SHARING KNOWLEDGE ACROSS THE MEDITERRANEAN AREA
NATO Security through Science Series This Series presents the results of scientific meetings supported under the NATO Programme for Security through Science (STS). Meetings supported by the NATO STS Programme are in security-related priority areas of Defence Against Terrorism or Countering Other Threats to Security. The types of meeting supported are generally “Advanced Study Institutes” and “Advanced Research Workshops”. The NATO STS Series collects together the results of these meetings. The meetings are co-organized by scientists from NATO countries and scientists from NATO’s “Partner” or “Mediterranean Dialogue” countries. The observations and recommendations made at the meetings, as well as the contents of the volumes in the Series, reflect those of participants and contributors only; they should not necessarily be regarded as reflecting NATO views or policy. Advanced Study Institutes (ASI) are high-level tutorial courses to convey the latest developments in a subject to an advanced-level audience. Advanced Research Workshops (ARW) are expert meetings where an intense but informal exchange of views at the frontiers of a subject aims at identifying directions for future action. Following a transformation of the programme in 2004 the Series has been re-named and reorganised. Recent volumes on topics not related to security, which result from meetings supported under the programme earlier, may be found in the NATO Science Series. The Series is published by IOS Press, Amsterdam, and Springer Science and Business Media, Dordrecht, in conjunction with the NATO Public Diplomacy Division. Sub-Series A. B. C. D. E.
Chemistry and Biology Physics and Biophysics Environmental Security Information and Communication Security Human and Societal Dynamics
Springer Science and Business Media Springer Science and Business Media Springer Science and Business Media IOS Press IOS Press
http://www.nato.int/science http://www.springeronline.nl http://www.iospress.nl
Sub-Series E: Human and Societal Dynamics – Vol. 12
ISSN: 1574-5597
Sharing Knowledge Across the Mediterranean Area
Towards a Partnership for Sustainable Management of Resources and the Prevention of Catastrophes
Edited by
Paul Faugeras
AFAS, Paris, France
Abdeslam Hoummada
University Hassan II Aïn Chock, Morocco
and
Robert Klapisch AFAS, Paris, France
Amsterdam • Berlin • Oxford • Tokyo • Washington, DC Published in cooperation with NATO Public Diplomacy Division
Proceedings of the NATO Advanced Research Workshop on Sharing Knowledge Across the Mediterranean Area for Prevention of Catastrophes and Sustainable Management of Water and Energy Casablanca, Morocco 5–7 September 2005 © 2006 IOS Press. All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, without prior written permission from the publisher. ISBN 1-58603-680-7 Library of Congress Control Number: 2006934006 Publisher IOS Press Nieuwe Hemweg 6B 1013 BG Amsterdam Netherlands fax: +31 20 687 0019 e-mail:
[email protected] Distributor in the UK and Ireland Gazelle Books Services Ltd. White Cross Mills Hightown Lancaster LA1 4XS United Kingdom fax: +44 1524 63232 e-mail:
[email protected]
Distributor in the USA and Canada IOS Press, Inc. 4502 Rachael Manor Drive Fairfax, VA 22032 USA fax: +1 703 323 3668 e-mail:
[email protected]
LEGAL NOTICE The publisher is not responsible for the use which might be made of the following information. PRINTED IN THE NETHERLANDS
Sharing Knowledge Across the Mediterranean Area P. Faugeras et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2006 © 2006 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
v
Foreword Paul FAUGERAS Editor, AFAS 1, Paris This volume gives the proceedings of the third conference of the series “Sharing knowledge across the Mediterranean”, which was organized jointly by the AFAS, the French association for the advancement of sciences, and the University Hassan II of Casablanca and which was held in this city on September, 5th to 7th 2005. This conference was sponsored by a dozen of organizations, among which NATO, which decided to make it as an Advanced Scientific Workshop. In addition to the opening session, nine different sessions were organized, with the following topics: • • • • • • • •
Session 1: Extension of the European space for research to the Mediterranean zone, Session 2: New energies for development, Session 3: Participation of scientist from the South to international projects: SESAME, Session 5: From food security to food safety in the Euro Mediterranean space, Session 6: Fighting the numerical divide, Session 7: Participation of scientist from the South to international projects: CERN, Session 8: Desalination of sea water and recycling of waste water, Session 9: Natural risks in the Mediterranean.
Session 4 dealt with possible future topics and is not reported here, as it was mainly in the form of an open discussion. Authors were requested to write down their own contribution. Some have kindly accepted to do it and they are gratefully acknowledged. The contributions written in English are published as such; those written in French were subsequently translated in English. The whole conference was recorded on video tapes. For financial and time reasons, it was not possible to transcribe all the exposés for which we didn’t receive a written contribution. Somewhat arbitrarily, we restricted ourselves to guest speakers and to the oral exposés, which were not touched in the previous conferences. Transcription was done in the original language of the speaker and was followed by some filtering to eliminate spoken jargon. Translation into English was subsequently made whenever needed. A footnote at the title of each article indicates the nature of the following document: original English, original French, translated, transcription from oral in English, transcription from oral in French and translation in English.
1
AFAS, CNRS, 1 place Aristide Briand, 92195 Meudon Cedex, France.
vi
Apologies are due to those whose contribution couldn’t be transcribed and reported here. Nevertheless, the author’s name, affiliation and title of each contribution is mentioned in due place. However, interested readers can ask the editor to get a copy on a CD-ROM of the slides of all presentations. The publication of these proceedings has been made possible thanks to a specific financial support of some of our sponsors, namely NATO, the Canon Foundation and CIEHAM. These specific contributions for the English edition are gratefully acknowledged. Warm thanks are finally due to Ms Marie-Laure Blanchet, editorial assistant of AFAS, who took care of the proceedings layout and of shaping the contributions, as well as the proof reading of some of the texts.
vii
Conference Chairman
Prof. Robert Klapisch, Honorary President of AFAS, Paris Conference Co-Chairman, Chairman of the Local Organizing Committee Prof. Abdelasam Hoummada, University Hassan II Aïn Chock, Marocco Scientific Programme Committee Prof. R. Klapisch, Paris Prof. A. Hoummada, Casablanca Prof. J.-P. Connerade, London Prof. J. A. Rubio, Madrid Prof. H. Schopper, Geneva Prof. G. Wormser, Orsay Prof. B. Hervieu, Paris Dr. B. Bachelier, Paris Dr. M. Balaban, L’Aquila, Italie Prof. A. Elmidaoui, Kenitra Prof. J. Ellis, Geneva Prof. Y. Lancelot, Marseille Workshop Proceedings
Dr. P. Faugeras, AFAS Paris
ix
Contents Foreword Paul Faugeras Committee
v vii
Opening Session Opening Remarks Robert Klapisch
The Actions of France and the French-Moroccan Partnership Pierre Appriou Welcome Address Mohamed Berkaoui Welcome Address Pascal Colombani
3 7 11 14
Session 1. Extension of the European Research Area to the Mediterranean ICTP as a Model for Excellence for Doctoral and Post-Doctoral Training in the South Katepalli R. Sreenivasan
19
Training and Career Development of Researchers: The EU Context Georges Bingen
29
Scientific Studies and Careers for Women in Tunisia Oum Kalthoum Ben Hassine
39
Evaluation, Criteria for Excellence Jean-Pierre Bourguignon
Women in Science and Their Role to Advance the Societies from the South Nora Berrah
31
43
Session 2. Energy for Development Novel Energies for the Future Carlo Rubbia
Energy Research at CIEMAT and the Almeria Solar Platform Project Juan-Antonio Rubio The Future of Wind Energy in Morocco D. Zejli, R. Benchrifa and A. Bennouna
49 65 70
x
EUROGIA: The Energy Cluster to Provide Green Solutions to Satisfy an Ever-Growing Demand for Energy Gabriel Marquette Sustainable Energy Scenarios in the Mediterranean: Current Situation and Prospects Dominique Gentile and Samir Allal
76 81
Session 3. Participation in International Projects: SESAME SESAME – Synchrotron Light for Experimental Science and Applications for the Middle East Herwig Schopper SESAME Science Programme – An Example of Knowledge Transfer Samar Hasnain The Synchrotron and the Laser: Are They Friends or Foes? Jean-Patrick Connerade
Other Contributions
89 93 100 115
Session 5. From Food Security to Food Safety, Constructing a Euromediterranean Area Demographic Perspectives, Changes in the Agricultural and Food Situation in the Mediterranean Region: Questions for Research Vincent Dollé
119
The Mediterranean, a Free-Trade Zone from 2010: What Consequences Will This Have for Agriculture, Food and Agronomic Research? Najib Akesbi
131
Roundtable Discussion
148
Agriculture: The Next EuroMed Frontier? Moncef Cheikh-Rouhou
142
Session 6. Fighting the Digital Divide E-Science and the Grid Ken Peach Other Contributions
161 175
Session 7. Water Desalination and Reuse Synergies Between Power Generation and Desalination: Economics and Social Advantages Corrado Sommariva Desalination and Wastewater Reuse Resources to Be Considered Azzeddine Elmidaoui
179 185
xi
Management and Distributed Monitoring of Water Resources Elpida Tzafestas, Gerasimos Rigatos and Constantinos Garagunis Other Contributions
188 190
Session 8. Participation of Southern Countries in International Programmes: CERN The Participation of Southern Countries in International Programmes: CERN Is not an Ivory Tunnel John Ellis
193
Moroccan Participation in ATLAS Driss Benchekroun
200
A Plea for Experimental Particle Physics in Algeria Farès Djama
210
Developing Collaboration with CERN Mohamed M. Sherif
Other Contributions
207
215
Session 9. Natural Risks in the Mediterranean Seismic Risk in the Mediterranean Regions Paul Tapponnier
219
Seismic Instrumentation Jean Virieux
250
Seismic Early Warning in Campania Paolo Gasparini
263
Volcanic Risk Around the Mediterranean Franco Barberi
235
Discussion
259
Other Contributions
267
Conclusions of the Meeting Conclusions of the Meeting Robert Klapisch
271
Recommendations
276
Author Index
279
Opening Session
Sharing Knowledge Across the Mediterranean Area P. Faugeras et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2006 © 2006 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
3
Opening Remarks Mr. Robert KLAPISCH2 Honorary President of AFAS, Paris Emeritus Research Director at CNRS
Thank you for attending the third edition of our conference “Sharing Knowledge across the Mediterranean.” I’m going to speak in French but present transparencies in English. I’d like to let you know that we also have interpreters and simultaneous translations and you can choose the language of your choice for this conference. I’d like to offer first of all the temporary apologies of Pascal Colombani, president of AFAS, who’s been delayed; his plane was late taking off and he will speak to you just as soon as he arrives in the course of the session. I should also let you know that the French minister François Goulard, who gave us his patronage and his considerable financial support, is not able to attend today, because, as often happens with ministers, he had obligations that were not foreseen at the time he agreed to come. First of all, I would like to address my warmest greetings to those of you who attended the conference in Marseille and the one at CERN [the European Organization for Nuclear Research]. For those of you who were at CERN last year, you will remember that a certain number of wishes were expressed during the course of the meeting. We took note of them, and since the end of the conference in Geneva, AFAS and IN2P3, the National Institute for Nuclear and Particle Physics of the French CNRS [National Center for Scientific Research], have worked out a preliminary program and begun finding different and varied sources of funding. Since December 2004 we’ve had an offer from our Moroccan colleagues to host this conference, and that’s why we’re here now. In February we asked the then minister for research, Mr. François d’Aubert, for his patronage and financial support, which were granted to us in the month of April. And I have to say that this conference would not have been possible without the support of the Moroccan community and of President Berkaoui, who’s going to come in a moment. More details will follow, but I don’t want to miss the opportunity to express all the pleasure I had in working intensively during these past weeks with Abdeslam Hoummada, whom you’ve all seen here present and very busy. I would like now in the rest of my talk to pay homage to the French and international contributors, starting with AFAS and IN2P3, but I have a total of eleven different contributors. So, what is AFAS? It’s the French Association for the Advancement of Science, which was founded in 1872, by Claude Bernard, and which is represented here by Pascal Colombani, its president, who’s going to arrive shortly; by Arlette Franceschetti, 2
Transcription from oral in French and translation.’
4
R. Klapisch / Opening Remarks
secretary-general, who helped us a great deal, some of us with plane tickets; by Paul Faugeras, editor of the journal Sciences, who published the reports from the Geneva meeting; and finally by myself, as honorary president and the predecessor of Pascal Colombani. IN2P3 is the National Institute for Nuclear and Particle Physics of the CNRS. It is represented here by Eliane Perret, who’s in charge of international relations, and by Guy Wormser, director of the Linear Accelerator Laboratory in Orsay, since last week, which I salute, and who’s going to organize the session on the fight against the digital divide which will take place tomorrow. In addition, Michel Spiro, the director of IN2P3, gave this project all his support—to the point of lending us his two private secretaries, who, you will recall, handled your registration in July. He must also offer his apologies for his absence, for it’s the season when the institutes prepare their budgets, and that prevented him from coming. I would now like to present to you the list of organizations and institutes who agreed to support our project and who are represented here. The list is long and I would like to thank them collectively for their support. I’d like to add that compared to last year, the growing number of institutions that supported us must be taken as a sign that our initiative has been very well received and I think that’s very encouraging for the future. I’m therefore just going to say a few words about each institution, in the order, if I can put it this way, in which they came on the scene; you can see, by the way, all the logos of the various institutes on the banner decorating the platform. I’ll start with the French embassy in Morocco, which is represented by Mr. Pierre Appriou, scientific advisor, who’s going to speak to us in a few minutes about the bilateral programs between France and Morocco. I would like to extend to him my particular thanks, because his support allowed a large number of distinguished people, present here, to be able to make the trip to Casablanca. Next is the Institute of Trieste, the ICTP—International Centre for Theoretical Physics, founded by Abdus Salam, and which is a reference point for doctoral and postdoctoral studies in the Third World. It is represented here by its director, Professor Katepalli R. Sreenivasan, whom I thank warmly for having come despite, evidently, a very full schedule. This afternoon at the beginning of the session he will give an altogether extraordinary description of this institution. CIEMAT is the Spanish Research Center for Energy, the Environment, and New Technology. It is represented here by its general director, Juan Antonio Rubio, who organized the session on energy and who’s going to present it this afternoon at the second session. INSTN is the National Institute for Nuclear Sciences and Techniques, which is the university branch of the French Atomic Energy Commission. It is represented by Professor Dominique Gentile, who will present his talk this afternoon. There will be a slight change in the title, but that will be clarified at the beginning of the session by Professor Rubio. CIHEAM is the International Center for Advanced Mediterranean Agronomic Studies. It is an intergovernmental association of 12 countries, one of which by the way is Morocco, and it is represented today by Mr. Vincent Dollé, who is the director of the Montpellier center. Mr. Bertrand Hervieu, whom some of you heard in Marseilles when he was president of the Institute for Agronomic Research, is now the secretary-general of CIHEAM, and I have to say that he immediately welcomed our initiative. He provided us with substantial financial support, but unfortunately he also had an institutional duty,
R. Klapisch / Opening Remarks
5
for on this very day, one of the four centers of CIHEAM is opening a conference in Bari which he must attend as secretary-general. I thank also Mr. Bernard Bachelier, who is the former director of CIHEAM in Grenoble and who is beginning a new project in launching the Foundation for Agriculture and Rurality in the World, of which the acronym, FARM, is a bilingual wink. Mr. Bachelier accepted to take up the work of Mr. Hervieu for the session on agriculture and food security, which is important, for, at bottom, we are all concerned—because we all eat. I learned on this occasion that “food security” means that people don’t die of hunger while “food safety” means that people don’t die from being poisoned. Both are obviously important. Next, the Research Institute for Development [IRD] is an institute that is represented today by Mr. Henri Guillaume, who’s here. Mr. Henri Guillaume is the head of the Rabat office of the IRD in Morocco. I should say that historically the IRD was above all concerned with sub-Saharan Africa. During the Marseilles conference, Mr. Girard, who was and still is president of the IRD, met the Moroccan minister, and that is how the IRD office in Morocco came to be. So you see that there are already some concrete results from this Marseille initiative, which we took in 2002, in association with Yves Lancelot, of Brittany and Marseille, who is also present. Let’s move on now to the Canon Foundation for Scientific Research. This foundation spontaneously sent an observer to Geneva, who was entirely seduced, particularly by the SESAME project. I’d thus like to thank Dr. Tom Eagleton, who is the scientific coordinator, for having confirmed his support for us and for being here today. CERN, which everyone is familiar with, welcomed us last year on the occasion of its 50th anniversary. The general director, Robert Aymar, kindly agreed to maintain a certain support this year, although that is not CERN’s tradition—they usually support only those conferences that take place at CERN. We have thus an eminent representative of CERN here, namely John Ellis, who will lead, like last year, the session on the extension of the program to nonmember states, particularly the countries of the south. Professor Herwig Schopper, who is a former general director of CERN and the promoter of the SESAME project, will preside over a session on this project Tuesday morning. SESAME is a project sponsored by UNESCO for the Mediterranean region and the Middle East, and this project is as we speak under construction in Amman. It will be an international laboratory, a little like a mini-CERN: its statutes are modeled on those of CERN. Professor Carlo Rubbia, Nobel Prize in Physics 1984, former director general of CERN also, will present us this afternoon with his vision of the new energies for the 21st century. And I must say personally that, having formerly been with CERN myself, we are very honored by this strong participation of CERN, which proves that CERN is not an ivory tower (one could say moreover an ivory tunnel), but is very much involved in the problems today’s world is facing. Finally, for it comes last on the schedule, I am particularly happy to thank the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, NATO or OTAN (depending on if you’re Anglophone or Francophone), which, in addition to substantial financial support, gave us a special status: in NATO language, this colloquium is an Advanced Research Workshop, which is to say that with this status we are not supposed to be very numerous, and we should present recommendations in addition to reports.
6
R. Klapisch / Opening Remarks
These reports will first be published in English by a publishing house called IOS Press, and we can be assured there will be a wide distribution through all NATO’s distribution organs. We’re already on NATO’s Website. In view of the fact that some Maghreb scientists, or young Maghreb scientists, are not very familiar with English, we have arranged to also publish a French edition, which will appear in the AFAS journal Sciences. Paul Faugeras, who also used to work at CERN, has taken charge of the publication of the reports and he asks you earnestly to give him an electronic copy of your presentations and if possible also a hard copy. In addition to helping him with his task, you will be sure that in doing so you can give your thoughts all the nuances you intended. So it’s in your interest. I’ll finish up by saying that NATO, as I already told you, encourages us to offer recommendations, and this is very important. I think that the recommendations, which must be brief—anything longer than a page won’t be read—and concrete, could have a considerable effect. As you have seen, we have some working rooms and I believe that things like a fiber-optic network as well as the problems of women scientists or agriculture, or European integration, visas for researchers, etc., could be good subjects for recommendations, and I think it’s a great way for these recommendations to be followed up by actions. Thank you, and I’m going to hand the floor over to Mr. Pierre Appriou, whom I thank for being here.
Sharing Knowledge Across the Mediterranean Area P. Faugeras et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2006 © 2006 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
7
The Actions of France and the French-Moroccan Partnership 3 Mr. Pierre APPRIOU Science Advisor to the French Embassy in Morocco Abstract. France and Morocco have developed for long an intense partnership, especially in the domain of education and research. Most of these programs are lasting several years, are decided by sector-based thematic committees and involve large French research institutions. One recent action is aiming in particular at developing networks of young enterprises in Morocco.
I am very happy to see this meeting take place in Morocco. I think that when Mrs. Bornemann-Blanc came to see me the first time to present a request for support for your event, the French embassy responded immediately. For various reasons, by the way: scientific reasons above all, as the embassy is interested in all the diverse and varied events that are held in Morocco, and they are very numerous—I’ll talk about that a little later. But also for more personal reasons, Mrs. Bornemann-Blanc and I having a working relationship that goes way back. When I was president of the University of Brest, we established a scientific event in Brest together called “Science and Ethics,” which has been going on for almost 10 years now. So I responded enthusiastically to this appeal. First of all, I would like, on behalf of the embassy, to welcome all the French nationals who made the trip to Morocco, to assure them once more how glad we are that they’re here, and to express our keen interest in the implications this type of international event has for France. It bothers me a little to speak of the French-Moroccan partnership since I can see that there are not only French and Moroccan people in the room—but I believe that’s my role, as science advisor to the French embassy, to speak about the state of this partnership today. The French-Moroccan partnership is extremely vast and is supported by committees that I’m going to try to clarify for you as briefly as possible. First of all there are the sector-based and thematic committees (CST). There are five of these CSTs and they cover just about all the exchanges France and Morocco can have. So it’s extremely varied, and the CST that interests us today is CST No. 1, which is involved with education, in the broad sense of the term, higher education and research. The decisions or the recommendations proposed by these committees are then ratified by a council, the Council of Direction and Planning (COP), of the partnership. This council wants to be a decision-making council, but for it be so effectively, these recommendations put forth by the COP must, during a high-level meeting that brings 3
Transcription from oral in French and translation.
8
P. Appriou / The Actions of France and the French-Moroccan Partnership
together every year the two prime ministers of the governments of France and Morocco, be validated by the two prime ministers. This year, this high-level meeting will be slightly postponed. As a general rule it takes place in July, but this year, it will be held in October or November. To come back to the Education, Higher Education, and Research CST, I think that as far as the two latter parts are concerned, we find ourselves actually in an extremely important context which is that of changes in higher education around the world, and in Europe in particular. A conference that was just held in Tarragona in June 2005, of which I received, not later than this morning, the summary of the final declarations, shows all the work now going on between France and Morocco. I’ll read you just two or three points from this declaration from Tarragona: “The participation of universities in the building of a Euro-Mediterranean society turns out to be urgent and necessary,” and the universities in the countries of the European Union that were present at Tarragona “recognize the Mediterranean question as a priority in defining the political and cultural future of Europe.” So, I think that in fact the time seems to have come to create a Euro-Mediterranean zone for higher education and research. I think too that all the conditions have been met for Morocco to be the pillar in the creation of this EuroMediterranean zone of higher education and research, at the level of the Maghreb countries and the countries of the Mediterranean perimeter. So, what is the French embassy doing to try to help Morocco get integrated into this European arena of higher education and research? There are two kinds of actions: 1) First, a type of action tied to the budgetary annuity: these are research programs, integrated action programs, related to agriculture and agronomy. These integrated action programs consist in linking up Moroccan and French teams on a given subject, with financial support awarded to these teams for a period of normally four years. This program has been going on for twenty years now, and has allowed us to lay the foundations for an attachment, I think extremely strong, of Moroccan research to French research within the framework of a partnership that I would call very successful. A change was made last year to this integrated action program: for a program to be eligible, there must now be two Moroccan teams on one side and two French teams on the other, in order to work toward the creation of networks. We believe in fact that research should now develop around structural networks. Speaking of budgetary annuity, I’d also like to mention the aid for colloquia, which allowed for example the French embassy to help put together today’s meeting. These requests for aid for colloquia are extremely numerous, we must get a hundred requests a year, and can support 20 to 25 of them each year, with criteria such as that the colloquia be international, of course—and, also of course, favoring French colloquia. 2) Next, we have programs that last several years. These programs are being implemented within the framework of what we call Priority Solidarity Funds (PSF), since Morocco is part of the Priority Solidarity Zone. And these programs, financed by this Solidarity Priority Fund, are extremely numerous; I’ll certainly forget a few of them in the enumeration I’m going to make, but I’ll speak of the most important. There are two types of programs financed by Priority Solidarity Funds; those we call PI programs, meaning that they are managed directly by the French embassy, and then other, mobilizing programs that are managed by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs in Paris. In terms of the PI programs, I’ll mention two important programs: one new program put in place in October 2004 that is involved with supporting the reform of
P. Appriou / The Actions of France and the French-Moroccan Partnership
9
higher education in Morocco. This program has three parts: one part concerns the administration of the university; one pedagogy, with the setting up of professional training, professional licensing or master’s—since we’re within the framework of the LMD, which Morocco chose to follow, of course, which makes things much easier— and then a third part, which is involved in the restructuring of research and the setup of doctoral programs. So there you have a brief summary of this program financed by the Priority Solidarity Funds; it’s a program that’s going to be financed over the course of four years and it costs approximately 4.5 million euros. One program that has been going on for three years now and that is coming to an end involves enhancing research and bringing Moroccan small and medium-sized companies up to standard. Here it’s about a transfer from the university to small and medium-sized Moroccan businesses. I believe that this is an extremely interesting program, because three networks were put in place: a network of industrial engineering, a network of technological distribution, and a network called Moroccan Incubation Expansion Network [RMIE]: here it’s really the creation of mini-businesses out of research projects at Moroccan universities. And, at the end of three years, the results are starting to come in, and we can already envisage the creation of a dozen businesses from the research results from Moroccan laboratories. There’s still a year to go in this program—and the sum here is also approximately four and a half million euros. In addition, we have important new programs, which are this time PSF, thus mobilizing, which means followed directly by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs in Paris. The first is concerned with social sciences in the Maghreb. I believe that this is an area that has been a bit neglected, and the fact of instigating this social sciences PSF in the Maghreb is indicative of the new dynamic that’s come about in the course of the last few years. The first selection committee for projects for this PSF was held last May in Paris, and I believe the first results allow us to think that the new dynamic is under way and should allow this sector, which is a little bit difficult, a little bit delicate, a little bit political, to develop and give all its force and newness to the introduction of this new dynamic at the level of higher education and research. And then, next to that, there are a certain number of projects financed by Priority Solidarity Funds that have been running for several years: a CHORUS project, a SIRMA project—some of you at CIHEAM know SIRMA, of course, since a technical assistant from CIRAD is piloting this project, which has to do with irrigation systems in the Maghreb and not just in Morocco, a project that is important for the entire Maghreb. I would also say a word about a new PSF that seems interesting to me and I believe that the French Association for the Advancement of Science will also find it interesting, though you probably already know about it. It’s a project that focuses on scientific and technical culture, and I think that this new project, which is managed, incidentally, by the IRD, is very interesting. Finally a last project, which has not yet begun but which should soon, we hope by next October, which has to do with the mobilization of the Moroccan diaspora. And I think that we’re expecting a lot from this project of the mobilization of the Moroccan diaspora in higher education, research, but also in the medical field. On that subject, I encourage you also to be messengers for this project and invite Moroccans living in France to volunteer to help energize this last PSF, on the Moroccan diaspora. Of course, all these relationships, all this work is being done in close collaboration with the great French research organisms, all of which are involved: CNRS, INSERM, IRD, CIRAD, … IFREMER also in the field of marine science. I believe that all this
10
P. Appriou / The Actions of France and the French-Moroccan Partnership
work is extremely promising, extremely revealing of this exemplary partnership and, if there’s a message I’d like to convey, it’s that we act so as to help this partnership to last, and be reinforced, and help Morocco to integrate as quickly as possible into this European arena of higher education and research. I spoke earlier about the conference in Tarragona that just took place. In this higher education network, made up of Mediterranean universities and research centers, which will be supported by the political, community, state, and local institutions of the participating countries, the following recommendations were made, and I’d like to quote them, even if they’re a bit obvious: 1. 2.
3. 4. 5. 6.
Skill development Job growth for young people in sectors requiring significant cultural skills through a system that has been advocated for a long time, but that gets more and more problematic, which is the system of internships and pilot projects, entrepreneurial in nature, supported by the universities and the networks I referred to earlier; the RMIE is working toward that. Mutual knowledge, and I think that it’s important between young students, professors, researchers, but also administrative and technical personnel, through the reinforcement of freedom of movement, exchanges, and communication. Respect also for the Euro-Mediterranean cultural and environmental heritage through various channels, and I think particularly of the translation of texts. The development of Euro-Mediterranean programs for education, for interuniversity exchanges, and other initiatives to advance training and the diffusion of knowledge. Intercultural dialogue—and I think that today’s meeting is very important in terms of this—and the reinforcement of the humanist values that are profoundly immutable and profoundly anchored in all the countries involved—through the participation of civil society and then also academic freedom and the independence of universities.
And that’s the perfect place for me to hand the floor over to the president of the University of Casablanca, Mr. Berkaoui. Thank you for your attention.
Sharing Knowledge Across the Mediterranean Area P. Faugeras et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2006 © 2006 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
11
Welcome Address4 Professor Mohamed BERKAOUI President of Casablanca’s Hassan II University
Ladies and gentlemen, vice cultural attaché, esteemed professors, esteemed deans of the university, Mr. president, it’s with real pleasure that I participate today in the inauguration of the work of this important gathering in the name of Sharing Knowledge in the Mediterranean Countries. I apologize for being a little late for the opening of this gathering. Minister Habib el Malki as well as Mr. Ouali had hoped to come and honor the opening of this conference with their presence, but as you know, the constraints of this time of year got in the way, and I myself was also stuck in meetings. Mr. Ouali sends you all his best wishes and hopes for real success with your work. Professor Hoummada told me that perhaps, if the opportunity comes up or perhaps tomorrow evening, we’ll get a chance to see Minister el Malki and Mr. Ouali. Our university is very honored to welcome such a gathering which has brought together such prominent participants. Please allow me to welcome you on my personal behalf and on behalf of the Hassan II University of Casablanca. Many distinguished people have come from here and from countries with whom we have close relationships, to talk about the advancement of science and to share their knowledge on topical subjects that are acutely important for all the countries to the north and the south of the Mediterranean. I’m not going to go into the details of the program, which perhaps was already presented to you before I got here, but it involves some very important subjects that I would like to come back to, such as information technologies and communication which would without a doubt be indispensable for bringing together the people of both sides of the Mediterranean, and also ensuring for scientists especially a quick dissemination of information among them and the exchange of their knowledge and their know-how, which is necessary for progress. I would like also to mention the problem of potential natural disasters in the Mediterranean region, particularly those linked to earthquakes, to volcanic activity, in our region. Our region is also very aware of the importance of the desalination of seawater; water treatment concerns us, simply as a means to alleviate the lack of potable water due to drought which is increasingly impacting the countries on the perimeter of the Mediterranean. Without forgetting, of course, food security, the role of science in the development of the agricultural and food sector to ensure sufficient food supply; that requires the participation of our population in the fight against poisoning (various harmful poisons), emerging animal diseases and their impacts on human health. Energy problems are becoming acute, and Morocco is not spared, in view of the price increase for a barrel of oil—for Morocco imports 100% of its oil. We only have to see the rise in oil prices that’s going on right now to be convinced of the urgency of 4
Transcription from oral in French and translation.
12
M. Berkaoui / Welcome Address
finding new development solutions and other sources of energy: your gathering is exciting a fair amount of interest in this area. Those are several aspects of the problems that will be discussed during this gathering and which will serve as a backdrop for sharing knowledge and bringing each other up to date in these areas, and also for seeking to develop a new kind of partnership between scientists in the south and their counterparts in the north. And of course, not just concerning science, but also sharing experiences in terms of education and research. As mentioned by Mr. Appriou a few minutes ago: in a partnership and an exemplary cooperation between Morocco and France, but also with other European countries and countries of the Mediterranean perimeter, our country joined the international education and research system and in particular the “LMD” international system. This years marks the third year that Morocco and Moroccan universities are applying this reform, and I hope that these significant reforms will bring us even closer to European scientists and those of the Mediterranean perimeter and around the world. This third year was made possible thanks to the sharing of knowledge between the countries we have close relationships with to try to benefit from experiences on both sides—and I won’t come back to this point which was already touched upon by Mr. Appriou—with the French and foreign cooperation to develop the administrations of our universities which today are enjoying pedagogic, scientific, administrative, and financial autonomy. This poses challenges, of course, in terms of our structure and of improving our internal and external efficiency to benefit the sustainable development of our region, of our country, and of our planet. Besides the administrations, there’s the educational aspect of the reform, and thus the use of new teaching methods, such as distance learning, e-learning, the virtual campus. All of this is aimed at a coming together to foster the expansion and development of our respective countries. But the changes won’t be lasting without quality science, fundamental science, of course, a science of development, a science of action, to accompany this process. And so, we have worked together with you to try to, as I was saying, get the most out of our successful experiments, on both sides. Our university, following the example of the 13 other Moroccan universities, is also in a crucial phase of structuring research so as to create favorable conditions that will allow our scientists to concretize and perpetuate their scientific production as regards innovation, and also new creations. For all these reasons, we are honored to welcome this gathering which will examine topics that are relevant today, and we want to offer, in conclusion, our best wishes for the success of this gathering—may it manage to achieve the objectives laid out, especially a bringing together of the participating scientists from both sides of the Mediterranean. I don’t want to finish without congratulating the organizers, whom I worked alongside, and whom I saw work hard to make this event a success. You all know as well as I do that to succeed at such a challenge isn’t easy, and I salute their determination and their investment. Yesterday as I watched the news on television I saw our professor of the French Association for the Advancement of Science, Mr. Klapisch, who was presenting this event. I can tell you that this conference is echoing very favorably throughout the region, our ministry, and the Moroccan scientific community, and I thank him very warmly. And of course I mustn’t forget the local organization committee, the professors of Hassan II University, who supported the scientific commission and the research and
M. Berkaoui / Welcome Address
13
cooperation commission with Hassan II University and all the other bodies starting with the French embassy, who supported this event. I am convinced that the results of your work will be very rich and will have a definite impact on the development of research; I’m sure it will lead to the establishment of a dynamic cooperation, fruitful and mutually beneficial to our Mediterranean regions. Once more, I wish you great success in your work and I thank you for your attention.
14
Sharing Knowledge Across the Mediterranean Area P. Faugeras et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2006 © 2006 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
Welcome Address5 Mr. Pascal COLOMBANI President of AFAS, Paris It’s a very great pleasure to be here and to find in such a convivial atmosphere so many distinguished guests for this event which, as I’m going to explain to you in a few minutes, is part of a series of conferences and colloquia on north–south scientific dialogue. Robert Klapisch has already thanked the many organizations who came to our aid, so I’m not going to go over that again. I would like however to make special mention of the Institute for Nuclear and Particle Physics, the universities Hassan II, Aïn Chock and Ibn Tofaïl, and the support of NATO, which allowed us finally to put this colloquium together—with, of course, the usual worries in terms of logistics and various other problems, but with nonetheless a bit of breathing room. To give you a little historical background, the French Association for the Advancement of Science is a very old association founded by Claude Bernard whose glory days were in the past until fairly recently. It had entered a kind of lethargic phase until Robert, a few years ago, pulled it out of its slumber by directing it in a very specific way toward a dialogue between society and science and technology: How do we make citizens better understand the importance of science and technology? That’s what we’re trying to do with means that are not considerable but that also are not nonexistent. We have several events in France that we’re involved with at all levels. We organize seminars that are open to everyone; it’s almost popularizing, but it’s very important, because it’s very successful. We put them on in partnership with the Conservatory of Applied Arts; we also work with the Palace of Discovery in Paris for other kinds of seminars that we put on regularly. We also have seminars with what we call “decision-makers,” meaning heads of industry, heads of the private and public sectors. Interestingly enough, these people are, of course, vaguely up to speed, but in fact not very up to speed at all with the major issues in science and technology. In addition to these regular activities, we launched, four or five years ago, more specifically this north–south scientific dialogue. We began in 2002, I believe, in Marseille with an event that cost a lot—though in the end we managed to recover—and that event had the merit of launching the topic in a very extensive, very vast manner. So vast that for the following conference, which took place in Geneva, at CERN on the occasion of the 50th anniversary of CERN, and with the support of CERN—thanks once again for that—we narrowed our focus, our meeting was smaller, a little like the format we have today and in which, like this year, we try to look at the big subjects: energy, health, food, freedom of movement, communication, the environment. It’s an occasion to examine these big subjects, yes, and perhaps not all of them, but with a fairly limited scope, and having here those distinguished persons who bring a great deal to them through their work and their thinking. 5
Transcription from oral in French and translation.
P. Colombani / Welcome Address
15
So what we’re discussing here, finally, are the big subjects of science and technology, and those whom these big subjects concern, which we’re going to look at today and tomorrow and the day after tomorrow: energy techniques and technologies, telecommunications, genomics, information technologies, sciences of the Universe. We can say, finally, that there are things that have changed, that are changing the world. When we talk about the digital divide, when we talk about genetically modified foods, when we talk about energy, after all these last years have brought us the genome, also the Internet, also the sun. In the end it’s a triptych—the genome, the sun, the Internet— which is changing how we build the north–south dialogue in the scientific and technical fields. We’re also addressing how we can develop scientific knowledge and so we’ll talk about SESAME, a specifically Mediterranean project. We’ll also talk about many other things, like the diffusion of knowledge and ways of life, because we also have to think about these somewhat sociological aspects: how to do all of this and what context it all brings about. So this year we have a special roundtable on the place of women in science and technology. I believe in the importance of these dialogues. It’s especially important that we know what naturally different perceptions our female colleagues bring to this largely male environment. It will be interesting to hear how these things can be or are seen by our colleagues, and how they can change—in particular how the relations between the sexes can be, in a way, redefined in our countries. So, to leave time for this roundtable, which is very important, I’m going to stop there and thank you for your attention.
Session 1 Extension of the European Research Area to the Mediterranean Convener: Jean-Patrick CONNERADE Imperial College of London President of Euroscience, Strasbourg
As an introduction of this afternoon’s session, I would like to remind you the agreements which were signed in Lisbon and in Barcelona, and which were aiming at transforming our European society as a “Knowledge Society”, an expression in vogue. Of course, all human societies are aiming at that goal; this project is indeed universal and puts the scientists at the center of our cares. In fact, the number of researchers and their level will determine what will happen to this “knowledge society”. This afternoon, we will look at the context in which researchers will work and how they will be welcomed in our societies. The sociology of the scientific world is part of the sociology in general, but it is admitted now that the place of the scientists should be at the centre of this new society. Therefore, we should ask ourselves the following questions: What should be the working conditions for researchers? − How the societies of tomorrow will attract and valorize them? − How can we evaluate their work and their potential? − How can we attract young people in the research field?
These questions are essential as they will touch upon our economies. Let us start with an example of the successful welcome of scientists in ICTP, the international laboratory founded by Abdus Salam, and whose role is essential for our countries.
Sharing Knowledge Across the Mediterranean Area P. Faugeras et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2006 © 2006 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
19
ICTP as a Model for Excellence for Doctoral and Post-Doctoral Training in the South6 Katepalli R. SREENIVASAN Abdus Salam Research Professor Director, ICTP Trieste Abstract. Founded by Abdus Salam and established near Triete, ICTP main goal is to make the most advance scientific knowledge available to everybody, especially the least advanced countries. Visitors coming from all over the world for a variable duration can continue there their own research or follow specialized courses. Links with local institutes are being developed, to follow and continue helping visitors, in particular in Africa, but are difficult to implement because of the lack of Internet communication means.
The frontiers of science have been expanding very rapidly at least in the last 100 years or so. For many institutes in developing countries, it is often very difficult to catch up with all the advances and to actively participate in making these advances. So many different schemes have been devised how to involve developing countries, not only in catching up but also in actually pushing the frontiers of science. ICTP, the International Center for Theoretical Physics, is one example of an organization that builds a bridge between developing and developed countries. Its goal has been to make the most advanced scientific knowledge available to everyone, including the least developed countries so that infrastructures of high level research can take roots in those countries. So that is the theme of our institution, and for instance, when Morocco is embarked on a new scientific ventures and cooperation with its neighborhoods of the North, it seems like a brief account of how ICTP functions, what it does and where it succeeds and why it succeeds. So it may be useful to explain these points and this is in this spirit that I offered to make the following presentation. I will start by following the suggestion of the convener of this session and by saying a few words about the history of ICTP. This Institute was founded more or less 40 years ago by Abdus Salam, who was the Nobel laureate in 1979, and whose work had direct connections with Carlo Rubbia by the way. This is an institution which operates under the tripartite agreement between two United Nations agencies, UNESCO and AIEA on the one hand, and the Government of Italy on the other. This is really a very important arrangement because the international character gives us an umbrella that makes it possible for this institution to be international, that is, for people from countries like Morocco for instance, to come and feel that the institution belongs to them. On the other hand, as you will see, the Government of Italy plays an extremely 6
Transcription from oral in English.
20
K.R. Sreenivasan / ICTP as a Model for Excellence for Doctoral and Post-Doctoral Training
important role because it actually funds for a very large amount. The mission of the center is to foster the growth of advanced studies and research in developing countries. As I said before, UNESCO and AIEA have given some money, and also we get some money from SIDA, the Kuwait foundation and others but about 82% of the budget comes from Italy. This country has been extremely generous in doing this and I think it has come within the culture of Italian scientific community for many years. An institution like ours is not only interested in creating knowledge, which of course many other institutions are always involved in, but in sharing it with others, which is at least as important. This is working the principle with which the Center works. But just for those of you who don’t know where ICPT is, the Figure 1 shows Europe and Trieste in the upper eastern corner of Italy. In the enlarged part, you can see Trieste here at the bottom and a few kilometers to the north, we have this campus where ICTP is located. There are number of other institutions that came up since ICPT was created, with ICPT’s leadership, not only in ICTP campus but also in this area, on the east of the city in the Science Park. ICPT is a part of institutions that actually have involvements in developing countries. Elettra, about which you will hear more perhaps tomorrow, is not far away. It is also another institution in which Carlo Rubbia was involved in, and which is interested in scientific capacity building up in developing countries.
Figure 1.
Now, let me say a little about how we are basically organized. We have 28 or so “permanent” scientist, permanent between quotation marks because within the UNESCO there is nothing permanent in general, but that is the general idea. These persons are involved in research, some of them are actually full state scientists and we would like everyone now to become full state scientist to have them fully involved in research and training coordination.
K.R. Sreenivasan / ICTP as a Model for Excellence for Doctoral and Post-Doctoral Training
21
We also have 110 temporary staff which includes about 52 or so post docs, staff associates – these are people who have acquired a name in their own countries in science and they come and spend some time with us so that they build bridges between themselves and us. Some of the temporary staff are long term visitors who have to write a book for instance, or who have a sabbatical leave to spend. We welcome such visitors and they do mostly research. Finally we have about 420 people in any given year that are short-term visitors, among them are our associates. These people, who are associates with the Centre for something of the order of 10 years, come almost every year or every other year sometimes, for about two months or so, and I will show you some statistics about Morocco for instance. Associates are people who have careers of their own in their own countries, but use ICTP as the means of keeping contact with the rest of the community and actually doing things that they could not do at home because they are bound by too much teaching or too much bureaucratic stuff and things of that sort. This really forms the core of the research activities in the center, but what makes the center somewhat even more special is that we usually have 4,000 to 6,000 visitors every year: 6,191 in 2003 and a little bit more in 2004. These visitors participate in many conferences and school programs and workshops and sometimes these are pedagogical trainings at the very frontier of the subject. It depends on the purpose of a particular program: the programs are organized by our scientists here along with the help of a number of other scientists in the rest of the world. So the Center works not only because of people who are there but also because of the connections it has with a number of other people outside.
Figure 2.
22
K.R. Sreenivasan / ICTP as a Model for Excellence for Doctoral and Post-Doctoral Training
Of course, to take care of this many visitors, to get visas and accommodation and so on, we have about 125 general staff. So that’s the nature of the institution in general. Figure 2 shows statistics between 1970 and 2003, (we did not have any statistics before 1970 and I have not been able to put the 2004 statistics yet). Basically, we have many visitors and person-months from United States and Europe. In fact the largest numbers of visitors we get are from Italy and from Western Europe because we are close to Italy and to Western Europe. But by and large, if you take out the Western Europe, the United States and part of Russia for instance, the rest is really developing countries in some general sense: Latin America, Africa, Asia, China and other Oceanic countries including Australia. So if you add them all up, you will get about 100,000 or so visitors for these many years, 50% from developing countries and 50% from the developed countries. The idea is in fact to mix people of different experiences, different backgrounds in such a way that they learn from each other mostly rather than from the people who are there permanently. Although there are only 50% visitors from developing countries, they spend 75% of the amount of personmonth that is, they spend more time in the center than people from industrialized countries. Figure 3 shows how the number of visitors has grown up with time. It is due mostly on how generous Italy has been with the money in some general sense. For the last few years, although we haven’t had any increase in money, we have squeezed more things and then we have made it possible to have more things within the center. ICTP visitors: 1964-2004 7000 6000 5000
Visitors from "Hosted activities"
4000
Visitors from developed countries From developing countries
3000 2000 1000
64 /6 68 5 /6 9 19 73 19 77 19 81 19 85 19 89 19 93 19 97 20 01
0
Figure 3.
Now let me come to what research gets done at ICTP and why it is done that way. The High Energy group is traditionally very strong; it has been very strong because of the interest of the founder and now we have expended it to include cosmology, astroparticle physics and condensed matter. There is also a statistical physics section, applied and pure mathematics, then an applied physics section, which includes medical physics, optics, lasers and fluid dynamics and so on. We then have a new section on earth sciences, which includes weather climate changes, oceanography, earthquakes, all the sciences that you are particularly interested in some of the remarks that were made
K.R. Sreenivasan / ICTP as a Model for Excellence for Doctoral and Post-Doctoral Training
23
earlier. We even had a program, or have had a program on environmental and ecological economics, and many other centers in fact are connected to us for this. I have to make something like a common sense statement here, which is: it is very important for ICPT to have a strong core of research activity. ICTP cannot be like many other UNESCO organizations for instance, because if we don’t do science, it is not possible for us to influence other people to do science and we have to do good science, not just any science. This is something that has been in our mind very deeply and we keep to this idea as much as possible. Now many people may ask why this emphasis on High Energy Physics and similar matters for developing countries? Who cares about High Energy Physics in developing countries? But actually my answer has several aspects and I want to spend a minute or so on this subject. Let’s say somebody from a developing country - Morocco is an exception in this case as there are many people interested in High Energy Physics here - let’s say somebody from Uganda wants to do High Energy Physics. Who am I to tell him that this is not for him and that it is only for people in the Institute for Advanced Studies in Princeton? For people like that there must be a place in the world to come and do this sort of stuff. I use High Energy Physics; and I know that CERN is of course a great institution that allows for it. But for such things, ICTP is in fact the place where many people have come. And secondly, if you really train yourself to do something in a rigorous way at some point in your life, this will really remain with you for the rest of the time and it is important to gain rigor in one’s way of thinking, otherwise it is impossible to do anything of some value. Furthermore, I actually believe, and I know this is the case, that the tools that one uses in one of these fields can be transferred to other areas. For instance I know people who have worked in let’s say cosmic microwaves, background radiation and use the analysis for mapping of the data, have in fact use the same kind of ideas for mapping, for instance, the farthest regions in Rwanda. Finally, we are also talking about sustainable development. Sustainable development has in fact very old problems such as providing in general clean drinking water and similar basic things. Even there, high end of technology can be extremely beneficial and CERN in fact has been using this idea in general. I can give you many examples where high end technology has been useful for age old problems of sustainable development goals. In many cases they consist of the trained people who have acted as nucleus for other institutions. This is not wishful thinking, it’s actually true. I know some of those people, who were trained and educated in ICTP. In addition, I must say that we have many programs on a very large number of domains even though we don’t have expertise within ICTP ourselves. We then involve others who are experts in these fields, but I don’t want to take you through all this stuff. We also built a new section on earth-based system physics, which consists of physics of climate systems, physics and predictions of earthquakes, and soil physics and alternative sources of energy, upper atmosphere. All of this is of direct interest to many developing countries. So this is my rapid answer to what we do and why we do it. In addition to the core activities, we take students who have just finished their bachelor’s degree in many of the developing countries and who are very bright people but don’t have the right sort of training and the right sort of education in order to go into research. These students of that level are 20 to 23-4 years old and come for a diploma program in ICTP. They spend a year or so taking courses in different branches of physics and mathematics. For the group that has just been graduated a few days ago, the students were mostly from the least developed countries. In a batch of 39 or so, 8
24
K.R. Sreenivasan / ICTP as a Model for Excellence for Doctoral and Post-Doctoral Training
are from Africa, 11 from Asia and Middle East, 4 from Latin America and 2 from Central Asia. Out of the 500 students or so we have had, 60% of them have entered in graduate schools and have done extremely well. Many of them remain connected to their own countries and we are planning new grades on applied mathematics and systems physics. This, I think, is another avenue in which young people who are very good are taken in at low level and then raised to very high level in general. Since we are in Africa and pretty surely, Morocco regards itself as an African Country, I want to spend a little time on the involvement of ICTP in Africa in the creation of affiliate centers in the rest of the world. (See Figure 4). These centers are small centers, but there the level of activities is very high. By creating many such small institutions around, the general idea is that it will be possible to raise the level of science everywhere. ICTP has been instrumental in creating about 14 affiliates centers; 6 of them are in Africa as shown on Figure 4. One of them is now closed unfortunately, but nevertheless the others are generally working very well. There are also many so-called external activities that we support in Africa, such as meetings, topical schools and workshops and so on. In Western Africa for instance we have, over time, really invested a lot on Mathematics through a concerted effort. Year after year, our people go and teach courses and arrange other activities, like networks of people, graduate programs, and so on.
Figure 4.
K.R. Sreenivasan / ICTP as a Model for Excellence for Doctoral and Post-Doctoral Training
25
To go back to visitors and fellows, these people are expatriates who want to go back to their countries for some time. We help them financially a little bit, as for associates. Out of the 256 associates we have, about 30% of the total are from Africa, and the STEP program has been set up for them. It concerns people who want to do PhD: they have to get the degree from their own countries and be registered in their own countries, but they come and spend half of their time in ICTP in order for them to get connected with the rest of the world in some general sense, with ICTP in particular. We also have the so-called PIL fellows, who are people coming from developing countries and spending some time in Italian laboratories, These people spend about a year or so in Italian labs, they are funded by ICTP to a large extent and the rest of the money comes from those institutions. We are also constructing some other programs in Kenya and other places. Now this is just to give you a general idea where people are coming from, in particular from Africa. From Morocco, for instance, we have as you can see, 785 visitors to ICTP and there are 5 institutions collaborating with ICTP in general. As you can see we have focused the large on the Western part of the continent and much on the East, and of course there is a large part that, for whatever reason, which has not been much involved in ICTP. One of the last things I want to talk about is the following: although our interest is mainly in physics and mathematics, in a very broad sense, it is not just very narrowly defined, but still, sometimes we get involved in projects which are outside of it in some sense. Let me give you an example to illustrate this. Previously, we used to supply books and libraries’ subscriptions to a number of scientists who had problems in getting all the literature. Today, the world is very different and literature has to be obtained electronically. But the bottleneck is that there is not much connectivity, especially with Africa. If one compares the cable traffic between let’s say United States and Europe and the one with Africa, you can have a rough idea of what the problem is (see Figure 5).
Figure 5.
Another way of looking at it this is the bandwidth between US and Europe and between Africa and US or Europe. You can see it is really a pittance. In fact in many
26
K.R. Sreenivasan / ICTP as a Model for Excellence for Doctoral and Post-Doctoral Training
places in Africa, if you want to download an issue of the Physical Review Letters, it is just almost impossible because you just log on to the network and then wait and wait. By the way Morocco is maybe an exception, as it almost never happens. Under these circumstances it is very hard for me to understand how anybody can do physics. This is why we have been pushing many institutions to provide the infrastructure for Internet Connection. We on the other hand will take care of providing access to technical literature, scientific literature through connections with publishers and other institutions and also provide training courses to really have some idea how to use that technology for instance. Another aspect is the quantitative measure of the speed of the Internet in Africa towards the rest of the world, shown in Figure 6 as a function of time starting in 1998 up to 2005. Don’t worry about the precise quantity with which the speed of the Internet is measured, it is actually measured by sending a pulse and then finding the time it takes to bounce back. On the left map are the institutions where the survey has been conducted, in fact there are two in Morocco, I think. You can see how North America has been doing and Europe actually falls fairly behind, but where is Africa in general? You should also understand that this is not necessarily inclusive of all the African countries, some of which I have ignored. As you can see in this right part, Africa is much worse than the rest of the world. This is why we are involved in such projects dealing with the Internet, only because these are vehicles by which you can communicate the knowledge that is essential.
Figure 6.
I must say that part of the problem comes from the government control in some sense, and in some cases, this is also coming from the cost for a certain quantity of Internet connectivity. Look at Nigeria for instance, the problem here is not coming because of the government regulations and other restrictions, but from the cost, which is almost 100 times higher than in the USA for the same bandwidth, which makes it extremely difficult for you to set up such connections. And therefore, one of the things we do is to try to improve that situation through different projects. One of them is to supply articles electronically through e-mail, but this is a very complicated affair. Let me finish now with three statements. The first one is that we try to look for skilled individuals, independent of which country they come from and of what the international standing of their institution is. I
K.R. Sreenivasan / ICTP as a Model for Excellence for Doctoral and Post-Doctoral Training
27
think this is very important, as even very poor institutions in poor countries have some very skilled individuals. Of course, we have to identify them, and this is a lot of hard work; it is not going to just happen like this. It is very easy to pick up the best people from Harvard or some place like that because they are in fact all very good, but the point is that if you want to pick up people on whom it is worth spending some time and effort, you have to do a lot of work. So this is one important thing. What we also do, or try to do anyhow, is to pick up the brightest scientists, without regard for reputation of their institution or the scientific target of their country, and set them in a position such that they can build their own activity in their own country. When this eventually happens, some of them do that and become involved in public life of their country, and we support them for a reasonably long period of time of the order of 10 years. There is no point in letting someone come at ICTP for three months and then forgetting about him. Absolutely nothing will happen if you do it like this. To the contrary, you should have a sustained connection for these people. Unfortunately we should be able to do more but we can’t. But whatever we do we do for a large period of time and capacity building means that, at some point the people involved must do something substantial with their hands and their minds: they just cannot come and sit in the lecture room, just nodding their heads and going away. They have to do something, they have to do research, they have to write something, this is a very essential point. The next thing is that institutions have to be transparent, and this is what we try to do. If we don’t have transparent institutions, good individuals cannot do very much. So this is another important aspect and we try very hard with various institutions. Institutions must also have steady sources of support, just like individuals, free of political interference I would say. We cannot do much there, this is a bit beyond us, but still we try to help people in many different ways. This is why ICTP gets engaged with politicians and ministries and other bodies, even though it is not our business directly. Like individuals, new institutions need the support of important people and other institutions. Networking is thus essential, and we support their creation quite often, but networking cannot replace a solid work and the effort of individuals. This is something I constantly keep saying, it is essential: networking is fine but you ought to have substance before you go do that. To sum up, among ICTP’s associates, we have had one President of the Republic, which is very nice, 11 ministers, deputy ministers, 2 members of parliament, 7 advisors to presidents or prime ministers, different presidents of University, deans of faculties and heads of institutions. I will conclude with just how a few people perceive ICTP, although this is obviously selective. For instance Lorenza Matsuri from Milan basically says: “The most important contribution of ICTP is the concept of excellence and at this, ICTP has been the most influencing institute in the world to bring that into existence”. In other words, we keep the goal of doing something really well: there is a big difference between doing things, and doing things well. That is a point that I constantly make. We have similar comments from Vietnam, for instance, which says: nearly every PhD physicists in East Asia has had an associateship with ICTP. What he says about East Africa is pretty much true of all sub-Saharan Africa in general. Finally, we don’t forget that this is happening in Italy, because for us it is very important to be connected to our neighbors and because Italian physicists have done very much for our center, not mentioning again the financial support of Italy to ICTP. I want to end this talk with a somewhat high note by citing what Mr. Andreotti, who used to be foreign minister in 1984, said from us: “This Center can make an effective
28
K.R. Sreenivasan / ICTP as a Model for Excellence for Doctoral and Post-Doctoral Training
contribution to the solution of the central problem of humanity, namely that of peace. Of course, this is true of all international institutions, CERN and other institutions they don’t really talk about peace all the time or almost never but somehow, by working the way they work, they contribute to peace. So this is my few things about ICTP.
Sharing Knowledge Across the Mediterranean Area P. Faugeras et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2006 © 2006 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
29
Training and Career Development of Researchers: the EU Context7 Georges BINGEN European Commission, Directorate General Research Abstract. My presentation will be an outline of the EU context, and will in particular include a brief presentation of: • Marie Curie actions open for co-operation with 3d countries • Charter/Code Training and career development of researchers are key in research policy. EU actions include general policy actions as well as financial instruments.
1. Financial Instruments (Mainly Marie Curie Actions) • • •
For many years (since the sixties) there are EU training fellowships; transfer of knowledge measures; as well as excellence promotion measures. In FP6 (2002-2006): €1.8 Billion; i.e. +/- €450 billion/year. A proposal for FP7 has been presented with the following specifications: doubling b of the requested budget; continuation of general FP6 philosophy and most of its actions; however also with a few extensions, of which in particular a new scheme for cooperation with 3d countries.
2. Policy Actions Since 2000, the European Research Area (ERA) concept provides a frame for an integrated approach including both the Community actions, i.e. not only RTD framework programmes, but also the coordination of EU and Member States research policy. Since 2002, EU Lisbon/Barcelona objectives, a knowledge for growth pact, reflects the need for more researchers (estimated to an additional 700,000 researchers, on top of the required 500,000 to replace the researchers leaving for retirement by 2010). 2.1. Action Line 1: Mobility Strategy Researchers benefit from mobility experiences of all types: international mobility as well as mobility between sectors. It creates experience, connections, networking, research contacts and generates cooperation. It needs therefore to be encouraged. 7
Original text in English.
30
G. Bingen / Training and Career Development of Researchers: The EU Context
But there are obstacles to the mobility of researchers (legal, administrative, social, and practical). Actions at community level include: • • •
Network of 200 mobility centres to provide practical support to mobile researchers; Eracareers Mobility portal, a unique web portal linking all web sites including information for mobile researchers, including job opportunities; EU (Visa) directive to facilitate entry conditions for non-EU researchers; recommendations to Member States to speed up visa delivery for short visits; etc.
2.2. Action Line 2: Career Development Policy Europe needs more and highly qualified researchers, but research careers are not attractive compared to other careers in Europe, and to e.g. US. There is therefore a tendency for the best brains to leave Europe. Actions have therefore been taken at Community level to ensure the recruitment and retention of researchers in the ERA: • •
Raising public (including policy makers) awareness (e.g. Researchers in Europe Initiative). Recognition of researchers rights and obligations, and commitments from research organisations (employers) and funders to respect and support researchers careers: the European Researchers Charter and Code of Conduct for the recruitment of researchers. These two instruments are a Recommendation from the European Commission to the Member States, employers, funders and researchers. They are the fruit of broad consultation of the scientific community, and reflect a broad consensus on the principles included. The Charter and Code are implemented on voluntary basis, and constitute a reference point for the career management of researchers, with an aim to assuring a supportive research environment and working conditions. They are expected to create a genuine (attractive, open, sustainable) European labour market for researchers.
Sharing Knowledge Across the Mediterranean Area P. Faugeras et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2006 © 2006 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
31
Evaluation, Criteria for Excellence 8 Jean-Pierre BOURGUIGNON CNRS – Institut des Hautes Etudes Scientifiques Abstract. The author has been involved in a number of evaluations of individuals, institutes or even countries. Although performed in his own field, i.e. mathematics, the experience gained over the year is valuable for other science domains and show that evaluation is essential for insuring excellence level and must be adapted to those being evaluated, researchers, structures and countries.
Thank you for inviting me to make this presentation, whose title “Evaluation Criteria for Excellence in Europe” was not exactly mine. The only transformation I made to the title was to add a comma after “evaluation”, as I think it changes a little bit the meaning. I also dropped “Europe”, because I felt that what I want to say is really general, even if my own experience is rather based either on Europe or America. So let me start my presentation by just giving few points of reference, simply for the purpose of saying that a number of things are probably biased mainly because of my personal professional experience. 1. Some Reference Points As a professional, I am a mathematician. I have been therefore working in theoretical science for quite some time, which at one extreme point of the scientific spectrum. I’ve been working at CNRS for already 37 years, but for five times in my life, I spent one year in different foreign countries: Japan, United States, Germany and a few others, China, and some several months in European countries. I have been also teaching in a University which is actually an engineering school, of a very special type, namely the Ecole Polytechnique. As part of my duty now, I have been appointed as the director of a private foundation, which is the Institut des Hautes Etudes Scientifiques, which is a very specific and completely international structure: last year we had visitors from 32 countries and in the last ten years, 54 countries visited IHES. The way we are organized is very much having in mind to bring scientists from different disciplines and have them working together. So, although I am a mathematician, I am used to deal with physicists and more recently with biologists because we started a new venture into molecular biology. The next point I want to make here is very directly connected to my topic: this is the fact that I did participate in a number of evaluations just as a mathematician but sometimes also with a broader spectrum. In particular I have been involved a number 8
Transcription from oral in English.
32
J.-P. Bourguignon / Evaluation, Criteria for Excellence
of times in recent years, in evaluating disciplines at a national level which, I think, was a very interesting and stimulating experience. For example, I was involved in the evaluation of mathematics in Canada as a country, UK, Austria; I am supposed to do something for Australia next February. So I have been involved in this special exercise of trying to tell a government or an agency where a country stands in terms of its level of development. The bias I wanted to speak about is, you know, that mathematicians tend to be elitists, so in some sense I must have not escaped this influence, and a number of things I am going to say tend to be elitist, but I think one has to deal with that. Another thing, to which I have been really very sensitive as a mathematician, is the fact that various disciplines function differently. This is something which is very often really overlooked, and I will be a bit critical to the Commission about that, because the Commission tends to completely uniform rules of all disciplines, which I think is a disaster. Anyway I am going to comment on that later. One point to note is that evaluation covers very different levels. The first is individual people, second level concerns laboratories or institutes, and last level is the discipline and the skills of the country. I really believe that, although we use the same words, namely evaluating, the methodology and also the way you can use information, the way you can take advantage of what you have found, are extremely different at various levels and therefore one has to be very careful in generalizing from one level to the other. Another point, which I believe is the heart of the matter, is that, in a sense, science, and in particular scientific research, is something for which the quest for excellence is really the motivation for getting the system working. Therefore if you can manage to get the system in a way that the quest for excellence is indeed recognized, it will have a very important influence on the way you structure the whole system. That is something I really have witnessed and I have seen a typical example of it in the case of Portugal. When Portugal joined the European Union, the situation, at least for my discipline of Mathematics, was not so extraordinary. There were some good laboratories but in general the level was very traditional. And the minister in place, who actually is the present minister - he was not minister all the time but has this position again - asked a group of people to evaluate the situation for Portugal. None of them was Portuguese. I must say that in 10 years the change of the situation has been absolutely dramatic. The whole point here was really to forget about local power but just to get outside people to look at the situation and propose for changes. So I really believe that if you take seriously this quest for excellence, you can have a very substantial impact on the way the research functions. Another way of saying what I just said concerning the way you can get to excellence is that, if you don’t follow this way and if you keep excellence evaluation being in the hands of friends of local people, the impact can be extremely negative. Therefore, it is absolutely crucial that the selection of people who evaluate be based purely on the competence level and a few rules concerning independence and making sure that people are really outsiders. 2. Conditions for a Successful Evaluation Let me go to what I see as an essential condition if you want to have successful evaluation. I want just to list a few points, which each time I will try to give a reason
J.-P. Bourguignon / Evaluation, Criteria for Excellence
33
for it. I already said that, research is done in very different ways depending whether you are theoretician or an experimentalist, and you also have to take into account the differences between disciplines and the different kinds of research you are doing. Taking into account this diversity is absolutely fundamental, and is not always done, which is very unfortunate. The key reason is exactly what I said: if you take a community of researchers, it has its own mode of organization, which of course has often very good reasons to exist, but sometimes the reasons are not so good. Another point is that, depending on the disciplines you are working in, your timescale is a different: if you are planning an accelerator like CERN has been doing, the basic timescale is more or less 20 years. For some other disciplines, the reaction has to be much quicker. Very often in industry also people know that they have to come up with a project very, very quickly. So you have to take these differences into account which means that the ways in which you are going to do the evaluation has really to respect these differences. Last point is of course that, even the signs of recognition are not the same. As mathematicians we tend to be very international in some sense, and it is quite unusual that there are some local, I mean national schools, although sometimes you find some twisted ways of looking at problems. One definitely has to be very attentive to the differences in recognition. Another thing which I learned, and which, I must say, I missed for some time, because I just believed in the words, which was a mistake on my part, is that, very often, the function you assign to a person with very well defined title is not the same from one discipline to the other. Just take the case of a postdoctoral fellow. As mathematician usually you can really start a new activity in a place by hiring a postdoctoral fellow; you are expecting that he comes already with a research program, which can really bring a new sub-discipline in the lab. It so happened that we had no system for postdoctoral fellows for long time in the French system. There was a very small program, which we called the Bresan Fellowships, which was taken care of by the ministry of foreign affairs. At some point I was asked to evaluate this program and I spent two days in the ministry looking with big pile of files. When looking at these files I was very shocked on the first day, but after a while I understood that I just missed something, which was the completely different nature of the letters of recommendation for postdocs in biology and those in mathematics or computer science. Basically all letters for postdocs in biology were describing the kind of techniques the person was really mastering, and essentially no words on the new ideas on his or her thesis. For mathematics, it was the exact opposite. The letters described what the new ideas that the person had brought were. This was clearly explaining that these different people were not expecting the same function in the lab. One has to be very careful that, with the same title, namely postdoctoral fellow, you may not expect at all the same implications or the same impact on the lab in which the person is coming from one discipline to the other. I want to make some more points. As I said choosing the evaluators is very difficult, but the kind of working conditions you offer them is also important. By working conditions I mean for instance, will the evaluators have the possibility of defining the kind of documents you are going to give them or do you decide a priori that they will be given this pile of documents and nothing else? I think it is very important for evaluations of a certain scale, that indeed some evaluators, maybe not the whole group but at least the chairman of the group, be associated with the kind of documents that he would like to have. In the same way I think it is extremely important,
34
J.-P. Bourguignon / Evaluation, Criteria for Excellence
if you want to have efficient evaluations, that also the program of visits is not something which is decided by the sites, by the visited places but also by the evaluators. So the evaluators should be given the opportunity to define the methodology they want to use, the kind of people they want to work with. Personally I have been always extremely strict about the fact that I really wanted to meet the young people separately from the advisors and spend quite some time with them. Sometimes it does not please some of the people in charge, but I think it is very important to give an opportunity of free speech without nobody from the institution and to listen to what could be said by the younger people. In conclusion, I think that what I call the working conditions or the boundary conditions of the evaluation, are not something of secondary importance because it could change completely the way the whole evaluation goes. The next stage is also very important: of course, in many organizations, evaluation is part of the system, but depending on how you set it up, you could have actually the evaluation not as a help for improving, but actually an obstacle for developing. Let me give few examples in the case of evaluation of people. Of course a typical moment where you evaluate people is when you want to promote them. And I must say, for having witnessed that at the CNRS, that because of actually lacking positions, it is very clear that one of the difficulties in improving interdisciplinarity is very much directly related to the way the procedure for promotions is implemented. Promotions are very difficult to get, people are more or less waiting in line for years to get their promotions, and many people have the feeling that if they don’t do what they are known to be the best at for some years and try to do something else, basically they ruin their chances for a promotion. So one has to be careful that evaluation can become actually an obstacle and not an incentive for people to look into pluridisciplinary programs, depending on how it is set up. Another example which I want to give, is in the United Kingdom, which has developed something, which I think was considered by many people as very important progress: it is called the Research Assessment Exercise and is a national committee which was set up and basically gives the grades to every lab. From these grades you get the basic level of financing. But actually the way it has been set up means that the unit which is really responsible for defending a given lab is the University in which this Lab is sitting. As a result, if the research team is really organized in a group, coordinated actions between small groups in different Universities, basically at different places, these groups are small enough that they are not seen by the administration as vital, and consequently, even if they are performing remarkably well as a group because they are really working together in a very organized way, finally such an activity is completely negated and it disappears from site, if you put too much emphasis on such an assessment exercise. And we could see this effect when we did the global evaluation for the United Kingdom for Mathematics: a number of networks which had been producing remarkable research works were completely disappearing from the organization just because the R&D research assessment exercise has made them invisible from every University where they were located. So clearly if you put in place a system which a priori looks nice, because you have a very thorough system of assessment, it may result in killing some kind of research activities. Of course that was not the intention of people who put it to work, but you need to point to this, I mean, difficulty. Another thing that I already mentioned, and which is something extremely important, is the fact that there are several structures, such as European Union and
J.-P. Bourguignon / Evaluation, Criteria for Excellence
35
European Commission, where they definitely want to have a completely uniform system of applications or complete uniform system of evaluation for all programs. I must say that, at least for the case of Mathematics, we have seen from European Commission that number of things have been actually going worse and worse in a sense that it was basically impossible to get a number of activities formulated in a proper way: even if you looked at the forms you had to fill, basically it was impossible to put anywhere everything which was significant. And as a result, you were really caught in some kind of impossibility of really making your case in the proper way. So when you are doing an evaluation, you need to recognize and to already take into account the format of the valuation the discipline you are evaluating. This is, I think, extremely important. 3. Evaluating Individuals As I pointed out already, it is very important to make a difference between evaluating individual people, evaluating Labs or Institutes, and evaluating disciplines at the National level or even European level, for several reasons. Let me just mention a few things. The evaluation of individual people is of course something which is very natural, and it is practiced by the scientific community in many different ways. When you submit an article to a journal, you are evaluated, as there is an editorial board that is looking into it, there are referees, and so this is something which exists already. For physics, almost all universities or institutes have a system, in which the thesis is not just read by the advisor but also by outside people with a reference. Many universities are also practicing systematically looking for outside referees when they want to promote people. So in a sense the practice of evaluating is already something which is completely accepted and in place for individual people. The key point is to make sure about independence of the people who make the judgment. Actually it is very difficult to avoid at some stage some self-recruiting, or, let say a system which is completely a closed market, where people who give opinions are actually people who have already a deal with the people who are evaluated. This is extremely critical, particularly for France: if you look at the spectrum of disciplines, the attitude of the community towards self-hiring is quite variable. Hiring people that you have trained can go up to 85%, for one discipline I will not mention, while it is only 16% or so for another one. This shows there are really very wide practices between these two extremes, and I think in the long run it makes a huge difference : if you are in a system where self-hiring is the rule, and if you stop to make an exception, people are really caught in a very difficult situation. If you don’t want to practice self-hiring, they have to send their people elsewhere, and of course some are hired nowhere, so you have to make a very voluntary measures to really make this change. This is typically what happened for Portugal, where the ministry was really extremely strict on this point. I must say that on a 10 years scale this is a remarkable success, but you have to be very tough at some point, and actually to refuse the means for people who want to practice self-hiring. Also, it is very important to identify and really give to people who are competent the opportunity to give their opinions. Actually this is something which all systems in the world are extremely tempted to avoid. One prefers to use very automatic system to do evaluation because, relying on the opinions of people seems to be very fragile and
36
J.-P. Bourguignon / Evaluation, Criteria for Excellence
also very difficult: people may change their minds and the opinions they express are sometimes a bit ambiguous, so it looks so much better to use automatic impact factors or things like this. I must say, as a mathematician I feel this is terrible. In fact, my own opinion on impact factors is that basically you can use them only when you know enough on the work, which means you don’t need them. So, one has to be very careful with the use of such systems. I am talking here of the evaluation of individuals. It is a different thing when you want to evaluate the value of an activity at, for example level of a country, even at level of institutes, and I will make some comments later. Personally as far as evaluation of individuals is concerned, I would really refuse to consider these things, which doesn’t mean one doesn’t have to look into the publications of these people, whether they have been publishing or not. But the point here is that the number is not the key factor, the key factor is the quality, and who can assess the quality but competent people? I know of most of the mathematicians: some are very famous people who have extremely few publications and some are extremely good people with many publications, and what makes the difference is of course what they have done, not so much how many papers they have published. Impact factors have a number of very negative consequences also: they tend to push people to publishing many papers, no matter what the quality is. At some stage, it’s extremely important to leave researchers, time enough to do ambitious work, to look at difficult questions. And if you tackle difficult questions, most likely you are going to need time to do anything substantial. I wanted to make this comment on the need for some patience when one talks about evaluating researchers, the need for relying on the judgment of competent people, and independent people, which is crucial. My last point concerning individuals concerns young fellows, young researchers. It is extremely important that one considers them in a special way, because it is very important that they know that they should take some risks. If they don’t learn young enough that they have the possibility of taking some risks, they will certainly not do it later. They would be tempted just to do some more technical work later, which may be all right, but they really could have done some more. So I think one has to be very careful. So from that point of view the initiatives which have been mentioned in the previous talk, and the fact that young people, in particular at the post-doctoral moment, should be given enough time, are very important. Postdoctoral fellowship with only one year is something, which should not exist any more, because, as soon as you get the job, you have to look for the next job so how can you do something of substance if you are given so little time? I know that very well because my own institution has a lot of difficulty in practicing long term commitments, but I think it is very important that a very special attention be given to young researchers. 4. Evaluating Structures Concerning the evaluation of research structures, I want to stress again the need to really to leave enough room for differences, for different scales, for the kind of research they are doing and so on. It is very well known that in many disciplines, financing projects has really become the heart of the financing of research. And I think this is very reasonable. On the other hand, if this becomes too important and is really the essential part of the money that labs are receiving, and in particular if this financing goes in short term projects, it can put the whole institution not in a good position to
J.-P. Bourguignon / Evaluation, Criteria for Excellence
37
prepare its future, and it will force people to just look for very narrow-minded and short-focused research programs, which is not good for the long run. Of course, you can have periods where times are difficult and you can concentrate the use these financial means, but it should not be done too systematically. It is very important that institutions have a balanced situation between some kind of long term commitments that they will be supporting, so that they can really think without too much pressure about what they want to do, and some other part of the activity which then could be very directly linked to projects. Another thing which I could witness by practicing evaluation which is also very important in particular if you keep in mind excellence: excellence is not something which comes from outside, but is also something which is very much felt in the lab itself or in the institution itself. The evaluation has really three parts. One part is this preparation period where people are just between themselves. The evaluators have not yet shown up, maybe they have more or less defined what kind of documents they would like to receive, but the people in the research structure are really facing the problem of preparing their documentation but also, they have the responsibility of choosing what will be their program for the future. So this part should not be missed. The phase during which people prepare documents for evaluators, is a very privileged moment, because it forces to internal discussion: where people are, what will be their priorities, basically whether they will be very ambitious, a little bit ambitious or not ambitious at all, etc. As this is an important moment, people should be given enough time to prepare this. The second part of course, the time of the evaluation itself where the evaluators and the people evaluated are confronted, and the last part, which should not be missed of course, is the moment where the evaluators give their opinion and how do you implement some of the recommendations or you refuse to implement the recommendations, anyway this kind of final interaction where the institution itself responds to the evaluation. For research structures I tend to be extremely critical with the idea of using systematically impact factors because very often the quantitative feeling you get from this impact factors quickly supersedes the thing which I think for me should be dominating, namely the quality and qualitative statements. Coming now to the last stage of evaluation, which is typically to look globally at a discipline, in a region, in a country, it seems to me one has to be very careful. What is a discipline? Of course, universities recognize some disciplines because of the histories behind them, but there are also emerging disciplines. It is very important at some stage that one accepts the idea that there will be some new disciplines showing up, that at some critical times new science is coming up by bringing together several disciplines, and so on. This is something, which has been very much of concern to the EPSRC, the Engineering and Physical Science Research Council in the UK. They decided to do a very systematic evaluation of their disciplines, and when they were finished the first round, they realized that by having divided science into physics, chemistry, computer science, mathematics, actually they missed some of the most the important part of their activities. Of course they were a bit shocked because maybe it meant that some experts who have been in charge of some disciplines should have looked more at the boundary but actually that was not so easy. For the part I was in charge of namely mathematics, where we wanted to look at the boundary with the computer science, we realized that some of the universities had agreed on doing so, but some others refused because they said we have already been evaluated for computer
38
J.-P. Bourguignon / Evaluation, Criteria for Excellence
science, and they did not want to be evaluated twice. So, when you define a territory, you have to be very careful not missing some very important territory beside it. Another point which is also very important is not to do too much evaluation: if you ask people to write reports too often they start not to write reports carefully, and that is the worst. I already mentioned that it is very important to have the evaluators involved when defining how you want to do the evaluation. It is really important to leave them this intellectual autonomy, and I must say that most of the time if you do this at the level of the country, the best way is to have no nationals involved. So this was the case for Portugal, this was also the case for the UK, and I must say that I am presently in a very difficult battle with Australian people because in the format they have proposed, there are many more nationals that non-national people in the committee and I feel it is not the right way of doing things. As I mentioned, the preparatory phase is extremely important and of course the choice of the team which is given the responsibility of doing this preparation, is something which has to be thought very carefully, and I must say that the success depends very much on this. 5. Conclusion So now, the key point of course is how do you take into account these new expectations and you don’t want to frustrate people too much? How you do the follow-up is a non trivial thing. I want to point out that if you are involved in evaluation, it is a very good way of creating some kind of common culture and common references. It is very important also in this process that you give an opportunity of having several points of view expressed. By doing so, it could really prepare a group of scientists to look into different ways research can be organized. I am thinking about French people who believe that the French way of organizing research is the best in the world, and they never looked at how it is organized elsewhere. That is Franco-French comment. The final point, of course, is that scientists should not forget that they are doing their work in relation with the society and producing this kind of evaluation could be, should be a very important moment also for scientists to prepare themselves to this relation to the society at large. Thank you very much. J.-P. Connerade — So thank you very much Jean-Pierre for the very perceptive account of how difficult it is to evaluate in an already international context. Now, by observing strict time, we have few moments for some discussion of these three presentations. I hope you have them all in mind. They were three very clear presentations, I think covering most of the themes which are important in the management of science, if you like, in the government of science.
Sharing Knowledge Across the Mediterranean Area P. Faugeras et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2006 © 2006 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
39
Scientific Studies and Careers for Women in Tunisia9 Oum Kalthoum BEN HASSINE Professor at the Faculty of Sciences of Tunisia President of the Association “Women and the Sciences” Abstract. Women have gained access to education in Tunisia more recently than Western countries. They more or less catch up but are suffering the same kind of problems: weak diversification of scientific careers, concentration of women in a limited number of scientific professions, higher unemployment rate. One remedy would be to insure parity in the juries for examinations.
At present, it is widely accepted that the full access of women to education confers upon them the status of agents of economic and social change. In fact, education is a human right indispensable to progress in all areas. This is why the program of action adopted in Beijing in 1995 during the Fourth World Conference on Women identified the universal and equal access of women to education and training as a critical area requiring priority action by governments and the international community. That is how today, certain criteria, such as the literacy rate and the percentage of children in fulltime education according to gender, constitute indicators of human development, for education is a prerequisite for sustainable development, which cannot be accomplished without the equal and full participation of women. To secure their futures, countries need the capabilities and creativity of all of their citizens. This is all the more true when it comes to access to the sciences and to technology, which are both generators of wealth and thus indispensable to development. Economic development depends on the acquisition and mastery of scientific and technological knowledge. The latter represents the key to success in a time when competition between nations is based on intelligence. In this context, the full and equal participation of women in the sciences provides, first, for an increase of the human scientific potential of the country and, second, for a greater diversity in the development of scientific knowledge and the formulation of new ethical norms for science and technology. Nevertheless, access to the sciences depends on the right to education. Tunisian women acquired this right in 1956 when one of the first measures taken by an independent Tunisia was the promulgation of the law of personal status. Among these measures, the establishment of free and compulsory schooling allowed the realization of significant progress in terms of girls’ access to all levels of education, including university, of which today the quantitative results are indisputable. Tunisia is in fact unique among Arab-Muslim countries for the legal status of women and the integration of women into the economy and society. 9
Original text in French, translated in English.
40
O.K. Ben Hassine / Scientific Studies and Careers for Women in Tunisia
A look at recent statistical data of percentages of students according to gender reveals that in recent years it is in fact women who have been responsible for the growth of the total university population, since certain faculties (medicine, law) and several tracks (medicine, biological sciences) have seen a significant increase of women students. Improvements in the percentage of children in full-time education have, in fact, gone hand in hand with a progressive reduction of the gap between girls and boys to the girls’ advantage, such that in universities today girls represent approximately 57% of the student body. Compared to their counterparts in Mediterranean countries where free and compulsory schooling for girls is a relatively long-established fact, Tunisian girls have, since they acquired access to education, mostly caught up. They are today more numerous in high schools and in universities, generally better students, and more persevering in their studies. (For the sake of comparison, in France, female students make up approximately 56% of the total student population.) However, despite this considerable breakthrough, girls still hesitate—in Tunisia as well as in most countries, including developed countries—to choose a course of study in technology or the sciences. Most women still opt for the humanities. Looking at all the analyses of recent statistical data (2000-2004) it can be seen that in Tunisia the presence of women in the scientific tracks has definitely increased in recent years. More young women, simply put, are studying science. Nevertheless, their number varies considerably from one track to the next, the highest percentages being recorded in the hard sciences (in secondary school), and in medicine and life sciences (in universities) [3]. This unequal specialization is, in large part, already determined by secondary school, where math and science act as filters and where the choices made by girls, who are fewer in number in the most valued baccalaureats, limit their study and career options [8]. This has an impact on the directions taken by female students in higher education, where one finds the same tendency, and where girls are underrepresented in certain technical and scientific tracks (engineering, physics, math, etc.). Indeed, even those—and there are many of them—who in high school tend toward the track of hard sciences go on to study medical and life sciences (female students representing more than 60% of the total number of students in medical and biological sciences). This situation is not specific to Tunisia (where schooling for all girls, and their access to higher education, are relatively recent accomplishments), for the slow integration of women into the sciences is widely shared, including in developed countries, where, although schooling and access to universities for girls are long established, the opening of scientific education to women is a recent conquest (Hermann in [10]). In France, as in Tunisia, girls are better represented in the various levels of education (girls representing more than 56% of the total number of students in France), and get better results than boys, but their tendencies don’t reflect their capabilities, for the majority of girls tend toward the humanities and social sciences (72.7%), and those who do choose science find themselves in the tracks of life sciences and health sciences (61.7% in medicine), which is judged very suitable for them (Hermann in [10]), since women seem to aspire to help, nurse, and care for others or even to teach, inform, and communicate… in short, activities that are traditionally considered feminine. The problem of the disparities between men and women in the sciences is thus to be found in all countries. Generally speaking, girls tend less than boys toward certain scientific and technical tracks and abandon training that offers better access to the job
O.K. Ben Hassine / Scientific Studies and Careers for Women in Tunisia
41
market, such as technical, computer, or engineering training, the recruitment for which, however, is considered to be particularly important for development [12]. According to certain studies and investigations conducted especially on the northern side of the Mediterranean [11], the unequal distribution of girls in the various scientific tracks is directly related to their own motives and to the image they have of these professions, which are different from those of boys. Boys are more interested in job opportunities, in hoped-for remuneration, and in prestige. Girls are looking more for social usefulness. Moreover, students often have a strong positive image of tracks that lead to more practical opportunities associated with professions (engineer, doctor, lawyer, journalist) which appear to them to be clearly defined, and which often provoke either a strong attraction (doctor, for girls) or a strong rejection (engineer, also for girls). On the other hand, for the more “generalist” tracks, such as sciences and humanities, the image seems more vague—or still more stereotyped, in that the opportunities seem at the same time fewer, less well-remunerated, less varied, and essentially geared toward teaching for humanities and research for science. Finally, there’s a demand, more frequent when it comes to girls, for a professional life that is compatible with family life, which is felt to be especially difficult in the professions of engineer and researcher. The consequences of all the above can be summarized as follows: − a weak diversification of scientific careers for women − the concentration of women in a limited number of scientific professions − a higher unemployment rate for young job-seekers who find the sectors for which their qualifications suit them already full. In Tunisia, where the law favors male-female parity on all levels and is well ahead of other countries, and where the collective conventions of employment reserve the same treatment for both sexes, an analysis of the published studies—mainly by CREDIF—on the question of the employment of women revealed that they occupy an unequal position in comparison with men on the job market, principally because of the lack of diversification in their training and professional qualifications [5]. This situation, as emphasized by the European Commission, is neither equitable, for women find themselves kept from the best jobs, in terms of pay, prestige, and social responsibilities—nor effective, for it deprives our societies of a part of their intellectual resources—nor efficient, for, to train many women at the highest level and then not use their skills is a waste. To this must be added the fact that women are absent from the spheres of power and have therefore little influence on scientific policies that determine the larger paths countries will take. Today, more than ever, sustainable development depends on equity in the sciences. This will not, however, be established until the talents of both men and women are made use of. In this context, the similarities revealed between France and Tunisia concerning the place of women in the sciences should constitute an important argument for building a true egalitarian partnership in the Mediterranean, renewed and reinforced. Indeed, the common future of this region requires cooperation that will encourage equal opportunities [4]. At a time when “commercial partnership and exchange” is strongly advocated, cooperation is necessary to ensure that neither side of the Mediterranean excludes its female citizens. To that end, the formation of a Mediterranean group qualified in the
42
O.K. Ben Hassine / Scientific Studies and Careers for Women in Tunisia
matter of equality in the sciences, along the model of the Helsinki Group for Europe, could constitute the most important link between the northern and southern sides of the Mediterranean. In conclusion, the development, on the periphery of the Mediterranean, of cooperative programs ensuring the promotion of equality between men and women through the exchange of positive experiences north/south and south/north, and best practices, could, as Edgar Morin put it so well, prevent Europe from closing in on itself [4]. Further reading [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11]
[12] [13]
Association Femmes et Sciences, Femmes dans les métiers scientifiques et techniques, Actes du Colloque organisé le 17 novembre 2001, Ministère de la Recherche à Paris, 2001. O.K. Ben Hassine, Femmes en Sciences : obstacles, défis et enjeux, Revue tunisienne des sciences sociales 118 (1999), , Pub du CERES, 11-26. O.K. Ben Hassine, La place de la femme tunisienne dans les sciences : analyse de la situation actuelle et perspectives de développement, Afkaronline Edit., 2004, 81-101 et sur le site : www.afkaronline.org. O.K. Ben Hassine, Femmes, Education, Sciences et Culture; in Proceedings of the Mediterranean Forum Conference «Women, Agents of change, A Mediterranean Perspective (Lugano, Suisse, 13-15 février 2004), 2004. O.K. Ben Hassine, Participation des femmes tunisiennes au développement : Etat des lieux de leur intégration au marché du travail; Afkaronline sur le site : www.afkaronline.org, 2004. O.K. Ben Hassine, Les Femmes dans les Sciences exactes : une approche comparée, Communication présentée au CREDIF lors de la célébration de la journée internationale de la femme le 12 mars 2004, 2004. O.K. Ben Hassine, Les Femmes dans les Sciences exactes : le point de la situation, Info-CREDIF 31 (2005). O.K. Ben Hassine, Les technologies de l’information et de la communication (TIC) et les femmes tunisiennes : enjeux et actions, Afkaronline sur le site : www.afkaronline.org, 2005. Commission européenne, Women and science: Making change happen, Proceedings of the Conference, Bruxelles 3-4 avril 2000, 2005 Hulin N., Les Femmes et l’enseignement scientifique, collection «Science, histoire et Société», Edit. Presses Universitaires de France, 2002. Accès des jeunes femmes aux études universitaires scientifiques et techniques : recherche commanditée par la Communauté Française et le Fonds social européen, menée par l’Institut de Sociologie et la Faculté des sciences de l’ULB sous la direction de M. Ala-luf et P. Marage, Newtonia (Rechercheaction in Faits & Gestes, 2004), http://www.egalite.cfwb.be ; http://ulb.ac.be/newtonia. Les études et les carrières scientifiques au féminin : Débats & Recherches en Communauté française Wallonie Bruxelles, Faits & Gestes 12 (2004), Site internet : www.cfwb.be. C. Solar, Savoirs des femmes et développement durable, Colloque International « Femmes, Sciences et technologie » ;(Tunis, 20-22 novembre 1997), 1997.
Sharing Knowledge Across the Mediterranean Area P. Faugeras et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2006 © 2006 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
43
Women in Science and their Role to Advance the Societies from the South10 Nora BERRAH Physics Department, Western Michigan University, USA Abstract. The past century has witnessed the scientific contributions of women rise significantly in many areas of science and in many parts of the world. We hope that in the new century this positive trend will continue, enabling increased numbers and retention of women in the sciences and, in addition, facilitating the leadership of women at all levels of academia, national laboratories, and industry.
Progress in the 21st century is taking the form of globalization in many areas, particularly in the fields of research and industry. Any such globalization can be achieved successfully only with the utilization, collaboration and mutual respect of all partners involved, regardless of race, religion or gender. The status of women in science has improved tremendously since the 1950’s. We now have female faculty in scientific departments, albeit in small numbers (between 5%-10% in physics, the lowest percentage in the sciences, and about 40% in biology). Women are not generally found in leadership positions such as Chairperson, Dean, Provost, Group Leaders or CEOs of companies, although a few (less than 1%) has achieved that role. I will present in this brief article my experience and perspective as a female physicist who grew up in a country from the South, Algeria and who earned a “Diplome d’études superieures” (bachelor of Sciences degree) in theoretical physics before pursuing a PhD in atomic and molecular physics in the USA. My experience in Algeria as a physics student at the University of Bab Ezzouar in Algiers was very positive. In fact, in 1980 Algeria had about 40% female physics students compared to less than 5% in the US, most of which were foreigners. In Algiers in 1979, I had one female professor but a few female Teaching Assistants. The present status in Algeria consists of 10%-15% of female professors and 40% of graduate students. I believe that North African countries benefited from the French role model provided by Dr. Marie Curie, and thus female scientists or students willing to pursue a career in science are not seen as oddities and have always been well accepted by the establishment as well as the rest of society. I have also been fortunate to have had a very positive experience while training as a PhD student at the University of Virginia, as a postdoc at Argonne National Laboratory and as a faculty at Western Michigan University where I hold a University Distinguished Professor of Physics position. I am also fortunate to be in an institution that truly believes in equality for the genders and the races and is an equal opportunity 10
Original text in English.
44
N. Berrah / Women in Science and Their Role to Advance the Societies from the South
employer. Presently, the president and the provost are both female. Three years ago, the president was African American, and the Dean of my college, Arts and Sciences, was a female. Other institutions also have diversified pools in their leadership positions but much remains to be done, not just in the societies of the South, which I think are more progressive professionally than is thought, but throughout the world. I believe that in order to retain and increase the number of women in science, we need to recognize and accept the fact that female needs can be different than those of the male. The most important difference that comes to mind is motherhood. During a woman’s career, the natural wish to become a mother may arise. Institutions should amend the present system in order to have this or other important needs met. This is a fundamental compromise that should be done for the sake of respecting differences. Tenure timetables should be allowed to stop for 1-2 years in academia, and industries should permit women to take a maternity leave of at least 3 months, without any penalty of losing one’s position or role in the work place. This is unfortunately still a problem in most societies of the North/Western countries with only a few exceptions, such as Sweden. I believe that there are a number of important factors that would enable an increase of women in science. Parental as well as teacher encouragement at all educational levels from kindergarten to high school and from college to graduate school are crucial. Teachers should make every effort to target and include women who have the abilities and interest in all technical and scientific activities that school offers. In my case, my math teacher targeted me in middle school and channeled me to the math/physics high school branch. I was planning to go to the biology branch. Constant reassurance boosts women’s confidence when they enter a male dominated field. The media could play a positive role to represent and portray successful scientific women. By and large, however, this is not presently the case in the US where female scientists are generally portrayed as unattractive, unpopular or incompetent while their male counterparts play the role of hero. These media portrayals are bound to perpetuate the perception that women are not cut out to be scientists and we need to insure that movies as well as documentaries illustrate prominent women in science as well as show collaborative efforts between men and women in laboratories where women play a significant role in the achievements of scientific breakthroughs. We all have a responsibility to inform and educate the media about the new realities by showcasing successful women scientists of today. Role models are very important, and thus institutions ought to hire competent females at all levels, from assistant professors to full professors as well as in leadership positions such as Chairs, Deans, Provost, President, CEO, etc. Although we live an era where affirmative action is being debated, my personal position is that for equal qualifications, institutions should give priority to female until the ratio of women to men increases. The debate over what constitutes an acceptable ratio is still inconclusive; however, suffice it to say that 10% and below is unacceptable in this day and age and 50% may be a positive goal to try to achieve. My general recommendations to increase and retain women in the sciences are the following: 1.
The workplace (Universities, laboratories, industries…) needs to accommodate female scientists by allowing flexible schedules that will permit their needs to be fulfilled. This doesn’t have to be exclusively for women and indeed should be a general, thoughtful policy that would keep any scientist happy.
N. Berrah / Women in Science and Their Role to Advance the Societies from the South
2.
3. 4.
5. 6.
45
The workplace should designate mentors to help new recruits to learn about how to become a successful scientist. As senior scientists know, success is linked not just to ones scientific abilities but also to understanding workplace policies. The mentoring often happens naturally among men, but not generally between men and women and there are not enough female scientists to take on that role. Thus, senior male scientists should take it upon themselves to mentor junior scientists, both male and female. The workplace should support all its new young employees with financial start-up packages to facilitate rapid successful research programs. The workplace should not overload its new employees with services that will hamper the research endeavors of its scientists. This occurs mostly in universities where services are part of faculty responsibilities and in general, women tend to be assigned more than their share of services to the department, college and university. Release time in the form of sabbaticals is extremely important to keep learning new techniques and to broaden one’s research portfolio. The workplace should promote competent women at all levels when they deserve it so that they may play a role model for new generations of scientists. My recommendations to thesis advisors are the following:
1.
2.
Mentor your students closely and give them responsibilities. Ensure that female students feel part of the group and are not mistreated in any way by their male colleagues. People’s sensitivities vary, and we all have to be alert to differences and treat students and colleagues with respect and sensitivity. Find means to allow students to travel to national and international conferences to present their work. This will give them a broad perspective of the scientific world as well as motivate them to increase their research efforts and stay in the field.
My recommendations to PhD students who would like to be in charge of an independent research program are the following: 1.
2. 3. 4.
It is important to have one or two postdoctoral positions in different laboratories to broaden and deepen one’s ability to develop a research program. The choice of a permanent position needs to be done carefully since workplaces vary with respect to their level of commitment and support to their employees. For large scale science, or for scientists of “users” facilities, chose collaborators cautiously as failed collaborations can be destructive in many ways. Participate to national and international workshops that guide and teach strategies to overcome conflicts in the workplace. Try to resolve any conflicts in the workplace amicably by trying to understand the nature of conflicts when they arise. Most conflicts are due to competition and that competition occurs among men, between men and women, and among women. Conflicts should not be taken personally and should not be interpreted necessarily to be due to gender or prejudice issues, although this sometimes can be the case. Human nature is not perfect and we need to deal with it intelligently by trying to put scientific goals ahead of the day to day irritations due to competition, sexism, and prejudice. Clear communication is key, compromise among all parties is essential and if all fails, it can be necessary to involve the workplace supervisor/director/Dean/Provost or President. Do not accept unacceptable
46
N. Berrah / Women in Science and Their Role to Advance the Societies from the South
compromises that you can not live with if you think rationally that they are biased and unjust. In conclusion, I believe that all scientists have the responsibility to advance all societies. Since women represent about half of the population, we all need to make strong efforts to encourage them, include them and facilitate their integration and promotion as scientists. In particular, women of the South can and should play a key role in their societies in order to allow their societies to advance and catch-up with their Northern counterparts. The latter should continue and even increase their efforts in creating more exchange and training programs between the North and the South in order to bring about a scientific balance that may make important contributions to economic and political stability.
Session 2 Energy for Development Convener: Juan Antonio RUBIO Director of CIEMAT, Madrid
Sharing Knowledge Across the Mediterranean Area P. Faugeras et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2006 © 2006 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
49
Novel Energies for the Future11 Carlo RUBBIA 1984 Nobel Prize in Physics Former Director General of CERN Abstract. Nowadays, energy is a severe problem for the mankind, not only because of the population explosion but also because human beings are calling for less poverty and better life. Fossil energies are limited and pose severe problems. New forms of energy can be expected from solar energy and from nonproliferating nuclear energy in various forms (Thorium cycle fission, nuclear fusion). Developed countries are urged to largely invest in the development of these new forms of energy, as this is their duty for the whole mankind.
Ladies and gentlemen, thank you very much for having invited me to give a presentation here today. I have to say, that I was hoping to leave the presentation for solar energy to one of the speakers who is not here today. Now, of course it’s very hard for me to change a presentation like this at the last minute, so I apologize from the beginning for the fact that maybe someone may find this presentation being too shifted towards nuclear rather than solar energy. Juan Antonio Rubio is going to discuss the question of solar energy in Spain, he is a person who is rather involved on the practical industrial application of solar energy, but I believe there was also space for a fundamental contribution on that matter. Solar energy was discovered already by Archimedes 2,000 years ago, when he tried to fight against the ships of the Romans. We checked that and we found indeed that could have been done: the numbers are such that he could have thrown them up. But the real problem now is not so much to know what the basic physics are but about the ability to produce an industrial amount of this energy and this is certainly something which is new to us. 1. The energy problems 1.1. The population explosion So let me start my presentation. We will discuss a few general subjects and then I will get on into the practical problems. Now, first of all, the underlying problem to everything we are doing today is the problem of the explosion of the populations and so it is worthwhile to ask ourselves why we have this and what are the reasons for the population to explode so quickly. You can see on Figure 1 a diagram which explains today’s thinking of what is the demographic transition. This is not an exponential explosion. It was considered an exponential explosion in the good old days of the Club of Rome (with Peccei et al.) but now we understand things in a very different way. 11
Transcription from oral in English.
50
C. Rubbia / Novel Energies for the Future
What we understand about this is that we are going through a number of phases in the human kind. In the first phase, we have high rates of birth and high death rates. So both are very large and balanced obviously, with the result that you find that you sit on a very low level of population, which is the standard level prior to the present demographic transition.
Figure 1. The demographic transition
Then, the death rate has decreased thanks to medicine, to better health, to more food, so people live better and better and the life expectancy, which was something like 29-30 years in the times of the Romans, is developing into something which is 70 to 80 years now and therefore very much larger. Surprisingly enough the birth rate continues to be high because this is a part of the society and this is the way it works. So we have declining death rate but a continuing high birth rate. The next step is that also the birth rate becomes under control: people realize that there are various different ways to organize society other than making children, that such a rate is not longer a justified situation, and therefore also the birth rate decreases, but it comes after, later, because this is a decision while the other one is fact of life. Finally, we come back with another situation in which both the death rate and birth rate are very small and presumably equal. But then, however, what is left over is an enormous change of population. This enormous change of the population has been estimated now by many models and many arguments and is in the order of 10 to12 billion people. This will occur across the next 50-100 years with a transition which will be different between rich countries and poor countries. Developing countries are still in the early stages of this process while in the fully rich countries the birth rate is in fact much smaller compared to the death rate. Just to give you a feeling of this, let’s take a look at numbers: in 1700 we were 600 million, in 1800 we became 930 million, and in 1900 we were 1.6 billion, in 1950 we were 2.4 billion—1950 for many of us was like yesterday—, in 1985 we were 5 billions and in 2020 we will be 8 billions. So we are now dealing with an explosive population growth which is today in the order of 90 million new people per year. 90 million is a very large number. The whole of the European Union of 25 countries are 300 million people, which means that in 3 and half years you make another European Union again. Everybody agrees on the fact that the future progress of mankind will be
C. Rubbia / Novel Energies for the Future
51
impossible without energy. With that many people and with no energy, you have really a very serious problem, and therefore my conclusion is that energy is necessary to preserve mankind: without such a thing we would not be able to preserve steadily mankind. It would be a disaster. 1.2. Energy and Human Life The second point is to understand a bit better what the situation is for the individual energy consumption. In the very advanced countries, it has increased a hundred fold since the beginning of history. The various stages of development have brought increasing energy consumption. In the present moment, today, each of us is producing of the order of 100 kg of CO2 per day. Incidentally I have to tell you that each car is producing 4 times its weight of CO2 for every year. So when you look at your car, think that every year there will be 4 times as much the weight of the car in terms of CO 2. And when you think that there are about a billion cars, you know what the problem is. On a more philosophical level, you could ask yourself what is the situation about the equivalent per year and you can see on Figure 2 a plot showing Egypt, Greece, Rome, the beginning of Christian era, the discovery of America, and then we have the industrial revolution and suddenly the industrial revolution has created a demand of fossil energy which has been accumulated for millions of years. Today in one year we are recovering roughly the amount of raw material of the fossils which is produced in one million year. So one million year to build it up and one year to burn it.
Figure 2.
Of course, everybody knows the situation; the fossil energy will be over in a certain moment. With some 12 billion people hanging there in this planet, there will be a question in front of us: Which primary energy source will be our alternative solution?
52
C. Rubbia / Novel Energies for the Future
Now we know also that energy consumption per person now is incrementing by more than 2 per cent per year, and we know that it is fossil dominated, and we also know that all the forecast say that in the next 30 years or so, unless something extraordinary happens, the fossils will still continue to produce the major fraction of energy used by the mankind. Now the real question is: And what after that? And whether it will be today, tomorrow, or at a time we are not going to be there, but surely the mankind intends to continue beyond that. But how will mankind continue to live beyond the exploitation of the fossils phase of its own development? 1.3. Energy and Poverty Another important point I would like to mention is: energy and poverty. There is a huge correlation between lack of energy and poverty. 1.6 billion people, a quarter of the current world population, are without electricity. And living without electricity is equivalent to be totally unable to engage oneself in any activity of socio-economic value whatsoever, because without electricity you are really isolated from the modern world, although living in the same planet, 1.6 billion people! 2.4 billion people rely almost exclusively on traditional energy sources. They have no energy which is delivered to them, they pick up the pieces of wood, they burn the wood and with they start cooking the food or whatever they need to do. Of the 6 billion people about one half live in poverty and out of this 1/5 are severely undernourished. The rest, us, live in comfort and health. These poor people are concentrated mainly in the developing countries. One can notice a tremendous improvement in China but you can see that India is quite a problem as well as Africa. Another remark should be made here: it is the responsibility of the technologically advanced countries to bring about solutions and show the way to those which need it most. If we are not able ourselves to developing cheap and abundant energy for everyone, the developing countries themselves will be unable to develop a system of responsibility. It is up to us to use the gift that we were given in terms of science and technology and transform this gift in a practical system which is not a star-war type of solution but something simple enough so the people in the emerging countries could be able to develop and improve their conditions of life. New energy, how soon? I have been given this talk for 30 minutes. During this time 5,000 new people have entered in the world, at the rate of 3 people per second, mostly in the developing countries, and they will need plenty of energy to survive decently. At the present consumption level, our reserves correspond to a duration of the order 230 years for coal, 45 for oil, 63 for gas and 54 for nuclear. The longevity of the survival of the fossil era will be affected on the one hand by the discovery of new exploitable resources strongly depending on the price, and on the other hand by the inevitable growth of the world population and their standard of living. So it is really difficult to see what the longevity will be. Obviously increased prices allow having more oil, but more people require more oil. One also has to take into account the long lead time for the massive development of some new energy sources, and the end of the fossil era may be on sight: 40-30 years is not a long time in order to turn around a complicated, expensive and immense problem, which is the one of generating new energy, and the problem of oil is only the first beginning. In this situation we have a newcomer, which is an important and a serious newcomer: the climatic changes. The consumption of fossil may be prematurely curbed by environmental disruption. It may well be that we won’t be allowed to burn all the
C. Rubbia / Novel Energies for the Future
53
coal which is there to be burnt, all the oil which is there to be burnt, because we may find that it changes the climate: the recent example of the major disaster of Katrina has probably something to do with the increased strength and the development of extreme events, which may be related to climatic changes. 1.4. Climatic Changes? As a physicist, I’d like to tell also to people who are not physicists another important point: the climatic effect of combustion of fossil fuel produces 100 times greater energy captured than the combustion itself produces, due to the incremental sub-solar radiation. In other words, we take one piece of coal, one Kg of coal, and we burn it and we ask ourselves what is the integrated solar heated effect? It’s 100 times bigger in terms of green house effect. This is due the fact that CO 2 emitted has a much longer life time and therefore integrating over this time, the effects produced represent effectively 100 times more solar power trapped inside the planet, in addition of the 1 which was done by us by the explicit act of burning. Doubling the preindusrial concentration of CO 2 in the atmosphere (a very serious perturbation) will occur after the extraction 1,000 billion tons of fossil carbon. We are presently facing a green house effect with dominating CO2, which is doubling within roughly 50 to 75 years, depending on how things are going. It is generally believed that major technology changes must occur before that, and that in order to modify the present traditional energy pattern, a formula for new research and development will be necessary. So research and development are the only way to come out of this mess, like it has been in all the other fields, medicine, health, industrial revolution, mobility, communication. They all depended on the ability to make a formidable effort in research and development. It should be the same in the case of energy, but I’m afraid that it is not what happens today. New dominant sources are needed in order to reconcile the huge energy demand growing rapidly, especially in the developing countries with an unacceptable climatic impact due to the reduced warming up as I mentioned. 1.5. Energy and GDP Now let us look here at some of the numbers which indicate the present situation. In Figure 3, I plot the energy spent in Giga Joule per capita as a function of the Gross Domestic Product (GDP) per capita. So the horizontal axis is representing the money we earn per capita, and the vertical one represents the energy produced in number of Giga Joule, which we use mostly in terms of fossils. Let’s look at what you find: first of all, the US are reaching some kind of stable situation but at a rather high level, above all the other countries. Europeans, Japan, Australia are getting quite close but not quite as high as the US, both in terms of work and in terms of other possibilities. But you can find huge number of people: China, India, Brazil, Thailand, Malaysia, Korea, which start all to be very tall in GDP per capita and are very energetic users. We know that the GDP per capita of these countries has certainly to go up. India, China have 10% increase per year. And since this is a universal curve, it all makes us to think that energy consumption will be for all in the same track of GDP. And the argument is simple: anything that you can buy, you can create but all needs energy and the energy has to be provided. In fact you can see in the case of China: in 1995, for a total of 1,000 TWh of energy produced, the source was hydro 8%, oil 6%, nuclear 1%,
54
C. Rubbia / Novel Energies for the Future
gas zero, and coal 75%. In 2020, 4 times more energy needs to be produced and we still are going to have 68% of coal and we are going to have very tiny renewable energy, 0.3%, a bit of more gas, a bit of more nuclear, a bit more oil,. But the most important thing on both graphs is the lack of a factor of 4 overall energy production which will have somehow to be discovered, to be used. This is an indication that there is a clear correlation between energy consumption that lead to an explosion of demand in the developing economy, a phenomenon that has been seen in China and in India.
Figure 3. Energy consumption as a function of GDP
1.6. New Energies, which Ones? Now, in the present situation it is perfectly normal as physicists to ask ourselves where do we have energy? Energy is a physical quantity, is a physical process, so physicists should know better than anybody else what it means, where to get these energies. There are only two natural resources: which have the capability in the long term to provide the energetic survival of the mankind, other sources will not have the capability to maintain the level of development we had. Only two elements, two forces are the sources: world energetic consumption today is less than 1/10,000 of what is available on the surface of the earth in sunny countries. If adequately exploited, solar energy— this is a hypothetical statement, which is not proven by any practical realization at the moment, J.A. Rubio will tell some more about solar energy in general—, but adequately exploited, this energy may provide enough energy for the mankind. This comes in the fact of 1 in 10,000 in sunny area will be enough to give us enough energy to run the world today. The other possibility is the nuclear energy, but new nuclear energy: we know that nuclear energy today is 6% of the primary energy of the planet, and we also know that energy consumption in the planet goes up by 2% per year that means that in 3 years we
C. Rubbia / Novel Energies for the Future
55
can wipe out the contribution of the actual nuclear because with this amount of nuclear, we are 3 years downstream of ordinary consumption. This is clearly too little. We also know that for instance the Kyoto protocol has 70 years shift in its effect, so these kinds of numbers are obviously too small to make a real change. Therefore if you want to have nuclear energy that is capable to give you half of the total energy, the other half being given by solar, and remembering that developing countries are growing like mad, obviously you have to say that the present nuclear energy is not adequate. In fact I already told you that the present nuclear energy is based on the Uranium 235, which is only 0.71% of the total energy contained in Uranium, and there is not more nuclear energy than there is oil at the first level. However, natural Uranium, Thorium could go under fission of a different nature and Lithium, which could go under fusion, are adequate for many thousands of years at several times at the present rate of consumption. So either new nuclear or solar are the only two cards we have. It’s unlikely that any stable long term development of mankind will be possible without both of them. There is no choice without one or the other. If you are standing in the middle of the Sahara you are not going to build a reactor, you are going to put a piece of sunny solar system, but if you are in Hamburg, Germany, then presumably you are going to have a hard time to pick up enough sun from there to go with it. So this nuclear energy is not today’s nuclear and this solar energy is not today’s solar. Completely new technology must be developed and that means that physicists and in general scientists should come in first, followed by industrialists to change the situation and the time we have is very short. 2. Novel Forms of Solar Energy Today, known renewable energy sources cover only 2.3% of the primary energy consumption. So, present nuclear, present hydro, present renewable energy is a footnote to the energy business. And in order to modify significantly such a pattern that is predominant, new technology must be developed. There is not conspiracy against renewable energy, it’s just that at the present circumstances they seem not to fly as they should. Let me give you some example of areas in which new development could be important: on Figure 4, I show some example of solar mirrors, in Italy, other devices that J.A. Rubio will talk about, which is solar power in Spain, and finally another important thing which is “biomass”. This can be used in certain ways to produce energy accordingly. All those things are in fact very much in the beginning of development and in fact new business could be developed.
56
C. Rubbia / Novel Energies for the Future
Figure 4.
So let me briefly touch the new solar energy. There is one fact: for one square meter of good location, South Morocco or places like that, it “rains” yearly an equivalent of 25 cm of oil. So it’s an enormous amount of energy that the sun gives us, our problem is not how much energy there is, but that we are not capable to use it, because at the end of every year, if you look around at any piece of land, you find that on any square meter there is not one nice barrel of oil ready to be used. There are various ways of using that energy: it can either be directly collected, eventually with concentrating mirrors or alternatively converted, although with a lower efficiency, into wind, biomass, hydro or photovoltaic, but none of these processes is used correctly so far. It’s not a conspiracy, there are two reasons why. One is the cost. The cheapest energy is known to be the mostly used energy and the fact the oil is going up is in favour to renewable energy (if not of the consumer!). Evidently the energy choice is a financial choice. The politicians can say what they want, the law of economics is much stronger: the energy that will come forward will always be the one that gives the biggest benefit in terms of financial terms to those people who have the strengths and the possibility to buy and invest. The second point is typical of renewable energy: the energy is produced only when the source is available and not whenever needed. This is the problem. Today we are in the middle of the night, there is no photovoltaic electricity to use. Tomorrow we can go there and there is no wind, so what do we do? Do we close the system? And so the energy produced by solar in any form, directly or indirectly, is normally very dependent on the moment, with the variability, which is incompatible with today’s rules. For instance I don’t see Lufthansa or any other company able to fly on solar energy because you can’t imagine the situation in which there is a cloud covering your solar system and you close the energy supply and so forth. In order to overcome these limitations, new technological developments are vigorously pursued in several countries in order to (1) reduce the cost to an acceptable level and (2) to introduce a thermal storage between the solar source and the application and J.A. Rubio will say more later on.
C. Rubbia / Novel Energies for the Future
57
Today, the only renewable energy that is winning is hydro for two reasons. First of all because hydro is sufficiently cheap, so to make energy you can do it with a cost that is compatible with that system, but also because you have a dam, a lake, in other words a possibility of separating the process of natural accumulation which in this case is rain, from the necessity to produce energy when you need it. So in my view a fundamental argument in favour of any form of energy to become a winner: it has to have low cost and it has to be available when you need it, not when it turns out to be possible to choose it. An example of new forms of energy using this concept of storage and being developed, is solar fields that are concentrating solar light into mirrors, see Figure 5. One mirror is producing a liquid which is hot in one side, cold in the other and the two systems are entirely separated. When there is sun you use the hot storage, when there is no sun you are going to use the cold storage which you have saved and therefore the combined alternator can operate in a way that is totally decoupled from the system, provided that the storage is pretty good and you see very quickly that it is. Concentrating Solar field Hot Storage (≈ 550 °C)
Cold Storage (≈ 290 °C)
Turbine and alternator
Figure 5.
On Figure 6, you can see a very important example of various sizes of systems for the storage of objects carrying energy: compressed hydrogen, liquid hydrogen, compressed CH4, methanol and gasoline and on the left, the thermal storage which is purely thermal. You see that the two sides are not very different, this is for the same stored energy. But, one has to be careful: heat combusts once in a life time, while the other thermal system is in fact something that can occur periodically. In other words, you recover the thermal, but you don’t recover the other. Let me give you some numbers: one mega watt hour of thermal energy can be stored in 5 meter cubic of molten salt, which is extremely good. Another way to compare thermal storage efficiency is gravitation (water coming down of a dam): it turns out that the storage thermal efficiency is equivalent to a gravitational water drop of 72 km!
58
C. Rubbia / Novel Energies for the Future
Figure 6. Solar collection with storage
So in the case of solar energy which we can store, we are talking about some sort of grand substitution, which you do in any application or process. As shown in Figure 7, today, in a standard system, you are using fossil fuel, you put oil into a boiler and heat up this liquid and this is used in a steam generator, to produce electricity, it could also be production of paper, it could be anything you want in which you heat, you take the flame, 95% of the oil is burnt and produces its heat in the field of application. Solar energy can be used for heating two tanks, as in Figure 5, and the two tanks replace the tanks that stored the fossil unit but everything else is the same. So there is a total decoupling between this part and the second part of the application, which remains the same. People should know more in principle whether they use oil which is burnt from a tank or when they use hot liquid which is accumulated from a source of sunshine.
Figure 7. The “grand” substitution
C. Rubbia / Novel Energies for the Future
59
To conclude this point, let’s look at Figure 8, which shows the whole planet: the green areas are the ones which receive most of sunshine and you can see that there are plenty of areas around the world and the scale on the left gives the number of GW.hour/Km2 per year. This little spot, indicated in red, is the land area theoretically required, by concentrating solar power, to supply the total expected world electricity demand of 35,000 Terawatt-hour per year in 2050. So there is clear evidence that you invented an intelligent and useful system which can make use of this energy in a sensible way.
Figure 8. Concentrating solar power (CSP)
Spreading this little white spot over the large green areas is not easy, but if you do that I believe that you will be able to have the full electricity support by 2050. This is absolutely remarkable. Of course not all electricity would be done in this way. 3. Novel Forms of Nuclear Energy So let me spend a bit of more time on nuclear energy and on the question of novel forms of nuclear energy. First of all, these new forms must be environmentally friendly. They don’t contribute to green house effect, but they must also be non-proliferating, and we will discuss this very carefully because most of the arguments for nuclear energy are primarily related to the fact that developing countries now want to have nuclear energy and this represents a major problem. They must not give rise to longlived radioactive by-products, there must be no chance of run-away production and one must have a very small fuel inventory. So, the question is a question mark in fact. Is there a rule for nuclear energy? Because not everybody would agree that you want to do nuclear energy all along, it means that when you finish with toxic fossil fuel you are obliged to go solar. Period. Because there is nothing else. I believe nonetheless that there should be nuclear energy, the question is in which kind of level you want to hook?
60
C. Rubbia / Novel Energies for the Future
In the sixties, ”atoms for peace” promised a cheap, abundant and universally available nuclear power, where the few “nuclear” countries would ensure the necessary know-how to the many others which have renounced to nuclear weaponry. Today, the situation is far from being acceptable: due to technological developments, the link between peaceful and military applications has been shortened: Uranium enrichment may be easily extended to a level sufficient to produce a “bomb grade” U-235 (see the case of Iran for instance); natural Uranium reactors with heavy water (CANDU) generate a considerable amount of Pu, such as produce easily Pu-239 “bomb grade” (the case of India).
• •
Now the question is: Can we have a free nuclear proliferation in all countries? In my view it can become acceptable only once the umbilical cord with this energy and weapon is cut. If we continue to play the game of energy linked with the bomb, problems of mankind would be so complicated that only a few countries will do it, and countries that have little or no energy, they will find themselves in difficulty. So totally different but new adequate technology must be developed. There are essentially three possibilities to do nuclear energy in large amounts without proliferation or with proliferation. Energy is produced whenever we have nuclear fusion or fission, as shown below: Th + n
232
U+n
238
Li + n T;
U + n fission + 2.3n
(Th cycle)
Pu + n fission + 2.5n
(238U cycle)
U;
233
Pu ;
239
233 239
T + D He + n
(fusion)
Particularly interesting are fission reactions in which a natural element is bred into a readily fissionable energy generating process. You start with something that is not fissionable or fusionable and you create from that another element which is used. First example is for Thorium which becomes 233U which is fissionable and gives you 2.3 neutrons and energy and is not proliferating. The other possibility is depleted Uranium which becomes Plutonium 239 but this reaction is heavily proliferating. So I believe that the reaction of Thorium and Lithium for fusion can be safely exploited in every country. Let me also mention why Thorium is not proliferating: for 3 reasons: • •
•
Decay heat of the α-decays which conflicts with the low temperature required by the explosive around the core (190 °C for 100 W) Gamma activity of the decay products makes the handling and transport virtually impossible. The contamination of 232U (2x103 ppm) due to Tl-208 (2.6 MeV) for a critical mass of Uranium is about 72 Sv/h (50% lethal dose after 5 minutes) which would make it impossible to build a bomb and transport it in airplane etc. Spontaneous fissions strongly reduce its potential yield because of preinitiation of the chain reaction. Easier to build Gun-type implosion systems are already excluded for Pu-239 with 66 neutrons g-1 s-1.
C. Rubbia / Novel Energies for the Future
61
Allow me to quickly skip all these stuff. Another important point I’d like to discuss is fusion reactor and ITER: you can see from this diagram (Figure 9) that ITER should become to a level sufficient to produce essentially ignition which has not been reached so far. The question is that ITER, in the most optimistic case, is only the beginning of the story because when the present generation of experiments is left, the next step will be ITER, which would be demonstration technology, confirmation of physics, and will not be yet a machine: after it, you are going to have a demonstration reactor and then eventually we are coming to do a commercial power reactor which will be in 50 years from now. Actually I have to tell you a joke in this respect: a famous person asked a fusion physicist: Why did you say that it takes 50 years to do it when you told me already 50 years 25 years ago? And he answered: “I’m a serious man, I don’t change my mind” (laughs).
Figure 9. Experimental results.
The second point I’d like to say is that the situation today is such that the amount of money that has been put, the amount of interest put by society into developing this new energies, either solar or nuclear, is a very tiny little amount of the money that has been invested in energy to be used. The example of ITER is 4 billion euro, which is two days of price increase of oil, and oil is only one third of the total energy cost which has been used. So in 10 years we will have ITER going and another 10 years to make profit of it, so 20 years in total. In 20 years society is going to find 2 days of cost increase of oil. 2 days put into the future, 2 days out of 20 years doesn’t seem a correct number in terms of ability of mankind not to be overthrown and covered by lack of preparation, which is a general problem that we see everywhere in modern society. In my view, we are not putting enough time and money in order to be able to develop new forms of energy wherever they are. With the various options we have, we should be able to solve the problem of the waste: all data show that for a normal Thorium reactor, the Thorium energy amplifier, the magnetic fusion plant, in 500 years you are going to be able to reach a level of actual coal radioactivity, 500 years which is a reasonable period of time which you know you can handle.
62
C. Rubbia / Novel Energies for the Future
Conclusion The future of mankind is crucially dependent on continuous availability of cheap and abundant energy. Should energy supply break down, mankind may collapse. This is the first and most important point. Energy from fossil is not forever. Furthermore it is likely to be prematurely curbed by the emergence of serious incontrollable climatic changes. Third point: time has come to consider other sources of energy without which mankind may be heading to disaster. Nuclear and solar are the only two candidates. Serious alternative, nuclear energy without Uranium 235, so new nuclear energy and without proliferation must be investigated. Proliferation should be removed as soon as possible. Nuclear fusion reactors are also likely candidate, presumably capable to produce energy for millennium to come and the difference between renewable and non renewable energy will then become totally academic. If it takes 20 centuries to burn up your energy it is unlikely renewable. Depleted Uranium is also possible but not for everybody because of proliferation concerns. Solar energy, particularly promising is the direct use to concentrate solar radiation in the wide regions of Sun Belt. These methods are likely to be successful in the long run. However, they need urgently an innovative research and development programme. Although innovative energy may eventually be more essential in developing countries, only our technically developed society can realistically foster such a change. Thank you very much.
Question — You didn’t mention Hydrogen as a source of energy. C. Rubbia — I can answer right away. Hydrogen is not an energy source. It is an energy carrier, like electricity. The real question is: How will evolve the method by which you produce hydrogen, if one day hydrogen will become the equivalent of synthetic natural gas, because everything you can do with natural gas you can think to do it with hydrogen? In fact we did have hydrogen in the past year in terms of “town gas”, which was 50% hydrogen and the rest was CO and this thing was used broadly all over European countries and also in America. So hydrogen is well known, it is produced as a chemical process, there is a huge amount of hydrogen 2% of today primary energy makes use of hydrogen, so it’s already a very well developed system. But it produces CO2, because to get it, one starts from natural gas. So, why should you go from natural gas to hydrogen when you can burn the CH4 right away and at best you would use the same amount of CH4 directly or indirectly because the final state and initial state are the same, and the energy consumption is the same. Under these conditions, obviously the real question of hydrogen is what will be the future source that can produce it. Now a lot of work has been done on solar, and there are people who are really building direct solar transformation in hydrogen. The transformation cannot be immediate, because water will go into hydrogen and oxygen naturally at 3,000 degrees which is far too high. You then have to make an indirect chain with intermediate steps, which are working in a circle, working as a catalyser, working to temperatures of 800 degrees and transform sun light into hydrogen which is accumulated and used as a natural gas. The efficiency of this system is very high: it is more than 50 per cent, at least in the laboratory. The second possibility which is supported strongly by the French is the one of nuclear power plant that goes directly
C. Rubbia / Novel Energies for the Future
63
into hydrogen. That nuclear has to be different than the present nuclear because it has to bear high temperatures. So, one of the major component of generation 4 reactor which will be built in France is the primary use of it to make a gas driven reactor with hydrogen at 800 degrees. It will go into a chemical system rather than producing electricity. So you bypass alternator etc. All this of course is for much later. Another problem of hydrogen is transport. There is a lot of work to do before this thing becomes a reality because the hydrogen requires a field sale, which is something that at the present moment is far to be realistic, then you have to have transport, distribution etc. so unfortunately energy, if you like, transport is not the right place. As a matter of fact, one third of energy goes into electricity, one third goes into industrial application and one third goes into transport, and that last part is the one which will remain with oil. Question — If I understand you correctly, it seems that ITER will not be on time, because we cannot expect anything out of it before 50 years. So it will be late for the bottlenecks in energy production. Is there a timetable for the other sources of energy you described? C. Rubbia — I’ll answer first from a quote from Churchill who said that “Democracy is very bad but all the other forms are worse”. So before saying that fusion is not going to work you ask yourself what other choices you have beside fusion, because otherwise you’ll be in trouble. The main problem is that Uranium 235 in the present situation is not very abundant. I believe that the bright days ahead of us will rely on fission, because fission has behind it 50 years of experience and a little bit of change will not hurt those gentlemen who are running the industrial system of nuclear power plants: when you go to a closed cycle and you make these breeding reactions as indicated in my presentation, you have a much more sophisticated system which would allow you to use all the depleted Uranium that you have around which is a huge amount and it would be used much more efficiently because you are drawing the whole of it not the 0.7%. So you gain between 150 and 200 times the number of material you need to produce a certain amount of energy. So the idea is to use a closed cycle, with the breeding, and to my view that solution, in the nuclear domain, is not a major step. You can make a breeding reactor tomorrow if you want and you can make it work without major problems. There are questions of fast breeder, slow breeder and the rest of it, but still, there is a bright future for fission and it’s not obvious to me that fusion will be the winner. Fusion is much more complicated, as it needs to go to 500 million degrees and there are two facts that you have to remember. Number one: fusion is not what people say, in other words, it’s not the reaction which works on the sun, because the reaction that works on the sun is a-neutronic, there are not neutrons there, while the other reaction produces Tritium. The sun is driven by a reaction which is mostly weakinteraction, the other one is nuclear-interaction. So the relationship between the sun and the other thing is totally a result of a misunderstanding, in my view. This is the first point. The second point is that people think that fusion is clean, but the present fusion is as dirty as fission, however, the great advantage is that fusion brings in radioactivity through activation products and therefore is more short-lived than the other system. So is a fission system which is operating with closed cycle, because in the closed cycle the actinides are not waste: they are used and burnt. So all together, the options are many. In my view it’s not the one solution or the other is the best, the decision will come from
64
C. Rubbia / Novel Energies for the Future
the future, not ours, somebody else’s future, the point is that we should not continue not to spend anything on this subject. The real problem is to put enough money into this. I said in the beginning that investment in the energy domain is very small. How small is it? Pharmaceutical, chemical, computer industry produces normally 15% or 20% of the sales in form of income which is used to start R&D, so R&D is in the order of 15 to 20 per cent of the initial cost of the product. What is the situation with energy? It’s extremely small worldwide: private and public energy research is between tobacco and beverages, which is half per cent. So we are spending more money today in tobacco, in buying coca cola than we are spending in order to transform a situation that is oil-driven into a situation which is driven by different principles, either solar, or nuclear or whatever. And you realize that this is much more expensive.
Sharing Knowledge Across the Mediterranean Area P. Faugeras et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2006 © 2006 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
65
Energy Research at CIEMAT and the Almeria Solar Platform Project12 Juan-Antonio RUBIO Director of CIEMAT, Madrid Abstract. CIEMAT is the only research center on solar energy operative in Europ. It aims at testing various technologies and devices for using solar energy to produce high temperatures, direct steam generation, solar detoxification, solar desalination. Components are also tested and experimental installations in various countries designed.
First of all I want to thank the organizers of this conference, and in particular my colleague Robert Klapisch for the kind invitation. CIEMAT is the Spanish centre for research in energy and environment. 30 years ago it was linked to the Spanish atomic energy commission, but since then there has been a diversification of the activity to cover all energy sources, environmental issues related to energy generation, also basic research, fundamental research in particular physics fields. So we wanted to promote basic science, fundamental science and also all the technologies associated to those developments with applications. These activities are integrated in the European framework but also CIEMAT has in mind to strengthen collaboration with Latin America and Mediterranean countries and this is one the reasons why I am here today. My presentation will mainly focus on thermal solar energy, in particular the solar plant “Almeria”, since I was requested to speak a little bit about it. Almeria is an Arab name as you know and this laboratory is one of the most important laboratories in solar field in the world. Now let me speak about solar energy, which is a potential massive energy source, clearly. In fact it generates from the sun, with a radio density of the order of 63 MW/m 2. However, the geometrical constraints between the sun and the earth lead to a dramatic decrease of the flux in such a way that the irradiant is slightly more than 1 kW/m 2. So if you want to produce energy in solar plants or high temperature applications of solar energy, you need necessarily to have concentration of devices, otherwise you don’t get what you want. There are several technologies used to concentrate solar energy (Figure 1). The technologies in 2 dimensions focus the energy along lines, while the technologies in 3 dimensions, such as the central receivers and the parabolic dishes, focus on a volume, on a point. For the technologies in 2 dimensions, I should also mention the parabolic flux technologies, which are not shown on the figure because they don’t have enough concentration factor and they are not used mainly for producing thermal energy. Anyway, the concentration factors for the parabolic troughs 12
Transcription from oral in English.
66
J.-A. Rubio / Energy Research at CIEMAT and the Almeria Solar Platform Project
are around 100, for the central receivers this factor can be 1,000 and for the parabolic dishes it could be several thousands. However the parabolic dishes represent a limited market mainly because of the installation cost and for the efficiency of the thermal cycle, and this is a technology mainly used for relatively small applications of a few tens of kilowatts.
Figure 1. Concentrating solar energy
So the most competitive technologies are the parabolic troughs and the central receivers. The parabolic trough has a lot of future, it could become competitive. You can get as much as you want, you just have to add more and more mirrors and you get more and more energy. However, the temperatures that you can reach is limited to several hundred of degrees centigrade. To the contrary, the central receivers of power can reach high temperatures, of 1,000 degrees or more, but they are limited in their size to about 50 MW. Of course you can also install central receivers and have as much power as you need by adding more reflectors. These are the most competitive technologies, according to my information; the parabolic troughs are a bit more competitive than the central receivers, but both technologies have to be developed and we’ll see what happens. Now let me come to the platform of “Almeria”. I will shorten my presentation to leave the floor for questions. First of all, “Almeria” is part of the Central Investigación Energeticas Monumentales and Tecnologicas which has about 1,400 people and an annual budget of 150 million euros. The goal of this platform is to make ready potential industrial applications by concentrating solar thermal energy. The location of the platform is distributed over 103 hectares in the Taberna desert of Almeria. General budget of the laboratory is about 10 million euros. Human resources: the are 100 people working there, 20 of them are commuting between Madrid and Almeria, and the auxiliary personnel for the maintenance of the platform represents about 50 %.
J.-A. Rubio / Energy Research at CIEMAT and the Almeria Solar Platform Project
67
The platform was born in 1977 in the framework of a large international collaboration and already in 1981 it delivered the first electricity. In 1997 it became part of a thematic collaboration with the DER from Germany. In 1999 it was recognized as the last scientific operative installation in Europ. And since its beginning, more and more experiments have been done on the platform and more installations have been added. So, now it’s really a large laboratory. Let me explain what are the main installations of the solar platform of Almeria, (see Figure 2). First of all, those with number 1 are the central receivers technologies, with two towers, the one on the left is 80 meters high with a nominal power of 7 MW and the other tower on the right has a nominal power of 2.7 MW.
Figure 2. Overall view of the Almeria platform
Then we have another installation, number 2, which is parabolic trough collector technology, which delivers 1.2 MW and is coupled to a multi distillation plant of 3 m 3 per hour. We will talk about it a little bit later on. Number 3 is a parabolic collector installation for direct steam generation, which is one the technologies developed in the platform. This installation has a power of 1.8 MW and is able to deliver 1 kg per second of steam at the temperature of 100 degrees and a pressure of 100 bars, and can produce electricity right away. Number 4 is a set of 6 parabolic dishes, each one of 50 MW of thermal power on which we got quite a lot of experience. Another installation, number 5, is a solar furnace, with a ground area of 100 m 2. It has a power of 60 kW and by concentrating that on a radius of about, in total, 28 cm over a width of about 10 cm, you can reach temperatures of 3,000 degrees. It is mainly used for earth and materials studies and also for developing technical applications. The installation number 6 is a solar detoxification unit of polluted water: there are 6 compound collectors which can make detoxification over a surface of about 40 m 2
68
J.-A. Rubio / Energy Research at CIEMAT and the Almeria Solar Platform Project
and in a volume of 500 litres. There is also another installation of parabolic collectors on two axes that is able to test detoxification on a volume of about 5,000 litres per hour. The installation number 7 is a solar desalinisation plant: it’s a multi effect distillation plant coupled with solar energy and in fact we are aiming now to produce pure water, to a price of about 3 euro per m 3. This is more expensive than reverse osmosis, but nobody knows, reverse osmosis rely mainly on energy cost and the multi effect distillation coupled with solar could become competitive. The installation number 8 is aiming at testing solar components and buildings. We have several cells, between 5 and 16 m3, with one wall prepared for testing architectural components: thermal losses, optical transmittivity, etc. And finally there is a kind of meteo station at the entrance of the platform of Almeria, which is part of the International Network for Meteorology. In order to shorten my presentation I will not go through each of these technologies, because C. Rubbia already made some descriptions, but nevertheless, if you have any questions, I’m ready to answer. However, what is important to know is that we are planning now to go ahead towards a massive solar energy supply. And in this sense we feel, as Carlo Rubbia said, that concentrating solar power has great potential as energy source. However, it has to be competitive. First of all, the installation cost of the thermal solar energy for one kilowatt an hour is between 2.3 and 3.5 times the installation cost of fossil fuel power plant. Also the operational and maintenance cost is higher by a factor 3 about as compared to the operational and maintenance cost of fossil fuel. However, we feel that there is a margin for competition. Why? We have to optimize the mirrors, first, we have to optimize the pipes and coating, we have to optimize the fluids—only the oil is operational—but there is the steam and there is also the gas, so there is a lot of margin to make an optimisation. We also have to optimize the control systems, which are very expensive in the installations. We have to optimize the conventional tools for energy generations and adapt them to the power that we can generate with our units. Finally there will be of course a decrease of the cost because of the series fabrication of the components. In total we feel that we can get this factor, 3, with respect to the current cost. So profiting now from a favourable legislation in Spain, CIEMAT is launching designs of about 50 MWe Units, in collaboration with the appropriate partners, and continue to build the required small testing prototype units. Thank you very much
Question — Time needed to build a new 50 MW plans that you have in mind? J.-A. Rubio — There are already several projects in Spain, mainly with oil. There are hundreds of projects I’d say 3-4 years. However, first of all we have to do design, this will take mostly 6-9 months, but there are already 10 plants which are foreseen in Spain of 50 MW each, so what we would like to do, is to incorporate in these plants the new technologies, this will take mostly between 4-5 and 10 years. Question — What is the down time for maintenance? J.-A. Rubio — Well, there is no problem with maintenance in general with mirrors, it depends on where they are. If it is in the desert you will have a problem with the sun, you have to clean up the mirrors continuously. However, in Almeria, there are
J.-A. Rubio / Energy Research at CIEMAT and the Almeria Solar Platform Project
69
no problems. By the way, Almeria is not the best place for sun, we have about 3,000 sunny hours per year, in fact only 6 days of rain per year. However, we have 3,0003,200 hours per year, it is enough, it is a good place. Canaries Island is the very best one, it is better than Almeria. In the countries of North Africa you have very good conditions, in the desert, because of the sun, but then you have to clean a lot the mirrors, continuously.
70
Sharing Knowledge Across the Mediterranean Area P. Faugeras et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2006 © 2006 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
The Future of Wind Energy in Morocco 13 D. ZEJLI14, R. BENCHRIFA and A. BENNOUNA Department of Technologies and of the Economics of Renewable Energies National Center for Scientific and Technical Research, Morocco Abstract. In this paper the authors describe progress made in the area of windpower technology throughout the world in general, and then present a project for electric power transmission using wind energy from the south of Morocco to the European Union. The cost per kilowatt-hour (kWh) of wind energy would be 0.05€ at its arrival in central Europe. Keywords: Wind energy, electric power transmission, costs, Morocco, European Union
1. Introduction In the opinions of many experts, and even of petroleum companies themselves, petroleum production will reach its peak in less than twenty years. Possible avenues to explore to counter this looming shortage aren’t abundant, and one of them is to return to renewable energies with new technologies to respond to the demands of development. The boom in renewable energies, which has been expected for many years now, finally seems to have begun. The case of wind energy is very revealing, since it shows the efforts undertaken by first Denmark and then Germany to bring to the technology of wind energy the success that we now know it to have. In fact, windmills were the first energy-producing constructions created by humankind, and they were used for thousands of years until the nineteenth century, when the windmill was dethroned by the fossil fuels that appeared with the Industrial Revolution. Since that time, very few windmills have been built; of those that remained, most have been abandoned and have disappeared from the landscape. It was only in 1973 that people rediscovered solar and wind power. The two gas crises, the specter of shortages, and the beginnings of awareness about the damage to the environment caused by fossil fuels all contributed to the reawakened interest in renewable energies that we’re seeing today.
Original text in French, translated in English. Corresponding author: Driss ZEJLI, CNRST, 52 Avenue Omar Ibn Khattab, B.P.: 8027, Agdal, Rabat, Morocco; E-mail:
[email protected]. 13 14
D. Zejli et al. / The Future of Wind Energy in Morocco
71
2. Wind Energy in the World If, almost thirty years ago, wind energy was considered the least promising of the renewable energies, the situation has changed considerably with the great improvements attained in the past few years in the technology of horizontal-axis wind turbines, and the fact that the costs for them have become competitive. The maximum power per unit for wind turbines was 10 kW at the end of the 1970s, 50 kW in 1984–85 and then 1.5 MW in 1996–97; today this power exceeds 4 MW. The cost, which was close to 0.3 €/kWh in 1980, is now between 0.025 and 0.05 €/kWh for on-shore sites. However, this leap for wind power is the result of the remarkable expansion of electric power, and its development has profited from the accumulated knowledge of several disciplines, especially meteorology, electric machines, aeronautics, structural dynamics, chemistry, and material physics, and also power electronics; hence the multidisciplinary aspect of this technology. The constantly increasing numbers of wind turbines which are connected all over the world to already established power grids shows how successful this technology has become (Figure 1).
Total installed power (MW)
Years
Figure 1. Electric power generated by wind throughout the world
Most modern wind turbines on the market today are the three-blade variety, the rotor being maintained in a position facing the wind. This configuration is called “the Danish Concept” and it tends to constitute the standard these days. Wind turbines function principally in two ways, depending on the choice of generator. Some wind turbines function with a constant rotation speed. In this case, the best output is achieved by a single wind speed. It is possible, however, to try to get a maximal output regardless of wind speed. This can be accomplished by making the rotation speed of the rotor vary; this allows for a very effective output. These wind turbines are equipped with a multipolar generator and power electronics that allow them to function at variable speeds.
72
D. Zejli et al. / The Future of Wind Energy in Morocco
3. Wind Energy in Morocco In 2000, Morocco began large-scale development of wind energy. Following two projects totaling 53 MW, the ONE (National Electricity Bureau) projects the installation of 320 MW: 140 MW in the region of Tangier, 60 MW in Taza, 60 MW at Essaouira, and 60 MW at Tarfaya. In addition, construction by the Lafarge Group of a wind farm to supply electric power to its cement plant in Tetouan can be considered a first for Morocco. One can hope that this initiative will have an encouraging effect on other national economic operators and actors who are still skeptical with regard to this form of energy and don’t yet quite believe in its breakthrough. 4. Is there a Future for Wind Energy in Morocco? Morocco is a country lying fallow, and yet the potential for the growth of the national economy is very high; a strong growth in electricity demand is therefore highly possible. Hence the leading role that the exploitation of this natural resource, of which our skies are generous, can take in the Moroccan economy, not forgetting the beneficial effects that it can have on the emergence of a new industrial fabric with strong potential to produce jobs and wealth. Morocco’s wind energy potential, as shown in Figure 2, is significant, and the transformation technology of this energy source exists and is even competitive. What is most needed is an actual desire to develop this form of energy, which, whether one wants it or not, will without a doubt have a place among the energy options of the future.
Figure 2. Wind energy map of Morocco [1]
Several months before the tenth anniversary of the Barcelona Process, let us imagine a project with ambitious long-term objectives. This project would combine the resources and assets of the partners on both sides of the Mediterranean. It would
D. Zejli et al. / The Future of Wind Energy in Morocco
73
involve electric power transmission using wind energy from southern Morocco to the European Union, as illustrated in Diagram 1.
Morocco Significant wind energy potential
European Union Increased demand for renewable energy + High demographic density _______________________________________________________________________________________ Urgent need for the emergence of a buoyant sector with strong potential to create jobs and wealth
Electricity →
Technology ←
Transferable technology that will create jobs
_______________________________________________________________________________________ Relatively limited financial resources
Investment ←
Presence of several financial institutions + Participation in various financial schemes + Private investment _______________________________________________________________________________________ Diagram 1. Morocco–EU partnership in the framework of an electric power transmission project
The coastal region of southern Morocco is among the windiest regions in the world. It is dominated by trade winds, which are known for their regularity and their sufficiently high speeds. Moreover, in addition to its low demographic density, a large part of this region is composed of plains and rocky plateaus. It therefore lends itself well to the installation of large wind farms. In this region Morocco could produce more than ten times its actual electricity needs. A large part of this production could be exported to the European Union using the technique of high-voltage direct current (HVDC) cables, which minimize line losses. This technique has already been proven in numerous projects of long-distance electric power transmission all over the world.
74
D. Zejli et al. / The Future of Wind Energy in Morocco
Let us suppose that a wind farm with a surface area of 10,000 km 2 is installed in southern Morocco; this farm would produce, as shown in Table 1, the equivalent of almost 200 TWh. This is a little less than 10% of European electricity consumption. Table 1. General data for electric power transmission project
Surface area of farm Minimum wind turbine density Total installed power Estimated production Maximum investment costs (Wind farms + HVDC) Total investment
10,000 km2 5 MW/km2 50,000 MW 200 TWh (European consumption: ~ 2,300 TWh) 1,400 €/kW 70,109 € (1.75 PIBMorocco (2004))
Based on the data shown in Table 1, the cost per kWh as formulated by the first equation below would be 0.05 €/kWh at the arrival of the current in central Europe. It would be less than that per kWh of wind energy produced in offshore Europe, the cost of which is between 0.06 and 0.09 €/kWh [2]. CGA = A(n ) =
Inv.A(n ) + C om Pr i.(i + 1) n
(i + 1) n − 1
(1) (2)
Inv: Total cost of investment (1,400 €/kW) Com: Annual cost of functioning and maintenance (22.5 €/kW.year) A(n): Coefficient of actualization i: Rate of actualization (10%) n: Life span (20 years) Pr: Annual electricity production 5. Socioeconomic and Environmental Effects of Electric Power Transmission Project 5.1. For Morocco − − − −
Export of a nonperishable product with higher added value Development of a new industry Chance for enormous job-creation possibilities Development of heretofore unproductive regions
D. Zejli et al. / The Future of Wind Energy in Morocco
75
5.2. For the European Union − Increase of renewable energies in European electricity consumption to achieve the objective of 21% by 2010 − Import of electricity with renewable origins less expensive than that produced locally − Emergence of a potential market for European products 5.3. For the entire region − Increase in the volume of exchange between the two sides of the Mediterranean − Reduction in illegal immigration. References [1] [2]
Centre de développement des Energies Renouvelables. Le Gisement éolien du Maroc (1995). A. Bonduelle, , M.Lefevre, Eole ou Pluton, Rapport de Greenpeace, décembre 2003.
76
Sharing Knowledge Across the Mediterranean Area P. Faugeras et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2006 © 2006 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
EUROGIA: the Energy Cluster to Provide Green Solutions to Satisfy an Ever-Growing Demand for Energy 15 Gabriel MARQUETTE Schlumberger Research, Director, European Affairs Chairman of EUROGIA Abstract. EUROGIA’s fundamental purpose is to initiate the technological developments which are fundamental to ensure a better management of fossil fuels for securing the world energy needs for the next decades, while respecting environmental quality and facilitating the migration towards the hydrogen economy and the use of renewable energy sources.
EUROGIA is a EUREKA 16 strategic initiative for sustainable development and more secure energy supply towards a cleaner and safer future. It has been officially labeled as a EUREKA cluster in March 2004 and is as such the first European R&D program dedicated to security of energy supply and energy chain decarbonisation. EUROGIA’s Roadmap is based on the oil & gas research priorities defined by EUROGIF 17 ’s Thematic Networks, which bring together stakeholders from 17 European countries (including Russia). EUROGIA’s objective is to put this industry vision into practice. EUROGIA is also there to facilitate the re-organisation of the oil & gas supply sector in order to face emerging challenges and to seize the historical opportunity represented by the changing business models vis-à-vis oil and gas operators. 1. Background Sustainable development is the challenge for a world with a growing population that expects better living conditions, in an endangered environment. The challenge is to Original text in English. EUREKA is the intergovernmental initiative supporting European innovation. It represents a panEuropean network for market-oriented, industrial R&D. EUREKA groups 35 countries, including around the Mediterranean Sea all European countries plus Turkey, Israel, and Morocco as an Associate Country. EUROGIA is the first EUREKA cluster for Energy. 17 EUROGIF, the European Oil and Gas Innovation Forum, represents the interests of the oil & gas service and supply industry (over 2000 companies employing 200,000 direct workers) which services oil and gas companies. EUROGIF is involved in 8 Thematic Networks (QHSE, ICT, Floating Structures, Subsea Production, Smart Reservoir, Materials, Gas Chain, CO2) mostly funded by the European Commission (FP5). They bring together more than 170 organisations—operators, contractors, SME’s, Research institutes, universities—from 17 European countries (including Russia). 15 16
G. Marquette / EUROGIA: The Energy Cluster to Provide Green Solutions
77
meet present needs without compromising future prospects. Energy systems must evolve to meet these changing needs and respond to environmental concerns, in particular global warming. All fuels will soon have to face rapidly changing, increasingly competitive and much more complex energy markets. In order to be able to satisfy its increasing energy needs, the world has moved from wood to coal and from coal to oil. It is moving today from oil to gas and will, tomorrow, move from gas to hydrogen and renewables. This evolutive process is quite often called “energy decarbonisation”. As an introduction, three general comments have to be made: 1. 2. 3.
Energy activities are now being governed by the “sustainable development” principle whereby economic development, environmental protection and social responsibility are closely interconnected: «meeting the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs». Renewable resources are booming, and in some countries, their annual growth rate can reach up to 20%. However, even if this growth remains constant over the next 20 years, renewables will meet in 2020 as little as 10% of today’s energy demand. Waste management is an essential element in new energy production developments; by-products of all processes must now be either commercialised or segregated and safely disposed of in the reservoir or elsewhere.
Consequently today all issues—technical, economical, environmental and societal—are closely interconnected. They can no longer be investigated independently from one another. As regards CO2 emissions, coal combustion has produced the heaviest emissions. Oil occupies a midway place and natural gas is the least polluting fossil energy source in this respect (e.g. its CO 2 emissions are half that of brown coal). Consequently, in the coming decades, an increase in natural gas consumption is quite likely to be the most effective means of reducing carbon dioxide emissions whilst renewable technologies are further developed, marketed and widely used. The long term goal is to achieve the so-called “hydrogen economy”. It is foreseen that energy demand will increase by 60% within the next 25 years and that fossil energies will still represent around 80% of the worldwide consumption for the same period. This will directly induce, in a “business as usual” scenario, the potential increase of CO2 emissions by 60%. With the main objective of reducing environmental & climatic impact in the next decades, it will be vital to efficiently manage the exploration, production, transport and use of fossil energies. To do so, it is therefore imperative to develop and deploy advanced technologies in both the short and medium to long term. The EU R&D effort of the Oil & Gas Industry represents 33% of the world’s total investment (6bn€), compared to 43% in the US (2.5bn€). O&G operators/producers increasingly outsource their R&D to the O&G Service & Supply Industry. Today, the latter contributes to more than one third of the world’s total R&D budget, and this trend is increasing steadily. As a consequence, the Service & Supply industry has gained more power and responsibility in the choice and design of the new technologies to be developed with a view to not only meet technical and commercial objectives but also to comply with environmental, safety and ethical requirements.
78
G. Marquette / EUROGIA: The Energy Cluster to Provide Green Solutions
This O&G Service & Supply industry sector is worth 40bn€ of yearly revenue for EU Member States plus Norway (of which 5% are invested in R&D every year), and it directly employs over 200,000 people. EU R&D investments in this sector exceed 700 M€ yearly (a figure equivalent to the US DoE’s yearly financial support to the US O&G R&D). 2. Objectives In order to face efficiently the energy demand challenges as well as the significant US and Asian competition, three main objectives must be met: • • •
The minimization of climate and environmental impact, due to the use of fossil energies, on the CO2 balance. The competitiveness of European O&G services and equipment sector The security of energy supply
3. Technical Vision In developing a technical vision to achieve these objectives, two avenues must be pursued: • •
Demonstration and deployment of technologies whose feasibility is already proven. Development of innovative high-technology solutions.
Main areas for research should be: 3.1. Decarbonisation: •
• •
Optimization and promotion of the gas chain will have a major impact on CO 2 emission reduction. This covers the elimination of flaring, treatment, contaminant re-injection, conditioning (chemical or physical liquefaction), transit (customized vessels, high pressure and heat insulated gas pipes) and conversion (gas turbines and micro-turbines, fuel cells), CO2 capture and storage: storage can be either static (deep water gasification) or dynamic (secondary oil recovery or recovery of methane from coal mines). Minimization of methane losses: transport (e.g. CIS), abandoned coal mines, energy distribution networks.
3.2. Security of Energy Supply: Optimization of reservoir management and the development of new fossil resources. • •
Exploration and exploitation of deep water reservoirs (< 3000 m): only 15% of the offshore has already been explored. Economic exploitation of gas fields and their associated gas.
G. Marquette / EUROGIA: The Energy Cluster to Provide Green Solutions
•
•
79
Optimization of integrated management of reservoirs, to boost the drainage coefficient from 35 % to 60 % within the next ten years: 1% of enhanced recovery rate = 2 years of worldwide energy consumption Innovative technologies such as multi-component, multi-dimensional, timelapse reservoir characterization and monitoring, interactive drilling, intelligent completion will be essential to achieve this goal. Finally non-conventional hydrocarbons have to be considered: oily sands, heavy oils, coal bed methane, coal bed gasification, methane hydrates (estimated reserves of methane hydrates amount to twice the rest of documented fossil energies reserves) whether on land or at sea bottom (characterization, secure processes of recovery and conversion).
These two areas, besides their considerable potential impact on CO 2 emission and the security of energy supply, have a major potential on the increase of European companies’ competitiveness in a worldwide market. 4. EUROGIA: Part of the Solution in the Energy Equation Faced with the development of the North Sea in the last 30 years and with the shift of R&D efforts from Oil & Gas Operating Companies towards service contractors and suppliers’ research laboratories, the European Service and Supply Industry has built-up a capacity to address new challenges such as deep water reservoirs, optimization of mature field recovery rates, non conventional hydrocarbons, migration to gas, etc. However, for this industry to stay competitive on the worldwide scene (with products and services being net contributors to the EU trade balance), more efforts are needed for a more effective integration. The EUREKA initiative has proven to be successful at structuring R&D at European level and beyond in specific research domains. It has also proven that its industry-driven approach can federate all key players, therefore capitalizing across borders on the expertise of large, medium and small enterprises, all benefiting from both private and public research support. EUROGIA is the tool for European industry to contribute to sustainable development through: • •
•
economic growth: a better positioning vis-à-vis non-European competition and a more secure energy supply for Europe social quality: sustained employment growth, particularly for highly qualified jobs, and increased attractiveness for scientific studies. This is to increase our visibility in the scientific world environmental protection: development of better technologies to minimise the impact of industrial activities on environment, to reduce greenhouse gases, to accelerate the migration towards the hydrogen economy, and to contribute to providing cost effective solutions in the renewable energy sources sector.
EUROGIA’s fundamental purpose is to initiate the technological developments which are fundamental to ensure a better management of fossil fuels for securing the world energy needs for the next decades, while respecting environmental quality and facilitating the migration towards the hydrogen economy and the use of renewable energy sources.
80
G. Marquette / EUROGIA: The Energy Cluster to Provide Green Solutions
EUROGIA is an integral part of this strategy: EUROGIA runs 2 to 3 calls for proposals yearly. Bottom-approach, industry-driven, market-oriented projects are key words. Proposals, evaluated by international experts following a peer review procedure, are expected to fall in the 2 areas/ 6 priorities which constitute EUROGIA’s backbone: •
•
Security of supply 1. More efficient exploitation of mature fields 2. Deep and ultra deep offshore fields 3. Non conventional resources Decarbonisation 1. Migration to natural gas 2. Carbon capture, use and storage 3. Migration to hydrogen economy.
17 projects, gathering more than 70 organisations from 11 countries and representing 80 M€ budget have already been granted the EUROGIA label.
Sharing Knowledge Across the Mediterranean Area P. Faugeras et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2006 © 2006 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
81
Sustainable Energy Scenarios in the Mediterranean: Current Situation and Prospects18 Dominique GENTILE a and Samir ALLAL b Director of the Institut National Sciences et Techniques Nucléaires b Senior Lecturer, Université de Versailles Saint-Quentin-en-Yvelines a
Abstract. The large population growth as well as the increase demand of energy per capita poses severe problems to the Southern Mediterranean countries. The basic trend scenario (laissez faire) leads to an explosion of the demand and may induce instabilities in the region. A more sustainable scenario is possible but requires a concerted political action of all countries involved.
1. Context •
•
•
18
Several exercises in regional energy prospective planning have been carried out in the last few years. Energy specialists have a habit of projecting in the long-term and describing contrasting images of national, regional and global energy demand-and-supply situations with different forecast ranges. Some of these exercises are forecasts outlining the most likely development for the energy sector if the trends observed in the recent period continue in the period under study. Others are a form of prospective planning and present contrasting images that reflect energy constraints and policies which are themselves diverse, and their consequences in terms of energy demand and supply, the environment, etc., on different forecasting horizons. Still others fix normative goals with a given forecast range (for example, to reduce hothouse gas emissions by X% or Y% of renewable energies on a more or less distant forecasting horizon) and set out the technical, economic and organisational conditions needed to reach that horizon. For the Mediterranean countries, the most recent and significant exercises are those developed by the Observatoire Méditerranéen de l’Energie and the Plan Bleu. These scenarios were discussed in a paper at the 4th session of the Université Méditerranéenne d’Eté that we held in Tunis from 11 to 13 July 2005, on the theme “Energy policy and sustainable development in the Mediterranean: challenges and new solidarities”. In the year 2000, the North Mediterranean countries (PNM), which represent 45% of the region, consumed 74% of total consumption of primary energy. An inhabitant of the PNM thus consumed over 3 times more than an inhabitant of a PSEM. The disparity is from 1 to 12 between the country that is the biggest Original text in French, translated in English.
82
D. Gentile and S. Allal / Sustainable Energy Scenarios in the Mediterranean
•
energy consumer per inhabitant—France, with more than 4,200 kep per inhabitant—and the smallest consumer of energy—Morocco, which consumes less than 350 kep per inhabitant (Figure 1). The inequality is even more marked for electricity, since the disparity was from 1 to 4 between the North and the South, and from 1 to 20 between the biggest consumer, France, with 9,000 kWh per inhabitant, and Morocco, with less than 500 kWh per inhabitant (Figure 2).
2025 2010
NORD
2000 1970
2025 2010
PSEM
2000 1970
(kep/hab )
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
4000
4500
Source: OME, 2005
Figure 1. Energy consumption per capita in the Mediterranean (1970, 2000, 2010, 2025)
2025 2010 2000
NORD
1970
2025
PSEM
2010 2000
(kWh/hab) 0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
7000
8000
Source: OME, 2005
Figure 2. Electricity consumption per capita in the Mediterranean (1970, 2000, 2010, 2025)
Analysis of past evolution of final consumption in the Mediterranean countries shows a very strong growth in final energy consumption for the residential sector (up more than 5% per annum between 1974 and 1999) and the transport sector (average annual growth of around 4%), mainly due to demographic growth, increased urbanisation, improved living standards and the inefficiency of current systems of energy consumption and production. These trends, as we
83
D. Gentile and S. Allal / Sustainable Energy Scenarios in the Mediterranean
•
shall see later (in the laissez-faire scenario), will tend to continue and become more pronounced in the PSEM countries in the coming years if the mechanism put in place to control the increase in energy consumptions is not reinforced. As far as supply structures are concerned, we cannot help but observe a predominance in the Mediterranean of hydrocarbons, a break-through in natural gas and marginal participation on the part of ENRs in energy results for the region (Figure 3). In 2000, fossil fuels (oil, carbon, gas) dominated the region’s energy supply (more than 75% of consumption in the North, and 96% in the South and East). This trend looks set to continue over the next few years, confirming the predominance of fossil fuels, which will account for 87% of energy consumption by 2025 (current-trend scenarios); oil will represent 40% of the balance, with not inconsiderable consequences on the climate. This underlines how much work needs to be done decarbonising EuroMediterranean energy systems if they are to reach the sustainable development goals for the region (Figure 4). Hydro
Nucléaire 13
Hydro ER 0 3
Charbon 12
Gaz 28%
2%
ER 0%
Charbon
15%
Gaz
22
Pétrole 50
Pétrole 55%
Source: OME, 2005
Figure 3. (left) Structure of the energy demand as a function of the source in the Mediterranean (2000 - 830 Mtep)
Figure 4. (right) Structure of the energy demand as a function of the source in the southern and eastern Mediterranean countries (2000 - 228 Mtep)
2. Importance of Demographic Growth in the Southern Mediterranean •
As regards demography, the population of the southern and eastern Mediterranean countries (PSEM) should grow over a period of 25 years (2000–2025) from 242 million inhabitants in 2000 to nearly 340 million inhabitants in 2025—that is, a growth of 40% over the period in question, which is sizeable, particularly in terms of the associated energy needs. In the PNMs, the demographic dynamics is much less marked, and the population should stabilise around 206 million by 2025 (as against 201 million in 2000) (Figure 5).
84
D. Gentile and S. Allal / Sustainable Energy Scenarios in the Mediterranean 400 350
PSEM
300
millions habitants
250 200
Nord
150 100 50 0 1950
1970
1980
1990
2000
2010
2020
Source: Plan Bleu, OME, 2005
Figure 5. Demographic evolution around Mediterrenean
3. The Consequences for Energy: Basic-Trend Scenarios (OME) •
•
The OME has drawn up for the Mediterranean basin as a whole a basic scenario with a forecasting horizon of 2025. This “basic-trend” scenario, socalled, is based on the guidelines defined in the Mediterranean countries’ energy strategies and takes into account the countries’ demographic and economic growth. It enables us to project, country by country, the level of primary energy demands and structure by source. The scenario is a nonsustainable one in which there is no significant change in the growth of consumption, with priority given to energy restraint. Even though the scenario integrates the pursuit of a certain underlying technological progress (a fall of the order of 0.9% per annum in energy intensity), according to these projections the total demand in primary energy in the Mediterranean basin as a whole could be as high as 1,400 Mtep by 2025 (Figure 6). In relation to 2000, growth would be of the order of 500 Mtep, that is +65% for the period as a whole and +2.1% on average per annum, for an average annual GDP growth of 2.7% in the Mediterranean basin as a whole. Between now and 2025, the PSEMs should experience growth rates in their energy demands four times greater than those of the PNMs, corresponding to a growth of +350 Mtep, that is 3.8% per annum between 2000 and 2025, as against + 200 Mtep, that is +1.2% per annum in the PNMs. By 2025, Turkey will have become the second biggest consumer of energy in the Mediterranean. The relative share of the PSEMs in the total consumption of energy in the Mediterranean will thus grow from 10% in 1970 to 40% in 2025. This basic-trend scenario results above all in spectacular growth in the demand for electricity in the region. Primary commercial energy is consumed first and foremost to produce electricity (34% on average, and possibly as much as 40% by 2025). It is the form of energy that has enjoyed the strongest growth in recent years, thanks to the development of the industrial sector (new processes, automation) and improvements in living standards in the residential sector (electrical appliances, air-conditioning, etc.).
85
D. Gentile and S. Allal / Sustainable Energy Scenarios in the Mediterranean
•
Total electricity consumption for the Mediterranean countries has more than tripled over the last three decades, reaching nearly 1,5000 TWh in 2000, with an average annual growth rate between 1971 and 2000 far superior (+4.5%) to that of primary energy consumption or the GDP. According to this basic-trend scenario, the strong growths in electricity consumption in the PSEMs will continue, reaching approximately 2,800 TWh by 2025 (which corresponds to a growth of +2.5% per annum), with an eventual tripling of electricity consumption in the PSEMs by 2025 (Figure 7). Again according to this scenario, in all of the countries the number of electricity consumers progresses strongly, reaching by 2025 an average of more than 8,500 kWh per inhabitant in the PNMs, but only 3,400 kWh per inhabitant in the PSEMs. The gap between the countries on the opposite shores of the Mediterranean grows smaller, but remains sizeable (from 1 to 2.5). This basic-trend scenario, anticipating a very strong growth in demand, prompts one to consider two big types of risk that could lead to reorientating current energy choices in the Mediterranean: − the first is of a geopolitical and socio-economic character and concerns the growing insecurity of energy developments in the Mediterranean countries, linked to the question of the access to energy of present and future generations; − the second is linked to a foreseeable worsening of the impacts of production and the use of energy on the environment and health.
Faced with these two risks, strategies that favour a more sustainable energy development in the Mediterranean are desirable. They should be based on energy that is efficient in terms of supply and demand, and on large-scale development of low-carbon forms of energy. The important goal of decoupling economics/necessary emission in the region will only be reached by the comingtogether of numerous changes in life-style, production and consumption, in the nature of infrastructures (urbanism, transport, etc.), in improved energy efficiency and the use of non-carbon technologies. The question this raises concerns EuroMediterranean coordination of the effort required and the public policies to be applied for the deployment of such sustainable strategies for the region. 2800
1600
2400 2000 1600
P S EM
800
P S EM
1200 800
400
NORD
0 1970
1980
1990
2000
2010
NORD
400 2025
TWh
Mtep
1200
0 1970
1980
1990
2000
2010
Source: OME, 2004
Figure 6. (left) Trend scenario for primary energy consumption in the Mediterranean
Figure 7. (right) Trend scenario for primary electricity consumption in the Mediterranean
2025
86
D. Gentile and S. Allal / Sustainable Energy Scenarios in the Mediterranean
4. Sustainable Scenario for the Region •
By way of illustration, the OME has sought to quantify the benefits of orientations of this kind, by means of a volontarist scenario that can be distinguished from the basic scenario by: − exploitation of a reservoir of economies of possible energies to the tune of 20% to 25% of the total energy demand, a perfectly “realistic” reservoir in the light of currently available techniques; − a more rapid development of renewable energies: 15% of primary energy output by 2025 (excluding biomass), as against 8% in the basic scenario, and 40% of electricity production, as against 20% in the basic scenario. These goals have been differentiated according to country. Comparing the two scenarios (volontarist and basic-trend) yields the following: − an energy intensity falling twice as fast, by 1.6% per annum; − an economising of energy of 208 Mtep per annum by 2025, equivalent to approximately half the foreseeable growth in demands between 2000 and 2025. 60% of this reservoir concerns the PSEMs, and 40% the PNMs ; − a 20-point fall in the average dependancy index of the Mediterranean countries in relation to the basic scenario by 2025. Overall, for the basin as a whole, it should fall from 34% to 18% between 2000 and 2025, whereas it should rise to 38% in the basic scenario by 2025; − sizeable financial economies, estimated at $450 billion for the period in question; − notable reductions, in the region of 25%, in CO 2 emissions linked to the Mediterranean countries’ energy activities. Needless to say, these orders of magnitude have no predictive value. They merely underline how much room for manoeuvre there is when it comes to energy restraint. They also illustrate, in quantitative terms, the high stakes involved in possible alternative scenarios that simultaneously reduce vulnerability to a variety of geopolitical, socio-economic and environmental risks. This volontarist scenario also shows how important it is to act quickly. Given the inertia of energy systems and the irreversability of certain structures, the choices we make today are crucial. Whichever scenario we envisage, and regardless of national policies, cooperation—and Euro-Mediterranean cooperation in particular—can play a very important role in favouring the development of such a sustainable scenario for the region.
Session 3 Participation in International Projects: SESAME Convener: Herwig SCHOPPER Chairman of SESAME Council, Geneva Former Director General of CERN
Sharing Knowledge Across the Mediterranean Area P. Faugeras et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2006 © 2006 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
89
SESAME – Synchrotron Light for Experimental Science and Applications for the Middle East19 Herwig SCHOPPER Chairman SESAME Council Abstract. SESAME is an international centre for research being set up in Jordan, near Amman. It will promote science and technology in the Middle-East by making available a facility for synchrotron radiation which can be used for research in many domains. At the same time, it will offer invaluable opportunities to develop cooperation and solidarity in the troubled region through joint efforts in science.
SESAME is an international centre for research being set up in Allaan (Jordan) situated 30 km from Amman, Jordan, following the model of CERN. It will promote science and technology in the Middle-East by making available a facility for synchrotron radiation which can be used for research in many domains, e.g. physics, material research, environment, archaeology, biology and even medicine. It will, at the same time, offer invaluable opportunities to develop cooperation and solidarity in the troubled region through joint efforts in science. In the long run it will contribute to establish a basis of know-how which will be indispensable to tackle also more general problems of the region. It has the following two main objectives: 1. 2.
promote science, technology and applications in the region, create confidence and improve the mutual understanding between partners of different traditions, religions and mentalities (“science for peace”) This will be achieved by • • • • •
Creating a centre of excellence for interdisciplinary research Promote the scientific international collaboration with the main criterion of scientific excellence Training of scientists, students, technicians and even administrators Attract scientists working abroad (reverse brain drain) Promote the development of applications and high-tech industry
The sources of synchrotron radiation have become in the whole world extremely useful tools for research. They are important for the long-term development of 19
Original text in English.
90
H. Schopper / SESAME – Synchrotron Light for Experimental Science and Applications
countries like improving the general conditions of life, reduce unemployment and education. Even a small fraction (1 or 2%) of the funds which are spent for short-term problem (e.g. infrastructures for roads and water) would be sufficient for such longterm projects. Like CERN, SESAME has been created under the auspices of UNESCO as an autonomous international laboratory by a decision of the Executive Board of UNESCO (Spring 2002) that qualified SESAME as a “quintessential UNESCO project combining capacity building with vital peace-building through science” and described it as a “... model project for other regions....”. UNESCO is the depository of the Statutes of SESAME. These Statutes came into force in April 2004 when six countries notified the Director-General of their wish to join the Centre and their acceptance of the Statutes. From 1999 until the Statutes came into force in April 2004, a number of countries participated in the work of the Interim Council (IC) that had been set up to take the necessary measures to prepare the establishment of the Centre. They did so either as Members or Observers of the IC. Following the formal recognition of the Centre by UNESCO in April 2004, most of the countries having participated in the IC confirmed their membership status in what then became the permanent Council of SESAME, namely Bahrain, Egypt, Israel, Jordan, Pakistan, the Palestinian Authority and Turkey. Some countries are still in the process of doing so e.g. Morocco, Cyprus and Iran. Iraq has recently asked to become a Member. Germany, Greece, Italy, Kuwait, the Russian Federation, Sweden, UAE, the UK and the USA are Observers. France, Spain and Japan are also shortly expected to become Observers. Other countries have expressed interest in becoming members. The basis for choosing Jordan as Host State was the assurance that all scientists of the world would have free access to the Centre, and the commitment by the Government of Jordan to provide the land, the existing buildings on the land, as well as the funds for the construction of the building to house the facility. H.M. Abdullah II, King of Jordan, strongly supports the project. Jordan and SESAME have signed a Seat Agreement guaranteeing SESAME privileges similar to those CERN has been given by its Host States, e.g. tax-free salaries. A tripartite cooperation agreement has been signed between Jordan, CERN and SESAME. Some countries have to acquire a new mentality having become a Member of an international organisation. They have to learn that they are “owners” of the centre even if it is not located in their own country. Each member, independent of its geographical location, has the same rights as far as the decision taking (definition of programmes, appointment of directors, etc), utilisation, recruitment of staff and industrial contracts are concerned. A conceptual design for the SESAME machine with a final energy of 2.5 GeV has been approved using components of the BESSY I storage ring and injector system which stopped operation in Berlin at the end of November 1999 and which were donated by the German government. These components were shipped from Germany to Jordan where they are being kept in trust by the Jordanian Ministry of Education until the building to house the Centre has been completed. Funds for the up-grading of the machine are being negotiated with the European Commission. SESAME will be a fully competitive 3.generation synchrotron radiation facility comparable to many similar machines in the whole world, but it will be the first such machine in the Mediterranean region and the Middle East.
H. Schopper / SESAME – Synchrotron Light for Experimental Science and Applications
91
The construction work of the building that is to host the Centre started in August 2003 and is expected to be ready in fall 2006. The installation of the injector system will then start immediately. Beamlines for the first phase of exploitation have been identified in close cooperation with potential users. Contacts with the users’ community are assured by four advisory committees (Beamlines, Scientific, Technical and Training Committee) which have organized a number of users’ meeting and workshops. Beamlines will have to be financed from outside the normal budget. Funds for beamline equipment are being sought from other organisations like IAEA. Some Members of SESAME have expressed their intention to take the responsibility for particular beamlines. Some components will also be obtained from other laboratories, as SLAC (Stanford Linear Accelerator Center) in the U.S. and Lure (Laboratoire pour l’Utilisation du Rayonnement Electromagnétique) in France which are donating components of beamlines from decommissioned machines. The Centre is managed by a Director (Minister Kh. Toukan, Jordan), an Administrative Director (H.Helal, Egypt), a Scientific Director (A. Baig, Pakistan) and a Technical Director (G. Vignola, Italy). It also has a core staff working on the upgrading of the machine. These are accelerator specialists from the region who have been trained in synchrotron radiation laboratories in Europe and the United States. The governing body of the centre is an international Council chaired by H.Schopper (Germany) and two Vice-Presidents (Dincer Ulkü, Turkey and Fawzy Elrefaie, President of the Egyptian Academy of Sciences). Training is one of the major objectives of SESAME, in particular • • •
the formation of young scientists and engineers of the region for the construction and operation of the machine, the training of scientists for the design, construction and operation of the beamlines, the education of potential users.
For this purpose fellowships and other support were made available by IAEA, ICTP, USA, Japan and some laboratories. From about 100 applicants from the region 20 were selected to spend a year or longer at European laboratories like Daresbury (UK), Lure (Paris), ESRF (Grenoble), ANKA (Karlsruhe), SLS (Villigen), Elletra (Trieste), DESY (Hamburg), Max-Lab (Lund). Eight experts were invited to stays in labs in the USA financed by DOE. A new training programme is under discussion with IAEA for which from 32 applications 9 scientists were selected already. The European Scientific Institute has accepted 9 researchers from SESAME members for the Joint Universities Accelerator School (JUAS 2005) in Geneva and because of the good experience they have offered to accept further young scientists for the 2006 schools. The National Synchrotron Radiation Research Centre (NSRRC) at Taiwan had funded three fellowships in 2005 and because of the satisfactory results they offered to continue the programme in 2006. Several workshops in different fields have been organized and users meeting take place regularly to keep close contacts with the potential users’ community. In conclusion it may be stated that SESAME has passed the threshold of no return, although some problems have still to be settled. It is expected that the SESAME machine will become operational in 2009. The more the realisation of the project takes
92
H. Schopper / SESAME – Synchrotron Light for Experimental Science and Applications
shape, the more interest and enthusiasm among potential users but also funding organisation can be observed. It is hoped that Morocco will take a positive decision to join SESAME in the near future and Morocco could even play an important role in coordinating the activities in other countries of North Africa.
Sharing Knowledge Across the Mediterranean Area P. Faugeras et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2006 © 2006 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
93
SESAME Science Programme – an Example of Knowledge Transfer 20 Samar HASNAIN Molecular Biophysics Group & North West Structural Genomics Centre Abstract. Synchrotron radiation sources have been an important research tool over the last decades. Developed countries have numerous sources and it is important that Middle-east countries have their own to promote research in atomic and molecular physics, structural and molecular biology, material sciences, environment and archaeology. Scientists from these different disciplines and from different countries will then be in close contact, which can only be beneficial to sciences and peace in the region.
It’s a real pleasure to be here in Morocco and I’d like to give my bottom-line statement already that it is essential for countries such as Morocco to become member of SESAME if they have any aspiration to make the country independent of others as well as building an infrastructure compatible with a knowledge-based economy. What I want to really do in this talk is to show you how SESAME has acted as a real example of knowledge transfer from those countries that have the knowledge of building and exploiting synchrotron radiation sources to countries and regions where this has not been the case at all. One of the things Professor Schopper has already mentioned is that the “synchrotron radiation” sources have been growing like mushrooms; they do look like the top of a mushroom, as you’ll see from various pictures. Until very recently, I would say, about 10 years ago or so, they have been the privilege of industrialized countries, or scientifically advanced countries, as one may want to call them. In the last 10 years or so they have become much more a symbol of aspiration from countries that are what we would call emerging economies and I’ll give you some examples of those as we go along. So let me start from the last slide that G. Vignola showed (Figure 1). I feel that the SESAME team has worked very hard and can be proud that one is trying to work towards a synchrotron radiation source in the Middle East region where there isn’t such a facility, just like Africa. For a third generation source, as we saw in the example of G. Vignola, the characteristics are identical even in terms of emittence to what is being currently built in Canada.
20
Transcription from oral in English.
94
S. Hasnain / SESAME Science Programme – An Example of Knowledge Transfer
Figure 1. Flux of the radiation from the different SR sources of the 2.5 GeV SESAME. The numbers in mm in the boxes are the corresponding period length.
So, just to give you an idea of what we’ve been talking about, the first radiation sources started with electron machines like Desy, like Mina, like Frascati and in Stanford: they started with the exploitation of bending magnets. Bending magnets in the curved region have provided already 6 orders of magnitude more X-rays than possible with conventional sources (Figure 2). The second and third generation sources have been based primarily on what we call insertion devices, namely ondulators. And more recently ondulators in vacuum have been pioneered by the Japanese synchrotron radiation sources and now these have been used with other sources, and SESAME has definitely the aspiration of acquiring that in the phase-1 beamlines. And if you look at ondulators, one is talking of about 11 orders of magnitude in terms of the brilliance, which is available in the X-ray region. Many of you would know why the X-ray region is important and I will show you here a few examples, which will demonstrate in a graphic fashion the speed with which the brilliance is being increasing through the sources starting from the rotating anode X-ray tube. One of the beauties of the synchrotron radiation sources is that they are truly interdisciplinary centres. To show you an example of a developed facility, let’s look at the first dedicated X-ray source synchrotron radiation sources at Daresbury, which is where I work. Now what you see (Figure 3) is that the zones which are coloured are Xray equipment. Those which do not have what we called X-ray huts are exploiting VUV and soft X-rays. The X-rays are primarily used for material science and for biological sciences and of course for environmental sciences, while VUV and soft Xrays are used for atomic molecular sciences and surface sciences. So you see that biologists, material scientists and physicists are working in very close proximity and their mutual knowledge is transferred just by proximity. So these are true interdisciplinary centres, and this is the reason of the success of the growth of the synchrotron radiation facilities as the basic science infrastructures.
S. Hasnain / SESAME Science Programme – An Example of Knowledge Transfer
Figure 2.
Figure 3.
95
96
S. Hasnain / SESAME Science Programme – An Example of Knowledge Transfer
Let me go back to my first point. There are currently 54 light sources which are operational in 19 countries, and this is no longer a priority of the scientifically developed countries; many countries have joined in. One of the first was India, the late Indira Gandhi who decided to put synchrotron radiation as part of the development of the region of Indore. Brazil has built a very successful synchrotron radiation facility in Campinas. China has been running such a source and recently has given approval for a third generation source in Shanghai. And of course, Singapore, Korea, Taiwan, and Thailand all have third generation sources, and they have been seen as part of infrastructure essential for development of a knowledge-based economy. 10 extraordinary facilities are in construction, including the SESAME, in Spain, UK, Australia, and France. The characteristics of the Spanish source are very similar to what has been done and developed for Jordan. Now, just to give you again an idea of the impact of X-ray, one measure is to look at Nobel Prizes which have been awarded for works using X-rays. Since the beginning, 18 have been awarded right across scientists, so you have physicists, medicine and chemistry, all these major disciplines are benefiting from the availability of X-rays. More recently two have been awarded directly from the synchrotron radiation experiments which have been carried out in the last 10 years or so. The latest of these has been given to Roderick Mackinnon. His first experimental result was obtained in December 23 1997, Nobel Prize was awarded in 2003. Very, very rapid recognition. This work was done at two synchrotron radiation sources, Chess at Cornell which is a first generation source and at the Brookhaven NSLS light source which is a second generation light source. The previous Prize was given to Sir John Walker for the discovery of F1-ATPase, its structure and the mechanism of its formation and this was recognised in 1997. This was done on SRS, at Daresbury which is the second generation SR source. I just make the point that these two Nobel Prizes have been awarded for works with the first and second generation sources. Just please remember that because I will highlight that in the context of SESAME performance. As we’ve heard, the synchrotron radiation and X-rays have made a huge impact in structural biology. Since the first researches that have been done on haemoglobin and which deserved Nobel Prizes only 30 years ago or so, the size of these structures has increased. Virus structures could be determined in 1985 and the nucleosome and ribosome structures were obtained in 1995: the size and complexity of these structures is becoming tremendous. Around 1970 it was inconceivable that we will ever attend the whole molecular machine structure of such complex proteins. So not only the complexity of the structure has increased but also the numbers of the structures are increasing extremely rapidly. And in fact in the UK, the structure of the F1-ATPase acted as a catalyst for the next generation of light sources to be built in the UK, which is known as Diamond. No wonder Biology is a major component of what has been proposed for SESAME. So these are just examples. Each of these in my view are worth a Nobel Prize, it’s just a question of what your luck is. The largest structure to date has been on Blue tongue virus core which is made up of thousands of proteins and every single atom in this structure has been determined using X-ray crystallography using a third generation source, ESRF in this particular case. So now let me just give you what Diamond is (Figure 4): this is a VUV source of very large circumference, very high performance and of course the cost according to the circumference is very large. But I just want to come on the right hand side of figure 4 which explains that the first design and proposal for this facility was made in 1992, the
S. Hasnain / SESAME Science Programme – An Example of Knowledge Transfer
97
funding was announced within 18 months of the F1-ATPase Nobel Prize, the site was decided between 1999 and spring 2003 and it will come in operation in 2007. So what you see here is the typical timescale for a scientifically advanced country where there’s a huge amount of scientific infrastructure for synchrotron radiation. UK was the country where the first dedicated structure for synchrotron radiation was built and it has taken 15 years. This is also the timescale that has been achieved for SESAME, and from that point of view, this is marvellous and in fact it is indeed praiseworthy to the counsel and everyone else.
Figure 4.
One of the major events in terms of the scientific program of SESAME that took place in October 2002 was funded by the Japanese, JSPS, who brought together the funding and the organisation necessary for what we call the first User Meeting which was highly successful. Through this and many other meetings, one has developed a scientific program for SESAME. So several hundreds scientists have been involved from the Middle East and from the wider region and they are on the best site and they have been put together and prioritised in terms of the six beamlines of phase one. The next user meeting is on the 5th– 8th of December 2005, the detailed program is on the website, I would encourage everyone from the Moroccan and the wider region to come and attend this meeting to look at the latest review of what is happening at the light source. Scientists at SESAME are divided up into 6 broad disciplines: structural and molecular biology, atomic and molecular sciences, which is basically physics, surface and interface science, environmental science, material science and archaeological science. Let me show you the types of insertion devices and the different regions which we’re going to use all the way from infrared to X-rays: we’ll have bending magnets, multiple wigglers and ondulators in vacuum (Figure 5).
98
S. Hasnain / SESAME Science Programme – An Example of Knowledge Transfer
Figure 5. Phase One Beamlines
What you see again on the fore plan (Figure 6) is an intermix of what is taking place on this science facilities. You can see the beamlines with some details of the design, which has taken place. And what you see also are offline facilities of material science, biomedical labs, environmental and archaeology and physics. So you really see the intermix of different sciences and disciplines. I don’t have time to go through these slides, and I’m just going to give you a flavour of what is happening in terms of applications: this is the corner for physics, magnetic materials, memories for highly advanced aspects. Again in the context of environment, techniques such as powder analysis will be used at SESAME. Archaeological science is going to be an important area, which again has a tremendous influence in the whole of the region: tracing history that you could do here is of extreme importance in terms of cultural heritage but also for the politicians and the decision makers. Environment/ Archaeology
Physics
Material Science LAB
BIOMEDICAL LAB
Figure 6.
S. Hasnain / SESAME Science Programme – An Example of Knowledge Transfer
99
So let me just come to some conclusion which is the bottom line and my inspiration of being involved in this project. If I look at the scientifically advanced countries synchrotron-radiation sources and their populations, and divide the total number for their population by the number of synchrotron-radiation sources then one comes to a simple conclusion, that these scientifically advanced countries have a synchrotron-radiation source for every 40 million population. If we compare it to the current existing members of SESAME we have a population of 305 million, in excess of that in the US and if we use the same ratio then we should have at least 7.5 synchrotron-radiation sources for these countries. Morocco has a population of 32 million and I think if Morocco wants to join in the knowledge-based economy it needs to invest in infrastructures of this kind. I believe that by becoming members of SESAME, they’ll be able to create many more synchrotron-radiation sources for the future in the region. And let me just finish with a quote of Abdus Salam which I think happily summarises the aspiration of this audience very eloquently: Science and technology are cyclical. They are a shared heritage of all mankind. East and West, North and South have all equally participated in their creation in the past, as we hope that they will in the future – the joint endeavor in sciences becoming one of the unifying forces among diverse peoples of this globe. Thank you very much.
100
Sharing Knowledge Across the Mediterranean Area P. Faugeras et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2006 © 2006 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
The Synchrotron and the Laser: are they Friends or Foes?21 Jean-Patrick CONNERADE Blackett Laboratory, Imperial College, London, and Euroscience, Strasbourg Abstract. The purpose of the present paper is to provide a brief introduction to the applications of Synchrotron Radiation (and in particular the SESAME ring) in the area of Atomic Physics. Atomic physicists are usually among the first to become involved in Synchrotron radiation experiments, and atomic physics remains an excellent introduction to the subject area of synchrotron radiation as a whole.
1. General Remarks and Background The many-body problem of classical physics is unsolved. The reason for this is understood: it is a consequence of the occurrence of chaos, as explained by Poincaré: there exist no solutions to the classical orbit equations for three bodies in closed form. In quantum physics, the situation is much less clear. The granularity of phase space, due to the uncertainty principle, is believed to inhibit chaos. Classical chaos, in order to occur, requires an infinite divisibility along the lines of the celebrated ‘universes within universes’ first described by Blaise Pascal. Interest therefore attaches to two situations. The first is the study of many-body effects in quantum mechanical systems, and the second is the persistence of chaotic effects from classical to quantum systems. In performing such studies, it is desirable to remove all sources of confusion due for example to a poor knowledge of the potential, and to work with a fully scaleable system. Both reasons lead one to select atoms, first because the inverse square law is the best known law of force in physics and second because it is completely scaleable. In atomic physics, many-body effects appear in a range of energies between the Xrays and the optical domain. This range is entirely accessible to synchrotron radiation, whereas the laser can only cover restricted portions, which are useful but do not allow the full range of phenomena to be studied. It is therefore necessary to use both types of source, and to have a good understanding of their respective properties in order to exploit their complementary features to the full. A particular aspect of the expertise required to perform synchrotron radiation experiments is indeed their complementarity with laser spectroscopy. This is important to recognize, because it provides both a route into synchrotron studies and an essential background training for researchers, who can perform in-house experiments in their own laboratories before attempting to work in the environment of a synchrotron radiation laboratory.
21
Original text in English.
J.-P. Connerade / The Synchrotron and the Laser: Are They Friends or Foes?
101
I will provide some simple examples to show that the two experimental methods are complementary. In some cases, we have even obtained our data by using both techniques, which allows them to be compared. I will not discuss the effects of high radiation intensity on the spectral response of atoms (multi-photon effects), since these are accessible by laser spectroscopy, but are still beyond the reach of synchrotron radiation studies at time of writing. Some of my examples are drawn from a review paper published in the Arabian Journal of Physics [1], and some others from a book recently re-issued by the Cambridge University Press [2]. 2. Examples drawn from Synchrotron and Laser Experiments on Free Atoms The most important wavelength range for atomic physics is the far ultraviolet and soft X-ray range, within which the simple approximations of the conventional independent electron model cease to apply. This turns out to be the most favourable range experimentally for many synchrotron radiation sources. Furthermore, the synchrotron covers all of this range, whereas lasers cover only a part of it.
Figure 1. Typical energy ranges for synchrotron radiation studies of atomic and molecular spectra
The main advantage of synchrotron radiation is the breadth of its radiation spectrum, which covers the full range from the infrared to the X-ray range essentially as a continuum. No laser is able to do that. However, windowless experiments cannot be performed under pressure, because an accelerator must function in good vacuum. The laser may then provide the only viable alternative. For instance, the example shown in Figure 2 would be very difficult to study with synchrotron radiation. In this experiment, a rather unusual perturbation of a Rydberg series was studied as a function of the pressure of a foreign gas introduced in the atomic column. This experiment would have been difficult to perform by using synchrotron radiation since it requires a buffer gas in the cell, and detection of very high Rydberg members by measuring the ionisation current using a thermionic diode detector, all of which are difficult to accomplish otherwise than by using lasers.
102
J.-P. Connerade / The Synchrotron and the Laser: Are They Friends or Foes?
Figure 2. Two-photon spectra of Calcium in the presence of a pressure of extraneous buffer gas. Notice the pronounced perturbation at high Rydberg members, which grows dramatically with increasing pressure of the buffer gas.
In fact, a simple way to tune a monomode laser is also to sweep the pressure in the oscillator cavity. If the cavity has been well tuned to a single mode, this procedure gives very good resolution, but unfortunately over a very limited wavelength range (typically, about 3 Ångströms for Nitrogen, but this depends also on the refractive index of the gas which is used). In Figure 3, the design of a homebuilt pressure-tuned Littman cavity which we have operated at Imperial College is shown. Notice that this is a simple, table-top device, in which a dye cell is pumped by an external fixed-frequency excimer laser operated at 308nm.
Figure 3. Design of pressure-tuned high resolution pulsed laser oscillator
J.-P. Connerade / The Synchrotron and the Laser: Are They Friends or Foes?
103
This type of laser can provide extremely high resolution in a very simple way in a small laboratory environment such as can readily be set up in a university. This enables researchers not only to complement a synchrotron radiation programme by higher resolution experiments performed ‘in house’, but also to train students on optical experiments before sending them to work in a synchrotron radiation laboratory. It is also very important for synchrotron users to know what can be achieved using laser sources, because the resolution available with a laser source cannot readily be achieved at the synchrotron. An example of a spectrum obtained using a tuneable laser based on the oscillator of Figure 3 is shown in Figure 4, which shows very high members of the principal series of Barium.
Figure 4. High members of the Principal Series of barium. The series can be followed up to a principal quantum number of about 120.
The next slide shows a direct comparison between the resolution achievable by coherent four-wave mixing using a number of laser beams to achieve short enough wavelengths, and by direct excitation using synchrotron radiation for precisely the same atomic spectrum. Note that two synchronously pumped lasers are required and that the tuning range displayed for the laser-based spectrum is only a few angströms. The higher resolution of the laser is not simply due to the optical components, but also in part to the higher flux of photons, which allows thermionic detection to be employed, and therefore yields much more reliable line profiles than one can obtain by photoabsorption techniques.
104
J.-P. Connerade / The Synchrotron and the Laser: Are They Friends or Foes?
Figure 5. Comparison between spectra of the high Rydberg members of the Magnesium atom obtained by synchrotron spectroscopy in photoabsorption (upper spectrum) and by coherent four-wave mixing spectroscopy using several laser beams (lower spectrum)
As it is showed in Figures 5 and 6, coherent sources can give tremendous spectral resolution, but of course their coverage remains very limited. Furthermore, as one exploits the almost inexhaustible wavelength coverage of the synchrotron source, by increasing the photon energy, to break into the more interesting range shown in Figure 1, high resolution becomes less relevant. Indeed there are many situations where it is actually not needed, especially in the ultraviolet and soft X-ray ranges, where synchrotron radiation is at its best. A fundamental limit for atomic spectroscopy is the natural width of a spectral line. In the UV and soft X-ray ranges, this is usually set by auto-ionisation broadening or by the Auger effect, not by radiative widths.
J.-P. Connerade / The Synchrotron and the Laser: Are They Friends or Foes?
105
Figure 6. Example of an autoionising line profile observed by laser spectroscopy
Consequently, we need to understand lineshapes, or more specifically: how shapes of lines are altered by interactions between overlapping or interacting profiles. These are indeed consequences of the many-body interactions. My next few examples will be taken from synchrotron spectra. In fact, one finds that there are many different types of line profile which can occur when autoionising resonances interact with each other. This subject has been studied a lot experimentally, and the observations using synchrotron radiation have revealed a rich variety of line profiles. Figure 7 shows the two basic types of profile, and is drawn from observations of both Xenon and Magnesium atoms in the autoionising range. The diversity of interactions is exemplified by the spectra of Figure 8, which show how spectral profiles of autoionising states can fluctuate in shape and width when they overlap. These changes reveal many interesting aspects of the many-body interactions, and are of great interest to theorists who wish to unravel the complexities of atomic spectra in this energy range. A full theory of the shapes of these interacting resonances has been set up, and is described, for example, in the book on highly excited atoms referred to previously. In this brief review, I will concentrate on experimental material, although some of the figures (in particular Figure 2) show theoretical curves which are intended to illustrate the ideal shapes calculated from the theory of interacting resonances for a wide range of possible parameters.
106
J.-P. Connerade / The Synchrotron and the Laser: Are They Friends or Foes?
Figure 7. The two basic types of resonance which can be observed in an autoionising Rydberg series are demonstrated by two experimental examples, drawn from the spectra of Magnesium and of Xenon.
J.-P. Connerade / The Synchrotron and the Laser: Are They Friends or Foes?
107
Figure 8. Various lineshapes observed in synchrotron radiation spectra of Thallium atoms. Note in particular the symmetry reversals which are characteristic of interacting line profiles.
When lines are very sharp, and occur in a suitable range for tuneable lasers, then it is usually better to turn to a laser source, which is why it is important to be familiar with both types of sources, and to perform experiments in two phases, using, e.g. one source (usually, the synchrotron radiation source) for exploration and the other (often the laser, if it is available in the required energy range) to complete the study. I now give an example of interacting profiles observed by laser spectroscopy. When performing such a laser experiment, which requires a long and tedious high resolution scan, it is an enormous advantage to have the synchrotron spectrum to refer to as the investigation proceeds. Figure 8 in particular shows an effect which was discovered using synchrotron radiation (the q-reversal effect): this is a flip in the symmetry of a series of autoionising resonances as a function of energy they pass through a very broad intruder. Indeed, this symmetry flip can be shown to occur at the point of maximum interaction, and there are some very general theorems which regulate the appearance and the number of such symmetry changes which can occur in an atomic spectrum. These theorems do not only apply in atomic physics, but can be extended to other subjects such as nuclear spectroscopy. However, atoms provide a particularly simple and mathematically ‘clean’ example, again because of the special properties of the scaleable inverse square law of force.
108
J.-P. Connerade / The Synchrotron and the Laser: Are They Friends or Foes?
Figure 9. Interacting autoionising resonances observed in a portion of the spectrum of the Ytterbium atom, showing how complicated changes in the line profiles are revealed by high resolution laser spectroscopy.
The very high flux of laser radiation into a narrow bandwidth obtained with synchrotron radiation sources (typically a kilowatt into a few gigahertz) allows ion and electron counting techniques to be used without compromising spectral resolution. By contrast, for ion counting with synchrotron radiation, a high flux machine with an undulator is desirable. Even then, sacrifices in resolution are inevitable, although the situation will improve with the new generation machines. To illustrate this point, I show data for Ca obtained at the DORIS accelerator with an undulator, and (for the same spectrum) with a coherent four-wave mixing method. First, in Figure 10, I show the Ca spectrum obtained with a thermionic diode at the DORIS undulator, using a chopper for phase-sensitive detection. From Figure 10, one would not suspect the enormous complexity underlying the Ca double excitation spectrum, which only emerges when one attempts a high resolution scan (see Figure 11) by laser spectroscopy.
J.-P. Connerade / The Synchrotron and the Laser: Are They Friends or Foes?
109
Figure 10. Spectrum of double excitations in Ca obtained by thermionic diode detection, using a chopper for phase-sensitive detection at the Doris undulator.
Figure 11. The underlying complexity of the doubly-excited spectrum of Ca.
Even Figure 11, which actually reveals over part of the energy range the emergence of ‘quantum chaos’ triggered by many-body interactions, does not do full justice to the detail which can be extracted by laser spectroscopy, as Figure 12 shows, which only contains a tiny portion of the most regular part of the spectrum in Figure 11.
110
J.-P. Connerade / The Synchrotron and the Laser: Are They Friends or Foes?
Figure 12. A tiny portion of the spectrum of Fig 11, obtained by coherent four-wave mixing spectroscopy at Imperial College.
Nonlinear four-wave mixing is a rather complex trick to extend the wavelength range of lasers. It allows beautiful details of a spectrum to be seen, provided its basic features are already known by synchrotron spectroscopy. Without prior knowledge of the spectrum achieved by using synchrotron radiation, it would be almost impossible to set up such a complex investigation. As another example of the complex effects which have been discovered by combining synchrotron radiation and laser spectroscopies, I give the vanishing fluctuation effect, which is illustrated in Figure 13, from the spectrum of barium.
Figure 13. The vanishing fluctuation effect
As one enters the range of inner shell spectroscopy, it becomes more and more difficult to use lasers to perform fine studies. In the following example (Figure 14), we see a rather high resolution spectrum obtained by multi-colour laser spectroscopy. This is probably as far as one can go by this technique, and the range covered then becomes so small that there is not much one can do using laser techniques.
J.-P. Connerade / The Synchrotron and the Laser: Are They Friends or Foes?
111
Figure 14. Example of multicolour laser spectroscopy
By way of contrast, I now show the full inner shell spectrum of Ca obtained by synchrotron spectroscopy (Figure 16). From this example, one may conclude that inner shells are hard to reach, with meagre results using lasers, but are ideally suited to be studied using synchrotron radiation.
Figure 16. The 3p inner shell spectrum of calcium by synchrotron spectroscopy
3. Experiments with Externally Applied Fields Another aspect of Synchrotron and laser studies is the exploitation of the polarisation of radiation to measure atomic oscillator strengths by using high magnetic fields to observe Faraday rotation. This is an extremely powerful method (the Magneto-Optical Vernier or MOV method, Figure 17), which was actually discovered by using synchrotron radiation. Both synchrotron radiation and coherent radiation sources are naturally polarised. This is a very useful feature which, again, makes them complementary.
112
J.-P. Connerade / The Synchrotron and the Laser: Are They Friends or Foes?
Figure 17. Magneto Optical Vernier pattern obtained by synchrotron radiation spectroscopy at the 500 MeV source of the Physikalisches Institut in Bonn
MOV patterns can also be obtained in the pulsed mode by laser spectroscopy, as shown in Figure 18. The study of such patterns can lead to a detailed understanding of the distribution of oscillator strengths in perturbed series.
Figure18. Oscillator strengths of the Ba Principal series
Finally, I give an example of an experiment which we do not yet know how to do with synchrotron radiation, although it might allow an important breakthrough to be achieved. The purpose of this experiment is to study ‘quantum chaos’ in three dimensions. The experimental layout involves a complex combination of laser and atomic beams, crossing inside a magnetic field, with a perpendicular electric field applied (Figure 19).
J.-P. Connerade / The Synchrotron and the Laser: Are They Friends or Foes?
113
Figure 19. Experimental arrangement for the crossed field studies at Imperial College (Hogan PhD thesis 2006)
The experiments with crossed fields have yielded an enormous amount of useful data relating to ‘quantum chaology’ (see the Stark maps of the diamagnetic spectra shown in Figure 20) but are limited to the investigation of bound states. The only way to extend the data would be to study photoionisation spectra of atoms in crossed fields. This, for the moment, lies beyond current experimental methods. Synchrotron radiation might well open up this new range of experiments, but further development of the detection techniques ill be required. Conclusion In conclusion, we can say that the synchrotron and the laser should be used together. To get the best results, use a laser at home and travel to a synchrotron from time to time. That way, you can cover a spectrum more completely, and use the power of the laser in the windows which are available. Also, you can go to a synchrotron source feeling confident about the experiment because it is familiar.
114
J.-P. Connerade / The Synchrotron and the Laser: Are They Friends or Foes?
Figure 20. Example of a Stark map for the diamagnetic patter of a Rydberg atom placed in crossed electric and magnetic fields. The data are obtained around principal quantum numbers of 52-55.
Acknowledgements The work described in this brief review owes much to a number of colleagues and former students who have contributed to it over many years. In particular, I would like to mention Professor M.Aslam. Baig (currently the Scientific Director of SESAME), Dr. Shahid Farooqi, Dr. Bakri Abdulla and Mr Stephen Hogan. Financial support for this research has come from a variety of sources, including The European Space Agency, the Deutscher Forschungsgemeinschaft, the Alexander von Humboldt Stiftung, the Bundesministerium für Forschungs und Technologie, the Royal Society of London and the Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council. References [1] [2]
J.-P. Connerade K.S. Bhattia and Y.Y. Makdisi, Spectroscopic Applications of Lasers, The Arabian Journal of Science and Engineering, 17 (1992), 191. J.-P. Connerade, Highly Excited Atoms, The Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1998 (re-issued as a paperback in 2005) ISBN-13 978-0-521-01788-6 and IBSN-10 0-521-01788-2.
115
Sharing Knowledge Across the Mediterranean Area P. Faugeras et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2006 © 2006 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
Other Contributions SESAME: Civil Construction and Machine Parameters Gaetano VIGNOLA SESAME, Jordan No written contribution Presentation: 25 slides in English * Condensed Matter Studies in Morocco Abdellah BENYOUSSEF No written contribution Presentation: 33 slides in English
Session 5 From Food Security to Food Safety, Constructing a Euromediterranean Area Convener: Bernard BACHELIER Director of FARM, Paris
Sharing Knowledge Across the Mediterranean Area P. Faugeras et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2006 © 2006 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
119
Demographic Perspectives, Changes in the Agricultural and Food Situation in the Mediterranean Region: Questions for Research22 Vincent DOLLÉ Director of CIHEAM-IAMM 23 Abstract. The steady growth of the population in the Mediterranean region, which grew by 150 million inhabitants between 1975 and 2000, is the result of very different demographic dynamics between the northern countries, on the one hand, and the southern and eastern countries, on the other hand. This demographic growth has been accompanied by heavy urbanization and concentration in the coastal zone. Other disparities are developing between the northern Mediterranean countries and the southern and eastern Mediterranean countries (the SEM countries), especially in terms of economic growth and human development. Poverty strongly affects the rural sector of the SEM countries, the majority of whose inhabitants live from an often family-based agriculture with unpredictable results. The pressure on the resources of the Mediterranean region is growing. The dependence of the SEM countries for basic food products is strong and the recourse to imports is growing. In this paper, data is presented to give a better idea of the state of food safety and food security for the countries of the Mediterranean region. Complementary research paths between the north and south sides of the Mediterranean are envisaged, in order to reduce the disparities and build a veritable Euro-Mediterranean rural entity benefiting from new basic knowledge produced by a network of regional research and higher education institutions working together in order to promote sustainable rural development. Keywords. Mediterranean, sustainable agriculture, population, demography, resources, trade, globalization, Euro-Mediterranean entity, agri-food, agronomic science, food security, food safety.
1. Mediterranean Population: Retrospective Analysis of its Changes and 30-Year Demographic Projections In a half-century the population of the countries surrounding the Mediterranean grew by 150 million inhabitants; it went from 300 million in 1975 to 400 million in 1995, then to approximately 450 million in 2000 (see Figure 1). The organization Plan Bleu’s past population data and projections for the future lead them to an estimate of more than 500 million inhabitants in the Mediterranean region in 2025. Analyses done by the Original text in French, translated in English. E-mail:
[email protected] IAMM (Institut Agronomique Méditerranéen de Montpellier), 3191, route de Mende, 34093 Montpellier Cedex 5 (France). Tel. +33 (0) 4 67 04 60 10, Fax + 33 (0) 4 67 04 60 75. 22 23
120
V. Dollé / Demographic Perspectives, Changes in the Agricultural and Food Situation
United Nations and then used in the work of CIHEAM24 place the population of the region at approximately 700 million toward 2050.
Population of Mediterranean Countries Retrospective and demographic projection from 1970 to 2025 Population in millions TOTAL; SOUTH and EAST; NORTH →Countries of the North: Spain, France, Monaco, Italy, Malta, Slovenia, Greece, Croatia, Bosnia, Yugoslavia →Countries of the South and East: Turkey, Syria, Lebanon, Israel, Egypt, Libya, Tunisia, Algeria, Morocco, Cyprus →Total Figure 1. Population changes on the north and south sides of the Mediterranean, 1970–2025. Source: Plan Bleu 2000, Plan Bleu 11 booklet.
This overall strong demographic growth of the Mediterranean basin is however the result of demographic dynamics that are quite different in the north and south, as in the east of the Mediterranean. More precisely: by countries of the north 25 we mean the countries of Mediterranean Europe as well as the Balkans. The southern and eastern Mediterranean (SEM) countries26 include the countries of the Maghreb and of the Near and Middle East. 24 See Agriculture et alimentation en Méditerranée. Les défis de la mondialisation, Mohamed Salah Bachta and Gérard Ghersi, 2004. 25 Countries of the north: Bosnia, Croatia, Spain, France, Greece, Italy, Malta, Slovenia, and Yugoslavia. 26 Countries of the south and east (SEM): Algeria, Cyprus, Egypt, Israel, Lebanon, Libya, Morocco, Tunisia, Turkey, and Syria.
V. Dollé / Demographic Perspectives, Changes in the Agricultural and Food Situation
121
In the northern Mediterranean countries, demographic stability is accompanied by an aging of the population and an overall stabilization of births. In these countries, more than one person in two will be more than fifty years old in 2025. This weak demographic growth is to be found in the majority of the countries in the zone, with even, for some of them, a drop in the number of inhabitants. On the contrary, in the SEM countries, strong demographic growth can be seen leading to a tripling of the population in a single generation. The population in these countries is mostly young and the demographic transition that would progressively lead to a stabilization of growth is not expected before 2025 (Figure 2: Population changes in the Mediterranean region (1950–2050), source: United Nations). In 2000, the northern countries made up 70% of the population. In 2025, it’s the SEM countries that will constitute 60% of the Mediterranean population. Millions d’habitants 700 600 500
Méditerranée 400
Nord Sud
300 200 100
1 950
1 970
1 990
2 010
2 030
2 050
Figure 2. Population changes in the Mediterranean region (1950–2050)
A more precise analysis of the location of these populations in the countries of the Mediterranean basin clearly shows that the occupations and the populations are concentrated in the coastal zone. This tendency is long established in the north of the Mediterranean, but it is increasingly true in the south as well. 3,392 built-up areas counted more than 10,000 inhabitants in 1995 (Figure 3, source: Plan Bleu and Géopolis); these built-up areas numbered fewer than 1,900 in 1950. In 20 years, the Mediterranean cities will have 100 million people more than they do today.
122
V. Dollé / Demographic Perspectives, Changes in the Agricultural and Food Situation
Coastal Mediterranean city Inland Mediterranean city
Figure 3. The population of the Mediterranean region is concentrated on the coasts.
In the same period, a comparative analysis of the changes to the rural populations of the SEM countries and of the European Union (EU) shows a totally inverse tendency for these two regions up to 2000. The agricultural population in the SEM countries has grown steadily; it increased from 60 million inhabitants in 1960 to 100 million in 2000 (see Figure 4).
Millions d'habitants
Population rurale 120 100 80 60 40 20
Union Européenne Monétaire
19 60 19 65 19 70 19 75 19 80 19 85 19 90 19 95 20 00
0
PSEM
Figure 4. Rural population changes in the Mediterranean region. Source: World Bank.
Starting in 2000, the observations and the demographic projections put forth by the FAO and Plan Bleu indicate a stabilization of this population. In 2002, the majority of the rural population, i.e., 57% of the 189 million inhabitants, was concentrated on the southern side. After 2010, this rural population should decrease. These demographic
V. Dollé / Demographic Perspectives, Changes in the Agricultural and Food Situation
123
dynamics, differentiated in the north, on the one hand, and the south and east, on the other, are accompanied by, for the entire Mediterranean region, a heavy urbanization with a concentration in the coastal zone. At the same time, the working agricultural population will be relatively smaller. Thus, more Mediterranean people living in cities will need to be fed by fewer Mediterranean farmers. Demographic growth in the Mediterranean region results in a number of impacts on various aspects of daily life, such as changes in the relationship between the working and the nonworking population and in that of the working agricultural population in relation to the total population. This demographic growth, primarily in cities, and the rural exodus that goes with it, have significant overall impacts on employment and revenues in the urban sector. The urbanization of the Mediterranean coastal zone will result, moreover, in associated changes in eating habits, nutritional practices, and food in general. Some of these changes could have significant consequences for public health (see Figure 5). The increase in this population comes, obviously, with an increased pressure on the environment and natural resources. In 2002, development pressure on agricultural lands was strong in the countries of the south; 40% of the Moroccan and 50% of the Turkish working populations were still farmers. The demand for energy 27 is also growing at a fast pace; this includes water demands for agriculture but also for domestic, industrial, and tourism-related use. The risks of social instability have thus also increased, and, as we will show in detail, the SEM countries will have to resort more and more to food imports to meet the needs of their populations. How should these challenges be properly met if the current disparities in the production of wealth from economic and human development among the north, the south, and the east stay the same? 2. Economic Development and Living Standards The total gross national product (GNP) of the Mediterranean region was 4 trillion dollars in 1995, but 90% of this GNP came from five countries of the European Union in the region which represented only 40% of the population. France produced 40% of this wealth, Italy 32%, Spain 15%, and Greece 5%. If the current growth rate of the gross domestic product (GDP) of the countries of the region stays the same, in 30 years the less than a third of the Mediterranean population living in the north will create and possess nine times more wealth than the two-thirds of the Mediterranean population living in the south (data from Plan Bleu and CIHEAM). The growth of the GNP by country is high for all the SEM countries; it has remained at more than 4% per year from 1975 to 2000, while, for the same period, it was 2.5% for the EU countries (see Table 1, source: World Bank, World Development Indicators 2003). In the same period, the growth of the GNP per inhabitant was low; this is directly linked to the influence of the demographic growth.
27 According to the scenarios of Plan Bleu reported in Courrier de la Planète, n° 73, 2004, the energy demand of 820 million tons of oil equivalent in 2000 will increase by 40 to 70% according to different scenarios by 2025.
124
V. Dollé / Demographic Perspectives, Changes in the Agricultural and Food Situation
Table 1. Median annual GNP growth rate, for GNP per inhabitant and for the total population (period: 19752001)
GNP
Population
GNP/inhabitant
4.29 2.44
2.44 0.47
1.81 1.96
Algeria Cyprus Egypt Israel Jordan Lebanon Malta Morocco Syria Tunisia Turkey
3.10 6.66 5.98 4.25 6.04 3.04* 5.76 3.78 4.37 4.78 3.66
European Monetary Union
2.46
SEM Countries France
2.65 0.89 2.37 2.47 4.17 1.60 0.75 2.11 3.26 2.20 2.17
0.35
* 1988–2001 for Lebanon. Source: World Bank, World Development Indicators 2003.
0.43 5.72 3.53 1.73 1.79 1.24 4.98 1.64 1.08 2.52 1.46
2.10
The GDP per inhabitant is 10 times lower in Algeria than in Italy; 30 times lower in Egypt than in France. The disparities in the production and distribution of wealth between the north and the south lead us to distinguish three levels of human development: the very developed, essentially “European” Mediterranean; a littledeveloped Mediterranean (Syria, Algeria, Morocco, Egypt); and, between the two, the moderately developed Mediterranean (the Balkans, Tunisia, Libya, Lebanon, Turkey). The living standards of the inhabitants of the SEM countries are stagnant. The population living below the national poverty line was growing in many countries in the final years of the 20th century (see Table 2, source: World Bank, World Development Indicators 2003). The data for several countries in the Maghreb and Egypt show that this population is larger in rural areas than in urban areas, and confirm moreover that the situation hasn’t reversed much in 10 years. Taken as a whole, the poverty rate is increasing in the majority of countries. Poverty in rural areas is still present, with its consequences in terms of education and health for the rural population. This situation doesn’t help much to reduce the gap between the coastal zones and the interior zones, the latter of which are getting poorer and more marginalized. The median human development index (HDI) for the Mediterranean was 0.79 in 200228 in comparison with a median world HDI of 0.72.
28 Source: PNUD. The HDI calculated for each country has a value between 0 and 1. In 2002, it was at more than 0.9 for France, Spain, and Italy; less than 0.7 for Algeria, Egypt, and Morocco.
125
V. Dollé / Demographic Perspectives, Changes in the Agricultural and Food Situation
Table 2. Population living below the national poverty line* in %
Year Algeria
1988
Egypt Jordan
1995 1991
Tunisia
1990
Morocco 1990
Rural
Urban
Total
23.3 nd
22.5 nd
22.9 15
2000 1997
13.1
3.5
7.4
1995
16.6
18
7.3
7.6
12.2
13.1
Year 1995
1999
Rural
Urban
Total
nd nd
nd nd
16.7 11.7
30.3
27.2
13.9
14.7
12
3.6
22.6
19
7.6
* National poverty line = set in relation to the median standard of living in each country. Source: World Bank, World Development Indicators 2003.
A few countries attract the majority of foreign direct investment (FDI), which, overall, remains at a low level in the Mediterranean region. The SEM countries attract just 2% of worldwide FDI while 4% of worldwide FDI is directed at developing countries. 45% of the flow of FDI to the SEM countries since 1995 has been directed to Turkey, Egypt, Morocco, and Tunisia. In this context of globalization, the EU remains however the primary investor in countries of the region, even if these countries are not developing their ability to attract this FDI. A significant part of revenues in foreign currencies of the SEM countries is tied to tourism, the impact of which on the growth of the GNP of these countries is increasing. Revenues from tourism contributed to more than 1% of the growth of the GNP in 1980; this contribution grew to more than 4% in 2001. Although 220 million tourists per year in the Mediterranean basin represents 30% of global flow, this rate hasn’t grown much in 10 years for the SEM countries; the touristic attractions of the SEM countries remain subject to active conflicts among certain countries in the Near East. Finally, in the agri-food industry sector, which also contributes to the GDP, the growth rate, around 2 to 3%, has remained steady over a long period.29 An increase in the performance of this sector would require improvements in companies’ management methods; some financial restructuring would help, but improvements in agricultural production would also guarantee the quality and availability of raw materials for the processing industry. It would also be useful to put in place procedures for the traceability of products that are indispensable to the conquest of high added value markets for local high-quality products whose origin can be guaranteed. Shrinking the economic gap between the north and the south is going to require very determined cooperative efforts. What role can the agricultural sector play in changing this situation? 3. Food, Consumption, and Importation The behavior of the Mediterranean consumer is influenced by lifestyle. The urbanizing population is increasingly attracted to the European—or, more generally, Western— style of consumption and distribution. This population, mostly quite young, makes socalled modern choices; their tastes are formed more and more outside the family unit. The Mediterranean and SEM consumer is, in addition, very susceptible to advertising and to the lifestyle displayed on Western television. More women are participants in 29
Source: Agri.Med, Annual report, 2004.
126
V. Dollé / Demographic Perspectives, Changes in the Agricultural and Food Situation
the economy starting in university (54% of university students in Tunisia since 2004 are… women). Women work increasingly outside the home. Family size is shrinking and, as a result, meal preparation is changing, simplifying, and standardizing. However, the various Mediterranean eating patterns (see Figure 5) are still clearly different from the average Western eating patterns (MCAO).
Grains and root crops Sugar and Honey Fruits and vegetables Fats Legumes Milk and milk products Fish Meat and eggs Figure 5. Mediterranean eating patterns, Agri.Med CIHEAM. 2005 Annual Report.
As the different models of eating patterns show, people on the south side of the Mediterranean consume more grains and root crops, more legumes, and sometimes more fish; on the other hand, they often consume much less meat, milk, dairy products, and fat. This model is often called the Cretan diet; it should be noted that this consumption model practiced by the peasant of Crete was often accompanied by a lot of physical exertion. The Cretan diet is the paradigmatic model to be achieved by many urban Westerners, who are often overweight from a young age30 and are more inclined to sit in front of the television for three hours a day than to expend enough physical effort to work off the surplus calories they’ve eaten. Diets in the south and east of the Mediterranean basin are a good thing that should be preserved, not least for the wealth and diversity of many local products. These products are the result of culinary traditions inherited from all the civilizations that have passed through the Mediterranean region, progressively enriched by new foods originating in Asia and the Americas. This extensive culinary repertoire is still fairly well transmitted from one generation to the next; meals, even frugal meals, are still quite structured and convivial. The Mediterranean diet unites pleasure and health, authenticity, local and quality products. It should thus be conserved as a nutritional and social good.
30
In 2004, one child in six in France was overweight.
127
V. Dollé / Demographic Perspectives, Changes in the Agricultural and Food Situation
To satisfy sharply growing domestic food needs, the national agricultural and agrifood industries must be increasingly supplemented by heavy importation. For the SEM countries, the total consumption of grains doubled from 1980 to 2004; this represents at present a volume of more than 100 million tons, 60% of which meets the needs only of Turkey and Egypt. The domestic production of grains in the SEM countries covered, in 1980, 75% of needs. This rate went down to 65% in 2002. In fact, the SEM countries’ dependence on grain imports is increasing. Milk consumption for the same region went from 18 million to 25 million tons. If meeting food needs is getting better on the whole, individual consumption remains low, essentially tied to the still slowly improving living standards among the rural population and the majority of the urban population. All the SEM countries are already, or are becoming, heavy importers of agricultural and agri-food products. In 2000, wheat was the most imported product, and represented for Egypt and Tunisia from 20 to 30% of their food imports. Worldwide, food imports represent approximately 8% of total imports; for the SEM countries, they represent 11% of these imports. Food oils are significant imports for Morocco, Tunisia, and Egypt; sugar for Morocco and Tunisia; tea for Egypt, Morocco, and Tunisia. Algeria and Egypt are big importers (see Table 3). In Morocco 31 and Tunisia, the coverage rate of agri-food imports versus agricultural and agri-food exports is improving. On the other hand, in 2000, Turkey became for the first time in its history an importer of agricultural and agri-food products (see Table 3). Europe is the biggest supplier of agricultural and food products to the SEM countries, even though a large part of imported grain products come from the American continent. Likewise trade between Europe and the southern Mediterranean means that Europe is also the main importer of Mediterranean goods. Ten years after the Barcelona Accords, agriculture is still an anomaly in terms of the formation of a large market and the setting up of free-trade zones, whose impacts are varied for the countries of the south—some positive, many others still negative. Table 3. Changes in the agri-food import/export coverage rate 1981 1982 1983 1984
1985
1986
1987
1988
Algeria Cyprus Egypt 5
90
21
60
30
35
17
53
24
24
71
25
29
19
68
27
17
73
26
3
103
21
2
90
22
2 3
1
1
1
74
77
77
82
84
Israel Jordan Lebanon Malta Morocco Syria
17
18
14
69
71
74
73
68
29
23
26
25
18
31
16
276
20
96
38
43
255
22
17
113
97
81
83
1991
3
83
15
68
25
12
1993
3
4
65
70
14
18
62
58
27
35
39
12
12
1992
100
24
112
30
16
69
14
70
77
676
587
32
18
14
643
47
93
99
38
25
Turkey
51
1
2
42
38
21
1989
1990
58
Tunisia
13
94
119 77
79
37
57
255
177
40
240
51
118
37
155
96
187
63
122
56
145
31 In 2003, the coverage rate of exports by imports was 0.42 for Morocco, 0.58 for Tunisia, and just 0.01 for Algeria (source: FAO/CIHEAM-IAMM, 2003).
128
1994 1995 1996
1997
V. Dollé / Demographic Perspectives, Changes in the Agricultural and Food Situation
Algeria Cyprus Egypt 1
65
17
5
60
11
4 1
71 45
13 10
Israel Jordan Lebanon Malta Morocco Syria 55 56 55
52
56 53
1
52
13
53
31
37
2000
2
46
16
48
29
12
1999
1
52
14
51
36
104
13
104
86
44
88
100
52
90
73
10
1998
11
Tunisia
11
14 15
17
92
112 101
73
99
72
69
43
58
73
57
Source: CIHEAM-IAMM calculations based on World Development Indicators 2003.
Turkey 179
101
101
111
117
131 93
The SEM countries, which experience clear difficulties in exploiting their potential to export fruits and vegetables such as olive oil, find themselves competing with the northern countries. The domestic need of the SEM countries for basic products is creating a growing dependence on the countries of the north. The Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) is sometimes justly contested without, however, a better alternative being put into place that would take into account all the functions provided by the agricultural sector. The question is, How to put in place a more sustainable Mediterranean agriculture that would sufficiently and healthily feed its inhabitants while preserving Mediterranean resources and lands, which are coming under greater and greater pressure? 4. An Environment and Resources Subjected to Strong Pressures, an Agriculture with still Uncertain Results Water is becoming an increasingly scarce resource. The data from Plan Bleu on water resources actually available per inhabitant and the projections for 2025 point to acute shortages both conjunctural and localized in certain countries (Morocco, Spain, Libya, Syria, Cyprus) in a few years. These shortages could become structural in countries with significant water needs, such as Egypt and Libya, starting in 2005. The situation would be less critical in Algeria, Israel, Palestine, and Tunisia, since these countries have lower water needs. The pressures are increasingly great on fragile ecosystems, with a growing loss of quality agricultural lands 32 linked to land clearing, erosion, and overgrazing. The cultivation of marginal lands can, moreover, endanger the biodiversity of these lands. Farming practices don’t change very much; there is a strong persistence of small farms 33 , very often parceled out. The microfundium remains widespread in Egypt. Access to agricultural services is difficult for farmers of the south and the east; obtaining credit to buy new equipment is not easy. Rural societies in the south remain vulnerable in view of the precariousness of their status. In this context, gaps in 32 34% of the land to the north of the Mediterranean basin is usable agricultural land, while just 9% of that to the south is. 33 In Morocco, 70% of farms representing 24% of usable agricultural land are smaller than 6 hectares.
V. Dollé / Demographic Perspectives, Changes in the Agricultural and Food Situation
129
agricultural productivity are growing between the north and the south with significant differences between the value added per worker in the north and the south 34. Faced with the growing demand for basic food products not produced by the countries themselves, the agricultural sector in the SEM countries offers fairly uneven performances. In these countries, agriculture remains strongly dependent on rainfall. A veritable crisis in productivity of lands under cultivation and of animal farming can be observed there. However, intensive farming, based on irrigation, is developing at a higher rate: irrigated land went from 11 million hectares in 1960 to more than 20 million in 200435 without, however, covering basic food needs as evoked above. In this context, Mediterranean agriculture has several challenges it must take up, among them: − to guarantee food security and safety by bringing to market—both for the domestic market and for export—healthy, quality products, easily available and accessible; − to find global markets for Mediterranean products with high added value, that have a strong identity, with a certified geographic origin that could lead to a label for Mediterranean products; − to go beyond the strict aspects of increasing agricultural production and to look rather at the dynamics of local and territorial development, at the promotion of true professional organizations, at the role that actors in the production process play, at setting up negotiations, and at the working out of development charters; − to manage natural resources (fauna, flora, water, earth) and bring the negative effects of climactic constraints, such as aridity and its repercussions on erosion, under control. Finally, it has become necessary, in the north as well as the south of the Mediterranean, to take into account the multifunctional aspect of agriculture by adding other functions to its function of essential production, including natural resource management and development. The agricultural policies of the SEM countries, which are the result of policies of structural adjustment, of trade liberalization, of globalization, lead to the abandonment of policies of self-sufficiency, then to the withdrawal of the state and of support structures in production and marketing. Overall, the agricultural industries of the SEM countries remain vulnerable. The question that must be asked is, How can scientific research contribute to the reduction of these imbalances, these disparities? 5. New Scientific Research Challenges In order to contribute to the improvement of agricultural production in the SEM countries and to the formation of a new arena of Euro-Mediterranean trade, scientific research must take up several challenges: technical challenges first, but also challenges involving organization and the setting of priorities. 34 The value added per worker in 2001 was US$60,000 in France, compared with US$1,300 produced by the agricultural worker in Egypt. 35 Source: 2005 study, FIPA, CIHEAM-IAMM, forthcoming.
130
V. Dollé / Demographic Perspectives, Changes in the Agricultural and Food Situation
Dealing with this situation, which could prefigure a crisis, is going to mean for agronomic science that it take into account new concerns allowing for the promotion of sustainable rural development. Work must be done to perfect new technical systems of reference, to innovate, to carry out technology transfer using a more global approach for the systems of production and the ecosystems into which they fit. A few examples: in grain cultivation, agronomic science and development structures should look carefully at the use of drought-resistant genetic material. Storage and conservation devices should be improved to enhance the value of both local and imported goods. Also, research into making bread out of grains should be undertaken for local grains. Several technical innovations are also anticipated: in supplemental irrigation for rainfed agriculture during periods of hydric stress, in the production of low-waterconsuming winter forage, in the enhancement of water used for agriculture, etc. Beyond these technical efforts, all aspects of agronomic science for rural development should take into account new transverse approaches linking agriculture, food, nutrition, and health. It is also necessary to look at the determining factors of how producers manage their lands, and, more globally, at rurality. It’s also important to analyze the effects of public policy, to take into account the withdrawal of state support and to make professional organizations aware of their responsibilities, to go from rural agricultural development to territorial development, and the growth of sustainable development. New organizations will be needed for research and training more closely linking public institutions, universities, and private partners in both the north and south of the Mediterranean. In the very short term, scientists should no longer be isolated, access to useful scientific knowledge should be facilitated, and research results should be published in media other than just international scientific academic journals with reading committees. This effort should be accompanied by reflection on the programming of the research and a more balanced allocation of resources for projects or teams working on priority issues, and also better shared among regional institutions. The objective of these research and development strategies is to develop skills, to produce reliable knowledge, to construct development scenarios and to propose more harmonious assumptions of Mediterranean development for decision-makers. Agronomic science organized for the whole of the Euro-Mediterranean region in conjunction with higher education could also take charge of a large interdisciplinary cooperative program for priority regional projects. New knowledge is needed for, on the one hand, the perpetuation of a family-farm-based agriculture which supports 75% of the rural populations of the SEM countries, and, on the other hand, the promotion of a more intensive, competitive agriculture that does not, however, ignore the environmental and health exigencies of sustainable development. It might thus be possible to construct a model of regional Euro-Mediterranean integration developing genuine complementarities reconciling food security and food safety with more harmonious development of the Mediterranean region.
Sharing Knowledge Across the Mediterranean Area P. Faugeras et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2006 © 2006 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
131
The Mediterranean, a Free-Trade Zone from 2010: what Consequences will this have for Agriculture, Food and Agronomic Research?36 Najib AKESBI Institut Agronomique et Vétérinaire Hassan II Abstract – At the Barcelona conference in 1995, it was proposed to set up a new partnership between Europe and the Mediterranean, aiming at a free exchange zone, but with some exception in agriculture. After 10 years, the balance is disappointing and a total free exchange zone will be detrimental for food security for the Mediterranean countries. Another partnership should be seek in which both sides of the Mediterranean find their advantages and food security and safety, through new ideas, like specialization of countries in specific food production and looking at farmer revenues instead of only food prices.
I think that, after these extremely interesting papers, my difficulty is going to be how to place myself so as to supplement what has been said. The hardest part will be to try to say what has not been said, or, at the very least, to say differently certain things which seem to me essential. I have been asked to try and imagine the Mediterranean as a free-trade zone from 2010, and to see what consequences this might have for agriculture, food and agronomic research. I shall try, then, to present my paper to you in three parts. In the first part, I shall try to set the scene, by which I mean that if, in the definition of the subject proposed, we mean to suggest that the agricultural sector of the Mediterranean will be a free-trade zone from 2010, the reality is different: yes, a free-trade zone is planned, but it will have to make do for the time being with limiting itself to industry, the flow of industrial goods. As for agriculture, it is still governed by the logic of the “agricultural exception”. In the second part, I shall try to set out and explain the consequences of this fact for agriculture and food in the Mediterranean. Finally, the third part will allow me to show that the alternative is not to be found in a free-trade zone but in what I call the “EuroMediterranean Region”, which should be built on two pillars that seem to me essential and which are called “complementarity” and “solidarity”. I shall take up the issue of research, which has been set out well by Vincent Dollé, but merely to situate it in the perspective of the Euro-Mediterranean region and to ask the questions that seem to me to constitute fruitful avenues of enquiry for the future. 36
Original text in French, translated in English.
132
N. Akesbi / The Mediterranean, a Free-Trade Zone from 2010
1. The Euro-Mediterranean Project of the Free Trade Zone: Industrial Free Trade and the“Agricultural Exception” The current Euro-Mediterranean project is the outcome of the “Barcelona process”. This process, begun in 1995, was initially built up as part of what was called the “renewed Mediterranean policy”—renewed because it aimed to go beyond previous global policy, with a number of innovations in relation to what had previously existed, particularly the notion of partnership, which broke with the notion of aid that had dominated in the past, the question of support for economic reforms, the development of a certain number of direct fundings, decentralised co-operation, and so forth. To understand the Barcelona process properly, we need to remember, I think, that the early 1990s was marked by the fall of the Berlin wall and the emergence of the PECOs, the countries of Eastern Europe. Such was the interest shown by western Europe in this part of Europe, which was emerging on the international stage, that in the southern and eastern Mediterranean a great many questions began to be asked, beginning with whether we weren’t in the process of becoming somewhat overlooked by history… The Barcelona process first came about, then, to deliver a message and affirm a commitment: Europe has not forgotten the Mediterranean and is proposing a plan which, on the face of it, looks very ambitious. The Barcelona declaration (made on 27 November 1995) sketched the outlines of that plan. Broadly speaking, the Euro-Mediterranean partnership will rest on three pillars. The first concerns the political and security matters supposed to organise “a common zone of peace and stability”. The second pillar is economic and is actually, in concrete terms, the free-trade zone, which is supposed to lead, through the benefits of trade, to the “zone of shared prosperity”. It is, it must be said, the most visible part of the plan and will move forward at a steady pace, according to a precise timetable. The third pillar concerns Cupertino in cultural, social and human affairs. This is the pillar that concerns scientific research, and since we will shortly be celebrating the tenth anniversary of the partnership that grew out of the Barcelona process, and therefore of the ten-yearly assessment, we cannot help but notice that it is one of the areas that have unfortunately been somewhat neglected. In concrete terms, the declaration and process have led to the signing of a certain number of accords, called the Euro-Mediterranean Partnership or Association Agreements. As can be seen from Table 1, the European Union has signed agreements with nearly all the eastern and southern Mediterranean countries (the PSEM), given that Malta and Cyprus are now fully paid-up members of the European entity. Only Syria remains to close the circle. In principle, these agreements are underwritten by a funding tool known as the MEDA programme and together form part of the European Union’s wish to assist the Mediterranean countries in their quest for development. That said, these agreements, as I just pointed out, initially involve a certain number of precise commitments to liberalisation in the trading of industrial goods, with a timetable for the removal of all tariff- and non-tariff barriers, generally over a period of 12 years. In the case of Morocco, for example, the removal of barriers begins when the agreement comes into force in March 2000 and should, in principle, lead to the complete free-trade zone in 2012. And so far, I can assure you, the tariff-removal programme has been carried out to the letter.
N. Akesbi / The Mediterranean, a Free-Trade Zone from 2010
Partner States Algeria Cyprus Egypt Israel Jordan Lebanon Malta Morocco Palestinian Authority Syria Tunisia Turkey
133
Paraphs Signature Comes into force December 2001 22 April 2002 February 1997 Member states of the EU as of 1 May 2004 25 June 2001 September 1995 November 1995 In force since 2000 April 1997 24 November 1997 1 May 2002 10 January 2002 17 June 2002 Member states of the EU as of 1 May 2004 November 1995 26 February 1996 1 March 2000 December 1996 February 1997 Temporary cooperation agreement, July 1997 Negotiations underway June 1995 July 1995 1 March 1998 April 1997 Customs union in force
Table 1. Agreement of the Euro-Mediterranean Association, August 2005
Source: European Commission delegation to the kingdom of Morocco, August 2005.
Where agricultural trade is concerned, on the other hand, we cannot fail to observe that the two parties have chosen to abide by the “agricultural exception”. What the term “agricultural exception” means is that, because agriculture is deemed to be a very unusual and highly sensitive sector, involving first of all human food and by extension therefore the dietary security of the population, but also the balance of rural areas, the relationship between town and country, the preservation of the landscape and of the rural historical and cultural heritage, and so on—for all these reasons, agriculture, it is felt, should remain a special sector and should not, therefore, be subject to liberalisation. Instead, we make do with a partial, limited and controlled liberalisation, in the form of “preferences” in the application of favourable customs tariffs or more flexible forms of non-tariff barriers (quotas, timetables, target prices, etc.). Up until 1995, moreover, these preferences were granted unilaterally by the European Union to its partners in the South, without the latter ever being required to do likewise. Under the Barcelona agreements, however, the new principle that will be applied is simply one of “reciprocity”: henceforth, preferential access to EU markets must be duplicated by preferences in kind, if not on the same scale, where the access of European goods to the markets of the PSEM is concerned. It’s a matter of give and take. The PSEM countries, of course, have not in the meantime become developed countries, which would justify a degree of parity in the granting of preferences; in fact, at a time when the race for markets is accelerating and competition between the great trading powers is stepping up, this new orientation should be seen as a clear commitment on the European Union’s part to, at the very least, consolidating its positions in its old “stalking grounds”. What assessment can we give today of this Euro-Mediterranean partnership, which in the case of Morocco is more than thirty years old? A period as long as this gives us the distance we need for a well-argued, well thought-out and reliable assessment. As a matter of fact, figures and statistics have already been furnished in the previous paper which enable us to conclude that overall the results are negative. To say the least, agriculture in the South has not advanced much in two or three decades. Productivity in
134
N. Akesbi / The Mediterranean, a Free-Trade Zone from 2010
particular has remained very low in the South, while in the North it has grown considerably. Production structures, meanwhile, have changed, but are now completely out of step with the consumption model. Briefly, we find a model that struggles to export what it produces and has increasingly to import what it consumes. True, certain sectors of agriculture have their strong points and have managed, for example, to develop profitable and competitive export outlets; nevertheless, they run up against protectionist policies and practices which are a serious obstacle to development. At the same time, these self-same agricultural sectors seem incapable of producing enough to satisfy even local needs. In addition to their chronic and growing deficits, trade balances in the food sector broadly reflect this state of affairs: exports polarised on what, for the sake of brevity, we can call fruits and vegetables (some liken them to the hors d’œuvre and dessert of a meal), and imports monopolised by staple commodities: cereals, oil, sugar, dairy products, meat—the main course, in a word. This state of affairs is a perfect illustration of the dependence, the insecurity even, of most PSEMs in matters of food. Are these co-operation and association agreements responsible in any way for this state of affairs? Though there can be no denying, of course, each country’s burden of “domestic responsibilities”, in urging the partner countries to adopt production and consumption models that today have manifestly reached a dead end, the agreements have contributed significantly, to say the least, to sowing the seeds of the current crisis. This being so, the question we now need to ask is the following: is free trade inescapable? We need to bear in mind, of course, that all the objective factors I mentioned earlier remain and argue in favor of upholding the principle of an “agricultural exception”. At the same time, however, we can easily observe that the steam-roller of free trade is doing its work, and that, day after day, it is advancing. We can, of course, drag our feet for a few more years in this or that round of international negotiations; this or that “summit” may fail, this or that round of negotiations at the OMC last longer than expected—but let us make no mistake, the strategic thrust is clear: the world is moving towards ever greater liberalization in trade, and the ultimate goal of the promoters of that dynamics is nothing but free trade. In addition to the very buoyant context of the OMC, we should also note, in my opinion, the growing number of regional or bilateral accords that weigh ever more heavily in the balance of freemarketers. On this question, I would like to digress for a moment to illustrate my argument with the example of Morocco, or more exactly the free-trade agreement it has signed with the United States. If we put that agreement in the context of the various accords Morocco has signed with its other partners—in particular, with the European Union, of course—we notice that the first effect of the agreement is to commit the country to a sort of free-market escalation and rivalry. The agreement with the United States is meant to be a full-scale free-trade agreement, global and irreversible. Even in the case of agriculture it does not recognize an exception, and though the deadlines for removing tariffs on certain products seem long enough (between fifteen and twenty years), the course has nonetheless been set, and the planning for liberalization drawn up down to the last detail. Paradoxically, then, the United States in this respect today appears to be in a much more “advanced” situation with regard to Morocco than the European Union. This state of affairs will clearly not last long, and we can safely assume that when the forthcoming negotiations open in 2007 between Morocco and the European Union, the latter will do everything in its power to put an end to it. It is inconceivable that Morocco’s European partner will make do with a level of “concessions” inferior to that secured by the United States. Its “demands” will start,
N. Akesbi / The Mediterranean, a Free-Trade Zone from 2010
135
therefore, where the latter’s left off and will seek to go further. We are caught up, then, in a free-market spiral that will mean that, the more we open up possibilities for free trade with this or that partner, the more we will be obliged to do likewise for this or that other partner, and so on. All in all, then, I think that, if we assume that the “meaning”, not of “History” but merely of “this particular history” is for the time being perfectly clear, but that the movement in agricultural trade is a bit sluggish when compared with other goods and services, we can deduce from this that the next decade, if it does not turn out to be the “twilight”, will nonetheless mark a decisive break with the past. Between 2010 and 2020, we will not have completely free markets in agricultural trade, but we will have gone a long way down that road; we will have laid the foundations for free trade in the future, and above all we will have cast serious doubts on current protection mechanisms and destabilized the regulatory systems that have worked thus far and preserved certain balances. I see that the chairman is already telling me I have only ten minutes left, so I’ll try to speed up my delivery, or at any rate move on to the second part of my paper and try to answer the following question: what consequences will this have for agriculture and food in the Mediterranean? 2. What Consequences will this have for Agriculture and Food in the Mediterranean? First of all, let us take a look at deep-lying trends, those that have been at work for a long time and look set to continue for a long time to come. To save time, I shall not dwell on demography, since the subject has already been well covered by the previous speaker. A word about the issue of immigration: it is obvious that immigration will continue and grow more pronounced, whatever mechanisms and devices are set in place to try and contain it. This means that it will continue to poison EuroMediterranean relations, which in turn may mean that the first pillar I mentioned earlier, the political and security pillar, will continue to be strengthened at the expense of the other two pillars, which are more concerned with economic and social development. Immigration, too, then, will continue to cast a cloud over Euro-Mediterranean relations, if not to poison them. Above all, I would like to stress a point which seems to me essential: the size of the disparities, the asymmetry. If there is one term that characterizes North-South relations in the Mediterranean, it is the word asymmetry. Everything in the Mediterranean region is asymmetrical. We are in a rather peculiar situation in which partners who are already very disparate to begin with grow further and further apart the more they maintain their partnership! I present here some data that overlaps substantially with that put forward earlier by Vincent Dollé and has no need of commentary, since it speaks for itself. Take the GDP: 85% of the region’s GDP is in the North, and 73% of its agricultural GDP is also in the North, not in the South. Let’s go on to trade: 81% of foreign trade and 93% of agricultural exports are still monopolized by the small number of European countries on the northern shores of the Mediterranean. How about productivity? Broadly speaking, an employed person in the North produces 5 times more than one in the South. As can be seen from the following chart, which presents the spread of cereal yields in the Mediterranean, the disparity
136
N. Akesbi / The Mediterranean, a Free-Trade Zone from 2010
between the 75 quintals per hectare in France and the 8 to 10 quintals in Morocco or Algeria seems huge. We need go no further in listing indicators of the disparities between the northern and southern shores of the Mediterranean. But they all come together to show for which countries it remains risky, and so to speak insane, to want to put in competition agricultural sectors whose results are so different.
Figure 1. Cereals: disparities in crop yields around the Mediterranean
What is going on with the agricultural policies of the Mediterranean countries today? Briefly, we can say that, in the North, the successive reforms of the Common Agricultural Policy amount to a questioning of a policy that has been highly productivist and, at the same time, endowed with a highly developed regulatory system. That said, we still know very little about what is being put in place, since the reforms undertaken have done little to show their capacity to ensure the conditions of a viable redeployment of existing capacities. We still do not know, for example, what the impact will be—particularly on production—of the shift from a system of price regulation to one of income regulation. All in all, a system seems to have been dismantled, but we don’t yet know what is being set up in its place, still less if the conditions for its positive overstepping are being invented, particularly with regard to a well thought-out, multi-purpose agriculture. Oddly enough, and without wishing to overstate the matter, of course, this is more or less what has been done in the South. In the South, it is those famous structural adjustment policies that have destabilized a system that, for the sake of brevity, can be described as interventionist. The system fulfilled certain functions fairly well, but here, too, what is certain today is that a system has been destabilized that at least had the merit of existing, without so far being replaced by another system founded on the private sector and the market-place. The bridging mechanism that is needed in the
N. Akesbi / The Mediterranean, a Free-Trade Zone from 2010
137
private sector to lay the foundations for a sort of new production pact has still not been found. This is how things stand in these matters in both North and South, so that the great challenge of our time is to try and perpetuate a form of agriculture that is sufficiently “productive” to reassure and provide healthy food for the population of the Mediterranean, and, at the same time, sufficiently well-thought-out to preserve the resources and lands of the region. For the moment, it is liberalization that is at the top of the agenda, and the question that needs to be asked—and, indeed, haunts people—concerns its impact on agriculture. The question which has particularly engrossed economists in recent years concerns the impact of free trade on the different types of farming, on employment, incomes and production systems. Quite a few studies have been made of the subject, and some of them have even focused on Morocco or Tunisia. I have tried to sum up the most striking and consensual conclusions in five points. The first point is that there is broad agreement on the fact that the consequences of liberalization will be positive for consumers and negative for producers. The former will benefit from the fall in prices, the latter will suffer from the foreign competition. The second point is that we are going to witness even greater deterioration in trade balances, very often in the South, and food dependence will get worse. The third point is that the fall in income for producers will be slight. The studies honestly don’t show that incomes will collapse. The falls in revenue will be slight on average, then, though high for certain categories of producer and certain regions (medium-sized farms and traditional production systems). Oddly enough, small farm-holders are likely to pull through when they dispose of external revenues and tend to consume more than they produce. Large modern farms geared to exporting will generally come out on top because free trade enables them to take advantage of their competitiveness. Are these conclusions optimistic? In point of fact, the objective conditions that prevail, the underlying trends at work and the absence of any accompanying strategy or appropriate regulatory policies would seem to incline to a certain pessimism. The pessimistic scenarios could get the better of the optimistic ones. I now come to the question of food security, and unfortunately I note that I have very little time left to address the matter. Very briefly, I would like first to stress that this concept is not perceived in the same manner in the northern and southern Mediterranean. In the South, we still consider security in quantitative terms. For us, food security is first and foremost approached in terms of the availability and accessibility of food. This, incidentally, is also the approach of the FAO, which at the World Food Summit in 1996 declared: “food security exists when all people, at all times, have physical and economic access to sufficient, safe and nutritious food to meet their dietary needs and food preferences for an active and healthy life”. The existence of production, of products available on the market, does not of itself ensure food security: one must also be in a position to pay for those products in order to acquire them, which raises the question of income levels, of the population’s purchasing powers, especially of the poor, who can suffer from food insecurity not because the products don’t exist but because they can’t acquire them. In the North, on the other hand, the situation is different, even if there do exist “pockets of poverty” here and there. There, it is questions of quality that prevail. Food security basically means the sanitary security of foodstuffs, and, more broadly speaking, their relation to human and animal health.
138
N. Akesbi / The Mediterranean, a Free-Trade Zone from 2010
That said, it would be a mistake to imagine that the two approaches are mutually exclusive, and that in the South in particular the qualitative dimension of food security is not yet an issue. To be more precise, I would like to return here to the Mediterranean food model mentioned earlier, the famous “Cretan model”, a model that is indeed excellent from the standpoint of the quality of the diet, which is balanced and very healthy; the model of reference recommended by the OMS, the FAO and other international bodies. But what we are seeing today is a certain drift away from this model in both North and South. The developments underway are indeed unfavorable and worrying (see Figures 2 and 3). In the North—we talked about this earlier— globalization is accelerating the extension, the generalization even, of the dominant model—what, for the sake of brevity, I shall call the “Macdonalds model”, with a strong increase in energy contents, mainly shared out between glucides, lipids and proteins (in favor of animal products, sugars and fats). But, in reality, this trend is universal. True, in the South the average food model still remains traditional and distinct from that of the North. What we are seeing is more like an accentuation of the main traditional characteristics: cereals, dried fruit, simple sugars. For want of sufficient purchasing power, the consumption of meats and milk takes a back seat. That said, globalization is at work everywhere, perhaps more slowly, but the extension of the dominant model is also more than perceptible in the countries of the South. The habits of consumption, the practices described earlier in the countries of the North, can also be observed to some extent in countries like Morocco, Tunisia and Egypt. And the directions in which consumption models in those countries are moving are just as worrying. With perhaps this paradox, which I have already pointed out: that the model of consumption is developing in a manner even more out of step with the model of production. To put it plainly, I would say that “poor food” precedes poor production; people learn to consume “Big Macs” when they haven’t even solved the problem of production. Their dependence is only that much greater. I stress this point because I have often heard colleagues from the North saying that, for the moment, the problem in our countries is merely “quantitative’. Whereas I say— whether for better or worse is of no importance—that the two challenges present themselves to us simultaneously: we have both a quantity problem and a quality problem with food.
Figure 2. Evolution in disposable income per inhabitant and per day in the North-Mediterranean countries (19632000)
139
N. Akesbi / The Mediterranean, a Free-Trade Zone from 2010
Figure 3. Evolution in disposable income per inhabitant and per day in the South-Mediterranean countries (1963-2000)
To summarise this part of my talk, I would like to say a few words about the Indicator of Food Quality Indicator (IQA), developed in the Mediterranean by Martine Padilla from work carried out by Gerber and others. The indicator is based on scores attributed to foods according to their quality in terms of the recommendations of specialised institutions. As can be seen from Table 2, the situation in the Mediterranean is not catastrophic, since in the end no IQA is higher than 13, the level beneath which the score is considered “very poor”. Still, it is none too reassuring either, for one notices over the years, between 1960 and 2000, a marked decline in the number of countries which had a good or very good score in 1960 and an average or poor score in 2000. This clearly means that, overall, the quality of food is declining. Years 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 Type of IQA
Table 2. Number of Mediterranean countries according to IQA scores
0–4 3 1 0 0 0 Very good
5–6 4 3 1 1 2 Good
7–9 3 8 10 9 10 Average
10–12 3 1 2 3 1 Poor
13–18 0 0 0 0 0 Very poor
Quality is going down, but let’s take another look at “quantity”. Though the FAO’s forecasts up to 2025 do not foresee any “quantitative” security problem in the Mediterranean as a whole, the experts at the same organisation acknowledge that “regional” estimations are unreliable. At all events, there is agreement on the fact that if the countries of the northern Mediterranean risk facing qualitative food insecurity, the
140
N. Akesbi / The Mediterranean, a Free-Trade Zone from 2010
southern Mediterranean countries and some vulnerable categories of the population in both North and South may experience both aspects of food insecurity simultaneously. Let us now move on quickly to the prospects and to the last part of this paper. 3. For a Research Geared to the Project of a Euro-Mediterranean Region I said earlier that the vision behind the free-trade zone seems to me a poor prospect because in reality it situates the project solely on the level of the market. The problem is that when you are on the market you are already involved in competition. The alternative, one that is genuinely aimed at mutual understanding and the future, should be situated upstream of the process, that is, at the level of Euro-Mediterranean production and production systems. What does this mean in concrete terms? It means that production systems should be organized so that they complement one another. We should work to build rational sector-based complementarities. Where agriculture is concerned, I would say that the complementarities between North and South are easier to build than elsewhere, because they are founded on objective natural and competitive factors. For example, if Morocco enjoys a relative advantage with regard to certain fruits and vegetables, well then, it should be allowed to develop these products by opening up the European markets of the North as much as possible. If France, on the other hand, produces ten times as much wheat as Morocco, it seems only natural that Morocco should agree to part of its cereal supplies coming from that country or, more generally speaking, from the European Union. That is the approach meant by complementarity: not the “specialization” advocated by the classical theory of free trade, but a well-thought-out attempt at a rational organization of production for a whole region—in this instance, the Euro-Mediterranean region—taking into account economic factors, of course, but also political and social ones. This implies that both the European Union and the PSEMs assume responsibility for the economic, financial, social and even political consequences of that choice. Particularly as, in this perspective, food security would be collective because it would rest on the capacity of the entire “region” to guarantee its population both availability and accessibility to food under healthy sanitary conditions. The concept of collective food security would make sense because it would be part of an overall political and strategic vision and would rest on a collective project that would underwrite its viability. But let us be quite clear about this, complementarity calls for solidarity, and the project would only be viable if the transformations were assumed by all, according to his or her capacities and constraints, and accompanied by sizeable funding and regulatory systems. While awaiting this project, which is not only ambitious but, it has to be said, nighon utopian today, the European Union could begin, I believe, by amending the contents of the Euromed partnership. It could agree, for example, to renegotiate the association agreements of the Barcelona process on a new basis of “asymmetrical reciprocity” or bilateral “Special Differentiated Treatment”. The European Union could also extend the logic of the “Leader” programmes to the eastern and southern Mediterranean to help promote rural development and, by the same token, food security. Again, it could join forces with the PSEMs at those international bodies where their common interests are negotiated, notably the World Trade Organization. And there is no shortage of areas where common efforts could yield results: improved access to the markets of the North, the setting-up of an international fund to finance imports from net importing countries, the constitution of minimum public cereal stocks by the main agricultural countries,
N. Akesbi / The Mediterranean, a Free-Trade Zone from 2010
141
and so on. In exchange, the PSEMs could support the argument of a multi-purpose agriculture. Last but not least, how else can I end this paper than by posing precisely those research questions raised by the plan for a Euro-Mediterranean region, at least with regard to the agricultural sector to which I have paid particular attention here— beginning with the precise model of “Euro-Mediterranean Region” that should be promoted. What model of regional integration should we build? With what complementarities? How should the Mediterranean’s agricultural and rural areas be reorganized? What kinds of reconversion should we promote? What agricultural model is capable of reconciling food and health security? How are we to increase productivity in the South, while at the same time preserving natural resources and human health? How should traditional products be valorized? What kinds of solidarity should be established? How are regulatory systems based on price mechanisms to be turned into wage-support systems? How should agricultural and food research be organized for the Mediterranean as a whole, and their efficiency improved? As you can see, this opens a vast field for research, in keeping with the ambitious Euro-Mediterranean project that ought to be ours.
142
Sharing Knowledge Across the Mediterranean Area P. Faugeras et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2006 © 2006 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
Agriculture The Next EuroMed Frontier?37 Moncef CHEIKH-ROUHOU Associate Professor at HEC (Hautes Etudes Commerciales), Paris Abstract. Agriculture is becoming the new border between North and South of the Mediterranean, mainly because of subsidies paid to farmers in developed countries. Although it has been proposed to reduce subsidies, the problem can only be solved with a new partnership between North and South, but also within the countries of south Mediterranean themselselves.
I would first of all like to thank the three speakers who preceded me because the essential has already been said and so, really, I should need less time to say what I have to say, but I can sum up my impressions by saying that there’s good news and bad news. The bad news is that the situation is critical, and the good news is that it’s not desperate, but we’re going to have to find ways to continue to move forward. I am currently an associate professor at HEC in Paris, HEC whose logo has become “Local Roots, Global Reach,” meaning with local roots in France and a global reach. There are 44 nationalities represented in the MBA program where I teach, and my main interest is in the analysis of and participation in economic and financial, but also social and political, construction, between Europe and its neighbors, whether it’s the Mediterranean or the countries of the east. Today, agriculture is a theme very dear to us, but I’m going to maybe shatter the calm by saying: isn’t agriculture in the process of becoming the true new border between the countries of Europe and of the Mediterranean, or between the Mediterranean of the north and the Mediterranean of the south? I’ll recap very quickly what’s already been presented to emphasize one point: the agreements between the north and the south of the Mediterranean were really initiated starting with Barcelona in 1995. The Barcelona Accords have three components: − an industrial component, which is starting to take shape since within two years, Tunisia, the first signatory, and Morocco, the second signatory a few years later, will have industrial markets that are entirely European, and vice versa. The industrial producer in Casablanca, in Tétouan, in Tunis, or in Bizerte will have the entire European market at his disposal with absolutely no restrictions. So industry seems to be working.
37
Transcription from oral in French and translation.
M. Cheikh-Rouhou / Agriculture: The Next EuroMed Frontier?
143
− one component, which could have been taken as related to security, but which is political, is the insistence on stability around the Mediterranean. The main condition for this stability is the transition to parliamentary democracy. An Indian, also English and American, Amartya Sen, received the Nobel Prize in Economics several years ago. Among his writings, the main work that earned him the Nobel Prize was that in which he proved that the biggest democracy in the world, which is not the United States but India, had stopped suffering from famines the day it put in place a system of parliamentary democracy—it might not be perfect, but it’s a parliamentary democracy. Famine ceased to exist because the alarms were sounded very early within this system. That’s why it’s in our interests that this security-related component be understood in the broadest possible sense—real stability. − a human component: research, education, women, and the rights of men and women. This third component could actually be a bridge for what we could propose at the end of the presentation. Concerning the industrial component, at the moment, four countries, Tunisia, Morocco, Egypt, and Jordan, are on the point of finalizing their entry into this agreement by 2010—2012 at the latest since there’s a two-year grace period—and all four will be industrially European. Algeria, Syria, and Lebanon will follow. At the level of services between Europe and the south of the Mediterranean, no agreement exists. Everything has been left to the WTO, to GATS (General Agreement on Trade in Services) and is in the process of being negotiated. If you want to open a consulting business, a lawyer’s office, a research center, it won’t fall under the jurisdiction of what has been prepared for us by the Euro-Mediterranean agreements, but under the jurisdiction of GATS. Finally, agriculture—I agree with what Professor Akesbi said—is a little bit forgotten in this story. Agriculture, which is today’s topic and which requires urgent attention, today, is not at all on the agenda for the building of Euro-Mediterranean relations. However, I’m going to try and insist on one point, and that’s the link between the treatment of agriculture and the fight against poverty, which is absolutely vital. I’ll start with some data (Table 1). Here are the amounts of aid which were distributed to farmers in the countries of the north, in the developed countries in 2001—it’s a few years old, but it takes time to reconstruct all this data from OCDE (the Office for Economic Cooperation and Development)—which amounted to approximately 251 billion euros. These are enormous amounts of money—you spoke about MEDA, and MEDA is 6 billion euros over five years. So we have here a “hit parade.” You rightly remarked that these amounts are not presented here by inhabitant, but by region. But anyway we find the EU leading the way with around 104 billion euros. The United States follows, with 55 billion euros and also, curiously enough, Japan with 53 billion euros, the main reason for which is that Japan considers its access to rice to be crucial and is ready to pay the price for it. We see Korea here for the same reason, and other countries we wouldn’t have expected to see, like Poland, which has a policy of reinforcing its agriculture. So these aid policies exist.
144
M. Cheikh-Rouhou / Agriculture: The Next EuroMed Frontier?
Table 1. Subsidies paid to farmers in millions of euro
To come back to the important remark made by Professor Akesbi, if nothing is formalized between the North and South part of the Mediterranean on this subject, what remains? Normally what remains is the law of the market, free trade. I’m going to try and demonstrate that free trade isn’t there yet, and that free trade is not even easily attainable. I want to make clear that these figures represent the total value of transfers from consumers and taxpayers (government) to producers arising from agricultural policies, and I draw your attention only to the fact that these policies don’t date from yesterday, but from 40 years ago. So today, there was first an agreement between the countries of the north that we can summarize by saying that the compromise that was reached in fact limits the amounts of subsidies paid by the countries of the European Union to their farmers, and the implications of this compromise. But this agreement has implications: developing countries have continued to draw attention to the fact that these payments continue to hurt agriculture in the countries of the south. The slight change is due to the fact that most of the subsidies would today be based not only on the quantity produced by the countries of the north, but also on the quality, meaning there was the introduction of a criterion of food quality and of attention paid to ecology, which is a major element. The compromise is as follows: Italy and France, at the time of these negotiations, stood firm, as we saw recently between France and Great Britain, and ended up obtaining that up to 25% of these subsidies for grain and up to 40% of the subsidies for cattle production could be tied to the quantity produced, the rest being evidently tied to what was called the element of quality and of ecology. So the content “incitement to production” continues to be relatively present in the countries of the north. The implications are that, from this agreement: − first, other agricultural reforms could be envisaged; − second, there could be international investment standards not only in industry, but also, in the future, in agriculture; − third, this would allow the introduction of ideas—important for you, researchers and research centers—for patents that would be covered and protected in the most efficient manner possible; − and other elements which I won’t speak about today.
M. Cheikh-Rouhou / Agriculture: The Next EuroMed Frontier?
145
At this time, in the north, there are two systems for the stabilization of farm revenues: − What is called the American system, established by the former American secretary of agriculture Brennan. The Brennan plan put in place, fifty years ago, a system that guarantees a price to producers. The American government fixes a price, the producers produce, sell, and whatever they don’t sell on the market, the state buys at this price, and they fill sacks which we’re all familiar with, with “shake hands” and the American flag behind them. This system is founded on the price starting from a target price, and we’re going to see what the target price is. − The European Union has another method that it uses to pay subsidies, which is a method of quantity. In both cases, they want to push production, but the effect is not going to be the same. Here the surface area sown is the criterion on which the payments are based. So there’s an incentive effect by surface area or by production. Are these policies legitimate? I tend to answer yes, as far as the attempt to stabilize the revenues of agricultural producers goes. Each country must see that there’s a fact that exists the world over, and that’s that supply and demand of agricultural products never resemble the supply and demand of industrial products, because the supply and demand of agricultural products are both extremely inelastic. Their curves are very vertical, contrary to industry, where they are relatively flat. The result of this inelasticity is that, as soon as there is a variation in climate or as soon as there’s a change in demand, the fluctuation of prices for agricultural products becomes enormous and the revenue of farmers is affected. So stabilizing the revenue of agricultural producers is completely legitimate. Second reason: I tend to say yes, because in fact, food security is sometimes extremely important. Japan thinks it’s worth it to pay 53 billion euros per year to be sure to have their rice. Vietnam, fifteen years ago, you remember, didn’t have enough rice, and invaded Cambodia to secure for themselves, above all, access to rice. So the security of access to food is an element that could be facilitated by these policies of supporting production. On the other hand, these policies should be used very cautiously, because there are some perverse effects that I’d like to insist on. These techniques and these methods of price support, in the countries of the north and throughout the world today, distort the market system. We are no longer in a system of free competition, of the free market, but in a system of prices that are manipulated by local considerations. Does this harm the countries of the Third World or not? It’s clear that since Cancun, and after Cancun, the countries of the Third World are sounding the alarm in saying, “Yes, it harms us.” If we look at the American method from the Brennan plan, where we fix a price and we say to producers: “Produce, we’ll buy what’s left,” and the European system, where we set the surface areas sown and the goals and where we say, “We will intervene to guarantee the revenue of the producers,” it’s obvious that the target price should theoretically be the equilibrium price if the free market existed (Fig. 1). In both cases, it’s what is called the target in the schemes of international negotiation. Unfortunately, in the system of export supports—and thank you for having drawn my attention to this point, for there is a globalized system of price support for exports—this target has the effect that the price as it is perceived by the producers of the south is found to be under the global prices that exist, even if there was no intervention.
146
M. Cheikh-Rouhou / Agriculture: The Next EuroMed Frontier?
Figure 1. Two present systems
To sum up, if we had done nothing, we should be around the target prices, the equilibrium prices. By intervening, in a way, we end up, especially by encouraging export, giving artificial prices to the market which discourages production in the countries of the south. What are the proposals? An American proposal can be summed up in three parts: − eliminate export subsidies, − only apply customs tariffs by competition of 25% maximum, − reduce payments to farmers so that they no longer overproduce. The Americans say that by doing this, we’d pay 100 billion dollars less over the course of five years (on the 251 billion euros). I’m going to ask the president of this session to have the kindness to summarize for us the French proposal of 2003, which I couldn’t update because of a problem with my computer. B. Bachelier — In 2003, at the time of the Evian Summit, France had proposed to place a moratorium on export refunds, in order to provoke a lowering of export market prices for all basic products headed for the least advanced countries. I remind you that this proposal of President Chirac’s was accepted by the Council of European Ministers, and that it was blocked because the Americans refused to join. So this American proposal, behind this refusal, wants the suppression of supports in all countries, and is a proposal that aims only for the reduction of agricultural prices and not for the maintenance of agricultural revenues. Europe proposed again a suppression of export refunds if the United States would reciprocate, a proposal that’s now blocked by the United States not joining. M. Cheikh-Rouhou — Thank you very much, esteemed president. The result is that we’re still blocked in the south. Another, very encouraging, way exists, and it was reinforced after what happened in Asia after the tsunami. The World Bank and the G8 are in the process of working to show the very close link between agricultural development, meaning the use of appropriate agricultural policies, and the fight against poverty. Agricultural trade is one of the key factors in the fight against poverty. I would draw your attention to the fact that, if trade between the north and the south of the Mediterranean is deficient in
M. Cheikh-Rouhou / Agriculture: The Next EuroMed Frontier?
147
institutional terms, in organizational terms—and that’s one of the propositions I support—in the south of the Mediterranean itself, trade is also deficient: the UMA (Arab Maghreb Union) has done nothing to encourage industrial or agricultural trade and the UMA is thus the region of the world in which trade within the region is weakest. It’s surpassed by the countries of the Gulf where the trade rate, even though it’s also weak, is higher. So it’s clear that agriculture, in the countries of the south of the Mediterranean, suffers from a double border: a north/south border and a south/south border. I can’t resist drawing your attention in passing to the French proposal of President Chirac to join in this fight against poverty by taxing plane tickets. It might be a good thing because it will bring in money, but the countries that receive tourists aren’t very happy to see this kind of practice develop, and anyway it would be a modest contribution. In conclusion, I think that we have to work now on Euro-Med agreements specific to the zone and that focus attention on the vital importance of agriculture. We can’t speak of stability in the region, nor of democratic transition, when poverty is either increasing or reaching a ceiling at a certain level. Tunisia had poverty rates, as we saw earlier, that have remained on the whole the same; even if they’re relatively low, we would have liked to have seen them decrease even more. The other countries, except for Egypt, have seen their poverty rates rise. There is a direct link between real stability, democratic transition, and changes in the poverty rate. Agriculture is at the center of all that. Next, we need to use, in the construction of a Euro-Mediterranean entity, a winwin approach. We can’t continue to play cat and mouse. We can’t each take credit, all the more since the data that have been presented show clearly that the sum of the national revenues of the countries of the south of the Mediterranean, from Mauritania to Turkey, doesn’t even reach a quarter of the Italian national revenue. If we add the other non-Mediterranean countries of the Middle East, meaning oil producers, we arrive, for the zone the World Bank calls MENA (Middle East and North Africa) at a revenue equal to half that of Italy. So, when we talk about proposals for the construction of inter-Mediterranean programs for the promotion of agriculture, no one thinks today that for the European partners, the result would be catastrophic upheavals—on the contrary, it could contribute to the promotion of extremely interesting changes for both parties. Communication around agricultural policy and around research is fundamental. What you are doing here, what Robert Klapisch is doing, what you are in the process of exchanging is fundamental and vital. Without this communication, all the calls for improving the system will go unheeded. It’s not the work only of administrations, but rather it’s also the work of civil society. Finally, we know that competition doesn’t come only from the countries of the north. We have seen that between the countries of the UMA trade is insufficient, but today, we know that poultry producers are attacked directly not by Belgium but by Thailand; we know what Brazil is in the process of doing to other countries in the south. So neither the partners of the north nor the partners of the south should be happy about so-called cutthroat competition that might arise between the countries of the south, because no one has anything to gain from it.
148
Sharing Knowledge Across the Mediterranean Area P. Faugeras et al. (Eds.) IOS Press, 2006 © 2006 IOS Press. All rights reserved.
Roundtable Discussion38 B. Bachelier — To start off the discussion, I’d like to take up two or three points from the preceding talks. First, we see the difficulty in conceiving of a balanced freetrade zone, because each of the partners is following policies that are in the process of evolving. The Common Agricultural Policy is evolving, we know, we’re going to talk about it, national policies are working on this question, there are no markets in the south, Morocco, for example, signed a free-trade agreement with the United States, etc. So there are many factors, and reconciling national production and exports, it’s extremely complicated. I’ve noticed some questioning from time to time of regulation systems and at other times of free trade, and so it’s clear that it’s all very complex. But it would be interesting to have your opinion, to discuss this. Another observation on this question of policies: obviously, neither North Africa nor Europe is alone in the world, and there are a certain number of factors that result from globalization and negotiations taking place at the World Trade Organization. Secondly, for the research agenda, there are some crucial questions that have been asked regarding the adaptation of the aims of research to Mediterranean agriculture and the corresponding issues. I’ve retained one decisive fact: the supply of foodstuffs in the south is not ensured by the countries in the south of the Mediterranean and the productivity for basic food products has increased very little during the past several years, so we have a real problem there. Of course there are the climatic hazards, we’ve got major ecological constraints and finally we’ve got a major problem in the adaptation of our research results to real situations. And then there are of course other issues that you’re going to raise, so: we’re listening. J. Brugère-Picoux — I’m going to raise a question concerning food security since that’s the subject here. You talked about Thailand. I’ve visited animal farms in Thailand, pigs and poultry, but they don’t have the same food security, especially as regards the use of antibiotics, as in European countries. We’re subject to drastic decisions, for example I see that we’ve suppressed, and here I use the example of poultry, products that were effective for example against blackhead in turkeys, which is devastating turkey farming in France because we have no effective products. So we end up having paradoxical situations in terms of food security, in suppressing products that were effective with poultry and which results in us importing goods from countries that won’t give us this same security. OK, with Thailand, we aren’t worried about H5N1, we won’t import anything at the moment, but we definitely have this serious problem with food security, with the sometimes too-drastic decisions that are made concerning the use of certain products at the source, at the farm. B. Bachelier — I don’t know if someone wants to respond to this question? I’ll come back to it. Thanks in any case for this comment, this reminder. 38
Transcription from oral in French and translation.
Roundtable Discussion
149
A participant — Thanks, if you’ll allow me I have a small comment to make, also a question to ask. For the comment, I’m going to start by borrowing from Mr. Akesbi the formulation he used of the asymmetry that exists between the north and the south. I think that this asymmetry can only begin to be dispelled when the north starts to concern itself with the real problems of the south, and I’ll give an example from the area of agricultural science, the date palm. The palm grove in the Maghreb is declining because of the north, but in practice, when we propose to the north to research a remedy, in practice they’re not interested. I remind everyone simply that the palm grove is a victim of a parasite, a fungus, that is virtually ravaging, we saw it earlier, all the palm groves of Morocco. Morocco has thus gone from being an exporter to being an importer of dates, and this problem also affects the border between Algeria and Morocco. That’s an example where maybe it’s not a good idea to count on only a south–south collaboration. We see, perhaps, in that axis, that research could be done between Morocco and Tunisia and start to give some examples. That’s my comment. The question is also for Mr. Akesbi, for the scientist and especially politician that he is. Is not Morocco’s position, I would say, delicate and uncomfortable between the signing of the two agreements, between the free-trade zone with the Americans and that with the Europeans, because as regards agricultural policy, what they don’t agree on is much greater than what they do? Thanks. B. Bachelier — Are there any other questions on the European and American agreements? If not, I’ll ask Mr. Akesbi right away to respond to this question, which is quite broad. N. Akesbi — On this question, I think there’s a first level, a first degree of evaluation, which is to say, finally, who wins, who loses? Between us, the answer is so obvious and the disproportions between the economies are such that the only question worth asking is, why? It’s obvious that the agreement with the United States is a political agreement. It’s not an agreement whose determining factors are economic. When we draw up the table, and we did so, of “who wins, who loses?” product by product for agriculture, there’s not a shadow of a doubt, as they say. But let’s move now beyond this first aspect, and you’re right to phrase the question this way. In my opinion the most important thing is that in fact this agreement creates situations that are nearly irreversible. I mean that today, between the European Union and the United States, Morocco is in the middle. Concerning the European Union, that said, no one is content today with this level of free-trade zone. If we think of real strategy, if we think of the Euro-Mediterranean region, if we know that geography imposes its law no matter what, it’s obvious that we will never be the Mexico of the United States—on the contrary we’re the Morocco of the European Union, simply put. If we subscribe to this strategic vision, the step that follows the free-trade zone is the customs union, before moving on to the stage of economic union, etc. But today, in signing the agreement with the United States, we have almost definitively compromised the possibility of one day making an agreement for a customs union with the European Union. Because you know the principle—a customs union, it’s not just liberalizing trade between the union members, it’s also establishing what they call, what Europe did when it was formed, the famous Common External Tariff, that means protecting the union by a customs tariff that can for example protect it from partners outside the union. So if tomorrow we want to form a customs union with the European Union, we’d have to accept establishing a common tariff with the European Union but against the United States,
150
Roundtable Discussion
for example, which is now no longer possible. We can’t at the same time have a customs union with the European Union and free trade with the United States. That’s where it appears to me to be something extremely dangerous, and these are unfortunately questions that no one thinks about, or at least that no one is debating anymore in Morocco. I repeat once more, that beyond the level of who wins and who loses at trade, the most serious thing in my opinion is that, the fact that we’ve prevented ourselves, and in a rather reckless way, from engaging in what should be, in principle, our natural sphere of activity. Robert Klapisch — As you could see, the room was very sensitive to the cries of alarm that you have raised, and I think that you’re completely right to denounce a situation that is tending toward an excessive liberalization and neglects perhaps some fundamental imbalances. It’s about these fundamental imbalances that I can perhaps make a remark, because I don’t quite see the coherence of what you are denouncing. It’s obvious that agriculture in the south is much less productive, let’s say by a factor of 10 per person, than in the north. Moreover you also talk about the danger of, for Morocco and the countries of the south, the excess urban population, the rural exodus and for the countries of the north which are obviously worried about immigration. Well, that’s where I wasn’t following you, for suppose that with a magic wand, thanks to Rubbia or the World Bank or the trade winds, suddenly we manage to find the energy, the money, and the resources to make agriculture in the south as productive as that in the north. The result would be that you’re going to have the same process as in the north, meaning essentially that fewer farmers will be necessary, and consequently you won’t have as a result of that an end to emigration and the rural exodus. So I think that there’s a real contradiction there and I think personally that, while supporting the idea of food self-sufficiency, of whatever you want, the real solution is shooting for the high end, toward the famous knowledge economy, where in fact we should perhaps look again at certain productions one day. You talked about wheat: we can remark that the Saudis insist on growing wheat with desalinated water, I don’t know if that’s a good use of resources—they can afford it—perhaps. But I think there’s a certain rationality that should impose itself, I’m not saying it should be done mechanically, but that each country can find its fundamental economic nature in the areas in which it’s superior: I mean, we’re not going to grow dates in Paris! I think that in fact the best solution, which won’t happen tomorrow, is for Morocco to enter, like India, like China, into the knowledge economy, which would allow a population that’s going to urbanize whether we want it to or not to live and prosper without recourse to dramatic solutions such as emigration, etc. B. Bachelier — Thank you, Robert. Who wants to respond to that question? J. Brugère-Picoux — Yes, I want to respond because we have an experience that I’ll share with you: the history of the egg market. We industrialized the egg in France. Across the way, you have Tunisia, which is a large poultry producer and which did not make this mistake, and I find that it’s important to know about this experiment: they in fact limited the number of eggs, they did not industrialize, but rather they kept the possibility of having small farmers, they organized the commercialization of eggs starting with these farmers and thus there was in fact a preservation of these farmers who were not, like ours, finally limited in number, because there was a law that let them, in fact, avoid this excessive industrialization.
Roundtable Discussion
151
A participant — We have to find the right balance, in fact... Strong productivity, that’s a good thing, but there’s no point in going too quickly, and we should keep the balance between self-sufficiency and the conservation of our bio-resources, of our vegetable resources. B. Bachelier — I’m going to make a couple of short remarks myself before handing the floor to N. Akesbi to respond to R. Klapisch. First, I think that yes, we must facilitate access to other forms of development for the countries of the south. That said, access to knowledge or innovation, to industrialization, that’s not a magic wand that’s going to exonerate us and solve the problem of improving the situation of farmers. Europe did it over a period of many decades, during the “glorious thirty” (1945-1973), by integrating its farmers into the national whole at a moment when there were very high growth rates but when there was at the same time a growth in the productivity and revenues of farmers. Certainly, improvement in productivity probably entails a reduction in the number of farmers, and an increase in the work of each farmer. That said, the ratio is first on the productivity per hectare and then on the productivity per person. One can increase considerably the productivity per hectare by working seriously at it, without however immediately provoking the consolidation of farms and rural exodus. I don’t believe that today the majority of developing countries, notably the populous countries of North Africa, can go from an improvement in the situation of farmers directly into industrialization or a knowledge economy. Even India, which has entered the knowledge economy with computer specialists, etc., worked to protect Indian agriculture and improvements thanks to the Green Revolution, which pretty well limited, actually for several decades, rural emigration, without which Indian cities would have exploded. So maybe you’re going to find a front of agronomists arguing for the agricultural exception on the grounds of food sovereignty and the fact that lands don’t move? N. Akesbi — I think that you answered most of the question for me. What I can perhaps add, simply, is that in my opinion the question of emigration can be disassociated from the question of agricultural productivity. It obviously can be associated if we want to contrast the two things, but I think in connection with the European Union, I think the movement of emigration can be mostly disassociated from the agricultural question. The attraction of Europe, the absence of possibilities for finding work at home, whether it be in agriculture, in industry or in the knowledge economy, is much more important. But we shouldn’t forget one thing, either, which is that today Europe sees the question of immigration as a kind of aggression from outside. Well, you know well that all the predictions, all the prospective studies are conclusive on this question: in 10, 15, 20 years Europe will need massive immigration and thus will accept this immigration as something positive. So if I brought up the question of emigration, it was simply to say that there’s an agricultural failure. It’s one factor among others, it’s not the only one but it’s a factor that gives only an impetus. To put it plainly, the farmer, because the land no longer nourishes him, because he can longer live where he is, because the rural world is not livable, let’s put things simply, but also because there’s no alternative in the cities of our countries because there are no industries, etc. ... he is reduced to trying to emigrate, but these are things that in my opinion should not be mixed up. I’ll let Vincent speak.
152
Roundtable Discussion
Vincent Dollé — I would like to position myself at another level of discussion, and bring a modest contribution on three small tracks, very modest, but which would allow, maybe not a rapid improvement to the situation, but at least help stop it from deteriorating at the same speed. Three examples: 1.
2.
3.
Creating jobs and revenues in the rural sector using channels that do not compete with those of the countries of the north. I’m thinking for example that we have a superb example with dates, it’s a product with very high added value, which could even be an almost luxury product with a permanent market tied to Ramadan. It’s growing strongly in northern Europe, is not competitive, and could even valorize notions of soil, of know-how, of ancestral practices, of the agriculture of the oasis, of ecosystems... There’s a fantastic subject, the scientists of the north are interested. For those who are interested I recently created my laboratory... I was lucky to start my career as a scientist in Morocco, in Marrakech actually, so I caught the virus very early. And it’s a very good subject because it’s a scientific subject of very high quality: how to control somatic embryogenesis, organogenesis, and out of that selected resistant varieties. If afterward we package them with local products, it would help create jobs, revenues, locally. So that means that at least those people in the south won’t go to the northern cities and wait for the boat to Melilla to go elsewhere. All the agriculture on the urban perimeter that doesn’t go to the large export markets, which answers the increasing demand for quality products grown with clean water: that’s a subject both for research and for the implementation of completed research work that corresponds to a stro