cover
title: author: publisher: isbn10 | asin: print isbn13: ebook isbn13: language: subject publication date: lcc: ddc...
143 downloads
3692 Views
1MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
cover
title: author: publisher: isbn10 | asin: print isbn13: ebook isbn13: language: subject publication date: lcc: ddc: subject:
next page >
Teaching and Learning English Worldwide Multilingual Matters (Series) Britton, James N. Multilingual Matters 1853590649 9781853590641 9780585225876 English English philology--Study and teaching--History--20th century, English philology--Study and teaching. 1990 PE65.T38 1990eb 428/.007 English philology--Study and teaching--History--20th century, English philology--Study and teaching.
cover
next page >
< previous page
page_i
next page > Page i
Teaching and Learning English Worldwide
< previous page
page_i
next page >
< previous page
page_ii
next page > Page ii
Multilingual Matters Age in Second Language Acquisition BIRGIT HARLEY Bicultural and Trilingual Education MICHAEL BYRAM and JOHAN LEMAN (eds) Cultural Studies in Foreign Language Education MICHAEL BYRAM Current Trends in European Second Language Acquisition Research HANS W. DECHERT (ed.) Dialect and Education: Some European Perspectives J. CHESHIRE, V. EDWARDS, H. MÜNSTERMANN and B. WELTENS (eds) English in Wales: Diversity, Conflict and Change N. COUPLAND and A. THOMAS (ed.) Introspection in Second Language Research C.FÆRCH and G. KASPER (eds) Key Issues in Bilingualism and Bilingual Education COLIN BAKER Language Acquisition: The Age Factor D.M. SINGLETON Language Distribution Issues in Bilingual Schooling R. JACOBSON and C. FALTIS (eds) Language in Education in Africa CASMIR M. RUBAGUMYA (ed.) Language Planning and Education in Australasia and the South Pacific R.B. BALDAUF and A. LUKE (eds) Learner Language and Language Learning C. FÆRCH, K. HAASTRUP and R. PHILLIPSON Marriage Across Frontiers A. BARBARA Methods in Dialectology ALAN R. THOMAS (ed.) The Moving Experience: A Practical Guide to Psychological Survival GAIL MELTZER and ELAINE GRAND JEAN Raising Children Bilingually: The Pre-School Years LENORE ARNBERG The Role of the First Language in Second Language Learning HÅKAN RINGBOM Schooling in a Plural Canada JOHN R. MALLEA Second Language Acquisition/Foreign Language Learning B. VanPATTEN and J.F. LEE (eds) Story as Vehicle EDIE GARVIE Please contact us for the latest book information: Multilingual Matters, Bank House, 8a Hill Road, Clevedon, Avon BS21 7HH, England.
< previous page
page_ii
next page >
< previous page
page_iii
next page > Page iii
Teaching and Learning English Worldwide Edited by James Britton, Robert E. Shafer and Ken Watson
MULTILINGUAL MATTERS LTD Clevedon · Philadelphia
< previous page
page_iii
next page >
< previous page
page_iv
next page > Page iv
MORLEY B5355-IV 1.05.90 K02 MultilingualMatters [00.0] L01 15:03 Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data Teaching and Learning English Worldwide/Edited by James Britton, Robert E. Shafer and Ken Watson on behalf of the International Federation for the Teaching of English. p. cm. Includes bibliographic references. 1. English philology Study and teaching History 20th century. 2. English philology Study and teaching. I. Britton, James N. II. Shafer, Robert Eugene, 1925-, III. Watson, Ken. IV. International Federation for the Teaching of English. PE65.T38 1989 428'.007 dc20 British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data Teaching and Learning English Worldwide. 1. Schools. Curriculum subjects: English language. Teaching. Sociopolitical aspects. I. Britton, James, 1908 May 18-. II Shafer, Robert E. III. Watson, Ken. 420'.7'1 ISBN 1-85359-065-7 ISBN 1-85359-064-9 (pbk) Multilingual Matters Ltd Bank House, 8a Hill Road, Clevedon, Avon BS21 7HH, England & 1900 Frost Road, Suite 101 Bristol, PA 19007 USA Copyright © 1990 James Britton, Robert E. Shafer, Ken Watson and the authors of individual chapters. All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced in any form or by any means without permission in writing from the publisher. Index compiled by Meg Davies (Society of Indexers). Typeset by Morley Harris Typesetting, Bristol. Printed and bound in Great Britain by WBC Print Ltd, Bristol.
< previous page
page_iv
next page >
< previous page
next page >
page_v
Page v Contents Foreword The Editors
vii
Introduction James Britton
1
1 The Teaching of English in England, 1945-1986: Politics and Practice Tony Burgess and Nancy Martin
7
2 The Growth of Accountability and the Accountability of Growth: Secondary School English Teaching in Post-War Scotland David Northcroft
39
3 The Teaching of English in Ireland John Killeen and Tom Mullins
65
4 The Swinging Pendulum: Teaching English in the USA, 19451987 John S. Simmons, Robert E. Sharer and Linda K. Shadiow
89
5 Teaching English Language Arts in Canada: 1965-1985 Sam Robinson, Laurence Walker, Nan Johnson and Trevor Gambell
131
6 Teaching English in Australia: A Personal View Diana Davis and Ken Watson
151
7 The Teaching of English in New Zealand Schools Vince Catherwood, Elody Rathgen and Russell Aitken
175
8 'The most important agent of civilisation': Teaching English in the West Indies, 1838-1986 200 Kathleen Drayton 9 English and the Teaching of English Literature in South Africa Hilary Janks and Jonathan Paton
226
10 A Language for the People: A History of English Language Teaching in Singapore Chua Seok Hong
249
< previous page
page_v
next page >
< previous page
next page >
page_vi
Page vi 11 English Language Teaching in the Philippines: A Succession of Movements Bonifacio P. Sibayan and Andrew B. Gonzalez
269
12 The Teaching of English in India, 1945-1985S. K. Das
297
13 The Teaching of English in Indonesia S. Takdir Alisjahbana
315
Comparative Data on the Thirteen Countries
328
Notes on Contributors
341
Index
347
< previous page
page_vi
next page >
< previous page
page_vii
next page > Page vii
Foreword There are few international studies of English teaching although the place of the English language as an international lingua franca is well established. There are even fewer historical studies of English teaching and none that we know of in international or comparative settings which is what this volume purports to be. What we have done under the aegis of the International Federation for the Teaching of English is to find authors or author teams in various countries where English is a mother tongue language or a significant second, or in some cases, third language. We asked these authors to write a history of the teaching of English in their respective countries between 1945 and the present. In several instances they began their accounts considerably earlier than 1945 to provide necessary background. Unfortunately, we were not able to be inclusive in this effort because of the limitations of time, space and energy and also because the social and political events of the last several centuries have resulted in the spread of English into so many different countries that several volumes would be required to tell the complete story. Essentially, the authors of the various chapters have concentrated on the place of English in a particular society and have attempted to describe how English exists in the social and political context of that society and how it has been shaped as a school subject and/or the language of instruction within that context. We were fortunate to be able to find authors in thirteen countries who are familiar with the recent history of English teaching in their respective countries and who, in all cases, are themselves significant contributors to that history. Being so, they write with a strongly held point-of-view about the significance of English as a school subject and its place in the social milieu. The editors acknowledge their debt to Professor Ian Pringle of Carton University in Ottawa, Canada, who led the Fourth International Conference on the Teaching of English in May of 1986 and who placed us in contact with many of our authors at that conference. A word of thanks is also due to the members of the Executive Committee of the International Federation for the Teaching of English who have encouraged us and supported our work. We are pleased to note that all royalties from the sale of this volume will help to support future AFT projects. Lastly, we thank
< previous page
page_vii
next page >
< previous page
page_viii
next page > Page viii
our authors who have cheerfully put up with our occasional misunderstandings of the dynamics of English teaching in their complex societies and who have been both gracious and understanding about delays in publication brought about by the various commitments of their editors. THE EDITORS
< previous page
page_viii
next page >
< previous page
page_1
next page > Page 1
Introduction James Briton I think the experience of reading the chapters in this book might be described as kaleidoscopic. There are many common themes, topics that recur chapter after chapter; the effect of examinations; the problem of set-books for reading; censorship; the literary canon and innovations that depart from it; nationality as a criterion for choosing authors; meeting multicultural needs and demands; dialects are they a problem? 'new grammars' what do they offer us? and so on. The kaleidoscope suggests itself because in any chapter a number of these items is likely to enter into varying relationships, constitute fresh configurations. A twist to the instrument and a fresh pattern appears. I find it fascinating to read for indications of the wider context social, political, historical, ideological that promises to explain why the items take up that particular configuration. One factor explicit in some chapters, disguised in others is the economic recession that made the 1970s in many parts of the world an 'age of anxiety'. An open mind is the first casualty when anxiety threatens us, and for some reason educational provision what goes on in schools seems to come early under scrutiny when anxiety attacks a nation's public opinion. Of course, national policies will reflect a range of differing reactions to crisis conditions national policies at least broadly representing the political parties in power. Cuts in educational spending may, for example, have reduced the resources for teaching in USA, Australia, New Zealand and the United Kingdom but by no means equally; the severity of the cuts and the resulting disablement would vary enormously. Anxiety has other even more damaging effects a loss of confidence in the educational service and a lowering of morale in the teaching profession. Many of the chapters refer to contrasting states of affairs in this respect; generally speaking 'professionalism' and high morale and efficient operating are seen as representing existing gains and pointing the way ahead; authoritarian control, top-down administration central control of the
< previous page
page_1
next page >
< previous page
page_2
next page > Page 2
curriculum in particular are seen as reactionary, a brake on progress and a state of affairs we have worked to leave behind. Essentially, the contrast is between an educational regime of trust and one of surveillance. To claim this is to recognise that the chapters of this book cannot be taken as reflecting all that goes on in the English classes of the nations represented. The average classroom, the average school in the average school district or local authority would no doubt be less affected by change in current directions, nearer to yesterday's norms, less conscious of its own direction, the rationale underlying its practices. What these chapters represent, we believe, is a distillation of the best practices a substantial consensus, a caucus, perhaps, that marks the way ahead. After all, the initiative came from people already associated, already committed to a general philosophical position one that owes its survival to the impetus provided by the Dartmouth Seminar of 1966 and the years of international co-operation that have resulted, and the one that is today embodied in the voluntary associations of the English teachers that constitute the International Federation for the Teaching of English. I have referred to the 'survival' of this conception because the enlightened (or 'progressive' where that is not a dirty word) view of education had its origins long before Dartmouth. I do not believe it is part of any bandwagon or fashion cycle or pendulum swing, but a slowly growing movement with philosophical roots way back in the past and pragmatic roots deep in the intuitive wisdom of generations of successful teachers. I think we need to make it clear that a commitment to the classroom teacher's power of decision in curriculum and associated matters is not the outcome of a bogus professionalism a policy of 'teacher knows best' but derives from an increasingly accurate analysis of the processes of teaching and learning. When it is recognised that effective teaching is not a unidirectional activity but the outcome of teacher/student interaction and, even more importantly, that learning is an effect of community rather than a mere reciprocal response to instruction; then it is manifest that the course of classroom events cannot be laid down by any external agency. Students, parents, society in general, must rely upon a classroom teacher's theoretical sophistication, the adequacy of the rationale by which he functions and his ability to put that theory into practice. It is a sad part of the story this book has to tell that alongside historical reviews reflecting earlier failures to recognize the truth of this analysis, we have to report a number of recent attacks on teacher professionalism and the dismantling of some of the institutions that had served to support and develop it.
< previous page
page_2
next page >
< previous page
page_3
next page > Page 3
A major source of variation in the teaching of English from country to country is, of course, the context of other languages in which it operates. Early attempts to extend the use of Irish Celtic as a mother tongue in the Irish Republic confronting a more recent recognition of the educational importance of a mother tongue, whether English or Irish, present, for example, a fascinating story, and one that is reflected to some extent in many other chapters. When we turn to the South African chapter, we have to abandon the kaleidoscope notion with which I began this introduction: the problems in South Africa are by no means a recombining of elements familiar in other configurations in other countries. I read that chapter with a growing sense of the courage required to pursue our common notions in so hostile an environment, and a growing sense that their account runs the risk of trivializing the problems and concerns that feature in our other countries, our other chapters. We can only hope that international concern and a degree of international consensus on English teaching may in some way, at some stage, provide support for their cause. It is interesting to notice where efforts have been and are being made to recognize and exploit the richness that linguistic and cultural variation can bring to an educational setting. It would be difficult to find a more dramatic example than the educational campaigns that formed a part of the Civil Rights Movement under Kennedy and Johnson in the United States. More recent activity is described in the Canadian chapter with its accounts of French immersion programmes and programmes for Indian and Mete education; and today in New Zealand determined efforts are being made to include Maori elements in the national image and resulting educational provision. Racial and regional differences provide a complex picture of West Indian education, but perhaps the dominant feature there might be called the 'birth of a language' the emergence of the novel in West Indian English and the effect of that phenomenon on the status of creole dialect its growing acceptance as a language in its own right. It is not in the least surprising that leaders of black opinion in South Africa are foreseeing a similar development for the English dialects of the black townships. Questions of national identity enter also into the field of literature teaching. The conception of 'literature in the English language' as a viable category seems to operate principally in the United Kingdom at the pre-college level; the United States has a long-established pattern that distinguishes between English and American authors and allots a place for both in the high school curriculum; and the chapters describing literature courses in Canada, Australia, New Zealand, the Caribbean all these make reference to a growing concern to establish studies in national and
< previous page
page_3
next page >
< previous page
page_4
next page > Page 4
sometimes regional literature. The demand is most insistent, I believe, where the effects of British imperialism have not been forgotten where the language of the colonists operated as a form of oppression. ('There are many reasons', writes Kneehole, the black South African, 'why English cannot be considered an innocent language.') I believe the material that is collected in this volume could best be regarded as documentation of the processes of change in English teaching. Fascinating questions are raised from its pages: what factors, for example are favorable to change and what factors defend the status quo? Are there watersheds and if there are, how do they come about? Do we progress by creating and resolving polar oppositions either at the classroom level or by scholarly analysis and research? Does 'outrageous fortune' play a part positively sometimes as well as negatively? Does the ebb and flow of bandwagon ideas leave any long-term effects or merely serve to distort the progress of orderly advance? Binary oppositions certainly abound in these accounts usually, though not always, clearly marked for value in accordance with the writer's opinion. Vocational education is seen as opposing sometimes 'liberal' and sometimes 'academic' educational ideals; response to literary works is seen as competing with biographical, historical and critical approaches; new grammars compete for time on the agenda that others would give to experience in writingand-reading. In Canada and the United States a 'whole language' movement confronts teachers who believe education focuses upon knowledge about cultural matters. The author of the Scottish chapter, David Northernmost, poses an opposition between growth, as a broad and optimistic educational analogy, and accountability, 'the external consideration that has increasingly come to haunt' its practitioners and there are echoes of this confrontation in various forms in other chapters. We set out, in fact, to document the teaching of English, but inevitably a good deal of time is spent in describing modes of assessment or evaluation and it must be admitted that no account would have been responsibly complete without information on this aspect. The trend, where circumstances are most favorable, is to move away from traditional modes of assessment written papers externally set and marked in the direction of internal assessment of course work; a procedure that would reflect and support the teaching programme rather than dictate its terms. Modes of assessment have certainly operated in the past as change agents, but they are an unacceptable channel in so far as they represent 'remote control' of curriculum matters and in that their specifications will tend to undervalue aspects of learning that are more difficult or more expensive to measure. Although there are fairly frequent brief references to educational
< previous page
page_4
next page >
< previous page
page_5
next page > Page 5
research in these chapters, it certainly cannot be said to play a major role ideas deriving from it, for example, are not developed in any detail. Perhaps the most interesting tendency is a recent move in the direction of classroom observation the 'teacher as researcher' a move that should have the effect of enhancing or enriching a teacher's role, provided research is conceived as a mode of discovery (with widely varying applications, or 'ranges of convenience') rather than as an instrument of proof. Certainly, the point has been forcibly made more than once in this book that it is only where teachers themselves are involved in research design and execution that the insights generated are likely to be carried effectively into practice. Doubtless the most startling omission in this account of English teaching, world-wide, is reflected in the extreme paucity of references to dramatic improvisation. It is my own opinion that despite excellent work often achieved by drama specialists, the limitations usually imposed by the timetable assigned to a 'specialist' (whether art teacher, drama teacher, music teacher or anyone else) does mean that improvisation can rarely be more than icing on the cake and meanwhile dramatic methods in the English lesson, a rich potential during the years when I was a teacher, seem to have been largely eclipsed. <><><><><><><><><><><><> It is, I believe, a notorious fact that an English teacher's resources are spread very thin and, while much the same is true for the teacher of a large class in an elementary school, that teacher is spared the multiple class-load of a rotary teacher. For rotary teachers, I believe it becomes necessary to establish routines and a saving of energy to stick to them; with a good teacher they will be useful routines, but none the less resistant to spontaneous modification. In my early years as a teacher, I certainly found that, while I recognized the need to re-plan, to make changes, I could not expect to change every programme each year; what I had to do was to carry on as usual in most classes while initiating a new programme in one or two selected classes. Which programmes to revise? clearly that was a matter of paying attention to pupil responses listening to pupil comments and 'reading' their behavior. With experience I think we become more open to change, less dependent on established classroom patterns. But there is no doubt that the climate of opinion in the school is a major factor; in a school where shop talk in the staff room is frowned on, where theories are despised and serious reading is a thing of the past the solitary teacher-asresearcher can hardly
< previous page
page_5
next page >
< previous page
page_6
next page > Page 6
expect to survive. A school that regards professional development for its teachers as a key part of its responsibilities, and where consultation time forms part of the school day, providing a forum for the discussion of new ideas and the joint planning of new procedures all that, rare though it may be 'on the ground' constitutes the way forward for English teaching. But that is not all; it would be inappropriate to introduce this history without referring finally to the kind of support for teachers afforded by the Associations for the Teaching of English. In countries like Australia and Canada, covering vast areas and scattered centares of activity, the need is paramount and the chapters that follow will tell of the gains and the difficulties to be surmounted. Other chapters report an urgent need for a national voice for English teachers perhaps even a need to keep alive whatever remnants of professionalism survive. And everywhere, regardless of local circumstances, the importance of a framework of support for English teachers in search of a more adequate conception and more efficient means of carrying out their role in tomorrow's world.
< previous page
page_6
next page >
< previous page
page_7
next page > Page 7
1 The Teaching Of English In England, 1945-1986: Politics And Practice Tony Burgess and Nancy Martin Introduction If developments in English are to be seen within their context, it is necessary to appreciate something of the administrative framework of education in the United Kingdom which has been in place for most of the post-war period but which is currently undergoing major change. Under this, national direction for the system has been derived from a department of state (the Department of Education and Science the DES formerly the Ministry of Education). But responsibility for provision and for day to day administration has been through elected local government authorities, who have education as one among a number of local government functions, including, for example, housing, social services and recreation. There are currently 109 of these local authorities and their educational (and other) arrangements have been financed partly through local taxes (rates) and partly through the centrally allocated rate support grant, which is annually set by government. The schools thus locally provided have been directed by Head Teachers, who are responsible to the Education Committee of their Local Education Authority (LEA), to a governing body and less directly to parents. The system, then, has been one with three tiers and with much devolution of responsibility. While a framework of national education acts guarantees provision between the ages of 5 and 16, the DES, in framing more immediate educational policy, has had necessarily to work through LEAs; and these LEAs have had in practice fairly considerable powers. Curriculum, to come to a matter more directly relevant to English, has been technically in the charge of governors, implying responsibility at school
< previous page
page_7
next page >
< previous page
page_8
next page > Page 8
level. However, in such a system teachers also can have considerable influence over what is taught, though such influence has been subject to strong checks and balances, especially those of national and local inspectorates and of a public examination system providing qualifications at the ages of 16 and 18. With powers thus separated, with considerable autonomy at different levels, the system has been one in which, for much of the post-war period, local initiatives have been possible; and grass root movements at school or professional level have come to have wider influence. English during these years undoubtedly owes something to this separation of powers. The new traditions of the subject have grown hand in hand with a developing sense of professional competence and responsibility. The account anticipates sharp changes, some introduced and some contemplated in the immediate future, which have emerged in more recent times. As public spending has come to be seen on the political right as the enemy of economic growth rather than its infrastructure, political pressures have multiplied against egalitarian directions in public education and against the relative autonomy of teachers and the education service. For much of the period the educational system in the UK would by comparison with other systems be classified as decentralized. By the late 1980s, a new education act introduced by the current secretary of state has made it clear that the future will lie with far greater centralization. This history of initial teacher autonomy and mounting political pressure for greater centralization is one to which we shall need to return. Forty years is not far from the working life of a teacher. We hope that it may be of interest if we pause for one more moment, on the threshold of the more specific story which we have to tell, to ask how it would have looked to him or her, a young entrant to the profession, in 1945? She would have set out on the crest of hopes for change. In schools, a major re-ordering was in hand, as the Butler Act abolished the old, all-through elementary schools and instituted universal secondary schooling. Major boundaries were being freshly drawn, even if much remained. Today, approaching retirement, she would be hard put to avoid noting the emergence of a very different climate. Teachers' unions, in the last few years, have been involved in a protracted struggle over conditions of service. Since the late 1960s there has been a continuous stream of pamphleteering from the political and educational right criticizing public education. Even before the present bill, central government direction of curriculum had been increasing rapidly and whole areas of educational provision are now funded, with direct control, from the department of employment rather than through educational expenditure.
< previous page
page_8
next page >
< previous page
page_9
next page > Page 9
We think that the story goes like this. Through to the beginnings of the 1960s, a new progressive framework was being constructed in which the central elements were comprehensive schooling, an altered examination system, the emergence of new subject teaching associations and the steady accumulation of agreed lines of a common English teaching practice. How deeply this was founded is hard to tell. It is possible to overestimate the depth and the degree of agreement but also to underestimate the durability. The 1960s and early 1970s look like years of consolidation of this framework as well as of development and innovation. A central element in this was the emergence of the Schools Council with something like general acceptance of a role for professional, teacher responsibility in curriculum and examinations reform. A decisive break in this period is marked by a speech given by Cablegram in 1976, at Ruin College, which initiated the so-called 'Great Debate' in British education. The present act, however, envisages a degree of centralized direction of curriculum and assessment which goes well beyond the themes of that debate and indeed beyond any recent policy statements. The ground for this change of direction was prepared by a hard-hitting attack on the educational changes of the 1950s and 1960s. It was mounted when a Labor Government was in power by a small but influential group of University teachers, writers, heads of grammar schools and a leading Conservative Member of Parliament. This attack foreshadowed most of the directions which have dominated the educational climate of the 1980s. It was published in a series of pamphlets (1969-71) self-named 'The Black Papers'. These set out to show that the egalitarian aims of the post-war Education Acts and Government Reports had ruined the schools and destroyed the existing high standards set by the selective grammar schools. Comprehensive schools had failed, they claimed, and the opening up of the curricula of schools and universities would lead to lower standards. Titles of some of the articles reveal both their own standpoint and that which they were attacking: for instance, 'The Egalitarian Threat', 'Pernicious Participation', 'Comprehensive Disaster', 'In Praise of Examinations'. They concluded by reasserting the importance of competition, as an educational aim, and of selection for schools for the ablest pupils. The Black Papers were at the time a unique phenomenon in the history of education. They were in no way a contribution to theoretical debate; they were a direct attack on the educational policies of post-war Governments in their attempts to develop equal opportunities for all, and were organized as a political campaign. Copies were sent to all Members of Parliament and buyers were urged to purchase ten extra copies and distribute them. When a Conservative Government was elected in 1970 they ceased publication, but
< previous page
page_9
next page >
< previous page
page_10
next page > Page 10
have had their successors in pamphlets published by the Centare for Policy Studies, a right wing think tank formed by Margaret Thatcher and Ketch Joseph in 1974. It is illuminating to see what has happened to the charges made by these papers and to the directions they advocated and to the tradition of influence from the right which they initiated. While the growing pains of the new comprehensive schools were manifold, an alternative view held that time was needed for teachers who had been socialized in selective schools to accommodate to the very different professional needs of common schools; these problems were regarded by the contributors to 'The Black Papers' not as growing pains but as outright failure and a strong case for putting the clock back. One has to ask how it was possible for the charges to be made to stick and for the winds of change to blow in a contrary direction. How much is it possible to see behind the facade of public clamor about the 'ills' of education? Why did a Labor leader give the coup de grace to a gradually emerging professional influence in education and to the egalitarian consensus in favour of a strong public education system which has emerged in postwar years? With hindsight, much may be attributed to political expediency a diversionary tactic to distract attention from the gathering economic recession and an attempt to draw the sting from a more fundamental attack on the whole British welfare state. Be that as it may, with the coming to power of the Thatcher Government in 1979, the stage had been set for an all-out attempt to take control of education from the local authorities and to curb, beyond recovery, the influence of teachers. It is within this broader history, then, that English has developed in post-war years; and to this, our more specific story, we turn. 1945-1960 It now seems extraordinary that English teachers had no common voice until the National Association for the Teaching of English was founded in the early 1960s. Science and Mathematics had had powerful associations for some years whereas only small associations with limited objectives and influence existed for English teachers in the 1940s. In 1947 the London Association for the Teaching of English, led by James Britton and Nancy Martin, was founded to provide a forum for London teachers, and between that date and the 1960s it steadily grew in influence. Its mode of working through study groups which reported to the Association as a whole (or were published) created a working democratic model which was influential when the National Association was founded in 1963. The London Association's first debates were concerned with aspects of
< previous page
page_10
next page >
< previous page
page_11
next page > Page 11
assessment where they touched classroom practice, in particular the influx of comprehension tests. Intelligence testing was on the way out as a means of sorting pupils into categories of ability administratively necessary within a system of selective schools. It disappeared with the coming of the common school, yet within these new large comprehensive schools some way of organising students which met their differing capacities and needs had to be found. It began to look as if comprehension tests (as indicators of reading ability) were all set to replace intelligence tests as a sorting agency which would recreate the selective system within the comprehensive schools and, in doing so, would set up 'Comprehension' as a new subject in the curriculum. The new Association challenged this trend (blown large by text book writers and publishers) by its first venture into the professional arena. This was a three-year comparison of the effects of class time spent doing comprehension versus straight reading of whole books. The findings, clearly in favour of books in all seven experimental schools, were influential in keeping comprehension as part of the ordinary process of reading. This was a micro-operation within a single subject field, but it was significant both in its own right, and as a first excursion into professional work bringing individual English teachers into a wider arena. As the 1950s wore on the pace of change accelerated. After free secondary education for all and the development of common schools, arguments came to centre on raising the school leaving age to 16. This put issues of assessment in the forefront of debate. Now the two thirds of the school population which had hitherto left without qualifying by an examination had to be catered for. The Secondary Schools Examinations Council was charged with establishing an examination available for all before this the public examination system had only catered for the one third of the school population which was in Grammar schools. What was now planned was an examination which would record students' achievements however meagre rather than put them above or below a pass line. The then Secretary of State for Education and the Secondary Schools Examinations Council were quite clear that the new examination should be the servant not the master of the schools and to this end 'effective teacher control of syllabus content, examination papers and examining techniques is the rock on which the CSE system will stand' (HMSO, 1963), and, indeed, the teachers' influence was clear in the liberalising directions of the new Certificate of Secondary Education when it came (1966). For English teachers it meant papers which did not separate language and literature as examination subjects; it meant a focus on reading and on continuous writing; it meant a choice of type of examination which could include coursework. For the first time examinations could be an aid to teaching
< previous page
page_11
next page >
< previous page
page_12
next page > Page 12
rather than a dead hand. Opposition came from some of the older examination boards because the new Certificate remained a poor relation of the established GCE (General Certificate of Education). Most schools opted for the old examination because it was deemed to carry more weight as a qualification: educational arguments about the relative effects of the two examinations proved of little account. Debate about modes of assessment went hand in hand with discussion about the content of the curriculum. Here various influences had been at work for some years. A progressive movement coming from private schools and the education of younger children argued for the importance of creative activities art, writing, drama, stories. What had been a matter of speculation, experiment and debate in the private sector gradually seeped into public education. One result of this growing focus on the general value of creative work was a profound change of attitude towards children's writing. It was now beginning to be seen as an expression of real experience, not merely an exercise of a skill. Dora Pym and Marjorie Hourd in their writings in the late 1940s and early 1950s were influential in changing people's notions about writing; writings which were expressions of real experience needed to be valued differently from mere exercises (Pym, 1956; Hourd, 1949). The gradual effect of this change of concept is, perhaps, only now in the 1980s coming to fruition in changes in students' views of their own capacities. The dominant figure in the late 1940s and early 1950s was F.R. Leavis at Cambridge. Denys Thompson at Yeovil school, supported by Leavis, founded The Use of English journal, and he and Leavis were extremely influential in developing a movement of devoted teachers of English whose beliefs lay in the regenerating power of good literature. Leavis and his associates were unusual in that they analysed the social contexts of education and pressed the role of literature by contrasting the culture of a mass civilisation with a minority culture which they saw as a defence against a corrupt society. But they valued it as a minority culture for a select minority for only those who could read and appreciate the best that had been written. One of Leavis's associates, David Holbrook, took their views more widely to include pupils in secondary modern schools and based his literary canon on ballads and popular literature of the past (of quality); in effect, just another form of elitism with a different kind of school population (Holbrook, 1961). It was this deep-rooted elitism which caused many good teachers to move away from the narrow canon of literature which Leavis propounded. This revolt of many English teachers against this elitist view was the beginning of the opposition to the dominance of literary criticism in school literature teaching, and of the 'Great Tradition' as the only source of
< previous page
page_12
next page >
< previous page
page_13
next page > Page 13
books to read in the new common schools. Here, with reading levels ranging from illiterate to University entrance, there had to be debate about what texts should and could be read; and arising from this came questions about what should count as literature. This was not just a matter of finding alternative texts, though this is how it appeared to many teachers faced with how to get their wide-ranging classes reading. In the past, what counted as literature had been in practice determined by the books chosen by the examiners, and the examinees were the students who would become future teachers and administrators. Now the teachers themselves had become to a large extent the examiners, and their constituency was the total population with all its immense variations. In this context of confusion, it seems relevant to recall some of those questions and discussions which sank away out of thought did not find a place on the agenda for action. The Crowther and Newsome Reports raised questions about the need for new forms of education for the new masses for whom education was now being provided (15-18 years and subsequently) (HMSO, 1959; HMSO, 1963). General issues were discussed about what account was being taken of working class culture. Might working class children have modes of perception and capacities that were not being met by educational procedures that were dominantly middle class? In the field of English, questions were asked about what literature should be chosen, and was literature itself a middle class product? Were teachers themselves socialised into the middle class with its distinctive values and therefore at odds with the majority of their pupils? To what extent could a national culture be said to exist, and to be part of the school horizon? These debates have disappeared, or gone underground. They may have touched too closely on social values in an upwardly mobile society, but, in any case, most discussions of a theoretical or speculative nature have gone to ground under the myopic influence of a focus on what is directly practical and supposedly basic. In the matter of what books to read, pragmatic solutions were found in books by contemporary writers with a focus on working class lives. Grammar teaching came under review from two aspects. First, studies were published which showed (once again) that knowledge of school grammar (parts of speech and clause analysis) could not be shown to have any effect on writing. As an emphasis developed on giving priority to experience of writing rather than study of language, so grammar teaching began to fade away in all but a few schools. Second, the growth of 'new grammars' coming chiefly from the USA seemed to open doors to a proper understanding of the functions of language in society, and to provide a tool for opposing the deadening effect of the weekly grammar lesson based on
< previous page
page_13
next page >
< previous page
page_14
next page > Page 14
archaic notions of grammar and rhetoric. A further result of the work on new grammars and linguistics was a move in favour of including linguistics in courses for teachers. This direction has steadily gained momentum, though it did not halt the decline of grammar teaching in schools. In matters of curriculum, the struggle between State and teachers for control was not at this time openly joined. Decisions rested largely with the Examination Boards and the teachers, with some advisory interventions from Her Majesty's Inspectors. The changes noted above have been selected for the way they touched the lives of teachers in the 1950s as classroom issues, but behind the practical debates was developing a sense of theoretical rationale derived chiefly from humanist philosophy with some input from psychology. Current discussion couched these ideas in such terms as 'language and inner representation', 'language and thought', 'language and discovery'. These phrases pinpoint the notion that language has a wider dimension than the mastery of correct forms and had implications that extended to other subjects and to learning in its most general sense. This change in the concept of language in its social and intellectual functions is, we suggest, the most significant change in the post-war years, and it is not yet adequately understood. Mastery of skill is still seen by many as the aim of language work. Even the Bullock Report (apart from James Britton's contributions, and in spite of the title 'A Language for Life') saw the purpose of English as being the acquisition of language. Full stop. It puts little explicit focus on language to do things with. This is implied, of course, but it does not raise any kind of flag to announce the implications and potential contained in the central concepts. Given these, the purposes of English teaching can now be not just the achievement of good writing, or good reading or good spelling but the mastery of an intellectual tool which may enable its users to reflect upon them, and also to investigate and reflect upon the outer social world. These ideas could not be assimilated quickly, and in any case, all the traditional practices of English teaching operated against them. Teachers had to move from teaching subject English with its focus on literature to consider all the uses of language which school students engage in and how to develop these for real purposes. Proficiency is no longer an adequate aim. Thus for English teachers the move was a double one: out of subject English and over to language in all subjects, and, second, from acquiring an abstract competence towards continually purposive language activity. There are, of course, many other kinds of change needed before the possibilities of this changed concept of language can be implemented in its full power. In 1954 appeared a booklet from the Ministry of Education called Language: Some Suggestions for Teachers of English and Others (HMSO,
< previous page
page_14
next page >
< previous page
page_15
next page > Page 15
1954). This was the first official post-war document about English teaching. No other of comparable range appeared until the Bullock Report, 20 years later. What is interesting about the 1954 booklet is that it provides a theoretical rationale based on current knowledge about language and its place in the world. Moreover, it concerns itself with the importance of the mother tongue in all learning. In this it breaks entirely new ground both in its official policy and in general understanding about language. With its powerful theoretical base, the document could have been the starting point for advice to teachers which would have opened up possibilities for quite different kinds of work in English and given rise to new forms of writing, and offered new opportunities for students to understand and use the power of language as a tool of all learning; but the authors did nothing of this. In their advice to English teachers they failed to explore the implications of the rationale they had articulated. Instead they presented traditional approaches as before. The booklet, Language, epitomised the way in which forces for change arising from new knowledge conflict with the conservatism of traditional practice. Moreover, institutions themselves are by nature conservative, and the pressures of school management systems cause all routines from timetables to hierarchies of command to operate against change. The resolution of this conflict can only be through the growth of teacher professionalism and the active participation of teachers in decisions of all sorts. This began to happen in the 1960s but it had not developed strongly enough as the history of the last of our three periods will show. 1960-1970 Uniquely, research became in the 1960s a first and even a predominant concern. Less than a year after the formation of the National Association for the Teaching of English (NATE) in 1963, the Schools Council was set up to 'carry out research and development work on curricula, teaching methods and examinations in primary and secondary schools'. This sometimes underestimated and now disbanded body was unusual in many ways. It brought under one roof responsibility for examinations and for curriculum, replacing the former Secondary Schools Examinations Committee. It was an independent body. All sectors of the educational field were represented on it, with school teachers forming a majority of its members. It had a brief, not just for co-ordination, but for research and development for change. The new Certificate of Secondary Education, which it was one of the
< previous page
page_15
next page >
< previous page
page_16
next page > Page 16
Council's earliest responsibilities to introduce, in due course bore witness to the wisdom of co-ordinating examinations with curriculum. As we noted above, the certificate was innovative and has been decisively preferred to 'O' levels, in professional opinion. Also without earlier parallel was the brief for development of curriculum. With the exception of this period in the 1960s the history of national attention to the curriculum has been substantially one of limitation and control. Initiating through the Council a period of curriculum development marked a decisive shift in attitude both to curriculum and to professional responsibility in curriculum matters. Above all, the commitment of funding for research in curriculum was a major and quite new step. Educational research in the UK has had different sources of development. Sponsored by the Department of Education and Science, it has tended to be policy orientated. In universities, it may have addressed more fundamental questions, but its history has reflected the low status attaching to the study of education. By the 1960s, there were distinguished bodies of work in child psychology and in the history of education. But some newer academic disciplines, sociology and linguistics especially, were still struggling to find a place in universities and were no more than on the threshold of making a contribution to education. English teaching, as we have seen, drew its theorisation principally from extensions of critical work and of literary study and from its own professional debates, while keeping in touch with thinking in linguistics and psychology. There had been at this stage mere glimmerings of possibilities for curriculum orientated research; work in Science education which had been funded by the Nuffield Foundation, talk of a new Mathematics. Against such a background, the Schools Council offered new opportunities. By 1965, the Council had recognised the need for 'a major initiative in the field of English teaching' and had produced its working paper 3: 'English a programme for research and development in English teaching' (HMSO, 1965). Following this, in 1966, several new researches were initiated. Some others were taken over from other funding bodies. This list marks out, in effect, a new field of language and literature in education. There was to be an investigation of relations between linguistics and English teaching, work which had already been begun by the linguist, Michael Halliday, and which was transferred from Nuffield to Schools Council funding. Oracy was to be studied by Andrew Wilkinson, in Birmingham, also continuing work originally funded by Gulbenkian. A project On writing, 'The Development of Writing Abilities, 11-18', was set up by James Britton, in London, with his associates, Harold Rosen, Bernard Newsome, Denis Griffiths, Alex McLeod and (the present writers) Nancy Martin and Tony Burgess. A survey of approaches to English was to be
< previous page
page_16
next page >
< previous page
page_17
next page > Page 17
undertaken by Bill Mittins, in Newcastle. Meanwhile, themes in teaching literature were taken up by Frank Whitehead, in Sheffield, who was to pay special attention to patterns of reading, and by Douglas Barnes, at Leeds, who, in a project to be developed in conjunction with NATE, set out to look at 'Children as Readers'. (Publishing details of these projects are given in the bibliography at the end of the chapter.) The Council also took some steps towards developing the teaching of English as a second language. June Derrick was invited to enquire into the 'Teaching of English to Immigrants', an enquiry whose title is indicative of the ways in which questions of English second language teaching and of minority languages were first perceived. In due course, a full project, SCOPE, was initiated. This was directed by June Derrick, with colleagues Josie Levine and Hilary Hester. It was to play an important role in disseminating information about UK's new populations and in developing a distinctive practice in the teaching of English as a Second (rather than Foreign) language. There was relatively little co-ordination at this stage between the English (mother tongue) projects just described and the work of the SCOPE team. Greater co-ordination in the teaching of English as a first and a second language has developed later (Derrick, 1966). Some aims in the original Schools Council Working Paper 3 were never fulfilled. There was the intention, for example, of a major, unifying investigation into development in communications which never materialised. The Council's research review, which identifies where work is needed, makes no reference to American work in psycholinguistics and sociolinguistics, a substantial omission, even at this early stage. Aside from references to the work of Basil Bernstein, then just beginning to make a considerable impact, there was little evidence of sociological (or social) awareness of language and literature. Such choices have been important. The influence of these years has been decisive for later generations and at no other time in the history of English teaching has such a range of fundamental research been so actively prosecuted. The movement towards a common schooling which had arisen in the 1950s was adopted as national policy during the Wilson administrations of the 1960s. Thereafter, schooling was remade from within. The few, pioneering and contested experiments of the early 1950s were successively joined by new schools, later constructions built to accommodate the rising post-war birth rate, and by amalgamations between former grammar and secondary modern schools resulting in fully comprehensive institutions. Coupled with these changes at secondary level, widespread experimentation took place with different patterns of schooling at local level and there
< previous page
page_17
next page >
< previous page
page_18
next page > Page 18
were developments in primary and further education of an equally radical and pioneering kind. For English teachers, one consequence was that the emerging directions of English practice were rarely seen just as a matter of new initiatives in the subject. They formed part of the experience of wider social change. Supported by a climate of opinion in favour of educational change, teachers sought in all parts of the system to create different institutions, to find routes beyond the continuities of class which had still been inscribed in the Butler Act. Correspondingly, the practical concerns of English teaching which became current in this context English content, language, literature, materials, de-streaming, mixed ability teaching, integrated studies, thematic organisation represented much more than a search for 'new methods in the subject', more than a mere 'technology'. Within a commitment to public education and to comprehensive schooling, they were concerns which were made urgent by the need to shape institutions afresh and to make an impact on different local settings. The Walworth school fourth year English course, published by John Dixon, Leslie Stratta and Simon Clements as Reflections in 1963, exemplifies such processes. Walworth was one of the earliest comprehensive schools, with a celebrated, battling, first head teacher, serving a white, working class community in South East London. Finding existing text books inappropriate, the English department invented their own new course, seeking to give currency to pupils' experience and including in this experience of the world, of political, social and humanitarian issues. Reflections ' success changed educational publishing. The course books which followed in its trail, together with the changed anthologies of poetry and prose, all owed to Reflections their publishers' sense of a new and different market. Reflections was a first breakthrough for the new English, but in its specific origins it also bears witness to those lived processes of local change which were, differently, the experience of all teachers at this time (Clements, Dixon & Stratta, 1963). Alongside Reflections, other work in English continued themes which had been begun in the 1950s, stimulated freshly by a climate supportive of curriculum development and research. The work of Dora Pym and Marjorie Hourd in writing was continued in books such as Robert Druce's Eye of Innocence or Alec Clegg's The Excitement of Writing (Druce, 1965; Clegg, 1964). Accompanying Andrew Wilkinson's work on oracy, an influential set of essays on Talking and Writing was edited by James Britton, in which a number of accounts of new practice were included (Britton, 1967). Among a number of works on the teaching of literature, Bolt and Gard's Teaching Fiction in Schools argued strongly for continuity with the traditions of
< previous page
page_18
next page >
< previous page
page_19
next page > Page 19
Leavis and Richards (Bolt & Gard, 1970). Two more general books about English teaching were widely influential: J. Patrick Creber's Sense and Sensitivity (Creber, 1965) and Frank Whitehead's The Disappearing Dais (Whitehead, 1966). Both caught in different ways significant truths about the English teaching which was replacing the practices of the former grammar schools. The new National Association for the Teaching of English had played its part in these events. The Association had had an active role in forming the Schools Council research agenda. The negotiations were conducted by Frank Whitehead, NATE's second chairperson. The style of the association's way of working was established from the first: a journal, a pattern of annual conferences, working groups and an officer of studies, subcommittees to coordinate work at different age levels, an emphasis on the contribution of local branches. In more than 20 years of its existence, NATE has had very little by way of full-time or seconded secretariat. At its best, NATE has stood for a commitment to a rationale in English teaching, explored, constructed and led by teachers in study groups, meetings of local associations, conferences and in the pages of the journal. If it has been able to maintain this emphasis, much is due to the work of these years in forming the association and in developing its distinctive style of operating. The 1960s saw the beginning of funding for experimental work in curriculum, and of the conferences and publishing that this led to. They also saw the beginning of Anglo-American co-operation in the field of English. The month-long Dartmouth seminar, sponsored by both countries, was reported in two books: in the US, H.J. Muller's (1967) The Uses of English aimed at a public readership, and John Dixon's (1967) Growth Through English addressed to the teaching profession. In the UK, the rationale made available through the latter has been widely influential though it has not gone unchallenged. The Dartmouth seminar was not directly responsible for establishing a body of ideas: its importance lies in its being the first step towards a continuing international dialogue through conferences and a small permanent organisation the International Federation for the Teaching of English and more directly, in the fact that many influential thinkers attended the conference and subsequently contributed to the very varied re-thinking of 'subject English' which was current at the time. So far, we have stressed the wide range of political and educational energies drawn together in the early 1960s. Teachers were allocated a role in developing curriculum and examinations. In the new comprehensive schools, it seemed that there might be support for seeking to reconcile egalitarian commitments with a positive role for education in contributing to economic growth. The formation of NATE gave to English teachers a
< previous page
page_19
next page >
< previous page
page_20
next page > Page 20
national forum. The new Schools Council offered opportunities for research and for developing new work. We want now to give more detailed attention to two of the lines of work developed at this time: those of James Britton and Michael Halliday. In selecting these for emphasis, we hope that we will not be thought to be undervaluing others. Our purpose is to illustrate characteristic and different tendencies in the theoretical work deriving from this period. Britton asked philosophical and developmental rather than critical questions about literature and his central questions are those within an epistemological orientation to be found also in Cassirer and Langer. These ask what is distinctive about the nature of art and literature within the kinds of knowledge open to human beings, hence (also) how are human beings able to know things and what is distinctive about literature as a form of human knowing. The ancestry of such questions is in Kantian and neo-Kantian tradition. Posed freshly by Britton, they challenged many assumptions about the teaching of both language and literature which were current and provided the shape of a rationale for English which has been powerfully influential. One effect of such questions is to interrupt versions of literary study in which an equation is made between reading literature and critical reading and therefore to question the version of this in the Richards/Leavis tradition. Another is to locate the rationale for language work, not in language development as such, but in language's contribution to the formation of mind. Britton made salient for the conceptualisation of English teaching and the theoretical orchestration of different kinds of English work a discussion of human mind. The notion of Spectator role (originating earlier and developed differently by D.W. Harding), gave to the English teacher one half of the work in the development of mind and by extension sees the rest of human knowledge as but collectively and correspondingly equal in importance knowing in the participant role. If there is a problem in such an account of the mind and its different realms of knowledge it is not that of underestimating the importance of literature. Far from being merely idiosyncratic, some such emphasis on the 'spectator' nature of art and literature is, on the contrary, within a mainstream of aesthetic tradition and is paralleled by similar accounts by D.W. Harding and Louise Rosenblatt in literary criticism and by Oakeshott and Langer among contemporary philosophers. In Britton's work the notion is given a specifically educational emphasis. It serves to foreground a distinctive set of questions which are important both for teaching and for explanatory theory. For example: what is distinctive about literature, what is characteristic of our manner of reading literary works, what is common to the processes of reading and writing
< previous page
page_20
next page >
< previous page
page_21
next page > Page 21
literature, how is reading related to evaluation and criticism. Also, because literature is explained within an account of thinking and knowing, within a 'role' taken up by mind, product is not separated from process, indeed the relation between them is offered as the central matter to understand. The creation of a literary work was seen by Britton as on a continuum with other reflective activities (gossip, going over experience) which are 'like literature' in nature but which do not necessarily issue in public and created form. It is this aspect of the way in which Britton has employed the notion of Spectator role which has seemed to some most questionable, as if he were regarding gossip and art as equivalent or seeking to undermine claims for the value to be gained from reading literature. However, to seek to establish a connection between art and other manifestations of mind is certainly not without precedent within the tradition of this form of explanation. Even more to the point, perhaps, an explanation of this sort seems a productive first step for thinking educationally about literature. The link which was made by Britton between language and literature should be understood against the background of this concern for the bases for human mind and for human knowledge. Literature is considered in Britton's theoretical work as part of what human beings have derived from the capacities which they have been afforded through language. It is not represented just as one particular language use. We stress the generality of the account, because terms like 'language' and 'use' are difficult and ambiguous and because the general position needs to be grasped if the subordinate concepts are to be understood. Britton does not mean just that (e.g.) poets use language, trivially true though that may be. Nor does he mean just that literature represents a use of language developed in our culture, which is only half a truth and is certainly reductive. Such versions of the connection between language and literature miss the orientation of the theoretical problem which Britton was confronting. Rather, the problem of the connection is posed by Britton at an epistemological level, and, following Cassirer and Langer, he finds the key to its solution in the human capacity for symbol. Symbol, in Britton's thought, forms the basis for human knowing and the capacity for symbolising is especially characteristic of the human mind. Language is the most developed form of symbolising. Participant and Spectator are differentiated roles which may be taken toward experience. Thus, language and literature are both connected and differentiated within a more fundamental theory of human development. But it might be best to understand Britton's theory of language as one version of an account which has been deeply influenced by an understanding of the power of literature. In the theorisation of English work in post-war years, a crucial division
< previous page
page_21
next page >
< previous page
page_22
next page > Page 22
seems to us to lie between an approach to language from linguistics, in which system is stressed and in which literature is regarded as a special form of language use, and an approach to language which arises from a recognition of language's role in construing experience, and which leads to an account of both language and literature in which it is role, rather than system, which is made central. Britton's work gave an impetus to the definition of English as a subject which sought to heal existing divisions and also allowed connections to be made with the new work in psychology and linguistics. English was established by it as anti-behavioural in its psychology, concerned with the role of language and literature in children's development and seeking to harmonise in practice the potential divisions in the subject between language use and language study. Above all, for us, the developmental emphasis has been crucial. Through it, generations of teachers have approached English not just as a subject but as a set of processes in children's learning, focusing less on the abstract questions of what is to be taught than on the capacities which children have and on how teachers can help these to be realised. Britton helped English teachers to be advocates rather than authorities and the cast of mind has been distinctive. An alternative project to Britton's was that of Michael Halliday. Concerned equally with linguistics and with English teaching, Halliday's work is comparable to Britton's in scale, though different in direction. There are some moves in common (for example, an emphasis on functional variety in language). However, their projects are essentially different, emerging at different, even rival, points on the compass of different moves open to those seeking to develop work in English in the early 1960s. Halliday's work arises from a history which is as much within linguistics as within English teaching. His work may be seen as part of the movement to establish contemporary studies of language in the universities during the 1950s and 1960s as a discipline, sometimes uneasily accommodated within English departments, sometimes in a separate department of Linguistics, to accompany literature in English studies. In acknowledged orientation and in occupying the post of Professor of General Linguistics at University College, London, Halliday continued and developed an established Firthian tradition of thought about language. He was also among the leaders of a new concern for applied linguistics and for the involvement of linguistics in education. For the decade between 1961 and 1971, Halliday's interests in linguistics and the teaching of English were closely intertwined through the Programme in Linguistics and English Teaching, sponsored at different
< previous page
page_22
next page >
< previous page
page_23
next page > Page 23
times by the Schools Council and by the Nuffield Foundation. Subsequently, this work has been continued in successive volumes written for teachers, some by Halliday himself, published in the Explorations in Language series (Arnold) and edited by his former collaborators, Peter Doughty and Geoffrey Thornton. Halliday's theoretical interests in language have been concerned equally with phonology and with more general linguistics and it is the latter which have been especially influential both in the intellectual climate surrounding English teaching and specifically in the perspectives made available to teachers through Schools Council and Nuffield programmes. Here we stress points which have been distinctive in Halliday's general linguistics since it is his influence at this theoretical, rather than applied, level of understanding which, despite the development of language study materials for schools, has been most important for the development of English teaching practice. As it has developed, Halliday's work has sought to link structural choices within grammar to function and to an underlying account of language as a social semiotic. The systemic grammar, developed by Halliday, rests on a social theory of language. As a commentator from within language teaching, William Currie, writes in the early 1970s: 'Fundamentally, a systemic grammar is concerned with the networks of systems, or choice options, which could be said to underlie an utterance. On the one hand we have an observed text (or a text which could have been spoken appropriately by a native speaker) and on the other we have a rationalisation of what might be said to be its underlying grammar in terms of the path through grammar systems such as transitivity, mood or theme by which the utterance is realised. When we look at a written text, or listen to a spoken one examining its surface structure as it were, (which is one stratum of text) we have observable series of elements. We could bracket these elements, label them at will. For example we could note ''noun + verb + noun" in a clause. But at a deeper level we could discover relationships, dependencies and the functionally important bonds between elements which encode speaker meaning and attitude. All of these relationships, deep down in the grammar, are in systems of choices available to the user. Taken far enough, this can become a sociolinguistic operation. Under an observed utterance lie networks of choices the grammar systems of the language; behind or prior to these we might describe the network of relationships which exist in society which in turn give rise to the need to steer an utterance through appropriate channels of dependencies to
< previous page
page_23
next page >
< previous page
page_24
next page > Page 24
be realised at the surface as a meaningful, effective sentence, clause, phrase, etc. . . .' (Currie, 1973) Whatever the technicalities of the grammar (and it has since been developed into a fully articulated apparatus by Halliday himself and by other linguists in this tradition: Hudson, 1971; Berry, 1975), the importance of this position must be seen against the background of the post-Bloomfieldian developments in theoretical linguistics in the 1950s and 1960s. Halliday's retention of the Firthian stress on language-in-context and on the relevance to analysis of non-language features of the context of situation was anti-behaviourist in its resistance to reducing language to discrete elements, abstracted from situation and from use an emphasis which was shared, as we have seen, by Britton and his collaborators. Distinctively, the stress on the social nature of language served also as a check on the idealism of Chomskyan emphases, in which competence had been separated from performance and the structures underlying language located not in society but in mind, an idealism which was powerfully influential in the 1960s on both sides of the Atlantic. Thus, the stress on 'Language as a Social Semiotic ',the title of a volume of essays collected by Halliday in the mid 1970s, was present in the first outlines of systemic grammar and it has been a stress which has grown more pronounced, with the emergence of other sociolinguistic critiques of Chomskyan versions of competence and perhaps also in connection with the (mutual) influence of Basil Bernstein's work on language and cultural codes. Without following Halliday's writings in anything like their entirety, it is enough to note here the social orientation of the theory but also the relatively formal and schematic way in which society is introduced as a level in analysis. This formality at the sociological and historical level, though we cannot here develop the point, also underlies the account of functions and, further, of registers, two of the analyses contributed by Halliday which have been most influential in educational thinking. While we have emphasised so far Halliday's contributions to the general theory of language and hence, indirectly, to the emergence in the 1960s of functional approaches to language and to English teaching, we must note also the more specific contributions which have been made by the project in Linguistics and English Teaching and by Halliday's collaborators in this. A list will have to suffice. Within this project an innovatory approach to initial teaching of reading was developed (Breakthrough to Literacy) and also materials directed towards language study in school and college (Language in Use). (See MacKay et al., 1970; Doughty et al., 1972b.) Subsequently, as noted, Peter Doughty and Geoffrey Thornton have continued to make available to teachers linguistic perspectives on language
< previous page
page_24
next page >
< previous page
page_25
next page > Page 25
in education and in this they have been joined by further generations of linguists, among whom might be included David Crystal, Pam Czierniewska and Michael Stubbs (see Doughty et al., 1972a; Crystal, 1976; Gannon & Czierniewska, 1980; Stubbs, 1987). In our view, the development of these theoretical projects in the 1960s was of crucial importance for English teaching. Of course, they did not settle matters for ever and left questions for the future. But the effect of this sustained period of thinking about issues in language in education theorised the work of teachers in the only sense which matters. Teachers' practice became a theoretical practice for a significant number, and classrooms the site for critical questions of value and theory. It was a development which was supported by the relations between teachers which were established through NATE, through Schools Council curriculum projects and through the traditions already established among English teachers by the pioneering work of the Use of English groups. Perhaps, also, language as a centre of attention, rather than a particular curriculum content, entailed a wide ranging and distinctive theoretical orientation. Whatever the reasons, and with all allowances made for over-emphasis and doubts about the extent of permeation, it is right to look back on the 1960s as a period of rich development for English teaching in which the work of a post-war generation of teachers and educators came properly of age. As the 1960s gave way to the 1970s, the wider political context of education changed. Poverty had been 'rediscovered', as Coates and Silburn put it, writing of the Forgotten Englishmen in 1968 (Coates & Silburn, 1968). They had in mind their own study of a Nottingham housing estate, together with the reports of Peter Townsend's Child Poverty Action Group, the Plowden Report's arguments about social deprivation and educational priority and the critical commentary by sociologists on the actual achievements in ending inequality of the welfare state. As well as social criticism, which now emerged more publicly, two other considerations made an impact in the closing years of the decade. There were already signs of economic recession. And, in 1968, many western countries experienced movements which made a revolutionary challenge to existing governments. Balanced against the action and arguments developing on the left there seemed new urgencies for retrenchment, reduction of public expenditure and social control. A new Conservative government was returned in 1970. NATE held its conference on the 'Language of Failure' against this background. At the same time, a critique developed of deprivationist versions of the culture of poverty on both sides of the Atlantic. Theories of language deprivation, 'blaming the victim', had been central in the compensatory programmes of both the US and the UK. These were identified for
< previous page
page_25
next page >
< previous page
page_26
next page > Page 26
criticism by the sociolinguists William Labov and Roger Shuy in the US and by Harold Rosen, a colleague of James Britton's and Nancy Martin's at the London Institute of Education, in UK (Labov, 1972; Rosen, 1972). These critiques helped to dismantle the optimism of the earlier, gradualist consensus of the 1960s. They also contributed to a new appreciation of linguistic and cultural diversity in both countries, which was to emerge more fully in the 1970s. The consensus was being dismantled, anyway, not from a sharper sense of inequality but from a different pressure from the right to abandon commitment to a comprehensive system. More fundamentally still, the whole set of post-war assumptions and policies about the welfare state was being rethought. The publication of one more important collection of ideas fittingly spans the 1960s and the 1970s. Language, the Learner and the School (Barnes et al., 1969) reflected much that had been achieved and at the same time indicated directions in which the new perspectives in English teaching might develop. The book arose from a conference of the local London Association for the Teaching of English. Included in it were analyses of classroom talk by Douglas Barnes and James Britton. In a final section, Harold Rosen, reporting the ideas which had inspired the conference, puts the case for language as an aspect of learning across the curriculum as a whole. This powerful idea was to become a key conception for the future and reflects the confidence which had been established among English teachers in the 1960s (Barnes et al., 1969). But by then battle of a different kind was being joined. The new Conservative government included in its political composition strands of opinion very different from the earlier consensual politics of Edward Boyle, strands which had already been made apparent by the Black Papers. An international conference of English teachers in 1971 questioned the political commitment of its leadership but in this the questions which were raised were only half the matter. English teaching had grown within a commitment to comprehensive education and at a time of expansionist policies for education. What was needed now was analysis of the new urgencies which were emerging on the educational and political right and nobody foresaw the strength of the reaction. The 1970s And Beyond The 1950s and 1960s may have belonged to the educators, but in the 1970s the initiative passed decisively to the politicians. Increasingly, the legacy of hope in the new, comprehensive education service of post-war
< previous page
page_26
next page >
< previous page
page_27
next page > Page 27
years has been remade from the political and educational right. Behind such remaking has lain the impact of economic recession and fears of a longer term decline in Britain's economy. One response has been a concern for vocational and technical education but, also, influencing the form taken by such response, there have re-emerged interests in re-introducing tripartitism and dividedness. Attention to curriculum, to examinations and to vocational training have been used as means of increasing control and direction from central government while at the same time bringing education into line with a market economic strategy. In the achievement of these wider objectives it has been necessary to curb the powers of teachers and to dismantle the professional consensus committed to comprehensive schooling and to educational expansion. Despite the achievement of a major statement about English teaching in the Bullock Report, much effort has had to be expended in defending, not developing, the principles established in earlier years and, in general, teachers have been on the defensive. In English teaching, the substantial achievement was the Bullock Report (1975), which, in its central positions, embodied much of the work of Britton, of linguists such as Halliday, and of the confidence won in everyday classroom teaching. Whatever the strengths of this Report, the circumstances of its commissioning and the fate of its actual outcomes illustrate the conflicts and impossibilities which have surrounded educational work throughout the period. Initiated amidst a concern about standards of literacy which had been orchestrated by the Black Papers in the late 1960s and early 1970s, the generous and balanced positions taken towards a 'Language for Life' represented a substantial reversal for opinion on the right. The ministerial expectations about the report's outcomes had undoubtedly been for a sharply critical mandate. Instead, reading was related in the Report to the total view about language development which was widely current among English teachers and the fears for falling standards were shown to have no basis in evidence. Equally, the wider vision of language in education which had issued in the publication of Language, the Learner and the School and in attention to language across the curriculum was made central and given firm backing. Following publication of the Bullock Report, an agenda might have been set for a generation of English teaching. This is not to imply that the Report was without weaknesses or inconsistencies or compromises on matters of importance. There were plenty. But there was also a central vision of the role of language and literature in education which commanded wide assent among opinion committed to an undivided, common system of education for the majority. With its acceptance of cultural and linguistic variety, the Report had the potential to inform public opinion and to make
< previous page
page_27
next page >
< previous page
page_28
next page > Page 28
current a practice in schools capable of transcending the disabling prestige attaching to narrow and class based versions of Standard English. But in fact the political and financial support were not forthcoming. The Report shared the same fate as other liberal reports in the period; the most recent example would be the Swarm Report on multicultural Britain (HMSO, 1984). No action was taken on its principal recommendations and its central themes were simply ignored. In the silence, memories faded and time made possible a return to the same strategies of engineering a crisis of confidence in educational standards with the same intentions of consolidating a mandate for stronger centralised intervention. Such intervention has been most explicit and most sharp recently, in the Thatcher years, but the dismantling of the educational consensus of the 1950s and 1960s had been begun long before. We have mentioned the Black Papers at the end of the 1960s as the most obvious markers of the growth of a new Tory populism. They advanced no new arguments. Their significance is in their illustration of the ease with which it has proved possible to create a climate from outside education in order that measures can be introduced which would otherwise be perceived as sectional and divisive. It was the move towards comprehensive education which was the principal target of the Black Paper writers. Other targets have followed progressivism, the teaching of grammar, standard English, Humanities, anti-racist education until, in more recent publications, not just a section of teachers (teachers of English, mainly) but a whole educational establishment including inner city local authorities, teacher trainers and the national inspectorate are presented as subverted by a common consensus (Marenbon, 1987). Such ideological warfare has not been trivial, since it has created a climate in which a national consolidation of the achievements of the 1960s has been ruled out and an alternative and in our view divisive framework substituted for the future. Despite such unhelpful movements at policy levels, there has continued to be work in English which has attended to fundamental understandings and principles in the subject. Britton's work was most widely disseminated in the 1970s with the publication of Language and Learning (1970) and the completion of the research into the development of writing abilities. This work was then developed by the project 'Writing across the Curriculum', directed by Nancy Martin, with colleagues Pat D'Arcy, Peter Medway, Brian Newton and Harold Smith (Martin et al., 1976). Halliday's work has been extended by the course Language in Use and by his further writing on language functions and on language development. Subsequently, his work has taken him away from the UK. However, the influence from linguistics has continued and increased, following his early lead.
< previous page
page_28
next page >
< previous page
page_29
next page > Page 29
More generally, themes which were initiated in the 1960s reached fruition later. Principal focuses have been on different uses of language, on process in talking, listening, comprehension, reading and writing and on teaching literature. Some major contributions have been made here. As well, the whole field of language and literature in education has been elaborated under the influence of international developments in linguistics, anthropology, sociology and in cultural and linguistic theory. While we cannot review here this whole field, we give some necessarily selective indications. A number of enquiries have been linked by the aim of identifying a coherent and conceptually powerful scheme of language uses. One hope in this has been to provide a co-ordinating rationale for English work, based on an understanding of the range of different kinds of discourse. Another has been for a tool in describing and promoting language development. These were concerns which were central to the research programme announced by the Schools Council in its early years and to the Dartmouth Seminar. The influence of Growth through English, a first attempt, has already been mentioned (Dixon, 1967). Further attempts at describing language uses were made in the late 1960s and early 1970s. James Britton's account of the expressive function and of its relation to the transactional and poetic was influenced by Roman Jakobson but was distinctively reformulated in terms of the participant and spectator roles (Britton et al., 1975). The account has been widely taken up in considering writing and language more generally and was a powerful influence on the Bullock Committee. Michael Halliday's parallel account of functions has especially influenced work on children's early language (Halliday, 1973, 1975). In particular, it was applied by Joan Tough in a scheme for promoting language development (Tough, 1977). More recently, a further set of categories has been proposed by Andrew Wilkinson, arising from his more recent work and concerned with the reflection in writing of children's cognitive, affective, moral and stylistic development (Wilkinson, 1987 a + b). Sociolinguistic interest in (diatypic) language variety has supported the intentions in these accounts. As will be clear, progress has been in the development of a number of alternatives rather than in the consolidation of any one scheme or approach. But the accounts have helped to generate practice of different kinds and they have served different purposes. While their future articulation is important, there is no doubt that the field is one in which major gains have been made since the 1950s. Some sense of range and connection in use has been a necessary complement to the accompanying interest in language processes. Awareness of the role of talk in learning has been a key understanding
< previous page
page_29
next page >
< previous page
page_30
next page > Page 30
in more recent English practice in post-war years. It has led to changes of emphasis in classrooms and has united work at primary, secondary and tertiary levels. It is an awareness which has reflected in part new concentrations in linguistics on spoken before written language. But there have also been educationally oriented formulations. Andrew Wilkinson's work on oracy, begun in the early 1960s, introduced to a wider audience a number of new understandings in linguistics and in the 1970s moved into an applied phase (Wilkinson, 1971). Douglas Barnes's delicate analyses of classroom talk have sustained a generation of English teachers (Barnes, 1976). Taken up, outside the English teaching community, by sociologists interested in classroom interaction, they have also been influential more widely. As well, understandings drawn from psycholinguistics and from studies of language development have entered and supported studies of spoken language. It is some measure of the force of this work that oracy has remained a lively theme into the 1980s. New work is currently under way. The teaching of reading has also been influenced by concentrations on meaning and on active cognition in psycholinguistics and by the work of Don Holdaway and Marie Clay (Holdaway, 1979; Clay, 1972). There has been a long history of attention to the teaching of reading in the UK and the work of Joyce Morris and Elizabeth Goodacre is among the best known (see Morris, 1966; Goodacre, 1967). Within English teaching, Margaret Spencer Meek has played a crucial role in promoting more recent understandings. Her work has drawn on the approaches of Frank Smith and of Ken and Yetta Goodman and has helped to make the work of these theorists available in the UK. Reading figured less strongly than other concerns in the early formulations of language across the curriculum, partly a reflection of the secondary orientation of this early work. Margaret Spencer Meek's focus on 'Achieving Literacy' has bridged the interests of primary and secondary teachers and helped to integrate reading into the concerns of language in education more generally (Meek et al., 1977, 1983). An aspect of this enhanced understanding of reading has been a concern to connect reading adequately to the teaching of literature. Here again, different traditions in primary and secondary education have tended to divide understandings which should, logically, be held together. There has been a vigorous growth of work both at this point of intersection between reading and literature teaching and from a more literary perspective. As well as Margaret Spencer Meek's The Cool Web, we should mention Geoff Fox and Michael Benton's work on children's literature and on teaching literature more generally (Fox & Benton, 1985). Arising from an interest in 16-19 education, John Dixon has been concerned with literary response and with ways of writing about literature. In her book Eccentric
< previous page
page_30
next page >
< previous page
page_31
next page > Page 31
Propositions, Jane Miller has edited a set of accounts of teaching literature at all levels which gives a wide range of examples of contemporary practice (Miller, 1984). In writing, there have been a number of newer accounts offering extensions or alternatives to Britton's Schools Council Project which was mentioned earlier. Andrew Wilkinson's 'Crediton Project' proposed a set of categories of general development and applied these to writing, as we have noted (Wilkinson, 1987a). There have been useful shorter books about writing by Geoffrey Thornton and by Robert Protherough (Thornton, 1980; Protherough, 1983). Alex McLeod and his collaborators have worked in classrooms, with a theory of critical literacy, and paid particular attention to collaborative drafting (McLeod et al., 1983). Myra Barrs, at the Centre for Language in Primary Education, London, has been developing work at primary level (Barrs, 1988). We should mention, too, the interest in writing which has been emerging among descriptive linguists. Catherine Perera's work has offered a useful complement to the concentrations which have been prevalent in English teaching (Perera, 1984). Some important contributions have been made in work which has looked at language at primary, secondary and tertiary levels. At primary, Connie and Harold Rosen's explorations of good practice, for a Schools Council Project, is still widely read for its sensitive documentation and powerful commentary (Rosen & Rosen, 1973). It is interesting to set this alongside Michael Armstrong's fascinating accounts of children learning in his Closely Observed Children (Armstrong, 1980). At secondary level, Peter Medway has reached teachers everywhere with his account of an innovative course intended to help young learners achieve autonomy, Finding a Language (Medway, 1980). Useful and stimulating books for English teachers have been written by Anthony Adams, Derrick Sharp and David Jackson though such a catch-all comment does them less than justice (Adams, 1974; Sharp, 1980; Jackson, 1987). Mike Torbe has continued to promote good practices in language across the curriculum in his work in Coventry and in his writing (Torbe, 1980, Torbe & Medway, 1981). Recently Dorothy and Douglas Barnes have researched different traditions in English teaching and presented a trenchant account of contemporary practice (Barnes & Barnes, 1984). At tertiary level, John Dixon's report of another Schools Council Project, 'English 16-19', usefully tackles relations between courses in Sixth Forms and those in Polytechnics. The central concerns of researchers in English in post-war years have been with universal understandings about language. They have paid particular attention to developing a general picture of language and learning and of language processes. Cultural and linguistic differences have been second-
< previous page
page_31
next page >
< previous page
page_32
next page > Page 32
ary considerations. It was a further step to put difference, cultural conflict, diversity of linguistic repertoires at the centre of the picture. For many English teachers, during the 1970s, there took place a profound intellectual shift. This was towards an explicit recognition of linguistic and cultural diversity as at the heart of English teaching, not just an additional consideration or a modification required in areas with high concentrations of minority populations. During the 1970s, it became clear that adjustment was required to a curriculum which had been conceived within assumptions of cultural and linguistic homogeneity. It was necessary to scrutinise instruction and materials for linguistic and ethnocentric bias. Increased provision for community language instruction and for the teaching of English as a second language was also needed. As well, the position of vernaculars and dialects in relation to standard English, questions of gender and social class, of cultural and linguistic difference, suggested the need for a fundamental realignment both of practice and of English teaching's traditional theoretical concerns. Where schools and colleges re-thought English in terms of linguistic and cultural diversity, there were new connections to be made between English, the teaching of English as a second language and the teaching of modern languages. These were made more easily possible as modern languages was redefined to include not just a few specially placed European languages (French, German, Spanish) but a range of other languages (Arabic, Hindi, Gujerati, Urdu, Greek, Turkish) now spoken in the UK as well as in their countries of origin. A new content to language awareness as an educational factor became possible against this background. There were implications for revising public examining, especially with regard to the numbers of languages offered for accreditation (Rosen & Burgess, 1980). English second language teaching has had increased attention and there have been growing attempts to co-ordinate traditions in this and in English as a mother tongue. ESL provision has had its own distinctive course of development during the period, as we have noted at intervals in this account. It is a form of provision which has been shaped by special factors in the UK: the arrival of new bilingual communities in the 1950s and 1960s and the reorientation of relatively longstanding traditions of teaching English as a foreign language which was then required. Reviewing the course of development of ESL provision, it is perhaps fair to say that there has been a tendency to think for too long of ESL arrangements as merely temporary (Brumfit et al., 1985; Levine, 1981). The characteristic form of provision in the late 1960s and early 1970s
< previous page
page_32
next page >
< previous page
page_33
next page > Page 33
was through language centres, locally provided. In-school and in-class support increased as this was perceived to be necessary and as the definition of the role of English Second language teaching changed: as earlier, assimilationist assumptions of a short period of adjustment were replaced by a recognition of continuing need for ESL instruction. But, though much increased, provision is still too ad hoc in nature. In-school support tends to be funded separately through Home Office Section 11 grants rather than being a main item on education budgets and is especially vulnerable to cutback. Policy at national level is still short of the realignment in curriculum which is needed. Developments are furthest ahead locally, in urban areas with strong concentrations of bilingual speakers and with local governments committed to improving provision. Within English teaching, Harold Rosen has been among those who have played a significant part in posing the new considerations of diversity. His work has continually been near the frontier of developments in English. As an English teacher at Walworth School in the 1950s he helped to create that tradition which emerged later in Reflections. His work on writing in the 1960s contributed to the new appreciation of variety and he helped to promote one of English teaching's most powerful, post-war conceptions: the aim of a language policy across the curriculum. In the 1970s, his pioneering rejection of deprivationist positions led to the formulation of a new requirement for language policies. This was that they be conceptualised in the light of the specific linguistic and cultural configurations of different areas. Influenced by the work of William Labov, his concentration on the 'language of inner city schools' brought together interests in dialect, bilingualism and social class. The informal research project of that name has reached teachers in many parts of the UK who have been concerned with thinking anew the responsibilities of English teaching in a multicultural society. One more word by way of closure. We have suggested here, we hope, the richness of a continuing tradition. English teaching, since the war, has achieved substantial consensus as to many of its most important themes and significant work has been developed around them. Varying emphases on language or literature are sometimes presented as evidence of division. In fact, as we have suggested, more significant tensions have seemed to us to exist between traditions setting out to theorise language while remaining deeply influenced by the study of literature and traditions, partly derived from applied linguistics or from English foreign or second language teaching, where attention to literature has been less central, though not absent. We have commented on this division in writing about the theoretical projects of the 1960s. In practice, among those teaching English in schools,
< previous page
page_33
next page >
< previous page
page_34
next page > Page 34
it is not the importance of literature which is likely to be most contentious, we suspect. The manner of attention to language, the extent of language study, the teaching of grammar still form the issues where gaps and divisions exist. Despite the findings of the recent Kingman Committee (HMSO, 1988) such issues are unlikely to be settled simply, while their importance remains to their present extent symbolic of wider ideological positions and as embedded in different forms of first degree and English teaching qualification. The failure to act adequately on the findings of the Bullock Report has forfeited more than a decade in which English teaching practice might have been further consolidated. The current attempt by government to remodel the education service by statute (The Education Act, 1988) would require an article in itself to deal with. Here, we can only comment, as far as English is concerned, that a form of intervention which has been so narrowly and sectionally conceived cannot command confidence for the future even if, in practice, English teaching and professional dialogue will no doubt find ways of surviving in the changed circumstances which are coming into being. The new, national curriculum has been conceived without any attempt to grasp the multicultural and multilingual nature of British society. Its core subjects have been linked to a view of testing which is in origin more concerned with supplying a means of guaranteeing accountability of schools and teachers than appropriateness to subject content or pupil development, though there are some signs of modifying this position. Curriculum issues in the public sector have been made subordinate to reorganising the financing of education and to providing for the possibility of a layer of opted-out schools equivalent to those formerly financed by direct grant. Powers have been centralised in the Secretary of State, professional opinion caricatured and bypassed and its role reduced. In this, the government has just been wrong about the means to gaining assent for a common curriculum, about its privileging of private education, about teachers and about the omniscience of the market as a means for developing quality in education. But English teaching has strengths on which to draw while facing an uncertain future. One clear gain in the period which we have been reviewing has been the development of the General Certificate of Secondary Education (GCSE) the common examination at 16+ which has replaced the formerly divided system of General Certificate of Education (GCE) and Certificate of Secondary Education (CSE). As we have commented earlier, change in the public system of examining began in the immediate post-war period with adjustments to the pre-war certificates and issued in the single subject examinations of 'O' and 'A' level. These were intended for some 20 and 10% of the population respectively. The Certificate of Secondary Education
< previous page
page_34
next page >
< previous page
page_35
next page > Page 35
followed in 1966. This introduced the two tier system of public examinations, mistrusted by the public and disliked by teachers. The new General Certificate of Secondary Education, an outcome which represents one of the more curious about-turns of right wing policy and one which has been strongly influenced by teachers, is one important earnest in the years ahead. A second clear benefit has been the development of teachers' centres and, more generally, of teacher focused projects and explorations. We should note that accompanying this, the role of the universities has become more federated, a strand among a range of influences, partly because funding for curriculum research has been successively reduced following the demise of the Schools Council. The decline in research represents a serious retreat which needs to be engaged but at education authority level there have been gains as well as losses. Now English advisers in more than 70 of the 100 or so local authorities have responsibility for development of work in English. The English Centre, in London, has reached teachers everywhere with the quality of its teacher produced materials and of its 'English Magazine'. While unusual in the scope and quality of its work, it serves as one example of what is possible at local level. Neither a consensus among English teachers, nor a transformation of the public examination system, nor a network of local advisers and teachers' centres may have been envisaged quite in their precise form 40 years ago, the date selected for the beginning of the present story. But they are evidence of advances made through the energies which have been offered in UK's decentralised education system in post-war years. In the more centralised system which is presently coming into being, those energies will be manifestly crucial in the classrooms, local areas and professional debates which constitute the real business of teaching and learning and there is every reason to believe that they will survive and prevail. Bibliography ADAMS, ANTHONY 1974, Every English Teacher. Oxford: Oxford University Press. ARMSTRONG, MICHAEL 1980, Closely Observed Children. London: Writers and Readers. BARNES, D. 1976, From Communication to Curriculum. Harmondsworth: Penguin. BARNES, DOROTHY and BARNES, DOUGLAS 1984, Versions of English. London: Heinemann Educational Books. BARNES, D., BRITTON, J. and ROSEN, H. 1969, Language, the Learner and the School. London: Penguin. BARRS, M. 1988, Drawing a Story. In N. MARTIN & M. LIGHTFOOT (eds), The Word for Teaching is Learning. London: Heinemann. BERRY, M. 1975, Introduction to Systemic Linguistics, Vol I: Structures and Systems. Oxford: Batsford.
< previous page
page_35
next page >
< previous page
page_36
next page > Page 36
BOLT, S. and CARD, R. 1970, Teaching Fiction in Schools. London: Hutchinson. BRITTON, J. (ed.) 1967, Talking and Writing. London: Methuen. 1970, Language and Learning. London: Allen Lane. 1982, Prospect and Retrospect: Selected Essays of James Britton (ed. G. Pradl). London: Heinemann. BRITTON, J., BURGESS, T., MARTIN, N., MCLEOD, A. and ROSEN, H. 1975, The Development of Writing Abilities, 11-18. London: Macmillan. BRUMFIT, C., ELLIS, R. and LEVINE, J. 1985, ESL in the UK: Educational & Linguistic Perspectives. ELT document 121. Oxford: Pergamon. CLAY, M. 1972, The Early Detection of Reading Difficulties. London: Heinemann. CLEGG, A. 1964, The Excitement of Writing. London: Chatto & Windus. CLEMENTS, S., DIXON, J. and STRATTA, L. (eds) 1963, Reflections: An English Course for Students. Oxford: O.U.P. COATES, K., and SILBURN, R. 1968, Poverty: the Forgotten Englishmen. London: Penguin. CREBER, J. P. 1965, Sense and Sensitivity. London: U.L.P. CRYSTAL, D. 1976, Child Language, Learning & Linguistics. London: Arnold. CURRIE, W. 1973, New Directions in Teaching English Language. London: Longman. DERRICK, J. 1966, Teaching English to Immigrants. London: Longman. DIXON, J. 1967, Growth through English. Oxford: OUP. DIXON, JOHN 1979, Education 16-49. Basingstoke: Macmillan Education. DOUGHTY, P., PEARCE, J., THORNTON, G. 1972a, Exploring Language. London: Arnold. 1972b, Language in Use. London: Arnold. DRUCE, R. 1965, Eye of Innocence. London: Brockhampton. FOX, G. and BENTON, M. 1985, Teaching Literature, Nine to Fourteen. Oxford: OUP. GANNON, P. and CZIERNIEWSKA, P. 1980, Using Linguistics, An Educational Focus. London: Arnold. GOODACRE, E.J. 1967, Reading in Infant Classes. London: NFER. HALLIDAY, M. 1973, Explorations in the Functions of Language. London: Arnold. 1975, Learning How to Mean. London: Arnold. 1987, Language as Social Semiotic. London: Arnold. 1985, An Introduction to Functional Grammar. London: Arnold. HALLIDAY, M., MCINTOSH, A. and STEVENS, P., 1964, The Linguistic Sciences and Language Teaching. London: Arnold. HOLBROOK, D. 1961, English for Maturity. Cambridge: CUP. HOLDAWAY, D. 1979, Foundations of Literacy. Sydney: Ashton Scholastic. HOURD, M. 1949, The Education of the Poetic Spirit. London: Heinemann. HUDSON, R. 1971, English Complex Sentences: An Introduction to Systemic Grammar. Amsterdam: North Holland. JACKSON, DAVID 1987, Continuity in Secondary English. London: Methuen. LABOV, W. 1972, Language in the Inner City: Studies in the Black English Vernacular. Philadelphia: University of Philadelphia Press. LEVINE, J. 1981, Developing Pedagogies in Multilingual Classrooms, English Education, 13, 3. MACKAY, D., THOMPSON, B. and SCHANS, P. 1970, Breakthrough to Literacy. London: Longman/Schools Council.
< previous page
page_36
next page >
< previous page
page_37
next page > Page 37
MARENBON, J. 1987, English Our English. London: Centre for Policy Studies. MARTIN, N. 1983, Mostly about Writing. New Jersey: Heinemann. MARTIN, N., D'ARCY, P., NEWTON, B. and PARKER, R. 1976, Writing & Learning Across the Curriculum. London: Ward Lock. MCLEOD, A., HARDCASTLE J., MELLOR, B., RICHMOND, J. and SAVVA, H. 1983, Growth, community & control in secondary school writers. In B. KROLL & G. Wells (eds), Explorations in the Development of Writing. Chichester: Wiley & Sons. MEDWAY, PETER 1980, Finding a Language. London: Writers and Readers. MEEK, M., WARLOW, A. and BARTON, G. (eds) 1977, The Cool Web. Oxford: The Bodley Head. MEEK, M., ARMSTRONG, S., AUSTERFIELD, V., GRAHAM, J. and PLACKETT, E. 1983, Achieving Literacy. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul. MILLER, J. (ed.) 1984, Eccentric Propositions. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul. MORRIS, J.M. 1966, Standards in Reading. London: NFER. MULLER, H.J. 1967, The Uses of English. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston. PERERA, K. 1984, Children's Writing and Reading. Oxford: Blackwell. PROTHEROUGH, R. 1983, Encouraging Writing. London: Methuen. PYM, D. 1956, Free Writing. London: ULP. ROSEN, C. and ROSEN, H. 1973, The Language of Primary School Children. London: Penguin. ROSEN, H. 1972, Language & Class. Bristol: Falling Wall Press. ROSEN, H. and BURGESS, T. 1980, The Languages & Dialects of London Schoolchildren. London: Ward Lock. SHARP, DERRICK 1980, English at School: The Wood and the Trees. Oxford: Pergamon. STUBBS, M. 1987, Educational Linguistics. Oxford: Blackwell. THORNTON, G. 1980, Teaching Writing. London: Arnold. TORBE, MIKE (ed.) 1980, Language Policies in Action. London: Ward Lock. TORBE, MIKE and MEDWAY, PETER 1981, The Climate for Learning. London: Ward Lock Educational. TOUGH, J. 1977, Tire Development of Meaning. London: Allen & Unwin. WHITEHEAD, F. 1966, Tire Disappearing Dais. London: Chatto. WHITEHEAD, F., COPLY, A.C. and MADDREN, W. 1974, Children's Reading Interests. London: The Schools Council. WILKINSON, A. 1968, The Implications of Oracy, Educational Review 20 (2). 1971, The Foundations of Language. Oxford: OUP. 1987a, The Writing of Writing. Milton Keynes: Open University Press. 1987b, The Quality of Language, English in Education 21 (2). Reports 1954: Language, HMSO. 1959: 15-18 (The Crowther Report), HMSO. 1963: Secondary Schools Examination Council: Final Report, HMSO. 1964: Half our Future (The Newsome Report), HMSO. 1965: Working Paper No.3: English: Schools Council, HMSO. 1975: A Language for Life (The Bullock Report), HMSO.
< previous page
page_37
next page >
< previous page
page_38
next page > Page 38
1984: Education for All (The Swann Report), HMSO. 1985: English 5-16, HMSO. 1988: Report of the Committee of Inquiry into the Teaching of English Language (The Kingman Report), HMSO.
< previous page
page_38
next page >
< previous page
page_39
next page > Page 39
2 The Growth Of Accountability And The Accountability Of Growth: Secondary School English Teaching In Post-War Scotland David Northcroft 1945-65: Tradition And The Rhetoric Of Change The 1947 'Report of the Advisory Council on Education in Scotland on Secondary Education' is a notable document. Three-and-a-half years of enquiry, 155 witnesses and 884 clauses of exposition culminate in the grand recommendation of a pattern of education for the country's 12 to 18-year-olds whose actualisation is only now, 40 years later, taking place and that with practical difficulty and in an atmosphere of professional uncertainty and industrial unrest. But here, barely 18 months after VE Day, was a public report that totally committed itself to the ideal of full secondary school courses for all, courses dedicated to the furtherance of individual achievement as evaluated by a system of internal assessment. A network of common 'omnibus' schools, it urged, should replace the contemporary divisive arrangement of pupils into the 'senior' and 'junior' establishments which meant that the great majority were being condemned to a brief two or three years in the latter where, since they were excluded from national certification, there could be no assurance of any coherently structured courses nor recognised record of attainment to attest to any personal progress that might have been made. 1 English, according to the Report, was to occupy a very special place in
< previous page
page_39
next page >
< previous page
page_40
next page > Page 40
its progressive new scheme of things: it was roundly declared to be not only the most important single subject in the curriculum but the very force whose humanising power could infuse the pupil's secondary school career with a sense of meaningful personal experience and so ensure his development into the articulate assured citizenship required by the post-war world. It was recognised, however, that to carry this effect, the school subject would have to be reformed away from a practice that had hitherto been preoccupied with a narrowly academic concern for stylised essay writing, latinate grammar exercises and a note-derived scholasticism in literature. It was a regenerated English, in which pupils could write about their own experiences, develop the power of speech and read within its rich literature about matters of individual concern, that would provide the basis for the new secondary courses. In this way the 1947 Report established a view of the subject as a 'field of human endeavour rather than a body of ordered knowledge' (para 128), a dedication to the growth of personal language as vitalised by the nourishing force of literature that Scotland's English teachers have been striving to give practical classroom expression to ever since. The SAC Report was enlightened, vigorous and eloquent; it was greeted with enthusiasm and it met with widespread acclaim. It was also totally ignored by the one body which then and always mattered the central authority of the Scottish Education Department. The 1947 document was to have no visible effect on either the structure or the conduct of an English teaching which was left to continue the way it had found it for the next 20 years. This disparity between the Report's message and the executive's indifference to its implementation tells us much about the reality of English teaching in Scotland and its post-war struggle towards the enactment of a common course founded on the enabling power of language and committed to the development of the individual child. Several forces combine to make up that reality, some distinctively Scottish but others representative, albeit in a heightened form, of the conditions which English teachers have had to encounter elsewhere during the last four decades. Although bound politically and economically to England and Wales within the United Kingdom, Scotland has always maintained a separate educational, as well as legal and Church (and football), system so that its schools are set in a surrounding landscape of self-consciously Scottish culture and values, the most honoured feature of which, historically, has been an upholding of the principle of equality of opportunity for all. This ideal is most vividly dramatised in the image of the lad o'pairts, the humble village boy who from whatever so lowly a station and however remote a croft could, given wit and determination, rise up to
< previous page
page_40
next page >
< previous page
page_41
next page > Page 41
gain the schooling that would enable him to graduate in a University system that prided itself on being open to all duly qualified entrants after which he could prosper in the legal system, enter business, serve his country as Governor of a Canadian province or even return to his native heath as village dominie or schoolmaster. 2 Such a picture has, of course, the quality of a myth but if so it has proved to be a compelling one, sufficiently potent to shape national action and to be inferred in the individual careers of many of those who became influential in Scottish education and thus able to help it perpetuate these values of competitive egalitarianism. It was out of such peat-like soil that, as scrutiny of its membership and selection of witnesses reveals, the 1947 Report sprang, although its advocacy of education for personal fulfilment rather than external success does represent modification rather than a straight continuation of a tradition which had up till then preferred to put individualism to the test of a monolithic examination system. It was, indeed, exactly this liberalising impulse, infused no doubt with a generous spirit of post-war reconstructionalism, that weakened the Report's grip on the actualities. Its advocacy, for example, of the common 'omnibus' school for all the nation's pupils represented an idealisation of the existing system in that it was derived from the small town parochial school to be found everywhere in Scotland except in the urban Lowlands where 80% of the population actually happened to live. There schools were divided into the academic 'senior' and the non-academic 'junior' secondaries to which selection was made via a 'control' examination and a system of IQ testing in which Scotland was indeed something of a pioneer.3 Similarly, the enthusiasm for individualised internal assessment could be seen as a profound challenge to a system in which the external examination was valued as the essential guarantee of academic worth. 'Equality' in Scotland, in fact, existed only at the point of entry; 'opportunity' for all really meant for all but the gifted minority the chance to fail. It was the Report's bold radicalism on such crucial issues that would condemn it to a magnificent futility rousingly received by a profession awaiting liberation, indefinitely shelved by the SED as it simply got on with the real Scottish business of inspecting, testing and grading while the enthusiasms of 1947 eventually talked themselves out during that long, unchanging decade, the 1950s.4 The ambivalent reception accorded the 1947 Report showed that effective change in subject teaching would have to wait upon the reform of the structures of a school and examination system that firmly circumscribed the profession's freedom of manoeuvre. To bring that about it would never be enough to convert the teaching majority, especially in a country whose
< previous page
page_41
next page >
< previous page
page_42
next page > Page 42
educational administration was and is so authoritarian in concept and centralist in operation. Scotland is, after all, a small country with a population little more than one half of the London conurbation's. At its base in Edinburgh, the Scottish Education Department can be held immediately responsive to the dictates of the Secretary of State for Scotland and from it, through its corps of Inspectors of Schools (the HMIs), it is able to command an intimate and logically connected system of local county or since the 1975 local government reforms regional and district Directors of Education who preside over the relatively small number of secondary schools (at present a total of less than 450 throughout Scotland) in their areas. Provision for teacher education is also on a correspondingly small scale, being centred on a handful of Colleges of Education whose perceived function at the time of the 1947 Report was accurately summed up in their designation as 'Training Centres', licenced to serve the needs of teacher production rather than to act as centres of curriculum initiative and development. There were in 1947, in fact, no alternative centres of professional interest through which to challenge or to enrich the directives that came from the centre. If as happened the SED decided to ignore the report of an Advisory Council as too progressive or impracticable then there was no other agency in English teaching no professional journal or teachers' organisation, no centre of subject-teaching research or tradition of in-service activity - to campaign for or to experiment with its ideas. The Secondary 'Advisory' Council was revealed as simply that it might well stand as a fine expression of a post-war desire to extend the best of the Scottish individual tradition in education, but it was divorced from any political structure that could give its recommendations effect. While the role of centrist authority has always been crucial in determining the possibilities open to Scottish teachers, it should be realised that what we are witnessing in the immediate post-war years is not so much totalitarian repression as organised inertia. The really remarkable thing about the country's English teaching from the 1930s right up into the 1960s is its sameness. The Inspectorate charged with the welfare of the subject were few in number, tended to be trained in the classics rather than English, and operated a system of ad hoc advice to one school at a time rather than of national investigation; they were content to interpret their remit as the maintenance of standards and the orderly conduct of the status quo. More important than anything they cared to say directly about the subject was the country's one external examination there being no independent examination boards north of the border which the HMI's both administered and marked. This, the 'Leaving Certificate' English paper, was designed for the
< previous page
page_42
next page >
< previous page
page_43
next page > Page 43
senior secondary 17-year-old pupil only, and confronted him with an unvarying format of essay interpretation passage plus analytical questions language exercises literature questions on a range of named classic texts. But from within what could become a comfortably unchanging regimen the individual teacher who had at secondary level to hold a university degree in the subject and was thus highly educated if not well trained could take some freedom to, for example, teach the literary version of his subject that his university career had grounded him in, and to do so, in many memorable cases, with idiosyncratic verve and commitment. What was lacking in the Scotland of 1947 was not so much a simple freedom from authority as an imaginative and energetic exercise of it sufficient to bind together the individual efforts of its all-graduate English teachers and to work out the classroom methodology by which to give them effective shape. In a small country, perhaps, the enactment of liberal ideas can best come about through the enlightened use of the authority vested in a tightly integrated system, but an authority sufficiently broadened by the representation within it of teaching, and of research and development interests, to evoke a wide response and to generate the necessary ideas. This last point has since proved to be especially important: a review of all those factors, that have continued to obstruct Scottish progress towards the final institution of a humanely child-centred version of English teaching, indicates that it is not simply the restrictions of political power that have been significant; there has also been an abiding uncertainty among the profession as to how to go about such a task. And this, in its turn, has reflected the difficulty English teachers have had and perhaps not just in Scotland in defining either the aims or the methodology of their subject in compellingly precise and practical terms so as to satisfy their public and to ensure the effectiveness of their own practice. Once again, the 1947 Report acts as an informative trailer for what was to come, for while its vision is imposing, it manages to say little, all too little, about the teaching approaches necessary for its actualisation. To find root in a hard educational climate, proposals for an English teaching founded on individual development and guided by sensitive internal assessment must be able to furnish convincing demonstration of the means by which practitioners can turn away from the prevailing tradition of uniform subject-transmission towards classroom methods that will indeed draw upon the resources of the pupil and engage him in a learning experience that is at once personally meaningful, progressively self-realising and clearly effective in traditional literacy-producing terms. In this respect, however, the Report can only fall back on a series of
< previous page
page_43
next page >
< previous page
page_44
next page > Page 44
suggestions that merely liberalise at the edges: its hope is that by dropping abstract grammar, by modernising texts and by breaking the classroom silence with lessons in speech skills, all pupils rather than the 'bookish' minority will be able to enjoy their English lessons as a personal satisfaction the source of which is still seen to lie within the subject itself rather than anything the pupil can bring to it. Any sense of an interaction between the two is effectively denied by the Report's suspicion of the contemporary pupil's culture (as 'debased by vulgarisms and corrupted by Hollywood') and most damagingly by its rejection of his own language, which it invites teachers to declare war on as an 'oppressive mass of merely debased and incorrect speech' (paras 277 and 282). It is words such as these that reveal the 1947 Report to be ultimately a somewhat datedly patrician document whose adherence to a tradition of populace-improvement cuts itself off from any possibility of working out the effectively pupil-directed methodology, informed by an understanding of the relevance of the child's own experience and the vitality of his language, appropriate to its progressive intentions. If 'progressive' is indeed what they truly were, for in the end it is difficult to see the Report as anything but civic in its orientation, not so much concerned with the individual himself as the befitting of him for citizenship of the 'free and well-ordered state'. 5 Certainly a document which exhorts its teachers to improve their practice by correcting the inevitably coarse speech of the pupil in 'a gracious and kindly' manner and which can talk quite so unselfconsciously of a need to conduct even the lowliest of their charges into 'the forecourts of the palace of literature' must be, despite the intrinsic decency of its desire to update an old tradition, bemused by the problem of how to engage the demotic energies of the masses in the enterprise of acquiring Standard English and of benefiting from the great 'storehouse of human experience' (para 318) that is deposited in its classic literature. 1965-75: Bulletins, Projects And Personal Growth It was not until the late 1960s that English teachers in Scotland began to develop the capacity to undertake the rigorous self-scrutiny of structure and of method necessary for real progress to be made towards the individualcentred English whose eloquent advocacy they had so admired in 1947. It was change in the educational milieu as a whole that forced the issue: the coming to power in Britain of a socialist government in 1964 precipitated a rapid move towards the institution of a 'comprehensive' school education by which to replace the old secondary divisions, that demanded everywhere
< previous page
page_44
next page >
< previous page
page_45
next page > Page 45
a radical rethinking of the curriculum and the relationships within it between system and pupil. This major reform was accompanied by a spirit of buoyant enthusiasm, a willingness to innovate that was assisted by a pumping into education of money at a higher flow than ever offered before or since. Evidence of expansionism was dramatic: the school population was multiplying as the post-war birth bulge came to maturity, while there was growing, in any case, a popular demand for extended opportunity to gain the qualifications that were seen as necessary to the further acquisition of the higher living standard now expected by all. And to serve these needs, new universities and colleges were chartered so as to recruit fresh energies into a teaching profession where a general loosening of promoted places could now hold out the prospect of early arrival at positions of curriculum power. The need to respond to the complexities of a rapidly growing system persuaded the SED that there would have to be a devolution of its powers, that the traditional, personalised authority of St. Andrews House, Edinburgh, would have to broaden the base of its operation and to seek out professional advice on how to proceed with the new structures and the new courses that were now required. The result was that within a year of the promulgation of Circular 600 enforcing local authorities to draw up plans for comprehensivisation of schools, the Secretary of State established in 1966 a Central Committee on the curriculum as an advisory body in which school representatives could join Departmental officers in counselling him on curricular matters. Other changes that occurred in this period were in tune with this move towards the enhancement of a responsible professionalism among teachers the old Teacher Training Colleges were reconstituted as semi-autonomous Colleges of Education with added freedom to undertake research and in-service initiatives, while a General Teaching Council for teachers was established so as to allow them to have a major say in the control over entrance into the profession. And in the regions local authorities were beginning to appoint subject 'advisers' to ensure that everywhere teachers were kept in touch with new educational developments. Out of all these reforms it was, perhaps, the institution of a Central Committee that was to be decisive in initiating necessary change. The 'CCC' was not one body so much as an organisation of interconnected committees which, through a range of subject specialist panels and local offspring groups, offered a coherent strategy by which to involve a very broad spread of teachers in the national formulation of new syllabus ideas. Certainly the English panel acted energetically towards this end: it not only set up study groups and published papers on its own account but also instituted in
< previous page
page_45
next page >
< previous page
page_46
next page > Page 46
Edinburgh the Centre of Information for the Teaching of English to which all English teachers were granted consultational access. It was from this Centre that Scottish teachers were at last given their own English journal as the CITE Newsletters of the early years (the late 1960s) quickly grew into Teaching English, which, under the enlightened editorship of Sydney Smyth, was to attract a range of lively writing and to establish a thoroughgoing review policy that has, since that time, been most influential in giving individual teachers a real sense of belonging to a genuinely professional discipline. The Panel also sponsored various in-service courses, including some very high-profile 'National Courses' designed to introduce an international or at least an England and Wales dimension into the Scottish scene. Most significant of all, however, was the rapid promotion of a multitude of 'Local Development Committees' throughout the land so as to give practically every English teacher in it the chance to contribute to the working out of practical reforms based on ideas coming from the centre. The Scottish system was, however, still small enough for the impact of individual personality, especially from those within an SED Inspectorate that still continued to hold overseeing power, to be felt and here it was fortunate that men of real quality and drive were now coming onto its English operations, most notably HMI's Andrew Chirnside and William Gatherer, the chairman of the first Central Committee English Panel. It was under the latter's vigorous leadership that right from its inception in 1966 the task was undertaken of carrying through nothing less than a complete reform of English practice and to do this by giving its teachers a sense of professional identity and purpose they had hitherto lacked. With dissatisfaction in what quickly came to be termed the 'old' prevalent English of fragmented exercises, stylised academic activity and impersonal language routines, the Panel embarked on a five year publishing plan that was carried through by a series of 'Bulletins' covering all aspects of secondary school work from Literature to Language and inclusive of common course work for 12- and 13-yearolds, as well as suitable activity for the 'early' school leaver (the School Leaving Age was raised to 16 during this period). Between 1967 and 1972 five such papers appeared, 6 each one of which was remarkably consistent in its promulgation of the new pupil-centred philosophy and quite confident in its ability to act as authoritatively seminal texts for in-service and Local Development work. Much hope was invested in the new Bulletin-led English as the effective strategy by which to bring about the long awaited classroom changes. Articles and papers of this time talk of what was happening in explicitly historical terms: one of the leading protagonists of the 1960s movement,
< previous page
page_46
next page >
< previous page
page_47
next page > Page 47
Chief Inspector of Schools Chirnside, was quite emphatic in the contrast he could draw between the 'barren, spartan' 1940s and 1950s and the 'flowering' 1960s in which English teachers were being excitingly confronted with 'Nothing less than the review, reappraisal and. . . . .dismantlement and refurbishing of the subject by which they had lived and the methodology by which they had plied their craft'(Chirnside, 1973). The proposed 'methodology' was squarely based on the notion of pupil involvement: literary texts and language topics were to be selected on grounds of their 'relevance' (key word) to the contemporary child; all the various activities that would make up a renewed English course now widened to include personal writing, talk, media material and 'real-live' social register were to be dynamically organised into centres of interest, or 'projects', 'units' and 'thematic studies', in which pupils could fulfil their imaginative, curious and thoroughly modern selves in the creating of naturalistic dramas such as, for the Secondary 1, Secondary 2 and the young School Leaver, the 'Street Accident' or the 'Devastation of the Highland Village by the Bursting of the Hydro-Electric Dam' (letter-writing, newspaper reports, TV interviews and map-sketching); or, once into the upper school, they could set to with satisfying investigations into 'Love and Marriage'; 'Drug Abuse' and 'Colour Prejudice' among other issues-of-thetime (quality journalism, referential writing, Wole Soyinka, assorted twentieth-century poems and Shakespeare's 'Othello'). By the mid-1970s, however, it was becoming clear that however real the advances towards it were, the results were falling short of a pupil-centred revolution in English teaching. Despite the vigorous lead given from the centre, despite the by now extensive infrastructure of advisers, College of Education Staff, Inspectors of Schools with counselling rather than purely monitorial roles, of Central Committees and Local Development Councils, evidence was coming through that the actual teaching in the schools remained obstinately didactic, desks-in-rows and text-book dominated. An Inspectors' Report on the causes of learning difficulty, 7 for example, showed that the new methods had not really changed the individual child's perception of a curriculum that was still teachingrather than learner-centred, while investigation of the specific effect of the Bulletins on classroom practice concluded that in many cases these methods had not even been tried at all (Cunningham, 1976). The new movement had not, in fact, succeeded in dealing with the reasons that had rendered futile the Secondary Advisory Committee's work 20 years previously. Not at the root, anyway, for while the Bulletin's thinking had become more determinedly pupil-centred, its hold on the reality of the Scottish situation was far from complete. For teachers the real
< previous page
page_47
next page >
< previous page
page_48
next page > Page 48
source of curriculum power remained the national examination system and as long as it continued to operate exclusively through monolithic external examinations aimed only despite the introduction in 1962 of a fourth year 'Ordinary' grade to supplement the traditional fifth year Higher Leaving Certificate at the 'top' 30%, teachers were going to feel little allegiance to the notion of 'common' courses in which the individual pupil or the innovative school-made syllabus must still struggle to find worthwile tangible recognition. And as retrospect began to take over, it was also becoming clearer that the new structure of 'centre' and 'local' committees was not really the exercise in participatory curricular democracy that had been intended. For many, a system in which the centre made all the pronouncements, and thus left the peripheral many to make the practical response, merely confirmed the traditional authoritarianism of the SED; for others the cutting off of teachers from the real Central Committee decision-making and the absence of any programme of evaluative research into the effectiveness of the 'new' methods underlined the endogenous gap between theory and practice in the Scottish educational world (those who can, teach those who can't, write about it). This failure to engage the energies of what was, after all, a highly qualified all-graduate secondary teaching force in the complex problem of making the new approaches work points to the real shortcomings of the 1960s movement. For the methodology as outlined in the Bulletins was scarcely detailed or incisive enough to show these teachers how to create change at the level where it really mattered the individual pupil's experience of 'English'. An excessive confidence had been placed in the potency of planning and selection, in the ability of 'relevant' materials organised into project-shaped sequences, to open up an awareness of the life-communicating properties of literature and language. But too often the 'relevance' represented an adult's perception of the matter and led to a teaching pattern in which 'significance' was seen to be in proportion to the subject's capacity for yielding lines of enquiry to be pursued according to teacher-made schemes of work. And, frequently, the centres of interest themselves proved to be little more than an ingenious reshuffling of all the old reading and writing obligations into 6-week packs of Hiroshima Childhoods, Imaginary Communities and Long Distance Lonelinesses. At the heart of the relevance problem was the issue of language. By the mid-1970s it was becoming evident that the Scottish attempt to make the English syllabus personally meaningful was being conducted at the level of topic rather than language. It was not that the Bulletins had ignored the latter indeed under the influence of HMI Gatherer, a noted authority in
< previous page
page_48
next page >
< previous page
page_49
next page > Page 49
the field of linguistics, that could scarcely be the case but rather that their interests had taken the direction of seeing language as a form of human behaviour in the social sense, to be practised by an invocation of typical everyday contexts hence all that project-work. But this had given rise to an approach which externalised speech and writing into a series of rules-obeying products, the acquisition of which was to be gained through analytical imitation. The understanding of language as a personal process in which the individual makes meaning out of experience by exploring and reshaping it in his own words received at this time little consideration, as did the need for a corresponding methodology that, based on the introduction of the child's own experiencing into the classroom, might have led to the provision of opportunity to utilise his own expressive forms of speech and thus for example to collaborate with others in informal group work or to engage in intimately personal writing in order to make a classroom topic his own. Elsewhere, but most accessibly in England, work was going ahead in this field, but despite the excellent efforts of a lone figure such as Bill Jackson (1973-74) of Hamilton College of Education the arguments relating learning to personal language were slow to penetrate north of the border. It appeared that the newly designed structures of curriculum development were proving to be too tightly controlled, too inward-looking to accommodate fresh thinking or individual initiatives and a limited system of educational research too much the servant of the system to engage the energies of its English teachers in the solving of real learning problems in their own classrooms. The result was that the very ideas, by which their sought-for individual-centred curriculum might have been created, trickled into Scotland too late and too diffuse to catch the wave of institutional reform that began with the moves towards comprehensive education in 1965 only months before the year when their international colleagues at the Dartmouth, USA, Conference were being excited by the possibilities of an English curriculum based on personal growth. 1975-85: Certification For All And The Standardisation Of Growth In the last several years Scotland's secondary school English teachers have found themselves caught up in an onrush of change that has proved to be different from that of the 1960s, not only in volume but also in the controlling of its direction. Although the SED had taken the initiative for reform in that decade, the exercise of its authority had been restricted to the establishing of those conditions that would enable the profession itself,
< previous page
page_49
next page >
< previous page
page_50
next page > Page 50
through the new supporting agencies of the Central Committee and its many Local Development Committees, to make its own interpretations of the subject's purpose and practice. More recent changes have differed in that they have proceeded from a general view of, and scheme for, the Curriculum as a whole, one that has sought to align English along with other 'core' subjects against wider social and individual pupil needs. Their origins are, however, to be found in the 1960s and their expansionist circumstances, for by the mid-1970s it was emerging that the liberalisation of traditional courses that had been permitted then was not going to be sufficient to satisfy the new demands now being made upon secondary schools. The universal establishment of comprehensive education and the complementary raising of the school leaving age to 16 were creating intolerable pressures on the existing national assessment system. Many thousands of late adolescent pupils were discovering that they had been forced to stay on at school to take courses which, in what they considered to be a meaningful sense, did not actually exist since official recognition and in the Scottish tradition that has always meant national certification was still only being given to the narrowly academic Scottish Certificate 'O' Grade and Higher syllabuses, and these were proving to be totally unsuitable for the many who were now being hopefully and hopelessly thrust into them. Accordingly, it was the Scottish Examination Board that in 1973 took the initiative by asking the Secretary of State to make enquiry into the assessment provision for senior pupils, with the result that he appointed the 'Munn Committee' in co-operation with the Central Committee, to enquire into matters of curriculum design and organisation and, with the Examination Board, the 'Dunning Committee' to report on assessment and certificate arrangements for the final two years of the secondary school (14-16 age group) a complementary distribution of responsibility which ensured that any proposals for syllabus reform had to be tied to the nationally controlled examination system, which thus continued to have the decisive influence. Indeed, we can view the whole of the Munn and Dunning machinery as not only an expression of Government concern but also of central power: the establishment of the twin national commissions, the making of representations and the central accumulation of evidence, the procedure of Enquiry, Report and Pronouncement, shaped itself into a characteristically Scottish ritual choreographed so as to culminate in the climactic declaration by the Secretary of State. When they were published in 1977 (SED, 1977a & b), the two reports read in such an interdependent fashion that they automatically became
< previous page
page_50
next page >
< previous page
page_51
next page > Page 51
'Munn-and-Dunning', a curriculum-and-assessment double act that clearly expressed the centrist predilection for a clear national framework by which to articulate and keep under control any changing academic-social concerns. Thus, they proposed, courses should be constructed along well-set subject lines though now legitimated through an epistemologically respectable designation into 'Modes of knowing and interpreting experience' to be offered on a core plus options basis, the latter to occupy no more than minority time. There were to be three syllabus levels 'Credit', 'General' and 'Foundation' to provide for the differentiation of ability across the whole cohort, each one of which was to be nationally assessed and officially certificated. Several years of feasibility study and working party elaboration have since ensued to give us a final course 'Arrangements' that were Secretary of State approved for commencement in Session 1984/85 as the aptly named 'Standard Grade' Syllabus (SED, 1982). This directed that the final two years of compulsory schooling (ages 1416) were to be controlled by sets of 'National Guidelines' that would act as an imperative definition for each subject, of course components and pupil targets of performance, in terms of objectives and levels of competence as set out on a standardised 7-point scale of achievement. Each pupil could now expect to leave school with an individual profile that would constitute a record of course work and attainment but which would also be rationalised into one global grade to be computed through the aggregation of criteria scores. Although the Arrangements were not to be prescriptively detailed at the level of content, in order to allow schools to make up their own implementations according to outline aims-and-objectives, appropriate teacher practice was shaped by an extensive programme of in-service work which during the initial stages was directed by specially appointed 'Field Curriculum Development Officers' and secured by a system of school syllabus moderation answerable to the Examination Board. However, several years of feasibility study lie between the 1977 Reports and these first subject proposals, years in which practical investigatory help was also to be offered through the findings of the 27 research projects that were centrally funded in order to address relevant innovative problems such as the operation of criterion-referencing in assessment and, in English, the teaching of talk, writing and reading skills (SED, 1980). More importantly still, subject teachers were permitted to play a part in their development, albeit under the monitorship of the Secretary of State's HMIs and filtered through 'Joint (Examination Board-Central Committee) Working Parties'. In the early period the HMIs who were entrusted with the devising of the original Guidelines went into partnership with a specially
< previous page
page_51
next page >
< previous page
page_52
next page > Page 52
selected range of 'pilot' schools so as to base later prescriptions on consultation and existing good practice. The kind of English that has emerged from the national requirement to produce a curriculum sufficiently clear in operation and rigorous in objectification, to act as nationally assessment-worthy, practical evidence producing courses for the whole range of the contemporary school population, has therefore come to be tempered in part by the ideas inherited by teachers from the 1960s. The final version of the English Arrangements (SEB, 1987) does represent a genuine attempt to use aims-and-objectives planning to recommend a rounded view of the subject in which personal 'growth and enrichment' stand alongside the obligations of 'competence', thus ensuring a continuing role for literature as well as acknowledging the place of socially useful skills. Similarly, its advocacy of the balanced, inclusive syllabus opens the way for a welcome broadening of activity to extend official status to at last 'talk' and 'listening'. The Arrangements use their necessary categorising to serve liberal intention in other ways as well: their definition of syllabus activity is left at the level of broad language behaviour rather than taken down to specific items, thus giving individual schools the freedom to make their own selection of materials and topics: these language areas are certainly formulated into outcomes but outcomes that are to be derived from the pupil's attempts to fulfil 'purposes', a strategy that opens the way to a teaching-and-learning approach based on formative, in-course assessment acting as meaningful preparation for the external evaluation stage. Encouragement for an experiential learning approach can also be found in the recommendation that grew out of the good practice shown in pilot schools that work continue to be organised into a series of 'units', that is into topic-based clusters of language and literature work activity that carry forward the 1960s Bulletins' enthusiasm but which may now be made more genuinely pupil-centred by an interpretation of 'projects' as contexts for purposeful language activity and not simply as a new portmanteau for old issues and relevant practices. It is by these means that the current Scottish development is attempting to put together a new synthesis in which, notionally at least, language and literature, skills and personal development the English subject aspirations of the earlier post-war period informing the directives of the present may be joined together in one purposeful syllabus enterprise. Unfortunately, further consideration of the way in which this compromise is going to work in practice does appear to suggest that the attempted consensus is in danger of breaking down beneath an inner contradiction of form and content, sufficient to undermine the genuine hopes of those who
< previous page
page_52
next page >
< previous page
page_53
next page > Page 53
are striving to preserve the best of our post-war individualist traditions against the newer demands for objective certainties within public frameworks. There must, for instance, be a fear that the demand for a description of English in terms of accountable teaching targets has led the HMI authors of The Arrangements into the importation of a syllabus design that pursues an aims-and-objectives analysis that will become constrictingly reductive. In the stated scheme of things, for instance, 'growth' and 'enrichment' do appear but only as members of an unexceptional invocation of generalised 'aims' that must quickly yield place to detailed lists of activities based on a dividing up of linguistic behaviour into the four modes of talking, listening, reading and writing which can then be further broken down into sets of specific purposes such as 'stating a point of view' or 'communicating a personal experience'. In this way the destination of precise specifications for teaching objectives is reached, since these 'purposes' once identified may now be categorised into sets of component skills so that, for example, 'talk' competence may become 'conveying information to an audience', mastery of which can be shown to depend on a demonstration of 'organisation' of content and manner of 'delivery' sufficiently 'intelligible' and 'clear' to achieve the overall informative purpose. Assessment may now be calculated by setting individual evidence of effectiveness in these tasks against lists of criteria derived from the required skills; differentiation into grades is worked by arranging such criteria along a 7-point scale of comparative achievement as illustrated by the Examination Board item bank of exemplars for each level. All this makes for a logical flowline account of the business of the English syllabus but one in which, it may be felt, the publicly necessary rationalisation of activity has been attained by turning to a different tradition of English teaching from the one that post-war Scottish teachers of the subject have grown up in. Whatever the shortcomings in practice, the ideals of individual development announced in 1947 and developed in the 1960s assumed a pattern of learning which is essentially personal in nature and which recognise that the attendant values such as 'responsiveness', 'creativity', 'moral awareness' would appear to be inherently unspecifiable in overt instructional terms, both by reason of their fluid, open-ended character and their attachment to an individuality of experience. And now over 20 years later, many would continue to argue for English as a wholeness of experience that has to be nurtured, the living integrity of which cannot be accounted for by facile subcategorisation into so-called 'modes' and 'purposes', nor evaluated by the instrument of targeted criteria. These are fears that will have to be tested against the actual quality of
< previous page
page_53
next page >
< previous page
page_54
next page > Page 54
learning experience offered to the individual pupil by classroom realisation of the new course. Early experience in this respect has not been altogether encouraging, for although English teachers have shown great resourcefulness in devising appropriate materials and topics, once these have been shaped into the requisite unit of work, the Standard Syllabus design has tended to act as a template that has tailored their activity into a turn-by-turn stitching together of skills, purposes, criteria and assessable objectives, in which a bit of 'listening for information' is made to join into some 'writing for special effect' before 'reading for referential meaning' can receive its designated due. Most damaging of all threatens to be the need to satisfy the voracity of a criterion-referenced assessment system which demands to be fed on a sufficiency of ingredients that are nevertheless so fine and purpose-specific as to enable the required accumulations of profiled performance to be served up. Thus will the flexibility and richness of the living language continue to be shredded down into interpretation passages disguised as technical reading taxonomies, into writing exercises to show mastery of the simulated letter of application for jobs that do not actually exist, into newfangled listening tasks based on old-fashioned factual recall and tape-recorded talk performances in solo, group and one-to-one model situations. For these reasons it is doubtful whether the new course will be any more effective than its predecessors in realising the ideals of an individual curriculum that can only be attained by its capacity to engage the pupil's own developing language powers with real learning experiences. Doubtful but not yet certain, for, it must be stressed, we are still at the stage of making projections and there are other more positive ways of reading the likely trends. At this early stage there must, for instance, remain the hope that a national syllabus will act as a genuine guideline that has the power to involve its teachers in a defining of aims and objectives and an integration of assessment requirements with their content planning that will achieve a new sharpness of direction for their teaching, as well as enabling them to share its underlying purposes with their pupils. And indeed, within the Standard framework as explained in the Arrangements, there is plenty of encouragement towards an interactive style of classroom practice to be attained through such formative approaches as writing based on personal drafting and self-evaluation, the use of pupil discussion, investigative reading styles and an imaginative exploitation of a full range of media supplemented by authentically contemporary artefacts and materials. However, to ensure that this is what will happen, a more flexible and teacher-trusting use will have to be made of an assessment requirement which at present threatens to do anything but release the teaching possibilities held within a syllabus design that, with regard to the freedom it permits
< previous page
page_54
next page >
< previous page
page_55
next page > Page 55
teachers in their selection of content, is quite boldly school-based in conception. At present the proportion of assessment allowed to internally derived evidence is no more than 50% 8 and even this is to be managed through a system of grade related criteria 'The GRC' that appears to be no more than an ill-bred hybrid born of a necessity to serve the traditional grading requirements of rational certification as much as to acknowledge individual achievement. It demands that teachers become the producers of performance criteria that can act as not so much an indication of the pupil's progress but as evidence for the aggregating of a score with which he may be labelled in respect of his fellows. Teacher judgement is further to be controlled by a set of externally-produced exemplars, to operate which teachers must become expert in matching pupil attainment against official paradigms, rather than be encouraged to direct their attention to the personal learning needs that a properly used criterion-referencing should diagnose. If the Examination Board grip could be sufficiently relaxed so as to give schools the freedom to produce and as a greater proportion of the net result internal evidence in the form of broad descriptions of actual outcomes the value of which would be assured by the quality of the teaching syllabus that produced it, then assessment could indeed come to have more of a diagnostic than a testing effect. The SEB's lists of criteria could then be offered not as fixed targets but rather as the descriptive means by which sensitive analysis of individual learning needs and a reconsideration of instructional strategy might be made. Such a formative intention would best be satisfied by asking the pupil to review the new demand in the light of present capacity, to work at ways of interpreting fresh experience against existing knowledge; constructive self-knowledge would best come from giving him the chance to work out his own response and solutions, to explore and to evaluate his own progress, to collaborate with his peers in so doing. And all this would form a pattern of teaching-become-learning that would call upon the pupil's own language resources and thus realise the potential for creating learning within him, in a way that the reforms of the 1960s quite failed to do. If this is really to happen in Scotland then teachers must be permitted the chance to think of assessment in educative rather than managerial terms, to act as something other than the administrators of Examination Board procedure. Schools must be allowed to offer internal assessment based on descriptions of actual activity and achievement, made up by those who are in the best position to know, that is the teachers themselves. And despite the fact that this would be a departure from the Scottish tradition of competitive individualism within a system of centralised control, such a
< previous page
page_55
next page >
< previous page
page_56
next page > Page 56
development could then perhaps become the long-awaited fulfilment of the liberal hopes of individual causes for all founded on internal assessment, with which the post-war story began in 1947. Conclusions: Growth, Accountability And State Development Two words bind the story of Scotland's post-war English teaching together, 'growth' and 'accountability'. And if the first expresses the shared philosophy that has inspired its progress from within during that time, the second is the external consideration that has increasingly come to haunt it. Within the profession, agreement as to the essential aims of the subject has been consistent: it is that English makes a unique contribution to the education of the individual because it nourishes his powers of self-expression, a process of Growth which leads us to discover what is in ourselves and our fellows through the humane medium of literature and language creatively used. This was the faith prologued in the 1947 Report's classical advocacy of the treasury of literature as an inheritance by which everyone had the right to acquire the civilised virtues; this was the idealism that was sustained by the romantic enthusiasms of the 1960s which urged development as the natural unfolding of the individual's language-given talents, and that was represented in the Standard Grade's proposals for a syllabus sufficiently inclusive and socially relevant to empower in the pupil a growing capacity to respond to all the circumstances of his life. But, in the post- no more than in the pre-war era, the teachers have never been set free to enact their liberal impulses, for the interplay that must always exist between any public education authority and its servants has been especially pronounced in the small, centralised country of Scotland. A characteristically Calvinist predicament, perhaps, except that the kind of problems that secondary school English teaching here and elsewhere has experienced, in developing the self-understanding and methodological expertise necessary to win a public acceptance of its pupil-centred aspirations, has also been picked out with a sharp enough focus on the well-defined Scottish stage to enable them to be seen by students of recent English teaching with heuristic clarity. What then, as we move towards the end of the century, might be concluded from the Scottish experiences since 1945 of attempting to strike the balance between the competing demands of subject idealism and social necessity, of Growth and Accountability? In Scotland the reforms of the 1960s offered the profession the opportunity and the supporting agencies to develop its own vision of the
< previous page
page_56
next page >
< previous page
page_57
next page > Page 57
subject; since then, however, our English teaching has become constrained by a wider concern for the relevance of the secondary school as a social institution, first of all to the whole range of pupils who have come to stay on in it, but now increasingly to the demands of 'society' as interpreted in the economic terms that have been conditioned by Scotland's share in recent British industrial and employment crises. At a time when teachers are being asked to fashion a testing new Standard curriculum, the Tory Government of the 1980s has given a ruthless cutting edge to the notion of 'accountability' with its doctrinal demand of 'value for money'; this has demonstrated its own valuations by making education throughout the UK the object for cost-cutting, efficiency campaigns at school level while at the same time investing money in 'training' for 16 to 18-year-olds through various schemes which seek to thrust education and job preparation together in courses administered by educational sub-contractors such as the 'Manpower Services Commission' and the 'Training, Vocational and Educational Initiatives'. And in Scotland in particular, a brand new pattern of 16+ instruction has been launched by a partnership of school and 'technical' and 'commercial' colleges combining to offer vocationally orientated courses that come in modularised batches, controlled by nationally-produced 'descriptors' that invariably relegate language to the role of 'communication skills' (SED, 1983). In a country whose education has always been centrally regulated, authority is obviously well placed to shape the system in the required governmental image and the curricular bodies that were developed during the 1960s can quickly become an efficient chain of command, while the tradition of Edinburgh edict-directing ad hoc working party can be relied upon to supply the necessary practical details. That so far in the latest period of reform, 'accountability' has been interpreted as a call upon the subject to explain itself through a clearly structured syllabus and through firm assessment criteria is no reassurance. The fear must be that by using an aims-and-objectives approach controlled by an external examination system, we in Scotland have trapped ourselves in a curriculum model that, because of its very character as an imposition of socially useful targeting in which literature becomes simply another usable (?) language skill along with telephoning and computerese will actually prove to be alien to the free creativity and individual wholeness of experience upon which our concern for personal growth depends. In such a finely-balanced situation, three, inter-related issues cry out for resolution, the first two of which are the necessity to devise an effective methodology based on individual learning needs and characteristics, and the degree of teacher involvement permitted to contribute to its develop-
< previous page
page_57
next page >
< previous page
page_58
next page > Page 58
ment. These, in their turn, lead to a third, underlying consideration the English teachers' capacity to articulate a professional concern for and to pursue an independently-voiced interest in the welfare and the conduct of their own subject. It has, in the first place, become all the more important that Scotland's English teachers continue to work at the devising of a methodology that, while based on personal creativity rather than the imitation of external communication models, will be demonstrably effective in its ability to lead pupils towards a mastery of language in all its applications. One of the lessons of our post-war experience is that if English teachers really are to hold fast to a philosophy of 'Growth' then they will have to show that it is as practicable as it is desirable, that it can be made to be accountable through the sureness of its aims and the clarity of its teaching strategies. If the 1960s in Scotland succeeded in overturning the comfortable old subject-centred methods that assumed that language had to be given to the child before he could be trusted to use it, they did not succeed in replacing it with a child-centred pedagogy that compelled the same degree of public assent. The work from south of the border by such as Douglas Barnes, John Dixon, Harold Rosen and, pre-eminently, James Britton, work which pointed towards an approach based on encouraging natural developmental processes through a language-and-learning logistic, began to enter Scottish teachers' consciousness in the mid-1970s, but it has yet to be defined into a thoroughgoing instructional practice. And this partly because advocacy of a classroom given over to the liberating energies of group talk and expressive writing has lacked conviction, not only in the eyes of both pupil and public but also in those of a university-trained profession who infer within its · apparently methods-free approach a disablement of their teaching expertise and a usurpation of their subject-based authority. If what is now required is the working out of an English syllabus that is neither subject- nor child-bound but is centred on an appreciation of the pupil-as-learner, an appreciation backed by an understanding of his linguistic resources and his communicative needs, then it might be that the research energies released by the Munn and Dunning programme rather than the ingredients of the formal Arrangements package represent the real step forward. Projects such as the Stirling University investigation into methods of writing instruction for 14 to 16year-olds, the work in Edinburgh and Aberdeen Colleges of Education on the application of formative assessment principles in both discussion skills and reading capacities in the same age group (Peacock & Roger, 1984; Francis, 1982; Fyfe & Mitchell, 1985), show how an educational psychologist's interest in learning processes may be allied to a regard for language development that promises to
< previous page
page_58
next page >
< previous page
page_59
next page > Page 59
produce a methodology in which the achievement of set criteria can become a series of creative challenges for both pupil and teacher. But and this is the second major finding that emerges from this postwar account such work must be carried forward in a way that involves all teachers. One of the dangers of history writing is that by concentrating on the spectacular event the dates and the battles it can quite miss the flow of day-to-day experience; while, like kings and presidents, Bulletins and Pilot Schemes may come and go, didactic teaching to serried ranks of secondary school pupils threatens to continue for ever. Latterly, research attention has been paid to classroom styles in the average Scottish comprehensive school (Corrie, Haystead & Zaklukiewicz, 1982) and this has revealed a persistence of teacher-centred work based on purely pragmatic considerations; teachers, it would seem, can become too busy holding the ring between the competing claims of national exams, institutional constraints, resources scarcity and disciplinary routines, too busy, in other words, simply managing the system, to think of problem-solving, enactive or discursive learning alternatives to what they are didactically doing, as anything but remote theory. Even the Munn and Dunning programme's attempts to pilot work through classroom observation quickly became subverted by the demands of a national project that created its own team-like allegiances: accounts given by participant teachers (Eleftheriou, 1985) contrast the early leisurely days of experimentation with the later rush towards decision in which school-based activity gave way to rounds of weekend meetings, task delegation and working party subgroups where the HMI leaders found themselves having to set the agenda, limit the alternatives and hasten individuals towards collective acceptance an executive routine that quite restored the custom of SED decision-making from the centre. And latterly all progress has been held up by the lingering catastrophe in Scotland of an industrial action and a boycott on curriculum development by teachers, who have been responding not only to many years of depressed salaries but also to increased work-loads and to sharpened disciplines in consequence of new Standard Grade courses imposed, as they infer, from without. 9 These are difficulties that could be considered to be the inevitable results of the maintenance into the 1980s of an authoritarian Scottish regime that continues to reduce the professional scope of its teacher employees. But this would be too simple a conclusion, for examination of what progress has been made in English teaching over the last 40 years does reveal some capacity within the SED for enlightened action and, moreover, an exercise of power by individual officials within it that has been genuinely anxious to reconcile governmental demand with the welfare of the subject: indeed, one
< previous page
page_59
next page >
< previous page
page_60
next page > Page 60
of the ironies of the Scottish situation has been the way in which as in the 1960s and in some aspects of the recent Standard programme central authority has acted as the instrument by which to impel liberal progress. An observation that brings us up against the last of the three unresolved issues that could be defined as determinants, not only of the post-war past but also of the future of the subject's teaching in Scotland the limits to professional self-sufficiency in a country where there has never existed any independent organisation of its English teachers. What has and has not happened since 1945 amounts to the playing out of a debate concerning the nature of English teaching and the role that the individual teacher can play in its shaping. And as, over the years, the reports and the edicts from the CCC, from the HMIs and the SED have mounted up, so, too, have the demands on professional expertise and responsibility. Problems concerning the curricular relationship between 'growth' and 'competence', the correct balance between external and school-based assessment, the nature of talk and listening skills, the assimilation of micro-technology into the syllabus, the definition and the development of a truly enabling literacy, are only a few examples of the kind of running concerns which, far from being mere Bulletins' enthusiasms or Standard Grade technicalities, are issues fundamental to the kind of subject we ought to be practising and to our ability to recreate it in effective classroom terms. In these circumstances knowledge is power: more than ever, it has become important for English teachers themselves to establish the leading voice in the defining of their subject, the freedom and the capacity to evaluate new ideas against their own judgements as to the nature of their calling otherwise, such is and has been the way of things in Scotland, control will finally pass into the hands of outside theoreticians and government agencies. Curriculum development has promised to work best in Scotland at those times when, as during the setting up of local development groups in the 1960s or the earliest days of Standard course piloting, the classroom teacher was able to play an active part, was given the time and opportunity to inform himself of new ideas, to define and to work out his own problems in partnership with consultant 'experts' but principally through his own action research and the shared experience of colleagues. The post-war Scottish system, especially as it has been developed over the last ten years, has, potentially at least, become flexible enough to accommodate the desired process of centreout dialogue, has now, with its Advisory Services, Colleges of Education, Central Committee groupings, local and national Resource Centres and the great expansion of school-focused in-service, established a potentially powerful network of collaborative resources ready
< previous page
page_60
next page >
< previous page
page_61
next page > Page 61
to assist in individual staff development as the real centre of curriculum change. The persistent Scottish tradition of centralised, uniform administration does have its dangers, however, for in a small tightly-organised country liberal reform will always depend upon the centre's willingness to use its executive power to promote the values that teachers themselves are ready to campaign for. In a country whose 40 years of post-war experience has shown it to be inexorably moving towards a uniform system of syllabus and assessment to cover all pupils but where unlike the USA, Canada, Australia, New Zealand and England, for example teachers have so far shown little interest in forming themselves into an independent body capable of promoting its own research and publications or of giving a united voice in the defence of that which is most distinctive and precious in their own subject's teaching, we can never be completely secure about the continued welfare of English. The Curriculum Development Service in Edinburgh that has now developed out of the original 1960s Centre of Information for Teachers of English, its periodical Teaching English and the Central Committee English Panel are each of them invaluable teacher-supporting institutions but they are dependent on Government patronage and subject to its reforms and economic rationalisations. For this reason they cannot substitute for the 'Scottish Association of Teachers of English' that alone would give Scotland's teachers a sense of united identity and an assurance of leadership in the development of their own subject's school curriculum as well as a guaranteed membership of IFTE and participation in the international exchange of ideas and experiences so necessary to the sustenance of a strong, free professionalism. More than ever it remains true to say that the state of English teaching in Scotland is as much a matter of unrealised possibilities as it is of problems that have yet to be surmounted. If the Scottish Education Department can now be persuaded, within the clear framework of a national policy of in-service and professional development with all the resources implications that that requires, further to devolve its powers in order to give school English departments the freedom to research their own teaching needs and to make their own informed demands upon the practical network that now exists of central and local committees, of subject advisers, research projects, Colleges and university departments; if schools could thus be permitted to work towards the creation of syllabuses that are both internally devised and assessed; and if the whole operation could be vitalised by the leading contribution of a profession so organised as to be able to act as a partner and as a counterbalance to those who represent the Government's Educational Department . . . then the Scottish system might at least succeed in fully
< previous page
page_61
next page >
< previous page
page_62
next page > Page 62
mobilising the capacities of its highly educated teachers in order finally to establish the individual curriculum for all pupils that has been the professed goal of the nation's English teachers since 1947. Acknowledgement I should like to record my grateful thanks to James Inglis, former Head of the English Department, Jordanhill College of Education, Glasgow, for helpful discussions during my preparation of this study. Mr Inglis is presently engaged on a most valuable research into the history of English teaching in Scotland. Notes To Chapter 2 1. Before the comprehensivisation of the 1960s, Scottish secondary school courses were organised on a selection by examination basis, made at the age of 12 when transfer from the primary school (age 5-12) was effected. Pupils then undertook either the 'academic' 5-year course leading to the Scottish Leaving Certificate (the 'Highers') or, after the raising of the school leaving age in 1947 to 15, the three-year non-certificate course which condemned the majority (approximately two-thirds) right from the age of 12 to the certain prospect of leaving school with no nationally recognised qualifications whatsoever. In the towns these divisions were represented by separate secondary schools the academic 'senior' and the non-certificate 'junior' but in more rural areas both types of course might be offered within the one building, the bilateral or so-called 'omnibus' schools that established for the SAC the model that its authors were now wishing to extend to all areas of the country. How big a change this would have created may be seen from the fact that in the early 1950s Scotland had about 900 secondary schools of which only about 200 (and many of these the smaller country schools) offered the full 5-year Certificate course. 2. For extended accounts of the Scottish tradition in education see Scotland, 1969; Osborne, 1968; Humes & Paterson, 1983. 3. Through the Moray House Tests of Intelligence, developed by Godfrey Thomson, Professor of Education at Edinburgh University and Director of Moray House Training College for Teachers. 4. It is questionable whether the SED really ever did publicly respond to the 1947 Report at all: not till almost five years later did it produce its own statement of position with regard to Secondary schooling and that in a Memorandum (1952) of such bland conservatism as to signal an intention to keep the essential pattern of post-12 education commented upon by the SAC safely intact. Neither this document, nor the 1955 updating Secretary of State's Report, had anything but a few modestly improving suggestions to make about either the nature and conduct of English or the organisational or curricular context in which it was to be taught. The rest was silence. As for the Advisory Committee,
< previous page
page_62
next page >
< previous page
page_63
next page > Page 63
it was gradually allowed to revert to a relatively minor, non-Report-making, quango role till its replacement by the sweeping Central Committee changes of the 1960s when things really did begin to happen. 5. See discussion of 'The Aim of Secondary Education' op. cit. paras 47-68. 6. All published by HMSO, Edinburgh as 'CCE Bulletins': 1) English in the Secondary School: Early Stages 2) The Teaching of Literature 3) English for Young School Leavers 4) English in the Secondary School, Later Stages 5) The Teaching of English Language In addition, a set of working papers, 'Projects in Practice', was also published. 7. In 1964, an Examination Board, which drew upon teachers as well as its own specialist staff for its functions, had been set up to administer the national system, thus ending the era of exclusive Inspectorate control over it. 8. Lately, even this proportion has come under threat since an SEB CCC working party has now (summer 1986) been set up to examine ways of simplifying the Standard Grade assessment procedures. One of the terms of reference is an invitation to consider the necessity of persisting with a large amount of school-based assessment in view of the time-consuming nature of its operation. 9. Since the time of writing summer 1986 the Scottish teachers' campaign for improved pay and conditions referred to here has been resolved. The effects of this dispute have, however, proved to be long-lasting. Beginning with a work- to-rule in 1985, teachers were to boycott all new curriculum development well into 1987, including the introduction of the Standard Grade courses. The result is that Standard Grade English has only become an actuality in a small minority of schools even now (summer 1988). Session 1987/88 has, though, seen much inservice and support work by Regional secondees and a national 'Central Support Group'. Following these preparations, almost all schools will become fully committed to the 'new' courses at last. References CHIRNSIDE, A. 1973, Robert Miller: A Chronicle of his Times. Teaching English Vol. 7, No. 1. CORRIE, M., HAYSTEAD, J. and ZAKLUKIEWICZ, S. 1982, Classroom Management Strategies. Scottish Council for Research in Education. CUNNINGHAM, D.K. 1976, Management of Curriculum Development. Unpublished thesis. Glasgow University. ELEFTHERIOU, M. 1985, School-based developments in foundation English. In S. BROWN & P. MUNN (eds), The Changing Face of Education 14-16: Curriculum and Assessment. London: Heinemann. FRANCIS, E. 1982, Learning to Discuss. Moray House College of Education. FYFE, RONALD and MITCHELL, E. 1985, Reading Strategies and their Assessment. London: NFER. HUMES, W. and PATERSON, H. (eds) 1983, Scottish Culture and Scottish Education 1800-1980. Edinburgh: John Donald.
< previous page
page_63
next page >
< previous page
page_64
next page > Page 64
JACKSON, W.A. 1973-74, Occasional Papers Nos 1, 2 and 3. Hamilton College of Education. OSBORNE, G. 1968, Change in Scottish Education. London: Longman. PEACOCK, C. and ROGER, A. 1984, Success in Writing. Scottish Curriculum Development Service. SCOTLAND, J. 1969, History of Scottish Education, 2 Vols. London: University of London Press. SEB. 1987, Standard Grade Arrangements in English. Edinburgh: SEB. SED. 1977a, The Structure of the Curriculum: The Third and Fourth Years of the Scottish Secondary School. (The Munn Report) Edinburgh: HMSO. 1977b, Assessment for All: Report of the Committee to Review Assessment in the Third and Fourth Years of Secondary Education in Scotland. (The Dunning Report) Edinburgh: HMSO. 1980, The Munn and Dunning Reports: The Government's Development Programme. Edinburgh: HMSO. 1982, The Munn and Dunning Reports: Framework for Decision. Edinburgh: HMSO. 1983, 16-18s in Scotland: An Action Plan. Edinburgh: HMSO. 1978, The Education of Pupils with Learning Difficulties: A Progress Report. Edinburgh: HMSO. 1947, Report of the Advisory Council on Education in Scotland on Secondary Education. Edinburgh: HMSO.
< previous page
page_64
next page >
< previous page
page_65
next page > Page 65
3 The Teaching Of English In Ireland John Killeen and Tom Mullins Major changes in the structure, content and rationale of the teaching of English at both primary and secondary levels took place in Ireland in the 1960s. Attempts were made to reconcile more fully the functional and aesthetic aspects of the teaching of English; to determine the place of the basic skills of reading and writing within an overall framework of the teaching of English; to examine the role of literature in the education of the young, particularly at the post-primary levels where the set literary text occupied a central position in the teaching of English; to provide an educational experience within the teaching of English which ensured that pupils could not only become literate, but literary; that they would not only learn to read but read to learn. In the context of Irish education, major changes were enacted at both primary and post-primary levels. This chapter will deal with the changes which were made, their intended effects and the present condition of the teaching of English. The significance of these changes can best be understood against an historical background. In general, it can be said that more than one hundred years prior to the 1960s, the role of the teaching of English in Irish education veered from one of subservience to one of domination, depending on the prevailing official approach to the place of English in the educational system at the time. The situation of English in schools in Ireland has always been culturally and politically complex. Even today when most people (not all) in the country learn English at home as their first and only language, Irish is still officially recognised by the State as the first official language and all pupils are required to take it at both primary and secondary level; knowledge of Irish is essential for gaining entry to the teaching profession and for obtaining positions in state bodies. It is of fundamental importance,
< previous page
page_65
next page >
< previous page
page_66
next page > Page 66
therefore, in trying to understand the development of English teaching to remember this continuing scenario of linguistic conflicts. English At Primary Level A Backward Look In the course of the nineteenth century, the Irish language was gradually replaced by English as the spoken and written vernacular of the country. From the time of its foundation in 1831, the national school system of primary school education emphasised the importance of English as a medium of school instruction and negated the native Irish language. Children were penalised for their failure to use English in the context of the school. The thrust of education at that time was directed towards the achievement of initial literacy in English and by 1920 English had well and truly triumphed. An important change took place after 1897 when a more humanising and liberal curriculum in English was enshrined in a Revised Programme for National School (1900). For the next two decades the centrality of English was emphasised and it was recommended that a considerable portion of the school day should be devoted to the teaching of English. Schools' Inspectors of that period reported considerable improvement in English as a result of the implementation of the Revised Programme (Coolahan, 1977). With the establishment of the Irish State in 1922, the policy of 'cultural assimilation' which had prevailed in Irish schools since the early part of the nineteenth century was replaced by one of 'cultural nationalism' (Coolahan, 1981). The new policy was based on the tenet that the school should be the prime agent in the revival of the Irish language. The result was that 'for most Irish children, the language of the home (English) was made subordinate in school to the target language (Irish) (de Buitleir, 1985: 3). Subsequent policy decisions of the new government reduced the importance of the position of English. The cultivation of a national tone in the classroom and the fixing of the Irish people in the 'Gaelic mould' became of paramount importance (Ireland, 1933). A new Irish Constitution (Ireland, 1937) declared that the English Language 'is recognised as a second official language'. The status of English in the schools was maintained at a low ebb, and official policy statements were said to be a contributory factor (Coolahan, 1982: 170). The curriculum was curtailed to ensure adherence to the essential features of the official programme. The Department of Education prescribed the syllabus in the different subjects for each standard was compiled and issued annually (de Buitleir, 1985).
< previous page
page_66
next page >
< previous page
page_67
next page > Page 67
In 1929, a Primary School Certificate Examination was introduced on a voluntary basis. This examination, a test of minimum competency, involved tests in Irish, English, Mathematics, History and Geography. In 1943, the examination was made compulsory for all pupils in sixth grade classes, and the examinable subjects were reduced to three, comprising written papers in Irish, English and Mathematics. Many children left school without taking the examination. Investment in Education (Ireland, 1966), a major study of the role of education in Irish life, indicated that in the year 1962/63 approximately 71% of those leaving school did so without obtaining the certificate. The report concluded that, 'The annual emergence of such numbers of young people who apparently have not reached what is commonly considered a minimum level of education can hardly be viewed with equanimity' (Ireland, 1966: 14). The examination was discontinued in 1967. In 1968 free post-primary education for all pupils was introduced, and the school leaving age was raised to 15 in 1972, two decisions which had an important influence on the teaching of English at primary level and significant implications for the teaching of English at post-primary level. In 1985 over 98% of pupils moved on from primary to post-primary education. For a period of 40 years Irish primary school children followed a narrow curriculum based on the three R's and courses in History, Geography, Needlework (for girls) and Manual Instruction (for boys) (Ireland, 1966). The teaching of Irish, English and Mathematics accounted for two thirds of the average weekly timetable. Macnamara (1966) found that more time was given to the teaching of Irish than to the teaching of English. Almost all primary schools followed the same curriculum irrespective of their size or location. The system of education was centrally controlled. Curriculum design was the function of the Department of Education. During the period 1933-1959 the Notes for Teachers which were issued annually by the Department of Education indicated that the official syllabus for the teaching of English was restrictive both in content and tone. For example, the directives for the teaching of English for 1956 which had been issued unchanged for the previous two decades contained the following recommendations for standard six of the primary school: English (a) To read with intelligence a suitable reader or story book. Conversation skills. Explanation, spelling. (b) To memorise 60 lines of poetry. (c) Such elementary portions of grammar as are necessary for the correction of errors made by the pupils in speaking and writing. Easy exercises in analysis.
< previous page
page_67
next page >
< previous page
page_68
next page > Page 68
Written English (a) Dictation. (b) Narrative. Simple description of familiar scenes and incidents. Letter writing (Ireland, 1956). A Council of Education Report (Ireland, 1954) did little to advance the position regarding the teaching of English in the primary schools. The recommendation regarding the teaching of English at secondary level had more substance and will be treated later. In the 1960s the Notes for Teachers reflected a more liberal attitude to the teaching of English with greater emphasis than before on the personal, expressive and aesthetic aspects of the teaching of the subject. A New Dawn In December, 1966 the primary inspectorate of the Department of Education was instructed by the Minister of Education to conduct 'a fundamental examination of primary education'. Early in 1967 a curriculum design team in the Department of Education addressed itself to answering questions relating to the purposes, content and methodology of the primary school curriculum. A steering committee within the primary school inspectorate formulated the rationale for a new curriculum for the primary schools. In 1967/68 a working document was produced and submitted to teachers, managers, associations, colleges of education, universities and other interested bodies for comment. In 1971, the New Curriculum for Irish primary schools was inaugurated. The curriculum guidelines were contained in a bilingual handbook in two volumes (700 pages) which had been prepared by schools' inspectors during 1970/71. The handbook stated that the aims of primary education were: (a) To enable the child to live a full life as a child. (b) To equip him to avail himself of further education so that he may go on to live a full and useful life as an adult in society (Ireland, 1971). The curriculum gave a new importance to the teaching of English in the primary school. No longer could the approach be one of grudging acceptance. The curriculum contained a positive and enthusiastic acknowledgement of the importance of developing a child's mastery of his first language. The oral development of the pupils was to be the basis of their subsequent success in reading and writing. Within a few years national surveys indicated that the teachers per-
< previous page
page_68
next page >
< previous page
page_69
next page > Page 69
ceived the New Curriculum had been implemented to a moderate extent in over 90% of the classes and that there had been considerable improvement in the teaching of English (Conference of Convent Primary Schools in Ireland, 1975; Irish National Teachers' Organisations, 1976, Fontes & Kellaghan, 1977). Irish and English were among the subjects Which had been most affected by the curriculum. The Practice Of English Class readers have been a traditional feature of the teaching of English in Irish primary schools. For many years such readers have been approved by the Department of Education. After the publication of the 1971 curriculum a new series of basal readers was published. In the course of the 1970s there was concern that some of these readers were unsatisfactory with regard to reading difficulty levels and continuity from reader to reader. It was thought desirable to produce a new series of readers which would more adequately meet the varied needs of primary school pupils. An examination of the most widely used basal readers in sixth grades over the past 40 years indicates that such books have altered significantly. The more recent texts contain a higher proportion of illustration. There is also a greater use of story and fantasy material. There are fewer informational excerpts, and less emphasis on moralistic and religious themes. More use is made of contemporary and humorous poems. More attention than heretofore is given to sex stereotyping (Greaney, 1986). The fact that these reading schemes have been accompanied by workbooks which frequently call for routine, banal and mechanical exercises in English is no cause for rejoicing. Many teachers regard such workbooks as essential in providing the language activities which pupils require to further their capacity to use the English language correctly. Unfortunately, their use tends to deflect English teaching from one of its main functions of encouraging pupils to write continuous English in contexts which are meaningful and appropriate. One aspect of the teaching of English which appears to have improved over the past two decades is reading comprehension. In a study of the effects of bilingualism, Macnamara (1966) reported that fifth grade children whose mother tongue was English were inferior to British children by 17 months approximately of English age. Subsequent to this finding, a series of investigations into the reading comprehension of Irish children was conducted in the Dublin region. These studies, which began in 1964 and have been replicated at four or five yearly intervals since, have indicated
< previous page
page_69
next page >
< previous page
page_70
next page > Page 70
significant improvement in reading comprehension and the narrowing of the gap between Irish and British children (Kelly & McGee, 1967; Travers, 1976; Ward, 1982). Recent national tests conducted by Schools Inspectors indicated that this progress has been maintained (Ireland, 1982). Apart from objective evidence of improvement in reading comprehension, both teachers and school principals indicate that there has been an improvement in the teaching of English (Irish National Teachers Organisation, 1976; Fontes & Kellaghan, 1977b). According to Schools Inspectors, improvement in English reading has been more marked than in any other aspect of the school curriculum (Ireland, 1982). However, despite the evidence for improvement in reading comprehension and perceived improvement in other aspects of the teaching of English, there is little room for complacency. There are indications that a sizeable number of primary school pupils are 'poor' readers; approximately one-fifth of the pupils in fifth grades in a number of Dublin schools fell into this category (Killeen, 1984). There is also evidence that about 15% of the pupils completing the primary school programmes are either unable to cope with the everyday demands of reading, or with the requirements of reading at the post-primary level (Fontes & Kellaghan, 1977a). There is also a considered opinion that while primary schools have been reasonably successful in the realm of comprehension, equal success has not been achieved in teaching and encouraging pupils to read to learn (Ireland, 1982). One indication of the willingness of pupils to read to learn is the amount of leisure time reading which they do. Studies of this aspect of pupil behaviour indicate that many Irish primary school children do little leisure time reading, either for information or pleasure (Greaney, 1980). The average amount given to leisure time reading was about 5% of the available time. Other studies of the leisure time reading of Irish primary school pupils indicate that girls read more than boys, that pupils from better off homes read most, and that boys read more non-fiction than girls. There is also evidence that most of the reading which is done by primary school pupils falls into the category of non-quality reading. The boom in the production of quality books for children in recent decades has had little effect on many Irish school children (Killeen, 1984). In this context, however, it has to be remembered that the influences which govern children's reading interests and reading habits are varied and complex, and that the school is only one of these influences. But the question has to be asked and answered: are the schools doing enough to encourage pupils to read independently with interest and enjoyment, and in what ways can teachers in their classroom
< previous page
page_70
next page >
< previous page
page_71
next page > Page 71
create an atmosphere supportive and promotive of the reading interests of pupils? The new curriculum emphasised the importance of both functional and imaginative writing. Since 1971 Irish primary schools have put considerable emphasis on aspects of pupil writing such as personal and creative writing. However, there is evidence that in too many classrooms there is an excessive emphasis on drill-like exercises to promote writing skills. An undue emphasis on decontextualised exercises in writing has deflected attention from the use of English in contexts where continuity in the use of the language is the primary goal. When asked about their priorities in the teaching of English, the majority of teachers rated oral work as of less importance than either reading or writing. Many teachers did not appear to appreciate the interrelationships among all aspects of the teaching of English (Ireland, 1982). The approach of many teachers to the correction of errors in writing needs to be reviewed. Too many teachers still regarded the marking of errors in pupil writing as a key feature of advancing writing abilities. There is a clear need to embark on major research work into aspects of children's writing which would involve both longitudinal and case studies and which would be informed by advances elsewhere in analysing, categorising and understanding the role of writing in the education of the young. The Curriculum advocated a variety of approaches to the teaching of poetry. A recent survey of the teaching of poetry in schools indicated that the majority of teachers in senior standards did not utilise sufficiently varied approaches (Killeen, 1984). Most teachers were content to present poetry to the classes by reading a poem aloud. Little use was made of drama in presentation and few teachers invited children to compile anthologies of their favourite poems. There was still considerable emphasis on memorisation, and the average number of poems taught over the period of a month was about three. Most teachers appeared to draw on the poems in the basal readers for the material of their lessons (Killeen, 1984). Although the most recent series of classroom readers contains a number of contemporary poems, publishers claim that they have been under pressure to include more traditional poems in the readers. Looking To The Future Within the past decade important changes have been made in the structure and control of Irish education. The formation of a Curriculum Unit in 1977 within the Department of Education indicated an official conscious-
< previous page
page_71
next page >
< previous page
page_72
next page > Page 72
ness about the importance of English in the education system. Since 1978, the Department through the Schools' Inspectors has embarked upon a series of national surveys to monitor the implementation of the New Curriculum and to check progress in aspects of the work of schools. Such surveys have already produced valuable information on a national level about aspects of the teaching of English (Ireland, 1982). In 1984, the Minister for Education convened the first meeting of the newly created interim Curriculum and Examinations Board. Within months a consultative document, entitled Issues and Structures in Education (Curriculum and Examinations Board, 1984), was produced which outlined the factors which would have to be considered in restructuring Irish education. Three discussion documents followed in 1985. One of these outlined the aims of primary school education. It was considered important that at the end of primary school, pupils should be able to: (a) read fluently and accurately, with understanding, feeling and discrimination; (b) develop the habit of reading for leisure; (c) develop a legible style of handwriting and satisfactory standards of spelling, syntax, punctuation and usage; (d) communicate clearly in speech and writing in ways appropriate for various occasions and purposes; (e) communicate orally and in writing through the Irish language at a level appropriate to their general ability and linguistic background; (f) communicate in a modern European language at a level appropriate to their general ability; (g) listen attentively and with understanding; (h) acquire information from various sources and recall information and findings in various ways and (i) develop an interest in and value for the arts. The document, Language in the Curriculum (Curriculum and Examinations Board, 1985b), acknowledged the centrality of the mother-tongue in the education of the young. Particular importance was placed on oral development within the school. Schools were urged to implement language policies which would put more emphasis on language use and less on language practice. Particular emphasis was placed on the importance of extensive use of the first language in schools where pupils are considered to be disadvantaged or socially deprived. Policy regarding the use of a second language related to its use for specific periods each day and its extension to other aspects of the curriculum as far as the abilities and the backgrounds of the pupils allowed. In the document, language was presented as a communication skill, and the traditional role of literature in the curriculum, particularly at post-primary level, was questioned. Overall, the past two decades have brought improvements in the teaching of English, and greater enthusiasm for the life enhancing aspects of the teaching of the subject. Reading comprehension levels have improved. There has been a growing emphasis on the importance of imaginative
< previous page
page_72
next page >
< previous page
page_73
next page > Page 73
writing in the lives of the pupils. Teachers have more access than before to a varied selection of attractively produced basal readers. Never has there been such a supply of potentially interesting reading material for pupils, albeit more available in public libraries and book shops than in schools. Both radio and television have encouraged imaginative and informational reading. Colleges of Education have put greater emphasis on the role of children's literature in the classroom. The inauguration of the Reading Association of Ireland and the impending foundation of the Children's Literature Association of Ireland are welcome indications of vitality within the sphere of the teaching of English. The most important change which has taken place in the teaching of English at primary level is an official acknowledgement that the home language is the primary instrument in the intellectual and aesthetic development of primary school children. English is now seen as not only a world language with a cultural deposit significantly enriched by an Irish dimension, but also as a potentially integrating force for the North and South of Ireland. English In Secondary Schools 1924-1988 Introduction The history of English teaching in Second Level schools in Ireland falls into two distinct periods divided by the decade of the 1960s. After 40 relatively stable years Ireland changed radically from being rural and inward-looking to a more urbanised society intent on building a new industrial economy and avidly looking outwards to the modern world for ideas. This dramatic re-orientation caused much questioning of the purposes and objectives of second level education: many of the questions posed at that time have still not been answered adequately. Up to the 1960s Irish Second Level Education was a dual system: the majority of pupils attended private, nominally fee-paying schools and colleges (government subsidised through capitation grants) largely run by Roman Catholic religious orders of priests, brothers and nuns. In these secondary schools pupils were prepared for two examinations: The Intermediate Certificate taken after three or four years and The Leaving Certificate taken after two more years which terminated the pupil's education. This structure essentially remained unchanged for 60 years. These secondary schools were socially and educationally very acceptable but it was not quite so acceptable to enter the other strand of the system entitled the Vocational Schools. These were state-run schools established
< previous page
page_73
next page >
< previous page
page_74
next page > Page 74
in the 1930s and largely staffed by lay-teachers catering for the non-academic pupil. These schools prepared pupils for a final examination held after three years called The Group Certificate. Pupils in the vocational scheme could not take the secondary school examinations. This socially divisive system was eventually changed in the 1960s when a comprehensive education scheme was introduced and later again a series of community schools were built with a broad curriculum to cater for academic and non-academic pupils. Likewise the vocational schools were academically upgraded in that they could now prepare their pupils for all examinations at Second Level. Frozen Worlds 1924-66 When the new Irish nation emerged in the 1920s it inherited from the previous English colonial administration an educational structure at second level which it largely retained. The inherited curriculum in English, however, was narrowly prescriptive and in the Intermediate Education (Amendment) Act of 1924 the newly founded Department of Education in the Irish government changed the English curriculum decisively. While the underlying rationale for the curriculum remained steadfastly Arnoldian, the prescribed texts were replaced by an 'open' course. English teachers were encouraged to use the new freedom to stimulate wide reading by their pupils. English teachers then were given the scope to be truly professional; they could within certain broad limits (admittedly academic) devise their own curriculum for pupils from year to year. From a centrally administered educational system it was a most enlightened flexible approach but unfortunately, as it soon became apparent, rather ill-advised. The Department had been unduly optimistic about the professional expertise of teachers and the sophistication of the pupils' reading skills. Within a few years it was necessary to publish aids for the teachers who were unable to cope with the freedom of choice offered and felt lost in this 'brave new world'. Teachers who worked in the previous prescribed programme, where the payment by examination results system operated, could not adjust when the examination pressure was reduced in the new open system. By the early 1930s a crisis point was reached, teachers directed their teaching towards imagined examination questions and the examiners themselves had difficulties devising questions to cater for the wide ability range of the pupils taking the one course. Consequently, in attempting to facilitate all, the questions tended to become easier to cater for the less endowed and so offered no challenge to the above-average pupils.
< previous page
page_74
next page >
< previous page
page_75
next page > Page 75
Eventually in 1934 in both Intermediate and Leaving Certificate Courses a new English course was introduced entitled English Language. This course was largely concerned with the acquisition of written skills and was seen as an entirely separate subject from English Literature. Although it was imaginatively impoverished in content it allowed some space for the non-academic pupil in the English curriculum. At this time in Ireland there was a prevailing hostile attitude to all things English, as already noted. While English was the vernacular of the majority of the population the state established Irish as the first official language and made it the responsibility of the Department of Education to foster the revival through the school system. Something of the intense quality of the opposition to English can be gathered from the proclamations of Professor T. J. Corcoran of University College, Dublin, who stated trenchantly: 'A command of English and of English expression is essential for Ireland and Irish Education: but the need for it should not be a ground for tolerating either English thought, or the expression of Irish thought in English in any enduring way' (Corcoran, 1922:270). Professor Corcoran was an immense influence in Irish educational thinking for many years and as a result many in positions of power in education were intent on undermining English as a subject in the schools in subtle and not so subtle ways. So in the programme for schools, 1925-26, the final note makes it clear that English is to be treated like any 'other foreign language'; the recommended reading of European authors in translation, while apparently culturally enlightened, was also a way of avoiding if possible too much immersion of the pupil in 'English thought'. Finally, there was no honours grade available in the Certificate examinations in English it was a pass subject, although honours could be obtained in Greek, Latin, French, Italian, Irish and Spanish. The state of English in the secondary schools during this early period was most unsettled. By the 1940s when it was clear that the revival of the Irish language was foundering, it became explicit Government policy that English was to be deliberately down-graded in the schools. The then Minister for Education, Mr Eamonn De Valera, stated, 'we shall have to be satisfied with a less high standard in English. There is no other way for it' (Dail Eireann 1094, 27 May, 1941). The failure of the Irish revival was partially attributed to widespread reading of English literature in the secondary schools; other nationalistic groups felt equally strongly about the situation: 'The intensive study of, and critical expository command over a vast
< previous page
page_75
next page >
< previous page
page_76
next page > Page 76
range of English literature, simply dripping with specifically English spirit, is a theory simply not to be endured any longer' (Ua Meacair, 1935: 123). As a result of these diverse pressures prescribed courses were reintroduced in 1941-42: the new programmes in English lacked coherence and were irremediably dull. The English Language course at Intermediate Level had just one novel and ten poems prescribed as reading material. If a pupil left school having completed the Intermediate cycle this would be his total experience of English Literature. If a pupil chose to continue his education at Leaving Certificate level he was quite unprepared to encounter the range of literature prescribed which consists of about 30 poems and a selection of essays from Goldsmith's Letters to a Citizen of the World. In the Intermediate English Literature programme and in both Leaving Certificate programmes no fiction was prescribed and the drama was represented by one Shakespearean text. Prose essays at both levels were generally uninteresting to adolescents and the selection of verse was included on nationalistic grounds, to which one would not object unduly except that quite a few of the poems were frankly of poor literary quality. The sense of the make-shift which characterises these programmes was given exemplary expression in the Syllabus for 1946-47, which refrained from even naming either the poems or authors at Leaving Certificate and simply proclaimed 'the even number series' (the 'numbers' were the numbers of the poems in the contents of the official Anthology of school). Very few in the educational context felt independent enough to protest against this blatant manipulation of the English curriculum. English teachers had no professional body at the time to represent their interests and bowed to the inevitable. There was one lone voice who protested forcefully against the deliberate negation of English and English Literature: Rev. Peter Birch, who objected to the deterioration in standards which the new courses would inevitably bring and saw the programme as a clear outcome of 'intolerant political and national prejudices' (Birch, 1944:391). He attacked the view that if Irish was to be revived English would have to suffer. 'From the purely educational point of view, the policy that would ignore the cultural possibilities of a modern language which has become naturalised and easy to assimilate, is not based on reason' (Birch, 1944:393). But the Rev. Peter Birch was a voice crying in the wilderness: these programmes continued in Irish second level schools until 1966. The state of English then during these 25 years could be described as quite moribund. An English teacher who first entered this programme as a pupil and then
< previous page
page_76
next page >
< previous page
page_77
next page > Page 77
subsequently returned to teach it described both experiences as 'excruciating'! (Connolly, 1986). In the 1950s Ireland was a rather self-righteous, self-satisfied nation. The cultural mould had been forged on the anvil of revolutionary history and hardened in the isolationist policies adopted in the first 40 years of the Irish state. The schools according to the nation were effective in initiating the pupils into the national inheritance; there was no need for change or development. It was a long hard winter. Signs Of Spring In 1950 the Department of Education established a body called The Council of Education to review the state of Irish education. The Council was composed mostly of educationalists from various interest groups within the system. It took 10 years to complete the project. The delay was essentially caused by ideological incompatibility between various members and not by any lack of commitment. After such a long period of gestation one might have expected some innovatory suggestions but the report resolutely opted for the status quo. It stated that the principal objective of education was the moral, religious and cultural development of the child: social and economic perspectives were not considered by the Council. The stance was characteristically theoretical and dogmatic: 'In its deductivist approach to analysing problems, its deference to the status quo, and its isolation of educational issues from their wider social context, it is an almost perfect reflection of much contemporary thinking' (Sheehan, 1979: 62). Nevertheless, despite its conservative stance, it did make a number of recommendations about the teaching of English which gave some hope for the future. The report was unequivocally positive about English, accepting its undeniable place as the vernacular of the country. Because of this it made strong recommendations that more attention should be paid to the hitherto neglected area of oral skills, and advocated 'such activities (e.g. debates, class discussions, dramatic performances) as will encourage young people to express themselves aloud with ease, and the use of teaching aids such as the gramophone, tape-recorder and sound film-projector' (Ireland, 1960: 160).
< previous page
page_77
next page >
< previous page
page_78
next page > Page 78
In relation to written English, traditional grammar instruction was still strongly recommended, albeit with more attention paid to usage rather than arid analysis in the Leaving Certificate cycle. The literary areas were generally found acceptable although broadening of the range of material was advocated. Thus the report noted that in the Intermediate Certificate English Language course there was a 'prevalence of poems of a melancholy type. The inclusion of some humorous or light verse of various periods from Chaucer to modern times would be a great improvement' (Ireland, 1960: 162). Other minor changes were advocated in the selection of prose and verse at Leaving Certificate level and they advocated that the practice of memorising verse should be curtailed. It is obvious that the Council of Education was intent on pleasing everyone and although some new moves were suggested nothing was discarded. The influence of this report was minimal; by the time it was published events in the country had progressed at such a rate that its timid suggestions were overcome by the torrents of change in Irish society. A new society was emerging in Ireland resulting from the unprecedented economic development; education long taken for granted by successive governments now came under intense scrutiny. Under the auspices of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (O.E.C.D.) a six-member committee of high-level civil servants and economists was formed to examine the educational system and to report on its economic infrastructure and general efficiency in serving the needs of the 'new Ireland'. The report entitled Investment in Education (Ireland, 1966) was not flattering to the system: it found much duplication of resources, inefficient procedures, intolerable environments and alienation of pupils, particularly of the lower socio-economic groups from the school system (Ireland, 1965). Subsequent to these findings certain significant changes were initiated within Irish education. Comprehensive schools were established in certain disadvantaged areas, the vocational system was upgraded and a free education scheme for all pupils was introduced. Numbers of pupils attending second level increased by 18,000 in the year 1967 and this upward trend continued for many years subsequently. The second level system burgeoned not alone with new pupils but with problems and dilemmas of all kinds. A much broader social spectrum now was found in the classroom; many of these pupils were anxious to improve their social and economic position and saw in education the means to that end. These pupils were looking for an up-to-date forward-looking curriculum catering for diversity in abilities and needs - they were essentially
< previous page
page_78
next page >
< previous page
page_79
next page > Page 79
demanding 'relevance'. The curriculum in its philosophic outlook was not based on 'relevance'; about this issue for many years a conflict waged particularly in the context of English teaching; as yet the issues have not been resolved. The Department of Education in response to the Report established Syllabus committees in various subjects. The English Committee was composed of various interest groups, teachers, inspectors, academics, trades unionists. The committee worked for a number of years to revise the whole curriculum in English and in 1966 the first innovations were introduced in the Intermediate Certificate cycle. New anthologies were published in verse, prose and short-stories, the latter a particularly successful and welcome move. These anthologies ranged quite widely over the field of English and Anglo-Irish Literature and dispensed with most of the chauvinistic material which had bedevilled the previous programme. Likewise, at Leaving Certificate level a new anthology of verse was introduced and some fiction and drama. Relatively modern authors appeared in all these anthologies but the orientation of the curriculum was still largely literary, historical and academic. Nevertheless, teachers responded enthusiastically to these new programmes and the teacher quoted earlier described the new courses as 'exhilarating'! (Connolly, 1986). Clearly in the midst of all this educational ferment English teachers were being challenged in new ways. In 1964 with the formation of The Association of Teachers of English (A.T.E.), teachers at last found a community to give a forum for discussion of their needs and ideas and equally important to give them a professional voice in the context of changes envisaged at the time or in the future. The Association immediately directed its attention to influencing the formation of the new syllabuses and also made important contributions to such controversial issues as examinations, teacher-training and the role of the Inspectorate. In 1966 the A.T.E. initiated an annual English Summer School which still continues. The A.T.E. has consistently advocated that any English programme must have as its objective the fostering of a dialectic between literary experience and pupil experience: from this encounter opportunities will issue for an endless variety of linguistic activities ranging from the functional to the poetic, through which the pupil will become truly personally literate and learn to cherish the creative power of language. In May, 1968 the Association had reason to make its voice aggressively heard when the then Minister for Education, Mr Brian Linehan, suddenly announced that the Department planned to introduce a common examination paper at Leaving Certificate level devoted solely to linguistic skills. In a statement Mr Linehan proclaimed:
< previous page
page_79
next page >
< previous page
page_80
next page > Page 80
'The emphasis will be on the speaking and writing of languages . . . the children will not have to learn large slabs of Shakespeare, Shelley and Keats. The simple essay will be the aim. The policy will be tilted at how to speak and write original and simple thoughts without reference to slabs of poetry and prose' (The Irish Times, 1968, 21st June: 1). The Minister thought that the children would be much more usefully employed reading the daily newspaper rather than reading Shakespeare. This announcement was greeted with anger and dismay by the A.T.E. and by the English Syllabus Committee which had been working for years to devise the new Syllabus. Professor Denis Donoghue, University representative on the Syllabus Committee asserted: 'that in fact the new syllabuses and examinations will be worse than the old. By ''worse" I mean: enforcing lower standards, a general depression of achievement, a specific programme which caters for the lazy and the dull at the expense of the intelligent student . . . This arrangement was denounced by every member of the Syllabus Committee: we considered it a retrograde decision, calculated to reduce the amount of literature taught in schools and to depress the standard of teaching in English' (Donoghue, 1968:60). The universities announced that the Leaving Certificate Common English paper would not be acceptable for Matriculation. The weight of the opposition eventually forced the Department to modify its position and this reductionist plan for English was modified and the Common paper was not introduced. The contribution of the A.T.E. to the shaping of the present condition of English in Irish secondary schools has been considerable. It rescued English teachers in the first instance from the imprisonment of extensive grammatical exercises and memorisation which had plagued the curriculum for many years: it resisted any attempt to introduce an over-functionalised approach to the teaching of language and it confidently asserted its trinity of humanistic ideals, the power of literature, the importance of the individual person and the creativity of the word, in the teeth of much cynical opposition. English teachers owe a large debt to the A.T.E. for preserving a coherent positive view of the profession when it was under threat in this country. Professor D. J. Murphy outlines, in a review of research on English teaching, the nature of the present challenge to teachers in Irish schools and therefore to the A.T.E.: 'The argument for placing imaginative studies at the centre of the
< previous page
page_80
next page >
< previous page
page_81
next page > Page 81
English curriculum has a long and respected ancestry and I would suggest it has not been invalidated by recent debate. The cultivation of imagination should continue therefore to be the primary aim of English teaching. The aesthetic model of English, however, is excessively restricted, and, if implemented, would involve a serious neglect of certain forms of linguistic competence. It is essential that a comprehensive programme of linguistic development be built into the English curriculum, so that the pupils can experience the diversity of language within the unified framework of a discipline specifically intended to further linguistic competence. The alternative concept of "language across the curriculum" is simply impractical in our present circumstances. It is particularly important that this programme ensure a balanced development of imaginative and functionalistic uses of English. The latter issue has particular urgency for us in view of our high rates of functional illiteracy. We need, also, to formulate carefully thought-out policies on the teaching of the basics and the development of oracy' (Murphy, 1985: 62). Promises Of Summer In A.T.E. 11 (1985) the editorial makes the point that it is now twenty years since any curriculum changes were introduced on a broad scale and that it is imperative that a review and overhaul of the English programme should be initiated. Although this rejuvenation is certainly needed it may be quite some time before it actually happens. The excitement of the 1960s has settled down and the in-built malady of the teaching profession, inertia, becomes more obvious from year to year. The presiding presence in Second Level education dictating the activities of many teachers at Senior Level is the understandable ambition of the pupils to acquire the necessary 'points' for university entrance. These 'points' are dependent on the grades a pupil achieves in the Leaving Certificate; this ruthless meritocratic system has ensured that most classrooms are dominated by 'Text and Test'. Only teachers with a very strong conviction and belief in their role as English teachers have managed to avoid succumbing to the demands imposed for results. It is not to be wondered at that in such a difficult context professional inertia flourishes and more lofty ideals and objectives gradually fade. This is a bleak picture but there are some glimmerings in the darkness. The report Investment in Education recommended that educational programmes needed constant revision to adapt to the changing demands of the
< previous page
page_81
next page >
< previous page
page_82
next page > Page 82
individual and society. While the Department of Education has been slow in taking up this suggestion other educationalists have acted upon it, urged on by the obvious alienation of pupils from the curriculum. During the 1970s funded in various ways (frequently from E.E.C. resources) a series of pilot projects were initiated in different regions. These projects restructured the curriculum in a manner which broke down traditional boundaries between subject disciplines and redirected the curriculum towards the achievement of objectives such as life-skills, work-skills and social awareness. These projects had various titles, Social and Environmental Studies Programme (S.E.S.P.), Early School Leavers Project (E.S.L.P.), Shannon Project of Intervention for Relevant Adolescent Learning (S.P.I.R.A.L.). While none of these particular programmes were directly concerned with English, they did provide the opportunity for new, meaningful explorations of and with language on which English teachers could capitalise in their own way. There was one scheme which did more directly impinge on the English teacher. This scheme, The North Mayo Project, funded by a philanthropic organisation, The Irish Foundation for Human Development, was unique in its orientation and approach. It sought to introduce the pupils to a range of new experiences which would develop their personal resources of imagination, creativity and self-awareness. Many progressive and modernist approaches were used, such as imagery, fantasising, meditation and interpretative dance and mime. Unfortunately, the project while well intentioned and most positive in outlook was ill-fated from the start due to a complexity of social and administrative factors. The most decisive government move in the Irish Educational System for decades occurred in 1984 when a new interim body called The Curriculum and Examinations Board (C. E. B.) was established to review the whole system. It is planned that the Board will ultimately become a statutory body distinct from the Department of Education and responsible for the educational system. The Board over the last two years has been publishing a series of documents on aspects of education and has had much to say about English in the curriculum particularly in two documents, The Arts in the Curriculum (C.E.B., 1985a) and Language in the Curriculum (C.E.B., 1985b). The Arts in the Curriculum included literature as one of the arts in its introductory preamble: however, when it came to consider each individual art, while it adequately discussed the role of drama, dance, music and the
< previous page
page_82
next page >
< previous page
page_83
next page > Page 83
visual arts, no detailed consideration of a rationale and programme for literature was presented. This was a most surprising and unfortunate omission, a splendid opportunity was lost to give literature a richer creative context or locus on the curriculum. Such a locus would have offered exciting professional opportunities for teachers in the way of reading, interpreting and presenting literary texts. The other document, Language in the Curriculum, has much to say on the teaching of English. The document illustrates quite clearly the degree of change which has occurred in official attitudes to English. Without reservation the document states 'through speaking English as a mother tongue, or as an exceptionally fluent second language, we can have access to another and particularly influential culture' (C.E.B., 1985b: 6). And again in the light of former attitudes the following statement is welcome,'as a small country we need to avoid the risk of cultural isolation'. On the actual teaching of English the document is quite forthright on its conception of past practice. 'Traditionally, the mother-tongue has tended to rely heavily on literature to provide the substance of its syllabuses in Irish schools. The leaving Certificate English syllabus in Rialacha agus Clar remarks: '. . . a writer's style and technique may invite, either orally or in writing, exercises in analysis, discussion, comparison and imitation. Likewise the content of a piece of writing may offer opportunities for oral and written exercises in comprehension, discussion and summary. The overall aim to be kept in view should be a fuller experience of the work studied. The final sentence leaves little room for doubt. It is the literary work which is seen as important the students' efforts in language as subsidiary. The aim of the teacher of the mother-tongue is made quite clearthe cultivation of "sound criteria of literary judgment and good taste"' (Rialacha agus Clar, 1983/84, p. 153). 'Such an approach, however admirable in itself, hardly seems sufficient to prepare the pupil to manage with the many-sided linguistic and cultural aspects of living. This approach starts from a bookish view of society and aims to preserve rather than to discover. It leads away from the important linguistic demands of contemporary life, or else towards them by an unnecessarily tortuous and circuitous route. It is inadequate, if not altogether out of date' (C.E.B., 1985b: 15). It calls for a much less academic stance and suggests: 'The context in which the mother-tongue should be studied and taught
< previous page
page_83
next page >
< previous page
page_84
next page > Page 84
in school is the context in which it is used in life; not just for literary/ artistic purposes, but generally, as, for example, in the home or outside the home, in contact with the media, in private reading and reflection, in the pursuit of information, in the creation of entertainment, in the discovery of self, and in the variety of ways through which ideas, feelings and values are communicated and received, orally or aurally or in writing' (C.E.B., 1985b: 16). The document advocates that in general the teaching of English should be largely accomplished through the communicative approach, which it characterises as language always being purposefully used rather than 'practice at language'. Such an approach is best cultivated as it continues, by adapting a task-approach in the classroom and where the live process of language is continually encountered by the pupil in meaningful personal and social situations. The teacher in this changed linguistic context must not be a remote pedagogue but rather'a resource for pupils, a manager, a facilitator of learning' (p. 19). In the area of assessment it suggests that 'assessment should help learners by diagnosing weaknesses' and marks should be weighted to favour communicative ability. The document finally states that 'a communicative approach is more a matter of re-analysis than revolution' but it recognises that the reorientation of it if it is to be successful will necessitate large-scale involvement by English teachers at all levels of design and implementation. 'They should also have the opportunity to take part in curriculum projects concerned with the elaboration and piloting of appropriate syllabuses, materials, methodology and tests at primary and post-primary levels' (p. 21). The approach advocated here appears to be an honest, forthright attempt to adapt the English programme to contemporary life and to give it flexibility to suit the challenges faced by different teachers in different classrooms. Nevertheless, many teachers would have reservations about the marginalising of literature in the document. While it is not totally dismissed it is generally presented as not being of great importance. With a foresight bred from past encounters with state agencies, the A.T.E. anticipated this negation of the role of literature by the C.E.B. In the Newsletter (A.T.E., 1984) largely based on submissions from English teachers, the association expressed reservations about the initial utilitarian directives which had been given to the Board and voiced the opinion that the implications for English could be ominous. The Newsletter declared: 'In the first place it may be tempting to lessen its (English's) significance in the curriculum. Stronger still, however, will be the urge to direct the
< previous page
page_84
next page >
< previous page
page_85
next page > Page 85
attention of a vast majority of pupils towards the achievement of basic communication skills, especially in the area of functional writing: the urge to move towards courses and examinations that develop proficiency in this area alone, to the exclusion of literature' (A.T.E., 1984: 2). The Newsletter editors showed a keen awareness of the manifold problems besetting English teachers in the country: it constituted the 'authoritative statement' which had been called for in A.T.E. 10. The shortcomings and imbalances of the present syllabus and the 'stultifying' examination pressures were well highlighted in a detailed and wide-ranging analysis. Many specific suggestions were made: more flexibility in literature courses and more enlightened examination procedures were strongly advocated. In the area of linguistic skills the Newsletter stressed the need for more emphasis on oral and aural skills and for the rejuvenation and enrichment of the present narrow approach to the teaching of writing. Characteristically the imaginative and aesthetic centre of English teaching was repeatedly underpinned in statements such as the following: To deprive pupils however limited their ability of access to the richness of imagination and to the most powerful source of transmitted humane experience is to rob them of a potential for growth both emotional and intellectual as well as reduce not enhance the quality of life and capabilities of leisure (A.T.E., 1984: 3). Thus while both the A.T.E. and the C.E.B. feel strongly that the English curriculum needs radical revision to meet the present day needs of pupils there is a fundamental philosophical difference evident between their proposed alternatives. However, a recently completed pilot project for the Intermediate Certificate (Lower Course) demonstrated that a creative compromise was possible. This project, largely urged on by the English Inspectors within the Department of Education, intimately involved English teachers on an action-research basis in curriculum planning and design. The material was chosen from a wide range of sources and the curriculum ranged freely over creative drama, the mass media, contemporary literature and literature for adolescents. The project was pursued in a number of schools throughout the country and culminated in assessment procedures which included continuous assessment as well as a conventional examination. The latter, however, strongly emphasised personal response rather than an academic or critical response and allowed plenty of creative space for the pupils in their answers and interpretations. While the final report in this project is not yet
< previous page
page_85
next page >
< previous page
page_86
next page > Page 86
available, the writers were assured by some of those teachers who participated in the project that it was a most revitalising experience for all concerned. It would appear, then, that the multifarious strands that constitute successful English teaching are slowly being woven together in Ireland in a new pattern. By 1988 it is hoped to introduce a new anthology of contemporary verse at Leaving Certificate Level to provide an alternative to the present historically structured course. Already at this level the range of drama has been significantly enlarged by the works of modern playwrights such as O'Casey, Miller and Friel. After a slow gestation period the Second Level English Curriculum in Irish schools appears to be growing in flexibility and becoming more teacher-pupil orientated. If the promise now being revealed (and there is still much to be done) is ultimately fulfilled then English teachers will have the liberty and responsibility of presenting their subject in as challenging and creative manner. Addendum In September, 1989 a new Junior English Syllabus was initiated in all second-level schools in Ireland replacing the Intermediate Certificate Syllabus. The new syllabus was planned by a Syllabus Committee of the National Council for Curriculum and Assessment (formerly the Curriculum and Examinations Board). The new Syllabus is a radical reorientation of the direction of English teaching in the country. Prescription of specific texts has been omitted and teachers are free to plan programmes in their broad guidelines to suit their own pupils. The syllabus emphasises that each pupil should develop competence and awareness in the areas of personal, social and cultural literacy and that language development and literary encounters should be creatively integrated with the pupils' own experience. The traditional barrier that was perceived to exist between the culture of the English class and the culture of the child has been removed by the recommendation that much young-adult literature and the mass-media in all its forms should play a significant role in English teaching. With this syllabus English teaching in Ireland has opened an intriguing episode in its story. English teachers have been empowered significantly and given a great opportunity for professional growth. It remains to be seen whether the State agencies provide the essential supports and resources,
< previous page
page_86
next page >
< previous page
page_87
next page > Page 87
specifically in the form of extensive and repeat in-service seminars, so that the vision enforcing the syllabus can be comprehensively achieved. English teachers and their pupils are going through interesting times in Ireland and the future should be one of educational debate full of potential for all concerned. References ABBS, P. 1981, English and the Arts. London: Heinemann. A.T.E. 1970, Editorial. Journal of the Association of English Teachers 1: Dublin, p. 3. 1983, Editorial. Journal of the Association of English Teachers 10: Dublin, pp. 5-6. 1984, Newsletter. Dublin. 1985, Editorial. Journal of the Association of English Teachers 11: Dublin. BIRCH, P. 1944, Secondary School English, The Irish Ecclesiastical Record, 63: pp. 391-95. CONFERENCE OF CONVENT PRIMARY SCHOOLS IN IRELAND 1975, Evaluation of the new curriculum for primary schools. Dublin: Conference of Convent Primary Schools in Ireland. CONNOLLY, I. 1986, Senior English Teacher, St Angela's College, Cork, Ireland, in conversation with writer, September 1986. COOLAHAN, J. 1977, Three eras of reading in Irish National Schools. In V. GREANEY (ed.), Studies in Reading. Dublin: Educational Company of Ireland, pp. 12-26. 1981, Irish Education: History and Structure. Dublin: Institute of Public Administration. COOLAHAN, Jr. 1982, Developments in English Reading in Irish National Schools, 1937-1977. In D. SWAN (ed.), Perspectives in Reading. Dublin: The Glendale Press. CORCORAN, J. 1922, How English may be taught without Anglicising, The Iris Monthly 51, Dublin: pp. 296-73. CURRICULUM AND EXAMINATIONS BOARD (C.E.B.) 1984, Issues and Structures in Education: A Consultative Document. Dublin. 1985a, The Arts in the Curriculum. Dublin. 1985b, Language in the Curriculum: A Curriculum and Examinations Board Discussion Paper. Dublin. DE BUITLEIR, S. 1985, Towards a General Theory of Curriculum and Evaluation. Dublin: Department of Education. DE VALERA, E. 1941, (May 27th) Proceedings of Dail Eireann, Cols. 1094-95. Dublin. DIXON, J. 1966, Growth Through English. Reading: National Association for the Teaching of English. DONOGHUE, D. 1968, University Professor, Studies LXIV. Dublin: pp. 60-65. FONTES, P. J. and KELLAGHAN, T. 1977a, Incidence and correlates of illiteracy in Irish primary schools. Irish Journal of Education. 11. 1977b, The New Primary School Curriculum: Its Implementation and Effects. Dublin: The Educational Research Centre, St Patrick's College.
< previous page
page_87
next page >
< previous page
page_88
next page > Page 88
GREANEY, V. 1980, Factors related to amount and type of leisure-time reading. Reading Research Quarterly, 15. 1986, Reading: How are we doing. Proceedings of the Fourth European Conference on Reading. IRELAND 1933, Department of Education. Notes for Teachers, English. Dublin: The Stationery Office. 1937, The Constitution of Ireland. Dublin: The Stationery Office. 1954, Department of Education. Report of the Council of Education. Dublin: The Stationery Office. 1956, Department of Education. Notes for Teachers, English. Dublin: The Stationery Office. 1960, Report of the Council of Education. Dublin: The Stationery Office. 1966, Department of Education. Investment in Education. Report of the survey team appointed by the Minister of Education in October, 1962. Dublin: The Stationery Office. 1971, Department of Education. Primary School Curriculum. Teacher's Handbook (2 vols.). Dublin: The Stationery Office. 1982, Department of Education. English in the Primary School: Survey Report. Dublin: The Stationery Office. IRISH NATIONAL TEACHERS' ORGANISATION 1976, Primary School Curriculum: Curriculum Questionnaire analyses. Dublin. KELLY, S.G. and MCGEE, P. 1967, Survey of reading comprehension. New Research in Education, 1. KILLEEN, J. 1984, Contrasting approaches to the teaching of English in some Irish primary schools: and Pupil outcomes in leisure time reading and in writing. Unpublished doctoral dissertations, University College, Dublin. MACNAMARA, J. 1966, Bilingualism and Primary Education. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press. MURPHY, D. J. 1985, English: Current aims and needs. A.T.E. 11. Dublin: pp. 50-63. NELSON, L. 1973, Chairman's Address Summer School 1972. A.T.E. 4. Dublin: pp. 81-89. SHEEHAN, J. 1979, Education and Society: Ireland 1945-70. J. Lee Gill (ed.) (pp. 61-72) Dublin: Macmillan. The Irish Times (1968, July 4). Dublin. TRAVERS, M. 1976, A second replication of a survey of reading comprehension in Dublin city schools. Irish Journal of Education, 16. UA MEACAIR, A. 1935, Reorganising Irish Education, The Catholic Bulletin 25. Gill: Dublin: pp. 120-25. WARD, N. 1982, A fourth survey of reading comprehension in Dublin city national schools. Irish Journal of Education, 16.
< previous page
page_88
next page >
< previous page
page_89
next page > Page 89
4 The Swinging Pendulum: Teaching English In The USA, 1945-1987 John S. Simmons, Robert E. Shafer and Linda K. Shadiow When key documents and retrospectives have been published on the teaching of English in the United States, their titles have consistently acknowledged a struggle: Freedom and Discipline (Report on the Commission on English, 1965), Tradition and Reform (Applebee, 1974), Consensus and Dissent (Farmer, 1986). The changing social and political fabric of the United States has pushed the operational definition of English teaching first toward one end of the continuum and then the other. The interim periods of momentary balance were usually disrupted by some socio/political event that reverberated beyond the political arena and into the educational one. 'Innovation', a movement toward one end of the philosophical continuum or the other, was sure to follow. In a 1966 article (whose title also acknowledges the perpetual struggle 'Innovation and Revolution'), Frank E. Ross points out that the original meaning of the word 'innovation' is not 'nova', or 'something new' but instead is 'change'. And 'change' implies 'choice'. Reviewing the teaching of English in the United States from 1945 to the present takes in changes and the subsequent choices occurring post-World War II through Sputnik, Vietnam, civil rights reforms, renewed social activism, and re-emphasised conservatism. At every juncture both choices and changes were made in the path of the teaching of English; some innovations were renovations some innovations were new. The beginning lines of Robert Frost's poem, 'The Road Not Taken' serve as a reminder of the endless possibilities a re-examination of history affords. Two roads diverged in a yellow wood, And sorry I could not travel both And be one traveler, long I stood
< previous page
page_89
next page >
< previous page
page_90
next page > Page 90
And looked down one as far as I could To where it bent in the undergrowth . . . Post-War Politics: 1945-1950 Many educators saw wartime service between 1941 and 1945. When they returned to their schools and classrooms they found that the progressive education of the 1930s still formed the basic philosophical directions for schooling in American society; the Seven Cardinal Principles of Secondary Education (formulated by the National Education Association's Commission on the Reorganization of Secondary Education in 1918) were still dominant in the thinking of American educators: (1) health, (2) command of fundamental processes, (3) worthy home membership, (4) vocation, (5) citizenship, (6) worthy use of leisure, (7) ethical character. The latest translation of this progressivism and its seven cardinal principles was formulated into a new report, Education for All American Youth, published by the National Education Association in 1944. The report recommended that most youth continue their education through high school and junior college, and urged educators to recognise the educational value of practical lessons. This approach was a continuation of the spirit represented in many of the progressive statements of the 1920s and 1930s, and was a natural post-war rallying point. According to Education for All American Youth, the focus of schooling was to be 'on the present lives of youth, on the improvement of community lives and on such practical matters as competence and occupations, citizenship, and family living' (p.12). Many traditional academics were disturbed at the inherent threat this approach seemingly represented to traditional academic disciplines. Thus, the period from 1944 to the late 1950s spurred a 'great debate' in American education during which many teachers trained in liberal arts and science disciplines found it increasingly difficult to teach within this 'life adjustment' approach. This 'great debate' accelerated between 1949 and the mid-1950s when books like Mortimer Smith's And Madly Teach (1949) complained that progressive education (as represented by the life adjustment movement) had become 'the official philosophy of American public education' and characterised teachers, administrators and schools of education as having a 'truly amazingly uniformative opinion regarding the aims, the content and the methods of education'. Books and rhetoric such as this prompted the formation of organisations like the Council for Basic Education which entered the fray in 1956 and championed educational conservatism.
< previous page
page_90
next page >
< previous page
page_91
next page > Page 91
The membership of the Council for Basic Education was made up largely of professors teaching at various universities, editors, journalists, and several self-appointed critics who feared the takeover of all public education by Deweyan apostles and, as they saw it, the inevitable 'watering down' of the curriculum: 'The Council for Basic Education was established in the belief that the purpose of education is the harmonious development of the mind, the will, and the conscience of each individual so that he may use to the fullest his intrinsic powers and shoulder the responsibilities of citizenship . . . It insists that only by the maintenance of high academic standards can the ideal of democratic education be realized' (Lynch & Evans, 1963). In two monographs which led to the founding of the Council for Basic Education, And Madly Teach by Mortimer Smith (1949) and Educational Wastelands by Arthur Bestor (1985), the National Council of Teachers of English (NCTE) was upbraided as one of the chief proponents of creeping mediocrity in public school curriculum development. J. N. Hook (1979) in his personal history of NCTE, A Long Way Together, describes English teachers' point of view on 'education for all American youth' and the 'life adjustment' emphasis in American education during this period: '. . . in general the life adjusters downplayed subject matter except when it contributed to the individual's self-knowledge or to relationships with others . . . The life adjusters to summarise somewhat unfairly wanted to teach literature and composition for their possible contributions to such youthful concerns as getting along with one's family, dating, making friends, and developing one's personality or to the more adult concern of getting and keeping a job'. The life adjustment movement inevitably affected much teaching of English. But it was by no means universally accepted. In 1945, a new NCTE Commission on the English Curriculum was appointed under the leadership of Dora V. Smith, Professor of English Education at the University of Minnesota. Members of the Commission were divided over the 'life adjustment' proposals and, because of the problems and debates, the Commission did not issue its first publication, The English Language Arts until 1952. This publication defined the English Language Arts as a product of the progressive tradition proposing 'to develop in students the ability to think and communicate in the English language and to understand the humanizing values of literature'. Its goals were to develop 'the linguistic abilities and the awareness of the values of life which are required by the fully mature civilized human being' (p.8). The Commission proposed that 'a
< previous page
page_91
next page >
< previous page
page_92
next page > Page 92
reasonable chance of achieving these goals' in the curriculum 'must be developed in the light of two major guiding principles': (1) using language power as an integral part of all growth, and (2) developing language power in social situations. Because of this emphasis on the process and utility of English (e.g. reading, writing, and speaking) instead of the content of English (e.g. literature and language study), The English Language Arts (Smith, 1952) and its five companion volumes struck fear into the hearts of those teachers and professors representing the disciplines of language and literature. An early reaction by Professor Ruth Wallerstein of the University of Wisconsin demonstrated this: 'The report does not clearly enough define our objects as teachers of the language arts. Yet surely a clear statement of what an educated citizen is, is our starting point. To keep clearly in mind what those subjects give, however taught, measures whether we are using fruitfully our knowledge of the individual and the stages of his development: and it must strictly determine our priorities of time' (Wallerstein, 1953:371). This single early criticism soon expanded into many. As one former President of the National Council of Teachers of English stated, 'when the report arrived on Washington Square (the headquarters of the Modern Language Association of America) it was assumed to be a major disaster' (Letter from Albert Markwardt to Robert E. Shafer, March 14, 1968). Throughout the decade, the battle raged between the forces of the progressives and the conservatives, largely in counterpointed publications and at national professional meetings. The cold war and the pervasive McCarthyisms of the 1950s provided an atmosphere conducive to such battles. To The Eve Of Dartmouth: 1950-1965 1950s Political Context In the 1950s, the US English curriculum reflected the mood of the nation and that mood had evolved to a taciturn one. The Eisenhower years were years of cooling off: from the intensity of the World War, from the frustrations of the Cold War, from the puzzlement of a 'no-win' war in Korea. The country needed to take a deep breath from all of this. 'Don't
< previous page
page_92
next page >
< previous page
page_93
next page > Page 93
rock the boat' seemed to be the watchword phrase as the decade entered mid-stream. In 1954, the Supreme Court entered its historic decision on Brown vs. Kansas, a ruling that invalidated the longstanding 1896 Plessy vs. Ferguson decision which had established separate-but-equal schools in the nation. The long overdue Civil Rights movement began in earnest. One of the most important elements of the civil rights movement was the desegregation of the nation's schools and, as one viewed the public school curriculum, English took a position of vital importance. School instruction in English classes provided the keys to developing the literacy skills vital to Blacks' abilities to procure voting privileges and prepare themselves for jobs. As access to a meaningful education in public schools became a top priority of civil rights' leaders, the question of the appropriateness of the English curriculum loomed larger and larger. Philosophical Context Senior high teachers, trained to teach (and experienced with) older adolescents had developed a heavily contentoriented programme usually dominated by formal, academic literature study in a predictable pattern: genres in the tenth grade, American literature in the eleventh grade, and British literature in the twelfth. This was supplemented by some instruction in language and composition, but primarily in the teaching of the five-paragraph theme and Latinate grammar. In the 1950s the pragmatic life-adjusters were of limited influence. At a time when the civil rights movement was challenging the schools to adjust to a 'new' population of students, many theorists supported a kind of status quo curriculum in which grammar dominated the landscape in the earlier grades and then gave way to literature in the later ones. Book reports, which were to the traditionalists a convenient blending of literature and writing, represented the bulk of literature study in the junior high years. Senior high literary study was dominated by the so-called 'classics'. Another point of view, however, was increasingly present. In direct contrast with this academically conservative philosophy was that of the contemporary pragmatists (descended philosophically from the progressives and the 'life adjusters'). These pragmatists produced a sizeable amount of professional literature on the nature and goals of the English curriculum in the 1930s, 40s, and 50s. The position was advocated but never adopted by the majority of English teachers. Using the philosophy of John Dewey (1938), particularly as expressed
< previous page
page_93
next page >
< previous page
page_94
next page > Page 94
in Experience and Education, as a point of departure, they advocated the position that the function of English curriculum was to provide young people with school experiences which mirrored those of life itself (e.g. Wilbur Hatfield's An Experience Curriculum in English, 1935). Although this position was advocated by an articulate, visible minority, including the leaders of the National Council of Teachers of English (and in its publications like the five-volume English Language Arts), it was not adopted nor widely practised by the mainstream of classroom teachers. These conflicting forces were at work in attempting to determine the shape of the English curriculum in the mid 1950s. Two manifestations of this struggle can be seen in the 'grammar controversy' and in certain movements in literature pedagogy found throughout the nation's schools during the period. Language Instruction During this period the traditional, prescriptive method of language instruction was challenged in the textbook arena and in professional debates by the advocates of the structural approach. A series of questions about the nature and purpose of language instruction were shaped by varying professional points of view, research, and social issues of the day. The place of traditional, Latinate grammar had grown in significance in the English curricula throughout the twentieth century. During the 1930s and 40s, one particular language textbook series, English in Action by Arthur Tressler (1925), was the one most used nationwide. Some teachers followed its rules, examples, and exercises with near-religious fervour. Beginning in the late 1940s, however, the Tressler text was gradually replaced by a series written by John Warriner (1982), English Grammar and Composition, that clearly implied a link between the study of formal grammar and the development of the writing abilities of young people. Despite more than 50 years of research to the contrary, many teachers believed that grammar study had a direct, positive' effect on students' abilities in reading, speaking and writing. By 1955, this belief had become solidly entrenched across the country. Members of the teaching profession took sides in this controversy. The topic continues to be one which is the subject of heated debate even today at local, state and national professional meetings. The impact of subsequent research, all of which confirms earlier findings, has met with a surprising amount of indifference, even hostility and indignation, within the ranks of the teachers and citizens.
< previous page
page_94
next page >
< previous page
page_95
next page > Page 95
In the mid 1950s, however, another factor was introduced: the emergence of structural or descriptive grammar in both the professional literature and the school curricula of some communities. First elaborated by Charles C. Fries (1940) in his book, American English Grammar, the basically inductive, oral-to-written approach to grammatical analysis grew in visibility during the ensuing years. Published professional materials (e.g. Markwardt, 1967; Francis, 1963; Gleason, 1961) however, had very little impact on classroom teachers as a whole, but did add another voice to the debate. And then in 1958, Paul Roberts published Understanding English, a text that presented a simplified explanation of the nature and processes of structural grammar. The resulting attention from university linguists, English educators and curriculum supervisors on all sides prompted the publication of Patterns of English (1956), a text designed for direct use in the high school classroom. As more teachers tried out the new structural and descriptive approach and as more English educators discussed it in their methods courses, the questions it raised challenging the traditional approach multiplied: 'Which grammar is best to teach?' 'What good does the learning of grammar do?' 'What is the place of usage in the course of English study?' For many years, usage was directly tied to grammar study, its rules based on those of Latinate, prescriptive grammar. The University of Wisconsin scholar, Robert C. Pooley, in Teaching English Usage (1946), introduced usage as a linguistic concept (a concept closer to the descriptive rather than prescriptive approach) and recommended the identification of 'appropriate levels of usage' instead of the 'Doctrine of Correctness' in usage teaching. (This doctrine had been created by British grammarians of the eighteenth century and had also been disseminated by Noah Webster in the Colonies.) And so another question was added to the professional debate: 'Which approach to usage is best to teach?' While both sides believed they could authoritatively answer the questions, none of the questions were resolved. In a related curricular area, the teaching of writing during this period was either shoved 'under the rug' or placed on the 'back burner'. Many teachers assigned a few themes, usually on such innocuous subjects as 'My Summer Vacation' or 'Why I am Going to College,' evaluated them with red pencil overkill and called that writing instruction. Others taught formal grammatical elements: labelling parts of speech, labelling parts of sentences, diagramming sentences and called that composition instruction. Still others assigned no writing at all to avoid the burden of heavy
< previous page
page_95
next page >
< previous page
page_96
next page > Page 96
paper load. As the end of this decade neared, composition in the public schools of the United States was in considerable difficulty. Literature Instruction Movement in literature instruction posed fewer dramatic confrontations than did language instruction. There was one area of controversy, however, and it has persisted to the present day much as the 'role of grammar' issue has in language instruction. During the mid 1950s, most of the debate on literary scholarship centred on historical approaches versus those of explication de texte. While the proponents of these two formidable schools of thought were 'squaring off' on university campuses and at meetings of the Modern Language Association of America (the principal scholarly organisation in the fields of modern languages and literature, including English), another force was gaining strength in the public schools. This force was in evidence largely in the junior high schools which, having had to evolve their own curriculum from the ground floor, had no tradition of literary choices to fall back on. Some literary bill of fare had to be found which would introduce students to literature and, at the same time. provide an appropriate transition for early adolescents from the reading to the study of literature. By the 1940s there were some unexpected rumblings on the horizon of literature for young people. A series of 'junior novels' written by serious authors expressly for a young adult audience began to emerge. Most of these novels attempted to develop significant themes around the world of adolescence, themes of the adolescent's growing up process through such milieu as sports, animals, travel, history and general adventure tales. Young adults responded with enthusiasm: teachers responded with hesitancy; critics flatly denied the value of the genre; and, as might be expected, young adult literature drew immediate fire from the Council for Basic Education. Critical criteria for judging such works began to take shape in the late 1950s with professional books examining the merits of the genre (Dwight Burton's 1959 text, Literature Study in the High Schools) and the merits of the books themselves (Dorothy Petitt's 1960 'A Study of the Qualities of Literary Excellence Which Characterizes Selected Fiction for Younger Adolescents'). This would culminate in the formulation of the Assembly on Literature for Adolescents (ALAN) by the National Council of Teachers of English (NCTE) in the early 1970s and the publication of the quarterly journal, ALAN Review, in 1978.
< previous page
page_96
next page >
< previous page
page_97
next page > Page 97
School Integration On September 23, 1957, Little Rock Central High School (Arkansas) was forcibly desegregated when 1,000 US soldiers accompanied a small number of frightened Black students through the front doors of the heretofore allwhite school. Little Rock caused a fundamental change to take place in American education because