A HISTORICAL COMMENTARY ON
POL YBIUS BY
F. W. WALBANK EMERITUS PROFESSOR OF ANCIENT HISTORY AND CLASSICAL ARCliAEOLOGY IN TliE UNIVERSITY OF LIVERPOOl.
VOLUME III COMMENTARY ON BOOKS XIX-XL
OXFORD AT THE CLARENDON PRESS
1979
ISBN-10: 0198140118 ISBN-13: 978-0198140115
CONTENTS LIST OF MAPS AND PLANS
ix
ABBREVIATIONS AND BIBLIOGRAPHY OF SHORT TITLES
xi
INTRODUCTION: THE FRAGMENTS I. Book xix 2. Book xx 3· Book xxi 4· Book xxii 5· Book xxiii 6. Book xxiv 7· Book xxv 8. Book xxvi g. Book xxvii IO. Book xxviii II. Book xxix 12. Book xxx I3. Book xxxi 14· Book xxxii rs. Book xxxiii r6. Book xxxiv 17. Book XXXV 18. Book xxxvi rg. Book xxxvii 20. Book xxxviii 2!. Book xxxix 22. Book xl
ASSIGNMENT OF THE I
3 7 13 r6 rg 22 22 25 27
30 34 37 40 43 43 44 46 47 49
so
TABLE OF FRAGMENTS: BOOKS VII-XXXIX COMMENTARY Book xix Book xx Book xxi Book xxii Book xxiii Book xxiv
51
63 64
88 176 214 254
vii
CONTENTS
Bool< xxv Bool( xxvi Hoole x x vii Book xxviii Book xxix Appendix ou the Ach;tcan Assemhlk•s
270
284 290
Rook xxx Book xxxi Book xxxii Book xxxili Book xxxiv Book xxxv Book xxxvi Book xxxvii Book xxxviii Book xxxix Book xl
321 361 406 415 463 518 542 563 640 651 684 685 726 744
Fragments
745
ADDENDA AND CORH.IGENDA TO VOLUME I
757
ADDENDA AND COl\ JUG E Nl)A TO VOLUME II
777
ADDENDA TO VOLlJME Ifi
793
INDEXES r. Gcurral 2.. Authors anti pa.~.m~e.~ 3· luscrifJtions, Papyri, and Ostrar.a 4· Gree/1
viii
LIST OF MAPS AND PLANS I. ALEXANDRIA::
2. AMBRACIA IN
189
97 124
3·
CN. MANLIUS VULSO'S ROUTE AGAI::.
141
4·
THE OLYMPUS AREA
382
5·
PYD::.
385
6.
THE REGION OF THE GREAT SLOPE (PTOLEMY VIII'S CAMPAIGN, 162)
487
7·
THE FAMILIES AFRICAN US
8.
POLYBIUS' CALCULATIONS OF THE DISTANCES FROM THE PILLARS TO MALEA
594
9·
THE RELATIVE LENGTH OF EUROPE AND ASIA COMPARED WITH AFRICA
597
OF
AEMILIUS
PAULLUS
AND SCIPIO
10. VITRUVIUS' TYMPANUM: VERTICAL SECTION
751
ix
ABBREVIATIONS AND BIBLIOGRAPHY OF SHORT TITLES (ADDITIONAL TO THOSE IN VOLUMES I
AND II)
Abh. Sachs. Ges. = Abhandlungen der Koniglichen Siichsischen Gesellschaft der Wissenschaften: phil.-hist. Klasse. Accame, Dominio = S. Accame, Il dominio romano in Grecia dalla guerra acaica ad Augusto. Rome, I946. Actes IX• Congr~s Bude = Actes du IX• Congrt.s de l'association Guillaume Budi, Rome, IJ-I8 avril, I973· 2 vols. Paris, I975· A]N =American journal of Numismatics. Altheim, Weltgeschichte = F. Altheim, Die Weltgeschichte Asiens imgriechischen Zeitalter. 2 vols. Halle, I948. Anal. Stud. =Anatolian Studies. Ancient Macedonia= Ancient Macedonia: First International Symposium. Thessalonica, I970. Ancient Macedonia I I = Ancient 1\Iacedonia I I: Second International Symposium. Thessalonica, I977· Ancient Society = Ancient Society and Institutions: Studies Presented to Victor Ehrenberg on his 75th birthday. Oxford, I967. Annales = Annales: Economies, Societtis, Civilisations. Annali di Pisa = Annali della scuola normale superiore di Pisa, lettere, storia e filosofia. ANSMN =American Numismatic Society: Museum Notes. Arch. Rel. = Archiv fur Religionswissenschaft. Asheri = D. Asheri, Leggi greche sul problema dei debiti. Pisa, 1969. A. Soc.= Ancient Society (Louvain). Astin = A. E. Astin, Scipio Aemilianus. Oxford, I967. Astin, Lex annalis = A. E. Astin, The Lex annalis before Sulla. Collection Latomus, 32. Brussels, I958. AttiAcc. Palermo= Atti della R. Accademia di Scienze, Lettere e Arti di Palermo. Aufstieg und Niedergang = Aufstieg und Niedergang der romischen Welt. Ed. H. Temporini. Berlin-New York, 1972Aymard, Etudes= A. Aymard, Etudes d'histoire ancienne. Paris, 1967. Badian, Flamininus = E. Badian, Titus Quinctius Flamininus: Philhellenism and Realpolitik. Louise Taft Semple lectures, 1970. Cincinnati, 1970. Badian, Publicans = E. Badian, Publicans and Sinners. Dunedin, 1972. Bagnall= R. S. Bagnall, The Administration of Ptolemaic Possessions outside Egypt. Columbia Studies in the Classical tradition, vol. 4· Leiden, 1976.
Bar-Kochva, Seleucid Army= B. Bar-Kochva, The Seleucid Army: Organization and Tactics in the Great Campaigns. Cambridge, 1976. Bengtson8 = H. Bengtson, Griechische Geschichte von den Anfangen bis in die romische Kaiserzeit. Ed. 3· Munich, 1969.
xi
AIIIIUHVIATIONS AND RIHLTOC.RAPHY 11111'11"~"· l<.'mlo~•/ll~tt~• ~
I r. Jlnrr,nr, I Ji~
~~"gmf>ltisr.hen
Fragmente des Eratos-
111~~~~•- l.nlp~ll(, 1 HHu.
H•n•h"11\l ll~'ll"H'II•Ilr
,,,.,,
U. ll.. ruluml!, lmf>t'rium und El"utheria: die romische Politik oll'tt Jr'i-n S/ll.J/m dl'-< gn8chlschen Ostens. Diss. Hamburg,
Btll"vo, Di~ Tyrannis bei den Griechen. 2 vols. Munich, l•jr•7· Bkkorml\n, Chronology = E. J. Bicketman, Chronology of the ancient world. London, 1968. Bilz = K. Bilz, Die Politik des P. Cornelius Scipio Aemilianus. Diss. Wiirzburg, 1935· B.M.C. Lydia= B. V. Head, Catalogue of the Greek coins of Lydia in the British Museum. London, 1902. Bomer = F. BOmer, Rom und Troia: Untersuchungen zur Friihgeschichte Roms. Baden-Baden, 1951. Bomer, Fasten= F. Bomer, P. Ovidius Naso: Die Fasten. 2 vols. Heidelberg,
lk>rvf', /"ymn'lli.t - II.
1957-8.
Bowra Essays= Essays presented to C. M. Bowra. Alden Press for \Vadham College Junior and Middle Common Rooms [Oxford], 1970. Briant, Antigone = P. Briant, Antigone le Borgne: les debuts de sa carriere et les problemes de l' assemblee mactidonienne. Paris, 1973. Briscoe, Commentary = J. Briscoe, A commentary on Livy, books xxxi-xxxiii. Oxford, 1973. Biittner-Wobst, Beitrage = Th. Biittner-Wobst, Beitriige zu Polybios. Jahresbericht der Kreuzschule zu Dresden, 190r.
Bull. Mus. Impero Romano= Bullettino del Museo dell'Impero Romano (published with Bull. Comm. Rom.). Bull. Ryl. Lib.= Bulletin of the John Rylands Library, Manchester. Burck = E. Burck, Die Erzithlungskunst des T. Livius. Berlin, 1934· Calderone = S. Calderone, IILETLE-Fides: ricerche di storia e diritto internazionale nell'antichita. Messina, n.d. [1964]. Caplan Studies = The Classical Tradition: Literary and Historical Studies in Honor of Harry Caplan. Ed. L. Wallach. Ithaca, 1966. Carcopino, Etapes = ] . Carcopino, Les Etapes de l'imperiaUsme YDmain. Paris, 1961. Carcopino, Gracques = ]. Carcopino, Autour des Gracques. Ed. 2. Paris, 1967. Carcopino, Points de vue = ] . Carcopino, Points de vue sur l'imperialisme romain. Paris, 1934· Cary and Haarhoff = M. Cary and T. J. Haa.rho:ff, Life and Thought in the Greek and Roman World. London, 1940. Cary and Warmington= M. Cary and E. H. Warmington, The Ancient Explorers. London, 1929. Casson, Macedonia= S. Casson, Macedonia, Thrace and Illyria. Oxford, 1926. Casson, Ships= L. Casson, Ships and Seamanship in the Ancient World. Princeton, 1971. Ceka, Questions = Hasan Ceka, Questions de numismatique illyrienne. Tirana, 1972-
Charles-Picard, Daily Life= G. and C. Charles-Picard, Daily Life at Carthage at the Time of Hannibal. London-New York, 1961.
xii
ABBREVIATIONS AND BIBLIOGRAPHY
CIJ = Corpus inscriptionum judaicarum. Clara Rhodos Clara Rhodos, Studi e materiali pubblicati a cura dell'Istituto storico-archeologico di Rodi, i-x, rgz8-r940. Cloch~. Thebes P. Cloch~. Thebes de Bt!otie des origines ala conqudte romaine. Paris, n.d. Conference Econ. Hist. Aix Secmtd International Conference on Economic History, Aix-en-Provence I96z. VoL I: Trade and politics in the ancient world. Paris, I965. Cont. I st. Fil. Class. = Contributi dell'Istituto di Filologia Classica, Sezione di storia. antica (Milan, 1963- ). Cook, Ionia J. M. Cook. The Greeks in Ionia and the East. London, 1963. Corbett P. A. Corbett, The Roman Law of Marriage. Oxford, 1930. Crampa, Labraunda inscriptions J. Crampa, Labraunda: Swedish Excavations and Researches, viii. I: The Greek Inscriptions, Part I: I-12 (period of Olympichus). Skrifter utgivna av Svenska. Institutet i Athen, 4°, V, iii, I. Lund, I 969. Crawford, RRC M. H. Crawford, Roman Republican Coinage. 2 vols. Cambridge, I975· Crawford, RRCH M. H. Crawford, Roman Republican Coin Hoards. London, I969.
CSCA California Studies in Classical Antiquity. Dahlheim W. Dahlheim, Struktur und Entwi.cklzmg des rlimischen Volke,rechts im 3· und a. Jahrhundert v. Chr. Vestigia, vol. 8. Munich, 1968. Danov = Christo M. Danov, Altthrakien. Berlin-New York, 1976. Daux, Chronologie delphique FD, III. Epigraphic, fascicule hors st!fie. Paris, I943· Davies 0. Davies, Roman Mines in Europe. Oxford, I935· Deininger = J. Deininger, Der politische Widersland gegen Rom in Griechenland, 217-86 v. Chr. Berlin-New York, 1971. DO\\"'ley, Antioch= G. Downey, A History of Antioch in Syria from Seleucus to the Arab Conquest. Princeton. I96I. Dugand, Aegitna J.-E. Dugand, De l'Aegitna de Polybe au trophk de Ia Brague. Publ. Fac. des lettres et sciences humaines de Nice. (Collection Mediterranoo antique et moderne, II.) Paris, 1970. Earl, M01'al and Political Tradition = D. C. Earl, The Moral and Political Tradition of Rome. London, 1967. Earl, Tiberius Gracchus D. C. Earl, Tiberius Gracchus: a St·:tdy in Politics. Collection Latomus, 6I. Brussels, 1963. EGF G. Kinkel, Epicorum graecorum fragmenta, i. Leipzig, 1877. Elsen K. F. Eisen, Polybiosinterpretationen: Beobachtungen zu Prinzipien griechischer und romischer Historiographic bei Polybios. Heidelberg, 1966. Entretiens sur Polybe Polybe. Entretiens sur l'Antiquite classique, 20. Ed. 0. Reverdin. Vandreuvres-Geneva, 1974. Epigraphica Epigraphica: Rivista italiana di epigrafia (Milan). Ergon arch. et. TO "Epyov rijs }ipxa
'E-ratp..las (Athens). Errington = R. M. Errington, Philopomwn. Oxford, 1969. Errington, Dawn R. M. Errington, The Dawn of Empire: Rome's Rise to world power. London, 1971.
xiii
A II IIJ{EVl ATTONS AND BIBLIOGRAPHY l~tlnnnn ILIId
l. Eurknu --II.('. Ftwl"•n, l'ro/Jitml' drr Vorgcschichte des zweiten punischen lil'ltf:"· Iii~•. l'mihur..:, II}I>H. J.''·'t"':/irijt :lllhrim llritrllge zur altet• Geschichte und deren Nachleben: 1•11~1~• lrrilt. f!ir Franz Althcim zum 6. 10. 68. Ed. Ruth Stiehl and H. E. St i...-. l vol~. Herlin, t•}hl). J•~.,t\1./irift 1/ir.":ltfeld ~~ Festschrift zu Otto Hirschfelds 6o. Geburtstage. Berlin, 11}0,\.
Vahlen = Festschrift Johannes Vahlen zum siebenzigsten Geburtstag von seinen Schulern. Berlin, 1900. Fll A iv ~~ Fontes Hispaniae Antiquae, fasc. iv: Las guerras de I54-72 a. de ]. C.; edici6n y comentario por Adolfo Schulten. Barcelona, 1937. Finley, Problemes de Ia terre = M. Finley, ed. Problemes de Ia terre en Grece ancienne. Paris, 1973. Flurl = W. Flurl, Deditio in fidem: Untersuchungen zu Livius und Polybios. Diss. Munich, 1969. Foucault = J. A. Foucault, Recherches sur Ia langue et le style de Polybe. Paris, 1972. Fraccaro, Opuscula = P. Fraccaro, Opuscula. 3 vols. in 4 parts. Pavia, Fr.~tschrift
~:ewidmet
1956-7.
Franke, Munzen
=
P.R. Franke, Die antiken Munzen von Epirus. Wiesbaden,
1961.
Fraser, Alex.= P.M. Fraser, Ptolemaic Alexandria. 3 vols. Oxford, 1973. Fraser, Samothrace = P.M. Fraser, Samothrace, II, Part i: The Inscriptions on Stone. New York, 1960. Galinsky = G. K. Galinsky, Aeneas, Sicily and Rome. Princeton, 1969. Gauthier = Ph. Gauthier, Symbola: les etrangers et Ia justice dans les cites grecques. Nancy, 1972. Gelzer, Nobility= M. Gelzer, The Roman Nobility, tr. R. J. Seager. Oxford, 1969.
Gillischewski = H. Gillischewski, De Aetolorum praetoribus intra annos 22I et r68 a. Chr. n. munere junctis. Diss. Berlin, 181)6. Giovannini, Untersuchungen = A. Giovannini, Untersuchungen uber die Natur und die Anfiinge der bundesstaatlichen Sympolitie in Griechenland. Hypomnemata, 33· Giittingen, 1971. GRBS = Greek, Roman and Byzantine studies. Grenier, Manuel= A. Grenier, Archeologie galla-romaine in Manuel d'archiologie prihistorique, celtique et galla-romaine, ed. J. Dechelette, vols. v and vi. Paris, 1931-4. GVI = W. Peek, Griechische Vers-Inschrijten, i: Grab-Epigramme. Berlin, 1955·
Haarhoff = T. J. Haarhoff, The Stranger at the Gate. Oxford, 1948. Habicht = C. Habicht, Gotlmenschentum und griecllische Stiidte. Zetemata, 14. Ed. 2. Munich, 1970. Hammond, Epirus = N. G. L. Hammond, Epirus: the Geography, the Ancient Remains, the History and the Topography of Epirus and Adjacent Areas. Oxford, 1967.
xiv
ABBREVIATIONS AND BIBLIOGRAPHY Hammond, Macedonia N. G. L. Hammond, A History of Macedonia. Vol. L Oxford, 1972. Hansen 2 E. V. Hansen, The Attalids of Pergamum. Ed. 2. Ithaca and London, 1971. Hatzfeld J. Hatzfeld, Les Trafiquants italiens dans /'Orient helltnique. Paris, 1919. Haussoullier, Etudes = B. Haussoullier, Etudes sur l' histoire de Milet et du Didymaeon. Paris, 1902. Heiland P. Heiland, Untersuchungen zur Geschichte des Konigs Perseus von Makedonien (I79-x68). Diss. Jena, 1913. Heinze, Geist R. Heinze, Vom Geist des Romertums. Leipzig-Berlin, 1938. Helly, Gonnoi B. Helly, Gonnoi. 2 vols. (i. La Cite et son territoire. ii. Les Inscriptions.) Amsterdam, 1973. Heurgon, Rise of Rome= J. Heurgon, The Rise of Rome to 264 B.C., tr. J. Willis. London, 1973. Heuzey-Daumet = L. Heuzey and H. Daumet, Mission archeologique de Macedoine. Paris, 1876. Hist. Filos. Medd. Dan. Vid. Selsk. = Det K. Danske Videnskabernes Selskab: Historisk-filosofiske Meddelelser. Historiographia Antiqua Historiographia Antiqua: Commentationes Lovanienses in honorem W. Peremans septuagenarii editae. Lou vain, 1977. Hommages Preaux = Le Monde grec: penste, litterature, histoire, documents: Hommages a Claire Pdau:t:. Ed. J. Bingen, O. Cambier, G. Nachtergael. Brussels, 1975. Horn = H. Horn, Foederati. Diss. Frankfurt, 1930. Howald-Meyer, Schweiz = E. Howald and Ernst Meyer, Die romische Schweiz: Texte und Inschrijten mit Obersetzung. Ziirich, 1940. Hultsch, EZ (1891), (1892). or (1893) F. Hultsch, 'Die erzahlenden Zeitformen bei Polybios'. Abh. Sru;hs. Ges. 13 (1891), 1-210; 13 (1892), 34767; 14 (1893), I-IOO. Huss, Untersuchungen W. Huss, Untersuchungen .zur Auj3enpolitik Ptolemaios' IV. Munich, 1976. Hyde, Routes= \V. \V. Hyde, Roman Alpine routes. (Memoirs of the American Philosophical Society, I I.) Philadelphia, 1935. IGLS Inscriptions grecques et latines de la Syrie, ed. L. Jalabert and R. Mouterde. Paris, 1929ILLRP Inscriptiones latinae liberae rei publicae. Vol. i 2 (r965), vol. ii (1963), ed. A. Degrassi. Florence. IM Mitteilungen des Deutschen A rchiiologischen I nstituts (A bt. Istanbul). Insc. Lind. C. Blinkenberg and K. F. Kinch, Lindos, fouilles et recherches, 1902-1914. II. Inscriptions, i-ii. Copenhagen-Berlin, 1941. Jal, Tite-Live, xli-xlii = P. Jal, Tite-Live, Histoire romaine, tome 31, livres xli-xlii. Bude ed. Paris, 1971. J AOS = ] ournal of the American Oriental Society. J. Aymard, Chasses J. Aymard, Les Chasses romaines des origines la fin du siecle des Antonins. Paris, 1951. Johnson Studies Studies in Roman Economic and Social History in Honor of Allan C. Johnson. Ed. P. R. Coleman-Norton. Princeton, 1951. Jones, CERFZ = A. H. M. Jones, Cities of the Eastern Roman Provinces. Ed. 2. Oxford, 197 I.
a
XV'
ABBREVIATIONS AND BIBLIOGRAPHY Kirchner, l'A = J. Kirchner, Prosopographia Attica. 2 vols. Berlin, I901-3. 1\lttint:r l'auly = Der Kleine Pauly: Lexikon der Antike. Auf der Grundlage van l'auly's Realencyclopiidie. Ed. K. Ziegler and W. Sontheimer, 19641\ilrtc, (;ordian = G. and A. Korte, Gordian, Ergebnisse der Ausgrabung im Jahre r900. J DAI, Erganzungsheft 5· Berlin, 1904. Koperhcrg = S. Koperberg, Polybii historiarum liber xxx. Diss. Amsterdam, I9I<). Lanckoronski, Stiidte Pamphyliens = Karl Graf Lanckoronski, Stadte l'amphyliens und Pisidiens. 2 vols. Vienna, 189o-2. Larsen, GFS = J. A. 0. Larsen, Greek Federal States: their Institutions and History. Oxford, 1968. Le Bas P. Le Bas-vV. H. vVaddington, Inscriptions grecques et latines recueillies en Grece et en Asie Mineure. V•partie, AsieMineure, nos. 1-1826. Paris, I 87o. Lehmann G. A. Lehmann, Untersuchungen zur historischen Glaubwiirdigkeit des Polybios. Miinster, 1967. Leip. Stud. Leipziger Studien zur classischen Philologie. Levick, Colonies Barbara Levick, Roman Colonies in Southern Asia Minor. Oxford, 1967. Long A. A. Long, Hellenistic Philosophy: Stoics, Epicureans, Sceptics. London, I974· Maass, Comm. At-at. E. Maass, Comme1ttariorum in Aratum t-eliquiae. Berlin, 1898. Ma.cKendrick, Mute Stones= P. L. MacKcnrlric.k, The Mute Stones speak: the Stot-y of Archaeology in Italy. London, H)(>:l. McShane R. B. McShane, The Foreign Policy (lf the Attalids of Pergamum. (Urbana. Studies in the Social Sciences, 53·) Urbana, Ill., I'J64. Maier, Mauerbauinschrijten F. G. Maier, Griecllische Mauerbauinschrijten, i. Texte und Kommentare. Vestigia.. J. Heidelberg, I'l5'l· MaK€1lovtKd. L'1rouMiv.
MaK€1lovtKd.: avyypa,.,.a 7T€pto0LKOV .. ~, 'Emtp
Malcovati, ORFS Oratorum romanorttm jragmenta, tertiis curis edidit H. Ma.lcovati. i. Textus. Turin, I953· Manni, Fasti E. Manni, Fasti ellenistici e ronUI.ni (323-31 a. C.). Supplement to Kokalos, i. Palermo, I96L Mason= H. J. Mason, Greek Terms jar Roman Institutions: a Lexicon and Analysis. (American studies in papyrt>logy, 13.) Toronto, I974· Meiggs-Lewis R. and D. Lewis, A Selection of Greek Historical Inscriptions to the of the Fifth Crntury B.C. Oxford, 1969. Meiggs, Ostia = R. Roman Ostia. Ed. z. Oxford, I973· Meister, Kritik = Klaus Meister, Historische 1\ritik bei l'olybios. Pa.lingenesia., 9. Wiesbaden, I975· Mekler, Acad. phil. index Here. S. Melder, Academicorum philosophorum index Ilerculanensis. Berlin, 1902. Melanges Charles Picard Melanges d'a,·chtologie et d'histoire afferts Charles Picard a /'occasion de son 65• anniversait-e. 2 vols. (Published a.s part of Rev. arch.) Paris, 1948.
a
Melanges Daux =Melanges helleniqttes offerts
xvi
a Georges Daux. Paris, 1975·
ABBREVIATIONS AND BIBLIOGRAPHY
a
Melanges Desrousseaux = Atelanges offerts A .-Af. Dcsrousseaux par ses amis et ses eleves en l'kotmeur de sa cinquantieme annee d'enseignement superieur (z887-I937). Paris, 1937. Melanges Gregoire IIArKAPIIEIA: Melanges Henri Gregoire. (Annuaire de l'Institut de philologie et d'histoire orientales, vols. 9-12.) Brussels, 19491953· Melanges Levy Melanges Isidore Levy. (Annuaire de l'Institut de philologie et d'histoire orientales, vol. 13.) Brussels, I955· Melanges Piganiol =Melanges d'archeologie et d'histoire offerts a Andre Piganiol, ed. R. Chevallier. 3 vols. Paris, 1966. Melanges Thomas= lvUlanges Paul Thomas, Recueil de memoires concernant la philologie classique dedie a Paul Thomas. Bruges, 1930. Mette H. J. Mette, Pytheas von }vfassalia. Berlin, 1952. Meyer, Pontos = Ed. Meyer, Geschichte des I{onigreichs Pontos. Leipzig, 1879. Michels A. K. Michels, The Calendar of the Roman Republic. Princeton, 1967. Miller, Itineraria K. Miller, Itineraria Romana: Romische Reisewege an der Hand der Tabula Peutingeriana dargestellt. Stuttgart, I9I6. MJ'vfAP Memorias de los Museos Arqueol6gicos Provinciales. M0rkholm Otto Morkholm, Antioch us IV of Syria. (Class. et Med. Dissertationes, viii.) Copenhagen, 1966. A. Momigliano, Terzo contributo alta storia degli Momigliano, Contributo 3 studi classici e del mondo antico. 2 vols. Rome, 1966. Momigliano, Contributo' A. Momigliano, Quarto contributo alla storia degli studi classici e del mondo antico. Rome, 1969. Momigliano, Filippo = A. Momigliano, Filippo il Macedone. Florence, 1934· Mommsen, RMW = Th. Mommsen, Geschichte des romiscken Munzwesens. Berlin, 186o. Mon. Ant. = Monumenti antichi pubblicati per cura della R. Accademia dei Lincei. Mooren L. Mooren, The Aulic Titulature in Ptolemaic Egypt, Introduction and Prosopography. Brussels, 1975· Moretti L. Moretti, Iscrizioni storiche ellenisticke. i. Attica, Peloponneso, Beozia. Florence, 1967. D. Musti, Lo stato dei Seleucidi. Extract from Studi classici Musti, Seleucidi e orientali, I 966, 59-201. Muttelsee = M. Muttelsee, Zur Verfassungsgesckichte Kretas im Zeitalter des Hellenismus. Diss. Hamburg, 1925. Nenci, Saggi = G. Nenci, Introduzione alle guerre persiane e altri saggi di storia antica. Pisa, 1958. Nock, Essays= A. D. Nock, Essays on Religion and the Ancient World. Ed. Z. Stewart. 2 vols. Oxford, 1972. Oliver, Civilizing Power = J. H. Oliver, The Civilizing Power. A study of the Panathenaic discourse of Aelius Aristides against the background of literature and cultural conflict, with text, translation and commentary. (Transactions of the American Philosophical Society, vol. s8. I.) Philadelphia, 1968. Oliver, Marcus = J. H. Oliver, 1'1.1arcus Aurelius. Aspects of civic and cultural policy in the east. Hesperia Suppl. 13. Princeton, 1970.
xvii
1\lllli<EVIATIONS AND BIBLIOGRAPHY
I IllY"'· Uuiii!JII'uwrr J. II. IIIIYt'l', Tl1t1 N11ling /'ower. A study of the Roma.ns In I hi' Ntl< owl '"nlury ufl11r Chri~l lhrough lho Roman oration of A eli us 1\ llolldo•• (TioUINII< t ionH of llu• Anwrican Philosophical Society, vol. 43· 4.)
l'hil,uJ,.Ipld!!.,
1•1.~.\·
I h lt~luloK, Ali{•l1~ira -
A. IC Orlandos, 'H
}1p~ra.8'"~
IDt ..pa. ""l Ttt P.VI/P.II'itl.
T!J~· Alh
= W. Otto and H. Bengtson, Zur Geschichte drs Niederganges des Ptolemtlerreiches: ein Beitrag _zur Geschichte des 8, und des 9· Ptolemiiers. Abh. Bay. Ak. IQJS. Otto, 6. Ptolemiier W. Otto, Zur Geschichte der Zeit des 6. Ptolemiiers. Abh. Bay. Ak. I934· Parker and Dubberstein = R. Parker and W. Dubberstein, Babylonian Chronology, 6:z6 B.C.-A.D. 75· Providence, 1956. P. Cair. Zen. C. C. Edgar, Zenon Papyri. 4 vols. Catalogue general des antiquites egyptiennes du Musee du Caire, 79- Cairo, I925-I93I. P. Col. inv. Columbia University papyrus, inventory number. Peremans, Vreemdelingen = \V. Peremans, Vreemdelingen en Egyptenaaren im Vroeg-Ptolemaeisch Egypte. Louvain, I937· Petzold, Studien ~ K.-E. Petzold, Studien zur M elhode des Polybios und zu ihrer historischen Attswertung. Vestigia, 9. Munich, 1969. P. Giess. Griechische Papyri im .'tiuseum des oberhessischtm Geschiehtsvereins zu Giessen, Bd. I, Hefte 1-3, ed. 0. Eger, E. Kornemann, P. M. Meyer. Leipzig-Berlin, rgro--IQI2. P. Grenj. 2 = B. P. Grenfell and A. S. Hunt, New Classical Fragments and Other Greek and Lat}n Papyri. Oxford, 1897. Philippson, Landschajten = A. Philippson and E. Kirsten, Die griechischen Landschaften. Vols. 1-4. Frankfurt, IQ.)o--rgy). Phillipson, International Law= Coleman Phillipson, The Internati(mal Law and Custom of Ancient Greece and Rome. 2 vols. London, I9II. Ph-il. Quaf't. Philological Quarterly: a. journal d<>votcd to scholarly investigation in the classical and modern languages and literatures. Iowa, I922- • Picard, Trophies = G. Charles-Picard, Les Trof>hles romains: contribution a l'histoire de Ia religion et de l'art lriomf,hal de Uome. Paris, I957· P. Kroll L. Koenen, Eine Ptolemitischr 1\iinigsurkunde (P. Kroll). Klassischphilologische Studien, rg. Wiesbaden, Iuium: Studies in Honour of Edward Togo Salmon, ed. J. A. S. Evans. Toronto, I974· Preaux =C. Preaux, L'Economie royalr de.< l.a{lides. nrusscls, I939· Preuner, Hestia-Vesta A. Prcuncr, llcstia-Vcsta: ein Cyclus religionsgeschichtlicher Forschungen. Tiibingeu, 1 flt.4. P. Rev. = B. P. Grenfell, Revenue Laws of l'tolcmy l'hiladetphus. Oxford, Ollu 1U1d Jltmgtson, Niedergang
r8g6.
Pritchett, Battlefields = W. K. l'dtdwtt, Studies in Aneient Greek Topography: Part II (Battlefields). Berkeley, 19&9.
xviii
ABBREVIATIONS AND BIBLIOGRAPHY Pritchett, Greek State at War W. K. Pritchett, The Gteek State at War: Parts I and II. Berkeley-Los Angeles-London, 1971-4. (Vol. r was first issued under the title: Ancient Greek Militayy Practices, Part I.) Proc. Afr. Class. Ass. The Proceedings of the Afyican Classical Associations. PYoc. Am. Phil. Soc. Pyoceedings of the American Philosophical Society. Proctor D. Proctor, Hannibal's Maych in Histoty. Oxford, 1971. Ramsay, Epistle W. M. Ramsay, Histo'l'ical Commentary on St. Paul's Epistle to the Galatians. London, 1899. Ramsay, Social basis W. M. Ramsay, The Social Basis of Raman Power in Asia Minor. Aberdeen, 1941. Ramsay Studies Anatolian Studies Presented to Sit< William Mitchell Ramsay. Edd. W. H. Buckler and W. M. Calder. Manchester, 1923. ROA V Rozpravy Oeskoslovenske Akademie Veil. Rend. Pontif. Ace. Rom. Arch. = Atti della pontificia accademia romana di archeologia: Rendiconti. Revue de l'histoi'l'e des religions. Rev. kist. rel. Reynolds and Ward Perkins=]. M. Reynolds and J. B. Ward Perkins, The Inscriptions of Roman TriPolitania. Rome-London, 1952. Riv. stor. dell'antichittl = Rivista storica dell'antichita (Bologna.). Robert, Carie = L. and ] . Robert, La Carie, ii. Paris, 1954· Robert, Glad·iateurs = L. Robert, Les Gladiateurs dans l'Orient grec. Limoges, 1940.
Robert, Noms indigenes= L. Robert, Noms indigenes dans I'Asie Mineure greco-romaine. Partie 1. Paris, 1963. Robert, OAfS= L. Robert, Opera minora sekcta. 5 vols. Amsterdam, 1969- • Roesch, Thespies = P. Roesch, Thespies et la confederation btlotienne. Paris, 1965.
Roscher's Lexikon = \V. H. Roscher, Ausjukrliches Lexikon der grieckischen und romischen Mythologie. Leipzig, r884-1937· Roussel, Delos = P. Roussel, Delos, colonie atktlnienne. Paris, 1916. Roveri = A. Roveri, Studi su Polibio. Studi pubblica.ti dall'Istituto di Filologia. Cla.ssica, I 7· Bologna, 1964. Salmon, Colonization = E. T. Salmon, Roman Colonization under the Republic. London, 1969. Samuel = A. E. Samuel, Ptolemaic Chronology. Miincbener Beitrage, 43· .Munich, 1962. Sarikakis = Th. Ch. Sarikakis, PQMA/01 APXONTEJ: THJ: EllAPXIAJ: MAKEJONIAJ:. Mlpos A'. J1?TJ Tijs lSpva~w~ Tij~ lrra.pxla.~ p.{XJl< Twv XPOI'<J)v Toii A,jyoJaTov (q8-271r. X.). Thessalonica, 1971. Saumagne = C. Saumagne. La Numidie et Rome: i\1asinissa et Jugurtha. Paris, 1966. S.-B. Frankfurt= Sitzungsberichte der Wissenschaftlichen Gesellschaft an der Johann Wolfgang Goethe-Ut~iversitlll, Frankfurt am Main. Schulten, Geograjta A. Schulten, Geografia y etnografla antiguas de Ia Peninsula Iberica. 2 vols. Madrid, 1959-1963. Schulten, Numantia, i and ii = A. Schulten, Numantia: Die Ergebnisse der Ausgrabungen, I905-I2. i. Die Keltiberer und ihre Kriege mit Rom. Munich, 1914. ii. Die Lager des Scipio. Munich, 19z7.
xix
ABBREVIATIONS AND BIBLIOGRAPHY Schluzc, Excerpta = E. H. F. Schulze, De excerptis Constantinianis quaestiones criticae. !Jiss. Hunn, 1lloC.. Scltw.,rtkg<:r 'T. Schwerlkger, Dcr acltiiische LJund von I46 bis 27 v. Chr. Vestigia, I'J. Munich, 1<J74· Scullarcl, /:'trtw:a·/1 Citic.> H. I L Seullard, Tlw h'truscan Cities and Rome. London, I<JI•7· Scullard, .'>'1:ipio Soldier " I L I L Scullard, .'>'cipio Africanu.~. Soldier and Politician. London, I<J70. Scullanl, Tile Elephant = I£. I{. Scullard, Th8 Elephant in the Greek and Roman WoYld. London, 1974· Sethc, UYkunden ii = K. Sethc, Urkundetl des aegyptischen Altertums, ii (Hieroglyphische Urkunden der griechisch-rJmischen Zeit, i). Leipzig, 1904. Shatzman = Israel Shatzman, Senatorial Wealth and Roman Politics. Collection Latomus, 142. Brussels, 1975. Sherk= R. K. Sherk, Roman Documents from the Greek East: Senatus Consulta and Epistulae to the Age of Augustus. Baltimore, 1969. Shimron, Late Sparta = B. Shimron, Late Sparta: the Spartan Revolution, 243-I46 B.C. (Arethusa Monographs, 3·) Buffalo, 1972. Simon = H. Simon, Roms Kriege in Spanien, I54-I33 v. Chr. Frankfurt, 1962. Skeat = T. C. Skeat, The Reigns of the Ptolemies. Miinchener Beitrage, 39. Munich, I954· Smith, Army= R. E. Smith, Service in the Post-Marian Roman Army. Manchester, 1958. Spratt, Tmvels = T. A. B. Spratt, Travels and Researches in Crete. 2 vols. London, 1865. Strasburger, Wesensbestimmung = H. Strasburger, ])ie Wesensbestimmung der Geschichte durch die antike Geschichtsschreibung. Wicsha
J.
Toynbee, Hannibal's Legacy.
2
vols. London, 1965.
ABBREVIATIONS AND BIBLIOGRAPHY P. Treves, ll mito di Alessandro e la Roma d'Augusto. Treves, Alessandro Milan, 1953· van der Mijnsbrugge M. van der Mijnsbrugge, The Cretan Koinon. New York, 1931. van Ooteghem J. van Ooteghem, L. 1kfarcius Philippus et sa famille. Brussels, 1961. van Stra.a.ten 1962.
M. van Straaten, Panaetii Rhodii fragmenta. Ed. 3· Leiden,
Versnel H. S. Versnel, Triumphus: an Inquiry into the Origin, Development and ;\feaning of the Roman Triumph. Leiden, 1970. Volkmann, Massenversklavungen = H. Volkmann, Die Massenversklavungen der Einwohner eroberler Stiidte in der hellenistisch-rihnischen Zeit. (Abhandlungen der Akadcmie der 'Vissenschaften und der Literatur, Gcistes- und sozia.lwissenschaftliche Klasse, 1961, 3.) Wiesba.den, 1961.
von Fritz, Geschithtsschreibung = K. von Fritz, Die griechische Geschichtsschreibung, i. z vols. Berlin, 1967. Walbank, Polybius F. W. Walbank, Polybius. Berkeley-Los AngelesLondon, 1972. Walbank, Speeches = F. W. Walbank, Speeches in Greek Historians. Third
J. L. Myres Memorial Lecture. Oxford, [1965). Warmington B. H. Warmington, Carthage. Ed. 2. Ha.rmondsworth, 1964. Watson, Obligations= A. Watson, The Law of Obligations in the Later Roman Republic. Oxford, 1965. Watson, Persons = A. Watson, The Law of Persons in the Later Roman Repzlblic. Oxford, 1967. Wehrli, Dikaiarchos = F. Wehrli, Die Schule des Aristoteles: Heft I: Dikaiarchos. Ed. 2. Basel, 1967. Wehrli, Hieronymos = F. Wehrli, Die Schule des Aristoteles: Heft ro: Hieronymos von Rhodos, Kritolaos und seine SchUler. Basel-Stuttgart, 1959. Welwei = K.-W. Welwei, Konige und Konigtum im Urteil des Polybios. Diss. Cologne, 1963. Wescher = C. Wescher, La Poliorcetique des Grecs. Paris, 1867. Westermann, Slave Systems = \V. L. Westermann, The Slave Systems of Greek and Roman Antiqtlity. Philadelphia, 1955. Wiener Eranos = Wiener Eranos. Zur 50. Versammlung deutscher Philologen in Graz, 1909. Vienna, 1909. Wilhelm, Neue Beitrilge iv =A. Wilhelm, Neue Beit'Jiage .rur griechischen Inschriftenkunde, iv. In 5.-B. Wien, 179 (1915), 6. Vienna, 1915. Wilkes, Dalmatia= J. J. Wilkes, Dalmatia. London, £969. Will= E. Will, Histoire politique du monde hellenistique (323-30 av. ].-C.). 2 vols. Nancy, 1966-7. Wilson, Emigration= A. J. Wilson, Emigration from Italy in the Republican Age of Rome. lYfanchester, 1966. Winkler, Aegypten =H. Winkler, Rom und Aegypten im 2. ]hdt. v. Chr. Diss. Leipzig, 1933. ZA S = Zeitschrift fur agyptische Sprache und Altertumskunde. Za.ncan = P. Zancan, ll monarcato ellenistico nei suoi elementi federativi. Padua, 1934. Z. Pap. Ep. = Zeitschrijt filr Papyrologie und Epigra.phik. XXI
INTRODUCTION THE ASSIGNMENT OF THE FRAGMENTS 1. BOOK XIX The absence from the Constantinian excerpts and Suidas of any fragments from this book suggests that, like xvii, xxvi, and xxxvii, it was already lost by the tenth century (cf. Moore, GRBS, 1971, 430–31). Since xx contained Ol. 147, 1 (see below), xix must have dealt with the whole of Ol. 146 (196–192). Passages based on P. in Livy xxxiv and xxxv are: xxxiv. 22. 4–41. 7 (195), the war with Nabis, from res Graeciae of Ol. 146, 1 = 196/5; xxxiv. 48. 2–52. 12 (194), Greek events from res Graeciae of Ol. 146, 2 = 195/4; xxxiv. 57. 1–61. 16 (193), events in Italy and Carthage from res Italiae and res Africae of Ol. 146, 3 = 194/3; xxxv. 12. 1–19. 7 (193), 25. 1–39. 8 (192), events from res Graeciae and res Asiae of Ol. 146, 4 = 193/2; xxxv. 42. 1–51. 10, Antiochus' crossing and subsequent events. This last passage seems to refer to Ol. 147, 1 = 192/1, hence the corresponding passage in P. probably came in book xx; Livy will have included it under A.U.C. 562 = 192 so as to end the book (and the pentad) with a striking event (cf. Nissen, Rh. Mus. 1871, 261, modifying his views in KU, 174–6). Only two 'fragments' survive. 1, from Plut. Cato mai. 10. 3, will be from the res Hispaniae of Ol. 146, 1 = 196/5 (cf. Livy, xxxiv. 8. 4–21. 8). 2 is a sentence from Livy, xxxiv. 50. 5–6, which draws on res Graeciae from Ol. 146, 2 (194). 2. BOOK XX These extracts are from the Constantinian excerpts: de legat. gent.: 2 (Antiochus and Boeotia: exc. 5); 3. 1–7 (embassies to Antiochus: exc. 6); 9. 1–11. 10 (negotiations with Aetolians: exc. 7); de uirt. et uit.: 4. 1–7. 5 (condition of Boeotia: exc. 71 and 72); de sent.: 12. 1–7 (Philopoemen at Sparta: exc. 97); 12. 8 (value of oral evidence: exc. 98). In de uirt. et uit. xx. 7. 5 is followed by xxi. 7. 5–6, and has a marginal note: τέλοσ τοῦ κ λόγου τῆς πολυβ\?\ ϊστορίασ. Since xxi. 7. 5–6 corresponds to Livy, xxxvii. 12. 8–9 (substitution of Eudamus for Pausistratus), which refers to 190, book xx evidently contained only the events of Ol. 147, 1 = 192/1, leaving the three remaining years of the olympiad to be dealt with in xxi. It has been argued above that Livy, xxxv. 42. 1–51. 10 corresponds to part of the res Graeciae of Ol. 147, 1 = 192/1; 1 (from Suidas) and 2 (from de legat. gent.) correspond to Livy, xxxv. 45. 9–46. 1 [1]
and 50. 5, and so fall here. Livy, xxxvi. 5. 1–35. 11, relates the Greek campaigns of 191, including Thermopylae, and clearly corresponds to the rest of P.'s res Graeciae for Ol. 147, 1 = 192/1; as we saw (p. 1), Antiochus' arrival in Greece had been described in Livy xxxv for reasons of composition. 3. 1–7 (from de legat. gent.) and 7. 3–5 (from de uirt. et uit.) correspond to Livy, xxxvi. 5 and 6; and 7. 3–5 is preceded in de uirt. et uit. by 4. 1–7. 2, on conditions in Boeotia, a digression clearly belonging here, though omitted by Livy (cf. 7. 4, διὰ τὰς προειρηµένας αἰτίας). Fragments of 4. 1–7. 2 also appear in Athenaeus, x. 418 (6. 6) and Suidas (6. 12). 8. 1–5 (from Athen. x. 439), on Antiochus' wedding, corresponds to Livy, xxxvi. 11. 1, and mentions book xx; 8. 6 is a quotation from Livy, xxxvi. 19. 11, on the battle of Thermopylae. 9. 1–11. 10 (from de legat. gent.) corresponds to Livy, xxxvi. 27–29, and the references to Corax (11. 11) and Aperantia (11. 12) from Stephanus, who says they are from book xx, match Livy, xxxvi. 30. 4 and 33. 7 respectively. If fg. 82 refers to Philip's siege of Lamia (see there), it should stand before 9. 1. This leaves only 12. 1–7 and 12. 8 from de sententiis. The former concerns a Spartan gift to Philopoemen, offered (according to Paus. viii. 51. 2) after an incident in which Philopoemen had closed the gates of Sparta against Flamininus and the Achaean general Diophanes, and settled affairs there himself. Plutarch (Philop. 15) dates the offer of the gift before Diophanes was made general for 192/1; but, despite inaccuracies in Pausanias, his date seems preferable (Aymard, PR, 337–8 n. 25). Errington, III, following Plutarch, dates the offer of the gift to 192; but the absence of other fragments from book xix suggests that it was already lost when the Constantinian excerpts were made, and this is strongly against Errington's view (see p. 1). True, to press this as excluding the Plutarchean date entirely would be to argue in a circle; but the incident seems more properly to be placed in 191 (and book xx) than in 192 (and book xix). According to Plutarch (Philop. 16) Philopoemen's intervention at Sparta preceded Thermopylae (late April, 191). Against this it could be argued that a considerable time may have elapsed between the Spartan incident and the offer of the gift; but if, as seems likely (see below), the Spartan embassy to Rome asking for the restoration of hostages was sent and returned in summer 191, there must have been time for the anti-Achaean party to gain power. Hence there is a good case for bringing this fragment (12. 1–7) forward; and since the events in it precede Thermopylae, it should stand between 8. 5 and 8. 6 (rather than immediately before 9, as Aymard, loc. cit., suggests). The context of 12. 8, on the importance of eyewitness evidence, is unknown. Pédech (Méthode, 359–60) suggests that it is from a passage [2]
in the prologue of xxi, in which P. explained that from this point onwards he was an eyewitness of the events he described. This seems improbable since (a) the passage is a communis locus (cf. xii. 27. 1 n.); (b) the assertion, emphasized by such a position, would tend to detract from the authority of what P. had recorded in his earlier books; (c) if P. was born around 200 (cf. Vol. I, p. 1 n. 1), he would not be a very effective eyewitness for events from 191 (but Pédech puts P.'s birth in 208: LEC, 1961, 145–50). It seems more prudent to leave it an open question whether 12. 8 belongs to xx or xxi, and what its context was. xxi. 1. 1–4, recounting the return of Spartan envoys from Rome, follows xx. 11. 10 in de legat. gent. Aymard (PR, 356 n. 1), following the older editors, restores it to book xx. This must be right; and in its support is the argument (which he does not mention) that since it describes the return of the embassy, it is more likely to be from res Graeciae than from res Italiae, and since the next passage in de legat. gent. is from res Italiae of Ol. 147, 2 = 191/0, xxi. 1. 1–4 will be part of res Graeciae of Ol. 147, 1 = 192/1. Since the dispatch of the embassy suggests that a party hostile to Achaea is in power, the passage will go after 12. 1–7. No fragments survive from res Asiae, but Livy, xxxvi. 41. 1– 45. 8, based on P., corresponds to part of them, including the Roman naval victory off Corycus. 3. BOOK XXI These extracts are from the Constantinian excerpts: de legat. gent.: 1. 1–4 (return of Spartan envoys from Rome: exc. 8); 2. 1–6 (supplicatio after Corycus: Aetolian embassy: exc. 9); 3. 1–4 (embassy from Philip: exc. 10); 3 b 1–2 (Eumenes' embassy to Achaea: exc. 11); 4. 1–5. 13 (negotiations with the Aetolians: exc. 12); 6. 2–6 (Phocaean embassy to Seleucus: exc. 13); 8. 1–3 (Scipios inform L. Aemilius and Eumenes of Aetolian truce: exc. 14); 10. 1–14 (Antiochus negotiates: exc. 15); 13. 1–15. 13 (Antiochus' further proposals: exc. 16); 16. 1–17. 12 (conditions imposed after Magnesia: exc. 17); 18. 1–24. 17 (embassies at Rome: exc. 18); 25. 1–11 (western Greece: exc. 19); 26. 1–19 (further events in western Greece: exc. 20); 29. 1–32. 15 (peace with Aetolia: exc. 21); 33. 1 (Manlius and the Galatian war: exc. 22); 34. 3– 13 (treatment of Moagetes: exc. 23); 35. 1–5 (Termessus: exc. 24); 36. 1–4 (Sagalassus: exc. 25); 39. 1–14 (Tectosages: exc. 26); 41. 1–44. 3 (peace terms for Antiochus: exc. 27); 46. 1–12 (Asian settlement: exc. 28); de legat. Rom.: 11. 1–13 (Antiochus approaches Prusias: exc. 16); 37. 1–3 (Manlius and [3]
Eposognatus: exc. 17); 37. 8–9 (more on Galatians: exc. 17 cont.); de sent.: 32 c 1–4 (Philopoemen's wisdom: exc. 99); 40 (on Ariarathes: exc. 100); 47 (Roman march through Thrace: exc. 101); de uirt. et uit.: 7. 5–6 (Rhodian admirals: exc. 73); 9. 1–3 (character of Diophanes: exc. 74); 34. 1–2 (Moagetes: exc. 75); de strategematis (T): 27. 2–6 (Ambracia: Wescher, 328). Book xxi contained Ol. 147, 2 = 191/0, 147, 3 = 190/89 and 147, 4 = 189/8. In addition to the fragments there are these passages of Polybian provenance in Livy (square brackets indicate where this provenance is in doubt): [xxxvii. 1. 1–6 (A.U.C. 564 = 190): res Italiae of Ol. 147, 2 = 191/0. Reception of Aetolian embassy at Rome. Nissen (KU, 188) makes this Polybian, comparing xxi. 2; but doubts subsist.] xxxvii. 4. 6–45. 21 (A.U.C. 564 = 190): res Graeciae and res Asiae of Ol. 147, 2 = 191/0. [xxxvii. 49. 1–8 (A.U.C. 564 = 190): despite Nissen (KU, 197–8), who compares Diod. xxix. 9, this account of an Aetolian embassy to Rome may be annalistic.] xxxvii. 52. 7–56. 10 (A.U.C. 564 = 190): embassies at Rome; Nissen (KU, 198–200) makes this Polybian. [xxxvii. 60. 1–7 (A.U.C. 564 = 190): Cretan affairs. Nissen (KU, 200–1) makes this Polybian; but its position before the Aetolian fighting is odd, if it is from P.'s res Graeciae and it may be annalistic.] If this and the two previous passages are Polybian they will be from the res Italiae and res Graeciae of Ol. 147, 3 = 190/89. xxxviii. 1. 1–27. 9 (A.U.C. 565 = 189): Cephallenia and Galatians; from the res Graeciae and res Asiae of Ol. 147, 3 = 190/89. xxxviii. 28. 5–34. 9 (A.U.C. 565 = 189): on Achaea; res Graeciae of Ol. 147, 4 = 189/8. xxxviii. 37. 1–41. 11 (A.U.C. 566 = 188): Asian settlement; res Asiae of Ol. 147, 4 = 189/8. For the argument that 1. 1–4 should stand in book xx see above, p. 3. Since the naval victory of Corycus (2. 1) was in late autumn, 191 (see Livy, xxxvi, 44. 1–45. 8, especially 45. 8, 'cum iam hiems appeteret'), the Aetolian embassy mentioned in this same fragment of de legat. gent. will also fall in winter 191/0 (cf. Livy, xxxvii. 1). The position of 3. 1–4 in the same collection dates Philip's embassy also to 191/0; this fragment is followed in de legat. gent. by 3 b, evidently from the res Graeciae of Ol. 147, 2 = 191/0. Livy, who devotes only xxxvii. 4. 6–7. 7 to res Graeciae before hastening on to Asia, omits this detail concerning Eumenes' approach to Achaea, but the troops are mentioned in Livy, xxxvii. 20. 1. 4. 1–5. 13 from the same collection deals with Athenian intervention to secure a truce in the [4]
Aetolian War; the corresponding passage in Livy, xxxvii. 6. 4–7. 7, shows that it is still part of res Graeciae of 190. 6. 2–6 (also from de legat. gent.) refers to Phocaea and is rightly preceded by a passage from Suidas; this, 6. 1, corresponds to Livy, xxxvii. 9. 1, and the mention of two priests of Cybele in 6. 7, also from Suidas, corresponds to Livy, xxxvii. 9. 9 (which thus locates the incident at Abydus). But Livy has omitted the dispatch of envoys to Seleucus mentioned in 6. 2–6, and it is possible that these events were described by P. at a point in his narrative corresponding to Livy, xxxvii. 11. 15, where the betrayal of Phocaea to Seleucus is mentioned. In that case 6. 2–6 would stand after 7. 1–4, a passage from Suidas describing Pausistratus' fire-machine, which corresponds to Livy, xxxvii. 11. 13. All three passages are from the res Asiae of Ol. 147, 2 = 191/0. 7. 5–7 is a combination of a passage from de uirt. et uit. and several extracts from Suidas; 'Pamphilidas' is an error for Eudamus, and the passage corresponds to Livy, xxxvii. 12. 7–9, which is still drawing on the res Asiae of Ol. 147, 2 = 191/0. If fg. 142 corresponds to Livy, xxxvii. 11. 7, it will stand before 7. 1–4 (see 7. 1–7 n.); and fg. 154, which seems to correspond to Livy, xxxvii. 14. 5, will stand between 7. 7 and 8. 1. 8. 1–3, from de legat. gent., refers to the same summer; there is no corresponding item in Livy, but Livy, xxxvii. 14. 3 mentions the arrival of L. Aemilius Regillus and Eumenes in Samos. 9. 1–3 on Diophanes' character is from de uirt. et uit. and 10. 1–14 on Antiochus' negotiations from de legat. gent.; the first links with Diophanes' arrival, described in Livy, xxxvii. 20. 1 ff., and the second with Livy, xxxvii. 18. 10 ff. The order of these two fragments should therefore be reversed (cf. Steigemann, 32; Büttner-Wobst, Phil. 1900, 572–3; Aymard, PR, 374 n. 12); fg. 228 (cf. Livy, xxxvii. 18. 8) will stand between 8. 3 and 10. 1; 11. 1–13, from de legat. Rom., dealing with Antiochus' approach to Prusias, corresponds to Livy, xxxvii. 25. 4–14; and its position in res Asiae of Ol. 147, 2 = 191/0 is further confirmed by the marginal note: λ\?\ κά i.e. book xxi. The flight of the pirates in 12 (from Suidas) corresponds to Livy, xxxvii. 27. 5. Antiochus' further attempt to negotiate, described in 13. 1–15. 13 (from de legat. gent.) corresponds to Livy, xxxvii. 34. 1–36. 9; and 16. 1–17. 12, which follows in the same collection, and relates the terms imposed after Magnesia, corresponds to Livy, xxxvii. 45. 3– 21. Livy's continuous narrative demonstrates that P.'s account of the Asian events of Ol. 147, 2 = 191/0 went down as far as the battle of Magnesia and its immediate sequel, even though this involved considerably overrunning the olympiad year. 18. 1–24. 17, from de legat. gent. describes the embassies sent to Rome in winter 190/89; the corresponding passage is Livy, xxxvii. 52. 7–56. 10 (which however ceases to transcribe P. at 24. 15). Although Livy has included these details under A.U.C. 564 = 190, they [5]
must have formed part of the res Italiae of Ol. 147, 3 = 190/89, and in fact 189, in P. The res Graeciae of that year begin at 25. 1–11, also from de legat. gent. This, and the next fragment, also from the same collection, 26. 1–19, both recount events of western Greece of 189 and correspond to Livy, xxxviii. 3. 1–8 and 3. 9–11 (Livy omits the adventure of the Aetolians described in 26. 6–19). Three passages from Anon. de obsid. tol. (ed. van der Berg), 169–74, 97–99, and 178– 95, are transcribed from P. and represent 27. 1–6, 27. 7–9, and 28. 1–17; all three deal with the siege of Ambracia, and that they form part of P.'s account can be seen from a comparison with Livy, xxxviii. 5. 1–5, 5. 6–9, 7. 4–8. 1. This assures their position. The first (27. 1–6) also overlaps de strateg. (T) for 27. 2–6 (this MS. is headed ΑΜΒΡ ΑΚΙΑΣ ΠΟΛΙΟΡΚΙΑ ΠΟΛΥΒΙΟΥ Β\\?\ ΚΑ); the third passage, 28. 1–17, is also in T, which continues a sentence further (28. 18). 29. 1–32. 15, from de legat. gent., deals with the Aetolian peace and corresponds to Livy, xxxviii. 9. 3–11. 9; it is thus still part of the events of Ol. 147, 3 = 190/89 (i.e. 189), and although it includes the hearing of envoys and ratification of peace at Rome, it seems to form part of the res Graeciae of that olympiad year (as the corresponding passage in Livy confirms). 32 b from Suidas on the capture of Same corresponds to Livy, xxxviii. 29. 10, and 32 c from de sent. refers to the restoration of Spartan exiles described in Livy, xxxviii. 34. 1–5; though Livy has these events under A.U.C. 565 = 189, both passages clearly belong to res Graeciae of Ol. 147, 4 = 189/8 (cf. Livy, xxxviii. 33. 1, ueris initio). 32 c 4 is difficult and, towards the end of the passage, impossible to decipher, but it appears to refer to steps taken the same year to prevent the restoration of the Spartan monarchy. Since however 32 b and 32 c belong to Ol. 147, 4 = 189/8, whereas 33–39 is still part of Ol. 147, 3 = 190/89, the two passages must be postponed to a place between 39 and 40. 33–39 consists of a group of fragments set in order by reference to the Polybian account of Manlius Vulso's Galatian campaign in Livy; they are: 33. 1 (de legat. gent.: Livy, xxxviii. 12. 1); 33. 2 (Suidas: Livy, xxxviii. 12. 7); 34. 1–2 (de uirt. et uit.: Livy, xxxviii. 14. 3); 34. 3– 13 (de legat. gent.: Livy, xxxviii. 14. 4–14); 35. 1–5 (de legat. gent.: Livy, xxxviii. 15. 3–6); 36. 1–4 (de legat. gent.: Livy, xxxviii. 15. 7–11); 37. 1–3 (de legat. Rom.: Livy, xxxviii. 18. 1– 3); 37. 4–7 (Suidas: Livy, xxxviii. 18. 7–9); 37. 8–9 (de legat. Rom.: Livy, xxxviii. 18. 10–15); 38. 1–7 (Plut. Mor. 258 c: Livy, xxxviii. 24. 2–11); 39. 1–14 (de legat. gent.: Livy, xxxviii. 25. 1–11). They clearly belong to res Asiae of Ol. 147, 3 = 190/89 (i.e. 189). 40 (from de sent.) is a fragmentary passage about Ariarathes, which in M follows 32 c 4 without any mark of separation. Hultsch (ad loc.) suggests that it belongs at 41. 4–5, where he suspects com[6]
pression in our extract. In any case it must, in view of its position, refer to Ol. 147, 4 = 189/8. Comparison with Livy, xxxviii. 37. 1– 39. 2, shows that 41. 1–44. 3 (from de legat. gent.), dealing with negotiations with Manlius and the peace with Antiochus, forms part of res Asiae of Ol. 147, 4 = 189/8. As we saw (above p. 6), 32 b and 32 c fall between 39 and 40 (or, if Hultsch's hypothesis concerning 40 is accepted, between 39. 14 and 41. 1). 45, from Suidas, also concerns Ariarathes: comparison with Livy, xxxviii. 39. 6 assures its position. 46. 1–12 (from de legat. gent.), on the final Asian settlement, corresponds to Livy, xxxviii. 39. 7–40. 1, and is therefore in place. 47, a fragmentary passage from de sent., deals with the Roman return through Thrace; see Livy, xxxviii. 40–41 (188), which indicates that, although recounting events in Europe, P. described Manlius' return here rather than under the res Graeciae of Ol. 148, 1 = 188/7, as a strict interpretation of his scheme might have suggested. (The alternative—to make the march through Thrace a pendant to the res Graeciae of Ol. 147, 4 = 189/8—would have involved describing it before the settlement in Asia.) 4. BOOK XXII 1 and 2 list topics from P. which were to be included in de legat. gent. and de legat. Rom.; the former (excc. 29–30) follow directly after xxi. 46. 1–2, the latter (exc. 18) after xxi. 37. 3. Büttner-Wobst introduces them as 'ex Polybii libro xxii excerpenda' but there is no reference to book xxii in the MSS., and Steigemann, 35, correctly observes that there is no absolute proof that that book contained all Ol. 148. However, these lists occurring at this point strengthen that hypothesis. They omit passages which figure in the excerpts (xxii. 3–5, 12. 5–10 are omitted from 1, xxii. 15 is omitted from 2) and mention others which do not (xxii. 1. 2–4 and xxii. 2. 1 have nothing corresponding in the text of the excerpts); nor are the topics invariably mentioned in their proper order. Thus the words ἡ γενοµένη σφαγὴ . . . τὰ προσταχθέντα διὰ τού των in xxii. 1. 5 occur between references to the negotiations at Tempe and Thessalonica on the one hand and those between Q. Metellus and the Achaeans on the other; yet it is clear that they refer to Ap. Claudius' embassy (xxii. 13–14), which took place the year after that of Q. Metellus (cf. Aymard, études, 18–19). Hence the lists are useful mainly as an indication that the events included probably occurred in Ol. 148. The following extracts are from the Constantinian excerpts: de legat. gent.: 3. 1–9 (Philopoemen sends Nicodemus to Rome; the Achaeans renew their alliance with Ptolemy V: exc. 31); 4. 1–17 (trouble in Boeotia: exc. 32); 5. 1–10 (dispute between Rhodes and Lycia: exc. 33); 6. 1–6 (reports at Rome; Q. Metellus sent to interview Philip: exc. 34); 7. 1– 10. 15 (embassies from kings to Achaea: [7]
Q. Metellus in Peloponnese: exc. 35); 11. 1–12. 10 (Q. Metellus reports to Rome; other envoys there: exc. 36); 14. 7–12 (Philip decides to send Demetrius to Rome: exc. 37); de legat. Rom.: 13. 1–14. 8 (Philip's massacre at Maronea: exc. 19); 15. 1–6 (affairs in Crete: exc. 20); de uirt. et uit.: 17. 1–7 (Ptolemy breaks his word to the rebels: exc. 76); 20. 1–8 (Apollonis, Attalus' wife: exc. 77); 21. 1–4 (Ortiagon's ambitions: exc. 78); 22. 1–5 (Aristonicus the eunuch: exc. 79); de sent.: 16. 1–4 (Philip II and Ptolemy V compared: exc. 102); 18. 1–11 (Philip V's responsibility for the Third Macedonian War: exc. 103); 19. 1–4 (dispute between Philopoemen and Archon: exc. 104). No fragment is attributed to any particular year of the olympiad, and only at 18. 1 is the olympiad mentioned in the text. Some help is forthcoming from Livy. In xxiii. 9 P. records under Ol. 149, 2 = 183/2 the arrival at Rome of several embassies and of Q. Marcius Philippus, who had been in Greece and Macedonia; Livy, xl. 2. 6 has the same event under A.U.C. 572 = 182. Marcius' departure is recounted in xxiii. 4. 16, which appears to be dealing with Ol. 149, 1 = 184/3, and this fits Livy, xxxix. 48. 5, who makes it A.U.C. 571 = 183. Marcius, then, probably left in spring 183. If we work back through the Polybian parts of Livy from this point, we get this result: Livy xxxviii. 1–11 (A.U.C. 565 = 189): res Graeciae of Ol. 147, 3 = 190/89 (see above, p. 4). xxxviii. 12–27 (A.U.C. 565 = 189): res Asiae of Ol. 147, 3 = 190/89 (see above, p. 4). xxxviii. 28. 5–34. 9 (A.U.C. 565 = 189): res Graeciae of Ol. 147, 4 = 189/8 (see above, p. 4). xxxviii. 37. 1–41. 11 (A.U.C. 566 = 188): res Asiae of Ol. 147, 4 = 189/8, in effect 188 (see above, p. 4). Livy takes nothing from P. in A.U.C. 567 = 187 or A.U.C. 568 = 186. xxxix. 23. 5–29. 2 (A.U.C. 569 = 185): res Macedoniae of Ol. 148, 3 = 186/5, in effect 185. xxxix. 33. 1–37. 21 (A.U.C. 570 = 184): res Macedoniae et Graeciae of Ol. 148, 4 = 185/4, in effect 184. xxxix. 46. 6–50. 11, 53 (A.U.C. 571 = 183): res Italiae, res Macedoniae, res Graeciae of Ol. 149, 1 = 184/3; see below, p. 16, on Philopoemen's death. The correspondence is clear and facilitates the assigning of the Polybian fragments to the various years of Ol. 148. 6. 1–6, a compressed fragment from de legat. gent., corresponds to Livy, xxxix. 24, where it falls in the middle of an account of Philip's war-preparations. This might suggest that although it concerns the arrival of embassies at Rome, it formed part of res Macedoniae of [8]
Ol. 148, 3 = 186/5; and so Nissen (KU, 332) assumes. However, the pluperfect tenses in Livy, xxxix. 24. 6–12 show that he is referring to earlier events belonging to the previous winter (186/5), before the sending of the envoys gives him a lead into the conference at Tempe (185) in Livy, xxxix. 24. 13–14. P., however, has plain aorists in 6. 1–6, and he probably reported the embassies at Rome under res Italiae in the normal way. Livy will have incorporated their reception in the Macedonian section for compositional reasons, the insertion beginning at § 5, rediere deinde causae. This hypothesis is confirmed by the order in which the events are listed in 1. 1–3. A short passage from Suidas, 6. 7, seems to be dealing with conditions in Aenus before Philip seized it; but since it may have formed part of some (now lost) explanation of the background of Philip's action—even coming somewhere within the compressed passage, 6. 1–6—one is scarcely justified in moving it to precede 6. 1 (see further ad loc.). The three preceding excerpts in de legat. gent. (3. 1–9, 4. 1–17, 5. 1–10) refer, the first two to Greek, the third to Asian affairs, and apparently belong to res Graeciae and res Asiae of Ol. 148, 1 = 188/7 or Ol. 148, 2 = 187/6—though they could fall in different olympiad years provided that 5 is not earlier than 3 and 4. Which year they do belong to has been a matter of debate. 3. 1–4 is much compressed. It mentions the massacre of Compasium, recorded in Livy, xxxviii. 33, which (see above, p. 8) relates the events of 189/8 (in fact 188: cf. Livy, xxxviii. 33. 1, ueris initio); next it refers to the dispatch of Spartan envoys to Rome, where they procured a letter from M. Lepidus, when he was consul (A.U.C. 567 = 187), and finally describes how, while the Spartans were still at Rome, Philopoemen sent Nicodemus of Elis to represent him there. Aymard (études, 18–30) has argued that Philopoemen must have acted as general, that this is his strategia of 187/6, and consequently that Nicodemus was sent to Rome in autumn, 187 (i.e. in Ol. 148, 2 = 187/6); having been delayed at Rome for some time, he reported back in the strategia of Aristaenus (186/5), cf. 7. 5. This implies that 3 and 4 are from res Graeciae of 187/6 and 5 from res Asiae of the same year. This chronology and assignment of the fragments has been challenged by Büttner-Wobst (Beiträge, 3–13) and, more recently, by Errington, 255–62. Büttner-Wobst assumes that Livy's Greek dates are all two years out, so that events of (e.g.) 188/7 are dated by him to 186/5; hence he puts Philopoemen's strategia of 3. 2–3 back to 189/8. Errington also makes this strategia that of 189/8, but since he accepts the accuracy of Livy's chronology, he has to assume that 7–10 contains a conflation of events belonging to 187 and 185, the break coming between 9. 14 and 10. 1. However, he proffers no explanation of such a major dislocation and contamination. Against the hypotheses of Büttner-Wobst and Errington see 3. 1–4 nn.; despite some [9]
difficulties, mentioned there, Aymard's chronology seems the most plausible. But on either view the order of the fragments remains unaffected. 3. 5–9 records a Ptolemaic embassy to Achaea. 6. 1–6 corresponds to Livy, xxxix. 24. 6–14 (see above, p. 8); but Livy, xxxix. 23. 5 is clearly a drastically compressed précis of the fragment of the de sent. now printed as 18. 1– 11, in which P. argues that Philip, not Perseus, planned the Third Macedonian War.1 Livy sums up its argument in one sentence, but gives an account of Philip's grievances clearly taken from a passage in P., no longer extant. De Sanctis (iv. 1. 250 n. 24) therefore argued that (assuming Livy's order to be also P.'s) 18. 1–11 should stand before 6. 1–6. This calls for two comments. First, as we have seen (pp. 8–9), 6. 1–6 probably forms part of res Italiae of Ol. 148, 3 = 186/5, the position of the corresponding passage in Livy, xxxix. 24. 6–12 among res Macedoniae being due merely to Livy's compositional technique; in which case 18. 1–11 need not precede 6. 1–6. But there is a more serious difficulty. In the excerpts de sent. 18. 1– 11 is preceded by 16. 1–4, a passage hard to decipher, but clearly contrasting Philip II's clemency after Chaeronea and Ptolemy V's breach of faith to the Egyptian rebels. 17. 1–7, from the de uirt. et uit., has one sentence in common with 16. 4 (at 17. 5), and the two extracts form part of a single passage belonging to the res Aegypti. But if 18. 1–11 belongs to res Macedoniae of Ol. 148, 3 = 186/5, then the comparison of Philip II and Ptolemy V should belong to res Aegypti of Ol. 148, 2 = 187/6, and so stand after 5. 10.2 But, according to 17. 5, Ptolemy V was 25 at the time of the action against the rebels; and since he was born on 30 Mesore 210 (9 October 210)—cf. xviii. 53. 4 n.; Volkmann, RE, 'Ptolemaios (23)', col. 1691; some scholars have made the year 209—his twenty-fifth birthday was on 30 Mesore (2 October) 185. This is an obstacle (and perhaps an insuperable one) to assigning 16–17 to Ol. 148, 2 = 187/6, as one is led to do if 18. 1–11 belongs to Ol. 148, 3 = 186/5. On the other hand, if 16–17 is from res Aegypti [10]
1
Livy also makes the point about Philip's responsibility for the war with Perseus at the end of the same Polybian passage, viz. at Livy, xxxix. 29. 3; and it could be argued that 18. 1–11 came at a point in P. corresponding to this rather than at a point corresponding to Livy, xxxix. 23. 5. This would not affect the order of the fragments (beyond excluding the possibility that 18. 1–11 preceded 6. 1–6); but the account of Philip's grievances (Livy, xxxix. 23. 6–13) is so closely linked with the statement in Livy, xxxix. 23. 5 that this seems likely to be derived from 18. 1–11, and Livy, xxxix. 29. 3 to be merely a repetition of the opening passage, designed to round off the section. 2 Steigemann, 40, argued that, because 18. 1 begins with the words ὅτι φησὶν ὁ Πολύβιος ἐν τῷ εἰκοστῷ δευτέρῳ, this fragment must be the first extract from that book in the de sent., hence that 16 must belong to Ol. 147, 4 = 189/8, which would bring it forward into book xxi. But 16 and 17 cannot be separated, and the reference to Ptolemy's age excludes Ol. 147, 4 as a date for the events mentioned. See further, p. 12.
of Ol. 148, 3 = 186/5, then 18. 1–11 must go into Ol. 148, 4 = 185/4, and the statement in Livy, xxxix. 23. 5, about Philip's responsibility for the Third Macedonian War must be assumed to have been brought forward from a later passage in P. This is difficult to believe, for two reasons. First, it does not match Livy's normal practice, which is to keep close to the Polybian text (the incorporation of Livy, xxxix. 24. 6–12 from the res Italiae (see above, pp. 8–9) is a rather different matter, and can be paralleled in Livy, xxxix. 33. 1–8, which describes the decisions at Rome as a lead in to the embassy of Ap. Claudius of 184); and second, it is not easy to fit such a passage as 18. 1–11 into the Polybian narrative of Ol. 148, 4 = 185/4, as an examination of the remaining Greek fragments will show. 7. 1–10. 15 relates discussion in Achaea and at 10. 1 mentions Q. Metellus' arrival from Macedonia. 6. 6 and Livy, xxxix. 24. 13 ff. show that Metellus was in Macedonia and Greece in 185; consequently 7. 1–10. 15 forms part of res Graeciae of Ol. 148, 3 = 186/5, in fact 185.1 (Livy, having omitted to recount Metellus' visit to the Peloponnese after xxxix. 29. 1–2, mentions it in parenthesis in xxxix. 35. 5–8, when introducing Ap. Claudius' embassy in 184.) The fragment 7. 1–10. 15 is followed in the excerpts de legat. gent. by 11. 1–12. 10, describing Metellus' report at Rome and the various embassies. Clearly this belongs to the next res Italiae, of Ol. 148, 4 = 185/4. This in turn is followed, in the same excerpts, by 14. 7– 12, which overlaps with 13. 1–14. 8 from the de legat. Rom. Comparison with Livy, xxxix. 34–35, which gives his version of the Macedonian events of 184 from P., confirms that 13. 1–14. 12 is from res Macedoniae of Ol. 148, 4 = 185/4. But if 18. 1–11 is also part of the res Macedoniae of Ol. 148, 4 = 185/4 (as seems to follow from putting 16–17 in Ol. 148, 3 = 186/5), what will be its relationship to 13. 1–14. 12? Comparison with Livy, xxxix. 33. 1–35. 4 shows that it is very difficult to find any place for the discussion of the causes of the Third Macedonian War in this context, for Livy, xxxix. 33. 1–8 gives the preliminaries at Rome and 34. 1–35. 4 gives Philip's actions at Maronea, the interview with Ap. Claudius, Philip's reaction, and his decision to send Demetrius to Rome, in a form which corresponds exactly with P.'s account in 13–14. The departure of the Roman envoys to the Peloponnese in Livy, xxxix. 35. 5 follows immediately on the passage corresponding to 14. 12, and it is clear that there was no place here for a discussion of the remote causes of the war. On the contrary, 14. 8 clearly implies Philip's warlike plans and suggests that P. has already discussed them elsewhere. It therefore looks as if De Sanctis was right in bringing 18. 1–11 forward into Ol. 148, 3 = 186/5 (though not in placing it before [11]
1
For Errington's hypothesis of a break between 7. 1–9. 14 (188/7) an 10. 1–15 (186/5) see above, pp. 9–10.
6. 1–6: see above, p. 10). But in that case, what is to be done with 16–17, which should precede 18 because of the order in the de sent.? There seem to be two alternatives. (a) It is possible that this is a rare example of the excerpts' appearing in the wrong order, and that the copyist of M (de sent.) omitted 18. 1–11 and then, after copying 16. 1–4, returned to it. On this hypothesis 18. 1–11 could belong to Ol. 148, 3 = 186/5 and 16–17 to the res Aegypti of the same year. One fact at least might seem to favour this theory. 18. 1–11 begins with the words ὅτι φησὶν ὁ Πολύβιος ἐν τῷ εἰκοστῷ δευτέρῳ. If in the original manuscript of the de sent. 18. 1–11 was the first extract from book xxii, the copyist of M (or some earlier intermediary) may have accidentally omitted it and, having discovered his error while copying the passage comparing Philip II and Ptolemy V (16. 1–4), have inserted it one place late, but retaining the introductory words. Against this is the fact that such dislocations are very rare; and further, the poor condition and fragmentary character of M prevents our knowing the usual practice of the original scribe of the de sent. or the copyist of M in indicating changes of book. In other of the Constantinian collections, references to books, normally in the margin, usually (but not invariably: cf. xxviii. 18. 1) indicate the beginning of a new book; see for example xx. 4. 1, xxvii. 12. 1, xxxi. 6. 1. Since however to assume such a dislocation here would both account for the book reference at 18. 1 (which had already led Steigemann to an untenable theory: see p. 10 n. 2), and produce an order of fragments consistent with the indications in Livy and the evidence for the age of Ptolemy V, it has much in its favour. (b) Alternatively, 16–17 must be from the res Aegypti of Ol. 148, 2 = 187/6. Against this is the reference in 17. 7 to Ptolemy V as being 25 years old (see above, p. 10). But it could be argued that P. or the excerptor (often careless at the beginning and end of an extract) has not clearly differentiated between being 25 and being in his twenty-fifth year (this error is in fact to be found in n. 76 of Dittenberger's commentary on OGIS 90, discussing this very passage; and see xxiii. 12. 1 n.); or the excerptor could have omitted some word such as σχεδόν. As between these two alternatives the first seems, on balance, preferable; in which case 16–17 will stand between 10. 15 and 11. 1 as res Aegypti of Ol. 148, 3 = 186/5 (and 18 will stand after 6. 7).1 [12]
1
Büttner-Wobst (Beiträge, 8) mentions with approval the suggestion of Schweighaeuser (vii. 516) that the mercenaries raised by Aristonicus in Greece (17. 6) were enrolled by virtue of the renewed alliance between Ptolemy and Achaea (3. 5–6); this is quite feasible with 16–17 as part of the res Aegypti of Ol. 148, 3 = 186/5, but of course the mercenaries may have nothing to do with Achaea.
We must assume that the events leading to the surrender of the rebels at Sais took place late in 185, when Ptolemy was already 25 years old. They will have been discouraged by the final collapse in 186 of the long-standing rebellion in Upper Egypt. See Addenda, p. 793. In the excerpts de legat. Rom. 13. 1–14. 8 (which overlaps with 14. 7–12 in de legat. gent.) is followed by 15. 1–6, dealing with Cretan affairs; the reference to Ap. Claudius shows that this belongs to res Graeciae of Ol. 148, 4 = 185/4, in fact 184. 19. 1–4 is from the excerpts de sent., where it follows 18. 1–11. It refers to a strategia of Archon, held during Philopoemen's lifetime, but the incident described need not be in its correct chronological place, but may have been introduced in some other context. On that assumption the passage is merely pinned down to the area between Ol. 148. 3 = 186/5 (the date of 18. 1–11 or possibly 16. 1–7: see above p. 12) and Ol. 149, 2 = 183/2 (xxiii. 10. 3, the next passage in M). But it is on the whole more likely that P. related the story in its proper place, in which case Archon must have been general after 186/5 and consequently (since this is the only vacant year before Philopoemen's death) in 184/3; see Aymard, études, 31. In that case (as De Sanctis, iv. 1. 242 n. 14, saw), this fragment is from book xxiii (since it refers to Ol. 149, 1 = 184/3) and stands before or after xxiii. 6 (see below, p. 15). Three fragments, 20, 21, and 22, are from the excerpts de uirt. et uit., where they follow 17. 7. Since the next passage in P is xxiii. 5. 4–14, which must be from the res Italiae of Ol. 149, 1 = 184/3— see below, p. 15—these three fragments must belong to res Asiae and res Aegypti in Ol. 148, i.e. to 185/4 at the latest; and since 17. 7 is from the res Aegypti of 186/5 (see above, p. 12), the year in each case must be 185/4. 20 concerns Apollonis, Attalus' wife, and the visit paid by two of her sons to Cyzicus; but it must be mentioned out of place, since it occurred later than the peace between Eumenes and Prusias (20. 8) which was itself after Flamininus' embassy of 183 (xxiii. 5. 1), and so in Ol. 149, 1 = 184/3. Apollonis may have been mentioned in relation to Cyzicus, which was allied to Eumenes against Prusias. Ortiagon (21) may also be mentioned in the context of this war, in which he supported Prusias (iii. 3. 6 n. and references quoted there). 22. 1–5 on the eunuch Aristonicus (already mentioned at 17. 6) will fall under res Aegypti. All these three passages will therefore remain in their present position. There is a further and perhaps decisive argument in favour of dating the surrender of the rebels at Sais to autumn 185. According to the second Philae decree (see xxii. 16. 1–17. 7 n.) the success of Eumenus (?) — who is probably Comanus (Peremans–van 't Dack, Prosopographica: Studia Hellenistica, 9 (Louvain, 1953), 27–28; cf. xxviii. 19. 1 n.)—was reported to the synod held at Alexandria on 6 September 186 by Aristonicus. This can scarcely be reconciled with the statement (17. 6) that after the surrender of the rebels at Sais Epiphanes went on to meet and take over mercenaries from Aristonicus at Naucratis, if these events took place late in 186, when Epiphanes was in his twenty-fifth year. But to date the events at Sais earlier than the Alexandrian synod is ruled out by the reference to Epiphanes' age. The most natural assumption is therefore that Aristonicus left for his recruiting visit to Greece after the synod of 186 and returned to Egypt in autumn 185. 5. BOOK XXIII The next firm point comes in book xxvii, where manuscripts of de legat. gent. (Y) and of
de legat. Rom. (U and V in the margins) [13]
record that xxvii. 1and 3 are from λόγος κζ, and the manuscript of de uirt. et uit. (P) also has λο κζ at xxvii. 12. On the likely assumption (see above, p. 7) that book xxii contained Ol. 148, it thus appears that olympiads 149, 150, and 151 were covered in books xxiii, xxiv, xxv, and xxvi. The Constantinian excerpts (and Suidas, which derived from them) contain no fragments from Ol. 151; and this is most easily explained if Ol. 151 was covered in a single book which was lost early. There is however one difficulty. Athenaeus (x. 439) attributes to book xxvi a passage on Antiochus Epiphanes which links closely with Athen. v. 193–4 and can be shown, by a comparison with Livy, xli. 20, to refer to Ol. 151, 1 = 176/5 (in fact 175); but Athen. x. 445 contains a passage, which is also attributed to book xxvi, but can be shown owing to an overlap with other excerpts to belong to Ol. 150, 2 = 179/8. If both attributions are true, book xxvi covered two olympiads, and this both Schweighaeuser (iv. 333–56) and Steigemann, 34, believed. But P. is very unlikely to have covered the events of 180–172 in a single book, and since that assumption leaves the absence of fragments from Ol. 151 (but not Ol. 150) unexplained, it seems more likely that the book reference in Athen. x. 445 is erroneous, and that Ol. 151 was covered in book xxvi. This leaves two olympiads, 149 and 150, for three books, xxiii, xxiv, and xxv. There is no quite conclusive evidence showing what the division was; for an apparent dearth of events may merely mirror the excerptors' choice or the extent to which Livy has drawn on P. Moreover the lacunae in our text of Livy xli make this a poor guide in any case. Nevertheless, the material that has survived favours the hypothesis that Ol. 149, 1–2 was dealt with in xxiii, Ol. 149, 3–4 in xxiv and Ol. 150 in xxv, which is how Büttner-Wobst arranges his text. Nissen (Rh. Mus. 1871, 266–7) assigned Ol. 149, 1 to xxiii, and Ol. 149. 2–4 to xxiv, because he believed Ol. 149, 1 = 184/3 to be crowded with events, including the deaths of Scipio, Hannibal, and Philopoemen; but that is improbable (see below, p. 16). We may now turn to the fragments of Ol. 149, 1–2. These extracts are from the Constantinian excerpts: de legat. gent.: 1. 1–4. 16 (Greek embassies at Rome: exc. 38); 5. 1–3 (Deinocrates: exc. 39); 5. 14–18 (more on Deinocrates: exc. 39 cont.)—these two passages are continuous in the excerpts; 6. 1–3 (envoys from Spartan exiles murdered: exc. 40); 7. 1–7 (Demetrius' return to Macedon: exc. 41); 9. 1–15 (Greek envoys at Rome: Marcius' report: exc. 42); 16. 1–13 (Messenians capitulate: exc. 43); 17. 1–18. 5 (envoys to Rome: Sparta readmitted into the Achaean federation: exc. 44); de legat. Rom.: 8. 1–7 (Q. Marcius in Macedonia: Philip's Thracian campaign: exc. 21); de uirt. et uit.: 5. 4–14 (Deinocrates: exc. 80); 10. 1–15 (Philip's [14]
crimes and disasters: exc. 81); 12. 3, 7 (Philopoemen's merits: exc. 82); 12. 8–9 (ambition and frankness of Philopoemen: exc. 83); 13. 2 (Hannibal's merits: exc. 84); 14. 1–4 (Scipio's ambitions: exc. 85); de sent.: 10. 3 (Philip's conscience: exc. 105); 10. 15–16 (Philip imprisons his enemies' children: Fortune avenges this: exc. 106); 11. 1–8 (Philip's speech to his sons: exc. 107); 12. 3–6 (Philopoemen's character: exc. 108); 14. 5–12 (Scipio and money: exc. 109); 15. 1–3 (on destroying trees and the like in war: exc. 110). Again Livy is helpful. The parts where he has drawn on P. are: Livy, xxxix. 46. 6–50. 11 (A.U.C. 571 = 183); see p. 8. Livy, xxxix. 53. 1–16 (A.U.C. 571 = 183); see p. 8. Livy, xl. 3. 1–16. 3 (A.U.C. 572 = 182): res Macedoniae. 1. 1–4. 16 corresponds to Livy, xxxix. 46, and describes the arrival of Greek embassies at Rome; it must belong to res Italiae of Ol. 149. 1 = 184/3. 5. 1–18 is made up from de legat. gent., de uirt. et uit., and two passages from Suidas (5. 5 and 5. 9), with an overlap at 5. 14. It concerns Deinocrates' behaviour at Rome, where he found Flamininus appointed envoy to the east. The year is unchanged, as a comparison of 6. 1–3 (res Graeciae) and 7. 1–7 (res Macedoniae), which follow on in de legat. gent., with Livy, xxxix. 53 makes clear. Marcius' arrival in Macedonia and Philip's Thracian campaign (8. 1–7: from de legat. Rom.) are both in 183 (see Livy, ibid.). It has been argued above (p. 13) that xxii. 19. 1–4 probably belongs to the res Graeciae of Ol. 149. 1 = 184/3; but whether it preceded or followed 6 is uncertain. 9. 1–15, describing the arrival of Greek envoys at Rome, and Marcius' report, forms part of res Italiae of Ol. 149, 2 = 183/2, as comparison with Livy, xl. 2. 6, shows. 10. 1–16, on Philip's disasters, is combined from de uirt. et uit., de sent., and several passages from Suidas, and corresponds to Livy, xl. 3. 3 f.; it is from the res Macedoniae of the same year, of which another fragment is the reference to the sacrifice to Xanthus in 10. 17 (cf. Livy, xl. 6. 1–3). 11. 1–8, from Philip's speech to his sons, corresponds to part of Livy, xl. 8. 7–20 (expecially 10–14), and is also from res Macedoniae of Ol. 149, 2 = 183/2 (in fact 182). 12. 1–9 is made up from de sent., de uirt. et uit., and Suidas, and concerns the death and character of Philopoemen; it must be from res Graeciae of Ol. 149, 2 = 183/2, which in this instance followed res Macedoniae. (12. 3–7 from de uirt. et uit. is excessively abbreviated but contains a sentence about Lycortas missing from de sent.) 13 on Hannibal (from Suidas and de uirt. et uit.) and 14 on Scipio (from de sent., de uirt. et uit., and Suidas) clearly link with Philopoemen's death. P. must have put all three deaths in the same year. Next follow three passages evidently from res Graeciae of this same [15]
year. 15. 1–3 (de sent.) condemning the destruction of trees and agricultural installations seems to be a criticism of Lycortas' ravaging of Messenia (cf. xxiv. 2. 3; Plut. Philop. 21. 1); 16. 1–13 (de legat. gent.) is on the capitulation of Messenia; and 17. 1–18. 5 (de legat. gent.) recounts the Roman reply to Achaean envoys and the Achaean readmission of Sparta. P.'s sequence is straightforward and consistent. A difficulty arises only because Livy, xxxix. 49–50, describes Philopoemen's death under A.U.C. 571 = 183, whereas P. puts it in Ol. 149, 2 = 183/2. The explanation is that Livy, who singled out the one most sensational incident from the war (cf. Livy, xxxix. 48. 6–49. 1), brought it forward into the previous consular year (183), so that it preceded the res Macedoniae of Ol. 149, 1 = 184/3 (Livy, xxxix. 53), whereas the corresponding passage in P. (7. 1–7) comes before Philopoemen's death. For detailed discussion of the chronology of the deaths of Philopoemen, Scipio, and Hannibal see the commentary on 12. 1– 14. 12. If Steph. Byz. s.v. Γαλάδραι should be emended to give a reference to book xxiii (Schweighaeuser, v. 59, would read Ι\?\ or Κ\?\ for \?\), this may come in the res Macedoniae of either Ol. 149, 1 or Ol. 149, 2 (see Büttner-Wobst, iv. 152 in app. crit.). Schweighaeuser (v. 54) attributes fg. 112 to res Asiae of Ol. 149, 2; it could refer to Pharnaces. 6. BOOK XXIV This probably contained the events of Ol. 149, 3 = 182/1 and Ol. 149, 4 = 181/0; see above, pp. 13–14. These extracts are from the Constantinian excerpts: de legat. gent.: 1. 1–7 (embassies at Rome: exc. 44—continuous with xxiii. 18. 5 and not distinguished from it in the manuscripts); 2. 1–5 (Peloponnesian affairs: exc. 45); 5. 1–8 (Eumenes' brothers in Rome: exc. 46); 6. 1–7 (Achaea and Ptolemy V: his death: exc. 47); 8. 1–10. 10 (the Achaeans and Rome: Callicrates: exc. 48); 10. 11–15 (same context: exc. 49); de legat. Rom.: 14. 1–15. 9 (war between Eumenes and Pharnaces: exc. 22); 15. 10–13 (same context: exc. 23); de uirt. et uit.: 7. 1–8 (Chaeron at Sparta: exc. 86); 11. 1–8 (comparison of Aristaenus and Philopoemen: exc. 87); de sent.: 3 (troubles in Crete: exc. 111); 12. 1– 13. 10 (comparison of Aristaenus and Philopoemen: exc. 112). The only relevant Polybian section of Livy is xl. 20. 1–24. 8 (A.U.C. 573 = 181), recording embassies to Rome, Philip's Thracian expedition and the murder of Demetrius. Livy has no Polybian section for A.U.C. 574 = 180. 1. 1–7 from de legat. gent. recounts the arrival in Rome and audience before the Senate of envoys from the Spartan exiles, Achaea, Eumenes, Ariarathes, and Pharnaces; Livy, xl. 20. 1– 4 [16]
describes the same occasion, mentioning Macedonian representatives as well. The context is clearly res Italiae of Ol. 149, 3 = 182/1 and the date winter 182/1. 2. 1–5, describing Achaean decisions following the return of envoys from Rome, must be from the res Graeciae of the same olympiad year (in fact 181). 3 (de sent.), on troubles in Crete, precedes a passage comparing Aristaenus and Philopoemen, which clearly arises out of a discussion of Achaean policy; and since Cretan affairs normally follow Achaean in any given olympiad year, this passage on Crete must be part of res Graeciae of at least the year before that of the Achaean discussions. Since these probably belong to Ol. 149, 4 = 181/0 (see below, pp. 18–19), 3 is likely to be from res Graeciae of Ol. 149, 3 = 182/1; but if 11–13 were to be postponed into book xxv, 3 might logically fall in Ol. 149, 4 = 181/0. 4, from Strabo (vii. 5. 1, C. 313), refers to Philip's ascent of Mt. Haemus in 181 (Livy, xl. 21. 2, 22. 5); but since Livy has no res Graeciae for this year, we lack even that indication whether P.'s res Macedoniae preceded or followed his res Graeciae for Ol. 149, 3 = 182/1, and so whether 4 should stand before or after 2. See xxiv. 1. 6 n. (If, as seems most likely, the Cretan chapters represented by 3 belong to this year, they will follow the Achaean (2), wherever the Macedonian go; Hultsch's order, putting 4 between 2 and 3, is unacceptable.) 5. 1–8, from de legat. gent., describing Eumenes' actions after a truce with Pharnaces and his brothers' reception at Rome, must be from res Italiae of Ol. 149, 4 = 181/0; their arrival back in Pergamum in spring 180 is recounted in 14. 4 (see p. 19). See BüttnerWobst, Beiträge, 14–15. 6. 1–7, from the same collection, describes Ptolemy V's offer of pentecontors to Achaea, the decision to send an embassy, and the news of his death. The latest Egyptian dating by Ptolemy Epiphanes (Tait, Greek Ostraca, Bodleian no. 96) is Pharmouthi 16 of year 25 = 20 May 180, and comes from Hermonthis (cf. Skeat, 32 n. 9); and Samuel, 139, calculates that, allowing three months for news of Epiphanes' death to get from Alexandria to Hermonthis in upper Egypt, this dating shows Epiphanes to have been still alive on, say, 20 February 180. Since the Canon gives him a reign of 24 years, thus putting his death in the course of his twentyfifth Egyptian year, he must have died between 20 February and 6 October 180 (the year end). So far no document warrants a closer dating. But the evidence seems to confirm that 6. 1–7 is from the res Graeciae of Ol. 149, 4 = 181/0, and refers to 180. 7. 1–8, from de uirt. et uit. and Suidas, concerns the demagogy of the Spartan Chaeron, who had been on an embassy to Rome the previous year (7. 1). If that embassy was the one in xxiii. 18. 4, 7. 1–8 is clearly part of res Graeciae of Ol. 149, 4 = 181/0. But in xxiii. 18. 4 Χαίρωνα was Schweighaeuser's emendation (following [17]
Reiske) of χάρωνα (Y); and P. Derow, Bowra Essays, 15 n. 1, would keep the manuscript reading, thus making the embassy mentioned here that of 184/3 (cf. xxiii. 4. 5), with the result that 7. 1–8 goes into the res Graeciae of 183/2. This is possible; but the emendation is a simple one and may well stand, Charon being otherwise unknown. The placing of this fragment will however be uncertain. 8. 1–10. 15, from de legat. gent., first describes Achaean deliberations on a letter brought back from Rome by the Spartan exiles. Aymard (études, 43–4) argues that this is the letter mentioned in 2. 1 and ignored after discussion in spring 181 (2. 5); but this need not be so, for Callicrates, speaking in Rome (9. 14), says: νῦν δὲ πάλιν ἐκ πλείονος χρόνου γραφόντων αὐτῶν ὑπὲρ τῆς καθόδου τῶν ἐκ Λακεδαίµονος φυγάδων, which suggests more than one communication. Hyperbatus is now general (8. 1) and Aymard (ibid.) argues that his strategia was in 181/0 and that, being pro-Roman, he will have raised the question of the letter immediately after entering office in autumn 181, only six months after the earlier discussion. Against this is the fact that the matter comes up in de legat. gent. after the account of the cancellation of the embassy to Ptolemy, following his death in 180 (6. 7); and though P. frequently has to revert to an earlier time within the olympiad year in passing from one theatre to another, this does not happen within the affairs of one area such as Achaea. Further, Errington has shown (263–4) that since Aratus was to have gone to Egypt (6. 6) and did go to Rome (8. 8), the second embassy must have been arranged after the first was cancelled. It follows that the discussion of the Roman letter under Hyperbatus took place, not in autumn 181, but after the news of Epiphanes' death in 180. This being so, a possible interpretation of the material is that Hyperbatus was general for 180/79 (not 181/0), that the letter was discussed as soon as he entered office and that the embassy went to Rome in autumn 180 and was heard at the usual time in winter 180/79; 8. 1–10. 15 would in that case form part of res Italiae of Ol. 150, 1 = 180/79. The order of the fragments would allow this, since the next excerpt in de legat. gent. is xxv. 2. 1–15 from the res Asiae of Ol. 150, 1 = 180/79; and the central feature of 8. 1–10. 15 is Callicrates' speech at Rome. This reconstruction (accepted by Nissen, Rh. Mus. 1871, 249; Niese, iii. 59 n. 1) implies putting Hyperbatus' strategia in 180/79, and that of Callicrates in 179/8 (10. 14); the general for 181/0 would be unknown. It is possible; but on balance it seems more likely that 8. 1–10. 15 forms part of res Graeciae of Ol. 149, 4 = 181/0, since 10. 14–15 seems to imply that Callicrates was made general soon after his return to Rome. Elsewhere embassies to Rome figure in res Graeciae: cf. xxi. 31. 3–32. 15; xxix. 10–11, in both of which passages the assignment to res Graeciae is confirmed by comparison with Livy. (In this P. retained a degree of [18]
flexibility; in xxx. 5. 2 ff. affairs of Rhodes and Caria are included in res Italiae.) The chronology will thus be as follows. Hyperbatus, as general for 181/0, raised the matter of the Spartan exiles in early summer 180, on the receipt of yet another letter from Rome; this was after news of Ptolemy's death had caused the cancellation of the mission to Egypt (6. 7). He either summoned a syncletos (xxiv. 8. 7 n.)—or possibly raised the matter at a regular synodos (cf. Errington, 264 n. 2)—and Callicrates, Lydiades, and Aratus were appointed envoys to Rome and left at once. There they were given an immediate hearing; this was unusual, but not unprecedented (cf. xxxii. 1. 4), and they had of course come in response to a Roman letter. They returned home the same autumn in time for Callicrates to be elected general for 180/79 (10. 14). One reason why P. dealt with this embassy under res Graeciae may have been that it fell in the middle of a consular year; for a parallel see xxi. 1 n. (One should, however, note that if new evidence from Egypt were to show that Epiphanes' death was so short a time before 6 October 180 as to leave no room for Callicrates' embassy to Rome before the Achaean elections in autumn 180, it would be necessary to revert to the theory that 8. 1–10. 15 is from the res Italiae of Ol. 150, 1 = 180/79, and falls in book xxv.) 11–13 (from de uirt. et uit., de sent., and Suidas) is a comparison between the policies of Philopoemen and Aristaenus; it does not indicate in what context P. introduced it. Since Philopoemen's death was in 182, that cannot have afforded the occasion; and Aristaenus' death (its date is unknown) seems an unlikely peg on which to hang it. It is perhaps most likely to have been introduced in relation to a discussion of Callicrates' methods; hence it stands in res Graeciae of Ol. 149, 4 = 181/0 (though if evidence from Egypt led to the postponement of 8. 1–10. 15 until book xxv (see above), 11–13 would also have to go into that book, probably as res Graeciae of Ol. 150, 1 = 180/79). 14. 1–15. 13 (from de legat. Rom.) describes the reopening of the war against Eumenes by Pharnaces in spring 180 before Eumenes' brothers returned from Rome (14. 4); soon afterwards the Roman envoys promised in 5. 8 arrive (14. 10, 15. 1). Clearly then 14. 1– 15. 13 is from res Asiae of Ol. 149, 4 = 181/0 (cf. Büttner-Wobst, Beiträge, 16–17; Steigemann, 43). 7. BOOK XXV For the likelihood that book xxv contained the history of Ol. 150 = 180/76 see above, pp. 13–14. These extracts are from the Constantinian excerpts: de legat. gent.: 2. 1–15 (end of war between Pharnaces and Eumenes: exc. 50); 4. 1–10 (Lycian embassy at Rome: [19]
exc. 51); 5. 1–5 (Rhodian decision to send an embassy to Rome about Lycia: exc. 52); 6. 1–6 (Rhodian and Dardanian envoys at Rome: exc. 53); de uirt. et uit.: 3. 1–8 (Perseus' new policy: exc. 88); 3. 9–10 (Philip's character: exc. 89). 2. 1–15, giving the terms of the settlement between Eumenes and Pharnaces and of the general peace in the area, follows xxiv. 8. 1– 10. 15 in de legat. gent. If, as seems likely (above, pp. 18–19), the latter passage is part of res Graeciae of Ol. 149, 4 = 181/0, its position in the excerpts would allow 2. 1–15 to form part of res Asiae of Ol. 149, 4 = 181/0, or Ol. 150, 1 = 180/79, or Ol. 150, 2 = 179/8, since the next passage in de legat. gent. (4. 1–10) is firmly placed in Ol. 150, 3 = 178/7 (see below, pp. 21–2). It seems likely that the general peace mentioned in 2. 1–15 was followed at no great interval by the treaty between Pharnaces and Chersonese recorded in IPE i2. 402, and dated by the oath sworn in the month Daisios of year 157 καθὼς βασιλεὺς Φαρνάκ[ης] ἄγει (11. 29–31). By the time of Pharnaces' son, Mithridates V Euergetes, Pontus was using an era dating from 296 (cf. Diehl, RE, 'Pharnakes (1)', col. 1850); whereas that used in IPE i2. 402 must be calculated from the accession of Mithridates II to the throne of Cius, which according to Diod. xvi. 90. 2 took place in the Attic year 337/6. R. C. Loeper (cf. Diehl, RE, 'Pharnakes (1)', col. 1850) dated this era from October 337, and if Daisios is May, Pharnaces' oath would be May 180 (if year 1 is 337/6, year 157 will be 181/0, not 180/79 as Rostovtzeff, CAH, ix. 217 f. states; so too Magie, ii. 1090 n. 45, and Latyschev, IPE i2. 402, 'annum 157 cadere . . . in annum 179 a. Chr.'). A date for this treaty in May 180 would perhaps allow 2. 1–15 to stand in Ol. 149, 4 = 181/0. But we cannot be certain from which month of the Attic year 337/6 the Pontic era began, and if it began late in that year, the treaty of IPE i2. 402 may indeed belong to 179. In favour of this (and the placing of 2. 1–15 in Ol. 150, 1 = 180/79) is the fact that after the breakdown of the talks in 180 (xxiv. 15. 12), the Roman envoys left Pergamum and Eumenes prepared to continue the war (xxiv. 15. 12). It seems unlikely that the consequent Pergamene attack can have developed enough to induce Pharnaces to be ready to make peace at any price (2. 1) before the next olympiad year (Ol. 150, 1 = 180/79). Hence, it seems preferable to leave 2. 1–15 where it stands (with a caveat). In view of the date of IPE i2. 402, it can hardly belong to Ol. 150, 2 = 179/8. Niese (iii. 78 n. 1) leaves 2. 1–15 in book xxv, and assumes that the peace was in autumn 180 (so too Diehl, RE, 'Pharnakes (1)', col. 1849); this is possible. See further Büttner-Wobst, Beiträge, 17; Steigemann, 43. 1. 1–2 (Strabo, iii. 4. 13, C. 163), recording Ti. Gracchus' exaggerated description of Spanish forts as cities, refers to events of Ol. 150, 1 = 180/79, since Livy, xl. 47. 1 shows Gracchus to have been propraetor [20]
in Spain in A.U.C. 575 = 179. As Diod. xxix. 26 is probably following P. in praising Gracchus' vigour, it is likely that P. recorded his campaigns under res Hispaniae of this year. However, Schulten (Hermes, 1911, 573) has shown convincingly that Strabo mentioned P. here in the context of Poseidonius' polemic, and that whether he took the Polybian reference from Poseidonius, who, since he opened his History with the year 144, can only have handled events of 179 in a geographical excursus (which in fact will have drawn on P.'s book xxxiv), or had it direct from P. (whom in book iii he quotes only from book xxxiv and not from the Histories generally), in either case, the implication is that 1. 1–2 belongs to book xxxiv, where P. discusses the towns of Celtiberia (cf. xxxiv. 9. 13).1 It is clear from the Polybian section of Livy, xl. 54. 1–58. 9, that Philip V died in 179 and that P. must have described his death under Ol. 150, 1 = 180/79. Livy (cf. Walbank, Philip, 295–9) suggests that it occurred late in 179 (though the words Demetriade hibernabat, Livy, xl. 54. 2, refer to winter 180/79, and have no relevance to the time of his death, as De Sanctis, iv. 1. 254 n. 28 imagined). Consequently, the account of Perseus' new policy in 3. 1–8 (from de uirt. et uit. with Suidas at 3. 1–2 and Athen. x. 445 at 3. 6–8: for the false attribution to book xxvi see above, p. 14) must come under res Macedoniae of Ol. 150, 2 = 179/8. Winter 179/8 would be appropriate for the renewal of friendship with Rome (3. 1). 3. 9–10 on Philip's character is the next excerpt in de uirt. et uit. and probably belongs to a comparison with his successor Perseus. 4. 1–10, 5. 1–5, and 6. 1–6 follow in succession in de legat. gent. The first describes the arrival of Lycian envoys at Rome and their hearing ἤδη τῆς θερείας ληγούσης (4. 2), the second the arrival of Roman envoys at Rhodes, to convey the Senate's decision following the Lycian embassy, and the third the arrival at Rome of the Rhodian embassy decided upon in 5. 4. These three excerpts must come from res Italiae, res Asiae, and res Italiae respectively, and a reference to the consuls of A.U.C. 577 = 177 (4. 1) seems to establish these as being the res Italiae of 178/7 (4. 1–10), the res Asiae of the same year (5. 1–5), and the res Italiae of 177/6 (6. 1–6). There is however a difficulty, since this implies that the late summer of 4. 2 ('after the expedition of the consuls . . . against the Istrians and Agrians') is summer 177; and this leaves insufficient time for the sending of an embassy to Rhodes, its hearing and the dispatch of Lycophron to Rome, where he has audience in Ol. 150, 4 = 177/6, i.e. probably at the beginning of the consular year 176. It has, therefore, been cogently argued by P. Derow (Phoenix, 1973, 350 ff.) that the names of the consuls of 177 have been incorrectly inserted by the excerptor at 4. 1, and that the Lycian envoys were in fact heard at the end of [21]
1
On Strabo's debt to P. in book iii see Pédech, Méthode, 579 n. 362.
summer 178 (cf. Livy, xli. 6. 8–12, who dates their audience before the consular elections for 177; Nissen, KU, 239–40, rejects Livy's details as annalistic and improbable, but thinks the date may well be right); see ad loc. for full discussion. In any event, the assignment of the three fragments is unaltered. The arrival of the Rhodian and Dardanian envoys (6. 1–6), described under res Italiae of Ol. 150, 4 = 177/6), will be at the end of 177; see Meloni, Perseo, 81. 8. BOOK XXVI This book, which was lost before 950, contained Ol. 151 = 176/2; see above, pp. 13–14. Athen. x. 445 is incorrectly attributed to book xxvi (see p. 14); but Athen. x. 439 and v. 193 both belong there and come from a discussion of the character of Antiochus IV, on which Diodorus (xxix. 32) and Livy (xli. 20) also draw. Since this section of Livy is under A.U.C. 579 = 175, and since Diodorus, loc. cit. relates his account to Antiochus' accession, which was in 175 (see 1 a 1 n.), both fragments will be from res Asiae of Ol. 151, 1 = 176/5, the first year covered in the book. 9. BOOK XXVII Three excerpts, 1. 1 (de legat. gent.), 3. 1 (de legat. Rom.), and 12. 1 (de uirt. et uit.) contain statements in the manuscripts that they are from book xxvii; and a comparison of the first and second of these with Livy, xlii. 43. 4 and xlii. 45. 1–2 (A.U.C. 583 = 171), and of the third with Livy, xlii. 67. 3 (part of the same Polybian narrative), shows that book xxvii contained Ol. 152, 1 = 172/1 (see above, pp. 13–14). Athen. x. 440 attributes to book xxix statements about Genthius which Livy, xliv. 30. 2 (following P.) places in A.U.C. 586 = 168. This gives the following arrangement: Ol. 152, 1 = 172/1 Ol. 152, 2 = 171/0 Ol. 152, 3 = 170/69 Ol. 152, 4 = 169/8
Book xxvii
Book xxix
This leaves uncertain whether xxvii contained Ol. 152, 1 and Ol. 152, 2 and xxviii Ol. 152, 3, or whether xxvii contained only Ol. 152, 1 and xxviii Ol. 152, 2 and Ol. 152, 3. BüttnerWobst has assumed the first alternative to be the right one; and it may seem more likely that as the war with Perseus developed events expanded to fill more space,1 and even that the arrangement 2:1:1 is more probable than 1:2:1 (though as Ol. 144 has 1:1:2 and Ol. 147 has 1:3, this is not to be pressed). However, probability is not proof, and we do not [22]
1
This seems to exclude the possibility that there was one year each in xxvii and xxviii, and Ol. 152, 3 and 4 in xxix.
know whether the events in 14. 1–20. 3 were in fact in xxvii or xxviii. In the state of uncertainty, they are perhaps best left as BüttnerWobst has them. These extracts are from the Constantinian excerpts: de legat. gent.: 1. 1–2. 12 (events in Boeotia: exc. 54); 4. 1–10 (Perseus and Rhodes: exc. 55); 5. 1–8 (Perseus and Boeotia: exc. 56); 6. 1–4 (same topic: exc. 57); 8. 1–15 (Perseus asks for peace: exc. 58); 14. 1–3 (Perseus' envoy in Rhodes: exc. 59); 19. 1–2 (war between Antiochus and Ptolemy: exc. 60); de legat. Rom.: 3. 1–5 (Rhodian support for Rome: exc. 24); 7. 1–16 (attitudes at Rhodes: exc. 25); de uirt. et uit.: 12. 1–3 (on Cotys: exc. 90); 13. 1–4 (Ptolemy, the Egyptian commander in Cyprus: exc. 91); 15. 1–16 (Cephalus of Epirus driven to join Perseus: exc. 92); 16. 1–6 (attempt to seize the consul, A. Hostilius: exc. 93); 17 (Pharnaces: exc. 94); 18. 1–3 (Attalus' approach to the Achaeans: exc. 95); de sent.: 9. 1–10. 5 (Perseus' position in Greece: exc. 113); 20. 1–2 (remarks about war: exc. 114); 20. 3 (difficulty in attaining to τὰ καλά: exc. 115). Livy, xlii. 29–30 and xliii. 37–67 seem to derive from parts of P. falling within Ol. 152, 1 = 171; but owing to the fragmentary nature of the text of Livy, no sections of it derived from P. have survived for the year 170. 1. 1–2. 12 follows xxv. 6. 6 in de legat. gent. (where it is attributed to xxvii: see p. 22) and corresponds to a section of Livy xlii. 43–44, a passage dealing with the relations between Rome and Boeotia and dated to 171. Two chapters later Livy (xlii. 45. 1) records the visit of Roman envoys to Rhodes, and this corresponds to 3. 1–5, from de legat. Rom.; but in xlii. 46 Livy returns to events of the same year in Greece, which means that 1. 1–2. 12 cannot be res Graeciae and 3. 1–5 res Asiae of Ol. 152, 1 = 172/1. Either P. treated the war with Perseus as a single whole (so Büttner-Wobst, who classifies all these fragments under 'Bellum Persicum') or, more probably, he here reckons the affairs of Rhodes as res Graeciae (and draws no clear distinction between res Graeciae and res Macedoniae). The following fragments fall into place when compared with Livy, viz.: 4. 1–10, cf. Livy, xlii. 46. 1–6; 5. 1– 8, cf. Livy, xlii. 46. 7–10; 6. 1–4, cf. Livy, xlii. 48. 1–4 (followed by fg. 234; cf. Livy, xlii. 49. 2); 7. 1–16, cf. Livy, xlii. 48. 9–10 (or 56. 1); 8. 1–15, cf. Livy, xlii. 62. 3–15; 9. 1–10. 5 (also in Suidas), cf. Livy, xlii. 63. 1–2 (omitting most of the Polybian original); 11. 1–7 (from Suidas), cf. Livy, xlii. 65. 9. (For the collections from which these fragments come see above.) 12. 1–3 (from de uirt. et uit.) follows xxv. 3. 9–10 in that collection, and is said in the margin to be from book xxvii. It is usually placed after 11. 1–7, by comparison with Livy, xlii. 67. 3; but Livy says nothing there on Cotys' character, and such remarks will have come more appropriately earlier, either in a section corresponding to Livy, xlii. 29. 12 where, under A.U.C. 583 = 171, Cotys' support of Perseus [23]
is mentioned (so Reiske), or, more probably, in one corresponding to Livy, xlii. 51. 10, 'uenerat eodem [sc. to Citium] Cotys, Seuthis filius, rex gentis Odrysarum, cum mille delectis equitibus, pari ferme peditum numero'; this is Cotys' first appearance, and judging by Livy, he received a full introduction. In that case 12. 1–3 is from the passage describing the gathering of the Macedonian army at Citium which preceded the account of the sending of the letter to Rhodes (7. 1–16), since that corresponds to Livy, xlii. 56. 1 (see below, xxvii. 7. 1–16 n.); it will stand between 6. 4 and 7. 1. 13. 1–4 (which follows 12. 1–3 in de uirt. et uit.) concerns the Egyptian commander in Cyprus, and, as it precedes 15. 1–16 (see below), it must be from res Aegypti of Ol. 152, 1 = 172/1. 14. 1–2 follows 8. 15 and precedes 19. 1–2 (on the war between Ptolemy and Antiochus) in the excerpts de legat. gent. The cessation of activity against the Romans mentioned in 14. 1 will be a reference to Perseus' retirement to Macedonia at the end of the campaigning season of 171. BüttnerWobst puts it early in the res Graeciae et Macedoniae (he says bellum Persicum) of Ol. 152, 2 = 171/0; in that case it may well, though it need not necessarily, precede the account of the events leading up to the attack on the consul A. Hostilius in Epirus (15. 1–16. 6). But it could be a pendant to events in the same theatre in Ol. 152, 1 = 172/1, in which case it would stand after 11. 7. As indicated above (p. 22), the fragments relating to Ol. 152, 2 = 171/0 may belong to book xxviii. 15. 1–16 and 16. 1–6 follow 13. 4 (in that order) in de uirt. et uit.; and 15. 6 is also in Suidas. As they concern the war with Perseus and as the next passage in this collection concerns Pharnaces and is therefore from res Asiae (17) they must be part of the res Graeciae et Macedoniae of Ol. 152, 2 = 171/0; A. Hostilius (16. 2) is the consul for A.U.C. 584 = 170. 17, as already noted, is from res Asiae (of Ol. 152, 2 = 171/0) and precedes (in de uirt. et uit.) 18. 1–3, which mentions an approach to some Achaeans by Attalus, and xxviii. 14. 1–4, a passage on Crete, which can be assigned to Ol. 152, 3 = 170/69 (see below, p. 26), in that order. Attalus was operating from Elatea, and there is no reason to put 18. 1–3 under res Asiae (as Büttner-Wobst does); and since Attalus and Eumenes returned to Pergamum in autumn 171 and wintered there 171/0 (Livy, xlii. 67. 8), the winter mentioned here (18. 1) must be that of 170/69. In that case, 18. 1–3 will stand early among the res Graeciae et Macedoniae of Ol. 152, 3 = 170/69, between xxviii. 2. 8 and xxviii. 3. 1. 19. 1–2, on the sending of Meleager to Rome by Antiochus, follows 14. 1–3 and precedes xxviii. 1. 1–9 (describing the arrival of these and other envoys at Rome) in the excerpts de legat. gent. The likelihood is that xxviii. 1. 1–9 is from res Italiae of Ol. 152, 3 = 170/69, and 19. 1–2 part of res Asiae of Ol. 152, 2 = 171/0 (as Büttner-Wobst [24]
places them); Meleager's embassy is then in winter 170/69. But if 14. 1–3 was a pendant to res Macedoniae of Ol. 152, 1 = 172/1 (above, p. 24), then 19. 1–2 could be from res Asiae of that year (with this order of fragments: 11. 7, 14. 1–3, 19. 1–2, 13. 1–4), and xxviii. 1. 1–9 could be from res Italiae of Ol. 152, 2 = 171/0, standing between 13. 4 and 15. 1 of book xxvii. For this dating see E. Bikerman, Chron. d' égypte, 1952, 398 n. 1. Though consistent with the position of the fragments, it has to be discarded for two reasons: (a) It would imply that a war that was being prepared in 171 and (cf. xxviii. 1. 1) had already broken out by the late winter of 171/0 left no trace of any action before 169; which is absurd. (b) The senate's statement to Meleager that they would send instructions about writing to Ptolemy to Q. Marcius Philippus (xxviii. 1. 9) suggests that he was, or was soon to be, in the east; and this could only (at that time) be as legatus in 171 (cf. Livy, xlii. 47. 9). This would imply that the embassies were heard in early autumn 171 in time for a letter to go to Marcius before his return to Italy (since there is no evidence that he stayed on in Greece into 170). If Meleager's embassy was in winter 170/69, Marcius could receive the instructions (perhaps before leaving Rome) as consul fro 169. 20. 1–2 and 20. 3 follow 10. 5 (Ol. 152, 1 = 172/1) and precede xxviii. 10. 1–2 (from res Graeciae et Macedoniae of Ol. 152, 3 = 170/69) in de sent. They have been placed where they stand as belonging to the war between Antiochus and Ptolemy; but the very general sententious reflections contained in them could come from almost any context, including the war against Perseus. Their proper place must therefore remain uncertain; nor can we say whether they belong to book xxvii or book xxviii. 10. BOOK XXVIII Whether this book contained the events of Ol. 152, 2 and 3, or merely those of Ol. 152, 3 is uncertain (see pp. 22–23); but the latter assumption (which is Büttner-Wobst's) is slightly more probable, and therefore it may be made as a working hypothesis. These extracts are from the Constantinian excerpts: de legat. gent.: 1. 1–9 (embassies from Antiochus and Ptolemy: exc. 61); 2. 1–8 (envoys from Rhodes: exc. 62); 5. 1–6 (debate in Acarnania: exc. 63); 8. 1–11 (Perseus and Genthius: exc. 64); 9. 1–8 (same topic: exc. 65); 12. 1–13. 14 (Polybius sent to the consul: exc. 66); 15. 1–3 (Cydonia and Eumenes: exc. 67); 16. 1–17. 15 (Rhodian affairs: exc. 68); 19. 1–7 (envoys to Antiochus: exc. 69); 20. 1–13 (same topic: exc. 70); 22. 1–3 (Syrian envoys to Rome: exc. 71); 23. 1–5 (Rhodian envoys to Antiochus: exc. 72); de legat. Rom.: 3. 1–4. 13 (Romans in Achaea and Aetolia: exc. 26); 6. 1–7. 15 (Achaean policy towards [25]
Rome, Perseus, and Eumenes: exc. 26 cont.); de uirt. et uit.: 14. 1–4 (Cydoniate treachery towards Apollonia: exc. 96); 18. 1 (remark on Antiochus: exc. 97; said in the margin of P to be from book xxviii); de sent.: 10. 1–2 (Perseus blames his general: exc. 116); 13. 9–10 (P. as envoy: exc. 117); 21. 1–5 (Eulaeus persuades Ptolemy to flee: exc. 118). Livy, xliii. 17–23 and xliv. 1–13 are from P. and, placed by Livy under 169, seem to represent the Polybian account of the war with Perseus in Ol. 152, 3 = 170/69. 8. 1–11 and 9. 1–8 (from de legat. gent.) correspond to Livy, xliii. 19. 13–20. 4 and 23. 8 (though Livy omits most of the contents of 9. 1–8); hence the three previous excerpts in de legat. gent. will go: (a) 1. 1–9 and 2. 1–8 in res Italiae of Ol. 152, 3 = 170/69; (b) 5. 1–6, which corresponds to Livy, xliii. 17. 7–9, in an earlier part of the section on the war with Perseus (as before—see p. 23—P. continues to run res Graeciae and res Macedoniae together). Since 3. 1–4. 13 (from de legat. Rom.) corresponds to Livy, xliii. 17. 2–6, it must immediately precede 5. 1–6. For the argument that xxvii. 18. 1–3 on Attalus' approach to the Achaeans in winter 170/69 belongs before 3 see p. 24. Livy also enables the following passages to be set in order: 10. 1–2 (de sent.) = Livy, xliv. 7. 8–9; 11. 1–2 (Suidas) = Livy, xliv. 9. 8–9 (on the testudo); 11. 3 (Suidas) from the same context (cf. Livy, xliv. 9. 3 and 6)—but the Livian version suggests that it more properly precedes 11. 1–2. If fg. 66 corresponds to Livy, xliv. 10. 10, it will stand here. 6. 1–7. 15, on Achaean policy, has no corresponding passage in Livy; however, it mentions Archon's entry into office as general for 170/69 (6. 9), and clearly precedes the next passage dealing with Achaea (12. 1–13. 14, from de legat. gent. with an overlap in de sent.), and its position seems assured since (a) the first sentence (6. 1) seems to refer to the Roman embassy, whose movements are recorded in 3–5; (b) in the de legat. Rom. it forms a continuous passage with 3. 1– 4. 13, except that at 6. 1 there is a jumbled sentence containing a reference to Acarnania, which clearly has to do with the section 5. 1–6, omitted from this selection. 12. 1–13. 14 (on P.'s embassy to the consul) is part of res Graeciae et Macedoniae, but P. has dealt with it towards the end of his account of the season's events. 14. 1–4 and 15. 1–3 both concern Cydonia in Crete; the former follows xxvii, 18. 1–3 (from res Asiae of Ol. 152, 2 = 171/0) in de uirt. et uit. Since Cretan affairs come before res Asiae in any year, 14. 1–4 must belong to xxviii, despite the fact that the next excerpt (18. 1) has a marginal note λο κη, which might suggest that it was the first passage taken from book xxviii. 15. 1–3 precedes 16. 1–17. 15 in de legat. gent. and is probably rightly placed after rather than before 14. 1–4, since the attack on Apollonia is less likely [26]
to have happened once Cydonia was in the hands of the Pergamene general Leon (15. 3). 16. 1–17. 15, on Rhodian affairs, follows 15. 1–3 in de legat. gent.; as in 12. 1–13. 14 the reference to Q. Marcius Philippus (cos. 169) confirms the passage as belonging to Ol. 152, 3 = 170/69. It describes the departure from Rhodes of the envoys (16. 5) whose audience at Rome had already been described (cf. 2. 1–2); but although it records the interview given by the consul to Rhodian envoys in Macedon, the passage mainly concerns Rhodes. In this instance Rhodian affairs seem to be treated as res Graeciae (which are not clearly separated from res Macedoniae during the war with Perseus); but the mention of an embassy to Alexandria in 17. 15 marks a transition to the war between Antiochus and Ptolemy. 19. 1–7, 20. 1–13, 22. 1–3, and 23. 1–5 are from de legat. gent. (in that order) and all concern that war; since the next passage in that collection, xxix. 3. 1–4. 10, belongs to res Graeciae et Macedoniae of Ol. 152, 4 = 168 (cf. Livy, xliv. 23), all four must be from book xxviii, since they are from res Asiae or res Aegypti (however events of this war are classed). 18. 1, from de uirt. et uit. (with the marginal note assigning it to book xxviii: above, p. 26), concerns Antiochus' character, and corresponds to Diod. xxx. 18. 1 (from the same excerpts); the obscure reference to Pelusium is clarified in Diod. xxx. 18. 2 (from de sent.), which shows that the fragment of P. under consideration stands correctly before 19. 1–7. 21. 1–5 (from de sent.), criticizing Eulaeus for persuading Ptolemy to abandon Egypt, corresponds to Diod. xxx. 17; and since Diod. xxx. 17 and 18. 1, based on P. (cf. Schwartz, RE, 'Diodoros', cols. 689–90), stand in that order in the excerpts de uirt. et uit., it is reasonable to conclude that the corresponding passages in P. were in the same order, and so that 21. 1–5 preceded 18 (cf. Mørkholm, 75 n. 45).1 This is more satisfactory than BüttnerWobst's arrangement, which involves putting the account of Eulaeus' advice (21. 1–5) after the council led by the new advisers Comanus and Cineas has resolved to approach Antiochus for terms 9. 1–7). 11. BOOK XXIX This book contained Ol. 152, 4 = 169/8 (see above, p. 22). These extracts are from the Constantinian excerpts: de legat. gent.: 3. 1– 4. 10 (Genthius joins Perseus: exc. 73); 10. 1–7 (Rhodian decision to mediate: exc. 74); 11. 1–6 (Genthius' envoys at Rhodes: exc. 75); 19. 1– 11 (Rhodian envoys at Rome: exc. 76); 23. 1–24. 16 [27]
1
It is true that Diod. xxxi. 1 and 12 (both from de sent.) correspond to xxix. 26 and 22 (from the same excerpts) respectively; but different areas appear to be involved, and Diodorus has evidently rearranged his material.
(Egyptian appeal to Achaea: exc. 77); 25. 1–7 (same topic: exc. 78); de legat. Rom.: 2. 1–4 (Senate sends C. Popillius to Antiochus: exc. 27); 27. 1–13 (Popillius meets Antiochus: exc. 28); de sent.: 1. 1–3 (speech of Aemilius Paullus: exc. 119); 5. 1–3 (Perseus and Eumenes: exc. 120); 6. 1–9. 13 (same topic: exc. 121); 12. 1–12 (on writing history: exc. 122); 17. 2 (unsuccessful devices: exc. 123); 20. 1–4 (Aemilius Paullus' speech on Perseus' defeat: exc. 124); 21. 1–9 (reflections on Perseus' fall; exc. 125); 22. 1–5 (Galatians attack Eumenes: exc. 126); 26. 1–2 (Antiochus prepares to attack Ptolemy: exc. 127). 13. 1–2 (from Athen. x. 440), on Genthius' crimes, mentions book xxix; 14. 1–3, 15. 1–3, and 18 are from Plut. Aem. 15, 16, and 19 respectively; and several extracts from Suidas can be shown to belong to this book. Livy, xliv. 23 (or 22)–46 and xlv. 3. 3–12. 8, covering events of A.U.C. 586 = 168, are based on P.'s account of Ol. 152, 4 = 169/8. Whether or no Livy, xliv. 22 is partly Polybian (so Nissen), 1. 1–3 (from de sent.) clearly corresponds in substance to Livy, xliv. 22. 8 ff. and so belongs to the res Italiae of Ol. 152, 4 = 169/8. 2. 1–4 (de legat. Rom.), on the dispatch of C. Popillius to Antiochus, is also from the same res Italiae; and since 2. 4 indicates a transition to another theatre (see ad loc.), 2. 1–4 must follow 1. 1–3. For the war with Perseus Livy, who uses P., provides a useful framework, which gives this order of fragments: 3. 1–4. 10 (de legat. gent.) = Livy, xliv. 23. 1–10; 5. 1–9. 13 (de sent.) = Livy, xliv. 24. 9–26. 2. 11. 1–6 (from de legat. gent.) corresponds to Livy, xliv. 29. 6–8; hence, although Livy has nothing corresponding to 10. 1–7, the order of the excerpts in de legat. gent. warrants placing that fragment where it now stands. (Ullrich, 65, adduces no good reason for reversing the order of 10 and 11.) Livy has omitted the Rhodian decision to offer mediation (10. 1–7) because he takes up Rhodian affairs only with the arrival at Rhodes of Macedonian and Illyrian envoys (Livy, xliv. 29. 6). 13. 1–2 (from Athen.) corresponds to Livy, xliv. 30. 2–5, and 14. 1–3 (from Plut. Aem. 15) to Livy, xliv. 35. 14 (though Livy gives less detail). Mueller may well be right in his suggestion that fg. 221 (Suidas) should stand between 13. 2 and 14. 1 (cf. Livy, xliv. 35. 2). Continuing, 14. 4 (Suidas) = Livy, xliv. 35. 19, and 16. 1–3 (Suidas), on the lunar eclipse, = Livy, xliv. 37. 9. Since 15. 1–3 (Plut. Aem. 16) precedes the eclipse (Plut. Aem. 17) in Plutarch, if it is to be treated as a fragment of P., it stands correctly where it is. 17. 1–4 and 18 concern the battle of Pydna; 17. 1, 17. 3, and 17. 4 are from Suidas, 17. 2 from de sent. and 18 from Plut. Aem. 19. 2. Of these 17. 3, 17. 4, and 18 seem to be from the same context (cf. οὐχ ὑπέµεινε τῇ ψυχῇ in 17. 3 and 17. 4, and ἀποδειλιᾶν in 17. 3 and 18), viz. Perseus' flight from the field. According to Plutarch this occurred at the beginning of the battle, though in the next chapter [28]
(Plut. Aem. 19), he quotes Poseidonius' divergent account; but when the Macedonian line broke, it was from Pydna that Perseus fled to Pella (Plut. Aem. 23. 1), as Livy (xliv. 42. 1–2) also records. It thus appears that P. recorded Perseus' withdrawal from the battle in a passage which Livy transcribed in that part of his narrative covered by the lacuna (Livy, xliv. 40. 10– 41. 1); and since 17. 2 corresponds to Livy, xliv. 41. 4, it follows that the order of the fragments should be: 17. 1, 17. 3, 17. 4, 18, 17. 2. 12. 1–12 stands between 9. 13 and 17. 2 in the excerpts de sent.; between 9. 13 and 12. 1 a page has been lost from M, but it is clear that 12. 1–12 represents a separate excerpt. The first words, πάλιν ἕτεροι περὶ τοῦ Συριακοῦ πολέµου, suggest that there has just been a reference to some other writers of monographs; and the position of the excerpt in the collection suggests that these were monographs on the war with Perseus. But the exact position of the fragment relative to the others dealing with this war cannot be determined. Hultsch, following Casaubon and Nissen (KU, 267), inserted after 18 a fragment from Suidas s.v. πρωτόπειρος, as being the equivalent of Livy, xliv. 44. 3 (cf. Diod. xxx. 22); Dindorf and Büttner-Wobst regard it as non-Polybian. Neither vocabulary nor diction seems inconsistent with P.'s style and its provenance should be left open. If it is Polybian, it comes between 17. 2 and 19. 1 (17. 2 being placed after 18: see above). 19. 1–11 (de legat. gent.) corresponds to Livy, xlv. 3. 3–8, and though it records the reception of Rhodian envoys at Rome it stands correctly where it has been placed, as part of the res Graeciae et Macedoniae (cf. Walbank, Yale Stud. 1975, 209); for though P. is willing to reverse the chronological order to maintain the separate 'theatres of action' (as when Rhodian envoys are heard at Rome in xxviii. 2 but do not leave Rhodes until xxviii. 16. 5–9), he could hardly have recounted the Rhodian interview in 168 before the battle on which its whole point depended. 20. 1–4 (de sent.) corresponds to Livy, xlv. 8. 6–7, which assures its position; and it should probably be preceded by fg. 74 (Suidas), mentioning the sending of a lictor to conduct Perseus to the consul (cf. Livy, xlv. 7. 4). 21. 1–9, which follows 20. 1–4 in de sent., was perhaps part of a general sketch of Macedonian history represented by Livy, xlv. 9. 2–7 (see further below, xxix. 21 n.). 22. 1–5 and 26. 1–2, on Eumenes' affairs and Antiochus' preparations for a renewal of the war respectively, come from the excerpts de sent. and must belong to res Asiae of Ol. 152, 4 = 169/8. Since Schweighaeuser, editors have inserted between them two fragments from de legat. gent., 23. 1–24. 16 and 25. 1–7, on an Egyptian appeal to Achaea for help against Antiochus; but the scene is Achaea, and it is more likely that they are from res Graeciae and therefore must come before 22. 1–5. Since they follow 19. 1–11 in de legat. gent., [29]
they cannot precede P.'s account of the war against Perseus, and should probably go after 21. 9. 27. 1–13 (de legat. Rom.) describes the famous episode when C. Popillius drew a circle round Antiochus; it corresponds to Livy xlv. 12. 3–8 and must stand here in res Aegypti. In the manuscripts it is followed by the phrase τέλος τοῦ λου λόγου, indicating not that this fragment belongs to book xxx (so Steigemann, 43–5), but that de legat. Rom. contains no fragments from that book. Büttner-Wobst adduces the parallel example at the end of book xxxviii, where the same excerpts have the phrase τέλος τῆς πολυβίου ἱστορίας (xxxviii. 13. 9). Further proof that 27. 1–13 is from book xxix is adduced by Koperberg, 94, who observes that Diod. xxxi. 2 (de sent.) corresponds to xxix. 27 and Diod. xxxi. 5. 2 (de sent.) to xxx. 4. 7 (note the reference to the swan-song); since, however, Diodorus is following P. and since the second passage is from res Italiae of Ol. 153, 1 = 168/7, the order of the fragments supports (without proving) the placing of xxix. 27 in Ol. 152, 4 = 169/8. 12. BOOK XXX xxxiii. 1. 1, from the excerpts de legat. gent., is attributed to that book in the margin of the manuscripts, and in xxxiii. 1. 5 A. Postumius Albinus is praetor; since his praetorship fell in the consulship of P. Cornelius Scipio Nasica and M. Claudius Marcellus (Cic. Acad. ii. 137), book xxxiii evidently contained Ol. 156, 1 = 156/5 (since this would be equated with the consulship of A.U.C. 599 = 155). It has already been established (above, p. 22) that book xxix contained Ol. 152, 4 = 169/8. Consequently, since P. nowhere in the main part of his Histories covers more than one olympiad in a single book, it seems likely that book xxx contained Ol. 153 = 168/4, book xxxi Ol. 154 = 164/0, and book xxxii Ol. 155 = 160/56. Analysis of the fragments confirms this hypothesis. These extracts are from the Constantinian excerpts: de legat. gent.: 1. 1–5. 16 (Attalus and Rhodians at Rome: exc. 79); 13. 1–11 (Greek embassies to the Romans in Macedonia: exc. 80); 16. 1–2 (the Ptolemies send an envoy to Rome: exc. 81); 17. 1–4 (Cotys' envoys at Rome: exc. 82); 18. 1–19. 17 (Prusias and Eumenes at Rome: exc. 83); 20. 1–7 (Athenian requests at Rome: exc. 84); 21. 1–5 (Rhodian and other envoys at Rome: exc. 85); 23. 1–4 (Cretan affairs: Rhodians send envoys to Rome: exc. 86); 27. 1–4 (Ti. Gracchus reaches Antiochus: exc. 87); 28 (Galatian audience at Rome: exc. 88); 29. 1 (dislike of Callicrates in Greece: exc. 89); 30. 1– 31. 20 (embassies at Rome: exc. 90); 32. 1–12 (Achaean embassy at Rome: exc. 91). (30. 7–8 stands after 32. 10 in the manuscripts; it was transposed by Schweighaeuser and subsequent editors have concurred (contra Koperberg, 85–86).) de uirt. et uit.: 6. 1–9. 21 (Greek [30]
opponents of Rome: exc. 98); 11. 1–6 (chaos in Aetolia: exc. 99); 12. 1–3 (also in Epirus: exc. 100); 29. 2–7 (Callicrates and his followers hated: exc. 101); de sent.: 4. 16–17 (part of the passage given in de legat. gent.: exc. 128); 5. 3 (the same: exc. 129); 10. 1–2 (an example of Tyche: exc. 130); 14 (a saying of Aemilius Paullus: exc. 131); 20. 8–9 (result for Athens of receiving Lemnos: exc. 132); 24. 1–2 (behaviour in Peraea on liberation: exc. 133). A framework is given by the excerpts de legat. gent., which contain sections from res Italiae of four separate years (since they are separated by events from other areas); these need not be, but in fact are, from four successive years. 1. 1–5. 16 (Attalus and Rhodians at Rome) corresponds to Livy, xlv. 19–25 (basically Polybian, but with annalistic or Livian versions of the Rhodian speeches); Livy's date, A.U.C. 587 = 167 points to Ol. 153, 1 = 168/7 for the fragment of P. Two passages (4. 16–17 and 5. 3) are also in de sent. where they follow xxix. 26. 2. 6. 1–9. 21, on the behaviour in adversity of three classes of antiRoman Greek statesmen, follows xxviii. 18 in the excerpts de uirt. et uit., and some scholars have wished to locate it in book xxix (Metzung, 7–8; van Gelder, Rhodier, 153 n. 1; Koperberg, 88). But its context is the behaviour of Deinon and Polyaratus of Rhodes after Perseus' defeat (6. 1, 7. 1), the war is over (7. 3), Polyaratus has had time to flee to Egypt (9. 2) and have other adventures (9. 2– 19). The fragment must therefore be retained in the res Graeciae of Ol. 153, 1 = 168/7. But Livy has no corresponding passage, and it remains uncertain whether it followed P.'s account of the reaction at Rhodes to news of the senatus consultum (5. 16), or the decision taken at Amphipolis about Aetolia, which led Livy (and so perhaps P.) to some general observations (Livy, xlv. 31). In the latter case, it would stand after 10 or even later; but the former is more likely and there is no cogent reason for displacing it from where it now stands. 10. 1–2 (de sent.) corresponds to Livy, xlv. 27. 7, and 10. 3–6 (four passages from Suidas) to Livy, xlv. 28. 2–5, on Aemilius Paullus' tour of Greece in 167; hence the position of 10 in res Graeciae of Ol. 153, 1 = 168/7 is assured. 11 and 12 have no passages corresponding to them in Livy, and since the next excerpt in de uirt. et uit. (29. 2–7) is from Ol. 153, 3 = 166/5 (see below, p. 33), they could (on the basis of their place in the excerpts) belong to either Ol. 153, 1 or Ol. 153, 2. However, as Schweighaeuser saw, the massacre mentioned in 11. 5 seems to be the one referred to in Livy, xlv. 28. 7 (A.U.C. 587 = 167), which confirms the placing of 11 and 12 in the res Graeciae of Ol. 153, 1 = 168/7. 13 (de legat. gent.), on congratulatory embassies sent to the Romans in Macedonia, corresponds to Livy, xlv. 31, and must follow 10 (and probably also 11 and 12). 14 (de sent.) corresponds to Livy, xlv. 32. 11, and 15, a reference to P. from Strabo, matches [31]
Livy, xlv. 34. 6, on the destruction of seventy Epirote cities; both clearly follow on in res Graeciae of Ol. 153, 1 = 168/7. 16. 1–2, which stands between 13. 11 and 17. 1–4 in de legat. gent. must be from res Aegypti of Ol. 153, 1 = 168/7. Livy, xlv. 42. 6 (A.U.C. 587 = 167) gives the annalistic version of the arrival of Cotys' envoys at Rome at the end of the consular year; 17. 1–4 (de legat. gent.) will therefore be from res Italiae of Ol. 153, 2 = 167/6. 18. 1–19. 17, on Prusias and Eumenes at Rome, and 20. 1–7, on the Athenian envoys, are closely linked in the excerpts de legat. gent. (cf. 19. 17); Livy, xlv. 44. 1–18, gives the annalistic version of the former section (with a reference to P. at 44. 19), but this is the last chapter in our manuscript of Livy, whose help is therefore lacking from now on. These passages, and 21. 1–5, which follows 20. 7 and precedes 23. 1–4 (on Crete) in de legat. gent., must all concern the same set of audiences in the res Italiae of Ol. 153, 2 = 167/6. 20. 8–9 from de sent. clearly links with 20. 7. 22. 1–12, from Athenaeus xiv. 615, describes games held to celebrate his victory by L. Anicius Gallus. His triumph was on the Quirinalia (of consular year 167, or Roman year 166) and this date (a.d. xii kal. mart.) is equivalent to 19 Nov. 167 (Jul.) or, if A.U.C. 587 = 167 was intercalary, 11 or 12 Dec. 167 (Jul.) (cf. Michels, 171–2; Derow, Phoenix, 1973, 355). But there is no evidence that Anicius' games immediately followed his triumph. Athenaeus assigns P.'s account to book xxx (22. 1); but this does not give us the year. Koperberg, 29, thinks that P. described the games under res Graeciae of 168/7, as a foil to those of Aemilius Paullus and a contrast to his ingenium (cf. Livy, xlv. 32. 10, 'prudentiam in dandis spectaculis, ad quae rudes tum Romani erant'); this chapter would then stand between 13 and 14. This is quite possible, but hypothetical. Accordingly it seems best to leave 22. 1–12 where it is generally placed, at the end of res Italiae of Ol. 153, 2 = 167/6, but to recognize that once it has been separated from Anicius' triumph (and if it is linked with that it will stand before 18. 1–19. 12, since Prusias' reception followed Anicius' triumph: Livy xlv. 43. 1–8, 44. 4–21), we cannot know in what context or indeed in which year P. introduced it. Since 23. 1–4, on Crete and Rhodes, stands at a point in de legat. gent. between 21. 5 (res Italiae) and 27. 1 (res Asiae)—which is in turn followed by 28 (res Italiae)—it is likely that 23. 1–4 is from the res Graeciae of Ol. 153, 2 = 167/6. Because it includes an embassy to Rome, which arrived in summer 166 (23. 3), Koperberg, 64–5, would include it under res Italiae of Ol. 153, 2 = 167/6; but the first part of the excerpt hardly fits res Italiae, whereas because of the unusual time of its arrival, the embassy may well have been mentioned en passant under res Graeciae. 24. 1–2 follows 20. 8–9 in de sent. and precedes xxxi. 6. 6, which belongs to res Asiae of Ol. 154, 1 = 164/3 [32]
(see below, p. 35); this would allow it to stand in res Asiae of Ol. 153, 2 = 167/6, Ol. 153, 3 = 166/5, Ol. 153, 4 = 165/4, or Ol. 154, 1 = 164/3 (see Fraser and Bean, 121–2). But since the reactions described are more likely to have been mentioned immediately after the liberation of the Peraea, the fragment may be left here. 25. 1–26. 9 (from Athen. v. 194, with overlap in Athen. x. 439 and Diod. xxxi. 16. 2–3) is attributed in Athen. x. 439 to book xxxi; but that attribution is unlikely to be correct. An extract mentioning a remark of Cato on the extravagance of Roman youths (xxxi. 25. 5–5a) is also attributed in Athen. vi. 274 to book xxxi; and, as will be demonstrated below (pp. 36– 7), it was probably included in the res Italiae of Ol. 154, 4 = 161/0. Consequently, if Athenaeus' attribution of the account of Antiochus' procession in 25. 1–26. 9 to book xxxi is correct, that book must have included both this and events of 161/0; but since Antiochus' games must have preceded his departure for the east (1 Macc. iii. 37), which was probably in May 165 (Mørkholm, 98 n. 37, 166), they are likely to have been described under the res Asiae of Ol. 153, 2 = 167/6. Hence book xxxi would have to begin with that olympiad year and continue to the end of Ol. 154, an arrangement unparalleled elsewhere. It must therefore be assumed that Athenaeus x. 439 is incorrect in attributing 25. 1–26. 9 to book xxxi. (Steigemann, 46–7, argues that book xxx contained Ol. 153, 1, book xxxi Ol. 153, 2–4, and book xxxii Ol. 154 and 155; and he therefore rejects Athenaeus' attribution of xxxi. 25. 5–5a to book xxxi, and puts the passage in book xxxii. This has no plausibility at all.) If this argument is accepted, 25. 1–26. 9 is from the res Asiae of Ol. 153, 2 = 167/6, and Antiochus' games are the sequel to those held by Aemilius Paullus at Amphipolis in 167 (Livy, xlv. 32. 8– 33. 1), as 25. 1 indicates. 27 (from de legat. gent.) clearly follows on the last passage (cf. Diod. xxxi. 17, with the same sequence from a different set of excerpts): it will be res Asiae, and Ti. Gracchus' legatio will belong to 166. His return was probably in 165 (cf. xxx. 30. 7 n.). 28, also from de legat. gent., is from res Italiae and therefore from a later year. Unless these excerpts contained nothing from Ol. 153, 3 = 166/5, it is to this year that 28 belongs; the Galatian envoys were evidently heard in the winter of 166/5. 29. 1, from the same excerpts, will be from res Graeciae of that olympiad year, since it is followed by 30. 1– 31. 20 belonging to the res Italiae of Ol. 153, 4 = 165/4 (see below). 29. 2–7 (from de uirt. et uit.) is clearly from the same context; it is followed in that collection by xxxi. 6. 1–5, which is preceded by the marginal comment λο\?\ λᾱ , which assigns that passage to book xxxi. Evidently there were no excerpts from Ol. 153, 4 = 165/4 in de uirt. et uit. 30. 1–31. 20 and 32. 1–12, both from de legat. gent., describe the [33]
arrival of a Rhodian and other embassies at Rome; this round of embassies seems distinct from those mentioned in xxxi. 1. 2–6, where Attalus and Athenaeus reply to the charges brought on the earlier occasion by Prusias and various Asian cities, and they are probably those heard at the beginning of A.U.C. 590 = 164. These excerpts will therefore be part of the res Italiae of Ol. 153, 4 = 165/4. This gets some confirmation from Livy, ep. 46, which puts the Rhodian embassy which secured the alliance of Rome and Prusias' complaints before the lustrum of 164 (cf. Koperberg, 80; Habicht, RE, 'Prusias (2)', col. 1114), though indeed the Livian periochae are often unreliable on the sequence of events. On the transposing of 30. 7–8 from its original place following 32. 10 see above, p. 30; and for the likelihood that xxxi. 1. 1 (from de legat. gent.) is from res Asiae of Ol. 153, 4 = 165/4 see below, p. 35. 13. BOOK XXXI For the argument that this book contained Ol. 154 = 164/0 see above, p. 30. These extracts are from the Constantinian excerpts: de legat. gent.: 1. 1 (Ti. Gracchus suppresses the Cammani: exc. 92); 1. 2–8 (embassy from Eumenes: exc. 92 cont.); 2. 1–14 (decisions concerning Syria, Macedonia, Asia Minor, and Egypt: exc. 93); 3. 1–5 (embassy from Ariarathes: exc. 94); 4. 1–4 (Rhodian embassy to Rome: exc. 95); 5. 1–5 (Calynda, Caunus, and Rhodes: exc. 96); 7. 1–4 (Ariarathes recovers his sister's and mother's bones: exc. 96 cont.); 10. 1–10 (Ptolemy VI's and his brother's envoys at Rome: exc. 97); 11. 1–15. 12 (Demetrius' escape from Italy: exc. 98); 17. 1– 18. 16 (struggle between the Ptolemies: exc. 98 cont.); 19. 1–4 (same topic: exc. 99); 20. 1–6 (Ptolemies' embassies at Rome: exc. 100); 21. 1–8 (embassies from Carthage and Masinissa at Rome: exc. 101); 32. 1–3 (Prusias, the Galatians, Eumenes, and Ariarathes send envoys to Rome: exc. 102); 33. 1–5 (Demetrius recognized: exc. 103); de legat. Rom.: 8. 1–8 (Roman envoys reach Cappadocia: exc. 29); de uirt. et uit.: 6. 1–5 (C. Sulpicius encourages accusations against Eumenes: exc. 102); 9. 1–4 (death of Antiochus IV: exc. 103); 22. 1– 30. 4 (Aemilius Paullus and Scipio Aemilianus: exc. 104); de sent.: 6. 6 (growth of Greek sympathy for Eumenes: exc. 134); 16. 1–2 (Ariarathes deters Artaxias from murder: exc. 135); 16. 3 (on beauty: exc. 136); 25. 5–5a (Cato's remark on the corrupt youth of Rome: exc. 137); 31. 1–3 (Rhodes accepts a subsidy from Eumenes: exc. 138). Antiochus IV's death was reported at Babylon between c. 20 Nov. and c. 18 Dec. 164 (see xxxi. 1. 8 n.); hence 9. 1–4 (from de uirt. et uit.) recording it stands correctly in res Asiae of Ol. 154, 1 = 164/3. (Part of this fragment is also in Suidas, s.v. δαιµονᾶν.) The previous excerpt in this collection, 6. 1–5 (recording the encouragement by [34]
C. Sulpicius of accusations against Eumenes), is probably the first from this book (see above, p. 33); 6. 6 (de sent.), commenting on this, goes naturally here. The sending of C. Sulpicius is mentioned in 1. 6 (from de legat. gent.); hence 1. 2–8 must be from res Italiae of the same year (Ol. 154, 1 = 164/3). 2. 1–14 and 3. 1–5 from the same excerpts also record embassies to Rome, apparently from the same winter. There could be a year's interval between 1. 2–8 and 2. 1–14; but this is unlikely, for in 3. 5 Ariarathes' envoys are said to have been well received because of Ti. Gracchus' report, and he had returned to Rome the previous olympiad year (xxx. 31. 19). Moreover, the return of these envoys to Cappadocia is recounted in 7. 1–4 (from de legat. gent.), and since in 8. 1–8 (from the de legat. Rom.) Cn. Octavius and Sp. Lucretius (whose dispatch from Rome was mentioned in 2. 9) arrive in Cappadocia, the order of all these interconnected excerpts within this olympiad year (Ol. 154, 1 = 164/3) seems assured; for the sequence of fragments in de legat. gent. determines the assignment of 4 and 5 to res Asiae (probably; though it is not always clear whether the affairs of Rhodes are included under Asia or Greece). On the suppression of the Cammani, mentioned in 1. 1 (de legat. gent.), see the commentary ad loc. Though included in one excerpt with 1. 2–8, it cannot form part of the res Italiae of Ol. 154, 1 = 164/3, but must be from res Asiae of Ol. 153, 4 = 165/4; it will refer to a date early in the olympiad year, since Gracchus returned from the east in late autumn or early winter 165 (cf. xxx. 30. 7 n.). Steigemann, 46, also puts 1. 1 after xxx. 32. 12 in book xxx, but assumes illogically that its date is 164. There is a slight uncertainty about the position of 9. 1–4 (de uirt. et uit.) relative to 7 and 8. Since the death of Antiochus IV (which it records) took place in autumn 164 (above, p. 34), 9. 1–4 could stand between 6. 1–6 and 7. 1–4, especially as the latter passage concerns events which were directly the result of Antiochus' death. But since P. may have dealt with Syrian affairs all together, this possibility does not warrant changing the established order. Two excerpts which follow each other in de legat. gent., 10. 1–10 (on the presence at Rome of Ptolemy VI's embassy and that of his younger brother, the future Euergetes II) and 11. 1–15. 12 (on Demetrius' escape to Syria), both mention the presence at Rome of Menyllus (10. 4, 12. 8), suggesting that both may refer to the same year. That this is in fact Ol. 154, 2 = 163/2 is clear from the reference to the murder of Cn. Octavius (11. 1), who had been sent out early in 163 (2. 9). Obsequens records the murder under the consuls of A.U.C. 592 = 162, which would equate with Ol. 154, 2 = 163/2. Eusebius, Chron. i. 253 Sch., makes Demetrius' first regnal year Ol. 154, 4 = 161/0, but since on arriving in Asia he quickly asserted his position, [35]
this must be corrected to Ol. 154, 3 = 162/1 to fit the death of the boy Antiochus V in 162 (cf. Niese, iii. 246 n. 1). Schweighaeuser, probably rightly, assigned a sentence from Suidas (15. 13) to the account of Demetrius' escape. As to whether it is from res Italiae or (more probably) res Asiae, see discussion ad loc.; in the latter case it could stand either before or after 16. 1–3 (on uncertainties about that passage see below). 17. 1–18. 16 (de legat. gent.) mentions the legati Cn. Merula (17. 8) and T. Torquatus (18. 1), whose dispatch to the east was recorded in 10. 9; it will therefore form part of the res Aegypti (BüttnerWobst less probably makes it res Africae because of the advance into Cyrenaica) of the same year, Ol. 154, 2 = 163/2. 19. 1–4, from the same excerpts, clearly follows directly after 17. 1–18. 16. Two short excerpts, 16. 1–2 and 16. 3, stand in de sent. between 6. 6 and 25. 5, which merely pins them down to a position between the res Asiae of Ol. 154, 1 = 164/3 and (see below) the res Italiae of Ol. 154, 4 = 161/0. 16. 1–2, on Ariarathes and Artaxias, corresponds to Diod. xxxi. 22, but the position of that passage in the excerpts de uirt. et uit. does not help to determine its date. Consequently the position of 16. 1–2 lies open as between Ol. 154, 2 = 163/2 (where Büttner-Wobst places it) and Ol. 154, 3 = 162/1; Ol. 154, 1 = 164/3 cannot be wholly excluded, but in that year Ariarathes was occupied with the Galatians and Syria (8. 1–8). 16. 3 is too brief and general for its context to be determined. 20. 1–6 (de legat. gent.) describes the arrival at Rome of Comanus and Ptolemy, whose dispatch is mentioned in 19. 2, and so must be from res Italiae of Ol. 154, 3 = 162/1. The next excerpt from de legat. gent., 32. 1–3, describes the sending of a gold crown by Ariarathes to Rome; its arrival is described in xxxii. 1. 1–7, which can be assigned to Ol. 155, 1 = 160/59 by comparison with Diod. xxxi. 28. 32. 1–3 must therefore be from res Asiae of Ol. 154, 4 = 161/0; and since 33. 1–5 also belongs (like xxxii. 1. 1–7) to de legat. gent., and concerns the sending of Cn. Octavius' murderer to Rome—his arrival is described in xxxii. 2. 1–3. 13—this passage too will stand in the same res Asiae. A fragment dealing with Masinissa and Carthage (21. 1–8) stands between 20. 1–6 (Ol. 154, 3 = 162/1) and 32. 1–3 (Ol. 154, 4 = 161/0); it could be from the res Africae of either year. The order of the two passages, 22. 1–30. 4 (from de uirt. et uit.) on Aemilius Paullus and Scipio Aemilianus, and 31. 1–3 (from de sent.) on Eumenes' subsidy to Rhodes, is assured by a short extract from the former (25. 5) in de sent. (22. 1–30. 4 is also duplicated by Suidas at 22. 3–4, 25. 7, 26. 3–8, 26. 3, 26. 4, 26. 6 and 26. 10, and by Athen. vi. 274 at 25. 5, mentioning book xxxi); they belong to res Italiae and res Graeciae respectively, but their position in the excerpts does not determine [36]
of which year. The digression on Scipio contained in 22. 1–30. 4 clearly arose on the death of Aemilius Paullus (cf. 22. 1–2). Livy, ep. 46 mentions this between Demetrius' return to Syria (162) and the draining of the Pomptine marshes by Cornelius Cethegus, cos. A.U.C. 594 = 160, thus leaving Ol. 154, 3 = 162/1 or Ol. 154, 4 = 161/0 open as the year of Aemilius' death. But internal evidence shows that the later year is the right one. The Greek detainees reached Rome in 167 (cf. xxxi. 24. 1 n.) and the friendship between P. and Aemilianus was established shortly afterwards. After devoting five years to gaining a reputation for moral strictness (xxxi. 25. 8 n.), Scipio set about gaining one for generosity. This involved three incidents, of which two linked with the death of Africanus' widow Aemilia (xxxi. 26. 1–27. 16) and the third, two years later (xxxi. 28. 1), with the death of Aemilius Paullus. Hence approximately seven years elapsed between the conversation of P. and Scipio and Aemilius' death; the conversation was therefore in 167 and Aemilius' death in 160, and 22. 1–30. 4 must be from the res Italiae of Ol. 154, 4 = 161/0. 31. 1–3 is from the same olympiad year, since the next passage in de sent. is from res Italiae of Ol. 155, 1 = 160/59 (xxxii. 3. 7–9: see below). It describes a subsidy from Eumenes to Rhodes, and could stand in either res Graeciae or res Asiae. 14. BOOK XXXII For the argument that this book contained Ol. 155 = 160/56 see above, p. 30. These extracts are from the Constantinian excerpts: de legat. gent.: 1. 1–7 (various embassies to Rome: exc. 104); 2. 1– 3. 13 (embassy from Demetrius: exc. 105); 3. 14–17 (embassy from Achaea: exc. 105 cont.); 7. 1–5 (embassy about Delos: exc. 106); 9. 1–5 (C. Fannius sent to Dalmatia: exc. 107); 10. 1–8 (various envoys at Rome: exc. 108); 14. 1–2 (envoys from Epirus: exc. 108 cont.); 16. 1–5 (Athenaeus sent to Rome to complain about Prusias: exc. 109); de legat. Rom.: 13. 1–9 (Roman decision to make war on Dalmatia: exc. 30); de uirt. et uit.: 5. 1–5 (Charops: exc. 105); 5. 6–6. 9 (the same: exc. 106); 8. 1–7 (Eumenes' character: exc. 107); 12 (Attalus restores Ariarathes: exc. 108); 15. 1–14 (Prusias' campaign against Attalus: exc. 109); de sent.: 3. 7–9 (overlap with fragment from de legat. gent.: exc. 139); 4. 1–2 (Aetolia after Lyciscus' death: exc. 140); 4. 3 (the same: exc. 141); 11. 1–7 (Orophernes, and Oropus: exc. 142); 11. 8–9 (remark on Orophernes: exc. 143). It has already been shown (above, p. 36) that 1. 1–7, mentioning the arrival of Ariarathes' envoys at Rome, and 2. 1–3. 13 are from res Italiae of Ol. 155, 1 = 160/59. Both are from de legat. gent. but there is an overlap with de sent. at 3. 7–9. 10. 1–8 (from de legat. gent.) recounts Ariarathes' arrival in Rome in summer 158; the date follows from the reference to the consuls of [37]
A.U.C. 597 = 157 in 10. 2, and the extract is clearly part of the res Italiae of Ol. 155, 3 = 158/7. 11. 3 shows that P. passed straight from Ariarathes' departure from Italy to the affairs of Cappadocia; hence 11. 1–7 and 11. 8–9, both from de sent., must be from res Asiae of the same olympiad year. 11. 10, from Athen. x. 440, is from the same context, but should probably precede 11. 1, since it comes from the account of Ariarathes' restoration. 11. 4 indicates that in this book, exceptionally, res Graeciae followed the section of res Asiae dealing with Ariarathes; but no fragments survive (unless xxxiii. 2 belongs here: see below, p. 40). 10. 1–8 is preceded in the excerpts de legat. gent. by 9. 1–5, which records the arrival of Issan (?) envoys at Rome and the dispatch to Dalmatia of C. Fannius. Before it in this collection comes 7. 1–5 on the arrival of Athenian and Achaean envoys at Rome to discuss Delos, and before that 3. 14–17, describing an Achaean embassy about the detainees. It seems likely that the latter, like 2. 1–3. 13, is from the res Italiae of Ol. 155, 1 = 160/59, and that 7. 1–5, with its new Achaean embassy, is from Ol. 155, 2 = 159/8, and from the res Italiae. 9. 1– 5 is also from res Italiae, but does it belong to the same year as 7. 1–5 (159/8) or 10. 1–8 (158/7)? The answer is in 13. 1–9, from de legat. Rom., which describes Fannius' return and the decision to make war on Dalmatia. It was now, P. observes (13. 7), ἔτος . . . δωδέκατον since the war against Perseus and the campaigns in Macedonia. Since P. described Pydna and the surrender of Perseus under Ol. 152, 4 = 169/8 (in book xxix), the twelfth year after would be Ol. 155, 4 = 157/6; hence 13. 1–9 will be from the res Italiae of that year, and 9. 1–5, recording C. Fannius' departure for Dalmatia, must fall in Ol. 155, 3 = 158/7, and immediately precede 10. 1–8. Two excerpts, 4. 1–2 and 4. 3, stand (in de sent.) between 3. 7–9 (res Italiae of Ol. 155, 1 = 160/59) and 11. 1–7 (res Asiae of Ol. 155, 3 = 158/7); they concern Lyciscus of Aetolia and belong to the res Graeciae of Ol. 155, 1 = 160/59 or Ol. 155, 2 = 159/8 (but not Ol. 155, 3 = 158/7, since in that year P. went directly from res Italiae to res Asiae (11. 3)). 5. 1–6. 9 consists of two passages which follow xxxi. 30. 4 in de uirt. et uit., and record the death of Charops of Epirus; the position of this section immediately after 4. 3 is confirmed by the reference to Lyciscus in 5. 1. It is clear from 6. 5 that Charops arrived in Rome before the death of Aemilius Paullus in 160 (see above, p. 37); hence, if his death at Brundisium (5. 4) occurred on his way home after his interview with the Senate (6. 3–9), this must have followed the entry into office of the consuls for A.U.C. 595 = 159, and his death the same year, i.e., in Ol. 155, 1 = 160/59. This confirms the placing of 4. 1–2, 4. 3, and 5. 1–6. 9 in the res Graeciae of Ol. 155, 1 = 160/59 (as in Büttner-Wobst). [38]
8. 1–7, which follows 5. 1–6. 9 in de uirt. et uit. (but is also largely in Suidas), is an obituary on Eumenes II; it immediately precedes (in that collection) 12, a statement that the first example of Attalus' principles was his restoration of Ariarathes, which occurred in Ol. 155, 3 = 158/7 (see above, pp. 37–8, discussing 11. 1–10), and is therefore not likely to have been much before. Diod. xxxi. 32 a makes Eumenes survive until after Ariarathes' expulsion; but Niese iii. 250 n. 5 plausibly emends 'Eumenes' to 'Attalus', and the easiest solution is that Eumenes died in 158, and that 8. 1–7 belongs to the res Asiae of Ol. 155, 2 = 159/8. 12 seems to be part of the account of Ariarathes' restoration and should therefore stand (with 11. 10) before 11. 1–7. 14. 1–2 follows 10. 8 in de legat. gent. and mentions the dispatch of envoys to Illyria 'with C. Marcius'. C. Marcius (Figulus) was consul A.U.C. 598 = 156, when he commanded the Roman forces in Dalmatia (Livy, ep. 47; App. Ill. 11. 1). 14. 1–2 could stand after 10. 1–8 in Ol. 155, 3 = 158/7; but it is unlikely that C. Marcius was sent out as a legatus in 157, since C. Fannius headed an Illyrian mission that year (9. 3, 13. 1). More probably then 14. 1–2 is from res Italiae of Ol. 155, 4 = 157/6, following 13. 1–9, since the mention of C. Marcius suggests that war had already been decided on. Either the envoys accompanied Marcius, who went out in command, or there has been some compression of the wording at the end of the extract. War between Prusias and Attalus is dealt with in 15. 1–14, from the excerpts de uirt. et uit. (where it precedes xxxiii. 4. 1–4)—with several passages from Suidas—and in 16. 1–5, which follows 14. 2 and precedes xxxiii. 1. 1–8 in de legat. gent.; it is also dealt with in xxxiii. 1. 1–2, 7. 1–4, 12. 1–13, and 13. 1–10. The traditional order for these fragments has to be corrected by comparison with Appian, Mithr. 3, a narrative deriving ultimately from P. (cf. Habicht, Hermes, 1956, 101–10). xxxiii. 1. 1–8 (from de legat. gent.) records the arrival of Athenaeus and P. Lentulus in Rome; a marginal note λογ. λγ΄ indicates that this is a new book in this collection, κατὰ χειµῶνα (xxxiii. 1. 1) suggests the usual winter hearing of embassies, and the year is Ol. 156, 1 = 156/5, since A. Postumius Albinus is praetor (xxxiii. 1. 5: this was in A.U.C. 599 = 155). This confirms the position of the preceding passage in de legat. gent., 16. 1–5, in the res Asiae of Ol. 155, 4 = 157/6. 15. 1–14 (from de uirt. et uit.) refers to Prusias' siege of Pergamum; and such a siege also occurs in xxxiii. 7. 1–4. Since it is clear from Appian that Prusias only besieged Pergamum once (cf. App. Mithr. 3, associating with the siege the ravaging of the Nicephorium (cf. 15. 3)), the excerpt 15. 1–14 should go in book xxxiii, following the sending of the three envoys (xxxiii. 1. 2); it forms part of res Asiae of Ol. 156, 1 = 156/5, standing after xxxiii. 3. 2. [39]
15. BOOK XXXIII Since 1. 1 is attributed in the margin of the manuscript to book xxxiii (see above, pp. 30 and 39), and it is known that book xxxiv was devoted to geography, it is virtually certain that xxxiii, like xxx, xxxi, and xxxii contained the events of one olympiad, Ol. 156 = 156/2. These extracts are from the Constantinian excerpts: de legat. gent.: 1. 1–8 (embassy sent to Prusias and Attalus: arrival of embassy from Achaea: exc. 110); 3. 1–2 (return of Achaean envoys: exc. 111); 8. 1–3 (Massiliote envoys report Ligurian attacks: exc. 112); 11. 1–7 (envoys from the Ptolemies; help sent to the younger: exc. 113); 14. 1 (Achaean envoys fail: exc. 114); 15. 1–2 (Heracleides brings Laodice and Alexander to Rome: exc. 115); 15. 3–4 (Astymedes reports on the Creto-Rhodian war: exc. 115 cont.); 16. 1–8 (Achaeans remain neutral in that war: exc. 116); 18. 1–14 (Attalus, Demetrius, and Alexander Balas at Rome: exc. 117); de legat. Rom.: 7. 1–4 (envoys report to Rome from Asia: new envoys sent to check on the war between Attalus and Prusias: exc. 31); 9. 1–10. 14 (Ligurians defeated: exc. 32); 12. 1–9 (Roman envoys to Prusias and Attalus: exc. 33); 13. 1–10 (war between Prusias and Attalus ended: exc. 33 cont.); de uirt. et uit.: 4. 1–4 (Aristocrates' failure as general: exc. 110); 5. 2–4 (Archias' suicide: exc. 111); 6. 1–9 (Priene refuses to give Orophernes' money to Ariarathes: exc. 112); de sent.: 17. 1–5 (Rhodian irrational behaviour: exc. 144); 20 (the behaviour of the masses: exc. 145); 21 (possible criticism of P.'s elaborate refutation of an obvious lie: exc. 146). 1. 1–8 belongs to the res Italiae of Ol. 156, 1 = 156/5 (see above, p. 39), and comes from de legat. gent. As ch. 2 Büttner-Wobst prints Aul. Gell. vi. 14. 8–10 on the Athenian philosophers' embassy to Rome, a passage which quotes P. Cicero (Acad. ii. 137) says they were heard by Postumius Albinus in the consulship of P. Scipio and M. Marcellus (155: see above, p. 30), so that chronologically the passage belongs here; but since P. recounted the trouble between Athens and Oropus in one piece in the res Graeciae of Ol. 155, 3 = 158/7 (xxxii. 11. 6), and the philosophers' visit to Rome was part of this, perhaps this passage should stand between xxxii. 11. 9 and xxxii. 13. 3. 1–2 (de legat. gent.) follows 1. 1–8 and describes the return of the Achaean envoys; it perhaps belongs more properly to res Graeciae than to res Italiae (where Büttner-Wobst assigns it). This does not affect the order of the fragments. The war between Prusias and Attalus lasted two years: it broke out in 156 (xxxii. 16. 1–5), Roman legati were sent in winter 156/5 to restrain Prusias (1. 1–2), and after being shut up in Pergamum by Prusias they reported back in 155 (7. 1–3); a new embassy (7. 3–4) arrived in the late winter of 155/4 (12. 1–2), and reported Prusias' [40]
intransigence at Rome (12. 8), and the war eventually ended in 154 (13. 5–10). The relevant excerpts are from de legat. Rom. and apparently are from res Italiae (7. 1–4) and res Asiae (12. 1–9 followed by 13. 1–10) of Ol. 156, 2 = 155/4; 3. 1–2 is followed by xxxii. 15. 1–14, describing Prusias' outrageous conduct (above, p. 39), which stands in the res Asiae of Ol. 156. 1 = 156/5. 9. 1–10. 14, which stands between 7. 1–4 and 12. 1–9 in de legat. Rom., describes a Massiliote embassy, a Roman embassy which met with rough treatment from the Ligurians, and the dispatch of Q. Opimius, cos. A.U.C. 600 = 154. This must be from the res Italiae of Ol. 156, 2 = 155/4 (P. has no separate section on Gaul), and so confirms the date of the excerpts relating to Prusias and Attalus. 8. 1–3 (from de legat. gent.) refers to the same Massiliote embassy, and therefore comes before 9. 1–10. 14; it is followed in the same excerpts by 11. 1–7, mentioning an embassy from the Ptolemies, and clearly part of the res Italiae of Ol. 156, 2 = 155/4, since it mentions the sending of Opimius to Liguria. This confirms Büttner-Wobst's arrangement of the fragments of res Italiae for this olympiad year. 4. 1–4 (de uirt. et uit.), on Aristocrates' failure, is related to the Rhodian war with Crete (cf. Diod. xxxi. 37), and Steigemann, 50–1, assigned it to Ol. 155, 4 = 157/6 (i.e. book xxxii); but as the preceding excerpt in that collection, xxxii. 15. 1–14, should stand in book xxxiii (see above, p. 39), 4. 1–4 must also stay in that book. Since P. normally deals with Rhodes at a point between res Graeciae and res Asiae (so that it sometimes seems to be reckoned as one and sometimes as the other), the fact that xxxii. 15. 1–14 forms part of the res Asiae of Ol. 156, 1 = 156/5 suggests that 4. 1–4 will stand in one of the three subsequent years of the olympiad. In the excerpts de uirt. et uit. 4. 1–4 is followed in succession by 5. 2–4 (on Archias' suicide after failing to betray Cyprus to Demetrius) and 6. 1–9 (on the refusal by Priene to surrender Orophernes' money to Ariarathes). 6. 1–9 is followed in the manuscript by a sentence which in fact belongs to book xxxiv (xxxiv. 6. 15), and is therefore likely to be the last excerpt from xxxiii in this collection. Thus, on the evidence of the manuscript, 5. 2–4 and 6. 1–9 might be from any of the last three years of Ol. 156. However, some help is available from Diodorus, from whom the excerpts de sent. give a section on the Celtiberian War (Diod. xxxi. 39–40) standing between two passages which correspond to 4. 1–4 (Diod. xxxi. 37) and 17. 1–5 (Diod. xxxi. 43)— P. being Diodorus' source at this point. If two passages on Rhodes were separated in P. by one from res Hispaniae, they were probably in separate olympiad years. But the evidence concerning the events at the outset of the Celtiberian War (see below, pp. 43–44) shows that the passage Diod. xxxi. 39–40 (corresponding to xxxv. 1) cannot be earlier than Ol. 156, 3 = 154/3. 17. 1–5 will be from the Rhodian [41]
events of the same year, and consequently 4. 1–4 must be from the Rhodian events of Ol. 156, 2 = 155/4. It would not necessarily follow that 5. 2–4 (from de uirt. et uit., supplemented by Suidas at 5. 1 and 5. 2a) on Archias' treachery, and 6. 1–9 on Orophernes and Priene were also from that year. But it is on the whole unlikely that Ariarathes waited until 153 or 152 to ask for the money, and this is in favour of putting 6. 1–9 (and so 5. 1–4 as well) in Ol. 156, 2 = 155/4. But in what order they stood relative to the chapters on the war between Attalus and Prusias is in doubt (and consequently whether 12. 1–13. 10 should stand before 5. 1–4, after 6. 1–9, or between the two passages).1 11. 1–7 (from the res Italiae of Ol. 156, 2 = 155/4: see above, p. 41) is followed in de legat. gent. by the following excerpts: 14 (Achaean embassy to Rome concerning the detainees); 15. 1–2 (arrival in Rome, while it is still summer, of Heracleides, bringing Laodice and Alexander Balas); 15. 3–4 (arrival of Astymedes of Rhodes at Rome); 16. 1–8 (Cretan and Rhodian attempt to get Achaean support); 18. 1–14 (senatorial audience for various embassies including Heracleides). Of these, 16. 1–8 is from res Graeciae and the rest from res Italiae; the reference to Heracleides shows that 16. 1–8 is from the year subsequent to 15. 1–2 and 15. 3– 4, and clearly 16. 1–8 must be from the res Graeciae of the same year as the two preceding passages. Since 11. 1–7, dealing with events after the dispatch of Q. Opimius to Gaul, probably refers to the second part of summer, 154 (see below, xxxiii. 11. 1–7 n.), the likelihood is that 14, 15. 1–2, and 15. 3–4 are all from the res Italiae of the next year, Ol. 156, 3 = 154/3. 16. 1–8 will be from res Graeciae of that year, and 18. 1–14 from res Italiae of Ol. 156, 4 = 153/2. For the argument that xxxv. 1. 1–6, on the outbreak of the Celtiberian War, should stand between 15. 4 and 16. 1 see below, p. 43. 17. 1–5 on Rhodian despondency follows xxxii. 11. 9 in de sent., and the evidence of Diod. xxxi. 43 (see above, p. 41) shows that it comes after 4. 1–4. Since it is unlikely to be more than a year after the Senate sent 'Quintus' to bring the war to an end (15. 4, dated to Ol. 156, 3 = 154/3: above), it probably belongs to the same olympiad year, and can stand after 16. 1–8, though the relationship of the two passages is uncertain. Four passages from Suidas quote extracts from 17. 1–5. 19, from Athen. x. 440, on Demetrius' addiction to drink, is assigned to this book; it could belong to Ol. 156, 4 = 153/2, when he was under attack, but could equally well be from the previous year. 20 and 21 follow 17. 5 in de sent., but since the next passage is [42]
1
The argument of Volkmann (RE, 'Ptolemaios (24)', col. 1714) that Archias' attempt is to be dated to 151/0 because of a large issue of gold in that year must be rejected, since 5. 1–4 must be from book xxxiii (Ol. 156).
xxxvi. 1. 1–7, they are not necessarily from book xxxiii. The former, on the behaviour of the masses, could come almost anywhere; the latter, polemical in tone, might well belong to book xxxiv, where P. attacks Pytheas, Eratosthenes, and Dicaearchus (cf. Schulze, Excerpta, 18 f.); xxxiv. 6. 15 is also from the Constantinian excerpts, evidence that that book was available to the excerptors. 16. BOOK XXXIV Four geographical fragments are attributed to book xxxiv, viz. 8. 1–2 (Athen. vii. 302), 8. 4–10 (Athen. viii. 330), 10. 1–4 (Athen. viii. 332), and 11. 4 (Steph. Byz. s.v. Αἰθάλη). 6. 15 (from de uirt. et uit.: exc. 113) follows xxxiii. 6. 9 in that collection, and clearly belongs to polemic against Eratosthenes. Schweighaeuser's conclusion (viii. 1. 105–7) that book xxxiv contained the geographical excursus promised in iii. 37. 11 and 57. 5 has been generally accepted, but the present arrangement of the fragments, essentially his, is rather arbitrary. Revision must depend, however, on an analysis of the purpose and likely content of the book and not on the chronological and historical considerations, and the economy of the collections of excerpts, which determine the order elsewhere. The problems of the organization of book xxxiv are therefore deferred to pp. 563 ff. 17. BOOK XXXV 2. 1–4. 14 follows xxxiii. 18. 14 in the de legat. gent. and since it refers to the consuls of A.U.C. 603 = 151 as having just entered upon their office (3. 7), it must be from the first year of Ol. 157, i.e. 152/1. The next passage in this collection, xxxvi. 3. 1–6. 6, has a marginal note which varies in different manuscripts: X has λς 'sed ς dubia', U has λγ, VOW have λα, and R has λς. Schweighaeuser (viii. 1. 132–3) had conjectured λς as the original reading and this must be right; the marginal note must indicate a new book. This passage refers to the landing of the consuls in Africa (6. 1), and these were those of A.U.C. 605 = 149 (cf. Livy, ep. 49). Hence this passage is from Ol. 157, 3 = 150/49, and book xxxv will contain Ol. 157, 1 = 152/1 and Ol. 157, 2 = 151/0. Only one extract is from the Constantinian excerpts: de legat. gent.: 2. 1–4. 14 (envoys from Spain: Scipio offers to accompany the consuls: exc. 118). As we saw, it forms part of res Italiae of Ol. 157, 1 = 152/1, a date confirmed by the references to M. Marcellus, the consul of 152, at 2. 1, 3. 1, and 4. 3. 1. 1–6 (from Suidas) is a general characterization of the Celtiberian War, which corresponds to Diod. xxxi. 39–40 (two excerpts from the de sent. of which the second closely echoes P.) ; see above, p. 41. The position of Diod. xxxi. 39–40 does not permit 1. 1–6 to be later than Ol. 156, 3 = 154/3; [43]
it must however have come immediately after the cancellation of the treaty, and this (cf. App. Hisp. 44–45) occurred just before the dispatch to Spain of Q. Fulvius Nobilior, cos. A.U.C. 601 = 153, who entered office on 1 Jan. (On the relationship of Appian to P. see 1. 1–6 n.) Hence 1. 1–6 must stand between xxxiii. 15. 4 and xxxiii. 16. 1, in the res Hispaniae of Ol. 156, 3 = 154/3. 5. 1 and 5. 2 (from Suidas) concern Scipio's deeds in Spain; they belong to Lucullus' campaign of 151 (cf. App. Hisp. 53; Livy, ep. 48) and so to res Hispaniae of Ol. 157, 1 = 152/1. Fg. 6 (from Suidas) may refer to Scipio's combat with a barbarian (Müller, Jahrb. 1870, 245 f.), and if so will follow 5. 2 under the same year. On whether fg. 18 (from Suidas) goes here see xxxv. 5. 2 n. 6. 1–4 is a passage from Plut. Cat. mai. 9, which quotes P. and concerns the release of the Achaean detainees, at a time when Scipio was in Rome and in the seventeenth year of their detention (Paus. vii. 10. 12). This points to 150, and the placing of the passage under res Italiae of Ol. 157, 2 = 151/0; but Ol. 157, 3 = 150/49 (which would take the passage into book xxxvi) cannot be wholly excluded (see ad loc.). 18. BOOK XXXVI These extracts are from the Constantinian excerpts: de legat. gent.: 3. 1–6. 6 (Punic deditio and surrender of hostages and arms: exc. 119); de uirt. et uit.: 15. 1–7 (Prusias' character: exc. 114); 16. 1–10 (Masinissa's character: exc. 115); de sent.: 1. 1–7 (on speeches: exc. 147); 2. 1–4 (Romans seek a pretext before making war: exc. 148); 9. 1–10. 7 (Greek views on the Third Punic War: the pseudoPhilip: exc. 149); 11. 1–4 (P. summoned to Lilybaeum: exc. 150); 12. 1–5 (P. speaks of himself in the third person: exc. 151); 13. 1–2 (on the fate of Callicrates' and Lycortas' statues: exc. 152); 13. 3 (on innovation: exc. 153); 14. 1– 5 (embassy sent to Attalus: exc. 154); 17. 1–16 (state of Greece and Macedonia: exc. 155). 3. 1–6. 6 is from res Africae of Ol. 157, 3 = 150/49 (above, p. 43). According to xxxviii. 1. 1, that book contained the downfall of Greece, which must have taken in Mummius' capture of Corinth; he was cos. A.U.C. 608 = 146, and book xxxviii therefore contained Ol. 158, 2 = 147/6. Since xxxv contained Ol. 157, 1 and 2 = 152/1 and 151/0, this leaves the three years Ol. 157, 3 = 150/49, Ol. 157, 4 = 149/8, and Ol. 158, 1 = 148/7 to be divided between two books; and since P. nowhere overruns an olympiad within a single book, xxxvi must contain Ol. 157, 3 and 4, and xxxvii Ol. 158, 1. 1. 1–7 and 2. 1–4 follow each other in de sent. and deal with speeches in history and the Roman emphasis on a just cause before declaring war. They clearly form part of P.'s introduction to the Third Punic War, and since 2. 1–4 has a corresponding passage in Diod. xxxii. 5, an excerpt from de uirt. et uit., in which collection it is preceded by [44]
a long discussion of Roman imperial policy (Diod. xxxii. 4; cf. 2), it is possible that P. had a fuller discussion than the surviving fragments indicate; but Diod. xxxii. 2 and 4 are not to be taken to represent P.'s own views (cf. Walbank, Entretiens sur Polybe, 18–20). Clearly then 1. 1–7 and 2. 1–4 precede 3. 1–6. 6, probably under res Italiae of Ol. 157, 3 = 150/49. Nissen, Rh. Mus. 1871, 275, suggests that fg. 99 on Roman policy (from Suidas) belongs here; if so, it will follow 2. 1–4. 6. 7, 7. 1–5, and 8. 1–8 are constructed from passages in Suidas, the position of which has been determined by comparison with Appian (and occasionally Diodorus). For 6. 7 cf. App. Lib. 80 and Diod. xxxii. 6. 2; Nissen, Rh. Mus. 1871, 276, would place fg. 192 after 6. 7, but this is doubtful. For 7. 1–2 cf. App. Lib. 91 (on the attitude at Carthage before the Roman decision was known). For 7. 3–5 cf. App. Lib. 91 (end) and 92. For 8. 1 (on Hamilcar- or HimilcoPhameas) cf. App. Lib. 100; his avoidance of a conflict with Scipio (8. 3) is mentioned at the end of the same chapter in Appian, and since the jealousy of Scipio is mentioned in App. Lib. 101, 8. 2 should probably follow and not precede 8. 3. 8. 4–5 corresponds to App. Lib. 103, but is so compressed as to misrepresent Scipio's reaction. 8. 6 (on reporting Scipio's remarks) was placed here by Schweighaeuser; this, because earlier, is perhaps more likely than, for example, after the Homeric quotation in xxxviii. 22. Fg. 67 may come in here. Cato's famous Homeric line about Scipio (8. 7) is in Diod. xxxii. 9 a 2; both there and in Livy, ep. 49, it is linked with Scipio's election to the consulship of A.U.C. 607 = 147, and Walton, in the Loeb edition of Diodorus, puts this fragment under 148 (its position in the de sent. allows this). However, it must go in 149, since Cato died in A.U.C. 605 = 149 (Vell. Pat. i. 12. 7; Plut. Cat. mai. 27. 5); Livy records his death before Galba's trial in that year (ep. 49). The quotation was probably mentioned parenthetically in res Africae. 8. 8 (which Büttner-Wobst repeats as fg. 232) mentions a ὁµολογία of Scipio, probably that made with Phameas (cf. Diod. xxxii. 17. 1; App. Lib. 108–9) shortly before Piso replaced Manilius as consul (for A.U.C. 606 = 148) and Scipio returned to Rome to stand for the consulship of 147. It therefore belongs to Ol. 157, 4 = 149/8, and follows 16. 12. Nissen, Rh. Mus. 1871, 276 would place fg. 47, on Scipio's deeds, between 16. 12 and 8. 8; but it is uncertain whether Aemilianus or Africanus is referred to (cf. xxxi. 30. 3 n.). Appian, Lib., contains a continuous narrative from the Punic declaration of war (Lib. 93) to Masinissa's death in 148 (Lib. 105), and gives no indication at what point P. halted his res Africae of Ol. 157, 3 = 150/49. Hence some of the incidents referred to in the above fragments may have been recorded under Ol. 157, 4 = 149/8. In the excerpts de sent. 2. 1–4 is followed by 9. 1–10. 7, discussing [45]
Greek views about Roman policy towards Carthage and about the pseudo-Philip; this passage precedes 11. 1–4 in this collection, a passage which mentions a letter from Manilius the consul of 149 summoning P. to Sicily, and P.'s return on reaching Corcyra, events which must form part of res Graeciae of Ol. 157, 3 = 150/49. 9. 1– 10. 7 must therefore be from the same res Graeciae. 12. 1–5 (also from de sent.) follows naturally after 11. 1–4. 14. 1–5 (de sent.) describes the sending of an embassy to Attalus II to restrain him from war against Prusias II. Appian (Mithr. 6) records that Attalus' envoys were heard and the Roman envoys dispatched under the chairmanship of a praetor urbanus, which would fit 149, when the two consuls were in Africa; and this date is confirmed by the fact that Cato was still alive. 14. 1–5 must be from the res Asiae of Ol. 157, 3 = 150/49 (its order in de sent. excludes the possibility of its being res Italiae); and 13. 1–2, on what happened to Lycortas' and Callicrates' statues, and 13. 3, on innovation, which stand between 12. 1–5 and 14. 1–5 in the excerpts de sent., must belong to the same olympiad year. 13. 1–2 will be from res Graeciae; 13. 3 is probably from res Graeciae, but it could be from res Asiae (perhaps referring to the rising against Prusias). 15. 1–7, a sketch of Prusias from de uirt. et uit., was probably inserted in connection with his death in 149 (Livy, Ox. ep., 50; Zon. ix. 28. 1); it will be from res Asiae of Ol. 157, 3 = 150/49, and 16. 1–10 on Masinissa, which follows in de uirt. et uit., will be from res Africae of Ol. 157, 4 = 149/8 (since res Africae precede res Asiae in any one olympiad year). 16. 1–8 is also in Suidas. 16. 11–12, from Plut. Mor. 791 F–792 A, is from the same context. In de sent. 14. 1–5 is followed by 17. 1–16 on the state of Greece and Macedonia; it mentions a Roman defeat at the hands of pseudoPhilip (17. 14), which is probably that of P. Iuventius Thalna, who perished in 148 (Livy, Ox. ep., 50). This passage is probably introduced as a digression in res Macedoniae of Ol. 157, 4 = 149/8 (cf. Steigemann, 52–53, against Nissen, Rh. Mus. 1871, 276, who includes it under res Graeciae). 19. BOOK XXXVII This book contained the events of Ol. 158, 1 = 148/7 (see above, p. 44); but no fragments survive from the Constantinian excerpts and almost certainly none from Suidas. xxxvii (like xix and xxvi: see pp. 1 and 22 above) was probably lost by the tenth century. Büttner-Wobst prints one possible fragment on a Museum in Macedonia, from Steph. Byz. (1); but the number of the book could be wrong. xxxviii. 19 (from Plut. Mor. 200 A) refers to fighting which followed Scipio's construction of a mole across the harbour mouth to furnish a footing on the χῶµα, which lay at the south–east extremity of the city on the sea side. This was in autumn, 147 [46]
(cf. App. Lib. 121–5, 126 χειµῶνος . . . ἀρχοµένου) and could have been described by P. in book xxxvii (Zon. ix. 29–30; Kahrstedt, iii. 658 n. 3); but since we do not know where P. broke off his account of the action of 147, and since fgs. 145 (on the fighting on the χῶµα) and 217 (on the bringing up of σαµβῦκαι) seem both to belong to this context, it is perhaps safer to leave xxxviii. 19 and these two fragments in book xxxviii (though this argument involves some risk of circularity in its assumption that there were probably no excerpts from xxxvii in Suidas.) 20. BOOK XXXVIII It is clear from xxxix. 8. 8 and the subscription to it in the manuscript of de sent. (M) that book xl was devoted to a résumé and some kind of contents list (see below, pp. 743–4); and 1. 1 assigns 'the downfall of the Greeks', which must include the events of Ol. 158, 2 = 147/6, to book xxxviii. It follows that the last three years of Ol. 158 were covered in the two books, xxxviii and xxxix, and though the division is not indicated, the amount of material involved would suggest that Ol. 158, 2 = 147/6 occupied xxxviii and the aftermath of the Achaean War xxxix. Whether the Histories included any other events of Ol. 158, 4 = 145/4, and how long P. remained in Rome (xxxix. 8. 1), are both unknown; nor is it clear where P. broke off Ol. 158, 2 = 147/6. Perhaps Mummius' capture of Corinth was in book xxxviii, and the destruction of the city (after the arrival of the ten legati) in xxxix; see below, p. 49. These extracts are from the Constantinian excerpts: de legat. Rom.: 9. 1–8 (Sex. Iulius Caesar sent to Achaea: exc. 34); 10. 1–13. 9 (events in Greece after his arrival: exc. 35); de uirt. et uit.: 7. 1–8. 15 (the Punic general Hasdrubal: exc. 116); 14. 1–2 (Pytheas, son of Cleomnastus: exc. 117); 15. 1–16. 10 (affairs under Diaeus: exc. 118); 17. 1–18. 12 (events at Corinth: exc. 119); de sent.: 1. 1–4. 9 (the ruin of Greece and earlier disasters : exc. 156); 5. 1–6. 7 (P.'s method of composition: exc. 157); 20. 1–11 (meeting with Hasdrubal: exc. 158); 21. 1–3 (Scipio's fears for Rome: exc. 159); 16. 11 (a surprise for someone unnamed: exc. 160); 16. 12 (someone unnamed compared with a man who dives before learning how to swim: exc. 161); 18. 5 (= de uirt. et uit. exc. 119: exc. 162); 18. 12 (the same: exc. 163). 1. 1–4. 9 (de sent.) appears to form part of an introductory section on the nature of the Achaean War (though book xxxviii does not open an olympiad), and it is followed in that collection by 5. 1–6. 7, a digression on P.'s method of composition, which involves breaking off his account of events in one area to pass to those of another (5. 2). This passage, which is in fact a description of P.'s normal practice (cf. 6. 3), of which the Third Punic War is merely an example (5. 2 λόγου χάριν), misled Büttner-Wobst into assuming that in this [47]
book there were two separate sections on Carthage (7. 1–8. 15 and 19 a–22. 3) divided by a section on Achaea (9. 1–18. 12). (Steigemann, 54, equally without good reason, took 5. 2 to be evidence that P. treated the Achaean events in book xxxviii in two separated sections.) In fact, as the placing of the excerpts clearly indicates, the res Africae of this book were dealt with in one block down to the sack of Carthage, which was in 146 (Livy, Ox. ep., 51), before the res Graeciae. In de sent. 5. 1–6. 7 is followed by two passages relating to events towards the end of the assault on Carthage; the first (20. 1–11 in Büttner-Wobst) describes Hasdrubal's surrender, the second (21. 1–3), which follows a long undecipherable passage, a remark of foreboding by Scipio. (The division between these two fragments is not clear and Boissevain and Büttner-Wobst differ slightly in their indication of this.) 7. 1–8. 15 (de uirt. et uit.) on Hasdrubal (a passage from which Suidas quotes at 7. 1–5, 8. 7, and 8. 10) must come before the two passages just mentioned; and they in turn will be followed by 22. 1–3 (= App. Lib. 132). 19 a (from Amm. Marc. xxiv. 2. 14–17) probably concerns an incident in the final stages of the storming of Carthage, and goes between 8. 15 and 20. 1 (see ad loc.). For the likelihood that 19 (= Plut. Mor. 200 A), together with fgs. 145 and 217 (?), belongs to this book (where they will stand before 7. 1 in the order fg. 217 (?), 19, fg. 145) see above, pp. 46–47. Finally, xxxvi. 8. 6 could equally well come in here after 22. 1–3. This order is supported by that of the parallel excerpts from de sent. in Diod. xxxii. 22–24, which treat successively Hasdrubal's conversation with Gulussa (cf. 7. 1–8. 15), his suppliant role before Scipio (cf. 20), and Scipio's reaction to the fall of Carthage (cf. 21). The Achaean events which follow are described more fully in Paus. vii. 14 ff., which serves as a check on the order. 9. 1–8 (de legat. Rom.) describes the return to Rome of L. Aurelius Orestes, sent as legatus in 147 (cf. Livy, Ox. ep., 51), and the dispatch of Sex. Iulius Caesar to Achaea (the passage is specifically attributed to book xxxviii). 10. 1–13. 9, from the same collection, describes the reception of Caesar, and subsequent events through winter 147/6 into 146; this is confirmed by Paus. vii. 14. 3–4, recording the sending of Thearidas to Rome (cf. 10. 11), and Critolaus' election as general for 147/6 in autumn 147. 14. 1–2 (which follows 8. 15 in the excerpts de uirt. et uit.) is about the Pytheas whom Paus. vii. 14. 6 mentions as Boeotarch. Niese (iii. 346 n. 2) assumes a lapse of time between 11 and 12, and suggests inserting 14. 1–2 here; but Pausanias mentions Pytheas after the meeting at Corinth (Paus. vii. 14. 5), described by P. in 12–13, and 14 should probably stay where it is. 14. 3 (= Oros. v. 3. 3) mentions the one battle, with Critolaus in command; it stands correctly here (cf. Paus. vii. 15. 3–4). 15. 1–16. 10, which [48]
follows 14. 2 in de uirt. et uit., gives a hostile account of Diaeus, who succeeded Critolaus as general for the remainder of 147/6. 16. 11 and 16. 12 follow 20. 1–21. 3 in de sent., where (BüttnerWobst reports) 16. 12 is followed continuo by the sentence beginning οὐδὲ γὰρ ἐπὶ τοῦ σκάµµατος, which is 18. 5 in the excerpt 17. 1–18. 12 included in de uirt. et uit., the difference being that there \ὁ προειρηµένος stands where exc. 162 in de sent. has ὁ ∆ίαιος ὁ στρατηγὸς τῶν Ἀχαιῶν. As a result, since Mai it has been assumed that 16. 12 (and 16. 11) refer to Diaeus. In fact 16. 12 and 18. 5 are from quite different contexts, and the fact that M runs them together merely indicates that the copyist may have thought both concerned Diaeus. Against the assumption that they did is (a) the absence of any occasion between the defeats in central Greece and the events described in 17. 1–18. 12 when Diaeus could have been surprised by the enemy and have considered making for home; (b) the unlikelihood of P.'s having levelled these criticisms against Diaeus in connection with the defeat at Chaeronea (cf. 14. 3 n.), when he can hardly have been surprised, and when Critolaus was the responsible general. Niese (iii. 347 n. 3) suggested that 16. 11–12 probably referred to Critolaus, and this has been cogently developed by Deininger (Phil., 1969, 287–91). If they are right, 16. 11 and 16. 12 will go between 14. 2 and 14. 3. As we have seen, 17. 1–18. 12 describes Diaeus' atrocities at Corinth; 18. 5 and 18. 12 also figure (after 16. 12) in the de sent. (see above, p. 47), so linking the two sets of excerpts. On the probable division between the Achaean events in books xxxviii and xxxix see p. 47. On xxxix. 1, which may belong to this book, see below, this page. 21. BOOK XXXIX These extracts are from the Constantinian excerpts: de uirt. et uit.: 1. 1–12 (on A. Postumius: exc. 120); 3. 4–11 (P.'s comments on Achaeus, Philopoemen, and Aratus: exc. 121); 4. 1–5. 6 (P. and the ten commissioners: exc. 122); 6. 1–5 (character of the Roman general: exc. 123); 7. 1–7 (obituary on Ptolemy Philometor: exc. 124); de sent.: 3. 1 (Philopoemen's statues left standing: exc. 164); 3. 2 (a proverb: exc. 165); 8. 1–8 (conclusion to the Histories: exc. 166). As already indicated (p. 47) P. probably ended book xxxviii with the capture of Corinth, leaving its destruction, which was carried out after consultation with the ten commissioners (cf. 2 n.), till book xxxix. 1. 1–12 (de uirt. et uit. and Suidas) discusses A. Postumius Albinus, who had been present at Scarpheia and was designated one of the ten commissioners. Its position after xxxviii. 18. 12 precludes [49]
its having been introduced in connection with the battle; but Postumius' later movements are obscure, and it is not known whether he returned in the meantime to Rome. Since P. did not name the commissioners (Cic. ad Att. xiii. 30. 2) the sketch is unlikely to have been introduced in that connection; and it must remain open whether 1. 1–12 belongs to book xxxviii or book xxxix. 2. 1–3 (from Strabo, viii. 6. 23, C. 381) quotes P. for the way works of art were treated by soldiers after the destruction of Corinth on the Senate's orders; the passage is probably from res Graeciae of Ol. 158, 3 = 146/5 (on the chronology of the capture and destruction see below, ad loc.). 3. 1 (de sent.), 3. 3 (Plut. Philop. 21. 5–6), and 3. 4–11 (de uirt. et uit.) concern Philopoemen's statues and are properly placed here. 3. 2, from de sent., is from somewhere between 3. 1 and the end of the book (cf. 8. 1–8); and if it refers to the thwarting of the 'certain Roman' mentioned in 3. 3, as is not unlikely, it will stand after 3. 3. 4. 1–5. 6 follows 3. 4–11 in de uirt. et uit. and mentions the return of the commissioners to Italy in spring 145; it is followed by 6. 1–5 on Mummius' tour round Greece. Both excerpts are rightly placed. The next excerpt in de uirt. et uit. is 7. 1–7, the obituary on Ptolemy VI, and this forms part of res Aegypti of Ol. 158, 3 = 146/5. The exact date of Ptolemy VI's death is not known, but the latest dating by him is 15 July 145 (cf. Skeat, 34 and below, 7. 1 n.). Schweighaeuser, ad loc., suggested that xxxiv. 14, belongs here; against this see the introduction to book xxxiv, below p. 568. 8. 1–8, which follows 3. 2 in the excerpts de sent., clearly comes at the very end of book xxxix. 8. 1 mentions P.'s journey to Rome, following the settlement of Greek affairs, but the chronology of this is uncertain. If it began late in 145 and covered winter 145/4, thus falling in Ol. 158, 4, it does not follow that P. discussed other events of that olympiad year. The visit to Rome may well have formed as it were an adjunct to the settlement, and a fitting conclusion to the Histories. 22. BOOK XL No fragments survive from this book; on its character see xxxix. 8. 8 n. [50]
TABLE OF FRAGMENTS: BOOKS VII-XXXIX VII
01. 141, I
216/5
Res Italiae Res Siciliae {two years}
I. I-3 1.4 2-5 6
]-8 Res Graeciae
9
fg. ro {see ad loc.) IO. 2-5 ro. r (or after 12 ?) II
VIII
01. 141, 2 = 215/4
Res Hispaniae Res Graeciae Res Asiae
01. 141, 3
Res Ualiae
214/3
Res Siciliae
Res Graedae
01. 141, 4
IX
Ol. J42, I
213/2
212/1
Res Asiae Res JtaJiae
12 13-14 I4 c (?) qd 15-!8 JB b I {?) 38 b 2 ( ?) 35-36 33. l-2 viL 14 b
iii. 19. 11} a 8-11 12 13-14 r4 b (or perhaps in 213j2) 15-21 24. I 24· 2 24. 3 24. 4-34· 13
Res Siciliae
37·
I
Res Asiae
37· 37· 37· 22. 22. 23
2-II 12 13 I-2 3
Prologue {11'po.!x:8E<:ns)
I-2
Res Jtaliae
3· I-9. 10 9· 1oa 9· II
5I
TABLE OF FRAGMENTS IX
01. 142, I
212/I
Res Siciliae Res Hispaniae
IO viii. 38
01. 142, 2
2I I/O
Res Italiae
a ( ?) 12-20 (or in Ol. 142, I: see Vol. II, p. Io) 21 ( ?) 22--26 26 a I-27. 9 27. ro(I) (or before 26 a 1) 27· 10(2) 27. I I 40·4 40. 5-6 45· l-2 45· 3(2) Phorounna 45· 3(1) Xynia 28-39 fO. I fO. 2-3 fl. 2-42·4 f2. s-8 (or before fl. z) 43 44· I 44· 2
II
Res Siciliae
Res Graeciae
Res Asiae Uncertain X
OJ. If2, 3
=
2I0/09
Res Italiae Res Hispaniae Res Graeciae
Res Asiae
01. I42, 4 = 209/8
Res Italiac Res Hispaniae Res Graeciae Res Asiae
XI
01. 143, I
=
208/7
I
2. I-20. 8 23-24 2_'i. I-5 26. l-6 26. 7-10 27. I-I3 3!. 15 28. 1-3I. 13 31. l4 32. I-33· 7 33· 8 34· 1-40. 12 41-47 xi. 7· 1 48 49
Prologue (17poiKll
I a
Res Italiae
I, I fg. 40 ( ?) 1.2-3. 6 3· 7 (uncertain: see Vol. II, p. 16) 4· I-6. IO 7· 2-3 7 • 4 } (or before 7· 2-3) 7· 5
Res Graeciae
52
II
TABLE OF FRAGMENTS
01. 143. 2 = 207/6
Res ltaliae Res Hispaniae
8. I-3 8. 4--6 8. 7 g. I-I8. IO xg a 1-3 (uncertain: see Vol. II, p. 17) 1g 20. 1-24. g 24 a 1-3 24 a 4 24· 10 24. I I 25-30
Res Asiae
XII
JI-33 34 I. l-5 2 3 4 a 1-4 d 8 5· I--6. 6 6. 7-8 6a-6 b (perhaps before 6. 7-8) 7· I-II. 7 II. 8 12. 1-3 12. 4-5 IZ.
f:t-7
12 a} (perhaps after I5 12 b or x6) 13-15 I6 17-22 (or after 23 or 25) 23 24 25. 1-5 25· 6-9 25 a 1-5 25 b 1-25 f 7 25 g 1-4 25 h I-26 a.4 26 b I-28 a IO
XIII
01. 143· 3
=
206/5
Res Italiae Res Graeciae Res Asiae
01. 143· 4
205/4
Res Graeciae
fg. r8o (?: see ad loc.) I. 1-3 1 a 1-3 2. I-5 g. I 9· 2-3 9· 4
9·5 3· 1-48 5· 2 5· I
53
TABLE OF FRAGMENTS XIII
OL 143, 4 = 205/4
Res Gyaeciae
Uncertain
XIV
XV
OJ. I4f, I = 204/3
01. I4f, 2
=
203/2
01. I4f, 3
=
202/I
6. I-7· II 8. I-7 (All these passages could equally well be in the Yes Gmeciae of 01. I43, 3: see Vol. II, pp. 2o22.) IO. I-II is a list of cities in Italy, Crete, Thrace, and Illyria, which could be in either 01. I43. 3 or 01. 143, 4: see Vol. II, pp. 422-3
Prologue ('trpobdha•>)
I a
Res Ajyicae Res Aegypti
I. I-10. II II. I II. 2-5 I2 (could precede II. I)
Res Ajricae I . I-16. 6 (rather than a I7. l-2 combination of 17. 3-19. 9 Yes I tatiae el A jricae, as Vol. II, p. 22 states, following ButtnerWobst) Res Graeciae 20
Res Asiae
21. I-2 21. 3-23. IO 24. I 24- 2 24- 3 24·4-6 25. 3-IO 25. I-2 25. ll-I9 24 a 26 a I-2 25. 2G-37 26. I-36. II 37
Res M acedoniae
2-9
Res Aegypti
XVI
5· 3 5· 4-6 (could precede 5· 2) 5· 7
10. I IO. 2-4 II
I2
54
TABLE OF FRAGMENTS Res GraeGiae
13 14· I-20. 9
Res Aegypti
21. I-22. IO
zz. Res Asiae
I l
22 a (as in book xv, res
Asiae follow Aegypti) 01. Iff, 4
201/0
Res Italiae Res M aGedoniae et GraeGiae
res
23 24. I-8 24- 9 25-26
27 28 29. I
29· 29. 35· 36· 38
XVII
OJ. 145,
2 3-34· 12 I-2
l-37· 7
Res Asiae
39· I 39· 2 39· 3-5
Uncertain
40. I-7 (na.mes from Steph. Byz. of which 40. 4 a.nd 40. 7 ma.y be from res Italiae: see Vol. II, p. 26)
No fragments
I-2 =
200/199 a.nd rgg/8
XVIII
01. 145, 3 = IgS/7
Res MaGedoniae et GraeGiae
1-12
13-15
I6 17. 1-5 17. 6
r8-33 34-39 40. 5
Res Asiae
a
I
41 a
2
4l
41. 1-IO
01. 145, 4
=
197/6
Res Italiae Res Graeciae
42 43· l-IZ 43· 13
40. 1-4
XIX
01. 01. 01. 01.
146, I l<J.6, z 146, 3 146, 4
= = = =-
196/5 195/4 194/3 I9J/2
Res Asiae
44-48 49· I 49· z-sz. 5
Res Aegypti
53-55
Res Hispaniae Res Graeciae
2
1
} No fragments
55
TABLE OF FRAGMENTS XX
01. 147• I = I92/I
Res Graeciae 2 3· I-7·5 8. 1-5 12. I-7 ( ?) 8. 6 fg. 82 ( ?) g. I-II. 10 II. II
I I. 12 xxi. I. 1-4 I2. 8 ( ?)
XXI
I9I/O
01. 147· 2
Res ltaliae Res Graeciae Res Asiae
I-6 3- 1-4 3 b l-2 4• 1-5. I3 6. I 6. 7 fg. 142 (?) 7• I-4 6. z-6 ( ?) 7· s-7 fg. I54 8. I-3 fg. 228 ( ?) IO. 1-14 g. I-3 II. I-!3 2.
12
01. I47. 3
=
rgoj8g
01. 147, 4 = r8gf8
Res Italiae Res Gracciae
Res Asiae Res Graeciae Res Asiae
XXII
01. r48, I Ol. I 48, 2
= =
r88/7 !87/6
Res Graeciae
01. q8, 3
=
r86/5
Res Asiae Res Italiae Res 1\faudmliae
56
13. I-rs. r6. 1-17. I8. I-24. 25. I-II z6. I-I9 27. I-6 27. 7-9 28. r-17 29. I-32. 33-39 32 b 32 c 40. I (?) 41. 1-44· 45 46. I-IZ 47
13 12 I7
IS
3
No fragments 3· I-9 4· I-17 5· I-IO 6. I-6 6. 7 18. l-U
TABLE OF FRAGMENTS Res Graeciae Res Aegypti Res Itatiae Res Macecloniae Res Graeciae Res Asiae Res Aegypti XXIII
01. 149,
I
=
184/3
Res Italiae
7· I-10. 15 I6. I-77· 7 II. I-12. IO IJ. 1-14. 12 15. 1-6 20 21 22
1-4 5
Res Graeciae
Res M acedoniae 01. 149, z
=
183/2
Res Italiae Res Ma,;edoni!UI
6 xxii.
19
)the relative order of these two passages is uncertain
7 8 9 ro II
Res Graeciae Res Asiae Uncertain
XXIV
01. 149. 3
01. 149, 4
18zjr
r8r/o
Res Itali.ae Res Graeciae Res 1\facedoniae Res Italiae Res Graeciae
12-18 (xxiv. 7 may belong here) fg. liZ ( ?) Steph. Byz. s.v. ra>.&i>pa• may go in the res 1lfacedoniae of I 84/3 or 183{2: see above, p. r6
2
3 4 (could precede z) 5 6
7 (could follow xxiii. r8: see above, pp. 17-18) 8-ro II-13 Res Asiae XXV
01. 150, 01. 150,
I 2
180/79 Res Asiae Res J.lii acedoniae 179/8
01. 150, 3
178!7
01. 150, 4
I
77/6
Res Italiae Res Asiae Res Italiae Uncertain
I{-15 2. 1-15
3· r-8 3· 9-IO 4· I-IO 5· 1-5 6. 1-6 r. r-2 probably belongs
in xxxiv. 9: see above, pp. 20--21 XXVI
01.
151, I
176/5
Res Asiae
ra I.
01.
151, 2
OL 151, 3 OJ. I5I, 4
175/4 174/3 I7J/2
1-14
} No fragments
57
TABLE OF FRAGMENTS XXVII
01. 15z, 1 = I72/I
01. 15z, z
=
171/o
Res Graeciae et Macedoniae
Res Aegypti Res Graeciae et Macedoniae
I. 1-Z. 12
3· I-5 4· I~6. 4 fg. 234 ( ?) I2. I-3 7· I-II. 7 I3. I-4 14. I-3 (could follow II. 7 in I 72/I : see above,
p. 24) I5.
I-16. 6
Res Asiae
I7
Uncertain
20.
Res Italiae
I. I-<}
19. 1-2
XXVIII
01.
I52,
3
=
170/69
I-3
2. I-8
Res Graeciae et Macedotliae
xxvii. r8. 1-3 3· 1-4. 13 5· I-6 6. 1-7. 15 8. I - I I g. I-8 IO. I-2 II.
3
I I. I-2
Res Asiae (uel Aegypti}
fg. 66 ( ?) I2. I-13. If (Achaea} I4. 1-4 (Crete} IS. 1-3 (Crete} 16. 1-I7. 15 (Rhodes} 21. 1-5 IS 19. 1-7 20. 1-13 22. 1-3
23. XXIX
01.
152,
4
=
x6gf8
Res Italiae
1-5
1-3 1-4 3· I-4· 10 5· I-9. 13 IO. 1-7 I.
2.
Res Graeciae el .Macedaniae
I I. I-6 12. I-2 13. 1-2
fg.
221
14. I-3 14·4 15. I-3 16. I-3 17. I
17. 3 17.4 z8
TABLE OF FRAGMENTS 17- 2
Suida.s s.v. 1Tp<JYr(nrc (?) 19. I-II
Res Asiae
fg. 74 ( ?) 20. 1-4 ZI. I-9 23. 1-24. I6 (Acltaea) 25. I-7 (Acha.ea) Z2. 1-4 26. I-2
XXX
01. 153, I = I68f7
Res Aegypti
27. 1-13
Res ltaliae Res Graeciae
I. 1-5. I6 6. 1-g. 21 (could stand after ro. 6 or even later in these res
Graeciae) IO, I-2
3 4 10. 5
IO.
10.
6 I I. I-6 IO.
Ol. 153.
2
= 167/6
Res Aegypti Res Italiae
Re.s Graeciae Res Asiae
OL I53. 3
=
166/5
01. 153, 4 = 165/4
Res ltaliae Res Graeciae
28 29. I 29. 2-7
Res Italiae
30. 1-31. 32. I-12 x.xxi. I, I
Res Asiae
XXXI
164/3
12. I-3 13. I - I I 14 15 16. I-2 17· I-4 r8. r-19. 17 20. I-7 20. 8-9 21. I-5 22. 1-12 (position uncertain) 23. 1-4 24. 1-2 (could be later; see above, pp. 32-33) 25. I-26. 9 n. 1-4
Res Italiae
I. 2-8 2.
Res Asiae
20
1-14
3· I-5 4· I -4 (Rhodes: could be res Graeciae) 5· 1-5 (Rhodes: could be res Gl'aeciae) 6. 1-5
59
TABLE OF FRAGMENTS XXXI
01. l5·h I = 164/3
01. 154. '2 = 163/2
Res Asiae
Res Italiae Res Asiae
Res Aegypti
XXXII
01. 154· 3
162/1
01. 154. 4
I6I/O
01. 155, I
160/59
Res Ilaliae Res Africae Res Italiae Res GYaeciae (uel Asiae) Res Asiae Res Ttaliae Res Graeciae
Ol. 155, 2 = 159/8 Ol. 155, 3
158/7
Res Italiae Res Asiae Res Ita/iae
6. 6 7· 1-4 8. 1-8 g, 1-4 (could stand between 6. 6 and 7· I) 10. I-IO I L 1-15. 12 I5. 1J (') (if from res Asiae this could stand after I6. r-3: see above, p. 36) 16. 1-2} (could follow 16. 3 ;~. ~) set> ahove, 17. 19. 20. 21. 2'2. 31.
3
1-18. 6 1-4 1-6 r-8 (or under I6I/o) I-30. 4 1-3 (Rhodes)
32. 1-3 33· 1-5 1-7 1-3. 13 14-17 1-2 3 I--{5. 9 7· 1-5 8. 1-7 9· IO. I.
2. 3· 4· 4· 5·
[Res Asiae]
n. , } 12 II. 1-7 1I. 8--9
Res Italiae
13. 1-9 14. 1-2 I6. 1-5
(.t!aim of Cappadocia treated as an extension of
res Italiae) Ol. 155, 4
157/6
Res Asiae XXXIII
OJ. 156,
I
01. 156, 2
156/5
Res Italiae
155/4
Res Asiae Res Italiae
Res Graeciae Res Asiae 6o
1. 1-8 2 (could be in res Graeciae of 158/7: see above, p. 40) 3· 1-2 (or in res Graeciae) xxxii. 15. 1-14 7· 1-4 8. I-3 9· 1-IO. I<j II. 1-7 4· 1-4 5· r
TABLE OF FRAGMENTS 5· 2 a 5- 2-4 6. I--9 I2. I-9 } (e:uct position I3. I-ro uncertain: see above, p. 42) 01. I56, 3
=
154/3
Res Italiae Res Hispaniae Res Graeciae
XXXV
XXXVI
01. 156, 4 = 153/2
Res Italiae Res Asiae Uncertain
OJ. I57, I = I52/I
Res Italiae Res Hispaniae
01. I57, 2
=
15I/o
Res Italiae
01. I57. 3
=
!50/49
Res Italiae Res Ajricae
Res Graeciae
Res Asiae 01. I57. 4
=
I49/8
Res Ajl"icae
Res Graeciae et Macedoniae
XXXVII
01. I58, I = I48/7
Res Macedoniae
14
15- I-2 15- 3-4 X-XXV. I. I-6 16 · l -8 } (Rhodes) I7. I-5 18. 1-14 I9 (or in I54/3) 20 (perhaps after I7. 5) 2I (perhaps in book xxxiv) 2. I-4- I4 5· I 5· 2 fg. 6 ( ?) 6. I-4 (probably this year) I. I-7 2. I-4 fg. 99 ( ?) 3- I-6. 6 6. 7 fg. I92 (very doubtful) 7· 1-2 7· 3-5 8. I 8. 3 8. 2 8. 4-5 8. 6 (or after xxxviii. 22) fg. 67 ( ?) (goes with 8. 6) 8. 7 9- I-IO. 7 II. 1-4 I2. I-5 I3. I-2 I3. 3 (or res Asiae) I4- I-5 I5- I-7 I6. I-IO r6. 11-12 fg. 47 ( ?) 8. 8 (= fg. 232) I7. I-I5
I
(
?)
61
TABLE OF FRAGMENTS XXXVIII OJ. 158,
2
!47/6
Introduction
1-4. 9
I.
5· I-6. 7 Res Africae
fr. 217 (?) 19
fg. 145 7• I-8. 15 19a 20, I-II
21. 1-3 22. I-3
Res Graeciae
9· I-8 IO. I-II. II I2. l-13.
14.
9
I-2
I6. II I6. 12
I4. 3 I5· I-I6. 10 17. I-I8. I2
XXXIX
01.
xss.
3
I46/5
Res Graeciae
r.
2.
3·
I-I2 (perhaps in book xxxviii: see above,
PP· 49-5°) I-3 I
3· 3 3· 2 (?) 3· 4-11
Res Aegypti 145{4
Epilogue
4· I-s. 6 6. 1-5 7· I-7 8. I-8
The foregoing table sets out the fragments of books vii·-xxxix (omitting book xxxiv) in the order defended on pp. 1-50). In the following commentary (as in Vols. I and II) the fragments are discussed in the order in which they a.ppear in Buttner-Wobst. A passage which on this system I believe to be incorrectly placed I have enclosed in square brackets, indicating what I think is its correct position by a cross-reference in angled brackets.
62
BOOK XIX 01. 146 = 196/2: no surviving fragments. See above, p.
I, for the Livian passages derived from P. Btittner-Wobst prints as fragments two passages which mention P.
1. l. noMj3,os p.~v y~ +TJC'L KTA.: Plut. Cato mai. IO. 3· This passage, from res Hispaniae (hardly res Italiae, as Biittner-Wobst) of 01. 146, I = 196/s. is from the Spanish campaign of M. Porcius M.f. Cato. The revolt of the Turdetani (197) spread to north Spain, where the proconsul C. Sempronius Tuditanus was defeated and died of wounds (Livy, xxxiii. 25. 8--9; Oros. iv. 20. ro). Cato was sent out as consul for 195; see Livy, xxxiv. 8. 4-::n. 8; App. Hisp. 39-41 (embroidered); Zon. ix. q. 5~7. Livy (xxxiv. 17. s-u) describes the disarming of the Spaniards and dismantling of city walls after the submission of the Bergistani. But this he relates twice, once before and once after the Turdetanian expedition (Livy, xxxiv. r6. 9-1o, 21, r--6). The later occasion is the more probable; cf. De Sanctis, iv. I. 453 n. I57· The towns to suffer stood near or north of the Ebro; cf. Livy, xxxiv. 17· 5, cis lliberum; App. Ilisp. 42, -rr£pl wlf3wa -rroTaplw; Zon. ix. 17; Frontin. i. r. 1; Polyaen. viii. 17; de uir. ill. 47· 2 puts them in Celtiberia. That they were eVTOS BaLTtoS 7TOTaJLOU must be \\'Tong (though Nissen, KU, 156, prefers it); it is either Plutarch's error (cf. Gelzer, RE, 'Porcius (7)', col. ns; De Sanctis, iv. 1. 454 n. 157)-he also mentions fighting around the Baetis in Mor. 199 c-or that of F.'s source (Fraccaro, Opuscula, i. 199). Cato's achievement is probably exaggerated (some of the sources go back to him), but does not merit complete scepticism. See Addenda. 2. ingens numerus etc.:= Livy, xxxiv. so. s-6, derived from F.'s res Graeciae of 01. 146. 2 = 195/4· The Roman slaves, taken prisoner in the Hannibalic War, were ransomed in response to an appeal made by Flamininus at a meeting of Greek delegations summoned to Corinth in spring 194; cf. Diod. xxviii. 13; Plut. Flam. 13. 4--6. Livy's soo denarii stand for soc drachmae; Plutarch says 'five minae'. See Aymard, PR, 258.
BOOK XX 01. 147, I = 192/1; above, pp. I-J. All surviving fragments (except perhaps 12. 8) are from res Graeciae. The deterioration in relations between Rome and Antiochus since the conference of Lysimachia in 196 (xviii. 49-52) was reeounted in book xix in a narrative in part represented by the Greek sections of Livy, xxxiv-xxxv (see p. I for details). In 192 Flamininus and three colleagues \vere sent to Greece to canvass support (Livy, xxxv. 23. 4-5). They visited Achaea, Athens, and Chalcis, and at Demetrias secured the banishment of the Magnetarch, Eurylochus, who fled to Aetolia (Livy, xxxv. 31. 332. 2). At the spring meeting (192) at Naupactus, in the presence of Antiochus' envoy, Menippus, the Aetolians resolved to summon Antiochus 'to free Greece and arbitrate between themselves and Rome' (Livy, xxxv. 32. I-33· n). They then organized action against Demetrias (which they took), Chalcis (where they failed), and Sparta (where, upon Nabis' being murdered, Philopoemen quickly intervened) ; see Livy, xxxv. J4· I-38. 14. Flamininus, joined by Eumenes, garrisoned Chalcis but held off Demctrias (Livy, xxxv. 39· r-8). See Holleaux, C AH, viii. 199-206 Etudes, v. 386-~6) ; Badian, Studies, 112-39·
Res Graeciae must have opened with a section corresponding to Livy, xxxv. 42. r-5r. ro p. r), covering autumn 192. I and 2 are from that section. 1. TplliKoVT« TW\1 &.1!'oKATjTwv KTA.: Suidas; d. Livy, xxxv. 45· 946. I (Paton is incorrect). In autumn 192 Antiochus crossed to Pteleum with ro,ooo foot, 500 cavalry, and 6 elephants (Livy, x.xxv.
43· 3-D), and was escorted to Demetrias by Eurylochus and other Magnesian leaders. At a meeting at Lamia Phaeneas called for negotiations w·ith Rome, but Thoas' motion to press ahead with war was carried. 'Haec uicit sententia, imperatoremque regem appellandum censuerunt et triginta principes cum quibus, si qua uellet, consultaret delegerunt' (Livy, xxxv. 45· 9). On the apocleti see iv. 5· 9 n.; below, Io. n, ro. 13, xxi. 5· 2. Larsen, GFS, 200, rejects the view of W. Schwahn (Wiett. Stud. I9JO, 141---9; RE, 'l:vJ.L71'oAtTda', col. rno) that they were the highest apxoV'T<<; acting as a committee; see too Touloumakos, 34· auv~ye Tou~: cl'll'oKATjTou~: KTA.: d. Livy, xxxv. 46. r, 'ita dimisso at Lamia] multitudo omnis in suas ciuitates dilapsa est; concilio rex postero die cum apocletis eorum unde bellum ordiretur consultabat.' Livy (xxxv. 46. z-51. 10) goes on to record the failure to 64
EMBASSIES TO ANTIOCHUS
XX. 3· 6
win over Chalcis, hesitation in Boeotia (d. § 2), the alliance of Amynander (through the influence of his brother-in-law, Philip of Megalopolis, a pretender to the Macedonian throne), the Achaean declaration of war on Aetolia and Antiochus, and the first fighting between Roman and Syrian forces, when Menippus wiped out soo H.omans in the precincts of the temple of Apollo at Delium. This led to the Roman war decision (Livy, xxxvi. 1. r~z. 5). 2. 4>LMwwou wpEa~Euaa.vTos: as Reiske saw, 'Philip' is an excerptor's slip for' Antioch us'; cf. Livy, xxxv. so. 5, 'et ab Achaeis quidem cum tristi responso legatio ad regem rediit: Boeoti nihil certi responderunt: cum Antiochus in Boeotiam uenisset, tum quid sibi faciundum esset se deliberaturos esse.' The Boeotians soon afterwards joined Antiochus ; cf. 7. 3~5.
3. 1-7. Embassies to An.tiochus from Epirus and Elis (192/r) 3. 1. 1-.vTL6xou 8u'l.Tpl~ovTos ~v Tfl Xac!,K£8~: following the battle of Delium all Euboea joined Antiochus (Livy, xxxv. 51. 6-ro), who now made Chalcis his headquarters. A comparison with Livy, xxxvi. 5· r-8 (based on P.), shows that both the first sentence and what follows have been abridged by the excerptor of de legat. gent., who has omitted a passage on Epirote policy (d. Xissen, KU, r2-13). XELp.&wos Ka.Ta.pxop.evou: cf. xvi. 24. r n. on this phrase; it indicates roughly the weeks from 20 November to 20 December. wo.pEyevovTo ••• wp~:aJ3EuTo.l: cf. Livy, xxxvi. 5· r, adding {what our text of P. omits) that Antiochus 'ipse sollicitabat ciuitatium animos mitten dis legatis'. Tou Twv 'HwnpwTwv ~6vous: for €8vos, used of the Epirotes, despite the purely geographical connotation of their name, see Insch. Mag. 32 l. 42; Bull. ipig. r967, 335· On the confederacy see Larsen, GFS, 273-81 ; Hammond, Epirus, 648-57 (657-71 for social and economic development). ot wEpt XO.powa.: on Charops see xxvii. rs. 2 n. ol wEpt Ko.AA.laTpa.Tov : unknown ; Li vy, xxxvi. 5. 1, omits the names of both Charops and Callistratus. 4. 8~;8L()at Tov d.wb ·Pwp.a.£wv woA.ep.ov: Livy, xxxvi. 5· 6-7, adds (probably from P.) that the Epirotes hoped to keep their record clean with Home and yet gain Antiochus' goodwill, if he kept away from Epirus, or, should he come, to have grounds for asking Roman pardon for having yielded to force. See Oost, 59-6o (who however seems wrong in regarding these reflections as perhaps Livy's own or due to contamination with another source). 6. wp£aJ3EuTo.s ••• 8La.AEX91Jaop.evous: they appear not to have been sent; nor did the Romans in fact advance through Epirus (d. Larsen, GFS, 417). D
XX. 3· 7
EMBASSIES TO ANTIOCHUS
7. xtX(ous 1T~
4. l-7. 2. Conditions in Boeotia After hearing the Elean and Epirote envoys Antiochus went to Thebes; and Livy, xxxvi. 6. 2, shows that P. gave this accoant of Boeotian decadence (which Livy condenses into one sentence) in order to explain Boeotian hostility towards Rome. M. Feyel (especially 275 ff. and 285 ff.) argues that P. put the onset of this decadence too early and that it began only in 220 and as a result of Philip V's deliberate policy: he encouraged anarchy so as to win Boeotia for Macedon. Cloche, Thebes, 240 ff. accepts Feyel's date of 220, while preferring P.'s analysis of the causes; but Aymard, Rev. hist. 196, 1946, 310-16, demonstrates the fragility of many of Feyel's arguments, especially those pointing to Philip's interference in the internal affairs of Boeotia or indicating 220 as a decisive date. Many of the faults and weaknesses of Boeotian social and economic life are those of contemporary Greece generally (cf. xxxvi. 17· 5 ff.; Feyel, 274-5, admits it). It is true that P.'s account is coloured by Achaean prejudice against Boeotia (cf. Feyel, 3os), though this prejudice probably owes less to the Hoeotian annexation of Megara in 224 (6. 8) than Feyel (127 ff.) thinks. Aymard rightly emphasizes P.'s dislike of any threat to the established social order; Achaeans were not likely to forget the alliance between social revolution and Spartan imperialism. Lehmann, 333-40, defends the accuracy of P.'s account. See also D. Mendels, A. Soc. 1977, 161-5. ~v To"ls A~;uKTPLKots Katpo"ls: during the Theban hegemony under Epaminondas and Pelopidas, after the battle of Leuctra (371); cf. vi. 43· 7· o&K olS' o1rws ••• AJ3au)KptTov: KaTa To avv.=xl> means 'continuously with' something just mentioned, 'without interruption' and so often 'straight away'; hence the most natural translation here is 'in the period that followed (sc. the Theban hegemony) they proceeded to lose gradually .. .' But this hardly f1ts the phrase €xovn:s aTpaT1Jyov Zlf3at6KptTov. Consequently Schweighaeuser (in his note) translated: 'nescio quo pacto continuo insequentibus temporibus utramque imminuerunt praetore Amoeocrito [sic]'. But as Abaeocritus commanded the Boeotian troops in 245 (Schweighaeuser did not know this), KaTCt TC\ avvt=xl> cannot mean 'at once', but must mean
4. 2.
66
CONDITIONS IN BOEOTIA
XX.4.
2
'gradually' over the period following the hegemony; and that is how Athenaeus (x. 418) takes it (in his admittedly compressed rendering): IloAvf3ws . . . >'Jaw ws BotwroL 1.u:y£ar'7v So~av Aaf36vr.:s 1-urfi rli AwKTptKd (d. 4. 2) Karfi JL!t J.rr' EBwx{a,; Kat JL€8a,; Sd8€VTO (cf. 6. s). But in that case
one needs something like 'in the following period the Boeotians proceeded gradually to lose their glory and prosperity; and this was particularly so when Abaeocritus was their leader. From that time (i.e. from his generalship) their reputation was completely reversed and they wiped out even the memory of their former glory.' Abaeocritus' command is the dividing line between two periods indicated by Jv roi:s Jfijs XP6vots and dm~ rovrwv rwv Katpwv; and why this was so is explained in §§ 4-5. It is tempting to insert something like <J.Lr£\tara S') before €xovT€S; but the fault may be due to more considerable compression and so be beyond easy repair. ic\~<noKp~Tov: so Kumanudes for l'lJLatOKptrov (P). Abaeocritus of Thebes, son of Abaeodorus, is known as a naopoeus at Delphi in 273 (Syll. 238, col. ii, no. 8), who was granted Delphic proxenia in the archonship of Ameinias (Syll. 446, where the archon is incorrectly given as Amyntas; see Roussel, BCH, 1923, 41-42; Bourguet, BCH, 1925, 24 n. r; Flaceliere, 449). Flaceliere, loc. cit., dates Ameinias' archonship to 263/2 (?). Plut. Arat. r6. r (following Aratus' 1\femoirs) relates how in his first generalship (245/4; cf. Walbank, A.ratos, 168--9) Aratus arrived too late to help the Boeotians, with the result that 'Aboeocritus (sic) the Boeotarch and ro,ooo men' fell fighting the Aetolians at Chaeronea (d. §§ 4-5). Abaeocritus is called Boeotarch by Plutarch, but general in P. From some date in the third century a federal general commanded Boeotian troops in place of the Boeotarchs, who however still existed (xviii. 43· 3 n.; Livy, xxxiii. 27. 8); cf. 6. 2, xxii. 4· 12 (187/6); Livy, xxxiii. 1. 3, L 7 (r97), xlii. 43· 9 (qr); GDI, r872 (a Delphic manumission-record which mentions a Boeotian strategos, Eureas, in the Delphic archonship of Melission, which Daux, 191, dates to rn/6). Busolt-Swoboda (ii. I4J6n. 2) and Feyel (r98 n. 4) both prefer Plutarch; and Roesch, Thespies, II2-zr, in a not wholly successful analysis of the above-mentioned passages, dismisses GDI, r87z, as an error and concludes that P. and Livy use arpar']yos (praetor) in a general, non-technical sense. Hence, he argues, there is no proof of the existence of a Boeotian federal general in the second century. However, though P.'s text here is none too sure, there is no reason to think that the word rrrpa-r']yrk is not his own; and Larsen, GFS, r8o n. r observes that Abaeocritus is referred to by Plutarch 'so to speak, as a monarchical commander', and that a single federal general may well have been instituted about 250, following the Achaean change to a single general in zss/4 (d. ii. 43· z n.); and the 67
XX. 4·
2
CONDITIONS IN BOEOTIA
fact that Abaeocritus' command represents a critical point in Boeotian decline perhaps favours the view that P. means 'in the strategia of Abaeocritus' rather than 'under the leadership of Abaeocritus'. But the evidence falls short of being decisive. On Boeotarchs see Aymard, Re11. kist. 1946, 308-9; Roesch, Thespies, 103-8.
4. :A.xa.~wv ••• EK1ToAEf1wa6.vrwv: the background of the AetoloBoeotian clash is obscure. Beloch (iv. r. 6r8, 2. 402-3) argued that Boeotia incited Phocis to defect from Aetolia, thus precipitating the Aetolian attack; but Flaceliere, 2oo and z.o7 (d. Feyel, 79-Bo) argues from the Amphictyonic votes that Boeotia resented the recent Aetolian annexation of southern Phocis (Klaffenbach, Klio, 1939, 2oo, argues that all Phocis was now annexed), and after abstaining from Amphictyonic meetings from c. zs6 now made war on the Aetolian confederation. See further xviii. 47· 9 n. f1ETil Ta.uTa. !Ca.TO. To auvEXES E1TOAE ....ouv: 'after which they forthwith made war on the Aetolians'; Ka.Td. To avv€xls goes closely with f.I.€Td -raiha. (so Feyel, 8o n. 2) rather than with JrroA.ip.ovv (when it would mean 'they made continual war'). The date of the Achaean alliance is not knO\m, but it was shortly before the battle of Chaeronea (245). 5. TWv :A.xa.~wv ••• tJ-EAAOvTwv 1Ta.pa.~o119Ef:v: according to Plut. Arat. 16. I, Aratus had been raiding Locris and Calydon, but came with 1o,ooo men too late to help the Boeotians. This would imply a return from Locris, and a quite separate march across the Isthmus (Larsen, GFS, 206 n. I). But P. implies that the Achaeans did not set out, and Plutarch's version may be exaggerated, not least as regards numbers (cf. Feyel, 8o-8r n. 5). ouK £v5E~6. .... Evo~: an implied criticism of Abaeocritus. 6. o\h' aywvos ou5EVOS .......ETa ICO~VOU 86yf10.TOS: perhaps referring to the failure of Boeotia to play a full part in the Hellenic Symmachy (Feyel, I62), and ignoring the large Boeotian contingent at Sellasia (ii. 65. 4). !.£ETa Kowoii ooyfl.a.To;; means 'by common decree' of the Symmachy, not of the Boeotian confederacy: for it is lack of collaboration, not ineffectiveness of the federal organs of government, that P. is criticizing (cf. Feyel, IS n. 1). For o[ •E!J..7JVE> as 'members of the Symmachy' cf. v. Io6. 7 n., vii. II. 8. 5. 1. TU OE K£4>6.1\a.~a. rijs •.• ayvola.s: 'the crowning act of all their individual follies was brought about thus'; cf. xxxix. 8. I for Ta KEr/>aAaLa in this sense, which is preferable to that of Schweighaeuser, 'ut singula ab his imprudenter facta in unum conferam'. Shuck burgh wrongly refers the phrase to what has preceded: 'such were briefly the steps in the degeneracy of Boeotia.' 2. 1rpoaEVE~f1a.v AiTwAots To ;avos: probably with isopoliteia (d. ii. 46. 2 n.; Porter, 58, on Plut. Arat. I6. I). 68
CONDITIONS IN BOEOTIA
XX.5. 7
3. 1TOAEJJ.OV ••• 1Tp0~ aTj!J.'IjTptov: on the war of Achaea and Aetolia against Demetrius II, which broke out in 239/8, see ii. 44· 1 n. 1TO.pa.y£VO!J.EVOU aTJ!J.TJTplou ••• El~ T,V Bo~wT[av: in 237/6, according to Feyel, 83 ff., basing his argument on eighteen Megarian proxeny decrees, three of them mentioning a king Demetrius (IG, vii. 1-14, 3473; BSA, 1912/13,82 ff., nos. i-iii), which had hitherto been attributed to Demetrius I, but which he refers to Demetrius II. If he is right, Demetrius entered Boeotia in 237j6, detaching it from Aetolia, and annexed Megara (Achaean since 243/2: cf. ii. 43· 5 n.); but Feyel's argument that he shortly afterwards handed over Aegosthena to the Boeotians (Feyel, 3o-3J, 1oo-4; cf. Robert, Rev. phil. 1939, 97-122, discussing JG, vii. 188-9) has been refuted by Etienne and Knoepfler, 323 ff., who base their case on a re-examination of the Boeotian archon-list. Both Aegosthena and Pagae became Boeotian along with Megara in 224. Demetrius' route into B0eotia is not recorded. Beloch, iv. I. 631 (following Niese, ii. 2i4) assumed that he came from Chalcis; Larsen (Phoenix, 1965, 122) suggests that his army was shipped from north Euboea direct to a Boeotian or Locrian port; Feyel, 101, thinks he may have forced Thermopylae, coming by land. i11rha€a.v ucj>a~ athou~ ••• MaKESbut: though no longer dominated by Aetolia, they did not make a complete break, since there is evidence for Thebes and Acraephia approaching the Amphictyonic Council to obtain privileges for the Agrionia and Ptoia festivals (Feyel, 12o-1; id., Epig. 14o-7). 5. :A.uKwvSav Ka.i N£wva: the grandfather and father (§ 12) of Brachylles (cf. xviii. I. 2 n.). Neon, a Theban, figures in a list of proxeni and theorodoci at Epidaurus, c. 225 ():IPX· l,P. 1933, 14 l. 30 = SEG, xi. 414). 7. :A.vT£yovo~ ••• tmTpo1TEUua.~ cfltAL1T1TOu: Antigonus Doson succeeded in spring 229 as Philip's guardian, becoming king probably in 228/7 (cf. ii. 44· 2 n., 45· 2 n.). 1rA£wv €1r£ TlVa.~ 1rpn€u~: probably in 227 (§ n n.); on 7Tpdgets see v. 26. In. The manuscript reading is 7Tpos ·ni laxa-ra rijs Bownlas 7Tpos !laf3puvav. Following Valesius and Palmerius Schweighaeuser corrected !la{3puvav to !lapvp.vav, and Buttner-\Vobst printed nls £axanas to avoid hiatus. (On laxana see D. M. Lewis in Finley, Problemes de la terre, 210-12. In Attica it seems often to mean land near the hills or, perhaps, recently cultivated; but here -ra lfaxa-ra has the usual meaning of 'frontier area'.) 7rpos with the accusative should mean 'towards' or 'against'; and the sense is probably 'sailing with a military purpose towards the frontier district of Boeotia against Larymna'. So Schweighaeuser; and it was probably rumour of some hostile action that caused Neon to be in the vicinity (§ 8). Feyel (n7 n. s) rejects this, but makes no suggestion as to 6g
XX. 5· 7
CONDITIONS IN BOEOTIA
what the Trp&.~ns were. Something in Asia (§ u) seems excluded, since P. mentions the hostile action in close relation to Boeotia. However, the repeated Trpo;; is awkward, and Hultsch's reading is tempting: TTMwv . . . 7rp6s ni laxaTa Tfj;; BotwTlas, Trepl A&.pvfLvav TrapaSO~ov yevofLEV'YJ'> ap7TI.vTew;; KTA. The coup (or whatever is meant) would then be directed at the frontier area, but not at Larymna. In any case, the sentence contains an anacoluthon, and there may be some compression by the excerptor. AO.pu1-1-va.v: the most easterly town in eastern Locris. It was Locrian in 273/2 (Flaceliere, 440; cf. GDI, 2593), but shortly afterwards Locris became Boeotian; when, after Chaeronea (4. 2 n.) Locris probably joined the Aetolian Confederacy (Beloch, iv. 2. 432), Larymna remained Boeotian. It consisted of an upper town and a lower port; on the site see Paus. ix. 23. 7. The lower town, again named Larymna, lies on the bay into which the Cephisus flows, through a katavothra from the Copaic Lake. See Geiger, RE, 'Larymna (1)', cols. 88o-1. 1rapa80~ou ••• cltJ-1TWTEWS: Will, i. 334, suggests a connection with the Rhodian earthquake of 227 (v. 88-90 n.). No proof is possible, but an abnormal tide could derive from a seismic disturbance. 8. 1rpoa1TE1TTWKu£a.s +,1-LflS: hence Neon's presence nearby. The rumour indicates strained relations between Boeotia and Macedonia; but Neon's position as hipparch shows that the Macedonian party still had some power (Feyel, II7 ff.). See further, on the relations of Boeotia and Macedon, ii. 49· 6 n. (exaggerating the degree of support for Macedon prior to these events). l1r1rapxwv Ton: as in the fifth- and early fourth-century confederacy (Thuc. iv. 72. 4; Plut. Mor. 578 B) the Boeotian cavalry was commanded by a hipparch, an important federal officer; cf. IG, ix. 1. 270 l. s (but the one mentioned in IG, vii. 3087-8 is probably a local official). See Busolt-Swoboda, ii. 1419 n. 4, 1436-7; Feyel. n8, 197, 204, 277· xapLV TOU 1Tapa+uAnTTEW TTJV xwpa.v: in view of the rumour. This is against Feyel's assumption (2o4) that the federal cavalry was carry-
ing out a routine frontier patrol under the hipparch. 9. 5uvntJ-Evos tJ-EynAa. ~Aci.IJiaL: evidence of strained relations with Macedonia (contra Feyel, u8-r9); hence Neon's decision was Trapd. T~v
7rpoaOoK£av mhwv.
e,~
10. TOLS •••
70
CONDITIONS IN BOEOTIA
XX. 5·
IZ
1940, 143 ff., and Bengtson, S.-B. Munchen, r97I, 3, 22 ff., against Dow and Edson, Harv. Stud. 1937, r68 ff., who would connect the expedition with an Athenian decree of 226 honouring Prytanis of who had gone as ambassador to Doson). Its purpose is obscure. It used to be regarded as an anti-Ptolemaic move (Beloch iv. r. 683; 2. 548 ff.; Tarn, CAH, vii. 722, 752); but Caria had recently been an object of contention between Antioch us Hierax and At talus I (v. 74· 4 n.), and Will, i. 334-5 suggests that Doson was acting Attalus and the Seleucids, a view modified by Bengtson lv!iinchen, 1971, 3, 26 ff.), who envisages a compact with I, who was to expand eastward into Phrygia, while Doson subdued Caria, all at the expense of the enfeebled Seleucid realm. Treves (Athen. 1935, 37 f.) even envisaged some collaboration with Ptolemy III. It is unlikely that the battle of Andros (d. v. 34· 7 n.; Will, i. belongs to this campaign, and there is no evidence that Doson made any permanent acquisitions in Caria; against the view of W. Otto, RE, 'Hippomedon', cols. 1845 ff., based on an interpretation of Syll. 502 (d. iv. 35· 13 n.), that Doson at this time got possession of Samothrace, see Bengtson, Strat. iii. 179; Fraser, Samothrace, ii. I. But he established relations with Olympichus of Alinda which lasted into the reign of Philip V (cf. v. 90. r n., with addendum, Vol. II, p. 645; xv. 20 n.; Crampa, Labraunda inscriptions). An inscription, lnsch. Priene, 37 11. 136 ff., mentioning Antigonus' arbitration in a dispute with Samos, may link with this expedition, but does not justify Beloch's assertion (iv. 2. 55o) that Priene became Macedonian. This arbitration is not mentioned by G. Kleiner, RE, SuppL-E. ix, 'Priene', col. u88; but the reference to Tov y.d.as tl>t[Am?Tov, and an earlier reference (1. 134) to Tov Aao8iKetov 1T6A
7I
XX. 5·
I2
CONDITIONS IN BOEOTIA
temporary military occupation (Bengtson, Strat. ii. 325 n. 6; Feyel, 131 n. 5). By a slip Strachan-Davidson calls the town Thebes. 13. 1TavTa.s TjvayKa.aa.v f10.KE8ov£tEIV: an exaggeration if, as seems likely (Feyel, I36---63). Boeotia was neutral in the Social War.
6. 1. axE8bv ELKOO"I Kol 1TEVT' ~Twv: in xxii. 4· 2 the same figure, calculated from after the Roman peace with Antioch us, takes one back to c. 212 (Feyel, 274). Here the point of reckoning will be rgzfr, which takes one to c. 217, the end of the Social War. (The pluperfect 1Tapa.yt£yovt£t indicates a time prior to that with which P. is concerned, viz. 01. 147, I = rg2(r, not, despite the ft.Jv • •• 8i, a time prior to that implied in tAa{JE d.pX'fiv.) In general P. links the rise of the house of Neon and the KaX£gta in Boeotia, but the twenty-five years of disorder in the courts cannot be directly related chronologically either to Neon's service to Doson (227) or to Brachylles' appointment at Sparta (222). Feyel, 274, argues that since in the present passage P. is concerned to exaggerate the period of disorder, the calculation of 25 years from 187/6 (xxii. 4· 2) is the more reliable. But having written 'nearly 25 years' here P. may simply have repeated the figure in xxii. 4· 2, just as he describes Philip V as seventeen years old in iv. 24. r (autumn 22o), having said the same in iv. 5· 3 (autumnwinter 221), the earlier passage giving the correct figure (Walbank, Philip, 295). P.'s account of Boeotia may find confirmation in Heracleides Criticus (i. rs-r6 = GGM, i. IOJ), who describes the cessation of activity in the courts for 30 years, and a state of violence and disorder at Thebes (Feyel, 275---6). Unfortunately this satirical treatise cannot be firmly dated; a third-century date is likely (but the 8ou.\£i:a in i. 2 = GGM, i. 98 refers to the condition of ~EI•ot, and not to that of the Athenians before the liberation from Macedonia in 229: Ferguson, 464-7). Certainly, a third-century date of composition would bring forward the onset of judicial anarchy to an earlier date than P. assigns to it; but in any case Heracleides speaks only of Thebes, P. of Boeotia generally. (It may be noted that many attempts to date Heracleides use the conditions described in P. as a point of reference; hence the danger of circular argument; see on this Daebritz, RE, 'Herakleides (46)', coL 486; F. Pfister, S.-B. Wien, 227(2), 1952, 44 f.) The conditions described by P. are generally applicable to central Greece, and not peculiar to Boeotia (cf. Feyel, 276-7, quoting evidence for debt and court delays in Aetolia, Thessaly, and Delphi; see below, xxii. 4· 2 n. ; Rostovtzeff, SEHHW, ii. 6ro ff., iii. 146o-r). But the years following r8o seem to have been a time of economic crisis in Boeotia; for evidence of com shortage see Roesch, Rev. phil. 1¢5, 256-61; Etienne and Knoepfler, 209 n. 705, 244 n. 9o8 (bringing down the date somewhat}. See also D. Hennig, Chiron, 1977, 119-48.
72
CONDITIONS IN BOEOTIA
XX.6. 7
lSwnKWV O"UJLf3oXa.lwv ••• KOWWV eyKA'I}JLO.T!alV: 'private contracts ... public suits'; the phrases cover civil and criminal justice. 2. cf:.poupAs 1Ta.pa.yyiXXoVT~S ••• o-rpo.Tctla.s Kowas: P. implies that these guard duties and federal campaigns were a sham, put on to prevent the operation of the courts. If true, this would lead to a decline in army morale (Fcyel, 277-9). lvc.ot 5e Twv aTpO.TT)ywv ••• JLW9o5oa£o.s : on Boeotian cnpa7'1J'Yol see above 4· 2 n.; Feyel, z66 n. 2, argues that cnpaTTJYO{ here means magistrates in general, but this is unlikely: p.w0o8oa{a. is commonly used of soldiers' pay (d. L 69. 3), and this p.ta06s may represent wages for service during the mobilizations (which could indeed have been made with this end in mind). It is not entirely certain that the payments TOLS" d-rrdpo'S· T6JV avOpdnrwv were for military service; indeed they are often treated as pure donatives (d. Rostovtzeff, .'-iEHHW, ii. 612, 'a regular salary to all poor out of public funds'; Feyel, 279; Tarn, HC, no, 'Opheltas ... helped the poor out of state funds'), but p.taBos is usually payment for service. 4. 1TA~L'aTa. ••• 1Tpos Tt)v TOLO.VT'I}V ••• 'Ocf:.eXTo.s: some such word as Ka.Ta!J'Taaw has fallen out after Tota.~v. Opheltas is unknown; but the Opheltiadae are known at Chaeronca (Plut. Mor. 558 A). 15. ctts ~owxlo.s Ko.l. JLE9o.s 5t~Tt9EvTo: cf. 4· 7 ; 'they employed it in feasting and drinking' i.e. while still alive, not by endowing such festivities after their death (a point missed by Schweighaeuser and Paton (Loeb ed.): cf. Feyel, I7 n. 1). 6. nm;:JL[pttov TOLS O"liO"O"LTtolS TO 1TA£LOV JLEpos: contrast Achaea, where Philopoemen persuaded his fellow citizens to reform, when they were mipt OEVrrva. ,PtAoTtp.ovp.~vwv Ka.l Tpa.rrl~a.s (Plut. Philop. 9· 6-8; Feyel, 281 n. 4). Against the argument of Passerini (Stud. it. 1934, 52) that P. is here echoing a moralist's commtmis locus with little factual basis, see Rostovtzeff, SEHHW, iii. 1461 n. 14. 7. MEya.pEI:s ••• a.ons ci.1Tevctuao.v 1rpos To(Js :A.xa.wus: for relations between Megara and Achaea down to 237/6 seeS· 3 n. On Demetrius' death the Achaeans recovered Megara, and some time between 228 and 227/6 made alliances with Boeotia and Phocis, which deposited hostages (Syll. 519; ii. 49· 6 n.). In 224, with Cleomenes at the Isthmus, Megara joined the Boeotian Confederation, probably under pressure from Antigonus Doson, who wanted to conciliate Boeotia (d. Feyel, 127, 134; above, ii. 52. 7 n.); fi-ETil Tfjs Twv 11xa.twv yvwp.7Js (§ 8) need not imply Achaean enthusiasm, but does show the Confederation countenancing a secession which would normally have been tantamount to a revolt (cf. Swoboda, Klio, 1912, 20 n. 7). Megara. returned to Achaea in a stratcgia of Philopoemen (Plut. Philop. I2. 3 f.; Paus. viii. so. sl- In view of§ g, {Jpa.xv .•. rrpo 'TWl' vilv >.«yop.b<wv KaLpwv, this has been taken to be that of 193(2 (Beloch, iv. 2. 434; Feyel, 62 n. I; Lehmann, 334 n. 6). Niese, ii. 567 n. 2, argued
73
XX. 6. 7
BOEOTIANS WELCOME ANTIOCHliS
for 2orjo. But the most likely date is that indicated by the order of events in Plutarch, 2o6/5 (Aymard, PR, 14 n. 7; Walbank, Philip, r6s; Errington, 77 n. r). For further bibliography see Robert, Rev. phil. 1939, us n. 4 ( = 01'.15, ii. 1268 n. 4); Robert (ibid. 97-122 = OMS, ii. 125~-75) shows that Aegosthena continued to be Boeotian after Megara rejoined Achaea. 10. ot S€ Bous~Toi. ••• i~ijA9ov t'll'i. Tous Mqap£is: probably in 206/5 (see previous note); cf. Plut. Philop. 12. 3; Paus. viii. so. 5· 12, a'II'O~\L'II'()VT€5 , , , TaS K~.f~aKaS; SO lOW Was their morale.
7. 2. W0'11'€p E'II'LTTJSes avTa'!I'6Soaw"' TUXT) 'II'OLOuf!lv"l: d. xi. s. 8 for the phraseology; Vol. I, p. 20 for Tyche punishing wrong-doing. l:mtp ~v ••• 'II'OLT)0'0~£9a ~v~~T)V: see xxii. 4 ft. for trouble in Boeotia following the war with Antiochus. 7. 3-5. The Boeotians welcome Antiochus This passage, from the excerpts de uirt. et uit., corresponds to Livy, xxxvi. 6. 1-2, which immediately follows the passage corresponding to 3· 1-7, Livy having passed over P.'s digression on Boeotian decadence (4. 1-7. r). T~v t'll'ava1p£aw T~v BpaxuXXou: winter 197/6; d. xviii. 48. r2 n. T~v aTpan1av ••• t'll'i. Kopwv£Lav SLlL Tous ••• "'ovous: for the out-
7. 3.
burst of murders of Romans in Boeotia, the collective fine of soo talents imposed by Flamininus, and the punitive attacks on Acraephia (under Ap. Claudius) and Coronea (under Flamininus) see Livy, xxxiii. 29. 1-9. Many bodies were found in the Copaic Lake, and the total of dead was reported to be soo. 4. SdL Tas 'll'poupT)~~vas ah1as: Livy, xxxvi. 6. 2, having passed over these, has to summarize: 're uera per multa iam saecula [sic] publice priuatimque labante egregia quondam disciplina gentis et multorum eo statu, qui diuturnus esse sine mutatione rerum non posset'. 5. OL TWV BoLWTWV ap~aVTES: 'the Boeotian magistrates' will include Boeotarchs, hipparch, and strategos (on whom see 4· 2 n.). But Valesius interpreted Livy's paraphrase (Livy, xxxvi. 6. 3, 'obuiam effusis undique Boeotiae principibus The bas uenit') as evidence that he took ap~aVTES to mean 'those WhO had held office', hence 'leading citizens'. Paton also renders 'those who had held office' ; and the rareness of the perfect makes this use of the aorist participle conceivable, though not compelling. ~yov ••• ets Tas 01\~as: here Antioch us secured a Boeotian declaration of war on Rome before returning to Chalcis (Livy, xxxvi. 6. 3-5). At a council held shortly afterwards at Demetrias, it was midwinter (Livy, xxxvi. 6. 9), about December-January 192/r.
74
ANTIOCHUS' MARRIAGE
XX. 8.
I
8. l-5. Antiochus' marriage at Chalcis At Antiochus' council at Demetrias (7. 5 n.) Hannibal advocated winning over or else attacking Philip V, and urged a more active policy against Rome (Livy, x..xxvi. 7· 1-21); but this was rejected, and Philip soon made an agreement with M. Baebius, who had crossed wi.th perhaps 2ooo men to Apollonia (Livy, xxxvi. ro. ro; Walbank, Philip, 199~2or). Antiochus, helped by Amynander and the Aetolians, now advanced successfully into Thessaly (Livy, xxxvi. 9· r~ro. 6) but withdrew from Lamia to Demetrias on learning of Ap. Claudius' arrival (Livy, xxxvi. ro. 6-14). Despite Livy, xxxvi. 10. 12, hiemem instare, it was now probably the end of January; and Antiochus will have spent February and March 191 at Chalcis (Walbank, Philip, 201-2, 32R-""9). On Antiochus' wedding at Chalcis see also Livy, xxxvi. u. r-2 (cf. rs. I, I7· 7); Diod. xxix. 2; App. Syr. r6; Plut. Philop. I/. l; Flam. r6. r (d. Robert, Hellenica, 7, 1949, 25 n. r). Livy and Diodorus follow P., Diodorus in some respects giving a truer version of P. than the passage from Athenaeus (x. 429) printed as a fragment (d. Schmitt, Antiochos, 6 n. 2). Antiochus had previously married Laodice, a daughter of Mithridates II of Pontus (iv. 48. 5 n., v. 43· r-4, viii. 20. u n.), who bore him three sons and either four or five daughters (Schmitt, Antiochos, r3 ff.); for a summary of the evidence concerning this forceful princess see Robert, Bull. epig. r97I, no. 6:.n. A royal prostagma dating to Xandikos of year II9 s.E. March/ April 193, found at Nehavend in Media (cf. Robert, Hellenica, 7, 1949, 5-22; iv. 2. 7 n.) shows Laodice alive barely two years before the marriage at Chalcis, and, stranger still, an inscription from Susa, dating from year IJ6 S.E. = rn/6 (d. Robert, Ret'. phil. I9J6, 137-52, esp. 149 f. ONES, ii. IZr6-3r, esp. 1228 f.; Hellenica, 7, 1949, 28; rr-12, 196o, 86 n. 2; Schmitt, Antiochas, n-12) indicates that she outlived Antiochus. A:ymard (Etudes, 212-29) suggested that Laodicc was repudiated for some unknown reason in 193, but restored to favour sometime after early 190, when her son, the later Seleucus IV, who was in temporary eclipse between autumn 192 and early 190, again appears holding commands, until in r88 he is associated with his father on the throne (Aymard, Etudes, 221 n. 3 for the evidence). Laodice's repudiation seems likely (for no other bigamous marriage is attested in the Selcucid dynasty), but there is no evidence that she was rehabilitated before her son's succession (J. and t. Robert, Bull. epig. 1951, no. 234). 8.1. o f.I-EYGS E1nKGAouf.1-tt"os: on this title cf. iv. 2. 7 n. and Vol. II, pp. 638-9; add :P. Herrmann, A nadolu (A natalia), 9, 1965 (1967), 37, fg. D 11. n, 30 (an inscription from Teos dating to after 204/3);
75
XX.8.
I
ANTIOCHUS' MARRIAGE
Pugliese Carratelli, Annuario, 45--46, 1967-8 (1969), 445-53, no. 2 I and II (an inscription from Iasus dating c. 190: cf. J. and L. Robert, Bull ipig. 1971, no. 621, who suggest that the second of these may be part of OGI.$, 237). Here, however, the words J1.v-rloxor; ... lv Tfj £lKoa'Tfi may be those of A thenaeus. 11'EVT~KoVTa. iJ.Ev ~T'I') yeyovws : this would make his birth 242 or 241 (iv. 2. 7 n.); but Schmitt (Antiochos, 4-5) argues convincingly that since both Diodorus (xxix. z) and Appian (Syr. 16) make him over fifty years, the qualifying word is likely to have been omitted by Athenaeus. P. is the source of Diodorus and probably of Appian (cf. Gabba, Rend. Line. ser. 8, 12, 1957, 339-51), and their version would allow for Antiochus' birth in 243 or 242. ooo Tn j.LEyu,.Ta. ••• &cve..AfJ+ws: d. Livy, xxxvi. n. 2, 'quantas simul duas res suscepisset, bellum Romanum et Graeciam liberandam'; Diodorus and Appian omit the liberation of Greece. TTJV ••• ~Aeu6€pwow: cf. iii. 7. 3, TTporf>aatv S' ~yrrr.Eov 'T~v 7wv 'EJJ,.-r}l•wv €1\.wOepwaw; see note ad loc.; PCdech, Methode, 174 n. 377· To the Aetolians the Roman liberation had merely been a ,_u:Odpp.oat> SwTToTwv (xviii. 45· 6). 2. ipa.a&l.s ••• 1J'a.p6evou Xa.AK~OlKTl!l: ct. Diod. xxix . .2, TTapO€vov .•• £i'mpeTTovr; £paaflds; App. Syr. 16, €v8a Kbprw ErmpeTToi'i,; lpom &Aovs. Ei'mpm-?>, used (of boys) in xxxi. 25. sa, may have stood in P.'s text. olvo1I'OT1'JS i:lv Ka.t j4£9a.,s xa.(pwv: cf. Li vy, xxxvi. 11. 2, 'in conuiuiis et uinum sequentibus uoluptatibus'. This picture of a winter spent in debauchery is clearly false (Antiochus was only a short time in winter quarters: 7. 5 n.) and may be modelled on the legend of Hannibal's fatal stay in Capua; see especially Diod. xxix. 2. Anti-Seleudd propaganda is to be detected (d. Will, ii. 174). 3. KAeo11"TOAEj.l-OU ••• 9uy6.T'I')p: cf. Livy, xxxvi. II. 1; he is unknown. 4. ;e£To 8e ... ovoj.la. Eu~olnv: cf. App. Syr. zo (below,§ 5 n.). Tam, Fergttson Stttdies, 499 n. 3, compares Philip II, who, he suggests, called his wife Olympias to celebrate the coincidence of his Olympian victory and Alexander's birth (Plut. Alex. 3· 5). As a girl Olympias is said to have been called Myrtale, Polyxene, and Stratonice (Plut. ~1or. 401 A; Justin. ix. 7. 13) ; but the three names are suspicious, and Philip is not said to have renamed her. So Antiochus' action is not clearly paralleled: its political significance (and perhaps that of the marriage itself) is plain. 5. TJTT1'j6ei.; ••• ;+uyev els "Ecflnrov: cf. App. Syr. 20, dm] If 'EA.ania,; ls XiJJ\Kloa, Kai ;, "Erf>Eaov p.eT' EvfJola> rijs veoyap.ov (Toih-o yd.p at'n-~v dw&p.a~Ev) £TTl Twv vel~v lrpwyEv. A thenaeus has probably compressed the text to include Antiochus' flight after Therrnopylae.
(12. 1-7: this passage, on Philopoemen's rejection of a gift at Sparta, probably belongs here; sec above, p. z.) 76
THE BATTLE OF THERMOPYLAE
XX. g.
I
8. 6. Fragment from the account of the battle of TJwrmopylae (191) Livy, xxxvi. 5· I-JS· n, covering the Greek campaigns including Thermopylae (chs. rs-19), corresponds to P.'s res Graeciae of 01. 147, r 192/r (see above, p. 2); the fact that P. is mentioned here does not justify singling out this sentence from the rest. On Antiochus' forces see 1 n. 9. l-11. 10. Roman negotiations with the Aetolians (r9r) After his defeat at Thermopylae (8. 6) in late April 191 (d. Walbank, Philip, 329-31), Antiochus fled to Chalcis and thence to Ephesus (8. 5 n.; Livy, xxxvi. 19. 9, 21. r). The consul, M'. Acilius Glabrio, now began the siege of Heraclea, while Philip V, who had recently been active along the Pagasaean coast road, taking Alope, Larissa Cremaste, Antron, Pteleum and, perhaps, Halus and Phthiotic Thebes (cf. Walbank, Philip, ~04 n. 6), simultaneously blockaded Lamia, seven miles away. Persistent night and day attacks, ending in a midnight assault, brought about the fall of Heraclea; but Philip made no headway with his mines at Lamia, and had to withdraw (Livy, xxxvi. zz. r-zs. 8; Zon. ix. 19; Phleg. TraiL, FGH, 257 F J6, III. I; Plut. Flam. rs. 3; App. Syr. 2I; below, II. 3 n.).
(fg. 82 may stand here; it concerns Philip's attack on Lamia.)
9. 1.
77
XX. 9.
2
ROMAN NEGOTIATIONS
2. !1\pxeSO.J.I.OV ••• na.vTa.AEOVTQ. ••• XO.Xnrov: on Archedamus see xviii. 21. 5 n.; he was Aetolian general in rgrfo (GDI, 1985-6), rSS/7 (GDI, 2132), 182/1 (GDI, 2036-7, 2047), and I75/4 (GDI, 1795, 1843, rg87); cf. De Sanctis, iv. r. 4oo-z; Klaffenbach, IG, ix 2 • r. p. li. Hostile to Rome (xxviii. 4· 3) he later joined Perseus of Macedon and followed him after his defeat (Li'vy, xliii. 21. g-2z. II, xliv. 43· 6; Plut. Aem. 23. 3). For the possibility that 'Andronicus, Andronici filius, Aetolus', executed by the Romans after Pydna (Livy, xlv. 31. 15) is an error for 'Archedamus' see Pedech, Methode, 267 n. 57; De Sanctis, iv. I. 350 n. 298 has a different hypothesis. Pantaleon is probably grandson of the Pantaleon who arranged the AchaeoAetolian alliance in 239 (ii. 44· r) and son of Archidamus (for Archidamus and the elder Pantaleon see iv. 57· 7 n.); he was general in r86/s (GDI, 1844, 1949), in 18o/79 (cf. Klaffenbach, IG, ixz. r. p. li) and in 174/3 (GDI, r8s6); cf. De Sanctis, iv. r. 402; Treves, RE, 'Pantaleon (6)', cols. 691-2. See xxviii. 4· 8 f. for his opposition to Lyciscus' pro-Roman policy after Perseus' defeat, and Livy, xlii. 15. 8-ro, for his help to Eumenes when the latter was struck by stones at Delphi (his presence beside Eumenes need not imply that he was pro-Roman: so M.eloni, Perseo, r84 n. z). Chalepus (so Bergk for the manuscript x6.A71aav: Livy, xxxvi. 27. z omits the names) was a Locrian from Naupactus; see IG, ix. r. 357; BCH, 1932, 4 I. 73 (expropriated at Delphi}; Lerat, ii. 227 (prosopography). He was general in the year of the Delphic archon Hybrias (GDI, zop, 2II7; BCH, I9JO, 288 n. r), which must be shortly before 198/7 and may be 199/8; Daux, 97-9S, r87; Klaffenbach, IG, ix 2 • L p. I. See xxi. 25. n n. 4. Twv ~K TfJS 'Hpa.KAElO.S Xa.~.)pwv: d. Livy, xxxvi. 24. 7 (of the lower town, which was taken first), 'oppidum uictores permissu consulis diripiunt, non tam ab ira nee ab odio, sed ut miles, coercitus in tot receptis ex potestate hostium urbibus, aliquo tandem loco fructum uictoriae sentiret.' On the division and disposal of booty in the Roman camp see x. 16, 2-17. 5 n. ; Acilius' remark was no doubt intended to irritate the Aetolian envoys. 5. AeuK&ov; L. Valerius Flaccus, cos. 195. According to ro. ro he was military tribune, as was his colleague in the consulship, l\L Porcius Cato (cf. Cic. de sen. 32; Plut. Cat. mai. 12. r); Appian, Syr. r8, gives them both this rank. But Livy (xxxvi. IJ. 1, 19. r, 22. 7, 27. 3-8, 28. 8; cf. Zon. ix. 20; Phleg. Trall., FGII, 257 F 36, III. r) calls him legat1,s. Scullard, Pol. 124 n. 3, suggests that the Livian tradition gave them both this title to glorify Cato; but it is not unprecedented for a military tribune to hold the title of legatus when acting independently (cf. Mommsen, St.-R. ii. 695 n. I; xviii. 8. 6 n.). See Munzer, RE, 'Valerius (173)', cols. 16-2o. 6. els T~Y 'Yrn1Ta.v: the meeting-place of the Aetolian council which 78
WITH THE AETOLIANS (191)
XX. 9.
IO
had sent envoys to Antiochus (9. 1 n.). Hypata, the main town of the Aenianes, stood high above the Spercheius valley, on the slopes of Oeta, about 25 km directly north-west of Heraclea; see Leake, NG, ii. IJ ff.; Stahlin, HeU. Thess. 221-2; Bi:quignon, 308-·IZ, -.vith plan. It is the modern Hypati. 8. E'lTVTEfJ.WV a.u-rwv -rT]v opfJ.tJ": 'cut the flood of their eloquence short' (Paton). 9. TP~'!Tea9a., '!Tpos Tov O.~U»fJ.a.nKov 'i..Oyov: 'to adopt a tone of supplication' (Shuckburgh}; for this sense of &.g~wf.Lartl(o,; d. xxxi. 7· 3, xxxii. 3· r6. Ka.l. oeia9a.~ -roO aTpO.TT)yoO auyyvwfJ.TJS Tuxeiv: xxxvi. 27. 7 adds a sentence: 'et se suppliciter agentibus iis adfuturum et apud consulem et Romae in senatu'. P. has nothing of this and Livy may have added it in the light of ro. 10, where Valerius intercedes with Acilius; an addition from an annalistic source (Dahlhcim, 33-34 n. 23) seem less likely. Piganiol, RIDA, 5, 1950,339-40, thinks Valerius meant to be helpful, inasmuch as a bond existed with the Valerii since the Aetolian treaty made by :\1. Valerius Laevinus in :ZII (Livy, xxvi. 24. 8-14; Vol. II, pp. rr-13); d. Dahlheim, 42 n. 46.
tO. SOnes a.•hous ets ,.,., 'PwfJ.a.lwv 'll'laTw: cf. Livy, xxxvi. 27. 8, 'haec una uia omnibus ad salutem uisa est, ut in fidemse permitterent Romanorum.' As P. explains (§ rz; a fuller definition in xxxvi. 4· r-3} the phrase is merely another way to describe deditio, unconditional surrender (Td T~v imTporr~v Soiiva~ 7T€pt av'roil T(j! KpaToilvn). The examples of the Mamertines (Vol. II, p. 6zg, addendum to i. IO. I-2 n.}, the Illy·rian cities (ii. II. s-12), Saguntum (Vol. II, p. 6JI, addendum to ii. 13. 7 n.; Vol. II, p. 635, addendum to iii. 15. 5 n.; iii. 15. 7, Jo. r), and certain Spanish states (x. 40. z) demonstrate that deditio was not necessarily followed by a disagreeable or dishonourable status; a letter sent by the Scipios to Heraclea by Latmus (Syll. 618 Sherk, 35} shows that in 190 surrender €ls T~v ~f.L€7'Epa[p, 7TWr
XX. 9· IO
ROMA~
NEGOTIATIONS
'at ego recipio.' Before accepting, the Romans might impose conditions: cf. Caesar, BG, ii. 32. r, 'deditionis nullam esse condicionem nisi armis traditis'; Livy, xxix. 3· J, 'in deditionem ita accipi eos, si .Mandonium ceterosque belli concitores tradidissent uiuos'. But, as the present incident shows, the validity of the act of deditio seems not to depend on the readiness of the party surrendering to accept the conditions nor upon the Romans' formal acceptance of the deditio (10. 7). Acceptance, it was hoped, would induce the Romans to treat the dediti generously; cf. Livy, xxxiv. 40. 3-4, where Nabis' envoy hopes to persuade Flami:ninus to accept deditio, but has to be content with a tmce; clearly the former was preferable (Larsen, CP, 1935, 198). But this did not alter the Romans' legal rights: if they treated the dediti well, it was because of the moral obligations of fides, not through any legal claim that deditio conferred on the persons surrendering (cf. Piganiol, RI DA, 5, 1950, 339-4i; Badian, 5-6). The harsh treatment of the Aumnci (above), Acilius' action towards the Aetolians (ro. 7-ro), and the treatment of Carthage in 146 (xxxvi. 3· r ff.) represented no breach of any treaty or compact, since, as Reuss (Volk. Grund. 6o ff.) has demonstrated, deditio involved none (cf. xxxvi. 9· rz-q). Attempts have been made, in view of a confused terminology in some sources (e.g. Livy, xxxix. 54· 7, quoted below; Val. Max. vi. 5· r), to draw a distinction between deditio in dicionem and deditio in fidem; against this see Dahlheim, 29-30. Similarly Calderone, 33 f., distinguishes between deditio and receptio in fidem, so that the party on:enng deditio had to fulfil certain conditions, but having once been receptus in fidem he became entitled to the benefits implied in this moral concept; where dediti are reported to have been harshly treated, they will not have been recepti in fidem. This will not do since (a) it runs directly counter to what P. says, (b) there is no example of a people's having made deditio and then having been specifically non recepti in fidem and treated severely. True, Latin sources recording the harsh treatment of dediti tend, not unnaturally, to avoid reference to fides; and dediti, for their own advantage, would try either deliberately or, like the Aetolians, through confusion, to draw distinctions; cf. Livy, xxxix. 54· 7, where Gauls argue 'dedisse se prius in fidem quam in potestatem populi Romani'. As P. records, deditio and receptio in fidem are the same action viewed from the two sides, and the formula of deditio, as recorded in Livy, i. 38. z (see above), has no place for a deditio which is facta but in which subsequently those making it are not recepti. Calderone argues that the Aetolian misunderstanding sprang from the fact that to a Greek 1rlan<; was a bilateral concept and, in the giving and of oaths, conjured up the notion of a compact. So
WITH THE AETOLIANS (191)
XX.
I().
7
There is some truth in this; but even more the misunderstanding arose because the Aetolians assumed, from their past experience of Roman behaviour, that in fidem zumire would imply generous treatment, with room for discussion, whereas Acilius chose to interpret the situation in its full rigour, as had been done earlier in relation to Capua, Atella, Calatia, and the Sabatini (cf. Livy, xxvi. 14. 2, 14. 8-16. 10, 33· r2 ff., 34). For clearly an act of deditio could not purchase immunity from retribution in all circumstances. The original meaning of fides has been much discussed since E. Fraenkel (Rh. 1"'1-ftts. 1916, 187 ff.) argued that it meant 'guarantee' and carried no moral overtones, a view rejected by R. Heinze (Hermes, 1929, 140 ff. =Geist, 25 ff.) and later defended by G. Beseler (Z. Sav.-Stzft. (Rom. Abt.) 49, 1929, 415 ff.; Atti del Congresso lnternazionale di Diritto Romano (Rome, 1933) i. 140 ff.). Piganiol (RIDA, 5, 1950, 345-ti) saw in it the mana residing in a leader's right arm; and Calderone, 90-98, connects it with rpelSeaOat, 'to spare, to renounce the rights of war'. The problem is peripheral to that of the meaning of in fidem uenire at the time P. was writing. Bibliography: in addition to works mentioned (among which that of Piganiol is especially important) see J. Paoli in Aeqttilas et bona fides: Festgabe fur A. Simonius (Basel, 1955), Zi4-S; I. Calabi, Riv. fil. 1956, 395; Posch!, Grlmdwerte, 101; Heuss, Volk. Grund. 64-66; Dahlheim, s-ti7 especially 2 s-sz ; Lehmann, IOJ-4; M. Merten, Fides Romana bei Livius (Diss. Frankfort, 1965), 6--7; Flurl, 26-82. t
10. 4.
Twv 8E Ka.To.veuacl.vTwv: Livy, xxxvi. 28. 2, probably for vividness (rather than following an annalist), adds here: 'turn decretum Phaeneas, in quo id diserte scriptum erat, ostendit.' jlTJ8evo. 8to.~o.tYELY .•• eic.; -nlv ,...ala.v: p:r}u: 1
I.
81
XX.
IO.
8
ROMAN NEGOTIATIONS
8. 'KHuwa;;: .•• TTEp~9E~Va.L: not actually done (cf. xxi. 5· 3 n.). 9. EO'Ta.aav awvoL: cf. fg. 192; on the expression see Wunderer, i. 6r. 10. Twv ••• XL;\ul.pxwv: the military tribunes were members of Glabrio's advisory council (cf. xiv. 2. n n.); on L. Valerius Flaccus' status see 9· 5 n., and on his intervention 9· 9 n. 11. TOUS nTTOKA'fjTOUS: see I n. ,.,.poaS;;:Ia9a.L 5E ~