Twenty-First Century Novels
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Twenty-First Century Novels THE FIRST DECADE
VOLUME 1 A-E
Jeffrey W. Hunter EDITOR
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Twenty-First Century Novels: The First Decade
© 2011 Gale, Cengage Learning
Project Editor: Jeffrey W. Hunter Editorial: Sara Constantakis, Kathy D. Darrow, Matthew Derda, Kristen Dorsch, Reed Kalso, Jelena O. Krstovic, Camille Reynolds, Carol A. Schwartz, Lawrence J. Trudeau Rights Acquisition and Management: Margaret Chamberlain-Gaston, Sari Gordon, Sue Rudolph, and Robyn Young Composition: Evi Abou-El-Seoud Manufacturing: Cynde Lentz Imaging: John Watkins
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. No part of this work covered by the copyright herein may be reproduced, transmitted, stored, or used in any form or by any means graphic, electronic, or mechanical, including but not limited to photocopying, recording, scanning, digitizing, taping, Web distribution, information networks, or information storage and retrieval systems, except as permitted under Section 107 or 108 of the 1976 United States Copyright Act, without the prior written permission of the publisher.
For product information and technology assistance, contact us at Gale Customer Support, 1-800-877-4253. For permission to use material from this text or product, submit all requests online at www.cengage.com/permissions. Further permissions questions can be emailed to
[email protected]
Product Design: Kristine Julien While every effort has been made to ensure the reliability of the information presented in this publication, Gale, a part of Cengage Learning, does not guarantee the accuracy of the data contained herein. Gale accepts no payment for listing; and inclusion in the publication of any organization, agency, institution, publication, service, or individual does not imply endorsement of the editors or publisher. Errors brought to the attention of the publisher and verified to the satisfaction of the publisher will be corrected in future editions.
LIBRARY OF CONGRESS CATALOGING-IN-PUBLICATION DATA Twenty-first century novels. The first decade / [project editor, Jeffrey W. Hunter]. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-1-4144-8761-8 (set) – ISBN 978-1-4144-8764-9 (v. 1) – ISBN 978-1-4144-8765-6 (v. 2) – ISBN 978-1-4144-8766-3 (v. 3) – ISBN 978-1-4144-8762-5 (ebk.) 1. Fiction–21st century–History and criticism. 2. Fiction–21st century– Bio-bibliography–Dictionaries. 3. Fiction–21st century–Dictionaries. 4. Fiction–21st century–Stories, plots, etc. I. Hunter, Jeffrey W., 1966PN3504.T84 2011 809.3'051–dc22
2010045843
Gale 27500 Drake Rd. Farmington Hills, MI, 48331-3535
ISBN13: ISBN13: ISBN13: ISBN13:
978-1-4144-8761-8 978-1-4144-8764-9 978-1-4144-8765-6 978-1-4144-8766-3
(set) (vol. 1) (vol. 2) (vol. 3)
ISBN10: ISBN10: ISBN10: ISBN10:
1-4144-8761-4 1-4144-8764-9 1-4144-8765-7 1-4144-8766-5
(set) (vol. 1) (vol. 2) (vol. 3)
This title is also available as an e-book. ISBN-13: 978-1-4144-8762-5 ISBN-10: 1-4144-8762-2 Contact your Gale, a part of Cengage Learning sales representative for ordering information.
Printed in Mexico 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 15 14 13 12 11
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Contents VOLUME 1 Volume 1 Contents by Title ....................................................................................................
vii
Advisors .....................................................................................................................................................
xi
List of Contributors .......................................................................................................................
xiii
Preface .......................................................................................................................................................
xv
Entries A-E ............................................................................................................................................
1
Title Index
.........................................................................................................................................
xvii
Author Index ....................................................................................................................................
xxiii
Major Prizewinners ......................................................................................................................
xxix
Nationality Index ..........................................................................................................................
xxxi
v (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Volume 1 Contents by Title The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian Sherman Alexie .................................................................... 1 The Accidental Ali Smith ................................................................................... Across a Hundred Mountains Reyna Grande ................................................................... The Adventures of Vela Albert Wendt ..................................................................... The Age of Orphans Laleh Khadivi .................................................................... Air, or, Have Not Have Geoff Ryman...................................................................... An Altered Light Jens Christian Grøndahl............................................
6 11 15 20 24 29
The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay Michael Chabon .............................................................. 33
Arthur & George Julian Barnes ....................................................................
56
The Astonishing Life of Octavian Nothing M. T. Anderson ............................................................... 60 The Athenian Murders José Carlos Somoza ......................................................
64
Atonement Ian McEwan .......................................................................
67
Austerlitz W. G. Sebald......................................................................
72
Await Your Reply Dan Chaon..........................................................................
77
The Ballad of Desmond Kale Roger McDonald ...........................................................
81
Baudolino Umberto Eco
..................................................................
85
Beasts of No Nation Uzodinma Iweala ...........................................................
90
American Gods Neil Gaiman .......................................................................
38
Beijing Coma Ma Jian...................................................................................
95
Anil’s Ghost Michael Ondaatje
.........................................................
42
Bel Canto Ann Patchett ...................................................................
100
Animal’s People Indra Sinha ..........................................................................
47
Bitter Fruit Achmat Dangor ............................................................
105
51
Blacklist Sara Paretsky ...................................................................
109
The Armies Evelio Rosero ....................................................................
vii (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Volume 1 Contents by Title
A Blessed Child Linn Ullmann ................................................................ The Blind Assassin Margaret Atwood ........................................................
113
The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao Junot Díaz ........................................................................
197
118
The Broken Shore Peter Temple ..................................................................
202
Blindsight Maurice Gee ....................................................................
122
Brooklyn Colm Tóibín ...................................................................
206
Blood from Stone Frances Fyfield ...............................................................
126
Bruised Hibiscus Elizabeth Nunez ..........................................................
211
Blooms of Darkness Aharon Appelfeld ........................................................
131
The Bullet Collection Patricia Sarrafian Ward ............................................
215
Blue Heaven C. J. Box ............................................................................
136
Camouflage Joe Haldeman ................................................................
219
The Boat to Redemption Su Tong ..............................................................................
140
Captain of the Sleepers Mayra Montero.............................................................
223
Bold as Love Gwyneth Jones ..............................................................
145
Carpentaria Alexis Wright ..................................................................
228
The Bonesetter’s Daughter Amy Tan ............................................................................
149
Carry Me Down M. J. Hyland ..................................................................
233
The Book of Chameleons José Eduardo Agualusa ...........................................
153
Celestial Harmonies Péter Esterházy .............................................................
238
The Book of Dead Birds Gayle Brandeis ...............................................................
158
The Changeling Kenzaburo ................................................................ Oe
242
The Book of Negroes Lawrence Hill.................................................................
162
Child 44 Tom Rob Smith ...........................................................
246
The Book of Night Women Marlon James .................................................................
166
The Children’s Book A. S. Byatt ........................................................................
250
The Book of Not Tsitsi Dangarembga...................................................
171
Citizen Vince Jess Walter ........................................................................
254
The Book Thief Markus Zusak ................................................................
175
The City & the City China Miéville ...............................................................
258
The Bottoms Joe R. Lansdale.............................................................
180
City of Thieves David Benioff .................................................................
262
The Boy Next Door Irene Sabatini .................................................................
184
Clara Callan Richard B. Wright ......................................................
266
Brandenburg Gate Henry Porter ..................................................................
188
The Clothes on Their Backs Linda Grant .....................................................................
271
193
Cloud Atlas David Mitchell ...............................................................
275
Breath Tim Winton .....................................................................
viii
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Volume 1 Contents by Title
The Corrections Jonathan Franzen ........................................................
279
Dirt Music Tim Winton .....................................................................
350
Crabwalk Günter Grass ...................................................................
283
A Distant Shore Caryl Phillips ...................................................................
354
Crescent Diana Abu-Jaber ..........................................................
287
The Dive From Clausen’s Pier Ann Packer .......................................................................
359
Douglass’ Women Jewell Parker Rhodes
..............................................
364
Down River John Hart ..........................................................................
368
Duma Key Stephen King ..................................................................
372
El Dorado Dorothy Porter .............................................................
377
The Electric Michelangelo Sarah Hall .........................................................................
382
The Elegance of the Hedgehog Muriel Barbery ..............................................................
387
318
The Emperor of Ocean Park Stephen L. Carter ......................................................
392
323
The Emperor’s Children Claire Messud ................................................................
398
328
Empire Falls Richard Russo ................................................................
403
Declare Tim Powers......................................................................
332
English Passengers Matthew Kneale ...........................................................
407
The Deposition of Father McGreevy Brian O’Doherty ..........................................................
336
Everyman Philip Roth
.....................................................................
412
......................................................
340
Everything Is Illuminated Jonathan Safran Foer ................................................
416
Diary of a Bad Year J. M. Coetzee ................................................................
344
The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time Mark Haddon ................................................................
291
The Curse of Chalion Lois McMaster Bujold.............................................
295
Dancing to “Almendra” Mayra Montero............................................................. Dark Palace Frank Moorhouse ....................................................... The Day We Had Hitler Home Rodney Hall .................................................................... The Days of Abandonment Elena Ferrante ............................................................... De Niro’s Game Rawi Hage ........................................................................ Dead Europe Christos Tsiolkas .......................................................... Death with Interruptions José Saramago................................................................
The Dew Breaker Edwidge Danticat
299 303 308 313
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
ix
Advisors Betty Carter Carter is a former school librarian and Professor of Children’s and Young Adult Literature at Texas Woman’s University. She currently reviews books for Horn Book and has served on selection committees for several children’s literature awards, including the Newbery, Sibert, and Boston Globe-Horn Book awards.
Don D’Ammassa D’Ammassa has published several science fiction novels and short stories. A former editor of the Hugo-nominated fan magazine Mythologies, he is a noted critic in the genres of fantasy, horror, adventure, and science fiction. He is also the author of The Encyclopedia of Science Fiction, The Encyclopedia of Fantasy and Horror, and The Encyclopedia of Adventure Fiction.
Natalie Danford Danford is a novelist and book critic whose articles and reviews have been published in The Los Angeles Times, Salon, and many other publications. She is also co-editor of the annual Best New American Voices anthology series, which introduces emerging writers.
Harvey Freedenberg Freedenberg is a regular reviewer for BookPage, Bookreporter.com and Shelf-Awareness.com and is a member of the National Book Critics Circle. He also writes a monthly column on books for Harrisburg Magazine. The author of several prize-winning short stories, he is a longtime board member of the Dauphin County Library System and served on the One Book, One Community Selection Committee.
Dwayne D. Hayes Hayes is a Managing Editor at Cengage Gale and has edited several literature titles, including Contemporary Authors and the Gale Contextual Encyclopedia of World Literature. In 2002 he founded the literary journal Absinthe: New European Writing, a biannual magazine of contemporary European literature and art. Absinthe has published the work of over 150 European poets and fiction writers in English translation and has also sponsored readings and film screenings by international writers and filmmakers.
xi (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Advisors
Pam Spencer Holley Holley is a retired coordinator of library services for Fairfax County, Virginia, Public schools. She has served on selection committees of many prestigious young adult literature awards, including the Margaret A. Edwards Award, the Alex Award, and the Michael L. Printz Award. She is an active member and former President of the Young Adult Library Services Association, a division of the American Library Association, and her reviews of young adult literature appear in numerous publications.
Dr. Elizabeth McMahon McMahon is a Senior Lecturer at the University of New South Wales, where she is coconvener of the Women’s and Gender Studies program and the Australian Studies program. A former President of the Association for the Study of Australian Literature (ASAL), she is co-editor of the journal Southerly and a consulting editor for the Australian Humanities Review. She has published extensively on Australian literature and culture.
Dr. Víctor Federico Torres Torres is the author of Diccionario de autores puertorriqueños contemporáneos (2009) as well as a bio-bibliography of Puerto Rican writers and numerous articles in scholarly journals. He has taught in the Departments of Hispanic Studies and Interdisciplinary Studies and at the Graduate School of Science and Information Technology at the University of Puerto Rico’s Rio Piedras Campus.
Professor Lydia Wevers Wevers teaches at Victoria University of Wellington in New Zealand, where she is Director of the Stout Research Centre for New Zealand Studies. A recent Fulbright Visiting Scholar in New Zealand Studies at the Center for Australian and New Zealand Studies (CANZ) at Georgetown University in Washington, D.C., she is an editor and book reviewer as well as a literature critic and scholar.
xii
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
List of Contributors Alana Abbott
Cynthia Giles
Jenny Ludwig
Abbott is an editor, a published novelist, and a comic book writer.
Giles holds an M.A. in English literature and a Ph.D. in interdisciplinary humanities. She has been a university instructor and freelance writer.
Ludwig holds an M.A. in English literature and has been a university instructor and freelance writer.
Susan Anderson Andersen holds a Ph.D. in English and is a freelance writer.
Robert Berg Berg is a professional freelance writer and critic, with an advanced degree in History and Criticism. He also has an extensive academic background in literary analysis.
Margaret Haerens Haerens is a freelance writer and editor living in New York City.
Masoud is a playwright and screenwriter living in New York City.
Harrabeth Haidusek
Sean McCready
Haidusek holds an M.A. in English literature and is a university instructor.
McCready is a freelance writer and editor specializing in literary criticism.
Todd Breijak
Michele Hardy
Breijak is a freelance writer with a background in literary and film criticism and theory.
Hardy holds an M.A. in creative writing and is an instructor in English and humanities.
Joseph Campana
Kevin Hile
Campana holds an M.A. in English literature and is a university professor.
Hile is a published author, editor, and radio show host on the MIentertainment Radio Network.
Harriet Devine
Lois Kerschen
Devine has a Ph.D. in English literature and is a freelance writer.
Kerschen has a Ph.D. in English and is a freelance writer and college instructor.
Catherine Dominic Dominic is a novelist and a freelance writer and editor.
Bisanne Masoud
Sheri Karmiol Karmiol holds a Ph.D. in English literature and is a university professor.
Stephen Meyer Meyer has an M.F.A. in creative writing and has been a university instructor and freelance writer.
Melodie Monahan
Judson Knight
Monahan holds a Ph.D. in English and operates an editing service.
Knight is the owner of a literary agency.
Janet Moredock
Nancy Dziedzic
Marta Lauritsen
Dziedzic is a freelance editor and writer living in Michigan.
Lauritsen is a high school AP English teacher.
Greta Gard
Adam Lawrence
Gard has an M.A. in English literature and has been a university instructor and freelance writer.
Lawrence has a Ph.D. in English literature and is a university professor.
Moredock is a freelance writer and former university instructor.
Janet Mullane Mullane is a writer, editor, and English teacher with a background in the social sciences and the humanities,
xiii (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
List of Contributors especially nineteenth-century literature and contemporary literary theory.
Anna Nesbitt Nesbitt is a former senior editor for Charles Scribner’s Sons with extensive background in literature criticism.
Wendy Perkins
Laura Pryor
Carol Ullmann
Pryor is a freelance writer who specializes in literature.
Ullmann is a freelance writer and editor who specializes in literature.
Rachel V. Smydra Smydra has an M.A. in English and is a university instructor.
Powder Thompson
Judith West
West holds an M.A. in English literature and has been an editor, writer, audiobook producer, and university instructor.
Thompson is a freelance writer and ivy-league graduate. He has advanced degrees in Shakespeare and Theatre.
Pamela Willwerth Aue
Perkins hold a Ph.D. in English and is a professor of American literature and film studies.
Doris Plantus-Runey
Pamela Toler
Kathy Wilson Peacock
Plantus-Runey holds a Ph.D. in English and is a university instructor and a translator and bilingual writer.
Toler has a Ph.D. in history and is a writer and university instructor.
xiv
Willwerth Aue is an educator, copyeditor, and writer in fields including business, science, and literature. Wilson Peacock is a published author and editor with an extensive background in literature criticism.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Preface Century Novels: The First Decade examines some of the most T wenty-First important fictional works published from 2000 to 2009. In order to help both students and casual readers develop a deeper understanding of these works, each title is covered in an entry that discusses style, characters, critical reception, and cultural and historical contexts, and provides recommendations of related materials and resources. With the participation of U.S. and international advisors, the list of titles has been developed to ensure broad coverage of world literatures, making Twenty-First Century Novels an excellent resource for multiethnic and multicultural curricula and communities. In selecting titles for inclusion, we’ve worked to provide a snapshot of the novel in the first decade of this century, with an eye to identifying works that are suitable for inclusion in a high school or college reading list in addition to being of interest to the general reader of literary fiction. We have kept in mind the criteria set forth by the College Board for works studied in an Advanced Placement English Literature and Composition class, seeking out works that “invite and reward rereading and do not, like ephemeral works in such popular genres as detective or romance fiction, yield all (or nearly all) of their pleasures of thought and feeling the first time through” (English Course Description, Effective Fall 2010, p. 49). We hope and believe that many of the titles included here will still be read twenty or thirty years from now, and that each of them offers insights into the general human condition as well as the condition of the novel at the start of the 21st century. In order to provide a broad view of the entire genre, we applied a number of additional criteria in making the final selections. Awards: Winners of a small number of highly prestigious awards have been included by default. While there are many valid arguments both for and against the value of awards, we would be hard pressed to find individuals better qualified to judge fiction that the juries who make these selections. We also believe that much can be learned about the literary culture of a time by examining the creative works it chooses to honor. In assessing additional titles for inclusion, the short lists for these
xv (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Preface
awards as well as other awards bestowed have also been taken into consideration. Lists of major award winners are provided in all three volumes. Genres: Despite the injunction of the College Board cited above, we acknowledge that many works in the “popular genres” do offer much more than simple entertainment. For that reason, no novel has been excluded simply because it belongs to a popular genre. Similarly, young adult fiction has been considered so long as it has significant adult readership and meets the other selection criteria. Outstanding series that began before 2000 but concluded during the decade have been treated in single entries; for ongoing series, individual books have been considered if they stand as serious contenders on their own. Graphic novels that are works of fiction have also been included. Finally, given that our primary audience will be English-speaking, we made the hard decision to include only works available in English at the time of compilation. Given that many very worthy works in other languages do not receive an English translation until years after they first appear, we reached that decision reluctantly. But we felt we would be doing the majority of our readers a disservice by pointing them at titles they could not in fact read. We hope the sampling of world literature provided here will whet English-speakers’ interest in international fiction and play some small role in stimulating the publication and teaching of novels in translation. Identifying the “best” or “most important” items in any large group of works is always a challenging and somewhat subjective task. It is particularly daunting to select a relatively small number of works from a genre as rich, varied, and global as the novel. We have no illusions that we have arrived at a definitive list; indeed, we are sure we have left out innumerable excellent works. Nonetheless we feel confident that we’ve provided a valid and vibrant picture of the novel in the first decade of the century. The Editors TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
xvi
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian By Sherman Alexie
W Introduction Sherman Alexie’s young adult novel The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian is a semi-autobiographical memoir of Alexie’s own efforts to escape the downward spiral of reservation life. The narrator is Arnold, or Junior as he is called. The novel begins with Junior’s description of his physical defects and progresses to an introduction to his family and to the absolute poverty of reservation life. After he finds his mother’s name inside his geometry book, Junior throws the book at Mr. P., his geometry teacher. Mr. P. tells Junior that he must leave the reservation and or he will be destined to the same lost dreams and poverty that he sees around him. Junior enrolls at Reardan High School, a school for rich white students, located twenty-two miles from the reservation. His best friend on the reservation, Rowdy, gives Junior a black eye for leaving the reservation and refuses to speak to Junior. At first Junior suffers in his new school. The only Indian at Reardan High, Junior is an outcast; he does find some friends, though, but is bullied until he begins to fight back. Eventually the other students begin to respect Junior, especially after he is invited to play on the varsity basketball team. There are times when Junior’s dad does not pick him up at school, and he is forced to walk home, but Junior never complains and is happy at his new school. Junior’s freshman year at Reardan High is marked by his exclusion from the reservation. Besides the loss of his friendship with Rowdy, other people on the reservation are angry that Junior has left the reservation school for a white school. People on the reservation see Junior’s actions as a rejection of Indian life. In contrast, Junior finds acceptance at his new high school and begins dating Penelope, one of the most popular girls in his class. A drunk driver kills Junior’s grandmother, but before she dies, she says that she forgives the Indian driver. When Reardan plays a basketball game
against Junior’s former school, Junior emerges as a heroic figure, even though he does not score many points. He realizes that beating the ill-equipped reservation school is an empty victory against kids who probably have not even eaten breakfast. Junior’s sister Mary dies in a fire she is too drunk to escape. At her funeral, Junior and Rowdy finally reconcile. Junior completes his first year of high school and realizes that he is part of many tribes, not just the Indian tribe on his reservation.
W Literary and Historical Context
Often times, diaries are not published; typically, they are written as an expression of personal experiences and private feelings. Because Alexie wrote The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian with the intention of having it published, he created a persona—Junior—as a means of transforming his autobiography into fiction. Some elements of Junior’s life are based on Alexie’s life. For instance, Alexie was born with hydrocephalus, and he grew up on the Spokane Indian Reservation, near Wellpinit, Washington. Alexie also left the reservation to attend high school in Reardan, Washington, after discovering his mother’s name written inside a school textbook. Like Junior, Alexie was also a star basketball player, and his sister died in a trailer fire. As part of his acceptance speech at the Horn Book Awards, Alexie said that The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian is about three-fourths autobiography and one-fourth fiction. Indians living on reservations experience the most extreme poverty of any minority in the United States. Reservation life is often compared to life in Third World countries, with limited access to electricity and indoor plumbing (Carlson, Rogers). Indian reservations are typically located in remote rural areas, which limits job and educational opportunities. Only a few businesses
1 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian
MAJOR CHARACTERS MR. P., Junior’s geometry teacher, tells Junior that he must leave the reservation if he is to have a future. PENELOPE is Junior’s love interest at Reardan High. She is bulimic, which teaches Junior that even rich white girls have problems. ROWDY, Junior’s friend on the reservation, resents Junior for leaving the reservation school but eventually reconciles with him. ARNOLD SPIRIT, called Junior, is the fourteen-year-old narrator. DAD SPIRIT, Junior’s father, is an alcoholic but also a talented singer and musician. GRANDMA SPIRIT is Junior’s mentor and the source of much good advice. She teaches Junior tolerance. MARY SPIRIT, also known as Mary Runs Away, is Junior’s sister. After she leaves the reservation and moves to Montana, she dies in a house fire, too drunk to wake up and escape.
provide jobs and incomes or even the necessary supplies for living. Poverty leads to higher rates of disease, such as diabetes, which is tied to a poor diet. Alcoholism and tuberculosis are also common on reservations. There is limited health care, and the Indian Health Service is often relegated to antiquated buildings and equipment. Many Indians receive food stamps and government-issued commodities, but these are inadequate to support a healthy life. Contrary to expectations, gaming and casinos have not eliminated poverty, since most casinos are only marginally profitable. Indian reservations are on land set aside by the federal government for Indian use. They are selfgoverning but fall under the regulation of the Department of the Interior and the Bureau of Indian Affairs. In some cases, individual Indians own the land on which they live, but in most cases, the land is held in trust by the Bureau of Indian Affairs, which prevents Indians from securing loans by using their homes as collateral. To improve their property, most homeowners use home equity loans to borrow money. Indians are unable to do this, and as a result, many homes are little more than shacks in a terrible state of disrepair.
W Themes The poverty that permeates the Indian reservation is an important focus of The Absolutely True Diary of a PartTime Indian. In the first few pages of the book, Junior witnesses his father shooting the family dog because they are too poor to pay for veterinary care. The reservation
2
Portrait of Sherman Alexie, author of The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian. Ulf Andersen/Getty Images
schools use the same textbooks generation after generation because they cannot afford to buy new books. Often, children attend school without eating breakfast, sometimes without having eaten dinner the night before. Junior writes that poverty feels deserved, that people are poor because they are stupid or ugly and that poverty saps the strength needed to fight poverty (13). Loss of hope is common on the reservation. In one of his cartoons, Junior draws his parents as they might have been had they not lost hope in the possibility of a successful future. At one of the many funerals that Junior attends, he notes that Indians have “LOST EVERYTHING” (173). They have lost their land, their languages, and their culture. To combat the grief that threatens to overtake his life, Junior makes a list of all the things that give him joy and hope. He lists his family and friends, but the list also includes favorite foods and books. The list contains small things, but Junior knows that hope is based on small things and not on wishes for success. Junior must try to balance his Indian identity on the reservation with his life at a school off the reservation. At the reservation school, the students take time to joke, but TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian
at Reardan High, the emphasis is on grades and sports and doing well. Off the reservation, Junior is more focused and serious, and he instinctively understands that he must leave his Indian identity behind if he is to succeed. On the reservation, he is called an apple—red on the outside but white inside. Junior explains to one of his new friends at Reardan that his reservation friends think “you become white if you try to make your life better” (131). For Junior, the struggle is to find a way remain connected to the Indian community and at the same time become a successful individual.
W Style Alexie uses cartoons as a device to express Junior’s sense of humor and the deep ironies of his situation. Junior escapes into his cartoons, which he calls his “lifeboats” (6). While not everyone understands a different language, many people understand graphic art. Junior’s cartoons reflect on the cultural duality he experiences. He draws his parents as they might have been had the weight of reservation life not destroyed their hope for the future. He draws himself, exaggerating his physical flaws as a way to make fun of himself. Junior also draws himself as split down the middle, with one side as he really is—a poor kid from the reservation—and the other side, as he hopes to become—a preppy adolescent in expensive clothing. Alexie uses first-person point of view, as is suitable to a diary format. This perspective puts readers on the inside of Junior, seeing through his eyes. Junior’s self-depreciating humor and his grief are expressed in an intimate, straightforward manner. His diary provides the evidence of the family’s loss and poverty, but it also reveals the laughter and joy that come from small triumphs. In the diary, Junior explores his identity and the grief that envelops him. First-person point of view draws readers as confidants in that exploration. Crude humor and irony are survival strategies. Junior uses humor both as a way to survive loss—his dog, his grandmother killed by a drunk driver, and his sister, killed in a house fire. By the time he is fourteen, Junior has already attended forty-two funerals. Alcohol, poverty, and lack of hope destroy people on the reservation, but Junior has learned that humor is one way to cope.
W Critical Reception Reviews of The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian were exceptionally positive. Typical is the review by Paula Rohrlick for Kliatt, who wrote that Alexie’s novel is “breathtakingly honest.” Rohrlick focused on the novel’s emotional content, calling it “raw emotion leavened with humor,” and noting that the novel is “funny, profane and sad” in its honesty. Rohrlick also pointed out that Junior’s voice “will stay with readers” and enlighten them
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Sherman Alexie was born October 7, 1966, at the Coeur d’Alene Indian Reservation, near Wellpinit, Washington. He was born with hydrocephalus (water on the brain) and was not expected to live. Alexie chose to be educated off the reservation and attended school in nearby Reardan. He then attended Gonzaga University and later the University of Washington. Alexie’s first two books of poetry were published shortly after he graduated from college. These works encouraged him to continue writing. Alexie’s first novel, Reservation Blues (1995), won the Before Columbus Foundation’s American Book Award and the Murray Morgan Prize. The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian, Alexie’s third novel, received several awards, including the National Book Award for Young People’s Literature and the Peter Pan Award, as well as the New York Time’s Notable Children’s Books of 2007 award. Alexie is also the author of multiple collections of short stories and several television and film scripts.
about the reservation experience. In her review for the Toronto Globe & Mail, Susan Perren focused on The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian as a “voyage of self-discovery.” According to Perren, Alexie’s novel is “brave, brash, bracing, iconoclastic and heart-breakingly tender.” Other reviewers, including Bruce Barcott in his review for the New York Times, expressed similar views. Barcott claimed that The Absolutely True Diary of a PartTime Indian might well be Alexie’s “best work yet.” Because this novel is so closely focused on action and emotion, reading this novel, Barcott suggested, “becomes more like listening to your smart, funny best friend recount his day.” The novel’s intimacy was also noted by Kate Agnew, who wrote in her review for the London Guardian that Alexie created a protagonist who is “funny, articulate and quick-thinking.” In other words, Junior is the ideal best friend whose stories engage readers and pull them into a narrative that is “bittersweet . . . funny, heartwrenching and utterly gripping.” Many reviewers of The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian focused on the cartoons and their role in captivating readers. Kathleen Odean’s review for Teacher Librarian was typical in that the cartoons “draw a wide range of readers into this outstanding novel.” In a review for USA Today, Whitney Matheson called the cartoons in The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian “flawless artwork” that is “invaluable to Alexie’s story.” Of course, it is not just the cartoons that make this novel so remarkable. Matheson claimed that the book will also “resonate” with readers and “lift spirits of all ages for years to come.”
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
3
The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian
Alexie’s early life and the beginning of his writing career.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Agnew, Kate. “Education: The Lesson: The Book: The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian.” Rev. of The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian, by Sherman Alexie. guardian.co.uk. Guardian 3 June 2008. Web. 8 Sept. 2010.
Grassian, Daniel. Understanding Sherman Alexie. Columbia: U. South Carolina P, 2005. Print. A literary biography that traces Alexie’s life and works and compares Alexie’s work and that of other Native American writers.
Alexie, Sherman. The Absolutely True Diary of a PartTime Indian. Illus. Ellen Forney. New York: Little, Brown, 2007. Print.
Margolis, Rick. “Song of Myself: Sherman Alexie’s First YA Novel.” School Library Journal 53.8 (2007): 29. Print. Interview focuses on influence of reading and books in shaping his life.
———. “Boston Globe—Horn Book Award Acceptance.” www.hbook.com/magazine/articles/ 2009/jan09_alexie.asp. Horn Book Magazine Jan.-Feb. 2009. Web. 8 Sept. 2010. Barcott, Bruce. “Off the Rez.” Rev. of The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian, by Sherman Alexie. nyt.com. New York Times 11 Nov. 2007. Web. 8 Sept. 2010. Carlson, Peter. “In the Year of ‘Dances with Wolves,’ Everybody Wanted to Be on the Senate Indian Affairs Committee. Nearly a Decade Later, It Can Hardly Get a Quorum.” washingtonpost.com. Washington Post 23 Feb. 1997. Web. 23 Sept. 2010. Matheson, Whitney. “USA Today’s Whitney Matheson Checks Out Some Other New Young-Adult Novels.” Rev. of The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian, by Sherman Alexie. usatoday.com. USA Today 18 Oct. 2007. Web. 8 Sept. 2010. Odean, Kathleen. “Boys Past and Present.” Rev. of The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian, by Sherman Alexie. Teacher Librarian 35.5 (2008): 10. Print. Perren, Susan. “No Reservations.” Rev. of The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian, by Sherman Alexie. theglobeandmail.com. Globe & Mail 24 Nov. 2007. Web. 8 Sept. 2010. Rogers, Tom. “Native American Poverty.” www .spotlightonpoverty.org. Spotlight on Poverty and Opportunity, n.d. Web. 23 Sept. 2010. Rohrlick, Paula. Rev. of The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian, by Sherman Alexie. Kliatt 41.5 (2007): 6. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Berglund, Jeff, and Jan Roush, eds. Sherman Alexie: A Collection of Critical Essays. Salt Lake City: U. Utah P, 2010. Print. A dozen interdisciplinary essays that explore Alexie’s work and will appeal to both scholars and fans alike. Cline, Lynn. “About Sherman Alexie.” Ploughshares 26:4 (2000-2001): 197-202. Print. Provides a profile of
4
Nelson, Joshua B. “‘Humor Is My Green Card’: A Conversation with Sherman Alexie.” World Literature Today 84.4 (2010): 39-44. Print. Interview in which Alexie speaks about loss of native cultures and language, the importance of education, and the antiintellectualism prevalent on reservations. Newton, John. “Sherman Alexie’s Autoethnography.” Contemporary Literature 42.2 (2001): 413-28. Print. Explores Alexie’s effort to distance himself from the previous generations of Native American writers and his efforts to focus on personal relationships and interrelationships between Indian and white. “Teens on the ‘Rez’ Underground and in the Office.” Rev. of The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian, by Sherman Alexie. canberratimes.com.au. Canberra Times 25 Oct. 2008. Web. 8 Sept. 2010. Notes that the heartbreak and poverty in The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian reveal the universality of Junior’s experiences. Gale Resources
Brill, Susan B. “Sherman (Joseph), (Jr.) Alexie.” Native American Writers of the United States. Ed. Kenneth M. Roemer. Detroit: Gale Research, 1997. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 175. Literature Resource Center. Web. 10 Sept. 2010. http:// go.galegroup.com/ps/i.do?&id=GALE% 7CH1200007252&v=2.1&u=itsbtrial&it=r&p= LitRC&sw=w McFarland, Ron. “Sherman (Joseph), (Jr.) Alexie.” Twentieth-Century American Western Writers: First Series. Ed. Richard H. Cracroft. Detroit: Gale Group, 1999. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 206. Literature Resource Center. Web. 10 Sept. 2010. http://go.galegroup.com/ps/i.do?&id=GALE% 7CH1200008364&v=2.1&u=itsbtrial&it=r&p= LitRC&sw=w Quirk, Sarah A. “Sherman (Joseph), (Jr.) Alexie.” American Novelists since World War II: Seventh Series. Ed. James R. Giles and Wanda H. Giles. Detroit: Gale, 2003. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 278. Literature Resource Center. Web. 10 Sept. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian
2010. http://go.galegroup.com/ps/i.do?&id= GALE%7CH1200011218&v=2.1&u=itsbtrial&it= r&p=LitRC&sw=w “Sherman Alexie.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2010. Literature Resource Center. Web. 10 Sept. 2010. http://go.galegroup.com/ ps/i.do?&id=GALE%7CH1000110878&v=2.1& u=itsbtrial&it=r&p=LitRC&sw=w Open Web Sources
Alexie’s Web site, at http://www.fallsapart.com contains information and links on the author, his works, awards, and other relevant topics. Alexie appeared on the Colbert Report on Comedy Central, October 28, 2008, to discuss politics and The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian. The video of this appearance is available at http://www.colbertnation.com/the-colbertreport-videos/189691/october-28-2008/shermanalexie Alexie was interviewed by Ross Frank for UCSD Guestbook (University of CA San Diego television station programming) on January 31, 2008. The video, in which Alexie speaks about his childhood and The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian, can be found at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZWol PAoDk3g National Public Radio interviewed Alexie on September 21, 2007. The audio file can be found at http:// www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php? storyId=14586575
For Further Reading
Alexie, Sherman. The Toughest Indian in the World. New York: Grove, 2001. Print. Collection of short stories about the difficulties in balancing Indian heritage and life on and off the reservation. Bruchac, Joseph. The Way. Plain City: Darby Creek, 2007. Print. Story of a young Native American boy who is bullied in his new school. Carvell, Marlene. Who Will Tell My Brother? New York: Hyperion, 2002. Print. The effort to remove offensive Indian mascots from a high school helps a teenage boy learn about his own Indian heritage. Castile, George, and Robert L. Bee, eds. State and Reservation: New Perspectives on Federal Indian Policy. Tucson: U. Arizona P, 1992. Print. Ten essays that explore the reservation system, including historical, political, and economic topics. Esckilsen, Erik. Offsides: A Novel. New York: Houghton Mifflin, 2004. Print. About Native American soccer player who refuses to play for his new high school unless they get rid of their Indian school mascot. Lomawaima, K. Tsianina, and Teresa L. McCarty. To Remain an Indian: Lessons in Democracy from a Century of Native American Education. New York: Columbia UP, 2006. Print. Critical evaluation of U.S. educational policies as experienced by Native Americans during the twentieth century. Peterson, Nancy J. Conversations with Sherman Alexie. Jackson: UP Mississippi, 2009. Print. Interviews from 1993-2007, in which Alexie speaks about his childhood, family, and reservation life. Sheri Karmiol
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
5
The Accidental By Ali Smith
W Introduction The Accidental has been hailed as a technical tour-de-force for Ali Smith’s verbal facility, merging of multiple perspectives, and creation of an atmosphere of both mischief and menace. Smith’s accomplishment is considered all the more remarkable for its innovative transformation of a familiar plot device, succinctly described in an Atlantic Monthly review of the novel: “family succumbs to magical charms of irresistible stranger and is forever changed” (Judd and O’Neill). The stranger in question is Amber MacDonald, a bewitching thirty-something vagabond who insinuates herself into the dysfunctional workings of a middle-class British family vacationing for the summer in a less-than-ideal Norfolk country cottage. The alluring but devious Amber draws each member of the Smart family into her web of intrigue: the mother Eve, a best-selling author suffering from writer’s block; the father Michael, Eve’s philandering college-professor husband; and Eve’s two children from a previous marriage, the suicidal seventeen-year-old Magnus and the irritatingly precocious twelve-year-old Astrid. The Accidental is layered in structure, consisting of a series of overlapping descriptions of Amber’s mysterious visit from the differing viewpoints of Eve, Michael, Magnus, and Astrid. Amber permanently alters the family dynamic and, “with eerie cunning, locates the secret latch in each member’s psyche and flips it” (Miller). The novel is thus an exploration of the metamorphosis of identity using the deus ex machina device of the unexpected visitor. But it is also and, according to critics, more importantly, an exploration of the art of storytelling and its capacity to represent meaning. Laura Miller’s review continues: “But as any farmer’s daughter or man who walks into a bar can tell you, the premise isn’t what counts most. Success is a matter of delivery; at least, Ali Smith’s novel The Accidental—winner
of the Whitbread Award and finalist for the Man Booker Prize—places all its chips on that bet.”
W Literary and Historical Context
The Accidental recalls the Italian film Teorema, directed by Pier Paolo Pasolini and starring Terence Stamp (mentioned on the book’s first page) as a mysterious vagrant who descends upon an Italian family and, in his just as sudden departure, induces them to confront the emptiness of their bourgeois existence. The Accidental is typical of Smith’s stories in its unconventionality. It is considered postmodernist in its use of metafictional devices that self-consciously fragment the classic structure of the novel in the realist vein. The Accidental is divided into three sections that correspond to the formal elements of the traditional novel: Beginning, Middle, End. But within each of these three sections are four third-person narratives devoted to each of the Smarts, distinctive in voice and perception of Amber. Complicating these disparate viewpoints is Amber’s first-person commentary, also contained in four sections, starting and finishing the novel and forming a bridge between the parts. The effect of these contrasting narratives of similar events is to disrupt traditional notions of objective reality, aligning The Accidental with postmodernist inquiries into the nature of truth and its modes of representation. Smith explained her approach to fiction in an online discussion forum, responding to questions about the competing narrative perspectives in her earlier novel Hotel World (2001), a work similar in structure to The Accidental: “For me there’s no story without voice, no voice without story, and no single story that doesn’t imply another one right next to it, or behind it, or in front of it—there’s always another story. . . . It’s a take on novel-writing that some readers, who like their worlds to be more complete and hermetic and their stories to be more comforting, to
6 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Accidental
take a less fragmented or multilogued direction, might find exasperating. It asks a reader to do quite a lot of work, and to participate. For me it’s the thing that drives the novel form” (“Ali Smith”). The classic elements of novelistic structure are turned on end in The Accidental. Writing for the London Sunday Times, Lucy Hughes-Hallett remarked, “Smith has written a proper novel with a beginning, a middle and an end, but turned it into an exuberantly inventive series of variations. At her beginning, each character is facing some kind of dead end. By the end, everything, including the story of the stranger on the doorstep, is ready to begin again.” The conclusion of The Accidental is anything but. The Smarts return from their holiday to find that Amber has emptied their house of its entire contents except an answering machine on which she has left a message directing them to reconcile with their pasts. The empty house—now devoid of any remnants of the Smarts’ past lives—suggests a new beginning rather than an ending.
W Themes None of the Smarts openly questions Amber’s sudden appearance, each one thinking she is somehow connected with another member of the family. In the end, Amber produces a profound change in all of them, breaking them of their complacent acceptance of their “unsettled settled lives” (Clark). Eve, thinking that Amber is just another one of the coeds Michael has seduced, eventually throws her out of the house, but not before Amber has convinced her that she is wasting her talents as a hack writer of imaginary afterlives of ordinary people who died young. Amber flirts outrageously with Michael but ultimately deflates his male ego and makes him conscious of his middle age and waning charms. Amber instead turns her libido on Magnus, whose suicide attempt she narrowly interrupts, persuading Magnus not to punish himself for a school prank that led to the death of a classmate. And Amber befriends the impressionable but jaded Astrid, opening her eyes to the possibility of uncensored interaction with her surroundings. Critics agree that it is the experimental narrative strategies, thematic as well as stylistic, which Smith uses to develop these character transformations that make a success of the novel. Thematically, Smith relies on a variety of intertextual strategies that filter reality through various media and reinforce the theme of the subjectivity of experience. Amber relates her own history through a series of cinematic vignettes that blur the distinction between fantasy and reality and call into question the actuality of her existence. Eve’s biographies, though imagined hypotheticals, are part of a series of books titled “Genuine Article.” Astrid spends her time filming her surroundings before Amber throws her camera over a
MAJOR CHARACTERS MICHAEL FLINT is a pompous professor of English with an addiction to younger women. In the end he loses his teaching job because of his numerous romantic flings with his students. He is married to Eve Smart, a popular writer with two children from her first marriage, Astrid and Magnus. AMBER MACDONALD is the mysterious uninvited guest at the Smarts’ vacation house. She claims car trouble to inveigle her way inside, then dramatically alters the life of each of the family members by drawing them into her curious spell. Eve Smart finally throws her out of the house. ASTRID SMART is Eve Smart’s precocious young daughter, mature beyond her twelve years even before the arrival of Amber. EVE SMART is the wife of Michael Flint, the mother of Astrid and Magnus, and a writer of popular biographies that speculate on the afterlives of people who died young in the World War II era. Eve believes that Amber is one of Michael’s sexual conquests. MAGNUS SMART is Eve’s son, a seventeen-year-old burdened by the guilt of having been involved in a school prank that claimed the life of a fellow student. He tries to commit suicide but is apprehended by Amber, who then becomes his lover.
bridge. And the dead girl that Michael obsesses over killed herself as a result of a widely circulated e-mail that displayed her head attached to the naked body of another woman.
W Style Stylistically, Smith also uses varying intertextual strategies appropriate to recording each character’s method of apprehending reality. Astrid’s story is told through stream-of-consciousness technique, Magnus’s through a series of repetitions that seem to mimic the formulae coursing through his math-whiz brain. Michael at first holds forth as if lecturing to a classroom full of undergraduates but midway through the novel his narrative changes to the hackneyed and confused Byronic sonnets he writes documenting his infatuation with Amber. Eve turns the Genuine Article interview formula inward on herself, but refuses to answer her own most relevant questions. These narrative constructions are meant to call attention to themselves as deliberate strategies, and the writerly playfulness extends to the language as well, imbuing the novel with what Steven Poole describes as “an infectious sense of fun and invention.” The Atlantic review concluded that Smith’s style itself was the
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
7
The Accidental
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Ali Smith is a highly acclaimed author of unconventional novels, short stories, and plays. She is known for her exuberant wordplay and inventive narrative techniques calling into question the reliability of truth and representation. Twice shortlisted for both the Man Booker Prize and the Orange Prize, for the novels Hotel World (2001) and The Accidental (2005), the latter was awarded the prestigious Whitbread Novel of the Year Award. Smith taught for a time at the University of Strathclyde in Glasgow, was elected a Fellow of the Royal Society of Literature in 2007, and now writes full time from her home in Cambridge, England, also contributing articles to such newspapers as the Guardian, the Scotsman, and the Times Literary Supplement.
intended focus of the novel: “The real story, though, is the language. . . . Smith maintains a playful, poetic idiom of startling and clarifying emotional power, so that the prose, in its logical beauty and its surprisingness, serves as an analogue of the enchantment dispensed by Amber. It’s
an enormous technical accomplishment that reminds us of the difference between linguistic hocus-pocus and real writing; more important, it casts a spell.”
W Critical Reception As if in response to Smith’s commentary in the online discussion forum quoted above, Neel Mukherjee affirmed the success of her project to engage the reader in the performance of her writing: “There are no clear-cut answers, only teasing hints. It is a kind of writing that is nothing short of an enormous vote of confidence in her readers’ imagination, an invitation to a true, joyous interaction.” Most critics of the novel have applauded Smith’s inventive narrative strategies and unpredictable language play. The commentary of London Telegraph reviewer Alex Clark is representative. Describing the place of the novel within the whole of Smith’s output, Clark declared, “True to form . . . it is a novel grounded on the idea of fracture—a fissiparous, splintered artefact that has little to do with willful gimmickry and everything to do with its author’s delight in story-telling, linguistic exuberance and ambitious, frequently painful truthseeking.” But a few reviewers were not enthusiastic
Ali Smith, author of The Accidental, at the Edinburgh International Book Festival. ª Colin McPherson/Corbis
8
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Accidental
In The Accidental, a British family spending the summer in a countryside cottage is visited by a beautiful young stranger who forever alters their lives. witchcraft/Shutterstock.com
about Smith’s privileging of experimentation over the demands of a traditionally developed plot. For example, Eoin Cunningham complained that “the main feeling one takes from this novel is that a very clever writer has decided to ‘do a Shakespeare’ and borrow a stock situation, characters and plot to use as a framework from which their experimental literary riffs may take flight. That would be fine if it worked, but The Accidental ends up more an exercise in cleverness than a story.” In discussing Smith’s characterizations of the Smart family, most reviewers have singled out Astrid for special praise. For example, Yvonne Zipp called Astrid “the book’s crowning glory” and Poole averred, “The only problem with the brilliance of Astrid as a fictional creation is that it rather makes you wish that the whole novel was hers.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
“Ali Smith.” encompassculture. British Council Arts. Web. 6 Sept. 2010. Clark, Alex. “Fresh Light on Amber and Eve.” Telegraph [London], 29 May 2005. Web. 30 Aug. 2010. Cunningham, Eoin. Rev. of The Accidental, by Ali Smith. Bookslut. Web. 5 Sept. 2010.
Hughes-Hallett, Lucy. “Fiction: The Accidental by Ali Smith.” Sunday Times [London], 22 May 2005. Reviews of Books.com. Amazon. Judd, Elizabeth, and Joseph O’Neill. “Finds and Flops.” Atlantic, 297.1 (Jan.-Feb. 2006): 173. Miller, Laura. “Who’s That Girl?” New York Times Book Review (5 Feb. 2006): 14 (L). Mukherjee, Neel. Review of The Accidental, by Ali Smith. Sunday Times [London], 1 Sept. 2005. Web. 29 Aug. 2010. Poole, Steven. “The Genuine Article.” Guardian, 11 June 2005. Web. 29 Aug. 2010. Zipp, Yvonne. “The Guest Who Throws a Family into Crisis.” Christian Science Monitor, 10 Jan. 2006. Web. 29 Aug. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Rev. of The Accidental, by Ali Smith. Kirkus Reviews, 73.22 (15 Nov. 2005): 1209. Brief plot review concluding, “It’s not so much about the story as it is about the virtuosity of the telling.”
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
9
The Accidental
Rev. of The Accidental, by Ali Smith. metacritic.com. Web. 8 Sept. 2010. Provides access to numerous reviews of The Accidental from leading sources, including the New York Times, the Atlantic, the London Review of Books, the Boston Globe, and the Washington Post. Bailey, Paul. “House Breaker.” Independent [London], 10 June 2005. Web. 29 Aug. 2010. High praise for The Accidental, calling the book a “page-turner,” Amber a “brilliant creation,” and Michael’s sonnet narrative an “isolated tour de force.” Dervin, Dan. “Unexpected Visitor Alters Family Life Already Dysfunctional.” Free Lance-Star [Fredericksburg, VA], 15 July 2007. NewsBankinc. Access World News. Web. 2 Sept. 2010. Commends the novel’s spirit of innovation. Schaub, Michael. “Surprise Visit Upends a Family’s Vacation.” San Francisco Chronicle 8 Jan. 2006. SFGate.com. Web. 29 Aug. 2010. Remarks upon Smith’s successful manipulation of multiple viewpoints, also praising Smith’s humor and creation of a sense of mystery. Whitney, Scott. Rev. of The Accidental, Audiobook. Booklist, 102.18 (15 May 2006): 64. Finds that the ensemble cast successfully re-creates the “hypnotic appeal” of the print version. Winter, Jessica. “Amber Alert.” Village Voice, 27 Dec. 2005. Web. 29 Aug. 2010. Review of The Accidental that looks at the book within the context of Smith’s other stories and her penchant for metafiction. Gale Resources
“Ali Smith.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2010. Also covered in Contemporary Authors New Revision Series, vols. 88, 159, and 199.
10
Open Web Sources
The hyperlink “CultureBooksAli Smith” at the website for the London Guardian contains a useful summary of Smith’s life and works, with a suggested reading plan and another link to reviews of her latest stories. http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/2008/jun/11/ alismith For Further Reading
The Man Who Came to Dinner. Dir. William Keighley. Perf. Bette Davis, Ann Sheridan, Monty Woolley, Richard Travis, Jimmy Durante, and Billie Burke. Warner Home Video, 2006. DVD. Comedy about a famous radio wit and cultural critic who takes over a small-town Ohio household after injuring himself in a fall on the ice outside the home. The fractures heal but the uninvited guest fakes the extent of his injuries to prolong his stay. Smith, Ali. The Seer. London: Faber and Faber, 2006. Print. A comedy of manners founded on a premise similar to The Accidental, concerning an Edinburgh couple whose life is completely disrupted by the arrival of the woman’s sister. In the play, the Amber figure, the sister, is even more a force of anarchy but the effect is one of farce. Teorema. Dir. Pier Paolo Pasolini. Perf. Terence Stamp, Silvana Magana, Massimo Grotto, Anne Wiazemsky, and Laura Betti. Mondo Home Entertainment, 2003. DVD. Film with a plot very similar to The Accidental and actually referenced in the novel. Terence Stamp plays the charming stranger in the movie, seducing all the members of a wealthy Italian family before mysteriously disappearing. This DVD is in Italian with English subtitles. Janet Mullane
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Across a Hundred Mountains By Reyna Grande
W Introduction Across a Hundred Mountains (2006) is Reyna Grande’s first novel. Largely autobiographical, the book opens with a poverty-stricken family living in a cardboard shack on the outskirts of a small Mexican village. Juana is a young girl whose father, Miguel, has left his family to find work en el otro lado—“on the other side.” He finds a “coyote” to take him to America, promising to send money to his family. After two years, the family has heard nothing from Miguel. Juana loses her baby sister in a flood, and the family is deeply in debt to the village’s loan shark. Juana, convinced that her father is across the mountains, leaves her mother to find him. Juana’s story is intercut with a narrative from the point of view of Adelina Vasquez, a Mexican girl who is a social worker in Los Angeles. Adelina is traveling to Mexico in order to discover the truth about her own father’s disappearance nineteen years earlier, and to get away from her pimp/ boyfriend. Traveling in opposite directions on similar quests, the two women meet in a Tijuana jail, where Adelina agrees to help Juana find the “coyote” who brought her father across the border and into the United States. While on the surface, Across a Hundred Mountains chronicles the personal journeys of two women, it also considers the larger issue of immigration and examines the poverty and destitution experienced by scores of Mexican families who risk their lives trying to escape their situations by crossing the U.S. border.
W Literary and Historical Context
Across a Hundred Mountains takes as its subject matter the contemporary phenomenon of Mexican immigration
into the United States. Although the book is a fictional account of immigration, Grande drew heavily upon her own experiences. Born in Mexico in 1975 and left behind to be raised by her grandmother while her parents immigrated to the United States to work, she came to the United States as an undocumented immigrant at the age of nine. Unable to find books that she could relate to, Grande has said, “I wrote this story because all of the books that I read, especially those by Latino authors, never quite captured my own experience,” adding, “A lot of books deal with the children of immigrants—what they go through and their identity as U.S.-born Latinos. I always felt a little left out because I wasn’t born here, and these stories weren’t reflecting my personal experience” (Rappaport). Rather than discuss the political implications of the immigration issue, Grande personalizes and humanizes the poverty and desperation faced by the thousands of Mexican immigrants coming over the border each year. Speaking about her own experience, Grande has commented, “The poverty—that’s very real to my experience. . . . My sister in Mexico had a habit of picking up things off the ground . . . and eating them, just because we didn’t have any food” (Rappaport). The border’s tendency to break families is illustrated in the novel as well as in Grande’s experience. Her father left for the United States, followed by her mother. When Grande crossed the border after them, several years later, her parents were divorced. According to the Los Angeles Daily News, “She has no memory of her parents ever living together. And when she arrived in the United States, she lived with her father, and although her mother was just 20 minutes away, she only saw her once or twice a month,” adding, “Grande said those childhood experiences reverberate in her writing” (Coca). In the book, Juana’s family is broken when her father leaves—an event that is a catalyst for further fractures and disconnects within the family, ultimately leading to Juana’s own journey and self-discovery.
11 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Across a Hundred Mountains
MAJOR CHARACTERS DON ELÍAS is a money lender from whom Miguel has to borrow in order to pay the “coyote” to ferry him across the border. When Lupe cannot pay him, he demands that she sleep with him, starting her descent into depression, alcoholism, and insanity. JUANA GARCIA is a poor Mexican girl whose father leaves for the United States and disappears. Two years later, Juana goes after him and, in Tijuana, meets Adelina, who agrees to help her across the border. LUPE GARCIA is Juana’s mother. After her husband leaves for the United States, she loses three of her children and finds herself deeply in debt to Don Elías. She spirals into alcoholism and madness, inspiring Juana to leave the village to find her father. MIGUEL GARCIA is Juana’s father. He borrows money from Don Elías to pay a “coyote” to take him across the Mexico/ U.S. border. His intention is to support his family, but he is not heard from again. ADELINA VASQUEZ is a social worker from Los Angeles who is traveling to Mexico to discover the truth about her father’s disappearance nineteen years earlier. She meets Juana in a Tijuana jail and agrees to help her on her quest.
W Themes Cultural identity assumes a fluid nature in Across a Hundred Mountains. Upon crossing the border, people’s identities shift and change. When characters enter a country that does not want them, they become anonymous and alone. Families on the Mexican side of the border, stuck in a cycle of poverty and violence, are torn apart as a result of members leaving. Despite his intention to effect a change by earning more money for the family, when Juana’s father leaves, the family’s misfortunes intensify. Grande assigns an almost mythical quality to the journey from Mexico to the United States by referring to the destination as “the other side.” She equates the journey from Mexico to the United States with a kind of rebirth, where new identities are acquired, but the novel shows that ultimately cultural identity is inescapable. The theme of cultural identity is extended by Grande’s treatment of duality in the novel. Juana and Adelina represent two sides of the same coin, each on a journey to discover themselves. Early in the novel, Juana meets a man who, speaking of the moon, tells her, “‘It has two faces. She only shows one face to the world. Even though it changes shape constantly, it’s always the same face we see. But her second face, her second face remains hidden in darkness. That’s the face no one can see. People
12
Mexican immigrants enter the United States illegally. Across a Hundred Mountains features the story of a young Mexican girl trying to locate her father, who disappears after sneaking into the United States to find work. Spencer Grant/Photo Researchers, Inc.
call it the dark side of the moon. Two identities. Two sides of a coin.’” (Grande 25). Rather than maintaining one identity, the novel illustrates the modernist notion of a fractured, multiplicity of identities.
W Style Grande’s narrative in Across a Hundred Mountains shifts between her two main characters. The book opens with a section told from Juana’s point of view. Héctor Torres, associate professor at the University of New Mexico in Albuquerque, has commented, “‘Adelina’ opens the narrations, situating the reader amid the search for the lost/absent father. The reader finds Adelina looking for the lost bones of her father. Nineteen years have passed, the narrator tells us, since the search began: ‘Too many years thinking he had abandoned them.’ Grande leaves her reader suspended over this abyss of narrative time and the corpse Adelina’s search has uncovered” (Torres). Across a Hundred Mountains has a narrative structure that TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Across a Hundred Mountains
manipulates time by situating Juana in a linear, chronological trajectory, while Adelina, generally moving forward through her time, is simultaneously allowed to move backward, through Juana’s time. As Torres observes, “Grande plays with narrative time, making it move backwards and forwards with each name until they collide, unsettling the formula of self-identity, A=A” (Torres). Grande uses deceptively simple language to tell her characters’ stories, with short, sometimes clipped sentences. This makes for a fast-paced story, and also gives the reader a sense of the complicated emotional states occupied by people living very simple lives and dealing with very basic human needs. One critic has suggested that, “Across a Hundred Mountains . . . maintains its power throughout because Reyna Grande keeps control over her language and does not feel a need to trumpet emotionally volatile scenes of alcohol and drug abuse, rape, poverty and infant mortality” (Olivas).
W Critical Reception Garnering critical acclaim, Grande’s novel won an American Book Award (2007) and an El Premio Aztlán Literary Award (2006). Called “a breathtaking debut from a young writer who has a remarkable literary future before her” (Olivas), Across a Hundred Mountains has been praised for its sparse language and honest portrayal of the realities of Mexico’s poor and of the immigration experience. One critic observed that the novel is written “In evocative language that never falls into the trap of bathos,” which contributes to “a striking and moving story” (Olivas). Another, calling the book “a powerful story that balances cultural trauma with reterritorialization and cultural renewal,” calls attention to the book’s “disarmingly simple prose” (Torres). Many critics note that Grande drew on her own life experiences while writing the novel, one commenting that the fact that “the novel is filled with details drawn from Grande’s own life adds immeasurably to the poignancy of the story” (Rappaport), but Grande maintains that the work is not entirely autobiographical—merely informed by her experience with Mexican poverty and as an undocumented immigrant. Commenting on Grande’s use of autobiography, one critic noted, “While acknowledging that the process draws from her personal experience, [Grande] was also quite candid about her disposition to depart from it and make up a tale free to bend the codes of authority housed under the name of realism” (Torres). While the vast majority of critics gave Across a Hundred Mountains rave reviews, some registered complaints about the writing, accusing the novel of having such shortcomings as “stereotyped characters and wildly melodramatic plotting” (Reese). Grande has been accused of writing with a melodramatic bent in the past. The Los Angeles Daily News reported that “Grande . . . said her melodramatic bent was understandable considering she’s
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Reyna Grande was born into poverty in rural Mexico and crossed the border to live with her father in Los Angeles when she was eight years old. At the urging of an English teacher at Pasadena City College, Grande attended the University of California at Santa Cruz, where she earned a bachelor’s degree in creative writing in 1999. Her senior project in UCSC’s Literature Department was the first eighty pages of Across a Hundred Mountains. After graduating, Grande was named a 2003 PEN USA Emerging Voices Fellow, which enabled her to enroll in free writing classes at UCLA. Now an American citizen, she lives in Los Angeles, teaches English as a second language, frequently visits schools to talk about writing and her books, and continues to write fiction.
from Mexico. . . . ‘Mexicans watch soap operas,’ [she] said with a laugh” (Coca). BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Coca, Rick. “Beyond Melodrama First-Time Novelist’s Fiction Underscored with Personal Truths.” Los Angeles Daily News, 2006. HighBeam Research. Web. 10 Sept. 2010. Grande, Reyna. Across a Hundred Mountains. New York: Washington Square Press: Atria, 2007. Print. Olivas, Daniel A. Rev. of Across a Hundred Mountains, by Reyna Grande. Latino Stories.com. El Paso Times, 16 Apr. 2006. Web. 10 Sept. 2010. Rappaport, Scott. “Alumni Profile: Across a Hundred Mountains.” UC Santa Cruz Review. UC Santa Cruz. 2007. Web. 10 Sept. 2010. Reese, Jennifer. Rev. of Across a Hundred Mountains, by Reyna Grande. Entertainment Weekly, 23 June 2006. Web. 10 Sept. 2010. Torres, Héctor. “Across a Hundred Mountains.” Hispanic Outlook in Higher Education, 2008. HighBeam Research. Web. 10 Sept. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Rev. of Across a Hundred Mountains, by Reyna Grande. Color Lines Magazine, 2006. HighBeam Research. Web. 10 Sept. 2010. Brief review of Across a Hundred Mountains praising Grande’s voice and use of detail. Shank, Jenny. “Reyna Grande’s Across a Hundred Mountains.” New West Books and Writers, 16 Aug.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
13
Across a Hundred Mountains
2007. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. Long review of the book that includes notes on the author, plot summary, and criticism of Grande’s characterization. Gale Resources
“Reyna Grande.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2007. Literature Resource Center. Web. 9 Sept. 2010. Open Web Sources
Grande’s website featuring a biography, speaking engagements, sections dedicated to her books, and contact information is at http://www.reynagrande. com/index.htm Grande’s publisher’s website includes a biography, interviews, reviews, and excerpts from her novels. http:// authors.simonandschuster.com/Reyna-Grande/ 27097999 An interview with the author in which she discusses her books and her career is at http://thedarkphantom. wordpress.com/2009/03/31/on-the-spotlight-
reyna-grande-author-of-across-a-hundred-moun tains/. For Further Reading
Grande, Reyna. Dancing with Butterflies: A Novel. New York: Washington Square Press, 2009. Print. Grande’s second novel, told from the perspectives of four different women in a Los Angeles dance company. Pérez, Ramón “Tianguis.” Trans. Dick J. Reavis. Diary of an Undocumented Immigrant. Houston: Arte Publico Press, 1991. Print. Autobiographical account that deals with the economy and culture of the United States from the perspective of an undocumented immigrant. Zucker, Norman L., and Naomi Flink. Desperate Crossings: Seeking Refuge in America. Armonk, NY: M. E. Sharpe, 1996. Print. Political and social analysis of refugee policies since the end of the Cold War. Discusses the 1980s exodus from Central America and the Haitian and Cuban exoduses of 1994. Todd Breijak
14
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Adventures of Vela By Albert Wendt
W Introduction Albert Wendt’s The Adventures of Vela begins as Alapati, the narrator, meets the immortal Samoan storyteller Vela when they are assigned adjacent hospital beds. Vela, who is emaciated, dying, and desirous of death, anoints the narrator as his chronicler in English. Vela is three hundred years old, so the story of his life spans that of the colonial period of Samoan history. The novel is both a revisionary account of Samoa from the point of view of the colonized and a set of meditations on what it means to write history. The Adventures of Vela, which was written over a period of nearly two decades, first appeared in 1995 as a long poem in Wendt’s collection Photographs. It is the longest novel in verse to come out of New Zealand and the Pacific, and Wendt refers to it as his life’s work. The novel won the Commonwealth Prize for literature in 2010.
W Literary and Historical Context
The Adventures of Vela is set in Samoa, a chain of volcanic islands in the South Pacific Ocean about 2,200 miles south of Hawaii. Under colonial rule from the beginning of the nineteenth century, the Samoan islands were split into two sections at the turn of the twentieth century. The eastern islands, today referred to as American Samoa, became territories of the United States in 1904. The western islands became known as Western Samoa (now just Samoa) and were controlled first by Germany and then by New Zealand beginning in 1914. New Zealand administered Western Samoa under the auspices of the League of Nations and then as a United Nations trusteeship. A resistance movement to both German and New Zealand rule, known as the Mau (“strongly held view”) movement, helped to edge the islands toward
independence on January 1, 1962, making it the first Pacific Island country to gain government autonomy. The Adventures of Vela, like Wendt’s previous work, falls in the category of postcolonial literature, a genre that reacts to, and usually against, the discourse of colonization. These works typically offer a critique of the ideological and historical effects of colonial rule in countries that are now independent. Postcolonial literature is also concerned with both the cultural and political policies implemented during colonial rule and the way that those policies changed the native cultures that existed before colonization. Works in the genre often critique classical English language texts that carry racist or colonial undertones through the process of “writing back.” Writing for the Journal of Pacific History, critic Paul Sharrad describes Wendt’s Samoan fiction as “a corrective reclamation of literary history” that counters the “false and demeaning images of Islanders and island life perpetuated in outsider writing and taught in colonial schools.” As Wendt says in a Dominion Post interview with Diana Dekker, the English programs of his own school days were structured “exactly like they were in England. . . . No New Zealand literature at all. I think they started teaching New Zealand literature in the 1970s.”
W Themes The Adventures of Vela fits strongly within the postcolonial tradition and, like Wendt’s earlier novels, struggles to provide a space in which the oral traditions of Samoa’s past can be accommodated, remembered, and reformed while resisting the reproduction of a homogenous “tradition”—a term, Wendt declared, that “means nothing to me” (Mallon). As Wendt notes in his essay “Towards a New Oceania”—often referred to as the founding document of Pacific studies—he is wary of the nostalgic desire to resurrect an imagined precolonial
15 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Adventures of Vela
MAJOR CHARACTERS ALAPATI, the unnamed narrator of The Adventures of Vela, meets Vela in a hospital and consents to chronicle his life. Vela comes in and out of his life over the course of several decades, and the narrative of Vela’s past is interspersed with sections describing the relationship between Alapati and Vela and Alapati’s family life. VELA, the immortal storyteller whose life is nominally the subject of the novel, conscripts Alapati to tell his life story. The parts of the novel that take place in the past are mainly a chronology of his life.
culture, instead encouraging New Zealand to embrace cultural and racial complexity as a strength rather than a weakness. As such, the novel does not attempt to revive a pure Samoan past but rather is influenced by the idea of “hybridity,” the central concept in postcolonial theorist Homi Bhabha’s argument in The Location of Culture. Bhabha contends that mixed cultural traditions present a challenge to colonial regimes specifically and to essentialist cultural beliefs and forms generally. Writers such as Wendt, Salman Rushdie, and Derek Walcott depict modern-day ethnic cultures that are strengthened by containing a mix of past and present and of Eastern and Western cultural traditions. In an interview with Vili Hereniko and David Hanlon in Contemporary Pacific, Wendt said, “It’s important that we decolonialize our histories. . . . In school, our histories were taught as prehistory or folk history.” The Adventures of Vela exhibits this desire to decolonize history by bringing the mythic figure from the prehistoric past into the present day and merging aspects of Samoan oral traditions with the literate culture of the present. Vela’s life span is long enough that his biography is itself the story of this endeavor, and his difficult friendship with the narrator is a metaphor for the attempt to provide a cultural form in which otherwise irreconcilable entities (mythic and historical, profane and ordinary, body and soul, past and present) can coexist. As Helen Watson White in the Sunday Star Times puts it, The Adventures of Vela is “storytelling about storytelling,” a novel that champions the possibility that many different voices can produce a more robust and complete version of truth and history than any one speaker can. The indefinite structure of the novel, which vacillates between a number of voices—not all of which are even identifiable but all of which speak with equal authority—suggests that even gods are simply additional voices witnessing events as they pass. The volatility of the text encourages multiple voices and rejects the cultural homogeneity that Wendt criticizes in “Towards a New Oceania.”
16
A man in traditional Samoan dress. In The Adventures of Vela, Alapati meets Vela, a 300-year-old Samoan storyteller who appoints him to be his chronicler in English. ª Bill Bachmann / Alamy
W Style The Adventures of Vela, which White refers to as a “postmodern potpourri,” is composed of a mix of styles (poetry, short story, and images); vocabularies (lyric, profane, modern, and archaic); and ideas (religious, cultural, and political). The discontinuous narrative, fragmented verse forms, lack of novelistic conventions such as clear characterization and identifiable speaking styles, absence of markers of temporal and geographical placement, and use of Samoan words can make the novel slow and frustrating to read. Although the book is best described as a hybrid or mixed form comprising elements of poetry, song, drama, and folktales, in an interview with Pacific Starmap, Wendt refers to it as a “novel in verse” rather than a poem. Novels, he says in his interview with Hereniko and Hanlon, “present the most complex histories that have been written . . . [because] you try to bring out the complexity in the characters,” and the “character” of a country is depicted through the behavior and character of the people who inhabit it. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Adventures of Vela
Structurally, The Adventures of Vela resembles an epic or long poem. Like an epic poem, it is divided into “books”—“Beginnings,” “The Chronicles of Nafanua,” “Travel,” and “The Last Adventure”—each of which has several chapters. Paula Green, writing for New Zealand Listener, calls the novel “a sumptuous feast that brings to mind the resonating layers of Dante’s Divine Comedy or Boccaccio’s Decameron.” The piece, however, more closely resembles a modern epic poem or long poem than the Renaissance epic poem represented by Boccaccio’s and Dante’s works. The Adventures of Vela is formally similar to modernist works such as Ezra Pound’s The Cantos and Mina Loy’s Songs to Johannes. Its structure is discontinuous, composed of fragments of verse and phrases, and the difficulty caused by the collagelike arrangement of the poem is accentuated by the fact that most readers are not familiar with the mythic background of the novel, nor will they recognize the words and phrases in Samoan that are used throughout. Despite Wendt’s description of The Adventures of Vela as a novel, the book does not have a continuous narrative. It covers the fictional Vela’s lifetime, from precolonial days to the present, but it bounces around in time. The book begins with Alapati’s first encounter with Vela, but the point of view of the novel alternates between sections that are clearly in the voice of the narrator, sections in which the narrator is unmistakably telling Vela’s story, others in which Vela seems to be telling his own story, and still others in which it is simply unclear who is speaking. The work melds the styles of oral storytelling, novelistic interest in characters, and the fragmentary form of the avant-garde poem into a structure that integrates the past and the present.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Albert Wendt was born in 1939 in Apia, Western Samoa, where he spent his childhood and high school years. He attended Victoria University and, after receiving an MA in history, returned to Samoa to teach history and literature. In the mid-1970s he began teaching at the University of the South Pacific and became a leading figure in the study of indigenous literature of the South Pacific Islands, or Oceania. Wendt, who was the first professor in New Zealand from one of the Pacific Islands, remains influential in the field of postcolonial literature and a strong advocate for native Oceanic writers. He has been particularly involved in supporting efforts to publish and distribute literary works by indigenous and native authors in New Zealand, Australia, and abroad. Wendt, a celebrated novelist, poet, and literary scholar, writes mainly about his native Samoa. His best-known novel, Leaves of the Banyon Tree (1979), won a New Zealand Book Award in 1980. He is the author of the novels Songs for the Return Home (1973), Flying Fox in a Freedom Tree (1974), Leaves of the Banyan Tree (1979), Ola (1991), and The Adventures of Vela, as well as of collections of short stories and volumes of poetry. He has edited two major anthologies of contemporary Pacific literature—Lali (1979) and Nuanua (1995)—and volumes on contemporary poetry from Fiji, Samoa, Vanuatu, the Solomon Islands, and the New Hebrides. Two of his novels, Songs for the Return Home and Flying Fox in a Freedom Tree, have been made into feature films.
whenever it occurred” to be “a merciful spell from considering bodily concerns.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
W Critical Reception The Adventures of Vela has garnered little attention in the press, though it won the prestigious Commonwealth Prize in 2010, edging out such internationally renowned writers as Peter Carey and J. M. Coetzee. One of the few substantial reviews of the novel, written by Green, lauds the book’s origins in “both indigenous oral traditions and Western literature.” Green, a poet from New Zealand, appreciates Wendt’s ability to bring the mythic and the real together, putting “flesh on character beyond what one might expect from the legacy of mythological narrative.” She remarks that Vela and Nafanua, the Samoan goddess of war, “are neither sanitized nor stereotyped but step out of lines that circulate grit and vulgarity as much as they do the rhythms of the sea.” The language of The Adventures of Vela—which, as Green points out, is not “sanitized”—was a concern for White, who found the “surfacing of Wendt the lyricist
Works Cited
“Albert Wendt.” Pacific Starmap. Pacific Starmap, n.d. Web. 14 Nov. 2010. Bhabha, Homi. The Location of Culture. London: Routledge, 1994. Print. Dekker, Diana. “The Adventurous Albert Wendt.” Dominion Post 1 Aug. 2009: 20. Print. Green, Paula. “Layer by Layer.” Rev. of The Adventures of Vela, by Albert Wendt. New Zealand Listener 8-14 Aug. 2009. Web. 14 Nov. 2010. Hereniko, Vili, and David Hanlon. “An Interview with Albert Wendt.” Contemporary Pacific 5.1 (1993): 112-31. Print. Mallon, Sean. “Against Tradition.” Contemporary Pacific 22.2 (2010): 362-81. Print. Sharrad, Paul. “Albert Wendt and the Problem of History.” Journal of Pacific History 37.1 (2002): 109-16. Print.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
17
The Adventures of Vela
Wendt, Albert. “Tatauing the Post-Colonial Body.” Span 42-3 (1996): 15-29. Print. ———. “Towards a New Oceania.” MANA Review 1 (1976): 1. Print. White, Helen Watson. “Free-Running Verse and Stories about Storytelling.” Sunday Star Times [Auckland] 26 July 2009: 8. Print.
The Emory University English Department’s Postcolonial Studies site provides a critical biography and bibliography on the author, as well as an analysis of the themes in Wendt’s early work. http://www. english.emory.edu/Bahri/Wendt.html
Criticism and Reviews
The New Zealand Electronic Poetry Centre features links to poems and poetic segments available online, in addition to a number of audio files of Wendt reading his own work. http://www.nzepc.auckland.ac.nz/ authors/wendt/
Ellis, Juniper. “‘The Techniques of Storytelling’: An Interview with Albert Wendt.” Ariel 28.3 (1997), 7184. Print. In this long interview, Wendt describes how his ideas about storytelling, form, and narration have changed over his twenty-year writing career.
The New Zealand Electronic Text Centre offers a history of Samoa until 1918 and has, among its listings, a page on “Myths and Legends of Ancient Samoa.” http://www.nzetc.org/tm/scholarly/tei-TuvAcco. html
Newton, John. “Challenging Pacific Poems.” Rev. of Photographs, by Albert Wendt. Evening Post [Wellington] 25 Aug. 1995: 5. Print. Newton’s review of Wendt’s 1995 volume Photographs describes the collection as “various, more formally ambitious [than his previous two books of poetry], and more abrasive.”
The Web site of the University of Auckland Library includes a comprehensive bibliography of Wendt’s literary and critical works. http://www.nzetc.org/ tm/scholarly/tei-TuvAcco.html
Additional Resources
Sharrad, Paul. Albert Wendt and Pacific Literature: Circling the Void. Manchester: MUP/Auckland University Press, 2003. Print. Sharrad’s study, the first monograph on Wendt, examines his position as one of the foremost international writers of Pacific literature and reads his work in the context of his own critical writing. ———. “Still Life Moving: Albert Wendt’s Photographs.” Journal of Postcolonial Writing 38:1 (1998): 56-68. Print. In this long review, the leading scholar on Wendt calls the “reconstruction in ‘The Adventures of Vela’ of traditional oral epic as verse narrative . . . a new element in Wendt’s poetry, and a very significant one.” Gale Resources
“Albert Wendt.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2010. Literature Resource Center. Web. 6 Nov. 2010. “Albert Wendt.” Contemporary Poets. Detroit: Gale, 2001. Literature Resource Center. Web. 6 Nov. 2010. Open Web Sources
Wendt’s personal and professional Web site contains biographical and bibliographic information on the author. http://www.albertwendt.com/Home_ Page_Albert_Wendt.html On its Web site the New Zealand Book Council reprints the entry on Wendt from The Oxford Companion to New Zealand Literature and offers additional biographical data. http://www.bookcouncil.org.nz/wri ters/wendta.html
18
For Further Reading
Ashcroft, Bill, Gareth Griffiths, and Helen Tiffin. Postcolonial Studies: The Key Concepts, 2nd ed. London: Routledge, 2007. Print. The encyclopedic format of the revised edition of this volume makes it a helpful introduction. It can be paired with Ashcroft, Griffiths, and Tiffin’s exhaustive sourcebook The Post-colonial Studies Reader (2006). Craig, Robert. The Dictionary of Polynesian Mythology. New York: Greenwood, 1989. Print. This alphabetized resource on Polynesian mythology includes the names and concepts from Samoan mythology that Wendt draws on in The Adventures of Vela. Craig’s introduction offers a useful historical overview of Samoa and its myths. Goetzfridt, Nicholas J. Indigenous Literature of Oceania: A Survey of Criticism and Interpretation. Westport: Greenwood, 1995. Print. Goetzfridt’s collection of critical and interpretive sources on literature of the Pacific Islands, New Zealand, and Australia covers poets, dramatists, and novelists beginning in the 1960s and focuses on academic criticism. Each entry is well annotated, and there is an extensive section on Wendt. Sharrad, Paul, and Karen M. Peacock. “Albert Wendt: Bibliography.” Contemporary Pacific 15.2 (2003): 378-420. Project MUSE. Web. 4 Nov. 2010. The compilation of sources on Wendt, compiled by prominent Wendt scholar Sharrad and updated in 1993 by Peacock, touts itself as the most complete collection of references on Wendt to date. Teaiwa, Teresia, and Selina Tusitala Marsh. “Albert Wendt’s Critical and Creative Legacy in Oceania: An Introduction.” Contemporary Pacific 22:2 (2010): TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Adventures of Vela
233-48. Print. This issue of Contemporary Pacific is devoted to Wendt’s work as a novelist, a poet, an intellectual, and a mentor. Teaiwa and Marsh’s introduction gives a brief but helpful overview of Wendt’s life and importance in the field of Pacific literatures and provides short annotations on the articles included in the rest of the issue.
Wendt, Albert. Photographs. Auckland: AUP, 1995. Print. A forty-page portion of The Adventures of Vela appears as the centerpiece of this book of mostly autobiographical poems.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Jenny Ludwig
19
The Age of Orphans By Laleh Khadivi
W Introduction The first novel in Laleh Khadivi’s planned trilogy about three generations of Kurdish men from Iran, The Age of Orphans begins in 1921 with the brutal massacre of Kurdish guerrillas by the Persian military in the Zagros Mountains. Only one Kurd survives, an eight-year-old boy—witness to the slaughter of his father, uncles, and cousins—who is then adopted by the soldiers and conscripted into the shah’s army. Eight years later he is renamed Reza Khourdi in honor of the king, Reza Shah Pahlavi, notorious for a modernization campaign that involved the silencing of all ethnic minorities disloyal to the cause of nationalism. Reza Khourdi distinguishes himself in the army of the new Iran by virtue of his contempt for the Kurds, rises to the rank of captain, and, with his Westernized Tehrani wife, is sent back to his hometown, Kermanshah, to enforce the shah’s rule over his own people. The return to Kermanshah forces Reza Khourdi to confront his past and the suppression of his birth heritage, and his carefully crafted persona begins to crack. Khadivi’s portrait of his fracturing self has been frequently praised for its psychological depth as well as for its broader implications regarding the meaning of nationhood in cultural clashes and ethnic confrontations around the world. The novel has also been admired as a brutally graphic yet poetic conjuring of a world that no longer exists.
W Literary and Historical Context
Born in Esfahan, Iran, of Persian and Kurdish heritage, Khadivi was only a small child when her family decided to leave the country at the start of the revolution and the ascendancy of the Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini. In 2002 Khadivi began to research the history of the Kurds, the
largest ethnic group in the world without a country of their own. The Age of Orphans focuses on the time of the creation of the modern Iranian state. The Kurds were traditionally a nomadic people of goat and sheep herders living in the mountainous regions of southwest Asia. The breakup of the Ottoman Empire after World War I created new nation-states—Iraq, Kuwait, Syria—but left the Kurds segmented between Iran, Turkey, and Iraq. In 1925 Reza Shah Pahlavi, a former military officer and prime minister, became king of Persia. His monarchy was a centralized, authoritarian regime demanding that tribal populations pledge loyalty to the shah. This meant that the Kurds were to be stripped of their autonomy, including their languages and customs, in the name of progress. But the Kurds were more defiant than other tribes. Their resistance to assimilation resulted in the brutal battles depicted in The Age of Orphans, which takes place during the reigns of both Reza Shah Pahlavi (19251941) and his son and successor, Mohammed Reza Shah Pahlavi (1941-1979). It has been argued that the country’s name change in the 1930s was influenced by Nazis friendly with the Iranian ambassador to Germany, who suggested that the Persian word for the nation, Iran, a cognate of “Aryan,” was preferable to the Westernized version, Persia, and would signal a new beginning free of Russian and British influence.
W Themes Natsumi Ajiki observed in a review of The Age of Orphans in the Kurdish Herald, “Ms. Khadivi’s utmost interest in her novel is to tell a story about a man who, in his lifetime, is born into a tribe and dies in a nation, as a citizen of that nation.” The statement underscores the importance of the theme of identity in the book, which explores the toll of self-denial and the dangers of conflicted allegiances. Reza Khourdi’s fierce denunciation of his Kurdish self destroys his soul, a reality he confronts
20 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Age of Orphans
in Kermanshah as memories of his mother and father mingle with images of his savagery in battle and his continuing suppression of the Kurds. Khadivi writes of Reza in the novel, “As a soldier he will be deftly divided through the head, as a murderer cut open through the heart and as an old man split so thoroughly that one side of him dies first, unbeknownst and long before the other, damned to serve in hell as a half a man” (qtd. in Al-Shawaf). Throughout the story, Khadivi uses a pattern of oppositions in developing the two sides of Reza Khourdi’s identity. The name given him in the Iranian army is doubly significant, “Reza” having been chosen in honor of the shah, “Khourdi” to denote his ethnic heritage. As Reza seeks to distinguish himself in the army, impulses of self-preservation collide with feelings of immense self-loathing, yet he continues on his brutal crusade, hoping to erase every element of the Kurd within him. His Tehrani wife, Meena, is everything he is not— educated, urban, Westernized; their station in Kermanshah is everything she abhors—rural, backward, tribal. The spiritual torture Reza begins to experience in Kermanshah derives from the conflicts between traditional and modern ways, the Kurd within him and the Iranian
MAJOR CHARACTERS BABA is Reza Khourdi’s beloved father, pummeled to death by the Shah’s army before Reza’s eyes. As an older man, Reza is haunted by his banishment of Baba to a “damp purgatory of forget and never-remember.” THE BOY is the name by which Khadivi uses to refer to Reza before he is orphaned and conscripted into the Shah’s army. MEENA is Reza’s Westernized wife from Tehran. She is vocal about her miserable confinement in Kermanshah and vies with Reza for dominance over the local Kurdish people and their many children. Meena is murdered by Reza. REZA KHOURDI is the main character in the novel, almost maniacal in his quest to distinguish himself in the Shah’s army by demonstrating his hatred for his own people, the Kurds. His programmatic denial of his heritage becomes a source of anguish, and his Kurdish-hating façade begins to crack after he is sent to subdue the Kurds in his home region.
The sun rises over the Zagros Mountains, the site of a violent slaughter that opens the novel The Age of Orphans. ª Lee Carruthers / Alamy
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
21
The Age of Orphans
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Laleh Khadivi is a documentary filmmaker and writer of fiction. Prior to the critical success of her debut novel, The Age of Orphans, she received much recognition for the film 900, an exposé of a women’s prison in Louisiana narrated by Susan Sarandon. Khadivi was a creative writing fellow at Emory University, 2007-2009, and has published short fiction in various magazines. The Age of Orphans earned Khadivi a Whiting Writers’ Award and is the first installment of a projected trilogy about the oppression of the Kurds in Iran.
without. As he grows older, Reza’s anguish is manifested in his treatment of his bitterly dissatisfied and complaining wife and their six children. His actions perpetuate a cycle of violence and betrayal. He poisons Meena, eight months pregnant with their seventh child, by putting arsenic, cyanide, and bleach in her tea. And he orphans his children, who have been taught to hate the Kurds. Khadivi explained her intent in the novel to Ajiki: “Readers could read the story, learn about the difficulties faced by Kurds during this period but ultimately understand that we are all torn between one loyalty and the next and how artificial nationality actually is.”
Orphans well worth the effort, not only as a historical account of a little-documented aspect of prerevolutionary Iran, but also as commentary on current ethnic struggles. Donovan noted its relevance to the present situation in Iran: “[The] ayatollahs are simply the latest in a line of aspirants, wiping out the old failed regime and trying to claim ‘this invisible thing called Iran.’” Faye A. Chadwell credited the novel with an even broader significance: “With her eloquent portrayal of Reza, Khadivi has created an epitomic character representing so many 20th-century and current cultural, ethnic, and national identity clashes.” Khadivi received a $50,000 Whiting Writers’ Award for The Age of Orphans, a grant bestowed annually on ten promising new authors. Khadivi is now working on the second book in the trilogy, The Walking, which focuses on Reza Khourdi’s youngest son. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Ajiki, Natsumi. “Celebrate a Kurdish Writer, Laleh Khadivi: The Age of Orphans.” Kurdish Herald 1.2 (June 2009). Web. 25 Sept. 2010. Al-Shawaf, Rayyan. “Breaking Taboos in Middle Eastern Fiction.” Globe & Mail (Toronto) 2 Jan. 2010. Book Review Index Online Plus, Gale InfoTrac. Web. 25 Sept. 2010. Chadwell, Faye A. “Khadivi, Laleh. The Age of Orphans.” Library Journal 15 Feb. 2009: 96. Donovan, Deborah. “The Age of Orphans.” Booklist 1 Feb. 2009: 23.
W Style Khadivi’s introduction of first-person accounts narrated by people known to Reza—his wife, his children, the girl he rapes, his commanding officer—enhances the portrait of his duality and the clash between modern and tribal society, adding, according to Bookslut reviewer Jacob Silverman, “a prismatic and humanizing perspective” on Reza. The style of the novel has received much attention, with critics disagreeing on the success of its richly evocative language. Brandon Robshaw remarked, “The style is poetic, intense and lyrical, even when describing events of great brutality.” Deborah Donovan described the language as “luminous . . . by turns graphic and poetic.” But a writer for Kirkus Reviews found the book “somewhat marred by a false and overlush lyricism.” And Silverman complained that the meaning of several passages was compromised by the accumulation of detail in densely phrased sentences with little punctuation. Rayyan AlShawaf appeared to agree, calling Khadivi’s prose “by turns beautifully lyrical and frustratingly grandiloquent.”
“Khadivi, Laleh: The Age of Orphans.” Kirkus Reviews 15 Dec. 2008. Robshaw, Brandon. “The Age of Orphans by Laleh Khadivi.” Independent on Sunday [London] 29 Aug. 2010. HighBeam Research. Web. 25 Sept. 2010. Silverman, Jacob. Rev. of The Age of Orphans, by Laleh Khadivi. Bookslut Mar. 2009. Web. 23 Sept. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Adil, Alev. Rev. of The Age of Orphans, by Laleh Khadivi. Independent [London] 4 Dec. 2009. Web. 25 Sept. 2010. Describes the orphan’s rebirth as the fierce soldier and the book’s representation of a cycle of violence. Rev. of The Age of Orphans, by Laleh Khadivi. Daily News [South Africa] 26 May 2010. HighBeam Research. Web. 25 Sept. 2010. Judges the book difficult to read because of its heartbreaking subject matter but in the end well worth the effort.
W Critical Reception
Rev. of The Age of Orphans, by Laleh Khadivi. Publishers Weekly, 8 Dec. 2008: 41. A concise plot summary.
Some reviewers remarked on the difficulty of reading a novel so graphically violent, but most found The Age of
“Emory Fellow Wins Whiting Writers’ Award.” US Fed News Service, including US State News. Ht Media Ltd.,
22
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Age of Orphans
2008. HighBeam Research. Web. 25 Sept. 2010. Press release announcing Khadivi’s selection as a winner of the 2008 Whiting Writers’ Award. The piece provides some biographical details pertinent to the composition of The Age of Orphans and the planned trilogy. Fox, Catherine. “Severed Roots Are Haunting.” Atlanta Journal-Constitution 8 Mar. 2009. NewsBankinc. Access World News. Web. 26 Sept. 2010. Mainly biographical piece based on Fox’s interview with Khadivi at her Atlanta loft. Gurría-Quintana, Ángel. “Kurd of Honour: A Loss of Innocence and the Birth of Kurdistan.” Financial Times [London] 7 Nov. 2009. NewsBankinc. Access World News. Web. 26 Sept. 2010. Finds much to praise in The Age of Orphans but notes that Khadivi sometimes sacrifices clarity to poetic flourish. Gale Resources
“Laleh Khadivi.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2010. Web. 19 Sept. 2010. Open Web Sources
The author’s website provides access to a brief biography of Khadivi and reviews of The Age of Orphans. http:// lalehkhadivi.com/about.html In a YouTube video filmed at Kepler’s Books, Khadivi speaks about The Age of Orphans and her interest in the Kurds. http://www.youtube.com/watch? v=NMrLDa2lrqM Alan Cheuse reviews Khadivi’s The Age of Orphans and Ismail Kadare’s The Siege on NPR’s All Things Considered, April 7, 2009. http://go.galegroup. com/ps/i.do?&id=GALE%7CA197405669&v=2.1& u=itsbtrial&it=r&p=LitRG&sw=w
http://www.bloomsburyusa.com/bloomsbury/ downloads/guides/ageoforphans.pdf For Further Reading
Abdolah, Kader. My Father’s Notebook. New York: HarperPerennial, 2007. Print. Novel in which an Iranian political exile attempts to decipher the cuneiform writings of his deaf-mute and nearly illiterate father, born to the temporary wife of a Persian nobleman early in the twentieth century. Achebe, Chinua. Things Fall Apart. New York: Anchor, 1994. Print. Achebe’s masterpiece, a novel in many respects similar to The Age of Orphans in its depiction of the destruction of an individual and the culture that gave birth to him. Things Fall Apart takes place in Nigeria and describes tribal life before and after colonialism. Kamrava, Mehran. The Political History of Modern Iran: From Tribalism to Theocracy. Santa Barbara, CA: Praeger Publishers, 1992. Print. Examines Iran’s political history from the establishment of the Qajar dynasty in 1785 to the present, with special attention to issues of tribalism, religion, and demagoguery. Pezeshkzad, Iraj. My Uncle Napoleon. Trans. Dick Davis. New York: Random House, 2006. Print. A cultural reference point in Iran, first published in Tehran in 1973 and made into a popular television series in 1976, but banned since the Islamic Revolution. The story, set during the Allied occupation in World War II, is a humorous take on events that occur in an Iranian mansion occupied by three wealthy families under the sway of a paranoid uncle. Janet Mullane
Khadivi’s publishers have drawn up a series of discussion questions on the novel for reading groups.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
23
Air, or, Have Not Have By Geoff Ryman
W Introduction Geoff Ryman’s acclaimed novel, Air, or, Have Not Have, combines elements of alternative universe science fiction, fairy tale, realism, and mysticism to relate the tale of a poor woman, Chung Mae, living in a small village, Kizuldah, in the fictional country of Karzistan. Kizuldah is described in the novel as “the last village in the world to go online,” and the story examines how Mae endeavors to prepare her people for the future (1). “Air” is a wireless network that connects all people to one another, brain to brain, giving them the ability to access all information currently found on the Internet, and more, but without needing a computer. During a disastrous test of the system in which many people lose their lives or their sanity, Mae’s mind accidentally fuses with that of a dying, elderly woman, causing Mae to gain all of the old woman’s memories. Mae’s experiences with this new, shared personality inspire her to learn all she can about Air and the outside world. Air explores the advantages and disadvantages of globalization and third world peoples being unwillingly and abruptly thrust into an advanced technological world, through a narrative that blends stark realism with a hint of pseudoscience that verges into the magical realm as well. Air won the British Science Fiction Association Award, the James Tiptree Jr. Award, and the Arthur C. Clarke Award.
W Literary and Historical Context
As Air takes place in an alternative universe, some could argue that the book has little or no historical context. However, science fiction often comments on and reflects the society or world in which it was written, and many readers and critics have inferred that Ryman intended Air
to present an examination of the ever-changing and developing technology of the early twenty-first century. Karzistan, though fictional, is reminiscent of the real world’s nation of Kazakhstan in Eurasia. Furthermore, the harsh plight of the peasants’ lives—most of them poor rice farmers—living in Kizuldah seems inspired by the denizens of the rural areas of China, particularly in the early- to mid-twentieth century. Although Air occurs in the early twenty-first century, most of its characters seem to come from a time centuries earlier, who only relatively recently and very slowly begin to integrate such modern-day conveniences as electricity into their everyday lives. The network, Air, is a fictionalized upgrade of the World Wide Web. Air, much like the Internet, is suddenly able to make the world much smaller. Using Air, even people in tiny, remote communities can now connect with other people thousands of miles away. Ryman looks at recent discussions of how the old world is dying and takes his examination one step further. Given the dramatic impacts of personal computer use and the Internet in the real world, he prompts readers to imagine a reality in which minds themselves are all connected, and both the wonder and fears that such a device, or ability, might engender in humanity. Ryman argues that the future is not here for better or for worse, but for better and worse.
W Themes Air revolves around such themes as memory, change, and rebirth. Human beings are shaped and defined by their memories, and when timid Mae’s mind merges with that of Mrs. Tung, Mae begins to adopt many of the attributes of this elder woman who was extremely courageous in her younger life. Mae conducts an affair, threatens a brutish neighbor with a knife, and decides to gain as much knowledge as she can about the world outside the small, poor village in which she has lived her entire life. There is a degree of irony in the fact that another woman’s
24 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Air, or, Have Not Have
memories of the past inspire Mae to look toward the future. Meanwhile, the change that Mae begins to embrace is reflective of the transition occurring in the outside world due to the new technology. Some people mourn the death of the old ways, and Ryman’s skillful portrayal of the dying traditions is poignant and sad. On the other hand, the new future promises unanticipated new growth, beauty, and potential. As Robert K. J. Killheffer explains, Ryman “recognizes the tremendous losses that change brings . . . but . . . balances his elegies with equally beautiful observations on the wisdom and necessity of acceptance.” This is perhaps best reflected in the flash flood that destroys the village near the end of the book. In her eulogy, Mae mourns the people and homes lost but concludes on a hopeful note: “But look at the beautiful new sea. Look at it sparkle. Look at how full of hope it seems; look, it has seagulls, who could hate such a beautiful sea?” (358).
W Styles Although Air is primarily a science fiction novel, Ryman uses a number of styles that are most often associated with more experimental literature. The majority of the book is written in stark, unembellished prose with only the most subtle of literary flourishes. Ryman introduces us to the characters of Kizuldah via restrained descriptions of their actions and daily lives, painting a picture that firmly establishes the initial verisimilitude of the world of the novel. As the novel progresses, he deals with the narrative’s mystical elements through a more postmodern style, blending in elements of stream-of-consciousness and magical realism. Though Air is technically a sci-fi conceit, Ryman never provides a full, explicit explanation for how it works. Instead, it seems to manifest itself in an almost spiritual manner, which is heightened by the presence of Mrs. Tung’s “ghost” in Mae’s mind. When Mrs. Tung speaks to Mae, Ryman presents the connection in a dreamlike style, forgoing quotation marks. Instead, the novel’s third-person narrator alternates with dialogue between Mrs. Tung and Mae, with verbal cues rather than punctuation indicating who is speaking. The way the text shifts from traditional narrative to strange images, memories, thoughts, and flashes of the future and past creates a surreal atmosphere that clearly marks these portions as separate from the depictions of the relatively mundane reality of the characters’ outer lives. Ryman is also aware of the irony that he is using the medium of the printed word in order to depict a future that has progressed beyond the need for paper and ink. He, therefore, consciously uses a very literary style in order to impart this tale about the future, and perhaps
MAJOR CHARACTERS FAYSAL HASEEM is a brutish, cruel misogynist who makes a living out of ruining others’ lives. A turning point in Chung Mae’s life occurs when she threatens him with a knife. SUNNI HASEEM is the pampered, shallow woman whose husband, Faysal Haseem, makes a habit of bankrupting poor farmers by granting loans they cannot afford. She seems sweet on the surface but is vicious underneath. JOE is Chung Mae’s kind but weak husband, who fails to satisfy her emotionally. With the intention of taking over Joe's farm, early in the novel, Faysal Haseem tricks Joe into taking a loan that he cannot afford to pay back. KEN KUEI is Chung Mae’s next-door neighbor and grandson to Mrs. Tung, the old woman whose memories transfer to Chung Mae upon Tung’s death. Shortly afterward, Chung Mae conducts an affair with Ken. CHUNG MAE is a poor, illiterate woman whose life is fundamentally altered by Air during the initial testing when the memories of a dying, elderly woman, Mrs. Tung, fuse with hers, inspiring Mae to embark on an internal quest of self-discovery. MRS. TUNG is an elderly grandmother at the start of the novel. When she dies during the initial testing of Air, her memories merge with those of Chung Mae. The merging enables Chung Mae to discover how brave and rebellious Mrs. Tung had been in her younger days. KWAN WING is Chung Mae’s good friend and confidante.
even more interestingly, focuses his tale on a group of poor peasants in a place that is the opposite of most traditional sci-fi settings.
W Critical Reception Air was released in 2004 to mainly positive reviews. London’s Guardian critic named it a “deft synthesis of science fiction and the literary mainstream novel,” praising it for its sensitive examination of the effect of globalization and modern “technology on the third world.” Additionally, this reviewer was impressed with Ryman’s concept of Air as a “metaphor for the inevitability of change,” and how Ryman juxtaposes his science fiction concept with moving and incisive characterizations of simple peasant life. Similarly, Publishers Weekly declared that the novel was, for Ryman, a “triumphant return to science fiction . . . superbly crafted,” and also commended him for his vivid and detailed portrayal of the lives of the people of
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
25
Air, or, Have Not Have
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Born in Canada in 1951, science fiction and fantasy writer Geoff Ryman moved to the United States at age eleven, and has spent the majority of his adult life in England. Known for writing extremely literate sci-fi, one of Ryman’s primary interests is in examining fantasy itself, probing how the stories of childhood affect and are affected by the process of growing up, a theme he explored to great effect in Was, a rumination on The Wizard of Oz. Ryman also spearheaded the “Mundane SF” movement, whose goal is to produce realist sci-fi that explores the connection between everyday people and technology. Interestingly, despite this credo, the novels Ryman is most noted for, such as Was, Lust, and Air, all incorporate elements of magical realism into their narratives.
Kizuldah. The reviewer called Air a “treat for fans of highly literate SF,” arguing that “this intensely political book has important things to say about how developed nations take the Third World for granted.” Although Air was generally well received, some critics did express qualms regarding Ryman’s style in the novel. Robert E. Brown of Library Journal wondered to
whom exactly the novel might appeal, claiming that “the tech stuff isn’t high-octane enough for techies, and the rural realism breaks no new ground.” A Kirkus Reviews critic held a more positive view regarding the characterization and prose, stating that Mae “is an impressive heroine, and the text is full of sharp commentary and vivid characters” but felt that the story “fails to engage fully and bogs down for long stretches.” Air won a number of prestigious literary awards, including the British Science Fiction Association Award, the James Tiptree Jr. Award, and the Arthur C. Clarke Award. It was also short-listed for the Philip K. Dick Award, the Nebula Award, and the John W. Campbell Memorial Award. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
“Air.” Rev. of Air by Geoff Ryman. Kirkus Reviews 15 Oct. 2003: 1248. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 18 July 2010. “Air.” Rev. of Air, by Geoff Ryman. Publishers Weekly 10 Nov. 2003: 47. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 18 July 2010. Brown, Robert E. “Ryman, Geoff. Air.” Rev. of Air, by Geoff Ryman. Library Journal 129.1 (Jan. 2004): 160. Print. General OneFile. Web. 18 July 2010.
Image of medical technology as art, simulating the network called “Air” that links the minds of characters in the novel. kentoh/Shutterstock.com
26
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Air, or, Have Not Have
Killheffer, Robert K. J. “Edenborn.” Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction 108.4 (Apr. 2005): 33+. Literature Resource Center. Web. 18 July 2010. “Review: Paperbacks: Fiction: Air, by Geoff Ryman.” Rev. of Air, by Geoff Ryman. Guardian [London] 4 Nov. 2006: 18. Print. General Reference Center Gold. Web. 18 July 2010. Ryman, Geoff. Air (Or, Have Not Have). New York: St. Martin’s, 2004. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Allberry, Russ. “Air by Geoff Ryman.” Rev. of Air, by Geoff Ryman. Eyrie.org., 13 Feb. 2006. Web. 18 July 2010. A review of Air that discusses Ryman’s key themes and metaphors and how he weds his science fiction concept with a rich portrayal of the characters that encourages reader empathy and understanding. Chiang, Ted. “Is Air Mundane?” Extrapolation 49.2 (2008): 211+. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 18 July 2010. Geoff Ryman spearheaded the “Mundane SF” movement—hard science fiction set in a “real world” more invested in exploring people’s interactions with technology than investigating potential future breakthroughs such as time travel, parallel dimensions, and other prospective inventions. Ryman has also claimed, however, that Air is not Mundane SF. This essay examines the novel from that perspective, attempting to determine whether or not Ryman is correct. Easterbrook, Neil. “‘Giving an Account of Oneself’: Ethics, Alterity, Air.” Extrapolation 49.2 (2008): 240+. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 18 July 2010. This essay explores the central metaphors of Air, particularly those of change and rebirth.
Open Web Sources
An interview with Ryman focusing on Air in which he discusses things such as his motivation for writing the novel, his style and technique, done via cyberspace, can be found at http://www.infinityplus.co.uk/ nonfiction/intgr.htm Ryman wrote an “interactive novel” called 253 or Tube Theatre, subtitled A Novel for the Internet about London Underground in Seven Cars and a Crash. Each section delves into the mind of a different character in one of the train cars, and by clicking on hyperlinks, one can “travel” to the minds of nearby characters or those in different cars who are connected, in some way, to that character. One can read the book “linearly” or by bouncing around via the hyperlinks. The entire novel is online at http:// www.ryman-novel.com
For Further Reading
Buck, Pearl S. The Good Earth. New York: John Day, 1931. Print. This Pulitzer Prize–winning novel set in late-nineteenth/early-twentieth century China depicts the lives of destitute people not far removed, culturally or technologically, from the characters of Air. Gibson, William. Neuromancer. New York: Ace, 1984. Print. An acclaimed novel credited with starting the “cyberpunk” movement of literature and film. Very different in tone to Air, it is thematically reminiscent, detailing a future in which everyone’s consciousnesses are connected to a global computer network.
Melzack, Geneva, and Iain Emsley. “Two Views: Air by Geoff Ryman.” Rev. of Air, by Geoff Ryman. Strange Horizons. 7 Nov. 2005. Web. 18 July 2010. This article compares two viewpoints on Air—both are very positive—each zeroing in on different aspects of the novel.
Mitchell, David. Ghostwritten. New York: Vintage, 1999. Print. This novel of interlinked short stories includes a section on a poor woman who operates a tea shack on the side of a mountain in China, reminiscent in theme and tone to Air. Like Air, Ghostwritten explores themes of globalization and how seemingly disparate cultures are connected on a basic, human level.
Soyka, David. “Air.” Rev. of Air, by Geoff Ryman. SF Site, 2007. Web. 18 July 2010. http://sfsite.com/ 02a/ai241.htmThis compelling review categorizes Air as a sort of inverted cyberpunk novel. Instead of the narrative existing inside of a computer’s virtual reality, the majority of the book takes place in the real world, examining people’s reactions to extreme technological advances.
Ryman, Geoff. Was. New York: Penguin, 1992. Print. Arguably Ryman’s best-known book, this novel depicts the lives of various people affected by The Wizard of Oz, from an alternate version of Dorothy Gale to Judy Garland to a young man dying of AIDS. Includes elements of magical realism and incisive character development similar to those Ryman would later use in Air.
Gale Resources
“Geoffrey Charles Ryman.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2006. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 18 July 2010.
Stiglitz, Joseph E. Globalization and Its Discontents. New York: Norton, 2002. Print. Written by a Nobel Prize winner, this book examines the policies that have furthered globalization and their negative effects on “Third World” countries.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
27
Air, or, Have Not Have
Zittrain, Jonathan. The Future of the Internet—and How to Stop It. Harrisonburg: R. R. Donnelley, 2008. Print. Presents interesting explorations of the impact the Internet has had on our world and how it might
develop in the future. While Zittrain’s beliefs might appear alarming to some readers, they do speak to several of the same issues that Ryman deals with in Air. Robert Berg
28
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
An Altered Light By Jens Christian Grøndahl
W Introduction Jens Christian Grøndahl’s An Altered Light begins as the story of a middle-aged divorce lawyer, Irene Beckman, whose husband Martin of over thirty years suddenly leaves her for a younger woman. In the first several chapters, the novel focuses on Irene’s reactions, on those of the couple’s grown children, and those of her mother Vivian in hospital facing hip replacement surgery. The fact that Vivian fears she may not survive the surgery leads her to entrust Irene with a journal written many years earlier, containing the secret of Irene’s paternity. Coupled with this revelation comes the subplot concerning publishing editor Thomas Hoppe, a man fifteen years Irene’s junior, with whom Irene had a brief affair a decade earlier. Thomas and his wife Susan are now seeking a divorce, and he too has become involved with a younger woman. The two plot lines concerning the aftermath of these current divorces leads into a third plot concerning Vivian and her first lover and Irene’s biological father, Samuel Balkin. Irene’s story is connected to European military history via her biological father and the story line connected to Thomas Hoppe and his second love interest, Tatiana. The surfacing story regarding Samuel Balkin begins in the late 1930s, when the Balkin family fled anti-Semitism in Leningrad and made their home in Copenhagen, where Samuel was a cellist, on the eve of World War II. With the Nazi occupation of Denmark and increasing threat to Jews in the country, the Balkins fled to Sweden, without knowing that Samuel had impregnated Vivian. The second connection to European history is through Thomas via the author Herbert Verhoeven, whose apartment Thomas uses for his trysts with Irene. In editing posthumously Verhoeven’s unfinished memoirs, Thomas meets and falls in love with the author’s protégée Tatiana. These papers taken together
with Tatiana’s own story report on how Herbert and Tatiana returned to Belgrade, the city of her birth, during the Balkan unrest and witnessed student protests against Slobodan Milosevic. Exploiting these political and national threads, Grøndahl shows how people living in Denmark were shaped by events that happened elsewhere in Europe. Grøndahl’s novel explores the idea of life paths and the way choice, timing, and military and political events conspire to determine people’s lives, creating the intersections in which relationships are forged or broken. In that everongoing process of meeting and separating, individuals face repeatedly the chance to say yes or no to the direction their lives are propelled to take. Jens Christian Grøndahl’s novel, written in Danish and published as Et andet lys in 2003, was translated by Anne Born into English and published as An Altered Light in 2004.
W Literary and Historical Context
The contemporary literary context for An Altered Light is much fiction written in the early 2000s that explores multiple points of view and the relativity of human experience. In the early 2000s, novelists as different as Annie Dillard, Rafael Yglesias, and Elena Ferrante set about to explore marital relationships from various perspectives, noting the subjectivity and relativity that determine how individuals define themselves and come to understand their relationships to others and the trajectories of their lives. The sense among many novelists in the twenty-first century is that reality is not single or constant. It is subjectively experienced and understood, and it is colored by more than external experiences, for dreams and daydreams also affect people’s experience and how they understand themselves. There is an assumption in the early 2000s that part of understanding the self
29 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
An Altered Light
MAJOR CHARACTERS IRENE BECKMAN, the protagonist and main point-of-view character, is a fifty-six-year-old divorce lawyer, married to a banker and mother of two grown children, Peter and Josephine. MARTIN BECKMAN, Irene’s husband of over thirty years, decides to leave his marriage and marry his mistress, Susanne, age thirty. PETER BECKMAN, brother of Josephine, is married to Sandra and has adopted fraternal twins, Emil and Amalie. SAMUEL BALKIN, a Russian Jew and former cellist, is the biological father of Irene Beckman, whom he meets in Ljubljana, Slovenia. SALLY HOPPE, married to Thomas Hoppe, faces his decision to get a divorce and seeks Irene’s legal advice. THOMAS HOPPE, married to Sally and with her the parent of son Magnus, seeks a divorce in order to marry Tatiana Pogorelic. TATIANA POGORELIC, born in Belgrade and protégée of author Herbert Verhoeven, falls in love with Thomas Hoppe when she seeks his editorial assessment of a manuscript Herbert left unfinished upon his death. VIVIAN, Irene’s mother, reveals that her first lover, Samuel Balkin, is actually Irene’s biological father.
requires facing the past that has directed a person to a certain place in the present and has shaped the evolving personality and values of that person. An Altered Light speaks to this awareness. The historical context for An Altered Light is virtually the history of Europe and the Middle East in the twentieth century. The earliest aspect of this context is the anti-Semitism enforced under Stalin in the USSR in the 1930s, with the closing of Yiddish schools and the removal of Jewish leaders, and the growth of Zionism among Russian Jews who set their sights increasingly on a nation state in Palestine. In the late 1930s, some Russian Jews immigrated to neutral Denmark, which had in 1939 signed a treaty of nonaggression with Germany. Nonetheless, Germany invaded Denmark in 1940, and the unprepared Danish government surrendered quickly. In its uneasy relationship with the German occupation, the Danish Parliament complied with some German orders but resisted others. It complied with German efforts to purge communists, but it resisted German efforts to identify the Jewish minority. By 1944, when news reached the Danes of the Nazi decision to purge Denmark of all its Jews, private citizens using motorboats
30
over a period of two months successfully transported most Danish Jews to safety in neutral Sweden. The Balkins in An Altered Light were likely among these Jews. The state of Israel was established in 1948 (Declaration of the Establishment), but conflict over boundaries and various wars scarred the area through the twentieth century and remained unresolved in the early 2000s. Another important historical context is the Yugoslav wars that stretched through the late 1990s and led to the breakup of Yugoslavia into separate nations. Also, included in the novel are references to the role of Slobodan Milosevic (1941-2006) as president of Yugoslavia and the demonstrations that forced his resignation in late 2000. Milosevic went on trial in The Hague on various charges and died there of a heart attack.
W Themes Repeatedly, Grøndahl refers to determining factors that impinge on individuals regarding their relationships or circumstances. His novel explores whether people are actually able to remain faithful to their response either way to a choice or decision and what factors make those responses more temporary than individuals making them assume. One instance in which he explores this idea occurs when Irene considers her mother’s journal in the light of a remembered photograph taken of Vivian in the spring 1944 when she is early in her pregnancy. This photograph reminds Irene of those of murdered people printed in newspapers. The victims “smile with the same trusting face, as if nothing bad can happen to them,” but with the knowledge of what has happened to them, the viewer does “violence to the expectant innocence shining in their eyes” (106). The point seems to be that retrospect allows a person to see in “an altered light” what in the ignorance of a past moment individuals cannot imagine as true for themselves. So people respond with a yes, for example, in their wedding ceremony, and yet in time that yes morphs to no, as they “lose their foothold” (117) in marriage and an unforeseen extramarital relationship ignites. The future forces at work in shaping these paths cannot be envisioned before their impact is experienced. This point is illustrated in the accident Irene has in which Thomas Hoppe on his bicycle collides with her car. If that accident had not occurred, she would never have met Thomas. The relationship they had ten years earlier is “only visible in the light of her past” (29). It leaps into view when her legal services are sought by Sally Hoppe who wrestles with the reality that Thomas is leaving her for another woman. People cannot help but reflect on the past in light of subsequent events; yet Irene, who looks back a lot, surprises herself when she remarks that “Looking back only gives you a stiff neck” (177). Doing so actually provides much more for Irene herself, especially regarding her meeting with the elderly Samuel Balkin. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
An Altered Light
W Style Grøndahl wrote An Altered Light in limited omniscient third-person point of view, using several point-of-view characters and three plotlines, which emerge piecemeal and not in chronological order. The thrust of the novel is from the present catalytic event (Martin Beckman’s dinnertime announcement that he is leaving the marriage) into the past as Irene traces the decisions and forces that determined the trajectory of events and brought key characters in her life to certain intersections in their lives. The tracing of these past events requires the information provided in Vivian’s early journal and the gleaning of information regarding the life of Samuel Balkin. Additionally, Irene unearths information about Herbert Verhoeven and Tatiana Pogorelic, since their relationship and Verhoeven’s death brings Tatiana face to face with Thomas and ultimately determines his decision to get a divorce. Other aspects of style in Grøndahl’s novel are dependent on Ann Born’s translation of the Danish into English. Though some awkwardness mars the translation, as in Born’s use of the cliché in “raise his nose from the grindstone” (17), the English seems faithful to Grøndahl’s rendering of perspective through the light
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Born November 9, 1959, in Lyngby, Denmark, Jens Christian Grøndahl produced seventeen books between 1985 and the early 2000s, four of which were translated into English. An Altered Light, the English translation of his novel Et andet lys, was short-listed for the 2006 International IMPAC Dublin Literary Award.
of certain moments. For example, when Irene watches “a ferryboat pass through the dewy, straw-yellow hemisphere of her wine glass” (164) and as she muses about how life “is ceaselessly altering, and there isn’t a place in the world where we belong” (270), only a “flowing beneath an awning between glinting spots of light on the calm surface of the water . . . shining with moist resin” (271). Grøndahl seems particularly interested in examining the factors that alter characters’ understanding of themselves and their circumstances. Their increased understanding alters the light in which they see themselves.
In An Altered Light, Irene’s biological father, Samuel Balkin, lived in Copenhagen, Denmark, during the 1930s to try to escape the antiSemitism in Russia. ª Jon Arnold Images Ltd / Alamy TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
31
An Altered Light
W Critical Reception Jens Christian Grøndahl’s An Altered Light was received favorably, though it appears not to have made a large splash. Joanne Wilkinson described it as “a penetrating examination of the shifting complexities of marriage.” Wilkinson also noted that the novel is “filled with philosophical ruminations and lyrical prose . . . [and] moves in unexpected directions and at its own measured pace.” Janet Evans agreed, describing the protagonist Irene Beckman as “introspective, philosophical, and psychological as she reflects on the years that passed all too swiftly.” Evans described Grøndahl as “one of Denmark’s most widely read contemporary authors” and explained that his experience as an essayist, playwright, and film director can be felt in this novel. Among more moderate evaluations was a reviewer in Publishers Weekly, who labeled the novel “a thoughtful, probing and fiercely introspective character study” but faulted it for “some pedestrian plotting.” The stronger part of the novel, according this Publishers Weekly review, is “the final narrative spin,” in which Irene searches for and meets Samuel Balkin. In all, this reviewer found that the best part of the novel is its “impressive insights about the unknowable nature of love and the partners we choose.” In the Kirkus Reviews best books of 2005 article, the reviewer praised Grøndahl for how he “coolly observes Irene’s slow transformation, and frames visual observations with painterly skill.” This article also quoted Grøndahl in commenting on what seemed to be a lackluster U.S. reception to the English translation: “I am confident that Americans . . . share my propensity for stopping in the middle of things,” Grøndahl is quoted as saying, “and looking back and thinking for a moment or two about how our lives are actually shaped. . . . In any case, I am glad to think of the unknown reader in, say, Idaho, who will eventually stumble upon a yellowed copy of a book of mine in the musty darkness of someone’s garage, and feel recognized.” It is this meditative, backward-glancing quality in An Altered Light that provides its distinction, and certain readers who encounter the novel may agree that it is just what they were looking for. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
“An Altered Light.” Rev. of An Altered Light, by Jens Christian Grøndahl. Publishers Weekly 31 Jan. 2005: 46. Declaration of Establishment of State of Israel, 14 May 1948. www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Peace+Process. Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs, 14 May 1948. Web. 18 Oct. 2010.
Grøndahl, Jens Christian. An Altered Light. Trans. Anne Born. Orlando: Harcourt, 2004. Print. “Grøndahl, Jens Christian: An Altered Light.” Rev. of An Altered Light, by Jens Christian Grøndahl. Kirkus Reviews, 15 Jan. 2005: 72. Print. “We at Kirkus Reviews Are Delighted to Present the Best Books of 2005.” Rev. of An Altered Light, by Jens Christian Grøndahl. Kirkus Reviews, 15 Dec. 2005: S3+. Print. Wilkinson, Joanne. “Grøndahl, Jens Christian. An Altered Light.” Rev. of An Altered Light, by Jens Christian Grøndahl. Booklist, 1 Mar. 2005: 1137. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Battersby, Eileen. “Strong Chance of First Irish Winner for Literary Award.” Irish Times, 6 Apr. 2006. Print. Sees Grøndahl’s novel not as a winner but as strong nonetheless and likely to find a wide audience. For Further Reading
Andreb, Hans-Jurgen. When Marriage Ends: Economic and Social Consequences of Partnership Dissolution. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, 2009. Print. Scholarly essays on divorce matters in European countries, including Denmark, Sweden, and Norway. Dillard, Annie. The Maytrees. New York: HarperCollins, 2007. Print. Tells the story of a marriage, a divorce, and in after years an unusual reconciliation. Ferrante, Elena. Days of Abandonment. Trans. Ann Goldstein. New York: Europa Editions, 2005. Print. Tells the story of a married woman, abandoned by her husband, who goes through a painful adjustment. Grøndahl, Jens Christian. Silence in October. Trans. Anne Born. Orlando: Harcourt, 2000. Print. Plays with the same ideas as those in An Altered Light, but from the perspective of the husband who is left by his wife. Kostyrchenko, Gennadi. Out of the Red Shadows: AntiSemitism in Stalin’s Russia (Russian Studies). New York: Prometheus Books, 1995. Print. Relies on declassified documents in the archives of the Central Committee of the Communist Party and the KGB to document the suppression of Jewish culture and removal of Jews from public roles. Yglesias, Rafael. A Happy Marriage. New York: Simon & Schuster, 2009. Print. Autobiographical novel depicting how two people are shaped by a long-term marriage and how the husband copes with the untimely death of his wife. Melodie Monahan
Evans, Janet. “Grøndahl, Jens Christian. An Altered Light.” Rev. of An Altered Light, by Jens Christian Grøndahl. Library Journal 15 Mar. 2005: 70+. Print.
32
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay By Michael Chabon
W Introduction The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay (2000), by Michael Chabon, follows the wild and difficult success of cousins Joe Kavalier and Sam Clay who find themselves as central figures in the Golden Age of comics with their creation, the Escapist. They are living in New York City in the 1940s, just before the United States enters World War II. At the same time, Joe’s family in Prague is under threat from the Nazis—and nothing Sam or Joe can do and no amount of money or creativity can save them. Joe eventually flees from his friends and family to enlist in the navy for a chance to pound out his frustration and anger on real enemies. Long after the war has ended, he returns to New York City, ashamed and estranged, and finds redemption and no more need of escape. The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay won the 2001 Pulitzer Prize for fiction and was followed in 2004 through 2006 with a comic book featuring the Escapist. Titled Michael Chabon Presents . . . the Amazing Adventures of the Escapist, the eight-issue series was published by Dark Horse Comics and won a prestigious 2005 Eisner Award for best anthology.
W Literary and Historical Context
The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay was published at a time when superheroes were making a comeback in both film and print. Batman, directed by Tim Burton, was released in 1989, kick-starting the revival interest in superheroes. Television shows such as Lois & Clark: The New Adventures of Superman (19931997) and Buffy the Vampire Slayer (1997-2003) secured teenage audiences and carried them through to the blockbuster film hits of the early twenty-first century,
including Mystery Men (1999), X-Men (2000), Unbreakable (2000), Spider-Man (2002), Spider-Man 2 (2004; for which Chabon was a screenwriter), The Incredibles (2004), Batman Begins (2005), Hancock (2008), Iron Man (2008), and Watchmen (2009). Anime, or animated Japanese shows and films, became popular in the United States during the 1990s, making way later in the decade for the print medium of manga, a form of Japanese comic. Anime and manga are not exclusively composed of stories about superheroes, but there is a strong association between these forms and heroes. Early manga titles that crossed over into the U.S. market and became popular included Sailor Moon and Ghost in the Shell. The 1986-1987 comic Watchmen, by Alan Moore (illustrated by Dave Gibbons), is a thoughtprovoking work that explores new visual layouts and ways of interpreting superheroes. Watchmen won a Hugo Award in 1988. Art Spiegelman’s Maus (published in two parts, 1986 and 1991) also took the comic book genre in new directions. This graphic novel, with the Jews drawn as mice and the Nazis as cats, is based on the actual survival of the Holocaust by the author’s father. Maus won a Pulitzer Prize in 1992. Following a decade of relative peace in the United States, the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks and the subsequent military action in Afghanistan and Iraq made heroism fashionable, even necessary to fill the ranks. As the conflicts in Afghanistan and Iraq neared a decade in length, the superhero genre of film, television, and print continued to be strong. Like the golem of Jewish folklore, superheroes gave people hope—however fantastic—that terrible enemies and impossible odds could be overcome.
W Themes Courage, in a book about comics and superheroes, is an easy theme to point toward, but Chabon’s novel dwells very little on the courage of the Escapist except to draw his magnificent feats in broad strokes. Instead, the
33 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay
MAJOR CHARACTERS SHELDON ANAPOL, a shrewd businessman, is the owner of Empire Comics. TRACY BACON is an exuberant and fun-loving man and Sam’s lover. SAM CLAY is a shy, quiet Jewish boy from Brooklyn and Joe’s American cousin. TOMMY CLAY is the son of Rosa and Joe, named for Joe’s brother Thomas who died during World War II. CARL HENRY EBLING is a mentally unstable Nazi sympathizer. LONGMAN HARKOO, Rosa’s father, is an eccentric, wellconnected, wealthy surrealist-art dealer. JOE KAVALIER is the protagonist, a clever artist and illusionist who flees Nazi-occupied Prague to live with his cousin Sam in New York City. ETHEL KLAYMAN, Sam’s mother and Joe’s aunt, is a practical woman who reluctantly supports the artistic pursuits of her son and nephew. BERNARD KORNBLUM, a retired illusionist, teaches his escape tricks to a teenaged Joe in Prague. ROSA LUXEMBURG SAKS, a bold, resourceful, and sensitive young woman, is Joe’s true love and muse.
author, through the actions of Joe, Sam, Rosa, Tracy, and others, examines the nature of courage in everyday lives. The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay is not simply a book about superheroes and their creators. It describes the courage of those unafraid to be themselves, such as Longman Harkoo and Tracy Bacon; to the courage of those who would put themselves in danger to help others, such as Bernard Kornblum; and the courage of those who continue to live when so much has been lost, like Joe. Survival also figures strongly in The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay, stemming from—but not limited to—its immigrant, post-Holocaust perspective. Some feats of survival are strictly physical, and these are the specialty of Joe and Bernard Kornblum, trained illusionists. Other feats of survival are emotional, such as Sam’s coming to terms with his homosexuality and Rosa’s having Joe’s baby after he has abandoned her. Moreover, the two cousins negotiate and survive the cut-throat world of comic book publishing. Survival in and of itself is not always a boon; it can also be a burden. For example, Holocaust survivors mourn the people and places they had to leave behind. Their survival can seem to have happened by chance and, therefore, feel meaningless. Chabon’s novel brings all these threads together, concluding that the purpose of survival is concerned with
34
the future (i.e., Joe and Rosa’s son Tommy) and not about the past (Joe’s brother Thomas).
W Style The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay traces the growth of Joe Kavalier and Sam Clay from childhood to adulthood. One of the literary techniques that Chabon uses to mark the growth of his characters over the course of the novel is tone. Tone is the mood of a work. The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay starts with a tone of mischievousness, when Joe is still in Prague, then turns more serious when he arrives in New York City and begins to collaborate with Sam. The middle section of the novel, during Joe and Sam’s young adulthood, is both joyous and dangerous as they each fall in love, create marvelous works, and run up against hard realities. The tone of the novel changes dramatically to grim and unhappy when Thomas dies and Joe leaves Rosa and Sam to enlist in the military. Fear and confusion turn to joy at the end when Rosa and Joe are reunited and Sam finally decides to live the life he’s always wanted. Foreshadowing is a technique that Chabon uses to hint at future events, heighten drama, and make events seem more plausible when they do occur. Joe and Thomas nearly die by drowning in the River Moldau, foreshadowing Thomas’s death by drowning six years later. Joe has unaccountably good luck and is continually escaping implausible situations, foreshadowing his survival of Ebling’s terrorist attack, carbon monoxide poisoning at the Kelvinator Station, and jumping from the Empire State Building. Foreshadowing causes the reader to anticipate what is to come without the reader knowing for sure how events will transpire.
W Critical Reception Many critics considered The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay to be the novel that marked Chabon’s maturity as a writer. David Horspool, one such critic, wrote in the Times Literary Supplement that this novel was “proof of the abiding power of complex, serious, engaged, but above all entertaining story-telling.” The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay won the 2001 Pulitzer Prize for fiction, inevitably bringing it under close critical scrutiny. While reviews were generally positive and critics, such as Jonathan Levi of the Los Angeles Times Book Review, were enamored with Chabon’s lyrical prose, not all were unequivocally won over. John Podhoretz, in a detailed review for Commentary, concluded that “this extraordinarily ambitious novel does not have all that much of interest to say.” Amy Benfer, in her Salon review, concurred with Podhoretz on some points but ultimately found that Chabon has succeeded in his approach: “It would seem like a guilty gorgefest, a sugary pop concoction, if, like pop art itself, it TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay
weren’t so heavily fortified with all the vitamins and minerals of true art.” Writing for the New York Times, Ken Kalfus disagrees with Podhoretz’s disappointment: “the depth of Chabon’s thought, his sharp language, his inventiveness and his ambition make this a novel of towering achievement.” Popular with readers as well, Kavalier & Clay was a strong seller at bookstores and continued Chabon’s ascent as a major twenty-first century writer.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Chabon, Michael. The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay. New York: Picador, 2000. Print.
Born in Washington, D.C., on May 24, 1963, Michael Chabon knew he wanted to be a writer from a young age. His first novel, Mysteries of Pittsburgh, was published in 1998 and brought Chabon both popular and critical success; it was made into a movie in 2008. His second novel, Wonder Boys (1995), was also captured on film, in 2000. Chabon’s literary success continued with The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay (2000), which won the 2001 Pulitzer Prize for fiction. Summerland (2002), The Final Solution (2004), The Yiddish Policemen’s Union (2007), and Gentlemen of the Road (2007) followed, with The Yiddish Policemen’s Union winning the Hugo Award in 2008. As of 2010, Chabon lived in Berkeley, California, with his wife Ayelet Waldman and their four children.
Harspool, David. “Sam and Joe Take on the Nazis.” Rev. of The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay, by Michael Chabon. Times Literary Supplement 6 Oct. 2000: 24. Print.
NYTimes.com. New York Times, 24 Sept. 2000. Web. 18 July 2010.
Kalfus, Ken. “The Golem Knows.” Rev. of The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay, by Michael Chabon.
Levi, Jonathan. “Hope against Hope.” Rev. of The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay, by Michael
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Benfer, Amy. Rev. of The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay, by Michael Chabon. Salon.com. Salon, 28 Sept. 2000. Web. 18 July 2010.
A man takes in the view from the top of the Empire State Building in New York City, the hometown of comic book creators Joe Kavalier and Sam Clay in The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay. ª DaZo Vintage Stock Photos/Images.com/Corbis
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
35
The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay
Michael Chabon, author of The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay, at the 2010 New Yorker Festival. Neilson Barnard/Getty Images for The New Yorker
Chabon. Los Angeles Times Book Review 8 Oct. 2000: 2. Print. Podhoretz, John. Rev. of The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay, by Michael Chabon. Commentary 111.6 (2001): 68. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Behlman, Lee. “The Escapist: Fantasy, Folklore, and the Pleasures of the Comic Book in Recent Jewish American Holocaust Fiction.” Shofar 22.3 (2004): 56-71. Print. Compares Chabon’s novel with works by Jonathan Safran Foer and Nathan Englander, regarding their treatments of fantasy and reality in writing about the Holocaust. Dirda, Michael. “Review of The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay.” Rev. of The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay, by Michael Chabon. Washington Post Book World (17 Sept. 2000): 15. Print. Praises Chabon’s sprawling narrative, including its cameos of historical figures, varied settings, and relentless theme of escapism. Maslin, Janet. “A Life and Death Story Set in Comic Book Land.” Rev. of The Amazing Adventures of
36
Kavalier & Clay, by Michael Chabon. NYTimes.com. New York Times, 21 Sept. 2000. Web. 20 July 2010. Describes the carefully crafted tension between the wild successes of the two comic-book-writing cousins and the grim struggles of their family in Europe. Punday, Daniel. “Kavalier & Clay, the Comic-Book Novel, and Authorship in a Corporate World.” CRITIQUE 49.3 (2008): 291-302. Print. Discusses Chabon’s novel in the context of economics to come to a better understanding of how the relationship between comic book authors and illustrators and their publishers affect the originality of the work. Sullivan, James. “The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier and Clay: A Novel.” Rev. of The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay, by Michael Chabon. Book Nov. 2000: 66. Print. Commends Chabon’s treatment of creativity and redemption. Gale Resources
Meanor, Patrick. “Michael Chabon.” American Novelists since World War II: Seventh Series. Ed. James R. Giles and Wanda H. Giles. Detroit: Gale, 2003. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 278. Literature Resource Center. Web. 8 July 2010. http://go.galegroup.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay
com/ps/i.do?&id=GALE%7CH1200011233& v=2.1&u=itsbtrial&it=r&p=LitRC&sw=w “Michael Chabon.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2010. Literature Resource Center. Web. 8 July 2010. http://go.galegroup.com/ps/ i.do?&id=GALE%7CH1000016823&v=2.1& u=itsbtrial&it=r&p=LitRC&sw=w “Overview: The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay.” Novels for Students. Ed. Ira Mark Milne. Vol. 25. Detroit: Gale, 2007. Literature Resource Center. Web. 8 July 2010. http://go.galegroup.com/ps/i. do?&id=GALE%7CH1430006436& v=2.1&u=itsbtrial&it=r&p=LitRC&sw=w Open Web Sources
Michael Chabon’s official Web site provides information on current projects as well as photographs of the author and free samples of his essays and fiction. http://www.michaelchabon.com The Amazing Web site of Kavalier & Clay is a fan site that collects information about the novel, reviews and criticism, Chabon and his other works, the history behind the novel, and other media related to the book. The owner of the site, Nate Raymond, also maintains a blog providing up-to-date news about Chabon. http://www.sugarbombs.com/ kavalier
For Further Reading
Chabon, Michael. The Yiddish Policemen’s Union. New York: HarperCollins, 2007. Print. Presents an alternative history about a present-day fictional settlement of Jewish people in Alaska following the demise of the nascent state of Israel during World War II. Chabon, Michael, et al. Michael Chabon Presents . . . The Amazing Adventures of the Escapist. Vols. 1-3. Milwaukie: Dark Horse Comics, 2004-2006. Print. Presents the three graphic novels depicting the adventures of the Escapist, Luna Moth, the Machine Gun, and more. Doctorow, E. L. Ragtime. New York: Random House, 2007. Print. First published in 1975, this novel is a groundbreaking work of historical fiction that blends fictional characters with historical figures, telling a story that is uniquely American. McCloud, Scott. Understanding Comics: The Invisible Art. New York: Harper, 1994. Print. Presents work of respected theorist on comics in art and communication, told in black-and-white comic book style. Spiegelman, Art. Maus: A Survivor’s Tale. New York: Pantheon, 1996. Print. Recounts Holocaust survival of Spiegelman’s father in graphic novel format.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Carol Ullmann
37
American Gods By Neil Gaiman
W Introduction Neil Gaiman’s novel American Gods is a melting pot of mythology, deftly weaving together modern incarnations of deities as far reaching as India’s Kali, Africa’s Anansi, the Germanic Easter, Egypt’s Thoth and Anubis, and the Algonquin Wisakedjak. Shadow, the protagonist, is pulled into the action of a mounting war between the old gods, who have immigrated to the United States and are slowly being forgotten, and the new gods of technology, who grow in strength and worshippers daily. In this novel, Gaiman explores issues of faith, truth, and identity while referring to Norse and Christian myths in the resolution of Shadow’s journey. American Gods won the 2002 Hugo Award, Nebula Award, and Bram Stoker Award and was a finalist for the 2002 World Fantasy Award. Although it was not a mainstream critical hit for a writer best known for his short stories and graphic novels, the novel was popular among fans of Gaiman and of the genres of science fiction, fantasy, and horror. Gaiman followed up American Gods with Anansi Boys (2005), a novel about Mr. Nancy’s two very different sons. Anansi Boys found more immediate commercial and critical success, perhaps due to the quiet popularity of American Gods.
W Literary and Historical Context
Religion became a political issue in the United States beginning in the late twentieth century, when the Christian Right, a movement that sought social conservatism through political change, began to take hold in Washington, D.C. Evangelical pastor Jerry Falwell founded the Moral Majority group in 1979, which had significant influence on the formation of the New
Christian Right and national politics in the 1980s. Through the campaign work of the New Christian Right, the Republican Party was able to claim control of the U.S. legislative, judicial, and executive branches during the 1980s and 1990s. The change in political activity toward social and religious conservatism was not reflected in the makeup of U.S. citizens and is largely a factor of media spin and political control. The Pew Research Center, as reported in a 2008 press release by Juliana Horowitz, found that between 1992 and 2008, the percentages of people who self-identified as liberal (18-21%), moderate (36-38%), and conservative (36-38%) did not change significantly. According to statistics released by the American Religious Identification Survey, the numbers of people selfidentifying as Evangelical Christian tripled from 1990 to 2008, but the raw numbers represent a very small fraction of the overall U.S. population (0.3 to 0.9% of the population). In the same period, Christian membership dropped by 10 percent and those identifying as having no religion rose by almost 7 percent. Both diversity and constant movement characterized the religious makeup of the United States, according to the Pew Forum on Religion and Public Life in June 2008. In a February 2008 report, Pew found that 92 percent of Americans believe in “God or a universal spirit” (5) and 56 percent say that religion is important in their lives.
W Themes “This is not a land for gods” (245) is the underlying premise of American Gods. As people immigrated to North America, incarnations of the deities they worshipped followed them and settled down in this new land, only to find themselves over time weak and nearly forgotten. Thus faith is a central theme in American Gods. Belief is what empowers the gods, but in the United States, a young nation driven by industry and settled by people looking to make a new life, faith in the old gods
38 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
American Gods
MAJOR CHARACTERS SAMANTHA BLACK CROW is a young woman Shadow befriends during his travels. CZERNOBOG, whose name translates as “black god,” is a Slavic deity who is a close ally to Mr. Wednesday. FAT KID is a modern god of computers, the Internet, and technology. MR. IBIS is the Egyptian god Thoth, arbitrator and inventor of writing. He works in a funeral parlor with Mr. Jacquel in Cairo, Illinois. MR. JACQUEL is the Egyptian god Anubis, who prepares and guides the dead to the Underworld. He works in a funeral parlor with Mr. Ibis in Cairo, Illinois. LOW KEY LYESMITH is Loki, trickster god of the Norse pantheon. He is Shadow’s prison cell mate. An Egyptian ankh. American Gods, a spiritual thriller, is riddled with religious myths and symbols. hao liang/Shutterstock.com
LAURA MOON, Shadow’s wife, is reanimated from the dead after Shadow drops a special coin in her grave. She helps Shadow throughout the book. MR. NANCY, also known as Anansi, is a trickster god who sides with Mr. Wednesday. SHADOW, the protagonist of the novel, is a large, quiet man, thirty-two years old, who is drawn into a war between gods. At the end of the novel, he is thought to be Balder, a god of the Norse pantheon, or perhaps Jesus. MR. WEDNESDAY is a modern incarnation of Odin and father of Shadow. MISTER WORLD is the main antagonist of the novel. He has Mr. Wednesday killed during a truce meeting. THE ZORYA is a triplicate deity who represents the Morning Star, the Evening Star, and the Midnight Star. In the novel, the triplicates live with Czernobog and help Shadow.
A spiritual Egyptian statue. In American Gods, a coming battle between the ancient gods and the modern gods looms in the distance. Ralf Juergen Kraft/Shutterstock.com
has fallen to the wayside. By contrast, Shadow observes that humans do not need the faith of other people to continue to exist, loosely declaring humans to be agents with free will, whereas the gods are prisoners of their own constituents. Trickery and the nature of truth constitute another important theme in American Gods. Many gods from pantheons around the world are associated with trickery, truth-telling, fortunes, misdirection, and wisdom. Low Key Lyesmith and Mr. Nancy are incarnations of trickster gods; Mr. Wednesday is representative of Odin, known as a god of wisdom in the Norse pantheon. In this novel, Mr. Wednesday is a grafter (one who plays confidence tricks). The central plot of the story concerns a confidence scheme on the part of Mr. Wednesday and Low Key Lyesmith. Shadow, who is an honest man, is not
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
39
American Gods
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Neil Gaiman was born in Portchester, England, in 1960. A voracious reader as a child, Gaiman left school in 1977 and, after collecting rejections for his short stories, began working as a freelance journalist. He returned to fiction in the mid1980s by writing for comic books, a medium he had loved for a long time. Gaiman took up retired DC Comics character the Sandman and, beginning in 1988, produced DC’s best-selling and award-winning series, The Sandman. American Gods was published in 2001. In 2002 American Gods won three major awards for works of science fiction, fantasy, and horror. Gaiman also won the prestigious 2009 Newbery Medal and the 2010 Carnegie Medal for the young adult novel The Graveyard Book (2008). In 1985 Gaiman married Mary McGrath and they have three children together; they divorced in 2008. Gaiman lives near Minneapolis, Minnesota.
as easy to trick as they assume. Through Shadow’s character and his success against Mr. Wednesday, Gaiman underlines the importance and power of truth. Wisdom is hard to come by: Shadow must hang upon a tree for nine days, die, and be revived in order to understand the advantage of being human.
W Style The setting of a work is the time and place in which the action takes place. Gaiman purposefully chose the United States in the late twentieth century for the setting of his novel American Gods. The United States is a relatively young country, just over two hundred years old at the time of this publication, populated largely by immigrants from around the world. The author sets this nation apart from all others because the incarnations of the deities that the immigrants brought with them have not fared well as the attention of their believers has drifted. The popularity of technology in the United States is another element that plays into Gaiman’s choice of this country for the setting; as mortals put their faith in cell phones, computers, the Internet, and the media, new gods arise to represent these elements of technology.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Rev. of American Gods, by Neil Gaiman. Publishers Weekly 28 May 2001: 46. Print. Bolonik, Kera. “Review of American Gods.” Rev. of American Gods, by Neil Gaiman. New York Times Book Review, 29 July 2001: 16. Print. De Lint, Charles. “American Gods.” Rev. of American Gods, by Neil Gaiman. Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction 101.3 (2001): 97-98. Print. Gaiman, Neil. American Gods. New York: HarperTorch, 2001. Print. Horowitz, Juliana. “Winds of Political Change Haven’t Shifted Public’s Ideology Balance.” pewresearch.org. Pew Research Center Publications, 25 Nov. 2008. Web. 22 Aug. 2010. Kim, Ann. Rev. of American Gods, by Neil Gaiman. Library Journal 15 June 2001: 102. Print. Kosmin, Barry, and Ariela Keysar. American Religious Identification Survey (ARIS) 2008. trincoll.edu. Trinity College, Mar. 2009. Web. 22 Aug. 2010. Olson, Ray. Rev. of American Gods, by Neil Gaiman. Booklist 15 May 2001: 1707. Print.
W Critical Reception Gaiman was best known for his work in the graphic novel industry, especially the multiple-award-winning series The Sandman, when American Gods was published in 2001. The novel received limited critical attention. Mainstream reviewers generally gave the novel a lukewarm reception, with Ray Olson of Booklist summarizing American Gods as “a tale that is just too busy and . . . unengaging.” Publishers Weekly called the plot “aimless” but predicted
40
that it would do well among Gaiman’s fans. Ann Kim of Library Journal, by contrast, found the novel “compellingly imaginative,” declaring “the fascinating subject matter and impressive mythic scope are handled creatively and expertly.” Kera Bolonik agreed. Gaiman “has a deft hand with the mythologies he tinkers with here; even better, he’s a fine, droll storyteller,” wrote Bolonik, reviewing for the New York Times Book Review. Charles de Lint, a respected fantasy author in his own right, reviewed the novel for the Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction and, true to Publishers Weekly’s forecast, gave the novel a good review, concluding that it would be a big hit for the year. He declared American Gods to be “a big, sprawling book that seems to take forever to get to its point, but what a wonderful journey it is to get there.” American Gods swept the genre fiction awards in 2002, taking home the Hugo, the Nebula, and the Bram Stoker awards. It was also nominated for the World Fantasy, British Fantasy, and Mythopoeic awards in 2002.
U.S. Religious Landscape Survey: Religious Affiliation— Diverse and Dynamic. pewforum.org. Pew Forum on Religion and Public Life, Feb. 2008. Web. 22 Aug. 2010. U.S. Religious Landscape Survey: Religious Beliefs and Practices: Diverse and Politically Relevant. pewforum. org. Pew Forum on Religion and Public Life, June 2008. Web. 22 Aug. 2010. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
American Gods Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Dalgleish, David. “Mythologizing America.” Rev. of American Gods, by Neil Gaiman. januarymagazine. com. January Magazine, July 2001. Web. 22 Aug. 2010. Gives a positive review of Gaiman’s novel, hailing it as his most ambitious since The Sandman. DuMond, Lisa. Rev. of American Gods, by Neil Gaiman. sfsite.com. SF Site, 2001. Web. 22 Aug. 2010. Celebrates Gaiman as a strong horror writer and predicts many award wins for this novel. Jensen, Jeff. “American Gods.” Rev. of American Gods, by Neil Gaiman. Entertainment Weekly 604 (13 July 2001): 75-76. Print. Offers a good review but criticizes Gaiman for an anticlimactic ending. Miller, Laura. Rev. of American Gods, by Neil Gaiman. salon.com. Salon, 22 Jun. 2001. Web. 22 Aug. 2010. Detailed positive review, faults Gaiman only for not including Jesus and the Greek deities. Slabbert, Mathilda, and Leonie Viljoen. “Sustaining the Imaginative Life: Mythology and Fantasy in Neil Gaiman’s American Gods.” Literator 27.3 (2006): 135-55. Examines the use of myth to connect readers to spirituality. Gale Resources
“Neil Gaiman.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2010. Literature Resource Center. Web. 22 Aug. 2010. http://go.galegroup.com/ps/i.do? &id=GALE%7CH1000034859&v=2.1&u =aadl&it=r&p=LitRC&sw=w Sanders, Joe. “Neil (Richard) Gaiman.” British Fantasy and Science-Fiction Writers since 1960. Ed. Darren Harris-Fain. Detroit: Gale, 2002. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 261. Literature Resource Center. Web. 22 Aug. 2010. http://go.galegroup. com/ps/i.do?&id=GALE%7CH1200010793 &v=2.1&u=aadl&it=r&p=LitRC&sw=w
in 2001. He enjoyed the experience of blogging so much that he developed the journal into a full-blown Web site featuring a biography, information about his novels, a message board, links to Web sites associated with Gaiman’s work, full-text short stories, and other extras—in addition to the journal that started it all. The full-text of the first chapter of American Gods, along with excerpts from his other books, can be found at http://www.neilgaiman.com HarperCollins, publisher of American Gods, has made the first one hundred pages available to read online free of charge at http://www.harpercollins.com/browsein side/index.aspx?isbn13=9780380789030 For Further Reading
Gaiman, Neil. Anansi Boys. New York: William Morrow, 2005. Print. Takes the character of Mr. Nancy (Anansi) from American Gods and tells the story of his two very different sons. Herodotus. The Histories. Trans. Aubery de Selincourt. New York: Penguin, 2003. Print. Travelogue and examination of the places Herodotus visited in his fifth century BCE travels; inspiring to Shadow in American Gods. James, John. Votan. London: Bantam, 1987. Print. Tells a story of a young Greek man who travels to Germany during the late Roman period, adventures that form the basis for Odin’s mythology. Jones, Diana Wynne. Eight Days of Luke. New York: Random House, 1990. Print. Story about a boy who inadvertently releases Loki from prison, instigating a battle between the gods. Riordan, Rick. The Lightning Thief. New York: Hyperion, 2005. Print. Story about a boy who learns he is the son of Poseidon and embarks on a quest to find Zeus’s lightning bolt. Willis, Roy, ed. World Mythology. New York: Holt, 1993. Print. A lavishly illustrated general introduction to the myths of nineteen cultures from around the world.
Open Web Sources
Carol Ullmann
Gaiman began an online journal, or blog, as part of the promotion of American Gods when it was published
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
41
Anil’s Ghost By Michael Ondaatje
W Introduction
W Literary and Historical
Anil’s Ghost (2000) is a work of historical crime fiction set against the backdrop of civil war and insurrection in 1980s Sri Lanka. The book received the Giller Prize, the Kiriyama Pacific Rim Book Prize, and the Governor General’s Award for English Language Fiction. The novel is divided into eight subsections, each one focusing tightly on the character or subject referred to in the title of that particular section. The narrative of the novel unfolds through this series of close examinations, and uses the main characters’ experiences to recount the events of the plot and to paint a vivid picture of a country torn apart by civil war, government-sanctioned murder, and secrecy. Anil, the protagonist, drives the story both narratively and thematically. Native to Sri Lanka, but educated in the West, Anil is uniquely suited to reflect the contrasts between East and West and the tensions between the two with regard to cultural outlook and the place and “definition” of truth in society. Michael Ondaatje uses this character as a lens to examine both the history of the Sri Lankan civil war and the international reaction of human rights organizations to this conflict. In the novel, Anil, a forensic pathologist, has returned to Sri Lanka as part of a human rights fact-finding mission. Anil and Sarath Diyasena, an archaeologist, discover evidence that suggests an unknown victim, nicknamed Sailor by the two investigators, has been murdered by government forces. As Anil digs further and further into this investigation she places herself in grave danger, and the novel builds to a suspenseful climax as layer upon layer of Sri Lanka’s interconnected turmoil is revealed.
Context
The Sri Lankan civil war began with “the advent of serious revolutionary disorder in 1983” (Matthews). The government faced intermittent insurgency by the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam, also known as the LTTE or the Tamil Tigers. The root of the insurgency was caused by ethnic tension between the Sinhalese and Tamil communities. The aim of the LTTE was the formation of a separate Tamil state in the northern part of Sri Lanka. Proscribed as a terrorist group by 32 countries, the LTTE allegedly employed tactics which included threatening or attacking civilians, ethnic cleansing, suicide bombings, and/or the recruitment and use of child soldiers (Bhattacharji). However, in opposing the LTTE, the Sri Lankan government has also been accused of extrajudicial killings, abductions, extortion, conscription, and the use of child soldiers (Bhattacharji). The war officially ended in May 2009 with the Sri Lankan government victorious. Anil’s Ghost was published in 2000, nine years before the official end of the war. The perspective of the novel is particularly useful for a number of reasons. The book provides an array of characters through which to view both the events of the Sri Lankan civil war and the differing value placed on the “truth” regarding certain incidents, and the differing versions of truth ascribed to certain events by Eastern and Western cultures. This offering of multiple perspectives enables the novel to be more accessible to readers from either hemisphere. Michael Ondaatje, while born in Sri Lanka, was educated in the West, much like his lead character, Anil. The official end of the war provides a new context for Anil’s Ghost, but it remains to be seen if the root causes of the war have been successfully dealt with or not.
42 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Anil’s Ghost
W Themes The war, and its effects on the people of Sri Lanka, is a major theme within the book. The civil war, and a string of human rights violations arising out of the war, prompts Anil’s return to Sri Lanka as she devotes herself to discovering the truth about what is happening in her former home. Some, like Gamini, barricade themselves off from the world. As Margaret Scanlan notes: “Gamini is visibly traumatized by war . . . [and] survives by immersing himself in his work.” Palipana, Sarath’s mentor, goes even further and withdraws from society altogether, choosing to live as a hermit. Others, like Sarath’s wife and Ananda, attempt to escape through suicide. The effects of the war are felt everywhere in Sri Lanka. Other major themes of Anil’s Ghost revolve around the concepts of truth and secrets. Anil comes to Sri Lanka in search of the truth. With Sarath’s help, she uncovers a number of hidden, buried, or obscured things, some hidden more thoroughly than others. However, Sarath himself remains largely an enigma, and Anil is never quite sure of his true nature. She remains unsure until the conclusion of the novel, when Sarath finally reveals himself through the actions he takes to save Anil and her research. Palipana, Sarath’s mentor, serves as another key element in examining the theme of truth. Lisa Pace Vetter explains that “for Palipana, the truth is not simply irrelevant or merely fabricated. Rather, truth must be understood as extended through time and composed of many different elements, objective and subjective.” This conclusion stems from a discussion Palipana holds with the novel’s protagonist, Anil.
W Style Ondaatje’s writing in the novel has been described by Publishers Weekly as “cryptic, elliptical.” This description stems, in part, from the postmodern style in which the book is written. As Chelva Kanaganayakam notes, this elliptical or fragmentary style is a literary device “that postmodern novelists use in order to move away from traditional linear narratives.” Anil’s Ghost exemplifies this “deliberately fragmentary style.” Scanlan further argues that Ondaatje’s “distinctive achievement in Anil’s Ghost is to create a narrative structure that replicates the experience of terror.” The disjointed scenes mirror the fragmentary nature of life as experienced by those caught in the war. Snapshot memories of horror are the primary recollections that stand out in the linear timeline surrounding the civil war. The structure of the novel, as well as the prose used within, help to shape the effect of the narrative on the reader. Anil’s Ghost is divided into eight subsections. This is one key structural component that contributes to the
MAJOR CHARACTERS ANANDA, a wreck of a man, driven to drink by the loss of his wife. At one time, he was a renowned painter and sculptor, partaking in the traditional eye-painting ceremony which gives life to statues, most notably figures of the Buddha. Ananda is enlisted by Anil and Sarath to re-create Sailor’s face. After he completes his work, Ananda attempts to kill himself by slashing his own throat. He is rescued by Anil and Sarath. SARATH DIYASENA, an archaeologist, is a Sri Lankan official who works closely with Anil to investigate the murders. Often aloof and of unknown political affiliation, Sarath provides Anil with an invaluable link to Sri Lanka. His connections provide access to the people, places, and things needed to complete their investigation. Sarath frequently challenges Anil’s assumptions, most notably in terms of what role truth plays in government and in life. GAMINI is Sarath’s younger brother and a doctor who works tirelessly on the never-ending stream of war victims. Gamini grew up in Sarath’s shadow, is addicted to speed, and was once in love with Sarath’s wife. Gamini helps Anil and Sarath save the life of Gunasena, a man they found nailed to the road as they traveled. Also known as “the Mouse,” Gamini’s perspective frequently provides a medical professional’s point of view. SAILOR is the name given to the skeleton of the unknown victim found by Anil and Sarath. Sailor proves to be a key to Anil’s human rights investigation in Sri Lanka. Discovering who he was and what happened to him becomes the main focus of the novel. ANIL TISSERA is a young woman who works as a forensic pathologist. She was born in Sri Lanka but left the country to pursue her higher education in the West. She returns to conduct a human rights investigation into various murders connected with the Sri Lankan civil war. The novel makes significant references to Anil’s past life in America, as well as her current activities in Sri Lanka.
elliptical or postmodern style of the novel. Each subsection is given its own thematically significant title: in some instances the name of one of the characters; in other cases a more interpretive or thematic nomenclature are used. For example, the subsection titled “The Mouse” refers to, and is written from, the perspective of Gamini. This allows the novel to retain islands of discrete, narrative structure, while simultaneously abandoning the linear format. Italicized anecdotes and narrative snapshots appear throughout Anil’s Ghost. Many are written from a firstperson perspective, increasing their immediacy. Some address past events, or allow the reader to glimpse
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
43
Anil’s Ghost
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Michael Ondaatje is a Canadian author and poet. Born in Sri Lanka in 1942, Ondaatje is perhaps best known for his novel The English Patient. Ondaatje’s personal narrative style involves weaving together a narrative from various disparate scenes or “threads.” These threads, while not always aligned in strict causal or temporal order, link together (often thematically) to create the narrative of the novel. Ondaatje premiered this style in his 1976 work, Coming through Slaughter, and it has been argued that The English Patient is a masterfully realized example of this form. Ondaatje has been the recipient of numerous awards, including the prestigious Man Booker Prize, awarded to The English Patient; and the Canadian Governor General’s Award, for both his fiction and his poetry. Ondaatje is also an Officer of the Order of Canada and a Foreign Honorary Member of the American Academy of Arts and Letters.
otherwise hidden scenes, things not always witnessed firsthand by the primary characters of the book during the course of the narrative. These vignettes serve to illustrate certain aspects of the war and the realities faced by the citizens of Sri Lanka.
W Critical Reception Anil’s Ghost was greeted with a wide range of critical response. Given the political nature of the novel’s subject matter, as well as its contemporary relevance to the then ongoing Sri Lankan civil war, criticism focused not only on the merits of the work as an artistic endeavor, but also on the place of the work within a social and/or political context. Kanaganayakam believes that “multiple analyses advanced by critics have specific implications for the evaluation of Sri Lankan fiction in particular and for postcolonial literatures in general.” New York Times reviewer Janet Maslin responds to some of the inherent difficulties with the postmodern form, remarking that the connection between the powerful images of the war scattered throughout the book and the plot of the novel are “indistinct. Frustratingly so, since the scattered aspects of this voyage of discovery are separately so powerful.” In her opinion, “the book’s real strengths lie in its profound sense of outrage, the shimmering intensity of its descriptive language and the mysterious beauty of its geography.” Theo Tait of the London Review of Books likewise expresses the view that while containing powerful imagery, the novel suffers from a disconnecting of events and a breakdown of plot progression that result from
Homes that were damaged in the Sri Lankan civil war, the same war that is featured in Anil’s Ghost. ª Howard Davies/Corbis
44
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Anil’s Ghost
Ondaatje’s signature style. He compares Ondaatje to one of the author’s literary characters, calling him one of his own “outlandish figures of comparison, the excellent novelist and the hammy, rather suspect wordsmith seem intertwined.” Other reviewers have lauded Anil’s Ghost, citing the opinion that this work, rather than an imperfect novel, is an inspired exploration of the form. Such reviewers have appreciated Ondaatje for pushing the envelope and bringing a poet’s aesthetic to the prose novel form. Still others prefer to focus on the social or political impact the book might have. Regardless of motive, the novel continues to provoke a wide spectrum of responses. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
“Anil’s Ghost.” Publishers Weekly 247.12 (2000): 70. Print. General OneFile. Web. 9 July 2010. Bhattacharji, Preeti. “Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (aka Tamil Tigers).” Council on Foreign Relations. 20 May 2009. Web. 9 July 2010. Kanaganayakam, Chelva. “In Defense of Anil’s Ghost.” ARIEL 37.1 (2006): 5+. Print. General OneFile. Web. 9 July 2010. Maslin, Janet. “Books of the Times; Unearthing the Tragedies of Civil War in Sri Lanka.” Rev. of Anil’s Ghost, by Michael Ondaatje. New York Times 11 May 2000: n.p. Print. NYTimes.com. Web. 9 July 2010. Matthews, Bruce. “The Limits of International Engagement in Human Rights Situations: The Case of Sri Lanka.” Pacific Affairs 82.4 (2009): 577+. Print. General OneFile. Web. 9 July 2010. Scanlan, Margaret. “Anil’s Ghost and Terrorism’s Time.” Studies in the Novel 36.3 (2004): 302+. Print. General OneFile. Web. 9 July 2010. Tait, Theo. “Hit the Circuit.” Rev. of Anil’s Ghost, by Michael Ondaatje. London Review of Books 22.14 (20 July 2000): n.p. Print. Lrb.co.uk. Web. 9 July 2010. Vetter, Lisa Pace. “Liberal Political Inquiries in the Novels of Michael Ondaatje.” Perspectives on Political Science 34.1 (2005): 27+. Print. General OneFile. Web. 15 July 2010. Additional Resources
Center. Web. 13 July 2010. Review focusing on the theme of war and the importance of death in Anil’s Ghost, with brief mentions of connections between the work and certain archetypal protagonist characteristics. Kertzer, Jon. “Justice and the Pathos of Understanding in Michael Ondaatje’s Anil’s Ghost.” English Studies in Canada 29.3-4 (2003): 116+. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 9 July 2010. A critical essay that addresses the political aspect (or lack thereof) of Anil’s Ghost, and examines questions of pathos, ethics, and responsibility. New, William H. “Anil’s Ghost.” Journal of Modern Literature (2000): 565. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 9 July 2010. Places Ondaatje’s work, focusing on Anil’s Ghost in particular, into the context of works written by other contemporary Canadian authors. Ratti, Manav. “Michael Ondaatje’s Anil’s Ghost and the Aestheticization of Human Rights.” ARIEL 35.1-2 (2004): 121+. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 13 July 2010. Critical essay that addresses questions of the political and social impact of Anil’s Ghost, and expands the book’s potential impact on human rights into the question of minority rights and state sovereignty as well. Smothers, Bonnie. “Anil’s Ghost.” Booklist 15 Mar. 2000: 1294. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 12 July 2010. Brief plot summary and review in support of Ondaatje’s style and the effects of the book as a work of art. Gale Resources
Guneratne, Anthony R. “Michael Ondaatje (12 September 1943-)”. South Asian Writers in English. Ed. Fakrul Alam. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 323. Detroit: Gale, 2006. 273-280. Print. From Dictionary of Literary Biography Complete Online. Web 12 July 2010. “Michael Ondaatje (1943-)”. Contemporary Literary Criticism. Ed. Janet Witalec. Vol. 180. Detroit: Gale, 2004. 173-285. Print. From Literature Criticism Online. Web 12 July 2010.
Criticism and Reviews
Open Web Sources
Allen, Brooke. “Meditations, Good & Bad.” New Criterion 18.9 (2000): 63. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 9 July 2010. Highly critical review that deconstructs Anil’s Ghost from the perspectives of language, plot, and poetic effect.
Michael Ondaatje’s personal website includes biographical information, quotes, and video clips. It is located at http://michaelondaatje.com/
Cusk, Rachel. “Sri Lankan Skeletons.” New Statesman 129.4485 (8 May 2000): 55. Print. Rpt. in Contemporary Literary Criticism. Ed. Janet Witalec. Vol. 180. Detroit: Gale, 2004. Print. Literature Resource
The Poetry Foundation’s website has an extensive entry on Michael Ondaatje. It includes a biography, a current bibliography of his work, a career synopsis and an extensive list of works for further reading. http:// www.poetryfoundation.org/archive/poet.html? id=5142
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
45
Anil’s Ghost
The Contemporary Writers website offers a biography of Michael Ondaatje, as well as an extended critical perspective on his various works. It also features a current list of prizes and honors awarded him. http://www.contemporarywriters.com/authors/? p=auth205 For Further Reading
De Silva, K. M. A History of Sri Lanka. Rev. ed. 2005. London: C. Hurst & Company, 2005. Print. A history of Sri Lanka; of particular note is chapter 38, which covers the change in regime and the beginnings of the Sri Lankan civil war. Gunawardena, C. A. Encyclopedia of Sri Lanka. Rev. ed. 2006. Elgin: New Dawn Press Group, 2005. Print. Covers major aspects of Sri Lankan history, geography, people, places, art, and culture. Jewinski, Ed. Michael Ondaatje: Express Yourself Beautifully. n.p.: ECW Press, 1994. Print. A biography of Michael Ondaatje, published before he wrote Anil’s Ghost.
46
Ondaatje, Michael. The English Patient. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, Inc., 1992. Print. Arguably Ondaatje’s best-known novel, winner of the Man Booker Prize, adapted into an Academy Awardwinning film. ———. Running in the Family. New York: W. W. Norton, 1982. Print. Fictionalized memoir by Ondaatje about his imagined return to Sri Lanka in the 1970s; involves aspects of magic realism and explores themes of memory, family, and societal expectations. ———, with Ellen Kanner. “New Discoveries from the Author of The English Patient.” Bookpage.com. Web. 13 July 2010. An interview with Michael Ondaatje, conducted shortly after Anil’s Ghost was published; includes some of his feelings about Sri Lanka and the impulse behind the writing of the novel. Powder Thompson
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Animal’s People By Indra Sinha
W Introduction Indra Sinha’s Animal’s People is a darkly satirical tale set in present-day India, in the city of Khaufpur. The city is a fictionalized version of Bhopal, the site of the 1984 Union Carbide pesticide leak, the worst recorded industrial disaster in history. The protagonist of Sinha’s novel is a nineteenyear-old man whose parents were among the thousands killed in a comparable chemical leak. Instead of killing him, however, the chemicals have caused his spine to become so twisted that he is forced to walk on all fours—thus his nickname, Animal. What might otherwise be a very bleak book is lightened by the novel’s dark sense of humor. Animal is not only incredibly profane but he is also perpetually horny, lusting after numerous women (including the daughter of a local musician) and bragging about the size of his penis. Further humor arises from his relationship with Ma Franci, the deranged French nun with whom he lives, as well as with his dog, Jara. The novel also incorporates numerous elements of magical realism. Animal’s People was short-listed for the 2007 Man Booker Prize for Fiction, as well as the 2009 International IMPAC Dublin Literary Award. It won the 2008 Commonwealth Writers Prize (Eurasia Region, Best Book).
W Literary and Historical Context
Although the Bhopal disaster occurred over twenty-five years ago, its effects are still being felt today. On December 2, 1984, a gas leak occurred at the Union Carbide India Limited (UCIL) pesticide plant, which caused thousands of people in the surrounding area to be exposed to harmful chemicals such as methyl isocyanate (MIC). The leak caused somewhere between 3,000 and
15,000 deaths, many of which were immediate, and many more of which were the result of diseases related to gas exposure. To this day, survivors continue to suffer from related illnesses and injuries, in no small part due to the fact that even after the main leak, abandoned chemicals continued to pollute the groundwater. The gas leak in Bhopal, India, is considered the worst chemical disaster in history. More than twenty-five years after the tragedy, several criminal and civil cases are still pending, both in the United States and India. Seven former employees, including the ex-CEO of UCIL, Warren Anderson, were convicted in June 2010 for criminal negligence, each one sentenced to two years in prison and a $2,000 fine. An eighth was convicted but died before his sentence could be carried out. The leak was blamed on numerous factors, including inadequate maintenance, the fact that at the plant, MIC was being stored in tanks filled far past recommended levels, and the failure of numerous safety systems, many of which, including the tanks’ refrigeration system, were deliberately turned off in order to save money. Contributing to the severity of the disaster were the large number of slums (and therefore countless people) in the immediate area, the lack of any safety plan in case of a catastrophe, and poor availability of health care. Top symptoms and injuries that resulted include respiratory and eye problems, neurological disorders, and birth defects.
W Themes Animal’s People centers on an exploration of how corporate greed can lead to the devastation and destruction of human lives, casually and senselessly sacrificed in the name of cutting corners and saving money. It uses a fictionalized account of the Bhopal disaster’s aftermath to demonstrate how the world’s poorest people have no voice in how the world is run, or even in something as basic as their own survival.
47 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Animal’s People
MAJOR CHARACTERS ANIMAL, the narrator and protagonist, is a crude and perpetually horny nineteen-year-old whose spine is so twisted he has to walk on all fours ELLI, is a doctor from the United States whose goal is to open a free clinic in Khaufpur, to help the victims of the gas leak. MA FRANCI is a French nun who was poisoned in the gas leak, causing her to lose her mind, along with her Hindi and English. She can communicate only in French with Animal, with whom she lives. NISHA is the young woman with whom Animal has fallen in love, despite the fact that she is Zafar’s girlfriend. ZAFAR is an activist who preaches for nonviolent methods of retaliation against the company that ruined the lives of his people. He is also the boyfriend of Animal’s crush, Nisha.
Years later, the people of Khaufpur continue to suffer, their torment given representation in the form of Animal, whose body is as twisted and damaged as the plight of the people among whom he lives. Throughout the novel, his deformity is a constant reminder of the wrongs that have been done to him and his people, even as his crude personality and obsession with sex reassert Animal’s humanity. He may be horrifying to look at, the novel stresses, but he has the same needs, desires, and drives as any other person. Animal also serves as an extreme symbol for all impoverished people in Third World countries who may seem unapproachably alien to First World people, but who are no less deserving of human rights. He is fiercely individual and refuses to allow his identity to become regarded merely as a statistic.
W Style Sinha writes Animal’s People as a first-person narrative, in the voice of Animal, a device that places the reader directly in the center of the tragedy and fear that continues to affect the lives of the people who populate the novel. The word khauf, part of the city’s name, means fear or horror. “I used to be human once,” Animal says at the start, a declaration that speaks both to his physical deformities and to how the public outside of Khaufpur has come to ignore his people’s plight, treating them as less than human (1). The novel is structured in the form of transcripts of tape recordings that Animal is supposedly making for a reporter, who plans on using his testimony, as well as that of other Khaufpur residents, to write a book about the
48
A mosque in Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh, India. A fictional version of Bhopal serves as the setting of the novel Animal’s People. ª Photosindia/Corbis
tragedy. Animal remains acerbic and cynical throughout, telling the journalist, “You were like all the others, come to suck our stories from us, so strangers in far off countries can marvel there’s so much pain in the world. Like vultures are you jarnaliss” (5). Regarding the last word, Animal, frequently speaks with mispronounced or even made-up words that reflect the mix of Hindi, French, and English languages that surrounds him. He mistranslates the word, company as “kampani” and refers to spying as “jamisponding,” a verb phonetically derived from “James Bond” (27, 105). Animal’s dark sense of humor and unique perspective on the world adds a satirical layer to the proceedings that keeps the novel from being fully bleak, even as it underlines his humanity. He is, after all, partaking in the particularly human practice of dealing with tragedy through humor and selfdeprecation. Animal can also read minds and even communicates with a two-headed fetus (another result of the gas leak) that has been preserved for study at a local laboratory—a nuance that references the magical realism that runs throughout much of Indian literature. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Animal’s People
W Critical Reception Upon its release, Animal’s People was lauded for the creative and uncompromising manner with which it confronted readers with the victims of the Bhopal disaster. Leslie Patterson of Library Journal praised Animal as a narrator for his “lively mind and . . . way with words, some of them angry and profane, some of them bitterly funny,” calling the novel a “gripping” reminder of a “continuing real-life tragedy.” Entertainment Weekly’s Karen Valby additionally called Animal “as delightfully human a narrator as one could hope to find.” Kirkus Reviews went so far as to say that Animal was “destined to be one of fiction’s immortals.” In the same vein, Donna Seaman of Booklist was very impressed with how Sinha yields humor from the tragedy. She described the novel as being a “story . . . imaginatively told. Writing with both serious intent and exuberant satirical humor, Sinha tells an antic, ribald, and searing tale of greed and heroism.” She went on to applaud “Sinha’s daring farce . . . [for asking] what it means to be human, . . . [rekindling] compassion for the still uncompensated victims of the real-life catastrophe, and . . . [celebrating] the resiliency of love and goodness in the poorest and most poisoned of places.”
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Born in India in 1950, Indra Sinha spent the majority of his adult life in England, where he was voted as one of the top ten best British copywriters of all time. His specialty was in producing uncompromising, forceful ad campaigns for such charities as the Bhopal Medical Appeal and Amnesty International. Although he resigned in 1995 to focus on literature and nonfiction writing, his interest in human rights and humanity in general recurs throughout his work. His writing abounds with empathy for the less fortunate, particularly in Animal’s People, in which he places the reader inside the perspective of a most afflicted narrator.
Some critics took issue with the novel’s use of magical realism. London’s Sunday Times found these elements of the novel to be underdeveloped and “halfhearted,” while Ligaya Mishan in the New York Times felt that they were “more disorienting than enlightening . . . Sinha veers between comedy and tragedy,
An abandoned factory sits in ruins. In Animal’s People, a chemical leak from a similar factory leaves the main character, Animal, so deformed that he must walk on all fours. ª Nathan King / Alamy TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
49
Animal’s People
awkwardly stuffing his story with improbable high jinks.” She was also not the only critic to find a great number of the characters other than Animal to be rather twodimensional, built on personality quirks rather than on “fully realized interior lives.” Despite that, however, even she found moments of great power in the novel: “every now and then his prose achieves a plainspoken lyricism that brings his subject into sharp focus.”
Irani, Anosh. Rev. of Animal’s People, by Indra Sinha. Globe & Mail [Toronto, Canada], 13 Oct. 2007: D4. Explores how Sinha fictionalized the true story of the Bhopal disaster in this novel. Gale Resources
“Sinha, Indra (1950-).” Student Resource Center. Detroit: Gale, 2009. “Sinha, Indra. Animal’s People.” Student Resource Center. Detroit: Gale, 2009.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Rev. of Animal’s People, by Indra Sinha. Kirkus Reviews 1 Jan. 2008. “Human, All Too Human; Fiction.” Rev. of Animal’s People, by Indra Sinha. Sunday Times [London], 30 Sept. 2007: 54. Mishan, Ligaya. “POISONED.” Rev. of Animal’s People, by Indra Sinha. New York Times Book Review, 9 Mar. 2008: 13(L). Patterson, Leslie. “Sinha, Indra. Animal’s People.” Rev. of Animal’s People, by Indra Sinha. Library Journal 133.5 (2008): 61+. Seaman, Donna. “Animal’s People.” Rev. of Animal’s People, by Indra Sinha. Booklist 15 Feb. 2008: 35. Sinha, Indra. Animal’s People. New York: Simon & Schuster, 2009. Print. Valby, Karen. “Animal’s People.” Rev. of Animal’s People, by Indra Sinha. Entertainment Weekly 7 Mar. 2008: 96. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
“The Animal Kingdom.” Rev. of Animal’s People, by Indra Sinha. India Today (2007). This mostly complimentary review from India nevertheless argues that the novel’s main flaw is that the grotesqueries of Sinha’s fictionalized Bhopal are not nearly as upsetting as what actually happened. Rev. of Animal’s People, by Indra Sinha. Guardian [London, England], 15 Sept. 2007: 17. Analyzes how Sinha infuses the entire novel with a sense of unspeakable horror that is all the more disturbing because it has its basis in truth. Beresford, Lucy. “Village of the Damned.” Rev. of Animal’s People, by Indra Sinha. New Statesman (1996) 26 Feb. 2007: 67+. This review explains how Sinha used the internet as a medium to help tell his story, through the use of a website for the fictional Khaufpur that he created in conjunction with the novel. “‘The Govt Must Stop Obstructing Justice.’” Times of India, 22 June 2008. Details Indra Sinha’s real-world efforts to help the survivors of the Bhopal gas disaster.
50
Open Web Sources
Indra Sinha’s blog includes informative postings on his travels and his culture at http://www.indrasinha.com There is a detailed biography and critical essay about Sinha’s work, along with a full bibliography and list of awards at http://www.contemporarywriters.com/authors/? p=auth519F079C191fb20F5CkXPTF00D99 For Further Reading
D’Silva, Themistocles. The Black Box of Bhopal: A Closer Look at the World’s Deadliest Industrial Disaster. Victoria: Trafford Publishing, 2006. Print. This study of the disaster includes documents related to the plant’s operation and construction, as well as to the inner workings of the company that ran it. It also includes in-depth analysis of the Indian government’s response to the disaster, as well as to its investigation. Fortun, Kim. Advocacy after Bhopal: Environmentalism, Disaster, New Global Orders. Chicago: U. of Chicago P., 2001. Print. Analyzes the aftermath of the Bhopal disaster and how it has inspired human rights advocacy in ensuing years. Hanna, Bridget; Ward Morehouse; and Satinath Sarangi, eds. The Bhopal Reader. New York: Apex, 2005. Print. This anthology of information includes testimonies, analysis, debates, scientific and legal commentary and evidence, as well as archival documentation about the disaster. Lapierre, Dominique, and Javier Moro. Five Past Midnight in Bhopal: The Epic Story of the World’s Deadliest Industrial Disaster. New York: Warner Books, 2002. Print. Written by a journalist from France and a writer from Spain, this book is both a recounting of the disaster and a history of how the factory came to be built in the first place. Morehouse, Ward, and M. Arun Subramaniam. The Bhopal Tragedy: What Really Happened and What It Means for American Workers and Communities at Risk. New York: Apex, 1986. Print. This early analysis of the Bhopal disaster also contains warnings for how similar disasters can occur in the future, should corporate greed continue to influence precautionary policies. Robert Berg TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Armies By Evelio Rosero
W Introduction Set in war-torn rural Colombia, Evelio Rosero’s novel The Armies is the story of a fictional valley town under attack by several rival military groups and drug traffickers that inhabit the surrounding mountain forests. For years these factions have been swooping into San José without warning to kidnap its wealthiest citizens and to inflict violence on the rest of the inhabitants, who have long since resigned themselves to this menace. At the heart of the story is Ismael Pasos, a seventy-year-old retired professor whose search for his missing wife exposes him to the suffering of nearly everyone in town. Over the course of the novel, Ismael gradually loses his sanity as his neighbors either flee or are brutally murdered. The Armies has been praised for its relentlessly unsentimental examination of Colombia’s drug wars and focus on the personal aspects of the crisis rather than attending to larger questions of politics and social reform. It won the Tusquets International Prize in 2006 and the Independent Foreign Fiction Prize in 2009.
W Literary and Historical Context
Rural Colombia has experienced nearly continuous violence since the late 1940s, when a period known as “La Violencia” erupted after the conservative government’s return to power in 1946 and the 1948 assassination of charismatic liberal leader Jorge Eliécer Gaitán Ayala. These two events led many conservative peasants to steal land from those who supported the liberal government; a chain reaction of violence ensued that lasted through the mid-1950s. After a brief respite, tension returned with the rise of several Marxist parties in the 1960s and continued with the development of
drug cartels in the 1970s and ’80s. As markets for cocaine grew, rural Colombia’s vast swathes of coca plants became coveted and disputed territory. All of this made the average citizen in these towns easy prey for the numerous cartels and guerrilla organizations that were competing for resources. Many of these groups, such as the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia (FARC) and the United Self-Defense Forces of Colombia (AUC), were more powerful than the national government, making law enforcement in the region nearly impossible. The Armies, which is set in present-day Colombia, does not identify any particular Colombian fighting force but rather portrays the violence as a permanent and ubiquitous threat coming from anonymous military forces that strike the citizens of San José at unpredictable times. From 1960 to 1967, as war spread throughout much of Latin America, there was a literature boom that featured two distinct types of writing. The more famous of these was made up of writers such as Julio Cortázar, Gabriel García Márquez, and Jorge Luis Borges. Together this group developed a new literary style called magic realism, in which fantastic, decidedly unrealistic elements are woven into otherwise realistic stories. The other collection of more traditional writers featured the likes of Mario Vargas Llosa, Carlos Fuentes, and Guillermo Cabrera Infante. Although Rosero is a great admirer of Márquez, he clearly is a descendant of the latter group. The Armies focuses exclusively on the stark realities of civilians coping with war, such as loved ones waiting for spouses and mothers tending to traumatized children.
W Themes Rosero introduces the themes of voyeurism and indifference in the novel’s opening scene, in which Ismael picks oranges and looks over a wall at his neighbor Geraldina, who is sunbathing in the nude. As Ismael dawdles and
51 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Armies
MAJOR CHARACTERS GERALDINA ALMIDA is Ismael’s neighbor. Her husband and son are kidnapped when the armies invade San José. Her son is eventually returned, but the trauma has left him mute. CHEPE is a café owner whose wife is pregnant. She is kidnapped, and one day the optimistic, good-natured Chepe receives a parcel containing several of her and their daughter’s fingers. HORTENSIA GALINDO is the wife of Marcos Saldarriaga, who was kidnapped years before the action of the novel unfolds. Every year she hosts a party on the anniversary of her husband’s disappearance. Because she insists that there be dancing at the party, it is not clear whether she is mourning or celebrating his disappearance. “HEY” is the empanada seller who earns his moniker for the one-word shout he uses to advertise his wares as he pushes his cart through town. Ismael continues to hear the famous “heeey” after the peddler has been assassinated. OTILIA DEL SAGRARIO ALDANA OCAMPO, age sixty, is Ismael’s wife. Early in the novel, in their only protracted scene together, she scolds her husband for his voyeurism and sends him to a priest. Ismael goes to a bar and to a doctor instead and misses a party he was supposed to attend with Otilia. The two share only one brief conversation after this before she disappears. ISMAEL PASOS is the seventy-year-old hero and narrator of the novel. An incorrigible Peeping Tom, Ismael enjoys picking oranges from the trees that line his property so he can peer over the wall at Geraldina, who sunbathes naked. One morning Ismael wakes up early and takes a walk in the countryside. The first of the armies attacks while he is gone, and his wife disappears. Ismael spends the better part of the novel looking for her as his mental health deteriorates.
gawks, Geraldina and her husband, Eusebio, who is clothed, relax as if they do not know Ismael is there. Eventually, Eusebio approaches the wall and says to Ismael, “Your oranges are round, but my wife must be more rounded, no?” The two men continue to have a circumspect, jocular conversation, and Geraldina eventually joins them. The scene exemplifies the manner in which the novel’s characters ignore what is happening around them and then dismiss the violation when it is brought to light. Rosero develops these themes in a broader social context at a party given by Hortensia, whose husband, Marcos, disappeared four years ago. Each year Hortensia throws an unusual gathering to acknowledge the anniversary of Marcos’s disappearance.
52
Even as partygoers recall the horror of the kidnapping, they look forward to the gathering as an opportunity to dance and gossip. Ismael skips the event and goes instead to a café, where he ogles the waitresses. All of this foreshadows how the townspeople deal with the armies that invade the day after the party. No one protests; instead, they continue with their lives, resigning themselves to despair. As the guerrillas and paramilitaries continue to draw blood and make demands, Rosero introduces another theme, something akin to loyalty but that could also be regarded as a stubbornness bordering on madness. Ismael refuses to leave town, even after months have passed and all signs indicate that his wife has died. Near the end of the story, he receives several letters from his daughter, urging him to leave San José and live with her and her husband. Ismael refuses and eventually will not even read the missives. At the novel’s conclusion, Ismael visits a dying man named Celmiro, who has locked himself in his home. As Ismael pounds at the door, it is revealed that for days Celmiro’s sons have tried to get him to leave with them, but he prefers to die alone in San José.
W Style The Armies is an example of literary realism, which is an attempt to depict contemporary life as it is. As noted in Maya Jaggi’s article in the Guardian, more than 100,000 Colombian citizens were either killed or disappeared in the last twenty years, according to an Amnesty International report from 2008. To re-create the horror and resignation of rural Colombia during the drug wars of the second half of the twentieth century, the novel contains a litany of atrocities, including an officer firing into an unarmed crowd of civilians, a doctor stuffing money and narcotics into cadavers to help guerrillas transport their contraband, and a group of soldiers killing and then raping a woman. Rosero chose San José (an extremely common city name in Colombia) for the name of the novel’s setting in order to represent any rural Colombian town. “I took everyday life, idyllic as it seemed, and sabotaged it as violence came in,” Rosero comments in the Guardian article. The novel’s realism extends to the interior life of its main character, and the language Rosero uses to narrate the story reflects Ismael’s failing mental health. Ismael suffers from emotional exhaustion and becomes forgetful, nearly demented, the longer he goes without seeing his wife. As his mental health deteriorates, the storyline likewise breaks down. For example, during one point late in the novel, when it seems as if a week has gone by, Ismael says that the armies have been in town for several months. He then starts introducing new characters and talks about them as if they have been present in the novel from the beginning. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Armies
W Critical Reception Although the English translation of Rosero’s novel has not yet been widely reviewed, critics who have studied the work have responded positively. Perhaps the most favorable among these is Boyd Tonkin’s notice in the Belfast Telegraph, which states, “If our age of cyclical terror and counter-terror needs its own answer to All Quiet on the Western Front, here it is.” Most of the reviews commend Rosero for managing the escalation of violence in the text without sentiment or remorse. For example, writing in the Independent, Daniel Hahn claims, “The violence is momentary but often shocking, shown in brief, grim pictures; the building despair is finely controlled and oppressive; but The Armies is a swift and engaging piece of prose.” Miranda France in the Telegraph concurs, commenting that “the horror of the villagers’ plight is always powerfully conveyed.” However, Tommy Wallach, writing for the World, recognizes that the relentless violence may put off many readers: “The only thing that can really be said against Rosero’s novel is either irrelevant or a deal breaker: it isn’t particularly fun to read. When the darkness falls over Ismael, it is never to rise again. Nothing is so bad that it can’t get worse. The manager of a local café receives the index fingers of his kidnapped wife and daughter in order
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Evelio Rosero was born on March 20, 1958, in Bogotá, Colombia. He began writing in earnest in his late teens, and since that time has published novels, poetry, short stories, novellas, journalism, young adult fiction, and flash fiction to great acclaim. Famous for riding his bike through Bogotá for exercise and for running errands, Rosero is otherwise known for leading the reclusive life of a tireless writer. He makes a point of not attending literary functions. Over the course of his career, Rosero has won several major awards, including Colombia’s Premio Nacional de Cuento (national short story award) at age twenty-one in 1979 for “Ausentes” (The departed) and Spain’s Premio Internacional de Novela Breve (international award for short fiction) for Papá es santo y sabio (Dad is holy and wise) in 1982. In 2006 he was awarded Colombia’s Premio Nacional de Literatura (national literature prize) for his body of work.
to extract a higher ransom. The city’s empanada vendor’s severed head is found in his grease boiler. One woman watches her son die, then is killed and raped (in that order) by a group of soldiers.”
The Armies takes place in the midst of a brutal Colombian drug war. ª Bill Gentile/Corbis TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
53
The Armies
Reviewers have also praised Rosero for focusing on the private lives of the villagers rather than delving into Colombian politics. In Quarterly Conversation, Travis Godsoe argues that despite its varied influences, among them the many Latin American novels that came before it and the dystopian works of Samuel Beckett, “The Armies stands well on its own as an engrossing tale and needs no reference or interpretation beyond one’s own emotions and sense of justice. . . . Perhaps this is because the book is an antiwar novel without politics, one that only concerns itself with consequences and is all the more moving for it.” Hahn echoes Godsoe’s remarks: “The war is not about politics for these characters, not about rival factions fighting for control. It is about personal tragedies, the loss of a wife, struggles with physical ailments, sensations of pain, heat, thirst, hope and hopelessness. And Evelio Rosero’s book is all the more powerful for it.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
France, Miranda. Rev. of The Armies, by Evelio Rosero. Telegraph. Telegraph Media Group, 26 Nov. 2008. Web. 23 Sept. 2010. Godsoe, Travis. Rev. of The Armies, by Evelio Rosero. Quarterly Conversation. N.p., 4 Jan. 2010. Web. 23 Sept. 2010. Grant, Linda, Boyd Tonkin, and Maya Jaggi. “Witness to War: Evelio Rosero on Fiction That Fights for Truth.” Independent [London]. Independent Print Limited, 15 May 2009. Web. 24 Sept. 2010. Hahn, Daniel. Rev. of The Armies, by Evelio Rosero. Independent [London]. Independent Print Limited, 16 Jan. 2009. Web. 23 Sept. 2010. Rosero, Evelio. The Armies. Trans. Anne McLean. New York: New Directions, 2009. Print. Tonkin, Boyd. Rev. of The Armies, by Evelio Rosero. Belfast Telegraph. Independent News and Media Limited, 19 Feb. 2010. Web. 23 Sept. 2010. Wallach, Tommy. “Of Violence and Beauty.” PRI’s The World. PRI’s The World, 9 Sept. 2009. Web. 24 Sept. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Ehrenreich, Ben. “After Macando: On Evelio Rosero.” Nation. The Nation Company, 7 Jan. 2010. Web. 23 Sept. 2010. Praises the author for his unsparing representation of the violence and desolation the warring armies have brought to Colombia in the past half century. Ehrenreich also argues that Rosero’s narrative implicates readers, creating in them a perverse desire to bear witness to the destruction that is wrought on the page.
54
Open Web Sources
Bomb Magazine features an interview with Rosero in which he speaks about his experiences being educated by priests and the place they occupy in his work, as well as the books that have most influenced him. http://bombsite.com/issues/110/articles/3364 The Web site Booktrust includes an interview with the author in which he discusses the difference between the way rural and urban Colombians understand the violence that has been ravaging the countryside since the late 1940s. http://www.translatedfiction.org. uk/show/feature/Translation-Evelio-Rosero For Further Reading
Camus, Albert. The Plague. Trans. Stuart Gilbert. New York: Vintage, 1991. Print. Set in the 1940s in Algeria, the novel documents a group of people who, much like the citizens of San José, resign themselves to their despair when a deadly communicable disease spreads through town. The Plague has been read as an allegory of the French resistance to the Nazi invasion during the 1940s. Durnan, Michael, and Mark Peceny. “The FARC’s Best Friend: U.S. Antidrug Policies and the Deepening of Colombia’s Civil War in the 1990s.” Latin American Politics and Society 40.2 (2006): 95-116. Print. This article claims that the success of U.S. antidrug policies in Colombia, such as the dismantling of drug cartels and the aerial fumigation of coca crops, pushed coca cultivation exclusively into areas dominated by the FARC insurgents and thus weakened the central government and exacerbated the civil wars in areas like Rosero’s San José. Erlick, June Carolyn. A Gringa in Bogotá: Living Colombia’s Invisible War. Austin: U of Texas P, 2010. Print. In this memoir Erlick gives an account of how urban Colombians lived during the same time period covered in The Armies. She examines both the signs of “convivencia”—the Colombians’ desire to live in peace despite the civil war—and the subtle ways in which the sense of war is present, even in the face of all of the acts of kindness the author witnesses there. García Márquez, Gabriel. One Hundred Years of Solitude. Trans. Gregory Rabassa. New York: Harper Perennial, 2006. Print. Many reviewers of The Armies have identified Rosero’s fictional San José as a literary counterpoint to Macondo, the fictional Colombian village in García Márquez’s masterpiece. Both places endure relentless civil war, but García Márquez’s fabulations and stylistic flourishes relieve the horror, while Rosero’s realism and stark prose amplify it. Green, W. John. “Guerrillas, Soldiers, Paramilitaries, Assassins, Narcos, and Gringos: The Unhappy Prospects for Peace and Democracy in Colombia.” Latin American Research Review 40.2 (2005): 137-49. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Armies
Print. Gives a comprehensive overview of the political, economic, and military climate that has existed in Colombia since the 1950s. Leech, Garry M. Beyond Bogotá: Diary of a Drug War Journalist in Colombia. Boston: Beacon, 2010. Print. A combination of journal entries and news reports, Leech recounts the eleven hours he spent incarcerated by FARC and documents his meetings with the leaders vying for power in Panama’s and Colombia’s drug wars. The book also reviews the effectiveness of U.S. antidrug measures in Latin America.
Web. 24 Sept. 2010. This article reports on measures undertaken by current Colombian government to resolve the land problems and reduce the sort of guerrilla and paramilitary activity depicted in Rosero’s novel. Vargas Llosa, Mario. The Feast of the Goat. Trans. Edith Grossman. New York: Picador, 2002. Print. Rosero cites Vargas Llosa’s realist work as one of his primary influences. The novel recounts the assassination of Rafael Leónidas Trujillo Molina, ruler of the Dominican Republic from 1930 to 1961.
“This Land Is Our Land: At Last the Government Tries to Reverse a Violent Agrarian ‘Counter-Reform.’” Economist. The Economist Group, 16 Sept. 2010.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Joseph Campana
55
Arthur & George By Julian Barnes
W Introduction Julian Barnes’s biographical novel Arthur & George (2005) tells the story of two men, one famous, the other not, whose lives intersect because of a miscarriage of justice. Based on a historical case, the novel develops the separate lives of Arthur Conan Doyle, the creator of Sherlock Holmes, and George Edalji, an English-born Anglo-Indian solicitor. First, Barnes develops the separate story lines in chapters identified by one or the other character’s name, and then he tells the story of how Conan Doyle helped George in chapters some of which bear the two names together. As Barnes tells the story and as he describes Conan Doyle investigating and interpreting the events, it seems that the brown-skinned myopic George Edalji is likely the victim of racial prejudice, though Edalji never believes he is. The novel is a re-creation of events, fictional except in its verbatim use of newspaper reports, certain letters, and other legal documents. An “Author’s Note” appears at the end of the novel that explains what happened to the historical persons on whom this fictional account is based.
W Literary and Historical Context
The decades of the late nineteenth century and early twentieth century provide the time frame for this novel. The famous case of George Edalji was tried in 1903, Edalji was incarcerated for three years and then released, and in 1907, Edalji contacted Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, asking for his assistance in an effort to restore Edalji’s good name and his license to practice law. Heralded in the West and in the United States for its history of common law, England at this time did not have an appeals procedure. Throughout the nineteenth century, the Home Office decided what cases to lay before the Court of Crown
Cases Reserved, an entity that reviewed only points of law. Largely as a result of Conan Doyle’s efforts to bring public attention to this case and an earlier one involving Adolf Beck, the Court of Criminal Appeals was established by the Criminal Appeal Act of 1907. This court was designed to review matters of law and fact and gave defense lawyers an appeal process whereby negative judgments could be reevaluated. It had the additional effect of curbing certain tactics of prosecutors. The growing agnosticism of George Edalji and Conan Doyle’s disinterest in established religion and increased interest in spiritualism reflect the fin-de-siécle erosion of traditional Christian faith. During the nineteenth century, various branches of scientific investigation developed and garnered public attention through lecture and public debate and challenged establish church teaching. Charles Lyell, in his Principles of Geology (1830-1833), suggested that the earth was shaped by forces acting over millions of years. Charles Darwin (1809-1882) in On the Origin of Species (1859) and The Descent of Man (1871) suggested how distinct species descend from common ancestors. Scientific investigation linked with intellectual fervor both undermined bedrock religious tenets and encouraged a hope that in the twentieth century people would be able to know for certain how life began and what lies beyond the grave. Arthur & George alludes to other contextual matters as well. One of these is the prevalence of what was called “galloping consumption” (67) and later termed tuberculosis, the pulmonary infection that afflicts Conan Doyle’s first wife and even in the early 2000s can be fatal in some cases. In the scenes describing George’s imprisonment, readers learn about the prison at Portland Bill, part of an island off the south shore of England near Weymouth. Barnes describes the iron cells, like dog kennels, the lack of fresh air, the prison regimen, and the unlikely possibility of escape. A persistently relevant contextual element is the impact of newspaper coverage on any celebrated legal case and how word choice reveals interpretation and can be inflammatory.
56 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Arthur & George
MAJOR CHARACTERS GEORGE AUGUSTUS ANSON, chief constable, was prejudiced against Parsees and likely encouraged his police officers to suspect George Edalji of mutilating the horses. SIR ARTHUR CONAN DOYLE, author of the Sherlock Holmes mysteries, tries to assist George Edalji in solving the crime of which he was charged. LOUISA HAWKINS DOYLE, called Touie, is the first wife of Conan Doyle. CHARLOTTE STONEHAM EDALJI is George’s Scottish mother. GEORGE EDALJI is an English-born Anglo-Indian who becomes a Birmingham solicitor and is falsely accused and found guilty of a crime. HORACE EDALJI, George’s brother, moves to Manchester and thus escapes the difficulties the Edalji family experience at the vicarage in Great Wyrley. MAUD EDALJI, George’s sister, provides him with strength during the trial and after his release shares a home with him until she dies.
Portrait of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, who created Sherlock Holmes and is one of the main characters in Julian Barnes’s Arthur & George. ª Classic Image / Alamy
W Themes An important theme in Arthur & George is presented first in connection with Conan Doyle’s method for writing his Sherlock Holmes mysteries: His method is to begin with the ending and, once it is understood, to trace the inevitable path back to the beginning, thus unfolding the plot in its entirety. The idea that knowledge of the ending determines the path or journey one must take from the beginning is related to the interest of George Edalji in trains and in the law. George admires the English rail service and writes a book about the laws that govern it. He admires how trains arrive at scheduled times at each town between the beginning and ending of a business commute or pleasure excursion. Railroad linearity and the logic that determines rail service can also be seen in the law, which George distinguishes from and privately holds above the Articles of Faith of the Church of England. The novel examines the notion of linear, logical progression from an ending back to the point of origin and challenges its obvious assumptions. The law is not exact; in exercise, it is subject to prejudice, to misinterpretation, and to malicious or ignorant miscarriages of justice. A detective can investigate a crime, working back
SHAPURJI EDALJI, George’s father, was born in Bombay where he converted to Christianity. He later becomes a priest in the Church of England and serves for over twenty years as the vicar of Great Wyrley. CONNIE CONAN DOYLE HORNUNG is the sister of Arthur Conan Doyle who objects to the author’s friendship with Jean Leckie. ERNEST WILLIAM HORNUNG, called Willie, is the husband of Connie. Willie tries to explain to Arthur why his relationship to Jean Leckie is reckless and in bad taste. JEAN LECKIE is the second wife of Conan Doyle. ALFRED WOOD is Conan Doyle’s personal assistant and secretary and plays a Watson-type role in the crime investigation on behalf of George Edalji.
from the crime scene to events and individuals related to that outcome and yet not arrive at the truth. George’s ideals about the English legal system are challenged by his own experience. Arthur Conan Doyle can use his celebrity status and writing expertise to fuel public opinion on George’s behalf and yet still not correctly identify the perpetrators of the crime or their motives. In these ways, Barnes makes of this early twentieth-century case a modern parable about how criminals may go unpunished and how investigations can be swayed by prejudice and public sentiment. As well meaning as many individuals in the legal system may be, various factors can subvert the justice system, causing the innocent to pay and the guilty to escape with impunity.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
57
Arthur & George
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Born January 19, 1946, in Leicester, England, Julian Barnes received his BA from Magdalen College, Oxford University, in 1968. He worked as a freelance writer and lexicographer, beginning in the early 1970s and then went on to be a television critic and a literary editor for the Sunday Times (London) and later a correspondent for the New Yorker magazine. In the 1980s he wrote several books, the fourth one of which, Flaubert’s Parrot (1986) being a particular success. He has written several detective novels, two of which under the pseudonym Dan Kavanagh, and three collections of essays, two short story collections and a translation of the memoirs of Alphonse Daudet, the nineteenth-century French writer. Arthur & George was nominated for the Man Booker Prize. As of 2010, he lived in London with his wife, Pat Kavanagh.
W Style Barnes’s style is ironic and humorous. The plot undermines the assumption early asserted by George Edalji that virtue is its own reward. As the novel demonstrates, one may feel self-satisfaction in being law abiding, but that does not protect a person from malicious others who are intent on mischief and who do not care whom they hurt in the process. Also disproved is the notion that the law allows for no ambiguity such as one finds in Christian beliefs. Indeed, ambiguity and obfuscation cloak police investigation, as prejudice can occlude legal proceedings. The law is putty, subject to innuendo, inference, and slander. The ironies in this novel would be dark indeed were it not for the humor, which is often conveyed by Barnes’s appropriation of Edwardian prose style and as often delivered through the funny lines given to Conan Doyle. Barnes’s handling of tense, which Terrence Rafferty noted was “terribly cunning,” is skillfully related to plot development. George’s story is in present tense until his life stops with his imprisonment at which time it is told in past tense. Conan Doyle’s story is in past tense until he meets Jean Leckie, at which point it unfolds in present tense. Thus, the handling of tense marks the progression or obstruction of progression in the lives of these two protagonists.
W Critical Reception Arthur & George was generally well received but did not escape negative criticism. Andre Bernard praised the novel, noting that Barnes had written “with mesmerizing skill, a remarkably tense and exciting drama.” Terrence Rafferty agreed, labeling it
58
an “extraordinary novel” and finding the portrait of Conan Doyle “generous and plausible.” Also enthusiastic was the evaluation of Andre Bernard, who wrote: “If you like Sherlock Holmes— and who doesn’t?—you’ll be plunged immediately into a marvelously readable account, written as fiction but entirely based on fact, of how Conan Doyle becomes involved in a great judicial injustice, and how he tries to solve a great mystery, Holmes-style.” Robert Winder agreed, writing that this “classic post-Victorian miscarriage of justice with a racist/imperialist undertow” allowed Barnes to write “a double biography,” one in which Conan Doyle allowed himself to play Holmes. Winder also noted that Barnes’s novel appeared “on the centenary of Edalji’s incarceration.” About Barnes’s total accomplishment, Bernard wrote: “reminiscent of the better English novels of the nineteenth century, it covers a great deal of territory while galloping at enormous speed, and yet is also loving in its minute details of village and city life, in its revelations of the oppressive truths of a rural environment and a suffocating Victorian moral sensibility, and in its examination of the sins of Empire. Not quite a mystery, nor yet a novel of ideas, it is simply terrific reading.” Rafferty stated this as the novelist’s achievement: “The beauty of the book lies in the restrained, level-eyed respect Barnes maintains for even his characters’ most desperate mental stratagems to keep confusion at bay.” On the negative side, certain critics faulted Barnes for trying to write like the great Victorian novelists. Winder asserted that Barnes uses “gentle archaisms and circumlocutions designed to suggest the fin-de-siécle atmosphere” and used “period detail . . . to create a sense of antiquity,” even when it was inaccurate to do so. In this point, Sebastian Smee agreed. Smee also faulted the ending, noting that the “urgent momentum of Barnes’s crime story leaves us feeling almost cheated by the absence of a culprit.” But Smee ended his review on a positive note, praising the novel for providing a “sprightly and acute . . . biography of Doyle, and as touching a sketch of the persecuted Edalji.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Barnes, Julian. Arthur & George. New York: Knopf, 2006. Print. Bernard, Andre. “Arthur and George.” Rev. of Arthur & George, by Julian Barnes. Kenyon Review 29.2 (2007): 2. Print. Rafferty, Terrence. “The Game’s Afoot.” Rev. of Arthur & George, by Julian Barnes. New York Times Book Review 15 Jan. 2006: 1(L). Print. Smee, Sebastian. “The Curious Case of the Slashed Horse.” Rev. of Arthur & George, by Julian Barnes. Spectator 9 July 2005: 34. Print. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Arthur & George
Winder, Robert. “Bumps in the Night.” Rev. of Arthur & George, by Julian Barnes. New Statesman 11 July 2005: 49+. Print.
Gale Resources
Additional Resources
Open Web Sources
Criticism and Reviews
Julian Barnes maintains a Web site at http://www. julianbarnes.com, which gives information on his other publications, interviews, biography, and current activities.
Ayers, Jeff. “Do the Time, Read the Crime.” Rev. of Arthur & George, by Julian Barnes. Library Journal 1 Sept. 2007: 184. Print. Points out how novelists are inspired by real-life cases. Hammer, Joshua. “Sherlock Holmes’ London.” Smithsonian 40.10 (2010): 56-65. Print. Identifies favorite spots in London of the detective and his creator. Mullen, Alexandra. “Sleuthing Conan Doyle.” New Criterion 26.10 (2008): 25-29. Print. Reviews recent biography on Doyle and the publication of his letters. Rasmussen, R. Kent. “Barnes, Julian. Arthur and George.” Rev. of Arthur & George, by Julian Barnes. Library Journal 1 Feb. 2007: 104. Print. Praises the lively character study but faults the novel’s beginning as too slow. Schwartz, Lynne Sharon. “An Unlikely Convergence.” Rev. of Arthur & George, by Julian Barnes. New Leader 88.6 (Nov.-Dec. 2005): 42-44. Print. A review that describes Barnes’s work as a restitching of the tattered Victorian story. Seaman, Donna. “Barnes, Julian. Arthur & George.” Rev. of Arthur & George, by Julian Barnes. Booklist 1 Jan. 2006: 22. Print. Asserts novel is brilliant inquiry “into the nature of delusion and hope” and explains how case was a catalyst for establishing the Court of Criminal Appeal. Watman, Max. “Ever-Present Human Hint of Yellow.” New Criterion 24.9 (2006): 58-65. Print. Reviews several British novels, including Arthur & George.
“Julian Barnes.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2010.
For Further Reading
Barnes, Julian. Flaubert’s Parrot. New York: Vintage International, 1990. Print. Tells the story of an English doctor who investigates some details concerning the life of Gustave Flaubert, the French nineteenth-century novelist. Doyle, Arthur Conan. Memories and Adventures. Intro. by David Stuart Davies. London: Wordsworth Editions, 2007. Print. One of several editions of this autobiography by the novelist. Lycett, Andrew. The Man Who Created Sherlock Holmes: The Life and Times of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. New York: Free Press-Simon & Schuster, 2008. Print. Comprehensive retelling of Doyle’s life by the biographer of Kipling and Dylan Thomas. Weaver, Gordon. Conan Doyle and the Parson’s Son: The George Edalji Case. Lahore, Pakistan: Vanguard Books, 2006. Print. Provides the history that is the major source for Barnes’s novel. Whittington-Egan, Richard, and Molly WhittingtonEgan, eds. The Story of Mr. George Edalji, by Arthur Conan Doyle. London: Camille Wolff Grey House Books, 1985. Print. Presents Doyle’s version of the story, first published in 1907. Melodie Monahan
Whittington-Egan, Richard. “Conan Doyle.” Contemporary Review 289 (Winter 2007): 518-19. Print. Reviews recent biography and other works on the famous author.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
59
The Astonishing Life of Octavian Nothing By M. T. Anderson
W Introduction In the first volume of The Astonishing Life of Octavian Nothing, The Pox Party, a black youth named Octavian is raised and educated by a group of Boston philosophers as part of an experiment to determine whether Africans are as intelligent as Europeans. After his mother dies as the result of another experiment (the “pox party” of the subtitle), Octavian runs away and joins the Patriot army fighting the British. He is soon recaptured and returned to Boston, where he is bound and forced to wear an iron mask. At the end of the volume, Octavian escapes with the aid of one of his instructors, Dr. Trefusis. In the second volume, The Kingdom on the Waves, Octavian and Dr. Trefusis head to Virginia, where the colony’s governor, Lord Dunmore, has issued a proclamation offering freedom to any slave owned by an American rebel who enlists to fight with the British. As part of the Royal Ethiopian Regiment, Octavian learns more about his African ancestry and the larger slave experience. M. T. Anderson is known for writing young adult novels that challenge readers to look at the world in new ways. In The Astonishing Life of Octavian Nothing, he creates an alternative history of the American Revolution by presenting British Loyalists as sympathetic characters and emphasizing the paradox of freedom-loving slave owners. The Astonishing Life of Octavian Nothing won several major awards, including the National Book Award for Young People’s Literature in 2006 and the Michael L. Printz Award for Excellence in Young Adult Literature from the American Library Association in 2007 and 2009.
W Literary and Historical Context
The Astonishing Life of Octavian Nothing is a historical novel set during the period of the American Revolution.
Much of the book is based on the role of slaves during the Revolution. The first African slaves in North America arrived in Jamestown in 1623. By 1750 there were roughly 300,000 slaves in the thirteen American colonies, making up about one-fifth of the population. Most had been born in the colonies and knew of Africa only through the stories of others. When the rift between Great Britain and the colonies began to develop in the years after the French and Indian Wars, slaves adopted the rhetoric of dissent in their own appeals for freedom. In 1775, when the long-simmering resentments between Britain and the colonies erupted into war, many slaves chose which side to fight for based on which army would offer them freedom. At first, George Washington refused to accept black soldiers in the Continental Army, though black freemen fought with their white counterparts at Lexington and Bunker Hill. By contrast, the governor of Virginia offered to emancipate any slave owned by Patriot masters who joined the Loyalist forces. Some 800 escaped slaves joined Dunmore’s Royal Ethiopian Regiment. Thousands more joined the British army in exchange for the promise of freedom. Sir Walter Scott’s Waverly, published in 1819, is generally considered the first true historical novel. Although some historical novels, such as Robert Graves’s I, Claudius (1934), deal with actual historical figures, most follow Scott’s basic formula, in which the story of a fictional character is told against the backdrop of an accurately rendered historical period. Anderson uses the conventions of the historical novel to turn the standard story of the American Revolution on its head. His characters are never directly involved in the best-known incidents of the war. In the first volume, the reader sees the beginnings of the war only at arm’s length through the concerns of the Novanglian College of Lucidity. In the second volume, Anderson focuses on the war experience of the escaped slaves who made up Lord Dunmore’s Royal Ethiopian Regiment. The result is what Kathleen Horning, writing in School Library Journal, says is “historical fiction as it’s never been written for teens.”
60 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Astonishing Life of Octavian Nothing
MAJOR CHARACTERS CASSIOPEIA, Octavian’s mother, is an African princess from the Oyo kingdom in West Africa who was captured and sold into slavery while pregnant with Octavian. Her death in the first volume as the result of smallpox inoculation triggers Octavian’s first attempt to escape from the Novanglian College of Lucidity. MR. GITNEY is the leader of the Novanglian College of Lucidity and Octavian’s chief guardian. OCTAVIAN is a young African prince who is raised and educated by a group of philosophers in an experiment to determine whether Africans have the same intellectual capacity as Europeans. Much of the story is told through “documents” purporting to be his written testimony. PRO BONO is Mr. Gitney’s valet, who introduces Octavian to the realities of slavery and provides him with the information he needs to escape from the College of Lucidity. He reappears in the second volume as Private William Williams in the Royal Ethiopian Regiment. MR. SHARPE is sent by the trustees to repair the finances at the College of Lucidity after the death of the institution’s primary patron. He represents a group of slave owners who want the experiment to fail as a means of justifying the practice of slavery.
Portrait of M. T. Anderson, author of The Astonishing Life of Octavian Nothing. ª Rick Friedman/Corbis
W Themes In The Astonishing Life of Octavian Nothing, Anderson uses the history of slave participation in the American Revolution to consider the fundamental irony of slave owners fighting for freedom. In an interview with Farai Chideya on National Public Radio’s Morning Edition, Anderson contrasts the Patriots’ battle for liberty with that of the American slaves who “are creating a revolution at their own level. They are almost two interlocking revolutions going on at the same time.” Anderson provides the reader with a clue to the central theme of the book in its subtitle, Traitor to the Nation. The reader inevitably wonders how a slave can be a traitor to a nation that does not recognize him as a citizen. At the end of the first volume, Anderson provides the answer. Both Octavian and Dr. Trefusis must flee to avoid being hanged. Dr. Trefusis is legally guilty of theft because he has helped Octavian escape. Octavian is technically a traitor to the nation for having attempted to kill his master, because such a murder is considered an attack on the concept of sovereignty.
DR. TREFUSIS is the oldest and most accomplished of Octavian’s tutors. At the end of the first volume, he helps Octavian escape at the risk of being arrested for theft. In the second volume, he accompanies Octavian to Virginia.
Anderson raises the prickly questions of liberty and slavery in the early chapters of the first volume. When Octavian first hears about the Patriots’ struggle “for liberty from oppression and from bondage,” he assumes that “soon, the bondage I but little understood that encompassed Bono and my mother and so many others of my acquaintance should melt away,” until he learns that his freedom is not included in the cause. Thereafter, Octavian’s choices are driven by a search for liberty as carefully reasoned as that of a Jefferson or a Franklin. At different points in the novel, he fights for both the Americans and the British, and he ultimately rejects both sides in favor of “a new route which should secure us from the ire and indifference of both England and Colony.”
W Style Stylistically, Anderson goes to great lengths to evoke the feel of the eighteenth century, both in his language and in the novel’s structure. Critics often praise the author for
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
61
The Astonishing Life of Octavian Nothing
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Matthew Tobin (M. T.) Anderson grew up in Stow, Massachusetts, a small town near Boston. Because of a distant family connection, he was encouraged to read Mark Twain when he was nine or ten. Hooked on Twain’s satire, he moved on to read other American satirists, including James Thurber, Woody Allen, and S. J. Perelman. After high school, Anderson spent a year in a British boarding school, where he discovered the British satirists, including Jonathan Swift and Evelyn Waugh. He attended Harvard for a semester and then transferred to Cambridge University, where he completed his BA in 1991. After college, he worked for three years as an editorial assistant at Candlewick Press. He left Candlewick to begin graduate work at Syracuse University, receiving an MFA in 1998. Anderson sold his first novel, Thirsty, to Candlewick in 1996, but his career as a writer for children and young adults did not take off until the publication of his picture-book biography of the composer George Frideric Handel in 2001. He began writing full time in 2005.
creating not just one, but a whole series of authentic colonial-era voices that vary according to the social standing and ethnicity of the characters. In an interview with Julie Prince in Teacher Librarian, Anderson described the process. He read eighteenth-century literature extensively, looking for the “ways in which eighteenth-century grammar and vocabulary varied from our own—words they tended to use, unusual syntactical tics, and so on.” According to Anderson, first-generation African American speech presented a special challenge. There are few records of actual speech, and the transcriptions that exist were often made by people focused on denigrating the African speaker. Anderson’s solution was to work with a friend who speaks Yoruba to understand “the ways in which African syntactical patterns may have translated into English. . . . What became obvious is that many of the features that were recorded by white observers actually had their roots in West African American.” Anderson reinforces the period feel of the book by employing a device often used in novels in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, most notably Bram Stoker’s Dracula (1897) and Wilkie Collins’s The Moonstone (1868). In these works, the author poses as the reporter of an actual incident, presenting his story in the form of a series of documents, most often letters, diaries, and sworn statements, that he has collected as evidence. The title page of Anderson’s work declares that the story of Octavian Nothing is “taken from accounts by his own hand and other sundry sources collected by Mr. M. T. Anderson of Boston.” The bulk of the story is told in Octavian’s own words, first as “drawn from the
62
Manuscript Testimony of Octavian Gitney” and later “from the nautical diary of Private Octavian Nothing.” Octavian’s accounts of his story are interspersed with newspaper clippings, scientific articles, letters written by various characters, and historical documents—all of which allow Anderson to show different perspectives on events in the narrative. At the end of the novel, Octavian wrests control of his life story from both the narrator and his former owners by returning to Boston and replacing Mr. Gitney’s elaborate records of Octavian’s childhood with his own narrative account.
W Critical Reception The Astonishing Life of Octavian Nothing is regularly praised for Anderson’s skillful evocation of the novel’s historical setting, believable reconstruction of eighteenthcentury language, and startling reversal of our assumptions about the American Revolution. Reviewers acknowledge that the novel may be challenging for the young adult audience at which it is aimed but are almost unanimous in declaring it worth the effort. Vicky Smith, writing in the Horn Book Magazine, praises Anderson’s work as “a brilliantly complex interrogation of our basic American assumptions. Anderson has created an alternative narrative of our national mythology, one that fascinates, appalls, condemns—and enthralls.” Julie Roach, also writing in the Horn Book Magazine, agrees: “M. T. Anderson’s beautifully written and elegantly structured novel immerses readers in the period using traditional eighteenth century language that resonates with the timeless struggle of being young in a cruel and unjust world. This brilliant and horrifying tale underlines the fact that within every well-known story there are others to be told.” Sharon Rawlins reports in the School Library Journal that “Anderson’s use of factual information to convey the time and place is powerfully done.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Anderson, M. T. The Astonishing Life of Octavian Nothing, Traitor to the Nation. Volume I: The Pox Party. Cambridge: Candlewick, 2006. ———. The Astonishing Life of Octavian Nothing, Traitor to the Nation. Volume II: The Kingdom on the Waves. Cambridge: Candlewick, 2008. ———. “Author M. T. Anderson on Octavian Nothing.” Interview by Farai Chideya. Morning Edition 25 Jan. 2007. General OneFile. Web. 20 Sept. 2010. Horning, Kathleen. “Patriot Games: Yes, Indeed, the British Are Coming! But M. T. Anderson’s Revolutionary War Novel Is Unlike Anything You’ve Ever TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Astonishing Life of Octavian Nothing
Read.” School Library Journal 52.11 (2006): 40+. General OneFile. Web. 20 Sept. 2010. Prince, Julie. “Giving Readers What They Want: An Interview with M. T. Anderson.” Teacher Librarian 37.1 (2009): 62+. General OneFile. Web. 24 Sept. 2010. Rawlins, Sharon. Rev. of The Astonishing Life of Octavian Nothing, Vol. I: The Pox Party, by M. T. Anderson. School Library Journal 52.10 (2006): 147. General OneFile. Web. 20 Sept. 2010. Roach, Julie. Rev. of The Astonishing Life of Octavian Nothing, Vol. I: The Pox Party, by M. T. Anderson. Horn Book Magazine 84.1 (2008): 27+. General OneFile. Web. 20 Sept. 2010. Smith, Vicky. Rev. of The Astonishing Life of Octavian Nothing, Vol. I: The Pox Party, by M. T. Anderson. Horn Book Magazine 82.5 (2006): 573+. General OneFile. Web. 25 Sept. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
“African-American History Comes to Life for Young Readers.” Rev. of The Astonishing Life of Octavian Nothing, by M. T. Anderson. St. Louis Post-Dispatch 18 Jan. 2009: F9. InfoTrac Custom Newspapers. Web. 26 Sept. 2010. This review compares Octavian Nothing to two other novels based on African American history. Anderson, M. T. “Printz Award Honor Speech.” Young Adult Library Services 6.1 (2007): 20+. Academic OneFile. Web. 20 Sept. 2010. In his thank-you speech for the 2007 Printz Award, Anderson discusses what historical novels can teach us. Bazelon, Emily. “A Pox on Pox Party.” Rev. of The Astonishing Life of Octavian Nothing, Vol. I: The Pox Party, by M. T. Anderson. Slate.com 20 Nov. 2006. Web. 25 Sept. 2010. A rare negative review that gives thoughtful consideration to the prevalence of message books in young adult fiction. Griswold, Jerry. “The War for Independence.” Rev. of The Astonishing Life of Octavian Nothing, by M. T. Anderson. New York Times Book Review 9 Nov. 2008: 20(L). General OneFile. Web. 26 Sept. 2010. Griswold compares The Amazing Life of Octavian Nothing to both Huckleberry Finn and Moby Dick. “Octavian Nothing Duo Has Everything for Questing Minds.” Rev. of The Astonishing Life of Octavian Nothing, Vol. II: The Kingdom on the Waves, by M. T. Anderson. Toronto Star 23 Nov. 2008: ID04. InfoTrac Custom Newspapers. Web. 26 Sept. 2010. This review of the second volume of the Octavian Nothing books looks at Anderson’s use of Enlightenment philosophy.
Gale Resources
“Anderson, M. T.” Authors and Artists for Young Adults. Vol. 60. Detroit: Gale, 2005. Gale Virtual Reference Library. Web. 20 Sept. 2010. “Anderson, M. T. 1968– (Matthew Tobin Anderson).” Contemporary Authors, New Revision Series. Vol. 167. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Gale Virtual Reference Library. Web. 20 Sept. 2010. “Anderson, M. T. The Astonishing Life of Octavian Nothing.” Literary Newsmakers for Students. Vol. 3. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Gale Virtual Reference Library. Web. 20 Sept. 2010. Open Web Sources
M. T. Anderson’s personal Web site has a biography and several essays discussing his novels. http:// mt-anderson.com/ The Web site of the Historical Novel Society includes links to several important essays on the genre. http:// www.historicalnovelsociety.org/definition.htm Part of Canada’s Digital Collection, the Web site Black Loyalists: Our History, Our People tells the story of the Black Loyalists who fought with the British and their experiences in Canada after the end of the Revolutionary War. http://www.blackloyalist.com/ canadiandigitalcollection/index.htm For Further Reading
Anderson, Laurie Halse. Chains. New York: Simon, 2008. Print. A mid-grade novel about two young slaves in the Revolutionary War that shares many themes with The Astonishing Life of Octavian Nothing. Bober, Natalie S. Countdown to Independence. New York: Simon Pulse, 2007. Print. A balanced account of the events that led to the American Revolution. Collier, James Lincoln, and Christopher Collier. My Brother Sam Is Dead. New York: Four Winds, 1974. Print. A Newbery Honor novel that tells the story of a family torn apart when brothers choose to fight on opposite sides in the American Revolution. Gay, Peter. The Enlightenment: The Science of Freedom. New York: Norton, 1996. Print. An excellent account of the Enlightenment scholars and ideas parodied by Anderson as the College of Lucidity. Schama, Simon. Rough Crossings: The Slaves, the British and the American Revolution. London: BBC, 2005. Print. A historical account of the British proclamation of emancipation for slaves who fought for Britain during the American Revolution.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Pamela Toler
63
The Athenian Murders By José Carlos Somoza
W Introduction The Athenian Murders (2002) is the sixth novel by popular Spanish writer José Carlos Somoza and the first to be published in an English translation. The multilayered narrative interweaves two stories. One is told in the text of an ancient manuscript (itself called The Athenian Murders): A “decipherer of enigmas” investigates the murders of several young philosophy students from Plato’s Academy. The other story unfolds in the footnotes created by the Translator, an unnamed protagonist who is preparing the first modern translation of the manuscript. The footnotes reveal the Translator’s gradual realization that he is working with an eidetic text (one employing repeated words and phrases to create an image in the reader’s mind) that may contain a secret message. Parts of the message seem to be directed at the Translator. He finds himself drawn into a third plot layer involving another modern character, Montalo, who is obsessed with discovering the ultimate meaning of the manuscript. All the layers revolve around philosophical speculation, and in the end they come together in a surprising twist. The Athenian Murders was well received by most critics and won the 2002 Macallan Gold Dagger awarded by the Crime Writers’ Association.
W Literary and Historical Context
The events of the ancient narrative take place in Athens during the time when the famed philosopher Plato (c 428-347 BCE) taught at the Academy, a school he founded around 387 BCE. The Academy operated until 86 BCE, when the grounds were destroyed (along with much of Athens) in the First Mithridatic War. While the school was under Plato’s direction, there was
no set curriculum. Most instruction was conducted through discussions of philosophical questions. Participants included both older scholars and young men, such as the ephebes (adolescents) who are killed in the plotline of the ancient Athenian Murders. In the course of that narrative, the characters explore other aspects of Athenian culture, including mystery cults (which taught certain doctrines to initiates by means of ritual experiences and ecstatic visions) and numerous philosophical factions. The story also alludes to the sexual mores of ancient Greek culture, such as the acceptance of sexual relationships between older men and young boys. The modern plotline occurs in an unspecified time and place.
W Themes The original Spanish title of Somoza’s novel, La caverna de las ideas (The cave of ideas), a reference to Plato, emphasizes the central thematic role of philosophical inquiry. Although the early Academy probably did not teach a specific doctrine, discussions undoubtedly reflected Plato’s own views. Plato recorded his beliefs in the form of dramatized dialogues between Socrates (his teacher) and various other philosophers. The most important of the dialogues, The Republic, contains a story now known as the Allegory of the Cave. In it, Plato suggests that the material world perceived by the senses is only a shadow of the real forms of things, which exist as ideas; therefore, reality can only be apprehended by the intellect. In The Athenian Murders the nature of reality (that is, the question of whether ideas have an independent existence, separate from the phenomenal world) is a continuing subject of inquiry, both in the ancient manuscript and in the story told by the Translator. As the Translator and Montalo pursue philosophical answers, they focus on the role that language plays in either depicting an existing reality or creating an independent reality.
64 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Athenian Murders
MAJOR CHARACTERS DIAGORAS is a tutor at Plato’s Academy who suspects that a young student was murdered and appeals to Pontor for help. He assists in the investigation and discusses philosophy with Pontor. MONTALO, a character in the modern story, was the first to copy the ancient text from papyrus. He kidnaps the Translator in his quest to prove his theory about the manuscript. PLATO is a historical character, a philosopher and teacher who appears only briefly in the ancient story. His Academy, students, and ideas are at the center of both the plot of the ancient text and the themes of the modern story. HERACLES PONTOR is the main character of the story in the ancient manuscript. He is the “decipherer of enigmas” summoned to investigate the murders of the young students of Plato’s Academy. THE TRANSLATOR is the unnamed protagonist of the modern story that unfolds in the footnotes to his translation. As he works on the ancient manuscript, he notices that a secret is concealed in the text, and eventually he becomes involved in a real-life mystery concerning the ancient manuscript and its meaning.
Greek philosopher Plato. In The Athenian Murders, a translator works on an ancient manuscript about the murder of several students from Plato’s Academy. Nick Pavlakis/Shutterstock.com
W Style Plato presented the precepts of his philosophy in the form of dialogues between characters with different ideas. In a similar way, Somoza creates a virtual discussion between Heracles Pontor, the protagonist of the ancient narrative, and the Translator, the main character of the modern narrative. The Translator comments on the original story in his footnotes, and as The Athenian Murders progresses, it begins to seem as if the original text is talking back to him. Another dialogue takes shape between the Translator and Montalo. Both men believe that eidetic imagery is incorporated into the style of the ancient manuscript. The eidetic message, which relates to the question of whether language creates reality, turns out to be a crucial element in the modern plotline. In this manner Somoza weaves the philosophical concepts explored in The Athenian Murders into the style and structure of the novel.
W Critical Reception The majority of critics have praised the conceptual inventiveness of The Athenian Murders and consider the novel strong overall. Publishers Weekly calls it “a highly original and literary approach to crime fiction.” Pedro Ponce, writing for the Review of Contemporary Fiction, observes that “the thrill of this novel comes from both its ingeniously structured mystery plot and the larger questions it raises about what constitutes knowledge and experience.” A review in the London Times declares that Somoza “weaves suspense, gore, a particular corner of Plato’s philosophy and layer upon layer of tantalizing reflexivity with ease and obvious relish.” Not all reviewers were convinced of the book’s merit, however. Kirkus Reviews concludes that “the plot’s deliberate obscurities both intrigue and annoy,” though “the rich, elegant writing will please all comers.” The reviewer cautions, “Mystery fans should be warned that Somoza is more interested in metaphysical questions and literary subtleties than traditional storytelling.” At the negative end of the spectrum, Michael D. Langan writes in the Buffalo News, “It’s hard to know whether the book is a gussied-up sexual escapade or a serious work of philosophical discourse.”
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
65
The Athenian Murders
ABOUT THE AUTHOR José Carlos Somoza was born in Havana, Cuba, in 1959, just a few months after Fidel Castro came to power. The following year Somoza’s family left everything behind and moved to Spain. He is now a Spanish citizen. Somoza has lived in Madrid and Cordoba, where he studied medicine and earned a degree in psychiatry in 1994. The same year, his first novel was accepted for publication, and he decided to become a writer. The Athenian Murders is his sixth novel and the first to appear in an English translation. Since then, two more of his novels have been translated into English: The Art of Murder (2004; Clara y la penumbra, 2001) and Zig Zag (2007; Zig Zag, 2006). Somoza’s novels have won several international awards, including (for his 2007 novel La Llave del Abismo) the Premio de Novela Ciudad de Torrevieja.
Thomas, Christine. “A Translator Solves Two Puzzles Shrouded in Mystery.” San Francisco Chronicle 16 June 2002: RV6. Print. This enthusiastic review points out some of the conceptual aspects of the novel. Gale Resources
“José Carlos Somoza.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2007. Literature Resource Center. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. Open Web Sources
The author’s official Web site is mainly in Spanish, but some material is translated into English. The site also provides photos of the author and a look at the colorful covers of his many Spanish publications. http://www.josecarlossomoza.com/ For Further Reading
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Rev. of The Athenian Murders, by José Carlos Somoza. Kirkus Reviews 1 Apr. 2002: 459. Print. Rev. of The Athenian Murders, by José Carlos Somoza. Publishers Weekly 6 May 2002: 33. Print. Rev. of The Athenian Murders, by José Carlos Somoza. Times [London] 6 Feb. 2002: 12. Print. Langan, Michael D. “Grecian Formula.” Rev. of The Athenian Murders, by José Carlos Somoza. Buffalo News 25 Aug. 2002: F5. Print. Ponce, Pedro. Rev. of The Athenian Murders, by José Carlos Somoza. Review of Contemporary Fiction 23.1 (2003): 150+. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Gerling, David Ross. Rev. of The Athenian Murders, by José Carlos Somoza. World Literature Today 77.3/4 (2003): 148+. Print. Gerling notes the relationship of Somoza’s novel to several other Spanish works and points out influences from the author’s background as a psychiatrist. Miller, Laura. Rev. of The Athenian Murders, by José Carlos Somoza. Salon 20 June 2002. Web. 12 Sept. 2010. Miller’s appreciative review effectively represents the tone and style of the novel. Pye, Michael. “Gripping Like a Crossword Puzzle, but Not Quite a Thriller.” Scotsman [Edinburgh] 14 Jan. 2002: 15. Print. This review compares The Athenian Murders unfavorably to Umberto Eco’s historical murder-mystery The Name of the Rose.
66
Schifino, Martin. Rev. of The Athenian Murders, by José Carlos Somoza. Times Literary Supplement [London] 5 Apr. 2002: 28. Print. Schifino cites interesting aspects of the work but ultimately finds it unsuccessful.
Eco, Umberto. The Name of the Rose. Trans. William Weaver. New York: Everyman’s, 2006. Print. Set in a medieval monastery, Eco’s intricate mystery novel became a best seller and inspired a number of other postmodern mysteries. The Athenian Murders is frequently compared to it. Murdoch, Iris. The Fire and the Sun: Why Plato Banished the Artists. New York: Viking, 1990. Print. In this nonfiction study of Plato’s cave allegory, novelist and philosopher Iris Murdoch explores some of the same questions and ideas that arise in The Athenian Murders. Santas, Gerasimos X., ed. The Blackwell Guide to Plato’s Republic. Malden: Blackwell, 2006. Print. This collection of essays examines the cultural, literary, and philosophical backgrounds of The Republic. Written for the general reader, it provides a helpful understanding of concepts discussed in The Athenian Murders. Somoza, José Carlos. Zig Zag. New York: HarperCollins, 2007. Print. The third of Somoza’s novels to be published in English, Zig Zag is a mixture of science fiction, horror, and suspense. Centering on a project that allows physicists to view the past, it offers a different approach to the author’s vision of temporal interactions. Wechsler, Robert. Performing without a Stage: The Art of Literary Translation. North Haven: Catbird, 1998. Print. Wechsler’s book, which introduces the processes and problems associated with translating works of poetry and fiction, presents an interesting context in which to understand the unnamed Translator’s role in The Athenian Murders. Cynthia Giles
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Atonement By Ian McEwan
W Introduction Atonement presents a novel within a novel, supposedly written by its protagonist, Briony Tallis, a woman who spends her life searching for forgiveness for her past lies. The story is based on one fateful night when, as a thirteen-yearold girl, Briony’s accusation dooms the life of an innocent man. The book is divided into four sections: the first details the events that lead to Briony’s crime, while the final three demonstrate its long-term effects from various perspectives. The novel deals with betrayal, the toll that betrayal exacts on the psyches of both perpetrator and victim, and the horrors of war. The novel is perhaps most notable for its metafictional framework, which allows Ian McEwan to explore the nature of writing and, in particular, stories, and the god-like relationship between author and creation. Atonement questions whether a reader should ever trust an author, and examines how easily perceptions can be misconstrued and manipulated. Atonement was a finalist for the prestigious Man Booker Prize, and won the National Book Critics Circle Award, the Los Angeles Times Book Prize, and the W. H. Smith Literary Award, among others. It was named Book of the Year by many major newspapers, and Time magazine included it on their list of 100 greatest novels ever written.
W Literary and Historical Context
The first section of Atonement occurs in a stately manor home in the English countryside, in 1935. McEwan uses this idyllic, old-fashioned setting as a counterpoint to the horrors of the war that eventually overtake the country, while hinting that the roots of these later occurrences rest underneath the gentle façade of the opening portion. Additionally, the first section references the works of Jane
Austen, whose writing style and settings are reflected in the quaint country estate setting and the intricacies of social interactions and class distinctions explored by McEwan in this section. In the second section, the famous Battle of Dunkirk is used to illustrate the brutality of war. Despite the fact that the Battle of Dunkirk was considered a success, McEwan highlights the fate of the thousands of men who died there. After suffering one of the worst defeats in the history of the British army, British and French forces retreated to Dunkirk, where they were able to build a line of defense and evacuate over 330,000 Allied forces. This was deemed a “miracle” by the dean of St. Paul’s Church in England (Anderson). The combination of hope and despair surrounding this event beautifully parallels Briony’s fantasy that Robbie survived the battle, as well as the crushing revelation that he did not. The third section details the life of a nurse in London during the evacuations. Fearing that London would be destroyed by German bombings—known as the Blitz— millions of civilians were relocated to rural areas in England. Atonement includes fascinating information about the exodus, including such facts as the removal of street signs in hopes that it would confuse potential invading forces. Ironically, this added to the chaotic, confusing atmosphere of this frightening time. Over 40,000 people ultimately died in the bombings, including Briony’s sister, Cecilia, who is struck down while trying to save wounded men.
W Themes Atonement centers on the themes of morality, interpretation, loss, and a quest for redemption through literature. In McEwan’s words, “empathy . . . to feel what it is to be someone else . . . [is] the cornerstone of a moral system” (Childs). When Briony is a young girl at the start of the novel, she experiences an epiphany: “Was everyone else really as alive as she was? . . . Was being [her sister] Cecilia just as vivid an affair as being Briony” (34)? While
67 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Atonement
MAJOR CHARACTERS LOLA MARSHALL, at the start of the novel, is a haughty fifteenyear-old girl who is raped by the much older Paul Marshall while staying at the home of her aunt and uncle. When her cousin, Briony, assumes that the culprit is Robbie Turner, Lola remains silent, thus conspiring in a lie that sends Robbie to jail. Years later, she marries Paul. PAUL MARSHALL is the inventor of “Army Amo” chocolate bars, perfect for soldiers’ rations because they do not melt. While visiting the family home of his friend, Leon Tallis, he rapes fifteen-year-old Lola. The crime is blamed on Robbie Turner, and years later Paul marries Lola, thus forever burying their secret. BRIONY TALLIS, protagonist of the novel, is thirteen when the book opens and she accuses Robbie of assaulting Lola. As the book progresses, the narrative follows Briony’s experiences as a nurse during World War II, and then as a novelist in the book’s epilogue. CECILIA TALLIS is Briony’s older sister. She is in love with Robbie Turner, her family housekeeper’s brilliant son. Their burgeoning romance is thwarted, first by Briony’s lies, and then by World War II, when she becomes a nurse. EMILY TALLIS is mother to Briony, Cecilia, and Leon. For years, she uses her migraines as an excuse to distance herself from her children. LEON TALLIS is Briony and Cecelia’s loving older brother, who both girls idealize. He invites his friend, Paul Marshall, home with him, thus leading to the event that will ruin Robbie, Cecilia, Lola, and Briony. ROBBIE TURNER is an extremely intelligent young man, whose mother works as a housekeeper in the Tallis home. Robbie falls in love with Cecilia, but Briony blames him for Lola’s rape. He is sent to jail for three years, following which he dies of an infection received on the battlefields of France in World War II.
this is an incredibly profound realization for a child, Briony has a limited point of view. As Pilar Hidalgo explains it, her “perception is distorted by literature and an imperfect knowledge of the world.” She is unable to deciper events clearly, leading her to misinterpret Robbie’s letter to Cecilia. As a result, Briony labels Robbie a rapist, an erroneous conclusion that ruins the lives of Robbie, Cecilia, and Briony herself. As an adult, Briony attempts to atone for her crime by writing a novel in which she places herself in Robbie’s and Cecilia’s shoes and attempts to see events from their perspective. The irony, of course, is that no one can truly know what it is to be someone else. Ultimately the only “real” character of the book is Briony herself, who, on a meta level, is also fictional.
68
W Style Atonement weaves a seemingly straightforward, old-fashioned narrative with a metatextual framework that does not fully reveal itself until the end. According to Peter Mathews, the way McEwan structures the novel, each successive part “forces the reader to revise his or her understanding of what was revealed earlier, sowing seeds of doubt that make the text blossom into a set of irreconcilable uncertainties.” The first section, the only one divided into traditional chapters, combines a plot and setting reminiscent of a Jane Austen novel, along with psychological examination and technique redolent of Virginia Woolf’s writings. Woolf’s style involved the exploration of the sensations and perceptions of the human mind, often employing a technique referred to as stream-of-consciousness. At the end of Atonement, we learn that the first three parts of the novel comprise a book that Briony has written. In hindsight, it is apparent that McEwan hides clues about the structure of the book within the text. For example, in Part Three, Briony receives a rejection letter from an editor regarding a novella she has written. The editor explains that she has misused Woolf’s technique by following the style but neglecting to add plot or meaning to the work. Only later do we realize that the first section of Atonement is in fact the revised draft of Briony’s novella, including the changes suggested by her editor. The coda also reveals that the two lovers, Robbie and Cecilia, rather than being reunited, as depicted in Part Three, actually died in the war. Briony’s action is foreshadowed at the beginning of the book, in which, as a child, she writes a melodramatic play about lovers torn apart by tragedy and circumstance. Her play, The Trials of Arabella, can be seen as the entirety of Atonement in microcosm—Briony, the author, putting her characters through hell and finally bestowing a happy ending upon them.
W Critical Reception Upon its release, Atonement received near universal acclaim. It was short-listed for the Man Booker Prize, the James Tait Black Memorial Prize, and the Whitbread Book Award. It won the National Book Critics Circle Award, the Los Angeles Times Book Prize, the W. H. Smith Literary Award, the Boeke Prize, and the Santiago Prize for the European Novel. Additionally, it was selected as Best Book of the Year by Time, the Washington Post Book World, Boston Globe, Chicago Tribune, Village Voice, Entertainment Weekly, San Francisco Chronicle, Atlantic Monthly, and Seattle Times, and as a New York Times Book Review Editor’s Choice. Entertainment Weekly ranked the book on a list of 100 best books of the past 25 years, and both Time and the Observer included it on their lists of 100 best novels ever written. Tom Shone of the New York Times declared Atonement “McEwan’s most complete and compassionate work to date,” while the Observer praised it for the fascinating TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Atonement
questions it raises regarding the relationship between author and text: “If fiction is . . . a way of ordering the universe in which the writer is away in her—or his—thoughts, then is it a form of escapism, lacking all moral force?” Some critics took issue with McEwan’s metatextual framework. As Brian Finney explains, these people “criticize what they understand to be an essentially realist novel that at the end inappropriately resorts to a modish self-referentiality.” According to the critic, this interpretation ignores the nuance that McEwan has woven throughout the work from the start,that Briony isanauthor. Atonement, he argues,is“a work of fiction . . . concerned with the making of fiction. . . . Brought up on a diet of imaginative literature, [Briony] is too young to understand the dangers that can ensue from modeling one’s conduct on such an artificial world. . . . [Later, she] attempts to use fiction to correct the errors that fiction caused her to commit.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Anderson, Duncan. “Spinning Dunkirk.” World Wars In-Depth. BBC, 5 Nov. 2009. Web. 15 July 2010.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Born in Aldershot, England, Ian McEwan is one of Britain’s most famous and celebrated living authors. He is known for the experimental nature of his writing, as well as his career-long focus on subject matter that is sometimes regarded as amoral or unsavory. His early books, such as First Love, Last Rites, were often dubbed “literature of shock.” Over the years, McEwan’s work has been re-evaluated, and critics now agree that his writing is not devoid of morality but instead explores gray areas in order to define “ethical limits” (Childs 4-5). Most of his novels, from The Child in Time to his most acclaimed, Atonement, focus on “couples and families in . . . claustrophobic situations” (3). He uses literary, historical, and meta textual references to examine “individual reactions to moments of crisis” and to present “the tenderness and brutality of relationships without sentimentality” (6). Among his many awards, McEwan was short-listed six times for the Man Booker Prize, which he won for Amsterdam in 1998.
Refugees flee from the ruins of Dunkirk, France, following a Nazi bombardment. Some parts of Atonement take place in France during World War II. ª Bettmann/Corbis TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
69
Atonement
Childs, Peter. “Introduction.” The Fiction of Ian McEwan: A Reader’s Guide to Essential Criticism. Ed. Peter Childs. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2006. 1-7. Print. Finney, Brian. “Briony’s Stand against Oblivion: The Making of Fiction in Ian McEwan’s Atonement.” Journal of Modern Literature 27.3 (2004): 68+. Print. General OneFile. Web. 15 July 2010. Hidalgo, Pilar. “Memory and Storytelling in Ian McEwan’s Atonement.” Critique: Studies in Contemporary Fiction 46.2 (2005): 82+. Print. General OneFile. Web. 15 July 2010. Lee, Hermione. “If Your Memories Serve You Well: Little Wonder Ian McEwan’s Engrossing, Deep Novel Has Been Shortlisted for the Booker. This Highly Literary Family Saga Is His Best Yet.” Rev of Atonement, by Ian McEwan. Observer [London] 23 Sept. 2001: 16. Print. InfoTrac Custom Newspapers. Web. 17 July 2010. Mathews, Peter. “The Impression of a Deeper Darkness: Ian McEwan’s Atonement.” English Studies in Canada 32.1 (2006): 147+. Print. General OneFile. Web. 15 July 2010. McEwan, Ian. Atonement. New York: Anchor, 2001. Print. Shone, Tom. “White Lies.” Rev. of Atonement, by Ian McEwan. New York Times 10 Mar. 2002: n.p. NYTimes.com. Web. 17 July 2010.
Child in Time,’ ‘Black Dogs,’ ‘Enduring Love,’ and ‘Atonement.’ New York: Peter Lang, 2004. Print. This book analyzes characters throughout McEwan’s work, focusing on the ways in which they define their own worlds and narratives, and by so doing, try to become at peace with themselves. Stovel, Nora Foster. “Ian McEwan: Atonement.” International Fiction Review 31.1-2 (2004): 114+. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 17 July 2010. An extremely positive review of Atonement that discusses the relation between its form and function as a narrative. Wells, Juliette. “Shades of Austen in Ian McEwan’s Atonement.” Persuasions: The Jane Austen Journal 30 (2008): 101+. Print. General OneFile. Web. 15 July 2010. This essay examines the links between Jane Austen’s writing and Atonement, revealing some less obvious connections, as well as the parallels between Briony and Austen. Gale Resources
Fletcher, John. “Ian Russell McEwan.” British Novelists since 1960. Ed. Jay L. Halio. Detroit: Gale Research, 1983. Print. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 14. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 17 July 2010. “Overview: Atonement.” Novels for Students. Ed. Sara Constantakis. Vol. 32. Detroit: Gale, 2010. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 17 July 2010. Open Web Sources
Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Crosthwaite, Paul. “Speed, War, and Traumatic Affect: Reading Ian McEwan’s Atonement.” Cultural Politics 3.1 (2007): 51+. Print. Academic OneFile. Web. 15 July 2010. This essay examines posttraumatic stress and how it relates to the characters and events of Atonement. D’Angelo, Kathleen. “‘To Make a Novel’: The Construction of a Critical Readership in Ian McEwan’s Atonement.” Studies in the Novel 41.1 (2009): 88+. Print. General OneFile. Web. 14 July 2010. This fascinating essay explores how the literary references that McEwan weaves throughout Atonement help the perceptive reader unlock the text’s mysteries, and demonstrates how the structure of the work strengthens and echoes its themes.
Ian McEwan’s official website contains a wealth of information about McEwan, including biography, published works, and perhaps most useful, books about McEwan and his work, from various countries and in various languages. http://www.ianmcewan. com ContemporaryWriters.com features a page on Ian McEwan, including a comprehensive biography, list of awards, quotes from McEwan, and critical perspective on his writings. http://www.contempor arywriters.com/authors/?p=auth70 The BBC’s official site has an animated map illustrating the events that led up to the Battle of Dunkirk at http://www.bbc.co.uk/history/worldwars/ wwtwo/launch_ani_fall_france_campaign.shtml For Further Reading
Impastato, David. “Secular Sabbath: Unbelief in Ian McEwan’s Fiction.” Commonweal 136.18 (2009): 14+. Print. General OneFile. Web. 14 July 2010. This essay examines McEwan’s writings through the lens of New Atheism, a movement of which he is a part.
Austen, Jane. Northanger Abbey. London, 1817. Print. The first portion of Atonement is, in large part, an homage to this posthumously published novel by Jane Austen. Atonement opens with a quote from this book.
Schemberg, Claudia. Achieving ‘At-One-Ment’: Storytelling and the Concept of the Self in Ian McEwan’s ‘The
McEwan, Ian. First Love, Last Rites. New York: Vintage, 1994. Print. McEwan’s first published book, this set
70
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Atonement
of short stories helped earn him the nickname “Ian Macabre,” due to the stories’ preoccupation with shocking moments. Many of McEwan’s later works derive from themes explored in this collection. ———. Saturday. New York: Anchor, 2005. Print. Though a thriller, McEwan’s famous novel, Saturday, deals with similar issues of morality that drive Atonement and was acclaimed as being a powerful, post-September 11th story. Sebag-Montefore, Hugh. Dunkirk: Fight to the Last Man. Cambridge: Harvard UP, 2008. Print. This book is an incisive examination of the fateful Battle of Dunkirk, with which Part Two of Atonement is concerned. Woolf, Virginia. Mrs. Dalloway. New York: Harcourt, Brace, 1925. Print. Briony’s writing style is largely
informed by Virginia Woolf. Mrs. Dalloway, one of Woolf’s seminal works, demonstrates the author’s deft use of stream-of-consciousness, peering into her characters’ psyches to tell the story. Adaptations
Atonement. Dir. Joe Wright. Perf. Keira Knightley, James McAvoy, and Brenda Blethyn. Focus Features, 2007. Film. Released in 2007, the film version of Atonement won the Best Film of the Year award at the 61st British Academy Film Awards and was nominated for seven Academy Awards, winning one for Best Original Score. General critical response was positive, though many argued that the film was too literal a translation of the book. Robert Berg
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
71
Austerlitz By W. G. Sebald
W Introduction Published in the year of the author’s death, Austerlitz (2001) is the last of W. G. Sebald’s four experimental novels. At the heart of the tale is a lonely scholar’s return to his origins in Czechoslovakia, where he learns the fate of his birth parents after the German occupation of Prague in 1938. Austerlitz won the 2001 National Book Critics Award, among many other honors. Like its three predecessors, Austerlitz has been praised for its formal innovation and the dreamlike quality of its meditations on the horrors of Nazi aggression. The story unfolds through a series of chance encounters between the scholar—Jacques Austerlitz, an architectural historian—and an unnamed narrator. The pair first meet in the 1960s, in a train station in Antwerp, Belgium. They continue to run into each other through the mid-1970s before losing touch for twenty years. When they cross paths in 1996, Austerlitz is recovering from a nervous breakdown. He complains of a deepening sense of isolation, so the narrator records his friend’s life story, which occupies the majority of the novel. By tracing the free associations of Austerlitz’s imagination and following his exhaustive digressions, Sebald examines the workings of memory and the joys and sorrows—mostly the sorrows—of recovering one’s lost history.
W Literary and Historical Context
The broad sweep of Austerlitz takes into account the full range of the devastation World War II visited on Europe. Of all the subjects considered in the protagonist’s myriad ruminations, the one given the most attention is the Nazi occupation of Czechoslovakia in 1938. On September 29, 1938, Adolf Hitler called the leaders of France, Italy, and the United Kingdom to a meeting in Munich.
Without inviting or consulting Czechoslovakia, the participants ordered that the Sudetenland—the northeastern part of the country and home to many ethnic Germans—be ceded to Germany. The Czech government capitulated the following day. These events occurred six months after the Anschluss, when Hitler’s army violated the Treaty of Versailles and crossed the Austrian border. The occupiers were greeted by riotous ovations as they marched through the streets of Vienna. Sebald never mentions the Anschluss or the Munich Conference directly, but in the early part of the story, Austerlitz’s father, Maximilian Aychenwald, anticipates the escalation of the Nazi threat. On a business trip to Munich, he watches a film of a party rally “which confirmed his suspicions that, out of the humiliation from which the Germans had never recovered, they were now developing an image of themselves as a people chosen to evangelize the world.” In response to what he has seen, Aychenwald arranges to have his four-year-old son taken into foster care in the United Kingdom. Austerlitz’s parents enlist the Kindertransport program to send him by train out of Czechoslovakia. Also known as the Refugee Children Movement, this rescue mission transported nearly 10,000 Jewish children out of Nazi Germany. Most of the children survived, but few ever saw their parents again. Shortly after seeing her child off, Austerlitz’s mother is sent to Theresienstadt, a concentration camp in what is now the Czech Republic that the Nazis reserved for prominent Jews. The site served as a showcase for visiting foreign diplomats and was intended to counteract rumors that Jewish people were suffering and dying in forced labor camps.
W Themes Austerlitz is an intricate meditation on how individual identity is constructed and how the external world works to overwhelm it. Austerlitz grows up thinking his name is
72 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Austerlitz
Dafydd Elias, the name given him by his adoptive Welsh parents, who never mention his past. Although he is old enough to recall the solitary train ride to the United Kingdom and his time with his birth parents, Austerlitz has suppressed these memories; they return to him only during bouts of depression in adult life. Shortly after his secondary school headmaster tells him his real name, Austerlitz encounters the name in the historical record, which both excites and confuses him. He first learns of Napoleon’s victory over a much larger Russo-Austrian army at the Battle of Austerlitz and later discovers the name in more obscure contexts. For example, he finds out that Fred Astaire’s real name was Austerlitz, that the rabbi who circumcised Franz Kafka’s nephew was also named Austerlitz, and that a woman named Laura Austerlitz witnessed a crime in Trieste in 1944 and made a public statement about it over twenty years later. The connection to Napoleon bestows on the adolescent Austerlitz a grand sense of himself, but the other discoveries puzzle and disorient him, giving him a sense of being adrift in time. On many occasions Austerlitz ponders the idea of being lost, and often he cannot decide which is worse: feeling alone and cut off from the world or being unable to separate himself from it, doomed always to return to the familiar. One night he considers the habits of the moths that cling to his walls. He is amazed that if he does not put them back outside they will die. He speculates that they know they have lost their way and that they are paralyzed by fear. Austerlitz also marvels at carrier pigeons, who, he learns, will find their way back to their original homes even if they are set to flying in the dead of night during a snowstorm at sea. Such musings fill Austerlitz with a sense of wonder, but they also cause despair; he concludes that though humans always return to their past, they are not capable of understanding what they discover there. Regarding the human fascination with history, Austerlitz tells the narrator that “our concern is with preformed images already imprinted on our brains, images at which we keep staring while the truth lies elsewhere.”
MAJOR CHARACTERS JACQUES AUSTERLITZ is an architecture historian living in England who, after suffering a nervous breakdown in 1992, becomes obsessed with long-suppressed childhood memories. AGATA AUSTERLITZOVA, Austerlitz’s mother, is a talented Jewish opera singer. Soon after putting her young son on a train bound for the United Kingdom, she is sent to Theresienstadt, a concentration camp billed by the Gestapo as an artists’ colony. MAXIMILIAN AYCHENWALD, Austerlitz’s father, is a businessman and a prominent official in the Czech Social Democratic Party. Recognizing the danger that the rising tide of Nazism poses for Jews, he flees to Paris after sending his son to Britain. GWENDOLYN ELIAS and her husband adopt Austerlitz when he is four years old and raise the boy as Dafydd Elias in their home in Bala. Gwendolyn keeps house meticulously until she becomes ill; the house gradually falls into disarray, and Austerlitz is sent to boarding school. REVEREND ELIAS, Austerlitz’s adoptive father, is a grim Welsh minister famous among his congregation for his fire-andbrimstone sermons. After Gwendolyn dies, Reverend Elias loses his sanity and is sent to an asylum. GERALD FITZPATRICK is a younger student at Stower Grange; Austerlitz is supposed to haze the boy and instead befriends him. The two remain close well into adulthood, but Fitzpatrick, an astrophysicist and amateur pilot, dies in a plane crash. ANDRE HILARY is Austerlitz’s history teacher and the first person to discover his intellectual promise. Shortly after the headmaster at Stower Grange tells Dafydd Elias that his real name is Jacques Austerlitz, Hilary, by coincidence, delivers an animated and thorough lecture on Napoleon’s victory at the Battle of Austerlitz. The revelation of his true name and the lecture transform Austerlitz’s sense of identity. THE NARRATOR, unnamed in the novel, shares many traits with Austerlitz, most notably a fascination with architecture and a penchant for meandering, highly intellectual reflection.
W Style Amalgams of novel, essay, and memoir, Sebald’s fictional works defy classification. The author himself called his writing “prose of uncertain form”—a phrase that is quoted often in treatments of his work. Among the most obvious aspects of Sebald’s style are long paragraphs and the photographs he inserts in his texts. The first paragraph of Austerlitz is twenty-five pages long; others run over forty pages. A sentence in the middle of the book extends for seven pages. In these protracted constructions Austerlitz’s digressive meditations move seamlessly over such topics as his favorite history teacher, the architecture of labor camps, the movement of billiard balls, and the sudden death of a dear friend. In the
VERA RYSANOVA is Austerlitz’s nanny in Prague. She recognizes the middle-aged Austerlitz immediately when he visits her home. Now an elderly spinster, Vera tells Austerlitz who his parents were and what she knows of their fate. MARIE DE VERNEUIL is an architectural historian who travels with Austerlitz on some of his visits to Prague. She eventually leaves Austerlitz because she cannot cope with his remoteness.
Spectator magazine Anita Brookner writes, “Sebald’s method, somewhat frightening in itself, is to trace a development through a series of surreal but lucid
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
73
Austerlitz
A group of war refugees arrive in London. In Austerlitz, an unnamed narrator recalls the life of Jacques Austerlitz, a scholar and a friend who endured personal tragedy doing World War II. ª Hulton-Deutsch Collection/Corbis
digressions, each one spiraling out of the last, until a conclusion of some sort is reached.” Instead of using paragraph and chapter breaks and dialogue, Sebald punctuates his narrative with a haunting collection of black-and-white photographs of doorways, vast ceilings, furniture, people with unfathomable expressions, ledgers, stamps, schedules, and a multitude of other articles from daily life. Rather than enhancing the meaning of the elegant, philosophically rich prose, however, the mundane articles in the photos add to the dreamlike quality of the book. For example, following Austerlitz’s remarks on billiard balls, Sebald inserts a twopage photo with a dark ball on the left and the cue ball on the right. Even though it is an accurate visual representation of what has just been described, the photo is tangential to the corresponding thought. The combined effect of the prose and photographs is to locate Austerlitz and Sebald’s other works somewhere between fiction and nonfiction. While his previous books
74
have a more conspicuous autobiographical quality (they include pictures of the author and use his name in the text), Austerlitz is nevertheless grounded in the historical record. Mirela Roncevic notes in the Library Journal that “the black-and-white photographs scattered throughout do not add to the depth of the story, but they do add to its genuineness, serving to validate the events and reconstruct the novel as a tangible historical document. Ultimately, the narrative transcends fiction and becomes history.”
W Critical Reception Austerlitz has received overwhelmingly positive reviews. Many critics assigned the book a place at the head of the canon of Holocaust literature almost immediately after its publication. Richard Eder remarks in the New York Times Book Review that the author “stands with Primo Levi as the prime speaker of the Holocaust.” Writing in the New TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Austerlitz
Republic, John Banville describes the book as “nothing less than a chronicle of the end of a civilization. Europe, Sebald is telling us, committed suicide in the first half of the twentieth century, and what remains is, for all the carefully applied cosmetics, a lifeless object of desperate veneration and uneasy nostalgia.” Many critics also consider Austerlitz to be the finest work in Sebald’s oeuvre. Brookner, for instance, calls it “the most accomplished of Sebald’s works,” praising in particular the novel’s “sense of displacement” and “blend of conscious and unconscious memory and observation.” Gabriele Annan concurs, observing in the New York Review of Books that “It’s not the story so much that takes hold of the reader: it’s the descriptions and the meditations, which can be hallucinatory in their effect. This is true of all his books, but in Austerlitz the proportion of rumination and evocation to narrative is larger than ever.” Praise for the quality of the translation has also been uniformly high. Banville asserts that Sebald’s new translator, Anthea Bell, outdoes her predecessor Michael Hulse (whose translations of Sebald were also well received): “Austerlitz, in Bell’s pristine translation, strikes a more profound and more moving note than that sounded in the earlier books.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Annan, Gabriele. “Ghost Story.” New York Review of Books 1 Nov. 2001: 26-27. Rpt. in Contemporary Literary Criticism. Ed. Jeffrey W. Hunter. Vol. 194. Detroit: Gale, 2005. Banville, John. “The Rubble Artist.” New Republic 26 Nov. 2001: 35-38. Rpt. in Contemporary Literary Criticism. Ed. Jeffrey W. Hunter. Vol. 194. Detroit: Gale, 2005. Brookner, Anita. Rev. of Austerlitz, by W. G. Sebald. Spectator 6 Oct. 2001: 64. Eder, Richard. “Excavating a Life.” New York Times Book Review 28 Oct. 2001: 10. Roncevic, Mirela. Rev. of Austerlitz, by W. G. Sebald. Library Journal 15 Oct. 2001: 110. Sebald, W. G. Austerlitz. Trans. Anthea Bell. New York: Modern Library, 2001. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Brockmeier, Jens. “Austerlitz’s Memory.” Partial Answers: Journal of Literature and the History of Ideas 6.2 (2008): 347-67. Web. 11 Sept. 2010. In an examination of Sebald’s treatment of time and memory, Brockmeier argues that in the novel, all moments exist simultaneously. The result is that human memory cannot reconstruct a knowable past and is therefore in perpetual disarray.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR W(infried) G(eorg) Sebald was born on May 18, 1944, in Wertach im Allgäu, Germany. He died in a car accident near his home in Norwich, England, on December 14, 2001; he was fifty-seven and at the height of his literary powers. Sebald was a professor of European literature at the University of East Anglia in Norwich from 1970 to his death. An accomplished scholar, he did not begin publishing fiction until he was in his midforties. He produced four autobiographical novels to widespread critical acclaim. Raised in post-World War II Germany, Sebald grew up confounded by the lingering horrors of the Holocaust and the Allied firebombing of urban Germany. Claiming he found the writing and research therapeutic, he revisits this period of his life in his major works, combining memory, historical accounts, old pictures, and photocopies of documents into a haunting meditation on the aftermath of war. Aside from Austerlitz, the works on which Sebald’s reputation rests are Schwindel (1990; Vertigo, 1999), Die Ausgewanderten (1992; The Emigrants, 1996), and Die Ringe des Saturn (1995; The Rings of Saturn, 1998).
Byatt, A. S. “Only Connect.” New Statesman 15 Oct. 2001: 52. Byatt’s analysis focuses on the moment Austerlitz discovers his true surname and the connections he then makes between his name and events and people from history. Lewis, Tess. “W. G. Sebald: The Past Is Another Country.” New Criterion 20.4 (2001): 85+. Lewis contends that of the signature aspects of Sebald’s fiction—including his formal innovations, his blending of literary genres, and the free associations of his digressive narratives—the most important is the manner in which his narrator remembers the dead as guides through history. Madden, Patrick. “W. G. Sebald: Where Essay Meets Fiction.” Fourth Genre: Explorations in Nonfiction 10.2 (2008): 169-75. Web. 11 Sept. 2010. Madden offers cogent summaries of Sebald’s four major novels, comparing the ways in which each straddles the divide between fiction and nonfiction. Pane, Samuel. “Trauma Obscura: Photographic Media in W. G. Sebald’s Austerlitz.” Mosaic 38.1 (2005): 37+. This analysis maintains that the apparently benign photographs of everyday objects placed throughout the novel emphasize the horror of the narrative, making the Nazi aggression, by comparison, even more incomprehensible. Zilcosky, John. “Lost and Found: Disorientation, Nostalgia, and Holocaust Melodrama in Sebald’s Austerlitz.” MLN 121.3 (2006): 679-98. Web. 11 Sept. 2010. Zilcosky draws a distinction between
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
75
Austerlitz
Austerlitz and Sebald’s three previous works of fiction, arguing that Austerlitz is the closest in structure and content to a traditional novel. Gale Resources
Landon, Philip. Rev. of Austerlitz, by W. G. Sebald. Review of Contemporary Fiction 21.3 (2001): 196. Rpt. in Contemporary Literary Criticism. Ed. Jeffrey W. Hunter. Vol. 194. Detroit: Gale, 2005. “W(infried) G(eorg) Sebald.” Contemporary Authors Online.CengageGale,2005. Biography Resource Center. Web. 31 Aug. 2010. “W. G. Sebald (1944-2001).” Contemporary Literary Criticism. Ed. Jeffrey W. Hunter. Vol. 194. Detroit: Gale, 2005. 253-348. Literature Criticism Online. Web. 31 Aug. 2010. Open Web Sources
The blog Vertigo: Collecting & Reading W. G. Sebald reprints an interview with Sebald conducted by Jens Mühling. It was originally published in the journal Pretext in 2003. In the interview Sebald speaks about teaching creative writing, why he avoids contemporary literature, and how he copes with writer’s block. http://sebald.wordpress.com/2008/02/19/ the-permanent-exile-of-wg-sebald-part-1 Maya Jaggi’s September 2001 interview with Sebald at London’s Queen Elizabeth Hall was the author’s last public appearance in Britain. He discusses several of his sources for Austerlitz, including the three people on whom the character Jacques Austerlitz is based. The Guardian’s Web site offers an edited transcript of the conversation. http://www.guardian.co.uk/education/ 2001/dec/21/artsandhumanities.highereducation The blog Writer Unboxed presents an interview with Anthea Bell, the translator of Austerlitz. Although much of the conversation is about Bell’s work translating young adult writers, she gives a detailed account of her effort to preserve the sound and style of Sebald’s German. http://writerunboxed.com/ 2006/08/18/interview-anthea-bell-part-1 University of Missouri-Kansas City law professor Douglas O. Linder’s Web site Famous Trials includes detailed information on the Nuremberg Trials. Linder provides links to transcripts from the proceedings against Nazi war criminals, images of the courtroom, and profiles of the defendants. http://www.law.umkc.edu/faculty/ projects/ftrials/nuremberg/nuremberg.htm For Further Reading
Allen, William Sheridan. The Nazi Seizure of Power: The Experience of a Single German Town 1922-1945. Danbury: Children’s, 1984. Print. Allen’s detailed account of the workings of the Nazi propaganda machine chronicles how the people of Northeim, Germany, became convinced that the Nazi Party
76
could lead Germany out of its economic recession and back to greatness. Appelfeld, Aharon. Badenheim 1939. Trans. Dalya Bilu. New York: Quartet, 1997. Print. Aharon Appelfeld is a concentration camp survivor and one of Israel’s foremost living writers in Hebrew. His novel, set in an idyllic resort town in Austria in the months before the outbreak of World War II, portrays Jewish visitors who ignore rumors of the deportation of fellow Jews to labor camps. Grass, Günter. The Tin Drum. New York: Vintage, 2005. Print. German Nobel Prize-winner Günter Grass’s masterpiece recounts the life of Oscar Matzerath, a three-foot-tall drummer boy who willfully stalls his growth at the age of three and travels through warravaged Germany and Poland recording the atrocities perpetrated by the Nazis. Jacobson, Dan. Heshel’s Kingdom. Chicago: Northwestern UP, 1999. Print. Jacobson’s autobiographical work describes a quest similar to that of Sebald’s character Austerlitz. Researching the life of his grandfather Rabbi Yisrael Yehoshua Melamed, Jacobson travels from his home in South Africa to Lithuania, where his grandfather died soon after World War I. At the conclusion of Austerlitz, the narrator begins reading this book, which Austerlitz had given him at one of their early meetings. Levi, Primo. If This Is a Man. Trans. Stuart Woolf. New York: Everyman, 2000. Print. Italian chemist and novelist Primo Levi’s account of the ten months he spent in Auschwitz is regarded by critics and many fellow writers as among the most profound memoirs of the Holocaust. Sebald, W. G. The Rings of Saturn. Trans. Michael Hulse. New York: New Directions, 1998. Print. After having been hospitalized following a mental collapse, Sebald’s unnamed narrator in The Rings of Saturn begins a walking tour of Suffolk County, England. He finds patterns of destruction and loss in nearly everything he sees. His thoughts move back and forth between the landscape and human history as he contemplates such topics as China’s opium wars, the novelist Joseph Conrad’s suffering, the herring industry, and floundering economies in seaside towns. Troller, Norbert. Theresienstadt: Hitler’s Gift to the Jews. Ed. Joel Shatzky. Raleigh: U of North Carolina P, 2004. Print. Troller’s memoir covers his two years in Theresienstadt. Many Jewish artists and performers went voluntarily to the supposed model ghetto rich in cultural life. Troller was deported to Auschwitz when he was discovered smuggling art out of the camp that depicted the true conditions under which the inhabitants lived. Joe Campana
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Await Your Reply By Dan Chaon
W Introduction
W Literary and Historical
Dan Chaon’s Await Your Reply (2009) contains a complex plot that revolves around characters assuming different identities. Diagnosed with schizophrenia as a teenager, Hayden Cheshire leaves his twin brother in Ohio and travels the world assuming different identities. As George Orson, Hayden leaves Ohio with his student Lucy Lattimore and heads to a deserted motel in Nebraska. Promising Lucy a life of travel and wealth, George obtains a large sum of money, two new identities, Brooke and David Fremden, and two plane tickets to Africa. After a few days, Lucy encounters men in the hotel lobby who are looking for George, whom, they claim, ripped them off with a money scam. Another identity Hayden assumes is that of Jay Kozelek, father to Ryan Schulyer who lives in Council Bluffs, Iowa. Jay contacts Ryan and persuades him to leave his adopted parents and come to rural Michigan. Jay concocts a scheme that involves Ryan’s assuming various identities that allow him to travel and transport money. This, too, ends badly as two men find Jay. One of the men cuts off Ryan’s hand after Jay refuses to tell him where the real Jay is located. Chaon alternates these chapters with the story of Miles Cheshire, Hayden’s brother in Ohio. Miles has spent years searching for Hayden, and it is through Miles’s recollections that readers uncover details about Hayden’s multiple identities. Miles resumes his search after receiving a letter from Hayden indicating that he is in Inuvik, Canada. Miles travels to Canada and meets up with Lydia Barrie. Lydia’s sister, Rachel Barrie, has taken off with her fiancé, Miles Spady, who Lydia determines is Hayden.
Chaon’s haunting story is reminiscent of authors such as Stephen King, Shirley Jackson, and J. R. Tolkien. Starting the story with unclear plot connections, Chaon, much like King and Jackson, leads readers through plot twists to reveal the connections between the characters. Writer Ray Bradbury, Chaon’s mentor, also influenced Chaon’s writing style. Well-known for his fantasy, horror, and science fiction novels, such as Fahrenheit 451, Bradbury incorporated imaginative science fiction scenes and suspense in his novels. Paralleling the efforts of his mentor, Chaon weaves together three suspenseful plots that keep his readers guessing about how plot components connect. Ira Levin, author of Rosemary’s Baby and The Stepford Wives, and Thomas Tyron, author of The Other, a classic story of scary twins, also influenced Chaon in his use of twins and elusive identities. Most of Chaon’s novel is set in Ohio and Michigan. Another location is the LightHouse Motel in Nebraska, where the story of George and Lucy takes place. Chaon’s interest in this location stems childhood memories at Lake McConaughy in Nebraska. As a result of reservoirs and dams, several towns were flooded and once the lakes dried up, the communities became ghost towns. Chaon also relies on the Internet as a historical context for his story. Chaon takes his title from a 1980s Nigerian Internet money scam, known as a 419, which refers to the article of the Nigerian Criminal Code. The scam involved unemployed university students assuming different identities to targeting companies in the West for money. Copycat scams followed with e-mails posted from Africa, Asia, and Eastern Europe requesting that receivers send money.
Context
77 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Await Your Reply
MAJOR CHARACTERS HAYDEN CHESHIRE grows up with his twin brother Miles in Cleveland, Ohio. Diagnosed with schizophrenia, Hayden leaves Ohio and assumes different identities, including George Orson and Jay Kozelek. MILES CHESHIRE, Hayden’s twin brother, follows in his father’s footsteps and works in a magic store in Cleveland. LUCY LATTIMORE, an eighteen-year-old orphan who lives in Pompey, Ohio, with her sister, takes off with George, her high school history teacher, for the Lighthouse Motel in Nebraska, where he finds them new identities and a large amount of cash. RYAN SCHULYER, who was adopted in Council Bluffs, Iowa, discovers that his biological father Ryan is his adopted mother’s brother.
W Themes In Await Your Reply, Dan Chaon constructs an unsettling story to suggest that the ability to create virtual identities online dehumanizes people. Chaon uses a twin, an orphan, and an adopted person to explore the nature of identity and how it has changed with advancements in technology. Growing up, Hayden and Miles are close as twins, but after Hayden is diagnosed with schizophrenia, Hayden begins to shift in and out of realty and leaves home. In this storyline, Chaon explores how a mentally ill twin dominates the other twin’s existence, and as a result, the healthy twin is also at risk for not being able to establish his separate identity. Lucy also has a hard time figuring out who she is. Her parents die in a car accident, so Lucy lives with her older sister. Realizing that Pompey is not in her future, Lucy leaves town with George, who was her history teacher in high school. George promises Lucy a new life full of money and travel, but it involves their leaving the country on the run with new identities. Lucy struggles with her decision to give up her identity and abandon her old life. Ryan’s story also involves issues of identity. Feeling his life has been a fraud after he finds out that his adoptive mother’s brother, Jay, is his biological father, Ryan leaves to go and work for Jay without telling anyone. His family and friends conclude he drowned; Ryan follows funeral news and tributes to him on the Internet and decides to stay and work for Jay by assuming a different identity. Chaon intertwines the stories of Miles, Lucy, and Ryan with that of the presence of Hayden, who to some degree never exists as Hayden after the first few chapters.
78
For years, Hayden slips into people’s lives by pretending to be different people in order to try on different identities. Once things change or go badly, Hayden simply buys a new identity and moves onto a different life. Through the character of Hayden, Chaon suggests that one negative effect of technology is the isolation it can create. With the isolation comes the ability to create new identities through online avatars and personas.
W Style Much like his mentor and his favorite authors, Chaon creates a plot full of inconclusive connections between several storylines. These gaps in the plot allow Chaon to build suspense by withholding the true identities of some characters. To emphasize the isolation of his characters, Chaon minimizes the emotional connections between characters. However, Chaon chooses certain moments for expression of emotion by using eloquent phrasing. For example, Lucy feels “a wavering shadow passing over her once again, all the different people she herself had wanted to become, all the sadness and anxiety that she had been trying not to think about now shifting above her like an iceberg.”
W Critical Reception With great success surrounding his early novels Among the Missing and You Remind Me of Me, critics were prepared to appreciate Dan Chaon’s use of plot twists and characters in Await Your Reply. Steven Almond in the Los Angeles Times noted that Chaon’s novel contains eloquently worded phrasing, such as “the faint scent of some mildly floral businesslike perfume” that sets the novel apart from works by other horror and science fiction writers. However, Almond decided that the early chapters are “too calculated” and that withholding the basic facts actually takes away from the story rather than enhances it. Alexander Cuadros of the Boston Globe concurred with Almond and suggested the Await Your Reply is “a fast, careless novel” because of Chaon’s use of thriller conventions to attract readers. Lucinda Rosenfeld of the New York Times disagreed with Cuadros’s charge that Chaon’s plot is weak. She argued that Chaon’s use of “intricate and suspenseful plotting” is a credit to Chaon’s ability to craft a suspenseful novel. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Almond, Steve. “Await Your Reply: A Novel by Dan Chaon.” Rev. of Await Your Reply, by Dan Chaon. latimes.com. Los Angeles Times 23 Aug. 2009. Web. 24 Sept. 2010. Chaon, Dan. Await Your Reply. New York: BallantineRandom House, 2009. Print. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Await Your Reply
Cuadros, Alexander. “Reply Goes for Cheap Thrill.” Rev. of Await Your Reply, by Dan Chaon. boston.com. Boston Globe 10 Oct. 2009. Web. 24 Sept. 2010. Rosenfeld, Lucinda. “Multiple Lives.” Rev. of Await Your Reply, by Dan Chaon. nytimes.com. New York Times 20 Aug. 2009. Web. 24 Sept. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Maslin, Janet. “Who Are These People? Well, That Depends.” Rev. of Await Your Reply, by Dan Chaon. nytimes.com. New York Times 19 Aug. 2009. Web. 24 Sept. 2010. Explores Chaon’s use of characters and plot to create suspense. Nawotak, Edward. “Novel Boots Up Intrigue with 3 Storylines.” Rev. of Await Your Reply, by Dan Chaon. Statesmen.com. Statesmen 23 Aug. 2009. Web. 24 Sept. 2010. Critiques Chaon’s use of plot to propel his three storylines. Tsong, Nicole. “Await Your Reply: Dan Chaon’s Novel of Shifting Identity.” Rev. of Await Your Reply, by Dan Chaon. seattletimes.nwsource.com. Seattle Times 11 Oct. 2009. Web. 24 Sept. 2010. Addresses Chaon’s recasting of his characters’ identities.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Born in Omaha, Nebraska, on June 11, 1964, Dan Chaon received his BA in 1986 from Northwestern University and his MA from Syracuse University in 1990. Prior to the publication of Await Your Reply, Chaon published three other books: the collections Fitting Ends and Other Stories and Among the Missing and the novel You Remind Me of Me. Chaon was a finalist for the National Magazine Award in Fiction in 2002 and 2007. As of 2010, Chaon taught at Oberlin College.
Gale Resources
“Dan Chaon.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Literature Resource Center. Web. 30 Sept. 2010. http://go.galegroup.com/ps/i.do? &id=GALE%7CH1000149004& v=2.1&u=itsbtrial&it=r&p=LitRC&sw=w Open Web Sources
Dan Chaon’s personal homepage, available at http:// www.danchaon.com, includes information about Chaon’s books and events.
Dan Chaon, author of Await Your Reply. Ulf Andersen/Getty Images TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
79
Await Your Reply
National Public Radio, available at http://www.npr. org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=112292650, includes Maureen Corrigan’s interview with Chaon about plot twists in Await Your Reply.
Morris, Chris. The Hanging Figure: On Suspense and the Films of Alfred Hitchcock. Santa Barbara: Praeger, 2002. Print. Includes insight into Hitchcock’s filming techniques.
PBS News Hour, available at http://www.pbs.org/ newshour/art/blog/2009/08/secrets-and-lies-inawait-your-reply.html, includes an interview of Chaon in which he discusses family, plot, and cinematic influences on his writing.
Snyder, Kurt. Me, Myself, and Them. New York: Oxford UP, 2007. Print. Provides insight into schizophrenia.
For Further Reading
Browder, Laura. Slippery Characters: Ethnic Impersonators and American Identities. Chapel Hill: U of North Carolina P, 2000. Print. Examines books presented as autobiographies written by people who are not who they claim to be.
Stickley, Jim. The Truth about Identity Theft. Upper Saddle River: Pearson Education, 2009. Print. Covers such topics as phishing and vishing, no-tech identity theft, trash as a means for identity theft, and identity theft in plain view. Wood, Andrew F., and Matthew J. Smith. Online Communication: Linking Technology, Identity, and Culture. Mahwah: Erlbaum, 2005. Print. Addresses the social implications of technology.
Klein, Barbara. Not All Twins Are Alike: Psychological Profiles of Twinship. Westport: Praeger, 2003. Print. Written by an identical twin with personal experience and research combined.
80
Rachel V. Smydra
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Ballad of Desmond Kale By Roger McDonald
W Introduction Roger McDonald’s ninth novel, The Ballad of Desmond Kale (2005), is a long historical novel about the first settlement efforts of the Australian Outback in the 1830s. The sheep farmers who ventured into this unknown territory turned their wool into gold and attracted expansion from the coastal cities into the wilderness. McDonald tells the story with characters of all classes and stations, both in Australia and England, depicting the early social and economic history of Sydney while spinning a captivating tale of adventure and romance. Central to this story is the pursuit of an escaped convict and expert sheep breeder, Desmond Kale, by an abusive missionary parson and magistrate, Matthew Stanton, who is obsessed with the idea of owning massive amounts of land and huge numbers of prize sheep. Everyone else in the book is either related to or working with these two figures. Rumors of Kale thriving in the Outback with a valuable flock of sheep turn into a mythical ballad sung by Irish colonists who admire his rebellion and are inspired by his success. The Stanton character is based on Samuel Marsden, prominent in Australian history as a profligate missionary, magistrate, and sheep breeder. Greed, hypocritical behavior, cunning, daring, and the pursuit of love and dreams are thematically sewn into a story that includes shipwrecks, prisons, colonial politics, and British society, and extensive information about sheep. The Ballad of Desmond Kale won the Miles Franklin Award in 2006 and the Adelaide Festival Prize for Fiction in 2008.
W Literary and Historical Context
In 1788 the Australian governor brought sheep to the new colony to supply meat, and some others followed,
but they were not suited to the Australian environment and soon died out. In 1797, at the Cape of Good Hope, captains Henry Waterhouse and William Kent each bought thirteen merino sheep, a breed known for its heavy fleece and fine wool that had thrived in Spain for two thousand years. These animals were likely descended from the king of Spain’s flock. Kent’s sheep were lost, but in Sydney, Waterhouse distributed his sheep to Kent, John Macarthur, Captain Rowley, and the infamous Samuel Marsden. Macarthur crossed his six merinos with the Bengal flock he had started in 1794 and learned that proper breeding could produce fine wool, so he procured more merinos. Macarthur, Waterhouse, Marsden, and William Cox thereafter pioneered fine-wool production in New South Wales with Macarthur promoting their product in London. Macarthur’s work was later honored with his picture on the two-dollar bill. By 1810 there were nearly 33,000 sheep of varying mixes in Australia. Explorers crossing the Blue Mountain in 1813 found good pastures and rivers to the west. Therefore, in 1815, Cox built a railroad across the mountains allowing settlers to expand sheep raising northward into Queensland, arriving in Adelaide in 1838. Other territorial expansions resulted in the sheep industry being established in every colony by the 1830s. Despite a drought that killed more than 200,000 sheep in 1843 and 1844, by 1879 there were a million sheep in Western Australia alone. Seventyfive percent of modern Australian sheep are classed as a separate breed of Australian merinos. Although wool production in the early 2000s is no longer the leading industry, Australia is the world’s largest exporter of wool, including most of the fine apparel wools.
W Themes McDonald titled his novel after the ballad that forms the structure of his book and establishes the theme of opposition to authority and rebellion against oppression
81 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Ballad of Desmond Kale
MAJOR CHARACTERS BLAISE CRIBBE, Tom’s stepbrother, is the sickly top wool expert in England who was once romantically involved with Dolly Stanton. DESMOND KALE, convict and master sheep breeder, escapes with Stanton’s prize sire and takes Rankine’s sheep into the Outback, becoming a legend in the process. MEG INCHCAPE, Desmond’s beautiful, kindly daughter, is a laundress for the military and Tom’s love interest. WARREN INCHCAPE, Meg’s son by the man who explored the Outback with Kale, has inherited his grandfather’s talent with sheep and is apprenticed to Stanton. PAOLO MORENO, called Paul Lorenze, is a Spanish shepherd who helped Rankine bring sheep from Spain, aided Kale’s escape, and becomes overseer during Stanton’s absence. TOM RANKINE, called Ugly Tom, is a tough, wily, and romantic New South Wales Ranger, juggling his favored position with the governor and conniving with Kale. DOLLY PRINGLE STANTON is the parson’s independent, cunning wife who loves Titus, hates Warren, dotes on Ivy, and remains loyal to Matthew. IVY STANTON is Dolly and Matthew’s headstrong daughter and Titus’s friend who encounters trouble with a naval officer on the voyage to England. MATTHEW STANTON is the arrogant, pious, ambitious “flogging parson” and magistrate who is obsessed with having the best sheep and finding Kale. TITUS STANTON is the aboriginal boy adopted by the Stantons, who is Warren’s close friend and is loved by Dolly and Ivy, but abused by the parson.
as expressed in a traditional Irish ballad. Kale’s ballad is an underground boast celebrating the triumph of a renegade and giving hope to the downtrodden while irritating those in power. Dreams and ambition are also important themes in the book. These ideas are connected to Kale’s dream of a new life of freedom and prosperity. In contrast, Stanton and his ilk have ambitions of great wealth and power. Australia was a whole new continent offering opportunities to those who were willing to endure the hardships. Even though the first colonists were convicts, they had a chance to set off eventually on their own. Succcess was unlikely because of the nearly insurmountable competition from the wealthy and powerful, at least until Kale came along. Until then, few dared to wander more than a few miles from Parramatta because the land seemed so forbidding, but Kale showed that there were vast
82
expanses where people and sheep could thrive. Once the trail was blazed, multitudes followed, and an enormous Australian sheep industry was born. The endeavor took good men and women capable of cunning and determination such as those exemplified by the characters in McDonald’s story. The hypocrisy of Christian endeavors is another theme of the novel. Instead of bringing love and redemption to the convicts and aborigines, Stanton used his mission ministry as a cover for his true ambitions as a sheep farmer. He preached to the convict laborers on Sunday but brutalized and exploited them during the week. Dolly adopted Titus, an aboriginal boy, to save him from savagery and perdition but did not extend the same Christian attitude to Warren.
W Style The framework of The Ballad of Desmond Kale is the novel’s most noticeable stylistic choice. Kale is not part of the main narrative except in a very few appearances at the beginning and the end of the book, yet the rest of the story involves all those who are connected to Kale and his sheep and his legend. This legend is told throughout the colony by means of an Irish ballad, and McDonald uses the titles of the eight verses or choruses to introduce each section of this epic tale. McDonald also makes the break in setting between Australia and England exactly halfway through the choruses. Concurrent to Kale, the narrative stems from Parson Stanton and his multilevel relationships with various entities in Australia and England. McDonald’s language is an impediment as well as a triumph. While the nineteenth-century style, vocabulary, and local idioms make for difficult reading, McDonald’s ability to replicate this form of language as if he had lived during those times and foreshadow the Gaelic, Spanish, Yiddish, and aboriginal influences on Australian English is impressive. This authentic language from the 1830s makes the already well-developed characters more authentic even though dialogue is sparse. McDonald incorporates a number of subplots into the narrative. These include Tom and Meg’s love story, a feud between stepbrothers Tom and Blaise, an unwed pregnancy, a shipwreck, the role of the Josephs family, the adventures of Titus and Warren, and government intrigues. In addition, McDonald provides extensive details about wool and sheep breeding.
W Critical Reception Comments from the critics about The Ballad of Desmond Kale tended to repeat certain observations; for example, reviewers have lauded the clever way that the novel is all about Kale yet not about Kale. A common complaint TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Ballad of Desmond Kale
concerned McDonald’s portrayal of the aborigines—that they are stereotypical and only background figures, except for Titus who lives in both worlds. A further complaint by reviewers was that the nineteenth-century language and Australian idioms make the novel difficult to read. Beyond these two negatives, the critics otherwise raved about the novel’s vividly drawn characters who become involved in greed, duplicity, redemption, and a compelling love story. In fact, Luise Toma, in an article published by M/C Reviews, declared that McDonald had become “the king of historical fiction and a supreme genius of creating landscapes so powerful you can smell the dust and wave away flies whilst you’re reading.” Katherine England, in her review in the Adelaide Advertiser, agreed, asserting that the book is “vibrant in its portrayal of the fascinating but unforgiving Australian bush that imprisons all but the most intrepid.” Luke Beesley, in a review that appeared in the Brisbane Courier Mail, stated that “[t]hirst for the reunion of separated characters, and the fate of Kale’s movements, spices the narrative tension.” Beesley concluded: “It’s a great yarn, craftily written, superbly edited for pace and humour and full of insight.”
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Born on June 23, 1941, in Young, New South Wales, Roger McDonald was the middle son of a Presbyterian minister, Hugh Fraser McDonald, and the historian Lorna McDonald. After a childhood in small towns, McDonald earned a BA in education in 1962 from the University of Sydney. He taught briefly, then worked as an educational radio/television producer and as an editor with the University of Queensland Press. His first two books were collections of poetry, but between 1975 and 2010, he published no poetry. Instead, with the help of a Literature Board fellowship, he worked part time as a poetry editor (1976-1980) and in 1979 completed his first novel, 1915, which won several awards and was made into a seven-part ABC television series in 1982. He also wrote various nonfiction works and screenplays. Between 1980 and 2010, McDonald lived mostly near Braidwood with stints in Sydney and New Zealand.
A herd of sheep moves to a new pasture. The Ballad of Desmond Kale is a fictionalized story about the early settlement of the Australian Outback by sheep farmers in the 1930s. Lee Torrens/Shutterstock.com
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
83
The Ballad of Desmond Kale BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Beesley, Luke. “Perfect Pitch in this Wild Colonial Yarn.” Rev. of The Ballad of Desmond Kale, by Roger McDonald. Brisbane Courier 26 Nov. 2005: M05. Print. England, Katherine. “History Comes Alive.” Rev. of The Ballad of Desmond Kale, by Roger McDonald. Adelaide Advertiser 3 Dec. 2005: W12. Print. McDonald, Roger. The Ballad of Desmond Kale. New York: Random House, 2007. Print. Toma, Luise. “Literature: The Ballad of Desmond Kale by Roger McDonald.” Rev. of The Ballad of Desmond Kale, by Roger McDonald. media-culture.org. M/C Media & Culture 15 Sept. 2006. Web. 23 Aug. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Bode, Katherine. “‘Opportunistic Transpositions and Elisions’: Roger McDonald’s The Ballad of Desmond Kale; or, the Fiction Question: Who Owns Stories?” Antipodes 22.2 (2008): 89. Print. Argues that McDonald idealizes equality and freedom but conceals aggression and rejection of women and minorities in Australian history. Boomert. “The Ballad of Desmond Kale, by Roger McDonald.” Rev. of The Ballad of Desmond Kale, by Roger McDonald. Boomerangbooks.com.au. Boomerang Books 7 Jan. 2010, Web. 4 Sept. 2010. Praises McDonald’s many excellent character portrayals but finds the language pretentious. Jacobson, Michael. “A Wooly Tale of Early Australia.” Rev. of The Ballad of Desmond Kale, by Roger McDonald. Gold Coast Bulletin 24 Dec. 2005: 016. Print. Lists the topics and types of characters in the novel then focuses on Tom Rankine’s role and McDonald’s research on colonial Australia. Myers, Seth. “Sheep and Contradiction Define Colonial Australia.” Antipodes 20.2 (2006): 204. Print. Focuses on the themes within the novel and comments about the roles of the characters.
84
Pierce, Peter. “The Ballad of Desmond Kale.” Rev. of The Ballad of Desmond Kale, by Roger McDonald. theage. com.au. Age 12 Nov. 2005. Print. Summarizes the book and discusses its language, metaphors, subplots, and emigrant stories. Open Web Sources
The First Tuesday Book Club, sponsored by ABC television, has a review on its Web site at www.abc. net.au/tx/firsttuesday/s/68431.htm concerning The Ballad of Desmond Kale and Roger McDonald. For Further Reading
Flanagan, Richard. Gould’s Book of Fish: A Novel in Twelve Fish. New York: Grove Press, 2002. Print. A magical realism novel about a convict on Van Dieman’s Island, Australia, in the 1830s, who records events and paints fish. Keneally, Thomas. Bring Larks and Heroes. New York: Penguin, 1989. Print. Set in a British penal colony in 1790s Australia, bleakly depicts one Irish corporal’s struggle of conscience amid corruption and deprivation. Kingsley, Henry. The Recollections of Geoffrey Hamlin. Whitefish: Kessinger Publishing, 2010. Print. Written in 1859 by an upcoming novelist, a firsthand account of life in the Australian Outback with bushrangers, forest fires, and drought. Marsden, J. B. Memoirs of the Life and Labours of the Rev. Samuel Marsden, of Paramatta, Senior Chaplain of New South Wales: And of His Early Connexion with the Missions to New Zealand and Tahiti. Charleston: Nabu Press, 2010. Print. Memoirs of the real 1800s “flogging parson,” magistrate, and sheep farmer upon whom McDonald based the Stanton character in The Ballad of Desmond Kale. McDonald, Roger. Mr. Darwin’s Shooter: A Novel. New York: Grove Press, 2008. Print. Award-winning fiction about a young sailor who helped Charles Darwin collect specimens for seven years, later confronting issues of friendship and faith. Lois Kerschen
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Baudolino By Umberto Eco
W Introduction Originally published in Italian in 2000, Baudolino (translated to English in 2002) is a novel by the scholar and writer Umberto Eco. The story begins in 1204, when sixty-year-old Baudolino recounts his life to the Byzantine historian Niketas Choniates. In this narrative within a narrative, the boy Baudolino is taken from his parents’ farm in northern Italy in 1155 by the German king and Holy Roman emperor Frederick Barbarossa; he is raised as Frederick’s adopted son. As a young man he hatches a plan to overawe Frederick’s European opponents by forming an alliance with a fabled Christian ruler in the East known as Prester John. Baudolino and his friends forge a friendly letter from Prester John to Frederick, which contains a description of John’s amazing empire, conceived in its entirety by the young forgers. Once “leaked” to Frederick’s enemies, the letter is expected to make them more cooperative. Baudolino and his friends come to believe that the kingdom they have imagined is real. Finally, in 1190 they set off to find Prester John. They return to Constantinople in 1204, largely convinced that John and his kingdom do not exist. Baudolino, though, still believes, and at the end of the novel he sets off to look one last time.
W Literary and Historical Context
Eco’s narratives are typically densely interwoven with ideas from the world in which they are set, and Baudolino is no exception. Central to the novel are the myths of Prester John and the Grasal (also Grail, or Graal), which were widely current in medieval Western Europe. Prester John was said to rule over a vast empire in Asia, an ideal Christian community possessed of unheard-of wealth. The myth likely originated in accounts of early Christian
communities in India, including Saint Thomas the Apostle’s ministry there. In 1165 a forged letter from Prester John was sent to the Byzantine emperor Manuel I Comnenus and other rulers, including Frederick. The letter helped spur Europeans’ interest in exploring East Asia. In the early thirteenth century, the German poet Wolfram von Eschenbach linked Prester John with the myth of the Holy Grail. In his epic poem Parzival, von Eschenbach made John a Grail-bearer and the son of a knight. The Grail was most often depicted as a serving vessel used at the Last Supper. Von Eschenbach based his description of the Grail on the authority of the (possibly fictional) French poet Kyot the Provençal, who appears as a character in Baudolino. Another French poet, Robert de Boron, wrote in his Joseph d’Aramithie of the Grail being used to collect the spilled blood of Christ (Boron also figures in Eco’s novel). The Grail thus became the most sought-after of holy relics. In Eco’s tale, the mythical vessel is given physical reality by the resourceful Baudolino, who identifies his dead father’s wooden wine bowl as the Grasal. He plans to give it to Prester John but is forced to return with it to Europe.
W Themes The grand theme of Baudolino concerns the power of faith in determining reality. As a boy Baudolino tells an impressive story of an imaginary encounter with a saint. In it the holy figure declares Frederick the one and only lord of Lombardy. The child’s tale promptly causes Frederick’s Italian foes to surrender. Much later Baudolino says to Choniates, “The kingdom of [Prester John] is real because I and my companions have devoted twothirds of our life to seeking it,” implying that good stories compel belief. In giving Baudolino a hand in everything from the canonization of Charlemagne to the counterfeited discovery of what becomes the Holy Grail in the novel,
85 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Baudolino
MAJOR CHARACTERS ABDUL, who befriends Baudolino at the University of Paris, writes songs for a princess he believes he once saw. He joins the quest to find Prester John’s kingdom in the hope that he will encounter her on his journey. BAUDOLINO, the adopted son of the emperor Frederick Barbarossa, conceives of an alliance with the legendary Christian ruler Prester John as a way to help Frederick consolidate his empire. Baudolino spends the rest of his life seeking the kingdom he imagined into being. KYOT is a young traveler who tells Baudolino and his friends that the Grasal is in Prester John’s castle. His character is based on the thirteenth-century poet Kyot the Provençal, who may have been merely a character invented by Wolfram von Eschenbach in Parzival. THE POET, Baudolino’s roommate at the University of Paris, becomes a court poet on the strength of poems written by Baudolino. He joins the quest for the power that finding Prester John’s kingdom will bring him. ZOSIMOS is a treacherous priest who claims to possess a map of the route to Prester John’s kingdom. He tries to steal the Grasal from Baudolino. FREDERICK BARBAROSSA, Holy Roman emperor, finds his energies consumed by destructive rivalries between Italian cities over which he has nominal rule. He wants to believe in Baudolino’s grand plan involving Prester John but dies before the quest gets under way. ROBERT DE BORON is a poet who joins in Baudolino’s search for Prester John. At the end of the quest he says he plans to write about his experiences. Joseph d’Aramithie, written by the real-life poet Robert de Boron in the late twelfth century, helped popularize the Grasal myth. NIKETAS CHONIATES is a Byzantine Greek historian to whom Baudolino tells his life story. Niketas’s character is also based on a historical figure. At the end of the novel, he remains undecided about whether to record what Baudolino has told him. SOLOMON OF GERONA is a Jewish rabbi. He joins the quest for the kingdom of Prester John hoping to find the Lost Tribes of Israel.
Eco calls into question not only the sources but also the truth of history. Brooke Allen notes in her Atlantic review of the book, “History, as we have to acknowledge, is no more than a generally accepted combination of facts, invention, propaganda, and wishful thinking, and Baudolino’s career illustrates the ways in which history is created and authorized.” In Baudolino’s hair-splitting religious disputes with fantastical monsters he encounters in his search for Prester John, Eco highlights the
86
Much of Umberto Eco’s novel Baudolino takes place during the Fourth Crusade, depicted here in a painting. ª Mary Evans Picture Library/Alamy
arguments’ airy lack of substance. Their impact on the Western and Eastern Christian churches, however, has been definitive. Like Prester John, historical truth is hopelessly elusive; the most compelling tale attracts believers. As Baudolino’s friend Boron says of the Grasal, it only acquires “the power of moving men” when it is believed to be lost.
W Style Eco’s novel opens with Baudolino’s first-person record of his initial meeting with Frederick Barbarossa, which the boy writes on parchment stolen from his mentor at court. In the second chapter, the narration changes to the third person and uses an omniscient viewpoint. This shift allows the inclusion of more narrative threads, giving the author greater opportunity to engage in his trademark elaboration of the story’s historical and cultural contexts. Baudolino’s tale of his personal history is a story within a story. The encompassing narrative revolves around his 1204 rescue of Niketas Choniates when Constantinople is sacked during the Fourth Crusade. Baudolino tells his story as he helps Niketas escape to Selymbria on the Sea of Marmara. Finally Baudolino leaves Selymbria to return to what is most real to him: the quest for the kingdom of Prester John. In Eco’s first novel, The Name of the Rose, a medieval murder investigation structures and directs the plot. Baudolino, however, is first and foremost a novel of ideas. Ideas overshadow characters and plot. The first part of the novel describes Frederick’s imperial frustrations in Italy and relates the myths of the Grasal and Prester John; it provides the motivation for Baudolino’s quest to find John’s kingdom. The quest itself forms the central part of the novel. It is an extended fantasy involving extreme TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Baudolino
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Umberto Eco was born on January 5, 1932, in Alessandria, Italy. He studied medieval philosophy and literature at the University of Turin, where he received a PhD in 1954. In the late 1950s he served as cultural programming editor for Radiotelevisione Italiana and began lecturing at the University of Turin. From 1959 to 1975 he worked as an editor for Casa Editore Bompiani. He has been a professor of semiotics at the University of Bologna since 1975. Eco has written about language, literature, art, politics, and culture for numerous publications. His first novel, Il Nome della rosa (1980; The Name of the Rose, 1983), was an international best seller and won the 1981 Strega Prize, Italy’s highest literary honor. His works typically involve an investigation of a mystery, through which he explores the nature of interpretive processes, bringing to bear his vast erudition on questions relevant to religion, philosophy, science, and art.
Portrait of Holy Roman Emperor Frederick Barbarossa, the adoptive father of the main character in Baudolino. ª Classic Image/Alamy
landscapes, exotic monsters, and bizarre rituals. Quests typically inspire transformations in character, but Baudolino’s voyage instead produces alterations in ideas and objects. After all the suffering he and his friends endure for the sake of Baudolino’s father’s wine bowl, it really does become a precious Grasal; when it is threatened or lost, it has “the power to move men.” The historical poets de Boron and Kyot the Provençal helped transform the Grasal into the most sacred of objects. Eco’s fiction supplies a decidedly irreverent backstory to their poetic visions.
W Critical Reception The critical response to Baudolino has been mixed. Most reviewers acknowledge that the novel abounds with historical detail and period authenticity. “Eco is good at evoking life in medieval Italy and at recreating the intellectual horizon of the period,” Thomas Wright asserts in the Spectator. Peter Green of the New York Times Book Review admires the novel’s “richly variegated haul of medieval treasures,” which makes it “compulsively readable.” In a Guardian review, A. S. Byatt argues that, as in his previous novels, Eco uses Baudolino to explore the ways in which humans find and create meaning: “It is an examination of the deep need for explanatory
stories . . . and works in codes and layers that resemble the medieval methods of biblical interpretation as much as modern semiotics.” Some critics have found the novel’s intellectual fireworks sufficient for its success. In his Booklist review Brad Hooper writes that Baudolino “beautifully mixes the elements of an adventure story with intellectual discussions of theology, government, language, geography, and politics.” Others, however, have felt that the novel’s intellectual preoccupations do not cohere well with the plot or the characters. Despite finding in the work a “brilliant conceit,” Byatt’s review concludes, “It is a peculiar kind of novel where the difficult ideas are more interesting than the swashbuckling, or the sex, or the death, or the gruesome objects. . . . It is a paradox that Eco’s most readable tale is also his least satisfactory.” Wright concurs: “While the debates and intellectual digressions in The Name of the Rose were an essential part of the narrative, here they aren’t successfully dramatised within the plot. The characters, too, are merely mouthpieces for ideas.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Allen, Brooke. “Barbarossa’s Boy.” Rev. of Baudolino, by Umberto Eco. Atlantic Oct. 2002: 160. Literature Resource Center. Web. 17 Oct. 2010. Byatt, A. S. “Here Be Monsters.” Rev. of Baudolino, by Umberto Eco. Guardian [London]. Guardian News and Media 19 Oct. 2002. Web. 17 Oct. 2010. Eco, Umberto. Baudolino: A Novel. Trans. William Weaver. Orlando: Harcourt, 2002. Print. Green, Peter. “For Sale: Head of John the Baptist. Box of 7.” Rev. of Baudolino, by Umberto Eco. New York
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
87
Baudolino
Times Book Review 3 Nov. 2002: 14+. Literature Resource Center. Web. 17 Oct. 2010. Hooper, Brad. Rev. of Baudolino, by Umberto Eco. Booklist July 2002: 1794. Literature Resource Center. Web. 17 Oct. 2010. Wright, Thomas. “Too Mediaeval by Half.” Rev. of Baudolino, by Umberto Eco. Spectator 2 Nov. 2002: 70. Literature Resource Center. Web. 17 Oct. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Rev. of Baudolino, by Umberto Eco. Kirkus Reviews 1 Aug. 2002: 1059. Literature Resource Center. Web. 17 Oct. 2010. Argues that the author burdens his story with lengthy philosophical discussions which further weaken an uninspired plot. Rev. of Baudolino, by Umberto Eco. Publishers Weekly 1 July 2002: 44. Literature Resource Center. Web. 17 Oct. 2010. Posits that readers overwhelmed by Eco’s earlier novels may find Baudolino more engaging and accessible because it features a better balance between fiction and intellectual discussion. Bernstein, Richard. “Of Unicorns and Satyrs and Things with No Knees.” Rev. of Baudolino, by Umberto Eco. nytimes.com. New York Times 16 Oct. 2002. Web. 17 Oct. 2010. Acknowledges the scholarship of the novel but faults the narrative for being aimless. Cobb, Gerald T. “A Quest of His Own.” Rev. of Baudolino, by Umberto Eco. America 11 Nov. 2002: 37. Expanded Academic ASAP. Web. 17 Oct. 2010. Provides a detailed overview of the novel and praises the author’s deft marshaling of historical data in telling Baudolino’s tale. Francese, Joseph. “Romancing the Family: Umberto Eco’s Baudolino.” American Journal of Psychoanalysis 65.3 (2005): 261+. Expanded Academic ASAP. Web. 17 Oct. 2010. Explores family relationships in Eco’s novel from a psychoanalytic perspective. Hoffert, Barbara. Rev. of Baudolino, by Umberto Eco. Library Journal July 2002: 116. Literature Resource Center. Web. 17 Oct. 2010. Finds the novel worthwhile but not as scintillating as Eco’s previous novels. Hughes-Hallett, Lucy. “Medieval Monsters Inc.” Rev. of Baudolino, by Umberto Eco. Sunday Times [London] 13 Oct. 2002: 47. Expanded Academic ASAP. Web. 17 Oct. 2010. Praises the novel’s ambition, its capacity to entertain, and the energy of Eco’s writing. Lacayo, Richard. “The Good Liar.” Rev. of Baudolino, by Umberto Eco. Time 4 Nov. 2002: 86. Expanded Academic ASAP. Web. 17 Oct. 2010. Appreciates the ideas behind Baudolino but argues that the novel is too long and is inundated by tall tales.
88
Langer, Adam. “Italian Hero.” Rev. of Baudolino, by Umberto Eco. Book Sept.-Oct. 2002: 62+. Literature Resource Center. Web. 17 Oct. 2010. Highlights the novel’s playfulness. “Making Up Is Never Easy to Do.” Rev. of Baudolino, by Umberto Eco. Economist 12 Oct. 2002. Expanded Academic ASAP. Web. 17 Oct. 2010. Maintains that the weight of too much learning in the novel proves lethal to the story Eco is trying to tell. Mars-Jones, Adam. “You Couldn’t Make It Up.” Rev. of Baudolino, by Umberto Eco. Guardian [London]. Guardian News and Media 27 Oct. 2002. Web. 17 Oct. 2010. Criticizes the novel’s narrative structure and its valuation of inventiveness over artistry. Stock, Jennifer. “Eco Chamber.” Rev. of Baudolino, by Umberto Eco. yalereviewofbooks.com. Yale Review of Books Spring 2003. Web. 17 Oct. 2010. Lauds the wealth of historical detail and learned asides in the text but contends that these cannot substitute for character development. Gale Resources
Friend, Bill. “Umberto Eco.” Twentieth-Century European Cultural Theorists, 1st series. Ed. Paul Hansom. Detroit: Gale, 2001. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 242. Literature Resource Center. 17 Oct. 2010. Rubino, Carl. “Umberto Eco.” Italian Novelists since World War II, 1965-1995. Ed. Augustus Pallotta. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 196. Literature Resource Center. Web. 17 Oct. 2010. “Umberto Eco.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2010. Literature Resource Center. Web. 17 Oct. 2010. “Umberto Eco.” Contemporary Literary Criticism Select. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Literature Resource Center. Web. 17 Oct. 2010. Open Web Sources
Eco’s home page features information about the author’s life and career, interviews, lectures, summaries of his many books, and links to other sources. http:// www.umbertoeco.com/en Fordham University’s Internet Medieval Sourcebook includes an excerpt from the fourteenth-century Travels of Sir John Mandeville in which the author, whose identity remains in doubt, describes the kingdom of Prester John. http://www.fordham .edu/halsall/source/mandeville.html For Further Reading
Boron, Robert de. Joseph of Arimathea: A Romance of the Grail. Trans. Jean Rogers. 1971. London: Steiner, 1990. Print. The medieval French poet describes the Grail as a vessel used at the Last Supper; Boron TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Baudolino
pictures Joseph of Arimathea later collecting the blood flowing from the side of the crucified Christ. Calvino, Italo. Invisible Cities. Trans. William Weaver. Orlando: Harcourt, 1974. Print. In Calvino’s novel Kublai Khan listens to Marco Polo’s brief, fantastical descriptions of the cities he has visited. In Eco’s novel the audience Niketas Choniates grants Baudolino is similar. Like Eco, Calvino explores the ways in which individual interpretation affects meaning. Eco, Umberto. Foucault’s Pendulum. Trans. William Weaver. Orlando: Harcourt, 1989. Print. In Eco’s second novel a scholar and his colleagues make up a history of the Knights Templar. Their game brings them into contact with a thrilling and dangerous reality. ———. Interview. “Eco Returns.” Europe Oct. 2002: 46+. Expanded Academic ASAP. Web. 17 Oct. 2010. This brief interview touches on highlights of Eco’s career. He describes the idea that led him to write about the forged letter of Prester John.
———. Serendipities: Language and Lunacy. Trans. William Weaver. Orlando: Harcourt, 1998. Print. In this volume of essays, Eco explores the outcomes of linguistic mistakes, misinterpretations, and hoaxes; he addresses the letter supposedly written by Prester John that inspired European explorations of Asia. “In Search of an Upside-Down World.” Bookseller 5 July 2002: 33. Literature Resource Center. Web. 17 Oct. 2010. This article features Eco’s descriptions of the character of Baudolino and of the real historical artifacts and actions that are attributed to him in the novel. It includes a brief account of San Baudolino, the patron saint of Eco’s native city, Alessandria. von Eschenbach, Wolfram. Parzival. Trans. A. T. Hatto. London: Penguin, 1980. Print. Von Eschenbach’s Arthurian romance describes the trials encountered by the knight Parzival in his long search for the Grail.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Janet Moredock
89
Beasts of No Nation By Uzodinma Iweala
W Introduction Uzodinma Iweala’s debut novel, Beasts of No Nation (2005), is a graphic depiction of the military experience of a child soldier in an unnamed West Africa country. Told exclusively from the child’s point of view in what may be called Nigerian English, this story gives an in-depth look at the mayhem, violence, and sexual abuse experienced by the protagonist, a pubescent boy named Agu. The novel begins with Agu hiding. He has seen his mother and sister flee with other females from his village; he has seen his father murdered. He is discovered by rebel fighters, beaten up by a child among them, and pulled into their ragtag group. All he knows at the start is that war has come to his village, and he has no choice but to be a soldier. His story then follows this marauding band of rebels as they plunder, rape, and burn their way through several villages. Over the course of these events, the guerrilla fighters suffer starvation, injury, and death. Agu and Strika, another young boy among the soldiers, are repeatedly sodomized by the commander. Though this novel has been labeled a young-adult book, it is not for the faint of heart and may be unsuitable for some young readers. In 2005 Iweala, a recent graduate of Harvard University, received the John Llewellyn Rhys Prize for best work of literature by a young writer for his novel.
W Literary and Historical Context
The literary context in the West for a novel such as Beasts of No Nation is the bildungsroman, the story of maturation. In this genre, the story is about how a child, the protagonist, grows to adulthood, a coming-of-age story. The trajectory of the bildungsroman typically moves from the childhood home of the protagonist into distant places and through various adventures that lead
the central character toward adulthood and perhaps to reconnection with family and childhood friends. In the nineteenth century, the bildungsroman tended to resolve happily, as in the case of David Copperfield (1850), but often during the twentieth century, the ending was more inconclusive, as is the case, for example, in Catcher in the Rye (1951). The historical context for Beasts of No Nation is the increasing prevalence during the late twentieth century of children being enlisted as soldiers in civil wars in African countries. In Africa, beginning in Mozambique in the 1980s, conscription of children (by various criminal means) as guerrilla soldiers was widespread. Jeffrey Gettleman, in a 2007 New York Times article, stated: “The Mozambicans learned that children were the perfect weapon: easily manipulated, intensely loyal, fearless and, most important, in endless supply.” Rebel forces and warlords caught on to this resource, and the use of children in tribal conflicts and civil wars spread elsewhere, as in Somalia, Congo, and Uganda. Warlords and renegade gangs, whose aim is often mainly to plunder local villages, have difficulty enlisting adults but can manipulate children with magic (Beah). These children may be told, for example, that their captors come from the stars or that oil rubbed into their bodies will protect them from harm. Persuaded or coerced, the children participate in brutal attacks on local people, burning villages and murdering babies with sticks. They are controlled by fear, for they witness how children who resist are maimed or killed (Beah). In the 1990s, when human rights organizations such as Amnesty International learned that child soldiers were being forced to eat their victims in Congo, under the pretext that it would make them stronger, the issue came before the United Nations, and concerned groups advocated a mandate that soldiers worldwide be at least eighteen years of age. Only the United Kingdom and the United States refused to sign (Gettleman). Such human rights organizations as the Coalition to Stop the Use of
90 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Beasts of No Nation
Child Soldiers seek to prevent the enlistment of children in military groups and to work for the demobilization and rehabilitation of children who have been conscripted. In 2007 human rights organizations noted that using children in military action had spread worldwide, and an estimated 300,000 children were at that time actively involved in civil wars (Gettleman).
MAJOR CHARACTERS AGU, the narrator and protagonist, is a pubescent boy abducted into the ragtag troop of guerrilla soldiers led by a local thug. COMMANDANT is the unnamed leader of the guerrilla troop, a sadistic child molester and thug.
W Themes The all-encompassing theme of Beasts of No Nation concerns how warfare dehumanizes people and how children in particular are traumatized by participating in guerrilla warfare. The novel dramatizes how these children are forced into following the warlord, how they cannot think of escaping, how they are physically and sexually abused, and how drugs are poured into them to mobilize them to commit brutal obscene acts. Inhabiting a nightmare from which they cannot awake, these children develop symptoms of ego disintegration, dissociation, and posttraumatic stress disorder. Starvation causes hallucination. A second theme pertains to the role played by Western missionary and aid workers. One indication is the presence of the Bible in Agu’s family home and among the guerrilla soldiers. Agu remembers fondly his mother reading from the Old Testament violent stories of Cain and Abel and of Abraham and Isaac; he remembers the magical story of Jonah and the fish. In his eyes, this primary text foretells violence as a way of life. In the final pages of the novel, where Agu describes being cared for in a coastal facility of some sort, Father Festus speaks to him about “Confession and Forgiveness and Resurrection” (139), but Agu admits he does not understand these words. What he understands is that he misses Strika, the mute boy who kicked him into submission when Agu was abducted and then slept next to him on the ground. What Agu understands is missing his friend, Strika. But when Agu begins to tell his story to the aid worker Amy, he sees her eyes fill with tears. He may not understand the priest’s theological terms, but he understands what he sees in her eyes.
W Style The most outstanding aspect of style in this novel is the narrative voice. The little boy Agu speaks in Nigerian English, mostly using the present progressive tense; typically using the singular noun and verb, even when speaking about a plural subject; and tending to omit the terminal -s. For example, Agu reports in the opening scene, “My head is just starting to tingle right between my eye”; “I want to be moving, but my whole bone is paining me and my muscle is paining me like fire ant is just biting me” (1). It is clear his assailant is already
DIKE is Agu’s best friend in his school days who flees with his family before the local warfare begins. MISTRESS GLORIA is the head teacher in the school Agu attends briefly. GRIOT is a child soldier who tells stories late at night, replaying the hanging of his mother, which he witnessed in a marketplace. LUFTENANT is second in command of the guerrilla troop; he is killed by a young prostitute. RAMBO is an older child soldier who figures out he and Agu can leave the Commandant and wakes Agu to tell him so. STRIKA is the mute child soldier who discovers Agu hiding and beats him up; later, Agu thinks of Strika as his only friend.
starving: Strika is described as “short dark body with one big belly and leg thin like spider’s own,” and “His neck is just struggling too much to hold up his big head” (2). The world of Beasts of No Nation is compressed by this voice, which causes the reader to see through the narrowing aperture of Agu’s eyes the “lacerating” pain of his experience (Burns and Hoffert). Agu’s figures of speech reveal the brutality of his existence. One of these links violence and sex. The connection comes from the commander’s repeatedly equating murder with falling in love, the ecstasy of killing. The pubescent Agu uses the word soldier as the name for penis; an erect penis is a soldier standing at attention. His sexual arousal during attacks on villagers is sometime drug-induced. Then, too, the boy conceptualizes intercourse as anal rape, which is perpetrated on him repeatedly by his commander. At the same moment when the lieutenant is knifed by a prostitute, Agu is waiting outside the brothel, masturbating. In another scene, Agu describes how the soldiers hiding at night are more like a family than an army; he stumbles over their bodies, searching for Strika and not finding him. Agu’s terror contrasts with his memory of the darkness of being hugged by his mother, “This kind of dark is making me to feel like I am turning inside out, so all of my thought is floating outside of me and all of my clothe is inside of me. I am walking with my hand stretching out in front of me because I am trying to catch all of those thought that is
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
91
Beasts of No Nation
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Uzodinma Iweala was born in 1982 in Washington, D.C., the son of two Nigerian immigrants, his father a physician, his mother a Massachusetts Institute of Technology economist and the former finance minister and foreign minister of Nigeria. Iweala graduated from Harvard University where he was a Mellon Mays Scholar. His first novel, Beasts of No Nation (2005), was based on his undergraduate thesis. After graduation, he decided to couple his writing career with the pursuit of a degree in medicine from Columbia University. In 2005 Beasts of No Nation won the John Llewellyn Rhys Prize for best work of literature by a young writer.
floating around me so I can make sure no part of me is missing” (106).
W Critical Reception Describing the reception of Beasts of No Nation, Ann Burns and Barbara Hoffert wrote in Library Journal that the novel got “uniformly glowing reviews.” Apparently
the critics were most impressed with the voice that narrates this story. A review in Publishers Weekly (PW) also remarked on “the extraordinary voice.” Identifying the “odd singsong cadence and twisted use of tense” in the “harrowing read,” the PW reviewer stated: “The impressionistic narration by a boy constantly struggling to understand the incomprehensible is always breathless, often breathtaking and sometimes heartbreaking.” Benedicte Page agreed: “The first thing you notice about the novel is the voice and its immediacy.” Simon Baker further explained Iweala’s handling of voice: Iweala “gives his hero a voice that is unliterary yet poetic, sometimes sliding into the present tense when describing the past: ‘They are giving me one room for myself’; ‘It is starting like this.’ At moments of high excitement, though, Agu finds himself in a kind of lexical blizzard, snatching desperately at words in his quest for expression: ‘Then they are angrying too much and just kicking so the whole of this place is shaking and the roof is falling apart small small.’” At first surprising and perhaps off-putting, this African English soon convinces readers that it is the only voice for this particular story, a voice that does not explain but only describes, juxtaposing contradictions and inexplicable, even surreal scenes without framing or distancing the reader from the impact of the action.
Nigerian refugees in Owerri, Nigeria. In Beasts of No Nation, a young boy from an unidentified West African country tells his story of losing his family and being forced into a group of rebel fighters. ª Bettmann/Corbis
92
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Beasts of No Nation
One effect of the voice is in how it conveys the speaker’s character. Baker applauded Iweala’s portrait of this child: “The acute characterization, the adroit mixture of color and restraint, and the horrific emotional force of the narrative are impressive. Still more impressive is Iweala’s ability to maintain not only our sympathy but our affection for his central character.” A review in the New Yorker observed that Beasts of No Nation depicts “war as a mesh of bestial pleasures and pain.” The reviewer admired Agu’s “primitive drive that enables him to survive his descent into hell . . . and keep hold of something resembling optimism.” This faith Agu has in education and his own ability to become something more than a soldier makes him, for the New Yorker, reviewer “a haunting narrator.” The Web site African Success explained how Iweala’s novel transforms its subject matter: “The novel is testament to the profound ability of literature to show horror, dismantle it and identify its parts, and arrive in the silent ether of the aftermath with something utterly unforgettable and, most importantly, worth cherishing.” In cautioning that readers “will come away feeling shattered by this haunting, original story,” Gillian Engberg summed up Iweala’s accomplishment: “Iweala distills his story to the most urgent and visceral atrocities, and the scenes of bloodshed and rape are made more excruciating by the lyrical, rhythmic language. In the narrator’s memories of village life, biblical stories, and creation myths, Iweala explores the mutable separation between human and beast and a child’s struggle to rediscover his own humanity after war.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
African Success: People Changing the Face of Africa, http://www.africansuccess.org/visuFiche.php? id=626&lang=en. Web. 4 Sept. 2010. Baker, Simon. “A Boy Soldier’s Heart of Darkness.” Rev. of Beasts of No Nation, by Uzodinma Iweala. New York Times Book Review 4 Dec. 2005: 70(L). Print. Beah, Ishmael. A Long Way Gone: Memoirs of a Boy Soldier. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2007. Print. “Beasts of No Nation.” Rev. of Beasts of No Nation, by Uzodinma Iweala. Publishers Weekly 29 Aug. 2005: 29. Print. “Briefly Noted.” Rev. of Beasts of No Nation, by Uzodinma Iweala. New Yorker 14 Nov. 2005: 95. Print. Burns, Ann, and Barbara Hoffert. “All New, All Distinct.” Rev. of Beasts of No Nation, by Uzodinma Iweala. Library Journal 15 Mar. 2006: 48+. Print. Engberg, Gillian. “Iweala, Uzodinma. Beasts of No Nation.” Rev. of Beasts of No Nation, by Uzodinma Iweala. Booklist 1 Sept. 2005: 64. Print.
Gettleman, Jeffrey. “The Perfect Weapon for the Meanest War.” nytimes.com. New York Times 29 April 2007. Web. 4 Sept. 2010. Iweala, Uzodinma. Beasts of No Nation. New York: HarperCollins, 2005. Print. Page, Benedicte. “Agu’s Hard Lessons in Killing.” Rev. of Beasts of No Nation, by Uzodinma Iweala. Bookseller 22 Apr. 2005: 27. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Barnes, Tania. “When War Is Child’s Play.” Rev. of Beasts of No Nation, by Uzodinma Iweala. Library Journal 1 Sept. 2005: 42. Print. Examines briefly the dilemma of an author writing about a world and experience he knows nothing about directly. “Iweala, Uzodinma: Beasts of No Nation.” Rev. of Beasts of No Nation, by Uzodinma Iweala. Kirkus Reviews 15 July 2005: 756. Print. Explains that while the civil war is horrific, the battle for Agu’s soul is what matters most. Mnubi, Godfrey M., and John H. Hoover. “Review of Beasts of No Nation and A Long Way Gone.” Rev. of Beasts of No Nation, by Uzodinma Iweala. Reclaiming Children and Youth 22 Sept. 2008. Print. Explains how Iweala’s depiction of the acculturation of Agu to becoming dangerous boy soldier contradicts the age-old tribal rituals that bring a boy to respected and productive manhood. Okorafor-Mbachu, Nnedi. “Beasts of No Nation (Book review).” Rev. of Beasts of No Nation, by Uzodinma Iweala. Black Issues Book Review 1 May 2006. Print. Compares the broken English used in the novel to other works by African authors. Stone, Misha. “Iweala, Uzodinma. Beasts of No Nation.” Rev. of Beasts of No Nation, by Uzodinma Iweala. Library Journal 1 Sept. 2005: 131. Print. Explains that the simple declarative voice of Agu makes the story all the more horrific. Gale Resources
“Uzodinma Iweala.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2007. Literature Resource Center. Web. 4 Sept. 2010. http://go.galegroup.com/ps/i. do?&id=GALE%7CH1000164888&v=2.1&u= itsbtrial&it=r&p=LitRC&sw=w Open Web Sources
African Success: People Changing the Face of Africa, at http//www.africansuccess.org/visuFiche.php? id=626&lang=en, has biographical information about Uzodinma Iweala. Coalition to Stop the Use of Child Soldiers, at http//www. child-soldiers.org, provides information about efforts
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
93
Beasts of No Nation
to stop the recruitment of children as soldiers and to provide for the rehabilitation of children who have been recruited. For Further Reading
Beah, Ishmael. A Long Way Gone: Memoirs of a Boy Soldier. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2007. Print. Firsthand report of child soldier in Sierra Leone who states that ideology gets lost quickly in a bloodbath. Honwana, Alcinda. Child Soldiers in Africa (The Ethnography of Political Violence). Philadelphia: U of Pennsylvania P, 2005. Print. Describes the recruitment, war experiences, and coping measures as reported by children in Mozambique and Angola.
94
Saro-Wiwa, Ken. Sozaboy: A Novel in Rotten English. Pueblo: Passeggiata P, 1986. Print. Describes the enlistment of a naive young man into the army to fight in the Nigerian civil war and how his idealistic hopes turn to disillusionment with his experience. Singer, P. W. Children at War. Berkeley: U of California P, 2006. Print. Thorough study of child soldiery written by a fellow at the Brookings Institution. Tutuola, Amos. The Palm-Wine Drinkard and My Life in the Bush of Ghosts. New York: Grove P, 1993. Print. Two novels from the 1950s, in one binding, by the famous African author and drawing from Yoruba folktale traditions. Melodie Monahan
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Beijing Coma By Ma Jian
W Introduction
W Literary and Historical
In this historical novel by dissident Chinese author Ma Jian, Dai Wei, the narrator, lies in a coma after being hit by a stray bullet at the 1989 student protests in Beijing’s Tiananmen Square, where the Chinese government fired at demonstrators. Dai, comatose for ten years, only intermittently aware of his surroundings, is consumed by memories from his childhood and from his years as a student organizer. He becomes increasingly aware of the circumstances surrounding his body, including visits from his girlfriend and medical personnel, as well as his mother’s struggles to care for herself and to meet his medical needs. His memories and his growing awareness construct a bleak and compelling portrait of Chinese society from the days of the Cultural Revolution through the democracy movement of the 1980s and the economic revival of the 1990s, during which China became an increasingly important part of the global economy. Beijing Coma, the first major novel about Tiananmen Square, is a powerful critique of twentieth-century Chinese government from one of its foremost dissident writers. This harsh, often humorous account of Dai’s struggle with his burgeoning sexuality under the strictures of the Cultural Revolution—as well as the history of his father’s political persecution under the Maoist regime and his mother’s desperate attempts to survive in the capitalist 1990s—is intended to prevent the forgetfulness Ma sees as endemic in Chinese culture. The novel was a New York Times Book Review Notable Book of the Year, a Washington Post Best Book of the Year, and a San Francisco Chronicle Best Book of the Year. It won the T. R. Fyvel Index on Censorship Award, was short-listed for the 2009 Independent Foreign Fiction Prize, and was on the long list for the 2010 International IMPAC Dublin Literary Award.
Beijing Coma is set in the Chinese city of Beijing during the last two decades of the twentieth century, covering the years up to and following the 1989 student protests at Tiananmen Square. The protests were sparked by the death on April 15, 1989, of Hu Yaobang, a former government official who openly criticized the violence that characterized the regime of Mao Zedong and urged Deng Xiaoping’s government to further loosen the economic, cultural, and social controls of the Maoist regime. The protests began as a wave of public mourning for a beloved leader but escalated when a number of political groups arguing for political reforms seized the occasion as an opportunity for a large-scale demonstration. Thousands of students gathered on April 17, presenting the government with a list of demands to further Hu Yaobang’s reform agenda. When police responded to the demonstrators with force, the situation drew national and international media coverage and an outpouring of support for the protests. Over the next several weeks, hundreds of thousands of Chinese workers, students, and dissidents gathered in Tiananmen Square. In other Chinese cities solidarity protests were held. Following a boycott of Beijing’s universities and a hunger strike by more than a thousand students, the Chinese government declared a state of martial law, but with thousands of people in the streets of Beijing, troops were unable to enter the city. Finally, on June 1, soldiers from the People’s Liberation Army (the governmental forces) pushed their way into the city and fired on the protesters. There is some question about the number of victims at Tiananmen Square (estimates vary between several hundred and several thousand), but the Chinese government’s actions have become emblematic of the oppressive behavior of authoritative governments and a reminder of the way that the repressions of the Communist era remain strongly in place.
Context
95 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Beijing Coma
MAJOR CHARACTERS A-MEI is Dai Wei’s second girlfriend and his first love, who ends their relationship when she moves to Hong Kong. LULU is Dai Wei’s childhood girlfriend. During the years of Dai Wei and Lulu’s childhood, sexual and romantic liaisons are forbidden, and his first traumatic encounter with members of the cultural police occurs when they are caught together, arrested, and harshly interrogated. CHEN HUIZHEN is Dai Wei’s mother and Dai Changjie’s wife. She is Dai Wei’s primary caretaker when he is comatose. She allows pharmacists access to Dai Wei’s body and sells his urine and his left kidney to fund special treatment from Master Yao, a member of the outlawed Falun Gong sect. During a government crackdown Master Yao is arrested, and Dai Wei’s mother, who has fallen in love with him, loses her mind. DAI CHANGJIE is Dai Wei’s father. An accomplished violinist, he lived and worked in America before returning to China to raise his family. He was a “member of the Five Black Categories” forbidden under Mao Zedong and spent twenty-two years in a labor camp. Branded a “rightist” for his resistance to Mao’s brutal Communist regime, he maintained dissident views for which his family was shunned. DAI WEI is the protagonist of Beijing Coma. Injured by a stray bullet during the 1989 protests at Tiananmen Square, he lies in a coma for ten years, alternately remembering his childhood and the years leading up to the protests. Viscerally aware of his body as it functions and slowly wakes up, as well as intermittently conscious of visitors and activities outside his room, Dai Wei is both the narrator of the novel and a metaphor for China’s own sluggish awareness of its history. TIAN YI is Dai Wei’s girlfriend during the years leading up to Tiananmen Square. A psychology undergraduate at Beijing University, where Dai Wei is enrolled as a graduate student in biology, she is one of his few frequent visitors while he is in a coma.
Ma, who lives in exile, extends his critique to the current Chinese government, and his books are banned in China. The final image of the novel, in which Dai and his mother’s building is demolished around them by order of one of Dai’s old girlfriends, now a real estate mogul, registers the cruel spirit of the Deng Xiaoping era and its obsession with wealth. As Jess Row of the New York Times and others point out, Ma’s detailed portraits of individual moments of resistance compound the political criticism of the book and are particularly pointed since the book came out just before the 2008 Olympic games.
96
W Themes Beijing Coma, as Row observes, “takes as a given Stephen Dedalus’s dictum [from James Joyce’s novel A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man], ‘History is a nightmare from which I am trying to wake up.’” The major theme of the novel, which connects Ma to such dissident writers as Milan Kundera of the former Czechoslovakia, is the way that individuals fit into historical events. Beijing Coma describes the organization and planning that led to the protests at Tiananmen Square in excruciating detail (the factional conflicts and power struggles that initiated the student movement make up the bulk of the novel’s pages), and Ma does so as part of an attempt to counter the encroachment of cultural amnesia. “No one,” Dai comments, “talks about the Tiananmen protests anymore.” While Tiananmen Square is the central event in Dai’s (and Ma Jian’s) life, the novel makes it clear that the loss of memory or the refusal to remember a traumatic past is also characteristic of twentieth-century Chinese history. The book focuses not only on political structures but also on the way that national government policies affect individuals, their lives, and their beliefs. These implications are most clearly articulated through the lengthy debates between Dai and his fellow student leaders as they argue about politics, about the relative benefits of different forms of protest, and when the protests would be most effectively implemented. The most compelling example of the long-term results of living under an authoritarian government is reflected in the changing views of Dai’s mother. During his childhood Dai’s mother, a former opera singer, shows only contempt for his father’s “rightist” views, which led to his imprisonment and to the ostracism of his family. After Dai is injured at Tiananmen Square, she finds herself similarly ostracized and left caring for him on her own. Their financial situation worsens, even in the thriving Chinese economy of the 1990s, and the government fails to accept any responsibility for Dai’s condition. Slowly she takes increasingly desperate measures to survive and to save her son and grows increasingly critical of the government she once believed in. The insanity that strikes her at the end of the novel is indicative of the longterm stress of living in fear of persecution and of being Dai’s sole caregiver. Beijing Coma is also a meditation on the role that literature, the arts, and the aesthetic experience in general can play in the midst of historical events. The image of a sparrow alighting on Dai’s chest, the experience that finally brings him back to consciousness, stands for a fragile beauty that is not strictly useful but that is nonetheless necessary. The sparrow, ordinary yet delicate, was marked for extermination in Maoist China, and the novel makes it clear that, while China has moved away from a strictly authoritarian government, the recovery will not be complete until there is room for this kind of simple pleasure. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Beijing Coma
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Ma Jian, a London-based author of novels and short stories, was born in 1953 in the city of Qingdao, China. He worked as a watch repairman and a painter of propaganda boards until he was assigned a job as a photojournalist for a state-run magazine. In 1982 he quit his job as a photojournalist under political pressure and traveled around China (he later wrote about his travels in the 2002 memoir Red Dust). He moved to Hong Kong in 1987 when his collection of short stories about Tibet, Stick Out Your Tongue, was banned by the government, but he continued to travel in China. He missed the protests in Tiananmen Square only because his brother was injured in an accident that put him in a coma, an experience that inspired the narrator’s injuries in Beijing Coma. Ma lived in Germany between 1997 and 1999 and then moved to London with his wife, Flora Drew, who is a noted translator from the Chinese and translates Ma’s works in English. Ma has been allowed to travel in China, but his writings are banned, and he is forbidden from making any public or political statements. Ma was described by Nobel laureate Gao Xingjian as “one of the most important and courageous voices in Chinese literature.” In addition to Beijing Coma, Red Dust (which won the Thomas Cook Travel Book Award in 2002), and Stick Out Your Tongue, Ma is the author of The Noodle Maker (2004) a finalist for a PEN literary award for a novel in translation.
Ma Jian, author of Beijing Coma. Getty Images
W Style Melissa Holbrook Pierson, in the Nation, refers to Ma as a “satiric playwright” who “pens scenes of madcap irony.” This ironic edge in Beijing Coma is widely noted by critics. Ma’s language can be lyrical, as in the passages remembering Dai’s old girlfriends, but history permeates every detail of Dai’s life, and the novel recounts the past and chronicles the present in excruciating, often unsparing detail. This attention to detail, which pushes the novel to over five hundred pages, is a powerful documentary tool that acts as a reminder that the brutal humor Ma displays originates in the events themselves rather than stemming from his stylistic choices. Beijing Coma has the length, sweep, and detailed renderings of an epic novel, but the structure is piecemeal, comprising three narrative strands: Dai’s memories, his current surroundings, and his descriptions of his slow physical recovery. The latter, italicized passages, scattered throughout the text, are full of the terminology—neurons awaken, ducts open up, fluids begin to move—one would expect from a medical student, but they are also exceedingly slow and lyrical, providing a contrast to his frenetic mental energy.
W Critical Reception Beijing Coma has received overwhelmingly positive reviews in the Western press. It was reviewed in nearly all the major book reviews and newspapers and unanimously declared an important book, one that not only details the years leading up to a major historical event of the late twentieth century but also provides an important meditation on the way that history is written or, in this case, forgotten. Ma’s sense of ironic humor is mentioned by almost all readers of the novel, who variously refer to it as a “tragicomedy” (Tash Aw), “blackly funny” (James Lasdun), “horror mixed with laughter” (Chandrahas Choudhury), and a mix of “gritty realism” and “absurdist satire” (Pankaj Mishra). Despite the bleak subject matter, however, critics see a powerful message of hope. The title of the novel in Chinese translates as “Land of Flesh,” and Ma explicitly connects Dai’s coma with the state of the Chinese people. Row quotes the preface to the Chinese edition of the novel: “Inside Dai Wei, there is a strong, resilient person who remembers, and only memory can help people regain the brightness of freedom.” Boyd Tonkin compares the novel to the sparrow it describes, saying it “is destined to be an eagle whose wings will cross the world. In Beijing [where the novel will not be published], powerful heads will hear them beat, and worry.”
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
97
Beijing Coma BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Aw, Tash. “A Story of Tiananmen Square.” Telegraph [London] 26 Apr. 2008: n. pag. Print. Choudhury, Chandrahas. “Testament to an Unquiet Brain.” Observer [London] 20 Apr. 2008: n. pag. Print. Lasdun, James. “Children of the Revolution.” Guardian [London] 3 May 2008: n. pag. Print. Mishra, Pankaj. “Tiananmen’s Wake: A Novel of Hope and Cynicism.” New Yorker 30 July 2008: n. pag. Print. Pearson, Melissa Holbrook. “A Powerful Novel about Tiananmen Square.” Nation 4 Aug. 2008: n. pag. Print. Row, Jess. “Circling the Square.” New York Times 13 July 2008: n. pag. Print. Tonkin, Boyd. “Ma Jian: Slaughter and Forgetting.” Rev. of Beijing Coma, by Ma Jian. Independent [London] 2 May 2008: n. pag. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Fenby, Jonathan. “Beijing Coma.” Times [London] 9 May 2008: n. pag. Print. Fenby lauds Ma Jian for a “huge achievement,” calling Beijing Coma “both intimate and sweeping.” Prose, Francine. “Casting a Lifeline.” Rev. of Beijing Coma, by Ma Jian. New York Review of Books 26 June 2008: n. pag. Print. Well-known novelist Francine Prose gives a helpful, detailed narrative summary of Beijing Coma’s complicated plot. Smallwood, Christine. “Cage of Bones.” Los Angeles Times 24 May 2008: n. pag. Print. Smallwood’s article provides a short positive review and multiple excerpts from an interview with Ma Jian and his partner and translator, Flora Drew. Yang, Belle. “Nightmare on Tiananmen Square.” Rev. of Beijing Coma, by Ma Jian. Washington Post 25 May 2008: n. pag. Print. Yang’s short, positive review calls Beijing Coma “an avenue through which [the Chinese people can] retrieve their souls and emerge from their collective coma.”
complex politics, including the political and cultural policies of Mao Zedong and Deng Xiaoping. http// academic.brooklyn.cuny.edu/core9/phalsall/texts/ chinhist.html Scholar Richard R. Wertz maintains this comprehensive portal to Web sites documenting Chinese history and culture. Frequently updated, it includes current newsfeeds as well as stable links to a range of helpful sites. http//www.ibiblio.org/chinesehistory/ This collection of Web resources on Asia, maintained by Robert Y. Eng, includes chapters from seminal history texts and sections devoted to each of China’s major political figures. http//newton.uor.edu/Depart ments&Programs/AsianStudiesDept/china-history. html For Further Reading
Dillon, Michael, ed. China: A Cultural and Historical Dictionary. Durham East Asia Collection. Surrey: Curzon, 1998. This guidebook, arranged alphabetically, provides definitions for and explanations of a large array of keywords from China’s history and culture, a helpful resource for understanding the complicated historical background of Beijing Coma. Kim, Mikyoung, and Barry Schwartz, eds. Northeast Asia’s Difficult Past. New York: Palgrave, 2010. Print. This collection of essays on remembrance and history in China, Japan, and Korea is part of the Palgrave Macmillan Memory Series, a series of volumes about the politics and aesthetics of memory in the modern era. Kundera, Milan. The Book of Laughter and Forgetting. Trans. Michael Henry Heim. New York: Knopf, 1980. Print. Kundera’s novel, banned under the Communist regime in Czechoslovakia, chronicles life under that regime and is often compared to Beijing Coma. Ma Jian. The Noodle Maker. London: Chatto, 2004. Print. Ma’s first novel, The Noodle Maker, which was excerpted in the New Yorker, relays the conversation between a writer of political propaganda and a professional blood donor who meet for dinner every week. The novel uses one of these dinners as the framework for a group of stories about the absurdities and cruelties of life in post-Tiananmen Square China.
Open Web Sources
———. Stick Out Your Tongue. London: Chatto, 2006. Print. This book of loosely autobiographical short fiction about a Chinese journalist traveling in Tibet was published in Chinese in 1997 and subsequently banned by the Chinese government for “harming the fraternal solidarity of the national minorities.”
A condensed history of China from its ancient roots through the modern era, this site provides a concise account of twentieth-century Chinese history and its
Pong, David. An Encyclopedia of Modern China. Scribner’s World History. Detroit: Scribner/Gale, 2009. Print. An engaging and up-to-date resource on
Gale Resources
“Ma Jian.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2010. Literature Resource Center. Web. 15 Oct. 2010.
98
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Beijing Coma
Chinese history and culture from the eighteenth century through the present day, this two-thousandpage work, available in both print and electronic editions, contains articles from well-known scholars and academics, comprehensive bibliographies for further study, and an appendix of primary source material. Adaptations
Farewell: A Fantastical Contemplation on America’s Relationship with China. Dir. and chor. Donald Byrd. Score by Byron Au Yong. Spectrum Dance Theater (Seattle Theater Group), Seattle. 2010. Performance.
Farewell was produced in 2010 for the second year of Spectrum Dance Theater’s “Beyond Dance: Promoting Awareness and Mutual Understanding (PAMU).” According to Spectrum, the goal of PAMU is to bring collaborators together from all over the world to create works that “examine issues relating to personal liberty, freedom, security and social justice.” Part I, “Considering Beijing Coma,” was inspired by the work of Ma Jian, who served as an adviser.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Jenny Ludwig
99
Bel Canto By Ann Patchett
W Introduction A detailed portrait of the human need for connection, Ann Patchett’s Bel Canto won both the Orange Prize for Fiction and the PEN/Faulkner Award. Set in the vice presidential palace of an unspecified South American country, the opening of the novel depicts a world of wealth and power, where an internationally renowned American opera singer has been invited to perform at a party given for a Japanese businessman whom the South American nation is hoping to woo. As the lights go down at the end of the performance, the home is taken over by terrorists, its occupants becoming hostages. The rest of the novel, based loosely on a real-life incident in Peru in the 1990s, traces the development of the bonds that form between the hostages and their captors in a period lasting over four months. Unfortunately for those individuals inside the home who have formed friendships and romances, the situation began as an act of terrorism and cannot end peacefully. Suspense and romance are features of the novel that contributed to its best-selling status.
W Literary and Historical Context
Patchett published her novel Bel Canto in a world in which the lines between literary fiction and genre fiction have become increasingly blurred. Bel Canto won literary awards in both the United Kingdom (the Orange Prize) and the United States (the PEN/Faulkner award), attesting to the idea that it is regarded as a work of literary fiction. Increasingly, literary novels such as Bel Canto are often becoming best sellers as well. In the months immediately following Bel Canto’s publication, a debate was waged in such papers and journals as the New York Times, the Atlantic, and the Observer regarding literary and popular fiction and the boundaries of these
categories. The genesis of this debate was a controversial article penned by B. R. Myers in a July 2001 article for the Atlantic, in which Myers rails against the merging of literary and popular fiction in vehement tones. Judith Shulevitz responds directly to Myers’s attack on the current state of literary fiction. While Shulevitz admits that Myers makes some valid points, particularly in identifying literary prizewinners whose prose is overwrought, Shulevitz concludes “Myers doesn’t have a sure grasp of the world he’s attacking.” The same summer, Robert McCrum, in the Observer, comments that some critics have begun to regard literary fiction as a genre unto itself. Others have gone further, McCrum notes, and argue that the literary label “could simply be a way of describing a novel that places style before content, puts prose before plot and subordinates character and narrative to nebulous aesthetic concerns.” McCrum discusses Myers’s article as well, suggesting that while the tone of the piece is perhaps a bit vitriolic, there may be some truth to Myers’s view that literary fiction has become something much different, something much less, than it used to be. The historical event that inspired Patchett’s literary novel took place at the residence of the Japanese ambassador, near Lima, Peru. In December 1996 prominent political figures and business executives mingled to celebrate the Japanese emperor’s birthday. The party was attacked by the Tupac Amaru Revolutionary Movement. Over five hundred hostages, along with the guerrilla forces who had captured them, were crowded into the residence. Negotiations eventually collapsed in March. Over the course of the standoff, all but seventy-two hostages were released. In April 1997 Peruvian military forces stormed the compound, killing fourteen rebels. One of the remaining hostages and two Peruvian soldiers were also killed.
W Themes In Bel Canto, Patchett offers an examination of human relationships and the intrinsic human need for
100 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Bel Canto
connection. The vice presidential residence, once it is taken over by the terrorists, becomes an incubator for an array of new relationships, bonds which are formed and maintained in a vacuum. This unique environment is a void in which the personal and political pasts of captives and captors fall away. Social barriers such as wealth and power disintegrate. Patchett creates a scenario in which the individuals involved begin to regard each other truly as individuals. They are still products of their environment, but the demands of the external world cease to exist. In this new world, sophisticated, elite Roxane can nurture a talent that the uneducated soldier Cesar was unaware he possessed. Another young soldier, Ishamel, can observe a few games of chess and absorb the intricacies of the game. He can further inspire the paternal love of the vice president. The Japanese translator Gen finds in the South American guerrilla soldier Carmen a willing and able student of language, and a woman he can love. Bridges are formed between soldiers and hostages, paths to relationships that could not exist outside of the captured vice presidential compound. In allowing such relationships to blossom in this environment, Patchett attacks the socioeconomic and political barriers that divide people, that cut off the possibility of connection, that prevent the unity that manages to exist inside the compound. Yet the insulated world is breached when the government forces attack the compound, kill the terrorists, and rescue the hostages. Forcibly the government army injects back into the insular world the violence, struggle, and despair of the outside world. Notably, many of the company inside the residence seem to welcome the opportunity to forget the constraints associated with the world outside during their captivity. They pursue relationships that are obviously doomed, not tracing the logical course of possible outcomes. Forgetting families and obligations, the hostages make plans to enmesh their lives with those of their assailants, to marry, to adopt, to mentor careers. The willingness of Roxane, Gen, and Ruben, for example, to become involved in long term ways with individuals—Cesar, Carmen, Ishamel—whom the rest of the world can only see as criminals, rebels, and killers, demonstrates the intensity of their desire for meaningful emotional connections. All of their desires are thwarted with the deaths of the soldiers, and of Hosokowa. In the end, the marriage of Gen and Roxane appears as another example of the desperation to hold on to an elusive sense of connection. Gen and Roxane wed themselves to the past, and to the sense of community they enjoyed while held as hostages, as they join their individual lives in marriage at the end of the novel.
W Style Bel Canto is written in the third person from the point of view of an omniscient narrator. This allows Patchett the
MAJOR CHARACTERS THE UNNAMED ACCOMPANIST, a pianist, travels with Roxane Coss in order to perform at Mr. Hosokawa’s birthday celebration in South America. In the opening scene, the pianist kisses Roxane at the end of the performance. A diabetic, and deprived of insulin, he is the first hostage to die. BEATRIZ, a female soldier who remains undisguised and displays masculine traits. She is less involved with the captives than some of her companions, and is killed in the siege that ends the standoff. CARMEN is a female terrorist who is disguised as a man for part of the novel. She falls in love with Gen Watanabe as he tutors her. CESAR is a young terrorist soldier who displays a musical talent that impresses Roxane. She intends to train him after the hostage crisis has ended. ROXANE COSS is a famous American opera singer who is tempted, against her better judgment, to sing at a party held in a South American locale. The government there wishes to persuade Hosokawa to build a factory in their country, and they use Roxane, whom Hosokawa is known to greatly admire, to encourage him. Although she allows herself to be used as a pawn, Roxane stands up to the terrorists initially, attempting to escape and refusing some of their demands. She and Hosokawa fall in love over the course of their confinement. KATSUMI HOSOKAWA is the Japanese businessman whom the South American government officials are courting, in the hopes that Hosokawa will decide to build a factory in their country. His love for opera is well known, and the government persuade Roxane Coss to perform at a party held in Hosokawa’s honor. He falls in love with Roxane and in many ways forgets about his former life. RUBEN IGLESIAS is the vice president of the South American country in which the novel is set. Throughout the standoff, Ruben continues to play the role of the host, just as he did at the party. He grows fond of Ishamel and plans to adopt him when the crisis is over, but Ishamel is killed in the siege. ISHAMEL is another young terrorist who becomes well liked by many of the hostages. He learns to play chess by watching Hosokawa. He is killed in the government siege of the compound. JOACHIM MESSNER is a Red Cross worker who is called in to serve as a hostage negotiator. The terrorists fail to recognize Messner’s indications that a military rescue siege is imminent. SIMON THIBAULT, a French ambassador, clings to the memory of his wife and the scarf she has left him after she is released but he is kept as a hostage. GEN WATANABE serves as Hosokawa’s translator, but, during the ensuing months, his ability to translate in a number of languages makes him an instrumental figure in the communications between the terrorists, the other hostages, and the Red Cross worker Messner.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
101
Bel Canto
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Ann Patchett was born on December 2, 1963, in Los Angeles, California. After her parents divorced, Patchett and her mother and sister moved to Nashville, Tennessee, where Patchett grew up. She attended Sarah Lawrence College, graduating with a bachelor’s of arts degree in 1984, and earning an MFA from the University of Iowa’s Writers Workshop in 1987. In 1992 Patchett published her first novel, The Patron Saint of Liars, which was named a New York Times Notable Book. A grant then led Patchett to the Bunting Institute at Radcliffe College in 1993. Following a divorce, Patchett returned to Nashville and pursued her writing career, supporting herself as a waitress. She published two more novels before Bel Canto appeared in 2001. She married Karl VanDevender in 2005. Patchett has continued to publish critically acclaimed novels, including Run, in 2007.
distance from which she can offer a detached view of her large cast of characters, but it still provides some sense of intimacy between the characters and the reader as it allows Patchett glimpses into the thoughts of various individuals. In an interview with David Podgurski in the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel (as referenced in Contemporary Authors, New Revision Series), Patchett states that she sought to write from the omniscient, third-person viewpoint in order to portray the drama of the story in the same manner that the original, historical event was broadcast on television. The story unfolds slowly, gradually, over the course of several months. The suspense built is of the emotional kind, as feelings among the characters grow and evolve, rather than a suspense rooted in violent action. Bel Canto contains this variety of suspense as well, but it is not the basis upon which Patchett builds her complex plot. Additionally, the language of the novel is controlled and precise, mirroring the distance of the narrator. From the novel’s opening scene, though, the prose can also reflect the emotion and passion of the novel’s characters. As they witness the accompanist reaching toward Roxane’s face to kiss her they collectively imagine a kiss that they do not see, as the lights are suddenly extinguished. Projecting their own desire for connection, the onlookers “assumed she continued her kiss” (Patchett 2). Using an omniscient third-person voice, Patchett lets her story unfold at arm’s length, yet also uses this voice to reflect her theme of the human longing for connection.
W Critical Reception
Author Ann Patchett wins the Orange Prize for Fiction in 2002 for Bel Canto. ª Rune Hellestad/Corbis
102
As a finalist for the National Book Critics Circle Award and the winner of the Orange Prize and the PEN/Faulkner Award, Bel Canto can only be regarded as a critical success. Wanda H. Giles, in a 2009 essay on Patchett for the Dictionary of Literary Biography, describes the novel as a “tour de force, a mix of realism, magic, and profound love and sorrow.” Giles goes on to characterize the critical reception of the novel in positive terms. Yet some reviewers found areas to criticize. Ruth Scurr, in a 2001 review for New Statesman, maintains, “the best parts of this uneven novel are the most hammed-up and comically implausible.” Nancy Poesy’s 2003 assessment for English Journal is more favorable. The critic explores Patchett’s thematic approach, stating, “the real beauty of Patchett’s story lies in the role that music and language play in the lives of her characters.” Poesy goes on to describe the way Patchett “artfully draws readers into the temporary, artificial world she creates.” Patchett’s use of the omniscient third-person voice comes under scrutiny by John Mullan in a 2002 essay for the Guardian. Mullan describes Patchett’s use of this voice, identifying the unusual way she employs it, noting that its efficacy is buoyed by a plot in which nothing really happens. Patchett risks the reader’s disbelief, Mullan contends, when her characters’ thoughts differ from their “official selves” TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Bel Canto
only in ways that are perpetually sympathetic. Patchett’s characterization is also the subject of some scrutiny, as James Polk in a 2001 review for the New York Times Book Review finds that “Patchett strains a bit too hard” to flesh out the revolutionaries as fully as she has the captives. Yet Polk also praises Patchett’s ability to provide “fine insights into the various ways in which human connections can be forged, whatever pressures the world may place upon them. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
“1 Hostage Killed in Daring Peru Rescue.” CNN World News 22 Apr. 1997. Web. 30 July 2010. Giles, Wanda H., and J. W. Bonner. “Ann Patchett.” Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 350. TwentyFirst Century American Novelists: Second Series. Ed. Wanda H. Giles and James R. Giles. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Print. McCrum, Robert. “The End of Literary Fiction.” Observer [London] 5 Aug. 2001. guardian.co.uk. Web. 30 July 2010. Mullan, John. “A Sense of Perspectives.” Guardian (13 July 2002): 33. Rpt. Contemporary Literary Criticism. Vol. 244. Detroit: Gale. Print. Myers, B. R. “A Reader’s Manifesto.” Atlantic July/Aug. 2001. the atlantic.com. Web. 30 July 2010. Patchett, Ann. Bel Canto. New York: HarperCollins, 2001. Print. “Patchett, Ann.” Contemporary Authors New Revision Series. Ed. Amanda D. Sams. Vol. 167. Detroit: Gale, 2008. 339-42. Print. Gale Virtual Reference Library. Web. 30 July 2010. Poesy, Nancy. “Review of Bel Canto.” English Journal 92.6 (July 2003): 92-93. Rpt. in Contemporary Literary Criticism. Vol. 244. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Print. Polk, James. “Captive Audience.” New York Times Book Review 106.23 (10 June 2001): 37. Print. Scurr, Ruth. “Novel of the Week: Bel Canto.” New Statesman 130.4548 (30 July 2001). Rpt. in Contemporary Literary Criticism. Vol. 244. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Print. Shulevitz, Judith. “The Close Reader: Fiction and ‘Literary’ Fiction.” New York Times 9 Sept. 2001. Web. 30 July 2010. Sims, Calvin. “A Nightmare in Lima: Hostages in Squalor.” New York Times 21 Dec. 1996. nytimes. com. Web. 30 July 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Clark, Alex. “Dangerous Arias.” Guardian 14 July 2001. Rpt. in Contemporary Literary Criticism. Vol. 244. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Print. Admires Patchett’s
ability to draw clearly defined portraits of such a wide range of characters and demonstrates parallels between the world of opera—a world in which one of Patchett’s characters is immersed—and Patchett’s novel. Foster, Aisling. “Martyrs to a Cause.” Times Literary Supplement 5230 (27 June 2003). Rpt. in Contemporary Literary Criticism. Vol. 244. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Print. Praises the psychological complexities of Patchett’s characterization in Bel Canto. Miller, Laura. “Bel Canto by Ann Patchett.” Salon 22 June 2001. salon.com. Web. 30 July 2010. Maintains that despite lapses in realism in the plotting, Patchett’s novel is filled with carefully drawn, realistic characters. Zaleski, Jeff. “Review of Bel Canto.” Publishers Weekly. 248.16 (16 Apr. 2001): 42. Rpt. Contemporary Literary Criticism. Vol. 244. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Print. Assesses Patchett’s narration in Bel Canto, maintaining that the detached perspective is reflective of the characters’ varied cathartic experiences. Gale Resources
“Ann Patchett.” Gale Contextual Encyclopedia of American Literature. Vol. 3. Detroit: Gale, 2009. 1282-85. Print. Gale Virtual Reference Library. Web. 30 July 2010. “Bel Canto.” Novels for Students. Ed. Sara Constantakis. Vol. 30. Detroit: Gale, 2010. 45-65. Print. Gale Virtual Reference Library. Web. 30 July 2010. Open Web Sources
Ann Patchett’s author website provides an overview of her literary career and includes information about her upcoming work and appearances. http//www .annpatchett.com/ PBS NewsHour features an interview between Gwen Ifill and Ann Patchett in which the two discuss Bel Canto. The exchange includes an examination of the Stockholm Syndrome, the psychological syndrome in which captives develop emotional attachments to their captors. http//www.pbs.org/ newshour/conversation/july-dec02/patchett_ 7-02.html The Orange Prize for Fiction’s website includes a synopsis of Bel Canto, a brief author biography, an interview with Ann Patchett, and a review of the novel. http// www.orangeprize.co.uk/show/feature/orange-belcanto The BBC News on This Day feature provides an overview and the historical context of the hostage crisis in Lima, Peru, in 1996. http//news.bbc.co.uk/onthis day/hi/dates/stories/january/13/ newsid_3330000/3330127.stm
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
103
Bel Canto For Further Reading
Fitzpatrick, Laura. “Stockholm Syndrome.” Time (31 Aug. 2009). Time.com. Web. 30 July 2010. Offers a brief summary of the psychological condition known as the Stockholm Syndrome, in which captives develop strong emotional connections to their captors, citing several famous instances, such as the Patty Hearst case. Patchett refers to the Patty Hearst case within the context of a discussion about Stockholm Syndrome, in an interview with Gwen Ifill about Bel Canto. Giampietri, Luis. 41 Seconds to Freedom: An Insider’s Account of the Lima Hostage Crisis, 1996-1997. New York: Presidio Press, 2007. Print. An account of the Lima hostage crisis written by one of the hostages, who happened to have once served as a field
104
commander of special operation forces. Giampietri describes how he aided the government in the siege that eventually ended the crisis. Patchett, Ann. Run. New York: HarperCollins, 2007. Print. A best-selling and well-reviewed novel concerned with the relationships and the inner workings of a political family in Boston. ———. Truth & Beauty: A Friendship. New York: HarperCollins, 2004. Print. A memoir in which Patchett details the contours of her friendship with Lucy Grealy, a fellow author, who died of cancer in 2002 at the age of thirty-nine. Catherine Dominic
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Bitter Fruit By Achmat Dangor
W Introduction
W Literary and Historical
A finalist for the Man Booker Prize and the International IMPAC Dublin Literary Award, Bitter Fruit is an important contribution to the literature of apartheid. Set in South Africa during the closing months of Nelson Mandela’s presidency in 1999, Bitter Fruit explores the enduring ramifications of the apartheid system at both the private and public level through the story of one family’s difficult struggle coming to terms with a painful past of violent racism. The events of the novel begin to unfold when Silas Ali, a veteran of the antiapartheid struggle and now a lawyer for the famous Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC), recognizes a man in a grocery store as the white security officer, François Du Boise, who arrested him twenty years earlier for his involvement in the African National Congress. Handcuffed and thrown into the back of a police van, Ali was forced to listen as Du Boise brutally raped his wife, Lydia, who like Silas, was classified as “colored” under the apartheid system. The couple has consciously avoided the subject of the rape for all these years. When Silas tells Lydia of the chance encounter, the long-kept secret incites tension between the two, in the end finally fracturing their strained and loveless marriage and causing a violent transformation in their son, a nineteen-year-old college student named Mikey who now discovers that he is the product of the assault. As each of the three Alis reacts completely differently to the disclosure and to the news that Du Boise is seeking amnesty through the TRC, Achmat Dangor questions the fidelity of the new government to the heroic ideals of the resistance movement and broaches important questions of historical memory that bear on themes of identity, truth, and authenticity.
Context
Bitter Fruit is to some degree autobiographical. Dangor was born in Johannesburg, South Africa, in 1948, at the start of apartheid, the legally sanctioned system of racial segregation enforced in South Africa until 1994 with the transition to democracy and the presidency of Nelson Mandela. Apartheid made racial segregation an official government policy, classifying residents into groups— white, black, colored (mixed race), and Asian—as a means of maintaining the minority rule of whites of European descent. Like his protagonist, Silas Ali, Dangor was classified as colored and suffered under the “resettlement” programs that forced people out of their homes into designated group areas. Also like his protagonist, Dangor was active in the antiapartheid resistance of the African National Congress (ANC) and participated in an official capacity in the new government. In the novel, Silas serves as a lawyer and liaison for the TRC, the agency headed by Archbishop Desmond Tutu designed as a courtlike forum for victims of racial abuse to air their grievances. The commission’s purpose was one of reconciliation and restoration, not retribution, as part of the negotiated settlement for democratic rule. Therefore, while perpetrators of the crimes were required to admit their acts in public, they were often granted amnesty for full confessions. Critic Ana Miller explains: “The new democratic South African Constitution and the TRC were products of a negotiated settlement with the apartheid regime. . . . The ensuing compromise limited the ANC’s constitutional ability to dismantle the economic and social legacy of apartheid and set substantial limits to the legal opportunities to prosecute against apartheid crimes.” Silas Ali’s involvement with the TRC, combined with Du Boise’s confession to Lydia’s rape and related crimes, leads to the
105 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Bitter Fruit
MAJOR CHARACTERS LYDIA ALI is of mixed race, the wife of Silas Ali and the mother of their nineteen-year-old son, Mikey. Lydia was raped by an Afrikaner police officer in 1978 as part of her husband’s punishment for subversive involvement in the African National Congress. More than twenty years later, the rape is still a taboo subject in the Alis’ crumbling marriage. MIKEY ALI is the biological son of Lydia Ali and François Du Boise, the white man who raped Lydia in 1978. When Mikey learns of his true parentage as a college student, he determines to seek vengeance against Du Boise. SILAS ALI is of mixed race, a former activist against apartheid, now a liaison for the Truth and Reconciliation Commission of the new democratic government of Nelson Mandela. Silas and his wife, Lydia, disagree on how best to grieve the past and punish François Du Boise for raping her twenty years earlier. FRANÇOIS DU BOISE is the white police officer who arrested Silas Ali in 1978 for his activities in the African National Congress. Du Boise is guilty of raping Lydia Ali, an assault that resulted in the birth of Mikey Ali. Du Boise seeks amnesty for his crimes through the Truth and Reconciliation Commission.
The plot of Bitter Fruit revolves around the South African policy of apartheid. Anke van Wyk/Shutterstock.com
encounter. This private record, and her self-imposed silence, contrast with the court of public record, the TRC, which, while generally considered successful at effecting a peaceful transition to democracy, has been faulted for rewriting history in a manner unsatisfactory to the victims’ concerns for justice. The strategies Lydia and Silas use to reckon with the past foreground the collision of
complete breakdown of the Alis’ marriage. Ali wants Lydia to tell her story to the TRC, recommending some type of healing at the public level, but Lydia refuses, convinced that her very personal trauma will be swallowed up and forgotten in the homogenized collective trauma of the nation. Lydia and Silas remain unable to connect emotionally because they cannot share the pain of the racially motivated assault.
W Themes Lydia’s devotion to silence and Silas’s preference for rationalizing the rape appear alongside Mikey’s obsessive drive to punish Du Boise, whom he kills at the end of the novel before escaping to India to claim his rightful Muslim heritage. All three methods of confronting and comprehending the past reveal the poisonous effects of the apartheid system on the present. In addition, all three methods pose questions about the nature of historical memory and its methods of articulation, with important ramifications for individual and national identity, the healing of personal and collective trauma, and the truth of innocence and guilt. As Ronit Frenkel noted, “Bitter Fruit is a text that opens history’s processes in order to narrate its ambiguities.” Since the day of her assault, Lydia had kept a diary documenting her feelings and her mind’s inability to separate both Mikey and Silas from the violent
106
Photograph of Achmat Dangor, author of Bitter Fruit. Jason Kempin/Getty Images for Mission US
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Bitter Fruit
new freedoms with the practical realities of government, suggesting that individual catharsis is subjugated in the interest of compromise and historical containment. Even Silas is cynical about the new government’s compromises. He observes that personal principles have also taken a backseat to the demands of bureaucracy: “Being in government is different from fighting for freedom. Things have to be managed now” (qtd. in Miller). For Mikey, on the other hand, personal and historic memories collide in what critic Shomit Dutta describes as a “radical destabilization of his sense of self.” His sense of alienation is first played out in a series of unemotional sexual encounters with older women. He then turns to vengeance and radical Islam as a means of ordering the chaos that has reconfigured his life, including the revelation that his maternal grandfather, a Muslim in India, had executed the British officer who raped his sister. Mikey’s murder of Du Boise, therefore, “links the colonial histories of India and South Africa through the racial and sexual violence of rape in both settings. . . . Mikey’s uninvited birthright haunts the family and is experienced as traumatic by Mikey, Lydia, and Silas” (Miller).
W Style Added to this shame of miscegenation is the shame attached by apartheid to the stigma of being “colored.” Lydia, Mikey, and Silas experience the evils of racial discrimination in different ways. Dangor portrays the psychological effects of racist ideologies through a thirdperson omniscient narration that explores the individual racial subjectivities of his characters. The novel is structured in three parts—Memory, Confession, and Retribution—that show the progressive development of the characters’ thoughts. These three parts—the personal response to trauma—are contrasted with the three elements of the public response to trauma as outlined by the TRC: Speak, Grieve, Heal. “But the story,” Barbara Trapido writes, “for all its political context, is stronger for keeping its focus on the evolving family drama, which it does through a series of interior sequences devoted in turn to Silas, to his wife Lydia, and to their meltingly beautiful but troubled and somewhat oedipal son, Mikey.”
W Critical Reception Reviewers of Bitter Fruit have frequently addressed the novel’s juxtaposition of the political realities of liberation with the ideals of the antiapartheid movement and with the need for victims of the system to finally heal old wounds. Critics have suggested that Mikey’s behavior bears some resemblance to the spirit of rebellion of his parents’ generation, which has now been replaced by an
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Born in Johannesburg in 1948 at the beginning of white apartheid rule, Achmat Dangor became a tireless antiapartheid campaigner and was under government surveillance during the old regime. Since the transition to democracy, Dangor has written stories and poems describing firsthand the brutal racism of the apartheid years, the often violent struggle for freedom, and the negotiated peace that led to democratic rule. He is best known for the novella Kafka’s Curse (1997), set against the backdrop of Nelson Mandela’s 1994 election, and the novel Bitter Fruit (2001), a Man Booker and International IMPAC Dublin Literary Award finalist describing postapartheid disillusionment. Dangor has worked for the new government in a variety of capacities. He is currently the CEO of the Nelson Mandela Foundation.
institutional framework that rationalizes away the horrors of the apartheid system. A notice for Bitter Fruit in Kirkus Reviews averred that the novel “embodies . . . a sober, measured account of former revolutionaries adjusting to their new roles as pragmatic administrators.” Writing for the Guardian, Gabriel Gbadamosi observed, “A seed of contempt germinates in Mikey as he reflects on the failings of his parents’ generation: ‘The struggle sowed the seeds of bright hopes and burning ideals, but look at what they are harvesting: an ordinariness.’ Mikey’s response to these levels of deception and self-deception is an insistence on ‘nowness’, a determination to keep his own identity open to change as he goes in murderous search of his biological father.” At the other extreme is Lydia’s internalization of her trauma, which she considers superior to the whitewashed truth of victim and perpetrator testimony issued by the TRC. Through Lydia’s silence, Miller argues, Dangor “problematizes oversimplified, generalized, and politicized notions of healing and foregrounds the need to pay attention to the individual contexts of traumatization.” Critic Judith Chettle also remarked on Dangor’s disillusionment with the negotiated settlement to democracy and the constraints placed on the TRC: “And though public confessions of past evils are cathartic and admirable, Mr. Dangor suggests they are not enough. Apartheid was so profoundly destructive of society that forgiveness and forgetting are inadequate response to such a massive psychic injury.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Rev. of Bitter Fruit, by Achmat Dangor. Kirkus Reviews 73.2 (15 Jan. 2005): 68. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 29 Aug. 2010. Chettle, Judith. “Apartheid’s Evils Described in Metaphor, but Ineptly.” Washington Times [DC] 17 Apr.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
107
Bitter Fruit
2005. Print. NewsBankinc. Access World News. Web. 30 Aug. 2010. Dutta, Shomit. “An Insurrection of the Loin.” Telegraph [London] 22 Dec. 2003. Print. Web. 27 Aug. 2010. Frenkel, Ronit. “Performing Race, Reconsidering History: Achmat Dangor’s Recent Fiction.” Research in African Literatures 39.1 (2008): 149-65. Print. WilsonSelectPlus. Web. 30 Aug. 2010. Gbadamosi, Gabriel. “Clouds over the Rainbow Nation.” Guardian 12 Dec. 2003. Print. Web. 29 Aug. 2010. Miller, Ana. “The Past in the Present: Personal and Collective Trauma in Achmat Dangor’s Bitter Fruit.” Studies in the Novel 40.1-2 (2008): 146. Print. Trapido, Barbara. “Bitter Fruit by Achmat Dangor: Tainted by the Poison of South Africa’s Past.” Independent [London] 12 Dec. 2003. Print. Web. 30 Aug. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
“Bitter Fruit.” Publishers Weekly 252.9 (28 Feb. 2005): 41. Print. Suggests that Dangor cautions against placing too much faith in the power of forgiveness to heal the wounds of apartheid. Heltzel, Ellen Emry. “Memory, Retribution in PostApartheid South Africa.” Seattle Times 22 May 2005. Print. NewsBankinc. Access World News. Web. 28 Aug. 2010. Contrasts the private pain of the Alis with the public trauma of the South African nation postapartheid. Price, Melissa. “A State’s Brutality Leaves Hearts Calloused.” San Francisco Chronicle 1 May 2005. Print. SFGate.com. Web. 30 Aug. 2010. Contrasts the suffering of Silas Ali and his wife, Lydia, and discusses their inability to connect on an emotional level. Rochman, Hazel. Rev. of Bitter Fruit, by Achmat Dangor. Booklist 101.11 (1 Feb. 2005): 941. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 29 Aug. 2010. Concludes from a reading of Bitter Fruit that neither silence nor truth about the evils of apartheid can heal old wounds in South Africa. Stuhr, Rebecca. Rev. of Bitter Fruit, by Achmat Dangor. Library Journal 130.2 (1 Feb. 2005): 67. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 29 Aug. 2010. Notes that the reality of democracy in South Africa has not lived up to the dream of antiapartheid activists. Wigston, Nancy. “The Elite’s Favourite Dish—A Family Declines in the New South Africa with Nary a Character Worth Cheering For.” Toronto Star 12 Dec. 2004. Print. NewsBankinc. Access World News. Web. 30 Aug. 2010. Negative review finding little in the book to merit its short-listing for the Man Booker Prize.
108
Gale Resources
“Achmat Dangor.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2007. Also covered in Contemporary Authors New Revision Series, vol. 163. Open Web Sources
Michigan State University offers an online eight-unit study guide chronicling the rise of apartheid in South Africa and the struggle for freedom, including interviews with activists, archival footage of mass resistance and police repression, and other firsthand accounts and artifacts. The media collections are complemented by essays and a variety of curricular materials arranged in chronological fashion. The study guide is titled South Africa: Overcoming Apartheid, Building Democracy. The PBS video Post-Apartheid South Africa describes South Africa sixteen years after democracy. The piece contrasts employment prospects for blacks and whites in the new economy and interviews Archbishop Desmond Tutu about the country’s future. Tutu was the leader of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission, widely credited with effecting the peaceful transition to the new government. For Further Reading
Coetzee, J. M. Disgrace. New York: Viking Penguin, 2000. Print. Explores continuing racial tension in postapartheid South Africa through the story of a college professor’s midlife crisis. Disgrace earned Coetzee an unprecedented second Man Booker Prize; he was awarded the Nobel Prize in Literature in 2003. Gordimer, Nadine. Burger’s Daughter. New York: Penguin, 1980. Print. Widely praised story of a young white woman’s struggle to come to terms with the legacy of her activist parents who were martyred in the fight against apartheid. Gordimer, for most of her life a resident of Johannesburg, was herself prominent in the cause for freedom. She earned the Nobel Prize in Literature in 1991. ———. The House Gun. New York: Penguin, 1999. Print. Novel about relationships between blacks and whites in postapartheid South Africa and the politicization of personal lives. Paton, Alan. Cry, the Beloved Country. New York: Scribner’s, 2003. Print. Story of a Zulu pastor and his disintegrating family, set amid the racial strife of 1940s Johannesburg. The novel, which first appeared in 1948, was considered a landmark publication for destroying any myths about the happy condition of blacks in South Africa. Still popular, Cry, the Beloved Country was one of Oprah Winfrey’s Book Club selections. Janet Mullane
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Blacklist By Sara Paretsky
W Introduction With Blacklist, Sara Paretsky added another installment to her successful series of detective fiction featuring private eye V. I. Warshawski. In this volume, the twelfth in the series, Warshawski is hired to investigate unusual sightings at the uninhabited mansion of an elderly woman in a wealthy suburb of Chicago. While casing the grounds, she discovers, in the swimming pool, the dead body of an African American journalist who appears to have been murdered. When she begins to look into his death, she finds connections that go back to the House Un-American Activities Committee and the “red scare” of McCarthy-era 1950s America, finding eerie parallels between it and the post-9/11 world of legalized torture and the Patriot Act. Critics have applauded Blacklist as a worthy successor to Paretsky’s earlier V. I. Warshawski novels, noting in particular the way she ties the contemporary political climate to McCarthyism.
W Literary and Historical Context
Blacklist begins in the wake of the terrorist attacks on the Pentagon and the World Trade Center on September 11, 2001, when members of the Afghanistan-based militant Islamist group al-Qaeda, led by Osama bin Laden, executed a series of suicide missions on U.S. ground for the first time in history, killing nearly 3,000 people. With the entire country in a state of shock and intense fear, then-president George W. Bush and the sitting Congress declared war on Afghanistan on October 7, 2001, with the aid of an international coalition of troops. U.S.-led forces initially were able to drive the oppressive Taliban regime from power; most al-Qaeda operatives were dispersed to other countries, mostly Pakistan. Within the United States, the government enacted a series of antiterrorism measures, including the October
26, 2001, Patriot Act, which vastly expanded the power of government and law enforcement authorities to access individuals’ telephone calls, e-mail messages, and financial and medical records for information on possible terrorist activity. Because of the apparently arbitrary nature of the expansion of power allowed by the Patriot Act, it was greatly controversial and is the subject of much criticism in Blacklist. The war in Afghanistan is also a source of anxiety for V. I. Warshawski, as her boyfriend in the book is on assignment there as a war correspondent. When Warshawski begins investigating the death of the journalist in the swimming pool, she is taken back four decades to the events the journalist was researching at the time of his murder: an investigation by the House Un-American Activities Committee (HUAC) of members of the Federal Negro Theater Project. HUAC was formed in 1938 as an investigative arm of the U.S. House of Representatives. Its primary purpose was always to curtail possible Communist activity in the United States, but this function reached fever pitch in the late 1940s, when the group opened hearings on the political activities of people involved in the film industry in Hollywood. As a result of the hearings, hundreds of actors, screenwriters, directors, and others were placed on a blacklist for allegedly being Communist sympathizers. In most cases this was never proven, and of those accused, most had their careers ruined. Meanwhile, in 1950, U.S. Senator Joseph McCarthy began making broad accusations about Communists and Soviet spies infiltrating the government. The era of McCarthy’s “witch hunts” became emblematic of a culture of paranoia and fear.
W Themes Critics have long noted that Paretsky’s V. I. Warshawski series takes detective fiction in a new and unusual direction—most notably with a strongly feminist lead character in a genre that has been dominated by machismo. Reviewing the book for the Washington Post,
109 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Blacklist
MAJOR CHARACTERS KYLIE BALLANTINE is the African American performer with the Federal Negro Theater Project whose career was ruined when she was accused of Communist activities by the House Un-American Activities Committee. Her story is being researched by contemporary journalist Marc Whitby. CALVIN BAYARD is a publishing magnate and free-speech advocate in the 1950s. CATHERINE BAYARD, the granddaughter of Calvin Bayard, hampers Warshawski’s investigation and may have been involved in Whitby’s murder. DARRAUGH GRAHAM is the son of Geraldine Graham and a client of Warshawski. GERALDINE GRAHAM is the elderly matriarch of the wealthy Chicago family that owns Larchmont Hall. She aids Warshawski in her investigation. V. I. WARSHAWSKI is a private detective in Chicago, Illinois. MARCUS WHITBY is the African American journalist whose dead body Warshawski stumbles upon in the pool of Larchmont Hall.
Maureen Corrigan notes that the social and political commentary that runs through the Warshawski books has earned Paretsky the scorn of critics who prefer more traditional male private detectives. Corrigan asserts, however, that “Blacklist delves into the Red Scare of the 1950s and makes pointed connections between McCarthyism and present-day threats to civil liberties in post-Sept. 11 America. Blacklist is a thoughtful, hightension mystery that’s unafraid of making (still more) enemies for the Warshawski series.” Ann Hellmuth, writing for the Orlando Sentinel, said, “Paretsky doesn’t spare the punches in tracking how the increase in federal powers since the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks has encroached on personal freedoms.” The story, Hellmuth writes, “contains subtle warnings about the loss of freedoms and is a reminder of how absolute power can corrupt and destroy the freedoms it is meant to protect.” Additionally, Warshawski becomes involved in the case of a young Egyptian man in the United States on a work visa who has been accused—probably wrongly—of terrorism.
W Style Blacklist is a multilayered novel, with a narrative that moves back and forth from contemporary Chicago to mid-century Washington, D.C., in addition to periodic ruminations on Afghanistan and the Middle East. It is densely packed with characters and historical references,
110
as well as with the trademark social commentary of the V. I. Warshawski books. As with other volumes in the series, Blacklist foregrounds the character of Warshawski herself as a hard-bitten, cynical, and tough-talking private eye—all qualities that would be not only expected but applauded in a male private detective, but are often considered abrasive and disconcerting in a female investigator.
W Critical Reception While earlier volumes in the Warshawski series examined social issues, Blacklist was widely viewed as Paretsky’s first overtly political novel. Most critics found her historical references and criticism of the state of contemporary civil liberties in the United States, as well as her story, compelling. Marilyn Stasio notes in a brief review in the New York Times the irony of the very vocal and frequently offensive Warshawski coming up against efforts to curtail her freedom of speech. Maureen Corrigan finds the novel one of the finest in the series, which she says overall have “grown richer and more ambitious with age.” But Corrigan also points to the political divide in the United States between those who support tougher national security measures regardless of their effects on civil liberties and those who oppose them—a difference that also divided critics and readers of Blacklist. Dorothy Blackman laments in her review for Knight-Ridder/Tribune News Service, “[W]ith so much sermonizing, Blacklist comes across mostly as a medium for expressing Paretsky’s own socio-political views. This turns an otherwise intriguing whodunit into a diatribe on civil liberties, and that is unfortunate.” Paretsky herself expressed surprise in an interview with Bob Cornwell on the Web site Tangled Web UK that Blacklist had been singled out as her only “political” work, maintaining that much of her work, and especially the V. I. Warshawski series, is inherently political. Not all the negative reviews of Blacklist had to do with its politics, though. Writing for the Chicago Sun-Times, Connie Fletcher describes the book as “weak, flailing, and often nonsensical. . . . With its murky plot, surprisingly ditzy heroine and multitudinous goofy moments, Blacklist may be the black sheep of the Warshawski series.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Blackman, Dorothy. “Author’s Politics No Mystery in Blacklist.” Knight-Ridder/Tribune News Service 19 Nov. 2003. Print. Corrigan, Maureen. “Scoundrel Time; A Private Eye Uncovers Powerful Betrayals and Political Secrets.” Washington Post 30 Nov. 2003. Print. Fletcher, Connie. “V. I. Comes a Cropper; Sara Paretsky’s Newest Mystery a Rare Stumble in Renowned Series.” Chicago Sun-Times 5 Oct. 2003. Print. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Blacklist
Hellmuth, Ann. “Mystery Tied to McCarthy Era Draws Parallels with Patriot Act.” Orlando Sentinel 12 Jan. 2004. Print. Stasio, Marilyn. “Muzzling V. I.” New York Times 19 Oct. 2003. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Six, Beverly G. “Breaking the Silence: Sara Paretsky’s Seizure of Ideology and Discourse in Blacklist.” South Central Review 27:1-2 (2010): 144-58. Print. Argues that Paretsky turns the detective fiction paradigm on its head by focusing on corruption and conspiracy within state apparatuses, using the ideology of culture and politics. Gale Resources
Dempsey, Peter. “Sara Paretsky.” Dictionary of Literary Biography, Vol. 306: American Mystery and Detective Writers. Ed. George Parker Anderson. Detroit: Gale, 2005. Print. Klein, Kathleen Gregory. “Sara Paretsky: Overview.” St. James Guide to Crime and Mystery Writers. Ed. Jay P. Pederson. 4th ed. Detroit: St. James Press, 1996. Print.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Sara Paretsky was born in Ames, Iowa, in 1947 and was raised in Kansas. She holds a BA in political science from the University of Kansas, an MBA from the University of Chicago’s Graduate School of Business, and a PhD in history from the University of Chicago. She worked with the poor on Chicago’s South Side in 1966 and moved there permanently in 1968. Paretsky’s works are strongly informed by her young adult experiences in the women’s and civil rights movements of the 1960s and 1970s.
Wyrick, Laura. “Sara Paretsky: Overview.” Reference Guide to American Literature. Ed. Jim Kamp. 3rd ed. Detroit: St. James Press, 1994. Print. Open Web Sources
Cornwell, Bob. “‘Anger Is a Very Bad Place to Start,’ Says Sara Paretsky.” Tangled Web UK. Web. 9 Aug. 2010. Gigstad, Judy. Rev. of Blacklist, by Sara Paretsky. Bookreporter.com. Web. 9 Aug. 2010.
In Blacklist, private eye V. I. Warshawski conducts an investigation at a Chicago mansion. Joseph Squillante TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
111
Blacklist For Further Reading
Bentley, Eric, and Frank Rich, eds. Thirty Years of Treason: Excerpts on Hearings before the House Committee on Un-American Activities. New York: Nation Books, 2001. Print. Presents and discusses testimony given before HUAC by people working in the film and theater industries from 1938 to 1968. Ceplair, Larry. The Inquisition in Hollywood: Politics in the Film Community, 1930-1960. Champaign, IL: U of Illinois P 2003. Print. Focuses on the effects of the HUAC investigations on those working in Hollywood.
Paretsky, Sara. Writing in an Age of Silence. New York: Verso, 2009. Print. Memoir in which Paretsky discusses the effects of her formative experiences in the social justice movement of the 1960s and 1970s on her worldview and her fiction. Adaptations
V. I. Warshawski. Dir. Jeff Kanew. Perf. Kathleen Turner, Jay O. Sanders, and Charles Durning. Hollywood Pictures, 1991. Film adaption of Deadlock, one of the books in Paretsky’s Warshawski series. Received mixed reviews.
Hoffman, Jan. “Nancy Drew’s Granddaughters.” New York Times 7 July 2009. Print. Discusses the legacy of the famous girl detective and quotes Paretsky on Nancy Drew.
112
Nancy Dziedzic
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
A Blessed Child By Linn Ullmann
W Introduction Linn Ullmann’s A Blessed Child, published in Norwegian in 2005 and then in English in 2009, consists mainly of the flashback memories of Isak Lövenstad’s three daughters, as they undertake a rare visit in 2005 to their father’s retirement home on the island where they vacationed as children between 1972 and 1979. Now Isak is eighty-four, in what he calls the “epilogue” (31) of his life, and he invites the eldest, Erica, to come for a winter visit. Ill at ease about driving, especially in bad weather, Erica urges her sister Laura to come along and do the driving, and when that fails, she urges her to pick up their third sister Molly and follow along separately for a reunion. For various reasons, each daughter has ambivalence about such a visit. It is during the journey toward the island home that the flashbacks occur, each daughter’s separate memories of the summer vacations elicited by the current trip. The major flashbacks revolve around the last summer they went to the island. That year, 1979, was the hottest summer on record since 1874; Erica and her intimate but clandestine friend Ragnar turned fourteen on the same day; Laura was eleven; and Molly was seven. During this summer of pubescent sexual initiation, the teens on the island entertain themselves with pornographic magazines and hurtful game-playing that escalates from bullying and psychological abuse to physical abuse under the influence of the cruel ringleader, Marion Bodström. Ostracized Ragnar is betrayed by only friend Erica, and on the night of her birthday party, her party guests, her sisters, and she take off after him, ultimately causing what is later called a “deliberate accident” (251), a stoning that leads to his drowning. This tragedy brings to an end the summer island visits, but its legacy variously affects Erica and Laura in later years, less so their younger sister. As they travel back to the
island in 2005, they revisit in memory the summers they shared as children, though they are less able to discern how those memories cast their shadows across their adult lives. A Blessed Child was long-listed for the Independent Foreign Fiction Prize and short-listed for Norway’s Brage Prize.
W Literary and Historical Context
In some ways, A Blessed Child is an example of postmodern fiction, in which multiple points of view are presented, each limited and somewhat unreliable. This handling of the perspective through which the action is viewed undermines the single all-encompassing authority that shapes third-person omniscient point of view. Somewhat in the tradition of her father, filmmaker Ingmar Bergman, Linn Ullmann defines the present time in this novel, the three daughters’ winter journey to Hammarsö in 2005, by the surfacing memories of island summers from 1972 to 1979. These remembered experiences are as present in the present time as the present journey is. Postmodernism privileges this subjective sense of time, the way the past insinuates itself in the present, and for a novel whose immediate timeframe is a two-day car trip, it is a fitting way to arrange the plot. As the daughters return after a hiatus of more than twentyfive years, their separate memories of those summers surface and are in a sense relived. Several points of historical context are provided in the novel, first of which, perhaps, is the fact that Isak Lövenstad is said to have made his professional reputation as one of the pioneers of ultrasound. Sonar and other underwater detection systems were beginning to be studied in the nineteenth century, and sonar was used to navigate submarines, particularly after the Titanic sank in 1912 and during World War I. Beginning in the 1940s in Europe, the medical diagnostic possibilities of ultrasound
113 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
A Blessed Child
MAJOR CHARACTERS MARION BODSTRÖM, Erica’s peer, who develops into the abusive ringleader of a group of teens who vacation on the island. ERIKA LÖVENSTAD, eldest daughter of Isak and his first wife, Elisabet, becomes emotionally involved with Ragnar and is sexually molested by Marion. ISAK LÖVENSTAD, a Swedish gynecologist and womanizer, has three daughters by three different women, two his wives, and untold other affairs. Isak retires to Hammarsö permanently after his second wife dies. LAURA LÖVENSTAD, daughter of Isak and his second wife, Rosa, tends to feel responsible for helpless or vulnerable others. ROSA LÖVENSTAD is Isak’s second wife, who threatens to leave Isak when his mistress Ruth gives birth to his third daughter, Molly. MOLLY is the daughter of Isak and his mistress Ruth. Ten and seven years younger than her two half-sisters, Molly practically never sees Isak after she is five years old. After her mother dies, Molly is raised by her maternal grandmother. ALFRED PAAHP is the old man living in the Colony, a subdivision in Oslo where Laura lives with her husband and two children. Grieving over the death of his brother and lonely, Paahp whiles away his days making beaded bracelets that he gives to the local little girls, much to the consternation of some neighbors. PALLE QUIST is the frustrated author who lives on Hammarsö and writes and directs the Hammarsö Pageant, which is performed each summer between July and August. RAGNAR, born on the same day and year as Erica, is the island outcast, who develops an intimate secret relationship with Erica and hides out in his hut in the woods, where he feels safe from the other teenagers. SIMONA is Isak’s island housekeeper from the 1970s into the early 2000s. During the twelve years when he does not use his house, she maintains the place and enjoys brief stays there away from her busy home and family life.
techniques were explored and developed in research centers around the world (Woo). By the late 1950s, fetal images were being captured that provided new information for obstetricians to use in treating their patients. Late 1950s research conducted in Lund, Sweden, promoted the obstetrical applications of the diagnostic tool. Akf Sjovall and Bertil Sunden were among a group of medical researchers who contributed to the advancement of ultrasound in perinatal medical treatment.
114
As for a cultural context, the novel indicates that in the 1970s, Sweden and Swedish language were dominant in Scandinavia. It is noted that in Sweden no one spoke Norwegian or watched Norwegian television, but in Norway, people typically spoke both Norwegian and Swedish, and in their homes, both Norwegian and Swedish television programs were available. The multinational character of the Lövenstad blended family and certain tensions between its members reflect this cultural imbalance.
W Themes The central theme in A Blessed Child encompasses various subjects having to do with group membership and community and the kinds of pressure that are exerted on members and against excluded others. One related subject explores how the family unit is defined, especially regarding offspring from multiple marriages and extramarital relationships. Laura thinks of herself as the full sister and Erika, from Isak’s first marriage, and Molly, from his extramarital affair, as half-sisters. Laura takes them in, especially bonding with the much younger Molly, for whom Laura feels responsible from their first meeting. Related to the idea of family structure and membership is the idea of community, one instance of which is given in the Colony, a subdivision of homes in Oslo where Laura lives with her husband and two children. The Colony community response to Alfred Paahp, the elderly Dane who makes beaded bracelets for the neighborhood girls and allows his property to deteriorate, illustrates how a social group works to protect itself and exclude individuals who are different and seem to pose a threat or erode economic investment by their habits. While Paahp spends his time stringing his beads and making bracelets for the children, the community association is holding its meetings to figure out how to get him to move away. Consulted lawyers say there are no grounds for his removal, but narrow-minded and suspicious parents want the man out of the area. The idea of group membership and the exclusion of isolated others is played out with fatal results by the island teens who are controlled by Marion, the alpha-female. In addition to subjects pertaining to solidarity and ostracism are those associated with compassion and kindred feeling. Examples occur in the novel regarding the family’s responses to birds: the injured bird on the lawn that makes Laura sit down and cry; the bird that flies into the study that frightens Molly who calls it toward the open window; and the elaborate funeral the family enacts for the sparrow. Linked to these instances is the scene in which Laura goes to Paahp’s house and holds his hand while prompting him to not answer the door when the committee comes to call. Laura, called “a love child” (141) by her father, is the one who stretches to include TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
A Blessed Child
others. She takes up crying Molly when the adults are out of hearing range, she holds hands with Paahp, and “her arms were long enough” (147) to embrace her husband and children.
W Style Told in limited omniscient third-person point of view, the novel is divided into five sections, each of which contains smaller sections, juxtaposed like fragments from a larger design, with remnants from the past surfacing but suitably not in chronological order. The current story is the 2005 winter trek to the island, extended by detours both literal and psychological. Within that overarching narrative are the flashbacks that surface in each sister’s thoughts as she travels toward her now elderly father. Another feature of Ullmann’s style is the way it changes to match the age of the sisters in the flashback being remembered. One instance occurs in 1975 when Laura is seven and discovers three-year-old Molly left in a carriage at Isak’s front door. Laura thinks, “It wasn’t a newborn because it was quite big and could sit up by itself” (113). Laura reasons that Erika and Rosa are away, and Isak cannot be disturbed for any reason. An
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Daughter of actress Liv Ullmann and film director Ingmar Bergman, Linn Ullmann was born on August 9, 1966, in Oslo, Norway. She obtained a BA in English literature from New York University in 1988, began a graduate program there, and then left without completing it to return to Oslo and pursue a career in journalism. She writes on political and cultural subjects, her work often appearing in Aftenposten, a widely circulated Norwegian newspaper. Her novel, A Blessed Child (published in English in 2009) was long-listed for the Independent Foreign Fiction Prize and short-listed for Norway’s Brage Prize. Before that work, Ullmann published three novels: Before You Sleep (1998), Stella Descending (2001), and Grace (2002). As of 2010, Ullmann lived in Oslo with her husband, Niels Fredrik Dahl, a Norwegian novelist and dramatist.
abandoned baby does not make for an exception. Laura is alone to resolve the problem and she does; she takes the baby for a ride in the carriage.
A Scandinavian island. A Blessed Child follows the three daughters of Isak Lövenstad as they visit him at his retirement home, which is located on the same Norwegian island where the girls spent many childhood vacations. Andrey Starostin/Shutterstock.com TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
115
A Blessed Child
W Critical Reception
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Certain reviews of A Blessed Child began with identifying Ullmann’s parents and perhaps linking this novel to the author’s biography. Another response was to appreciate the writing, the lack of chronological order to the events, and the skillful translation by Sarah Death, but to criticize the ending for its lack of resolution, its failure to assign blame and responsibility. Representative of both these approaches is the review by Stacey D’Erasmo, who began by pointing out autobiographical details in the novel. About its backward glancing narrative, D’Erasmo wrote: “Tenderness . . . can convey an illusion of connection. . . . Desire and memory tangle and dissolve in melancholy.” During that “pivotal summer of 1979,” D’Erasmo asserted, “the savage adolescent culture” forces Erika “to choose between power and the heart.” The failure of the novel, according to D’Erasmo, is that Ullmann “shies away from hammering home . . . Isak’s deep moral failure” and that she leaves the past “more vivid than the present,” which is not true to life. Many reviewers praised Ullmann’s writing style; for example, Elizabeth Dickie lauded Ullmann for her “impressive voice” and her “facility with language.” A reviewer in Publishers Weekly described the book as an “arresting and well-observed saga,” but it cautioned that the novel’s “tonal coolness won’t be for everyone.” That coolness might have been on the mind of a reviewer in Kirkus Reviews who praised the novel’s “stark beauty” but went on to observe how the story “leaves moral issues tantalizingly open.” In a review that placed Ullmann’s novel in a larger literary context, Jennifer Vanderbes explained how A Blessed Child offers a “fresh change” from the dominant “pattern of bad boys and female victims,” calling Ullmann’s book “a rare literary foray into [the] dark realm” of “psychological warfare and silent cruelty that often pass for female friendship.” But according to Vanderbes, Ullmann commits a serious mistake. In this novel, which according to Vanderbes makes Lord of the Flies “look almost prudish,” Ullmann “seems unsure in the end who, exactly is guilty.” The charge from Vanderbes is: “Having bravely portrayed a world where girls behave wickedly, Ullmann curiously reverts to painting them as victims, not culprits.” Also commenting on the autobiographical elements and praising the translation, Boyd Tonkin identified the central subject: “Conformism shows its savage streak among the island’s pubescent girls,” who are “led by hyper-sexual teen queen Marion.” Ullmann has psychological insight, according to Tonkin, showing how “loneliness clings like a burr to all of Isak’s girls.” In all, these reviewers found much to admire in A Blessed Child, but most seemed to expect that the ones who commit crimes will be identified and punished in the end, and such critics bulked at punishment being the means of group solidarity, a new social adhesive, rather than a means of justice.
116
Works Cited
D’Erasmo, Stacey. “Girls of Summer.” Rev. of A Blessed Child, by Linn Ullmann. New York Times Book Review 17 Aug. 2008: 6(L). Print. Dickie, Elizabeth. “A Blessed Child.” Rev. of A Blessed Child, by Linn Ullmann. Booklist 1 Aug. 2008: 33. Print. “Growing Up Is Hard to Do.” Rev. of A Blessed Child, by Linn Ullmann. Publishers Weekly 12 May 2008: 34. Print. Tonkin, Boyd. “Cries and Whispers on the Chilling Baltic Breeze.” Rev. of A Blessed Child, by Linn Ullmann. Independent [London] 5 Sept. 2008. Print. “Ullmann, Linn: A BLESSED CHILD.” Rev. of A Blessed Child, by Linn Ullmann. Kirkus Reviews 15 June 2008. Print. Vanderbes, Jennifer. “Girls Behaving Badly.” Rev. of A Blessed Child, by Linn Ullmann. Washington Post 10 Dec. 2008. Print. Woo, Joseph. “A Short History of the Development of Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology.” http://www .ob-ultrasound.net/history1.html, n.d. Web. 26 Sept. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Jeffrey, Ben. “A Blessed Child by Linn Ullmann.” Rev. of A Blessed Child, by Linn Ullmann. www.guardian.co. uk. Guardian 5 Sept. 2009. Web. 25 Sept. 2010. Admires the translation, sees parallels to Lord of the Flies in the fateful summer of 1979, and finds the lack of resolution at the end insufficient for the rise in action. Gale Resources
“Linn Ullmann.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2010. Literature Resource Center. Web. 25 Sept. 2010. http//go.galegroup.com/ps/i.do? &id=GALE%7CH1000135537&v=2.1&u =itsbtrial&it=r&p=LitRC&sw=w Open Web Sources
Leserglede provides information on Ullmann, including an interview and reviews, at http//www.leserglede. com/norwegian-author/linn-ullman.html For Further Reading
Geyh, Paula, Fred G. Leebron, and Andrew Levy, eds. Postmodern American Fiction: A Norton Anthology. New York: Norton, 1997. Print. Post–World War II innovations in American fiction writing, compiled and analyzed. Golding, William. Lord of the Flies. New York: Norton, 2008. Print. The 1954 novel portraying boys on an TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
A Blessed Child
island who become feral, to which A Blessed Child is compared by some reviewers.
lary novel in which a father tells his life story to the daughter he abandoned.
King, Lily. Father of the Rain. New York: Atlantic Monthly P-Grove/Atlantic, 2010. Print. Set against the Nixon resignation, a story of polarized children in the wake of their parents’ divorce.
Steinbeck, John. Of Mice and Men. New York: Penguin, 2002. Print. The 1939 novel about a mentally challenged strong man and the man who tries without success to protect him.
Norman, Howard. What Is Left the Daughter. New York: Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, 2010. Print. An episto-
Melodie Monahan
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
117
The Blind Assassin By Margaret Atwood
W Introduction Margaret Atwood’s The Blind Assassin (2000) is an intricately structured story of two sisters who grow up in Toronto, Ontario, Canada, between the two world wars. The narrative contains the main story, told in the first person by Iris Chase Griffen, the surviving sister. Interspersed with her story of their lives are newspaper clippings and parts of a novel, apparently written by Laura Chase, that contains a science fiction story. The novel opens with Iris’s announcement that soon after the end of World War II, Laura drove Iris’s car off of a bridge and drowned. Iris struggles to remember and record the details in her narrative that lead up to the tragedy. She includes stories of the decline of her once prosperous family led by her industrialist father Benjamin Chase, her subsequent marriage to the wealthy businessman Richard Griffen, Laura’s confinement in a mental institution, and the sisters’ relationship with Alex Thomas, a leftist revolutionary who is on the run from governmental officials. Iris hopes that her estranged granddaughter, Sabrina, will eventually read her account of their family history. The important parallels between the various narrative threads eventually emerge in the novel’s working out of its complex themes, including the difficulties inherent in telling the truth about the past.
W Literary and Historical Context
The important historical contexts in The Blind Assassin are the worldwide Great Depression of the 1930s and the treatment of women during that decade. Canada was particularly hard hit during the Depression. One of the major causes of the economic hardships Canada faced was the collapse of world trade, which generated
approximately one-third of the country’s gross national income. The resulting loss of jobs was compounded by cutbacks on goods and services at home. When Benjamin Chase is forced to close his button factory, he determines that the only way he can protect his daughters is to arrange a marriage between Iris and Richard. The economic hardships Canadian workers endure prompt Alex to become a union organizer, which eventually leads to his participation in illegal activities. Women had limited choices in Canada and in other Western countries during the first half of the twentieth century. At an early age, girls were trained to take on the traditional roles of wife and mother. Women who tried to venture outside the home and establish careers were denounced as a threat to family stability, especially during the Depression when it was difficult for men to find work. Instead, women were encouraged to focus on supporting their husbands’ careers and to sublimate their own ambitions. It took three more decades for women to begin to gain any measure of social and economic advancement. Iris suffers from this oppressive environment, which causes her to sacrifice herself for the economic security of herself and her sister. Her father forces her into marriage with a man she does not love and eventually grows to revile. Laura also becomes caught in this web of oppression. When she tries to rebel, Richard has her confined in a mental institution.
W Themes The Blind Assassin examines how difficult it can be to tell the truth about one’s past, especially when it involves the collapse of a family. Iris claims that she is trying to write an accurate account of her and Laura’s experience, but she often is an unreliable narrator, neglecting to provide all the details. One such detail that she does not include is the reason that she told Laura about her own relationship with Alex—information that contributes to Laura’s
118 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Blind Assassin
death. She avoids anything in her narrative that may point to her negligence and culpability in her sister’s tragedy. She also suggests the motive behind such omissions when she admits that she wants to memorialize herself, to assert her existence, especially to her estranged granddaughter. Another related theme involves the sacrifices Iris was forced to make to protect her sister as well as herself. When she chronicles the soul-deadening life she endures with Richard, admitting that her father coerced her into the marriage to save what was left of the family, she hints at her bitterness over the responsibilities she had to take on, which compounds her anguish. This bitterness appears to have led her to acts of vengeance and subsequent feelings of guilt, which she refuses to acknowledge in an act of self-preservation.
MAJOR CHARACTERS BENJAMIN CHASE is the sisters’ distant father. When he loses his fortune, he arranges Iris’s marriage to Richard. He eventually drinks himself to death. LAURA CHASE is Iris’s naive, fragile sister. She commits suicide after she learns of Iris’s relationship with Alex. IRIS CHASE GRIFFEN is the octogenarian narrator of the central story. She tries to piece together the truth about her and her sister’s past, but her sense of pragmatism conflicts with her feelings of guilt, and as a result, her narrative remains inconclusive. RICHARD GRIFFEN, Iris’s cold, ambitious husband, tries to maintain control of Laura as well as Iris.
W Style Atwood constructs a complex interplay among the four fragmented narratives in the novel. The newspaper clippings provide some of the facts, including the deaths of the family members as well as historical accounts of the Depression and World War II. Iris’s narrative provides only glimpses of the details that lead up to the collapse of her family. The novel published under Laura’s name that Iris includes in her narrative provides clues to the missing pieces in her own story. The tale of the lovers who construct a science fiction narrative that centers on the sacrifice of virgins echoes her feelings of oppression and sacrifice. The title of this narrative, “The Blind Assassin,” hints at Iris’s role in her sister’s tragedy. Her word choice here implies, or at least tries to convince readers, that while she in a sense was her sister’s assassin, she was blind to what she was doing. Ironically, Iris has a keen eye for historical detail, as her name suggests, especially those that help document her life in high society during the Depression and World War II. She arranges her narrative into chapters with titles that call attention to her world—names of places like “The Imperial Room” and The Arcadian Court” or clothing items such as “Red brocade,” The eggshell hat,” or “The houndstooth suit.” Other chapter titles such as “The Weary Soldier” and “Loaf Givers” reflect the realities of war and poverty.
W Critical Reception The critical reception for The Blind Assassin was overwhelmingly positive, with reviewers citing its welltold story, vivid detail, and compelling characters. Many critics noted that the intricate narrative construction was at times difficult to follow yet ultimately rewarding. B. A. Andrews’s review of the novel for World Literature Today commented on Atwood’s postmodern narrative technique: “the writing defines ‘play’ as only great novelists
WINIFRED GRIFFEN PRIOR, Richard’s sister, runs Richard’s household in an effort to ensure that Iris and Laura meet the social standards she has set for all of them. REENIE, Benjamin Chase’s good-hearted housekeeper, looks after the two sisters as they are growing up. ALEX THOMAS is a leftist revolutionary who becomes involved with Iris and Laura.
understand the word: it is precise, mischievous, deft, educated, mysterious, stratified, ambitious, allusive, confounding, spirited, maddening, and clarifying.” Andrews concluded that the novel, while “demanding,” is “dependably entertaining.” Lorrie Moore, in her review for the New Yorker, claimed that The Blind Assassin “is the best example of the kind of narrative pastiche at which [Atwood] excels.” In her review of the novel for Americas, Barbara Mujica insisted it is “like a funhouse hall of mirrors—full of strange twists, false leads, misleading reflections, and labyrinthine trails that weave in and out of one another in the most intriguing way.” Laurie Selwyn, in her review for the Library Journal, found the narrative “compelling,” offering “many different layers of interpretation.” Critics also praise Atwood’s use of language. For example, Mujica commented, “in spite of her intricate plot, her prose flows effortlessly” in this “brilliant and beautiful novel, a veritable tour de force.” She added: “Atwood uses language so deftly. Her metaphors are often astonishing in the way they join together unrelated notions. Yet they never seem intrusive or contrived.” Elizabeth Templeman, in an article for Southern Humanities Review, pointed out Atwood’s “piercing wit, in truncated phrases strung together sometimes relentlessly.” She also praised Atwood’s “meticulous and lustrous” historical detail, which in her view adds to the story’s power.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
119
The Blind Assassin
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Born November 18, 1939, in Ottawa, Ontario, Margaret Atwood began writing when she was six years old and decided less than a decade later to be a writer. She has written several volumes of poetry, nonfiction and fiction, short stories, and children’s books and has been published in more than twentyfive countries. Atwood has received popular and critical acclaim for her writing along with several awards, including Le Chevalier dans l’Ordre des Arts et des Lettres in France and the National Arts Club Medal of Honor for Literature. In 2000 she was awarded the Man Booker Prize for The Blind Assassin. Among her most critically acclaimed works besides The Blind Assassin are The Handmaid’s Tale (1985) and Alias Grace (1996). As of 2010, Atwood lived in Toronto.
Atwood’s characterizations, however, generated some disagreement among critics. Templeman praised Atwood’s characters, who, she argued, are “forcefully
drawn, demanding both interest in their plights, and sympathy.” Andrews, however, asserted that Atwood’s characters “are rarely likable . . . [o]r even ethical,” including those in The Blind Assassin. Yet, she conceded, readers bring their own compassion to the novel and are ultimately entranced by Atwood’s “mesmerizing way with a story, even a story as maddening and complex as this one.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Atwood. Margaret. The Blind Assassin. New York: Random House, 2000. Print. Moore, Lorrie. “BIOPERVERSITY.” New Yorker 19 May 2003: 88. Literature Resource Center. Web. 16 July 2010. Mujica, Barbara. “The Blind Assassin.” Rev. of The Blind Assassin, by Margaret Atwood. Americas (English Edition) 53.1 (2001): 61. Literature Resource Center. Web. 16 July 2010. St. Andrews, B. A. “Review of The Blind Assassin.” World Literature Today 76.1 (2002). Rpt. in Contemporary Literary Criticism. Vol. 246. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Literature Resource Center. Web. 13 July 2010. Selwyn, Laurie. “The Blind Assassin.” Rev. of The Blind Assassin, by Margaret Atwood. Library Journal 125.20 (2000): 212. Literature Resource Center. Web. 16 July 2010. Templeman, Elizabeth. “Review of The Blind Assassin.” Southern Humanities Review 36.1 (2002): 91-93. Rpt. in Contemporary Literary Criticism. Vol. 246. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Literature Resource Center. Web. 13 July 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Bouson, J. Brooks. “‘A Commemoration of Wounds Endured and Resented’: Margaret Atwood’s The Blind Assassin as Feminist Memoir.” CRITIQUE: Studies in Contemporary Fiction 44.3 (2003): 251+. Literature Resource Center. Web. 13 July 2010. Analyzes the politics of gender relations in the novel and claims that the victimization of women links the narratives. Dancygier, Barbara. “Narrative Anchors and the Processes of Story Construction: The Case of Margaret Atwood’s The Blind Assassin.” Style 41.2 (2007): 133+. Literature Resource Center. Web. 13 July 2010. Introduces the concept of narrative anchors, which link the novel’s various substories. One such anchor is the specific language used in the novel’s first sentence relating Laura’s death. Photograph of Margaret Atwood, author of The Blind Assassin. ª BERND THISSEN/epa/Corbis
120
Dumars, Denise. “Out of This World: SF for Novices.” Rev. of The Blind Assassin, by Margaret Atwood. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Blind Assassin
Library Journal 126.13 (2001): 196. Literature Resource Center. Web. 16 July 2010. Explains how Atwood’s works, including The Blind Assassin, fit the genre of science fiction. Hite, Molly. “Tongueless in Toronto.” Women’s Review of Books 18.6 (2001): 1. Rpt. in Contemporary Literary Criticism. Vol. 246. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Literature Resource Center. Web. 13 July 2010. Focuses on how Atwood shapes the novel’s narrative, which reinforces its focus on the problems inherent in trying to tell the truth about the past. Ingersoll, Earl. “Waiting for the End: Closure in Margaret Atwood’s The Blind Assassin.” Studies in the Novel 35.4 (2003): 543+. Literature Resource Center. Web. 13 July 2010. Examines the novel as a mystery, but one without a traditional closure. Gale Resources
Thompson, Lee Briscoe. “Margaret (Eleanor) Atwood.” Canadian Fantasy and Science-Fiction Writers. Ed. Douglas Ivison. Detroit: Gale Group, 2002. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 251. Literature Resource Center. Web. 16 July 2010. http//go. galegroup.com/ps/i.do?&id=GALE&%7 CH1200010390&v=2.1&u=itsbtrial&it=r& p=LitRC&sw=w Open Web Sources
upcoming publications, her blog, a biography, and resources for writers, among others. For Further Reading
Atwood, Margaret. Alias Grace. Toronto: McClelland & Stewart, 1996. Print. Based on the sensational murder trial in 1843 of Grace Marks, a Canadian teenager who worked as a maid for the husband and wife she was accused of murdering. ———. The Handmaid’s Tale. Toronto: McClelland & Stewart, 1985. Print. Dystopia of the near future, made more frightening by its parallels to the political machinations of the early twenty-first century. Cooke, N. Margaret Atwood: A Biography. Toronto: ECW Press, 1998. Print. Contains several excerpts from Atwood’s letters. Kröller, Eva-Marie. The Cambridge Companion to Canadian Literature. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 2004. Print. Examines works by various Canadian writers. Reid, Robin Ann. Women in Science Fiction and Fantasy. Westport: Greenwood, 2008. Print. Essays that focus on British and American science fiction and fantasy in fiction, poetry, nonfiction, film, and art, and explores how women are presented in these works. Adaptations
In 2002, Icon Entertainment International made the film The Blind Assassin in Canada.
Margaret Atwood’s own Web site, at http//margaretat wood.ca, has links to her speaking engagements,
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Wendy Perkins
121
Blindsight By Maurice Gee
W Introduction
W Literary and Historical
Maurice Gee’s Blindsight (2005) is the story of a sister and brother, Alice and Gordon Ferry, of their unusual closeness and how their lives move in divergent directions. The first-person narrator, Alice looks back at the age of seventythree to describe the Ferry family and the schooling and teen years she shared with her brother. Then she traces the divergent life paths Gordon and she took. While Alice flourished as a scientist, Gordon was drawn to helping others, first as a teacher and later in low-level hospital work. The possessive and devoted Alice sought to control Gordon’s choices, and this effort included an action Gee does not reveal until the final pages. While Alice manages to find a harmonious mate and make a name for herself in research, Gordon veers off into anonymity and homelessness. The present action of the novel covers the appearance of Adrian Moore and his developing relationship to Alice, his biological great-aunt. It seems Gordon impregnated a young woman who subsequently gave the baby up for adoption. That child was Adrian’s father who on his deathbed asked Adrian to locate his biological grandfather and reach out to him. Adrian finds the published Alice Ferry easily, but discovering the truth about Gordon is a greater challenge, made more difficult by Alice’s efforts to mislead Adrian. Blindsight is an exploration of sibling relationships and bonding and the kinds of factors that can propel siblings along their separate life paths. Told from the point of view of the seemingly totally reliable narrator, Alice, the story slowly unearths the degree of her obsession with her brother and the lengths she was willing to go to keep him to herself.
Context
One literary context for Blindsight consists of those works that use an unreliable narrator, a device that provides ways to explore the psychology of the narrator and to withhold information from or mislead the reader for any of various reasons. Robert Browning, the nineteenthcentury English poet, used unreliable narrators in his Madhouse Cells, one of which is the so-called lover in “Porphyria’s Lover” (1836). J. D. Salinger’s The Catcher in the Rye (1951) is narrated by teenager Holden Caulfield, and only at the end of the novel do readers learn that Holden is now in a mental institution, and his narration of the events of one weekend when he dropped out of school may be part of a therapy session. Ken Kesey’s 1962 novel One Flew over the Cuckoo’s Nest is narrated by the schizophrenic Chief Bromden who reports through the delusional maze of his symptoms on life in a mental institution. In these examples, the authors draw the reader into the narrator’s reality, and however skewed that perspective is, the reader gets the opportunity to see things in an unusual way. If the author handles the point of view skillfully, then the reader feels increased suspense and intrigue as fissures or inconsistencies in the narrator’s story are noted. By the conclusion, the reader is likely asked to reinterpret events in light of what is ultimately revealed about the narrator. Gee uses this device for his own purposes, giving hints along the way that pique the reader’s curiosity about how the plot is ultimately resolved. Various references provide an historical context for Blindsight. The story begins in the 1940s during World War II, and references are made to Mary Ferry’s fear that her son Gordon may be drawn into military service. Luckily, the war will end before he is old enough to serve. Alice describes the late 1950s and early 1960s when she
122 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Blindsight
and Gordon are dating. She recalls Eddie Fisher’s “Dungaree Doll” (1956) and Ricky Nelson’s “Lonesome Town” (1958) and the rage of the horror movie, The Incredible Shrinking Man (1957), all of which have thematic significance for the novel in its focus on sexual pairing and how individuals measure one another in their efforts to find and choose a mate. Other references are made to Alcoholics Anonymous (AA), the self-help recovery program that in the early 2000s is worldwide, but which had its origins in the United States in the early 1930s with the work of Bill Wilson. By the 1960s and 1970s, AA was well established in New Zealand and helping down-and-out alcoholics take charge of their lives again. Finally, a specific historical seed for the novel was explained by Iain Sharp in his review. Sharp described the “mild-mannered tramp Rob Jones,” who was well known in Wellington, New Zealand. Called “the Bucket Man because he carried his few possessions in a plastic bucket,” Jones also slept in a hiding place on the Tinakori Hills. Sharp listed several characteristics Jones and Gordon shared, “including the bucket, rough Tinakori abode, perpetually downcast gaze, quietness and shuffling route around inner Wellington.” Jones gained even more notoriety when an estimated six hundred people attended his funeral. The physical condition called blindsight refers to a level of perception that may occur in people who are totally blind as a result of injury to the part of the brain that is responsible for vision. In this condition, individuals who are blind in certain parts of their visual field can, nonetheless, respond to certain visual stimuli. Such individuals may not be able to recognize objects, for example, but be able to anticipate movement of objects.
W Themes The novel begins and ends with the same sentence: “Father taught us how not to love” (5, 192). This statement explicitly tags the model set by Earl Ferry as an explanation for how Alice and Gordon develop. Their radically different lives are explained by Alice this way: “I mean Father’s greediness in love, his benevolence and appetite, which started Gordon and me on our divergent ways” (5). If by “taught,” Alice means “by his example,” then Earl showed his children both exceptional benevolence and a heightened sexuality or sensual response to others. These responses in Earl are mixed rather than mutually exclusive. While Alice suggests that Gordon took the path of benevolence and she the path of appetite, the matter is more complicated than that. The thematic point seems to be that as children grow into adulthood they apply something of the lessons they learned in watching their parents and these serve as momentum in shaping the children’s lives.
MAJOR CHARACTERS ALICE FERRY, the narrator, is a seventy-three-year-old widow and retired mycologist. EARL FERRY, Alice’s father, is a chemist like his father, a sentimental man and a sensualist. GORDON FERRY, Alice’s younger brother, is a kind-hearted compassionate man who cannot tolerate cruelty and seeks to help others. CYRIL HANDY is a poor alcoholic friend of Gordon who comes by Gordon’s place for handouts. JOSEPHINE IMRIE is a highly sexed beautician who gets involved in abusive relationships and has a brief affair with Alice’s father. NEVILLE KITE is Alice’s kindly husband, a man older than her father and without academic degrees but brilliant in his field. ADRIAN MOORE, Alice’s great nephew and Gordon’s biological grandson, lives with Alice and tries to discover what became of Gordon. ADRIAN MOORE, biological grandson of Gordon, comes to live with Alice and discover the truth about his biological roots.
The title refers to a medical condition: the ability of an otherwise totally blind person to perceive the location of objects and their movement. In a literal sense, this condition might be used to describe how Gordon walks around town, head down, avoiding eye contact, he shuffles along not seeing those around him and yet aware of them enough to avoid hitting pedestrians who share the sidewalk with him. Considered figuratively, the condition becomes a metaphor for how individuals see the world around them, taking the part they see for the whole when in fact they are blind to most of what exists. In this sense, the term becomes a description of the limits of any particular point of view. This theme is played out in several of the characters. Alice tells part of the story but lies about or omits other parts. She reveals part and she withholds part. She knows and loves her brother intimately and long term, but he disappears from her view, and when he reappears she only sees him in part. This process of trying to see what one is blind to or trying to uncover what is hidden from view or lost can be said to describe much of the novel’s action and indeed the narrative style. Adrian Moore wants to discover his biological grandfather; he relies on what Alice tells him, at first innocently accepting her fiction as truth. But the research efforts of his girlfriend reveal Alice’s lies and omissions, and in a sense, that revelation helps Adrian see more and also causes him
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
123
Blindsight
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Born August 22, 1931, in Whakatane, New Zealand, Maurice Gee grew up in Henderson, a suburb of Auckland, and received his BA and MA from the University of Auckland. Highly prolific and touted as New Zealand’s finest writer, Gee produced numerous collections of short stories through the 1950s and 1960s and nearly thirty novels by the time Blindsight appeared in 2005. After that he published Salt (2007), Gool (2008), and Access Road (2009). In 2004 the University of Auckland awarded him an honorary doctorate in literature. In 2006 Blindsight won the Montana New Zealand Readers’ Choice award and Book award for fiction and the Deutz Medal for Fiction. As of 2010, Gee lived in Wellington, New Zealand.
to question what he has been told. Ultimately, the novel is about the mystery of a homeless person that haunts his relatives who love him. The question of what makes a person go off so entirely from human connection, even when others want to connect with him, remains only partially answered. Incestuous love may be a driving
force, murder may be another, and other determining factors (at least in this novel) remain undiscovered.
W Style Blindsight begins with the elderly Alice observing Gordon, the vagrant, shuffling along the inner-city streets of Wellington. This is their present time. Alice then goes back to their childhood, early family life, and to two important events in Gordon’s life that show his empathy for others and natural inclination to help others feel better. Her reflection on the more distant past is disrupted by the arrival of Adrian Moore who is intent on finding his biological grandfather and has only had luck in identifying his published great-aunt, Alice. The rest of the novel traces Adrian’s efforts, both to assist Alice and to work through her lies to the truth. Another feature of the style is the self-consciousness Alice expresses as the author of her own story. Her intention is to resurrect Gordon, who “stepped into the world with such innocence and goodwill” (7) and at the start showed so much more promise than she did and who has been lost to her for years. She is eager to see “beyond our fire” (7) and yet ambivalent regarding what
Photo of New Zealand author Maurice Gee with his daughter, Emily. Maurice Gee is the author of the novel Blindsight. ª Tim Cuff / Alamy
124
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Blindsight
a widening vision may require of her. This ambivalence shows itself in deliberately checking her speed. For example, at one point she says before she goes on she needs to describe a certain day more fully (45); at another point she remarks, “I’d like to describe my life as Dr Ferry and Mrs Kite but have a bridge to cross before I reach it” (118). A third place she remarks, “I’m shuffling twenty years like playing cards” (138). Added to these stylistic features are the remarkable metaphorical patterns used by Gee throughout the novel, one of which has to do with stitching as a figure for connection, the other with gravitational pull. Faced with her father’s infidelity and unable to soothe his feelings, Alice notes that “the stitching between us was undone” (41). Adrian describes the role of his double bass in the band as “more like stitching. . . . It fastens things together” (62), not unlike Adrian’s role himself regarding Alice and Gordon. Later Alice realizes she and Gordon “circle each other like binary stars . . . together and apart” and others “made no gravitational pull” (82). Their relationship is who they are, made from the same cloth, connected and yet not connected as binary stars.
W Critical Reception Blindsight was well received but not widely reviewed. David Larsen described Gee’s novel as “a remarkable and memorable read.” He also affirmed that the characters “are worth the effort it takes to get to know them.” The novel’s human interest also appealed to Patricia Soper, who pointed out that the story is about “every attribute that makes us human.” Soper concluded: “Gee never disappoints.” Iain Sharp wrote a longer review of Blindsight. Sharp analyzed “high achiever” Alice as the narrator: “Because she initially seems so sane and perceptive, and because she addresses us with Gee’s crystalline lucidity, it takes a while to realise she is not a narrator to be trusted. Her jealousy, possessiveness, snobbery and capacity for frightening rage stand in contrast to Gordon’s easy-going compassion.” Sharp also expounded on the significance of the title for both Gordon and Alice: “Gordon in his later years, trudging the same path through Wellington day after day without lifting his head or meeting anyone’s gaze, is an example of one kind of blindsight. But the subtler forms of impairment that afflict Alice are more disquieting.” Sharp concluded that the book is both a quick read and delivers lasting effect: “Blindsight is a book you can whiz through in a couple of sittings. But its skilfully managed implications will haunt you for weeks to come. It is, without a doubt, one of the year’s best local novels.”
Larsen, David. “Maurice Gee: Blindsight.” Rev. of Blindsight, by Maurice Gee. www.nzherald.co.nz. New Zealand Herald, n.d. Web. 27 Oct. 2010. Sharp, Iain. “Great Fiction from Bleak Street-Truths.” Rev. of Blindsight, by Maurice Gee. Sunday StarTimes 9 Oct. 2005. Print. Soper, Patricia. “Gee Whiz: What a Book.” Rev. of Blindsight, by Maurice Gee. Southland Times 17 Dec. 2005. Print. “Two Minutes with Maurice Gee.” Press [New Zealand] 29 July 2006. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Moore, Christopher. “Playing God Joins the Platinum List.” Press [New Zealand], 14 Oct. 2006. Print. Along with other titles that have sold well, mentions that Gee’s novel Blindsight sold ten thousand copies in its first year. ———. “Worthy of the Award.” Press [New Zealand] 26 July 2006. Print. A description of New Zealand’s Montana New Zealand Book Awards with praise for Maurice Gee for winning it. Gale Resources
“Maurice Gee.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2010. Literature Resource Center. Web. 27 Oct. 2010. http//go.galegroup.com/ps/i.do? &id=GALE%7CH1000035790&v=2.1&u=itsbtria l&it=r&p=LitRC&sw=w For Further Reading
Flagg, Fannie. I Still Dream about You. New York: Random House, 2010. Print. Reflections on the secets people hide combined with a murder mystery. Gee, Maurice. Salt. Orca Books, 2009. Print. One of a trilogy for young adult readers concerning colonialism and radioactive weaponry. Hopper, Kim. Reckoning with Homelessness. Ithaca: Cornell UP, 2003. Print. By an anthropologist and about types of homeless shelters, including almshouses, flophouses, shelters, and airports. Laurence, Margaret. The Stone Angel. Chicago: U of Chicago P, 1964. Print. Narrated by elderly woman who resists adult son’s efforts to place her in a retirement home. Sarton, May. As We Are Now. New York: Norton, 1992. Print. The 1973 novel narrated by an elderly woman in rural old-folks’ home who insists she is not insane.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Melodie Monahan
Works Cited
Gee, Maurice. Blindsight. Auckland: Penguin Group (NZ), 2005. Print. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
125
Blood from Stone By Frances Fyfield
W Introduction Frances Fyfield’s novel Blood from Stone begins when Marianne Shearer—a wealthy and successful, but not very well-liked—criminal defense attorney, leaps to her death from the balcony of a London hotel. Her death leaves many questions unanswered: Why did she kill herself? Why are all her belongings missing? And why did she die wearing such a fantastic skirt? The secrets are wrapped up in Shearer’s final trial, where the successful exoneration of the violent criminal Rick Boyd comes at the cost of his victim, a key witness who commits suicide halfway through the trial. Blood from Stone won the prestigious Dagger Award in 2008, and was hailed by the judges as “a subtly and elegantly written exploration of contemporary themes” (“Frances Fyfield Wins”). Fyfield’s experience as a criminal prosecutor lends her narratives “a believability that her novelist-by-day-novelist-by-night peers often lack” (“Interview: Frances Fyfield”). David Sexton contends she has “emerged as one of the most intriguing and original crime writers in the generation since P. D. James and Ruth Rendell.”
W Literary and Historical Context
Frances Fyfield says, “I hate novels being used as social criticism—it’s like being whacked over the head. . . . Better for that sort of perspective to emerge as a natural result of the story you’re trying to tell” (qtd. in de Villiers). That is not to say that Fyfield’s novels do not have social relevance. The author “has a knack for picking a troubling episode from the news and transforming it to fit into her imaginative world” (Wheatley). While writing Blood from Stone, Fyfield was inspired by the story of Katherine Ward, a British lawyer who leaped to her death from the window of a
London hotel. Fyfield wanted to explore why a successful, attractive woman might do such a thing. “My interest is in the aftermath of crime, and the things that lead up to it,” says the author (qtd. in Coren). “I am not really interested in writing a ‘whodunit.’ I am much more interested in the ‘why’” (qtd. in Wickens). Fyfield’s vast experience working as a lawyer has given her “incredible insight into the best and worst of humanity” (What’s Your Motive?) In her line of work, she would frequently be sent into the worst parts of London, which she says gave her a “fascinating knowledge” (“Seedy Underbelly”). “It instills . . . an ice-chip in the heart which helps you be objective—a great advantage. It acquaints you with all sorts of nasty human behavior” (qtd. in de Villiers). Fyfield talks of the distress felt when “you are no longer surprised by man’s inhumanity to man” and the “sense of relief when you are surprised, but also the cut-off point when you don’t want to know any more. That’s the point at which I begin to write” (qtd. in Dougary).
W Themes Peter Guttridge writes, “Frances Fyfield is all about psychological exploration.” This exploration often proves very dark, and Fyfield has been accused of writing only about “damaged people.” But this, Fyfield says, “makes her work more powerful. The characters are not normal heroes with happy lives and strong roots but must rise above a handicap to become heroic” (Deziel). Not all of Fyfield’s damaged characters are heroes; the theme of the violent serial predator appears in many of her books. Like Rick Boyd in Blood from Stone, her “monsters are very often men who perpetrate the most appalling violence against women” (“Law Meets High Fashion”). Another recurring theme in Fyfield’s writing is the damaged psychology of the battered woman, as her narratives often “bristle with wounding insights into the pathology of women who conspire in their own manipulation” (“Frances Hegarty”). Laura Wilson has said, “[W]hen it
126 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Blood from Stone
comes to the dissection of the human spirit, [Fyfield] is the most efficiently brutal scalpel-wielder we have.” Another theme of Blood from Stone is that of “baggage, both emotional and physical, whether clung to, discarded, or simply stashed away and forgotten” (Wilson). One of the characters, Mr. Joyce, runs a selfstorage unit, and Fyfield skillfully employs this as a metaphor for the unearthing of buried secrets in the narrative. “Storage is magic,” Fyfield writes. “Nothing will perish in here” (248). Mr. Joyce comments that most of what people store is rubbish they can’t bear to get rid of, but it’s “rubbish with attitude and meaning” (251). Finally, Fyfield writes about redemption. Blood from Stone may be dark, “but there are also bright flourishes of hope and a surprising and even uplifting conclusion” (Turnbull). The author says, “What I want to say in all my books is that people can suffer terrible abuse and survive” (qtd. in Sexton).
MAJOR CHARACTERS RICK BOYD is the serial predator represented by Marianne Shearer. He mentally and physically abuses his victims, and cons them for their money. PETER FRIEL is a young lawyer who was on the defense team for Rick Boyd. After the case shatters his belief in the system, he becomes determined to find out why Marianne Shearer killed herself. ANGEL JOYCE is Rick Boyd’s victim. She kills herself halfway through his trial rather than endure the trial and continue to be questioned by Marianne Shearer. HENRIETTA JOYCE is Angel’s older sister, and the one who rescued Angel from Rick Boyd and encouraged her to prosecute. Henrietta, a clothes-restoration and preservation expert, runs the business FrockServe.com.
W Style
MR. JOYCE is Angel and Henrietta’s father, and the proprietor of WJ Storage, a successful self-storage facility.
Fyfield is known for her skillful, elegant prose, and Blood from Stone is no exception. “Her descriptions of the colours and textures of clothing and artifacts are, as always, lyrical and lush” (Wilson). The contrast between Fyfield’s “fluid, almost poetic” prose and the grittiness of her subject matter combine for a “compelling, hypnotic effect” (Low). Fyfield writes, “She was admiring herself, hands splayed on the wood, when I took off the first digit. The blood went in the soup and salt went in the wound. She slept very well, I assure you” (6). Fyfield eschews the traditional “cosiness of so much old-fashioned detective fiction” and instead imbues her work with a melancholic, “haunting, slightly surreal quality” (Sexton). Marcel Berlins, writing for the London Times describes Blood from Stone as unfolding “subtly and absorbingly” in “typically Fyfieldian manner.” Indeed, this slow burn is common in many of the author’s works, as she quietly pulls the reader deeper into the story. “The use of the trial transcripts and the slow pace of the storytelling” give “Fyfield plenty of time to delve into the protagonists’ psyche” (Croll). The author is known for writing stories where plot is a function of character, and the action is driven by the “skillful, creepy psychological” portraits and “penetrating characterization” (Scrivener). Says Fyfield, “I like to explore a situation, not be led by a plot” (qtd. in Coren). In Blood from Stone, that situation is why the lawyer, Marianne Shearer, jumps to her death, and “the explanation . . . is a perfect example of Fyfield’s work: beautifully written, cold, and emotionally brutal” (Wheatley).
MRS. ELLEN JOYCE is Angel and Henrietta’s mother.
W Critical Reception The British press has “gone wild in its praise” of Frances Fyfield, “calling her the ‘new queen of crime’ and the
THE LOVER was Marianne Shearer’s lover for many years. Married with children, he always kept his affair with Marianne secret. THOMAS NOBLE is the lawyer Marianne Shearer left in charge of sorting out her estate after her death. Unfortunately, Noble cannot seem to locate a will or any of Ms. Shearer’s belongings. FRANK SHEARER is Marianne Shearer’s broke and underachieving younger brother, and stands to inherit her money and apartment. MARIANNE SHEARER is the highly successful criminal defense attorney who, for reasons unknown, kills herself after her client Rick Boyd’s exoneration.
‘mistress of menace’” (Scrivener). She is known as “the crime writer’s crime writer,” a statement that appears to ring true: P. D. James, with whom the author is often compared, is reported to have told Fyfield’s Canadian publisher, “you’ll be all right with this one, dear” (Sexton, qtd. in Scrivener). Blood from Stone proved overwhelmingly popular with critics, though a few have taken issue with the plausibility of some of its plot points. A reviewer for the London Independent calls attorney Marianne Shearer’s battering of the witnesses “excessive” and questions whether such behavior would be permitted in an English courtroom (“Law Meets High Fashion”). Some critics find the reasoning behind Shearer’s suicide “highly unlikely” (Croll), but others admit that though “Fyfield’s plot hinges on a whopping coincidence . . . it is acceptable because of her gift for creating characters who seem like real people” (Kerridge).
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
127
Blood from Stone
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Frances Fyfield was born in 1948 in rural Derbyshire, England. Her parents, whom she describes as eccentric, raised animals with no real knowledge of animal husbandry. As a result, pigs escaped, and chickens roamed indoors. “I thought everyone lived like this,” Fyfield says (qtd. in Scrivener). After receiving her BA in English from the University of Newcastle upon Tyne, Fyfield admits she took some time to find her career, taking various jobs from teaching English to working as a sales assistant, until she decided to study law (qtd. in Dougary). After working for the Metropolitan Police and the Crown Prosecution Service, Fyfield published her first novel at age thirty-nine. Since then, the author has published nearly twenty-five crime novels—three under her birth name Frances Hegarty—including two series, and has been nominated for an Edgar Award and won two Dagger Awards. Often compared to the work of Ruth Rendell and P. D. James, her novels are known for their chilling psychological profiles, and A. N. Wilson calls Fyfield “the best crime writer alive” (qtd. in Coren).
However, not all reviewers appreciate highly realistic characters; one such critic found the majority of them “entirely unappealing” and professed “it is extremely difficult for the reader to develop any form of empathy with them” (Croll). Most critics, though, praise Fyfield’s fascinating characters. “They’re all off-kilter, of course— one of Fyfield’s pleasurable trademarks” (Guttridge). Sue Turnbull says, “Fyfield has a talent for capturing the quiet despair of ordinary people trapped by circumstance,” and Shelley Orchard calls one of the protagonists, Henrietta, “clever, cutting, and courageous.” Critics also praise Fyfield’s “ingenious plotting,” and comment that the complex set-up of Blood from Stone “takes Fyfield just ten pages of precise and polished prose to establish” (Turnbull). The narrative is complex; after its initial start the story unfolds slowly and “takes time to work through, but is all the more satisfying and thoughtprovoking for that” (Clements). BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Berlins, Marcel. “Lingering Shivers.” Review of Blood from Stone by Frances Fyfield. Times [London] 15 March 2008. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 11 Aug. 2010 Clements, Toby. “GENRE.” Review of Blood from Stone, by Frances Fyfield. Daily Telegraph [London] 5 April 2008. InfoTrac Newsstand. Web. 11 Aug. 2010. Coren, Giles. “What Makes the Perfect Crime Writer?” Times [London] 5 Aug. 1995. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 11 Aug. 2010. Croll, Luke. Rev. of Blood from Stone, by Frances Fyfield. Reviewing the Evidence Feb. 2008. Web. 11 Aug. 2010. de Villiers, Melissa. “True to Crime.” Sunday Times [South Africa] 3 Aug. 2008. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 11 Aug. 2010. Deziel, Shanda. “Strange and Neurotic.” Maclean’s 29 Apr. 2002: 115-17. Academic Search Complete. Web. 11 Aug. 2010. Dougary, Ginny. “Tales from Humanity’s Underbelly: Ginny Dougary Meets a Lawyer Who Copes with the Distress of Gruesome Crime Cases by Writing Novels.” Independent [London] 27 Nov. 1989. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 11 Aug. 2010. “Frances Fyfield Wins the 2008 CWA Duncan Lawrie Dagger.” The Crime Writers’ Association. Web. 11 Aug. 2010. “Frances Hegarty.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2002. Fyfield, Frances. Blood from Stone. Great Britain: Sphere, 2008. Print. Frances Fyfield, author of Blood from Stone. ª Sophie Bassouls/Sygma/ Corbis
128
Guttridge, Peter. “Review: Crime Round-Up: On the Way from Hope to Despair: Jack Reacher Drifts into TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Blood from Stone
High-Octane Trouble in Colorado, While Elsewhere Blood and Body Parts Abound . . . ” Rev. of Blood from Stone, by Frances Fyfield. Observer [London] 6 April 2008. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 11 Aug. 2010. “Interview: Frances Fyfield.” Book Reporter 20 Apr. 2001. Web. 11 Aug. 2010. Kerridge, Jake. “CRIME; CHICK LIT; Not Just Mindless Violence; Jake Kerridge Tracks Down Dastardly Plots with Emotional Power.” Rev. of Blood from Stone, by Frances Fyfield. Daily Telegraph [London] 6 Dec. 2008. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 11 Aug. 2010. “Law Meets High Fashion in Investigation into WellDressed Barrister’s Death.” Rev. of Blood from Stone, by Frances Fyfield. Independent [London] 27 Mar. 2008. Print. InfoTrac Newsstand. Web. 11 Aug. 2010. Low, Shari. “Staying In: Book Group.” Rev. of Blood from Stone, by Frances Fyfield. Daily Record [Glasgow] 29 Mar. 2008. Highbeam Research. Web. 11 Aug. 2010. Orchard, Shelley. “This Week’s Selections.” Review of Blood from Stone by Frances Fyfield. Advertiser [Sydney] 24 May 2008. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 11 Aug. 2010. Scrivener, Leslie. “A Prosecutor Turns to Crime.” Toronto Star 16 May 1993. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 11 Aug. 2010. “Seedy Underbelly of the Metropolis.” Herald [Glasgow] 20 Mar. 2000. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 11 Aug. 2010. Sexton, David. “London by Fright.” Evening Standard [London] 2 Jan. 1998. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 11 Aug. 2010. Turnbull, Sue. “Plot, Pasta, and Plenty of Claret; Review of the Week.” Rev. of Blood from Stone, by Frances Fyfield. Sydney Morning Herald 28 June 2008. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 11 Aug. 2010. “What’s Your Motive?” Publishers Weekly 247.43 (23 Oct. 2000): 243. Literature Resource Center. Web. 9 Aug. 2010. Wheatley, Jane. “Beyond the Grave, Voices that Still Linger: Books.” Rev. of Blood from Stone, by Frances Fyfield. Times [London] 31 May 2008: 9. InfoTrac Newsstand. Web. 11 Aug. 2010. Wickens, Barbara. “Wondering Why Crime Happens.” Maclean’s 108.22 (29 May 1995): 26. Academic Search Complete. Web. 11 Aug. 2010. Wilson, Laura. “Review: Crime: Blood from Stone, by Frances Fyfield.” Rev. of Blood from Stone, by Frances
Fyfield. Guardian [London] 16 Feb. 2008. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 11 Aug. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
“Frances Fyfield: The Lawyer and Crime Writer on Her New Novel, Blood from Stone.” Rev. of Blood from Stone, by Frances Fyfield. Book Show Web. 11 Aug. 2010. A review of Blood from Stone, and short interview with the author. Sutton, Henry. “Books: New Releases.” Review of Blood from Stone, by Frances Fyfield. Mirror 7 Mar. 2008. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 11 Aug. 2010. A short, positive review of Blood from Stone. Taylor, Andrew. “Recent Crime Novels.” Rev. of Blood from Stone, by Frances Fyfield. Spectator 3 May 2008: 37. Literature Resource Center. Web. 9 Aug. 2010. A positive review of Blood from Stone, focusing on the strength of the narrative. Gale Resources
“Frances Fyfield.” St. James Guide to Crime & Mystery Writers, 4th ed. Detroit: St. James Press, 1996. Rpt. in Biography Resource Center. Web. 11 Aug. 2010. Open Web Sources
Frances Fyfield’s official website at http//www.frances fyfield.co.uk includes biographical information about the author and her novels and awards. Visitors to the website can also listen to a series of short stories by Fyfield, called “A Dark and Stormy Night,” read by various voice-over artists and first broadcast on BBC Radio in 2006. Track six is Fyfield’s interview with Jenny Murray on Women’s Hour on July 5, 2006, after the publication of Fyfield’s novel The Art of Drowning. The website for the Crime Writers’ Association Dagger Awards, at http//www.thecwa.co.uk/index.php gives information about the award, past winners, and author events. There is also information about National Crime Fiction Week, and the Young Crime Writers’ Competition, organized by the Crime Writers’ Association. For Further Reading
Adilman, Sid. “Former U.K. Prosecutor Hunts Fictional Criminals.” Toronto Star 9 Apr. 2002. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 11 Aug. 2010. Fyfield discusses her original desire to write romance, but suggests her “weird and dark imagination” eventually drove her to write crime fiction. Highsmith, Patricia. The Talented Mr. Ripley. New York: Coward-McCann, 1955. Print. The story of the young sociopath Tom Ripley and his quest to trade
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
129
Blood from Stone
his banal existence for a life of wealth and sophistication, at all costs. Highsmith, like Fyfield, is known for her searing psychological portraits, causing the reader to sympathize with Tom even when his actions become completely amoral. James, P. D. Cover Her Face. New York: Simon & Schuster, 1962. Print. In P. D. James’s debut novel, she introduces detective Adam Dalgliesh, who must investigate the murder of a beautiful young social climber. This novel marks the beginning of the Adam Dalgliesh series, with over a dozen novels. Murphy, Rachel. “Interview: Frances Fyfield—How Amanda Brought; Amanda Burton’s Thrilling New Crime Series Is Based on the Life of Author and Solicitor Frances Fyfield.” Mirror [London] 11 May 2002. InfoTrac Newsstand. Web. 11 Aug. 2010. An interview with Fyfield about three of her Helen West novels that have been adapted for television. The character of Helen West is loosely based on Fyfield’s experiences as a prosecutor with the Crown Prosecution Service.
130
Rendell, Ruth. Tigerlily’s Orchids. London: Hutchinson, 2010. Print. In this novel by esteemed crime writer Ruth Rendell, young, naive Stuart Font throws a housewarming party with terrible consequences when he invites his young, beautiful Asian neighbor, whom he has dubbed “Tigerlily.” Richardson, Anna. “Fyfield Snatches Dagger.” Bookseller 18 July 2008: 48. Literature Resource Center. Web. 9 Aug. 2010. A short article detailing Frances Fyfield’s 2008 Dagger Award for Blood from Stone. Selway, Jennifer. “Books: Kind Hearts and Chloroform— Jennifer Selway Talks to Frances Fyfield about Kittens, Crime, and Evil in Court.” Observer [London] 22 Sept. 1991. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 11 Aug. 2010. The author discusses recurring themes in her writing, her schedule, and how her law career and divorce influenced her work. Bisanne Masoud
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Blooms of Darkness By Aharon Appelfeld
W Introduction Set in an unnamed Ukrainian village during World War II, Blooms of Darkness (2006) is the story of a preadolescent Jewish boy who comes of age in a brothel under the care of a Catholic prostitute. Hugo Mansfeld spends most of his time hiding in a closet listening to Mariana conduct business with male clients, who sometimes beat her when she refuses their demands. Over the course of the novel, Mariana increases her drinking and needs Hugo’s tenderness to obtain relief from the depression caused by her work. The two eventually become lovers. When the brothel closes they attempt to make a life together living off the land in the foothills of the Carpathian Mountains, but they are apprehended by the Russian army and separated. Blooms of Darkness has been praised for its spare, evocative prose and, in a series of carefully sketched love scenes, for striking a note of optimism without lapsing into sentimentality. Kind, but also willful and erratic, Mariana cares for Hugo as a protective mother would, but she grows dependent on him as she confides her troubles and discovers that he listens to her without judging her. With the constant threat of Nazi search parties in the background, Aharon Appelfeld shows how love grows out of vulnerability and mutual trust, regardless of the age of the lovers.
W Literary and Historical Context
Blooms of Darkness takes place between 1942 and 1944 in an unnamed village in what is today Ukraine, a country that lies between Poland and Russia. During World War II, the village of the novel was located in territory that was fought over by Germans and Soviet armies. Initially, when Germany invaded Poland in 1939, Germany and the Soviet Union entered into an agreement in which
they each took control of areas that lay between their countries. On June 22, 1941, however, Germany declared war on the Soviet Union, and its army advanced eastward across Ukraine. The allegiance of Ukrainians was split, with the majority of Ukrainians siding with the Soviets. Those Ukrainians who welcomed the Nazis as liberators discovered that the German army had little interest in enlisting their support against the Soviets. Appelfeld makes no mention of how the Nazis administered the parts of Ukraine that they occupied but notes that German soldiers conducted regular searches for Jews. In 1944 the Soviet army started pushing the Germans out of Ukraine. The brothel in Blooms of Darkness provides services to German soldiers who are stationed away from the front. As the Russians advance through Ukraine, the women execute the prostitutes they find because the service they provided to German soldiers was considered to have been aiding the enemy. An estimated five million to eight million Ukrainians died in World War II, including up to 500,000 Jews who were killed by the Germans.
W Themes As the novel’s title suggests, one of the main themes in Blooms of Darkness is the idea that something beautiful or hopeful can emerge from even the most desperate situation. Appelfeld introduces this theme when Hugo flees with his mother through a sewer toward the brothel where Mariana works. When the stench becomes unbearable the young boy faints. He awakes lying on grass, unable to remember most of the journey. Appelfeld writes, “Hugo will think a great deal about that dark night, trying to tie the details together, and he will wonder again and again how his mother had managed to pull him out of the sewer and restore him to life.” At the end of the novel, when Hugo and Mariana wander penniless while evading the Russian army, they find hope and beauty in the Psalms from the Bible, even though Hugo is an atheist and to Mariana the verse is
131 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Blooms of Darkness
MAJOR CHARACTERS MARIANA is the prostitute who cares for Hugo in his mother’s stead but eventually falls in love with him and initiates him into the rites of sex. Mariana is Catholic, and she often tries to convert Hugo, who is Jewish but has been raised as an atheist. VICTORIA is the cook at the brothel who reluctantly watches over Hugo when Mariana abandons him for short spells, either to drink or to look after her own mother. Hugo fears that Victoria will turn him over to the authorities. HUGO MANSFELD is a well-educated eleven-year-old boy whose parents are pharmacists. After Nazi soldiers send Hugo’s father to a concentration camp, Hugo’s mother leaves her son in the care of Mariana, a childhood friend who is now a prostitute. Soft-spoken but observant, Hugo comes of age in the brothel listening from his hiding place in Mariana’s closet to her interactions with her clients, and he eventually becomes her lover. JULIA MANSFELD is Hugo’s mother, who carries her son at night through a sewer to evade the Nazi soldiers who are searching neighborhood homes for Jews. After a number of her contacts vanish, Julia is forced to leave her son at a brothel and find her own place to hide.
incomprehensible. Mariana says to him, “Read, honey, you have a marvelous voice. I don’t understand the poems but they exalt my soul.” The novel also offers a strident argument against fear and pessimism. Early in the novel, before Hugo escapes with his mother, one of the boys from the neighborhood circulates fearsome rumors about what awaits them with the arrival of the Nazis. Hearing the rumors, Hugo thinks to himself, “You mustn’t be so pessimistic. Pessimism weakens you. You have to be strong and encourage your mother.” Mariana says much the same to Hugo when he expresses doubt that they will survive: “Don’t fear. Fear debases us. A debased person isn’t worthy of living. If you’re going to live, then live in freedom. That simple thing was what I didn’t know. All my life I lived a debased life.”
W Style In Blooms of Darkness Appelfeld uses a literary technique called understatement to convey the menacing threat with which people fleeing a murdering army must live. Characters in the novel often speak in terms that are considerably less harsh or severe than the circumstances seem to warrant. For example, when Hugo wakes on the grass and tells his mother that he does not
132
remember anything from after having been carried through the sewer, she responds, “There’s nothing to remember.” The mother betrays no further emotion and the narrative picks up without haste: “But meanwhile, it’s dangerous to linger in the open field. They make their way, hunched over, to a nearby grove of trees. Every few minutes they stop, kneel, and listen.” Both the mother’s dismissive response and the steady pace of the following sentences may seem incongruous with their flight from the Nazis and impending separation, but the contrast between the style of the language and the action of the plot emphasizes rather than diminishes the danger. Appelfeld also uses a limited third-person point of view to emphasize the injustices that many of the characters suffer. The reader sees and hears only what the narrator is able to see and hear. The reader may understand the reported events differently from the narrator, however. In this case, for example, the narrator is an eleven-year-old boy completely unfamiliar with sex who is hiding in a closet of a brothel, and when he gives an account of the noises he hears he does not know that he is describing a sexual act, much less an exceptionally crude one. Likewise, when he hears men leaving in a huff because Mariana has refused one of their demands, he is not aware that she is putting her job—and his safety—in jeopardy. The tenseness of this situation is heightened by the fact that Mariana is entertaining and then rebuffing the very persons who are hunting Hugo during the day. Hugo’s blindness to his danger makes that danger more palpable to the reader.
W Critical Reception Blooms of Darkness has received overwhelmingly positive reviews, with critics citing the allure of Mariana’s character and the simple, evocative language of the novel as its greatest virtues. The reviewer for Publishers Weekly calls Mariana “an exhilarating tragicomic heroine” and claims that Appelfeld’s “lean, spare prose does not shy away from harsh realities.” Also entranced by Mariana, David Leavitt raves in the New York Times Book Review that she is an “astonishing creation” who “sets the novel on fire the moment she enters it.” Focusing on Appelfeld’s language, a reviewer for Kirkus Reviews observes that Blooms of Darkness is “a beautiful read” that “achieves its powerful emotive effects through simplicity and understatement.” Leah Strauss writes in Booklist that the novel is “a haunting tale of love and loss with a conclusion that is both grim and elegantly hopeful.” Some critics rank the novel with Elie Wiesel’s Night and The Diary of Anne Frank, two of the most critically acclaimed and widely read works on Nazi occupation that are told from the point of view of a young person. Writing in the Library Journal, Henry L. Carrigan Jr. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Blooms of Darkness
German soldiers enter a Ukrainian city like the one that serves as the setting for the novel Blooms of Darkness. Roger Viollet/Getty Images
claims, “This latest from Israeli novelist Appelfeld joins classics such as Elie Wiesel’s Night in depicting the struggles of a young man to come to terms with the loneliness and despair of a world falling apart.” Leavitt strikes a similar chord, noting that “like Anne Frank’s diary—a work to which it will draw justified comparison—Blooms of Darkness records a brutal process of education.”
Leavitt, David. “The Whore’s Secret.” Rev. of Blooms of Darkness, by Aharon Appelfeld. New York Times Book Review 21 Mar. 2010: 16(L). Print
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Buruma, Ian. “What Is There to Say?” Rev. of Blooms of Darkness, by Aharon Appelfeld. New York Review of Books 57.7 (2010). Web. 20 Oct. 2010. Asserts that Appelfeld treats being Jewish as an affliction and that the author could be read as being insensitive to assimilated Jews.
Works Cited
Appelfeld, Aharon. Blooms of Darkness. New York: Schocken, 2010. Print. Rev. of Blooms of Darkness, by Aharon Appelfeld. Kirkus Reviews 15 Feb. 2010. Print. Rev. of Blooms of Darkness, by Aharon Appelfeld. Publishers Weekly 4 Jan. 2010: 28. Print. Carrigan, Henry L., Jr. Rev. of Blooms of Darkness, by Aharon Appelfeld. Library Journal 1 Apr. 2010: 66. Print.
Strauss, Leah. Rev. of Blooms of Darkness, by Aharon Appelfeld. Booklist 15 Mar. 2010: 18+. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Cooper, David. Rev. of Blooms of Darkness, by Aharon Appelfeld. New York Journal of Books. New York Journal of Books, LLC, 9 Mar. 2010. Web. 20 Oct. 2010. Argues that a central theme in Blooms of Darkness and other novels by Appelfeld is a sense of sadness and loss among the Gentiles who
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
133
Blooms of Darkness
The events of Blooms of Darkness take place during the struggle to fight off invading German forces. S. Khoroshko/Slava Katamidze Collection/Getty Images
attempt to shield Appelfeld’s Jewish characters from persecution. Glinter, Ezra. Rev. of Blooms of Darkness, by Aharon Appelfeld. National Post [Toronto]. National Post Inc., 13 Mar. 2010. Web. 20 Oct. 2010. Examines how Appelfeld evokes the tragedy and horror of the Holocaust without referring specifically to concentration camps, in part by focusing on private situations in remote corners of the war zone. Margolin, Elaine. “Men from Boys.” Rev. of Blooms of Darkness, by Aharon Appelfeld. Jerusalem Post 4 Apr. 2010. Print. Provides an autobiographical reading of Blooms of Darkness and speculates that Appelfeld writes to reunite with his mother, who was killed by Nazi soldiers when Appelfeld was nine years old. Gale Resources
“Aharon Appelfeld.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2010. Gale Biography in Context. Web. 20 Oct. 2010. “Aharon Appelfeld.” Encyclopaedia Judaica. Ed. Michael Berenbaum and Fred Skolnik. 2nd ed. Detroit: Macmillan Reference USA, 2007. Gale Biography in Context. Web. 20 Oct. 2010.
134
“Aharon Appelfeld.” Encyclopedia of World Biography. Detroit: Gale, 1998. Gale Biography in Context. Web. 20 Oct. 2010. Open Web Sources
In an online interview with Haaretz, Israel’s oldest daily newspaper, Appelfeld discusses his escape from a German concentration camp in 1941 and the various ways he accesses memories when he prepares to write about his past. http//www.haaretz.com/culture/ books/questions-answers-a-conversation-withaharon-appelfeld-1.283933 At writerscast.com, a Web site that features interviews with contemporary writers, Aharon Appelfeld discusses with David Wilks how he works with translators, about the languages he spoke in his home, and why Blooms of Darkness is a work of fiction despite its many autobiographical elements. http//www .writerscast.com/aharon-appelfeld-blooms-of-dark ness/ The Web site Roland Collection of Films on Art provides a video interview with Aharon Appelfeld in which he discusses his arrival in Israel and his decision to become a writer. http//www.rolandcollection.com/ films/?prm=a20-b116-c1662-d2-e0 TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Blooms of Darkness For Further Reading
Appelfeld, Aharon. The Story of a Life: A Memoir. New York: Schocken, 2004. Print. Memoir chronicling a period of more than seventy years covers Appelfeld’s escape from a concentration camp, his resettlement in Palestine at age fourteen, his university studies, and his writing career. Appelfeld also reflects on what it means to be Jewish and why one should write about the subject without sentimentality.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Frank, Anne. The Diary of a Young Girl. Ed. Otto H. Frank. Trans. Susan Massotty. New York: Everyman’s Library, 2010. Print. New edition of the diary contains 30 percent more material than the original version (1947) and recasts Anne Frank to be more sarcastic and rebellious than the sensitive, vulnerable child of the original version.
Aharon Appelfeld was born on February 16, 1932, in Zhadova, a village in what is now Ukraine. When he was eight years old, Nazi soldiers raided his home, murdered his mother, and deported him and his father to a concentration camp in the Romanian-occupied district of Transnistria. The boy escaped from the camp and lived in the woods for three years before he was captured by the Russian army and forced to work as a cook. After the war, Appelfeld lived briefly in a displacedpersons camp in Italy and then immigrated to Palestine in 1946. He now lives in Israel. The author of more than forty books, Appelfeld is considered one of the leading writers who publishes in Hebrew. Appelfeld draws heavily on his past in much of his fiction but rarely makes explicit reference to his experience in a concentration camp, focusing instead on private, isolated situations in remote areas away from the battlefields and the camps. Although he was raised speaking German, Appelfeld writes in Hebrew, which he began studying at age thirteen, because he believes it would be repugnant to tell the story of the Jewish experience during World War II in the language of those who persecuted Jewish people.
McCarthy, Cormac. The Road. New York: Vintage, Rpt. ed., 2009. Print. Like Mariana and Hugo, who trudge through the foothills of the Carpathian Mountains in the waning days of World War II, the father and son in McCarthy’s novel wander alone through a world in the aftermath of its devastation, scavenging for food and seeking shelter from murdering bands of thugs.
II recounts the author’s return with her mother to their native soil in 1991. Savage visits personal friends of her mother as well as historical markers such as the excavation of a mass grave that honors victims of Stalin’s purges.
Carell, Paul. Scorched Earth: The Russian-German War, 1943-1944. Atglen: Schiffer, 1994. Print. Regarded by many historians as the definitive account of the German defeat in eastern Europe by the Russian army, this volume contains hundreds of photographs, military campaign maps, and an extensive bibliography.
Roth, Philip. Shop Talk: A Writer and His Colleagues and Their Work. New York: Vintage, 2002. Print. Roth’s collection of interviews with fellow writers contains a chapter in which Appelfeld discusses his decision to write in Hebrew rather than in German. Savage, Ania. Return to Ukraine. College Station: Texas AM UP (TAMU Press), 2000. Print. Memoir by a Ukrainian-born journalist who fled during World War
Wiesel, Elie. Night. New York: Hill Wang, 2006. Print. Memoir chronicles author’s experiences in Auschwitz and Buchenwald concentration camps with his father and includes an account of Wiesel’s loss of faith in God and his disgust with himself for at times wishing he could be free of his ailing father.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Joseph Campana
135
Blue Heaven By C. J. Box
W Introduction Blue Heaven is a thriller set in the gorgeous ranch country of northern Idaho, where retired Los Angeles Police Department (LAPD) officers come to retire—an area known as “Blue Heaven.” When a twelve-year-old girl, Annie, and her younger brother, William, witness an execution-style murder perpetrated by four retired police officers, they flee for their lives. The killers, however, volunteer to lead the search for the missing children and the unsuspecting local sheriff agrees. With no one to trust, Annie and William meet Jess Rawlins, a old-school rancher with a stubborn streak who is determined to protect the children and serve justice on the killers looking for them. Meanwhile, a retired LAPD detective, Eduardo Villatoro, comes to town to investigate a decade-old robbery-and-murder case that has been unsolved too long and becomes embroiled in the chase. Told over a tense, action-packed forty-eight-hour period, Blue Heaven explores themes of greed, betrayal, trust, justice, and the power of redemption. Upon its publication, the novel quickly became a best seller. In 2009 it received the Edgar Award for Best Mystery Novel of 2008. As critic Margaret Cannon states in her review of the book, “Blue Heaven is [C. J.] Box’s seventh novel, and it’s as good as a psychological/action thriller gets.”
W Literary and Historical Context
Blue Heaven is regarded as one of the best examples of the thriller genre published in 2008. To be successful, thrillers use suspense and excitement through a variety of narrative techniques, including cliffhangers, plot twists, and red herrings, and by creating an atmosphere of danger by implied or real violence, crime, chase scenes, and mysterious or menacing characters. In Blue Heaven, the action takes place over a very short time and is
intensified by the reader’s concern for the threatened characters: two scrappy but vulnerable children, Annie and William, who are being chased by four experienced and heartless ex-cops who are determined to kill them. The thriller genre can be traced back to ancient epic poems, like Homer’s Odyssey, and One Thousand and One Nights, which use plot twists and elements of detective fiction. Thrillers have been a popular genre throughout history; whether through stories told around a campfire or in medieval castles or in isolated homes in the wilderness, some of the most popular stories were thrillers because they are entertaining, exciting, and appealed to the human instinct for justice and survival. There are several subgenres of thrillers, such as spy novels, crime fiction, mystery fiction, and legal thrillers. Today thrillers are one of the most successful genres of popular fiction. Blue Heaven also touches on a cultural issue that has garnered debate and controversy in recent years: the conflict between outsiders and longtime residents of Montana, Wyoming, Idaho, and similar areas because of land development. As outsiders buy up land to build mini-ranches and swoop in for long vacations, longtime residents resent the ostentatious homes and estates of these newcomers. There is a clash of lifestyles and values—and economics. Newcomers are often very wealthy, while many old-time ranchers are not. Although their influx of cash into county coffers and local businesses are welcomed, their lifestyles and culture often are not.
W Themes Betrayal is a recurring theme in Blue Heaven. As the novel opens, Annie and William feel betrayed by their mom because of her boyfriend, and they escape to go fishing— only to witness a murder by four ex-cops. They are then pursued by the killers, who are supposed to follow the law and protect them, not kill them. They are also inadvertently betrayed by the townspeople, who have
136 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Blue Heaven
been fooled by the ex-cops. With the killers heading the search for Annie and William, the kids do not have anyone to trust until they meet Jess Rawlins. As in most crime thrillers, justice is also a central theme in Blue Heaven. Jess realizes he has to protect Annie and William, even at the risk of his own life. Eduardo comes to Idaho to solve a decade-old crime because the victim’s family deserves justice. In the process, both men find redemption: Jess, battered by romantic and financial problems and feeling like a failure, is redeemed by doing the right thing for Annie and William; and Eduardo will finally solve a crime that has haunted his conscience for years. Box also touches on a sociocultural theme that has affected the west since the first settlers came out to build ranches and cities in a pristine natural environment: the conflict between new arrivals and those already on the land. Newcomers represent change—sometimes unwelcome change. In Blue Heaven, the new arrivals are the retired LAPD cops who are trying to escape their own haunted pasts. “Box deftly weaves in another important issue that faces the ‘new’ West—depressed rural communities being invaded by ‘transplants’ who move there for the area’s character and then turn around and try to change everything,” Leslie Doran writes in a review of the novel. “Among the many new residents in Idaho are the retired West Coast cops. Some try to fit in and join the community; others stay by themselves and follow unknown pursuits, showing little respect for their neighbors.”
W Style In reviews of Blue Heaven, critics maintain that Box fully uses his rural Idaho setting not only to create suspense in the novel, but also to add richness and texture to the story. Leslie Doran observes that “Box uses the rich Idaho landscape to good effect, setting much of the action outdoors. The rugged wilderness provides a welcome haven for the children, offering many places for hiding while at the same time threatening their chances of survival. Early-spring weather is treacherous, and wildlife abounds, but the most dangerous threat comes from the men chasing them.” Reviewer Hallie Ephron concurs and applauds Box’s ability to engage the reader through setting and by exploiting the characteristics of a suspense novel. “The ranch setting, combined with a rich, complex story, gives the novel the flavor of a Western saga,” she states in her review of Blue Heaven. “Cliffhanger scene shifts, a ticking clock, and escalating danger lend it all the trappings of a suspense novel, but with characters that make the reader care.” Leslie Doran also comments on Box’s use of the ticking clock technique in the novel. “The proverbial ticking clock drives the sometimes-frantic pace of Blue Heaven, with a majority of the novel taking place over a two-day period,” Doran notes.
MAJOR CHARACTERS JESS RAWLINS is a rancher in the North Idaho area known as “Blue Heaven.” When Annie and William Taylor show up in trouble and in need of an ally, Jess helps them at risk to himself. With a failing ranch on the cusp of foreclosure and abandoned by his family, Jess is determined to redeem himself by protecting Annie and William. ANNIE TAYLOR is a twelve-year-old girl who sees a murder while fishing with her little brother, William. The two siblings escape into the woods and find protection from a local rancher, Jess Rawlins. MONICA TAYLOR is Annie and William’s lonely and scared mother. A heartbreaker, she has a knack for getting involved with the wrong men. WILLIAM TAYLOR is Annie Taylor’s younger brother. While fishing one day, they witness an execution-style murder and must go on the run to escape the killers. EDUARDO VILLATORO is a retired LAPD detective who comes to Idaho to investigate an old robbery case and becomes involved in protecting Annie and William.
Analysis of Box’s narrative style also extends to his prose and exposition. Margaret Cannon finds that “his prose is as spare and elegant as James Lee Burke’s, and his loving exposition of the western American landscape is excellent, as good as anything Hollywood ever put on film.” Reviewers also examine the depth and realism of the characters in Blue Heaven, arguing that Box succeeds in crafting complicated, believable characters facing convincing problems and issues. “One of the more attractive features of any Box novel is the memorable characters he creates,” Leslie Doran argues. “They display the welcome familiarity of the old West while facing the challenges of the new West. His characters are sympathetic, with fully realized depth and complexities.”
W Critical Reception Blue Heaven spent four weeks at the top of the New York Times best-seller list and received the Edgar Award for Best Mystery Novel in 2008. Critics praised the novel as a suspenseful, action-packed read. In her Globe and Mail review, Margaret Cannon maintains that “this is a terrific suspense novel, with superb characters and a satisfying plot. You’ll be hooked.” Chris Rubich also commends the sense of high drama and tension in Blue Heaven. “It’s four days of high tension and high action. And Box delivers surprises until the final page,” he states in his review of the novel. Another reviewer, Leslie Doran, finds that the novel “crackles with electric tension and action,
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
137
Blue Heaven
ABOUT THE AUTHOR C. J. Box was born in Casper, Wyoming, and attended college at the University of Denver in Colorado. After graduating in 1981, he worked briefly as a ranch hand, exploration surveycrew member, fishing guide, and newspaper reporter and editor. Box is also the former manager of travel development for the Wyoming Travel Commission. In recent years, he founded the Rocky Mountain International Corporation, which promotes tourism to Montana, Wyoming, South Dakota, North Dakota, and Idaho from Europe. He is currently the CEO and president of the company. In 2001 his first novel, Open Season, introduced the character of Joe Pickett, a crimesolving game warden in Wyoming. Box’s Joe Pickett series has proven to be very popular and the novels have been translated into 24 languages. In 2007 he was honored as Writer of the Year by the Rocky Mountain Fiction Writers. He lives in Cheyenne, Wyoming.
while the characters plumb the depths of human emotions, including greed, corruption, callous disregard of human suffering and, on the other hand, love, honor and compassion.” Some reviewers, however, criticized narrative strategies that counteracted the carefully constructed suspense. A review in Publishers Weekly found fault with one of the storylines in the novel and unfavorably compared Blue Heaven with Box’s wildly popular Joe Pickett series. “A subplot involving a retired California detective pursuing the original robbery case adds too many extra characters and undercuts the suspense,” the review states. “Readers expecting the same brisk story lines as the author’s Joe Pickett crime novels (Free Fire, etc.) will be disappointed.” Chris Rubich assesses Box’s complicated and authentic characters as one of the best aspects of the novel. “Box excels in capturing the personalities and lifestyles of the inland Northwest,” Rubich asserts. “He also masterfully peels away the layers of lives to reveal secrets that influence folks’ decisions across decades.” Focusing on Rawlins, the protagonist of Blue Heaven, Rubich finds that there are similarities between the hard-knocked Rawlins and Box’s most famous character, Joe Pickett. “Fans of Joe Pickett will find the tortured good-guy values in Rawlins, too,” he adds. “And the added focus of the children struggling just to get home and erase the dangers makes the stakes higher.” Most critics found Blue Heaven to be a rich, fastpaced thriller. “Against a backdrop of wilderness, rich with the scent of pine and cattle, there are strong elements of classic tragedy here as well, as yearning propels all of the characters, good and bad, into mortal peril,” Hallie Ephron concluded in her review. “Blue Heaven is my favorite kind of thriller—one with a heart.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Rev. of Blue Heaven, by C. J. Box. Publishers Weekly 254.41 (15 Oct. 2007). Print. Cannon, Margaret. Rev. of Blue Heaven, by C. J. Box. Globe and Mail 5 Feb. 2008. Web. 10 Aug. 2010. Doran, Leslie. “Kids Flee Killers in Idaho Panhandle: C. J. Box Enters Thriller Territory with Plight of Siblings Who Witness a Murder.” Denver Post 24 Feb. 2008. Print. Ephron, Hallie. “Sleuths Bearing Wrenches, and Old Wounds.” Boston Globe 27 Jan. 2008. Web. 10 Aug. 2010. Rubich, Chris. “Betrayals Mount in Box’s New Novel.” Billings Gazette 26 Jan. 2008. Web. 10 Aug. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Portrait of C. J. Box, author of Blue Heaven. Matthew Peyton/Getty Images
138
Blundell, Graeme. “Long-Running Arm of the Law.” Australian 10 May 2008. Finds Blue Heaven to be TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Blue Heaven
“as classy, elegiac and as affecting as any of those wonderful Joe Pickett stories.” Graff, Keir. Rev. of Blue Heaven, by C. J. Box. Booklist 104.3 (1 Oct. 2007). Commends Box’s ability to build suspense in Blue Heaven, and calls the novel a true page-turner. Hartlaub, Joe. Rev. of Blue Heaven, by C. J. Box. Bookreporter.com 2008. Web 10 Aug. 2010. Favorable review of the novel that praises Box’s distinctive twist on the crime thriller genre. Gale Resources
“C. J. Box.” Contemporary Authors Online. Farmington Hills: Gale, 2010. Open Web Sources
C. J. Box’s website, www.cjbox.net, features synopses of his books, his blog, a reader forum and polls, and a photo gallery. It posts updated information on his upcoming appearances and other events. Fans can also sign up for Box’s newsletter. Similar information on Box, his books, and critical reviews of his novels can be found on the Macmillan website, found at www.us.macmillan.com. Tourism information about Idaho, the setting of Blue Heaven, can be found at the Idaho Tourism Bureau website, at www.visitidaho.org. Peruse maps and photographs, sign up for an e-newsletter, and learn about all the events and activities happening in the state. The National Park Service website for Yellowstone Park, at www.nps.gov/yell, features video and photos of the gorgeous national park. You can also view the Old Faithful webcam, which streams the geyser eruptions live.
For Further Reading
Anderson, Patrick. The Triumph of the Thriller. New York: Random House, 2007. Print. Explicates the long-standing popularity of the thriller genre and considers some of its most important figures, such as Edgar Allan Poe, Raymond Chandler, Dashiell Hammett, and Dennis Lehane. Ascari, Maurizio. A Counter-History of Crime Fiction: Supernatural, Gothic, Sensational. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2007. Print. Traces the evolution of crime fiction from the Middle Ages to the late twentieth century, exploring how the genre developed and differentiated itself from detective fiction. Box, C. J. Nowhere to Run. New York: G. P. Putnam’s Sons, 2010. Print. In this novel, Joe Pickett is working in his last week as the temporary game warden in the isolated town of Baggs, Wyoming. When strange things start happening in the surrounding mountains, he is compelled to investigate. James, P. D. Talking about Detective Fiction. New York: Knopf, 2009. Print. James is regarded as one of the world’s top writers of detective fiction. In this literary history, she investigates the origins of the genre and considers the long-lasting appeal of detective novels. Parker, T. Jefferson. Iron River. New York: Dutton, 2010. Print. Parker’s 2010 novel is the third in the series featuring Los Angeles Sheriff Deputy Charlie Hood. In this book, Hood joins Operation Blowdown, a law enforcement attempt to stop the massive flow of guns and money across the U.S.-Mexico border.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Margaret Haerens
139
The Boat to Redemption By Su Tong
W Introduction Set in Milltown, a fictional city along the Golden Sparrow River in China, The Boat to Redemption (2009) chronicles eleven years (1966-1977) in the life of Ku Dongliang, the son of Communist Party enthusiasts. Following his parents’ divorce, Dongliang comes of age among barge workers in a river community. Over the course of the novel, Dongliang, who narrates the story, copes with his father’s disgrace, his mother’s strident loyalty to the Communist Party, and his own frustrated sexual longings by nursing an obsession for Huixian, an orphan who grows into a beauty and becomes a favorite of party leaders. The Boat to Redemption has been praised for its realistic portrayal of the relationships between small-time party members and disenfranchised citizens during China’s Cultural Revolution. The people of Milltown do their best to follow Communist doctrine to the letter, often quoting slogans in their everyday speech, while looking with scorn on the barge workers, who do not concern themselves at all with politics. The story highlights the extremes of behavior to which people resort when forced to live under intense government scrutiny and to vie for political favor. Su Tong’s novel won the Man Asian Literary Prize in 2009.
W Literary and Historical Context
The Boat to Redemption is set during the Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution, which began on August 8, 1966, when the Communist Party of China (CCP) passed the “Decision Concerning the Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution,” and ended on September 9, 1976, with the death of the CCP chairman Mao Zedong. Under the supervision of Chairman Mao,
the Cultural Revolution affected the lives of almost every Chinese citizen. The decade was marked by famine, violence, the destruction of antiques and cultural artifacts, and a comprehensive dissemination of propaganda. Mao made his primary appeal to the youth of China, who responded by forming the Red Guards, associations of young paramilitaries who were encouraged by the CCP to terrorize anyone whose devotion to party ideals was deemed questionable. Local authorities were instructed to disregard the actions of these ruffians. Mao spread his ideals by circulating a red book, known in the West as “The Little Red Book,” which was filled with his quotations, and by subsidizing operas and films that celebrated party ideals. He posted his portrait throughout the country and commissioned posters illustrating various aspects of the party’s vision. On June 27, 1981, five years after Mao’s death, the CCP issued an official judgment on the Cultural Revolution, distancing itself from Mao’s actions during that infamous decade but at the same time honoring his contribution to the establishment of the People’s Republic of China. China’s government discourages independent research on this period of its history. In writing about this subject while resident in China, Su Tong risks being labeled a dissident by the Chinese government. The Boat to Redemption contains no explicitly derogatory remarks about Mao Zedong or the CCP.
W Themes Martyrdom and celebrity are central themes in The Boat to Redemption. The novel opens with an account of Deng Shaoxiang, a revolutionary martyr who stored guns and ammunition in coffins for retrieval by the Communist army. According to legend, Deng’s activities were discovered when she changed her routine by storing pistols in a baby basket. Before her execution, she set the baby, rumored to be her son, afloat on the Golden
140 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Boat to Redemption
Sparrow River in his basket. Officially recognized as the child in the basket, Ku Wenxuan lives a life of privilege until middle age. The CCP then revokes his birthright, declaring that the fish-shaped birthmark on his buttocks, which marks him as Deng’s progeny, is fraudulent. Immediately afterward he loses his position as Milltown’s party secretary. The novel’s two central female characters, Qiao Limin and Huixian, pursue honor by auditioning for roles in the party-endorsed operas that tour the country. Neither achieves national fame but both become local celebrities, Qiao as a radio broadcaster, and Huixian for her reenactments of Li Tiemei, the central character in The Legend of the Red Lantern, a famous opera from the period. Aside from its political concerns, The Boat to Redemption focuses on Dongliang’s struggle to escape his father’s tyrannical rule. Shamed by public knowledge of his philandering, Ku Wenxuan will not so much as permit Dongliang to have an erection, even after the latter has grown well into his twenties. Dongliang steadfastly defies his father but cannot summon the courage to move away.
W Style Su Tong’s works have often deviated from conventional modes of storytelling, and the author is also known for crafting lavish, elegant sentences that violate standard rules of grammar. The Boat to Redemption, however, is a traditional, linear novel written in simple, grammatically sound sentences. The action of the novel unfolds in chronological sequence, with the characters often speaking in the stilted language of Communist party doctrine. For example, when a group of barge workers gathers to dissuade Ku Wenxuan from punishing his son for his pursuit of Huixian, Wenxuan tells them, “Go ahead, stir up plenty of trouble and break all the rules. I won’t need to use family law; I’ll let national laws do their job. Sooner or later you’ll be handed over to the dictatorship of the proletariat.” Satirical in his philandering days Ku Wenxuan would seduce a woman by telling her that “your body emanates the spirit of revolutionary romanticism.” During Wenxuan’s stint as party secretary, women felt honored when he told them that they appeared to be living in accord with the revolution’s ideals of hard work and selflessness. Su Tong’s writing in these passages can be read as satirical. In the instances cited above, Su is likely criticizing the leaders of the CCP, who imposed such stilted language on ordinary citizens. He may also be making fun of people who internalize the language to such an extent that they use it when discussing romantic love and such private family matters as disciplining children.
MAJOR CHARACTERS BIANJIN, the town idiot, is declared the rightful son of Deng Shaoxiang, based on the identification of a fish-shaped birthmark on his buttocks. HUIXIAN is the object of Ku Dongliang’s obsession. The two first meet as children, when the abandoned Huixian is adopted by the barge workers in the river community. When she grows into a beautiful young woman, the party casts her as Li Tiemei, the heroine from a famous opera popular during the Cultural Revolution, in its parades. Huixian fails to become an actress and loses her party privileges as a result of her willfulness. KU DONGLIANG, who is fifteen when the story begins, is the narrator of the novel. After his parents’ divorce he moves with his father onto a barge. He falls in love with Huixian, an orphaned girl adopted by the river community. When Huixian moves to Milltown, Dongliang stalks her until the party’s security officers threaten his life. KU WENXUAN grows up believing that he is the son of Deng Shaoxiang, a martyred revolutionary heroine. When investigators declare instead that he is the son of a fisherman and a prostitute, Wenxuan loses his prestigious government post, and his wife divorces him. Wenxuan spends the rest of his life petitioning the government to recognize his birthright. QIAO LIMIN is Dongliang’s mother, a factory worker, and a radio broadcaster. She divorces Ku Wenxuan after he loses his birthright and confesses his extramarital affairs to party officials. Qiao refuses to share custody of Dongliang and forces him to choose to live either with her or with Wenxuan. ZHAO CHUNTANG assumes Wenxuan’s position as party secretary in Milltown. He recruits Huixian by giving her a prominent role in the party’s parades but later demotes her when she refuses to live at his beck and call.
W Critical Reception The Boat to Redemption has received mostly positive reviews. Critics who praise the novel point to the narrator’s charisma and the accuracy of the author’s depiction of life during China’s Cultural Revolution, which Su leavens with bawdy humor that exposes the absurdity of the government’s preoccupations. In the London Daily Mail, Eithne Farry claims that the author “paints Dongliang’s erratic behaviour with broad brush-strokes and the humour is rough, raw and irreverent, but there is genuine sympathy for the maverick
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
141
The Boat to Redemption
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Su Tong is the pen name of Zhong Gui Tong, who was born on January 23, 1963, in Su Zhou, a city of six million people located along the Yangtze River. He has published several novels and more than two hundred short stories and is among the most widely admired of contemporary Chinese writers. He achieved international fame when a film version of Raise the Red Lantern, a novella from Wives and Concubines (1990), earned a nomination for the Academy Award for Best Foreign-Language Film in 1992. A leading figure among China’s avant-garde writers, Su Tong has a reputation for elegant prose and formal experimentation. A traditional realist novel, The Boat to Redemption is recognized as a departure from his previous work.
whose impetuous behaviour can only bring trouble in a prescriptive, claustrophobic world.” SH Lim of Time Out Kuala Lumpur notes that Su successfully portrays the
extremes of behavior characteristic of those who live under intense government scrutiny. “What the novel captures is a kind of life where the frantic impulse to survive—to have enough to fill the stomach and quench the throat—overwhelms and precipitates ridiculous behavior,” Lim writes. Likewise, Shabhano Bilgrami argues in the Asian Review of Books that the balance Su strikes between “painful, gut-wrenching incidents” and “a passion, which is tempered by humor” make the novel “not only bearable but mesmerizing to read.” Critics who fault the novel claim that Su undermines its plot by devoting too much of the second part of the book to Huixian. Lim calls Huixian’s misadventures “a detour that leads nowhere.” Hugo Barnacle of the London Sunday Times argues that the second part of The Boat to Redemption “breaks one of the basic rules of narrative”: Dongliang, a first-person narrator, cannot possibly know about Huixan’s experiences on land because he is not present. One notable exception to this view is Christine Williams’s review in the Sunday Express, which asserts that, when Huixian becomes the focus of the narrative, “more twists, turns and tragedies hold the reader’s attention right to the end.”
In The Boat to Redemption, the main character lives with his father on a barge in China. ª Horizon International Images Limited/Alamy
142
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Boat to Redemption BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Barnacle, Hugo. Rev. of The Boat to Redemption, by Su Tong. Sunday Times. Times Newspapers Ltd, 12 Feb. 2010. Web. 13 Oct. 2010. Bilgrami, Shabhano. Rev. of The Boat to Redemption, by Su Tong. Asian Review of Books. Image Alpha (Holdings) Ltd, 4 Jan. 2010. Web. 13 Oct. 2010. Farry, Eithne. Rev. of The Boat to Redemption, by Su Tong. Mail Online. Associated Newspapers Ltd, 1 Feb. 2010. Web. 13 Oct. 2010.
community and concludes that the novel’s central concern is with how corrupt politics exile a person from his or her potential. “The Boat to Redemption a Winning Perspective on the Past.” People’s Daily Online. People’s Daily Online, 7 Dec. 2009. Web. 13 Oct. 2010. Distinguishes The Boat to Redemption from other novels and short stories by Chinese writers on the Cultural Revolution, which, the reviewer notes, typically have adult rather than adolescent protagonists. Gale Resources
Lim, SH. Rev. of The Boat to Redemption, by Su Tong. Time Out Kuala Lumpur. Time Out Group Ltd, May 2010. Web. 13 Oct. 2010.
“Zhong Gui Tong.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2007. Gale Biography in Context. Web. 12 Oct. 2010.
Su Tong. The Boat to Redemption. Trans. Howard Goldblatt. London: Random House, 2010. Print.
Open Web Sources
Williams, Christine. Rev. of The Boat to Redemption, by Su Tong. Express.co.uk. Northern and Shell Media Publications, 4 Jan. 2010. Web. 13 Oct. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Hill, Justin. Rev. of The Boat to Redemption, by Su Tong. Independent [London]. Independent Print Ltd, 29 Jan. 2010. Web. 13 Oct. 2010. Speculates that English-speaking readers are likely to find the humor and the violence in the novel juvenile and overwrought but that Chinese readers will regard the novel’s melodrama as an accurate representation of life during the Cultural Revolution. Li, Yiyun. Rev. of The Boat to Redemption, by Su Tong. Guardian [London]. Guardian News and Media Ltd, 9 Jan. 2010. Web. 13 Oct. 2010. Notes that, on the strength of his previous, more experimental works, Su Tong had established himself as a leader in China’s avant-garde, but that The Boat to Redemption marks a shift in Su’s style from exotic, labyrinthine sentences to the more prosaic, familiar language of a realistic novel. Mirsky, Jonathan. “Fear Hovers in China.” Rev. of The Boat to Redemption, by Su Tong. Spectator 16 Jan. 2010: 36+. Print. Contains anecdotes from some of Su Tong’s colleagues, who lived through the Cultural Revolution, and gives specific examples of the privileges high-ranking party members enjoyed, including greater access to their personal files and permission to add details to the most flattering aspects of the files. Mukherjee, Neel. Rev. of The Boat to Redemption, by Su Tong. Neelmukherjee.com. Neel Mukherjee, 5 Feb. 2010. Web. 13 Oct. 2010. Contrasts the proper lives of the party members living on land with the bawdy, slapstick existence of the people in the barge
Su Tong discusses reading habits in modern China and corruption in the Chinese publishing industry in an interview with China Daily, an English-language national newspaper published by the Chinese government. http//www.chinadaily.com.cn/en/doc/ 2003-08/24/content_257750.htm China the Beautiful—a cultural heritage Web site with links to pictures and information on Chinese classics, art, history, literature, poetry, calligraphy, and paintings—has recordings of several of the arias from The Legend of the Red Lantern, the opera frequently referenced in The Boat to Redemption. http//www .chinapage.com/xwang/aria.html#list Morning Sun, a Web site that documents the origins and history of the Cultural Revolution in China, has video footage of The East Is Red, a government-sponsored, epic song-and-dance film celebrating the virtues of Communism. http//www.morningsun.org/east/eir. html Morning Sun also features slides of government forms documenting the resettlement of people and the confiscation of goods. http//www.morningsun.org/ living/personnelFiles/index.html Chineseposters.net, a Web site maintained by Dr. Stefan R. Landsberger, a sinologist trained at Leiden University in the Netherlands, showcases one of the largest private collections of Chinese propaganda posters in the world. Spanning the period from 1925 to 2006, the collection is arranged by date and theme. http// chineseposters.net/gallery/ The Mao Tse Tung Internet Archive houses a collection of quotations from Chairman Mao arranged in thirty-three categories, including “Youth,” “Women,” “Culture and Art,” “Correcting Mistaken Ideas,” and “Self-Reliance and Arduous Struggle.” http// www.marxists.org/reference/archive/mao/works/ red-book/
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
143
The Boat to Redemption For Further Reading
Gao Yuan. Born Red: A Chronicle of the Cultural Revolution. Stanford: Stanford UP, 1987. Print. Gao’s memoir covers the period from 1966 to 1969, when he was in middle school and joined the Red Guards. As a student Gao zealously backed the Cultural Revolution in China, despite the fact that his father was a target of the Communist Party. Jin, Ha. A Free Life. New York: Vintage, 2009. Print. This story of a Chinese couple who immigrate to the United States after the Tiananmen Square Massacre in 1989 contrasts the immigrant experience with the upheavals of revolution. Like The Boat to Redemption, Ha Jin’s novel traces the dissolution of a single-child family.
the 1930s in rural China, this novel focuses on how large-scale historical events, like the Second SinoJapanese War (1937-1945), disrupt family life and create intolerable conditions in communities. Like Su Tong and Raise the Red Lantern, Mo Yan became famous in the United States when a film adaptation of Red Sorghum was nominated for an Academy Award in 1988. Su Tong. Raise the Red Lantern: Three Novellas. Trans. Michael S. Duke. New York: Harper Perennial, 2004. Print. Initially published as Wives and Concubines, this collection of novellas secured Su’s reputation when a film adaptation of Raise the Red Lantern was nominated for the 1992 Academy Award for Best Foreign-Language Film. Like Ku Wenxuan, the heroine of the title story suffers chronic humiliation and takes refuge in increasingly bizarre behavior.
Li, Yiyun. The Vagrants. New York: Random House, 2010. Print. Set in rural China during the Cultural Revolution, this novel centers on the execution of a former Red Guard member accused by the Communist Party of being a counterrevolutionary. Like Su Tong, Li focuses on how the politics of the era affects romantic and familial relationships.
Wolff, Tobias. This Boy’s Life. New York: Grove Press, 2000. Print. This memoir chronicles the writer’s coming-of-age in the aftermath of his parents’ divorce. Wolff lives with his mother, but like Dongliang, spends much time reflecting on the unfair choices the divorce forces him to make.
Mo Yan. Red Sorghum: A Novel of China. Trans. Howard Goldblatt. New York: Penguin, 1994. Print. Set in
Joseph Campana
144
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Bold as Love By Gwyneth Jones
W Introduction Winner of the 2002 Arthur C. Clarke Award, the United Kingdom’s premiere prize for novels in the science fiction category, Bold as Love is the first book in Gwyneth Jones’s pentology about a group of rock musicians at the helm of a near-future England on the brink of imminent collapse. As this first installment opens, the British royal family has quit and what is left of Parliament has declared Dissolution Year, breaking its ties with the other countries in the United Kingdom just as the European Commonwealth is itself fragmenting wholesale. England’s Home Secretary decides to bolster public morale by establishing a Counter Cultural Think Tank, a sort of shadow government composed primarily of rock stars. But an Ozzie Osbourne-type figure, Pigsty Liver, envisions a different scenario, staging a violent coup d’état at a Cabinet meeting that claims the lives of the Home Secretary and many of the rockers assigned to the Think Tank. The story pits Pigsty in a battle for control of England with surviving rockers Ax Preston, Sage Pender, and Fiorinda Slater, friends modeled on the legendary figures of King Arthur, Lancelot, and Guinevere. The updated Arthurian triumvirate prevails, now confronted with the seemingly insurmountable task of transitioning England out of its turmoil. Bold as Love has been praised for its vivid characterizations of its three main protagonists as well as for its thoughtful meditations on current social, political, and environmental issues extrapolated to some of their more unfortunate consequences. In an interview with LOCUSonline (“Gwyneth Jones: Magical Science”), Jones offered a synopsis of the series: “People argue over whether the ‘Bold as Love’ books are fantasy or science fiction. I call them fantasy, because the story is a romance. It’s set in the future, but it’s about a good prince, a fairy princess, and a perfect Champion (rock stars being the knights and princesses of
our culture). On the other hand it’s set in the future, in a time of profound change. It’s about a global social and scientific revolution, and it involves plenty of high-tech extrapolation from the possibilities of the present day. So maybe it’s fantasy and science fiction.”
W Literary and Historical Context
Bold as Love takes its name from the title of a 1967 Jimmie Hendrix album, Axis; Bold as Love. Indeed, the novel as a whole owes much to the countercultural movement of the 1960s and early 1970s and the notion that rock musicians had political sensibilities worth taking seriously. As Francis Spufford explains, “The salient oddity of Bold as Love is that its achievement is rooted not in the festival scene of 2001, but in the world of 1971. It substantiates the dreams not of present-day apocalypse-minded teenagers, but of their counterparts 30 years ago, who read Michael Moorcock’s Jerry Cornelius novels and relished the fantasy of the Rolling Stones playing gigs in the rubble of liberated cities.” But, as Jones’s comments in an interview with Andrew M. Butler indicate, the novel is even more broadly indebted to history, both personal and political: “You can think of the ‘Bold as Love’ sequence as being based on my life and times: including the formative influence of my parents’ struggle against Fascism in the thirties, the Gravity’s Rainbow story of the Second World War and the rocket science that came out of that, the austerity of the fifties, the psychedelic sixties, Vietnam, Civil Rights, molecular biology, neuroscience, environmental disaster, the lot. It’s all in there, all the fashions and customs and history that I’ve been exposed to, all mixed up together.” Bold as Love is also much indebted to the mythology surrounding King Arthur. The relationships among Ax, Sage, and Fiorinda is drawn on the famous love triangle
145 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Bold as Love
MAJOR CHARACTERS PIGSTY LIVER is a drug-addled and destructive rocker who is thwarted is his attempt to overthrow the government of the Counter Culturals. SAGE PENDER, as the Lancelot figure, is Ax Preston’s right-hand man. He is the visionary behind the band AOXOMOXOA and THE HEADS and a techno-wizard capable of transforming his face with holographic images of skulls. AX PRESTON is the King Arthur figure in the novel, the rocker who directs England’s restoration. He is the lead guitarist of the band THE CHOSEN FEW, armed with heroic ideals and a database implant. FIORINDA SLATER is the Guinevere figure in the triumvirate of friends who attempt to rebuild England. She is a daughter of rock-and-roll royalty, singer for the band DARK, and possibly possessed of magical powers.
of Arthur, Lancelot, and Guinevere. Accordingly, there is the familiar three-way political and sexual intrigue. But Jones rewrites the myth with a twist so that, instead of Fiorinda disrupting the bond between the two men—Ax,
the King Arthur figure, and his trusted ally, Sage, as Lancelot—all three remain partners and friends. The camaraderie of King Arthur’s Round Table remains intact, and there is the suggestion that a peaceful England-cum-Camelot will be restored out of the maelstrom.
W Themes Jones is herself a product of the counterculturalism movement of the 1960s. Thus, the major themes in the novel grow out of her well-developed social consciousness. Bold as Love is antiestablishment in the sense that it foresees a world transformed by the rock anthems of the 1960s, using countercultural poetics as a curative to social, political, and environmental crises. The world inherited by Ax, Sage, and Fiorinda is bleak and chaotic: England has no allies and no central government; a virus has nearly obliterated the Internet; electricity reserves are shrinking; uncontained diseases are at epidemic levels; a conflict with Islamic separatists in Yorkshire verges on an ethnic bloodbath; and pollution and global warming are serious threats as well. The three friends discover their hidden talents as they attempt to restore England’s infrastructure and economy and crusade on behalf of Green causes. Ax, Sage, and Fiorinda shift their attention
Photo of Gwyneth Jones, author of the novel Bold a Love. ª Jeff Morgan 03/Alamy
146
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Bold as Love
from one calamity to another and devote their sparse free time to giving free public concerts aimed at national solidarity. The novel deconstructs contemporary power struggles in England using what Jones calls the “Matter of Britain” to explore what truly is the matter with Britain (qtd. in Forshaw). But Jones has also insisted that the novel is not so much nationalistic as it is suspicious of entrenched power structures in general and political apparatuses that have long since outlived their usefulness.
W Style The style of Bold as Love is informed by a musical consciousness. In fact, the website for the series includes a list of the fictional band members who comprise Jones’s cast of characters as well as a musical playlist for each chapter with songs that express its thematic concerns. References to actual song titles, lyrics, and rock performers abound in Bold as Love. Combined with Jones’s staging of concerts as the sites of political maneuvering, these allusions add to the novel’s spirit of youthful energy. Analogous to some of the rock lyrics Jones references, Spufford described Jones’s prose as “elegant in a disheveled way.”
W Critical Reception Results of a 1993 survey conducted by the journal Science-Fiction Studies counted Jones among the most unjustly neglected writers of the genre (Weinbaum). Writing for a Femspec symposium in 2004, Batya Weinbaum recorded no change in Jones’s critical stature despite her winning of the Arthur C. Clarke Award. Weinbaum called for a critical reassessment, noting, “Every sf academic I know admires and respects Jones’s work. The complex imbrications of hard scientific and ethical speculations, the fiercely insightful feminist, leftist, and green politics, and the intense critiques of gender, ethnicity, and colonialism we find in her fiction cry out for the kind of attention that Ursula Le Guin, Joanna Russ, and Marge Piercy have received.” Bold as Love attracted largely positive, if slight, critical notice. Reviewers were impressed by Jones’s inventive use of rock-and-roll and Arthurian motifs applied to a future political landscape. They were unanimous in their admiration for Jones’s well-drawn characterizations of Ax, Sage, and Fiorinda and the loyal relationship that develops among them. Though the novel is bleakly pessimistic in some of its future prognostications, critics found it to be ultimately infused with a sense of hope due to the idealism of the rock musicians. Suzanne Keen, for one, commented, “Normally, serious literary fiction flirts with sci-fi only in the form of dystopia, but Bold as Love puts the question positively: What would it take to build a
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Alongside more than twenty fantasy novels for young adults, Gwyneth Jones has produced a considerable body of science fiction for adult readers, including a trilogy published in the 1990s about an Aleutian invasion of the earth and a pentology published the following decade about a trio of 1960s-inspired rock stars who assume control of a near-future England just as it threatens to deconstruct into Dark Ages chaos. Many times short-listed for the Arthur C. Clarke Award, Britain’s most prestigious prize for writers of science fiction, Jones finally won in 2002 for Bold as Love, the first volume in her series of stories dedicated to the countercultural idealism of the 1960s.
Utopia, and who would you put in the seats of that Round Table?” Asked about the novel’s optimism by Sandy Auden for the SF Site, Jones responded, “I didn’t make that decision, the music did. That’s what music does, if it works, whether it’s Chopin or Blink 182. It excites, raises your spirits, arouses, gets people going.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Auden, Sandy, and Gwyneth Jones. “Winning with a Bold Streak: An Interview with Gwyneth Jones.” SF Site. Web. 27 July 2010. Butler, Andrew M., and Gwyneth Jones. “Going Uphill: An Interview with Gwyneth Jones.” Femspec 31 Dec. 2004. HighBeam Research, Gale. Web. 26 July 2010. Forshaw, Barry. “Books: Biography of Gwyneth Jones: The Music of the Future.” Independent [London] 12 Dec. 2003. NewsBank, Access World News. Web. 26 July 2010. “Gwyneth Jones: Magical Science.” LOCUSonline Jan. 2004. Web. 24 July 2010. Keen, Suzanne. “Christmas Critics, Novel, Book Reviews.” Commonweal 5 Dec. 2008. HighBeam Research, Gale. Web. 26 July 2010. Spufford, Francis. “Visons of Albion: Francis Spufford Celebrates a Rock ‘n’ Roll Pastoral.” Guardian [London] 25 Aug. 2001: 8. Print. Weinbaum, Batya. “Jones: An Introduction.” Femspec 31 Dec. 2004. HighBeam Research, Gale. Web. 26 July 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Bartholomew, Kathleen. Rev. of Bold as Love, by Gwyneth Jones. Green Man Review. Web. 24 July 2010.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
147
Bold as Love
Issues high praise for the “larger than life” trio of Ax, Fiorinda, and Sage and the novel’s well detailed, if less mythic, minor characters. However, Bartholomew notes that the English specificity of the novel may prove an obstacle to American readers. “Bold as Love: Publisher and Industry Reviews.” Waterstones.com. Web. 25 July 2010. Reprints a Kirkus review that calls Bold as Love “a gripping evocation of what happens when the ideals and protests of popular music are played out for real with guns rather than guitars.” Rev. of Bold as Love, by Gwyneth Jones. Publishers Weekly 252.36 (12 Sept. 2005): 48(1). Student Resource Center - College Edition Expanded. Web. 23 July 2010. Describes the premise of Bold as Love. Butler, Chris. Rev. of Bold as Love, by Gwyneth Jones. infinityplus: sf, fantasy, horror. Web. 24 July 2010. Finds little in the way of escapism in the novel, wishing for more of the scenes in which Ax, Sage, and Fiorinda find a few moments of relaxation away from all of England’s troubles. Schroeder, Regina. Rev. of Bold as Love, by Gwyneth Jones. Booklist 102.3 (1 Oct. 2005): 43(1). Student Resource Center-College Edition Expanded. Detroit: Gale. Web. 23 July 2010. Calls Bold as Love a “satisfying blend” of rock-and-roll idealism and Arthurian legend. Skoya, David. Rev. of Bold as Love, by Gwyneth Jones. the SF Site. 2001. Web. 24 July 2010. Considers the novel’s premise hard to believe but nonetheless judges Bold as Love a worthwhile read because of its finely drawn characters. Gale Resources
“Gwyneth A(nn) Jones (1952-).” Something about the Author. Vol. 159. Detroit: Gale, 2005. 113-16. Something about the Author Online. Web. 28 July 2010.
250-52. Gale Virtual Reference Library. Web. 23 July 2010. Open Web Sources
Suzanne Keen described the website for the “Bold as Love” series of novels, http//www.boldaslove.co. uk/The%20Bands%20Framed.html, as “a multime dia work of art in its own right.” The site prioritizes a cast list identifying the members of the rock bands fictionalized in the novels and provides a playlist representative of thematic concerns for each of the chapters in each of the novels in the series. Jones’s own homepage, http//homepage.ntlworld. com/gwynethann/, provides biography and personal anecdotes and access to the author’s blog and the “Bold as Love” webpage. For Further Reading
Jones, Gwyneth. Band of Gypsies. London: Victor Gollancz, 2005. Print. The fourth novel in the “Bold as Love” sequence. ———. Castles Made of Sand. London: Victor Gollancz, 2002. Print. The second novel in the “Bold as Love” sequence. ———. Midnight Lamp. London: Victor Gollancz, 2003. Print. The third novel in the “Bold as Love” pentology. ———. Rainbow Bridge. London: Victor Gollancz, 2006. Print. The final novel in the “Bold as Love” series. Malory, Sir Thomas. Le morte d’Arthur: King Arthur and the Legends of the Round Table. New York: Signet, 2001. Print. A concise rendering of Malory’s famous chronicles of the legendary King Arthur and the knights of his Round Table, written in the fifteenth century. Janet Mullane
“Jones, Gwyneth A(nn) 1952-.” Contemporary Authors, New Revision Series. Vol. 123. Detroit: Gale, 2004.
148
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Bonesetter’s Daughter By Amy Tan
W Introduction The Bonesetter’s Daughter addresses Amy Tan’s concerns with memory, writing, and the tension between mothers and daughters. Written in three parts, the novel tells the stories of multiple generations of women in one Chinese American family, beginning with Ruth, a middle-aged American-born editor and ghostwriter living with her boyfriend and his children in San Francisco. Ruth is experiencing an identity crisis in her relationships with her boyfriend and her mother, LuLing, a Chinese immigrant who has always been a figure of unwelcome dominance in her daughter’s life. But when Ruth begins to see signs of dementia in LuLing, she realizes that she risks losing her only link to her family’s history. The second part of the book is a first-person telling of LuLing’s story, which she wrote down in Chinese calligraphy when she began losing her memory. Ruth has her mother’s memoirs translated and, as she reads the astonishing story, she discovers shocking revelations about her family history. In the book’s third part, Ruth decides what to do with the information she has, leading her to make major life changes and finally find her own voice. Reviewers were largely impressed with Tan’s handling of her multiple storylines and numerous characters, although many asserted that Tan concluded the story too abruptly.
W Literary and Historical Context
In the novel, LuLing is born in a village called Immortal Heart near Peking (Beijing) in 1915, and her story in the second part of The Bonesetter’s Daughter ends at the dawn of World War II, when she immigrates to the United States. In the twenty-odd years of LuLing’s life that are recounted, China underwent some of the most profound social and political changes in its history. The Revolution
of 1911 resulted in the 1912 founding of the Republic of China, moving the country away from the imperial rulers who had controlled it for thousands of years. A constitution was passed in 1913, and the provisional senate and president began instituting reforms intended to create a balance of powers. The effort to move the country toward democracy was short-lived, however, as the permanent president, Yuan Shih-kai, attempted to reinstitute imperialism and declared himself emperor. Additionally, the country was still largely controlled by regional warlords and a feudal system. Even after it agreed to play a role in World War I on the Allied side— under the condition that all German-held regions of China be returned to Chinese control—the country continued to be subjected to foreign imperialism, which the Chinese deeply resented. The awarding of the formerly German-held Shandong Province not to China but instead to Japan was a particularly sore point, and a wave of Chinese nationalism was sparked. On May 4, 1919, thousands of students organized a massive protest and strike, issuing a list of demands. Businesspeople and workers around the country also went on strike to show their solidarity with the May 4 Movement. It was out of this movement that Chinese Communism emerged. In 1921 the Communist Party of China (CPC) was founded. The Kuomintang (Chinese Nationalist Party) had been established as China’s first political party in 1912, and the two originally worked together to remove the warlords from power in the provinces. A violent split occurred between the parties, however, and during the 1927 Shanghai Massacre, Kuomintang leaders purged their party of Communists in a series of arrests and executions. The Kuomintang then formed the central government of China for the next ten years. Nonetheless, the representatives of the CPC set up encampments in rural provinces, establishing these as the Soviet Republic of China. One of the leaders of this movement was Mao Zedong, the future leader of the People’s Republic of China. In the meantime, China was engaged in
149 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Bonesetter’s Daughter
MAJOR CHARACTERS LULING YOUNG is Ruth Young’s elderly mother. Born in a village in China, LuLing has never fully adjusted to life in the United States. As she feels her memory beginning to fail, she writes her memoirs so that her middle-aged daughter might read them and finally understand her and the family’s past. RUTH YOUNG is a Chinese American editor in San Francisco who ghostwrites self-help books and has a contentious relationship with her elderly mother, LuLing. PRECIOUS AUNTIE is LuLing’s mute, disfigured nursemaid in China. Her story is equal in importance to LuLing’s, for at the end of LuLing’s story, Precious Auntie is revealed to be the girl’s real mother.
intermittent battles with Japan over the latter’s attempts to colonize China. In 1937 the Second Sino-Japanese War broke out, with Germany, the Soviet Union, and the United States all providing support to China. Allegiances shifted when the Japanese bombed Pearl Harbor in 1941, drawing the United States into World War II, and broadening the conflict between China and Japan into the second front, known as the Pacific War. It was at this time that many Chinese fled the country, settling in the United States, like LuLing in The Bonesetter’s Daughter.
ª Marc Brasz/Corbis
W Themes As in much of Tan’s work, intergenerational conflict, especially between mothers and daughters, is a hallmark theme of The Bonesetter’s Daughter. Additionally, the novel confronts the lack of understanding between Chinese-born elders and their American-born offspring, as well as the secrets and misunderstandings both between generations of women and within the self. In Ruth’s case, for example, an annual case of mutism every August brings up questions of self-censorship and the problem of finding one’s voice. Similarly, in the second part of the book, LuLing’s nursemaid, known to the child as Precious Auntie, is disfigured and missing her tongue and communicates only with LuLing, through a secret sign language. Written language holds equal symbolic significance in The Bonesetter’s Daughter. Ruth’s career as a ghostwriter—a writer who pens works that are attributed to others—again leads to questions about her own “voice.” That she cannot read LuLing’s calligraphy, but must have her mother’s story translated so that she can understand it, also speaks to the fundamental lack of understanding between mother and daughter. Likewise, LuLing reveals in her own story that Precious Auntie was
150
Amy Tan, author of The Bonesetter’s Daughter, at a book signing.
the daughter of the “bonesetter” of the book’s title—and both she and her father had an uncanny ability to “read” meaning into the mysterious dragon bones found in the caves near their home. Later, when Ruth is a child, LuLing believes her own daughter is able to communicate with the dead by writing messages in the sand tray used to practice Chinese calligraphy. In this sense, Ruth is quite literally a ghostwriter. And the ghosts from LuLing’s past—as they exist in her memory and as they existed in reality—are essential to Tan’s narrative, for Tan demonstrates that personal and family history can affect families for generations. Writing for the New York Times, Nancy Willard explained, “For Tan, the true keeper of memory is language, and so the novel is layered with stories that have been written down—by mothers for their daughters, passing along secrets that cannot be said out loud but must not be forgotten.”
W Style The Bonesetter’s Daughter is told in three separate narrative parts. The first is Ruth’s story in contemporary TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Bonesetter’s Daughter
San Francisco, up to her discovery and the translation of her mother’s memoirs. The second part is told in the firstperson by LuLing, and it recalls her childhood and young adulthood in China. The third part returns to Ruth’s life in San Francisco and the decisions she makes based upon what she learns from LuLing’s story. Tan’s work has garnered praise for her unique writing style, which interweaves narratives from different generations and geographical elements into one cohesive story. Her poetic use of language and the complexity of her narrative as the story moves from Ruth’s childhood to LuLing’s life in China has been lauded for its poetic and evocative quality.
W Critical Reception The Bonesetter’s Daughter was well-received by critics and readers, who noted almost unanimously Tan’s ability to weave a complex mystery with great skill. According to Maria Russo, who reviewed the book for Salon.com, “The Bonesetter’s Daughter comes into its own in the flashbacks to Ruth’s childhood, which give an adept and pungent account of the mortifications of a certain type of immigrant childhood: on the one hand overly sheltered and on the other completely without guidance in the navigation of everything from sex to school bureaucracies. And when Tan writes in LuLing’s voice, the effect is nothing short of haunting.” In fact, most critics found Tan’s writing in Ruth’s voice to be strained and only mildly interesting, noting that her storytelling skills do not really come to the fore in The Bonesetter’s Daughter until she leaves Ruth’s voice and begins writing in LuLing’s. Many critics found the book’s third section to be overly simplistic. Helene Lorber, reviewing the novel for the Knight-Ridder/Tribune News Service, wrote: “The book falters at the end, when it switches back to modern-day San Francisco. Having read the family history, Ruth still must deal with LuLing’s illness. She and her partner hatch a scheme to get LuLing into a utopian assisted-living facility that’s more appropriate for a second-rate sitcom than a thoughtful book. There’s even a surprise Schwab account to pay for it all. But the world of memory needs no such gimmicks.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Lorber, Helene. Rev. of The Bonesetter’s Daughter, by Amy Tan. Knight-Ridder/Tribune News Service. Tribune Company. 2001. HighBeam Research. Web. 30 Sept. 2010. Russo, Maria. “The Bonesetter’s Daughter, by Amy Tan.” Salon.com 21 Feb. 2001. Web. 29 Sept. 2010. Willard, Nancy. “Talking to Ghosts.” New York Times 18 Feb. 2001. NYTimes.com. Web. 30 Sept. 2010.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Amy Tan was born in Oakland, California, in 1952, an American-born daughter of Chinese immigrants. She received bachelor and master’s degrees from San Jose State University. Known for her lyrical prose, many of Tan’s stories focus on the emotional and cultural conflicts between Chinese American mothers and daughters, sisters, or friends who struggle to understand each other across a generational and cultural divide. Tan’s first novel, The Joy Luck Club, was an international best seller and was adapted into a popular film in 1993. Subsequent works by Tan include The Kitchen God’s Wife, The Hundred Secret Senses, and a children’s book titled The Moon Lady. Tan’s work has been universally critically acclaimed, and she has won numerous awards for her fiction. She resides in Sausalito, California, with her husband.
Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Hull, Akasha. “Uncommon Language.” Women’s Review of Books 18.9 (June 2001): 13. Literature Resource Center. Web. 30 Sept. 2010. Brief summary of The Bonesetter’s Daughter, theorizing that this work is “essentially about writing and the act of writing.” Lui, Cynthia W. “Tracing the Life of the Bonesetter’s Daughter.” International Examiner 2 Oct. 2001. Highbeam Research. 30 Sept. 2010. Reviews The Bonesetter’s Daughter from a Chinese American perspective, discussing especially Tan’s focus in all her novels on mothers and daughters. Moxley, Melody A. Rev. of The Bonesetter’s Daughter, by Amy Tan. Kliatt 37.3 (May 2003): 22. Literature Resource Center. Web. 29 Sept. 2010. Brief, positive review of The Bonesetter’s Daughter. Gale Resources
“Amy (Ruth) Tan.” Contemporary Popular Writers. Ed. Dave Mote. Detroit: St. James Press, 1997. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 29 Sept. 2010. “Amy Tan.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2006. Literature Resource Center. Web. 29 Sept. 2010. Champion, Laurie. “Amy (Ruth) Tan.” Asian American Writers. Ed. Deborah L. Madsen. Detroit: Gale, 2005. Print. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 312. Dunick, Lisa M. S. “The Silencing Effect of Canonicity: Authorship and the Written Word in Amy Tan’s Novels.” MELUS 31, no. 2 (2006): 3-20. Rpt. in Contemporary Literary Criticism. Vol. 257. Detroit: Gale, 2008.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
151
The Bonesetter’s Daughter For Further Reading
Jones, Vanessa E. “Secrets and Lives in Writing Her New Book, The Bonesetter’s Daughter, Amy Tan Reconciles Loss, Memories, and Family Ghosts.” Boston Globe 1 Mar. 2001. Print. Interview in which Tan recounts the revelations she and her siblings had after their mother’s death and the ways in which this affected her writing of The Bonesetter’s Daughter. Kingston, Maxine Hong. The Woman Warrior: Memoirs of a Girlhood among Ghosts. New York: Vintage Books, 1989. Print. This book comprises a series of autobiographical vignettes, and is often described by critics as a powerful memoir by Kingston of her experiences growing up as a first-generation Chinese American woman who struggles to find her identity.
152
Tan, Amy. The Joy Luck Club. New York: G. P. Putnam, 1989. Print. Tan’s first and best-selling novel, focusing on four Chinese American immigrant families living in California, the book is framed within the narrative of the mahjong game that allows three mothers and four daughters to share stories about their lives. ———. The Kitchen God’s Wife. New York: Penguin, 2006. Print. This is Tan’s second novel, and one where she once again focuses on a mother-daughter relationship. The novel tells the story of Winnie’s past in war-torn China during the 1940s, as she works to establish a relationship with her daughter, Pearl. Nancy Dziedzic
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Book of Chameleons By José Eduardo Agualusa
W Introduction Set in post–civil war Angola, José Eduardo Agualusa’s novel The Book of Chameleons (2004) is the story of Félix Ventura, a self-conscious albino who invents distinguished family histories for the nouveaux riche of Angola seeking to secure their positions in the turbulent nation. One of his clients, an unnamed former war photojournalist whom Ventura dubs José Buchmann, embarks on a quest to meet the mother Ventura has created for him. Buchmann’s journey leads him to face a crisis from his real past that threatens Ventura’s love affair with a photographer named Angela Lucia. The Book of Chameleons won the Independent Foreign Fiction Prize in 2007. Agualusa has been praised for his ability to use the technique of magic realism, a style of writing used by Latin American writers that blends fantastical elements with realistic portrayals of everyday events. The Book of Chameleons is narrated by a gecko named Eulálio, who in the novel is a reincarnation of Jorge Luis Borges, the Argentine writer believed to be among the chief contributors to the development of magic realism.
W Literary and Historical Context
The Book of Chameleons is set sometime between 1992 and 1994, during a lull in what up to that point had been a seventeen-year civil war in Angola. This civil war had, in turn, followed a fourteen-year war for independence from Portugal. The Portuguese landed in Angola in 1575 and ruled the territory as a colony from 1655 to 1951, when the area was declared an overseas province. Begun in 1961 as an uprising against forced cotton harvesting, the Angolan War for Independence was not concluded until 1975, shortly after a leftist coup in Lisbon overthrew the
authoritarian regime in Portugal. Upon gaining independence the three leading factions in Angola—the Communist People’s Movement for the Liberation of Angola (MPLA), the anti-Communist National Union for the Total Independence of Angola, and an association of separatist movements called FLEC—waged a twentyseven-year war for control of the new republic. The war finally ended in 2002. Much of the fighting was funded by the United States and the Soviet Union, both of which saw Angola as a crucial ally in the Cold War. According to most estimates more than 500,000 people died in the conflict. The early 1990s was a period of political and economic optimism in Angola. The ruling Communist Party made concessions to rival factions, bringing a lull in the fighting, and a series of discoveries of new petroleum reserves turned Angola into one of the richest countries in Africa. Fortunes were made overnight. However, the newly wealthy had to fight for social acceptance from the landed Portuguese-speaking aristocracy. To obtain prestige and often to protect themselves, these people sought the services of men like Ventura, who invented aristocratic bloodlines for their clients. Agualusa re-creates the tensions in Angola of the early 1990s by using a technique called magic realism, which was developed by the Latin American writers he grew up reading, namely Jorge Amado, Gabriel García Márquez, and Borges. In this method of writing, elements of magic are woven into a realistic universe in order to give readers a deeper understanding of that universe. The narrator in The Book of Chameleons, a reincarnation of Borges as a highly articulate gecko, is the most conspicuous of the magical elements in the book.
W Themes Identity construction is the central theme of The Book of Chameleons. Agualusa considers the essential characteristics of a person and explores whether it is possible for
153 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Book of Chameleons
MAJOR CHARACTERS EULÁLIO is the gecko that narrates the story. The events of its life, which are revealed in a series of dreams interspersed throughout the book, are based on the life of Argentine writer Jorge Luis Borges. EDMUNDO BARATA DOS REIS is a vagabond who strikes Buchmann as an interesting subject for a photo essay. As the former journalist tries to capture him on film, his curiosity grows, until one day he visits Barata’s underground home when he thinks the vagabond will be away. When Barata returns earlier than anticipated, he catches Buchmann rummaging through his belongings, and the two men recognize each other from earlier days of the civil war. JOSÉ BUCHMANN is the appellation Ventura gives to a nameless photojournalist who seeks his services. Enamored of the family history Ventura has created for him, Buchmann embarks on a labyrinthine search for his fictional ancestors. However, as he delves into his fictional past, he comes into contact with Edmundo Barata dos Reis, a man from his past. ANGELA LUCIA is a dreamy, somewhat intellectual photographer. She travels the world trying to take pictures that match her ideals for form and color. Ventura falls in love with her because she does not react self-consciously, as most others do, to his skin color. EVA MILLER is Buchmann’s fictional mother, who in Ventura’s yarn disappears under mysterious circumstances. Buchmann embarks on a search for her that takes him halfway around the globe and ultimately returns him to his real past. FÉLIX VENTURA is an albino who creates respectable histories—complete with documents and family portraits—for the nouveaux riche of Angola who require such legacies to secure their prestige and protect their wealth.
people to reinvent themselves by changing one aspect of their identity. In the novel the first marker of each character’s identity is his or her past. The unnamed war journalist in the story, who never discloses why he requires Ventura’s services, attempts to change his present self by purchasing a new past from Ventura, thus becoming José Buchmann. Once given a new name and a new lineage, Buchmann feels free of old burdens and tries to embody his new identity by traveling to the memorials of the forebears Ventura has created for him. While this idea may seem fantastic, Agualusa notes in an interview appended to the novel that in a war-torn country like Angola, many people need new pasts in order to make
154
their futures more secure. In Buchmann’s case, as with many real Angolans protecting their new petroleum fortunes, enemies are looking for him, and he is ashamed of something he has done in his past. A new name with documents and pictures of relatives will help throw adversaries off his trail and perhaps allow him to forget what nags his conscience. In The Book of Chameleons Agualusa examines the extent to which the journalist’s new past makes him a new person. He concludes that ultimately a person cannot transform himself or herself in the way Buchmann has tried. In the novel’s climactic scene, a man from Buchmann’s past, and the source of his shame, appears and threatens to disrupt not only Buchmann’s peace of mind but also Ventura and Lucia’s thriving relationship. On the other hand, Agualusa proposes that people can reinvent themselves by falling in love. By showing a character such as Buchmann flourish, even briefly, under a new, distinguished name, Agualusa suggests that part of a person’s identity is often based in how others regard him or her, or how the person senses he or she is regarded by others. At the beginning of the novel, Ventura is convinced that his albino skin makes him unlovable. He brings home prostitutes who eye him with disgust before going to bed with him. For company he enlists the friendship of a pet gecko, to which he speaks after listening to Brazilian love songs. One night he says to the gecko, “You’ve really got terrible skin, you know that? We must be related.” However, when the photographer Angela Lucia shows interest in Ventura, his selfconsciousness gradually evaporates, and he is reborn in their romantic relationship—less eccentric, more affable, and undeniably happy.
W Style Composed in thirty-two short chapters, The Book of Chameleons reads like a set of independently presented vignettes held together by two thinly sketched plotlines— Buchmann’s search for his invented mother and Ventura’s romance with Angela Lucia—as well as by the gecko’s ruminations on love and dreams. Each of chapters has its own title page, with no print on the reverse side, suggesting that what follows is not so much part of a unified novel but an entity unto itself—perhaps a short story or a poem in a collection. At the same time, however, there is a discernible pattern to the book’s arrangement. Six times in the novel, at semiregular intervals, the gecko recounts a dream. Titled “Dream No. 1,” “Dream No. 2,” and so forth, these highly impressionistic pieces comment on the book’s plotlines and themes. For example, in the first dream the gecko walks through a crowd, trying to shake people’s hands, but is ignored—a reverie that speaks to Ventura’s isolation. In “Dream No. 2,” the chapter that precedes Lucia’s arrival in the story, the gecko hears a man’s voice from TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Book of Chameleons
underground while at the same time a dog appears with a radio around its neck. The man’s voice and the sounds from the radio intermingle, and the gecko recalls the final image from the dream in this confused way: “‘The worst of sins is not to fall in love,’ said God, with the soft voice of a tango-singer: ‘This broadcast has been sponsored by the Marimba Union Bakeries.’” Books that contain such formal eccentricities have been labeled metafiction, which is a form of storytelling that does two things at once: it exists as any regular narrative does, with characters, a plot, complications, and a resolution; and it questions what a story is and if a story can ever be something else. For example, at the very end of the climactic scene in The Book of Chameleons, Agualusa breaks out of traditional narrative form and finishes the scene in a twelve-line visual poem. In addition to resolving the plot, the style of writing used at this point questions the nature of the book of itself. After 180 pages of prose with paragraphs and chapter breaks Agualusa appears to be writing a novel, but twelve lines of verse near the end may suggest that he classifies the work as a poem as well.
W Critical Reception Reviews of The Book of Chameleons have focused primarily on Agualusa’s surprising narrator and on the competence with which the author, in such a slender volume, manages an intricate plot while experimenting with several postmodern tropes. Most of the notices have been positive. Regarding Agualusa’s narrator, perhaps the most positive of the reviews comes from Amanda Hopkinson. Writing in the Independent, she claims, “Not since Gregor Samsa’s metamorphosis have we had such a convincing non-human narrator.” Although considerably less effusive, Nicholas Lezard’s review in the Guardian agrees that the book’s narrator is a first-rate storyteller: “To tell the truth, I am not confidently sure why the narrator is a lizard. If there is a symbolic point, it eludes me. But that is actually a strength of the novel, its not being shackled to an interpretation. From a storytelling perspective, it’s very useful: Ventura treats him as a pet, and confides in him; and, being able to climb over any surface, even inverted ones, the gecko can observe anything he wishes. In short, an ideal narrator.” Publishers Weekly calls Eulálio “a lovable narrator, alternately sardonic and wistful.” A review of the novel in African Business, although positive, refuses to overlook the oddness of the choice: “The Book of Chameleons is populated with stories whose characters never quite settle. It is some pages in before you realize that the narrator—rather charming, witty as he is—is a lizard. A very articulate and very friendly lizard, and—like all Agualusa’s narrators—unusually perceptive. But a lizard nonetheless.” Critiques of the book’s plot and the philosophical ground it attempts to cover have been somewhat more
ABOUT THE AUTHOR José Eduardo Agualusa was born Alves da Cunha on December 13, 1960, in Huambo, Angola. He grew up reading Latin American writers Gabriel García Márquez, Mario Vargas Llosa, Jorge Luis Borges, and Jorge Amado, whose fictional universes reminded Agualusa of the Angola where he came of age. After graduating from college, where he studied agronomy and forestry, Agualusa split his time between Angola, Brazil, and Portugal. He began working as a journalist for the Portuguese magazine LER and the Angolan newspaper A Capital, as well as writing novels, poetry, and plays. Several of his books have had their beginnings in his newspaper columns, which the writer regards as notebooks to record stories, characters, and phrases that might one day grow into larger works. A Stranger in Goa (2000), for example, began as a newspaper piece about unusual names that seem to represent their owner’s destiny. His 1997 novel Creole, about a Portuguese adventurer who falls in love with a slave woman, won the Portuguese Grand Prize for Literature and was a bestseller in seven countries. In 2007 The Book of Chameleons was awarded the Independent Foreign Fiction Prize, making Agualusa the first African-born writer to receive the honor. His work has been translated into twenty languages.
varied. Among those who praise Agualusa is James Crossley, who, in the Review of Contemporary Fiction, observes, “In description, the novel may come across as a bizarre and confusing mix of the horrific, comical, political, sexual and intertextual, but in the reading, all these elements blend naturally, with subtle and supple results.” Likewise, the New Internationalist finds that Agualusa handles complex material deftly: “It is entirely fitting, in a book dealing with the mutability of truth and ambiguity of identity that the plot morphs effortlessly across genre boundaries, from the dreamscapes of magical realism to a gripping political thriller and even, in the unexpected but wholly satisfying climax, a murder mystery.” Other reviewers, however, were unsatisfied with the ending and found Agualusa’s formal innovations derivative. Writing in the Times Literary Supplement, Stephen Henighan claims that “the story’s final twists feel imposed.” Village Voice reviewer Alexis Soloski compares Agualusa to the writer he has chosen to emulate and finds the former wanting: “Like Borges, Agualusa (in Daniel Hahn’s translation) writes relatively straightforward prose embellished by vivid visual details. Unlike Borges, Agualusa has a tendency toward the precious—a woman who Polaroids rainbows, a chortling lizard. Agualusa’s novel is gentler than Borges’s fictions, but less intricate and arresting.”
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
155
The Book of Chameleons BIBLIOGRAPHY
Gale Resources
Works Cited
“José Eduardo Agualusa.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Gale Biography in Context. Web. 16 Sept. 2010.
Agualusa, José Eduardo. The Book of Chameleons. Trans. Daniel Hahn. New York: Simon, 2008. Print. Rev. of The Book of Chameleons, by José Eduardo Agualusa. African Business Jan. 2007: 64. Gale Biography in Context. Web. 16 Sept. 2010. Rev. of The Book of Chameleons, by José Eduardo Agualusa. New Internationalist Magazine. 1 Dec. 2006. Web. 19 Sept. 2010. Rev. of The Book of Chameleons, by José Eduardo Agualusa. Publishers Weekly 7 Apr. 2008: 41. Gale Biography in Context. Web. 16 Sept. 2010. Crossley, James. Rev. of The Book of Chameleons, by José Eduardo Agualusa. Review of Contemporary Fiction 28.3 (2008): 186. Gale Biography in Context. Web. 16 Sept. 2010. Henighan, Stephen. Times Literary Supplement. 23 Sept. 2005: n. pag. Complete Review. Web. 16 Sept. 2010. Hopkinson, Amanda. “Truth Hangs by a Lizard Tale.” Independent. Independent Print Limited, 24 Nov. 2006. Web. 16 Sept. 2010. Lezard, Nicholas. “The View from Upside Down.” Guardian. 30 June 2007. Web. 16 Sept. 2010. Soloski, Alexis. Rev. of The Book of Chameleons, by José Eduardo Agualusa. Village Voice. 13 May 2008. Web. 16 Sept. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Guterres, Maria. “History and Fiction in José Eduardo Agualusa’s Novels.” Fiction in the PortugueseSpeaking World. Ed. Charles M. Kelley. Cardiff: U of Wales P, 2000. 117-38. Print. Explores how Agualusa deploys the trope of magic realism to blur the line between history and fiction. Mabe, Chauncey. “Literary Effects Grow Tiresome.” Rev. of The Book of Chameleons, by José Eduardo Agualusa. Sun Sentinel. 8 June 2008. Web. 18 Sept. 2010. Argues that Agualusa leans too heavily on other writers, such as Italo Calvino and Jorge Luis Borges, and that the novel lacks surprises. Whatley, Daniel. Rev. of The Book of Chameleons, by José Eduardo Agualusa. Quarterly Conversation, n.d. Web. 18 Sept. 2010. Considers the various literary influences on Agualusa’s work and cites the namedropping of writers as one of the book’s chief weaknesses. Ultimately, Whatley calls the novel a success because, though its antecedents are obvious, the book “is not precisely like any novel you’ve ever read.”
156
Open Web Sources
José Eduardo Agualusa’s Web site contains an author biography, links to descriptions of his books, and a set of photos of the author taken during his travels through Namibia and Angola. http//www.agualusa. info/ The BBC’s Africa Beyond Web site features an interview with Agualusa from 2007, shortly after The Book of Chameleons was awarded the Independent Foreign Fiction Prize. The author discusses the porous boundary between reality and fiction in Angola and the effect his dreams have had on his creative work. http//www.bbc.co.uk/africabeyond/africanarts/ 19126.shtml In an interview on the Web site Words without Borders, Agualusa speaks about the Angolan and Latin writers who have influenced his work, his role as a critic of the contemporary politics of Angola, and how an individual’s construction of his or her past directs the person’s future. http//wordswithoutborders.org/ar ticle/an-interview-with-jos-eduardo-agualusa/ For Further Reading
Agualusa, José Eduardo. Creole. Trans. Daniel Hahn. London: Arcadia, 2002. Print. Written as a series of letters by a wealthy adventurer, Creole examines the triangular slave trade between interior Portugal, Angola, and Brazil. Amado, Jorge. Dona Flora and Her Two Husbands. New York: Vintage, 2006. Print. The story of a widow who remarries and later welcomes the ghost of her dead husband back into her bed, this novel is widely regarded as Amado’s masterwork. According to Agualusa, the Brazilian writer is among the first writers in Portuguese to use Brazilians of African origin as main characters in his work. Borges, Jorge Luis. Collected Fictions. Trans. Andrew Hurley. New York: Penguin, 1999. Print. This volume contains all of Borges’s published short fiction, offering an exhaustive look at the stories from which Agualusa drew much of his inspiration for The Book of Chameleons. Hodges, Tony. Angola: The Anatomy of an Oil State. Bloomington: Indiana UP, 2003. Print. This nonfiction work examines the corrupt system of patronage in Angola that has widened the rift between the rich and the poor in a country that, Hodges claims, should be able to use its vast oil and diamond reserves to create a prosperous society. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Book of Chameleons
Maier, Karl. Angola: Promises and Lies. London: Serif, 2007. Print. American journalist Maier reshapes his dispatches to the Independent and the Washington Post into a compelling narrative of the civil war in Angola. Pepetela. Mayombe. Portsmouth: Heinemann, 1996. Print. Mayombe is a novel by Pepetela, a white Angolan who is recognized as one of the country’s most important writers. It examines the racial, emotional, and ideological tensions among the members of the MPLA, who won independence for Angola from Portugal after a waging a guerrilla war between 1961 and 1975.
Spillman, Rob, ed. Gods and Soldiers: The Penguin Anthology of Contemporary African Writing. New York: Penguin, 2009. Print. This anthology includes an excerpt from Agualusa’s Book of Chameleons as well as writings by Chinua Achebe, Ngugi wa Thiong’o, and other leading African writers. Williamson, Edwin. Borges: A Life. New York: Viking, 2004. Print. This biography examines Jorge Luis Borges through a Freudian lens and offers insight into the writer’s private life, particularly the frustrations and anxieties of his love life.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Joseph Campana
157
The Book of Dead Birds By Gayle Brandeis
W Introduction Gayle Brandeis’s The Book of Dead Birds (2003) tells the story of Ava Sing Lo, a young woman of mixed African American and Korean ethnicity, and her mother, Helen, a former prostitute from Korea who was impregnated by an African American G.I. in the early 1970s. The novel chronicles Ava’s struggle to connect with her mother and to overcome her own feelings of sexual repression. As a young child Ava accidentally killed many of her mother’s beloved pet birds. Years later, in an act of redemption, Ava travels to the Salton Sea to assist in the effort to save birds that have been exposed to agricultural poisoning. The main text is interspersed with flashbacks to Helen’s life in Korea, excerpts from Helen’s journal, and the notebooks of famed naturalist John James Audubon. Critics have admired Brandeis’s first novel for its wellresearched details and its poetic qualities. In 2002 The Book of Dead Birds won the Bellwether Prize for Fiction, an award that supports literature of social change.
W Literary and Historical Context
During the mid-1990s, the period in which the main action of The Book of Dead Birds takes place, agricultural poisoning led to the massacre of birds in the Salton Sea in California’s border region. Thousands of birds, including more than fourteen hundred endangered California brown pelicans, died of avian botulism. In the novel, as Ava joins the effort to save these birds, the horrors of the worst bird die-off in U.S. history are described in vivid detail. Korea serves as a secondary setting of the novel. Flashbacks take the reader to Korea during the 1960s, when Ava’s mother was coming of age. Poverty and the exploitation of women were widespread in Korean
society, and many young women were lured into prostitution. The young Helen hopes for a better life than the one she endures as a sea diver, and she naively leaves home to seek her fortune. Soon she and her friend, Sun, are drawn into prostitution, and Helen eventually becomes pregnant by an anonymous African American soldier. Her plight highlights the difficulties that women of her era faced in a society that did not value women and that turned a blind eye to abuse and exploitation.
W Themes The Book of Dead Birds centers on the protagonist’s efforts to connect with her mother. Helen is unable to discuss her painful and brutal past with her daughter. Instead Ava learns her mother’s story through a pansori, a traditional Korean music form in which a long story is told through song. As Helen sings her pansori she incorporates the details of her past with traditional lyrics. Ava accompanies her mother on the chang’go, a Korean drum, and then writes down everything her mother sings about. Ava also makes discoveries about her mother by reading Helen’s journal—what Ava calls her “book of dead birds.” Helen’s entries include obituaries she has written about her dead birds, bits of feathers and eggshell, and newspaper articles related to birds or other topics of interest to Helen. Ava and Helen grow closer when Helen joins her daughter in the bird rescue operation at the Salton Sea. Birds clearly figure heavily in the novel, serving as metaphors for Helen’s inability to escape her past and Ava’s failed efforts to communicate with her mother. Birds both divide and unite mother and daughter. Throughout her life Ava repeatedly kills her mother’s pet birds by accident, and Helen has carefully recorded these events in her book of dead birds. The two women find a semblance of redemption in their efforts to save the birds dying near the Salton Sea, as Ava gains selfconfidence and a greater understanding of her mother.
158 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Book of Dead Birds
W Style The main action of The Book of Dead Birds takes place during the late twentieth century, with the bulk of the story narrated in the first person by Ava. Some parts of the novel are presented in the third person, describing the life of brutality and prostitution Ava’s mother endured in her native Korea in the 1960s. However, rather than providing the gruesome details of Helen’s past all at once, Brandeis reveals the stories bit by bit, interrupting Ava’s narrative with flashbacks that describe Helen’s young adulthood. The author also pauses from time to time to offer entries from the journal Helen has kept as an adult, excerpts from writings by noted ornithologist John James Audubon, and descriptions of the protagonist’s dreams. The text of each of these digressions is set in a font different from that of the novel’s primary text, signaling a shift in time or speaker, away from the main plot. A poet as well as a novelist, Brandeis has been praised for the lyric quality of her prose. Her sensitivity to word choice is evident, for example, in her protagonist’s name. At first glance the choice of “Ava” as the name of the protagonist might seem cliché in its association with birds, but the protagonist explains that her mother drew a different connection to her love of birds when she selected the name: “My mother named me Ava because she liked how the English letters looked—the big A a beak pointed upward, the v a sharp slash of wings, the small a round and flat as a parrot’s eye.” David Abrams, reviewing the novel for January Magazine, comments that “poetry abounds on every page and graces every sentence” and that “Brandeis has a poet’s ear for the music of language.”
W Critical Reception Critical reception of The Book of Dead Birds has been mixed. Commentators count among the novel’s strengths the poetic qualities of Brandeis’s writing. Joanne Wilkinson, in a review for Booklist, argues that Brandeis “is at her best in her lyrical descriptions of nature and in the finely detailed portrait of the emotional tug-of-war between mother and child.” Critics have also appreciated the author’s attention to detail and historical accuracy. In writing about The Book of Dead Birds for Library Journal, Eleanor J. Bader lauds the work as being “poignant and well researched.” Brandeis receives high marks for her well-developed, sympathetic characters. On the other hand, some reviewers have suggested that the author attempts to tackle too many weighty subjects at once. Wilkinson, for example, complains that “Brandeis’ novel suffers, at times, from overly fraught symbolism and an awkwardly tacked-on subplot.” A Kirkus reviewer observes that “too many elements . . . fight for ascendancy and resolution: murdered prostitutes washed up on the shores of the Salton Sea; the sorrowful, desperate
MAJOR CHARACTERS AVA SING LO is the novel’s protagonist. Ava struggles with identity and sexual repression because of her mixed racial background and the fact she has never met her father. She distances herself from men, and is initially cautious with Darryl. HELEN SING LO (originally Hye-yang), Ava’s mother, is a Korean woman and a former prostitute. An American soldier marries her, effectively rescuing her from prostitution; however, he abandons her after she gives birth to another man’s child. She struggles to provide for Ava and continues to be haunted by her past. DARRYL STERNBERG is Ava’s love interest and the director of the bird rescue operation at the Salton Sea. SUN is Helen’s childhood friend, whom she follows into a life of prostitution.
history of Helen’s and Sun’s lives as G.I. prostitutes; and the early massacre at Cheju-do in 1948.” Bader likewise suggests that “Brandeis’s writing is at times heavyhanded.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Abrams, David. “Fledgling Flight.” Rev. of The Book of Dead Birds, by Gayle Brandeis. January Magazine Oct. 2003. Web. 23 Aug. 2010. Bader, Eleanor J. Rev. of The Book of Dead Birds, by Gayle Brandeis. Library Journal 1 May 2003: 153. Literature Resource Center. Web. 19 Aug. 2010. Rev. of The Book of Dead Birds, by Gayle Brandeis. Kirkus Reviews 1 Apr. 2003: 489+. Literature Resource Center. Web. 19 Aug. 2010. Brandeis, Gayle. The Book of Dead Birds. New York: HarperCollins, 2003. Print. Wilkinson, Joanne. Rev. of The Book of Dead Birds, by Gayle Brandeis. Booklist 15 May 2003: 1642. Literature Resource Center. Web. 19 Aug. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Dieter, William. “Death Yields Tenderness, Redemption in Birds.” Rocky Mountain News Online 2 May 2003. Web. 23 Aug. 2010. A lengthy assessment that admires the novel’s plot and lauds Brandeis’s effort as a first-time novelist. Mahoney, Blair. Rev. of The Book of Dead Birds, by Gayle Brandeis. Modern Word 30 Jan. 2004. Web. 23 Aug. 2010. A generally positive review that discusses the
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
159
The Book of Dead Birds
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Gayle Brandeis was born in 1964 in Chicago, Illinois, and spent her childhood in the Chicago area. She began writing poetry as a young child, and her poetry and other writings have been featured in such publications as the Nation and the Mississippi Review. Brandeis completed an individualized learning program at the University of Redlands in California in which she earned a BA in “Poetry and Movement: Arts of Expression, Meditation and Healing.” She then studied at Antioch University, completing an MFA in creative writing. Her first book-length publication was the nonfiction work Fruitflesh: Seeds of Inspiration for Women Who Write (2001), a guide for aspiring women writers. In addition to The Book of Dead Birds, Brandeis has written three other novels: Self Storage (2007); Delta Girls (2010); and My Life with the Lincolns (2010), her first novel for young readers. The author and her family live in Riverside, California.
novel’s theme of sexual repression and references to various books, including Audubon’s Birds of America. Pearl, Nancy. “California, Here I Come.” Rev. of The Book of Dead Birds, by Gayle Brandeis. Library Journal 1 Apr. 2004: 144. Literature Resource Center. Web. 19 Aug. 2010. A brief review that provides an overview of the novel. Pelland, Alice. “When a Daughter Takes Flight.” BookPage 10 Nov. 2003. Web. 19 Aug. 2010. An analysis that focuses on the relationship of the protagonist and her mother. Wolff, Carlo. “Healing at Heart of Sensitive MotherDaughter.” Milwaukee Journal Sentinel 4 May 2003: E6. Print. A review that praises the insightful nature of Brandeis’s writing. Gale Resources
“Gayle Brandeis.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Literature Resource Center. Web. 19 Aug. 2010.
In the story, Ava’s desire to help the endangered birds is prompted by childhood incidents in which she accidentally killed her mother’s pet birds. SpicStock/Shutterstock.com
160
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Book of Dead Birds
In The Book of Dead Birds, Ava Sing Lo goes to the Salton Sea in California to help rescue birds that have come in contact with agricultural poisons. Brent Stirton/Getty Images
Open Web Sources
Gayle Brandeis’s official Web site offers a brief biography, links to the author’s blogs, excerpts from her novels, and information about her inspiration for The Book of Dead Birds. http//www.gaylebrandeis.com/ HarperCollins, publisher of The Book of Dead Birds, furnishes a reading guide for the novel, with a synopsis of the book, discussion questions, and a brief author biography. http//www.harpercollins.com/author/ authorExtra.aspx?isbn13=9780060528041& displayType=readingGuide The Audubon Society presents information about current bird conservation efforts. http//www.Audubon.org/ The Web site for the Bellwether Prize for Fiction features a press release that was issued upon Brandeis’s winning the award in 2002. http//www.bellwether prize.org/
Durrow, Heidi W. The Girl Who Fell from the Sky. Chapel Hill: Algonquin Books, 2010. Print. The daughter of a Danish woman and an African American G.I. is the focus of Durrow’s novel. Junghyo, Anh. Silver Stallion: A Novel of Korea. New York: Soho Press, 1990. Print. Set in a small village in Korea during the Korean War, Silver Stallion provides a frank and revealing portrait of how Koreans were affected by the war. Keller, Nora Okja. Fox Girl. New York: Viking, 2002. Print. Fox Girl, which takes place just after the Korean War, concerns the search for Korean American identity as well as the tragic culture surrounding Korean prostitution. Silver, Marisa. The God of War: A Novel. New York: Simon & Schuster, 2008. Print. Silver’s work traces the struggles of a family living near the Salton Sea in 1978.
For Further Reading
Choi, Sook Nyul. Echoes of the White Giraffe. Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1993. Print. Choi’s novel for young readers offers insight into the role of women in Korean society. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Harrabeth Haidusek
161
The Book of Negroes By Lawrence Hill
W Introduction
W Literary and Historical
Drawing from the historical document called The Book of Negroes, Lawrence Hill has created a novel with the same title—a fictionalized account of Aminata Diallo, captured by slave traders from her village in West Africa. The novel was published as The Book of Negroes in Canada, Great Britain, South Africa, and India, and as Someone Knows My Name in the United States, Australia, and New Zealand. Aminata, an eleven-year-old freeborn Muslim, survives the forced overland march of the coffle (chained line of prisoners) to slave ships headed for South Carolina indigo plantations. During the sea voyage, Aminata insists on calling out the names of the captives to affirm their humanity. Among the named fellow villagers is Chekura, a young man sold by his uncle to slavers, whom she later marries. Aminata uses her skills as translator to work as a baby catcher (midwife). Raped by the ship’s doctor, she gives birth to her first child, who is destined for bondage. On Robinson Appleby’s indigo plantation, Aminata, or Meena as she was known, marries Chekura, though they must live apart, and she learns to read and write from Mamed, the trusted Negro overseer. Later she is sold to Solomon Lindo, a Jewish inspector, but she escapes Charles Town toward the end of the American Revolution and gets to Nova Scotia, where the British have offered freedom to those whose names were recorded in The Book of Negroes. Hill includes historic figures, such as Sam Fraunces, the black owner of a New York tavern, and the Birchtown preacher, Blind Moses Wilkinson, as he describes how Aminata travels to Nova Scotia and then to Freetown in Sierra Leone, and finally to London, England. Despite its realistic depiction of slavery, Hill’s narrative describes kind strangers, the promise of freedom, individual dignity, and the reward of accomplishment.
Context
The historical document called The Book of Negroes records the names of three thousand black people who pledged their service to the British during the Revolutionary War in exchange for freedom and their passage to and settlement in British colonies. The Slave Trade Act of 1807 made illegal the business of transporting and selling slaves; it was followed in 1833 by the Slavery Abolition Act, which outlawed the institution itself. The United States abolished slave trade in 1808, and the Thirteenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution abolished slavery in 1865. Black loyalists, like the white loyalists faithful to King George during the Revolution, were offered their freedom in British colonies as a reward for their service behind lines. Bleak conditions, including poor housing and lack of provisions and jobs, revived racial tensions and led to the first race riot. Nearly twelve hundred black loyalists sailed from Halifax back to Africa and settled at Freetown in Sierra Leone in 1792. Moses Lindo, a Sephardic Jew from England, eventually became an inspector after his arrival in South Carolina in 1756; however, Hill’s depiction of this character is otherwise fictional. John Clarkston founded Freetown in 1792, along with freed American slaves who sailed from Nova Scotia. Hill places him in Sierra Leone longer than his actual sojourn. The historical Thomas Peters (1738-1792), known as Black Moses, died shortly after landing in Freetown from malaria, not at the hands of slavers as in the novel.
W Themes The Book of Negroes, published in the United States and Australia as Someone Knows My Name, is about freedom
162 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Book of Negroes
and identity, both literal and figurative. Aminata is born free, and thus very aware of the loss of her personal liberty. But she is also intellectually free and able to cultivate her skills despite being in bondage. Assisted by diverse characters, Hill’s protagonist uses her fierce sense of identity to outwit her captors, but it is her proficiency in speaking and writing that insures her survival and ultimate victory. The theme of language is also important. Hill suggests that the fictional slave narrative by Aminata Diallo sheds more light on the institution of slavery. Her skill at articulating events and relationships underscores the value of the storyteller as a witness to history.
W Style Hill’s style is both gritty and eloquent, particularly in the voice of his protagonist, Aminata Diallo. Peppering the narrative and dialogue with colloquialisms of Fulfulde and Bamanankan, as well as English, Hill produces different voices, that are distinguished by such words as woloso, toubabu, and buckra. In addition, Hill mimics the Djeli art of preserving elements of oral tradition, with compound metaphors similar to the kennings of Old English, such as “baby catcher” or “firestick.” He uses fresh images to describe objects, calling the slave ship, for example, “an animal in water,” and he puns effectively, such as with the word Guinea for a geographical place, a unit of currency, and modifier of the epithet for a wench. Hill implicates language at every turn, showing how it has the power to kill or conquer, and he suggests cultural assumptions in the rules governing usage, which, for example, prohibited slaves from using the word “white” or whites from using the name “Mary” for a female slave whose real name was not known. Distinctions between slave and servant collapse first in context, then in actuality. In the tradition of a bildungsroman, Aminata’s tale is one of development, as she is dislocated from her homeland and besieged by obstacles as she travels across three continents. Hill’s spry heroine comes of age by her wit, her ability to read and write, her skill as a negotiator, and her indefatigable virtue.
W Critical Reception Lawrence Hill’s third novel, The Book of Negroes, enjoyed critical acclaim because of its fine storytelling. Already an established Canadian author, Hill turned to an overlooked historical document with the eponymous title of his novel and created a memorable protagonist, whom Stephen Kimber described as both lifelike and larger than life. Sarah Johnson offered similar praise for Hill’s depiction of Aminata as a quintessential unconquerable heroine. Stressing another feature, Tahmima Anam
MAJOR CHARACTERS ROBINSON APPLEBY is a tyrannical indigo plantation owner who abuses Aminata and eventually sells her to Solomon Lindo. CHEKURA, sold by his uncle to slavers, is Aminata’s village companion and later her husband and the father of May. AMINATA (MEENA) DIALLO, the narrator, recounts her life story as an old woman. MAMADU DIALLO, jeweler by trade, is Aminata’s Muslim father who teaches her to write in Arabic. He is murdered by the Toubab slavers. FANTA, the youngest wife of the village chief, is mean to everybody but relies on Aminata to catch her baby on board the slave ship. FOMBA, a gentle hunter, is among those in the coffle who survive the trip to a South Carolina indigo plantation with Aminata. SIRA KULIBARI, the village midwife, is Aminata’s mother. She teaches her daughter to “catch babies,” but she is also slain by slavers. SOLOMON LINDO, an indigo inspector, makes a deal to purchase Aminata from Appleby, on the condition that he can sell her firstborn son. Using his Jewish identity to strike a common chord in Aminata as an outsider, he treats her as a servant, teaches her bookkeeping, and allows her to hire out as a midwife in Charles Town. He manumits her long after she has escaped his servitude. MAMED, the black overseer on the Appleby plantation, teaches Aminata to read and write. MAY, the daughter of Aminata and Chekura, is kidnapped by the Witherspoons but later reunited with her mother in London. TOM, the medicine man on the slave ship, misleads Aminata with his occasional generosity and then rapes her. LIEUTENANT MALCOLM WATERS, a British officer, arranges for Aminata to participate in compiling the ledger known as The Book of Negroes.
credited the protagonist with language skills that play a role in transforming her fate. Many critics agreed that Hill’s own use of language and his development of characters give The Book of Negroes its major strengths. Johnson, writing in Booklist, called the novel “a masterful example of historical storytelling,” The epic style and vivid characters earned the novel the Best Regional Book award for Canada and the Caribbean, the Overall Commonwealth Best Book, and the Writers’ Trust Fiction Prize.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
163
The Book of Negroes
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Born in Toronto, Ontario, Canada, in 1957, to a black father and white mother, Lawrence Hill explores themes of racial identity and social justice in his work. He received his BA from Université Laval in Quebec City, Quebec, in 1980, and his MA from Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore, Maryland, in 1992. Hill has worked as a reporter, freelance writer and researcher, and teacher. His publications include the novel, Any Known Blood (1997); the autobiography, Black Berry, Sweet Juice: On Being Black and White in Canada (2001); and (with Joshua Key), the biography, The Deserter’s Tale: The Story of an Ordinary Soldier Who Walked Away from the War in Iraq (2007). As of 2010, Hill lived with his wife and children in Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.
Ruth Scurr called Hill’s novel “an imaginative response to the real historical document.” Kimber agreed that Hill’s slave narrative weaves history and fiction so deftly that it is possible to confuse the two and imagine the author’s inventions are historical events. But he was quick to add that he did not impugn Hill for irresponsible handling of the facts. Rather he commended the author for his “seductive power as a storyteller.” Sarah Churchill
pointed out in her review in the Guardian that Hill observes the slave narrative tradition of Olaudah Equiano, and she added that his “textured and nuanced grasp” is reinforced by his historical research. Others, such as Luanne Gaines, applauded Hill for telling Aminata’s story, lest readers forget her. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Anam, Tahmima. “Reading for Pleasure: The Author of a Golden Age Admires a Fictional Narrative Told by a Female Slave.” Rev. of The Book of Negroes, by Lawrence Hill. Bookseller 6 June 2008: 22. Print. Churchill, Sarah. “Bought and Sold.” Rev. of The Book of Negroes, by Lawrence Hill. Guardian.co.uk. Guardian 24 Jan. 2009. Web. 30 July 2010. Gaines, Luanne. Rev. of Someone Knows My Name, by Lawrence Hill. curledup.com. Curled up with a Good Book 2007. Web. 23 July 2010. Hill, Lawrence. The Book of Negroes. New York: HarperCollins, 2007. Print. Johnson, Sarah. “Someone Knows My Name.” Rev. of The Book of Negroes, by Lawrence Hill. Booklist 15 Oct. 2007: 33+. Print. Kimber, Stephen. “The Lived Truth of Slavery: Fiction So Powerful It Stumped an Historian.” Rev. of The Book of Negroes, by Lawrence Hill. Literary Review of Canada 15.5 (2007): 19. Print. Scurr, Ruth. “The Book of Negroes by Lawrence Hill.” Rev. of The Book of Negroes, by Lawrence Hill. entertainment.timesonline.co.uk. Times [London] 16 Jan. 2009. Web. 30 July 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Hill, Lawrence. “Freedom Bound.” Beaver: Exploring Canada’s History 1 Feb. 2007. Print. Details about the historical document recorded by the British, including entries of freed slaves. Jarrett-Macauley, Delia. “A Slave’s Great Journey.” Rev. of The Book of Negroes, by Lawrence Hill. washingtonpost.com. Washington Post 26 Feb. 2008. Web. 18 July 2010. Explains use of female North-American slave narratives in portraying Aminata Diallo. Kavanagh, Afra. “Slavery’s Painful Stories.” Rev. of The Book of Negroes, by Lawrence Hill. Canadian Literature 197 (2008): 141-43. Print. Describes Aminata’s indictment of everyone who contributed to the institution of slavery. The Book of Negroes tells the story of Aminata Diallo, a young girl who is captured by slave traders in West Africa. ª North Wind Picture Archives / Alamy
164
Kline, Nancy. “From Slavery to Freedom.” Rev. of The Book of Negroes, by Lawrence Hill. newyorktimes.com. New York Times 20 Jan. 2008. Web. 18 July 2010. Applauds Aminata Diallo, Hill’s protagonist, who TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Book of Negroes
writes a slave narrative that exposes the horrors and ironies of slavery. Gale Resources
“Lawrence Hill.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Literature Resource Center. Web. 26 July 2010. http//go.galegroup.com/ps/i.do?&id =GALE%7CH1000045561&v=2.1&u=itsbtrial& it=r&p=LitRC&sw=w Open Web Sources
Jane Finch interviewed Lawrence Hill on January 19, 2010, a transcript of which is provided at her Web site at http//www.jane-finch.com/interviews/ lawrencehill.htm as a podcast. The Lawrence Hill Web site, at http//www.lawrencehill. com, includes information on the author and his works. For Further Reading
Douglass, Frederick. Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass: An American Slave, Written by Himself. New York: Bedford-St. Martin’s Press, 2002. Print. Classic autobiography and slave narrative, which affirms the importance of literacy.
Equiano, Olaudah. The Interesting Narrative and Other Writings. Ed. Vincent Carretta. New York: Penguin Classics, 2003. Print. Recounts personal experiences as a slave and later as respected member of the antislavery movement. Greene, Jack P. Money, Trade, and Power: The Evolution of Colonial South Carolina’s Plantation Society. Columbia: U of South Carolina Press, 2001. Print. Explores the slave economy in South Carolina and discusses gender issues such as reproductive abilities of female slaves and trade skills of male slaves. Mitchell, Faith. Hoodoo Medicine: Gullah Herbal Remedies. Port Carling: Summerhouse Press, 1999. Print. Describes African American folk culture preserved by slaves and their descendants, particularly in the South Carolina Sea Islands. Schneider, Dorothy, and Carl J. Schneider. Slavery in America. New York: Checkmark Books, 2006. Print. Emphasizes various aspects of slavery using primary materials.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Doris Plantus-Runey
165
The Book of Night Women By Marlon James
W Introduction Marlon James’s second novel, The Book of Night Women, traces the life of Lilith, a mixed-race slave on a Jamaican sugarcane plantation in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries. The green-eyed Lilith is the product of a union between a black teenage slave and her white overseer. She feels that her white ancestry elevates her above her fellow slaves, and she is reluctant to join a group of her half-sisters, the “Night Women,” in planning a slave uprising. Lilith eventually becomes involved with Robert Quinn, a white overseer who previously supervised her regular beatings. Lilith and Quinn have a daughter, and at the end of the novel the daughter reveals herself as the narrator of her mother’s story. The Book of Night Women catalogs the horrors of slave life and the complex hierarchies that existed among both enslaved and free peoples during that time. Critical reception of the novel was varied, with many reviews noting the book’s graphic, often shocking depictions of violence. The Book of Night Women was a finalist for the 2009 National Book Critics Circle Award for fiction.
W Literary and Historical Context
Jamaica came under British rule during the midseventeenth century and remained so for more than 150 years. Enslaved Africans were brought to the island via the Atlantic slave trade. Sugarcane and coffee were cultivated in Jamaica, and slave labor was employed to work the plantations, providing a lucrative enterprise for the British Empire. These slaves were often treated brutally by their white overseers, who whipped, raped, and even murdered them. Many female slaves, often barely beyond childhood themselves, bore children as a result of the sexual abuses of white overseers. Lilith, the protagonist of The Book
of Night Women, is the product of such an encounter. Her teenage mother’s death in childbirth is described early in the novel. The Book of Night Women graphically depicts the horrors of life on a typical Jamaican sugarcane plantation in the late eighteenth century and details the difficulties and dangers associated with any act of resistance. With more than twenty slaves for every white master, Jamaica saw numerous uprisings and slave conspiracies during the eighteenth century. In James’s novel, a group of six slave half-sisters, all daughters of the same white overseer, form a secret society called the Night Women. Together they plan an uprising, which ultimately fails with devastating results. Slavery was officially abolished in the British Empire on August 1, 1834. The Book of Night Women follows in the tradition of West Indian literature, which began to develop in the mid-twentieth century. Much of West Indian literature deals in some way with issues and concerns associated with Caribbean history, including language, ethnicity, and national and colonial identity. Like Lilith in The Book of Night Women, many Caribbeans claim a mixed-race heritage and identify with more than one culture, among them African, English, Spanish, and even American.
W Themes Although The Book of Night Women portrays the torture and cruelty that were common in Jamaican society during the late eighteenth century, its central concern is the theme of power versus powerlessness. Throughout the novel the narrator repeatedly declares, “Every Negro walk in a circle.” Gail Lumet Buckley, in her analysis of the novel for the Washington Post, interprets the phrase as a simple, succinct summary of the brutal world of West Indian slavery. “It seems to mean,” says Buckley, “that black life in the Americas was a vicious circle, full of the terrible things that whites did to blacks and that blacks did to whites and to blacks because of whites.” Slaves vastly outnumber whites, and the constant threat of
166 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Book of Night Women
rebellion seems to make for an environment even more horrific than that of some other neighboring slave cultures. Sexual and other forms of physical abuse become vehicles for power and control. Susan Straight, writing in the Los Angeles Times, points out that “sex is a weapon, a method, a shackle. An act of violence and power.” Straight notes that some of the slave women’s bodies are “the living chronicle of rape and power.” Indeed, Lilith’s torso is so scarred from whippings that she appears to have a “quilt on her back.” Murder and mysticism also empower slaves as they attempt to resist their vicious oppressors. When a black enforcer, or “Johnny-jumper,” tries to rape the fourteenyear-old Lilith, she resists him and kills him with his own sword. This murder gives Lilith a glimpse of power, and she goes on to murder others, desperately trying to gain some control over her own life. Arifa Akbar, reviewing the novel in the Independent, observes that Lilith is “both exhilarated by this demonic energy within her” and at times “consumed by self-loathing and guilt.” Akbar also notes that “James uses the imagery of witchcraft and African shamanism inventively, as a metaphor for political resistance.” Homer, the leader of the Night Women, has mastered the art of African potion making, using her lotions to heal victims of violence and also to “send the masters and their wives into deranged states of mind as a form of revenge.” Class distinction is closely related to the struggle for power. The lives of blacks are considered expendable, since black slaves are cheap and are easily acquired. The hierarchy is not limited merely to blacks and whites, however. “House slaves” who serve the family of the master are valued above other slaves. Lilith believes that she is better than other slaves because her green eyes are proof of her white heritage. In addition, black Johnnyjumpers abuse other slaves. Class distinction exists among whites as well. Robert Quinn, for example, is disdained by British authorities simply because he is Irish. Nevertheless, he is considered superior to slaves. His affair with Lilith illustrates their society’s insuperable barriers inherent in a relationship that crosses class and racial lines, since the scars on Lilith’s back serve as a reminder that she has been brutalized at Robert’s command. Rayyan AlShawaf, writing in the Miami Herald, suggests that “the intrinsic dichotomy between Lilith and Quinn dooms their relationship. . . . So thorough and consuming is destructiveness that even love doesn’t stand a chance.”
W Style The most distinctive stylistic feature of The Book of Night Women is James’s use of Jamaican patois. This Englishbased dialect developed among the slave populations of the seventeenth century and blends British English, Hiberno-English (Irish English), and Lowlands Scots with west African influences. In her review in the Independent, Akbar observes that the “narration is one
MAJOR CHARACTERS HOMER is the leader of the Night Women, a group of six halfsisters who plan a slave rebellion. Homer is skilled with herbs and lotions, using her powers both to heal and to inflict cruelty on her enemies. LILITH, the novel’s protagonist, is the daughter of the white overseer Jack Wilkins and a teenage slave girl, who dies when Lilith is born. The green-eyed Lilith works on the Montpelier plantation as a house slave. The Night Women attempt to recruit her in an effort to further their plans for a slave uprising. Lilith becomes the mistress of Robert Quinn, an Irish overseer, with whom she eventually has a child. LOVEY QUINN is the daughter of Lilith and Robert Quinn. At the end of the novel, it is revealed that Lovey is the narrator of the story. ROBERT QUINN is an Irish overseer who initially supervises regular whippings of Lilith. He falls in love with Lilith, and she becomes his mistress. The two are never fully able to overcome the cultural restrictions that prevent them from having a relationship as equals. JACK WILKINS is a white overseer on the Montpelier plantation. He rapes young slave girls, fathering a number of children, including the members of the group that calls itself the Night Women.
of the novel’s strongest features, written in the vernacular and carrying its own drum-like rhythm which is as lyrical as it is hypnotic, even in the most violent passages.” In a review for the Los Angeles Times, Susan Straight calls the book “a chant, using repetition and verse.” Both the narration and the dialogue within the novel are written in patois. Dialogue is distinguished from narration with dashes rather than quotation marks. To indicate who is speaking, the narrator uses simple dialogue tags, such as “Homer say” or “Homer ask.” The story is told by a third-person narrator whose identity is revealed only at the end of the novel. It is Lilith and Robert Quinn’s daughter, whom Lilith names Lovey Quinn, who narrates her mother’s story. Lilith taught her daughter to read and write, and Lovey tells the reader that writing is a liberating experience for her—what she writes in the darkness “is as free as free can be, even if it never come to light and go free for real.” In the last lines of the book, Lovey explains that she began writing about her mother in 1819, several years after the action in the story takes place. She begins each chapter with either a brief description of an event or a philosophical observation, such as “White man is white man is white man, but not every nigger be the same nigger,” or “Every Negro walk in a circle. Take that and make of it what you will.”
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
167
The Book of Night Women
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Born in 1970 in Kingston, Jamaica, Marlon James earned a BA in literature from the University of the West Indies (1991) and an MA in creative writing from Wilkes University (2006). While studying at Wilkes, James received Norman Mailer’s Norris Church Mailer Scholarship for Creative Writing. The author’s work has been published in several anthologies, including Iron Balloons (2006; edited by Colin Channer), Bronx Noir (2007; edited by S. J. Rozan), and Silent Voices (2007; edited by Peter A. Balaskas), and in the Caribbean Review of Books. John Crow’s Devil (2005), James’s debut novel, was a finalist for both the Commonwealth Writers’ Prize and the Los Angeles Times Book Prize. An essayist as well as a novelist, James is a professor of literature and creative writing at Macalester College in St. Paul, Minnesota. He has also taught at the Calabash International Literary Festival Workshop in Kingston and the Gotham Writers Workshop in New York City.
W Critical Reception Critics have offered mixed reviews of The Book of Night Women. Praise for the novel generally focuses on James’s vivid depictions of the cruel, violent conditions and helpless circumstances that slaves endured in late
eighteenth-century Jamaica. A Bookmarks reviewer calls the novel “a stunning testament to the dynamics of ultimate power and powerlessness.” Kaiama Glover, writing in the New York Times, offers a similar assessment, declaring that “James has conducted an experiment in how to write the unspeakable—even the unthinkable. And the results of that experiment are an undeniable success.” Reviewers have also acknowledged James’s ability to capture the complex class struggles that exist in both black and white societies. On the other hand, Jim Hannan, reviewing the novel for World Literature Today, concludes that the novel is “flawed,” finding fault with James’s “superficial” characterization and suggesting that “his patois is plodding and unimaginative” compared to that of other Caribbean writers. Some critics have complained about the excessive—and perhaps sometimes gratuitous— violence in the novel. For example, Rayyan Al-Shawaf, a reviewer for the Miami Herald, argues that the author’s “preoccupation with detailing the history and methods of slave punishment in his native Jamaica sometimes interferes with the story. Describing the violence meted out to a character, he might segue to listing other sorts of torture historically inflicted on slaves.” In addition to its consideration for a National Book Critics Circle Award, The Book of Night Women was a finalist for the NAACP Image Award and the Minnesota Book Award. The novel was also named the third-best book of 2009 by New York magazine.
Jamaican slaves on a sugar plantation. In the story, Lilith, the daughter of a slave and a white overseer, becomes involved in a romantic relationship with her own overseer. English School
168
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Book of Night Women
Jamaican slaves are set free. The Book of Night Women chronicles the story of Lilith, a biracial Jamaican slave. Thomas Picken BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Akbar, Arifa. Rev. of The Book of Night Women, by Marlon James. Independent [London]. Independent Print Ltd, 28 Aug. 2009. Web. 5 Oct. 2010. Al-Shawaf, Rayyan. “The Author Portrays Strong Female Characters in This Tale Set in 19th Century BritishRuled Jamaica.” Rev. of The Book of Night Women, by Marlon James. Miami Herald 4 Mar. 2009. Web. 5 Oct. 2010. Buckley, Gail Lumet. “Vengeance Is Theirs.” Rev. of The Book of Night Women, by Marlon James. Washington Post 17 Feb. 2009. Web. 5 Oct. 2010. Glover, Kaiama L. “Womanchild in the Oppressive Land.” Rev. of The Book of Night Women, by Marlon James. New York Times Book Review 1 Mar. 2009: 7L. Print. Hannon, Jim. Rev. of The Book of Night Women, by Marlon James. World Literature Today 84.1 (2010): 66. Print. James, Marlon. The Book of Night Women. New York: Riverhead, 2009. Print.
Straight, Susan. Rev. of The Book of Night Women, by Marlon James. Los Angeles Times 8 Mar. 2009. Web. 5 Oct. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Rev. of The Book of Night Women, by Marlon James. Bookmarks May-June 2009: 32. Literature Resource Center. Web. 5 Oct. 2010. Provides an overview of critical reception of the novel as well as a critical summary of the book. Rev. of The Book of Night Women, by Marlon James. Jamaican Book Review. Jamaicans.com, 31 Mar. 2009. Web. 5 Oct. 2010. Favorable review that includes biographical information about the author as well as links to additional book reviews. Reed, Troy. “Editors’ Choice Novels for May 2009.” Rev. of The Book of Night Women, by Marlon James. Historical Novel Society. Historical Novel Society, May 2009. Web. 5 Oct. 2010. Positive review that praises the novel’s realistic dialect and James’s character portrayal.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
169
The Book of Night Women
St. John, Edward B. Rev. of The Book of Night Women, by Marlon James. Library Journal 15 Feb. 2009: 14. Literature Resource Center. Web. 5 Oct. 2010. Brief review that discusses point of view in the novel as well as the complexities of nineteenth-century Jamaican society. Smith, Candace. Rev. of The Book of Night Women. Booklist 15 Apr. 2009: 58. Literature Resource Center. Web. 5 Oct. 2010. Audiobook review that admires the poetic quality of James’s prose. Open Web Sources
On his Web site, Marlon James provides a brief biography, an overview of his writings, and a blog. http//marlonjames.com Macalester College offers online information about the author’s life, writings, and teaching career. http// www.macalester.edu/english/james.html Listeners can access an audio recording of James’s March 2009 interview with Tom Ashbrook for National Public Radio’s On Point, in which James discusses The Book of Night Women. http//www.onpointradio. org/2009/03/jamaicas-night-women
refers to the brutal task of working in the sugarcane fields of the Dominican Republic. The book centers on the massacre of Haitian workers in the 1930s and the potentially devastating consequences of racism. Diptee, Audra. From Africa to Jamaica: The Making of an Atlantic Slave Society, 1775-1807. Gainesville: UP of Florida, 2010. Print. This scholarly work details the history of slavery in Jamaica and slavery’s impact on Jamaican society. James, Marlon. John Crow’s Devil. New York: Akashic Books, 2005. Print. Like The Book of Night Women, James’s first novel is set in Jamaica. During the midtwentieth century, a Jamaican village deals with religious conflict and suggestions of witchcraft. Levy, Andrea. The Long Song. London: Headline Review, 2010. Print. Levy’s novel takes the form of a memoir written by an elderly Jamaican woman named July, who is a former slave. The story is set on a sugarcane plantation in early nineteenth-century Jamaica. Morrison, Toni. Beloved. New York: Knopf, 1987. Print. Morrison’s celebrated novel chronicles the life an escaped slave and her daughter.
For Further Reading
Harrabeth Haidusek
Danticat, Edwidge. The Farming of Bones. New York: Soho, 1998. Print. The title of Danticat’s novel
170
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Book of Not By Tsitsi Dangarembga
W Introduction The Book of Not is Tsitsi Dangarembga’s sequel to her 1988 semi-autobiographical novel Nervous Conditions, in which she detailed the efforts of a young Zimbabwean girl named Tambudzai, or Tambu, to acquire an education despite the difficulties she faced, including extreme poverty, misogyny, and colonialism. Dangarembga traces Tambu’s journey in Nervous Conditions and then in The Book of Not. In the first novel, Tambu develops a pragmatism that allows her to see her brother’s death as an event in her favor. For example, because he was the only male in the family, his death allowed Tambu to attend school. Similarly, in The Book of Not, Tambu learns to come to terms with her sister’s dismemberment, which occurs during the Zimbabwean war for independence. Tambu’s primary concern in The Book of Not is to leave her village and attend the Young Ladies’ College of the Sacred Heart, a missionary school to which she has won a scholarship. What Tambu does not understand is that Sacred Heart is a relic of European colonialism, a place where she will encounter the same kind of patronizing racial assumptions she is trying to escape. Dangarembga makes it clear that Tambu’s overidentification with the whites at the school is just another consequence of colonialism, and that colonized peoples suffer long-term effects from their subjugation.
W Literary and Historical Context
Until 1980 Zimbabwe was variously called either Southern Rhodesia or simply Rhodesia, named after the Englishborn South African explorer Cecil Rhodes. By 1889 Rhodes held a monopoly on the world diamond trade and later cofounded the DeBeers Mining Company, which
continues to trade in diamonds into the twenty-first century. Hoping to make a name for himself, Rhodes began acquiring mining rights in central and southern Africa by forging treaties with chieftains. In 1889 he was granted a charter by Queen Victoria to form the British South Africa Company (BSAC), which was modeled on the highly successful British East India Company. Several thousand white settlers followed Rhodes to the region, hoping to capitalize on the mining opportunities. Instead, with protection from the BSAC’s private army, the settlers took over much of the fertile land. They also ignited tensions between tribal leaders, only some of whom had signed treaties with Rhodes. The First Matabele War broke out in 1893, in which the Ndebele king, Lobengula, and his tribesmen fought the BSAC and British troops, who used the most advanced weaponry available at the time. The war ended the following year, with the death of Lobengula, the loss of all the Ndebele territory, and establishment of the country of Southern Rhodesia. A Second Matabele War began in 1896 and is known in Zimbabwe as the First War of Independence. It, too, ended in defeat for the Ndebele, as well as the Shona, and cemented the BSAC’s control of the region. From the start, Rhodes and his settlers wanted as much independence as possible from British colonial interference. With the BSAC’s charter set to expire in 1914, Rhodes requested a ten-year extension to avoid having the colony overtaken by South Africa. In 1923 the white population of Southern Rhodesia voted to establish itself as a self-governing colony, and it remained so until 1953, when it entered a federation with Northern Rhodesia and Nyasaland (now the countries of Zambia and Malawi, respectively). But while Southern Rhodesia had no African suffrage or legislative representation, Northern Rhodesia, with a much smaller white population, allowed for three, and later five, seats for Africans in its assembly. The movement for African independence that was taking hold across the continent during the first half of the twentieth century resulted in growing concerns in
171 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Book of Not
MAJOR CHARACTERS NTOMBI is an African classmate of Tambu’s at Sacred Heart. She has a more well-rounded approach to life and is contrasted favorably with Tambu. NYASHA is Tambu’s cousin, who was partly raised and educated in England before returning to Zimbabwe. She plays a smaller role in The Book of Not than in Nervous Conditions, where her own “nervous condition” is a major plot point. TAMBUDZAI, more commonly called Tambu, is a young woman coming of age during Zimbabwe’s war for independence from colonial rule during the 1960s and 1970s. TAMBU’S MOTHER has become embittered by poverty, racism, and marriage to a tyrannical husband. She is skeptical of Tambu’s ambitions.
Southern Rhodesia about the increasing number of Africans serving in Northern Rhodesia’s government. Thus, all three colonies petitioned the British government to dissolve the federation in 1963. Shortly thereafter Africans gained a majority in the governments of both Northern Rhodesia and Nyasaland. Southern Rhodesia, now calling itself simply Rhodesia, rejected the trend of majority rule sweeping the African colonies and instead voted to continue its white-minority rule through the Unilateral Declaration of Independence (UDI) from Great Britain in 1965. The British considered the UDI an act of rebellion and requested that the United Nations (UN) enact economic sanctions against Rhodesia. In the meantime, two pro-democracy parties were formed in Rhodesia. In 1961 Joshua Nkomo formed the Zimbabwe African People’s Union (ZAPU); his colleagues in the group were Ndabaningi Sithole and Robert Mugabe. Internal tensions reached a peak among the three in 1963, when Sithole and Mugabe left ZAPU and formed a rival pro-independence group, the Zimbabwe African National Union (ZANU). Although a new constitution was passed in 1962 that allowed for some African representation in the country’s parliament, a new, white supremacist party, the Rhodesian Front, was formed by Ian Smith, and it easily won in the elections of 1962. Winston Field was installed as prime minister and Smith was his deputy. In 1964 Smith succeeded Field as prime minister and had Nkomo and Mugabe, followed by Sithole, arrested and imprisoned until 1974. Smith issued the UDI in 1965, but UN sanctions were not instituted until 1968. Meanwhile, guerrilla fighting took hold of the country, led by the competing ZAPU and ZANU. Lasting from 1964 to 1979, the fighting is known as the Rhodesian Bush War, or Zimbabwe War of Liberation. In 1976 Nkomo and Mugabe reconciled and formed the
172
black-nationalist Patriotic Front. With his government on the brink of collapse, Smith agreed to negotiations in 1978, during which he made concessions that allowed the moderate African leader of United African National Council (UANC), Bishop Abel Muzorewa, to be elected prime minister. In 1979 Zimbabwe-Rhodesia was created, with a new constitution that ended white minority rule and the institution of a land reform program. In 1980 the old rivalry between Nkomo and Mugabe was revived when the two faced off against each other in the general election, which Mugabe won. Now officially independent of colonial rule, the new nation was renamed Zimbabwe. Although he initially gave Nkomo a role in the new government, Mugabe dismissed him in 1982, igniting tribal violence that lasted until 1987. At that point, Mugabe and Nkomo tried to reconcile their differences by coming together in a single party and amending the constitution so that Mugabe would serve as executive president and Nkomo as vice president. The country’s brief flirtation with democracy ended. Under Mugabe’s leadership, which had begun with great promise, Zimbabwe suffered economically and socially. Life expectancy dropped dramatically, hunger and poverty increased, HIV/AIDS reached epidemic rates, and the country experienced numerous humanitarian crises. As of 2010, Mugabe remained president.
W Themes According to Rosanne Kennedy, in an essay in Studies in the Novel, “Dangarembga innovatively uses irony, humor, and farce to dramatize the absurdities of racism in a colonial society and the impediments to witnessing it, thereby bringing into visibility what is unspeakable in (post)colonial Zimbabwe. The novel dramatizes the narrator’s struggle to break out of a repetition compulsion, manifested in her obsessive desire for recognition, which continually leaves her deflated and depressed.” In Nervous Conditions Tambu watches as her English-educated cousin Nyasha crumbles under the weight of racial and cultural confusion and suffers a breakdown. In The Book of Not it is Tambu who loses her sense of self when she tries to assimilate into white culture through educational achievement at a white-run academy. Kennedy continues: “In narrating Tambu’s struggles to become someone, and the undoing of her subjectivity, the novel dramatizes ordinary, everyday acts of racism in a gendered colonial context. By locating the story in the context of a colonial war in which the colonized are not unified against the white minority, the novel reflects on the psychological and political effects of witnessing traumatic events in a culture in which no one is supposed to remember what they saw.” Helon Habila, reviewing the book for the Guardian, writes, “The novel’s irony—and irony is the armature on which this whole story hangs—is that Tambu doesn’t see how false and unachievable her goal is. In a sense, this is the same old TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Book of Not
story of being black in a far too white world, even though here—more irony—the white world is actually in Africa.” Having been raised and educated partly in England, Dangarembga herself experienced the fractured existence of living in two cultures—one of which had historically exploited the other. In The Book of Not, Tambu becomes so invested in achieving success in the white world that she begins to betray her own culture, at one point taking part in a volunteer effort to aid white Rhodesian soldiers in the war for independence in order to comfort two white classmates whose parents were killed by guerrilla fighters. Despite her commitment to success, and despite Zimbabwe’s winning independence in 1980, Tambu repeatedly experiences the same forms of racism. At school she watches silently as a white student accepts an award that should have gone to her. And later, while working at a white-owned advertising agency, a white male colleague takes credit for Tambu’s work and wins an award for that as well. Conditioned by racism and misogyny to hold her tongue, Tambu is unable to defend herself in both cases.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Tsitsi Dangarembga was born in Mutoko, Rhodesia, in 1959, but moved with her parents, who were continuing their educations, to England when she was two years old. The family returned to the colony when Dangarembga was six. She attended a missionary school in Mutare, returning to England as a young adult to study medicine at Cambridge University. Homesickness took her back to Africa just prior to Zimbabwean independence in 1980, and she entered the University of Harare to study psychology. She became involved in theater, writing and directing plays, and also began writing fiction. Her first novel, Nervous Conditions, was the first English-language novel published by a Zimbabwean woman and won a prestigious Commonwealth Writers Prize. Dangarembga next studied film in Berlin and began writing and directing highly acclaimed motion pictures.
In The Book of Not, Tambudzai is a young Zimbabwean girl determined to obtain an education in spite of the challenges she faces. ª Aladdin Color, Inc./Aladdin Color, Inc./Corbis
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
173
The Book of Not
W Style The Book of Not is written entirely from Tambu’s point of view. As such, it provides no other perspective but hers, and it becomes increasingly difficult for the reader to remember that Tambu’s perspective is more and more warped as the story moves forward. As Tambu repeatedly explains, she is entirely focused on herself and her own achievement, to the exclusion of everything else. Ironically, though, the more she focuses on herself, the less she engages with her culture and her family, risking losing a fundamental part of her identity.
W Critical Reception Nervous Conditions is considered a classic of twentiethcentury African literature and has been hailed as one of the most significant works written by an African woman. Critics noted that the novel provides a rare glimpse into the experiences of a broad spectrum of Zimbabwean women, including Tambu’s mother, embittered by poverty and low expectations and resentful of her daughter’s opportunities, and her cousin Nyasha, who suffers from anorexia and other emotional problems because she cannot reconcile her feelings about Africa and England. These characters reappear in The Book of Not, but reviewers of the sequel found their roles reduced because of Tambu’s intensified focus on her own development. Helon Habila explained in her review that “[t]he whole novel is an examination of Tambu’s increasingly warped perspective, achieved through a focused, almost claustrophobic first-person point of view and a masterly deployment of flashbacks.” Heather Margolis, reviewing The Book of Not for the Journal of Asian and African Studies, also commented on Tambu’s gradual loss of connections: “Throughout [Tambu’s] struggle, the realm of the other expands to envelope much more than those who do not look like her or speak her native language. As the vast other builds a cold cement around her heart, Tambu labors ever more intensely and erratically to establish connections through the narrowing gaps. This personal isolation is the acknowledged but silent tragedy.” Some critics compared The Book of Not unfavorably with Nervous Conditions, maintaining that Tambu’s relentless refusal to protest the wrongs done to her made her seem more a martyr than a heroine. Most, however, agreed that Dangarembga narrates the story with such deft irony and sardonic humor that Tambu remains a likeable figure in spite of her flaws.
Kennedy, Rosanne. “Mortgaged Futures: Trauma, Subjectivity, and the Legacies of Colonialism in Tsitsi Dangarembga’s The Book of Not.” Studies in the Novel 40.1-2 (Spring-Summer 2008): 86-107. Print. Margolis, Heather. Rev. of The Book of Not, by Tsitsi Dangarembga. Journal of Asian and African Studies 42, no. 6 (Dec. 2007): 578-79. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Mustafa, Fawzia. “Reading Development and Writing Africa: UNFPA, Nervous Conditions, and The Book of Not.” Comparative Literature Studies 46.2 (2009): 379-406. Print. Examines Dangarembga’s novels in the context of the literal and figurative concept of “human” in the postcolonial world. Wanner, Zukisma. Rev. of The Book of Not, by Tsitsi Dangarembga. African Writing Online, June-Aug., 2007. Web. 4 Oct. 2010. Review that takes into account the role of Zimbabwe’s colonial history in the formation of Tambu’s character. Gale Resources
“Dangarembga, Tsitsi.” Black Literature Criticism: Classic and Emerging Authors since 1950. Ed. Jelena Krstovic. Vol. 1. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Gale Virtual Reference Library. Web. 11 Nov. 2010. ————. Contemporary Authors Online. Web. 11 Nov. 2010. Mabura, Lily G. N. “Black Women Walking Zimbabwe: Refuge and Prospect in the Landscapes of Yvonne Vera’s The Stone Virgins and Tsitsi Dangarembga’s Nervous Conditions and Its Sequel, The Book of Not.” Research in African Literatures 41.3 (2010): 88+. Print. For Further Reading
Barclay, Philip. Zimbabwe: Years of Hope and Despair. New York: Bloomsbury USA, 2010. Print. Journalistic account of Zimbabwe’s election of 2008, which Robert Mugabe won despite predictions to the contrary. Fuller, Alexandra. Don’t Let’s Go to the Dogs Tonight: An African Childhood. New York: Random House, 2003. Print. Memoir of the author’s childhood in colonial Rhodesia. Rogers, Douglas. The Last Resort: A Memoir of Zimbabwe. New York: Crown, 2009. Print. Memoir of life in Zimbabwe under Robert Mugabe’s dictatorship.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Nancy Dziedzic
Works Cited
Habila, Helon. “In Time of War.” Guardian [London], 4 Nov. 2006. Web. 3 Oct. 2010.
174
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Book Thief By Markus Zusak
W Introduction
W Literary and Historical
Markus Zusak’s The Book Thief takes place during World War II, in the town of Molching, in Germany. Narrated by Death, the work explores the life of a young girl, Liesel Meminger, and her efforts to adjust to life with her new foster family. As the reader learns over the course of the novel, Liesel’s own family was splintered when her father, accused of being a Communist, disappeared. Her mother struggled to raise Liesel and her brother, but fearing for her family’s safety as Hitler gains power, Liesel’s mother decides her children will be safer in the hands of a German family not scarred by labels and accusations. In the course of the journey, Liesel’s brother, Werner, dies. At his grave site, Liesel picks up a book the young grave digger has dropped. This becomes the first incident in Liesel’s long history of book thievery. Throughout the novel, Liesel grows to love her foster parents, particularly, her foster Papa, Hans Hubermann. She makes friends, notably with Rudy Steiner. Liesel’s Papa, however, has a dangerous association in his past. His life was saved by another German soldier in World War I, a German who happened also to be Jewish. Now, as the Nazis have targeted Jews as the enemies of Germany, Hans’s dead friend’s son has come to Hans for help. Max Vanderburg is subsequently hidden in the Hubermanns’ basement. Eventually, a tender friendship grows between Max and Liesel. The war wages on. Max must leave when Hans’s kindness to a Jewish man being marched to a concentration camp is observed by Nazi authorities. Hans himself is forced into service in the Nazi army. He returns safely however, but Liesel’s joy in her father’s return is shortlived. Soon, her street is bombed by Allied forces. Writing in her basement during the night of the bombing, Liesel alone of all her loved ones survives.
Set during World War II, Zusak’s novel is told from a modern, or rather, timeless perspective. Narrated by Death, the work is contemporary in terms of Zusak’s experimentation with nonlinear narration and in terms of his choice of the mythic character of Death as the commentator on the novel’s characters and action. While Death is clearly looking back on events that have already occurred, the story itself unfolds within the time frame of the war, and the characters—unlike Death—do not speak in the present-day vernacular. The action of the book takes place almost entirely within the German town of Molching, beginning in 1939. Himmel Street becomes a microcosm for the tensions playing out in larger German cities and all over the country. Adolf Hitler had risen to power in the aftermath of World War I, advocating a strongly nationalistic philosophy as the only means of rebuilding a strong Germany. He sought to restore territories lost during World War I. In 1938 he invaded Austria, and in 1939 Czechoslovakia. After signing a nonaggression pact with the Soviet Union regarding Poland, Hitler proceeded to invade Poland, an act that brought Britain, France, Australia, and New Zealand into the war. Throughout the war, the Nazi government transported enemies of the state to various concentration camps. Forced labor camps established in the early 1930s detained Communists and other political dissidents, as well as those deemed socially “deviant,” including homosexuals. Later, following the invasions of Austria, Czechoslovakia, and Poland, the Nazis imprisoned and murdered Jews from Germany and all its newly occupied regions. As the war wore on, prisoners of war were also incarcerated. If not outright murdered, many of these individuals died of mistreatment, exposure, disease, or starvation. According to United States Holocaust Memorial Museum
Context
175 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Book Thief
MAJOR CHARACTERS DEATH is the omniscient, first-person narrator of The Book Thief. He shows himself to be gentle, scooping up souls when their bodies expire and transporting them to their eternity. He sees much of the world in terms of color, and describes his impressions in a highly poetic manner, although his style of narration is rather conversational. Death is attracted to Liesel’s story, and although he does not explicitly state why, his commentary suggests that he is drawn to Liesel not just because of her goodness, but because her goodness stands in such stark contrast, and eventually in such blatant opposition to Hitler’s evilness. Death is as moved to despair by Hitler’s treatment of the Jews as any modern reader. Thinking of the souls he collects, of the countless Jewish people who have died in concentration camps, Death describes how he tries to “de-realize” what has happened. He observes the way he mentions the name of God “in a futile attempt to understand.” In the end, Death’s perspective on the human race is that he remains “haunted by humans.” ILSA HERMANN is the wife of the mayor of Molching. Ilsa witnesses Liesel rescuing a book from the pile of Jewish books being burned in a Nazi book-burning rally. Ilsa later, however mutely, shares with Liesel her secret library. HANS HUBERMANN is Liesel’s foster father. Where his wife Rosa is harsh, Hans is gentle. He tenderly coaxes Liesel out of her shell of grief after she loses both her brother (to death) and her mother (after being abandoned by her). Hans teaches Liesel to read from her stolen books and comforts her when she wakes from her nightmares. He is compelled by a sense of duty and guilt to shelter the son of the man who saved his life in World War I. After an act of compassion for a Jewish man being made to parade through the streets of Molching with his fellows, Hans is subsequently sent off to war. He returns home with only a broken leg, but is killed shortly afterward when Himmel Street is bombed. ROSA HUBERMANN is Liesel’s foster mother. She is also the mother of a son and a daughter who are older and
documentation, between 1933 and 1945, Nazi Germany created twenty thousand concentration camps and incarcerated millions of individuals. Approximately three million Jews were killed in camps specifically constructed for their extermination. In 1945 the Allied forces liberated the prisoners in concentration camps, yet many were too ill or weakened by disease or starvation to survive.
176
make only brief appearances in the story. Despite her rough and sometimes cruel treatment of Liesel, Rosa loves her, and this emotion is brought to the fore after the Hubermanns begin hiding Max Vanderburg in their basement. LIESEL MEMINGER is the story’s protagonist. Given up by her mother, Liesel is forced into a foster home with her brother, yet her brother does not survive the journey there. Liesel is welcomed by Hans Hubermann and, less affectionately, his wife. In contemplating her life and the state of affairs in Germany, Liesel grows increasingly defiant. As she begins to devote herself to Max Vanderburg’s safety, consoling him and helping him in any way she can, Liesel begins to hate Hitler and what he has done to Germany and to the people she loves. Liesel is comforted by words and books, and stealing books for her becomes a way to soothe the emotional trauma she continues to suffer. PAULA MEMINGER is Liesel’s mother. It is suggested in the course of the novel that her poverty, combined with her status as the wife of a suspected Communist, compels her to seek a foster family to care for her two children. WERNER MEMINGER is Liesel’s brother. His death and subsequent burial haunt Liesel for years, and also inspire her first act of book thievery. RUDY STEINER is a young boy who befriends Liesel shortly after she moves in with the Hubermanns. He becomes her accomplice on many occasions as they steal food or books. MAX VANDENBURG is the son of the man who saved Hans Hubermann’s life in World War I. When being Jewish becomes a dangerous thing in Germany, Max is aided by a friend who hides him and helps him reach Hans. Hans, indebted to Max’s father, welcomes Max into the Hubermann home, where life alters drastically as the family attempts to hide their secret and to help Max as best they can at the same time.
W Themes The Book Thief is a thematically rich novel in which Zusak explores a variety of war-related topics. One of the most salient themes of the work is summed up in the novel’s last line, when Death observes, “I am haunted by humans.” Much of the novel is devoted to the depiction of the inhumane treatment of human beings by fellow TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Book Thief
human beings. Hitler’s large-scale oppression of the Jews is only one example. Zusak takes pains to also depict a German citizenry sometimes reluctant and often vigorously opposed to Hitler’s beliefs and aims. The Nazis’ cruelty to anyone who hesitates to subscribe to Hitler’s message is seen in the way both Liesel’s and Rudy’s fathers are taken from their families, and in the way both Liesel and her father are whipped and beaten for approaching and helping Jewish prisoners as they are marched through town. Death, however, is equally mystified by the way human goodness manages to exist in a world that can also create a Hitler. Acts of goodness and sacrifice abound in the novel, beginning with the way Liesel’s mother is prepared to sacrifice her own ties to her children in order to protect them. Hans sacrifices his family’s safety to protect another man’s son, in acknowledgment of the way that man saved Hans’s own life. Liesel’s selflessness is revealed in her generosity and love toward Max, a man to whom she owes nothing, but with whom she feels a sense of shared pain and victimization. The mayor’s wife, plagued by her own
sorrows, climbs out of her grief to befriend Liesel and share with her a love of books and language. Liesel in turn shares this love of reading with her neighbors, comforting them in the darkness of the basement during air raids. The power of words is another of The Book Thief ’s main themes. Before Liesel can even read the words in a book, she is comforted by the very existence of the book itself. Learning to read is a journey she takes under Hans’s guidance, and consequently the act of reading is forever imprinted with a sense of comfort for Liesel. Through Max, Liesel learns that Hitler has used words to further his malevolent plans; Death also emphasizes the fact that Hitler has crafted Nazi Germany and the myth of German superiority through words. Words, therefore, reflect the dual nature of humanity, their inherent capacity for good and for evil inherent in humans—a nature that haunts Death.
W Style In The Book Thief, a novel acknowledged as a work intended for teens, Zusak employs a unique, omniscient first-person narrator: Death. Death tells Liesel’s story, and snippets of the stories of other characters as well. As a commentator on the action, Death additionally interrupts the narrative to make observations, or sometimes to tell the reader about the future events of a particular character’s life. Occasionally, Death will relate events involving a character’s death, but outside of the otherwise linear narrative of The Book Thief; Death then revisits the events leading up to the point already revealed. As the story continues, Death gradually conveys that much of what he is relating has been taken directly from the story Liesel will eventually write herself, The Book Thief. Furthermore, Death retains the habit of talking to the reader in a casual, conversational style, placing the superstructure of the narrative outside of the story’s historical context. Despite the obvious nature of the work as historical fiction, Zusak’s unconventional narrative style reaches out to its intended audience as it approaches a horrific period of world history in a voice that is both modern and sympathetic.
W Critical Reception
Set during World War II, The Book Thief follows a young German girl who develops a penchant for stealing books. Ksenia Palimski/ Shutterstock.com
The Book Thief, winner of numerous literary awards, was well received by critics upon its publication. Its style and careful yet ambitious treatment of its tragic subject matter are the focus of many assessments of the work. John Green in a 2006 review for the New York Times Book Review observes that in Australia, the book was marketed to adults, while in the United States it has been aimed at a teenage audience. Arguing that the work is appropriate for young adult readers, Green states that while some teenagers may find that the story begins sluggishly, it is a book with the potential to be “life-changing.” He finds that young readers need to be exposed to “alternatives to
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
177
The Book Thief
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Markus Zusak was born in Sydney, Australia in 1975 to workingclass immigrant parents, his mother being German and his father Austrian. Having worked as a janitor and a high school English teacher, Zusak published his first novel, The Underdog, in Australia in 1999. Subsequent works gradually received increasing critical attention. His 2002 novel, I Am the Messenger, published in the United States in 2005, won Zusak a Michael L. Printz Honor. The work was additionally nominated for the Los Angeles Times Book Prize. His most commercially and critically successful work to date, The Book Thief was published in 2006. Zusak’s next novel is a coming-of-age story titled Bridge of Clay, slated for a 2011 release by Knopf.
ideological rigidity” and to “explorations of how stories matter.” Hazel Rochman, in a 2006 review for Booklist, maintains that despite the excessive shifting from the past to the present in the story’s narration, the work is a “powerful story.” In an unsigned 2006 Kirkus Reviews assessment, the critic describes Zusak’s writing as “elegant, philosophical and moving.” Claire Rosser, in a 2007 review of The Book Thief for the journal Kliatt, comments on the ways in which Zusak’s novel challenges the boundaries within which young adult novels are typically inscribed. In assessing The Book Thief for a 2007 review for the Guardian, Philip Ardagh comments on the way the book has been marketed in some countries as a teen novel, and in others as a work for adults. Ardagh finds it appropriate for both audiences, and he praises Zusak’s adroit characterization and story telling. Ardagh finds the work “a novel of breathtaking scope, masterfully told.”
“Zusak, Markus: The Book Thief.” Kirkus Reviews 74.2 (15 Jan. 2006): 91. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Rev. of The Book Thief, by Markus Zusak. Coventry Evening Telegraph 30 Dec. 2006: 33. Print. The critic praises Zusak’s novel for its thematic complexity and the “elegant, haunting” quality of Zusak’s writing. Brace, Marianne. “Forget the Scythe: Death Needs a Mop.” Independent on Sunday 31 Dec. 2006. HighBeam Research. Web. 28 Sept. 2010. Brace applauds Zusak’s characterization, particularly his depiction of Liesel and Death, and commends the work as a whole. Humphreys, Simon. Rev. of The Book Thief, by Markus Zusak. Mail on Sunday 4 Mar. 2007: 73. Print. Humphreys offers a largely favorable review of Zusak’s novel, praising the author’s prose and ability to move the reader, while faulting the narrator (Death) for a tone that is sometimes grating. Gale Resources
“The Book Thief.” Literary Newsmakers for Students. Ed. Anne Marie Hacht. Vol. 3. Detroit: Gale, 2009: 41-63. Print. Gale Virtual Reference Library. Web. 28 Sept. 2010. “Markus Zusak.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Also covered in Contemporary Authors. Vol. 223. Detroit: Gale, 2004: 451-52. Print. Open Web Sources
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Ardagh, Philip. “It’s a Steal.” Guardian 6 Jan. 2007. guardian.co.uk. Web. 28 Sept. 2010. Green, John. “Fighting for Their Lives.” New York Times Book Review 14 May 2006: 26. Print. “Holocaust Encyclopedia.” United States Holocaust Memorial Museum. Web. 28 Sept. 2010. Print. Maughan, Shannon. “It’s a Wonderful (Sales) Life: The Staying Power of The Book Thief.” Publishers Weekly 257.34 (30 Aug. 2010): 16. Print. Rochman, Hazel. “Zusak, Markus. The Book Thief.” Booklist 102.9-10 (1 Jan. 2006): 88. Literature Resource Center. Web. 28 Sept. 2010. Rosser, Claire. “Zusak, Markus. The Book Thief.” Kliatt 40.2 (Mar. 2006): 19. High Beam Research. Web. 28 Sept. 2010.
178
“Zusak, Markus.” Contemporary Authors New Revision Series. Ed. Amanda D. Sams. Vol. 163. Detroit: Gale, 2008: 420-23. Gale Virtual Reference Library. Web. 28 Sept. 2010.
Random House’s author website for Markus Zusak features information about the author, reviews, bibliography, and discussion forums. http//www. randomhouse.com/features/markuszusak/ The BBC covers the history of the world wars on its website and features a section on the Holocaust. Included is an interactive timeline, interactive maps, and links to essays on various related topics. http// www.bbc.co.uk/history/worldwars/genocide/ For Further Reading
Nees, Greg. Germany: Unraveling the Enigma. Boston: Intercultural Press, 1999. Print. After reviewing modern German history, Nees analyzes German cultural themes and stereotypes, exploring such topics as the German sense of duty and responsibility, and the German desire for order and security TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Book Thief
Spinelli, Jerry. Milkweed. New York: Knopf Books for Young Readers, 2003. Print. Spinelli’s novel is, like The Book Thief, a young adult novel focused on World War II. It takes place in Nazi-occupied Warsaw and is told from the point of view of a poor young boy uncertain of his heritage. Wistrich, Robert Solomon. Hitler and the Holocaust. New York: Modern Library, 2001. Print. Wistrich, a professor of modern Jewish history, explores the forces contributing to the anti-Semitism that
Hitler capitalized on in the years leading up to World War II. The author then goes on to trace the history of the Holocaust during the war years. Zusak, Markus. I Am the Messenger. New York: Knopf, 2005. Print. Originally published in Australia in 2002, Zusak’s young adult novel centers around a nineteenyear-old cab driver whose life alters completely after he stops a bank robbery.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Catherine Dominic
179
The Bottoms By Joe R. Lansdale
W Introduction The Bottoms (2000) is a work of literary detective fiction by the noted mystery and science fiction writer Joe R. Lansdale. The story is narrated in the present day by the elderly Harry Collins, who describes a chain of traumatic happenings from his childhood in East Texas in the 1930s. The series of events unfolds when Harry and his sister Thomasina, (known as Tom), discover the mutilated body of an African American prostitute in the woods near their home. Their father, the community’s constable, investigates the crime, motivated by a desire for justice. His investigation is impeded by citizens who feel that African American deaths are not worth investigating and by Ku Klux Klan members who brand him a “nigger lover” and threaten his family. As the murders continue, Harry is forced to come to terms with the brutality and injustice of the world in which he lives. The work has been praised for its re-creation of the dialect and racial politics of 1930s, Texas, as well as for its coming-of-age narrative. It won the 2001 Edgar Award for Best Mystery Novel and helped to bring Lansdale to the attention of a broader readership.
W Literary and Historical Context
The central story of The Bottoms takes place in East Texas during the Great Depression, a period of economic strife that gripped the country beginning in 1929. During this era unemployment reached a record high, while incomes and prices fell dramatically. Many people were forced to turn to soup kitchens and breadlines for food. Others traveled the country with their families, desperately seeking work. While the national economy began to show signs of improvement by 1933, it did not fully recover for more than a decade. The novel opens with Harry’s reflection on the period: “I suppose there was
some back then had money, but we weren’t among them. The Depression was on.” Later in the novel, Harry’s grandmother arrives from North Texas with stories of the Dust Bowl, the brutal dust storms that destroyed farmland in Texas, Oklahoma, and beyond, compounding the problems of the Depression by destroying the crops and livelihood of farmers and farmworkers. Lansdale’s novel also dramatizes the racial bigotry and violence that were prevalent in the South during the 1930s. The Ku Klux Klan, which had died out shortly after the Civil War, remerged in 1915, with membership reaching a peak in the 1920s. It was during this second wave of popularity that the Klan adopted the burning cross as a symbol. Although membership was beginning to die out nationally in the 1930s, when Lansdale’s story takes place, the Klan was still active around the country, particularly in the Midwest and the South. In the novel members of the Klan attempt to dissuade Harry’s father from investigating the murders of black prostitutes. Later they burn a cross in the Collins’s yard and lynch an innocent, elderly African American man for the crimes.
W Themes Racial injustice permeates the fictional world of The Bottoms and is the central theme of the novel. While characters such as Harry’s father and grandmother have developed progressive views that lead them to view African Americans as equals, the majority of people in their community seek to keep the two races segregated, threatening abuse or death to those who cross racial boundaries. The white mill manager, Pappy Treesome, is repeatedly attacked by the Ku Klux Klan because he has married an African American woman, and his mentally handicapped son is castrated and burned to death for exposing himself to a white woman. When Jacob begins to investigate the murders of African American prostitutes, he is warned off by his former friend, Red Woodrow, who tells him, “It’s known far and wide all
180 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Bottoms
over this country you’re a nigger lover, and you ain’t careful you’re gonna bring up another generation of them nigger lovers, and some folks around here have all the nigger lovin’ they want.” Lost innocence is another prevalent theme in The Bottoms. At the beginning of the novel, Harry’s biggest concerns are that his wounded dog might have to be put down or that the Goat Man, a monstrous creature from an old wives’ tale, haunts the woods near his home. He and his sister feel comfortable roaming the woods and befriending all of their neighbors, black and white, without any fear of repercussions. Over the course of the novel, however, Harry and Tom are changed indelibly by events in their community. Toward the end of the narrative, Harry reflects on his former innocence: “Just a short time before I had been a happy kid with no worries. I didn’t even know it was the Depression, let alone that there were murderers outside of the magazines that I read down at the barbershop.” Within a relatively short time, however, the boy is awakened to the realities of hatred and cruelty as he finds a murder victim and witnesses, in rapid succession, an autopsy, a lynching, and an assault on his young sister.
W Style The Bottoms is narrated in the first person by Harry Collins, who is looking back on the events of his childhood more than seventy years later. His voice re-creates the dialect of his childhood (“I just soon I didn’t see nothing like it again, and I sure hate Harry and Tom seen it.”). The most extreme example of this dialect comes from the toothless Pappy Treesome (“Dey zay ooo god u ded gul in duh eyezouse, cozdabull.”). Lansdale also plays with figurative language, creating colorful metaphors that reflect Southern life. As Steve Jelbert notes in his Times review of the novel, the author is “never afraid to stretch a curious metaphor to within an inch of its cotton-picking life.” Largely because of its similar treatment of racial violence, Lansdale’s novel has frequently been compared to Harper Lee’s 1960 novel To Kill a Mockingbird. Also set during the Great Depression, Lee’s novel is the story of a young brother and sister whose father is appointed to defend an innocent black man accused of raping a white woman. The novel includes a near lynching and a wrongful conviction. Like Lee’s novel, The Bottoms is a bildingsroman, or a novel that traces a character’s coming-of-age. Traditionally the protagonists of such novels mature through emotionally painful experiences that force them to seek a better understanding of the world. In Lansdale’s novel Harry must grapple with the trauma of discovering a body and the racial violence that ensues. He is forced to give up his childhood belief in a fictitious monster, the Goat Man, and come to terms instead with the capacity of his fellow human beings for
MAJOR CHARACTERS GRANDMA is Harry and Tom’s maternal grandmother. She comes to live with the family after the death of her husband and helps to investigate the murders. MISS MAGGIE is an elderly African American woman who is known as the longtime companion of Red Woodrow’s father. She is later revealed to be Red’s mother. She is murdered by Red after he learns the truth of his parentage. MOSE is an elderly black man who briefly falls under suspicion in the murders. After he is lynched, his innocence is proven. Known to have had some white blood, he is revealed to be the biological father of Red Woodrow. TELLY is Mose’s mentally handicapped son. He has been living in the woods and is mistaken by the children for the Goat Man. He witnesses Cecil abducting Tom and leads Harry to her. He is killed rescuing the children, but he kills Cecil in the process. CECIL CHAMBERS is a World War I veteran and barber who works for Harry’s father. After he kidnaps and abuses Tom, he is revealed to be the serial killer. He is killed by Telly. HARRY COLLINS is the narrator of the story. He helps to investigate the murders after his father sinks into depression and alcoholism. JACOB COLLINS is the father of Harry and Tom. He is a farmer and barber and the local constable. He falls into depression and alcoholism after he cannot prevent the lynching of Mose. After a popular white woman is murdered, proving Mose’s innocence, Jacob vows to give up alcohol. THOMASINA “TOM” COLLINS is Harry’s younger sister. She is kidnapped and molested by Cecil Chambers, but she is rescued after Telly witnesses the abduction and warns Harry. RED WOODROW is an old friend of Jacob. The men’s friendship ended in rivalry for Harry’s mother. A staunch racist, Red is unable to handle the knowledge that both of his biological parents were of African American descent. After carving the word nigger in his chest, he covers himself in tar and hangs himself.
monstrosity. Over the course of the novel, he receives an education in sexual perversion, bigotry, and violence and discovers that even his parents have secrets. “I had learned too,” he explains, “that the people I knew, or thought I knew, had problems and lives. Mama and Daddy had a past.” These discoveries are so earthshattering, he reveals, that “I wouldn’t have been surprised right then to discover the moon could be reached by climbing to the top of the highest tree, and with a good pair of scissors you could snip it in half.”
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
181
The Bottoms
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Joe R. Lansdale was born on October 28, 1951, in Gladewater, Texas. After studying at the University of Texas at Austin and at Stephen F. Austin State University, he held a number of jobs that included stints as a factory worker and ditch digger before devoting himself full time to writing beginning in 1981. His first mystery novel, Act of Love, was published that same year. Over the next two decades Lansdale published more than thirty books, including a popular mystery series featuring the detectives Hap Collins and Leonard Pine, and several volumes of short fiction. In addition to the Edgar Award for The Bottoms, Lansdale’s work has garnered six Bram Stoker Awards from the Horror Writers of America, and an American Mystery Award. During the 1990s Lansdale wrote screenplays for Batman: The Animated Series. He lives in Nacogdoches, Texas, where he continues to write novels in the mystery, horror, and science fiction genres.
W Critical Reception Upon its publication in 2000, The Bottoms was met with critical accolades. In addition to receiving the Edgar Award, the book was nominated for a Dashiell Hammett Award for Best Novel and for the Mystery Readers International’s 2001 Macavity Award for Best Mystery Novel. While these awards recognized Lansdale’s achievements in the mystery genre, many reviewers have noted that the power of the novel’s social commentary and the literary quality of its prose elevate it beyond the confines of the mystery genre, making it appealing to a wider audience of readers. In his Booklist review of The Bottoms, Les Lukowsky praises the novel by noting, “Effectively combining mystery and family history, it offers a vivid, multifaceted glimpse back to a simpler, but not necessarily better, time.” He goes on to suggest that the novel represents Lansdale’s transcendence of the mystery genre, asserting that “if any author ever deserved a breakthrough book, it’s Lansdale. This should be it.”
An aging narrator, Harry Collins, recalls a childhood story of racial violence and the Ku Klux Klan in The Bottoms. Popperfoto/Getty Images
182
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Bottoms
Not all assessments of the novel have been wholly positive, however. In his review of the novel in the London Times, Edward Clark comments that “while Lansdale’s depiction of life in America’s Deep South during the Thirties is compelling, he often lapses into cliche, sentimentality and a certain unintentional burlesque.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Clark, Edward. “New Paperbacks.” Rev. of The Bottoms, by Joe R. Lansdale. Times [London] 25 Nov. 2000: n. pag. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 15 Aug. 2010. Jelbert, Steve. “Fiction.” Rev. of The Bottoms, by Joe R. Lansdale. Times [London] 11 Aug. 2001: n. pag. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 15 Aug. 2010. Lansdale, Joe R. The Bottoms. New York: Mysterious Press, 2000. Print. Lukowsky, Les. Rev. of The Bottoms, by Joe R. Lansdale. Booklist 1 June 2000: 1798. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
De Lint, Charles. Rev. of The Bottoms, by Joe R. Lansdale. Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction Jan. 2001: 24. Offers an overview of The Bottoms and compares it to Lansdale’s earlier novel The Boar (1998). Julian, Janet. Rev. of The Bottoms, by Joe R. Lansdale. Kliatt July 2002: 49. Recommends Lansdale’s novel for its strong narration and its treatment of sensitive social issues. Knight, Bill. Rev. of The Bottoms, by Joe R. Lansdale. Magill Book Reviews (2001): n. pag. Academic Search Premier. EBSCO. Web. 15 Aug. 2010. Praises Lansdale for his attention to detail and his development of the novel’s characters. Lunn, Bob. Rev. of The Bottoms, by Joe R. Lansdale. Library Journal Aug. 2000: 158. Likens The Bottoms to works by William Faulkner and Harper Lee. Stasio, Marilyn. Rev. of The Bottoms, by Joe R. Lansdale. New York Times 24 Sept. 2000: 29. Print. Favorably reviews the novel, emphasizing its outlook on Southern life and race relations. Gale Resources
Group, 2000. 79-82. Gale, Cengage Learning Trial Site. Gale. Something about the Author Online. 13 Aug. 2010. Open Web Sources
The author’s official Web site includes a biography, a bibliography of his work, and the full text of select short stories. http//www.joerlansdale.com/ The Web site of the University of Missouri-Kansas City School of Law brings together information about lynching in the United States, providing historical context and statistics. http//www.law.umkc.edu/ faculty/projects/ftrials/shipp/lynchstats.html For Further Reading
Brundage, W. Fitzhugh. Under Sentence of Death: Lynching in the South. Chapel Hill: U of North Carolina P, 1997. Print. This collection of essays examines lynching from sociological and historical perspectives. Lansdale, Joe R. A Fine Dark Line. New York: Mysterious Press, 2003. Print. Set in 1958, Lansdale’s follow-up to The Bottoms tells the story of a thirteenyear-old boy who stumbles on a box of love letters tied to an unsolved double murder. Lee, Harper. To Kill a Mockingbird. Philadelphia: Lippincott, 1960. Print. The Bottoms has been compared to Lee’s classic coming-of-age novel about racial injustice. MacLean, Nancy. Behind the Mask of Chivalry: The Making of the Second Ku Klux Klan. New York: Oxford University Press, 1994. Print. MacLean chronicles the post-World War I resurgence of the Ku Klux Klan. Shlaes, Amity. The Forgotten Man: A New History of the Great Depression. New York: HarperCollins, 2007. Print. This book examines the Great Depression, emphasizing economics and politics as well as individuals’ experiences. Vronsky, Peter. Serial Killers: The Method and the Madness of Monsters. New York: Berkeley Books, 2004. Print. Vronsky investigates the phenomenon of serial killing in its historical, psychological, and cultural contexts.
“Joe R. Lansdale.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2009.
Greta Gard
“Joe R(ichard) Lansdale (1951-).” Something about the Author. Ed. Alan Hedblad. Vol. 116. Detroit: Gale
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
183
The Boy Next Door By Irene Sabatini
W Introduction The Boy Next Door is a story of forbidden love set in Zimbabwe in the chaotic days following the country’s 1980 independence from British rule. As the book follows the relationship between a white man and a “colored” woman over the course of almost twenty years, The Boy Next Door also chronicles the racial, ethnic, and political turmoil that descended upon the country following the heady days of excitement that greeted black majority rule and Robert Mugabe’s appointment as prime minister. The main characters of The Boy Next Door are Ian McKenzie, a seventeen-year-old white “Rhodie” of British descent recently convicted of setting his stepmother on fire, and his naive and studious fourteen-year-old neighbor, Lindiwe Bishop, who becomes obsessed with the facts of the crime—and with Ian, following his mysterious release from prison some eighteen months later. Warned by her upwardly mobile parents, a black mother and white father, to stay away from Ian, Lindiwe nevertheless develops a secret bond with him that matures into love as their lives are taken in many different directions by the turbulent political situation in Zimbabwe. The Boy Next Door received the Orange Prize for New Writers, an important international prize for women’s fiction. In conferring the honor on the novel, Di Spiers, the chair of judges, remarked, “At heart a love story, it is also so much more as, through the experiences of its charismatic protagonists, it charts the first two decades of the emerging Zimbabwe with honesty, humour and humanity” (author’s website).
W Literary and Historical Context
The Boy Next Door recalls the Zimbabwe of author Irene Sabatini’s youth. She was raised in southern Zimbabwe in the country’s second-largest city, Bulawayo, the setting of
much of the novel. In an interview with Belinda Otas, Sabatini explained that the novel originated in the conflux of two circumstances: her publisher’s request for a memoir about Zimbabwe in the time of independence and a phone call from her father, still living in her childhood home in Bulawayo, telling her that the house next door had burned. Then, about a year after this phone call, Sabatini told Otas, the first line of the novel came to her, “Two days after I turned fourteen the son of our neighbor set his stepmother alight.” The Boy Next Door is divided into four parts which chronicle the developing relationship of Lindiwe and Ian as well as the deterioration of Zimbabwe, once heralded as a model of African democracy. Part 1 occurs in the 1980s as the country attempts to adjust to the transformation to black majority rule. Lindiwe and her family are the first blacks to settle in their Bulawayo neighborhood after integration. Her parents’ mixed marriage would have been forbidden in the former Rhodesia. Lindiwe is light-skinned but considered “colored.” She is an excellent student but is taunted by racial slurs at the mostly white school her parents insist she attend. Ian, on the other hand, is a brash and bold high school dropout, still possessed of the elitist attitude of the white ruling class, though the McKenzies are the last remaining whites on the street. The two protagonists develop a friendship against a backdrop of widespread terror as Matabeleland (southern Zimbabwe) is occupied by a brigade of North Korean soldiers sent to crush any rebellion from ethnic Ndebele opposing the nationalist government of Robert Mugabe, who is backed by the Shona majority in the north. The succeeding parts of the novel find Ian and Lindiwe separated for many years as Lindiwe attends school—as did the author—in the northern city of Harare, and Ian takes his photojournalism career to South Africa. In the years before and after they reunite, the government of Mugabe further disintegrates with ethnic and racial riots, corruption among political leaders
184 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Boy Next Door
and the military, and economic devastation. Terror reigns as thousands are killed in violence that erupts between warring black factions and between whites and blacks, and as Mugabe’s plan to redistribute the land owned by the whites comes to involve intimidation and murder. Additionally, South African rebels seek to destabilize the new democracy.
W Themes Amy Virshup wrote in the New York Times of Lindiwe and Ian, “Their shared status as outsiders brings them together in this novel about love, family, and what it means to be African.” These themes—love, family, and identity—emanate from the intersection of private lives and public events. In a video interview on the author’s website, Sabatini described the plot as hinging on the threatened love affair of Ian and Lindiwe: “The question throughout the novel, that the novel asks, is, will they manage to keep this connection despite all the trauma and drama that is happening all around them?” The “trauma and drama” is political as well as personal. Aside from their difference in color, complicated by the everwidening racial divide that accompanies Mugabe’s rule, there are their diverse family backgrounds and the continuing threat posed by Lindiwe’s parents to their union. Added to that are the killings and torture of innocent people happening almost daily around them as Mugabe’s regime becomes increasingly dictatorial. Because of the volatility of the situation, a writer for Kirkus Reviews noted, Sabatini “never manages to convince us of the durability of the lovers’ relationship, which is key.” Sabatini said in the interview with Otas that she also hoped to show the affirmative side of independence in the form of the influx of people from all over the world into Zimbabwe just after liberation: “I guess one of the most important stories that I wanted to convey . . . is just how multicultural it was. There was such a heady mix of nationalities: young people, full of energy and good will . . . to help this new nation find its feet. Zimbabwe was going to be a socialist paradise. . . . There was Black, White, Coloured, Asian, Shona, Ndebele . . . and the rest of the world, all squashed up against each other in this (previously) isolated land-locked country.” But Sabatini also admitted that this spirit of optimism existed mostly in the north and drew international attention away from the brutal massacres occurring to the south in Matabeleland.
W Style In her interview with Otas, Sabatini described the style of The Boy Next Door as “stripped down,” designed to highlight the emotional intensity of the story unburdened by excessive description. The dialogue is colorful, consisting of a pastiche of untranslated Shona, Ndebele,
MAJOR CHARACTERS DADDY BISHOP is Lindiwe’s father, a white man who works in the Telecommunications Department of the post office. He is married to a black woman, Lindiwe’s mother, but is unfaithful, conducting an affair with their adopted daughter, Rosanna. LINDIWE BISHOP is one of two main characters. At the start of the novel, she is a shy fourteen-year-old girl fascinated by a crime that occurred at her neighbor’s house. As the novel progresses, she becomes romantically involved with the person accused of the crime, the young white boy who lives next door. Their love is threatened by family circumstance and deteriorating political conditions in Zimbabwe. MUMMY BISHOP is Lindiwe’s mother. At time goes on, she is trapped in a loveless marriage to Lindiwe’s white father. She is desperately opposed to Lindiwe’s involvement with Ian. DAVID MCKENZIE is the son of Lindiwe and Ian. IAN MCKENZIE is the other main character. He is the object of Lindiwe’s love, forced to confess to the crime of setting his stepmother on fire, imprisoned and then released. He has aspirations as a photojournalist and travels to South Africa when Lindiwe is away at school in the north of Zimbabwe. ROSANNA is the adopted daughter of Mummy and Daddy. Daddy fathers a child by her.
British English, Afrikaans (South African), and Zimbabwean street slang. The meaning of the language reveals itself slowly, just as Sabatini unveils the many secrets of the plot in gradual fashion, including Lindiwe’s admission to Ian after several years’ separation that they are the parents of a son, David. Other family secrets mysteriously unravel as well—the involvement of Ian’s father in the military campaign against independence, the mental illness of Ian’s stepmother, the fractured marriage of Lindiwe’s parents, and her father’s child by their adopted daughter, Rosanna. This personal drama seems disturbingly real because it is played out against a sharply realized historical backdrop Sabatini experienced firsthand.
W Critical Reception The Boy Next Door was published in several editions, including separate releases in the United States, Germany, Sweden, and Norway. Amanda Craig described its appeal for the London Independent: “What makes this novel so interesting is that it is a story about the difficulties of first love drawn against a vivid background of political change. We all know something of the sufferings of Zimbabweans, black and white, under
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
185
The Boy Next Door
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
United States, where it was greeted with limited, though mostly positive, reviews. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Irene Sabatini won the Orange Award for New Writers with her debut novel, The Boy Next Door (2009), which chronicles the secret love of a white man and a mixed-race woman set against the backdrop of Zimbabwe’s crumbling democracy in the 1980s and 1990s. Sabatini writes from firsthand experience in The Boy Next Door, having grown up in Bulawayo, in the south of Zimbabwe, where much of the novel takes place. She subsequently studied and traveled widely, in Colombia, the Caribbean, and Europe. She currently resides in Geneva, Switzerland.
Mugabe, but Sabatini shows the gradual collapse of her ‘country of eternal optimists’ with a hundred swift, sure touches and a rich cast of characters, heightening tension and mystery.” Elsewhere, Craig included The Boy Next Door among a list of deserving novels that had received almost no publicity in the United Kingdom (New Statesman). The situation was similar in the
Works Cited
Craig, Amanda. “Booked Up.” New Statesman 139.5008 (5 July 2010): 6. Literature Resource Center. Web. 20 Sept. 2010. ———. Rev. of The Boy Next Door, by Irene Sabatini. Independent (London) 29 June 2010. Web. 19 Sept. 2010. Otas, Belinda, and Irene Sabatini. “Irene Sabatini: My Interviews. In Conversation (June 2010).” Author website. Web. 19 Sept. 2010. “Sabatini, Irene: The Boy Next Door.” Kirkus Reviews, 15 Aug. 2009. Print. Spiers, Di. “Irene Sabatini: The Boy Next Door.” Author website. Web. 19 Sept. 2010. Virshup, Amy. Rev. of The Boy Next Door, by Irene Sabatini. New York Times 16 Sept. 2009. Web. 19 Sept. 2010.
Pedestrians walk through a busy intersection in Zimbabwe, the setting of the novel The Boy Next Door. ª Robert Fried / Alamy
186
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Boy Next Door Additional Resources
For Further Reading
Criticism and Reviews
Rev. of The Boy Next Door, by Irene Sabatini. Publishers Weekly 256.30 (27 July 2009): 39. Print. Provides a concise plot summary. Bush, Vanessa. “The Boy Next Door.” Booklist 106.2 (15 Sept. 2009): 28. Plot synopsis of what Bush calls a “beautifully written first novel.” McKay, Carla. “Out Now in Paperback.” Daily Mail [London] 2 July 2010. HighBeam Research. Web. 18 Sept. 2010. High praise for Sabatini, “a born writer,” and her debut novel, “a completely engrossing story.” Otas, Belinda. Rev. of The Boy Next Door, by Irene Sabatini. New African Woman no. 4 (2010): 98. Ethnic NewsWatch. ProQuest. Web. 20 Sept. 2010. Mostly favorable review commending the accuracy of Sabatini’s historical details and the book’s picture of a multicultural Zimbabwe in the early years of independence. Open Web Sources
The author’s website, http//www.irenesabatini.com/, includes biography, a reading guide to The Boy Next Door, print and audio interviews with the author, links to published and reader reviews, and a photo gallery of Bulawayo and other parts of Zimbabwe.
Barclay, Philip. Zimbabwe: Years of Hope and Despair. London: Bloomsbury, 2010. Print. Diplomat Barclay records his three-year stint in Zimbabwe working for the British Embassy. Barclay witnessed the scandal of the 2008 election, when Robert Mugabe used death squads to cling to power after he was voted out. Meldrum, Andrew. Where We Have Hope: A Memoir of Zimbabwe. London: Murray, 2004. Print. A journalist’s account of Zimbabwe’s failed promise chronicling the food riots, fuel shortages, inflation, and racial violence that followed independence. Meldrum was expelled from Zimbabwe after twenty years of exposing the corruption and terror of Robert Mugabe’s regime. Rogers, Douglas. The Last Resort: A Memoir of Zimbabwe. New York: Harmony Books, 2009. Print. A narrative of Zimbabwe by a journalist and travel writer who grew up there during the declining democracy of Robert Mugabe and his attempts to take over the land of the white people, including that of Rogers’s family.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Janet Mullane
187
Brandenburg Gate By Henry Porter
W Introduction
W Literary and Historical
Henry Porter’s novel Brandenburg (published in the United States as Brandenburg Gate) is the third in his series featuring the British secret service agent Robert Harland. Set in the weeks just before the fall of the Berlin Wall, this adventure is set in East Germany, where a former Stasi (East German secret police) agent has been called into service once again. Harland is the handler for the former Stasi agent, Rudolf Rosenharte, who is now working as an art historian in Dresden. They are asked to make contact with Rosenharte’s former lover, whom the Stasi believe has important intelligence. In order to ensure Rosenharte’s cooperation, the Stasi have taken Rosenharte’s twin brother Konrad prisoner. Although Rosenharte knows his lover is dead, he plays along with the Stasi’s plan to meet her in Italy, in order to buy his brother time. In Italy, Rosenharte is approached by British and American intelligence agents, who seek to place him back in East Germany as a double agent. The Westerners believe Rosenharte can help identify Islamic terrorists operating in East Germany. Rosenharte is aided by Ulrike Klaar, an anticommunist dissident with her own political agenda. Through the course of the novel, Rosenharte and Ulrike fall in love. Although Rosenharte’s prime objective is to free his brother from prison and protect his brother’s family, he is only marginally successful. His brother dies in prison, although his sister-in-law and nephews are safely relocated. At the novel’s conclusion, Rosenharte and Ulrike escape Stasi pursuers as the Brandenburg Gate opens and the Berlin Wall ceases to be an obstacle closing off East Germany from West Germany.
The Brandenburg Gate, built in the eighteenth century, became, along with the Berlin Wall, a postwar symbol of the division of Germany into two countries, East and West Germany. Germany and the city of Berlin were divided into two sectors at the end of World War II by the Allied powers—one portion was occupied by the United States, Great Britain, and France, and the other portion by the Soviet Union. In the postwar years, the relationship between the Soviets and the Western nations began to erode. The year 1949 saw a further reorganization of Germany. The zones occupied by the United States, Great Britain, and France united to form the Federal Republic of West Germany, while the Soviet zone became the German Democratic Republic. Although Berlin was entirely within the Soviet zone, as part of the peace negotiation, the city, like the country, had to be divided among the Allied forces. West Berlin retained the democratic nature of its occupying forces, while East Berlin was under Communist rule. The economies of the two Germanies developed along radically different paths—capitalist versus communist—and by the 1950s, many East Germans were fleeing to the more prosperous West Germany. The Berlin Wall was erected in 1961 to stem this flow, although communist East Germany claimed the wall was erected as a means of protecting the East Germans from Western influence. The Brandenburg Gate was in the Soviet sector of what was now East Berlin and was incorporated into the Berlin Wall. In 1961, the Brandenburg Gate, once a point of passage, was closed, and heavily guarded, to prevent any East Germans from leaving the country via that route. Escape attempts often ended in death. In the late 1980s, Soviet,
Context
188 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Brandenburg Gate
MAJOR CHARACTERS COLONEL OTTO BIERMEIER works for the Stasi Main Directorate for foreign intelligence, and is Rosenharte’s direct contact to the Stasi for much of the novel. Biermeier and Ulrike work together to draw Rosenharte back into the Stasi’s web. KURT BLAST, who later reveals his former name to have been Hans-Joseph Huch, is an East German who helps Rosenharte rescue Ulrike from prison. ROBERT HARLAND is the British agent who seeks Rosenharte’s cooperation in obtaining information about an Arab terrorist. He is Porter’s recurring character. Depicted as intelligent and sympathetic, Harland aids Rosenharte, Ulrike, and Kurt in their escape from the Stasi at the novel’s end. JESSIE is the name of the British agent who becomes the second Annalise Schering. Although purportedly working to gather information from Ulrike Klaar for the British, she and Ulrike are both members of the peace movement. ULRIKE KLAAR is an East German agent, known to the British agents as Kafka, who is passing information about the East Germans to the West. She also possesses ties to an Arab terrorist, and is a committed member of the peace movement. Her conflicting loyalties become the subject of the increasing fascination of Rosenharte, with whom Ulrike falls in love. Ulrike explains to Rosenharte that she and Biermeier used Konrad as a pawn, getting him imprisoned, in
Eastern bloc nations began to lose their powerful grip on the region. Civil unrest in Poland and Hungary contributed to the decision of the East German government to lift restrictions on travel between East and West Germany in 1989. The Brandenburg Gate was opened, and soon the Berlin Wall was dismantled. East and West Germany were officially reunited in 1990.
W Themes Organized around the theme of the failure of communism, Porter’s novel is focused on the political intrigue generated by the shifting balance of power in Europe. Although the story centers sympathetically on the East German Rosenharte, Porter’s approach is clearly biased toward the West, and Western values. Although Rosenharte was once a Stasi agent himself, he becomes a pawn of his government, and a victim in the sense that his own life is at risk, as are the lives of his family members. His brother’s death comes at the hands of his Stasi captors. Some critics have commented on Porter’s obvious favoring of the British
order to involve Rosenharte, claiming that Rosenharte was needed as a reliable “intermediary” who could get the information to the West about the Arab terrorist movements. KONRAD ROSENHARTE is Rudolf Rosenharte’s brother. He is described as a filmmaker, and a political dissident. Imprisoned ostensibly for his radical behavior, he in fact is being used by Klaar and Biermeier, and the Stasi, in order to manipulate Rosenharte. RUDOLF ROSENHARTE is the story’s protagonist. A former Stasi agent, Rosenharte has extricated himself from the world of espionage and has become an art historian, living in Dresden. The Stasi, however, have another job for Rosenharte, and they have imprisoned his dissident filmmaker brother, Konrad, to encourage Rosenharte to do their bidding. ANNALISE SCHERING is Rosenharte’s former lover, whom he believes to be dead, but is said to be in Trieste, Italy, where Rosenharte is to meet her and gather the intelligence she is believed to possess. The woman he meets is someone who has adopted Annalise’s identity; later her identity as a British agent named Jessie is uncovered. COLONEL ZANK is the Stasi agent who pursues Rosenharte and Ulrike when it becomes clear they are a threat to German Democratic Republic. Zank is portrayed as cruel, and his character is a reflection of the oppression the East German regime.
in the novel. Phil Jacobson in a 2005 review for the Daily Mail states that Porter’s British agents are “onedimensional” but are shown to be “thoroughly decent types serving a noble cause.” Jacobson goes on to lament the lack of “moral ambivalence” regarding espionage that one is more likely to find in the novels of John le Carré. Likewise, Max Hastings, in a 2005 article for the Observer, states that Porter never doubts who “the good guys” are, and that while John le Carré’s novels are permeated with “a sense of moral equivalence between the two sides’ spies, Porter plainly admires Britain’s Secret Intelligence Service.” The failure of communism in the Eastern bloc countries, then, is set against the superiority of Western, and specifically, British politics and government. Rosenharte’s interest in Ulrike Klaar, who is aiding the British through her own espionage, underscores Porter’s themes. Ulrike is an outspoken dissident, a critic of the regime that rules East Germany, and an agitator who fuels the public outcry against the government. Rosenharte’s attraction to a resistance figure such as Ulrike clearly posits him on the democratic, Western side of the struggle that Porter depicts.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
189
Brandenburg Gate
The Brandenburg Gate in Berlin, Germany. The events of Brandenburg Gate take place in Berlin just before the fall of the Berlin Wall. Jeremy Reddington/Shutterstock.com
W Style Porter’s Brandenburg Gate, set in the recent past, is a tale of espionage and intrigue, a work placed within the genre of the political espionage thriller. A complex plot typical of the genre is layered with historical details surrounding the crumbling of the Soviet power in Eastern Europe. Porter’s novel is part of a trend observed by critic Andrew Taylor, in a 2005 review for Spectator. Taylor observes, “[T]he modern thriller has developed a retrogressive tendency and often looks for its inspiration to the past.” Brandenburg Gate is an example of this tendency to capitalize on the richness of the history of the Cold War era in order to craft a thriller with a suitable quantity of intrigue and villainy. As Porter explores the intricacies of espionage and counterespionage during this particular time and place, his straightforward prose provides the reader with the sense that while dense and intricate, the plot, with twists and turns provided by characters with a variety of motivations, may be unwound, deciphered. Porter’s style reflects his experience as a journalist. The third-person narrating voice conveys a deceptive aura of objectivity, yet Porter doles out the information needed to trace the
190
varying loyalties in the plot at his leisure in this work of over four hundred pages.
W Critical Reception Winner of the Crime Writers’ Association Ian Fleming Steel Dagger Award for 2005, Porter’s Brandenburg Gate has been widely praised a solid work of genre fiction. Matthew Lewin, in a 2005 review of Brandenburg Gate for the Guardian finds that Porter enriches the typical “tale of intrigue and deception, betrayal and retribution,” with a deeper examination of individual responses to such experiences. Lewin praises Porter’s exploration of how people “cope with the demands on their lives” wrought by such circumstances. Additionally, Lewin commends Porter’s “fascinating switchback rollercoaster of a plot.” In a 2006 review of Brandenburg Gate for the Observer, upon the occasion of the paperback version of the work being published, Sarah Hughes appreciates both the plotting and characterization, noting that “Porter spins a merry web involving British, American, Russia and East German spies in an ever more complicated dance, where no one, least of all TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Brandenburg Gate
the reader, is aware of who is really pulling the strings.” Hughes further comments that the East German characters’ complexities of emotion are also well detailed, as they balance their own “anti-west” socialism against the fact that “they rejected their own socialist state.” Other critics have harsher views of the characterization and style Porter uses. Philip Jacobson, in a 2005 review for the Daily Mail finds that the novel’s “main weakness lies in its generally unconvincing supporting cast.” The dialogue is also found to be occasionally inferior, according to Jacobson. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Burgan, Michael. The Berlin Wall: Barrier to Freedom. Minneapolis: Compass Point Books, 2008. Print. Hastings, Max. “A Brandenburg Concerto for Our Times.” Observer [London] 26 June 2005: 17. Print. guardian.co.uk. Web. 24 Aug. 2010.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Henry Porter was born in 1953, in Worcestershire, England. A political columnist for the Observer, Porter focuses his journalism on the issues of civil liberties and rights in Britain. In 1990 Porter married Liz Elliot; they have two daughters. Porter published his first novel, Remembrance Day, in 2000. This work was followed with the first in what has become a series of works featuring the British agent Robert Harland, A Spy’s Life, published in 2001. Two additional novels in this series have followed, including Brandenburg Gate, in 2005. In addition to publishing spy novels set in the past, Porter’s recent work, such as the 2009 The Dying Light, published in the United States in 2010 as The Bell Ringers, explores the England of the near future. Porter also works as the London editor of the New Yorkbased magazine Vanity Fair.
“Henry Porter.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2008.
Jacobson, Philip. “A Spy Goes Back into the Cold.” Daily Mail 8 July 2005: 58. Print. Questia. Web. 24 Aug. 2010.
Hughes, Sarah. “Paperback of the Week.” Observer [London] 12 Feb. 2006, Review Section: 27. Print. guardian.co.uk. Web. 24 Aug. 2010.
Lewin, Matthew. “After the Fall.” Guardian [London] 9 July 2005, Review Section: 27. Print. guardian.co.uk. Web. 24 Aug. 2010.
Germans flood through the recently fallen Berlin Wall. Brandenburg Gate is a spy thriller set in Germany that begins just weeks before the fall of the wall. ª Regis Bossu/Sygma/Corbis TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
191
Brandenburg Gate
Porter, Henry. Brandenburg Gate. London: Orion, 2005. Print. Taylor, Andrew. “In Search of Fresh Villains.” Spectator 298.9233 (23 July 2005): 39. Print.
Open Web Sources
Henry Porter’s author website offers biographical information, news on new releases, and a bibliography of Porter’s works. httpwww.henry-porter.com
Criticism and Reviews
Porter’s British publisher, Orion, offers a synopsis of Porter’s novel Brandenburg Gate. http//www.orion books.co.uk/books/brandenburg-paperback
Robson, David. “Double-Crossing Double Agents.” Sunday Telegraph 3 July 2005. Print. Telegraph.co.uk. Web. 24 Aug. 2010. Robson provides a brief but favorable review, commenting on the novel’s complex plot and large cast of duplicitous characters.
In its coverage of world history, the BBC contains the section “Mapping the Fall of Communism,” on its website. Text and graphics offer an overview of the pivotal events in Eastern Europe leading to the fall of Communism. http//news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/8347035.stm
Additional Resources
Sutton, Henry. “High Spy.” Mirror 17 June 2005. Print. HighBeam Research. Web. 24 Aug. 2010. Sutton praises Porter’s Brandenburg Gate for its intricacies, and delights in Porter’s choice in setting the novel in Europe during the Cold War. Terpening, Ronnie H. Rev. of Brandenburg Gate, by Henry Porter. Library Journal 131.4 (1 Mar. 2006): 79. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 21 Sept. 2010. Terpening commends the well-researched nature of Brandenburg Gate and praises the richness of Porter’s characterizations. Wright, David. Rev. of Brandenburg Gate, by Henry Porter. Booklist 102.13 (1 Mar. 2006): 74. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 21 Sept. 2010. Wright suggests that while Brandenburg Gate could be characterized as overly complex, the plot is intriguing. Gale Resources
“Porter, Henry.” Contemporary Authors. Ed. Amy Elisabeth Fuller. Vol. 273. Detroit: Gale, 2008: 32224. Print. Gale Virtual Reference Library. Web. 24 Aug. 2010.
192
For Further Reading
Funder, Anna. Stasiland: Stories from behind the Berlin Wall. London: Granta Books, 2003. Print. In this collection of stories, Funder relates from the perspective of East German citizens the challenges and sufferings endured by those who lived inside the oppressive republic. Greenstreet, Rosanna. “Q & A: Henry Porter, Writer and Journalist.” Guardian [London] 29 Aug. 2009, Weekend Section: 11. Print. guardian.co.uk. Web. 24 Aug. 2010. Greenstreet provides a brief interview with Porter about his interests and personal life. Porter, Henry. The Dying Light. London: Orion, 2009. Print. Published in the U.S. as The Bell Ringers by Atlantic Monthly Press in 2010, Porter’s novel is set in the near future in an England envisioned by Porter as a police state. ———. “Why I Write about the Surveillance State.” Independent [London] 7 Aug. 2009. independent.co. uk. Web. 24 Aug. 2010. Porter discusses his exploration of the world of espionage in his fiction, and the way his work as a journalist has provided insights into this world. Catherine Dominic
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Breath By Tim Winton
W Introduction Tim Winton’s eighth novel, Breath (2008), is a coming-ofage story. The plot follows the narrator, Bruce Pike, from age twelve to fifteen. His friend, Loonie, is a year older and considerably wilder. Pike’s parents are in the dark about his activities, and Loonie’s bar-owning father does not care. Together, the boys discover surfing and a famous but aging expert, Sando, who tutors them in the sport. They compete for Sando’s attention and take on increasingly dangerous challenges. Eventually, Loonie and Sando go off on a surfing trip, leaving Pike to become sexually entangled with Sando’s wife and needing to make a decision about where his life is headed. Winton is considered by many to be Australia’s most popular novelist. His themes for this short novel are concerned with addictive behaviors, philosophical issues about escaping the ordinary, and the lessons learned in youth that can affect one’s whole life. Set in Western Australia, the novel is written with clear but highly descriptive language that helps the reader understand the thrills and art of surfing.
W Literary and Historical Context
Surfing developed among the Polynesian nations. The ancient Hawaiians named it he’e nalu or “wave sliding.” Both a sport but a training exercise for leaders, the chief was the best rider with the best board. Kahunas (priests) prayed for good waves, and competitions settled conflicts among the upper class. However, the dissipation of the Hawaiian culture with the coming of westerners almost extinguished the practice of surfing until its revival in the early twentieth century. In 1907 George Freeth, an IrishHawaiian, brought the sport to California; in 1912 Jim
Jordan and his oversized board made Virginia Beach the surfing capital of the East Coast; in 1915 Duke Kahanamoku, a surfing legend, introduced surfing to Australia. Advances in the 1920s in technology, materials, and surfboard design made the sport more accessible to the general public, and the first major surfing competition was held in 1928. Adding fins to the boards made surfboarding easier to learn and allowed for more trick maneuvers. Over the years, the boards became lighter and more manageable with the use of Styrofoam and fiberglass rather than woods. The invention of the wet suit in the 1950s also allowed surfers to catch waves in colder water and weather. The sport’s first major promoter was Dale Veazy, a manufacturer of surfboards who used advertising endorsements. Then interest exploded after Hollywood started making surf or beach party movies such as Gidget (1959) and the documentary The Endless Summer (1966). In the 1960s, boards were shortened from ten to six feet, and surfing became commercialized and culturally influential in clothes styles, music, and surfing magazines. In the 1970s, Australia became the center of the surfing world, which includes professional surfers, a number of supporting businesses, and fans around the world.
W Themes Addiction is a major theme of Breath: addiction to surfing, to danger, to pushing the limits and facing fear; Bruce’s addiction to Eva; Eva’s addiction to autoerotic asphyxiation, all of which in rebellion against the natural human compulsion to breathe. Surfing, its art, physicality, and danger serve in the novel as a stark contrast to the dreaded state of being ordinary, of living in a dull mining town like Sawyer. For Pikelet and Loonie, surfing gives meaning and intensity to their lives and makes them special. In addition, surfing is a way for these teens to prove their masculinity as measured by strength and daring.
193 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Breath
MAJOR CHARACTERS IVAN LOON (Loonie) is Bruce Pike’s danger-addicted, mouthy, surfing buddy who lives neglected at his father’s pub until he is caught up in the surfing world. BRUCE PIKE (Pikelet), the narrator, is a loner with older, unaware parents, who uses surfing to combat boredom, but discovers other excitements and their dangers, too. BILL SANDERSON (Sando), is a 36-year-old former surfing champion who surfs all over the world, has cosmopolitan tastes, and becomes a guru to Pikelet and Loonie. EVA SANDERSON, Bill’s difficult wife, was a free-style skier until a mangled knee causes her to find her thrills elsewhere, including an affair with Pikelet.
The title makes it obvious that breath is a theme of the novel. The importance of taking a breath, or not being able to, is laced throughout the narrative: One needs breath to play the didjeridu; Bruce’s father stops breathing because of sleep apnea; as children Bruce and Loonie
compete to see who can hold their breath the longest while playing in the river; surfers need sixty-seconds worth of breath to survive when submerged by a wave; Eva fights for breath during autoerotic asphyxiation. Another theme concerns the effects of the past upon the middle aged, especially men. Surfing may provide an escape mechanism as well as new spiritual and aesthetic experiences, but where does it lead? Bruce’s spirits soar when he surfs, and he feels that he is doing something as graceful as dancing, but the letdown when not surfing causes him to seek other highs, other dangers that leave him with long-term emotional damage and a continuing battle to find balance in his life as a whole rather than just on the surfboard.
W Style Winton structured Breath as a story about Bruce Pike as a youth framed by Pike as a middle-aged paramedic. The frame is quite brief, only seven pages at the beginning of the book and sixteen pages at the end, but it is sufficient to set up the scenario of the older Pike reflecting on the most daring period of his life. As a paramedic, Pike is called to a suicide that he is able to recognize is an accidental death
The plot of Breath revolves around the exploits of a group of Australian surfers. Stephanie Swartz/Shutterstock.com
194
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Breath
due to autoerotic asphyxiation because of his own teenage experiences with this dangerous practice. Inside this frame is a first-person story with just four main characters. The short novel has vivid images of the oceans and surfing. Within his spare prose, Winton uses lively action verbs that help the reader to understand the thrill of surfing. His language is also quite lyrical, and there are passages in which he interrupts the action of the story with effective descriptions that enable readers to get inside the characters’ emotions and feel their intensity. Winton’s practice in planning a novel is to first decide on the setting because the location and its landscape, the feelings he gets about the people in a certain place, are what give him inspiration. Almost always, the setting is in Western Australia, as in Breath, because that is Winton’s home, the area and people he knows well. In conjunction with the setting, his habit is to emphasize Australian English, using colloquialism to convey local characters.
W Critical Reception According to the critics, there are a number of flaws in Breath. Russell Celyn Jones, as published by the Times, provided a summary: Winton sometimes rushes, reverts to empty phrases and posturing, and ends the book badly. However, Jones concluded, when it comes to describing surfing, Breath is “as good as it gets.” Jennifer Schuessler, in the New York Times Book Review, agreed on its strength: “The freeze-frame descriptions of surfing . . . are gripping.” Barbara Hoffert, in a review for the Library Journal, concurred but added that the reasons Bruce gives for a derailed life are “not entirely convincing.” However, the novelist excels at his subject matter. Hoffert wrote: “Winton is pitch perfect in capturing (but not exploiting adolescent angst), and he describes surfing and the sea so thrillingly that even non-swimmers will want to plunge right in.” Philip Hensher agreed with Hoffert: Winton can “make us see, while sitting in our armchairs, exactly what it would be like to stand on a bit of hardboard while a 30-foot wave defeats our attempts to float on it.” Hensher explained Winton’s “virtuosity” in Breath as the ability “to move seamlessly from Pikelet’s honest speech into an elevated but absolutely direct account of what it is like to fling yourself at these great waves.” David Maine, in his Publishers Weekly review, praised Winton’s style: “Winton’s language, often terse, never showy, hovers convincingly between a teenager’s inarticulateness and the staccato delivery of a grown man.” Adding a note about the theme of the novel, a review in the New Yorker concluded that Breath “is both a hymn to the beauty of flying on water and a sober assessment of the costs of losing one’s balance, in every sense of the word.”
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Born in Karrinyup, Western Australia, in 1960, Tim Winton attended Curtin University and Western Australia Institute of Technology. He has written novels, nonfiction, and short stories, receiving numerous awards and becoming one of Australia’s premier authors. His books include the Lockie Leonard children’s series, which has been adapted as a TV series. One of these books and his novels Cloudstreet and That Eye, the Sky have been adapted for the stage, and his novels That Eye, the Sky and In the Winter Dark have been adapted for film. Winton likes to cook, dive, fish, and surf. He belongs to the Australian Marine Conservation Society and the Stop the Toad Foundation as a patron and has established the Tim Winton Award for Young Writers. Married to a nurse and administrator, Denise, Winton has three children—two sons and a daughter. As of 2010, they lived in Western Australia.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
“Breath.” Rev. of Breath, by Tim Winton. New Yorker 84.20 (2008): 95. Print. Hensher, Philip. “Ruling the Waves.” Rev. of Breath, by Tim Winton. Spectator 307.9375 (2008): 36. Print. Hoffert, Barbara. “Winton, Tim. Breath.” Rev. of Breath, by Tim Winton. Library Journal 133.7 (2008): 78. Print. Jones, Russell Celyn. “Breath by Tim Winton: The Times review.” Rev. of Breath, by Tim Winton. timesonline. co.uk. Times [London] 25 April 2008. Web. 23 Aug. 2010. Maine, David. “Breath.” Rev. of Breath, by Tim Winton. Publishers Weekly 225.14 (2008): 40. Print. Schuessler, Jennifer. “Beach Boys.” Rev. of Breath, by Tim Winton. New York Times Book Review 8 June 2008: 17(L). Print. Winton, Tom. Breath. New York: Picador-Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2008. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
“Breath.” Rev. of Breath, by Tim Winton. bookmarksmagazine.com. Bookmarks Sept.-Oct. 2008. Web. 23 Aug. 2010. Comments on surfing as the center of the story and includes a critical summary and excerpts from other reviews. Ness, Patrick. “The Seventh Wave.” Rev. of Breath, by Tim Winton. guardian.co.uk. Guardian 10 May 2008.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
195
Breath
Web. 23 Aug. 2010. Summarizes the story then comments on Winton’s prose and the theme of fear. O’Reilly, Nathanael. “Testing the Limits of Endurance.” Rev. of Breath, by Tim Winton. Antipodes 22.2 (2008): 169. Print. Reviews Winton’s career, provides a story summary, and comments on Winton’s descriptions and tone. Ratcliffe, Sophie. “New Fiction.” Rev. of Breath, by Tim Winton. Daily Mail 9 May 2008: 68. Print. Briefly discusses the framework of the novel and its philosophical message about the value of surfing. “Winton, Tim: BREATH.” Rev. of Breath, by Tim Winton. Kirkus Reviews 1 Apr. 2008. Print. Examines the language and characters and remarks on Winton’s handling of youth and lessons learned. Gale Resources
“Tim Winton.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Literature Resource Center. Web. 19 Aug. 2010. http//galenet.galegroup.com/servlet/ GLD/hits?r=d&origSearch=true&o=DataTy pe&n=10&l=d&c=1&locID=itsbtrial&secondary= false&u=CA&t=KW&s=2&NA=Tim+Winton
biography and links to several interviews and other information. For Further Reading
Ben-Messahel, Salhia. Mind the Country: Tim Winton’s Fiction. Perth: U of Western Australia P, 2006. Print. The first book-length study of Winton’s fiction, divided into four thematic sections. Carey, Peter. Oscar and Lucinda. New York: Vintage, 1997. Print. Australian novel about a minister and an heiress who love gambling and each other. Hawkins, Christopher. The Water’s End. Bloomington: Trafford, 2006. Print. Hawkins’s first novel about a Jersey boy and his complicated romance on the beaches of Mexico. Warshaw, Matt. The Encyclopedia of Surfing. New York: Mariner Books, 2005. Print. Covers the history, mythology, statistics, and other facts about surfing. Winton, Tim. Cloudstreet: A Novel. New York: Scribner’s, 2002. Print. Tells the story of two very different families who share a house for twenty years. Lois Kerschen
Open Web Sources
Winton maintains a Web site for Breath at http//breath. timwinton.com.au, which lists awards and includes a
196
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao By Junot Díaz
W Introduction In The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao (2007), Junot Díaz intertwines the stories of Dominican Republic political figures with the stories of the Cabral and de Leon families to amplify Oscar de Leone’s struggle with his identity, culture, and quest for love. Living with his mother Beli and his sister Lola, Oscar, nicknamed Oscar Wao by some bullies who liken him to Oscar Wilde, stays at home to write stories, read science fiction, watch cartoons, enjoy role-playing games, and dream about finding love and becoming a wellknown author. Lola narrates a chapter, but it is Yunior, Lola’s occasional boyfriend, who narrates the story of Oscar, his family, and their bad luck, resulting from a curse (fukú) with a history of its own. Díaz’s lengthy first section tells the history of the fukú and Oscar’s adolescence, then Lola narrates her own story. From this point, Díaz moves the narrative to the Dominican Republic and back in time to tell Beli’s story. The setting reverts to Oscar and his collegial experiences at Rutgers University, where Oscar’s bad luck continues to prevail as he continues to seek relationships with unattainable women. Díaz changes the setting to the Dominican Republic in the second section for Abelard Cabral’s story, in which the history of the curse becomes clearer as Díaz reveals Abelard’s encounter with Dominican dictator Rafael Trujillo. The narrative shifts to Oscar as an adult and describes Beli, Oscar, and Lola’s return to the Dominican Republic to visit La Inca. While there, Oscar meets his grandmother’s neighbor, Ybon, a semiretired prostitute. Even though she is involved with a Dominican police officer, Oscar falls in love with her. The third portion describes the encounter between Oscar and Ybon. The encounter ends badly for Oscar, who is eventually beaten and then killed by the police officer’s goons. The story ends with Yunior reading a letter from
Oscar, in which Oscar describes his last encounter with Ybon.
W Literary and Historical Context
Frequently alternating time and place in The Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao, Díaz’s narrative jumps from New York, New Jersey, and Santo Domingo, Dominican Republic, and in and out of different decades of the twentieth century. The story of Oscar and the family curse is set during the time when Rafael Trujillo (1891-1961) was in power, from 1930 to 1938 and from 1942 to 1952. As commander of the National Army, Trujillo established his power by 1930 by harassing and intimidating voters for the presidential elections. Winning 95 percent of the vote, Trujillo took over a stunned nation and began his feudalistic-like reign, which lasted until 1952. During this period, Trujillo ruled with complete authority, maintaining a secret police force and establishing monopolies over all state enterprises. Ironically, life got better for most Dominicans during Trujillo’s reign, but Trujillo’s fascist ideals put many citizens in great fear and peril (Haggerty). Díaz also weaves in a footnote about Trujillo’s protégé, Joaquín Balaguer (1906-2002). After Trujillo’s assassination in 1961, Balaguer was accused of fixing elections and intimidating voters. He won the election and ruled “with a sometimes ruthless manner for 22 years and six presidential terms” (Kershaw).
W Themes In The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao, Díaz illustrates the struggles and costs that are associated with the pursuit of love. Díaz uses Oscar, a social outsider, to show that
197 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao
MAJOR CHARACTERS ABELARD CABRAL, Beli’s father and Oscar and Lola’s grandfather, dies at the hands of Trujillo’s regime. BELI (BELICIA) CABRAL DE LEON is the mother of Lola and Oscar and the niece of La Inca. YUNIOR DE LAS CASAS is Oscar’s roommate, occasional boyfriend of Lola, and the narrator of most of the novel. LA INCA is Oscar and Lola’s grandmother and Beli’s aunt. She raises Beli after the tragic death of Beli’s parents. LOLA DE LEON is Oscar’s older sister and Yunior’s intermittent girlfriend. OSCAR DE LEON, the protagonist of the story, is an overweight, Dominican American nerd. He spends his time writing, reading science fiction, and searching for love and a bit of good luck. YBON PIMENTEL is a semiretired prostitute who becomes Oscar’s love interest.
even though love can endure, it does not have the power to transform a person into the person he wants to be; the power has to come from the person himself. Unfortunately, Oscar never realizes he has the power and authority to make these changes happen. Díaz includes stories of Oscar’s family members to show how love cannot save individuals even though they make great sacrifices in order to love and be loved. Lola and Yunior sacrifice their love for each other in order learn how to construct independent lives since their love is not enough to bind them together. The relationship between Abelard and his daughter serves as another example of the cost of love. Abelard sacrifices his freedom for his daughter, but in the end, the sacrifice goes unrewarded as his daughter drowns. A second theme that appears in the novel is that of cultural identity. Díaz connects the history of the Dominican Republic with the histories of Oscar, Lola, and Yunior to show that their own histories and the histories of their country are inseparable. How to merge these histories, however, is what confronts Lola and Yunior. Lola runs away from her past, and Yunior has a series of infidelities in order to gloss over his past. In the end, both characters resolve how to accept their Dominican heritage rather than reject it. Oscar, who refuses to confront who he is, remains a displaced person who never fits in. As a result, Oscar comes to mirror people, especially immigrants, who struggle to fit in because they either will not or cannot blend their past and present cultural heritages.
198
Set in the Dominican Republic, some of the events in The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao take place during the reign of President Rafael Trujillo. ª Bettmann/Corbis
A third theme in the novel is that of politics, power, and authority. In combining Oscar’s story with that of Abelard, Díaz documents the history of the Dominican dictator Rafael Trujillo. Díaz uses Trujillo to explore how one man can rise to power and once he is in control, how horrifying it is when that solitary voice comes to be the voice a nation.
W Style Díaz successfully constructs a plot in which readers have to unravel the characters’ stories and their connections to each other. By juxtaposing not only characters—Lola and Beli, Oscar and Yunior, and Abelard and Trujillo—along with the past and present, and the setting of the United States and Dominican Republic, Díaz manages to throw readers into the same quandary as some of his characters, giving them a sense of displacement. The style of this novel is heavily infused with Spanish and English idioms and dialects from New TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao
Jersey in the 1980s and Santo Domingo in different decades. Díaz uses intermittent exchanges between Oscar’s story and the chapters laced with family member accounts to bounce readers back and forth in time and place. Consequently, readers encounter chapters spliced into Oscar’s story. Because of the erratic change in time and place, the text itself moves swiftly to focus on different characters as the voice swings from third person (Yunior) to first person, (Lola). Díaz uses Yunior as the primary narrator to offset the tragedy with comedy and to interject a sense of style and voice that manages to connect readers to the prose. With street-smart references, vulgar language, and a sense of lightness and humor, Yunior manages to reveal his own complicated history while telling the story of Oscar and his family.
W Critical Reception Díaz’s Drown, a collection of short stories published in 1996, was well received; however, it took Díaz eleven years to publish his first novel, The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao. Praised for his handling of the protagonistnarrator, intermingling of historical footnotes, and engaging prose, Díaz won the 2008 Pulitzer Prize and the National Book Critics Circle Award in addition to several other awards and accolades. Much of the novel’s success is attributed to Díaz’s use of setting. According to Michiko Kakutani in the New York Times, Díaz successfully uses setting to fuse the stories of past and present, combining Dominican history with that of a fat Dominican ghetto kid from Paterson, New Jersey, who is looking to lose his virginity. Kakutani indicated that Díaz successfully “fashioned both a big picture window that opens out on the sorrows of Dominican history, and a small, intimate window that reveals one family’s life and loves.” She argued that this book “establishes him as one of contemporary fiction’s most distinctive and irresistible new voices.” A few reviewers noted the strength of the historical footnotes and the narrative, which moves readers into the past. For example, Alice O’Keefe in the New Statesmen praised Díaz for the book’s portions that focus on Dominican history and the story of Abelard and Beli as the sections that “drive the narrative.” Despite the rave reviews from some reviewers, a few others, however, noted some weaknesses in Díaz’s use of language. James Wood in the New Republic argued that Díaz does not do anything new with language, and as a result, his text does little to connect readers to characters. In the Philadelphia Inquirer, Carlin Romano critiqued Díaz for his “sprinkles sci-fi/comic book/fantasy references, and Spanish and Spanglish phrases, with abandon and no explanation, as if smugly unconcerned for any reader of the ‘universal’ sort he’s said he hopes to attract.” However, Romano stated that there is value in the read as the novel “grows on you because Díaz slowly
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Born in Santo Domingo, Dominican Republic, on December 31, 1968, Junot Díaz immigrated with his family in 1974 to Parlin, New Jersey, to reunite with his father, who immigrated earlier. Raised in New Jersey, Díaz received his BA from Rutgers University and his MFA in creative writing from Cornell University. From 1997 to 2002, Díaz taught in the MFA program at Syracuse University, and in 2003 he became associate professor in the Program in Writing and Humanistic Studies, part of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology School of Humanities, Arts, and Social Sciences. Díaz is the author of Drown (1996), a short story collection that received wide recognition, and editor of The Beacon Best of 2001: Great Writing by Women and Men of All Colors and Cultures. Díaz won the 2007 National Book Critics Circle Award and the 2008 Pulitzer Prize and for The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao.
convinces us that Oscar, the sad sack Díaz might have become, is real and matters.” A. O. Scott from the New York Times stressed that Díaz’s success lies in his use of his narrator Yunior. Even though Yunior’s street-savvy persona is in direct conflict with his authoritative use of language in the telling of Oscar’s story and in the footnote accounts, Scott saw the conflict Yunior’s narrative voice creates as part of the appeal and the voice that holds the text together. John Lingan in the Quarterly Review indicated that Yunior is “a breathless and colloquial storyteller” and that, over the course of the book, Yunior’s contribution is an essential ingredient in the success of the story. Susan Straight in the Los Angeles Times agreed with Scott. She noted that Díaz took a risk in choosing Yunior, who is “unconcerned about whether his language is accessible.” O’Keefe, however, disagreed with both Scott and Straight; she argued that Yunior is “an inconsistent character” because he is an unreliable narrator and, therefore, distances the reader. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
“Book Review: The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao.” Isak’s Blog 4 June 2010. Web. 10 July 2010. Haggerty, Richard A., ed. “The Era of Trujillo.” Dominican Republic: A Country Study. Washington: GPO for the Library of Congress, 1989. Print. Kakutani, Michiko. “Travails of an Outcast.” Rev. of The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao, by Junot Díaz. nytimes.com. New York Times 4 Sept. 2007. Web. 25 July 2010. Kershaw, Sarah. “Joaquin Balaguer; 95, Dies; Dominated Dominican Life.” NYtimes.com. New York Times 15 July 2002. Web. 13 July 2010.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
199
The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao
Lingan, John. Rev. of The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao, by Junot Díaz. quarterlyconversation.com. Quarterly Conversation, n.d. Web. 25 July 2010.
Library. Web. 28 July 2010. http//go.galegroup. com/ps/i.do?&id=GALE%7CCX2285700052& v=2.1&u=itsbtrial&it=r&p=GVRL&sw=w
Romano, Carlin. “The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao: It’s Hard Going but Stay with It.” Rev. of The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao, by Junot Díaz. Philadelphia Inquirer.com. Philadelphia Inquirer 7 Sept. 2007. Web. 26 July 2010.
“Junot Díaz.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2010. Literature Resource Center. Web. 28 July 2010. http//go.galegroup.com/ps/i.do?&id= GALE%7CH1000124825&v=2.1&u= itsbtrial&it=r&p=LitRC&sw=w
Scott, A. O. “Dreaming in Spanglish.” Rev. of The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao, by Junot Díaz. nytimes. com. New York Times Sunday Book Review 30 Sept. 2007. Web. 1 July 2010.
“Junot Díaz.” Contemporary Literary Criticism. Vol. 258. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Literature Resource Center. Web. 28 July 2010. http//go.galegroup.com/ps/ i.do?&id=GALE%7CH1121130000&v=2.1&u =itsbtrial&it=r&p=LitRC&sw=w
Straight, Susan. “A Love Supreme.” Rev. of The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao, by Junot Díaz. Latimes. com. Los Angeles Times 9 Sept. 2007. Web. 20 July 2010. Wood, James. “Call It Sleep.” Rev. of Drown, by Junot Díaz. New Republic 215.25 (1996): 39-42.
“Selected Websites on Junot Díaz’s Life and Works.” Gale Online Encyclopedia. Detroit: Gale, 2010. Literature Resource Center. Web. 28 July 2010. http//go.galegroup.com/ps/i.do?&id=GALE %7CH1440124825&v=2.1&u=itsbtrial&it=r& p=LitRC&sw=w
Additional Resources Open Web Sources
Criticism and Reviews
Díaz, Junot, and Juleyka Lantigua. “Junot Díaz.” Progressive 70.9 (2007): 33-36. Print. Discusses social outcasting, the Internet generation, immigrant status, and the writing process. Hannan, Jim. “Junot Díaz. The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao.” World Literature Today 82.2 (2008): 65+. Print. Describes effective use of grim humor contrasted with the horror of the Trujillo regime to unravel the story of Oscar and the curse. Stetler, Carrie. “A Decade of Writer’s Block Over, Díaz Publishes His Novel.” Newhouse News Service. 29 Aug. 2007. Web. 1 July 2010. Discusses the role of Yunior as character and narrator. ———. “From ‘Ghetto Nerd’ to MIT: Writer Junot Díaz.” Newhouse News Service 20 Oct. 2005. Web. 1 July 2010. Explores the role of Oscar as protagonist in relation to Díaz’s childhood. Thompson, Bob. “The Outsider Is In: An Immigrant’s Stories.” Washington Post.com. Washington Post 20 Sept. 2007. Web. 25 July 2010. Addresses the theme of self-identity. “The Yale Literary Magazine Interviews Junot Díaz.” Yale Literary Magazine 20.1 (2008): 26+. Print. Explores the connection Díaz has to Yunior, the narrator in two of his works, his literary influences, and his role as a writer representing a different culture. Gale Resources
“Díaz, Junot 1968-.” Contemporary Authors, New Revision Series. Ed. Amy Elisabeth Fuller. Vol. 183. Detroit: Gale, 2009. 145-49. Gale Virtual Reference
200
“Díaz’s First Novel Details a Wondrous Life,” posted on National Public Radio’s All Things Considered, available at http//www.npr.org/templates/story/ story.php?storyId=14004835, includes Alan Cheuse reviewing The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao. “First Novel Examines ‘Dominican-American Sci-Fi Geek,’” posted on National Public Radio’s All Things Considered, Weekend Edition, available at http// www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php? storyId=15271108, is a podcast of Andrea Seabrook interviewing Junot Díaz on the stereotypes in his work, Dominican themes, mashing of cultures, and making life choices. Facebook page dedicated to Junot Díaz, available at http//facebook.com/pages/Junot-Diaz/ 111850538834522 includes posts about his writing, books, and interviews. “Junot Díaz Discusses His ‘Wondrous’ Debut Novel” posted on National Public Radio’s Fresh Air, available at http//www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php? storyId=90111248, includes a podcast of Terry Gross interviewing Díaz his childhood, writing experiences, family history, and influences. Junot Díaz’s Web site, available at http://www.junot diaz.com, includes information about lectures and work in progress. For Further Reading
Brown, Isabel Zakrewski. Culture and Customs of the Dominican Republic. Westport: Greenwood, 1999. Print. Highlights the land, people, customs, religion, performing arts, and literature of the Dominican Republic. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao
Céspedes, Diógenes, and Silvio Torres-Saillant. “Fiction Is the Poor Man’s Cinema: An Interview with Junot Díaz.” Callaloo 23.3 (2000): 892-907. Print. Focuses on Díaz’s childhood experiences, creative process, and the intermingling of cultural references into his texts.
Pons, Frank Maya. The Dominican Republic: A National History. Princeton: Markus Wiener, 1998. Print. Offers a comprehensive overview of the history of the Dominican Republic.
Diederich, Bernard. Trujillo: The Death of a Dictator. Princeton: Markus Wiener, 2000. Print. Chronicles the dictatorship of Trujillo after thirty-one years of ruling the Dominican Republic.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Rachel V. Smydra
201
The Broken Shore By Peter Temple
W Introduction Published in Australia in 2005 and in the United States in 2007, Peter Temple’s The Broken Shore is a detective novel written in a literary style. A departure from Temple’s popular Jack Irish series, the book follows Joe Cashin, a Melbourne homicide detective who takes a position in Port Monro, a small rural town on the Victorian coast, after he is seriously injured on the job. There he becomes involved in a murder investigation that forces him to confront police corruption and racial bigotry. He also has to face his awkward relationship with his mother and brother. Set in contemporary Australia, The Broken Shore employs distinctly Australian dialogue, to the extent that the North American edition of the book includes a glossary defining more than sixty terms. The novel addresses a number of social concerns, from class and racial tensions to homophobia and pedophilia. It won the British Crime Writers’ Association’s 2007 Duncan Lawrie Dagger Award (formerly the Gold Dagger Award) for the year’s best work of detective fiction.
W Literary and Historical Context
Much of the plot of The Broken Shore relies on tensions between Australia’s white majority and Indigenous Australians, or Aborigines. Historically, these tensions date back to the arrival of Europeans on the Australian continent in the late eighteenth century. Under British colonial rule, Australia’s indigenous population was decimated by disease. It has been estimated that the indigenous population of the continent precontact was more than 300,000; by 1900 it had dwindled to fewer than 100,000. Over the next century, Indigenous Australians struggled to overcome racial bigotry, win
suffrage and representation, and reclaim land. Although they won the right to vote in 1962 and gained limited rights to their land in 1972, indigenous people remain underrepresented in Australian politics and are often isolated in poverty-stricken settlements. In the novel, Aboriginal characters live primarily in “the Daunt,” an economically depressed indigenous settlement. Cashin recalls the taunting that his cousin, whose mother was Aboriginal, endured during their youth. As the novel unfolds, people of indigenous descent remain the subject of derision among the white police force, who refer to them in pejorative terms such as “Daunt dickheads,” “coons,” “niggers,” and “boongs.”
W Themes Power and its abuses are central themes in Temple’s novel. The book illuminates a number of important inequalities between those who have power and those who do not. The murdered Charles Bourgoyne is the novel’s most obvious representative of the abuses of power. His wealth puts him at the top of the class structure, a position he takes advantage of in order to abuse disadvantaged children while paying officials to look the other way. Bourgoyne’s death highlights the disparities in power and credibility between the community’s white majority and its indigenous minority. Before it is eventually revealed that Bourgoyne was killed by his stepson, a victim of his abuse, the combination of racial prejudice and a police cover-up leads to the senseless deaths of three young Aboriginal men who are suspected of the crime. Temple is quick to point out, however, that bigotry extends beyond lines of race and class. Cashin frequents a restaurant owned by Leon Gadney, who relocated to the area after his male lover was murdered, either by antigay zealots or by equally bigoted police officers. Later, Cashin learns that the successful brother he has long resented is struggling with his own homosexuality. The brother,
202 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Broken Shore
MAJOR CHARACTERS CHARLES BOURGOYNE is a prominent citizen whose murder sets off the chain of events that dominate the plot. As the detective Cashin investigates, he discovers that Bourgoyne and his friends had been sexually abusing and likely murdering children for many years through the guise of a charity camp. Bourgoyne is murdered by his stepson, Jamie, in retaliation for the abuse. JOE CASHIN is a homicide detective who has been relocated to a small town on Australia’s southern coast. While investigating a murder case, he uncovers corruption that implicates local police. MICHAEL CASHIN is Joe’s successful brother. Though the two have never been close, they are brought together after Michael attempts suicide and confesses that he has been forced out of his high-powered job after he was photographed kissing a man. HELEN CASTLEMAN is a defense attorney and Cashin’s love interest. She is defending Donny Coulter, the young Aborigine accused in Bourgoyne’s death, and uncovers evidence that helps Cashin unravel the truth about Charles Bourgoyne’s death.
Detectives follow a lead about two teenagers trying to sell a missing watch at a pawn shop in the book The Broken Shore. Linda Armstrong/ Shutterstock.com
Michael Cashin, loses his job after he is photographed kissing his male lover. As a result the lover, who is married and has children, commits suicide. Michael subsequently also attempts suicide. While these revelations bring Cashin and his brother closer together, Temple makes it clear that homophobia does real and lasting harm to families and communities. The relationship between the past and the present is also a central theme in The Broken Shore. Characters such as Bourgoyne’s stepson, Jamie, and the drifter Dave Reb are haunted by the abuse they suffered at the hands of Bourgoyne and his friends. The abuse turns Jamie into a sadistic killer and is ostensibly responsible for Reb’s life of poverty and isolation. Cashin is also haunted by events from his past, including his father’s suicide, his mother’s careless parenting style, and what he perceives to be his own responsibility for the death of a fellow cop. Both he and Reb are seen to gain some strength from their joint effort to rebuild the ruined home of Cashin’s ancestor, an act that symbolizes their determination to come to terms with the past and create a new future.
DETECTIVE HOPGOOD is a senior police detective and an obvious racist who is investigating the attack on Charles Bourgoyne. Cashin becomes suspicious of Hopgood’s insistence on the guilt of three young Aborigines, and Hopgood is later revealed to have turned a blind eye to Bourgoyne’s crimes. DAVE REB is an itinerant worker, or “swaggie,” whom Cashin discovers sleeping in a shed. Touched by the man’s circumstances and apparent honesty, he offers him a job. The two men develop a friendship. Dave eventually reveals that he attended Bourgoyne’s charity camp as a child.
W Style The Broken Shore is stylistically notable for its terse dialogue, which is marked by coarse language, slang, and racial slurs. Typical of such dialogue is Detective Hopgood’s warning against arresting the young Aboriginal suspects at home: “You don’t go into the f—ing Daunt at night and arrest people. It’s Indian territory. Excellent chance we end up being attacked by the whole f—ing street, the whole f—ing Daunt, hundreds of coons off their f—ing faces.” At the same time, the book’s narrative passages are full of visual details described in language that borders on the poetic (“Cashin went for a walk, bought cigarettes, another surrender. A cold night, rain in the west wind, the last of the leaves flirting with bits of paper in the streetlights.”).
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
203
The Broken Shore
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Peter Temple was born in South Africa in 1946. He immigrated to Australia in 1980, seeking to distance himself from the repressive and racist system of apartheid in his native country. Living in Sydney, Temple established himself as a well-respected journalist, writing for both newspapers and magazines. In 1995 he began to focus full time on fiction writing. In 1996 he published his first novel, Bad Debts. The work introduced attorney Jack Irish, a character who would feature prominently in a series of subsequent novels. Bad Debts won the prestigious Ned Kelly Award for crime fiction and helped establish Temple’s reputation as a favorite Australian crime writer. Temple produced eight more novels over the next decade, including The Broken Shore. Like his other works, The Broken Shore depicts the life and landscape of Australia. It garnered Temple his fifth Ned Kelly Award. His 2009 novel Truth revisits some of the characters introduced in The Broken Shore.
Commentators have pointed to such prose when arguing that Temple’s novel, while clearly rooted in the detective fiction tradition, transcends the genre with its
literary style. Writing in the Washington Post, for example, Patrick Anderson described The Broken Shore as “an exceptional blending of first-rate crime fiction and a literary sensibility.”
W Critical Reception When it was first published in Australia in 2005, The Broken Shore was an immediate critical success. In addition to winning the 2006 Ned Kelly Award for Best Novel, it garnered the 2005 Colin Roderick Award, which honors the best Australian literary work representing life in that country. With its publication outside of Australia, the book drew international praise for its treatment of sensitive social issues as well as for its writing style. Commentators were especially drawn to Temple’s gift for description and his ability to depict numerous different characters and situations with an even hand. Susanna Yager noted in the Sunday Telegraph that “This is a very fine book. Characterisation, dialogue and the quality of the prose are all top-class,” while Anderson praised Temple for his character development, writing that the novel “presents sophisticated portraits of at least a dozen of Port Monro’s citizens—the rich and the poor,
The novel The Broken Shore is set in a small, rural Australian town, much like the one shown in this photo. ª sam oakes / Alamy
204
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Broken Shore
the honest and the corrupt—all seen with compassion and without illusion.” The Broken Shore has even been the subject of some scholarly analysis. For example, in an article in the journal Antipodes, William Sayers examines Temple’s use of Australian slang, noting in particular how characters are marked by the language they use. “Temple’s long career as a journalist,” he writes, “has given him a fine ear for popular speech and its reflection of ethnic and class selfidentification. His protagonist, Joe Cashin, uses none of the terms reviewed here, which qualifies him to get the killers and the girl. On the other hand, his detective counterpart from a neighboring jurisdiction, Hopgood, who is eventually shown to be corrupt and implicated in some of the crimes, delivers the most offensive characterization of the Aboriginal community, aware that Cashin has in-laws there.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Anderson, Patrick. “Brutal Eloquence.” Washington Post 18 June 2007: C03. Print. Sayers, William. “Hoon, Coon, and Boong in Peter Temple’s Detective Fiction.” Antipodes 22.2 (2008): 165+. Print. Temple, Peter. The Broken Shore. Melbourne: Text Publishing Company, 2005. Print. Yager, Susanna. “Crime Fiction.” Sunday Telegraph [London] 9 July 2006: 49. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Rev. of The Broken Shore, by Peter Temple. Kirkus Reviews 15 Apr. 2007: 363. Print. Offers an overview of the novel’s plot and praises its psychological insight. Rev. of The Broken Shore, by Peter Temple. Publishers Weekly 2 Apr. 2007: 38. Print. Emphasizes the novel’s attention to character development and setting. Graff, Keir. Rev. of The Broken Shore, by Peter Temple. Booklist 15 Mar. 2007: 30. Print. A favorable review that likens Temple’s Australia to the American West. Ott, Bill. “The Year’s Best Crime Novels.” Booklist 1 May 2007: 6+. Print. Praises the intelligence of Temple’s novel. Williams, Wilda. Rev. of The Broken Shore, by Peter Temple. Library Journal 15 May 2007: 85. Print.
Lauds the author’s prose style and his insight into racial and class politics. Gale Resources
“Peter Temple.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Open Web Sources
The Australian Crime Fiction Database offers an online bibliography of Temple’s work. http//www.crime downunder.com/petertemple.html The Web site Tangled Web UK includes an interview with Temple by Bob Cornwell in which the author discusses his work. http//www.twbooks.co.uk/crimescene/Pe ter-Temple-talks-to-Bob-Cornwell.htm The January Magazine Web site offers an overview of Temple’s career through 2002 and notably includes the writer’s reflections on his craft and publishing. http//www.januarymagazine.com/profiles/ptem ple.html Reading Group Guides offers an introduction to the novel and questions to guide discussion of the book. http// www.readinggroupguides.com/guides_B/broken_ shore1.asp For Further Reading
Flood, Josephine. The Original Australians: Story of the Aboriginal People. Crows Nest: Allen & Unwin, 2006. Print. Provides a history of Australia’s indigenous people and their culture. Karl, Roland F., et al. Australia: Continent of Contrasts. Munich: C.J. Bucher, 2007. Print. Presents an imagerich introduction to the continent of Australia. Kuhns, Joseph B., and Johannes Knutsson. Police Use of Force: A Global Perspective. Santa Barbara: Praeger, 2010. Print. Explores the use of force in its myriad forms by police officers around the world. Rowe, Kerrin P. Wordbook of Australian Idiom—Aussie Slang: No Worries! She’s Apples! Victoria, BC: Trafford, 2005. Print. Offers an overview of slang terms and idioms in Australian English. Temple, Peter. Truth. Melbourne: Text Publishing Company, 2009. Print. A mystery that features Inspector Stephen Villani, who appears in The Broken Shore.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Greta Gard
205
Brooklyn By Colm Tóibín
W Introduction Colm Tóibín’s novel Brooklyn is a story about twentiethcentury immigration. The heroine, Eilis (pronounced EYElish) Lacey, is the youngest and least important daughter in the Lacey family. Her mother has been widowed and her three brothers have all left Ireland for jobs in England. Eilis’s older sister, Rose, is a bookkeeper who supports their widowed mother with her wages. Employment and husbands are in short supply in the small town of Enniscorthy, where the girls and their mother live. Rose asks a visiting priest, Father Flood, to help Eilis immigrate to the United States. Father Flood finds Eilis a job and a place to stay and watches over her as she settles into her new life in Brooklyn. Eilis is one of several Irish girls living in Mrs. Kehoe’s boardinghouse. She finds a job working for Bartocci’s department store, under the watchful eye of Miss Fortini, her supervisor. To help Eilis cope with her loneliness and homesickness, Father Flood arranges for Eilis to enroll at Brooklyn College, where she can complete the requirements for a bookkeeper’s certificate in two years. At Brooklyn College, Eilis’s professor, a Holocaust survivor, encourages her to continue her studies. Eilis attends Friday night dances at Father Flood’s church and also helps him serve Christmas dinner to the homeless. All of these activities help Eilis to feel more connected to her new home in Brooklyn. At one of the dances, Eilis meets Tony, a young Italian American, who soon becomes her boyfriend. Tony falls in love with Eilis and begins pressing her to marry him. He loves baseball and takes her to Ebbets Field to watch the Brooklyn Dodgers play. When Rose dies suddenly, it is Tony and his family who offer Eilis the most comfort. None of Eilis’s brothers is willing to move back to Ireland and care for their mother. One of the brothers writes and tells Eilis that her mother needs her. When she decides to return for a
one-month visit, Tony insists that they marry secretly. He is afraid that Eilis will not return to Brooklyn unless they are married. The visit to her mother does stretch beyond the month, and Eilis is tempted to stay by Jim, a local Irish man, who courts her. In the novel’s concluding paragraphs, however, Eilis chooses to leave Ireland and return to Tony and the life they have planned together.
W Literary and Historical Context
In Brooklyn, the owner of Bartocci’s department store says that “Brooklyn changes every day” (61). During the 1950s, the predominately Jewish and Italian neighborhood in Brooklyn gave way to new immigrants from the Caribbean and to an influx of African Americans from the southern United States. The Brooklyn Dodgers drew huge crowds to Ebbets Field in the 1950s. Although Brooklyn residents had diverse backgrounds, they were united in their worship of the Dodgers and their belief that the team would eventually win a World Series, which they finally did in 1955. However, just as the Jews and Italians were leaving Brooklyn for the suburbs, so too did the Dodgers, who left Brooklyn in 1958 for Los Angeles. Coney Island is a favorite date destination for Brooklyn’s Eilis and Tony during the summer months. In the 1950s, Coney Island was a favorite location for New Yorkers wanting to escape the city heat. More than one million bathers would cram onto the beach at Coney Island. The three miles of boardwalk included more than nine hundred different shops, restaurants, games, and rides. The amusement park contained the Cyclone, one of the largest roller coasters in the United States, as well as the Wonder Wheel, an exceptionally large Ferris wheel. These rides and many others began to disappear by the mid-1950s, as more people moved to the suburbs and land in Brooklyn became more valuable when used for residences than for amusement.
206 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Brooklyn
In Brooklyn, Tony’s family purchases land on Long Island and begins planning for the family’s move out of Brooklyn. The desire to escape Brooklyn for Long Island was felt by many people in the 1950s. In Brooklyn, people were crowded into apartments or in multiple-family houses. With little open land and no yards, children played in the streets. Many people wanted to build in outlying areas. This market supported the work of Levitt and Sons, the real-estate developer that spearheaded the construction of suburbia and built more than seventeen thousand homes for families trying to escape urban congestion.
W Themes For the first few weeks that Eilis is in Brooklyn, she refuses to think about Ireland and her family. Homesickness does not appear in Brooklyn until Eilis receives letters from home. Before the letters arrive, she thinks about Ireland, especially her mother and sister and she thinks about the town. With the arrival of the letters, Eilis suddenly thinks about her life in Enniscorthy, especially her bedroom, her clothes, and even the food her mother cooked. Her homesickness is not centered on people, although she clearly misses Rose. Instead, Eilis misses the ways in which she defined her own life in Ireland. In Brooklyn, she dresses differently and eats different food. The changed personal and intimate parts of her life cause her to be homesick. Social stratification in Brooklyn is depicted in the relationships between the other boarders at Mrs. Kehoe’s. Working at a desk job is considered superior to working in a store as a clerk. Working as a domestic servant has the lowest form of social status. Eilis is immune to this stratification, but her fellow tenants are especially condemning. When a new boarder arrives, the other tenants ostracize her because she cleans the house instead of paying rent. The women who perform office work also earn the highest salary, and so there is a clear correlation between social stratification and economic reward. Brooklyn is the story of exile. Eilis has no choice about moving to Brooklyn. Her sister Rose makes the arrangements and informs Eilis that she is to leave and dictates when the departure will occur. In Brooklyn, Eilis is under the care and supervision of Father Flood, who recreates Ireland in his small part of Brooklyn. As a result, Eilis remains an exile, even when living in Brooklyn, where she sees herself as a ghost, with no friends or family to sustain her. Her only venture outside her Irish Brooklyn community occurs late in the novel, when she goes to visit her Italian boyfriend’s family. Her isolation even permeates her letters home, in which she writes about people generally but not about how she feels or about Tony, whom she loves.
W Style Brooklyn is told from the point of view of Eilis. This perspective is especially effectively for a character like Eilis
MAJOR CHARACTERS JIM FARRELL is the Irish man whose marriage proposal tempts, and nearly convinces, Eilis to divorce Tony and remain in Ireland. TONY FIORELLO is Eilis’s Brooklyn boyfriend. He becomes her fiancé and, by the end of the novel, her husband. Although Eilis is warned about the lasciviousness of Italian men, Tony is kind, generous, and devoted to Eilis. FATHER FLOOD is the priest for the area in Brooklyn where Eilis lives. He sponsors her immigration and provides support when she needs it most. MADGE KEHOE is the proprietor of the boardinghouse where Eilis lives in Brooklyn. Madge is judgmental and controlling but also protective of the young women living in her house. MRS. LACY, a widow, favors her older daughter Rose over her other daughter, Eilis. EILIS LACEY, a young Irish woman, immigrates to the United States and finds her home and work in Brooklyn. ROSE LACEY, Eilis’s older sister, is beautiful, athletic, gregarious, and much admired by everyone. She arranges for Eilis to leave Ireland and find a fresh start in Brooklyn.
who thinks one thing but does something completely different. In her actions, Eilis is restrained, oftentimes an observer of her own life. She thinks about rebellion, but quickly rejects the possibility. Instead, she obeys as a dutiful daughter, sister, employee, tenant, and girlfriend. It is clear that she often wishes she could do something entirely different than what is expected of her. The heroine of Brooklyn is defined by her passivity. Tóibín characterizes Eilis by her emotional state rather than by her actions. Throughout Brooklyn, she is restrained, cautious, and obedient without objection. And yet while she acquiesces to the demands of those around her, her mind is in turmoil and nearly always ready to do rebel. When Miss Fortini tells Eilis not to bother using a changing room to try on several bathing suits, Eilis is upset, since no one had seen her naked before (161). In spite of her distress, Eilis tries on the bathing suits in front of Miss Fortini and can only escape after all four suits have been fitted. Her thoughts during this scene show her to be a woman who is tortured by her inability to act according to her own desire. Tóibín did not create a back story for his characters. Nothing of the past is explained. The novel moves forward telling Eilis’s story but does not reveal her family’s life before the start of the novel. Tóibín tells readers nothing about Rose or that in 1950s Ireland it was customary for one of the daughters to remain
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
207
Brooklyn
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Colm Tóibín was born in Enniscorthy, County Wexford, Ireland, in 1955. He worked as a journalist and as a teacher. Tóibín has published several nonfiction books, including travel books about living in Spain, Homage to Barcelona (1990) and Walking along the Border (1987), which focuses on the boundary between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland. Tóibín’s fifth novel, The Master (2004), was short-listed for the Man Booker Prize in 2004 and was selected by the New York Times as one of the ten best books of 2004. Brooklyn, Tóibín’s sixth novel, was awarded the Costa Novel of the Year Award in 2010. As of 2010, Tóibín had homes in Ireland, Spain, and New York and often stayed in these locations.
unmarried and care for an aging parent. No information is provided about Eilis prior to the start of the novel. Readers know virtually nothing about Tony’s life or that of his family, except that they are Italian. As a result, readers must pay careful attention to Eilis’s narration to know these characters and understand their motivations. There is no information to distract, and more importantly, there is no information that readers might use to predict behaviors. Instead, clues are provided by dialogue or by what Eilis thinks or observes.
W Critical Reception Reviews of Brooklyn were almost uniformly positive. Many reviews were similar to one written by Peter Kemp for the London Sunday Times, who praised Tóibín’s novel as “elating” and “brilliant.” Kemp also admired
The Brooklyn Bridge in New York. In Brooklyn, Eilis Lacey is a young Irish girl who immigrates to Brooklyn, New York. H. Armstrong Roberts
208
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Brooklyn
One of the few complaints about Brooklyn pertained to the depiction of Eilis, who is so readily compliant to demanding others. In her review for the Christian Science Monitor, Yvonne Zipp complained that Tóibín’s heroine is a “doormat,” who “is almost a parody of 1950s femininity.” Zipp described Eilis as a heroine who is “sweet,” “curvy,” “attractive but not alarming so,” “good at school but not ambitious,” and “above all, biddable.” Although Zipp thought that Eilis could use some backbone, she also found that there is much to admire in Brooklyn. Tóibín’s attention to small details is especially effective in relating his heroine’s life. In the end, Zipp celebrated Brooklyn as “a masterpiece of quiet reflection, bringing up deep emotions submerged under the placid exterior and giving the novel an ache that will linger for days.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Goring, Rosemary. “Brooklyn Calling.” Rev. of Brooklyn, by Colm Tóibín. heraldscotland.com. Sunday Herald 17 May 2009. Web. 4 Aug. 2010. Kemp, Peter. Rev. of Brooklyn, by Colm Tóibín. thesundaytimes.co.uk. Sunday Times 19 April 2009. Wed. 4 Aug. 2010. St. Mark’s Catholic Church in Brooklyn, New York. In the story, Eilis meets a handsome young Italian man named Tony at a church dance. Vladimir Korostyshevskiy/Shutterstock.com
Tóibín’s ability to create “a fresh dimension of humane warmth” in a novel that also remains so lucid in its depiction of Eilis’s life. Kemp enjoyed Tóibín’s ability to create a novel that is stylistically straightforward and without unneeded digressions. This “pared-down style” is not so bare, though, that it eliminates comedy, and as a result, Kemp asserts, Tóibín created “a novel that stands out as remarkable even among Ireland’s distinguished roll of fiction about home and exile.” In her review of Brooklyn for the Sunday Herald, Rosemary Goring was similarly complimentary of Tóibín’s talents, pointing out that although the novel might initially seem a bit “dreamy,” it soon becomes clear that Brooklyn is an “exquisitely observed story.” Goring’s review celebrated Tóibín’s narrow focus on Eilis’s life, which reveals itself through many small details. Brooklyn, suggested Goring, is “a profoundly moving, deceptively artless creation whose brilliance lies in its restraint.” Bernard O’Donoghue’s review of Brooklyn for the Irish Times also focused on Tóibín’s restraint in creating scenes that are “unsensational” and “delicately described.” According to O’Donoghue, Brooklyn has “not a sentence or a thought out of place.” This is high praise, indeed, for a novel that many reviewers judge to be Tóibín’s finest work.
O’Donoghue, Bernard. “The Clear Voice of a Master.” Rev. of Brooklyn, by Colm Tóibín. irishtimes.com. Irish Times 25 April 2009. Web. 4 Aug. 2010. Tóibín, Colm. Brooklyn. New York: Scribner’s, 2009. Print. Zipp, Yvonne. “Brooklyn: The Quiet, Contemplative Story of a Young Woman Leaving Ireland for a New Life in the Brooklyn of the 1950s.” Rev. of Brooklyn, by Colm Tóibín. csmonitor.com. Christian Science Monitor 8 May 2009. Web. 4 Aug. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Bracken, Claire. “Brooklyn.” Journal of Irish Studies 5 (2010): 166. Print. Analyzes the objectification of Eilis Lacey as Irish property, the visible material of society and social life. Knox, Malcolm. “An Irish Face in Brooklyn: Interview with Colm Tóibín.” theage.com.au. Age 15 May 2010. Web. 4 Aug. 2010. Suggests that Tóibín draws connections between immigration to the United States and the recent increase of immigration to Ireland, of those who come with no history or connection to the land but with the desire to start over. McCrum, Robert. “You Can Take the Man Out of Ireland: Interview with Colm Tóibín.” observer. guardian.co.uk. Observer 26 Apr. 2009. Web.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
209
Brooklyn
4 Aug. 2010. Explains the mechanics of writing and his enjoyment of teaching. O’Kelly, Emer. “Delicate Portrait of a Soul Triumphs in Tóibín’s Tale.” Rev. of Brooklyn, by Colm Tóibín. independent.ie. Sunday Independent 3 May 2009. Web. 4 Aug. 2010. Claims that Brooklyn reveals the dreariness of a life held in check, where longings for escape are only tentative for a heroine who is bound by duty. Ross, Michael. “The Soul Trader.” Rev. of Brooklyn, by Colm Tóibín. thesundaytimes.com.uk. Sunday Times 26 Apr. 2009. Web 4 Aug. 2010. Links Tóibín’s childhood experience in Ireland with the experiences of the heroine in his novel. Schillinger, Liesl. “The Reluctant Emigrant.” Rev. of Brooklyn, by Colm Tóibín. nytimes.com. New York Times 3 May 2009. Web. 4 Aug. 2010. Discusses the heroine of Brooklyn, who never complains, even when complaining would serve her well. Taylor, Christopher, “The Country Girl.” Rev. of Brooklyn, by Colm Tóibín. guardian.co.uk. Guardian 9 May 2009. Web. 4 Aug. 2010. Explains that Tóibín uses humor and not sentimentality to describe the immigrant experience. Witchel, Alex. “His Irish Diaspora.” Rev. of Brooklyn, by Colm Tóibín. nytimes.com. New York Times 3 May 2009. Web. 4 Aug. 2010. Explores Tóibín’s childhood and influences on his writing, including a story he heard about Brooklyn many years earlier. Gale Resources
“Colm Toibin.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2010. Literature Resource Center. Web. 4 Aug. 2010. http//go.galegroup.com/ps/i.do?&id=GA LE%7CH1000114647&v=2.1&u=itsbtrial&it=r& p=LitRC&sw=w “Colm Toibin.” Contemporary Literary Criticism. Ed. Jeffrey W. Hunter. Vol. 285. Detroit: Gale, 2010. Literature Resource Center. Web. 4 Aug. 2010. http//go.galegroup.com/ps/i.do?&id=GALE% 7CH1107500000&v=2.1&u=itsbtrial&it=r& p=LitRC&sw=w Middleton, Tim. “Colm Toibin.” British and Irish Novelists since 1960. Ed. Merritt Moseley. Detroit: Gale, 2003. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 271. Literature Resource Center. Web. 4 Aug. 2010. http//go.galegroup.com/ps/i.do?&id=GALE% 7CH1200011139&v=2.1&u=itsbtrial&it=r& p=LitRC&sw=w
210
Open Web Sources
Tóibín maintains a Web site at: http//www.colmtoibin. com, which contains information about his novels and book signings. An interview with Tóibín on National Public Radio, in which he discusses characterization and immigration and the dynamics of family life in Brooklyn, can be found at http//www.npr.org/templates/story/sto ry.php?storyId=103761998 For Further Reading
Almeida, Linda Dowling. Irish Immigrants in New York City, 1945-1995. Bloomington: Indiana UP, 2001. Print. A survey focusing on the role of economics and social change as an indicator of Irish identity among recent Irish immigrants to New York City. Frommer, Harvey, and Myrna Katz Frommer. It Happened in Brooklyn: An Oral History of Growing Up in the Borough in the 1940s, 1950s, and 1960s. New York: State U of New York, 2009. Print. A collection of anecdotal memories culled from many interviews with Brooklyn residents. Hamburger, Eric. The Historical Atlas of New York City: A Visual Celebration of 400 Years of New York City’s History. New York: Holt, 2005. Print. An illustrated history of New York City, including the five boroughs. Martinez, Ruben, and Joseph Rodriguez. The New Americans. New York: New Press, 2004. Print. Companion book to the PBS series tracing the stories of seven immigrant families. Miller, Kerby A. Emigrants and Exiles: Ireland and the Irish Exodus to North America. New York: Oxford UP, 1985. Print. A social history that relies on primary source documents, such as letters and diaries, as well as historical documents to provide a history of the Irish immigration experience. Reiss, Marcia. Brooklyn Then and Now. San Diego: Thunder Bay Press, 2002. Print. A photographic history of Brooklyn, with oversized photos of historical Brooklyn, including then and now photos of Brooklyn landmarks. Tóibín, Colm. The Master. New York: Scribner’s, 2004. Print. A fictionalized study of Henry James. Sheri Karmiol
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Bruised Hibiscus By Elizabeth Nunez
W Introduction Set in 1950s Trinidad, Bruised Hibiscus (1994) is a novel about a friendship between two women that transcends class and racial barriers. When a fisherman recovers the body of a white woman from the sea, the rage and frustration that results leads to the reunion of two childhood friends, each haunted by a brutal crime they had witnessed years ago. Now reunited, the two women reestablish their bond and find the courage to face their own unhappy marriages. By confronting their complicated pasts and unhappy present, they then try to find fulfillment and happiness in their lives. Bruised Hibiscus also explores themes of colonialism, domestic violence and sexual oppression, and class and racial differences in colonial Trinidad. Upon its publication, Bruised Hibiscus was a commercial and critical success, receiving the American Book Award in 2001. As Sandra Adell maintains in her review, “In this novel [Elizabeth] Nunez weaves such a rich and well-crafted tapestry of legend, myth, and history that one cannot help comparing her to Toni Morrison, whose Song of Solomon stands out as a masterpiece among novels of the African diaspora.”
W Literary and Historical Context
Bruised Hibiscus is set in 1954 on the small Caribbean island of Trinidad, which for years has been grouped with its sister island, Tobago, and known as Trinidad and Tobago. Both islands were originally settled by Amerindians and encountered by Christopher Columbus in 1498. Trinidad was eventually colonized by the Spanish, but settled by the French, who developed the lucrative sugarcane industry. The Spanish surrendered Trinidad to the British in 1797. The British abolished slavery, which left a dearth of workers for the large sugarcane plantations
and the burgeoning cacao industry. In 1830s the British began a campaign to attract workers from China, West Africa, and India. Racial resentments between the different groups festered, and sometimes exploded into violence. The presence of workers from various nations also created class and racial barriers, which are explored in Bruised Hibiscus. Trinidad received its independence from the British Empire in 1962. The island nation became a republic in 1976. Elizabeth Nunez’s novel is set at the point at which British colonialism was beginning to loosen its grip on Trinidad. Although the ownership of most of the lucrative sugarcane business was in the hands of white colonialists, other immigrant groups were starting to gain economic and political power. Class and racial stratification were still entrenched, but the institutional structure that kept them in place was starting to show cracks. The real-life inspiration for the book can be found in the “Author’s Notes” at the close of the book. “On April 7, 1954, Dr. Dalip Singh, a Trinidadian physician, strangled his German wife, Paula Inge, removed her intestines, sutured her abdomen, ferried her body in a pirogue to the middle of the Gulf of Paria and dumped it there. The next morning her body floated up on the beach at Freeman’s Bay in Otahiti.” This horrific murder is fictionalized at the opening of Bruised Hibiscus, and acts as the catalyst for the reunion of two childhood friends, Rosa and Zuela.
W Themes Class, racial, and gender differences play a major role in Bruised Hibiscus. Many of the relationships in the novel are affected by the prejudices and discrimination found in Trinidadian society. For example, Cedric is haunted by feelings of inferiority because of his race and takes out his revenge on his white wife and other women. The Chinaman keeps Zuela under his control, a virtual prisoner in the family’s stores. The friendship between
211 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Bruised Hibiscus
MAJOR CHARACTERS CEDRIC is Rosa’s husband. The headmaster of a local secondary school, he has always felt inferior to whites despite his intellect. His marriage to Rosa has gone cold, and he often accuses her of infidelity. His increasingly menacing behavior leads Rosa to embark on her pilgrimage and her renewed friendship with Zuela. ROSA is a white Trinidadian, the youngest daughter of a British plantation owner and his mistreated wife. Rosa is suffering in a stifling marriage to Cedric, a black headmaster whom she suspects of unspeakable acts. When on a pilgrimage to the Shrine of Our Lady of Fatima, she runs into her old friend, Zuela, and renews her friendship with her. With Zuela’s help, she begins to confront her past. ZUELA is a black Trinidadian worn out from her terrible marriage to an opium-addicted Chinaman. After marriage at fourteen, bearing ten children, and being treated like a prisoner in her own house, she is ready to escape her dreadful marriage and begins a pilgrimage to the Shrine of Our Lady of Fatima, where she encounters a childhood friend, Rosa. Trying to help her old friend, she sends Rosa to a healer, Mary Christophe. Zuela finally finds the courage and resourcefulness to escape her marriage and find fulfillment and love.
Rosa, a wealthy white woman, and Zuela, a poor black one, is shadowed by class and racial issues. Yet both Rosa and Zuela are able to transcend those class and racial barriers to rekindle their childhood friendship and find the courage to try to address their past and move toward a better future. Another key theme in the novel centers on violence against women. With the story turning on an incident based on the true story of a husband’s brutal murder of his wife, Bruised Hibiscus documents the emotional and physical brutality of men toward women. As children, Rosa and Zuela witness a man’s vicious sexual assault of a young woman behind a bush, which bonds them together and yet tears their friendship apart. Cedric berates and demeans his wife, Rosa. The Chinaman maintains an iron grip on Zuela, keeping her pregnant and isolated from the greater community. It is only through Rosa and Zuela’s renewed friendship and a growing sisterhood that the two women are able to take steps to change their circumstances.
W Style When discussing the style of Bruised Hibiscus, most critics describe it as lyrical in quality. Some single out Nunez’s use of an authentic, rhythmic Trinidadian dialect, which
212
adds to the lyrical nature of the story. Other reviewers, like Sandra Adell, underscore the author’s use of symbolism and imagery. “The image of the young girl behind the hibiscus bush is one of several recurring images that contribute to the lyrical, almost incantatory quality of Bruised Hibiscus,” Adell states in her review in the African American Review. “They are disturbing images: images of a notorious gangster, Boysie Singh, who the islanders believe murders and cuts out the hearts of young women to rub on the hooves of his racehorses to make them run faster; of two pigs devouring the butchered body of a woman named Melda; of the opiumaddicted Chinaman’s recurring nightmares of his wife and daughter being slaughtered back in China; of Zelda, not much older than the ‘girl-child’ behind the hibiscus bush, being bargained over by her father and the Chinaman who came to her village in Venezuela ‘to buy alpagats [sandals] for his store and took her, too.’” Jessica Opad finds that Nunez’s lyrical style takes some time to find its legs, noting that the beginning of the novel is stilted and difficult. “Although Nunez’ poetic style helps set the tone of the novel, the first few chapters feel as if she tries too hard to be poetic, as her lengthy sentences can be hard to follow,” she maintains. “Once she introduces both of the main characters, however, she seems to become more comfortable with her narrative voice and abandons unnecessary lengthiness without losing the poetic flow of the novel.”
W Critical Reception Bruised Hibiscus received critical praise, earning an American Book Award in 2001. Critics commend Nunez for crafting a vivid and haunting story of horrible violence and a redemptive friendship between two damaged women. As reviewer Zakia comments, “Nunez is a gifted writer. She employs the brevity and repetition of poetry in her work. She writes unpretentiously, deftly inserting sex, murder and cruelty into a story that also speaks truth to friendship, love and a miracle or two. She is able to create a telling story that is not cheapened by the oftenexploited aforementioned themes. Her writing is like the sway in the walk of a confident woman. Buy it. Read it. It’s good.” In her review in the African American Review, Sandra Adell lauds Nunez’s ability to create a suspenseful novel. “She keeps her distance and lets her imagination and beautiful writing prevail,” Adell states. “The result is a stunning and often chilling work of fiction that one will find hard to put down or to forget.” Adell also reflects on Nunez’s position in black literature. “It is evident from her novels that Elizabeth Nunez’s imagination is likewise a storehouse of stories, legends, and myths,” she argues. “She is an accomplished writer who is creating a memorable space for herself in African diaspora literature. She is one of those rare novelists who must be read.” TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Bruised Hibiscus
Author Elizabeth Nunez’s Bruised Hibiscus is set on the Caribbean island of Trinidad; pictured here is Trinidad's Maracas Bay. PHB.cz (Richard Semik)/Shutterstock.com
New York Times reviewer Jana Giles does find flaws in the novel. “Nunez’s shrewd employment of native dialect enlivens the narrative, but without efficiently enhancing plot or character,” she states. “She fails to handle suspense well, frequently revealing just enough of what will happen next to diminish your desire to actually read about it. And she interrupts what could have been a fluid fictional dream with too much commentary and too many descriptive passages. It’s as if she never quite comes to see her characters as more than vehicles for conveying ideas.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Adell, Sandra. Rev. of Bruised Hibiscus, by Elizabeth Nunez. African American Review 35 (2001). Print. BNET. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. Giles, Jana. “Trouble in Paradise.” New York Times Book Review 105.15 (9 Apr. 2000). Print. General OneFile. Web. 23 Sept. 2010. Opad, Jessica. Rev. of Bruised Hibiscus, by Elizabeth Nunez. Voices from the Gap (17 June 2009). Web. 13 Sept. 2010. Zakia. Rev. of Bruised Hibiscus, by Elizabeth Nunez. ColoredGirls.com (2002). Web. 13 Sept. 2010.
Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Rev. of Bruised Hibiscus, by Elizabeth Nunez. Publishers Weekly 241. 41 (10 Oct. 1994): 62. Print. Deems Bruised Hibiscus to be a “thoughtful critique of race, gender, and class relations” in Trinidad in the midtwentieth century. Rev. of Bruised Hibiscus, by Elizabeth Nunez. Publishers Weekly 247.9 (28 Feb. 2000): 59. Print. Classifies Bruised Hibiscus as a work of Caribbean Gothic and praises Nunez’s deft use of authentic Trinidadian dialect. Nussbaum, Lisa S. Rev. of Bruised Hibiscus, by Elizabeth Nunez. Library Journal 125.5 (15 Mar. 2000): 128. Print. Recommends Bruised Hibiscus as a beautifully written novel with well-drawn and sympathetic characters. Gale Resources
“Elizabeth Nunez.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Literature Resource Center. Web. 11 Sept. 2010. “Elizabeth Nunez.” Black Literature Criticism: Classic and Emerging Authors Since 1950, Vol. 3, 2nd ed. 147-58. Print. From Gale Virtual Reference Library. Web. 23 Sept. 2010.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
213
Bruised Hibiscus
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Elizabeth Nunez was born on February 18, 1944, in Cocorite, Trinidad. Her father, Waldo, was an oil company executive and labor commissioner for the government, and Elizabeth grew up in comfortable circumstances. At the age of nine, she won a children’s writing competition in the Trinidad Guardian, which spurred her interest in fiction writing. After graduating from high school, she worked briefly for Shell Oil Company. In 1963 she traveled to Wisconsin to enroll in Marian College, a small Catholic women’s college. There she experienced widespread racism and hostility as one of the few black students at the college during the turbulent years of the civil rights struggle. In 1967 she graduated with a BA in English and returned to Trinidad, intent on becoming a teacher. When she was consistently turned down in favor of Canadian candidates, Nunez became an outspoken activist against the prejudicial hiring practices of her homeland. She immigrated to the United States, settling in New York City in 1968. Nunez earned her MA in English from New York University in 1971 and became an instructor at Medgar Evers College, City University of New York. In 1977 she earned her PhD from New York University. Her first novel, When Rocks Dance, was published in 1986. Nunez formed the National Black Writers Conference with her friend, the author John Oliver Killens, and served as director from 1986 through 2000. She has edited anthologies of Caribbean writing and has published essays and book reviews. In 2001 she was awarded an American Book Award for her novel, Bruised Hibiscus.
Open Web Sources
The website for the Center for Black Literature at Medgar Evers College is a resource for students to study the literature of the African Diaspora. It also links to the latest information for The National Black Writers’ Conference, lists recent publications, and has a photo gallery of the group’s events. http//www.centerfor blackliterature.org/
about the show is available at the Black Writers in America website. http//www.cuny.tv/series/bwa/ index.lasso The official website of Trinidad and Tobago, http://www. ttconnect.gov.tt/gortt/portal/ttconnect, provides links to government ministries, such as the Ministry of Tourism. Research, statistics on tourism, pictures, video, and maps of Trinidad are available. For Further Reading
Allen-Agostini, Lisa, and Jeanne, Mason, eds. Trinidad Noir. New York: Akashic Books, 2008. Print. A noir anthology comprising eighteen stories set in the sunny locale of Trinidad and Tobago. Written by different authors, the stories use the beauty of the natural environment and juxtapose it with the violence, political corruption, poverty, and drug culture found on the island. Danticat, Edwidge. Krik! Krak! New York: Soho Press, 1995. Print. A collection of autobiographical stories that illuminate Danticat’s sorrow at leaving her tyrannized country of Haiti and her difficulty adjusting to a new land. Several of the stories explore the immigrant experience. Neptune, Harvey R. Caliban and the Yankees: Trinidad and the United States Occupation. Chapel Hill: U of North Carolina P, 2007. Print. In this informative history, Neptune chronicles the installation and operation of U.S. military bases on Trinidad and Tobago during World War II and the uneasy relationship between the two countries in the postwar years. Nunez, Elizabeth. Beyond the Limbo Silence. Seattle: Seal Press, 1998. Print. In this autobiographical novel, a young Trinidadian woman receives a scholarship to a small Catholic women’s college in Wisconsin. Alienated from her privileged white classmates, she finds purpose in the burgeoning civil rights movement and a passionate relationship with a driven black activist.
Nunez’s PBS series on black writers, Black Writers in America, premiered in 2003. More information
214
Margaret Haerens
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Bullet Collection By Patricia Sarrafian Ward
W Introduction The Bullet Collection is an account of two troubled girls growing up in Beirut during the Lebanese Civil War (19751991), told from the perspective of exile in the United States. The story is narrated by the younger of the two sisters, seventeen-year-old Marianna, whose memories move back and forth in time and space between her ravaged homeland and her difficult new life in America. The novel records a childhood in which regular daily activities—going to school, preparing meals, meeting boys—take place amid routine sniper fire, air raids, and shelling attacks, the debris from which is retrieved by the older sister, Alaine, in a failed effort to objectify the daily brutality and forms the collection of war relics of the title. Both girls suffer crippling depression from their inability to process the violence and the inexplicable unwillingness of the older generation to speak of it. The Bullet Collection is modeled on the personal experiences of the author. Like her protagonist, Patricia Sarrafian Ward was raised in war-torn Beirut by an American father and Lebanese Armenian mother. Her family, too, resolved to escape the bloodshed and fled to the United States in 1987. Although the Lebanese Civil War has inspired many works of fiction, in English as well as Arabic, The Bullet Collection is distinguished by its adolescent narrator and its disturbing portrayal of the psychological effects of war on children too young to understand it.
W Literary and Historical Context
In a 2005 essay, Syrine C. Hout drew attention to a recent corpus of Lebanese exilic writing that included The Bullet Collection. Hout noted, “The last decade has seen the rise of Anglophone and Francophone novels by
Lebanese-born first-time authors who spent their childhood and adolescence, fully or partially, in war-torn Lebanon between 1975 and 1991.” Hout went on to describe some typical features of this literature of exile, written not only from the vantage point of geographic dislocation but also in hindsight, giving the authors some critical distance from the immediacy of the violence that forced their relocation. The Lebanese Civil War caused an estimated one million people to flee the country; more than 100,000 people were killed, many of them civilians, and approximately 17,000 people went missing. The conflict largely developed along Muslim and Christian lines and was exacerbated by the presence of Palestinian guerrillas. Early in the strife, battles between Christian Phalangists and Muslims from the Lebanese National Movement destroyed much of Beirut and led to the establishment of a “green line” separating Muslim West Beirut and Christian East Beirut. The city remained divided until the end of the conflict. Various foreign influences, including troops from Israel, Syria, France, and the United States, complicated the struggle, as did the increasing illegitimacy of certain home militias involved in criminal activities. The war caused the collapse of administrative and other public services in Beirut and disintegration of the infrastructure. It was amid this atmosphere that Ward—and the family in her book—left Lebanon for safety in the United States.
W Themes In her essay on Lebanese literature of exile, Hout identified several themes common to the genre: expatriation, memory, and identity. The idea of identity in The Bullet Collection takes on layered significance as it invokes Marianna’s premature coming of age, as well as her divided loyalty to her country. Throughout the story, Ward develops contrasting identities of the sisters. Marianna, fair and blue-eyed like her father, looks like
215 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Bullet Collection
MAJOR CHARACTERS ALAINE is the sister of the narrator, Marianna, two years older and obsessed with visiting battle sites in Beirut. Her war souvenirs—bullets, grenades, shrapnel—form the collection mentioned in the title of the novel. She is severely damaged by the war psychologically but recovers in the United States. DADDY is the father of Alaine and Marianna. A respected historian in Beirut, he applies for a job at a supermarket in the United States. MARIANNA is the seventeen-year-old narrator who revisits wartorn Beirut in her disjointed memories. Once the stronger of the two sisters, she adjusts poorly to life in the United States while Alaine thrives. MUMMY is the mother of Alaine and Marianna. She suffers in silence or tears and is traumatized by the war’s effect on her family. UNCLE BERNIE is a member of the family, mysteriously kidnapped and then shot.
an outsider in her home country, while Alaine possesses the dark eyes and hair of Middle Easterners. In Beirut, it is Marianna who struggles to understand Alaine’s desperation but, once they arrive in the United States, Alaine adjusts well to their strange circumstances while Marianna begins skipping school and abusing drugs. It is now Marianna who becomes obsessed with cataloging images of war, which for her exist alongside reflections on the more idyllic Beirut of her earliest memories. Marianna is nostalgic and insists on maintaining a vital connection to Lebanon, but she is frustrated in her efforts to resuscitate this past by her family’s denial of all that came before. Ward frequently juxtaposes images of the United States and Lebanon to further explore Marianna’s conflicted loyalties to an America that has given her family safe shelter and to a Lebanon “that insists on being remembered even after forcing us to leave” (qtd. on DePauw University English Department website).
W Style The text of The Bullet Collection is divided into three seasons—autumn, summer, and winter—but Marianna’s
In the story, Alaine collects bullet casings and other debris left behind after battles in the Lebanese Civil War as a means by which to objectify the everyday violence. David Maska/Shutterstock.com
216
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Bullet Collection
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Born and raised in Beirut, Lebanon, during the time of the civil war (1975-1991) that devastated the city, Patricia Sarrafian Ward and her family fled to the United States in 1987. She attended Sarah Lawrence College and then received an MFA from the University of Michigan, where she won the Hopwood Award for an early version of her highly praised debut novel, The Bullet Collection (2003). The Bullet Collection describes the impact of the civil war on a Beirut family from the perspective of a teenage refugee in the United States determined to maintain a connection with her homeland. Ward’s short stories have appeared in numerous publications. She has currently changed directions in her career, devoting her time to book arts, including printing and miniatures.
The Bullet Collection follows the story of two young sisters during the Lebanese Civil War, a conflict in which Yasser Arafat, pictured on the left, played an important role. ª Bettmann/Corbis
memories move freely back and forth between the past and the present in a manner some critics say evokes the disjointed thoughts of a child unable to comprehend her chaotic surroundings. The language of The Bullet Collection has been described as “sensual” (Salem) and “lyrical, dreamlike” (Armenian Reporter International). A writer for Kirkus Reviews referred to the style of the novel as “densely impressionist,” adding, “Ward orders her circuitous tale only by seasons, backtracking years behind, then fast-forwarding to the family’s sad, listless exile in America in what is perhaps an imitation of the erratic workings of childhood memory.”
W Critical Reception The Bullet Collection received the Anahid Literary Award from the Armenian Center at Columbia University as well as prizes recognizing talented new writers from the Hala Maksoud Foundation and the Great Lakes College Association. The novel has been frequently praised for its insight into the psychological effects of war, especially the sisters’ self-destructive tendencies as substitution for a repressed emotional response to violence. Susannah Tarbush remarked, for example, “The girls’ psychological breakdown could be seen as a sane response to a world that has gone mad.” The depth of the characterizations has been considered all the more impressive in a novel that vividly documents the experience of war. Elise Salem
remarked on the balance achieved in The Bullet Collection: “I was especially pleased that Ward was able to maintain a plotline and a host of engaging characters while, at the same time, narrating the complex emotional dimensions of the war. Many other ‘war novels’ have drowned in the war itself.” Hout devoted a second essay entirely to The Bullet Collection as a representation of trauma theory. Donna Seaman also remarked on the book’s broader implications: “In Ward’s powerful debut novel, two sisters and their Beirut family serve as a microcosm for all the resiliency and magic of that war-torn city and all the tragedy of the endless bloodshed in the Middle East.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Rev. of The Bullet Collection, by Patricia Sarrafian Ward. Kirkus Reviews 71.3 (1 Feb. 2003): 179. Print. Hout, Syrine C. “Memory, Home, and Exile in Contemporary Anglophone Lebanese Fiction.” CRITIQUE: Studies in Contemporary Fiction 46.3 (2005): 219. Print. ———. “Revisiting Lebanon: Testimony, Trauma, and Transition in Patricia Sarrafian Ward’s The Bullet Collection.” Middle Eastern Literatures 12.3 (2009): 271-88. Web. 20 Sept. 2010. “Patricia Sarrafian Ward.” DePauw University English Department Visiting Writers, Fall 2004. Web. 22 Sept. 2010. “Patricia Sarrafian Ward Wins GLCA’s New Writers Award.” Armenian Reporter International 36.44 (14 Aug. 2004): 22. Ethnic NewsWatch, ProQuest. Web. 20 Sept. 2010. Salem, Elise. “Patricia Sarrafian Ward, The Bullet Collection.” Literary Review 46.4 (2003): 769. Print.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
217
The Bullet Collection
Seaman, Donna. “Ward, Patricia Sarrafian. The Bullet Collection.” Booklist 99.13 (1 Mar. 2003): 1143. Print. Tarbush, Susannah. “Patricia Sarrafian Ward and Her Novel The Bullet Collection.” Dar Al-Hayat [Saudi Arabia] 18 Sept. 2003. Author website. Web. 22 Sept. 2010.
For Further Reading
Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Chadwell, Faye A. “The Bullet Collection.” Library Journal 128.5 (15 Mar. 2003): 118. Print. Complimentary synopsis concluding that Ward is a “writer to watch.” “Patricia Sarrafian Ward’s The Bullet Collection.” Armenian Reporter 5 Jan. 2008: C19. Ethnic NewsWatch, ProQuest. Web. 20 Sept. 2010. Praises Ward for bringing to light a story that will ring true to the thousands afflicted by the civil war in Lebanon. Gale Resources
Rev. of The Bullet Collection, by Patricia Sarrafian Ward. Publishers Weekly 250.16 (21 Apr. 2003): 40. Plot summary emphasizing the well-developed contrast between Lebanon and the United States and the inversion of the girls’ roles. “Ward, Patricia Sarrafian 1969-.” Contemporary Authors. Vol. 224. Detroit: Gale, 2005. Gale Virtual Reference Library. Web. 19 Sept. 2010. Open Web Sources
The author’s website provides links to Ward’s biography, a list of her publications, and reviews of The Bullet Collection available online. http//www.patriciasarra fianward.com/Publications.html
218
The website for Ward’s publisher, Graywolf Press, offers an excerpt from The Bullet Collection, highlights from reviews of the book, and discussion topics critical to the story. http//www.graywolfpress.org/Related_ Content/Discussion_Topics/Discussion_Topics_ Bullet_Collection/ Alameddine, Rabih. The Perv: Stories. New York: Picador, 1999. Print. Eight short stories describing the alienating effects of the diaspora on people caught up in the Lebanese Civil War. Al-Shaykh, Hanan. Beirut Blues. New York: Anchor, 1996. Print. Novel told in the form of letters written by a woman trying to make sense of her life in a warravaged Beirut. ———. The Story of Zahra. New York: Anchor, 1996. Print. Records the devastating psychological effects of the Lebanese Civil War on a directionless young misfit mistreated by men, including a boyfriend who may or may not be a rooftop sniper in Beirut. This novel was banned in several Arab countries as giving a false impression of Arab culture. Jarrar, Nada Awar. Dreams of Water. New York: Harper, 2007. Print. Novel in which the author records her own exile from Beirut in the form of a story about a Lebanese family whose son goes missing in the civil war. ———. A Good Land. New York: HarperCollins, 2009. Print. Considers the effect of Israel’s 2006 bombing of Beirut on several characters from different generations, all connected by the same city block and their displacement in the earlier civil war. Janet Mullane
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Camouflage By Joe Haldeman
W Introduction Camouflage, written in 2004 by Joe Haldeman, tells the story of a strange vessel that crashed to Earth millions of years ago and the evolution of the two beings who presumably came from it. The novel switches among three points of view, as two serial flashbacks follow the two shape-changers, named The Changeling and The Chameleon, through history, while a third narrative charts the discovery of the artifact in 2019 and researchers’ subsequent attempts to open it. Like many of Haldeman’s novels, Camouflage deals with what it means to be human, the ways in which we evolve and learn to love, and the struggle to build and maintain a personal moral code. Haldeman has been called “one of the most important science fiction writers of our time,” and Camouflage adds to his list of successes, having won the James Tiptree Award for Science Fiction in 2004, and the Nebula, awarded by the Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America, in 2005 (Graham).
W Literary and Historical Context
Joe Haldeman believes that “the science fiction writers are some of the few people who are trying to understand what the true drivers of our times were” (“Science Fiction”). Science fiction writing “tells a ripping yarn while also asking serious questions about mankind, about mankind’s place in the universe, about the universe itself” (Sallis). Haldeman’s time in Vietnam greatly influences his writing, and Camouflage is no exception. The author uses the Changeling’s evolution to explore the theme of war, and the “necessity of maintaining a strict moral code in opposition to humanity’s predominant amorality” (“Joe Haldeman 1943-”). The creature contends “the gulf between the two sides was so large it was as if they were two different species.” The Changeling wishes it “had an
opportunity to observe other cultures than American without the complication of war.” Even when the war ends, it observes, “It looked as if there might be just one World War, with breathing spaces for rearming, that would last until somebody won” (129). Cecilia Tan, one of the jurors for the James Tiptree Award, said of Camouflage, “This book explores the human condition as thoroughly as any literary work, with understanding of gender at the crux of that understanding” (James Tiptree Award website). The Changeling comes ashore in 1931, an “ageless, sexless entity,” (Le Guin, qtd. in “Camouflage, Joe Haldeman”) but after assuming many identities, both male and female, it finally settles, in 2021, on a female identity. “As it grows more human, the choice becomes more important to it; it ends up a woman by preference. If gender isn’t the central concern of this novel, it’s near the center, and the handling of it is skillful, subtle, and finely unpredictable” (Le Guin).
W Themes As James Sallis writes in the Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction, Camouflage seeks an answer to the question, “What does it mean to be human?” Haldeman’s writing frequently features characters who “attain selfawareness as a result of their moral opposition to the corrupt and uncaring systems they purportedly represent” (“Joe Haldeman 1943-”). As the Changeling makes its way through history, it becomes, at one point, a prisoner on the Bataan Death March. After watching several Japanese soldiers encourage a group of American soldiers to drink water from a stagnant pool, and then shoot them for it, the Changeling realizes it is “having difficulty trying to generalize about human nature” (109). Haldeman grapples with the problem of evil, the ways in which we learn, and the foundations of ethics, as the Changeling not only realizes “it had seen enough killing in the Pacific to reserve it as a course of last resort”
219 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Camouflage
MAJOR CHARACTERS THE CHAMELEON is a shape-changer of unknown origin, come to Earth before the time of Jesus Christ. The Chameleon can instantly adopt any human shape, delights in destruction and killing, and is seemingly immortal. THE CHANGELING, a shape-changer from the globular cluster Messier 22, landed on Earth in a vessel that crashed into the Pacific Ocean more than one million years ago. Eventually forgetting its origins, the creature has taken various forms, eventually coming ashore as a human in 1931. The Changeling, unlike the Chameleon, can assume both organic and nonorganic forms. JAN DAGMAR is an exobiologist brought in by NASA to head up the artifact research team. JACK HALLIBURTON is the scientist and ex-military man who approaches Russell Sutton with a proposal to explore the artifact. RUSSELL SUTTON, the researcher who famously raised the Titanic, is the head of Poseiden Projects, an organization devoted to marine resource management and exploration. After the discovery of a strange vessel in the TongaKermadec Trench off the coast of Samoa, Sutton leads a team in their efforts to bring the artifact ashore and attempt to open it.
but also eventually learns to love a human (Sallis). The creature comments that she knows not only love, but “human nature, darling, maybe better than you do. And outsider with almost a century of observation. . . . I know xenophobia, too. I’ve been black and Asian and Hispanic in America . . . a white prisoner on the Bataan Death March. . . . There’s nobody on this planet more ‘different’ than me” (275). Haldeman says “of course I hope that the world will read my books and renounce war and prejudice and bad food,” but that in the end, “all anybody reasonable can hope for is that the world has a little more meaning or complexity or love because you were in it” (qtd. in “Joe Haldeman, Contemporary Authors Online).
Journal, cites the author’s “customary economy of words,” and Cecilia Tan, one of the jurors for the Tiptree Award, compares Haldeman’s style to the minimalist prose of Ernest Hemingway. Haldeman himself has said that the rhythm of his writing is almost as important as the story itself. “I’ll say a line over and over until it sounds right, and then write it down. I go over it . . . once backwards, so I don’t pay attention to the text, but rather to the patterns of words. I know that one error I always make is repetition, so I’m on the lookout for individual words repeated, and rhetorical patterns as well” (“Joe Haldeman,” Contemporary Authors Online). Camouflage also reflects the writer’s typically dry sense of humor: When the Chameleon, an immortal shape-shifter, hears of Jesus, Haldeman writes, “It was as a Parthian that he heard the story of Jesus Christ, which interested him. Killed in public and then resurrected, he was evidently a relative. He would keep an eye out for him” (66).
W Critical Reception
W Style As Gregory Feeley points out in the Washington Post, Haldeman’s skillful development of the plot helps the reader accept its more implausible details. Yet, Feeley continues, while “Haldeman’s adept plotting, strong pacing, and sense of grim stoicism have won him wide acclaim, . . . for me the great virtue in his fiction lies in its style. His prose is laconic, compact, seemingly offhand but quite precise.” Jackie Cassada, writing for Library
220
The novel Camouflage is based on the arrival and evolution of two alien beings that most likely emerged from an unidentified spacecraft millions of years ago. Yellowj/Shutterstock.com
Most reviewers of Camouflage agree with Cecilia Tan, juror for the Tiptree Award, who called it “one of the best science fiction books I have read in years” (Tan, qtd. in “Camouflage, Joe Haldeman”). According to Carl Hays of Booklist, “Haldeman proves as engaging a storyteller as ever, especially given this book’s irresistible premise and page-turning action.” Many praise the skill with which Haldeman handles the complexity of the novel’s three story lines. “Haldeman handles this TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Camouflage
complicated scheme effortlessly, and the ending is satisfying whether or not you have figured out who is who” (Jonas). The only bone of contention seems to be the ending, which some found unsatisfying. “Wellconstructed and intriguingly set up,” commented a reviewer in Kirkus Reviews, “but ultimately a disagreeable surprise: the story slips away, and you’re left holding an empty coat.” However, most called the climax “stunning,” and Gregory Feeley, writing for the Washington Post, states, “That it does not push the envelope doesn’t make it any less enjoyable.” James Sallis contends that it is our attachment to Haldeman’s characters that makes his novels so ultimately satisfying, regardless of any issue taken with the ending. “And that is of course what makes Joe Haldeman a first-rate novelist . . . his characters are forever real to us, forever authentic. They choke up, and we find ourselves clearing our throats.” Roland Green, writing in Booklist, noted, “Haldeman couldn’t write a bad book to win a bet” (qtd. in “Joe Haldeman,” Contemporary Authors Online).
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Joseph William Haldeman was born in 1943 in Oklahoma City, Oklahoma and earned his BS from the University of Maryland in 1967. He wanted to be an astronaut, but he was drafted into the U.S. Army that same year and was badly injured in Vietnam when, as he describes it, he “stood too close to a booby-trap when a booby set it off” (qtd. in Hicks). After returning home, Haldeman sold two science fiction stories he’d written while taking an undergraduate creative writing course. He eventually earned his MFA. in creative writing from the Iowa Writers’ Workshop in 1975. The winner of numerous science fiction awards, Haldeman has published more than twenty novels and a half dozen short story collections and has also received the Rhysling Award, for science fiction poetry. Haldeman is an adjunct professor in the Program in Writing and Humanistic Studies at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, where he has taught since 1983.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Rev. of Camouflage, by Joe Haldeman. Kirkus Reviews 15 May 2004: 477. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 3 Aug. 2010.
“Joe Haldeman.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Literature Resource Center. Web. 30 July 2010.
“Camouflage, Joe Haldeman.” The Official Website of The James Tiptree, Jr., Literary Award Council. Web. 4 Aug. 2010.
“Joe Haldeman 1943-.” Contemporary Literary Criticism. Ed. Roger Matuz, Cathy Falk, and Mary K. Gillis. Vol. 61. Detroit: Gale Research, 1990. 168-87. Print. Literature Criticism Online. Web. 30 July 2010.
Cassada, Jackie. “Haldeman, Joe. Camouflage.” Review of Camouflage, by Joe Haldeman. Library Journal Aug. 2004: 72. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 3 Aug. 2010. Feeley, Gregory. “From a Gathering of Lost Pilgrims to a Nation’s Capital of the Future-Four Forays into the Magical.” Review of Camouflage, by Joe Haldeman. Washington Post 3 Oct. 2004. Print. Highbeam Research. Web. 30 July 2010. Graham, Mark. “Books at a Glance.” Rev. of Camouflage, by Joe Haldeman. Rocky Mountain News 17 Sept. 2004. Print. Highbeam Research. Web. 30 July 2010.
Jonas, Gerald. “Science Fiction.” Rev. of Camouflage, by Joe Haldeman. New York Times Book Review 18 July 2004: 19. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 30 July 2010. Sallis, James. “Life.” Rev. of Camouflage, by Joe Haldeman. Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction Dec. 2005: 38. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 3 Aug. 2010. “Science Fiction.” Media in Transition website. 29 Aug. 1998. Web. 2 Aug. 2010.
Haldeman, Joe. Camouflage. New York: Penguin Group, 2004. Print.
Additional Resources
Hays, Carl. Rev. of Camouflage, by Joe Haldeman. Booklist Aug. 2004: 1913. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 3 Aug. 2010.
“Ace Books.” Rev. of Camouflage, by Joe Haldeman. Library Bookwatch 1 Sept. 2004. Print. Highbeam Research. Web. 30 July 2010. A short review of Camouflage.
Hicks, James Scott. “Joe (William) Haldeman.” TwentiethCentury American Science-Fiction Writers. Ed. David Cowart and Thomas L. Wymer. Detroit: Gale Research, 1981. Print. Also covered in Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 8. Detroit: Gale Research, 1981. 198-201. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 30 July 2010.
Criticism and Reviews
“SF/Fantasy/Horror Notes.” Rev. of Camouflage, by Joe Haldeman. Publishers Weekly 26 July 2004: 42+. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 3 Aug. 2010. A short, mixed review of Camouflage, with a focus on the novel’s problematic ending.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
221
Camouflage Gale Resources
“Joe Haldeman.” Authors and Artists for Young Adults, Volume 38. Gale Group, 2001. Biography Resource Center. Farmington Hills: Gale, 2010. Web. 30 July 2010. “Joe W. Haldeman.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2010. Literature Resource Center. Web. 3 Aug. 2010. “Joe (William) Haldeman.” St. James Guide to Science Fiction Writers, 4th ed. Detroit: St. James Press, 1996. Biography Resource Center. Web. 30 July 2010. Stableford, Brian. “Joe Haldeman.” Science Fiction Writers: Critical Studies of the Major Authors from the Early Nineteenth Century to the Present Day. Ed. Everett Franklin Bleiler. New York: Scribner’s, 1982. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 30 July 2010. Open Web Sources
Joe Haldeman’s official website at http://home.earth link.net/˜haldeman includes biographical information about the author, as well as an autobiographical essay, interesting FAQs, information about Haldeman’s books, his hobbies, the courses he teaches at MIT, and his travel and cumulative diaries. Haldeman’s blog on Live Journal, http://joe-haldeman. livejournal.com/ has new entries nearly every day, with comments from readers. The website for the James Tiptree Award, http://tiptree. org/, includes information about the award—an annual literary prize for science fiction or fantasy that expands or explores the understanding of gender—as well as information about current and past winners. The website for the Nebula Awards, http://www .nebulaawards.com/, managed by the Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America, has information
222
about past winners, as well as interviews and links to guest blogs. For Further Reading
Clement, Hal. Needle. New York: Avon, 1976. Print. In Clement’s science fiction classic, an alien detective on the trail of a murderer of the same species crashes to Earth on an isolated island. Requiring a host, the detective, called The Hunter, takes up residence in a fifteen year-old boy to track his quarry. Also published as From Outer Space, Needle is out of print but used copies are available on Amazon, as well as an audio version. Haldeman, Joe. The Forever War. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1974. Print. In Haldeman’s story of an interstellar war between humans and an alien race called the Taurans, special ships called collapsars are used to travel to enemy planets. Among the many difficulties the soldiers must face, one of the most difficult is that because time in space passes at a different rate, the soldiers return home to find that they have aged only a year in the passing of three decades on Earth. “Sci-fi Fans Embrace Worlds Beyond.” Gazette 23 Jan. 2005. Print. Highbeam Research. Web. 30 July 2010. A short article about the annual COSine Science Fiction Convention, which Joe Haldeman attends every year with his wife. Westerfeld, Scott. Polymorph. New York: Roc, 1997. Print. In Westerfeld’s novel, a young shape-shifter makes her way through a futuristic New York City, changing her appearance at will. She believes she is the only one of her kind, until she meets another, older shape-shifter with evil intentions, and must stop him. Bisanne Masoud
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Captain of the Sleepers By Mayra Montero
W Introduction Originally published in Spanish as El capitán de los dormidos (2002), Captain of the Sleepers (2005) is Mayra Montero’s story of traumatic events that haunt two men for more than five decades. At the opening of the novel, J. T. Bunker, an eighty-three-year-old former pilot, is dying of cancer. Seeking peace, he asks Andrés Yasín, the son of his former lover, to meet him on St. Croix; he wants to discuss a dramatic incident from their shared past. As the two men enter into uneasy conversation, their memories take them back in time to Vieques, Puerto Rico, in the late 1940s and early 1950s. The two men take turns narrating as their shared history unfolds and glimpses of the truth of the central mystery emerge. Set against the backdrop of the failed struggle for Puerto Rican independence, Captain of the Sleepers traces the aftereffects of both personal and national traumas. It has been praised for its portrayal of lost innocence and political strife.
W Literary and Historical Context
Much of Montero’s novel is set on Vieques, a small island that is part of Puerto Rico. In 1898, with the defeat of Spain in the Spanish-American War, Puerto Rico fell under American control. During World War II the United States began to use the islands as a naval base. Many of the country’s agricultural workers, already suffering from the decline of the sugar industry, were evicted from the lands they had occupied. In the novel, Andrés’s mother makes frequent trips to a camp of dispossessed islanders, delivering food and old clothing. The residents must also deal with navy bombing
maneuvers and the constant stench of the fish killed by the bombs. The Puerto Rican independence movement is another focus of the novel. Puerto Rico has a lengthy colonial history, first under Spain and then under the United States. During the 1930s and 1940s, several attempts to gain independence from American rule failed. On October 30, 1950, nationalists launched attacks on American targets throughout Puerto Rico. In Captain of the Sleepers, Andrés’s father, Frank Yasín, is committed to the nationalist cause and recruits J. T. to smuggle weapons in his plane. The novel is dedicated to the memory of two historical figures who appear in the story as friends of the Yasín family: Roberto Acevedo, a nationalist who was killed in the uprising, and Vidal Santiago, a barber who served a lengthy prison sentence for his role in the uprising.
W Themes Questions of Puerto Rican nationalism, cultural identity, and relations with the United States are central to Captain of the Sleepers. Montero also explores the lifelong effects of childhood trauma. The pivotal crisis of the novel occurred some fifty years in the past, when twelve-year-old Andrés saw (or thought he saw) J. T. perform an act of sexual violence so taboo and grotesque that, as Andrés explains, “I turned into a half-crazed boy, staring at the wall and talking to imaginary lights.” J. T. insists that Andrés misunderstood what he saw. Equally haunted by that moment, J. T. avows: “My life ended that day, Andrés. I got sick too. A sickness that’s lasted fifty years.” Sexual violence is tied to another of the novel’s thematic concerns: political oppression and the displacement of Puerto Rican people by American forces. In the narrative, a young woman who makes money offering herself sexually to American soldiers is brutally murdered. The servicemen responsible are never brought to
223 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Captain of the Sleepers
MAJOR CHARACTERS SANTA makes money selling sexual favors to American servicemen. She also provides Andrés with his earliest sexual experiences, allowing him to touch and kiss her naked body. She is later murdered by servicemen. ROBERTO ACEVEDO, a historical figure, was killed in the October 30, 1950, uprisings in Puerto Rico. In the novel, he is Estela Yasín’s lover. JOHN TIMOTHY (J. T.) BUNKER, an American pilot, is one of the novel’s narrators. The titular Captain of the Sleepers, he gained his nickname ferrying dead bodies from one island to another for burial. In the 1940s he was in love with Andrés’s mother. In the present-day narrative, he is eightythree years old. Suffering from terminal cancer, he meets with Andrés and attempts to explain the events that unfolded many years earlier. VIDAL SANTIAGO, a barber and nationalist revolutionary, is also a historical figure. In the story, he is a frequent guest at Andrés’s father’s hotel. ANDRÉS YASÍN, the other narrator, is a sixty-two-year-old Columbia University-educated former district attorney who comes to St. Croix to meet with J. T. Bunker at the older man’s request. He has been haunted throughout his life by his mother’s suicide and by what he believed he witnessed afterward. ESTELA YASÍN is the wife of Frank and the mother of Andrés. She has a brief affair with J. T. Bunker before turning her affections to her childhood friend, the nationalist revolutionary Roberto Acevedo. The two plan to run away. After Roberto is killed, she commits suicide. The events surrounding her death have haunted Andrés for fifty years. FRANK YASÍN is Estela’s husband and Andrés’s father. The owner of a hotel on the island of Vieques, he becomes involved in revolutionary activity. He is close friends with J. T. Bunker, whose help he enlists in smuggling arms for the nationalist cause.
justice, though their identities are widely known. A review by the Nation’s Kate Levin suggests that this murder “reveals one of the novel’s great strengths: Montero’s ability to convey how people viscerally experience the depredations of colonialism.”
W Style Captain of the Sleepers is in part a historical novel, drawing on real-life events and figures. Montero, who has been active in calling for Puerto Rican independence,
224
sympathetically depicts the plight of the people of Vieques, demonstrating how they have been dispossessed by the American military presence. In bringing to life Roberto Acevedo and Vidal Santiago, she humanizes the nationalist movement. The work also reads as a mystery novel. The plot opens with Andrés’s mention of the central traumatic incident, but the details are not revealed until much later in the novel. As the narrative alternates between Andrés’s present-day confrontation with J. T. and the late 1940s and 1950s, the events that shaped both men’s lives come to light. The often rapid shifts between the two time periods emphasize how deeply the past affects the present. Hilda Lloréns writes in the Women’s Review of Books, “Montero tells a brilliant story, skillfully using the past to narrate a tale of the present. With delicate and forceful prose, she evokes feelings of heartbreak and rage.” While Andrés recounts most of the story in the first person, the narration is occasionally assumed by J. T. Through him, the reader learns details that Andrés could not have known and others that, as a child, he could not have understood. Often, events that Andrés remembers are later recounted by J. T., who gives them a new layer of meaning. The interplay between the two narratives further develops the themes of truth, subjectivity, and history.
W Critical Reception When El capitán de los dormidos was published in 2002, Montero’s earlier works had already made her popular with Spanish-speaking readers. The 2005 publication of the novel’s critically acclaimed English translation earned Montero international recognition. Readers and critics alike have been captivated by the book’s suspenseful plot. Kirkus Reviews attributes to Montero “a wizard’s ability to transfix readers’ attention as she peels away successive, deceptive layers of plot and meaning.” In addition, the author has been widely praised for her sensitive treatment of childhood trauma and its aftereffects; and her elegant writing and storytelling powers have drawn admiration. Publishers Weekly raves, “Montero’s atmospheric, minimal prose beautifully conjures the sensitivity, ardor and craving for normality that define adolescence.” Cherie Thiessen’s review for January Magazine describes the work as “an evocative, haunting story, as fatalistic, moody and inevitable as a Greek tragedy.” Edith Grossman (best known for her translations of Gabriel García Márquez) has been lauded for the grace of her English translation. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Captain of the Sleepers BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Rev. of Captain of the Sleepers, by Mayra Montero. Kirkus Reviews 15 June 2005: 660. Rev. of Captain of the Sleepers, by Mayra Montero. Publishers Weekly 25 July 2005: 42. Levin, Kate. “All about My Mother.” Rev. of Captain of the Sleepers, by Mayra Montero. Nation 5 Dec. 2005: 34-38. Print. Lloréns, Hilda. “The Power of Secrets.” Rev. of Captain of the Sleepers, by Mayra Montero. Women’s Review of Books 23.2 (2006): 28-29. Print. Montero, Mayra. Captain of the Sleepers. Trans. Edith Grossman. New York: Farrar, 2005. Print. Thiessen, Cherie. “Sleeping Sickness.” Rev. of Captain of the Sleepers, by Mayra Montero. January Magazine Sept. 2005. Web. 5 October 2010. Additional Resources
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Mayra Montero was born in Havana, Cuba, in 1952 and grew up in Puerto Rico. She studied journalism in Mexico and Puerto Rico. While continuing her career as a journalist, she established herself as a noted fiction writer. Her first book, a collection of short stories titled Veintitrés y una tortuga, was published in 1981. She gained a larger audience with the publication of her first novel, La trenza de la hermosa luna, in 1987. The volume was short-listed for Spain’s prestigious Herralde Award. Over the next two decades, she produced eight more novels, including La última noche que pasé contigo (1991; The Last Night I Spent with You, 2001) and Son de Almendra (2005; Dancing to “Almendra,” 2007), Montero became famous for her storytelling abilities and the often sexually explicit character of her work. She is also known as a political activist who has lent her voice to the cause of Puerto Rican independence.
Criticism and Reviews
“Chatting with Mayra Montero.” Criticas 2.4 (2002): 8. Print. An interview in which Montero discusses her novel and its English translation.
Grossman, Edith, and Mayra Montero. “A PrizeWinning Translator and a Distinguished Cuban Novelist Share Ideas on How They Work.” Washington Post
Puerto Rican soldiers guard a group of Nationalists. Much of Captain of the Sleepers is based on the unsuccessful fight for Puerto Rican independence in the 1940s and 1950s. ª Bettmann/Corbis TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
225
Captain of the Sleepers
A large portion of Captain of the Sleepers is set on the Puerto Rican island of Vieques. kai hecker/Shutterstock.com
25 Dec. 2005: T10. Print. A conversation between Montero and Grossman, who translated the book into English. Lopez, Adriana. “Captain of the Translators: PW talks with Edith Grossman.” Publishers Weekly 25 July 2005: 43. Lopez briefly interviews the translator of Captain of the Sleepers, who discusses the novel and its eroticism. Seaman, Donna. Rev. of Captain of the Sleepers, by Mayra Montero. Booklist 1 Sept. 2005: 66. A brief review that focuses on the work’s treatment of the haunting effects of both sex and death. Shreve, Jack. Rev. of Captain of the Sleepers, by Mayra Montero. Library Journal 1 Aug. 2005: 70. The author praises the novel, calling for more widespread recognition of Montero among English-speaking readers.
Open Web Sources
The Web site of HarperCollins Publishers offers a brief biographical sketch of Montero and information about her novels. http://www.harpercollins.com/ author/index.aspx?authorid=6842 The educational Web site WorldAtlas provides facts about Puerto Rico and its history. It also features a map of Puerto Rico that is helpful in visualizing the locales of Montero’s novel and the trips that the characters make between Vieques and the Puerto Rican mainland. http://www .worldatlas.com/webimage/countrys/namerica/ caribb/pr.htm For Further Reading
Gale Resources
Barreto, Amílcar Antonio. Vieques, the Navy, and Puerto Rican Politics. Gainesville: UP of Florida, 2002. Print. This nonfiction volume analyzes recent developments in the relationship between the U.S. Navy and the community of Vieques, where protests against American forces escalated in 1999.
“Mayra Montero.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2007.
Montero, Mayra. In the Palm of Darkness. Trans. Edith Grossman. New York: Harper, 1997. Print. The first
Taylor, Ihsan. “Paperback Row.” New York Times Book Review 18 Feb. 2007: 28(L). Taylor provides a brief overview of the novel’s plot.
226
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Captain of the Sleepers
of Montero’s novels to be translated into English, In the Palm of Darkness is the story of an American scientist searching for a rare species of frog in Haiti and the native guide who aids him in his quest. Negron-Muntaner, Frances. Puerto Rican Jam: Rethinking Colonialism and Nationalism. Minneapolis: U of Minnesota P, 1997. Print. This collection of essays attempts to find alternatives to the opposition between the colonialist and nationalist positions in the debate over Puerto Rico.
Rigau, Jorge. Puerto Rico Then and Now. San Diego: Thunder Bay, 2009. Print. Rigau’s text and photographs introduce Puerto Rico and provide useful context for Montero’s novel. Rodengen, Jeffrey L. The Legend of Cessna. Ft. Lauderdale: Write Stuff, 1998. Print. The nonfiction work offers a history of Cessna aircraft, the type of plane flown by J. T. Bunker in the novel.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Greta Gard
227
Carpentaria By Alexis Wright
W Introduction Focusing on a conflict concerning land rights in the Carpentaria Gulf region of Australia, Alexis Wright’s novel, Carpentaria (2006), depicts the layers of disharmony between the Aboriginal and white residents of the fictional mining town of Desperance, and within the indigenous community itself. The work traces the interactions of the varied Aboriginal groups that exist on the outskirts of Desperance with the residents of Uptown, the white portion of town. The story explores, on the surface, the debate over the land rights to the mine. On a deeper level, Carpentaria examines the sources of racial conflict, reveals the sense of spiritual interconnectedness with the land felt by the indigenous people, and fleshes out the despair and discord within the Aboriginal communities. Several features of the story, including character names that suggest larger, archetypical meaning, and the references to the spiritual beliefs of the Aboriginal people, combine to lend Carpentaria a mythical, fable-like quality. Praised for its blend of mysticism and reality, the novel won a number of Australian literary awards and became an international best seller.
W Literary and Historical Context
As a member of the Aboriginal Waanyi nation, and an activist dedicated to Aboriginal rights, Wright drew on the realties of white and Aboriginal conflict for her novel Carpentaria. She writes at a time when debates over rights to land and land use, as well as Aboriginal human rights issues, are in the forefront of Australian politics. According to Sandy Wood’s 1999 article for American University’s Human Rights Brief, the Native Title Amendment Act of 1998 was designed to aid in settling disputes regarding land rights, but aboriginal rights
activists found much in the act to criticize. Wood further contends that many politicians and a “substantial portion of the public” do not support native title rights. There continues to be much discussion regarding the breadth of legal implications concerning native title rights. A 2009 Native Title Amendment Act continues to be debated, and 2010 reform discussions are underway. Other sources of conflict between Aboriginals and non-Aboriginals, informs Tara Ravens in a 2007 article for AAP General News (Australia), involve the Australian government’s attempts to purge the child abuse of indigenous children on Aboriginal lands by banning alcohol use on indigenous lands and removing the need for non-Aboriginals to have a permit to access the land of indigenous people. Ravens reports that Wright herself spoke out against the government’s approach. Other activists supported the government’s intentions of controlling the plague of child abuse, but questioned the actions designed to support the measures. In the first decade of the twenty-first century, an increasing number of Australian historians and writers are addressing Australia’s treatment of its indigenous people, both historically and in contemporary society. Wright lends her voice to that of other Aboriginal and nonAboriginal writers who seek to address in their writing the reality of Australia, past and present. As Margaret Allen indicates in a 2001 essay for Hecate, many nonAboriginal Australians are rousing themselves “from what has been termed the ‘great Australian silence’ about Aboriginal history in Australia.” In addition to Wright, other Australian writers who address the Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal history of conflict in some way include Kim Mahood, Kenny Laughton, Sally Morgan, and Nicholas Jose.
W Themes Among the major themes Wright treats in Carpentaria is the conflict between the Aboriginal community and
228 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Carpentaria
MAJOR CHARACTERS STAN BRUISER is the corrupt mayor of Desperance. Bruiser is also considered the ring leader of the part of town known as Uptown, and its white mob. ANGEL DAY is Normal Phantom’s wife, and has fashioned her home out of the rubbish heap near which the family lives. Often described as beautiful, and as the queen of the rubbish pile, she leaves her husband for Mozzie Fishman, and leaves Desperance behind. MOZZIE FISHMAN is depicted as a religious zealot or evangelist who periodically appears in town with his followers, some of whom inhabit the spirit world. They travel through the country seeking the spiritual resting places of their ancestors. HOPE is an Eastender and Joseph Midnight’s granddaughter. She falls in love with Will Phantom and bears his child, Bala. Stranded with Normal and Bala at the end of the novel, Hope leaves her son with his grandfather in order to search for Will.
Carpentaria is based on an Australian land dispute between white Australians and Aboriginals. ª Bettmann/Corbis
non-Aboriginals concerning the mining land at the heart of the story. The complete segregation of the town of Desperance that Wright depicts establishes a thematic structure by which all things may be viewed as a dichotomy: home versus despair, white versus black, for example. Yet Wright’s treatment of such conflicts is more complex than this binary approach initially suggests. As Frances Devlin-Glass observes in a 2007 review of Carpentaria for Antipodes, Wright possesses an insider’s understanding of the political machinations of the small, segregated towns that Desperance represents. Her “long history of working in Aboriginal bureaucracies” has generated “a fine contempt for self-serving small-town mindsets” that makes its way into her novel. Such a background allows Wright the ability to view the conflicts she explores from the inside out; her characters are all imbued with human frailties and shortcomings, Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal alike. Wright also explores the relationship between the Aboriginal sense of spirituality and their worldview. Connected by their ancestral and spiritual beliefs to the land, the Aboriginal community is surprised to learn that the white community of Uptown lacks a history filled with heroes, and is devoid of holy ground. Such discoveries diminish, in the eyes of the Aboriginal community, the rights of the whites to the land, land that was once their own. In tracing the Aboriginal connection to their own history and their spiritualism,
JOSEPH MIDNIGHT is regarded as the leader of the Eastside mob, or the group of Aboriginals who live on the east side of Desperance. They claim to be the true inhabitants of the area. Midnight allowed the mine to be established and was paid for his agreeing to this use of the land. He is considered the enemy of Normal Phantom and the Westenders. BALA PHANTOM is the son of Will and Hope Phantom. NORMAL PHANTOM is the narrating character of Carpentaria. A onetime fisherman, Normal, also known as Norm, is married to Angel Day, who later leaves him for Mozzie Fishman. Norm and his family belong to the Westside mob, or the group of Aboriginals who live on the west side of Desperance; they are also known as the Pricklebush people. The larger Aboriginal community to which the Westenders and the Eastenders once belonged became fractured, in part due to Joseph Midnight’s agreement with the mining company. Some of Pricklebush people are known to travel in a land of ghosts and gather the stories of the elderly. Norm and his family are at the center of the novel’s narrative. Following the cyclone at the end of the novel, Norm is adrift at sea for forty days with Hope and his grandson Bala. After Hope disappears to look for Will, Norm and Bala return to the wreckage of Desperance. WILL PHANTOM is the son of Normal Phantom and Angel Day. Will becomes involved in the dispute for land rights and he takes a stand against the mine, seeking its violent destruction. Will falls in love with an enemy to the Westenders, the Eastender, Hope. The couple has a son together, Bala. After the town is decimated by a cyclone at the end of the novel, Will drifts alone on an island composed of floating detritus.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
229
Carpentaria
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Born on November 25, 1950, Alexis Wright is a member of Australia’s Waanyi nation. Wright’s father was a white cattleman who died when Wright was five years old. After his death, she was raised by her Waanyi mother and grandmother in Cloncurry, Queensland. She has worked as an indigenous researcher, administrator, and educator, and as an activist for Aboriginal rights. Prior to her publication of Carpentaria in 2006, Wright wrote the nonfiction study of alcoholism and alcohol legislation in Aboriginal communities, Grog War in 1997, and the novel Plains of Promise, also in 1997. Carpentaria won a number of literary awards, including, among others, the Miles Franklin Award, the Australian Literary Fiction Book of the Year, the Australian Literature Society Gold Medal, and the Queensland Premier’s Literary Award, all 2007.
Wright emphasizes the link to the past possessed by the indigenous people, but also a curiosity about the white world. Through the exploration of this interplay between the two cultures, Teresa Podemska-Abt maintains, in a 2010 article for Kultura—Historia—Globalizacja (Culture—History—Global Studies) “Carpentaria pushes readers to realize that Indigenous cultures and societies are in a constant progress.” Modern indigenous communities, as Wright demonstrates, evolve in part based on their interactions with other, non-Aboriginal individuals and groups. At the end of the novel, the survival of Normal Phantom and some of his family members, and their return to the area that was once their home suggests the ability of Aboriginal communities to adapt, survive, and maintain their connection to their land as well.
W Style Incorporating supernatural and realistic elements, Carpentaria is often described as a work of magical realism. The term was first used in 1925 in relation to visual arts, and in 1949 in association with fiction, and includes any work that synthesizes elements of the supernatural, absurd, fantastic, or mystical with a story that is otherwise rooted in realism. Throughout the novel, Wright fuses the Aboriginal myths with her narrative, making the supernatural an integral part of the reality of the story. As the story opens, for example, the natural landscape of the area is described in terms of indigenous myth, as the “ancestral serpent” carves a channel from the sea into the land and back again, creating in its wake the tidal rivers of the region. In one of these rivers, the reader learns, the “up-to-no-good Mission-bred kids accidentally hanged Cry-baby Sally.” The reference to a contemporary event, the death of Cry-baby Sally, is incorporated into the ongoing tale of the river serpent, whose breath is
230
mentioned a beat later. The interconnection between myth and reality is an integral part of the Aboriginal community Wright describes, and of the narrative itself. Carpentaria fuses the magical with the realistic through the figure of Normal Phantom, an elder of the indigenous community, who also serves as the point-ofview narrating character. Phantom lends the story the air of an oral tale, and breathes life into the supernatural-filled stories and legends—both ancient and contemporary—of his people. The supernatural is already a part of Normal Phantom’s reality. His narration is as much infused with the spiritual and mystical as it is with the mundane and commonplace. Through Phantom, Wright allows her complex novel its moments of levity and humor. As a narrator, Phantom has his own biases, and the reader must embrace the overlay of his attitudes and sense of mysticism or attempt to see through it.
W Critical Reception It is often noted that Wright’s Carpentaria, which eventually became an international best seller, was not initially well received by Australian audiences, despite the early critical acclaim it received from Australian reviewers. Jane Perlez, in her 2007 New York Times Book Review assessment, cites the “highly laudatory reviews” that failed to translate into sales. Perlez attributes the initial failure of the novel to the fact that Australian independent bookstores are operated “by political liberals, who have often expressed embarrassment at the sorry treatment of Australia’s indigenous people,” and consequently were unwilling to promote the novel. The novel’s style—its blending of the mystical or supernatural with the realistic—has been a source of much discussion among other critics. Ross Chambers, in a 2008 article for Australian Literary Studies, comments on the way the surrealism or magical realism of Carpentaria may be regarded as an example of the postcolonial appropriation of the surrealist mode. Similarly, Frances Devlin-Glass, in a 2007 review of the novel for Antipodes, explores the work’s “hybridized genres,” questioning whether it is a work of “social realism, magic realism, Aboriginal traditional stories straight or fictionalized.” Devlin-Glass goes on to suggest like Chambers that the novel’s approach is ultimately postcolonial in its appropriation of these genres. Katy Guest, in her assessment of the novel in a 2008 review for the Independent, praises the work as a “massive achievement” but is unable to determine whether it is to be taken as magical realism, an old man’s stories, or simply, a dream. Guest describes the plotting as “absurd” and the narrative as scattered, but also states that the novel is a “monstrous work of genius.” Paul Sharrad evaluates Carpentaria in a 2009 essay for Australian Literary Studies. He states that Wright’s narrative challenges mainstream audiences by “asserting cultural difference from white society” and TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Carpentaria
“speaking through communal, senior and oral voices rather than focusing on an individual tale of selfdevelopment.” In assessing the style of Carpentaria, Sharrad likens Wright’s work to that of Gabriel García Márquez and Salman Rushdie—others known for their use of magical realism—and states that like Marquez and Rushdie, Wright transforms “didactic data into symbolic figures that fit with the social practices and narrative devices of the novel.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Allen, Margaret. “The Brothers Up North and the Sisters Down South: The Mackay Family and the Frontier.” Hecate. 1 October 2001. Web. HighBeam Research. 26 July 2010. Chambers, Ross. “‘Isn’t There a Poem about This, Mr. DeMille?’ On Quotation Camp and Colonial Distancing.” Australian Literary Studies 23.4 (2008) 377+. Print. Questia. Web. 27 July 2010. Devlin-Glass, Frances. “Alexis Wright’s Carpentaria.” Antipodes 21.1 (June 2007): 82. Print. Guest, Katy. “Carpentaria, by Alexis Wright.” Independent [London]. 25 April 2008. Web. 27 July 2010. “Native Title Reform.” Australian Government: Attorney-General’s Department. Web. 27 July 2010. Perlez, Jane. “Aboriginal Lit.” New York Times Book Review 18 Nov. 2007. Book Review Desk: 31(L). Print. Podemska-Abt, Teresa. “Anti-Nativism in Australian Indigenous Literature.” Kultura—Historia— Globalizacja, no. 7 (2010). Web. 27 July 2010. Ravens, Tara. “NT: Skepticism and Distrust Greets Aboriginal Reforms.” AAP General News (Australia) 22 June 2007. Web. HighBeam Research. 27 Jul. 2010. Sharrad, Paul. “Beyond Capricornia: Ambiguous Promise in Alexis Wright.” Australian Literary Studies 24.1 (Apr. 2009): 52+. Print. Vernay, Jean-Francois. “An Interview with Alexis Wright.” Antipodes 18.2 (Dec. 2004): 119. Print. Wood, Sandy. “Aboriginal Land Rights in Australia.” Human Rights Brief 6.3 (Spring 1999). Web. 27 July 2010. Wyndham, Susan. “Gulf Country’s Voice Shines in Australian Epic.” Sydney Morning Herald 22 June 2007. Web. 27 July 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Devlin-Glass, Frances. “A Politics of the Dreamtime: Destructive and Regenerative Rainbows in Alexis Wright’s Carpentaria.” Australian Literary Studies
23.4 (2008): 392+. Print. Examines the symbolism and the elements of magical realism in Carpentaria. Joseph, Laura. “Opening the Gates of Hell: Regional Emergences in Carpentaria and Dreamhunter.” Southerly 69.2 (Summer 2009): 66+. Print. Explores the way Wright and Elizabeth Knox, from Australia and New Zealand, respectively, emphasize in their work the transcendence of the regional over the national. Lake, Ed. “Carpentaria: A Mother Load of Mystery.” Telegraph.co.uk 19 Apr. 2008. Web. 27 July 2010. Provides a brief review of Carpentaria in which the work is compared with James Joyce’s Ulysses in terms of its status as a national epic and in the way it employs the particular details of regional space and the habits of regional expression. Gale Resources
“Alexis Wright.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Open Web Sources
The National Native Title Tribunal website is a resource that aids in explaining the issue of native land rights in Australia. The site provides links to pertinent legislation and resources for Aboriginal Australians. http:// www.nntt.gov.au/What-Is-Native-Title/Pages/ Approaches-to-Native-Title.aspx Alexis Wright’s American publisher, Simon and Schuster, provides an author biography, bibliography, and updates regarding the author’s upcoming works. http://authors.simonandschuster.com/Alexis Wright/47814863 The Australian Government’s Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade provides a brief overview of the history of indigenous Australians and their relationship with European settlers. http://www.dfat.gov. au/aib/history.html For Further Reading
Heiss, Anita and Peter Minter, eds. Macquarie PEN Anthology of Aboriginal Literature. Allen & Unwin Australia, 2008. Print. The first anthology of Aboriginal Australian literature, Heiss and Minter’s collection spans two centuries of Aboriginal writing. Mahood, Kim. Craft for a Dry Lake. Anchor, 2000. Print. Mahood’s memoir delineates the transformation of her relationship to her Aboriginal ancestry and her sense of connection to the land of the Tanami region, which was her childhood home. Wright, Alexis. “Embracing the Indigenous Vision: Novelist and Artist Alexis Wright Proclaims the Need for Complete Self-Determination by Aboriginal Peoples in Framing and Administering Policies for
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
231
Carpentaria
Their Futures.” Meanjin 65.1 (Mar. 2006): 104+. Print. Wright discusses her work with indigenous communities and the challenges they face as they seek to maintain their sovereign rights within Australia.
Aboriginal communities and their conflict with the Europeans who colonized their land. The tensions between Aboriginal spirituality and the Christianity of the colonists is a main focus of the novel.
———. Plains of Promise. U of Queensland P, 1997. Print. Wright’s first novel, this work is concerned with
Catherine Dominic
232
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Carry Me Down By M. J. Hyland
W Introduction M. J. Hyland’s Carry Me Down, published in 2006, is a firstperson narrative written in the present tense from the perspective of John Egan, an eleven-year-old boy growing up in Ireland in 1971. At nearly six feet, John is unusually tall for his age. Although he has the body of an adult, he still has the mind of a child, something that unsettles his parents, who no longer know quite how to relate to him. Meanwhile, John becomes obsessed with discerning the difference between lies and truth. In part this obsession stems from his own traumatic life, including the pressures of living in poverty and his parents’ marital troubles. John eventually comes to regard himself as a sort of human lie detector, but because he is still very young and literal-minded he lacks the maturity to understand adult nuances and the ability to process his own complex emotions, both of which lead to significant troubles over the course of the novel. Carry Me Down was short-listed for the Man Booker Prize for Fiction, as well as the Commonwealth Writers’ Prize (Eurasia Region). It won the Encore Award for Best Second Book and the Hawthornden Prize for Best Work of Literature.
W Literary and Historical Context
Carry Me Down is written as a coming-of-age novel, and employs a stream of conscious style of narration, using the voice and cadence of a young male narrator. Focusing on the thought processes of eleven-year-old John Egan, the narrative voice in Carry Me Down is very reminiscent of the writing style used by J. D. Salinger in The Catcher in the Rye. This is particularly true of Hyland’s use of an episodic narrative structure relating a number of mundane, seemingly unconnected events. John Egan’s
narrative voice is also reminiscent of Christopher John Francis Boone, the young protagonist of Mark Haddon’s 2003 novel, The Curious Incident of the Dog in the NightTime. Similar to other stream-of-consciousness novels, Carry Me Down does not emphasize the context in which the story is set. The reader is aware that the novel is set in Ireland, in the 1970s, but Hyland does not focus on providing situational detail in the novel. In fact, Hyland mentioned in an interview with Andrew Lawless for Three Monkeys Online that she was not “particularly concerned … with time and place” for this book. She insists that she did not “set out to say anything about Irish culture—nothing.” Despite her stated intent, Lawless opined that Carry Me Down provides a “keen psychological profile” of Ireland in the 1970s. Ireland was rife with religious and political conflict during the 1960s and 1970s. After centuries of being a British dominion state, Ireland had split in two during the 1950s. Protestant-dominated Northern Ireland remained under British rule while the rest of the Irish counties declared themselves a republic in 1948. Sentiment for a united Ireland remained strong, however, and the Irish Republican Army (IRA) sponsored years of violent, terrorist attacks on Northern Ireland during the 1960s, 1970s, and beyond, in an effort to break ties between the north and England. Despite the violence that characterized Irish history during this time, Ireland’s economy grew significantly during the 1960s and 1970s. Ireland became part of the European Community in 1973. As noted earlier, Hyland does not draw significantly on the social and cultural milieu of 1970s Ireland in Carry Me Down. Her decision to focus closely on the musings of her narrator has been compared unfavorably to similar works set in contemporary Ireland, most notably Roddy Doyle’s Paddy Clarke Ha Ha Ha and The Butcher Boy, by Patrick McCabe (Thompson). While Thompson faults Hyland’s novel for a meandering plot and other shortcomings, she does assert that Carry Me Down “introduces some interesting themes. There are Oedipal
233 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Carry Me Down
MAJOR CHARACTERS BRENDAN is John Egan’s best friend, but their relationship breaks down over the course of the book. JOHN EGAN, the novel’s protagonist and narrator, is an abnormally tall, poor, introspective, eleven-year-old boy who becomes obsessed with determining the difference between truth and lies, and thinks of himself as a human lie detector. MR. EGAN, John’s father, is a rough, violent man who drinks too much and cheats on his wife while telling his family that he is studying in order to get a job. John is under the impression that his father does not love him. MRS. EGAN, John’s mother, loves her son, but is frightened by him and does not know how to relate to him. MR. ROCHE is a teacher who serves as an inspiration to John, despite the fact that he is physically violent with some of his other students.
undercurrents when John succeeds in getting his father removed from the flat and moves into his mother’s bed. There is a concern, very relevant today, about the effects upon a child when he is taken into the confidence of adults and told more about family relationships than he is mature enough to understand.” These themes, along with Hyland’s portrayal of adolescence and difficult family life in the novel, have been praised by other reviewers.
W Themes Carry Me Down is a novel that explores the dichotomy between honesty and dishonesty and the impact of telling lies on others. The lies depicted in the novel have thematic resonance, hiding the truth about the relationships in the book. For example, John’s father kills an entire litter of kittens before his wife can return home and discover that her cat has given birth. When John vomits at the sight of this grisly scene, he claims that his reaction is not related to the killing. The truth is, John is appalled because Mr. Egan has told him that he was not bothered by the idea of killing the cats. John is extremely sensitive to lies and throughout the novel, he feels sickened when others lie to him. He is so literal-minded, however, that he has trouble distinguishing between serious lies and white lies, and uses the distinction between “lies” and “truth” as his emotional road map. Late in the novel, his father makes up a story about a pair of socks that he presents to John, and although the intent is to delight John, the action angers him instead. Similarly, John misinterprets other actions throughout the story, and he is not emotionally or intellectually
234
mature enough to understand the full implication of people’s actions. Ironically, one of the times his intuition is on target occurs when he realizes that his “Da” is cheating on his mother. Unfortunatly, the truth simply makes his mother furious at John. Hyland also introduces the subtle irony that, no matter how much John claims to hate lying, he habitually lies to cover his tracks. As Mrs. Egan bitterly scoffs, “An eleven-year-old in the body of a grown man who insists on the ridiculous truth and has got into a bad habit of lying” (275).
W Style Carry Me Down is written in first-person present tense, a method that serves to place the reader directly inside the protagonist’s mind, experiencing the events in John’s life, both mundane and traumatic, at the same time that he does, without giving readers any type of buffer. Writing from this vantage point injects readers into the immediate situation with the character, not allowing them any reassurances that the storyteller has ultimately survived the experience at hand. Hyland’s writing style, sparse and direct, additionally serves to enhance the immediacy, the claustrophobia, and the tension within John’s life experiences. Hyland also makes use of the “unreliable narrator”— a literary device common in many postmodern works, in which the narrator is not to be trusted and may even be directly lying to the audience. Besides being a tool by which an author is able to misdirect a reader, the “unreliable narrator” also speaks to the idea that there can never be such a thing as complete truth, because everyone has a different perspective. Because of his youth and inexperience, John thinks he is telling the truth. However, Hyland anticipates that perceptive readers will take John’s words with a grain of salt, being fully aware that John is a young boy who makes certain leaps in judgment. Thus, using the “unreliable narrator” allows Hyland to convey to his readers a fuller picture of what is actually happening. This is particularly true of John’s mental state. From his own point of view, John is completely normal. However, when he attacks his mother, readers will comprehend the full extent of his mental instability, while John remains confused about the reasons and consequences for his actions.
W Critical Reception Carry Me Down met with overwhelming praise upon its release and subsequently won a number of prestigious literary awards. It was also nominated for the Man Booker Prize. Charlotte Moore, in the Spectator, praised Hyland for exploring the “frightening and unsavoury frontier land between childhood and adulthood with unswerving TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Carry Me Down
sympathy and clear-sightedness.” Meanwhile, the New Statesman’s Simon Baker was impressed with Hyland’s knack for conveying “a sense of horror even when describing everyday life. She presents us with a family in which weakness and brutality coexist, and portrays a troubled childhood with accuracy and style.” In Booklist, Hazel Rochman declared, “the child’s naïve first-person . . . narrative brings achingly close his helplessness in a powerful adult world.” She went on to applaud the novel for dealing with a complex philosophical issue, that of “pain . . . [being] harder than ignorance. Who needs the truth?” Publishers Weekly called the novel a “piercing testimony to the bewilderment and resiliency of youth.” Its reviewer found John, as a narrator, to be “singular and powerful throughout. . . . By the subtle, satisfying denouement, one is . . . saving a space for . . . [John] among the year’s memorable characters.” Some critics faulted Hyland for a lack of narrative cohesiveness. For example, Entertainment Weekly’s Michelle Kung felt that “Hyland fails to instill . . . [John] and his family with enough empathy for us to be invested in their fates.” A critic in the London Observer wrote,
ABOUT THE AUTHOR M. J. Hyland was born in London to Irish parents. The family moved from Australia to Dublin and back again. Hyland endured an unhappy childhood, with an abusive, alcoholic father and her childhood experiences often inform her work. According to the London Observer, “Hyland specialises in characters fatally out of step, misfits struggling with self-pity and deceit, caught in an undertow of violence and sexual menace.” Her novels are also known for their dense, precise detail. This atmosphere, described by reviewers as almost “claustrophobic,” reverberates throughout her novels, including How the Light Gets In, Carry Me Down, and This Is How. Hyland’s work has been short-listed for the Man Booker Prize, the Commonwealth Writers’ Prize, and the Barnes and Noble Discover Award. She has won several awards, including the Sydney Morning Herald’s Best Young Novelist Award, the Encore Award for Best Second Book, and the Hawthornden Prize for Best Work of Literature.
This photo shows the demolition of a residential tower in Dublin, Ireland, the setting of the novel Carry Me Down. ª George Carter / Alamy
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
235
Carry Me Down
“John never quite rings true as a narrator, failing to elicit the suspension of disbelief so vital for a book of this kind.” Furthermore, Guardian reviewer Kate Thompson criticized the narrative for being slow paced and “somewhat meandering, with many repetitive and redundant scenes. . . . A mild, ghoulish curiosity kept me turning the pages, but the novel’s tidy resolution left me with more questions than answers.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Baker, Simon. “Light and Dark.” Rev. of Carry Me Down, by M. J. Hyland. New Statesman [1996] 135.4791 (8 May 2006): 56+. Print. Rev. of Carry Me Down, by M. J. Hyland. Publishers Weekly 253.3 (2006): 38. Print. Rev. of Carry Me Down, by M. J. Hyland. Observer [London] 25 Feb. 2007: 25. Print. Hyland, M. J. Carry Me Down. Edinburgh: Canongate, 2006. Print. Kung, Michelle. “Carry Me Down.” Rev. of Carry Me Down, by M. J. Hyland. Entertainment Weekly 869 (24 Mar. 2006): 74. Print. Lawless, Andrew. “Carry Me Down—M. J. Hyland in Interview.” Three Monkeys Online, May 2007. Web. 30 Nov. 2010. Moore, Charlotte. “The Trouble with Being a LieDetector.” Rev. of Carry Me Down, by M. J. Hyland. Spectator 29 July 2006. Print. Rochman, Hazel. “Hyland, M. J., Carry Me Down.” Rev. of Carry Me Down, by M. J. Hyland. Booklist 102.12 (15 Feb. 2006): 44. Print. Thompson, Kate. “Helping Hands: Kate Thompson on a Tale of Disturbed Adolescence: Carry Me Down by M. J. Hyland.” Guardian [London] 22 Apr. 2006: 16. Print. General Reference Center Gold. Web. 1 Sept. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
“A Boy against the World.” Rev. of Carry Me Down, by M. J. Hyland. Europe Intelligence Wire 8 Apr. 2006. This review discusses how M. J. Hyland’s troubled childhood informs the narrative of Carry Me Down, and the character development of the protagonist, John, in particular. “Hyland Games.” Scotsman [Edinburgh, Scotland] 11 July 2009: 9. Print. InfoTrac Custom Newspapers. Web. 1 Sept. 2010. This in-depth interview with M. J. Hyland was held when This Is How was released, but its discussion of Hyland’s background and influences is equally applicable to Carry Me Down.
236
“I’m a Human Lie Detector, Honest: An Enthralling Novel Tells the Story of a Boy Who Thinks He Has Special Powers.” Rev. of Carry Me Down, by M. J. Hyland. Observer [London] 23 Apr. 2006: 24. Print. This review analyzes how Carry Me Down functions as a potent and effective character study. “Listening to the Child Within; Fiction.” Rev. of Carry Me Down, by M. J. Hyland. Times [London] 8 Apr. 2006: 14. Print. This review places Carry Me Down into the context of the coming-of-age novel tradition, discussing the evolution of the child narrator. Scurr, Ruth. “‘You Vomited at the Sight of the Dead Kittens.’” Rev. of Carry Me Down, by M. J. Hyland. Daily Telegraph [London] 22 Apr. 2006: 10. Print. This review focuses on the disturbing imagery in Carry Me Down, exploring how the traumatic events influence John’s obsessions. Gale Resources
“Hyland, M. J. (1968-).” Student Resource Center. Detroit: Gale, 2009. From Student Resource CenterCollege Edition Expanded. Web. 30 Aug. 2010. Open Web Sources
M. J. Hyland’s official site includes a significant amount of information, including news, reviews for all of her books, blog postings, and more at http://www. mjhyland.com A comprehensive biography, bibliography, list of awards, and a critical essay on M. J. Hyland can be found online at the British Council Contemporary Writers website. http://www.contemporarywriters.com/ authors/?p=auth5181C8790ebf71D73DjLq2A B4EE9 For Further Reading
Haddon, Mark. The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time. New York: Vintage, 2003. Print. This forerunner to Carry Me Down is also written in the first-person, told from the perspective of a young boy who has a learning disability. Hyland, M. J. How the Light Gets In. New York: Canongate, 2004. Print. This earlier novel by Hyland deals with themes similar to those presented in Carry Me Down, this time through the character of a sixteen-year-old girl trying to overcome the trauma of having grown up in an unsupportive, verbally abusive family. ———. This Is How. New York: Black Cat, 2009. Print. This Is How reads as a thematic sequel to Carry Me Down, telling the story of a troubled young man who undergoes a mental breakdown at TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Carry Me Down
the age of fourteen, and becomes obsessed with mechanics. McCourt, Frank. Angela’s Ashes. New York: Touchstone, 1999. Print. A memoir of a poor boy growing up impoverished in Ireland.
Salinger, J. D. The Catcher in the Rye. New York: Little, Brown, 1951. Print. This seminal coming-of-age classic focuses on a troubled young male protagonist struggling to understand the intricacies of the adult world around him. Robert Berg
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
237
Celestial Harmonies By Péter Esterházy
W Introduction Celestial Harmonies (2003) is the title of the English translation of the Hungarian novel Harmonia Caelestis (2000) by the noted postmodernist Péter Esterházy. The complex and often challenging 800-page work is an account of the author’s aristocratic Hungarian family, but it is not a conventional historical narrative. The first of its two parts is an inventive, allusive reflection on all the “fathers” (real and fantastic) of the Esterházy lineage from its rise in seventeenth-century Hungary through its extraordinarily powerful position in European affairs during the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries to its decline in the changing social conditions of the twentieth century. The second part is a more personal account of the author, his father, Mátyás Esterházy, and their life under Communist rule in postwar Hungary. Harmonia Caelestis received the Hungarian Literature Prize and the Sándor Márai Prize, as well as the Premio Circeo in Italy and the Herder Prize in Germany. The English translation by Judith Sollosy was well received by critics and brought Esterházy to the attention of a wider audience.
W Literary and Historical Context
The two parts of Celestial Harmonies deal with history very differently. Part 1, titled “Numbered Sentences from the Lives of the Esterházy Family,” contains 371 passages set in many different times and places. Each passage is organized around an allegorical “father,” who may in any given instance be a mythic figure or a real member of the Esterházy family. The Esterházy line descended from Paul, Fürst Esterházy von Galantha (1635-1713), who was elected regent of Hungary in 1681 and who established the family’s importance by regaining Hungary from the Ottomans. His grandson began the family’s
illustrious patronage of music and the arts, appointing Franz Joseph Haydn to his court in 1761. Haydn went on to become one of the greatest composers of the time while in the service of the Esterházys. During the nineteenth century the immensely wealthy family continued amassing political power and position in Hungary, Austria, and Germany. Count Móric Esterházy, the author’s grandfather, served briefly as prime minister of Hungary during World War I before a series of revolutions destabilized the country. Following World War II, Hungary came under Communist rule, and Péter Esterházy’s family was impoverished. Part 2 of Celestial Harmonies, “The Confessions of an Esterházy Family,” focuses on the difficult life of his father, Mátyás, who was detained as an enemy of the state, beaten, and forced into agricultural labor.
W Themes Julian Evans observes in his Guardian review of the novel that “there are other themes to Celestial Harmonies, questions of homeland, dictatorship, history and how to face it, but Esterházy’s overwhelming business here is with his father.” In part 1, Evans continues, “this father is plural, encompassing all the narrator’s fathers, back to the dynasty’s beginnings.” The plural father is variously depicted as good and bad, real and fantastic, lofty and ridiculous, loving and destructive. He is shown in many different times and places, under circumstances ranging from the ordinary to the extreme. Through the juxtaposition of several hundred passages about “my father,” Esterházy creates a thematic resonance that reveals the universal nature of fatherhood as expressed through the men of one diverse, historic European family. In part 2 the “real” father and the relationship between father and son take over the narrative, serving as the central figures in Esterházy’s exploration of family and depiction of life in a totalitarian regime. Although his
238 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Celestial Harmonies
parents endured hardship and fear during most of the author’s early life, the family is shown to be close and often surprisingly happy. As one commentator, writing in Kirkus Reviews, puts it, “rather than a lament about how the mighty have fallen, the story is a more rueful tale of how the mighty coped.” In this sense Celestial Harmonies is a tribute to the endurance of the Esterházy family, not only through the upheavals of Hungarian history over many centuries but also in its eventual transition from great importance to complete powerlessness.
W Style Barbara Hoffert, in a review for Library Journal, characterizes Celestial Harmonies as “not exactly a novel but more like an extended prose poem on family, nation, and history.” This assessment applies particularly to part 1, which depends almost entirely on allusions, imagery, and inventive language, providing very little in the way of conventional narrative or structural coherence. The 371 passages vary in length (ranging from a few words to several pages), point of view, and tone. Throughout, Esterházy uses material from a wide variety of sources, frequently weaving quotations into the text without direct reference or reworking phrases and sentences drawn from other works of literature. This technique (sometimes referred to as “intertextuality”) is characteristic of Esterházy’s writing in particular and postmodern writing in general. In a concluding section of Celestial Harmonies, the author lists many of the sources from which material was borrowed or incorporated, but he does not provide their location in the text. By this means he creates a kind of identification game for the reader, reflecting the idea that literature is a shared product of human culture. As Marianna Birnbaum observes in World Literature Today, “Esterházy is a magician of the word: each of his sentences may incorporate archaisms, political and street jargon, puns, and his own neologisms.” Although part 2 takes a more conventional approach to storytelling than part 1, it too challenges the reader’s expectations and relies as much on style as on substance. The 201 “chapters” of part 2 move unpredictably through the different times in his father’s life and show events from different perspectives, building up a multilayered view not only of Esterházy’s father but also of their relationship and of the world in which they lived.
MAJOR CHARACTERS MÁTYÁS ESTERHÁZY is the author’s actual father. Born into one of Europe’s most famous and powerful aristocratic families, and later stripped of his wealth and title, Mátyás Esterházy worked in a variety of menial jobs to care for his wife and children. “MY FATHER” is a recurring character in part 1 of the novel. Esterházy applies the characterization to many different men, both real and imagined, in order to create a composite image of the Esterházy patrimony and of the universal qualities of fatherhood. “MY FATHER’S SON” is a recurring characterization that refers to the author, Péter Esterházy.
W Critical Reception
Images
Despite its challenging style, Celestial Harmonies has been admired by most critics. In a starred review Kirkus describes the novel as “daunting at first, then richly rewarding,” calling it “a major achievement.” Publishers Weekly also stars the work, asserting that “Esterhazy has
created a vast anti-epic splicing the fine-grained nostalgia of Nabokov’s Speak, Memory with the anarchic spirit of Looney Toons.” The broad range of interpretations applied to the novel is demonstrated by James Crossley’s
Péter Esterházy, author of Celestial Harmonies. Ulf Andersen/Getty
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
239
Celestial Harmonies
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Péter Esterházy was born in Budapest, Hungary, in 1950, shortly after Hungary had effectively become a client state of the Soviet Union. He finished secondary school in 1968 and then studied mathematics at the Eötvös Loránd University, in Budapest, where he graduated with a BS degree in 1974. For the next four years he worked as a mathematician in the Informatics Institute of the Ministry of Furnaces and Heavy Machinery, but during this period he also began writing. His work was soon published in literary journals, and by 1978 he began writing full time. His inventive, personalized version of postmodernism soon became admired in Europe, but his work was not published in English until the 1990s. Esterházy and Gitti Reen, an artist, were married in 1973 and have three children. Esterházy had believed all his life that his father, Mátyás, was an opponent of the Communist regime and that he had been punished for his resistance. Shortly after completing Celestial Harmonies, however, Esterházy learned from the release of previously secret government documents that his father had been a Communist informant. In 2002 Esterházy published Avitott Kiadás (Corrected edition), which he called an “appendix” to Celestial Harmonies. In the new volume he combines extracts from his father’s reports to the government with his own comments and an account of the process by which he came to terms with this unexpected revelation. Although Esterházy is unsparing in his assessment of Mátyás’s double life, his account retains affection and a measure of understanding.
assessment in the Review of Contemporary Fiction, which focuses on the novel’s narrative scope. Crossley contends that “the two parts of the novel . . . seem to address all the aspects of human endeavor, which means that the most appropriate adjective to employ in describing this novel is epic.” The Guardian reviewer Julian Evans acknowledges both the epic and the antic qualities of the work, noting that its “expansive, deeply coloured, visionary picture” is enhanced by “Esterházy’s always flickering lightness and humour.” A few commentators, however, feel that Celestial Harmonies takes on too much and does not fully succeed. A brief review in the New Yorker, for example, concludes that “ultimately, Esterházy’s attempt to explode epic until it resembles the shards and mirrors of his own style doesn’t quite live up to its ambition, though it yields many extraordinary moments.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Birnbaum, Marianna D. Rev. of Harmonia Caelestis, by Péter Esterházy. World Literature Today 74.3 (2000): 611-12. Print.
240
Rev. of Celestial Harmonies, by Péter Esterházy. Kirkus Reviews 15 Dec. 2003: 1412. Print. Rev. of Celestial Harmonies, by Péter Esterházy. New Yorker. Condé Nast Digital, 10 May 2004. Web. 15 Oct. 2010. Rev. of Celestial Harmonies, by Péter Esterházy. Publishers Weekly 2 Feb. 2004: 58. Print. Crossley, James. Rev. of Celestial Harmonies, by Péter Esterházy. Review of Contemporary Fiction 24.3 (2004): 132+. Print. Evans, Julian. Rev. of Celestial Harmonies, by Péter Esterházy. Guardian [London] 12 June 2004: 27. Print. Hoffert, Barbara. Rev. of Celestial Harmonies, by Péter Esterházy. Library Journal 15 March 2004: 104. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Bazsányi, Sándor. “A Literary Approach towards Aristocratism.” Hungarian Literature Online. Hlo.hu, 1 Feb. 2006. Web. 15 Oct. 2010. This thoughtful analysis provides a Hungarian view of the novel. Bermel, Neil. “Fathers and Sons.” Rev. of Celestial Harmonies, by Péter Esterházy. New York Times Book Review 30 May 2004: 13. Print. Bermel’s extended review, which focuses on Esterházy’s postmodernism, is positive, on balance. Bernstein, Michael André. “Dynasty.” New Republic 12 April 2004: 42-45. Print. In a long and serious essay, Bernstein argues that Celestial Harmonies and Avitott Kiadás (Corrected edition), must be read together. Kavenna, Joanna. “The Giant My Father: Péter Esterházy’s Flotsam and Jetsam of Family Memoirs.” Times Literary Supplement 30 Apr. 2004: 21-22. Print. Kavenna’s thorough consideration of the text finds both messiness and splendor, resulting in a mixed verdict. Zamoyski, Adam. “Voyage round My Fathers.” Rev. of Celestial Harmonies, by Péter Esterházy. Spectator 8 May 2004: 45. Print. In a generally positive assessment, Zamoyski finds the novel both enthralling and difficult. Gale Resources
Kappanyos, András. “Péter Esterházy.” TwentiethCentury Eastern European Writers: Third Series. Ed. Steven Serafin. Detroit: Gale, 2001. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 232. “Péter Esterházy.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2005. “Péter Esterházy.” Contemporary Literary Criticism. Vol. 251. Detroit: Gale, 2008. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Celestial Harmonies Open Web Sources
An interview with the author is available at Words without Borders. http://wordswithoutborders.org Hungarian Literature Online offers excerpts from the novel. http://www.hlo.hu A video of Péter Esterházy talking with the poet Wayne Koestenbaum can be viewed at the New York Public Library’s Web site. http://www.nypl.org For Further Reading
Aczel, Richard. “Hungary.” Oxford Guide to Contemporary Writing. Ed. John Sturrock. Oxford: Oxford UP, 1996: 194-202. Print. This chapter discusses the broad outlines of Hungarian literature during the latter half of the twentieth century and places Esterházy’s writing in context.
societies provides a helpful background for understanding Esterházy’s work. Esterházy, Péter. Helping Verbs of the Heart. New York: Grove Weidenfeld, 1991. Print. The first of Esterházy’s works to be widely available in English, this avant-garde novella revolves around his mother’s death. Land, Thomas. “Beaten into Betrayal?” Times Literary Supplement 13 Sept. 2002: 24. Print. Land’s review discusses Avitott Kiadás (Corrected edition), in which Esterházy documents the discovery that his father had been an informant. Molnár, Miklós. A Concise History of Hungary. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 2003. Print. The complex political, geographic, and social history of Hungary is well explained in this accessible volume.
Boyers, Robert. The Dictator’s Dictation: The Politics of Novels and Novelists. New York: Columbia UP, 2005. Print. Boyers’s examination of fiction in totalitarian
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Cynthia Giles
241
The Changeling By Kenzaburo Oe
W Introduction The Changeling (2010), originally published in Japan in 2000 as Torikae ko, chronicles the friendship between two Japanese men over five decades. The narrator, Kogito, is a successful writer married to the sister of his friend Goro, a famous filmmaker. Goro has developed the habit of sending Kogito recordings of his reflections on their shared experiences. When Goro unexpectedly commits suicide, Kogito returns to the tapes, reviewing them obsessively in an effort to understand his friend’s life and death. As he listens to the recordings Kogito is drawn back into the years following World War II, during which he and Goro became involved in a charismatic leader’s attempt to launch a symbolic suicide attack on the occupying forces. Trying to understand Goro’s suicide forces him to revisit and attempt to come to terms with those traumatic events from long ago. The novel is set in present-day Japan and Germany, with flashbacks to Kogito’s and Goro’s youth. Drawing heavily on author Kenzaburo Oe’s life, The Changeling explores issues such as artistic production, death, friendship, and change. The novel has been praised for its meditative qualities and its blurring of the boundaries between life and art.
W Literary and Historical Context
Although The Changeling is set primarily in twenty-firstcentury Japan, Kogito’s memories carry him back to the years following Japan’s defeat in World War II. With the occupation of the Allied forces came the restructuring of the Japanese government and the transfer of power away from the emperor, whose role became purely symbolic. During this time democratic principles, such as universal suffrage, were also introduced. In the novel, as the
occupation winds to a close, Goro and Kogito become involved with a group of rebels planning an attack on the unchallenged American occupiers. They are aided by an American soldier named Peter, who is motivated by his desire for Goro. In what turns out to be one of the defining moments in both of their lives, Goro and Kogito learn that some of the rebels want to turn on Peter, knowing they can use his desire for Goro to lure him to his death. is an accomplished student of world literature, Oe and his novel includes references to numerous works of literature and translation. Goro and Kogito engage in extended discussions of Arthur Rimbaud (1854–1891), a French poet known for his experiments with language and poetic form. Near the close of the novel Kogito discovers Goro’s rendering of their discussion of Rimbaud’s “Adieu” in his unfinished screenplay and interprets it as an admission of his friend’s planned suicide. The work’s governing allusion, however, surfaces only at the novel’s end. Kogito returns from Germany, where he has spent one hundred days “quarantining” himself from Goro’s tapes, with a copy of Maurice Sendak’s Outside over There. The book tells the story of a girl named Ida whose baby sister is stolen away by goblins while in her care. After Ida discovers that her sister has been replaced with a goblin changeling, she undertakes a dangerous quest to free her sibling. The changeling appeals to Goro’s sister and Kogito’s wife, Chikashi, as a metaphor for her brother’s postwar transformation, and “outside over there” becomes a metaphor for the dark world of trauma that Goro experienced among the rebels in his youth.
W Themes Death is one of the foremost themes of Oe’s novel. While Goro’s suicide is the most visible instance of this subject in the work, discussions of suicide and death pervade many of the conversations that take place
242 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Changeling
MAJOR CHARACTERS DAIO is a former disciple of Kogito’s father and a charismatic leader determined to carry out a symbolic attack against the occupying forces aimed at raising Japanese anger against the occupiers. PETER is an American soldier who aids Daio’s cause, apparently out of his desire for Goro. Although his fate is never discovered, one of the two endings to Goro’s screenplay suggests that he was brutally murdered by the rebels. TAGAME is the personified recording device that connects Kogito to his deceased friend Goro. Named after a species of water beetle that its headphones resemble, the device becomes Kogito’s constant companion, frustrating his wife and frightening his son. AKARI CHOKO is Kogito’s son. Although a birth defect left him cognitively challenged, Akari shows considerable musical talent. CHIKASHI CHOKO is Kogito’s wife, who is known for her straightforward, no-nonsense approach to life. At the end of the novel she clarifies many points that her husband had not been able to see. KOGITO CHOKO is the narrator of Oe’s novel, whose experiences roughly parallel the author’s own. The character’s name is derived from the French philosopher René Descartes’s famous line, “cogito ergo sum”—“I think, therefore I am.” In The Changeling, the character of Goro is based on Japanese filmmaker Juzo Itami, the real-life brother-in-law of author Kenzabur o Oe. ª TWPhoto/Corbis
between the characters both before and after Goro’s suicide. Kogito witnesses the tragedy of his friend’s slow decline from cancer and feels the composer’s pain at having to scale back his artistic endeavors in creating an “Abridged Composition Plan for the Remainder of My Life.” It is also revealed at critical times during the novel that those around Kogito have feared that he would commit suicide, even before the death of his friend. After Goro’s death Chikashi, begging her husband to end his obsession with Goro’s recordings, comments that “it isn’t that I think you’re doing these late-night séances as a way of gearing up for your own journey to the Other Side, but still . . . ” Later she associates Goro’s death with the dark trauma of “outside over there,” understanding that such a place holds power over Kogito as well. Kogito, on the other hand, clings to the belief that the “other side” referenced by Goro in his final tapes is a positive state through which the two might continue to communicate. Tied into the theme of death is the metaphor of the changeling. At the end of the novel Chikashi explains
GORO HANAWA is the brother of Chikashi and the close friend of Kogito. Before committing suicide he records a number of cassette tapes for Kogito that reflect on his memories of their relationship as well as events from his own life. He leaves behind the storyboards for the film he never made, and his notes suggest the truth of the trauma he experienced.
the breakthrough she experienced when first encountering Outside over There, immediately relating to the protagonist’s feelings of responsibility for her stolen sibling. She realizes that Goro was himself a changeling, forever altered by his postwar experiences. She explains that she hoped that in giving birth to her first child, she would be giving birth to Goro as he once was—a desire that deepened her depression when her child was born disabled. At the end of the novel Chikashi encounters a young woman named Ura, with whom Goro had shared a highly erotic but unconsummated relationship in Berlin. When she finds out the woman is pregnant and has been abandoned by the child’s father and her parents, Chikashi offers to help support her because Ura, like Chikashi, believes the child will bring new life to Goro.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
243
The Changeling
ABOUT THE AUTHOR was born on January 31, 1935, in the small Oe Kenzaburo village of Ose, on the Japanese island of Shikoku, where he was raised with the stories of his ancestors and the history of his birthplace. These stories deeply affected his later career as a was exposed to writer. After Japan’s defeat in World War II, Oe the democratic principles of the new Japan, which inspired him to leave his village for Tokyo. There he studied French literature and began to write. His first novel, Memushiri kouchi (Budnippng, lamb shooting), was published in 1958 and depicts the continued to write devastation of war on young people. Oe novels, short stories, and essays, and his work came to the attention of international audiences. In 1994 he was awarded the Nobel Prize in Literature. The Changeling shares with Oe’s many other works an interest in history and philosophy and a reliance on autobiographical elements.
In the story, Goro commits suicide by jumping off the roof of an office building. Sincere Image
W Style The Changeling is told in the third person, with the narrator’s focus remaining almost exclusively on Kogito until Chikashi takes over in the novel’s concluding chapters. This unexpected shift contrasts the different styles and approaches to life of husband and wife, shedding light on their clearly troubled relationship while adding important information to the story. In several concise chapters Chikashi outlines a version of Goro’s life and experiences that makes clear the limits of Kogito’s knowledge and interpretation. Several critics have noted that her version is much more enlightening than the many chapters devoted to her husband’s memories and philosophical reflections. The novel is, in part, a work of fictional biography that draws heavily on the author’s own life, depicting characters and events that would have been familiar to like his protagonist Kogito, is a Japanese readers. Oe, well-known novelist, and many of the events that Kogito describes are based on the writer’s own experiences. Goro is also clearly based on a real person—Oe’s brother-in-law, the Japanese filmmaker Juzo Itami, who killed himself in 1997. Furthermore, Oe’s oldest son, Hikari, was born with a birth defect that left him cognitively impaired. Like Hikari, Akari, the son of Kogito, develops a talent for music that transcends his disabilities. The Changeling is also a philosophical novel, or novel of ideas. In philosophical fiction issues more commonly raised in philosophical texts are central to the narrative. Notable works in this tradition, which can be traced back as early as the fourth century, include Thomas Carlyle’s Sartor Resartus (1833-1834), Friedrich Nietzsche’s Thus
244
Spoke Zarathustra (originally published in German as Also sprach Zarathustra, 1883-1885), and Jean Paul Sartre’s Nausea (first released in French as La Nausée, 1938). The Changeling’s defining philosophical issues include the meaning of death and the importance of art.
W Critical Reception Upon its English publication The Changeling was praised by commentators for its intricacy and philosophical style. Many lauded the book for its concluding shift to Chikashi’s consciousness. Akshita Nanda’s review of the novel in the Straits Times, praises its understated complexity, describing the work as “surprisingly light yet multi-layered.” Peter Pierce’s review in the Sydney Morning Herald calls the book “an illuminating study of art, friendship, and identity” that ultimately achieves “a kind of serenity and optimism.” Not all critics reacted positively to The Changeling, however. Many were bothered by the book’s many unresolved problems and unanswered questions. Writing in the Washington Post, for example, Michael Dirda suggests that the book “sadly lacks a clear and compelling narrative line” and that it “isn’t only long, it feels long.” Others found fault with the obscurity of the book’s allusions, particularly for English-speaking readers. In a related critique some commentators have suggested that the novel suffers from an awkward translation. Christopher Tayler’s review of the novel in the Guardian, for example, critiques Deborah Boliver Boehm’s translation, TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Changeling
particularly her attempts to explain Japanese culture to an English-speaking audience. Tayler suggests that Boehm “often appears to be clumsily incorporating footnote-type information into the text.” This criticism is echoed by Nanda, who notes that “a few chunks of explanatory text would have been better placed as footnotes.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Kenzabur ——— “Oe o.” Nobel Prize Laureates in Literature, Part 3. Detroit: Gale, 2007. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 331. (1935-).” Contemporary Literary “Kenzabur o Oe Criticism. Ed. Tom Burns and Jeffrey W. Hunter. Vol. 187. Detroit: Gale, 2004. 149-283. Literature Criticism Online. Web. 28 Aug. 2010.
Works Cited
Open Web Sources
Bares All.” Dirda, Michael. “Through a Thin Veil, Oe Washington Post 25 Mar. 2010: C10. Print.
The online magazine Bookslut offers a review of the novel that describes it as a complex, difficult read full of obscure allusions but praises it as worth the effort. http://www.bookslut.com/fiction/ 2010_04_015958.php page on Grove/Atlantic’s Web site The Kenzabur o Oe provides a biographical sketch and bibliography, an overview of the author’s major works and awards, and study guides for some of his better-known works. http://www.groveatlantic.com/grove/bin/wc.dll? groveproc˜genauth˜571˜0
Nanda, Akshita. “Till Death Do Us Part.” Rev. of The Straits Times [SingaChangeling, by Kenzabur o Oe. pore] 4 July 2010: n. pag. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 28 Aug. 2010. Kenzabur Oe, o. The Changeling. Trans. Deborah Boliver Boehm. New York: Grove, 2010. Print. Pierce, Peter. “Reflections on a Life Revisited.” Sydney Morning Herald 14 Aug. 2010: 32. Print. Tayler, Christopher. Rev. of The Changeling, by Guardian [London] 12 June 2010: Kenzabur o Oe. 10. Print. Additional Resources
The official Web Site of the Nobel Prize features brief and his work. http://nobel information about Oe prize.org/nobel_prizes/literature/laureates/1994/ oe-bio.html
Criticism and Reviews
For Further Reading
Carrigan, Henry L., Jr. Rev. of The Changeling, by Library Journal 1 Apr. 2010: 69+. Kenzabur o Oe. Lauds the novel for its exploration of the relationship between the past and present, and likens it to works by Czech writer Milan Kundera and German author Günter Grass. New Yorker Rev. of The Changeling, by Kenzabur o Oe. 29 Mar. 2010: 101. Notes favorably the novel’s autobiographical qualities. Publishers Rev. of The Changeling, by Kenzabur o Oe. Weekly 30 Nov. 2009: 26. Offers incidents from the author’s life as context for the novel.
Keene, Donald. The Pleasure of Japanese Literature. New York: Columbia UP, 1988. Print. Developed from his lectures on the same topic, Keene’s book explores the origins and aesthetics of Japanese literature. Oe, Kenzabur o. The Silent Cry: A Novel. Trans. John Bester. New York: Harper, 1974. Print. This earlier focuses on the relationship between two novel by Oe adult brothers whose lives take different paths.
McCulloch, Alison. “Fiction Chronicle.” Rev. of The New York Times Book Changeling, by Kenzabur o Oe. Review 16 May 2010: 28(L). Praises the contemplative nature of the novel. Olson, Ray. Rev. of The Changeling, by Kenzabur o Oe. Booklist 1 Mar. 2010: 48. Commends the novel’s merging of elements of the autobiographical novel and the roman à clef. Gale Resources
Kenzabur Hirano, Hidehisa. “Oe o.” Japanese Fiction Writers since World War II. Ed. Van C. Gessel. Detroit: Gale, 1997. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 182.
Richie, Donald. A Hundred Years of Japanese Film: A Concise History. Tokyo: Kodansha, 2001. Print. This nonfiction volume provides a history of Japanese cinema, examining popular films and prominent Japanese directors, including Oe’s brother-in-law Juzo Itami, on whom the character of Goro was based. Toland, John. The Rising Sun: The Decline and Fall of the Japanese Empire, 1936-1945. New York: Random, 1970. Print. Toland’s work of nonfiction chronicles Japanese history in the years leading up to and during World War II. Williamson, Kate T. A Year in Japan. New York: Princeton Architectural, 2006. Williamson’s journal of her year in Japan offers insight into the people and culture of the country in which The Changeling is set.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Greta Gard
245
Child 44 By Tom Rob Smith
W Introduction A murder mystery set in the 1950s in the Stalinist Soviet Union, Tom Rob Smith’s Child 44 (2008) has been regarded as a work more complex and literary than the typical novel in this genre. The novel centers around MGB (state security police) officer Leo Demidov, an ideologue who investigates what he is told to investigate and dutifully hides whatever he is told to make disappear. Demidov adheres to the Soviet notion that crime, except for that related to political challenges to the State, does not exist in the workers’ paradise that is the socialist republic. In the course of pressuring the father of a dead boy to rescind his insistence that the child has been murdered, Demidov is drawn into the perplexing mystery of the child’s death. Forced to investigate his own wife in order to prove his loyalty to the State, Demidov refuses to implicate her in any wrongdoing. His insubordination, which would normally have severe consequences, is punished in the aftermath of Stalin’s death, and consequently results only in a demotion and relocation from Moscow to a remote village. He resumes his investigation into what he now believes is a string of serial, ritualized killings of children, while continuing to struggle against the interference of Vasili Nikitin, an MGB agent investigating Demidov and his wife. At the novel’s conclusion, Demidov is revealed to be one of the two boys in the 1930s vignette with which the novel opens, the older brother of the boy who grew up to be the serial killer Demidov has been chasing.
W Literary and Historical Context
Although Tom Rob Smith’s novel is set in the 1950s, the historical figure upon which the story is loosely based was a Russian serial killer who murdered over fifty people in the
1970s and 1980s. Andrei Chikatilo, who became known as the Ripper of Rostov, murdered and cannibalized women and children. Chikatilo was later tried and executed for the crimes. Smith takes the notion of this type of killer and situates him in the Stalinist Soviet Union during a time period in which violent crimes were ignored by the State. To admit that such crime existed in what was ostensibly a worker’s paradise, an ideal communal state of existence, would be to admit that Soviet socialism was a failure. In Smith’s novel, then, the government that allows such crimes to occur and instead punishes innocents who speak out against the government, becomes the true villain. Joseph Stalin ruled the Soviet Union from the late 1920s until his death in 1953. Following Vladimir Lenin’s death in 1924, Stalin, then the general secretary of the Communist Party, portrayed himself as Lenin’s heir and gradually consolidated power. Under his leadership, the people of the Soviet Union suffered many abuses. He forced the collectivization of agriculture and oversaw the rapid industrialization of the country. In the 1930s, during what became known as the Great Terror, Stalin purged the Communist Party of its so-called enemies—a move that led to execution or exile to labor camps for countless citizens. Despite the emaciated state of the Red Army and his lack of preparedness for Adolf Hitler’s invasion in 1941, Stalin led the Soviet Union to victory over the Nazis, but at a huge cost. In 2010, on the anniversary of the Soviet defeat of Nazi Germany, a day known as Victory Day, Russian President Medvedev offered harsh criticism of the Soviet Union, Communism, and particularly Stalin, an attack that stood in sharp contrast to the more positive assessment offered by Medvedev’s predecessor, the former president and now prime minister Vladimir Putin. According to a 2010 article by Tony Halpin in the United Kingdom’s online journal the Times, “Mr. Medvedev said that Stalin had committed unforgivable crimes regardless of any progress made by the Soviet Union under his rule.” Medvedev further condemns the “mass crimes against the people” for which Stalin was responsible.
246 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Child 44
MAJOR CHARACTERS ANDREI is introduced to readers as a young boy. He avoids contemplating the horrors his village is experiencing— starvation, disease—by hiding in his room with a deck of cards given to him by his father. Andrei perpetually waits for his older brother, Pavel, to play with him, but Pavel is always busy. Andrei is perceived as clumsy and stupid, but in reality he simply needs glasses. Throughout the course of the novel, messages are sent to Pavel in the form of victims of a serial killer, who is in fact Andrei. As Andrei tells Pavel, his goal in life is to make Pavel regret abandoning Andrei during their childhood. ARKADY is the little boy who eventually becomes known in Demidov and Nesterov’s investigation as Child 44, or the 44th victim of the serial killer Demidov pursues. LEO DEMIDOV/PAVEL is the protagonist of the novel. Attacked and later raised by the man who would have murdered him, Leo begins a new life when he is taken to Moscow. After growing up in fear, he becomes a soldier, and eventually a war hero. Promoted to the rank of officer for the secret State police, Demidov arrests anyone who is suspected of questioning the government or threatening the illusions the government wishes to sustain, and he does so knowing that horrible fates—in prisons, work camps, or at the hands of torturers or executioners—will meet those he has arrested. Soviet leader Joseph Stalin with a young girl. Child 44 is a murder mystery novel that takes place in the Stalinist Soviet Union of the 1950s. Henry Guttmann/Getty Images
W Themes In Child 44, Smith intertwines the theme of personal redemption with that of government corruption. The protagonist’s loyalty to a corrupt state is not defended, but portrayed bluntly. Demidov knows that the fear he fuels is an effective means of controlling the people. Yet he seems to believe in the notion of a greater good; he views himself as serving a higher cause, one that ultimately benefits the society in which he lives. However, faced with the murder of a child, along with having to investigate his own wife, Demidov’s feelings about justice and truth begin to change. The mechanism through which this personal transformation happens is the State itself, combined with Demidov’s growing understanding of its corrupt nature. Under Stalin’s rule, Demidov likely would have been executed, but Stalin’s death provides a reprieve for Demidov, and the agents responsible for his punishment send him into exile with his wife instead of a work camp or ordering his immediate death. In the small town to which he has been sent, Demidov discovers that another child has died, and that this murder has been covered up as well. As the political corruption he faces becomes undeniable,
RAISA DEMIDOV is Leo’s wife. Her relationship with her husband evolves as the novel progresses. She admits to having married him out of fear; through the course of the novel, she becomes an object of Leo’s investigation, as he is forced to prove his loyalty to the state by implicating Raisa in political misdeeds. While he suspects her of infidelity, the State suspects her of espionage. At the end of the novel, she and Leo seek to adopt two children whose parents were killed as a result of Leo’s actions. GENERAL NESTEROV is a militia officer with whom Leo Demidov works to solve the murders, although their cooperative relationship takes time to develop. Nesterov enables Demidov to continue the investigation by helping Demidov and Raisa escape, when the nature of the investigation—that it is focusing on a serial killer, and that there are no firm suspects—makes it dangerous to pursue. VASILI NIKITIN, an MGB agent, is Demidov’s rival and enemy, and charges Raisa Demidov with espionage. Demidov is tasked by Nikitin to verify this claim. Once Leo and Raisa become enemies of the state, Nikitin doggedly hunts them, following their trail to Andrei’s home. As Nikitin is about to shoot them, Andrei stabs and kills Nikitin.
Demidov’s road to personal redemption becomes clearer. While pursuing the case puts him and his wife in danger, Demidov is driven by a desire to arrive at the truth, rather
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
247
Child 44
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Born on February 19, 1979, in London to a Swedish mother and an English father, both antique dealers, Tom Rob Smith was raised in London. He graduated from Cambridge University in 2001, and spent a scholarship-funded year writing. He worked as television assistant storyliner before landing a position that sent him to Cambodia, as a British Broadcasting Corporation writer on a local soap opera. After publishing Child 44 in 2008, Smith sold the film rights to director Ridley Scott. He published his second novel, The Secret Speech, in 2009.
than the fabrications of the State. He seeks to stop the killer before more children are killed. The focus of the novel, the stolen innocence of children, is another thematic thread that is woven throughout the work. In the vignette with which the novel opens, the two impoverished boys are forced to learn about loss, hunger, and death at a very young age. The older boy, Pavel, has had to take on the role of the man of the house following his father’s death, while the younger boy, Andrei, idolizes his older brother. While he is hunting a cat for food, Pavel is caught, beaten and taken away, himself destined to become food for a couple’s starving son. When Pavel’s would-be murderer discovers that his own son has died, he and his wife raise Pavel as their own child. Andrei is left with a grieving mother, who blames her younger son for Pavel’s disappearance. Andrei grows up to become the serial child killer whom Leo/Pavel, is hunting. The lives of forty-four children are cut short, ended torturously, as Andrei tries to get the attention of his brother, whom he strongly suspects works for the MGB. Smith indicts the State for this tragic loss of innocence—if the Soviet government had allowed for the notion that crime exists, Andrei would have been arrested years before he killed so many innocent people.
goes beyond the scope of a typical murder mystery. The personal transformation of Demidov, from a Stalinist automaton to a thinking, caring individual, is the primary feature that allows the novel to transcend the traditional boundaries of the genre. From the omniscient narrator point-of-view, Smith explores the emotional conflicts not only of Demidov, but of other, often minor characters as well, fleshing out details often lost in the hurried pace of many genre mysteries. Such a narrative strategy lends the story emotional weight and highlights Smith’s central theme of the brutality of the State.
W Critical Reception Long-listed for the Man Booker prize in 2008, Smith’s Child 44 has been praised by some critics as a genre novel with literary overtones. Critics such as Barry Forshaw, in a 2008 article for the Independent, find that despite its status as a “crime novel,” the work “has the texture of more serious writing.” Janet Maslin, in a 2008 New York Times review, describes Smith’s novel as “tightly woven,” and goes on to praise the work’s complexities and plot twists, although the critic does fault Smith’s prose as “slightly ponderous.” Similarly, Marilyn Stasio, in a 2008 piece for the New York Times Book Review, states that some portions of the novel suffer from a “static and wordy” style. Stasio, however, praises the tightening of the prose as the novel’s plot advances. In these later sections of the book, Smith’s style becomes “more fluid and cinematic,” Stasio argues. Smith’s plot development is a source of commendation among critics as well. Thomas Gaughan, in a 2008 review for Booklist, finds the pace of the plot to be “relentless,” while Henry Sutton in a 2008 article for the Mirror, describes the work as “tense, atmospheric, inventive, and surprisingly timely.” Commenting on the deeper thematic concerns of the novel, Andrew Nagorski, in a 2008 Newsweek article characterizes Smith’s work “as a penetrating deconstruction of the myths of what passed for justice in the Soviet Union.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
W Style
Works Cited
Although Smith’s work is ostensibly a work of genre fiction—a murder mystery—its prose style, in combination with some of its themes, has led to it being regarded as a literary novel as well. The work is written from the perspective of an omniscient, third-person narrator, providing Smith with access to the thoughts of all his characters. In focusing on the crisis of conscience the protagonist endures, Smith’s novel shares “the preoccupation, in fact, of many a literary novel,” states Barry Forshaw in a 2008 review of Child 44 for the Independent. The fact that the novel also made the long list for the Man Booker prize is indicative that the novel
248
Forshaw, Barry. “Child 44, by Tom Rob Smith.” Independent [London] 14 Apr. 2008. Web. 21 Aug. 2010. Gaughan, Thomas. Rev. of Child 44. Booklist 104.11 (1 Feb. 2008): 4. Print. Halpin, Tony. “Medvedev Denounces Stalin for ‘Mass Crimes against the Russian People.’” Times [London] 8 May 2010. Web. 21 Aug. 2010. “Joseph Stalin.” BBC History: Historic Figures. Web. 21 Aug. 2010. Maslin, Janet. “Forget It, Comrade. This Is Moscow.” New York Times 8 May 2008. Web. 21 Aug. 2010. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Child 44
Nagorski, Andrew. “When a Hunter Gets Captured by the Game.” Newsweek 2 May 2008. Web. 21 Aug. 2010. Smith, Tom Rob. Child 44. London: Simon and Schuster, 2008. Print. Stasio, Marilyn. “Forbidden Questions.” New York Times Book Review 4 May 2008: 26(L). Print. Sutton, Henry. “Books: Red Menace; Book of the Week, Child 44 by Tom Rob Smith.” Mirror 29 Feb. 2008: 11. Print. Questia. Web. 21 Aug. 2010. Additional Resources
Open Web Sources
The Biography Channel’s Web site, at www.biography. com, offers a brief biography of the serial killer Andrei Chikatilo, the murderer upon whom Smith loosely based his novel. Seventeen Moments in Soviet History, at www. soviethistory.org, explores critical events in the history of the Soviet Union, including detailed coverage of Stalin’s rule. Tom Rob Smith’s Web site offers biographical information, news of upcoming events, and a complete bibliography of Smith’s works. http://www. tomrobsmith.com
Criticism and Reviews
Rev. of Child 44, by Tom Rob Smith. Kirkus Reviews 1 Mar. 2008. Contends that despite the unlikely coincidences in the novel, Child 44 is commendable for its exciting pace and fascinating setting. Rev. of Child 44, by Tom Rob Smith. Publishers Weekly 255.9 (3 Mar. 2008): 29. Print. Favorable review of Smith’s Child 44 in which the anonymous critic praises Smith’s plot, characterization, and historical detail. Conaty, Barbara. Rev. of Child 44, by Tom Rob Smith. Library Journal 133.5 (15 Mar. 2008): 63. Print. Offers a brief overview of Smith’s novel and praises the pace and plotting of the story. Geard, Amanda. “Thriller Set against Sinister Backdrop of Stalin’s Russia.” Cape Times 5 Dec. 2008. HighBeam Research. Web. 21 Aug. 2010. Review of Child 44 in which Smith’s thorough research is applauded. Guttridge, Peter. “In Pursuit of a Russian Ripper.” Observer [London] 2 Mar. 2008. Web. 21 Aug. 2010. Commends Smith’s novel as an exciting, complex thriller, and provides a brief interview with the author. Gale Resources
“Tom Rob Smith.” Contemporary Authors. Ed. Elisabeth Fuller. Vol. 282. Detroit: Gale, 2009: 387-89. Print. Gale Virtual Reference Library. Web. 21 Aug. 2010.
For Further Reading
McCauley, Martin. Stalin and Stalinism. 3rd ed. London: Longman, 2003. Print. Originally published in 1982, McCauley’s work studies the way Stalin transformed the Soviet Union and its interpretation of socialism. McCauley examines both the advances made in the realm of industrialization and the brutality of Stalin’s regime. Pridemore, William Alex. Ruling Russia: Law, Crime, and Justice in a Changing Society. Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield, 2005. Print. Pridemore explores the way the dramatic changes in Russian society, in terms of culture, politics, and economics, shaped the evolution of its legal and criminal justice systems. Smith, Martin Cruz. Gorky Park. New York: Random House, 1981. Print. Tom Rob Smith’s Child 44 has been compared to this novel by Martin Cruz Smith, in which homicide investigator Arkady Renko faces threats from the KGB and other sources as he pursues the perpetrator of a triple homicide in Moscow. Like Child 44, Gorky Park is the first novel in a series of thrillers featuring a recurring investigatorprotagonist. Smith, Tom Rob. The Secret Speech. London: Simon and Schuster, 2009. Print. Smith’s second thriller resumes the story of Leo Demidov, the protagonist of Child 44, and his family, who once again find themselves at the center of a web of crime and political intrigue. Catherine Dominic
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
249
The Children’s Book By A. S. Byatt
W Introduction A. S. Byatt’s The Children’s Book (2009) is an intricate portrait of several families living through a time of profound social change, from the last few years of the Victorian era to the end of World War I. Byatt, a prolific author who won the Man Booker Prize for her immensely popular novel Possession (1990), took several years to complete The Children’s Book. The result pleased many reviewers but disappointed some, who found the work overly didactic. The main character, Olive Wellwood, is a successful writer of fairy tales, a social idealist, and the mother of a large family. She is also the center of a complicated social network that becomes part of the narrative. Through this large cast of characters, Byatt depicts aesthetic and political movements of the time and explores the complexities of creative life. As destructive secrets chip away at the seemingly enlightened existence of the Wellwoods, the families become increasingly entangled. In the end the events of World War I eclipse the domestic and artistic dramas created by the characters. The Children’s Book was short-listed for the Booker Prize in 2009.
W Literary and Historical Context
The Children’s Book begins in 1895, during Britain’s transition from the late Victorian tradition of repression to the social ferment of the Edwardian era (1901–1910), and ends by portraying the impact of World War I (1914–1918) on the lives of the characters. Several cultural developments of the period are critical components of the novel, in particular the Arts and Crafts movement and Fabianism, both of which reached their peak of influence between 1880 and 1910. The Arts and Crafts movement promoted a return to simpler principles
of design and a more authentic approach to workmanship. It had a strong impact on aesthetic trends not only in Britain but also internationally. Many of its proponents opposed industrialization, emphasizing the social value of handwork, and some pursued such utopian ideas as the formation of craft communities for artisans. In this respect the Arts and Crafts movement shared common ground with socialist groups such as the Fabian Society. Founded in 1884, the society advocated gradual economic reform and social transformation rather than revolution. Among its members were literary notables George Bernard Shaw, H. G. Wells, and Virginia Woolf. The novel also addresses the era’s changing view of women and children. A romanticized ideal of childhood innocence emerged during this period, but at the same time, children were often neglected—left to the care of nannies and boarding schools or exploited through child labor. Women began to seek higher education and to campaign for the right to vote, establishing the foundations of the feminist movement in England. A historical figure who was engaged with many of these social developments, children’s author and Fabianist Edith Nesbit, served as an inspiration for the character of Olive Wellwood.
W Themes An ambitious work, The Children’s Book explores the tensions between men and women, parents and children, art and life, conformity and individuality, and appearance and reality. By structuring the novel around four households—those of Olive and Humphry Wellwood, Humphry’s brother Basil, the Fludds, and Major Prosper—Byatt illuminates her varied themes from four different vantage points. The thematic strands of the novel are woven together most dramatically in the story of Olive and her family, whose apparently idyllic life at Todefright (their picturesque country home) conceals secrets and darker realities. The self-indulgence of Olive
250 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Children’s Book
MAJOR CHARACTERS BENEDICT FLUDD is a brilliant but unstable ceramicist who abuses his daughters while his laudanum-addicted wife neglects them. PHILIP WARREN, a poor but gifted boy, is rescued by Olive’s circle of friends after he is found hiding in a museum. He is apprenticed to Benedict Fludd and becomes a successful potter. DOROTHY WELLWOOD is the most sensible of the Wellwood children. She wants to become a physician and is determined to find out who her actual parents are. HUMPHRY WELLWOOD, Olive’s upper-class husband, is a womanizer who turns from banking to social activism. Like Olive, he is more concerned with his personal interests than with the children. OLIVE WELLWOOD is a successful writer of fairy stories and the matriarch of a large family. Having escaped from the poverty of her childhood, she pursues a variety of utopian ideas and creative explorations while leaving much of the household management to her sister. TOM WELLWOOD is the eldest Wellwood son and Olive’s favorite. He prefers nature to society, is mistreated at boarding school, and ultimately feels betrayed by his mother. Portrait of A. S. Byatt, author of The Children's Book. ª ANDY RAIN/ epa/Corbis
and her husband results in a house full of ambiguously related children, and Olive finds it difficult to separate her creative role as a writer from her practical role as a mother. Her seemingly benign exploitation of the children—whom she uses to feed her imagination—has tragic consequences. The gap between appearance and reality is even more sinister at Purchase House, where the deranged Benedict Fludd memorializes the sexual abuse of his daughters in hidden works of art. As the story unfolds, all of the characters are shaken by unexpected and unalterable realities, from the suicide of Olive’s favored son, Tom, to the terrible toll of World War I.
W Style The Children’s Book depicts a great variety of personalities and relationships while also creating an involved portrait of a social setting and a historical era. Byatt accomplishes her objective by building an intricate yet logical network of associations around a charismatic central character. She employs the arrival of an outsider, Philip Warren, to reveal this network and to set off a chain of events that forms the essential outline of the novel. Tom discovers
young Philip in the museum where Olive’s friend Prosper Caine holds an important position. The two adults make the boy into something of a protégé. He is first presented to Olive’s diverse, eccentric social circle at an annual midsummer party where most of the many characters are assembled. Then he is apprenticed to Benedict Fludd, whose derangement eventually affects everyone’s fate. As the narrative structure develops, some of the characters introduced at the party disappear, while others become unexpectedly important. In addition, the political alignments and aesthetic ideals defined early in the novel provide motivation and background for the many activities of the characters, such as a visit to the dazzling 1900 Exposition Universelle in Paris. Byatt uses a third-person omniscient narrator. This strategy and the structure of the novel enable her to manage a large cast of characters engaged in complex, overlapping plotlines. She uses the device of children’s books to provide a more intimate view into Olive’s relationships with her children, especially Tom. The larger narrative is interspersed with excerpts from the special stories Olive writes for each of the children. The reader gradually realizes that these are more than imaginative tales; they are psychological documents that Olive uses to define her visions of the children.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
251
The Children’s Book
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
characterisation and narrative drive” but contends that it succeeds as a novel of ideas. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Antonia Susan (Drabble) Byatt was born on August 24, 1936, in Sheffield, England, to parents John Frederick and Kathleen Marie Drabble. She earned a BA from Newnham College, Oxford, in 1957 and took graduate courses at Bryn Mawr College in Pennsylvania and at Somerville College, Oxford, before marrying economist Ian Charles Rayner Byatt in 1959. The couple divorced in 1969. Byatt married Peter John Duffy the same year. She had two children in her first marriage and two in her second. From 1962 to 1983, she taught literature at several institutions. A prolific writer, Byatt is best known for her 1990 novel Possession, which won the Man Booker Prize (1990), the Irish Times-Aer Lingus International Fiction Prize (1990), and the Commonwealth Writers' Prize for Best Book in the Eurasia Region (1991). Her 1992 novella Morpho Eugenia served as the basis for the film Angels and Insects (1995). Byatt, who has also written a critical biography of Iris Murdoch and has edited several anthologies, was made a Dame Commander of the British Empire (DBE) in 1999.
Works Cited
“Byatt’s a Winner: Critics Full of Praise for The Children’s Book.” Bookseller 15 May 2009: 40. Print. Rev. of The Children’s Book, by A. S. Byatt. Kirkus Reviews 15 June 2009: 620. Print. Dunmore, Helen. Rev. of The Children’s Book, by A. S. Byatt. Times [London] 24 Apr. 2009: n. pag. Web. 20 Sept. 2010. Hoffert, Barbara. Rev. of The Children’s Book, by A. S. Byatt. Library Journal 134.13 (2009): 64. Print. Jones, Radhika. “Mother Grimm: A. S. Byatt’s Latest Novel.” Time 19 Oct. 2009: 62. Print. Rubin, Martin. Rev. of The Children’s Book, by A. S. Byatt. San Francisco Chronicle 25 Oct. 2009: F1. Print. Schuessler, Jennifer. “Dangerous Fancies.” New York Times Book Review 11 Oct. 2009: BR10. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
W Critical Reception Bookseller reports that The Children’s Book “attracted a wealth of reviews, finally becoming the most reviewed title” on the weekend following its publication. The majority of assessments have been positive. Kirkus Reviews calls the novel “ambitious, accomplished and intelligent,” noting that “Byatt’s concern is the vast area where utopian visions collide with human nature.” Writing for Library Journal, Barbara Hoffert describes The Children’s Book as “pitch perfect, stately, told with breathtakingly matter-of-fact acuteness.” A Time magazine review by Radhika Jones concludes that although Byatt’s latest novel is not the equal of Possession, it is still “a rich and ambitious work, steeped in ideas and capped with a lacerating final act.” In his appraisal in the San Francisco Chronicle, Martin Rubin lauds Byatt’s “imaginative capacity to transmogrify what she has studied into something truly felt.” Some reviewers were less patient with Byatt’s informational excursions, and several found the novel too long and sprawling. Jennifer Scheussler, for example, comments in the New York Times Book Review that “so much is stuffed into The Children’s Book that it can be hard to see the magic forest for all the historical lumber—let alone the light at the end of the narrative tunnel.” However, even reviewers who acknowledge flaws in the book typically take a balanced view. Writing in the London Times, Helen Dunmore notes that “the panoramic quality of The Children’s Book is achieved at some cost to brilliance of
252
Clark, Alex. “Her Dark Materials.” Guardian [London] 9 May 2009: 6. Print. Clark’s appreciative review focuses on Byatt’s dark vision of artistic creation in The Children’s Book. Lowry, Elizabeth. “Repossessed by A. S. Byatt.” Times Literary Supplement [London] 13 May 2009: n. pag. Web. 20 Sept. 2010. This review examines the Edwardian view of childhood as a context for Byatt’s novel. Tillinghast, Richard. “An English Saga.” New Criterion 28.9 (2010): 73+. Print. A positive assessment that focuses on the novel’s historical setting. Walden, George. “Period Pains.” New Statesman 27 Apr. 2009: 48+. Print. Walden suggests that Byatt’s novel possesses certain characteristics of the late Victorian era that is its subject. Wood, James. “Bristling with Diligence.” London Review of Books 31.19 (2009): 6-8. Print. Wood provides a thoughtful overview of style and themes in The Children’s Book and a mixed opinion of the novel’s merits. Gale Resources
“A. S. Byatt.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2010. Literature Resource Center. Web. 12 Sept. 2010. Coelsch-Foisner, Sabine. “A. S. Byatt (24 August 1936-).” British and Irish Short-Fiction Writers, 1945–2000. Ed. Cheryl Alexander Malcolm and David Malcolm. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 319. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Children’s Book
Detroit: Gale, 2005. 39-47. Dictionary of Literary Biography Complete Online. Web. 18 Sept. 2010. Musil, Caryn McTighe. “A. S. Byatt (24 August 1936-).” British Novelists since 1960, 1st series. Ed. Jay L. Halio. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 14. Detroit: Gale, 1983. 194-205. Dictionary of Literary Biography Complete Online. Web. 18 Sept. 2010. Parris, P. B., and Caryn McTighe Musil. “A. S. Byatt (24 August 1936-).” British Novelists since 1960, 2nd series. Ed. Merritt Moseley. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 194. Detroit: Gale, 1998. 82-97. Dictionary of Literary Biography Complete Online. Web. 18 Sept. 2010. Open Web Sources
The author’s official Web site provides a biography, a lengthy bibliography, and interviews, including a link to a radio discussion of The Children’s Book with Diane Rehm. http://www.asbyatt.com and http:// thedianerehmshow.org/shows/2009-10-05/byattchildrens-book-knopf For Further Reading
Briggs, Julia. Edith Nesbit: A Woman of Passion. Stroud: Tempus, 2007. Print. Author of such famous stories as The Railway Children, Nesbit was also a noted social activist. Byatt’s interest in Nesbit influenced her creation of Olive Wellwood, the matriarch in The Children’s Book.
Cambridge UP, 1982. Print. This detailed examination focuses on the time period covered in The Children’s Book, illuminating political and aesthetic trends that affect Byatt’s characters. Byatt, A. S. Possession: A Romance. London: Vintage, 2002. Print. Published in 1990, Byatt’s novel intertwines a modern love story with a parallel tale that explores art and life in the Victorian era. Through both similarities and differences, this earlier novel provides an interesting counterpoint to The Children’s Book. Harries, Elizabeth W. Twice upon a Time: Women Writers and the History of the Fairy Tale. Princeton: Princeton UP, 2003. Print. Examining a feminine style of storytelling in the context of fairy-tale traditions, Harries presents useful background for understanding the character of Olive Wellwood. She also discusses Byatt and several of the author’s earlier works. Kelly, Kathleen C. A. S. Byatt. New York: Twayne, 1996. Print. Kelly surveys Byatt’s work and examines the author’s relationship to postmodernism. Von Franz, Marie-Louise. The Interpretation of Fairy Tales. Boston: Shambhala, 1996. Print. Von Franz, a Jungian analyst, explores some of the fairy tale’s psychological aspects, including shadow symbolism and the role of evil. Her views provide insight into the function of fairy stories for the Wellwood family.
Britain, Ian. Fabianism and Culture: A Study in British Socialism and the Arts c. 1884-1918. Cambridge:
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Cynthia Giles
253
Citizen Vince By Jess Walter
W Introduction A crime novel by a highly respected journalist, Citizen Vince won the 2006 Edgar Allan Poe Award for best novel from the Mystery Writers of America. Author Jess Walter has been praised for writing complex characters inhabiting the crime world, as well as for his gritty, realistic dialogue. Citizen Vince begins by introducing the reader to Vince Camden, who is working as a baker in a Spokane, Washington, doughnut shop. It is soon clear that Vince is not a law-abiding citizen; he also steals credit card numbers and runs another side business in which he hides marijuana in souvenir jars of volcanic ash from Mount Saint Helens as a way of using tourists as unwitting drug distributors. Vince has a long criminal history, and his previous dealings with credit cards landed him in the witness protection program after he testified in court against several organized crime bosses. No longer Marty Hagen of New York, he gets a new start as Vince Camden. Vince finds the daily routine of working at Donut Make You Hungry to actually be refreshing, but he cannot seem to avoid the allure of the criminal activities. He dreams of a life where he enjoys a modest home, wife, and children, so he saves the money he earns from selling stolen credit card numbers and marijuana. Receiving a voter registration card under his new name also inspires visions of becoming a citizen participating in American democracy, something he could not do as Marty Hagen. Vince’s old habits catch up with him when Lenny and Doug, the men with whom he works in the credit card scheme, begin to suspect that Vince is hoarding more than his share of the profits. Lenny brings in a mob hit man named Spike from New York. Recognizing Spike from his days back East, Vince suspects that his past is catching up
with him and that the mob has somehow figured out he is really Marty Hagen. Going back to his old stomping grounds in New York, Vince finds the mob boss who put the hit out on him in an effort to pay him back. His plan goes awry, however, and Vince is sent back to Spokane to become a hit man himself. This leads to a confrontation with Spike and a surprise climax.
W Literary and Historical Context
Citizen Vince is set in the days just before the 1980 U.S. presidential election in which incumbent Democrat Jimmy Carter lost to Republican Ronald Reagan. Vince becomes intrigued by the politics of the day both because of his recently received voter’s registration card and because he is attracted to a woman named Kelly, a regular visitor to his doughnut shop who is also campaigning for her attorney boss, Aaron Grebbe, who wants to become a state senator. The mood at the time is a desire for change. President Carter’s administration has been politically damaged by a long-standing hostage crisis in Iran. In 1979 the U.S.-supported shah of Iran was overthrown during an Islamic fundamentalist revolution led by the Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini. In November 1979, the U.S. embassy in Tehran was stormed by young revolutionaries who took more than sixty Americans as hostages. The incident became a political crisis for Carter because the Iranians’ demands for the release of the hostages were so extreme that the president could not give in to them. Carter’s inability to resolve the problem, and an embarrassingly unsuccessful helicopter mission to rescue the hostages, caused him to be seen as weak in comparison to Reagan, whose campaign portrayed the Republican and former California governor as a tough
254 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Citizen Vince
MAJOR CHARACTERS ANGE is one of Johnny Boy’s men. Like many of the characters in the book, he takes a liking to Vince, and he plays a key role in the novel’s climax. DAVID BEST is the deputy U.S. marshal who is Vince’s contact in the Witness Protection Program. JOHNNY BOY is the crime boss of the Gamino crew in Queens and puts the hit on Vince. Johnny, still in grief over his daughter’s death in a car accident, forgives Vince’s debt to the mob, but at a price. VINCE CAMDEN is the novel’s thirty-six-year-old protagonist. Born Marty Hagen, he went into the Witness Protection Program after testifying against mob bosses. DONNIE CHARLES is the crooked cop who is temporarily Dupree’s partner in New York. Often unnecessarily violent, Donnie still manages to be a sympathetic character when his personal loss is revealed. DOUG works with Lenny and Vince in the credit card scheme. He is the owner of Doug’s Passport Photos, where he also makes phony IDs for underage teens who want to drink alcohol.
The events of Citizen Vince take place just prior to the 1980 U.S. presidential election. ª David J. & Janice L. Frent Collection/Corbis
leader who would strengthen the U.S. military and negotiate from a position of strength. The political debate becomes a background tapestry for the novel, as Vince tries to decide whether his voting would really matter and, indeed, whether or not it really matters which side wins the election. The concept of trying to overcome a two-party system is also addressed by the author when he refers to the campaign of independent candidate John Anderson. Vince realizes Anderson has no chance of winning the election and says so to a campaigner for Anderson, who struggles to come up with a reason why anyone should vote for a man who cannot win.
W Themes The main theme of Citizen Vince focuses on the idea of whether or not it is possible to change one’s lot in life. Vince is repeatedly portrayed in the book as very intelligent and likable, yet he seems incapable of escaping the criminal, lower-class world into which he was born. A talented chess and card player, Vince also came up with the idea of distributing marijuana by hiding it in souvenir
ALAN DUPREE a rookie detective who takes on the Vince Camden case. Honest and determined, he is the only cop in Spokane that suspects Vince was somehow involved in Doug’s murder, and he pursues the case all the way to New York City. AARON GREBBE is an attorney running for the Washington state legislature. A Republican, he is earnest in his conservative beliefs and a Reagan supporter. His belief in gun ownership rights proves to be a key element in the story. LENNY HUGGINS is Vince’s boss in the credit card operation. He suspects that Vince is keeping more than a fair share of the profits and therefore hires a hit man. KELLY, an attractive law firm worker whom Vince becomes attracted to after she visits his doughnut shop. She works for attorney Aaron Grebbe, and it soon becomes known that the two are having an affair, much to Vince’s disappointment. RAY “STICKS” SCATIERI (Ray LaRue) is a hit man for the mob who seemingly has no moral qualms whatsoever. Like Vince, he was put into the Witness Protection Program, but even as Ray LaRue he lacks Vince’s desire to go straight. BETH SHERMAN is a 33-year-old prostitute who dreams of becoming a realtor. She is trying to turn her life around, quitting drugs and becoming an attentive mother to her son, Kenyon. She would like to be Vince’s girlfriend, as well, but feels unworthy of his attention.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
255
Citizen Vince
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Jess Walter is a resident of Spokane, Washington, where much of his fiction is set. A graduate of Eastern Washington University, he worked as a crime reporter and was a finalist for a Pulitzer Prize in 1992 for spot news reporting, as well as a two-time Livingston Award finalist, a prize that goes to journalists under the age of thirty-five. His first two books are nonfiction, true crime works: 1995’s Every Knee Shall Bow: The Truth and Tragedy of Ruby Ridge and the Randy Weaver Family, which was later reprinted in 2001 as Ruby Ridge, and In Contempt (1996), written with Christopher Darden. His experience reporting on real criminals provided a solid background for writing crime fiction, beginning with 2001’s Over Tumbled Graves. After winning the Edgar for Citizen Vince, Walter was a finalist for the National Book Award for The Zero (2006).
volcanic ash. He is also very street smart. However, he has known no other life than that of the criminal, having a jail record that goes back to when he was fifteen. Given a new identity under the Witness Protection Program, Vince has been offered a golden opportunity to change his ways and become a new man. Although his job at the doughnut shop, where he is the head baker, is rather menial, routine, and boring, Vince relishes it. It is his first legitimate job, and he has been working there two years without taking a vacation because he enjoys it. He becomes enamored with the successful law office worker Kelly, but considers her out of his league, so he reads literary novels in the hope of impressing her. When he learns that she is having an affair with one of her bosses, however, Vince reconsiders his friend Beth as a possible partner. Although Beth has been surviving as a prostitute, she dreams of becoming a real estate agent. Both Beth and Vince, despite their longings for a modest home and family, seem fated to their predetermined lives. Beth repeatedly studies for her real estate exam, never passing it, but she has successfully quit drugs and loves being a mother to her son. Her inability to succeed in a legitimate job keeps her working on the streets, however. For Vince, it is his voting card that prompts him to think about changing his life by becoming a respectable citizen who participates in democracy. He becomes interested in the political debate, not just for president, but for lower offices as well. Critics have noted that Walter spends ample time on the political background of the story, arguing that by doing so, the author creates a plausible reason for Vince to change his life. “The way Walter uses the presidential election as a backdrop in this story adds a subtle finishing touch. Without the attention given to the election the reader would not be able to see
256
how Vince manages to overcome his criminal ways” (Plucker). Despite his yearning to make good on his debt to the mob and live a clean life, however, Vince seems unable to break the cycle into which he was born. The theme of fate is related to the theme of trying to change one’s position in life. And the ultimate fate is that of death. Significantly, Vince obsesses about death at the book’s beginning by scanning his memories of people he has known who are now deceased. Vince, knowing he cannot avoid the ultimate end, ponders whether he can at least change his days on Earth. Fate also deals harshly with several secondary characters in Citizen Vince. For example, the crooked New York cop Donnie Charles was once a good police officer, but when his only daughter is stricken with a heart defect, he cannot afford the medical bills and so he becomes corrupt in efforts to pay. The reader is initially led to dislike Donnie, but this revelation makes readers empathize with him a bit more. Walter creates other sympathetic villains in the book as well, including crime boss Johnny Boy whose hateful temperament was inspired by the tragic death of his own daughter in a car accident. Several critics have lauded Walter’s ability to invent characters whose personalities appear to be genuinely molded by their environments and circumstances.
W Style Written in the third person unlimited, present tense, Citizen Vince has an immediate feel reminiscent of noir detective novels. This is compounded by the gritty, streetsavvy dialogue of the novel’s characters. Walter’s narrative, especially at the beginning of the book, tends to the telegraphic and reportorial, a style befitting his journalism background. Several characters are described in asides reminiscent of detective dime novels of the 1930s, but the style is still distinctly modern in its setting and dialogue.
W Critical Reception Citizen Vince has been praised by reviewers for its sympathetic, complex characters and lively, action-filled plot. Even critics who found flaws in Walter’s novel felt that it was redeemed by several strong points. One reviewer noted that although the prose suffers from “indulgent free verse” the author “manages to pull it off with zippy dialog and a likable, if extremely flawed, main character” (Perkins). Another critic felt the novel lacked literary depth, describing the contents as “empty calories,” but went on to say that “it’s twisty, it’s surprisingly light, and it goes down real easy” (Geier). Several critics particularly enjoyed the main character, who, though a flawed criminal, is also an engaging protagonist with many admirable traits. Many reviewers TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Citizen Vince
noted that Vince is intelligent and he expresses genuine sympathy for others in his life. “Walter has created what may be the most charming small-time hood since Elmore Leonard’s Stick” wrote Elmer DeWitt, while Marianne Fitzgerald added: “What makes Walter’s third novel . . . so enjoyable is Vince, a flawed but sympathetic character trying to find redemption. Not only is Vince engaging, but so are many of the other secondary characters, observed some reviewers: “[A] . . . great aspect of this book is that while each character has an internal battle to pursue, there are still other intriguing plot occurrences” (Plucker). This critic then went on to write: “There is enough action in this book to hold a reader with an extremely short attention span, yet at the same time enough internal reflection to help each character solve their dilemma.” A Kirkus Reviews contributor concluded that Citizen Vince is “a story full of wonderful small surprises—among them Vince’s way of finally achieving citizenhood. Dispassionate and compassionate by turns, and always engrossing.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Review of Citizen Vince, by Jess Walter. Kirkus Reviews 72.17 (1 Sept. 2004): 836. Print. DeWitt, Elmer. “5 Mystery Writers Worth Investigating.” Time 167.26 (26 June 2006): 71. Print. Fitzgerald, Marianne. Rev. of Citizen Vince, by Jess Walter. Library Journal 130.5 (15 Mar. 2005): 76. Print. Geier, Thom. Rev. of Citizen Vince, by Jess Walter. Entertainment Weekly (29 Apr. 2005): 155. Print. Perkins, Christine. “The Financial Lives of the Poets.” Library Journal. 134.15 (15 Sept. 2009): 54. Print. Plucker, Carrie. “Engaging ‘Citizen Vince’ Is Worth a Read.” America’s Intelligence Wire 10 Nov. 2005. Web. 1 Aug. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Sennet, Frank. Rev. of Citizen Vince, by Jess Walter. Booklist 101.6 (15 Nov. 2004): 566. Print. A positive assessment of Citizen Vince in which the critic asserts that the author’s skillful use of dialogue and characterization makes the rather unlikely plot work.
Open Web Sources
The Fact Index, at www.fact-index.com, includes a page titled “U.S. Presidential Election 1980” that provides election results and discussion of party primaries and the general election. The Jess Walter Home Page, at www.jesswalter.com, includes a brief biography, list of the author’s books, and book signing schedule. The U.S. Marshals Service Witness Security Program, found at www.usmarshals.gov/witsec, explains briefly the purpose of this program and its history. For Further Reading
Bazell, Josh. Beat the Reaper. New York: Little, Brown, 2009. Print. Pietro Brwna has been a criminal since he was fourteen and killed the man who murdered his grandparents. Recruited by the mob, he works as a hit man until entering the Witness Protection Program. Trying to turn his life around, he becomes a doctor, but a chance acquaintance with a mobster brings his past rushing back. Egan, Timothy. Breaking Blue. New York: Knopf, 1992. Print. Based on research about the true murder of a man in Spokane, Washington, during the Great Depression, this novel combines crime fiction with the experience of a journalist (Egan was Seattle bureau chief of the New York Times) who reopens the case in the present day. Leonard, Elmore. Stick. New York: Arbor House, 1983. Print. The hero of this crime novel, Ernest “Stick” Stickley, has served jail time, but he now wants to set his life straight. His plan to put his life back together in Miami is thwarted when he becomes the victim of a crime. When he realizes that getting revenge could also prove financially profitable, Stick goes back to his old criminal ways. Pileggi, Nicholas. Wiseguy. New York: Simon and Schuster, 1985. Print. Gangster Henry Hill turns against the mob to testify and help convict members of the Luchese family. Written by an experienced crime reporter. Russo, Richard. Empire Falls. New York: Knopf, 2001. Print. Walter’s writing style has been compared to that of Russo, who here writes about a likable loser who becomes the hapless target of the police and a wealthy family in a economically depressed Maine town. Kevin Hile
Gale Resources
“Jess Walter.” Contemporary Authors New Revision Series. Vol. 163. Detroit: Gale, 2008. 396-99. Print.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
257
The City & the City By China Miéville
W Introduction China Miéville’s The City & the City is often classified as a work of fantasy fiction, specifically of the subgenre called the New Weird. However, elements of outright supernatural influence are rare to nonexistent. Rather, the work focuses on human psychology and the potential power of the human mind as the mechanic behind the strange state of affairs in The City & the City. The two cities referred to in the title are located in Eastern Europe and are named Beszel and Ul Qoma, respectively. Although both cities occupy the same geographic space, they are separated more by culture, perception, and human psychology than anything else. The plot follows the actions of Inspector Tyador Borlú as he investigates the brutal murder of a young woman. His investigations eventually lead him from his native city of Beszel to its counterpart, Ul Qoma, and he eventually uncovers intimations that there may be yet a third city hiding between the other two. The book was nominated for a Nebula Award and a Hugo award in the Best Novel category, and won both the BSFA Award for Best Novel and the Arthur C. Clarke Award.
W Literary and Historical Context
The City & the City, while a work of new weird fantasy fiction, owes a great deal to the tradition of detective novels and police procedurals. As Denise Hamilton of the Los Angeles Times describes it, “Miéville mines the tropes of detective fiction—the murder scene, the coroner’s autopsy, the witnesses who saw nothing.” The City & the City takes those tropes, builds upon them and fuses them
with other diverse elements to produce the narrative of the story. Adding to the mystery that serves as the foundation of the novel as a police procedural, Miéville creates other mysteries of a more esoteric nature, questions which explore the laws of reality as they apply to the “plural” nature of his created city. The protagonist of the book, Inspector Borlú, represents one of the classic detective archetypes, the veteran gumshoe. Other archetypes are used to create characters like Quissim Dhatt, a native of Ul Qoma and example of the “badcop” character who physically shakes down the perps to get the information he wants, or Lizbyet Corwi, the young beat officer with a finger on the pulse of the city around her. With its concept of Breach (a mysterious force that acts to keep the borders between the two cities and their peoples and culture intact), The City & the City also brings to mind elements of dystopic novels such as 1984. Likewise, parallels can also be made with “wartime Sarajevo or Cold War Berlin” (Hamilton). In many ways, the cities themselves, with their distinct cultures and styles, are characters in their own right, just as Inspector Borlú or Lizbyet Corwi are characters in the novel.
W Themes The “crosshatching”—defined by authors John Clute and John Grant in The Encyclopedia of Fantasy as “two or more worlds [that] may simultaneously inhabit the same territory”—of Beszel and Ul Qoma in The City & the City provides a solid structure for the examination of a number of the book’s central themes. Miéville is, in fact, known for writing which melds theme and structure, so much so that one “cannot help but be impressed by the fact that the central concept of the book is . . . a natural continuation of the themes” (McCalmont). The separation of the cities is accomplished, in part, by the psychological conditioning of the inhabitants to
258 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The City & the City
MAJOR CHARACTERS TYADOR BORLÚ is an Inspector with the Beszel Extreme Crime Squad. Borlú is a veteran detective with a penchant for travel and extensive experience. He is a citizen of the city of Beszel. The protagonist of the novel, Borlú is drawn into events by the mysterious murder of a young woman. LIZBYET CORWI is a young beat officer. Borlú befriends Corwi early on in the book, and she quickly becomes his assistant. Borlú values Corwi because she has the ability to talk intimately with younger people of Beszel with whom Borlú does not easily interact, due to the generation gap that exists between them. QUISSIM DHATT is a senior detective in Ul Qoma, Beszel’s “sister city.” Borlú joins up with Dhatt when Borlú's investigations lead him to Ul Qoma. Dhatt can be seen as the “badcop” to Borlú’s “gudcop.” Dhatt swears constantly, beats what he needs to know out of suspects and generally embodies the archetype of the hard-boiled detective.
W Style
The City & the City features a pair of twin European cities. Ul Qoma is a beautiful, vibrant city, while Beszel is a rusting urban graveyard like the one in this picture. ª Pablo Corral Vega/Corbis
“unsee” anything relating to the “other city.” This brings up themes of perception and the question of how to define boundaries, as well as a comment on the power of the human mind (a theme that is echoed in Inspector Borlú’s murder investigation). Themes of cultural identity also dovetail into the structure, all the more so because the two cultures in conflict literally occupy the same space. Beszel and Ul Qoma were once enemies, and are still rivals, for every person in each city occupies the same physical space. Each city nevertheless maintains a distinct culture and the separation of the cities works to preserve that culture. Miéville’s use of neologisms reinforces this. As Jonathan McCalmont puts it, “The obsession with the layering complexity and ultimate arbitrariness of language feeds the idea that culture is not something that is born of essential properties but of habit, custom and will. . . . The cities of Beszel and Ul Quoma are manifestations of the ultimately arbitrary and essence-free nature of human culture: two cultures, one shared space.”
The City & the City is a departure from Miéville’s customary style. Hamilton, who describes Miéville’s earlier works (particularly Perdido Street Station, The Scar and Iron Council) as “baroque, dense and lyrical,” observes that “where earlier books were drunk on language, detail, color and character, [The City & the City] is gray, chilly and stripped down.” This departure in style reflects a noir aesthetic, and calls to mind the gritty black-and-white feel of such noir film masterpieces as The Maltese Falcon. The noir format does not, however, completely define the style of the novel. More than anything else, The City & the City is a work of the new weird. It pushes the literary boundaries of the fantasy genre and blends inspirations, tropes and literary devices from a number of sources to produce the overall narrative. The noir format, and its attendant archetypes provide a baseline structure for plot and character, from which Miéville departs and refines his novel. The noir archetypes are particularly evident in the characters, from the veteran detective Inspector Borlú to the “badcop” Senior Detective Dhatt. The damsel in distress, however, is already dead—a victim of plot. Her death is the inciting incident that sets the narrative in motion, a narrative that contains numerous twists and dangers befitting any example of the noir detective novel or police procedural. This narrative is thus familiar and yet different. The thread of “familiar yet different” in The City & the City is also evident in Miéville’s use of neologisms.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
259
The City & the City
ABOUT THE AUTHOR China Miéville is an award-winning English fantasist whose work is often considered part of the New Weird movement in speculative fiction. His work often blends a variety of elements or bridges speculative fiction with other fiction genres, such as the sea quest (The Scar), American Western (Iron Council), or detective noir (The City & the City). Miéville is also well known for his work in literary theory and his left-wing political thought, having published both essays and books on those topics. These impulses manifest themselves in many of Miéville’s works, including Iron Council, considered by many critics to be Miéville’s most overtly political novel to date. As Miéville explains in an interview in the Believer, however, his novels, while they may express his political interests, are not vehicles for his politics, but expressions of his passionate love for “monsters and the weird and horror stories and strange situations and surrealism.”
The new words he has created help explain unfamiliar concepts and give us an additional insight into the culture(s) of the novel. Words such as “unsee” (72), “unsmell” (66) and “topolganger” (144) take familiar roots and combine them to express unfamiliar concepts expressed in the book.
“The City & the City is, in many ways, an extraordinary piece of writing. But it is not the novel it should have been. It is competent where it should have been challenging, abstract where it should have been concrete and timid where it should have been bold.” McCalmont later expresses the belief that the book, while “not a bad novel,” was not deserving of the BSFA, Arthur C. Clarke, and Hugo awards that it won. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Clute, John, and John Grant. The Encyclopedia of Fantasy. New York: Macmillan, 1999. Print. Hamilton, Denise. Rev. of The City & the City, by China Miéville. Los Angeles Times 25 May 2009. Web. 1 August 2010. McCalmont, Jonathan. “The City & the City.” Rev. of The City & the City, by China Miéville. Zone-SF.com. Web. 1 August 2010. Miéville, China. “China Miéville [Science Fiction Author].” Interview by Lou Anders. Believer Apr. 2005. Print. ———The City & the City. New York: Del Rey, 2010. Print. Moorcock, Michael. “The Spaces in Between.” Rev. of The City & the City, by China Miéville. Guardian [London] 30 May 2009. Web. 1 Aug. 2010.
W Critical Reception
Additional Resources
The City & the City garnered postive responses from readers and critics overall. In addition to winning an Arthur C. Clarke Award, a Hugo Award for Best Novel and a British Science Fiction Association (BSFA) Award, as well as nominations for a number of other awards, The City & the City was lauded by many reviewers. A veteran writer of science fiction and fantasy, Michael Moorcock reviewed the book for the Guardian, saying “As in no previous novel, the author celebrates and enhances the genre he loves and has never rejected. On many levels this novel is a testament to his admirable integrity. Keeping his grip firmly on an idea which would quickly slip from the hands of a less skilled writer, Miéville again proves himself as intelligent as he is original.” Reservations about the novel were expressed by some critics, albeit most often as part of a “mixed review” response or as a single reservation about the work as a whole. Denise Hamilton noted that “Borlu seemed an archetype more than a fleshed-out character,” but concluded that “that’s OK,” as the cities are the real protagonists of the book. One critic, Jonathan McCalmont, of Zone-SF.com, went further. In his view, the novel was disappointing due to failed potential, more than anything else. He writes,
“Divided City of Mental Maps: A Political Allegory Masquerading as a Straightforward Crime Novel Delivers a Thrilling Narrative on ‘Selective Vision’” Times [London] 16 May 2009: 11. Academic OneFile. Web. 1 Aug. 2010. Feature article from the Times of London discussing The City & the City as political allegory.
260
Criticism and Reviews
Hollands, Neil. “Miéville, China. The City & the City.” Library Journal 134.5 (2009): 101. General OneFile. Web. 1 Aug. 2010. Review of The City & the City, calling it an “existentialist thought piece.” McKie, Andrew. “Unseeing Is Believing.” Spectator 20 June 2009: 32. General OneFile. Web. 1 Aug. 2010. Review of The City & the City, featuring some discussion of both allusions and comparative authors. Moyer, Jessica. “The City & the City.” Booklist 105.15 (1 Apr. 2009): 23. General OneFile. Web. 1 Aug. 2010. Review of The City & the City, considering the work as a detective novel. Nicoll, James Davis. “PW Talks with China Miéville: Investigating the Strange: In The City & the City (Reviews, Apr. 13), British Fantasy Author Miéville Gives an Old-Fashioned Police Procedural a TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The City & the City
Makeover.” Publishers Weekly 256.16 (2009): 36. General OneFile. Web. 1 Aug. 2010. Rev. of The City & the City, featuring an interview with China Miéville. Wolfe, Gary K. “Gary K. Wolfe Reviews China Miéville.” Rev. of The City & the City, by China Miéville. LocusMag.com 3 June 2009. Web. 1 Aug. 2010. Review of The City & the City, including a discussion of the idea of crosshatching, where two similar worlds simultaneously occupy the same space. Gale Resources
“China Miéville.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2010.
found here: http://www.isfdb.org/cgi-bin/ea.cgi China_Miéville For Further Reading
D’Ammassa, Don. Encyclopedia of Fantasy and Horror. New York, Facts on File, 2006. Print. General reference encyclopedia for fantasy and horror fiction; includes a biographical entry on China Miéville. Lyall, Sarah. “Making Squid the Meat of a Story.” Rev. of Kraken, by China Miéville. New York Times 23 July 2010. Web. 1 Aug. 2010. Provides a New York Times profile of China Miéville.
“China Miéville (1972-)”. Contemporary Literary Criticism. Ed. Jeffrey W. Hunter. Vol. 235. Detroit: CengageGale,2007.187-223. Literature Criticism Online. 22 July 2010.
Miéville, China. Between Equal Rights: A Marxist Theory of International Law. Leiden: Brill Academic Publishers, 2005. Print. Miéville’s book on political theory and international law was adapted from his PhD thesis.
Open Web Sources
———. King Rat. London: Macmillan, 1998. Print. Miéville’s first novel, nominated for an International Horror Guild Award and a Bram Stoker Award.
China Miéville’s personal website and blog, “rejectamentalist manifesto,” is located at http://chinamieville.net/. It features thoughts expressed by the author, as well as numerous quotations, author opinions, and vintage photographs. The Internet Speculative Fiction Database at http:// www.isfdb.org/ includes an entry on China Miéville, as well as coverage of speculative fiction authors of all subgenres. A summary bibliography (including links to several interviews) of China Miéville’s work can be
VanderMeer, Ann, and Jeff VanderMeer, eds. The New Weird. San Francisco: Tachyon Publications, 2008. Print. A collection of new weird short fiction and essays, includes an examination of the new weird as a genre, as well as fiction by China Miéville.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Powder Thompson
261
City of Thieves By David Benioff
W Introduction
W Literary and Historical
In City of Thieves (2009), David Benioff creates a fictional protagonist, Lev Beniov, an average seventeen-year-old, and his likable soldier-sidekick, Kolya, within the setting of the brutal and horrific Siege of Leningrad. The action opens with Lev, a member of the Kirov Fifth-Floor Brigade, sitting on the rooftop of his building on New Year’s Eve. He is orphaned by the disappearance of his Jewish poet-father at the hands of the NKVD (Russian Secret Police) and his mother and sister, who have fled the city, as the nine-hundred-day Nazi siege begins. The daily fight for survival as bombs fall and food grows scarce makes Lev and his friends careless. One night Lev reluctantly saves a female friend when they are pursued by the Secret Police but ends up arrested. His arrest occurs when the attrition of the siege forces Lev and his friends to loot the dead body of a German paratrooper. He is caught by the NKVD and thrown into the Crosses, an infamous Soviet prison. There he meets Kolya, a charismatic soldier, who has been arrested on charges of desertion. Execution is imminent until a Soviet colonel offers them a chance to win their freedom and ration cards by undertaking a suicide mission. Lev and Kolya agree to find a dozen eggs required to make a wedding cake for the colonel’s daughter, who is to be married in a week. The prospect of locating such a valuable commodity underscores the hardships that come with war—a seemingly simple task such as finding a chicken becomes near impossible. The two journey throughout the region, seeking food, subsistence, avoiding troops, gunfire, and avoiding other predators, including cannibals. Despite their surprising success at survival, and if ultimately finding the eggs, lives are lost.
In The 900 Days: The Siege of Leningrad, Harrison Evans Salisbury explains that Adolf Hitler sought to starve the city into submission. In The Legacy of the Siege of Leningrad, 1941–1995, Lisa A. Kirschenbaum discusses incidents of starvation that created predators of corpses, as well as murderers of citizens, for the purpose of feeding on human flesh in a twisted bid for survival. In the face of the overwhelming oppression of the Nazi assault, Leningrad citizens continued to carry on, despite facing additional threats from within by the Soviet communist government. Benioff fictionalizes the unbelievable adventures of Lev and Kolya but relies on history for its context. On the one hand, Hitler’s offensive was merciless and unrelenting, from falling bombs to Nazi death squads. On the other, the harsh penalties for exceeding rations, such as stealing (even from the enemy), included death by firing squad. Though nearly half of the three million inhabitants perished, the city never yielded. The corruption of Communist Party members and military high command on both sides during the siege resulted in additional losses among the lesser ranks and citizens. Hitler’s strategy of cutting supply lines to Leningrad amplified the Soviet command’s hoarding of food and supplies in general. Both the Nazi and Communist elite ensured themselves the luxury of fine cuisine at the expense of people like Lev and Kolya. In addition to depicting the mutually corrupt high command of the Nazi and Soviet armies, Benioff describes instances of cannibalism, which actually occurred. Scholars such as Kirschenbaum have documented these horrific conditions and events from this period.
Context
262 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
City of Thieves
W Themes A main theme within City of Thieves concerns the experience of coming of age under extreme circumstances. Lev’s father is a victim of the communist purge due to his controversial views. Despite his legacy as a poet, he vanishes without a trace, leaving Lev fatherless and naive. At seventeen, the puny, boyish Lev is still at the mercy of biological forces typical of all young men: he wants to lose his virginity. By contrast, Kolya is a natural romantic with considerable experience. He resolves to facilitate Lev’s right of passage into manhood, oftentimes in the most hopeless and darkly humorous of situations. The indomitable resilience of the human spirit in the face of war and starvation serves as another theme within this novel. Lev and his original companions, Vera and Oleg, dream of better times they have known and those they hope to know, in efforts to overcome the horrors and deprivation of war. They are hungry and cold but still driven by youthful urges. Moments after they loot the dead German paratrooper’s body, the Soviet police give chase. Vera, the object of Lev’s daydreams, trips and falls behind as Lev makes his escape. He thinks better of his own salvation, however, and helps Vera over the fence, only to be taken into custody. Vera, to his disappointment, never looks back. Finally, Benioff’s novel suggests that extreme and unthinkable circumstances of war reveal the worst and best of humanity. Cannibalism stands on one end, and loyalty and self-sacrifice stand on the other. Virtual strangers, Lev and Kolya become fast friends out of mutual recognition of their individual value as men. Their devotion to one another provides their greatest chance at surviving the impossible situation in which they find themselves. As they reveal their individual secrets, they unite against the dark side of the human condition that war provokes.
W Style City of Thieves is a first-person novel narrated by Lev Beniov. However, the first chapter, which serves as a kind of preface, is a first-person narration by David Benioff, in which the author explains the main source for the story that is to follow. Typical of the bildungsroman, a genre about the psychological and moral growth of the protagonist to adulthood, the main character in this novel seeks his right of passage during the great siege of Leningrad. Benioff’s prose is straightforward and pragmatic in contrast to the horrifying events he describes. The novel is plot-driven by the grisly Nazi siege of Leningrad, which gives the tone and setting of Lev and Kolya’s absurd adventure qualities of a black comedy. In terms of historical accuracy, though, Benioff displays
MAJOR CHARACTERS MAJOR ABENDROTH, the Nazi commandant of a prison camp, becomes a target for Lev and Kolya because it is rumored he has eggs. Lev beats him at chess in exchange for the eggs. OLEG “GRISHA” ANTOKOLSKY is one of Lev’s friends who escapes arrest the night they loot the body of the dead German paratrooper. LEV BENIOV, the seventeen-year-old protagonist, is offered freedom from prison if he can find a dozen eggs needed to make a wedding cake for a Soviet colonel’s daughter. GALINA is one of the young women forced to serve the sexual needs of the Nazis in exchange for food and lodging outside Leningrad. SONYA IVANOVNA has an intimate relationship with Kolya and gives refuge to him and Lev. KORSAKOV is the leader of the Soviet partisans whose group Lev and Kolya infiltrate. VIKA, the crack-sniper who works for Korsakov, is also a member of the NKVD. Lev falls in love with her. NIKOLAI ALEXANDROVICH VLASOV, called Kolya, is the deserter Lev meets in the Crosses prison. ZOYA, a fourteen-year-old forced to join Galina and Nina as a prostitute for the Einsatzgruppen, the Nazi death squads.
a serious grasp of this chapter in the Soviet resistance to German invasion, as he presents an unusual cast of characters at odds and in concert with a traditional quest motif. Lev and Kolya become unlikely quixotic heroes in search of a chicken who can lay eggs and thus save them from execution, combining elements of folk tale with twentieth-century battle intrigue. Reminiscent of coming-of-age stories, City of Thieves relies on overcoming obstacles whose singular reward is living to tell the tale.
W Critical Reception City of Thieves was generally well received. Already regarded as a successful screenwriter for his first novel’s adaptation to film (25th Hour), Benioff enjoyed praise from many critics for his City of Thieves. In her review in the Library Journal, Barbara Conaty remarked that Benioff’s portrayal of starving Leningrad is done with aching realism. She recommended the novel to readers of all ages. Similarly, Booklist critic Ben Segedin wrote in his young-adult review that the “high-spirited adventure” of the novel’s seventeen-year-old protagonist “will thrill mature readers.” In his audio review on All Things
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
263
City of Thieves
ABOUT THE AUTHOR David Benioff was born in 1970 in New York. He earned a BA at Dartmouth College in 1992, and an MA at Trinity College, Dublin, Ireland. Before achieving success as a screenwriter, author, and producer, Benioff earned his living variously as a bouncer, disc jockey, educator, and wrestling coach.
Considered, Alan Cheuse found City of Thieves “psychologically satisfying and historically authentic,” despite its “mythic proportions.” Writing in Entertainment Weekly, Jennifer Reese applauded City of Thieves as a “funny, sad, and thrilling novel.” However, the book also encountered a fair share of detractors. In a somewhat negative review in the Los Angeles Times, Donna Rifkind wrote that the novel would fail to strike an emotional chord with readers, and she cited specifically the “barrier between its characters’ emotions and the reader’s.” Jane Ridley was even less kind in her article in the Spectator. She concluded, “Benioff’s novel is under-researched and lacking in psychological insight.” But Gerald Jacobs, casting a vote with other positive reviews, asserted that City of Thieves
constituted a successful blend of historical fact and absurd adventure, told with the “economy and immediacy of Benioff’s style.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Benioff, David. City of Thieves. New York: Plume, 2009. Print. Cheuse, Alan. “Books to Read over the Long Weekend.” Rev. of City of Thieves, by David Benioff. All Things Considered. npr.org. National Public Radio, 4 July 2008. Radio. Conaty, Barbara. “Benioff, David. City of Thieves.” Rev. of City of Thieves, by David Benioff. Library Journal 133.6 (2008): 72. Print. Jacobs, Gerald. “Danger and Friendship in Wartime Leningrad: City of Thieves by David Benioff.” Rev. of City of Thieves, by David Benioff. Sunday Telegraph [London] 27 July 2008. Print. Kirschenbaum, Lisa A. The Legacy of the Siege of Leningrad, 1941–1995. New York: Cambridge UP, 2009. Print. Reese, Jennifer. “City of Thieves.” Rev. of City of Thieves, by David Benioff. ew.com. Entertainment Weekly 20 May 2008. Web. 2 Sept. 2010.
City of Thieves is set at the time of the Nazi invasion of Leningrad, Russia, during World War II. ª Hulton-Deutsch Collection/Corbis
264
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
City of Thieves
Ridley, Jane. “Truth Is Stranger than Fiction.” Rev. of City of Thieves, by David Benioff. Spectator.co.uk. Spectator 28 June 2008. Web. 24 Sept. 2010. Rifkind, Donna. “Siege Mentality.” Rev. of City of Thieves, by David Benioff. latimes.com. Los Angeles Times 11 May 2008. Web. 24 Sept. 2010. Salisbury, Harrison Evans. The 900 Days: The Siege of Leningrad. New York: De Capo Press 2003. Print. Segedin, Ben. “City of Thieves.” Rev. of City of Thieves, by David Benioff. Booklist 104.16 (2008): 31. Print. Additional Resources
Mergendahl, Peter. “Best Thriller.” Rev. of City of Thieves, by David Benioff. Rocky Mountain News 6 Dec. 2008. Print. Sums the novel up by declaring it a “thrilling adventure that’s also a cinematic romp of friendship, love and memory.” Gale Resources
“David Benioff.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2010. Literature Resource Center. Web. 23 Sept. 2010. http://go.galegroup.com/ps/i.do? &id=GALE%7CH1000186074&v=2.1&u =itsbtrial&it=r&p=LitRC&sw=w
Criticism and Reviews
For Further Reading
“City of Thieves.” Rev. of City of Thieves, by David Benioff. New Yorker 84.21 (2008): 87. Web. 24 Sept. 2010. Echoes the critics who found City of Thieves an entertaining read, though too sentimental and lacking in “emotional engagement” of the reader.
Butler, Rupert. Stalin’s Secret War: The NKVD on the Eastern Front. Barnsley: Pen and Sword, 2010. Print. Traces the use of terror as a political force from the Okhrana of czarist Russia to the KGB of the Soviet Union.
House, Christian. “He’s Ready for His Close-Up.” independent.co.uk. Independent 6 July 2008. Web. 24 Sept 2010. Interview with Benioff noting his keen attention to history, evident in “intriguing details” surely “moulded by extensive research.”
Jones, Michael. Leningrad: State of Siege. New York: Basic Books, 2008. Print. Military historian’s account of the siege drawn from eyewitness accounts, diaries, and discovery of suppressed incidents, such as cannibalism.
Fishman, Boris. “Wartime Rations.” Rev. of City of Thieves, by David Benioff. nytimes.com. New York Times 6 July 2008. Web. 24 Sept. 2010. Writes a lively, affectionate take on Benioff as an enviable but talented writer who should not be criticized.
Lasker, Emanuel. Lasker’s Manual of Chess. Milford: Russell Enterprises, 2009. Print. General strategies for chess by acclaimed chess master who held the Second World Class Champion title from 1894 to 1921.
Kakutani, Michiko. “City of Thieves: Books, Nonfiction.” Rev. of City of Thieves, by David Benioff. www. military.com/entertainment/books/book-reviews/bookreview-city-of-thieves. New York Times 8 July 2008. Web. 24 Sept. 2010. Suggests that “Benioff’s book lets its characters inhabit the human condition in all of its sometimes compromised versatility.” McDowell, Lesley. “City of Thieves.” Rev. of City of Thieves, by David Benioff. independent.co.uk. Independent 5 July 2009. Web. 24 Sept. 2010. Singles out the character of Kolya as the key to the novel’s success in overcoming the absurdity of the premise; declaring him a “mesmerising enough character, witty and irreverent, to carry the tale.”
Magellas, James. All the Way to Berlin: A Paratrooper at War in Europe. New York: Presidio Press, 2004. Print. World War II lieutenant’s memoirs of battle experiences after the Pearl Harbor attack, including his part in the bloody Operation Market Garden, where Allied casualties exceeded those of the Normandy invasion. Wettlin, Margaret. Fifty Russian Winters: An American Woman’s Life in the Soviet Union. New York: Wiley, 1994. Print. Intimate account of a Philadelphia student who remains in Soviet Union after marrying a theater director. Includes her challenges as an idealistic member of the KGB and firsthand experiences with hardship. Doris Plantus-Runey
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
265
Clara Callan By Richard B. Wright
W Introduction
W Literary and Historical
In Richard B. Wright’s epistolary novel Clara Callan (2003), the eponymous protagonist lives in Whitfield, Ontario, a small village of six hundred people, where gossiping about one’s neighbors is a way of life. On the surface, Clara’s life seems empty and lonely, but Clara actually has a rich life, filled with secrets, passion, and tragedy. Clara’s younger sister, Nora, flees small-town life for New York City, where she finds success as an actress. The novel begins in 1934 and covers some four years of Clara’s life. Clara’s story begins six months after the funeral of her father. With Nora’s departure for New York, Clara is alone in the large house. She has no close friends and spends her time reading and playing the piano. One Sunday, she suddenly realizes that she no longer believes in God. This loss of faith sets her even more apart from her neighbors, who are accustomed to seeing one another at church each week. Clara’s absence is noted. One day a drifter attacks Clara as she walks alone. This act consumes Clara’s life for the next two years; she searches for this man, traveling to places where she thinks she might find him. Nora finds success in New York. She is chosen for some small stage roles, but her biggest success is on a radio soap opera that is broadcast across the United States and Canada. Nora’s life is exciting, and she assumes that Clara’s life back in Whitfield is quiet, even empty. However, Clara has met a married man, with whom she has an affair. The whole village knows about Clara’s affair, which further sets her apart from her neighbors. There are no secrets in a small village when people listen in on telephone calls and watch their neighbors from behind curtains.
Clara Callan is set in the mid-1930s the time of the Great Depression and high unemployment. War in Spain and Adolf Hitler’s rise in Germany generated fear of Nazis and fascism in North America. The possibility of another world war in Europe worried people in Canada and in the United States. For a brief time, the 1936 Olympics in Germany were mistakenly interpreted as a sign that Germany would not wage war, either against its own Jewish citizens or those of neighboring countries. The love affair of England’s Edward VIII was big news, as was his subsequent abdication in 1936 and marriage to the American divorcée Wallis Simpson. Their life before abdication and after a tabloid subject across Canada during the mid-1930s. Most transportation across Canada was limited to automobile and train, and travel to Europe was by ocean liner. The Hindenburg, which was the first transcontinental airship, exploded at Lakehurst, New Jersey, in 1937. After this disaster, it was widely believed that transatlantic air travel would never be resumed. The Dionne quintuplets were born in Canada in 1934 and were displayed in a glass enclosure for many years; people paid an admission charge to view them at Quintland. In 1936 readers were enthralled with a new novel, Gone with the Wind, and radio soap operas kept listeners close to their radios; Hollywood movies, which allowed audience members to forget about the Depression for a couple hours, were very popular. During the 1930s, many women were limited to employment as teachers, secretaries, or nurses, but some women challenged these old rules. In some locations, women formed Housewives’ Leagues to picket companies that were guilty of unfair employment practices toward women. There was a general fear that women were taking jobs from men; as a result, by 1932, women who married were routinely fired from public schools,
Context
266 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Clara Callan
MAJOR CHARACTERS CHARLIE is the drifter who rapes Clara. CLARA CALLAN is a thirty-one-year-old single woman when the novel opens. She is a schoolteacher with a vivid imagination and a highly creative mind. She is likable, inviting, and warm but also secretive. Her sexual awakening further isolates her from her rigid and sexually repressed neighbors, who also condemn Clara for her lack of religious observance. NORA CALLAN is Clara’s twenty-nine-year-old sister, an impulsive and generous woman who goes to New York to pursue an acting career. Although her relationships with men are not always successful, Nora is never deeply affected by their failure. EVELYN DOWLING is a writer, who works with Nora. She is sophisticated and provides Nora with friendship and emotional support. She is also a friend to Clara, when she needs help. LEWIS MILLS is a journalist, with whom Nora has an affair. He takes Clara and Nora to Italy on a vacation, where he behaves as the stereotypical ugly American, offending almost everyone he meets. FRANK QUINLAN is a married man, with whom Clara has an affair. Frank has many affairs and is easily bored with women.
People walk in front of the New York Stock Exchange in the 1930s. In Clara Callan, Nora moves to New York City to become an actress. ª The Print Collector/Alamy
public utilities, transportation systems, and nearly all other public or government jobs. Only unmarried women were permitted to work. Single women were also expected to be chaste, and unmarried women who became pregnant were not permitted to teach in schools.
W Themes Clara Cullen presents readers with an interesting dichotomy—Clara’s struggle to be the woman she wants to be and the woman she really is. This struggle is a major theme in the novel. Clara wants to be a poet, but she writes less than perfect poems. She plays the piano, but when her playing lacks perfection, she quits. Clara assumes that if she cannot achieve perfection, there is no point in continuing to try. She can read the poetry of great poets and listen to professional pianists on a recording. In this sense, her need for perfection
provides a life that is limiting and prevents her from enjoying creative expression and participation in these arts. Clara often ponders the nature of truth. She realizes on the trip to Italy that people rarely know the truth about people or events. Clara values truth but understands that absolute truth is elusive. She understands that just as she is keeping secrets from people, people are keeping secrets from her. The interior life is true, but very few people experience that level of truth and knowledge. Clara does not apply truth to history. Clara and her correspondents often mention historical events, but only in passing and without critical commentary. History occurs in the background and is not relevant to Clara. Her focus is on the individual and not on the greater community beyond her village. Clara possesses a rich imagination. After she is attacked, she becomes obsessed with her attacker and at one point even refers to him as her “errant knight” (188). For nearly two years, she looks for him in crowds. She imagines what his life is like and whether he has a family. Clara also imagines that he attacks other women. When she sees him at an amusement ride, she learns his first name, which makes her thoughts about his life more concrete. Clara is
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
267
Clara Callan
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Richard B. Wright was born in Midland, Ontario, Canada, on March 4, 1937. For much of his career, he taught English at Ridley College in St. Catharines, Ontario. His third novel, In the Middle of Life (2003), was awarded the Faber Memorial Prize for Fiction. Wright’s eighth novel, The Age of Longing, was nominated for both the Giller Prize and the Governor-General’s Literary Award. Clara Callan, Wright’s ninth novel, was awarded three prestigious Canadian literary awards and led his publisher to reissue Wright’s earlier novels and also guaranteed an audience for the novels that followed, including Adultery (2004), a novel about betrayal, and October (2007), which is set in World War II Quebec. In 2007 Wright received the Order of Canada in recognition of his contributions to Canadian literature.
ostracized in her community. She shocks her neighbors, who then shun her. The conventional women of her small town lack imagination and are outraged by Clara’s view of the world.
W Style Clara Callan is an epistolary novel, that is, primarily composed of the letters that Clara exchanges with her sister, Nora. Clara occasionally writes to other people as well, but the letters to Nora constitute the one constant in her life. Through the letters, readers learn about Nora’s life in New York, but Clara’s life is less open. The letters make clear that Clara is keeping secrets from nearly everyone. Clara also keeps a journal, the entries in which reveal what she really thinks and feels. Comparing Clara’s journal entries with her letters reveals how she masks her life private and proves that she is not the demure, boring woman that so many people judge her to be. The epistolary format and the journal entries show the difference between inner reality and social façade. The afterword explains what eventually happens to Clara. In this section, which takes place in 2000, Clara’s now elderly daughter reveals what happens to her mother. Clara’s journal reads like an interior monologue, providing Clara’s candid sense of her life. She describes the rape in graphic terms. Much of what she thinks and feels is expressed without self-consciousness. As a result, readers experience what Clara experiences
This photo shows the skyline of New York City in the 1930s. In Clara Callan, Nora finds success as a radio actress in New York City. Natalia Bratslavsky/Shutterstock.com
268
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Clara Callan
directly, without a sense of filter or analysis that would distance it.
W Critical Reception Wright received several important Canadian literary awards for his ninth novel, Clara Callan. In awarding Wright the Giller Prize, Robert Fulford, a member of the Giller Prize jury, noted that Wright’s novel is neither dramatic nor sensational, and yet, two months after reading the novel, he could not forget the characters (Bemrose). Clara Callan also won the Governor-General’s Literary Award and the Trillium Prize. Each of these three awards brings with it a financial award. Clara Callan was also the first choice of readers, who voted in the 2002 Pearson Canada Readers’ Choice Book Award. Reviews of Clara Callan were generally complimentary. In a review of Clara Callan for the Toronto Sun, Jane Van Der Voort called Clara a “true-to-life” fictional heroine, who is believable, someone “you can believe you once knew.” Fiction writer Paul Quarrington admitted at the onset of his review of Clara Callan that he was not “predisposed to like . . . Clara Callan.” In a review that appeared in the Globe and Mail, Quarrington confessed he does not like epistolary novels and that a male writer assuming a female heroine’s voice is risky. However, in reading the book, Quarrington found that he liked both the format and the characters. Quarrington stated that Wright did an “admirable job” in creating Clara, a character, who “seems a living, breathing human being.” While most reviews were positive, one review stood out for its negativity. The review of Clara Callan that appeared in Canadian Literature was particularly unfavorable. Writer Marta Dvorak pointed out that Wright “sets out to construct the chronicle of a society,” using the stories of two sisters, Clara and Nora. This intention allows Wright to focus on an important decade in “North American social evolution.” Dvorak argued that Wright falls short of his goal and that his weaving of history and fiction “is contrived yet obvious.” Dvorak also criticized Wright for his use of clichés, which “abound,” and for a narrative that is “simplistic and predictable.” Other complaints included redundancy, bad sentence structure, and language that is “wooden,” “stilted,” and “mechanical” (Dvorak). Lest it appear that Dvorak could find nothing to admire in a novel that so many others celebrated, she finished her review by noting that “certain meditative passages are remarkably fine,” as are “contemplative phrases or an arresting beauty.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Bemrose, John. “Hero of the Humdrum.” Rev. of Clara Callan, by Richard B. Wright. Maclean’s, 3 Dec. 2001: 64. Print.
Dvorak, Marta. “An Epistolary Tandem.” Rev. of Clara Callan, by Richard B. Wright. Canadian Literature 177 (2003): 193-94. Print. Quarrington, Paul. “Can’t Help Loving That Gal.” Rev. of Clara Callan, by Richard B. Wright. Globe and Mail, 1 Sept. 2001: D2. Print. Van Der Voort, Jane. “The Kind of Woman You Thought You Knew.” Rev. of Clara Callan, by Richard B. Wright. Toronto Sun, 17 Feb. 2002: S27. Print. Wright, Richard B. Clara Callan. Toronto: HarperCollins, 2001. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
D’Entremont, Joelle M. “Clara Callan.” Rev. of Clara Callan, by Richard B. Wright. cercles.com Cercles, n.d. Web. 26 July 2010. Real women’s experiences and rich character development reveal the loneliness and isolation of small village life. Dinka, Nicholas. “The Tender Trappings of Success.” quillandquire.com. Quill & Quire 1 Sept. 2004. Web. 26 July 2010. Author profile focuses on Wright’s literary career and discuses many of his novels. Jackson, Lorna. “Clara Callan.” Rev. of Clara Callan, by Richard B. Wright. quilllandquire.com. Quill & Quire Sept. 2001. Web. 26 July 2010. Suggests that Wright is a compassionate writer, whose characters are both good and dishonest and complex enough to be profound. Martin, Sandra. “The Wrighterly Stuff.” Rev. of Clara Callan, by Richard B. Wright. Globe and Mail, 1 Sept. 2001: D3. Print. Wonders if Clara Callan will finally provide Wright with the fame he deserves. Preston, Edwina. “Contrasts in the Early Radio Days.” Rev. of Clara Callan, by Richard B. Wright. Age, 24 Aug. 2002: 7. Print. Points out that Clara Callan is about a woman who struggles to escape 1930s clichés, while illustrating the traps that women faced in that decade. Simonds, Merilyn. “Every Letter a Revelation: A Master Storyteller’s Epistolary Novel Is a Many-Layered Marvel.” Rev. of Clara Callan, by Richard B. Wright. Ottawa Citizen, 2 Sept. 2001: C11. Print. Praises epistolary form that allows readers to experience a character’s life, as she experiences it. Gale Resources
Doyle, James. “Richard B(ruce) Wright.” Canadian Writers since 1960: First Series. Ed. William H. New. Detroit: Gale Research, 1986. Dictionary of Literary Biography Vol. 53. Literature Resource Center. Web. 25 July 2010. http://go.galegroup.com/ps/i.do? &id=GALE%7CH1200004626&v=2.1 &u=itsbtrial&it=r&p=LitRC&sw=w
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
269
Clara Callan
“Richard B. Wright.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Literature Resource Center. Web. 25 July 2010. http://go.galegroup.com/ps/i. do?&id=GALE%7CH1000108465&v=2.1&u =itsbtrial&it=r&p=LitRC&sw=w Open Web Sources
An interview with Wright, in which he discusses writing a new novel after the success and fame that came with Clara Callan, is available at http://www.cbc.ca/ arts/books/wright.html For Further Reading
Berton, Pierre. The Dionne Years: A Thirties Melodrama. New York: Norton, 1978. Print. A history of the Dionne quintuplets that attempts to provide a balanced look at the girls’ lives and the community that chose to put them on display. Brendon, Piers. The Dark Valley: A Panorama of the 1930s. London: Jonathan Cape, 2000. Print. Focuses on the political and economic changes that fueled fascism, Nazism, and communism and led to militaristic and totalitarian governments.
Toronto: UP of Toronto, 2009. Print. Uses primary documents—letters, memoirs, newspapers, and government records—to illustrate the difficulties that people faced in the Great Depression in Canada. Cox, Jim. The Great Radio Soap Operas. Jefferson: McFarland, 1999. Print. Presents a history of the radio soap operas that were popular from the 1930s to 1960. Kruger, Arnd, and W. J. Murray, eds. The Nazi Olympics: Sport, Politics, and Appeasement in the 1930s. Urbana: U of Illinois P, 2003. Print. Explores the political ramifications of the 1936 Olympics and includes essays about the games’ effect on the United States, Great Britain, France, Finland, Sweden, Norway, Denmark, and the Netherlands. Triece, Mary. On the Picket Line: Strategies of WorkingClass Women during the Depression. Urbana: U of Illinois P, 2007. Print. Examines the efforts of working-class women to challenge traditional ideology regarding the interplay of marriage, family, and work. Sheri Karmiol
Campbell, Lara A. Respectable Citizens: Gender, Family, and Unemployment in Ontario’s Great Depression.
270
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Clothes on Their Backs By Linda Grant
W Introduction The Clothes on Their Backs (2008) is a novel by the British writer and journalist Linda Grant. The story of Vivien Kovaks is narrated in flashback, from Vivien’s perspective in middle age. The only child of Jews who fled Hungary for London just before World War II, Vivien grows up in a stifling atmosphere of suppressed fear. As a teenager, she rebels by giving rein to her flamboyant fashion sense. Her ultimate rebellion, however, occurs when she seeks out her uncle, Sándor Kovacs, an infamous slumlord and convicted criminal whom she has seen only once and whom her father loathes so much that he changed the spelling of his last name. After meeting Sándor, Vivien agrees to help him write a memoir. In the process she learns her family’s history. Her gratitude for this opportunity, however, is tempered by her revulsion to Sándor’s evident brutality. It is only after he acts to defend her from hatred in the only way he knows—and dies as a result—that Vivien is able to gain an appreciation for him. In 2008 The Clothes on Their Backs was short-listed for the Man Booker Prize. It received the South Bank Show literature award in 2009.
W Literary and Historical Context
In the first chapter, and again near the end of the novel, Vivien’s narration takes place in the early twenty-first century, and she notes its terrorist attacks and scares, including an attack on the London Underground in 2005. Several decades of London’s history pass by, however, in Vivien’s flashback during the course of the novel. Her young adulthood is touched by the racist violence of the skinheads and the National Front, a Fascist political party that was most active in the 1970s.
She hands out leaflets for the Anti-Nazi League, an organization that was founded in 1977 to counter the rise of far-right groups in Britain. Terror played a role in Vivien’s immediate family history, but she knows little about it until she begins to help Sándor write his memoir. He tells her about the Hungarian village where he and her father were born, about the race laws that cost her grandfather his livelihood and drove Sándor to make pimping his profession, and, finally, about the labor unit in the Hungarian army in which he and her grandfather served during World War II. Jewish men were conscripted into the labor-service system to build railroads, dig trenches, clear rubble, and perform other heavy labor for the Hungarian—and, later, German—forces. Tens of thousands of Jewish men served in these labor units, and thousands died from malnutrition, disease, exposure, and physical abuse and torture. Sándor Kovacs’s character is based on Peter Rachman, a Polish refugee who became a landlord in the Notting Hill section of postwar London. Rachman was known for his ruthless exploitation of tenants, which led to the coining of the term Rachmanism to describe similar unscrupulous practices.
W Themes The Clothes on Their Backs revolves around themes of identity, belonging, appearances, and inner truths. In growing up while being cut off from the past and the present by her immigrant parents’ fearfulness, Vivien becomes impatient with her life as a “mouse person.” As a university student she strikes out into the world with a persona she has fashioned for herself from the previous generation’s designer castoffs, but this carapace can only protect her for so long. After she marries and her husband dies on their honeymoon, she is forced to return to the “arid,” “inert” life of her parents’ home.
271 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Clothes on Their Backs
MAJOR CHARACTERS SÁNDOR KOVACS is Vivien’s uncle. A survivor of the Hungarian army’s notorious labor service in World War II, Sándor fended for himself after his arrival in London by buying up cheap properties and chopping them up into miserable flats that he rented to West Indian immigrants. His reputation for brutality notwithstanding, Sándor is Vivien’s only link to her past and, of her three remaining relatives, the one to whom she feels closest. BERTA KOVAKS is Vivien’s mother and Ervin’s wife. She longs for Vivien to assimilate quietly into English life and deflects her questions about the family’s history. ERVIN KOVAKS is Vivien’s father and Sándor’s brother. Ervin is a fearful man who is particularly fearful of his crime-stained brother, whom he tries to shut out of his life. Ervin does not understand at all why Vivien wants to know about the family’s history. VIVIEN KOVAKS, the narrator and protagonist, searches for her identity as a young woman and begins to find it when she meets her father’s estranged brother, Sándor, soon after he has served time in prison for his activities as a slumlord. Repelled by Sándor’s evident brutality, Vivien is also drawn by his charisma and recognizes in him her own appetites for life and its pleasures. EUNICE is Sándor’s black girlfriend and the successful manager of a fashionable dress shop. Almost thirty years after Sándor’s death, Eunice still blames Vivien for spoiling the happy life that she and Sándor had together and for sending him to an early grave. CLAUDE, one of Sándor’s tenants, becomes Vivien’s lover after she starts helping her uncle write his memoir. Vivien feels a powerful physical attraction to Claude, but he has little to offer her emotionally. He completely fails to understand why she is angered by his wish to have a swastika tattooed on his body.
By asking her help in writing his memoir, Sándor offers Vivien the opportunity to learn about her origins for the first time. Her nascent sense of who she is, however, is beset by challenges. Her lover, Claude, one of Sándor’s tenants, accuses her of murder after learning that she aborted her dead husband’s child. Moved by Vivien’s distress, Sándor decides to evict Claude. He finds the younger man wearing a leather jacket decorated with a swastika, the sight of which sends Sándor into a murderous rage. Claude survives his attack, but Sándor in his rage suffers a series of strokes and dies. Almost thirty years later, Vivien cherishes both Sándor’s “enduring gift” to her—her past—and their time together for teaching her “the only truth that matters: that suffering
272
Picture of Linda Grant, author of Clothes on Their Backs. ª STEPHEN HIRD/Reuters/Corbis
does not ennoble and that survivors survive because of their strength or cunning or luck, not their goodness, and certainly not their innocence.”
W Style Grant’s novel is narrated in the first person by the protagonist, Vivien Kovaks. Most of the narration takes the form of an extended flashback that covers the period between the arrival of Vivien’s parents, Berta and Ervin Kovaks, at their flat in London in 1938 to the death of Sándor Kovacs, Vivien’s uncle, in 1977. As noted by Barbara Carey in the Toronto Star, Grant’s prose “is more substance than style. She isn’t a snappy writer, but the unfussy thoroughness of her storytelling has a strong, cumulative effect.” The Clothes on Their Backs is a character study, an exploration of the ways in which environment interacts with the deep inner truth of an individual to shape a life. The horrors of war transform the street-savvy Sándor into a brutal businessman who sees no crime in renting squalid, unheated rooms to West Indian immigrants at top market price. Sándor nonetheless remains capable of the tenderness, passion, and lust for life that Vivien feels TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Clothes on Their Backs
her parents may never have had. Unmoored from her past, Vivien drifts in English society, first trying on, briefly, the role of wife to an English lord and then becoming a punk, albeit a punk who hands out leaflets for the Anti-Nazi League. There is a gap in her identity that she eventually understands only Sándor can help her fill, by describing for her the lives from which her own life has sprung. Sándor’s goodness is vouched for by someone Vivien at first considers a doubtful source, his girlfriend, Eunice. When the two women first meet, Vivien sees only Eunice’s mask for the outside world: her elegant clothing, perfect makeup, and graceful comportment. Not until the end of the novel does the now-elderly Eunice reveal to Vivien the scars left behind by racial hatred and tell her of the passionate gratitude and love she still feels for the long-dead Sándor, whose love helped heal her wounds.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Linda Grant was born on February 15, 1951, in Liverpool, England, to Russian and Polish Jewish parents. She studied English at the University of York and holds an MA in English from MacMaster University. From 1995 to 2000 she was a feature writer for the Guardian, and in 1997 and 1998 she also wrote a weekly column for the newspaper. Her first novel, The Cast Iron Shore (1996), won the David Higham First Novel Award and was short-listed for the Guardian Fiction Prize. When I Lived in Modern Times (2000) won the Orange Prize for Fiction. In these and her other novels, Grant explores themes of identity and purpose through her female protagonists. She addresses similar concerns in her nonfiction. In Remind Me Who I Am, Again (1999), for example, Grant reflects on the centrality of memory to the concept of self in her account of her mother’s struggle with dementia.
W Critical Reception The Clothes on Their Backs has won accolades for its astute characterizations and masterful storytelling. In his review for Independent, Michael Arditti describes the novel as “at once a beautifully detailed character study, a poignant family history, and a richly evocative portrait of the late 1970s.” Barbara Carey likewise declares that the novel’s “greatest strength is its characterization” and singles out Sándor Kovacs as “a particularly compelling figure.” The character of Vivien, notes Jane Shilling in the Times (London), “resembles a rawer, angrier version of one of Anita Brookner’s dutiful daughters, waiting in a tightly suppressed agony of longing for life to happen.” The relationship between Vivien and Sándor forms the rich center of Grant’s novel. Kamila Shamsie comments in the Guardian that “the best part of the novel is in Vivien’s interactions with her uncle, the way he constantly challenges her notions of reality,” provoking her to try to “understand something of this loud, flamboyant figure . . . so disturbingly filled with impulses she recognized in herself.” Reviewers have also been impressed with Grant’s ability to pack powerful themes into a story whose pace never flags. Writing for the Guardian, Viv Groskop observes that “there is nothing lightweight about [the novel’s] themes and yet it is so artfully constructed that you barely feel that you’re reading it at all, so fluid and addictive is the plot.” The prominent clothing imagery in the novel, on the other hand, has drawn mixed reviews. Shamsie writes that the notion that “the clothes we wear define us and change us” is “a fascinating idea, but one which is not fully woven into the narrative.” Similarly, Arditti contends that the novel’s “sole significant flaw is its failure to establish its extensive clothing imagery as the overarching metaphor for which it strives.”
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Arditti, Michael. “The Slum Landlord Settles His Accounts.” Rev. of The Clothes on Their Backs, by Linda Grant. Independent [London]. Independent Print Ltd, 15 Feb. 2008. Web. 29 Sept. 2010. Carey, Barbara. Rev. of The Clothes on Their Backs, by Linda Grant. Toronto Star 14 Sept. 2008: ID04. CPI. Q (Canadian Periodicals). Web. 29 Sept. 2010. Grant, Linda. The Clothes on Their Backs: A Novel. New York: Scribner's, 2008. Print. Groskop, Viv. “London’s Burning.” Rev. of The Clothes on Their Backs, by Linda Grant. Guardian [London]. Guardian News and Media Ltd, 17 Feb. 2008. Web. 29 Sept. 2010. Shamsie, Kamila. “The Warp of History.” Rev. of The Clothes on Their Backs, by Linda Grant. Guardian [London]. Guardian News and Media Ltd, 23 Feb. 2008. Web. 29 Sept. 2010. Shilling, Jane. Rev. of The Clothes on Their Backs, by Linda Grant. Times [London]. Times Newspapers Ltd, 24 Jan. 2008. Web. 29 Sept. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Rev. of The Clothes on Their Backs, by Linda Grant. Kirkus Reviews 15 Nov. 2008. Literature Resource Center. Web. 29 Sept. 2010. Praises the novel’s psychological insights and its portrayal of Vivien’s search of her identity. Cooke, Rachel. Rev. of The Clothes on Their Backs, by Linda Grant. Evening Standard [London]. ES
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
273
The Clothes on Their Backs
London Ltd, 12 Sept. 2008. Web. 29 Sept. 2010. A positive review that highlights the novel’s combination of “big ideas” and coming-of-age story. Perrick, Penny. “She Wears It Well.” Rev. of The Clothes on Their Backs, by Linda Grant. Sunday Times [London] 3 Feb. 2008: 66. Expanded Academic ASAP. Web. 29 Sept. 2010. A detailed review that addresses the novel’s psychological complexity and Grant’s skill in capturing the inner truths of her characters as well as their surface appearances. “To London with Only ‘The Clothes on Their Backs.’” All Things Considered. National Public Radio, 28 Jan. 2009. Literature Resource Center. Web. 29 Sept. 2010. A transcript of a brief review that praises the depiction of the tension between the generations of the Kovaks family. Gale Resources
“Linda Grant.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2010. Literature Resource Center. Web. 28 Sept. 2010. Open Web Sources
Linda Grant’s Web site features a biography, excerpts from her works, selected journalism, reviews and other information about her books, and a schedule of readings and other public appearances. http://www .lindagrant.co.uk The Holocaust History Project has a collection of photographs that depict the Holocaust in Hungary, including photographs of forced-labor battalions. http://www.holocaust-history.org/hungarianphotos//
For Further Reading
Braham, Randolph L. The Politics of Genocide: The Holocaust in Hungary. Condensed ed. Detroit: Wayne State UP, 2000. Print. The condensed version of Braham’s history of the Jewish ordeal in Hungary during World War II includes a section on the Labor Service System of the Hungarian armed forces. Grant, Linda. The Cast Iron Shore. London: Picador, 1996. Print. Grant’s prizewinning first novel follows a privileged young British Jewish woman on a lifechanging journey to New York City. ———. Remind Me Who I Am, Again. London: Granta Books, 1999. Print. In this reflective work on her mother’s struggle with dementia, Grant explores her family’s Eastern European heritage, noting that her immigrant parents, like Berta and Ervin Kovaks, were happy to leave their history behind. Green, Shirley. Rachman. London: Joseph, 1979. Print. Grant referred to this biography of the notorious London landlord Peter Rachman in creating the character Sándor Kovacs. Knight, Nick. Skinhead. London: Omnibus Press, 1982. Print. Photographs accompany this history of skinheads in London from the group’s origins in the 1960s through its revival in the mid-1970s. Watson, Gavin. Skins and Punks: Lost Archives, 1979– 1985. New York: VICE Books, 2008. Print. This photographic retrospective of the skins and punks of English youth culture in the late 1970s and 1980s also features commentaries and first-person accounts. Janet Moredock
Exploring 20th Century London offers photographs, time lines, and articles for delving into various periods and themes in the city’s recent history. http:// www.20thcenturylondon.org.uk/
274
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Cloud Atlas By David Mitchell
W Introduction David Mitchell’s Cloud Atlas (2004) is a complex, epic novel composed of a series of six interlocking novellas set over a span of centuries, each story belonging to a different genre and style. The first novella is a journal by an American notary returning home via ship from the Chatham Islands in 1850. The second is an epistolary novel, composed of letters written by a struggling musician to his male lover in 1931 Belgium. The third novella is a mystery, tracing a female journalist as she investigates corporate espionage in California, 1975. The fourth is a thriller set in the early twenty-first century about an independent publisher running from the mob. The fifth and sixth sections are science fiction tales, the first of which is set in the near future and centers on a fabricant, or manufactured clone, sentenced to death for rebelling against its dystopian government, and the second of which takes place far into the future and focuses on a primitive tribesman struggling for survival on a postapocalyptic Earth. Cloud Atlas was short-listed for the Man Booker Prize, the Commonwealth Writers' Prize, the Arthur C. Clarke Award, and the Nebula, and won the British Book Awards Literary Fiction Award, and the Richard & Judy Best Read of the Year.
W Literary and Historical Context
David Mitchell’s writing belongs to a postmodern tradition that follows in the footsteps of such esteemed writers as James Joyce, Vladimir Nabokov, and Paul Auster. Notable traits of postmodern fiction include experimentation with language, fragmentation of narrative, the use of unreliable narrators, literary deconstruction, irony, satire, pastiche, intertexuality, and
metatextuality. Also characteristic is the propensity to invent words and play with language in unusual ways, especially in works by such authors as Joyce and Nabokov. Many of these elements are present in the writing style Mitchell uses in Cloud Atlas, especially his use of the concept of a text that is, in large part, aware of being a text. Many postmodern writers include or write themselves into their stories, such as Paul Auster in his New York Trilogy. While Mitchell does not employ this technique quite so literally in Cloud Atlas, the manner in which each section eventually reveals itself as a story read or viewed by a character in the successive section calls attention to each chapter as a manufactured work of fiction. Often, characters in one chapter will go so far as to point out the deficiencies of the previous chapter. For example, Robert Frobisher, in the second novella, reads the diary that forms the first novella, and deems it unconvincing and poorly written, concluding that it is a fake. Of course, on a metatextual level, it is. The character Sonmi˜451 believes the film of Timothy Cavendish’s story (the story preceding hers) to be melodramatic and overwrought. Mitchell’s purpose in doing this seems to be to make the reader constantly, actively aware of each novella as being a meticulously structured satire or pastiche.
W Themes Arguably Cloud Atlas’s major recurring theme is that of man’s capacity for cruelty. Practically every story in the book involves some form of enslavement, or examples of a stronger entity asserting power over a weaker one. “The Pacific Journal of Adam Ewing” discusses colonialism and its devastating effects on native populations. “Letters from Zedelghem” centers on a more petty type of enslavement—in this tale, a narcissistic composer treats a young assistant as a personal servant, heaping abuse and humiliation upon him. “Half-Lives” depicts a journalist trying to expose a billion-dollar corporation running a
275 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Cloud Atlas
MAJOR CHARACTERS VYVYAN AYRES is an elderly, famous composer, who hires Robert Frobisher to write out his compositions for him. TIMOTHY CAVENDISH is a small-press publisher in the early twenty-first century who finds himself in trouble when he is pursued by the brothers of a gangster whose memoirs he published. ADAM EWING is an American notary in 1850, journeying home on a ship across the Pacific from the Chatham Islands. ROBERT FROBISHER is a poor, young musician from England in 1931, who obtains a job in Belgium writing out the compositions of a famous composer, Vyvyan Ayres. LUISA REY is a young journalist in 1975 who investigates corporate espionage and corruption at a power plant. SONMI ˜ 451 is a genetically cloned chain-restaurant server, sentenced to execution for rebelling against the dystopian society that created her, in the not-too-distant future. ZACH’RY is a primitive tribesman in the far distant future, living a miserable existence long after most of humanity is wiped out.
nuclear power plant that is, in fact, unstable. In “The Ghastly Ordeal of Timothy Cavendish,” a elderly man is trapped in a nursing home against his will. “An Orison of Sonmi ˜ 451” is about a dystopian future society in which people are manufactured specifically to work as menial laborers, with no hope for advancement or legal protection. “Sloosha’s Crossin’ An’ Ev’rythin’ After” examines the fallout following the destruction of Earth. Despite the focus on cruelty in the novel, the second half of the book provides a more optimistic view. In the end, the stories highlight humanity’s flaws while pointing to the capacity of individual people for growth and change.
W Style Cloud Atlas is composed of a series of six novellas bound together by recurring imagery and themes. Additionally, the separate stories (each a pastiche of a different writing style) are structurally presented in a manner reminiscent of Russian nesting dolls. Specifically, in the first half of the book, each story is contained within the story that immediately follows it. “The Pacific Journal of Adam Ewing” is a diary being read by the protagonist of “Letters from Zedelghem;” the letters in turn are being read by the protagonist of “Half-Lives: The First Luisa Rey Mystery,” a mystery novel being read by the protagonist of “The Ghastly Ordeal of Timothy Cavendish.” That novella, in turn, is a film being viewed
276
Photo of David Mitchell, author of Cloud Atlas. Dave M. Benett/ Getty Images
by the protagonist of “An Orison of Sonmi˜451,” which is the holy text of the protagonist of “Sloosha’s Crossin’ An’ Ev’rythin’ After.” While the first half of the novel goes inward, the second goes outward. “Sonmi˜451” turns on the film, in which Timothy Cavendish reads the Luisa Rey book, and with the progressioin continuing to the end of the book. This fragmentary style accomplishes two goals. First, it mimics the act of reading a book. In other words, each story eventually cuts to the successive story because a character in the next story is reading the current story. This character is usually interrupted by the events that will eventually become the story read by a character in the following story. Secondly, it allows Mitchell to emphasize one of the novel’s major nuances, the connection between people in seemingly different cultures and time periods. On a metatextual level, Mitchell also seems to be arguing that characters across vastly divergent styles of literature possess many more similarities than first meets the eye. In other words, although the outside circumstances may change, most stories follow a common arc, regardless of author or genre. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Cloud Atlas
W Critical Reception Cloud Atlas was well received by critics, and many reviewers have hailed Mitchell as a genius, an adjective that recurs throughout criticism of his work. He is specifically praised for his uncanny ability to capture a wide variety of voices and styles. For example, Tom Bissell in the New York Times heaped lavish praise upon Mitchell, saying, “He writes as though at the helm of some perpetual dream machine, can evidently do anything, and his ambition is written in magma across this novel’s every page.” He went on to add, however, that Cloud Atlas “is frustrating not because it is too smart but because it is not nearly as smart as its author.” Criticism of Cloud Atlas focuses heavily on the structural aspects of the work, with some reviewers faulting Mitchell for the complexity of its literary arrangement. For example, Troy Patterson notes in Entertainment Weekly that the novel is weaker than the sum of its parts—“Mitchell’s talents for riotous incident and energetic prose keep the pages turning, but Atlas’ disparate strands are linked only by the flimsiest of pretenses. . . . The six cylinders never function as one engine.” On the other hand, Robert K. J. Killheffer writes, “Taken by themselves, each of the stories . . . are utterly, even slavishly, conventional. . . . Nevertheless . . . [a] sense of unity emerges from the repetition of images, metaphors, and coincidences—an almost metaphysical awareness of the interconnectedness and interdependence of things.” Overall, the book was well received. Newsweek International called it “a wild, wonderful ride . . . Mitchell . . . seduces you with his compelling characters and their narratives.” Over the course of the novel, “the fine threads that link the narratives multiply, and the stories become increasingly interwoven. In the hands of a lesser writer, this book would be, at best, the sum of its disparate parts. It’s a testament to Mitchell’s formidable skill and imagination that Cloud Atlas adds up to so much more.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Bissell, Tom. “History Is a Nightmare.” Rev. of Cloud Atlas, by David Mitchell. New York Times 29 Aug. 2004: n.p. Web. 5 Aug. 2010. Killheffer, Robert K. J. “Edenborn.” Rev. of Cloud Atlas, by David Mitchell. Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction Apr. 2005: 33+. Print. Mitchell, David. Cloud Atlas. New York: Random House, 2004. Print. Patterson, Troy. “Cloud Atlas.” Rev. of Cloud Atlas, by David Mitchell. Entertainment Weekly 20 Aug. 2004: 133. Print. “Pushing the Envelope: David Mitchell’s New Book Is Brilliantly Exasperating.” Rev. of Cloud Atlas, by
ABOUT THE AUTHOR David Mitchell is one of the most acclaimed young British novelists writing today. Known for his evocative prose and chameleon-like ability to capture a wide variety of voices and tones, two of Mitchell’s most critically acclaimed novels, Ghostwritten and Cloud Atlas are tightly woven collections of short stories and novellas whose various pieces intersect and interlock in numerous ways, both in theme and narrative. A major thematic thread in his works is the interconnectedness of human beings on a global scale, from differing countries and even time periods. Mitchell has been short-listed twice for the Man Booker Prize, was selected by Granta magazine as one of the Best of Young British Novelists, and was listed by Time Magazine as one of the 100 Most Influential People in the World.
David Mitchell. Newsweek International 30 Aug. 2004: 57. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Hensher, Philip. “Roller-Coaster of a Ride.” Spectator 294.9158 (14 Feb. 2004): 34+. Print. A glowing review of Cloud Atlas that focuses, in large part, on the thematic and literal connections between the various novellas in the book. Iyer, Pico. “The Concertina of Time: In Cloud Atlas David Mitchell Makes Writing a High-Wire Act— Brave, Dazzling but Too Far Aloft.” Rev. of Cloud Atlas, by David Mitchell. Time 23 Aug. 2004: 67. Print. This review places Cloud Atlas into the context of Mitchell’s previous novels, discussing their overlapping themes and styles. Mitchell, David. “Review: Guardian Book Club: Week Three: David Mitchell on Writing Cloud Atlas.” Guardian [London] 12 June 2010: 6. Print. In this article, Mitchell discusses his writing process, and addresses critics’ concerns with Cloud Atlas. Skidelsky, William. “A World of Tricks.” New Statesman [1996] 22 Mar. 2004: 55. Print. In this positive review, Willam Skidelsky analyzes the major thematic concerns explored in Cloud Atlas, and follows these threads across the arc of the six novellas that comprise this work. Wood, James. “The Floating Library.” New Yorker 5 July 2010: 69. Print. This article from the New Yorker examines all of the major works Mitchell has released to date, examining common themes and explaining why he is highly acclaimed by many readers.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
277
Cloud Atlas Gale Resources
“Mitchell, David (1969-).” Student Resource Center. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Open Web Sources
The Washington Post has an in-depth interview of David Mitchell, discussing the genesis, structure, and meaning of Cloud Atlas at http://www.washington post.com/wp-dyn/articles/A17231-2004Aug19. html For Further Reading
Auster, Paul. The New York Trilogy. New York: Penguin Books, 1990. Print. Mitchell has cited Paul Auster as a major influence on his own writing. Auster’s work often explores the the concept of metafiction, examining the role of the narrator in literature. Similar to Mitchell’s Cloud Atlas, Auster’s New York Trilogy is a collection of three thematically linked stories. Dick, Philip K. Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? New York: Del Rey, 1968. Print. This dystopian, science-fiction story about human-looking androids was the basis for the noted film Blade Runner and an
278
important influence on the “Sonmi˜451” section of Cloud Atlas. Joyce, James. Ulysses. Paris: Shakespeare and Company, 1922. Print. James Joyce’s masterpiece shares a great deal in common with Mitchell’s writing and is documented as one of Mitchell's major influences. Joyce and Mitchell use similarly creative prose, elements of metafiction, and multiple voices in their work. Mitchell, David. Black Swan Green. New York: Random House, 2006. Print. Arguably Mitchell’s most intimate work, this semiautobiographical tale of a young boy growing up in England showcases the author’s ability to capture unique points of view, in this case that of a child, and features the interconnected short story structure of his more epic novels. ———. Ghostwritten. New York: First Vintage International, 1999. Print. Mitchell’s first novel, Ghostwritten, is structurally similar to Cloud Atlas and is composed of numerous short stories, told from many different perspectives. Robert Berg
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Corrections By Jonathan Franzen
W Introduction The Corrections (2001) is a seriocomic saga of the Lamberts, a midwestern family on the verge of falling apart. Chip Lambert, the novel’s protagonist, chronicles the tensions between his parents’ old-fashioned worldview and their children’s contemporary East Coast sensibility, as Enid, the clan’s matriarch, tries to gather them all together one last time for Christmas. The narrative weaves together the stories of each family member. Enid decides to try to ignore her husband’s Parkinson’s and advancing dementia by planning a cruise for the two of them. After being fired from a tenure-track teaching position at a New England college for having sex with one of his students, Chip struggles to support himself with editing work, script-writing, and a bizarre Internet scam in Lithuania. His sister and brother try to cope with relationship difficulties. Recognizing that this may be their last Christmas together, Enid insists that they try to reconcile their differences and come home. The power of this semiautobiographical novel lies in Jonathan Franzen’s humorous and lyrical portraits of family life and of his poignant, sympathetic narrative of the tensions that can erupt among family members. The novel’s title becomes it dominant metaphor as it reflects the Lamberts’ struggle to make corrections in their own lives as well as in their relationships with each other.
W Literary and Historical Context
The Corrections takes place in the United States during the 1990s, a time of rampant consumerism and materialism. During this prosperous decade, unemployment hovered between 4 and 5 percent, the stock market was
booming, and salaries were increasing. With this prosperity came a significant rise in consumer spending, fueled by Americans’ appetite for designer goods and the latest technological gadget such as compact disc players, cellular phones, and personal computers. Many cultural critics argued that this new materialism turned Americans away from traditional values. One such value was the ideal of pursuing advanced education in order to improve others’ lives. In the 1990s, more young people explained that they decided to attend college in order to get better paying jobs. More Americans idolized and tried to emulate the rich and famous, a trend exploited by advertisers who hired celebrities to endorse products. Consumers got instant gratification when they bought these products as symbols of their social status. Franzen’s characters share this obsession with money and the benefits it provides while ignoring the human connections in their lives.
W Themes The Corrections provides a critique of modern culture, specifically its consumerism and its promotion of pharmaceuticals for treating depression and anxiety. Ironically, Chip condemns materialism in his classes, yet when he loses his job, he gripes about not being able to buy what he considers to be the essentials of a good life, such as fine wines, gourmet foods, and Adobe Photoshop, and so he continually borrows money from his sister. He also chides his mother’s midwestern frugality, which prompts her to write letters instead of spend money for phone calls and to get one of the cheapest berths on the cruise she and Albert take. As she saves her pennies, she envies others’ wealth and continually complains that she and her husband missed out on the rewards of the stock market boom. Franzen also criticizes the overuse of pharmaceuticals as he depicts each member of the family at different times
279 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Corrections
MAJOR CHARACTERS ALFRED LAMBERT, Chip’s father, has Parkinson’s disease and is experiencing the beginnings of dementia. CAROLINE LAMBERT, Gary’s wealthy wife, continually argues with her husband over his support of his aging and often demanding parents. CHIP LAMBERT, the novel’s main character, struggles to find an authentic life while redefining his relationship with his parents. DENISE LAMBERT, Chip’s sister, a chef at a successful Philadelphia restaurant, finds contentment in a lesbian relationship. ENID LAMBERT, Chip’s mother, who is both manipulative and supportive of her children, tries to get the family together for Christmas. GARY LAMBERT, Chip’s older brother and a bank president in Philadelphia, suffers from clinical depression.
in the novel taking pills for various emotional troubles. His view seems to be that these medications prevent the characters from dealing with the problems that cause their depression and anxiety. Another important theme centers on family relationships. Alfred’s physical and mental decline ultimately forces the characters to reevaluate their familial ties and to rediscover the importance of family. Toward the end of the novel, when the family members come together to help move Alfred into a nursing home, they experience the healing power of compassion and forgiveness.
W Style The novel’s title provides its ironic controlling metaphor. All of the members of the Lambert family make corrections in their lives, but very few of these bring them happiness and contentment. The siblings try to correct their parents’ midwestern lives by establishing more meaningful and authentic ones for themselves on the East Coast, but Chip has trouble finding a rewarding job and keeping it, Gary’s marriage is falling apart, and Denise has a series of failed relationships, including one with a married man. Enid tries to correct her life by living through her children, but they refuse to let her in enough to accomplish this goal. They all take pills to correct their anxieties and depression, including one appropriately named Corecktall, which helps them avoid confronting the problems that caused these ailments.
280
Photo of Jonathan Franzen, author of the novel The Corrections. James Keivom/NY Daily News Archive via Getty Images
The elderly Lamberts live in St. Jude, and the town’s name provides another metaphor that enriches the novel’s thematic message. St. Jude is the patron saint of lost causes, an appropriate place for Albert, who is struggling to maintain his physical and mental well-being, and Enid, who is trying to assert her relevance in a world that no longer values her.
W Critical Reception Winner of the prestigious National Book Award in 2001, Jonathan Franzen’s best-selling third novel, The Corrections, won over many critics for its compelling portrait of a dysfunctional American family. One such critic, Valerie Sayers, in her review of the novel for Commonweal, praised Franzen’s “deft, often dazzling” portrait of a family that is falling apart and admitted that she was “as charmed as Oprah herself must have been when she first announced her [book club] pick.” Sayers added, “the surprising pleasure is his gradual move to warm sympathy for the souls he has been skewering.” In his review in New Statesman, Nicholas TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Corrections
Blincoe determined that Franzen linked his themes in “poignant, non-trivial ways” and that the novel is a “triumph.” A review in the Atlantic echoed this assessment in its claim that “Franzen is a wizard, endlessly inventive in his thematic connections and scene setting.” Many critics also responded positively to the construction of the novel. The Atlantic review, for example, praised the book’s narrative and claimed that Franzen’s “powers of language are astonishing.” The reviewer concluded that “The Corrections is a wide-open performance, showcasing the full range of his skills and his eclectic intelligence.” Some reviewers, however, found fault with the novel’s construction. Philip Hensher, in his review in Spectator, argued that the novel’s characters “are rather cloudy . . . none of them leaps off the page or stays in the mind.” He also claimed that “there is a constant sense of overloading, of weighing down characters and objects with explicit significance.” In fact, Hensher found this type of long-windedness throughout the novel, arguing that Franzen “is tiresomely over-explicit, always explaining when he should be dramatizing.” He did conclude, though, that “these faults noticeably diminish as the book progresses, and after 150 pages or so Franzen starts to seem in some control of his material.” Max Watman in an article for New Criterion also found occasional fault with Franzen’s narrative, insisting that “Franzen’s mellifluousness . . . gets the best of him at times.” Yet, Watman determined that this flaw was only a small “distraction” in an “adroit” novel, “both hilarious and stirring,” and deserving of its many positive reviews. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Blincoe, Nicholas. “High Art Lite.” Rev. of The Corrections, by Jonathan Franzen. New Statesman 10 Dec. 2001: 52+. Print. Rev. of The Corrections, by Jonathan Franzen. Atlantic Sept. 2001: 136. Print. Franzen, Jonathan. The Corrections. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2001. Print. Hensher, Philip. “Writing beyond His Means.” Rev. of The Corrections, by Jonathan Franzen. Spectator 24 Nov. 2001: 44+. Print. Sayers, Valerie. “Caffeinated Realism.” Rev. of The Corrections, by Jonathan Franzen. Commonweal 21 Dec. 2001: 23+. Print. Watman, Max. “On the Hysterical Playground.” New Criterion 20.3 (2001): 67+. Print.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Jonathan Franzen was born in Western Springs, Illinois, in 1959, but he grew up in a St. Louis suburb, which became the setting for two of his novels. In 1987 he became a literary celebrity after his first novel, The Twenty-seventh City, was published. His second novel, Strong Motion (1992), did not achieve the acclaim of the first, but his third novel, 2001’s The Corrections, lived up to the promise he showed in the first and won the National Book Award for Fiction that year. Franzen’s later publications include a novel, Freedom (2010), essays, and articles for the New Yorker. As of 2010, Franzen lived in New York City.
compares the novel to other twentieth-century works, including those by F. Scott Fitzgerald and Don DeLillo. Greer, Bonnie. “Magnum Oprah: The Great American Novel.” Rev of The Corrections, by Jonathan Franzen. New Statesman 7 Jan. 2002: 30. Print. After commenting on the fracas over the novel’s selection for the Oprah Winfrey book club, discusses the difference between critically acclaimed and popular novels. Hutchinson, Colin. “Jonathan Franzen and the Politics of Disengagement.” CRITIQUE: Studies in Contemporary Fiction 50.2 (2009): 191+. Print. Analyzes Franzen’s first three novels, including The Corrections, as social novels and critiques of twentieth-century consumerism. Rakoff, Joanna Smith. “Making The Corrections: An Interview with Jonathan Franzen.” Poets & Writers 29.5 (2001): 27+. Print. Discusses the autobiographical elements of the novel. Wood, James. “Abhorring a Vacuum.” New Republic 225.16 (2001): 32+. Print. Analyzes the novel’s narrative and Franzen’s role as a cultural ironist. Gale Resources
“Jonathan Franzen.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Literature Resource Center. Web. 31 July 2010. http://go.galegroup.com. ezproxy.pgcc.edu/ps/i.do?&id=GALE %7CH1000033707&v=2.1&u=pgcc_main &it=r&p=LitRC&sw=w
Additional Resources
Open Web Sources
Criticism and Reviews
Jonathan Franzen News on the New York Times Web site, available at http://topics.nytimes.com/topics/refer ence/timestopics/people/f/jonathan_franzen/
Gessen, Keith. “A Literary Correction.” American Prospect 12.19 (2001): 33+. Print. Favorably TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
281
The Corrections
index.html, contains links to several current and archived articles on Franzen and his work. For Further Reading
Franzen, Jonathan. How to Be Alone: Essays. New York: Straus, 2002. Print. Twelve of Franzen’s articles, ranging from autobiographical details of his family life to an analysis of the contemporary novel. ———. The Twenty-seventh City. New York: Farrar, Straus, 1988. Print. Presents a fictionalized account of life in St. Louis in 1984, a city run by Asian Indians.
Kershner, R. B. The Twentieth-Century Novel: An Introduction. New York: Bedford-St. Martin’s Press, 1997. Print. Presents an overview of the modern, post-modern, and contemporary novel as well as historical and social contexts. Ochoa, George. America in the 1990s. New York: Facts on File, 2006. Print. Decades of American History. Explores through commentary and photographs popular culture and the arts in the last decade of the twentieth century. Wendy Perkins
Glickman, Lawrence B. Consumer Society in American History: A Reader. Ithaca: Cornell UP, 1999. Print. Collected essays presenting a comprehensive view of American consumerism patterns from the 1600s to the present.
282
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Crabwalk By Günter Grass
W Introduction Crabwalk, written by German Nobel laureate Günter Grass and published in 2002, is based on the sinking of a German passenger liner, the Wilhelm Gustloff, on January 30, 1945. In Grass’s fictional account of the tragedy that cost nine thousand lives, one of the few survivors is a child, Paul Pokriefke, born as his mother is being rescued. This momentous birth annoyingly shadows Paul throughout his life as his mother continuously retells the story and hounds her son, a journalist, to write their story. In Paul’s fifties, he is compelled by a famous author to begin the project. In his research, he discovers that his estranged teenage son, under the influence of his grandmother, has a Web site dedicated to neo-Nazi sentiments about the Gustloff’s sinking. The struggle of the German people to come to terms with the legacy of World War II is the overriding theme of the novel. The title reflects Paul’s description of his investigation method—like the way a crab walks, in appearance a backward movement, but actually a rapid sideways step that manages to move it forward. Thus the story moves back and forth between present and past, between historical data and the lives of its fictional characters. Written in his seventies, Crabwalk is a part of Grass’s long-term campaign to urge Germans to realize not just their responsibility for but their victimization and suffering in World War II.
W Literary and Historical Context
In German literature, social and critical novels revived after World War II through the work of authors such as Günter Grass, Heinrich Böll, and Max Frisch. Organizations were formed to promote literary activities (for
example, Group 47 in Germany and the Vienna Circle in Austria) and fostered experimental writers such as H. C. Artmann and Ernst Jandl of Austria. While West German writers explored various styles, East German writers tended to use socialist realism. Both groups were heavily focused on Nazi history from the 1970s to the 1990s. Neo-Nazism is an extremist, anti-intellectual, rightwing offshoot of Nazi ideology that developed at the end of World War II and persisted into the early 2000s. This social/political movement copies the symbols of Nazism such as the swastika and the straight-arm salute but differs in some ways, too. In those countries where its activities are not banned by law, neo-Nazism actually functions as just another political party. Neo-Nazis are less focused on anti-Semitism, although they deny that the Holocaust occurred. Their fanatical nationalism causes them to fear and hate foreigners and immigrants. The social aspect of the movement—the drinking, singing of battle songs, and marches—is attractive to the members who tend to be discontented loners from poor areas. Neo-Nazism gives these individuals a feeling of superiority and a way to blame others for their own social, political, and economic problems. Consequently, neo-Nazism has been successful in gaining members in the economically strained area that used to be East Germany, but it exists in many other countries as well. Some groups, especially in Germany, advocate violence. In the United States, neo-Nazis are associated with other white dominance groups such as the Ku Klux Klan.
W Themes A major theme of Crabwalk concerns the price Germans paid for the suppression of their sufferings during World War II. Many Germans were so preoccupied with war crimes, reparations, and guilt over Nazi military aggression and the Holocaust that they did not allow themselves to consider that they, too, had suffered during this terrible period. Germans were so tormented by their
283 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Crabwalk
MAJOR CHARACTERS DAVID, whose real name is Wolfgang Stremplin, is the supposedly Jewish person who argues in the chat room with Konny over issues surrounding the Gustloff. KONRAD POKRIEFKE, called Konny, is Paul’s son, an unbalanced loner who becomes a Nazi apologist on a Web site about the Gustloff. PAUL POKRIEFKE, the narrator and a mediocre journalist bitter about being fatherless and a failed father, is compelled to write about the Gustloff and its effect on his life. TULLA POKRIEFKE is Paul’s overbearing mother and a Stalinist who perpetually retells the details of the Gustloff’s sinking and influences Konny adversely.
past that they, like Tulla and Paul, had difficulty basing their lives on anything else. Nonetheless, they did move on, building a better nation, only later to discover that some of their children wanted to revert to Nazism. They
looked away from incidents such as the sinking of the Wilhelm Gustloff, but the legacy was an open wound that some in the next generation discovered and exploited with resentment instead of healing with more appropriate ways of grieving. Grass uses an oblique crabwalk approach to this subject because approaching directly was taboo in German society. He uses the Gustloff to embody all the horrors experienced by the German people during the war. The tale shows that collateral damage and war crimes occurred on both sides. It also warns that the problems brought on by fascism and Stalinism might never end if guilt and grief are turned into hatred and fear again, just as the oppressive treaty after World War I drove the German people to nationalistic fanaticism as a response to their humiliation. Another theme is the search for fatherhood. The Germans obsessed over the fatherland, Paul repeatedly wonders about his father’s identity, and Konrad joins a neo-Nazi community to find the family that his father did not give him. Paul’s own bitterness towards his parents turns into a distracted parenting that, paradoxically for someone so affected by the past, leads to his becoming involved with his son over the Internet.
Crabwalk recounts the sinking of a German passenger ship and describes how the tragic event continues to affect survivors years later. Hugo Jaeger/Timepix/Time Life Pictures/Getty Images
284
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Crabwalk
W Style The most obvious element of style in Crabwalk is Grass’s time framework that is presented in a sideways manner similar to the movement of a crab. A half century of German history is woven together in a back and forth motion that incorporates historical facts into the fictional narrative. Grass moves from the present to various places in the past, not in chronological order but in the sequence in which memories and the researched history surface in the mind of the first-person narrator. This presentation reflects the reluctance and confusion of the harried narrator. The research also allows the inclusion of various subplots about Wilhelm Gustloff, his killer, and the Russian submarine commander who torpedoed the story’s fated ship. Another stylistic feature is the use of three generations. Each represents a specific period and political position: Tulla as the fascist who accepts life in East Germany, Paul as the politically moderate person who chooses to live in the West, and Konrad who embraces right-wing neo-Nazism. Each has a certain take on the meaning of the sinking of the Gustloff. None of them is a likable character since each, according to Grass’s design, exemplifies flaws in German society. To counter Paul’s ambivalence about his birth, Grass creates the mystery figure who sees the need to tell the story of the Gustloff. This figure is described as the author of Dog Years, so he is most likely Grass himself, who believes that the German people need to tell their own war stories.
W Critical Reception Crabwalk (2002) was called by some Grass’s best work since The Tin Drum in 1959. As Sarah Schaeffer stated in a review for the New Statesman: “Crabwalk is compulsive, leading you towards the final, shattering twist . . . Grass could scarcely be delving deeper into the German soul and challenging its demons to do their worst.” A reviewer for Publishers Weekly concurred that Grass is “A writer who refuses to avert his eyes from unpleasant truths, [who] remains an eloquent explorer of his country’s troubled twentieth-century history.” In an article in the New York Times Book Review, Jeremy Adler remarked: “Grass’s control over this scenario is masterly. Repeatedly switching between frames, he deftly keeps his metaphor in view, to illuminate the zigzag narrative line.” Adler added that the crab, a scavenger crustacean, is a good symbol for “the book’s underlying meanings, notably the criminal debris, the unregenerate guilt, that lies buried in the deep” and shows that “it takes a hard shell to survive.” Magdalena Ball, in a review for the Compulsive Reader, found that there is “much in this work that is beautiful—showing Grass’s keen poetic voice,” and she complimented Crabwalk as “a complex and difficult
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Günter Grass was born October 16, 1927, in the Free City of Danzig (known after 1945 as Gdansk), Poland. Drafted into the German army at fifteen, Grass spent 1945 and 1946 in an American prisoner of war camp. Afterward, he survived as a laborer and eventually as an apprentice stonecutter where his artistic talents led him to enroll first in the art academy in Düsseldorf and then the Berlin Academy of Fine Arts (19531955). Grass married Anna Schwarz in 1954, and they had four children; in 1979 he married Utte Gruner. An accomplished graphic artist and sculptor, Grass began his literary career writing poetry. However, his novel The Tin Drum (1959), considered one of the finest of the twentieth century, catapulted him into international celebrity. Among his multiple literary association memberships and awards is the 1999 Nobel Prize in Literature.
novel which challenges the reader to think about history, about perspective, and narrative truth.” Ball also noted that Grass deliberately “keeps the reader at arm’s length” by making the characters “too wooden and unlikeable,” but she admitted that the characters represent values that are also unattractive. Despite the novel’s acclaim, it is not without its detractors. Reflecting the concerns of other reviewers, Irmgard Hunt commented in a World Literature Today review that Grass’s “themes and style are worn.” She complained that Grass has been obsessing over German history in the same style for decades but was at least in this work he was contemporary and “very clever” in his “use of the Internet and the world of the chat room.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Adler, Jeremy. “Ship of State.” Rev. of Crabwalk, by Günter Grass. New York Times Book Review 108 (2003): 12. Print. Ball, Magdalena. “Crabwalk by Günter Grass.” Rev. of Crabwalk, by Günter Grass. compulsivereader.com. Compulsive Reader, n.d. Web. 30 Sept. 2010. “Crabwalk.” Rev. of Crabwalk, by Günter Grass. Publishers Weekly 250.9 (2003): 51. Print. Grass, Günter. Crabwalk. New York: Harcourt, 2002. Print. Hunt, Irmgard. “Review of Im Krebsgang.” Rev. of Crabwalk, by Günter Grass. World Literature Today 77.1 (2003): 128-29. Print. Schaeffer, Sarah. “Germany’s Titanic.” Rev. of Crabwalk, by Günter Grass. New Statesman 132.4632 (2003): 54. Print.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
285
Crabwalk Additional Resources
Gale Resources
Criticism and Reviews
Caso, Frank. “Grass, Günter. Crabwalk.” Rev. of Crabwalk, by Günter Grass. Booklist 99.12 (2003): 1047. Print. Briefly summarizes the story and comments on how the ship’s tragedy leads to a family’s tragedy. Cone, Edward. “Grass, Günter. Crabwalk.” Rev. of Crabwalk, by Günter Grass. Library Journal 128.1 (2003): 154. Print. Comments that Grass successfully conveys the horror of the ship’s sinking and the situation of German society following World War II. “Crabwalk.” Rev. of Crabwalk, by Günter Grass. Kirkus Reviews 71.1 (2003): 11. Print. Remarks on the tension and disdain Grass expresses regarding fascism, Stalinism, capitalism, and poor parenting. Franklin, Ruth. “The Tin Book.” Rev. of Crabwalk, by Günter Grass. powells.com. New Republic Online 7 Aug. 2003. Web. 30 Sept. 2010. Reviews the controversy over German suffering under the Nazis and concludes that Crabwalk is a repeat of Grass’s previous literary statements. Gimson, Andrew. “A Parable of a Lost Talent.” Rev. of Crabwalk, by Günter Grass. Spectator 291.9112 (2003): 49. Print. Negatively reviews the novel and asserts that Grass has lost his touch and manages only wooden techniques. Lezard, Nicholas. “Almost Taboo.” Rev. of Crabwalk, by Günter Grass. Guardian.co.uk. Guardian 17 Apr. 2004. Web. 30 Sept. 2010. Discusses the story’s background, Grass’s persona in the book, and the faults of the English translation. McCann, Sean. “Crabwalk.” Rev. of Crabwalk, by Günter Grass. Book Mar.-Apr. 2003: 74. Print. Refers to the novel as a poetic description of German suffering and identity. Parker, Ian. “Günter Grass, Crabwalk Synopsis.” warwick.ac.uk. University of Warwick 28 Nov. 2006. Web. 30 Sept. 2010. A synopsis of the novel that remarks on Grass’s themes and motivation. Updike, John. “Suppressed Atrocities.” Rev. of Crabwalk, by Günter Grass. New Yorker 79.9 (2003): 185. Print. Thoroughly summarizes the story while commenting about its messages on parenting and the German conscience. Youngman, Paul A. “The Realization of a Virtual Past in Günter Grass’s Crabwalk.” Studies in Twentieth and Twenty-first Century Literature 32.1 (2008): 179. Print. A critical analysis of the various forms of media used in the novel to narrate the past, particularly the role of the Internet.
286
“Günter Grass.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Literature Resource Center. Web. 26 Sept. 2010. http://galenet.galegroup.com/servlet/ GLD/hits?r=d&origSearch=true&o=DataType& n=10&l=d&c=1&locID=itsbtrial&secondary= false&u=CA&t=KW&s=2&NA=Gunter+Grass Mayer, Sigrid. “Günter Grass.” Nobel Prize Laureates in Literature, Part 2. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 330. Detroit: Gale, 2007. Literature Resource Center. Web. 26 Sept. 2010. http://galenet. galegroup.com/servlet/DLBC_Online? vrsn=1.0&dd=0&srs=ALL&locID=itsbtrial&b1= KE&srchtp=b&c=1&ste=10&stp=DateDes cend&dc=tiPG&d4=0.25&n=10&docNum= BK1560675017&b0=Gunter+Grass&tiPG=0 Open Web Sources
A review by Mary Whipple, a Grass bibliography, a list of related links, and a brief biography are provided by Mostly Fiction Book Reviews, at http://www.mostly fiction.com/history/grass.htm For Further Reading
Adler, J., ed. From Prague Poet to Oxford Anthropologist: Franz Baermann Steiner Celebrated, Essays and Translations. London: Institute of Germanic Studies, U of London P, 2003. Print. Contains the poem “Prayer in the Garden” that was the literary model for Crabwalk. Grass, Günter. The Tin Drum. New York: Mariner, 2010. Print. The 1959 magical realism tale told from the viewpoint of a three-year-old boy when Danzig is retaken by Germany, with themes about fatalism and survival. Niven, William, and James Jordan, eds. Politics and Culture in Twentieth-Century Germany. Rochester: Camden House, 2003. Print. A collection of essays that explore the relationship between politics and the arts in Germany from World War I to 1998. Sellwood, A. V. The Damned Don’t Drown: The Sinking of the Wilhelm Gustloff. Annapolis: Naval Institute Press, 1996. Print. One of the few books that describes the tragedy, this history focuses on four passengers. Wellington, Hubert. Journal of Delacroix. London: Phaidon Press, 1995. Print. An influence on Grass, this diary of a great French painter that is a classic study on art, literature, and life. Lois Kerschen
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Crescent By Diana Abu-Jaber
W Introduction Diana Abu-Jaber’s Crescent (2003) is a romance novel told from the perspective of Sirine, a thirty-nine-year-old Iraqi American. Sirine lives in Los Angeles with her uncle, who raised her after her parents’ death. She is the cook at Nadia’s Café, a Lebanese restaurant in a predominately Arab section of Los Angeles. Crescent combines political discourse and romance in a novel that is also a human rights story about the displacement that war creates. Sirine falls in love with Hanif Al Eyad (called Han), a literature professor, who is an Iraqi refugee. It would be dangerous for Han to return to Iraq, and Sirine has never lived there. Their relationship is defined by their mutual longing for Iraq and by the poetry and food that help these expatriates create a place in the United States. Sirine’s cooking reminds Han of home and reminds Sirine of the home she once shared with her parents. Crescent brings together many markers familiar to the immigrant experience. Westernization and loss of culture, as well as loss of home and all it represents, are common to the immigrant experience. The emphasis on color and race is especially important, since it allows Abu-Jaber to focus on profiling and stereotypes, as Arab Americans try to fit into American society. Woven into the story of Sirine and Han is her uncle’s telling of an Arabic legend about Abdelrahman Salahadin, who like Sirine and Han, is also on a journey to find love, his home, and himself.
W Literary and Historical Context
Crescent is set in Los Angeles approximately nine years after the Persian Gulf War of 1990-1991. Thanks to CNN and twenty-four-hour television news, Iraq and politics were given continual attention in the United
States in 1999. Saddam Hussein was still in power, and his secret police murdered whomever they wished and did so with little provocation. Economic sanctions against Iraq in 1990 remained in place in 1999. Malnutrition was common among Iraqi citizens, and there were few medical resources for treating illness or injury. Beginning in 1998 and continuing for the next several years, the United States and Great Britain engaged in air attacks against Iraqi missile factories and airfields. Abu-Jaber’s Crescent is set in 1999, six years after the first attack on the World Trade Center in 1993. Tension between Arab Americans and other racial or ethnic groups was common during the 1990s. This tension was also evident in American society much earlier, primarily because people knew little about the Arab world. Most Americans regarded all Middle Eastern men—exclusive of Jews—as Arabs, without differentiating among them by religion or country of origin. To be a Muslim means to be a follower of Islam, but not all Arab Americans are Muslim. Many Americans did not realize that fewer than 20 percent of Muslims are Arabs. Instead, stereotypes about Arabs were common. Even before the terrorist attacks of 2001, there was a common perception among uninformed Americans that all Arab men were terrorists. This misguided view led to acts of violence against Arab American men. When Crescent was written in 1999, many Americans believed that Islam was a violent and repressive religion and that gender roles were strictly maintained, often at the expense of women, who were considered inferior. In 1999 Westerners were still unfamiliar with veiling, or the wearing of a hijab or veil. Many non-Muslim people in the United States continued into the early 2000s to think that veiling is repressive, but many Arab women feel that the veil is simply a way to maintain their modesty. To wear a veil is a personal choice. In Crescent, Rana wears a veil, which might seem to suggest that she is a repressed Muslim woman, and yet, this character is a feminist, who is enrolled at the university, and has divorced her abusive husband. In addition, many Arab American women in this novel forgo the veil.
287 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Crescent
MAJOR CHARACTERS AZIZ ABDO is an Iraqi womanizer and poet who sets out to seduce Sirine. HANIF AL EYAD is an exiled Iraqi literature professor who falls in love with Sirine but longs to return to Iraq. He feels guilt, isolation, and regret because of the loss of his family and homeland. MIREILLE is the waitress at Nadia’s Café and Nadia’s daughter. NATHAN is a young photographer who watches Han and Sirine and surreptitiously takes their picture many times. He is mysterious about his past and why he follows Han everywhere. RANA is a young divorced Muslim, who wears a veil and is a feminist. SIRINE is a thirty-nine-year-old blond Iraqi American with no cultural identity. She uses food as a way to connect to her Iraqi past and as a substitute for the love she fears will be taken from her, just as her parents were when she was nine years old. Food is also a way for Sirine to nurture those around her. UM-NADIA is the Lebanese owner of the café where Sirine cooks and functions as a pseudo mother. UNCLE, whose name is not given, is a storyteller and the head of Near Eastern Studies at the university. He raises Sirine after her parents die.
W Themes Racism and prejudice against Arabs are important themes. Crescent was written before the September 11, 2001, attacks on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon, but Abu-Jaber reminds readers that bias against Arab men predates the 2001 attacks. Crescent offers commentary on contemporary issues involving ethnicity, profiling, and stereotyping of Arab immigrants. Um-Nadia chases away the two government men who come to Nadia’s Café to observe the Arab men who eat there. Aziz also relates his own experiences with bias when he explains being mistaken for a terrorist because he is Arab. The use of food to heal and to function as a bridge between the homeland of the past and the immigrant’s new life as an American is an important second theme. Food is, as Abu-Jaber tells Robin Fields, a “cultural memory” (Field 217). The Arabic Thanksgiving dinner, in which Sirine blends Arab foods with American foods, is one example of how food symbolizes both the culture of Iraq and American traditions. A third theme is the pain of loss or of exile. Sirine has lost her parents to death, but she recalls as a child how
288
they traveled extensively on humanitarian missions, leaving her behind. Sirine fears loss and fears falling in love, and yet, this is a novel about the search for love and the need to assuage loneliness. Han is similar in his inability to give himself totally to Sirine. His fear is based on the pain of exile from his home and the loss of his family.
W Style Abu-Jaber uses evocative descriptions and symbolism in Crescent to convey a sense of ethnicity and the immigrant experience. The book is filled with lush descriptions of food and of the people in the café, but the descriptions of home and the longing to return are especially poignant, as when Han tries to describe his feelings about Iraq and tells Sirine that “the night that seems to start two thousand years ago, it’s so light and dry” (82). The title of the book refers to the crescent moon, an important cultural signifier of Muslim life. The crescent is the new moon that symbolizes the beginning of the Islamic new month, but it also is a reminder to return to one’s home, which is not possible for many Arab immigrants in Nadia’s Café. The yearning for their cultural and ethnic past is a common feeling among all of the refugees and immigrants described in Crescent. The story that Sirine’s uncle tells about Abdelrahman Salahadin contains elements of magical realism. The story suggests ancient Arabian Nights legends but is peopled with actors such as Omar Sharif and Richard Burton, who is present in the story as an actor and archaeologist. The uncle’s fable also serves as a mirror to Sirine and Han’s romance. The story that the uncle tells is drawn from Hollywood movies about Arabs, but it also recalls the oral transmission of narrative, which preceded written texts in the ancient Middle East. The fable parallels the main story until the end of the book when the two stories merge. The use of third-person omniscient point of view allows readers to understand what Sirine does not herself understand. The narration of the central story never leaves Sirine, but since she is often blind to her own motives, the omniscient narrator provides a larger understanding. The story the uncle tells of Abdelrahman Salahadin is a separate narration that uses third-person point of view, just as with the story of Han and Sirine.
W Critical Reception Crescent is the second novel published by Abu-Jaber. This work received several awards, including the PEN Center USA Award for Literary Fiction in 2004. It also received the American Book Award and was named one of the twenty best novels for 2003 by the Christian Science Monitor. Reviews of Crescent were exceptionally positive and enthusiastic. After noting how cleverly Abu-Jaber weaves TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Crescent
together the story of Sirine and Han and the fable about Abdelrahman Salahadin, Yasmine Bahrani told USA Today readers that Abu-Jaber “takes pains to evoke a sense of place and of community” in locating the novel in Nadia’s Café. However, after celebrating Abu-Jaber’s efforts to chronicle the lives of Arab Americans, Bahrani lamented that the author offers so little information “about the Arab milieu,” beyond the menu for food at Nadia’s Café. Bahrani viewed this as a minor complaint, though, given that Crescent provides a “normalizing” picture of the Arab community engaging in the same kinds of activities as any other group of immigrants.” Several reviewers noted the timing of Crescent, so soon after the September 11, 2001, attacks. In his review in the Christian Science Monitor, Ron Charles wrote that Abu-Jaber’s novel allows Americans a view of “Iraqis outside the ‘axis of evil,’” an expression used by George W. Bush. Charles also celebrated the complexity of the novel, with its mix of “romantic comedy, political protest, fairy tale, and cultural analysis.” In a Prairie Schooner review, Amelia Montes also noted how effectively Abu-Jaber creates characters that “defy common stereotypes” in a “beautiful
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Born in Syracuse, New York, on November 5, 1959, Diana AbuJaber grew up in both New York and in Jordan. She has published one memoir and three novels. She also has written occasional op-ed pieces about the challenges Arab Americans face. Arabian Jazz (1993) is about the tensions felt by those who try to live in both the Arab and American world. The Language of Baklava (2005) is a memoir. Origin is a mystery novel, in which the focus is no longer on the Arab American world. As of 2010, Abu-Jaber lived in Portland, Oregon, and taught at Portland State University.
braiding of story” that is a “quiet meditation” and an important depiction of Arab Americans postSeptember 11. Crescent explores what it means to be an exile and to experience the loss of a homeland, and much of its appeal lies in its humanizing of Iraqi expatriates.
In Crescent, Sirine is a chef at a Lebanese restaurant in a part of Los Angeles that is heavily populated by Arabs. ª Sergio Pitamitz/Corbis
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
289
Crescent BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Abu-Jaber, Diana. Crescent. New York: Norton, 2003. Print.
Web. 20 July 2010. http://go.galegroup.com/ps/i. do?&id=GALE%7CH1000114206& v=2.1&u=itsbtrial&it=r&p=LitRC&sw=w Open Web Sources
Bahrani, Yasmine. “Crescent Meshes Two Tales of ArabAmerican Culture.” Rev. of Crescent, by Diana AbuJaber. usatoday.com. USA Today, 15 May 2003. Web. 19 July 2010.
Diana Abu-Jaber’s official Web site includes links to her books, with brief summaries and reader guides. It is available at http://www.dianaabujaber.com.
Charles, Ron. “An Iraqi Love Feast Spiced with Despair.” Rev. of Crescent, by Diana Abu-Jaber. csmonitor.com. Christian Science Monitor 27 Mar. 2003. Web. 19 July 2010.
For Further Reading
Montes, Amelia. “Diana Abu-Jaber, Crescent.” Rev. of Crescent, by Diana Abu-Jaber. Prairie Schooner 80.1 (2006): 211-14. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Bader, Eleanor J. “Abu-Jaber, Diana. Crescent.” Rev. of Crescent, by Diana Abu-Jaber. Library Journal 128.1 (2003): 116. Print. Discusses Crescent as an examination of the cost of politics on human life. Fadda-Conrey, Carol. “Arab American Literature in the Ethnic Borderland: Cultural Intersections in Diana Abu-Jaber’s Crescent.” MELUS 31.4 (2006): 187205. Print. Argues that the protagonist in Crescent, the cook Sirine, is a bridge between the Iraqi homeland and immigrant life in the United States. Field, Robin E. “A Prophet in Her Own Town: An Interview with Diana Abu-Jaber.” MELUS 31.4 (2006): 207-25. Print. An interview in which AbuJaber explains her purpose in writing and her efforts to merge Arab and American cultures. Gana, Nouri. “In Search of Andalusia: Reconfiguring Arabness in Diana Abu-Jaber’s Crescent.” Comparative Literature Studies 45.2 (2008): 228-46. Print. Explains that Crescent demystifies Arab life, while focusing on the importance of maintaining a cultural heritage. Mercer, Lorraine, and Linda Strom. “Counter Narratives: Cooking Up Stories of Love and Loss in Naomi Shihab Nye’s Poetry and Diana Abu-Jaber’s Crescent.” MELUS 32.4 (2007): 33-46. Print. Explores the ways in which food communicates love and reveals memory. Shalal-Esa, Andrea. “Diana Abu-Jaber: The Only Response to Silencing . . . Is to Keep Speaking.” Aljadid: A Review & Record of Arab Culture and Arts 8.39 (2002): 4-6. Print. An interview in which Abu-Jaber discusses exile and the crisis of identity that lies at the center of Crescent.
Abu-Jaber, Diana. The Language of Baklava. New York: Pantheon, 2005. Print. A memoir that uses food to relate the experiences of the author in growing up in an Arab American family. Dahmash-Jarrah, Samar. Arab Voices Speak to American Hearts. Tampa: Olive Branch, 2005. Print. Contains twelve interviews with Arab Americans who hope to dispel stereotypes, while advancing knowledge of Arab life in the United States. Foster, Benjamin R., and Karen Polinger Foster. Civilizations of Ancient Iraq. Princeton: Princeton UP, 2009. Print. Traces the history of Iraq from 8000 BCE to 637 CE and provides a political and cultural overview of the ancient country of Iraq. Halaby, Laila. West of the Jordan: A Novel. Boston: Beacon, 2003. Print. About four young Arab American women trying to establish their own identities, while also trying to bridge two very different cultures. Kaldas, Pauline, and Mattawa Khaled, eds. Dinarzad’s Children: An Anthology of Contemporary Arab American Fiction. Fayetteville: U of Arkansas P, 2009. Print. Short stories by nineteen authors of Arab descent who write about their experiences as Arab Americans. Malek, Alia. A Country Called Amreeka: Arab Roots, American Stories. New York: Free Press, 2009. Print. A series of shared experiences of Arab immigrants who find it difficult to become part of American cultural life. Sasson, Jean. Mayada, Daughter of Iraq: One Woman’s Survival under Saddam Hussein. New York: Dutton, 2003. Print. Describes a woman’s imprisonment in an Iraqi jail and the friendships forged in prison that made it possible for her to survive. Shakir, Evelyn. Bint Arab: Arab and Arab American Women in the United States. Westport: Praeger, 1997. Print. A history of Arab immigration to the United States from a woman’s perspective. Sheri Karmiol
Gale Resources
“Diana Abu-Jaber.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2006. Literature Resource Center.
290
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time By Mark Haddon
W Introduction
W Literary and Historical
In Mark Haddon’s first-person novel, The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time (2003), the narrator Christopher John Francis Boone is an autistic savant. This fifteen-year-old boy discovers the neighbor’s dog, Wellington, murdered with a garden fork. Perplexed by the crime and encouraged by his teacher to write a book, Christopher begins his murder mystery much to the disapproval of his single father, Ed. In one sense, the novel is the book Christopher writes as he goes about detecting the mystery of who killed Wellington, Mrs. Shears’s poodle. In another sense, the novel is about the experiences Christopher has while solving the mystery and writing about it. Ed Boone becomes a single father upon his wife’s departure. He tells his son that she went to the hospital unexpectedly and then died there of a heart attack. Ed faces maintaining the household, holding a job, and meeting the special needs of his son. Christopher circumvents his father’s order to stop investigating Wellington’s death and undertakes a journey that takes him to neighbors in Swindon and from there to London in search of his mother. Reminiscent of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s detective fiction, The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time portrays its protagonist as someone ruled by dispassionate deductive reasoning. Christopher negotiates the environs of an English suburb despite his disorder (perhaps a type of autism called Asperger’s syndrome), which he handles by applying special breathing and other techniques he has learned in school. He is prone to bouts of groaning and overreacts to the proximity of others and being touched, to metaphor, and to yellow and brown. He finds comfort in prime numbers and mathematical proofs. Haddon has recast the conventional detective as a boy whose phobias and fancies reveal the mental environment of an autistic child trying to make sense of human behavior.
In the character and point of view of Christopher Boone, Haddon suggests the world as it is understood by children with autism spectrum disorders (ASD). Previously confused with other mental conditions, such as schizophrenia, the complex developmental disorders referred to collectively as autism were studied throughout the twentieth century; however, as of the early 2000s, much about these conditions remained unknown. In the 1980s one type of autism was identified as Asperger’s syndrome, using the independent studies of Hans Asperger (1906-1980) and Leo Kanter (18911984). One of a subgroup of ASD, Asperger’s became an official diagnosis in 1992, when it was recorded in the tenth edition of the diagnostic manual International Classification of Diseases (ICD-10), published by the World Health Organization. Christopher Boone illustrates this disorder: He has high brain function but is unable to act normally in social interaction, and in stressful situations, he resorts to nonverbal sounds and mechanical rocking or pounding. By the 1990s, special needs schools began to appear, with teachers trained to assist and educate students with such disorders. Other contextual references in the novel are identified by Christopher’s interests. For example, he is fascinated by astronomy, studies the Apollo missions, and fantasizes about being an astronaut alone in space. Reaching his teens in the 1990s, Christopher is affected by the technology revolution that transformed countries in the West in the last third of the twentieth century. Like millions of other teens, Christopher spends many afterschool hours alone in his bedroom, entertaining himself with computer games and videos. Another reference is to automated teller machines (ATMs), which first came into use in the United Kingdom in late 1972. Quite suddenly, a card and password were all individuals needed to access bank accounts from remote locations. Thus, Christopher
Context
291 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time
MAJOR CHARACTERS CHRISTOPHER JOHN FRANCIS BOONE, the narrator and protagonist, is fifteen years old, gifted in mathematics, and has Asperger’s syndrome, a high-functioning form of autism. He lives with his father and attends a school for students with special needs. ED BOONE, Christopher’s father, owns and runs a heating maintenance and boiler repair business. JUDY BOONE, Christopher’s mother, has had difficulty meeting her son’s needs and two years earlier she moved to London with her lover, Roger Shears. EILEEN SHEARS is a neighbor. Wellington was her dog and her husband left town with Christopher’s mother. SIOBHAN is Christopher’s main teacher.
has the means to withdraw money from his father’s account by using an ATM machine in the Swindon train station.
W Themes In The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time people struggle to find meaning and maintain stability in a dynamic world. The narrator, Christopher Boone, strives to control his life, including keeping a schedule of before-and-after school activities, preparing for his math exams, and taking care of his pet rat Toby. He thinks about the world as if his brain were a computer. He also tries to understand his mother’s absence and obey his father. Certain random events, such as the appearance and number of yellow cars in traffic, cause Christopher to reach irrational conclusions about daily experience and to seek relief in the predictability of mathematical and thought problems. Another theme pertains to loss and how people cope with it, and related to this subject is the novel’s focus on how crimes are solved. The first event is the discovery of the murdered dog, which dramatizes how Christopher and Mrs. Shears react to loss. Using his knowledge of Sherlock Holmes's mysteries, Christopher realizes that the absence of any telling behavior on the part of Wellington, the murdered poodle, is actually a clue to solving the crime. The same idea of absence and loss with regard to his mother, Judy Boone, leads Christopher to discover that she did not die, but rather left Swindon with her lover, Roger Shears. The novel is also about language, about verbal communication that works or does not work and about written text as a means for defining reality. Christopher
292
When a neighbor’s dog is murdered with a garden fork, Christopher John Francis Boone tries to find the person responsible for the animal’s death in The Curious Incident of the Dog in the NightTime. Christopher Elwell/Shutterstock.com
understands language literally and is keen on defining unusual words. He experiences clichés and metaphors as dissonance. His unique way of comprehending words leads readers to see how language can convey meaning and obscure it. In this sense, the novel is about language use and about the difference between writing about life and experiencing it directly.
W Style The strictly observed first-person point of view conveys the narrator’s autism without labeling it. Christopher’s literal perspective and mathematical prowess come across in his unusual attention detail. But when he is overstimulated by too much sensory information, he uses diagrams and pictographs, or orthographic devices, such as capitalization or bold font, to impose order on his subject. The point of view remains Christopher’s, but because he has total recall, adult dialogue is reported TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Born in Northampton, England, on September 26, 1962, Mark Haddon worked various jobs, including assisting patients with multiple sclerosis and autism. He earned a BA in English from Merton College, Oxford University, in 1981 and an MA from Edinburgh University in 1984. Before publication of The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time, which won the Whitbread Book of the Year Award, Haddon wrote and illustrated children’s books. He also worked in television and won a British Academy of Film and Television Arts award for his work on episodes of Microsoap. As of 2008, Haddon lived with his wife and children in Oxford, England.
Christopher John Francis Boone tries to unravel the mystery surrounding the murder of his neighbor's dog, a poodle named Wellington, in The Curious Incident of the Dog in the NightTime. ª INTERFOTO / Alamy
verbatim. The statements by adults around Christopher inform readers about how others interact with Christopher and react to his autistic symptoms. When Ed Boone discovers the book Christopher is writing about solving Wellington’s murder, he says to his son, “How stupid are you?” Unable to access normal emotional response and inclined to comprehend literally, Christopher responds: “This is what Siobhan says is a rhetorical question. It has a question mark at the end, but you are not meant to answer it because the person who is asking it already knows the answer.” Despite or because of his disability, Christopher embodies the characteristics of an effective, calculating detective. He is practical, methodical, and unsentimental. Haddon’s style effectively portrays the autistic genius he has created, so that regardless how convoluted the text can get with its odd syntax and permutations, the tone remains honest and as incapable of lying as Christopher Boone is.
W Critical Reception Mark Haddon had a successful career as a writer and illustrator of children’s books before writing his critically acclaimed first novel, The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time. It was well received by critics, who generally praised it for the reliable narrative voice. The
novel delighted critics because the strength of Haddon’s narrative rests on artful prose rather than on Christopher’s disorder, which is never mentioned in the book. Apart from his behavior problems, Christopher is a junior detective who rises victoriously above his limitations or capitalizes upon them in order to solve a mystery or two. In the New Statesman, David Annand wrote: “Although Christopher was emotionally stunted, his inadvertent wittiness and honesty made him instantly adorable.” Sharon Kirkes praised Haddon’s grasp of the character and his condition in her review appearing in Library Journal: “Mark Haddon brilliantly captures the voice and logicality of high-functioning teenager Christopher, who, in the course of investigating a minor mystery— the death of a neighbor’s dog—challenges himself, and his parents, to confront unforeseen issues and events.” But some reviewers found the book off-putting. For example, Nicholas Barrow, writing in Spectator, and informed by his own experience with Aspberger’s, found Christopher irritating and tedious. Barrow felt that Haddon spends too much time shoring up his protagonist’s zeal for math with equations and diagrams, which Barrow thought “pointless.” Nevertheless, many critics praised Haddon’s accomplishment in his successful first novel. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Annand, David. “Shaking Things Up.” Rev. of The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time, by Mark Haddon. New Statesman 17 Apr. 2006: 55. Literature Resource Center. Web. 4 July 2010. Barrow, Nicholas. “It Ain’t Necessarily So.” Rev. of The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time, by Mark Haddon. Spectator 17 May 2003: 65+. Literature Resource Center. Web. 4 July 2010. Haddon, Mark. The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time. New York: Vintage-Random, 2003. Print.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
293
The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time
Kirkes, Sharon. “Fiction on the Spectrum.” Rev. of The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time, by Mark Haddon. Library Journal 132.7 (2007): 132. Literature Resource Center. Web. 4 July 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Edwards, Jacqueline. “Haddon, Mark. The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time, a Novel.” Rev. of The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time, by Mark Haddon. Kliatt July 2004: 18. Literature Resource Center. Web. 13 July 2010. Haddon’s novel viewed as a bildungsroman. Maryles, Daisy. “Poodlecide Pays.” Rev. of The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time, by Mark Haddon. Publishers Weekly 14 Feb. 2005: 14. Literature Resource Center. Web. 13 July 2010. Credits success of this detective story to its autistic protagonist. McInerney, Jay. “The Remains of the Dog.” Rev. of The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time, by Mark Haddon. New York Times Book Review 15 June 2003: 5. Literature Resource Center. Web. 12 July 2010. Observes that the novel is open-ended and that the real mystery is not the crime but the literal and logic-driven boy detective. Muller, Vivienne. “Constituting Christopher: Disability Theory and Mark Haddon’s The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time.” Papers: Explorations into Children’s Literature 16.2 (2006): 118+. Literature Resource Center. Web. 12 July 2010. Identifies the reader as an ethnographer with a privileged view of an autistic savant’s mind and emphasizes the relevance of Haddon’s portrayal of Christopher in terms of readers’ perceptions of the abled and disabled. Rorke, Robert. “A ‘Curious’ Coincidence: In Britain, Young Adult Readers Read Mark Haddon’s Novel at the Same Time as Grownups.” Rev. of The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time, by Mark Haddon. Publishers Weekly 252.28 (2005): 164. Literature Resource Center. Web. 13 July 2010. Notes Haddon’s novel has the distinction of being a successful crossover novel. Gale Resources
“Mark Haddon.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Literature Resource Center. Web. 13 July 2010.
294
Open Web Sources
Haddon maintains a Web site called Mark Haddon Home Page, at http://www.markhaddon.com, which contains images, such as simultaneous drawings he has done with his children and comments by the author about current cultural and popular events. The blog Web site called Mostly Fiction Book Reviews, at http://www.mostlyfiction.com, contains a review of The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time. For Further Reading
Atwood, Tony. The Complete Guide to Asperger’s Syndrome. London: Jessica Kingsley, 2008. Print. An informative and accessible compilation of research and clinical experience on children and adults who suffer from Asperger’s, appropriate both to professionals as well as individuals and families interested in fresh approaches to this condition. Glendening, Daniel J. “Author Mark Haddon Takes a Novel Approach to Autism.” America’s Intelligence Wire 19 Jan. 2004: n. p. Print. Review that emphasizes the novel’s literary accomplishment over a clinical treatment of autism. Greenspan, Stanley, Robin Simons, and Serena Weider. The Child with Special Needs: Encouraging Intellectual and Emotional Growth. New York: Perseus Books, 1998. Print. Covers a variety of disorders, including autism, and suggests ways parents can maximize emotional and intellectual development of children with special needs. Lemke, Donald B. The Apollo 13 Mission. Bloomington: Capstone Press, 2006. Print. A work designed for children that features a graphic presentation of the Apollo 13 mission. Sicile-Kira, Chantal. Autism Spectrum Disorders: The Complete Guide to Understanding Autism, Asperger’s Syndrome, Pervasive Developmental Disorder, and Other ASDs. New York: Perigree Trade-Penguin, 2004. Print. Winner of the 2005 Autism Society of America’s Outstanding Literary Work of the Year Award, an excellent reference guide for parents and professionals. Wells, David. The Penguin Book of Curious and Interesting Numbers. New York: Penguin, 1998. Print. Essentially a dictionary of numbers, highlighting unusual features of many numbers. Doris Plantus-Runey
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Curse of Chalion By Lois McMaster Bujold
W Introduction The Curse of Chalion (2001) is the second fantasy novel by the popular science fiction author Lois McMaster Bujold. It is the first of three works set in a richly detailed fictional world based loosely on Spain in the late Middle Ages. The novel is regarded as a crossover work that combines elements of the romance novel with high fantasy and employs a sophisticated yet accessible writing style that appeals to both teens and adults. Critics as well as readers have praised The Curse of Chalion for its interesting, well-developed characters and for its carefully drawn background of complex political events and theological concepts. The story follows a betrayed nobleman on his reluctant quest to save the royal house of Chalion and to find personal healing. In 2002 The Curse of Chalion was nominated for a Hugo Award, a Locus Award, and a World Fantasy Award. The novel received a Mythopoeic Award for Adult Literature.
W Literary and Historical Context
The Curse of Chalion is set in a carefully developed fictional world whose social system closely resembles that of medieval Europe and whose religious system is similar to that of ancient Greece. The geography of the Chalion world is roughly an upside-down version of the Iberian Peninsula, and the cultural terminology is a recognizable variant of Spanish. For example, the country of Chalion is called a “royacy,” the king is the “roya,” and so on. The plot revolves around an arranged marriage, much like the marriage between Isabella and Ferdinand that united Spain in the fifteenth century. As in that period of Spanish history, in the novel there are not only political intrigues but also religious divisions. In Chalion the Quintarian religion recognizes five gods, but in the rival land of Roknar, the Quadrene religion considers one of the five
to be a demon rather than a god. As a result of this difference, Chalion society is more permissive and inclusive than that of Roknar. The two powers have been at war for some time, and the situation is complicated by a civil war in the nearby kingdom of Ibra. Conventional factors, such as political intrigue and personal conflict, drive many of the problems besetting Chalion, but supernatural forces are also involved. In the Chalion world, magic does work, the gods are real, and, as it turns out, a secret curse is afflicting the royal family.
W Themes The major themes of The Curse of Chalion, which include sacrifice, redemption, and the relationship of fate and free will, derive mainly from the novel’s speculative theology. The Quintarian religion and its “heretical” Quadrene offshoot are reminiscent of Greek polytheism, featuring a hierarchy of priests and a profusion of rituals dedicated to one or another of the gods. The “holy family” (Father, Mother, Daughter, Son) has similarities to the Greek pantheon and to aspects of Christianity. Some aspects are also based on pagan religions and natural magic. For example, the gods are associated with seasons and elements, and they govern different aspects of daily life. The fifth deity in this system is Bastard, who was begotten by a demon on the Mother. In the Quintarian view, Bastard is the god of balance, who governs the difficult, the irregular, and the unseemly. In the Quadrene view, Bastard is a demon like his father, and Quadrene adherents regard as evil everything associated with Bastard. Like the Greek deities, these gods are a mixture of capriciousness and compassion, and their actions are unpredictable. In the Chalion world, however, they must obey certain rules, and they can act in human affairs only with the willing cooperation of a human being. Humans have the opportunity to choose their allegiances and the degree to which they become involved with the gods.
295 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Curse of Chalion
MAJOR CHARACTERS BETRIZ is Iselle’s companion, with whom Cazaril falls in love. DONDO DY JIRONAL is a march (marquis) of the powerful Jironal family. He and his father are scheming to take control of the government through an arranged marriage between Dondo and Iselle. ISELLE is the teenage royesse (princess) of Chalion. She matures and develops political skill while trying to avoid an arranged marriage. LUPE DY CAZARIL is a castillar (equivalent to a baron) of Chalion who was a respected military leader and scholar until he was betrayed by Dondo dy Jironal and sold into slavery. He escapes and returns to Chalion, where he becomes Iselle’s tutor and is swept into court intrigues. TEIDEZ is Iselle’s naive younger brother and as royse (prince) of Chalion is next in line to the throne. He is manipulated by the Jironals.
This power of choice is tested when Lupe dy Cazaril, the protagonist of The Curse of Chalion, must decide whether to risk his own soul in the pursuit of justice.
W Style Bujold uses two techniques to make the world of Chalion believable. The first is a somewhat formal style of writing that suggests a historical novel rather than a modern fantasy. The dialogue is natural and unstilted, however, and the descriptive passages are colorful without being flowery. The second technique is indirect development of the background. Information about the Chalion world is revealed through references in the narrative rather than through direct exposition, gradually building up a picture of the society through the characters, their reflections, and their experiences. Bujold develops the narrative environment methodically in the first half of the novel, which focuses on setting up the problem. The second half then takes a sharp turn, adding metaphysical layers to the action and intrigue already established.
A knight with armor and sword. In the story, Cazaril must undertake a difficult quest wrought with danger to save the kingdom of Chalion. Vladimir Nikulin/Shutterstock.com
296
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Curse of Chalion
The novel’s third-person viewpoint is controlled by the protagonist, but the other main characters contribute their perspectives through expressive dialogue. In addition, several of the minor characters are vividly drawn and in some cases turn out to be unexpectedly important to the story, enriching the plot development. Cazaril dominates the novel, not only through his observations and actions but through his personal journey. In the beginning of the story, he is depicted as a man wounded in body and spirit, seeking only a retreat into anonymity. As fate draws him back into the center of political intrigue, he must make a series of choices. By following his own principles at each turn, he finds the path to healing both for himself and for Chalion. Through this structured interconnection of the hero’s interior journey with the exterior action, Bujold effectively blends characterization and plot to create a satisfying outcome.
W Critical Reception The Curse of Chalion has drawn praise from most reviewers. Carol Reich, writing for Kliatt, calls the novel “an extremely well-crafted story,” noting that “Bujold excels at creating complex characters you care for, and at catching them up in terrific action/adventure stories laced with thoughtful ponderings on ethics and religion.” In a review for Booklist, Roland Green describes the novel as “nicely detailed and wittily accented,” while Jackie Cassada, writing in Library Journal, concludes that “compelling characters and richly detailed world building make [The Curse of Chalion] a strong addition to fantasy collections.” Almost all of the many online reviews of the novel are highly enthusiastic. A few critics, however, have found the novel too formulaic or too conservative. For example, writing for Emerald City, Cheryl Morgan complains that “The Curse of Chalion is hopelessly transparent and hardly ever does anything that might upset the delicate sensibilities of a brain-dead middle class readership.” Morgan’s opinion reflects the view that contemporary fantasy should be more experimental and intellectually challenging than The Curse of Chalion is. Paul Brink, on the other hand, sums up the novel’s mainstream appeal in School Library Journal, arguing that “a finely balanced mixture of adventure, swordplay, court intrigue, romance, magic, and religion makes this book a delightful read.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Brink, Paul. Rev. of The Curse of Chalion, by Lois McMaster Bujold. School Library Journal 47.10 (2001): 194. Print. Cassada, Jackie. Rev. of The Curse of Chalion, by Lois McMaster Bujold. Library Journal July 2001: 131. Print.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Lois McMaster Bujold was born in Columbus, Ohio, in 1949. Her father, Robert Charles McMaster, was an engineer famous for his pioneering work on nondestructive testing of materials. He was also a science fiction fan, passing on to his daughter the books and magazines he enjoyed. Bujold began writing at an early age. From 1968 to 1972, she studied English, photography, and biology at Ohio State University but did not graduate. In 1971 she married John Fredric Bujold, also a science fiction fan. Bujold worked as a pharmacy technician until she became a full-time mother. She finished her first novel in 1983 but did not find a publisher for it until 1986. Almost immediately she became a popular science fiction author, writing skillful space operas with memorable characters. She is best known for the Miles Vorkosigan series, which includes more than a dozen novels set in a complicated future reality and featuring a brilliant, disabled mercenary hero. Bujold has won four Hugo awards and two Nebulas. She lives in Minnesota.
Green, Roland. Rev. of The Curse of Chalion, by Lois McMaster Bujold. Booklist 1 May 2001: 1672. Print. Morgan, Cheryl. “The Curse of Brain Candy.” Rev. of The Curse of Chalion, by Lois McMaster Bujold. Emerald City 81 (2002). Web. 20 Oct. 2010. Reich, Carol. Rev. of The Curse of Chalion, by Lois McMaster Bujold. Kliatt Jan. 2005: 40. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
D’Ammassa, Dan. Rev. of The Curse of Chalion, by Lois McMaster Bujold. Science Fiction Chronicle May 2001: 40. Print. Offers a positive assessment of Bujold’s writing. Kelso, Sylvia. “Evolutions of the Fantasy Hero in Peter Jackson’s The Lord of the Rings and Lois McMaster Bujold’s The Curse of Chalion.” Paradoxa 20 (2006): 247-62. Print. Compares Lupe dy Cazaril with Aragorn (Lord of the Rings) in an examination of older fantasy heroes. ———. “The God in the Pentagram: Religion and Spirituality in Modern Fantasy.” Journal of the Fantastic in the Arts 18.1 (2007): 61+. Print. Discusses The Curse of Chalion in the context of contemporary trends in fantasy. Wagner, Thomas M. Rev. of The Curse of Chalion, by Lois McMaster Bujold. SFReviews.net. N.p., n.d. Web. 18 Oct. 2010. Brief, enthusiastic review that outlines key points of the novel.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
297
The Curse of Chalion
Edinburgh Castle, Scotland. In The Curse of Chalion, a betrayed nobleman sets out on a journey to find redemption and save the royal house of his native Chalion. godrick/Shutterstock.com
Wilde, Thursa. Rev. of The Curse of Chalion, by Lois McMaster Bujold. SFX Magazine Sept. 2002. Web. 18 Oct. 2010. Favorable review that provides a useful overview of the novel, focusing especially on its speculative theology.
———. “Mind Food: Writing Science Fiction.” Journal of Youth Services in Libraries 10.2 (1997): 157. Print. Bujold discusses her development as a writer and explains the six characteristics of fiction that she feels are vital in creating audience engagement.
Open Web Sources
———. Paladin of Souls. New York: EOS, 2003. Print. This Hugo winner is the second novel set in the Chalion world. A continuation of The Curse of Chalion, Paladin of Souls follows a pilgrimage undertaken by Iselle’s mother, Iste, who is cured of her curse-induced insanity in the first volume.
The author’s official Web site provides news, links, and reference materials, including maps of the Chalion world and a glossary of characters and terms. http:// www.dendarii.com/
Kelso, Sylvia. Three Observations and a Dialogue: Round and About SF. Seattle: Aqueduct, 2009. Print. This work includes a wide-ranging dialogue between Kelso and Bujold concerning contemporary science fiction.
Gale Resources
“Lois McMaster Bujold.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2008.
For Further Reading
Bujold, Lois M. The Hallowed Hunt: A Novel. New York: Eos, 2005. Print. Although set in the Chalion world, this novel departs completely from the previous story line to explore a different geographic area, a different type of culture, and a different set of theological and supernatural elements.
298
Reid, Robin A. Women in Science Fiction and Fantasy. Westport: Greenwood, 2009. Print. This encyclopedic volume contains essays by a variety of scholars and includes a profile of Bujold. Cynthia Giles
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Dancing to “Almendra” By Mayra Montero
W Introduction Reporter Joaquín Porrata, the protagonist of Mayra Montero’s Dancing to “Almendra,” would like to be on a crime beat, but his editor has him assigned to cover an animal’s death at the local zoo. Thanks to some whispered clues by a beleaguered zookeeper, as well as his own stubbornness, Joaquín uncovers a twisted connection between the story about the hippopotamus death that he is covering and the simultaneous death of a mob boss in New York City. Traversing Havana as he searches for links between the two crimes, Joaquín must deal with his strained family and his brother’s increasingly erratic behavior while also negotiating a strange love affair with a one-armed woman whose own past contains an association with the mob. Dancing to “Almendra” takes place in Havana, Cuba, in 1957, just two years before Fidel Castro’s revolutionary forces successfully overthrew the government, and the city itself is the most compelling character in the novel. Beautiful, wild, and wealthy, Havana seethes under the threat of the revolutionaries hiding in the hills, and it displays all the desperate joy and uninhibited love and betrayals of a society that knows its end is near. Mary Margaret Benson notes that the novel functions as “both social commentary and a wellconstructed mystery” yet the most compelling element of the novel is what Marcel Berlins describes as “a vivid portrait of a louche, exciting underworld that was soon to disappear.”
W Literary and Historical Context
Dancing to “Almendra” is set in Cuba in 1957, in the years preceding Fidel Castro’s successful overthrow of the government of Fulgencia Batista. The struggle against
the Batista government, known for its brutality and corruption, began with an uprising in 1953 in which Batista’s men captured Fidel Castro and his brother, Raúl. Batista, under external political pressure, released the brothers, and the revolutionary forces retreated for several years. The novel is, therefore, set in a time of political uncertainty that was characterized by decadence and money. The Mafia influences that Joaquín has been obsessed with since his childhood are an indication of the corruption of the Cuban government and its shaky economy.
W Themes The novel provides a historical portrayal of 1950s Cuba, a time and place not often used as a literary setting. It focuses on the turmoil and beauty of the years between Castro’s failed rebellion in 1953 and his successful takeover of the Batista government in 1959, a period filled with dancehalls, beautiful women, and sultry evenings. Joaquín is seduced by the lives of the rich and notorious, even while he investigates an international Mafia crime syndicate that deals in cavalier murder. The novel focuses on emotional as well as political secrets, and Joaquín’s journalistic task is complicated and often sidetracked by his personal life. The personal and political are, in Montero’s depiction of Havana, difficult to separate. As personal secrets proliferate—facts about Yolanda’s past, his brother’s secret political life, Lucy’s homosexuality—the connections between the characters multiply and maintaining trust either at the private or public level begins to seem impossible.
W Style Dancing to “Almendra,” which is divided between Joaquín’s investigations and his lover Yolanda’s memories, is difficult to categorize stylistically or generically. It contains characteristics of the hard-boiled 1940s crime
299 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Dancing to “Almendra”
MAJOR CHARACTERS UMBERTO ANASTASIA is the New York-based Mafia executioner who is murdered as the novel begins. Although he is a fictional character, he is based on real-life Mafioso Albert Anastasia. Dancing to “Almendra” was inspired by Anastasia’s murder at the Park Sheraton Hotel in New York City in 1957, an incident that Montero researched extensively in writing the novel. AURORA is the mother of Joaquín’s best friend and his first love interest. LUCY, Joaquín’s sister and ally, is shunned by her parents because of her homosexuality. Joaquín refers to her as “the great ambiguity that was Lucy.” MADRAZO is the managing editor of Prensa Libre, the paper that hires Joaquín to investigate the connection between the death of Anastasia and the dead hippopotamus. JOAQUÍN PORRATA is the twenty-two-year-old protagonist of Dancing to “Almendra.” A journalist in Havana in the 1950s, he is frustrated by the stories he is assigned to cover. A story about an escaped hippopotamus that is killed at the Havana zoo, however, turns out to be mysteriously related to the murder of Mafia executioner Umberto Anastasia in New York City on the same day. Porrata becomes obsessed with uncovering the truth behind this mysterious link, while at the same time dealing with his love for Yolanda and the secrets that emerge about his own tangled family relationships. SANTIAGO is Joaquín’s brother. Overwhelmingly social, he puts Joaquín in touch with Yolanda. After Santiago’s death, his family learns of his involvement with Fidel Castro’s revolutionary movement. YOLANDA, whose real name is Fantina, is a beautiful, onearmed circus performer with whom Porrata falls in love. Yolanda has a mysterious past filled with odd lovers that weighs on her and confuses Joaquín. The narrative is interspersed with passages in which she remembers her early life and childhood, her start with the circus, and the events that lead to her meeting Joaquín.
novel, the detective novel, the memoir, and magical realism. The novel is structured like a detective story as it follows the investigation into the death of a hippopotamus at the Havana Zoo. When one of the zookeepers discloses to Joaquín a connection between the animal and a dead mob boss, Joaquín begins to investigate it and seeks to untangle lies from the truth. Although Joaquín’s adventures are wild and often surreal, the narrative voice is that of a journalist. He establishes the facts and explains as he proceeds the interconnections he finds between events and persons. The slightly flat realist tone contrasts
300
Joaquín Porrata finds a connection between the death of a hippopotamus at a zoo and the assassination of Mafia kingpin Umberto Anastasia in Dancing to “Almendra”. ª Bettmann/Corbis
with the often terrifying events of the novel in the style of noir novelists such as Dashiel Hammett. A long-standing journalist, Montero effectively gives Joaquín the voice of a young newspaperman, capturing his desire for factual clarity, his wonder at a world of overwhelming decadence and fading beauty, and his growing recognition of the consequences of his actions. Several reviewers discuss magical, or magic, realism in relation to Dancing to “Almendra.” Magical realism, a term coined by the Caribbean writer Alejo Carpentier in the 1940s, refers to a style typically associated with Latin American writers in which fantastical events are narrated in a deadpan style. Montero’s style in the novel is not strictly magical realism, but it cultivates a similar tone by employing the manner and creed of a reporter against the nearly fantastical world of wealth and glory in Havana. Moreover, the aspects of the novel that tend towards the grotesque (Yolanda’s loss of an arm, the cast of circus performers, Lucy’s oddly expressed sexuality, a hippopotamus) are evocative of a carnivalesque world that is very close to magical realism. Yolanda’s memories, narrated in chapters interspersed within Joaquín’s story, are more lyrical and tend toward the nostalgic. Though her memories are far from TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Dancing to “Almendra”
happy, they seem to match the beautiful melancholy that Joaquín sees in her and that the reader sees in the last days of Cuba’s decadent 1950s.
W Critical Reception Dancing to “Almendra” received mostly positive coverage, though it was not reviewed widely. Reviewers agree that Montero’s book is engaging and imaginative and that its survey of prerevolutionary Havana and Cuban society is both unusual and important. Bill Ott, in Booklist, lauds the novel for “probing beneath the surface to expose the tangled emotions and complex allegiances within a society on the brink of destruction,” and the reviewer in Publishers Weekly similarly remarks, “the drama of a nation disintegrating in a crisis is made very personal.” Reviewers also concur that Montero’s book is well researched and that the historical content does not interfere with the imaginative content of the novel. As
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Mayra Montero was born in 1952 in Havana, Cuba, and spent part of her childhood in Puerto Rico. Montero’s father, the wellknown comedian and actor Manuel Montero, worked in both Cuba and Puerto Rico. She studied journalism in Puerto Rico and Mexico and worked as a foreign correspondent in Central America and the Caribbean region. Montero today lives in Puerto Rico and writes a weekly column called “Antes que llegue el lunes” (“Before Monday arrives”) for the Puerto Rican daily newspaper El Nuevo Día. Montero writes in Spanish. Her books are widely translated, and most of them have been translated into English by Edith Grossman. Her books include Twenty-three and A Turtle, The Braid of the Beautiful Moon (a finalist for the Herralde award), and The Messenger. Dancing to “Almendra” is her first novel set in the Cuba of her childhood.
Dancing to “Almendra” begins two years before rebel forces led by Fidel Castro overthrow the Batista government in Cuba. ª Lester Cole/Corbis TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
301
Dancing to “Almendra”
Publishers Weekly states, “Montero blends fact and fiction with narrative aplomb.” According to Laura Wilson for the Guardian, the wealth of content combined with Joaquín’s enthusiastic investigative spirit add to the “galloping pace” that makes Dancing to “Almendra” an “exuberant and riveting read.” More than one reviewer, however, found the wealth of detail, long list of characters, and energetic narrative to be confusing. As the reviewer for Kirkus Reviews comments, “there’s simply too much of everything.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Berlins, Marcel. Rev. of Dancing to “Almendra,” by Mayra Montero. Times [London]. Times Newspapers Ltd, 30 June 2007. Web. 22 Oct. 2010. Rev. of Dancing to “Almendra,” by Mayra Montero. Kirkus Reviews 74.23 (2006): 1193. Print. Rev. of Dancing to “Almendra,” by Mayra Montero. Publishers Weekly. 243.47 (2006): 30. Print. Montero, Mayra. Dancing to “Almendra”. Trans. Edith Grossman. New York: Farrar, 2007. Print. Ott, Bill. Rev. of Dancing to “Almendra,” by Mayra Montero. Booklist 1 Jan. 2007: 56. Print.
from the 1950s. http://cuba1952-1959.blogspot. com/2009/09/cuba-1950s-life-on-google-books. html Poet and critic Dana Gioia gives a brief historical account of magical realism (referred to here by Gioia as magic realism), followed by a detailed reading of its role in Gabriel García Márquez’s story “A Very Old Man with Enormous Wings.” http://www.danagioia.net/ essays/emarquez.htm This Web site, maintained by Dr. Antonio Rafael de la Cova, a professor at Indiana University at Bloomington, contains a wide selection of historical resources about the Cuban revolution. http://www. latinamericanstudies.org/cuban-revolution.htm For Further Reading
Chomsky, Aviva, Barry Carr, and Pamela Marie Smorkaloff, eds. The Cuba Reader: History, Culture, Politics. Durham: Duke UP, 1993. Print. This comprehensive sourcebook on Cuba ranges from the first descriptions of the island written by Christopher Columbus through the present today, including historical documents, images, fiction, and political writings.
Criticism and Reviews
English, T. J. Havana Nocturne: How the Mob Owned Cuba and Then Lost It to the Revolution. New York: William Morrow, 2007. Print. English’s book gives an engaging, strongly narrative history of the commercial interests that the American Mafia held in 1950s Cuba and how Castro’s revolution brought the mob’s involvement in Cuba to an end.
Lewis, Jim. “Havana Nights.” Rev. of Dancing to “Almendra,” by Mayra Montero. New York Times Book Review 18 Feb. 2007. Print. A long review in which the author expresses delight in the work.
García Márquez, Gabriel. One Hundred Years of Solitude. Trans. Gregory Rabassa. New York: Harper, 1970. Print. This complicated genealogical novel is one of the seminal examples of magical realism.
Omang, Joanne. “Havana Noir.” Rev. of Dancing to “Almendra,” by Mayra Montero. Washington Post 13 May 2007. Print. A review that lauds Montero for her gritty, beautiful portrait of Havana.
Greene, Graham. Our Man in Havana. New York: Viking, 1958. Print. Greene’s novel, set in Havana during the Batista regime, depicts a corrupt world of British spies. In 1959 it was made into a movie starring Alec Guinness.
Wilson, Laura. “Crime: Roundup of Recent Releases.” Rev. of Dancing to “Almendra,” by Mayra Montero. Guardian [London] 27 June 2007. Print. Additional Resources
Wyman, Anna Julia. Rev. of Dancing to “Almendra,” by Mayra Montero. San Francisco Gate 29 Jan. 2007. Print. A positive review that attempts to catalog the many characters, events, ideas and themes in the novel. Gale Resources
“Mayra Montero.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2007. Literature Resource Center. Web. 18 Oct. 2010. Open Web Sources
This Web site contains a collection of links to Life magazine covers and articles about Cuba that date
302
Zamora, Lois Parkinson, and Wendy B. Faris, eds. Magical Realism: Theory, History, Community. Durham: Duke UP, 1995. Print. Zamora and Faris’s collection of documents and articles about magical realism extend beyond Latin American literature, attempting to place the style in a global context. They include seminal manifests from Alejo Carpentier and Gabriel García Márquez and more recent critical accounts that place magical realism within the context of globalization and postcolonial studies. Jenny Ludwig
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Dark Palace By Frank Moorhouse
W Introduction
W Literary and Historical
Set largely in 1930s Geneva, Dark Palace (2000) follows the career of Edith Campbell Berry, an Australian officer of the League of Nations. The League, convened in 1920 in the aftermath of World War I, was the first attempt to establish a world peacekeeping body. The character of Edith was originally introduced in Frank Moorhouse’s first novel, Grand Days (1993), which depicts the institutional history of the League. In Dark Palace, the companion book, Edith’s personal and professional experiences are intimately connected to the ill-fated outcomes of the international body. Dark Palace opens in 1931 as Edith celebrates a renewed five-year contract with the League. She is the private secretary to Swiss Under-Secretary-General Bartou. Despite the fact that her marriage to British journalist Robert Dole is failing, she strives to be an efficient employee and a polished cosmopolitan married woman. Through her service to the League, Edith pursues her ambition to become a new breed of international citizen, one deeply committed to the League’s goals of ensuring peace and disarmament. Edith’s professional challenges are played out against the vast backdrop of post-World War I diplomacy: the novel depicts the League’s intricate diplomatic responses to, among other crises, the United States’ flirtation with membership, Italy’s invasion of Ethiopia, and the Nazis’ obvious and threatening rise to power. In her work Edith’s actions and thoughts show her grappling with political, social, and personal realities. Constraints—and failure—plague both Edith and the League at all levels. At the close of the story in 1946, the League has collapsed and the United Nations is set to take its place.
The 1919 Treaty of Versailles, one of several settlements between Germany and the Allied powers at the end of World War I, gave birth to the League of Nations. Germany signed the treaty under protest, and despite President Woodrow Wilson’s support, the U.S. Congress refused to ratify it, weakening the League’s powers from the outset. The body’s main goal was to prevent another war through disarmament, arbitration of international disputes, and the implementation of social programs to foster the participating nations’ independence and strength. This shift toward peace, however, was inconsistent with the preceding century’s modus operandi, and the rubble and disillusionment that World War I left in its wake added to the organization’s appearance of naiveté. The perception of weakness created an undercurrent to the concrete challenges the League faced: encroaching Italian Fascism, German Nazism, U.S. isolationism, and British appeasement. In Grand Days Frank Moorhouse depicted the institutional history of the League of Nations. Dark Palace continues the story, tracing the League’s decline and eventual eclipse by the establishment of the United Nations. Edith embodies the ideals of the League. According to John Scheckter in World Literature Today, “She asserts her belief that self-regulation of appetites, adherence to declared principles, and alliance of selfinterest with the greater good will lead to enlightened resolution of personal and public issues.” What the League attempts in international relations, Edith tests in her personal life. The irony is that the reading audience knows that the League ultimately fails, and tension is created in the suggestion that Edith will, too. Few novels have focused on the historical involvement of women in the League. Several well-known women served as delegates to League assemblies and
Context
303 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Dark Palace
MAJOR CHARACTERS ALVA is Edith’s best friend from her university days. When Edith visits her former home, she renews her connection with Alva, and Edith realizes that many of her old friends remain parochial in habit and thinking. The meeting both confirms and isolates Edith in her role as an international citizen. EDITH CAMPBELL BERRY, the protagonist of both Grand Days and Dark Palace, is originally from rural southeast Australia. An officer of the League of Nations, she is deeply dedicated to its work of ensuring peace in the years after the Great War (World War I). Her personal and professional accomplishments and challenges are inextricably intertwined. In the face of disappointments on both fronts, she struggles with her idealism and eventually matures. ROBERT DOLE, a British journalist, is Edith’s brutish husband. As the novel opens, Edith and Robert’s marriage has failed. JOHN LATHAM is Edith’s mentor. Latham is a historical figure. A lawyer and politician, he led the Australian delegation to the League of Nations General Assembly in Geneva in 1926. Latham was eventually named chief justice to the High Court in 1935. SCRAPER is one of Edith’s university pals. She runs into him during a trip to Australia to visit her dying father. Scraper was horribly disfigured by a bomb in World War I, and in a scene of both pathos and intimacy, Edith overcomes her repulsion and offers him sexual pleasures. AMBROSE WESTWOOD is Edith’s transvestite bisexual lover, first introduced in Grand Days. In the aftermath of her failed marriage, Edith rekindles her ties with Ambrose. He is charming, intelligent, and a master of good taste with a sardonic sense of humor.
pressured the body on behalf of their causes. Within the organization, however, women were primarily offered lower-status appointments than men and had less significant responsibility. Moorhouse places Edith Campbell Berry in a position higher than any historical woman actually achieved.
W Themes In 1931, when Dark Palace begins, the League of Nations is already on the road to failure. International idealism has little leverage against misbehaving nations such as Italy, Japan, and Germany. The body has no military to enforce its decisions, and the imposition of economic sanctions is generally ineffective. Edith’s idealism and hope—generalized in the novel to everyone working for the League, from the national leaders on down—shows the human element tied to the
304
organization’s decline. According to Peter Porter in the Guardian, “The League, as well as the people caught up in it, demonstrate for Moorhouse that human frailty is independent of country of origin.” Although Edith commands center stage in the novel, Moorhouse creates a parallel between the fate of the League and the protagonist’s personal life. The author builds up his readers’ desire that the League should succeed. The dramatic presentation of the rise of Nazism and the fall of Paris at the end of the 1930s, however, leads to the loss of all hope of peace and confirms the powerlessness of international law. Edith’s life, too, is presented in terms of idealism and morality. The failure of the League does not quite allow readers to infer that Edith’s optimism was entirely misplaced, only supremely challenged. In this arena Moorhouse inverts traditional assumptions of what is good and bad. Edith’s wellintentioned, conventional marriage to Robert has failed, and she resumes a former relationship with Ambrose, a cross-dressing bisexual who offers her greater satisfaction. By the close of the novel, Edith has decided to take another chance at love, her hope tempered by the hard realities she has experienced.
W Style Before the publication of Grand Days, Frank Moorhouse was primarily known as a short story writer. In A Reference Guide to Short Fiction, Bruce Bennett contends that as a stylist Moorhouse “has a special interest in the hints and clues that short fiction can provide on the changing myths of region or nation.” In his novels the author both solidifies and expands these ideas, shifting his ground to the myths of nation and world. Edith represents Australia in the changing international world order. Perceived as a lesser colonial power, Australia is positioned in the novel to be a significant actor in its own national life, and Edith has the same self-determining power in her professional position with the League. Both Grand Days and Dark Palace are historical novels. Moorhouse’s meticulous research and deft imagination are palpable, revealing a skill in blending actual incidents and people with those he creates. Dark Palace is also a romance. Edith’s continued affair with Ambrose, including the presentation of their sexual conduct, is rendered with sympathy yet without illusions. Moorhouse’s love story is rich in detail and psychological insight. The third-person narration of Dark Palace is limited to Edith’s point of view, following her every action and thought, including her dialogues with herself. In this way Moorhouse creates a fully realized, compelling heroine. Her self-awareness is effectively juxtaposed with the international action, and both are presented with wit and wordplay. Writing in the Australian, Brian Kiernan notes that the novel is “driven by dialogue . . . TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Dark Palace
intricately and subtly structured, remaining eminently readable . . . and carried off so impressively.”
W Critical Reception Upon its publication Dark Palace received mainly positive reviews. In the Sunday Telegraph Julia Flynn remarks that the novel is “somber in tone, yet not cynical . . . spacious and leisurely, filled with long, chatty conversations” and that Moorhouse “handles diffuse material with a sure hand.” Quadrant’s P. P. McGuinness lauds the book as “one of the finest historical novels of [Australian] literature which, unlike the narrow ‘Australian’ point of view of so much of our literature, is able to place itself and Australia confidently in a world context.” Other reactions to the novel were more mixed or even unenthusiastic. Francis Henry King of the Daily Telegraph calls Moorhouse’s prose style—which employs short sentences and paragraphs—“jerk[y]” and “lurching.” King commends the story, however, and praises Moorhouse’s Edith as a “creation of whom any novelist would be proud.” Writing in the Weekend Australian, Peter Craven complains that “everything is done with a kind of cluttered slow-motion fluffiness.” He suggests
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Frank Moorhouse was born on December 21, 1938, in Nowra, New South Wales, Australia. He began his writing career as a newspaper journalist: in 1956 he served as a cadet reporter for the Sydney Daily Telegraph, and in 1959 he moved to the Wagga Wagga Advertiser in New South Wales. He continued at various papers throughout the 1960s. In the 1970s he became a full-time writer, focusing on short fiction. Moorhouse’s early reputation rested on several story collections, including The Americans, Baby (1972) and The Electrical Experience (1974). His collection Forty-Seventeen (1988) won the Australian Literature Society Gold Medal and the Age Book of the Year Award. In a dramatic public relations fumble, after Grand Days was presented with the Miles Franklin Award, the prize was withdrawn because the novel was not sufficiently “Australian.” Moorhouse lives in Sydney.
that the prose is “best read in rapid gulps, like an airport novel. If it is read slowly, for the grain of voice, the cadence and the syntax, what becomes apparent is a level of infelicity, highlighting the book’s crudeness of effect.”
The League of Nations building in Geneva, Switzerland. Dark Palace is a fictional account of the failure of the League of Nations. ª Bettmann/ Corbis
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
305
Dark Palace
In the story, Edith Campbell Berry—a young Australian officer in the League of Nations—witnesses the ongoing problems and eventual failure of the peacekeeping organization. ª Hulton-Deutsch Collection/Corbis
Alan Lawson, in Australian Writers, 1950-1975, and Kiernan both remark on the Jamesian nature of Dark Palace. Lawson claims that Moorhouse “writes ‘about’ Australia in the way that Henry James wrote ‘about’ America,” by extricating his characters from their natural environments so that their national characteristics can be played out and examined against a European backdrop. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Bennett, Bruce. “Moorhouse, Frank.” Reference Guide to Short Fiction. Ed. Thomas Riggs. 2nd ed. Detroit: St. James, 1999. 438-39. Gale Virtual Reference Library. Web. 28 Nov. 2010. Craven, Peter. “Burdened by History.” Weekend Australian [Sydney] 2 Dec. 2000: R10. InfoTrac Newsstand. Web. 23 Nov. 2010. Flynn, Julia. “Peacenik in Our Time: Julia Flynn Praises an Elegant Evocation of the Inter-War Years.” Rev.
306
of Dark Palace, by Frank Moorhouse. Sunday Telegraph [London] 3 Feb. 2002: n. pag. Web. 23 Nov. 2010. Kiernan, Brian. “Libertarian Rules.” Rev. of Dark Palace, by Frank Moorhouse. Australian [Sydney] 14 Feb. 2001: B16. Academic OneFile. Web. 23 Nov. 2010. King, Francis Henry. “The World Is Not Enough; Francis King Is Irked and Enthralled by a Saga about the League of Nations.” Rev. of Dark Palace, by Frank Moorhouse. Daily Telegraph [London] 26 Jan. 2002. InfoTrac Newsstand. Web. 23 Nov. 2010. Lawson, Alan. “Frank Moorhouse.” Australian Writers, 1950-1975. Ed. Selina Samuels. Detroit: Gale, 2004. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 289. Literature Resource Center. Web. 23 Nov. 2010. McGuinness, P. P. Rev. of Dark Palace, by Frank Moorhouse. Quadrant Nov. 2000: 83. Literature Resource Center. Web. 23 Nov. 2010. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Dark Palace
Porter, Peter. “How to Be Good: Peter Porter Admires a Saga of Idealism under Threat from History and Love under Threat from Convention.” Rev. of Dark Palace, by Frank Moorhouse. Guardian [London]. Guardian News and Media, 9 Mar. 2002: 10. Web. 23 Nov. 2010. Scheckter, John. Review of Grand Days, by Frank Moorhouse. World Literature Today 69.1 (1995): 218(1). Educator’s Reference Complete. Web. 22 Nov. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Bliss, Carolyn. Rev. of Dark Palace, by Frank Moorhouse. World Literature Today 77.1 (2003): 91(2) Educator’s Reference Complete. Web. 22 Nov. 2010. This largely positive review admires the novel’s heroine and calls Moorhouse “an old-school social realist with a postmodern appreciation of the kinky.” Howe, Renate. “Oral Sex and the League of Nations: The Genre of Faction in Grand Days and Dark Palace.” Journal of Australian Studies 71 (2001): 101+. Student Resource Center-College Edition Expanded. Web. 23 Nov. 2010. Howe argues that the increasing professionalism of fiction writers in the postmodern era presents a challenge to historians. Dark Palace, she says, provides the opportunity to examine the “difference between fiction and fact, between what is imagined and what is real.” Hurley, Michelle. “Grand National.” Rev. of Dark Palace, by Frank Moorhouse. Daily Telegraph [Surry Hills] 2 Dec. 2000: G11. InfoTrac Newsstand. Web. 28 Nov. 2010. In her eclectic review of the novel, Hurley quotes liberally from a discussion with Moorhouse about his feelings regarding the League of Nations, his protagonist Edith Campbell Berry, and the years he spent traveling and researching in preparation to write Dark Palace and Grand Days. Turner, Geoff. “Past Master.” Rev. of Dark Palace, by Frank Moorhouse. Sunday Mail [Brisbane] 3 Dec. 2000: 30. InfoTrac Newsstand. Web. 23 Nov. 2010. Turner touts Edith’s strengths and suggests that reading Grand Days and Dark Palace in succession will double the reader’s pleasure. Walker, Nicola. “A Brilliant Career.” Rev. of Dark Palace, by Frank Moorhouse. Literary Review 45.1 (2001): 181+. General OneFile. Web. 23 Nov. 2010. This review of Dark Palace highlights the protagonist’s professional and personal relationship dynamics. Gale Resources
“Frank Moorhouse.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2002. Literature Resource Center. Web. 23 Nov. 2010.
Detroit: St. James, 2001. 722-23. Gale Virtual Reference Library. Web. 28 Nov. 2010. Open Web Sources
The United Nations’ League of Nations Archives offers links to research resources, photo archives, a time line, and a selected bibliography of scholarship on the League of Nations and its history. http://www. indiana.edu/~league/index.htm The Australian Broadcasting Corporation’s Radio National Web site presents a talk Frank Moorhouse gave at the National Library of Australia in 2005. Moorhouse reflects on how writers use research material to invent fictional worlds or explore others’ lives. The library’s rich archives, he explains, fueled his imagination as he prepared to write Grand Days and Dark Palace. http://www.abc.net.au/rn/arts/bwriting/ stories/s1393994.htm The online edition of the Australian National University’s Australian Dictionary of Biography provides career and personal biographical information about Sir John Greig Latham (1877-1964). Latham led the Australian delegation to the League of Nations General Assembly in 1926 and appears in the novel as Edith’s mentor. http://adbonline.anu.edu.au/biogs/ A100002b.htm For Further Reading
Coltheart, Lenore. Laughing at Boundaries: The Idea of Edith Campbell Berry. Ed. David Lowe. London: Sir Robert Menzies Centre for Australian Studies, U of London, 1994. Web. 3 Dec. 2010. Working Papers in Australian Studies 99. Coltheart examines the role of women internationalists involved in the League of Nations and places Edith Campbell Berry in this setting. Duggan, Stephen Pierce, ed. The League of Nations: The Principle and the Practice. Ithaca: Cornell U Library, 2009. Print. Originally published in 1918, this volume describes the workings of the League of Nations at its inception. Knock, Thomas J. To End All Wars: Woodrow Wilson and the Quest for a New World Order. Princeton UP, 1995. Print. Knock traces President Woodrow Wilson’s concept of the League of Nations as it evolved, examining it within the context of U.S. neutrality during the first two years of World War I. Moorhouse, Frank. Grand Days. New York: Pantheon, 1993. Print. The precursor to Dark Palace is set in the 1920s and introduces a younger Edith Campbell Berry to readers. Marta Lauritsen
Frost, Lucy. “Moorhouse, Frank.” Contemporary Novelists. Ed. Neil Schlager and Josh Lauer. 7th ed. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
307
The Day We Had Hitler Home By Rodney Hall
W Introduction The Day We Had Hitler Home (2000), by the Australian novelist and poet Rodney Hall, takes as its basis a fictional interlude in the life of its infamous title character. Just after the end of World War I, the future dictator shows up among a group of returning veterans in the remote Australian town of Yandilli. Despite his obvious personal defects, Hitler captures the attention of the young Audrey McNeil, the book’s protagonist, who eventually pursues him all the way back to Munich, Germany. There she dabbles in the artistic high life of interwar Germany before ultimately encountering the horrifying truth of what Hitler represents and of who she, in her acquiescence to the distorted morality of Nazism, has become. The book constitutes a seventh installment in a series that explores the history of Australia’s colonization through metaphorical and sometimes fantastic tales. Short-listed for the Miles Franklin Award in 2001, it won an Australian Literature Society Gold Medal that year. Though some reviewers have faulted the author for taking an approach that leaves readers little room to judge the story and characters for themselves, many others have lauded what Katharine England in the Advertiser calls “an admirable feat of creative erudition.”
W Literary and Historical Context
Throughout 1919, the year in which the story begins, soldiers made their way home from the battlefields of World War I (1914-1918). These veterans included not only the Australians and others on the victorious Allied side but also the defeated forces of Germany and the nations aligned with it. Among these was a thirty-year-old enlisted man named Adolf Hitler.
Little about Hitler’s biography up to that point suggested that he would one day become one of history’s most diabolically influential figures. A frustrated artist, he had been a vagabond before the German declaration of war in August 1914 presented him with an opportunity for glory in battle. He excelled as a soldier fighting on the Western Front in France, but a poison gas attack left him hospitalized, his face blistered and his eyes bandaged. When a chaplain delivered the news of Germany’s surrender on November 11, 1918, Hitler wept bitterly. He would later say that in this moment he realized that his life’s mission was to make Germany a great power. Hitler never traveled outside of Europe, let alone to Australia, but The Day We Had Hitler Home depicts him arriving in the remote Australian village of Yandilli among a boatload of returning soldiers. In reality he left the German army in 1919 to take a job in Munich as a police spy investigating radical groups. Among these was a small organization called the National Socialist German Workers Party—“Nazi” for short. Attracted by the Nazis’ brutal power tactics, Hitler soon quit his job to devote himself full time to the party. He had found the means of fulfilling his “mission,” which in time would bring about untold horrors that claimed millions of lives.
W Themes The central thematic concern of The Day We Had Hitler Home is the concept of “otherness”—that is, the recognition of differences between one’s own existence and the existence of others. In this novel, as in earlier works by Hall, Australia is depicted as the ultimate physical and geographical “other” to the rest of humanity, which views it literally from the opposite side of the planet. Likewise, the Australian characters gaze outward to the world beyond their shores and see things from a reversed viewpoint.
308 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Day We Had Hitler Home
MAJOR CHARACTERS BELLO is an actor of Senegalese origin who becomes Audrey’s lover in Germany. His murder by the Nazis and Audrey’s realization that she is carrying his baby force her to abandon both Germany and her fascination with Hitler and Nazism. ETTY is an Aborigine who works for Sybil, Audrey’s older sister. As Audrey matures, she comes to regard Sybil’s abuse of Etty, and by extension the white Australians’ mistreatment of the Aborigines, as a crime not unlike the one Hitler seeks to perpetrate against the Jews. ADOLF HITLER is the object of Audrey’s fascination. He captivates her when he appears in her hometown of Yandilli among a group of Australian veterans returning from World War I. (This premise is entirely fictional: in reality Hitler never left Europe.) He travels with Immanuel to the former German colony of Papua New Guinea and thence to Germany, where Audrey later goes in search of the future dictator. AUDREY MCNEIL is the book’s protagonist. Eighteen years of age when the story begins, she is living with her sister, Sybil, and Sybil’s husband, Immanuel. Audrey resists Immanuel’s lecherous designs on her. When Hitler shows up in her remote hometown of Yandilli, she is captivated by him and ultimately travels to Germany on the pretext of returning a journal that supposedly belongs to him. Photo of Rodney Hall, author of the novel The Day We Had Hitler Home. Gaye Gerard/Getty Images
Audrey, who becomes fascinated with Hitler and ultimately follows him to Munich, explores further meanings of otherness. Her journey places her amid the poisonous atmosphere of Nazism, which has its own notion of the “other”: Jews, communists, and anyone else perceived as a threat. Although Audrey at first embraces Nazism, in time her exposure to life on the far side of the planet gives her a new perspective on the lives of her fellow human beings. Earlier Audrey had ignored her sister Sybil’s mistreatment of her servant Etty, an Aborigine whose people had lived in Australia long before the arrival of whites. As the novel progresses, however, Audrey’s view changes completely: “I accept something I never understood until today. That this land, the entire continent, once belonged to Etty’s people . . . living where they have belonged since before the pyramids were built. Imagine that: fugitives who belong.” She goes on to recognize that whereas she had viewed the Aborigines as the ones to be observed from the standards of Western society, she now realizes that “We are observed” by the Aborigines.
DILYS MCNEIL is Audrey’s mother, who, Audrey has been told, abandoned her to be raised by Sybil. IMMANUEL MOLOCH is Sybil’s rakish husband, an entrepreneur and adventurer who spies on Audrey and attempts to coax her into bed. SYBIL MCNEIL MOLOCH is Audrey’s sister, seventeen years her senior. Childish and petulant, she abuses her Aboriginal servant Etty and tries to ignore her husband’s philandering. When Hitler appears near the beginning of the book, she mistakes him for her German friend Dieter Leppert. OTTOLINE is Audrey’s child by Bello. The protagonist’s relationship with her mixed-race offspring serves as a benchmark of her increased understanding, both of herself and of the larger political events taking place around her.
W Style The Day We Had Hitler Home is a highly stylized book, though not so much in the writing as in the way it is presented. Consistent with the theme of opposition or otherness, the novel—in the view of Andrew Riemer, a critic for the Sydney Morning Herald—is “constructed in the manner of a palindrome,” or a word (such as radar) that reads the same backward and forward. “The turning
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
309
The Day We Had Hitler Home
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Rodney Hall was born in England in 1935 and later immigrated with his family to his mother’s native Australia. He worked as a freelance scriptwriter and actor during the 1950s and 1960s and earned a BA from the University of Queensland in 1971. Beginning with a book of verse in 1962, Hall has published more than a dozen volumes of poetry and nearly as many novels. Most notable among the latter are the six books that comprise the trilogies A Dream More Luminous than Love (1988-1993) and The Island in the Mind (1996), in which Hall employs imaginative literary motifs in an exploration of Australian history. He and his wife, Maureen Elizabeth MacPhail, have three children.
point,” Riemer explains, “is clearly identified by a page containing no more than these words: ‘so the tale hinges to look in on itself, the two equal leaves of a mirror’. Until that turning point, and for a good many pages beyond, Hall’s writing . . . allows the reader to enter into a troubling complicity with Audrey’s infatuation with Herr Hitler and her growing admiration for his ideals.” Beyond that page, Audrey’s attitude toward the “other” gradually reverses itself. Audrey narrates the story in a series of flashbacks and, true to her adopted profession of filmmaker, begins each chapter with an outline of how she would have shot the scene that follows. Though this method “might strike one immediately as lazy writing,” Stephen Corby comments in the Daily Telegraph, “it is in fact extremely effective. Hitler may be a central character, ducking and weaving through the text, but this is very much Audrey’s story.” In fact, the title character disappears from the foreground of the narrative early in the book, when, soon after his arrival in Yandilli, Audrey’s brother-in-law spirits Hitler away to the former German colony of Papua New Guinea. Thenceforth the improbable premise of the book fades away, and the Hitler of the narrative gradually blends with the one who actually existed. In Munich, where Hitler is by now emerging as a powerful leader, Audrey glimpses him from afar and encounters him directly only in a single, anticlimactic meeting. For the most part, however, he remains more a figment of Audrey’s imagination than a genuine character in the novel.
W Critical Reception The critical response to the novel has been mixed. Some commentators have praised Hall’s achievement in tying the narrative to the larger thematic landscape of the two
310
preceding trilogies. Others, however, have faulted the author for a didactic, predictable approach both to the title character and to the story as a whole. In raising these objections, such reviewers are certainly not defending a mass murderer or even expressing reservations concerning the novel’s implausibility; rather, they question whether a character as farcically unappealing as the one in Hall’s book could really have wooed a nation of millions to commit crimes on a massive scale. Joanna Griffiths, writing in the Guardian, suggests that “Hitler . . . behaves as if he is Charlie Chaplin just dropped in from [the comedy] The Great Dictator: he stuffs himself with cream cakes, falls over, grunts and sneers and is highly sensitive about his moustache.” Quoting a scene in which Hitler attempts to molest Audrey (“lips slobbered along my jaw. . . . Terrified, I smelt wrecked things on his breath.”), Corby asks, “Was Hitler such a cad? We don’t know, but Hall knows we suspect he would have been.” Riemer criticizes the plot, commenting that “absurdity caps absurdity in a manner that would seem appropriate to a Mel Brooks farce, perhaps, but not to the work of an accomplished poet and novelist.” Writing in the Scotsman, Michael Faber observes that “Hall is so worried we won’t ask ourselves the right questions that he relentlessly feeds them to us.” Nevertheless, Faber also describes The Day We Had Hitler Home as “a sincere and generous-spirited book, commendably ambitious and adventuresome,” and Riemer judges it “quirky and almost consistently fascinating.” In the view of the Advertiser’s Katharine England, “Rodney Hall has filled a vast canvas with brilliant invention and bold surmise,” while Corby concludes that Hall’s “latest novel offers language to languor in. One turns some phrases over and over. It’s almost a pleasure to have Hitler home.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Bradley, James. “The Lost Island.” Rev. of The Day We Had Hitler Home, by Rodney Hall. Australian 11 Oct. 2000: B5. Web. 15 Oct. 2010. Corby, Stephen. “Unleashing a Monster in Print.” Rev. of The Day We Had Hitler Home, by Rodney Hall. Daily Telegraph [Sydney]. News Limited, 25 Nov. 2000: G10. Web. 15 Oct. 2010. England, Katharine. “Vast, Brilliant Canvas.” Rev. of The Day We Had Hitler Home, by Rodney Hall. Advertiser [Adelaide]. Advertiser Newspapers Ltd, 11 Nov. 2000: M23. Web. 15 Oct. 2010. Faber, Michael. “Fumblings with the Fuehrer.” Rev. of The Day We Had Hitler Home, by Rodney Hall. Scotsman. Johnston Press Digital Publishing, 21 Apr. 2001: 7. Web. 15 Oct. 2010. Griffiths, Joanna. “G’day, Adolf, Fancy a Tinny?” Rev. of The Day We Had Hitler Home, by Rodney Hall. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Day We Had Hitler Home
Guardian [London]. Guardian News and Media Ltd, 29 Apr. 2001. Web. 15 Oct. 2010. Hall, Rodney. The Day We Had Hitler Home. Sydney: Picador, 2000. Print. Riemer, Andrew. “A World off Its Hinges.” Rev. of The Day We Had Hitler Home, by Rodney Hall. Sydney Morning Herald. Fairfax Media, 28 Oct. 2000: 3. Web. 15 Oct. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Bennett, Vanora. “Ordinary Folk Who Helped Hitler to the Top.” Rev. of The Day We Had Hitler Home, by Rodney Hall, and The Right Hand of Sleep, by John Wray. Times [London]. Times Newspapers Ltd, 11 Apr. 2001. Web. 15 Oct. 2010. Compares The Day We Had Hitler Home and John Wray’s The Right Hand of Sleep, which is likewise set against the backdrop of events in central Europe during the interwar period. Bennie, Angela. “Unchained Melody.” Sydney Morning Herald. Fairfax Media, 3 Feb. 2007: 30. Web. 15 Oct. 2010. Interview with Hall that discusses The Day We Had Hitler Home in the context of his two trilogies and the later novel Love without Hope (2007). Brown, Phil. “Nazi Business.” Brisbane News 1 Nov. 2000. Web. 15 Oct. 2010. Profile of Hall focusing on the personal experiences that influenced the writing of The Day We Had Hitler Home. Crawford, Stuart. “Flight of Fancy in Mid-Air Crash.” Rev. of The Day We Had Hitler Home, by Rodney Hall. Herald [Glasgow]. Herald & Times Group, 28 Apr. 2001: 12. Web. 15 Oct. 2010. Negative review that faults the novel for its improbable plot and its “simplistic and clumsy” portrayal of Hitler. Dempsey, Dianne. “Carrying the Can.” Rev. of The Day We Had Hitler Home, by Rodney Hall. Courier-Mail [Brisbane]. Queensland Newspapers, 21 Oct. 2000: M9. Web. 15 Oct. 2010. Positive review that notes Hall’s condemnation of Australian atrocities against the Aborigines. Horspool, David. “Today New South Wales, Tomorrow the World.” Rev. of The Day We Had Hitler Home, by Rodney Hall. Daily Telegraph [London] 24 Mar. 2001: 5. Print. Favorable review citing other novels about Hitler, including Young Adolf by Beryl Bainbridge and The Portage to San Cristobal of A. H. by George Steiner. Meek, James. “Nuremberg Rally, Invasion of Poland, Dunkirk . . . ” Rev. of The Day We Had Hitler Home, by Rodney Hall, and other works. London Review of Books 6 Nov. 2001: 28-29. Print. Comparative review of nine novels, among them The Day We Had Hitler
Home, involving World War II and the events leading up to it. Sharkey, Michael. “The Sound and the Fuhrer.” Rev. of The Day We Had Hitler Home, by Rodney Hall. Weekend Australian 21 Oct. 2000: R15. Positive review that cites the popularity of Hall’s work in both Australia and Germany. Sullivan, Jane. “Balancing the Monstrous and the Banal.” Age [Melbourne] 28 Apr. 2007: 30. Print. Discussion of The Day We Had Hitler Home in the context of other novels about Hitler, including Norman Mailer’s The Castle in the Forest. Taylor, D. J. “Echoes of War.” Guardian [London]. Guardian News and Media Ltd, 21 Apr. 2001. Web. 15 Oct. 2010. Overview of recent fiction and nonfiction works involving military history, among them The Day We Had Hitler Home. Vile, John. “Tyrant Who Went the Distance.” Rev. of The Day We Had Hitler Home, by Rodney Hall. Hobart Mercury 16 Sept. 2000: 50. Print. Mixed review that questions whether Hall successfully presents plausible reasons why Germans would have rallied to Hitler’s cause. Gale Resources
“Rodney Hall.” Contemporary Authors, New Revision Series. Vol. 69. Detroit: Gale Research, 1999. Literature Resource Center. Web. 15 October 2010. “Rodney Hall.” Contemporary Literary Criticism. Vol. 51. Detroit: Gale Research, 1989. Literature Resource Center. Web. 15 Oct. 2010. “Rodney Hall.” Contemporary Novelists. Ed. Neil Schlager and Josh Lauer. 7th ed. Detroit: St. James, 2001. Literature Resource Center. Web. 15 Oct. 2010. “Rodney Hall.” Contemporary Poets. Ed. Thomas Riggs. 7th ed. Detroit: St. James, 2001. Literature Resource Center. Web. 15 Oct. 2010. “Rodney Hall.” Dictionary of Literary Biography. Ed. Selina Samuels. Vol. 289: Australian Writers, 19501975. Detroit: Gale Group, 2004. Literature Resource Center. Web. 15 Oct. 2010. Open Web Sources
A doctoral thesis, The Grotesque Poetics of Rodney Hall’s Dream Trilogies (2000) by Greg Ratcliffe of the University of Wollongong, Australia, is available on the Research Online page of the university’s Web site. http://ro.uow.edu.au/theses/845 The Web site of the Australian Broadcasting Corporation includes a recording and a transcript of Hall’s Alfred Deakin lecture, “Being Shaped by the Stories We Choose from Our History.” http://www.abc.net. au/rn/deakin/content/session_4.html
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
311
The Day We Had Hitler Home
An interview with Hall appears on the Booktopia Blog Web site. http://blog.booktopia.com.au/2010/04/ 27/feature-rodney-hall-author-of-popeye-nevertold-you-answers-ten-terrifying-questions/ A guide to the papers of Rodney Hall, held by the National Library of Australia, is available on the library’s Web site. http://nla.gov.au/nla.ms-ms4834 On its Web site, the Australian newspaper the Age features an overview of the Miles Franklin Award short-list writers and books, including Hall and The Day We Had Hitler Home. http://www.theage.com. au/news/books/the-prize-writers/2008/06/12/ 1212863841291.html?page=fullpage For Further Reading
Bainbridge, Beryl. Young Adolf. London: Duckworth, 1978. Print. Like The Day We Had Hitler Home, Young Adolf depicts the future dictator in a setting he never actually visited, in this case the British city of Liverpool in 1912. Hall, Rodney. A Dream More Luminous than Love: The Yandilli Trilogy. Sydney: Picador, 1994. Print. This trilogy, which includes the novels Captivity Captive (1988), The Second Bridegroom (1991), and The Grisly Wife (1993), portrays Hall’s fictional town of Yandilli during the nineteenth century. ———. The Island in the Mind. Sydney: Macmillan, 1996. Print. This trilogy consists of the novels Terra Incognita, The Lonely Traveller by Night, and Lord Hermaphrodite and chronicles the period leading up to the discovery and colonization of Australia. The Day We Had Hitler Home is the seventh installment in a series made up of The Island in the Mind and the books in the Dream More Luminous than Love trilogy.
312
Hitler, Adolf. Mein Kampf. New York: Reynal & Hitchcock, 1939. Print. Providing a view inside Hitler’s mind, Mein Kampf (“My Struggle”) is both autobiography and blueprint for the crimes he would unleash when he took power. A committee from the New School for Social Research performed the translation for this edition. Mailer, Norman. The Castle in the Forest. New York: Random House, 2007. Print. In this last work of the prominent American writer’s career, Hitler is envisioned through the eyes of a demon named Dieter. Rosenbaum, Ron. Explaining Hitler: The Search for the Origins of His Evil. New York: Random House, 1998. Print. Rosenbaum studies the moral and psychological aspects of the dictator’s character. Rosenfeld, Alvin. Imagining Hitler. Bloomington: Indiana UP, 1985. Print. This volume offers a highly critical examination of novels about Hitler, including George Steiner’s The Portage to San Cristobal of A. H. Rosenfeld, Gavriel. The World Hitler Never Made: Alternate History and the Memory of Nazism. New York: Cambridge UP, 2005. Print. Rosenfeld examines a wide range of fiction works on Hitler. Steiner, George. The Portage to San Cristobal of A. H. Boston: Faber, 1981. Print. In Steiner’s novella, widely cited as one of the most controversial fiction works on Hitler, the dictator is captured in South America thirty years after the end of World War II and put on trial. At the story’s climax, Hitler proclaims himself the Jews’ benefactor because the Holocaust made possible the establishment of Israel as a state. Judson Knight
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Days of Abandonment By Elena Ferrante
W Introduction
W Literary and Historical
Elena Ferrante’s The Days of Abandonment (2005) tells the story of a woman’s reactions across approximately six months to the unexpected news that her husband is leaving their marriage. The story begins in April when the husband quietly announces his decision, and it extends through August as the wife’s emotional state reaches its nadir and then begins to stabilize. Told in the first person from the wife’s point of view, the events are shaped and interpreted through the haze and growing paranoia of Olga’s descent into near-madness, including her beating up the family dog, stalking her husband and his mistress and later attacking them physically in the street, driving dangerously, and putting her children at risk in several ways. She stops personal hygiene, neglects the apartment, and sleeps through the day, ignoring the time she ought to pick up the children from school. At the same time, her refined language deteriorates into vulgarity and obscenity. During the summer her mental state reaches psychotic levels as she dissociates and hallucinates, suffers short-term memory loss, and fails to make meals or pay the bills. By August 4, which she calls “the hardest day of the ordeal of [her] abandonment” (88), she is at a point of near-total incapacitation, hearing voices, seeing her face distort or come apart in the bathroom mirror, and failing to address the urgent needs of a sick son and the family dog that is near death. The rise from this point is in the near term assisted by her neighbor Aldo Carrano and in the longer term by her gradual realization that she does not love her husband any more. She begins to get a grip on her daily tasks and finds work; the suggestion is she finds comforting companionship with Carrano. Originally published in 2002 as I giorni dell’abbandono, Ferrante’s novel was a controversial best seller in Italy for a year or more.
The literary context for The Days of Abandonment lies in two allusions to literature about adultery and the dissolution of marriage and the disastrous effects these experiences can have on women. These allusions occur on the morning of the “hardest day,” when Olga looks through her notebook and sees quotations from Simone de Beauvoir’s The Woman Destroyed (1967) and from Leo Tolstoy’s Anna Karenina (1877). She does not remember writing the quotations in this notebook, does not remember underscoring the Tolstoy quotations in red. The transcribed passages consist of questions Anna Karenina asks herself right before the train runs over her, killing her: “Where am I? What am I doing?” A writer herself and feeling similarly desperate, Olga identifies with the suicidal Anna. Both Tolstoy and de Beauvoir saw the potential dangers for women in marriage, saw the way male prerogative can exercise itself at women’s expense, and saw the way sexual impulses can ruin people’s lives. In the scene in which Olga examines her notebook, Ferrante draws the reader’s attention to this novel’s literary context. Ferrante invites the reader to consider the persistence of stories about scorned woman, about marriages that run amuck, about sexual relationships that are culturally defined and individuals who fail to fit the assigned mold or press themselves into it only to awaken one feeling distorted and cheated. These issues are widely known and can make for predictable plots, as some reviewers of The Days of Abandonment noted, but Ferrante’s handling is fresh and interesting: In this particular scene, Ferrante has her character wonder about having written down and underscored the questions another novelist’s character asks, thus identifying the dangerous condition Olga has reached and the universality of her experience. One historical context for The Days of Abandonment is the subject of divorce in predominantly Catholic Italy.
Context
313 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Days of Abandonment
MAJOR CHARACTERS CARLA becomes Mario’s mistress at the age of twenty-one. ALDO CARRANO, a cellist, lives in the apartment below Olga and develops a sexual relationship with her and helps her and her children. EMILIA, called the poverella (meaning poor one), a Naples woman long-since deceased, was abandoned by her husband and tried to commit suicide. As a child Olga knew Emilia, and after her own marital separation, Olga often thought about her. LEA FARRACO, wife of Mario’s colleague, is Olga’s friend and serves as a go-between for Mario and his estranged wife. GIANNI, ten, is the son of Mario and Olga. ILARIA, seven, is the daughter of Mario and Olga. MARIO, forty, is an engineer at the Polytechnic in Turin, who suddenly leaves his wife Olga for the much younger Carla. OLGA, thirty-eight, is suddenly abandoned by her husband Mario and develops severe depression in the months that follow his departure. The Days of Abandonment follows a woman named Olga as she reacts to being left by her husband. ª Ikon Images/Corbis
The Roman Catholic Church historically prohibited divorce and controlled under what specific circumstances the church would grant an annulment. Given that the Vatican is located in Rome and most Italians are Catholic, the church has exerted a particularly strong influence on Italians, shaping for centuries the national attitude toward marriage and divorce. Indeed, it was not until 1971 that divorce became legal in Italy. A referendum in 1974 passed by a broad majority, preserving the legality of divorce. By the early 2000s, adultery and divorce were facts of life, however scandalous they might seem to many Italians.
W Themes The main theme of The Days of Abandonment concerns the psychological and emotional adjustment a wife undergoes in the aftermath of a husband’s decision to leave the marriage. It depicts the progression through grief and depression during which the abandoned wife reacts and adjusts to the husband’s departure, depicting the way a woman’s psyche and the world she inhabits can virtually come apart during the traumatic process of reconstruction and the challenge of starting anew. Olga must envision herself and her world in a new way, and doing so takes time. Told from the woman’s point of view, the novel takes the reader into the typically hidden part of this adjustment, describing how a woman reviews
314
her own life, thinks about the lessons she learned as a child from her mother and from other women, reflects on the way she saw herself before marriage and after having children. Part of the adjustment requires this painful selfexamination that engenders growing awareness but at the cost of letting go of one’s past hopes, one’s past beliefs about oneself. The message in Ferrante’s handling seems to be that survival of the death of a marriage is possible, but uglier and more painful than perhaps people realize. Another theme in the novel concerns how time is experienced by a person going through such emotional upheaval and self-doubt. Olga loses track of time, misses whole days in sleep, feels suddenly a child again and at the same time old beyond her years. She looks at her sevenyear-old daughter and imagines her “old, her features deformed, near death” (89). She thinks back to when the children were babies, how she waited for the moment before her pregnancies to recur when she was “young, slender, energetic, shamelessly certain [she] could make [herself] a memorable person” (92). Even on her hardest and most delusional day, Olga realizes her “grammatical tenses weren’t correct” (89), yet she begins to intuit that the past is past. She tells herself, “Time is a breath . . . today it’s my turn, in a moment my daughter’s, it had happened to my mother, to all my forebears” (89). As she realizes the death of her marriage, Olga goes into a warp about what being a mother and having TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Days of Abandonment
children means, and maybe these distortions are akin to her distorted sense of time and her losing a grip on her verb tenses. In her worst mental condition, she imagines that motherhood turned her into “a lump of food” her “children chewed without stopping, a cud” (92). Her children were “bloodsuckers,” and she was permanently polluted with a “stink of motherhood” (93) that could not be washed off. Ferrante ran the risk of creating a protagonist that many readers may find reprehensible; the author ran this risk in order to dissect the internal experience of abandonment, an experience so grave it threatens to cause the character to abandon her own sense of self and all she once was able to do to fulfill societal expectations. The message seems to be that when a person is traumatized as Olga is, the person’s sense of self deteriorates and assessment of relationships turns dark.
W Style The Days of Abandonment consists of forty-seven brief chapters that move the plot ahead at different rates. The first chapter describes only the lunch announcement by Mario of his decision to leave the marriage. Subsequent chapters cover a week, even several weeks at a time. But for the hardest day, August 4, the pace slogs into slow motion, hours stretching across sixteen chapters, a long, drawn-out day in which Olga stalls and breaks apart, and readers feel increasing tension regarding the urgent problems she cannot address. As Olga’s psychic condition worsens, her ability to function constricts as well. This constriction is conveyed literally by the setting, with is described with enclosure details. Olga and her children are locked into the hot apartment without neighbors, without a phone, without a computer hook up, without any way to get outside help. Olga goes out of her husband’s study, closing the door on the dying dog. She locks herself into the bathroom and stares at herself in the mirror as the tub overflows. She cannot operate the dead-bolt security locks she had installed in the apartment door. The vicelike tightening described in these passages underscore Olga’s paralysis. The story is told in first-person point of view in the past tense. The protagonist looks back on this time from some future point when she is better, when she is holding a job, managing household tasks and her children’s needs, when “the obscene language suddenly disappeared” and she was “ashamed” of having used it (154). Yet to convey the immediacy of the experience, she does not frame the memory by putting it into a healthy perspective. Rather, especially during the interminable hardest day, she describes how she hallucinated that Emilia, the scorned woman of her childhood, appeared in the apartment, sitting at Mario’s desk, writing in Olga’s notebook; she describes hearing her warning that there
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Elena Ferrante (a pseudonym) was born in Naples, Italy. Her first novel, L’amore molesto, 1992, was published in English as Troubling Love in 2006, and her second novel, I giorni dell’abbandono, 2002, was published in English as The Days of Abandonment in 2005. She also published La frantumaglia (2003) and La figlia oscura (2006), the latter published in English as The Lost Daughter (2008). A celebrated contemporary Italian novelist, Ferrante eschews public attention and keeps her actual identity a secret.
was little time left. Olga remembers not wanting to engage in “so gaudy” (16) a grief, as the poverella (the poor woman) expressed, whining and crying out in the night for all the neighbors to hear. Olga describes how frightened she was by “the nearly imperceptible images of the mind, the scarce syllables . . . a simple violet flash of meanings, a green hieroglyphic of the brain” (154-55). She describes how she smacked herself in the face and then smiled, and only when her daughter mentioned it, did she realize she had bloodied her own nose. In these and other ways, Ferrante uses the narrowest point of view to telescope back into psychosis and examine it close up, not as if with a magnifying glass but as from within the smear on the slide beneath that glass.
W Critical Reception Published first in 2002, The Days of Abandonment made it to the best-seller lists in Italy and stayed there for about a year. The story of adultery and a wife abandoned for a mistress nearly half her age, once it was published in English by Europa Editions, made a popular read in the United States, although critics were not unqualified in their praise. Many commented on the extreme emotionality, obscenity, and violence that make up much of this novel. A review in the New Yorker called the novel “excruciatingly blunt”; Lisa Nussbaum described the novel as “raw and gut-wrenching,” and Olga’s emotions as boiling over “like molten lava, searing everything they touch.” Jean Hanff Korelitz described the deserted wife Olga as going through “a purgatory of rage and bereavement.” Many found the raw depiction of Olga’s deterioration striking, but some found it shocking, even repugnant. While critics admired the prose, they did so despite Ferrante’s reliance on a predictable plot. Korelitz, for example, stated that “The novel . . . progresses in a predictable, even classic, order,” and the familiar signposts of “anger, denial, bargaining, depression, acceptance” are
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
315
The Days of Abandonment
easily identified. Janet Maslin also commented on the predictability, but she explained what makes this novel different from others: “The template for the hot-blooded Italian best seller . . . is familiar, in fiction and in life. But the raging, torrential voice of the author is something rare.” The voice, the first-person narrative of the wife, Olga, makes this work different, according to Maslin. Connected to the effect of voice is the shift in the novel from standard English to vulgarity and obscenity. Korelitz commented on this progression, noting how alarmed Olga is by her descent from refined language to sarcasm to obscenity. Radhika Jones explored Olga’s progression, linking it to Olga’s memory of the poverella (the poor woman abandoned by her husband whom Olga knew as a child). Jones pointed out that the central issue is how one copes with this kind of abandonment. The answer is that there are a range of ways, and at one extreme is the poverella “whose noisy, ceaseless grief . . . was so excessive that it became repellent” and at the other extreme is “the relentless interiority of Olga’s anguish, her obsession with fantasizing her husband’s new life and questioning her own.” Jones explained that the “abandonment” is not only Mario’s decision to leave his marriage but also “the danger that Olga will abandon herself—her identity, her sanity, her capacity to live.” This risk reaches its most serious state on that longest and most painful day, August 4, when Olga is hounded by the dog’s death and her son’s rising temperature and cannot get help. Jones explained it this way: “As her psychic world narrows, so does her physical one, until she must literally combat death within the walls of her own apartment, and time seems to slow down to draw out the epic nature of her struggle.” Jones concluded that “what is perhaps most amazing about this novel . . . is that [Ferrante] is able to steer her characters toward a point of grace, not beyond pain, but through it.” That description of the ending is stated more strongly than the one given by the New Yorker reviewer, who said the novel ends on a “redemptive note,” which is a “welcome reprieve.” Motoko Rich commented on the good work of Europa Editions, a press that was established in 2005. Maslin agreed, noting that Europa Editions promised to be an excellent source “for European fiction for Englishspeaking readers.” Maslin also gave a nod to the translator, Ann Goldstein, who gives the novel its “breathless grammatical momentum.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
“Briefly Noted.” Rev. of The Days of Abandonment, by Elena Ferrante. New Yorker 31 Oct. 2005: 87. Print. Ferrante, Elena. The Days of Abandonment. Trans. Ann Goldstein. New York: Europa Editions, 2005. Print.
316
Jones, Radhika. “Elena Ferrante, The Days of Abandonment.” Rev. of The Days of Abandonment, by Elena Ferrante. Literary Review 22 Sept. 2005. Print. Korelitz, Jean Hanff. “Il Divorzio.” Rev. of The Days of Abandonment, by Elena Ferrante. New York Times Book Review 25 Sept. 2005: 27(L). Print. Maslin, Janet. “The Days of Abandonment: Books/ Fiction.” Rev. of The Days of Abandonment, by Elena Ferrante. International Herald Tribune 8 Sept. 2005. Print. Nussbaum, Lisa. “Ferrante, Elena. The Days of Abandonment.” Rev. of The Days of Abandonment, by Elena Ferrante. Library Journal 15 Oct. 2005: 44. Print. Rich, Motoko. “Publisher Finds Success in Translations.” New York Times 26 Feb. 2009: C1. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Rev. of The Days of Abandonment, by Elena Ferrante. complete-review.com. Complete Reviews, n.d. Web. 16 Sept. 2010. Faults Ferrante for relying on “fairly obvious devices,” such as the breakdown in communications, and cautions that this novel may not appeal to some readers. Saunders, Kate. “The Days of Abandonment.” Rev. of The Days of Abandonment, by Elena Ferrante. Times [London], 22 July 2006. Print. Calls novel a “harrowing dissection” of the experience of being dumped and a warning to anyone considering adultery. Gale Resources
“Elena Ferrante.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Literature Resource Center. Web. 16 Sept. 2010. Document URL http://go. galegroup.com/ps/i.do?&id=GALE% 7CH1000186758&v=2.1&u=itsbtrial&it=r&p= LitRC&sw=w For Further Reading
de Beauvoir, Simone. The Destroyed Woman. New York: Collins-G. P. Putnam’s Sons, 1969. Print. The title story, one of three, is about a woman dealing with the fact that her husband is having an affair, a story alluded to in The Days of Abandonment. Chopin, Kate. The Awakening. New York: Norton, 1993. Print. In the Norton Critical Edition, complete with secondary materials, the story of a woman who cannot resolve the conflict between being a mother and being an artist. Ferrante, Elena. Troubling Love. New York: Europa Editions, 2006. Print. Tells the story of a woman who returns to Naples to investigate her mother’s mysterious death by drowning and to uncover the family history of marital abuse and the private life the mother had. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Days of Abandonment
Gilman, Charlotte Perkins. The Yellow Wall-paper and Other Stories. Oxford: Oxford UP, 2009. Print. Regarding the title story in this collection, a firstperson account of a nineteenth-century woman who descends into madness as a result of receiving the so-called rest cure.
Tolstoy, Leo. Anna Karenina. Trans. George Gibian. New York: Norton, 1995. Print. The great novel about adultery, cruelty, and suicide, mentioned in The Days of Abandonment as important to the abandoned wife Olga.
Plath, Sylvia. The Bell Jar. New York: Harper Perennial Modern Classics, 2006. Print. Famous novel about depression that leads to suicide attempt by an ambitious young woman growing up in the 1950s.
Adaptations
The Days of Abandonment. Dir. Roberto Faenza. Perf. Margherita Buy, Goran Bregovic, Luca Zingaretti, and Alessia Goria. 2006. Film. Melodie Monahan
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
317
De Niro’s Game By Rawi Hage
W Introduction Canadian photographer Rawi Hage’s debut novel, De Niro’s Game, is the coming-of-age story of a young Lebanese man struggling to escape the senseless and random sectarian violence raging in Beirut in the 1980s. It also chronicles Bassam’s friendship with his childhood friend, George, whose predilection for violence and the game of Russian roulette earns him the name De Niro, after the American actor and the role he played in the 1978 movie The Deer Hunter. As both young men get involved in the underworld of crime, politics, and drugs endemic in 1980s Beirut, they are faced with moral choices that will determine their future paths. De Niro’s Game was published to laudatory reviews and was nominated in 2006 for both the Giller and Governor General’s literary prizes. In 2008 it received the highly regarded International IMPAC Dublin Literary Award. Reviewers praise the novel as a powerful debut that provides insight into the political turmoil in Lebanon in the 1980s and into how that violence affected Beirut citizens. As Stephan Christoff observes, “Turning the pages of De Niro’s Game, one is transported to the war-torn streets of Beirut in the midst of Lebanon’s 15-year civil war, a tragic reality of flying bombs and bullets.”
W Literary and Historical Context
De Niro’s Game is set in 1980s Beirut, Lebanon, a country torn apart by sectarian strife, an Israeli invasion, and a string of bloody assassinations of national political figures. Once part of the Ottoman Empire, and then under French control in the early twentieth century, Lebanon is a country on the eastern shore of the Mediterranean Sea, bordered by Syria and Israel. Independent since 1943, Lebanon has been buffeted by
strife for many years but is also recognized as a regional center for finance and trade. In 1975 civil war broke out in Lebanon between the pro-Western, right-wing Christian Maronite leadership and Muslim antigovernment militias, who were bolstered by massive waves of Palestinian refugees crossing the border from Israel and the support of the militant Islamic group the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO). Rapid urbanization and a widening gap between rich and poor also contributed to civil unrest. In April 1975 a busload of Palestinian refugees was ambushed by a militia associated with the Christian Maronite Phalangists, the main Christian political party in Lebanon. The attack sparked retaliatory strikes by pro-Palestinian and antigovernment groups, quickly blossoming into widespread sectarian strife. In 1976 Syria intervened to impose a peace deal. When a rift between Syria and the Maronite government led to more conflict, Israel invaded Lebanon in 1982 and bombarded urban areas, causing massive death and injury. That same year, the Phalangists carried out a massacre of Lebanese and Palestinian Muslims in the Sabra and Shatila refugee camps, killing between eight hundred to fifteen hundred people. Later evidence showed that the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) facilitated the massacres. Israel withdrew from Beirut, and Syria stepped in again in 1986. By this time, factions, splinter groups, organized crime, and warlords were also involved, trying to advance their own interests, with Beirut as their battleground. After a power struggle in 1988, a new president, Michel Awn, was appointed, but was driven out in 1990 after alienating the United States and Syria. By 1990 the civil war was over, killing an estimated 150,000 people and devastating the country’s economy.
W Themes One of the central themes of De Niro’s Game is religion and the damage human beings can cause in the name of religion. During the novel, Beirut is torn apart by
318 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
De Niro’s Game
sectarian violence between Christian and Muslim militias, and many innocent people are killed. Lives are ruined and irrevocably changed, with people having to do things they would never have thought they would have to do, just to survive. As Nigel Beale observed in his Washington Post review of the novel, “If anything, the book champions secularism and highlights the evil of which organized religion, regardless of brand name, is capable. Attacking God so directly makes the book a statement against all religion, Hage says, against the imposition of narrow standards of morality on society, not just in the Middle East, but around the world.” Hopelessness is another key thematic concern in De Niro’s Game. With constant bombardments, deaths, and chaos surrounding them, young people such as Bassam and George look forward to a future without hope or promise. Survival is often by luck, as the bombs falling from the sky fall indiscriminately. Without hope, many of the young people turn nihilistic and adopt games that reflect their despair. Hage’s novel is named after one such game: De Niro’s game is Russian roulette, played by Robert De Niro’s character in the 1978 movie The Deer Hunter. In the game, players take a gun and load one bullet, leaving the other chambers empty. They then spin the chambers, put the gun against their head and pull the trigger, hoping that the bullet is in another chamber. The randomness of the game mirrors the randomness of living in a war-torn country, where innocent people on the street are killed every day simply because they are in the wrong place at the wrong time.
W Style De Niro’s Game is narrated by the protagonist, Bassam, and traces his coming of age in war-torn Beirut to his escape to Paris, where he begins to reflect on his experiences and figure out what has happened to him and his friendship with George. Reviewers often comment on Hage’s filmic narrative approach to the novel—blunt, quick, with flashes to other characters and scenes. As Nigel Beale contends, “The feel of the novel is frenzied, with great movement and cinematic cuts. Passages of reflection, contemplation and quiet suddenly break to violence. This, explained Hage, is what the war was like for him.” Many critics focus on the flatness of Hage’s prose— not necessarily a pejorative term in this case. “Applied to Rawi Hage’s debut novel of violence and revenge in the bombed-out streets of Beirut, the word flat is praise,” argues reviewer Craig Taylor. “Throughout this novel Hage barely wavers from a flattened, declarative style that feels weighted with that particular dread that characterizes places where bombs rain down and most people have access to firearms. In the midst of its civil war, Lebanon is a place where nothing stays upright for long. Beirut has been flattened, and the aspirations of those who traverse its rubble have been destroyed with it.”
MAJOR CHARACTERS BASSAM is the narrator of De Niro’s Game. Living in Beirut during the brutal civil war, Bassam’s situation further deteriorates when his best friend, George, becomes involved with the Christian militia and starts selling drugs. After Bassam’s parents are killed during a bombing and he finds his own life in danger, he escapes Beirut, and arrives in Paris. It is there that he meets Rhea and begins to process his experiences in order to come to terms with his life. GEORGE is Bassam’s childhood friend, disenfranchised by the Lebanese Civil War. Nicknamed De Niro, George works at a small betting parlor and distinguishes himself by his recklessness. He is drawn to the Christian militia and soon gets involved with the world of drugs and violence surrounding it. He eventually betrays Bassam and steals Rana, his girlfriend. RANA is Bassam’s girlfriend in Beirut. She eventually leaves him for George. RHEA is George’s half-sister. Bassam and Rhea meet when he arrives in Paris. She is curious about George, and asks Bassam to tell her of their lives and hardships in Beirut during the war. Unable to tell her the truth, he makes up stories to tell her.
Other critics have praised Hage’s ability to depict action and avoid didacticism and melodrama. As M. Wayne Cunningham notes, “The excitement of Hage’s action-packed plot is supplemented by his visually and viscerally descriptive language, often of the war’s violent impact upon the innocent—whole neighborhoods destroyed, mothers mourning, a child dying in Bassam’s arms. There is no preaching about the excesses of war, only the showing.”
W Critical Reception Critics regard De Niro’s Game as a highly successful debut novel. It was nominated in 2006 for both the Giller and Governor General’s literary prizes, and two years later received the highly regarded International IMPAC Dublin Literary Award. As M. Wayne Cunningham maintains, “In all, De Niro’s Game is an amazing feat for an author writing in English as his third language— after Arabic and French—and well-deserving of ten thousand plaudits.” A number of reviewers focus on Hage’s prose and his ability to make the violent streets of Beirut come alive for readers. Craig Taylor notes that Hage has “vividly retrieved a time of pockmarked streets, cratered houses, and despair. But Hage, who survived nine years of civil war, is not planting any trees or prettifying the area in this
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
319
De Niro’s Game
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Rawi Hage was born in 1964 in Beirut, Lebanon. He was raised a Christian Maronite. When he was boy, a bloody civil war broke out in Beirut between Muslim-backed political groups and Christian Maronite forces. When he was eighteen years old, he moved to New York, where he lived for nine years and attended the New York Institute of Photography. He then settled in Montreal, Canada, in 1992. He worked as a retirement home security guard, then as a commercial photographer while attending Dawson College. He later received a BFA from Concordia University. He became involved in writing after keeping a journal for a photography exhibit. Hage received a grant from the Quebec Art Council to write a book of short stories, but wrote a novel, De Niro’s Game, instead. It was published in 2006 and was nominated for both the Giller and Governor General’s literary awards, and received the 2006 Hugh MacLennan Prize for Fiction. In 2008 De Niro’s Game received the International IMPAC Dublin Literary Award. That same year his second novel, Coachroach, was published. Hage’s work has been translated into more than twenty languages. He currently lives in Montreal.
look back. This is a grim, flat book. Hage’s flatness gives it the right tone of bruised emotion, disconnectedness, and violence; it’s what makes this such an effective debut.” Hage’s treatment of the friendship between Bassam and George is also a focus for some critics. “It’s a hallucinatory vision of how war corrupts even friendship,” Nigel Beale contends in his review of the novel. “De Niro’s Game is a work of literature, but due to its subject matter it also contributes to history and memory. Hage stays away from conclusions, preferring to present ambiguous, complex characters as representatives of humanity’s dark side, which he believes we should all face and talk about.” Beale also notes the novel’s universal appeal. “Written in English and calling upon Arabic poetry and French philosophy, De Niro’s Game forms an intriguing trilingual hybrid that should cement its appeal worldwide.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Beale, Nigel. “Sudden Death for the Home Team.” Washington Post Book World (24 June 2008). Web. 23 July 2010.
A destroyed car is evidence of a bombing attack in Beirut, Lebanon. In De Niro’s Game, Bassam leaves the violence of Beirut after a bombing kills his parents. ª M.I Stock photos / Alamy
320
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
De Niro’s Game
In De Niro’s Game, Bassam tries to escape the violence of the Lebanese Civil War during the 1980s. ª Megapress / Alamy
Christoff, Stephan. “Lebanon: Shadows of War.” Dominion 44 (13 Apr. 2007). Web. 23 July 2010. Cunningham, M. Wayne. “Ten Thousand Plaudits.” January Magazine (May 2007). Web 23 July 2010. Taylor, Craig. Rev. of De Niro’s Game, by Rawi Hage. Quill & Quire (June 2006). Web. 23 July 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
“Rawi Hage’s Long Day’s Journey into Secularism.” Arts & Opinion 6 (2007). Web. 23 July 2010. Interview with Hage that traces his evolving relationship with religion and his literary influences. Wagner, Vit. “De Niro’s Game Wins Rich Prize.” Toronto Star 13 June 2008. Web. 23 July 2010. Considers De Niro’s Game a Canadian novel and discusses the impact of receiving the IMPAC prize on Hage’s life and work. Waters, Juliet. “Dogs of War.” Montreal Mirror 22-28 June 2006. Web. 23 July 2010. Discusses Hage’s success with the publication of De Niro’s Game and some of the key themes of the novel.
Gale Resources
“Hage, Rawi.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Open Web Sources
To learn more about Lebanon’s civil war, the Global Security website at http://www.globalsecurity.org traces the origins of the conflict, chronicles the major figures and events, and provides background on the key political factions involved in the war. The Tanbourit website, at http://www.tanbourit.com/ lebanon_war.htm, also has a comprehensive overview of the conflict. Rawi Hage’s HarperCollins website, at http://www. harpercollins.com, has a short biography of the author and information on De Niro’s Game. Lebanon’s Ministry of Tourism’s website offers a plethora of information on attractions, events, and sightseeing opportunities in the country. More than twelve thousand pictures of Lebanon are on the site, which also includes historical and cultural background for interested readers http://www.lebanon-tourism. gov.lb.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
321
De Niro’s Game For Further Reading
Camus, Albert. The Stranger. New York: Vintage International, 1989. Mentioned in De Niro’s Game, The Stranger explores the senseless killing of a stranger by a young Algerian man. Critics regard Camus’s novel as one of the most influential novels of the twentieth century. Fisk, Robert. Pity the Nation: The Abduction of Lebanon. New York: Atheneum, 1990. A detailed history of Israel’s invasion of Lebanon and its aftermath.
322
Friedman, Thomas L. From Beirut to Jerusalem. Rev. ed. New York: Anchor Books, 1995. A historical and psychological study of the Israeli invasion of Lebanon and the Lebanese Civil War. This work received the 1989 National Book Award for Nonfiction. Hage, Rawi. The Cockroach. Toronto: House of Anansi Press, 2008. Hage’s second novel follows a misanthropic, thieving immigrant living in Montreal. Margaret Haerens
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Dead Europe By Christos Tsiolkas
W Introduction In Dead Europe, Christos Tsiolkas examines the forces, both ancient and modern, that have shaped the lives of Europeans in the twenty-first century. The primary narrative focuses on the thirty-six-year-old Isaac Raftis, a gay Australian of Greek heritage, as he explores the dark underbelly of both modern Europe and his own psyche. A secondary plotline set in a Greek village during the 1940s delves into ancient tales of ghosts and vampires to uncover the roots of a curse hanging over Isaac and his family. Although it has earned acclaim from a wide array of critics and won the Book of the Year Fiction Award from the Australian newspaper the Age in 2006, Dead Europe has also elicited strong negative responses. The book offers an almost unrelievedly grim portrayal of the characters and events it depicts, and its pages abound with scenes of furtive sexual couplings, abuse, and bloodlust. Most controversial of all is its employment of anti-Semitic imagery to explore what judges for the Age prize describe as “poisonous, atavistic hatreds that lurk beneath the veneer of civilization.”
W Literary and Historical Context
As a travel narrative, Dead Europe belongs to a literary tradition that dates back to Homer’s Odyssey and that includes hundreds of fiction and nonfiction works by authors ranging from Marco Polo to Mark Twain. Tsiolkas’s novel is far more than a travelogue, however; rather, it exposes the history of ethnic and political strife, with its attendant uprooting and displacement of whole populations, that has shaped the peoples of Europe. The son of immigrants, Isaac is a product of one such displacement, the Greek diaspora. (Diaspora, a Greek word, means “scattering” or “displacement.”) The
history of the Greek diaspora is almost as old as Greece itself, but whereas Greek merchants of ancient times willingly migrated to trading colonies along the Mediterranean, in more recent times large numbers of Greeks have been forced from their homeland by war. Its location in the Balkan Mountains of southeastern Europe has placed Greece at the crossroads of numerous modern conflicts. Germany invaded Greece in April 1941, and Nazi forces continued to occupy the nation until October 1944. A brief period of relative peace ended in March 1946, when the communist Democratic Army of Greece revolted against the pro-Western government. The Greek Civil War, which was part of the larger cold war, ended in September 1949 with the defeat of the communists. Four decades later, as communist domination in Eastern Europe began to erode with the collapse of the Berlin Wall in 1989, new ethnic wars broke out in the Balkans. These events brought with them further migrations, in this case to rather than from Greece, both by war refugees and by members of the Greek diaspora who had long been trapped in communist countries.
W Themes Although critics have identified many themes in Dead Europe, these can be summed up in a single word: separation. This is manifested in a variety of ways, including the separation Isaac’s parents made from their homeland by moving to Australia. His father, who dies just before the story begins, still longs for the old country, but his mother, Rebecca, has chosen never to return. Isaac, a second-generation member of the diaspora born on foreign soil, likewise experiences a sense of separation from his countrymen when he travels through Greece. A decade has passed since his last visit, and people he remembered as warm and sympathetic seem to have been transformed into suspicious strangers. Several of them confront him with the accusation that his mother
323 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Dead Europe
MAJOR CHARACTERS ANDREAS is a friend and an occasional traveling companion and sexual partner of Isaac, the novel’s protagonist. COLIN is Isaac’s working-class lover. Isaac leaves him behind in Australia to embark on his harrowing journey through Europe. ELIAS is a Jewish boy whom Lucia and Michaelis, despite their anti-Semitism, agree to protect from the Nazis. Although the couple abuses him horribly, Lucia is aroused by him, and after a hasty coupling, she conceives his child. Later she persuades Michaelis to murder Elias, giving rise to a curse that will haunt her family forever. GERRY is an old Jewish friend of Isaac’s family who lives in Paris. Revelations about his relationship with Rebecca suggest that he may be Isaac’s real father. GIULIA is Isaac’s cousin, with whom Isaac travels to his grandmother’s village in Greece. “KING KIKE” is a grotesquely obese Jewish porn maven whom Isaac meets in Prague. CHRISTOS PANAGIS is the son of Lucia and Elias, though Michaelis believes the boy to be his. Lucia develops an instant oedipal attraction to the boy and forces him to breastfeed even when he is much too old to do so. Later Christos’s paternal grandmother strangles him in an attempt to rid her village of a curse. LUCIA PANAGIS is Isaac’s grandmother. “The most beautiful woman in Europe” in her youth, she is the protagonist of the novel’s secondary plotline, set in Greece during the 1940s. MICHAELIS PANAGIS is the husband of Lucia and the father of Rebecca, whom he takes with him to Australia at the end of the 1940s story line. ISAAC RAFTIS is the novel’s protagonist and narrator. A thirtysix-year-old Australian photographer of Greek descent, he travels to Greece for an exhibit of his works and then embarks on a journey through Europe’s—and his own— dark underside. REBECCA PANAGIS RAFTIS is the daughter of Lucia and Michaelis and the mother of Isaac. She grows up in an atmosphere of abuse, first from her mother and then at the hands of racist thugs in Australia.
has forgotten the loved ones she left behind, and a heated argument ensues. In the end he mutters, “It is you who have forgotten us.” On a larger scale, there is the separation of modern Europeans who are alienated from one another and themselves by a globalist consumer culture that purports
324
Portrait of Christos Tsiolkas, author of Dead Europe. ª Colin McPherson/Corbis
to unite them. There is also the separation of peoples dispersed by wars and the rise and fall of regimes. Emblematic of these conditions is Isaac’s experience in Prague, where freedom from communist oppression makes possible all manner of debauchery. In working out his themes, Tsiolkas employs a variety of recurring motifs, including traditional myths and superstitions that keep people in fear of dark, unseen forces; ethnic hatred, particularly anti-Semitism; and sexual abuse, which transforms what should be an act of intimacy into an act of violence.
W Style Several critics have described Dead Europe as a “magic realist” novel, referring to a literary style in which supernatural or otherworldly elements are woven into an otherwise realistic landscape. Though the tale abounds with ghosts, vampires, and ancient curses, the writing style is far grittier than that of most magic realism. Indeed, Dead Europe is not a book for readers of delicate sensibilities. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Dead Europe
In Prague, Isaac meets a truly horrifying figure, a grotesquely fat Jewish pornographer called “King Kike” who puts on a live sex show in which an adult male performs fellatio on, and then rapes, an eleven-year-old boy. By then Isaac is well on his way to becoming a fervent anti-Semite, a journey that begins literally in the book’s first sentence: “The first thing I was ever told about the Jews was that every Christmas they would take a Christian toddler, put it screaming in a barrel, run knives between the slats, and drain the child of its blood.” The person who relates this vampirelike myth (an example of “blood libel,” whereby Jews were accused of killing Christian children in order to use their blood in religious rituals) is Isaac’s mother, and the scene opens up a whole array of horrors from the past, present, and future. These horrors, and their meaning for Isaac, unite the novel’s two story lines, which are presented in alternating chapters. The first of these plotlines is the present-day saga, set in various European locales and narrated by Isaac in the first person; the second, told in the third person, takes place in a Greek village during the 1940s. In keeping with the “magic realist” tag, several critics compare this second line of narrative to a fairy tale, and indeed it begins like one: “High in the mountains, where the wind goes home to rest, lived Lucia, the most beautiful woman in all of Europe.” This is a fairy tale of the most gruesome kind, however, involving numerous scenes in which children are abused—sexually or otherwise—and even murdered.
W Critical Reception The book’s portrayal of life in general, and of Europe in particular, is anything but pretty. Clara Iaccarino observes in the Sun Herald that “far from the postcard view of cosmopolitan European cities, Tsiolkas strips away the romance of Paris, Venice, Athens and Prague to reveal a culture deeply changed by the grip of globalization.” Jason Steger summarizes the uncomfortable experience of reading the novel, stating matter-of-factly that “Dead Europe is a book that divides people.” Robert Manne, writing in the Monthly, an Australian magazine, is far more critical. Whereas many other commentators view the book’s depictions of anti-Semitism as cautionary, Manne maintains that Dead Europe flirts with the boundaries of incitement to hatred. The novel’s portrayal of Jews is almost unrelentingly negative; many of the leading characters give vent to violent antiJewish sentiment. Manne asks, “Are we meant to assume [that] there is some direct cultural continuity between the traditional Christian anti-Semitism of the Greek villagers and the contemporary left-wing political anti-Semitism concerning the dispossession of the Palestinians and the fusion of Jewish and American power?” Manne’s criticism, however, represents a minority view. Sentiments expressed by Sacha Molitorisz in the
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Born in 1965 to working-class Greek immigrant parents, Christos Tsiolkas was raised in Richmond, Australia, a suburb of Melbourne. Lively discussions of politics and the traditions of the family’s southern European homeland (including strange tales of vampires, ghosts, and other peculiar items of folklore) animated the daily life of the household and exerted a strong effect on Tsiolkas’s worldview. He graduated from the University of Melbourne in 1987 and pursued a career as a journalist, a playwright, a screenwriter, a filmmaker, and ultimately a novelist. His first novel, Loaded (1995), was later filmed as Head On (1998). Besides receiving the Age Book of the Year Fiction Award for Dead Europe, Tsiolkas won the 2009 Commonwealth Writers’ Prize for Best Novel in the South-East Asia and South Pacific Area for The Slap (2008). Tsiolkas lives in Melbourne with his longtime partner, Wayne van der Stelt.
Sydney Morning Herald are more common: “Dizzying in its ambitions and intensity, Dead Europe is an impressive achievement.” Clara Iaccarino, reviewing the work for the Sun Herald, calls the book “a wake-up call for the millennium.” Steger quotes the judges who awarded Tsiolkas the Age’s fiction prize. They characterize the work as “a confronting novel that is both startlingly original and passionate in its pursuit of an authentic sense of self—one that is freed from the tainted legacy of inherited beliefs and prejudices.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Iaccarino, Clara. “Old World Yields to Modern Woes.” Rev. of Dead Europe, by Christos Tsiolkas. Sun Herald [Sydney]. Fairfax Media, 3 July 2005: 58. Web. 18 Oct. 2010. Lloyd, Paul. “Meet the Author: Christos Tsiolkas: Wrestling Demons.” Advertiser [Adelaide]. Advertiser Newspapers Ltd, 18 June 2005: W11. Web. 18 Oct. 2010. Manne, Robert. “Dead Disturbing: A Bloodthirsty Tale that Plays with the Fire of Anti-Semitism.” Rev. of Dead Europe, by Christos Tsiolkas. Monthly. Morry Schwartz, June 2005. Web. 20 Oct. 2010. Steger, Jason. “Haunted by Europe’s Demons.” Age [Melbourne]. Fairfax Media, 26 Aug. 2006: 27. Web. 18 Oct. 2010. Tsiolkas, Christos. Dead Europe. Sydney: Vintage, 2005. Print. ———. “European Vocation.” Interview by Sacha Molitorisz. Sydney Morning Herald. Fairfax Media, 18 June 2005: 22. Web. 18 Oct. 2010.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
325
Dead Europe Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Cañadas, Ivan. “Exhuming History: Neo-Conservatism and Christos Tsiolkas’s Dead Europe (2005).” Cultural Logic: An Electronic Journal of Marxist Theory and Practice (2007): n. pag. Web. 18 Oct. 2010. A discussion of the novel from a Marxist perspective; it makes reference to Francis Fukuyama’s End of History. Dooley, Gillian. Rev. of Dead Europe, by Christos Tsiolkas. Adelaide Review 19 Aug. 2005: 19. Web. 18 Oct. 2010. A mixed review in which Dooley maintains, “I will not say it’s a ‘must read,’ although it is the most compelling book I’ve read for some time.” Iaccarino, Clara. “Facing the Darkness of Our Times.” Rev. of Dead Europe, by Christos Tsiolkas. SunHerald [Sydney]. Fairfax Media, 29 May 2005: 65. Web. 18 Oct. 2010. A positive review that contrasts the novel’s tone with the personality of the author, who “is nowhere near as embittered as his writing would have you believe.” Kelly, Matthew. “The Fuss over Super-Fine Fiction.” Australian 4 Oct. 2006: 12. Web. 18 Oct. 2010. A wide-ranging discussion of recent literary fiction, including Dead Europe. Mansfield, Nick. “‘There Is a Spectre Haunting . . . ’: Ghosts, Their Bodies, Some Philosophers, a Novel and the Cultural Politics of Climate Change.” Borderlands 7.1 (2008): n. pag. Academic OneFile. Web. 18 Oct. 2010. An analysis of the politics of global climate change that makes reference to Dead Europe.
Infanticide in Dead Europe and Drift.” Australian Literary Studies 23.2 (2007): 230. Literature Resource Center. Web. 18 Oct. 2010. An assessment of the role of the mother in Dead Europe and Brian Castro’s 1994 novel Drift. Open Web Sources
An interview with Tsiolkas appears on the Bookslut Web site. http://www.bookslut.com/features/ 2009_09_015115.php Portal Journal of Multidisciplinary Studies, a publication of the University of Technology, Sydney, offers the text of “The Possibility of a ‘Dead Europe’: Tsiolkas, Houellebecq and European Mythologies,” by Nicholas Manganas. http://epress.lib.uts.edu.au/ ojs/index.php/portal/article/viewArticle/495 A videotaped interview with Tsiolkas is posted on Paul Reynolds’s PeoplePoints Web site. http://www. peoplepoints.co.nz/2009/05/wordshed-christostsiolkas-from-his.html The independent Australian bookseller Readings features the text of a short interview with Tsiolkas on its Web site. http://www.readings.com.au/interview/ christos-tsiolkas The transcript of an interview with Tsiolkas is available on the Web site of the Australian Broadcasting Corporation’s Radio National program Book Talk. http://www.abc.net.au/rn/arts/booktalk/stories/ s1404914.htm For Further Reading
Marr, David. “Journey through Cursed Lands.” Rev. of Dead Europe, by Christos Tsiolkas. Sydney Morning Herald. Fairfax Media, 25 June 2005: 20. Web. 18 Oct. 2010. A positive review of “a story that would collapse in a squalid heap but for the hell-bent exhilaration of the writing.”
Ellis, Bret Easton. Less than Zero. New York: Simon and Schuster, 1985. Print. With its depictions of homosexuality, drug abuse, meaningless sexual encounters, and even snuff films, Ellis’s debut novel was as shocking in its time as Dead Europe is to early-twentyfirst-century readers.
Rosenblatt, Les. “A Place Where Wolves Fuck.” Arena Magazine 79 (2005): 46-48. General OneFile. Web. 18 Oct. 2010. A discussion of anti-Semitic imagery in Dead Europe.
Fukuyama, Francis. The End of History and the Last Man. New York: Free Press, 1992. Print. In his 1989 essay “The End of History,” here presented in expanded form, Fukuyama argues that Western liberal democracy represents the culmination of human social evolution. Highly influential, Fukuyama’s work also elicits strong reactions from many, and several reviewers cite Dead Europe as a rebuttal to it.
Sornig, David. “Specters of Berlin in A. L. McCann’s Subtopia and Christos Tsiolkas’s Dead Europe.” Antipodes 21.1 (2007): 67. Literature Resource Center. Web. 18 Oct. 2010. An examination of imagery in the two novels that relates to the fall of the Berlin Wall. Syson, Ian. “A Taste of European Decay.” Rev. of Dead Europe, by Christos Tsiolkas. Age [Melbourne]. Fairfax Media, 28 May 2005: 4. Web. 18 Oct. 2010. A highly positive review of the novel that later won the publication’s Book of the Year Fiction Award. Van den Berg, Jacinta. “‘Are You Weaker than a Woman, Weaker than Even a Mother?’: Abjection and
326
Kaplan, Robert D. Balkan Ghosts: A Journey through History. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1993. Print. In this work written in the aftermath of communism’s demise, noted international correspondent Kaplan discusses the influence of ancient hatreds on the affairs of the Balkan region. The book received an unexpected publicity boost when President Bill Clinton was photographed with a copy under his arm. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Dead Europe
Muravchik, Joshua. Heaven on Earth: The Rise and Fall of Socialism. San Francisco: Encounter, 2002. Print. Heaven on Earth examines a political system that, even after its demise, has continued to influence events in Europe. The book is a companion to a Public Broadcasting System documentary series of the same name. Sedaris, David. When You Are Engulfed in Flames. New York: Little, 2008. Print. Like Tsiolkas, American essayist Sedaris is a gay man of Greek heritage, but his humorous and apolitical style could not be more different from that of his Australian counterpart.
In this collection, Sedaris offers his own take on the life of a visitor in Europe. Stoker, Bram. Dracula. 1897. Ed. Harold Bloom. Philadelphia: Chelsea, 2003. Print. The original novel of vampirism in southeastern Europe, Dracula, was based on ancient folktales. von Rezzori, Gregor. Memoirs of an Anti-Semite. New York: Viking, 1981. Print. In his novel, expanded from his 1969 New Yorker story of the same title, von Rezzori examines the roots of anti-Semitism.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Judson Knight
327
Death with Interruptions By José Saramago
W Introduction Death with Interruptions (also published as Death at Intervals) is a novel by the Nobel Prize-winning Portuguese author José Saramago. Originally published in Portuguese as As intermiténcias da morte (2005), the novel was translated into English by Margaret Jull Costas. The story takes place in a small, unnamed country during an unspecified year. On the first day of the year, people stop dying. What seems a wondrous blessing soon takes shape as a national disaster of unprecedented scale, as months pass and the numbers of those who should die but cannot climb rapidly. So begins Saramago’s dark and humorous fantasy on the rigors of eternal life and the benefits of death. Later in the novel, death emerges as a protagonist. She has resumed her normal activities, but now, she sends courteous letters to warn people of their approaching demise. One day, to death’s dismay, a letter is returned. She discovers that the intended recipient is a cellist, a bachelor, and a lover of music and nature who lives with his dog. Death cannot force herself to dispatch the man. She falls in love with the cellist, and she is last seen in bed with her arms around him, doing something that death is not supposed to do: sleeping.
W Literary and Historical Context
Death with Interruptions has characteristics of both fantasy and fable. Its central premise is absurd or fantastical, a feature shared with other novels by Saramago. In The Stone Raft (A jangada de pedra, 1986), for example, the Iberian Peninsula, severed from Europe by an earthquake, floats freely in the Atlantic Ocean. In Blindness (Ensaio sobra a cegueira, 1995), nearly the entire population of a large city is struck blind.
The approach is similar to that employed by German novelist Franz Kafka, whom Ron Charles of the Washington Post calls Saramago’s “literary ancestor.” The novel’s moral intent gives it the air of a fable. Beneath the breathless flow of words describing the unnamed country’s crisis, there is a simple tale about how death gives structure and meaning to life. In the first half of the novel, the characters, though human, are known only by their titles or roles, and they speak and act accordingly. Such titles as “funeral director” and “grammarian” have certain connotations or values attached to them, which Saramago exploits rhetorically, just as Aesop does with the fox and the lamb. Saramago’s satirical novels have inspired comparisons with the works of George Orwell. Both writers demonstrate an ear for the abstruse language of bureaucracy, and in Death with Interruptions, Saramago revels in it, to great ironic effect: “The prime minister ended by stating that the government was prepared for all humanly imaginable eventualities, and determined to face with courage and with the vital support of the population the complex social, economic, political, and moral problems that the definitive extinction of death would inevitably provoke, if, as everything seemed to indicate, this situation was confirmed.”
W Themes The themes of Death with Interruptions radiate from the novel’s opening sentence: “The following day, no one died.” Such an event is incomprehensible, prompting the reader to question why no one died and to wonder what life would be like without death. In the novel’s first pages, there is a sense that “humanity’s greatest dream since the beginning of time, the happy enjoyment of eternal life here on earth, had become a gift within the grasp of everyone.” Soon, however, the dream turns to nightmare, as the country groans under the weight of an ever-increasing population of gravely ill, injured, or simply aged people
328 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Death with Interruptions
who are unable to live or die and require constant care. Industries are destroyed by lack of demand (funeral homes) or faced with impossible workloads (nursing homes). Church leaders must contemplate their demise, for death was the foe that religion was supposed to help people overcome. Philosophers, too, are left with nothing to do but “philosophize about . . . the void.” When death returns to work, people celebrate with champagne. Order is restored. In the end, death is shown to be a greater blessing than eternal life. Nonetheless, death remains humanity’s greatest source of fear, loss, grief, and regret. How can people make peace with death? As the cellist demonstrates, the way to be reconciled with death is to love life and all of its wonders.
MAJOR CHARACTERS THE CELLIST is an ordinary, middle-aged bachelor, neither ugly nor handsome, who lives with his dog. He has no idea that death has been trying to send him a letter, and he is unaware of her investigations in his apartment. He gets to know her when she assumes human form and charms him from a box seat during a concert in which he performs. Their first few meetings do not go well: Death is, unsurprisingly, cold, abrupt, and peremptory in her behavior. Finally, his performance of J. S. Bach’s Cello Suite no. 6 brings them into each other’s arms.
Stylistically, Death with Interruptions shares similarities with other works by Saramago, including The Stone Raft and Blindness. Characters are designated only by their official titles or roles—prime minister, department head, cellist, or son-in-law, for example. Entities whose names normally are capitalized—the “catholic apostolic church of rome,” for example—are not granted that distinction in Saramago’s world.
DEATH, at the beginning of the novel, is spiteful and grumpy, a frostbitten skeleton in a sheet who lives in a cold, dark room underground. She stops killing people because she feels that they do not appreciate the order and meaning that she brings to their lives. The chaos that accompanies her work stoppage appalls her, and so, after seven months, she resumes her duties, but with one new rule: From now on, she will send violet-colored letters to people one week before they are to die so that they will have time to put their affairs in order. This system works well until, one day, a letter comes back. This unprecedented development draws death into the cellist’s life.
In Saramago’s novel, the character Death stops claiming souls for a period of time. Here, a hand sifting sand represents the transient nature of human life. Vibrant Image Studios/Shutterstock.com
The novel is narrated in the third person from an omniscient point of view. The narration is hectic and chatty. Writing in the New Yorker, James Wood describes Saramago’s narrative style as “unidentified free indirect style—his fictions sound as if they were being told not by an author but by, say, a group of wise and somewhat garrulous old men, sitting down by the harbor in Lisbon, having a smoke, one of whom is the writer himself.” This impression is conveyed by Saramago’s junglelike syntax, a hallmark of his work. Sentences flow on for a page or more. Punctuation is idiosyncratic, and periods appear infrequently. In a self-deprecating passage in the novel, a grammarian who is called in to analyze a letter written by death describes her prose as an “insult” to the art of writing. Sounding like an exasperated editor, he singles out among death’s grammatical sins “the chaotic syntax, the absence of full stops, the complete lack of very necessary parentheses, the obsessive elimination of paragraphs, the random use of commas and, most unforgivable of all, the intentional and almost diabolical abolition of the capital letter.” In satirizing government and religion, Saramago makes skillful use of irony in Death with Interruptions. An example is the liberal sprinkling of clichés and aphorisms throughout the text. As James Wood notes, these platitudes, often placed in the mouths of politicians, are “neither quite validated or disowned; they are ironized by the obvious gap . . . between the knowing Nobel laureate writing his fictions and the person or persons seemingly narrating these fictions.”
W Style
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
329
Death with Interruptions
ABOUT THE AUTHOR José de Sousa Saramago was born on November 16, 1922, in the village of Azinhaga, Portugal. “Saramago,” a pejorative nickname for the writer’s father meaning “wild radish,” accidentally was added to his birth certificate. Saramago published his first novel, Terra do pecado (The land of sin) in 1947, but he did not publish another until Manual de pintura y caligrifia (The manual of painting and calligraphy) in 1977. He produced four novels during the 1980s, including Memorial do convento (Memoir of the convent, 1982), whose English translation, Baltasar and Blimunda (1987), finally brought Saramago international recognition. Many consider The Year of the Death of Ricardo Reis (1991) to be his greatest work. An atheist and a communist, Saramago was known for his pointed satires of religion and capitalist politics. In 1995 he received the Camões Prize, Portugal’s highest literary honor, and in 1998 he was awarded the Nobel Prize in Literature. He died in Lanzarote, in the Canary Islands, on June 18, 2010.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Basilières, Michel. “Saramago’s Death Takes a Holiday.” Toronto Star 12 Oct. 2008: ID04. CPI.Q (Canadian Periodicals). Web. 12 Oct. 2010. Bollig, Ben. “Hold the Grim Reaper.” Rev. of Death at Intervals, by José Saramago. Guardian [London]. Guardian News and Media Ltd, 10 Feb. 2008. Web. 12 Oct. 2010. Charles, Ron. “Death Takes a Holiday.” Washington Post 26 Oct. 2008. Web. 12 Oct. 2010. Rev. of Death with Interruptions, by José Saramago. Bookmarks Jan.-Feb. 2009. Literature Resource Center. Web. 12 Oct. 2010. Max, D. T. “Stay of Execution.” New York Times Book Review 26 Oct. 2008: 19(L). Literature Resource Center. Web. 12 Oct. 2010.
W Critical Reception Death with Interruptions has been well received by critics, though some have felt that it lacks the artistic vision and verve of The Year of the Death of Ricardo Reis (O ano da morte de Ricardo Reis, 1984) or Blindness. James Wood asserts that the novel “efficiently mobilizes its hypothetical test case, and quickly generates a set of sharp theological and metaphysical questions about the desirability of utopia, the possibility of Heaven, and the true foundation of religion.” Michel Basilières finds the novel “as complex and subtle as any Greek tragedy, but no less simple and direct than a fable by Aesop, La Fontaine, or Borges.” Many reviewers have responded positively to the love story between death and the cellist. Ron Charles praises the way this development “catches us off guard”: “How can the most tender relationship that Saramago has ever written involve death as a nervous lover? This is a story that can’t possibly work or affect us, but it does, deeply, sweetly.” Some reviewers have found the first half of the novel, a frenetic satire of politics, religion, and capitalism, longwinded and tedious. “One senses,” D. T. Max writes in the New York Times Book Review, “that the author, a lifelong critic of capitalism, is mostly interested in pricking the modern state. Critique muscles out character.” Lydia Millet echoes this complaint in the Toronto Globe and Mail: “Painfully absent in Interruptions are the tensions and subtleties of immediate relations between persons— those that so cleverly drive more conventional and more powerful narratives, such as the one that holds Blindness together.” Margaret Jull Costa’s translation of the novel has received high marks. A Bookmarks reviewer praises
330
Costa’s ability to “rein in the author’s difficult style . . . and bring [his] genius to the page.” Ben Bollig of the Guardian likewise observes that Saramago’s “distinctive, multi-voiced style [is] skillfully maintained in Costa’s translation.”
Millet, Lydia. “Death Takes a Holiday, and Falls in Love.” Globe and Mail [Toronto] 11 Oct. 2008: D14. CPI.Q (Canadian Periodicals). Web. 12 Oct. 2010. Saramago, José. Death with Interruptions. Trans. Margaret Jull Costa. Orlando: Harcourt, 2008. Wood, James. “Death Takes a Holiday.” Rev. of Death with Interruptions, by José Saramago. New Yorker 27 Oct. 2008: 88. Literature Resource Center. Web. 12 Oct. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Allen, Bruce. “Saramago’s Genius.” Rev. of Death with Interruptions, by José Saramago. Kirkus Reviews 8 Aug. 2008. Literature Resource Center. Web. 12 Oct. 2010. An enthusiastic review that praises the novel’s structure and thematic development. Rev. of Death with Interruptions, by José Saramago. Publishers Weekly 21 July 2008: 136. Literature Resource Center. Web. 12 Oct. 2010. A brief review that characterizes Saramago’s novel as “a philosophical page-turner.” “Death’s Absence, Writ Large and Small.” Rev. of Ghost in Love, by Jonathan Carroll, and Death with Interruptions, by José Saramago. All Things Considered. National Public Radio, 9 Dec. 2008. Literature Resource Center. Web. 12 Oct. 2010. Praises the range of Saramago’s satire and his ability to fashion appealing stories from satire. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Death with Interruptions
Deveson, Tom. Rev. of Death at Intervals, by José Saramago. Sunday Times [London] 3 Feb. 2008. Web. 12 Oct. 2010. Criticizes the satirical first half of the novel for its “labored prolixity.” Hopkinson, Amanda. Rev. of Death at Intervals, by José Saramago. Independent [London]. Independent Print Ltd, 11 Apr. 2008. Web. 12 Oct. 2010. Hails the novel for its imaginativeness and “fresh ideas,” but notes the challenges that the author’s prose poses for readers. Miller, Laura. Rev. of Death with Interruptions, by José Saramago. Salon.com 30 Oct. 2008. Web. 12 Oct. 2010. Gives a nod to the novel’s satirical first half as its most original component and worries that the ending is perhaps a little too neat. Preto-Rodas, Richard A. “José Saramago: Art for Reason’s Sake.” World Literature Today 73.1 (1999): 11. Literature Resource Center. Web. 12 Oct. 2010. Reynolds, Susan Salter. “The Bell Stops Tolling.” Rev. of Death with Interruptions, by José Saramago. Los Angeles Times 9 Nov. 2008. Web. 12 Oct. 2010. Expresses concerns about the artificiality of the novel’s first section and its runaway narrative. Turner, Forest. Rev. of Death with Interruptions, by José Saramago. Library Journal 1 Sept. 2008: 122. Literature Resource Center. Web. 12 Oct. 2010. Praises the introduction of death as a character as a key to the novel’s success. Gale Resources
“José Saramago.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Literature Resource Center. Web. 12 Oct. 2010. “José Saramago.” Contemporary Literary Criticism. Ed. Jeffrey W. Hunter. Vol. 275. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Literature Resource Center. Web. 12 Oct. 2010. Ornelas, José N. “José Saramago.” Nobel Prize Laureates in Literature, Part 4. Detroit: Gale, 2007. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 332. Literature Resource Center. Web. 12 Oct. 2010. Open Web Sources
Nobelprize.org features a video of Saramago’s Nobel acceptance speech (with English translation) and an autobiography, a bibliography, a transcript of the
award presentation, and a collection of photos from the award ceremony. http://nobelprize.org/nobel_ prizes/literature/laureates/1998/ Times Topics: José Saramago from the New York Times features reviews, interviews, and articles from the newspaper’s archives, as well as biographical information and links to other online resources. http:// topics.nytimes.com/top/reference/timestopics/ people/s/jose_saramago/index.html?scp=1-spot& sq=jose%20saramago&st=cse For Further Reading
Bloom, Harold. José Saramago. Bloom’s Modern Critical Views. New York: Chelsea House-Infobase, 2005. Print. Literary critic Harold Bloom introduces a representative selection of critical essays on Saramago’s works. Eberstadt, Fernanda. “José Saramago, Nobel PrizeWinning Portuguese Writer, Dies at 87.” New York Times 18 June 2010. Web. 12 Oct. 2010. New York Times obituary includes biographical information and excerpts from interviews with critics and the author. Kafka, Franz. The Metamorphosis and Other Stories. Trans. Joyce Crick. New York: Oxford UP, 2009. “The Metamorphosis,” one of Kafka’s best-known stories, describes the life of a man who awakes one morning to discover he has been transformed into a hideous creature. Saramago, José. Blindness. Trans. Giovanni Pontiero. New York: Harcourt, 1997. Print. Saramago’s novel, originally published in 1995, describes the struggles of a small group of people to survive in a city where nearly all of the residents have lost their sight. ———. Interview. “José Saramago: Death Interrupted.” LA Weekly 5 Aug. 2010. Web. 12 Oct. 2010. In this posthumously published interview, Saramago discusses the subjects of his novels, his writing style, his views on religion and political ideologies, and the significance of love and death. ———. The Stone Raft. Trans. Giovanni Pontiero. New York: Harcourt, 1995. Print. This novel, originally published in 1986, follows the political chaos that ensues after an earthquake sends the Iberian Peninsula floating off into the Atlantic Ocean.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Janet Moredock
331
Declare By Tim Powers
W Introduction Tim Powers’s novel Declare opens in 1963, when Andrew Hale, a former British spy, is recalled to duty from his current post as a lecturer at University College of Weybridge. He is asked to complete a mission, which failed in 1948 on Mount Ararat, Turkey, the reputed site of the final resting place of Noah’s Ark and home to fallen angels, also referred to as djinns. Hale agrees to be reactivated and meets up with his former colleague, the historical British master spy and mole for the Soviet Union, Kim Philby. He also reconnects with former colleague and love, Elena, a Spanish-born communist. The center of the plot involves supernatural djinns who inhabit the mountain, one of whom was kidnapped by the Russians and made a ghula, or guardian angel, in the form of an old woman, called Machikha Nash. She had protected Russia since 1883. Her Majesty’s Secret Service was tasked with destroying the old woman, hence, ensuring the downfall of the Soviet Union. The original mission ultimately failed, however, because Hale had used the wrong bullets. The Cold War that followed World War II motivated the British to send Hale back to the Ahora Gorge, but this time Hale learns the full import of his role. He discovers that Philby is really his half brother and that they share a mystical bond; Hale and Philby are two halves of one person. In order for Hale to complete the mission successfully, he must shoot Philby with bullets made from a special meteorite, called the Shihab stone, but not kill him. The djinn, instead, lured by the Shihab particles, would consume Philby and, following their mutual death, Russia too would no longer enjoy special protection.
W Literary and Historical Context
Powers uses historical persons and events around which to develop his novel. Kim Philby’s scandalous activities as
a double agent are, therefore, factually accurate; however, Powers creates fictional explanations to fill in gaps and magnify the intrigue. For example, he gives supernatural causes for Philby’s difficult relationship with his father, St. John Philby, who is also Hale’s father. References to and anecdotes regarding other notable historical figures, such as T. E. Lawrence, known also as Lawrence of Arabia, and British double agent Guy Burgess, correspond with the Cold War timeline and espionage operations. In his book, The Master Spy: The Story of Kim Philby, Phillip Knightley corroborates many of Powers’s details about Philby, Burgess, and the Cold War. Mount Ararat, as a long suspected site for the final docking of Noah’s Ark, acknowledges both archaeological speculation and popular myth. Powers blends these scientific inquiries with legends, folklore, and biblical references, including apocryphal sources, to suggest additional, though alternate reasons, for British activities in the Middle East. Political interest in the paranormal and supernatural forces is well documented, particularly on the part of Russia and Nazi Germany. The fallen angels who did not drop straight to Hell, but were trapped on Mount Ararat, became the focus of Allied and Axis powers who would exploit them for political gain, as Powers suggests the Russians had done. In addition to historical records, Powers uses other apocryphal sources to assert that the Devil hitched a ride on the Ark by hanging onto the roof, to bolster the credibility in the presence of djinns on Mount Ararat. The geopolitical importance of the location provides the embellishment of Russian and Nazi preoccupation with the region, so the variety of characters in the novel is itself based on fact, into which Powers injects plausible versions of history. Powers also incorporates the rise of socialist and communist sympathizers in the West during the Cold War in Declare. Philby’s own memoirs reflect the trend in many British universities toward communist sensibilities by men, such as Guy Burgess, an historical figure. The novel also employs diverse sets of jargon that correspond to code talking between the secret agents and a lexicon of
332 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Declare
MAJOR CHARACTERS GUY BURGESS is colleague and co-conspirator with Kim Philby, along with another double agent named Maclean. CLAUDE CASSAGNAC is an MI5 consultant whose life is sacrificed to provide cover for Andrew Hale. Hale agrees to take the blame for his colleague’s murder in order to complete his mission. ELENA TERESA CENIZA-BENDIGA becomes a devoted communist when her parents are murdered by fascists in Spain. She is paired with Hale who is working uncover, and they fall in love. ANDREW HALE, born in Palestine, is a spy with the British Secret Service who is recalled to duty. He must complete a failed mission called Declare. MRS. HALE, Andrew’s mother, is a former Catholic nun who hides the identity of her son’s father. When he is only seven, she introduces Andrew to Jimmie Theodora, who eventually becomes his handler.
Launching of a spy satellite. In Declare, Andrew Hale is a former British spy who is asked to complete a doomed mission. RALPH CRANE
SALIM BIN JALAWI, an Arab, is Hale’s oldest friend in the Middle East who accompanies him on his journey to the Ahora Gorge. He is assassinated before they reach their destination. HAKOB MAMMALIAN is an Armenian assigned to Hale as his handler on behalf of the Russian spies.
artifacts, talismans, and amomon root, which promised eternal life, as cited by many sources, including the firstcentury historian Josephus. After Hale shoots Philby with Shihad buckshot, he offers his half-brother the root in exchange for Elena.
W Themes One of the novel’s major themes is the nature and power of deception as a powerful force over moral choice. The main protagonist, Andrew Hale, suffers from strange dreams and, while very young, is introduced by his mother for no apparent reason to his future handler of the SOE, Jimmie Theodora. The identity of his father is not revealed to him until many years later. When he turns eighteen, he is officially recruited into the British Secret Service, where he is trained in the art of deception. Every mission requires a cover identity and the use of codes and ciphers. Hale learns to overcome morals and ethics as he fulfills every duty in service to his country. He first begins to reflect upon the invasive power of deception when he pretends to be a communist in order to infiltrate the movement and falls in love with Elena, an avowed communist. Another theme addresses the challenges of national loyalty in service of the greater good at the expense of personal happiness. Hale must deceive the woman he
HARRY ST. JOHN PHILBY is father to Kim and Andrew. He uses his knowledge as an Arabist and British explorer to conspire with supernatural forces for Kim’s perceived destiny as a potentially immortal being, under the protection of djinns. KIM PHILBY, master spy for the British Secret Service, shocks the world with his defection to Russian Intelligence after he is suspected of being a mole. He is Andrew’s half-brother by St. John Philby and can be in two places at once until Andrew is born. JIMMIE THEODORA is a seasoned British spy who mentors Andrew Hale.
loves by taking the blame for the murder of a mutual friend and colleague, in order to establish yet another cover identity. The life of Claude Cassagnac is sacrificed in order to convince the KGB that Hale is a genuine defector. Elena, however, comes to hate Hale for the murder and threatens to kill him despite her attachment to him. Hale, though conflicted, remains resolute to carrying out orders of the Crown, regardless of his own emotional bonds. The multiple storylines of the novel invoke as many themes as subplots; however, one of the more important ones is the relationship of family. St. John Philby exploits for personal ambition and through supernatural means the
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
333
Declare
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Born February 29, 1952, Tim Powers earned his BA at California State University, Fullerton, and became a successful writer of science fiction. He has won several awards, including the 1984 Philip K. Dick Memorial Award, for The Anubis Gates, and the 2001 International Horror Guild Best Novel Award, for Declare. In an interview for www.powells.com, Powers remarked on the historical events portrayed in Declare: “ . . . I made it an ironclad rule that I could not change or disregard any of the recorded facts, nor rearrange any days of the calendar—and then I tried to figure out what momentous but unrecorded fact could explain them all.” As of 2010, Powers lived with his wife in Muscoy, California.
destiny of his mystical son. As a result, Kim Philby struggles with disruptive feelings, even as he too becomes obsessed with his own possibilities, protection from harm with talismans or fox fur coats being one of them. Mrs. Hale refuses to disclose the name of Hale’s father, whose indiscretion with her while a nun is the very thing that forces the half-brothers to share one soul. Though compromised from all quarters by lies and deception, Andrew and Elena’s love emerges as the most honest and enduring bond of all.
W Style Powers is well regarded as a protégé in the tradition of John le Carré for espionage thrillers. Declare is a third-person novel in the espionage genre with parallel stories from the 1940s and 1960s. But Powers blends the traditional spy thriller with generous portions of science fiction and fantasy. The various intelligence operations of the Cold
War provide the foundation for the main action; however, Powers continuously blends, weaves, and smashes the different genres together in dense, complicated prose. Thus, the subplot of fallen angels is mixed with special forces to control the supernatural powers dwelling on Mount Ararat. Kim Philby has the power to be in two places at once until his half-brother is born, and Andrew Hale learns from Elena how to walk at a certain pace that renders him invisible. Supernatural abilities such as these allow the spies to achieve their separate and competing missions. But the novel also conceals a traditional love story, which has tragic elements rendered with sentimental flourish, that stands in contrast to the structure of a tale of espionage. The language shifts constantly from bureaucratic spy talk to foreign phrases, each of which refers to obscure bits of politics; covert phrases; or folklore, myth, and legend. While the suspense builds on several fronts, from Hale and Philby’s early conflicts to their joint confrontation with the djinns on Mount Ararat, flashbacks of Elena surface repeatedly and reinforce the power of love. Finally, the theme of extraordinary explanations for lacunae in the historical record suggests that truth and deception are two sides of the same coin. Powers uses enough fact to make the fictional elements of the narrative plausible, at least. For example, it is true that T. E. Lawrence had a significant role in British interests in the Middle East during the Arab Revolt of 1915-1916. It is also true that he died in a motorcycle accident; however, Powers offers alternative reasons for Lawrence’s activities in Arabia and his unexpected death.
W Critical Reception Declare was generally well received by critics for its ambitious scope as a multigenre work anchored by historical fact. In his review in Bookpage, William D. Gagliani praised
Mount Ararat, a key location of an important mission for Andrew Hale in Declare. Zorik Galstyan/Shutterstock.com
334
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Declare
Powers as a “masterful melder of fact and fiction.” He cited specifically the character of Kim Philby, the British spy, who defected to the Soviet Union. John Berlyne echoed Gagliani, stating in SFRevu that Powers “demonstrates his uncanny ability of wrapping his fiction around a tightly research historical framework.” Writing for Library Journal, Devon Hass, assured that “Fans of John le Carré will appreciate the authentic period detail, meticulous descriptions of the business of espionage, and portraits of actual spies.” Some serious reviewers dedicated to science fiction and fantasy genres outside the mainstream were more cautious of Declare. Despite general praise for the novel in his review in Eyrie, Russ Allbery concluded that the “strongest parts of this book by far [are] the elements of the supernatural.” But other traditional sources were less kind. For example, Publishers Weekly asserted that Declare is “all offbeat and daringly imaginative, but ultimately rather foolish entertainment.” But many critics appeared to agree with Eric Brown, who in his review in the Guardian called it “an immense hybrid of classic spy novel and supernatural thriller.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Allbery, Russ. “Declare.” Rev. of Declare, by Tim Powers. Eryie 23 Jan. 2005. Web. 7 Sept. 2010. Berlyne, John. “Declare, by Tim Powers.” Rev. of Declare, by Tim Powers. SFRevu 1 Jan. 2001. Web. 7 Sept. 2010. Berry, Jedediah. The Manual of Detection. New York: Penguin, 2009. Brown, Eric. “The Passage, Declare, and Blood and Iron.” Rev. of Declare, by Tim Powers. Guardian 5 June 2010. Web. 6 Sept. 2010. Gagliani, William D. “Declare, by Tim Powers.” Rev. of Declare, by Tim Powers. Bookpage Mar. 2001. Web. 7 Sept. 2010. Hass, Devon. “Declare.” Rev. of Declare, by Tim Powers. Library Journal. 125.19 (2000): 97. Print. Knightley, Phillip. The Master Spy: The Story of Kim Philby. New York: Knopf, 1989. Print. Powers, Tim. Declare. New York: Harpertorch-HarperCollins, 2001. Print. Weich, Dave. “Tim Powers Rewrites the Cold War.” Powells.com 26 Jan. 2001. Web. 25 Jan. 2011. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Berry, Michael. “Declare.” Rev. of Declare, by Tim Powers. SFGate 18 Nov. 2001. Web. 8 Sept. 2010. Refers to Powers’s adept use of historical figures as the main force in his hyperkinetic narrative.
Farrell, Eleanor M. “Declare, by Tim Powers.” Rev. of Declare, by Tim Powers. Mythprint 38:3 (2001): n.p. Web (mythsoc.org/mythprint/2001). 6 Sept. 2010. Notes le Carré’s influence in terms of capturing Cold War espionage with all of its noble double-cross and suspicion and praises Powers’s main protagonist as well-drawn and sympathetic. Raines, Phillip. “Declare, by Tim Powers.” Rev. of Declare, by Tim Powers. Infinity Plus 9 Nov. 2002. Web. 6 Sept. 2010. Acknowledges Powers’s grasp of geopolitical nuance and unflattering detail of the British secret service and notes similarities to le Carré. Gale Resources
“Tim Powers.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Literature Resource Center. Web. 2 Sept. 2010. http://go.galegroup.com/ps/i.do? &id=GALE%7CH1000079567&v=2.1&u= itsbtrial&it=r&p=LitRC&sw=w For Further Reading
Gaddis, John Lewis. The Cold War: A New History. New York: Penguin, 2006. Print. Presents the complicated history of the Cold War as told by a Yale professor. Guiley, Rosemary Ellen, and Philip J. Imbrogno. The Vengeful Djinn: Unveiling the Hidden Agenda of Genies. Woodbury: Llewellyn Publications, 2011. Print. Explores the nature and dangers of djinns using quantum physics, folklore, and Islamic sources such as the Qur’an. Koltuv, Barbara Black. Amulets, Talismans, and Magical Jewelry: A Way to the Unseen, Everpresent, Almighty God. Lake Worth: Nicholas-Hays, 2005. Print. Discusses the history of magical artifacts used for creating a closer connection to God and uses author’s profession as clinical psychologist and Jungian analyst to defend the power of religious and cultural charms. Lawrence, Thomas Edward. Seven Pillars of Wisdom: A Triumph. New York: BN Publishers, 2009. Print. Lawrence of Arabia’s personal account of his role in unifying Arab factions against Turkish incursion. Philby, Kim. My Silent War: The Autobiography of a Spy. New York: Modern Library, 2002. Print. Personal account of failings of the British Secret Service and Philby’s decision to side with the communists, despite the truth about Stalin’s leadership. Prophet, Elizabeth Clare. Fallen Angels and the Origins of Evil: Why Church Fathers Suppressed the Book of Enoch and Its Startling Revelations. Kearney: Summit UP, 2000. Print. Suggests that Jesus was well acquainted with the Book of Enoch, long suppressed by the Catholic Church.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Doris Plantus-Runey
335
The Deposition of Father McGreevy By Brian O’Doherty
W Introduction Set in County Kerry in the west of Ireland during World War II, The Deposition of Father McGreevy (1999) tells the story of the decline and eventual demise of a remote hilltop village in the 1940s. Once a thriving farming community, the village is struck by a series of disasters. These begin during one exceptionally harsh winter during which the village is cut off by deep snow and a mysterious epidemic results in the deaths of all the women. Next, all the village children are separated from their fathers and sent to be educated at a convent in Dingle, the nearby town, and the men of the community sink into depression and sloth. Further misfortunes follow, as the villagers are ostracized after rumors of bestiality become rife in the town, and a major tragedy finally disperses the remaining inhabitants. The novel begins and ends with a framing device, as William Maginn, an Irish journal editor living in London, hears the story in the 1950s from an acquaintance and visits Dingle to find out more. Maginn acquires the deposition of the local priest, Father McGreevy, which then becomes the main part of the story. Brief accounts of Maginn’s meetings with two of the surviving community members follow the deposition. The novel concludes with an epilogue.
W Literary and Historical Context
The use of a frame (Maginn’s introduction and conclusion, in the case of The Deposition of Father McGreevy) is a common device in literature. It serves to set the scene and provide a broader context for the action. In the case of a story from the remote past, the frame may make the storyline more credible, as in Nathaniel Hawthorne’s handling of “The Custom House” in The Scarlet Letter (1850). The final section of the frame, which follows the
conclusion of the main story, may provide a resolution to the plot and/or an interpretation of it. In this novel, the existence of the frame allows for Maginn’s footnotes, which elucidate Irish terminology and explain literary and historical references. William Maginn is a fictional character, but an Irish journalist and editor of the same name lived and worked in London at the beginning of the nineteenth century. At the beginning of World War II, when the action of this novel takes place, Ireland had only recently emerged from several hundred years under repressive English rule. Following the Irish War of Independence in 1922, the southern part of the country had become the Irish Free State, and in 1948 it was renamed the Republic of Ireland. Over the preceding centuries, followers of the dominant religion, Roman Catholicism, had been denied the vote. The Irish language, known as Gaelic, had also been suppressed, although English had only become the majority language in the early to mid-nineteenth century. The Dingle Peninsula, where the novel is set, is one of the remaining areas of Ireland, known as Gaeltacht, where Irish is still spoken as a daily language. Prior to the arrival in Ireland of St. Patrick and other Christian missionaries in the fifth century, the indigenous Irish people followed a religion later known as Celtic polytheism. Despite the establishment of Christianity as the dominant religion of the country by missionaries, the rich body of mythology that accompanied the ancient religion was not suppressed. Folk beliefs, folktales, and folk heroes remained deeply ingrained in the Irish psyche, especially in remote country areas, even into the early 2000s.
W Themes A major theme of The Deposition of Father McGreevy is religious conservatism, as embodied by the traditional Irish Catholicism of Father McGreevy. McGreevy is a hardworking priest, dedicated to his parish and his flock, committed to his faith, and convinced that the church
336 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Deposition of Father McGreevy
plays a vital role in the survival of his village. But he is also narrow-minded and naive, and his conservative views and prejudices limit his ability to deal with elements in the remote mountain culture and to serve more fully his parishioners. Set in opposition to this theme is that of Ireland’s pre-Christian past and its survival in the form of various local beliefs. This is mainly exemplified in the character of old Biddy McGurk, McGreevy’s housekeeper. Her beliefs and practices, once they are discovered by McGreevy, result in the priest’s coming to view her as a witch. The best of Ireland’s Celtic culture is demonstrated by Muiris O’Sullivan, an Irish speaker and a repository of the preChristian legends. Associated with these themes is that of aberrant sexuality in the form of bestiality. McGreevy is horrified when he discovers the brain-damaged Tadgh engaged in a sex act with a sheep, but when he unburdens himself of this knowledge to Dr. McKenna, the doctor brushes him off, saying this is a common practice in remote areas. Later, however, when rumors of the practice reach
MAJOR CHARACTERS WILLIAM MAGINN is a London-based Irish journalist and distant relative of Father McGreevy. He manages to get a copy of McGreevy’s deposition and publishes an annotated version of it. FATHER HUGH MCGREEVY is the parish priest of a small hilltop village in the west of Ireland. He struggles unsuccessfully to keep the small community together. BIDDY MCGURK, Father McGreevy’s housekeeper, embraces traditions of old Ireland, much to McGreevy’s distress. MUIRIS O’SULLIVAN is one of the villagers whose wife dies during the epidemic. TADGH O’SULLIVAN, Muiris’s brain-damaged older son, is the unwitting cause of much of the village’s tragedy after McGreevy finds him copulating with a sheep.
Decaying buildings and homes make up the ruins of a deserted village in Ireland. The Deposition of Father McGreevy tells the story of a similarly abandoned Irish village in the 1940s. ª David Lyons / Alamy TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
337
The Deposition of Father McGreevy
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Born in 1934, in County Roscommon, Ireland, Brian O’Doherty studied medicine at Trinity College, Dublin, and Cambridge University Medical School. After a brief period working as a doctor, he immigrated to the United States in 1957 to conduct medical research at Harvard University. He then turned to the visual arts and became a sculptor, conceptual artist, and installation artist. In 1972, he began signing his work Patrick Ireland, in protest against the Bloody Sunday killings in Derry. He worked as an art historian and a filmmaker and wrote several books of art criticism in addition to two well-regarded novels. He taught film criticism for twenty years before becoming a professor of fine art at Long Island University. As of 2010, he lived on Long Island, New York, with his wife, art historian Barbara Novak.
Dingle, the villagers are abused and ostracized by the townspeople.
W Style The Deposition of Father McGreevy is written in the past tense. The prologue, the two chapters that follow the deposition, and the epilogue are narrated in the first person by William Maginn. The main body of the novel, called “The Priest’s Tale,” also in the first person, is in the voice of Father Hugh McGreevy, as recorded in his deposition to the local policeman in Dingle. Both narrators, and other characters whose voices are present in the novel, are native Irish speakers, meaning that Irish Gaelic is their first language. Maginn, as a journalist and an educated man, writes more or less Standard English. McGreevy’s section of the novel, however, is peppered with Gaelic words and phrases, which are translated in the footnotes. When the speech of the villagers is reported, it is frequently in what is known as Irish English, or Hibernian English, which differs from Standard English in its syntax and vocabulary, as in “Isn’t it glad I am that my little girl isn’t up here with the rest of us misfortunates” (254), for example. Biddy McGurk, especially in her decline as it is reported in the final chapter, uses frequent Irish English lexis, such as “Yiz is all the same, all of yiz. Little maneen with your hoity toity” (371). There are rich descriptions in McGreevy’s section, in which the priest describes the natural world, which to some extent seems to alleviate his pain and anxiety.
W Critical Reception The Deposition of Father McGreevy drew unqualified praise from many reviewers. Nicholas Lezard, writing in
338
Photo of Brian O’Doherty, author of the novel The Deposition of Father McGreevy. ª Sion Touhig/Sygma/Corbis
the Guardian, described it as “remarkable and haunting” and saw it as both “powerful and understated” and “beautifully told and beautifully modulated.” For Melanie McDonagh of the Evening Standard, it is “a wonderful novel.” She admired the novelist’s use of “direct speech of extraordinary fluency” and wrote that the novel “breathes a gentle humanity.” A reviewer in the Atlantic wrote that it is “a morbid tale, but holds one’s interest” and praised Brian O’Doherty’s “eloquent prose.” Even the few reviewers who faulted the novel generally did so while acknowledging that these were minor flaws in an otherwise fine work. David Lloyd, for example, reviewing the novel in World Literature Today, called it “engaging and convincing” and its relationships “heartbreakingly real” but found fault with the character of Muiris, who, having been silent throughout most of the novel, becomes “inexplicably chatty” at the end, and described the footnotes as dissonant and unnecessary. A review in Publishers Weekly criticized the style of Father McGreevy’s account, stating that it “veers between believable dialect and over-the-top stage-Irish.” This reviewer felt that “his first person narration can be hard to TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Deposition of Father McGreevy
take,” but he ended the review by acknowledging that “readers will surely enjoy the history and myth O’Doherty spins out.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
“The Deposition of Father McGreevy.” Rev. of The Deposition of Father McGreevy, by Brian O’Doherty. Atlantic May 1999: 130. Print. “The Deposition of Father McGreevy.” Rev. of The Deposition of Father McGreevy, by Brian O’Doherty. Publishers Weekly 246.7 (1999): 85. Print. Lezard, Nicholas. “Bad Faith.” Rev. of The Deposition of Father McGreevy, by Brian O’Doherty. guardian.co. uk. Guardian 21 July 2001. Web. 14 Oct. 2010. Lloyd, David. “Brian O’Doherty: The Deposition of Father McGreevy.” Rev. of The Deposition of Father McGreevy, by Brian O’Doherty. World Literature Today 76.1 (2002): 148+. Print. McDonagh, Melanie. “The Story That Shamed a Town.” Rev. of The Deposition of Father McGreevy, by Brian O’Doherty. thisislondon.co.uk. Evening Standard 16 Oct. 2000. Web. 14 Oct. 2010. O’Doherty, Brian. The Deposition of Father McGreevy. New York: Turtle Point Press Helen Marx Books, 1999. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Cline, David. “The Deposition of Father McGreevy.” Rev. of The Deposition of Father McGreevy, by Brian O’Doherty. Booklist 15 Apr. 1999: 1516. Print. Draws attention to Father McGreevy’s voice, as entirely convincing. Hogan, Kay. “The Deposition of Father McGreevy.” Rev. of The Deposition of Father McGreevy, by Brian O’Doherty. Library Journal 124.4 (1999): 111. Print. Praises the novel for its effective detail. MacDonald, Hugh. “The Deposition of Father McGreevy.” Rev. of The Deposition of Father McGreevy, by Brian O’Doherty. Herald 11 Aug. 2001. Print. Praises O’Doherty’s ability to articulate his characters’ sensibilities.
McNabb, Deirdre. “Damned Villagers.” Rev. of The Deposition of Father McGreevy, by Brian O’Doherty. Press, [New Zealand] 2001. Print. Notes that O’Doherty builds the plot to a crescendo is this gripping novel. Gale Resources
“Brian O’Doherty (1934-).” Contemporary Literary Criticism. Ed. Draper, James P., et al. Vol. 76. Detroit: Gale Research, 1993. 93-97. Literature Criticism Online. Web. 12 Oct. 2010. http:// galenet.galegroup.com/servlet/GLA/itsbtrial/ FJ3521050013 Open Web Sources
The Guardian Web site, available at http://www. guardian.co.uk/culture/2000/oct/13/artsfeatures. bookerprize2000, contains a report by Michael Ellison of a conversation with Brian O’Doherty after the October 2000 announcement that The Deposition of Father McGreevy had been short-listed for the Man Booker Prize. For Further Reading
Bartlett, Thomas. Ireland: A History. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 2010. Print. A comprehensive survey of Ireland’s history, politics, society, and culture, from prehistory to the early 2000s. Hickey, Raymond. Irish English: History and Present-Day Forms. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 2007. Print. A study tracing the development of Irish English from the late Middle Ages to the early 2000s. Hindley, Reg. The Death of the Irish Language: A Qualified Obituary. London: Routledge, 1991. Print. Studies the decline of Irish Gaelic and locates the areas where it survived as of the late 1990s. Moore-McCann, Brenda. Brian O’Doherty/Patrick Ireland: Between Categories. Farnham: Lund Humphries, 2009. Print. In-depth study of the works of Brian O’Doherty, both literary and visual. O’Doherty, Brian. The Strange Case of Mademoiselle P. New York: Pantheon, 1992. Print. Set in eighteenthcentury Vienna, a fictionalized account of Dr. Franz Mesmer, inventor of animal magnetism or hypnotism.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Harriet Devine
339
The Dew Breaker By Edwidge Danticat
W Introduction The Dew Breaker has been described as an unconventional novel that tells its story through a series of loosely related vignettes that deal with the emotional devastation left by torture. The book’s central figure is a Haitian-born barber in Brooklyn, New York, whose daughter, an artist named Ka, believes he was imprisoned under the dictatorship of François Duvalier in the 1960s. When Ka finds out that her father was in fact employed by the state as a torturer, everything she believes is thrown into question. Stephen M. Deusner, reviewing The Dew Breaker for Bookreporter.com, described the succeeding chapters: “The story-chapters that follow travel back and forth between New York and Haiti, between the unfulfilled hope of America and the crushing disillusion of the island country. But each segment of the novel somehow refers back to Ka’s father and the agony and misery he inflicted on his people.” In the end, Ka—and the reader—finds that the situation is far more complex, and ultimately unknowable, than it at first appears.
W Literary and Historical Context
In Haitian Creole terminology, the term “dew breaker” refers to the government-sponsored torturers of the Duvalier regime who arrived at dawn, disturbing the fresh dew on the grass, to arrest their victims. This secret police was known as the Tontons Macoutes, or “Bogeymen,” instituted by Haitian President François Duvalier in response to concerns that the new revolutionary leader of Cuba, Fidel Castro, and Dominican dictator General Rafael Trujillo might mount an attack on Haiti. Duvalier also feared opponents within his own country, particularly after his fraudulent 1961 presidential victory that led the United States to suspend all diplomatic ties to Haiti.
Undeterred, in 1964 Duvalier had Haiti’s constitution changed to name him “president for life.” Duvalier had been a respected physician and campaigner against disease in Haiti, who studied at the University of Michigan for a time and served as Minister of Health and Labor under Haitian President Dumarsais Estimé. He had opposed the takeover of the Estimé government by Paul Magloire in 1950, for which he was forced to go into hiding. In 1956 Magloire announced a truce with his political opponents, and his military government collapsed. Duvalier came out of exile and declared his intention to run for president. With the broad support of the people and running on a platform promising to end elitism and return Haiti to its African roots—including the official support of voodoo, of which Duvalier was an avid practitioner—Duvalier easily won the election in 1957 and became known as “Papa Doc.” His presidency was threatened, however, by insurgents, and in response Duvalier imposed ever-tighter military controls, including the creation of the Tontons Macoutes to act as his first line of security. By 1963 Duvalier had developed a cult of personality around himself, centered largely on his self-proclaimed status as a semidivinity and voodoo sorcerer. In the 1960s the Tontons Macoutes was responsible for killing as many as 60,000 Haitians, and thousands more fled the country to escape crushing poverty. In 1971 Duvalier had the Haitian constitution amended to declare his son, JeanClaude, president upon his death, which occurred in April of that year. At just nineteen years old, Jean-Claude had little interest in running Haiti. Upon pressure from the United States, he agreed to some reforms, but his regime was rife with corruption, and under his control the country plunged further into poverty, unemployment, and illiteracy. Additionally, the Tontons Macoutes continued to terrorize the citizenry. In 1986, however, a massive popular uprising rendered the “dew breakers” powerless, and Jean-Claude was forced into exile in France. Although he was accused of embezzling as much as $800 million from Haiti during his presidency, he
340 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Dew Breaker
MAJOR CHARACTERS ANNE is the unnamed Dew Breaker’s wife. She is a native of Haiti and the sister of her husband’s last torture victim there. She is a figure of forgiveness and redemption, although it is unclear in the book if she knows the whole of her husband’s past. BEATRICE is a seamstress who is convinced that her Haitian torturer is one of her neighbors in Brooklyn. DANY is a Haitian immigrant whose parents were the victims of political violence. He is obsessed with finding and murdering the Dew Breaker. THE DEW BREAKER is the unnamed torturer from the Duvalier regime, who brutally beat and killed numerous Haitians. Now living quietly in Brooklyn as a barber and landlord, the Dew Breaker appears to have redeemed himself, although his past actions continue to torment those around him. KA is the daughter of Anne and the Dew Breaker. She is a thirtyyear-old artist living in Brooklyn who grows up believing her father was a political prisoner in Haiti and learns the truth only as an adult.
A Haitian militia member. In Dew Breaker, Ka, a young Haitian woman living in Brooklyn, learns that her father was once a torturer under Haitian dictator François Duvalier. Romano Cagnoni/Getty Images
remains in France, and as of 2010 Swiss courts ruled that he could reclaim the $6 million in assets that had been frozen in accounts since his exile began in 1986.
W Themes The primary theme of The Dew Breaker is the lifelong aftermath of the experience of torture and terror, for both victim and perpetrator, and the possibility of redemption. After the initial chapter, “The Book of the Dead”—in which Ka and her father travel to Florida to deliver a sculpture she has made of him to a wealthy buyer, her father destroys the statue en route, and then recounts the story of his past to his shocked daughter—the chapters of The Dew Breaker each focus on someone either in New York or Haiti, and it gradually becomes clear that they have all been affected in some way by the work of the torturer. In “The Bridal Seamstress” an older woman who works as a seamstress in New York and is highly regarded for her work making wedding dresses, insists she
lives on the same street as the man who tortured her in Haiti. Although she bears the scars from his beatings, the house she says he lives in is vacant, and her sanity is questioned by other characters, although the reader knows she is talking about the barber, Ka’s father. Other chapters feature the friends and family members of his victims, and in the final chapter, “The Dew Breaker,” readers are taken back to the Duvalier era in Haiti, where Ka’s father is depicted torturing and killing a preacher so brutally that even his superiors are stunned. Out in the street he meets a woman named Anne, whom he marries and moves with to New York. Here it is revealed that the Dew Breaker’s wife is the sister of the preacher he killed; he credits her with saving his soul, and their daughter, Ka, comes to understand the full complexity of her parents’ experience. In an interview on National Public Radio's Tavis Smiley show, Edwidge Danticat discussed the many facets of character in a single person and how she developed the character of the dew breaker: “I wanted him to be human in the way that we’re all human. I think often when we categorize people so simplistically; we either hate them or we love them, or they’re great or they’re angels or they’re saints, especially people who are put in front of us as leaders. And we take these people and give them halos or give them horns. And I think it’s never as simple as that. I think most of us are somewhere in between. But we have to understand the environments that create these types of people, and fiction allows one to do that.”
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
341
The Dew Breaker
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Edwidge Danticat was born in Port-au-Prince, Haiti, in 1969. Her father immigrated to the United States when she was two years old, and her mother two years later. Danticat and her younger brother lived with an uncle until her parents could afford to send for them eight years later. When she arrived in Brooklyn at the age of twelve, Danticat spoke no English and had a difficult time adjusting to American life. Nonetheless, she went on to attend Barnard College, graduating in 1990 with a degree in French literature. Next she received her master’s degree in creative writing from Brown University. Danticat has won numerous prizes and awards for her fiction, including a MacArthur “genius” grant in 2009.
W Style
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Several of the chapters of The Dew Breaker were first published as short stories, and critics have noted that most are able to stand on their own merits. Some reviews call the book a short story collection, while others maintain that it is a novel. The book’s chapters are tied together by the sense that all the characters are haunted by what they experienced in Haiti. Stylistically, this novel follows closely in the Haitian tradition of historically based fiction immersed in the politics, culture, physical surroundings, and popular storytelling forms of the Haitian people. The stories in The Dew Breaker revolve primarily around displaced Haitians and a network of Haitian-Americans whose lives have been impacted by the dew breaker in the past. The first tale in the novel, according to Danticat, focuses on “telling stories from the point of view of people who hurt us as opposed to the people that are hurt.” The following eight stories intertwine the personal histories of Haitians whose lives have been marked by a dew breaker’s acts of violence. Danticat employs a variety of broken communications to relate the fractured nature of the Haitian-American experience: “ . . . dropped cell phone calls; unplayed answering machine messages; sleep-talking; miscommunication in English-as-a-second-language classes; recognition and non-recognition between fathers, sons, and brothers; fellow expatriates mistakenly . . . identified as former Macoute torturers,” according to Kevin Meehan and Bernadette A. Davis. This technique effectivey portrays the sense of displacement and the struggle to maintain contact and communication that diasporic characters experience.
W Critical Reception The Dew Breaker was widely praised by critics, who found Danticat’s restrained storytelling to be a perfect foil for the
342
outrageous crimes she recounts. According to New York Times book editor Michiko Kakutani, The Dew Breaker is “Ms. Danticat’s most persuasive, organic performance yet. As seamless as it is compelling, the novel recounts its harrowing tale in limpid, understated prose, using a looping structure of overlapping stories to tell the Dew Breaker’s story by indirection.” Robert McCormick, reviewing the book for World Literature Today, found the story of the Dew Breaker too elliptical, and blamed the book’s construction as a series of short stories for what he sees as lapses in Danticat’s disclosure of vital information. Regardless of the fine line the book treads between novel and story collection, however, Sam McManis, writing for the Chicago Sun-Times, notes that Danticat’s writing ability cannot be faulted. The stories in The Dew Breaker, he writes, are “presented in sparkling prose that evokes sentiment but never descends into sentimentality. It is tough, muscular writing, unsparing as an executioner. Danticat chills your spine as she breaks your heart.”
Works Cited
Cox, Tony. “Interview: Edwidge Danticat Discusses Her New Book, The Dew Breaker.” Tavis Smiley, National Public Radio. Web. 18 Mar. 2004. Deusner, Stephen M. “The Dew Breaker.” Bookreporter. com. Web. 5 Sept. 2010. Kakutani, Michiko. “Books of the Times; Hiding from a Brutal Past Spent Shattering Lives in Haiti.” New York Times, 10 Mar. 2004. Web. 8 Sept. 2010. McCormick, Robert. Rev. of The Dew Breaker, by Edwidge Danticat. World Literature Today, 1 Jan. 2005. Print. McManis, Sam. “The Heartbreaking Horrors of Haiti.” Chicago Sun-Times, 21 Mar. 2004. Print. Meehan, Kevin, and Bernadette A. Davis. “Edwidge Danticat.” Dictionary of Literary Biography. Ed. Wanda H. Giles and James R. Giles. Vol. 350. Detroit Gale, 2009. Literature Resource Center. Web. 12 Sept. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Cobham, Rhonda. “The Penance of Speech.” Women’s Review of Books, 21.8 (May 2004): 2-3. Print. Rpt. in Short Story Criticism. Ed. Jelena O. Krstovic. Vol. 100. Detroit: Gale, 2007. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 12 Sept. 2010. Gibb, Lorna. “The Torturer’s Wife.” Times Literary Supplement 5275 (7 May 2004): 22. Print. Rpt. in Short Story Criticism. Ed. Jelena O. Krstovic. Vol. 100. Detroit: Gale, 2007. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 12 Sept. 2010. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Dew Breaker
Valbrun, Marjorie. Rev. of The Dew Breaker, by Edwidge Danticat. Black Issues Book Review, 6.4 (July-Aug. 2004): 43. Print. Rpt. in Short Story Criticism. Ed. Jelena O. Krstovic. Vol. 100. Detroit: Gale, 2007. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 12 Sept. 2010. Watman, Max. “Not to Comment, but to Illustrate.” New Criterion, 22.9 (May 2004): 58-65. Print. Rpt. in Short Story Criticism. Ed. Jelena O. Krstovic. Vol. 100. Detroit: Gale, 2007. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 12 Sept. 2010. Gale Resources
“Edwidge Danticat.” Contemporary Authors Online. Web. 12 Sept. 2010. “Edwidge Danticat.” Contemporary Literary Criticism Select. Detroit: Gale. Literature Resource Center. Web. 12 Sept. 2010. Open Web Sources
“Times Topics: Edwidge Danticat.” http://ww.nytimes. com. http://topics.nytimes.com/topics/reference/ timestopics/people/d/edwidge_danticat/index.html Web. 8 Sept. 2010.
Union, 25 Apr. 2004. Web. 8 Sept. 2010. Interview in which Danticat discusses her creative process, as well as her personal feelings about her character the Dew Breaker. Norris, Michele. “Interview: Edwidge Danticat Discusses Her New Book The Dew Breaker and the Country of Haiti.” All Things Considered, National Public Radio, 15 Mar. 2004. Broadcast. Interview in which Danticat explains how she views the character of the dew breaker, as well as the pride Haitians feel for their country. Press, Joy. “The Dew Breaker.” Village Voice, 24 Mar. 2004. Print. Interview with Danticat in which she discusses how spending her childhood in Haiti affected her, as well as the experience of learning about one’s parents’ pasts. Danticat, Edwidge. “Less Than Human.” Progressive, Dec. 2007. Web. 8 Sept. 2010. Danticat’s written testimony to the U.S. Congress on the mysterious death of her elderly uncle—and other immigrants— while in the custody of the Department of Homeland Security and Immigration and Customs Enforcement in Miami.
For Further Reading
Barnes, Steve. “Ghosts of Haiti; Novelist Edwidge Danticat’s Dew Breaker Explores the Echoes of the Island’s Violent Past and Present.” Albany Times-
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Nancy Dziedzic
343
Diary of a Bad Year By J. M. Coetzee
W Introduction Diary of a Bad Year (2007) by J. M. Coetzee chronicles one year (2005) in the life of C, an aging author who enlists the services of Anya, a twenty-nine-year-old beauty, to transcribe for a German publisher a series of essays called “Strong Opinions.” Jealous of the affection developing between Anya and C, Anya’s boyfriend, Alan, installs spyware on C’s computer, giving him access to the writer’s financial holdings, which are considerably larger than Anya and Alan would have guessed. The novel has been praised for an intricate three-part structure in which each of the pages is divided into halves or thirds. One of C’s essays, or “strong opinions,” appears at the top of every page. Subjects for these pieces cover a wide range of topics, including pedophilia, intelligent design, the failings of the British prime minister Tony Blair, animal rights, and the torture of political prisoners. Below the essay, C records his feelings for Anya in a diary entry. Often below the diary entry is a third section featuring snippets of Anya and Alan’s running conversation about the quality of C’s work and the ethical implications of manipulating his finances. By separating each page in this manner, Coetzee elucidates the novel’s ethical concerns in essay form and in dramatic form simultaneously.
W Literary and Historical Context
Diary of a Bad Year is set in 2005, when a coalition led by the United States and the United Kingdom was fighting in Afghanistan and Iraq. These two operations were the largest campaigns in what the coalition called the war on terror, a global military effort directed against radical Islamist terror organizations and the regimes suspected of supporting them. The war on terror began
in 2001, when the coalition sent troops to Afghanistan to fight al-Qaeda, a terrorist organization believed to be responsible for attacks on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon on September 11, 2001. In 2003 the coalition invaded Iraq in response to dubious intelligence reports that established a link between President Saddam Hussein and al-Qaeda. The reports also cited evidence that Hussein was storing weapons of mass destruction in Iraq. In the following year, 2004, reports appeared claiming that the U.S. government sanctioned the torture of political prisoners detained at the Abu Ghraib facility in Baghdad, Iraq, and at the Guantánamo Bay facility in Cuba. Soldiers at these holding centers were allegedly forcing confessions from inmates by using electrocution, rape, and more sophisticated techniques, such as strappado hanging and waterboarding, which leave no physical marks on the victim. Grouchy and polemical through most of the first half of Diary of a Bad Year, Coetzee’s narrator reserves the worst of his bile for U.S. president George W. Bush and U.K. prime minister Tony Blair. Of what awaits Bush, C writes in mythological terms: “In the outrages that he and his servants perform, notably the outrage of torture, and in his hubristic claim to be above the law, the younger Bush challenges the gods, and by the very shamelessness of that challenge assures that the gods will visit punishment on the children and grandchildren of his house.” The narrator calls Blair a man with “no moral compass save personal ambition.” The novel also considers the politics of contemporary Australia, where Coetzee took up residence in 2002 and where the narrator of Diary of a Bad Year also lives. The narrator considers John Howard, who served as prime minister of Australia from 1996 to 2007, a fiscal conservative in the tradition of U.S. president Ronald Reagan and U.K. prime minister Margaret Thatcher and laments that, given Howard’s support of the Bush administration, Australia may be losing some of its old charm. The narrator writes, “What I liked best about Australia, when I first visited in the 1990s was the way in
344 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Diary of a Bad Year
which people conducted themselves in their everyday dealings: frankly, fairly, with an elusive personal pride and an equally elusive ironic reserve. Now, fifteen years later, I hear the sense of self embodied in that conduct disparaged in many quarters as belonging to an Australia of a past now outmoded.” He concludes this thought by noting that “Australian society may never—thank God!— become as selfish and cruel as American society, but it does seem to be sleepwalking in that direction.”
W Themes Comprising fifty-five diverse essays and a subplot involving both Anya’s romantic love for Alan and her platonic love for C, Diary of a Bad Year covers a wide range of themes. Underpinning all of the novel’s darker musings is the idea that the transformative power of art may trump the worst of what humans have wrought. The narrator concludes the essay “On National Shame,” a piece about the torture of the detainees at Guantánamo Bay, with a reflection about a performance of the Finnish composer Jean Sibelius’s fifth symphony. He wonders how a Finn would have reacted to hearing the piece the first time it was performed in Helsinki one hundred years ago and concludes that such a person “would have felt proud, proud that one of us could put together such sounds, proud that out of nothing we human beings can make such stuff.” Turning his thoughts back to Guantánamo, the narrator observes, “Musical creation on the one hand, a machine for inflicting torture on the other: the best and the worst that human beings are capable of.” Here, early in the novel, the narrator gives vice and virtue equal measure. However, as the subplot develops and as the narrator warms to Anya, his opinions gradually soften. By the end of the novel, the scales tip in favor of art. The last two pieces in the book are tributes to the German composer Johann Sebastian Bach and the Russian writer Fyodor Dostoyevsky. The narrator argues that “the best proof we have that life is good, and therefore that there may perhaps be a god after all is that to each of us, on the day we are born, comes the music of Johann Sebastian Bach. It comes as a gift, unearned, unmerited, for free.” The last essay focuses on a moment in Dostoyevsky’s The Brothers Karamazov when Ivan returns to God his ticket to the universe because the world is too terrible. Although the narrator of Diary of a Bad Year may have begun rejecting the world as Ivan does, by the end of the novel he is overwhelmed with tears, sobbing with joy because he lives in a world where such a book exists.
W Style Coetzee introduces the novel’s three-part structure gradually. Initially he splits each page in half with a line
MAJOR CHARACTERS ALAN is a forty-two-year-old financial planner and Anya’s live-in boyfriend. He devises what he believes is a foolproof plan to skim off some of the interest of Señor C’s financial holdings, but Anya calls a halt to the scheme. ANYA is a twenty-nine-year-old former model enlisted by Señor C to type the recorded versions of his essays. As the novel progresses, Anya’s role in the writer’s life and work grows with her first critiquing and editing some of the pieces and eventually serving as Señor C’s protector and muse. JOHN C, or Señor C as he is called by Anya and Alan, is a seventy-one-year-old writer who has been asked by a German publisher to submit a set of essays to be released alongside the work of five other leading writers under the title “Strong Opinions.”
separating the essay at the top of the page from the diary entry at the bottom. The opening diary entries chart the narrator’s attempts to enlist Anya’s services as a typist. About twenty-five pages in, after Anya agrees to help, Coetzee introduces the third strand of the novel, breaking the page with another line and placing Anya and Alan’s conversations about the narrator at the bottom third of the page. Initially the three sets of prose are distinct and self-contained. The essays may run for a couple of pages, but each diary entry is concluded on one page, as is each snippet of conversation. The voice and subjects of the early essays are unaffected by the material below. Gradually this structure changes, and the parts begin to overlap and converge on each other. Anya begins to criticize some of the essays, causing the narrator to write more in his diary and to soften his tone in his essays. The diary entries grow longer, spilling onto the next page. Recognizing that her criticism is heard, Anya warms to the narrator; her boyfriend notices, and the conversations at the bottom of each page become longer. Suddenly the reader has to decide how to read the novel: whether to read each page top to bottom or to read each part to its conclusion and double back to finish the other parts. One effect this structure—especially juxtaposing the personal essays and diary entries of a narrator bearing the same initials and living in the same town as the book’s author—is to tempt the reader into viewing Diary of a Bad Year as a confession in which Coetzee airs his political views in the essays and his private insecurities in the diary entries. At times Coetzee seems to warn readers not to regard the novel this way. For example, when Anya assumes that she knows the narrator’s soul because she has read a few of his essays, he says to her, “Tread
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
345
Diary of a Bad Year
carefully. You may be seeing less of my inmost depths than you believe.”
W Critical Reception Diary of a Bad Year has earned predominately negative reviews, with critics agreeing for the most part that Coetzee’s formal experimentation is tedious, that the characters are banal, and that the novel is not a worthy successor to the works that earned the author a Nobel Prize in 2003. A reviewer for Publishers Weekly notes that “Anya is little more than a trophy to be disputed, and Alan as an unscrupulous, boorish reactionary is a caricature.” The reviewer goes on to claim that while
“C’s essays, especially the later ones inspired by Anya, hold some interest,” Diary of a Bad Year “is not one of Coetzee’s major efforts.” Writing for the Observer, Adam Mars-Jones argues that the novel’s “ambitions to threedimensional status are fitful—it bears the same relationship to a novel as a hologram does to a sculpture.” Among the harsher voices, an Atlantic reviewer declares that “the main action of Coetzee’s disjointed novel consists of C’s contemplating his navel and reflecting, endlessly and not very artfully, a seemingly limitless disgust.” A reviewer for Kirkus agrees, suggesting that “there’s something wrong with a novel in which a twisted, exploitative sexual relationship is far less interesting than are dozens of pages of discursive commentary.”
Photograph of J. M. Coetzee, author of Diary of a Bad Year. ª Micheline Pelletier/Corbis
346
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Diary of a Bad Year
Critics who have praised the book have found the main character sympathetically drawn and the novel’s resolution satisfying. Writing in the Telegraph, Caroline Moore calls Diary of a Bad Year “a thoroughly unselfpitying portrayal of loneliness: of an old man, stranded in a foreign country and left behind by the tides of change.” Christopher Tayler, reviewing the work for the Guardian, finds the novel to be “funnier than anything else” Coetzee has written and argues that by the end, the book “becomes unexpectedly moving, offering surprises while avoiding a final thunderclap with the restraint that Coetzee’s readers have learned to expect.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Coetzee, J. M. Diary of a Bad Year. London: Vintage, 2007. Print. Rev. of Diary of a Bad Year, by J. M. Coetzee. Atlantic Mar. 2008: 104+. Rev. of Diary of a Bad Year, by J. M. Coetzee. Kirkus Reviews 15 Dec. 2009: n. pag. Rev. of Diary of a Bad Year, by J. M. Coetzee. Publishers Weekly 17 Sept. 2007: 31. Mars-Jones, Adam. “Even Nobel Winners Can Make Mistakes.” Rev. of Diary of a Bad Year, by J. M. Coetzee. Observer [London]. Guardian News and Media Ltd, 26 Aug. 2007. Web. 10 Oct 2010. Moore, Caroline. “The Prejudices of an Ageing, Lonely Writer.” Rev. of Diary of a Bad Year, by J. M. Coetzee. Telegraph [London]. Telegraph Media Group, 13 Sept. 2007. Web. 10 Oct. 2010. Tayler, Christopher. “Just Like Life.” Rev. of Diary of a Bad Year, by J. M. Coetzee. Guardian [London]. Guardian News and Media Ltd, 1 Sept. 2007. Web. 10 Oct. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Chapman, Michael. “The Case of Coetzee: South African Literary Criticism, 1990 to Today.” Journal of Literary Studies 26.2 (2010): 103+. Argues that with the political ambivalence of Life and Times of Michael K and Disgrace and the formal innovations of Elizabeth Costello and Diary of a Bad Year, Coetzee may be drawing critics’ attention away from political issues and back to what Chapman calls “the intricacies of the text,” as Jane Austen and Joseph Conrad did with their stylistic innovations. Collellmir Morales, Dolors. “J. M. Coetzee’s Diary of a Bad Year: Ethical and Novelistic Awareness.” Miscelanea 40.2 (2009). Web. 9 Oct. 2010. Claims that by the end of the book, as the material from the three parts of each page overlaps and converges, Coetzee achieves the unity of a traditional novel.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR J. M. Coetzee, winner of the 2003 Nobel Prize in Literature, has published twenty volumes of fiction and nonfiction in a career spanning more than thirty-five years. He was born on February 9, 1940, in South Africa to parents of Afrikaner descent and studied English literature and mathematics at the University of Cape Town. In the early 1960s Coetzee moved to London, where he worked as a computer programmer while completing the requirements for an MA in English from the University of Cape Town. In 1965 Coetzee quit programming to focus exclusively on literature, enrolling in the University of Texas on a Fulbright scholarship and completing a PhD in linguistics in 1969. Coetzee began to establish his literary reputation with his third novel, Waiting for the Barbarians (1980), which was well received by critics, if not widely read. In 1983 Coetzee won the first of his two Man Booker Prizes for Life and Times of Michael K, the story of a simpleton forced to live off the land in the South African countryside. The second Booker Prize came in 1999 for Disgrace, which most readers and critics regard as Coetzee’s masterwork. In 2006 Coetzee obtained Australian citizenship. He currently resides in Adelaide with his partner, Dorothy Driver, a fellow academic.
Deresiewicz, William. “Foes.” Nation 25 Feb. 2008. Web. 9 Oct. 2010. Compares Coetzee’s novel to Philip Roth’s Exit, Ghost, citing both works as part of a small emerging canon of contemporary books about old age. Also claims that the essays that appear embedded in Diary of a Bad Year and Elizabeth Costello are more interesting and elegant than the nonfiction Coetzee has published in recent years. Mantel, Hilary. “The Shadow Line.” New York Review of Books 17 Jan. 2008. Web. 9 Oct. 2010. Contrasts C’s robust voice on the top third of each page with his equivocations below the page breaks, noting how over the course of the novel, C’s opinions soften and his character recedes, while Anya comes to inhabit the moral center of the novel. Marcus, David. “The Ambivalence Artist.” Dissent 56.1 (2009): 115+. Project Muse. Web. 10 Oct. 2010. Argues that whereas in the three works immediately preceding the novel Coetzee had adopted a direct and confessional style, in Diary of a Bad Year he returns to the ambivalence of his earlier work, in which, Marcus claims, Coetzee’s position on the ideas he examines is considerably more difficult, if not impossible, to ascertain. Ruttenburg, Nancy, and Mark Sanders. “Introduction: J. M. Coetzee and His Doubles.” Journal of Literary Studies 25.4 (2009): 1+. Asserts that Coetzee uses characters who are authors to examine the limits of a
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
347
Diary of a Bad Year
writer’s authority over the characters and ideas in his or her text. Spencer, Robert. “J. M. Coetzee and Colonial Violence.” Interventions 10.2 (2008): 173+. Web. 9 Oct. 2010. Suggests that whereas Coetzee’s Waiting for the Barbarians revives in readers “a moral and ultimately political sensibility” that rejects torture, Diary of a Bad Year makes an “unusually explicit” call for action against the hateful ideologies that sanction such violence. Wood, James. “Squall Lines.” New Yorker 24 Dec. 2007: 140. Traces the themes of dishonor and cruelty throughout Coetzee’s oeuvre and examines the similarities in structure and content between Diary of a Bad Year and Elizabeth Costello, one of Coetzee’s previous novels. Gale Resources
“J. M. Coetzee.” Authors and Artists for Young Adults. Vol. 37. Detroit: Gale, 2000. Biography Resource Center. Web. 25 Aug. 2010. “J. M. Coetzee.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Literature Resource Center. Web. 25 Aug. 2010. “J. M. Coetzee (1940-).” Contemporary Literary Criticism. Ed. Janet Witalec. Vol. 161. Detroit: Gale, 2003. 205-56. Literature Criticism Online. Web. 25 Aug. 2010. Marais, Michael. “J. M. Coetzee.” South African Writers. Ed. Paul A. Scanlon. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 225. Detroit: Gale, 2000. Literature Resource Center. Web. 25 Aug. 2010. Marais, Michael, and Merritt Moseley. “J. M. Coetzee.” Nobel Prize Laureates in Literature, Part 1. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 329. Detroit: Gale, 2007. Literature Resource Center. Web. 25 Aug. 2010. Open Web Sources
The official Web site of the Nobel Prize provides videos of Coetzee’s Nobel lecture, banquet speech, and receipt of the Nobel Prize in Literature. http:// nobelprize.org/mediaplayer/index.php?id=555 Kultur & Noje, a Swedish online newspaper, features Coetzee’s interview with David Attwell, considered one of the world’s leading authorities on Coetzee’s work. Attwell speaks with Coetzee about the 2003 Nobel Prize and the writers who have influenced Coetzee’s fiction. http://www.dn.se/kultur-noje/ an-exclusive-interview-with-j-m-coetzee-1.227254 Michael Tomasky, American editor-at-large for the British newspaper the Guardian, discusses a Republican Party-funded commercial that criticizes U.S. President Barack Obama’s plan to incarcerate prisoners currently held at Guantánamo Bay in prisons on the U.S.
348
mainland. http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentis free/michaeltomasky/video/2009/may/08/obamarepublican-attack-ad-guantanamo-detainees Writing for BOOK Southern Africa, an Internet newspaper that reviews South African books, Peter Singer, Australian philosopher and professor of bioethics at Princeton University, discusses the ethical problems of sex and race, the treatment of animals, and the role of reason in Coetzee’s work. http://book.co.za/ blog/2010/08/05/podcast-peter-singer-on-coet zee-and-ethics-plus-cbc-interview-with-coetzee/ For Further Reading
Blair, Tony. A Journey: My Political Life. New York: Knopf, 2010. Print. The former British prime minister offers his account of the decision to back the U.S.-led war in Iraq as well as justifications of other questionable policies. Two of the narrator’s essays in Diary of a Bad Year explicitly criticize Blair’s leadership, and several others discuss the failures of the coalition in Iraq and Afghanistan. Coetzee, J. M. Disgrace. New York: Penguin, 2008. Print. Considered Coetzee’s masterwork, this novel examines the manner in which Lucie Lurie, a rape victim, responds to police indifference and to the dishonor foisted upon her by her father and her neighbors in the aftermath of the crime. In Diary of a Bad Year, the narrator’s argument with Anya over who suffers the greater dishonor in a rape, the rapist or the victim, almost ends the narrator’s relationship with his typist. ———. Elizabeth Costello. New York: Penguin, 2004. Print. Similar to Diary of a Bad Year, this novel uses an inventive structure to give the main character a platform for discussing ethical issues. Throughout the book, the aging novelist Elizabeth Costello attends lectures and gives speeches on topics including the ethical treatment of animals, the role of the absurd in the works of the German writer Franz Kafka, and sexual dynamics between men and women. Coll, Steve. Ghost Wars: The Secret History of the CIA, Afghanistan, and Bin Laden, from the Soviet Invasion to September 10, 2001. New York: Penguin, 2004. Print. Coll, an editor for the Washington Post who covered Afghanistan from 1989 to 1992, offers a comprehensive study of the failure of American intelligence operations and the rise of the Taliban and al-Qaeda in Afghanistan in the years leading up to September 11, 2001. Several of the entries in Diary of a Bad Year cite the failures of American politics in the Middle East and Afghanistan from the Cold War through the present day. Hirst, John. Sense and Nonsense in Australian History. Melbourne: Black, 2009. Print. One of the chapters in Hirst’s book examines the dispossession of Aboriginal Australians and their wars with white TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Diary of a Bad Year
Australians. Coetzee’s narrator in Diary of a Bad Year cites Hirst’s book in an entry that considers whether white Australians should apologize to Aboriginal Australians for taking their land. Leist, Anton, and Peter Singer, eds. J. M. Coetzee and Ethics: Philosophical Perspectives on Literature. New York: Columbia UP, 2010. Print. This anthology of essays by contemporary philosophers examines Coetzee’s treatment of such ethical issues as the relationship between humans and animals, the dynamics of
sex between men and women, the possibility of justice in postcolonial society, and the origin of moral values. Roth, Philip. Exit, Ghost. New York: Vintage, 2008. Print. Like Señor C, Nathan Zuckerman, the main character in Roth’s novel, is an aging writer who falls in love with a twenty-something beautiful woman who is in a troubled relationship.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Joseph Campana
349
Dirt Music By Tim Winton
W Introduction Tim Winton’s Dirt Music (2001) examines the journey for personal change undertaken by forty-year-old lost soul Georgie Jutland and by Luther Fox, a musician in his thirties who has been trapped for three years by the grief of losing his entire family. Despite the small-town social stricture that seems to forbid their being together, Georgie and Luther fall in love and help each other begin to heal and grow. Composed over a decade, Dirt Music is memorable for its vivid depictions of Western Australian landscapes. The novel won the 2001 Western Australia Premier’s Book Awards for fiction and overall; the 2002 Book of the Year Award from the Australian Booksellers Association; the 2002 Miles Franklin Award; the 2002 Christina Stead Prize for Fiction from the New South Wales Premier’s Literary Awards; and was short-listed for the 2002 Man Booker Prize for fiction.
W Literary and Historical Context
Settled by Europeans beginning in the eighteenth century, twenty-first-century Australia is largely populated by immigrants and dislocated natives. Historically, Australia provided a place where immigrants could redefine themselves, but as Europeans arrived, the aboriginal way of life was threatened and indigenous people had to cope with sharing the land with these newcomers. The country’s history engendered a literature that deals with selfdiscovery, written by people who examined the landscape and their own identities as immigrants and natives. For example, at the turn of the twentieth century, Barbara Baynton wrote short stories about ordinary life in the bush. Another author connected to the setting is Henry Lawson, particularly remembered for his character, Jack Mitchell, who exemplifies the Australian bush philosopher.
Nearly a century later, Australian identity is still an unresolved problem that writers address. Christos Tsiolkas, son of Greek immigrants to Australia, wrote about this identity crisis in his award-winning novel The Slap (2008). Peter Carey deals with issues of postcolonialism in his novels as modern Australia strives to be more independent of influences from the United Kingdom, the United States, and Japan. Winton, with his focus on Australian landscapes and environmentalism, writing about strong women and damaged men, is an important part of the literary identity of Australia in the early twenty-first century.
W Themes Salvation is a key theme in Dirt Music. Georgie and Luther are each on a quest of personal discovery, having reached a point in their lives where something must change, for better or for worse. Luther is the source of salvation for both Georgie and himself. Georgie, who has been adrift in her life since she lost her call to nursing, rediscovers her instincts to care and nurture in her love for Luther. With Georgie as his catalyst, Luther returns to his music, which helps him resolve his grief and move on with his life. Jim is also on a quest of personal discovery. Circumscribed by family history, Jim wants to rise above the brutish Buckridge past, but he ultimately fails to find salvation. He seeks out Luther on a mad journey into the backcountry of Western Australia, but Jim cannot completely articulate what he needs from Luther, and so he cannot find him. Salvation, in this novel, is a deeply emotive experience. “Music wants to be heard. Feeling wants to be felt” (362), Georgie thinks to herself near the end of the novel while looking for Luther. Luther’s emotions are reflected in his music, a music that is raw, visceral, and rises up out of the land, plucked by his hand. Georgie expresses herself physically, by swimming, cooking, saving a woman who has been in a car accident, and renovating the Fox farmhouse. Salvation in Dirt
350 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Dirt Music
Music is personal, earthy, and uplifting in this novel that otherwise tends toward grimness.
W Style Setting is an important aspect of Winton’s style. Establishing the time and place of a story, setting can be general or specific, actual or fictitious, but it is typically significant to the plot. In the case of Dirt Music, the setting is specific, significant, and a combination of actual and fictitious. The novel is set in Western Australia during the early twenty-first century; however, the small town of White Point and Coronation Bay and its archipelago are fictional. Winton, who grew up in Western Australia, often makes the landscape a vivid, sensual part of the story—almost a character in itself. In Dirt Music, Winton takes his readers from the windy southwest coast, across the floodplain farmland just inland to the arid mulga country, into the colorful Pilbara region, and finally to the tropical northern coast. Western Australia’s landscape is varied, loud, vibrant, and emotive, making it the perfect setting to Winton’s novel about music and self-discovery.
W Critical Reception Dirt Music, like Winton’s other novels, was popular with audiences, but critics gave it mixed reviews. Critics concurred that his skill as a wordsmith and his talent as a storyteller are evident, but the plot and characters of this novel did not hold up to close, critical scrutiny. Tom Gibbons, writing in the Australian journal Quadrant, stated that “Winton’s comparatively restricted narrative point of view made it difficult for this reader to empathise with his characters, consequently difficult to believe in and attach importance to their experiences.” New Statesman critic Martyn Bedford pinpointed the problem, stating that Georgie’s narrative was less “engrossing” than Luther’s. Peter Porter, reviewing the novel for the Guardian, was more forgiving, declaring the novel to be “very well written.” Porter’s only criticism was that the pacing was slow. Bedford ultimately summed up the critical appraisals of Dirt Music by concluding that “with a writer as good as Winton, even this near miss of a novel leaves echoes in your mind long after you have shut the book.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Bedford, Martyn. “Novel of the Week. (Books).” Rev. of Dirt Music, by Tim Winton. New Statesman, 27 May 2002: 53. Print. Gibbons, Tom. “The Way Wa Lives Now.” Rev. of Dirt Music, by Tim Winton. Quadrant, 1 Nov. 2002: 85-86. Print.
MAJOR CHARACTERS BEAVER, an ex-biker who runs the local gas station, has dirt on everyone in town. BESS, Horrie’s wife, is dying of bowel cancer. She is a former English teacher and talks to Luther about books. JIM BUCKRIDGE, Georgie Jutland’s boyfriend, is a great fisherman and an undeclared leader in the community of White Point. LUTHER FOX, grieving the loss of his entire family from unnatural causes, abandons music and becomes a shamateur (fish poacher). He and Georgie embark on an affair that rocks him from his grief. HORRIE, an ex-merchant marine who loves Russian composers, is on a final road trip with his wife Bess. He gives Luther a ride for part of his journey. JUDE, Georgie’s favorite sister, becomes depressed after the death of their mother and attempts suicide. GEORGIE JUTLAND, forty years old and without direction or motivation, is brought back to life when she meets Fox. NORA is a sixteen-year-old hitchhiker whom Luther tries to help when she appears caught in Rusty’s net of anger and drugs. RUSTY is a young drug-addicted surfer with a peg leg with whom Fox travels for a while.
Porter, Peter. “Rednecks of the Outback.” Rev. of Dirt Music, by Tim Winton. Guardian, 8 June 2002: 26. Print. Winton, Tim. Dirt Music. New York: Scribner's 2001. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Craven, Peter. “Perils of the Popular.” Rev. of Dirt Music, by Tim Winton. Meanjin 62.1 (2003): 133-43. Print. Finds Dirt Music lacking as compared to Winton’s other works and the two other novelists reviewed. “Dirt Music. (Fiction).” Rev. of Dirt Music, by Tim Winton. Kirkus Reviews, 15 Mar. 2002: 366. Print. Reviews the novel positively, discussing the importance of growth and change for the central characters. “Dirt Music. (Fiction).” Rev. of Dirt Music, by Tim Winton. Publishers Weekly, 22 Apr. 2002: 46. Print. Discusses the landscape as an important and unique element in Winton’s novel.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
351
Dirt Music
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Tim Winton was born August 4, 1960 in Perth, Australia to a father who was a police officer and a mother who was a homemaker. He spent his childhood holidays swimming and reading, the latter of which inspired him to become a writer. Between the ages of ten and 18, he wrote approximately fifty stories. Winton studied creative writing at the Western Australia Institute of Technology. His first novel, An Open Swimmer (1982) was published the same year he married his wife, Denise. Winton’s work has consisently been recognized with awards from 1982 forward, including two Commonwealth Writers Prizes and four Miles Franklin Awards; Dirt Music received the Miles Franklin Award in 2002. Winton was declared a Living Treasure by the Australian National Trust. As of 2010, Winton lived in Fremantle, near Perth, with his wife and children.
Mytton, Leigh. “Dirt Music Paints a Bleak Picture.” Rev. of Dirt Music, by Tim Winton. news.bbc.co.uk. BBC News 16 Oct. 2002. Web. 13 Oct. 2010. Declares the novel to be a “page-turner.”
Nesbitt, Robin. “Dirt Music. (Fiction).” Rev. of Dirt Music, by Tim Winton. Library Journal 1 Mar. 2002: 141. Print. Celebrates Winton’s handling of the issues of love, death, and maturity. Winton, Tim. Interviewed by Andrew Denton. Enough Rope with Andrew Denton. ABC1. ABC, Sydney. 25 Oct. 2004. Television. Winton discusses his past and his inspiration for his stories and novels. Winton, Tim. Interviewed by Maura Murizzi and Andrew Lawless. “‘You Kill Them If Pressed’—Tim Winton.” www.threemonkeysonline.com. Three Monkeys Online May 2006. Web. 13 Oct. 2010. Shares his approach to writing characters and discusses his view on being seen as a quintessential Australian author. Gale Resources
Rossiter, Richard. “Tim Winton.” Australian Writers, 1975-2000. Ed. Selina Samuels. Detroit: Gale, 2006. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 325. Literature Resource Center. Web. 11 Oct. 2010. “Tim Winton.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Literature Resource Center. Web. 11 Oct. 2010.
Dirt Music is set in a small town in the Australian Outback. Tommaso Lizzul/Shutterstock.com
352
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Dirt Music
“Tim Winton.” Contemporary Literary Criticism. Vol. 251. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Literature Resource Center. Web. 11 Oct. 2010. “Tim Winton (1960-).” Short Story Criticism. Ed. Jelena Krstovic. Vol. 119. Detroit: Gale, Cengage Learning, 2009. 303-48. Print. Open Web Sources
The British Council Contemporary Writers maintains a Web page about Tim Winton. Available at http:// www.contemporarywriters.com/authors/?p= auth03c7l393712635104, the page includes a biography, bibliography, awards information, an essay on Winton’s critical perspective, and contact information. For Further Reading
McCarthy, Cormac. Suttree. New York: Vintage, 1992. Print. Published in 1979, this novel features the story of a man who has abandoned a mundane yet successful life to be a fisherman on the Tennessee River. Smith, W. Ramsay. Myths and Legends of the Australian Aborigines. Minneola: Dover, 2003. Print. Stories about the origins of the world and the cultural practices of indigenous Australians. Winton, Tim. Cloudstreet. New York: Scribner's, 2002. Print. Published in 1992, tells the story of a two very different families who share a house in Perth after World War II. ———. The Turning: Stories. New York: Scribner's, 2006. Print. Examines life in small-town Australia in this collection of seventeen short stories.
Carey, Peter. Illywhacker. New York: Vintage, 1996. Print. Published in 1985, tells the tale of a 139-yearold con man who exemplifies one aspect of the Australian identity.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Carol Ullmann
353
A Distant Shore By Caryl Phillips
W Introduction Caryl Phillip’s seventh novel, A Distant Shore (2003), is the story of a middle-aged woman on the brink of a nervous breakdown or mental collapse. In the opening pages, readers learn that she is recently retired and is divorced. Her parents have died, and her sister has died just weeks earlier. Dorothy is alone in the world, but she is also a woman who further self-isolates herself. From the vantage point of her home at the top of a hill, she can stand in her window and watch her neighbors and the villagers below. She watches but does not join them. She also watches the local night watchman Solomon polish his car. Solomon is much younger and he is black, an anomaly that stands out in Dorothy’s small English village, where there are very few inhabitants who are not native Caucasian English people. When Solomon offers to drive Dorothy on her errands and to her doctor’s appointments, these two disparate personalities with nothing in common but their loneliness, become friends. Solomon is murdered by a group of white hoodlums early in the novel, but after his murder, Phillips provides Solomon’s back story and explains how he arrived in England. In an unnamed African country, Solomon was a rebel war leader, who killed frequently. After his family was massacred, he was smuggled out of Africa and eventually arrived in England, where he was arrested for rape. Solomon was soon freed after the young woman refused to testify, but upon release, he was told to move where his arrest would not be known. There are people who welcome immigrants, but many English people do not, and so Solomon’s life is one of tension and stress because he is in England illegally. Solomon is lucky enough to find someone who gives him shelter and helps him with the legal process for becoming a citizen. After Solomon moves to a small village to start over, he sees Dorothy, who appears very
lonely. Solomon sets out to be a friend to her, just as people had earlier befriended him and helped him. He wants to rescue her from her loneliness. In the next section of the book, readers learn Dorothy’s back story. Dorothy’s parents showed her no love, and her unhappy marriage ended when her husband of thirty years ran off with a younger woman. Dorothy was forced to take an early retirement after a colleague filed a charge of sexual harassment. Dorothy’s two affairs with married men ended badly, but in relating these events, she is incapable of seeing that the wives of these men are entitled to hate her. As trauma upon trauma is heaped upon Dorothy, she slowly begins to lose her mind. She cannot function, cannot sleep, drinks too much, and acts inappropriately in public, often laughing in a crazy manner. Soon she is committed to a mental hospital, where she resides at the end of the novel.
W Literary and Historical Context
In the late 1990s and during the first decade of the twenty-first century, England had a significant problem with illegal immigration. In 2005 the number of illegal immigrants in England was estimated to be 430,000, but many in government believed that the true estimate might be as high as 570,000. By 2009 the number of illegal immigrants was estimated to be near one million. Many of these illegal immigrants were people whose asylum requests were denied or who overstayed their visas. In A Distant Shore, Phillips describes the prejudice that immigrants face in England. Groups opposed to immigration cite 2010 employment statistics that suggest immigrants take jobs that have traditionally gone to young people, leaving many native Englanders unemployed in this age group. Other studies indicate that
354 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
A Distant Shore
many other jobs are also going to immigrants, with estimates as high as 80 percent of newly created jobs being filled by immigrants. The perception that immigrants take jobs from native English people explains much of the criticism directed toward the government’s open-door immigration policy. Lack of employment opportunities also account for much of the hostility directed toward immigrants. A 2008 poll revealed that 60 percent of people thought that there were too many immigrants in Great Britain and half of the people polled said that all foreigners should leave. Phillips does not identify the African country from which Solomon flees. There are many countries that Phillips might have chosen. Between the 1960s and early 2000s, civil war raged in Nigeria, Mozambique, Congo, and Sierra Leone. Civil wars resulted in genocides in Rwanda and Sudan, while there was thirty years of conflict between Ethiopia and Eritrea.
W Themes Loss of home is the most compelling theme of A Distant Shore. Dorothy is not at home in her own space or in her
MAJOR CHARACTERS SOLOMON BARTHOLOMEW is a refugee from Africa, who befriends his neighbor Dorothy. In Africa, he was known as Gabriel, but once he became a rebel leader, his name was Hawk. He adopts a different personality to fit each name. BRIAN is Dorothy’s husband, who flees their sterile marriage for a younger woman. DOROTHY JONES is an emotionally damaged middle-aged woman, who is neglected and needy. The harder she tries to make someone love her, the more that person withdraws and the more emotionally fragile she becomes. MAHMOOD is a local newspaper seller, with whom Dorothy has an affair. SHEILA, Dorothy’s younger sister, runs away from her abusive parents as a teenager, leading to an estrangement that ends only as Sheila is dying. GEOFF WAVERLY is the teacher who charges Dorothy with sexual harassment.
In A Distant Shore, Dorothy’s friend Solomon was a civil war leader in Africa before he was smuggled into England. ª Patrick Robert/Sygma/ Corbis
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
355
A Distant Shore
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Caryl Phillips was born March 13, 1958, on the Caribbean of island St. Kitts. He grew up in Leeds, England, and attended Oxford University. Phillips began his literary career by writing for the theater, but he also wrote for radio and film. In 1992 he was named the Sunday Times Young Writer of the Year for his novel, Cambridge. Phillips’s Crossing the River (1993) was short-listed for the Man Booker Prize for Fiction. A Distant Shore, Phillips’s seventh novel, was a finalist for the PEN/ Faulkner Award. A Distant Shore was also the New York Times and the Chicano Tribune’s Best Book of the Year and a Hurston/Wright Award finalist. As of 2010, Phillips taught at Yale University.
own village. She is recently divorced and retired. Her only sister has died, as have her parents. In addition, she harbors a family secret—her father sexually assaulted her younger sister. Dorothy cannot sleep and sometimes acts irrationally, sees a psychiatrist, and has been confined to a mental hospital. She does not feel at home in her own country, and as she notes in the final sentences of the novel, the mental hospital is not her home, either. Likewise Solomon has no home. He must flee his native country after war destroys his family. He knows that he is also a hunted man and will be killed if caught. He is forced to change his name, and thus, he has no identity associated with his home. In England, he is unwelcome because he is black. His racial difference means he can never be a true Englishman, as the hate mail he receives makes clear. Dorothy and Solomon become friends because they are lonely and socially isolated. Dorothy is disgusted by the lack of manners that she sees in the people around her. She is impressed with Solomon because he is unfailingly polite and is always neatly dressed. Dorothy, however, is rarely neatly dressed. Her life is out of control, and her appearance shows it. Her clothing is dirty and wrinkled, which she notes but considers unimportant in her own dress, since she can fix it if she wishes. Dorothy is different from her neighbors and acts in some ways irrationally, which makes her noticed, something most fifty-five-year-old women do not experience. Her strange appearance and often irrational behavior cause her to be all the more isolated and lonely. In A Distant Shore, both Dorothy and Solomon seek asylum. Solomon seeks a safe haven from his native country. Dorothy is a stranger in her own country. She does not recognize England anymore. There are new communities and new houses. The names of towns are changed and the people in her old community have values that are different from hers. New immigrants of color are clearly not English. Dorothy, who no longer fits
356
into this new England, is a woman seeking asylum in her own country.
W Style A Distant Shore does not have a chronologically linear plot. Phillips shifts back and forth, jumping from the novel’s present time to a nonspecific time in the past and then jumping still further back to a more distant past. In telling the story of Solomon’s life in Africa, when his name is Gabriel, Phillips begins with the massacre of Gabriel’s family, which leads to his need to escape from Africa. Then Phillips takes the reader back in time to when Gabriel was a rebel leader known as Hawk. Time then moves forward to his escape to France and then forward again to Gabriel in jail, and then back in time again to his escape from France, before moving forward again to his release from jail and flight from London. Phillips’s novel also shifts back and forth between points of view. There are five sections in the novel. The first section is Dorothy’s narration and is told in the present tense. In this section, readers learn about Dorothy’s damaged emotional and mental state. Readers learn about Solomon, from Dorothy’s point of view, and hear about his death. The second section is Solomon’s story, but it is told in third person. The third section describes Dorothy’s life, this time in third person. In the fourth section, Solomon describes the last year of his life and his friendship with Dorothy. In the final section, Dorothy tells the story of her life in a mental hospital, where she has been sent to recover. In the final section of A Distant Shore, Phillips uses an interior dialogue to relate Dorothy’s experiences in the mental hospital. She does not speak and the jumble of thoughts might best be compared to stream of consciousness. Her thoughts seem deranged, mirroring her emotional turmoil.
W Critical Reception Reviews of A Distant Shore were mixed. Laurence Wareing’s review in the Glasgow Herald was typical of praise for Phillips’s novel. Wareing celebrated A Distant Shore because it captures both the public and the private reactions of England’s sometimes contentious welcome of new immigrants. According to Wareing, A Distant Shore is a “powerful novel of asylum seekers” and a depiction of “a nation deeply affected by changes in the world around it.” In its depiction of a small English village struggling with change, Wareing claimed that Phillips “exposes the myth of the serene” English village, which is so focused on preserving the old ways and for generations has been unwelcoming to strangers. Linda Watkins’s review of A Distant Shore in the African American Literature Book Club, an online site, TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
A Distant Shore
also praised Phillips’s book. Watkins was especially complimentary of Phillips’s characterization of Dorothy as a “depressed-obsessed” teacher and of Solomon, as a former solder who is trying to start over in England. Watkins also admired how Phillips created two protagonists, whose “perspectives of the world are clear and humanistic, even though both come from extremely different backgrounds.” Watkins called the novel “accomplished” and “unique.” On the negative side, Natasha Walter’s review in the Guardian was significantly less enthusiastic. Walter complained that Phillips’s novel is an idea, rather than a reality, that the work “doesn’t have enough flesh on its bones to come alive.” Walter’s complaint was that the two protagonists appear to be lecturing from memorization and “explaining things point by point to the reader.” According to Walter, A Distant Shore lacks sufficient energy, and instead of revealing experiences, Phillips simply “explained” experiences to readers. As a result, in this novel, the experiences of the protagonists are generic, rather than specific. BIBLIOGRAPHY
the reader from becoming too comfortable in a world of prejudice and bigotry. Evans, Diana. Rev. of A Distant Shore, by Caryl Phillips. independent.co.uk Independent 21 Mar. 2003. Web. 11 Aug. 2010. Argues that monotonous prose and careless repetition in A Distant Shore distract readers from an otherwise important story. Mantel, Hilary. “Anyplace, England.” Rev. of A Distant Shore, by Caryl Phillips. telegraph.co.uk Daily Telegraph 8 Mar. 2003. Web. 12 Aug. 2010. Claims that stereotypes, not individuals, make A Distant Shore a flawed novel. Sarvan, Charles P., and Hasan Marhama. “The Fictional Works of Caryl Phillips: An Introduction.” World Literature Today 65.1 (1991): 35-40. Print. Offers a good general introduction to Phillips’s earliest novels. Whittier, Darryl. “High Tides and Missed Endings.” Rev. of A Distant Shore, by Caryl Phillips. theglobeandmail. com Globe and Mail 13 Dec. 2003. Web. 12 Aug. 2010. Contends that A Distant Shore provokes readers to question ideas about morality and the need for survival.
Works Cited
“430,000 Illegal Immigrants in UK.” Guardian 30 June 2005. Print. Doughty, Steve. “80% of New Jobs Have Gone to Migrants since Labour Came to Power.” dailymail. co.uk. Mail Online 11 Dec. 2011. Web. 11 Aug. 2010. Phillips, Caryl. A Distant Shore. New York: Vintage International, 2003. Print. Walter, Natasha. “The Sadness of Strangers.” Rev. of A Distant Shore, by Caryl Phillips. guardian.co.uk Guardian 15 Mar. 2003. Web. 11 Aug. 2010. Wareing, Laurence. “Seeking a Life More Ordinary.” Rev. of A Distant Shore, by Caryl Phillips. heraldscotland.com Herald (Scotland) 15 Mar. 2003. Web. 12 Aug. 2010.
Gale Resources
“Caryl Phillips.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2010. Literature Resource Center. Web. 15 Aug. 2010. Document URL http:// go.galegroup.com/ps/i.do?&id=GALE %7CH1000113763&v=2.1&u=itsbtria l&it=r&p=LitRC&sw=w Sander, Reinhard. “Caryl Phillips.” Twentieth-Century Caribbean and Black African Writers: Third Series. Ed. Bernth Lindfors and Reinhard Sander. Detroit: Gale Research, 1996. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 157. Literature Resource Center. Web. 15 Aug. 2010. Document URL http://go.galegroup. com/ps/i.do?&id=GALE%7CH1200004243& v=2.1&u=itsbtrial&it=r&p=LitRC&sw=w Open Web Sources
Watkins, Linda. Rev. of A Distant Shore, by Caryl Phillips. aalbc.com. African American Literature Book Club, n.d. Web. 11 Aug. 2010.
The Caryl Phillips Web site, at carylphillips.com, provides information on the author, his works, and appearances.
“Young People Think Immigrants Are a Threat to National Identity and Jobs.” dailymail.co.uk. Daily Mail 27 Sept. 2008. Web. 11 Aug. 2010.
Random House provides an author page for Caryl Phillips at http://www.randomhouse.ca/author/results. pperl?authorid=23875
Additional Resources
For Further Reading
Criticism and Reviews
Alao, Abiodun. Brothers at War: Dissidence and Rebellion in Southern Africa. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1994. Print. Examines the ideological and ethnic differences that have fueled wars in Mozambique and Angola.
Cooper, Rand Richard. “There’s No Place Like Home.” Rev. of A Distant Shore, by Caryl Phillips. nytimes. com. New York Times 19 Oct. 2003. Web. 11 Aug. 2010. Claims that in spite of some irritating prose habits, Phillips creates a novel that is designed to keep
Campbell, Greg. Blood Diamonds: Tracing the Deadly Path of the World’s Most Precious Stones. Boulder:
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
357
A Distant Shore
Westview, 2002. Print. Examines the use of diamonds to finance the civil war in Sierra Leone and even to fund al-Qaeda terrorists. Gberie, Lansana. A Dirty War in West Africa: The RUF and the Destruction of Sierra Leone. Bloomington: Indiana UP, 2005. Print. Exposes the corruption and violence of the war between the Revolutionary United Front and the government of Sierra Leone. Johnson, Douglas H. The Root Causes of Sudan’s Civil Wars. Bloomington: Indiana UP, 2003. Print. Provides a summary of the events and an analysis of the cause of the war in Sudan.
358
Panayi, Panikos. An Immigration History of Britain: Multicultural Racism since 1800. London: Longman, 2009. Print. Explores several important issues linked to the history of immigration in Great Britain, including employment, racism, and poverty. Reynolds, Jill. The Single Woman: A Discursive Investigation. New York: Routledge, 2008. Print. Provides a collection of interviews about how single women live in Great Britain that focuses on identity and social expectations. Sheri Karmiol
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Dive from Clausen’s Pier By Ann Packer
W Introduction Carrie is already falling out of love with Mike, the fiancé whom she has been dating since high school, when he makes a dive into too-shallow water at a quarry, breaking his neck. If he survives, he will be quadriplegic. Carrie is torn between being the dutiful girlfriend who stays and suffers beside him and freeing herself from a life she had already decided she did not want before tragedy struck. After a few weeks of playing the part, she flees her home in Madison, Wisconsin, for New York City, where she can reinvent herself. She shows up on the doorstep of a gay friend from high school and moves in, begins taking courses in design, and embarks on a love affair with the mysterious Kilroy, who is everything Mike is not. Although Carrie struggles with discovering what the right course of action is, and though her life in New York seems idyllic, she cannot bear the guilt of abandoning Mike without some kind of resolution. Eventually, she returns to Madison to make peace with Mike. Praised for its beautiful prose, The Dive from Clausen’s Pier was selected as the first Good Morning America book club title and became an immediate best seller.
W Literary and Historical Context
Set in the same period in which it was written, The Dive from Clausen’s Pier is divided between Madison, Wisconsin, and New York City. During the early 2000s, Madison was named one of the best places to live in the United States. According to the New York Times Book Review, during the decade that led up to the release of the novel, Madison held rankings in the top ten best cities to live in for women and for families; it was ranked fourth most-child friendly, fifth fittest, and all around best
medium-sized city in the United States. Much of the emphasis however, is on families, rather than on young singles looking for adventure. New York has long had a reputation for being a place where people go to start over or re-create themselves. Its population topped eight million in the 2000 census, making it an easy place to lose oneself. The Dive from Clausen’s Pier appeared during the year that Oprah Winfrey decided to end her book club. The talk-show host’s book club had made famous several novels, and when she discontinued the program, several television hosts stepped in to try to fill the gap. The Dive from Clausen’s Pier was selected as the title to launch Good Morning America’s new monthly book club. The debut novel sped up the charts, both in the New York Times and in such industry magazines as Publishers Weekly. The original print run of 30,000 copies was increased exponentially, and experts estimated that within the week of the announcement from Good Morning America, nearly 250,000 copies of the novel were in print (Maryles).
W Themes The Dive from Clausen’s Pier centers on the ideas of the cost of emotional relationships, and on how to balance what is owed to family and friends with being true to oneself. Carrie once loved Mike, but she feels their relationship is coming to an end. Mike’s tragic accident serves to bind her to him more thoroughly, because she does not simply want to abandon him. But Mike does not want her pity, either. Ann Packer focuses on what happens to love and friendship in the face of adversity, showing how different characters react to what they feel are betrayals. Carrie’s best friend, Jamie, bluntly tells Carrie she should not be the type of girl who dumps her boyfriend after an injury like this one. And yet, Carrie longs for freedom, not only from the responsibilities she now has in an already
359 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Dive from Clausen’s Pier
MAJOR CHARACTERS CARRIE BELL wants more than marriage to her high school sweetheart and a life in her hometown, but when tragedy causes her fiancé, Mike, to become a quadriplegic, she feels it is her duty to stay. However, when duty and expectations become too much for her to bear, she flees Madison, Wisconsin, for New York City, hoping to start a new life while continuing to tell friends and family that she plans to return. While in New York, Carrie embarks on a relationship with the exciting and mysterious Kilroy, whose moody and brooding attitude is exactly the opposite of the calm she shared with Mike. Eventually, despite the positive experiences she has in New York, Carrie returns to Madison to set things right. JAMIE is Carrie’s best friend, who believes that Carrie needs to stay in her relationship with Mike, especially now that Mike needs her most. KILROY becomes Carrie’s lover while she is in New York. He is the opposite of what Carrie sees in Mike. But Kilroy also has a past that weighs on him, and he, like Carrie, is trying to escape the expectations of others.
In the story, Carrie is beginning to regret her engagement to her high school sweetheart Mike, and then he breaks his neck after diving into shallow water. costall/Shutterstock.com
MIKE MAYER is aware that his relationship with Carrie is on the rocks, and that knowledge is precisely what encourages him to take the risky dive off Clausen’s Pier. The resulting catastrophe—an injury that causes him to become a quadriplegic—serves to put further strain on their relationship and it completely changes Mike’s life. Despite wanting to save his relationship with Carrie, Mike does not want her to stay with him out of pity—he wants, and misses, her love.
daily life into her narrative to create a sense of realism. “As keenly observant of the everyday world as she is of the subtle interactions between people, Packer deftly captures life in contemporary America,” Kathy Pohl described in the Writer. Packer described her process in an interview to Pohl, explaining that she began with the characters and their conflicts, and she knew where they started and where she wanted them to end in relationship to one another. Packer does not use flashy prose, instead building suspense through her descriptions of Carrie’s inner journey. Carrie’s ultimate decision about whether to stay in New York or to return to Madison is up in the air, and even the ending, when Carrie returns to make her peace, is a surprise, due to the way it is approached. This look into Carrie’s motives and her ultimate decision—despite the pleasures she experiences in New York—gives the novel psychological depth and make the tale more complex than it seems on the surface. For a portion of the story, the tale seems to be about Carrie’s escape and her experiences finding herself in a new life. But Packer builds those expectations of her audience, only to twist them in a resolution which still feels absolutely true to Carrie’s character. While Packer’s settings are drawn very clearly—she uses both New York and Madison, Wisconsin, both of which she has lived in—it is the characters and their relationships that are continuously noted as the core of the book. In the New York Times Book Review, Rob Nixon wrote, “Packer’s quick gift for capturing a character’s voice infuses the novel with a generous cast
ROOSTER is Mike’s best friend and his main defender.
unwanted relationship, but from the burden of expectations that surround her. Carrie’s actions seem divided into two categories: betrayal or self-betrayal. But Packer also looks at her choices in terms of selfishness versus self-preservation. Carrie struggles to find the balance between those two things. She cannot continue to keep up her act as the suffering, devoted girlfriend whose love has never been stronger because the role is not true, and it prevents her from being true to herself.
W Style Packer centers her stories around characters, rather than around plot, weaving very detailed observations about
360
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Dive from Clausen’s Pier
of memorable friends. . . . [T]he author’s deft sense of character ensures that the inner movements of Carrie’s journey keep us off balance and enthralled.” Other critics, including a contributor to Publishers Weekly, noted her keen ear for dialogue, feeling that the way the characters speak makes them seem more like flesh-and-blood people, thinking their own thoughts, than characters on the page. The characters are largely ordinary people, but their expression in dialogue are so true to who they are in terms of their relationships and their identities in the story that they are immediately recognizable.
W Critical Reception The Dive from Clausen’s Pier was a commercial success beyond the expectations of either the publisher or Packer. Packer explained to Pohl that the experience of success “was wonderful; it was so beyond my wildest dreams. Honestly, I’d been working on that book alone in a room for 10 years, never ever being at all sure I would be published, let alone by a wonderful publisher, let alone to critical acclaim or great sales. I mean, it was just one sort of surprising delight after another.” The novel received a Great Lakes Book Award and the Kate Chopin Literary Award. Reviews were typically complimentary, and focused on the vivid lives of the characters. Even reviewers who found Carrie hard to identify with thought that aspect made her more interesting (“Ann Packer”). Nola Theiss of Kliatt commented on how engaged she became with the characters’ lives, explaining, “When an author leaves the reader thinking about the future of the characters, as if they have lives beyond the final page. that’s a sign of good writing, and this book is full of good writing.” A Publishers Weekly critic found The Dive from Clausen’s Pier to be an “engrossing debut novel” and “the sort of book one reads dying to know what happens to the characters, but loves for its wisdom.” Booklist critic Carrie Bissey focused on Carrie’s difficulties in finding her answers, writing, “her struggle to do what’s right and her revelations about the life she wants for herself will keep readers turning page after eloquently written page.” A critic for Kirkus Reviews found that while the ending was surprising, “there’s not a false note in the story’s tentative resolution,” and concluded that the novel is “Very fine fiction indeed.”
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Although writing was highly valued in Ann Packer’s family, she herself never intended to become a writer. The daughter of a creative writing teacher and a law professor, both of whom worked at Stanford University, Packer was born on March 4, 1959. Though her mother also worked as a writer, and though her brother was interested in literature early on, Packer loved reading but had no inclinations to write herself. During her senior year of college at Yale, a friend persuaded her to take a fiction-writing course, despite her lack of interest. Packer quickly fell in love with writing, describing the process as “almost like a conversion experience” (Pohl). She completed a degree in English at Yale, then moved to New York and worked for Ballantine Books. She attended the Iowa Writers’ Workshop, where she earned her MFA, and sold her first short story before graduating. Packer has taught creative writing at the Wisconsin Institute for Creative Writing in Madison, where half of The Dive from Clausen’s Pier is set. Her first book, a short story collection titled Mendocino and Other Stories, was published in 1994; many of the stories had been previously published in Ploughshares, the New Yorker, and other magazines. The Dive from Clausen’s Pier was published in 2002, and Songs without Words followed in 2007. Packer has been included in Prize Stories 1992: The O. Henry Awards and has received a National Endowment for the Arts fellowship, the James Michener Award, and the Kate Chopin Literary Award.
Maryles, Daisy. “Kudos for Knopf. (Behind the Bestsellers).” Publishers Weekly 24 June 2002: 20. Nixon, Rob. “Guilt Trip: In This novel, a Young Woman from Wisconsin Flees to New York to Get away from Her Responsibilities.” New York Times Book Review 12 May 2002: 11. Pohl, Kathy. “Writing from the Heart: When Tragedy Strikes, Friendship Becomes a Mixed Blessing in Ann Packer’s Heartbreakingly Poignant Novels.” Writer Feb. 2008: 18. Theiss, Nola. “The Dive from Clausen’s Pier, a Novel. (Paperback Fiction).” Kliatt July 2003: 25+. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Bissey, Carrie. “Packer, Ann. The Dive from Clausen’s Pier.” Booklist 15 Mar. 2002: 1213. Rev. of The Dive from Clausen’s Pier. Kirkus Reviews 1 Jan. 2002: 14+. Rev. of The Dive from Clausen’s Pier. Publishers Weekly 4 Mar. 2002: 54.
Maryles, Daisy. “Kudos for Knopf. (Behind the Bestsellers).” Publishers Weekly 24 June 2002: 20. Maryles discusses The Dive from Clausen’s Pier’s commercial success, as well as the new book groups springing up to replace the Oprah Book Club. Watman, Max. “Guileless Games. (Fiction Chronicle).” New Criterion 20.9 (2002): 66+. Watman reviews The Dive from Clausen’s Pier among other
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
361
The Dive from Clausen’s Pier
When Carrie runs off to New York City in The Dive from Clausen’s Pier, she decides to get involved in fashion design. ª Vladimir Godnik/ moodboard/Corbis
novels about the turmoil lurking beneath seemingly normal lives. The other reviewed titles include Everything Is Illuminated by Jonathan Safran Foer and Spies by Michael Frayn. Gale Resources
“Ann Packer.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2008.
For Further Reading
Open Web Sources
Ann Packer provides excerpts, a reading group guide, quotes from reviews, and award information about The Dive from Clausen’s Pier on her Web site. Additional information about the author and her projects is also available. http://www.annpacker. com/the_dive_from_clausens_pier A review of The Dive from Clausen’s Pier by Karen Valby is accessible on the Entertainment Weekly Web site. The review laments the loss of Oprah’s Book Club, suggesting that the novel would have been an excellent selection. http://www.ew.com/ew/ article/0,,234460,00.html Reviews of the film version of The Dive from Clausen’s Pier are available through the Internet Movie
362
Database. Most of the reviews are by audience members, rather than professional critics. http:// www.imdb.com/title/tt0452611/ Discussion questions and a synopsis of the novel are available from Reading Group Guides.com, a Web site dedicated to providing helpful conversation starters about novels. http://www.readinggroupguides. com/guides3/dive_from_clausens_pier1.asp Dorris, Michael. Yellow Raft Blue Water. New York: Picador, 2003. Print. By Native American novelist Dorris, this novel follows the lives of several women who are abandoned, or abandon each other. Rayona, half-black, half-Indian, is left by her mother to live with her aunt; later, Rayona leaves her aunt behind to become a rodeo star. The story follows all three women as they deal with their choices and the events life hands them. Ellison, Brooke. Miracles Happen: One Mother, One Daughter, One Journey. New York: Hyperion, 2002. Print. This is the true story of Ellison, who was paralyzed at age eleven. With the help and encouragement of her mother, she became the first quadriplegic to graduate from Harvard University. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Dive from Clausen’s Pier
Listfield, Emily. Waiting to Surface. New York: Atria, 2007. Print. Based on the disappearance of Listfield’s own husband, this novel follows Sarah Larkin on a search to discover what happened when her husband, Todd, vanished. Todd had been living a double life, and Sarah, along with Todd’s ex, a policeman, and a private investigator try to piece together what happened to lead up to his disappearance. Packer, Ann. Songs without Words. New York: Knopf, 2007. Print. Packer’s second novel also focuses on friendship, this one between two women. Liz and Sarabeth are childhood friends who became close due to Sarabeth’s mother’s suicide. As adults, Liz has a family life with two children; Sarabeth is eccentric and
has a bohemian lifestyle, leaving Liz feeling as though she’s taking care of Sarabeth. A crisis with Liz’s daughter leaves Liz wondering if she is a good mother and makes Sarabeth relive moments in her past. Adaptations
The Dive from Clausen’s Pier. Dir. Harry Winer. Perf. Michelle Trachtenberg, Sean Maher, and Will Estes. Lifetime. 25 Jul. 2005. Television. The Lifetime channel’s adaptation of Packer’s novel, filmed as an 86-minute short movie for television.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Alana Abbott
363
Douglass’ Women By Jewell Parker Rhodes
W Introduction
W Literary and Historical
A great deal is known about the public life and endeavors of Frederick Douglass, a seminal figure in the abolitionist movement of nineteenth-century America, largely due to his autobiography, Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave (1845). Douglass published new versions of his autobiography in 1855 and 1881, and his work earned him great renown in the abolitionist movement, as well as iconic status in the women’s rights movement. Jewell Parker Rhodes tackles the lesser-known area of Douglass’s personal life in her historical novel, Douglass’ Women (2002). Douglass was married to an illiterate, free black woman named Anna Murray Douglass for forty-four years, until her death in 1882. She was instrumental in helping Douglass escape from slavery to the North and she took pride in assuming a traditional, familial role, performing the traditional “women’s work” of maintaining the household and raising children. Although Douglass rarely spoke or wrote of her, Rhodes tells Anna’s story in the style of an oral slave narrative, reconstructing their life together. The sections dedicated to Anna are juxtaposed with sections written from the point of view of Ottilie Assing, a white, half-Jewish, half-Christian German woman, with whom Douglass carries on an affair for nearly three decades. The sections written in Ottilie’s voice are in the style of letters and diaries, and describe how she satisfies Douglass’s intellectual needs in ways that Anna is incapable of. Working with Douglass as a translator, Ottilie spends time as a guest at the Douglass’s home, a situation that provides much of the tension in the novel. After Anna dies, Douglass marries Helen Pitts, which proves to be tragic for Ottilie.
Context
In Douglass’ Women, Rhodes confronts a variety of controversial issues contemporary to Douglass’s lifetime. After Douglass escapes slavery with the help of Anna, he publishes his first autobiography. When the book does well in the marketplace, he becomes a recognizable figure and is threatened with recapture by his former slave master. With Anna’s consent, Ottilie takes him to London, where their affair begins. When his freedom is bought by fellow abolitionists, Douglass and Ottilie return to America and Anna realizes the nature of their relationship. Douglass is believed to have maintained controversial relationships prior to his affair with Ottilie, too. According to Douglass scholar Richard Yarborough (UCLA), “He also was connected with a white British abolitionist earlier in the 1850s that hit the press. William Lloyd Garrison, with whom Douglass had fallen out, brought it to the attention of the public, although people had been muttering about it for a while” (qtd. in Chadwick). Two years after Anna’s death, Douglass remarries. His second wife, Helen Pitts, the daughter of a friend of Douglass’s, is twenty years his junior, and is also white. Rhodes’s fictionalized account of the story veers from reality when, devastated by Douglass’s marriage to Pitts, Ottilie Assing commits suicide in a Paris hotel. Through alternating narratives by Anna and Ottilie, Rhodes allows each woman to emerge from Douglass’s shadow, explaining their own motivations and ultimately understanding and respecting each other. In one section, Ottilie comments on Anna, saying, “I shouldn’t have hated her. She loved him, just like me.” Likewise, referring to Ottilie, Anna says, “Miss Assing wasn’t a Delilah. I see that now” (Rhodes). Structured in such a way, both women are given the advantage of hindsight as
364 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Douglass’ Women
MAJOR CHARACTERS OTILLIE ASSING is a German, half-Jewish, half-Christian white woman with whom Douglass has a twenty-eight-year-long affair, frequently spending summers at the Douglass household. She translates Douglass’s work and considers herself his “intellectual wife.” ANNA MURRAY DOUGLASS falls in love with Douglass upon first meeting him. She helps him escape slavery and they marry. She bears him five children, and maintains his household while he travels and organizes for the abolitionist cause. FREDERICK DOUGLASS is a former slave, married to Anna Murray Douglass for forty-four years while carrying on a decades-long affair with Ottilie Assing. Douglass becomes famous for his civil rights activism. After the death of Anna Murray Douglass, he marries Helen Pitts. OLUWAND is a slave on board a ship with Ottilie Assing as she travels to America. Oluwand, rather than return to slavery, takes her own life by jumping over the ship’s rail. Ottilie is haunted by Oluwand throughout Douglass’ Women.
Douglass’ Women explores the romantic relationships of Frederick Douglass, the famed American abolitionist and author. ª Bettmann/Corbis
a means to tell their stories. According to Karen Grigsby Bates, “Anna Douglass has been in history’s shadows, so Jewell Parker Rhodes decided to bring her out through this fictionalized memoir” (qtd. in Chadwick). Ottilie Assing sacrifices for Douglass, as well. According to Susan Tekulve in her review for Books, “[Rhodes] explores the desperate reasoning that allows Ottilie to give up her own freedom in order to remain Frederick’s ‘spiritual wife.’”
W Themes A primary thematic concern in Douglass’ Women is that of freedom and identity. Both of the women central to the story give up a degree of personal freedom in order to maintain a relationship with Douglass while, according to
the Washington Post, “Rhodes suggests that neither could compete with the man in his mirror”(Washington Post) The author has commented on her website, “My novel is about two free women who, ironically, become enslaved by love in a romantic triangle.” The way that Anna retains her personal sense of freedom is, ironically, by choosing to remain illiterate, despite Douglass’s encouraging her to learn to read and write. According to Rhodes, “For me, Anna’s illiteracy signified a passive-aggressive reaction to her husband’s frequent absences, his infidelities, and his growing sense that she was, as he often suggested, ‘an old black log.’” Ottilie, conversely, submits completely to Douglass, having been raised by parents of different ethnicity and religion, according to the romantic notion that true love was worth losing her own sense of self and individuality. The Washington Post observes, “Ottilie shares her mother’s opinion that a woman should choose ‘passion over propriety (Washington Post).’” Ultimately, both women lose to “the man in his mirror.” Ottilie takes her own life when her idealistic view of their relationship is corrupted by Douglass’s marriage to Helen Pitts. Anna, after bearing five of Douglass’s children and raising them, alone, while he advances the abolitionist and suffrage causes with Ottilie at his side, dies and is given an enormous public funeral.
W Style In Douglass’ Women, Rhodes employs different styles of communication for the narratives of each of the principal
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
365
Douglass’ Women
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Dr. Jewell Parker Rhodes was raised in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, and earned a BA in drama criticism, an MA in English, and a doctor of arts degree in English from Carnegie Mellon University. She has written six novels, a children’s novel, and two writing guides for black authors. She has won several literary awards and her work has been anthologized in four collections. Her work has been published throughout North America and Europe. Dr. Rhodes is the artistic director for global engagement and chairs the Virginia G. Piper Center for Creative Writing at Arizona State University.
women. The sections written from Anna Murray Rhodes’s perspective are written in the form of the traditional slave, or captivity, narrative. Slave narratives were very popular with the public of the time—Frederick Douglass’s own narrative sold thirty thousand copies between 1845 and 1860. Giving Anna voice through the style of the slave narrative lends historical authenticity to the work. Since many slaves, like Anna, were illiterate, their narratives had to be dictated to abolitionists. According to Rhodes, on her website, “Because of her illiteracy, Anna tells her life story in the oral tradition. Like a slave narrative, she begins the substance of her speech with ‘I was born’ and works her way forward.” Juxtaposed against chapters written from Anna’s point of view are the sections written from the perspective of Ottilie Assing. To tell Ottilie’s story, Rhodes uses the conventions that were available and popular among women of means during that period. Since Ottilie is a German heiress, she is given more formal means of communication. Rhodes says, “Ottilie, as a white woman of letters, a German, half-Jewish, halfChristian draws upon the nineteenth century women’s tradition of using letters, journals, and diaries to tell her tale.” By constructing the story in chapters that alternate between each woman’s story, Rhodes gives each the opportunity to reflect on her actions and to come to terms with her feelings about Douglass and about each other. According to the author, “[I]t’s the whole idea that in loving, women need to value self-love, value themselves enough to survive sometimes problematic or negative relationships” (qtd. in Chadwick). Conspicuously absent in the novel is the point of view of Douglass himself. Both women portray the Douglass character through the lens of their own experience, giving voice to the character that, because of the novel’s style, does not have a voice of his own.
366
W Critical Reception Winner of several awards, including the 2003 American Book Award and the 2003 PEN Oakland Josephine Miles Award for Outstanding Writing, Douglass’ Women has garnered great critical and popular acclaim. Called a “masterpiece of historical fiction” (Carroll), the novel has been praised for its vivid reimagining of the personal life of one of American history’s great civil rights activists. According to Karen Grigsby Bates, Rhodes said she “relied on a skeleton of historical facts as the foundation for her novel” (qtd. in Chadwick). Some critics, however, have questioned her interpretation of the facts. The Washington Post has reported that, “[I]n Love across the Color Lines, Maria Diedrich’s nonfiction book about the Douglass-Assing relationship, the author quotes from the memoirs of Helene von Racowitza, an actress who socialized with the pair: ‘Our good Ottilie was . . . entwined in passionate love with the beautiful dark Fred. . . . but she honored his marriage bond’” (Washington Post). Rhodes, however, maintains that a sexual relationship did exist, saying, “There were . . . approximately 200 letters in which Ottilie and Frederick talk about their relationship that suggests a really heartfelt intimacy. But according to the letters, it does seem as though they had a very sexual, romantic relationship, as well” (qtd. in Chadwick). Few critics have registered complaints about Douglass’ Women. Although conceding that “Douglass’ Women is an enthralling novel, more often triumphant than not, a novel of passion and tenderness and strength and remarkable power,” critic and novelist Lee Martin contends that, “There are moments that are overwrought. The dialogue is sometimes exaggerated, and Rhodes occasionally forces emotional responses from her characters.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Carroll, Denolyn. “Douglass’ Women. Book Review.” Black Issues Book Review Sept.-Oct. 2002. Print. BNET. Web. 4 Sept. 2010. Chadwick, Alex. “Profile: Different Side of Frederick Douglass Told in the New Book, Douglass’ Women.” NPR Special. National Public Radio. 2003. HighBeam Research. Web. 1 Sept. 2010. Martin, Lee. “A House Divided.” Washington Post. Washington Post Newsweek Interactive Co. 13 Oct. 2002. Print. HighBeam Research. Web. 3 Sept. 2010. Rhodes, Jewell Parker. Douglass’ Women. New York: Atria, 2002. Print. ———. “How I Came to Write Douglass’ Women.” JewellParkerRhodes.com. 2009. Web. 2 Sept. 2010. Tekulve, Susan. “Douglass’ Women.” Rev. of Douglass’ Women. Book Sept.-Oct. 2002: 81. Print. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Douglass’ Women
“The Washington Post Book Club; Douglass’ Women, by Jewell Parker Rhodes. Presented by Jabari Asim.” Washington Post. Washington Post Newsweek Interactive Co. 1 Feb. 2004. Print. HighBeam Research. Web. 2 Sept. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Bush, Vanessa. “Rhodes, Jewell Parker. Douglass’ Women.” Booklist 15 Sept. 2002: 208+. Print. “Cover to Cover.” New Pittsburgh Courier. Real Times, Inc. 13 Sept. 2003. Print. HighBeam Research. Web. 3 Sept. 2010. Brief review in the context of other African American novel reviews. Discusses the metaphysical concerns of the novel set against the historical reality. Rev. of Douglass’ Women. (Fiction).” Kirkus Reviews 15 July 2002: 988. Print. Rev. of Douglass’ Women. (Fiction).” Publishers Weekly 5 Aug. 2002: 50+. Print. “Profile: Different Side of Frederick Douglass Told in the New Book, Douglass’ Women.” Day to Day 20 Aug. 2003. Rhodes, Phyllis. “Douglass’ Women by Jewel Parker Rhodes.” Apooo Bookclub. Apooobooks, 25 Oct. 2002. Web. 4 Sept. 2010. Review of Douglass’ Women that discusses the relationship between Anna Douglass and Ottilie Assing in the novel. Gale Resources
Open Web Sources
The Apooo Bookclub website offers commentary about Douglass’ Women by Jewell Parker Rhodes that discusses the context of the book and relates it to her personal life and opinions. http://www.apooobooks. com/anna-murray-douglass-a-twenty-first-centurysister-by-jewell-parker-rhodes/ Jewell Parker Rhodes’s official website includes information about her books, a brief biography, events listings, and her blog and podcast. http://www. jewellparkerrhodes.com/index.html For Further Reading
Diedrich, Maria. Love across Color Lines: Ottilie Assing and Frederick Douglass. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 1999. Print. Interpretation of the DouglassAssing relationship that considers nineteenth-century racial, class, and gender issues. Douglass, Frederick. Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave. 6th ed. London: H. G. Collins, 22, Paternoster Row, 1851. Print. Sixth edition of Douglass’s first autobiography. Rhodes, Jewell Parker. Voodoo Dreams. 4th ed. New York: Macmillan Picador, 1995. Print. First novel by Jewell Parker Rhodes, a fictionalized account based on the life of a nineteenth-century voodoo priestess. Stowe, Harriet Beecher. Uncle Tom’s Cabin. New York: Random House: Bantam Classics, 1982 (1852). Print. Antislavery novel credited by many historians for contributing to the outbreak of the Civil War.
“Jewell Parker Rhodes.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2010.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Todd Breijak
367
Down River By John Hart
W Introduction Down River won the prestigious Edgar Award. By most critical accounts, Down River excels as a mystery because it seamlessly blends a story of murder and other violent crime with a family saga reminiscent of the best literature of the American South. Like the Southern authors with whom John Hart has been compared—Harper Lee, Pat Conroy, William Faulkner, Tennessee Williams—Hart evokes a strong sense of place, directing his protagonist, Adam Chase, to return to his beloved Rowan County, North Carolina, even after his acquittal in an unsolved murder case there five years previous has left most of the community and some of his family still convinced of his guilt. The family, and the community, to which this prodigal son returns is burdened by long-kept secrets that push their way to the surface in a wave of more recent crime that is coincident with Adam’s return home. In the end, the violence turns out to be linked to the refusal of Adam’s wealthy father, Jacob Chase, to sell his 1,400-acre family farm to developers. Seeking to clear his name of the earlier murder charge and brought back to Rowan County at the request of an old friend who has now disappeared, Adam must now also solve the new crimes, which the townspeople are only too eager to blame on an unwelcome and already suspect member of local royalty. Referring to Down River and its predecessor, The King of Lies (2006), Oline Cogdill observed, “Hart found his niche weaving tenets of crime fiction into the Southern novel, with multilayered plots that focus on greed, power and the strength and fragility of families.”
W Literary and Historical Context
An attorney with an accounting degree, Hart might have more logically chosen to write legal thrillers in the
manner of John Grisham. Indeed, much of his inspiration derives from the noir detective stories and movies of the 1940s. But, in all three of his novels to date, Hart has combined these elements of crime fiction with features associated with the traditional Southern novel, including a strong sense of place and an awareness of family and community as the nexus of events. Down River has more specifically been associated with the Southern Gothic for its focus on the secrets and betrayals of an old and wealthy family long established by its connection to the land, now trying to hang on to a bygone era. The sometimes grotesque family portrait is complete with a wicked stepmother who, in this case, swears eyewitness testimony to Adam’s presence at the scene of the murder of local football hero Gray Wilson. Her accusations result in Adam being arrested for a crime he did not commit. Although Adam is acquitted, no one else has been charged in the crime in the five years since Adam escaped to New York City to avoid the lingering taunts of the community and the suspicions of his own family. The mystery that envelops Down River grows out of a history of family dysfunction that recalls Faulkner’s Compson clan, horribly troubled by greed, mental illness, pride, and violent squabbles over property that has been in the family for generations.
W Themes The story of Down River moves along two subplots, described by a reviewer for Publishers Weekly: “The almost Shakespearean snarl of family ties is complicated by a very modern struggle between economic progress and love for the land, between haves and have-nots” (“Down River”). Another reviewer, Vy Armour, observed, “Greed, love, passion, family secrets—any of these could describe the currents of Down River.” This complicated tangle is enriched by the theme of the return of the prodigal son in the figure of Adam Chase. Always volatile and contentious, Adam is now back home
368 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Down River
MAJOR CHARACTERS ADAM CHASE is the main character, acquitted of a murder five years earlier and now returned to the scene of the crime to clear his name and seek the understanding of his family. Trouble seems to follow Adam, and he becomes a suspect in other crimes in the insular community of Salisbury, North Carolina. JACOB CHASE is Adam’s estranged father. He is refusing to sell his family farm in the face of significant pressure and threats from other members of the community who want the nuclear power plant. JAMES CHASE is Adam’s younger step-sibling, involved now in several shady business deals, gambling, and drinking. JANICE CHASE is Adam’s stepmother, the mother of James and Miriam. Janice falsely accuses Adam of being at the scene of Gray Wilson’s murder in bloodied clothing. Her testimony at Adam’s trial divides the family. MIRIAM CHASE is James’s twin sister and Adam’s step-sibling. Troubled by depression, she has recently sliced her wrists in a failed suicide attempt. DANNY FAITH is Adam’s friend, the one who pleads with Adam to come back home. He disappears and his body is found sometime later, part of a series of new crimes in Salisbury. John Hart, author of Down River, holds his Best Novel Award at the 2010 Edgar Awards. Matthew Peyton/Getty Images
to help out an old friend, Danny Faith, and convince his family and the community of Salisbury, North Carolina, that he is not responsible for Gray Wilson’s death or the current rash of crime: the assault near the banks of the river of Grace Shepherd, the teenage daughter of Dolf Shepherd, a school friend of Adam and one of the few people in town who welcomed him back; the discovery of Danny Faith’s decomposing body; arson associated with the production of crystal methamphetamine in the trailer of a dying old man who shoots himself. Suspense builds as the townspeople, unaware of Danny’s reasons for returning home and with an ax to grind against the Chase family, hope to point the evidence against him. The puzzle is further complicated by Adam’s continuing affections for the girlfriend he left behind, Robin, now a member of the Salisbury police force. Indicative of the importance of geography to the thematic development, the novel unfolds from Danny’s perspective upon first sighting the river after an absence of five years: “The river is my earliest memory. . . . Everything that shaped me happened near that river. I lost my mother in sight of it, fell in love in its banks. I could smell it on the day my father drove me out. It was part of
ZEBULON FAITH is Danny’s father, the proprietor of a motel and recently involved in illegal drug activities to pay off his debts. ROBIN is Adam’s ex-girlfriend, now a police officer on the Salisbury force. DOLF SHEPHERD is Adam’s friend from school days. He is accused of Danny Faith’s murder and Adam seeks to find the real killer. GRACE SHEPHERD is Dolf’s teenage daughter. Local law enforcement wants to pin her assault by the river on Adam. GRAY WILSON is the local football hero whose murder is still unsolved. Adam Chase is accused but acquitted at trial.
my soul, and I thought I’d lost it forever” (qtd. in Penzler). The flood of memories unleashed by the river takes the reader back to Adam’s youth and his approach to manhood, his already uneasy relationship with his father made more so by his discord with his stepmother, Janice, and the emotional instability of his twin stepsiblings: the flamboyant James, now plagued by gambling debts and alcoholism, and the timid Miriam, failed in a recent suicide attempt. Adam’s current search for acceptance must penetrate these family dynamics as well as the barriers presented by the town itself,
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
369
Down River
ABOUT THE AUTHOR John Hart has been widely heralded for his mastery of the literary thriller in his three published novels, The King of Lies (2006), Down River (2007), and The Last Child (2009). All three New York Times best sellers, the first one was nominated for an Edgar Award and the second two are winners of the prize. An attorney and banker with a degree in French literature as well, Hart combines his love of crime fiction with a poetic reverence for the rural South of his upbringing. His works have been compared to such masters of American Southern fiction as William Faulkner and Tennessee Williams for their strong sense of the importance of place in the history of prominent families torn apart by divided loyalties and long-standing grudges tied to the land. His novels have also been classed with those of his more experienced predecessors in the genre of the contemporary literary thriller, including James Lee Burke and Michael Malone.
between crime fiction and general literature. Rich with traditional elements of detective stories—family secrets, least-likely suspects and red herrings—it is equally abundant in the poetic language, striking imagery, and layered subtexts of America’s most significant books and authors. If you value Harper Lee, James Lee Burke, Truman Capote, and Michael Malone . . . it’s time to add John Hart to your bookshelves.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Armour, Vy. Rev. of Down River, by John Hart. BookBrowse, BookBrowse Recommends 8 Nov. 2007. Web. 1 Aug. 2010. Cogdill, Oline. “For Lawyer John Hart Not to Write Would Be Criminal.” South Florida Sun-Sentinel 22 Feb. 2009. South Florida Sun-Sentinel.com. Web. 3 Aug. 2010. “Down River.” Publishers Weekly 254.31(6 Aug. 2007): 168.
which, as many critics note, operates as a character in its own right.
Maslin, Janet. “Adam, Grace and Faith: Roles in a Humid Thriller.” New York Times 4 October 2007. Web. 3 Aug. 2010.
W Style
Penzler, Otto. “Thumbs Up for Down River.” New York Sun 24 October 2007. NewsBank, Access World News. Web. 28 July 2010.
Applauded as a “literary thriller,” Down River melds stylistic attributes on two planes, dialogue and description. The river of the title, the Yadkin, and the surrounding landscape and town are evoked in what reviewers have praised as lush and sensual language establishing the primacy of place to the action of the novel. Hart’s skill at character portrayal has been admired as equally poetic and nuanced, slowing and mysteriously bringing his most unbalanced characters to the edge of despair. Through dialogue, on the other hand, Hart develops scenes of overwrought emotion signaling the instability of personal relationships that threaten to turn ugly and violent at the slightest provocation. The speech of the characters is derivative of 1940s hardboiled detective stories, creating what Janet Maslin referred to as “deep-dish noir dialogue” and a “hothouse atmosphere.”
W Critical Reception Reviewers have been divided in their opinions of the plot development of Down River, with some arguing that it is a taut thriller and other noting that its suspense is sometimes undercut by melodrama and hyperbolic emotion. However, the novel has been almost universally applauded as a promising mixture of crime fiction and Southern family drama. Otto Penzler was enthusiastic in his appraisal: “Down River successfully erases the line
370
Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Alesi, Stacy, and John Hart. “John Hart.” Library Journal 134 (15 Mar. 2009): 96. Print. An interview with Hart describing his transition from attorney to writer and his attachment to Rowan County, North Carolina. Hart also explains that the idea for the child protagonist of The Last Child developed out of the character of the youngster Adam Chase encountered fishing by the banks of the river when he first returned to Salisbury. “Down River.” Bookmarks (Jan.-Feb. 2008): 48. Print. Provides a sampling of the reviews of Down River. “Hart, John: Down River.” Kirkus Reviews 1 Aug. 2007. Print. A concise plot summary. Hartlaub, Joe. Rev. of Down River, by John Hart. bookreporter.com. Web. 2 Aug. 2010. Positive review describing Down River as a novel that “invokes the spirit of the best of southern literature.” Kimball, Sue. “Down River Is a Winner for Hart.” Fayetteville (NC) Observer 14 Sept. 2008. NewsBank, Access World News. Web. 27 July 2010. Sorts through the tangled plot in summary fashion. Smith, Deirdre Parker. “Mysteries Muddy the Water ‘Down River.’” Salisbury (NC) Post 30 Sept. 2007. NewsBank, Access World News. Web. 27 July 2010. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Down River
Describes the plot of Down River and accords it “edge-of-the-seat” suspense. Gale Resources
“John Hart.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2010. Also covered in Contemporary Authors New Revision Series, Vol. 193. Open Web Sources
Hart’s author website, http://www.johnhartfiction. com/, provides biography, synopses of his books, his own comments on his rapid success, and a list of his scheduled appearances. For Further Reading
Faulkner, William. The Sound and the Fury. A Norton Critical Edition, edited by David Minter. New York: Norton, 1994. Print. Faulkner’s most highly
esteemed work in a series of books about the Compson clan of Jefferson, Mississippi, a prominent Southern family with skeletons in its closet. Hart, John. The King of Lies. New York: Thomas Dunne Books, 2006. Print. Hart’s debut novel, also set in Rowan County, North Carolina, about a Southern lawyer searching for the murderer of his wealthy and domineering father. ———. The Last Child. New York: Thomas Dunne Books/St. Martin’s Minotaur, 2009. Print. Hart’s most recent book, considered reminiscent of Harper Lee’s To Kill a Mockingbird. The novel follows a young boy to the dangerous side of his neighborhood as he embarks on a quest to find his abducted twin sister.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Janet Mullane
371
Duma Key By Stephen King
W Introduction Stephen King’s 2008 novel Duma Key tells the story of wealthy builder Edgar Freemantle, whose life is thrown into turmoil after a disastrous accident at a building site. The accident results in the amputation of his arm, damage to his hip, and a serious head injury that impairs his memory and speech and leaves him susceptible to fits of rage. Shortly after the accident, his wife leaves him, and though he considers suicide, he agrees to his therapist’s advice to try a change of venue. He moves to Duma Key, a small Florida island with few residents. There he tries his hand at sketching and painting, an old hobby that quickly blooms into an obsession. He also meets the mysterious Elizabeth Eastlake, a wealthy elderly woman who owns most of the island, and her affable caretaker, Jerome Wireman. Mrs. Eastlake has some odd advice for Edgar regarding his art and life, which Edgar and Wireman write off to her Alzheimer’s—at first. It soon becomes apparent that Edgar is no ordinary painter, and Duma Key is no ordinary island. His paintings become premonitions, and then he discovers he is able to alter reality through his art. Impressed by his paintings, a gallery in Sarasota schedules a show featuring his work, but as the show grows nearer, Edgar begins to suspect that something besides his own talent is guiding the creation of his art—something much darker, which puts Edgar and those he loves in jeopardy. King’s novel blends horror and fantasy with an exploration of the mysterious workings of the human mind, especially the power of memory and imagination. Edgar’s accident, Mrs. Eastlake’s childhood head injury, and a bullet lodged in Wireman’s brain from a failed suicide attempt, all seem to give Edgar and Mrs. Eastlake special abilities that create a sympathetic bond between them from their first
meeting. As the details of Mrs. Eastlake’s past surface, Edgar learns just how strong this bond really is.
W Literary and Historical Context
Though the main action of Duma Key takes place in the early 2000s, the history of Florida in the 1920s becomes relevant when Edgar begins learning more about Elizabeth Eastlake and her family. In the novel, fictional tycoon John Eastlake was a good friend of Dave Davis, a real-life real estate magnate who created Tampa’s Davis Islands out of swampland, making a fortune in the process. King embellishes Davis’s history by making him a part-time bootlegger as well. South Florida was a prime site for bootleggers during Prohibition, due to its proximity to the Bahamas and its many ports. Tampa— Davis’s home—was such a hot spot for the smuggling illegal alcohol and related criminal activity that it earned the nickname “Little Chicago.” Three of the novel’s main characters—Edgar, Wireman, and Elizabeth Eastlake—have all sustained serious head injuries. Mrs. Eastlake is also suffering from Alzheimer’s disease. Certain medical studies have shown that Alzheimer’s patients are nearly ten times more likely to have sustained a head injury that left them unconscious than the rest of the population. In the 1990s and early 2000s increased research on Alzheimer’s disease led to the development of several new drugs used to treat its symptoms, as well as new theories about direct genetic manipulation as a possible treatment in the future. Unfortunately Alzheimer’s was considered incurable as of 2010; treatments at that time served only to alleviate its symptoms. The death of Ronald Reagan in 2004 from Alzheimer’s focused attention on the use of controversial stem cell research in finding a cure.
372 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Duma Key
W Themes King uses the major characters of Duma Key to explore the untapped powers of the human mind. Each of these characters has experienced brain damage in some way, but each has been given, in return, unusual powers: prescience, clairvoyance, the power to create reality from imagination. Imagination and self-expression are powerful tools that come with a heavy responsibility, as they can affect the material world. Both Wireman and Edgar tell the reader repeatedly, “God punishes us for what we can’t imagine” (286). Though this is said in a negative context—referring to the horrors one fails to imagine— it can also be read as a comment on how most humans use a small fraction of their mental capacity. Significantly, all three characters with brain injuries have been injured on the right side, the side of the brain associated with creativity and self-expression. An associated theme concerns memory and how memory works. Edgar, whose verbal memory is impaired by his injury, uses the technique of thinking sideways to remember words and names when he cannot easily access them, making associations between words until he arrives at the correct one. Afflicted with Alzheimer’s disease, Elizabeth Eastlake is losing her memories, but through her artwork, Edgar is able to access them. Elizabeth tells Edgar, “Art is memory, Edgar. . . . The clearer the
MAJOR CHARACTERS JACK CANTORI is hired by Edgar’s real estate agent to assist Edgar while he is on the island. ELIZABETH EASTLAKE, a wealthy elderly woman suffering from Alzheimer’s disease, owns almost all the property on Duma Key. Edgar comes to know her after meeting Wireman, her caretaker. EDGAR FREEMANTLE, former CEO of a building company who was seriously injured in an accident on a building site, has moved to Duma Key in hopes of aiding his recovery. ILSE FREEMANTLE, Edgar’s younger and favorite daughter, is in college. MELINDA FREEMANTLE, Edgar’s older daughter, teaches in France. PAM FREEMANTLE, Edgar’s former wife, divorced Edgar shortly after his accident. XANDER KAMEN, Edgar’s psychologist, recommends the move to Florida. JEROME WIREMAN is Edgar’s newest friend and caretaker of wealthy octogenarian Elizabeth Eastlake.
Author Stephen King’s Duma Key is set on a fictional Florida Key off the coast of Sarasota. ª Mirek Weichsel/First Light/Corbis TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
373
Duma Key
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Stephen King was born on September 21, 1947, in Portland, Maine, and was raised in Maine by his mother, Nellie Ruth Pillsbury King. He graduated from the University of Maine at Orono in 1970, and married fellow writer Tabitha Spruce in 1971. King supported himself by teaching high school English and selling short stories to men’s magazines until 1973, when the success of his novel Carrie allowed him to write full time. In 1999 King was hit by a van while out on a walk near his home in Maine and was seriously injured (many critics speculated that he used this experience to inform his portrayal of Edgar Freemantle in Duma Key). After his recovery, he continued to write, and as of 2010 had written over fifty books. King’s work has won numerous awards, including multiple Bram Stoker Awards (from the Horror Writers Association), the O. Henry Award for Best Short Story of 1996, the Grand Master Award from the Mystery Writers of America, and the National Book Foundation’s Medal for Distinguished Contribution to American Letters in 2003. King and his wife spend their winters in Florida and the rest of the year in Maine.
memory, the better the art” (492). Memories, unfortunately, are not always positive, as Edgar finds when Elizabeth’s memories literally come back to haunt him. As Edgar says, “Loss of memory isn’t always the problem; sometimes—maybe even often—it’s the solution” (518).
W Style Duma Key is written in the first person, from the perspective of Edgar Freemantle. Edgar tells the story in retrospect, about four years after the events have occurred. Because Edgar already knows the end of the story, he can draw conclusions and foreshadow events in a way he could not if he were relating the events in the present tense, as they happen. For instance, when Edgar describes his last glance of his daughter Ilse as she boards the airplane leaving Florida, he says, “I wish with all my heart that I could have seen her better, because I never saw her again” (538). King alternates between Edgar’s story and the childhood tale of Elizabeth Eastlake’s head injury and resulting artistic flowering. The installments of Elizabeth’s tale are titled “How to Draw a Picture,” I through XII, printed in italics. At first, the reader is unaware whose story is being told in these installments, until Edgar meets Elizabeth Eastlake and learns more of her history. The novel concludes with the last installment. King earned his reputation writing horror novels, and elements of that genre are present in this work. Though the first half of the book centers more on
374
In Duma Key an injured builder moves to one of the Florida Keys to recover and begins creating strange paintings with mysterious powers. Martha McGowen/Shutterstock.com
psychological aspects of Edgar’s recovery, later chapters include deaths, blood, ghosts, and creatures from the underworld. King refers to Greek mythology as well with the character of Persephone, first introduced as the name of a macabre ship Edgar paints repeatedly without knowing why. In Greek mythology, Persephone is the mate of Hades, god of the underworld; her name means “bringer of destruction.” She lives up to that name in the final chapters of Duma Key.
W Critical Reception Critics have typically been divided over Stephen King’s work, and Duma Key was no exception. Though many critics agreed that the novel is an enjoyable read, there were differing opinions as to its literary merit. James Campbell, in a largely negative review in the New York Times Book Review, called King’s characterization “flimsy,” claiming that Edgar is not a likable protagonist and that his friend Wireman is “annoying.” However, a review in Publishers Weekly praised King’s “ability to create fully realized characters” and called the novel “well crafted.” Other points of contention included the amount of time it takes King to reach the more horrific events of the novel. Adele Hartley, in a review for the Guardian, stated that King spent too long on Edgar’s recovery. She wrote: “It’s hard not to feel impatient as the clues and nightmares proliferate” (though she went on to praise the eerier portions of the book). Janet Maslin of the New York Times weighed in with the opposite opinion: “Mr. King constructs his story with patience and rigor. His own past tendency to wander untethered into the world of dreams is under control.” The Publishers Weekly review TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Duma Key
questioned the necessity of the novel’s ghastlier elements, stating, “The transition from the initial psychological suspense to the supernatural may disappoint some.” It seems that King’s work is an acquired taste, a taste that, fortunately for King, has been acquired by millions of loyal readers. Benjamin Percy of Esquire is one of those; in his review, Percy wrote, “Stephen King has always been good, but with his latest novel, Duma Key, he once again approaches greatness.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Campbell, James. “Dark Art.” Rev. of Duma Key, by Stephen King. New York Times Book Review 2 Mar. 2008: 9(L). Print. “David Paul Davis and His Islands.” tampapix.com. Tampa Pix, n.d. Web. 8 Oct. 2010. “Duma Key.” Rev. of Duma Key, by Stephen King. Publishers Weekly 10 Dec. 2007: 37. Print. Hartley, Adele. “Books, Evil Dolls and Other Weirdness.” Rev. of Duma Key, by Stephen King. guardian.co.uk. Guardian 16 Feb. 2008. Web. 8 Oct. 2010. “Head Injury and Alzheimer’s Disease–Study.” fi.edu. Franklin Institute Online, 2004. Web. 8 Oct. 2010. “History of Alzheimer’s Disease.” hod.kcms.msu.edu. Kalamazoo Center for Medical Studies, 2004-2005. Web. 8 Oct. 2010. King, Stephen. Duma Key. New York: Pocket BooksSimon and Schuster, 2008. Print. Maslin, Janet. “Darkness in the Land of Steady Sunshine.” Rev. of Duma Key, by Stephen King. nytimes. com. New York Times 21 Jan. 2008. Web. 8 Oct. 2010. Percy, Benjamin. “Still King.” Rev. of Duma Key, by Stephen King. esquire.com. Esquire 21 Feb. 2008. Web. 8 Oct. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Bancroft, Colette. “With Duma Key, Stephen King Brings Horror to Our Backyard.” sptimes.com. St. Petersburg Times 20 Jan. 2008. Web. 8 Oct. 2010. Looks at Floridian aspects of the novel; compares themes from Duma Key to those of King’s earlier works. Dugdale, John. “Duma Key by Stephen King.” Rev. of Duma Key, by Stephen King. timesonline.co.uk. Sunday Times 20 Jan. 2008. Web. 8 Oct. 2010. Examines allusions to classic horror tales within Duma Key and the understated (for King) use of horror elements.
Graham, Mark. “King Plot No Accident.” Rev. of Duma Key, by Stephen King. rockymountainnews.com. Rocky Mountain News 18 Jan. 2008. Web. 8 Oct. 2010. Describes parallels between King’s personal injury and the novel’s plot and looks at recurrent device of auto accidents in King’s novels. Karim, Ali. “King’s Florida Nightmare.” Rev. of Duma Key, by Stephen King. januarymagazine.com. January Magazine Jan. 2008. Web. 8 Oct. 2010. Points out allusions and parallels between this novel and other King works and examines the theme of randomness in the events of the characters’ lives. “King, Stephen: Duma Key.” Rev. of Duma Key, by Stephen King. Kirkus Reviews 15 Dec. 2007. Print. Compares theme of this novel with that of The Shining. Rahner, Mark. “Stephen King’s Absorbing New Thriller, Duma Key.” Rev. of Duma Key, by Stephen King. seattletimes.com. Seattle Times 22 Jan. 2008. Web. 8 Oct. 2010. Criticizes King’s recycling of themes and plot lines from earlier works and suggests areas of book that need editing. Gale Resources
“Stephen (Edwin) King.” Contemporary Literary Criticism Select. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Literature Resource Center. Web. 8 Oct. 2010. http://go.galegroup. com/ps/i.do?&id=GALE%7CH1103890000 &v=2.1&u=itsbtrial&it=r&p=LitRG&sw=w Open Web Sources
The extensive Web site http://stephenking.com features complete lists of all of King’s works and awards, news about upcoming books and movies, a biography, a message board, and more. For Further Reading
Alexandrian, Sarane. Surrealist Art. New York: Thames and Hudson, 1985. Print. Examines the development of the surrealist movement in art from 1916 to 1966; discusses a wide range of surrealist artists and features many color illustrations of their work. King, Stephen. On Writing. New York: Pocket BooksSimon and Schuster, 2001. Print. Offers advice on writing tools and techniques; begins with autobiographical chapters, including a description of the 1999 incident in which King was near-fatally wounded by a minivan. Mason, Michael Paul. Head Cases: Stories of Brain Injury and Its Aftermath. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2009. Print. Describes the case histories of several patients dealing with the effects of traumatic brain injury (TBI), the few resources available to them through the health care system, and the different ways in which TBI can occur.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
375
Duma Key
Wiater, Stanley, et al. The Complete Stephen King Universe: A Guide to the Worlds of Stephen King. New York: St. Martin’s Griffin-St. Martin’s Press, 2006. Print. Offers analyses of King’s works, grouped in categories. Describes the ways in which the various novels overlap in theme, character, and setting. Includes analyses of novels written under King’s various pseudonyms as well.
Williams, Joy. The Florida Keys: A History and Guide. 10th ed. New York: Random House, 2003. Print. Combines history and travel guide to create a comprehensive look at the Florida Keys. Includes offbeat sites to visit, nature lore of the region, and little-known historical facts. Written by a novelist and resident of the Keys. Laura Pryor
376
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
El Dorado By Dorothy Porter
W Introduction El Dorado (2007) is a crime thriller told in verse rather than prose. The story itself is a harrowing one, following the hunt for a serial killer (the title character) who targets children in Victoria, Australia. Catching the killer is the job of detective inspector Bill Buchanan, who turns for help to his childhood friend Cath. A secondary plot concerns the erotic attachments of these protagonists, not only Bill’s unrequited love for Cath, who is a lesbian, but also Cath’s steamy affair with a much younger woman, Lily. The tale, which is divided into six sections, explores not only the disturbing topic of the primary plot but also themes such as lost worlds that serve as a metaphor for the loss of childhood innocence. Dorothy Porter published numerous collections of poetry in her lifetime, along with four novels in verse. Her employment of poetry in the novel form, particularly in the crime thriller, won her a much wider audience than most poets enjoy. Praised by critics in a variety of Australian publications, El Dorado was shortlisted for the inaugural Prime Minister’s Literary Award and nominated for the Ned Kelly Award for Best Fiction in 2007.
W Literary and Historical Context
The verse novel is a format as old as literature itself, dating from such early epics as the Sumerian Gilgamesh and Homer’s Iliad and Odyssey through such notable works as Don Juan by Lord Byron and Aleksandr Pushkin’s Eugene Onegin. In the fast-paced electronic age, however, the form might seem to be outdated. As Jaya Savige observes in Australia’s Courier Mail, “These days the words poetry and page-turner are hardly synonymous. But for Dorothy Porter . . . there is no reason why they shouldn’t be.” In answer to the question
“Why write verse novels?” Geoffrey Lehmann in the Weekend Australian quotes Porter: “Like most poets I was sick of not being read.” Through the use of poetry in the form of a novel, and a fast-paced crime novel at that, El Dorado brought Porter a much wider audience. Her Monkey’s Mask, for example, appeared as a major motion picture, starring Kelly McGillis, in 2000. El Dorado is not a typical crime story, as it deals with a particularly heinous act: the serial murder of children. The text references a real unsolved case of child abduction (and presumably murder) that transformed Australian society. On January 26, 1966 (Australia Day, a national holiday), Jim and Nancy Beaumont allowed their three children, ranging in age from four to nine, to journey alone by bus to Glenelg Beach, five minutes from their home in Adelaide. The parents never saw their children again, and the case—which, despite a number of suspects, remained unsolved four decades later—forever changed the way Australian parents regarded the matter of protecting their children’s safety.
W Themes A central theme in El Dorado is one that springs quite obviously from its grisly portrayal of murdered children: the loss of innocence. Images of Peter Pan and his “Lost Boys” proliferate throughout the story, as does the concept of vanished and imaginary worlds. Even the killer’s pseudonym harkens to such a vision, referring as it does to the legend of a “lost city of gold” in South America. He believes that by killing the children he is sending them to a better place. Entwined with this concept of fictional worlds is Cath’s profession as a Hollywood illusionist, or “imaginary worlds specialist director,” whose “job was to make/ the imaginary world/plausible.” Bill characterizes her as one possessed with “the lateral thinking/of an intelligent child/spliced with/an intuitive adult’s experience.” Every film she has worked on involves
377 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
El Dorado
MAJOR CHARACTERS BILL BUCHANAN is one of the story’s protagonists. A fiftysomething detective inspector for the Victoria Police in Australia, he has the task of finding and capturing the killer, a quest that for him has particular significance because he is the father of a young girl, Caitlin. In solving the crime, Bill turns for help to Cath, a friend since childhood, for whom he feels a strong but unrequited love. CAITLIN BUCHANAN is Bill’s rebellious teenage daughter, who resists his efforts to protect her and whose safety becomes a matter of major concern as her father hunts for the killer. CATH, along with Bill Buchanan, is one of the story’s central characters. She works as an “imaginary worlds specialist director” in Hollywood, and Bill turns to her, with her knowledge of the world of illusion, for help in solving the crimes. Bill has a romantic attachment to her that she does not share, not least because she is a lesbian. JASMINE COOK is a rookie police constable who works alongside Bill in pursuit of the killer. EL DORADO is the killer whose murders of young children form the basis for the book’s plot. He is so named because he leaves a gold mark on his victims’ foreheads (El Dorado was the name for a legendary city of gold in South America), and his identity is revealed only near the end of the story. LILY is a young herpetologist (a scientist concerned with the study of snakes) who, despite a significant age difference, develops a romantic relationship with Cath. This story, along with Bill’s unrequited love for Cath, forms the book’s secondary plot. AXEL PINE is a trauma counselor who, in Bill’s view, goes too far in attempting to protect children. “If Axel Pine had his way,” Bill observes at one point, “there’d be mandatory detention / for anyone who looks twice / at any child—/ under thirty.” PUT-PUT is a childhood acquaintance of Bill’s and Cath’s whom they, along with other children, persecuted mercilessly for being a “weird kid.”
water, leading to her nickname, Noah, and blending easily with the idea of another famous imaginary world, Atlantis, which is also the title of the book’s second section. Working as she does in the world of fantasy, Cath is obsessed with holding on to the illusion of youth. Thus Bill, looking at the unlined face of his “fifty year something” contemporary, surmises that she has undergone cosmetic surgery. More pointedly, Cath attempts to hold on to youth through her pursuit of Lily, whom she describes as “absurdly young.” She fears that when people see them together in public, they may mistake
378
Photo of Dorothy Porter, author of the novel El Dorado. ª MARKA/ Alamy
them for mother and daughter, and Cath worries that she is merely “a stupid deluded/leering embarrassing/old tart.”
W Style Rather than a single long poetic work, El Dorado is structured around separate poems, with titles such as “Howzat,” “The Facts of Life,” and “Bill’s Nightmare.” These are grouped within the larger framework of the book’s six sections: “The Stolen Child,” “Atlantis,” “Neverland,” “Lovers’ Cave,” “El Dorado,” and “The First Snake.” Commenting on this marriage of two quite different stylistic elements, the verse novel and the murder mystery, fellow poet Lisa Gorton observes in the Sydney Morning Herald that “the two forms, apparent opposites, work well together. The verse novel’s line breaks build suspense and its accelerated pace adds to that expectation of the end, which is the first charm of murder mysteries.” Although the verse-novel format sets it apart from most crime fiction, in other respects El Dorado is faithful to the conventions of the genre. Such stories necessarily TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
El Dorado
involve not only the crimes themselves but also the clues that help solve them, including evidence at the crime scenes and the killer’s taunting of the authorities through the media—in this case by letters to the editor of the Age, an actual Australian newspaper. There is also the “red herring,” or false clue, which appears in a number of forms, for instance when Bill incorrectly judges one of the murders to be a copycat killing. Likewise Bill, as often happens with detectives in crime stories, becomes too personally involved in the case, especially after his daughter Caitlin disappears. Wordplay and literary allusion also characterize the style of El Dorado. Porter employs a number of words and images peculiar to Australian English. “Howzat,” for instance, is a local variation on “how’s that,” the standard form of an appeal for an umpire’s decision in a cricket match. She also uses standard English in unusual ways, for example by having Cath describe her love for Lily as “radioactively festive like an X-ray on ecstasy.” Allusions to literature and popular culture abound, with references to works ranging from fairy tales and ancient myths to Mickey Mouse cartoons and James Bond movies.
W Critical Reception Critics laud Porter’s skillful use of language, her employment of the verse-novel form within the crime genre, and—to a lesser degree—her balancing of the primary plot against the secondary one. According to Geoff Page, writing in the Canberra Times, “The Cath/ Lily romance (too tame a word perhaps) threatens at times to derail things but also adds an extra and poignant depth” to the relationship between Bill and Cath. Likewise, Geoffrey Lehmann writes in the Weekend Australian that “about halfway through I was beginning to wonder whether the Cath and Lily affair would overwhelm the El Dorado narrative and whether Porter was writing two novels in one. However, like an expert juggler . . . by the end of the novel Porter manages to balance her themes.” Lehmann goes on to say that “for those unfamiliar with the verse novel as a form, El Dorado is a good place to start,” while Gillian Dooley, in the Adelaide Review, maintains that “narrative verse is an unusual art form these days, probably rightly so, because it’s hard to imagine many writers doing it as well as Porter does.” Gorton, in the Sydney Morning Herald, praises the author’s use of language. Noting that Porter has cowritten songs with jazz musician Paul Grabowsky, Gorton observes that “Porter’s verse novels also work like jazz. Her short-line stanzas . . . have a raw, involving jazz style; and you could think of her plots as improvisations on the set pieces of her imagery.” The author, Gorton concludes, “fits complex characters, elaborate images and strung-out verse into a fast-paced murder mystery.” In a
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Dorothy Porter was born in Sydney, Australia in 1954. Her father was a barrister (lawyer) and her mother was a highschool chemistry teacher, and both continued to work into their eighties. Her career as a writer began at the Queenswood School for Girls, where she enthralled classmates with stories, and at age fourteen she began her diary with the words “I’m going to be a writer.” Graduating from the University of Sydney in 1975 with a BA in English and history, she set out to make a living as a poet. Though poetry books typically do not enjoy large sales, Porter found great success by melding the versenovel form with the crime thriller in such works as The Monkey’s Mask, adapted for the screen in 2000. A selfdescribed pagan and an open lesbian, Porter lived with fellow writer Andrea Goldsmith from 1993 until Porter’s death in 2008 at age fifty-four from breast cancer.
similar vein, Corrie Perkin writes in the Weekend Australian that “Porter weaves a masterly narrative of changing rhythms that pull the reader across an unpredictable, rolling ocean of words . . . . But aside from its poetic strengths, El Dorado is also a riveting murder mystery.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Dooley, Gillian. Rev. of El Dorado, by Dorothy Porter. Adelaide Review. Adelaide Review 20 July 2007: 24. Web. 14 Oct. 2010. Gorton, Lisa. “Crime’s Last Stanza.” Rev. of El Dorado, by Dorothy Porter. Sydney Morning Herald. Fairfax Media, 26 May 2007: 34. Web. 14 Oct. 2010. Lehmann, Geoffrey. “Innocence Lovingly Stolen within Familiar Verse.” Rev. of El Dorado, by Dorothy Porter. Weekend Australian. News Limited, 9 June 2007: 8. Web. 14 Oct. 2010. Page, Geoff. Rev. of El Dorado, by Dorothy Porter. Canberra Times. Fairfax Media, 16 June 2007: 12. Web. 14 Oct. 2010. Perkin, Corrie. “Venturing into Disturbing Terrain.” Weekend Australian. News Limited, 21 April 2007: 12. Web. 14 Oct. 2010. Porter, Dorothy. El Dorado. Sydney: Picador Pan Macmillan Australia, 2007. Print. Savige, Jaya. “Crime Thriller Bursts into Verse.” Rev. of El Dorado, by Dorothy Porter. Courier-Mail [Brisbane]. Queensland Newspapers, 5 May 2007: M33. Web. 14 Oct. 2010.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
379
El Dorado Additional Resources
Open Web Sources
Criticism and Reviews
A lengthy review of El Dorado, followed by an interview by Magdalena Ball with Porter, appears on the Web site of M/C Reviews: Culture and Media, an Australian online journal of popular culture. http:// reviews.media-culture.org.au
Craven, Peter. “A Piece of Work, and Then Some.” Sydney Morning Herald. Fairfax Media, 10 Jan. 2009: 33. Web. 14 Oct. 2010. Craven, a judge for the inaugural Prime Minister’s Literary Award in 2008, for which El Dorado was short-listed, examines Porter’s life and work. Goldsworthy, Peter. “Tall Tales and True in Chapter and Verse.” Rev. of El Dorado, by Dorothy Porter, and other works. Australian. News Limited, 2 May 2007: 12. Web. 14 Oct. 2010. This is a comparative review of El Dorado, along with two other poetry works by Australians: Lawrie and Shirley: The Final Cadenza by Geoff Page and Fredy Neptune by Les Murray. Knight, Stephen. “Our Dark Materials: Crime Fiction.” Age [Melbourne]. Fairfax Media, 20 June 2009: 26. Web. 14 Oct. 2010. The author gives a lengthy overview of Australian crime fiction, including El Dorado. Knobel, Paul. “Poet Pushed Boundaries and Encouraged Others.” Age [Melbourne]. Fairfax Media, 12 Dec. 2008: 18. Web. 14 Oct. 2010. This obituary discusses El Dorado in the context of Porter’s larger career. Neill, Rosemary. “Pulping Our Poetry.” Weekend Australian. News Limited, 7 July 2007: 4. Web. 14 Oct. 2010. Neill gives a lengthy discussion of Australian poets’ efforts to reach wider audiences, including Porter’s employment of the novel-in-verse format in El Dorado and other works. Ryan, Gig. “Of Lucid Verse and Passionate Truths.” Age [Melbourne]. Fairfax Media, 20 Dec. 2008: 23. Web. 14 Oct. 2010. This is a discussion of Porter’s career and works, including El Dorado. Smith, Tony. “The Destruction of Childhood—It’s Criminal.” Rev. of El Dorado, by Dorothy Porter, and other works. AQ: Australian Quarterly 79.4 (2007): 36-40. General OneFile. Web. 15 Oct. 2010. Smith examines El Dorado, along with two other crime stories by Australian writers: Gabrielle Lord’s Shattered and Jane Goodall’s The Calling. Gale Resources
“Dorothy (Featherstone) Porter.” Contemporary Poets. Seventh edition. Detroit: St. James, 2001. Literature Resource Center. Web. 15 Oct. 2010. “Dorothy Porter.” Australian Writers, 1975-2000. Ed. Selina Samuels. Detroit: Gale, 2006. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 325. Literature Resource Center. Web. 15 Oct. 2010. “Dorothy Porter.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Web. 15 Oct. 2010.
380
An appreciation of Porter’s life and works is available on a site dedicated to the author. http://dorothyporter. wikispaces.com An interview, conducted by Rosanna Licari, is featured on the Web site of Stylus Poetry Journal. http:// www.styluspoetryjournal.com An interview with Porter is available on the Compulsive Reader Web site. http://www.compulsivereader.com Porter’s Australian publisher offers a study guide that includes an overview of the novel’s plot, characters, and themes, along with discussion questions, on its Web site. http://www.panmacmillan.com For Further Reading
Carr, Caleb. The Alienist. New York: Random House, 1994. Print. A novel that, like El Dorado, concerns the hunt for a killer of children, The Alienist is set in New York City during the 1890s, when psychologists were known as “alienists.” The novel features real people, most notably Theodore Roosevelt, and portrays a fictional early effort to apply psychological profiling in catching a criminal. Jones, Tayari. Leaving Atlanta. New York: Warner, 2002. Print. One of several books relating to the murders of more than two-dozen children in Atlanta in the early 1980s, Leaving Atlanta is a novel depicting the lives of several children during the time of the murders. Mailer, Norman. The Executioner’s Song. New York: Little Brown, 1979. Print. Critic Don Anderson has described Porter as “Australia’s Norman Mailer.” In The Executioner’s Song, Mailer portrays the crimes, conviction, and execution of Gary Gilmore, who in 1977 became the first U.S. prisoner executed after the reinstatement of the death penalty the year before. Nabokov, Vladimir. Pale Fire. New York: Putnam, 1962. Print. Pale Fire, like El Dorado, employs poetry and explores the twisted mind of a killer, but it does so in quite a different way. Whereas the tone of El Dorado is serious, Pale Fire is a highly satirical book. The title refers to a long poem by the murder victim, and the book is composed primarily of the killer’s annotations to the manuscript. Porter, Dorothy. The Monkey’s Mask: An Erotic Murder Mystery. New York: Little Brown, 1994. Print. Porter’s most successful work (it was adapted for the stage and ultimately to film), The Monkey’s Mask TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
El Dorado
prefigures El Dorado in its use of the verse-novel format for a crime thriller. Sebold, Alice. The Lovely Bones. New York: Little Brown, 2002. Print. Sebold’s novel, later adapted as a motion picture, concerns a young girl who was abducted, raped, and murdered.
Melbourne: Wiley, 2006. Print. This book examines the 1966 case, referred to in El Dorado, which forever altered Australian parents’ views about protecting their children’s safety. Judson Knight
Whiticker, Alan. Searching for the Beaumont Children: Australia’s Most Famous Unsolved Mystery.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
381
The Electric Michelangelo By Sarah Hall
W Introduction Sarah Hall’s The Electric Michelangelo (2004) tells the story of Cy Parks, born in 1907 and raised in the working-class seaside resort town of Morecambe, England. His mother runs a hotel that caters to the sick and dying; as a teenager Cy becomes apprenticed to the town’s misanthropic tattoo artist, Riley. Cy becomes the Electric Michelangelo of the title, first in Morecambe and then in Coney Island, New York. The novel revels in the often violent lives of boardwalk entertainers who are marginalized from society. The physical pain inflicted by Cy’s tattoo needle serves as a metaphor for the often brutal psychological pain of his existence. The novel received excellent reviews and was shortlisted for Britain’s prestigious Man Booker Prize and longlisted for the Orange Prize. Hall’s realism in depicting the art of tattooing was informed by the three tattoos she received herself in the process of researching the book, which allowed her to delve into the history of the folk art. As she told Benedicte Page in an interview for Bookseller, “tattooing is a record of life, because you commemorate events with a picture, so your skin becomes a kind of history.”
W Literary and Historical Context
At the turn of the twentieth century, England’s resorts on the Irish Sea were popular vacation destinations for factory workers in the northern industrial towns of Manchester and Liverpool. Although Morecambe was not as well known as Blackpool, a much larger resort to the south, it contained all the amusements British vacationers expected: wide beaches, music halls, game arcades, amusement rides, fortune tellers, restaurants— and tattoo parlors. The salty air was advertised as being
healthful, and many people flocked to the region in hopes that the fresh breeze would alleviate their consumption or tuberculosis, just as Reeda’s guests at the Bayview Hotel do. By the 1930s, when Cy arrives in Coney Island, the seaside oasis is already past its prime. The major amusement parks—Dreamland, Steeplechase, and Luna Park—had all suffered major fires and been torn down or scaled back, yet the island’s reputation for decadence remained. Just a subway’s ride from all the boroughs of New York, the attractions on Coney Island were within reach of millions who had neither the money nor the time to travel beyond the confines of the city. As with Morecambe, tattoo artists were a fixture on the Coney boardwalk. The electric tattoo machine, the same used by Riley and Cy, was developed by New Yorker Samuel O’Reilly in 1891. O’Reilly adapted Thomas Edison’s 1876 electric engraving machine for use on human skin. In 1899 Englishman Alfred Charles South improved this design into the modern two-coil system still used today. During the time the novel takes place, tattoos were closely associated with the circus and those who spent their lives at sea. Many sideshows featured completely tattooed individuals, and tattoo artists could be found wherever circus performers congregated—especially seaside resorts such as Coney Island and Morecambe. The execution of Lulu the elephant in The Electric Michelangelo is based on a real event. Topsy the Elephant was a popular circus attraction at Coney Island’s Luna Park at the turn of the twentieth century. Over the years, the ill-tempered Topsy killed three of her handlers. After the death of the third (who had tried to feed her a lighted cigarette), her owners decided to kill her. Her execution was scheduled for January 4, 1903, and was turned into a media event that was filmed for posterity. Thomas Edison suggested electrocuting Topsy with alternating current (AC) as a way of demonstrating to his competitors George Westinghouse and Nikola Tesla that AC was more dangerous than the direct current (DC) generated
382 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Electric Michelangelo
MAJOR CHARACTERS GRACE is a circus performer and refugee from Eastern Europe who lives in Cy’s apartment building with her horse, Maximus. She is intelligent and independent, and Cy falls in love with her during the long hours it takes to cover her body in tattoos of eyes. When an acquaintance douses her in acid, her skin dissolves and she nearly dies. CYRIL PARKS, known as Cy, is the Electric Michelangelo of the title. As a boy he grows up in his mother’s no-frills Bayview Hotel and tends to the sick guests; he becomes apprenticed to the town’s tattoo artist as a teenager. Haunted by the deaths of his mother and his mentor Riley, Cy leaves Morecambe for Coney Island, where he meets Grace, whose body he covers in tattoos of green eyes. After he gouges out a man’s eyes in retaliation for the man attacking Grace with acid, Cy returns to Morecambe. He revives his shuttered tattoo business and takes on a young apprentice.
In The Electric Michelangelo, Cy Parks is a tattoo artist living in Morecambe, England, who moves to New York City to practice his trade on Coney Island. ª Bettmann/Corbis
by the Edison Company. A crowd of 1,500 gathered to watch as Topsy dined on carrots dipped in potassium cyanide and then as smoke poured from the soles of her feet as the switch was thrown. In a few short seconds, the 28-year-old elephant toppled over like a felled tree to the delight of the spectators.
W Themes Pain and suffering is one of Hall’s major themes in The Electric Michelangelo. Cy grows up surrounded by pain. The guests at his mother’s hotel are dying, painfully and slowly, and it is his job to clean up after them. When his mother harbors girls and women undergoing painful abortions, young Cy grows accustomed to their anguished, frightened cries. Despite the proximity of so much misery, Cy comes to understand that his mother, while she does not romanticize suffering, feels that it is her duty to help people endure it. As a tattoo artist, Cy’s livelihood requires that he cause pain, and in the roughand-tumble circles in which he travels, brute force is a way of life. Riley wallows in pain both mental and physical as a tortured artist, a situation that comes to a head when his hand is smashed and he commits suicide by swallowing bleach, which proves to be an incredibly agonizing death. Grace, who has submitted to hundreds of hours of tattoo
REEDA PARKS is Cy’s mother and the proprietor of the Bayview Hotel. Charitable in nature, Reeda believes it is her duty to provide a decent vacation for factory workers who have toiled their whole lives in the service of others. She also provides a safe harbor for girls and women who seek abortions, although she does not perform them herself. When she is diagnosed with breast cancer in 1922, she meticulously closes down the hotel and teaches Cy everything he needs to know to survive without her. ELIOT RILEY is the eccentric, misanthropic tattoo artist who chooses Cy to carry on his business. He torments Cy but teaches him well, becoming his father figure and drawing the boy into his marginal existence. Riley has a foul mouth and drinks constantly, but he considers himself an artist and takes his work seriously. When his hand is smashed in a fight, he has nothing left to live for and commits suicide. MALCOLM SEDAK is a mentally unstable man who feels threatened by Grace’s proto-feminism. He tries to kill her by drenching her in acid, which lands him in the mental ward of a prison. In retaliation for his crime, Cy gouges his eyes out.
needle discomfort, is splashed with acid and her skin dissolves, nearly killing her. She is disfigured for life, permanently, painfully cobbled and scarred to the point of freakishness. Cy gouges out the eyes of Grace’s attacker, using his unflinching familiarity with human flesh to exact revenge. Living on the fringes of the mainstream seems to leave the characters disproportionately exposed to pain and suffering. As much as the book is about pain, it is also about healing. Cy inherits a sense of benevolence from Reeda and malevolence from Riley. He balances these opposing
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
383
The Electric Michelangelo
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Sarah Hall was born in 1974 in the northern English county of Cumbria, close to the seaside town of Morecambe where the first half of The Electric Michelangelo takes place. She graduated from Aberystwyth University in Wales and received a master’s degree in literature from St. Andrews University in Scotland. Although she regards herself first as a poet, she received accolades for her first novel, Haweswater (2002). Haweswater is a fictionalized account of the flooding of a reservoir in 1936 in the Cumbrian village of Mardale, an event that irrevocably changes the lives of the Lightburn family, who have farmed the land for generations. Critics praised Hall’s deft use of language and water imagery in the book, and it received the Commonwealth Writers Prize for best first book and the Betty Trask Award. After The Electric Michelangelo, Hall published The Carhullan Army (titled Daughters of the North in the United States), the story of a near-future dystopia also set in Cumbria, which serves as a cautionary feminist tale of a fragile, post-oil, ravaged-climate world. The book received the John Llewellyn Rhys Prize. How to Paint a Dead Man (2009) tells the intergenerational story of four artists with ties to a reclusive Italian landscape painter who died in the 1960s. Hall divides her time between England and North Carolina.
forces successfully, for the most part. At any time his precarious circumstances could justify a descent into hatred, as happened to Riley, but instead he chooses a path toward hope and reconciliation. He does lash out, however, when Grace is harmed. He commits a heinous crime—his first—in retaliation for the pain she suffers. He chooses to heal himself—to leave behind the brutality that befell him on Coney Island in favor of Morecambe, a place made painful by ghosts but in which he can leave a positive artistic legacy. In the end he reconciles himself to mentoring Nina, choosing this new beginning over a languishing decline into old age. Another theme of The Electric Michelangelo is folk art. In interviews, Hall has stated that her interest in the folk art of tattooing compelled her to write the novel. Folk art is created by those not formally trained and its skills are passed down from one generation to the next through informal mentoring. Unschooled painting, woodcarving, and quilting are forms of folk art that have been disparaged by experts for generations; they give great pleasure to the artists and their recipients but are deemed inferior to works created and sold as art. Tattooing has existed for centuries, yet until recent times those who underwent the procedure in Western cultures were considered to be on the fringes of society. Riley imparts to Cy an appreciation for the seriousness
Portrait of Sarah Hall, author of The Electric Michelangelo. ª Colin McPherson/Corbis
384
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Electric Michelangelo
and beauty of tattoos despite their alienation from respectable society. As folk art, their tattoos are made for and enjoyed by the working class, who see them as totems of their life experiences. Cy’s customers use their tattoos to give them a sense of individuality amid the anonymity of the modern, industrialized world. Grace uses her whole body as a canvass for folk art, allowing Cy to live up to his nom de plume. As the real Michelangelo painted the Sistine Chapel, so Cy is the Michelangelo of Grace’s body, turning it into a cathedral of folk art. And as with the predicament of folk art throughout most of history, her tattooed eyes are seen as a hideous aberration by the man who attacks her.
W Style Hall regards herself as a poet first and a novelist second. Thus, it makes sense that The Electric Michelangelo is infused with poetic imagery and that critics consistently commend Hall for her evocative lyricism. As she told Benedicte Page in an interview for the Bookseller, “In this book I was going for an old-fashioned, lyrical feel to suit the setting, with a lot of internal rhyming within the sentences.” The result, according to Michelene Wandor of the Sunday Times is “muscular, glinting prose.” Lilian Pizzichini, writing in the Financial Times, complimented Hall’s “gorgeously embellished prose” that gives “tantalizing glimpses” of the characters’ lives. Likewise, Susann Cokal, writing in the New York Times Book Review, said the “novel is more about images than plot” and concluded that readers should revel in the novel’s “slow grace” and “allow the language and imagery to sweep [them] up.”
W Critical Reception Hall had already made a name for herself with her first novel, Haweswater, and reviews for The Electric Michelangelo were just as positive. Jem Poster, writing in the Guardian, called it “a work of unusual imaginative power and range.” Writing in Booklist, Carol Haggas admired how Hall “explores timeless themes of loss and redemption with an ageless wisdom and grace.” A writer for Kirkus Reviews grew weary of the characters and poetic language, but a critic from Publishers Weekly called the writing “pure joy.” Cokal concluded that “Hall’s novel is to be admired for its own slow grace.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Cokal, Susann. “Body of Work.” New York Times Book Review 6 Nov. 2005: 17. Literature Resource Center. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. Rev. of The Electric Michelangelo, by Sarah Hall. Kirkus Reviews, 1 Aug. 2005: 806. Literature Resource Center. Web. 13 Sept. 2010.
Rev. of The Electric Michelangelo, by Sarah Hall. Publishers Weekly, 8 Aug. 2005: 211. Literature Resource Center. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. Haggas, Carol. Rev. of The Electric Michelangelo, by Sarah Hall. Booklist 15 Oct. 2005: 30. Literature Resource Center. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. Page, Benedicte. “Recorded on the Skin: Sarah Hall’s Second Novel Explores the Mysterious Art of the Tattooist.” Bookseller 21 Nov. 2003: 26. Literature Resource Center. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. Pizzichini, Lilian. Rev. of The Electric Michelangelo, by Sarah Hall. Financial Time 17 April 2004: 33. Literature Resource Center. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. Poster, Jem. “Written in Skin: Jem Poster Traces a Tattoo Artist’s Compelling Journey.” Guardian, books. guardian.co.uk (27 Mar. 2004): 27. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. Wandor, Michelene. Rev. of The Electric Michelangelo, by Sarah Hall. Sunday Times [London], 16 May 2004: 52. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Guest, Katy. “Interview: Writer Sarah Hall’s Novels Paint Communities Teeming with Life and Teetering near Death.” Independent 10 Aug. 2007. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. A lengthy interview with Hall in which she discusses all her novels, especially her research for The Carhullan Army and its ties to her own life. Thwaite, Mark. “Interview with Sarah Hall, Author of The Electric Michelangelo.” Ready, Steady Book 5 Dec. 2008. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. In this brief interview Hall talks about the differences and similarities between Haweswater and The Electric Michelangelo, writers who inspire her, and her research and writing process. Gale Resources
“Sarah Hall.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Web. 3 Sept. 2010. Open Web Sources
Sarah Hall’s official website at sarahhallauthor.com includes biographical information, overviews of her novels, and a schedule of events and personal appearances. For Further Reading
Baker, Kevin. Dreamland. New York: HarperCollins, 1999. Print. Baker’s expansive novel is set in Coney Island at the turn of the twentieth century. It blends multiple storylines featuring low-life carnies and hucksters with Tammany Hall politics and real-life
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
385
The Electric Michelangelo
historical figures that filtered through the park during its heyday. Brodie, Allan, and Gary Winter. England’s Seaside Resorts. London: English Heritage, 2007. Print. This history of English resorts focuses on the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, when the shore became the favored destination for Britain’s working classes. The authors focus on the special character of resort towns and include both new and historical photos. Caplan, Jane, ed. Written on the Body: The Tattoo in European and American History. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2000. Print. This scholarly collection of essays traces the history of tattooing in the West, particularly its roots in European and American history. Contributors conducted original research, with several examining the link between tattooing and slavery and tattooing and sexuality.
386
Hall, Sarah. Haweswater. New York: Harper Perennial, 2006. Print. Hall’s first novel won Britain’s Commonwealth Writers Prize for Best First Book. Set in the rural north of England, the book concerns the destruction of the Lightburns’ way of life when a reservoir is built that will flood their ancestral land. Kasson, John F. Amusing the Million: Coney Island at the Turn of the Century. New York: Hill and Wang, 1978. Print. This nonfiction account of Coney Island outlines its cultural significance in the pre-World War I era and includes numerous photos. Kathleen Wilson
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Elegance of the Hedgehog By Muriel Barbery
W Introduction Muriel Barbery’s The Elegance of the Hedgehog is a complicated novel. It explores ideas from such diverse areas as art and esthetics; literature and composition theory; film and music; sociology; economics; psychology; and French versus Japanese culture, particularly regarding the social implications of interior design. Faulted by some readers for investing in ideas at the expense of plot, the novel ingeniously weaves together two journals, written by characters who are astute thinkers and observers. One is fifty-four-year-old concierge Renée Michel, widowed since the mid-1980s, who reports on her life (both public and private) and develops theories about art, culture, and upperclass French society. The other is Paloma Josse, a precocious twelve-year-old who resides with her parents and sister in the upper-class apartment building that Renée manages. As different in class, age, and appearance as they are, these journal writers share common values and interests (for example, in music and Japanese culture); for different reasons, each chooses to reserve her insights for the safe precinct of her journal—that is, until a new resident, Kakuro Ozu, sees their real natures and manages to bring each out of her shell and into friendship with each other. For more than two decades, Renée has maintained the appearance of a low-class, uncultivated concierge, mostly adept at hiding her broad tastes in literature and gourmet cooking. In a sense, she believes doing so is part of her job as a concierge—to fulfill rich people’s expectations of some one in such a lowly position. Thus, every day she plays into the assumptions of snooty tenants and “perpetuates the charade of social hierarchy” (20). Paloma, a precocious and studious prepubescent child, entrusts her cunning descriptions of social intercourse and her conceptualization of profound thoughts to her journal
and habitually withdraws to hiding places in an effort to keep undercover her exceptional intelligence. Thus, she seeks to avoid the work that would befall her if her welleducated and ambitious parents ever saw her intellectual potential. Barbery’s second novel, L’élégance du hérisson, was published in French in 2006. Having held a place on the French best-seller list for more than one hundred weeks, it became a candidate for translation. That work was done by Alison Anderson, and The Elegance of the Hedgehog, published by Europa Editions, appeared in 2008.
W Literary and Historical Context
The literary and broader cultural context for The Elegance of the Hedgehog reflects Barbery’s formal education in philosophy and her love of literature and the arts. The novel begins with an allusion to Karl Marx, which immediately establishes the class consciousness that separates the concierge from the wealthy apartment residents. Barbery also demonstrates Renee’s familiarity with theoretical and philosophical texts when she quotes Feuerbach’s eleventh thesis (18) on the spur of the moment and compares herself to another “notorious concierge,” Legrandin, in Marcel Proust’s Remembrance of Things Past. She eschews popular romance, such as the works of Barbara Cartland, but loves Anna Karenina so much she has named her cat Leo, after the novel’s author, Leo Tolstoy. She loves film, alludes to Gone with the Wind and Blade Runner, and recalls that the last outing she enjoyed with her terminally ill husband was to see The Hunt for Red October. Startled in Kakuro’s bathroom, she immediately recognizes the piped-in music as the Confutatis in Mozart’s Requiem (221), and she responds emotionally to his exceptional reproduction of a still life by Pieter Claesz (199). While
387 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Elegance of the Hedgehog
MAJOR CHARACTERS PIERRE ARTHENS is the famous food critic who lives on the fourth floor. His death allows Kakuro Ozu to move into the luxury apartment building. COLOMBE JOSSE, older sister of Paloma, is a typical elitist styleconscious teenager. PALOMA JOSSE is the precocious twelve-year-old journal writer who narrates part of the novel. MANUELA LOPES, the Portuguese cleaning lady and mother of four, is the refined friend and confidante of Renée Michel. RENÉE MICHEL, a fifty-four-year-old concierge, is a cultivated, well-read widow who hides her cultural interests and social views from the apartment-building residents for whom she works. KAKURO OZU, a wealthy exporter of film equipment, moves into the apartment vacated by the Arthens family after Pierre’s death and changes the status quo in the building. OLYMPE SAINT-NICE, nineteen, aspires to being a veterinarian and talks to Renée at length about animals in the building. ANTOINE PALLIÈRES is the youngster who comments on Marx and whose wealthy father is in the arms industry.
Renée’s main ruse is to fool the apartment-building residents into thinking she is “a typical French concierge” (19), in fact, the novel sets out to deconstruct the very class system that Renée outwardly complies with in such minute detail. Renée is, in truth, a rare individual, as much “a permanent traitor to [her] archetype” (22) as her refined friend, the Portuguese cleaning woman, Manuela. The historical context for this novel pertains first to the class society of urban Paris, represented in the novel by the concierge and the apartment-building residents. Traditionally, and particularly in Paris, where many people live in apartment buildings, the concierge (generally male) fulfills the duties of a full-time doorman or lobby manager, a person who assists residents as they come and go, monitors their mail, takes messages, holds packages, and is entrusted to check on apartments when residents are away on vacation. The concierge historically occupied a small apartment on the ground floor, adjacent to the lobby, arranged in such a way that he could register the lobby activity and respond quickly to residents’ and visitors’ needs. With its origins in medieval times, the position of concierge developed apace with the popularity of urban apartment living. However, by the middle of the twentieth century, the position became somewhat less common. Seen as expensive and perhaps mostly unnecessary, the role of concierge was gradually replaced by that
388
The events of The Elegance of the Hedgehog take place in a Paris apartment building like the one seen here. ª Image Source/Corbis
of a doorman who worked a standard shift and lived elsewhere.
W Themes Equally interesting and central themes abound in this novel, but the title points to one that may be the most important. The difference between how a person appears and what that person is like inside is depicted in the two journal writers and in other characters as well. The most direct application of this idea occurs when Paloma responds to Kakuro Ozu’s observation that Renée “radiates intelligence” (143). Paloma says, “Madame Michel has the elegance of the hedgehog: on the outside, she’s covered in quills, a real fortress, . . . on the inside, she has the same simple refinement as the hedgehog: a deceptively indolent little creature, fiercely solitary— terribly elegant” (143). Related to the theme of appearance versus inner reality is one about what prevents people from connecting and what is required for connections to form. One of Paloma’s profound thoughts provides an explanation: TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Elegance of the Hedgehog
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Born May 26, 1969, in Casablanca, Morocco, Muriel Barbery was raised in France. She attended École Normale Supérieure de Fontenay-Saint-Cloud (1990-1994) and received her MA in 1991 and her DEA in 1994, both in philosophy, from the Sorbonne. She worked as an assistant student monitor at the Université de Bourgogne, from 1994 to 1997; as a training instructor at Lower Normandy-Saint-Lô IUFM, from 1998 to 2007; and as a teaching coordinator there from 2004 to 2007. Her first novel, Une goumadise, appeared in 2000; it was translated and published in English as Gourmet Rhapsody in 2009. Her second novel, L’Élégance du hérisson, appeared in 2006; it was published in English as The Elegance of the Hedgehog in 2008. The second work remained on the French best-seller list for more than one-hundred weeks and was translated into fourteen languages. As of 2010, Barbery lived with her husband in Japan.
In the story, the death of food critic Pierre Arthens makes it possible for Kakuro Ozu to move into the apartment building. ª Hussenot/ SoFood/Corbis
people cling to their assumptions and see others as a reflection of those assumptions. In order for people to see others for what they really are, those assumptions must be set aside. Paloma writes: “We never look beyond our assumptions and . . . we just meet ourselves. We don’t recognize each other because other people have become our permanent mirrors” (144-45). Mr. Ozu is adept at setting his assumptions aside; he sees Renée and Paloma for the intelligent people they are because he is free of preconceived beliefs about them. Other themes pertain to the nature of art and the proper use of intelligence. After seeing the Claesz still life in Kakuro’s apartment, Renée considers that excellent art is “perfection purloined from duration and its weary greed” and concludes that “art is emotion without desire” (204). She connects this concept of art to the human search for consonance amid dissonance. Like true connection that occurs when people set aside their assumptions, art delivers a universal purity that rises above particular human pretense and conflict. A related idea pertains to time, to how the present is experienced and the future conceptualized. Living fully in the present is connected to being able to appreciate its ephemeral beauty. Paloma conceptualizes this idea as she watches a rosebud fall: “Beauty consists of its own passing. . . . It’s the ephemeral configuration
of things in the moment, when you see both their beauty and their death” (272). Finally, the proper use of intelligence is in helping others. This application is fulfilled first in Paloma’s insight about healing through healing others and in the final wrenching event between Renée and the street person. What matters most is that people help one another, that they look past their assumptions and the constraints of social hierarchy to connect, assist and affirm others.
W Style Two distinct voices color the prose style of The Elegance of the Hedgehog, and to prevent readers from confusing them, they are printed in different fonts. Among its many subjects, this novel is also preoccupied with style, with language and what is conveyed by the different ways it is used, and by composition theory. Grammar is so important that the term serves as a heading for one of the novel’s five sections. In these ways, the style of the novel can arguably also be said to be its subject. The importance of understanding grammar is explained by Paloma in her journal as she describes speaking up for the first time in class, challenging her teacher’s inept response and expounding on the utility and beauty of correctly used grammar, on how grammar is a conduit of meaning, how meaning is conveyed when it is unclouded by incorrect verb tense and confused handling of other parts of speech. Paloma goes on to explain that language is misused generally in society, and regrettably, ordinary people who do not understand grammar can “get screwed . . . by the fine talkers” (57). Knowing grammar well allows people to
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
389
The Elegance of the Hedgehog
communicate effectively and appropriately; it also allows people to know when they are being manipulated or slighted. Renée expounds on the significance of elision that indicates lack of sincerity and consideration, for example, how a resident will ask her to do something, “would you,” without using the word, “please” or some other word of gratitude. She boils at the pretentious misuse of a word and spends fifteen minutes spewing over a misused comma. These irritations result from her sense that the grammatical mistakes her uppity residents make betray the thin veneer of their pretensions. But privately she waxes poetic thinking about a scene Tolstoy sets in Pokrovskoye, the point of which is the comfort in repetitive scything, which sweeps free of willful striving (123), a thought that takes her to the nature of writing itself. She likens writing her journal to being “adrift on some inner sea” for “writing has something of the art of scything about it”: “The lines gradually become their own demiurges and . . . I witness the birth on paper of sentences that have eluded my will . . . teaching me something that I neither knew nor thought I might want to know. This painless birth, like an unsolicited proof, gives me untold pleasure” (123). The action of this novel is, arguably, its style and the theory that attends it, for the action that matters most is the experience of writing and the composition that emerges from the two main characters, who are journal writers.
W Critical Reception L’élégance du hérisson was a huge popular success in France, bringing its author to global attention in a way her first novel did not. This success was considered justification enough for translating the novel into English. While some critics wondered if the English version would be as successful among readers in North America, many others thought it would be surprising if the novel was any less popular outside France than it was in France. Bruce Crumley, for example, stated that The Elegance of the Hedgehog “seems to have scored a direct hit on the global zeitgeist.” Heather Thompson explained the success, describing the book as “absurd and lyrical, cheery and bleak, contemplative and tender.” Thompson went on to highlight what she called the “key” to Barbery’s success, her “faith in human goodness. Amid ruminations about east and west, poverty and wealth, Racine and Bescherelle, phenomenology and Freudianism, it is the revelatory joy the characters afford each other—with recognition, with friendship, with love—that quietly rises to the top.” These elements in the novel, according to Thompson, made it a best seller.” But it was the work’s ruminations that made some critics find fault. For example, Caryn James found these parts impeded the plot: “Especially in the novel’s early stretch, Barbery . . . seems too clever for her own
390
good. . . . Her brief chapters, more essays than fiction, so carefully build in explanations for the literary and philosophical references that she seems to be assessing what a mass audience needs.” Thompson agreed, pointing out that Barbery has “an infectious, if occasionally unsubtle, didactic ardour.” Heather Paulson also pointed out how the plot is burdened by its philosophy: “The plot thins at moments and is supplanted with philosophical discourse on culture, the ruling class, and the injustices done to the poor, leaving the reader enlightened on Kant but disappointed with the story at hand.” Crumley conceded the point but ended positively regarding it: “Barbery demonstrates her own deep love and command of art, philosophy, and literature. Indeed, Elegance can be a bit intimidating when Renée’s philosophical references and brainier ruminations run thick. In the end, however, the novel wins over its fans with a life-affirming message, a generous portion of heart and Barbery’s frequently wicked sense of humor.” Crumley also quoted the author herself, who placed the theoretical parts in perspective: According to Crumley, Barbery stated: “For me, those factors were only anecdotal in telling the story of these two solitary women, and how they arranged their lives to give full rein to their passions.” A review in Kirkus Reviews took what others saw as drawback and celebrated it: “Barbery teaches philosophical lessons by shrewdly exposing rich secret lives hidden beneath conventional exteriors.” That reviewer’s final assessment was affirmative: “With its refined taste and political perspective, this is an elegant, light-spirited and very European adult fable.” In addition, both Terry Ann Lawler and a reviewer for Publishers Weekly praised the audio recording of the book. Lawler described the novel as “a beautiful love story that quietly takes on classism and the meaning of life.” The Publishers Weekly review of the audio recording drew special attention to the reading by Cassandra Morris as Paloma. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Barbery, Muriel. The Elegance of the Hedgehog. Trans. Alison Anderson. New York: Europa Editions, 2008. Print. “Barbery, Muriel: The Elegance of the Hedgehog.” Rev. of The Elegance of the Hedgehog, by Muriel Barbery. Kirkus Reviews 1 July 2008. Print. Crumley, Bruce. “Muriel Barbery: An Elegant Quill.” Rev. of The Elegance of the Hedgehog, by Muriel Barbery. www.time.com. Time, 27 Aug. 2008. Web. 11 Oct. 2010. Print. Rev. of The Elegance of the Hedgehog, by Muriel Barbery. Publishers Weekly 31 Aug. 2009: 52+. Print. James, Caryn. “Thinking on the Sly.” Rev. of The Elegance of the Hedgehog, by Muriel Barbery. New York Times Book Review 7 Sept. 2008: 23(L). Print. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Elegance of the Hedgehog
Lawler, Terry Ann. “Barbery, Muriel. The Elegance of the Hedgehog.” Rev. of The Elegance of the Hedgehog, by Muriel Barbery. Library Journal 15 Sept. 2009: 30. Print. Paulson, Heather. “The Elegance of the Hedgehog.” Rev. of The Elegance of the Hedgehog, by Muriel Barbery. Booklist 1 Aug. 2008: 34. Print. Thompson, Heather. “Charm and Cleverness.” Rev. of The Elegance of the Hedgehog, by Muriel Barbery. New Statesman [1996] 1 Sept. 2008: 51+. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
“Barbery, Muriel: The Elegance of the Hedgehog” Rev. of The Elegance of the Hedgehog, by Muriel Barbery. Kirkus Reviews 1 July 2008. Print. Touches upon the familial reason why Renée is so class-conscious and self-protective. Rev. of The Elegance of the Hedgehog, by Muriel Barbery. Bookmarks Nov.-Dec. 2008: 41. Print. Describes briefly Renée’s and Paloma’s interest in Japanese culture. Rev. of The Elegance of the Hedgehog, by Muriel Barbery. Publishers Weekly 19 May 2008: 30. Print. Describes the autodidact Renée and “supersmart” Paloma and alludes to how Kakuro sets about transforming them. Paulson, Heather. “The Elegance of the Hedgehog.” Rev. of The Elegance of the Hedgehog, by Muriel Barbery. Booklist 1 Aug. 2008: 34. Print. Points out how the novel works to expose the ridiculous pretensions of the wealthy Parisian apartment residents. Popowich, Sam. “Barbery, Muriel. The Elegance of the Hedgehog.” Rev. of The Elegance of the Hedgehog, by Muriel Barbery. Library Journal 15 June 2008: 53. Print. Largely negative review that faults the novel for being laden with Barbery’s particular interests.
Open Web Sources
A Muriel Barbery fan site, at http://murielbarbery.com, provides information about the author and her novels. The Web site Bookstore People, at http://www .bookstorepeople.com/2009/05/lost-in-translationii-a-conversation-with-muriel-barbery, contains notes from a May 16, 2009, interview with Muriel Barbery. For Further Reading
Barbery, Muriel. Gourmet Rhapsody. New York: Europa Editions, 2009. Print. First novel by Barbery, telling the story of the inner life and desires of Pierre Arthens, in his final days. Frank, Anne. The Diary of a Young Girl. Ed. Otto H. Frank. Trans. Susan Massotty. New York: DoubledayRandom House, 2001. Print. Claims to be the definitive edition of the famous diary by the child who perished in the Holocaust. Robinson, Marilynne. Gilead. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2004. Print. Pulitzer Prize–winning novel about Iowa small-town living told in journal written by protagonist Reverend John Ames during the last year of his life. Shields, Carol. The Stone Diaries. New York: Penguin Books, 1994. Print. Pulitzer Prize–winning novel, consisting of journal entries, letters, recipes, and newspaper articles, presented as the compiled family papers of Daisy Stone Goodwill. Verghase, Abraham. Cutting for Stone. New York: Knopf-Random House, 2009. Print. Weaves medicine into narrative of twin boys who grow up in a medical facility in Ethiopia. Melodie Monahan
Gale Resources
“Muriel Barbery.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2010. Literature Resource Center. Web. 11 Oct. 2010.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
391
The Emperor of Ocean Park By Stephen L. Carter
W Introduction The Emperor of Ocean Park is Stephen L. Carter’s first novel following seven nonfiction books on law and American society. A law professor at Yale University, Carter stirred controversy with his 1991 book, Reflections of an Affirmative Action Baby, which questions the wisdom of continuing affirmative action and prompted him to be labeled as a conservative by many within the liberal-minded factions of the African American community. The novel, more than six-hundred pages and longer than typical mystery novels, centers on the suspicious death of a disgraced, conservative, African American judge named Oliver Garland and his son Talcott’s search for the truth about his father’s past. There are a number of subplots in the book, including a scathing look at academia and the process of appointing federal judges and justices, as well as the social tensions within the African American community as more blacks move into the upper class. The intrigue begins after Oliver Garland is found dead in his office of an apparent heart attack. His daughter, Mariah, thinks that the conservative judge, who had a number of enemies, was killed. She goes to her brother Talcott for help. Initially, Talcott is not convinced, but then he is approached by Jack Ziegler at the cemetery. Ziegler, an old friend of the judge’s, caused Garland to lose a Supreme Court appointment because Ziegler, who still associated with the judge, was a known organized criminal. Ziegler asks Talcott about “the arrangements,” but Talcott has no idea what he is talking about. What “the arrangements” are soon becomes more clear when Talcott finds out that his father may have been hiding important papers that could cause a lot of trouble for rich and powerful people. While Talcott remains uncertain about the circumstances of his father’s death, Jack Ziegler’s obvious
involvement leads him to suspect there are many things in his father’s past he did not know and that he needs to find out. Part of the mystery clearly stems from papers that the judge hid and that he wants Talcott to discover using clues involving their shared knowledge of chess. Talcott is soon pursued by several parties who seem to have an interest in the papers as well. Talcott fears for his life, despite assurances from Ziegler that he and his family will not be harmed. Along the way, Talcott learns more about events that start to explain his father’s odd behavior, including Oliver Garland’s obsession with finding those responsible for his youngest daughter Abby’s death years before. Meanwhile, Talcott’s search for the truth causes him problems at work and at home. His wife, Kimmer, fears that his behavior threatens her nomination to the court of appeals, and the university’s dean pressures Talcott to stop whatever he is doing because it is causing him to miss teaching his classes, and he verbally abuses a student whose father is a key donor to the law school. The many scenes set at Talcott’s home and at the university allow Carter ample space to comment on politics within academia, the judicial nomination process, the changing status of African Americans in the United States, and the strains that families face after shocking deaths. The Emperor of Ocean Park was a Today show book club selection, a Quality Paperback Book Club main selection, and a Literary Guild/Doubleday Book Club/Mystery Guild alternate selection; it was also on the New York Times and Essence magazine best-seller lists in 2002.
W Literary and Historical Context
Written soon after the turn of the twenty-first century, The Emperor of Ocean Park is set in the period after
392 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Emperor of Ocean Park
MAJOR CHARACTERS MARIAH DENTON is Talcott’s surviving sister. Mariah married a white man and gave up a career as a promising journalist to become a housewife and mother. ABBY GARLAND was the youngest Garland sibling. Her death in a hit-and-run car accident devastates the family, especially Oliver, and sets into motion a series of other tragic events. ADDISON GARLAND is the oldest son of Oliver. Also an attorney, he has had a peripatetic career punctuated by a series of affairs. Addison is the son in whom Oliver first trusts to reveal an important clue about Abby’s death, but the information so disturbs him that he turns further away from his father. Photograph of Stephen L. Carter, author of The Emperor of Ocean Park. Ted Thai/Time Life Pictures/Getty Images
Democratic President Bill Clinton has left office and Republican George W. Bush has moved into the White House. The presence of a conservative, right-wing U.S. administration parallels a key event in the book’s backstory. During the administration of President Ronald Reagan, the novel’s Judge Oliver Garland was nominated by the president to fill an opening in the U.S. Supreme Court. This fictional story line parallels the real-life nomination of conservative African American judge Clarence Thomas by President George H. W. Bush. But, while Thomas was named to the U.S. Supreme Court, Garland is rejected. Both nominations involved scandal: Justice Thomas was accused of sexually harassing attorney Anita Hill, who worked for Thomas when they were both involved with the Department of Education; the fictional Garland is accused of associating with Jack Ziegler, a powerful man in the underworld who has been charged with numerous crimes, including murder, but who has never been found guilty. Garland and Ziegler had gone to college together and Garland had asserted, unsuccessfully, that their meeting had been merely social. Carter sets his present-day story within the privileged world of academia and the upper classes. Within this context, he explores the implications of a growing elite class of well-educated African Americans and how they fit in—or do not fit in—to a traditionally white social, legal, and political environment.
W Themes A central theme in The Emperor of Ocean Park has to do with the growing African American upper class, racial
BENTLEY GARLAND is Talcott and Kimmer’s only child. The parents fear that he shows signs of developmental problems after birth, and Kimmer is wracked with guilt as she feels responsible due to drinking alcohol during the pregnancy. KIMBERLY “KIMMER” GARLAND is Talcott’s wife. While she seems to love Talcott, she is a workaholic and Talcott suspects she is having an affair with her law firm partner. OLIVER GARLAND, called “The Judge” by his son Talcott, was highly respected as an erudite attorney and adjudicator who was originally very liberal. Profoundly affected by the death of his daughter Abby, he becomes increasingly conservative, displaying erratic behavior over time. TALCOTT “MISHA” GARLAND is the main protagonist. A noted intellectual and law professor, he is an authority on tort law. He is the middle child in the family and viewed by his brother and sister as rather humorless and dour. WALLACE WARRENTON WAINWRIGHT is a U.S. Supreme Court justice who plays a key role in the novel’s conclusion. DANA WORTH is a professor at the university and the most loyal of Talcott’s university friends. She sticks by him when the dean and other professors wonder whether he is having an emotional breakdown. REV. DR. MORRIS YOUNG helps counsel Talcott, offering him support and boosting the law professor’s faith, which becomes an important theme. JACK ZIEGLER was in the CIA but is currently involved in the criminal underworld and has been charged with numerous crimes, including murder. His friendship with former college roommate Oliver Garland costs the judge his Supreme Court appointment.
tension, and the idea of what it means to be a successful black person in America. In an article published in the Michigan Law Review, critic Frank Wu noted how the
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
393
The Emperor of Ocean Park
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Currently the William Nelson Cromwell Professor of Law at Yale University, Stephen L. Carter was born in Washington, DC, and spent his childhood in Ithaca, New York. He went to Stanford University to earn a bachelor’s degree in 1976, before attending Yale Law School. He completed his JD in 1979 and moved to Washington, D.C., where he was a law clerk for the U.S. Court of Appeals under Judge Spottswood W. Robinson III, as well as for U.S. Supreme Court Justice Thurgood Marshall. From 1981 to 1982, Carter was an associate with the law firm Shea & Gardner. Yale University hired him to the law faculty as an assistant professor in 1982; he became a full professor just three years later. The author of several nonfiction and fiction titles, Carter also writes a column for Christianity Today. Lauded as one of the “Fifty Leaders of the New Millennium” in a 1994 Time magazine list, he has been awarded honorary degrees from Bates College, the Virginia Theological Seminary, and Colgate and Notre Dame universities, as well as the Louisville-Grawemeyer Award in Religion. Carter lives with his wife and children in Cheshire, Connecticut.
protagonist, Talcott Garland, makes a reference to University of Chicago sociology scholar Robert E. Park, who wrote a famous 1956 monograph about how the “black bourgeoisie were a self-deluded class who would never be accepted as either black or bourgeoisie.” Carter’s novel comments on the idea that African Americans have made gains in advancing up Western society’s economic ladder, but certain factions feel they are simultaneously forgetting or rejecting their heritage in an effort to fit into an elite class dominated by whites. This theme remains in the background for the entire novel. Wu notes that “ostensibly, his [Carter’s] book is a mystery-thriller, replete with false leads, false endings, and true surprises. Within that structure, it is also a study of the black bourgeoisie, a nation within a nation, as real as it is imagined, who are as black as they are bourgeoisie”. Many events and circumstances in the novel portray a grim view of the state of the modern world. Talcott, in his search to find out what happened to his father, is repeatedly disappointed by where his search leads him. Along the way, he discovers plagiarism at the academic level, judicial corruption, corporate influence on the legal system, students who are interested in becoming lawyers for all the wrong reasons, and a wife who is cheating on him. Among all this chaos, he begins to find some comfort in his religious faith. As Elizabeth Fox-Genovese noted: “Carter’s ubiquitous asides on the sorry state of our world jostle against his underlying faith in God’s goodness and the potential for even fallen humans to exercise free will to choose good, our capacity for
394
friendship and loyalty, and parents’ capacity to love their children”.
W Style Written in the first person from the perspective of the main protagonist, Talcott Garland, The Emperor of Ocean Park falls within the category of what author Tom Wolfe called the “literary manifesto for the new social novel”—a work that comments on the ugliest sides of humanity and society using realistic narrative, according to Wu. To comment on all the areas of society—family, academia, politics, social class—that Carter tries to cover, the storyline takes a desultory, complex path. There are numerous subplots in the novel. Some critics have commented that this makes the book overly long and difficult to follow, while others have complimented the author’s ambitious efforts. Only one literary device in the novel is a clear symbol and ongoing motif: the game of chess (Talcott is even nicknamed “Misha” in honor of Russian champion Mikhail Tal). Talcott is an expert in the game, as was his deceased father, and Judge Garland gives his son a number of clues about the mystery through chess references and his obsession with creating a chess scenario called the “Double Excelsior.” In this optional rule of play, the black and white pieces cooperate to checkmate the black king, but Talcott’s father tried to create a strategy in which the underdog black pieces actually win against white. To do so, one white pawn and one black pawn must work together to become knights and checkmate the white king. In chess, as in American society, by and large, white has the distinct advantage and creating a chess situation where black actually wins, even with the help of white pieces, is nearly impossible. Another notable feature of this debut novel is that it contains many similarities to the author’s own life and experiences. Both Stephen L. Carter and the fictional Talcott Garland become respected law professors at Ivy League schools, following brief careers with law firms; both are fascinated by the game of chess. But Carter, in a lengthy author’s note at the end of the book, emphasizes that he and Talcott are in no way the same person. Carter has kept his novel realistic, and the settings are clearly based on Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut, and other towns and cities, though the author has changed a variety of facts to better suit his story. Likewise, he has “altered the history of America’s past two decades in minor but noticeable respects” to fit the story.
W Critical Reception Because Carter is so well known as an academic and author of provocative nonfiction, The Emperor of Ocean TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Emperor of Ocean Park
Park received considerable critical attention. The author received a $4-million book contract, which caused considerable buzz among literary critics. When the novel debuted, however, many reviewers considered the book ambitious but flawed. Critics appreciated the author’s characterizations and attention to themes and issues, but several found fault with his writing style, describing the novel as the obvious work of a fiction neophyte. As David Gates noted, “Ocean Park is hung about with kick-me signs that betray the amateur. He has a repertoire of naively vivid synonyms for the simple, completely adequate ‘says’ rivaling the word hoard of the late Mildred Benson (a.k.a. Carolyn Keene). . . . He’s addicted to cheesy foreshadowing (‘Or so I foolishly imagine. But another disaster is in store’), sudden illuminations (‘the final, astonishing piece of the puzzle clicks into place’) and portentous one-line paragraphs.” Other reviewers found fault in the book’s pacing and plotting, asserting that Carter’s interest in philosophical asides and characterization came at the expense of the story. For instance, Ann Hellmuth observed that “[a]lthough the book has aspects of a thriller, the plot moves at a snail’s pace. Everything Talcott does is framed against the background of race,” adding that “Carter packs his novel with insights, seemingly throwaway paragraphs that nevertheless cause the reader to stop, think and reread.” “Suspense falls flat,” remarked Jennifer Baker, “as the author delivers description for action and philosophy rather than plot.” “The large cast of characters and the convoluted and occasionally distracting twists of plot into which they lead Misha can occasionally confuse the reader, and they figure among the few signs of Carter’s novice status as a novelist,” said Elizabeth Fox-Genovese, who continued: “But Carter weaves the tightening web of suspense and the intensifying aura of danger with sure professional skill.” A couple of critics observed that the book’s conclusion was somewhat disappointing. James Hopkin commented: “Unfortunately, the last 60 pages deteriorate into a rally of implausible events: a hurricane with a killer in the woods, a drowning, a resurrection (of a bad guy thought dead) and several shootings in the cemetery,” and a Yale Law Review contributor stated: “While Carter lays a masterly foundation over the first 500 pages, the climax is somewhat unconvincing and apt to leave the reader dissatisfied.” Despite such problems, many commentators felt that, overall, The Emperor of Ocean Park offers enough rewards to be worth the read. Brigitte Frase commented that “although The Emperor of Ocean Park gets off to a very slow start, and suffers from too many digressions, the patient reader will not regret having persevered.” Vanessa Bush countered the objections of colleagues by asserting: “An elegantly nuanced novel, with finely drawn characters, a challenging plot, and
perfect pacing,” and Gene Seymour thoroughly enjoyed the way that “Carter is very good at evoking the wonderlands of American life, whether the Vineyard, Aspen or Washington’s ‘Gold Coast’ enclave of wealthy, powerful African-Americans. He’s even better at describing the machinations and intrigue in law school faculty offices.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Baker, Jennifer. Rev. of The Emperor of Ocean Park, by Stephen L. Carter. Library Journal 127.7 (15 Apr. 2002): 123. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 23 Sept. 2010. Bush, Vanessa. Rev. of The Emperor of Ocean Park, by Stephen L. Carter. Booklist 98.15 (1 Apr. 2002): 1283. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 23 Sept. 2010. “Carter, Stephen L. (1954-).” Student Resource Center. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Student Resource Center College Edition Expanded. Web. 2 Sept. 2010. Rev. of The Emperor of Ocean Park, by Stephen L. Carter. Yale Law Review 112.5 (Mar. 2003): 1303. Print. General OneFile. Web. 23 Sept. 2010. Fox-Genovese, Elizabeth. “The Way It Was before: Stephen Carter’s First Novel Offers a Compelling Mystery.” Books & Culture 8.4 (July-Aug. 2002): 30. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 23 Sept. 2010. Frase, Brigitte. “Crime as a Vehicle for Culture.” New Leader 85.3 (May-June 2003): 45. Print. General OneFile. Web. 23 Sept. 2010. Gates, David. “Is It a Long Good Buy? Yale Professor Stephen Carter Got $4.2 Million for His Epic Novel of Suspense. The True Mystery Is Why.” Newsweek 139 (10 June 2002): 56. Print. General OneFile. Web. 23 Sept. 2010. Harris, Mark. “‘Emperor’ State: Stephen Carter’s Flawed, Fascinating First Novel Plumbs a Mystery at the Core of an Upscale Black American Family.” Entertainment Weekly 658 (14 June 2002): 90+. Print. General OneFile. Web. 23 Sept. 2010. Hellmuth, Ann. Rev. of The Emperor of Ocean Park, by Stephen L. Carter. Knight-Ridder/Tribune News Service 17 July 2002: K4504. Print. General Reference Center Gold. Web. 23 Sept. 2010. Hopkin, James. “Novel of the Week.” New Statesman 131.4590 (3 June 2002): 55. Print. General OneFile. Web. 23 Sept. 2010. Seymour, Gene. “Poisoned Ivy.” Nation 275.4 (22 July 2002): 25. Print. General OneFile. Web. 23 Sept. 2010. Wu, Frank H. Rev. of The Emperor of Ocean Park, by Stephen L. Carter. Michigan Law Review 101.6
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
395
The Emperor of Ocean Park
(May 2003): 2209+. Print. General OneFile. Web. 23 Sept. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Barsanti, Chris. Rev. of The Emperor of Ocean Park. Book (May-June 2002): 80. Print. General OneFile. Web. 23 Sept. 2010. The critic appreciates a book that explores the world of the upper-class African American while simultaneously feeling that the author lectures too much about race and academia. Bashir, Samiya A. Rev. of The Emperor of Ocean Park, by Stephen L. Carter. Black Issues Book Review 4.3 (May-June 2002): 49. Print. General OneFile. Web. 23 Sept. 2010. Bashir notes that the author touches on many issues that will appeal to a wide spectrum of readers and that the novel “Successfully liv[es] up to at least some of the hype.” Dodson, Angela. “Literary Checkmate: The Overwhelming Response to First-Time Novelist Stephen Carter Has the Publishing World Calling It the Next Bonfire of the Vanities.” Black Issues Book Review 4.3 (May-June 2002): 46. Print. General OneFile. Web. 23 Sept. 2010. A discussion of the author’s background, publishing history, the publishing deal for his first work of fiction, plot summary, and the author’s intentions for the book. Rev. of The Emperor of Ocean Park, by Stephen L. Carter. Publishers Weekly 249.16 (22 Apr. 2002): 45. Print. General OneFile. Web. 23 Sept. 2010. A summary and positive assessment of the novel. Hamilton, Kendra. “Writing for Pleasure and Profit: Law Professor Spins a Tale of Mystery, Sex and Intrigue to the Tune of a $4.2 Million Book Deal.” Black Issues in Higher Education 19.11 (18 July 2002): 30. Print. General OneFile. Web. 23 Sept. 2010. A look at Carter’s first large publishing deals in fiction and his interests in emphasizing complex characters in his novels. Monaghan, Peter. “The Novel Worlds of Stephen L. Carter.” Chronicle of Higher Education 54.44 (11 July 2008). Print. General One File. Web. 30 Aug. 2010. Monaghan talks about Carter’s standing in the academic community and his center-left views on issues like affirmative action and religion that flavor his novels. Nelson, Michael. “Stephen L. Carter: The Christian as Contrarian.” Virginia Quarterly Review 79.3 (2003): 487-97. Print. General OneFile. Web. 23 Sept. 2010. An exploration of Carter’s personal background, specifically focusing on the circumstances under which he wrote The Emperor of Ocean Park. Page, Benedicte. “The Last Judgement: This Summer’s Biggest Hype Is a Complex Legal Thriller Infused
396
with Its Author’s Christian Faith.” Bookseller 3 May 2002: 27. Print. General OneFile. Web. 23 Sept. 2010. Quotes the author’s comments about liberalism versus conservatism, marriage, and religion in his fiction. Peterson, V. R. “Pages.” People Weekly 57.22 (10 June 2002): 47+. Print. General OneFile. Web. 23 Sept. 2010. Peterson appreciates the mores expressed in Carter’s novel. “Telling a Terrific Tale; For Some, It’s Academic.” Connecticut Law Tribune (9 Sept. 2002). General OneFile. Web. 20 Aug. 2010. Comparing Carter to other lawyers-turned-novelists, the reviewer feels The Emperor of Ocean Park has some stylistic flaws but that this is countered by interesting characters and a complex plot. Gale Resources
“Carter, Stephen L.” Newsmakers 2008 Cumulation. Ed. Laura Avery. Detroit: Gale, 2009. 63-66. Print. Gale Virtual Reference Library. Web. 2 Sept. 2010. “Carter, Stephen L. 1954-.” Contemporary Authors New Revision Series. Vol. 179. Detroit: Gale, 2009. 76-83. Print. Gale Virtual Reference Library. Web. 2 Sept. 2010. “Carter, Stephen L. (1954-).” Student Resource Center. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Student Resource Center College Edition Expanded. Web. 2 Sept. 2010. Open Web Sources
Judgepedia is an online encyclopedia that explains how state and federal courts work, including the nomination process and law changes that have affected the courts. http://judgepedia.org The Oyez Project provides information on all justices who have served on the U.S. Supreme Court, as well as a virtual tour of the building and audio recordings dating back to 1955 that were recorded at the court. http://www.oyez.org Stephen L. Carter’s author home page includes a list of his fiction and nonfiction books, a blog, and information on public appearances. http://www. stephencarterbooks.com Stephen L. Carter’s home page at Yale University offers background and contact information. http://www. law.yale.edu/faculty/SCarter.htm For Further Reading
Morrison, Tony. The Bluest Eye. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 1970. Print. While having nothing to do with a murder mystery, this novel addresses a unique theme—the idea that white people are more beautiful than black people. The main character, Pecola, is a young black woman obsessed TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Emperor of Ocean Park
with the desire to have blue eyes. Both Carter and Morrison explore social concepts about whether success and beauty should be based on racial standards. Mosley, Walter. Devil in a Blue Dress. New York: Norton, 1990. Print. Mosley’s Easy Rawlins debuts here, spawning a successful series of mystery novels. Rawlins, a black World War II veteran, loses a good factory job that was putting him on the path to becoming part of the established middle class. He takes work as an investigator, which leads to his involvement in the worlds of postwar gangsters and corrupt politicians. Mosley’s Rawlins resembles Carter’s Talcott in that both are decent men struggling to maintain their values in a corrupt world. Sayers, Dorothy L. Gaudy Night. London: Gollancz, 1935. Print. A classic mystery novel set at Oxford University, Sayers’s novel also deals with social prejudices, though in this case it is about women’s roles in academia.
Thomas-Graham, Pamela. Blue Blood: An Ivy League Mystery. New York: Simon and Schuster, 1999. Print. This novel features a Yale University setting and an investigator who is an African American woman and also a Harvard University economics professor. Wolfe, Tom. The Bonfire of the Vanities. New York: Bantam Books, 1987. Print. Many of the themes of racism, social class, and greed found in Carter’s book are also examined in the Wolfe best seller, which is about a tragic car accident that kills a young black man, sending scandalous shockwaves among politicians and the Wall Street and religious elite. Adaptations
The Emperor of Ocean Park, Warner Brothers, 2010. Film. A movie adaptation starring Will Smith, directed by Carl Franklin, and with screenplay by Stephen Schiff.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Kevin Hile
397
The Emperor’s Children By Claire Messud
W Introduction
W Literary and Historical
Claire Messud’s third novel, The Emperor’s Children, received high acclaim when it was published in 2006. It is a satirical portrait of the New York literary circle and its pretensions. The main characters are three friends who meet while in college at Brown University: Danielle Minkoff and Julius Clarke, two Midwesterners who see New York City as the place to make their mark in the world; and Marina Thwaite, a native of the city who has returned to claim her supposed entitlements. Unfortunately, all three see themselves as deserving of preference and destined for greatness, even though none of them know how to achieve success. They are approaching thirty, but not maturity, and floundering in their careers. While Danielle has a job as a TV documentary producer, she cannot manage to land an impressively worthwhile project. Julius decides to trade his impoverished life as a freelance critic for a parasitical relationship with a wealthy attorney but cannot give up the excitement of occasional homosexual trysts. Marina has procrastinated for seven years over the writing of a trivial book and, after a failed romance, has moved in with her parents. Her mother is a lawyer who helps the downtrodden, and her father is the famous journalist Murray Thwaite, the emperor whom everyone else wants to emulate or destroy. Into this urban scene appears an Australian who is starting a new social criticism magazine and a nephew who worships the idea of Murray. Their entwinements with the Thwaite family and the events of September 11, 2001 raise questions about whether the tumult will break through the characters’ self-absorption. Messud’s skill with language and piercing yet compassionate insights make this novel highly readable and intriguing.
The action of The Emperor’s Children occurs between March and November 2001, mostly in New York City, at a time when people wondered what the new George W. Bush administration might bring. But certainly no one was expecting the radical changes that resulted from the attacks of September 11, 2001. The reaction among Americans was dramatic. Many who might not otherwise have done so joined the military. The Emmy Awards were postponed but eventually presented in a low-key manner. Security became a primary concern, so the Department of Homeland Security was created to coordinate and improve communications among intelligence agencies such as the Federal Bureau of Investigation, the Central Intelligence Agency, the Defense Department, and local law enforcement. Airport security was tightened with additional personnel and requirements for passengers such as having to remove shoes when going through the metal detector and carry liquids separately, among other restrictions. Transport and passport transactions were examined carefully for potential dangers from chemical weapons and saboteurs. The so-called war on terrorism began, which led to intense and controversial military action in Iraq and Afghanistan. Undoubtedly, routine life and the national consciousness were altered permanently in the United States because of the events of September 11, 2001. In the literary world of 2001, the Pulitzer Prize for commentary went to Dorothy Rabinowitz of the Wall Street Journal for her articles on American society and culture and to Gail Caldwell of the Boston Globe for her observations of contemporary life and literature. Proof, by David Auburn, won the Pulitzer and Tony for best play, while The Producers won twelve Tony awards. Furthermore, best-seller books were written by Amy Tan, Jonathan Franzen, P. D. James, Hampton Sides, and David McCullough.
Context
398 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Emperor’s Children
MAJOR CHARACTERS JULIUS CLARKE, a freelance critic, has no steady work and one aging designer suit for social-climbing events. His situation forces him into temp work and a doomed domestic relationship with a wealthy attorney. DANIELLE MINKOFF is a TV documentary maker who yearns to tackle a significant subject but has to settle for a filler piece on liposuction. She introduces Marina to her future husband and has an affair with Marina’s father. LUDOVIC SEELEY, the Australian editor of a new magazine intended to lambaste prominent cultural figures, marries Marina to gain social acceptance. He wants to be Napoleon and assumes that everybody does. ANNABEL THWAITE, Marina’s mother and Murray’s wife, is the family anchor and a lawyer who gets involved in her hardship cases. The Emperor’s Children follows three young college friends struggling to find success in the stressful New York City business world and overcome their own self-absorption. ª Randy Faris/Corbis
W Themes Anthony Powell’s Books Do Furnish a Room provides the epigraph to The Emperor’s Children and identifies a theme of the book. Personal myths, the beliefs people have about themselves, can be shaped by unrealistic expectations and social pressures; they can make it hard to adapt practically to everyday life. When these beliefs are complicated by the demands of class or family, they can be crippling. The result, in the case of the three friends in The Emperor’s Children, is a neurotic preoccupation with doing something great without the work ethic needed to realize such ambitions. Marina, Danielle, and Julius are Ivy League graduates with a sense of entitlement. When the world does not fall at their feet, they feel sorry for themselves and become confused about how to proceed. They are alarmed that they might have been wrong about their privileged status, that they may be ordinary instead of extraordinary. Coming of age is also a theme of the novel. It is a late coming of age for these friends who have spent their twenties extending their college life of parties and potential while waiting for their intellect, education, and placement in the New York City literary scene to magically produce their hoped-for results. They waste time, trying to cover up their failures; they compete with the previous generation of their ideological set. Through these characters, Messud describes satirically the snobbery of the New York City elite. They believe they are smarter and better informed than the majority, whom they look down on as the ignorant
MARINA THWAITE, beautiful, shallow, and unemployed, lives with her parents while trying to finish a trivial book on children’s clothes. She goes to work for and marries Ludovic. MURRAY THWAITE, the center of attention, is a legendary liberal social activist and cultural critic and also a hypocrite and adulterer, who is egotistical enough to think that he could write a book about how people should live. FREDERICK TUBB (aka Bootie) leaves college to educate himself and find real life at Uncle Murray’s knee. Soon disillusioned, he writes a scathing exposé about Murray. An unstable, clueless geek, Bootie is nonetheless perceptive and uncompromising.
masses. However, their ideas are not based on any deeply held beliefs about much of anything, including God’s existence. Hollowness and hypocrisy shape the unrealistic personal myths of the three friends and the emperor, Murray, and Bootie, the pretender to Murray’s throne. The title of the book refers to the outward appearance of this New York clique; the book itself reveals these individuals’ fear of being exposed.
W Style Messud’s satirical work incorporates multilayered plots with intellectual depth and psychological analysis. Satire is an aspect of tone that is sometimes comic, but more often harshly critical. In this case, it is used to ridicule a certain class. Multilayered plots are apparent in the separate presentations of the three friends’ lives, particularly the unshared parts of Julius’s situation. The novel is an intellectual and psychological study of the self-absorbed
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
399
The Emperor’s Children
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Born on October 8, 1966, in Greenwich, Connecticut, to a Canadian mother and Algerian French father, Claire Messud had an international upbringing in Australia and Canada but went to Yale University and then Cambridge University where she met her husband, the literary critic James Wood. As of 2010, the couple lived with their two children, Livia and Lucian, in the Boston area. Messud has taught at Johns Hopkins University and Warren Wilson, Amherst, and Hunter colleges. Her four books have earned her a finalist nomination for the PEN/Faulkner Award (twice), and she has received several awards, including the Encore Award, Addison Metcalf Award, and Strauss Living Award.
characters, exploring how such attitudes develop and what they produce. Messud has an ability to pack descriptions with information and to bring alive diverse settings such as an ordinary home in Watertown, a gay bar, an office, an elegant apartment, or a coffee shop, with vivid scents, sounds, tastes, and textures. Her descriptions convey the pretentiousness of her characters and their inner doubts and desires. The plot does not unfold in chronological order. Rather, Messud moves back and forth in time, not with big jumps, but just enough to give readers background from one person’s perspective and information about what was actually happening to another character in the meantime. Messud’s distinctive style has been compared to that of Henry James, Edith Wharton, and Iris Murdoch.
W Critical Reception The Emperor’s Children has often been described as a comedy of manners and Messud praised as a satirist who effectively describes modern urban society. Robin Nesbitt, writing in the Library Journal, explained that “This wonderful read is an insightful look at our time and the decisions people make.” He added that “The reader will be tugged in many directions as these characters’ lives intersect in the realms of love, family, friendship, and tragedy.” A review in Publishers Weekly declared: “Messud remains wickedly observant of pretensions– intellectual, sexual, class and gender.” Kirkus Reviews described the novel as “A stinging portrait of life among Manhattan’s junior glitterati.” Santiago Ramos surmised in Commonweal that the characters are not entirely detestable because “Messud is a subtle and compassionate satirist. Her character’s questions and doubts may once have been her own.” Messud’s fluid narrative and vibrant characters have also been praised. Carol Haggas wrote in Booklist: “Tangy
400
dialogue, provocative asides, glittering imagery, and nimble postulations build toward an electrifying and edifying conclusion.” However, not every critic was happy with the conclusion. Elizabeth Judd, writing in the Atlantic, commented: “Messud misguidedly concludes with the obligatory 9/11 denouement, which compels her Manhattanites to shelve their vainglorious projects and engage in collective hand-wringing.” Paul J. Griffiths, in Commonweal, also detected a soap-opera sentiment: “none of the characters see 9/11 as anything other than a glass through which their own insecurities may be refracted and perhaps transformed; catharsis, or bathos?” Katie Roiphe, writing in Slate, agreed: “The only substantial weakness in this excellent book is the ending,” which other critics also found abrupt and hollow compared to the rest of the book. Nonetheless, The Emperor’s Children was considered generally to be wellwritten, intelligent, and entertaining. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Rev. of The Emperor’s Children, by Claire Messud. Publishers Weekly 253.19 (2006): 43. Print. “The End of Irony.” Rev. of The Emperor’s Children, by Claire Messud. New York Times Book Review 27 Aug. 2006: 1(L). Print. Griffiths, Paul J. “Unclothed but Not Redressed.” Rev. of The Emperor’s Children, by Claire Messud. Commonweal 133.19 (2006): 22+. Print. Haggas, Carol. “Messud, Claire. The Emperor’s Children.” Booklist 1 Aug. 2006: 42+. Print. Judd, Elizabeth. “New Fiction.” Rev. of The Emperor’s Children, by Claire Messud. Atlantic Sept. 2006: 120. Print. “Messud, Claire: The Emperor’s Children.” Kirkus Reviews 15 June 2006: 596. Print. Nesbitt, Robin. “Messud, Claire: The Emperor’s Children.” Library Journal 131.10 (2006): 108+. Print. “Novel: The Emperor’s Children in New York.” Rev. of The Emperor’s Children, by Claire Messud. All Things Considered. National Public Radio 29 Aug. 2006. Ramos, Santiago. “Summer Reading.” Commonweal 135.12 (2008): 22+. Print. Roiphe, Katie. “Thirtysomething.” Rev. of The Emperor’s Children, by Claire Messud. slate.com. Slate 28 Aug. 2006. Web. 7 July 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Amidon, Stephen. “All that Glitters.” Rev. of The Emperor’s Children, by Claire Messud. New Statesman 135.4812 (2006): 58. Literature Resource Center. Web. 29 June 2010. Explains that Messud TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Emperor’s Children
gives readers a closer insight into the characters than one might normally expect with a two-tiered narrative of satire and portraiture. Beck, Stefan. “Learning from Tools.” Rev. of The Emperor’s Children, by Claire Messud. New Criterion 25.1 (2006): 115+. Print. Beck discusses the accuracy of Messud’s insights into New York City literati and petty ambitions with his own apt analysis of the plot and its themes. Cooke, Rachel. “A Nest of Junior Vipers Meets Its Nemesis.” Rev. of The Emperor’s Children, by Claire Messud. Evening Standard 18 Sept. 2006: 38. Print. Praises Messud for her ability to make readers care about characters even when they are not easily liked. Eckel, Sara. “On the Media.” Rev. of The Emperor’s Children, by Claire Messud. Village Voice 51.32 (2006): 56. Print. Comments on Messud’s compassionate portrayal of despicable characters. “The Emperor’s Children.” Bookmarks Nov.-Dec. 2006: 43. Print. Includes review comments from six major newspapers and a short critical summary. Iannone, Carol. “Entitlement Crisis.” Rev. of The Emperor’s Children, by Claire Messud. Commentary 123.2 (2007): 70+. Print. Includes short background on Messud and calls the novel’s ending a copout. Jackson, Lorne. “Showbiz: Worthy Newcomer Stakes Claim in the Twin Towers Aisle.” Rev. of The Emperor’s Children, by Claire Messud. Sunday Mercury 6 May 2007: 2. Print. Concludes that Messud sharply delineates her characters and makes them sympathetic. Klinghoffer, David. “Before the Fall.” Rev. of The Emperor’s Children, by Claire Messud. National Review 58.23 (2006): 49+. Print. Comments on the self-involvement of the characters, the accuracy of the sense of entitlement of Brown graduates, and the quality of the writing. Steinberg, Sybil. “Discerning Displacement: A Sense of Dislocation and Exile Is Central to Claire Messud’s Fiction; Most of Her Characters Are Emotionally and Culturally Alienated.” Rev. of The Emperor’s Children, by Claire Messud. Publishers Weekly 253.31 (2006): 25. Print. Identifies ties between Messud’s life and that of her characters. Gale Resources
“Claire Messud.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Literature Resource Center. Web. 29 June 2010. Open Web Sources
The New York Times Topics Section online has a selection on Messud that lists commentary and archival articles published in the Times as well as a
navigator list of resources about Messud from elsewhere on the Web. http://topics.nytimes.com/ topics/reference/timestopics/people/m/claire_ messud/index.html Messud, as guest fiction editor, wrote an article titled “Writers, Plain and Simple” that asks why women authors are so seldom award winners. It can be found in Guernica, an online magazine of art and politics, at http://www.guernicamag.com/features/1528/ seven_remarkable_women_claire On September 13, 2006, Messud was interviewed by Madeleine Brand about The Emperor’s Children for the National Public Radio program Day to Day. “Sept. 11 Plays a Role in Coming-of-Age Novel” can be heard at http://www.npr.org/templates/story/ story.php?story Id=6067982 On August 27, 2007, the National Public Radio program All Things Considered aired an interview with Messud about books she recommends; this interview, conducted by Melissa Block, can be heard at http:// www.npr.org/templates/sotry/story.php? storyId=12871742 Alfred A. Knopf/Vintage Books maintains a Facebook page for Claire Messud, which provides updates on book tours, reviews, and news, at www.facebook. com/clairemessud. A list of and links to reviews relevant to The Emperor’s Children can be found at www.metacritic.com/ books/authors/messudclaire/emperorschildren. A review of The Emperor’s Children, by Cannonball Read/Dene, and comments from readers can be accessed at http://www.pajiba.com/book_reviews/ the-emperors-children-by-claire-messud.php Tulane University’s Newcomb College Center for Research on Women sponsored Messud as its twentyfourth Zale writer-in-residence; details as well as a biography and a few links to resources on Messud can be found at http://tulane.edu/nccrow/programs/ messud.cfm For Further Reading
James, Henry. The Ambassadors. New York: Oxford UP, 2009. Print. Similar to Messud’s novel stylistically, and follows an American who is seduced by Parisian life in the nineteenth century. McCarthy, Mary. The Group. New York: Mariner Books, 1991. Print. Follows eight Vassar graduates from 1933-1940 with critical descriptions of their society as they try to lead emancipated, meaningful lives. Murdoch, Iris. Under the Net. New York: Penguin Books, 1977. Print. Similar in style to The Emperor’s Children, Under the Net follows complicated romantic attractions and work relationships among a set of young writers.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
401
The Emperor’s Children
Nemirovsky, Irene. David Golder, the Ball, Snow in Autumn, The Courilof Affair. New York: Everyman’s Library, 2008. Print. With introduction by Messud, novellas by a Russian refugee who lived in France in the 1920s and 1930s. O’Neill, Joseph. Netherland. New York: Vintage, 2008. Print. Novel about the effects of 9/11 on the lives of a Dutch-born equities analyst, his wife, his gangster friend; and New York City.
Square Press, 2002. Print. Collection of eyewitness accounts of events of 9/11 and their aftermath by journalists and ordinary citizens to the online magazine Salon.com. Wharton, Edith. The House of Mirth. New York: Library of America, 2009. Print. Similar to Messud stylistically, focusing on the pressures of maintaining status in New York society during the Gilded Age. Lois Kerschen
Editors of Salon.com. Afterwords: Stories and Reports from 9/11 and Beyond. New York: Washington
402
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Empire Falls By Richard Russo
W Introduction Richard Russo’s Empire Falls tells the story of Miles Roby, the forty-two-year-old soon-to-be-divorced proprietor of the Empire Grill, a diner in the working-class town of Empire Falls, Maine. The diner, and practically everything else in Empire Falls, is owned by Francine Whiting, matriarch of the Whiting dynasty. The Whitings once employed most of Empire Falls in their textile mill and shirt factory, which were shut down years earlier. The beleaguered citizens of Empire Falls continue to hope that by some miracle, the mill and factory will reopen and the town will be prosperous once again. Miles’s wife Janine is leaving him for Walt Comeau, the cocky and somewhat dim owner of the fitness club where Janine teaches aerobics. Their sensitive teenage daughter Tick lives with Janine but prefers Miles and helps him out by busing tables at the Grill. Tick befriends John Voss, who is bullied by her ex-boyfriend Zack. Through Miles’s flashbacks, the reader learns that Miles’s late mother Grace once had an affair with a man named Charlie Mayne whom she met during a vacation on Martha’s Vineyard. Miles had never seen her so happy. But upon returning to Empire Falls, Grace was stuck with Max Roby, Miles’s ne’er-do-well father, such that Grace was forced to support the family by working at the shirt factory. After the affair, she began working for Francine Whiting, taking care of her disabled daughter Cindy. When Miles was in college, his mother was diagnosed with cancer, and Mrs. Whiting offered Miles the job at the Empire Grill, so that he could be closer to Grace. Miles dropped out of school to run the Grill. Francine promised Miles that when she died, the Grill would go to him. But Francine Whiting is still very much alive and something of a mystery to Miles. Even though she is the
owner of the Grill, she does not seem pleased when business begins picking up. Only later, when the true identity of Charlie Mayne is revealed, does Miles realize Francine’s motive in employing him and his mother for all these years. This revelation, and a tragic event at Tick’s school, finally prompt Miles out of his passivity and force him to make a change in his life.
W Literary and Historical Context
The main action of Empire Falls appears to take place in the late 1990s or early 2000s (the period in which the book was written) though no actual time is specified. The late 1990s saw an epidemic of school violence, beginning with the 1997 shooting that killed three and injured five at a high school in West Paducah, Kentucky. Just a few months later, in March 1998, two boys, aged eleven and thirteen, shot and killed four students and a teacher at a middle school in Jonesboro, Arkansas. Then in 1999, two teenagers at Columbine High School in Littleton, Colorado, killed fifteen (including themselves) and wounded twenty-three others in the worst school shooting in the U.S. to that date. In the 1990s, a real crisis in the U.S. textile industry occurred. An increase in Asian imports beginning in 1997 cut severely into U.S. profits. Between 1997 and 2002, some 240 U.S. textile mills shut down. Unfortunately for Grace Roby, in the 1960s, divorce was still considered scandalous, and for a devout Catholic like Grace, it was unthinkable. The no-fault divorce laws of the 1970s made getting a divorce easier and reduced the stigma attached to it, but the Catholic Church maintained its position that marriage is indissoluble (annulments were possible, but difficult to obtain). Father Tom voices the attitude of Grace’s time toward divorce and adultery. When Grace confesses her sins to
403 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Empire Falls
MAJOR CHARACTERS WALT COMEAU is the cocky, cheerful blowhard and fitness club owner known as “The Silver Fox,” who had an affair with Miles’s wife Janine. CHARLENE GARDINER is the well-endowed, wisecracking Empire Grill waitress for whom Miles has pined since high school. JIMMY MINTY is the Empire Falls policeman Miles has known and disliked since childhood. ZACK MINTY is the cruel, volatile, yet popular ex-boyfriend of Miles’s daughter Tick. DAVID ROBY, Miles’s younger brother, works at the Empire Grill. He used to have a drinking problem, until he nearly died in an auto accident. GRACE ROBY is Miles’s late mother, a beautiful woman who died of cancer when Miles was in college. JANINE ROBY is Miles’s soon-to-be-ex-wife, who is on a mission to make up for all the sex she missed in her marriage to Miles by marrying Walt Comeau. MAX ROBY is Miles’s derelict father, a lazy, inept housepainter who takes advantage of Miles and David. MILES ROBY, the protagonist, possibly the nicest man in Empire Falls, feels trapped in his present life at the Empire Grill. CHRISTINA “TICK” ROBY is Miles’s sensitive, rail-thin daughter, who is struggling beneath the emotional burden of her parents’ divorce. JOHN VOSS is an unnaturally quiet, ragged boy at Tick’s school, bullied by Zack Minty. HORACE WEYMOUTH is a regular at the Grill and a reporter for the Empire Gazette. CHARLES BEAUMONT WHITING is Francine Whiting’s deceased husband and the last male of the Whiting dynasty. CINDY WHITING is Francine Whiting’s disabled daughter, who pines for Miles. FRANCINE WHITING is the matriarch of the Whitings and owner of the Empire Grill.
Father Tom, he is without compassion. Young Father Mark expresses a more modern, compassionate attitude, though he is censured for it by the diocese.
W Themes One of the key themes in Empire Falls is repression and its consequences. In the cases of Miles Roby and John Voss, repression leads to violence. Miles, driven by his
404
Empire Falls is set in the fictional town of Empire Falls, Maine, a community that is still struggling years after the closure of a large textile mill. Bob Orsillo/Shutterstock.com
decent nature and Catholic upbringing, gives everyone but himself the benefit of the doubt. He allows the man who had an affair with his wife to eat regularly at his diner and live in his former house; he lets Janine have nearly everything in the divorce settlement; he kowtows to Francine Whiting while she imperiously criticizes his motives and behavior. John Voss’s repressed anger and grief are so extreme that he rarely even speaks. Like Miles, who is afraid of what he will do if he ever openly admits how much he despises Walt, John Voss has too much rage to express it safely, so instead he becomes numb and emotionless. The consequence of this repression for both men is violence. Miles, finally pushed too far, breaks Walt Comeau’s arm while arm wrestling, and then gets in a fistfight with policeman Jimmy Minty. More tragically, John Voss kills several students and teachers at Tick’s high school. A related theme is guilt, Miles’s constant companion. Instead of being angry with Janine for having an affair, Miles feels guilty for not having been a better husband. He feels guilty about having never finished his college education, as his mother wanted, and it was guilt that prompted him to drop out of college to be with her. When forced to choose between his own desires and his guilt, guilt wins every time, and Miles represses his desires. Likewise, the guilt Miles’s mother feels over her affair keeps her working for Francine Whiting and married to Max Roby for the rest of her life. Though Miles chuckles at how Empire Falls looks to its past in the hope that it will somehow return, Miles’s present is crippled by his past as well. The memory of his mother, and her disappointment in him, as well as his memory of her brief moments of happiness with Charlie Mayne, color his whole outlook on life. He has learned to fear heights—emotional as well as physical—reaching the TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Empire Falls
conclusion that it was his mother’s peak experience on Martha’s Vineyard that caused all her future suffering.
W Style Two hallmarks of Russo’s style are his rich, compassionate characterization and his humor. Empire Falls is written in omniscient point of view, allowing the reader to learn the inner thoughts and feelings of even relatively minor characters. Russo gives understandable motives to even the most annoying or hateful characters; he shows the reader why these characters are the way they are. The reader does not learn, however, the inner thoughts of Francine Whiting or John Voss; knowing their thoughts would reveal key plot developments that Russo wishes to keep hidden. The bleak setting and events of the novel are lightened by Russo’s abundant humor. Some characters, such as Miles’s completely tactless father Max, provide humor every time they appear. Walt Comeau’s brainless boasting and Horace Weymouth’s dry wit give humor to the scenes at the Grill. Likewise, Russo’s narration is often spiced with wry observations on human nature. Russo uses flashbacks, entire chapters written in italics, to tell the story of Miles’s boyhood and his mother’s affair. These chapters are interspersed with the present-day action and gradually unravel the mystery of Grace’s affair and Francine Whiting’s vendetta against her and Miles. A prologue and epilogue, also in italics, frame the novel with the story of C. B. Whiting, Francine’s husband, who committed suicide in front of his wife and daughter.
W Critical Reception Empire Falls was largely well received when it was released in 2001; Russo was awarded the Pulitzer Prize for the novel in 2002. The panoramic scope of Empire Falls, with its large cast of characters and use of both past and present narratives, make it a more ambitious novel than any Russo had written before. Some critics, in fact, felt Russo had taken on too much; James Marcus of the Atlantic Monthly described the book as “overstuffed,” and Rita D. Jacobs of World Literature Today claimed that it “goes on for too long.” Others, however, felt that Russo handled the larger canvas of Empire Falls successfully. Bruce Fretts of Entertainment Weekly called it “dense in the best sense of the word.” Many critics praised Russo’s empathy for his characters. A. O. Scott, in the New York Times, for instance, claimed that Russo displayed “humane sympathy for weakness and self-deception—a sympathy extended even to the manipulative Mrs. Whiting.” Maria Russo of Salon agreed, noting that Russo wrote the novel
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Born James Richard Russo in Johnstown, New York, on July 15, 1949, Richard Russo spent his childhood in Gloversville, New York, a once-prosperous small town similar to those he later portrayed in his novels. Russo taught at several universities while writing his early novels, Mohawk (1986), The Risk Pool (1988), and Nobody’s Fool (1993). Nobody’s Fool was the first of his novels to be made into a movie, starring Paul Newman, who admired Russo’s work. After writing Straight Man (1997), a satire of academia, Russo left teaching to write full time. Empire Falls (2001) was his next novel. Following the Pulitzer Prize for Empire Falls, Russo published a collection of short stories, The Whore’s Child (2002). His next novel, Bridge of Sighs, was released in 2007, followed by the lighter novel That Old Cape Magic (2009). He has also written several screenplays, including the script for the HBO miniseries production of Empire Falls. As of 2010, Russo lived in Camden, Maine, with his wife Barbara.
“without sentimentality or nostalgia, just compassion for his characters’ foibles.” Russo’s trademark sense of humor, often praised in works such as Straight Man (1997), was a favorite aspect of Empire Falls for many reviewers. Ron Charles of the Christian Science Monitor admired the “devastating (and devastatingly funny) descriptions of small-minded people.” Fretts wrote that Russo’s “one-liners can make you laugh out loud.” Critics were divided, however, over the ending of the novel. Jacobs felt the school violence seemed incongruous with the rest of the story; she wrote, “when the surprises come at the end, they feel abrupt and forced.” Scott, however, disagreed with this assessment. He claimed that these surprises, though shocking at first, “seem, in retrospect, like inevitabilities.” Overall, Russo’s novel was well liked and, while not groundbreaking or avant-garde, was considered a finely crafted story filled with memorable characters. As Tom Bissell wrote in Esquire, “There are bound to be other, flashier novels published this year, but very few will find such a deep, permanent place in one’s heart.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
American Textile Manufacturers Institute. “The Current State of U.S. Manufacturing and the Impact of the Manufacturing Recession.” Statement to U.S. Senate Committee on Commerce, Science and Technology, 21 June 2001: 1. Print. Bissell, Tom. Rev. of Empire Falls, by Richard Russo. Esquire June 2001: 42. Print.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
405
Empire Falls
Charles, Ron. “Grease Spots on the American Dream.” Rev. of Empire Falls, by Richard Russo. Christian Science Monitor 10 May 2001: Features 18. Print. Fretts, Bruce. “Maine Attraction: Richard Russo’s Empire Falls Draws Readers into the Tangled Lives of Smalltown New Englanders.” Rev. of Empire Falls, by Richard Russo. Entertainment Weekly 18 May 2001: 72-73. Print. Jacobs, Rita D. Rev. of Empire Falls, by Richard Russo. World Literature Today 76 (2002): 153. Print. Marcus, James. Rev. of Empire Falls, by Richard Russo. Atlantic Monthly June 2001: 104. Print. Russo, Maria. Rev. of Empire Falls, by Richard Russo. salon.com. Salon 21 May 2001. Web. 27 Aug. 2010. Russo, Richard. Empire Falls. New York: Vintage Contemporaries, 2002. Print. Scott, A. O. “Townies.” Rev. of Empire Falls, by Richard Russo. New York Times Book Review 24 June 2001: 8. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
scope of Russo’s novel and examines his handling of the father-daughter relationship. Gale Resources
“Richard Russo.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Open Web Sources
Random House’s Web site features profiles of its authors; the section on Russo, found at http://www. randomhouse.com/knopf/authors/russo, includes summaries of his works, an interview, and photos of Maine sites that Russo had in mind while writing Empire Falls. For Further Reading
Anderson, Sherwood. Winesburg, Ohio. New York: Oxford UP, 2008. Print. Chronicles small-town life in this classic 1919 collection of short stories. Gutman, Richard J. S. American Diner, Then and Now. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins UP, 2000. Print. A history of the American diner, from horse-drawn lunch carts to the classic stainless steel diner, including photos.
Broun, Bill. “Down Home Folk.” Rev. of Empire Falls, by Richard Russo. Times Literary Supplement 5127 (2001): 22. Print. A lukewarm review of Empire Falls, citing sentimentality and imprecise language as its faults.
Moran, William. The Belles of New England: The Women of the Textile Mills and the Families Whose Wealth The Wove. New York: Thomas Dunne-St. Martin’s Press, 2002. Print. Includes such topics as New York industrialists moving into New England, immigration and ethnicity of workers, and protests.
Cryer, Dan. “Through the Mill.” Washington Post Book World 31.21 (2001): 7. Print. Examines Russo’s characterization of Miles Roby, comparing him to Russo’s previous protagonists.
Russo, Richard. Bridge of Sighs. New York: Knopf, 2007. Print. The story of Lou C. Lynch (nicknamed Lucy), living in Thomaston, New York, a town that has seen better days.
Epstein, Joseph. “Surfing the Novel.” Commentary 113.1 (2002): 32+. Print. Compares Empire Falls favorably to Jonathan Franzen’s The Corrections, examining the difference in attitudes and outlook in the two novels.
———. “In Defense of Omniscience.” Bringing the Devil to His Knees: The Craft of Fiction and the Writing Life. Ed. Charles Baxter and Peter Turchi. Ann Arbor: U of Michigan Press, 2001. 7-17. Print. Russo’s contribution to a collection of essays on writing, explaining the advantages of using the omniscient viewpoint.
Hower, Edward. “Small-Town Dreams: Disappointment Haunts the Characters in Richard Russo’s Depiction of Life in a Hapless Maine Backwater Town.” World and I 16.10 (2001): 243. Print. Examines the characterization of the novel, which Hower cites as its main strength. Maslin, Janet. “Books of the Times; Turning against the Tide in a Backwater.” Rev. of Empire Falls, by Richard Russo. New York Times 10 May 2001: E9. Print. Favorably compares the novel to Russo’s previous works, citing his effective use of metaphor and symbolism.
Adaptations
Empire Falls, HBO Home Video, 2007. DVD. Two-part miniseries starring Ed Harris as Miles Roby, Joanne Woodward as Francine Whiting, and Paul Newman as Max Roby. Laura Pryor
McLeese, Don. Rev. of Empire Falls, by Richard Russo. Book July 2001: 63. Print. Commends the grand
406
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
English Passengers By Matthew Kneale
W Introduction Matthew Kneale’s English Passengers is a two-track novel about an expedition to discover the Garden of Eden in Tasmania and the demise of the Aborigines there in the 1800s. The expedition is headed by a minister and amateur geologist who wants to disprove the claims of Charles Darwin and others about the age of Earth. His companion is a physician who wants to study the natives to prove his theories of white racial superiority. Their captain and his crew are Manx smugglers (from the Isle of Man) who accept the passengers only as a cover for their real endeavors. Their misadventures provide a humorous contrast to their zealous passengers. Unique to this novel is its structure with twenty different narrators. Some appear only once; others many times. The result is a broad range of viewpoints that reveal the arrogant and misguided mentality of Victorian colonialists without the author having to overtly teach the history of the period. Two of the characters are based on real people: one the government agent who transferred the Aborigine population off the mainland to a separate island, and the other an Aborigine woman who led warriors against the whites while shouting obscenities in English. It took Kneale seven years of extensive historical research and skilled writing to produce this novel, which earned a nomination for the Booker Prize and for the Book Trust in 2000 and then won the Whitbread Prize, the award from the Booksellers Association of Great Britain and Ireland in 2000, and received the Prix Relay du Roman d’Evasion in 2002.
W Literary and Historical Context
Tasmanian literature originated in the early 1800s when Tasmanians produced some of the earliest books and
plays published in Australia. The history of colonization by convicted criminals, the unique flora and fauna, the breathtaking landscapes, the isolation of the continent and its proximity to Antarctica, and the destruction of the Aborigines remain common themes. Poetry has dominated over fiction, although modern novels have gained more distribution. In addition, a special Tasmanian Gothic genre has developed from its colonial history, natural beauty, and Aboriginal lore. There are two noteworthy literary publications—Island and Famous Reporter. Also, the Tasmanian government sponsors the arts by providing prizes and grants. The Tasmanian Aborigines, also called Parlevar, had possibly 15,000 members from various tribes prior to British colonization in 1803. By the 1830s, most were dead from violence and disease (usually flu, pneumonia, and tuberculosis). In 1833 George Robinson took two hundred survivors to Flinders Island, supposedly to protect them, but actually to free up the mainland. In 1847, forty-seven survivors were transferred back to the mainland at Oyster Cove. The last full-blooded Parlevar died in 1876. Scientists at the time vied for their skeletons for racial comparisons; in the early 2000s, remains were still being returned for respectful internment. With the people were lost all the indigenous languages, although some reconstructions were attempted. Children of the descendants were forcibly removed to special schools between 1900 and 1972; eventually an apology was issued by the government for these actions and monetary compensation offered to the families.
W Themes Two themes in English Passengers are readily evident: the cruelty and ignorance that led to the tragic decimation of the Tasmanian Aborigines and the stupidity of ethnocentrism, of assumptions based on religious and political arrogance. The latter, of course, contributed to the former. British colonial expansion was justified not only
407 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
English Passengers
MAJOR CHARACTERS JACK HARP, Peevay’s father and a former convict, appears as the narrator five times in early chapters. ILLIAM QUILLIAN KEWLEY is the unlucky ship captain and smuggler from the Isle of Man who is forced by circumstances to take passengers to Tasmania. PEEVAY, the product of his mother’s being raped by Jack Harp, is the narrator who describes the lives of the Aborigines as they steadily die out. THOMAS POTTER is an arrogant physician and eugenicist seeking specimens to support his theories. He resents Wilson’s leadership and repeatedly causes conflicts. TIMOTHY RENSHAW is a young botanist and ne’er-do-well sent on the expedition by his parents in the hope that the journey will improve his character. GEORGE ROBSON moves the Aborigines to a new island, but they resent his attempts to Christianize and civilize them and just keep dying. TAYALEAH is Peevay’s half-brother who is found by settlers, taken to England and educated, then returned to Tasmania where he is torn between two worlds. WALYERIC, Peevay’s mother and named Mary by the British, rejects Peevay for being half-white. She spends her life wanting to kill white people, especially Jack Harp. GEOFFREY WILSON is a righteous minister and amateur geologist who thinks the Garden of Eden was actually located in Tasmania, so he leads an expedition there in 1857.
by demands of politics and commerce, but also by the belief in the benefits of the supposedly superior British civilization and Christian religion. With firm conviction in the righteousness of their endeavors, it did not occur to the British that they were bringing diseases and dangerous convicts to prey upon unsuspecting natives. They thought, with the best of intentions, that they were bringing modern advantages and Christian principles to a people who would be grateful for the enlightenment. So, with no regard for the ancient traditions, languages, and beliefs of the natives, the British, with corrupt colonial governments and businesses mixing with do-gooders, proceeded to destroy a culture with disease, starvation, humiliation, and exploitation. These themes are represented by the various characters. Mr. Robson is one of the misguided dogooders, Jack Hart one of those who exploited the natives, Rev. Wilson one of those who become delusional in their religious fanaticism, Dr. Potter one of the racists, and Peevay one of those who suffer because of the malice
408
and colossal errors of others. These characters express the Victorian attitudes about race, phrenology, geology, and theology that grew more entrenched when challenged by such contrary visions as those suggested in Darwin’s research. What Wilson and Potter discover is that the world is not a place of absolutes, but a place where chance can determine one’s fate.
W Style Kneale employs twenty different first-person narrators to tell the story, each with a distinctive point of view that represents the attitudes, social system, and errors of British colonialism. Some of the voices are heard only once, some many times, but each provides a different perspective on the action. Kneale’s achievement in customizing each voice to fit each character is extraordinary. Although this assignment of speech characteristics might lock the frequently appearing characters into a type, the technique of periodically dropping in lesser characters keeps the narrative fresh and surprising and avoids routine in the rotation. The multiple narrators aid the movement of the action, and their placement emphasizes certain ironies. The structure of the novel incorporates two story lines: Peevay’s experiences and the expedition. These plots begin in two different time periods but eventually come together. The two stories also have different moods. Peevay’s story is always heartbreaking, but the expedition has the reader laughing at the antics and terrible luck of the Manx crew. This mix of tragedy and comedy is handled with great skill. The foibles of Captain Kewley and the misguided missions of Wilson and Potter are contrasted with an effect that lessens the tension the reader perceives as building toward a bad end. Strangely, Peevay’s mother, although an important figure, is not one of the narrators. Peevay speaks for all his people, perhaps to symbolize how alone and diminishing in numbers they are. Kneale depicts this painful lesson from history without ever coming across as didactic.
W Critical Reception English Passengers has received high praise from many reviewers. Peter Bacon stated in a Birmingham Post review: “Kneale stitches together a rich tapestry of swashbuckling adventure, social satire and serious historical/colonial critique, and manages it seamlessly.” Echoing that evaluation in a New Straits Times review, Shareem Amry declared: “English Passengers is a ripping yarn that manages to be many things at once: in some chapters, it’s a seafaring tale, in others, it’s a resurrection of a forgotten and shameful history.” Hugh MacDonald’s remarks about the novel, appearing in the Herald, also listed Kneale’s TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
English Passengers
accomplishments: “Kneale deftly handles his material, spinning a story which is in turns comic, instructive, and ultimately horrifying.” In a Birmingham Post review, Christine Barker focused on the novel as “an expose of human greed and the terrible exploitation of native races by so-called civilized aggressors” and as “a wonderful catalogue of human characteristics from the almost sublime to the absolutely abhorrent.” Similarly, Bernard D. Cooperman’s review, published in Kliatt, noted how Kneale showed “the self-delusions, greed, cruelty and stupidity through which the British justified their expansion and the accompanying extermination of the local population.” Cooperman praised Kneale’s technique of “carefully intertwined narratives . . . with plot twists and comic characterizations,” all the while juxtaposing “religious fundamentalists and Social Darwinists” and “aboriginal half-castes, imperial officials, rogue sailors, petty thieves, vicious convicts, and the occasional innocent.” Commenting on the extensive ground Kneale covers in English Passengers, John de Falbe concluded in a Spectator review that “the meticulously researched
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Matthew Kneale was born November 24, 1960, in London, England, to two famous authors—Nigel Kneale, the Manx screenwriter who wrote the Quartermass series, and children’s writer Judith Kerr. Matthew Kneale majored in modern history at Oxford University and graduated in 1982. He then taught English as a foreign language in Tokyo and in Rome, settling in Rome sometime later. He also worked as a tutor and a freelance photographer. Kneale’s first novel, Whore Banquets, was published in 1987. Like his father, Kneale won the Somerset Maugham Award for a first novel. Kneale has received awards for several other novels. In September 2000, he married Shannon Russell.
historical details and background are artfully deployed and always help to keep the novel afloat rather than threatening to sink it.” De Falbe called the novel “a tour de force of technical control and stamina.” Also controlled is
The city of Hobart is the capital of Tasmania, Australia. Tasmania is the setting of author Matthew Kneale’s English Passengers. ª 19th era/ Alamy
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
409
English Passengers
the temptation to preach, according to Frank Wilson as published in the Knight-Ridder/Tribune News Service: “What you have here is a rip-roaring tale ingeniously told in language that frequently rises to the level of poetry. Moreover, Kneale achieves a powerful moral resonance without ever once climbing onto a soapbox.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Amry, Shareem. “Sailing into Forgotten History.” Rev. of English Passengers, by Matthew Kneale. New Straits Times 8 Aug. 2001. Print. Bacon, Peter. “Faith, Fear, and Foreboding en Route to Van Diemen’s Land.” Rev. of English Passengers, by Matthew Kneale. Birmingham Post 16 June 2001. Print. Barker, Christine. “A Journey of a Lifetime into the Imagination.” Rev. of English Passengers, by Matthew Kneale. Birmingham Post 18 Mar. 2000. Print. Cooperman, Bernard D. “English Passengers.” Rev. of English Passengers, by Matthew Kneale. Kliatt 1 July 2002. Print. De Falbe, John. “Very Rum Shipmates.” Rev. of English Passengers, by Matthew Kneale. Spectator 4 Mar. 2000. Print. Kneale, Matthew. English Passengers. New York: Nan A. Talese, 2000. Print. MacDonald, Hugh. “Paperbacks.” Rev. of English Passengers, by Matthew Kneale. Herald 31 Mar. 2001. Print. Wilson, Frank. “English Passengers.” Rev. of English Passengers, by Matthew Kneale. Knight-Ridder/ Tribune News Service 13 Sept. 2000. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Cory, Charlotte. “Books: Dark Side of the Empire.” Rev. of English Passengers, by Matthew Kneale. Independent 18 Mar. 2000. Print. Introduces the plot and characters and comments on the multiple narrators and Dr. Potter’s character. Rev. of English Passengers, by Matthew Kneale. M2 Presswire 6 Apr. 2000. Print. Finds the book original and comments on the craft of the two strands of the narrative. Fearn, Nicholas. “Books: Cabin Fever, Irritating Characters Make for a Long and Frustrating Read.” Rev. of English Passengers, by Matthew Kneale. Independent 19 Mar. 2000. Print. Comments on Walyeric, the person upon whom Peevay’s mother is based, the annoying voice of Wilson, and the novel’s length. Guest, Katy. “The Modern Ventriloquist.” Independent 8 June 2007: n.p. Print. Interviews Kneale about English Passengers and discusses his career.
410
Hochschild, Adam. “The Floating Swap Meet.” Rev. of English Passengers, by Matthew Kneale. New York Times 28 May 2000. Print. Reviews the plot and characters and the two-novel nature of the book. MacDonald, Hugh. “Whitbread Prize Turn-up for Book.” Herald 24 Jan. 2001. Print. Announces Kneale’s selection for the award and comments on his achievements with English Passengers and his other works. Miller, Laura. “English Passengers by Matthew Kneale.” Rev. of English Passengers, by Matthew Kneale. salon. com. Salon.com 21 Feb. 2001. Web. 16 Oct. 2010. Finds the book highly enjoyable and comments on the characters and their messages. Sanderson, Mark. “A Smuggled Message on the Ship of Fools.” Rev. of English Passengers, by Matthew Kneale. Evening Standard 16 Oct. 2000. Print. Discusses the characters and themes and how the reading may be slowed by so many characters. Gale Resources
“Mathew Kneale.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2010. Literature Resource Center. Web. 16 Oct. 2010. Open Web Sources
FantasticFiction hosts a Web page on Kneale that contains a short biography, and lists of his works, available at www.fantasticfiction.co.uk Bookreporter.com provides a picture of and an interview with Kneale at www.bookreporter.com/authors/ au-Kneale-Matthew.asp The Compulsive Reader presents an interview about English Passenger and Kneale’s awards and parents, available at www.compulsivereader.com/html/index. php?name=News&file;=article&sid;=87 For Further Reading
Flanagan, Richard. Gould’s Book of Fish: A Novel in Twelve Fish. New York: Grove Press, 2002. Print. A magical realism novel by a notable Tasmanian author about a convict on Van Dieman’s Island in the 1830s who records events and paints pictures of fish. Grimson, John. The Isle of Man: Portrait of a Nation. London: Robert Hale, 2010. Print. Provides the history of settlement as well as information about the island’s modern government, commerce, and social developments and images of the island’s landscapes and historic areas. Kneale, Matthew. When We Were Romans. Norwell: Anchor, 2009. Print. Kneale’s teen novel about a child who moves from London to Rome where he is expected to be the adult in place of his mentally ill mother. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
English Passengers
Leigh, Julia. The Hunter. New York: Penguin, 2001. Print. Describes the search for the possibly extinct Tasmanian tiger by an unethical geneticist who hides his intentions from the locals who befriend him.
aboriginal family that disappeared and discusses the effects of aboriginal displacement on the Australian mentality.
Taylor, Rebe. Unearthed: The Aboriginal Tasmanians of Kangaroo Island. Kent Town: Wakefield Press, 2004. Print. Explores the mysterious story of a land-owning
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Lois Kerschen
411
Everyman By Philip Roth
W Introduction Philip Roth’s 2009 novel, Everyman, moves from the funeral to the life and death of its unnamed protagonist. From the eulogies at graveside, Roth moves quite seamlessly into a third-person limited omniscient point of view that sketches out the story of this man’s life, which is shaped in part by his having inherited from his father a predisposition to certain medical conditions, along with the preoccupation with sickness and mortality that those induced.
W Literary and Historical Context
Roth’s title is an allusion to the fifteenth-century morality play, The Summoning of Everyman, frequently referred to simply as Everyman. This medieval work enacts the then widely held Christian belief that the good and bad deeds in a person’s life determine whether that person’s immortal soul goes to heaven or hell in the afterlife. The work assumes that God is the ultimate judge who makes this decision. Thus, the medieval work warns mortals to consider their actions, because ultimately their souls will be rewarded or punished accordingly. By contrast, Roth’s protagonist is a Jew by birth and an unbeliever by education, a man whose horror of death is linked to his belief that a human being is only the material body, and the material body’s destiny on Earth is determined by genetics. Set primarily in New Jersey and focused on the Jewish community in Elizabeth and Newark, Roth’s novel foregrounds the large number of Jews who settled in the state and thrived in business there. While Jews began settling the East Coast of North America as early as the seventeenth century, they did so in much larger numbers in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. They fled anti-Semitism in Eastern Europe, particularly in Russia, in search of freedom and work in
the United States. Naturally, they followed relatives and friends in serial immigration patterns that caused extended families to settle in the same areas and communities to develop in which their original languages and culture were preserved. The jeweler father of Roth’s protagonist wants to build his business beyond his own Jewish community in Elizabeth, New Jersey, so he chooses to name it Everyman’s Jewelry Store and to display a Santa Claus in his window at Christmas time in order to draw Christians as customers. This strategy illustrates both the cohesiveness of the Jewish community and the necessity in the early twentieth century for small businesses to increase their customer base in order to grow. In the early 2000s, Jews in New Jersey constituted just under 6 percent of the total population, a percentage second only to New York’s 8 percent. Roth’s novel follows a life trajectory that is extended by medical advancements. His protagonist survives into his seventies because modern medicine compensates for his innate frailty. The use of antibiotics and surgery preserve him through a ruptured appendix in 1967; angioplasty and stents keep his arteries open; quintuple bypass surgery and a pacemaker keep his heart ticking; and a renal stent supports his kidneys. In 1999, a common vascular surgical procedure called carotid endarterectomy allows plaque to be scraped from his left carotid artery, and he drives himself home the following morning. In a literal sense, this man’s autobiography is identical to his medical history.
W Themes Roth’s novel, like the medieval morality play with which its shares its name, points to the subject it also shares: mortality. But unlike the morality play, Roth’s novel asserts that human beings exist only while their physical bodies live. The protagonist eschews all religious claims that life continues after death, that there is existence beyond the grave. Convinced there is not, he lives in
412 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Everyman
MAJOR CHARACTERS CECILIA is the first wife of the protagonist and mother of his sons, Lonny and Randy. HOWIE, the brother of the protagonist, is blessed with robust good health he inherited from his mother and has made millions working for Goldman Sachs. He is also fortunate in his timing, retiring in the early 1990s before the investment firm hits trouble in the early 2000s. MERETE JESPERSEN, a Copenhagen fashion model, is the third wife of the protagonist. NANCY is the devoted daughter of the protagonist. PHOEBE is the second wife of the protagonist and mother of Nancy. THE PROTAGONIST, the unnamed son of a New Jersey jeweler, succeeds in the New York advertising industry but fails in marriage and faces repeated medical crises.
Some deny their own aging and are shocked to recognize their increasing frailty. Others surrender to the battle of aging and, in the face of widowhood and physical pain, opt out with an overdose of pain medication. In all, the novel explores the fact of physical mortal existence and how the human psyche deals with it, issues that each person faces in his own way. Philip Roth, author of Everyman. Andrew Harrer/Bloomberg via Getty Images
W Style
dread of dying and faces death as annihilation. Having inherited a frail constitution like his father’s (and not the robust one of his mother and brother Howie), the protagonist from early on obsesses about physical illnesses and the constant threat of dying. Roth explores the way his protagonist’s materialistic worldview shapes his perception of aging. A related theme maps out how a person’s actions are affected by their hormones and libido. Roth’s protagonist is a womanizer, and while having three failed marriages troubles him, he persists in acting out sexually, even in his retirement community when as an elderly man he tries to pick up an attractive young jogger on the boardwalk. Though he has some compunction about his behavior and particularly the pain it causes his family members, the protagonist is driven by sexual urge. So, in other words, character is plot at the hormonal level. A third theme has to do with how facing death shapes how people act. Many people think about what they want to leave their descendants. They work hard to amass an estate, like the protagonist’s father; they write wills and amend them continuously, like the protagonist.
One striking aspect of style in Everyman is the use of the third-person limited point of view in order to individualize the protagonist and to demonstrate his universality. This man is a particular New Jersey Jew who lives from 1933 to 2005. He is a New York advertising director, who succeeds in business and who exploits his position of power in order to engage in illicit sex with his female employees. He has a specific medical history of clogged arteries and heart trouble. He regrets three failed marriages and failed relationship with his two sons. He loves his daughter. At the same time, the handling of point of view deftly works toward the opposite emphasis, portraying this man as very much like other men. This nameless protagonist is, in effect, every man. He appreciates his parents and laments their deaths, he is competitive with his sibling, and he faces his mortality and the inevitability of death. Like everyone else, he ages, becomes ill and increasingly dependent, and dies. He is one of a group in a waiting room, waiting for medical treatment, waiting for burial. On the day of his funeral, hundreds of other individuals in New Jersey are buried, too.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
413
Everyman
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Born on March 19, 1933, in Newark, New Jersey, Philip Roth attended Rutgers University and then completed his BA at Bucknell University. He received his MA from the University of Chicago in 1955 and returned to pursue a PhD in 1956. The following year, he dropped out of the program and began writing reviews for the New Republic. Roth’s 1959 collection of stories, Goodbye, Columbus, won the National Book Award for that year and was made into the iconic film by the same name. Many of his novels became best sellers, among them Portnoy’s Complaint (1969). He won the Pulitzer Prize in 1977 for American Pastoral. In 1959 Roth married novelist Margaret Martinson, but the couple divorced in 1963. In 1990 he married longtime companion English actress Claire Bloom, but they too were divorced within four years. Roth won the PEN/ Faulkner award three times, on the third occasion for Everyman.
Given the novel’s somber subject, it is surprising how much humor Roth incorporates in it. For example, as the protagonist is being pushed into surgery, his dim-witted third wife wrings her hands and calls out, “What about me?” (44). The surgeon later describes her as “an absence and not a presence” (45). After the destruction of the World Trade Center towers, the protagonist decides to leave New York: “I’ve got a deep-rooted fondness for survival,” he says. “I’m getting out of here” (66). At the retirement home on the Jersey shore, he tries to paint but soon loses enthusiasm for it. He laments to his daughter that he has had “an irreversible aesthetic vasectomy” (103). Indeed, comedy is most effective when it links the individual with the universal, and that seems to have been Roth’s goal in writing Everyman.
W Critical Reception Philip Roth’s twenty-seventh book, the novel Everyman, was generally well-received, and it won the 2007 PEN/ Faulkner award for fiction. Ihsan Taylor called it an “elegant novel,” and Gurumurthy Neelakantan described it as “a sustained meditation on mortality.” Henry Carrigan agreed, stressing as he identified its theme how much this novel is like other works by Roth: “This brilliant little morality play on the ways that our bodies dictate the paths our lives take is vintage Roth.” Several critics pointed out that Roth makes his protagonist both unique and universal. John Hiett, for example, wrote that “Roth’s achievement here is to particularize this very generic life.” Roth seems to be performing more than one trick at a time, using the morality play and arguing against it, focusing on an
414
Everyman character and defining this twentieth-century New Jersey Jew who succeeds in the New York advertising scene and fails at marriage. In his combination of traits, Laurie Hartshorn noted that the protagonist has “the right combination of pathos and bravado.” Several critics wrote about the morality play that provides Roth with a title for his novel and with which the novel is compared. For example, Neelakantan explained that Roth sustains “the ethos of the morality plays which were usually enacted in cemeteries,” by situating “large chunks of action in the cemetery.” Taking a slightly different stance, John Leonard remarked that the graveyard scenes are “all stage props in an operatic descant of despair as the flesh fails, the mind blinks out, and there’s nothing left ever to wake up to.” Comparisons to Leo Tolstoy were drawn. Leonard pointed to similarities between Roth’s novel, which begins with the protagonist’s funeral, and Tolstoy’s The Death of Ivan Ilyich, which begins with Ivan’s colleague reading the newspaper report of the protagonist’s death and funeral arrangements. “Not since the last mad days of Tolstoy,” Leonard wrote, “has a writer been so furious knowing we must die, and so visceral about it.” John Garvey also noted such connections but explained that as “creations,” the character of Everyman and the character of Ivan Ilyich do not die like real people. They live on in art as, what Garvey called, “helpful reminders.” In all, critics offered warm praise for Roth’s slim novel, impressed by the way it conflates the particular and the universal and the way it explores how one’s medical history can, as Neelakantan wrote, “make death unmitigatingly real.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Carrigan, Henry L., Jr. “Roth, Philip. Everyman.” Rev. of Everyman, by Philip Roth. Library Journal 1 Apr. 2006: 86. Print. Garvey, John. “Death Becomes Him.” Rev. of Everyman, by Philip Roth. Commonweal 133.13 (2006): 20+. Print. Hartshorn, Laurie. “Everyman.” Rev. of Everyman, by Philip Roth. Booklist 1 Nov. 2006: 72. Print. Hiett, John. “Roth, Philip. Everyman.” Rev. of the audiobook Everyman, by Philip Roth. Library Journal 1 Apr. 2007: 130. Print. Leonard, John. “New Books.” Rev. of Everyman, by Philip Roth. Harper’s Magazine May 2006: 79+. Print. Neelakantan, Gurumurthy. “Everyman.” Rev. of Everyman, by Philip Roth. Shofar 25.4 (2007): 168+. Print. Roth, Philip. Everyman. New York: Vintage, 2006. Print. Taylor, Ihsan. “Paperback Row.” Rev. of Everyman, by Philip Roth. New York Times Book Review 6 May 2007: 32(L). Print. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Everyman Additional Resources
Open Web Sources
Criticism and Reviews
Byatt, A. S. “The Dying Animal.” Rev. of Everyman, by Philip Roth. New Statesman [1996] 24 Apr. 2006: 44+. Print. Points out Roth’s use of the diamond as “imperishable,” by way of contrast to human lives. Gordimer, Nadine. “Lust and Death.” New York Times Book Review 7 May 2006: 1(L). Print. Explains how in the works of Fuentes, García Márquez, and Roth, acting out sexual urge in old age is how men oppose death. Nelson, Sara. “Everyman.” Rev. of Everyman, by Philip Roth. Publishers Weekly 20 Feb. 2006: 132. Print. Explains how the book is both universal and general and how Roth melds anger, grief, and humor. Omer-Sherman, Ranen. “Philip Roth. Everyman.” Rev. of Everyman, by Philip Roth. Philip Roth Studies 2.2 (2006): 161+. Print. Explains how the banality of death is contrasted with the individuality of the loveable protagonist. Royal, Derek Parker. “Grave Commentary: A Roundtable Discussion on Everyman.” Philip Roth Studies 3.1 (2007): 3+. Print. Presents verbatim the discussion of a group of scholars on Roth’s novel. Gale Resources
Helterman, Jeffrey. “Philip (Milton) Roth.” American Novelists since World War II: First Series. Ed. Jeffrey Helterman and Richard Layman. Detroit: Gale Research, 1978. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 2. Literature Resource Center. Web. 31 July 2010. “Philip Roth.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2010. Literature Resource Center. Web. 31 July 2010.
The Web site of the Philip Roth Society, at http:// rothsociety.org/writings.htm, provides a range of information on the author. For Further Reading
Ard, Patricia M. The Jews of New Jersey: A Pictorial History. Piscataway: Rutgers UP, 2002. Print. Through pictures, gives a sense of the Jews who lived in New Jersey from the seventeenth century to the beginning of the twentieth. Bova, Ben. Immortality: How Science Is Extending Your Life—and Changing the World. New York: Avon Books, 1998. Print. Popularizes certain scientific research in cellular life and gene therapy in order to put forward the prediction that people will live increasingly longer lives. King, Alan. Matzo Balls for Breakfast and Other Memories of Growing Up Jewish. New York: Free Press-Simon and Schuster, 2004. Print. Collected essays by famous people, many of whom are entertainers, about growing up Jewish. Roth, Philip. The Facts: A Novelist’s Autobiography. New York: Vintage-Random House, 1997. Print. An episodic, somewhat fictionalized autobiography in which the author’s alter ego plays a part in evaluating the work. ———. Patrimony: A True Story. New York: VintageRandom House, 1996. Print. Biography of the author’s father, Herman Roth. ———. The Plot against America. New York: VintageRandom House, 2004. Print. A fictionalized historical novel covering the early years of World War II, which presents the effects of Charles Lindbergh being elected president instead of Franklin Roosevelt.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Melodie Monahan
415
Everything Is Illuminated By Jonathan Safran Foer
W Introduction Jonathan Safran Foer’s debut novel, Everything Is Illuminated, begins when the hero, also named Jonathan Safran Foer, embarks on a journey to Ukraine. His goal is to find a woman who he believes helped his grandfather escape the Nazis during World War II. Accompanied by his guide and translator, Alex Perchov; Alex’s grandfather, their driver; and his grandfather’s dog, Sammy Davis Jr., Jr., they set off to find the village of Trachimbrod. The story unfolds through Alex’s description of their journey and letters he writes to Safran Foer—in what Laura Miller called “hilariously mangled English”—after its completion. A separate narrative written in the style of magical realism details the colorful history of the village of Trachimbrod, and the stories eventually converge in a shattering climax. Janet Maslin of the New York Times called Everything is Illuminated “a complex, ambitious undertaking . . . a fearless, acrobatic, ultimately haunting effort to combine inspired mischief with a grasp of the unthinkable.” The book proves “that the novel is not just alive, but still the most dangerous, exhilarating and affecting genre in literature.”
W Literary and Historical Context
According to Sam Munson, writing in Commentary, “Jonathan Safran Foer has a natural gift for choosing subjects of great import and then pitching his distinctive voice sharply enough to be heard above their historical din.” In the case of Everything Is Illuminated, that subject is the Holocaust. Foer visited Ukraine in 1997, when he was nineteen, on a quest to find a woman, perhaps named Augustine, who had apparently helped his grandfather escape from the
Nazis during World War II. Armed with only an old photograph, the author found no traces of this woman, and nothing remained of her village of Trachimbrod except a plaque (Authors and Artists for Young Adults). Foer says, “I didn’t know the trip was going to become a book. I started writing about it as nonfiction, but I became bored. What struck me most about the whole trip was that I had found nothing: not an artistic nothing, not an inspiring nothing, just the most mundane nothing, and from that I had to make something” (qtd. in Llewellyn Smith). Everything Is Illuminated has been referred to by many critics as the next Great American Jewish Novel, but Foer does not consider himself religious, and says he “surprised himself by writing about a culture he had always neglected” (qtd. in Llewellyn Smith). About writing in the Jewish tradition, the author says, “I didn’t write towards it or away from it. I just wrote what I wanted and needed to write” (qtd. in Hartog). In doing so, Foer paints “a vivid and hectic portrait of the lost world of European Jewry, whose inhabitants squabble and cheat, love and lust their way into oblivion, willfully blind to the apocalyptic fate that awaits them” (“To Hell and Back”).
W Themes Memory, one of the central themes in Foer’s Everything Is Illuminated, is described by Foer as a sixth sense. “Jews have six senses. Touch, taste, sight, smell, hearing . . . memory. . . . For Jews memory is no less primary than the prick of a pin, or its silver glimmer, or the taste of the blood it pulls from the finger. The Jew is pricked by a pin and remembers other pins. It is only by tracing the pinprick back to other pinpricks . . . that the Jew is able to know why it hurts. When a Jew encounters a pin, he asks: ‘What does it remember like?’ (199). As the novel hurtles toward its climax, and Alex’s grandfather gives his account of the Nazi invasion of his village, “memory
416 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Everything Is Illuminated
becomes the most important issue, its denial futile” (“Pain in the Ukraine”). The novel is also concerned with the ways we imagine the past, and our connection to it. Foer’s use of magical realism is “a self-conscious device for imagining the past, but one which always announces the gap between itself and the past as it was experienced” (Behlman). By “making fictions that announce their fictiveness, fictions that ultimately surround historical experience but do not present that experience directly,” the author highlights the difficulty of accessing and understanding past experiences, both personal and collective (Behlman). This is especially true when these events surround loss or trauma, and Foer demonstrates that under these circumstances “language becomes a leaky vessel for meaning” (“An Interview with Jonathan Safran Foer”). As each character seeks his own illumination, the novel explores the issues of why and how we write about memory, and how language can begin to “approach the unspeakable nature of joy or terror” (“Postmodern Proof”).
MAJOR CHARACTERS ALEX’S GRANDFATHER, also in the employ of Heritage Touring, serves as the driver for Alex and Jonathan’s journey to find the village of Trachimbrod. BROD is the baby that floats to the surface when Trachim B’s axle wagon sinks into the Brod River. JONATHAN SAFRAN FOER is the young hero of the novel, who goes to Ukraine in search of the village of Trachimbrod and a woman named Augustine who may have helped his grandfather escape the Nazis during World War II. ALEXANDER PERCHOV, employed by his father’s company, Heritage Touring, is Jonathan Safran Foer’s Ukrainian translator and guide. YANKEL D is the disgraced usurer who adopts the baby Brod, after she is mysteriously “born” from the Brod River.
W Style
Portrait of Jonathan Safran Foer, author of Everything Is Illuminated. David Levenson/Getty Images
In Foer’s highly stylized novel Everything Is Illuminated, the author uses two distinctly different voices to tell his story. The first is that of Alexander Perchov, the Ukrainian translator and guide who aids Jonathan Safran Foer on his journey. “Written in the most deliriously idiosyncratic English,” these sections portray a “thesaurus-raiding, dictionary-defying wrestle with language” (“Postmodern Proof”). Much of the novel’s humor comes from these passages, though they foreshadow the darker parts of the novel, as Alex writes in one of his letters to Jonathan, “I know that you asked me not to alter the mistakes because they sound humorous, and humorous is the only way to tell a sad story” (53). In stark contrast, Foer employs magical realism to create “the literary equivalent of a Marc Chagall shtetl painting” in his descriptions of the history of the village of Trachimbrod (“To Hell and Back”). Reviewers compare his “mastery of voice and technique” to that of Gabriel García Márquez, Jorge Luis Borges, and Franz Kafka as “one passage of bravura writing follows another” (Hitchings). This “stylistic gamble . . . allows for a simultaneous vision of possibilities,” rather than simple comedy or tragedy (“Postmodern Proof”). Safran Foer writes of the last celebration in Trachimbrod, “this was celebration, unmitigated by imminent death. This was imminent death, unmitigated by celebration” (270). In Everything Is Illuminated, the author transmits “linguistically a message that lesser writers might have conveyed editorially: the unreliability of reconstructing foreign events”; Alex’s struggle with English “represents and echoes
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
417
Everything Is Illuminated
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Jonathan Safran Foer was born in 1977 in Washington, D.C. He attended Princeton University and majored in philosophy, but a writing class taught by Joyce Carol Oates made him seriously consider pursuing a writing career. After a trip to Ukraine when he was nineteen, Foer wrote Everything Is Illuminated while still studying at Princeton. Sections of the book were published in the New Yorker in 2001, and the novel was published in 2002, garnering overwhelming critical acclaim and winning the Guardian Prize for a First Book, the National Jewish Book Award, the New York Public Library’s Young Lion Award, and the Saroyan Prize. Actor Liev Schreiber optioned the book and directed the film adaptation, which was released in 2005. Safran Foer’s second novel, Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close, was published in 2005 and has been optioned for film. Foer is also the author of the nonfiction work Eating Animals. He lives in Brooklyn with his wife, author Nicole Krauss, and their son, Sasha.
Safran Foer’s distance from the history he is trying to see” (Lawson). This technique is used to searing effect at the end of the book, when Alex’s grandfather gives his account of what happened when the Nazis reached his village. His narrative “slips into a stream of painful consciousness . . . a brutal directness that conveys the panic of a mind unable to hold in all the horror” (“Pain in the Ukraine”).
W Critical Reception Rarely do books spark the kind of polarizing reaction resulting from Foer’s debut novel, Everything Is Illuminated. Indeed, B. R. Myers noted that “the reaction to the book was more interesting than the book itself”. Marilyn H. Karfeld wrote, “He’s been called the next Philip Roth and mentioned in the same breath as Gabriel García Márquez, Franz Kafka and Jorge Luis Borges. Everything Is Illuminated is his startlingly inventive, funny, wise, and poignant first novel.” Marie Arana of the Washington Post said, “Rarely does a writer as young as Jonathan Safran Foer display such virtuosity and wisdom. His novel is madly complex, at times confusing, overlapping, unforgiving. But read it, and you’ll feel altered, chastened—seared in the fire of something new” (qtd. in Authors and Artists for Young Adults). Conversely, Melvin Jules Bukiet called it a work of “mawkish, selfindulgence,” and Harry Siegel dubbed it a mixture of “shtick and sentiment, the most self-involved work about the Holocaust since Maus, with all the gravitas of Robin Williams’ Jakob the Liar.” Critics disagree on the subject of the book’s humor, which B. R. Meyers believes “is to verbal comedy what
418
cream pies are to the visual kind. The question, then, is how so many could have found this mangled-language schtick both screamingly funny and searingly new. It isn’t as if Safran Foer handles it particularly well.” On the other hand, writer Francine Prose claims it is difficult to get through the initial chapters of the book, because “you keep laughing out loud, losing your place, starting again, then stopping because you’re tempted to call your friends and read them long sections of Jonathan Safran Foer’s assured, hilarious prose.” Prose goes on to say that “Not since Anthony Burgess’s novel A Clockwork Orange has the English language been simultaneously mauled and energized with such brilliance and such brio.” In response, the author comments that he has “never fumed over a bad review. The thing I really don’t like is reviews that say, ‘This is a nice book’” (qtd. in McDonald). “If people say I approached an inapproachable subject in an inappropriate way, or say when I tried to be moving I was just sentimental, then that to me is interesting and worth talking about” (qtd. in Llewellyn Smith). “The point of a novel,” Safran Foer goes on to say, “is not to appeal to as many people as you can, but to find readers who will say, “This is my favorite book that was ever written” (qtd. in McDonald). BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Behlman, Lee. “The Escapist: Fantasy, Folklore, and the Pleasures of the Comic Book in Recent Jewish American Holocaust Fiction.” Shofar 22.3 (2004): 56-71. Rpt. in Contemporary Literary Criticism. Ed. Jeffrey W. Hunter. Vol. 265. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Literature Resource Center. Web. 30 Aug. 2010. Bukiet, Melvin Jules. “Wonder Bread: Come with Us to a Place Called Brooklyn, Where the Stories Are HalfBaked, and Their Endings Bland and Soft.” American Scholar 76:4 (2007): 22+. Literature Resource Center. Web. 30 Aug. 2010. Foer, Jonathan Safran. Everything Is Illuminated. New York: Houghton Mifflin, 2002. Print. Hartog, Kelly. “Fame and Fatherhood.” Jerusalem Post 10 Nov. 2006. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 12 Sept. 2010. Hitchings, Henry. “Elliptical Idiolects.” Rev. of Everything Is Illuminated, by Jonathan Safran Foer. TLS Historical Archive 14 June 2002: 21. Web. 11 Sept. 2010. “An Interview with Jonathan Safran Foer.” New Zealand Herald 4 July 2005. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 12 Sept. 2010. “Jonathan Safran Foer.” Authors and Artists for Young Adults.Vol.57.CengageGale,2004. Biography TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Everything Is Illuminated
Resource Center. Farmington Hills: Gale, 2010. Web. 30 Aug. 2010. “Jonathan Safran Foer.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2010. Literature Resource Center. Web. 30 Aug. 2010. Karfeld, Marilyn H. “Everything Illuminated? Maybe Not. And That’s O.K.” Cleveland Jewish News 15 Nov. 2002. Highbeam Research. Web. 11 Sept. 2010. Lawson, Mark. “Saturday Review: Fiction: Guile by the Mile: A Sly Take on the Holocaust Pays Off.” Rev. of Everything Is Illuminated, by Jonathan Safran Foer. Guardian [London] 8 June 2002. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 12 Sept. 2010. Llewellyn Smith, Julia. “Jonathan Safran Foer is the Latest Literary Sensation to Arrive from America. But Can Such a Precocious Talent Survive the Hype? He Talks to Julia Llewellyn Smith.” Daily Telegraph [London] 31 May 2002. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 12 Sept. 2010. Maslin, Janet. “Books of the Times; Searching for Grandfather and a Mysterious Shtetl.” Rev. of Everything Is Illuminated, by Jonathan Safran Foer. New York Times 22 Apr. 2002. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 12 Sept. 2010. McDonald, Alyssa. “Jonathan Safran Foer.” New Statesman 22 Mar. 2010: 51. Literature Resource Center. Web. 30 Aug. 2010. Miller, Laura. “Everything Is Illuminated by Jonathan Safran Foer.” Rev. of Everything Is Illuminated, by Jonathan Safran Foer. Salon.com 26 Apr. 2002. Web. 11 Sept. 2010. Munson, Sam. “In the Aftermath.” Rev. of Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close, by Jonathan Safran Foer. Commentary 119.5 (2005): 80+. Literature Resource Center. Web. 30 Aug. 2010. Myers, B. R. “A Bag of Tired Tricks: Blank Pages? Photos of Mating Tortoises? The Death Throes of the Postmodern Novel.” Atlantic May 2005: 115+. Literature Resource Center. Web. 30 Aug. 2010. “Pain in the Ukraine.” Rev. of Everything Is Illuminated, by Jonathan Safran Foer. Scotsman 8 June 2002. Highbeam Research. Web. 11 Sept. 2010. “Postmodern Proof of the Novel’s Power.” Rev. of Everything Is Illuminated, by Jonathan Safran Foer. Scotland on Sunday 16 June 2002. Highbeam Research. Web. 11 Sept. 2010. Prose, Francine. “Back in the Totally Awesome U.S.S.R.: The Immigrant Hero of This Antic Novel Loves His New Country, Macerates His New Tongue, and Just Wants to Go Carnal.” Rev. of Everything Is Illuminated, by Jonathan Safran Foer. New York Times Book Review 14 Apr. 2002: 8. Literature Resource Center. Web. 30 Aug. 2010.
Siegel, Harry. “Extremely Cloying & Incredibly False.” Rev. of Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close, by Jonathan Safran Foer. NYPress.com 20 Apr. 2005. Web. 11 Sept. 2010. “To Hell and Back; New American Fiction.” Rev. of Everything Is Illuminated, by Jonathan Safran Foer. Economist, 6 July 2002. Highbeam Research. Web. 11 Sept. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Bolonik, Kera. “The Century’s First Great American Jewish Novel.” Rev. of Everything Is Illuminated, by Jonathan Safran Foer. Forward 26 Apr. 2002. Highbeam Research. Web. 11 Sept. 2010. A positive review of the book, focusing on the ways in which it both recalls the Jewish literary tradition and brings a fresh, new perspective to the American Jewish Novel. Collado-Rodriguez, Francisco. “Ethics in the Second Degree: Trauma and Dual Narratives in Jonathan Safran Foer’s Everything Is Illuminated.” Journal of Modern Literature 32.1 (2008): 54+. Literature Resource Center. Web. 30 Aug. 2010. An essay examining the ways in which myth and magical realism can be combined with traditional linear narration to offer a fresh perspective on the trauma narrative in fiction. Deb, Siddhartha. “Novel of the Week.” Rev. of Everything Is Illuminated, by Jonathan Safran Foer. New Statesman 1 July 2002: 55. Literature Resource Center. Web. 30 Aug. 2010. In this slightly mixed review, Deb focuses on the ways the postmodern devices employed in the novel sometimes interfere with its storytelling. Feuer, Menachem. “Almost Friends: Post-Holocaust Comedy, Tragedy, and Friendship in Jonathan Safran Foer’s Everything Is Illuminated.” Shofar 25.2 (2007): 24+. Literature Resource Center. Web. 30 Aug. 2010. An essay exploring the friendship that exists in the novel between Jonathan Safran Foer and his Ukrainian guide and translator, Alex Perchov. Kohn, Robert E. “Safran Foer’s Everything Is Illuminated.” Explicator 65.4 (2007): 245+. Literature Resource Center. Web. 30 Aug. 2010. Kohn details the ways in which postmodern fantasy fiction and magic realism can be employed as a valid means to balance the historical record to include “histories of the excluded, those relegated permanently to history’s dark areas.” McCulloch, Jamie. “Creating the Rogue Hero: Literary Devices in the Picaresque Novels of Martin Amis, Richard Russo, Michael Chabon, Jonathan Safran Foer, and Steve Tesich.” International Fiction Review 34.1-2 (Jan. 2007): 13-26. Rpt. in Contemporary
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
419
Everything Is Illuminated
Literary Criticism. Ed. Jeffrey W. Hunter. Vol. 265. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Literature Resource Center. Web. 30 Aug. 2010. McCulloch explores the ways in which the rogue hero is portrayed in picaresque fiction. Zabawski, James. “Everything Is Illuminated: A Bright Debut for Author.” Rev. of Everything Is Illuminated, by Jonathan Safran Foer. Capital Times 18 Apr. 2003. Highbeam Research. Web. 11 Sept. 2010. A favorable review of the novel in which Zabawski especially commends Safran Foer’s decision to insert himself into the story, and the ways in which this device enhances the meaning of the novel. Gale Resources
“Jonathan Safran Foer.” Authors and Artists for Young Adults.Vol.57.CengageGale,2004. Biography Resource Center. Farmington Hills: Gale, 2010. Web. 30 Aug. 2010. “Jonathan Safran Foer.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2010. Literature Resource Center. Web. 30 Aug. 2010. Open Web Sources
Jonathan Safran Foer’s official website at http://www. theprojectmuseum.com includes information about the author and his novels and awards. The website for the Guardian First Book Award, at http://books.guardian.co.uk/firstbook2002/ 0,,779641,00.html, includes reviews of Safran Foer’s novel, excerpts, links to two interviews with the author, and two links to audio files: one of Safran Foer’s awards acceptance speech and another of him reading a story at the ceremony. The website for the William Saroyan International Prize For Writing, at http://library.stanford.edu/saroyan/ index.html gives information about the award, past winners, judges, and an entry form. For Further Reading
Anderson, Hephzibah. “Road Fiction Takes a New Direction.” Evening Standard [London, England] 26 July 2004. Highbeam Research. Web. 11 Sept. 2010. Anderson meets with author Jonathan Safran Foer in Prague to discuss how his trip to Ukraine in 1997 inspired his novel. Bernard, Sarah. “The Natural Surrealist.” Independent on Sunday [London] 21 Apr. 2002. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 12 Sept. 2010. Bernard accompanies Safran Foer to New York’s indoor flea market in Chelsea to discuss the success of his novel, and his collection of framed blank pages from famous writers. Chabon, Michael. The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay. New York: Picador, 2000. Print. Chabon’s
420
Pulitzer Prize-winning novel, set against the backdrop of World War II, follows the lives of cousins Joe Kavalier and Sam Clay, as they launch a comic book and create the superhero character The Escapist. “Everything Is Illuminated, but the Path Isn’t Always Clear.” Washington Post 23 Sept. 2005. Highbeam Research. Web. 11 Sept. 2010. A positive review of the film adaptation of Everything Is Illuminated. “Everything Is Illuminated, Movie Analysis.” Daily Variety 6 Sept. 2005. Highbeam Research. Web. 11 Sept. 2010. A mixed review of the film adaptation of Everything Is Illuminated, focusing on the film’s transformation of a very stylized book into a straightforward, somewhat limited linear narrative. Foer, Jonathan Safran. Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close. New York: Houghton Mifflin, 2005. Print. Safran Foer’s second novel follows nine-year-old Oskar Schell, whose father was killed in the 2001 World Trade Center attack. After finding a mysterious key his father left behind, he begins his search of New York City for the matching lock. Hernandez, Nelson. “Town Lives Only in Memory; Washingtonians Share Story of a Place Lost in the Holocaust.” Washington Post 14 Apr. 2008. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 12 Sept. 2010. Avrom Bendavid-Val—whose father was from Trachimbrod, the village where Safran Foer sets his novel—hosts a reunion for the descendants of the village. Safran Foer attended the reunion in Washington, D.C. Houpt, Simon. “I Hit the Book Lottery.” Globe and Mail [Toronto] 21 Apr. 2003. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 12 Sept. 2010. Safran Foer discusses his gratitude at the warm reception he has received by the community of successful writers he admires. “Interview: Jonathan Safran Foer Discusses Writing His First Book, Everything Is Illuminated.” Weekend All Things Considered. National Public Radio (NPR) 7 Apr. 2002. Literature Resource Center. Web. 30 Aug. 2010. In his NPR interview, Foer talks about the development of his writing career, including the encouragement he received from his professor, author Joyce Carol Oates. Jones, Alison. “Light in Times of Darkness; Alison Jones Talks to Liev Schreiber about Everything Is Illuminated.” Birmingham Post [England], 28 Jan. 2006. Highbeam Research. Web. 11 Sept. 2010. Jones talks with actor and director Liev Schreiber about the connection he feels with Safran Foer’s novel, and his excitement about meeting the author and adapting the book for film. Mullan, John. “Review: Guardian Book Club: John Mullan on Everything Is Illuminated by Jonathan Safran Foer. Week Four Readers’ Responses.” Guardian 27 Mar. 2010: 6. InfoTrac Newsstand. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Everything Is Illuminated
Web. 11 Aug. 2010. Jonathan Safran Foer talks with book club members about their reaction to his novel. Schulz, Bruno. The Street of Crocodiles. New York: Penguin Books, 1977. Print. Schulz’s interlocking stories of reality and illusion defy categorization. What began as a prose experiment is now one of Schulz’s best-known works. Spiegelman, Art. Maus I: A Survivor’s Tale: My Father Bleeds History. New York: Random House, 1973. Print. A graphic novel based on Spiegelman’s interviews with his father, a Holocaust survivor. ———. Maus II: A Survivor’s Tale: And Here My Troubles Began. New York: Random House, 1986. Print. The second installment of Spiegelman’s critically acclaimed novel.
Styron, William. Sophie’s Choice. New York: Random House, 1976. Print. The story of the young Southerner Stingo, an aspiring writer who comes to Brooklyn and befriends Sophie, a Polish immigrant who survived internment at Auschwitz, and her lover, Nathan. Adaptations
Everything Is Illuminated. Dir. Liev Schreiber. Warner Independent Pictures, 2005. Film. The film adaptation of Jonathan Safran Foer’s novel, which marks Liev Schreiber’s debut as both director and screenwriter.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Bisanne Masoud
421
Twenty-First Century Novels THE FIRST DECADE
VOLUME 2 F-O
Jeffrey W. Hunter EDITOR
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Contents VOLUME 2 Volume 2 Contents by Title .................................................................................................... Entries F-O Title Index
....................................................................................................................................
.............................................................................................................................................
Author Index
...................................................................................................................................
Major Prizewinners Nationality Index
....................................................................................................................
...........................................................................................................................
vii 423 xi xvii xxiii xxv
v (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Volume 2 Contents by Title Family Matters Rohinton Mistry...........................................................
423
The Girl in the Tangerine Scarf Mohja Khaf ......................................................................
478
Far and Beyon’ Unity Dow .......................................................................
427
The Girl Who Played Go Shan Sa ..............................................................................
482
The Feast of the Goat Mario Vargas Llosa ....................................................
431
The Glass Room Simon Mawer .................................................................
487
Fleshmarket Alley Ian Rankin ........................................................................
437
Gould’s Book of Fish Richard Flanagan .........................................................
492
Fox Girl Nora Okja Keller .........................................................
442
The Great Fire Shirley Hazzard ............................................................
497
Frida’s Bed Slavenka Drakulic ........................................................
447
The Great Man Kate Christensen ..........................................................
502
Gabriel’s Story David Anthony Durham ........................................
452
Grotesque Natsuo Kirino ................................................................
507
Galileo’s Dream Kim Stanley Robinson .............................................
456
Half of a Yellow Sun Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie ..............................
511
Garden of Beasts Jeffery Deaver ................................................................
461
A Happy Marriage Rafael Yglesias ................................................................
516
The Garden of Last Days Andre Dubus III..........................................................
464
Harbor Lorraine Adams ............................................................
520
Ghosts of El Grullo Patricia Santana .............................................................
468
The Harmony Silk Factory Tash Aw .............................................................................
524
Gilead Marilynne Robinson..................................................
471
The “Harry Potter” Series J. K. Rowling..................................................................
530
Gilgamesh Joan London...................................................................
475
The Hiding Place Trezza Azzopardi ........................................................
535
vii (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Volume 2 Contents by Title
His Dark Materials Philip Pullman ...............................................................
540
Kafka on the Shore Haruki Murakami........................................................
623
Home Marilynne Robinson..................................................
545
The Keep Jennifer Egan..................................................................
628
Hominids Robert J. Sawyer ..........................................................
550
The Keepers of Truth Michael Collins .............................................................
633
The Human Stain Philip Roth .......................................................................
554
Killing Time with Strangers William S. Penn ............................................................
638
The Hummingbird’s Daughter Luis Alberto Urrea .....................................................
558
The Kite Runner Khaled Hosseini ...........................................................
642
Hunger Mohamed al-Bisatie ...................................................
562
The Known World Edward P. Jones ..........................................................
647
If I Die in Juarez Stella Pope Duarte .....................................................
566
The Lacuna Barbara Kingsolver
...................................................
653
Ilustrado Miguel Syjuco ................................................................
569
Landscape of Farewell Alex Miller ........................................................................
657
The Image, the Icon, and the Covenant Sahar Khalifeh ................................................................
573
Let the Great World Spin Colum McCann ...........................................................
661
In the Country of Men Hisham Matar ................................................................
578
Liberation Joanna Scott ....................................................................
665
Infinity in the Palm of Her Hand Gioconda Belli ...............................................................
583
Life of Pi Yann Martel .....................................................................
669
The Informers Juan Gabriel Vásquez...............................................
588
The Line of Beauty Alan Hollinghurst .......................................................
675
The Inheritance of Loss Kiran Desai .......................................................................
592
Liquidation Imre Kertész ...................................................................
680
Inkheart Trilogy Cornelia Funke .............................................................
597
The Invention of Hugo Cabret Brian Selznick ................................................................
The Little Stranger Sarah Waters ...................................................................
685
602
The Janissary Tree Jason Goodwin .............................................................
Local Brian Wood .....................................................................
689
606
A Long Long Way Sebastian Barry ..............................................................
693 697
Jimmy Corrigan: The Smartest Kid on Earth Chris Ware........................................................................
610
The Lost Dog Michelle de Kretser....................................................
Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell Susanna Clarke ..............................................................
614
Love Toni Morrison ...............................................................
701
618
Man Gone Down Michael Thomas...........................................................
705
Journey to the Stone Country Alex Miller ........................................................................
viii
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Volume 2 Contents by Title
The Manual of Detection Jedediah Berry ...............................................................
710
Nation Terry Pratchett
............................................................
785
March Geraldine Brooks .........................................................
714
Netherland Joseph O’Neill ...............................................................
789
The March E. L. Doctorow ............................................................
718
Never Let Me Go Kazuo Ishiguro .............................................................
794
The Master Colm Tóibín ...................................................................
723
The Night Watch Sarah Waters ...................................................................
799
The Maytrees Annie Dillard ..................................................................
728
No Man’s Land Duong Thu Huong ...................................................
803
Memories of My Melancholy Whores Gabriel García Márquez .........................................
733
No One Will See Me Cry Cristina Rivera-Garza ...............................................
808
Middlesex Jeffrey Eugenides .........................................................
738
The Northern Clemency Philip Hensher...............................................................
813
The Millennium Trilogy Stieg Larsson...................................................................
743
Novel about My Wife Emily Perkins..................................................................
817
Minaret Leila Aboulela ................................................................
748
Of Kids & Parents Emil Hakl ..........................................................................
821
Mister Pip Lloyd Jones ......................................................................
753
Olive Kitteridge Elizabeth Strout ...........................................................
825
Montano’s Malady Enrique Vila-Matas ....................................................
757
Omega Minor Paul Verhaeghen ..........................................................
829
Moral Hazard Kate Jennings .................................................................
761
On Beauty Zadie Smith .....................................................................
833
Mother’s Milk Edward St. Aubyn ......................................................
765
On Chesil Beach Ian McEwan ....................................................................
838
Mudbound Hillary Jordan ................................................................
769
Opportunity Charlotte Grimshaw ..................................................
842
Mystic River Dennis Lehane ..............................................................
773
Oryx and Crake Margaret Atwood ........................................................
846
The Namesake Jhumpa Lahiri ................................................................
777
Out Stealing Horses Per Petterson ..................................................................
851
The Naming of the Dead Ian Rankin ........................................................................
781
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
ix
Family Matters By Rohinton Mistry
W Introduction Rohinton Mistry’s Family Matters (2002) is the story of how a Parsi family’s tragic past impacts their daily life, amid the violence and political corruption of Bombay in the 1990s. Nariman Vakeel is a seventy-nine-year-old retired professor of literature who is struggling with Parkinson’s disease. He is cared for in the beginning by a resentful stepdaughter and stepson, who cannot forgive him for betraying and causing the death of their mother. Flashbacks reveal that in his youth Nariman was bullied by his parents into a loveless marriage with a Parsi widow, Yasmin, with two children, Coomy and Jal. He was not allowed to marry his true love, Lucy, a Goan Catholic. The marriage, however, produces a daughter, Roxana, who, along with her husband, Yezad Chenoy, and their children, Murad and Jehangir, provide the only sunshine in Nariman’s old age. Roxana’s family is eventually forced into taking Nariman into their cramped two-room apartment to give him round-theclock care as his condition worsens. The pressure forces the Chenoy family into immoral ways to get more money for survival, which involves Yezad in the dirty politics of Bombay. Nariman slips into daydreaming as his body deteriorates, and he tells the grandchildren, Murad and Jehangir, stories of his past. The sensitive Jehangir collects the fragments of family history, intent on making sense of them. It is he who finishes the family chronicle after Nariman dies, telling how Murad repeats his grandfather’s crime of wanting to go with a non-Parsi girl, thus bringing the family history full circle. Woven into the tragedies are moments of family sharing, love, coping, and the ceremonies of life and death.
W Literary and Historical Context
The novel takes place against the background of Bombay politics in the 1990s. On December 6, 1992, Hindu
militants destroyed the Babri Mosque at Ayodyha, a site sacred to the Hindu god, Rama. This act led to riots in Bombay with angry Muslims confronting Hindu activists. The violence left eight hundred dead and many homeless. This event was a shocking blow to Bombay’s reputation for multicultural tolerance. The Hindu nationalists pushed for Hindutva, the rule by the Hindu majority. In 1995 the Hindu extremist group Shiv Sena (Army of Shiva) formed a coalition government with the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). Bombay’s name was changed at this time to the Hindu version, Mumbai. The Shiv Sena was implicated in terrorist acts and in criminal underground activities such as the illegal lottery, the Matka, on which Yezad gambles the household money. The moral question the novel poses—how to behave ethically in an unethical environment—is embedded in the Parsi religion, Zoroastrianism, the minority religion of the main characters. The Parsis came to India from Iran in the tenth century BCE. Their prophet, Zarathustra, lived in the sixth century BCE and taught there are two forces in the universe, good and evil. Humans must choose the good. Parsis are required to have good thoughts, good words, and good deeds. The Parsi community in the novel worries about the social plight of its members, for they are diminishing in numbers, due to intermarriage and emigration. Parsis once had a privileged status under British rule: They spoke English, were excellent at business and cosmopolitan in taste. In the 1990s, as the novel shows, they were losing their religious and social identity.
W Themes A major concern of Family Matters is decay and corruption in the physical self, the civic realm, and characters’ ethics. Detailed descriptions are given of Nariman Vakeel’s reduced bodily functions. Corruption in politics caused by extremist groups such as the Shiv Sena destroys the safety and morale of the city.
423 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Family Matters
MAJOR CHARACTERS LUCY BRAGANZA is Nariman Vakeel’s true love forbidden to him because she is a Goan Catholic. JEHANGIR CHENOY is the grandson of Nariman Vakeel, a sensitive boy who loves his grandfather and his stories about the past. MURAD CHENOY is the rebellious older brother of Jehangir, who, like his grandfather Nariman, falls in love with a non-Parsi girl. ROXANA CHENOY is the daughter of Yasmin and Nariman, the mother of Jehangir and Murad, and the wife of Yezad. She is devoted to caring for her dying father, despite hardship. YEZAD CHENOY is the son-in-law of Nariman, who begins as liberal, balanced, and tolerant but changes into a fanatical Zoroastrian when he gets down on his luck. COOMY CONTRACTOR is the daughter of Yasmin by a previous marriage and Nariman’s bitter spinster stepdaughter, who blames Nariman for her mother’s death. JAL CONTRACTOR is the peace-making and hard-of-hearing stepson of Nariman; he is unmarried and lives with his sister Coomy. YASMIN CONTRACTOR, widowed with two children, Coomy and Jal, becomes Nariman’s wife in an arranged marriage. She is jealous of Lucy. VIKRAM KAPUR is the owner of Bombay’s Sporting Good Emporium where Yezad is employed. A liberal and generous Hindu, he is murdered by the Hindu right wing, Shiv Sena. VILAS RANE is a bookseller and Yezad’s best friend, who writes letters for illiterate people with relatives living abroad. NARIMAN VAKEEL, the protagonist, is the patriarch of the family, whose mistakes in youth still trouble the younger generations. He is a retired professor of English literature suffering from Parkinson’s disease but still sweet and humorous as he is dying.
Corruption also invades the moral fiber of otherwise decent people such as Yezad and Jehangir, who give in to baser impulses just to cope with financial need. Related to the theme of decay is a sense of loss. Nariman and Yezad long for their lost childhood and the past. The characters lose their financial security, health, loved ones, and opportunity. The past can never be recovered, although it continues to influence the present. The conflict between family duty and personal need is another important theme, evinced in Nariman’s and Murad’s forbidden love affairs. The Parsis have been a tight-knit community, with strong family ties. If Nariman
424
Rohinton Mistry holds a copy of his book, Family Matters. John Li/ Getty Images
married a Catholic the price would be cultural purity and identity. Another important thread in the novel concerns the ambiguity of moral action. The Parsi desire for purity and goodness is central to Mistry’s work. Yezad, for instance, turns to religion after losing his job and becoming disillusioned. Instead of gaining purity, he becomes fanatical and estranges his family. Good intentions can still go wrong. Family love and humane acceptance of others, however, are affirmed as stabilizing influences against uncertainty.
W Style Mistry, like Indian author Salman Rushdie, settled in the West and wrote about Bombay. Rushdie’s Midnight’s Children (1981) depicts Bombay in a postmodern fantastic style. Rushdie’s style became the standard for Indian postcolonial fiction. Postmodernism emphasizes fragmentation, discontinuity, pastiche, irony, and self-conscious narration. By contrast, Mistry’s realistic mode of depicting Bombay is similar to much nineteenth-century fiction with its straightforward TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Family Matters
storytelling and accumulation of detail about everyday life. Mistry is able to show a complex and diverse society full of contradictions, striving to remain coherent through human sympathy. Like Charles Dickens, he is able to produce individual portraits against a large social canvas The prose is polished but economical. Mistry is a master of metaphor. For instance, in Family Matters, the decay of Nariman’s body becomes a metaphor for the general corruption in society. Other metaphors come from literature, such as Nariman’s comparing his demise to that of William Shakespeare's character King Lear as he is shunted from one relative to the next the play. The novel has an omniscient narrator who quickly and deftly switches among the various perspectives of the characters. An epilogue narrated in the first person by fourteen-year-old Jehangir, Nariman’s grandson, provides a personal perspective on the family history. Although the accumulated detail is unhurried, giving the reader the impression of having lived through a whole life, the pace is somewhat nervous and jumpy, befitting the rhythm of city dwellers. Mistry is less able to draw female than male characters. In Family Matters, the focus goes from one generation to another through the male figures: from Nariman, the grandfather, to Yezad, the son-in-law, to Jehangir, the grandson. Roxanna is a strong female character, but she remains in the background. The women, Coomy, Lucy, and Yasmin, all meet tragic ends, for they are less free to shape their own lives.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Rohinton Mistry was born in Mumbai, India, on July 3, 1952, and earned a degree in mathematics and economics from Mumbai University in 1973. After moving to Canada in 1975, he worked in a bank before he returned to school at the University of Toronto to study English and philosophy. His short stories were published in the 1987 collection, Tales from Firozsha Baag. His three subsequent novels, Such a Long Journey, A Fine Balance, and Family Matters, were short-listed for the Man Booker Prize. Such a Long Journey was made into a 1998 film. As of 2010, Mistry lived near Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
considered simply one of the best writers, Indian or otherwise, now alive.” Allen did not think a comparison of Mistry with Leo Tolstoy or Dickens was exaggerated. Like those famous nineteenth-century authors, Mistry uses large metaphors to focus readers’ attention on the disintegration of family life. John Updike agreed in the New Yorker, calling Mistry’s realism Tolstoyan, with every detail illustrating “the eventually crushing weight of the world.” Updike noted that although some minor characters seem flat, the author treats his characters with compassion. He has “the patience,” Updike stated, “to tease narrative and moral interest out of domestic life.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
W Critical Reception Family Matters is Mistry’s third novel and third nomination for the Man Booker Prize. Mistry earned widespread respect from reviewers in 2002, who lauded his clear style but noted the depressing picture he paints of family life. Lee Langley, for instance, in the Spectator, claimed: “Mistry is good at families, the abrasive nature of propinquity.” Because he depicts “the minutiae of everyday suffering,” his “world is not a happy one.” Referring to its depiction of religion, John Sutherland in his New York Times review asserted that the reader needs background in the Parsi religion to understand the moral dilemmas posed by this novel. He pointed out the novel’s title seems to ask whether family in itself is significant in a modern age, concluding that the ambiguous novel does not give a clear answer. Rocio Davis, in a review in Canadian Ethnic Studies, noted that although the book affirms Parsi culture, Mistry clearly attacks fundamentalist bigotry in any religious group. Amid Mistry’s juxtaposition of opposites, such as happiness and sorrow, he shows us “moments of redemptive humanity.” Davis also thought Mistry showed skill with the minor characters. Concerning Mistry’s writing style, Brooke Allen, in the Atlantic, stated unreservedly that Mistry “ought to be
Works Cited
Allen, Brooke. “Loss and Endurance: Rohinton Mistry’s Tragic and Triumphant Vision.” Rev. of Family Matters, by Rohinton Mistry. Atlantic 290.2 (2002): 165. Print. Davis, Rocio G. “Family Matters. (Book Reviews).” Rev. of Family Matters, by Rohinton Mistry. Canadian Ethnic Studies Journal 34.1 (2002): 159. Print. Langley, Lee. “Grim Home Thoughts from Abroad.” Rev. of Family Matters, by Rohinton Mistry. Spectator 288.9060 (2002): 41. Print. Mistry, Rohinton. Family Matters. New York: Vintage, 2002. Print. Sutherland, John. “King Lear in Bombay.” Rev. of Family Matters, by Rohinton Mistry. New York Times Book Review 107.41 (2002): 7. Print. Updike, John. “Home Care.” Rev. of Family Matters, by Rohinton Mistry. New Yorker 30 Sept. 2002. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Aldama, Frederick Luis. “Review of Family Matters.” Rev. of Family Matters, by Rohinton Mistry. World
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
425
Family Matters
Literature Today 77.2 (2003): 77-78. Print. Explains how Mistry looks through the veneer of family life to find its suffering yet affirms the role of storytelling in keeping families together.
www.postcolonialweb.org/canada/literature/mistry/ takhar4.html, has a page of resources on Rohinton Mistry, includes an overview of contextual materials and themes in Mistry’s work as well as a biography.
Bhautoo-Dewnarain, Nandini. Rohinton Mistry: An Introduction. Delhi: Foundation Books, 2007. Print. Explains themes in Mistry’s work.
An interview of Mistry by Linda L. Richards from January Magazine, at http://www.januarymagazine. com/profiles/mistry.html, gives a sense of Mistry’s personality and provides background on his work.
Heinegg, Peter. “Wandering Between Two Worlds.” America 188.8 (2003): 30-32. Print. Praises scope of Family Matters with its details about the plight of the Parsis in Bombay and descriptions of individual lives. Morey, Peter. “Communalism, Corruption, and Duty in Rohinton Mistry’s Family Matters.” Alternative Indias: Writing, Nation, and Communalism. Eds. Peter Morey and Alex Tickell. Amsterdam: Rodopi, 2005. 141-60. Print. Discusses moral ambiguity in the novel, with reference to the Zoroastrian idea of goodness. Rich, Katherine Russell. “Ties that Blind.” O: The Oprah Magazine 3.10 (2002): 90. Print. Views the novel as an accurate depiction of the hypocrisy often found in family life. Tullo, Ellen. Rev. of Family Matters, by Rohinton Mistry. British Medical Journal 339.7712 (2009): 111. Print. Praises Mistry’s novel for its depiction of Parkinson’s disease. Gale Resources
Genetsch, Martin. “Rohinton Mistry.” Dictionary of Literary Biography. Volume 334: Twenty-first-Century Canadian Writers. Edited by Christian Riegel. Detroit: Gale, 2007. 187-91. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Web. 21 July 2010. http://galenet.galegroup.com/ Servelet/GLD/hits?r=d&origSearch=true Siddiqi, Yumna, “Rohinton Mistry.” British Writers: Supplement 10. Ed. Jay Parini. Detroit: Scribner’s, 2004. Scribner Writers Series. Literature Resource Center. Web. 16 July 2010.http://go.galegroup. com/ps/i.do?&id=GALE%7CH1483000035& v=2.1&u=itsbtrial&it=r&p=LitRC&sw=w Open Web Sources
For Further Reading
Clark, Peter. Zoroastrianism: An Introduction to an Ancient Faith. Brighton: Sussex Academic Press, 1998. Print. An overview of the basic beliefs of the Zoroastrians and their relevance in the late 1990s. Hansen, Thomas Blom. Wages of Violence: Naming and Identity in Postcolonial Bombay. Princeton: Princeton UP, 2001. Print. Bombay politics in the period described in Family Matters, including the Shiv Sena and the sociological changes that led to the city’s name change. Luhrmann, Tania. The Good Parsi: The Fate of a Colonial Elite in a Postcolonial Society. Cambridge: Harvard UP, 1996. Print. Describes how Parsis enjoyed an elite position under the British Raj because they adopted British ways and culture. Their domination of Bombay deteriorated with Indian independence. Mistry, Rohinton. A Fine Balance. New York: Vintage, 2001. Print. Describes Dina, a poor widow turned seamstress, who, along with three other characters, survives Indira Gandhi’s rule in the 1970s during the State of Internal Emergency. ———. Swimming Lessons and Other Stories from Firozsha Baag. New York: Vintage, 1997. Print. Eleven short stories, including the much-anthologized “Swimming Lessons.” Rushdie, Salman, and Elizabeth West, eds. Mirrorwork: 50 Years of Indian Writing 1947-1997. New York: Holt, 1997. Print. Anthology of Indian postcolonial prose in English, both fiction and nonfiction, including works by Parsi writers Bapsi Sidhwa and Rohinton Mistry.
“The Canadian Literature and Culture” section of the Postcolonial Literature and Culture Web site, at http://
426
Susan Andersen
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Far and Beyon’ By Unity Dow
W Introduction Far and Beyon’ (2000) is a novel set in the southern African country of Botswana. It tells the story of Mosa Selato, a girl whose family has lost two of its four children to AIDS. As nineteen-year-old Mosa struggles to resume her academic studies after an unplanned pregnancy and abortion, she must face the injustices of an educational system in which female students are often the victims of sexually predatory teachers. She and her younger brother, Stan, who lives with his teacher’s white family, must also navigate the cultural divide between the traditional African beliefs and values espoused by their family and the increasingly prevalent Western ideas and goods. Unity Dow, the author of Far and Beyon’, was Botswana’s first female high court judge, and her commitment to social justice pervades the work. The book has been recognized for its sensitive portrait of characters attempting to balance Western education with traditional teachings and for its strong statement about women’s rights.
W Literary and Historical Context
Far and Beyon’ is set in present-day Botswana. The country was under British control from 1885 to 1966, and English remains one of its two official languages (the other is Setswana). Greatly affected by the global AIDS pandemic, it has one of the world’s highest prevalence rates of the disease. In the novel Mosa’s two older brothers have both died of AIDS. Her mother, Mara, is unwilling to accept their diagnosis, choosing to believe that the young men were victims of a curse. In fact, the topic of AIDS is so taboo among Mosa’s family members that it is rarely referred to by name; instead, it is called “this disease,” “the radio disease,” or “the disease with a
short name.” At the end of the novel, Mosa faces her fears and has herself tested for HIV, and she and her brother Stan rejoice over the negative result. Dow’s novel also reflects Botswana’s struggle for gender equality after many years of rule by maledominated institutions. As a lawyer and judge, Dow built a reputation as a champion of women’s rights and cofounded two women’s advocacy organizations. The injustices she witnessed during her legal career inform her book. For example, when Mosa tries to help Cecilia, a family friend who is dying from complications of AIDS, she turns to the Kagiso Law Office, an association much like those run by Dow. Nevertheless, Cecilia dies soon after her case is dismissed by a sexist judge, and before long the child for whom she sought support also dies. Enraged, Mosa sends the judge a copy of her friend’s funeral program, but she knows that her small act of defiance will not bring about change.
W Themes Far and Beyon’ depicts the importance of removing the barriers to women’s education in developing countries. As the novel opens, Mosa has been on a break from school that began with an unplanned pregnancy. She desperately wants to complete her education, feeling that “school was her passport to a better life.” After convincing the school officials to allow her to return, she must deal with the lecherous Mr. Merake, who humiliates her in class after she refuses his advances. Inspired by the injustice she sees around her, Mosa recruits female classmates to describe their experiences of persecution in poems, artwork, and dance performances. They present their work at a school reception to which they have invited the country’s minister of education. The production is a success, and there is hope that conditions may finally change, allowing Mosa to go “far and beyon’.”
427 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Far and Beyon’
MAJOR CHARACTERS CECILIA is Lesedi’s daughter. Dying of AIDS, she asks Mosa to help her seek child support for the young daughter she will leave behind. LESEDI is an old friend of Mara’s. The two met during their first pregnancies and remained close as their children grew. Mara ends their friendship, convinced by diviners that Lesedi placed a jealous curse on her family, causing the deaths of her two oldest sons, Thabo and Pule. The two women are reunited by Cecilia’s illness. MR. MERAKE (OR “BONES”) is a teacher at Mosa’s school known for making sexual advances on students. Mosa exposes his wrongdoings when she invites the female minister of education to attend an awards ceremony at her school. MR. MITCHELL is the American mathematics teacher with whom Stan lives. MARA SELATO is the mother of Thabo, Pule, Mosa, and Stan. Determined to follow the traditional practices of her culture, she refuses to believe that her older sons’ deaths were the result of AIDS. Instead, she consults numerous diviners and allows them to convince her that her good friend Lesedi has cursed her family. MOSADI “MOSA” SELATO is Mara’s third child and her only daughter. Although Mosa was once a star student and the head of her school debate team, she left after becoming pregnant, and much of the novel chronicles her attempt to finish her education against overwhelming odds. STAN SELATO is Mara’s youngest child. He lives with the family of Mr. Mitchell, his white math teacher. While both he and Mosa struggle with the cultural rift between their family’s traditional African beliefs and their own exposure to Western culture and values, Stan suffers greater distress. SINAH is a classmate of Mosa’s who seeks her help when their teacher, Mr. Merake, begins to harass her.
Mosa’s stand against sexual harassment brings to the surface the issues of women’s rights that are an everpresent undercurrent in the text. Early in the novel, as family and friends gather for her son Pule’s funeral, Mara sees a woman with an injured leg being forced to give up her chair to an able-bodied man. At Mosa’s school, only girls are assigned to the rotating schedule of classroom cleaning. When Mosa attends court proceedings with her friend Cecilia, she witnesses firsthand the discriminatory practices that dominate the legal system. She is horrified to learn, for example, that a woman can never bring a charge of rape against her husband, no matter what the circumstances.
428
Angered by such pervasive sexism, Mosa confronts her brother about their community’s marriage traditions. Their discussion of differing prewedding instructions for men and women also reveals the conflict between Western and traditional values that is thematically central to the novel. Stan, living with his teacher’s family, is caught in the middle of this struggle. The narrator explains that he “had learned over the years to separate his two lives.” While Dow emphasizes the ways in which traditional beliefs can hinder social and medical progress, she also sympathizes with those who cling to them. The novel includes a moving scene in which Cecilia’s family must convince her that she can die and join her ancestors.
W Style Far and Beyon’ is narrated in the third person; Dow uses her characters’ differing perspectives to dramatize the rift between Western and traditional values. The story focuses primarily on Mosa, whose skepticism about traditional practices is familiar to modern readers. The passages that depict Mosa’s mother, Mara, inspire sympathy toward those who believe their ancestors can communicate with and guide the living. Mara’s thoughts are conveyed in some of the novel’s most poetic writing, while the descriptions of Mosa’s beliefs are drier and at times didactic. Dow’s novel is a bildungsroman, a work that traces the protagonist’s transition from childhood or adolescence to adulthood. At the beginning of the story, Mosa is grappling with events that occurred a few months earlier, when a police officer who visited her school seduced her. After she became pregnant, he abandoned her, and she sought an abortion. Her forced absence from school has made her realize how much she values her education, and she returns as a strong young woman who refuses to submit to abuse and harassment. Her newfound resilience helps her stand up to Mr. Merake and inspires her fellow students to do the same. Though Mosa still faces an uphill battle as the novel ends, she has developed poise and confidence that will serve her well as an adult. Far and Beyon’ can also be considered a feminist novel in that it explicitly promotes equality between the sexes. Depicting the pervasive cultural bias that subordinates women to men in both public and private life, the book encourages all young readers to advocate for themselves.
W Critical Reception Although Dow was already well known in Africa as a groundbreaking female court justice, the publication of Far and Beyon’ established her reputation as an important TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Far and Beyon’
figure in contemporary African literature. Reviewing the book for the online magazine Women Writers, Moira Richards praises Dow’s treatment of such sensitive contemporary issues as sexism and AIDS, observing, “Dow has couched all these weighty issues into a very readable and life-affirming novel, accessible to the young adult reader and unforgettable to older readers who might have thought they knew most of what goes on in our world.” Many critics have traced connections between Dow’s legal career and advocacy for women and her literary themes. In an article in the New Zealand newspaper the Dominion about Dow’s dual careers as judge and author, Sarah Prestwood remarks, “Writing a novel became an unofficial way for her [Dow] to make a political statement.” She quotes Dow’s comment that “‘as a judge, every time I open my mouth, I have to watch what I say. In fiction, I have the right to say whatever I like.’” Commentators have also noted Dow’s careful handling of the gulf between traditional and Western cultures in the book. For example, Melinda Brown commends the novel in the Law Institute Journal for exploring “the paradoxes of a country where children
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Unity Dow was born in Botswana on April 23, 1959. She spent much of her early life in the village of Mochudi, later studying law at the University of Botswana and the University of Edinburgh. After completing her degree, she joined with other progressive academics, journalists, and lawyers to found the women’s advocacy group Emang Basadi! (Stand Up, Women!) and the Women and Law in Southern Africa research project, organizations that educate women about their rights and help them advocate for themselves. In the early 1990s Dow came to national attention when she successfully challenged a sexually discriminatory citizenship law. The victory led to a greater awareness of the women’s rights movement and to Dow’s appointment as the country’s first female high court judge, a position she held from 1998 to 2009. Her investment in justice for women has inspired her writing. Following the success of Far and Beyon’, she published The Screaming of the Innocent (2002), Juggling Truths (2003), and The Heavens May Fall (2006). She also cowrote Saturday Is for Funerals (2010; with Max Essex), an account of the AIDS crisis in Botswana.
Far and Beyon’ examines the many hardships faced by a young girl living in a small African village like the one pictured here, in Botswana. Lucian Coman/Shutterstock.com
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
429
Far and Beyon’
wear Nikes and drink Coke, but people use witchcraft and traditional magic to try to treat AIDS.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Brown, Melinda. Rev. of Far and Beyon’, by Unity Dow. Law Institute Journal 75.7 (2001): 9. Print. Dow, Unity. Far and Beyon’. Gaborone: Longman, 2000. Print. Prestwood, Sarah. “African Author Called to Judgment.” Dominion [Wellington] 20 Aug. 2001: 8. Print. Richards, Moira. Rev. of Far and Beyon’, by Unity Dow. Women Writers May 2003. Web. 31 Aug. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
De Vries, Fred. “The High Court of Writing.” Business Day [Johannesburg] 3 Mar. 2007. General OneFile. Web. 1 Sept. 2010. An interview in which Dow discusses the relationship between her writing and her judicial career. Rev. of Far and Beyon’, by Unity Dow. Africa News Service 23 Feb. 2001. General OneFile. Web. 1 Sept. 2010. A favorable review that provides a summary of the novel’s plot and political message. “The Little Known Talents of Unity Dow.” Africa News Service 17 Nov. 2008. General OneFile. Web. 1 Sept. 2010. A discussion of Dow’s role as both writer and judge, with brief notes about her novels, including Far and Beyon’. Reed, John. “The Novelist Judge and Her Small, Devoted Readership: Unity Dow Confronts a Society Tugged by Conflicting Forces.” Financial Times 20 June 2006: 4. General OneFile. Web. 1 Sept. 2010. An article that considers Dow’s life and the inspiration for her writing, along with a short description of Far and Beyon’. Rochman, Hazel. Rev. of Far and Beyon’, by Unity Dow. Booklist 1 May 2002: 1518. A review praising the novel for its evenhanded depiction of life in southern Africa.
430
Open Web Sources
The Web site of Dunsford Publishing Consultants includes an overview of Dow’s novel and excerpts from reviews. http://www.dunsfordpublishing.com/ books.html#farBey The Centre for Creative Arts at the University of KwaZulu-Natal offers a survey of Dow’s career and writings. http://www.cca.ukzn.ac.za/images/tow/ TOW2004/dow.htm For Further Reading
Dow, Unity, and Max Essex. Saturday Is for Funerals. Cambridge: Harvard UP, 2010. Print. In this nonfiction volume, Dow and Harvard medical researcher Max Essex present an overview of the AIDS crisis in Botswana, including history, stories of some of those infected, and an account of the country’s war against the disease. Engel, Jonathan. The Epidemic: A Global History of AIDS. New York: Smithsonian/Collins, 2006. Print. Engel’s book chronicles the history of the global AIDS pandemic, examining the disease in its sexual, religious, economic, and political contexts. Good, Kenneth. Diamonds, Dispossession & Democracy in Botswana. Rochester: Currey, 2008. Print. This work of nonfiction by Good, an expert on Botswana, traces the history and politics of the country and its economy. Lewis, Suzanne Grant. Education in Africa. Philadelphia: Lippincott, 2005. Print. Lewis’s book explores education in contemporary Africa, documenting governmental responses to the need for increased access to educational opportunities. Smith, Alexander McCall. The No. 1 Ladies’ Detective Agency. Edinburgh: Polygon, 1998. Print. The first in a popular series, Smith’s novel (which was made into a television series) tells the story of a female private detective in Botswana. Greta Gard
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Feast of the Goat By Mario Vargas Llosa
W Introduction Mario Vargas Llosa’s novel The Feast of the Goat (2000; English translation by Edith Grossman, 2001) is a multifaceted novel about the individual and national trauma induced by the dictatorship of Rafael Leónidas Trujillo in the Dominican Republic. The narrative reflects on the Trujillo dictatorship through three interwoven story lines. The first belongs to Urania Cabral, a successful New York lawyer who fled the Dominican Republic at the age of fourteen and returns to her native country in 1996, ostensibly to visit her aged and ailing father, Agustin, who was once one of Trujillo’s closest advisers. The second belongs to Trujillo himself, focusing largely on the last day of his life in 1961 and giving the reader direct insight into the consciousness of a corrupt but fascinating tyrant. The third story line follows the actions and memories of several of Trujillo’s assassins, many of whom had once been loyal to the president and his regime. As these distinct narrative threads finally intersect in the last few chapters of the novel, they comment on the insidious and far-reaching spiritual damage that is wrought by a cult of personality such as Trujillo’s.
W Literary and Historical Context
General Rafael Trujillo, also known as “the Goat,” ruled the Dominican Republic from 1930 until his assassination on May 30, 1961. He officially led the country as president from 1930 to 1938 and from 1942 to 1952; while out of office, he controlled the Dominican Republic through various puppet presidents. Trujillo was often capricious, manipulating people to his own ends. His tests of loyalty, abusive quid pro quos, meant Trujillo could demand the completion of atrocities that would serve the republic and his personal goals. Vargas Llosa’s portrait of
Trujillo shows a character deeply preoccupied with his own image. The Feast of the Goat belongs to a tradition of Latin American dictator novels, including Augusto Roa Bastos’s I the Supreme (1974), Alejo Carpentier’s Reasons of the State (1974), and Gabriel García Márquez’s Autumn of the Patriarch (1976). However, Vargas Llosa’s novel is a departure from magical realism, the style of Latin American writers from the period known as the “Boom.” The Feast of the Goat differs in two significant ways. First, according to Michael Wood in the London Review of Books and Andrew Foley in the Journal of Literary Studies, Vargas Llosa’s research grounds the story in reality rather than a mythical abstraction. Bastos, Carpentier, and García Márquez create pseudorealities for their despots, whereas Vargas Llosa achieves a gritty, inescapable realism for his. Second, Vargas Llosa’s organization signifies the complex connection between ruler and ruled. The Cabral father-daughter relationship dramatizes the complicity of a tyrant’s subjects in supporting the regime. Also, the conspirators understand the heavy price they have paid in serving Trujillo. Vargas Llosa weaves the memories and actions of historical and fictional characters to portray oppression and betrayal.
W Themes The Feast of the Goat exhibits the tension between nostalgia and trauma through the characters’ memories. The novel opens in 1996 with Urania returning to the Dominican Republic after thirty-five years. She revisits her memories of the city, her childhood, and the event that forced her departure. Over the course of a day she visits her father, now incapacitated by a stroke, as well as her aunt and cousins. Every place Urania sees naturally evokes memories. Some are pleasant; others have been suppressed. She was victimized by Trujillo and, in a profound betrayal, by her father. Through remembering and confronting her past, the traumatic details are set in
431 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Feast of the Goat
MAJOR CHARACTERS JOAQUIN BALAGUER is Trujillo’s puppet president and supporter. Balaguer appears as a dutiful cipher; following Trujillo’s assassination, however, he fills the power vacuum. ANTONIO IMBERT BARRERA is a disillusioned politician who becomes angry at the hypocrisy and cruelty of the Trujillo regime. He joins other conspirators in plotting the Goat’s death. AGUSTIN CABRAL is General Trujillo’s former secretary of state and part of the regime’s inner circle. He is complicit in the atrocities at the hands of the country’s leader that are revealed in the story. URANIA CABRAL is the daughter of Agustin. Her family’s experiences illustrate historical events of the Trujillo government and its demise. Over the course of a day, her long-held secret and reason for self-exile is revealed. COLONEL JOHNNY ABBES GARCIA is head of Servicio Inteligencia Militar (SIM), the Dominican Republic’s intelligence service. He is a brutal and ruthless man, “an arch-demon of great refinement,” according to Kirn. As Trujillo’s enforcer, he does the dirty work. AMADO GARCIA GUERRERO, or Amadito, is a disillusioned army lieutenant. To prove his loyalty, he gave up his beloved and later was forced to kill her brother. Following Trujillo’s assassination, he and Maza fight the SIM members who come to arrest them. ANTONIO DE LA MAZA is one of Trujillo’s bodyguards. Because his brother is killed in a government cover-up, he vows revenge. He elects death rather than capture and torture after Trujillo’s assassination. GENERAL JOSE ROMAN, nicknamed Pupo, is a conspirator and vengeful former Trujillo supporter. He agrees to form a provisional government as soon as he is shown Trujillo’s corpse. When that actually happens, however, Roman freezes in apparent impotence. GENERAL RAFAEL TRUJILLO, known as the Goat, the Chief, and the Benefactor, is based on the historical dictator of the Dominican Republic from 1930 to 1961. The novel depicts Trujillo’s political and personal life on his last day. RAMFIS TRUJILLO, the general’s son, is a well-known playboy. Although a disappointment to Trujillo, he serves in the military. He is also prominent in the vengeance-ridden postassassination developments.
front of the reader at the same time Urania is facing them. In another narrative thread, as the assassins anticipate their encounter with Trujillo, they privately remember the events that have brought them to this vengeful point. In this way, memory and motivation unite Urania’s story
432
The central figure of The Feast of the Goat, Dominican Republic president Rafael Trujillo speaks to his countrymen about communism. ª Hulton-Deutsch Collection/Corbis
to those of the assassins’. In connecting these characters thematically, Vargas Llosa helps readers understand the extent to which Trujillo’s evil penetrated society. Trujillo’s cult of personality determines his governance. In this immoral regime, Agustin offers Trujillo his fourteen-year-old daughter as appeasement. Agustin is the victim of his own ambition, Urania is sacrificed, and Trujillo’s impotence is witnessed by Urania. Humiliated, he deflowers her with his fingers and berates her in his thoughts. Trujillo’s encounter with Urania is the crucible of the action in the novel. During Trujillo’s reign his supporters grew in power, but the costs became intolerable. For Urania, confrontation with her past assuages her psychological pain, while the assassins choose murder as their revenge.
W Style The three interwoven story lines, delivered by an omniscient narrator, are an affecting and effective style choice. Because the focus alternates between first Urania, then Trujillo, and finally the assassin-conspirators, the individuals become part of a horrific tableau by the close of the novel. The tone of each strain is quite distinctive. The narrative voice is sometimes very close, mirroring TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Feast of the Goat
the individual at hand, or is set at a measured distance, allowing a sort of cinematic long shot. One of the prominent overall effects is an understanding of how each individual’s story is also an important part of the overall story of the Dominican Republic. As Laura Miller notes in Salon, Vargas Llosa’s structure of two time frames and three distinct narrative facets is “set up to deliver gobs of exposition.” The introspection of the characters offers a sort of intimacy that is at times compelling (in Urania’s case) and at other times repulsive (in Trujillo’s case, as when he tortures and abuses people). This is also where the author’s mix of researched historical detail combined with his imaginative genius accumulates both weight and significance as the story reaches its final scenes. The assassination of Trujillo comes roughly midway through the novel, but Vargas Llosa reinforces the continuance of the dictator’s influence by repeatedly shifting back to scenes of the living Trujillo.
W Critical Reception Reviewers of The Feast of the Goat have been impressed by Vargas Llosa’s research of the atrocities attributed to
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Mario Vargas Llosa, born in Peru on March 28, 1936, is a prolific novelist, journalist, social critic, and political activist. All of Latin America took notice when his groundbreaking novel The Time of the Hero was published in 1963. The book won the Spanish Critics Award and the rage of Peru’s military. He soon rose to prominence during the Latin American “Boom.” Vargas Llosa’s many novels vary in tone, narrative style, and theme. They include The Green House (1965), Aunt Julia and the Scriptwriter (1982), The War at the End of the World (1985), and Death in the Andes (1996). In 1990 Vargas Llosa ran for the presidency in Peru but lost to Alberto Fujimori. Disheartened by Fujimori’s harsh rule, he moved to Spain. He also has homes in London and in Lima, Peru. Vargas Llosa won the 2010 Nobel Prize in Literature.
Trujillo’s military. Most see Vargas Llosa’s narrative choices as adeptly accomplished and praise his imaginative ventures into the thoughts of Urania, Trujillo, and the conspirators. Alan Cheuse of SFGate considers him a
This photograph shows the car in which Dominican dictator Rafael Trujillo, the subject of The Feast of the Goat, was assassinated. ª Bettmann/Corbis
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
433
The Feast of the Goat
“master of the intricate and complex relation of the far past to the near past and immediate present.” Reviewers seem united in their responses to the heinous nature of Trujillo’s brutality and authoritarianism. Laura Miller, in Salon, writes, “Never has a novel drawn the malignant political potential of crude, unfettered masculinity more ferociously.” Critics also note Trujillo’s physical weaknesses—incontinence and impotence—suggesting these private embarrassments are the underpinnings of the dictator’s more public humiliation of others. Most critics agree that Vargas Llosa maintains firm stylistic control. Michael Wood writes in the London Review of Books that the “individual stories do build up a satisfyingly intricate picture.” Also, as the novel “arrives at its truly mesmerizing pages . . . it’s no longer quite a dictator novel . . . but it is an intensely intelligent political novel.” The only one of the inner circle who escapes is President Balaguer, Trujillo’s puppet. Walter Kirn, in the New York Times, labels Balaguer an “unlikely savior” who undergoes “a transformation of dazzling subtlety that has to be read twice to be appreciated.” Kirn describes Edith Grossman’s translation as “crackling” and energized, whereas in Miller’s view the prose is “clunky” at times, a weakness that is not helped by Grossman’s “wooden and often inept” translation. Reviewers agree that Vargas Llosa has written an important novel, which can also be read, as Olga Lorenzo of the Age does, as a comment on the “irrational forces of dictatorship that can be understood.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Cheuse, Alan. “Power Mad: Mario Vargas Llosa’s New Novel Serves Up the Horrors of Rafael Trujillo’s Reign in the Dominican Republic.” Rev. of The Feast of the Goat, by Mario Vargas Llosa. SFGate. Hearst Communications, 25 Nov. 2001. Web. 10 Oct. 2010. Foley, Andrew. “Power, Myth and Freedom.” Rev. of The Feast of the Goat, by Mario Vargas Llosa. Journal of Literary Studies 24.1 (2008): 1. Literature Resource Center. Web. 6 Oct. 2010. Jaggi, Maya. “Fiction and Hyper-reality.” Guardian [London]. Guardian News and Media Ltd, 16 Mar. 2002. Web. 7 Oct. 2010. Kirn, Walter. “Generalissimo.” New York Times. New York Times, 25 Nov. 2002. Web. 6 Oct. 2010. Lorenzo, Olga. “Dissection of a Despot.” Age [Melbourne]. Fairfax Media, 15 July 2002. Web. 6 Oct. 2010. Menton, Seymour. Rev. of The Feast of the Goat, by Mario Vargas Llosa. World Literature Today 74.3 (2000): 676. General Onefile. Web. 8 Oct. 2010.
434
Miller, Laura. Rev. of The Feast of the Goat, by Mario Vargas Llosa. Salon.com 6 Dec. 2002. Web. 6 Oct. 2010. Wood, Michael. “Memories of a Skinny Girl.” London Review of Books. LRB Limited, 9 May 2002. Web. 6 Oct. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Bell-Villada, Gene H. “Thirty-One Years of Solitude.” Commonweal 128.19 (2001): 20-21. Rpt. in Contemporary Literary Criticism. Ed. Janet Witalec. Vol. 181. Detroit: Gale, 2004. Literature Resource Center. Web. 11 Oct. 2010. Bell-Villada asserts that The Feast of the Goat “will most surely become THE book about the long Trujillo nightmare and the ongoing, sordid aftermath.” Hensher, Philip. “The Feast of the Goat. (Books: Anatomy of a Tyrant).” Rev. of The Feast of the Goat, by Mario Vargas Llosa. Spectator 30 Mar. 2002: 38+. Literature Resource Center. Web. 11 Oct. 2010. Situates The Feast of the Goat well outside the popular idea of the Latin American novel, noting its strengths, obsessions, and direction. Howard, Gregory. Rev. of The Feast of the Goat, by Mario Vargas Llosa. Review of Contemporary Fiction 22.1 (2002): 120-21. Rpt. in Contemporary Literary Criticism. Ed. Janet Witalec. Vol. 181. Detroit: Gale, 2004. Literature Resource Center. Web. 11 Oct. 2010. Howard describes The Feast of the Goat as “a visceral lesson in the complex synergy of political intrigue, sex, machismo, and history.” Johnson-Wright, Heidi. “January Interview with Mario Vargas Llosa.” January Magazine Jan. 2002. Web. 10 Oct. 2010. An interview with Vargas Llosa that contains commentary on his most recent work and his creative process. Kakutani, Michiko. “Storyteller Enthralled by the Power of Art.” New York Times. New York Times, 7 Oct. 2010. Web. 10 Oct. 2010. Offers a succinct overview and commentary on Vargas Llosa’s work and its legacy. Schwartz, Lynne Sharon. “Sensationalism and Sensibility.” New Leader 84.6 (2001): 30-31. Rpt. in Contemporary Literary Criticism. Ed. Janet Witalec. Vol. 181. Detroit: Gale, 2004. Literature Resource Center. Web. 11 Oct. 2010. Takes issue with “the unalloyed cruelty” detailed in The Feast of the Goat as “neither complex nor interesting, and lingering on its details yields easily to sensationalism.” Shakespeare, Sebastian. Rev. of The Feast of the Goat, by Mario Vargas Llosa. New Statesman 131.4554 (2002): 57. Rpt. in Contemporary Literary Criticism. Ed. Janet Witalec. Vol. 181. Detroit: Gale, 2004. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Feast of the Goat
Literature Resource Center. Web. 8 Oct. 2010. Provides a mixed assessment of The Feast of the Goat, noting that “even if this is not a great novel, Vargas Llosa is still a great storyteller.” Torch, Rafael. Rev. of The Feast of the Goat, by Mario Vargas Llosa. Antioch Review 60.2 (2002): 342-43. Rpt. in Contemporary Literary Criticism. Ed. Janet Witalec. Vol. 181. Detroit: Gale, 2004. Literature Resource Center. Web. 11 Oct. 2010. Asserts that The Feast of the Goat is “full of the tremendous power of the Latin American epic, and Vargas Llosa once again delivers a sweeping statement about the turbulent history of Latin America.” Gale Resources
“Edith Marian Grossman.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2003. Literature Resource Center. Web. 6 Oct. 2010. “Mario Vargas Llosa.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Literature Resource Center. Web. 8 Oct. 2010. “Mario Vargas Llosa.” Literature Resource Center. Detroit: Gale, 2010. Web. 8 Oct 2010. Open Web Sources
Vargas Llosa’s official Web site offers information on his novels and other publications, news links, and a short biography. http://www.mariovargasllosabooks. com/ The official site of the Nobel Prize committee features information on all laureates, including Vargas Llosa. http://nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/literature/laure ates/2010/ The Complete Review holds a collection of reviews of The Feast of the Goat and links to the original publications. http://www.complete-review.com/reviews/vargas/ fiestac.htm The Historical Text Archive offers a good overview of the political history of the Dominican Republic and the often unpleasant involvement of the United States. http://historicaltextarchive.com/sections.php?o p=viewarticle&artid=362 Oberlin College & Conservatory’s Web site presents sources and general resources on Latin America. http://www.oberlin.edu/faculty/svolk/latinam.htm For Further Reading
Alvarez, Julia. In the Time of the Butterflies. New York: Plume, 1994. Print. Three of the four Mirabal sisters were murdered by Trujillo’s henchmen in November 1960 for their involvement in efforts to topple the Trujillo regime. Alvarez’s fictionalization of their story won the National Book Critics Circle Award in 1994.
Chaddick, Larissa, and Luis Rebasa-Soraluz. “Demons and Lies: Motivation and Form in Mario Vargas Llosa.” Review of Contemporary Fiction Spring 1997: 15. Literature Resource Center. Web. 10 Oct. 2010. In this interview, Mario Vargas Llosa discusses his style and purposes in his fiction and recent nonfiction. He also responds to questions regarding the importance of the novel as a genre and touches directly on the writing of Gustave Flaubert, Victor Hugo, García Márquez, and Franz Kafka. Chang, Jorge Villanueva, and Jimena Pinilla Cisneros. “An Interview with Mario Vargas Llosa.” World Literature Today 76.1 (2002): 64(6). General OneFile. Web. 6 Oct. 2010. This interview features Vargas Llosa’s comments on the resiliency of the novel form, how technology will affect publishing books, and the contributions of several seminal writers such as Jorge Luis Borges, William Faulkner, Marcel Proust, and Kafka. Furtis, Richard Lee. Foundations of Despotism: Peasants, the Trujillo Regime, and Modern Dominican History. Stanford: Stanford UP, 2003. Print. This nonfiction work looks beyond the Trujillo cult of personality and the oppressive state apparatus to find the basis for the political legitimacy of the Trujillo regime. García Márquez, Gabriel. Autumn of the Patriarch. New York: Harper, 1976. Print. Both a novel of the Latin American literature period known as the “Boom” and one of the premier dictator novels, García Márquez’s book is quite different in style but similar in topic to The Feast of the Goat. Lopez-Calvo, Ignacio. God and Trujillo: Literal and Cultural Representations of the Dominican Dictator. Gainesville: UP of Florida, 2005. Print. This nonfiction volume focuses on the personal and public life of the dictator, as well as his known and probable psychological traits, and traces the history of SpanishAmerican dictators in general and Trujillo in particular. Robinson, Nancy P. “Origins of the International Day for the Elimination of Violence against Women: The Caribbean Contribution.” Caribbean Studies 34.2 (2006): 141+. Academic OneFile. Web. 8 Oct. 2010. Robinson traces the development of the international human framework for women’s rights and explores the origins of the International Day for the Elimination of Violence against Women in the Latin American context, through the life stories of the Mirabal sisters in the Dominican Republic. Adaptations
The Feast of the Goat. Dir. Luis Llosa. Perf. Isabella Rossellini, Paul Freeman, Stephanie Leonidas, Tomas Milian. Future Film Group, 2005. Film. Director Luis Llosa, an accomplished filmmaker and the novelist’s
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
435
The Feast of the Goat
brother-in-law, trims the triple focus of the original work to two dovetailed stories—those of Urania and the conspiracy to kill Trujillo. True to the novel is the creation of the atmosphere of terror, sycophancy, and savagery that pervaded Dominican society for more than three decades. The Feast of the Goat. Adapt. and dir. Jorge Triana. Repertorio Español. 2003 and 2007. Performance. New York City’s Repertorio Español’s stage
436
adaptation of The Feast of the Goat is a critically acclaimed presentation by the father-daughter team of Jorge and Victoriana Triana. In 2007 the production moved to Lima, Peru, also to great acclaim. A prominent feature of the stage production is that the same actor who portrays Agustin Cabral also plays the dictator Trujillo. Marta Lauritsen
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Fleshmarket Alley By Ian Rankin
W Introduction Fleshmarket Close (2004), published in the United States as Fleshmarket Alley, is the fifteenth installment in Ian Rankin’s Inspector Rebus series. As the novel begins, Rankin’s popular and tenacious John Rebus character is aging and surly. He is urged by his superiors to retire and is relegated to a new station, in Gayfield Square, where he feels uncomfortable and out of place. His case involves the death of an illegal immigrant— a Kurdish journalist—who was found murdered in an Edinburgh housing project called Knoxland. His investigation leads him to cross paths with Rankin’s secondary protagonist in the series, Detective Sergeant Siobhan Clarke, who is investigating the disappearance of the sister of a teenage girl who was brutally raped and subsequently committed suicide. A third plot involves the discovery of the skeletons of a woman and an infant, found buried beneath a concrete cellar in Fleshmarket Close. The exhumation of the skeletons leads Rebus through a labyrinth of connections that provide relationships between the various plotlines. Rankin’s Rebus character is drawn in the hard-boiled detective tradition of Raymond Chandler and Dashiell Hammett, but with Scottish dialect. The novel explores racial tensions and the contemporary issue of illegal immigration while maintaining a dark humor and an understated style.
W Literary and Historical Context
Many of Rankin’s novels are influenced by real crime events—often newspaper stories read by Rankin inspire the crimes investigated by Rebus. Fleshmarket Alley’s connection to real crime was the murder of an immigrant in Glasgow, which, according to Rankin, made him
“think a lot about the Scots and about racism and the myth of how welcoming we are to strangers” (Moore). The novel takes as its subject matter the real problem of illegal immigration in the country. Scotland’s Evening News has reported that “[T]he number of illegal immigrants stopped at the UK’s ports and airports increased by nearly two thirds between 2003 and 2005” (Picken), right around the time Rankin was writing the novel. Rebus’s investigation into the murder leads to the larger problem of an organized crime ring, and, though widely acknowledged for his realistic and accurate geographical descriptions of Edinburgh, the city’s criminal element is overstated in the novel. Speaking of the nature of crime in the city, Rankin has been quoted as saying that the “Edinburgh of [his] novels was criminologically fantastic,” and that “the real, ‘quite safe city’ had neither the murder rate nor the underworld activity of his writing” (Mullan). Inspector Rebus owes a debt of gratitude to the American hard-boiled detective. Rankin studied American literature, and he was inspired to write detective novels by 1940s American films. In the vein of the American hard-boiled detective, Rebus is very masculine and gruff, a hard-drinking, less than professional cop who generally occupies a moral high ground, demonstrated in Fleshmarket Alley by his social commentary about racism in Scotland.
W Themes Rankin uses Fleshmarket Alley as a vehicle for social commentary, focusing on the themes of immigration and racism in Scotland. Much of the story takes place around Knoxland, the housing projects where the body of Stef Yurgii, the murdered asylum seeker, was found. The tenements are squalid and dangerous dwellings, and, according to one critic, “Although it seems unlikely that Rebus would be ignorant of the inhuman living
437 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Fleshmarket Alley
MAJOR CHARACTERS DETECTIVE SERGEANT SIOBHAN CLARKE is a secondary protagonist. She a protégée of Rebus’s, and is investigating the disappearance of Ishbel Jardine when the cases intersect. DONALD CRUIKSHANK was convicted of raping Tracy Jardine, the sister of Ishbel, whose disappearance is being investigated by DS Siobhan Clarke. ISHBEL JARDINE goes missing after her sister, Tracy, was raped by Donald Cruikshank and subsequently committed suicide. JOHN REBUS is the main protagonist in the story, a detective inspector who is investigating the murder of a Kurdish asylum seeker. He is approaching retirement age and is a cynical man who is a heavy drinker and smoker, distrusts authority, and is generally ornery.
conditions in Edinburgh’s crime-infested council housing, he is properly indignant about them. To his freshly opened eyes, Knoxland is ‘another culture, another country,’ a no man’s land that ‘tended to attract only the desperate and those with no choice’” (Stasio). The slums, where the majority of Edinburgh’s asylum-seekers live, are contrasted with detention centers, where other immigrants are detained while they wait for their fate to be determined by the police and the government. The story has been called “an opportunity for Rankin to open up the immigration debate with Rebus as the voice of reason. He finds that not only is racism alive and kicking within the police force, it’s thriving in Knoxland where angry adults and churlish children offload fired-up talk of bogus asylum seekers and terrorists posing as refugees” (Henry). The social issue is broadened to include human trafficking as the plot progresses and the cases of both Rebus and Siobhan Clarke intertwine and lead to Edinburgh’s red-light district and sex industry, leading a critic to observe that Fleshmarket Alley is “an uncomfortable read, reflecting only too well the nastiness of our society.”
Fleshmarket Alley deals with issues of illegal immigration. Many illegal immigrants are held in detention centers until the government determines their fate. Christopher Furlong/Getty Images
438
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Fleshmarket Alley
W Style Fleshmarket Alley is written in the style of a police procedural—a genre that emerged in the 1940s and 1950s and presented audiences with a realistic representation of criminal investigations. It is a novel that in many ways challenges and subverts the conventions of the style. Typically, a police procedural will place the story’s crime and investigative techniques in the foreground, sublimating larger questions of justice, psychology, and social norms. In Fleshmarket Alley, however, this is reversed, and Rankin focuses on the issues of race and immigration. Rather than the usual first-person point of view, told from the detective’s perspective, Rankin uses a third-person omniscient viewpoint. The focus of the narrative is usually on Inspector Rebus, but occasionally shifts to the point of view of other characters.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Ian Rankin was born in Fife, Scotland, in 1960 and graduated from the University of Edinburgh. He worked several jobs before becoming a full-time novelist, publishing his first novel, The Flood, in 1986. The first novel in the DI Rebus series, Knots and Crosses (1987), was his first effort at crime fiction. He has published more than two dozen novels, including ones written under the pseudonym Jack Harvey, short story collections, nonfiction, and a graphic novel. He has contributed to BBC documentaries, including a three-part series on the subject of evil. Rankin has won several awards, including two Dagger prizes from the Crime Writers’ Association, and an Edgar award.
Fleshmarket Alley, the fifteenth novel in Rankin’s Inspector Rebus series, takes place in present-day Edinburgh, Scotland. ª Malcom Fife/Corbis
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
439
Fleshmarket Alley
As is common in detective fiction, the story comprises more than one case—Rebus’s investigation into Stef Yurgii’s murder and Clarke’s investigation of Ishbel Jardine’s disappearance—and the two cases intersect with a third plotline involving two skeletons that are found to have been stolen from Edinburgh University. Also common to the genre, the personal life of the detective is central to the story, establishing Rebus’s personal interest in his work. This has led a critic from Glasgow’s Evening Times to the observation that “The hard-drinking cop is a bit clichéd in crime fiction but Rebus fans will observe how over the years the books have changed from the hunt for the perpetrator of a crime to our hero’s personal problems and relationship with colleagues.” The effect of highlighting Rebus’s personal life is to make the reader invested in the character as much as the story, which well serves a series with seventeen installments.
W Critical Reception Ian Rankin’s DI Rebus series is among the most popular and successful in contemporary crime fiction. Widely praised for his mastery of the genre, many critics note the expertise with which Rankin weaves complex subplots through his novels. One critic has observed, “As expected, Fleshmarket Alley begins with a murder, but it subsequently runs through several other scenarios— another murder, a runaway daughter, human smuggling” (Endelman). Critics have also noted that Rankin deftly handles his various plots, slowly letting them unfold. Writing about Fleshmarket Alley in the New York Times, Janet Maslin said, “It is in keeping with Rebus’s grudging manner that these novels are in no hurry to explain themselves. They take their own sweet time letting plots coalesce.” Fleshmarket Alley has also won praise for its social commentary, tackling the issue of immigration with “care and passion” (Robins). Romaine S. Scott III, writing for the American Bankruptcy Institute Journal, has commented, “Rankin’s storytelling skills are excellent. Although his style is understated, he keeps the reader engrossed by building intrigue around social commentary immersed in crystal-clear descriptions of the culture of everyday life in Edinburgh.” And, in the Evening Times, a critic said, “Rankin is a craftsman, but far from escapism, this is an uncomfortable read, reflecting only too well the nastiness of our society.” Rankin has been criticized for not writing literary fiction, but instead writing light, summer reading, saying such things as, “Rankin is an easy, comfortable fit for an airplane ride, a day at the beach or those quiet minutes before you turn out the light on a busy work day” (Scott). Rankin, however, does this self-consciously. Regarding his chosen genre, Rankin has been quoted as saying, “I thought, do I want to spend seven years at
440
university writing books that are only read by people at university, like James Joyce’s Ulysses, or do I want to write the kind of books my Dad would read? It was a pretty simple answer” (Moore). BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Endelman, Michael. Rev. of Fleshmarket Alley, by Ian Rankin. Entertainment Weekly 31 Jan. 2005. Web. 11 Aug. 2010. “Fleshmarket Close by Ian Rankin.” Daily Post [Liverpool]. MGN Ltd. 2004. HighBeam Research. Web. 8 Aug. 2010. “Fleshmarket Is a Little Too Close to the Bone.” Evening Times. Newsquest (Herald & Times) Ltd. 2004. HighBeam Research. Web. 7 Aug. 2010. Henry, Andrea. “Book Reviews: Top Rankin; Fleshmarket Close by Ian Rankin.” Mirror [London]. MGN Ltd. 2004. HighBeam Research. Web. 7 Aug. 2010. Maslin, Janet. “Complicated Mysteries, Complicated Detectives.” New York Times 14 Feb. 2005. Web. 11 Aug. 2010. Moore, Clayton. “An Interview with Ian Rankin.” Bookslut Apr. 2005. Web. 9 Aug. 2010. Mullan, John. “Crime Praise.” Guardian [London] 16 Sept. 2006. Web. 9 Aug. 2010. Picken, Andrew. “Airport Security Catching Two Illegal Immigrants Every Week.” Evening News - Scotland. Scotsman Publications. 2007. HighBeam Research. Web. 9 Aug. 2010. Scott, Romaine S., III. “Fleshmarket Alley.” American Bankruptcy Institute Journal. American Bankruptcy Institute. 2006. HighBeam Research. 7 Aug. 2010 Stasio, Marilyn. “Dead and Bloated.” New York Times 6 Feb. 2005. Web. 10 Aug. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Kyle, Tom. “Edinburgh in the Flesh; Critic’s Choice.” Daily Mail [London]. McClatchy-Tribune Information Services. 2004. HighBeam Research. Web. 11 Aug. 2010 Review of Fleshmarket Alley that discusses the novel’s plot and the psychology of DI Rebus. Lipkien Gershenbaum, Barbara. “Reviews.” Bookreporter. com. 2010. Web. 7 Aug. 2010. Review of Fleshmarket Alley that includes a detailed summary and interview excerpts. Ross, Peter. “Sympathy for the Devil: Please Allow Us to Introduce Ian Rankin, a Man of Wealth and Taste. He’s Been Around for Years Writing about Inspector Rebus, but Now the Series Is Coming to an End, and Britain’s Most Successful Crime Novelist Must TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Fleshmarket Alley
Decide What to Do Next. A Good Time, Then, for Peter Ross to Take a Magnifying Glass to the Fascinating Life and Career of a Very Scottish Literary Star.” Sunday Herald. Newsquest (Herald & Times) Ltd. 2004. HighBeam Research. Web. 11 Aug. 2010. Critical essay on Rankin that discusses his history, themes, and the genesis of Fleshmarket Alley. Gale Resources
Gowers, Rebecca. “Murky Depths.” New Statesman [1996] 4 Oct. 2004: 54+. “Ian Rankin.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2008. “Ian Rankin.” Contemporary Literary Criticism. Vol. 257. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Open Web Sources
Perskie, Jana L. “Ian Rankin.” Mostly Fiction Book Reviews. MostlyFiction.com. 12 June 2005. Web. 9 Aug 2010. http://www.mostlyfiction.com/sleuths/ rankin.htm Smith, Jules. “Contemporary Writers.” British Council. 2009. Web. 7 Aug. 2010, at http://www.contemporarywriters. com/authors/?p=auth02A17M435212626443
Minnesota Press, 1985. Print. Book about the social phenomenon and popularity of crime fiction. “Out of the Darkness: His Working Life May Be Murder, but Ian Rankin’s Motivation Is a Surprise.” Daily Mail [London]. McClatchy-Tribune Information Services. 2004. HighBeam Research. Web. 11 Aug. 2010. Interview with Rankin during which he discusses his family, the Rebus character, and thematic concerns of Fleshmarket Alley. Rankin, Ian. Rebus: The Early Years—Knots and Crosses / Hide and Seek / Tooth and Nail. New Ed. Edition. London: Orion, 2000. Print. The first three novels in the DI Rebus series. ———. Rebus’s Scotland: A Personal Journey. London: Orion, 2005. Print. Nonfiction book about Edinburgh featuring 120 photographs. Adaptations
Rebus. STV Productions. Clerkenwell Films. Perf. Ken Stott, John Hannah, Gayanne Potter. ITV Network. 2000-08. Television show. Detective drama based on the DI Rebus series set in and around Edinburgh. Todd Breijak
For Further Reading
Mandel, Ernest. Delightful Murder: A Social History of the Crime Story. Minneapolis: University of
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
441
Fox Girl By Nora Okja Keller
W Introduction Nora Okja Keller’s Fox Girl (2002) is the story of Hyun Jin and her half-sister Sookie, who reach their sexual maturity and brutal initiation in the slums that surround a U.S. military camp near Pusan, Korea. The novel follows Hyun Jin and Sookie as they discover the truth about their parents and are virtually thrown into the streets to manage on their own without familial support. Because of her biracial status, Sookie is considered one of the throwaway children, offspring of Korean prostitutes and African American GIs, abandoned by their African American fathers and left to be raised, abandoned, or killed by their impoverished prostitute mothers. These biracial children and teens are scorned by Korean society, with its engrained belief in racial purity and abhorrence of Korean prostitutes, particularly those who service African Americans. In this brutal environment, the biracial teenagers use the only resource they have: The females sell their bodies; the males hawk stolen goods and pimp. In this sordid world, certain women in business are dominant, for example, Hyun Jin’s shop-owning mother who dominates her husband; Bar Mama, who runs a bar and brothel; and Mrs. Yoon, who buys teenage girls and transports them illegally to Hawaii to work as sex slaves. The novel also portrays various roles played by men: the kindly yet hen-pecked Appah, father of Hyun Jin; Lobetto, the pimp; and Chazu, the African American soldier who is a client of both Duk Hee and her daughter, Sookie. The racially segregated America Town or shantytown around the military base is a prison for its diverse inhabitants, and each exercises power in certain ways in order to survive and in other ways is victimized in the process. Only through a chance opportunity is Hyun Jin able to exploit her illegal immigration to Hawaii, there to find herself bereft of
everyone who ever mattered to her except for the salvaged throwaway baby she has claimed as her own.
W Literary and Historical Context
Fox Girl is a bildungsroman, a coming-of-age novel. This genre was especially popular in the nineteenth century, with such works as Charles Dickens's Great Expectations (1861) in England and Mark Twain's Huckleberry Finn (1885) in the United States. Darker versions of the stories of initiation and loss of innocence appeared with Stephen Crane’s Maggie: A Girl of the Streets (1893) and at the beginning of the twentieth century with Upton Sinclair’s The Jungle (1906), both of which depict working-class squalor, corruption in industry, and deterministic factors such as birth, class, and social oppression that shape working-class people and the unemployed poor. The fallen woman has been a staple of literature through the centuries, perhaps one of the most famous being Hester Prynne in Nathaniel Hawthorne’s Scarlet Letter (1850). Hawthorne also wrote a short story “The Birthmark” about how men devalue and eventually destroy flawed women. Regarding Asian American literature, the context for Keller’s novel lies in the more immediate past, with such works as Maxine Hong’s memoir Woman Warrior: Memoir of a Girlhood among Ghosts (1975) and Amy Tan’s novel The Joy Luck Club (1989), both of which are about the Chinese American experience. Fox Girl is set in the 1960s, a time of racial conflict and prejudice around the globe and the civil rights movement in the United States, which culminated in the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and then took a blow with the 1968 assassination of one of its key leaders, Martin Luther King Jr. The seventeen-year-old Lobetto shows off a letter from his father, sent five years earlier, in which
442 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Fox Girl
MAJOR CHARACTERS APPAH, Hyun Jin’s father, is sympathetic and kindly but dominated by his harsh and prejudiced wife, who owns the sweet shop that supports the family. BAR MOTHER is the boss of the bar and brothel where both Hyun Jin and Sookie work. CHAZU is the African American soldier who is a client of Duk Hee and then temporarily partners with Sookie and provides her with an apartment. DUK HEE is Sookie’s mother and the birth mother of Hyun Jin. She makes her living as a prostitute servicing African American soldiers. HYUN JIN, the Korean narrator, is a teenager living in the slums around the U.S. military camp. LOBETTO is a racially mixed teenager who early on expects his African American father to send for him but later must work as a pimp in order to make any money. MYU MYU is Sookie’s baby that Hyun Jin claims as her own. A young schoolgirl reacts to the loss of her school following an attack during the Korean War, a military conflict that serves as the backdrop for author Keller’s Fox Girl. ª Photos 12/Alamy
his father alludes to the I Have a Dream speech King made in Washington, D.C., in 1963, and expresses the hope that race relations and economic opportunities for African Americans will improve. American culture reaches Hyun Jin, Sookie, and Lobetto through exported goods and leads them to imagine an American culture of riches and ease. In her apartment, Sookie shows off the “American style” appliances, concluding, “In America, . . . it’s too much work even to turn your wrist” (102). Also, at the venereal disease clinic, mention is made of men who like teenage girls who have hardly any breasts. One woman comments, “Some men like that. . . . Did you see the styles in the American magazines? Cosumo, Vo-gu, all have that Twiggy girl who looks like a boy” (40). Twiggy (born Lesley Hornby in 1949) was arguably the first international supermodel, famous in the 1960s and 1970s for her pencil-thin figure and her elfin look. Her flat, narrow figure, completely free of womanly curves, became an ideal in the fashion world of the West.
W Themes A central theme in Fox Girl focuses on the concept of identity and group membership: biological, racial, social, and in the workplace. The novel explores how demarcations between groups of people are drawn and
SOOKIE is the half-sister of Hyun Jin, a racially mixed teenager whose mother works as a prostitute servicing African American GIs. MRS. YOON transports Korean prostitutes to Hawaii and exploits them there as sex slaves.
defined and how individuals in groups and excluded from them come to identify themselves. In the racially bifurcated America Town and in the animosity between pure Koreans and racially mixed offspring, there is a constant competition for limited resources and a longing for connection and home. Children born into this environment scarcely stand a chance, unless they adapt and learn the tricks of the streets. As they seek a way of making money, they typically lose track of their identity, their selfhood. Prostitution hurries this erosion of self, as Sookie explains: “the more you do it, the more you know it’s not the real you. The real you flies away, and you can’t feel anything anymore” (131). Hyun Jin is effective as a prostitute, intuiting what men want. She boasts, “I could be their idea of me” (208). It is not surprising that Sookie’s unwanted baby is named Myu Myu, “little no name” (199). Prostitution is a means of income, a way of getting thin soup and a blanket or box to sleep in; its price is selferasure. Connected to the question of identity and group membership is the question repeatedly raised concerning whether an individual’s life is a matter of genetics or the will to survive and the courage to make choices that work. Hyun Jin’s adoptive mother repeatedly asserts: “It’s in
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
443
Fox Girl
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Born December 22, 1965, in Seoul, Korea, to a Korean mother and a German computer engineer, Nora Okja Keller grew up in Hawaii and obtained her BA from the University of Hawaii. After that, she received an MA from the University of California, Santa Cruz. Her first novel, Comfort Woman (1997), won the American Book Award for 1998 and the Cades Award for 1999. She married James Keller in 1990, and as of 2010, she lived with her husband and children in Waipahu, Hawaii.
the blood. Everyone’s life is mapped from the moment of birth” (50). This belief asserts that since Hyun Jin’s birth mother Duk Hee is a prostitute who services African Americans, Hyun Jin cannot escape prostitution herself; it is her genetically determined destiny. Sookie is even more
seriously condemned by her parents, one Korean and the other African American. Keller explores the forces that determine people’s lives, and in the world she depicts no one is a free agent. Many of the powerful forces lie beyond the individual’s control: facts of birth, economic circumstances, social class, and geographical and temporal location. When Hyun Jin’s father says, “You are what you are” (125), he seems to acquiesce to his wife’s beliefs about the forces shaping Hyun Jin’s life.
W Style Fox Girl is told in first-person point of view: It is Hyun Jin’s story of growing up in America Town, how she discovered her origins and was forced into learning the ways of the streets. It is a story of self-discovery, that is, one in which she discovers that what she has always believed about herself and her parents is a lie. The story is a sordid version of learning the facts of life, the facts of
U.S. president Dwight D. Eisenhower visits Korea around the time of the Korean War, the setting of the novel Fox Girl. ª Corbis
444
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Fox Girl
one’s past. But looking back from her mid-twenties, Hyun Jin considers a different reading of her father’s rejection of her. She recalls leaving them the last time, how her father seemed to agree with her mother in saying, “Blood will tell!” (125). The older Hyun Jin looks back across five years and nearly five thousands miles and pauses: “Sometimes I think I could have changed my story at this point in my life” (125). Now she realizes that personal choice does play a role in shaping people’s lives and how they interpret others and events affects both their self-concept and their life paths, too. The story changes with a different perspective: Perhaps her father meant for her to take heart because she is his offspring as much as she is the offspring of Duk Hee, her birth mother. As the immediate story unfolds, however, Keller limits the point of view to the inexperienced young girl who needs to find a way to survive beyond her parents’ shop but who is unfamiliar with what her work will entail. The point of view widens as the narrator becomes more street-wise and resilient. In a sense, the process is one of transformation, and that is where the title and the myth of the shape-shifting fox play a part. Hyun Jin takes on other forms, other roles, and doing so helps her survive. It is fitting that in final scene Myu Myu rubs ointment on Hyun Jin’s hands, easing the soreness where her skin has sloughed off. In Hawaii, Hyun Jin has the possibility of becoming more nearly herself.
W Critical Reception Nora Okja Keller drew attention to Korean American perspectives when she published Comfort Woman in 1997, and by the time Fox Girl was published in 2002, the literary world of critics and scholars had taken note. Keller had, according to Logan Hill, exposed “another underimagined era of military occupation.” Maritess A. Tse agreed. The importance of Keller’s book is that through “her use of harsh vocabulary and images of rape . . . the reader [is forced] to face the ugly reality that millions are or have lived through when foreign soldiers occupy another land.” Keller’s accomplishment is the way she exposes the previously hidden or forgotten victims of sexual exploitation and dramatizes the sexualized Asian female, both forms of collateral damage left in the wake of war. Writing along similar lines, Jennifer Ho stated in her review that Fox Girl that Keller’s “poignant novel . . . shows the full humanity of the unseen and neglected people of America’s forgotten war.” She also explained that Keller’s “sympathetic yet flawed” characters are not “simply oppressed victims.” Rather they struggle under horrific conditions to survive. Ho wrote: “Describing Hyun Jin’s initiation into prostitution, Keller details the atrocities born by her body not for shock value but to bear witness to what countless teenage girls had to
endure (and still endure) in order to make money and stay alive.” Donna Seaman agreed, stating in her review that Fox Girl “unflinchingly explores the terrible nexus of sex and war and honors the resiliency of women.” According to Seaman, Keller’s achievement is “an empathic, valiant, and spellbinding” novel, with an effect “as harrowing as it is cathartic.” Shirley Quan described the novel as “a tale of sheer fortitude,” and a reviewer in Kirkus Reviews stated that Keller has created “an unself-pitying microcosm of outcasts so bedazzled by American culture that even rape and infanticide are tolerated on the way to a better life.” A reviewer in Publishers Weekly agreed and went to point out that the novel is “unsentimental in portraying the callousness of human nature that’s been degraded by violence and deprivation” and eloquent in “describing the pureness of spirit to which even the most bitter victim can rise.” The Publishers Weekly review summarized Fox Girl as a “rare, honest picture of a marginal society unfamiliar to most American readers” and “a contribution to Asian American understanding.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Rev. of Fox Girl, by Nora Okja Keller. Kirkus Reviews 1 Feb. 2002: 128. Print. Rev. of Fox Girl, by Nora Okja Keller. Publishers Weekly 28 Jan. 2002: 267. Print. Hill, Logan. “Novel History Lessons: A Profile of Nora Okja Keller.” Poets & Writers 30.2 (2002): 30-37. Print. Ho, Jennifer. “Review of Fox Girl.” Rev. of Fox Girl, by Nora Okja Keller. Amerasia Journal 30.2 (2004): 117-19. Print. Quan, Shirley N. “Fox Girl.” Rev. of Fox Girl, by Nora Okja Keller. Library Journal 15 Mar. 2002: 108. Print. Seaman, Donna. “Keller, Nora Okja. Fox Girl.” Rev. of Fox Girl, by Nora Okja Keller. Booklist 15 Mar. 2002: 1212. Tse, Maritess A. “Korean War Kids.” Rev. of Fox Girl, by Nora Okja Keller. International Examiner 30 Apr. 2002. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Driscoll, Amy. “Fox Girl: Bitterly Honest.” Rev. of Fox Girl, by Nora Okja Keller. Albany Times Union 12 May 2002. Print. A review that praises Keller for drawing attention to the forgotten victims of the Korean War. Hill, Logan. “Novel History Lessons: A Profile of Nora Okja Keller.” Poets & Writers 30.2 (2002): 30-37. Print. An interview in which Keller explains how
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
445
Fox Girl
writing her novels required her to find her own Korean American identity. Lee, Sung-Ae. “Re-visioning Gendered Folktales in Novels by Mia Yun and Nora Okja Keller.” Asian Ethnology 68.1 (2009): 131+. Print. Explores how Yun and Keller draw on culturally specific folktales and also engage in the gendered assumptions of those tales. Madsen, Deborah L. “Nora Okja Keller: Telling Trauma in the Transnational Military-(Sex)industrial Complex.” Interactions 22 Sept. 2006. Print. Explores the sexual exploitation of Asian women in general and Korean women specifically and suggests that Fox Girl asks whether prostitutes are born or made. Tse, Maritess A. “Korean War Kids.” Rev. of Fox Girl, by Nora Okja Keller. International Examiner 30 Apr. 2002. Print. A positive review, which appreciates that Keller directs attention to those invisible people who must reconstruct their countries and their lives after enduring war in their midst. Gale Resources
“Nora Okja Keller.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2005. Literature Resource Center. Web. 27 Sept. 2010. http://go.galegroup.com/ps/ i.do?&id=GALE%7CH1000126258&v= 2.1&u=itsbtrial&it=r&p=LitRC&sw=w “Nora Okja Keller.” Contemporary Literary Criticism. Ed. Jeffrey W. Hunter. Vol. 281. Detroit: Gale, 2010. Literature Resource Center. Web. 27 Sept. 2010. http://go.galegroup.com/ps/i.do?&id=GALE %7CH1103150000&v=2.1&u=itsbtrial&it=r &p=LitRC&sw=w
446
For Further Reading
Choi, Susan. The Foreign Student. New York: HarperFlamingo, 1998. Print. The story of a young man who flees the Korean War by becoming a foreign student at a university in Louisiana with graphic depictions of the Korean War. Hara, Marie, and Nora Okja Keller, eds. Intersecting Circles: The Voices of Hapa Women in Poetry and Prose Honolulu: Bamboo Ridge Press, 1999. Print. A collection of writings by mixed-race women. Keller, Nora Okja. Comfort Woman. New York: Viking, 1996. Print. Set in Hawaii and containing a portrait of a Korean woman who was forced to become a sexual slave, one of the comfort women who serviced Japanese soldiers during World War II. Moon, Katharine H. S. Sex among Allies: Military Prostitution in U.S.-Korean Relations. New York: Columbia UP, 1997. Print. Describes the camptowns that flourished around U.S. bases in Korea after the end of the Korean War and were a source of friction in U.S.-Korean relations because of the venereal disease, crime, and local antipathy. Pihl, Marshall R., Bruce Fulton, and Ju-Chan Fulton, eds. Land of Exile: Contemporary Korean Fiction. Armonk: M. E. Sharpe, 2007. Print. The 1993 collection of out-of-print short fiction translated into English, which depicts post-World War II South Korea, its culture, and society. Melodie Monahan
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Frida’s Bed By Slavenka Drakulic
W Introduction
W Literary and Historical
Slavenka Drakulic’s Frida’s Bed, published in Croatian as Frida ili o boli in 2007 and translated into English by Christina Pribichevich-Zoric in 2008, is a fictionalized portrait of painter Frida Kahlo (July 6, 1907-July 13, 1954), told in both the third- and first-person point of view. The novel is in effect a loose life-review reverie that takes place as Frida lies in her bed on her final day, her health deteriorating quickly with pneumonia, death imminent, and considerations of hastening the end with morphine recurring as the day wanes. As she awakens on this day, she feels her body and searches for faint memories of being well before she was afflicted with polio at the age of six. Whether in third or first person, the point-of-view character is Frida herself, making this novel a fictionalized account of her inner reality, her way of seeing the world through what she calls the “carapace” (17), not only of the plaster body cast but of her body itself, so often fitted with rigid corsets and other support devices. Frida reviews her memories of all the pain that followed the bus and trolley crash in which she was severely injured at age eighteen and the multiple operations that followed it. She reviews her teenage relationship with Alex, handily shipped off to Europe in the months following the crash; her increasing interest in painting; her approaching Diego Rivera for his assessment of her artwork; their relationship and her several miscarriages; her relationship with her parents and siblings, particularly Cristina (called Kity) who has an affair with Rivera after he and Frida marry. Mostly Drakulic emphasizes the personality and physical challenges of Frida herself, but italicized portions of the text contain brief descriptions of some of her paintings, linking them to the biography.
The literary context for Drakulic’s novel lies in a variety of works that focus on the invalid and that dramatize the isolation that surrounds a person who suffers chronic pain. The protracted hospital stays and long periods of enforced bed rest suggest such nineteenthcentury works as Charlotte Perkins Gilman’s long short story, “The Yellow Wall-paper” (1892), which depicts the infamous rest cure designed by Silas Weir Mitchell for the treatment of hysteria. Another work that is suggested by Drakulic’s novel is the diary of Alice James (1850–1892), sister of psychologist William James and novelist Henry James, who was a mostly eclipsed invalid in a family of important men. Susan Sontag wrote a play, Alice in Bed (1993), about Alice James’s invalidism. The primary historical context for the novel consists of the biographies of Frida Kahlo and Diego Rivera, wellknown material that has been covered in various studies, in film, and in other works of fiction. In addition to this material and analyses of selected Kahlo paintings, Drakulic draws on the early-twentieth-century polio epidemic, long before the polio vaccine was discovered by Jonas Salk in the 1950s. In addition, Drakulic uses biographical information regarding the Riveras’ interest in communism, their belief in Stalin, and their support of Leon Trotsky, who with his wife Natalia sought political asylum in Mexico and lived for a time in the Kahlo family home. Another historical context for the novel is the nouveau art world of the early twentieth century that welcomed Kahlo and her work, notably after her New York and Paris exhibitions. The novel describes the appreciation Georgia O’Keeffe expressed to Kahlo during the 1938 New York exhibition. Drakulic also describes how the Dadaist Marcel Duchamp and surrealists André Breton, Joan Miró, and Pablo Picasso all embraced her
Context
447 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Frida’s Bed
FRIDA KAHLO DE RIVERA, the protagonist and point-of-view character, is stricken by polio and later invalided by severe injuries from a traffic accident. She becomes a successful painter.
her isolation from family and friends, she had this reflection of herself always available, her chief subject and object of study. This sense of the divided self, a woman in bed facing a woman in mirror, is developed thematically as key to Kahlo’s psychological makeup. The fictional protagonist repeatedly experiences herself as split or divided, a pervasive sense of self as both self and other that makes up who she is, a psychic division that sharpens as the years go on. Chronic pain is the chief catalyst for this split and connected to it are the two lessons Frida states: “how difficult it is to imagine somebody else’s pain” (16) and “when pain rivets you to your body you have to step out of yourself if you are to survive” (22). In the first lesson lies her understanding of what sustains the gulf between herself and others; in the second lesson, she discovers the necessity of painting as a way of externalizing suffering and enduring it. Art provides for “self-separation” (16); it provides for and requires the disembodied point of view (23).
LEON TROTSKY, the communist revolutionary, accepts asylum in Mexico and with his wife, Natalia, lives in the home of Frida’s parents.
W Style
MAJOR CHARACTERS CRISTINA KAHLO, called Kity, is the youngest daughter who is devoted to Frida’s care and yet has an affair with her husband, Diego Rivera. DON GUILERMO KAHLO is Frida’s epileptic father, a successful businessman who encouraged his daughters and favored Frida among them. DOÑA MATILDA KAHLO, Frida’s mother, is a cold, critical woman who is unable to support Frida during her protracted hospitalizations and convalescence. DIEGO RIVERA, called the Maestro, is the famous Mexican mural artist who marries Frida but is insatiable in his pursuit of other women.
and her work during and after her 1939 Paris exhibition. While the novel explains how Rivera’s murals and his recognition as an artist eclipsed Kahlo and her work for decades during their marriage, it does not explain that after Kahlo’s death, interest in her work equaled and even at times overshadowed interest in his. Staying within Kahlo’s point of view, the novel describes the couple in Detroit, only covering Kahlo’s miscarriage during the stay and her depiction of it in her painting, Henry Ford Hospital; the novel ignores Rivera’s famous murals (1931), which he was commissioned by Edsel Ford to paint in the Detroit Institute of Arts, a tribute to the auto industry and Ford’s gift to Detroit.
W Themes The principal theme of Frida’s Bed is the correlation between Kahlo’s physical body and her body of work. Drakulic depicts the many ways in which Kahlo projected her self-concept, both her physical body and her psychological nature, onto her work. Most of Kahlo’s paintings are self-portraits, and many of them surrealistically depict traumatic moments in her life, an example of which is the painting Henry Ford Hospital, which depicts her hospitalization in Detroit for miscarriage. Drakulic emphasizes the fact that Kahlo began painting in bed using a mirror suspended above her. In
448
Three features of style are striking in Frida’s Bed, the first being the way point of view slides between third person and first person. The split point of view is an effective stylistic choice to convey the split in Frida’s psyche. She is both observing from the outside (third person) and observing from the inside (first person). So the clever handling of point of view mirrors Frida’s own view of herself, her interior feelings and thoughts and herself as object in a work of art. The second feature of the style is the way sections on the paintings themselves are spliced into the reverie. These analyses of specific paintings are written in third person, a more objective-sounding point of view seemingly quite distant from the third person linked to Frida herself. Drakulic obviously selected the paintings deliberately to link them to certain moments in the artist’s life events, as the artist herself linked them. In this way, the novel mirrors the critical assessment of Kahlo’s oeuvre, tending to interpret her work autobiographically. Kahlo is at the center of her work, and in the novel, these analyses of her art enact that pattern in the art’s reception, pegging image to event. A third stylistic feature is the way time is handled subjectively. Sarah Norris, in her review of the novel, likened it to “a one-woman play,” pointing out how Drakulic “reserves analysis for Kahlo herself, overlaying scenes with internal monologue.” Some readers may miss the smooth handling of time that establishes the present moment as the day Frida dies and the scenes as her interior floating memory of scenes and moments, regrets and unanswered questions. Overlying these reveries is the third-person speaker who couches events in TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Frida’s Bed
interpretation or larger context. Kevin Clouther, in his review, found this handling allowed Drakulic to focus her emphasis regarding the biography: “Unlike other re-imaginings of Kahlo’s life, this novel avoids lingering on the most salacious details of her biography, dignifying instead her pain, her devotion to Rivera, and her startling paintings.”
W Critical Reception A criticism of Frida’s Bed that recurred in many reviews is that the novel covers material that is far from new. Eleanor J. Bader, for example, commented that the novel does not add anything new to the biography. Clouther stated that approaching Kahlo’s art as an expression of her suffering has been done repeatedly. Norris stated outright that “Drakulic’s contribution to material that has been covered extensively, in biographical books and movies, isn’t immediately clear.” But these reviewers also pointed out how Drakulic’s handling is fresh or unusual. For
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Born July 4, 1949, in Rijeka, Croatia, then part of Yugoslavia, Slavenka Drakulic received a BA in comparative literature and sociology from the University of Zagreb (1976). In Zagreb, she worked as a staff writer (1982-1992) for the Start and Danas, both local newspapers, often writing on feminist issues. Drakulic has published articles, novels, and nonfiction and may be best known for her political work, for example, As if I Am Not There (1999), a novel about crimes against Bosnian women during the Balkan war, and They Would Never Hurt a Fly: War Criminals on Trial in The Hague (2005), a fictionalized portrait of genocide and its Serbian perpetrators, especially Slobodan Milosevic. In the 1990s, Drakulic left Croatia for political reasons. As of 2010, she has lived in Stockholm, Sweden; Vienna, Austria; and Zagreb, Croatia.
This photo shows painter Frida Kahlo and her husband, Diego Rivera, two of the main characters in Frida’s Bed. ª Bettmann/Corbis TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
449
Frida’s Bed
example, for Bader, the psychological penetration coupled with the art criticism is original: “What distinguishes the work is Drakulic’s impassioned—albeit imagined— interrogation of the psychological underpinnings of Kahlo’s artistry and daily routines.” Bader also stated that “the novel juxtaposes Kahlo’s first-person psychosocial analysis with art criticism to create something wholly new.” Clouther praised “Drakulic’s attempt to understand Kahlo’s many years of marriage to the oversized artist Diego Rivera” but regretted that “the complexities of their relationship are left messy and maddening, even illogical.” Norris concluded that despite its drawbacks, the novel is “a studied attempt to fill in the gaps of Kahlo’s life with empathy and grace.” The value of the italicized art criticism in the novel was also debated by many reviewers. Clouther was among those who felt it did not work, asserting that “these explorations feel more intrusive than illuminating.” However, Norris saw the device as linked to the novel’s overall strategy: “[Drakulic] pulls the narrative in outlying directions while remaining tethered—on a long leash—to the subject of Frida Kahlo’s paintings.” A review in Publishers Weekly suggested that the paintings fit as an integral part of the life story: “Frida’s paintings move from hobby to burning need, a way to survive his betrayal and her own cursed physicality,” and a review in Kirkus Reviews saw the necessity of linking Frida’s art to her life: “This often-downbeat work includes ample stream-of-consciousness musings and brief examinations of Kahlo’s art, and how it was influenced by her life.” The Kirkus Reviews reviewer may have reflected the conclusion of others by finding that the novel is, in sum, an “elegant portrait of an artist that grants Kahlo a vulnerability and complexity often missing from the kitschy images of her that abound today.”
Additional Resources
BIBLIOGRAPHY
———. S.: A Novel about the Balkans. New York: Penguin Group, 1999. Print. The fourth novel of Drakulic, which tells the story of an unmarried Bosnian woman, a Muslim and the daughter of a Serb, a raped by a Serbian soldier in 1992 and finds herself in a Stockholm hospital giving birth in 1993.
Works Cited
Bader, Eleanor J. “Drakulic, Slavenka. Frida’s Bed.” Rev. of Frida’s Bed, by Slavenka Drakulic. Library Journal 133.19 (2008): 59+. Print. Clouther, Kevin. “Frida’s Bed.” Rev. of Frida’s Bed, by Slavenka Drakulic. Booklist 1 Aug. 2008: 35. Print. Drakulic, Slavenka. Frida’s Bed. Trans. Christina Pribichevich Zoric. New York: Penguin, 2008. Print. “Drakulic, Slavenka: Frida’s Bed.” Rev. of Frida’s Bed, by Slavenka Drakulic. Kirkus Reviews 1 Aug. 2008. Print. “Frida’s Bed.” Rev. of Frida’s Bed, by Slavenka Drakulic. Publishers Weekly 255.30 (2008): 51. Print. Norris, Sarah. “Fiction Review: Frida’s Bed.” Rev. of Frida’s Bed, by Slavenka Drakulic. SFGate.com. San Francisco Chronicle 13 Aug. 2008. Web. 18 Nov. 2010.
450
Criticism and Reviews
Marcus, Richard. “Book Review: Frida’s Bed by Slavenka Drakulic.” Rev. of Frida’s Bed, by Slavenka Drakulic. http://blogs.epicindia.com/leapinthedark Leap in the Dark. 5 Sept. 2008. Web. 18 Nov. 2010. A review from the perspective of a writer with chronic pain, which analyzes the effects of chronic pain and opiate use and how these drive a person to create. “Mexican Autobiography. (Art).” Time 27 Apr. 1953: 92. Print. Coverage of the first and only exhibition Kahlo had in Mexico. Norris, Sarah. “Fiction Review: Frida’s Bed.” Rev. of Frida’s Bed, by Slavenka Drakulic. SFGate.com. San Francisco Chronicle 13 Aug. 2008. Web. 18 Nov. 2010. A long review that evaluates Drakulic’s contribution to well-known material, in part through her connecting the interior life to specific paintings. Open Web Sources
A Web site, titled Frida Kahlo: The Complete Works, available at http://www.frida-kahlo-foundation.org/ biography.html, provides a biography, images of Kahlo’s paintings, and links. “The Real Frida Kahlo,” a collection of short film clips and photographs arranged together as a video, may be found online at various sites. For Further Reading
Drakulic, Slavenka. How We Survived Communism and Even Laughed. New York: HarperCollins, 1991. Print. A portrait of living under communism by the Croatian journalist and various ways she determines the gap between Eastern Europe and the West.
Gilman, Charlotte Perkins. The Yellow Wall-paper and Other Stories. Ed. Robert Shulman. New York: Oxford UP, 1995. Print. The famous title story describing how a woman goes insane by being isolated and kept on strict bed rest. Herrera, Hayden. Frida: A Biography of Frida Kahlo. New York: HarperCollins, 1983. Print. Reissued in 2002, a respected biography of the artist covering her personal life, art, and political beliefs and activities. James, Alice. The Diary of Alice James. Ed. Leon Edel. Boston: Northeastern UP, 1999. Print. Private journal that secured a separate literary place for the TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Frida’s Bed
historically eclipsed sister of two famous brothers, William and Henry James. Koestler, Arthur. Darkness at Noon. New York: Macmillan, 1941. Print. Novel that portrays a communist revolutionary caught in the late 1930s Moscow show trials. Kovic, Ron. Born on the Fourth of July. New York: Akashic Books, 2005. Print. The 1976 memoir of a Vietnam soldier who is severely injured and returns to the United States to protest against the war, all the time coping with the dead weight of his body.
Marnham, Patrick. Dreaming with His Eyes Open: A Life of Diego Rivera. Berkeley: U of California P, 2000. Print. First biography since the 1960s, focusing on Rivera’s work, his financial arrangements, and political beliefs, without allowing attention to Kahlo to overshadow the book’s main subject. Sontag, Susan. Alice in Bed. New York: HarperCollins, 1993. Print. A play that illustrates Sontag’s interest in illness as metaphor as it depicts Alice James’s lifelong physical struggles.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Melodie Monahan
451
Gabriel’s Story By David Anthony Durham
W Introduction Gabriel’s Story (2001) is a reimagining of the Western literary genre from the point of view of an African American teenager named Gabriel Lynch. Gabriel, who was raised in the East, is shocked by the harsh lifestyle of the Kansas frontier, where his family relocates in the late 1870s. Eager to experience life, he and his friend James, another black youth, take off with a group of cowboys led by the charismatic Marshall Hogg and his African American partner, Caleb. Soon, however, Gabriel and James witness atrocities that force them to grow up quickly and leave them longing for home. When an opportunity to escape presents itself, Gabriel embarks on a quest to find his way back to the Kansas home he had so desperately wanted to leave behind. Alternating Gabriel’s tale with the experiences of the family he abandoned on the frontier, David Anthony Durham explores issues of pioneer life, post–Civil War racism (which is directed not just at African Americans but at Native Americans and Mexican Americans as well), and social justice. The critically acclaimed novel won the American Library Association’s 2002 Alex Award, a prize given to works of literature for adults that are also appealing to young adult readers.
W Literary and Historical Context
In the decades following the American Civil War (1861– 1865), thousands of newly freed slaves headed west to seek a new life. The West appealed to many African Americans, largely because racial bigotry was less pronounced on the frontier than in other parts of the United States. In the novel, Gabriel’s stepfather Solomon tells him that “out here, a man ain’t so much fighting against white folks as he is fighting against the land.” Despite such optimism, African American settlers faced unique challenges
stemming from racial bigotry. Many young black men, like Gabriel, saw in the life of the cowboy a chance to experience real freedom and new opportunities. Generically, the novel is fixed in the tradition of Western fiction, a genre that has its roots in the frontier tales of notable American writers such as James Fenimore Cooper (1789–1851). The literary style flourished at the beginning of the nineteenth century, when Zane Grey (1875–1939) popularized a romanticized version of the West, and reached the height of its popularity in the 1960s, when Louis Dearborn L’Amour’s series of more than 100 works capitalized on the popularity of cowboys in American culture. Durham’s innovation in the Western genre is to present frontier life from the perspective of an African American character, reflecting on the unique challenges that minorities faced in the American West.
W Themes Issues of racism and racial injustice are at the forefront of Gabriel’s Story. As African American settlers, Gabriel and his family regularly face bigotry. After a hate-filled farmer prevents the local shopkeeper from selling him the plow blade he desperately needs, Solomon comments, “We’re still finding the course to better things.” It is while traveling with Marshall, however, that Gabriel experiences the most severe and troubling kinds of racism. Although Caleb, a former slave, has achieved status and respect as Marshall’s traveling companion, many of the men traveling with the group repeatedly speak to Gabriel and James in derogatory terms. The increasingly despondent James is ridiculed as a “damn fool nigger” and beaten by one of Marshall’s men. Marshall defends his trust in Gabriel on the grounds that he’s “the faithful dog type” of “nigger.” Racism is also apparent in the men’s reaction to Native Americans. After Marshall and his men refuse to help some native people they encounter because, in Marshall’s words, “they’re the wretched dregs of a wretched race,” Dunlop, another cowboy in the group, reflects that Native
452 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Gabriel’s Story
Americans have “been done a mighty wrong, if you ask me. It’s indecent, is what it is.” Later, as the cowboys pass through New Mexico, they slaughter a Mexican American family and take one of its daughters captive. They subject her to repeated sexual assaults as they travel, justifying the crimes based on the assertion that “Mexicans are the uppitiest sons of bitches next to niggers!” Racial tensions come to a head at the end of the novel when Marshall and Caleb arrive at Gabriel’s home in Kansas, intent on reclaiming the gold that was in the saddlebag of the horse that Gabriel used to escape from the cowboys. Caleb, who has shown little remorse to the group’s victims throughout the novel, unexpectedly kills Marshall in order to save Gabriel’s family.
W Style In addition to being a work of Western fiction, Gabriel’s Story is a bildungsroman, a novel that traces a protagonist’s development into adulthood, usually chronicling the struggles that he or she must overcome. To this end the narration is focused on Gabriel’s experiences, with sections detailing the lives of other characters set in italics. As the story unfolds the young Gabriel is bitter about his mother’s remarriage and the move to Kansas, which has taken him away from city life and his dreams of becoming a doctor. This resentment spurs his decision to leave Kansas with Marshall. What he sees of the world and its cruelty, however, leads not only to his maturation but also to his realization that home and family are of unparalleled value. When he finally reaches home, it is with a new respect for his mother and Solomon and a desire to be a part of their lives on the frontier. While the novel’s plot is typical of a bildungsroman, critics have noted that the author’s narrative talent differentiates it from other works of that genre. Reviewing Gabriel’s Story for the Washington Post, for example, Jabari Asim notes that “Durham’s richly detailed descriptions and imaginative plotting helped to elevate Gabriel’s Story above the humdrum routine of a typical coming-of-age tale.” Bob Minzesheimer’s USA Today review echoes this praise, commenting that “the best of Durham’s descriptions are rooted in the landscape.” As Asim and Minzesheimer point out, Durham describes the landscapes and nature through which his characters pass in poetic detail. As the band of men moves from Texas to New Mexico, for example, they encounter a new landscape in which “the plains stretched to the horizon, spotted by occasional prickly pear and tree cholla, all sharing muted colors that varied little except with the rising and setting of the sun, when that orb played tricks of light across the sand and set colors moving in ribbons.”
W Critical Reception Upon publication Gabriel’s Story garnered widespread critical acclaim. It was named a Notable Book by the
MAJOR CHARACTERS CALEB is Marshall’s traveling companion. Although Marshall does not realize it, he is also his half-brother, the product of Caleb’s mother’s rape by her master. He is known to be both perceptive and quite brutal. He is the one, for example, who is left behind to kill a Mexican American family after Marshall’s men rape and kidnap the family’s daughter. DUNLOP is a cowboy who is originally from Scotland. Like Gabriel and James, he is horrified by the atrocities that the men commit. After he protests the killing of the Mexican American family and the repeated rape of the young woman, he is tied up by the cowboys but manages to escape. He joins the young woman’s brother and helps him seek revenge against Marshall and Caleb. MARSHALL ALEXANDER HOGG is a magnetic cowboy who hires James and Gabriel. He is also a brutal man who kills and steals seemingly without thought. At the end of the novel he is killed by his longtime partner, Caleb. JAMES is a young African American orphan who joins Marshall’s group with Gabriel. He is deeply affected by the cruelty and violence he witnesses and begins to lose touch with reality. When the group plunges into a river to escape Mexican vigilantes, he does not fight the current. Dunlop later finds his body and buries him. BEN LYNCH is Gabriel’s younger brother, who is forced to grow up quickly after his brother leaves the homestead. His hard work helps the family survive on the frontier. ELIZA LYNCH is the mother of Gabriel and Ben. After her relatively prosperous husband died, she married Solomon, a man she had known while both were slaves. At the story’s conclusion she explains to Gabriel that she can understand the horrors he has witnessed because she has experienced similar atrocities firsthand. GABRIEL LYNCH is a young African American man who once dreamed of becoming a physician. Resenting his mother’s remarriage, he leaves the family’s homestead in Kansas to travel with a group of cowboys led by Marshall. After the group is separated in a frantic flight from a band of vigilantes who are pursuing them, he flees on Marshall’s horse and makes his way back home.
New York Times and was chosen for the Booklist Editors’ Choice list. In addition to the Alex Award, the novel received the 2001 First Novel Award from the Black Caucus of the American Library Association and the 2002 Legacy Award for Debut Fiction from the Hurston/Wright Foundation. In his review of the novel for Book, Tom LeClair describes Gabriel’s Story as “a morally complicated, socially nuanced story of American violence and its discontents. Told with great economy and restraint, it is a very promising debut.”
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
453
Gabriel’s Story
In Gabriel’s Story, Gabriel Lynch and his family set off in 1871 for the Kansas frontier with a group of other settlers. American Stock Archive/Getty Images
Not all reviews of the novel were entirely positive. Paul Spillenger, writing for the Washington Post, suggests that the book is a “concatenation of cliches from start to finish.” Most criticism of the novel, however, was tempered with praise. Maria Russo notes in the New York Times Book Review that “aspects of the plot don’t quite make sense,” that “some of its machinations strain credibility,” and that “the novel’s often exalted portrayal of women as purehearted repositories of all that is good and true almost calls to mind second-rate Victorian fiction.” Despite this, Russo ultimately concludes that the book is “both artistically impressive and emotionally satisfying, a serious work that heads off in exhilarating directions.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Durham, David Anthony. Gabriel’s Story. New York: Doubleday, 2001. Print. LeClair, Tom. Rev. of Gabriel’s Story, by David Anthony Durham. Book Mar. 2001: 74. Minzesheimer, Bob. “Young Cowboy Seeks Spiritual Path in Wild West.” Rev. of Gabriel’s Story, by David Anthony Durham. USA Today 18 Jan. 2001: 6D. Print. Russo, Maria. “Growing Up with the Country: In This First Novel, a Black Teenager Comes of Age on the American Frontier.” Rev. of Gabriel’s Story, by David Anthony Durham. New York Times Book Review 25 Feb. 2001: 7. Spillenger, Paul. “First Novels, Lasting Lessons.” Washington Post 8 Jan. 2001: C5. Print.
Works Cited
Additional Resources
Asim, Jabari. “Liberated Promise.” Rev. of Gabriel’s Story, by David Anthony Durham. Washington Post 16 July 2002: C03. Print.
Criticism and Reviews
454
Burns, Ann, and Emily Joy Jones. Rev. of Gabriel’s Story, by David Anthony Durham. Library Journal TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Gabriel’s Story
1 Nov. 2000: 101. A short review offering an overview of the novel’s plot. Franscell, Ron. “The Rough Ride Home for an AfricanAmerican Cowboy.” Rev. of Gabriel’s Story, by David Anthony Durham. Christian Science Monitor 25 Jan. 2001: 18. Print. A positive critique that focuses on the novel’s attention to character and its coming-of-age plot. Rev. of Gabriel’s Story, by David Anthony Durham. Booklist 1 Jan. 2002: 761. A short review that likens the novel to the work of notable Western author Cormac McCarthy. Rev. of Gabriel’s Story, by David Anthony Durham. New York Times Book Review 3 June 2001: 24. A review emphasizing the uniqueness of Gabriel’s character and his status as an outsider. Rev. of Gabriel’s Story, by David Anthony Durham. Publishers Weekly 4 Dec. 2000: 54. A critique that lauds Durham’s prose style as well as his multicultural take on the traditional Western genre. Hopkins, Natalie. “Novel Treads on New Terrain with Odyssey of Black Youth.” Washington Post 3 May 2001: T23. Print. An overview of the novel as well as the author’s reflections on his work. Smothers, Bonnie. Rev. of Gabriel’s Story, by David Anthony Durham. Booklist 15 Dec. 2000: 788. A review highlighting the work’s multicultural perspective and the power of its carefully developed plot.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR David Anthony Durham was born in New York City on March 23, 1969. He spent his childhood in Maryland and attended the University of Maryland, Baltimore County, where he discovered his passion for writing. While still in college he won the 1990 Malcolm C. Braly Award for Fiction for his short story “August Fury.” Two years later another short story, “The Boy-Fish,” garnered the Hurston/Wright Fiction Award. In 1994 Durham entered graduate school at the University of Maryland in College Park. He wrote two unpublished novels while he was still a student and completed an MFA in 1996. After graduating, Durham moved to Great Britain and published several short stories. He then relocated to France, where he composed Gabriel’s Song in 1999. The author followed up on the success of his first novel with Walk through Darkness (2003); Pride of Carthage (2006); Acacia: The War with the Mein (2007); and Acacia: The Other Lands (2009), all of which were critically acclaimed. He currently lives with his wife and children in western Massachusetts. In addition to writing, Durham teaches at the Stonecoast low-residency MFA program.
novel traces the experiences of a fugitive slave and the man who is tracking him. Durham, Philip. The Negro Cowboys. New York: Dodd, 1965. Print. This nonfiction volume examines the lives of the often-forgotten African American cowboys who contributed to the settling of the West.
Open Web Sources
Gibson, Rob. Plaids & Bandanas: From Highland Drover to Wildwest Cowboy. Edinburgh: Luath, 2003. Print. Gibson’s work of nonfiction considers the lives of Scottish citizens who, like the fictional Dunlop, found a new life as cowboys on the American frontier.
The author’s official Web site offers a brief summary of the novel, as well as a biographical sketch, excerpts from his other works, and a blog. http://www .davidanthonydurham.com/novels/gabriels.html
Jakes, John. A Century of Great Western Stories: An Anthology. New York: Forge, 2000. Print. This collection brings together short pieces of fiction from the Western genre.
The blog Neth Space features an interview with David Anthony Durham in which the author discusses his Acacia series. http://nethspace.blogspot.com/2007/ 08/david-anthony-durham-answers-questions.html
Katz, William Loren. Black Pioneers: An Untold Story. New York: Atheneum Books for Young Readers, 1999. Print. Katz’s volume of nonfiction explores the experiences of African Americans who settled in the American West.
Gale Resources
“David Anthony Durham.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2009.
The Handbook of Texas Online includes an article on black cowboys and their role in the early history of Texas. http://www.tshaonline.org/handbook/ online/articles/BB/arb1.html For Further Reading
McCarthy, Cormac. All the Pretty Horses. New York: Knopf, 1992. Print. This bildungsroman is the first novel in the popular Border Trilogy by McCarthy. Durham’s work has frequently been compared with that of McCarthy.
Durham, David Anthony. Walk through Darkness. New York: Doubleday, 2002. Print. Durham’s second
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Greta Gard
455
Galileo’s Dream By Kim Stanley Robinson
W Introduction Kim Stanley Robinson’s Galileo’s Dream (2009) is both a biographical account of the most productive years of experimentation in the life of seventeenth-century scientist Galileo Galilei and a science fiction tale about thirty-firstcentury human colonists on the Galilean moons of Jupiter. Robinson likes to explore ideas about the human comprehension of time, and, in writing Galileo’s Dream, he looked at time in the context of quantum mechanics as some characters try to change both the past and the future. What emerges from this story is an understanding that time is not fixed and immutable but individual spirit may be. Robinson is a multiple-award-winning author most famous for his Mars trilogy, beginning with Red Mars (1992). He has won two Hugo Awards, two Nebula Awards, a World Fantasy Award, six Locus Awards, a John W. Campbell Award, and a British Science Fiction Association Award for his short and long fiction, marking him as a major voice in the field of science fiction and fantasy literature. Given that he often writes about history (The Years of Rice and Salt) and utopias (Pacific Edge), some critics have commented that his work should have appeal beyond the narrow audience of science fiction.
W Literary and Historical Context
The title of Robinson’s novel, Galileo’s Dream, is a reference to Johannes Kepler (1571-1630), the German astronomer who wrote a book called Somnium, published posthumously in 1634, although drafts were widely circulated during his lifetime. Somnium, translated as The Dream, is ostensibly a description of planetary movement but set within a fictional account of a man who travels to the moon. In Robinson’s novel, Galileo
laughs at Kepler for his imagination about what—and who—might be out there in space, which seems ironic given Galileo’s excursions to Jupiter. Kepler and Galileo were part of the scientific revolution, a period of marked growth in foundational scientific knowledge spurred by the 1543 publication of Nicolaus Copernicus’s On the Revolutions of the Heavenly Spheres. Copernicus’s heliocentric theory placed the sun at the center of celestial movement rather than Earth, a theory that the Catholic Church viewed as heretical. Galileo’s telescope observations supported Copernicus. Late in life, Galileo was found guilty of heresy for writing in support of heliocentrism. It was Galileo’s use of experimentation that further established the scientific method for research and learning, which continued the scientific revolution. With the rigors of the scientific method, subsequent scientists such as Isaac Newton, Blaise Pascal, and Benjamin Franklin were able to advance human understanding of natural phenomena.
W Themes Galileo’s Dream explores the concepts of fate and free will. The age-old debate of fate versus free will concerns whether a person’s life is predetermined to be what it becomes or whether individuals control their future by the choices they freely make. In Robinson’s novel, Galileo attempts to divert his fate from burning at the stake for heresy after being warned of this future by Hera, a resident of the Jovian moon Io from the thirty-first century. Ganymede, also from the future, tries to hasten Galileo’s martyrdom to further his own goals. For Robinson, the debate over fate versus free will cannot be resolved with a simple answer because time is not simple or linear. Time is the context in which fate or free will exists. Robinson describes the passage of time as a “river mouth, with braiding channels, each one of which is a kind of reality, or a potentiality” (292). The novel explores this concept of multiple dimensions or
456 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Galileo’s Dream
MAJOR CHARACTERS AURORA, a humanlike artificial intelligence from Europa in the thirty-first century, helps Galileo learn the scientific advancements of the past fourteen hundred years. MAFFEO BARBERINI is a clever man and a fan of Galileo’s work but changes dramatically after he becomes Pope Urban VIII. CARTOPHILUS is a time-and-space traveler from Ganymede’s time who works in Galileo’s household and assists with his trips to Jupiter’s moons. GALILEO GALILEI, the central character of the novel, is an extraordinarily talented mathematician and inventor living in early-seventeenth-century Italy. GANYMEDE, a righteous cult leader from the moon Ganymede in the thirty-first century, brings Galileo through time and space to further his own goals. HERA, resident of Io in the thirty-first century and Ganymede’s enemy, helps Galileo avoid his fate of burning at the stake.
In part, Galileo’s Dream examines the real-life accomplishments of renowned seventeenth-century scientist Galileo Galilei, pictured here. Georgios Kollidas/Shutterstock.com
potentialities. Galileo works to gain friends in high places only to have his friends die, his enemies ascend to power, and his own ignorance of worldly politics work against him. All of which gives the impression that Galileo’s personality—irascible, obsessed, exceedingly intelligent, and a know-it-all—works against him regardless. Robinson argues that Galileo, forewarned of his martyrdom, is able to mitigate his fate into house arrest, an argument for a middle ground in the fate versus free will debate. In a sublime moment of insight about how time works, Galileo realizes: “Everything was always changing, always: so it was change itself that was eternal” (393). Time, which is not linear, contains the existence of many Galileos.
W Style Imagery is descriptive language used by an author to convey a subject through sensory detail. Imagery makes scenes, characters, and events more vivid and engaging for the reader, even if what is being described is fantastical. Robinson describes Galileo’s joy of discovery as “his body ringing” like a bell (31). He describes the colors of Jupiter and its moons when Galileo travels to the planet in the future. Jupiter is shades of orange, yellow, and red and attracts quiet contemplation. Europa is cold and icy with weaker gravity than Earth and appears
MARIA CELESTE, also known as Virginia, is Galileo’s beloved daughter whom he commits to a nunnery because she is illegitimate and, therefore, unmarriageable.
in shades of blue and green. Europa’s capital city, Rhadamanthas Linea with its canals and balconies, reminds Galileo of Venice. Io is yellow and its lumpy sulfurous surface looks exactly like Galileo imagines hell would appear, which makes it a forbidding place. Robinson uses allusion to add depth of meaning to his novel. Galileo’s Dream includes allusions to Hera, the wife of Zeus, who is a major character and someone Galileo comes to love; Ganymede, the lover of Zeus, who is detested by Hera both in the novel and in the mythology; and the title of the book, which is an allusion to Johannes Kepler’s Somnium.
W Critical Reception Robinson wrote the highly acclaimed, multiple awardwinning Mars trilogy: Red Mars (1992), Green Mars (1993), and Blue Mars (1996). Reviewing for the Guardian, Adam Roberts praised Galileo’s Dream as “thought-provoking and moving in equal measure.” For him, Robinson is one of the best science fiction writers in the world, and Galileo’s Dream lives up to Robinson’s standard of excellence. “Elegant, charming, funny and profound, Galileo’s Dream is magnifico,” Roberts concluded. Jackie Cassada in Library Journal called the novel a “masterwork,” predicting that it will expand “the potential of the genre to reach out to a broad audience.” Cassada’s review underlined
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
457
Galileo’s Dream
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Kim Stanley Robinson was born in Waukegan, Illinois, in 1952, and grew up in Southern California. He graduated with a BA in literature from the University of California in San Diego in 1974 and earned his MA in English from Boston University in 1975. Robinson returned to San Diego for his PhD, which he earned in 1982 with a thesis on the works of Philip K. Dick. Robinson married Lisa Howland Nowell in 1982, and with her had two sons. He published his first novel, The Wild Shore, in 1984 and went on to win many prestigious science fiction awards, including two Hugo Awards for Best Novel and two Nebula Awards. As of 2010, Robinson lived in Santa Ana, California, with his family.
Robinson’s blending of historical fiction and science fiction, a technique that has also been employed, as other critics have observed, by mainstreams authors
such as Joyce Carol Oates, but without the perceived stigma that the label science fiction can sometimes convey. Paul Kincaid took a rare negative position in his review of Galileo’s Dream for the Web site SF Site. Kincaid observed that the historical part of the novel is richly detailed and Galileo’s character fully realized, whereas the science fiction portions are not as well articulated and distract from the building drama in Galileo’s life. Kincaid wrote: “It is the science fiction that makes this novel weak, it is the history that makes it strong.” In a long review for the online science fiction literature magazine Strange Horizons, John Clute discussed the reliability of the narrator in Galileo’s Dream, which makes the science fiction element crucial to the story’s success. Clute concluded that the character “Galileo is a stunning creation, a histrion utterly real to the eye, a porridge of sensation who turns on a dime into icon.” Robinson also won over Michelle West, critic for the Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction, who professed at the beginning of her review that while she generally found Robinson’s work to be “cerebral” and
Much of Galileo’s Dream takes place in the future on the Galilean moons of Jupiter. Stasys Eidiejus/Shutterstock.com
458
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Galileo’s Dream
“unapproachable,” she unequivocally found this book to be different. She concluded: “if a book can be said, without pretension, to be profound, it is Galileo’s Dream.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Spinrad, Norman. “On Books.” Rev. of Galileo’s Dream, by Kim Stanley Robinson. www.asimovs.com. Asimov’s Science Fiction Oct.-Nov. 2010. Web. 15 Sept. 2010. Positively reviews Robinson’s novel but takes exception to the imbalance of detail between Italy and the Galilean moons.
Works Cited
Cassada, Jackie. “Robinson, Kim Stanley. Galileo’s Dream.” Rev. of Galileo’s Dream, by Kim Stanley Robinson. Library Journal 15 Nov. 2009: 59. Print. Clute, John. “Scores.” www.strangehorizons.com. Strange Horizons 18 Jan. 2010. Web. 15 Sept. 2010. Kincaid, Paul. “Galileo’s Dream.” Rev. of Galileo’s Dream, by Kim Stanley Robinson. www.sfsite.com. SF Site 2010. Web. 15 Sept. 2010. Roberts, Adam. “Kim Stanley Robinson’s Galileo’s Dream.” Rev. of Galileo’s Dream, by Kim Stanley Robinson. Guardian 15 Aug. 2009: 8. Print.
Gale Resources
“Kim Stanley Robinson.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Literature Resource Center. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. http://go.galegroup.com/ps/ i.do?&id=GALE%7CH1000083750&v=2.1& u=aadl&it=r&p=LitRC&sw=w “Kim Stanley Robinson.” Contemporary Literary Criticism. Vol. 248. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Literature Resource Center. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. http://go. galegroup.com/ps/i.do?&id=GALE% 7CH1119780000&v=2.1&u=aadl&it= r&p=LitRC&sw=w
West, Michelle. “Musing on Books.” Rev. of Galileo’s Dream, by Kim Stanley Robinson. www.sfsite.com/fsf/. Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction May-June 2010. Web. 15 Sept. 2010.
“Robinson, Kim Stanley 1952–.” Contemporary Authors, New Revision Series. Ed. Amanda D. Sams. Vol. 173. Detroit: Gale, 2008. 328-35. Gale Virtual Reference Library. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. http://go.galegroup.com/ps/i.do?&id= GALE%7CCX3070600120&v=2.1&u= itsbtrial&it=r&p=GVRL&sw=w
Additional Resources
Open Web Sources
Criticism and Reviews
MangalaWiki is an online encyclopedia dedicated to the works of Kim Stanley Robinson. This extensive Web site has a biography, bibliography, and detailed information about all of Robinson’s novels and collections and even some of his novellas and short stories. MangalaWiki is available at http://www .kimstanleyrobinson.info/w/index.php5?title=Main_ Page
Robinson, Kim Stanley. Galileo’s Dream. New York: Ballantine, 2009. Print.
Canavan, Gerry. “What Our Writers Are Reading: Galileo’s Dream.” Rev. of Galileo’s Dream, by Kim Stanley Robinson. www.indyweek.com. Indy Week 23 Dec. 2009. Web. 15 Sept. 2010. Commends Robinson’s treatment of a future utopia in this novel. Emsley, Iain. “Weft Counting.” Rev. of Galileo’s Dream, by Kim Stanley Robinson. januarymagazine.com. January Magazine Sept. 2009. Web. 15 Sept. 2010. Applauds Robinson’s realistic and sympathetic portrayal of Galileo and the travails of the future. Rev. of Galileo’s Dream, by Kim Stanley Robinson. Publishers Weekly 30 Nov. 2009: 33. Print. Praises Robinson’s blended narrative of the past and the future. Kaveney, Roz. “Galileo’s Dream, by Kim Stanley Robinson.” Rev. of Galileo’s Dream, by Kim Stanley Robinson. www.independent.co.uk. Independent 10 Aug. 2009. Web. 15 Sept. 2010. Admires Robinson’s risk-taking in making an egotistical historical figure a sympathetic protagonist. Silver, Steven H. “Galileo’s Dream.” Rev. of Galileo’s Dream, by Kim Stanley Robinson. www.sfsite.com. SF Site 2010. Web. 15 Sept. 2010. Celebrates Robinson’s treatment of Galileo’s life interwoven with future politics of science.
Robinson’s publisher, Random House, maintains an author Web site with links to many of his books, which are available for browsing and full-text search as well as purchase. Robinson’s Random House Web site is available at http://www.randomhouse.com/ author/results.pperl?authorid=25839 For Further Reading
Henry, John. The Scientific Revolution and the Origins of Modern Science. 3rd ed. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2008. Print. Examines the scientific revolution from the fourteenth through the seventeenth centuries. Kepler, Johannes. Kepler’s Somnium: The Dream or Posthumous Work on Lunar Astronomy. Trans. Edward Rosen. Mineola: Dover, 2003. Print. From 1634, describes planetary movement within a fantastical narrative about a journey to the moon.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
459
Galileo’s Dream
Robinson, Kim Stanley. The Years of Rice and Salt. New York: Spectra, 2003. Print. Explores an alternative history in which Europe is dominated by Asia with reincarnation as a unifying storytelling element.
Stephenson, Neal. Anathem. New York: Harper Perennial, 2010. Print. Addresses the many-worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics in a science fiction novel.
Sís, Peter. Starry Messenger: Galileo Galilei. New York: Scholastic, 1997. Print. Presents an illustrated biography of the life and work of the seventeenth-century scientist.
460
Carol Ullmann
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Garden of Beasts By Jeffery Deaver
W Introduction Jeffery Deaver was widely known for producing several successful crime novel series featuring likable detectives and well-regarded storytelling when, in 2004, he surprised his fans by publishing Garden of Beasts, a historical thriller set primarily in Berlin in 1936, at a pivotal point in Adolf Hitler’s rise to power. As Garden of Beasts begins, readers are introduced to German American Paul Schumann, a World War I veteran who distinguished himself in combat with his excellent marksmanship and his ability to compartmentalize his emotions. Back in New York City after the war, Schumann opens a boxing gym and occasionally works as a freelance sports writer, but he earns extra money by performing contract killing for Mafia bosses. During one hit, it becomes apparent that he has been set up, and he finds himself given a choice by prosecutor Tom Dewey and the head of Naval Intelligence James Gordon: travel to Germany disguised as a sports journalist covering the 1936 Berlin Olympics and assassinate Reinhard Ernst, Hitler’s head of German rearmament, or go to prison and face the death penalty. Schumann accepts the assignment in Berlin, only to find himself involved in a series of double-crosses and hidden agendas. But in witnessing the brutality of the Nazi regime firsthand, he also comes to understand that his mission entails far more than just staying out of prison. Garden of Beasts won the Crime Writers Association’s Ian Fleming Steel Dagger Award in 2004. Rosemary Herbert, book review editor for the Boston Herald, noted Deaver’s nuanced portrait of his characters in Garden of Beasts: “Deaver ups the emotional ante by making the villains and the hero complex characters. The Nazis he portrays here are more than evil personified while the hero has a decidedly criminal past. The idea is to have readers feel for both sides
when the characters are pitted against each other in a lifeand-death crisis.”
W Literary and Historical Context
The historical setting of Garden of Beasts is the 1936 Berlin Olympics, often called the “Nazi Olympics.” Berlin had won the bid to host the 1936 Summer Olympics in 1931, two years before Hitler was named chancellor of Germany in 1933. By 1936 the Nazis been openly persecuting Jews, and the myth of the superiority of the Aryan “race” had been perpetuated among Germans since the election of Hitler to office. Knowing Germany would receive international press during the Olympic games, Hitler reluctantly agreed to remove temporarily all anti-Semitic propaganda from Berlin, but he blocked German-Jewish athletes from competing. Initially, Hitler’s plan was to ban all Jews from competing in the games, but international pressure would not allow it. The United States seriously considered boycotting the games in protest of Nazi racial policies—which were by that time widely known—but the effort failed, and American athletes, including legendary African American track and field star Jesse Owens, won a total of fifty-six medals, second only to the host country’s eighty-nine. The Nazis’ success in hosting a major international event increased the wave of German nationalism and, for a brief time, created the illusion of a justifiably proud but peaceful country. According to the online exhibit “The Nazi Olympics: Berlin 1936,” curated by the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum, “Having rejected a proposed boycott of the 1936 Olympics, the United States and other Western democracies missed the opportunity to take a stand that contemporary observers claimed might have restrained Hitler and bolstered international resistance to the Nazis. After the Olympics, Germany’s expansionism and the persecution of Jews and
461 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Garden of Beasts
MAJOR CHARACTERS TOM DEWEY is an ambitious Manhattan prosecutor who offers Schumann the deal to go to Germany on assignment or risk the death penalty. REINHARD ERNST is the head of the German rearmament program under Adolf Hitler’s Nazi regime. A family man of ambiguous morality, Ernst is caught between wanting to make himself Hitler’s right-hand man and his wariness of Nazism. JAMES GORDON is head of Naval Intelligence. Along with Dewey and an American senator, he recognizes Schumann as the ideal candidate to infiltrate the international press corps of the Berlin Olympics. WILLI KOHL is a German police detective who is committed to his job but deeply ambivalent about the Nazi fanaticism he sees increasing around him. PAUL SCHUMANN is a World War I veteran and part-time hit man in New York City who is tapped to travel to Berlin during the 1936 Olympics to assassinate Reinhard Ernst, the head of Adolf Hitler’s rearmament program.
other ‘enemies of the state’ accelerated, culminating in World War II and the Holocaust.”
W Themes In an interview on Bookreporter.com, Deaver explained that he was inspired to write Garden of Beasts by the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001. “I wanted to write a book with a different villain—basically, pure evil, institutionalized evil, rather than your typical hit man or serial killer . . . I liked the Olympics as an image because of the stark irony: There was Hitler putting on a show for world harmony while at the same time preparing for war and murdering thousands of opponents in the early concentration camps.” The apparent contradiction between appearance and reality is one of the central themes of Garden of Beasts, exemplified by the characterization of the three main figures in the book. According to a review by John Orr in the Sunday Gazette-Mail, Paul Schumann, Reinhard Ernst, and German police inspector Willi Kohl—investigating the murder of what appears to be a member of the SS and on Schumann’s trail—all are depicted sympathetically, despite the Nazi connections of the latter two. While Schumann is a hit man in New York, he follows a strict code of killing only those who deserve to be punished for their transgressions—mainly, mob bosses. Kohl, Orr writes, is a “gifted detective” who “must deal with Nazi fanatics and members of other
462
police agencies more interested in politics than in finding out who killed the man in the alley.” And even the fictional Nazi rearmament specialist whom Schumann is sent to kill, Ernst, is shown in scenes with his wife and children that serve to humanize him. Schumann discovers, as well, during his time in Berlin that the façade of Olympic glory embraced by the Nazis conceals disturbingly evil motives, and nothing is as it appears.
W Style Deaver is first and foremost a writer of thrillers, regardless of their historical backdrop. His works all follow an established pattern and style, including Garden of Beasts, widely categorized as a historical thriller. The historical thriller is a subgenre of the thriller, the hallmarks of which include red herrings, plot twists, and fast-paced action scenes. Historical thrillers place those elements in the past, usually mixing real and fictional characters and attempting to paint an accurate picture of a specific time period while focusing on a single, potentially explosive, event.
W Critical Reception Garden of Beasts was well received by critics and readers. While Deaver was aware that it represented a departure from his more typical publications, he sought to deliver, above all, a quality thriller. Deaver told CBS’s Early Show: “Garden of Beasts is typical of my thrillers. It takes place over about 48 hours—lots of twists and turns, big surprise ending, and yet, another surprise ending, on the last two pages, yet another big whammy ending.” According to John Orr, regular readers of Deaver’s thrillers might at first be put off by the ample historical background Deaver provides in Garden of Beasts: “There is not the razor’s edge of creepiness that puts adrenaline in the blood of readers, as in Deaver’s earlier books. Those fans may have to work a little harder to get into this book, but Garden of Beasts will reward the effort.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
“Author Talk.” Bookreporter.com July 2004. Web. 14 Aug. 2010. Herbert, Rosemary. “Deaver’s Latest Novel Enters ‘Garden’ of Evil.” Boston Herald 8 Aug. 2004. Print. Morales, Tatiana. “Garden of Beasts; Jeffery Deaver’s Novel Set in Nazi Germany.” The Early Show 20 July 2004. Web. 14 Aug. 2010. “The Nazi Olympics: Berlin 1936.” United States Holocaust Memorial Museum. Web. 14 Aug. 2010. Orr, John. “Where Evil Hides: Garden of Beasts Lacks Jeffery Deaver’s Trademark Creepiness, but It Has Nazis.” Sunday Gazette-Mail 22 Aug. 2004. Print. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Garden of Beasts Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Laing, Allan. “Wicked Games; Jeffery Deaver Ponders Evil at the Berlin Olympics but, Says Allan Laing, His Novel Is a Thriller Not a History Lesson.” Herald, 4 Sept. 2004. Print. Interview in which Deaver discusses Garden of Beasts. Open Web Sources
Jeffery Deaver’s official Web site, http://www.jeffery deaver. com, contains brief descriptions of his work, excerpts from his books and short stories, and several related links. For Further Reading
Large, David Clay. Nazi Games: The Olympics of 1936. New York: Norton, 2007. Print. Discusses how the 1936 Olympic Games changed the course of Germany, and world history, by successfully disseminating Nazi propaganda across the globe.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Jeffery Deaver was born in Glen Ellyn, Illinois, in 1950. He received a journalism degree from the University of Missouri, followed by a law degree from Fordham University. Deaver practiced law before deciding to devote himself to writing fiction full time. While an attorney, during long commutes to his office, Deaver began to write suspense novels, the type of fiction he enjoyed reading most. His novels have won many awards in the United States, the United Kingdom, and Japan, including the Crime Writers Association of Great Britain’s Ian Fleming Steel Dagger Award for Garden Of Beasts in 2004. His novel The Bone Collector was adapted as a feature film in 1999, and his novels have been translated into more than thirty-five languages.
Nancy Dziedzic
Spectators gather at a stadium during the 1936 Olympic Games, which were held in Berlin, Germany. In Deaver’s Garden of Beasts, hit man Paul Schumann goes undercover at the 1936 Olympics as part of a plot to assassinate a Nazi official. ª INTERFOTO / Alamy
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
463
The Garden of Last Days By Andre Dubus III
W Introduction The Garden of Last Days (2008) begins on an early September night in 2001, in Florida. April, a stripper, is on her way to work at the Puma Club for men. April’s landlady Jean, who usually babysits three-year-old Franny, is in the hospital, so April has decided to bring her daughter to the club, where she can watch children’s videos in the office while her mother works. April quickly gets caught up with an unusual foreign client, whose name is Bassam. He has a great deal of money, all in cash, and he is extremely free with it, demanding private time with April. But while she is in the Champagne Room with Bassam, Franny gets scared and wanders out of the office looking for her mother. Meanwhile, another client, A. J., drunk and angry, is in the car park, having been thrown out of the club for holding hands with his favorite stripper. He has been denied access to his own beloved small son, and when he spots Franny alone and crying, he decides to take action, with disastrous results. The Garden of Last Days is a tense psychological thriller, which brilliantly illuminates an aspect of the period leading up to the terrorist attacks on the World Trade Center towers on September 11, 2001. Told from several different perspectives, the novel compassionately shows the underlying humanity of a group of flawed individuals.
W Literary and Historical Context
The Garden of Last Days takes place in the few days immediately before the attacks on the World Trade Center in New York City. On the morning of September 11, 2001, nineteen al-Qaeda terrorists hijacked four commercial passenger planes. Two of the airliners were
intentionally crashed into the Twin Towers of the World Trade Center. Everyone on board was killed, and many others who were working in the buildings also died. Another plane crashed into the Pentagon, near Washington, D.C., and a fourth crashed into a field in Pennsylvania. Overall, the attacks are estimated to have claimed nearly three thousand victims. The identity of the attackers was quickly established by the Federal Bureau of Investigation. Mohamed Atta, from Egypt, was the ringleader of the nineteen hijackers. Fifteen of the hijackers were from Saudi Arabia, two from the United Arab Emirates, one from Egypt (Atta), and one from Lebanon. Responsibility for instigating and planning the attacks was claimed by Osama bin Laden, a prominent Saudi Arabian terrorist and founder of the Islamic extremist organization al-Qaeda. Prior to the attacks, several of the hijackers spent time in Jacksonville, Florida, where they stayed at the Ramada Inn. While they were there, they are known to have visited strip clubs and to have purchased pornographic videos and used the services of prostitutes. Doing so was breaking strict Islamic law, and a sin for these Muslim fundamentalists who were about to die for their faith, having been promised the pleasures of eager virgins in heaven.
W Themes A major theme of The Garden of Last Days concerns extremist Islamic fundamentalism and its results. Bassam is shown to be a rather naive young man, who, despite the warnings of his father, a good-hearted moderate Muslim, has been recruited by an extreme terrorist organization. The incentive that has persuaded him to die for his faith is the promise of heavenly rewards after death in the shape of willing and beautiful young virgins. But during the waiting period before the attacks, Bassam and his fellow hijackers indulge in supposedly sinful activities involving alcohol and sex.
464 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Garden of Last Days
MAJOR CHARACTERS BASSAM AL-JIZANI, a young man from Saudi Arabia, is recruited as a suicide attacker by an Islamic terrorist organization. He visits the Puma Club and pays large sums of money for a private session with April. A. J. CAREY has been frequenting the Puma Club after being unwillingly separated from his wife and child. He decides to rescue Franny when he finds her alone and frightened. DEENA CAREY is A. J.’s estranged wife and the mother of his son Cole. APRIL CONNORS is a single mother who works as a stripper in the Puma Club. She is saving money to buy a house for herself and her three-year-old daughter Franny. FRANNY CONNORS, April’s daughter, wanders off after being left in the office at the Puma Club and is found by A. J. Carey. JEAN HANSON, April’s elderly widowed landlady, who is in poor health, is deeply attached to Franny, for whom she normally babysits while April is at work. LONNIE PIKE, intelligent but severely dyslexic, is a bouncer at the Puma Club and is in love with April.
In The Garden of Last Days, April’s young daughter, Franny, wanders alone outside of the strip club. ª David McGlynn / Alamy
Closely linked to this theme is that of sex and sexuality versus marital and parental love. April tolerates her degrading job as a stripper because she sees it as a way of securing a permanent home for herself and her muchloved small daughter. A. J., depressed and angry after the breakup of his marriage and his separation from his adored son, takes refuge in the strip club and develops a crush on one of the strippers. Bassam, the product of a loving family, becomes obsessed with the forbidden temptations of Western sexuality. A third important theme of the novel is the underlying humanity of characters who may initially appear morally culpable. A. J., angry and drunk, abducts a child in the belief that he is rescuing her from a worse fate. April could easily be judged as a bad parent for taking her child to the club, but she is a loving mother who only wants the best for Franny. Lonnie, whose job as a bouncer often entails violence, genuinely loves April and wants nothing more than to help her and care for her. And Bassam, despite the terrible commitment he has made to his faith, is shown to be a confused young man, torn between his religious beliefs and his more human urges.
W Style The Garden of Last Days is divided into a number of short chapters. These are all narrated in the third person, each from the point of view of a single character. Most of the chapters are in the past tense, but those that focus on Bassam are in the present tense. Despite the third-person narration, the novel closely follows the thought processes of the separate characters. They replay conversations in their heads, worry about the future, watch the world around them, experience anger, confusion, anxiety, and fear according to their individual circumstances. The prose style of the novel is intimate, idiomatic, and conversational. Much of the action is described through the observational gaze of the characters, and some attempt is made to differentiate between the styles of their chapters, as when Franny, for example, sees the world through the innocent eyes of a three-year-old. The most distinctive chapters are those of Bassam. Written in stilted English into which Arabic phrases are closely interwoven, they give a telling picture of his thoughts and motivations.
W Critical Reception The Garden of Last Days was greeted with enthusiasm by many reviewers. John Dufresne, writing in the Boston
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
465
The Garden of Last Days
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Born in Oceanside, California, in 1959, Andre Dubus III grew up on the Massachusetts-New Hampshire border. He graduated from the University of Texas at Austin with a BA in sociology and began writing fiction soon afterward, at the age of twentytwo. He worked as a self-employed carpenter and a college writing teacher. His novel House of Sand and Fog was made into an Academy Award-nominated motion picture. He is a member of a large literary family, and his father, the late Andre Dubus Jr., was a prize-winning novelist and short story writer. As of 2010 Andre Dubus III lived in Massachusetts with his wife, performer Fontaine Dollas Dubus, and their three children.
Globe, called it “storytelling of the finest kind: unforgettable and desperate characters caught up in a plot thundering toward catastrophe.” In the Guardian, Irvine Welsh praised Dubus’s writing style, describing it as “that missing link between the high literary novel and the superior thriller” and wrote that “tension and confusion are wrought from every spare yet evocative sentence.” The prose was also admired by James Gibbons, who wrote in the Los Angeles Times that the writing style often achieved “a vivid, muscular immediacy.” Not all reviewers agreed, however. Several reviews of The Garden of Last Days compared the novel unfavorably to Andre Dubus III’s previous best-selling novel, House of Sand and Fog (1999). Doug Johnstone, writing in the Independent, argued that the plot was sprawling and uneven and suggested that this was owing to two different plot lines that were never fully integrated. Although he acknowledged Dubus’s skill in getting inside the heads of ordinary lower-class Americans, he believed this was not enough to save “this unwieldy and uneven novel.” Jay McInerney, in the New York Times, was not impressed by the writing style, regretting that “the rich specificity of the prose in Dubus’s previous novel is seldom on display.” Overall, however, despite the slight disappointment expressed in some reviews, reviewers generally agreed that Dubus is a writer of real talent for empathy toward characters who are made to appear better than their actions might suggest. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Dubus, Andre, III. The Garden of Last Days. New York: Norton, 2002. Print. Dufresne, John. “The Wanderers.” Rev. of The Garden of Last Days, by Andre Dubus III. boston.com. Boston Globe 1 June 2008. Web. 24 Sept. 2010.
466
The Garden of Last Days takes place days before the attacks on the World Trade Center on September 11, 2001. ª Aerial Archives / Alamy
Gibbons, James. “The End Game.” Rev. of The Garden of Last Days, by Andre Dubus III. latimes.com. Los Angeles Times 22 June 2008. Print. Johnstone, Doug. Rev. of The Garden of Last Days, by Andre Dubus III. independent.co.uk. Independent 25 Jan 2009. Web. 24 Sept. 2010. McInerney, Jay. “The Devil Wears Nada.” Rev. of The Garden of Last Days, by Andre Dubus III. nytimes. com. New York Times 22 June 2008. Web. 24 Sept. P2010. Welsh, Irvine. Rev. of The Garden of Last Days, by Andre Dubus III. guardian.co.uk. Guardian 27 Sept. 2008. Web. 24 Sept. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Formy-Duval, John M. “The Garden of Last Days by Andre Dubus III.” Rev. of The Garden of Last Days, by Andre Dubus III. http://contemporarylit.about. com/od/fiction/fr/gardenLastDays.htm about.com. Contemporary Literature. Web. 24 Sept. 2010. Praises the novel as interesting and thoughtprovoking reading, creating an utterly plausible world, and believes it to be the best novel of 2008. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Garden of Last Days
Gibbons, James. “The End Game.” Rev. of The Garden of Last Days, by Andre Dubus III. latimes.com. Los Angeles Times 22 June 2008. Web. 24 Sept. 2010. Admires the novel for its ability to evoke sympathy for flawed characters but sees it as uneven and unable to fulfill its aspirations. McCullough, Laura. “In the Garden of Men: Considering Andre Dubus III’s The Garden of Last Days, and the Sins of the Fathers, Including His Own.” thepotomacjournal.com. Potomac Journal, Summer 2009. Web. 24 Sept. 2010. Sees the novel as Dubus’s attempt to outwrite his novelist father and argues that an important theme is the danger of gender-role expectations. Gale Resources
“Andre Dubus III.” Contemporary Authors Online, CengageGale,2007.Web.25Sept.2010.http:// galenet.galegroup.com/servlet/GLD/hits?r=d& origSearch=true&o=DataType&n=10&l=d&c=1& locID=itsbtrial&secondary=false&u=CA&u=CLC& u=DLB&t=KW&s=1&NA=Andre+Dubus+III “Andre Dubus III.” Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 292. Detroit: Gale, 2004. Literature Resource Center. Web. 25 Sept. 2010. http://galenet. galegroup.com/servlet/GLD/hits?r=d& origSearch=true&o=DataType&n=10&l=d&c= 2&locID=itsbtrial&secondary=false&u=CA&u= CLC&u=DLB&t=KW&s=1&NA=Andre+ Dubus+III
Dubus III, in which the author describes the source of the idea for The Garden of Last Days and his writing practice in general. The Identity Theory Web site, available at http://www. identitytheory.com/people/birnbaum3.html, contains an interview with Andre Dubus III, in which the author speaks at length about his influences and his writing practice. For Further Reading
Der Spiegel Magazine. Inside 9-11: What Really Happened. New York: St Martin’s Press, 2002. Print. A minute-by-minute account of events on September 11, 2001, and an account of the hijackers’ lives during the preceding months. Dubus, Andre, III. House of Sand and Fog. New York: Vintage, 1999. Print. Novel showing the dark side of the immigrant experience in the United States at the end of the twentieth century as seen through the eyes of two adversaries. Kepel, Gilles. The War for Muslim Minds: Islam and the West. Cambridge: Harvard UP, 2004. Print. History of Islamic fundamentalism and relations between Islam and the West. Weitzer, Ron. Sex for Sale: Prostitution, Pornography and the Sex Industry. London: Routledge, 1999. Print. Essays on various aspects of the sex industry in the United States and elsewhere. Harriet Devine
Open Web Sources
The Blip TV Web site, available at http://blip.tv/file/ 851251, contains a video interview with Andre
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
467
Ghosts of El Grullo By Patricia Santana
W Introduction Patricia Santana’s Ghosts of El Grullo is the coming-of-age tale of an incredibly smart young woman, Yolanda “Yoli” Sahagun. As she begins her journey, Yoli comes to realize that she cannot progress to the next stage in her life without first delving into her past and that of her parents, reconciling the ghosts of the past with her dreams of the future. Yoli grew up in a crowded house in San Diego during the 1970s, with eight siblings, an abusive father, and a kind mother. Shortly after she moved out of her childhood home to attend college, Yoli’s mother dies unexpectedly. This event prompts Yoli to return to El Grullo, Mexico, where her parents grew up, hoping that this knowledge will help inform her along the road to becoming the woman she is meant to be. What unfolds is a stream-of-consciousness tapestry of family history, memories, and dream sequences that detail Yoli’s emotional journey. Ghosts of El Grullo is the sequel to Santana’s Motorcycle Ride on the Sea of Tranquility, which detailed Yoli’s childhood and the experience of her older brother after he returned home from the Vietnam War. Ghosts of El Grullo was awarded the Premio Aztlán Award, the American Book Award, and the San Diego Book & Writing Award, all in 2008.
W Literary and Historical Context
Ghosts of El Grullo is part of a long-standing literary tradition, namely the coming-of-age novel. A seminal example of this type of novel is J. D. Salinger’s classic, The Catcher in the Rye, about a disaffected prep school boy, Holden Caulfield, trying to find his place in a world that seems full of hypocrisy and phoniness. On the surface, Ghosts of El Grullo seems very different from Catcher in
the Rye. Unlike Holden, Yoli is searching for answers in her family’s past. Also, in contrast to Holden, who is cynical and uses vulgar language, Yoli’s voice is softer and more yearning. She longs for her mother and is in search of answers. At their heart, though, both Yoli and Holden are young people who avoid returning to their family home and instead pursue a quest to discover some sort of truth. Both are caught in a liminal space between childhood and adulthood, feeling an equal pull in both directions, longing to strike out on their own and yet still very much influenced by the comfortable dreams of their youth. Yoli’s character is not new to Santana’s work. Santana first introducd readers to Yoli in Motorcyle Ride on the Sea of Tranquility, in which she was a young girl, distressed at the changes in her older brother, Chuy, after his return from the Vietnam War. Chuy appears, in a less prominent capacity, in this novel.
W Themes As the title suggests, the main theme of Ghosts of El Grullo is the past. Although the ghosts in the story are not literal ones or even supernaturally present, the novel uses the ghost metaphor to explore Yoli’s past. Laura Wilson, writing for Southwestern American Literature, describes them as ghosts “of memory, family, and cultural history.” Over the course of the novel, Yoli encounters many “ghosts,” including events and people from her family history, people from the past life her parents left behind, and those from her own childhood memories, the most poignant of which is Yoli’s beloved mother, whose loss leaves a palpable mark on the young protagonist. Yoli is also psychologically scarred by her father’s unpredictable nature. His kind and caring demeanor often turns instantly cruel and overbearing. His “ghost” is one of the key players in the novel, having spawned many “ghosts.” The “ghost” of her father, whom Yoli
468 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Ghosts of El Grullo
MAJOR CHARACTERS CHUY SAHAGUN is Yoli’s older brother, who struggles with the aftermath of fighting in the Vietnam War. DELORES SAHAGUN is Yoli’s mother. She dies of cancer early in the novel, inspiring Yolanda’s journey of self-discovery. LORENZO SAHAGUN is Yoli’s father. Lorenzo is described as “erratic,” because of his swift mood changes. YOLANDA SAHAGUN, or Yoli, is the protagonist, a young woman in her late teens who is inspired to travel to Mexico in an attempt to learn about her own past.
Two women wash clothing in the Mexican Riviera. In Ghosts of El Grullo, Yolanda ventures to her parents’ homeland of Mexico to try to understand her heritage. ª Charles O'Rear/Corbis
encounters by learning about his past in El Grullo, contrasts with the “ghost” of her own memory of her father from her childhood. Similarly, information she learns about her mother from the woman’s friends help Yoli assemble a fuller picture of both her mother and her own heritage.
W Style Patricia Santana writes Ghosts of El Grullo from the perspective of her young female protagonist, Yoli, who is in her late teens and a college freshman. Following her mother’s death, she decides to travel to El Grullo, Mexico, where her mother grew up. Santana presents Yoli’s journey in the form of a first-person, stream-ofconsciousness narrative that fully immerses the reader in the character’s emotional journey through her own and her family’s past. Stream-of-consciousness was a literary device made popular in the early twentieth century by writers such as Virginia Woolf and James Joyce. The goal of this type of
writing was to capture human thought processes as they occur, with ideas unfolding nonlinearly, as they occur naturally in people’s minds, as opposed to the more stylized and formal manner used by earlier novelists to present internal monologues. As Southwestern American Literature’s Laura Wilson describes, “The narrative moves from real life to dreams or memories effortlessly. Through her reveries and travels, Yoli tries desperately to put the pieces together: her childhood memories, the complex relationship between her parents” along with the “emerging Chicana and feminist movements surrounding her, and her family’s history in Mexico.” Over the course of the novel, Santana writes in deliberately evocative prose meant in an effort to paint a three-dimensional picture that places readers directly within Yoli’s memories. Yoli describes her mother’s sewing in the following words: “[T]he rat-tat-tat-tat of the machine’s humming as my mother expertly slipped a fuchsia-colored palazzo pant through the machine’s needle plate, then the click of the presser foot lifter, then the scissor snip of thread indicating she was done sewing that portion of the garment.” Describing her family’s estate in Mexico, Yoli explains, “Huge spiders, poisonous scorpions, and anguished phantoms had dominion here.” Santana also sprinkles Spanish words and phrases throughout the text that ground it in the culture of its characters.
W Critical Reception Upon its release, Ghosts of El Grullo received three awards—the Premio Aztlán Award, the American Book Award, and the San Diego Book & Writing Award. Despite its literary honors, the book received lukewarm reviews that praised Santana’s writing style, but were not overly enthusiastic about the storyline. Whitney Scott, in Booklist, wrote that Yoli’s voice was “refreshing” and she praised the novel’s “vividly descriptive prose.” Meanwhile, Laura Wilson liked the novel overall, although she
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
469
Ghosts of El Grullo
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Patricia Santana’s two novels featuring Yolanda Sahagun, Motorcycle Ride on the Sea of Tranquility and Ghosts of El Grullo, are somewhat autobiographical because of the number of similarities they reveal about the author’s own life. Like Yolanda, Santana comes from a family of Mexican immigrants, with nine siblings. Like Yolanda’s parents, Santana’s parents are also from El Grullo, and Santana also attended the University of California at San Diego. The evocative nature of Santana’s prose is vivid, leading some reviewers to theorize that her language derives from real-life characters. Santana’s novels are steeped in the Mexican immigrant culture, filtered through the influence of the United States. She won the University of California, Irvine, Chicano/Latino Literary Contest in 1999, the 2003 Best Books for Young Adults by the Young Adult Library Services Association Award, the 2008 Premio Aztlán Award, the American Book Award, and the San Diego Book & Writing Award, among others.
Scott, Whitney. “Ghosts of El Grullo.” Rev. of Ghosts of El Grullo, by Patricia Santana. Booklist 15 Mar. 2008: 27. Print. Wilson, Laura. “Ghosts of El Grullo: A Novel.” Rev. of Ghosts of El Grullo, by Patricia Santana. Southwestern American Literature 35.1 (2009): 85+. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Ramey, Julia. “Coming of Age: This Novel about a Mexican-American Teen Is Occasionally Whiny, but Overall Worthwhile.” Rev. of Ghosts of El Grullo, by Patricia Santana. Tucson Weekly 17 July 2008. Web. 12 Sept. 2010. This mostly positive review faults Santana with often making Yoli’s narration either redundant, mundane, or petulant. Gale Resources
“Patricia Santana.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2006. Open Web Sources
found the plot lacking innovation. “Take away the incessant reminders of significance,” she writes. “Take away the cultural specifics that make this work’s content unique. What remains? We are left with the age-old story of one’s emergence into adulthood: the desperate need for independence, the desire to forge one’s own revolution, the formation of ‘the self’—certainly a story that we have all read, many times before.” A distinguishing characteristic of the novel for Wilson is Santana’s use of the English language. Wilson asserts that Santana “has the ability to make the dreadfully mundane extraordinary.” At the same time, Wilson deemed the “ghosts” metaphor obvious and repetitive, leading her to conclude that the author did not trust the readers to make connections for themselves, leading to a tendency to over-explain the significance of events. The Hispanic literary blog La Bloga took issue with what it regarded as Santana’s stereotypical depiction of Yoli’s parents. According to La Bloga, the father is too hyperbolically abusive and the mother too saintly: “I began to mistrust the narrator’s perception[s],” the blogger explains. At the same time, the blogger also found the imagery strong and the language compelling. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Rev. of Ghosts of El Grullo, by Patricia Santana. La Bloga. 13 Jan. 2009. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. Santana, Patricia. Ghosts of El Grullo. Albuquerque: U of New Mexico P, 2008. Print.
470
Patricia Santana’s official Website includes a comprehensive biography, bibliography, news and events. http://patriciasantana.net For Further Reading
Agee, James. A Death in the Family. New York: Vintage, 1998. Print. This novel about a family coping with the loss of a family member, told from the perspective of each of the people affected, is reminiscent of Yoli’s mourning for her mother and her own investigation of the past. Castillo, Ana. So Far from God. New York: Norton, 2005. Print. This novel features ghosts of a more literal nature than those in Ghosts of El Grullo, but it also relates the story of a family of Mexican immigrants in America, confronting their past. McEwan, Ian. Atonement. New York: Anchor, 2001. Print. This is a coming-of-age novel about a woman who spends her entire life haunted by a crime she committed as a child. Salinger, J. D. The Catcher in the Rye. New York: Little, Brown, 1951. Print. This seminal coming-of-age classic focuses on a troubled young male protagonist struggling to come to terms with his burgeoning adulthood. Santana, Patricia. Motorcycle Ride on the Sea of Tranquility. Albuquerque: U of New Mexico P, 2002. Print. Patricia Santana’s first novel introduces Yoli and the rest of the Sahagun family. Powder Thompson
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Gilead By Marilynne Robinson
W Introduction The narrator of Gilead (2004) is the Reverend John Ames, who over several months during 1956 writes a long letter to his son. At seventy-six and dying of heart disease, Ames writes what he calls his begats, hoping that his little boy will someday read this document and understand more about the father he will hardly remember. Ames describes events in the present year and reflects on his life in Gilead, Iowa, where his parents moved when he was two. He tells stories about his father and grandfather, who shared his name and were also clergymen. His recollections reach back to 1830 when his grandfather traveled west from New England to Kansas. Having written thousands of sermons, Ames aspires now to write with a candor his natural reticience typically disallows. As he progresses, he shifts from biographical and historical information to his private daily struggle with envy and anger. These hidden emotions are triggered, ironically, by Ames’s best friend, the Reverend Robert Boughton, who has enjoyed what Ames has been denied: a long marriage and fathering many children all of whom reached maturity. Ames wrestles specifically with his feelings about Boughton’s son Jack, who returns to Gilead during the months when Ames experiences declining health and writes his letter.
W Literary and Historical Context
Gilead refers to several important events in American history, including the conflict in the 1850s between abolitionist and pro-slavery settlers in Kansas and the American Civil War, specifically the battle of Wilson’s Creek, Missouri, where Grandfather Ames lost an eye. The novel alludes to regional differences regarding postCivil War racial laws and prejudice, particularly regarding miscegenation (intermarriage between the races). It
includes the Kansas drought and famine of 1892 and the Spanish influenza in 1915 and 1916. It also alludes to World War II, the integration of baseball in 1947, and the reelection of Dwight Eisenhower in 1956. The three generations of Ames clergymen are witnesses to these parts of American history. Slavery and race relations constitute the most important historical context for the novel. Grandfather Ames goes to Kansas to help settle the debate over slavery in the western territories and see these areas admitted as free states. Many Northerners wanted to limit slavery to the Deep South. Many people were adamant abolitionists, while others feared that if slavery spread west, plantation-type farming would squeeze out ordinary farmers. The conflict intensified with the KansasNebraska Act (1854), which divided Kansas territory into a northern and southern part and allowed local people to vote on whether their area would permit slavery. Free Soilers moved into this territory intent on outnumbering pro-slavery settlers and winning this vote. The resulting numerous gunfights caused the area to be known as Bleeding Kansas. By contrast, Iowa was solidly for abolition, and its towns served as safe havens on the Underground Railroad, a secret network of cooperation that assisted fugitive slaves. Many Iowa houses were built with secret cupboards and closets designed for hiding escaped slaves. After the Civil War, Iowa did not pass anti-miscegenation laws, and African Americans and white people lived in comparative peace there. This historical fact explains why Jack Boughton returns to Gilead in hopes of finding some modicum of social tolerance and a place where he and his black common-law wife and their son might be able to live.
W Themes One important theme concerns intergenerational relationships. As the Reverend Ames writes to the adult he envisions his own son will become, he reflects on the
471 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Gilead
MAJOR CHARACTERS FATHER AMES, the narrator’s father, was a Congregationalist minister and pacifist who joined the Quakers as a protest against his own father’s belief in violence as the way to oppose slavery. GRANDFATHER AMES, the narrator’s grandfather, had visions of Jesus that prompted him to leave his home in Maine in 1830 and travel west to Kansas to join the abolitionists’ efforts. Grandfather Ames wanted to join the Union army when the Civil War began but was disqualified because of his age. He followed the troops anyway, in the role of clergyman, and was wounded at the Battle of Wilson’s Creek, Missouri. JOHN AMES, the narrator and protagonist, is seventy-six years old and dying of heart disease. Married late in life, he has a young son to whom he writes. LILA AMES, the narrator’s late-in-life second wife, is an uneducated newcomer to Gilead when she meets the Reverend Ames and asks to be baptized by him. She is devoted to her husband and son and tries to educate herself with Bible studies on Sundays. LOUISA AMES, the narrator’s first wife, dies in childbirth, leaving John Ames a widower at age twenty-five. JOHN AMES BOUGHTON, called Jack, is the troubled son Robert Boughton cannot understand. Unable to tell his father about his wife and child, Jack confides in the Reverend Ames and seeks Ames’s blessing. ROBERT BOUGHTON, the narrator’s best friend and a Presbyterian minister, has a long married life and fathers eight children. His daughter Glory attends him in his final years. His prodigal son Jack returns the summer of 1956 but leaves again before Robert Boughton dies. THE SON of the Reverend Ames to whom the long letter is addressed is unnamed in this novel. (In Robinson’s subsequent novel, Home, readers learn that this child is named Robert Boughton Ames after his father’s best friend.) In 1956 this boy turns seven.
relationship between his grandfather and his father and between his elder brother Edward and their father. The novel explores intergenerational breaches and the longterm resentment they cause, and it offers one way forgiveness can be achieved. Ames ponders biblical stories of fathers and sons and of fathers who abandon their wives and sons. He seeks insight and forgiveness related to issues of betrayal and loss, and he wants peace as he confronts dying. Another important theme concerns faith and doubt and how religious belief changes across generations.
472
Grandfather Ames gave his sermons with a gun in his belt. The narrator’s pacifist father went among the Quakers to worship in protest of his father’s militancy. The narrator’s brother Edward, a university professor, became an atheist and lived a few hundred miles away, completely out of touch with his parents and his brother. Incorporating Christian beliefs and other philosophies, the novel explores how individuals come to believe what they do and how they live in compliance with or rebel against the values of others. A third theme pertains to the act of writing and what happens when a person attempts to take stock of his life, his family’s experiences, and his beliefs. The Reverend Ames is experienced in writing homilies, but the writing he attempts here is new to him, and it takes him from autobiography and family history to the crux of his own psychological makeup. As he moves from the outer facts of his life to its emotional center, he gains self-awareness and forgiveness. The balm in this Gilead is love, historically associated with the state-wide efforts to help fugitive slaves escape north, in the Reverend Ames’s life with the love of congregation and family, including his namesake, Jack Boughton.
W Style Gilead reads like a private letter or journal, written over time and intended for one reader only, the writer’s son. Marilynne Robinson stays strictly inside the Reverend Ames’s voice and within his frame of reference. The effect is to give readers a sense of intruding on the most private thoughts and feelings of the narrator. The extended letter as a form shapes the novel’s content. The letter does not explain as much as one might expect. Restricted to the one point of view, others’ perceptions and views are not given. Also, the novel breaks off without describing how Ames dies; readers do not know what happens to his young widow or if his letter is ever read by the son. They do not know what becomes of Jack Boughton and his family. Ames is self-conscious and deliberate as a writer. He thinks about the books he has read and about words and what they mean. He ponders the Parable of the Prodigal Son and other relevant stories. He pays careful attention to the physical world, to details in the immediate setting, and his descriptions are vivid and memorable. Thus, the text has the kind of self-absorption or self-consciousness that might be found in the private document it claims to be.
W Critical Reception Gilead was heralded immediately as an important novel, and being awarded the Pulitzer Prize affirmed its positive reception. Many critics praised the characterization of the TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Gilead
narrator and the prose style. Michael Vander Weele, among others, noted how the novel requires readers to slow down to a small-town 1950s pace, slow down to the reverend’s flow of thoughts, as one would alter one’s pace to accommodate an elderly gentleman. Valerie Miner praised the work as a character study, noting Ames’s “fallibility, humility, and humor,” and she praised the novel for its “evocation of place and keen appreciation for history as well as for its candid, often gripping, examination of conscience.” Miner concluded that the “literary epistle” was movingly “threaded with supplication and atonement.” Simon Baker agreed that Ames is a skillful writer, given his piles of sermons, “the equivalent of 225 books,” but went on to theorize that Ames’s weekly homily production may account for why the prose is “almost too writerly.” James Wood explained some of the risks in having a clergyman as the main character. He pointed out that in the English tradition of the novel “the local vicar is usually safely contained as hypocritical, absurd or possibly a bit dimwitted.” Robinson bravely departs from this established tradition, Wood admitted, and succeeds in doing so. Vander Weele stressed that the success of Ames is in his voice, “its humor, counsel, risk.” Here is a clergyman to take seriously, a man who makes 1950s Protestantism meaningful to twenty-first century readers. Ames works to understand virtue and vice and achieve resolution. The professional commitment of a minister to his flock and his hidden moral dilemmas are portrayed in this novel with respect and love. Wood praised Gilead for having “a spiritual force that’s very rare in contemporary fiction.” Robinson’s Gilead is an accounting a man’s struggle with his own fallibility, and in the face of death, his affirmation that the world as it is—is a gift. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Baker, Simon. “Looking Back without Anger.” Rev. of Gilead, by Marilynne Robinson. Spectator 297.9219 (16 Apr. 2005): 47. Print. Miner, Valerie. “Iowa Meditations.” Rev. of Gilead, by Marilynne Robinson. Women’s Review of Books 22.3 (2004): 19. Print. Sayers, Valerie. “There Is a Balm.” Rev. of Gilead, by Marilynne Robinson. Commonweal 132.4 (2005): 22. Print. Vander Weele, Michael. “Marilynne Robinson’s Gilead and the Difficult Gift of Human Exchange.” Rev. of Gilead, by Marilynne Robinson. Christianity and Literature 59.2 (2010): 217. Print. Wood, James. “Acts of Devotion.” Rev. of Gilead, by Marilynne Robinson. New York Times Book Review (28 Nov. 2004): 1. Print.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Marilynne Robinson was born in 1943 in Sandpoint, Idaho. She graduated from Brown University (1966) and received her PhD from the University of Washington (1977). Gilead is the second of three novels, including Housekeeping (1980) and Home (2008). Robinson has also published three works of nonfiction: Mother Country: Britain, the Welfare State, and Nuclear Pollution (1988), The Death of Adam: Essays on Modern Thought (1998), and Absence of Mind: Dispelling the Inwardness from the Modern Myth of Self (2010). Robinson is a professor of English at the University of Iowa where she teaches in the Iowa Writers’ Workshop. As of 2010, she lived in Iowa City, Iowa.
Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Bailey, Lisa M. Siefker. “Fraught with Fire: Race and Theology in Marilynne Robinson’s Gilead.” Christianity and Literature 59.2 (2010): 265+. Print. Examines Robinson’s use of fire, explains the biblical significance of the town’s name, and connects these to race issues. Hobbs, June Hadden. “Burial, Baptism, and Baseball: Typology and Memorialization in Marilynne Robinson’s Gilead.” Christianity and Literature 59.2 (2010): 241+. Print. Develops the premise that Ames is not fighting death in his letter writing but rather the way in which the passage of time causes people to forget. His letter to his son is a valiant effort to salvage what may be forgotten by the next generation. Leonard, John. “New Books.” Rev. of Gilead, by Marilynne Robinson. Harper’s Dec. 2004: 87+. Print. Reviews Gilead, pointing out that like Housekeeping, this novel conveys its meaning with superlative style. Simpson, Mona. “The Minister’s Tale: Marilynne Robinson’s Long-awaited Second Novel Is an Almost Otherworldly Book—and Reveals Robinson as a Somewhat Otherworldly Figure Herself.” Rev. of Gilead, by Marilynne Robinson. Atlantic Dec. 2004: 135. Print. Personable review that heralds the strengths of Housekeeping and Gilead. Tanner, Laura E. “‘Looking Back from the Grave’: Sensory Perception and the Anticipation of Absence in Marilynne Robinson’s Gilead.” Contemporary Literature 48.2 (2007): 227-252. Rpt. in Contemporary Literary Criticism. Ed. Jeffrey W. Hunter. Vol. 276. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Print. Explains how the narrator’s awareness of his imminent death shapes his perception of immediate surroundings and events,
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
473
Gilead
and she explains the irony involved in Ames’s effort to represent his life in text as his hold on life wanes. Gale Resources
Marsh, Janet Z. “Marilynne Robinson.” Twenty-FirstCentury American Novelists: Second Series. Ed. Wanda H. Giles and James R. Giles. Detroit: Gale, 2009. 310-16. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 350. Literature Resource Center. Web. 30 June 2010. http://go.galegroup.com/ps/i.do?&id=GALE% 7CH1200013923&v=2.1&u=itsbtrial&it=r&p= LitRC&sw=w Monahan, Melodie. “Critical Essay on Gilead.” Novels for Students. Ed. Ira Mark Milne. Vol. 24. Detroit: Gale, 2007. Literature Resource Center. Web. 30 June 2010. http://go.galegroup.com/ps/i.do?&id= GALE%7CH1420073749&v=2.1&u= itsbtrial&it=r&p=LitRC&sw=w Open Web Sources
Guardian.co.uk presents an interview with Marilynne Robinson conducted by Emma Brockes on 30 May 2009, and available at http://www.guardian.co.uk/ culture/2009/may/30/marilynne-robinson/print UI Pulitzer Prize Winners, at http://www.iowalum. com/pulitzerPrize/robinson.html, contains interviews with University of Iowa professors who have won the Pulitzer Prize, including an interview with Marilynne Robinson. This site contains a link to a National Public Radio interview with Robinson. Willow Springs from Eastern Washington University presents an interview with Marilynne Robinson at http://willowsprings.ewu.edu/interviews/ robinson.php
For Further Reading
Bernanos, Georges. The Diary of a Country Priest. New York: Carroll and Graf, 2002. Print. Written in Majorca in 1935, and reprinted many times, the story of a French priest who in his dutiful innocence and outward simplicity is unable to connect with his parishioners and thus takes up diary writing to commit to paper what he cannot speak. Freedom Writers. The Freedom Writers Diary: How a Teacher and 150 Teens Used Writing to Change Themselves and the World around Them. New York: Broadway Books, 1999. Print. Inspiring story of teacher Erin Gruwell and her inner-city students who studied the Freedom Riders of the 1950s and were inspired to write their own stories of prejudice and survival. The account served as the basis for a film with the same title. Pascoe, Peggy. What Comes Naturally: Miscegenation Laws and the Making of Race in America. Oxford: Oxford UP, 2009. Print. Spans 1863 to 2000 and explains that miscegenation laws grew out of two beliefs, that interracial marriage is unnatural and that whites are genetically superior to blacks; also discusses cross-ethnic unions between whites and American Indians, Hawaiians, Asians, and East Indians. Richards, Leonard L. The Slave Power: The Free North and Southern Domination, 1780-1860. Baton Rouge: Louisiana State UP, 2000. Print. Begins with the conflicts between Northern and Southern congressmen in Washington over the western territories and explores the slaveholding oligarchy so influential in the nation’s capital and the Free Soilers and Republicans who opposed it. Melodie Monahan
474
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Gilgamesh By Joan London
W Introduction Gilgamesh (2001) is the first novel by the award-winning short-fiction writer Joan London. Beginning in an isolated farming region of Australia just before the outbreak of World War II, this deftly crafted work follows an unlikely adventurer on a journey through Europe to Armenia and back again. The central character, Edith Clark, is an Australian teenager who falls in love with a visiting cousin’s Armenian friend. After the men have left, she learns that she is pregnant. Inspired by their tales of adventure and by the ancient Mesopotamian epic poem The Epic of Gilgamesh, she takes her infant son on a quest through wartime Europe to the fabled mountain land of his father. The critic William Cobb describes Gilgamesh, which was named the 2002 Book of the Year by the Australian newspaper the Age, as “a novel in the old-fashioned and much honored sense, a haunting and tender story of sacrifice and loss, an evocation of gritty and indefatigable life.”
W Literary and Historical Context
Edith Clark, the protagonist of Gilgamesh, travels widely in the course of the novel, but the principal settings of the tale are the Australian outback and Soviet Armenia. The story begins after World War I, when Edith’s parents meet and decide to move to South West Australia as part of the Group Settlement Scheme initiated in the 1920s. The program was intended to create a rural dairy industry, but there were many problems with its implementation, and most settlers failed. The novel begins and ends in the fictional settlement town of Nunderup, and London convincingly portrays the difficulties of the land and the isolated culture in which Edith and her sister grow up. On the eve of World War II,
Edith leaves Nunderup to find her Armenian friend Aram, who has returned to his home country without knowing he has fathered her child. Armenia, a mountainous region that lies at the juncture of eastern Europe and western Asia, became the first officially Christian country in 306 CE but was eventually absorbed into the Muslim Ottoman Empire, creating ethnic and religious tensions. A large number of Armenians are believed to have been killed by Turkish forces in 1915 (though these reports are disputed by the government of Turkey). Following a struggle for independence, Armenia was annexed by the Soviet Union in 1922. Armenian patriots continued to oppose the Soviets during the 1930s. In the novel, Aram, whose family was killed in the massacres of 1915, goes back to join the Armenian underground.
W Themes The Epic of Gilgamesh is one of the earliest-known works of literature. The stories that make up the epic, which was probably written in Mesopotamia around 2000 BCE, are thought to be based on legends about a real Gilgamesh who ruled the ancient Sumerian city of Uruk. In the epic Gilgamesh becomes great friends with Enkidu, a “wild man” whom the gods had created to distract Gilgamesh from tyrannizing his subjects. The two have great adventures, but when Enkidu is killed, Gilgamesh is inconsolable. Although he journeys to the underworld in search of his friend, in the end he must accept the loss and learn from his experiences. This compelling story seems surprisingly contemporary, and it has been admired by readers since the first modern translation was published in the 1870s. In London’s Gilgamesh, Edith’s cousin Leopold, an archaeologist, carries a copy of the epic with him everywhere, and the volume becomes both a talisman and an inspiration for Edith and later for her son. Although the novel Gilgamesh is not intended to be a retelling of the epic, it explores the same themes: friendship, loss, journey, realization, and return. Leopold
475 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Gilgamesh
MAJOR CHARACTERS LEOPOLD is Edith Clark’s cousin, an English archaeologist who comes to visit the Clark family in Australia. He and his friend Aram tell Edith of their adventures, and Leopold gives her a copy of The Epic of Gilgamesh. EDITH CLARK is an Australian teenager who lives in an isolated farm community and falls in love with Aram, an Armenian visitor. After Aram leaves, Edith discovers that she is pregnant. With her infant son, she sets out for Armenia to find Aram. JIM CLARK is Edith and Aram’s son. After spending his early years in Armenia, Jim has difficulty adjusting to Australian life, but as a teenager he finds his own way, and at the end of the novel he embarks on a new adventure. ARAM SINANIEN is a fiercely patriotic Armenian who becomes Leopold’s driver and then his friend. Aram, whose family was killed in a Turkish massacre during World War I, returns to Armenia to join the resistance against Soviet occupation of his home country.
and Aram, like Gilgamesh and Enkidu, are great friends who go on adventures together, and ultimately one of them must grieve the death of the other. Edith and her son, Jim, can also be seen as a pair of travelers who go on a quest for someone they have lost (Aram), and the rest of their lives is shaped by that adventure.
W Style In order to tell a large story in a relatively short book, London concentrates on carefully selected, sharply observed details that reveal a great deal without saying too much. Her sentences are generally short and unadorned, often depending for their effect on intense visual imagery and gracefully compressed description. Edith, the protagonist, is thoughtful but not introspective, so her characterization develops mainly through her actions, which advance the plot without taking up a great deal of the narrative. The novel’s third-person omniscient narration begins at a high level, telling the family’s background story in just a few well-structured pages. It then shifts to Edith’s perspective for the core events of the book and focuses increasingly on the viewpoint of her son, Jim, as the novel concludes. Edith’s share of the story seems to recede as she realizes that her future challenges will be about staying rather than leaving, while Jim’s share expands as he prepares to go in search of his own destiny. Overall London’s style is restrained, mixing judicious use of metaphor and occasional flights of lyricism into a narrative that is gracefully spare.
476
W Critical Reception Gilgamesh was widely reviewed, for the most part with enthusiasm. Dan Neill and Jane Perry, reviewers for the Guardian, praise the novel for “its sleek storyline, its sharp, glittering narrative fragments, its carefully honed sentences, its heroic women and its shadowy men, its spanning of generations and continents, its epic allusions, its sense of the sublime.” Writing in the Daily Mail, Ned Denny concludes that “readers will finish [the novel] feeling that they are holding in their hands something rare and precious.” Alev Adil, reviewing the novel for the Independent, characterizes Gilgamesh as “a remarkable first novel,” noting that it is “beautifully written and constructed, dreamlike yet believable.” Most reviewers have praised London’s economical writing and restrained style, but a few have found the novel underdeveloped. In a review for the San Francisco Chronicle, for example, Selina O’Grady calls the work “surprisingly slight,” adding that “London gives us too small a focus while paradoxically distancing us from Edith by endowing her with the quasi-invulnerability of epic.” Nevertheless, O’Grady finds the novel “charming” and observes that its ending may suggest a “hope that humanity can find heroism not just in violence but also in building communities.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Adil, Alev. “The Monday Book: Utopian Dreamers in a World Scarred by War.” Rev. of Gilgamesh, by Joan London. Independent [London] 1 Dec. 2003: 14. Print. Cobb, William J. “Restless Hearts Leave Home: Australian Characters’ Saga Parallels Mesopotamian Myth.” Rev. of Gilgamesh, by Joan London. Houston Chronicle 24 Aug. 2003: 18. Print. Denny, Ned. “Savouring Friends and Solitude.” Rev. of Gilgamesh, by Joan London. Daily Mail [London]. Associated Newspapers Ltd, 20 Aug. 2003. Web. 7 Oct. 2010. Neill, Dan, and Jane Perry. “Kings and Criminals.” Rev. of Gilgamesh, by Joan London. Guardian [London] 1 Nov. 2003: 26. Print. O’Grady, Selina. Rev. of Gilgamesh, by Joan London. San Francisco Chronicle 13 Apr. 2003: M-4. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Bader, Eleanor J. Rev. of Gilgamesh, by Joan London. Library Journal 1 Feb. 2003: 116+. Print. Bader gives the novel a “highly recommended” status. Blader, Bonnie. Rev. of Gilgamesh, by Joan London. Rain Taxi Online Spring 2003. Web. 7 Oct. 2010. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Gilgamesh
Blader’s positive review focuses on the characterization of Edith. Rev. of Gilgamesh, by Joan London. Kirkus Reviews 1 Feb. 2003: 168. Print. This mixed review finds the novel engrossing but derivative. Rev. of Gilgamesh, by Joan London. Publishers Weekly 27 Jan. 2003: 232. Print. This positive review notes the novel’s powerful evocation of the Australian landscape. Lee-Potter, Charlie. “An Ancient Fable—with Power Cuts.” Rev. of Gilgamesh, by Joan London. Independent [London]. Independent Print Ltd, 7 Sept. 2003. Web. 7 Oct. 2010. Lee-Potter admires London’s writing but finds the novel unsatisfying overall. Prose, Francine. “Imagining Armenia.” Rev. of Gilgamesh, by Joan London. New York Times Book Review 15 June 2003: 8. Print. In a long and balanced review, the noted novelist Prose offers detailed praise for Gilgamesh. Gale Resources
“Joan London.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2010. Open Web Sources
The Web site Australia’s South West offers maps, photos, and historical information about the area where the Clark family in Gilgamesh lives. http://www.austra liassouthwest.com/en/Pages/default.aspx The Armenian government’s tourism site presents the history of Armenia from the Armenian viewpoint, together with information about the land and its people. http://www.armeniainfo.am/about/ ?section=history For Further Reading
Avakian, Arra S., and Ara J. Movsesian. Armenia: A Journey through History. Fresno: Electric, 2003. Print. The rich, complicated history of Armenia is thoroughly documented in this volume, which provides useful background for understanding both the real and the imagined Armenia presented in Gilgamesh.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Joan Elizabeth London was born in Perth, Western Australia, Australia, in 1948. After graduating from the University of Western Australia, where she studied English and French, London taught for a while and began writing short fiction. Her first collection, Sister Ships and Other Stories, appeared in 1986 and was named Book of the Year by the Age. In 1994 a second collection, Letter to Constantine, won a Steele Rudd Award and a West Australian Premier’s Award for Fiction. Although London was not well-known outside Australia when her debut novel was published, Gilgamesh was praised by critics in England and the United States and was considered for both an Orange Prize and an IMPAC Dublin Literary Award. The Good Parents, her second novel, was published in 2008 and received a Christina Stead Prize for Fiction. London lives in Fremantle, Western Australia, with her husband, Geoff, as of 2010.
Foster, Benjamin R., Douglas Frayne, and Gary M. Beckman. The Epic of Gilgamesh: A New Translation, Analogues, Criticism. New York: Norton, 2001. Print. This critical edition of The Epic of Gilgamesh, which contains an English translation from original sources, a detailed introduction, explanatory annotations, and illustrations, offers a helpful context for understanding the classic work. London, Joan. The Good Parents. London: Atlantic, 2008. Print. London’s second novel also centers on an adolescent protagonist and explores the themes of journey and self-realization. ———. Sister Ships and Other Stories. New York: Penguin, 1988. Print. London’s first collection of stories features heroines who, like Edith Clark, do not fit into the worlds they inhabit. Sullivan, Jane. “The A-Z of Joan London.” Age [Melbourne]. Fairfax Media, 5 Apr. 2008. Web. 10 Oct. 2010. This profile of the author includes London’s comments on the relationship between her life and her novels.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Cynthia Giles
477
The Girl in the Tangerine Scarf By Mohja Kahf
W Introduction The Girl in the Tangerine Scarf (2006) opens in the 1970s and introduces Syrian immigrant Khadra Shamy and her family. Khadra is an idealist and she is devoted to the Muslim community to which she and her family belong. Her youth is described in detail, as are the problems facing a young, conservative Muslim woman as she grows up in Middle America. As a young woman, she accompanies her family on their hajj—the trip to Mecca that is prescribed for all Muslims once in their lives—and she comes to the realization that the version of Islam that she has grown up with is not the only version. She begins to lose some of her idealism, a process that continues as her marriage to a more conservative Kuwaiti man falls apart. Khadra flees to Syria to live with her aunt but eventually returns to the United States, more liberal in her religious notions, but still a devoted Muslim who wears the hijab, or the traditional headscarf for women. Mohja Kahf’s novel draws on her own history—the author also grew up in Indiana—and the text critiques contemporary Muslim beliefs while showing the diversity of the Muslim world. Misconceptions about Muslims from the perspectives of their non-Muslim neighbors are also addressed, sometimes with violent consequences, as when the sister of one of Khadra’s friends is murdered early in the novel. Khadra is caught between two identities, Muslim and American, and over the course of the book, she learns how to come to terms with being both, as well as with being comfortable with herself.
W Literary and Historical Context
Written after the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks on the World Trade Center, The Girl in the Tangerine Scarf
is one among a body of novels by Muslim writers that offer insight into both Arab and Muslim culture from a native perspective. These novels attempt to counter the ideas propagated by many media images of Islamic fundamentalism. The Girl in the Tangerine Scarf delves into the complexity of the Muslim world, showing diversity in beliefs and traditions among Muslim subcultures, both in the United States and the Middle East. The Muslim population of the United States has continued to grow since data began to be collected in the early 1990s. The actual number, however, is hotly contested; higher estimates by Muslim organizations have been countered by non-Muslim organizations. The latter groups have been accused of trying to marginalize Muslims, while the Muslim organizations are accused of misrepresenting their numbers in order to gain greater political representation (Robinson). During the 1980s, Muslims in America were an even smaller minority than their present numbers indicate. The American Religious Identification Survey (ARIS) estimates that in 1990, Muslims made up 0.3% of the population of the United States. Both ARIS and the PEW Trust placed that number at 0.6% of the population in 2007-2008. That growing number means that more Muslims in America, like Khadra, must balance their identities as Muslims and Americans.
W Themes Culture clashes and identity are the dominant themes in Kahf ’s first novel. Like her poetry, The Girl in the Tangerine Scarf depicts what it is like to be Muslim in America. Khadra grows up in Indiana, a minority, but firm in her faith and comfortable in her community until tragedy strikes and the sister of a friend is murdered. The event shows the violent racism present in Indiana of the 1980s and reveals the persecution that Khadra and her peers face. Her identity as a young woman, however, is
478 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Girl in the Tangerine Scarf
solid in the face of this persecution: she knows what she believes and where she fits. In the middle of the novel, Khadra finds her idealism challenged. On hajj to Mecca with her family, she discovers that the Islam she has grown up with is not the same as the Islam practiced in Saudi Arabia. She is arrested on her way to dawn prayer at the mosque, as women are barred from this service. Her cousin’s Saudi friends harass her. Later, after she is married, she questions her husband’s authority to forbid her riding a bicycle and she chooses to have an abortion rather than have to give up her studies at an American university. Against a backdrop of U.S. and Middle Eastern politics during the 1980s and 1990s, Khadra struggles to determine what it means to be both Muslim and American. Her travels take her to Syria, where she learns another interpretation of Islam from an aunt. When she returns to the United States, she avoids going home because she cannot identify with the naive beliefs she had as a child and does not want to confront the violence she remembers there. However, when she eventually returns home, she finds that she is comfortable with her own understanding of her faith, and she is confident in herself.
MAJOR CHARACTERS HAKIM is Khadra’s ex-husband from a disastrous marriage. KHADRA SHAMY is the protagonist of the novel. She begins as a young girl in Indiana and through her travels in the Middle East, she comes to question her understanding of her faith. Eventually, after living in Syria and returning to the United States, she grows to accept her beliefs and become comfortable with herself.
W Style The Girl in the Tangerine Scarf is written in the tradition of immigrant literature. Like novels of other cultural clashes, The Girl in the Tangerine Scarf shows the journey of one character whose cultural identity is in conflict and uses her individual story to symbolize the universal search for self-awareness. Immigrant novels often include autobiographical details and anecdotes. Tarek el-Ariss of Banipal noted that the details in Khadra’s journey are
This photo shows two women wearing traditional Muslim clothing. In The Girl in the Tangerine Scarf, the main character wears a hijab, a traditional Muslim headscarf for women. ª Janine Wiedel Photolibrary / Alamy
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
479
The Girl in the Tangerine Scarf
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Mohja Kahf was born in Damascus, Syria, and came to live in the United States as a child. An associate professor of comparative literature at the University of Arkansas, Kahf’s first book is a scholarly text about the portrayal of Muslim women in literature. Western Representations of the Muslim Woman: From Termagant to Odalisque deals with how that representation changed from medieval writings to nineteenth century literature. In 2003 Kahf published a book of poetry, E-mails from Scheherazad; many of the poems in the collection counter the idea of what many non-Muslim readers think it means to be a Muslim woman in the modern world. For example, Kahf contrasts the idea of the clothing restrictions many object to in Muslim culture with the business dress code of high heels and nylons to which Western women have subjected themselves. Her first novel, The Girl in the Tangerine Scarf draws on many of Kahf’s own childhood experiences in Indiana, though she has stated that the book is not autobiographical. In addition to her writing and teaching schedule, Kahf offers readings of her work, which are informal and often include song and dance.
mostly mundane; the events are of an everyday nature rather than highly sensationalized. “Clearly, such are the trappings of the autobiographical genre that sets out in this case to tell both a personal and a communal story,” wrote el-Ariss. Khadra’s voice through Kahf ’s narration offers critiques of both Muslim and American society. Khadra’s reactions to her unwanted pregnancy and her husband’s insistence that she not ride her bicycle show her questioning of traditional values. In other instances, Kahf ’s own voice finds its way into the narrative. According to a critic for Publishers Weekly, these “authorial incursions,” in which Kahf airs her thoughts on both religion and the cultures in which Khadra finds herself, “are heavy-handed.” However, el-Ariss found Khadra an “earnest” narrator, and felt that the character grows to achieve the “balance that allows her to hold on to Islam as home while acknowledging the limitations and the contradictions at the heart of its many practices.”
W Critical Reception Although Kahf is a well-respected scholar and poet whose literary criticism and poetry have received awards, her first novel received very few critical reviews. It was particularly successful commercially among Muslim American women, but received little press in the mainstream review periodicals or in scholarly journals. A Publishers Weekly critic found Khadra “a compelling protagonist” and felt the secondary characters were “varied and believable.” While el-Ariss of Banipal wrote that in the novel, “Kahf
480
provides us with a kaleidoscopic view of growing up Muslim and female in America,” he also felt that Khadra’s voice was too earnest and held the novel back from becoming literature beyond a simple telling of cultural perspective in a particular moment in history. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
“ARIS 2008 Report: Part 1A–Belonging.” American Religious Identification Survey 2008. Web. 4 Oct. 2010. el-Ariss, Tarek. “Little Mosque on the Prairie.” Banipal Magazine of Modern Arab Literature 30 (2007). Web. 4 Oct. 2010. Rev. of The Girl in the Tangerine Scarf, by Mohja Kahf. Publishers Weekly 14 Aug. 2006: 180. “PEW Forum on Religion & Public Life / U. S. Religious Landscape Survey.” CBS News. Web. 4 Oct. 2010. Robinson, B. A. “Number of Muslims in the U.S.” Religious Tolerance Web site. 14 June 2010. Web. 4 Oct. 2010. “Tangerine Scarf: A Story of Muslims in America.” Morning Edition. National Public Radio. 7 Dec. 2006. Web. 1 Oct. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Abdurraqib, Samaa. “Making It Survive Here and ‘Dreams of Return’: Community and Identity in the Poetry of Mohja Kahf.” Arab Voices in Diaspora: Critical Perspectives on Anglophone Arab Literature. Ed. Layla Al Maleh. Amsterdam: Rodopi, 2009. 44962. Cross/Cultures: Readings in the Post/Colonial Literatures in English 115. This essay investigates the themes of Kahf’s poetry. The ideas of community and identity are also thoroughly explored in The Girl in the Tangerine Scarf. Hoyt, Heather Marie. “An ‘I’ for Intimacy: Rhetorical Appeal in Arab American Women’s Literature.” Dissertation Abstracts International, Section A: The Humanities and Social Sciences 67.6 (2006): 2156. Hoyt compares Kahf’s works to the writings of Suheir Hammad and Naomi Shihab Nye, two other female Arab American writers. Gale Resources
“Mohja Kahf.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Open Web Sources
Kahf’s publisher, Public Affairs Books, offers a summary and excerpt of The Girl in the Tangerine Scarf on their web page. A short profile of Kahf is also TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Girl in the Tangerine Scarf
available. http://www.publicaffairsbooks.com/ publicaffairsbooks-cgi-bin/display?book= 9780786715190
blending modern life with traditions such as wearing the hijab, providing a complex picture of growing up Muslim in Australia.
A profile of Kahf as a writer and a poet is available in the New York Times online archives. The article discusses Kahf’s poetry, her decision for Khadra to remain veiled, and one of Kahf’s readings. http://www .nytimes.com/2007/05/12/books/12veil .html?_r=1
Kahf, Mohja. E-mails from Scheherazad. Gainesville: UP of Florida, 2003. Print. Kahf’s collection of poetry includes many of the same themes of belonging and self-discovery found in The Girl in the Tangerine Scarf. Many of the poems discuss being a Muslim woman in a Western world.
Online reviewer Zainab (AnonyMouse), a conservative Muslim, reviewed The Girl in the Tangerine Scarf from a conservative viewpoint, praising the novel for being so true to Muslim life in middle America, but criticizing the compromises Khadra makes in her faith. http://muslimmatters.org/2007/08/11/ the-girl-in-the-tangerine-scarf-book-review/
Mernissi, Fatima. Dreams of Trespass: Tales of a Harem Girlhood. Reading: Addison-Wesley, 1994. Print. This true story describes life growing up in the 1940s in Morocco. Mernissi remembers the extended family structure of the modest harem where she grew up and she explains how her mother taught her to be rebellious, rather than accepting of her position in life.
On her Boston Bibliophile blog, reviewer Marie talked about her experience reading The Girl in the Tangerine Scarf with her interfaith book club, and what made the title a good choice. http://www. bostonbibliophile.com/2010/02/review-girl-intangerine-scarf-by-mohja.html For Further Reading
Abdel-Fattah, Randa. Does My Head Look Big in This? New York: Orchard, 2007. Print. Australian-born Amal, of Muslim Palestinian descent, is a devout Muslim teen faced with constant misunderstandings about her life and her faith. The novel, geared toward a young adult audience, follows Amal’s difficulties
Tan, Amy. The Hundred Secret Senses. New York: Putnam, 1995. Known for her novels about family relationships among women and feelings of being an outsider, Tan creates the story of two half-sisters from different world views. Kwan is superstitious; she was raised in China and believes she can see ghosts. Olivia is more assimilated to the modern culture around her, but she is fascinated by Kwan’s stories of ghosts. As adults, the sisters and Olivia’s ex-husband Simon go to China on a magazine assignment, where Olivia begins to understand her sister’s perspective.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Alana Abbott
481
The Girl Who Played Go By Shan Sa
W Introduction Originally published in French as La joueuse de go (2001), The Girl Who Played Go (2003) traces the unlikely relationship between a middle-class Chinese teenager and a Japanese soldier. Set during Japan’s occupation of Manchuria in the 1930s, the work depicts the ongoing game of Go between the two characters, who remain unnamed until the end of the novel. Go is an ancient strategy game in which two players battle for dominance of a game board using black and white stones. The book’s narration moves back and forth between the young woman and the soldier, replicating the movement of the game itself and the opposition between Japanese forces and the Chinese resistance. As the narration shifts between the two characters, it chronicles the events leading up to their first meeting, the contentious game to which they return over many weeks, and the slow development of their unspoken friendship. It also dramatizes the physical and psychological destruction of war and occupation, the cultural differences between the Chinese and the Japanese, and the imbalance of power between men and women. The novel has been praised for its unique storyline, its innovative narrative structure, and its treatment of sensitive issues.
W Literary and Historical Context
The Girl Who Played Go is set in Manchuria, a region in northeast Asia that has a long and contested history. During the 1930s Manchuria was under the control of the Japanese military, which had assassinated the Manchurian warlord Zhang Zuolin in 1928, launched an invasion in 1931, and set up a puppet government. After the invasion numerous Japanese forces and settlers
poured into Manchuria, displacing native farmers and landowners. Although official Chinese resistance to the Japanese occupation ended with a cease-fire on February 27, 1932, guerrilla forces continued to mount attacks on Japanese troops during the occupation, which lasted through World War II. The novel depicts the brutality of the conflict between the Japanese and Chinese armies. The female narrator, Song of the Night, remembers when “the Japanese besieged us, and the shelling went on for days.” She also recalls when, following the surrender of Chinese troops, “according to rumors, 3,000 men were taken outside the town and shot.” Song of the Night meets the Japanese lieutenant when he is sent undercover to the town’s square to play Go with suspected Chinese revolutionaries. Later she chances upon a guerrilla assault in the marketplace, and is saved by the young revolutionary Min, who becomes her lover. As her friendship with Min and his roommate Jing unfolds, she continues to play Go with the Japanese lieutenant. Eventually, Jing, Min, and their female friend Tang are arrested as revolutionaries. Jing confesses under torture, but Min and Tang are executed. In the aftermath of the executions, Song of the Night flees to Peking with Jing, only to face the horrors of a Japanese bombing campaign and capture by Japanese soldiers.
W Themes Shan Sa contrasts Song of the Night’s point of view as a middle-class Chinese woman with that of the Japanese lieutenant. At the beginning of the novel, the lieutenant notes with disgust that “the Chinese Empire has sunk irretrievably into chaos,” steadfastly believing that “we [the Japanese] are their saviors.” Fueled by his pride in Japanese history and culture, he writes to his younger brother that “We will all die some day. Only our nation will live on. Thousands of generations of patriots will together create Japan’s eternal greatness.” His
482 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Girl Who Played Go
perspective is altered over time by his war experiences and his love for Song of the Night. At the end of the novel, he encounters her after she has fled a bombing raid on Peking and been captured by his men, who are about to rape her. He persuades the men to let him have the first turn, then tries to comfort her as she begs him to kill her. After promising that “for your sake I’m going to turn my back on this war and betray my own country,” he kills Song of the Night and then himself. Song of the Night’s powerlessness at the end of the novel is just one of the many examples of sexual inequality described by Sa. Song of the Night’s friend Huong feels powerless when her father threatens to stop supporting her if she refuses to marry the man he has chosen for her, even though she sees the marriage as legally sanctioned rape. Song of the Night’s siser, Moon Pearl, explains that marriage to an unfaithful man ruined her: “I was like a silkworm, spewing the best of me from my insides, and now I’m just a barren husk.” The narrator herself concludes that “men are spiders who weave traps for women with their seed” when she becomes pregnant with Min’s child, only to have him betray her by marrying his friend Tang in prison. The Japanese lieutenant’s memories of Miss Sunshine, an apprentice geisha whom he loved before the war, also underscore inequalities between men and women in Japanese society. Traditionally geisha are “deflowered” by wealthy men who pay large sums of money for the privilege. Miss Sunshine’s mother attempts to protect her daughter from this practice by paying for the ceremony herself and asking the Japanese lieutenant to serve as her daughter’s first sexual partner.
W Style The Girl Who Played Go is composed in short chapters (some are little more than a page in length), with narration alternating between Song of the Night and the Japanese lieutenant. Although the two characters do not begin their game of Go until midway through the novel, many commentators have noted that the narrative structure parallels the back-and-forth movement of the game, in which players alternate placing stones on a game board. In representing the invasion and occupation from first one viewpoint and then the other, the novel mirrors the warfare it describes. The back-andforth motion continues after the characters begin their game, with each reflecting on the game’s progress, the opponent, and the day-to-day struggles of life in war-torn China. The novel concludes with the Japanese lieutenant’s narration of his own death: “I fall onto the girl who played go. Her face looks pinker than it did earlier. She is smiling. I try very hard to keep my eyes open so I can look at my beloved.” The novel is written in a style that Janice P. Nimura describes in the New York Times Book Review as “spare
MAJOR CHARACTERS HUONG is Song of the Night’s friend. She revels in the attention of her many male admirers, whom she has learned to manipulate for gifts. After her father arranges a marriage for her, she is faced with the decision to refuse the match and lose her father’s financial support or go forward with an unsuitable marriage. She ultimately becomes the mistress of a wealthy banker to avoid the marriage. THE JAPANESE LIEUTENANT is one of the novel’s two narrators. Because he speaks Mandarin, he is sent to play Go in the center of town disguised as a Chinese man, with the hope he might ferret out revolutionaries. Instead he enters into a lengthy game with a mysterious and silent Chinese girl, Song of the Night, with whom he falls in love. When she asks him to help her run away, he refuses and immediately regrets his decision. Despite his reverence for Japan, he chooses to honor his connection with Song of the Night over his ties to his country. JING is Min’s close friend and the son of the town’s new mayor. He confesses his love for Song of the Night despite her relationship with Min. After he and his friends are arrested, Jing confesses under torture. He is the only one to escape execution and lives on in constant fear and shame. MIN is Song of the Night’s lover. The two meet when he rescues her from a rebel attack. Jing suggests that Min was only using Song of the Night for pleasure and that he had always loved his fellow rebel Tang, whom he marries before they are both executed. MISS SUNLIGHT is the geisha whom the Japanese lieutenant loved in Japan. SONG OF THE NIGHT is the female narrator, whose name is only revealed right before her death. Although she came from a prosperous, Westernized family, she falls into despair after an unplanned pregnancy, the execution of her lover, and an abortion. She runs away with Jing but is captured by Japanese troops and killed by the Japanese lieutenant at her own request. TANG is a female revolutionary. A longtime friend of Min’s, she marries him in prison before the two are executed. Song of the Night later suspects they were lovers.
prose adorned with images that linger in the mind.” Sa employs numerous metaphors to describe her characters and their emotions. The Japanese lieutenant is particularly drawn to metaphor. Contemplating the mysterious girl with whom he has been playing a drawn-out game of Go, he explains that “she is a mountain that protrudes from a cloudy sky, only to melt all the more surely into the fog.” Song of the Night, though generally more direct and less poetic than her opponent, also frequently thinks in
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
483
The Girl Who Played Go
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Shan Sa was born Yan Ni in Beijing, China, on October 28, 1972. She began writing poetry at a very early age, publishing her first works when she was only eight years old. After the massacre at Tiananmen Square, she left China to live with her father in Paris. There she attended L’École alsacienne, where she studied philosophy and sociology. She also developed an interest in painting and worked with the avant-garde painter Balthus. Some commentators have noted the effects of Sa’s training as a painter on the descriptive detail of her later writings. Her first novel, Porte de la paix céleste, which means “gate of celestial peace,” was published in 1999. The work was met with critical acclaim and garnered a Prix Goncourt. Although her third novel, The Girl Who Played Go was the first to be translated into English. It too was awarded a Prix Goncourt. Sa has continued to write novels, several of which have been translated into English.
metaphors. Reflecting on her aging father, for example, she comments, “Life is a castle of lies slowly dismantled by the passage of time.”
W Critical Reception When it was first published in France in 2001, The Girl Who Played Go received numerous critical accolades, garnering Sa her second Prix Goncourt, France’s top literary prize. The work was the first of Sa’s novels to be translated into English, and the translation won the Kiriyama Prize, which recognizes works depicting the diverse peoples and experiences of the Pacific Rim and South Asia. Praising Sa’s work in East-West Connections, Andrea Kempf notes that “her greatest achievement is the creation of two compelling characters whose youth is betrayed by the events of their time and who carry the novel and the game of Go to its ultimately inevitable conclusion.” Many commentators have considered the effects of Sa’s artistic training on her language and eye for descriptive detail. Alan Cheuse’s World Literature Today review, for example, asserts that “the language is frank, yet lyrical, and the story exact yet elegiac, dreamburdened yet realistic.” Other reviewers, interested in Sa’s unique position as a woman of Chinese origin writing in French, have investigated how this straddling of cultures affects her work. Sarah A. Smith’s Guardian review contends that the book “marks Shan Sa out as one of several diaspora
A teenage Chinese girl and a Japanese soldier play the ancient Chinese game of Go in The Girl Who Played Go. ª Photo Japan / Alamy
484
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Girl Who Played Go
In The Girl Who Played Go, a young Chinese girl starts a friendship with a Japanese soldier. The novel is set during the 1930s when Japan occupied Manchuria. ª Bettmann/Corbis
writers currently experimenting with a fusion of western and eastern traditions.” Some reviews of the novel, however, have been less positive. Writing in the Washington Post, Amy Kroin describes Sa as a “purveyor of strained metaphors” and comments that “no detail or sentiment is allowed to exist on its own; it must be compared to something else, and generally in such an intricately specific way that the effect is distracting rather than revealing.” She also faults the novel for its numerous footnotes, which she suggests make it “feel more like an academic work.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Cheuse, Alan. “Off the Air: Book Reviews from National Public Radio.” World Literature Today 79.3-4 (2005): 14+. Kempf, Andrea. Rev. of The Girl Who Played Go, by Shan Sa. East-West Connections 5.1 (2005): 194+. Kroin, Amy. “War Games.” Washington Post 4 Jan. 2004: T09. Print.
Nimura, Janice P. “More Violent Than Chess.” New York Times Book Review 26 Oct. 2003: 24. Sa, Shan. The Girl Who Played Go. Trans. Adriana Hunter. New York: Knopf, 2003. Print. Smith, Sarah A. “Rules of the Game.” Guardian [London] 24 May 2003: 27. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Bantick, Christopher. Rev. of The Girl Who Played Go, by Shan Sa. Sydney Morning Herald 17 May 2003: 16. Print. Explores the role of the game of Go in The Girl Who Played Go and praises the novel’s unexpected but fitting ending. Rev. of The Girl Who Played Go, by Shan Sa. Kirkus Reviews 15 Sept. 2003: 1152. Lauds Sa’s historical insight and development of her central characters. Rev. of The Girl Who Played Go, by Shan Sa. Publishers Weekly 29 Sept. 2003: 43. Emphasizes Sa’s depiction of her female protagonist’s budding sexuality.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
485
The Girl Who Played Go
Hoffert, Barbara. Rev. of The Girl Who Played Go, by Shan Sa. Library Journal 15 Oct. 2003: 100. Admires Sa’s writing style but finds the novel somewhat cold. Lawson, Anthea. Rev. of The Girl Who Played Go, by Shan Sa. Times [London] 14 May 2003: 20. Print. Focuses on the author’s biography and style of writing. Marler, Myrna. Rev. of The Girl Who Played Go, by Shan Sa. Kliatt Mar. 2005: 23. Praises the novel’s imagistic language. Taylor, Alan. Rev. of The Girl Who Played Go, by Shan Sa. Herald [Glasgow] 31 July 2004. Print. Relates the events of the novel to the author’s family history and explores the political metaphors inherent in the characters’ game of Go. Gale Resources
“Sa Shan.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Open Web Sources
The author’s official Web site offers a biography, book overviews, and a list of her awards, as well as information about her art exhibits. http://shan-sa. com/profile.html The online magazine Bookslut features a review of The Girl Who Played Go that explores the tangled relationship between love, war, and the game of Go in Sa’s novel. http://www.bookslut.com/fiction/ 2004_02_001506.php PEN American Center provides a brief biography of Shan Sa on its Web site. http://www.pen.org/page.php/ prmID/758
486
The WaterBridge Review has an online critique of The Girl Who Played Go as part of its series on Kiriyama Prize-winning novels. http://www.waterbridgere view.org/032004/rvw_girl_who.php For Further Reading
Gallagher, John. Geisha: A Unique World of Tradition, Elegance and Art. London: Collins, 2003. Print. This work of nonfiction introduces the geisha tradition, exploring the role of the geisha and the perception of these women both in Japan and among foreigners. Sa, Shan. Alexander and Alestria: A Novel. Trans. Adriana Hunter. New York: Harper, 2008. Print. Sa’s novel (originally published in French as Alexandre et Alestria: Roman, 2006) is a fictional biography of Alexander the Great. Shotwell, Peter. Go! More Than a Game. Boston: Tuttle, 2003. Print. This introduction to the game of Go includes a history of the game and essays about its role in Asian culture. Tsunetomo, Yamamoto. Hagakure: The Book of the Samurai. Trans. William Scott Wilson. New York: Kodansha, 2002. Print. Translated from the original Japanese text of Yamamoto Tsunetomo (1659-1719), this work serves as a manual for samurai. It outlines the traditions and beliefs that are so important to the male narrator of The Girl Who Played Go. Young, Louise. Japan’s Total Empire: Manchuria and the Culture of Wartime Imperialism. Berkeley: U of California P, 1998. Print. This nonfiction work traces Japan’s imperial role in Manchuria. Greta Gard
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Glass Room By Simon Mawer
W Introduction The Glass Room (2009) by Simon Mawer chronicles the lives of Viktor and Liesl Landauer, a prosperous couple living in Czechoslovakia during the late 1920s and 1930s. Viktor, a wealthy mogul who manufactures automobiles, marries Liesl, a forwarding-thinking woman with a passion for modern art and architecture. On their honeymoon the Landauers meet Rainer von Abt, the architect who will design their futuristic home, which features chrome, clean lines, and glass. The centerpiece of the house is the expansive Glass Room, with its onyx wall, sparse furnishings, and modern art. As the novel progresses and the events leading up to World War II begin to unfold, the Landauers are forced to flee their home. Viktor, who is of Jewish descent, fears the possibility of a German invasion and begins funneling money to Switzerland. The Landauers escape to Switzerland and eventually to America, while ownership of their prized house passes from one government to another, ultimately becoming a museum. A compelling story that is deeply engaged with history, ideas, and aesthetics, The Glass Room garnered numerous positive reviews and was a finalist for the 2009 Man Booker Prize.
W Literary and Historical Context
During the 1920s, as Europe was rebounding from World War I, a wave of modernism and rational thinking swept the continent. Dadaism, cubism, and surrealism, for example, were among the artistic movements that developed during this period in response to the complex political, social, and economic conditions of the industrialized world. The Nazis vehemently rejected modern art because of their belief that it was corrupted by Jewish influence, preferring instead the “purity” of classical
Greek and Roman art and architecture. In The Glass Room the cultured, progressive Landauers boldly embrace the ideals represented by modern art through the construction of their home, considered ahead of its time with its chrome pillars and glass walls. Mawer based the novel’s fictional Landauer House on the Villa Tugendhat in the city of Brno, Czech Republic, which was designed by German architect Ludwig Mies van der Rohe in the late 1920s as a celebration of space and light. The Villa Tugendhat even features an onyx wall similar to the one in Mawer’s novel, as well as furniture designed specifically for the home. In the 1990s the villa was opened to the public as a museum (as is the Landauer House in The Glass Room). In the novel the undercurrent of social unrest and the eventual threat of a German invasion overshadow the Landauers’ life of ease and luxury. By the late 1930s Nazi leader Adolf Hitler was determined to annex Czechoslovakia. Ultimately the country ceased to exist and was divided and absorbed into the German Third Reich. These events, coupled with the growing antiSemitism that pervaded the German national mind-set, led to the persecution and displacement of many Jews in Czechoslovakia and throughout Europe. The Landauers are representative of this group, as they lose their beloved home, are forced to flee their country and later Europe, and are cut off from friends and loved ones to escape the horrors that Jews endured during World War II.
W Themes The Glass Room functions as the central symbol around which the book’s major themes develop. Upon the room’s completion, Liesl remarks that in the Glass Room “‘you feel so free, so unconstrained. The sensation of space, of all things being possible.’” Ironically, the transparency of the Glass Room draws attention to its occupants’ secrets, such as Viktor’s extramarital affair and
487 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Glass Room
MAJOR CHARACTERS RAINER VON ABT is the architect who designs Landauer House and conceives of the Glasraum, or Glass Room. His philosophy of architecture is to “capture and enclose the space within” rather than merely to “build walls and floors and roofs.” A devotee of the revered architect Adolf Loos, Abt believes that “ornament is crime,” preferring instead clean lines, modern materials, and understated furnishings. HANA HANÁKOVÁ is the best friend of Liesl Landauer. Hana, though married, is bisexual and openly promiscuous. She declares her love for Liesl, and the novel intimates that Liesl and Hana have a physical relationship. Hana’s husband is Jewish, and the couple suffers at the hands of the Nazis during the war. KATALIN KALMIN is the Jewish mistress of Viktor Landauer. She works as a seamstress and a prostitute to provide for herself and her young daughter. When the Nazis invade Austria, she becomes a refugee and by coincidence finds herself in Viktor’s home. Viktor’s wife, Liesl, not knowing that Katalin is her husband’s mistress, invites Katalin to stay with the family and serve as a caregiver to their children. LIESL LANDAUER, wife of Viktor Landauer, embraces modern art, architecture, and music. After Liesl’s long and difficult recovery following the birth of her second child, her marriage to Viktor becomes strained. Liesl eventually befriends Viktor’s mistress, Katalin. VIKTOR LANDAUER is a wealthy Jewish automobile manufacturing magnate. At the onset of World War II, he and his family are forced to flee to Switzerland to avoid persecution by the Nazis. Viktor develops a relationship with a Jewish prostitute who, in a twist of fate, comes to live with his family.
a rape that occurs there after Nazis take over the house. Also ironic is the fact that such a seemingly fragile structure remains intact amid the destructive forces of war, while human values and life seem almost disposable. Occupants come and go and ownership of the house changes hands, but the Glass Room remains. In their quest for racial purity, the Nazis use the Glass Room to conduct experiments to determine whether individuals possess physical qualities that are distinctly Jewish. These degrading trials prove inconclusive, and the Nazis abandon the project. In his Washington Post review, Ron Charles notes that in this regard “the architecture proves purer than the human spirit.” Themes of progress and innovation, also suggested by the Glass Room, resonate throughout the novel. Viktor fervently believes that “inovace and pokrok, innovation and progress,” are paths to peace and that the Czechs can “choose” their history. The Glass Room
488
In The Glass Room, Viktor and Liesl Landauer are forced to flee their newly built Czechoslovakian home when German troops begin to invade. ª Hulton-Deutsch Collection/Corbis
represents what people are capable of envisioning and creating when they are at liberty to pursue their own destinies. The architect who designs the Landauer House comments that “ever since Man came out of the cave he has been building caves around him, [ . . . ] but I wish to take Man out of the cave.” The Glass Room reflects the effort to lift humankind out of savagery, even as the war encroaches on freedoms and destroys lives. Viktor’s argument that people can choose their own history is negated as he is forced to flee from his homeland to avoid persecution by the Nazis.
W Style The Glass Room features an omniscient third-person narrator with a direct, matter-of-fact, almost clinical voice. In his analysis for the Guardian, Ian Sansom notes the “dreamlike simplicity” of Mawer’s prose. Anita Brookner, writing in the Spectator, observes that the novel is written with a “clarity” that is “almost unfamiliar.” Charles offers another perspective on Mawer’s writing style, suggesting that he “has written this novel as though it were a translation, endowing his prose with a patina of Old World formality that sounds all the more romantic.” For the contemporary, English-speaking reader, this foreign ambiance, or sense of cultural distance, is further developed by the author’s liberal use of German and Czech terms and his periodic inclusion of TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Glass Room
in-text definitions and explanations to clarify nonEnglish expressions. Thematically, the use of German and Czech terms reflects the intermingling of cultures and the growing German dominance in the region. As Charles points out, each language has significance in the context of the historical moment, as “choosing to speak Czech or German or English becomes a matter of resistance or collusion or hope.” In his approach to storytelling, Mawer avoids using a linear narrative, choosing instead to capture seemingly random events that, when viewed in the context of the whole, imbue the tale with a sense of continuity and dimension. The main action of the novel spans more than a decade, and each chapter propels the reader to some point weeks or months into the future. The buildup to World War II looms in the background, at first only in vague allusions in the novel, but increasing in prominence as the war intrudes bit by bit upon the lives of the characters.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Simon Mawer was born in 1948 in England. His father served in the Royal Air Force, and the family moved frequently during the author’s childhood, spending several years in Cyprus and Malta in addition to England. Mawer credits these experiences with giving him an understanding of feelings associated with exile, a concept that he explores in The Glass Room. He attended Brasenose College, Oxford, earning a degree in zoology. Mawer has taught biology in several countries and has lived in Italy since 1977. At age forty he published his first novel, Chimera (1989), which won the McKitterick Prize. The Glass Room is Mawer’s eighth novel. His body of work also includes two nonfiction titles: A Place in Italy (1992) and Gregor Mendel: Planting the Seeds of Genetics (2006).
Viktor Landauer, a man of Jewish heritage, and his wife escape from Czechoslovakia and move to Switzerland as the German invasion begins. ª Hulton-Deutsch Collection/Corbis
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
489
The Glass Room
W Critical Reception Upon its publication The Glass Room garnered largely positive reviews. Critics have particularly admired Mawer’s compelling plot structure and the straightforward, unadorned nature of his prose. Sansom, for example, characterizes the book as “a thing of extraordinary beauty and symmetry.” James Purdon, reviewing the work for the Observer, likewise argues that “like the house, the novel is flawlessly constructed, revealing the careful plan of its reflections and symmetries, the lines of force hidden in its surfaces and its concealed architecture.” Reviewers have also praised Mawer’s seemingly effortless ability to incorporate German and Czech terms without disrupting the natural flow of the text. Reviewing the work in the Washington Post, Ron Charles recognizes Mawer’s skill with language, remarking that the author’s “attention to foreign languages enriches every episode.” In addition, critics have lauded Mawer for his ability to bring to life the cold, impersonal space of the Glass Room. Writing in the New York Times Book Review, Alison McCulloch asserts that the Glass Room becomes a “main character” in the novel, a passive and “unsympathetic” observer of the events that play out both in the world and in the lives of the characters. The Glass Room becomes “a window on the hopes and fears of its various inhabitants and the conflicts that rip Europe apart.” Some reviewers, however, have pointed out that the story loses some of its momentum later in the novel. Events become predictable, even inevitable, much like the real-life history that unfolded during the midtwentieth century. Nevertheless, critics insist that this slowdown in the novel’s final chapters does not detract from the overall success of the work. Brookner observes that even though “in the latter part of the novel the interest trails off, [ . . . ] like the house, the structure endures.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Brookner, Anita. “Pure, but Never Simple.” Rev. of The Glass Room, by Simon Mawer. Spectator 28 Feb. 2009: 29. Literature Resource Center. Web. 26 Aug. 2010. Charles, Ron. “The Windows of War.” Rev. of The Glass Room, by Simon Mawer. Washington Post 11 Nov. 2009. Web. 26 Aug. 2010. Mawer, Simon. The Glass Room. New York: Other Press, 2009. Print. McCulloch, Alison. “Fiction Chronicle.” Rev. of The Glass Room, by Simon Mawer. New York Times Book Review 24 Jan. 2010: 14(L). Print. Purdon, James. Rev. of The Glass Room, by Simon Mawer. Observer 25 Apr. 2010. Web. 26 Aug. 2010.
490
Sansom, Ian. “Design for Living.” Rev. of The Glass Room, by Simon Mawer. Guardian 24 Jan. 2009. Web. 28 Aug. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Chamberlain, Lesley. Rev. of The Glass Room, by Simon Mawer. Independent [London] 13 Feb. 2009. Web. 26 Aug. 2010. Favorable assessment that explores historical context and character development in the novel. Rev. of The Glass Room, by Simon Mawer. New Yorker 21 Dec. 2009: 139. Print. Brief review that focuses on the function of the Glass Room in the Landauer House. Love, Barbara. Rev. of The Glass Room, by Simon Mawer. LJ Book Reviews 25 Dec. 2009. Literature Resource Center. Web. 26 Aug. 2010. Touts Mawer’s novel as a worthy finalist for the Man Booker Prize. Shilling, Jane. Rev. of The Glass Room, by Simon Mawer. Daily Telegraph 14 Jan. 2009. Web. 26 Aug. 2010. A positive review that praises Mawer’s sense of place and skill with language. Vaughan, David. “Simon Mawer Talks about The Glass Room.” Radio Prague 7 May 2010. Web. 26 Aug. 2010. An interview in which Mawer discusses his inspirations for the novel as well as the book’s historical context. Gale Resources
“Simon Mawer.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Literature Resource Center. Web. 26 Aug. 2010. Open Web Sources
Simon Mawer’s official Web site features excerpts from the author’s novels, samples of his nonfiction writing, and a brief biography. http://www .simonmawer.com The official Web site of the Man Booker Prize offers an interview with Simon Mawer in which he discusses The Glass Room. http://www.themanbookerprize. com/perspective/articles/1263 For Further Reading
Chacko, David. Like a Man. Cedarburg: Foremost, 2007. Print. Chacko’s action-adventure story highlights the Czech resistance during World War II. Held, Joseph, ed. The Columbia History of Eastern Europe in the Twentieth Century. New York: Columbia UP, 1993. Print. This collection, published by Columbia University, includes a chronology of events in Eastern Europe from 1918 to 1990, as well as chapters on Czechoslovakia, Germany, and Eastern Europe. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Glass Room
Loos, Adolf. Ornament and Crime: Selected Essays. Riverside: Ariadne, 1998. Print. The celebrated architect whose theories of design, architecture, and education are lauded in The Glass Room are detailed in this collection of thirty-six essays. Mawer, Simon. The Bitter Cross. Boston: Little, Brown, 2001. Print. Another of Mawer’s historical novels, The Bitter Cross takes place during the Protestant Reformation of the sixteenth century. The book
addresses the complex conflicts related to religion and war. Patterson, Charles. Anti-Semitism: The Road to the Holocaust and Beyond. Lincoln: iUniverse.com, 2000. Print. Patterson provides an overview of Jewish history in the context of the development of antiSemitism.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Harrabeth Haidusek
491
Gould’s Book of Fish By Richard Flanagan
W Introduction Starting with the title, Richard Flanagan’s Gould’s Book of Fish: A Novel in 12 Fish proves to be no ordinary novel. The chapters are divided by twelve fish paintings, and each chapter is printed in a different color to correspond to the type of material the fictional Gould used in making ink. The paintings were actually done by the real William Gould, a forger and murderer who was sent to Sarah Island in 1825 and died in 1831 while trying to escape. His paintings are now housed in the Allport Library and Museum of Fine Arts, part of the State Library of Tasmania. Flanagan used Gould’s life as the basis for this novel, which explores the concepts of truth and reality in the making of history as well as issues surrounding British colonization, industrialization, and scientific inquiry that include the exploitation of natives and the poor. The book, first published in 2001 and awarded the Commonwealth Writers’ Prize in 2002, is an example of magical realism.
W Literary and Historical Context
Magical realism originated in the visual arts and developed among Latin America writers. The term magical realism was coined in 1925 by Franz Roh, a German art critic who was trying to describe a visual response to the inexplicable aspects of reality. In the 1940s, Latin American writers took up the form, and its concept was explained in a notable 1949 essay by Cuban writer Alejo Carpentier. Eventually, Gabriel García Márquez, the 1982 Nobel laureate from Colombia, popularized this type of literature through his internationally acclaimed works, especially One Hundred Years of Solitude (1967). Magical realism combines the rational with the supernatural, situating the fantastic in the normal world.
It presents the paradox of unresolved opposites, involving shifting borders and changes, that attempts to convey a truer reality than conventional realism. Tasmania, with Hobart as its capital, consists of a large island and some smaller nearby islands, all of which is about 150 miles south of Australia. It has been a state in the Australian Commonwealth since 1901. It was named in 1856 after the Dutch explorer Abel Tasman, who saw it in 1642, although he called it Van Diemen’s Land after the governor of the Dutch East Indies. Aborigines had already populated the island for about 35,000 years. When the British colonized the island in 1803, there were an estimated ten thousand Aborigines divided into nine major ethnic groups. European diseases reduced this population to three hundred by 1833, and these individuals were removed to Flinders Island. The last full-blooded Aborigine died in 1876. The early settlers were mostly convict laborers and farmers, with harsh prisons established at Port Arthur and Macquarie Harbour. In the early twentyfirst century, Tasmania had 500,000 inhabitants and kept large areas as unspoiled, natural environments.
W Themes A major theme of Gould’s Book of Fish concerns the nature of truth. Gould’s tales constitute a variant history that counters the falsified Sarah Island records that Jorgen Jorgensen created to hide the truth about conditions and events at the prison. However, Gould is a professional con artist, practiced in deception, so the question is can the reader trust anything that he says. In addition, the version of Gould’s book that is provided is drawn from the memory of Sid Hammett and may not be accurate. The major characters are all insane and therefore untrustworthy, and what they know is part reality and part hallucination. Flanagan is thus asking how much of what is considered history is actually purposely or otherwise altered. If history is suspect, then a further question concerns the history of Tasmania and Australia, whether it is the
492 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Gould’s Book of Fish
MAJOR CHARACTERS CAPOIS DEATH ran a grog shop in Hobart until sentenced to Sarah Island where he builds a locomotive and a Mah-Jong Hall for the Commandant. THE COMMANDANT, insane, tyrannical, syphilitic, and a convict once himself, wears a gold mask, turns the prison into a trading post, and devises grandiose schemes. WILLIAM BUELOW GOULD, a forger and thief, is sent to a horrific Tasmanian prison where his artistic and storytelling talents result in The Book of Fish. SID HAMMETT, the narrator in the first chapter, finds Gould’s book, has it analyzed for authenticity, loses it while drunk, then resolves to rewrite it from memory. JORGEN JORGENSEN, the colony’s administrator, attempts to manipulate history by writing false reports about events on the island. TOBIAS ACHILLES LEMPRIERE, the colony’s rotund and ambitious surgeon, commissions Gould to paint the local fish and experiments with pickled aboriginal heads. POBJOY, the prison guard, likes to talk to Gould and viciously beat him. TUPENNY SAL, an Aborigine, is Gould’s lover and the Commandant’s mistress.
Gould’s Book of Fish: is set in a prison colony in Tasmania, Australia, in the 1830s. ª Michael S. Yamashita/Corbis
triumphant story of European civilization and progress or a horror story of oppression and genocide. Flanagan’s book reflects his concerns about aboriginal rights and those of families like his that came to Tasmania as convicts. Tied to these questions are reflections on freedom and the consequences of colonialism, commercial expansion, and unregulated scientific pursuit. The idea of progress was often used to justify the elimination of native populations and the use of cruel forced labor. In addition, Flanagan shows how beauty and horror can co-occur. His use of humor, even while describing torture and death, makes this point. Gould realizes that beauty and wonder are as limitless as ugliness and sin. His beautiful paintings are created in a prison. Thus, in the world of this novel, even in the worst of circumstances, Flanagan manages to counterbalance the negative with more positive outcomes and events.
W Style Each of the twelve fish that head the chapters has a metaphorical relationship to a character in the text so as
to strengthen the relationship between men and fish. The fish also represent Gould’s fears and dreams. By contrast, the men resemble each other more than the fish resemble each other in that all the characters are con men and incorrigible liars. The characters are not individualized. Gould is never all that realistic because his language is very literary, the story is in his head, and the history he provides is purposely intended to undercut the official version. Further, the novel does not contain much in the way of ordinary dialogue or plot. There is no linear chronology; rather, just as the book Hammett finds has the story written in a circular fashion with the text continuing on the back and in-between lines, so Gould’s story runs in circles and loops back on itself. The narrator never passes up a chance to digress, which may be an indicator of his madness or of the misty curtain that exists between fantasy and reality. Just as Gould painted pictures with watercolors, Flanagan paints pictures with words that evoke visual images and appeal to the senses. Flanagan is able to convey the torture and death on Sarah Island at the same time that his expressions are irreverent and humorous. The terror of the place is emphasized when Gould’s normally playful and enjoyable tone is removed.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
493
Gould’s Book of Fish
ABOUT THE AUTHOR A descendant of Irish convicts taken to Tasmania between 1845 and 1852, Richard Flanagan was born there in 1961 and was raised in Rosebery, a mining town. Although he left school at sixteen to work, he graduated from the University of Tasmania with honors in 1982. A Rhodes scholar, he then earned a master’s of letters from Oxford University. He worked as a river guide and laborer and wrote four history books before his first novel, Death of a River Guide (1994), which won the National Fiction Award. In 1997, Flanagan published The Sound of One Hand Clapping (Australian Booksellers Book of the Year Award and the Vance Palmer Prize for fiction), which became a movie, directed by Flanagan, and won best film at the 1998 Berlin Film Festival. Flanagan published The Unknown Terrorist in 2007 and Wanting in 2009. As of 2010, Flanagan, an avid canoeist, lived in Tasmania with his wife and children.
Otherwise, Gould’s humorous understatements serve to make the horror starker by contrast. All in all, Flanagan’s stylistic innovations regarding story line and language make for a unique reading experience.
W Critical Reception An oft-repeated adjective applied to Gould’s Book of Fish by critics is phantasmagoric, in reference to the procession of things seen or imagined and the constantly changing scenes in the story. Marc Kloszewski, in Library Journal, explained that “Flanagan’s darkly humourous tale is impressive in its ability to cross seamlessly the borders between the realistic and fantastic and carries a wonderful sense of drama and satisfying closure.” Nola Theiss commented in Kliatt that it is almost impossible to separate the “hallucinations, fantasies, and reality.” She also marveled that “Flanagan captures the time and place so well that the reader has no choice but to become submerged into the culture and swim, like one of Gould’s fish, with the current.” The language of the book has been one of its most noted features. Tom Vaughan, writing on Illiterarty.com remarked that the novel is “entertaining, stunningly wellimagined, and written in a prose that jigs effortlessly across the page about 90 percent of the time,” adding that Flanagan produces “perfect prose that can and will be deliciously colourful, revolting, joyous and cynical inside the same sentence.” D. J. Taylor remarked similarly in the Spectator about the “tremendous energy” of the
This photo shows Macquarie Harbour in Tasmania, the setting of the novel Gould’s Book of Fish. ª Julian Love/JAI/Corbis
494
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Gould’s Book of Fish
language with “every sentence throwing up its cargo of alliterative special effects.” Michiko Kakutani’s article in the New York Times called Gould’s Book of Fish a “wondrous, phantasmagorical meditation on art and history and nature” and described Flanagan’s achievement as giving readers “rhapsodic descriptions of the natural world in all its variety and ingenuity, startling tales of escape and redemption and detailed renderings of the baroque fantasies that crowd his characters’ minds.” John Dugdale’s review in New Statesman provided a summary of the novel’s elements: “a virtuoso exercise in period pastiche, a prison diary, a caustic critique of colonialism, a raunchy Georgian picaresque romp taking in three continents, a study of insanity, and a witty, self-conscious postmodern construct.” Wrapping many elements into one book, Flanagan has been considered too ambitious and confusing, but most critics have called the book a masterpiece of creativity. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Dugdale, John. “Lost on the Island of Forgetting.” Rev. of Gould’s Book of Fish, by Richard Flanagan. New Statesman 131.4590 (2002): 50. Print. Flanagan, Richard. Gould’s Book of Fish. Sydney: Pan Macmillan Australia, 2001. Print. Kakutani, Michiko. “Books of the Times: A Reborn Criminal Distills Beauty from a Prison’s Abominable Depths.” Rev. of Gould’s Book of Fish, by Richard Flanagan. nytimes.com. New York Times 26 Mar. 2002. Web. 2 Aug. 2010. Kloszewski, Marc. “Gould’s Book of Fish.” Rev. of Gould’s Book of Fish, by Richard Flanagan. Library Journal 127.5 (2002): 108. Print. Taylor, D. J. “Swimming in Magic Realism.” Rev. of Gould’s Book of Fish, by Richard Flanagan. Spectator 289.9072 (2002): 52. Print. Theiss, Nola. “Gould’s Book of Fish.” Rev. of Gould’s Book of Fish, by Richard Flanagan. Kliatt 38.5 (2004): 60. Print. Vaughan, Tom. “Book Review: Gould’s Book of Fish by Richard Flanagan.” Illiterarty.com. Book Reviews and Blogs by Bridget 9 May 2007. Web. 2 Aug. 2010.
Campbell, James. “Learning His Scales: Richard Flanagan’s Narrator Is a Nineteenth-century Convict Who Paints Fish.” Rev. of Gould’s Book of Fish, by Richard Flanagan. New York Times Book Review 107.15 (2002): 26. Print. Discusses Flanagan’s literary influences, motive, narrative energy, symbols, and digressions. Rev. of Gould’s Book of Fish, by Richard Flanagan. Publishers Weekly 249.12 (2002): 40. Print. Briefly summarizes the novel and its themes. O’Hara, Roberta. “Gould’s Book of Fish: A Novel in Twelve Fish.” Rev. of Gould’s Book of Fish, by Richard Flanagan. Bookreporter.com. Bookreporter.com, n.d. Web. 1 Aug 2010. Reviews the characters and background of the story then comments on its creativity and imagery. Routledge, Chris. “Recommended Reads: Gould’s Book of Fish by Richard Flanagan.” Rev. of Gould’s Book of Fish, by Richard Flanagan. chrisroutledge.co.uk. Chris Routledge 6 Oct. 2008. Web. 1 Aug. 2010. Analyzes the characters, structure, style, and themes of the novel. Shipway, Jesse. “Wishing for Modernity: Temporality and Desire in Gould’s Book of Fish.” Australian Literary Studies 12.1 (2003): 43+. Print. Makes the case that the book is Flanagan’s call for social structure transformation in Tasmania. Gale Resources
“Richard Flanagan.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Literature Resource Center. Web. 31 July 2010. http://galenet.galegroup.com/ servlet/GLD/hits?r=d&origSearch=true&o=Data Type&n=10&l=d&c=1&locID=itsbtrial&secondary= false&u=CA&t=KW&s=2&NA=Richard+Flanagan Open Web Sources
At http://www.powells.com/bibio/17-978080213 9597-3, the Web site for Powell’s Books, a synopsis, a staff review, and excerpts from published reviews are provided as well as reader comments. The Complete Review, at http://www.complete-review .com, provides review excerpts, a staff review, links to full reviews, and information about various authors. This site has a page on Gould’s Book of Fish.
Criticism and Reviews
The Web site http://groveatlantc.com contains a list of discussion questions about Gould’s Book of Fish and suggestions for further reading.
Birne, Eleanor. “Gould’s Book of Fish: A Novel in Twelve Fish by Richard Flanagan.” Rev. of Gould’s Book of Fish, by Richard Flanagan. independent.co.uk. Independent 14 June 2002. Web. 1 Aug. 2010. Analyzes influences, characters, plot, dialogue, and conclusion and provides a summary of the story.
Contemporary Writers has a page at http://www. contemporarywriters.com/authors/?p= auth03C19J465512635268 dedicated to Richard Flanagan, which includes a biography, a bibliography, and a critical perspective written by Garan Holcombe in 2005.
Additional Resources
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
495
Gould’s Book of Fish For Further Reading
Borges, Jorge Luis. The Aleph and Other Stories. Ed. Andrew Hurley. New York: Penguin Classics, 2004. Print. A collection of stories filled with philosophical questions and extrasensory surprises by an exemplar of magical realism. Bowers, Maggie Ann. Magic(al) Realism. New York: Routledge, 2004. Print. Explains the genre of magical realism and provides definitions, a history of the movement, and key works in fiction, film, and art. Carey, Peter. True History of the Kelly Gang: A Novel. New York: Vintage Books, 2001. Print. The fictional letters of legendary outlaw and folk hero Ned Kelly, describing the hard lives of the poor settlers who made Australia.
496
García Márquez, Gabriel. One Hundred Years of Solitude. New York: Harper Perennial, 2004. Print. A highly acclaimed magical realism novel about the dreams and struggles of a village, its founder, his descendants, and resident ghosts. Maxwell-Stewart, Harnish. Closing Hell’s Gates: The Life and Death of a Convict Station. Melbourne: Allen and Unwin, 2008. Print. A history of the brutal prison on Sarah Island, Tasmania, from 1822 to 1834. Melville, Herman. Herman Melville: Typee, Omoo, Mardi. New York: Library of America, 1982. Print. From the author of Moby Dick, three once very popular South Sea romances, which include adventure and political allegory. Lois Kerschen
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Great Fire By Shirley Hazzard
W Introduction
W Literary and Historical
Shirley Hazzard’s novel The Great Fire (2003) presents the devastation of war as the landscape for a love story. Set in Japan during the Allied occupation following World War II, the narrative centers on Aldred Leith, a decorated, yet disillusioned war hero. Consumed by loneliness and numbed by the traumas of battle, Aldred travels through East Asia chronicling a culture transformed by the consequences of war. After arriving in Japan to record the effects of the Hiroshima bombing, Aldred meets Helen Driscoll and her dying brother, Benedict. Although Helen is just seventeen years old and under the guardianship of her dictatorial father, Aldred is drawn to Helen and her unwavering devotion to her brother. As Aldred writes about the physical annihilation of the city, he begins to recognize the emotional scars within himself and seeks solace in the company of Helen and Benedict. He is amazed by the Driscolls’ precociousness and their connection to the literature they read. Despite his reservations, Aldred falls deeply in love with Helen whose impassioned, yet naive feelings rival his own. Despite their imminent parting, Aldred feels reconnected with the world and himself through the possibility of love and positive human relationship. A subplot of the novel focuses on the friendship between Aldred and Peter Exley. Exley, a war veteran prosecuting crimes committed by the Japanese military, has become even more disconnected from the world than Aldred. Their friendship is tested, yet strengthened by each man’s struggle to reinvent himself in the wake of death and destruction. Ultimately, The Great Fire demonstrates the transformative power of love to help people rise from the ashes and counteract the desolation of war. Through the redemption of Aldred and Exley, the novel illustrates the inherent human need for love to render life meaningful.
Context
A post–World War II Japan provides the setting for The Great Fire. After Japan refused to accept the Potsdam Declaration offered by the Allied powers during World War II, President Harry S. Truman ordered the bombings on Hiroshima on August 6, 1945, and on Nagasaki three days later. These nuclear attacks resulted in more than 150,000 deaths within the first few seconds. On August 15, 1945, Emperor Hirohito announced Japan’s surrender to the Allies, signaling the end of World War II. From 1945 to 1951, Japan was occupied by Allied forces, fronted by U.S. and U.K. militaries. Aldred arrives during this occupation period and witnesses the devastation of the Hiroshima bombing. As part of Japan’s political reform, several military tribunals, including the International Military Tribunal for the Far East, were created to arrest and prosecute Japan’s military leaders who had committed crimes against humanity. The International Military Tribunal for the Far East is similar to the tribunal in Hong Kong where Peter works as a prosecutor of war crimes.
W Themes The Great Fire examines the physical effects of war and the psychological scars left in its wake. Aldred observes the “wartime shambles of a harbor with its capsized shipping” (7) and the “ancient darkness” (9) that blankets the landscape. He realizes that this scene could be anywhere in the world, emphasizing war’s universal nature. The psychological damage caused by war is also explored, primarily through Aldred and Peter. Aldred has become consumed by a sense of detachment and suffers the loss of his youth, his marriage, and connection to his father. He is a passive spectator to his life, “his body chugging submissively” (3) as he travels by train through Asia. Peter
497 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Great Fire
MAJOR CHARACTERS BENEDICT DRISCOLL, the son of Brigadier Barry Driscoll, suffers from a fatal degenerative disease, yet impresses Aldred with his intellect, wit, and unwavering optimism. HELEN DRISCOLL, Benedict’s precocious younger sister, is devoted to Benedict and shares his passion for reading literature. She falls in love with Aldred and wishes to marry him despite the objections of her parents. PETER EXLEY is an Australian war veteran whose life was saved by Aldred during battle. He prosecutes crimes committed by the Japanese military and struggles to reinvent his future in the aftermath of war. ALDRED LEITH is a thirty-two-year-old British war hero commissioned to chronicle the effects of the bombing on Hiroshima. Through his love for Helen, he rediscovers hope for himself and for a postwar world.
has also disengaged from himself, using his war trauma as an excuse to withdraw from others. Closely tied to the theme concerning the consequences of war is a rediscovery of the capacity to love in spite of these consequences—that love and hope are
General Douglas MacArthur meets Japanese Emperor Hirohito in September 1945. The Great Fire is set in Japan two years after the end of World War II. ª Bettmann/Corbis
498
especially needed to leaven desolation and loss. Aldred concludes that “in the wake of so much death, the necessity to assemble life [is] urgent” (5). When he comforts Helen after the suicide of a Japanese soldier, he realizes that “the whole world needs comforting” (38). Through his bond with Helen, memories of war recede, his past is replaced with love, and he begins to fall asleep, “a saved man” (97). Even Exley opens himself up to the possibility of hope and the value of human connection when he attempts to save a sick child. As he rushes to the hospital with the girl in his arms, he feels “his existence stirring in its coma” (121). Overall, the universal message of The Great Fire is that people have the inherent desire and need to love and be loved. Hazzard demonstrates that human connection is necessary to give life meaning and that a lack of love can be devastating. As Aldred writes in his journal, “It is the incompleteness that haunts us” (43).
W Style Shirley Hazzard’s prose contains explicit literary allusions. These references to past literary figures enrich the characterization of Helen and Benedict and further the plot by engaging Aldred’s interest in the Driscolls, which then leads to his love for Helen. Aldred overhears Helen reading Edward Gibbon’s The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire to Benedict. He then learns of their fascination with Thomas Carlyle. This compels Aldred, a devotee of literature, to develop a relationship with them based on a shared admiration. When he later travels to Hong Kong, Aldred writes to Helen, telling her that “no one was reading Carlyle in the next room, or bringing [him] John Clare with tremulous hand” (95). Here, the allusions simultaneously signify his bond with her and his loneliness without her. Hazzard is also suggesting that through literature of the past, the characters have connected with one another and found solace in an uncertain present. Allusions to William Shakespeare as well as fairy-tale romance figures also figure prominently in the narrative. Aldred uses these allusions to portray his love affair with Helen as one not of sexual desire, but a pure, almost spiritual romance. As he observes Helen resting, he compares her to Sleeping Beauty. In conversations with Exley, he refers to Helen as the Changeling. He likens their love to that of Romeo and Juliet. This particular analogy emphasizes Aldred’s belief that their love is a passionate, yet impossible one—he is fifteen years older, her parents are vehemently opposed to the relationship, yet their love cannot be denied. The great fire of the novel’s title is a symbol and provides another distinction in Hazzard’s style. The title refers to the seventeenth-century blaze that engulfed London, and to the Blitz and the destruction of Hiroshima. The sensory imagery of flames, smoke, and TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Great Fire
ashes symbolizes to Aldred “loss and disruption” (31), which not only permeates Japan but the entire world. Although the great fires represent this global and personal displacement, they come to represent hope, the desire for love, and redemption. Aldred’s account of the effects of war begins to lose its importance, replaced by the story of him and Helen. He remembers once thinking that he would “die from the great fires into which his times had pitched him,” but now he “had discovered a desire to live completely; by which he meant, with her” (167). Finally, Exley discovers that war cannot destroy truth, and he intends to bring it “out of the fire, intact but with appropriate scars” (198).
W Critical Reception Shirley Hazzard’s keenly anticipated work The Great Fire (2003) arrived over twenty years after the publication of
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Shirley Hazzard was born on January 31, 1931, in Sydney, Australia. As a child, she traveled extensively because of her father’s diplomatic post. While living in Hong Kong, she was commissioned by British Intelligence in 1947 to chronicle the civil war in China. From 1952 to 1962, she worked for the United Nations (UN) Secretariat in New York. After a sojourn to Italy in 1962, she began to write fiction. After resigning from the UN, she published Cliffs of Fall and Other Stories (1963). Subsequent publications include The Evening of the Holiday (1966), The Bay of Noon (1970), and Transit of Venus (1980), winner of the National Book Critics Circle Award. After a twenty-year absence from fiction, she published The Great Fire in 2003 and was awarded the National Book Award for Fiction. As of 2010, Hazzard resided in New York.
The atomic bomb is dropped on Nagasaki, Japan. The Great Fire follows war hero Aldred Leith as he records the aftermath of the Hiroshima bombing. ª Nagasaki Atomic Bomb Museum/epa/Corbis TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
499
The Great Fire
her award-winning novel, The Transit of Venus (1980). Many reviewers, including Thomas Mallon, deemed Hazzard’s story a worthy follow-up to her last novel. Mallon, writing in the Atlantic, proclaimed, “Now Hazzard has at last, in the language of birth and publishing, delivered, and if The Great Fire lacks the astonishing densities of The Transit of Venus . . . , it still streaks through a reader’s ken in the manner of a comet.” Hazzard’s work was lauded for its vivid and accurate depiction of postwar Japan and East Asia. In her review in Quadrant, Jamie Grant wrote that readers “will be drawn in by the calm elegance of Hazzard’s prose, and by her convincing depiction of physical settings and social manners in several parts of the world.” Other reviewers noted how Hazzard’s richly drawn characters interact within an epic text, marked by the loss and disruption of war. In the Spectator, for example, Anita Brookner described the novel as “busy with an enormous sense of movement, as all alliances are haphazard, largely unsought, and above all temporary.” Brookner also commended Hazzard’s attention to the redemptive nature of love, pointing out that although the protagonists “are marked by an atmosphere of past and lost idealism,” the passion between Aldred and Helen characterize a “love story that surprises by its intensity.” However, some reviewers tempered their praise. Barbara Hoffert, in Library Journal, asserted that the novel was “magisterial” but ultimately “a dark book.” And, although Kirkus Reviews found fault with the narrative’s “slightly improbable ending,” it ultimately conceded that Hazzard’s novel was an “indescribably rich story,” which “moves from strength to strength,” and the Kirkus reviewer predicted, “no reader will be unmoved by its sorrowing, soaring eloquence.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Brookner, Anita. “Travelling Far without Finding Home.” Rev. of The Great Fire, by Shirley Hazzard. Spectator 293.9145 (2003): 60. Print. Grant, Jamie. “Unities and Proprieties.” Rev. of The Great Fire, by Shirley Hazzard. Quadrant June 2004: 92. Print. Hazzard, Shirley. The Great Fire. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2003. Print. “Hazzard, Shirley. The Great Fire.” Rev. of The Great Fire, by Shirley Hazzard. Kirkus Reviews 15 Aug. 2003: 1036+. Print. Hoffert, Barbara. “Hazzard, Shirley. The Great Fire.” Rev. of The Great Fire, by Shirley Hazzard. Library Journal 15 Oct. 2003: 98. Print. Mallon, Thomas. “Princess of Discrimination: Shirley Hazzard’s Masterly Descriptions and Expertly Drawn Characters Are in Full Evidence in This New Novel— Her First in More than Twenty Years.” Rev. of The
500
Great Fire, by Shirley Hazzard. Atlantic Nov. 2003: 156+. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Rev. of The Great Fire, by Shirley Hazzard. Antipodes 18.1 (2004): 81. Print. Claims The Great Fire is an epic text, citing its range and the depth of its scenes and protagonists. Rev. of The Great Fire, by Shirley Hazzard. Booklist 1 Jan. 2004: 776. Print. Describes The Great Fire as a work fraught with emotion, commenting on the redemptive power of love as protagonists search for meaning in the aftermath of war. Olubas, Brigitta. “Anachronism, Ekphrasis and the ‘Shape of Time’ in The Great Fire.” Australian Literary Studies 23.3 (2008): 279+. Print. Examines references to works of art and literature within The Great Fire and their import to the protagonists. ———. “Visual Art and Bourgeois Forms in Shirley Hazard’s Fiction.” Southerly 68.1 (2008): 13+. Print. Explores Hazzard’s creation of bourgeois culture in modern societies within selected novels, including The Great Fire. Gale Resources
Olubas, Brigitta. “Shirley Hazzard.” Australian Writers, 1950-1975. Ed. Selina Samuels. Detroit: Gale, 2004. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 289. Literature Resource Center. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. http://go. galegroup.com/ps/i.do?&id=GALE%7CH 1200011548&v=2.1&u=&it=r&p=LitRG&sw=w “Shirley Hazzard.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2006. Literature Resource Center. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. http://go.galegroup.com/ps/ i.do?&id=GALE%7CH1000043792& v=2.1&u=itsbtrial&it=r&p=LitRG&sw=w Open Web Sources
The National Book Foundation Web site, available at http://www.nationalbook.org/nba2003_shazzard. html, contains Hazzard’s National Book Award acceptance speech (2003), biographical information on the author, and excerpts from The Great Fire. For Further Reading
Cranna, Michael. The True Cost of Conflict: Seven Recent Wars and Their Effects on Society. New York: New York Press, 1995. Print. Examines the lesser-known economic, social, and moral consequences of the Gulf War and other international conflicts and compares these effects to those of World War II. Giangreco, D. M. Hell to Pay: Operation Downfall and the Invasion of Japan, 1945-1947. Annapolis: Naval TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Great Fire
Institute P, 2009. Print. Analyzes the U.S. motivation for the nuclear bombing of Japan in 1945. Hazzard, Shirley. Cliffs of Fall and Other Stories. New York: Knopf, 1963. Print. Collection of short stories that examines the relationship between men and women as they face issues of marriage, identity, and mortality. —-—. The Transit of Venus. New York: Penguin Books, 1980. Print. Tells the story of two orphaned sisters whose relationship is challenged as they choose different paths to obtain love and security.
Smith, Wendy. “Shirley Hazzard: In Life as in Art, It’s the Individual and the Truth that Matter Most to this Author.” Publishers Weekly 9 Mar. 1990: 48+. Print. Discusses Hazzard’s experience working for the United Nations Secretariat in New York and the subsequent publication of Countenance of Truth: The United Nations and the Waldheim Case (1990) and explains that for Hazzard truth functions in the creation of nonfiction and fiction.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Michele Hardy
501
The Great Man By Kate Christensen
W Introduction
W Literary and Historical
Kate Christensen’s novel The Great Man (2007) is less about the Great Man—fictional painter Oscar Feldman, already five years dead by the time the novel begins—and more about the unique, strong women in his life who survived him. Two very different biographers both decide to write Feldman’s life story, and in order to learn the great man’s secrets, they come calling on Claire (Teddy) St. Cloud, his longtime mistress; Abigail Feldman, his wife; and Maxine Feldman, his sister. Oscar Feldman was a hedonistic womanizer with charm to spare, who specialized, not surprisingly, in figurative painting of nude women. His sister Maxine, arguably the more talented of the two siblings, is less well known, laboring in the shadow of her flamboyant brother. Maxine, now in her eighties, is a cantankerous, caustic loner, who lives with her dog Frago and secretly lusts after her assistant Katerina. She despises Teddy, Oscar’s charismatic mistress of forty years, for trying to steal Oscar away from Abigail, his wife. In an effort to protect Oscar’s legacy, the women meet in order to ensure their stories are in agreement. Teddy, her best friend Lila, and Maxine all share a secret about Oscar and his work that they agree to keep from the biographers. Christensen portrays these women, all in their seventies and eighties, as highly intelligent, thoughtful, passionate, and erotic. Relating their stories about Oscar to the two biographers causes them to reassess their lives and make changes that move the plot forward. In the end, revelations about the great man are less important than these women and who they become over the course of the novel.
Context
Through the women’s interviews with the biographers, the reader learns Oscar Feldman’s opinion of his contemporaries. Though Feldman is fictional, the painters discussed (most of whom Feldman disdains) are not. Lucian Freud, mentioned by Teddy in one of the interviews, is an acclaimed German-born British painter (the grandson of Sigmund Freud) known for his nudes, just like the fictional Feldman. Though Teddy says Feldman dismissed Freud as talentless, the real-life Freud and the fictional Feldman have much in common. Freud, like Feldman, concentrated on realistic portraits of nudes when abstract expressionism was the style of many of his contemporaries. Also like Feldman, Freud has a reputation as a lothario, even in his eighties; with his many marriages and affairs, he is rumored to have fathered dozens of children. In 2008 Freud’s painting Benefits Supervisor Sleeping fetched the highest price ever paid for a painting by a living artist; a private collector purchased the nude portrait for $33.6 million. In the novel, biographer Henry Burke flatters Maxine Feldman by comparing her work to that of real-life abstract expressionist Franz Kline, who, like Maxine, painted his most famous works entirely in black and white. Kline, born in Pennsylvania in 1910, began as a figurative painter, like Feldman, but then turned to abstract expressionism in the 1940s. He died of heart failure in 1962. All the women in the novel were in their thirties and forties during the women’s liberation movement of the 1960s and 1970s; the choices available to younger women in these decades were nonexistent when the fictional characters were making key decisions about their
502 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Great Man
educations, careers and relationships. The options available during the 1950s, when Teddy and Lila were at Vassar, are reflected by their experiences: Teddy became a secretary, and Lila, who wanted to be a novelist, married an English professor and had three children. Thanks to organizations such as the National Organization for Women (NOW), founded in 1966, and civil rights legislation prohibiting sexual discrimination in the job market, women have more options in the early 2000s. Some women, however, are finding that having it all is a goal too difficult to achieve. Teddy’s daughters Ruby and Samantha have taken sides: Samantha is a stay-at-home mother with a domineering husband, while Ruby is a dedicated career woman with no intention of having a family. Each believes the other has made the wrong choice.
W Themes Art and sex are intertwined throughout the novel as forms of self-expression. Oscar, a charismatic and fascinating man by all accounts, loved women, and in addition to his wife and his mistress, he had numerous casual affairs. His artwork was an extension of his obsession with women; he painted female nudes in an aggressive, blatantly sexual style, or as Maxine puts it crudely in an interview with Henry Burke, “He f—ed them with brushes.” Teddy tells biographer Ralph Washington that the only abstract expressionist Oscar ever admired was Cecily Brown, a real life artist whose works are overtly sexual in nature. Maxine Feldman’s paintings are on the opposite end of the artistic (and sexual) spectrum: austere, colorless, and completely abstract. Maxine is a loner who finds the company of others a burden and a chore. Her irascible personality pushes people away, but she secretly fears dying alone and regrets her failed relationship with her former lover, Jane Fleming. The relationship ended as a result of Maxine’s failure to express her feelings. Though her paintings are not sexual in nature, Maxine channels her frustrations into her work, continuing to paint prolifically even in her eighties. Another theme that runs through the novel, especially in the story of Teddy St. Cloud, is that of control and independence. Teddy’s need to maintain control in her life and relationships explains her choice of Oscar Feldman as a mate; because he is married, and unavailable much of the time, their relationship allows Teddy to be in control of her home, the raising of their children, and her career. She knows she will never need to sacrifice any of that control in her life with Oscar. The fear of relinquishing control postpones her eventual involvement with Lewis, her former boss; her objection to the relationship is not lack of interest, but fear that the relationship will be an intense and involving one, with a man who is completely available to her. Similarly,
MAJOR CHARACTERS HENRY BURKE is the mild-mannered, sexually frustrated white biographer who comes to interview the women for his book on Oscar. ABIGAIL FELDMAN, Oscar’s long-suffering wife, spends most of her time at home caring for their autistic son Ethan, who is now forty-seven years old. MAXINE FELDMAN, the lesbian sister of Oscar is a cantankerous, misanthropic but brilliant abstract expressionist painter who labored for years in her brother’s shadow. OSCAR FELDMAN is the figurative painter who played a major role in all the women’s lives. A hedonistic lover of women, he died about five years before the novel begins. LILA SCOFIELD, Teddy’s best friend since college, was in love with Oscar from afar and lived vicariously through Teddy for years. CLAIRE (TEDDY) ST. CLOUD, Oscar Feldman’s faithful mistress of forty years, is a sharp, charismatic, and somewhat intimidating woman of seventy-four. RALPH WASHINGTON, another biographer, is an ambitious gay black man with many intellectual theories about Oscar and his art.
though Lila is initially thrilled to be involved with a younger man, she later confesses that she does not like what she becomes in a relationship: submissive, silly, and coquettish. The fear of relinquishing control is not an irrational one. Teddy’s daughter Samantha is dominated by a possessive husband who monitors her whereabouts and keeps her submissive; Samantha rationalizes the situation, saying that this is how marriage works. Because her mother and father were not married and her father rarely visited, she assumes this is true. In an effort to be the opposite of her mother, she sacrifices all control of her own life.
W Style Christensen’s choice of the omniscient viewpoint in The Great Man is important for a number of reasons. First, it gives readers a fuller, more complete portrait of Oscar Feldman, as seen from the viewpoints of several different characters. Second, because some of the characters are either antagonistic toward or unacquainted with the other characters, readers would
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
503
The Great Man
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Kate Christensen was born on August 22, 1962, in Berkeley, California. Her father was a radical Marxist lawyer who defended members of the Black Panthers, among others, and her mother studied at Juilliard to become a professional cellist. When her parents divorced in 1968, her mother took Christensen and her two younger sisters to Arizona, where Christensen received her PhD and became a clinical psychologist. After high school, Christensen attended Reed College in Portland, Oregon, majoring in English; she also attended the acclaimed Iowa Writers’ Workshop. Her first novel, In the Drink, was published in 1999, followed by Jeremy Thrane in 2001, and The Epicure’s Lament in 2004. The Great Man, for which Christensen won the PEN/ Faulkner Prize in 2008, was published in 2007. She followed this with the novel Trouble (2009). As of 2010, Christensen lived in Brooklyn, New York, with her husband.
learn little about them if the story were told from a first- or third-person point of view. Told from the omniscient viewpoint, the story can explore Maxine’s
crusty exterior and her hidden lonely, vulnerable, and insecure core. Christensen’s use of humor gives the characters dimension and makes the novel more enjoyable. The nebbishy biographer Henry Burke and his uptight counterpart Ralph Washington are at the mercy of the sharp-witted Teddy and Maxine, who leave them flustered and unsure. Christensen infuses more humor in the story with the use of creative similes and metaphors; when Henry’s baby is falling asleep in the baby carrier Henry wears, Christensen compares the baby as lolling like a drunk in a doorway. By having the two biographers interview the women, Christensen can tell their histories and reveal the character of Oscar Feldman without resorting to flashbacks or long paragraphs of expository prose. In addition, the way the different women react to the biographers gives readers more information about their characters as well. Because Christensen gives the biographers their own foibles and problems—Henry Burke, for instance, is a new father having trouble in his marriage—they are more than just a storytelling device; instead, they become characters in their own right.
Following the death of fictional artist Oscar Feldman in The Great Man, two separate biographers interview the three most important women in Feldman’s life: his wife, sister, and mistress. Kenneth V. Pilon/Shutterstock.com
504
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Great Man
W Critical Reception The Great Man was generally well received by critics, as evidenced by the PEN/Faulkner Award given to Christensen for the novel in 2008. In the New York Times, Janet Maslin praised the novel, calling it “as unexpectedly generous as it is entertaining.” Sue Corbett of People described Christensen’s characters as “exquisitely drawn,” an opinion echoed by Carol Memmott of USA Today, who wrote, “These characters are wonderfully developed.” Many reviewers were impressed by Christensen’s complex portrayal of aging women, women often relegated to the stereotypical roles of kindly grandmother or cranky old crone. Corbett wrote that Christensen “has raised the bar for writers who hope to realistically portray the aging American woman,” and a reviewer for Kirkus Reviews called the novel “a joyful art-world romp . . . that allows aging women to come across as sexy.” Not all reviewers were charmed by the story of these women, however. In a sarcastic negative review in Entertainment Weekly, Troy Patterson wrote that while the reader may find a few “droll bits” of humor in Christensen’s novel, these were not enough to compensate for her “overripe prose.” A few reviewers noted that the novel, while long on characterization, was short on plot. The reviewer from Kirkus Reviews described the plot as “flimsy,” and Corbett wrote, “Not much happens in the course of 300 pages.” Christine Perkins, in a mostly positive review for Library Journal, felt that the two biographers were “poorly developed,” calling them “bland and indistinguishable.” The novel opens with a fictional obituary of Feldman from the New York Times and ends with a book review of the two competing biographies. Some reviewers who otherwise praised the novel found these pieces to be less successful. Maslin called them “tone-deaf,” and a reviewer in Publishers Weekly, who described the rest of the novel as “eloquent,” wrote that the obituary and reviews were “less than convincing as artifacts.” Many critics, though, found The Great Man to be a finely crafted character study of four aging but lively women, made all the more enjoyable by Christensen’s dry wit. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
“Cecily Brown.” saatchi-gallery.co.uk. Saatchi Gallery. Web. 5 Sept. 2010. Christensen, Kate. The Great Man. New York: AnchorRandom House, 2008. Print. Corbett, Sue. “Books.” Rev. of The Great Man, by Kate Christensen. People 68.9 (2007), n.p. Print. “CWLU Chronology: A Timeline for Second Wave Feminism.” uic.edu. University of Illinois at Chicago. Web. 5 Sept. 2010.
Edge, Simon. “Lucien Freud: The Lothario.” express.co. uk. Daily Express 16 May 2008. Web. 5 Sept. 2010. Rev. of The Great Man, by Kate Christensen. Kirkus Reviews 15 June 2007. Print. Rev. of The Great Man, by Kate Christensen. Publishers Weekly 21 May 2007: 31. Print. “Lucien Freud Painting Sells for Record £17m.” telegraph.co.uk. Telegraph 14 May 2008. Web. 5 Sept. 2010. Maslin, Janet. “A Celebrated Artist Dies, Then His Life Gets Difficult.” Rev. of The Great Man, by Kate Christensen. New York Times 6 Aug. 2007. Print. Memmott, Carol. “Women Cover the Canvas of The Great Man.” Rev. of The Great Man, by Kate Christensen. USA Today 30 Aug. 2007: 4D. Print. Patterson, Troy. Rev. of The Great Man, by Kate Christensen. Entertainment Weekly 24 Aug. 2007: 139. Print. Perkins, Christine. Rev. of The Great Man, by Kate Christensen. Library Journal 1 Aug. 2007: 64. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Buchsbaum, Tony. “We Are What We Say.” Rev. of The Great Man, by Kate Christensen. januarymagazine. com. January Magazine Aug. 2007. Web. 6 Sept. 2010. Examines how the novel is not just about Oscar or the women in his life, but about the power of storytelling. Frey, Hillary. “An Art World Novel Lays It on Thick: Ex-Wives and Aging Mistresses.” Rev. of The Great Man, by Kate Christensen. observer.com. New York Observer 14 Aug. 2007. Web. 6 Sept. 2010. Asserts that the scope of Christensen’s novel is too broad and explains how this problem could have been fixed. Kleffel, Rick. Rev. of The Great Man, by Kate Christensen. bookotron.com 27 Sept. 2007. Web. 6 Sept. 2010. Describes how Christensen’s unflinching portrayal of the aging women gives depth and reality to the novel. Koch, Elizabeth. Rev. of The Great Man, by Kate Christensen. sfgate.com. San Francisco Chronicle 14 Aug. 2007. Web. 6 Sept. 2010. Criticizes the characterization in Christensen’s novel and examines problems with the novel’s structure. Seaman, Donna. “A Complex Palette.” Rev. of The Great Man, by Kate Christensen. chicagotribune.com. Chicago Tribune 22 Sept. 2007. Web. 5 Sept. 2010. Examines how Christensen uses pairs of opposites throughout the novel, especially black-and-white images.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
505
The Great Man Gale Resources
“Kate Christensen.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2010. Literature Resource Center. Web. 7 Sept. 2010. Open Web Sources
Random House Books maintains an author page on Kate Christensen, available at randomhouse.com/ features/katechristensen, which includes interviews with the novelist, descriptions of her books, and even recipes for the dishes Teddy, Abigail, and Maxine cook up in The Great Man. For Further Reading
Christensen, Kate. Trouble. New York: Anchor-Random House, 2010. Print. Follow-up to The Great Man, telling the story of a New York therapist who decides to leave her husband and join her troubled rock star friend on a jaunt to Mexico. Feaver, William. Lucian Freud. New York: Rizzoli, 2007. Print. Provides a biographical sketch of Freud, four interviews, and over four hundred reproductions of Freud’s work.
Classic by acclaimed food writer that Christensen reviewed for National Public Radio. Includes Fisher’s trademark poetic prose and a variety of oyster recipes. Gaugh, Harry F. Franz Kline. New York: Abbeville P, 1994. Print. Considered the definitive volume on Kline’s life and work. Includes biographical information Gaugh gleaned from interviews with Kline’s friends and critics and from Kline’s own correspondence. Also features 170 illustrations of the artist’s work. Hess, Barbara. Abstract Expressionism. Los Angeles: Taschen, 2009. Print. Includes an introduction, a timeline of the Abstract Expressionist movement, which began in the 1940s, plus photos and analyses of the most important works and artists. Updike, John. Seek My Face. New York: Knopf, 2002. Print. Another novel featuring the art world, profiling a seventy-nine-year-old artist who was married to two famous painters, one based on Jackson Pollock. Laura Pryor
Fisher, M. F. K. Consider the Oyster. New York: North Point Press-Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 1988. Print.
506
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Grotesque By Natsuo Kirino
W Introduction Gurotesuku was first published in Japan by Natsuo Kirino in 2003. The novel was translated into English by Rebecca Copeland and published in the United States in 2007 as Grotesque. The novel follows a trio of girls who attended the competitive Q High School for Young Women in Tokyo during the late 1970s. Two of the girls, the nymphomaniac Yuriko and attention-starved Kazue, become prostitutes and are murdered within months of each other in the late 1990s. The third girl is the book’s unnamed narrator—Yuriko’s unattractive, hate-filled older sister. Kirino has stated in interviews that part of the inspiration for the book came from a crime in Japan known as the Office Lady Murder, in which a Nepalese man killed an office worker who was moonlighting as a prostitute. The accused killer in Grotesque is a Chinese national, and Kirino traveled to China to research the lives of rural migrants in the country’s unique special economic zones. The Japanese version of Grotesque won the Izumi Kyoka Prize.
W Literary and Historical Context
The cutthroat academic world of the Q High School for Girls accurately reflects the competitive nature of secondary education in Japan, where much of a student’s self-esteem is derived from being admitted to a highranking school. Students frequently attend “cram” schools to prepare for entrance exams to top high schools in hopes that doing well will secure them admission to a top university. In Japan, high school covers grades ten through twelve, and although it is not compulsory, nearly all youth attend the best schools their parents can afford (public schools are not free, but they cost significantly less than more elite private schools). Schools are headed by
male principals, and two-thirds of all teachers are male, facts that are reflected in Grotesque. Conformity is prized in the rigid school environment. Students with minor learning disabilities or slightly unusual mannerisms or physical traits will become the target of bullies. Someone who is “half” (i.e., having only one Japanese parent) such as Yuriko and her sister would easily be targets of bullying, as would any student who came from a lower socioeconomic background. In fact, bullying is so pervasive in Japanese secondary schools that it has resulted in the concept known as toko kyohi—refusal to go to school. Suicides among those who are bullied are not uncommon, yet the problem remains largely unaddressed by administrators. The skeletally thin Kazue in Grotesque is symptomatic of the pervasiveness of anorexia and bulimia among Japanese schoolgirls. The illusion of youth causes many young women to remain as slim as prepubescent girls. Anorexia requires discipline, and many young women pride themselves on maintaining a strict diet in order to fit into stylish clothes that are made in only very small sizes. A 2001 national nutrition study by the Ministry of Health, Labor and Welfare reported a 100 percent increase from 1990 to 2000 in the number of women whose body mass index (BMI) met the definition of anorexia—10 percent of women in their twenties and 16 percent in their thirties. Japan is home to one of the world’s most thriving sex industries, called fuzoku, which encompasses a wide variety of practices that are enjoyed by a majority of the country’s male population. Prostitution has been technically illegal since 1956, but abundant loopholes allow nightclubs, “soapland” clubs that feature erotic baths, massage parlors, telephone clubs, traditional call-girl services, “health” shops, and “image” clubs, all of which are sexual in nature. Ubiquitous love hotels, theme parklike inns where rooms can be rented by the hour and discretion is assured, are common in many neighborhoods and no attempt is made to hide their purpose.
507 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Grotesque
MAJOR CHARACTERS TAKASHI KIJIMA is the son of a professor at Q High School. He is gay, rebuffs Kazue’s advances, and becomes Yuriko’s pimp. MITSURU is the best student at Q High School and aspires to attend Tokyo University and become a doctor. She wants to be friends with the narrator, who continually rebuffs her. Mitsuru eventually joins a cult, spends time in prison, and marries Professor Kijima. THE NARRATOR is Yuriko’s older sister, a homely, bitter woman who rejects love, sex, and human companionship based on her lifelong, all-consuming disgust for her sister. KAZUE SATO attends the Q High School for Girls with Yuriko and her sister. She longs for approval from teachers, boys, and classmates, which ultimately leads to her moonlighting position first as a call girl then as a low-class streetwalker, even though she has a good office job. She is murdered, and although her murderer is assumed to be Zheng, it is never definitively solved. YURIKO is a preternaturally beautiful girl for whom everything in life comes easily. She is unrepentantly obsessed with sex from the time she is an adolescent. Prostitution is her sole profession, but as she gets older and her beauty fades, she becomes a low-class streetwalker and is murdered. ZHENG ZHE-ZHONG grew up impoverished in rural China. He and his sister escape to the city only to become sexual slaves for the daughter of a high-ranking party official. He possibly kills his sister before making his way to Japan. He is put on trial for both Yuriko’s and Kazue’s murders, but confesses only to killing Yuriko.
Many young women participate in what is known as “compensated dating,” in which men pay for their services on an informal basis. Through fuzoku, married men pay for sexual services while their wives stay at home raising the children. Kirino features this time-honored double standard in many of her novels, including Grotesque, in which young women are fetishized and older women are considered expendable.
W Themes The most pervasive theme in Grotesque is beauty, both its presence and absence, and how it impacts the lives of women in contemporary Japan. Kirino implies that for a woman, beauty is a key that opens all doors. Yuriko is not smart, yet she sails into the prestigious Q High School for Girls solely based on how she looks while her sister studies dutifully for a difficult exam. Yuriko’s beauty enables her to seduce any man in order to obtain
508
whatever she desires. All goes well for her until her beauty starts to fade. By the time Yuriko hits thirty she is no longer considered desirable. The high fees she commanded as a teenager slowly decline, until she is forced to wear a wig and walk the streets, becoming interchangeable with the much less beautiful Kazue. Kazue’s decline is just as precipitous; having never achieved as much approval from her office job as she feels she deserves, she seeks approval from men, especially Zheng, and as she ages she degrades herself to the point that even homeless men are repulsed by her. Both women are murdered while in their early to mid-thirties, an age, Kirino suggests, at which women become useless. Age is the enemy for Japanese women; it robs Yuriko and Kazue of their only assets. The other side of beauty is the grotesque, which in literature refers to characters who are both unattractive (physically and psychologically) and who inspire empathy. In the novel, the narrator is a grotesque figure; not only is she unattractive but she is so filled with hatred for nearly everyone that the reader cannot help but feel sorry for her. Kazue is grotesque in the way she so desperately wants people to like her that she prostitutes herself, mistaking lust for love. In the absence of physical beauty, she allows herself to be used by others as proof of her value as a human being.
W Style Grotesque contains elements of a mystery and a thriller, yet its lack of resolution defies both genres. Zheng confesses to killing Yuriko but denies killing Kazue. Why he would readily confess to one but not the other—when the evidence indicates he killed both—is never explained. The reader is pulled along by the suspense but left unfulfilled at the novel’s conclusion. This technique allows Kirino to keep the focus on her theme of beauty and the unfair stigmatization of aging women in Japan rather than on the whodunit aspects of the plot. Parts of Grotesque are written in a diary format, allowing readers to glimpse the minds of both Yuriko and Katsue from a first-person perspective. Along with the initial first-person narration of Yuriko’s nameless older sister and Zheng’s deposition, the novel comprises four first-person narrations, giving the reader insight into the minds of all four main characters. The unreliable narrator is a factor to consider in reading Grotesque. As Kirino told Margy Rochlin of LA Weekly, “There’s this constant issue of the narrator’s ambiguity and the question of whether or not she’s actually reliable.” Part of this ambiguity stems from her anonymity. “I wanted to leave her an anonymous, representative person, so I left the name out.” As a girl, the narrator screams in sheer terror at Yuriko’s monstrous nature—making the reader question her sanity. One also wonders about the reliability of Yuriko’s hypersexuality as voiced by the narrator, a middle-aged virgin with no TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Grotesque
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Natsuo Kirino is the pseudonym of Mariko Hashioka, a Tokyobased writer whose first books were romance novels. Kirino was born in 1951 and received a law degree from Seikei University; she did not begin writing novels until she was 30. She switched from romance to thrillers based on her interest in the psychological aspects of crime and the lack of a market for romance novels in Japan. The first of these, Kao ni Furikakaru Ame (The face on which rain falls) received the Edogawa Rampo Prize for crime fiction in 1993. Her crime novels struck a chord with readers, and her tales of ordinary women who become mixed up in unsavory circumstances became known as feminist noir. Her mystery novel Out received the Japan Mystery Writers’ Association Prize in 1998, and the English translation, published in the United States in 2003, met with critical acclaim and was nominated for the Edgar Allan Poe award for best novel from the Mystery Writers of America—a rare event for a non-American author. The plot concerns two factory workers who help a third coworker murder her abusive husband and discard his dismembered body in various locations around Tokyo. All of Kirino’s novels explore the rigid gender imbalance in Japanese society, in which women are not expected to find personal and professional fulfillment and men are not expected to remain faithful to their wives. Kirino counts among her influences Yukio Mishima, Flannery O’Connor, and Patricia Highsmith.
Portrait of Natsuo Kirino, author of Grotesque. Amanda Edwards/ Getty Images
interest in men. This suspicion is reinforced by Yuriko’s journal, in which she writes of the narrator bombarding her with phone calls, despite the sister’s insistence that she had no contact with Yuriko during this time. She claims Yuriko is lying, but given the narrator’s allconsuming hatred and obsession with her sister, the reader is left to wonder.
W Critical Reception Critics admired Grotesque for its revealing look into the social hierarchy of Japan, in which women are ranked on looks and are always less powerful than men. In writing about Kirino’s approach to feminist noir in World Literature Today, J. Madison said that “in Kirino’s gritty portrayals of contemporary society, it is women specifically who are cornered and do unimaginable things. . . . Kirino’s novels stand out not just in their sensational elements but also in their convincing realism.” A reviewer for Washington Post Book World wrote, “Kirino’s women speak from beneath the lacquered surfaces of traditional
Japan,” and “[provide] a powerful indictment of that society.” Margy Rochlin, reviewing Grotesque in LA Weekly said that “in Japan, her brainy writing-style mashup is known as ‘Kirino Jynru,’ or a book that borrows freely from several genres but feels beholden to none of their rules.” Sophie Harrison, in a review for the New York Times Book Review, said that with Grotesque, Kirino “dismembers the detective novel . . . hacking off suspense, glamour, mystery and horror to leave a disconcerting stump of a book that fulfills no conventional expectations.” Some reviewers felt the narrator’s hatred overwhelmed the book. “She hates everything, inside of school and out, with an intensity that is at first brilliant but becomes exhausting,” wrote Harrison. Leigh Anne Vrabel, writing in Library Journal, gave the book a mixed review. While acknowledging the success of its intended grotesque effect, she noted that readers may find “the stream of ugliness” ultimately “wearying.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Harrison, Sophie. “Memoirs of a Geisha’s Sister.” New York Times Book Review 15 Apr. 2007: 15. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 20 Sept. 2010.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
509
Grotesque
Hongo, Jun. “Law Bends over Backward to Allow ‘Fuzoku.’” Japan Times 27 May 2008. Print. General OneFile. Web. 22 Sept. 2010. Jones, Dan. “Good Women and Bad Men.” Spectator 311.9450 (10 Oct. 2009): 39. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. Madison, J. “Unimaginable Things: The Feminist Noir of Natsuo Kirino.” World Literature Today 84.1 (Jan./ Feb. 2010): 9. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 22 Sept. 2010. Pike, Kathleen M., and Amy Borovoy. “The Rise of Eating Disorders in Japan: Issues of Culture and Limitations of the Model of ‘Westernization.’” Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry 28 (2004): 493531. Print. Princeton.edu. Web. 22 Sept. 2010. Rochlin, Margy. “Grotesque: Natsuo Kirino’s Dark World.” LA Weekly 5 July 2007. Literature Resource Center. Web 22 Sept. 2010. Tanikawa, Miki. “Free to Be.” New York Times 1 Jan. 2003. Print. NYTimes.com. Web. 22 Sept. 2010. Vrabel, Leigh Anne. Review of Grotesque. Library Journal 132.4 (1 Mar. 2007): 74. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 20 Sept. 2010. “Working Women.” Washington Post Book World 27 May 2007: 6. Print. General OneFile. Web. 22 Sept. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Kirino, Natsuo. “Natsuo Kirino: International Noir.” Pen.org. Web. 22 Sept. 2010. In this transcription of a speech given at the 2005 PEN World Voices Festival of International Literature, Kirino discusses her background and talks about how she prefers not to be known as a certain type of genre writer, because she fears it will limit her audience. Seaman, Amanda C. Bodies of Evidence: Women, Society and Detective Fiction in 1990s Japan. Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press, 2004. Print. Seaman explores how five authors, including Kirino, incorporate the issues of consumerism, identity crises, sexual violence, discrimination, and harassment in the workplace in their female-centric crime novels. Gale Resources
“Natsuo Kirino.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2010. Literature Resource Center. Web. 31 Aug. 2010. Also covered in Contemporary Authors, vol. 283. Print.
510
Open Web Sources
Natuso Kirino’s Web site is available in both Japanese and English, which provides a brief biography and synopses of her novels. http://www.kirino-natsuo. com For Further Reading
Golden, Arthur. Memoirs of a Geisha. New York: Knopf, 1997. Print. Golden based this tale of a famous geisha in Kyoto on his extensive interviews with a real-life retired geisha. It is a tale of sex, love, intrigue, and intense, hateful rivalry between two “sisters” for the attention of important men, without whom they will not survive. Kawakami, Sumie. Goodbye Madame Butterfly: Sex, Marriage and the Modern Japanese Woman. Translated by Yuko Enomoto. Seattle: Chin Music Press, 2007. Print. Kawakami writes of the sex industry in contemporary Japan through interviews with a variety of women. In various forms, prostitution is pervasive and practiced openly in Japan, but always with a double standard at its core that forbids such pleasure to married women. Kirino, Natsuo. Out. Translated by Stephen Snyder. New York: Kodansha International, 2003. Print. Three women, each forced to work at a boxed-lunch box factory for different reasons, band together to dispose of the murdered body of one of the women’s husbands. Miyabe, Miyuke. All She Was Worth. New York: Kodansha International, 1996. Print. Miyabe is a well-respected writer of crime thrillers, several of which have been translated into English. This novel concerns identity theft, a missing woman, and the intense consumerism of Japanese society in the 1990s. Muller, Karin. Japanland: A Year in Search of Wa. New York: Rodale, 2006. Print. Muller is an American documentary filmmaker who wrote about a year in Japan, searching for harmony and exploring the culture, from judo to sumo wrestlers to samurai. Peace, David. Tokyo Year Zero. New York: Knopf, 2007. Print. Peace, an award-winning novelist who lived in Tokyo for 15 years, based this novel on a real-life serial killer who murdered young women in postWorld War II Tokyo and the drug-addicted, troubled inspector who tries to stop him. Kathleen Wilson
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Half of a Yellow Sun By Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie
W Introduction Half of a Yellow Sun is the second novel by Nigerian writer Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie. Highly acclaimed, this book won the prestigious Orange Broadband Prize for fiction. Stemming from the Adichie family experiences, the story is set in the 1960s during the early days of Nigeria’s independence from Great Britain and during the later civil war between the ruling Hausas of the north and the Igbos of the southeast. Using the point of view of three different people, Adichie focuses on the psychological and material effects of the war on her characters rather than concentrating on the war itself. In particular, the brutality and starvation imposed on the new country of Biafra are memorably described. Central to the plot are fraternal twin sisters Olanna and Kainene, raised in affluence; their lovers Odenigbo, an idealistic professor, and Richard, a British expatriate, respectively; and the professor’s houseboy, Ugwu. Their evolving relationships are marked by love, betrayal, loyalty, and forgiveness. Ugwu matures from an uneducated thirteen-year-old to a revolutionary soldier. Besides the complexities of love, important themes include class and cultural differences and disillusionment. These themes carry messages about moral responsibility, the destructiveness of prejudice, and the need to place love above petty issues. Critics have declared Half of a Yellow Sun a significant addition to the genre of historical fiction.
W Literary and Historical Context
Nigeria gained independence from Great Britain on October 1, 1960. Two years later, it adopted a constitution and joined the British Commonwealth. The country consisted of 250 ethnic groups religiously
divided between Muslims and Christians. Traditionally the most prominent tribes were the northern Muslim Hausas and Fulanis and the southeastern Christian Igbos. Traditionally the Igbos had republican communities instead of kingdoms, but the British, who favored the Hausas, had established a system of warrant chiefs among the typically ambitious Igbo traders. The Igbos also had an center of intellectual activism at the University of Nigeria in Nsukka. Here, revolutionary idealists created the motivation and philosophy for rebellion. In 1966 the Hausas massacred thousands of Igbo. As a result, the Igbos tried to secede from Nigeria and set up their own country of Biafra. However, the Biafran territory contained important oil reserves that Nigeria could not afford to let go. Militarily superior and well-financed, Nigeria brutalized Biafra and used blockades of foodstuffs to starve the people of Biafra into submission. The war lasted from July 1967 to January 1970, during which only a few other countries recognized Biafran independence and most showed indifference. The plight of the Biafran people was so extreme that demonstrations against the cruelty were staged in several major cities around the world. Unfortunately, relief funds only served to prolong the misery of the war. Over one million people died. The Red Cross reported at the time that Biafra presented the biggest crisis since World War II. For Africans, the Biafran conflict constituted a dark period in the continent’s history.
W Themes A major theme of Half of a Yellow Sun is love—the various types of love and the complications of love. There is the love between the twin sisters that sometimes gets set aside because of envy and betrayal. There is also the love between Olanna and Odenigbo and between Kainene and Richard. Both affairs are intense and sincere but compromised by infidelity and
511 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Half of a Yellow Sun
MAJOR CHARACTERS RICHARD CHURCHILL, a blond, blue-eyed British journalist, falls in love with ninth-century Igbo-Ukwu art and Kainene. Wanting to belong, he learns Igbo and considers himself Biafran. ODENIGBO is a university mathematics professor and revolutionary idealist whose personal weaknesses result in damaged relationships and unbearable disillusionment. KAINENE OZOBIA, not distracted by beauty, is more focused than her sister and runs part of her father’s business, She is confident, enigmatic, sardonic; she has to learn how to forgive. OLANNA OZOBIA, the beautiful fraternal twin of Kainene, is a sociology teacher who rejects her parents’ wealth and power to live with Odenigbo, yet maintains class standards until the war causes her to truly find herself. UGWU, bright, kind, and discerning, is thirteen when he becomes houseboy to Odenigbo and an observer of the family dynamics and the build up of a revolution. His growth and experiences reflect the moral messages within the story.
failure to commit. The war causes the sisters to learn what is important in their lives, and that is love. After the horrors they witness, family transgressions seem small in comparison. Another important theme concerns class prejudice and cultural assumptions. Adichie clearly shows the differences between the educated elite and village Igbos such as Ugwu’s family and Odenigbo’s mother. Susan exemplifies the superior, colonial attitude of the British. The twins’ parents show the grasping ambition and excess of the newly rich. Democratically sensitive but privileged Olanna is disgusted by the cockroaches in her cousin’s house and tries to keep Baby from playing with low-class children even though they are all in the same desperate situation. Further, Adichie makes the point that the story of the Biafran war is not for the ex-patriot Richard to tell, but belongs to a Biafran. Another theme is that of illusion and disillusionment, promise and devastating disappointment. The ideals of the university elite are severely tested, and the hope of an independent Biafra where the Igbos can be safe from ethnic rivalries is brutally dashed. Intertwined with this theme is a message about the multitude of wars that are incited by prejudice and outside interferences caused by a lust for power and oil.
This photo shows two British businessmen being held prisoner during the Nigerian Civil War, which serves as the backdrop for the novel Half of a Yellow Sun. ª Hulton-Deutsch Collection/Corbis
512
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Half of a Yellow Sun
W Style Adichie breaks the flow of the traditional chronological order of her narrative in two ways. One is that she inserts in eight places in the novel excerpts from a book that one of her characters writes about the experiences of the war. These short excerpts are set off from the rest of the text by a different font, style, and tone; each is introduced by number and the bold heading “The Book: The World Was Silent When We Died.” The excerpts provide information on Nigerian history. Ultimately, Adichie also uses them to make a political point about who should be writing Africa’s stories. The second chronological disruption is the division of the book into four parts, moving back and forth from the early 1960s to the late 1960s with about a four-year break in between. The purpose of the break allows Adichie to concentrate the story on the time when Nigeria was newly independent at the beginning of the decade in contrast to the time of the Biafran war at the end of the decade. Also, by presenting events in the late
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Born in Nigeria in 1977, eight years after both of her grandfathers died in the Biafran war, Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie grew up in the university town of Nsukka. Her father was a statistics professor and university deputy vice chancellor, and her mother was a registrar. Adichie studied science there for two years, then went to Eastern Connecticut State University for her BA, graduating summa cum laude. She then studied creative writing at Johns Hopkins and African studies at Yale. She received the 2002 Caine Prize for African Writing, the 2003 O. Henry Prize, and the BBC Short Story Award. Her first novel, Purple Hibiscus (2004), earned several prestigious award nominations and received the Best First Book Award from the Commonwealth Writers’ Prize and the Hurston/Wright Legacy Award. Adichie was granted the 2005-2006 Hodder Fellowship at Princeton and a 2008 MacArthur Foundation Fellowship. As of 2010, she divided her time between the United States and Nigeria.
Igbo tribesmen prepare for battle. The civil war that started when the Igbo people attempted to form their own nation is the focus of the novel Half of a Yellow Sun. ª Bettmann/Corbis TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
513
Half of a Yellow Sun
1960s, then returning to where she left off in the early 1960s, she is able to delay revealing the crisis in the relationship between Olanna and Odenigbo. Although this novel is about a war, Adichie’s emphasis is on characters involved in this situation rather than on politics or the conduct of the war. She uses three narrators with a limited point of view: Ugwu, Olanna, and Richard. The reader is thus given these separate perspectives on events, and Adichie is better able to engineer the presentation of the psychological and moral challenges that her characters face.
W Critical Reception The critical reaction to Half of a Yellow Sun has bordered on awe. John Harding in the Daily Mail stated: “The book paints a massive canvas through intimate detail. It is funny, heartbreaking, exquisitely written and, without doubt, a literary masterpiece and a classic.” African Business magazine declared “this extraordinary novel” to be “immensely powerful and with a sweeping pace” because its wide scope covers moral responsibility, the end of colonialism, ethnic allegiances, class and race, and “the way in which love can complicate all of these things.” Ebony magazine added that Adichie “has impressed critics with her vivid, accurate portrayal of some of the significant periods in Nigeria’s history.” Two particular aspects of Adichie’s writing that caught the critics’ attention are her use of language and her narrative strategies. Susan VanZanten Gallagher, in Books and Culture, referred to Adichie’s “Elegant prose sparingly spiced with metaphors and sensual detail.” A review in the Evening Standard declared that “Adichie writes the handsome, straightforward prose wielded only by those with a real story to tell.” In addition Bookstore. com called her language “direct, uncompromising, and shocking in its simplicity.” As for Adichie’s narrative strategies, VanZanten Gallagher called the use of excerpts from The World Was Silent When We Died “brilliant” because it “succinctly supplies the history that forms the background for the intellectual and emotional human drama.” The online review source, Bookmarks, noted that Adichie’s “manipulation of point of view and time adds depth and perspective.” Other critics question the value of the manipulation of chronological time because it may confuse the reader instead of building tension. Nonetheless, the general response from the literary world was that Adichie has a rare talent that may one day rank her among the greatest of novelists. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
“From the Motherland: Eight Africans & Their Contributions to the World.” Ebony 63.6 (2008): 112+. Print.
514
“Half of a Yellow Sun.” Rev. of Half of a Yellow Sun, by Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie. African Business Oct. 2006: 65. Print. “Half of a Yellow Sun.” Rev. of Half of a Yellow Sun, by Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie. Bookmarks Nov.-Dec. 2006: 37. Web. 19 June 2010. Harding, John. “New Fiction.” Rev. of Half of a Yellow Sun, by Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie. Daily Mail, 18 Aug. 2006: 62. Print. VanZanten Gallagher, Susan. “Remember Biafra?” Rev. of Half of a Yellow Sun, by Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie. Books and Culture 14.1 (2006): 29. Print. “Yellow Grabs the Orange as Gifted Adichie Wins for Novel about Biafra.” Evening Standard, 7 June 2007: n.p. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Cheuse, Alan. Rev. of Half of a Yellow Sun, by Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie. World Literature Today 81.1 (2007): 7. Print. Comments on the number of good Nigerian writers and the way Adichie adds a psychological element to historical fiction. Hawley, John C. “Biafra as Heritage and Symbol: Adichie, Mbachu, and Iweala.” Research in African Literature 39.2 (2008): 15. Print. Looks at three twenty-first-century treatments of the Biafran conflict: Dulue Mbachu’s War Games, Adichie’s Half of a Yellow Sun, and Uzodinma Iweala’s Beast of No Nation. Kearney, J. A. “The Representation of Child Soldiers in Contemporary African Fiction.” Journal of Literary Studies 26.1 (2010): 67. Print. Examines at length the depiction of child soldiers in five novels, including Half of a Yellow Sun. Nixon, Rob. “A Biafran Story.” Rev. of Half of a Yellow Sun, by Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie. New York Times Book Review 1 Oct. 2006: 9(L). Print. Comments on Adichie’s themes of loyalty and betrayal and the universal elements of her war story. Novak, Amy. “Who Speaks? Who Listens? The Problem of Address in Two Nigerian Trauma Novels.” Studies in the Novel 40.1-2 (2008): 31. Print. Uses Freud to analyze trauma, neocolonialism, and two Nigerian novels, Graceland, by Christopher Abani, and Half of a Yellow Sun. White, E. Frances. “While the World Watched.” Rev. of Half of a Yellow Sun, by Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie. Women’s Review of Books 24.3 (2007): 10. Print. Discusses the book-within-a-book technique and the pairing of characters in Half of a Yellow Sun. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Half of a Yellow Sun Gale Resources
“Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Literature Resource Center. Web. 29 June 2010. http://go.galegroup. com Open Web Sources
A Web site is dedicated to Half of a Yellow Sun at www. halfofayellowsun.com, which includes information about Adichie, a synopsis, an excerpt, a list of review quotations, and links to other sources. LitGuides provides a summary of the book, a short biography, several reviews, and excellent discussion questions; this source can be found at www.litlovers. com/guide_half_of_yellow_sun.html “A Blazing Sun—The Storyteller Returns,” by Ikhide R. Ikheloa, is an analytical salute to Half of a Yellow Sun, available at http://wordsbody.blogspot.com/2006/ 10/review-half-of-yellow-sun.html A summary of Half of a Yellow Sun and a list of book review comments is available at www.bookbrowse. com/reviews/index.cfm?book_number=1860 A worthwhile review of Half of a Yellow Sun is provided at http://bookstore.com/drama/half-of-a-yellowsun-a-review
tribal life and the changes brought by colonialism and Christianity. Adichie, Chimamanda Ngozi. Purple Hibiscus: A Novel. New York: Anchor, 2004. Print. Adichie’s first novel, about a wealthy Nigerian teenage girl whose respected family has terrible secrets. ———. The Thing around Your Neck. New York: Knopf, 2009. Short stories depicting the diversity of Nigerians and Nigerian Americans. Forsyth, Frederick. The Biafra Story: The Making of an African Legend. Barnsley: Pen and Sword, 2007. By the author of Day of the Jackal, Odessa File, and Dogs of War, written from the author’s experiences as a war correspondent. Adaptations
“Lennon Childhood Film Gets Grant,” bbc.co.uk. BBC News, n.d. Web. 18 July 2008. In 2008 the BBC reported that Biyi Bandele, who wrote a stage play from Chinua Achebe’s Things Fall Apart, would write the screenplay for a film adaptation of Half of a Yellow Sun thanks to a lottery-funded development grant of £39,375 from the U.K. Film Council in partnership with BBC Films. Lois Kerschen
For Further Reading
Achebe, Chinua. Things Fall Apart. New York: Anchor, 1994. Print. First published in 1958, depicts Igbo
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
515
A Happy Marriage By Rafael Yglesias
W Introduction Rafael Yglesias’s A Happy Marriage is an autobiographical novel that describes the twenty-seven-year marriage of Enrique Sabas, a novelist and screenplay writer, and Margaret Cohen, a graphic artist turned stay-at-home mother of two. Though the title suggests a blissful union, this novel presents individuals who are nor always happy, nor always faithful, but who make their often uneasy way toward shaping lives defined by one another. Yglesias does here what he has done before: He seeks to understand his life by writing about it. The fictionalized portrait of his marriage to Margaret Joskow, including her untimely death, is both invocation and eulogy. The novelist describes how Enrique and Margaret court, marry, and settle into their professional lives in New York City, have their sons, and move through early difficult years of demanding work and child care, with its side effects of fatigue and diminished libido, toward increased appreciation of each other and mature love. Just entering their fifties and now wealthy with sons doing well in school, Enrique and Margaret face her terminal bladder cancer. This book forces readers to look to the end of life while evaluating and living in the present. Yglesias accomplishes here both a tribute and a warning. In conjuring his wife and their relationship he honors her memory; in the intimate details of her dying, he invites readers to appreciate the all-too-often overlooked opportunity of the present moment.
W Literary and Historical Context
The immediate setting for A Happy Marriage is New York City from the mid-1970s until the early 2000s;
however, references are made to the Bohemian days of the 1950s in Greenwich Village and to urban deterioration and increase in crime during the 1970s. The 1950s and 1960s marked a heyday for abstract expressionists such as Mark Rothko, Robert Motherwell, and Willem de Kooning, and the 1963 founding of the New York Studio School confirmed New York as the avant-garde art center in the West. Enrique drops out of high school in tenth grade and moves to Greenwich Village, drawn to its cultural mystique, and, like the author of this novel, Enrique publishes his first novel while still in his teens. The action of the novel spans two major national events, the Watergate scandal leading to President Nixon’s resignation in 1974 and the destruction of the World Trade Center towers on September 11, 2001. During the intervening decades, the publishing industry became intensely competitive and, in some ways, was subverted by celebrity status and glitz. Literary hopefuls, like Enrique and his friend Bernard, flocked to New York to make it big, and, when producing their works did not pay, a fortunate few among them made their way into related professions, such as writing screenplays and magazine reviews. The novel focuses on a narrow group of rising sophisticates, individuals who make names for themselves and eventually can afford the expensive New York City lifestyle. Contextual factors connected to Margaret’s illness and death include the availability of speedy medical service and luxurious hospital accommodations for those with excellent insurance and cash for large out-of-pocket costs, home hospice services, and burial in an historic cemetery. Enrique’s contacts get Margaret to the front of the line for medical treatment, and her millionaire parents provide the couple with a hotel-like suite at a New York hospital. Such VIP luxury rooms may cost $1,500 per day or more. In the 1960s, choice of hospice services grew with increasing understanding of the dying process. Elisabeth Kübler-Ross’s psychological study On Death and Dying
516 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
A Happy Marriage
MAJOR CHARACTERS DOROTHY COHEN, Margaret’s controlling mother, has had a difficult relationship with her daughter but is able to express appreciation of her in Margaret’s final days. LAWRENCE COHEN, Margaret’s wealthy father, faces his daughter’s death but cannot reconcile himself to her life being cut short. NATALIE KO is the hospice physician who attends Margaret at home. ENRIQUE SABAS, the protagonist, has a successful career as a novelist and screenwriter. Enrique is married twenty-seven years to Margaret, and he and his wife have two sons, Gregory and Max. GUILLERMO SABAS, Enrique’s father, is a successful author who dies the year before Margaret. MARGARET COHEN SABAS is a graphic designer who marries Enrique Sabas and bears him two sons. She develops bladder cancer and dies in her fifties. ROSE SABAS, Enrique’s mother, is a successful author who lives in a retirement facility after she is widowed.
Photograph of Rafael Yglesias, author of A Happy Marriage. Evan Agostini/Getty Images
(1968) brought end-stage issues to public attention, and increasingly thereafter medical specialists and others affirmed the benefits of hospice care for the dying patient and family members. Margaret chooses a Buddhist rabbi to officiate at her funeral and a grave site in Green-Wood Cemetery in Brooklyn, which sold a few new plots in the early 2000s and was declared a National Historical Landmark in 2006.
W Themes The primary theme of A Happy Marriage is identified in the novel’s title. The book explores in hindsight one marriage of twenty-seven years. It looks back from a time following the wife’s death, intent on mapping the way this relationship began, developed, and ended. The book explains that because these two individuals remained in their marriage, they learned over years how that relationship defined them as people, what they received from one another, and how their partnership was the essence of their shared lives. Connected to the primary theme is one concerning the effects of a person’s terminal illness on that person’s
BERNARD WEINSTEIN introduces Enrique to Margaret. Early on, Bernard aspires to being a novelist, but over the years, he achieves fame and financial success as a reviewer and television personality. SALLY WINTHROP, one of Margaret’s best friends, has an affair with Enrique.
spouse, children, and extended family members. The book dramatizes the physical, familial, and social changes that occur as the wife declines. It depicts the various and complicated effects her illness has on her husband, their sons, and her parents. This intimate portrait nullifies the barriers, denial, and avoidance that often prevent healthy people from seeing the reality of terminal illness and its effects on both the patient and supportive others. Equally important, the book shows how relatives’ feelings and attitudes change and how much stress is generated by witnessing the dying process. A third theme has to do with how a writer comes to understand his life through writing. The protagonist, Enrique Sabas, is a writer of autobiographical novels. Rafael Yglesias fashioned a novel from his own experience, and that novel examines how writers may seek to find meaning through language and text. The young Enrique is inhibited, and he has trouble communicating his feelings and speaking his own truth. His reticence creates barriers between him and his friends, and it blocks his budding relationship with Margaret Cohen. Later in life, Enrique wonders if being a writer is actually an
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
517
A Happy Marriage
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Born May 12, 1954, in New York City, Rafael Yglesias knew early on he wanted to be a writer. The son of famous authors, Jose Yglesias and Helen Yglesias, Rafael dropped out of high school to pursue his writing career and published an autobiographical novel, Hide Fox, and All After, in 1972, when he was eighteen. Yglesias married the artist Margaret Joskow and with her had two sons, Matthew and Nicholas. Matthew Yglesias became an online blog writer. Margaret Yglesias died of cancer in 2004. A Happy Marriage, Yglesias’s his ninth novel, is dedicated to her. As of 2010, Yglesias lived in Greenwich Village.
avoidance strategy. As he faces his wife’s final days, he feels that language itself is useless. Enrique cannot find the moment or the words to convey what he feels. He cannot say thank you and good-bye in a way that makes sense to him. The irony here is that Yglesias successfully finds the words to describe how words fail.
W Style The structure of A Happy Marriage is one of its most interesting stylistic features. The novel has twenty-one titled and numbered chapters. The odd-numbered chapters describe early times in the marriage and the even-numbered ones the final days of Margaret’s life. The chapter titles link in often surprising ways, and details in the end of one chapter often connect in surprising ways with details in the beginning of the next. In chapter eight, Margaret’s parents say where they want their daughter buried, and Enrique has to convey Margaret’s different wishes and help his in-laws accept them. In this chapter, readers learn Margaret has twelve hours to live, and in fact, there are twelve chapters left in the novel. Gradually the distance narrows between the early periods and the final days; put another way, the plot of the past converges eventually with the plot of the present. The novel is written in third-person limited point of view, from the perspective of Enrique, and his perspective shifts through the novel as he ages. For example, in his early twenties Enrique obsesses about his clothes as he prepares for his first date with Margaret; seven years into their marriage, he is self-deluding and manipulative when he attempts to justify to himself his having an affair with Margaret’s best friend; when grief and exhaustion crash inside him in the final days, he is frayed, nervous, and overwhelmed. In part, the purpose is to project through his evolultion what Yglesias calls the “rampless bridge between birth and death” (330).
518
W Critical Reception In her review of A Happy Marriage, Malena Watrous wrote that the novel is so “unabashedly autobiographical” as to be virtually “a memoir in the third person.” Indeed, many critics recognized that Yglesias drew on personal experience in characterizing protagonist Enrique Sabas and in describing the death of Enrique’s wife Margaret, and many thought the autobiographical elements strengthened the fictional work. Publishers Weekly described the book as a “devastatingly raw appraisal of a nearly 30-year marriage.” Joanna Burkhardt wrote that it is a “picture of how a successful marriage comes to be—and ends.” Jo-Ann Veillette-Stonehart added, “The book is a poignant story of what it means to share life and death with someone.” Several critics pointed out that the marital relationship comes into focus when the spouses confront terminal illness. A Publishers Weekly review stressed the “blunt, heart-wrenching detail” of the wife’s decline and the husband’s “selfish desire to postpone his loss.” Also praising the description, Watrous wrote, “This is real intimacy, the hard-earned kind between two people who have chosen to stick it out to the end.” The mystery of their marriage, according to Watrous, “propels the book forward.” Carolyn Kubisz described the book as “beautifully written,” an affirmation that “a marriage, and the people who form it, don’t have to be perfect to be happy.” About the characterization of Enrique, Scott Muskin found it deficient, pointing out that the self-absorbed protagonist “ego-tripped through courtship, kids, infidelity and therapy pretty much like a big, fat baby.” Kirkus Reviews agreed, finding Enrique “both unlikable and impossible to take seriously.” Muskin and the Kirkus Reviews writer also agreed that the back story is problematic: Muskin wrote that it “obscured” the present story about Margaret’s decline; the other stated that it “devolves into confessional.” Kirkus concluded negatively that “Yglesias knows how to pluck the heartstrings but flounders in the execution.” In the final judgment, Muskin disagreed: “In prose that flexes with unflinching confidence, Yglesias parts the hospital curtain to show not just death’s indignities . . . but also its tender comedy, small reprieves and surreal turns of fortune.” Despite these criticisms, the novel succeeded for many readers. Librarian Pam Locker listed the best novels of 2009 in alphabetical order, giving the H to A Happy Marriage. Indeed, many critics seemed to agree that this is a novel worth reading. But Veillette-Stonehart gave a warning about the novel’s emotional impact: “Be prepared . . . to appreciate through the author’s eyes what it is like to truly love another, in sickness and in health, until death.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Burkhardt, Joanna M. “Yglesias, Rafael. A Happy Marriage.” Rev. of A Happy Marriage, by Rafael Yglesias. Library Journal 1 May 2009: 73. Print. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
A Happy Marriage
“Yglesias, Rafael: A Happy Marriage.” Rev. of A Happy Marriage, by Rafael Yglesias. Kirkus Reviews 1 June 2009. Print. “A Happy Marriage.” Rev. of A Happy Marriage, by Rafael Yglesias. Publishers Weekly 23 Mar. 2009: 42. Print. Kubisz, Carolyn. “A Happy Marriage.” Rev. of A Happy Marriage, by Rafael Yglesias. Booklist 1 May 2009: 63 +. Print. Locker, Pam. “The Very Best Novels from 2009, from A to Z.” Rev. of A Happy Marriage, by Rafael Yglesias. Evansville Courier and Press 10 Jan. 2010. Print. Muskin, Scott. “Tough and Tender, This ‘Marriage’ Enlightens.” Rev. of A Happy Marriage, by Rafael Yglesias. Minneapolis Star Tribune 19 July 2009. Print. Veilette-Stonehart, Jo-Ann. “Recommended Readings.” Rev. of A Happy Marriage, by Rafael Yglesias. Commonweal 4 Dec. 2009. Print. Watrous, Malena. “Terminal Bliss.” Rev. of A Happy Marriage, by Rafael Yglesias. nytimes.com. New York Times July 16, 2009. Web. 29 July 2010. Yglesias, Rafael. A Happy Marriage. New York: Scribner’s, 2009. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Smith, Dinitia. “A Novel of the Author’s Affair with His Wife, until Cancer Did Them Part.” Rev. of A Happy Marriage, by Rafael yglesias. newyorktimes.com. New York Times, 26 July 2009. Web. 29 July 2010. Affirms the novelist has turned his life into a work of art. Gale Resources
“Rafael Yglesias.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Literature Resource Center. Web. 25 July 2010. http://go.galegroup.com/ps/i.do?&id=GA LE%7CH1000108906&v=2.1&u=itsbtrial&it=r& p=LitRC&sw=w
Open Web Sources
Rafael Yglesias maintains a Web site at http://rafaelygle sias.com, which provides information about publica tions and events and links to radio interviews with Terry Gross and Leonard Lopate. For Further Reading
Cairns, Moira, et al. Transitions in Dying and Bereavement: A Psychosocial Guide for Hospice and Palliative Care. Baltimore: Health Professions Press, 2003. Print. Describes what terminally ill patients and their families experience while receiving hospice and palliative support. Lopate, Phillip, ed. Writing New York: A Literary Anthology. New York: Library of America, 2008. Print. Over one hundred short stories that together draw a portrait of New York and celebrate the onehundredth anniversary of the unification of its five boroughs. Metcalf, Peter, and Richard Huntington. Celebrations of Death: The Anthropology of Mortuary Ritual. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1999. Print. Explores various subjects related to death, ritual, and grief, including different cultures and practices in the United States. Rutherfurd, Edward. New York: A Novel. New York: Doubleday, 2009. Print. By the author of Sarum, a fictional history of generations of families that span the history of New York. Yglesias, Rafael. Fearless. New York: Grand Central, 1993. Print. Tells the aftermath for two passengers who survive a plane crash after taking off from New York City.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Melodie Monahan
519
Harbor By Lorraine Adams
W Introduction Lorraine Adams’s Harbor is a satiric thriller that explores the negative implications of the U.S. Department of Homeland Security, established following the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks on America, and the dangers of racial profiling in the pre- and post-9/11 era. The protagonist, Aziz, is a 24-year-old immigrant to America who escapes horrors in his homeland of Algeria only to find himself at the center of a Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) case. Although Aziz is innocent, the FBI believes he is part of a terrorist cell, in large part due to their own misinterpretation of events as well as their mistrust of his ethnicity. The bulk of the novel focuses on Aziz’s life in America, but the narrative contains flashbacks to his earlier life in Algeria, shedding light on the circumstances that led him to flee his homeland. The latter portion of the novel reveals the FBI's point of view, and is awash in dramatic irony as Adams reveals the prejudices that inform the FBI investigation and guide their assumptions about Aziz. Adams won the Fourth Annual Virginia Commonwealth University (VCU) First Novel Award for Harbor in 2004, as well as the Art Seidenbaum Award for First Fiction from the Los Angeles Times. The novel was also nominated for an Orange Prize in the United Kingdom.
W Literary and Historical Context
The attacks of September 11, 2001, a seminal event in recent American history, serve as the basis for the plot in Harbor. In a violent and coordinated terrorist attack, members of a militant Islamic group known as al-Qaeda commandeered numerous U.S. commercial jets—all of which were full of passengers at the time—and flew them into important U.S. landmarks, the most prominent of
which were the two planes that crashed into the twin towers of the World Trade Center in New York City. A third plane crashed into the Pentagon near Washington, D.C., while the fourth came down in rural Pennsylvania, thanks to passengers and flight crew who managed to thwart the hijackers, but not soon enough to save themselves. None of the flights had any survivors, and the death toll, including passengers and on-ground victims, totalled nearly 3,000. In the wake of these horrifying attacks, the entire Western world, and particularly the United States, went on the alert for other terrorist attacks. An unfortunate side effect of the effort to increase homeland security measures was the increase of racial profiling. Specifically, in the wake of September 2001, people of Arabic or Middle Eastern descent and/or practicing Muslims are often subjected to a greater level of scrutiny than people of other ethnicities or races. Harbor presents the story of an innocent man of Algerian origin who is reluctantly involved in petty criminal activity upon his arrival in America. These actions cause the FBI to misconstrue him as part of a terrorist cell. Aziz’s treatment by the U.S. government is eerily similar to the abuse he suffered under his own government.
W Themes Harbor explores how fear can cause those in power to make decisions that threaten the civil liberties of the very people they are sworn to protect. Harbor uses Aziz’s story to analyze the ambiguities of situations similar to those in America in the post-September 11 era. On the one hand, Homeland Security had good cause for their concern. The world was a very frightening place immediately following the terrorist attacks of September 11. On the other hand, many people believe that the sense of insecurity following the September 11 terrorist attacks allowed the American government nearly free license to pursue methods of inquiry that were disturbing and racist. Harbor demonstrates how easy it is for an entire
520 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Harbor
race/ethnicity or religion to be held suspect following the dreadful actions of a small, militant contingency. Adams demonstrates how, for some people, the United States can be just as oppressive an environment as the totalitarian regimes from which such people hoped to escape. While in his native land of Algeria, Aziz explains the abuses he wants to leave behind: “[T]here was nothing Antar [a warlord] did not believe was his right. There were those among Antar’s men who took to depravity the way birds take to air. They had imaginations bloated with ways to inflict suffering” (157). While the FBI agents are not willfully cruel, the novel demonstrates how their resulting actions are just as harmful.
MAJOR CHARACTERS AZIZ is an illegal American immigrant, who escapes Algeria only to find himself the center of a federal investigation in the wake of September 11. GHAZI is a charismatic young man, also an Algerian immigrant to the United States. He suffers from depression and is obsessed with Al Pacino films. HEATHER is Rafik’s plump, American girlfriend, whom the others view as pampered and whiny. MOURAD is Aziz’s brother, who has the good fortune to receive a green card.
W Style Harbor places the reader directly into action, limiting the reader’s viewpoint to that of Aziz and a few of his compatriots. According to Amy Driscoll, critic for Knight-Ridder/Tribune News Service, the novel has “no overview or omniscient narrator; the novel is largely internal and almost myopic, the scope of vision confined to what Aziz and his friends see.” This serves to make the paranoia within Aziz’s group about the FBI’s investigation
RAFIK, Aziz’s first contact upon arriving in America, is involved in all sorts of illegal activity, including fencing stolen merchandise, such as materials to make bombs.
seem more palpable. For a majority of the narrative, the reader is denied the larger picture, and is limited to the viewpoint of the main characters, as they struggle with the fear of being watched.
Cargo ships at Boston Harbor. In Harbor, Aziz sneaks into America by stowing away in a tanker ship traveling to Boston. Pierdelune/ Shutterstock.com
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
521
Harbor
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Lorraine Adams is the author of two novels, Harbor and The Room and the Chair, both of which are heavily informed by her former job as an investigative journalist. She worked for the Washington Post for eleven years and won a Pulitzer Prize for reporting on civil rights violations by Texas police. In 2000 she was assigned to investigate a story on terrorism, during the course of which she came to know a group of young refugees from Algeria under surveillance by the FBI. She ended up resigning from her journalism job over philosophical disagreements with her employers regarding these young men, and wrote Harbor as a result. She wanted to tell the story that the Post had refused to publish.
The focus shifts quite deliberately at a few key points in the novel. The novel is interspersed with what Driscoll refers to as “increasingly vivid flashbacks.” Sometimes these take the form of flashbacks to Aziz’s life in Algeria, illustrating the compelling reasons that drove him to leave. At other times, the shifts in focus mirror some of the hardships he faces in the United States, ironically highlighting the fact that his escape to the United States did not result in the freedom he seeks. The latter portion of the book includes a few chapters from the perspective of the FBI agents. These sections mirror the myopic style of the chapters written from Aziz’s perspective. Focusing on the FBI’s point of view, these chapters allow the reader to see the reasons why the investigators come to misconstrue Aziz and his friends’ actions throughout the novel, making a pointed statement about the moral ambiguity and dilemma behind some of the actions taken by Homeland Security.
W Critical Reception Lorraine Adams’s Harbor was highly acclaimed when it was first released. It went on to win the Fourth Annual VCU First Novel Award in 2004 and the Art Seidenbaum Award for First Fiction from the Los Angeles Times. It was additionally nominated for an Orange Prize in the United Kingdom, which celebrates excellent, original, and accessible women’s writing from around the world. Amy Driscoll of Knight-Ridder/Tribune News Service called Harbor a “razor-sharp debut novel” that presents an “intimate exploration of the nature of terrorism and political sanctuary in modern-day America. It’s a vivid, fast-paced entry into an immigrant’s story that is part thriller, part social commentary and at times darkly funny.” She went on to praise the novel for managing to capably blend its satirical and thriller elements. Adams “has written a terrific book,” Driscoll wrote, “weaving
522
suspense and dread in rhythms that grow even more rapid as the novel concludes. With its relevant references to terrorism and staggering hallucinatory intensity, Harbor leaves the reader reeling, wondering—as we do so often in life—how much is real and how much delusion.” Neil Gordon, in the New York Times Book Review found Adams’s accomplishment quite remarkable. He elaborated by saying that it is “easy to explain how Lorraine Adams knows so much about the illegal Algerian community in America, about credit card fraud, terrorism and F.B.I. investigations,” noting that the novel is based on Adams’s reporting for the Washington Post. “What’s harder to explain,” he continued, “is how Adams is able to draw us so convincingly into the reality of her cast: These characters are the product of a viruoso act of the imagination. . . . ” He found the novel a “remarkable act of artistic empathy . . . [that] dramatize[s] not just the awful nature of our strife-filled world but all the hopeless complexity of its ethical and cultural roots.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Adams, Lorraine. Harbor. New York: Vintage, 2004. Print. Driscoll, Amy. “Fast-Paced Novel Harbor Explores Nature of Terrorism, Sanctuary.” Rev. of Harbor, by Lorraine Adams. Knight-Ridder/Tribune News Service 2 Sept. 2004: K3813. Print. Gordon, Neil. “Under Surveillance.” New York Times Book Review 5 Sept. 2004: 7. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Rev. of Harbor, by Lorraine Adams. Publishers Weekly 251.24 (2004): 41. Print. This review provides an excellent recap of Harbor’s major plots and characters. Lewis, Debi. “Adams, Lorraine. Harbor.” Rev. of Harbor, by Lorraine Adams. Booklist July 2004: 1815. Print. This review praises Adams for revealing complex ambiguities, allowing her readers to draw their own conclusions. Ollerer, Coletta. “Harbor.” Rev. of Harbor, by Lorraine Adams. Reviewer’s Bookwatch Mar. 2005. Print. This review examines Harbor as a novel structured in three layers—Aziz’s backstory, his life in America, and the FBI’s perception of him. Reese, Jennifer. “Pearl of a Harbor: Lorraine Adams’s Extraordinary Debut Traces Muslim Immigrants in America.” Rev. of Harbor, by Lorraine Adams. Entertainment Weekly 20 Aug. 2004: 129. Print. This review analyzes the novel as a new twist on the immigrant experience genre. Rungren, Lawrence. “Adams, Lorraine. Harbor.” Rev. of Harbor, by Lorraine Adams. Library Journal 129.11 TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Harbor
(2004): 56. Print. This review defines the different meanings of the word harbor and how they relate to Adams’s novel. Open Web Sources
Lorraine Adams’s official Web site features articles and reviews about Adams’s work, a biography, information about events and appearances, excerpts of her upcoming work and more. http://lorraineadams.net/ For Further Reading
Adams, Lorraine. The Room and the Chair. New York: Knopf, 2010. Print. The Room and the Chair also deals with the war on terror. Eggers, Dave. What Is the What: The Autobiography of Valentino Achak Deng. New York: Vintage, 2007. Print. This novel by Dave Eggers examines the immigrant experience in America, and compares and contrasts the hardships experienced in the
protagonist’s own country with his experiences upon arriving in America. Goldsmith, Jack. The Terror Presidency: Law and Judgment inside the Bush Administration. New York: Norton, 2009. Print. This work examines the George W. Bush administration’s stance on civil liberties. Meyer, Jane. The Dark Side: The Inside Story of How the War on Terror Turned into a War on American Ideals. New York: Anchor, 2009. Print. This book examines what it perceives as abuses wrought by the American government in its attempt to subdue terrorism. Rehnquist, William H. All the Laws but One: Civil Liberties in Wartime. New York: Vintage, 2000. Print. This book explores the tradition, throughout American history, of dealing with the issue of civil liberties during wartime.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Powder Thompson
523
The Harmony Silk Factory By Tash Aw
W Introduction Tash Aw’s debut novel, The Harmony Silk Factory, tells the story of Johnny Lim, a businessman from humble beginnings who rose to prominence in Malaysia in the 1930s and 1940s. Set against the backdrop of British colonialism, the underground swell of communism, and the threat of the eventual Japanese invasion, the story unfolds through the accounts of three separate narrators, who each reveal different, and often conflicting, versions of Johnny Lim’s life and personal character. The first section is narrated by his son Jasper, whose bitter account seeks to expose his father as a liar, a traitor, and a murderer. As Alfred Hickling writes, “You wouldn’t expect a character to come back from an assassination like that,” but the next two accounts—one in the diary of Lim’s wife, Snow, and the other from his best friend, the Brit Peter Wormwood, now living out the remainder of his life in a rest home near Malacca—paint a very different picture of Lim. According to Alice Jones, “Aw’s prose is beautifully wrought and thoughtful, switching with agility between comedy, suspense, romance, and lyrical description.” The novel is full of ambiguities, but while loose ends abound, in Lucy Clark's view, “answers may be elusive, satisfaction is not. It’s a lovely book.”
W Literary and Historical Context
When asked by Aviva Tuffield by Aviva Tuffield to describe his novel The Harmony Silk Factory, Tash Aw replies: “I can’t because the whole point of it was to make it indescribable. It was an attempt to refresh and change the whole genre of the Second World War novel. It’s a war story without the war, there is very little war action in it. It’s a love story and a ghost story and a psychological thriller and a road trip all squashed into a form that
purports to be a historical war novel.” The author wrote his novel as a deliberate response to stories such as those by Somerset Maugham, which also depict Malaysia in the 1930s and 1940s and which Aw describes as “incredibly bad.” Tired of reading accounts of Southeast Asia where “white men in smoking jackets sit around drinking gin,” Aw, as he told Sean Yoong, hoped “to tweak Malaysia’s historical image in literature” by penning a “novel that was very faithful to Malaysia, a levelheaded story that isn’t at all exotic or sentimental.” Because much of the storytelling in Malaysia is based on oral tradition, the country does not have an extensive literature, as Tuffield has observed. Aw hopes to help change this. He set The Harmony Silk Factory in the 1930s and 1940s, and his second novel, Map of the Invisible World, takes place in Malaysia and Indonesia in the 1960s. Aw tells Bron Sibree that this progression through time is part of his plan to “map the emotional landscape of Southeast Asia over the course of the past six or seven decades . . . to reclaim Southeast Asian history and force Southeast Asian literature into the limelight. I want to write about Southeast Asia in a way that no one has seen before. I’m just reclaiming it for myself.”
W Themes Tash Aw believes “it is not the novelist’s role to answer questions but to pose them” (qtd. in De Guzman). In The Harmony Silk Factory, the questions are, who is Johnny Lim, and whose version of events are to be believed? Jasper Lim sets out to tell “The True Story of the Infamous Chinaman Called Johnny” and calls his father “a liar, a cheat, a traitor and a skirt chaser. Of the very highest order.” As each narrator gives his or her personal account of events, Charmaine Chan notes, Johnny is revealed, in turn, to be a murderer, a hero, a traitor, a loyal friend, a “country bumpkin and sophisticate,” a communist leader, an informant for the Japanese, and a simple working-class Chinese man in awe of his
524 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Harmony Silk Factory
beautiful wife. The novel’s overarching themes are the reinvention of personal histories and, in Carlene Ellwood's words, the “inherent flaws of memory.” Aw states that “each narrator tries to convince you that his/her version is really what happened . . . and the inconsistencies in their narrative show how difficult that is” (qtd. in Nayar). Peter I. Barta argues that the novel “carefully integrates assumptions, not only about the existence of a unified human subject, but, more importantly, about the very possibility of constructing any unified body of knowledge. The novel also deals heavily with the idea of the outsider or the disenfranchised. “It’s possible to be an outsider in your own country,” Aw states in the New Zealand Herald. “It’s possible to feel like you’re living in the margins of that society.” In The Harmony Silk Factory, Aw tells Emine Saner, “[e]very character is an outsider, even if they’ve never left their place of birth, they just don’t sit comfortably with the people around them.”
MAJOR CHARACTERS FREDERICK HONEY is a pompous British businessman and a friend of Snow’s father. MAMORU KUNICHIKA is the head of the Japanese secret police, who accompanies Johnny, Snow, Peter, and Honey on their voyage to the Islands of the Seven Maidens. JASPER LIM is Johnny Lim’s son, and the first narrator of the book. JOHNNY LIM is the elusive subject of the novel, a successful Chinese businessman whose story is told from three separate narrative viewpoints, none of them his own. SNOW SOONG is Johnny Lim’s beautiful young wife, whose diary narrates the second section of the book. TIGER TAN is the original owner of the the Harmony silk factory, who bequeaths it to Johnny.
W Style Tash Aw’s The Harmony Silk Factory is written from three separate narrative viewpoints, in three distinct styles. According to the author, the first narrator, Johnny Lim’s
PETER WORMWOOD, a British man living in Malaysia, is Johnny’s best friend and confidant.
In The Harmony Silk Factory, Johnny Lim is a descendant of Chinese laborers who worked in the mines. Lisa Wiltse/Bloomberg via Getty Images TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
525
The Harmony Silk Factory
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Tash Aw, born in Taipei, Taiwan, was raised in Malaysia, and moved to England at the age of eighteen to study law at Cambridge University. Aw worked as a lawyer for four years, writing The Harmony Silk Factory when he could find the time. After he had saved enough money, he quit the law firm to enroll in the creative-writing program at the University of East Anglia, where he completed the novel. The book was published quickly after its completion, and won the Whitbread Prize (now the Costa Book Award) for Best First Novel, the Commonwealth Writers’ Prize for Best First Novel, and was long-listed for the Man Booker Prize. Aw’s second book, Map of the Invisible World, has also received great critical acclaim. The author lives in London, but makes several yearly trips to rural Malaysia to visit his grandparents, and give workshops to young writers. He follows a selfimposed, strict work schedule, writing each day from 8:30 am to 6:30 pm. “The big danger,” Aw tells Paul Lloyd, “is that if you’re not disciplined you can just flush your whole day down the loo.” The author is grateful to be a working writer, he says to Bron Sibree, and confesses “I think I was made in some way to live with words.”
son Jasper, “speaks in the way an educated Malaysian would, which is grammatically correct but not very idiomatic” (qtd. in Barta). His second narrator, Snow Soong, Johnny’s wife, tells her version of events through diary entries. Snow’s section of the novel, which tells of a voyage to the group of islands known as The Seven Maidens, takes on a dreamlike quality that borders on magical realism, as Luke Beesley notes. Indeed, her diary begins, “Accept your fate . . . Mother’s words invade my dreams” (137). After a strong storm washes the small crew overboard, they camp on one of the islands, and Snow is haunted by strange cries in the night it seems only she can hear. Aw comments, “The big element in Malay rural tradition is the ghost story. In Snow’s section, the landscape is very threatening and heightened” (qtd. in Ghosh). The third section of the narrative is told by the British Peter Wormwood, and “most of the book’s intertextuality occurs in Peter’s section” Aw tells Barta. It is also the only section to include any British slang. According to Neel Mukherjee, writing for the Times, “Where Aw emerges as uncontested winner is in the subtle modulations of the three narratorial voices. From the clunky unreliability of Jasper, through the pellucid prose of Snow’s journal to the intelligent, slightly camp,
Johnny Lim’s ancestors in the novel The Harmony Silk Factory spent their lives doing backbreaking work mining precious metals, like those pictured here, for very little pay. Lisa Wiltse/Bloomberg via Getty Images
526
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Harmony Silk Factory
aesthetic eloquence of Wormwood, Aw orchestrates a graceful ballet of dissonances and congruences, of echoes and discords.” The result is prose that, in Clark’s opinion, is “lucid, uncluttered, beautiful . . . and fluid, not unlike the beauty found in a length of silk.”
W Critical Reception The Harmony Silk Factory was well-received by critics, though one area where opinions differed was the structure of the novel, with its three shifting narrative perspectives. According to Carlo Wolff, writing in the Denver Post, the concept is good, but “thinks better than it reads.” Aw “writes with what seems like effortless fluidity,” Alfred Hickling maintains, “yet the dazzling haze of the construction seems ultimately designed to deflect attention from the fact that it frequently demands patient re-reading without really deserving it.” However, Publishers Weekly notes “the chief benefit of this structural trick is to make palpable the limitations of each character’s perspective, and that’s no mean feat.” These limitations paint a contradictory portrait of Johnny Lim, which bothered some reviewers. “Their interpretations are too diverse. There is no subtlety. . . . [For] the son and wife to see such enormous variations in character is too unbelievable,” Alyson Rudd asserts. Paramita Ghosh takes issue with each character’s reference to Lim as “inscrutable.” “The book’s stumbling block is its core. At its heart is the same old cliché of the inscrutable East that the writer seems to have peddled and criticized at the same time.” Most reviewers, however, find the “deliciously unreliable” narrators, in Tom Adair’s description, one of the book’s most appealing qualities. Ultimately, critics agree with Anita Sethi’s view that “it is these frayed seams, these broken ties—the constant clutching after, yet eluding of connection—that exert the most powerful emotional pull.” “Like a bolt of raw silk,” Alfred Hickling observes, “Tash Aw’s debut can be a little rough and transparent in places. But perhaps one ought to accept the inconsistencies as integral to the effect.” Neel Mukherjee was among the critics who did not love the narrative device, but “in a book as bewitchingly written and gracefully assured as this, it’s hardly worth quibbling about, particularly when the author makes such dazzling use of his strengths: a sense of unraveling mystery, a devastating revelation towards the end, a complexity that defies a neat tying of all the threads or pat answers.” As Adair comments, “In less gifted hands it would have all imploded. But Tash Aw sings it like a chorus, in perfect pitch, in a book to be prized.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Adair, Tom. “The Harmony Silk Factory: A Trio of Truths.” Rev. of The Harmony Silk Factory, by Tash
Aw. Scotsman [Edinburgh] 26 Mar. 2005. Print. InfoTrac Newsstand. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. Aw, Tash. The Harmony Silk Factory. New York: Penguin Group, 2005. Print. Barta, Peter I. “In Search of Knowledge: Voicing the Void in Tash Aw’s The Harmony Silk Factory.” Intertexts 9.2 (2005): 105+. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. Barta, Peter I. “The Post-colonial Novel: An Interview with Tash Aw.” Intertexts 22 Sept. 2005. Highbeam Research. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. Beesley, Luke. “The Colour of Subtlety.” Review of The Harmony Silk Factory, by Tash Aw. Courier Mail [Queensland, Australia] 28 May 2005. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 12 Sept. 2010. Chan, Charmaine. “The Harmony Silk Factory.” Review of The Harmony Silk Factory, by Tash Aw. South China Morning Post 10 July 2005. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 12 Sept. 2010. Clark, Lucy. “Layered Yarn Spun from Fine Silk.” Review of The Harmony Silk Factory, by Tash Aw. Sunday Telegraph [Sydney] 12 June 2005. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 12 Sept. 2010. De Guzman, Amanda. “A Book with No Message.” Business Times Singapore 5 June 2009. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 12 Sept. 2010. Ellwood, Carlene. “A Story of Love, Regret, and Guilt.” Rev. of The Harmony Silk Factory, by Tash Aw. Sunday Tasmanian [Australia] 19 June 2005. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 12 Sept. 2010. Ghosh, Paramita. “Singing in the Diaspora.” Hindustan Times [New Delhi] 8 Feb. 2009. Print. InfoTrac Newsstand. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. “The Harmony Silk Factory.” Review of The Harmony Silk Factory, by Tash Aw. Publishers Weekly 252.7 (14 Feb. 2005): 52. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. Hickling, Alfred. “Saturday Review: Fiction: Bound in Tropes of Silk: Alfred Hickling Is Maddened and Charmed by a Malayan Adventure.” Rev. of The Harmony Silk Factory, by Tash Aw. Guardian [London] 26 Mar. 2005. Print. InfoTrac Newsstand. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. Jones, Alice. “The Independent Book Group: A Protean Figure amid the Jungle.” Review of The Harmony Silk Factory, by Tash Aw. Independent [London] 7 Oct. 2005. Print. InfoTrac Newsstand. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. “Living in the Margins.” New Zealand Herald 14 May 2009. Print. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 12 Sept. 2010.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
527
The Harmony Silk Factory
Lloyd, Paul. “Meet the Author: Tash Aw; Wrapped in Aw.” Advertiser 30 July 2005. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 12 Sept. 2010. Mukherjee, Neel. “A Malayan Mystery; Fiction.” Rev. of The Harmony Silk Factory, by Tash Aw. The Times [London] 26 Feb. 2005. Print. InfoTrac Newsstand. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. Rudd, Alyson. “The Harmony Silk Factory; We Say. . . . ” Rev. of The Harmony Silk Factory, by Tash Aw. Times [London] 18 Feb. 2006. Print. InfoTrac Newsstand. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. Saner, Emine. “An Overnight Success? It’s Taken Me 12 Years to Win the Whitbread; He Was the Surprise Winner of This Week’s Novel Award, but as Author Tash Aw Reveals, He’s Always Been an Outsider.” Evening Standard [London] 6 Jan. 2006. Highbeam Research. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. Sethi, Anita. “The Friday Book: Unravelling the Strands of Memory.” Rev. of The Harmony Silk Factory, by Tash Aw. Independent [London] 11 Mar. 2005. Print. InfoTrac Newsstand. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. Sibree, Bron. “Veil Lifts on Hidden History.” Courier Mail [Australia] 16 May 2009. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 12 Sept. 2010. Tuffield, Aviva. “Colonial Fantasies Laid to Rest.” EXTRA 28 Aug. 2005. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 12 Sept. 2010. Wolff, Carlo. “WWII in Malaysia, through a Lens Vaguely.” Rev. of The Harmony Silk Factory, by Tash Aw. Denver Post 27 Mar. 2005. Print. InfoTrac Newsstand. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. Yoong, Sean. “Malaysian Author’s International Success Buoys Country’s Literary Hopes.” AP Worldstream 22 July 2005. Highbeam Research. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
language is adapted and remade both in the postcolonial novel, and the world at large. Gee, Maggie. “In a Jungle of Emotions; Fiction.” Review of The Harmony Silk Factory, by Tash Aw. Sunday Times [London] 6 Mar. 2005: 53. Print. InfoTrac Newsstand. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. In her slightly mixed review of The Harmony Silk Factory, Gee feels the influence of Joseph Conrad is too heavily felt in Aw’s novel. “Hot off the Press.” Review of The Harmony Silk Factory, by Tash Aw. Straits Times [Singapore] 4 Sept. 2005. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 12 Sept. 2010. A mixed review of Aw’s novel that speaks specifically to the strength of the final third of the book. Jones, Alice. “The Independent Book Group: Smoothness in Triplicate; Alice Jones Reveals Your Views on The Harmony Silk Factory.” Rev. of The Harmony Silk Factory, by Tash Aw. Independent [London] 7 Oct. 2005: 26. Print. InfoTrac Newsstand. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. The Independent Book Group members share their views of Tash Aw’s The Harmony Silk Factory. McCarthy, Marian. “Silky Prose in a Debut to Be in Aw Of.” Review of The Harmony Silk Factory, by Tash Aw. Age [Melbourne] 18 June 2005. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 12 Sept. 2010. In this very positive review, McCarthy cites the author’s refusal to give any concrete answers as one of the book’s biggest strengths. Nayar, Parvathi. “Writing with a Sense of Nostalgia; Parvathi Nayar Talks to Tash Aw, the Winner of the Whitbread First Novel, and Reviews His The Harmony Silk Factory.” Business Times Singapore 27 Jan. 2006. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 12 Sept. 2010. Rabalais, Kevin. “No Place Like Home.” Weekend Australia 9 May 2009. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 12 Sept. 2010.
Cheuse, Alan. “A Poor Malaysian Boy Does Well, Then Falls Far.” Review of The Harmony Silk Factory, by Tash Aw. San Francisco Chronicle, 3 Apr. 2005. Print. SFGate. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. A very favorable review of Aw’s novel, calling it a “beautifully composed and memorable story.”
Gale Resources
Cuthbert, Denise. “Whose English Is It Anyhow? Denise Cuthbert Suggests How Traditional Tools of Western Dominance, Including the English Language, May Be Fruitfully Adapted and Redeployed by Former Colonial Nations.” Meanjin 66.2 (2007): 81+. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. In her essay, Cuthbert demonstrates the relationship forged with the English language in formerly colonized nations, and the ways in which the English
The Web site for the Costa Book Awards, formerly called the Whitbread Prize, gives information about the award, lists of past winners, and submission information. There are also links to any current contests and promotions running on the site, such as the Six Book Challenge, which provides incentives and creative reading activities for adults wishing to improve their literary skills. http://www.costabookawards.com/ index.aspx
528
“Tash Aw.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2006. Literature Resource Center. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. Open Web Sources
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Harmony Silk Factory
Tash Aw’s official Web site includes biographical information about the author and his novels and awards. http://www.tash-aw.com/Tash_Aw_ Author_Website/About.html For Further Reading
Aw, Tash. Map of the Invisible World. New York: Spiegel and Grau, 2010. Print. Tash Aw’s second novel takes place in 1960s Indonesia and Malaysia, as it narrates the parallel lives of separated siblings Adam, who searches for his adoptive father, Karl, after he is kidnapped, and Johan, who lives with a wealthy Malaysian family in Kuala Lumpur. Chee, Kee Hua. “The Man behind the Author.” Star Online 12 June 2005. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. In this short interview with Tash Aw, he discusses his newfound fame as a novelist. Doreian, Robyn. “Tash Aw; The Books That Changed Me.” Sun Herald [Sydney] 16 Oct. 2005. LexisNexis Academic. Web. 12 Sept. 2010. Aw discusses some of the books that have had an impact on his life and writing. Eng, Tan Twan. The Gift of Rain. New York: Weinstein Books, 2008. Print. Tan Twan Eng’s first novel tells the story of Philip Hutton—half-Chinese and the youngest son of a successful British trader in Penang, Malaysia— growing up just before and during World War II.
hard times, Tash Aw was inspired to use three separate narrative viewpoints for his novel. Faulkner’s work is told from the points of view of the three Compson brothers, Benjy, Quentin, and Jason, with an additional fourth section told in the third person, without a single first-person narrator. Koch, Christopher. The Year of Living Dangerously. London: Michael Joseph, 1978. Print. Christopher Koch’s novel follows a group of expatriate journalists in Jakarta, Indonesia, in 1965, before and during the overthrow of President Sukarno. Mohan, Ambikaipaker. “As Malay Dying; AngloMalaysian Author Tash Aw Discusses His Faulkneresque Debut Novel.” Austin AmericanStatesman 11 Sept. 2005: K5. Print. InfoTrac Newsstand. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. In this interview, Aw discusses the subject of British colonialism in Malaysia, and the ways in which it has been portrayed by British writers. Nagu, Suzieana Uda. “A Tale to Tell.” New Straits Times 29 April 2007. Highbeam Research. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. Aw talks with Nagu about traveling to promote The Harmony Silk Factory, and discusses beginning work on his second novel. Bisanne Masoud
Faulkner, William. The Sound and the Fury. Jonathan Cape and Harrison Smith, 1929. Print. After reading Faulkner’s classic story of a Mississippi family fallen on
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
529
The “Harry Potter” Series By J. K. Rowling
W Introduction
W Literary and Historical
The “Harry Potter” series (1997-2007), is comprises of seven volumes and three supplemental books that have sold more than 325 million copies worldwide. The story of a boy wizard whose fate is to thwart the most powerful dark wizard in history, the series has received numerous awards, including the British Book Award, the Nestlé Smarties Gold Award, the Hugo Award, the Andre Norton Award, and the Mythopoeic Fantasy Award for children’s literature. Available in more than 200 countries and translated into 64 languages, the Harry Potter saga is one of the most popular children’s series of all time, as well as a pop culture phenomenon. Written in third person, the books follow Harry Potter from his unassuming beginnings living in a cupboard under the stairs to his discovery that he is not only a wizard, but a famous one, since his survival of a killing curse from the evil Lord Voldemort temporarily defeated the dark lord. Over seven books, Harry grows from an eleven-year-old child to a competent seventeen-year-old wizard, who makes the adult decision to face down Voldemort once and for all. As much a series of mysteries or British school novels as they are fantasies, the books explore very real themes of growing up, struggling with loss, and doing the right thing. They embrace the classic tropes of good versus evil, follow the pattern of the mythic hero, and make great use of fairy-tale elements from tales around the world. J. K. Rowling’s alternate world of wizardly magic has introduced new vocabulary—“muggles” for nonmagical people, or “quidditch,” the most famous wizarding sport— into pop culture and created one of the most popular series of all time.
Context
By the end of the twentieth century, the fantasy genre already had ardent fans, and children’s fantasy novels were a well established medium. The publication of J. R. R. Tolkien’s The Hobbit in 1937 and his subsequent Lord of the Rings trilogy helped to define many of the tropes that became standard in fantasy. But J. K. Rowling, who told Lev Grossman in 2005 that she had never finished The Lord of the Rings, used tropes while also working to turn the genre on its head, avoiding the escapism common in other fantasy novels. “I was trying to subvert the genre,” Rowling told Grossman in Time. “Harry goes off into this magical world, and is it any better than the world he’s left? Only because he meets nicer people. Magic does not make his world better significantly. The relationships make his world better. Magic in many ways complicates his life.” The fantasy content in the series drew crowds of antiwitchcraft protesters and censors. The books were often pulled from school library shelves and school book sales. A group of students in Zeeland, Michigan, formed one of the first anticensorship groups to defend the books, calling themselves Muggles for Harry Potter. Supported by the American Booksellers for Freedom of Expression, the group fought to be allowed to read the books without restriction, and in May 2000, the books were returned to shelves in school libraries. The series continued to face censorship throughout its publication, topping the American Library Association’s list of top one hundred banned books of the decade from 2000-2009.
W Themes Over the course of the Harry Potter series, the three primary characters grow up from eleven-year-old
530 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The “Harry Potter” Series
MAJOR CHARACTERS ALBUS DUMBLEDORE is the headmaster of Hogwarts, a boarding school for young witches and wizards. Though he begins the series as a mentor with a special interest in Harry, he grows as a character, with human foibles and flaws, until his childhood and teenage passions are revealed in the final book of the series. HERMIONE GRANGER, one of Harry’s two companions instrumental in helping Harry defeat Voldemort, is known for her quick thinking and book smarts. Early in the series, she is a stick-in-the-mud about breaking the rules, but as she is drawn further into Ron and Harry’s intrigues, she becomes adept at navigating the gray areas between the rules. DRACO MALFOY is Harry’s primary rival. A full-blooded wizarding aristocrat, Malfoy dedicates himself to the cause of Voldemort. But as he realizes the risks of angering his chosen master, he suffers, mirroring what may have happed to Harry if he had chosen the path of darkness himself.
J. K. Rowling, author of The “Harry Potter” Series, autographs copies of her book Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows at the Kodak Theater in Los Angeles. AP Photo/Ric Francis, File
beginning students into accomplished magic-wielding adults, capable of making decisions that impact not only their lives but the larger world as well. The classic theme of coming of age is explored not only through Harry Potter, but through his companions Ron Weasley and Hermione Granger. That their journey from childhood to adulthood happens over seven books, which were published over the course of ten years, meant that the reading audience who began at the age of the characters when the series started roughly paralleled their aging process. As horror writer and critic Stephen King wrote in Entertainment Weekly, “Jo Rowling’s kids grew up . . . and the audience grew up with them.” Like many epic tales, the Harry Potter series revolves around the struggle between the hero and the villain, between good and evil. But while some roles are clear— Harry is always the hero and Voldemort, always the villain—there are many shades of gray in between, making it difficult at times for the characters to know whom they can trust. That moral complexity deepens the stories, keeping them from offering easy answers. Though magic solves many problems, it creates them as well, and though it is often used by Rowling to move the plot
HARRY POTTER is the young hero of the series. Born to two talented wizards, Harry is targeted by Voldemort with a spell meant to kill the child. Instead, the spell rebounds against Voldemort, marking Harry forever as The Boy Who Lived. As Harry learns more about his family history, he grows in his own magical abilities until at last he confronts, and defeats, the evil wizard. SEVERUS SNAPE, the potions master at Hogwarts for the first five books, is the most ambiguous character in the novels. Once a follower of Voldemort, he has sworn his allegiance to Dumbledore. In order to serve as a spy against Voldemort’s people, he must pretend to be loyal to Voldemort, and his actions make this loyalty seem the truth. Snape hates Harry due to his previous rivalry with Harry’s father, but is pledged to protect the boy because of his feelings for Harry’s mother. LORD VOLDEMORT was once a Hogwarts student named Tom Riddle, but his lust for power drove him to become one of the most powerful dark wizards known to history. His attempt to kill Harry as a baby nearly defeated him, and it takes most of Harry’s young life for Voldemort to regain a body, and his former power. In the final book, Harry must confront the villain, resulting in Voldemort’s death. RON WEASLEY is Harry’s best friend and a stalwart companion, and, alongside Hermione, is instrumental in helping Harry defeat Voldemort. The youngest of several brothers, Ron serves as a kind of foil for the orphaned Harry. Though Ron often serves as comic relief, over the course of the series, he too grows and matures, proving himself a worthy friend, and worthy of the romantic interest of Hermione.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
531
The “Harry Potter” Series
ABOUT THE AUTHOR J. K. Rowling is one of the best-known, best-selling writers in the world; the success of the “Harry Potter” series has given Rowling celebrity appeal. Before becoming a writer, she worked as an educator, teaching English as a foreign language in Portugal. After a divorce, she moved to Edinburgh with her young daughter, where she eventually finished Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone. She first got the idea for the boy wizard while traveling on a delayed train from Manchester to King’s Cross Station in London. Rowling had not anticipated the worldwide appeal the books came to enjoy, but she has used her fame to make contributions to charity organizations; several of her tie-ins to the Harry Potter novels have been sold with all of the proceeds going to charities, such as Comic Relief, the Children’s Voice, Children’s High Level Group, and Dyslexia Action. Having finished the Harry Potter series, Rowling has said she is working on a different type of book, and is unlikely to write another fantasy story.
along, it is never used to cheat the characters out of ethical dilemmas. In fact, magic has no power over death, a lesson in acceptance that begins in the very first novel and resolves poignantly as the series comes to a close.
W Style While the “Harry Potter” series is easily classified as fantasy, the books follow a pattern identified by critic Harold Bloom as traditional of novels about British boys’ schools, beginning with Tom Brown’s School Days by Thomas Hughes, first published in 1857. Christopher Hitchens of the New York Times likewise compared the novels to the “Boys’ Weeklies” stories set in British boarding schools, published during the 1940s. The mundane part of Harry’s life—his classes and the sports team that often take priority over the larger good vs. evil battle for the first six books—is structured by the boarding school atmosphere at Hogwarts, despite the fact that the subject material for the students is exclusively magic. The seventh book, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, is the first and only installment to diverge from the school story structure. Several of the novels in the series also make use of the traditional mystery format, offering a riddle to be solved by the heroes as they gain clues. For example, in Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets, the entire plot revolves around who has opened the chamber and let out a monster that is harming students; Harry, Ron, and Hermione piece together clues, discovering the secret just in time for Harry to confront the villain. The climax of the series serves as the final denouement and the mystery is solved.
532
The world of the series is based on a contemporary setting, roughly paralleling the dates of the books’ publications; the alternate reality is populated with creatures from fairy tales, mythologies, and legends from all over the world. The characters are multicultural British students and adults, and the creatures they encounter range from entirely new creations (such as the terrifying dementors) to dragons with breed names and brownielike house elves that Hermione encourages to unionize. Many of the elements are based on folklore and fairy tales, but are changed to fit the modern sensibilities of the readers.
W Critical Reception Initially published in 1997, Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone, published as Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone in the United States, won several awards and some critical attention—as a children’s book. By the fourth book, Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, the novels had become a phenomenon. Bookstores stayed open until midnight the day of the release, serving drinks named after beverages from the books and offering games and trivia based on the books. The novels spawned fan fiction, rock bands based on and named after the characters, and academic conferences to discuss the works. But while the books became a popular success early on, the critical world has been divided on how to treat the novels. In his now-famous opinion piece in the Wall Street Journal, critic Harold Bloom dismisses the novels as simply children’s books, and not very good ones at that. He writes, “One can reasonably doubt that Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone is going to prove a classic of children’s literature. . . . [Rowling’s] prose style, heavy on cliché, makes no demands upon her readers.” Though many academics sided with Bloom in not considering children’s books worth critical reaction, prominent institutions such as the New York Times have reserved review space for each title, and noted writers, including Stephen King, have been the series’ staunchest defenders. Rowling “was and is an incredibly gifted novelist,” King writes in his Entertainment Weekly review of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows. “While some of the blogs and the mainstream media have mentioned that Rowling’s ambition kept pace with the skyrocketing popularity of her books, they have largely overlooked the fact that her talent also grew.” The academic sphere has also seen a growth of interest in the series. Dr. Gwen A. Tarbox of Western Michigan University suggests that there is a field of Harry Potter studies. “There’s such a large body of criticism now and the level of scholarship is really excellent,” she explains in the Observer. “‘We need to recognise that just because something’s popular doesn’t mean it’s bad. There’s a great deal we can learn about things that are TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The “Harry Potter” Series
popular. And it’s popular among such a diverse group of readers.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
series. He looks at the understanding of death as it appears in the series, and how this relates to Harry as a Christ-figure.
Works Cited
Gale Resources
Bloom, Harold. “Can 35 Million Americans Be Wrong? Yes.” Wall Street Journal 11 July 2000. Web. 12 July 2010.
“The Harry Potter Phenomenon.” Philip Nel. Dictionary of Literary Biography Yearbook 1999. Ed. Matthew J. Bruccoli. Detroit: Gale Group, 2000. 173-79. Dictionary of Literary Biography Online. Web. 12 July 2010.
Cadwalladr, Carole. “Harry Potter and the Mystery of an Academic Obsession.” Observer 6 Aug. 2006. Web. 12 July 2010. Grossman, Lev. “J. K. Rowling: Hogwarts and All.” Time 17 July 2005. Web. 12 July 2010. Hitchens, Christopher. “The Boy Who Lived.” New York Times Book Review 12 Aug. 2007: Book Review Desk: p1(L). King, Stephen. “J. K. Rowling’s Ministry of Magic.” Entertainment Weekly 17 Aug. 2007. Web. 15 July 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Baggett, David, Shawn E. Klein, and William Irwin, eds. Harry Potter and Philosophy: If Aristotle Ran Hogwarts. Chicago: Open Court, 2004. Print. Part of the “Pop Culture and Philosophy” series, this collection features seventeen essays by philosophy experts on topics including the ethics of magic, the relation of the brain to the mind, and feminism as shown through Hermione. Berman, Laura. “Dragons and Serpents in J. K. Rowling’s Harry Potter Series: Are They Evil?” Mythlore 27.1-2 (2008): 45. Print. Berman delves into the mythological differences used by Rowling to distinguish her snakes from her dragons, making comparisons in her text to the works of Tolkien, the Chronicles of Narnia, and The Little Prince.
“J. K. Rowling.” Children’s Literature Review. Ed. Tom Burns.Vol.112.Detroit:CengageGale,2006. 118-216. Literature Criticism Online. Web. 12 July 2010. “J. K. Rowling.” Children’s Literature Review. Ed. Scot Peacock. Vol. 80. Detroit: Gale, 2002. 174-216. Literature Criticism Online. Web. 12 July 2010. “J. K. Rowling.” Children’s Literature Review. Ed. Jennifer Baise. Vol. 66. Detroit: Gale Group, 2001. 77-111. Literature Criticism Online. Web. 12 July 2010. “J. K. Rowling.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Web. “J. K. Rowling.” Contemporary Literary Criticism. Ed. JeffreyW.Hunter.Vol.217.Detroit:Cengage Gale, 2006. 172-354. Literature Criticism Online. Web. 12 July 2010. “J. K. Rowling.” Contemporary Literary Criticism. Ed. Jeffrey W. Hunter. Vol. 137. Detroit: Gale Group, 2001. 304-41. Literature Criticism Online. Web. 12 July 2010. “J. K. Rowling.” Something about the Author. Vol. 174. Detroit: Gale, 2007. 147-54. Something about the Author Online. Web. 12 July 2010. Open Web Sources
Croft, Janet Brennan. “Naming the Evil One: Onomastic Strategies in Tolkien and Rowling.” Mythlore 28.1-2 (2009): 149. Print. Tolkien scholar Croft discusses the consequences of naming evil in the “Harry Potter” series and in Tolkien’s Middle Earth materials.
J. K. Rowling’s Home Page offers inside information behind the “Harry Potter” series, a biography of Rowling, news about her books, and a place to debunk rumors collected online. The site also offers links to resources in publishing, Rowling’s charitable foundation, and the “Harry Potter” films. http:// www.jkrowling.com/
Kakutani, Michiko. “For Harry Potter, Good OldFashioned Closure.” New York Times. 18 July 2007. Web. 12 July 2010. In this review, Kakutani, a Pulitzer Prize-winning critic, offers an assessment of the “Harry Potter” series through the lens of its final installment, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows.
The fan site MuggleNet, which has been active since 1999, collects rumors, news, and discussions about the “Harry Potter” series, including news about the films and the actors. It is also a repository of fan fiction, fan art, and an interactive role playing game based on the novels. http://www.mugglenet.com/
McCarron, Bill. “Christianity in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows.” Notes on Contemporary Literature. 2009. HighBeam Research 17 Feb. 2011. McCarron examines Christian themes in the “Harry Potter” series, specifically revealed in the final volume of the
Warner Bros., the producers of the Harry Potter films, hosts an interactive Web site for the movies. The site opens to the most recent film, offering trailers, a gallery of stills, and information about the plot. http://harrypotter.warnerbros.com/
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
533
The “Harry Potter” Series
The American publisher of the “Harry Potter” series, Scholastic, has polls, trivia challenges, pronunciation guides, and other resources for each book of the series. Illustrations from the American editions, by Mary Grandpré, are also featured on the site. http:// harrypotter.scholastic.com/ For Further Reading
Hughes, Thomas. Tom Brown’s Schooldays. London: Macmillan, 1857. Print. An example of a British school novel, the book follows the adventures of young Victorian boy Tom Brown at his rugby school. Tom’s rivalry with fellow student Flashman is similar to Harry Potter’s relationship with Draco Malfoy, though without the life-or-death stakes. A 1913 edition of the novel is available as a free e-book. Riordan, Rick. The Lightning Thief. New York: Hyperion, 2005. Print. Related in the coming-of-age and good versus evil themes to the Harry Potter series, The Lightning Thief and its sequels follow the tale of Percy Jackson, a twelve-year-old who discovers he is the son of a Greek god. Alongside his friends, Percy defends a modern-day Olympus against the threat of a reborn Kronos.
Deathly Hallows, The Tales of Beedle the Bard is a collection of fairy tales that children from Rowling’s wizarding world grew up being told. The collection contains notations by Albus Dumbledore and was ostensibly compiled by Hermione Granger after the events of the final book. We Are Wizards. Dir. Josh Koury. Brooklyn Underground Films, 2008. Film. This documentary, written by director Josh Koury, explores the fan culture surrounding the Harry Potter novels. The film follows several of the wizard rock bands, including Harry and the Potters, Draco and the Malfoys, and the Hungarian Horntails. Adaptations
The Harry Potter novels have been adapted as films by Warner Bros.: Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone, 2001; Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets, 2002; Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, 2004; Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, 2005; Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, 2007; Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, 2009; and Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, in two parts, 2010 and 2011.
Rowling, J. K. The Tales of Beedle the Bard. London: Children’s High Level Group, 2008. Print. First referenced in the 2007 novel Harry Potter and the
534
Alana Joli Abbott
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Hiding Place By Trezza Azzopardi
W Introduction Trezza Azzopardi’s debut novel, The Hiding Place (2000), tells the story of a poor Maltese immigrant family living near the docks in Cardiff, Wales. Using both first and third person narration, Azzopardi tells this story mostly from the perspective of the youngest of the six daughters, Dolores (called Dol), who is born in 1960. The novel depicts what happens to a family when the father is a compulsive gambler, whose losses eat away at the household and who is willing to pay off his debts by giving away his daughters. Having immigrated to Tiger Bay in 1948, Frank Gauci is a self-confident risk taker and slow thinker, who jumps to conclusions and acts on them without considering how these actions affect others. The family gradually and inexorably disintegrates under the blows of his recklessness, rampant gambling, and physical abuse. His abandonment of the family hastens his wife’s mental breakdown and is the final blow to the family’s dissolution. The plot depicts a series of family disasters and betrayals, perhaps the most important of which, certainly for Dolores, is the kitchen fire that leaves her as a newborn infant scarred and without the fingers on her left hand. Her presence in the family from this point on is to confirm its bad luck or, worse, a curse upon the household. In all, the novel depicts how precarious life is for children born into extreme poverty to parents unable to meet their needs. It dramatizes the vulnerability of females, particularly in this kind of situation, whose sexual appeal or lack of it determines their value in the marketplace of matchmaking and marriage. Mary Gauci, the mother, is as much at risk as her daughters in this respect, and facing desperate financial conditions, she resorts to sexual bartering in the thin hope of maintaining the household. The novel focuses on the mid 1960s, when Dolores is five years old. The child’s perception of events is
augmented by the knowledge of the adult woman Dolores becomes who returns to the family house upon the death of her mother. The Hiding Place was distinguished by being short-listed for the Man Booker Prize, and in the years immediately following its appearance, the novel was translated into over a dozen languages.
W Literary and Historical Context
One literary context for The Hiding Place is the bildungsroman, the autobiographical novel of maturation. In this genre are certain novels that depict the powerlessness of children in corrupt and abusive environments, such as Charles Dickens’s David Copperfield (1850). The protagonists in novels of this sort typically look back as mature adults, both seeking to understand the world they inhabited as a child and seeing that world, at least in part, through the child that protagonist once was. The reader has a perspective on that world the child cannot share, but the awakening mature protagonist tries to piece together. The reader sees the child’s powerlessness, the cruelty and kindness of adults caring for the child, and the unfairness of the world at large in which this unsuspecting child has been born. So in a sense there is a distinction between the awareness of the first-person narrator and the reader’s interpretation of the text that narrator provides. Azzopardi’s departure from this genre lies in her use of third-person point of view to fill out or expand the story beyond the central narrator’s field of awareness and vision. Regarding the historical context of the novel, Leo Carey in his review of The Hiding Place pointed out that Azzopardi directs attention to the Maltese immigrant experience in Wales: “Though far less prominent in British society, let alone British fiction, than immigrants from former colonies, a Maltese and southern Italian
535 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Hiding Place
MAJOR CHARACTERS EVA AMIL, Mary’s only friend, helps the family after the fire and during crises. She is especially fond of Dolores, whom she calls Petal. SALVATORE CAPANONE is Frankie’s best friend and co-owner initially of The Moonlight café. CELESTA GAUCI is the eldest Gauci daughter who marries a well-to-do widower and remains in Cardiff. DOLORES GAUCI, called Dol, is the narrator, the youngest of the Gauci daughters, born in Cardiff but as an adult works as a librarian in Nottingham. FRANCESCA GAUCI, called Fran, is always to blame and punished severely. She cuts her name into her forearm and eventually becomes a street person. FRANK GAUCI, called Frankie, is the husband of Mary and father of six daughters, a compulsive gambler and abusive man who abandons his family. LUCA GAUCI is the fifth daughter, impossible to control as a child, and intensely angry. She marries and lives in Vancouver as an adult and at the time of Mary’s funeral has developed cancer. MARY GAUCI is Frank’s wife and the mother of six daughters, who has a mental breakdown as she witnesses the disintegration of her family. ROSARIA GAUCI, called Rose, the third Gauci daughter, ultimately marries Terence, who is as abusive to her as her father was. JOE MEDORA, initially Frankie’s friend, is the local Cardiff mobster who takes Frankie’s daughter Marina in payment for Frankie’s debts. PIPPO SEGUNA, a drinks merchant and widow, marries Celesta Gauci, who is over twenty years his junior. Celesta and Pippo have two sons, Jumbo and Lewis.
diaspora flowed steadily to Welsh coastal towns through most of the 20th century.” Specifically, the novel depicts how “this closed society is clannish, Catholic and ruled by a local mafia.” The novel also focuses on the seductiveness of gambling and other criminal activity that promises something for nothing or for apparently nothing, but in which the reward of potential fast money comes with high though likely hidden risk. Much research indicates correlations between problem gambling and eroding family conditions. For example, the article “Gambling Addiction and Problem Gambling: Signs, Symptoms, and Treatment” states that “gambling can strain . . . relationships, interfere with responsibilities at home and work,
536
and lead to financial catastrophe.” The devastating impact of addictive gambling on a family is depicted graphically in The Hiding Place. In his review, Carey stated: “In [Frankie’s] hands, coins, cards, dice and horses are like so many weapons to inflict damage on his family.”
W Themes First and foremost, The Hiding Place explores the terrain of child abuse and neglect. It depicts the way children learn about the world through their familial experiences, variously internalizing abusive patterns, acting them out, and trying as they mature to escape this painful legacy of their childhood. Carol Anshaw explained in her review of the novel how parental abuse increases children’s already natural vulnerability: “Without the protection and guidance of parents, the way grows lonelier and more treacherous, with boogeymen lurking in the shadows. And when the parent himself is the boogeyman, childhood becomes the landscape of nightmare; the earth runs red, the sky turns black.” Equally important is the theme concerning memory, which comes via the author’s handling of point of view and time. The present time of the returning adult child who seeks to piece together the past and make a list of whatever and whoever is missing is the overarching perspective in which the perceptions and skewed memories of certain events are laid out, and the spaces between the found bits filled in with fiction or left gaping because of blank ignorance. The adult Dolores, now a librarian in Nottingham, states that she is good at lists, assumes in returning to her family’s home she will be able to find the necessary artifacts to outline the past she shared with her sisters. She wants what happened to tally, to make sense. In the reunion after Mary’s death, Celesta, the eldest daughter, protests that she does not “Do Memory Lane” (266). Perhaps she can afford to resist it; she marries into financial security, part of which requires her not to expose her husband’s criminal activities. But for Dolores this is the work at hand, literally and metaphorically. She is the archivist, the one who uncovers what other people may think is lost for good. She recalls: “I used to think my hand would grow back . . . I’d watch for signs. At night, I’d will the fingers to sprout, eating up the vacant space like a bloom captured on a time-lapse camera” (278). Dolores sees in her own body the legacy of loss, and for her, the work of maturation is discovering “what will and won’t grow back” (278). Memory work is central to her process of making peace with what is, however unjust and cruel.
W Style One striking feature of style in The Hiding Place is Azzopardi’s handling of point of view. Partly, the novel is TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Hiding Place
the first-person narrative of Dolores Gauci, and much of this narrative pertains to a time when Dolores is five years old. The novel opens with this five-year-old child keeping a lookout for her father in order to provide her mother with time to visit safely with Mary’s friend Eva Amil. Within two pages, this point of view expands, as Dol relates how as a newborn she slept in a chest, hidden from her father, and how her mother moved the baby in its bed dangerously near the kitchen fire. The first chapter ends with the narrator admitting, “That was a time before I was four. The house is still here, and now I am here, standing at the window of the bedroom we shared” (6). Thus, this first-person narrator is actually the adult woman who has returned and who in moving around the now-empty childhood house recalls memories of and stories about her childhood. The complication in this point of view comes as the narrator tells parts of the story in third person from the perspective of others, reporting what she has been told in many cases but in others not revealing how she came to know certain parts of the family history. Some of this history is challenged by the other sisters. At the same time that the point of view suggests much can be “unearthed” (277), the fact is that, like her baby fingers that melted in
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Trezza Azzopardi was born in Cardiff, Wales, one of six children born to a Maltese father and a Welsh mother. She graduated from University of East Anglia (UEA) with a BA in English and American studies and an MA in creative writing. She also obtained an MA in film and television studies at the University of Derby. Following The Hiding Place (2000), Azzopardi published three novels: Remember Me (2003), Winterton Blue (2007), and The Song House (2010). The Hiding Place was short-listed for the Booker Prize and the James Tait Black Memorial Prize and won the Geoffrey Faber Memorial Prize. As of 2010, Azzopardi taught at UEA and lived in Norwich, England.
the fire, much is lost forever. In this sense, the novel’s style underscores one of its themes: memory is an often creative work of maturation, an inevitably imperfect and incomplete process. The challenge in reading this novel was explained by Anshaw in her review: “Memory and dream come into play as mechanisms for sorting out a life
The Hiding Place tells the story of a poor family of Maltese immigrants living by the docks of the city of Cardiff, Wales. ª Anne-Marie Palmer / Alamy
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
537
The Hiding Place
that is chaotic, a house that is dark with secrets, its shadows filled with the unknowable. Time glides from present to past, and eventually into the future.”
W Critical Reception For a debut novel, The Hiding Place scored high among many reviewers, proof of which is its being short-listed for the Booker Prize, a rare distinction for a first work. Describing the novel’s accomplishment, Anshaw stated: “Azzopardi writes with authority, working in an elegant dialect of dreams; many of her scenes have a wavering quality to them, a tint that sets them apart from daylight reality. Incidents are smudged at their edges.” Carey also praised the novel, calling it “quieter and more intense, focusing entirely on the horrific sufferings within a single family.” Eleanor J. Bader called the novel “elegant and auspicious,” and Anshaw called it “impressive.” A reviewer in Publishers Weekly agreed: The Hiding Place proved Azzopardi to be “a writer of remarkable sensibility and literary prowess.” But certain critics disagreed on the unusual handling of point of view. The PW reviewer praised the five-yearold’s narrative, finding it “the perfect voice to unearth the family’s confusing and shady secrets.” Carey took a different position because he put together that child’s story with other firsthand material in the novel: “Perhaps in more deliberate hands,” Carey theorized, “such conflation of perspectives might have yielded some new kind of insight. Here it suggests a simple inability to make up one’s mind about how to tell the story and saps some of the book’s power.” In all, though, many critical reviews applauded what Azzopardi accomplished in this novel. Anshaw, for example, praised the portrait of a family as it “begins cannibalizing itself to survive,” the daughters emerging “scarred, cauterized.” Anshaw concluded: “Aside from a sentimental turn at the end, this book makes none of the faltering steps common to first novels.” Marlene Chamberlain expressed affirmation like that of other critics, writing, “Given the family background, there may be some comparison to Frank McCourt’s memoir, Angela’s Ashes (1996), but Azzopardi’s debut novel stands on its own as a testament to learning to survive childhood when parents are not up to the job and you’re among the down-and-out.” Bader predicted that even resistant readers will be affected by this story: “even the cynical and skeptical will find themselves moved by the Gauci family’s heartbreaking saga.”
Azzopardi, Trezza. The Hiding Place. New York: Atlantic Monthly Press, 2000. Print. Bader, Eleanor J. “The Hiding Place.” Rev. of The Hiding Place, by Trezza Azzopardi. Library Journal 15 Oct. 2000: 100. Print. Carey, Leo. “Snake Eyes: A Novel follows the Dissolution of a Maltese Family in Wales.” Rev. of The Hiding Place, by Trezza Azzopardi. New York Times Book Review 14 Jan. 2001: 16. Print. Chamberlain, Marlene. “The Hiding Place.” Rev. of The Hiding Place, by Trezza Azzopardi. Booklist 1 Sept. 2000: 64. Print. “Gambling Addiction and Problem Gambling: Signs, Symptoms, and Treatment.” http://helpguide.org/ mental/gambling_addiction Helpguide.org, n.d. Web. 14 Nov. 2010. “The Hiding Place.” Rev. of The Hiding Place, by Trezza Azzopardi. Publishers Weekly 6 Nov. 2000: 70. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Carey, Leo. “Snake Eyes: A Novel follows the Dissolution of a Maltese Family in Wales.” Rev. of The Hiding Place, by Trezza Azzopardi. New York Times Book Review 14 Jan. 2001: 16. Print. Evaluates The Hiding Place in light of its being short-listed for the Booker Prize and faults the author’s handling of point of view. Gale Resources
“Trezza Azzopardi.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2007. Literature Resource Center. Web. 13 Nov. 2010. http://go.galegroup.com/ps/i. do?&id=GALE%7CH1000171430&v=2.1& u=itsbtrial&it=r&p=LitRC&sw=w Open Web Sources
Information about Trezza Azzopardi is available for the Web site maintained by the University of East Anglia, http://www.uea.ac.uk/lit/People/Academic/ Trezza+Azzopardi For Further Reading
Karr, Mary. The Liars’ Club. New York: Penguin Group, 1995. Print. Autobiography of a childhood in East Texas with a mentally unstable, often-married mother and abusive father.
Works Cited
Lee, Bill. Born to Lose: Memoirs of a Compulsive Gambler. Center City: Hazelden, 2005. Print. Story of how a twelve-step program saved the life of a first generation Chinese American.
Anshaw, Carol. “In Terra Incognita.” Rev. of The Hiding Place, by Trezza Azzopardi. Women’s Review of Books 18.7 (April 2001): 11. Print.
McCourt, Frank. Angela’s Ashes: A Memoir. New York: Touchstone, 1999. Print. Highly acclaimed autobiography about growing up in extreme poverty in
BIBLIOGRAPHY
538
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Hiding Place
Ireland, a work to which The Hiding Place is compared. Segal, Uma A., Doreen Elliott, and Nazneen S. Mayadas, eds. Immigration Worldwide: Policies, Practices, and Trends. Oxford: Oxford UP, 2009. Print. Examines immigrant patterns in the early twenty-first century, covering migration patterns and refugee status and conditions in twenty-five countries.
Wolff, Geoffrey. The Duke of Deception: Memories of My Father. New York: Vintage Books, 1979. Print. Beautifully written autobiography focusing on the author’s father who was an inveterate liar. Wolff, Tobias. This Boy’s Life: A Memoir. New York: Grove-Atlantic, 1989. Print. Painful 1950s story about the author’s troubled boyhood.
Smith, Andrea L. Colonial Memory and Postcolonial Europe: Maltese Settlers in Algeria and France. Bloomington: Indiana UP, 2006. Print. A study of immigration patterns among Maltese but does not cover Wales.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Melodie Monahan
539
His Dark Materials By Philip Pullman
W Introduction His Dark Materials is a trilogy of fantasy novels: The Golden Compass (1995; published in the United Kingdom as Northern Lights); The Subtle Knife (1997); and The Amber Spyglass (2000). The novels chronicle the coming of age of Lyra Belacqua, a brave young girl destined to break the tyrannical hold of the Church on the people of an alternative world to ours—one that seems similar, but is also reminiscent of late Victorian England. The Church, also aware of her destiny, is set to destroy her. Her journey takes her through the fabric of space into other worlds; leads her into alliances and battles with witches, armored bears, angels, and the dead; reveals her true parents, and unites and eventually divides her from her true love and fellow adventurer, Will Parry. The trilogy’s treatment of organized religion has led to many critics classifying His Dark Materials as an antireligious allegory. As reviewer Michael Dirda states, “Think of this trilogy as a counterblast to C. S. Lewis’s Christian science fiction and his celebrated chronicles of Narnia. [Philip] Pullman is of the Devil’s party, William Blake’s party, and he knows it. He has also written the best, deepest and most disturbing children’s fantasy of our time. By comparison, the agreeable and entertaining Harry Potter books look utterly innocuous.”
W Literary and Historical Context
With the publication of the antireligious allegory His Dark Materials, Pullman ignited a controversy that would get stronger with the appearance of each book. As Dirda states, the books were clearly against organized religion. “Even those who judge his theology objectionable will find Pullman’s sheer storytelling power sinfully irresistible,” he contends. “But make no mistake: This book views organized religion as repressive, life-smothering,
mendacious and just plain wrong, right from the beginning of time.” The religious right in the United States was particularly incensed by Pullman’s books as well as the publication of the Harry Potter series, which romanticized the use of magic and witchcraft. They perceived the books as threats to their worldview and potentially blasphemous. The trilogy has been denounced by both Focus on the Family and the Catholic League for Religious and Civil Rights. Pullman’s trilogy was often viewed as a direct rebuttal of the overt Christianity of C. S. Lewis’s Chronicles of Narnia series. In fact, Pullman has described the Narnia books as religious propaganda. As Peter Hitchens notes, “[M]any who buy these books for children and grandchildren would be surprised, and even shocked, if they knew just how vehemently Pullman despises the Christian Church, and how much he loathes his dead rival, [C. S.] Lewis. He is, in fact, the AntiLewis.” His Dark Materials is also examined in terms of its complicated relationship to John Milton’s epic poem Paradise Lost. When Pullman first envisioned the first book in the trilogy, The Golden Compass, he set out to write a Paradise Lost for kids. In fact, the title of the trilogy is taken from a phrase in Milton’s epic. Paradise Lost tells the biblical story of Adam and Eve’s fall into sin and casting out from the Garden of Eden. In this telling, Satan—in the form of a snake—convinces Adam and Eve to eat the fruit of the tree of knowledge, which results in their loss of innocence and fall from God’s grace. In Pullman’s interpretation, Lyra’s striving for knowledge and experience is courageous, liberating, and ultimately an act of salvation for the universe.
W Themes In Pullman’s trilogy, innocence and experience are key thematic concerns. Because children are innocent and have yet to experience the tribulations of adulthood, they
540 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
His Dark Materials
MAJOR CHARACTERS LORD ASRIEL is a well-respected explorer and researcher in experimental theology. The Church, however, stripped him of his money and power when it was discovered that he had had an affair with a married woman, Mrs. Coulter, and fathered a child, Lyra, with her. He is determined to find the secret behind the mysterious Dust. LYRA BELACQUA is the protagonist of His Dark Materials. As the trilogy opens, she is a twelve-year-old girl who does not remember her life before her uncle, Lord Asriel, brought her to live in Jordan College, a men's-only college at Oxford University in Lyra’s parallel universe. As the trilogy progresses, she must confront many dangerous and tragic situations. IOREK BYRNISON is a male armored bear who proves to be a loyal friend to Lyra. He is a skilled smith, and repairs the subtle knife in the second book of the trilogy. MRS. COULTER is Lyra’s mother and the head of the General Oblation Board (or Gobblers), a Church faction that secretly kidnaps children to experiment on them by cutting away their daemons. PANTALAIMON, or Pan, is Lyra’s daemon. He takes different forms according to his mood or state of mind, including an ermine when he is sleeping and a bird when he and Lyra need to search for something.
Photo of Philip Pullman, author of the His Dark Materials trilogy. ª Colin McPherson/Corbis
do not attract the Dust, or dark matter, that seems to cling to adults. Dust is the physical manifestation of human consciousness—the knowledge, responsibility, and pain that adults must endure. Knowledge is another major theme in His Dark Materials, as the Church strives to keep people in ignorance through fear, superstition, and even violence. In Judeo-Christian theology, Adam and Eve eating the apple from the Tree of Knowledge caused their exile from the Garden of Eden; in Pullman’s book, it is a joyous event that signals the acceptance of free will—even if being free to make your own decisions results in pain and loss. Adam and Eve’s decision to choose free will is reflected in the major struggle of the book: the Church strives to keep people ignorant and impose their beliefs on the populace, while Lord Asriel and his allies struggle to free them. In particular, the Church works relentlessly to discourage physical pleasure, knowing that it connects people to the natural world and leads them to become independent thinkers. As in the Adam and Eve story, sex and knowledge are irrevocably connected and leads to the loss of innocence—something the Church clearly understands and wants to control.
SERAFINA PEKKALA is the queen of a powerful witch clan who helps Lyra as she searches for the lost children. WILL PARRY is a young man who leaves his world in order to find his lost father, the explorer John Parry. In his adventures, he meets Lyra, who becomes his companion and lover. The two are forced apart at the end of trilogy, as Will must live in his world and Lyra must return to her parallel universe. ROGER PARSLOW is Lyra’s friend. It is his kidnapping by the Gobblers that prompts Lyra to travel north to find him. He is eventually killed by Lord Asriel at the end of The Golden Compass.
When Lyra and Will have their sexual encounter, it marks Lyra’s break with the Church and her turn toward experience and adulthood.
W Style In His Dark Materials, Pullman uses an omniscient, anonymous first-person narrator, but he provides the perspective of the major characters. It is a coming-of-age story of the protagonist, Lyra Belacqua, who is twelve years old as the first book opens. By the conclusion of the trilogy,
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
541
His Dark Materials
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Philip Pullman was born in Norwich, England, in 1946. His father was in the Royal Air Force, so he spent much of his young life traveling with his family in England, South Africa, Zimbabwe, and Australia, finally settling in North Wales after his father’s death and mother’s remarriage. As a young man, he attended Exeter College, Oxford, to study English literature. In 1971 he became a teacher, but in his free time he began to pursue in long-standing interest in writing. His first children’s book, Count Karlstein, was published in 1982. In 1986 he became an instructor at Westminster College, where he taught courses on the Victorian novel and on the folk tale. After eight years there, he decided to leave teaching and become a writer full time. He established his reputation as one of England’s best-known fantasy writers with the publication of his trilogy of novels—The Golden Compass (1995; published as Northern Lights in the United Kingdom), The Subtle Knife (1997), and The Amber Spyglass (2000)—known as His Dark Materials. Acclaimed by critics, the trilogy received several prestigious prizes, including the Carnegie Medal, the Guardian Children’s Book Award, and the Whitbread Book of the Year Award for The Amber Spyglass. Pullman also was honored with the 2002 Eleanor Farjeon Award for children’s literature. In 2006 The Golden Compass received the Carnegie of Carnegies, chosen by readers to be the best of all the earlier winners of the award. He was also honored with the Astrid Lindgren Memorial Award in 2005. He lives with his wife, Jude, in Oxford, England.
she is a young woman who has experienced the joy and pain of being separated from her true love. In between, she discovers much about herself, has her worldview completely turned upside down, has an epic battle with evil, and loses both her parents. Pullman’s descriptions are clear and simple without resorting to cliché. To build suspense or prepare a cliffhanger, he shifts between protagonists at crucial moments to provide the reader with the full scope of the danger they are facing. Cliffhangers are prominent: The Golden Compass concludes with Lyra finding a hole in the fabric of space and traveling to another world; The Subtle Knife ends with Lyra’s abduction. The trilogy is also rife with symbolism. One of the most important symbols is the use of daemons to represent the external expressions of people’s souls. Daemons take forms that reflect their humans’ character or mood; they can also take a specific form for a specific action. For example, Lyra’s daemon, Pan, can take the shape of a mouse to run away from danger or a bird to search for something. Witches’ daemons take the form of birds, which reflects their ability to fly. Separating from one’s daemon is very traumatic and can cause great pain. It represents an individual’s separation from one’s own
542
soul and takes great strength and determination. Another key symbol is the aurora borealis, which symbolizes the separation between different worlds. Angels can pass between worlds using the aurora borealis. As the aurora borealis and constellations have throughout time, they also represent the human yearning for knowledge and connection. As early civilizations looked up to the sky and considered explanations for why there were patterns of lights, they incorporated such phenomena as the aurora borealis into their myths, legends, and creation stories. These stories were passed from generation to generation.
W Critical Reception His Dark Materials is one of the most discussed and controversial stories of the early twenty-first century. Controversy erupted over Pullman’s portrayal of organized religion in the trilogy, which is often seen as a scathing indictment of the Roman Catholic Church and its political, religious, and social control. Most reviewers found the book to be a biting anti-Christian allegory, with the church painted as dictatorial and cruel and the universe run as a police state. As critic Andrew Marr observes, “These books have disturbed and angered Christian theologians almost everywhere that they have been noticed. . . . But I want my children to read him for a reason that C. S. Lewis would have understood—because they will be better people afterwards.” However, other critics view the books to be a direct and serious threat to children. For example, Pete Vere describes the books as “Evil. This one word describes Philip Pullman’s His Dark Materials trilogy. All the more diabolical is the marketing of his books to children. And yet, as Catholics continue to debate Harry Potter, Britain’s second-most popular children’s author has snuck onto reading lists as award-winning literature.” Reviewers praise Pullman’s vivid imagination, rich descriptions, intricate plot, and masterful plotting. Dirda asserts that “His Dark Materials is a novel of electrifying power and splendor, deserving celebration, as violent as a fairy tale and as shocking as art must be.” Whatever negatives there were in the trilogy, Dirda claims, the overall effect was quite compelling. “Despite various flaws—too much overt moralizing, the unwarranted flipflop in the fundamental character of Mrs. Coulter, not enough Serafina Pekkala—His Dark Materials is an overwhelming reading experience, brought to a sublime and touching close by The Amber Spyglass,” he concludes. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Chabon, Michael. “Dust & Daemons.” New York Review of Books 25 March 2004. Web. 12 July 2010. Dirda, Michael. Rev. of The Amber Spyglass, by Philip Pullman. Washington Post 29 October 2000. Web. 12 July 2010. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
His Dark Materials
Hitchens, Peter. “A Labour of Loathing.” Spectator 18 January 2003. Web. 12 July 2010.
2008. Literature Resource Center. Web. 12 July 2010.
Marr, Andrew. “Pullman Does for Atheism What C. S. Lewis Does for God.” Telegraph 24 January 2002. Web. 12 July 2010.
“Philip Pullman.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Literature Resource Center. Web. 11 July 2010.
Vere, Pete. “His Dark Materials Trilogy.” Catholic Insight 15 (November 2007). Web. 12 July 2010.
“Philip Pullman.” Contemporary Literary Criticism. Ed. Jeffrey W. Hunter. Vol. 245. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Literature Resource Center. Web. 12 July 2010.
Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Colbert, David. The Magical Worlds of Philip Pullman: A Treasury of Fascinating Facts. New York: Berkley Books, 2006. Print. Explores the inspiration behind His Dark Materials and discusses the controversial themes found in the trilogy. Freitas, Donna, and Jason King. Killing the Imposter God: Philip Pullman’s Spiritual Imagination in His Dark Materials. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 2007. Print. Investigates theological and philosophical dimensions of His Dark Materials, finding that Pullman’s trilogy does not present an atheist vision, but instead one imbued with Christian values and tradition. Lenz, Millicent, with Carole Scott. His Dark Materials Illuminated: Critical Essays on Philip Pullman’s Trilogy. Detroit: Wayne State UP, 2005. Print. Collection of critical essays on Pullman’s trilogy. Rayment-Pickard, Hugh. The Devil’s Account: Philip Pullman and Christianity. London: Darton, Longman and Todd, 2004. Print. Studies the religious and mythological themes found in His Dark Materials and identifies influence on Pullman’s writing. Vere, Pete, and Sandra Meisel. Pied Piper of Atheism: Philip Pullman and Children’s Fantasy. San Francisco: Ignatius Press, 2007. Print. Derides Pullman’s antireligious message in His Dark Materials, describing it as atheistic and harmful to children. Watkins, Tony. Dark Matter: Shedding Light on Philip Pullman’s Trilogy His Dark Materials. Downers Grove: InterVarsity Press, 2004. Print. Offers a laudatory assessment of Pullman’s trilogy and illuminates the major themes of and influences on His Dark Materials. Wheat, Leonard F. Philip Pullman’s His Dark Materials—A Multiple Allegory. Amherst: Prometheus Books, 2007. Print. Contends that His Dark Materials is a complex triple allegory and describes the trilogy as one of the most profound and challenging works ever written. Gale Resources
Byrne, Sandie. “Philip Pullman.” British Writers: Supplement 13. Ed. Jay Parini. Detroit: Scribner’s
Hunt, Caroline C. “Dictionary of Literary Biography Yearbook Award for Distinguished Children’s Book Published in 2000.” Dictionary ofLiterary Biography Yearbook 2000. Ed. Matthew J. Broccoli. Detroit: Gale, 2000. Dictionary of Literary Biography Complete Online. Web. 11 July 2010. Open Web Sources
Philip Pullman’s official Web site at http://www.philip pullman.com provides information on his books, allows viewers to see his illustrations, and provides a forum for fans to discuss His Dark Materials. It also has interviews and a Q & A with the author. Random House’s Web site for His Dark Materials at http://www.randomhouse.com/features/pullman/ includes information on Pullman’s books, the author’s advice on writing, and an excerpt from his 1996 Carnegie Medal acceptance speech. New Line Cinema’s official Web site for the film adaptation of the first novel in the trilogy can be found at http://newline.com/properties/golden compassthe.html. Fans can view art and pictures related to the movie. For Further Reading
Beahm, George W. Discovering the Golden Compass: A Guide to Philip Pullman’s Dark Materials. Charlottesville: Hampton Roads, 2007. Print. Written as a companion piece to the film adaptation of The Golden Compass, this book introduces Pullman’s intricate and imaginative world to beginners. Gribbin, Mary, and John Gribbin. The Science of Philip Pullman’s His Dark Materials. New York: Knopf, 2005. Print. Investigates the science behind Pullman’s trilogy. Loewenstein, David. Milton—Paradise Lost. New York: Cambridge UP, 1993. Print. Examines John Milton’s epic poem in its historical, literary, and theological contexts. Parkin, Lance, and Mark Jones. Dark Matters: An Unofficial and Unauthorised Guide to Philip Pullman’s Internationally Bestselling His Dark Materials Trilogy. London: Virgin, 2005. Print. Offers a dictionary of key words and explanation of key symbols in the trilogy; charts locations and provides a
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
543
His Dark Materials
history of Lyra’s world; and provides essential information on the story. Pullman, Philip. Lyra’s Oxford. 2003. Print. A volume that continues Pullman’s story of His Dark Materials, including a short story, “Lyra and the Birds,” with the same characters as the trilogy, a map of Lyra’s Oxford, a postcard as one character to another, a ship’s itinerary, and a page from a guidebook. Simpson, Paul. The Rough Guide to Philip Pullman’s His Dark Materials. New York: Rough Guides, 2007. Print. Considers the origins of Pullman’s story, examines influences on the books, and offers information on locations found in the trilogy. Squires, Claire. Philip Pullman, a Master Storyteller: A Guide to the Worlds of His Dark Materials. New York: Continuum, 2006. Print. Explores the contexts, sources, and influences that inform His Dark Materials, and scrutinizes the controversies and theological debates surrounding the trilogy.
Discusses autobiographical themes in Pullman’s work and identifies the other major influences on his life and fiction. Adaptations
His Dark Materials. Dir. Nicholas Hytner. Perf. Dominic Cooper, Anna Maxwell Martin, Patricia Hodge, Timothy Dalton. 2003. Stage. Nicholas Wright’s adaptation of Pullman’s trilogy was staged at the Royal National Theatre’s Olivier Theatre in 2003. The play was performed in two parts on alternating nights because of its length. The Golden Compass. Dir. Chris Weitz. Perf. Nicole Kidman, Daniel Craig, Sam Elliott, Kathy Bates, Kristin Scott Thomas. 2007. Film. This cinematic adaptation of the first novel in the His Dark Materials trilogy received mixed reviews on its debut in 2007. Margaret Haerens
Tucker, Nicholas. Darkness Visible: Inside the World of Philip Pullman. London: Wizard Books, 2003. Print.
544
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Home By Marilynne Robinson
W Introduction Home is Marilynne Robinson’s highly acclaimed companion piece to her 2004 Pulitzer Prize-winning novel Gilead. Home tells the same story of 1950s Iowa farm life, but this time the scene shifts from the household of John Ames, the dying Congregationalist minister of Gilead, to that of his closest friend and neighbor, the retired Presbyterian pastor, Robert Boughton. The novels present different perspectives on the theme of the prodigal son in the figure of Jack Boughton, Robert Boughton’s favorite son and the Reverend Ames’s namesake, a ne’er do well and an alcoholic whose return home to Gilead, Iowa, after an absence of twenty years forms the major dramatic incident in both books. The unexpected appearance of the newly repentant Jack in the later work occasions the penetrating moral and philosophical questioning for which Robinson has become famous, for at the heart of Home is the struggle of the elder Boughton to find a way to forgive his son for the disgrace he has brought upon the family. In calculated contrast to Gilead, an epistolary novel written in the form of homiletic letters addressed by Ames to his seven-year-old son, Home is narrated in the third person by Jack’s youngest sister, Glory Boughton, a thirty-eight-yearold childless schoolteacher only recently returned to Gilead herself after a failed marriage. Pious and dutiful but compassionate, Glory is the only person who manages to break through Jack’s silence, and through her the reader is supplied with a more sympathetic portrait of his misdeeds than the one that emerges from Ames’s epistles. Winner of Britain’s Orange Prize for women writers and a finalist for the National Book Award, Home received as much notice for its meditations upon Christian themes as for its precise, lyrical language. As Malcolm Jones writes, “Robinson’s greatest achievement is that she manages to introduce the notions of belief and religious mystery without
ever seeming vague. She never shies away from uncomfortable truths.”
W Literary and Historical Context
A Congregationalist deacon and longtime student of religious history, Robinson draws on her Calvinist reading of theology in all of her writings to express and defend her faith. For Robinson, the seventeenth-century French theologian John Calvin was a humanist far unlike his stereotypical image as an erratic thinker and persecutor of heretics. Robinson’s remarks on Calvin in the essay “Puritans and Prigs” are pertinent to the crisis of Jack Boughton’s return to Gilead: “The belief that we are all sinners gives us excellent grounds for forgiveness and selfforgiveness, and is kindlier than any expectation that we might be saints, even while it affirms the standards all of us fail to attain.” The spiritual preoccupations of Home are immediately apparent in Robinson’s setting; the name of the town, Gilead, is taken from the Book of Jeremiah, specifically the prophet’s lamentation for a “balm in Gilead” to heal sick souls. In an interview with Jennie Rothenberg, Robinson explained that “Gilead” is “used as a symbol of what can be restored, what can be hoped for.” Robinson’s consuming interest in spiritual matters is also manifest in the novel’s patterning after the parable of the prodigal son. Derived from the Gospel of St. Luke, the parable is the story of a favorite son who squanders his inheritance then returns home in poverty to be welcomed with open arms by his father.
W Themes Robinson’s reimagining of the parable of the prodigal son drives the novel’s spiritual themes of guilt, forgiveness, faith, and redemption as well as its controlling ideas of
545 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Home
MAJOR CHARACTERS JOHN AMES is the Congregationalist pastor of Gilead, the Reverend John Boughton’s oldest and closest friend and Jack Boughton’s godfather. Like the Reverend Boughton, Ames is in his seventies and in failing health, but he married late and has a young son, Robby. Ames has long distrusted Jack Boughton, but he is willing to give him a second chance when he sees that Jack is making an effort to reform. GLORY BOUGHTON is the narrator of Home and Jack Boughton’s youngest sister. She is back in Gilead to escape a failed romance and to care for her ailing father, the Reverend John Boughton. Glory has more success reconnecting with Jack than does her father. JACK BOUGHTON is Glory Boughton’s brother, the black sheep of the family who returns home after a twenty-year absence seeking peace and forgiveness. But Jack feels undeserving and destined to failure and struggles to accept kindness. A final disappointment causes Jack to seek solace once again in alcohol, and he leaves Gilead not wanting to cause his father any more pain. ROBERT BOUGHTON is the patriarch of the family, the father of eight children, and the retired Presbyterian minister of Gilead. Boughton is as devoted to the church as he is to his wayward son, Jack, but he has never understood Jack and wonders if he himself is perhaps responsible for his bad behavior. He tries to be kind and gentle to Jack when he reappears in Gilead, but he cannot help himself from lashing out in anger at him.
home and family. Home, in the words of A. O. Scott, is “a book unsparing in its acknowledgment of sin and unstinting in its belief in the possibility of grace.” The Reverend John Boughton is unwavering in his love for his troubled son despite his notorious past—his thieving, his drinking, and his fathering of a child with an underage girl he abandoned—but the elder Boughton’s devotion is matched by his bitterness and by his fear that his failing health will not be able to withstand the heartbreak of his son’s almost certain second escape from Gilead: “I thanked God for him every day of his life, no matter how much grief, how much sorrow—and at the end of it all there is only more grief, more sorrow, and his life will go on that way, no help for it now.” By contrast, the Reverend Ames manages to overcome his persistent fears of Jack’s malignant influence on his young son and becomes persuaded that Jack is deserving of a second chance. According to James Wood, “What propels the book, and makes it ultimately so powerful, is the Reverend Boughton, precisely because he is not the soft-spoken sage that John Ames is in Gilead. He
546
The country estate of Robert Boughton in Home is located in rural Iowa. George Burba/Shutterstock.com
is a fierce, stern vain old man, who wants to forgive his son and cannot.” For his part, Jack is desperately guilty about his misdeeds and desperately in need of family reconciliation, but he considers himself unworthy and finds Glory’s Christian forgiveness unbearable. Yet brother and sister bond while caring for their father, both feeling comforted and at the same time stifled by their childhood home, “this good and blessed and oppressive tabernacle of Boughton probity and kind intent.”
W Style Very little actually happens in Home. It consists mainly of family conversations, some of them relayed in flashback, that circle around similar ideas of loneliness, healing, judgment, mercy, guilt, loss, and forgiveness. The speech of Glory and Jack and their father is filled with the wisdom of the gospels and is laced with scriptural quotation, hymns, and prayers. There are frequent discussions of the Bible as Jack settles into his new domestic routine, working in the garden or in the barn, TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Home
still haunted by his failure to live up to his father’s expectations. In the opinion of many reviewers, Gilead has an old-fashioned feeling that results from the application of Robinson’s singular prose—simple, elegant, restrained, poetic—to matters of quotidian existence and timeless themes of faith and responsibility. The full extent of Jack’s sordid past remains an enigma for much of the novel, as does the exact reason for his decision to make his way back to Gilead. These details are only slowly revealed by Robinson, mostly in the course of hesitant conversations between Jack and Glory, neither of whom are completely comfortable talking about their life’s failures and disappointments. The late revelation that Jack has a Black common-law wife and son in St. Louis comes when Jack’s letters to the woman, Della, are returned in the mail unopened. It had been Jack’s hope that he and Della could find acceptance in Gilead for their mixed-race family with the blessings of the Reverends Ames and Boughton. This dream is shattered by Della’s rejection of him, and Jack resorts to his drinking and other bad habits and resolves to leave Gilead.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Marilynne Robinson is the author of novels widely regarded as American classics. Housekeeping (1980), winner of the Ernest Hemingway Foundation Award for best first novel, established her reputation as a gifted writer of luminous prose with remarkable insights into the importance of history and place in defining the human sensibility. Robinson’s second and third novels, the Pulitzer Prize-winning Gilead (2004) and National Book Award nominee Home (2008), are companion efforts taking up the theme of the prodigal son and focused on the families of Protestant ministers in rural Iowa. In between writing the novels, Robinson devoted herself to nonfiction with important essays on environmental themes and spiritual matters relating to her Congregationalist faith. Robinson currently teaches at the Iowa Writers’ Workshop. She has recently published a new collection of essays, Absence of Mind (2010), which returns to one of her favorite topics, the tension between scientific reasoning and spirituality.
In the novel Home, Jack Boughton returns to his family's rural Iowa home to see to his dying father. IntraClique LLC/ Shutterstock.com
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
547
Home
W Critical Reception Robinson has been much applauded for her unabashedly Christian subject matter in Home. Reviewers have commented at length on her religious and philosophical messages, including the apparent tension between the ideas of spiritual rebirth and Calvinist predestination, but they have also insisted that her themes transcend religious affiliation. Steve J. Van der Weele has commented, “To write a religiousbased novel such as this—doing justice to the requirement of the art of fiction while avoiding didactic heaviness—is a rare accomplishment.” Robinson’s critics often have expressed awe at the beauty of her language, the result of precision and economy, not affect, as Ruth Franklin has noted: “Her language is often elegant, but never elevated.” The slow unraveling of Jack’s history has been a subject of much discussion among critics. For some, he remains too much of a mystery, so that the novel comes up short in comparison with the fuller, more interiorized characterizations of Gilead. James T. Keane, for example, argued that “Ms. Robinson simply leaves the reader feeling that her characters are perversely choosing not to communicate, and as a result, her sad family drama feels less affecting than stage managed.” But Franklin issued an opposing opinion: “Glory will not learn Jack’s full story until the novel’s emotional last pages. Such withholding may at first seem coy, but it is intrinsic to the workings of Robinson’s fiction, in which restraint, both literary and psychological, seems to be a virtue equal to faith, hope, and charity.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Franklin, Ruth. “God Is in the House.” New Republic 239.6 (8 Oct. 2008): 34-38. Rpt. in Contemporary Literary Criticism. Vol. 276. Ed. Jeffrey W. Hunter. Detroit: Gale, Cengage Learning, 2009. Literature Criticism Online. Web. 15 July 2010. Gritz, Jennie Rothenberg. “Gilead’s Balm: Marilynne Robinson Talks about Her Long-Awaited Second Novel and the Holiness of the Everyday.” Atlantic Monthly 17 Nov. 2004. Web. 15 July 2010. Jones, Malcolm. “Wanted: More Balm in Gilead.” Newsweek 22 Sept. 2008: 73. Print. Student Resource Center—College Edition Expanded. Detroit: Gale. Web. 10 July 2010. Keane, James T. “Faith and Family.” America 119.14 (3 Nov. 2008): 29. Print. Student Resource Center— College Edition Expanded. Detroit: Gale. Web. 10 July 2010. Robinson, Marilynne. Home. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2008. Print. ———. “Prigs and Puritans.” The Death of Adam: Essays on Modern Thought. New York: Houghton Mifflin, 1998. Print.
548
Scott, A. O. “Return of the Prodigal Son.” New York Times Book Review 21 Sept. 2008: 16(L). Print. Student Resource Centere—College Edition Expanded. Detroit: Gale. Web. July 2010. Van Der Weele, Steve J. “Home.” Christianity and Literature 58.3 (Spring 2009): 546. Print. Literature Resource Center. Detroit: Gale. Web. 10 July 2010. Wood, James. “The Homecoming.” New Yorker 8 Sept. 2008: 76. Print. Student Resource Center— College Edition Expanded. Detroit: Gale. Web. 10 July 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
De Falbe, John. “Hope and Glory.” Spectator 1 Nov. 2008: 47. Print. Student Resource Center—College Edition Expanded. Detroit: Gale. Web. 10 July 2010. Praises the universality of the novel’s moral questioning, proclaiming, “I know of no comparable examination of the soul in contemporary literature.” Domestico, Anthony. “Acts of Apostles.” Commonweal 135.18 (24 Oct. 2008): 36. Print. Student Resource Center—College Edition Expanded. Detroit: Gale. Web. 10 July 2010. Describes Home as a novel primarily concerned with hospitality, where rituals of care and forgiveness bestowed on the exiled Jack Boughton take on an almost sacramental quality. Grossman, Lev. “Home Is Where the Hurt Is.” Time 22 Sept. 2008: 92. Print. Student Resource Center— College Edition Expanded. Detroit: Gale. Web. 10 July 2010. Finds much to praise in Home but complains that Jack Boughton is too abstract a character to satisfy readers. Jones, L. Gregory. “Back Home in Gilead.” Christian Century 125.22 (4 Nov. 2008): 33. Rpt. in Contemporary Literary Criticism. Vol. 276. Ed. Jeffrey W. Hunter. Detroit: Gale, Cengage Learning, 2009. Print. Literature Criticism Online. Web. 15 July 2010. Praises Robinson for revisiting the character of Jack Boughton in Home, asserting that the novel’s strength rests in teaching readers to consider multiple perspectives. Kakutani, Michiko. “Family Tries Reassembling the Shards of Its Past.” New York Times 9 Sept. 2008: E1 (L). Print. Student Resource Center—College Edition Expanded. Detroit: Gale. Web. 10 July 2010. Negative review of Home finding the family drama contrived and the subject matter—emotional relationships—unsuited to Robinson’s talent for precise language. LaMascus, R. Scott. “Toward a Dialogue on Marilynne Robinson’s Gilead and Home.” Christianity and Literature 59.2 (Winter 2010): 197(5). Print. Student Resource Center—College Edition Expanded. Detroit: Gale. Web. 10 July 2010. Special journal TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Home
issue devoted to Robinson focused mainly on Home and Gilead. Robinson, Marilynne, and Sarah Fay. “The Paris Review Interview.” Paris Review. 186 (Fall 2008). The Art of Fiction, no. 198. Web. 17 July 2010. Frequently quoted interview in which Robinson speaks about her faith, her study of the relationship between science and religion, and her passion for history. Gale Resources
“Gilead.” Novels for Students. Ed. Ira Mark Milne. Vol. 24. Detroit: Gale, 2007. Print. Gale Virtual Reference Library. Web. 10 July 2010. “Marilynne Robinson.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Print. Literature Resource Center. Detroit: Gale. Web. 10 July 2010. Marsh, Janet Z. “Marilynne Robinson.” Twenty-firstCentury American Novelists: Second Series. Ed. Wanda H. Giles and James R. Giles. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 350. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Print. Literature Resource Center. Web. 10 July 2010. Maguire, James H. Twentieth-Century American Western Writers: First Series. Ed. Richard H. Cracroft. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 206. Detroit: Gale Group, 1999. Print. Open Web Sources
Robinson discussed her new collection of essays, Absence of Mind, and the contentious relationship between science and religion on the Daily Show with Jon Stewart, 8 July 2010. http://www.thedailyshow. com/full-episodes/thu-july-8-2010marilynne-robinson
Kecia Lynne spoke with Robinson for a four-part interview conducted on behalf of the Iowa Writers’ Workshop, October, 2009. http://www.youtube. com/watch?v=6sPBBDWmOi4 Robinson spoke with National Public Radio about the “Iowa aesthetic” and her novels Gilead and Home on Weekend Edition Saturday, 20 Sept. 2008. http:// www.npr.org/templates/player/mediaPlayer.html? action=1&t=1&islist=false&id=94799720&m= 94850396 For Further Reading
Holy Bible: New Revised Standard Version. Edited by Bruce M. Metzger. New York: Oxford University Press, 1991. Print. The Gospel of St. Luke, 15:10-32, is Jesus’s parable of the prodigal son. Robinson, Marilynne. Gilead. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2004. Print. The companion volume to Home, which presents a different perspective on the Boughton family black sheep, Jack Boughton. Gilead recalls four generations in the family of Reverend John Ames and is wider in scope than Home, using much of Iowa’s abolitionist history as background. Warren, Robert Penn. The Circus in the Attic and Other Stories. San Diego: Harcourt Brace, 1965. Print. Contains Warren’s most frequently anthologized story, “Blackberry Winter,” about a middle-aged man’s recollections of his ninth summer, June 1910. Critics have suggested that the narrator symbolizes the prodigal son, returned home in his memories.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Janet Mullane
549
Hominids By Robert J. Sawyer
W Introduction Acclaimed science fiction writer Robert J. Sawyer’s Hominids, the first novel in The Neanderthal Parallax series, presents an alternate universe in which Neanderthals have evolved into the dominant species. When the book begins, Ponter Boddit, a Neanderthal scientist, is accidentally sent to our reality while performing a quantum experiment. Hominids is the story of what happens when Boddit, a man from a related but markedly different species learns about our world. It is also an anthropological and philosophical study of Neanderthal society, in contrast to the people and cultures of our Earth. Neanderthals were a primitive society, but Sawyer turns this knowledge upside down in Hominids, presenting them as a more advanced and enlightened group. This contrast is fleshed out early in the book, when Mary Vaughan, a human scientist, is raped. The sweet and potentially romantic relationship that develops between Ponter and Mary ironically highlights the idea that man may be more intrinsically violent than Neanderthals. Hominids won the prestigious Hugo Award for science fiction. Additionally, it was a finalist for the John W. Campbell Memorial Award, the Aurora Award, the Seiun Award, and the Spectrum Award. The San Francisco Chronicle and Borders Books also both named it on their year’s best lists.
W Literary and Historical Context
Neanderthals were not direct ancestors of modern-day man, but an entirely different species called Homo neanderthalensis. Homo sapiens, from whom modern-day man evolved, and Neanderthals coexisted approximately
forty thousand years ago. Both species were driven solely by instinct, with the same low level of comprehension about the world and their place in it. Eventually, consciousness began to emerge in Homo sapiens, bringing with it, in Sawyer’s words, “art and sophisticated language and science and religion and subtle emotions and planning for the future” (“Committing Trilogy”). Less than ten thousand years later, the Neanderthals had become extinct, as the Homo sapiens’ abilities outstripped them in almost every area, eventually making humans the planet’s dominant species. A major tenet of quantum theory is the idea that any time an event with multiple potential outcomes occurs, each of these outcomes, in fact, does occur, only in separate universes that split off from one another. If this is true, then it stands to reason that there is a reality in which Neanderthals, rather than Homo sapiens gained consciousness. This is the concept around which Sawyer crafted Hominids, imagining what modern day Earth would look like if Neanderthals evolved instead of humans. Based on factual information gleaned by scientists about Neanderthal culture and their biological makeup, Sawyer creates a Neanderthal society that is quite different from human society, taking into account the divergent physiology (larger brains, reduced vocal range due to head shape) and social patterns that may have potentially developed over the course of forty thousand years.
W Themes Evolution is the major theme of Hominids, and one of the primary concerns of the book is exploring the current state of mankind. Additionally, Sawyer dwells on the reasons our society evolved in the manner it did through the use of the Neanderthal universe conceit. Ponter’s reality stands as a contrast to modern-day Earth and provides a means through which Sawyer confronts his human characters and the reader with the idea that our
550 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Hominids
MAJOR CHARACTERS LOUISE BENOIT is a beautiful, confident female postdoctoral student of physics, who initially rescues Ponter from drowning and then continues to help him over the course of the novel. PONTER BODNER is a Neanderthal scientist from a parallel Earth who is accidentally sent to our universe while conducting one of his experiments, thus making the people of these two realities aware of each other for the first time. DAKLAR BOLBAY is Ponter’s female mate and Adikor’s primary accuser following Ponter’s disappearance. HAK is a sophisticated computer implant in Ponter’s wrist who communicates with him throughout, helping Ponter figure out the English language, as well as providing other crucial tools. ADIKOR HULD is Ponter’s male life-partner and scientific partner. When Ponter disappears, Adikor is the key suspect in the murder trial. JASMEL KET is Ponter’s eldest daughter, whom Adikor entreats to speak on his behalf. LURT is Adikor’s female mate. RUBEN MONTEGO is a physician who helps Ponter, along with Louise and Mary. Hominids is based on an alternate universe in which Neanderthals, such as the one depicted here, became the dominant species instead of homo sapiens. Marcio Jose Bastos Silva/Shutterstock.com
core philosophies and beliefs may actually be either subjective or influenced by our biological makeup. Sawyer frequently satirizes today’s world by demonstrating Ponter’s perplexed reactions to human behavior. Other times, Sawyer touches on more controversial concepts, such as the idea that every Neanderthal has both a female and a male mate, or the revelation that Neanderthals have no concept of religion. When Mary explains Heaven and Hell to Ponter, he responds, “In other words . . . people of your kind behave properly only because they are threatened if they do not” (265). In fact, the idea of retribution does not dissuade people from committing crime. One of the central ironies of the novel is that the most primitive action of the book, Mary’s rape, is committed by a human. In contrast, Neanderthals have eliminated most violent crimes. As a counterbalance to the otherwise enlightened paradise of the Neanderthal, their method of maintaining order has been to digitally record every citizen at all times. They respond to all crime by sterilizing the perpetrator and his/her immediate family in order to keep them from corrupting the genetic pool.
MARY VAUGHAN, a female genetics expert, who is attacked and raped at the start. As the book progresses, she forms a friendship with Ponter that eventually develops into potential romance.
W Style Hominids is a science fiction novel that belongs to a subgenre often referred to as “anthropological sci-fi.” As such it centers on an examination of a fictional culture that is meticulously crafted by the author, holding up to close scrutiny about the logic of the society it portrays. Beliefs, customs, hierarchy, and family structure are all outlined, and Sawyer describes the scientific aspects of the work in often minute detail. This gives Hominids an edge of “hard sci-fi,” a brand of science-fiction that emphasizes accuracy about the science behind the fiction, even as the bulk of the work is more concerned with “soft sci-fi” topics, such as sociology, anthropology, and psychology. The novel is related in the form of two parallel narratives, mirroring the two realities of the worlds that make up Hominids: one narrative focuses on the fish-outof-water tale of Ponter as he acclimates to the human world, while the other relates a thriller/courtroom drama about Ponter’s male mate, Adikor, as he attempts to clear himself of the charge that he is Ponter’s supposed
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
551
Hominids
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Known as one of Canada’s premiere science fiction authors, Robert J. Sawyer has written novels including Hominids, Humans, and Hybrids (collectively known as The Neanderthal Parallax), Calculating God, and Flashforward. The latter was adapted into a television series, FlashForward, for ABC television network. Sawyer’s works have a number of major themes in common. Many of them focus on the idea of what would happen if modern-day people were confronted by the discovery of a new scientific truth. In many of Sawyer’s stories, the stimulus of encountering an extraordinary event shocks his characters to their core, causing them to reevaluate their philosophy and beliefs. The clash between science and theology is another major thematic thread in Sawyer’s fiction. Despite his critique and satirization of contemporary society, much of Sawyer’s writing is optimistic in its outlook about humankind’s potential and future. Sawyer has won numerous literary awards for his work, including the Hugo award and the Nebula award.
murderer. The chapters alternate between the Neanderthal world and the human world. Sawyer also makes liberal use of satire. A great deal of comedy emerges from the disconnect between how Ponter and his personal computer, Hak, interpret a situation versus the human interpretation. Ponter’s confusion over human cultural idioms is another source of humor in the novel. Satire also appears in the brief bold-faced paragraphs that open many of the chapters— this text includes pieces of fictional news stories reporting on Ponter’s appearance and even a David Lettermanesque “Top Ten” list. In addition to being humorous, these snippets of pop culture and media depictions of major news events further enhance the reality of the novel. The excerpts also provide an ironic commentary on the potential coverage that contemporary news outlets would grant such earth-shattering news, were such an event to actually occur.
W Critical Reception
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Johnson, Roberta. “Sawyer, Robert J. Hominids.” Booklist 98 (1 June 2002): 1698. Print. General OneFile. Web. 31 July 2010. Sawyer, Robert J. “Committing Trilogy: The Origins of ‘The Neanderthal Parallax.’” SFWriter.com. Web. 2 Aug. 2010. Sawyer, Robert J. Hominids. New York: Tor, 2002. Print. Teehan, John. “Robert Sawyer’s Hominids: It’s Not Your Father’s Cavemen Story.” Rev. of Hominids, by Robert J. Sawyer. Strange Horizons 22 July 2002. Web. 2 Aug. 2010. Wagner, Thomas M. “Hominids.” Rev. of Hominids, by Robert J. Sawyer. SFReviews.Net 2003. Web. 2 Aug. 2010. Additional Resources
Hominids was praised by critics for its convincing portrayal of the Neanderthal world and its intelligent and engaging presentation of philosophical discussions. The book went on to receive the prestigious Hugo, among a number of other high-profile awards. John Teehan, of the popular sci-fi site, Strange Horizons, applauded Sawyer for his “careful use of archaeology and sociology . . . to create a reasonably postulated world of modern Neanderthals not only to show us a world that might have been, but also to allow us to examine ourselves through the eyes of an alien
552
culture.” While Teehan deemed much of the science in the novel of “dubious quality,” he acknowledged that this is true of most science fiction, whose primary purpose is to act as the conduit by which an author can explore his ideas. Roberta Johnson, in Booklist, was appreciative of Sawyer’s protagonist, calling Ponter “a most winning creation . . . thoughtful, brave, and charming. . . . The smaller-scale, peaceful, environmentally savvy world of Ponter’s people is equally well realized, though Sawyer loses a little steam trying to pin humanity’s woes on organized religion.” Primarily well received, Hominids was nonetheless faulted by some reviewers for its underdeveloped secondary characters. Some, such as Thomas M. Wagner, at SciFiReviews.net, dismissed the novel as a “work of pop-literary shock and awe,” calling Sawyer a writer of “eminently readable yet stylistically trashy page-turners.” Wagner went on to call Sawyer’s philosophical agenda “stale at best and condescending and offensive at worst, and some of its most dramatic moments border on unintentional comedy.” Most critics had a more balanced view of the book, however, overlooking its shortcomings for its fascinating exploration of sociology, anthropology, and theology.
Criticism and Reviews
DuMond, Lisa. “Hominids.” Rev. of Hominids, by Robert J. Sawyer. SF Site 2002. Web. 1 Aug. 2010. This review analyzes how Sawyer uses a science fiction conceit to discuss deeper issues of culture and biology. Forde, Pat. “An Analysis of Hominids.” SFWriter.com 2003. Web. 2 Aug. 2010. An in-depth literary analysis of Hominids, arguing for the sophistication of Sawyer’s writing, from plotting, structural, and thematic perspectives. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Hominids
Rev. of Hominids, by Robert J. Sawyer. Globe and Mail [Toronto] 8 June 2002. Print. InfoTrac Custom Newspapers. Web. 31 July 2010. Both a review of Hominids and a discussion about Sawyer’s writing, on the whole, and why he has become such a popular author. Rev. of Hominids, by Robert J. Sawyer. Publishers Weekly 249.24 (17 June 2002): 48. Print. This review of Hominids praises the novel for the sophistication of its anthropological and philosophical elements. Snider, John C. “Book Review: Hominids by Robert J. Sawyer.” Rev. of Hominids, by Robert J. Sawyer. SciFiDimensions 2002. Web. 1 Aug. 2010. A review that examines how Sawyer uses his Neanderthals as a conceit to examine human nature. Gale Resources
“Sawyer, Robert J(ames) 1960-.” Contemporary Authors. Ed. Scot Peacock. Vol. 212. Detroit: Gale, 2004. 371-91. Print. Gale Virtual Reference Library. Web. 1 Aug. 2010. Open Web Sources
Robert J. Sawyer has a comprehensive author site, including in-depth analyses of each of his books, study guides, interview, comprehensive bibliographies for further reading on their subjects, and more at http:// www.sfwriter.com/ Robert J. Sawyer was interviewed by the Internet radio show, Hour 25, the full episode of which can be heard at Mike Hodel’s Hour 25 Web site. Web. 1 Aug. 2010. http://www.hour25online.com/Hour25_ Previous_Shows_2002-06.html#robert-sawyer _2002-06-21
For Further Reading
Boyd, Neil. The Beast Within: Why Men Are Violent. Vancouver: Greystone Books (Douglas and McIntyre), 2000. Print. An evolutionary and psychological study of what makes men prone to violence. LeGuin, Ursula K. The Left Hand of Darkness. New York: Ace, 1969. Print. This acclaimed book is considered a classic of anthropological science fiction, focusing on a planet of people who have either no gender or both. It concerns a society that, like the Neanderthal one, defies normal gender stereotypes. Sawyer, Robert J. Calculating God. New York: Tor, 2009. Print. This controversial book explores many themes similar to those in The Neanderthal Parallax, specifically religion and man’s relationship with a potentially mythical God. ———. Humans. New York: Tor, 2003. Print. The second volume in The Neanderthal Parallax, and the first sequel to Hominids, this installment contains more social satire than the first, highlighting Mary’s trip to Ponter’s universe. ———. Hybrids. New York: Tor, 2003. Print. The conclusion to the trilogy, in which Mary and Potner’s love culminates in their decision to create the first Human-Neanderthal hybrid child. Shreeve, James. The Neanderthal Enigma: Solving the Mystery of Modern Human Origins. New York: William Morrow, 1995. Print. An exploration of Neanderthals and of what might have led modern man to develop in the manner currently espoused by scientists.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Robert Berg
553
The Human Stain By Philip Roth
W Introduction Set against the heightened political tensions that defined American public life during the late 1990s, The Human Stain (2000) by Philip Roth tells the story of a disgraced college professor who has harbored a deep personal secret through his fifty-year career. Although the narrative initially concerns a relatively small scandal involving an inopportune classroom remark, it eventually broadens in scope to address such themes as sexual politics, blackmail, and the problem of racial identity in the United States. The professor, Coleman Silk, is a charismatic but troubled classics scholar who has concealed his African American origins in order to live his life “not black, not even white—just on his own and free.” In its portrait of Coleman, the novel explores the ways in which society often shapes, sometimes brutally, the individual’s quest for self-realization. One of Philip Roth’s most acclaimed and controversial novels, The Human Stain received both the 2001 PEN/Faulkner Award for Fiction and the 2000 National Jewish Book Fiction Award.
W Literary and Historical Context
The Human Stain is the third novel in what Roth has described as his “American trilogy” (qtd. in McGrath), a series that began with American Pastoral (1997) followed by I Married a Communist (1998). Like its predecessors, The Human Stain chronicles life in the United States during a period of intense social, political, and cultural conflict. The novel makes repeated references to the 1998 Monica Lewinsky scandal involving U.S.president Bill Clinton, who was impeached for perjury after lying about his relationship with Lewinsky, a White House intern. The scandal revealed how deeply divided the country was on such issues as sexuality, privacy, and the moral lives of
public figures. The highly publicized political battles of the era create a fitting backdrop for Coleman Silk’s own personal drama, as a series of increasingly damaging revelations threatens to overshadow his years of dedicated service to Athena College. Within the context of academic life in the 1990s, Coleman’s predicament illustrates the extremely narrow path that many scholars had to follow in order to abide by the standards of political correctness. In this respect, Roth’s chronicle of the persecution of Coleman as a consequence of a ruthless academic code and a society that preys on the slightest indiscretions encapsulates the zeitgeist of the time in which the novel is set.
W Themes Themes of identity and race lie at the core of The Human Stain and serve as the point of departure for Roth’s explorations into Coleman Silk’s character. In depicting Coleman’s efforts to redefine himself, Roth exposes the inherent instability of human identity in a manner that echoes F. Scott Fitzgerald’s portrait of the quintessential self-made man in the novel The Great Gatsby (a fact noted by both Michiko Kakutani, and Lorrie Moore). Ironically, Coleman’s undoing is a direct result of his subterfuge. When Coleman refers to a pair of students who are perpetually absent from his class as “spooks,” he uses the term in a very specific sense, in which “spook” means “spy” or “secret agent.” One of his students, however, assumes that “spook” is intended as a derogatory term for an African American. Coleman’s unfortunate word choice takes on racial overtones precisely because people believe that he is white. The conflict between the individual and society is another of Roth’s central concerns in The Human Stain. Coleman’s decision to eschew his past in the pursuit of what Igor Webb calls “radical autonomy” represents a basic human resistance to being stereotyped or labeled. Although he has embraced this freedom throughout his adult life and shaped his character on his own terms, Coleman cannot escape the broader social
554 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Human Stain
MAJOR CHARACTERS FAUNIA FARLEY is a younger woman who becomes Coleman Silk’s lover soon after the death of his wife, Iris. An illiterate, emotionally battered woman who works as a janitor at Athena College, Faunia serves as a symbol of Coleman’s fall from grace and of his fierce desire to achieve liberation from social norms. LESTER FARLEY, the husband of Faunia, is a troubled Vietnam veteran whose hostile, often threatening, behavior establishes the undercurrent of menace that drives the plot to its climax. After he orchestrates the fatal car crash that kills Coleman and Faunia, Lester becomes Zuckerman’s chief antagonist.
Picture of Philip Roth, author of The Human Stain.. David Montgomery/Getty Images
and cultural forces that play such powerful roles in defining who we are. In this sense, Coleman’s ruse, though emblematic of his audacious and imaginative personality, is also extremely fragile.
W Style Roth’s characteristic humor and his insightful rendering of the complexities of human psychology are on full display in The Human Stain. Broad in scope, the novel interweaves dialogue, flashbacks, and interior monologue with authorial meditations on contemporary society, in particular the various unsavory details surrounding the Clinton-Lewinsky scandal. Although Nathan Zuckerman is the narrator of the work, his point of view remains unobtrusive for long passages of the novel, allowing the story of Coleman’s decline to unfold as a straightforward narrative. This technique is typical of a traditional realistic novel in many respects, but The Human Stain also contains certain distinct postmodern elements, particularly in its portrayal of Zuckerman—the secluded novelist and Roth alter ego, who has been a character in a number of the author’s best-known works. Early in the novel, Coleman Silk approaches Zuckerman, who is his neighbor, to propose that he write Coleman’s life story for him. Although Coleman is driven by the wish to exonerate himself in the aftermath of the scandal, Zuckerman quickly asserts control over the narrative, transforming the material of Coleman’s life into a work of fiction. As Zuckerman struggles to create order in the wake of Coleman Silk’s
DELPHINE ROUX, a young faculty member in Athena’s English department, is Coleman’s conniving, ruthless nemesis. She blackmails Coleman Silk after she learns the secret truth about his past. A scholar of contemporary literary theory, Roux serves as a vehicle for much of the novel’s satire and is the target of many of Roth’s scathing depictions of hypocrisy and pretense within academic circles during the period. COLEMAN SILK, the novel’s main protagonist, is a retired classics scholar and former dean of Athena College, a small liberal arts institution in western Massachusetts. In his early seventies, Coleman struggles to rehabilitate his life and reputation after an innocuous, offhand remark is misinterpreted as racist by one of his students. As the plot unfolds, however, Roth reveals that Coleman is embattled with far larger personal issues over which he ultimately is powerless to assert control. NATHAN ZUCKERMAN, a famous novelist and Coleman’s neighbor, plays the role of both observer and chronicler of the novel’s central drama. Although Zuckerman’s character is largely in the background for much of the novel’s action, his perspective on Coleman’s tragic fate shapes the work’s style and plot.
personal destruction, Roth raises compelling questions about the nature of fictional representation and the thin line that separates authenticity and fabrication. In this way, Roth’s overarching narrative strategy mirrors his protagonist’s own efforts to live a “fictionalized” existence. Roth blurs the line between reality and fiction even further in the work’s closing pages, which describe Zuckerman’s final, uneasy encounter with the murderous Lester Farley. By making it clear that Farley has no intention of harming Zuckerman and that Farley has requested a copy of the “book” that Zuckerman has written, Roth as author crosses the boundary between the fiction he has his characters create and the reality of his book and its readers.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
555
The Human Stain BIBLIOGRAPHY
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Philip Roth was born on March 19, 1933, in Newark, New Jersey. He is among the most influential American novelists from the post-World War II era. Roth has dedicated his career to exploring diverse aspects of modern Jewish American identity. He first achieved acclaim in 1959, with the publication of his debut short story collection, Goodbye, Columbus. The work earned Roth the National Book Award for fiction, and immediately established him as one of the most promising young writers in the United States. In 1969 Roth became a literary celebrity, while sparking considerable controversy, with the publication of his best-selling, sexually charged comic novel Portnoy’s Complaint. A prolific talent, Roth has published a number of major works, among them Zuckerman Unbound (1981), Operation Shylock (1993), and American Pastoral (1997), for which he earned a Pulitzer Prize. Roth has continued to publish steadily into the twenty-first century. Later novels include The Plot against America (2004), Exit Ghost (2007), and Nemesis (2010).
Gates, David. “Truth and Consequences.” Rev. of The Human Stain, by Philip Roth. Newsweek 15 May 2000: 70. Print. Hynes, James. “Professor of Passion.” Rev. of The Human Stain, by Philip Roth. Washington Post 7 May 2000: 3. Print. Kakutani, Michiko. “Confronting the Failures of a Professor Who Passes.” Rev. of The Human Stain, by Philip Roth. New York Times 2 May 2000: 1. Print. McGrath, Charles. “Zuckerman’s Alter Brain.” New York Times 7 May 2000: 8. Print. Moore, Lorrie. “The Wrath of Athena.” Rev. of The Human Stain, by Philip Roth. New York Times 7 May 2000: 7. Print. Roth, Philip. The Human Stain. Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 2000. Print. Webb, Igor. “Born Again.” Rev. of The Human Stain, by Philip Roth. Partisan Review 67.4 (2000): 648-52. Print. Additional Resources
W Critical Reception
Criticism and Reviews
The Human Stain received widespread praise upon its publication in 2000. New York Times reviewer Michiko Kakutani calls the novel a “large and stirring book,” praising Roth for depicting the novel’s historical era with “uncommon insight and perception.” She describes Roth’s portrait of the conflicted Coleman Silk as “beautifully nuanced” and “by turns unnerving, hilarious and sad.” Reviewing the book for the New York Times, novelist Lorrie Moore calls The Human Stain “astonishing, uneven, and often very beautiful,” while David Gates in Newsweek hails the “ventriloquizing” talent with which Roth portrays his various characters, attributing his mastery of a wide range of different personalities to his “overflow of passion about realworld outrages.” At the same time, many of the book’s fiercest admirers have found fault with some of Roth’s character studies, notably his depiction of Lester Farley, whom Moore describes as constructed “from every available cliché of the Vietnam vet.” Although some commentators have criticized the novel’s prose style—James Hynes of the Washington Post, for instance, describes it as “graceless”—most acknowledge that Roth approaches his subject matter with a fierce, passionate intelligence. Hynes himself expresses a strong appreciation for Roth’s willingness to tackle ambitious themes in the novel and asserts that The Human Stain is far more memorable than other “more carefully crafted” contemporary novels.
556
Works Cited
Abbott, Philip. “‘Bryan, Bryan, Bryan, Bryan’: Democratic Theory, Populism, and Philip Roth’s ‘American Trilogy.’” Canadian Review of American Studies 37.3 (2007): 431-52. Print. Analyzes how the notion of populism, both as a form of collective political expression and as a destabilizing social force, plays a central thematic role in Roth’s novel. Boddy, Kasia. “Philip Roth’s Great Books: A Reading of The Human Stain.” Cambridge Quarterly 39.1 (2010): 39-60. Print. Investigates the ways in which Roth borrows from classical literary forms, notably the epic and tragedy, in The Human Stain. Glaser, Jennifer. “The Jew in the Canon: Reading Race and Literary History in Philip Roth’s The Human Stain.” PMLA: Publications of the Modern Language Association of America 123.5 (2008): 1465+. Print. Explores the multifaceted ways in which Roth’s novel confronts, engages with, and ultimately participates in multicultural modes of literary discourse. Kaplan, Brett Ashley. “Reading Race and the Conundrums of Reconciliation in Philip Roth’s The Human Stain.” Turning Up the Flame: Philip Roth’s Later Novels. Ed. Jay L. Halio and Ben Siegel. Newark: U of Delaware P, 2005. 172-93. Print. Examines the fundamental tensions between individual and collective identity at play in the novel and interprets the work within the context of identity and racial politics in the United States in late 1990s. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Human Stain
Parrish, Timothy L. “Ralph Ellison: The Invisible Man in Philip Roth’s The Human Stain.” Contemporary Literature 45.3 (2004): 421-59. Print. Considers questions of identity and race in The Human Stain, comparing the work’s central themes to those elucidated by Ralph Ellison in his landmark novel Invisible Man (1952). Royal, Derek Parker. “Plotting the Frames of Subjectivity: Identity, Death, and Narrative in Philip Roth’s The Human Stain.” Contemporary Literature 47.1 (2006): 114-40. Print. Discusses the ways in which the personality of the narrator, Nathan Zuckerman, insinuates itself into the novel’s portrayal of Coleman Silk. Gale Resources
Kremer, S. Lillian. “Philip Roth.” American Novelists since World War II, Fifth Series. Ed. James R. Giles and Wanda H. Giles. Detroit: Gale Research, 1996. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 173. Literature Resource Center. Web. 5 Oct. 2010. “Philip Roth.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2010 Web. 5 Oct. 2010. “Philip Roth.” Contemporary Literary Criticism. Ed. Jeffrey W. Hunter. Vol. 201. Detroit: Gale, 2005. Contemporary Literary Criticism Select. Web. 5 Oct. 2010. Pinsker, Sanford. “Philip (Milton) Roth.” TwentiethCentury American-Jewish Fiction Writers. Ed. Daniel Walden. Detroit: Gale Research, 1984. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 28 Literature Resource Center. Web. 5 Oct. 2010. Open Web Sources
The Facebook page for The Human Stain provides an online forum where fans of the book can discuss some of the work’s central themes, the circumstances under which Roth wrote the novel, and other issues related to the work. http://www.facebook.com/pages/ The-Human-Stain/105564032810064 The Human Stain Reading Group Guide on the Knopf Doubleday Web site provides a detailed synopsis of the book and provides a series of thought-provoking discussion questions concerning the novel. http:// reading-group-center.knopfdoubleday.com/2010/ 01/08/the-human-stain-guide/
and provides access to a range of scholarly discussions and resources related to the author’s career. http:// rothsociety.org/ For Further Reading
Broyard, Bliss. One Drop: My Father’s Hidden Life—A Story of Race and Family Secrets. New York: Little Brown, 2007. Print. This personal memoir reveals the story of Anatole Broyard, a famed literary critic and author who concealed his African American origins from the public until his death in 1990. Coetzee, J. M. Disgrace. New York: Viking, 1999. Print. A searing portrait of a failed academic who engages in a vindictive love affair with one of his students. Fitzgerald, F. Scott. The Great Gatsby. New York: Scribner’s, 1925. Print. Landmark American novel tells the story of Jay Gatsby, a man born into humble origins who reinvents himself in order to earn money, prestige, and the love of a married woman. Mamet, David. Oleanna. New York: Pantheon Books, 1992. Print. A play that explores themes of sexual, professional, and political power in contemporary American academia. Roth, Philip. American Pastoral. Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1997. Print. The first novel in Roth’s American trilogy, American Pastoral examines the tensions between family and political commitment in the turbulent 1960s. ———. I Married a Communist. Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1998. Print. The second installment in Roth’s American trilogy, I Married a Communist reflects on political and ethnic persecution within Newark’s Jewish community during the McCarthy era. Adaptations
The Human Stain. Dir. Robert Benton. Perf. Anthony Hopkins, Nicole Kidman, Ed Harris, Gary Sinise. Miramax Films, 2003. Film. This 2003 adaptation received mixed reviews, with many critics praising the powerful performances of Hopkins and Kidman while asserting that the actors were miscast in their roles. Stephen Meyer
The Philip Roth Society engages in literary panels and forums dedicated to examining Roth’s body of work
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
557
The Hummingbird’s Daughter By Luis Alberto Urrea
W Introduction The Hummingbird’s Daughter tells the story of Teresita Urrea, a mixed-blood Mexican woman whose rise to fame as a medicine woman and miracle worker becomes intertwined with a civil war in late nineteenth-century Mexico. The child of a rich, white ranch owner and a peasant washerwoman, Teresita grows up in Sinaloa and Sonora, in northwest Mexico. She is raised by her abusive aunt until a kindly medicine woman, Huila, takes her under her wing and teaches her the art of healing. Living in an impoverished world made worse by the dictatorship of Porfirio Díaz, Teresita dreams of a better life, and eventually her healing powers enable such dreams to come to fruition. After a miraculous return from death, she earns the status of a saint, and her miracles, as well as her denunciation of government tyranny, inspire an uprising. Luis Alberto Urrea’s tale combines historical investigation with a lyricism inspired by Mexican folk legend to explore the harsh realities of poverty, war, and prejudice.
W Literary and Historical Context
The Hummingbird’s Daughter is based loosely on accounts of the real Teresa (or “Teresita”) Urrea, the daughter of a fourteen-year-old peasant mother and Don Tomás Urrea, a prosperous rancher. Initially inspired by the discovery that Teresita was a distant relation of his, Luis Alberto Urrea focused his investigation on the woman’s legendary status as a saint in 1880s Mexico, during the beginning of Porfirio Díaz’s regime. According to folklore, the sixteen-year-old Teresita was raped and pronounced dead, only to revive during her wake. Thousands of pilgrims heard rumors about this apparent miracle and traveled to Sonora to see Teresita, while the Catholic Church officially declared her a heretic.
Although this historical background seems to defy reality, Urrea consciously exploits the legendary potential of Teresita’s life to redefine reality through a literary technique known as “magical realism.” Often associated with films that deliberately manipulate the perception of images through camera tricks, magical realism, as Jeffrey Wechsler explains, provides a way of reordering reality to make it strange. It is a technique in which the ordinary events of life, such as birth and death, are invested with poetic imagery and often presented almost as fairy tales or legends. Events described are perhaps exaggerated but remain possible within the scope of human knowledge. In Urrea’s novel, Teresita somehow has the ability to make her hands become hot in order to administer healing to her patients. When questioned about it, she shrugs and says matter-of-factly, “My hands are always hot.” Here and throughout the novel, a supernatural oddity is accepted as the norm. By incorporating elements of legend and lore and infiltrating the mundane with the magical, Urrea magnifies the importance of miracles in hopeless times.
W Themes Although much of the action in the novel relates to the conflict between the rich and the poor, author Urrea also explores the ways in which human sympathy can transcend economic boundaries. The traditional class conflict of rich versus poor is underscored by the “haciendas,” the estates owned by rich, white investors and operated through the employment of the indigenous population. Tomás Urrea is the “patrón” of the estate featured in The Hummingbird’s Daughter, and early in the novel we are invited to consider the great contrast between his living conditions and those of Teresita. Whereas Teresita’s aunt’s house has a dirt floor, Tomás’s great house has shiny wood floors, as well as clean, white, gauzy curtains. Despite this apparent divide, Tomás’s sympathy for those who work on his estates, and for the daughter who is mistreated by her aunt, allows class
558 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Hummingbird’s Daughter
MAJOR CHARACTERS CAYETANA CHAVEZ is Teresita’s mother, a peasant washerwoman known by most in the village as “the hummingbird” for her slight figure. Cayetana is only fourteen when she gives birth to her daughter. To avoid the inevitable hardship of raising the child, she leaves Teresita with her sister and escapes Mexico. HUILA is the village’s midwife and visionary. She helps deliver Teresita and later teaches her medicinal skills. The survivor of a previous massacre, Huila combines her great knowledge of healing with a defiant resistance to both “Yoris” (white masters) such as Tomás and the government police who terrorize the people.
The Hummingbird’s Daughter follows the life of Teresita Urrea, a Mexican medicine woman who performs miracles during a civil war in her country. Elena Ray/Shutterstock.com
boundaries to be crossed. This crossover is most apparent when the young Teresita sneaks into the main house and, instead of being banished, is welcomed and given refreshment by Tomás. Another conventional notion that Urrea reevaluates is sainthood. Living in the impoverished conditions of her aunt’s abode, Teresita is malnourished, filthy, and liceridden—hardly the picture of the typical saint. Yet thousands flock to her village and seek her out, ignoring the Catholic Church’s charge of heresy. As critic Stacey D’Erasmo argues, Teresita “is a saint as envisioned not in the marble reaches of the Vatican but in the populist pueblos of liberation theology.” Teresita’s practical acceptance of her gifts, combined with her sympathy toward people, places her in stark contrast to the Christian religious authorities who condemn this earthy saint and express little sympathy for the plight of the oppressed.
W Style Urrea’s investment in magical realism, which enables a reappraisal of miracles and sainthood, produces a writing style in which everyday objects and events are elevated by lyrical description. A task as habitual as preparing and drinking coffee in the morning is rendered so poetically that the ritual becomes somehow larger, as though “a tidal wave of coffee [has] rushed west across the land, rising and falling from kitchen to fire ring to cave to ramada.” In this instance, the communal nature of a ritual is reinforced through the use of metaphor. Coffee, as well as tamarind, cheese, tobacco, and rum, are described in
TÍA is the sister of Cayetana. She is forced to look after Teresita. Unmarried, with two children of her own, Tía is resentful of her responsibilities and takes out her frustrations on Teresita, viciously abusing her and depriving her of proper nourishment. TERESITA URREA is the daughter of Cayetana and Tomás. She is compelled to live with her abusive aunt until she is befriended by Huila. Intrigued with the world around her, Teresita soon discovers that she is different from other children, possessing the blond hair of her white father and special gifts that enable her to heal and, according to others, perform miracles. TOMÁS URREA is a white rancher, known by the Sinaloans as a “Yori,” or white master, and is also identified as the “patrón.” The son of a wealthy patrón himself, Tomás nevertheless learns when he is young to respect the peasantry and be wary of the Mexican government and its bullying police force.
ways that reinforce their importance to a community unused to such luxuries. Urrea’s poetic style is most apparent when it is used to describe the mundane tasks of cleaning and cooking or violent events such as the slaughter of Mexican peasants. The dreary tasks that tie men and women to the earth are given a special significance, and the very atmosphere is heightened with anticipation of food preparation and consumption. Urrea also employs his lyrical prose to articulate the horrors that have been downplayed by official history. In other cases, straight narration is often interrupted by observations inspired by folk wisdom or legends, reaffirming the importance of the imagination in the creation of truth. Throughout the narrative, Urrea’s lyricism is punctuated by his economical use of dialogue. Using short, rapid exchanges, he establishes the temperaments of his characters and demonstrates his humorous insight into the motives that drive humans.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
559
The Hummingbird’s Daughter
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Luis Alberto Urrea was born in Tijuana, Mexico, to an American mother and a Mexican father. He was educated at the University of California, San Diego, and did graduate work at the University of Colorado, Boulder, before turning to writing. Urrea has won awards for his fiction, poetry, and essays. The Devil’s Highway (2004) won the Lannan Literary Award and was a finalist for the Pulitzer Prize and the Pacific Rim Kiriyama Prize. In much of his work, Urrea uses his mixed heritage as the impetus for explorations of American and Mexican relations and the larger themes of love, war, and redemption. Urrea is also skilled at weaving together historical and fictional elements, and his use of magical realism allows him to offer poetic insights into everyday human experience.
W Critical Reception Critics commenting on The Hummingbird’s Daughter have been most impressed by the author’s blend of fact and fantasy and his lyrical response to a violent period of Mexican history. The product of some twenty years of research, the novel affirmed Urrea’s prominence as a magical realist writer and an important commentator on Mexican politics and culture. Recognizing the author’s skillful blend of narrative craft and political commentary, a Publishers Weekly reviewer declares that “Urrea effortlessly links Teresita’s supernatural calling to the turmoil of the times, concealing substantial intellectual content behind effervescent storytelling and considerable humor.” Other critics have noted the author’s attention to both the large and the seemingly insignificant details of life, as well as his attunement to both the physical and the metaphysical realms of human experience. A few commentators have been critical of Urrea’s blend of history and fiction. Library Journal’s Lawrence Olszewski contends that Urrea’s tale is more a “novelized biography than a work of fiction” and that “more research seems to have crept in than creativity.” Further, Olszewski charges that the depiction of the rebellion and miracles lack conviction. Taking almost the opposite view, Stacey D’Erasmo in the New York Times Book Review describes the novel as having “the woodcut feeling of a bedtime story, or of family legends that have been told so many times they’ve gone smooth, like the lettering on old gravestones.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
D’Erasmo, Stacey. “A Saint with Grit.” New York Times Book Review 3 July 2005: 9(L) Print.
560
Rev. of The Hummingbird’s Daughter, by Luis Alberto Urrea. Publishers Weekly 18 Apr. 2005: 44. Book Review Index Plus. Web. 1 Aug. 2010. Olszewski, Lawrence. Rev. of The Hummingbird’s Daughter, by Luis Alberto Urrea. Library Journal 15 May 2005: 109. Book Review Index Plus. Web. 1 Aug. 2010. Urrea, Luis Alberto. The Hummingbird’s Daughter. New York: Little, Brown, 2005. Print. Wechsler, Jeffrey. “Magic Realism: Defining the Indefinite.” Art Journal 45.4 (1985): 293-98. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Cheuse, Alan. Rev. of The Hummingbird’s Daughter, by Luis Alberto Urrea. World Literature Today July-Aug. 2006: 35. Book Review Index Plus. Web. 1 Aug. 2010. In his review, Cheuse considers the theme of border crossing in Urrea’s novel and praises the color, depth, and breadth of the work. Hiltbrand, David. “Mystical Mexican Epic Tells Story of Miracle-Working Girl.” Philadelphia Inquirer 1 June 2005: n. pag. Book Review Index Plus. Web. 1 Aug. 2010. In his positive review, Hiltbrand praises Urrea’s lyrical prose, noting that it gives vibrancy to both the spirit world and the animal world. Rev. of The Hummingbird’s Daughter, by Luis Alberto Urrea. Kirkus Reviews 15 Apr. 2005: 450. Book Review Index Plus. Web. 1 Aug. 2010. In this review, an anonymous critic offers an informative summary of Urrea’s novel. Martinez, Elizabeth Coonrod. “Remembering the Borderlands’ Forgotten.” Americas Sept.-Oct. 2006: 60. Book Review Index Plus. Web. 1 Aug. 2010. Martinez considers how the frequent descriptions of the food consumed by the characters in Urrea’s novel serve to reinforce class differences. Nava, Alex. “Teresa Urrea: Mexican Mystic, Healer, and Apocalyptic Revolutionary.” Journal of the American Academy of Religion 73.2 (2005): 497519. Print. Nava explores the apocalyptic and mystical elements of the Teresita Urrea character, underscoring the ways in which her spiritual ministry challenged and condemned Porfirio Díaz’s oppressive dictatorship. Gale Resources
González-T., César A. “Luis Alberto Urrea (20 August 1955-).” Chicano Writers, Third Series. Ed. Francisco A. Lomeli and Carl R. Shirley. Detroit: Gale, 1999. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 209. Dictionary of Literary Biography Complete Online. Web. 1 Aug. 2010. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Hummingbird’s Daughter Open Web Sources
The Web site of Powell’s Books features an interview with Urrea by Jill Owens. The discussion focuses on The Hummingbird’s Daughter as well as his more recent work, Into the Beautiful North (2009). http://www. powells.com/authors/luisalbertourrea.html For Further Reading
1580-1750. Austin: U of Texas P, 2000. Print. Sampson and Tudela use extensive archival material, as well as maps, portraits, and religious art, to explore the writings and ministry of female religious figures up to the mid-eighteenth century. This study provides a valuable context for the later religious and political tensions dramatized in Urrea’s novel.
Franco, Jean. Plotting Women: Gender and Representation in Mexico. New York: Columbia UP, 1989. Print. Focusing largely on letters and true accounts, Franco explores the position of women in Mexico. Her goal is to promote a feminist understanding of Mexican culture.
Urrea, Luis Alberto. Across the Wire: Life and Hard Times on the Mexican Border. New York: Anchor, 1993. Print. In this earlier nonfiction work, Urrea offers a captivating examination of life in Mexico. His portrait is a sympathetic but honest account of the abject poverty that dominates so many living on the Mexican side of the U.S.-Mexico border.
Kaup, Monika. Rewriting North American Borders in Chicano and Chicana Narrative. New York: Peter Lang, 2001. Print. Kaup’s book considers the thematic use of the border in Chicano and Chicana literature. It is especially relevant to Urrea’s writings, which focus on the tensions surrounding the MexicoU.S. border.
Vanderwood, Paul. “Response to Revolt: The CounterGuerrilla Strategy of Porfirio Díaz.” Hispanic American Historical Review 56.4 (1976): 551-79. Print. Vanderwood’s article on the Díaz regime covers the twentieth-century Mexican Revolution, which had its antecedents in the economic unrest and revolutionary responses depicted in Urrea’s novel.
Sampson, Elisa, and Vera Tudela. Colonial Angels: Narratives of Gender and Spirituality in Mexico
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Adam Lawrence
561
Hunger By Mohamed al-Bisatie
W Introduction Originally published in Arabic as Ju’ in 2007, Hunger (2008) is a short novel by Mohamed al–Bisatie that chronicles a rural Egyptian family’s daily struggles to obtain enough food to survive. The need for food drives the novel, but the story also depicts a father’s stifled dreams of education, a mother’s patience and her curiosity about her more affluent neighbors, and an eldest son’s resourcefulness. As a writer al-Bisatie is known for bringing wit and humor to even the direst of situations, and Hunger displays his characteristic style. Although the novel ultimately offers a stark portrait of the characters’ circumstances and a bleak outlook for their future, this dark tone is mediated by the family’s oftencheerful banter, the parents’ continued sexual desire, and the mother’s intense love for her children. The novel won alBisatie praise for his facility in humanizing serious topics such as poverty, hunger, and social inequality.
W Literary and Historical Context
Hunger is set in modern-day rural Egypt, a sector of the country that is home to a disproportionate number of the nation’s poorest residents. Although Egypt’s urban areas have modernized, rural areas have significantly lagged behind in infrastructure, sanitation, technology, and other advancements. In the novel Zaghloul and his family live in a one-room home made of brick and mud. They lack access to conveniences such as indoor plumbing and must constantly contend with fleas and lice. al-Bisatie belongs to the Generation of the Sixties, a group of progressive Egyptian writers named after the decade in which they first rose to prominence. Collectively, these writers were inspired by a desire for social justice and freedom. Most were mentored by Naguib Mahfouz, a Nobel Prize-winning author who helped
bring about a renaissance of Arabic literature. In an article for Al-Ahram Weekly Online, al–Bisatie reflects on Mahfouz’s influence on his development as a writer, describing him as “incredibly supportive” and a “subtle mentor.” al–Bisatie is also known as a member of influential Egyptian writers associated with the literary magazine Galiri 68 (Gallery 68), which focuses on the publication of works with a modernist aesthetic and a progressive political agenda. al-Bisatie’s interest in politics is reflected in Hunger, particularly in the scenes in which Zaghloul listens as a group of university students question the direction of their country. “Why,” they ask, “has our country, unlike other countries of the world, known long years of colonization—and the worst sorts of colonization: Turkish, French, English?” They discuss the Egyptian Revolution of 1952, in which military forces overthrew the king and established a republic. These reflections prompt one student to comment, “Just tell me a single country that has been ruled by the military for nearly sixty years.”
W Themes As its title suggests, hunger is the governing theme of alBisatie’s novel. On a literal level the plot is shaped by the characters’ various responses to their physical need for food. Zaghloul prefers not to work, and the family often lacks even bread to eat. Zaghloul’s wife, Sakeena, must often borrow bread from her neighbors—a burden that fills her with great shame, though she is always careful to pay them back. Even with borrowed bread, the family is almost always hungry. Their nights are miserable because “colic brought on by hunger keeps sleep away.” The few occasions when the family has more than bread to eat are treated with much fanfare. For example, when Sakeena is employed by a wealthy neighbor, her children are amazed at the meals she is able to provide for them, asking, “Will we be eating like this every day?” After Sakeena’s
562 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Hunger
MAJOR CHARACTERS HAGG HASHEM is a wealthy widower who has a big home near Zaghloul and his family. Sakeena is extraordinarily interested in the goings-on at his house, and her curiosity leads her indirectly to a job as a servant there. During her employment all of the members of her family are well fed. After Hashem dies, however, Sakeena’s family returns to dire poverty and hunger. RAGAB is the nine-year-old son of Sakeena and Zaghloul. HAGG ABDUL RAHEEM is a wealthy, overweight man who pays Zaghloul to help him get on and off his mule and get around. While Zaghloul is employed, he is able to provide his family with good meals, but when Raheem dies, the family’s struggles for survival begin anew. SAKEENA is the wife of Zaghloul and the mother of their two sons. As a woman, she has very little power in the family and must watch her family suffer for lack of food. ZAGHLOUL is Sakeena’s husband. Although he routinely volunteers to help in the clearing of chairs after condolence gatherings, he does not like to keep a regular job, and his unemployment is a driving factor in his family’s perpetual hunger. Originally published in Arabic, the novel Hunger depicts an Egyptian family’s ordeals of not having enough food to eat. Galyna Andrushko/Shutterstock.com
employer dies and the family is plunged back into poverty, the family’s industrious elder son, Zahir, arranges a deal with a local baker, bringing home scraps of ruined bread until the kindly baker leaves town. Zahir also receives food from his friend Abdullah. This act of generosity ends, however, when Abdullah’s father, believing Zahir an unsuitable playmate for his educated son, threatens to break Zahir’s neck if he catches him near their home again. In addition to the physical hunger for food, the novel takes as its themes sexual hunger and the desire for knowledge and education. Zaghloul and Sakeena often engage in banter about the frequency and duration of their own lovemaking, and Zaghloul enjoys listening to a group of university students boast about their sexual exploits. Zaghloul’s attraction to the students also underscores his longing for knowledge and education, both of which are denied to him because of his poverty. In listening to the students, he finds that “what he did understand exercised his mind for a long time, and even what he did not understand he found himself attracted to.” When he attempts to question a visiting Muslim leader about religion, however, he is badly beaten and called an “infidel” and a “good-for-nothing.”
ZAHIR is the elder of Sakeena and Zaghloul’s sons. At just twelve years of age, he is forced to provide food for himself and his family by any means he can. He receives food from his more affluent friend and develops a friendship with a local baker who gives him the scraps of ruined bread.
W Style Reviewing one of al-Bisatie’s other novels for World Literature Today, Marcia Lynx Qualey characterizes the author as “a novelist associated with powerful, poetic prose and an obsession with village life in Egypt.” Denys Johnson-Davies, who would later translate Hunger, notes in Al-Ahram Weekly Online that al-Bisatie’s style is “characterised by a brevity and directness often lacking in other Arab writers” and that he makes “no attempt to either dramatise or romanticise the situations.” Likening the author’s style to that of a journalist, Johnson-Davies suggests that it stands out for its attention to “the richness of the spoken language” that “has become more refined with the years.” Hunger displays this characteristic style, alternating between descriptive passages and dialogue. Some of the most detailed passages in the novel describe food. In one such scene Sakeena and Zaghloul watch with interest as their wealthy neighbor loads his trucks with all manner of foods—such as pigeons, honey, quail, ducks, chickens, cheese, and cooking oil—to be delivered to his son and
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
563
Hunger
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Mohamed al-Bisatie was born on November 19, 1937, in ElGamalia in Egypt’s Shaqiya Province. al-Bisatie’s father was a teacher, and the young man was well educated, earning a bachelor’s degree from the University of Cairo in 1960. After completing his degree al-Bisatie took a job in the government auditor’s office in Cairo. He began to pursue his love of writing in his spare time, and his first short story, “Al-Kibar-wa-’lSighur” (“The Old and the Young”), was published in 1967. He continued to write stories and longer works of fiction and became associated with a group of young, progressive writers known as the Generation of the Sixties. His first novel, Al-Tajir wa-l-Naqqash (The Merchant and the Painter), was published in 1976. al-Bisatie remained at the government auditor’s office throughout his career, retiring from the agency in 1997. Several of his works have been translated into English by Denys Johnson-Davies. His texts have also been translated into Spanish, Italian, and French.
daughter in faraway cities. These descriptions underscore the privation experienced by Zaghloul and his family, who on many days consider themselves fortunate to have even bread to eat. This particular scene is interrupted by a sexually charged dialogue between Zaghloul and his wife, in which he explains that quails “do wonders for a man,” such that “they say that the man doesn’t get up off her the whole night.” Sakeena responds, “So? What about you, man, without any quail?” As it does throughout the novel, such humor helps to lighten the tone of the family’s depressing circumstances.
W Critical Reception Ju’ was met with widespread critical acclaim, which led to the translation of the work into English just a year later. In 2009 the original Arabic version of the novel was short-listed for the prestigious Emirates Foundation International Prize for Arabic Fiction. This prize, sometimes known as the Arab Booker Award, honors the best works of Arabic fiction each year and promotes Arab literature around the globe. Although Hunger has not been widely reviewed in English, published commentary on the novel has been overwhelmingly positive and has helped increase the author’s visibility among English-speaking readers. Describing al-Bisatie’s work in Al-Ahram Weekly Online, David Tresilian notes that he writes with a “spare, understated prose” and comments that his fiction frequently depicts “lives lived out within small, usually well-regulated communities with a view to suggesting the inter-relation of public and private events.” Many
564
commentators have noted that Hunger returns to common themes from al-Bisatie’s earlier writing, including his emphasis on rural village life and his advocacy for the downtrodden members of society, who are excluded from most of the benefits of progress and modernization. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
al-Bisatie, Mohamed. Hunger. Trans. Denys JohnsonDavies. Cairo: American U in Cairo P, 2008. Print. Johnson-Davies, Denys. “Village Life from Within.” Al-Ahram Weekly Online 13-19 May 1999. Web. 1 Sept. 2010. “Mahfouz’s Progeny: The Generation of the Sixties.” Al-Ahram Weekly Online 13-19 Dec. 2001. Web. 7 Sept. 2010. Qualey, Marcia Lynx. “Mohamed al-Bisatie. Drumbeat.” World Literature Today 84.4 (2010): 60. General OneFile. Web. 1 Sept. 2010. Tresilian, David. “Summer Reading, à la Française.” Al-Ahram Weekly Online 8-14 June 2000. Web. 1 Sept. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Dawood, Ibrahim. Rev. of A Last Glass of Tea and Other Stories, by Mohamed al-Bisatie. World Literature Today 73.2 (1999): 383. Dawood’s review of one of al-Bisatie’s short story collections provides useful context for the author’s other works. El-Wardani, Mahmoud. “Through the Mask of Yasmine.” Rev. of Layali Okhra [Other Nights], by Mohamed al-Bisatie. Al-Ahram Weekly Online 10-16 Feb. 2000. Web. 6 Sept. 2000. This review of alBisatie’s 2000 novel Layali Okhra (Other Nights) provides an overview of pervasive themes in the author’s body of work and surveys his novels in the context of his association with the Generation of the Sixties. Although the analysis predates Hunger, it provides insight into the novel’s relationship with al-Bisatie’s earlier works. Rev. of Hunger, by Mohamed al-Bisatie. National [Abu Dhabi] 16 Mar. 2009. Web. 7 Sept. 2010. This review of Hunger discusses its nomination for the Emirates Foundation International Prize for Arabic Fiction. “Lean and Crisp Writing Makes for Biting Read.” Rev. of Hunger, by Mohamed al-Bisatie. Arab News [Jeddah] 29 June 2008. InfoTrac Custom Newspapers. Web. 1 Sept. 2010. This favorable review of the novel includes a plot overview and situates the work in the context of the author’s life. Tresilian, David. “The Way It Is: An Interview with Mohamed al-Bisatie.” Cairo Today Sept. 1991: 61-3. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Hunger
Print. This interview places al-Bisatie’s work in the context of his Egyptian contemporaries and characterizes its political consciousness. Gale Resources
“Mohamed Al-Bisatie.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2006. “Overview: ‘A Conversation from the Third Floor.’” Short Stories for Students. Ed. David A. Galens. Vol. 17. Detroit: Gale, 2003. Print. Open Web Sources
This article in Egypt Today examines the life and career of Denys Johnson-Davies, the renowned Arabic-English translator of Hunger. http://www.egypttoday.com/ article.aspx?ArticleID=6463 An excerpt from Hunger can be found on International Literary Quarterly’s Web site. http://www.interlitq. org/issue2/mohamed_el_bisatie/job.php The American University in Cairo Press, one of the world’s foremost publishers of Arabic-English translations, provides an overview of Hunger as well as brief biographies of its author and translator. http:// www.aucpress.com/p-2699-hunger.aspx For Further Reading
Print. al-Bisatie’s novella explores scandal, struggle, and community politics in a small Egyptian village. Hopkins, Nicholas S., and Kirsten Westergaard, eds. Directions of Change in Rural Egypt. Cairo: American U in Cairo P, 1998. Print. This volume of essays explores the changing face of rural Egypt. Its examinations of rural life, poverty, and progress provide context for al-Bisatie’s novel. Jacquemond, Richard, and David Tresilian. Conscience of the Nation: Writers, State, and Society in Modern Egypt. Cairo: American U in Cairo P, 2008. Print. This nonfiction study of progressive Egyptian authors representing a number of genres includes a discussion of al-Bisatie’s work. Johnson-Davies, Denys. Memories in Translation: A Life between the Lines of Arabic Literature. Cairo: American U in Cairo P, 2006. Print. This memoir by Johnson-Davies, the translator of Hunger, reflects on his career as one of the world’s foremost ArabicEnglish translators. Tresilian, David. A Brief Introduction to Modern Arabic Literature. London: Saqi, 2008. Print. Tresilian’s book provides an overview of contemporary Arabic authors and their texts and includes a discussion of al-Bisatie’s work.
al-Bisatie, Mohamed. Houses behind the Trees. Trans. Denys Johnson-Davies. Austin: U of Texas P, 1998.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Greta Gard
565
If I Die in Juarez By Stella Pope Duarte
W Introduction Stella Pope Duarte’s If I Die in Juarez is a dark, meditative novel that dramatizes the tragic fate of an alarming number of young Mexican women who were abducted and murdered during the 1990s while on the way to or from work in factories owned by American companies. This fictionalization focuses on three young women—13-yearold Evita, 19-year-old Petra, and 12-year-old Mayela—all of whom are forced to grow up much faster than normal due to the poverty and brutality that exists in their lives. Evita lives in the red light district and works as a prostitute; Petra, her cousin, moves to the gritty city of Juarez in order to earn money to help her sick father; Mayela, Petra’s artistic friend, lives in an orphanage. The story of the three girls is framed within the context of several murders that remain unsolved; the novel ends triumphantly, with justice restored. If I Die in Juarez received the 2009 American Book Award, the 2008 Southwest Book of the Year Award, and the 2008 Arizona Book Award for Best in Popular Fiction, and was nominated for a Pulitzer Prize for Fiction.
W Literary and Historical Context
If I Die in Juarez was inspired by tragic, real-life events that occurred in the mid-1990s. The North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) was enacted during this time, and was intended to ease the trade problems between the United States, Canada, and Mexico. As a result, many American-owned factories were established in Mexico, and numerous young Mexican women were hired to work in them. The women worked in factories known as maquiladoras, and were paid only a tiny fraction of what people in American factories earned. Between 1993 and 2008, over five hundred women between the ages of eleven and
twenty-two were murdered in the Juarez area, either on their way to or home from work. Hundreds of the bodies demonstrated signs of sexual abuse and sickening torture, and many were mutilated beyond recognition. To this day, thousands of women who worked in maquiladoras remain missing. The most famous of these murder cases involved three friends, Vileta Mabel Alvidrez, 18, Juana Sandoval Reyna, 17, and Esmerelda Juarez Alarcon, 16. Currently, these murders remain unsolved. Speculation about the perpetrators has included drug traffickers, cartels, serial killers, satanic cults, and even the idea that the women were abducted by members of the porn industry making “snuff films.” Duarte traveled to Mexico to conduct her research for this novel, and interviewed several women who lived and worked in the area, and were friends of the victims. She also scoured through newspapers and other documentation. Although the real-life murders on which Duarte based her novel were never resolved, Duarte wraps up her story more neatly, sparing the three female protagonists, who manage to vanquish their attackers.
W Themes The major themes of If I Die in Juarez revolve around the loss of innocence. Petra, Mayela, and Evita are three young women forced to grow up far too abruptly due to the poverty in which they live and the social injustices they must endure on a daily basis. Evita lives in the red light district, surrounded by prostitutes; Petra is forced to make an arduous journey to Juarez in order to earn money for her starving family; and Mayela finds herself in a filthy, poverty-stricken village on the outskirts of the city. Before long, Evita begins prostituting herself in order to make a living. The other two girls compromise themselves in other ways in order to survive. Duarte describes the degradation in which these young women live on a constant basis in great detail, paralleling it with the very real danger they face at the hands of the unknown forces stalking and preying upon women
566 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
If I Die in Juarez
of their age and circumstances. Duarte further exposes the misogyny that lies at the heart of these attacks, as well as the society that has failed to bring these killers to justice.
W Style If I Die in Juarez is historical fiction, albeit based on events in the recent past. Duarte’s research for her novel was conducted in a manner similar to writing history. Her characters are fictional, however, allowing her to fashion a more uplifting ending than the fate of the actual women on whom the novel is based. Durate writes with a vivid attention to detail, with the aim of placing her readers in her characters’ footsteps in order to experience the the squalor and heartbreak of their lives. Duarte is particularly focused on painting a richly detailed picture of her characters’ inner lives. Despite their squalid circumstances, the girls retain a sense of hope and optimism. They dream of escaping to the United States in order to have improve their lot in life. Their goals are symbolically expressed through Mayela, who is an artist. Her twin brother died at birth, and yet Mayela continues to imagine seeing him. Instead of causing her despair, this “ghost” inspires her. Duarte
MAJOR CHARACTERS EVITA is a thirteen-year-old girl who has to leave home to escape her abusive, alcoholic mother, only to end up living a life of prostitution. MAYELA, an acquaintance of Evita’s cousin, Petra, is a twelveyear-old Tarahumara Indian orphan with immense artistic talent. PETRA, Evita’s nineteen-year-old cousin, moves from the country to Juarez in order to work in a factory.
describes how he “came to her in her dreams. He was . . . beautiful . . . always smiling with her. He sat on her shoulder . . . , a tiny baby with paper-thin wings like an angel’s. . . . [He] told her . . . he would protect her. . . . Over and over again she painted . . . a blue baby flying, with pink wings and shiny yellow toenails.” Her deceased twin comes to represent dreams of escape, as well as beauty amid sadness and strife.
This photo shows a poster of a missing girl. The novel If I Die in Juarez focuses on the staggering number of young Mexican women who are abducted and murdered. ª TOMAS BRAVO/Reuters/Corbis TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
567
If I Die in Juarez
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Born and raised in a barrio in Phoenix, Arizona, Stella Pope Duarte did not begin to pursue her literary career until 1995, when a dream about her deceased father inspired her to begin writing. The Arizona Commission on the Arts awarded her a creative writing fellowship for her first short story collection, Fragile Night, which additionally led to her nomination for the PEN West Fiction Award. She won a second fellowship for her novel, Let Their Spirits Dance, in 2001. Themes that run throughout her work include the Mexican experience, both as immigrants in the United States and in Mexico, and the ghosts of the past. A human rights activist, Duarte is also an inspirational speaker who tours giving speeches on literacy, leadership, diversity, women’s rights, Chicano history, and more.
the novel’s happy ending, but conceded that “it’s comforting to believe in the strength of community and family as depicted by Duarte and to trust that the real-life citizens of Juarez will continue their protests against the corruption that suffocates their city.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Duarte, Stella Pope. If I Die in Juarez. Tucson: U of Arizona P, 2008. Print. Rev. of If I Die in Juarez, by Stella Pope Duarte. Publishers Weekly 255.4 (2008): 43. Serros, Michele. “Butterflies Are Free.” Rev. of If I Die in Juarez, by Stella Pope Duarte. Ms. Summer 2008. Web. 13 Sept. 2010. Additional Resources Open Web Sources
Stella Pope Duarte’s official website includes a comprehensive biography, bibliography, news, and events. http://www.stellapopeduarte.com
W Critical Reception Upon its release, If I Die in Juarez received numerous awards, including the American Book Award, the Arizona Book Award, and the Southwest Book of the Year Award; the novel was also nominated for a Pulitzer Prize for Fiction. Overall, reviews were very positive. Critics were particularly impressed with the vivid picture Duarte depicts concerning the lives of the poor people of Juarez. Publishers Weekly found the novel an extremely powerful read. “Over the course of the novel,” noted the reviewer, “the girls are stripped of their childhoods and face grotesque realities that stalk the streets, even under the guise of protection.” The critic lauded Duarte’s prose, which was found to be “laced with anguish and desperation . . . [bringing] to life the grime and sleaze of Juarez.” Michele Serros of Ms. magazine declared that so “vividly does . . . [Duarte] detail survival within the grimy confines of la Zona del Canal that readers may be prompted to take a long, hot bath.” Serros did observe a few flaws in the book, however, and found Duarte’s use of symbolism heavy-handed. She cites the fact that “her villain, a Juarez factory owner and drug lord with a thirst for blood and conquest, maintains direct lineage to none other than 16th century conquistador Hernan Cortes, and the resurrection of a barely breathing rape victim commences on Easter Sunday” as particular examples of this overworked symbolism. The critic also questioned
568
For Further Reading
Bowden, Charles. Murder City: Ciudad Juarez and the Global Economy’s New Killing Fields. New York: Nation, 2010. Print. A book that exposes how global greed has led to conditions that allowed the Juarez murders to occur and remain unpunished. De Alba, Alicia Gaspar. Desert Blood: The Juarez Murders. Houston: Arte Publico Press, 2007. Print. Another novel based on the grisly Juarez murders. Duarte, Stella Pope. Women Who Live in Coffee Shops and Other Stories. Houston: Arte Publico Press, 2010. Print. This short story collection by Duarte explores the seedy underbelly of an urban environment in a manner reminiscent of If I Die in Juarez. Rodriguez, Teresa, Diane Montane, and Lisa Pulitzer. The Daughters of Juarez: A True Story of Serial Murder South of the Border. New York: Atria, 2007. Print. This nonfiction book provides a true account of the Juarez murders. Valdez, Diana Washington. The Killing Fields: Harvest of Women. Los Angeles: Peace at the Border, 2006. Print. Another history of the hundreds of women who have been abducted and murdered in Mexico. Powder Thompson
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Ilustrado By Miguel Syjuco
W Introduction Ilustrado (2010), the debut novel of Filipino writer Miguel Syjuco, tells a multifaceted story that centers on a young man’s search for his identity. The novel opens with the discovery of a dead body, a presumed suicide, floating in New York’s Hudson River. The body is that of Crispin Salvador, a once-great Filipino writer who had lived in exile for years, teaching at Columbia University while working on his magnum opus. One of Crispin’s students, a young Filipino expatriate named Miguel Syjuco, becomes obsessed with unearthing the true circumstances of his mentor’s death and his missing manuscript. Miguel’s inquiries lead him back to the Philippines, where his search for the truth about Crispin raises questions about his own relationship to their troubled homeland and leads to a surprising denouement. While still in manuscript, Ilustrado won the Man Asian Literary Prize and the Palanca Award for best novel in 2008.
W Literary and Historical Context
In the novel Crispin Salvador’s body is discovered floating in the Hudson River in mid-February 2002, five months after the September 11, 2001, attack on the World Trade Center. With the world’s attention focused elsewhere, the largely unnoticed death of the Philippines’ “literary lion” echoes the historical fate of his homeland, once the “gateway to Asia” but now a postcolonial backwater. Through Crispin’s writings and the story of Miguel’s return to the Philippines, Syjuco provides snapshots of the country at various points in history. He lays bare the links between the subjugation of the islands’ peoples under centuries of colonialism and the current social and political malaise that has stymied
reform since the fall of the Ferdinand Marcos regime in 1986. Each generation has hoped that among its offspring is a new group of Ilustrados (enlightened ones) to bring reform and renewal to the country. The original Ilustrados were educated Filipino men of the late nineteenth century who laid the groundwork for independence from Spain by encouraging Filipino nationalism. Like Crispin before him, Miguel dreams of becoming a new Ilustrado, though he wants to do so through his writing, not by becoming the politician his grandparents have dreamed of. Syjuco’s use of the techniques of postmodern literature to relate passages of the history of the Philippines, as well as the stories of Miguel’s and Crispin’s families, has prompted some reviewers to compare his novel to The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao (2007) by Junot Díaz. The latter work relates the struggles of a Dominican American family to historical events in the Dominican Republic under the dictatorship of Rafael Trujillo.
W Themes Ilustrado explores themes that are significant to both artists and émigrés. Miguel, an ambitious writing student, looks to Crispin, his mentor, for inspiration in finding his artistic purpose. Miguel feels pressured by his family to give something back to his homeland, but he is uncomfortable with his Filipino identity and with the expectations laid upon him as a Filipino writer. Although Crispin claims to have chosen exile because it makes him “an honest writer,” Miguel observes that his mentor has not published in years and seems frustratingly indifferent to ongoing political strife in the Philippines. When Miguel eventually begins to write Crispin’s biography, he hopes that the process will illuminate answers to his own problems: “the idea that his life could help me with mine . . . somehow kept me sane.” Syjuco weaves the themes of cultural identity and artistic purpose into a novel that itself embodies the
569 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Ilustrado
MAJOR CHARACTERS CRISPIN SALVADOR is a Filipino writer living in exile in New York and teaching creative writing at Columbia University. As the subject of his student Miguel Syjuco’s ongoing research in the Philippines, Crispin figures prominently throughout the narrative. In the end, however, the reader learns that Miguel has died and that Crispin has been imagining and telling Miguel’s story from the beginning of the novel. MIGUEL SYJUCO is a young man from the Philippines who is studying creative writing at Columbia University. Obsessed with learning about the life of his mentor, Crispin Salvador, whose death is reported at the beginning of the novel, he begins to write Crispin’s biography. His research takes him back to his homeland, where his investigations into another man’s life teach him to live his own.
imaginative search a story represents. In the epilogue, as Crispin ponders the death of a student who drowned in the Philippines, he echoes Miguel’s thoughts: “To make sense of what was happening to me, I obsessed on what had happened to him.” The fixation leads Crispin to destroy his unfinished masterpiece and to begin anew, with a memorial to his student. In the final paragraphs it becomes apparent that the drowned student is Miguel and that, from the novel’s very beginning, the reader has been reading a memorial to Miguel—Crispin’s attempt to “imagine the mystery of his life.”
W Style In Ilustrado Syjuco employs many of the techniques associated with postmodern literature. Characters in this genre sometimes share names or biographical details with their creators. By making the character Miguel Syjuco like himself in significant ways, Syjuco encourages the reader to question the boundary between fact and fiction in Ilustrado. Another of the novel’s postmodern features is pastiche, the combination of different styles and genres within a composition. Miguel’s first-person narration carries the main story line yet is frequently supplanted by other “sources” of information, including fictional news reports, e-mails, blogs, and even spam. In this type of structure, often described as a bricolage, no one source of narration can claim complete authority. Miguel’s narrative is called into question throughout the story by the other voices Syjuco has created for that very purpose. Ilustrado also provides many instances of intertextuality, such as the reference to The Approach to Al-Mu’tasim in the novel’s final chapter. The book is the work of Mir Bahadur Ali, a fictional character within a fictional work of the same title by the Argentine author Jorge Luis Borges. The reference clearly marks Ilustrado as fiction, and it indicates the chapter it appears in as a story within a story. Syjuco also liberally applies the techniques of metafiction, or fiction that draws attention to its fictionality. By repeatedly highlighting the novel’s artificiality, he creates tension with the mass of quotidian detail about his characters that gives the work the “realistic” cast of a traditional novel. The result is a kind of knot that is not released until the book’s final pages, in which Crispin writes, “When I finished writing, spent, after four seasons at the typewriter, I had knotted his being forever with mine. And with this fiction of possibilities, entwined with the possibilities of fiction, I’ve woven in my own unlived life.” By revealing the knot that he has created, Crispin untangles the one at the heart of Syjuco’s novel.
W Critical Reception Photo of Miguel Syjuco, author of the novel Ilustrado. ª Colin McPherson/Corbis
570
Even before its publication, Ilustrado was hailed as an extraordinary debut novel. Almost universally, reviewers TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Ilustrado
have described the work as “ambitious” and extolled Syjuco’s talent and ingenuity. Charles Foran, writing in Toronto’s Globe and Mail, describes Ilustrado as being “at once flashy and substantial, brightly charming and quietly resistant to its own wattage.” As noted in Kirkus Reviews, the novel’s “framing is simple, though nothing is clear, and everything encompassed remains open to question.” According to many critics, the novel’s serious thematic concerns form a core that is buoyed by comedy. For instance, a New Yorker reviewer finds in Ilustrado a “sociopolitical polemic” leavened with “lighter fare, such as a memorable thread of bawdy jokes.” Noting that the work is “bristling with comic verve” and “metafictional playfulness,” Robert Collins of the Sunday Times praises Ilustrado’s “vibrant mix of Borgesian literary labyrinth and acerbic émigré comedy.” While most critics have delighted in the postmodern architecture of Syjuco’s novel, a few objections have been raised. Foran praises the writer’s effort, declaring that he has the potential to be “a literary bridge-builder between the formally innovative and the reader-friendly.” Similarly, a reviewer in Publishers Weekly observes that Syjuco “shows considerable ingenuity in binding [the novel’s] divergent threads into a satisfying, meaningful story.” Michael Dirda of the Washington Post, however, finds that “the book seems to be going in several directions at once” in its final pages and concludes that Ilustrado is “more a novel of wonderful parts than a completely successful whole.” Alex Good of the Toronto Star concurs, noting that while “disjunction and indeterminacy are Syjuco’s aim,” a “loss of focus” in the final chapters “makes it hard to keep straight what Ilustrado is finally supposed to be about.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Collins, Robert. “Home and Away.” Rev. of Ilustrado, by Miguel Syjuco. Sunday Times [London] 13 June 2010: 40. Expanded Academic ASAP. Web. 17 Sept. 2010. Dirda, Michael. Rev. of Ilustrado, by Miguel Syjuco. Washington Post. Washington Post Co. 6 May 2010. Web. 17 Sept. 2010. Foran, Charles. “New Filipino Fiction Is Fabulous, Flashy, Funny.” Globe and Mail [Toronto] 8 May 2010: F13. CPI.Q (Canadian Periodicals Index Quarterly). Web. 17 Sept. 2010. Good, Alex. “A Death in the Afternoon: A Famous Novelist Is Dead in the Hudson River; Let the Precocious Games Begin.” Toronto Star 11 July 2010: IN6. CPI.Q (Canadian Periodicals Index Quarterly). Web. 17 Sept. 2010. Rev. of Ilustrado, by Miguel Syjuco. Kirkus Reviews 1 Mar. 2010: n. pag. Literature Resource Center. Web. 17 Sept. 2010.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Miguel Syjuco was born on November 17, 1976, in Manila, Philippines. He holds a BA in English literature from Ateneo de Manila University, an MFA in creative writing from Columbia University, and a PhD in English literature from the University of Adelaide in Australia. Both of Syjuco’s parents are active in government in the Philippines. Like the character Miguel Syjuco in Ilustrado, Syjuco was encouraged by his family to pursue a career in law and politics, but he chose to continue with his literature studies and writing. Syjuco’s dedication to writing led to a succession of peculiar and minimally supportive jobs, including stints as a bookie’s assistant and as a handbag salesman on eBay. His aim in entering Ilustrado into the competition for the Man Asian Literary Prize was to make the long list and perhaps gain the attention of a literary agent.
Rev. of Ilustrado, by Miguel Syjuco. New Yorker 24 May 2010: 71. Literature Resource Center. Web. 17 Sept. 2010. Rev. of Ilustrado, by Miguel Syjuco. Publishers Weekly 1 Feb. 2010: 31. Literature Resource Center. Web. 17 Sept. 2010. Syjuco, Miguel. Ilustrado. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux. 2010. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Bonner, Raymond. “Manila Vice.” Rev. of Ilustrado, by Miguel Syjuco. New York Times Book Review 13 June 2010: 8(L). Literature Resource Center. Web. 17 Sept. 2010. Focuses favorably on the narrative and stylistic complexities of the novel. Finnell, Joshua. Rev. of Ilustrado, by Miguel Syjuco. Library Journal 15 Feb. 2010: 91. Literature Resource Center. Web. 17 Sept. 2010. Praises Syjuco’s craft in interweaving a historical portrait of the Philippines with his narrative. Gurria-Quintana, Angel. Rev. of Ilustrado, by Miguel Syjuco. Financial Times. Financial Times Ltd. 5 June 2010. Web. 17 Sept. 2010. Highlights the satiric brio of Syjuco’s treatment of the Filipino upper class. Leber, Michele. Rev. of Ilustrado, by Miguel Syjuco. Booklist 1 Apr. 2010: 24. Literature Resource Center. Web. 17 Sept. 2010. Critiques and praises Syjuco’s novel as a “literary landmark.” Mars-Jones, Adam. Rev. of Ilustrado, by Miguel Syjuco. Guardian.co.uk. Guardian News and Media Ltd. 29 May 2010. Web. 17 Sept. 2010. Downplays the effectiveness of Syjuco’s metafictional artifices but commends his evocation of contemporary Manila.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
571
Ilustrado
O’Connor, Joseph. Rev. of Ilustrado, by Miguel Syjuco. Guardian.co.uk. Guardian News and Media Ltd., 29 May 2010. Web. 17 Sept. 2010. Focuses on and applauds Syjuco’s exploration of the possibilities of fiction. Gale Resources
As part of its collection of country studies, the Library of Congress offers an overview of the Philippines, including information on the islands’ history and culture. http://countrystudies.us/philippines/ The Web site Tagalog Lang provides an introduction to Filipino culture, with collections of articles on literature, music, religion, and language. http:// tagaloglang.com/Filipino-Culture/ For Further Reading
Barber, John. “The Shooting Star of Filipino Fiction.” Globe and Mail [Toronto] 1 May 2010: F8. CPI.Q (Canadian Periodicals Index Quarterly). Web. 30 Sept. 2010. In a profile of the author, Syjuco describes his struggle to succeed as a writer, how that
572
struggle is reflected in Ilustrado, and the challenges facing Filipino writers. Lau, Joyce Hor-Chung. “An Expatriate Filipino Writes of a Parallel Life.” New York Times 9 May 2010: A12. Print. Syjuco talks about his background as a member of a wealthy Filipino family that lived abroad during the years of Ferdinand Marcos’s dictatorship, the trajectory of his writing career, and the current state of politics in the Philippines. Syjuco, Miguel. “And if This Leader Should Happen to Fall . . . ” Editorial. International Herald Tribune. New York Times 19 May 2010. Web. 17 Sept. 2010. In this op-ed piece Syjuco discusses the vicissitudes of the Philippines’ recent political history. ———. Interview. Times [London]. Times Newspapers Ltd. 13 June 2010. Web. 17 Sept. 2010. In this e-mail interview, Syjuco discusses his method and intent in writing Ilustrado, his travels and studies abroad, and the writers he wants to tackle his biography. Janet Moredocke
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Image, the Icon, and the Covenant By Sahar Khalifeh
W Introduction Originally published in Arabic in 2002 and translated into English in 2008, The Image, the Icon, and the Covenant by Sahar Khalifeh tells the story of Ibrahim, a former schoolteacher who is attempting to make peace with his past as he enters old age. Divided into three sections, the novel traces Ibrahim’s ill-fated love for a young Catholic woman named Mariam, whom he abandoned while she was pregnant with his child. Although he eventually found wealth and traveled the world, Ibrahim was unable to establish a lasting relationship or produce an heir. Returning to his homeland after many years and two failed marriages, he must confront the realities of life in a much-changed Jerusalem as he searches for the woman and child he abandoned in his youth. The Image, the Icon, and the Covenant has won praise for its treatment of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, as well as for its insight into the often-uneasy relationship between Muslims and Christians in Palestine. The work is the first by Khalifeh, a noted feminist, to feature a male narrator/ protagonist. The novel’s depictions of gender inequality in Palestinian society, however, are no less striking than in the author’s earlier texts.
W Literary and Historical Context
The contested past of Jerusalem is an important aspect of The Image, the Icon, and the Covenant. With history dating back to the fourth millennium BCE, Jerusalem is a city sacred to Jews, Christians, and Muslims. It is home to a number of important religious sites, including the Temple Mount (believed to be the site of Solomon’s First Temple), the Western (or Wailing) Wall (identified by Jews as part of the ancient First Temple), the Church of
the Holy Sepulchre (built on what tradition holds is the site of Christ’s crucifixion), and the Al-Aqsa Mosque (a holy site believed to have been visited by Muhammad during the Night Journey recorded in the Qur’an). In the novel Ibrahim visits the Church of the Holy Sepulchre with Mariam, and he is near the Al-Aqsa Mosque when violence breaks out there in 2000. In modern times Jerusalem has been at the center of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Following World War II, the 1947 United Nations Partition Plan called for the creation of separate Jewish and Arab states in Palestine, with the city of Jerusalem, sacred to both sides, being ruled by coalition. Most of Palestine’s Jewish residents embraced the plan, but the majority of the Arab population did not. When Israel declared its independence in 1948, Arab forces launched an invasion, beginning the 1948 Arab-Israeli War. After the conflict Jerusalem was divided between Israel and Jordan. Violence flared again in 1967 with the Six-Day War between Israel and the Arab countries of Egypt, Jordan, and Syria. As a result of the fighting, Jerusalem was reunified under Israeli control. Hostilities continued to rise over the next three decades, and in 2000 a period of prolonged violence known as the Second (or Al-Aqsa) Intifada erupted. Although the conflict ended by 2005 (the exact date is disputed), the fate of Jerusalem and Palestine remains contested. The Image, the Icon, and the Covenant dramatizes the ongoing Israeli-Palestinian tensions, beginning just before the Six-Day War and ending during the Second Intifada.
W Themes Thematically central to Khalifeh’s novel is the clash between cultures, which is initially represented in Ibrahim and Mariam’s relationship. Mariam, a Christian, was born in the Middle East and raised in Brazil. At one point in the narrative Ibrahim bemoans the vast differences between them: “She was Christian and I was Muslim,
573 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Image, the Icon, and the Covenant
MAJOR CHARACTERS IBRAHIM is the narrator of the novel. As a young man he falls in love with Mariam. When she becomes pregnant, her brothers attempt to kill Ibrahim, and he makes the decision to leave Mariam behind and go to work for an American oil company that takes him around the world. He builds great wealth but experiences two failed marriages and never has any more children. In an attempt to atone for his sins, he starts a charity to support Palestinian widows and orphans. He later returns to Jerusalem seeking Mariam and his son, Michael. He is disappointed when first Michael and then Mariam reject him. At the end of the novel, unsure of Michael’s fate as the Second Intifada breaks out, he embraces a friendship with the dispossessed Jamileh. JAMILEH is an elderly Palestinian woman whom Ibrahim meets when he is searching for Mariam. Cast out of her home by two young American Jewish men who have managed to assert a legal claim to it despite her proof of ownership, Jamileh is living in Mariam’s former home. She and her husband had taken in a pregnant Mariam, and when Michael was born, Jamileh, a nurse, arranged for a birth certificate listing her and her husband as his parents in order to spare Mariam from being formally shamed as an unwed mother. Jamileh helps Ibrahim understand Mariam’s life as a young, single mother. MARIAM is the woman who haunts Ibrahim’s memories. Before she met Ibrahim, she had lived briefly in Brazil, where she fell in love with a priest who considered leaving the church to be with her. After Ibrahim abandons her during her pregnancy, she lives briefly with Jamileh, who helps her care for the infant she eventually gives up. Ibrahim goes to great lengths to find her, but when he does, the two argue and she is unwilling to forgive him or to acknowledge their former relationship in the way that he had hoped. MICHAEL is the son of Ibrahim and Mariam, who develops a reputation as a gifted seer and faith healer. Raised as an orphan in a Catholic monastery, he refuses to accept Ibrahim as his father. At the end of the novel, Ibrahim loses sight of Michael during the outbreak of the Second Intifada and fears for his safety. His whereabouts remain unknown as the novel ends.
she was rich and I was poor, she knew the world and had traveled the world.” It is ultimately the worldly Mariam who suffers most over their relationship: “People cursed and ostracized her—the Christians because she loved a Muslim, and the Muslims because she was a sinner who deserved to be stoned.” After Mariam becomes pregnant, her brothers, to whom “Islam was simply a joke, a deviation in history, a camel,” attempt to kill Ibrahim to defend her honor.
574
Later, Ibrahim comes to see his failed relationship with Mariam as tied to the fate of Jerusalem: “Mariam and her memory were lost; so was I, and so was Jerusalem. We had become two individuals on separate shores divided by a river and an occupation army.” When Ibrahim returns to his homeland in 2000, he finds it changed, and conflicts between opposing factions become more central to the narrative. After he finds his son, Michael, now thirty-five, Ibrahim asks him how he became a faith healer. Michael, who eschews affiliation with any one faith, responds, “I saw people around me swimming in pools of blood, Arabs and Jews, Armenians, Circassians, various ethnic groups, and different peoples with similar stories. I saw massacres and carnage everywhere undertaken in the name of religion and nationalism.” Although Khalifeh depicts the injustice of the Israeli occupation of Jerusalem, she, like Michael, is careful about pinning responsibility for the conflict solely on the Israelis. She also suggests that the Palestinians will never be free until they overcome the gender inequality that leaves daughters undervalued and women at the mercy of men—subject to domestic violence and honor killings.
W Style Narrated in the first person by an elderly Ibrahim, the novel is divided into three distinct sections—The Image, The Icon, and The Covenant—that collectively give the book its title. As the section titles suggest, the narrative focuses on Ibrahim’s pursuit of sura, which translates as “photograph,” “picture,” or “image,” among other meanings. As Aida Bamia explains in the “Translator’s Note” of the novel, its definition “depends greatly on context and lends itself easily to both concrete and abstract meanings.” When Ibrahim returns to the West Bank, he seeks a photograph of Mariam as he remembers her from her youth. After finding a photo in her former home, he tucks it in his wallet, carrying it with him as he searches for the woman herself. Upon finding Mariam, however, he realizes he was pursuing a romanticized version of her and a love that never existed. Publishers Weekly suggests that “the title’s complexities mirror those of this fugue-like novel, which finds Ibrahim cycling among versions of himself and of Mariam. As Ibrahim’s realizations pile up, their irreconcilability becomes a delicate and powerful allegory for Middle Eastern conflict.” The Image, the Icon, and the Covenant is a realist novel, one that works to establish a sense of verisimilitude about the events it conveys. To this end, Khalifeh works to develop a detailed and realistic portrait of her characters, their thoughts, and their surroundings. Although Mariam is represented primarily through Ibrahim’s memories of her, her voice is briefly heard when he returns to her family home, now occupied by an TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Image, the Icon, and the Covenant
elderly woman named Jamileh. She has preserved Mariam’s former belongings, including journals in which she described her struggles as a new, single mother. In allowing Mariam to speak for herself through her journal entries, Khalifeh adds a new layer of insight into the relationship between Mariam and Ibrahim.
W Critical Reception Khalifeh had already established herself as a top contemporary Arab writer when the Arabic version of the novel was published in 2002. The work drew praise for its depiction of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and intrigued readers as the first of Khalifeh’s works to feature a male narrator. In 2006 the novel won the Naguib Mahfouz Medal for Literature, a prize that recognizes a top work of contemporary Arab fiction worthy of translation. The prize led to the novel’s translation and publication in English in 2008. The English version has not been widely assessed, however, and existing critiques have been mixed. In reviewing The Image, the Icon, and the Covenant for the Journal of Palestine Studies, Hala Halim commends the “abiding power of Khalifeh’s
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Sahar Khalifeh was born in Nablus, Palestine, in 1941. She was the fifth girl born to a family desperately seeking a male heir, and her parents’ disappointment with her gender shaped her outlook on life. As an adult Khalifeh left an arranged marriage after more than a decade of misery, returning to Palestine from the home she had shared with her former husband in Libya. She earned a bachelor’s degree in English from Birzeit University and launched her writing career. Published in 1972, the novel Lam na’ud jawari lakum (We are not your slave girls anymore) established Khalifeh as an important voice in Palestinian feminism and literature. She followed the success of this initial work with Al-Subbar (1976; Wild Thorns, 1985), which would become her best-known work internationally, and led to a sequel in 1980 titled ‘Abbad al-shams (The sunflower). While enjoying these successes, Khalifeh earned a PhD in women’s studies from the University of Iowa in 1988. Her other notable works include Al-Mirath (1997; The Inheritance, 2005) and Rabi’har: Rihlat al-sabr wa al-subbar (2004; The End of Spring, 2008).
A village in Jordan. The Image, the Icon, and the Covenant takes place in the Middle East, specifically in Jerusalem and Palestine. OPIS/Shutterstock.com
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
575
The Image, the Icon, and the Covenant
narrative,” while Publishers Weekly lauds Khalifeh for tackling a sensitive subject, describing the novel as offering “a challenging take on vexing territory.” Kirkus Reviews, however, criticizes the text for its lack of strong and well-defined characters, asserting, “A novel about character and identity needs sharper, stronger protagonists than the blurry Ibrahim and Mariam.” Halim is somewhat critical of Bamia’s English translation, suggesting that it is too literal in its translation and that Bamia misinterprets what it means to be faithful to an original text, as “‘fidelity’ appears to have been construed as closeness to the denotative signification of the words.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Bamia, Aida. Translator’s Note. The Image, the Icon, and the Covenant. By Sahar Khalifeh. Northampton: Interlink, 2008: 261-62. Print. Halim, Hala. Rev. of The Image, the Icon, and the Covenant, by Sahar Khalifeh. Journal of Palestine Studies 37.4 (2008): 85. Print. Rev. of The Image, the Icon, and the Covenant, by Sahar Khalifeh. Kirkus Reviews 15 Dec. 2007: n. pag. Print. Rev. of The Image, the Icon, and the Covenant, by Sahar Khalifeh. Publishers Weekly 5 Nov. 2007: 45. Print. Khalifeh, Sahar. The Image, the Icon, and the Covenant. Trans. Aida Bamia. Northampton: Interlink, 2008. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Bamia, Aida A. “Sahar Khalifeh: Novelist and Feminist.” Banipal: Magazine of Modern Arab Literature 1516.26 (2002-2003): 26. Print. A brief article that mentions The Image, the Icon, and the Covenant and offers an overview of Khalifeh’s life and its impact on her writing. Harlow, Barbara. “Partitions and Precedents: Sahar Khalifeh and Palestinian Political Geography.” Intersections: Gender, Nation, and Community in Arab Women’s Novels. Ed. Lisa Suhair Majaj, Paula W. Sunderman, and Therese Saliba. Syracuse: Syracuse UP, 2002: 113-31. Print. Examines the representation of Palestine and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict in Khalifeh’s work. Nazareth, Peter. “An Interview with Sahar Khalifeh.” Iowa Review 11.1 (1980): 67-86. Print. An interview with Khalifeh in which she discusses her life and early career. Pierpont, Claudia Roth. “Found in Translation: The Contemporary Arabic Novel.” New Yorker 18 Jan. 2010: 74. Print. Discusses Khalifeh’s work among those by other prominent Arabic novelists.
576
Sabbagh, Suha. “An Interview with Sahar Khalifeh, Feminist Novelist.” Palestinian Women of Gaza and the West Bank. Ed. Suha Sabbagh. Bloomington: Indiana UP, 1998: 136-44. Print. An interview emphasizing Khalifeh’s feminist stance. “Saher Khalifa: An Interview.” Star [Amman]. Jordan Press and Publishing Co. 26 Nov. 1998. Web. 19 Oct. 2010. An interview in which Khalifeh discusses her life and work. Gale Resources
Al-Mallah, Ahmad. “Sahar Khalifa.” Twentieth-Century Arabic Writers. Ed. Majd Yaser Al-Mallah and Coeli Fitzpatrick. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 346. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Print. “Sahar Khalifeh.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Web. 19 Oct. 2010. Open Web Sources
The Web site for Arab World Books provides an author page about Khalifeh that includes biographical and bibliographical information, as well as a list of awards won. http://www.arabworldbooks.com/authors/ sahar_khalifa.html Khalil Sakakini Cultural Centre’s Web site offers an overview of art and culture in Palestine and includes a page dedicated to Sahar Khalifeh. http://www .sakakini.org/literature/sahar.htm Palestine Facts presents an online overview of the conflict between Israel and Palestinian Arabs that is useful context for Khalifeh’s novel. http://www.palestinefacts.org/ The University of Minnesota’s Web site VG/Voices from the Gap includes a page on Khalifeh that features an author biography, bibliography, and a collection of links related to Khalifeh and her work. http://voices. cla.umn.edu/artistpages/khaifehsahar.php For Further Reading
Armstrong, Karen. Jerusalem: One City, Three Faiths. New York: Knopf, 1996. Print. This work of nonfiction explores the history of Jerusalem and its centrality to Christianity, Judaism, and Islam, offering helpful context for Khalifeh’s novel. Glanville, Jo, ed. Qissat: Short Stories by Palestinian Women. London: Telegram, 2006. Print. This volume collects short works of fiction by Palestinian women. Harms, Gregory, and Todd M. Ferry. The Palestine-Israel Conflict. A Basic Introduction. Ann Arbor: Pluto, 2005. Print. This volume provides an overview of the conflict between Palestine and Israel that frames Khalifeh’s novel. Khalifeh, Sahar. The Inheritance. Trans. Aida Bamia. Cairo: American U in Cairo P, 2005. Print. The TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Image, the Icon, and the Covenant
second of Sahar’s novels to be translated into English, The Inheritance tells the story of an American-born woman of Palestinian descent working to rediscover her family and her identity in the Middle East.
of Catholicism and the history of the Roman Catholic Church offers background to the faith of fictional Mariam.
O’Collins, Gerald. Catholicism: A Very Short Introduction. Oxford: Oxford UP, 2008. Print. This overview
Greta Gard
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
577
In the Country of Men By Hisham Matar
W Introduction Hisham Matar’s In the Country of Men tells the story of a young boy named Suleiman growing up in the oppressive environment of Libya in 1979, with the country under the control of the despotic ruler Muammar Gaddafi. Over the course of the novel, Suleiman discovers that a number of his friends and family, including his father, are antigovernment revolutionaries working against the Guardian, as Gaddafi calls himself. Matar’s harsh tale is one of childhood cut short, in which a nine-year-old learns brutal truths about the workings of his world, learning that his government is not beneficent, and that morality is often determined by whoever happens to be in power. In England In the Country of Men was nominated for the prestigious Man Booker Prize, as well as the Guardian First Book Award in 2006, and went on to win the 2007 Royal Society of Literature Ondaatje Prize and the Commonwealth Writers’ Prize Best First Book Award for Europe and South Asia. It won the Premio Vallombrosa Gregor von Rezzori and Premio Internazionale Flaiano in Italy, the first Arab American Book Award, and was nominated for the 2007 National Book Critics Circle Award in the United States. It has been translated into twenty-two languages.
W Literary and Historical Context
Since 1969 Muammar Abu Minyar al-Gaddafi has been the ruler of Libya, making him the fourth-longest-serving national leader alive today. He originally came into power as the result of a bloodless coup d’état against then leader King Idris while the latter was away, seeking medical treatment. Gaddafi’s revolution deposed the king’s nephew and abolished the entire monarchy, proclaiming the country the Libyan Arab Republic. He sought to
fashion the country into a safe haven for anti-Western radicals and promised to provide weapons and money to any group formed to fight imperialism. He formed a Revolutionary Command Council in order to rule Libya, and instated himself as its chairman, calling his form of government, “Islamic socialism.” He claimed to be doing all this for the people. His programs emphasized liberation, welfare, and education, all of which were laid out in a number of books he wrote to reinforce his political philosophy. Like many dictators, Gaddafi poses himself as a loving, beneficent ruler and yet underneath the surface, he is a dangerous and violent man. Beyond providing weapons to terrorists, Gaddafi turned Libya into a police state, executing any suspected dissidents and encouraging people to turn on their loved ones in an attempt to find these enemies. In 1980 he sent hit squads abroad to kill dissidents living outside of the country and ordered any remaining dissidents to return to Libya, to be tried by his government. Gaddafi has executed hundreds of political dissenters. Political groups opposed to him include the National Front for the Salvation of Libya, the Committee for Libyan National Action in Europe, and the National Conference of the Libyan Opposition. In the Country of Men paints a bleak picture of the poor people who come to suffer under Gaddafi’s regime of supposed socialism and openness.
W Themes The two major themes of In the Country of Men are arguably the cruelty of the powerful and corrupt, and how the young can misinterpret circumstances as a result of not being mature enough to decipher the adult complexities in the world surrounding them. The protagonist, Suleiman, although he is only nine years old, ends up betraying a number of friends and family members to the government because he is not initially old enough to understand that his country’s ruler is not the
578 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
In the Country of Men
kind leader he purports to be. As reviewer Mary Ann Harlan explains, “What is most disturbing is that he must play the game of adults, but without knowing the rules. There is no heroism here, only fear, betrayal, and mistrust.” In one scene, Suleiman finds himself performing an act of cruelty, throwing a rock at a friend. In another, he tries to save a beggar from death by drowning and then kicks the man in the face. These scenes illustrate Suleiman’s anger and confusion at all the mixed signals he is receiving, both from his family and the oppressive world in which he lives, and also demonstrate how easy it is for an otherwise “good” person to become violent for seemingly little reason. These moments stand as a parallel to the brutal, public interrogation and execution of a political insurgent, Ustath Rashid, at the hands of the government.
W Style Hisham Matar writes In the Country of Men from his nine-year-old narrator’s perspective. Describing these circumstances through the eyes of a child serves the
MAJOR CHARACTERS FARAJ EL DEWANI or “Baba,” is Suleiman’s father, who is secretly working against the despotic government of Gaddafi. NAJWA EL DEWANI, or “Mama,” is Suleiman’s alcoholic mother with whom he shares a relationship by turns sweet and tempestuous. SULEIMAN EL DEWANI is the narrator and protagonist of the novel, now an adult, recalling the dark events that occurred in his country and in his family when he was nine years old. MOOSA is Baba’s best friend, with whom Suleiman is sent to live in Egypt at the end of the novel. KAREEM RASHID is Suleiman’s best friend and the son of Ustath Rashid, who conspired against the government with Baba. USTATH RASHID, a co-conspirator with Baba against Gaddafi’s government, he is arrested before the novel begins and publicly executed in one of its most shocking moments.
This photo shows Libyan President Muammar Abu Minyar al-Gaddafi. Several of the main characters in In the Country of Men work against Gaddafi’s regime. ª Wally McNamee/Corbis TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
579
In the Country of Men
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Hisham Matar was born in New York City to Libyan parents and lived there for the first three years of his life, while his father worked for the United Nations’ Libyan delegation. Afterward, they moved back to Libya until 1979, when they were forced to flee the country to Egypt due to his father being accused of attempting to sabotage the Libyan government. Much later, in 1990, his father was kidnapped in Cairo, with evidence suggesting that he was kidnapped by Egypt’s secret police and delivered back to Libya, where he might still be to this day, if he is still alive. These experiences and the emotions they provoked in Matar largely inspired him in writing In the Country of Men, which remains his only novel to date. He has, however, had a number of essays published in the New York Times, the Times, the Guardian, the Independent, and Asharq Alawsat.
purpose of further enhancing the horror of what Gaddafi did to the people of his country. Suleiman’s confusion at these chaotic events represents the fear and disarray being
felt by everyone, but it is taken to an even deeper level because of his youth and immaturity. Because Suleiman does not always grasp the nuances that an adult would, Matar makes it the job of the adult reader to make connections that Suleiman cannot, which causes dramatic irony as well as sadness. For example, Suleiman’s mother is an alcoholic, but she tells him that the alcohol is her medicine, so he does not understand why she would take “medicine” that makes her ill. Neither does he understand why she burns his father’s books, nor why she becomes so enraged when he tells the names of some of his father’s friends to a seemingly nice man in a car. The adult reader realizes, among other things, that the books must contain seditious material and that the man was coaxing the boy into informing on his friends and family, dooming them to an awful fate. The innocent point-of-view of a child also manages to make some of the novel’s moments of violence all the more disturbing. When he watches a public execution on television, Suleiman notes how the victim stops at every rung of the ladder he is forced to climb, to beg for mercy. He describes the scene further: “his trousers were wet. . . . A couple of men hugged and dangled from his ankles. . . . They looked like children satisfied with a swing they had
In this photo, citizens show their support for Libyan leader Muammar Abu Minyar al-Gaddafi in the 1970s. In the novel In the Country of Men, the main character discovers that his family members are working against Gaddafi’s oppressive administration. ª Geneviève Chauvel/Sygma/Corbis
580
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
In the Country of Men
just made” (188). This sweet, childish image stands in stark contrast to the degrading torment through which the man is suffering.
“Paperback of the Week: In the Country of Men, Hisham Matar, Penguin, £7.99.” Rev. of In the Country of Men, by Hisham Matar. Observer [London] 25 Feb. 2007: 25. Print.
W Critical Reception
“Paperbacks; Fiction.” Rev. of In the Country of Men, by Hisham Matar. Times [London] 17 Mar. 2007: 14. Print.
In the Country of Men received nearly universal acclaim upon its release and went on to win the Royal Society of Literature Ondaatje Prize and the Commonwealth Writers’ Prize, and to be nominated for the Man Booker Prize, among others. Publishers Weekly raved that the novel’s “brutality resonates beyond the bloody events themselves to a brutalizing of heart and mind for all concerned. Matar renders it brilliantly . . . Matar wrests beauty from searing dread and loss.” The London Observer reviewer called it “stunning,” and was particularly impressed with Matar’s restraint in telling his story. Rather than continuously plunging the reader into the “grisly details” of Gaddafi’s rule (though that certainly happens at times), he instead focuses on “a claustrophobically domestic setting,” thus making Matar’s “portrayal of oppression deeper and more resonant, intensifying the themes of collusion, treachery, mutual dependency, and thwarted freedom by giving them both private and public dimensions.” Reviewers were equally taken with the narrative voice, calling Suleiman “utterly convincing.” Entertainment Weekly’s Jennifer Reese spoke further about what made Suleiman such an effective narrator: “In limpid prose, Matar captures an ordinary, sometimes craven boy caught up in a political nightmare, and the poignant grown-up nostalgia for the certainties and security of a childhood cut abruptly short.” In other words, the poignancy of the adult Suleiman (and one can imagine Matar as well), looking back at a time before he lost his innocence, adds to the novel’s emotional verisimilitude and strength. The London Times reviewer agreed, saying, “In a text glowing with emotional truth, Matar constructs his young narrator’s perspective to evoke both the nameless and overwhelming feelings of childhood and an adult understanding of events. . . . In Hisham Matar’s extraordinary novel it becomes again what it was in David Copperfield and Jane Eyre—the universal cry of the innocent victim of institutional sadism.”
Reese, Jennifer. “In the Country of Men.” Rev. of In the Country of Men, by Hisham Matar. Entertainment Weekly 2 Feb. 2007: 129. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Adams, Lorraine. “A Lyrical Portrait of Evil Infantilized; In the Country of Men, Books & Ideas.” Rev. of In the Country of Men, by Hisham Matar. International Herald Tribune 3 Mar. 2007: 10. Print. This review analyzes Suleiman’s perceptions and how they complement and contrast with the world around him. “A Child’s-Eye View of Terror; Novel.” Rev. of In the Country of Men, by Hisham Matar. Times [London] 15 July 2006: 15. Print. This review compares Suleiman to the child narrators of Charles Dickens and other famous coming-of-age novels. el-Youssef, Samir. “The Curse of Topicality.” Rev. of In the Country of Men, by Hisham Matar. New Statesman 31 July 2006: 58. Print. This review criticizes the novel for what it sees as a sketchy and underdeveloped indictment of Gaddafi, accusing Matar of falling victim to Western stereotypes of Libyans. Keates, Jonathan. “Love in the Land of Gaddafi.” Rev. of In the Country of Men, by Hisham Matar. Spectator 9 Sept. 2006. Web. 5 Oct. 2010. This review/analysis places In the Country of Men in the context of the coming-of-age genre. Gale Resources
“Matar, Hisham 1970-.” Contemporary Authors. Vol. 259. Detroit: Gale, 2008. 257-58. Print. “Matar, Hisham (1970-).” Student Resource Center. Detroit: Gale, 2008. Web. 16 February 2011.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Open Web Sources
Works Cited
Harlan, Mary Ann. “Matar, Hisham. In the Country of Men.” Rev. of In the Country of Men, by Hisham Matar. School Library Journal 53.6 (2007): 180. Print. Rev. of In the Country of Men, by Hisham Matar. Publishers Weekly, 253.43 (2006): 34+. Print. Matar, Hisham. In the Country of Men. New York: Dial Press, 2007. Print. 188.
There is a comprehensive interview with Hisham Matar available at http://www.bookreporter.com/ authors/au-matar-hisham.asp For Further Reading
Haddon, Mark. The Curious Incident of the Dog in NightTime. New York: Vintage, 2003. Print. This novel is another first-person narrative told from the perspective of a young boy whose misunderstanding of
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
581
In the Country of Men
certain events due to his age influences his actions and reactions throughout the novel. Hyland, M. J. Carry Me Down. Edinburgh: Canongate, 2006. Print. This novel, narrated by a young boy speaking about his troubling childhood, is reminiscent of the limited perspective of the young Suleiman in In the Country of Men. McEwan, Ian. Atonement. New York: Anchor, 2001. Print. This coming-of-age novel about a young girl whose misinterpretation of an event due to her lack of maturity leads to tragedy shares a number of themes with In the Country of Men.
582
Salinger, J. D. The Catcher in the Rye. New York: Little, Brown, 1951. Print. This seminal coming-of-age classic focuses on a troubled young male protagonist struggling to understand the intricacies of the adult world around him, much like In the Country of Men. Vandewalle, Dirk. A History of Modern Libya. New York: Cambridge UP, 2006. Print. An in-depth history of Libya, both before and after Gaddafi’s revolution. Robert Berg
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Infinity in the Palm of Her Hand By Gioconda Belli
W Introduction Infinity in the Palm of Her Hand (2009), by Nicaraguan poet and novelist Gioconda Belli, retells the story of Adam and Eve, from their creation to the murder of their son Abel by his brother Cain. The novel was originally published in Spanish as El infinito en la palma de la mano (2008) and was translated into English by Margaret Sayers Peden. In Belli’s account Adam and Eve are not together long before Eve’s curiosity leads them to seek out “the Other” (Elokim, their creator), a mysterious being whose gaze follows them everywhere in the Garden. The search for Elokim ultimately leads to Eve’s decision to consume fruit from the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil and the subsequent expulsion of the pair from the Garden for having disobeyed Elokim’s command not to eat the fruit. With their Paradise lost, Adam and Eve must confront the problems that have shaped all of human history—hunger, thirst, ignorance, death—and qualified all of human happiness. In 2008 Belli’s novel won the Biblioteca Breve Prize and the Sor Juana Inés de la Cruz Award for a work in Spanish by a woman.
W Literary and Historical Context
In her author’s note Belli describes finding The Secret Books, a volume that contains an ancient account of the first couple after their expulsion from the Garden of Eden. Like the other “secret books” of the title, The Life of Adam and Eve was excluded by the church fathers as they canonized the books of the Bible in the centuries immediately following the emergence of Christianity. Its authenticity in doubt, The Life of Adam and Eve was relegated to a group of writings known as pseudepigrapha, or falsely attributed writings. Another of these ancient
stories, The Second Book of Adam and Eve, relates that Cain and Abel, Adam and Eve’s sons, each had a twin sister. These sisters, Luluwa and Aklia, do not appear in the book of Genesis, but Belli assigns them significant roles in her first-family drama. The story of Adam and Eve is thought to have Jewish origins and may have stemmed from oral traditions thousands of years old. Written versions began to appear a few hundred years before Christ. During the Middle Ages scholars considered The Life of Adam and Eve and similar apocryphal accounts important sources of information about the time of Creation, despite their noncanonical status. Literature abounds with allusions to Adam and Eve and the Garden of Eden. In the seventeenth century English poet John Milton retold the Creation story in his epic poem Paradise Lost. In the early twentieth century the humorist Mark Twain wrote a series of short comic pieces about the first couple that included “excerpts” from their diaries. More recent retellings are the novels Havah: The Story of Eve (2008), by Christian fiction writer Tosca Lee, and Eve (2009), by American author Elissa Elliott.
W Themes With Eve’s very first words—“What are we doing here?”—Belli introduces the themes that pulse through her novel: freedom and the quest for knowledge. Eve learns from the Serpent in the Garden that she and Adam are unique in creation because Elokim has made them free—and therefore capable of disobeying him. However, the price of disobeying Elokim’s commands is expulsion from the Garden and death. This transforms the eating of the fruit from the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil (i.e., the acquisition of knowledge) into the ultimate act of freedom. With knowledge of good and evil, of course, comes loss of innocence and, thus, Paradise. Nevertheless, Eve reasons that, having made her free, Elokim must
583 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Infinity in the Palm of Her Hand
MAJOR CHARACTERS ABEL is Adam and Eve’s second son. The handsome Abel follows in Adam’s footsteps as a provider. Abel’s attraction to Luluwa, Cain’s twin sister, leads to his being killed by a jealous Cain. ADAM is the first man and Eve’s husband. He is distraught at having been cast out of the Garden and blames Eve for their plight. Outside the Garden Adam cannot imagine life without Eve and is constantly preoccupied with providing for her and their children. AKLIA is Abel’s twin sister. The shock of Abel’s death causes Aklia to lose her reason and speech. Despite Eve’s entreaties, she decides to live out her life with a band of monkeys. CAIN is Adam and Eve’s first son. He resents Abel’s attraction to Luluwa. The festering conflict between the two brothers finally erupts, and Cain kills Abel. ELOKIM, the creator of all there is, made Adam and Eve free but forbade them, on pain of expulsion from the Garden, to exercise their freedom. Capricious and uncommunicative, Elokim is an absentee God whose motives and aims are unknown. EVE is the first woman and Adam’s wife. Driven by curiosity, she is the first to eat the fruit of the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil. Cast out of the Garden for disobeying Elokim, Eve continues to be curious and to try to understand her reason for being. LULUWA is Cain’s twin sister. Her beauty causes conflict among the men of the family. After Cain kills Abel, Luluwa joins him in exile.
El infinito en la palma de la mano, or Infinity in the Palm of Her Hand, retells the story of Adam and Eve. ª Images.com/Corbis
THE SERPENT acts as Adam and Eve’s main conduit of information about Elokim and his creation. Her account of the Tree of Knowledge of Good and Evil makes it impossible for Eve to resist doing what Elokim has expressly forbade: eating the forbidden fruit.
W Style
intend for her to eat the fruit in order to set in motion “History,” the “gigantic spiral of ephemeral and transparent men and women” that is revealed to her in a vision. The alternative is to remain in the Garden, “tranquil and passive, like the cat and the dog,” for eternity. After their expulsion from the Garden, Adam and Eve experience for the first time such gnawing needs as pain, hunger, and thirst. Knowledge is not what they expected (its accumulation is slow and unpredictable), and yet it is their sole equipment for forging a new life in the wilderness. It also brings them one invaluable gift, as Eve tells her daughters late in the novel: “We call it love.”
584
Belli tells her story in prose that is direct and economical. Writing in the South Florida Sun-Sentinel, Chauncey Mabe praises the novel’s “lyrical yet precise language.” The third-person narration smoothly bears the grandeur of the Creation story, and the voices of Adam and Eve are convincingly ingenuous in articulating its profound themes. The newly created Eve, for example, asks the fundamental questions (“What are we doing here?” “Who can explain to us where we come from?”) that set the stage for all that is to come. Belli relates the details of Adam and Eve’s unique life, conveying the splendor of every “first”—self-awareness, orgasm, birth—with “deftness and clarity,” according to National Public Radio (NPR) reviewer Alan Cheuse. He uses the term biblical science fiction to identify the freshness of experience that Belli captures in passages like the one in which she describes the taking of Eve from Adam’s rib: “Later he would remember his body opening, the split that divided his being to release the intimate creature that until then TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Infinity in the Palm of Her Hand
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Gioconda Belli was born on December 9, 1948, in Managua, Nicaragua. She aspired to work in the medical field, but her father rejected the idea. In the mid-1960s she embarked on a career in advertising. Through work she became friends with members of the Sandinista National Liberation Front, and by the early 1970s she was deeply involved with the rebel group. Around the same time she began to write poetry, publishing her first volume of poems, Sobre la grama (On the grass), in 1972. Her second book of poetry, Linea de fuego (1978; Firing line) won the Casa de las Américas Prize. After the Sandinistas gained control of Nicaragua in 1979, Belli worked in the government for several years. In 1988 she published her first novel, La mujer habitada (The Inhabited Woman, 1994), which became an international best seller. In subsequent novels she continued to explore the erotic and feminist themes that also figure prominently in her poetry. In 2000 she published a memoir, El país bajo mi piel: Memorias de amor y guerra (The Country under My Skin: A Memoir of Love and War, 2002). Her novel El país de las mujeres (2010; The women’s country) won the 2010 La Otra Orilla prize for Latin American literature.
Photo of Gioconda Belli, author of the novel Infinity in the Palm of Her Hand. ª imagebroker/Alamy
had dwelled within him. He could scarcely move. His body in its incarnation as chrysalis acted on its own; he could do nothing but wait in his state of semiconsciousness for whatever was to happen.” The economy and precision of the language in Belli’s novel is not surprising, given her long and successful career as a poet. Precise language is language chosen unselfishly, as Susan Salter Reynolds suggests in her review for the Los Angeles Times: “[The Creation story] is an act of calligraphy—too much ego and the mirror that is the story cracks, the pool ripples. . . . Told with pure intent, imagination and clarity, the story is generous, capacious. The story becomes The Story.” Belli works within the ancient narrative, respecting its structural integrity while seeing in those first lives the dream, as well as the reality, of what it is to be human.
W Critical Reception Critics have responded favorably to Infinity in the Palm of Her Hand. Kirkus Reviews characterizes the novel as “a realistic portrayal of the children of a laissez-faire God,” in
which Belli delivers a “somber, meditative treatment of the First Family.” Other reviews have demonstrated a similar appreciation for the seriousness of Belli’s endeavor. Booklist reviewer Margaret Flanagan observes that, in Belli’s hands, “Adam and Eve are complex, humanistic creatures whose temptation and subsequent fall perhaps signal the intellectual, social, and artistic fruition of mankind.” In Eve’s ruminations on the forbidden fruit, Mary Margaret Benson, writing for Library Journal, sees Belli asking “whether eating the . . . fruit was sin or perhaps intellectual curiosity and the quest for knowledge of good and evil.” In the novel Eve asks the Serpent, “Which would you choose? Knowledge or eternity?” Belli describes the book in her author’s note as “a deep exploration of . . . the myths that shape us and the way we cling to them, despite the truths science sets before us.” Although her Creation story makes a concession to evolutionary science’s account of human origins, it is poignantly enfolded in the story of Adam and Eve’s own offspring. “Without abandoning the timeless biblical story,” notes Publishers Weekly, “Belli manages to introduce a modern Darwinian element that’s both stark and eloquent.” Traumatized by the murder of her twin (Abel) at the hands of Cain, Aklia loses “reason and conscience” as well as the ability to speak. Having “returned to innocence,” Aklia leaves to join a band of monkeys. Her departure, explains the Serpent, marks the beginning of “a long, slow time” in history—a time in which Aklia’s descendants will develop the knowledge and freedom that will permit their return to Paradise.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
585
Infinity in the Palm of Her Hand BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Belli, Gioconda. Infinity in the Palm of Her Hand. Trans. Margaret Sayers Peden. New York: Harper, 2009. Print. Benson, Mary Margaret. Rev. of Infinity in the Palm of Her Hand, by Gioconda Belli. Library Journal 134.1 (2009): 76. Literature Resource Center. Web. 7 Sept. 2010. Cheuse, Alan. “Two Novels about Creation.” Rev. of Infinity in the Palm of Her Hand, by Gioconda Belli. All Things Considered. National Public Radio 6 Mar. 2009. Literature Resource Center. Web. 7 Sept. 2010. Flanagan, Margaret. Rev. of Infinity in the Palm of Her Hand, by Gioconda Belli. Booklist 105.12 (2009): 30. Literature Resource Center. Web. 7 Sept. 2010. Rev. of Infinity in the Palm of Her Hand, by Gioconda Belli. Kirkus Reviews 1 Feb. 2009: n. pag. Literature Resource Center. Web. 7 Sept. 2010. Rev. of Infinity in the Palm of Her Hand, by Gioconda Belli. Publishers Weekly 255.51 (2008): 28. Literature Resource Center. Web. 7 Sept. 2010. Mabe, Chauncey. Rev. of Infinity in the Palm of Her Hand, by Gioconda Belli. Sun-Sentinel [South Florida]. Sun Sentinel 15 Mar. 2009. Web. 7 Sept. 2010. Reynolds, Susan Salter. Rev. of Infinity in the Palm of Her Hand, by Gioconda Belli. Los Angeles Times. Los Angeles Times 15 Mar. 2009. Web. 7 Sept. 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Barbas-Rhoden, Laura. “Anatomy of a Woman: Pleasure, Power, and Politics in Gioconda Belli’s Writing.” Unveiling the Body in Hispanic Women’s Literature: From Nineteenth-Century Spain to Twenty-first-Century United States. Ed. Renee Scott, Arleen Chiclana y Gonzalez, and Marjorie Agosin. Lewiston: Mellen, 2006: 187-202. Print. Barbas-Rhoden’s chapter situates Belli’s writing in the wider context of representations of women and women’s bodies in the works of Hispanic women writers. Belli, Gioconda. Interview by Kenia Halleck. Bomb. Bomb Magazine, Winter 2001. Web. 7 Sept. 2010. This interview with Belli on Bomb magazine’s Web site addresses numerous topics, including the forces that define identity, the cultural effects of globalization, historical memory, the origins of the author’s 2010 novel El país de las mujeres, and how she chooses the subjects of her novels. ———. Interview by Jacki Lyden. All Things Considered. National Public Radio, 29 Nov. 2002. Web. 8 Sept. 2010. NPR’s interview with Belli focuses on the
586
author’s involvement with the Sandinista rebels in Nicaragua and her view of her role as a writer and as a woman in the revolutionary movement. Detwiler, Louise A. “Looking at My Sex: Gender Judgments in La mujer habitada.” Ixquic: Revista Hispanica Internacional de Analisis y Creacion 4 (2003): 1-15. Print. Discusses Belli’s novel La mujer habitada as an exploration of the risks faced by women who overstep traditional gender boundaries. Dunlap, Susanne. Rev. of Infinity in the Palm of Her Hand, by Gioconda Belli. Historical Novels Review. Historical Novel Society Feb. 2010. Web. 11 Sept. 2010. Considers the importance of language in Belli’s retelling of the Creation story. Schulenburg, Elizabeth. Rev. of Infinity in the Palm of Her Hand, by Gioconda Belli. BookLoons, n.d. Web. 11 Sept. 2010. This review, though generally favorable, notes some of the ways in which Belli’s novel differs from the biblical story of Adam and Eve. Gale Resources
“Gioconda Belli.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2007. Literature Resource Center. Web. 7 Sept. 2010. Preble-Niemi, Oralia. “Gioconda Belli.” Modern Spanish American Poets: Second Series. Ed. Maria Antonia Salgado. Dictionary of Literary Biography. Vol. 290. Detroit: Gale, 2004. Literature Resource Center. Web. 7 Sept. 2010. Open Web Sources
Gioconda Belli’s official Web site includes information about her poetry, novels, political writings, and children’s books, as well as a biography, reviews, and information about her public appearances. http:// www.giocondabelli.org/ The online version of the New York Daily News features a brief interview in which Belli discusses Infinity in the Palm of Her Hand, her feminist views, and her involvement with the Sandinistas. http://www. nydailynews.com/latino/2009/04/15/2009-0415_gioconda_belli_life_after_paradise.html In this Apr. 2006 episode of the PBS television talk show Charlie Rose, available on the show’s Web site, Belli discusses the writing process with novelist Salman Rushdie and Israeli author David Grossman. http:// www.charlierose.com/view/interview/436 For Further Reading
Alter, Robert. Genesis: Translation and Commentary. New York: Norton, 1997. Print. This translation of the book of Genesis renders the original Hebrew of the Genesis story into contemporary English and offers a commentary emphasizing the themes and characters that unify the story’s narrative. TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Infinity in the Palm of Her Hand
Elliott, Elissa. Eve: A Novel. New York: Bantam, 2009. Print. Elliott’s novel, which covers some of the same territory as does Infinity in the Palm of Her Hand in fleshing out Eve’s story, presents a style and thematic and philosophical preoccupations that differ from Belli’s work. Kahn, Paul W. Out of Eden: Adam and Eve and the Problem of Good and Evil. 2006. Princeton: Princeton UP, 2010. Print. This philosophical inquiry begins when Eve eats the forbidden fruit and argues that the root of evil lies in the human condition itself. Kvam, Kristen E., Linda S. Schearing, and Valarie H. Ziegler, eds. Eve and Adam: Jewish, Christian, and Muslim Readings on Genesis and Gender. Bloomington: Indiana UP, 1999. Print. This anthology documents the history of interpretation of the story of Adam and Eve in the major monotheistic religions. Lee, Tosca. Havah: The Story of Eve. Colorado Springs: NavPress, 2008. Print. In this fictional first-person account by Eve, she describes her constant struggles to regain Paradise.
Lumpkin, Joseph B. The First and Second Books of Adam and Eve: The Conflict with Satan. Blountsville: Fifth Estate, 2009. Print. This nonfiction work features two apocryphal accounts (in contemporary English) of the lives of the first family, including The Second Book of Adam and Eve, which numbers Luluwa and Aklia among Adam and Eve’s children. Pagels, Elaine. Adam, Eve, and the Serpent: Sex and Politics in Early Christianity. New York: Vintage, 1989. Print. Pagels presents an analysis of the evolution of early Christian thought with regard to human nature, morality, and sexuality. Twain, Mark. The Diaries of Adam and Eve. Ed. Shelley Fisher Fishkin. New York: Oxford UP, 1997. Print. This collection features “excerpts” from the diaries of the first couple, as originally “translated” by the humorist Twain at the beginning of the twentieth century.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Janet Moredock
587
The Informers By Juan Gabriel Vásquez
W Introduction Juan Gabriel Vásquez’s Los Informantes (2004), translated into English by Anne McLean as The Informers (2008), is a first-person novel narrated by Gabriel Santoro, “el junior.” A journalist by vocation, Santoro decides to write a book about Sara Guterman, a German Jew and friend whose family fled Nazi Germany and joined an enclave of fellow immigrants in Bogotá, Colombia. Set in the late 1980s and early 1990s, with flashbacks to the late 1930s and early 1940s, Gabriel Santoro’s narrative describes how Sara’s parents operated the Nueva Europa Hotel, which was really an internment facility for Germans suspected of being Nazis or Nazi sympathizers. A Life in Exile, Sara’s story, recounts the witch hunt produced by Colombia’s political commitment to the United States. The witch hunt made getting informers and identifying suspects more powerful than discovering the truth. Santoro learns of the infamous blacklists, which identified auswanderer (German immigrants) as targets of suspicion, regardless of proof, many of whom lost their businesses, freedom of mobility, and, in some cases, their lives. But Gabriel is unaware of the consequences his book will have for his father, Gabriel Santoro “el senior” and others. When Gabriel’s book is published, his father, a celebrated lawyer, rhetoric professor, and civic leader, writes an unflattering review and provokes a rift with his son. Three years later, Gabriel receives an unexpected call from his father inviting him to visit. What he anticipates might be an opportunity for reconciliation turns out to be news that the elder Santoro must undergo bypass surgery. Dr. Santoro’s second chance at life, further inspired by his love affair with Angelina, compels Gabriel to dig deeper into the past, especially when his father dies in a car accident after a visit to Medellín and an interview with Angelina, impugning the otherwise honorable reputation of Dr. Santoro,
is televised. Gabriel’s pursuit of the truth discloses that Dr. Santoro falsely accused Konrad Deresser, a family friend, of collusion with the Nazis, an accusation that resulted in Deresser’s suicide and the destruction of his family.
W Literary and Historical Context
South American compliance with U.S. blacklisting of German émigrés provides the political context for Vásquez’s novel about the unscrupulous methods employed against former German citizens. Vásquez uses Colombia as the backdrop for his novel. In Nazis and Good Neighbors: The United States Campaign against the Germans of Latin America in World War II, Max Paul Friedmann writes that Colombia expelled 20 percent of its German expatriates, while many others were interned in so-called hotels, forced to forfeit their businesses and property, shunned socially, and ruined to the point of being driven to suicide, as the case of Konrad Deresser illustrates. The novel also refers to the blacklisting of Colombians who did business with the Nazis or were accused of doing business with them. Under an edict from U.S. President Franklin Roosevelt, called the Proclaimed List of Certain Blocked Nationals, and with the compliance of the Colombian government, police clamped down on suspected commercial activities that were believed to be contrary to the aims of U.S. military action in Europe. Eduardo Santos, who was president of Colombia in 1941, agreed with a series of U.S. demands, including fortifying the Caribbean coast and guarding against infiltration of Axis funds into Latin America, all designed to frustrate potential Third Reich efforts to expand into that area. Colombian citizens who were accused of sympathizing with the Third Reich had their assets frozen, and some people were falsely accused by selfinterested informers.
588 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Informers
MAJOR CHARACTERS HANS BETHKE, a dinner guest at the Deressers’ home, expresses pro-Nazi sentiments and provokes a heated argument with Enrique Deresser and leads Dr. Santoro to betray Konrad Deresser to the authorities. JULIA BETHKE is Hans Bethke’s tolerant wife. ENRIQUE DERESSER, Konrad’s angry son, is also Gabriel’s friend, whose whereabouts and fate are conjectured in Gabriel’s second novel. KONRAD DERESSER is a German émigré who is betrayed by his friend and blacklisted by the Colombian government. He commits suicide. MARGARITA DERESSER, Konrad’s supportive wife, writes impassioned letters in his defense, when Konrad is accused of being a Nazi sympathizer. Her pleas denied, she eventually leaves her family. ANGELINA FRANCO is Dr. Gabriel Santoro’s physiotherapist. She becomes his lover, and after his death, his detractor. PETER GUTERMAN is the German Jew who owns the Nueva Europa Hotel. He is an intimate family friend of the Santoros. SARA GUTERMAN is Peter’s daughter and the subject of Gabriel Santoro’s biography. REBECA LÁZARO is Enrique Deresser’s wife. Bogotá, Colombia, is the setting for The Informers, which follows the life of a German Jew whose family fled from Germany to Bogotá. gary yim/Shutterstock.com
The novel demonstrates the power of false accusation and slander. Informers had the ability to ruin strangers and friends alike, simply by conveying the right amount of suspicion. In such cases, by accepting slander as fact, the public record may result in the wrong verdict.
SERGIO ANDRES FELIPE LÁZARO is the son of Rebeca and Enrique (Deresser) Lázaro. JOSEPHINA SANTAMARIA is Konrad’s black mistress. She is one of the last people to see him before he takes his life. DR. GABRIEL SANTORO is a celebrated legal scholar, professor of rhetoric, and civic leader. His son and namesake is Gabriel Santoro, the journalist. GABRIEL SANTORO is a journalist who writes A Life in Exile, a biography of Sara Guterman, which provokes his father’s scathing review. HANS AND LILI UNGAR are bookstore proprietors who pass a letter from Enrique Deresser to Gabriel Santoro, inviting him to visit.
W Themes The central theme of the novel is betrayal. In his youth, Dr. Santoro betrays his friend, Konrad Deresser, who is promptly blacklisted as a Nazi sympathizer. Dr. Santoro’s sharp criticism of his son’s book betrays his guilt and fear of being exposed for implicating an innocent man. Shortly after Gabriel and his father have reconciled, however, Dr. Santoro is killed in an automobile accident, and his lover, Angelina, betrays him by publicly accusing him of being an impostor and lying about past treachery and deceit. Intrigued by her claims, Gabriel investigates his father’s past and learns that he, too, has contributed to betraying his father and Deresser’s son, Enrique.
Dr. Santoro’s rebuke of his son’s book identifies another theme: how words can shape events. Gabriel’s good intentions in writing about Sara Guterman blind him to the damage he will cause. Dr. Santoro overreacts to Gabriel’s book out of remorse and tries to atone by visiting Enrique, who disappeared after his father’s suicide, reinforcing the theme that words matter, both spoken and suppressed.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
589
The Informers
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Juan Gabriel Vásquez was born in Bogotá, Colombia, in 1973 and left in 1996 to pursue studies at the Sorbonne in Paris. Citing James Joyce’s Ulysses as his inspiration for becoming a writer, Vásquez has published two books. The first, Los Informantes (The Informers), which appeared in Spanish in 2004 and in English in 2009, was the result of a conversation he had with a German Jewish woman. His second novel, Historia secreta de Costaguana, was published in 2007, the same year he was nominated as one of the best young writers of South America, the Bogotá 39. As of 2010, he taught Spanish literature to American students in Barcelona, Spain, where he lived with his wife and children.
A third theme addresses the role of the media in making private matters public. Despite Dr. Santoro’s desire to put things right, his good intentions have disastrous consequences when Angelina presumes she has been abandoned and goes public with what she knows about Santoro. Gabriel, the journalist, quickly appreciates the irony of publishing the truth; however, he questions the final cost.
The Informers was Vásquez’s first book to be published in English, but by that time, in 2009, he was already a successful teacher, writer, and translator. Many critics agreed that he is among the more talented Latin American writers emerging in the early 2000s. Writing in the Independent, Tom Gaisford noted “echoes of Hamlet” in Vásquez’s narrator, Gabriel, and the Sunday Independent called Vásquez a mature John le Carré in the midst of a labyrinthine narrative by Borges, producing a “misty and enigmatic mood of doubt, shadow and secrecy.” In the Washington Post, Jonathan Yardley praised Vásquez’s translator, Anne McLean, for preserving the novel’s “lean yet textured prose in lucid English that manages to echo its Spanish roots.” Other critics modified their praise. Louis Boyan, writing for Riverhead Books, found some of Vásquez’s dialogue “longwinded,” although he finally agreed that the Colombian writer is a “fresh and exciting voice.” In his review in the Guardian, Nick Caisor complimented Vásquez’s decision to break with Latin American tradition, in turning “to history rather than the myth of his country.” So, in all, the novel was praised by many but with reservation by some. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
W Style Vásquez’s novel is a stark departure from the literary conventions long followed by other South American writers such as Jorge Luis Borges and Gabriel García Márquez. Structured as a book within a book, Vásquez uses a straightforward journalistic prose style, complete with question-and-answer format, not unlike a formal interview. The narrator, Gabriel Santoro, is not the central character. It is the secret past of his father, Dr. Gabriel Santoro, that drives the plot. Vásquez narrates the story behind A Life in Exile in neutral language. But then Gabriel writes a fictional account of what his first book failed to address. The journalistic prose shifts to a less formal and less lean narrative voice. As Gabriel speculates about gaps in Sara’s account of the mistreatment of Germans in Colombia, characters such as Konrad and his wife and the mysterious Enrique begin to develop. Gabriel’s hypothetical musings arouse more questions that require a more expansive prose style. Overall, the text sustains the tone of investigative reportage, quite different from the magical realism so typical of many South American authors. Despite the clear and economical journalistic style, the technique of writing a book within another book allows the narrator to share the role of protagonist after Dr. Santoro dies. The first-person narrative voice becomes more self-indulgent, as speculative questions carry the plot to its equally speculative conclusion.
590
W Critical Reception
Boyan, Louis. “Revealing a Colombian Past.” Rev. of The Informers, by Juan Gabriel Vásquez. pastemagazine. com. Paste Magazine 18 Aug. 2009. Web. 27 July 2010. Caisor, Nick. “History’s Shadows.” Rev. of The Informers, by Juan Gabriel Vásquez. guardian.co.uk. Guardian 24 May 2008. Web. 27 July 2010. Friedmann, Max Paul. Nazis and Good Neighbors: The United States Campaign against the Germans of Latin America in World War II. New York: Cambridge UP, 2003. Print. Gaisford, Tom. “When Knowledge Destroys.” Rev. of The Informers, by Juan Gabriel Vásquez. independent. uk.co. Independent 26 Oct. 2008. Web. 29 July 2010. Vásquez, Juan Gabriel. The Informers. Trans. Anne McLean. New York: Riverhead Books, 2009. Print. Yardley, Jonathan. “Wartime Betrayals.” Rev. of The Informers, by Juan Gabriel Vásquez. washingtonpost. com. Washington Post 2 Aug. 2009. Web. 27 July 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Flood, Allison. “Colombia Dominates Independent Foreign Fiction Prize Shortlist.” guardian.co.uk. Guardian 1 Apr. 2009. Web. 30 July 2010. Equally TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Informers
acknowledges both translator and author in prize competition. Gurría-Quintana, Angel. Rev. of The Informers, by Juan Gabriel Vásquez. ft.com. Financial Times 19 May 2008. Web. 30 July 2010. Identifies how treachery and betrayal extend beyond the novel, suggesting everyone is capable of compromising personal ethics under the right circumstances. Long, Karen. “In Juan Gabriel Vásquez’s Intricate The Informers, the Past Isn’t Past at All.” Rev. of The Informers, by Juan Gabriel Vásquez. cleveland.com. Cleveland Plain Dealer 5 Oct. 2009. Web. 27 July 2010. Explains that the amputation of Santoro’s hand is a symbol for a Colombia with a buried history of violence and betrayal. Newton, Maud. “In Bogota, an Intricate Web of Secrets, Betrayal.” Rev. of The Informers, by Juan Gabriel Vásquez. npr.org. National Public Radio 5 Oct. 2009. Web. 30 July 2010. Situates the novel’s force in the protagonist’s curious protest of Santoro’s biography of a family friend and questions the merits of reportage. Rohter, Larry. “In 1940s Colombia, Blacklists and ‘Enemy Aliens.’” Rev. of The Informers, by Juan Gabriel Vásquez. newyorktimes.com. New York Times 2 Aug. 2009. Web. 30 July 2010. Cites U.S. policy in the blacklisting of German nationals as an overlooked topic of World War II. Vásquez, Juan Gabriel. “Beyond Bogotá.” Interview by Richard Lea. guardian.co.uk. Guardian 23 Sept. 2008. Web. 30 July 2010. Features the author’s need to leave Colombia in order to write about it.
For Further Reading
Evans, M. Stanton. Blacklisted by History: The Untold Story of Senator Joe McCarthy and His Fight against America’s Enemies. New York: Three Rivers Press, 2009. Print. Reevaluates the validity of Joseph McCarthy’s lists of suspected communists in the United States. McCarthy’s Senate investigations led to fear and suspicion of communists in the U.S. similar to the anxiety about Nazis in the Colombia of Vásquez’s novel. Mack, Michael. German Idealism and the Jew: The Inner Anti-Semitism of Philosophy and German Jewish Responses. Chicago: U of Chicago P, 2003. Print. Addresses philosophy and anti-Semitism in the tradition of Immanuel Kant and G. W. F. Hegel and explores the nature of dual identities of German Jews. Moore, Michaela Hoenicke. Know Your Enemy: The American Debate on Nazism, 1933-1945. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1999. Print. Explores the long-term political and international effects of the U.S. tendency to distinguish Germans from Nazis. Persico, Anthony. Infamy on Trial. New York: Penguin, 1995. Print. Recounts the story of the trial of Nazi war criminals, and challenges the notion that Nuremburg was a kangaroo court. Shirer, William L. The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich: A History of Nazi Germany. New York: Simon and Schuster, 1995. Print. Acclaimed account of Adolf Hitler’s rise to power and his defeat in World War II.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Doris Plantus-Runey
591
The Inheritance of Loss By Kiran Desai
W Introduction Kiran Desai’s The Inheritance of Loss (2006) is sprawling novel set in the mid-1980s in a crumbling old house in Palimpong, India, in the Himalyas and the restaurant kitchens and temporary living quarters of undocumented workers in New York City. The novel chronicles the story of an orphaned teenage girl, Sai, living with her aloof grandfather, a retired judge, and her growing engagement with the larger world after a failed romance with a budding Nepalese insurgent. Juxtaposed with Sai’s story is that of Biju, the son of the judge’s cook, as he struggles to keep his head above water in Manhattan as an undocumented worker, feeling invisible, homesick and alienated from the privilege and opportunity that surround him every day. Exploring themes of class and ethnic conflict, discrimination, fundamentalism, alienation, and the effects of globalization on commerce and culture, Desai interweaves the stories of Indian and Nepalese characters connected by their frustrating and sometimes humiliating encounters with the West. As Pankaj Mishra states, “Although it focuses on the fate of a few powerless individuals, Kiran Desai’s extraordinary new novel manages to explore, with intimacy and insight, just about every contemporary international issue: globalization, multiculturalism, economic inequality, fundamentalism and terrorist violence.”
W Literary and Historical Context
The Inheritance of Loss is set at the onset of the 1986 Gurkha uprising in the West Bengal hill town of Palimpong, in the majestic Himalayan mountains. Most of the town’s residents are Indians of Nepalese descent, and more than 615,000 live in the northern regions of
West Bengal. Considered a separate ethnic group, the Gurkas are Nepalese in origin and renowned for their fearlessness, superior fighting skills, and warrior mindset. There are approximately 1.4 million Gurkhas living in India. During the colonial period in India, the British military recruited Gurkha fighters for its prestigious Gurkha regiments, which survive today in the British and Indian armies. In 1980, after decades of corruption, neglect, and discrimination in the region, Gurkhas began to demand more power. They formed the Gurkha National Liberation Front (GNLF), a political party aiming to establish a separate Gurkha state in the Nepalese areas of West Bengal. In 1986 a guerrilla war broke out, and three hundred people were killed in the conflict over the next few years. In 1988 the GNLF signed the Darjeeling Hill Accord, a peace treaty that created the Darjeeling Hill Council, an autonomous government body responsible for governing the district of Darjeeling, in exchange for giving up their demands for an independent and separate state. In 2000, however, the GNLF renewed their demands for independence. The experiences of Biju, the undocumented Indian working tirelessly in the restaurant kitchens of New York City and renting filthy, overcrowded living quarters, portrays the unstable and peripatetic existence of illegal immigrants working in the West and the effects of globalization on the world economy. As many immigrants are drawn to the opportunities they might find in America, they are also trapped by poverty, discrimination, and law enforcement to live in the shadows of great wealth and privilege. This stratification between the haves and have-nots is a key theme of The Inheritance of Loss.
W Themes Immigration and globalization are key themes in Desai’s novel. Biju travels to the other side of the world—the kinetic, multicultural chaos of New York City—to pursue economic opportunity but finds only loneliness,
592 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Inheritance of Loss
impotence, poverty, and humiliation. Finally, he decides to go home to visit his father, eventually realizing that the ties of family, tradition, and culture are more important to him than those of economic opportunity. Jemu, like Biju, has been beaten down by his experience with the West. During his years at Cambridge, Jemu was profoundly affected by the racism he felt every day as an Indian in Britain. However, when he returned to India, he perceived his native land as backward and inferior to England. A confirmed Anglophile, he rejected his wife and child and instead longed to return to a civilized past informed by English culture and tradition. As reviewer Ann Harleman observed, “Desai builds her transcontinental romp about the pursuit of a ‘better life’ and the price it almost always exacts to a climax that is much darker than the rollicking tone it’s written in.” Jemu’s preoccupation with British manners and culture obscures his view of the real world, in which outside forces are rising up in the form of Nepali insurgents—a guerrilla force that will invade his crumbling old house to ransack it for guns and food and disturb his sense of order and consideration. Motivated by frustration and anger, these young men are looking to reassert their independence from India and to address what they view as discrimination, corruption, and poor policy foisted upon the Nepali people of West Bengal. In The Inheritance of Loss, class, ethnic, and gender differences figure prominently. Some, like Gyan, struggle to address and reform them through violence; others, like Jemu, look to defend them as tradition and order.
W Style As critic Ann Harleman maintains, The Inheritance of Loss “offers all of the pleasures of traditional narrative in a form and a voice that are utterly fresh.” Employing an omniscient point of view, the novel alternates between Kalimpong and Biju’s life in New York City through the skillful use of meaningful and natural transitions. The narrative also shifts in time—from Jemu’s experiences in England to Sai’s life at her grandfather’s crumbling house in the Himalayan Mountains in the mid-1980s. This double juxtaposition of time and place allows Desai to find parallels between Jemu and Biju’s immigrant experiences as well as reflecting on changing ideas of country, custom, ethnicity, and colonialism as perceived by Jemu as a young man and his granddaughter years later. Although the novel is composed of a number of connected threads, at the conclusion of The Inheritance of Loss Desai is able to deftly bring the various stories together. The Inheritance of Loss can be considered an example of migrant literature. In this genre, fiction explores the challenges of the migrant experience. As Biju works tirelessly in one New York restaurant after another for low wages, hoping to tap into the American dream, he finds
MAJOR CHARACTERS BIJU is the son of Jemubhai’s cook. Looking for opportunity, he makes it to New York City where he toils at a number of subsistence jobs as an undocumented worker. His life is very difficult, marked by frequent job changes, homesickness, hiding from immigration authorities, and frustration at trying to exist in an alien culture. He returns to India to visit, and is captured by the Nepalese insurgents. Luckily, he escapes and is reunited with his father. THE COOK works for Jemubhai and is Biju’s father. When Biju is in America, the two write letters. He adores Sai, and becomes a surrogate father for her. GYAN is descended from a Nepalese Gurkha mercenary. He is hired to tutor Sai in mathematics, and the two youngsters become romantically involved. He eventually rejects her life of privilege, however, and falls in with a group of Nepalese insurgents who are sick of being treated as second-class citizens in their own country. His gang breaks into Jemubhai’s home in search of weapons, and in the process terrorizes the family. When Sai confronts him, he realizes that he has moved on with his life. JEMUBHAI (JEMU) PATEL is an irascible retired judge who lives with his orphaned granddaughter in his once-grand home in Kalimpong, India, in the Himalayan Mountains near Nepal. He was educated at Cambridge University, England, and his years abroad have imbued him with an Anglophile perspective on his native Indian culture. Although his years in England were characterized by racism and postcolonial discrimination, upon his return to India he viewed aspects of his native land as backward and provincial. SAI is an orphaned teenage girl living with her grandfather, a retired judge, in Kalimpong. She has fallen in love with her tutor, a young man from the area named Gyan, who eventually rejects her and her sheltered life. After her house is raided by Nepalese insurgents, she searches out Gyan— only to realize that he has inexorably changed.
that the opportunities he hoped for are too few and far between for a poor, homesick Indian immigrant. Instead of the riches he hoped for, he finds loneliness, poverty, and exhaustion. As a book written by an Indian author—albeit with a strong British and American experience, The Inheritance of Loss is often discussed within the context of other recent Indian works written in English. Many of these works explores the lingering effects of British colonialism and postcolonialism conflict. In Desai’s novel, she also focuses on the Nepali-Indian ethnic conflict exploding in the 1980s in West Bengal, with the Gurkhas seeking their independence from India.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
593
The Inheritance of Loss
The Inheritance of Loss tells the story of Biju, the son of a judge’s cook, as he struggles to survive as an illegal immigrant living and working in New York City. ª David Turnley/Corbis
W Critical Reception Published in 2006, The Inheritance of Loss garnered laudatory reviews from critics and quickly became a bestselling novel. It received both the prestigious Man Booker Prize for best novel in 2006 and the National Book Critics Circle Fiction award in 2007. Critics praise Desai’s rich characters and descriptions, and her deft handling of time and place. Most commentary focuses on the weighty themes in the novel. Pankaj Mishra states that “although it focuses on the fate of a few powerless individuals, Kiran Desai’s extraordinary new novel manages to explore, with intimacy and insight, just about every contemporary international issue: globalization, multiculturalism, economic inequality, fundamentalism and terrorist violence. Despite being set in the mid1980’s, it seems the best kind of post-9/11 novel.” Some reviewers also noted the cynical and depressing tone of the narrative. Mishra found that “though relieved by much humor, The Inheritance of Loss may strike many readers as offering an unrelentingly bitter view,” but concludes that much of the Western world is not aware of the powerlessness and impotence much of the world feels.
594
In that sense, Desai dares to tell the truth and does not imbue her novel with magical realism or unrealistic happy endings. Reviewer Sarah Hughes also touches on Desai’s bold and masterful treatment of political and socioeconomic themes. “The Inheritance of Loss dissects the dream of empire, old and new, and lays bare the idea of colonial modernity. It shows, without judgment, what happens to those who leave for a new life and yet find themselves outcasts both at home and abroad. It is a novel that manages to be both warm-hearted about human nature and clear-sighted about humanity’s flaws.” Desai’s treatment of such themes often inspires comparisons between Desai and the renowned author V. S. Naipaul. As Hughes observes, “The comparisons with Naipaul may be inevitable, but this [novel] proves Desai has a mature, compassionate voice of her own.” BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Harleman, Ann. “Luminous Family Saga Bridges Eras, Cultures.” Boston Globe 4 Jan. 2006. Web. 8 Jan. 2010.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Inheritance of Loss
Hughes, Sarah. “Uncle Potty and Other Guides to the Truth.” Observer 3 Sept. 2006. Web. 8 July 2010. Mishra, Pankaj. Rev. of The Inheritance of Loss, by Kiran Desai. New York Times Book Review 9 Feb. 2006. Web. 8 July 2010. Roy, Sandip. “Empires, Families in Flux.” San Francisco Chronicle 26 Feb. 2006. Web. 8 July 2010. Walter, Natasha. “Mutt and the Maths Tutor.” Guardian [London] 26 Aug. 2006. Web. 8 July 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Barton, Laura. “A Passage from India.” Guardian [London] 12 Oct. 2006. Web. 8 July 2010. A profile of Desai written right after The Inheritance of Loss was awarded the Booker Prize. Desai reveals her mixed feelings upon receiving the award. Ghosh, Tapan K., ed. The Fiction of Kiran Desai: Focus on The Inheritance of Loss. New Delhi: Prestige Books, 2009. Print. Full-length study of Desai’s novels, paying particular attention to The Inheritance of Loss.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Kiran Desai was born on September 3, 1971, in New Delhi, India. Her mother was the noted Indian novelist Anita Desai, and Kiran spent her early years living with her family outside of New Delhi and in Kalimpong, in the Himalayas—a setting she would use later in her novel The Inheritance of Loss. She went to school at St. Joseph’s Convent in Kalimpong, but at the age of fifteen she was sent to England to continue her education. After a year, she moved to the United States to finish high school in Massachusetts. After graduation, she enrolled at Bennington College in Vermont, and then studied at the creative writing program at Hollins University in Roanoke, Virginia. It was there she began writing her first novel, Hullabaloo in the Guava Orchard (1998). She had gotten inspiration for the book from a newspaper article on a hermit in India who lived for many years in a tree. Desai eventually transferred to the writing program at Columbia University, where she received her MFA degree. Her second novel, The Inheritance of Loss, was published to critical acclaim, receiving both the prestigious Man Booker Award for best novel in 2006 and the National Book Critics Circle Fiction award in 2007. She currently lives in Brooklyn, New York.
In The Inheritance of Loss, a teenage girl named Sai lives with her grandfather, a retired judge whose experiences in the Western world have led him to view his native India as “too messy for justice.” ª Brian A. Vikander/Corbis
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
595
The Inheritance of Loss
Kirchner, Bharti. “The Inheritance of Loss: A Moving Tale of Honesty and Horror.” Seattle Times 20 Jan. 2006. Web. 8 July 2010. Laudatory review of The Inheritance of Loss that commends the novel’s humor, honesty, and humanity. Nimsarkar, P. D., ed. Kiran Desai, the Novelist: An Anthology of Critical Essays. New Delhi: Creative Books, 2008. Print. A volume of critical essays focusing on Desai’s two novels: Hullabaloo in the Guava Orchard and The Inheritance of Loss. Ramesh, Randeep. “Book-Burning Threat over Town’s Portrayal in Booker-Winning Novel.” Guardian [London] (2 Nov. 2006). Web. 8 July 2010. Discusses the reaction to Desai’s portrayal of Nepalese people in Kalimpong, India, where the novel was set. Vijh, Surekha. “Kiran Desai: Icon of the New Breed of Writers.” World and I 23.4 (Apr. 2008). Academic OneFile. Web. 7 July 2010. Identifies Desai as representative of an emerging breed of authors who are multicultural, multiethnic, and multiracial. Gale Resources
Alessio, Carolyn. “Kiran Desai.” British Writers: Supplement 15. Ed. Jay Parini. New York: Scribner’s, 2010. Literature Resource Center. Web. 5 July 2010. “Kiran Desai.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2007. Literature Resource Center. Web. 5 July 2010. Open Web Sources
Gurkhas.com is an informational resource for Gurkhas serving in the British military. The site has a picture and video gallery, history, and forums for Gurkhas or those interested in the history of the Gurkha community in England. http://www.ghurkhas.com Information on the Indian Himalayas can be found at Indiasite.com. The site discusses geographical attractions and offers pictures of the majestic mountain range. http://www.indiasite.com/land/ himalayas.html
interactive tour of Ellis Island, publish your own story online, and explore the immigration history of different ethnic groups in the United States. http:// www.teacher.scholastic.com/activities/immigration For Further Reading
Adiga, Aravind. The White Tiger. New York: Free Press, 2008. Print. Chronicles the story of an Indian driver and his tortured relationship with his privileged boss, set against an India beset by class differences and economic stratification. Desai, Kiran. Hullabaloo in the Guava Orchard. New York: Atlantic Monthly Press, 1998. Print. Desai’s first novel follows the adventures of an Indian mystic who lives in a tree. Farwell, Byron. The Gurkhas. New York: Norton 1984. Print. An entertaining and romantic study of the Gurkhas, focusing on their skills as warriors, history, and major conflicts. Guha, Ramachandra. India after Gandhi: The History of the World’s Largest Democracy. New York: Ecco, 2007. Print. A history of the political, cultural, and social history of India after the death of Mahatma Gandhi and offers biographical sketches on major political figures of the era. Naipaul, V. S. A Bend in the River. New York: Knopf, 1979. Print. Mentioned prominently in The Inheritance of Loss, Naipaul’s novel chronicles the encounter of traditional Africa with the modern West. Orner, Peter, ed. Underground America: Narratives of Undocumented Lives. San Francisco: McSweeney’s, 2008. Print. A collection of oral histories from undocumented workers struggling to survive in America, offering a first-person look at the immigrant experience. Rushdie, Salman. Midnight’s Children. New York: Knopf, 1981. Print. A profound influence on Desai’s work, Rushdie chronicles the story of two infants switched at birth in India at the stroke of India’s independence day.
First-person stories of the immigrant experience can be found on the Scholastic Teachers website. Get an
596
Margaret Haerens
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Inkheart Trilogy By Cornelia Funke
W Introduction Inkheart is the first novel in a metafictional fantasy trilogy written by German writer Cornelia Funke. Inkheart was originally published in Germany as Tintenherz, in 2003. Meggie’s father, Mo, owns a terrible secret: when he reads books aloud, the characters come to life—but real people are physically drawn into the books. An evil villain, Capricorn, hopes to exploit in Mo’s talents. To escape, Mo takes a book, Inkheart, and flees to visit Elinor, the aunt of his wife, Teresa, who has been missing for years. While Elinor secretly borrows Mo’s book, Mo is captured by Capricorn, setting Meggie on a quest to get her father back—and possibly save her mother. As the story progresses, Meggie discovers her father’s talent, and realizes that while Capricorn belongs in Inkworld, the world of Inkheart, her mother, who belongs with her, has been drawn into the novel in Mo's place. Meggie and her father seek out the help of Fenoglio, the author of Inkheart, to destroy the evil Capricorn once and for all. When the story continues in Inkspell, Dustfinger, a character from Fenoglio’s novel Inkheart, is still searching for a way back to Inkworld. When he finally finds someone who can help him, his apprentice and foster son, Farid, is left in Meggie’s world. Farid believes that Meggie possesses the power to get him home, and when the two of them go to Inkworld, Meggie’s parents follow. When they arrive in Inkworld, they find that Fenoglio, who settled in Inkworld at the end of Inkheart, has lost control over his creation. As Fenoglio attempts to rewrite reality, having Meggie, who has inherited her father’s gift, read his revisions aloud, more and more complications arise, and the world changes beyond Fengolio’s imagining. In the meantime, competing scribe Orpheus makes inroads in his attempts to take over Inkworld, and by the
beginning of the last novel in the trilogy, Inkdeath, he has succeeded. Mo has fallen into the role of Bluejay, a vigilante that Fenoglio based on him, risking the ire of the world’s villains, including Adderhead. The world has become darker and more violent, and Meggie has become both more mature and involved in a potential romance, as two swains compete for her affections. As the trilogy progresses, the themes and content both become more mature. The final book is aimed more toward teens than the children who were originally the target audience of Inkheart. With the publication of Inkdeath in English translation in 2008, the story drew to a final conclusion.
W Literary and Historical Context
Following the success of the Harry Potter series by British author J. K. Rowling, the first book of which was published in 1997, Inkheart and its sequels were introduced to an audience of older children and young teens already comfortable with reading enormous tomes, according to reviewer Peter Sieruta. Other large-scale fantasy trilogies and series appeared on the market at roughly the same time, such as the Bartimeaus trilogy by Jonathan Stroud, the Inheritance Cycle by Christopher Paolini, and the Twilight novels by Stephenie Meyer. Inkheart and its sequels also draw connections with a wide scope of previously written, similar works by quoting them at the beginning of each chapter. Children’s writers mentioned in the books include Maurice Sendak, Roald Dahl, Shel Silverstein, J. K. Rowling, Philip Pullman, and Kate DiCamillo. Writers of adult works, from William Shakespeare to Margaret Atwood to Pablo Neruda, are also quoted or mentioned within the pages.
597 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Inkheart Trilogy
MAJOR CHARACTERS ADDERHEAD is one of the major villains in Inkworld—an immortal tyrant who Mo, as the Bluejay, is determined to destroy. THE BLUEJAY is Mo’s alter ego in Inkworld. Based on Mo, Fenoglio writes the Bluejay as a vigilante who fights against the oppression of Adderhead. When Mo comes to Inkworld, he is mistaken for the Bluejay, and eventually ends up taking on the persona himself. CAPRICORN is the primary villain in Inkheart, both in the real novel and the fictional one written by Fenoglio. Summoned accidentally into the real world by Mo, Capricorn is determined to use Mo to help him rule both the real world and Inkworld. DUSTFINGER, a fire-eater, was accidentally summoned into the real world by Mo, and he longs to return to Inkworld. ELINOR is Meggie’s book-collector aunt, who sets Meggie’s quest into motion by “borrowing” Mo’s copy of Inkheart without Mo’s permission. FARID, Dustfinger’s apprentice and adopted son, is left behind when Dustfinger returns to Inkworld. FENOGLIO is the original author of Inkheart, who goes to live in Inkworld when Capricorn is defeated. MEGGIE, the heroine of the novels, begins the series as a twelve-year-old girl. When her father is kidnapped by Capricorn, she discovers that he has the ability to pull characters and objects out of books when he reads them aloud. As Meggie grows up, she realizes that she has a similar power to shape reality through reading aloud. MO, Meggie’s father, is a bookbinder with the ability to summon objects and characters out of books when he reads aloud. He sets the action of the series in motion, first by sending his wife inadvertently into Inkworld, and then by summoning Capricorn into existence. When Mo and Teresa go to rescue Meggie in Inkworld, he is mistaken for the Bluejay, a vigilante. TERESA is Mo’s wife and Meggie’s mother. She is stuck in Inkworld after her husband accidentally sent her there by reading aloud.
W Themes The power of words and the battle between good and evil are the two most dominant themes in the Inkheart Trilogy. Mo’s and Meggie’s ability to read characters “out” of their books, and Fenoglio and Orpheus’s competing to rewrite Inkworld in their own image, are examples of how the impact of words is emphasized. As the series progresses, it
598
In this photo, author Cornelia Funke accepts an award for her contributions to German literature, which includes her Inheart Trilogy. ª UWE ZUCCHI/epa/Corbis
also becomes clear that “wordcraft can create unintended circumstances,” according to reviewer Jean Boreen. Fenoglio tries to fix bits of the story as it spirals out of his control, but each change he introduces results in unintended consequences. According to Carolyn Phelan of Booklist, once Meggie journeys to Inkworld, “she realizes the consequences of her choice and the seeming impossibility of putting things right in either place.” Words and meaning, Funke seems to imply, can change. The battle between good and evil also becomes more complicated and nuanced as the series progresses. In Inkheart, Meggie and Mo clearly represent good, while Capricorn is evil. This does not mean that the heroes always make the right choices: Mo has lied to Meggie for nine years, both about his talent and about her mother, putting them both in danger. The tone of the books becomes darker as Inkworld itself becomes a more violent place. Similarly, ethical decisions that the characters must make are less clear, such as Mo’s choice to take on the role of the freedom fighter, the Bluejay. As decisions become harder to make, the characters look at the world TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Inkheart Trilogy
in a more complicated way. Their decisions are less a matter of choosing good over evil, and evolve into questions about how to shape their own destinies.
W Style While Funke makes good use of traditional fantasy and adventure tropes in her cycle, it is the metafictional references that draw the most attention. The characters continually play with words, and with the nature of their story, twisting and turning the narrative as it builds, “sometimes at cross-purposes," as Francine Levitov observes. Each chapter opens with a quote that offers insight into the action of that chapter. Funke draws on a wealth of literary inspirations, and gives Meggie a love of reading that allows the author to play with stories inside of other stories in a fuller way. The novels follow a trilogy format. Funke brings her first novel to an almost self-contained conclusion, allowing only a few loose threads. The second novel ends with a cliffhanger. At the end of Inkspell, Boreen notes, Funke has “resolve[ed] a few loose ends while setting the stage for the conflicts that must be resolved concerning the fates of the main characters.” All those threads are tied together at the end of Inkdeath. The novels become more mature as the series continues, straddling the border between children’s literature and books for young adults or adult readers. Occasionally, critics, such as the reviewer for Publishers Weekly, bemoan the slow pace, saying that Funke “sputters for a hundred pages filling in backstory” in Inkdeath. Others, such as the critic for Kirkus Reviews, found that while she “takes her time with her tale,” the slower pace serves to heighten the sense of menace created by the villains.
W Critical Reception The Inkheart Trilogy garnered positive reviews at the time of its publication, and the first two novels won awards in both Germany and the United States. Inkheart was so popular that it was optioned for a movie, starring Brendan Fraser and award-winning actress Helen Mirren. Eileen Wright, in Library Media Connection, writes of Inkheart, “There is adventure, suspense, anxiety, hope, love, and strong family bonds that all strengthen this adventure about the love of reading books.” Abby McGanney Nolan, reviewing for the New York Times Book Review, calls Meggie a “spirited heroine whose perilous circumstances and love of stories have her pondering and quoting” from a wide variety of literary pieces, and considers the story “sprinkled with some magical fairy dust of its own.” In a starred review, a contributor to Kirkus Reviews also praises Meggie as “a stalwart heroine who never loses her childish nature,” and attributes partial credit for the “vivid images and heartstopping language” to translator Anthea Bell.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Cornelia Funke was trained and educated as a social worker. She worked in that profession for three years while she was enrolled in a book illustration program. Once she finished her course, Funke became a full-time illustrator, working primarily on board games and book art. Although she had no plans to write professionally, Funke was frustrated by what she felt was a lack of imagination in the books she was illustrating. This prompted her to pen her own tales. Her first novel, Monstergeschichten, was published in 1993, and several novels for young readers followed. It was not until 2002, however, that Funke’s work made its English-language debut. A young German fan wrote a letter to Chicken House Books in England, complaining that she could only read her favorite books in German, not in English. The editors at Chicken House were intrigued, and Funke’s first translated title, The Thief Lord, became a best seller. Since then, many of Funke’s other novels have been translated into English and have proven equally commercially popular, including the Inkheart Trilogy, Dragon Rider, Igraine the Brave, and Reckless. Funke continues to write and illustrate, and has self-illustrated many of her titles.
Inkspell is considered “equally engaging” in Jean Boreen’s review for the Journal of Adolsecent and Adult Literacy, and the book was selected for Booklist’s top ten fantasy books for youth in 2006. Carolyn Phelan in Booklist calls Inkspell a “stronger book than its predecessor.” A Kirkus contributor states that “Funke delivers more than enough action, romance, tragedy, villainy and emotion to keep readers turning the pages” in her second installment. Inkdeath, however, had many threads to wrap up, and a cast of 114 characters that required an eight-page appendix to help readers follow their stories. Critics complained of the slower pacing and overly complicated plot, while noting that the conclusion “should provide ardent fans of the series with both comfort and closure” (Hunt). A Kirkus Reviews critic finds the “storytelling is as compelling as ever,” but bemoans a shift in audience; Inkdeath, the critic feels, is for teens and adults, not for children. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Boreen, Jean. Rev. of Inkheart, by Cornelia Funke. Journal of Adolescent and Adult Literacy 47.5 (2004): 433+. Print. Hunt, Jonathan. Rev. of Inkdeath, by Cornelia Funke. Horn Book Magazine 85.1 (Jan.-Feb. 2009): 91. Print. ———. Rev. of Inkspell, by Cornelia Funke. Journal of Adolescent and Adult Literacy 50.1 (2006): 79+. Print. Rev. of Inkdeath, by Cornelia Funke. Kirkus Reviews 1 Sept. 2008. Print.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
599
Inkheart Trilogy
Rev. of Inkdeath, by Cornelia Funke. Publishers Weekly 22 Sept. 2008: 59. Print. Levitov, Francine. Rev. of Inkspell, by Cornelia Funke. Kliatt May 2006: 44. Print. Mattson, Jennifer. “Top 10 Fantasy Books for Youth.” Booklist 15 May 2006: 57. Print. Nolan, Abby McGanney. “Children’s Books.” New York Times Book Review 21 Dec. 2003: 17. Print. Phelan, Carolyn. Rev. of Inkspell, by Cornelia Funke. Booklist 1 Oct. 2005: 52. Print. Sieruta, Peter D. Review of Inkheart by Cornelia Funke. Horn Book Magazine 80.1 (Jan.-Feb. 2004): 81-82. Print. Rpt. Children’s Literature Review. Ed. Tom Burns. Vol. 145. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Wright, Eileen. Review of Inkheart by Cornelia Funke. Library Media Connection 22.4 (Jan. 2004): 64-5. Print. Rpt. in Children’s Literature Review. Ed. Tom Burns. Vol. 145. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Boreen, Jean. “‘Blurring’ the Borders between Reality and Fantasy: Considering the Work of Cornelia Funke.” ALAN Review 32.1 (Fall 2004): 26-31. Print. Rpt. Children’s Literature Review. Ed. Tom Burns. Vol. 145. Detroit: Gale, 2009. Along with an interview with Funke, Boreen’s essay includes a discussion of the way that fantasy literature allows readers to examine the real world, using Funke’s novels as examples. She concludes that the personal growth of the characters in Funke’s books is the strongest part of the novels. Zvirin, Stephanie. “Inkspell.” Booklist 1 Dec. 2005: 73. Print. Zvirin reviews the audiobook version of Inkspell, narrated by Brendan Fraser. She discusses the story, as well as what Fraser’s vocal choices and accents add to the telling. Gale Resources
“Cornelia Funke.” Contemporary Authors Online. Detroit: Gale, 2010. Open Web Sources
Though Funke has no personal home page, the Cornelia Funke Fans website, available in both English and German, is run by her sister to keep fans up to date on the latest news. The site is not only a place for information about Funke’s works, but is a community where fans can interact with each other and converse about the worlds in Funke’s novels. http://www .corneliafunkefans.com/ American publisher Scholastic has an author profile page for Funke, offering information about Funke’s biography as well as her worlds. Pages exist for the
600
Inkworld books, Funke’s Ghosthunters series, and other novels that have been published in English translation. http://www.scholastic.com/cornelia funke/bio.htm For book groups, Scholastic has also created a discussion guide page, helping bring up interesting questions and topics related to the three novels. Sections on characters, themes, and setting open conversations, and exercises for helping teachers use the books in class are given as well. http://www2.scholastic.com/ browse/collateral.jsp?id=36165 Information about the film adaptation of Inkheart is available on the Inkheart Movie website. There is a gallery of images from the film, as well as profiles of the cast and filmmakers, and several wallpapers, icons, and other extras are available for download. http:// www.inkheartmovie.com/ For Further Reading
Funke, Cornelia. Dragon Rider. Trans. Anthea Bell. New York: Chicken House, 2004. Print. Another of Funke’s fantasy novels in translation, Dragon Rider tells the story of Firedrake, a young dragon who lives in the Scottish Highlands, the last remaining home of dragons on Earth. When that home is threatened, Firedrake and his brownie friend Sorrel travel to the legendary home of the silver dragons, where Firedrake and the other dragons might be safe from humans. Lin, Grace. Where the Mountain Meets the Moon. New York: Little, Brown, 2009. Print. Minli believes desperately that a journey to visit the Old Man of the Moon can save her family from poverty. Following clues provided by talking goldfish, she sets out on her quest, much to the dismay of her parents. Several folktales from Minli’s world are interspersed with her journey, layering stories upon stories—many of which, it turns out, are true after all. The novel was a Newbery Honor book and the winner of the Mythopoeic Fantasy Award in Children’s Literature in 2010. Mantchev, Lisa. Eyes Like Stars. New York: Feiwel and Friends, 2009. Print. Orphan Beatrice “Bertie” Shakespeare Smith has lived in the Theater Illuminata for as long as she can remember. But when she is questioned about what she contributes to a world where the characters from different plays are summoned into the world by the stage manager, and the set changes are magically instantaneous, she decides to take on the role of director in order to stay in the only home she has ever known. McCaughrean, Geraldine, trans. One Thousand and One Arabian Nights. New York: Oxford University Press, 1987. Print. King Shahryar does not trust women, and so he marries a new wife every day, killing her the next morning. This process continues until TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Inkheart Trilogy
Shaharazad becomes his wife, and tells him such fascinating tales that he cannot bear to kill her. A classic collection of stories within stories that emphasizes the transformative power of tales, One Thousand and One Arabian Nights, as translated by McCaughrean, has been in print since its original hardcover publication. A paperback edition was released in 2000. Adaptations
Inkheart. Dir. Iain Softley. Perf. Brendan Fraser, Helen Mirren, and Jim Broadbent. New Line Cinema, 2008. Film. The first book of the trilogy premiered in
2008, spurring on several movie tie-in titles that further adapt the novel for younger readers. Tintenblut. Produced in Hannover, Germany, 2006. Play. Inkspell, titled Tintenblut in its original German form, was adapted as a play in Germany the year after it was released as a novel. Tintenherz. Produced in Bonn, Germany, 2006. Play. The original German version of Inkheart was adapted as a musical play and performed in Funke’s native Germany.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Alana Abbott
601
The Invention of Hugo Cabret By Brian Selznick
W Introduction The Invention of Hugo Cabret tells the story of a twelve-yearold orphan living in a train station in Paris in 1931. Hugo is trying to fix a badly damaged automaton, hoping it will give him a message from his dead father. In the process of fixing the automaton, Hugo becomes entangled with Georges Méliès, a former filmmaker who lost his dreams when his studio closed ten years before. Hugo and Méliès, reluctant at first, help each other discover and recover their dreams and, therefore, shape their futures. The fictional Méliès is based on a real person who was a pioneer filmmaker in the early days of motion pictures. When it was published in 2007, Brian Selznick’s novel introduced a new format for storytelling. Aimed at an audience of nine to twelve years old, The Invention of Hugo Cabret has 158 illustrations and movie stills (316 pages) in a 533-page book. Not quite a graphic novel or a picture book, this cinematic format and the story it tells captured the attention of readers and critics. Selznick’s novel won the Caldecott Honor in 2008.
W Literary and Historical Context
The Invention of Hugo Cabret is set in Paris during the year 1931 and tells a fantastical tale concerning the historical pioneer filmmaker, Georges Méliès. Motion pictures were invented by brothers Auguste and Louis Lumière, who debuted their first movie on December 28, 1895, to an audience of thirty-three people. Méliès was famous in his day for making movies with wildly fantastic images and plots, a strong contrast to the documentaries produced by the Lumières. Méliès was a performing magician and used
his theater to show his films; he was called a cinemagician, or a magician of the cinema. He made over five hundred movies, including A Trip to the Moon (1902), his most famous piece and the first science fiction film. As the film industry grew, larger companies squeezed Méliès out of business. An impoverished Méliès sold toys at Montparnasse Station, but his creative work was rediscovered during the 1920s due to the growing surrealist art movement. He was awarded a Legion of Honor in 1931, the highest civilian award bestowed by the French government. Inspired many years after seeing A Trip to the Moon, Selznick wrote The Invention of Hugo Cabret as a way to tell Georges Méliès’s story, notes critic Lewis Jacobs.
W Themes The Invention of Hugo Cabret is about the importance of dreams. Dreams are not merely the provenance of childhood or of fantasy. Inspiration is drawn from dreams, and this inspiration propels individuals toward the creation of new technology, works of art and literature, and theories. In his novel, Selznick emphasizes that mechanical capability (Hugo) is not enough to survive; magic is also needed. Hugo’s salvation lies not with the automaton through which he desperately hopes to get a message. Rather it comes through its creator, Georges Méliès, once a magician and filmmaker—a dream maker. In the process of drawing Méliès back to his creative life, Hugo is reborn as a magician also: Professor Alcofrisbas. In this novel, dreams provide inspiration and motivation. Méliès, the first person to make films for entertainment, is the ultimate dreamer and fantasist, but his failure to succeed in business has crushed all that he once loved. He and Hugo complement each other, save each other, and thus achieve their dreams.
602 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Invention of Hugo Cabret
W Style Selznick uses a framing device in The Invention of Hugo Cabret. A framing device is a structural device that occurs at the beginning and end of a story, giving the reader a sense of closure when the story ends and the element is repeated. In Selznick’s novel, this element is Professor Alcofrisbas, who provides an introduction and is the voice of the final chapter. In addition to framing the story, Professor Alcofrisbas gives the reader a surprising insight at the end of the novel, heightening the sense of drama and closure. Symbolism, or the use of objects or images to represent abstract ideas, is also present in The Invention of Hugo Cabret. Clocks represent time, which in Hugo’s case, is running out. When he stops winding the clocks in the train station, the drama of the story increases as the audience anticipates what might happen to Hugo once the clocks begin to break down. Another symbol in this novel is light, which represents invention. The light of the movie projector is mentioned repeatedly; it summons those who want to see new and marvelous sights. In the painting of Prometheus at the film academy, the figure is blasting white light from his finger instead of fire, drawing an association between humankind’s consciousness and creativity and the growing movie industry. Méliès rediscovers his work while sitting amid the flickering light of a projector showing one of his films.
W Critical Reception Sue Corbett, in an author profile for Publishers Weekly, described how Selznick’s ideas for The Invention of Hugo Cabret increased from a 150-page chapter book with a single illustration per chapter to a 533-page novel with over 300 pages of illustrations. Neither a graphic novel nor a picture book, Hugo Cabret was lauded by reviewers for excellent storytelling, engaging illustrations, and especially for the unusual text-and-picture combination that heralded a new literary form. “The book, an homage to early filmmakers as dreammakers, is elegantly designed to resemble the flickering experience of silent film melodramas,” wrote a reviewer for Kirkus Reviews. John Schwartz, in an article for the New York Times Book Review, agreed, describing Selznick’s novel as “much more than a graphic novel: it is more like a silent film on paper.” Roger Sutton summed it up in the Horn Book Magazine: “The interplay between the illustrations . . . and the text is complete genius.” The Invention of Hugo Cabret was awarded the Caldecott Medal, the top award for illustration, in 2008. A movie adaptation directed by Martin Scorsese was filmed in 2010 and scheduled for release in 2011.
MAJOR CHARACTERS PROFESSOR H. ALCOFRISBAS is a magician and Hugo’s alter ego. CLAUDE CABRET is an alcoholic timekeeper who works at the train station in Paris. HUGO CABRET, the main character of this novel, is an imaginative twelve-year-old boy who is good with clocks and other mechanical objects. ISABELLE, the ward of Georges’s Méliès, is Hugo’s friend. GEORGES MÉLIÈS, a toymaker with a booth at the train station, has a mysterious past. JEANNE MÉLIÈS is Georges’s wife and wants to keep him safe from his past. ETIENNE PRUCHON is a film student who befriends Isabelle and Hugo. STATION INSPECTOR keeps the train station running smoothly. RENE TABARD is Etienne’s professor at film school.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
“Biography for Georges Méliès.” IMDB.com. Internet Movie Database Web. 30 July 2010. Corbett, Sue. “Drawn to Cinema.” Rev. of The Invention of Hugo Cabret, by Brian Selznick. Publishers Weekly 19 Feb. 2007: 64-5. Print. Jacobs, Lewis. “Honor Where It Is Due: A Belated Tribute to Méliès, Who Made the First ‘Story’ Films.” New York Times 3 Apr. 1938: 158. Print. Lanzoni, Rémi Fournier. “Georges Méliès and the Adventure of the Film 32-Studio.” French Cinema. New York: Continuum International, 2005: 32-6. Print. Mack, Tracy. “The Amazing Brian Selznick: A Profile in Three Acts.” Horn Book Magazine 84.4 (2008): 407-11. Print. “Martin Scorsese’s London Film Hugo Cabret Recruits an All-Star Cast.” NME.com. NME 1 July 2010. Web. 29 July 2010. Riding, Alan. “The Birthplace Celebrates Film’s Big 1-0-0.” New York Times 28 Feb. 1995. Print. Schwartz, John. “Children’s Books.” Rev. of The Invention of Hugo Cabret, by Brian Selznick. New York Times Book Review 11 Mar. 2007: 16. Print.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
603
The Invention of Hugo Cabret
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Brian Selznick was born on July 14, 1966, in East Brunswick, New Jersey. He graduated from the Rhode Island School of Design in 1988 and began his career in children’s books working for the specialty store Eeyore’s Books for Children in New York City. Selznick wrote and illustrated his first book, Houdini’s Box (1991), and went on to illustrate over twenty other books. He won the 2001 Caldecott Honor for his illustrations in Barbara Kerley’s book The Dinosaurs of Waterhouse Hawkins and the 2008 Caldecott Medal for The Invention of Hugo Cabret. Besides writing and illustrating, Selznick enjoyed performing and put on several productions as a puppeteer. As of 2010, Selznick divided his time between Brooklyn, New York, and San Diego, California.
“Selznick, Brian: The Invention of Hugo Cabret.” Rev. of The Invention of Hugo Cabret, by Brian Selznick. Kirkus Reviews 15 Jan. 2007: 81. Print. Selznick, Brian. The Invention of Hugo Cabret. New York: Scholastic, 2007. Print. Sutton, Roger. “The Invention of Hugo Cabret.” Rev. of The Invention of Hugo Cabret, by Brian Selznick. Horn Book Magazine 83.2 (2007): 173-75. Print. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
“Caldecott Stunner.” School Library Journal 54.2 (Feb. 2008): 13. Print. Reports reactions from members of the American Library Association upon hearing the news that Selznick’s unusual novel won the Caldecott Medal.
In this photo, a man works on an automaton, much like the one Hugo tries to repair in the novel The Invention of Hugo Cabret. ª Bettmann/ Corbis
604
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Invention of Hugo Cabret
Hayn, Judith A. “The Invention of Hugo Cabret.” Rev. of The Invention of Hugo Cabret, by Brian Selznick. Journal of Adolescent and Adult Literacy 51.2 (2007): 189. Print. Praises Selznick’s creative blend of text and illustration to create a new kind of graphic novel. Mattson, Jennifer. “The Invention of Hugo Cabret.” Booklist 1 Jan. 2007: 97. Print. Highlights the cinematic influences in Selznick’s novel, from the illustrations and movie stills to the character of Méliès. McGillis, Roderick. “Fantasy as Epanalepsis: ‘An Anticipation of Retrospection.’” Papers 18.2 (2008): 7-14. Print. Discusses fantasy and retrospection in the context of Selznick’s novel, including how Hugo uses the past to reinvent his future. Shea, Peter. “Thinking in Stories.” Thinking 19.2/3 (2009): 1. Print. Emphasizes the viewpoint of young readers and how they will interpret fantasy and reality in Selznick’s novel. Ward, Elizabeth. “A Dazzling New Book Is Less than Meets the Eye.” WashingtonPost.com. Washington Post 25 Mar. 2007. Web. 2 Aug. 2010. Criticizes the novel as flat and uninspired, relying on its gimmick of illustrations to impress readers. Gale Resources
“Selznick, Brian 1966–.” Something about the Author. Ed. Lisa Kumar. Vol. 171. Detroit: Gale, 2007. 17075. Gale Virtual Reference Library. Web. 2 Aug. 2010. Open Web Sources
The Invention of Hugo Cabret has its own Web site at http://www.theinventionofhugocabret.com/index. htm with information about the novel, its author, historical background of the story, and news. It includes links to video interviews and a slideshow of the novel’s opening sequence. A Trip to the Moon (Le voyage dans la luna), by Georges Méliès, is the first science fiction film ever made. Filmed in 1902, it is approximately twelve minutes long and tells the story of a group of astronomers who travel to the moon in a rocket, discover unfriendly natives, and return home just in the nick of time. A narrated, digitized video of this silent film is available from the Internet Archive, http://www.archive.org/ details/Levoyagedanslalune
The Franklin Institute of Philadelphia is home to a working automaton that inspired the one in Selznick’s novel. Created around 1800 by Henri Maillardet, a Swiss man who worked on clocks and other machines, this automaton was damaged in a fire and, after being repaired, created four different pictures and three poems. Video of the automaton in action can be seen on the institute’s Web site, http://www.fi.edu/ learn/sci-tech/automaton/automaton.php?cts= instrumentation For Further Reading
Clee, Paul. Before Hollywood: From Shadow Play to the Silver Screen. New York: Clarion Books, 2005. Print. Examines the artistic and scientific techniques and inventions that predated the invention of motion pictures. Includes a chapter about Méliès. Ezra, Elizabeth. Georges Méliès: The Birth of the Auteur. Manchester: Manchester UP, 2000. Print. Closely studies Méliès’s innovative films and seeks to disprove some myths about his career as a filmmaker. Gaiman, Neil. The Graveyard Book. New York: HarperCollins, 2008. Print. About a young boy who is adopted by ghosts and grows up in a graveyard while trying to solve the mystery of who murdered his parents and sister. Won the 2009 Newbery Medal and Hugo Award. Priest, Christopher. The Prestige. New York: Tor, 2006. Print. About two rival magicians in Victorian-era London competing to be the best in their field. Won the 1996 World Fantasy Award and was made into a feature film in 2006. Selznick, Brian. “Caldecott Medal Acceptance.” Horn Book Magazine 84.4 (2008): 393-406. Print. Shares his inspiration and motivation to write Hugo’s story. ———. Interview by Michele Norris. All Things Considered. National Public Radio. 9 Feb. 2007. Web. 19 January 2011. Explores the author’s childhood, experience with magic, and desire to Hugo’s story. Wood, Gaby. Edison’s Eve: A Magical History of the Quest for Mechanical Life. New York: Anchor, 2003. Print. Talks about Méliès’s lost automata collection.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Carol Ullmann
605
The Janissary Tree By Jason Goodwin
W Introduction In The Janissary Tree, the Sultan of the Ottoman Empire is planning to modernize his realm, introducing greater innovations and replacing the traditional military with a more Western-style force. When several soldiers of the new army disappear, Yashim Togalu, a eunuch, is asked to investigate. He is able to link the disappearances with two other crimes: the murder of a girl from the Sultan’s harem, and the robbery of jewels belonging to the Sultan’s mother. As a eunuch, Yashim can go where normal men cannot, including the Sultan’s harem. As an unassuming, plain-looking individual, Yashim blends in and walks unnoticed, allowing him to gather the clues needed to solve the mystery. Along with his own investigative skills, he relies on help from Preen, a köçek dancer who was castrated in his youth and dresses as a woman, and Palieski, the Polish ambassador to the sultanate. With their help, he unravels a plot of the janissaries—elite traditional guardians of the Sultan who had supposedly been disbanded ten years before—to stage a coup against the Emperor. The Janissary Tree received an Edgar Allan Poe Award for best novel in 2007.
W Literary and Historical Context
The Ottoman Empire lasted for nearly six hundred years, beginning in the fourteenth century. When the Christian Byzantine Empire collapsed, the Turks expanded their territory, which had stretched across the Anatolian peninsula, through southeastern Europe and into northern Africa. Though the majority of the Ottomans were Muslims, the strongest force within the military of the empire was a standing army of Christians called the janissaries (Sansal). The force was originally formed in the 1300s from captives taken during the Crusades; the
soldiers were forced to provide military service as tribute. This same group was transformed into an elite group that followed the sultan exclusively. Due to their training and excellent performance, many janissaries were granted land or administrative positions within the government. Though the Ottoman Empire was a strong government, it did not keep up with the technology developed in Europe’s industrial revolution, and thus as Europe expanded its influence, the Ottoman Empire struggled to adapt and keep up. The Janissary Tree takes place as the influence of the Ottoman Empire, which collapsed in 1922 (Hooker), is waning, struggling to balance tradition with new, modern ways of doing things that made other nations gain in power. The Janissary Tree was published in 2007, shortly after Turkish author Orhan Pamuk received the Nobel Prize in Literature. In 2005, Pamuk made statements about the mass killings of Armenians and Kurds during the rule of the Ottoman Empire—Pamuk’s statements resulted in his being charged as a criminal for insulting Turkey (Contemporary Authors). The charges were dropped in 2006, the same year Pamuk was awarded the Nobel Prize. Many of Pamuk’s novels are set in Turkey, including My Name Is Red, published in English in 2001, which features a murder that takes place during the Ottoman Empire.
W Themes The Janissary Tree is set during a time when traditional values collide with attempts at bringing the Ottoman Empire into the modern world. The progressive Sultan has many enemies among his more traditional subjects. Thus, the story focuses closely on the clash between those who believe the past has greater value and those who see the necessity of changing for the future. The story begins with Yashim being asked by the Sultan’s commander-inchief, the seraskier, to investigate the disappearances of four young officers from the new, French-trained army.
606 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Janissary Tree
The seraskier gives Yashim only ten days to solve the crime because the Sultan will soon make a controversial decree to modernize the empire (Smith). The disappearances could cause complications in a situation that is already fraught with political turmoil. Jason Goodwin also explores themes of gender and sexuality through the very nature of his main character. Yashim is a eunuch, a status that causes him emotional distress (Smith), even while providing him with advantages over other investigators. In the novel, he is described: “he lacked balls. Not in the vulgar sense: Yashim was reasonably brave. But he was that creature rare even in 19th-century Istanbul. Yashim was a eunuch” (Goodwin, 5). This condition does not stop Yashim from having an affair with the wife of the Russian ambassador, but it does cause him to be isolated in his own culture. The themes of gender and sexuality are also explored through Preen, a köçek dancer who, like others of his profession, was castrated at puberty. The male dancers dress like women. The novel focuses on the friendship between these two outcasts, both of whom are men denied key aspects of the traditional male role.
MAJOR CHARACTERS PALIESKI is the ambassador for Poland, a country that has been divided between the Russians, the Prussians, and the Austrians. Like Yashim, Palieski is an outcast, an ambassador without a country to represent. Palieski aids Yashim’s investigation. PREEN, like Yashim, was castrated during his puberty. He is not a eunuch, however; he is a köçek dancer, who dresses like a woman. Along with being one of Yashim’s oldest friends, he is one of the people who helps Yashim in his investigation. YASHIM TOGALU, a eunuch, is an investigator for the Sultan of the Ottoman Empire. Though his status as a eunuch marks him as an outsider, it also enables him to cross into areas prohibited to other men, including the Sultan’s harem. Yashim is intelligent and charismatic, but is also able to blend into the background, giving him an advantage when watching people for information pertaining to the case.
W Style There are several subgenres in crime fiction, and the “history-mystery” is a popular category, explains Natasha Cooper of the London Times. According to her, the secret to success in this genre is “balancing the demands of narrative with the need for accurate research.” Cooper states that many writers have trouble with the style because their grasp on how to achieve that balance is
Janissaries, such as those depicted in this portrait, would be the soldiers of the new army created by the sultan in The Janissary Tree. ª INTERFOTO/Alamy
tenuous. But in the case of The Janissary Tree, she writes, “Jason Goodwin’s first novel is a refreshing example of best practice.” The novel follows the traditional rules of crime fiction, featuring many of the staples in the genre: chases, escapes, and a clear resolution to the mystery. There are attempts on Yashim’s life, glamorous sexual encounters, and scenes of violence. The detective himself is troubled— perhaps flawed—but intelligent and charismatic. According to Margaret Cannon of the Toronto Globe and Mail, Goodwin “delivers a good old-fashioned whodunit with a fine twist ending.” Goodwin’s historical research is evident in his use of Istanbul in a way that makes the setting nearly equal to a character in importance. Piero Bohoslawec writes in the Financial Times that, aside from Yashim, “The other central figure is Istanbul itself, beautifully evoked.” Aspects of life in 1836 Istanbul are worked in throughout the novel, not only showing Goodwin’s study of history, but also capturing the flavor of the locale, accomplished in part through Yashim’s cooking, which highlights Turkish cuisine. A contributor to the Indian periodical the Statesman notes Goodwin’s ability to portray Istanbul vividly: “He excels at bringing this exotic and mysterious city to life. It’s the city to beat all cities, overcrowded and greedy with mosques, labyrinthine streets, princes, beggars and Russian spies.” Cooper describes the city as “a place—and a set of ideas—full of twisty byways, colourful jewelled corners, spiced air, violence and rotting detritus; at once alluring and repulsive.”
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
607
The Janissary Tree
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Edgar-award winner Jason Goodwin began his career as a travel writer, contributing to periodicals including Condé Nast Traveler and the New York Times. He studied the Byzantine Empire at Cambridge University and became fascinated with Istanbul. In his first book, The Gunpowder Gardens: Travels in China and India in Search of Tea, Goodwin recounts his travels in India and China, uncovering the history of tea. The result reads like a cross between a travelogue and a history book. The success of that book enabled Goodwin to make a six-month pilgrimage through Eastern Europe to Istanbul with two traveling companions. The trip became the subject of On Foot to the Golden Horn: A Walk to Istanbul. He followed that travelogue with a history book, the well received Lords of the Horizons: A History of the Ottoman Empire. Though he published two nonfiction books on American themes, he returned to Istanbul as the setting for his mystery series, which begins with The Janissary Tree. Goodwin makes his home in Sussex, England, with his wife Kate and their four children.
Boyd, Steve. Rev. of The Janissary Tree, by Jason Goodwin. Sunday Times [London] 17 June 2007: 48. Academic OneFile. Web. 23 July 2010. Cannon, Margaret. “Crime Books.” Globe and Mail [Toronto] 24 June 2006: D11. InfoTrac Custom Newspapers. Web. 23 July 2010. Goodwin, Jason. The Janissary Tree. Farrar, Straus & Giroux, 2007. Print. Hooker, Richard. “The Ottomans.” World Cultures Web site. Washington State University 2006. Web. 13 Aug. 2010. Rev. of The Janissary Tree, by Jason Goodwin. Publishers Weekly 253.6 (6 Feb. 2006): 46. General OneFile. Web. 23 July 2010. Sansal, Burak. “The Ottoman Empire.” All about Turkey Web site. All about Turkey, n.d. Web. 13 Aug. 2010. Smith, Joan. “A Turkish Delight; Fiction Special.” Sunday Times [London] 6 Aug. 2006: 47. Academic OneFile. Web. 23 July 2010. “Spotlight: Death in Historic Istanbul.” Statesman [India] 18 Sept. 2006. General OneFile. Web. 23 July 2010.
W Critical Reception In addition to receiving the Edgar Allan Poe Award, The Janissary Tree met with predominantly positive critical reviews. In the London Times, where the book was listed for two weeks in the column “You Really Must Read,” reviewer Steve Boyd concludes that the novel is an “unconventional and gripping thriller.” A Publishers Weekly critic considered the book “a welcome shift to fiction” for Goodwin, and called The Janissary Tree and “impressive first of a new mystery series.” Goodwin “makes a bold new statement in the detective genre by breaking new ground,” according to a reviewer for India’s Statesman. The critic noted that while other mysteries have been set in Istanbul, none has heroes like Yashim. Marilyn Stasio, writing for the New York Times Book Review, also points to Yashim as “the only eunuch detective in the genre.” The novel “is a wonderful trip into a long-lost world, the history of which is now touching our own,” writes Cannon, noting that she eagerly anticipates further books in the series. Cooper concludes, “Intelligent, elliptical and beguilingly written, The Janissary Tree is a rare pleasure.” Since its original publication, the novel has been translated into thirtyeight languages.
Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Rev. of The Janissary Tree, by Jason Goodwin. Kirkus Reviews 74.5 (1 Mar. 2006): 210. General OneFile. Web. 23 July 2010. Notes many elements of Goodwin’s novel while offering an assessment of why some elements did not work. Smart, Harriet. “Making It Up.” Solander: The Magazine of the Historical Novel Society 10.2 (2006): 2-4. Historical novelist Harriet Smart interviews Goodwin about his transition from nonfiction writing into penning mystery novels. Gale Resources
“Jason Goodwin.” Contemporary Authors Online, Gale, 2010. Reproduced in Biography Resource Center. Farmington Hills, Mich.: Gale, 2010. Web. 23 July 2010. “Orhan Pamuk.” Contemporary Authors Online, Gale, 2010. Reproduced in Biography Resource Center. Farmington Hills, Mich.: Gale, 2010. Web. 23 July 2010. Open Web Sources
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
Bohoslawec, Piero. Rev. of The Janissary Tree, by Jason Goodwin. Financial Times 30 June 2007: 57. General OneFile. Web. 23 July 2010.
608
Though he updates infrequently, Goodwin keeps a blog, at www.thebellinicard.wordpress.com, that provides additional insights into his work and his characters. He has written entries about how his characters might celebrate holidays, updates fans about new TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
The Janissary Tree
titles in the series, and provides links to some of his recipe sources. Jason Goodwin’s Home Page, at www.jasongoodwin.net, offers insights into his novels, particularly the series featuring Yashim. The world of The Janissary Tree is further explored through period images of Istanbul and a description of food typical of Turkish cuisine during Yashim’s era. Goodwin was interviewed by Barbara Peters of the Poisoned Pen Press and Bookstore. The interview, filmed in six segments, is available online at www .poinsonedpen.com. For Further Reading
Goodwin, Jason. Lords of the Horizon. London: Chatto & Windus, 1998. Print. Goodwin’s research for this history of the Ottoman Empire paved the way for his later mystery novels set during that era. Lords of the Horizon combines aspects of history and travel writing to make the Ottoman Empire feel immediate.
———. The Snake Stone. London: Faber & Faber, 2007. Print. The second in Goodwin’s “Yashim the Eunuch” series, The Snake Stone follows an investigation gone wrong: Yashim is asked to discover more about French archaeologist Lefere, but when the man is murdered outside the French embassy, Yashim is the only suspect. Marillier, Juliet. Cybele’s Secret. New York: Knopf, 2008. Print. Marillier combines mystery and fantasy elements in her young adult novel, also set in Istanbul during the Ottoman Empire. Teen Paula is working as her merchant father’s secretary on a trade mission that leads her to become embroiled in the dealings of a pagan cult. Pamuk, Orhan. Istanbul: Memories of a City. New York: Knopf, 2005. Print. Originally published in Turkish in 2003, Istanbul is a memoir intertwined with a series of literary essays by Nobel Prize-winning novelist Pamuk that describes the city in the modern era. Alana Abbott
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
609
Jimmy Corrigan: The Smartest Kid on Earth By Chris Ware
W Introduction Chris Ware’s graphic novel Jimmy Corrigan: The Smartest Kid on Earth concerns the cheerless life of a 36-year-old man who works in a dreary office mail room. The work won the Guardian First Book Award in 2001, marking the first time a graphic novel was awarded this prestigious U.K. prize. The story’s protagonist is a lonely, bored, and frustrated bachelor who struggles with the lack of human contact in his life. Jimmy fills his emotional void with frequent fantasies about an ideal family life, even imagining that his father is a superhero. Out of the blue Jimmy receives a note from his long estranged father, and a meeting is arranged. While the reunion is anything but ideal, Jimmy’s father is able to provide some family history, including an extended narrative about Jimmy’s grandfather, whose lonely existence in the previous century was remarkably similar to his grandson’s. Using the historical backdrop of nineteenth- and twentiethcentury Chicago, Ware explores the lives of three generations of Corrigan men while touching upon themes of rejection, isolation, and depression.
W Literary and Historical Context
Jimmy Corrigan is an American graphic novel, a genre derived from an older tradition of comic books popularized in the late 1930s that featured romanticized—and often Herculean protagonists, such as Superman. In the 1950s comic artists began to explore darker themes and create more flawed characters, perhaps in response to the uncertainty of the post-World War II period, when the threat of nuclear war shattered the illusion that an individual hero could solve the world’s problems. By the 1980s comics had further evolved, with artists such as Art Spiegelman and Harvey Pekar repositioning the genre for
a more adult audience. These comics featured ordinary and unattractive protagonists whose lives were anything but heroic. Innovation in the graphic novel continued into the twenty-first century, as North American artists increasingly saw the form as a vehicle for social commentary. While the superhero comics of the past were frequently set in cities, they rarely explored the effects of America’s urbanization or the alienating experience of being immersed within a densely populated metropolis. Critics James Sullivan (Book) and Candida Rifkind (Canadian Review of American Studies) agree that an achievement of the work is Ware’s evocative depiction of how monotonous urban planning has a crushing effect on the human spirit. Especially impressive is Ware’s recreation of the World’s Columbian Exposition (also known as the Chicago World’s Fair). Held in 1893, the event foreshadowed the rapid modernization of America that would take place in the early twentieth century. A review of Jimmy Corrigan in Publishers Weekly notes that Ware’s portrayal of Chicago’s urban sprawl symbolizes the familial disconnection in three generations of Corrigans.
W Themes Rejection, isolation, and depression, the central themes of Jimmy Corrigan, are apparent from the very start of the novel. The first sequence shows Jimmy’s world as a small, insignificant corner of the globe. It begins with a panel depicting a large expanse of black sky with a sprinkling of stars, followed by seven smaller panels in which the perspective gradually enlarges from a small globe to the nondescript apartment building where young Jimmy and his mother live. In the next sequence, an elderly man posing as “Super-Man” befriends Jimmy in order to sleep with his mother. This is the first of many betrayals in the novel and causes Jimmy to fantasize about other “supermen” who might serve as surrogate fathers. Later, when the
610 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Jimmy Corrigan: The Smartest Kid on Earth
narrative flashes back to the 1890s, it is revealed that Jimmy’s grandfather—like Jimmy—was abandoned by his father and spent many hours fantasizing about a more ideal family life. In the twentieth century, the grown-up Jimmy is frequently depicted sitting alone in his sparsely furnished apartment or uncomfortably enclosed in his office cubicle, wishing he had the nerve to talk to his female coworkers. In flashbacks to the nineteenth century, Jimmy’s grandfather is also often left alone in his room, spinning wild fantasies about rescuing women from dangerous thieves. Even when he is in the company of his father, a grim silence looms. This level of rejection and isolation leads to depression, which then causes both Jimmy and his grandfather to fantasize about being able to fly, killing their fathers, or simply leading different lives.
W Style Ware’s technique in Jimmy Corrigan is distinguished by the meticulously drawn architectural landscapes in which he places his hapless characters. A contrast exists between the majestic, awe-inspiring buildings, such as those featured at the Chicago World’s Fair, and puny, pathetic figures like Jimmy’s grandfather who are dwarfed by the towering modern structures. The Publishers Weekly review notes a particular sequence in which Ware’s skillful designs capture the misery of an unwanted and despised child: Jimmy’s great-grandfather surprises his son with an outing to the fair but then abruptly abandons the boy. The scenario stands in marked contrast to the perfect domestic life presented in pre-World War II comic strips such as Blondie. Additionally, Ware’s pale and rotund protagonist is a far cry from the hyper-masculine figures of superhero comics. Jimmy’s sad and sagging face and lack of a fine physique give the impression that he is literally being pulled down by the force of gravity. Despite the often overwhelming bleakness of its imagery, Jimmy Corrigan is enlivened by a wide variety of cartoon drawings and panel structuring styles. Ware includes many pages that feature cutouts of buildings, toys, and even people related to the narrative, including a version of young Jimmy himself, that invite the reader to participate in the imaginary worlds of the novel. In his Booklist review of The Acme Novelty Date Book: 1986–1995, which contains raw sketches of Ware’s cartoons, Gordon Flagg notes that, instead of using single panels organized in an obvious linear sequence, the artist experiments with multiple panels arranged in such a way that readers are invited to interpret the sequence themselves and participate in the narration. To express an abrupt shift from the past to the present, Ware slightly alters the shade of the sky and the shape of the buildings in a sequence of panels. In such instances the reader is able to travel between Jimmy’s and his grandfather’s worlds and gain insight on the intergenerational link. According to Rifkind, this flashback technique represents
MAJOR CHARACTERS JIMMY’S ESTRANGED FATHER, who lives in Michigan, attempts to make up for years of neglect by inviting his son for a visit. However, the arranged reunion is made painfully awkward by the father’s social indelicacies and his somewhat disingenuous attempts at fatherly tenderness. JIMMY’S GRANDFATHER is presented as a highly imaginative but ultimately lonely child living in late-nineteenth-century Chicago. Fearful of his father’s temper, the boy spends most of his days in solitude, up in his room or outside, where he creates imaginary adventures. JIMMY’S GREAT-GRANDFATHER is a brutish, intolerant man whose wife died during childbirth. He blames his son for the tragedy and ultimately abandons him during the Chicago World’s Fair. ANTONIO is a classmate of Jimmy’s grandfather. Antonio befriends the boy and even invites him to his house to meet his father, who makes toy horses. AMY CORRIGAN is Jimmy’s African American half-sister, adopted by his father some years after he had abandoned Jimmy and his mother. Jimmy meets Amy when they receive news that their father has been in a car accident. She is a kind, energetic, and sociable person. JIMMY CORRIGAN is the eponymous protagonist, who spends most of his days contemplating the indifferent world around him in contemporary Chicago. Jimmy fantasizes about being talented, dashing, and more sociable, but he fails in every category. MRS. CORRIGAN is Jimmy’s self-absorbed, overbearing mother. She is consumed with checking up on her son. MISS MCGINTY is a friend of Jimmy’s grandfather from school. She eventually spurns him when she discovers that he is motherless.
Ware’s rejection of traditional notions of linearity and exploits the ability of characters in a graphic novel to “re-inhabit” the past.
W Critical Reception Critical response to Jimmy Corrigan has been consistently positive, as many reviewers enthusiastically welcomed a new talent in the field of graphic fiction. Reviewers have lauded Ware’s ability to combine old and new traditions and to exploit the potential of this art form to examine the damaged lives of everyday people. Critics have also observed his attempt to build upon the work of previous graphic novelists, and some have compared his artistic virtuosity to that of Spiegelman.
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
611
Jimmy Corrigan: The Smartest Kid on Earth
ABOUT THE AUTHOR Chris Ware was born in 1967 and raised in Omaha, Nebraska. As a child he was fascinated by the work of a local cartoonist who worked for the Omaha World-Herald, where his grandfather was an editor. Still, his true start as a graphic storyteller came years later when, as a student at the University of Texas in Austin, he illustrated a regular comic strip for the Daily Texan. It was during his college years that Ware first conjured up some of his most famous graphic novel personages, including Jimmy Corrigan and Quimby the Mouse. When his work appeared in Spiegelman’s graphic fiction magazine RAW in the mid-1980s, Ware became known to a larger readership for his distinctive design and drawing techniques. His skills were on full display in The Acme Novelty Library, the comic book series in which Jimmy Corrigan was serialized from 1995 to 2000. With his publication of the complete novel in 2000, Ware gained recognition in the wider field of contemporary fiction. Ware is best known for his sparse landscapes and his attention to geometrical form. While he is also skilled in the art of narration, he excels at rendering emotion through the silences of his characters and the subtle changes in body language that signal discomfort or agony.
A number of reviewers also have touted Ware’s skill with manipulating his panels. In his review of Jimmy Corrigan for Booklist, Flagg argues that “Ware effectively uses tiny, repetitive panels to convey Jimmy’s limited existence, then suddenly bursts a page open with expansive, breathtaking vistas.” The author’s talent for architectural design was praised by other critics, including Sullivan, whose commentary in Book emphasizes the skill with which Ware re-creates the Chicago World’s Fair. Other critics have drawn attention to Ware’s ability to combine a variety of drawing styles, cartoons, and text in his novel. As Laura J. Kloberg observes in her review in National Forum, “the graphic style is clean and crisp, stylized, yet it has great detail; it is crowded with images but not cluttered. All parts of the book lend to the rich visual mix.” Rifkind expands on this notion of artistic fusion, commending Ware’s “experiments with page layout, frame sizes, vivid colours, and intricate architectural detail to combine dizzying visual spectacle.”
Rev. of Jimmy Corrigan: The Smartest Kid on Earth, by Chris Ware. Publishers Weekly 4 Sept. 2000: 87. Web. 29 July 2010. Kloberg, Laura J. Rev. of Jimmy Corrigan: The Smartest Kid on Earth, by Chris Ware. National Forum 81.3 (2001): 44-45. Web. 29 July 2010. Rifkind, Candida. “Drawn from Memory: Comics Artists and Intergenerational Auto/Biography.” Canadian Review of American Studies/Revue Canadienne d’Etudes Américaines 38.3 (2008): 399-427. Web. 29 July 2010. Sullivan, James. Rev. of Jimmy Corrigan: The Smartest Kid on Earth, by Chris Ware. Book Jan. 2001: 66. Web. 29 July 2010. Additional Resources Criticism and Reviews
Bennett, Juda, and Cassandra Jackson. “Graphic Whiteness and the Lessons of Chris Ware’s Jimmy Corrigan.” ImageTexT: Interdisciplinary Comic Studies 5.1 (2010). Web. 29 July 2010. This collaborative article analyzes Ware’s technique of manipulating the comic book form in order to challenge notions of whiteness. Bennett and Jackson argue that while Jimmy never comprehends his own racial status, readers are made aware of his rather complicated family history. Bredehoft, Thomas A. “Comics Architecture, Multidimensionality, and Time: Chris Ware’s Jimmy Corrigan: The Smartest Kid on Earth.” Modern Fiction Studies 52.4 (2006): 869-90. Print. Draws attention to the architectural design featured in Jimmy Corrigan, noting that Ware’s technique of multiple panels challenges notions of linear time and narrative. Drucker, Johanna. “What Is Graphic about Graphic Novels?” English Language Notes 46.2 (2008): 39-55. Print. Compares graphic novels to a variety of other forms, including comics, livres d’artistes, and illustrated books. Drucker discusses a number of interpretive strategies for analyzing the graphic novel form.
Flagg, Gordon. Rev. of The Acme Novelty Date Book: 1986-1995, by Chris Ware. Booklist 1 Oct. 2003: 309. Web. 29 July 2010.
Kannenberg, Gene, Jr. “The Comics of Chris Ware: Text, Image, and Visual Narrative Strategies.” The Language of Comics: Word and Image. Eds. Robin Varnum and Christina T. Gibbons. Jackson: UP of Mississippi, 2001. 174-97. Print. Argues that Ware’s manipulation of the text and images in his comics reflect his familiarity with book publishing practices and trends, commenting that a work such as Jimmy Corrigan is referencing not just the comic tradition but the wider field of textuality.
———. Rev. of Jimmy Corrigan: The Smartest Kid on Earth, by Chris Ware. Booklist 15 Nov. 2000: 598. Web. 29 July 2010.
Weiner, Stephen. Rev. of Jimmy Corrigan: The Smartest Kid on Earth, by Chris Ware. Library Journal 15 Nov. 2000: 64. Web. 29 July 2010. A review of
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Works Cited
612
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Jimmy Corrigan: The Smartest Kid on Earth
Jimmy Corrigan that considers Ware’s presentation of human relationships in the novel. Gale Resources
“Chris Ware (1967-).” Something about the Author. Ed. Alan Hedblad. Vol. 140. Detroit: Gale, 2003. Something about the Author Online. Web. 30 July 2010. Open Web Sources
The official Carl Hammer Gallery Web site features samples from its exhibition of Chris Ware’s artwork, including specific panels from his comic strips and graphic novels. http://www.hammergallery.com/ Artists/Ware/ware_chris.htm The Guardian Web site offers a candid interview with Ware and presents some of his views on graphic novel art and his early inspiration for working in the genre. http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/2001/dec/07/ guardianfirstbookaward2001.gurardianfirstbookaward For Further Reading
Baetens, Jan. The Graphic Novel. Leuven, Belgium: Leuven UP, 2001. Print. The Graphic Novel explores the ways in which the genre uses images and text to articulate violence and traumas. While there are no substantial instances of physical violence in Jimmy Corrigan, Baetens’s book demonstrates Ware’s exploration of the traumatic impact of parental abuse and alienation.
Literacy. Worthington: Linworth Publishing, 2004. Print. A Novel Approach considers how graphic novels can serve the purpose of fostering literacy, especially for second-language learners who might benefit from its visual orientation. Pekar, Harvey. American Splendor: The Life and Times of Harvey Pekar. New York: Doubleday, 1986. Print. Pekar’s well-known autobiographical graphic novel presents the author’s own misanthropic views on everything from politics to social relationships. Weiner, Stephen, and Chris Couch. Faster than a Speeding Bullet: The Rise of the Graphic Novel. New York: Nantier Beall Minoustchine, 2003. Print. One of the most comprehensive histories of the graphic novel, this book explores the ways in which post-World War II comics helped prepare the groundwork for the darker, more adult themes explored in the sorts of works produced later by Spiegelman and Ware. Wolk, Douglas. Reading Comics: How Graphic Novels Work and What They Mean. Cambridge: Da Capo Press, 2007. Print. Reading Comics considers the history and theories of graphic novels and offers a critical survey of recent examples of the genre. One chapter is specifically devoted to Ware and the recurrence of emotionally tormented characters in his graphic novels. Adam Lawrence
Crawford, Philip. A Novel Approach: Using Graphic Novels to Attract Reluctant Readers and Promote
TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY NOVELS: THE FIRST DECADE
(c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
613
Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell By Susanna Clarke
W Introduction Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell, by Susanna Clarke, was published in 2004, preceded by a major marketing campaign from publisher Bloomsbury, who predicted the novel to be a best seller during a time when fantasy fiction and movies were at a height of popularity. (There is no period after “Mr” in the title, in line with English usage.) The novel tells the story of two very dissimilar Englishmen in the early nineteenth century, Norrell and Strange, who become England’s first practical magicians since the Raven King of the eleventh century. Magic, which stems directly from the Faerie realm, turns out to be a much more perilous endeavor than they first realize. Clarke’s novel uses elements of alternate history, fantasy, gothic literature, and realism and was celebrated by critics and audiences upon its release. Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell won the 2005 Hugo Award and was long-listed for the 2004 Man Booker Prize. It was named Book of the Year for Time magazine and Book Sense and was on the New York Times best-seller list for ten weeks, reaching number three. Clarke’s second book was short story collection The Ladies of Grace Adieu and Other Stories, published in 2006.
W Literary and Historical Context
The characters of Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell are concerned with strife between the English and French that played out during the Napoleonic Wars. At the conclusion of the French Revolution in 1799, Napoleon Bonaparte staged a coup and took control of the government. In 1804, he declared France an empire and crowned himself emperor. For the next
eleven years, Napoleon conscripted soldiers and waged war against other European countries, taking control of the Austrian Empire, Spain, Italy, Naples, the Grand Duchy of Warsaw (modern Poland), Switzerland, and many Germanic states, including Westphalia, Bavaria, and Saxony. The disastrous invasion of Russia in 1812 weakened Napoleon’s control over the French Empire and significantly diminished the size of his army. Napoleon abdicated in 1814 and was exiled, but he returned the following year in an attempt to raise a new army and retake control of the French Empire. Defeated in June 1815 at the Battle of Waterloo by British, Danish, and Prussian forces, Napoleon was exiled to the remote island of St. Helena where he died six years later. The Napoleonic Wars devastated Europe because of the high casualties (made even higher by the large number of conscripted soldiers) and long duration.
W Themes Insanity is a central theme in Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell. Insanity was and is a stigma in Western societies because insane people can be unsettling to be around and yet often require care to keep themselves and others safe; for example, Lady Pole is sent to Yorkshire after she tries to kill Mr. Norrell, where she is looked after by Mr. Segundus who has recently taken up the profession of madhouse keeper. Clarke explains away insanity in her novel as experiences with the Faerie realm. Those who experience Faery are not driven mad by it so much as they have increasing difficulty living in both worlds and communicating with those in the mortal realm. In keeping with Clarke’s realism, the characters who are thought to be insane or to have had bouts of madness, such as Lady Pole, Jonathan Strange, and Childermass, are in fact experiencing a melding of realities and draining of
614 (c) 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell
mortal energy. The reader has the omniscient perspective to see these unstable behaviors as a reasonable effect of unusual circumstances.
MAJOR CHARACTERS STEPHEN BLACK, a black man, is butler of the Pole household and under enchantment by the gentleman with the thistledown hair, who declares Stephen will be a king.
W Style The style, language, and tone of Clarke’s novel is reminiscent of nineteenth-century writers such as Charles Dickens (known for his realism, humor, and for making working-class characters central figures in his stories) and Jane Austen (known for her humor and social commentary with a focus on female characters). This imitative technique is known as pastiche. Clarke’s pastiche of nineteenth-century writers lends authenticity to Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell while it pays homage to these writers. Clarke’s novel is also characterized by elements of romantic and, specifically gothic, literature. Her focus on magic, the supernatural, languishing heroines, madness, and death are all typical features of gothic literature. She does not go as far as writing a true romantic novel in the style of Mary Shelley; Clarke pulls back from the emotive expression common to all romantic literature and instead turns to the realism of Dickens, Austen, and Sir Walter Scott. This combined approach is the basis for the alternate history of Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell. Clarke is able to evoke the past without alienating modern readers.
W Critical Reception Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell was marketed by its publisher, Bloomsbury, as Harry Potter for adults, highlighting its mesh of magic and the every day world. Many reviewers duly noted this marketing line but went on to exclaim that the novel is so much more. Brad Hooper of Booklist declared, “it’s an exceptionally compelling, brilliantly creative, and historically finetuned piece of work.” Some commented negatively on the book’s length and the author’s intent in writing in a style reminiscent of a comedy of manners. A Publishers Weekly reviewer noted that