYHQ LDVWDWXOXLvQSURFHVXOGHGH]YROWDUHHFRQRPLF vQUH JLVWUkQGXVHSURJUHVHFRQFUHWL]DWHvQGLYHUVLILFDUHDDFWLYLW LORUYDORULIL FDUHDVXSHULRDU DVXUVHORUGHPDWHULLSULPHH[WLQGHUHDUH HOHLGHXQLW L LQGXVWULDOHEDQFDUHGH]YROWDUHDFRPHU XOXLH[WHULRUHWF'H]YROWkQGXVH vQWUXQULWPDQXDOGHXQXOGLQFHOHPDLULGLFDWHGLQOXPHLQGXVWULD URPkQHDVF LQWHUEHOLF DvQUHJLVWUDWSURJUHVHvQFHHDFHSULYHúWHGLYHUVL WDWHDSURGXVHORU DYLRDQH,$5úL,$5YDJRDQHDXWREX]HPR WRDUHHOHFWULFHLQVWDOD LLSHWUROLHUHHWF DMXQJkQGV VDWLVIDF vQ ± DQXO GH YkUI DO SURGXF LHL LQWHUEHOLFH ± GLQ QHFHVDUXO SURGXF LHL LQWHUQHÌQDFHODúLDQGLQWRWDOXOSURGXF LHLLQGXVWULDOHHUDGHVWLQDW IDEULF ULL PLMORDFHORU GH SURGXF LH LDU SURGXF LHL EXQXULORU GH FRQVXPLQGXVWULDSDUWLFLSkQGFX ODUHDOL]DUHDSURGXVXOXLVRFLDOúLFX DYHQLWXOXLQD LRQDOID GHUHVSHFWLY vQ ÌQ FkQGUDPXULOHHFRQRPLFHQHDJULFROHDXDMXQVV UHSUH]LQWH GLQ SURGXVXO VRFLDO úL GLQ YHQLWXO QD LRQDO 5RPkQLD D GHYHQLW XQ VWDW DJUDULQGXVWULDO vQ FDUH YHQLWXO QD LRQDO VH FLIUD OD SHVWH GRODUL SH FDS GH ORFXLWRU PDL PXOW FD vQ 7XUFLD *UHFLD 3RORQLD %XOJDULDúLDSURDSHODIHOFDvQ,XJRVODYLDúL8QJDULD 3LHUGHUHDvQ DFLUFDRWUHLPHGLQWHULWRULXOQD LRQDOvQVSHFLDO D XQHL PDUL S U L GLQ 7UDQVLOYDQLD ERJDW vQ PDWHULL SULPH D I FXW FD 5RPkQLDV QXPDLGLVSXQ GHXQHOHVXUVHLPSRUWDQWHGHPDWHULLSULPH GLQ DXUXO ILQ GLQ DUJLQW GLQ FXSUX GLQ SOXPE úL GH vQWUHDJD FDQWLWDWH GH ]LQF HWF ÌQ DQVDPEOX vQ RFWRPEULH ID GHLXQLHDFHODúLDQVDSLHUGXWGLQSURGXF LDLQGXVWULDO GLQQXP UXOvQWUHSULQGHULORUPDULSURGXF WRDUH GLQFDSLWDOXO LQYHVWLW GLQ SHUVRDQHOH vQFDGUDWH GLQ VXSUDID D DUDELO GLQYDORDUHDSURGXF LHLDJULFROHHWF
1DWXUDUHOD LLORUHFRQRPLFHFX*HUPDQLDFDUHDvQFHUFDWúLDUHXúLW vQ PXOWH SULYLQ H V úL VXERUGRQH]H HFRQRPLD URPkQHDVF SUHOXkQG QXPHURDVHvQWUHSULQGHULLQGXVWULDOHLQVWLWX LLEDQFDUHGHDVLJXU ULHWFúL V IDF GLQFRPHU XOURPkQHVFXQPRQRSRODO$[HL FDQWLWDWHDGHSHWURO WULPLV vQ5HLFKvQSHULRDGD VDVLWXDWODPLOLRDQHWRQH UHSUH]HQWkQGGLQWRWDOXOH[SRUWXOXLURPkQHVF SUHMXGLFLLOHSURYRFDWH GH WUXSHOH JHUPDQH GLQ 5RPkQLD VFKLPEDUHD SULRULW LORU SURGXFWLYH FD XUPDUHDDQJDM ULL ULLvQU ]ERLODLXQLH PLOLWDUL]DUHDvQWUHSULQ GHULORU GLVWUXJHULOH SURYRFDWH GH ERPEDUGDPHQWHOH DQJORDPHULFDQH vQ VSHFLDO vQ PDUHOH HIRUW GH U ]ERL úL DO L IDFWRUL DX SURYRFDW PDUL SLHUGHUL HFRQRPLHL URPkQHúWL &X WRDWH DFHVWHD vQ YDUD DQXOXL 5RPkQLD GLVSXQHD vQF GH XQ SRWHQ LDO HFRQRPLFRILQDQFLDU DFFHSWDELO SHQWUXR DU DIODW GHWUHLDQLvQU ]ERL 6LWXD LDVDvQU XW LWGXS WUHFHUHD ULLGHSDUWHD1D LXQLORU8QLWH OD DXJXVW FD XUPDUH D UHJLPXOXL GXU GH DUPLVWL LX LPSXV GH VRYLHWLFL vQILLQ ULL VRFLHW LORU PL[WH URPkQRVRYLHWLFH VRYURPXUL GHVILLQ DWHSkQ vQ vQFHSXWXOXLLQVWDXU ULLFRQWUROXOXLGHVWDWDVXSUD YLH LLHFRQRPLFHHWF $FHVW GLQ XUP SURFHV DYHD V ILH ILQDOL]DW GXS FkQG VD LPSXVUHQXQ DUHDODSURSULHWDWHDSULYDW DVXSUDPLMORDFHORUGHSURGXF LH úL OD PHFDQLVPHOH HFRQRPLHL GH SLD úL VD WUHFXW OD LQGXVWULDOL]DUHD VRFLDOLVW SULQ SXQHUHD DFFHQWXOXL GXS PRGHO VRYLHWLF SH GH]YROWDUHD LQGXVWULHL JUHOH FX SUHF GHUH D PLMORDFHORU GH SURGXF LH vQ GHWULPHQWXO EXQXULORUGHFRQVXPúLODWUDQVIRUPDUHDVRFLDOLVW DDJULFXOWXULL vQFKH LDW vQ SULQ vQILLQ DUHD *RVSRG ULLORU $JULFROH &ROHFWLYH QXPLWH XOWHULRU&RRSHUDWLYH$JULFROHGH3URGXF LH PHPEULLFRRSHUDWRULSXWkQG S VWUDGRDUORWXULPLFLGHS PkQWGHSkQ ODKD3URFHVXOVDGRYHGLW D IL GH]DVWUXRV SHQWUX HFRQRPLD úL DJULFXOWXUD URPkQHDVF OD IHO FD úL SHQWUX U QLPHFXWRDWHF vQDQLL¶SURFHVXOGHPHFDQL]DUHúLLULJDUHD OXFU ULORUDJULFROHGHDVLJXUDUHFXVSHFLDOLúWLúLFXQRLVRLXULGHSODQWHúL UDVH GH DQLPDOH SURGXFWLYH D vQUHJLVWUDW UH]XOWDWH QRWDELOH I FkQG FD SURGXF LDDJULFRO V FUHDVF 2VFKLPEDUHvQFDGUXOSROLWLFLLHFRQRPLFHDLQWHUYHQLWvQGHFHPEULH FkQG VD GHFLV DFFHSWDUHD XQXL vQFHSXW GH GHVFHQWUDOL]DUH D DFWLYLW LORUSURGXFWLYHúLGHLQWHQVLILFDUHDSURFHVXOXLGHPRGHUQL]DUHúL UHQWDELOL]DUHDDvQWUHSULQGHULORUÌQDFHVWVFRSDXIRVWFRQWUDFWDWHPDVLYH vPSUXPXWXULGLQVWU LQ WDWHSkQ vQ GDWRULDH[WHUQ D ULLDMXQJkQG
vQV OD FLUFD PLOLDUGH GH GRODUL 8UP ULQGV DVLJXUHÄLQGHSHQGHQ D´ HFRQRPLF úLSROLWLF D ULL1LFRODH&HDXúHVFXDGHFLVV DFKLWHFkWPDL UDSLG GDWRULD H[WHUQ vQ FDUH VFRS D IRU DW H[SRUWXO YkQ]kQG GHVHRUL SURGXVHOHVXEFRVW5H]XOWDWXODIRVWFDWDVWURIDOvQQLFLDQLHFRQRPLD URPkQHDVF OLSVLW GHIRQGXULSHQWUXPRGHUQL]DUHGHWHULRUkQGXVHUDSLG QLYHOXO GH WUDL DJUDYkQGXVH GLQ FH vQ FH PDL PXOW SULQ UD LRQDOL]DUHD PXOWRUSURGXVHGHVWULFW QHFHVLWDWH'H]DVWUXODIRVWDFFHOHUDWGHDPEL LD úHIXOXLVWDWXOXLURPkQFDUHFRQGXFHD DUDvQPRGGLFWDWRULDOGHDGRYHGL OXPLLÄHILFLHQ D´SROLWLFLLSHFDUHRSURPRYD &XWRDWHJUHúHOLOHHIHFWXDWHvQFRQGXFHUHDúLGHVI úXUDUHDSURFHVHORU HFRQRPLFHGLQFDGUXOHFRQRPLHLVRFLDOLVWHFRQGXVHFHQWUDOL]DWLQL LDOSH ED]DSODQXULORUDQXDOH úL DSRLFLQFLQDOHODvQFHSXWXODQLORU ¶5RPkQLDDGHYHQLWXQVWDWLQGXVWULDODJUDU3ULQLQYHVWL LLFRQVLGHUD ELOHvQSURFHVXOGHLQGXVWULDOL]DUHVDUHXúLWV GHFRQVWUXLDVF QXPHURDVH RELHFWLYH LQGXVWULDOH FDUH DX DFRSHULW SUDFWLF DSURDSH WRDWH ]RQHOH ULL GHVHRUL I U V VH LQ VHDPD GH SRVLELOLW LOH GH DVLJXUDUH FX PDWHULL SULPH ÌQ FDGUXO UHDOL] ULORU LQGXVWULHL URPkQHúWL VDX VLWXDW SURGXFHUHD DXWRWXULVPXOXL Ä'DFLD´ vQ vQ FRODERUDUH FX ILUPD IUDQFH] Ä5HQDXOW´SHUIHF LRQDWDSRLúLWUDQVIRUPDWvQÄ'DFLD±´ HOLFRSWH UXOXL Ä,$5´ vQ FRODERUDUH FX ILUPD IUDQFH] Ä$ORXHWWH´ SXQHUHDvQIXQF LXQHDSULPHLWXUELQHGHOD&HQWUDOD+LGURHOHFWULF GHOD 3RU LOHGH)LHU FDOFXODWRUXOÄ)HOL[´ SODWIRUPDSHQWUX H[SORDWDUHD L HLXOXLúLDJD]HORUQDWXUDOHGLQ0DUHD1HDJU SULPD QDY GHSHVFXLWRFHDQLF DYLRQXOGHSDVDJHULÄ520%$&´ vQFRODERUDUHFXRILUP GLQ0DUHD%ULWDQLH DYLRDQHGHYkQ WRDUH úL ERPEDUGDPHQW Ä,$5´± %UDúRY úL GH ERPEDUGDPHQW OD &UDLRYDvQFRODERUDUHDFX,XJRVODYLDÌQDQVDPEOXvQV DIRVWYRUEDGHR GH]YROWDUHH[WHQVLY GDUvQIRDUWHPXOWHVLWXD LLLQHILFLHQW PDLDOHVID GHUHDOL] ULOHVLPLODUHODQLYHOXOVWDWHORUGH]YROWDWH 'XS UHYROX LD GLQ 'HFHPEULH JXYHUQDQ LL URPkQL úLDX SURSXVV UHDOL]H]HRHFRQRPLHGHSLD GHVFHQWUDOL]DW úLFRPSHWLWLY vQ SULPLL DQL DL WUDQ]L LHL RELHFWLYHOH SULRULWDUH DOH GH]YROW ULL HFRQRPLFH URPkQHúWL YL]kQG WUDQVIRUPDUHD VWUXFWXULORU HFRQRPLFH OHJLVODWLYHúLLQVWLWX LRQDOHOLEHUDOL]DUHDSUH XULORUPHQ LQHUHDVLVWHPXOXL GHVXEYHQ LLHWF
ÌQWUH úL SROLWLFD HFRQRPLF D 5RPkQLHL D XUP ULW FRQWLQXDUHDSURFHVXOXLGHOLEHUDOL]DUHDSUH XULORU GHVI úXUDUHDUHIRUPHL ILQDQFLDUH úL PDQDJHULDOH D DJHQ LORU HFRQRPLFL FX FDSLWDO GH VWDW UHJOHPHQWDUHDPRGXOXLGHDGPLQLVWUDUHDVHFWRUXOXLSXEOLFGHH[SORDWDUHD PRQRSROXOXL VWDWXOXL úL GH vPEXQ W LUH D UHJLLORU DXWRQRPH VWLPXODUHD GH]YROW ULL úL FRQVROLG ULL VHFWRUXOXL SULYDW SURPRYDUHD XQRU P VXUL RUJDQL]DWRULFHOHJLVODWLYHúLLQVWLWX LRQDOHQHFHVDUHIXQF LRQ ULLSLH HLGH EXQXUL úL VHUYLFLL UHJOHPHQWDUHD úL RUJDQL]DUHD SLH HL IRU HL GH PXQF FRUHODUHDSROLWLFLORUVDODULDOHFXHYROX LDLQGLFDWRULORUGHHILFLHQ UHVWUXF WXUDUHD úL GH]YROWDUHD VLVWHPXOXL EDQFDU úL GH DVLJXU UL RUJDQL]DUHD LQVWLWX LLORUGHED] úLDFDGUXOXLOHJLVODWLYQHFHVDUFUH ULLSLH HLGHFDSLWDO SHUIHF LRQDUHD VLVWHPXOXL ILQDQFLDU úL EXJHWDU FRQWLQXDUHD OLEHUDOL] ULL FRPHU XOXL H[WHULRU VWLPXODUHD H[SRUWXOXL úL D LQYHVWL LLORU GH FDSLWDO VWU LQ SURPRYDUHD XQRU SURJUDPH VHFWRULDOH GH UHIRUP V Q WDWH vQY PkQWDVLJXU ULVRFLDOHHWF ÌQ SHULRDGD XUP WRDUH SURJUDPXO GH GH]YROWDUH HFRQRPLF GHQXPLW ÄWHUDSLD GH úRF´ D YL]DW DFFHOHUDUHD UHIRUPHORU VWUXFWXUDOH FX DFFHQW SH OLEHUDOL]DUHD SUH XULORU PDL DOHV OD HQHUJLH SURGXVH DJULFROH úL VHUYLFLL SXEOLFH OLEHUDOL]DUHD UHJLPXOXL FXUVXOXL GH VFKLPE UHGXFHUHD WD[HORU YDPDOH GH LPSRUW HOLPLQDUHD VXEYHQ LLORU UHWUDJHUHDFUHGLWHORUVXEYHQ LRQDWHSHQWUXDJULFXOWXU SURPRYDUHDLQYHV WL LLORUVWU LQH UHIRUPHLQVWLWX LRQDOHHWFÌQ FXVSULMLQXOXL)RQGXOXL 0RQHWDU ,QWHUQD LRQDO VD DGRSWDW Ä3URJUDPXO DQWLFUL] FDUH D LPSXO VLRQDW PDQDJHPHQWXO UHIRUPHORU VWUXFWXUDOH vQFHSXWH vQ DQLL DQWHULRUL D FRPSOHWDWúLDFWXDOL]DWFDGUXOOHJLVODWLYúLLQVWLWX LRQDOFRQIRUPVWDGLXOXL GHGH]YROWDUHDVRFLHW LLURPkQHúWL ÌQ UHDOLWDWH vQV GDWRULW XQRU FDX]H RELHFWLYH LQVXILFLHQ D UHVXUVHORUILQDQFLDUHSURSULLPHQ LQHUHDVW ULLGHL]RODUHD ULLvQFLUFXLWXO ILQDQFLDU LQWHUQD LRQDO DFFHVXO OLPLWDW OD ILQDQ DUHD H[WHUQ FRQMXQFWXU HFRQRPLF QHIDYRUDELO SLHUGHUHDSLH HORUGLQIRVWXO&$(5UHWUDJHUHD SUHPDWXU DVWDWXOXLGLQHFRQRPLHHWF GDUúLVXELHFWLYH OLSVDGHH[SH ULHQ LQFOXVLYODQLYHOJXYHUQDPHQWDOLQFRQVHFYHQ DvQDSOLFDUHDQRLORU SURJUDPH úL VWUDWHJLL GH GH]YROWDUH FRQWLQXDUHD DSOLF ULL VLVWHPXOXL GH DFRUGDUH D VXEYHQ LLORU SXEOLFH PRGXO GHIHFWXRV GH LPSOHPHQWDUH D UHIRUPHL IXQFLDUH HWF QLYHOXO SULQFLSDOLORU LQGLFDWRUL DL GH]YROW ULL HFRQRPLFHD ULLDU PDVvQGHFHQLXOFDUHDXUPDWVXEFHOGLQ
&X WRDWH DFHVWHD SURFHVXO GH FUHDUH D XQHL HFRQRPLL GH SLD FRPSHWLWLYH úL GLQDPLFH GH PRGHUQL]DUH D HFRQRPLHL URPkQHúWL D IRVW GHFODQúDWIDSWSHUFHSXWúLSHSODQHXURSHDQúLPRQGLDOvQIHEUXDULH vQFHSkQGQHJRFLHULOH GH LQWHJUDUH D 5RPkQLHL vQ 8QLXQHD (XURSHDQ SURFHVILQDOL]DWODLDQXDULH 6WUXFWXUDVRFLDO )RU VRFLDO vQSOLQ DVFHQVLXQHODvQFHSXWGHVHFROEXUJKH]LDVD FRQVROLGDWQXPHULFúLPDWHULDOvQW ULQGXúLSR]L LLOHvQLQGXVWULHFRPHU úL ILQDQ H úL VD VWUDWLILFDW SULQ FRQVWLWXLUHD PDULL EXUJKH]LL FX LQWHUHVH SUHSRQGHUHQWEDQFDUH&RQFXUHQ DPDULORULQGXVWULDúLúLEDQFKHULVWU LQL SURFHVXOOHQWGHFHQWUDOL]DUHDFDSLWDOXOXLDI FXWvQV FDPDUHDEXUJKH]LH DXWRKWRQ V ILH SX LQ QXPHURDV vQ DQVDPEOX SUHGRPLQkQG EXUJKH]LD PLF úLPLMORFLHUHSUH]HQWDW vQDSDUDWXODGPLQLVWUDWLYvQDFWLYLW LGHWLS PHúWHúXJ UHVF úL RSHUD LL FRPHUFLDOH VLPSOH ÌQ SURYLQFLLOH URPkQHúWL DIODWH VXE RFXSD LH VWU LQ FX WRDWH F HUD EORFDW vQ GH]YROWDUHD HL GH F WUHDXWRULW LOHGRPLQDWHEXUJKH]LDURPkQ PLF úLPLMORFLHDDYXWXQ UROLPSRUWDQWvQVXV LQHUHDPLúF ULLGHHOLEHUDUHQD LRQDO ÌQ SHULRDGD LQWHUEHOLF EXUJKH]LD URPkQ úLD DFFHQWXDW UROXO vQ DQVDPEOXOVRFLHW LLGLIHUHQ LLQGXVHWRWPDLPXOWSULQVSRULUHDQXPHULF D FDWHJRULLORU PLFL úL PLMORFLL FRQFRPLWHQW FX SDXSHUL]DUHD XQHL S U L D EXUJKH]LHLPLFL 0RúLHULPHD D FRQWLQXDW V GH LQ vQ SULPHOH GHFHQLL DOH VHFROXOXL ;; LPSRUWDQWH SR]L LL vQ YLD D HFRQRPLF D ULL vQ FRQGL LLOH vQ FDUH MXP WDWH GLQ VXSUDID D FXOWLYDW VH DIOD vQ VW SkQLUHD PDULORU SURSULHWDUL IXQFLDUL &X WRDWH DFHVWHD S U L DOH HL DX PDQLIHVWDW WHQGLQ H GH vPEXU JKH]LUH LPSOLFkQGXVH vQ LQGXVWULH FRPHU VSHFXOD LL ILQDQFLDUH HWF ÌQ SHULRDGD LQWHUEHOLF XUPDUH vQ VSHFLDO D UHIRUPHL DJUDUH GLQ PRúLHULPHDVDGH]LQWHJUDWGLQSXQFWXOGHYHGHUHDOFODVHLVRFLDOHRSDUWH WUHFkQGvQUkQGXULOHPDULLEXUJKH]LLH[SORDWkQGXúLSURSULHW LOHSHED]H FDSLWDOLVWH 'H]YROWDUHDLQGXVWULHLDVSRULWQXPHULFFODVDPXQFLWRDUHvQVSHFLDO SUROHWDULDWXO LQGXVWULDO GH IDEULF OD vQFHSXW GH VHFRO FDUH D DGRSWDWIRUPHGHRUJDQL]DUHSROLWLF úLSURIHVLRQDO SURJUDPHGHDF LXQH SURSULLPLOLWkQGSHQWUXRYLD PDLEXQ &DXUPDUHDFUHúWHULLQXP UXOXL
vQWUHSULQGHULORUvQVSHFLDOvQPDUHDLQGXVWULHDSDXSHUL] ULL U QLPLLvQ SHULRDGDLQWHUEHOLF QXP UXOPXQFLWRULORUDVSRULWGHODvQ ODvQ &DSDFLWDWHDRUJDQL]DWRULF DFODVHLPXQFLWRDUHDLHúLW vQ HYLGHQ vQ WLPSXO PDULORU PLúF UL UHYHQGLFDWLYH FDUH VDX VXFFHGDW SHUPDQHQW XQHOH ILLQG GH PDUH DPSORDUHL JUHYHOH GH OD /XSHQL *ULYL D%XFXUHúWL &)53ORLHúWL úD 0XOW YUHPHFODVDVRFLDO FHDPDLQXPHURDV U QLPHD±PDMRUL WDWHDFXS PkQWSX LQVDXGHORF±DIRVWSHUPDQHQWLQWHUHVDW vQVROX LR QDUHD SUREOHPHL DJUDUH SULQ OLFKLGDUHD PDULL SURSULHW L PRúLHUHúWL ULGLFkQGXVH GHVHRUL OD OXSW DWXQFL FkQG FRQGL LLOH GH WUDL GHYHQLVHU LQVXSRUWDELOH FHD PDL UHSUH]HQWDWLY úL PDL GUDPDWLF PLúFDUH VRFLDO GRYHGLQGXVH vQ DFHVW VHQV U VFRDOD GLQ 'XS UHIRUPD DJUDU GLQ PXO L UDQLDXSULPLWS PkQWvQV QXúLFUHGLWHSHWHUPHQOXQJFX GREkQ]L DFFHVLELOH 3UREOHPH PDUL DX IRVW GHWHUPLQDWH úL GH GLIHUHQ HOH GLQWUHSUH XOSURGXVHORULQGXVWULDOHúLFHOHDJULFROHGHOLSVDLQYHQWDUXOXL DJULFRO PRGHUQ GH VSRUXO GHPRJUDILF OD VDWH FDUH D SXOYHUL]DW SURSULH W LOHDJULFROH vQ ODNPSVXSUDID DUDELO UHYHQHDXORFXL WRUL SHQWUXDVROX LRQDFRQWUDGLF LLOHGLQWUH U QLPHúLEXUJKH]LDDJUDU OD vQFHSXWXO GHFHQLXOXL SDWUX VWDWXO D LQWHUYHQLW SULQ OHJHD SHQWUX FRQYHUVLXQHD úL OLFKLGDUHD GDWRULLORU DJULFROH DFRUGkQG WRWRGDW vPSUXPXWXUL SH WHUPHQ OXQJ úL UHJOHPHQWDUHD GREkQ]LORU PD[LP VWLPXODUHDH[SRUWXULORU3UREOHPDIXQGDPHQWDO D U QLPLL±LQVXILFLHQ D S PkQWXOXL úL D XWLODMHORU DJULFROH PRGHUQH ± D FRQWLQXDW V QX ILH VROX LRQDW 2 LPSRUWDQW FODV VRFLDO D 5RPkQLHL vQ VHFROXO ;; D IRVW UHSUH]HQWDW GH LQWHOHFWXDOLWDWH FDUH D I FXW FD FHUFHWDUHD úWLLQ LILF V FXSULQG YDVWH GRPHQLL GH LQYHVWLJDUH vQ PDWHPDWLF ILLF FKLPLH ELRORJLHPHGLFLQ JHRORJLHHWFRULHQWkQGXVHVSUHGRPHQLLFXDSOLFDEL OLWDWHSUDFWLF LPHGLDW VDXPDLSX LQLQYHVWLJDWH $O WXULGHDFHVWHFODVHVRFLDOHGHED] vQVRFLHWDWHDURPkQHDVF DX H[LVWDW úL FDWHJRULL PLMORFLL PHVHULDúL QHJXVWRUL PLFL SURGXF WRUL FRPHUFLDQ LHWF úLS WXULVRFLDOHFDUHDXFRQWULEXLWúLHOHODGH]YROWDUHD VWDWXOXL URPkQ ÌQ SHULRDGD LQWHUEHOLF vQ FDGUXO JUXSXULORU PLMORFLL D VSRULW QXP UXO SHUVRQDOXOXL IXQF LRQ UHVF úL D FHOXL GLQ VIHUD VHUYLFLLORU SDUWLFXODUH úL GH VWDW PLFLL IXQF LRQDUL DGPLQLVWUDWLYL WUHFkQG vQ UkQGXO S WXULORUGHMRVDOHPLFLLEXUJKH]LLVDXSUROHWDUL]kQGXVH
,QVWDXUDUHD UHJLPXOXL FRPXQLVW D SURGXV PRGLILF UL LPSRUWDQWH vQ VWUXFWXUD VRFLDO D 5RPkQLHL 5HIRUPD DJUDU GLQ QD LRQDOL] ULOHGLQ úL GHVILLQ DUHDSURSULHW LLSULYDWHúLDOWH P VXULOXDWHGHUHJLPDXGXVODGHVILLQ DUHDEXUJKH]LHLúLDXOWLPHORU U P úL HDOHPRúLHULPLLvQWLPSFHSURFHVXOLQWHQVGHLQGXVWULDOL]DUHD DGXV PXQFLWRULPHD vQ SULP SODQ FDUH OLSVLW GH DOWH SRVLELOLW L GH H[LVWHQ GHFkW PXQFD vQ vQWUHSULQGHULOH VRFLDOLVWH D XUPDW SROLWLFD SDUWLGXOXL FRPXQLVW /D UkQGXO HL U QLPHD OLSVLW GLQ QRX GH S PkQW D PLJUDW VSUH RUDú DQJDMkQGXVH vQ DFWLYLW L FX FDUDFWHU LQGXVWULDO ÌQ FRQGL LLOH vQ FDUH UHJLPXO D vQJU GLW úL FKLDU D LQWHU]LV SRVLELOLW LOH GH VWXGLX SHQWUX GHVFHQGHQ LL FODVHORU ERJDWH LQWHOHFWXDOLWDWHD DYHD V ILH FRQVWLWXLW FX SUHF GHUH GLQ ILL GH PXQFLWRULúL UDQL
;5($/,= 5,$/(ù7,,1 (, &8/785,,ù,632578/8, ùWLLQ DúLFXOWXUD
ÌQFXUVXOVHFROXOXL;;UH]XOWDWHGHRVHELWH úLFKLDUSHUIRUPDQ H V DXvQUHJLVWUDWvQúWLLQ FXOWXU VSRUWHWF2FRQWULEX LHGHRVHELW vQDFHVW VHQV D DYXW $FDGHPLD 5RPkQ LQVWLWX LH UHSUH]HQWDWLY FX DFWLYLWDWH SHUPDQHQW vQGRPHQLXOFHUFHW ULLúWLLQ LILFHFUHD LHLOLWHUDUHúLDUWLVWLFH HWFvQUHJLVWUkQGSURJUHVHvQWRDWHGRPHQLLOHGHDFWLYLWDWHúLFRQWULEXLQGOD HYROX LDVRFLHW LLURPkQHúWL0XOWHGLQUHDOL] ULOHDFDGHPLFLHQLORUURPkQL úLQXQXPDLVDXULGLFDWODQLYHOPRQGLDO 3ULQWUH GRPHQLLOH vQ FDUH VDX vQUHJLVWUDW UH]XOWDWH GHRVHELWH PHQ LRQH] ± PDWHPDWLFD PHFDQLFD FHUHDVF LQWURGXFHUHD XQRU PHWRGH PDWHPDWLFHvQVWXGLXOIHQRPHQHORUYLH LLVRFLDOHHWF 6SLUX+DUHW SHQWUX PHULWHOH VDOH vQ DFHVW GRPHQLX 8QLXQHD ,QWHUQD LRQDO $VWURQRPLF D DWULEXLW vQ QXPHOH V X XQXL FUDWHU GH SH ID D LQYL]LELO GH SH 3 PkQWD/XQLL VWXGLXOHFXD LLORULQWHJUDOHúLDOJHRPHWULHLSULQLQWURGX FHUHDXQHLQRLFODVHGHFXUEH 7UDLDQ/DOHVFXúL*KHRUJKH L HLFD WHRULD WRSRORJLF D IXQF LLORU WHRULD HFXD LLORU OLQLDUH FX GHULYDWH SDU LDOH vQ GRPHQLXFRPSOH[ 6LPLRQ6WRLORY XQHOHGHVFRSHULULPDWHPDWLFHvLSRDUW QXPHOH PHFDQLFDJHQHUDO DVLVWHPHORUKLGURGLQDPLFLLDHURGLQDPLFLLúL WHRULD HODVWLFLW LL &DLXV ,DFRE XQHOH GLQ GHVFRSHULUL vL SRDUW QXPHOH WHRULD GHULYDWHL DOYHRODUH WHRULD IXQF LLORU SROLDUPRQLFH HWF 0LURQ 1LFROHVFX DOJHEUD ORJLFLL úL WHRULD DOJHEULF D PHFDQLVPHORU DXWRPDWH DQDOL]DIXQF LRQDO vQPHFDQLF úLvQJHRPHWULDGLIHUHQ LDW HWF *ULJRUH 0RLVLO WHRULD SUREDELOLW LORU WHRUHPD IXQGDPHQWDO D DOJHEUHL WRSR ORJLDIXQF LLORUILOR]RILHPDWHPDWLF 2FWDY2QLFHVFX HWF
$vQFHSXWV IXQF LRQH]HvQVXEGHQXPLUHDGH6RFLHWDWHD
$FDGHPLF 5RPkQ DQL PDL WkU]LX DFHDVWD D OXDW GHQXPLUHD GH $FDGHPLD5RPkQ
± IL]LFD PDJQHWLVP úL IHQRPHQH FX GXEO UHIUDF LH HOHFWULF úL GHSRODUL]DUHDOXPLQLLFXDQWDGHPDJQHWLVPDVRFLDW HOHFWURQXOXL ùWHIDQ 3URFRSLX XQHOH GHVFRSHULUL vL SRDUW QXPHOH WHRULD EHWRQXOXL DUPDW VRQLFLWDWHD HWF *HRUJH*RJX &RQVWDQWLQHVFX HPLVLD HOHFWURQLF D PHWDOHORU VXE LQIOXHQ D ERPEDUGDPHQWXOXL LRQLORU SR]LWLYL HWF (XJHQ % G U X UD]HOH;HWF +RULD+XOXEHL ±FKLPLD FRPSR]L LDFKLPLF DSHWUROXULORUDQDOL]DPLQHUDOHORUúL URFLORUGLQ&DUSD LHWF 3HWUX3RQL FRPEXVWLDJD]HORUúLVWXGLXOIO F ULL 1LFRODH 7HFOX D LQYHQWDW EHFXO GH ODERUDWRU FX UHJODUH DXWRPDW D FXUHQWXOXL GH DHU úL JD] FKLPLD DQRUJDQLF úL DQDOLWLF *KHRUJKH 6SDFX FHUFHW ULvQGRPHQLXOFKLPLHLDQDOLWLFHIL]LFHúLDQRUJDQLFH ,OLH * 0XUJXOHVFX FKLPLD RUJDQLF WHRUHWLF úL DSOLFDWLY &RVWLQ ' 1HQL HVFX FRORUDQ LVLQWHWLFL &RQVWDQWLQ,,VWUDWL ± ELRORJLD VSHRORJLH úL ELRVSHRORJLH (PLO 5DFRYL IRQGDWRU DO DFHVWRU GRPHQLL GH FHUFHWDUH D I FXW VWXGLL vQ SHVWH GH SHúWHUL KLGURELRORJLHRFHDQRORJLHLKWLRORJLHHFRORJLHSLVFLFXOWXU PX]HRORJLH ]RRORJLH ELRHFRQRPLH *ULJRUH$QWLSD IRQGDWRUDO0X]HXOXLGHLVWRULH QDWXUDO GLQ%XFXUHúWLFDUHvLSRDUW QXPHOH ELRORJLDFHOXODU *HRUJH (PLO3DODGH SHQWUXIXQGDPHQWDUHDDFHVWHLúWLLQ HDSULPLW3UHPLXO1REHO vQ ELRORJLD úL SDWRORJLD FHOXODU D VLVWHPXOXL FDUGLRYDVFXODU 1LFRODH6LPLRQHVFX ±PHGLFLQD YDFFLQDUHDDQWLKROHULF GU,RDQ&DQWDFX]LQR FUHDWRU DO ,QVWLWXWXOXL GH VHUXUL úL YDFFLQXUL DILOLDW OD UH HDXD ,QVWLWXWXOXL 3DWHXU GLQ 3DULV DQDWRPRSDWRORJLH KLVWRFKLPLH FHOXOD QHUYRDV HWF GU *KHRUJKH 0DULQHVFX ,RQ 0LQHD DGPLQLVWUDUHD vQ GR]H IUDF LRQDWH D VWURIDQWLQHL vQ EROLOH FDUGLRYDVFXODUH 'DQLHO 'DQLHORSRO SHQWUX SULPD GDW vQOXPH PLFURELRORJLHPRGHUQ EDFWHULRORJLHDQDWRPLHSDWRORJL F HSLGHPLRORJLH LPXQRORJLH DQWLELRWHUDSLH EDFWHULRORJLH HWF 9LFWRU %DEHú HQGRFURQRORJLH 1LFRODH3DXOHVFX DGHVFRSHULWSHQWUXSULPDGDW LQVXOLQDvQ YDFFLQXULDQWLKROHULFHELRORJLDEDFWHULRIDJXOXL 0LKDL &LXF HQGRFULQRORJLH QHXURORJLH SVLKLDWULH ELRFKLPLH JHULDWULH HPEULRJHQH] ELRORJLHYHJHWDO &RQVWDQWLQ,3DUKRQ ± WHKQLDF DYLD LH ± 7UDLDQ 9XLD D UHDOL]DW OD PDUWLH SH FkPSXOGHOD0RQWHVVRQGHOkQJ 3DULVvQSUHPLHU PRQGLDO SULPXO]ERU GLQ OXPH FX XQ DYLRQ FRQFHSXW úL FRQVWUXLW GH HO PRQRSODQXO 9 EUHYHWDW vQ )UDQ D OD DXJXVW H[FOXVLY FX PLMORDFH SURSULL GH ERUG $XUHO9ODLFXDSURLHFWDWFRQVWUXLWVLQJXUúLSLORWDWPDLPXOWHWLSXUL
GH PRQRSODQH +HQUL &RDQG D UHDOL]DW vQ SHQWUX SULPD GDW vQ OXPH PDFKHWD XQXL DYLRQ I U HOLFHYLLWRUXO DYLRQ FX UHDF LH vQ PDFKHWD XQXL DYLRQ FX PRWRU UDFKHW FX FRPEXVWLELO VROLG vQ XQ DYLRQED]DWSHSURSXOVLDSULQUHDF LHvQ SULPXODYLRQELPRWRUGLQ OXPH D EUHYHWDW vQ IHQRPHQXO DHURGLQDPLFÄHIHFWXO &RDQG ´ DHURGLQDPLF (OLH &DUDIROL SURLHFW UL úL FRQVWUXF LL GH RELHFWLYH FLYLOH $QJKHO6DOLJQ\SRGXOGHSHVWH'XQ UHOD&HUQDYRG FHOPDLPDUH GLQ(XURSDúLDOWUHLOHDGLQOXPH FLEHUQHWLF ùWHIDQ2GREOHMDVDPDL RFXSDW GH IL]LF ILOR]RILH SVLKRORJLH GUHSW OLWHUDWXU 2 UHDOL]DUH GHRVHELW vQGRPHQLXODYLDWLFúLQXQXPDLDIRVWUHSUH]HQWDW GH]ERUXO vQVSD LXOFRVPLFUHDOL]DWvQ GHSLORWXOURPkQ'XPLWUX3UXQDULXSH QDYDVRYLHWLF Ä6RLX]´ ± LVWRULD QD LRQDO úL XQLYHUVDO 1LFRODH ,RUJD QD LRQDO úL SUREOHPH WHRUHWLFH DOH úWLLQ HL LVWRULFH $OH[DQGUX ;HQRSRO QD LRQDO &RQVWDQWLQ & *LXUHVFX DUKHRORJLH 9DVLOH 3kUYDQ &RQVWDQWLQ 'DLFRYLFLX 6LYLX'UDJRPLU,RDQ/XSDúúD ± JHRJUDILH úL JHRORJLH JHRJUDILH JHQHUDO HWQRORJLH JHRJUDILF JHRJUDILH XPDQ JHRJUDILH HFRQRPLF JHRJUDILH UHJLRQDO 6LPLRQ 0HKHGLQ L JHRORJLH úL SDOHRQWRORJLH *ULJRUH &RE OFHVFX JHRJUDILH VWUDWLJUDILHSDOHRQWRORJLH ,RQ7K6LPLRQHVFX ± ILORVRILH VRFLRORJLH HVHLVWLF 0LUFHD (OLDGH 'LPLWULH *XVWL &RQVWDQWLQ1RLFD0LUFHD9XOF QHVFX(PLO&LRUDQ(XJHQ,RQHVFXHWF ± úWLLQ H HFRQRPLFH HFRQRPLD QD LRQDO FUL]H HFRQRPLFH HWF 9LUJLO0DGJHDUX LQVWLWX LLEDQFDUHJkQGLUHDHFRQRPLF UROXOVWDWXOXL SUREOHPHHFRQRPLFHúLILQDQFLDUH 9LFWRU6O YHVFX HFRQRPLHPDWHPD WLF HFRQRPLH QHRFODVLF HFRQRPLH HFRORJLF úL ELRHFRQRPLH 1LFRODH *HRUJHVFX5RHQJHQ LVWRULHHFRQRPLF úLVRFLDO LVWRULDJkQGLULLHFRQR PLFH WHRULD HFRQRPLF FRQWHPSRUDQ HFRQRPLD SURWHF LHL PHGLXOXL DPELDQW PHWRGRORJLD FHUFHW ULL úWLLQ LILFH HFRQRPLFH WUDQ]L LD GH OD HFRQRPLD FHQWUDOL]DW VSUH HFRQRPLD GH SLD 1LFRODH 1 &RQVWDQWLQHVFX 0LKDLO0DQRLOHVFX0LWL &RQVWDQWLQHVFX ± úWLLQ H MXULGLFH GUHSWXO URPkQHVF L]YRDUH MXULGLFH VFULVH GUHSW FLYLO GUHSW FRPSDUDW $QGUHL 5 GXOHVFX GUHSW FLYLO GUHSWXO IDPLOLHL GUHSW LQWHUQD LRQDO SULYDW GUHSWXO IDPLOLHL 7UDLDQ ,RQDúFX MXULVW GLSORPDWúLRPSROLWLFHWF 1LFRODH7LWXOHVFX ÌQGRPHQLXOSRH]LHLVDXUHPDUFDW,RQ0LQXOHVFX*HRUJH%DFRYLD *HRUJH&RúEXF2FWDYLDQ*RJD,RQ3LODW/XFLDQ%ODJD7XGRU$UJKH]L
,RQ%DUEX$OH[DQGUX3KLOLSLGH1LFRODH/DELú1LFKLWD6W QHVFX0DULQ 6RUHVFX ,RDQ $OH[DQGUX $GULDQ 3 XQHVFX $QD %ODQGLDQD 0LUFHD 'LQHVFXHWF 3UR]D D IRVW UHSUH]HQWDW VWU OXFLW GH %DUEX ùWHI QHVFX 'HODYUDQFHD,RQ/XFD&DUDJLDOH,RQ6ODYLFL/LYLX5HEUHDQX+RUWHQVLD 3DSDGDW %HQJHVFX &DPLO 3HWUHVFX 0LUFHD (OLDGH (XJHQ /RYLQHVFX (XJHQ ,RQHVFX ùWHIDQ $XJXVWLQ 'LRQDú 0DULQ 3UHGD 3HWUX 'XPLWULX $XJXVWLQ%X]XUD2FWDYLDQ3DOHU1LFRODH%UHEDQúD 3ULQWUH FULWLFLL OLWHUDUL VDX GLVWLQV *HRUJH & OLQHVFX ùHUEDQ &LRFXOHVFX $OH[DQGUX 3LUX 6 &URKP OQLFHDQX 0LUFHD =DFLX 1LFRODH 0DQROHVFXúD 'RPHQLXO DUWHORU SODVWLFH D IRVW GRPLQDW GH ùWHIDQ /XFKLDQ *HRUJH3HWUDúFX&DPLO5HVVX'XPLWUX*KHD 1LFRODH*ULJRUHVFX,RQ XFXOHVFX &RUQHOLX %DED &RQVWDQWLQ %UkQFXúL 'LPLWULH 3DFLXUHD &RUQHO0HGUHD2VFDU+DQ,RQ-DOHD'XLOLX0DUFX2FWDY'RLFHVFX,RQ 0LQFX3HWUH$QWRQHVFX,RQ'%HULQGHL'LPLWULH0DLPDUROXúD 0X]LFDDIRVWUHSUH]HQWDW vQPRGVWU OXFLWGH*HRUJH6WHSK QHVFX DXWRUXO SULPHL VLPIRQLL URPkQHúWL &RQVWDQWLQ 'XPLWUHVFX SULPHOH FYDUWHWH GH FRDUGH *HRUJH 'LPD FWLWRU DO OLHGXOXL URPkQHVF *HRUJH (QHVFX YLRORQLVW SLDQLVW FRPSR]LWRU GLULMRU SHGDJRJ HWF 7LEHULX %UHGLFHDQX6DELQ'U JRL,RQHO3HUOHD0LKDLO-RUD&RQVWDQWLQ%U LORLX 7LEHULX2ODK'LQX/LSDWL6HUJLX&HOLELGDFKH,RQ9RLFXHWF 6SRUWXO 0DUL SHUIRUPDQ H VDX vQUHJLVWUDW úL vQ GRPHQLXO VSRUWLY vQ FDGUXO F UXLDVDXRE LQXW ± SULPD PHGDOLH ROLPSLF EURQ] RE LQXW GH HFKLSD GH UXJE\ D 5RPkQLHLOD-RFXULOH2OLPSLFHGHYDU GHOD3DULVGLQ ± SULPXO WLWOX GH FDPSLRQ HXURSHDQ RE LQXW GH ER[HUXO /XFLDQ 3RSHVFXODJDODGHER[SURIHVLRQLVWODFDWHJRULDPXVF vQ ±SULPXOUHFRUGPRQGLDOIHPLQLQRE LQXWGH6PDUDQGD%U HVFXOD V ULWXUDFXSDUDúXWDGHODPvQ
&XQRDúWH5RPkQLD(GLWXUD(FRQRPLF %XFXUHúWLSS
±SULPXOWLWOXGHFDPSLRQPRQGLDORE LQXWGH$OH[DQGUX3DSDQ úL 'XPLWUX +XEHUW vQ SURED GH ERE GRX SHUVRDQH OD FDPSLRQDWHOH PRQGLDOHGHOD6FKUHLEHUKDX*HUPDQLDvQ ± SULPD PHGDOLH ROLPSLF LQGLYLGXDO DUJLQW RE LQXW GH +HQU\ 5DQJOD-RFXULOH2OLPSLFHGHYDU GHOD%HUOLQvQSUREDÄ0DUHOHSUHPLX DOQD LXQLORU´GLQFRPSHWL LDGHF O ULHvQ ± SULPXO UHFRUG PRQGLDO PDVFXOLQ RE LQXW GH 'XPLWUX 3DUDVFKLYHVFXODDWOHWLVP SUREDGHNPPDUú vQ ± SULPD PHGDOLH ROLPSLF GH DXU RE LQXW GH ,RVLI 6kUEX OD WLU SUREDGHDUP FDOLEUXUHGXVIRFXULSR]L LDFXOFDW FXUHFRUGROLPSLF úLPRQGLDOHJDODWvQ ±SULPXOWLWOXPRQGLDOODHFKLSHvQMRFXULVSRUWLYHRE LQXWGHHFKLSD IHPLQLQ D5RPkQLHLGHKDQGEDOvQOD)UDQNIXUWvQ*HUPDQLDvQ SHUIRUPDQ UHSHWDW GH IHWH vQ RE LQXW úL GH E LH L vQ OD KDQGEDO vQ OD 'RUWPXQGDSRL úL vQ úL SUHFXP úL GH IHWHvQ ± SULPD &XS D &DPSLRQLORU (XURSHQL RE LQXW GH HFKLSD GH KDQGEDO IHPLQLQ ùWLLQ D %XFXUHúWL vQ PDUWLH SHUIRUPDQ UHSHWDW GHE LH LLGHOD5DSLG%XFXUHúWLvQLXOLH ± SULPXO WLWOX HXURSHDQ GH MXQLRUL RE LQXW GH HFKLSD GH IRWEDO D 5RPkQLHL vQ FDGUXO FHOHL GHD ;9D HGL LL D 7XUQHXOXL 8()$ SHQWUX MXQLRULvQ ± SULPXO WLWOX HXURSHDQ GH VHQLRUL RE LQXW GH HFKLSD GH YROHL D 5RPkQLHL OD FDPSLRQDWXO PDVFXOLQ GH YROHL GHVI úXUDW vQ 5RPkQLD vQ ± SULPXO WLWOX GH FDPSLRQ PRQGLDO OD úDK RE LQXW GH )ORULQ *KHRUJKLXvQ ± FHD PDL EXQ VSRUWLY D OXPLL ,RODQGD %ODú vQ SHQWUX SHUIRUPDQ HOH RE LQXWH OD DWOHWLVP SURED V ULWXUD vQ vQ O LPH GXS FH V ULVHODLXOLH PHWULúLRE LQXVHDSRLUHFRUGXULPRQGLDOH GLQFDUHFRQVHFXWLYH ±SULPDILQDO GH&XS D&DPSLRQLORU(URSHQLvQWUHGRX HFKLSH URPkQHúWLODYROHLPDVFXOLQvQ vQWUH'LPDQRúL5DSLGFkúWLJDW GH 'LQDPRFDúLvQ ± SULPD PHGDOLH OD -RFXULOH 2OLPSLFH GH LDUQ RE LQXW GH HFKLSDMXO,RQ3DQ XUXúL1LFRODH1HDJRHOD-2GHOD*UHQREOHvQSURED GHEREGRX SHUVRDQHvQ ± SULPD ILQDO D Ä7XUQHXOXL &DPSLRQLORU´ GH WHQLV PDVFXOLQ FkúWLJDW GH,OLH1 VWDVHOD3DULVvQ ±SULPDQRW GHODJLPQDVWLF OD-RFXULOH2OLPSLFHRE LQXW GH 1DGLD&RP QHFLOD0RQWUHDOvQ
± SULPXO WURIHX LQWHUQD LRQDO Ä*KHDWD GH $XU´ GHFHUQDW XQXL IRWEDOLVW URPkQ 'XGX *HRUJHVFX GH OD 'LQDPR vQ SHUIRUPDQ UHSHWDW vQ ± SULPXO WLWOX GH FDPSLRDQ PRQGLDO OD JLPQDVWLF SH HFKLSH RE LQXWGHHFKLSDIHPLQLQ OD&DPSLRQDWHOHPRQGLDOHGHOD)RUW:RUWK 68$vQ ±SULPD&XS D&DPSLRQLORU(XURSHQLODIRWEDORE LQXW GH6WHDXD %XFXUHúWLOD6HYLOLDvQILQDODFX)&%DUFHORQDvQ ± SULPD 6XSHUFXS D (XURSHL OD IRWEDO RE LQXW GH 6WHDXD %XFXUHúWLOD0RQWH&DUORvQILQDODFX'LQDPR.LHYvQ ±SULPXOURPkQFDUHFXFHUHúWH(YHUHVWXO PHWUL &RQVWDQWLQ / F WXúXvQ ± SULPXO FDPSLRQ PRQGLDO URPkQ GLQ ER[XO SURIHVLRQLVW 0LKDL /HXODFDWHJRULDVHPLPLMORFLHvQ OD+DPEXUJvQID DSDQDPH]XOXL 6DQWLDJR6DPDQLHJR 'DF OD vQFHSXW GH VHFRO SROLWLFD H[WHUQ D 5RPkQLHL HUD RULHQWDW VSUH YHVWXO (XURSHL DUD I FkQG SDUWH úL GLQWUR DOLDQ SROLWLFRPLOLWDU 7ULSOD $OLDQ FDUH vQ DFHOH PRPHQWH vL JDUDQWD LQWHJULWDWHD WHULWRULDO VIkUúLWXO GH VHFRO D J VLWR vQ SOLQ SURFHV GH LQWHJUDUH HXURSHDQ RFFLGHQWDO úL HXURDWODQWLF GH UHGHILQLUH D WUDGL LLORUGLSORPDWLFHURPkQHúWL 9LD DSROLWLF LQWHUQ úLHDH[WUHPGHFRPSOH[ VDGHVI úXUDW vQ FDGUXO PDL PXOWRU IRUPH GH JXYHUQ PkQW ± PRQDUKLH FRQVWLWX LRQDO VDXDXWRULWDU SkQ vQ VDXUHSXEOLF SRSXODU VDXVRFLDOLVW ±úLUHJLPXULSROLWLFH±SDUODPHQWDUGHPRFUDWLFH SkQ vQ úL GXS 5HYROX LD GLQ GHFHPEULH VDX GLFWDWRULDOH ± vQ FDUHDIXQF LRQDWVLVWHPXOPXOWLSDUWLGUHVSHFWLYPRQRSDUWLG (YROX LLúLLQYROX LLvQIXQF LHGHQDWXUDUHJLPXOXLSROLWLFSDUFXUV úLGHFRQWH[WXOLQWHUQD LRQDOVDXSURGXVúLvQFHHDFHSULYHúWHVLWXD LD HFRQRPLHLVWUXFWXUDVRFLDO úWLLQ DFXOWXUDVSRUWXOHWFvQUHJLVWUkQGX VH UHDOL] UL úL vPSOLQLUL GDU úL LQVXFFHVH úL HúHFXUL WRDWH DSDU LQkQG SRSRUXOXLURPkQúLDOWRUDFXFDUHDFRODERUDWVDXFDUHDXvQFHUFDWV L LQIOXHQ H]HHYROX LDLVWRULF 7RDWH DFHVWHD IDF FD LVWRULD 5RPkQLHL vQ VHFROXO ;; V ILH H[WUHPGHLQWHUHVDQW úLLQFLWDQW SHQWUXOHFWXU VWXGLXúLFHUFHWDUH
%,%/,2*5$),(
)ORULQ&RQVWDQWLQLX2LVWRULHVLQFHU DSRSRUXOXLURPkQ(GLWXUD8QLYHUV (QFLFORSHGLF%XFXUHúWL $OHVDQGUX'X X0RGRILF ULDOHVWDWXTXRXOXLWHULWRULDOHXURSHDQ 3UHOLPLQDULLFRQ LQXWúLFRQVHFLQ H(GLWXUD)XQGD LHL5RPkQLDGH0kLQH %XFXUHúWL ,RDQ 6FXUWX *KHRUJKH %X]DWX ,VWRULD URPkQLORU vQ VHFROXO ;; (GLWXUD3DLGHHD%XFXUHúWL ,RDQ 6FXUWX ,VWRULD FRQWHPSRUDQ D 5RPkQLHL (GLWXUD )XQGD LHL5RPkQLDGH0kLQH%XFXUHúWL ùWHIDQ /DFKH 5RPkQLD vQ UHOD LLOH LQWHUQD LRQDOH (GLWXUD )XQGD LHL5RPkQLDGH0kLQH%XFXUHúWL *KHRUJKH2QLúRUX ,VWRULDFRQWHPSRUDQ XQLYHUVDO (GLWXUD )XQGD LHL5RPkQLDGH0kLQH%XFXUHúWL *KHRUJKH 2QLúRUX ,VWRULD FRQWHPSRUDQ XQLYHUVDO GXS (GLWXUD )XQGD LHL5RPkQLDGH0kLQH%XFXUHúWL 9LRULFD 0RLVXF ,VWRULD UHOD LLORU LQWHUQD LRQDOH 3kQ OD PLMORFXO VHFROXOXLDO;;OHD(GLWXUD)XQGD LHL5RPkQLDGH0kLQH%XFXUHúWL 1LFRODH ,VDU ,VWRULD PRGHUQ D URPkQLORU (GLWXUD 8QLYHUVLWDU %XFXUHúWL 7KHRGRUD 6W QHVFX6WDQFLX ,QWHJUDUHD HXURSHDQ úL HXURDWODQWLF D 5RPkQLHL(GLWXUD)XQGD LHL5RPkQLDGH0kLQH%XFXUHúWL 6RULQ&ULVWHVFX5HOD LLSROLWLFRGLSORPDWLFHúLPLOLWDUHHXURSHQH(GLWXUD )XQGD LHL5RPkQLDGH0kLQH%XFXUHúWL
