Thermal Adaptation
This page intentionally left blank
Thermal Adaptation A Theoretical and Empirical Synthesis Mich...
126 downloads
2579 Views
6MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Thermal Adaptation
This page intentionally left blank
Thermal Adaptation A Theoretical and Empirical Synthesis Michael J. Angilletta Jr.
1
3
Great Clarendon Street, Oxford ox2 6dp Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford. It furthers the University’s objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education by publishing worldwide in Oxford New York Auckland Cape Town Dar es Salaam Hong Kong Karachi Kuala Lumpur Madrid Melbourne Mexico City Nairobi New Delhi Shanghai Taipei Toronto With offices in Argentina Austria Brazil Chile Czech Republic France Greece Guatemala Hungary Italy Japan Poland Portugal Singapore South Korea Switzerland Thailand Turkey Ukraine Vietnam Oxford is a registered trade mark of Oxford University Press in the UK and in certain other countries Published in the United States by Oxford University Press Inc., New York © Michael J. Angilletta Jr. 2009 The moral rights of the author have been asserted Database right Oxford University Press (maker) First Published 2009 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, without the prior permission in writing of Oxford University Press, or as expressly permitted by law, or under terms agreed with the appropriate reprographics rights organization. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside the scope of the above should be sent to the Rights Department, Oxford University Press, at the address above You must not circulate this book in any other binding or cover and you must impose the same condition on any acquirer British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data Data available Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data Data available Typeset by Newgen Imaging Systems (P) Ltd., Chennai, India Printed in Great Britain on acid-free paper by CPI Antony Rowe, Chippenham, Wiltshire ISBN 978–0–19–857087–5 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
978–0–19–857088–2
To Amy, Taylor, and Kyle, for your exceeding tolerance of my wild ideas.
This page intentionally left blank
Preface
The first book that I read as a graduate student was Foraging Theory (Stephens, D. W., and J. R. Krebs. 1986, Foraging Theory. Princeton, Princeton University Press). At the time, I was planning to study the evolution of foraging behavior in snakes, and thus wanted to acquire a conceptual background for this work. As fate would have it, my subsequent research did not focus on foraging behavior (or snakes), but the book made a lasting impression on me anyway. The authors laid out a comprehensive and insightful theory, moving from simple models to complex ones, while drawing on relevant empirical data. The book culminated in a rigorous appraisal of the field’s accomplishments, driven by the match between theoretical predictions and empirical observations. Had I pursued my interest in foraging biology, the book would surely have become my academic bible. Instead, I soon developed a greater interest in thermal biology, only to discover that no analogous resource existed for this discipline. I don’t want to give you the impression that little was known about thermal biology or that no one had attempted a conceptual synthesis. Neither impression would be accurate. In many respects, thermal biology has progressed tremendously, as one can conclude from reading an early synthesis of this topic (see Cossins, A. R., and K. B. Bowler. 1987, Temperature Biology of Animals. New York, Chapman and Hall). In other respects, though, thermal biology continues to lag behind other disciplines. Let me explain. When it comes to documenting patterns, few disciplines have made more progress than thermal biology. But if we judge progress by our understanding of the processes that generate these patterns, then we have much progress to make. While proximate explanations abound, ultimate explanations remain scarce. This problem stems
from the paucity of quantitative models of thermal adaptation. Thermal biologists have described patterns and documented effects to the point that empirical knowledge has far outstripped theoretical understanding. Most papers in thermal biology focus on empirical descriptions or rely on verbal arguments about adaptation. In comparison, consider the discipline of foraging biology that I referred to above; herein lies a trove of quantitative models and experimental tests about evolutionary hypotheses. The basic ideas about the evolution of foraging behavior were formulated in the 1960s and have been gradually developed to the point that the evolutionary impacts of many factors—from constraints on digestion to risks of predation—have been explored in great detail. Few evolutionary processes in thermal biology have been modeled to the same degree, and no major synthesis of evolutionary thermal biology has emerged. My aim is not to cast blame (for I would certainly share in this blame). Rather, I want to see thermal biology keep pace with other biological disciplines. And to do so, we must develop a quantitative theory of thermal adaptation. Upon closer inspection, a wealth of evolutionary models lie waiting for thermal biologists to adopt as their own. Beginning with Levins (Levins, R. 1968, Evolution in Changing Environments: Some Theoretical Explorations. Princeton, Princeton University Press), biologists have been modeling the evolution of quantitative traits in variable environments for more than four decades. With the growth of this theory, an increasing emphasis has been placed on genetic, developmental, and ecological issues. Many of the models can be applied to understand aspects of thermal adaptation. Although some of these models are mathematically intense, I have distilled from them the essence of what they tell us about adaptation to temperature. For thermal vii
viii
P R E FA C E
biologists, this book contains a synthesis of theory that should guide research in the coming decade. For evolutionary biologists, the book contains an evaluation of current models of evolution in variable environments. Throughout the book, you may notice a taxonomic bias. This bias stems from two factors. First, intentional bias resulted from my conceptual focus. The book revolves around the concept of a thermal performance curve, which describes the relationship between body temperature and organismal performance. Most of the book draws on studies of ectotherms because we can measure their performance curves more readily than we can measure those of endotherms. Students of endotherms will find the most relevant theoretical and empirical content in Chapter 4, but other chapters contain relevant theory. Second, some bias inevitably results from the lack of suitable data for certain taxa. In each chapter, I focused on the data most relevant to the theory. Consequently, certain chapters are rich with examples involving animals, plants, or microbes, but no chapter contains an even coverage of all of these groups. I hope this taxonomic bias reflects my effort to evaluate the theory more than my ignorance of the literature (although the latter seems inevitable given the exponential growth of knowledge). Above all, I tried to produce the kind of synthesis that I had longed for when I was a graduate student. If I succeeded in this effort, my success was due partly to the biologists who mentored me in my formative years: Justin Congdon, Art Dunham, Henry John-Alder, and Peter Petraitis. My views were also shaped by discussions or collaborations with George Bakken, Lauren Buckley, Ray Huey, Rob James, Joel Kingsolver, Bill Mitchell, Carlos Navas, Amanda Niehaus, Peter Niewiarowski, Warren Porter, Leslie Rissler, Mike Sears, Frank Seebacher, and Robbie Wilson. Many colleagues were kind enough to comment on sections of the book or provide information about their research: David Atkinson, George Bakken, Lauren Buckley,
Brandon Cooper, Lisa Crozier, Marcin Czarnołeski, Wilfried Gabriel, George Gilchrist, Lumír Gvoždík, Gabor Herczeg, Luke Hoekstra, Ray Huey, Jose Martín, Bill Mitchell, Mike Sears, Ben Williams, and Robbie Wilson. Their suggestions and insights contributed greatly to the final product. Other colleagues provided original images or permission to adapt figures: Martin Ackermann, Steve Beaupre, Gabriel Blouin-Demers, Lauren Buckley, Andy Clarke, Lisa Crozier, Michael Dillon, Wilfried Gabriel, Ted Garland, George Gilchrist, Bruce Grant, Brian Helmuth, Ray Huey, Jacob Johansson, Joel Kingsolver, Mark Kirkpatrick, Michael Kopp, Sue Mitchell, Carlos Navas, Mark New, Camille Parmesan, Steve Piper, Mike Sears, Tim Shreeve, Gian-Reto Walther, and Kazunori Yamahira. Finally, the preparation of this book was greatly accelerated by the help of Angela Borchelt and Phaedra Seraphimidi, who obtained copyright permissions for the figures adapted from other sources. An undertaking of this magnitude requires the support and encouragement of many people. I am greatly indebted to my colleagues at Indiana State University, who picked up the slack for me during my sabbatical. The chair of my department, Charles Amlaner, kept my teaching load in check during the remainder of my writing. The Lilly Foundation and the Office of the Provost at Indiana State University provided financial support. I owe an equal debt to the students who kept my lab productive despite my reallocation of energy from research to writing: Dee Asbury, Brandon Cooper, Joe Ehrenberger, Matt Schuler, Somayeh Semati, Melissa Storm, and Ben Williams. Most of all, I thank my family—Amy, Taylor, and Kyle. They kindly endured my crazy work schedule and my occasional stress responses. I would not have completed this book without their patience and understanding. Michael J. Angilletta Jr. May 24, 2008 Terre Haute, Indiana, USA
Contents
Preface
vii
1
Evolutionary Thermal Biology 1.1 The challenge of evolutionary thermal biology 1.2 Thermal reaction norms 1.3 The role of theory 1.4 Theoretical approaches to evolutionary thermal biology 1.4.1 Optimality models 1.4.2 Quantitative genetic models 1.4.3 Allelic models 1.4.4 The complementarity of theory 1.5 Empirical tools of the evolutionary thermal biologist 1.5.1 Quantifying selection 1.5.2 Experimental evolution 1.5.3 Comparative analysis 1.6 Conclusions
1 1 3 5 6 6 8 10 13 13 14 14 15 18
2
Thermal Heterogeneity 2.1 Operative environmental temperature 2.2 Global patterns of operative temperature 2.2.1 Latitudinal clines 2.2.2 Altitudinal clines 2.3 Quantifying local variation in operative temperatures 2.3.1 Mathematical models 2.3.2 Physical models 2.3.3 Statistical models 2.4 Conclusions
19 20 23 23 27 29 29 31 32 33
3
Thermal Sensitivity 3.1 Patterns of thermal sensitivity 3.2 Proximate mechanisms and tradeoffs 3.2.1 Thermal effects on enzymes (and other proteins) 3.2.2 Membrane structure 3.2.3 Oxygen limitation 3.2.4 Conclusions from considering proximate mechanisms 3.3 Optimal performance curves 3.3.1 Optimal performance curves: survivorship and related performances 3.3.2 Optimal performance curves: fecundity and related performances 3.3.3 Contrasting the two models
35 35 40 41 43 44 45 47 47 51 53 ix
x
CONTENTS
3.4
Using models to understand natural patterns 3.4.1 Survivorship 3.4.2 Locomotion 3.4.3 Development 3.4.4 Growth 3.4.5 Reproduction 3.4.6 Why do certain patterns differ from predicted ones? 3.5 Have we mischaracterized thermal clines? 3.5.1 Reciprocal transplant experiments 3.5.2 Laboratory selection experiments 3.5.3 Conclusions from reciprocal transplant and laboratory selection experiments 3.6 Have phenotypic constraints been correctly identified? 3.6.1 A jack of all temperatures can be a master of all 3.6.2 The proximate basis of performance determines tradeoffs 3.7 Do all performances affect fitness? 3.8 Does genetic variation constrain thermal adaptation? 3.8.1 A quantitative genetic model based on multivariate selection theory 3.8.2 A genetic model for survivorship and related performances 3.8.3 A genetic model for fecundity and related performances 3.8.4 Predictions of quantitative genetic models depend on genetic parameters 3.9 Does gene flow constrain thermal adaptation? 3.10 Conclusions
54 56 62 66 66 68 69 70 70 71 74 75 75 75 76 79 81 81 83 84 85 87
4
Thermoregulation 4.1 Quantifying patterns of thermoregulation 4.2 Benefits and costs of thermoregulation 4.2.1 Benefits of thermoregulation 4.2.2 Costs of thermoregulation 4.3 An optimality model of thermoregulation 4.4 Do organisms thermoregulate more precisely when the benefits are greater? 4.5 Nonenergetic benefits of thermoregulation 4.5.1 Thermoregulation during infection 4.5.2 Thermoregulation during pregnancy 4.6 Do organisms thermoregulate less precisely when the costs are greater? 4.7 Nonenergetic costs of thermoregulation 4.7.1 Aggressive interactions with competitors 4.7.2 Risk of predation or parasitism 4.7.3 Risk of desiccation 4.7.4 Missed opportunities for feeding or reproduction 4.7.5 Interactions between different costs 4.8 Endothermic thermoregulation 4.8.1 The evolutionary origins of endothermy 4.8.2 Optimal thermoregulation by endotherms 4.9 Conclusions
88 88 91 91 96 98 102 105 105 106 107 111 111 112 116 116 118 119 119 122 125
5
Thermal Acclimation 5.1 Patterns of thermal acclimation 5.2 The beneficial acclimation hypothesis 5.2.1 Developmental acclimation 5.2.2 Reversible acclimation 5.2.3 Beyond the beneficial acclimation hypothesis
126 126 127 127 131 135
CONTENTS
5.3
5.4
5.5
5.6
5.7 5.8
Costs of thermal acclimation 5.3.1 Costs of energetic demands 5.3.2 Costs of time lags 5.3.3 Interaction between costs Optimal acclimation of performance curves 5.4.1 Optimal developmental acclimation 5.4.2 Optimal reversible acclimation 5.4.3 Relaxing assumptions about fitness Evidence of optimal acclimation 5.5.1 Does the thermal optimum acclimate more than the performance breadth? 5.5.2 Do organisms from variable environments acclimate more than organisms from stable environments? Constraints on the evolution of acclimation 5.6.1 Genetic variance and covariance 5.6.2 Gene flow Toward ecological relevance Conclusions
xi
135 136 139 139 140 141 143 145 146 146 146 149 149 152 154 155
6
Temperature and the Life History 6.1 The link between performance and the life history 6.2 General patterns of age and size at maturity 6.2.1 Thermal plasticity of age and size at maturity 6.2.2 Thermal clines in age and size at maturity 6.2.3 Experimental evolution of age and size at maturity 6.3 Optimal reaction norms for age and size at maturity 6.3.1 A comparison of two modeling approaches 6.3.2 Thermal effects on juvenile mortality 6.3.3 Thermal constraints on maximal body size 6.3.4 Thermal effects on population growth 6.3.5 A synergy of evolutionary mechanisms 6.4 General patterns of reproductive allocation 6.4.1 Thermal plasticity of offspring size 6.4.2 Thermal clines in offspring size 6.4.3 Experimental evolution of offspring size 6.5 Optimal size and number of offspring 6.5.1 Direct effect of temperature on the optimal offspring size 6.5.2 Indirect effects of temperature on the optimal offspring size 6.5.3 Teasing apart direct and indirect effects on reproductive allocation 6.6 Optimal variation in offspring size 6.7 Conclusions
157 157 158 158 159 161 162 163 164 166 169 170 171 171 171 172 174 174 176 177 178 179
7
Thermal Coadaptation 7.1 Traits interact to determine fitness 7.2 Coadaptation of thermal sensitivity and thermal acclimation 7.3 Coadaptation of thermal physiology and thermoregulatory behavior 7.3.1 Mechanisms favoring a mismatch between preferred temperatures and thermal optima 7.3.2 Predicting coadapted phenotypes 7.4 Coadaptation of thermoregulatory behavior, thermal physiology, and life history 7.5 Constraints on coadaptation 7.6 Conclusions
181 181 182 186 189 193 195 196 196
xii
CONTENTS
8
Thermal Games 8.1 Filling the ecological vacuum 8.2 Approaches to the study of frequency-dependent selection 8.3 Optimal thermoregulation in an evolutionary game 8.3.1 Competition during thermoregulation 8.3.2 Predation during thermoregulation 8.3.3 Relaxing assumptions of simple models 8.4 Optimal performance curves in an evolutionary game 8.4.1 The coevolution of thermal optima between species 8.4.2 The coevolution of thermal breadths between species 8.4.3 Gene flow and the coevolution of thermal optima 8.5 Life-history evolution in a thermal game 8.6 Conclusions
199 199 200 200 201 203 205 207 207 210 211 212 213
9
Adaptation to Anthropogenic Climate Change 9.1 Recent patterns of climate change 9.1.1 Global change 9.1.2 Regional change 9.1.3 Local change 9.2 Observed responses to recent thermal change 9.2.1 Shifts in phenology 9.2.2 Shifts in geographic ranges 9.2.3 Disruption of ecological interactions 9.2.4 Changes in primary productivity 9.3 Predicting ecological responses to global warming 9.3.1 Correlative versus mechanistic models 9.3.2 Mechanistic models of responses to environmental warming 9.3.3 Predicting differential responses of populations and species 9.4 Adaptation to directional thermal change 9.4.1 Adaptation of thermoregulation 9.4.2 Adaptation of the thermal optimum 9.4.3 Adaptation of the performance breadth 9.5 Thermal games in a warming world 9.6 Evolutionary consequences of gene flow in a warming world 9.6.1 Spatially heterogeneous warming can reduce the flow of maladapted genotypes 9.6.2 Spatially heterogeneous warming can increase the flow of preadapted genotypes 9.7 Conclusions
214 214 214 215 216 216 216 217 217 218 218 219 220 223 224 227 229 231 232 233 233 235 236
References
238
Author Index
277
Species Index
283
Subject Index
285
CHAPTER 1
Evolutionary Thermal Biology
1.1 The challenge of evolutionary thermal biology Of the hundreds of variables that can shape the phenotype of an organism, temperature has undoubtedly captured more than its share of attention.1 Biologists have linked temperature to everything from temporal patterns of growth, survival, and reproduction (Angilletta et al. 2002a; Huey and Stevenson 1979; Savage et al. 2004) to spatial patterns of body size, population density, and species diversity (Angilletta et al. 2004a; Brown et al. 2004; Wiens et al. 2006). Unlike many other variables that concern biologists, temperature is not just a property of life; it is a property of matter. Nothing escapes its control. Still, the same change in temperature will not affect all organisms equally. Moreover, temperature does not affect the same organism equally at all stages of the life cycle. These phenomena raise serious questions for biologists. To what extent does this phenotypic variation reflect adaptation to temperature? And what
1
Thermal biologists often make sweeping statements of this nature, but what evidence do we have to back up this view? I became curious while working on this book, so I performed a simple analysis using the ISI Web of Science. Twelve other wellstudied variables were chosen as key words, representing both abiotic and biotic factors: competitors (or competition), energy, food, light, nitrogen, oxygen, parasites (or parasitism), pH, predators (or predation), pressure, salinity, and water. To limit the number of extraneous references, I used the term “biology” in conjunction with the environmental variable (e.g., “temperature and biology”); I have no reason to think this approach would bias the outcome. Since 1945, more than 3568 papers have used the terms “temperature” and “biology.” Temperature ranks third on the list, behind water (4369) and light (3723) but well ahead of food (3029), pressure (1920), parasites (1917), oxygen (1769), predators (1621), and other variables (<1500 each).
processes facilitate or constrain this thermal adaptation? To answer these questions, we must first identify the specific phenotypes that we seek to explain. Strategies for coping with thermal heterogeneity define a continuum of two dimensions (Fig. 1.1). The first dimension describes the degree to which an organism’s performance depends on its temperature (thermosensitivity or thermal sensitivity), ranging from organisms whose performance depends strongly on temperature (thermal specialists) to organisms that perform well over a broad range of temperatures (thermal generalists). The second dimension describes the degree to which an organism regulates its temperature (thermoregulation), ranging from organisms that maintain a nearly constant body temperature (perfect thermoregulators) to organisms that conform to their environmental temperature (perfect thermoconformers). All organisms fall somewhere within the continuum bounded by these axes. For example, most mammals and birds are thermal specialists that thermoregulate precisely (Cossins and Bowler 1987). Certain fish, such as those that live in the intertidal zone, are thermal generalists that can undergo dramatic fluctuations in temperature during a single day (Somero et al. 1996). The position of an organism along this continuum can change over time. In fact, an individual can be a specialist during specific seasons but a generalist over the course of a year. Thus, strategies for coping with thermal heterogeneity include irreversible and reversible forms of phenotypic plasticity. These strategies determine the life histories of organisms by limiting their acquisition and allocation of resources. The relationships among thermosensitivity, thermoregulation, and the life history govern the course of adaptation in variable environments. 1
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
Th Sp er ec m ial os ist en s
Ge ne ra l
iti
vi ty
is t
2
1 3
2
7b
7a 4
P ther erfect mor egu lato r
The
rmo
regu
5
latio
n
Figure 1.1 Strategies of coping with thermal heterogeneity include different combinations of thermosensitivity and thermoregulation. The shaded regions depict the strategic sets of hypothetical species; intraspecific variation determines the areas of these sets. A strategic set can change seasonally or ontogenetically, as exemplified by the arrow connecting two sets for the same species (7a and 7b).
6
ther Perfect moc onfo rme r
Although a vast and venerable literature documents the scope of these strategies, we still do not understand why certain species exhibit certain phenotypes. Why do some organisms function over a wide range of temperature when other organisms do not? Why do some organisms adjust their thermosensitivity in response to extreme or fluctuating temperatures when other organisms do not? I think most biologists would agree that the answers to these questions involve adaptation. Still, we would be hard pressed to provide rigorous answers at this time. How can we know so much about the thermal biology of organisms, yet know so little about its evolution? I believe progress in evolutionary thermal biology has lagged behind progress in other evolutionary disciplines because of the paucity and simplicity of our theoretical models.2 In fact, few investigations have been directly motivated by quantitative models. And even fewer have been motivated by the desire to distinguish between two or more competing models. In the literature on thermal biology, empirical descriptions of patterns probably outnumber quantitative models of evolution by more than
100 to one. This situation partly resulted from historical factors. The study of thermal biology has its roots in ecological physiology (Bennett 1987a), which has always been a relatively empirical discipline.3 Only recently have ecological physiologists seriously shifted their attention from questions concerning what, when, and how to ponder the question of why. This conceptual transition catalyzed the origin of evolutionary physiology, which has flourished in recent decades (Burggren and Bemis 1990; Feder et al. 2000; Garland and Carter 1994; Magnum and Hochachaka 1998). Despite this shift in focus, empirical observations have continued to accumulate far more rapidly than have theoretical ideas. Today, the limited number of quantitative models prevents effective application of the scientific method to evolutionary thermal biology (see Hilborn and Mangel 1997). In this book, we shall draw on models from the general discipline of evolutionary biology to gain rigorous insights about thermal adaptation. First, we must construct a framework for understanding
3
2
Although you may view this statement as a harsh criticism, you should consider the role of quantitative models in a comparable discipline to appreciate my point. For example, biologists who study how organisms adapt to variation in the quantity and quality of food have made tremendous progress over the past few decades, largely because of the development and application of theoretical models (reviewed by Kamil et al. 1987; Stephens et al. 2007; Stephens and Krebs 1986).
As an aside, I believe the controversy surrounding the metabolic theory of ecology stems from its unique attempt to explain a wealth of physiological data with a simple mathematical model (see Brown et al. 2004). Despite the need for caution when invoking such unifying theories, opponents of the metabolic theory seem oblivious to the fact that no alternative model currently offers greater predictive power. Perhaps the strong reaction to this theory reflects the mindset of ecological physiologists as much as it reflects limitations of the models.
E V O L U T I O N A RY T H E R M A L B I O L O G Y
thermal adaptation that integrates current theoretical paradigms and modern empirical approaches. Then, we can use this framework to explore the structure of current theory and the level of empirical support; this exploration will begin with models that consider mechanisms operating at the organismal level and build up to models that account for the interactions among organisms. Along the way, we shall draw on biochemical and genetic evidence to validate key assumptions. By synthesizing models of behavioral, physiological, and life-historical evolution, we should advance toward a general theory of thermal adaptation. By the end of the book, we will have addressed many questions concerning thermal adaptation: 1. How do organisms experience thermal heterogeneity in their environment? Do different organisms perceive the same thermal environment differently? If so, how do we define the operative environment experienced by a particular organism? (Chapter 2) 2. Why do some organisms function over a wide range of temperatures, while others function only within a relatively narrow range? (Chapter 3) 3. Why do some organisms regulate their body temperature within narrow limits, while others conform to environmental temperatures? (Chapter 4) 4. Why do some organisms possess a capacity to reversibly or irreversibly alter their sensitivity to temperature, while other organisms do not? (Chapter 5) 5. Despite the diversity of behavioral and physiological responses to temperature, why do general relationships exist between environmental temperature and the life history? (Chapter 6) 6. Can we answer the preceding questions independently, or must we consider the evolutionary interactions among thermosensitivity, thermoregulation, and the life history? (Chapter 7) 7. Can we understand thermal adaptation without considering the interactions among individuals of one or more species? (Chapter 8) 8. Can a theory of thermal adaptation help us to predict the biological consequences of anthropogenic climate change? (Chapter 9) Any effort to address this many questions in a single book can succeed only with some focus. This
3
focus could take one of several forms—taxonomic, methodological, or conceptual. I have chosen a conceptual focus: the thermal reaction norm. All of the models presented in this book describe the evolution of some type of thermal reaction norm. Therefore, we must start by defining this fundamental concept and recognizing its strengths and limitations.
1.2 Thermal reaction norms Thermal responses at all levels of biological organization are best described as phenotypic plasticity. The study of phenotypic plasticity has a long and complex history (Sarkar 2004; Schlichting and Pigliucci 1998), but most research in this area has been guided by the concept of a reaction norm. A reaction norm describes the relationship between a continuous environmental variable and a continuous phenotypic variable (see reviews by Gotthard and Nylin 1995; Schlichting and Pigliucci 1998; Stearns 1989; West-Eberhard 2003). A thermal reaction norm represents a special case in which the environmental variable is temperature. In practice, any aspect of behavior, physiology, morphology, or life history can be viewed in the context of a thermal reaction norm (DeWitt and Scheiner 2004; Stearns 1989). Although biologists define plasticity in numerous ways (Debat and David 2001), I define plasticity as the derivative of a reaction norm (Fig. 1.2). For a linear reaction norm, plasticity simply equals the slope of the function. For a nonlinear reaction norm, the concept of plasticity becomes muddled as the slope of the function depends on the temperature of interest. A trait unaffected by temperature has no plasticity, but this trait still has a reaction norm; the slope of this reaction norm equals zero and the intercept equals the mean value of the trait. Given this definition of plasticity, we can compare plasticities among traits or taxa. Moreover, we can quantify the evolution of plasticity for specific traits. The trait of interest affects the way we conceptualize and quantify a thermal reaction norm. Some traits, such as growth rate, change repeatedly in response to temperature (labile traits). Other traits, such as the number of body segments, become fixed during development (fixed traits). For a labile trait,
4
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
(a)
(a) Cold specialist
Low plasticity
Phenotype
Phenotype
No plasticity
Heat specialist
Generalist
High plasticity Body temperature High Low plasticity plasticity
(b) Parameter describing thermal sensitivity
High plasticity
Phenotype
(b)
Body temperature Figure 1.2 The derivative of a reaction norm quantifies the thermal plasticity. For linear reaction norms (a), plasticity remains constant over a broad range of temperatures, but can vary among genotypes. For nonlinear reaction norms (b), the plasticity expressed by a single genotype depends on the range of temperatures.
we can measure the change in the trait of an individual exposed to a range of temperatures (Fig. 1.3a). Such studies are usually designed to avoid confounding the temperature and time of measurement (e.g., randomizing the order of measurements solves this problem). Reaction norms for labile traits often depend on the developmental environment of the organism, such as its developmental temperature. In other words, thermal plasticity itself can undergo plasticity! To quantify this “plasticity of plasticity,” we can examine the relationship between the developmental temperature and the thermal sensitivity after development (Fig. 1.3b). For a fixed trait, a reaction norm must be estimated from measures of relatives raised at different temperatures. Using a group of distantly related individuals would yield a generalized reaction norm (Sarkar and Fuller 2003), which includes phenotypic variation among genotypes. Using clones or siblings would yield a more accurate reaction norm. Reaction norms
Developmental temperature Figure 1.3 Thermal reaction norms characterize many different kinds of traits. (a) For labile traits, instantaneous (or short-term) fluctuations in body temperature affect the phenotype. (b) Thermal reaction norms can change via acclimation; such changes are described as plasticity in the parameters that define the reaction norm shown in (a).
for fixed traits usually describe the influence of the mean developmental temperature. If thermal fluctuations are important, we can construct a multivariate reaction norm that describes the phenotype as a function of the mean and the variance of temperature (Fig. 1.4). This diversity of applications underscores the conceptual value of the reaction norm. How can we know whether thermal reaction norms were produced by adaptation? To acquire such knowledge, we must construct predictive models of evolution and apply these models to the study of thermal plasticity. In other words, we must develop a theory of thermal adaptation. With this goal in mind, the remainder of this chapter focuses on the role of theory in evolutionary thermal biology.
Phenotype
E V O L U T I O N A RY T H E R M A L B I O L O G Y
40 Va ria 30 nce of te
40 30 10 re
10
an
Me
ure
rat
20
20 mp era tu
e mp
te
Figure 1.4 A multivariate reaction norm can describe the influence of the mean and the variance of developmental temperature on a fixed trait. In this hypothetical example, a univariate reaction norm would give an incomplete view of thermal plasticity because of the interaction between the mean and the variance of temperature.
1.3 The role of theory In his book Evolution in Changing Environments, Richard Levins (1968) opened with a visionary discussion of the role of theory in biology. He predicted that theoretical biology, an emerging discipline at the time, would soon disappear. I interpret his argument as follows. Science has always been a process of building and evaluating models of how nature works. But some biologists had lost sight of this reality, which eventually fueled a movement to bring theoretical direction to empirical research. Levins reasoned that, as more biologists accepted the need for theory, the distinction between theoretical biology and empirical biology would dissolve. In Levins’ own words, “once it [theoretical biology] has made its points part of the thinking of biology in general, it will loose [sic] its identity as a distinct field” (p. 4). Sadly, Levins’ admirable vision did not come to pass. Even today, a fairly wide rift separates biologists who conduct theoretical research from those who conduct empirical research. I shall voice an extreme view (hopefully, one that Levins would espouse): scientific understanding advances most rapidly when researchers combine theory and empiricism. At the very least, we need a reciprocal exchange of ideas between theorists and empiricists;
5
theorists should model processes in light of previous observations and empiricists should collect data that address current models. My motivation for writing this book was to bridge the gap between theorists and empiricists who study thermal adaptation. To achieve this goal, I must convince you that progress in evolutionary thermal biology hinges on this connection. As a first step, I should elaborate my view on the interplay between models and data. A theory consists of a group of models describing related phenomena (e.g., foraging theory). Each model describes a set of mechanisms proposed to explain the phenomena. These models inspire the hypotheses and experiments that capture the attention, time, and energy of biologists. Yet, different forms of modeling exist and not all of these forms can offer the same degree of insight. Indeed, models differ greatly in the clarity of their assumptions and the precision of their predictions. Most models can be characterized as verbal, graphical, or mathematical. A verbal model is a textual description of the modeler’s ideas. Generally, the assumptions of a verbal model are implicit. Furthermore, its predictions would be qualitative and could be inaccurate if the modeler has not processed his assumptions carefully. Because of this imprecision, we cannot easily evaluate and refine verbal models. A graphical model depicts a set of relationships among variables plotted in Euclidean space. Although the assumptions of a graphical model are also implicit, one can infer them by analyzing the graph. The predictions of the model can be qualitative or quantitative depending on whether the modeler has specified numerical values of the variables. Finally, a mathematical model embodies the assumptions of the modeler in an algebraic form. The relationships among variables and the units of measurement are defined explicitly. As such, mathematical models embody clear assumptions and deliver precise predictions. In this book, I focus primarily on mathematical models rather than verbal or graphical models. This focus does not imply that mathematical models provide the best representations of truth; in fact, they do not (see Lakoff and Núñez 2000). All models, including mathematical ones, represent caricatures of nature more than illustrations of truth (Hilborn and Mangel 1997). But the explicit assumptions
6
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
of mathematical models enable other biologists to (1) verify the validity of those assumptions and (2) generate competing models by altering the assumptions. Furthermore, mathematical models generate more comprehensive and more precise predictions, which facilitate distinctions among competing models that make qualitatively identical predictions under certain conditions. We can evaluate a model in one of two ways. First, we can validate the critical assumptions of the model. Acritical assumption determines the model’s qualitative behavior. Relaxing some assumptions will cause only quantitative changes in behavior, but a critical assumption underlies some unique prediction. If this assumption proves false, the prediction would also be false. Second, we can compare independent observations with the predictions of the model. By independent observations, I mean data that were not used to formulate or parameterize the model. Throughout the book, I adopt both approaches to evaluate models. Rather than evaluate one model at a time, we gain deeper insights by directly comparing the performances of two or more models (Chamberlin 1890). In the traditional statistical paradigm, the prediction of a single model is pitted against a null hypothesis, which generally states that no pattern or effect should be observed. Presumably, rejection of the null hypothesis implies support for the model (also known as affirming the consequent). Unfortunately, many other models could have made a prediction similar to that of the model in question. Thus, competition between an evolutionary model and a null model provides only weak support for a theoretical idea (Anderson et al. 2000; Oreskes et al. 1994). Competition between two or more evolutionary models always yields a more fruitful outcome. For example, competition between mutually exclusive models eliminates some ideas from the set of possibilities. In this way, each experiment brings us closer to identifying the best available model (Platt 1964). When a set of models describes mutually inclusive mechanisms, we can still infer the relative importance of each mechanism (Quinn and Dunham 1983). Today, we can choose from several statistical paradigms, such as information theory (Burnham and Anderson 2002) or Bayesian theory (Ellison 2004), to directly compare the performance
of two or more models (reviewed by Johnson and Omland 2004). These paradigms enable us to formally rank a set of models by their ability to describe the data. But even an informal comparison of models is better than no comparison at all. Therefore, let us examine the kinds of theoretical models available for the study of thermal adaptation.
1.4 Theoretical approaches to evolutionary thermal biology Three distinct modeling approaches will appear throughout this book: optimality models, quantitative genetic models, and allelic models (Berrigan and Scheiner 2004; Scheiner 1993). Each of these approaches possesses unique strengths, yet each also imposes some limitations. In this section, I outline the basic features of these three approaches. While doing so, I highlight the way that each approach informs us about thermal adaptation.
1.4.1 Optimality models An optimality model describes the phenotype that maximizes fitness in a given environment (Box 1.1). This goal is accomplished by combining two mathematical functions: (1) a phenotypic function that defines the set of possible phenotypes and (2) a fitness function that relates these phenotypes to fitness in given environments (Maynard Smith 1978; Mitchell and Valone 1990). Combining the phenotypic and fitness functions enables one to map the fitness landscape—a graphical depiction of the relationship between potential phenotypes and their fitness. A fitness landscape tells us the direction and strength of natural selection given the current phenotype. Under certain conditions (described below), natural selection would ultimately yield the phenotype that maximizes fitness (i.e., the optimal phenotype). The heart of an optimality model is a set of assumptions about the tradeoffs that constrain the phenotype (Mitchell and Valone 1990), sometimes referred to as functional constraints (Arnold 1992). Biologists often consider one of two classes of tradeoffs: allocation tradeoffs or acquisition tradeoffs. An allocation tradeoff occurs when an increment in resources allocated to one function results in a decrement in resources allocated to other functions (Heino
E V O L U T I O N A RY T H E R M A L B I O L O G Y
7
Box 1.1 Types of optimality models Optimality models are divided into three classes: static, dynamic, and frequency dependent (Maynard Smith 1978). Below, these classes are described in order of increasing complexity. Static optimization Static models optimize one or more variables in an environment that does not change over time. Do not equate static with deterministic; the optimal strategy could depend on probabilities (e.g., the daily probability of surviving), but these probabilities would remain constant. Static optimization requires the use of differential calculus to determine the phenotypic value that maximizes fitness (or some proxy for fitness). Dynamic optimization Dynamic models optimize one or more variables in an environment (internal or external) that changes over time.
and Kaitala 1999; Kozłowski 1992). An acquisition tradeoff occurs when an increase in the duration or intensity of foraging results in an increase in the probability of being injured or killed (Lima and Dill 1990). Support for a model indirectly supports the importance of the specified tradeoffs. When modeling thermal reaction norms, we must consider additional tradeoffs. Models of optimal reaction norms define the degree of plasticity that maximizes fitness in a variable environment. Because all optimality models link environments, phenotypes, and fitness, any model can predict the optimal reaction norm when two conditions hold: (1) the phenotype expressed in one environment does not constrain the phenotypes expressed in other environments and (2) plasticity imposes no decrease in survivorship or loss of energy. We would merely predict the optimal phenotype in each of several environments and connect the points to define a reaction norm. But this approach ignores potentially important constraints on the evolution of thermal reaction norms. For example, a specialist–generalist tradeoff occurs when a phenotype that improves fitness at one temperature also reduces fitness at
In a dynamic model, the organism makes sequential decisions. These decisions cause changes in variables that describe the state of the environment or the organism. For example, a dynamic optimization of reproduction involves rates of energy intake and expenditure that increase with body size (a phenotypic state variable). Dynamic optimization usually requires the application of optimal control theory, such as dynamic programming. Frequency-dependent optimization When the fitness of a strategy depends on the strategies adopted by other individuals (i.e., frequency-dependent selection), one must take a game theoretic approach to optimization (Maynard Smith 1982; Nowak and Sigmund 2004). In game theory, the optimal strategy cannot be invaded by any alternative strategy—hence it is called an evolutionarily stable strategy. As we shall see in Chapter 8, the evolutionarily stable strategy often deviates from the optimal strategy under frequency-independent selection.
another temperature (Levins 1968; Palaima 2007). Additionally, various costs of plasticity can affect the optimal reaction norm (reviewed by DeWitt et al. 1998; Schlichting and Pigliucci 1998). Hence, the optimal reaction norm in a variable environment often deviates from the optimal phenotype in a constant environment. Optimality models comprise two kinds of assumptions: hard-core and strategic assumptions (Mitchell and Valone 1990). The hard-core assumptions are the foundation of the optimization research program and thus are the same for all models: 1. Mutation generates a small number of new phenotypes each generation. 2. Different phenotypes yield different fitnesses. 3. Populations of phenotypes typically reside near a stable equilibrium. 4. The relative fitnesses of phenotypes near the stable equilibrium are not influenced by the way these phenotypes are transmitted genetically. The strategic assumptions depend on the specific problem under investigation and thus differ among models. Strategic assumptions are related to either
8
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
(1) the constraints on the phenotype or (2) the way the phenotype determines fitness. As an example of the former, many optimality models of thermal adaptation assume that organisms cannot enhance function at high temperatures without sacrificing function at low temperatures (see Chapter 3). Other optimality models assume that organisms possess a fixed quantity of energy at any time (see Chapter 6). Either of these assumptions would constrain the set of possible phenotypes. As an example of the latter, an optimality model could describe fitness as the product of survivorship and fecundity. Alternatively, one might assume survivorship remains constant and fecundity increases with body size; hence, size at maturity would be considered an adequate proxy for fitness. Strategic assumptions usually determine the qualitative behavior of the model. The failure of an optimality model to predict the observed phenotypes indicates a violation of at least one strategic or hard-core assumption. First, the hypothesized tradeoffs might be incorrect or incomplete. Second, the mapping between the phenotype and fitness might be incorrect, or fitness might be defined incorrectly. Finally, we might question the hard-core assumptions, which are necessary for selection to maintain the optimal phenotype. Genetic drift impedes adaptation in small populations (Holt 1990), and mutation drives phenotypes away from the optimum when natural selection is weak (Gilchrist and Kingsolver 2001). Persistent gene flow along an environmental cline swamps a population with deleterious genes, despite strong selection in local environments (Lenormand 2002). Moreover, natural selection produces few evolutionary changes when phenotypic variation lacks a genetic basis (Arnold 1992). In the end, we might have to model these additional factors that constrain thermal adaptation. Let us now consider some approaches that emphasize the role of genetic constraints during adaptation.
1.4.2 Quantitative genetic models Quantitative genetic models enable us to relax some of the hard-core assumptions of optimality models and examine the evolutionary dynamics of traits. In quantitative genetic models, traits are determined
by many genes, each of which has a small quantitative effect on the phenotype (Gillespie 2004; Rice 2004). This theory partitions phenotypic variance into genetic and environmental components. In his seminal book, Ronald Fisher (1930) showed that the mean fitness of a population increases in proportion to the genetic component of phenotypic variation. In particular, he distinguished between the additive and nonadditive effects of alleles. Only the additive portion of genetic variation contributes to the evolution of fitness; the nonadditive portion stems from interactions among genes (dominance and epistasis), which are altered by recombination. Thus, the phenotypic variance (VP ) must be partitioned as VP = VG + VE ,
(1.1)
where VG equals the variance attributable to genetic effects and VE equals the variance attributable to environmental effects. If we assume only additive genetic effects exist, the heritability of the phenotype (h2 ) equals the proportion of variance caused by genetic effects: h2 =
VG VG = . VP VG + V E
(1.2)
Thus, the value of a phenotype depends not only on genes but also on environmental factors, such as temperature. When the effect of the environment on the phenotype depends on the genotype, a genotype-by-environment interaction exists. In such cases, a better model for partitioning the phenotypic variance would be VP = VG + VE + (VG×E ) + VError ,
(1.3)
where VG×E equals the variance caused by the interaction between genes and the environment—i.e., the genetic variance in phenotypic plasticity. Statistical methods can partition the components of variance and estimate the magnitude of the genotype-byenvironment interaction (Lynch and Walsh 1998). With this framework alone, researchers have quantified genetic variation in thermal reaction norms (e.g., Scheiner and Lyman 1991), but predicting their evolution requires (1) a more precise means of estimating genetic variances and (2) a significant advance in modeling selection. Both advances were made during the development of multivariate selection theory (Via and Lande 1985).
E V O L U T I O N A RY T H E R M A L B I O L O G Y
Multivariate selection theory enables us to predict the evolution of thermal reaction norms under genetic constraints (reviewed by Arnold 1994). At the root of this theory lies a model of the simultaneous evolution of two or more traits (Lande 1979; Lande and Arnold 1983). This model describes change in the phenotype as a function of selective pressure (estimated by selection gradients) and genetic variation (estimated by genetic variances and covariances): Z = βG,
(1.4)
where Z equals a vector of changes in phenotypic values, β equals a vector of selection gradients, and G equals a matrix of genetic variances and covariances. For example, the evolution of three traits would be represented by Z1 β1 G11 G12 G13 Z2 = β2 G21 G22 G23 , (1.5) Z3
β3
G31
G32
G33
where Zi equals the change in trait i, β i equals the selection gradient for trait i, Gii equals the genetic variance of trait i, and Gij equals the genetic covariance between traits i and j. A selection gradient equals the partial derivative of relative fitness with respect to the phenotype; in other words, a selection gradient measures the change in fitness that results from a very small change in the phenotype. In the special case of directional selection, the selection gradient equals a constant. In the case of stabilizing or disruptive selection, however, the selection gradient varies with the phenotypic value. The genetic variance in eqn 1.5 equals the additive genetic variance described by Fisher (VG of eqn 1.2); thus, the rate of adaptation will be proportional to the genetic variance. Many factors can limit the genetic variance of a trait (Table 1.1). The genetic covariance between two traits determines how the selection of one trait will influence the evolution of another trait. For example, when the genetic covariance is negative (Gij < 0), selecting a larger phenotypic value of trait j will decrease the phenotypic value of trait i. Genetic covariances result from several mechanisms, including linkage disequilibrium, pleiotropy, and developmental modularity (Lynch and Walsh 1998; West-Eberhard 2003).
9
Table 1.1 Factors that reduce the genetic variance of a specific trait 1. Persistently small population leads to loss of variation by genetic drift 2. Mutational effects are skewed by mechanistic/physiological constraints 3. Small target of mutation lowers the rate of mutation 4. Mutation rates are unusually low 5. New allelic associations are not frequently formed by recombination 6. The phenotype is canalized during development despite mutations 7. The trait is genetically correlated with another trait under selection 8. The same genotype has the highest fitness in all environments 9. Continuous directional selection leads to fixation of favored alleles Modified with permission from Blows and Hoffman (2005).
To use multivariate selection theory, we must represent a thermal reaction norm as a set of traits with genetic variances and covariances. Several approaches exist for translating a reaction norm into a set of traits: (1) the character-based approach, (2) the parameter-based approach, (3) the characteristic value-based approach, and (4) the function-based approach. Although these approaches should produce similar results (de Jong 1995), they involve different mechanics. In the character-based approach, one treats the same trait measured at multiple temperatures as equivalent to multiple traits measured at one temperature (Falconer 1952; Via 1987; Via and Lande 1985). Each element of the G matrix becomes the additive genetic variance of the phenotype expressed at a temperature (Gii ) or the additive genetic covariance between the phenotypes expressed at different temperatures (Gij ). The vector of selection gradients determines the strengths of selection acting on a single trait at different temperatures. In the parameter-based approach, one describes the reaction norm with a mathematical function, and treats parameters of the function as equivalent to traits (Scheiner and Lyman 1991). Although any function can be used, mainly linear and polynomial functions have been explored (David et al. 1997; Gibert et al. 1998). For a linear function, the slope represents the plasticity of the phenotype and the intercept represents the mean of the phenotype. As in the trait-based approach, a genetic variance–covariance matrix is used in conjunction
10
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
with selection gradients to model the evolution of the reaction norm. Selection gradients for the parameter-based approach apply to parameters of the function. In the characteristic value-based approach, one describes the reaction norm with a mathematical function and then derives characteristic values from this function to serve as traits (Gibert et al. 1998). A subtle but important distinction exists between a parameter and a characteristic value. Parameters, such as a slope and intercept, are estimated by fitting a model to data. Although some parameters have obvious biological meanings, other parameters do not. We can replace biologically meaningless parameters with characteristic values of the function, such as the phenotype at a particular temperature or the mean phenotype over a range of temperatures. The evolution of these characteristic values could be predicted in the same way that one predicts the evolution of the parameters. In the function-based approach, one treats the reaction norm as a trait with an infinite number of dimensions (Gomulkiewicz and Kirkpatrick 1992). In other words, the thermal reaction norm describes the phenotype at an infinite number of temperatures. The infinite-dimensional approach relies on nonparametric statistics, which have the advantage of relaxing some restrictive assumptions of the other approaches. An infinite-dimensional analysis yields principal components that describe the genetic variance and covariance of the reaction norm. These estimates of genetic variance and covariance can be used to model the response to selection (Kingsolver et al. 2001a). Regardless of which approach we choose, applying a quantitative genetic model poses unique challenges and requires new assumptions. First, we must know the selection gradients corresponding to the traits that represent the reaction norm. We can obtain these gradients from the fitness landscape of an optimality model (see Section 1.4.1) or estimate them empirically (see Section 1.5.1). Second, we must know the genetic variances and covariances associated with these traits. We can estimate these parameters through breeding experiments or artificial selection (Box 1.2). Regardless of how we obtain genetic variances and covariances, most
quantitative genetic models assume these parameters remain constant during evolution. In reality epistasis, selection, recombination, and migration change the genetic variances and covariances of real traits (Archer et al. 2003; Hansen 2006; Pfrender and Lynch 2000; Roff and Mousseau 1999; reviewed by Steppan et al. 2002). Other assumptions arise from the statistical methods used to estimate genetic variances and covariances (Table 1.3). Despite these assumptions, quantitative genetic models provide a valuable complement to optimality models (Roff 1994), as we shall see in later chapters.
1.4.3 Allelic models As the name implies, an allelic model describes the genes that shape the phenotype. Thus, allelic models pry open the black box of genes created by quantitative genetic models. The classic analytical models of one or two loci (reviewed by Gillespie 2004) have given way to more complex models explored through computer simulations of genetic algorithms (reviewed by Mitchell and Taylor 1999; Schoenauer and Michalewicz 1997). The details vary greatly from model to model, but the allelic models described in this book all share some general properties. These models focus on a population of diploid organisms, with multiple alleles per locus. Each allele has an additive effect on the genetic value of a trait. For our purposes, the trait will represent some parameter that describes a thermal reaction norm, as in the parameter-based approach of quantitative genetics (see Section 1.4.2). The phenotypic value of this parameter results from the sum of allelic effects and an environmental effect. Because the mean environmental effect equals zero, the mean phenotypic value of the trait equals the mean genetic value. The phenotypic variance equals the sum of the additive genetic variance and the environmental variance (see eqn 1.1). Initially, a population of genotypes is formed by randomly assigning a set of alleles to each individual. Then, within each generation, individuals survive and reproduce according to their phenotype. Upon reproduction, some probability exists that the genetic value of an allele will change by mutation; most mutations cause very small changes
E V O L U T I O N A RY T H E R M A L B I O L O G Y
Box 1.2 Estimating parameters of quantitative genetic models Quantitative genetic models of thermal adaptation require estimates of genetic variances and covariances. Estimating these parameters for a reaction norm requires a fairly complex experimental design (Scheiner 2002). For labile traits, one can quantify a thermal reaction norm through repeated measures of individuals. For fixed traits, however, one must estimate the reaction norm using clones or siblings, because the phenotype of an individual cannot be measured at multiple temperatures. Quantitative genetic parameters estimated from siblings should be viewed with caution because microenvironmental variation can inflate estimates of genetic variance (Windig et al. 2004). Genetic variances and covariances can be quantified through breeding experiments or artificial selection (Falconer 1989; Lynch and Walsh 1998). Breeding experiments Relationships among relatives can be used to estimate genetic variances and covariances. Three kinds of relatives are commonly used: (1) parents and offspring, (2) full siblings, and (3) half-siblings. In each case, males (sires) and females (dams) are randomly mated to produce a set of offspring. These offspring are reared in controlled environments to reduce environmental effects on the phenotype. In the context of thermal adaptation, the trait could be a phenotype measured at a single temperature or a parameter that describes a thermal reaction norm. The additive genetic variance of each trait can be determined by linear regression or analysis of variance (ANOVA). When a trait is measured in both parents and their offspring, a linear regression of the offspring phenotype on the mean parental phenotype reveals the additive genetic variance. Specifically, the proportion of variance in the offspring phenotype explained by the parental phenotype (r 2 ) approximates the heritability of the
trait (VG /VP ; see eqn 1.2). Alternatively, the phenotypic variance among full or half-sibling families can be used to estimate the additive genetic variance. For a full sibling design, each male is mated randomly to a single female. A nested ANOVA estimates the proportion of phenotypic variance explained by familial identity (sire or dam). Assuming the maternal environment and genetic dominance do not influence the phenotype, the additive genetic variance equals twice the variance observed among families. When maternal and dominance effects are suspected, a half-sibling design provides a more accurate estimate of additive genetic variance. Each male is mated randomly to several females. A more accurate estimate of the additive genetic variance results because each mother experiences a unique environmental condition and provides a unique genetic complement. A nested ANOVA estimates the proportion of phenotypic variance explained by paternal identity; the additive genetic variance equals four times the variance observed among half-sibling families. By raising individuals from the same family at different temperatures, one can use an ANOVA to estimate the genetic variance of plasticity (Table 1.2). Artificial selection The response to artificial selection can also be used to estimate genetic variances and covariances. One starts with a large population of organisms that expresses phenotypic variation in the trait of interest. This population is randomly subdivided to create replicate lines; some lines will experience selection and other lines serve as controls. For each selection line, the researcher selects individuals that have either the highest or the lowest values of the trait. For example, imagine we wished to know the genetic variance of heat tolerance. In some lines, we would select individuals with a heat tolerance greater than the median (i.e., the top 50%). For other lines, we would select
Table 1.2 Interpreting the results of an analysis of variance applied to a breeding experiment conducted at multiple temperatures Factor
Description
Genotype or familial identity (VG ) Temperature (VE ) Genotype × temperature (VG×E ) Error (Ve ) Total (VP )
Genetic variation in the mean phenotype expressed across temperatures Mean thermal plasticity of the phenotype Genetic variation in the thermal plasticity of the phenotype Variation among individuals within genotype at a temperature Phenotypic variance
Modified with permission from Via (1994). continues
11
12
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
Box 1.2 Continued
¯z1 = β1 · G11 .
(1.6)
The selection gradient (β 1 ) would depend on the intensity of selection that we imposed (s) and the phenotypic variance (VP ): s , β1 = VP
(1.7)
where s equals the difference between the mean phenotype of the selected population and that of the original population. Substituting eqn 1.7 into eqn 1.6 and solving for the genetic variance yields: ¯z1 VP G11 = . s
(1.8)
Given eqn 1.8, we can easily estimate the genetic variance from the response to our selective regime and the
phenotypic variance. Figure 1.5 illustrates the estimation of ¯z1 /s for fruit flies that were artificially selected for heat tolerance (Gilchrist and Huey 1999). Furthermore, artificial selection tells us about the genetic covariance between two traits. For example, imagine we wanted to know whether heat tolerance and cold tolerance covaried genetically. After selecting for greater or lesser heat tolerance, we could use the change in cold tolerance to estimate the genetic covariances (Gij and Gji ): G21 = G12 =
¯z2 VP , s
42
40
38
36 0
5
10
15
25
30
Figure 1.5 Response to selection for heat tolerance (knockdown temperature) in Drosophila melanogaster. Replicate lines were selected for greater or lesser heat tolerance. The slope of each relationship equals ¯zi /s , which is proportional to the genetic variance. Adapted with permission from Macmillan Publishers Ltd: Heredity (Gilchrist and Huey 1999), © 1999.
Assumption
Description
Linearity Additivity
Genetic and environmental effects can be described by a linear statistical model No interactions between genes (epistasis) or between genes and environments (environmental effects on the reaction norm) Genetic and environmental effects are normally distributed Genetic variances and covariances do not change
Modified with permission from Pigliucci and Schlichting (1997).
20
Cumulative selection differential (s)
Table 1.3 Assumptions of quantitative genetic theory
Normality Constant G matrix
(1.9)
where VP and s apply to the selected trait (heat tolerance) and ¯z2 applies to the correlated trait (cold tolerance). Knockdown temperature (°C)
individuals with a heat tolerance lower than the median (i.e., the bottom 50%). For control lines, we would select individuals randomly with respect to heat tolerance. In all lines, we would randomly mate selected individuals to produce the next generation. The remaining individuals would be eliminated from each line. With each successive generation, the mean heat tolerance of the selected lines should diverge from the mean heat tolerance of the control lines. Using eqn 1.4, we could estimate the genetic variance of heat tolerance (Gii or VG ) from the response to artificial selection. This equation tells us the response to selection depends on the selection gradients and the genetic variances and covariances of traits. If we assume no trait other than heat tolerance-experienced selection, the response to selection becomes simple:
E V O L U T I O N A RY T H E R M A L B I O L O G Y
in the genetic value but some can have large positive or negative effects (mutational effects are usually drawn from a Gaussian distribution with a mean of zero). A finite population and independent assortment can lead to genetic drift within these simulations. Over time, the mean phenotype of the population evolves as a consequence of this selection, mutation, and drift. Allelic models confer a major advantage over quantitative genetic models: the genetic variances and covariances can change. Because genes are modeled explicitly, mutation, recombination, drift, and selection change the frequencies of alleles over generations. Ultimately, the trait can evolve to an equilibrial value, such as the evolutionary optimum. Thus, an allelic model provides information about the dynamics and outcome of adaptation. On the downside, allelic models require one to specify not only the fitness landscape but also genomic structure, mutation rate, population size, and mating behavior (Hertz and Kobler 2000). As we shall see, the dynamics of thermal adaptation depend on these genetic and demographic parameters.
13
alleles along with rates of mutation, recombination, and migration, even though these parameters are usually unknown. Thus, no single approach lacks drawbacks. In this book, we shall use all three theoretical approaches to study thermal adaptation. The simplest way to draw on their collective strength is to apply these approaches sequentially. Generally, we shall start by applying an optimality approach to a particular phenomenon. When one optimality model fails, another optimality model may succeed because of its more realistic assumptions. When an optimality approach fails altogether, we shall explore the potential explanations offered by quantitative genetic and allelic models. For example, a lack of additive genetic variance might explain why the optimal phenotype has not evolved. Alternatively, migration between populations in different thermal environments might prevent populations from attaining local optima. This progression from simple to complex approaches will provide greater insights than would a focus on any single approach.
1.4.4 The complementarity of theory All three of the modeling approaches discussed here possess strengths and weaknesses. Optimality models describe fitness landscapes given functional constraints on the phenotype (the phenotypic function) and a hypothetical relationship between the phenotype and fitness (the fitness function). Yet, optimality models assume genetic constraints do not prevent the optimal phenotype from evolving. Furthermore, optimization does not describe the evolutionary dynamics that precede an equilibrial phenotype. In contrast, quantitative genetic and allelic models explicitly account for genetic constraints on phenotypes and describe the dynamics that lead to an evolutionary equilibrium. In these models, however, a fitness landscape must either be assumed or be quantified empirically (Via et al. 1995). Furthermore, evolutionary dynamics depend largely on the assumptions about genetics. In quantitative genetic models, genetic variances and covariances are assumed to be constant even though they are known to vary (Steppan et al. 2002). In allelic models, one must specify the number of loci and
1.5 Empirical tools of the evolutionary thermal biologist Models help us to understand the diversity of phenotypes observed in nature, but simply formulating a model that describes a previous observation will not advance knowledge. The model must predict unobserved phenomena and new observations must be made to confirm this ability. Testing the kinds of models outlined in Section 1.4 requires us to determine the match between predictions and observations. Throughout this book, we shall rely on three distinct approaches to evaluate models: (1) quantifying selection in natural environments, (2) quantifying evolution during selection experiments, and (3) comparing organisms from different environments. These approaches focus on different temporal scales of evolution, ranging from one generation to hundreds of generations. They also provide different strengths of evidence for adaptation and different levels of generality. Let us briefly review each approach to better understand its strengths and limitations.
14
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
1.5.1 Quantifying selection Measures of selection in natural environments can be used to evaluate optimality models and parameterize genetic models. Recall that an optimality model defines the fitness landscape—the relationship between the phenotype and fitness (see Section 1.4.1). This landscape can be described mathematically by parameters called selection gradients. Quantitative genetic and allelic models require knowledge of selection gradients to determine the dynamics of adaptation (see Sections 1.4.2 and 1.4.3). Thus, measures of selection gradients in natural environments can validate critical assumptions of these models. Recently, statistical methods for quantifying selection have undergone rapid development (Box 1.3), enabling one to estimate selection gradients in natural environments. Sometimes, limited variation in thermal reaction norms prevents one from defining the adaptive landscape in sufficient detail. In such cases, artificial selection can increase the frequency of rare genotypes (Bennett 2003; Conner 2003), thereby expanding the scope of an analysis. Artificially selecting thermal reaction norms requires a different approach than the one used to select a trait expressed at a single temperature. For labile traits, the reaction norm can be measured by exposing each individual to a range of temperatures. For fixed traits, one must estimate the reaction norm by raising clones or siblings over a range of temperatures. In the latter case, the investigator selects individuals from clonal or familial lines that exhibit the desired reaction norm (Scheiner 2002). In addition to amplifying the frequency of rare genotypes, one can further increase the diversity of phenotypes by engineering ones that do not occur naturally. Both genetic and phenotypic engineering can accomplish this goal. Genetic engineering involves the insertion or deletion of genes to produce changes in the phenotype (see, for example, Tatar 1999). A variety of methods have been developed for genetic engineering in model organisms (reviewed by Tatar 2000). Phenotypic engineering involves either physical or physiological manipulation of the phenotype. In the simplest case, a novel phenotype might be engineered through physical manipulation (Sinervo 1990). More
complex approaches involve exogenous delivery of hormones or neurotransmitters (see, for example, Ketterson and Nolan 1992). Both genetic and phenotypic engineering extend the range of phenotypes for analyses of selection (reviewed by Travis and Reznick 1998).
1.5.2 Experimental evolution Despite the value of short-term measures of selection, observations over longer periods can reveal the dynamics of evolution and possibly even the equilibrial phenotypes. The predictions of evolutionary models have been tested experimentally in artificial mesocosms and natural environments. In the former case, one maintains replicated populations in controlled thermal environments. In the latter case, one establishes replicated populations in a novel natural environment; for mobile organisms, each population must be physically enclosed to prevent migration. In both cases, one compares the evolutionary responses in experimental populations with those in control populations (Box 1.4). Although both kinds of experiments have the same goal, each has its own advantages and disadvantages. Laboratory experiments directly link environmental temperatures to the evolution of phenotypes (Bennett and Lenski 1999). With a careful experimental design, any difference between the phenotypes of experimental and control lines can be attributed to thermal adaptation (see Box 1.4). However, practical considerations demand organisms with short generations, high fecundity, and tolerance to artificial conditions (e.g., Drosophila melanogaster or Escherichia coli). Field experiments can reveal novel patterns of thermal adaptation because natural selection depends on the interaction of temperature and other environmental factors. The use of natural environments eliminates the need to care for organisms, but creates difficulties when monitoring populations and interpreting results (see Box 1.4). Although these two kinds of experiment clearly complement one another, most experimental studies of thermal adaptation have occurred in the laboratory.
E V O L U T I O N A RY T H E R M A L B I O L O G Y
15
Box 1.3 Measuring selection gradients
where α equals the intercept, β equals the slope of the relationship between the phenotype and fitness, and ε equals the residual variation (i.e., the variation in fitness not associated with the trait); by assumption, ε is normally distributed with a mean of zero. The selection gradient (β) approximates the strength of directional selection (Fig. 1.6a). The selection gradient can be standardized by the mean or the variance of the trait to facilitate comparisons among traits or taxa (Hereford et al. 2004). Stabilizing or disruptive selection is quantified by adding a second-order term (z 2 ) to the model; a negative β for the second-order term indicates stabilizing selection whereas a positive second-order term indicates disruptive selection (Fig. 1.6b and c). Because most traits are correlated with other traits, researchers often use multiple regression to estimate selection gradients. A multiple regression model describes the relationship between two or more traits and the relative fitness: w = α + β1 z1 + β2 z2 + · · · + βn zn + ε,
(1.11)
where zn and β n equal the phenotypic value and the selection gradient of trait n, respectively. The selection gradient calculated by multiple regression describes the effect of trait n on relative fitness, independent of all other traits (Lande and Arnold 1983). In the context of thermal adaptation, the traits would represent phenotypes measured at different temperatures or parameters of a thermal reaction norm (see Section 1.4.2). In practice, fitness is notoriously difficult to define, much less measure. Ideally, one would measure the lifetime reproductive success of a sexual organism or the population growth rate of a clonal organism, but many other proxies for fitness have been used to quantify selection (Endler
1.5.3 Comparative analysis Although direct measures of selection are ideal, such observations are impractical or even impossible to accumulate for most species. Given this limitation,
(a)
Relative fitness
(1.10)
 (z) > 0  (z) = 0
b(z) < 0
(b) Relative fitness
w = α + βz + ε,
1986; Kingsolver et al. 2001b). When a proxy for fitness is measured during part of the life cycle, selection gradients describe an episode of selection rather than natural selection, per se (for an insightful discussion of these concepts, see Endler 1986).
 (z 2 ) < 0
(c)
Relative fitness
The direction and magnitude of natural selection can be quantified by regression (reviewed by Brodie et al. 1995). A regression model relates the phenotypic value of a trait (z ) to the relative fitness of an individual (w ; fitness of the individual divided by the mean fitness of the population):
 (z 2 ) > 0
Phenotype (z) Figure 1.6 Hypothetical fitness landscapes for (a) directional, (b) stabilizing, and (c) disruptive selection. The sign of the selection gradient (β ) differs among these functions.
the generality of current models must be assessed through comparative analyses. The comparative method has always been the mainstay of biologists (Somero 2000), but we can now choose from a
16
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
Box 1.4 Experimental designs for detecting adaptation Experiments in the laboratory or field enable one to document thermal adaptation, but a careless design can lead to an ambiguous or erroneous result (Rose et al. 1996). An adequate experimental design would enable us to attribute the evolutionary response to natural selection imposed by environmental temperature, as opposed to other selective pressures or genetic drift. In laboratory experiments, one would start with an ancestral population that was already adapted to the artificial environment. In field experiments, populations would be chosen to avoid recent changes in the selective environment. From the ancestral population, one must establish both experimental and control lines (Fig. 1.7). Experimental lines experience a novel thermal environment, whereas control lines continue to experience the thermal conditions of the ancestral population. Because genetic drift within lines can produce spurious patterns or constrain adaptation, each line should consist of a large number of mating pairs (≥50). As in any experiment, adequate replication underlies the quality of the statistical inference. Replicating observations in a selection experiment poses a major challenge because the effective unit of replication equals the population (or line) rather than the individual. Thus, experiments with only a few lines per thermal environment should be interpreted
with caution. That said, most selection experiments presented in this book involved fewer than five lines per temperature. This unfortunate reality stems partly from a tradeoff imposed by logistical constraints; when the availability of space, time, or money limits the sample size, researchers face a tradeoff between having enough individuals within lines to avoid genetic drift and having enough lines within treatments to achieve statistical power. Inferring thermal adaptation from field experiments requires some caution. In an artificial mesocosm, environmental temperature can be manipulated while all other factors are controlled or randomized among lines. Consequently, one can infer thermal adaptation by comparing experimental lines from a novel thermal treatment with control lines from the ancestral thermal treatment. In a natural environment, many factors covary with environmental temperature. Thus, we might falsely conclude that thermal adaptation occurred if other environmental factors imposed the predicted selective pressure. A more robust inference requires replicated populations in multiple thermal environments, which increases the likelihood that other factors will vary randomly with respect to environmental temperature.
Ancestral population
Control lines
Replicate line 1
Replicate line 2
Experimental lines
Replicate line 1
Replicate line 2
bewildering array of statistical procedures for combining phylogenetic, environmental, and phenotypic data to test evolutionary hypotheses. Understanding these procedures will be helpful because much of the theory presented in this book will be tested by the comparative method. Two applications of the comparative method serve our
Figure 1.7 Replication of experimental evolution requires multiple lines, each founded from an ancestral population. Individuals are randomly sampled from the ancestral population to establish each line.
purpose: (1) studies of covariation between traits to test hypotheses about tradeoffs and (2) studies of covariation between environmental temperature and organismal phenotypes to test hypotheses about thermal adaptation. The simplest comparison involves the study of organisms in extreme environments. Biologists
E V O L U T I O N A RY T H E R M A L B I O L O G Y
17
Box 1.5 Calculating phylogenetically independent contrasts Imagine a trait, X , that has evolved within a lineage represented by four extant species (A–D). The values of X in these species are interdependent because all four species shared some portion of the evolutionary history (Fig. 1.8). Yet each species also experienced a period of evolution that was independent of the other species. For example, species A and B diverged from a common ancestor (E), and any divergence in X that occurred after these species formed was clearly independent of evolution that occurred elsewhere within the lineage. Therefore, the contrast between the values of X in species A and B (i.e., XA − XB ) is called a phylogenetically independent contrast (Felsenstein 1985). For any set of n data points one can compute n − 1 independent contrasts. To compute these contrasts, we need a cladogram depicting only the relationships among extant taxa, branch lengths for the cladogram, and data for two or more variables (Garland et al. 1992). Contrasts are computed for each pair of taxa, starting at the tips and moving down the tree. The values of X for ancestral taxa, such as E in Fig. 1.8, are estimated as the weighted mean of X for its descendants. For example, the value of X for taxon E (XE ) would be calculated as: (1/vA )XA + (1/vB )XB , (1.12) XE = 1/vA + 1/vB where vA and vB equal the branch lengths leading from the ancestor to taxa A and B, respectively. Because pairs of taxa that diverged more recently will have smaller contrasts, one should standardize contrasts before using them in statistical analyses (Garland et al. 1992). Standardization is quite simple because the expected mean of the contrasts equals zero; therefore, all one has to do is divide the contrasts by their standard deviation. We can use contrasts in any statistical analysis, but the following restrictions hold: (1) all standard assumptions of parametric statistics that apply to the raw data also apply to independent contrasts and (2) statistical models should not include an intercept because the intercept of a relationship between two sets of contrasts theoretically equals zero (Garland et al. 1992). The validity of independent contrasts rests on two major assumptions (Garland et al. 2005; Martins and Hansen
automatically assume that organisms living in extreme thermal environments, such as Antarctica, have adaptations for doing so (Magnum and Hochachaka 1998). This assumption seems reasonable given most organisms cannot tolerate such
1996). First, evolution of a trait must have followed a process that resembles Brownian motion; in other words, the expected change in the trait’s value equals zero and the variance of this change scales in proportion to the duration of evolution. This assumption holds for directional selection as long as the optimal phenotype fluctuates over time. Second, the sequence and timings of divergence among taxa are known. Although these assumptions are surely violated in all cases, comparative analyses of raw data require equally restrictive assumptions (Garland et al. 1999). When conducting comparative analyses of thermal adaptation, researchers often calculate independent contrasts for environmental temperature. Arguably, the use of independent contrasts for environmental temperature is inappropriate because environmental variables do not necessarily possess the same properties as phenotypes (Martins 2000). Nevertheless, Garland and colleagues (1992) noted that contrasts could be computed for a continuous environmental variable if environmental states were passed from ancestor to descendant. This assumption seems reasonable considering that geographic structure among populations ensures that individuals in a relatively cold environment produce offspring that experience a relatively cold environment.
XB B
XA A
νA
XC C
XD D
νB E
F
Figure 1.8 This hypothetical cladogram depicts the relationships among four extant taxa, A–D, that differ in some trait X . Ancestral taxa are labeled as E and F. Branch lengths for taxa A and B are labeled as vA and vB , respectively.
thermal extremes. By comparing the phenotypes of these organisms with those of organisms in less extreme environments, we learn how organisms deal with thermal stress. But how extreme must a thermal environment be for us to assume that an
18
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
organism’s thermal physiology reflects adaptation? Because we usually cannot answer this question, comparisons between two taxa from disparate environments provide only weak evidence of thermal adaptation (Garland and Adolph 1994). A more powerful way to study adaptation is to compare phenotypes of species across a range of environments in a phylogenetic context (Gittleman and Luh 1994; Harvey and Purvis 1991; Huey 1987; Martins 2000; Miles and Dunham 1993). Three methods of phylogenetic comparative analysis have been most commonly used (Garland et al. 2005): (1) independent contrasts (Felsenstein 1985), (2) generalized least-squares models (Martins and Hansen 1997), and (3) Monte Carlo simulations (Martins and Garland 1991). Comparative studies of thermal adaptation have used the method of independent contrasts. This method transforms a set of raw data into a set of new data that meet the assumption of statistical independence. These new data consist of contrasts, which estimate the divergence in a trait between two taxa since their most recent common ancestor (Box 1.5). In principle, independent contrasts can be calculated for either phenotypic or environmental variables (Felsenstein 2002; Garland et al. 1992). Therefore, we can use independent contrasts to relate thermal change to evolutionary change within a lineage. In certain circumstances, we should rely on analyses of raw data instead of analyses of independent contrasts. For example, independent contrasts should not be used when phenotypic differences among taxa are caused primarily by environmental factors (i.e., phenotypic plasticity). Likewise, independent contrasts would be undesirable if we were testing the quantitative predictions of competing models, particularly when the models predict nonlinear relationships between environmental temperature and phenotypic values. The reason is simple: independent contrasts do not retain information about the actual environmental or phenotypic values—only the difference between the values for sister taxa (see Box 1.5). The extensive use of independent contrasts stems from the overabundance of qualitative predictions in evolutionary
biology (i.e., trait X should correlate positively with trait Y). Finally, an analysis of independent contrasts would be an overly conservative test of adaptation if stabilizing selection has maintained the observed phenotypes (Martins 2000). For all of these reasons, we shall interpret analyses of raw data in conjunction with analyses of independent contrasts when the two disagree.
1.6 Conclusions As an opening to this book, I have tried to lay a foundation on which we can rest the concepts, models, and experiments presented in the coming chapters. The array of phenomena studied by thermal biologists—thermal sensitivity, thermoregulation, and thermal acclimation—naturally lead to the construct of a thermal reaction norm. This construct opens many doors because biologists have spent decades developing tools for the study of reaction norms. By estimating and comparing thermal reaction norms for labile or fixed traits, we can discover general patterns of interest. But to understand the evolution of these patterns, we must do more than accumulate data. We must gather and interpret our data in light of models. Evolutionary biology offers the theoretical and empirical tools needed to dissect these patterns and identify their causes. The evolution of thermal reaction norms can be explored through optimality models, quantitative genetic models, and allelic models. As we shall see, these models offer a wealth of predictions about thermal adaptation. The accuracy and generality of these models can be determined from direct measures of natural selection, experimental evolution in controlled environments, and comparative analyses of phenotypic variation. Before we begin to use these tools, we must familiarize ourselves with the thermal heterogeneity of natural environments. This variation in temperature over space and time creates the impetus for evolutionary change. For this reason, we shall deal with the topic of thermal heterogeneity in the next chapter.
CHAPTER 2
Thermal Heterogeneity
The temperature of an organism—a quantitative measure of the kinetic energy of its molecules— determines the capacity for heat to flow between the organism and its environment (see Haynie 2001). If the organism possesses the same temperature as its environment, the two are in thermal equilibrium (i.e., no net flow of heat occurs between them). But if the organism and the environment differ in temperature, the warmer entity will lose heat while the cooler one gains it. This flow of heat occurs through a variety of physical processes whose relative importance varies among environments (Gates 1980; Mitchell 1976; Porter and Gates 1969). Aquatic organisms mainly exchange heat with their environment via conduction and convection. The high thermal conductivity and heat capacity of water cause the body temperatures of these organisms to closely follow the temperatures of their aqueous surroundings (Spotila et al. 1992). For terrestrial organisms, conduction, convection, radiation, and evaporation contribute significantly to the body temperature (Fig. 2.1). Below the surface of the ground, the impacts of radiation, convection, and evaporation weaken (as they do in water). These processes cause a net exchange of heat between an organism and its environment as long as the two differ in temperature. In the real world, organisms rarely enter thermal equilibria with their environments. The motion of the earth combined with radiation from the sun drives a continuous redistribution of heat throughout the planet. Thus, living things must deal with thermal change on a variety of temporal scales. First, environmental temperatures cycle daily because of the periodic exposure to solar radiation; this predictable source of thermal heterogeneity results from the rotation of the earth around its axis. Second,
environmental temperatures change rapidly and unpredictably with atmospheric conditions, such as wind speed and cloud cover. Third, environmental temperatures change seasonally because of the tilt of the earth as it orbits the sun. Finally, environmental temperatures change both cyclically and directionally among years. For example, changes in atmospheric and oceanic circulation drive fairly regular phenomena of warming and cooling in the Pacific Ocean, referred to as El Niño and La Niña. In geological history, extensive periods of warming and cooling were triggered by changes in the earth’s orientation and orbit. In recent history, humans have perturbed the atmosphere so much that earth has entered a period of warming comparable to those caused by astronomical events. Depending on its location and lifespan, an organism experiences the combined stress of some or all of this thermal change. In this chapter, we shall consider the patterns of thermal heterogeneity experienced by organisms. As we shall see, these patterns can be quantified with mathematical, physical, or statistical models. In each case, one seeks to define the body temperature of an organism based on variables that influence heat exchange. First, we shall derive a mathematical relationship between environmental conditions and the body temperature of an organism. Then, we shall use this relationship to explore how spatial and temporal variations in environmental conditions create heterogeneity of body temperatures on a global scale. Finally, we shall see how physical and statistical models have enabled researchers to quantify thermal heterogeneity on local scales. The patterns of environmental variation described in this chapter will help us to define the selective pressures on physiology, behavior, and life history in subsequent chapters.
19
20
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
Dust
Radiation from the atmosphere
Scattered solar radiation Reflected solar radiation Evaporative heat loss Convective heat exchange
Radiation from vegetation
Radiative heat loss
Radiation from the ground
Conductive heat exchange
2.1 Operative environmental temperature When an organism’s environment changes, so does its body temperature. Consider a terrestrial organism consisting of a body core and a body surface. This individual gains heat from its metabolic reactions and the radiation absorbed by the body surface. Incoming radiation includes short-wave radiation from the sun (solar radiation) and long-wave radiation from all other surroundings (thermal radiation). The individual loses heat through the emission of radiation from the body surface and the evaporation of water from the respiratory organs and body surface. Heat is also exchanged with the ground and air by conduction and convection, respectively. The transfer of heat by these processes occurs (1) between the core and surface of the organism and (2) between the surface of the organism and its environment (Fig. 2.2). When environmental conditions change, these fluxes of heat change. The organism will heat or cool until it reaches a steadystate temperature. At this steady state, the organism continues to exchange heat with its environment, but gains and losses balance one another.
Figure 2.1 Routes of heat exchange between an organism and its environment include radiation, conduction, convection, and evaporation. An organism absorbs several kinds of radiation, including direct radiation from the sun, scattered radiation from the atmosphere, and reflected and thermal radiation from surfaces. Adapted from Tracy (1976) with permission from the Ecological Society of America.
Qmet – Qresp
Qevap
Qabs
Kcond Qemit
Ts
Tb
Kconv Ta Kcond Tg
Figure 2.2 A thermal circuit diagram depicts the routes of heat transfer between a terrestrial organism and its environment. Nodes representing the body core, body surface, air, and ground are labeled according to their temperatures (Tb , Ts , Ta , and Tg , respectively). A resistor symbol denotes heat flux by conduction or convection, whereas an arrow denotes any other form of heat flux. Rates of conduction and convection depend on the coefficients of conduction (Kcond ) and convection (Kconv ), respectively. The capacitance symbol represents the heat capacity of the animal. Adapted from Bakken (1976) with permission from Elsevier. © 1976 Elsevier Ltd.
To understand how certain environmental conditions influence the body temperature of an organism, we shall apply a concept known as the operative environmental temperature (or operative temperature). The operative temperature (Te ) equals the
THERMAL HETEROGENEITY
steady-state temperature of an organism in a particular microclimate in the absence of metabolic heating and evaporative cooling (Bakken 1992). As such, this temperature characterizes the thermal environment as perceived by the organism, independent of any physiological thermoregulation. To define the operative temperature in mathematical terms, Bakken and Gates (1975) modeled the routes of heat flux between an organism and its environment. Gains and losses at the surface of the organism were described as follows: Qcond + Qabs = Qevap + Qemit + Qconv ,
(2.1)
where Qcond , Qabs , Qevap , Qemit , and Qconv equal rates of heat flux caused by conduction, absorbed radiation, evaporation, emitted radiation, and convection, respectively. The term for conduction (Qcond ) refers to heat flux between the core and surface of the body; conduction between the body surface and the environment was assumed negligible.4 Similar fluxes determine the change in the organism’s core temperature over time: C
dTb = Qmet − Qresp − Qcond , dt
(2.2)
where C equals the heat capacity of the organism, Tb equals the core body temperature, t equals time, and Qresp equals the rate of evaporative heat loss during respiration. These rates of heat flux represent averages for the whole organism, which avoids an explicit consideration of spatial heterogeneity or surface area. In reality, these fluxes vary among regions of the organism, but this simplified model will suffice for our purposes (for a more complex model, see Bakken 1981). At a steady state, the influx and efflux of heat balance one another such that the core and surface temperatures of the organism remain constant over time. To find the steady state, we must find the core temperature that satisfies the conditions set by
21
eqns 2.1 and 2.2, where dTb /dt = 0. Solving for the steady-state temperature becomes much easier when the terms in these equations are linear with respect to temperature. For example, conduction and convection are linear functions of differences between temperatures: Qcond = Kcond (Tb − Ts )
(2.3)
Qconv = Kconv (Ts − Ta ),
(2.4)
and
where Kcond and Kconv equal coefficients of conduction and convection (W K−1 ), and Ts and Ta equal temperatures of the body surface and air, respectively. In contrast, emitted radiation scales nonlinearly with the temperature of the organism’s surface: Qemit = Aσ εTs4 ,
(2.5)
where A equals the surface area of the organism, σ equals the Boltzmann constant, and ε equals the emissivity of the organism. To simplify calculations of heat transfer, Bakken (1976) approximated this nonlinear term with a linear one:5 Qemit ∼ = Aσ εTa4 + 4Aσ εTa3 (Ts − Ta ).
(2.6)
With this approximation, eqn. 2.1 becomes: Kcond (Tb − Ts ) + Qabs ∼ = Qevap + (Aσ εTa4 + 4Aσ εTa3 (Ts − Ta )) + Kconv (Ts − Ta ).
(2.7)
The approximation of emitted radiation causes little error, except when the body temperature of the organism deviates substantially from the air temperature (Tracy et al. 1984). Once we have linearized eqn 2.1, we can easily solve for the steady-state temperature of the organism. To do so, we first substitute eqn 2.3 into
4
One can reasonably ignore conduction between the organism and its environment when little surface area of the organism contacts the ground or when little difference exists between the temperatures of the ground and the body surface. Bakken (1976) presented a more general model of operative temperature that includes conduction between the organism’s core and the ground, but subsequent applications of the concept of operative temperature follow the special case derived here (see, for example, Bakken 1985; Bakken 1992; Dzialowski 2005).
5
Bakken and Gates (1975) used a different linear function to approximate radiation, resulting in a slightly different mathematical definition of operative temperature. Here, I combined the linear approximation of Bakken (1976) with the model of heat exchange proposed by Bakken and Gates (1975). This approach leads to the definition of operative temperature that appears in subsequent publications (G.S. Bakken, personal communication).
22
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
eqn 2.2 and rearrange to define Ts in terms of Tb : Ts = Tb −
b Qmet − Qresp − C dT dt
Kcond
.
(2.8)
Then, we obtain the steady-state temperature of the organism by substituting eqn 2.8 into eqn 2.7, setting dTb /dt equal to zero, and solving for Tb : Tb ∼ = Ta + +
Qmet − Qresp Kcond
Qmet + Qabs − Qresp − Qevap − Aσ εTa4 Kconv + 4Aσ εTa3
.
(2.9) If we assume the organism gains no heat from metabolism and loses no heat by evaporation (or that these fluxes cancel one another), we arrive at the operative temperature: Qabs − Aσ εTa4 Te ∼ . = Ta + Kconv + 4Aσ εTa3
(2.10)
Thus, the operative temperature reflects an increment in body temperature caused by solar radiation, discounted for the heat lost by convection. In a burrow, where an organism receives no solar radiation, the operative temperature equals the ambient temperature (Chappell and Whitman 1990). For certain organisms, the operative temperature should account for the heat lost by evaporation. For example, amphibians possess a wet epidermis and many species cannot physiologically control their evaporative water loss (Duellman and Trueb
1986; Spotila et al. 1992). The relative humidity of the environment determines the rate of evaporation, and hence influences the body temperature of these organisms (Gates 1980). A biologically relevant measure of operative temperature for such organisms, referred to as the wet operative temperature, accounts for evaporative heat loss (for details, see Campbell 1977). Operative temperatures depend on interactions among absorbed radiation (Qabs ), air temperature (Ta ), and wind speed (which affects Kconv ). We can visualize these interactions in the form of a climate–space diagram (Kingsolver 1983; Porter and Gates 1969; Scott et al. 1982; Spotila et al. 1972). These diagrams depict the combinations of environmental conditions for which an organism will experience a certain steady-state temperature. Obviously, these combinations depend on the physical properties of the organism that determine heat exchange (e.g., color, shape, and size). Figure 2.3 shows the combinations of absorbed radiation, air temperature, and wind speed for which a desert iguana (Dipsosaurus dorsalis) will reach 30◦ C. The impact of absorbed radiation and air temperature on the steady-state temperature depends on the wind speed, as depicted by the crossing of the lines. Such plots highlight the interactions among environmental factors that influence the operative temperature. To the extent that these factors vary predictably over space and time, they create patterns of thermal heterogeneity.
40 Wind = 0 cm s–1 Wind = 100 cm s–1 Wind = 1000 cm s–1
Air temperature (°C)
35 30 25 20 15 10
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
Absorbed radiation (cal cm–2 min–1)
1.0
Figure 2.3 The same body temperature occurs under many combinations of radiation load, air temperature, and wind speed. Each line shows the conditions that yield a predicted body temperature of 30◦ C for a desert iguana, with a mass of 67 g and a surface area of 180 cm2 . Adapted from Porter and Gates (1969) with permission from the Ecological Society of America.
THERMAL HETEROGENEITY
2.2 Global patterns of operative temperature Global variation in solar radiation and environmental temperature gives rise to latitudinal and altitudinal clines in operative temperatures. The intensity of solar radiation determines the amount of radiation absorbed by a particular organism. The air or water temperature determines the heat exchanged via convection. As solar radiation and environmental temperatures vary dielly and seasonally, so do geographic clines in operative temperatures.
2.2.1 Latitudinal clines Ultimately, all latitudinal variation in operative temperatures stems from changes in solar radiation. The quantity of solar radiation received by an organism and its environment depends on the time of day, the time of year, and the location on earth (reviewed by Gates 1980; McCullough and Porter 1971). These sources of variation stem from the tilt of the earth’s axis and its elliptical orbit around the sun. During June, the northern hemisphere tilts toward the sun, and thus receives more solar radiation that the southern hemisphere. The opposite phenomenon occurs during December, leading to the opposing seasons observed in these regions of the planet. At any location, the rotation of the earth on its axis creates variation in solar radiation on a daily basis; radiation peaks daily at solar noon, when the sun’s rays become perpendicular to a particular surface of the earth. These simple principles combine to determine the radiation received at a particular place and time, h S0 (Gates 1980): 2 d¯ ¯ (sin φ · sin δ + cos φ · cos δ · cos h), h S0 = S 0 d (2.11) where S¯ 0 equals the solar constant (1360 W m−2 ), d and d¯ equal the actual and mean distances respectively between the earth and the sun, φ equals the latitude of the surface, δ equals the declination of the sun, and h equals the hour angle of the sun (the angle by which the earth must rotate to bring the point directly perpendicular to the sun’s rays). Given the presence of an atmosphere, only a fraction of solar radiation reaches the surface of the
23
earth; the atmosphere absorbs, reflects, or scatters the remaining radiation. To model the reduction in solar radiation caused by the atmosphere, we must add a coefficient (τ m ) that defines the transmission of radiation: 2 d¯ ¯ S = S 0 h 0 d × (sin φ · sin δ + cos φ · cos δ · cos h)τ m , (2.12) where 0 ≤ τ ≤ 1. The exponent m equals the length of the path by which radiation travels through the atmosphere divided by the shortest possible path to sea level. By integrating eqn 2.2 over time, one can calculate daily or annual radiation load for any latitude. The hour angle changes over the course of a day, and the sun’s declination changes over the course of a year. Gates (1980) integrated over the set of hour angles to obtain the daily radiation load; plotting this radiation as a function of latitude and time of year reveals certain patterns (Fig. 2.4). For a realistic range of atmospheric transmissions, the greatest incident radiation occurs at 30◦ N during the solstice in June and 30◦ S during the solstice in December (Fig. 2.5a). During the equinoxes in March and September, however, the greatest incident radiation occurs at the equator (Fig. 2.5b). Over the course of a year, the equator receives 2.4 times the radiation that the poles receive (Gates 1980). This variation in solar radiation contributes directly to latitudinal clines in the operative temperatures of organisms (see eqn 2.10). Solar radiation also affects operative temperatures indirectly by causing variation in the temperatures of air, water, and soil. Global patterns of environmental temperature are most easily inferred from air temperatures, which have been recorded for decades at thousands of locations (Box 2.1). In the northern hemisphere, air temperature decreases strongly with increasing latitude (Fig. 2.7). This latitudinal gradient becomes most pronounced during winter (Addo-Bediako et al. 2000; Bradshaw and Holzapfel 2006; Ghalambor et al. 2006), a phenomenon resulting from the contrasting seasonal patterns of solar radiation at different latitudes (see Fig. 2.4). A global model of daily temperatures constructed by Piper and Stewart (1996) nicely
24
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
90 0
0
North
60 10
10
Latitude
30
0 10
South
–30
–60
0
Ja n. Fe b. M ar . A pr . M ay Ju n. Ju l. A ug . Se p. O ct . N ov . D ec .
–90
Month
Figure 2.4 The daily intensity of incident radiation varies predictably with latitude and the time of the year. The values plotted here were based on a transmittance of 0.6. Adapted from Gates (1980) with permission from Dover Press.
(a) 50
(b) 40
= 1.0
= 1.0
Radiation (MJ m–2 day–1)
Radiation (MJ m–2 day–1)
40
= 0.8
30
= 0.6 20
= 0.8
20
= 0.6
10
10
–90
30
–60
–30
0 30 Latitude
60
90
–90
–60
–30
0 Latitude
30
60
90
Figure 2.5 The transmission of solar radiation affects the latitudinal clines of solar radiation during the solstice (a) and the equinox (b). Positive values of latitude are for the northern hemisphere. Adapted from Gates (1980) with permission from Dover Press.
THERMAL HETEROGENEITY
Box 2.1 Mapping environmental temperatures on a global scale Since the production of the first standardized thermometers in the 18th century, the measurement and analysis of temperatures have blossomed into a global enterprise. Today, the World Meteorological Organization, the World Data Center for Meteorology, and the Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission collectively archive temperatures recorded by roughly 10 000 terrestrial weather stations and several hundred coastal buoys. Additionally, thermal records for the ocean surface have been estimated from satellite images (Kerr and Ostrovsky 2003). To facilitate comparative research, these organizations set guidelines for methodology and accuracy; for example, the World Meteorological Organization defines air temperature as the temperature of a thermometer exposed to air at a height of 1.2–2.0 m and sheltered from direct solar radiation. The efforts of these organizations have generated two beneficial outcomes for thermal biologists. First, we now have excellent models of spatial and temporal variations in air and water temperatures to guide our research. Second, we can use normal temperatures—mean temperatures for a consecutive period of 30 years—to identify anomalous conditions and directional trends. Current estimates of global warming depend on normal temperatures for 1961–1990 (see Chapter 9). The thermal data collected by weather stations enable one to map environmental temperatures on a global scale. To construct such maps, one must convert the extremely patchy distribution of thermal records into a regularly spaced grid. Climatologists accomplish this feat by fitting regression models to the available data or interpolating temperatures between weather stations (see, for example, Zhao et al. 2005). The global patterns described in this chapter stem from the work of Piper and Stewart (1996) and New and colleagues (1999), who used methods of interpolation to map mean temperatures and mean daily ranges of temperatures for all continents but Antarctica. Below, I briefly contrast the procedures used by these investigators. Piper and Stewart (1996) used time series of air temperatures from more than 7500 weather stations to create maps of daily mean temperatures and daily ranges of temperature at a spatial resolution of 1◦ (latitude by longitude). To increase the size of their sample while ensuring consistency among stations, they recalculated mean temperatures as the average of the minimal and maximal temperatures. To simplify their model, they adjusted all temperatures to sea level prior to interpolation.
After interpolation, they readjusted the temperature at each location based on the altitude. Their method of interpolation involved distance weighting. For each grid point, the temperature was estimated from temperatures recorded at 5–10 neighboring weather stations; the influence of each record on the predicted temperature was weighted by the proximity of the weather station to the grid point. In contrast to Piper and Stewart, New and his colleagues used a two-step process to generate maps of monthly mean temperatures and monthly ranges of temperatures at a resolution of half a degree latitude/longitude. First, they modeled the global distribution of normal temperatures for 1961–1990 (New et al. 1999). Because normal temperatures are more accessible than time series, the researchers could include data from more than 12 000 locations. Each temperature was weighted by the variance and the number of years contributing to the normal temperature (maximum = 30 years). Unlike Piper and Stewart, New et al. interpolated over three dimensions, eliminating the need to adjust temperatures for the altitude. To avoid errors caused by the low density of weather stations in some regions, they divided the land surfaces into 22 overlapping tiles (Fig. 2.6) and fitted a separate spline function to the data for each tile. Once New et al. had obtained a grid of normal temperatures, they used records of thermal anomalies (deviations from the normal temperature) to create monthly thermal maps for the period of 1901–1996 (New et al. 2000). Thermal anomalies were interpolated by distance weighting to form a grid for each month. By combining the grid of thermal anomalies with the grid of normal temperatures, New et al. generated a global map of temperatures for each period of time. Several sources of error influenced the quality of global thermal maps. First, not all measurements of temperature were made at comparable times of day (Piper and Stewart 1996). Deriving daily mean temperatures from minimal and maximal temperatures reduced some bias caused by differences in timing (New et al. 1999). Second, the sheer magnitude of data involved in these analyses virtually guaranteed the existence of typographical errors. Many of these errors were eliminated by careful review of the data prior to analysis. Errors were assumed to exist when monthly mean temperatures failed to follow a seasonal cycle or a mean temperature fell outside the range bounded by the minimal and maximal temperatures. Finally, errors in interpolation might have resulted from a paucity of temperatures at certain latitudes and altitudes. continues
25
26
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
Box 2.1 Continued 80
. . .. . . . . ..... . . . . 16 . .. 10 . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . .. . . . . .. . .... . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . .. .................. ... . .... ....... . . . . . . .. . . . . .. . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . ... .. ... ... .. . . . .. . . . . .. . .. . . . .. .. . .. ... .. ....... . ... .... . . . .. ................. . .. . . ..... . ....... ... ................... . ... . . .. ... ... . .. . . . . . .. . .. .. . . .. . . .. .. . .. . . ............ ...... ..... .. ........ ........ . .. .. . .. ............................ ......................... ........... .......... .. . . ......... . . .. .. ... ........ . . .. . . . . . .. . .. . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . .. .. ...................... .................... .. . . .. . . . . . . . .. . . . . . .. . ... . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. .... . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . .. . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. .. . . . . . . . . . .. .. .. . . . . . . . . ... ... . ... . . . . . .. . . .............. .. 2 .................. ........... . .. . .. . . .. .. .. . . ......... ... . ........... .. .................. .. . .............. ..... ... ................................ ...................... ............... ...... ......................... . .... .......... ... ... ................ .......... .. ........................ ... . ....... .. ...... ............................ . ....... . .................... ........................ ... ........................ .... .................... .... .. .. . . .... . ..... .... ...................... ..... ..................................... ................ ................................... ............................. . ... .. .. . .. . . . ..... ............ . .... .... ...... ...... ... .. ......... ................................. ........ .. .............. .............. ... ....... ..... .. ... ..... ............... ..... ...... .. ...... .................... ........ ...... ....... ............................. ... .... ..... .. ........... 3 ...................................................................... .. ...................................... ... ............. . .......... ...... ..... . .. ...... ..... ........ . ....... .. .............. ..... ... 11 ........ ...... ............ ...... ..... . .................. ........... ...... ........... .......... ... .... ........................ ........... ....... ....... .......... ................. ........................ .............. .... ............................. . ................ ..... ......... . . . . . ...... . . . . . ... . .. . . . . . . . . . . ... . .. . ..... . . .. .................. ....... . . . . . . . . . . .. .. . . . . . .. ... . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . ... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . .. . . .. . . . .. . .. .. .. . . .. .. . ... .. ..... ........... .............. .............. ............. .... ......................... ................................. .......... ..... ... .... .. ..... ........... ........... .... ... .............. ........................ ................ . ........ ................... .. ..... ........ ....... . . ...... ............... .... ................ . ..... ....... ....... ............... ................ ... ............. .. ....... .................. . .. ......... ...................................... ....... ............................ ... ... ...... . ... .. .......... ............ ......... . . ......... 4 ................................ .. ... ..... ....................... ........ ...... .... .. . ...... ......... ... ........ . ..... ... .. ... .. ............... ......... .......... ......... ....... ....... . .... ...... ............... ........ 19 ....................... . .. ..................................................... ................. .................. .... . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . ...... . . . . . .. . . . .. . . . . . . .... . .. . . . . ... . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . ... ... ..... . ...... ..... .. . ..... . ..... . .... . ..... 5 . ....................................................................... ..... .................................. . .. . . ..... . ...... ...... ................. ............. ........... . . .... . .. . ..... ......... ...... 18 .......................... . .. . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . .. .. . . . .. . .. . . . . . ......... ........... .... .... ... . . .. . . ............. .. ........ ......... .. .......... ............... .. .... ... . ... . 6 . . . . .. .. .. .. . . .. . . . .. . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . ......... ... ... ... ........... .............. . ... ............... ... ....... . . . . . ............. .. . . .............. .. . . . . . . . . . . . ................................................. . . . . . . .. . . 17 . . . .. .. .......... ........................... ... ... ..... ........ .............. . . ...... . . . .. 7.. ........................... ........ .. .. .... ... ......... . ........13 ............................... ................... ........ 12 .. ....... ... . . . . ... . . ....... .. .. . . . .... ..... . . . ..... ........ . . .......... . . .. . ............... ....... . . . ... . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . ... . . . . ..... .. . ........... .. .. . . . .......... . . . ... . .. ..... .................... . . ..... . . . .. ..... . . ...... ........ . .. .. . 20. ..................... . . . ......... .... .. . ... . . .. . ..... ... .............. . ................. .. . .... ..... ......... .. ..... . ................. . . . . . ...... ..... ... . ... ... .. .. ...................... . ..... ......... . .. . ... . . . . . . . .. ..... ......... . .......... . 8 . . . . . . . . . . . .. ... . . . . . . . 14 . . .. .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . ..... ..... . . . . . ..... ....................... .. . .. ... . . ......... ....... ........................... .... .. ......................................................... . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . .. . . . . .. . . .. . . . . . . .. . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .. . . . ... . . .. . ... . . ............................ .. .. ....... ......... . ... ..... ......... . . ... ..... . .... ............ ......... ......... ............................................ . .......... .. ....... 15 . . .............. . ........................................... . ..... ..... ... ................................ . ............. ..... . .... ...... ......... . ... . . . .. ............ . . . 21 ........ . .. . .. .. . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . ..... . . . 22 . 9 . .
1
..
60 40 20 0 –20 –40
–60 –180
–150
–120
–90
–60
–30
0
30
60
90
120
150
180
Figure 2.6 Locations map of air temperatures. To increase the accuracy of interpolation, the continents were divided into 22 tiles based on the density of weather stations. Reproduced from New et al. (1999) with permission from the American Meteorological Society.
New et al.’s method of fitting of splines to separate tiles helped to minimize the influence of data-rich regions on data-poor regions. Cross-validation of global thermal
maps indicated these potential sources of error were not so problematic as to obscure major patterns of thermal heterogeneity (New et al. 2000).
30
40
30
10 20 0 10 –10 0
–20
–30 90 75 60 45 30 15
0 –15 –30 –45 –60 –75 –90
Latitude (°)
Temperature range (°C)
Mean temperature (°C)
20
Figure 2.7 Air temperatures of terrestrial environments depend strongly on latitude. Data are the mean air temperatures (black circles) and annual ranges of air temperatures (gray circles) in the New World. Positive values of latitude are for the northern hemisphere. The maximal mean temperature and the minimal thermal range occurs in the tropics. Adapted from Clarke and Gaston (2006) with permission from the Royal Society.
THERMAL HETEROGENEITY
thermal environments (Vázquez and Stevens 2004). In contrast, the southern hemisphere has a weaker latitudinal cline in temperature (Fig. 2.7), owing to the buffering of the small land masses in this hemisphere by vast oceans (Addo-Bediako et al. 2000; Ghalambor et al. 2006). Aquatic environments exhibit far less variation in temperature because of water’s tremendous capacity to store heat. This phenomenon holds for freshwater and marine environments, but is especially exaggerated in large bodies of water such as oceans. For example, the annual range of surface temperatures of the Pacific Ocean never reaches one-half of the annual range observed at the same latitude on land (compare Figs 2.7 and 2.9). This thermal buffering keeps coastal climates warmer than inland ones, particularly in winter (New et al. 2002). Interestingly, while seasonal variation in temperature peaks at high latitudes in terrestrial environments, the peak occurs at intermediate latitudes in the oceans (see Fig. 2.9 and Parmesan et al. 2005). Nevertheless, mean water temperatures of marine and freshwater environments decrease from the tropics to the poles, in a manner that resembles latitudinal clines in air temperature (Clarke and Gaston 2006; Vannote and Sweeney 1980).
40 20 0 –20
Norway (70.5°N, 24.5°E)
–40 40 20 Minimal/maximal air temperature (°C)
0 –20 Belarus (53.5°N, 24.5°E)
–40 40 20 0 –20
Romania (45.5°N, 24.5°E)
–40 40 20 0 –20
Sudan (15.5°N, 24.5°E)
–40
27
40 20 0
2.2.2 Altitudinal clines
–20 Zaire (0.5°N, 24.5°E)
–40 0
60
120
240 180 Day of year
300
360
Figure 2.8 Seasonal profiles of daily minimal and maximal temperatures at five latitudes, ranging from the equator to the Arctic. The longitude was held constant at 24.5◦ E. Modified from Piper and Stewart (1996) by permission of the American Geophysical Union.
illustrates this point (Fig. 2.8). At the equatorial latitude of Zaire (0.5◦ N), temperatures remain fairly constant throughout the year. Moving from Zaire toward Belarus (53.5◦ N), the seasonal variation in daily temperatures becomes greater. As one moves even farther northward (70.5◦ N), the seasonal range of temperatures decreases slightly because summer temperatures never approach those seen at lower latitudes. The data from these localities reflect a very general latitudinal cline in the seasonality of
At any latitude, a shift in altitude results in predictable changes in solar radiation and air temperature. Both of these changes relate to the relatively low air pressure at a high altitude (air pressure reflects the mass of air above a point in the atmosphere). Recall that the atmosphere absorbs, reflects, or scatters radiation. If all else is equal, a shorter path through the atmosphere results in a greater transmission of radiation. Specifically, the exponent of the transmission coefficient (m of eqn 2.12) decreases linearly with decreasing air pressure (Gates 1980). Therefore, surfaces at a higher altitude receive a greater intensity of solar radiation. Additionally, the low air pressure at a high altitude reduces the air temperature through an adiabatic process (Monteith and Unsworth 1990). As the pressure of rising air decreases it expands and cools. For dry air, the magnitude of adiabatic cooling equals about 10◦ C per kilometer. Moist air cools less as it rises because of
28
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
35
12 10
25
8
20 6 15 4 10 2
5
Range of temperatures (°C)
Mean temperature (°C)
30
Figure 2.9 Surface temperatures of marine environments depend strongly on latitude. Data are the mean surface temperatures (black circles) and annual ranges of surface temperatures (gray circles) in the Pacific Ocean (170◦ W). Positive values of latitude are for the northern hemisphere. Latitudinal patterns of ocean temperatures match those of terrestrial air temperatures, except the thermal range of ocean temperatures peaks in each temperate zone and drops sharply toward each polar region. Adapted from Clarke and Gaston (2006) with permission from the Royal Society.
0
0
90 75 60 45 30
(a)
15 0 –15 –30 –45 –60 –75 –90 Latitude (°)
(b) 10
20
8 Number of sites
Temperature (°C)
0
−20
−40
6
4
2
0
−60 0
2
4 6 Altitude (km)
8
10
−8
−7 −6 −5 −4 −3 −2 Temperature lapse rate (°C km–1)
Figure 2.10 Air temperatures decrease with increasing altitude because of adiabatic cooling. (a) Air temperatures at different altitudes measured by a weather balloon released in Germany. Black and gray circles denote measurements taken during summer and winter, respectively. The slope of each line describes the rate of adiabatic cooling. (b) Most rates of adiabatic cooling throughout the globe range from –5◦ C to –7◦ C per kilometer of altitude. Hashed and gray bars denote measurements taken during summer and winter, respectively. Adapted from Dillon et al. (2006) by permission from Oxford University Press.
THERMAL HETEROGENEITY
the heat generated by condensation. We express the consequence of this cooling in the form of an environmental lapse rate, which equals the change in the temperature of still air with an increase in altitude. The environmental lapse rate varies among localities, but usually falls in the range of 5–7◦ C per kilometer (Fig. 2.10). Because of adiabatic cooling, an organism at a high altitude in the tropics can experience an air temperature similar to that experienced by an organism at a low altitude in the temperate zone (Ghalambor et al. 2006). Note, the greater solar radiation and the lower air temperature at higher altitude have opposing effects on the operative temperature of an organism (see eqn 2.10). In general, the effect of air temperature outweighs that of solar radiation, leading to lower operative temperatures at higher altitudes (Adolph 1990; Bashey and Dunham 1997; Beaupre 1995; Diaz 1997; Grant and Dunham 1990; Hertz 1992; Van Damme et al. 1989).
2.3 Quantifying local variation in operative temperatures Because operative temperature depends on absorbed radiation and environmental temperature, environments at higher latitudes or higher altitudes would offer lower operative temperatures if all other factors were equal. Yet all else is never equal! Regional differences in topographical and meteorological conditions disrupt the latitudinal and altitudinal clines in operative temperature caused by solar radiation and environmental temperature. For example, a uniform warming of air by 1◦ C along a latitudinal cline was predicted to increase body temperatures of intertidal mussels by anywhere from 0.1◦ C to 0.9◦ C, depending on the timing and duration of emersion at each site (Gilman et al. 2006). Similar irregularities in geographic clines result from variations in wind speed, cloud cover, and vegetation density. These factors influence conduction, convection, or radiation to create heterogeneity of operative temperatures on local scales. To really understand the selective pressures imposed by thermal environments, we must model the local variation in operative temperature. Quantifying local variation in operative temperature poses a major challenge. As we can see from eqn 2.10, the operative temperature depends on interactions among micrometeorological conditions
29
of the environment and physical properties of the organism (see also Gates 1980). Micrometeorological conditions vary greatly over very small scales (see, for example, Bartlett and Gates 1967); therefore, we must have some way of directly or indirectly monitoring these conditions at the numerous microenvironments available to an organism. Furthermore, color, shape, and size vary considerably among organisms. Consequently, models of operative temperature must be tailored for each species, or even for each phenotype of a species. Because of these difficulties, we know less about the variation in operative temperatures within local environments. What we do know about local heterogeneity comes from the use of mathematical, physical, and statistical models. These models differ in their attention to mechanism and their ease of application. At one extreme, a mathematical model provides a detailed description of heat transfer, but requires careful measurements of many parameters at each location. At the other extreme, a statistical model creates a black box relating environmental characteristics and operative temperatures. Although these models lack an explicit mechanistic link between variables, they offer the potential to predict operative temperatures over much broader scales. At the interface of these two approaches lies the popular approach of measuring operative temperatures with a physical model of the organism. In this section, we shall examine the advantages and disadvantages of each approach.
2.3.1 Mathematical models The earliest attempts to characterize operative thermal environments relied on mathematical models of heat transfer. As we saw in Section 2.1, we can use the principles of biophysics to derive a mathematical function relating operative temperature to micrometeorological variables and organismal parameters. Researchers have developed similar models for a wide range of organisms, including mollusks (Denny and Harley 2006; Helmuth 1998), insects (Henwood 1975; Kingsolver 1983), amphibians (Tracy 1976), and reptiles (Porter et al. 1973; Seebacher and Grigg 1997). Mathematical models have been used to characterize operative temperatures on both regional and local scales.
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
800
750
0
500 1000 Time (s)
1500 38
500 1000 Time (s)
500 1000 Time (s)
1500
500 1000 Time (s)
1500
35 34 33 32 31 0
500
1000
1500 44
Time (s)
0
0
36
Ground temperature (°C)
32 31 30 29 28 27 26 25
6 5 4 3 2 1 0
Predicted Actual
37
30 Air temperature (°C)
Wind speed (m s–1)
850
Body temperature (°C)
Solar flux (W m–2)
30
1500
43 42 41 40 39
0
Figure 2.11 Measurements of radiation load, air temperature, ground temperature, and wind speed were used to compute the temperature of a mussel on a rocky shoreline. On average, the predicted temperature fell within 1◦ C of the actual temperature of a mussel. Reproduced from Helmuth (1998) with permission from the Ecological Society of America.
For example, Porter and colleagues computed geographic variation in operative temperatures of various ectotherms on multiple continents (e.g., Grant and Porter 1992; Kearney and Porter 2004). At the other extreme, Bartlett and Gates (1967) calculated the range of operative temperatures on the surface of a single tree. Mathematical models not only predict operative temperatures, they also predict how evaporative cooling and metabolic heating might cause the body temperature to deviate from the operative temperature (Casey 1992; Helmuth 1998; Tracy 1976). Although mathematical models have provided tremendous insight regarding the factors that influence operative temperature, they are impractical for mapping thermal environments at a sufficient resolution to understand selective pressures on
behavior and physiology (O’Connor and Spotila 1992). To compute operative temperature from a mathematical model, one must know the solar radiation, ground reflectivity, air temperature, ground temperature, and wind speed (see Fig. 2.11). The overwhelming task of obtaining such data for a large number of locations precludes a fine-scale mapping. In most cases, researchers have computed operative temperatures for a limited number of microclimates, such as full sun and full shade (Christian and Bedford 1995; Seebacher and Grigg 1997; Van Damme et al. 1989). As we shall see in later chapters, this coarse-scale mapping of the environment obscures much of the heterogeneity that drives thermal adaptation. For this reason, many researchers have adopted a different approach to study thermal heterogeneity.
THERMAL HETEROGENEITY
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
31
Figure 2.12 Physical models of operative temperatures are constructed to mimic the radiative, conductive, and convective properties of an organism. Examples include a copper electroform of a lizard (a), a mussel shell filled with silicone (b), a copper tube designed to mimic a snake (c) and a moist agar model shaped like a toad (d). Because the agar model incorporates evaporative water loss, this type of model records wet operative temperatures. (b) Courtesy of Brain Helmuth; (c) courtesy of Steven Beaupre; (d) courtesy of Carlos Navas.
2.3.2 Physical models Physical models provide a convenient alternative to mathematical models for mapping thermal heterogeneity on very small scales (Bakken and Gates 1975). Physical models mimic the radiative, convective, and conductive properties of living organisms in the absence of physiological function. As such, the temperature of the model at its steady state equals the operative temperature (Bakken 1976, 1992). In theory, a physical model should have no heat capacity and would reflect a fairly instantaneous measure of operative temperature. In practice, good physical models of operative temperatures respond rather quickly to changes in heat flux relative to the responses of real organisms. To date, researchers have constructed physical models from a wide range
of materials, including metallic electroforms, rubber hoses, and dried exoskeletons (Fig. 2.12). For organisms that lack physiological control over evaporative cooling, models with a wet surface have been used to estimate steady-state body temperatures more accurately (Bartelt and Peterson 2005; Navas and Araujo 2000). When properly constructed, a physical model can predict the body temperature of an organism within 1◦ C of its actual value (reviewed by Dzialowski 2005). The most accurate models consist of hollow metallic electroforms painted to match the reflectivity of the organism (Fig. 2.12a). Metallic objects of similar dimension but slightly different shape yield larger errors (Walsberg and Wolf 1996). In the rare event that solar radiation and convection contribute
32
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
little to the heat flux of an organism, simple physical models constructed from commercial temperature loggers might adequately estimate operative temperatures (Vitt and Sartorius 1999). Nevertheless, one should always determine the accuracy of a physical model under a range of conditions that reflect those of the environment (Bakken 1976; Dzialowski 2005). Because most types of physical models require little time and money to construct, researchers can use these models to record operative temperatures on a much finer scale than they have done with mathematical models (Bakken 1989). For example, one can estimate the frequency of operative temperatures by placing models at randomly determined points (e.g., Grant and Dunham 1990) or at intervals along transects (e.g., Grant 1990). Alternatively, one can place models in specific microenvironments and use the area of each microenvironment to infer the frequency of operative temperatures (e.g., Grant and Dunham 1988). Collectively, these sampling designs have shown that operative temperatures depend on the type of substrate (Adolph 1990), the slope of the ground (Helmuth and Hofmann 2001; Sartorius et al. 2002), the amount of shade (Christian and Weavers 1996; Hertz 1992), and the posture and orientation of the organism (Bakken 1989; Christian and Bedford 1996; Grant and Dunham 1988). For a given location, posture, and orientation, operative temperatures rise throughout the morning and reach a maximum near the middle of the day (Bashey and Dunham 1997; Dorcas and Peterson 1998; Hertz 1992; Sartorius et al. 2002; Schäuble and Grigg 1998). Diel cycles of operative temperatures are more pronounced in terrestrial microclimates that receive solar radiation than they are in shaded or aquatic microclimates (Brown and Weatherhead 2000; Christian and Weavers 1996). Despite these insights, the majority of researchers have sampled environments at very low spatial and temporal resolutions. In a review of published studies, Dzialowski (2005) noted a typical sampling design has included fewer than five physical models deployed for no more than 5 days! Thus, while physical models offer practical advantages over mathematical models, very few researchers have capitalized on their potential to rigorously map operative thermal environments.
2.3.3 Statistical models A statistical model offers a powerful compromise between a highly mechanistic mathematical model and a purely phenomenological physical model. As seen in Section 2.1, we can use mathematics to describe an operative temperature in terms of heat fluxes between an organism and its environment. Equation 2.10 describes a precise relationship between many independent variables and the operative temperature. Nevertheless, we would need to know the values of these variables at very high spatial and temporal resolutions to map operative temperatures with this mathematical model. Although we cannot easily determine all of these variables at many points in the environment, we can obtain reasonable proxies for these variables at a high resolution. Given these proxies, we could capture a great deal of information about operative thermal environments from a statistical model (Hertz 1992; Howe et al. 2007; Sears et al. 2004). Ultimately, the power of a statistical model depends on the degree to which the independent variables relate mechanistically to operative temperature (or correlate with variables that do). Commonly used proxies include air temperature, wind speed, slope, aspect, and elevation, but some models also include categorical variables such as the type of substrate or vegetation (Box 2.2). Statistical models enable researchers to create detailed maps of operative thermal environments. For example, Sears and colleagues (2004) constructed a model that related slope, aspect, elevation, wind speed, and air temperature to the operative temperature of a small lizard. The independent variables were obtained from micrometeorological equipment and a digital elevation map. For some locations, operative temperatures were estimated with physical models (see Section 2.3.2). These point samples were used to parameterize the statistical relationship between the independent variables and the operative temperature. Once the model was parameterized, operative temperatures were predicted for an entire landscape at a series of times (Fig. 2.14). These thermal maps have a resolution of less than a meter and a mean error of less than 2◦ C! This scope and resolution of thermal mapping greatly exceed those achieved with mathematical
THERMAL HETEROGENEITY
33
Box 2.2 Modeling operative temperatures with artificial neural networks
or physical models alone. As we shall see in the chapters that follow, the mapping of fine-scale heterogeneity plays a critical role in understanding the selective pressures on organisms.
the model’s ability to predict the independent data even though its ability to predict the training data continues to improve. At this point, training should cease and the model should perform well when applied to new data. In general, artificial neural networks outperform linear models at predicting operative temperatures. For example, general linear models overpredicted low operative temperatures or underpredicted high operative temperatures (Howe et al. 2007; Sears et al. 2004). A potential drawback of an artificial neural network model is that mechanisms remain obscured by the “black box” of the model. Nevertheless, many ecologists have found these models ideal for predicting phenomena when underlying mechanisms exist but cannot be precisely formulated (Lek and Guégan 2000).
Continuous
Input layer
Discrete
Identifying the most accurate statistical model to predict operative temperatures can be challenging because these temperatures depend on the interaction of many environmental variables. Traditional statistical approaches, such as multiple regression analysis, often yield poor approximations of nonlinear relationships (Lek et al. 1996). To solve this problem, two groups of researchers have turned to artificial neural networks (Howe et al. 2007; Sears et al. 2004). An artificial neural network discovers the nonlinear relationship between a set of independent variables and a dependent variable. These models offer great flexibility and power because (1) the independent variables can be either continuous or categorical and (2) the relationships between these variables and the operative temperature can take on many different forms (e.g., linear, sigmoidal, and step functions). Parameterizing an artificial neural network involves a process that mimics learning by a brain (reviewed by Basheer and Hajmeer 2000; Lek and Guégan 1999). The basic structure of the model consists of three interconnected layers: an input layer, a hidden layer, and an output layer (Fig. 2.13). The input layer consists of independent variables, such as air temperature, wind speed, slope, aspect, and elevation. The output layer consists of the operative temperature. In between, a hidden layer transforms the data from the input layer to the prediction at the output layer. This transformation involves a set of coefficients and thresholds that serve as the parameters of the model. The process of learning begins by randomly choosing the values of these parameters. The model then proceeds to train itself by comparing the predicted and observed temperatures and adjusting the parameters to improve the fit. After many iterations of training, an artificial neural network will converge on an excellent description of the data. The trick is to avoid overtraining the model such that it provides a perfect description of the training data but a poor description of novel data. To avoid overtraining, one must periodically confront the model with independent data during the training process. Initially, training improves the ability of the model to predict both the training data and the independent data. But, eventually, training will decrease
time Ta sun2 sun5 wind height substrate bare broken thin thick
Hidden layer
Output layer
Tex
Figure 2.13 The structure of an artificial neural network designed to predict microenvironmental temperatures (Tex ) from a combination of continuous and discrete variables. The continuous variables in this model include the time of day (time), air temperature at 1.3 m (Ta ), wind speed at 1.5 m (wind), solar radiation over previous 2–5 minutes (sun2 and sun5), and height above the ground (height). Discrete variables include the type of substrate and the degree of ground cover (bare, 0–29%; broken, 30–69%; thin, 70–100% with visible substrate; thick, 70–100% with no visible substrate). Adapted from Bryant and Shreeve (2002) with permission from Blackwell Publishing.
2.4 Conclusions Since its derivation, the concept of an operative temperature has guided efforts to characterize thermal
34
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
58 46 34 21 9
Figure 2.14 Operative temperatures available to small lizards in the Mescalaro sand dunes (New Mexico, USA) change dramatically throughout the morning on a summer’s day (M. W. Sears, G. S. Bakken, M. J. Angilletta, and L. A. Fitzgerald, unpublished observations). (a–d) Each map depicts an operative thermal environment over an area of 460 × 320 m at a resolution of 0.5 m. (a) 7 a.m.; (b) 9 a.m.; (c) 11 a.m.; (d) 1 p.m. See plate 1.
environments from the organismal perspective. Spatial and temporal variations in solar radiation and air temperature give rise to changes in operative temperatures. All else being equal, operative temperatures decrease with increasing latitude or altitude. However, substantial heterogeneity of operative temperature exists within local environments, particularly terrestrial environments at higher latitudes. This local heterogeneity results from the physical structure of the habitat, as well as diel, seasonal, and annual changes in meteorological conditions. Spatial and temporal variations in operative temperatures undoubtedly impose selective pressures on the thermal sensitivities, thermoregulatory strategies, and life histories of organisms. Both the
magnitude and predictability of thermal change should determine the evolutionary impact. Diel and seasonal changes can be extreme, but they come with certainty. Stochastic variation among days and years complicates adaptation to predictable cycles. The relative magnitudes of predictable and unpredictable changes vary with latitude. Moreover, the size, mobility, and lifespan of an organism determine its perception of thermal heterogeneity. For example, a fruit fly experiences mostly diel change within its lifetime, but a Galapagos tortoise experiences diel, seasonal, and annual changes. As we shall see in the coming chapters, the course of thermal adaptation depends on the way each organism perceives the thermal heterogeneity of its environment.
CHAPTER 3
Thermal Sensitivity
3.1 Patterns of thermal sensitivity Anyone familiar with physics and chemistry should be unimpressed by the discovery that life depends on temperature. Temperature constrains the rates of chemical reactions, and biochemical reactions are no exception (Hochochka and Somero 2002). These constraints lead to thermal sensitivities of function at cellular, systemic, and organismal levels (Rome et al. 1992). The thermal sensitivity of biochemical reactions places severe limits on life (Pörtner 2002). Prokaryotic cells function within the narrow range of −5◦ C to 110◦ C (Jaenicke 1991, 1993). Eukaryotic cells are even further restricted, tolerating temperatures between −2◦ C and 60◦ C (Tansey and Brock 1972). Some organisms can tolerate temperatures outside these ranges, but do not function normally during exposure to such extremes. Yet, each living organism comprises a unique set of reactions. Thus, while the chemistry of life restricts the thermal tolerances of organisms, no two organisms have exactly the same thermal restrictions. By altering the structures of the reactants or even the nature of the reactions, species have evolved a rich diversity of thermal reaction norms. As an example, consider thermal reaction norms for fitness, which I refer to as fitness curves.6 Barlow (1962) compared the fitness curves of two species of aphids raised in controlled environments (Fig. 3.1a). The fitness of Myzus persicae was greatest at 20◦ C 6
I avoid the term tolerance curve (Levins 1968) because the literature contains conflicting uses of this term. Originally, Levins (1968) defined a tolerance curve as the relationship between an environmental variable and fitness. Since then, this term has also been used to describe the relationship between an environmental variable and survivorship (Gilchrist 1995). The word tolerance can also imply the critical thermal limits to performance (Pörtner 2002; van Berkum 1988).
and decreased sharply around this maximum. In contrast, the fitness of Macrosiphum euphorbiae was maximized over a wider range of temperatures (20−25◦ C). Relatively speaking, we could call M. persicae a thermal specialist and M. euphorbiae a thermal generalist. Similarly, fitness curves varied greatly among fives strains of rotifers (Fig. 3.1b). Differences among fitness curves have been observed for many kinds of organisms. Such observations demand explanation because natural selection should influence the thermal sensitivity of fitness more strongly than it does any phenotype. Although differences among fitness curves may motivate studies of thermal adaptation, the concept of a fitness curve offers thermal biologists very little advantage for understanding most biological phenomena. First, reaction norms for fitness cannot be measured accurately for many organisms. Fitness is a function of lifetime reproductive success, which obviously cannot be measured more than once per individual. In the examples above, asexual reproduction by aphids and rotifers enabled researchers to estimate the fitness curves of clones. But clones cannot be obtained for the majority of organisms under study. Second, biologists cannot easily measure the fitness of organisms in ecologically relevant environments. In most environments, temperature varies temporally within generations, and we might need to incorporate this variation in the concept of a reaction norm to accurately predict fitness (Fig. 3.2). Moreover, nature contains a plethora of biotic and abiotic factors that one cannot replicate in a laboratory, and these variables can interact with temperature to determine components of fitness (Fig. 3.3). Consequently, we cannot
35
36
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
Relative fitness (% of maximum)
(a)
(b) 100
100
80
80
60
60
40
40
20
20 0
0 0
5
10 15 20 25 Temperature (°C)
30
14
35
16
18 20 22 Temperature (°C)
24
26
Figure 3.1 Fitness curves vary within and among species. (a) Between two species of aphids, Macrosiphum euphorbiae (dashed line) tolerated higher temperatures than did Myzus persicae (solid line). Data are from Barlow (1962). (b) The thermal sensitivity of fitness varied tremendously among strains of parthenogenetic rotifers. Data are from Ricci (1991). In both studies, fitness was defined as the Malthusian parameter, r (see Box 3.3).
0.5 P < 0.10
Fitness (r)
0.4 0.3
P < 0.05 0.2 0.1 Constant temperatures Fluctuating temperatures
0.0 24
26
28
30 32 34 36 38 40 Mean temperature (°C)
42
44
Figure 3.2 Thermal reaction norms for fitness sometimes differ when measured under constant and fluctuating temperatures. In this example, fitnesses measured at two constant temperatures deviated from fitnesses measured in fluctuating environments with the same mean temperatures. Fitness was defined as the Malthusian parameter, r (see Box 3.3). Data are from van Huis et al. (1994).
be certain that fitness curves expressed in a laboratory resemble those expressed in nature. Finally, and perhaps most importantly, we generally do not ponder questions about the evolution of fitness, per se. Rather, we wish to understand the evolution of phenotypes that presumably contribute to an organism’s fitness. In this chapter, I focus on thermal reaction norms for organismal performance, which are generally referred to as thermal performance curves (Huey and
Stevenson 1979). I define performance as any measure of an organism’s capacity to function, usually expressed as a rate or probability. Common measures of performance include locomotion, assimilation, growth, development, fecundity, and survivorship7 (Table 3.1). Less common functions, such as sensory perception (Samietz et al. 2006; Werner 1973) and immunological activity (Hung et al. 1997; Mondal and Rai 2001), can also be considered performances. All of these functions share an important property: they respond rapidly (and usually reversibly) to changes in temperature. We can capture the general characteristics of this response with several parameters (Fig. 3.4): (1) the thermal optimum (Topt ); (2) the thermal breadth (or performance breadth); (3) the thermal limits, referred to as the critical thermal minimum (CTmin ) and the critical thermal maximum (CTmax ); and the maximal performance (Pmax ). To study variation in performance curves, we must first be able to quantify them objectively. Several approaches have been used to quantify performance curves. First, a mathematical function can be chosen and its parameters can be estimated by 7
Other authors have distinguished between curves for survivorship and curves for other performances. For example, Gilchrist (1995) referred to curves for survivorship as tolerance curves. Later, van der Have (2002) referred to the same concept as a viability curve. For simplicity, I chose to treat survivorship as I would any other measure of performance.
THERMAL SENSITIVITY
Growth rate (calories day–1)
1000
Cmax
37
C = 2000
500
0 1000
C = 1000
C = 500
500
0
5
10
15
5 20 Temperature (°C)
10
15
20
Figure 3.3 The amount of food available to a fish determines its thermal sensitivity of growth rate. Plots are shown for fish consuming 500, 1000, 2000, and maximal (Cmax ) calories per day. Reproduced from Elliot (1982) with permission from Blackwell Publishing.
Table 3.1 Common measures of organismal performance. Examples of each kind of performance reflect relevant measures for various taxa. The sources contain detailed descriptions of the procedures for measuring these performances. Performance
Examples
Source
Locomotion
Voluntary speed Maximal burst speed Maximal jumping distance Maximal sustainable speed Maximal distance (endurance)
Gilchrist (1996); Heckrotte (1983) Bennett (1980); McConnell and Richards (1955) Navas et al. (1999) Scribner and Weatherhead (1995); Wilson and Franklin (2000a) Angilletta et al. (2002b); Full and Tullis (1990); Ojanguren and Bra˜na (2000) Samietz et al. (2006) Greenwald (1974); Van Damme et al. (1991) Albentosa et al. (1994); Dutton et al. (1975); Warren and Davis (1967) Howe and Marshall (2002); Kaufmann and Pough (1982) Kudo et al. (2000) Avery et al. (1993); Harwood (1979); Nicieza et al. (1994); Waldschmidt et al. (1986) Boddy (1983); Lebedeva and Gerasimova (1985); Leffler (1972) Båmstedt et al. (1999); Brett et al. (1969) Li (2002); Stanwell-Smith and Peck (1998) Lamb and Gerber (1985) Berger et al. (2008); Howe (1962) Denoel et al. (2005); Wilson (2005) Carrière and Boivin (1997) Berrigan (2000); Leffler (1972) Selong et al. (2001)
Feeding/assimilation
Growth Development Reproduction
Survival
Mechanosensory ability Probability of capturing prey Ingestion of food/energy Absorption of water/minerals Photosynthesis Digestion/passage of food Change in length Change in mass/energy 1/duration of developmental stage % per day Egg production Mating success Oviposition rate Probability of survival per unit time Time until 50% mortality
fitting a statistical model to a set of data (Huey and Stevenson 1979). Choosing among potential models can be difficult, but tools for model selection can help when no a priori reason exists to choose a particular model (Box 3.1). Alternatively, others have
adopted a simpler approach based on the concept of a minimum convex polygon (Bauwens et al. 1995; van Berkum 1986). Regardless of the approach, an objective description of the performance curve enables us to determine its key properties.
38
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
Performance
Pmax
Performance breadth CTmax
CTmin
Topt Temperature Figure 3.4 A hypothetical performance curve shows the stereotypical optimum at an intermediate temperature. The thermal optimum (Topt ), performance breadth, critical thermal limits (CTmin and CTmax ), and maximal performance (Pmax ) are labeled. Adapted from Huey and Stevenson (1979) by permission from Oxford University Press.
Ascertaining the thermal limits of performance can be difficult, particularly when performance cannot easily be measured at extreme temperatures. Often, one must use an indirect means of bounding a performance curve. For example, curves for locomotor performance are generally bounded by some measure of immobility. For lizards, the inability of an individual to right itself has been used to estimate the critical thermal maximum. For fruitflies, the inability to cling to a surface has been used for the same purpose (Berrigan 2000; Huey et al. 1992). Lutterschmidt and Hutchison (1997a) argued that the temperature at which muscles begin to spasm provides the best measure of the critical thermal maximum. Whatever the measure, one should be aware of the assumptions associated with using indirect estimates of thermal limits to define performance curves (Lutterschmidt and Hutchison 1997 b).
Box 3.1 Selecting the best model of a thermal reaction norm
Maximal sprint speed (cm s–1)
To compare performance curves, we must be able to describe them objectively. This description usually involves fitting a statistical model to empirical data. Several models have been favored by researchers, but how do we know the best model to describe any particular set of data? Instinctively, we might fit several models to the data and choose the model that describes the greatest amount of variation (i.e., the model with the highest r 2 ). Although this approach seems reasonable at first, further thought raises a
serious issue. Literally thousands of models exist to choose from, and some of these models are so complex they would over-fit the data. In other words, a very complex model would not only describe the pattern of thermal sensitivity but also the error in the data (Burnham and Anderson 2002). Consequently, conclusions drawn from this model could be erroneous. What we desire is a model that describes the thermal sensitivity without fitting noise in the data.
Gaussian Exponentially modified Gaussian
200
150
100
50
0 0
10
20 30 Temperature (°C)
40
50
Figure 3.5 The relationship between temperature and sprint speed as described by two statistical models: a Gaussian model and an exponentially modified Gaussian model. A comparison of values of Akaike’s information criterion indicated that the Gaussian model provides a better description of the data. Data are the mean sprint speeds of 12 lizards. Adapted from Angilletta (2006) with permission from Elsevier. © 2006 Elsevier Ltd. continues
THERMAL SENSITIVITY
39
Box 3.1 Continued Information theory provides a more sophisticated approach to describe performance curves (Angilletta 2006). One starts with a set of hypothetical models. These models can be chosen for their general form or derived from some mechanistic understanding (e.g., Schoolfield et al. 1981; Sharpe and DeMichele 1977). Then, one fits each model to the data, obtaining the estimated parameter values and the residual sum of squares. Finally, one calculates the Akaike information criterion (AIC) for each of the models (Burnham and Anderson, 2002): AIC = −2L + 2K +
2K (K + 1) , N −K −1
(3.1)
where L equals the maximized log-likelihood value of the model, K equals the number of parameters (including the error term), and N equals the sample size. The maximized log-likelihood value of a model can be computed easily from the model’s residual sum of squares (Burnham and Anderson, 2002). The AIC estimates the information lost when using a particular model to describe the data. Therefore, the best the model in the set is the one with the lowest value of AIC.
Any survey of performance curves within or among species will reveal some variation in the thermal optimum, breadth, and limits of performance. Consider the performances curves shown in Fig. 3.6. For any type of performance, the shape or position of the curve varies among closely related organisms. For example, the lizard Takydromus wolteri sprints fastest at 30◦ C, but its congener Takydromus sexlineatus sprints fastest at 34◦ C (Fig. 3.6a). Likewise, two distinct types of performance need not be equally sensitive to changes in temperature; compared to survivorship, sprint speed proceeds well over a very narrow range of temperatures (Fig. 3.6f). Is such variation in performance curves adaptive? If so, how does this variation influence the ability of organisms to survive and reproduce in their environments? Many species (or genera) span large portions of the earth. Obviously, species that extend from the tropics to the poles must be capable of tolerating
The AIC differs from a simple measure of fit, such as the r 2 , because it also depends on the model’s complexity (i.e., the number of parameters). The second and third terms in eqn 3.1 eliminate the bias in fit associated with more complex models. By correcting this bias, we avoid choosing a model that overfits the data. To illustrate this point, consider two models that I used to describe the thermal sensitivity of locomotor performance (Fig. 3.5). Although a simple Gaussian model (r 2 = 0.70, K = 4, AIC = 45.2) describes much less variation than does an exponentially modified Gaussian model (r 2 = 0.98, K = 6, AIC = 71.4), information theory indicates the simple model provides a better description of thermal sensitivity (for details, see Angilletta 2006). This result should satisfy theorists, who often use a Gaussian function to study the evolution of performance curves (see Section 3.3). At the same time, this result should alarm empiricists, who often record performance curves that appear asymmetrical. Because the AIC depends on the sample size, a larger sample might have supported the more complex model. This example underscores the need to collect sufficient data to accurately describe the thermal sensitivity of performance.
thermal extremes. But how do these species accomplish this feat? Do individuals at the extremes of the range achieve lower fitness than individuals at the center of the range? Or have subpopulations adapted to thermal heterogeneity within the geographic range? Two distinct strategies would enable a species to occur over a broad geographic range. Populations at the extremes of the range could consist of specialists that perform best at their respective environmental temperatures. Alternatively, the global population could consist of generalists capable of functioning over a wide range of temperatures. Which of these strategies, if any, should we expect to evolve? And can this adaptation explain the diversity of performance curves observed among species? To answer these questions, we must consider the processes that define the thermal sensitivity of performance and the evolutionary costs and benefits of altering these processes.
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
(a)
(b)
100 80 60 40 Takydromus wolteri Takydromus sexlineatus Takydromus septentrionalis
20 0 15
Specific growth rate (d–1)
(c)
20
25
30
35
40 (d)
0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5
Spain Finland Russia Germany
0.4 0.3 16
18
20
22
24
26
28
(f)
90 60 30 0
Koliella anatarctica Chlorella sacchrophila Chlorella sorokiniana 0
10
20
30
40
0.05 0.04 0.03 0.02 Coenagrion hastulatem Coenagrion puella
0.01 12
14
16
18
20
22
24
26
28
1.00 0.98
80
Daily survivorship
Maximal daily fecundity
120
0.00 10
30
(e) 100
150
0.06 Developmental rate (d–1)
Sprint speed (cm s–1)
120
Photosynthesis (µmol O2 h–1 mg–2)
40
60 40 20 0
18
Woodland Agricultural 20
22
24 26 28 30 Temperature (°C)
32
34
0.96 0.94 0.92 0.90 0.88 0.86
36
0.84
Bactrocera cucurbitae Bactrocera dorsalis Bactrocera latifrons Ceratitis capitata 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30 32 34 Temperature (°C)
Figure 3.6 Thermal sensitivities of performance vary within and among species. Examples shown here represent common measures of organismal performance: (a) sprinting speeds in three species of lizards (Chen et al. 2003; Ji et al. 1996; Zhang and Ji 2004); (b) gross photosynthesis in three species of algae (Vona et al. 2004); (c) growth rates in four populations of Daphnia magna (Mitchell and Lampert 2000); (d) developmental rates (1/duration of larval stage) in two species of damselflies (van Doorslaer and Stoks 2005b); (e) fecundity in two populations of butterflies, Pararge aegeria (Karlsson and Van Dyck 2005); and (f) survivorship in four species of fruitflies (Vargas et al. 1996). Where shown, error bars are ± 2 SE. (e) Adapted with permission from the Royal Society.
3.2 Proximate mechanisms and tradeoffs What proximate factors determine the shape of a performance curve? The precise answer to this question almost certainly depends on the performance
in question. The asymmetrical performance curves for locomotion and growth differ markedly from the more symmetrical performance curves for survivorship (van der Have 2002). The answer also depends on the way in which we measure performance.
THERMAL SENSITIVITY
3.2.1 Thermal effects on enzymes (and other proteins) Hochachka and Somero (2002) brilliantly summarized the thermal constraints on the functions of enzymes (see also Fields 2001; Jaenicke 1991; Somero 1995). For any chemical reaction, temperature determines the proportion of reactants that possess the free energy required for reaction; as the temperature increases, more reactants exceed the energy of activation. Enzymes lower the energy required for activation and thus speed the reaction at any given temperature. The function of the enzyme requires both an initial conformation that can bind the substrate(s) and a change in this conformation that creates an ideal environment for the reaction. Because of the diversity of weak interactions that maintain the structures of proteins, either too high or too low a temperature will destroy the necessary conformation to bind substrate. Even a moderate drop in temperature alters the rate of conformational change, leading to inactivation at low temperatures well above that required to denature the enzyme. Thus, extreme temperatures impair enzymatic function and consequently slow biochemical reactions, leading to performance curves for specific
100 % of maximal activity
Chronic exposure to a temperature usually elicits a different level of performance than acute exposure (Christian et al. 1986; Kingsolver and Woods 1997). Nonetheless, for a particular measure of performance recorded with a particular methodology, we can ask which cellular and systemic factors dictate the thermal sensitivity. Do the same factors determine the thermal optimum and the critical thermal limits? Is the critical thermal minimum necessarily linked to the critical thermal maximum, or can these parameters evolve independently? Likewise, does physiology dictate a genetic correlation between the performance breadth and the maximal performance? As we shall see, modeling the evolution of thermal sensitivity demands tentative answers to these questions (see also Pigliucci 1996). Therefore, before we explore some evolutionary models, let us consider some hypothetical cellular mechanisms for the thermal sensitivity of performance.
41
80 60 40 20 0 20
25
30 35 40 Temperature (°C)
45
50
Figure 3.7 Thermal sensitivities of the activity of adenosine triphosphatase (ATPase) resemble sensitivities of organismal performance. Data shown here are for four species of lizards: Dipsosaurus dorsalis (solid circles), Gerrhonotus multicarinatus (open circles), Sceloporus undulatus (triangles), and Uma notata (squares). From Licht (1967). Reprinted with permission from AAAS.
enzymes that resemble those for whole organisms (Fig. 3.7). The substitution of amino acids can alter the thermal properties of proteins (Fields 2001; Jaenicke 1991). Because the active site of an enzyme requires very specific amino acids to promote covalent reactions, this region generally remains conserved during evolution. Instead, natural selection favors mutations that alter the conformational stability of the enzyme (Hochochka and Somero 2002; Marx et al. 2007). A more flexible structure helps an enzyme to change shape faster during catalysis. However, this instability of conformation comes at a price; a flexible enzyme spends a greater fraction of its time in a conformation that prevents the binding of substrate (Fig. 3.8). Hence, a flexible enzyme could have a lower affinity for its substrate. In general, an enzyme with greater conformational stability functions better at high temperatures, and an enzyme with less conformational stability functions better at low temperatures (Fields 2001; Somero 1995). Two kinds of enzymatic variants can underlie the diversity of performance curves (Somero 1995). A mutation that alters the structure of an enzyme can produce an orthologous allozyme that enhances performance at some temperatures but reduces performance at others. Duplication of genes can lead to the evolution of paralogous isozymes, which
42
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
Distribution of conformational microstates Warm-adapted ortholog
Cold-adapted ortholog
(a)
Binding competent
Binding competent
More ordered
Conformation
High
Binding ability
Low
Rate
Less ordered Low High
(b)
Binding competent
Binding competent
Figure 3.8 Temperature influences the distribution of conformational microstates for orthologs of a protein from warm- and cold-adapted species. (a) At a given temperature, a cold-adapted ortholog possesses a broader distribution of conformational microstates because of its flexible structure. For this ortholog, a larger fraction of molecules exists in conformations that bind ligands poorly (or not at all). However, these less ordered conformations reduce energy barriers for catalytic conformational changes and, therefore, speed enzymatic activity. (b) At their respective environmental temperatures, the intrinsic difference in stability between warm- and cold-adapted orthologs leads to similar distributions of conformational microstates for both orthologs. Adapted from Somero (2003) with permission from Elsevier. © 2003 Elsevier Ltd.
would enable an organism to operate over a wider range of temperatures. First, two identical copies of the gene would exist, and later one or both of these copies could evolve to alter the ancestral function of the enzyme. If one of these isozymes evolved greater or lesser flexibility, the pair would complement each other in a variable environment. However, unless additional resources are used to synthesize isozymes, an organism will still be unable to increase its performance in one range of temperatures without decreasing its performance in another.
Based on correlative evidence, we might conclude that performance curves respond to evolutionary changes in the structures of enzymes (Mitten 1997). For example, orthologous allozymes for lactate dehydrogenase, LDH-Ba and LDH-Bb , enable thermal specialization of swimming endurance in the common killifish, Fundulus heteroclitus (reviewed by Powers and Schulte 1998). The catalytic efficiency of LDH-Bb exceeds that of LDH-Ba at temperatures below 25◦ C, while the opposite is true at temperatures above 25◦ C. The function of LDH-B influences the level of ATP in erythrocytes, which regulates the affinity of hemoglobin for oxygen. Accordingly, homozygotes for LDHBb sustained faster swimming speeds at 10◦ C than did homozygotes for LDH-Ba , but these genotypes swam equally fast at 25◦ C. At high temperatures, I presume the swimming performance of homozygotes for LDH-Ba would exceed that of homozygotes for LDH-Bb , but this comparison has not been made. Consistent with this presumption, LDH-Ba occurs more frequently in populations that inhabit warm environments than it does in populations that inhabit cold environments. Importantly, neither genotype outperforms the other at all temperatures. Similarly, variation in the performance curves for growth rate among genotypes of Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) reflects the synthesis of paralogous isozymes (Rungruangsak-Torrissen et al. 1998). A common form of trypsin, TRP-2∗ 100, functions at high temperatures (> 10◦ C), whereas the variant TRP-2∗ 92 functions at low temperatures (< 9◦ C). Salmon that synthesized both forms grew fairly well in the range of 4−20◦ C. A second variant, TRP-1∗ 91, functions over a wide range of intermediate temperatures, such that individuals synthesizing both TRP-2∗ 100 and TRP-1∗ 91 grew faster in the range of 6−17◦ C than did individuals synthesizing both TRP-2∗ 100 and TRP-2∗ 92. These two patterns of isozyme expression represent thermal specialization and thermal generalization, respectively. Because individuals within populations of salmon differ in the number and concentration of isozymes synthesized under controlled thermal conditions (Rungruangsak-Torrissen et al. 1998), we could hypothesize that performance curves evolved by selection for the synthesis of particular isozymes.
THERMAL SENSITIVITY
Gel phase
Region of phase separation
Low temperature
Fluid, or liquid-crystalline, phase
43
Inverted hexagonal phase High temperature
Physiological temperature Membrane fusion
Figure 3.9 The structure of a membrane can shift from a fluid phase at tolerable temperatures (center) to either a gel phase at lower temperatures (left) or an inverted hexagonal phase at higher temperatures (upper right). The last phase ultimately results in fusion of the phospholipid bilayer (lower right). Reprinted, with permission, from the Annual Review of Physiology (Hazel 1995), Volume 57. © 1995 by Annual Reviews (www.annualreviews.org).
Although the evolution of isozymes appears less common than the evolution of allozymes (Fields 2001), both types of biochemical evolution could alter performance curves.
3.2.2 Membrane structure Temperature also determines the movement and conformation of cellular membranes (Fig. 3.9; Hazel and Williams 1990). On one hand, relatively low temperatures slow the movements of phospholipids, resulting in a gel-like membrane. On the other hand, relatively high temperatures speed these movements too much, disrupting the laminar structure. Passive regulation, active transport, and enzymatic function within membranes depend on a semifluid structure. Therefore, membranes perform the same balancing act between flexibility and stability performed by enzymes. Because of this balancing act, physiological functions involving membranes proceed best within a
moderate range of temperatures (reviewed by Hazel 1995). Although most organisms can maintain the full integrity of their cellular membranes over a breadth of 10−15◦ C, the optimal temperature depends on the composition of their phospholipids (Hazel 1995; Hazel and Williams 1990). Saturated fatty acids provide less intrinsic fluidity than do unsaturated fatty acids. Consequently, membranes composed of primarily saturated fatty acids function better at high temperatures than membranes composed of primarily unsaturated fatty acids. An organism can produce membranes suited for cold or warm environments by using the appropriate mixture of fatty acids (Fig. 3.10). Still, adaptation to one thermal extreme necessarily leads to maladaptation to the other extreme. Do thermal effects on membranes limit organismal performance less than or more than thermal effects on enzymes? Although this question seems reasonable, we would have difficulty separating
44
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
0.30 0.28 0.26
Anisotropy
0.24
3.2.3 Oxygen limitation
Pigeon
DPH at 20°C TPA at 20°C DPH at Tb TPA at Tb
Rat
Perch
0.22
Cichlid
0.20 0.18 Trout
0.16 0.14 0.12 –10
Notothenia 0
10
20
30
40
50
Body temperature (°C) Figure 3.10 Membranes of cold-adapted species (e.g., an Antarctic fish, Notothenia neglecta) are far more fluid (i.e., less ordered) than membranes of warm-adapted species (e.g., the rat or the feral pigeon). Species adapted to intermediate temperatures (perch, trout, and cichlid) possess intermediate levels of membrane fluidity. Membrane fluidity was assessed using fluorescent probes: 1,6-diphenyl-1,3,5-hexatriene (DPH) and trans-parinaric acid (TPA). A high level of anisotropy reflects a low level of membrane fluidity. Reprinted, with permission, from the Annual Review of Physiology (Hazel 1995), Volume 57. © 1995 by Annual Reviews (www.annualreviews.org).
the functions of membranes and enzymes in real cells. By disturbing the fluidity of a membrane, extreme temperatures likely slow the function of proteins embedded within the phospholipid bilayer (Else and Wu 1999; Wu et al. 2001, 2004). Such disturbances can also affect the function of intracellular enzymes that rely on substrates transported through the membrane. Finally, the permeability of membranes partly determines the cellular milieu in which enzymes must function (Somero 2003). Very likely, the interaction between membranes and enzymes limits the performance of organisms (see, for example, Almansa et al. 2003). With this in mind, we shall now consider a model of thermal tolerance that involves both enzymes and membranes, particularly those associated with aerobic metabolism.
Recently, Pörtner and colleagues (2000) proposed a model of thermal tolerance based on oxygen limitation. This model posits that the thermal limits of performance are set by the temperatures at which aerobic respiration fails to meet energetic needs (Fig. 3.11). At low temperatures, organisms become incapacitated by the inability of mitochondria to generate the ATP required for activity. At high temperatures, ventilation and circulation fall below the level required to supply the mitochondria with sufficient oxygen. This model draws support from the close match between the temperatures that cause death and the temperatures at which organisms shift from aerobic to anaerobic respiration (but see Klok et al. 2004; reviewed by Pörtner 2001). If this model correctly identifies the cause of critical thermal limits, adaptation to thermal extremes will require changes in mitochondrial, circulatory, and respiratory capacities. A greater density or capacity of mitochondria could lower the critical thermal minimum of an organism (Guderley 2004; Pörtner et al. 2000). Still, such adaptations of metabolic systems would impose a tradeoff. The current view assumes that adaptation to cold environments causes maladaptation to warm environments. This hypothetical tradeoff results from an increase in proton leaking and futile cycling within mitochondria, which increase energy consumption at rest (Pörtner et al. 1998, 2000). The higher resting rate of energy consumption will cause a parallel shift in the critical thermal maximum. This model also predicts a potential tradeoff between the performance breadth and the maximal performance. Although an increase in mitochondrial density would raise metabolic demands at rest, organisms can eliminate this cost by reducing the leakiness of membranes (Pörtner et al. 1998) or the activity of enzymes (Pörtner et al. 2000). Either of these strategies would limit aerobic scope, potentially causing a decrease in the capacity for performance. Thus, the model of Pörtner and colleagues links the thermal limits, performance breadth, and maximal performance in ways that resemble the tradeoffs associated with enzymatic function (see Section 3.2.1).
THERMAL SENSITIVITY
45
(a)
% Oxygen limited 100 aerobic scope (steady state)
Blood oxygenation Anaerobic metabolism
0 (b) Mo2 ∆max
Residual ATP production capacity + Proton leakage
0 (c)
Q
(cardiac + ventilatory output)
∆max
Qmax
Qrest 0 (d) Rate of aerobic performance
0 Temperature
3.2.4 Conclusions from considering proximate mechanisms Of the biochemical and physiological processes discussed in this section, which one really limits performance at the organismal level? The answer likely depends on the temporal scale of thermal heterogeneity. Fields (2001) noted that the temperature required to denature a protein can exceed the critical thermal maximum of the organism. Based on this point and other evidence, Pörtner concluded that oxygen limitation offers the most plausible
Figure 3.11 A model of thermal tolerance based on limits to aerobic capacity. The mismatch between oxygen demand and supply sets the window of thermal tolerance of metazoans. (a) The onset of anaerobic metabolism sets the critical thermal maximum. (b) At both low and high temperatures, the mitochondria cannot supply sufficient ATP. At low temperatures, the inactivation of mitochondrial enzymes and membranes prevents the production of ATP. At high temperatures, the rising fraction of mitochondrial proton leakage produces a mismatch between the supply and demand of oxygen. (c) Accordingly, the thermal sensitivity of ventilation and circulation, especially the difference between maximal and resting outputs, characterizes limits to oxygen supply and aerobic scope. (d) Thermal sensitivities of mitochondrial, ventilatory, and circulatory functions combine to generate an asymmetric performance curve, with a thermal optimum for performance near the temperature that maximizes aerobic scope. Adapted from Pörtner et al. (2006, Physiological and Biochemical Zoology, University of Chicago Press). © 2006 by The University of Chicago.
explanation for the thermal tolerances of organisms (Pörtner 2001, 2002). This conclusion may be valid for stable environments where organisms must grow and reproduce during persistent exposure to extreme temperatures. In heterogeneous environments, however, organisms could use anaerobic respiration to endure transient exposures to temperatures outside the window for aerobic scope. Other lines of evidence suggest the function of enzymes as a limiting factor for performance. The induction of heat-shock proteins under thermal stress implies that some loss of enzymatic function could
46
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
occur within the natural range of temperatures, which presumably exceeds the critical temperature for aerobic scope. van der Have (2002) found a striking match between the predicted thermal
limit of enzymatic activity and the observed thermal limit of embryonic survival (Box 3.2). Still, I believe that many factors contribute to the decline in organismal performance at extreme temperatures,
Box 3.2 Proximate basis of thermal sensitivity of development Thermal performance curves for survivorship during embryonic or larval stages possess a shape that differs from a typical performance curve (van der Have 2002). Instead of being asymmetrical, as in Fig. 3.4, these curves tend to be more symmetrical with very sharp transitions between the performance breadth and the thermal limits (see Fig. 3.6f). According to van der Have, this relationship stems from the reversible inactivation of proteins that drive cellular division. The gradual inactivation of enzymes with increasing or decreasing temperature can result in a thermal threshold for transcription (Fig. 3.12). Undoubtedly, cellular division and differentiation during development requires transcription. If proteins involved in transcription cannot maintain their functional conformation, the embryo or larvae would ultimately perish. This argument was formalized in a model describing the influence of a single rate-limiting enzyme (or group of enzymes) on development. The upper and lower temperatures at which transcriptional rates should drop
were calculated from the Sharpe–Schoolfield model: r (T ) =
0.5
Expected thermal limit (°C)
Rate or probability
transcription rate probability in active state
HA R
1 1 298.2 − T
(3.2)
where r equals the rate of development, T equals temperature in K, R equals the universal gas constant, 298.2 equals the temperature at which no inactivation occurs, HA equals the enthalpy of activation, Pa equals the probability that the enzyme will be in the active state, and ρ represents a fitted parameter (Schoolfield et al. 1981; Sharpe and DeMichele 1977). Using developmental rates for 14 species, van der Have estimated the temperatures at which activation and inactivation were equally likely (i.e., Pa = 0.5). Based on his model of the cell cycle, these temperatures would shut down transcription within cells. A striking match exists between the theoretical limits for development and the empirical limits for survivorship (Fig. 3.13). 40
1.0
ρTPa e 298.2
Ceratitis Dacus Drosophila Dendroctonus Lipaphis Myzus
30
20
10
0.0 0
10
TL
20
30
TH Temperature (°C)
40
50
Figure 3.12 Temperature affects the probability that an inducer activates the transcription of an operon. The rate of transcription drops sharply as the temperature approaches the point at which the transducer is equally likely to be active or inactive. Adapted from van der Have (2002) with permission from Blackwell Publishing.
0 0
10 20 30 Observed thermal limit (°C)
40
Figure 3.13 An excellent match exists between the observed thermal limits to survivorship and the expected thermal limits of development. Data are for 14 species of insects from six genera. A reference line of y = x is shown. Adapted from van der Have (2002) with permission from Blackwell Publishing.
THERMAL SENSITIVITY
Low-temperature specialist
High-temperature specialist
Generalist Figure 3.14 Specialist–generalist tradeoffs constrain variation in performance curves. An improvement in performance at low temperature requires a decrement in performance at high temperature, and vice versa. Thus, a specialist for low or high temperature would achieve greater maximal performance than a generalist.
especially given the coadaptation that occurs among different elements of thermal physiology (a topic explored in Chapter 7). Overall, the thermal limits to performance probably depend on a complex interplay between biochemical, cellular, and systemic designs. Regardless of the primary cause of thermal sensitivity, we can draw at least one conclusion about the potential constraints on performance curves. Most of the cellular mechanisms described above involve a tradeoff between performance at high temperatures and performance at low temperatures. For example, adaptations of enzymes and membranes to low temperatures generally result in maladaptations to high temperatures. Adaptations that enhance the aerobic capacity at low temperatures create an energetic sink at high temperatures. These biochemical constraints should give rise to genetic correlations between parameters of a performance curve. First, a genotype that performs well in cold environments should perform poorly in warm environments. In the context of a performance curve, a shift in the critical thermal minimum should require a parallel shift in the critical thermal maximum. Second, a genotype that functions over a broad range of temperatures (e.g., through the expression of multiple isozymes) should be a jack of all temperatures and a master of none (Huey and Hertz 1984). In other words, an increase in the performance breadth should cause a decrease in the maximal performance. We can classify these predicted correlations as specialist–generalist
47
tradeoffs (see Chapter 1), because an evolutionary increment in performance at one temperature causes an evolutionary decrement in performance at another temperature (Fig. 3.14). Given the cellular mechanisms described above, specialist–generalist tradeoffs should impose ubiquitous constraints on evolution.
3.3 Optimal performance curves To understand the tremendous variation in performance curves, let us first turn to optimality models. In particular, we shall focus on two distinct models designed to predict the relationship between a performance curve and fitness. Each model predicts the thermal optimum and performance breadth that maximize fitness in a given environment, subject to certain constraints. As we shall see, these models differ in fundamental ways, including the manner in which performance contributes to fitness (Box 3.3). The first model considers the thermal sensitivity of survivorship, or other performances that relate directly to survivorship. The second model considers the thermal sensitivity of fecundity, or other performances that relate directly to fecundity. Nevertheless, both models share many key features, including a strict constraint imposed by specialist–generalist tradeoffs. By examining these models in turn, we shall see how slightly different sets of assumptions lead to very different predictions regarding the optimal performance curve.
3.3.1 Optimal performance curves: survivorship and related performances Building on the seminal work of Levins (1968), Lynch and Gabriel (1987) modeled the evolution of performance curves for survivorship (i.e., the probability of survival during a unit of time).8 Their 8
Lynch and Gabriel envisioned their focus to be the evolution of fitness curves, which they termed tolerance curves. I avoid their interpretation and their vocabulary for good reason. They considered how performance responds to thermal heterogeneity within the life of an individual. Yet fitness is a property of an individual that should be characterized by a single value. Here, I reinterpret their model to understand the evolution of thermal sensitivities of survivorship because this interpretation seems equally valid and more intuitive.
48
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
Box 3.3 Performance and fitness How will performance curves evolve in variable environments? To answer this question, we must understand how the performance of interest relates to fitness. We might define fitness as the number of offspring produced by an individual during its life. But when estimating the mean fitness of a genotype (or phenotype), we cannot simply record the fecundity of individuals because many individuals will not live to reproduce at all. Therefore, we must also consider the probability that individuals will survive to reproduce. For practical purposes, we can define fitness as the rate at which a genotype increases within a population. This measure of fitness depends on two demographic variables: age-specific survivorship and age-specific fecundity (Stearns 1992). These variables contribute differently to the fitness of a genotype in stable and growing populations (Kozłowski 1992). In stable populations, fitness equals the net reproductive rate (R0 ): ∞ R0 =
l (x )m(x )dx ,
(3.3)
x =α
where l (x ) equals survivorship at age x , m(x ) equals fecundity at age x , and α is the age at maturity. In a growing population, one must estimate fitness another way because offspring produced early in life contribute more to the increase of a genotype than do offspring produced late
model makes predictions for an asexual organism with discrete generations, but the main predictions also hold for a sexual organism (Gabriel 1988). This model can also help us to understand the thermal sensitivity of any other performance that directly affects survivorship (e.g., sprint speed). The model was deigned to determine the optimal performance curve in an environment that varies stochastically over space and time. For simplicity, the body temperature of the organism was assumed to equal its operative environmental temperature. The operative temperature was described by a Gaussian probability distribution. Hence, the organism experienced the mean temperature most
in life. For a population with a stable age distribution, fitness equals the Malthusian parameter (r ), which we can estimate with Euler’s equation: ∞ 1=
e −rx l (x )m(x ) dx .
(3.4)
x =α
Note that eqn 3.3 defines a special case of eqn 3.4, in which the rate of population growth equals zero (i.e., r = 0). Because temperature affects r and R0 differently (Huey and Berrigan 2001), we need to know the appropriate measure of fitness for each population under investigation. Because many populations remain stable over long periods (Sibly et al. 2007), some modelers feel that R0 represents a superior measure of fitness (see Kozłowski et al. 2004). Regardless of the measure we choose, the fitness function reveals an important point about the relationship between performance and fitness. Performance can determine either the survivorship or the fecundity of a genotype at age x . Because l (x ) equals the product of survivorship from birth to age x , performances that affect survivorship contribute multiplicatively to the fitness of a genotype. But performances that affect fecundity contribute additively to the fitness of a genotype. As we shall see in this chapter, the distinction between multiplicative and additive contributions to fitness plays a critical role in understanding the evolution of performance curves (see also Gilchrist and Kingsolver 2001).
often and experienced extremely high and low temperatures rarely. To understand how temporal and spatial sources of variation were combined, imagine a genotype develops, grows, and reproduces in a particular subset of its environment; let us call this subset the microenvironment. This microenvironment has a mean (φs ) and a variance (Vtw ) of temperature. Assuming microenvironments vary, the mean temperature of each microenvironment, φs , is drawn from a distribution for the macroenvironment, which has its own mean (φt ) and variance (Vφ s ) of temperature. Finally, the distribution of temperatures for the macroenvironment, φt , can change over time. Consequently, two kinds of temporal heterogeneity must be considered:
THERMAL SENSITIVITY
49
0.5
z1
z2
Survivorship
0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0.0 –3.0
–1.5
0.0 1.5 Environmental temperature
variance within generations (Vφ tb ) and variance among generations (Vφ tb ). As we shall see, these sources of variation do not equally affect the optimal performance curve. Lynch and Gabriel modeled the performance curve as a Gaussian function (Fig. 3.15): 2 P(z1 , z2 |φ) = (2πz2 )−0.5 e[−(z1 −φ) /2z2 ] ,
(3.5)
where P equals the performance (i.e., survivorship), z1 equals the thermal optimum, and z2 determines the performance breadth. Because this function describes a probability density, the integral (or area under the curve) remains the same for all values of z1 and z2 . In other words, this function conveniently imposes a specialist–generalist tradeoff because an increase in performance at one temperature necessarily reduces performance at another. The values of z1 and z2 of an individual were determined by genotypic and environmental factors: z1 = g1 + e1
(3.6)
z2 = g2 + e2 .
(3.7)
and
In these equations, g1 and g2 represent genetic determinants of the thermal optimum and performance breadth, respectively, whereas and e1 and e2 represent deviations from the genetic values caused by the developmental environment. This developmental noise affects the optimal performance curve very
3.0
Figure 3.15 Lynch and Gabriel used a Gaussian performance curve to model the evolution of thermal sensitivity. This curve was determined by two parameters: a thermal optimum (z1 ) and a √ performance breadth ( z2 ). Adapted from Gabriel and Lynch (1992) with permission from Blackwell Publishing.
little, but adaptation would proceed more slowly when either e1 or e2 differed from zero (Lynch and Gabriel 1987). The fitness of a genotype, w( g1 , g2 ), depends on two things. First, we must consider its fitness in any particular microenvironment (φs ), subject to the temporal variance of temperature (Vφ tw ). Then, we must consider the probability that a genotype will experience that particular microenvironment, given the spatial variance of temperature (Vφ s ). Because the product of survivorships at all time intervals defines the survivorship to reproduction, fitness in a particular microenvironment must be calculated as the geometric mean of performance over the duration of a generation (τ ):
τ
1/τ P(g1 , g2 |φs )i
.
(3.8)
i=1
The probability of encountering a particular microenvironment was defined as: 2 f (φs |φt ) = (2πVφs )−0.5 e[−(φs −φt ) /2Vφs ] ,
(3.9)
where f (φs |φt ) equals the probability of φs given φt . By combining Eqns. 3.8 and 3.9, Lynch and Gabriel defined the expected fitness of a genotype, w( g1 , g2 |φt ), given the spatial and temporal
50
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
(a)
(b)
(c)
Optimal breadth (g2)
200
Vfs =
Vftb = 0
100
150 100
Vftb = 10
Vftb = 100
100
10
10
0.1
0.1
0.1 10
50
100
0 0
20
40
60
80
100 0 20 40 60 80 100 0 20 Variance of temperature within generations (Vφtw)
40
60
80
100
Figure 3.16 Both spatial and temporal variations in environmental temperature affect the optimal performance breadth. (a–c) Each plot shows the effect of temporal variation within generations (Vφ tw ) for different levels of spatial variation (Vφ s = 0.1, 10, or 100); (b The three plots differ in the level of temporal variation among generations (Vφ tb = 0, 10, or 100). For these analyses, Lynch and Gabriel assumed the existence of developmental noise in the thermal optimum, but no developmental noise in the thermal breadth. Adapted from Lynch and Gabriel (1987, The American Naturalist, University of Chicago Press). © 1987 by The University of Chicago.
heterogeneity of temperature: 1/τ +∞ τ w( g1 , g2 |φt ) = f (φs |φt ) P(g1 , g2 |φs )i dφs , −∞
i=1
(3.10) In biological terms, fitness equals the probability of surviving until reproduction at age τ . Lynch and Gabriel implicitly assumed that survivorship has no influence on fecundity (i.e., all genotypes produce the same number of offspring). Therefore, the genotype with the greatest probability of surviving until τ could expect the greatest fitness. Using this fitness function, Lynch and Gabriel calculated the optimal values of g1 and g2 for a combination of spatial and temporal heterogeneity in a single generation (Fig. 3.16a). Obviously, the optimal performance curve should be centered on the mean temperature (i.e., g1 = φt ). But does spatial and temporal variation affect the optimal breadth of the performance curve? Intuitively, the optimal performance breadth (g2 ) increases with increasing thermal heterogeneity. Two other results seem less intuitive. First, developmental noise in the thermal optimum favors a reduction in the performance breadth. This result occurs because developmental noise creates phenotypes with different thermal optima, which reduces the need for a genotype to have an inherently wide performance breadth. Second, spatial and temporal heterogeneity interact
to determine the optimal genotype; at high levels of spatial variation, even small levels of temporal variation favor moderate performance breadths (Fig. 3.16a). Lynch and Gabriel went on to consider the longterm fitness of genotypes with different performances curves. In doing so, they considered the effects of thermal heterogeneity within and among generations on the optimal performance curve. Variation among generations was modeled such that φt at each generation was drawn from a Gaussian distribution with a variance of Vtb . In this case, the fitness of a genotype corresponds to the geometric mean of performance within and among generations (n): 1/n n w( g1 , g2 ) = lim w(g1 , g2 |φt ) (3.11) n→∞
i=1
By substituting eqn 3.10 into eqn 3.11, Lynch and Gabriel extended their calculation of the optimal performance curve from a single generation to infinitely many generations. Importantly, extreme variation among generations always favors a greater performancebreadththanwouldbefavoredwhenthemean temperature remains the same among generations (Fig. 3.16b and c). Especially wide performance breadths are favored when the temperature within generations varies little over space or time. Despite these results, variation within generations has a
THERMAL SENSITIVITY
greater impact on the optimal performance breadth than does variation among generations. In summary, we can derive three testable predictions from Lynch and Gabriel’s model. First, the performance breadth for survivorship should be roughly proportional to the thermal heterogeneity experienced during an organism’s life. Second, the widest performance breadths for survivorship should evolve in spatially homogenous environments where temperature varies both within and among generations. Finally, both developmental noise and spatial variation prolong the time required for the optimal performance curve to evolve.
3.3.2 Optimal performance curves: fecundity and related performances Like Lynch and Gabriel, Gilchrist (1995) modeled the optimal performance curve of an asexual organism with discrete generations. But Gilchrist chose a fitness function that differed fundamentally from the fitness function described in the preceding section.
Low 50 (a)
In the model of survivorship, fitness was calculated as the geometric mean of performance over the life of the organism. In Gilchrist’s model, fitness was calculated as the sum of performance over the life of an organism. Arguably, performances such as growth and developmental rates contribute to fitness in this additive fashion. If so, we can use Gilchrist’s modeltounderstandhowcertainperformancecurves evolve by natural selection, particularly when the organism reproduces semelparously or when adult survivorship does not vary with age (see Box 3.3). Gilchrist envisioned an organism whose body temperature varied dielly and seasonally according to its environment. Diel variation in temperature was stochastic, but seasonal variation was deterministic; specifically, seasonal variation followed a sinusoidal function. Because the organism completed many generations per year, seasonal variation occurred primarily among generations. Using nine combinations of diel and seasonal variations, Gilchrist determined the optimal performance curve for different levels of thermal heterogeneity within and among generations (Fig. 3.17).
Variation within generations Medium
High (c)
(e)
(f)
(h)
(i)
Low
(b)
25 0 50 (d)
Medium
25 0 50 (g)
Variation among generations
Mean temperature (°C)
51
High
25 0 0
60
120
180 0
60
120
180
0
60
120
180
Day of season
Figure 3.17 Gilchrist modeled the evolution of thermal sensitivity under nine combinations of daily and seasonal variations in temperature. These combinations created different levels of thermal heterogeneity within and among generations. Variation within generations depended on stochastic daily changes (error bars) and the sinusoidal seasonal changes. Variation among generations depended entirely on seasonal changes. Adapted from Gilchrist (1995, The American Naturalist, University of Chicago Press). © 1995 by The University of Chicago.
52
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
Instead of using a Gaussian function, Gilchrist modeled the performance curve using an asymmetric function (e.g., Fig. 3.4), which was characterized by a performance breadth (B) and critical thermal limits:
of the frequency distribution and the performance curve:
P(Tb , B, CTmax )
= 4 eρ(Tb −CTmin ) − e[(ρB)−1.2ρ(CTmax −Tb )]
The long-term fitness of a genotype must be defined as the geometric mean of fitnesses for all generations (n): 1/n CT n max W= fg (Tb ) · P(Tb , B, CTmax )
(3.12) where Tb equals the body temperature, B equals the range of temperatures bounded by the CTmin and the CTmax , and ρ determines the area under the curve. To impose specialist–generalist tradeoffs, Gilchrist maintained a constant area under the performance curve by setting the value of ρ according to the other variables. As mentioned above, the fitness of a phenotype equaled the sum of performance throughout life. Because the temperature varied within and among days, the optimal strategy maximizes the sum of performance given the frequency distribution of temperatures in the current generation (fg ). Thus, the fitness for a single generation equals the product
fg (Tb ) · P(Tb , B, CTmax ).
g=1 Tb =CTmin
(3.14) Using eqn 3.14, Gilchrist determined the optimal performance curve in the nine environments shown in Fig. 3.17. The majority of environmental conditions favor a thermal specialist with the smallest possible performance breadth (Fig. 3.18). The thermal optimum of this specialist should roughly equal the most frequent body temperature. This result makes perfect sense when the temperature remains relatively constant over time. But, surprisingly, an
High
(a) 10
(b) 1
(c) 0.2
(d) 2
(e) 1
(f) 0.2
(g) 1
(h) 0.5
(i) 0.2
Low
40
Variation among generations Medium High
30 Maximal temperature (°C)
(3.13)
Tb =CTmin
Variation within generations Medium
Low 50
CT max
w=
20 50 40 30 20 50 40 30 20 0
10
20
30 0
10
20
30 0
10
20
30
Performance breadth (°C) Figure 3.18 Most patterns of thermal heterogeneity explored by Gilchrist (1995) favor the evolution of thermal specialists. These fitness landscapes correspond to patterns of thermal heterogeneity shown in Fig. 3.17. Contour lines delineate the fitness of the various performance curves; the interval of the contour lines resides to the right of each plot’s label (e.g., a 10). The triangle on each fitness landscape marks the optimal performance curve. Adapted from Gilchrist (1995, The American Naturalist, University of Chicago Press). © 1995 by The University of Chicago.
THERMAL SENSITIVITY
extreme specialist also achieves the greatest fitness when temperature varies moderately or even greatly within generations. This conclusion holds as long the variation among generations remains low. In fact, the optimal performance breadth tightly follows the ratio of variation within generations to variation among generations. Specialists are more fit than generalists when the variation within generations equals or exceeds the variation among generations (Fig. 3.18). The cause of this result should be obvious; a thermal specialist would become extinct during a generation when temperatures fall outside its performance breadth. Keep in mind, this model does not consider how spatial variation in temperature might preserve such genotypes. Gilchrist went on to consider how a bimodal distribution of temperatures would affect the optimal performance curve. Arguably, this extension of the model more accurately represents the thermal heterogeneity of most terrestrial environments and certain aquatic environments. The optimal performance curves were surprisingly similar to those of the initial model; extreme specialists possessed the greatest fitness unless variation among generations exceeded variation within generations. Nevertheless, we should expect the thermal optimum for performance to be centered on the modal temperature instead of the mean temperature. Because of the asymmetry of the performance curve, a thermal optimum equal to the upper mode confers greater fitness than a thermal optimum equal to the lower mode. If temperature does not vary, a thermal optimum equal to the lower mode confers the same fitness as a thermal optimum equal to the upper mode. We shall return to these points in Chapter 7.
3.3.3 Contrasting the two models We have analyzed two models that predict optimal performance curves in variable environments. Armed with these models, we can try to understand the diversity of performance curves described in Section 3.1. Before doing so, let us briefly compare and contrast the ideas captured by these models. Although both models consider a similar problem, each represents a unique set of assumptions about the nature of thermal heterogeneity, the constraints
53
on the phenotype, and the relationship between the phenotype and fitness. These assumptions define the environmental, phenotypic, and fitness functions of each model (Table 3.2). Not surprisingly, different assumptions lead to different predictions. In particular, the models provide radically different perspectives on the importance of temporal heterogeneity. Lynch and Gabriel’s model predicts that the performance breadth will be directly related to the thermal heterogeneity within generations. In contrast, Gilchrist’s model predicts that the performance breadth will be more affected by the relative amounts of thermal heterogeneity within and among generations. While these models differ in several ways, one seems most relevant to this result: the way in which performance contributes to fitness. Therefore, we should expect to observe broader thermal breadths of survivorship in organisms subject to greater variation in temperature. At the same time, we should not expect to see this same relationship when comparing thermal breadths of other performances. Despite this discrepancy, both models predict that the optimal performance curve will enable maximal performance at the most frequent body temperature (or very close to this temperature). Therefore, support for either model would depend on the degree to which the thermal optima for various performances match the mean or modal temperatures. For example, if we compared genotypes from warm and cold environments, we should observe a pattern similar to the one shown in Fig. 3.19a. Alternatively, we might observe only partial adaptation to local environments (Fig. 3.19b), which would weakly support these models. Finally, we might observe a difference in performance curves between genotypes that provides no support for these models. In particular, both models would be refuted if genotypes from one environment performed as well as or better than genotypes from other environments at all temperatures. I refer to such genotypes as masters of all temperatures. When these masters of all temperatures come from the colder environment (Fig. 3.19c), the pattern of intraspecific variation is called countergradient variation because the genetic effects on performance counter the environmental effects on performance (Conover and Schultz 1995). When these masters
54
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
Table 3.2 A comparison of two models of optimal performance curves. Major assumptions underlying the environmental, phenotypic, and fitness functions of each model are listed. Model component
Lynch and Gabriel’s model
Gilchrist’s model
Environmental function
• Temperature is normally distributed.
• Temperature is either normally distributed or bimodally distributed. • Mean temperature varies systematically among generations. • Mean temperature does not vary spatially. • Body temperature equals environmental temperature. • Temperature does not depend on other environmental variables. • The performance curve is skewed left. • The integral of the performance curve remains constant. • Developmental noise does not occur.
Phenotypic function
Fitness function
• Mean temperature varies stochastically among generations. • Mean temperature varies spatially. • Body temperature equals environmental temperature. • Temperature does not depend on other environmental variables. • The performance curve is symmetrical. • The integral of the performance curve remains constant. • Both genes and the environment (i.e., developmental noise) affect the performance curve. • The performance curve cannot acclimate to temperature. • Fitness for a single generation equals the product of performance over time. • Fitness over many generations equals the geometric mean fitness.
of all temperatures come from the warmer environment (Fig. 3.19d), the pattern is called cogradient variation. Neither pattern should occur when the performance curves evolve according to specialist– generalist tradeoffs.
3.4 Using models to understand natural patterns Many species have large geographic ranges, spanning broad latitudinal or altitudinal gradients. As the range of a species expands, populations at the leading edge encounter novel thermal environments. In general, populations at high latitudes or altitudes experience colder environments than do populations at low latitudes or altitudes (Chapter 2). Populations at different latitudes or altitudes also experience different amounts of temporal variation in temperature. Based on the models described in the preceding section, we should expect very different selective pressures over the range of a species. Provided sufficient genetic variation and limited gene flow exist, performance curves would diverge
• The performance curve cannot acclimate to temperature. • Fitness for a single generation equals the sum of performance over time. • Fitness over many generations equals the geometric mean fitness.
among populations (Grether 2005; Kawecki and Ebert 2004). Therefore, performance curves should vary predictably along latitudinal and altitudinal clines. To make useful predictions about geographic variation in performance curves, we must first consider how the performance of interest contributes to fitness. Consider the five performances most commonly measured: survivorship, locomotion, development, growth, and reproduction. How could each of these performances affect the fitness of an organism? The effect of survivorship is obvious; survivorship to maturation and survivorship between successive reproductive events factor heavily in calculations of fitness (see Box 3.3). Furthermore, Lynch and Gabriel’s model was specifically designed to predict the evolution of performance curves for survivorship (see Section 3.3.1). Using this model, we could make two predictions about the thermal sensitivity of survivorship: (1) colder environments, such as those found at high latitudes and altitudes, should lead to the evolution of lower thermal optima and (2) more variable environments, such as those found
THERMAL SENSITIVITY
(a)
Shift in thermal optimum (strong support for theory)
Performance Shift in thermal breadth (weak support for theory)
(d)
Performance
Performance
Temperature
Cogradient variation (no support for theory)
Hot source environment
Hot source environment Cold source environment
Hot source environment
Temperature
Temperature (b)
Countergradient variation (no support for theory)
Cold source environment
Hot source environment
Performance
Cold source environment
(c)
55
Cold source environment
Temperature
Figure 3.19 One of four patterns could emerge when comparing thermal performance curves between populations. (a) Evidence that thermal optima have diverged between populations strongly supports theory. (b) Evidence that performance curves have diverged and a specialist–generalist tradeoff occurred weakly supports theory. (c and d) Countergradient or cogradient variation does not support theory because thermal optima have not diverged and a specialist-generalist tradeoff has not occurred.
at high latitudes, should lead to the evolution of wider performance breadths. Now, consider the remaining performances. A greater capacity for locomotion can enhance foraging (Greenwald 1974), dominance (Robson and Miles 2000), and survivorship (Christian and Tracy 1981; Husak 2006; Jayne and Bennett 1990). If locomotor performance contributed significantly to survivorship, we should expect its thermal sensitivity to also vary according to Lynch and Gabriel’s model. If locomotor performance contributes to fitness more through fecundity than through survivorship, we should expect its thermal sensitivity to vary according to Gilchrist’s model. The same would be true for development, growth, and reproduction, which seem to contribute additively to fitness. The sum
of development over time determines the developmental stage at the end of that time; reproduction generally requires developmental transitions among embryonic, larval, and adult stages. Likewise, the sum of growth over these stages determines the body size at maturation, which strongly influences the fecundity of an organism (Roff 2002). Finally, reproductive performance contributes directly to fecundity. When performance contributes to fitness via its effect on fecundity rather than its effect on survivorship, we should expect slightly different patterns of variation along thermal clines. Although the thermal optimum should still decrease with increasing latitude or altitude, the performance breadth should vary only under certain conditions. Specifically,
56
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
geographic variation in the performance breadth should depend on the relative magnitude of intraand intergenerational variation in temperature (see Section 3.3.2). Obviously, these two components of variance depend on the lifespan and habitat of an organism. Short-lived aquatic species, such as Daphnia magna, experience relatively stable temperatures within generations because of the high heat capacity of water, but experience more variable temperatures among generations because of seasonal changes in water temperature. In such species, performance breadths for development, growth, and reproduction should increase with increasing latitude. For long-lived species (≥ 1 year), and particularly those in terrestrial habitats, performance breadths should remain relatively narrow over a latitudinal range. Armed with these specific predictions for real environments, we can see how well optimality models explain intra- and interspecific variation in performance curves. To keep things organized, we shall concentrate on the five performances described above, beginning with survivorship and ending with reproduction.
3.4.1 Survivorship The mere existence of organisms in extreme thermal environments, where most cannot survive, implies such organisms have adapted to these conditions (Clarke 1991). At one extreme, Antarctic fish swim in water cold enough to kill other fish (Wilson et al. 2001). At the other extreme, certain bacteria dwell in waters that would boil virtually any organism (Brock 1994). As assumed by current models, species adapted to extreme temperatures usually function poorly at moderate temperatures (see, for example, Wilson et al. 2001). Adaptation to thermal extremes seems to have come with a cost. This kind of qualitative support for the theory is reassuring, but the real utility of a theory comes from its ability to make predictions over a broad range of conditions. To determine whether current models provide this power, we must see how well they can predict intra- and interspecific variation in performance curves. Ideally, we would use direct comparisons of performance curves for survivorship to evaluate the
predictions of Lynch and Gabriel’s model. Surprisingly, such data are limited (Table 3.3). Although many researchers have documented relationships between temperature and survivorship (see review by Angilletta et al. 2004a), they have generally done so for one or two populations at a time. The paucity of well-designed comparative studies prohibits general inferences about the evolution of these performance curves; however, available studies paint a fuzzy picture. Moore (1940) made the first effort to formally relate the thermal breadth of survivorship to the range of environmental temperatures. His summary of published data suggested aquatic animals possess much narrower breadths for survivorship than do terrestrial animals. More recently, at least one intraspecific analysis of survivorship supported the predicted relationship between thermal heterogeneity and performance breadth; in the beetle Hyperaspis notata, the performance breadth of a strain from high latitude was broader than that of a strain from low latitude (Dreyer et al. 1997). In the vast majority of intraspecific comparisons, however, little support can be gleaned for our predictions. Comparisons of survivorship over narrow (Drent 2002; Lankford and Targett 2001) or wide ranges (Ayres and Scriber 1994; Otterlei et al. 1999; Reisen 1995) of temperatures yielded no covariation between thermal heterogeneity and performance breadth. In fact, two latitudinal comparisons of tadpoles from the same species yielded different results. For a pair of populations of Rana temporaria (Stahlberg et al. 2001), tadpoles from a cold environment survived better at a low temperature than did tadpoles from a warm environment. For another pair of populations of the same species (Merila et al. 2000), tadpoles from the colder environment survived worse at a low temperature and better at a high temperature! These more recent comparisons within species and genera fly in the face of Moore’s early study. Despite the inability of Lynch and Gabriel’s model to explain variation in performance breadth, the model still could explain variation in thermal limits of survivorship (reviewed by Garland and Carter 1994; Vernberg 1962). Many studies report direct measures of the thermal limits or indirect measures of thermal tolerance (Table 3.4). Indices of thermal tolerance include the temperature at which
THERMAL SENSITIVITY
57
Table 3.3 Comparative studies of the thermal sensitivity of survivorship. In most cases, individuals were raised from birth in a common garden (CG = Y), but in a few cases individuals either were acclimated to identical conditions for some number of days or were not acclimated (CG = N). Organism
Cline
CG
Measure(s)
Pattern
Source
No difference between populations
Ayres and Scriber (1994)
Canadian tiger swallowtail (Papilio canadensis) Atlantic croaker (Micropogonias undulatus) Common frog (Rana temporaria)
Latitude
Y
Survivorship at 12–30◦ C
Latitude
14 days
Survivorship at 1–5◦ C
No difference between populations
Lankford and Targett (2001)
Latitude
Y
Survivorship at 10–20◦ C for 15 days
Stahlberg et al. (2001
Common frog (Rana temporaria)
Latitude
Y
Survivorship of larvae at 14◦ C and 22◦ C
Beetle (Hyperaspis notata)
Latitude
Y
Survivorship at 15–34◦ C
Baltic clam (Macoma balthica) Mosquito (Culex tarsalis)
Latitude
Y
Survivorship at 10–20◦ C
Latitude
Y
Survivorship at 15–35◦ C
Latitude
Y
Survivorship at 4–14◦ C
Larvae from a cold environment survived better at 10◦ C than larvae from a warm environment. Larvae from a cold environment survived better at 22◦ C and worse at 14◦ C than larvae from a warm environment. B80 was broader for the strain from high latitude than it was for the strain from low latitude. No difference between populations Survivorship of females from a warm environment was higher at 20◦ C and 25◦ C than survivorship of females from a cold environment. No thermal or population trends
Atlantic cod (Gadus morhua)
Merila et al. (2000
Dreyer et al. (1997)
Drent (2002) Reisen (1995)
Otterlei et al. (1999)
Notes: B80 , 80% performance breadth.
animals lose motor function (knockdown temperature or critical thermal maximum), the duration of exposure to an extreme temperature before loss of function (knockdown time), and the time required to recover from exposure to an extreme temperature (recovery time). Because these measures are quick and easy to make on large numbers of individuals, many data exist to evaluate the predictions of optimality theory. We might deduce much about survivorship from these indirect measures of thermal tolerance. For example, we could interpret the knockdown temperature as an acute thermal limit to survivorship (Cooper
et al. 2008); in other words, survivorship equals zero at the knockdown temperature. Knockdown and recovery times probably correlate with the thermal limit to survivorship under chronic exposure, but should be interpreted with caution (Hoffmann et al. 2003). Certain geographic patterns of thermal tolerance make sense in light of Lynch and Gabriel’s model (Table 3.5). Early studies of reptiles and amphibians focused on variation in the critical thermal maximum, which arguably correlates with the acute thermal limit of survivorship. In some taxa, the CTmax tends to be greater for individuals that inhabit
58
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
Table 3.4 Common indices of the tolerance of extreme temperatures. Examples were chosen to illustrate applications in diverse taxa. Indices of freeze tolerance (e.g., supercooling point) were deliberately omitted because they do not reflect adaptation to temperature per se (Clarke 1991). Measure
Description
Example
Lethal temperature
The temperature that causes the death of 50% of the individuals in a sample (abbreviated as LT50 ) The time required for 50% of the individuals in a sample to die from exposure to a temperature (also abbreviated as LT50 , but should not be confused with the lethal temperature) Minimal or maximal temperature at which motor function ceases or muscular spasms occur (often used to place an upper or lower bound on a performance curve) Probability of survival following a brief exposure to a high temperature Probability of survival following a brief exposure to a low temperature The minimal temperature that causes an individual to lose motor function during heating The time required for an individual to lose motor function during exposure to a high temperature The maximal temperature that causes an individual to lose motor function during cooling The time required for an individual to recover from loss of motor function following exposure to a low temperature
Stillman and Somero (2000)
Lethal time
CTmin or CTmax
Heat-shock survivorship Cold-shock survivorship Knockdown temperature Knockdown time Chill-coma temperature Chill-coma recovery
warmer environments (Hertz 1979; Hertz et al. 1979; Licht et al. 1966a; Miller and Packard 1977; but see Spellerberg 1972). In other taxa, both the CTmax and CTmin decrease with increasing latitude (Snyder and Weathers 1975). In both situations, the thermal limits of performance appear to have shifted in the direction of the environmental temperature. Still, other patterns make no sense. For example, several investigators found no divergence in the CTmax or lethal limits along latitudinal clines (Gaston and Chown 1999; Klok and Chown 2005; Winne and Keck 2005). Overall, lower thermal limits seem to vary more closely with latitude than do upper thermal limits, which could stem from the steeper latitudinal cline in minimal environmental temperature (Ghalambor et al. 2006). The CTmin of dung beetles decreased with increasing latitude, despite no cline in CTmax (Gaston and Chown 1999). Furthermore, Castenada ˜ and colleagues (2005) observed a very strong relationship between the minimal environmental temperature and the chill-coma recovery time among four populations of woodlice. Importantly, most of these studies involved a small number of populations or species and included no phylogenetic control for pseudoreplication (see Box 1.5).
Berrigan (2000)
Gaston and Spicer (1998); Miller and Packard (1977); Winne and Keck (2005) Sorensen et al. (2005) Gilchrist et al. (1997) Huey et al. (1992) Huey et al. (1992) Gibert and Huey (2001) Castaneda et al. (2005)
More rigorous studies included larger samples or phylogenetic control. Stillman and Somero (2000) focused on latitudinal variation in the upper lethal temperature of crabs in the genus Petrolisthes. They found that crabs from warm environments survived acute exposures to higher temperatures than did crabs from cold environments (Fig. 3.20a). The same result was obtained when independent contrasts were used (Fig. 3.20b), indicating that adaptation of the thermal limit of survivorship has occurred within this genus. Despite this strong support for the current theory, the most comprehensive intraspecific study to date provided little support. AddoBediako and colleagues (2000) compared lower lethal temperatures and critical thermal maxima among species of insects. They found no evidence that the CTmax varied latitudinally. Although lower lethal temperatures decreased at the northern latitudinal extreme, this decrease in the mean resulted from an increase in the variance. Many species from very high latitudes exhibited lower lethal temperatures as high as those of species from low latitudes. A more comprehensive picture of the evolution of thermal tolerance has emerged from comparisons among populations and species of Drosophila
THERMAL SENSITIVITY
59
Table 3.5 Comparative studies of thermal tolerance, including lethal thermal limits (LT50 , CTmin , or CTmax ), heat resistance (knockdown temperature or time), and cold resistance (chill-coma temperature or recovery time). In most cases, individuals were raised from birth in a common garden (CG = Y), but in a few cases individuals either were acclimated to identical conditions for some number of days or were not acclimated (CG = N). Organism(s)
Cline
CG
Measure(s)
Pattern
Source
Algae Valonia utricularis
Latitude/longitude
Y
lower and upper lethal temperatures (LT50 s)
Lower and upper LT50 s were positively related to minimal and maximal environmental temperatures, respectively.
Eggert et al. (2003a)
Insects Drosophila buzzatii
Altitude
Y
Y
Altitude
Y
Knockdown time at 40◦ C
Latitude
Y
Loss of male fertility (CTmax )
Latitude
Y
Times to recover from exposures between –7◦ C and 2◦ C
Latitude
Y
Survival at –2◦ C for 2 hours
Latitude
Y
Recovery from 8 hours at 0◦ C
Latitude
Y
Knockdown time at 39◦ C
Latitude
Y
Latitude
Y
Time to recover from exposure to 0◦ C for 16 hours Loss of righting response (CTmin )
Drosophila serrata Drosophila spp.
Latitude
Y
Latitude
Y
Drosophila spp.
Latitude
Y
Knockdown time was negatively related to altitude; survivorships after heat and cold shocks were unrelated to altitude. Knockdown time was negatively related to latitude; in females, survivorship after heat shock was positively related to latitude (no relationship existed for males). Knockdown time was greater for populations from lower elevation. Tropical species had a higher CTmax than did temperate species. Temperate populations recovered faster than subtropical populations at low temperatures. Survival was positively related to latitude. Recovery time was negatively related to latitude. Knockdown time was negatively related to latitude. Recovery time was negatively related to latitude. CTmin was negatively related to latitude. Recovery time was negatively related to latitude. Cold tolerance was greater for species from higher latitudes, but heat tolerance was unrelated to latitude. Heat tolerances were greater for populations from lower latitudes.
Sorensen et al. (2005)
Latitude
Knockdown time at 37◦ C; survivorship after exposure to 40.5◦ C for 1 hour; recovery from 12 hours at 0◦ C Knockdown time at 40◦ C; survivorship after exposure to 40.5◦ C for 1 hour
Drosophila spp.
Latitude
Y
Drosophila melanogaster
Time to recover from exposure to 0◦ C for 8 hours Lower and upper lethal temperatures
Lethal time (LT50 ) at high temperature, resistance to knockdown, and knockdown temperature Time to recover from exposure to 0◦ C for 16 hours
Temperate species recovered faster than tropical species.
Sarup et al. (2006)
Sorensen et al. (2001) Rohmer et al. (2004) David et al. (2003)
Hoffmann et al. (2002) Hoffmann et al. (2002) Hoffmann et al. (2002) Ayrinhac et al. (2004) Gibert and Huey (2001) Hallas et al. (2002) Ohtsu et al. (1998)
Berrigan (2000)
Gibert et al. (2001) Continued
60
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
Table 3.5 Continued Organism(s)
Cline
CG
Measure(s)
Pattern
Source
Drosophila and Scaptodrosophila spp.
Latitude
Y
Lower and upper lethal temperatures
Kimura (2004)
Embryonopsis halticella Lycaena tityrus
Latitude
N
Lethal limits
Cold tolerance was greater for species from higher latitudes, but heat tolerance was unrelated to latitude; within species, cold tolerance was greater for strains from higher latitudes. No differences between populations
Altitude
Y
Time to recover from exposure to –20◦ C for 6 min; knockdown time at 47◦ C
Insecta
Latitude
N
CTmax and lower and upper lethal temperatures
Scarabaeidae
Altitude
4 days
Loss of righting response (CTmin ) and onset of spasms (CTmax )
Crustaceans Orchestia gammarellus
Latitude
51 days
Lethal temperature and lethal time
Petrolisthes spp.
Latitude
N
Upper lethal temperature (LT50 )
Porcellio laevis
Latitude/altitude
14 days
Times to recover from exposures between 0◦ C and 7◦ C
Altitude
4 days
Latitude/altitude
Cold tolerance increased with increasing altitude; heat tolerance was greater in populations from low and middle altitudes than in a population from high altitude. Lower lethal temperature was very low at high northern latitudes; upper lethal temperature and CTmax were unrelated to latitude. CTmin was negatively related to latitude; CTmax was unrelated to latitude.
Klok and Chown (2005) Karl et al. (2008)
Addo-Bediako et al. (2000)
Gaston and Chown (1999)
Individuals from a warm environment tolerated heat better than individuals from a cold environment. LT50 was positively related to maximal environmental temperature. Recovery time was positively related to minimal environmental temperature.
Gaston and Spicer (1998)
Loss of motor function (CTmax )
CTmax was negatively related to altitude.
Miller and Packard (1977)
N
Duration of survival at 46◦ C
Licht et al. (1966a)
Altitude
N
Anolis semilineatus Anolis gundlachi
Altitude
N
Altitude
N
Nerodia rhombifer Zootoca vivipara
Latitude
Y
Altitude
N
Onset of spasms and loss of righting response (CTmax ) Onset of spasms and loss of righting response (CTmax ) Onset of spasms and loss of righting response (CTmax ) Onset of spasms and loss of righting response (CTmax ) Loss of righting response (CTmin and CTmax )
CTmax was positively related to maximal field body temperature. CTmax was negatively related to altitude. CTmax was negatively related to altitude. CTmax was negatively related to altitude. No relationship with latitude
Amphibians Pseudacris triseriata Reptiles Amphibolurus spp. Anolis krugi
No differences between populations
Stillman and Somero (2000) Castañeda et al. (2005)
Hertz (1979) Hertz (1979) Hertz et al. (1979) Winne and Keck (2005) Gvoždík and Castilla (2001)
THERMAL SENSITIVITY
(a) 42 40
8
38
6
(b) 1.4 2
1.2 1.0 Contrast for LT50
9 12 10 11
36 LT50(°C)
5 7
1 3 4
13
34
14 16
32
15
17
30 19
28
15
0.6 0.4
0.0
r 2 = 0.88
26 10
0.8
0.2
18
20
21
61
20 25 30 35 Maximal temperature (°C)
40
45
r 2 = 0.72
–0.2 0.0
0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 Contrast for maximal temperature
3.0
Figure 3.20 Among species of porcelain crabs, the lethal temperature (LT50 ) was strongly related to the maximal temperature of the microenvironment. This relationship held for analyses of raw data (a) and independent contrasts (b). In the plot of raw data, each point represents the LT50 of a species: 1, Petrolisthes gracilis; 2, P. tridentatus; 3, P. armatus, northern Gulf of California; 4, P. armatus, Panama; 5, P. holotrichus; 6, P. hirtipes; 7, P. platymerus; 8, P. crenulatus; 9, P. sanfelipensis; 10, P. agassizii; 11, P. haigae; 12, P. galathinus; 13, P. granulosus; 14, P. cabrilloi; 15, P. cinctipes; 16, P. laevigatus; 17, P. violaceus; 18, P. tuberculatus; 19, P. manimaculis; 20, P. eriomerus; 21, P. tuberculosus. Adapted from Stillman and Somero (2000, Physiological and Biochemical Zoology, University of Chicago Press). © 2000 by The University of Chicago.
(reviewed by Hoffmann et al. 2003). Most studies to date accord with our theoretical predictions. For three species, intraspecific comparisons of chill-coma recovery revealed that tolerance of low temperatures has adapted to local climates. Flies of both D. melanogaster and D. serrata from high latitudes recovered faster than conspecific flies from low latitudes (Ayrinhac et al. 2004; Hallas et al. 2002). Drosophila buzzatii exhibited a similar cline in chillcoma recovery over its altitudinal range (Sorensen et al. 2005). Variation among species of Drosophila can also be explained by the theory. Intuitively, tropical species of Drosophila require far more time to recover from chill coma than do temperate species (Fig. 3.21). A phylogenetic comparative analysis by Gibert and Huey (2001) revealed correlated changes in latitude and the lower thermal limit during the evolution of a major clade; as expected, species that encountered higher latitudes have evolved a lower chill-coma temperature. Collectively, these data provide strong evidence that thermal limits in species of Drosophila have adapted to local thermal environments. Nevertheless, the same data also indicate that adaptation to one thermal extreme
does not necessarily cause maladaptation to the other. For example, tolerances to heat and cold seem to have evolved in parallel within D. melanogaster (Hoffmann et al. 2002), but have evolved independently within D. buzzatii (Sorensen et al. 2005). Unfortunately, we do not know whether the apparent increases in the breadth of thermal tolerance have imposed any costs of maximal performance. In summary, measures of survivorship under chronic exposures to constant temperatures do not support the current theory, whereas measures of thermal limits during acute exposures partially support the theory. Generally, thermal optima do not decrease and performance breadths do not increase with increasing latitude as predicted by Lynch and Gabriel’s model. In contrast, measures of lethal temperatures, knockdown times, and recovery times often covary predictably with latitude and altitude. In some instances, latitudinal variation in the lower thermal limit occurs in the absence of latitudinal variation in the upper thermal limit, suggesting greater thermal heterogeneity at high latitudes has led to the evolution of thermal generalists. Perhaps measures of acute thermal tolerance relate more to
Number of observations
62
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
15 14 13 12 11 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0
Tropical species Temperate species
0
10
20
30
40 50 60 70 80 Recovery time (min)
90
100 110 120
phenotypes under selection in natural environments than do measures of chronic thermal tolerance.
3.4.2 Locomotion The thermal sensitivities of jumping, swimming, walking, and sprinting have been estimated for many species (Table 3.6). In amphibians, the thermal sensitivities of jumping and swimming vary predictably within and among species. Wilson (2001) compared jumping performances among populations of the marsh frog, Limnodynastes peronii, along both latitudinal and altitudinal clines in eastern Australia. As expected, frogs from cool environments jumped better at low temperature and worse at higher temperatures than did frogs from warm environments; the performance breadth also appeared to be broader in cooler environments, but measurements were not taken over a broad enough range to compare performance breadths quantitatively. A similar study was conducted by John-Alder and colleagues, who compared jumping performances among species of North American frogs; they observed broader performance breadths in species that bred in colder environments. Extensive comparisons of swimming performance have been made among populations and species of frogs in the Andes of South America (reviewed by Navas 2006). Navas (1996a) showed that four species of frogs from high elevations had lower thermal optima and broader performance breadths than did their congeners from low elevations. In two of the four
Figure 3.21 Tropical species took far longer than temperate species to recover from an exposure to 0◦ C for 16 hours. Data are means for 26 temperate and 48 tropical species of Drosophila. Adapted from Gibert et al. (2001) with permission from Blackwell Publishing.
cases, this expansion of the performance breadth seems to have come at a cost of maximal performance (Fig. 3.22), indicating a specialist–generalist tradeoff. Similar adaptations along altitudinal clines have been observed within and among other species of anurans (Navas 2006). For a combination of historical and logistical reasons, the most comprehensive comparisons of thermal sensitivities have focused on the maximal sprint speeds of lizards (reviewed by Angilletta et al. 2002a). Briefly, one stimulates an individual to run along a linear track and records the greatest velocity achieved during the run. Usually, one records the fastest of several such runs as the maximal sprint speed. This procedure is repeated at different temperatures to construct a performance curve for each individual. An early study by Hertz and colleagues suggested the thermal sensitivity of sprint speed in an agamid lizard (Stellio stellio) had not adapted to thermal variation along an altitudinal cline. Later, more extensive investigations produced evidence of thermal adaptation. Among five species of Anolis, the thermal optimum for sprinting was correlated with the median field body temperature, and the 95% performance breadth9
9
Although mathematical definitions of the performance breadth vary among models, empiricists typically estimate this parameter as the range of temperatures that enables performance that equals or exceeds some percentage of the maximal performance. The two most common estimates are the 95% performance breadth and the 80% performance breadth.
THERMAL SENSITIVITY
63
Table 3.6 Comparative studies of thermal performance curves. These exemplary studies were chosen for their reasonable samples along thermal clines (at least three populations per cline or multiple clines) and sufficient resolutions of thermal performance curves (at least five temperatures). In most cases, individuals were raised from birth in a common garden (CG = Y), but in some cases individuals either were acclimated to identical conditions for some number of days or were not acclimated (CG = N). Performance
Organism(s)
Cline
CG
Pattern
Source
locomotion Sprinting
Anoles
Latitude/altitude
N
van Berkum (1986)
Sprinting Swimming
Starred agama Various genera of frogs
Altitude Altitude
N N
Jumping
Tree frogs
Latitude
N
Jumping
Striped marsh frog
Latitude/altitude
N
Rolling
Isopods
Latitude
N
Sprinting
Lizards
Latitude/altitude
N
Topt increased with increasing field body temperature; B80 increased with increasing variation in body temperature. None Topt was lower for each congener at a higher altitude. B80 increased with increasing variation in body temperature. Topt increased with increasing environmental temperature. Topt increased with increasing environmental temperature. Topt and CTmax increased with increasing field body temperature; CTmin was unrelated to Topt and CTmax .
Development Embryonic Common frog Larval Wood frog Larval Green frog
Latitude Altitude Latitude/altitude
Y Y Y
None Countergradient variation Countergradient variation
Larval
Latitude
Y
None
Assimilation/growth Wet mass Marine algae
Latitude/longitude
Y
Cell number
Bacteria
Latitude
Y
Dry mass
Trees
Latitude
Y
B80 increased with increasing range of environmental temperatures. Topt was related to water temperature. Topt was related to latitude.
Photosynthesis Photosynthesis
Pondweed Aquatic macrophytes
Latitude Latitude
Y N
none Topt was related to latitude.
Cell number Cell number
Symbiotic algae Marine algae
Latitude Latitude
Y Y
Topt was related to latitude. Topt did not vary, but B80 and thermal limits were widest for algae from the most stable environment.
Pea aphid
Hertz et al. (1983) Navas (1996a) John-Alder et al. (1988) Wilson (2001) Casta˜neda et al. (2004) Huey and Kingsolver (1993)
Laugen et al. (2003b) Berven (1982) Berven and Gill (1983; Berven et al. (1979) Lamb et al. (1987) Eggert et al. (2003a)
Hahn and Pockl (2005) Cunningham and Read (2003a) Pilon and Santamaría (2002) Santamaría and van Vierssen (1997) Sun and Friedmann (2005) De Boer et al. (2005)
Continued
64
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
Table 3.6 Continued Performance
Organism(s)
Cline
CG
Pattern
Source
Dry mass Energy
Water flea Atlantic halibut
Latitude/longitude Latitude
Y 40–50 days
Mitchell and Lampert (2000) Imsland et al. (2000)
Length
Medaka
Latitude
Y
Length/mass
Silverside
Latitude
Y
Wet mass Reproduction number of infective juveniles
Arctic charr
Latitude
Y
Cogradient variation Countergradient variation Countergradient variation Countergradient variation none
Yamahira and Conover (2002) Larsson et al. (2005)
parasitic nematodes
worldwide
Y
none
Grewal et al. (1994)
Yamahira et al. (2007)
Note: Topt , thermal optimum for performance; B80 , 80% performance breadth; CTmin , critical thermal minimum; CTmax , critical thermal maximum.
Atelopus
30
*
*
20
A. sp. nov. A. muisca A. varius
10 Strokes in 10 s
*
*
*
20
Colostethus
30
10
C. subpunctatus C. flotator C. talamancae
0
0 0 30
10
20
30 30
Eleutherodactylus
*
20
0
10
20
Hyla
*
* 20
* 10
*
10 E. bogotensis E. diastema
0 0
10
30
20
30
H. labialis H. microcephala H. ebraccata
0 0
10
20
30
Body temperature (°C) Figure 3.22 The thermal sensitivity of swimming performance differed between congeners in four genera distributed along an altitudinal gradient. Solid and open symbols denote species from high and low altitudes, respectively. Adapted from Navas (1996a, Physiological and Biochemical Zoology, University of Chicago Press). © 1996 by The University of Chicago.
was correlated with the range of field body temperatures (van Berkum 1986). An even larger study comprising 18 species of lizards representing four families lent additional support to the current theory
(van Berkum 1988). Among these species, the 95% performance breadth and the range of temperatures between the thermal limits (CTmax − CTmin ) were correlated with the range of field body temperatures.
Optimal temperature (°C)
(a)
(b) 40
30
r = 0.76 20 15
25
35
45
(c)
Critical thermal minimum (°C)
Field body temperature (°C)
Critical thermal maximum (°C)
THERMAL SENSITIVITY
65
50
40
r = 0.68 30
25
35
45
Optimal temperature for sprinting (°C)
16 r = 0.08 12
8
4 30
40 Critical thermal maximum (°C)
50
Figure 3.23 Evolutionary correlations were detected between thermal characteristics of 19 species of lizards. (a) The thermal optimum for sprinting evolved in concert with the mean field body temperature; the solid reference line has an intercept equal to zero and a slope equal to 1. (b) The critical thermal maximum evolved in concert with the thermal optimum for sprinting. (c) The critical thermal limits evolved independently. Adapted from Huey and Kingsolver (1993, The American Naturalist, University of Chicago Press). © 1993 by The University of Chicago.
Interestingly, the 80% performance breadth was unrelated to variation in field body temperature. In general, does the thermal optimum evolve to match the mean temperature experienced by lizards? Compiling data from these and other studies, Huey and Kingsolver (1993) conducted the largest comparative analysis of performance curves for sprinting. Moreover, they used a robust phylogenetic hypothesis to compute independent contrasts for these variables. Contrasts of thermal optima correlated strongly with contrasts of field body temperature (Fig. 3.23a), supporting the prediction that the thermal optimum should track the temperature experienced most frequently. If sprint speed were to evolve according to current models, we should also expect corresponding shifts in the CTmin and
CTmax ; however, only the CTmax evolved in concert with the thermal optimum (Fig. 3.23b and c). Thus, species with higher thermal optima can sprint over a wider range of temperatures than species with lower thermal optima. This result disagrees with the notion that specialist–generalist tradeoffs constrain the evolution of this performance curve. Such a result also sharply contrasts the patterns observed in frogs, whose evolutionary history seems to have been constrained by specialist–generalist tradeoffs (see above). As with the thermal sensitivity of survivorship, the thermal sensitivity of locomotion sometimes evolves according to the models described in Section 3.3, but does not always do so. For some taxa, important discrepancies exist between the predicted
66
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
and observed relationships among thermal heterogeneity, thermal optima, and performance breadths. The agreement between theory and observation will get considerably worse as we consider other performances.
3.4.3 Development From earlier in Section 3.4, recall two predictions about the thermal sensitivity of development. First, the thermal optimum should match the mean (or modal) temperature. Second, the performance breadth should scale according to the relative magnitudes of thermal heterogeneity within and among generations; for short-lived species, the performance breadth should increase with increasing latitude because seasonal variation would occur primarily among generations. Unfortunately, optimality models do little to help us understand latitudinal variation in the thermal sensitivity of development. Although few comparative studies of development have adequately defined the shapes of performance curves, none of these studies suggests these curves have evolved according to Gilchrist’s model (see Table 3.6). A few other studies provide either partial or indirect support for the model. For example, green frogs from a montane population developed faster at low temperatures but slower at high temperatures than did frogs from a lowland population (Berven et al. 1979). Similarly, copepods have diverged along latitudinal clines; genotypes from high latitude developed faster at low temperatures than genotypes from low latitude, and vice versa at high temperatures (Lonsdale and Levinton 1985). More often, investigators have uncovered either no latitudinal pattern or an unexpected pattern. Clones of pea aphids (Acyrthosiphon pisum) from five populations did not possess very different thermal optima or breadths, and neither parameter was related to latitude or temperature (Lamb et al. 1987). In fact, variation among clones within populations was greater than variation among populations. Hoffmann and colleagues (2005) raised genotypes of the mouse-ear cress (Arabidopsis thaliana) from 65 populations throughout the world. Their results were exactly the opposite of what we should expect
given thermal adaptation; plants from cold environments developed slower at 14◦ C and faster at 22◦ C than plants from warm environments. By comparing performance curves for development along latitudinal and altitudinal transects, investigators have uncovered many examples of countergradient and cogradient variations (Fig. 3.19c and d). Cogradient variation has been documented in common garden studies of insects, including ant lions (Arnett and Gotelli 1999) and fruit flies (Norry et al. 2001). Countergradient variation has been documented in similar studies of reptiles and amphibians. In two species of lizards, embryos from cold environments developed faster under cool and warm cycles of temperature than embryos from warm environments (Oufiero and Angilletta 2006; Qualls and Shine 1998). In frogs (Rana spp.), countergradient variation occurs on both macro- and microgeographic scales. Among five populations from latitudes ranging from 55◦ to 70◦ N, tadpoles at higher latitudes developed faster at constant temperatures (14−22◦ C) (Laugen et al. 2003a; Merila et al. 2000). Along altitudinal transects, tadpoles from mountain ponds developed faster over wide ranges of temperatures than did tadpoles from lowland ponds (Berven 1982; Berven and Gill 1983). On a microgeographic scale, tadpoles from shaded ponds developed faster at two constant temperatures than tadpoles from unshaded pond (Skelly 2004). The abundance of evidence for cogradient and countergradient variations challenges our theory, which assumes a jack of all temperatures will be a master of none. If we take these patterns at face value, we must conclude a genotype can be a master of all temperatures.
3.4.4 Growth Geographic variation in the thermal sensitivity of growth rate has been documented for many species (see Table 3.6). Here, I define growth broadly to include everything from the change in mass (or length) to the assimilation of energy from the environment (photosynthesis). As with developmental rate, we can explain very few observations using insights from Gilchrist’s model.
THERMAL SENSITIVITY
Growth rate (% inoculum)
800 2
600
1
3 4 5
6 7
400
200 0 16
18
20
22
24
26
28
30
32
Temperature (°C) Figure 3.24 The thermal optimum for the growth of symbiotic algae (Trebouxia irregularis) isolated from lichens of the genus Cladina varied with latitude. The relationship between the temperature of the environment during summer and the thermal optimum was quite strong (r 2 = 0.74, P < 0.005). Source localities: 1, Florida, USA; 2, North Carolina, USA; 3, Rhode Island, USA; 4, Oaxaca, Mexico; 5, Ontario, Canada; 6 and 7, Alaska, USA. Adapted from Sun and Friedmann (2005) with kind permission from Springer Science and Business Media. © Springer-Verlag 2005.
Studies of growth, in terms of biomass or length, have yielded very weak support for the current theory. The best support comes from a study of symbiotic algae (Trebouxia irregularis) isolated from seven populations of lichens (Cladina spp.) along a latitudinal transect (Sun and Friedmann 2005). The performance breadths of the algae were remarkably uniform for all populations, but the thermal optimum correlated strongly with latitude (Fig. 3.24). In other words, algae from cold and warm environments were specialized for low and high temperatures, respectively. Several other studies provide mixed support. Australian trees from temperate rainforests exhibited slightly lower thermal optima than did trees from tropical rainforests. Nevertheless, performance curves for temperate and tropical trees overlapped greatly (Cunningham and Read 2003a). Similar patterns of thermal adaptation were observed in fish (Belk et al. 2005; Schultz et al. 1996) and frogs (Berven et al. 1979; Stahlberg et al. 2001), but divergences in thermal optima between populations were minimal and genotypes grew submaximally within their natural range of environmental temperatures.
67
Many other researchers have documented patterns that cannot be explained by Gilchrist’s model. In most cases, genotypes from one environment outperform genotypes from other environments over a wide range of temperatures (i.e., countergradient or cogradient variation). For example, water fleas (Daphnia magna) spanning Finland to Sicily exhibited cogradient variation, with no evidence of divergence in the thermal optimum for growth rate among populations (Fig. 3.25c). Countergradient variation has been observed in a wide range of animals, including insects (Van Doorslaer and Stoks 2005a), crustaceans (Lonsdale and Levinton 1985), and fish (Imsland et al. 2000; Jonassen et al. 2000; Yamahira et al. 2007). The best studied case of countergradient variation occurs within the Atlantic silverside, Menidia menidia (Conover and Present 1990). Genotypes from high latitudes grow as fast as or faster than genotypes from low latitudes. A similar pattern has also been documented within the more narrowly distributed congener, M. peninsulae (Fig. 3.25d). Finally, certain patterns correspond to neither cogradient nor countergradient variation but still cannot be explained by Gilchrist’s model. For example, genotypes of herbaceous plants (Vicia pisiformis and V. dumetorum) from intermediate latitudes exhibited faster growth over a range of temperatures than did genotypes from high and low latitudes (Black-Samuelsson and Andersson 1997). Furthermore, marine algae (Fibrocaspa japonica) from very stable waters off the coast of New Zealand exhibited a wider performance breadth than those of conspecifics from more variable waters off the coasts of Germany and Japan (De Boer et al. 2005). Thermal sensitivities of photosynthesis also seem difficult to explain with Gilchrist’s model. Although thermal optima and performance breadths vary greatly among plants (reviewed by Berry and Bjorkman 1980; Davison 1991), rigorous comparative studies have generated some unexpected patterns. Cunningham and Read (2002) compared the thermal sensitivities of net photosynthetic rate between temperate and tropical trees. Consistent with the theory, trees from higher latitudes underwent maximal rates of photosynthesis at lower temperatures than trees from lower latitudes. Because a generation for a tree spans many seasons, thermal heterogeneity among seasons should have
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
(a)
(c) 0.9 FS1 MM SD LB OM CN
DO
Specific somatic growth rate (day–1)
68
0.8
Spain Sicily S. Germany N. Germany
0.7 0.6 0.5
OM FS1 MM SD
0.4 0.3
S2
(b)
DO S2 CN LB
17
20
Belgium Finland Russia England
23 26 Temperature (°C)
(d)
29
NS 5.0 Menidia menidia Menidia peninsulae
NS 40° N
NY Menidia menidia SC SA
30° N
NSB VB Menidia peninsulae
AB
Growth rate (mg day–1)
4.0 NY 3.0
SC SA
2.0
NSB VB
1.0
GK
GK 100° W
90° W
80° W
70° W
AB
60° W
0 15
20
25 30 Temperature (°C)
35
Figure 3.25 Cogradient variation in growth rate has evolved among populations of water fleas, Daphnia magna, while countergradient variations in growth rate have evolved among populations of Atlantic silversides, Menidia menidia and Menidia peninsulae. (a) Sites throughout western Europe where water fleas were collected: Munich, Germany (CN); Doñana, Spain (DO); Storgrundet, Finland (FS1); Lebrade, Germany (LB); Moscow, Russia (MM); Oude Meren, Belgium (OM); Sicily (S2); South Dalton, UK (SD). (b) Sites near the eastern coast of the USA where fish were collected: Nova Scotia (NS); New York (NY); South Carolina (SC); and St. Augustine (SA), Apalachee Bay (AB), New Smyrna Beach (NSB), Vero Beach (VB), and Grassy Key (GK), Florida. (c and d) The thermal sensitivities of growth, measured in terms of mass. Plots for Daphnia magna were reproduced from Mitchell and Lampert (2000) with permission from Blackwell Publishing. Plots for Menidia spp. were reproduced from Yamahira and Conover (2002) with permission from the Ecological Society of America.
resulted in the evolution of thermal specialists (see Section 3.3.2). Yet trees from more seasonal environments possessed a wider thermal breadth of photosynthesis (Fig. 3.26). Thermal sensitivities of photosynthesis by aquatic macrophytes are even more difficult to explain. Clones of Potamogeton pectinatus, collected over latitudes of 42◦ to 68◦ , possessed very similar performance curves (Pilon and Santamaria 2002). Worse still, species of aquatic macrophytes collected from high latitudes had
higher thermal optima than did species collected from low latitudes—the opposite of what should emerge from thermal adaptation (Santamaria and van Vierssen 1997).
3.4.5 Reproduction Relatively few researchers have investigated performance curves for reproduction along geographic
THERMAL SENSITIVITY
16
(b) 80% performance breadth for photosynthesis (°C)
80% performance breadth for photosynthesis (°C)
(a)
14 12 10 8 7
8
9 10 11 Annual range of maximal daily temperatures (°C)
12
69
16
14
12
10
8
8
9 10 11 12 Mean daily range of temperatures (°C)
Figure 3.26 Performance breadth for photosynthesis increased with increasing thermal heterogeneity during the year (a), but was unaffected by the magnitude of thermal heterogeneity during the day (b). Data are from Tables 2 and 3 of Cunningham and Read (2002).
clines (see Table 3.6). The most extensive comparison was made by Grewal and colleagues (1994), who compared the performance breadths of 12 species of parasitic nematodes from different regions of the world. Performance breadths differed between species from the same locality but did not differ among species from different localities. Hence, Grewal concluded thermal adaptation had not occurred. In contrast, recent studies of butterflies on a microgeographic scale yielded less surprising results. Butterflies from warm agricultural habitats laid more eggs at high temperatures and fewer eggs at low temperatures than did butterflies from cool wooded habitats (see Fig. 3.6e); this pattern held both within species (Karlsson and Van Dyck 2005) and between species (Karlsson and Wiklund 2005). Lastly, the thermal limits of fertility differed between males of temperate and tropical strains of D. melanogaster; the CTmin and CTmax of tropical males exceeded those of temperate males (David et al. 2005; Rohmer et al. 2004). Although these studies are too few to draw a general conclusion, Gilchrist’s model explains some, but not all, of these data.
3.4.6 Why do certain patterns differ from predicted ones? The simple models described in Section 3.3 make many assumptions, some of which will be invalid for any species. These assumptions fall into four broad categories: (1) assumptions about the state of
the environment, (2) assumptions about the nature of phenotypic constraints, (3) assumptions about the relationship between the phenotype and fitness, and (4) assumptions about the presence of genetic variation. First, we might have incorrectly related the thermal conditions of natural environments to the conditions of the models, including the mean, mode, or variance of operative environmental temperature. Second, the models might have incorrectly defined have the phenotypic set, including the range of phenotypes that organisms can express (e.g., thermal optima and performance breadths) and the tradeoffs that constrain the covariation between traits (e.g., specialist–generalist tradeoffs). Third, the models might have incorrectly defined the fitness set, including the timing or nature of how performance contributes to fitness. Finally, the hard-core assumptions of optimality models might have been invalid for some of the organisms considered above; from Chapter 1, recall that several assumptions must be made to infer evolutionary equilibria from optimality models, including the existence of genetic variation in performance curves (see Section 1.4.1). When one or more of these assumptions are violated, we can expect real patterns to differ from predicted patterns. Given the mixed support for the predictions of optimality models (Table 3.7), we should expect that some of the assumptions of the theory do not apply very generally to the species that have been studied thus far. By questioning our assumptions, we can learn how to develop more accurate models of the evolution of thermal
70
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
Table 3.7 A summary of comparative studies of thermal performance curves listed in Tables 3.3 and 3.6. The majority of these studies provided evidence of evolutionary divergence between populations, but only a minority of them provided support for the predictions of optimality theory
Performance
Case studies
Evidence of evolution
Support for theory
Survivorship Locomotion Growth Development Reproduction
8 7 11 4 1
4 6 9 2 0
2 6 5 0 0
sensitivity. Therefore, the remainder of this chapter focuses on the validity of these assumptions and the models that might provide deeper insights.
3.5 Have we mischaracterized thermal clines? To predict geographic variation in performance curves, we assumed some knowledge of the temperatures experienced by organisms. Although clear latitudinal and altitudinal clines in temperature exist (see Chapter 2), temporal and spatial heterogeneity in real environments likely differ from the conditions assumed in current optimality models. Unlike the normally distributed temperatures of Lynch and Gabriel’s model, temporal variation is bimodally distributed. Furthermore, temperatures in natural environments are correlated over time because of seasonal changes in climate. Gilchrist’s model accounts for the bimodal distribution and the temporal autocorrelation of temperature, yet this model also fails to explain many empirical observations. Perhaps the bigger problem is that both models assume that organisms conform to the operative temperature of their environment. Yet thermoregulation decouples the mean temperature of an organism from the mean temperature of its environment. In doing so, thermoregulation can inhibit the evolution of performance curves along geographic clines (Huey et al. 2003). In Chapter 4, we shall take a closer look at the evolution of thermoregulation. Lastly, neither optimality model considers the possibility
that environmental temperature could change directionally over time, such as the recent warming of many regions throughout the planet. In Chapter 9, we shall return to this topic and examine the consequences of continuous warming for the evolution of performance curves. Do these complexities really explain why geographic patterns do not conform to the predictions of optimality models? Or is there something fundamentally wrong with another aspect of the theory? To answer these questions, we can consider the results of two kinds of experiments: reciprocal transplants and laboratory selection (Kassen 2002). In a reciprocal transplant experiment, one moves a subset of individuals from one thermal environment to another thermal environment, and vice versa. If each population has adapted to its respective environment, genotypes will achieve greater fitness in their native environment than they will in a foreign environment. Furthermore, the native population should outcompete the transplanted population in each environment (Kawecki and Ebert 2004). Still, transplant experiments provide only weak support for models of thermal adaptation because environments differ in more ways than temperature. Laboratory selection experiments offer more powerful tests of evolutionary models. In a selection experiment, one exposes replicated populations to controlled temperatures and observes the evolutionary responses (Section 1.5.2). Thus, we can easily infer the selective environment and relate the evolutionary responses to our theoretical predictions. Nevertheless, artificial environments of the laboratory lack many of the important elements of natural environments (predators, parasites, competitors, etc.), preventing us from generalizing conclusions from laboratory experiments. Because both reciprocal transplant and laboratory selection experiments have distinct advantages and disadvantages, let us examine examples of each to see whether they support the predictions of optimality models.
3.5.1 Reciprocal transplant experiments Reciprocal transplant experiments have revealed strong evidence of adaptation to local environments. Schluter (2000) reviewed more than 40 experiments
THERMAL SENSITIVITY
in which the performance or fitness of native and transplanted genotypes were compared in multiple environments. In all but eight experiments, native genotypes outperformed transplanted genotypes in each environment. Some degree of adaptation to the local environment seems the norm rather than the exception. But to what extent has this adaptation been driven by thermal heterogeneity? If thermal adaptation has occurred, we should expect a correlation between the relative performance of a genotype and the thermal conditions of the environment. Such a correlation was observed when populations of the carline thistle (Carlina vulgaris) were transplanted among five regions of Europe (Becker et al. 2006). The fitness of plants was greatest in their native region and decreased as the difference in temperature between the native and transplant regions increased. An experiment conducted by Chapin and Chapin (1981) provided weaker support for the current theory, in the sense that only one of two performances followed the expected pattern. These researchers transplanted populations of a sedge (Carex aquatilis) among five locations, ranging from an Arctic site (4◦ C) to a subalpine site (17◦ C). Only Arctic plants survived in the Arctic, but these same genotypes did not survive in three of the warmer sites. Roughly speaking, growth rates in localities where multiple genotypes survived were consistent with cogradient variation. Other experiments yielded results consistent with countergradient variation or no variation in performance curves. Cleavitt (2004) reciprocally transplanted fragments of a subalpine moss (Mnium arizonicum) and a lowland moss (M. spinulosum). In both environments, the subalpine species survived as well as or better than the lowland species. Furthermore, quantum yield was greater for subalpine adults in both environments. By transplanting tadpoles between lowland and mountain ponds, Berven (1982) observed faster growth (but not faster development) of montane genotypes in both environments. Reciprocal transplants of lizards (Sorci et al. 1996) and frogs (Morrison and Hero 2003a) along altitudinal gradients yielded no evidence of adaptation to local environments. Overall, reciprocal transplant experiments confirm the conclusion we drew from a survey of comparative data: simple optimality models cannot account for some of
71
the variation in thermal sensitivity observed along geographic clines.
3.5.2 Laboratory selection experiments Laboratory experiments enable researchers to directly explore the evolutionary consequences of specific selective environments (see Chapter 1). To date, laboratory selection of short-lived organisms— viruses, bacteria, and fruit flies—have contributed to our understanding of thermal adaptation. In each experiment, a population was maintained at a single constant temperature for many generations to enable adaptation to the artificial conditions of the laboratory. Then, the population was subdivided to form selection lines. Each line was exposed to one of several thermal environments for another series of generations. At the end of this period, the performance curves of these lines were compared. For each experiment, optimality models predict specific outcomes; for example, selection at a constant temperature should produce a thermal specialist that performs maximally at this temperature. Bennett, Lenski, and their colleagues have conducted some of the most elegant experimental studies of thermal adaptation. Taking advantage of Escherichia coli’s short generations, ease of culture, and genetic markers, these investigators designed a selection experiment that meets the rigorous standards required to infer adaptation (see Box 1.4). First, selection lines were established from populations that had been raised under laboratory conditions for 2000 generations; thus, the investigators were unlikely to have confounded adaptation to artificial conditions with adaptation to environmental temperature. Second, sufficient replication was used to generate confidence intervals for the mean response to selection. Third, genetic markers enabled the researchers to eliminate the possibility that contamination or migration caused the observed patterns. Finally, a remarkable feature of E. coli makes these studies of adaptation truly unique: E. coli survives prolonged exposure to freezing temperatures, enabling Bennett and colleagues to store ancestral populations and directly compare the performances of ancestral and derived lineages.
72
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
empirical observations are the most impressive evidence of thermal adaptation to date. Still, some important predictions of the theory could not be confirmed. Optimality models assume that adaptation to the mean or modal operative temperature will come at the expense of fitness at other temperatures. This phenomenon was seen in some lines but not others. Adaptation to 20◦ C was accompanied by a decrement in fitness at 42◦ C, but the converse was not true. In fact, most lines maintained their tolerance ranges despite the expectation that specialists would have evolved at constant temperatures (Fig. 3.27). Perhaps the duration of selection was insufficient for specialists to evolve. In a similar experiment, selection for 20 000 generations at 37◦ C resulted in increasing specialization over the first 10 000 generations, with significant increases in specialization occurring only after the first 2000 generations (Cooper et al. 2001). Huey and colleagues (1991) compared the performances of flies that had evolved at 16.5◦ C and 25◦ C for over 4 years. They found only weak support for the predictions of Gilchrist’s model. Flies that evolved at 16.5◦ C developed faster at 16.5◦ C and slower at 25◦ C than flies that evolved at 25◦ C. Nevertheless, differences in developmental rates were small and both sets of selection lines developed faster at 25◦ C than they did at 16.5◦ C. Hence, any shift in the thermal optimum was likely to be very slight. Possibly, the thermal limits of survivorship responded to selection because flies that evolved at
Bennett et al. (1992) used a population of E. coli that had been cultured at 37◦ C for 2000 generations. The population was raised in flasks of medium and was diluted daily through serial transfers. After an initial period, the population was divided into 24 selection lines, each of which was assigned to a thermal environment. Six lines were shifted up by 5◦ C (42◦ C lines), six lines were shifted down by 5◦ C (32◦ C lines), and six lines were cycled daily between 32◦ C and 42◦ C (32−42◦ C lines); a fourth set of six lines remained at 37◦ C to enable the researchers to consider further adaptation to laboratory conditions. These lines were maintained at their respective thermal regime for 2000 generations. After this period of selection, the thermal sensitivities of fitness were described in two ways. First, they estimated absolute fitness in terms of clonal growth. Second, they calculated the fitness of the derived line relative to its ancestor by resuscitating the ancestral genotype and growing it alongside the descendants (Bennett and Lenski 1993, 1996; Bennett et al. 1992). During the experiment, all lines adapted to their thermal environment. In fact, adaptation of the thermal optimum was nearly perfect! Thermal optima for lines that evolved at 32◦ C, 37◦ C, and 42◦ C equaled 30◦ C, 37◦ C, and 42◦ C, respectively. Moreover, lines in the fluctuating environment evolved a thermal optimum equal to the upper mode (42◦ C), which corresponds exactly to the prediction of Gilchrist’s model. In my mind, these matches between theoretical predictions and
1.50 1.25 Fitness relative to ancestor
1.50
32°C lines
*
1.00
1.00
0.75
0.75
0.50 1.50
20
25
30
35
40
0.50 1.50
42°C lines
1.25
*
1.00 0.75 0.50
37°C lines
1.25
*
*
1.25 1.00
*
20
25
30
35
40
32/42°C lines
*
* *
*
0.75 20
25
30
35
0.50 40 20 25 Temperature (°C)
30
35
40
Figure 3.27 Experimental evolution of Escherichia coli at 32◦ C, 37◦ C, 42◦ C, or 32–42◦ C for 2000 generations increased fitness in the selective environment without decreasing fitness in other environments. Plots show the mean fitness of selected lines relative to the mean fitness of the ancestral line over a range of temperatures. Asterisks denote temperatures at which the fitness of the selected lines differed significantly from the fitness of the ancestral line. Adapted from Bennett and Lenski (1993) with permission from Blackwell Publishing.
THERMAL SENSITIVITY
(a)
4 G4 at 44°C
18
14 12
2
Fitness 10 Mutations 8
1
6 0 50
70
90 Passage
110
4 130
(b)
6 5
4
φX174 at 44°C
Fitness
4
3 Mutations
3 2 2 1
1
0 –1
0
10
20 30 Passage
40
50
Number of mutations
3
Number of mutations
Fitness of G4 (doublings per generation)
16
increased exponentially during incubation. Following incubation, a subsample of the viral population was transferred to a new flask of naïve bacterial cells and the cycle continued. Large populations (106 ) were used to minimize genetic drift during the experiment. Selective regimes were tailored to each phage. The investigators knew one of the phages (G4) tolerated high temperatures poorly; therefore, they cultured this phage at 37◦ C for 40 transfers, then at 41.5◦ C for 50 transfers, and finally at 44◦ C for 50 transfers. The other phage (φX174) was cultured directly at 44◦ C for 50 transfers. At certain intervals, the fitnesses (or doubling rates) of the phages were measured at 37◦ C and 44◦ C to assess whether adaptation had occurred. The fitness of the G4 phage increased slowly and steadily throughout the experiment, but the fitness of the φX174 phage increased very sharply within five generations and remained relatively constant thereafter (Fig. 3.28). During adaptation to 44◦ C, the φX174 phage suffered a slight decrease in fitness at 37◦ C, but the G4 phage suffered no decrease in fitness at this ancestral temperature. Possibly, loss of fitness at lower temperatures occurred but went undocumented. Following up on this possibility, Knies and colleagues (2006) analyzed the pattern of adaptation in the G4 phage using
Fitness of φX174 (doublings per generation)
16.5◦ C were less likely to survive a brief exposure to 39.5◦ C than were flies that evolved at 25◦ C. One year following this study, the lines at 25◦ C were divided to create an additional set of lines, which were shifted to 29◦ C. After 4 additional years of evolution, James and Partridge (1995) remeasured developmental times in the three sets of lines. At temperatures ranging from 16.5◦ C to 29◦ C, the lines that evolved at 16.5◦ C developed faster than the lines that evolved at either 25◦ C or 29◦ C. Countergradient variation, which has been documented often among natural populations (see Section 3.4), had evolved in the laboratory! The survivorship following heat shock still differed predictably among lines. However, the knockdown temperature, the survivorship following cold shock, and the thermal optimum for sprinting differed very slightly or not at all (Gilchrist et al. 1997). Recently, viruses have been added to the family of organisms used to study experimental adaptation to temperature. Holder and Bull (2001) permitted two bacteriophages to evolve through serial transfers at a constant temperature. Each phage was introduced into a culture flask with an excess of bacterial cells and was incubated for a period of time. Each infected bacterial cell lysed to yield approximately 100 viral progeny, such that the viral population
73
0.6 0.4 0.2 0
Figure 3.28 Experimental evolution of bacteriophages at 44◦ C revealed slow and steady adaptation by one phage (a) and rapid adaptation by another (b). Each plot shows the accumulation of mutations (filled circles) in a phage, along with the change in fitness (open circles). Error bars denote standard errors of the mean of four assays. Adapted from Holder and Bull (2001) with permission. All copyright is retained by the Genetics Society of America.
74
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
Box 3.4 Template mode of variation: a novel statistical method for describing variation among performance curves Assuming performance curves have a common form or template, one can describe variation in these curves among genotypes in terms of the shifting or stretching of this template. Kingsolver (2001) described three modes of variation: hotter–colder, faster–slower, and specialist–generalist (Fig. 3.29). The hotter–colder and faster–slower modes describe horizontal and vertical shifts, respectively. The specialist–generalist mode describes a simultaneous horizontal stretch and vertical shift. Izem and Kingsolver (2005) showed how one can estimate the percentage of variation associated with each of the modes. First, a template model must be fitted to data for multiple genotypes. These investigators used a simple model with three parameters of interest: 1 1 Pi (Tb ) = ai + P (Tb − mi ) , (3.15) bi bi
(b)
(c)
Performance
(a)
where Pi equals the performance of genotype i , and the parameters ai , mi , and bi set the mean performance, thermal optimum, and performance breadth, respectively, of the template. By examining differences in these parameters among genotypes, one can determine the degree to which each of the three modes contributes to variation in the performance curve. Importantly, the specialist–generalist mode should not be confused with the specialist–generalist tradeoffs discussed throughout this chapter. The specialist–generalist mode defines a pattern of variation in the performance curve, whereas specialist–generalist tradeoffs define a class of mechanisms that lead to such patterns. Actually, both the faster–slower and the specialist–generalist modes can result from specialist–generalist tradeoffs. Therefore, the concepts of modes and tradeoffs are related but not equal.
Temperature Figure 3.29 Using template mode of variation, one can partition the variation in a performance curve among three modes: (a) faster–slower, (b) hotter–colder, and (c) specialist–generalist. These modes reflect changes in the parameters of a template function. Adapted from Knies et al. (2006) with permission from the Public Library of Science.
a method known as template mode of variation (Box 3.4). They obtained samples of this phage from the ancestral and selected populations and measured the thermal sensitivity of fitness over a much broader range of temperatures (27−44◦ C). A shift in the thermal optimum accounted for almost 50% of the evolutionary change in the thermal reaction norm. This analysis nicely demonstrated that adaptation to high temperature caused maladaptation to low temperatures, as assumed by optimality models.
3.5.3 Conclusions from reciprocal transplant and laboratory selection experiments Reciprocal transplant and laboratory selection experiments have corroborated the failure of optimality models to explain the evolution of thermal sensitivity. Many reciprocal transplant experiments revealed evidence of local adaptation, but adaptation to one environment does not always cause maladaptation to other environments. Selection experiments with E. coli and D. melanogaster demonstrated conclusively that a jack of all temperatures need not
THERMAL SENSITIVITY
be a master of none. Furthermore, the experiment with D. melanogaster showed that thermal optima sometimes evolve slowly even in the face of strong selective pressure. Given the designs of these experiments, we cannot attribute the mismatch between theory and observation to poor knowledge of the thermal environment. Instead, we must question other assumptions of optimality models.
3.6 Have phenotypic constraints been correctly identified? Two constraints define the phenotypic functions of the optimality models described in this chapter: (1) performance curves cannot change by acclimation and (2) performance curves must maintain a constant area during evolution. The first constraint prevents the hypothetical organism from adjusting its thermal sensitivity of performance during development. In Chapter 5, we shall consider the potential for thermal acclimation and examine models that relax this constraint. The second constraint prevents an organism from adapting to one temperature without losing function at another temperature. Because specialist–generalist tradeoffs have been a major focus of this chapter, let us now consider the empirical evidence for this constraint.
3.6.1 A jack of all temperatures can be a master of all Much evidence stands against the idea that specialist–generalist tradeoffs universally constrain performance curves. Numerous examples can be found among the comparative studies discussed in Section 3.6. Even the earliest comparisons of performance curves indicated that a jack of all temperatures could also be a master of all; for example, Huey and Hertz (1984) found that the rank order of performance among individuals of several species was fairly conserved across a range of temperatures (ca. 20◦ C). Much experimental work, including both quantitative genetic and artificial selection experiments, now corroborates this comparative evidence. A comparison of wasp strains raised under common environmental conditions revealed little or no correlation between the performance breadth and the maximal performance (Carriere and Boivin
75
1997), whereas a comparison of aphid families revealed a negative genetic correlation for males but no genetic correlation for females (Gilchrist 1996). Among 29 genotypes of Daphnia pulicaria, no relationship existed between the thermal breadth of fitness (r) and the maximal fitness (Palaima and Spitze 2004). Using template mode of variation (Box 3.4), Izem and Kingsolver (2005) discovered that only half of the variation among families of butterflies reflected some form of specialist–generalist tradeoff; the remaining half included variation in the height of the performance curve (13%) and variation that could not be explained by their model (33%). Selection experiments have also provided mixed support for the importance of specialist–generalist tradeoffs. Selection for greater performance at one temperature does not always cause a correlated decrease in performance at other temperatures (Anderson et al. 2005; Bennett and Lenski 1993; Carrière and Boivin 2001). As concluded from the survey of comparative data (Section 3.4), a jack of all temperatures does not have to be a master of none.
3.6.2 The proximate basis of performance determines tradeoffs Recall that specialist–generalist tradeoffs arise from the thermal adaptation of enzymes, membranes, and organelles (see Section 3.2). Despite the sound biochemical basis for specialist–generalist tradeoffs, species can apparently avoid these tradeoffs during evolution. How do some genotypes become masters of all temperatures? And what other kinds of tradeoffs prevent these genotypes from taking over the world? When performance curves differ between genotypes, the proximate mechanisms that generate this difference can be quite complex. These mechanisms not only include changes in the structures of enzymes, but can also include changes in concentrations (Somero et al. 1996). Furthermore, enzymes do not function in a vacuum; they interact intimately with their surroundings and these interactions affect the thermal sensitivity of enzymatic function. Additional stability emerges from interactions between enzymes and other molecules, such as ions, substrates, coenzymes, biogenic amines, and ATPconsuming chaperones (Fields 2001; Hochochka and
76
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
Somero 2002; Jaenicke 1991; Somero 2003). Greater concentrations of paralogous isozymes or extrinsic stabilizers could expand the thermal breadth of performance. Finally, the number, size, or quality of organelles, cells, tissues, and organs should also influence performance. But any evolutionary increase in performance comes at a price! Enzymes and their stabilizers cost energy to produce or sequester. Organelles, cells, and tissues cost energy to produce and maintain. The energy expended on such adaptations to temperature must be diverted from other functions. When these kinds of thermal adaptation occur, an organism must acquire additional energy to continue performing multiple functions or reallocate energy among competing functions. For instance, an individual that maintains higher concentrations of enzymes could enhance performance at extreme temperatures without a loss of performance at moderate temperatures, but would have less energy to devote to other cellular processes (an allocation tradeoff). If we assume the same individual forages more to offset this energy demand, we should expect this behavior to impose a greater risk of predation or parasitism (an acquisition tradeoff). Therefore, every modification of a performance curve results in some type of tradeoff (Box 3.5). To appreciate the importance of these tradeoffs, consider some of the proximate mechanisms for variation in the thermal sensitivity of growth rate. In many cases, populations in colder environments have evolved faster growth at relatively low temperatures (see Table 3.6). Yet the mechanisms that underpin these adaptations can be quite diverse. Thermal adaptation of enzymes decreases the concentrations necessary for anabolic and catabolic processes, leaving more energy available for somatic growth. Growth efficiency also increases when organisms divert energy from cellular maintenance, such as protein turnover or ion transport (Bayne 2004; Hawkins 1991, 1995; Hulbert and Else 2000). Finally, intense rates of foraging and consumption fuel rapid growth. Accordingly, species have taken multiple routes to the same evolutionary endpoint. In some species, rapidly growing genotypes allocate more energy to growth and less to maintenance (Imsland et al. 2000;
Lindgren and Laurila 2005; Oufiero and Angilletta 2006; Robinson and Partridge 2001). In other species, genotypes achieve rapid growth through high rates of energy intake (Jonassen et al. 2000; Nicieza et al. 1994). The evolution of growth rate often involves simultaneous changes in food consumption and growth efficiency (Billerbeck et al. 2000; Jonsson et al. 2001; Lonsdale and Levinton 1989; Stoks et al. 2005; Van Doorslaer and Stoks 2005a). Artificial selection has underscored the interactive role of behavior and physiology in the evolution of growth rate. Aquacultural breeding programs have produced slow- and fast-growing lines of commercially important species. In two species of oysters, rapidly growing genotypes had higher rates of food consumption, lower rates of maintenance metabolism, and lower costs of somatic growth (Bayne 1999, 2000). Tradeoffs arising from an increase in feeding or a reduction in maintenance can affect the fitness of these genotypes in certain environments (Box 3.6). Because a diversity of proximate mechanisms can transform the genotype into the phenotype, we cannot assume all evolutionary changes will give rise to specialist–generalist tradeoffs. Once we begin to consider the interactions among acquisition, allocation, and specialist–generalist tradeoffs, we have entered the realm of life-history theory. This body of theory describes the way in which strategies of acquisition and allocation evolve. In Chapters 6 and 7, we shall see how life-history theory can help us to understand the evolution of performance curves.
3.7 Do all performances affect fitness? At first, asking whether performances such as survivorship and reproduction affect fitness sounds silly. Still, optimality models assume a very specific relationship between performance and fitness. To find the optimal performance curve, both Lynch and Gabriel (1987) and Gilchrist (1995) assumed fitness was directly related to performance. In other words, these models propose a form of directional selection characterized by a positive linear selection gradient (see Fig. 1.6a). Does directional selection really approximate the true nature of selection? Perhaps
THERMAL SENSITIVITY
77
Box 3.5 Tradeoffs associated with the evolution of thermal performance curves Recently, my colleagues and I summarized the kinds of tradeoffs that constrain the evolution of performance curves (Angilletta et al. 2003). These tradeoffs are best illustrated by an example: imagine performance curves for growth and reproduction. Suppose a mutation enables a genotype to grow more rapidly at low temperatures. The mutant could grow rapidly because it allocates more energy to growth than the ancestor would; however, the mutant’s increase in growth rate would decrease its reproductive rate (Fig. 3.30a). Life historians refer to such relationships as allocation tradeoffs (Zera and Harshman 2001). Alternatively, the mutant could grow more rapidly by acquiring more energy, such that no energy is diverted from reproduction (Fig. 3.30b). In this case, the mutant could enhance growth rate and reproductive rate simultaneously (Reznick et al. 2000). This mutant will likely experience an acquisition tradeoff, in which an increase in the duration or intensity of feeding increases the probability of death by predation (Gotthard 2000; McPeek 2004; Stoks et al. 2005). Finally, the mutant could grow more rapidly by
X Y X Y
Temperature
(c) Phenotype
(b) Phenotype
Phenotype
(a)
assimilating and using resources more efficiently (Wieser 1994). This form of adaptation would require changes in enzymatic structure that impose a specialist–generalist tradeoff (Fig. 3.30c). Importantly, genotypes can combine these different mechanisms to further enhance performance, but multiple tradeoffs would occur. When a performance curve evolves, both the derivative and the integral of the function can change (i.e., the shape and the height can evolve). Mechanisms associated with specialist–generalist tradeoffs influence the derivative of the curve without changing its integral (see Fig. 3.30c), whereas mechanisms associated with allocation or acquisition tradeoffs influence the integral of the curve. Because a performance curve results from many interacting mechanisms, we cannot always understand tradeoffs by comparing the shapes of curves among genotypes. Evolutionary thermal biologists must closely examine the proximate mechanisms by which genotypes express different performance curves.
X Y X Y
Temperature
Temperature
Figure 3.30 Three classes of tradeoffs associated with variation in thermal performance curves. Each plot depicts two or more performance curves; the pies depict the quantity of resources allocated to one function (X ) versus another function (Y ) at a given temperature. (a) Given a fixed quantity of resources, a difference in the allocation of resources between X and Y (e.g., growth and reproduction) can cause a difference in performance at all temperatures. An evolutionary change in performance resulting from function X (e.g., growth rate) would be negatively correlated with an evolutionary change in a performance resulting from function Y (e.g., fecundity). (b) A difference in the acquisition of resources can cause a difference in performance at all temperatures. In this case, an evolutionary change in the performance resulting from function X could be positively correlated with an evolutionary change in a performance resulting from function Y. (c) Performance at certain temperatures can be enhanced by thermal specialization, as a genotype can perform more efficiently within a narrow range of temperatures or less efficiently within a broader range of temperatures. Such specialist–generalist tradeoffs are commonly imposed by assuming the area under the performance curve remains constant (see Section 3.3). Adapted from Angilletta et al. (2003) with permission from Elsevier. © 2003 Elsevier Ltd.
under certain conditions submaximal performance would lead to a greater expectation of fitness, even if it reduces survivorship or reproduction during the short term. Consider an even more outrageous idea: variation in certain performances might not contribute to fitness at all.
To evaluate these ideas, we must quantify selection gradients. Unfortunately, few people have successfully measured selection gradients for performance (Kingsolver et al. 2001b). The reason is simple: researchers often use performance (e.g., survivorship) as a proxy for fitness. This practice
78
T H E R M A L A D A P TAT I O N
Box 3.6 Evolutionary tradeoffs: a case study of fish variation in the performance curve depend on the phylogenetic scope of analysis. Although variation among populations of M. menidia was caused by different strategies of acquisition and allocation, variation between M. menidia and its southern congener, M. peninsulae, was driven partially by thermal specialization (Yamahira and Conover 2002). Maximal burst speed (cm s–1)
The investigations of countergradient variation in the growth rate of the Atlantic silverside (Menidia menidia) constitute one of the best case studies illustrating the tradeoffs associated with the evolution of performance curves. At all temperatures, fish from Nova Scotia grow faster than fish from South Carolina because they consume more food and convert a greater fraction of their food to body mass (Billerbeck et al. 2000; Present and Conover 1992). Presumably, the costs associated with the evolution of growth rate can be reduced by combing behavioral and physiological strategies. Furthermore, these strategies enable northern fish to grow relatively quickly over a wide range of temperatures. Still, Conover and colleagues presented compelling evidence of a tradeoff between growth rate and swimming speed (Fig. 3.31). When starved, the rapidly growing fish from Nova Scotia were unable to swim as fast as the slowly growing fish from South Carolina. Feeding further increased the difference in swimming speed between the two groups. As a consequence, fish from Nova Scotia suffered a greater risk of predation in staged encounters with predators than fish from South Carolina (Fig. 3.32). In addition to the obvious tradeoff between feeding and survivorship, the intrinsically slower swimming of northern fish might have resulted from a poor quality of muscle caused by allocation tradeoffs. Interestingly, the mechanisms that underlie
200 175 150 125 100 NS SC Population and feeding status
Figure 3.31 Atlantic silversides from Nova Scotia (NS) were unable to swim as fast as fish from South Carolina (SC), regardless of whether they were fed (filled boxes) or fasted (open boxes). Reproduced from Billerbeck et al. (2001) with permission from Blackwell Publishing.
1.0
Survivorship
0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0 0
10
20
30 Time (min)
40
50
assumes the very thing we are trying to determine— namely, that fitness depends directly on performance. In reptiles, proxies for fitness only sometimes correlate with locomotor performance
60
Figure 3.32 Survivorship of Atlantic silversides from South Carolina (dashed line) exceeded that of fish from Nova Scotia (solid line) during staged encounters with predators. Reproduced from Lankford et al. (2001) with permission from Blackwell Publishing.
(reviewed by Angilletta et al. 2002a). We know virtually nothing about selection gradients for other performances, let alone selection gradients for their thermal sensitivity.
THERMAL SENSITIVITY
In fact, despite the hundreds of thermal sensitivities reported in the literature, only one group of researchers has ever estimated a selection gradient for a performance curve. Kingsolver and colleagues (2007) quantified performance curves for relative growth rate in caterpillars (Pieris rapae). Because these caterpillars grow incredibly fast during late instars, these investigators were able to record growth by the same individuals over a range of temperatures. These acute thermal sensitivities differed from chronic thermal sensitivities (Kingsolver and Woods 1998) and better reflect the temporal scale of thermal variation in nature (Kingsolver 2000). After determining the performance curve for each individual, they exposed individuals to one of two thermal regimes: a cool cycle and a warm cycle (Fig. 3.33a). Fitness was estimated as the product of developmental rate, adult survivorship, and adult mass. Thus, the authors were able to quantitatively evaluate the assumption of directional selection. To better appreciate the results of this experiment, let us briefly consider how selection should act on each region of the performance curve. Kingsolver and Gomulkiewicz (2003) proved that, under certain conditions, the strength of selection should depend directly on the frequenc