ASSEMBLY
FEBRUARY 2012
www.assemblymag.com
Servo-Driven Grippers pg 32 High-Mix Assembly Driving Small Screws Resistance Welding
34 40 44
ASSEMBLY FEBRUARY 2012
Vol. 55, No. 2
32
66
COVER STORY
34
32 Quick-Change Artists
Servo-driven grippers lend flexibility to automated assembly lines in the automotive industry and beyond.—Jesse Hayes
40 FEATURES
DEPARTMENTS
34 Maintaining Quality in a Build-to-Order Shop
Editorial . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6
For custom server appliance assembler MBX Systems, new procedures have virtually eliminated workmanship defects.—Jill Bellak
40 Automation for Small Screws
Tiny fasteners present big problems for assemblers. —Austin Weber
44 Adaptive Control of Resistance Welding 46
A new technology could reduce, or even eliminate, the need for destructive and nondestructive testing of robotically welded joints.—Tom Taylor
The time is right for reshoring.—John Sprovieri
New & Noteworthy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8 Automated IV leak test system eliminates visual inspections.—Austin Weber
Fastening Threads. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10 Getting with the program.—David Archer
Assembly Lines . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 ‘Assembly Plant of the Year’ award call for nomimations. —Austin Weber
Assembly Plant of the Year . . . . . . . . . . . 23 Nominate your facility for our annual award.
Assembly in Action . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24 3D printer prototypes complex, multimaterial products. —Jim Camillo
Product Reviews . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 47 In-depth profiles of the latest assembly technology.
Case Studies in Assembly . . . . . . . . . . . . 51 NEXT MONTH Assembling Tractors How to Implement 5S Get Proactive for Safety Lean Plant Layout
Read how our advertisers have helped their customers solve problems and improve processes.
Products . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 73 Classified . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 82
57
Advertisers Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 83
Cover photo courtesy SCHUNK Inc.
Shipulski on Design . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 84
2 ASSEMBLY / February 2012 www.assemblymag.com
Lean and supply chain sensitivity.—Mike Shipulski
. t r a P e h t o t g n i h T t s e s o l C e h T Grippers ators u t c A y r a t o R s Linear Slide es sori s e c c A t o b o R
for the inside story, go to:
www.closestthing.com 800-772-4865
w w w . s c h u n k . c o m
ASSEMBLY NLINE
ONLINE TABLE OF CONTENTS
FEBRUARY 2012
WWW.ASSEMBLYMAG.COM
We’ve Changed!
ASSEMBLY now has a bigger and better Web site. The totally redesigned site delivers more information in an easier-to-navigate platform for an enhanced online experience. Features include quicker navigation with fast access to articles, special reports, columns and blogs. In addition, there’s an advanced key word search function that allows engineers to find articles by date, author or issue. There’s also social media integration for relevant content sharing. The site includes Web-exclusives, slideshows and 10 years of archived articles. You’ll also find content organized by key words, such as adhesives, fastening and robotics.
Web Extras AVOID THESE MISTAKES WITH SMALL SCREWS Engineers make several common mistakes with assembly applications involving small screws. For instance, underestimating or overestimating failure torque can cause problems. The correct torque depends on the size and tolerances of the boss hole, length of engagement, and the materials being fastened.
ASSEMBLY
WEBINARS Watch webinars on-demand at anytime.
ASSEMBLY webinars are a FREE and convenient way to get educated and informed on the latest industry topics. CONNECT WITH ASSEMBLY
Web Blogs UPDATED REGULARLY
ASSEMBLY editors and industry experts share their views on the latest in assembly and manufacturing.
» COMMENT ON THE LATEST POSTINGS » UPDATED REGULARLY
BEHIND THE SCENES AT SIEMENS’ NEW TURBINE ASSEMBLY PLANT In November, Siemens Energy opened a new gas turbine assembly plant in Charlotte, NC. Editor in chief John Sprovieri takes you behind the scenes.
ASSEMBLY
RADIO
ASSEMBLY SHOWROOMS Visit ASSEMBLY’s virtual product showrooms to view leading supplier information, products and services online.
TV
ASSEMBLY
ASSEMBLY Radio provides audio interviews on the latest news and topics in assembly and manufacturing.
HERRMANN ULTRASONICS: ULTRASONIC WELDING Herrmann Ultrasonics offers myriad solutions for joining plastic parts.
NOW PLAYING!
SEALANT EQUIPMENT: INDUSTRIAL DISPENSING From gasketing to potting, see how the experts at Sealant Equipment have tackled a wide range of automated dispensing applications.
» When Would You Use 3D Vision Technology? » TRW Manager Talks About Assembling Air Bag Inflators
4 ASSEMBLY / February 2012 www.assemblymag.com
HIGHER OEE HIGHER ROI HIRE ATS
TURNKEY FACTORY-WIDE AUTOMATION SOLUTIONS ATS delivers more than automation. We provide expertise gained from the successful completion of over 15,000 projects worldwide. We leverage proven best practices to produce innovative automation solutions with the lowest total cost of ownership. And, our global resources ensure you receive exceptional on-site service and support. Want to elevate your factory automation to new heights? Talk to ATS.
For more information, email us at
[email protected], call 1 866 546 8515, or visit us at www.atsautomation.com
See us at ATX 4EXAS, Booth
Editorial
ASSEMBLY
The Time Is Right for Reshoring
L
ast September, Otis Elevator Co. announced that it was moving production from its factory in Nogales, Mexico, to a new, $40 million assembly plant in Florence, SC. The new facility will bring more than 360 new jobs to South Carolina. The move is good news for South Carolina— where the unemployment rate stood at 9.9 percent in November 2011—and, indeed, for the country as a whole. Otis is one of a growing number of manufacturers that have decided to bring production back to the United States from overseas. According to a report released last month by the White House, real business fixed investment has grown by 18 percent since the end of 2009. In the past two years, 334,000 manufacturing jobs have been created, while manufacturing production has increased by 5.7 percent on an annualized basis since its low in June 2009. That’s the fastest pace in a decade. While reshoring is laudable for its own sake, recent economic conditions have produced sound business reasons for bringing work back home, too. Freight costs and overseas labor rates are rising. And even the Chinese yuan is inching up in value, from $0.152 in January 2011 to $0.158 in January 2012. Seizing the moment, the Obama administration is trying to promote more insourcing of jobs by U.S. companies after decades of outsourcing to foreign countries. At a forum hosted by the White House last month, the Obama administration announced steps to encourage more factory construction in the United States and more investment here by foreign companies. “Today I am meeting with companies choosing to invest in the one country with the most productive workers, best universities, and most creative and innovative entrepreneurs in the world: the United States of America,” Obama said prior to the forum. “And I’m calling on those businesses that haven’t brought jobs back to take this opportunity to get the American people back to work.” During the forum, Obama said his administration would soon propose new tax provisions to reward companies that bring back jobs to the United States or make new investments here. At the same time, the administration would move to eliminate tax breaks for companies that ship jobs overseas. The White House noted that although many other countries solicit business investment at the national level, the United States traditionally has left that job to the states. The Obama administration is trying to change that. Last year, it launched a program called SelectUSA to work with states to promote business investment. In addition, the Commerce and State departments will launch a pilot program in 10 countries to encourage businesses there to invest more in the United States. We applaud the Obama administration for encouraging investment in domestic manufacturing, and we urge U.S. companies to carefully consider the total costs of offshoring when deciding where to make their products. The time is right for reshoring.
®
155 N. Pfingsten Rd., Suite 205 Deerfield, IL 60015 For subscription information or service, please contact Customer Service at: Tel: 847.763.9534 or Fax: 847.763.9538 or e-mail
[email protected]
TOM ESPOSITO Publisher
[email protected] BILL DEYOE Associate Publisher
[email protected] JOHN SPROVIERI Editor
[email protected] AUSTIN WEBER Senior Editor
[email protected] JIM CAMILLO Senior Editor
[email protected] DONALD E. HEGLAND Editorial Director Emeritus MIKE ROBINSON Art Director
[email protected] AMANDA PODINA Marketing Coordinator
[email protected] LISA WEBB Production Manager
[email protected] CAROLYN PERUCCA Buyers Guide Project Leader
[email protected] CINDY WILLIAMS Corporate Reprint & Trade Show Coordinator
[email protected] CORPORATE DIRECTORS Publishing John R. Schrei Corporate Strategy Rita M. Foumia Information Technology Scott Krywko Production Vincent M. Miconi Finance Lisa L. Paulus Creative Michael T. Powell Directories Nikki Smith Human Resources Marlene J. Witthoft Events Scott Wolters Clear Seas Research Beth A. Surowiec
BNP Media Helps People Succeed in Business with Superior Information 6 ASSEMBLY / February 2012 www.assemblymag.com
The Professionals’ Choice.
“I am a genuine Loctite® user and this is a genuine Mahr® precision gage.” Charles Toffling Design Engineer, Mahr Federal
For more information on Loctite brand industrial adhesives and sealants, visit www.useloctite.com or call 1.800.LOCTITE (562.8483). ®
Except as otherwise noted, all marks used are trademarks and/or registered trademarks of Henkel and/or its affiliates in the U.S. and elsewhere. ® = registered in the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office. Mahr is a registered trademark of Mahr GmbH. © Henkel Corporation, 2010. All rights reserved. 6887 (10/10)
NEW Ask The Glue Doctor™ to prescribe the best ƐŽůƵƟŽŶĨŽƌLJŽƵƌ ĂĚŚĞƐŝǀĞĂƉƉůŝĐĂƟŽŶ͘
Scan here
to connect with The Glue Doctor™
& NOTEWORTHY
Leak Test System Eliminates Visual Inspections
The Med75 leak detector is designed for production testing of IV filters. It speeds cycle times and eliminates human error from visual inspection. The mass flow leak detector features three ports on the filter: an inlet, an outlet and a vent. It automatically performs either hydrophilic or hydrophobic membrane tests at 9 psig—in a cycle time of only 6 seconds. The device includes embedded Web pages to monitor and access operations remotely, including interactive test parameter updates. InterTech Development Co. 847-679-3377 www.intertechdevelopment.com
Adhesives ͻ^ĞĂůĂŶƚƐͻŽĂƚŝŶŐƐͻ Tapes ŶĐĂƉƐƵůĂŶƚƐͻŝƐƉĞŶƐŝŶŐƋƵŝƉŵĞŶƚ Contact us directly to request a free catalog.
1-800-888-0698 ǁǁǁ͘ĞůůƐǁŽƌƚŚ͘ĐŽŵ
Mobile Tool Carts Are Flexible and Maneuverable
Technician Series mobile carts are ideal for lightweight tool storage and transport. The shelf cart features 2-inch deep pan shelves at the top and bottom covered with a ribbed rubber mat. The drawer units include a core lock and two keys, as well as a premium mesh drawer liner. The carts, which provide a 400 pound capacity, have two fixed and two swivel-withwheel-lock casters. Model NS carts are 17.5 inches wide and available in 14 configurations, while Model ST carts are 31.75 inches wide and available in nine configurations. Lista International Corp. 800-722-3020 www.listabox.com
8 ASSEMBLY / February 2012 www.assemblymag.com
Light-Cure Conformal Coating Is Solvent-Free E-MAX 903-E is a solvent-free, light-cure conformal coating that is engineered to cure with UV and visible light using DYMAX Corp.’s LED curing equipment. A secondary moisture-cure mechanism provides ambient cure in shadowed areas. The coating also features high chemical resistance, low viscosity, and a tack-free cure immediately upon cooling after light exposure. It is available in 30 milliliter syringes, 1-liter bottles and 5-gallon cans. Ellsworth Adhesives 800-888-0698 www.ellsworth.com
In-Line 2D Optical Micrometer Is Fully Automated The TM-3000 2D optical micrometer can be used in fully automated high-speed, in-line or off-line measurement and inspection applications. It combines the functionality of a laser scan micrometer, machine vision system and optical comparator into a single device. The micrometer is available in three sensor head sizes, along with the ability to use two transmitter-receiver pairs simultaneously to provide unparalleled flexibility. Because the system works in two dimensions, it can measure up to 16 points within the measurement area. Keyence Corp. of America 888-539-3623 www.keyence.com
www.assemblymag.com February 2012 / ASSE M B LY 9
Fastening THREADS
Getting With the Program
P
rogrammable torque tools have become popular in recent years, due to quality initiatives. However, quality improvements don’t come as soon as a new tool is plugged in. Properly sized and maintained, the torque scatter of a good (though much less expensive) clutch tool will not be substantially different than a programmable tool, if the latter is simply programmed to run at the same free speed and shut off at the same torque as the “dumb” tool. You should only make the additional investment for the opportunity to improve joint quality. Many engineers don’t take full advantage of that opportunity and fail to maximize their investment or their product quality. While there ■ By David Archer are several reasons for this, one big culprit is President uncertainty as to how to determine the parameters for programming a good tightening strategy. Archetype Joint LLC I’ll address the most common situation: Orion, MI
[email protected] Target torque has been established by product engineering and the plant engineer must develop the tightening strategy. We’ll also assume that the joint doesn’t have unusual characteristics or requirements, so the most widely used strategy of torque control with angle monitoring can apply. Factors such as equipment, rundown, tightening and process limits should be examined. Equipment. This factor is applicable for any tool that has the programming capability to implement it. Though not directly tied to programming, one requirement for effective tightening strategy development and process control is the ability to plot torque vs. angle traces. Note that plotting torque against time is not the equivalent, as changes in spindle speed affect the slope of the trace. This, in turn, suggests joint behavior that is not actually present. Simultaneously plotting both torque and spindle speed against angle is the ideal means for understanding joint behavior during tightening. Rundown. This step covers advancing Archetype Joint the fastener from the point of socket or bit specializes in joint engagement until shortly after clamp load is design, testing being generated. The primary question in this and validation. step is how fast the spindle should turn. If the Dave Archer can fastener is free-running (no resistance from be contacted thread-forming or a locking feature), maximum at darcher@ speed can be used if socket engagement can be archetypejoint.com maintained. 10 ASSEMBLY / February 2012 www.assemblymag.com
Thread interference may require reduced speed, particularly when the fastener or nut member is a material other than steel. This can be determined by comparative testing. Rundown, and sometimes tightening, is more consistent when all adapters are eliminated and the distance between the fastener and tool drive is minimized. Take advantage of soft-start capability when the fastener’s drive features are difficult to engage. Tightening. This step starts at completion of rundown and ends with tool shut-off at the program’s conclusion. In most cases, the transition to tightening involves reducing spindle speed. At what torque this transition should occur, how speed is reduced and to what value, are decisions that should be made after consideration of each joint. This knowledge is nearly impossible without access to torqueangle-speed traces. The tightening step should start after the joint components are fully aligned, indicated by the torque-angle trace’s slope. This slope is a measure of resistance, which is more useful to think of as joint stiffness. Stiffness increases as component contact area increases, and then stays constant until clamp load is great enough to yield components. How close the transition point should be to the start of this linear portion of the trace is largely a function of how much the spindle turns before target torque is reached and how speed will be reduced. Earlier transitions tend to reduce scatter at an increase in cycle time. However, in most cases, rotation is so short the time penalty is trivial. Another speed-related phenomenon that should be avoided is stick-slip, a condition where friction fluctuates, causing “noise” in the trace as torque oscillates up and down. Premature shut-off is often the result. Experimenting with changes in speed should be the first response. Both these conditions usually produce a squealing noise, which should also be a flag for investigation. Final tightening speed should be related to fastener diameter, as friction can be influenced by the relative velocity of mating surfaces. Common ranges for clamp load-critical joints are 40 to 80 rpm for M8 (5/16 inch) bolts down A to 10 to 20 rpm for M16 (5/8 inch) bolts.
ROBOTS DO IT BETTER! Higher Quality with Reduced Labor Costs
SOLDERING Contact, Laser, or Ultrasonic Desktop soldering robots for stand-alone applications from Fancort and Japan UNIX
SCREW FASTENING Standard Electric or Servodrivers
For higher levels of automation Fancort and Japan UNIX have three robotic platforms. Shown is the 700H SCARA
PCB DEPANELING Desktop Routers
Desktop PCB routers with vacuum system, adjustable fixture and zero-stress tab removal
Desktop robotic screw fastening with optional drivers and feeders
Contact us to learn more about how our unique robotic solutions can reduce your labor costs and increase the quality of your assemblies.
1-888 FANCORT
[email protected]
www.fancort.com
See us at APEX Booth 1146
Assembly Lines
Inventions New facilities ‘Assembly Plant of the Year’ Award Call for Nominations
Philips Respironics’s New Kensington, PA, facility was the recipient of the 2011 Assembly Plant of the Year award.
DEERFIELD, IL—ASSEMBLY Magazine and The Boston Consulting Group Inc. are currently seeking nominations for the 2012 Assembly Plant of the Year award. The 9th annual award will recognize a manufacturing facility in the United States that has applied world-class processes to reduce production costs, increase productivity, shorten time to market or improve product quality. Entries will be judged by ASSEMBLY’s editorial staff and BCG’s operations practice on a broad range of operational performance measures and the use of manufacturing management tools. The winning facility will receive a crystal award and a commemorative banner. Previous recipients have been Philips Respironics, New Kensington, PA (2011); Eaton Corp., Lincoln, IL (2010); Batesville Casket Co., Manchester, TN (2009); IBM Corp., Poughkeepsie, NY (2008); Schneider Electric/Square D, Lexington, KY (2007); Lear Corp., Montgomery, AL (2006); Xerox Corp., Webster, NY (2005); and Paccar Inc./Kenworth Truck Co., Renton, WA (2004). Companies interested in applying for the 2012 Assembly Plant of the Year award can fill out the online form at www.assemblymag.com.There is no entry fee, and more than one plant may be nominated. The deadline for submissions is April 30. For more information, contact Austin Weber at
[email protected] or 847-405-4013. 12 ASSEMBLY / February 2012 www.assemblymag.com
Mergers
MFG Tray Celebrates 60th Anniversary LINESVILLE, PA—MFG Tray, a manufacturer of fiberreinforced composite products, is celebrating its 60th anniversary this year. It was one of the first manufacturers of massproduced commercial products using polyester resins and fiberglass reinforcements. “Known originally as Toteline, MFG Tray’s products gained popularity and acceptance rapidly into a variety of applications due to the durability and performance offered by composite construction,” says John Thompson, general manager.
MFG Tray is celebrating its 60th anniversary this year.
“We would not have survived 60 years without striving daily to be the best,” adds Thompson. “Our teammates’ desire to serve the customer and to deliver the highest quality product has never been compromised for any reason. We are very grateful to the customers, distributors and the MFG Tray teammates that
have made our first 60 years a success. We look forward to the next 60.”
Sensors Help Optimize Assembly Time MAGDEBURG, Germany—Traditionally, manufacturing engineers have manually timed assembly procedures to improve ergonomics, reduce waste and increase productivity. But, that method is prone to error. A new system records times automatically and cuts costs for manufacturers. Engineers at the Fraunhofer Institute for Factory Operation and Automation IFF have developed a system that uses three matchbox-sized sensors integrated in a sleeve. It records hand and arm movements precisely. The device also measures the start and end of individual actions, such as reaching, grasping, setting up, joining, checking or releasing. The interlinked sensor modules are positioned on the upper and lower arm and the hand. Assemblers only have to put on the two sleeves. They fit snuggly and don’t impede the wearer. “Until now, every individual movement has usually been timed by someone with a stopwatch or with digital time boards manned by employees,” says Martin Woitag, research manager at the Fraunhofer IFF. “This approach is not really objective, however.
For decades, ABB variable speed drives and Baldor motors have set the standard for quality, reliability and energy savings. Now, industrial customers in the U.S. can buy these products and receive expert support from a single source. Call 479-646-4711 to locate the district office nearest you. Two trusted names. One local source for sales and support. Only from ABB and Baldor. baldor.com
©2011 Baldor Electric Company
• Local Sales & Support • Energy Efficiency • Industrial Motors & Drives • Unmatched Customer Service
Scan with your smartphone to watch a motor and drive energy efficiency video or go to http://bit.ly/mSM0JV.
Assembly Lines
Sensors integrated in a sleeve record hand and arm movements of assemblers.
It is replete with errors and disadvantageous for everyone involved. The stress factor for employees is extremely high and they might not execute their jobs at their usual speed. “The stopwatch method only allows a process organizer to time five individuals simultaneously, depending on the situation,” adds Woitag. “Our solution makes it possible to re-
cord time simultaneously, even at several workplaces, without requiring additional labor. The system’s greater precision and objectivity is crucial.” Woitag and his colleagues rely on inertial sensors for their solution. They measure the acceleration and angular velocities of arms and hands in the X, Y and Z axes. Unlike other motion tracking systems, such
14 ASSEMBLY / February 2012 www.assemblymag.com
as GPS, the inertial measurement system functions without any other infrastructure. The inertial sensors independently detect objects’ positions in space. “What is more, our solution doesn’t require complex calibration,” claims Woitag. “A tool that teaches in the measuring points directly at the assembly workplace one time is all that is needed.” A PC application completes the system. The software calculates and reconstructs the motion sequences based on the sensor data. It breaks processes down into motion segments and ascertains the related times. The sleeves are currently used only for assembly tasks performed while sitting at workstations. But Woitag and his colleagues intend to configure the system to also
analyze assembly operations performed while standing or moving around. They plan to use the sensors to detect posture and analyze workplace ergonomics.
Misumi Opens New Distribution Center SCHAUMBURG, IL—Misumi USA Inc. has opened a new Los Angeles Distribution Center. The 34,000-square-foot facility in Torrance is located near Los Angeles International Airport. In addition to warehouse space, the building includes office space to house the company’s technical support and insidesales professionals. “The grand opening of our Los Angeles Distribution Center marks a significant mile-
Assembly Lines
“In phase one of [our] expansion plan, the new distribution center will be largely devoted to cross-docking of products,” adds Kaneda. “Phase two, scheduled for the Misumi USA Inc. has opened a new distribution near future, will center in Los Angeles. stone as we continue to grow allow for stocking of compoour U.S. customer base,” says nents which comprise much of Yoshihiro Kaneda, general our next-day delivery program.” For more information, contact manager of factory automation at Misumi USA. “The MISUMI at 800-681-7475. new center will help reduce lead times and freight shipping costs and, by supplementing our centrally located distribu- BMW Invests in tion capabilities in the Chicago South Carolina area, it will allow us to con- Plant tinue to serve customers with the responsiveness and rapid SPARTANBURG, SC—The delivery times our customers BMW Group is expanding expect and rely on. capacity at its 18-year-old
assembly plant here. The Spartanburg were exported, company plans to invest $900 making the BMW Group the million in the facility over the largest automotive exporter to non-NAFTA countries. next three years. Since it opened in 1994, “This will create 300 new jobs by the end of this year,” the Spartanburg plant has unclaims says Frank-Peter Arndt, dergone four expansions and the member of the board of produced six different BMW management of BMW AG models. Employment has responsible for production. grown from 500 initially to “This will allow us to produce more than 7,000 today. The state-of-the-art plant 350,000 units in Spartanburg uses advanced production in the midterm.” Last year, the BMW processes that make vehicle plant produced 276,065 vehicles for more than 130 markets around the world, representing an increase of 73 percent over the previous year. More than 70 percent of the vehicles BMW is investing $900 million in its Spartanburg, produced in SC, assembly plant.
Zero Defects. Highest Productivity. Stop Waste. Finally, easy-to-use software that solves the toughest plant floor manufacturing challenges. Ujigami™ is a comprehensive Product Directed Manufacturing System that delivers the highest levels of quality and productivity, resulting in best performance for manufacturing, warranty and Ujigami software watches over your plant floor... coordinating... controlling... reporting... and is a proven Dock-to-Dock performer in manufacturing and warehouse operations.
Visit www.watchover.us to learn how Ujigami makes manufacturing easy.
www.watchover.us
- Software and Services by Tutelar Technologies Inc. -
16 ASSEMBLY / February 2012 www.assemblymag.com
(905) 331-6808
Tough application, ingenious solution
Exactly
Mastering challenges together — Rexroth makes it easy to implement automation. Our many years’ experience in a wide range of industries has given us extensive application knowledge. We offer this comprehensive understanding to the tasks you bring us, leading to ingenious solutions. Regardless of the drive technology used, we thought ahead and integrated intelligence throughout. This consistency makes you more efficient — from planning to start-up and daily operation. Your benefits are real: Increased productivity, improved energy efficiency and maximum machine safety. You can count on Rexroth to have the appropriate drive and control solution to meet your needs exactly.
Bosch Rexroth Corporation www.boschrexroth-us.com
See us at ATX 4EXAS, Booth
Assembly Lines
production environmentallycompatible. Over the past five years, the plant has lowered its energy consumption by 48 percent, reduced CO2 emissions by 44 percent and waste by 65 percent. In 2010, the Spartanburg plant generated almost 62 million kilowatt hours of electricity from a methane gas energy center located on the grounds of the facility and supplied by a local landfill. This accounts for more than 37 percent of the entire plant’s total electrical demand.
Sysmelec and MTA Automation Merge GALS, Switzerland—Sysmelec SA and mta automation ag have merged their operations and created a new company called Unitechnologies SA. “Through the effect of size
and synergies, the new company will be able to significantly improve the services offered to [our] customers,” says Emilio Stornaiuolo, CEO. Under the Sysmelec and mta brand names, Unitechnologies will focus on its traditional markets, which include medical, watchmaking, automotive, microelectronic, electromechanical and optoelectronic applications. “In the future, new and innovative products destined for the automation of technological processes will be added to the range of current equipment,” says Stornaiuolo.
New Online Tool Aids Material Research CAMBRIDGE,
MA—The
Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) and the Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory have developed an online toolkit that allows engineers to easily find a material with specific properties. Using a Web site called the Materials Project, it’s now possible to explore an evergrowing database of more than 18,000 chemical compounds. The site’s tools can quickly predict how two compounds will react with one another, what that composite’s molecular structure will be, and how stable it would be at different temperatures and pressures. The project is a direct outgrowth of MIT’s Materials Genome Project, initiated in 2006 by Gerbrand Ceder, a professor of materials science and engineering. The idea, he says, is that the site “would become the Google of
material properties,” making available data previously scattered in many different places, most of them not even searchable. For example, it used to require months of work—consulting tables of data, performing calculations and carrying out precise lab tests—to create a single phase diagram showing when compounds incorporating several different elements would be solid, liquid or gas. “Now, such a diagram can be generated in a matter of minutes,” claims Ceder. “The new tool could revolutionize product development in fields from energy to electronics to biochemistry, much as search engines have transformed the ability to search for arcane bits of knowledge,” adds Steven Chu, U.S. secretary of energy. “It could drive discoveries that not only help power
MULTI-SPINDLE
SCREW DRIVING
DTI=ROI Return on investment can be 6 months or less. simplest screw feeding 85 years of combined experience World's system with only one moving part Multi-feed from one bowl US based company 5 US Patents Exclusive patented design, manufactured in USAtorque;variable RPM's Adjustable
18 ASSEMBLY / February 2012 www.assemblymag.com
1607 Norfolk Place SW Conover, NC 28613 800 948 1038 designtoolinc.com
[email protected] Just Add Screws
DESIGN TOOL INC.
www.ati-ia.com/patent
Engineers are calling it a revolutionary design for reliable Tool Changing. We call it patent #8,005,570.
The problem: Preventing the tool changer from separating from the robot arm when air pressure is lost. The solution: A back-angle cam with stepped down piston to prevent vibration or high acceleration from defeating the Fail-Safe. A simple idea. A revolutionary advance in reliability. The ATI Tool Changer with patented back-angle cam. Simply smart engineering. See it now at www.ati-ia.com/patent.
See us at ATX West, Booth 4115
www.ati-ia.com/patent
Assembly Lines
clean energy, but are also used in common consumer products. This accelerated process could potentially create new domestic industries.” According to Ceder, the Materials Project is much more than a database of known information. The tool computes many materials’ properties in real time, upon request, using the vast supercomputing capacity of the Lawrence Berkeley Lab. “We still don’t know most of the properties of most materials,” says Ceder, but in many cases, these can be derived from known formulas and principles. Already, more than 500 engineers from universities, research labs and manufacturers have used the new system to seek new materials for lithiumion batteries, photovoltaic cells and new lightweight alloys for use in cars, trucks and airplanes. Chu believes the development
of new materials for clean energy, transportation, electronics and other fields could be the key to revitalizing American manufacturing. “I don’t think we’re going to be manufacturing the old things,” he points out. “We have to be constantly innovating,” claims Chu. “If we could do more rapid materials development, we could push things out into manufacturing much faster.” For more information about the Materials Project, click http://materialsproject.org.
Spirol Honored for Green Initiative DANIELSON, CT— SPIROL International Corp., a leading manufacturer of fastening and joining components, was recently presented with the 2010 GreenCircle
road VTKR
Award by the Connecticut Department of Energy and Environmental Protection for the creation of the SPIROL Nature Conservation area. This is the second time the Microneedles penetrate the upper layer of the company has been skin without reaching nerves. recognized for environmental preservation. developed a new silk-based SPIROL’s first GreenCircle microneedle system that Award was received in delivers precise amounts of 2008 for its Environmental drugs over time and without need for refrigeration. The Management System. tiny needles can be fabricated under normal temperature and so they can be loaded Silk Microneedles pressure, with sensitive biochemical Deliver Controlled- compounds and maintain their activity prior to use. They Release Drugs are also biodegradable and Painlessly biocompatible. While some drugs can be MEDFORD, MA—A team of researchers at Tufts University swallowed, others can’t surSchool of Engineering have vive the gastrointestinal tract.
Cut, strip, and terminate wires with the fully automatic %TKOR%GPVGT. Equipped with high precision technology, the %TKOR%GPVGT features a compact modular design offering space for up to 6 processing stations, such as seal loaders, twisting and tinning stations, doubling unit, etc. Dynamic and powerful servo motors combined with an intelligent control system provide high output rates to meet even the most demanding production schedules. Quick changeovers make it ideal for low volume, high-mix jobs as well as larger production runs. The %TKOR%GPVGT is the perfect passenger for your road trip to success.
Schleuniger, Inc. Schle Manchester, NH | USA www.schleuniger-na.com/cst_am (603) 668-8117
Innovators in Wire Processing 20 ASSEMBLY / February 2012 www.assemblymag.com
To Be Precise.
Assembly Lines
Hypodermic injections can be painful and don’t allow a slow release of medication. Only a limited number of small-molecule drugs can be transmitted through transdermal patches. Microneedles no more than a micron in size and able to penetrate the upper layer of the skin without reaching nerves are emerging as a painless new drug delivery mechanism. But, their development has been limited by constraints ranging from harsh manufacturing requirements that destroy sensitive biochemicals, to the inability to precisely control drug release or deliver sufficient drug volume, to problems with infections due to the small skin punctures. The process developed by the Tufts bioengineers addresses all those limitations. It involves ambient pressure
and temperature and aqueous processing. Aluminum microneedle molding masters were fabricated into needle arrays with a radius of less than 10 microns and a height of about 500 microns. Elastomer polydimethylsiloxane was cast over the master to create a negative mold; a drug-loaded silk protein solution was then cast over the mold. “Changing the structure of the secondary silk protein enables us to ‘preprogram’ the properties of the microneedles with great precision,” says David Kaplan, chairman of biomedical engineering at Tufts. “This is a very flexible technology that can be scaled up or down, shipped and stored without refrigeration and administered as easily as a patch or bandage. We believe the potential is enormous.”
Schunk Symposium to Feature Leading Experts MORRISVILLE, NC— Schunk Inc., a leading supplier of clamping technology and gripping systems, will host its 5th annual Expert Days on Service Robotics on Feb. 29 and March 1. Under the motto “Service Robotics—Quo vadis?” the forum will examine the opportunities and potentials of this rapidly growing market. Topics will include “Perception and Learning,” “Robots and Component Design” and “Robots and People.” Top-notch speakers from around the world will present current trends, the latest research and promising business models. Two of the honored guests will be Dr. Roland Siegwart
See us at ATX Texas, Booth 1505 22 ASSEMBLY / February 2012 www.assemblymag.com
Schunk will hold its 5th annual robotics symposium on Feb. 29 and March 1.
from ETH Zurich and Steve Cousins from Willow Garage, a firm that develops hardware and open-source software for personal robotics applications. For more information, click http://expertdays.schunk.com or call 800-772-4865.
Presented by and NO ENTRY FEE! We’re looking for plants that have applied world-class assembly processes to reduce production cost, increase productivity, shorten time to market or improve product quality. Any assembly plant in the United States is eligible. Plant size, type of assembly process or type of industry is not important, as long as the facility is involved in joining discrete parts into finished products. The 9th annual Assembly Plant of the Year award will be presented at a special ceremony at the winning plant. The plant will receive a commemorative banner and will be featured in the October issue of ASSEMBLY magazine. To nominate a plant, click www.assemblymag.com. For questions, contact
[email protected]
Deadline April 30, 2012
Previous recipients of the award: 2004
2005
2006
KENWORTH TRUCK CO. Renton, WA
XEROX CORP. Webster, NY
LEAR CORP. Montgomery, AL
2007
2008
2009
SCHNEIDER ELECTRIC/ SQUARE D Lexington, KY
IBM CORP. Poughkeepsie, NY
BATESVILLE CASKET CO. Manchester, TN
2010
2011
EATON CORP. Lincoln, IL
PHILIPS RESPIRONICS, New Kensington, PA
Assembly in Action
3D Printer Prototypes Complex, Multi-Material Parts
F
Jaguar Land Rover uses the Connex500 3D printer to develop and test prototypes of complex, multi-material parts. Photo courtesy Jaguar Land Rover
For reprints of any Assembly in Action article, please contact Cindy Williams at
[email protected] or 610-436-4220 ext. 8516.
or more than a decade, the Coventry, UK-based wing of Indian TATA Group has owned Jaguar and Land Rover—two very different types of vehicles. Jaguar was launched in 1935 as the first affordable sports car capable of 100 mph. The Land Rover, first built in 1948, is an all-purpose vehicle with offroad capabilities. Currently, Jaguar Land Rover (JLR) produces eight vehicle lines. To ensure that these lines maintain their premium position in the marketplace, nearly 20 percent of JLR’s workforce is employed on product development. These workers use a variety of tools to quickly create and approve designs. These tools include CNC model making, a fully equipped metalwork and tool shop, and in-house prototyping. JLR uses several rapid prototyping machines, including a Connex500 3D printing system made by Objet Geometries Ltd. JLR chose the Connex500 because it features PolyMatrix technology, which allows fast development and testing of complex, multi-material parts directly from CAD data. By jetting two distinctive model materials in preset combinations in a matrix structure, the machine can create prototypes made of flexible and rigid materials, with different mechanical and physical properties, and various finishes. The system can print models made of up to 14 different materials in a single
24 ASSEMBLY / February 2012 www.assemblymag.com
print job. It prints ultrathin 16-micron layers and can create models up to 500 by 400 by 200 millimeters. The printer uses FullCure materials to create accurate, clean, smooth and highly detailed 3D parts. In 2008, the Connex500 was initially used to produce a complete facia air vent assembly, as a working part, for a Range Rover Sport. Rigid materials were used for the housing and air-deflection blades. Rubber-like materials were used for the control knobs and air seal.
The machine can create prototypes made of flexible and rigid materials. The assembly was produced in a single process. Once printed, the assembly was cleaned and tested immediately to make sure that all hinges on the blades worked and the control knob had the right look and feel. Since then, the system has accumulated 5,000 hours of operation, used 600 kilograms of resin, and printed more 2,500 parts. Although this amount represents a small percentage of the 30,000 parts prototyped annually by JLR, the number produced on the Connex500 has been steadily in-
Jaguar Land Rover used the Connex500 to create a headlamp washing system. Photo courtesy Migueldefender (YouTube)
Delivering the Best in Automation
Reg Onlin ister e Prom using o Co de: AB
March 14–15, 2012 Fort Worth Convention Center | Fort Worth, TX
Cutting-edge Technologies from the World’s Leading Automation Suppliers in: Lean Manufacturing
Control Software/Hardware
Custom Automation
Motion Control
Robotics
Assembly Systems
Vision Inspection Systems
Drives
Sensors
Motors
…and much more!
ATXtexas.com
Assembly in Action
creasing. Currently, the printer produces more than one third of JLR’s resinbased part prototypes. The JLR styling department is the most frequent user of the system. More than half of everything produced on the 3D printer finds its way into the design studio to help finalize new design proposals.
A good example is the creation of an entire telescopic headlamp washing system that extends and cleans headlamps every fifth time the windscreen is washed. The Connex-printed components proved to be robust enough for rigorous testing, verifying their design before moving into the expensive tooling stage.
TM
New Series ECV Electric Cylinders
W ith
Workstations Help GM Supplier Deliver Just in Time, Every Time
Easy 3 S Step tep Sizing & Motor Selection
S All ECV powered units are available with inline or foldback motor mounting
Electrically-driven units based d on proven PHD linear designs
High thrust and speed capacities Also Available!
ESK/ESL FDQWLOHYHUVOLGHV
ESG
VDGGOHVOLGHV
Order a free catalog & view animations of the many benefits of ECV Cylinders
Call 1-800-624-8511 or go to phdplus.phdinc.com/am212
JLR also uses the printer for overmolding. For example, two materials are used, but not mixed, to create a cover with a rubber seal. Once the seal is cleaned, it is used directly for fit and function testing. The company also uses the printer to develop door seals and protective gaiters made of its proprietary material TangoBlackPlus. This nonrigid material allows designers and manufacturers to create high-quality prototypes that closely resemble a broad range of rubber products. For more information on 3D printers, call 877-489-9449 or visit www.objet.com.
hreveport, LA, is home to an Android Industries assembly plant and a General Motors manufacturing plant. Located just 1 mile apart, the two companies work closely together. Every day, Android ships hundreds of engine and transmission assemblies to GM by trailer truck for just-in-time placement onto awaiting chassis for Chevy Colorado and GMC Canyon trucks. In fact, Android’s decision to build its plant in Shreveport was the result of being awarded a GM assembly contract to support the introduction of these two truck lines. Opened in 2003, the Android plant encompasses 226,000 square feet. Interestingly, not one robot can be found in all that space. Instead, located up and down the assembly line are skilled
6LQFH3+'KDVGHVLJQHGDQG SURGXFHGKLJKSUHFLVLRQUHOLDEOHSURGXFWV IRULQGXVWU\2XUSURGXFWVVXSSRUWHGE\ RXUVWURQJFRPPLWPHQWWRGHOLYHU\VHUYLFH DQGTXDOLW\KDYHPDGHXVDOHDGHULQWKH DXWRPDWLRQLQGXVWU\,I\RXGRQ¶WNQRZ DERXW3+'FKHFNXVRXW
26 ASSEMBLY / February 2012 www.assemblymag.com
Flow Cell workstations allow workers to quickly and easily grab components for assembly. Photo courtesy UNEX Manufacturing Inc.
Over 25 years I have attended or exhibited at trade shows in many sectors around the world. I never thought that there could be a virtual equivalent to a physical show until Tech ManufactureXPO. I made a good number of contacts and had some very interesting discussions. The content, quality of exhibitors and the mechanics of navigating the show were excellent. It was well worth my time. Congratulations on an innovative event! - D.Paul Zito,, W.E.S.T. Forwardingg Services
Wednesday, May 2, 2012 8:30am – 3:30pm EDT
2nd Annual
FREuEal virtent! ev Event Sponsor:
An educational virtual event covering trends in manufacturing from design to delivery.
PRESENTATION LINE-UP No travel or registration fees so you can attend with your whole team No time spent out of the office Reach multiple suppliers with the click of a button (more than ten are already signed up!) Chat one-on-one with your manufacturing peers
Keynote MAKE: An American Manufacturing Movement Deborah L. Wince-Smith President and CEO The Council on Competitiveness Full Service Assembly Process Management Solutions presented by
Download free whitepapers, case studies and new product information
Can’t Touch This: Inspecting to CAD using Non-Contact Technology presented by
Live Presentations
Educational Webinar
Listen to How-To Podcasts from manufacturing experts sponsored by
Register by March 2 to be entered to win an iPad!
presented by
Lunch-n-Learn: Preparing for Supply Chain Disruptions presented by Editors from appliance DESIGN, Adhesives and Sealants Industry, ASSEMBLY, Quality and World Trade 100
www.TechManufactureXPO.com
Exhibitors: DELTA REGIS Tools Inc.
Media Sponsors:
Get show announcements! Snap the tag to follow @AssemblyMag1 on
Interested in Exhibiting? Sarah Gorajek, Online Events Manager, Tech ManufactureXPO (248) 786 - 1671•
[email protected]
Assembly in Action
technicians accompanied by modular Flow Cell workstations that help them meet and exceed critical production targets. Shreveport is the first Android Industries facility to use Flow Cell workstations, says Mark Geer, lead engineer for Android and a member of the facility’s launch team. From these workstations,
which are made by UNEX Manufacturing Inc., workers quickly and easily grab components that they then attach to engine and transmission assemblies at a steady pace. “We can put four days worth of material on the Flow Cell and not have to replace material,” says Geer. Geer outfitted the Shreveport plant
OLIGOMERS. ADHESIVES. COATINGS. EQUIPMENT. AND ONE PRICELESS RESOURCE. THAT’S THE DYMAX EDGE. Achieving manufacturing efficiency is a complex challenge that requires more than an off-the-shelf solution. The Dymax EDGE offers an entire toolbox of resources, from oligomers, to customized adhesives and coatings, to dispensing, to light cure equipment. More importantly, our expertise enables light cure technology to provide the most efficient solution for your application. To learn more, visit dymax.com.
877-396-2988
28 ASSEMBLY / February 2012 www.assemblymag.com
dymax.com
with equipment similar to that used in the company’s other plants. However, when it came to workstations, he wanted an alternative to pipe-type structures with plastic wheels—which the company had used in other plants. Flow Cell workstations feature standard mix and match components that include vertical posts, horizontal beams, and Span-Track full-width roller tracks. The components are durable and designed to withstand the heavyduty high-volume pace of manufacturing plants. They are made to perform well for many years and come with a seven-year warranty. Geer likes that the components create a workstation that is durable, mobile and ergonomic. He also likes the system’s flexibility. Workstations can be assembled, disassembled and reassembled quickly and easily as needed. Common reasons include a new worker who needs the workstation to be a different height, or the workstation must be moved to a different area of the plant. Geer also likes the Span-Track roller tracks, which allow easy component flow from load point to pick point and are easy to reposition in the workstation. Android workers use the tracks to transport items like bolt boxes and hand-to-handle totes. The Shreveport facility features 22 Flow Cell workstations, which were all constructed in one day by production line employees. Geer says each one took about 30 minutes to build. For more information on modular workstations, call 888-460-7726 or visit www.unex.com.
LED Lighting Brightens Floor, Finances at Metal Parts Plant
S
panish manufacturer Martisa produces metal parts for the automotive industry at its Barcelona plant. However, the plant, which measures 1,288 square meters, has experienced various lighting problems the past several years.
Delivering the Best in Automation
June 19–21, 2012 McCormick Place North | Chicago, IL
Cutting-edge Technologies from the World’s Leading Automation Suppliers in: Automated Assembly Machines and Systems
Control Software/ Hardware
Assembly Workstations, Benches, Seating and Lighting
Conveyors
Adhesives, Tapes, Sealants and Dispensing Equipment
Machine Vision Systems and Non-Contact Sensors
Custom Automation
Pneumatic and Hydraulic Power and Hand Tools Robotics, End Effectors and Pick-And-Place Machines …and much more!
Motion Control
Components Supported By
AATexpo.com
Assembly in Action
DuroSite lights provide consistent luminance of 200 lux at floor level. Photo courtesy Dialight Corp.
The facility’s 32 400-watt high-pressure sodium (HPS) lights often flickered and dimmed due to energy surges caused by the plant’s metal processing machinery. The HPS lights produced inconsistent lighting throughout the plant; illuminance varied from 118 to 270 lux at floor level. Also, the lights took 10 minutes to re-strike following power outages, negatively impacting productivity. Maintenance was also a challenge, as the HPS lights were mounted at a height of 9 meters, ran 10 hours a day
five days a week, and had to be replaced every 10,000 hours. Each replacement light cost 50 euro, while the mobile elevation platform required to install the light cost 100 euro per day. Looking to create better and more even lighting—as well as save energy—company executives met with energy consultant Area Energetica, which is a partner of lighting distributor Inelec. Area Energetica recommended replacing the HPS lights with DuroSite LED High Bay lights made by Dialight Corp. DuroSite LED High Bays are 150watt lights that are L7 rated to last 80,000 hours and maintain 80 percent luminance after 60,000 hours. The lights produce minimal heat with no ultraviolet light or infrared radiation. They also require no maintenance, come with a 5-year continuous performance warranty and are mercury-free.
30 ASSEMBLY / February 2012 www.assemblymag.com
DuroSite lights are mounted at the same height as the HPS lights, but they provide consistent luminescence of 200 lux at floor level. Martinez says DuroSite lights also switch on and off instantly to improve lighting efficiency and reduce re-strike time following power outages. The new lights have reduced Martisa’s lighting energy use by 69 percent, from 9.9 watts per square meter to 3.7 watts. The lights have also reduced the plant’s carbon emissions. Each fixture weighs 17 pounds and features a housing made of copper-free, powder-coated aluminium. IP6-rated, the housing is designed to withstand dust and moisture. The fixture can be equipped with an acrylic, polycarbonate or tempered flat lens, or a polycarbonate dome lens. For more information on LED lights, call 732-919-3119 or visit www.dialight.com.
Assembly in Action
Supplier Improves Welding Quality With 3D Vision
K
WD Automobiltechnik GmbH manufactures side panels and assemblies for various car manufacturers at its Wolfsburg, Germany, plant. There, KWD has a welding station that uses 3D image processing software to improve robot guidance and welding quality. The station features three KUKA robots: one for spot welding and two for handling the parts. The parts-handling robots are equipped with grippers and integrated vision systems. KWD uses Cognex VisionPro 3D image processing software in conjunction with the vision systems. As welding begins, one robot is positioned in front of the component magazine. Inside the magazine, arranged horizontally in a stack, are small parts to be welded to the side panel. The robot verifies the correct position of the parts and grabs them, whereupon pins
AUTOMATION SYSTEMS
secure a side panel in place. Meanwhile, a second robot with a twosided gripping system positions itself in front of the transport rack that contains large parts arranged in a vertical stack. This robot checks the position of the transport lock, measures the position of the large parts, and picks them up. Subsequently, both robots move to the loading station and put down the parts in the correct position and in the logical sequence. Welding is then performed by a spot welding robot. Afterward, vision systems in the first and second robots check the number and location of the welds, and whether they were placed in the predefined fields. The vision systems also examine whether the roots of the weld points are correct based on the parameters of the welding control. Data obtained from the testing is archived, and images are assigned to the associated parameters. In this way, KWD achieves complete traceability
On Time On Budget On Purpose
At KWD’s assembly plant in Wolfsburg, Germany, 3D image processing software improves robot guidance and welding quality. Photo courtesy Cognex Corp.
and documents and verifies quality. Each welded component is then removed by the second robot and placed in the transport rack for finished parts. Once the required number of finished parts is stacked in the rack, a signal is sent to transport logistics, which collects the full rack and delivers a new empty rack. The process is then repeated. For more information on 3D vision software, call 508-650-3000 or visit www.cognex.com.
8303 Green Meadows Dr. N. Lewis Center, OH 43035 (740) 548-3721
Vertically-Integrated
Full Service Machine Builder-Integrator Full Project Management and Engineering Services Automotive - Energy - Consumer Products - Munitions - Food - Medical Device ENERGY
CONSUMER PRODUCTS
Robotic disassembly of consumer products for recycling.
Vision-Guided Robots place mirrored tiles “into” Solar Dishes.
www.xasinc.com www.assemblymag.com February 2012 / ASSE M B LY 31
ASSEMBLY
Robotics
Quick-Change Artists Servo-driven grippers lend flexibility to automated assembly lines in the automotive industry and beyond.
As model variety increases, automotive components can only be produced profitably if automated assembly lines can be changed over in a short time. Photo courtesy FANUC Robotics
For information on how to obtain reprints/e-prints of this article, please contact Cindy Williams at
[email protected] or 610-436-4220 ext. 8516. By Jesse Hayes Automation Product Manager SCHUNK Inc. Morrisville, NC
T
he major advantage of robots is their flexibility. It’s ironic, then, that robot end-effectors are typically custom-made for a specific part. If the robot must handle different parts in the same run, a tool changer and multiple grippers are often required. However, pausing to swap grippers is unproductive, and storing multiple sets of grippers on the line takes up valuable floor space. This issue is particularly acute in the automotive industry, where more and more OEMs and suppliers are moving towards universal plants and flexible assembly lines. As model variety increases, engines and other components can only be produced profitably if automated assembly lines can be changed over in a short time. Multifunctional servo-driven grippers, which can handle a variety of parts in alternating succession, are one solution to the problem. For example, flexible servo-driven grippers are available for handling crankshafts, cylinder heads or motor blocks. A special gripper equipped with a compensation unit can handle four types of cylinder heads weighing up to 95 kilograms. The compensation unit rests on a floating bearing and is then locked eccentrically. A stroke of 342 millimeters enables the gripper to pick up components of different sizes. The compact gripper integrates with the existing robot controller and does not require an additional control unit or regulator. Flexible grippers for automotive welding lines are more complex. For reliable handling, numerous factors have to be considered, such as the
32 ASSEMBLY / February 2012 www.assemblymag.com
variety of part sizes; the varying surfaces and positions of gripping points; and the forces and vibrations affecting the gripper. Ideally, the parts and assembly line should be designed at the same time. For example, when designing parts, engineers should try to identify identical clamping and gripping points.
Thanks to plug-and-play connectivity, the gripper works like another robot axis. Lightweight Grippers A robotic cell for automotive side sills provides an idea of what a flexible clamping and gripping system for vehicle assembly might look like. The cell was jointly developed by SCHUNK, FANUC Robotics and systems integrator FFT EDAG. The cell consists of one six-axis robot for assembly and an additional six-axis robot that acts as a flexible clamping device. The latter is equipped with a SCHUNK LEG long-stroke electric gripper. The standardized, modular gripper weighs 8.8 kilograms, grips with a maximum force of 1,140 newtons, and provides a stroke length from 0 and 568 millimeters. For this application, it was equipped with a servo-electric drive from FANUC. Thanks to plug-and-play connectivity, the gripper works like another robot axis and can be actuated with the same instruction set. Two degrees of freedom at the gripper, five at the device, and six at
Made from carbon-fiber composite, this gripper weighs just 10 kilograms. Photo courtesy SCHUNK Inc.
the robot open up a new spectrum of possibilities for assembly. To save more weight in end-of-arm tooling, grippers can be made from composites. For example, SCHUNK offers a long-stroke gripper, the LEG-C, made of a carbon-fiber composite with a scalable pneumatic drive. At a weight of 10 kilograms, the LEG-C provides a maximum gripping force of 4,000 newtons and a variable stroke of up to 600 millimeters. If shortened finger travels are required, the stroke can be individually scaled. This minimizes cycle times and reduces compressed-air consumption, which makes the gripper much more
The SDH-2 three-finger gripper was designed to mimic the ability of the human hand. Photo courtesy SCHUNK Inc.
Pausing to swap grippers is unproductive, and storing multiple sets of grippers on the line takes up valuable floor space. Servo-driven grippers solve that problem. Photo courtesy SCHUNK Inc.
efficient. The gripper’s aluminum fingers are also executed in a lightweight design. They travel on recirculating ball-bearing carriages. The gripper can be exactly adjusted to the individual payload. In case of particularly high gripping forces or extremely long fingers, the distance between the carriages can be enlarged. This way, even fingers with a length of more than 1,000 millimeters can be used. The belt drive and the synchronized fingers ensure that the gripper works precisely at variable strokes. This is ideal when large and small parts have to be alternately handled. In addition to flexibility, lightweight servo-driven grippers are also more energy-efficient. Gripper Lends a Hand For gripping a wide variety of small components, the human hand is surely the best template. The SDH-2 three-finger gripper was designed to mimic the ability of the human hand. With its seven independent degrees of freedom, it can grip and position various objects without any setup. A tactile sensor system safely and sensitively monitors the optimum grip and supplies information to the control unit to make gripping corrections if necessary. This enables even difficult geometries to be reliably handled, positioned and inserted. The gripper is also protected
against dust and humidity. In the future, the automotive industry will have highly flexible manufacturing plants that do not need rigidly defined tools, devices or grippers. Sensorequipped, servo-driven gripping and handling systems will be the linchpin of these new plants. A
ASSEMBLY ONLINE For more information on robotic assembly, visit www.assemblymag.com to read these articles: Assembly Showroom: SCHUNK Inc. Assembly in Action: Automated Feed System Heats Up Production of Cold-Forming Press. Assembly in Action: Waterproofing a Space Robot.
Servo-driven grippers allow alternate handling of engine blocks, wheel rims, crankshafts and cylinder heads. Photo courtesy SCHUNK Inc.
www.assemblymag.com February 2012 / ASSE M B LY 33
ASSEMBLY
Flexible Assembly
Maintaining Quality in a Build-to-Order Shop For custom server appliance assembler MBX Systems, new procedures have virtually eliminated workmanship defects.
Instead of using printed tickets and manually crossing items off the list as they are picked, technicians now use iPads mounted on carts in conjunction with Bluetooth bar code scanners. Photo courtesy MBX Systems
For information on how to obtain reprints/e-prints of this article, please contact Cindy Williams at
[email protected] or 610-436-4220 ext. 8516. By Jill Bellak Chief Operating Officer MBX Systems Wauconda, IL
[email protected]
I
magine assembling Samsung, Sony, Sharp and Toshiba televisions in the same plant at the same time— each with different flat panels, components and features, from built-in WiFi to 3D displays—and you’ll have some idea of the challenges facing MBX Systems in manufacturing made-to-order server appliances and embedded systems. Each custom-built appliance uses a different chassis, dozens of different components, and variations in processes such as cabling, branding, software image loading, and testing. These widely divergent requirements can wreak havoc on scheduling, workload distribution, on-time delivery and particularly quality control. Several years ago, MBX addressed these issues by developing special production, picking, tracking, staffing and quality control procedures. The company also developed proprietary shop floor software tailored to the plant’s needs. Highlights include a new work center arrangement with more narrowly defined tasks, replacement of written build instructions with visual documents to facilitate correct assembly of each system, and deployment of Apple iPads to replace a picking system based on paper tickets. Over the next year, these and other changes yielded: A 42 percent reduction in system and workmanship defects. A 57 percent increase in manufacturing volume in the same physical space. A 94 percent customer retention rate, up from 77 percent.
34 ASSEMBLY / February 2012 www.assemblymag.com
A 116 percent jump in sales, even
during the depths of the recession. Significantly, much of that growth came from new customers dissatisfied with their previous contract manufacturers. One such customer was a digital media services company whose appliances frequently malfunctioned within hours of deployment. Another was a provider of investigation management software whose previous supplier shipped three defective boxes in a row. Those reliability problems disappeared with the switch to MBX, thanks to the strategies the plant established for maintaining quality in a high-mix environment. Hundreds of Permutations MBX primarily manufactures OEM hardware appliances used by software vendors as an alternative to delivering their applications to corporate data centers on CDs, as electronic downloads or in the cloud. Each system is built to optimize the performance of that particular application and preloaded with the vendor’s software, eliminating the need for IT staff at the customer site to install, configure and fine-tune software setup. Applications include data archiving, network storage, network monitoring, data and network security, content management, voice over IP, video production and video on demand. MBX also manufactures turnkey hardware-and-software modules to be embedded in products ranging from medical equipment to industrial machinery. With these disparate functions and unique customer needs, no two platforms are alike. One system may
be the size of a set-top box, while another may occupy a 6-foot-tall rack large enough to hold 42 servers. Some will have video capture or TV tuner cards, while others will require encryption chips, solid-state hard drives or other specialty parts in addition to motherboards, processors and memory to match the specific application. Customers such as SnapStream, a supplier of television search and monitoring appliances, have unique requirements, such as custom testing and special configuration of each machine based on the channels the end user wants to record. Other needs such as custom scripting, special back-ofmachine port labeling, specialty brackets to hold components in place, and antitampering features for government use, add to the challenge of consistently delivering quality product. Yet MBX is succeeding. “Since all of our customers require 24/7 reliability, it’s mission-critical that we provide the [best performing], fault-tolerant and efficient serverclass hardware. MBX not only helps us accomplish that feat, but also goes the extra mile to ensure the future success of our company,” says Adrienne Gonzalez, enterprise support specialist at SnapStream, which has reported only two defects since MBX began implementing its new manufacturing software and processes in 2009. Divide and Conquer As part of those operational changes, MBX divided the assembly process into more discrete tasks, doubled the number of work centers to correspond to those tasks, and imposed associated controls, such as automatically displaying build instructions on the assembler’s computer monitor as a job arrives at his workstation. Instead of the previous threestation setup, MBX now runs six work centers. Each job begins with picking in the warehouse and then moves to preassembly, where raw components like motherboards and hard drives are installed into the chassis.
In one year, MBX reduced system and workmanship defects by 42 percent. Photo courtesy MBX Systems
Next comes: which includes wiring and installation of custom-branded faceplates, color-coding of ports for easy customer connectivity, and in some cases the addition of security protections, such as blocking unused ports. Visual inspection, to validate the accuracy of the physical assembly. Configuration, for software installation and testing. Final quality control inspection, to approve the physical appearance and functionality of the finished appliance. Supporting this new arrangement Cabling,
is MBX’s new project management software, called Signal, and an array of other new processes specifically designed to cope with the variation in customer needs. These include: Customized workflow for each appliance. When each new job order comes in, platform engineers work with the customer to determine his needs, configure the system, create the bill of materials, and define the steps required to complete the build. The workflow is then entered into the production software, which makes it possible to customize job routing for each order
MBX divided the assembly process into more discrete tasks, doubled the number of work centers, and imposed controls, such as automatically displaying build instructions on the assembler’s computer monitor. Photo courtesy MBX Systems www.assemblymag.com February 2012 / ASSE M B LY 35
Flexible Assembly
When each new job order comes in, engineers work with the customer to determine his needs, configure the system, create the bill of materials, and define the steps to complete the build. Photo courtesy MBX Systems
based on the tasks that must occur in each work center and the background processes required to fulfill these tasks. Wiki-based documentation of each platform design. Use of a wiki instead of printed design documents ensures that assemblers have access to current build information on every appliance
or embedded system. Design updates based on component changes or work center feedback to manufacturing engineers can be incorporated into the wiki immediately and tracked by date, user and reason for future reference. Replacement of text-based assembly instructions with visual documentation.
36 ASSEMBLY / February 2012 www.assemblymag.com
As prototypes are being assembled, documentation technicians develop visual build documents that show every component location, cable turn, screw torque and other information. These documents, with accompanying written instructions, are entered into the wiki and displayed at the relevant work center on professional-grade 23-inch LCD monitors with a wide, 178-degree viewing angle that enables assemblers to view the screen from multiple positions without distortion. Build instructions customized for each work center. As each hardware unit arrives at a workstation, the builder scans a bar code affixed to the chassis and instantly receives build instructions related exclusively to the tasks for which that station is responsible. Removing instructions that are not relevant to a particular work center saves time and eliminates confusion. Quality Plus Efficiency All of MBX’s processes contribute to quality assurance. For example, adding
As prototypes are being assembled, documentation technicians develop visual build documents that show every component location, cable turn, screw torque level and other information. Photo courtesy MBX Systems
a new inspection work center midway through the line process enables assembly errors to be caught earlier in the build. In fact, every appliance or embedded system undergoes repeated inspections—not just one unit in 10 or 50. Numerous other checkpoints and controls also help keep workmanship defects at bay. For starters, assemblers at each work
A defect review team meets regularly to examine the most frequent build defects and develop strategies to minimize errors. Photo courtesy MBX Systems
center physically check the previous station’s accuracy against the visual build document to see if there is any deviation. As a result, every appliance is inspected at least five times—once for each work center after leaving preassembly. Any anomalies are recorded and corrected by the builder before the order moves to the next workstation. Second, if any configuration step is overlooked, MBX’s production
software automatically detects the omission, posts a warning on the computer screen, and prevents the builder from signing out and passing the mistake to the next work center. That safeguard prevents configuration errors, such as delivering an appliance loaded with the wrong software version or neglecting to capture a MAC address required to identify the device on the customer’s network.
The Dawn of a New Generation r One of the smallest, lightest,
r r r r
fastest DC controlled fastening systems in its class 70 models to meet all your fastening needs Transducerized for optimum torque control One controller for ease of use 1-4000 Nm
Call toll free 1-800-852-1368 www.aimco-global.com Regional Sales Opportunities Available. Submit letter of qualifications to
[email protected]
Made in the USA
www.assemblymag.com February 2012 / ASSE M B LY 37
Flexible Assembly
Each custom-built appliance platform uses a different chassis, dozens of different components, and variations in processes such as cabling, branding, software image loading, and testing. Photo courtesy MBX Systems
Third, MBX has a defect review team consisting of the director of manufacturing, a diagnostics specialist, and quality control and configuration technicians. The team meets regularly to examine the most frequent build defects and develop strategies to minimize human
“D4”
error. Based on their findings, the team may then modify build documents to clarify assembly processes. The team’s recommendations have helped drive continuous improvement and reduce defects, particularly on new platforms where errors are most likely to occur.
None of these quality control measures have diminished manufacturing efficiency, largely due to the ability of MBX’s production software to facilitate scheduling, workload distribution and adherence to customer deadlines. With the Signal software, schedules are optimized by analyzing booked vs. actual work time, employee calendars and time clock data. Managers can easily spot developing bottlenecks and move assemblers between work centers to keep operations running smoothly. Up to 15 people can work on the same order simultaneously to maximize output. Orders can be reprioritized on the fly to accommodate rush jobs or other scenarios. In addition, the software has given managers better insight into job costing and enabled real-time productivity metrics to be displayed on large monitors on the shop floor so assemblers can easily monitor their progress against estimated build times. This helps keep production moving.
Ergonomic Workstations (KQ\Z[HISL/LPNO[ 7V^LY4HUHNLTLU[-LH[\YLZ /PNOS`*VUÄN\YHISL +LZPNULKMVY,YNVUVTPJ *VTMVY[HUK/PNO7YVK\J[P]P[`
Only the Best!
WORKBENCHES s WORKSTATIONS s ROLLING CARTS
Deploy Dimension 4 Modular Workstations to create sophisticated production lines and cells
IACindustries.com
&OR