THE
AGORA ATHENIAN RESULTS OF EXCAVATIONS CONDUCTED BY
THE AMERICAN SCHOOL OF CLASSICAL STUDIES AT ATHENS
VOLUME XXII...
53 downloads
1813 Views
144MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
THE
AGORA ATHENIAN RESULTS OF EXCAVATIONS CONDUCTED BY
THE AMERICAN SCHOOL OF CLASSICAL STUDIES AT ATHENS
VOLUME XXIII
ATTIC
POTTERY BLACK-FIGURED BY
MARY B. MOORE AND MARY ZELIA PEASE PHILIPPIDES WITH THE COLLABORATION OF
DIETRICH VON BOTHMER
THE AMERICANSCHOOLOF CLASSICALSTUDIESAT ATHENS PRINCETON,NEW JERSEY 1986
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data 1937Moore, Mary B. Attic black-figuredpottery. (The Athenian Agora ; v. 23) Includes bibliographicalreferencesand indexes. 1. Agora (Athens, Greece)-Catalogs. 2. Vases, Black-figured-GreeceAthens-Catalogs. 3. Greece-Antiquities-Catalogs. 4. Athens (Greece)Antiquities-Catalogs. I. Philippides, Mary Zelia Pease, 1906- . II. Von Bothmer, Dietrich, 1918- . III. American School of Classical Studies at Athens. IV. Title. V. Series. DF287.A23A5 vol. 23 938'.5 s [938'.5] 86-20615 ISBN 0-87661-223-0
TYPOGRAPHY BY THE AMERICAN SCHOOL OF CLASSICALSTUDIES PUBLICATIONS OFFICE C/O INSTITUTE FOR ADVANCED STUDY, PRINCETON, NEW JERSEY PLATES BY THE MERIDEN GRAVURE COMPANY, MERIDEN, CONNECTICUT PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA BY THE TOWN HOUSE PRESS, SPRING VALLEY, NEW YORK
To
THE MEMORY OF
LUCY TALCOTT
FOREWvORD This volume contains the Attic black-figuredpottery found in the Agora excavationsbetween 1931 and 1967 during the directorshipsof T. Leslie Shear and Homer A. Thompson. Many of these vases and fragments have already appeared in various excavationreports or in special studies. In this volume, however, all of them are presentedtogether for the first time in order to give as full a recordas possible of this richly varied material. We wish to thank most Homer A. Thompson for the opportunityto publish these vases and no less for his unfailing support of the projectand his interest in it. We remembergratefully the late Lucy Talcott for all kinds of invaluable adviceand help as well as for establishingthe Agora system of recordkeeping, which enabled us to retrieveinformationso easily. Our special debt to the work of Sir John Beazley and our dependence upon it during all phases of our collaborationwill be apparent throughoutthe entire volume. We invited Dietrich von Bothmer to tollaborate with us. He read the manuscript and offered numerous helpful suggestions for improvementand changes that saved us from many errors. During her three-term leave from Hunter College in New York, he gave MBM the use of an office in the Greek and Roman Department at the Metropolitan Museum of Art as well as access to his photographicarchive, personal notes on vases, departmentbooks and offprints. These ideal working conditions enabled the research to proceed with much greater speed than would have been possible otherwise, and the special material made availablehas greatly enrichedthe contentsof this volume. We wish to express special thanks and gratitude to the staff of the Agora excavations for its friendly and cheerful cooperationduring all phases of this study:T. Leslie Shear, Jr., Field Director; John McK. Camp II, Assistant Field Director;Lucy Krystallis and Helen Townsend who, as successive secretaries,coped uncomplaininglywith our requests and questions;William B. Dinsmoor, Jr., for the plan indicating the deposits; Alison Frantz for the majority of photographs; Robert K. Vincent, Jr. for much of the new photography;Nicholas Restakisand KyriakeMoustaki for their care in printing the photographs;and Stephen Koob for restorationwork. We also thank the following colleagues and friends for various kinds of help and support: Peter H. von Blanckenhagen, Andrew Clark, Poly Demolini, Charles Edwards, Evelyn B. Harrison, Caroline Houser, Henry Immerwahr, David Jordan, Phyllis Williams Lehmann, Mary Aiken Littauer, Joan R. Mertens, Martin Robertson,Gerhard Schmidt, Evelyn Lord Smithson, Eugene Vanderpool, and Marjorie Venit. During the time we shared the work on this volume, we were separatedby a considerablegeographic distance. It was, therefore, necessary to divide our labors in a manner that would not impede our progress. MZP wrote a preliminary description of all the entries. These were then rewritten to conform to the format we had decided upon, and for some the content was revised. Most descriptionsare basically hers. She set up a picture file, made a detailed check list (typed in duplicate and meticulously checked by Ann Brownlee), and gathered and organized the deposit
viii
FOREWORD
informationfrom the excavationrecords.MBM is primarilyresponsiblefor the comparandain the Catalogue, the discussionof all the shapes, the chapteron pottersand painters,the concordanceand andto large extent, for the selection of vases to be illustratedas well as for the layout of indexes, and, the plates. The profile drawings are by Helen Townsend; the other drawings are by MBM. During the three years that MBM worked on the project, she was the fortunate recipient of financial support from the following sources: a stipend from the American School of Classical Studies, Octoberto December, 1978; an NEH Fellowship for 1979; two summer grants, one from the American Philosophical Society, the other from the Faculty Research Award Program of the City University of New York. During the summers 1977 and 1980, she enjoyedthe hospitalityand facilities of the American School of Classical Studies and wishes to thank its staff for helping to make her visits to Athens both comfortableand productive.MZP wishes to thank the Agora for fellowships granted in 1957/1958 and in 1966/1967. New York and Athens September, 1985
MBM and MZP
TABLE OF CONTENTS .
vii
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . LISTOF ILLUSTRATIONS
xii
. FOREWORD
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..
ABBREVIATIONS. INTRODUCTION.
. .
. .
.
. .
.
.
.
.
. .
.
. .
.
.
. .
.
. .
.
.
.
. .
.
. .
. .
.
. .
. .
.
. .
.
. . . . . .
. . .
.
. . . . . .
. . .
.
. . . . . . . .
SHAPESTUDIES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Pis. 1-15 ......................... ONE-PIECEAMPHORAE 1-127 Decorated on neck and body; figures not set in panels 1-6
xiv .
1
.
4 4
Panel amphorae 7-116 Special one-piece amphorae 117-119 Scheme of decoration uncertain 120-127 Pls. 16-26
NECK-AMPHORAE 128-225
.........................
7
Late 7th century 128-137 Non-standard:first half of the 6th century 138-164 Ovoid neck-amphorae165-177 Panel neck-amphorae178-182 Neck-amphorae of Panathenaic shape 183-188
Standardneck-amphorae189-205 Small late neck-amphorae206-225 PANATHENAIC AMPHORAE226-338
Pis. 26-34
......................
12
Prize vases 226-318 Non-prize vase 319
Uncertain if prize or non-prize vases 320-337 Miniature Panathenaic amphora 338 AMPHORAE, TYPE UNCERTAIN339-366
Pis. 34-36
....................
P1. 36 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
AMPHORALIDS 367-372 LOUTROPHOROI373-389
Pls. 36-38 ..........................
18 18 18
Hydriai 373-376 Amphora 377 Type uncertain 378-389 PELIKAI 390-397 PSYKTER 398
PI. 38 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
20
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
20
P1. 39
SKYPHOS-KRATERS399-413
Pis. 39-41 .........................
22
Pls. 41-46 . .........
23
Bowls 399-403 Lids 404-413 COLUMN-KRATERS414-490
TABLE OF CONTENTS
x
Pls. 46 and 47.......
VOLUTE-KRATERS 491-500
25 .......
Pls. 47 and 48 ...............
CALYX-KRATERS 501-509 LEBETESGAMIKOI 510-518
Pis. 48 and 49
519-525 KRATERS,TYPEUNCERTAIN
26 ...
......
. . 27 29
P1. 50 ..............
STANDS 526-602 Pls. 51-56 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Conical supports 526-560 Cylindricalsupports 561-586 Supports, type uncertain587-601 Sosian stand 602
32
Pls. 56 and 57.....................
LOUTERIA 603-607
Pls. 57 and 58 ........... Bowls 608-614 Stands 615-617
33
DINOI608-617
HYDRIAI 618-669 Pls. 59-63 . Round-bodiedhydriai 618-624 Shoulderedhydriai 625-649 Kalpides 650-669 OINOCHOAI 670-786 Pls. 64-73. 670-722 Olpai Oinochoai 723-776 Olpai or oinochoai 777-786
35 . . . . . . . . . . . . .... . . . ... . . . .... . . . . ..........
.
...................
P1. 88
PHORMISKOI 1258 and 1259
KOTHONS 1260-1264 PYXIDES 1265-1296
47
............
48
P1. 88 ...........
49
Pls. 88 and 89 ........ Pls. 89-91 .
39
43
LEKYTHOI ........... 787-1256 Pls. 73-87 .. Earliest 787-791 The lekythos painters, I: chiefly earlier 792-868 The lekythos painters, II: the Gela Painter 869-883 The lekythos painters, III: the Edinburgh Painter 884-886 The lekythos painters, IV: the Class of Athens 581 887-1124 Unattributed lekythoi:late 6th or 5th centuryB.C.1125-1159 The lekythos painters, V: the Sappho Painter and the Diosphos Painter 1160-1180 The lekythos painters, VI: the Theseus Painter and the Athena Painter 1181 The lekythos painters, VII: the Haimon Group 1182-1237 Unattributedlekythoi: 1238-1256 ALABASTRON 1257
29
............
..
..
.. . . . .. .
49
Corinthian type 1265 and 1266 Tripod-pyxides 1267-1278
Type A 1279-1286 Powder pyxides 1287-1289
Lids 1290-1296 LEKANIDES 1297-1360
Pls. 91-93 ..................
Lidless 1297-1329 Lidded 1330-1355 Uncertain if lidless or lidded 1356-1360
51
TABLE OF CONTENTS LIDS1361-1387
Pls. 94 and 95 ..............
53
..............
53
PLATES 1388-1426 Pis. 95-97 Type A 1388-1410 Type B 1411-1424 Other 1425 and 1426
Pls. 97 and 98
PHIALAI 1427-1439 MASTOID1440
xi
.............
56 57
P1. 98 ................
57
P1S. 98 and 99 .............
1441-1450 CHALICES
SKYPHOI 1451-1657 Pis. 99-107 ............. Corinthian type 1451-1471 Attic type 1472-1656 Special 1657
58
CuPs 1658-1846 Pis. 108-118 . Komast cups 1658 and 1659 Siana cups 1660-1684 Little Master cups 1685-1745 Cassel cup 1746 Droop cups 1747-1752 Type A and Sub-A 1753-1779 Type B 1780 Stemless cups 1781-1800 Cups, type uncertain 1801-1846
62
BOWL1847
P1. 118 .
.............
............... PI. 118.
EPINETRA 1848-1850 THYMIATERIA 1851-1853
68 ...........................
OPEN VASES, SHAPE UNCERTAIN1909-1932
Pls. 119-121 Pls. . 121-123.
P1. 123 . .
MISCELLANEOUS 1933-1935
DISKS1947-1949
69
P1. 119 ..............
CLOSED VASES, SHAPE UNCERTAIN1854-1908
PLAQUES 1936-1946
Pls. 123 and 124
CONCORDANCE
70
.
70
.
.
.
.
.
71
.
.
.
.
.
71 72
.......
DEPOSIT SUMMARIES
*
........
PI. 124 ....
POTTERS AND PAINTERS ..... CATALOGUE
69
...
...
. .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
73 .
99 329 337
.......
INDEX I: POTTERS, PAINTERS, GROUPS, AND CLASSES
355
INDEX II: SUBJECTS ......
359
INDEX III: GENERAL
363
......
INDEX IV: SHAPE AND ORNAMENT INDEX V: COLLECTIONS
PLATES
368 371
.....
INDEX VI: INSCRIBED NAMES
.......
....
382
LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS FIGURES IN TEXT
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22
. . . . . . . . . . . One piece amphora 1 (P 6155 a) ...... . 6 . . . . . . . . . . One-piece amphora (P 15088) ... . 34 . . . . . . . . . . One-piece amphora (P 1250), graffito . . . . . . . . . ....... . . 139 (P 13113) Neck-amphora ...... . . . . . . . . . 140 (P 17966) Neck-amphora . . . . . . . . . . ...... . 179 (P 25013) Neck-amphora . .. . . . . . . . . . ...... Amphora 341 (P 20678) . . . . . . . . . . . ...... Amphora 342 (P 26642) . . . . . . . . . . . Amphora 347 (P 25338) ........ . . . . . . . . . . . Amphora 358 (P 22999), dipinto. ..... . . . . . . . . . . . Psykter 398 (P 27885) ........ . . . . . . . . . . . Skyphos-krater400 (P 6577) ...... Dinos stands 615 (P 26619), 616 (P 21708), and 617 (P 13271) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Olpe 698 (P 6457) ........ ..... . . . . . . . . . . . 1150 (P 24411), dipinto Lekythos . ...... . . . . . . . . . . lid 1293 (P 15545) Pyxis . . . . . . . . . . . Lid 1382 (P 15387) ....... . . . . . . . . . . . Skyphos 1559 (P 1270), graffito ...... ... . . . . . . . . . . . . 1615 (P 23175), graffito Skyphos ... . . . . ...311 ... . 1793 (P 6552), graffito Cup . . . . . . . . . . . .. . 1833 (P 4928), graffito Cup . . . . . . . . . . ...... vase 1931 (P 21186) Open
PLATES
1-15 16-25 26 27-33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42-45 46 47 48
One-piece Amphorae Neck-amphorae Neck-amphorae.PanathenaicAmphorae PanathenaicAmphorae PanathenaicAmphorae.Amphorae,Type Uncertain Amphorae,Type Uncertain Amphorae,Type Uncertain. Amphora Lids. Loutrophoroi Loutrophoroi Loutrophoroi.Pelikai Psykter. Skyphos-kraters Skyphos-kraters Skyphos-kraters.Column-kraters Column-kraters Column-kraters.Volute-krater Volute-kraters.Calyx-kraters Calyx-kraters.Lebetes Gamikoi
99 100 104 118 119 125 143 144 145 146 151 152 180 192 241 257 267 287 293 315 324
LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS 49 50 51-55 56 57 58 59-63 64-72 73 74-87 88 89 90 91 92-93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100-107 108-117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124
Lebetes Gamikoi Kraters, Type Uncertain Stands Stanlds.Louteria Louterion. Dinoi Dinoi Hydriai Oinochoai Oinochoai. Lekythos Lekythoi Alabastron. Phormiskoi. Kothons Kothons. Pyxides Pyxides Pyxides. Lekanides Lekanides Lids Lids. Plates Plates Plates. Phialai Phialai. Mastoid. Chalices Chalices. Skyphoi Skyphoi Cups Cups. Bowl. Epinetra Thymiateria. Closed Shapes Closed Shapes Closed and Open Shapes Open Shapes Open Shapes. Miscellaneous. Plaques Plaques. Disks
PLAN The Athenian Agora showing the Location of Deposits
xiii
ABBREVIATIONS * "p."and"no."in references understood
AA AAA ABL *ABV AC Agora VIII Agora XII Agora Picture Book AJA AK Albizzati Arias ArtBull *ARV2 'ApX'ED AthMitt BABesch Bakir, Sophilos BCH Beazley, Development Beazley, EVP BJb BMFA Boardman,ABFV Boardmanand Hayes, Tocra, 1963-1965 Bohr, Schaukelmaler Bothmer,Amazons Bothmer,Amasis Painter Brann. See Agora VIII Brijder,Siana Cups I Brommer,Heldensage3 BSA Buitron, New England Collections Callipolitis-Feytmans, Les plats attiques
= = = = = =
ArchdologischerAnzeiger Athens Annals of Archaeology C. H. E. Haspels, Attic Black-figuredLekythoi,Paris 1936 J. D. Beazley, Attic Black-Figure Vase-Painters,Oxford 1956 Archeologiaclassica E. T. H. Brann, The Athenian Agora, VIII, Late Geometricand ProtoatticPottery, Princeton 1962 = B. Sparkes and L. Talcott, The Athenian Agora, XII, Black and Plain Pottery of the 6th, 5th and 4th CenturiesB.C., Princeton 1970 = Excavationsof the AthenianAgora Picture Books = AmericanJournal of Archaeology = Antike Kunst
= C. A. Albizzati, Vasiantichi dipinti del Vaticano,Rome 1925-1939 = P. E. Arias, M. Hirmer, and B. Shelton, A History of Greek VasePainting, New York 1963 = Art Bulletin
= J. D. Beazley, Attic Red-Figure Vase-Painters,2nd edition, Oxford 1963 = 'ApXaLoAoytcK'E7,epls E
= = = = = = = = = =
Mitteilungen des DeutschenArchdologischenInstituts,AthenischeAbteilung Bulletin van de Vereenigingtot Bevorderingder Kennis van de antieke Beschaving G. Bakir, Sophilos.Ein Beitrag zu seinem Stil, Mainz 1981 Bulletin de correspondancehellenique J. D. Beazley, The Developmentof Attic Black-figure,Berkeley 1951, corr. ed. 1964 J. D. Beazley, Etruscan VasePainting, Oxford 1947 BonnerJahrbiicher Bulletin of the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston J. Boardman,Athenian Black Figure Vases,London 1974 J. Boardmanand J. Hayes, Excavationsat Tocra, 1963-1965, The Archaic Deposits, London 1966 = E. Bohr, Kerameus,IV, Der Schaukelmaler,Mainz 1982 = D. von Bothmer,Amazons in GreekArt, Oxford 1957 = D. von Bothmer, The Amasis Painter and his World,New York and London, 1985 = = = =
H. A. G. Brijder,Siana Cups I and KomastCups, Amsterdam1983 F. Brommer, Vasenlistenzur griechischenHeldensage, 3rd ed., Marburg 1973 British School at Athens, Annual D. Buitron, Attic VasePainting in New England Collections,Cambridge,Mass. 1972
= D. Callipolitis-Feytmans,Les plats attiquesafigures noires, Paris 1974
ABBREVIATIONS
xv
= D. Callipolitis-Feytmans, Les "louteria"attiques,Athens 1965 Callipolitis-Feytmans, "Louteria" = C. Clairmont, Das Parisurteilin der antiken Kunst, Zurich 1951 Clairmont, Parisurteil Cristofani, VasoFranqois = M. Cristofani,Materialiper servirealla storiadel vaso Franqois[Bolletinod'Arte,Serie Speciale 1], Rome 1980 = Corpus VasorumAntiquorum CVA = Deutsches ArchaologischesInstitut, Athen D.A.I. = 'ApxaloXoyLKbvoLAerTo AEAT = Enciclopedia dell'arteantica, classicae orientale EAA = FestschriftfiirFrank Brommer,Mainz 1977 FestschriftBrommer = A. Furtwangler, K. Reichhold, et al., GriechischeVasenmalerei,Munich 1904-1932 FR = J. Frel, Panathenaic Prize Amphoras,Athens 1973 Frel, PPA = E. Gerhard, Auserlesenegriechische Vasenbilder,Berlin 1840-1858 Gerhard,A V = Greek,Roman and Byzantine Studies GRBS = B. Graef, Die antiken Vasen von der Akropoliszu Athen, Berlin 1925-1933 Graef = A. Greifenhagen, Eine attischeschwarzfigurigeVasengattungund die Darstellungdes Greifenhagen Komosim VI. Jahrhundert,Konigsberg1929 = Greek Vasesin the J. Paul Getty Museum, OccasionalPapers on Antiquities Greek Vasesin the J. Paul Getty Museum Hoffmann, Ten Centuries = H. Hoffman, Ten Centuriesthat Shaped the West, Houston 1971 = IllustratedLondon News ILN = Jahrbuchdes deutschenarchiologischenInstituts JdI = Journal of Hellenic Studies JHS = Jahresheftedes bsterreichischenarchiiologischenInstitutes JOAI = Jahrbuchdes Rimisch-GermanischenZentralmuseumsMainz JR-GZM Karouzou, Amasis Painter = S. Karouzou, The Amasis Painter, Oxford 1956 Karouzou,
'Avayvpovvros KerameikosVI, ii Kurtz, Athenian White Lekythoi Langlotz MadrMitt Mertens, Attic White-Ground MJb MMSt Mommsen, Affecter MonAnt MonPiot Moon, Midwestern Collections Muller, L6wen und Mischwesen NC Noble, Techniques Notable Aquisitions 1975-1979 OCD
= S. Karouzou, BLt/3AoL07K r ^js v 'AOrvaLs 'ApXaroAoyCLKl 'EEraLplas, XLVIII, 'Ayyeia rov 'Avayvpov^ros, Athens 1963
= K. Kubler, Kerameikos.Ergebnisseder Ausgrabungen,VI, ii, Die Nekropoledes spiten 8. bisfrihen 6. Jahrhunderts,Berlin 1970 = D. C. Kurtz, Athenian White Lekythoi,Patternsand Painters, Oxford 1975 = E. Langlotz, GriechischeVasen in Wiirzburg,Munich 1932 = Mitteilungen des deutschenarchdologischenInstituts, MadriderAbteilung = J. R. Mertens, Attic White-Ground.Its Developmenton Shapes Other than Lekythoi, New York 1977 = Minchener Jahrbuchder bildendenKunst = MetropolitanMuseum Studies = H. Mommsen, Kerameus,I, Der Affecter,Mainz 1975 = Monumenti antichi = Fondation E. Piot, Monuments et me'moirespublies par l'Academiedes Inscriptionset Belles-Lettres = Greek Vase-Paintingin Midwestern Collections,W. G. Moon, ed., Chicago 1979 = P. Miiller, Lbwen und Mischwesen in der archaischengriechischenKunst, Zurich 1978 = H. Payne, Necrocorinthia.A Study of Corinthian Art in the Archaic Period, Oxford 1931 = J. Noble, The Techniquesof Painted Attic Pottery, New York 1965 = MetropolitanMuseum of Art, Notable Acquisitions 1975-1979, New York 1979 = OxfordClassicalDictionary
xvi 01. Ber. *Paralip. RA REA Richter and Milne, Shapes and Names Roberts,Pyxis Studi Misc. Tiverios Ure, Sixth
ABBREVIATIONS = Bericht iiber die Ausgrabungenin Olympia = J. D. Beazley, Paralipomena.Additionsto Attic Black-Figure Vase-Paintersand Attic Red-Figure Vase-Painters,Oxford 1971 = Revue archeologique = Revue des etudesanciennes = G. Richter and M. Milne, Shapesand Names of Athenian Vases,New York 1935 = S. Roberts, The Attic Pyxis, Chicago 1978 = ?r7AJ T70 KoYroAeovros,Athens 1980 sroo fs iuPl.rv NLKoAdov = Studi Miscellanei = M. Tiverios, tO Avbos KaLTrOEpyo rov, Athens 1976
= P. N. Ure, Sixth and Fifth CenturyPotteryfrom Rhitsona, London 1927
INTRODUCTION The Attic black-figuredpottery found in the Agora spans the entire periodof the productionof this fabric and provides a nearly complete picture of the developmentof its shapes and the style of its painters. Many of the vases, especially the smaller ones, are complete or retain enough of their original characterto allow plaster restorationof the missing parts, but by far the larger proportion of the material consists of fragments. Making sense and order of these small scraps has been a particularly stimulating challenge, though not without many pitfalls; thus, we have kept in mind that "fragmentsare dangerous allies, and extra care must be taken in finding the whole shape to which they belong."' Attic black-figuredpottery has been found all over the Agora, but most of it comes from dumped fillings associated with houses, shops, or civic buildings, in particular from wells and cisterns located around the bordersof the square.2A few cremationand inhumationburials, chiefly from the Archaic Cemetery on the west slope of the Areopagus, also yielded Attic black-figuredmaterial, primarily lekythoi. The dating of these various findspots,whether wells, graves, or other kinds of deposits, is based to a large extent on the figuredpotteryfound in them. Some of these deposits,such as the upper fill of the Rectangular Rock-cut Shaft (G 6:3) or the large well found beneath the gutter of the Stoa of Attalos (Q 12:3),3probablyindicate the presenceof potters'workshopsin the area; the Stoa Gutter Well may also reflectthe massive clean-up operationafter the Persian Sack. Thus, the latest pottery in such deposits is of particular importance for the light it sheds on the characterof late Attic black figure in relation to its historicalbackground. The Plan following the Plates shows the Agora around 300 B.C., and on it the wells, cisterns,and burials useful for this volume are indicated.We have retainedthe four symbols used in Agora XII for wells and cisterns, since very many of these deposits containedblack figure, and we have added one for burials:
O Wells
which went out of use by or before 525
B.C.
{ Wells in use between 525 and 480 B.C. * Wells dated between 480 and 400 B.C.
) 0 Wellsandcisternsof the 4th centuryB.C. A Burials of the 6th century B.C.
On pp. 329-336, there is a list of these deposits that includes all those indicatedon the plan as well as many others. If a deposit has been describedin a previousAgora volume, the informationis not repeated. For each of these we give only its grid location, type (i.e., well, burial, pit, etc.) and date, followed by the pertinent catalogue numbers;for the descriptionof such deposits, the appropriate referenceis given, and if a deposit has been publishedseparately,this sourceis also included. In the case of deposits that have not previouslybeen described,a summaryof the general character
IAgora XII, p. 2.
2
For the characterand contents of a typical well, cf. Agora VIII, pp. 107-108; also, Agora XII, p. 44. 3 The material from the Rectangular Rock-cut Shaft was published by E. Vanderpool in Hesperia 7, 1938, pp. 363-411
and Hesperia 15, 1946, pp. 265-336. The potteryfrom the Stoa Gutter Well is published by S. R. Roberts (Hesperia 55, 1986, pp. 1-72) who has studied its workshop implications. All the Attic black figure from these two deposits is included in this volume.
2
INTRODUCTION
appears before the catalogue numbers. In the Catalogue itself, we give a deposit or grid reference for all entries except those that are sporadic or stray finds and therefore have no reference. For these, we use the term "No grid".Whenever possible, the level is indicatedby the following letters: POU = Period Of Use; L = Lower; M = Middle; U = Upper. Range and quality of the Agora black figure offer importantevidencefor the characterof decorated pottery associated with an ancient civic and industrial center or used in domestic quarters. Shapes mass-producedin the late 6th or early 5th centuries B.C., chiefly small lekythoi, cups, and skyphoi, naturally representthe largest amount of Attic black figure. But noteworthyis the quantity of material datablebetween 625 and 580 B.C., the period when Attic potterywas not yet exported to other parts of the Mediterranean.4Besides the Agora, only the Akropolis,the Kerameikos,and the cemeteryat Vari have yielded very early Attic black figure in any quantity. In addition,we have includedseveral of the thelatest vases published in the volume of Geometricand Protoatticpottery (AgoraVIII) since they illustrate well the transitionfrom Protoatticto black figure. Nearly every shape decoratedin black figure has been found in the Agora, although of course some are known only from small fragments. Of the pots, the largest number are amphorae:onepiece panel amphorae;neck-amphorae,including several variants of the shape; and Panathenaic amphorae,for which there is an uninterruptedsequence,beginning with the very earliest of about 560 B.C.and lasting until the late 4th century B.C.,the period when this study stops.5 Only one amphoraType A, 1934 (PI. 123), has been identifiedin the Agora material,and it is perhaps ironic that one cannot determine if it was decoratedin black figure or in red igure, because all that remains of the decoration is the lotus-palmette chain above the panel. Next in quantity after the amphoraeare the column-kraters,and there are also a good numberof stands, includingone of the rare Sosian type, 602 (P1. 56). There are not very many hydriai, yet examples of each type, the round-bodied,the shouldered,and the kalpis, have been found. Missing among the large shapes are stamnoi, which are mainly decoratedin red figure,6and neck-amphoraewith figures on both the shoulder and the body. The latter, to judge by the known provenancesof the attributedexamples, may have been intended mainly for export.7Among the smaller vases, lekythoi are by far the most numerous, particularly those of the Class of Athens 581 and those from the Haimon Workshop. These are followed in quantity by skyphoi, cups of various types, including severalof the Segment Class, and oinochoai. Missing are two shapes rarely found in Attic black figure: aryballoi and kantharoi;also absent are kyathoi and mastoi, although in the Agora, examples of the latter are known in black pattern as well as in plain black and of the former,only in plain black.8 Examples of less commonshapes in Agora black figure include loutrophoroi(both the hydria and the neck-amphoravarieties), pelikai including 391 (PI. 38), the unique one with rays above the foot, skyphos-kraters,volute-kraters,chalices, calyx-kraters,lebetes gamikoi, louteria, dinoi, and pyxides. Among the rare shapes, the Agora excavations have producedthe earliest known Attic black-figuredalabastron,a psykter,two phormiskoi,four kothons,a few epinetra,thymiateria,and phialai. The section on shapes concludeswith plaques and disks. The earliest exported Attic black-figuredvase is still the fragment by the Nettos Painter found at Cervetri and once in Leipzig, but it seems to be an isolated example. Cf. ABV 5, 3; Paralip. 2, 5; W. Herrmann, WissenschaftlicheZeitschriftder UniversitdtRostock,XVI, Die griechische Vase, Rostock 1967, pp. 455-456. 5 For Panathenaicamphoraeof the Hellenistic and Roman periods, cf. footnote7 below, p. 13. 6 For stamnoi, cf. B. Philippaki, The AtticStamnos,Oxford 1967, especially chapter 2 for the black-figuredexamples;also, 4
C. Isler-Kerenyi,Stamnoi, Lugano 1977, pp. 18-28. 7 Footnote 2 below, p. 8. 8 Agora XII, p. 143. For mastoi, the inventorynumbersare P 1217 and P 24556, both in black pattern;P 25277, the knob reserved,the rest black. Although publicationof the black-patternedvases fromthe Agora was plannedfor this volume(Agora XII, p. 57, note 11), owing to the large quantityof black-figured material, we decidedto exclude the patternedpieces. They will be the subjectof a separate study by MZP.
INTRODUCTION
3
Many of the Agora vases were already attributedby Beazley and appear in the pages of AB V or Paralipomena. Quite a few more have been attributed,and for these, following Beazley's example, the name of the scholar attributing the vase appears in brackets after the name of the painter. During the course of the work on this volume, the painters of a good many other vases were detected, and here the pertinent comparisons are cited, except for many of the late lekythoi where the attribution is based on comparisonwith the plentiful examples in the Agora. Some of the painters, such as Kleitias or the Antimenes Painter, are representedin the Agora only by one or two small sherds;the work of others, such as those decoratinglekythoi of the Class of Athens 581, the Haemonians, or the painters of the CHC Group, is so well representedthat one is temptedto suggest that their workshops were very close to the Agora, perhaps even within its boundaries. As rich as the Agora black figure is with regard to the variety of shapes and the large number of painters who decoratedthem, this volume is not intended to be a history of Attic black figure, but instead it tries to show how the black figure from the Agora fits into the existing chronologicaland stylistic framework for shapes and artists and how, in certain cases, it increases our knowledge of their development. The organization of our material and the format of the catalogue entries are modeled on those of two previous Agora pottery volumes, VIII and XII, with small changes made to accommodatethe features of black figure not found in Protoatticor in plain black. The sequence of shapes is based on that in the index of ABV for the Agora and other Athenian collections. For each shape or its variants, the arrangementis generally chronological,with painters or groups of painters and contemporarythough unattributedpieces appearing together. In the Catalogue, we have cited as much comparativematerial as necessary, not only to increase the usefulness of the study but in the case of small fragmentsto renderthem more intelligible in shape and decoration. It has been impossible to illustrate all the Agora black-figuredpottery in this volume, but the selection we have made gives a comprehensiveview of the material. All the important pieces are shown, whether previously published or not, and all whole vases or fragmentsthat present unusual or puzzling features are illustratedas well. In the case of the large quantity of late lekythoi,many of which are virtually duplicatesof one another,we have let a few examples stand for very many. The chronologicalorganizationof the material within each shape has meant that very often large, wellpreservedpots or even big fragmentsappear together on the same plate with very small ones, and, for each piece to be intelligible to the reader,there was no way in which the scale of reductioncould be kept consistent within a single plate. Thus, on the same plate, there are sometimes as many scales as there are figures. This procedureof selectionand illustrationdiffers considerablyfrom the presentationof pottery in Agora volumes VIII and XII, where all the vases describedin the catalogue were picturedand where in most cases the characterof the materialpermitteda single scale to be used for a given plate. Therefore, to visualize the size of the pot or fragment,the readerwill have to rely on the measurements given in the Catalogue. Since the discussion of each shape is not a monographic study but only a brief sketch, we have included profile drawings only of those vases that present odd featuresor whose contoursare not easily understoodin a photograph.In the case of certain fragments, we have attempted full or partial reconstructiondrawings to help clarify the figure or the composition.All measurementsare given in meters.One furthernote. Since references to the CVA appear constantly, it was necessaryto devise a formula for citing it that would be both brief and intelligible. Thus: CVA, Boston 1 [USA 14], pl. 12 [624]:1 CVA, M.F.A. Boston, fascicule 1 [USA fascicule 14], pl. 12 [USA plate 624], fig. 1.
SHAPE STUDIES ONE-PIECE AMPHORAE 1-127
Figs. 1-3
Pls. 1-15
The one-piece amphora, distinguished primarily by the continuous curve of its profile between mouth and foot, is a favoriteshape among Attic black-figurepainters. Three varietiesare known in figured ware: Type A with flanged handles, flaring mouth, and foot in two degrees;Type B, the oldest of the three, with round handles, flaring mouth, and echinus foot; and Type C, like Type B but with torus mouth.1 In Attic black figure, Type B is preferred,and all but one of the Agora fragments, even the later ones, come from amphorae Type B, rather than the larger and showier Type A, which was probably introducedinto the repertoryof Attic shapes by Exekias during the late third quarter of the 6th century B.C.2Type A seems to have been intendedmainly for export.3 The only certainamphoraType A fromthe Agora is 1934 (PI. 123), a late 6th-centuryone with the figureddecorationnot preserved,and no example of the rare Type C has been identifiedamong the black-figuredfragments,although this variety appears in plain black.4 The largest number of one-piece amphoraefrom the Agora date in the secondand third quarters of the 6th century B.C., the years when the shape enjoys its greatest popularity. The earliest onepiece amphoraehave separate subjectson the neck and body, a decorativearrangementthat is soon given up in favorof one with the figuresset in panels, a schemewhich becomesthe normalone from the beginning of the 6th century on. 117-119 (Pls. 13-15), three large fragmentaryamphorae, which preservespecial schemesof decoration,help to roundout the picture. 120-127 (P1. 15) come from one-piece amphoraeof normal size, but they do not preserveenough of the figures for us to be certain of the systems of decoration. The three types were distinguished by Beazley, JHS 42, 1922, pp. 70-71. Cf., also, Beazley, AK 4, 1961, pp. 49-50; R. Lullies, AK 7, 1964, pp. 85-88, especially for Type B. For Types B and C, cf. Mommsen, Affecter,pp. 48-51. 2 Vatican 344 (ABV 145, 13; Paralip. 60, 13) is still the earliest example of the canonicaltype. Its antecedentsare to be found in Group E: Louvre F 53 (ABV 136, 49; Paralip. 55, 49), which is Type B except for its flaring foot; Berlin 1699 (ABV 136, 53; Paralip. 55, 53), Berlin 1698 (ABV 136, 54), London, B.M. B 205 (ABV 136, 55), and London, B.M. B 194 (ABV 135, 56; Paralip. 55, 56), which have Type A handles and a flaring foot without base fillet; Kassel T. 384 (ABV 137, 57; Paralip. 55, 57; CVA, Kassel 1 [Germany35], pls. 21 [1701]:1, 22 [1702]) and Budapest 9132 (ABV 137, 58; Paralip. 55, 58), which have an echinus foot. Canonicalamphoraeof Type A are usually well over 0.50 m. in height, thus considerably larger than most amphorae Type B, although exceptions in this variety exist, e.g., Berlin, inv. no. 4823 by the Painter of Acropolis606: 0.80 m. (ABV 81, 4; Paralip. 30, 4; CVA, Berlin 5 [Germany45], pls. 1 [2146]:2,
3 [2148]); New York, M.M.A. 51.11.3, related to Lydos: 0.557 m. (ABV 119, II, 6; Paralip. 48, II, 6); Boston, M.F.A. 89.257, by the Swing Painter: 0.52 m. (ABV 304, 2; CVA, Boston 1 [USA 14], pl. 3 [625]; Bohr, Schaukelmaler,pl. 2); New York, M.M.A. 12.198.4, the Bateman Group: 0.555 m. (ABV 258, 5; Paralip. 114, 5); and New York, M.M.A. 41.85, the Group of Toronto 305: 0.542 m. (ABV283, 13 and 391, 1; Paralip. 124, 13). 3 Among the attributed amphorae Type A with known provenances,very few come from Greeceand the East. Four are known to us, none from Athens. One, by the Amasis Painter, is from Samos (ABV 151, 18; Paralip. 63, 18; Bothmer, Amasis Painter, p. 109, fig. 67); another, in the mannerof the Antimenes Painter, was found on Cyprus (ABV 279, 48); and two come from Kamiros, London, B.M. B 197 by the Painter of Berlin 1686 (ABV 296, 1; Paralip. 128, 1) and Rhodes 14093 by the Swing Painter (ABV 307, 57; Bohr, Schaukelmaler, pls. 79, 80). The last two are close in date and may even have been part of the same shipment. 4 AgoraXII, p. 48.
ONE-PIECE AMPHORAE DECORATED
ON NECK AND BODY; FIGURES NOT SET IN PANELS
5 1-6
P1. 1
A small number of early one-piece amphoraeare decoratedaccordingto the principleestablished for neck-amphorae,the large area of figured or ornamental decorationon the neck being clearly separatedfrom the figures on the body and the body decorationnot framedat the sides. On the onepiece amphorae, one or two lines of glaze divide neck from body decoration.The area below the main body decorationmay be supplementedby an animal frieze or a pattern and by rays above the foot, or it may be left in plain black glaze. The earliest known examples are four early works by the Nettos Painter that have figures on both neck and body.51 (PI. 1) is near the Nettos Painter in style, 2 is not far from him, and both were probably decoratedas those by the painter himself. Slightly later than these is 3 (P1. 1), which has a frieze of rosettes on the neck with the body decoration ending at about the level of the handle root, comparableto the lower limit of the earliestAttic blackfigured panels (cf. below, p. 6). Later examples of these amphorae,such as the one by the Gorgon Painter, Louvre E 817,6 have an ornamentalpatternon the neck and figureddecorationon the body that continues well below the maximum diameter. This manner of decoratingthe one-piece amphora disappears by the second quarter of the 6th century. 6 (P1. 1) by Sophilos with its three animal friezes on the body and the lotus-palmettefestoonon the neck is one of the latest examples,7 and it looks ahead to the type of ovoid neck-amphorawith the figureddecorationon the body set in friezes (below, pp. 9-10). PANEL AMPHORAE 7-116
Pis. 2-12
In Attic black figure, the one-piece amphoramost often has the figureddecorationset in reserved panels, and in the Agora, the panel amphora is one of the most numerousof the large shapes. This variety does not develop from the one-piece amphora with separate areas of decorationon the neck and body, for the type exists already in the first half of the 7th century B.C., one of the earliest examples being one from the Agora that has ornamentaldecorationin a small panel set high on the vase.8It is not certain who was the first to decorateAttic potterywith figuredpanels, but examples are known by the third quarter of the 7th centuryB.C., and aroundAthens the idea may have begun with the Ram-jug Painter who decorated each of two olpai with a lion protome set in a broad panel.9 One of the earliest Attic black-figured panel amphorae is the Siren amphora, which has been linked with the Nettos Painter, although not firmly attributedto him.10With its exceptionally 5Aigina 565 (ABV 3, 1; Paralip. 1, 1); London, B.M. 1874.4-10.1, formerlyA 1531 (ABV3, 2; Paralip. 2, 2); Eleusis Z 21 (ABV 679, 2 bis; Paralip. 2, 3); Kerameikos,inv. no. 658 (AB V 3; Paralip. 1; KerameikosVI, ii, no. 116 and pls. 89-91; for the attribution, cf. footnote 11 below, p. 74). The fragment recently acquired by the J. Paul Getty Museum is from an amphora probably decorated according to this scheme (81.AE.114.30: J. Frel, "Three Notes on Attic Black Figure in Malibu," Greek Vases in the J. Paul Getty Museum 1, 1983, p. 36, figs. 1, 2). One may also mention the one-piece amphora in Berlin (1961.7), decoratedon one side only (neck:confronted panthers; body: confronted griffins), the reverse being plain black glaze (CVA, Berlin 5 [Germany 45], pls. 1 [2146]:1, 2 [2147]). This amphora has been comparedwith the work of the Nettos Painter by F. Brommer (Jahr. Berl. Museen 4, 1962, pp. 1-16), but he rightly concludesthat it is not by this artist. A further argument is the stiff symmetrical composition, a decorativearrangementnot found on the four amphoraeby the painter himself. This type of amphora and its decorationhave been discussedbriefly by I. Scheibler (JdI 76, 1981, pp. 40-42) and by K. Kubler (KerameikosVI, ii, pp. 153-156).
6 ABV
9, 7; Paralip. 6, 7. 7 Later still are the versions by the Polos Painter (ABV 44, 1-4) and Berlin 31139 by the Prometheus Painter (CVA, Berlin 5 [Germany 45], pi. 4 [2149]:1, 2). Boardman(JHS 95, 1975, p. 7) suggests that the figured frieze above the panel on Reggio 4001 in the manner of Exekias (ABV 147, 6; Paralip. 61, 6) may have extended to the mouth of the vase. 8 P 6463 (Agora VIII, p. 32, no. 21, pl. 2); also P 12582 (AgoraVIII, p. 89, no. 514, pl. 82) and the amphora found on Piraeus Street (AeAT 17, 1961/62 [1963], pl. 26:a). 9 So, Karouzou,Amasis Painter, p. 42; see also, AgoraVIII, no. 578 (here, 7) and p. 24. It is surely no accidentthat the idea of a decorativepanel surroundedby black glaze was first tried out on one-piece amphorae and olpai, for their continuouscurvedshapes lend themselveswell to this schemeof decoration, as rightly emphasized by Scheibler (JdI 76, 1961, pp. 32-33). Recently, Sarah Morris has argued that the Black and White Style of Protoattic pottery, to which the work of the Ram-jug Painter belongs, is the productof an Aeginetanworkshop,not a mainland one (The Black and White Style, New Haven 1984). 10Athens, N.M. 221 (ABV 6: "The pictures are already in
6
SHAPE STUDIES
broad panels framed very near the handles, it stands a little apart from the other early panel amphorae, which have somewhat small panels often placed rather high on the vase emphasizing the incurvingcontourof the shoulderand neck, e.g. 10, 14, 17 (Pls. 2, 3). On these, the pictorialarea is very limited, filling ornament is sparse or omitted altogether, and there is no pattern above the panel. The appearance is rather somber and subdued. The subjects in these early black-figured panels are single or confrontedanimals and monsters, or else they are protomes, which may be human, subhuman, or animal. 7-10 are the examples from the Agora. 8 (PI. 2) gives some of the forepartsof an animal, surely one of a confrontedpair; 7 (PI. 2) is the earliest preservedAttic blackfigured example of a human head in the panel of an amphora;tIthe odd beardedhead terminating in a truncatedsnaky form on 10 (P1.2) still awaits an interpretation. The Gorgon Painter is the first Attic black-figurepainter to favor decorationset in panels and to explore the possibilities of this scheme of decoration,particularlyon his one-piece amphoraeand olpai.'2 12 (PI. 2), attributedhere, is the only panel amphoraby him found in the Agora, but another, 11 (PI. 2), is in his manner. During the first quarter of the 6th century, the panel becomes considerablywider, and it often extends below the maximumdiameterof the body, which results in a more unified appearanceof shape and decoration,e.g. 12, 33 (PI. 4), 34 (PI. 5). In this period, an ornamentalfrieze may appear abovethe panel, and there are often rays abovethe foot, two features that become standard.'3The ornament may be simple rosettes or a more intricate lotus-palmette pattern, either a chain or a festoon, e.g. 34. 4 In the panels new subjectsare introduced,perhaps by the Gorgon Painter, in particularan animal moving to right (not simply standingstill) and a single horseman on a galloping mount.1511 and 12, 24 (PI. 3), and 29 (PI. 4) are the earliest examples from the Agora. The largest numberof panel amphoraein the Agora (35-96) come fromthe middledecadesof the 6th century, i.e., 560-530/20 B.C., the period when the shape is most popular, particularlyin the work of Lydos and his companion, the Painter of Louvre F 6 (49, 50, 54-59: Pls. 6-8), also the painters of Group E (74: PI. 9), and the Swing Painter (77: PI. 9). During these decades,the onepiece amphora tends to become much taller in proportionto its width, although there is considerable variationfrom potterto potter. The size of the panel is governedby the proportionsof the vase, and there are usually areas of contrastingblack surroundingit. 47 (P1.6) with its very broadpanels that reach almost to the handles is an exception. In additionto the lotus-palmettefestoonor chain panels";Paralip. 6). J. M. Cook (BSA 35, 1934/35, pp. 199200), followed by Karouzou ('Avayvpovvros, pp. 129 and 134), thought that this amphora might be an early work of the Nettos Painter, but this attributiondoes not seem quite convincing. To be sure, there are similarities, but the drawing is less skillful and somewhat sketchycomparedwith the firm drawing of the painter himself. Equally unconvincingis the attribution of 7 (P1.2) to the Nettos Painter, and the Woman Head amphora in Munich also ought to be kept apart (ABV 16, 2; Paralip. 9, 2), although H. Diepolder (Festschriftfur Carl Weickert, Berlin 1955, pp. 111-120) and Karouzou ('AvayvpoVvTos!, p. 135, no. 23) thought it, too, might be by the Nettos Painter. Panels may also be seen on the neck-amphoraeby the Lion Painter and the Bellerophon Painter. These are very broad, reaching almost to the handles. Lion Painter: Athens, N.M. 16393 (ABV 2, 1); Athens, N.M. 16392 (ABV 2, 2); Bellerophon Painter: Athens, N.M. 16389 (ABV 2, -, 1); Athens, N.M. 16391 (ABV 2, -, 2; Paralip. 1, 2). Add also, Athens, N.M. 16380, an unpublishedone that bears resemblancesto the work of the Nettos Painter: on the neck: A, woman's head in outline; B, the like; on the body:A, boar; B, the like. 11See catalogue entry below.
12 For a panel neck-amphora by the Gorgon Painter, cf. Richmond62.1.10, attributedby Bothmer (H. C. T. Reed and P. Near, AncientArt in the VirginiaMuseum, Richmond1973, no. 86, wrongly called Corinthian). 13 Ornamental friezes appear at about the same time on olpai (see below, p. 40). 14Rosettes: e.g., Louvre C 10620 by the Gorgon Painter (ABV 9, 9; Paralip. 7, 9) and Louvre CA 3327 in his manner (ABV 9, 8; Paralip. 7, 8; 8). Compare also the contemporary amphora in Leipzig, T 3299 (CVA, Leipzig 2 [DDR 2], pl. 1 [62]:1, 2) that looks like a panel amphora except for the lack of side frames:on each side is a lion to right; above, five rosettes. The earliestfestoonabovethe panel of an amphorais very likely the one by Sophilos on the Jena amphora (ABV 39, 7; Paralip. 18, 7; Baklr, Sophilos, pls. 11, 12). An oddity is the lotus-palmette chain abovethe panel of a Horse-head amphorafound in Athens, Ephoria F, no. 1144 (M. Piccozzi, Studi Misc. XVIII, Rome 1971, p. 15, no. 9), for these panels are normallywithout ornament. Here, the thick units are similar to the Gorgon Painter's use of this ornament on his namepiece (ABV 8, 1; Paralip. 6, 1).
15 See
below, p. 76.
NECK-AMPHORAE
7
above the panel, other types of ornamentappear, in particularivy leaves (e.g. 55 and 57: PI. 7) and hanging lotus buds (e.g. 69: P1. 8, 77, 81). Most of the Agora panel amphoraeare too fragmentary to illustrate the entire shape very well, and not many are attributed,but three of them preserveodd or unusual ornamental features that deserve mention. The widely spaced units of the lotus-palmette festoon on 76 (PI. 9) are uncommonand comparebest with some examples in the Princeton Group. The palmette chain without lotuses on 41 (PI. 5) is an odd ornamentbest paralleled in the work of the St. Audries Painter. 96 (PI. 11) has a net pattern above the panel, an ornamentthat is more at home above the panels of other shapes, e.g. kalpides (657, 658 and 663, 664: Pls. 62, 63), olpai (687-689: Pls. 66, 67), or choes (755-757: PI. 72) than it is on amphorae. From 530 B.C.on, the best of the black-figuredpanel amphorae are of the larger and more impressive Type A rather than Type B. Exekias may have introducedthe new type, for the earliest canonical example is by him, the famous one in the Vatican with the double signature.l6 1934 (PI. 123) is the only certain amphora Type A from the Agora, but since we cannotbe sure whether the figured decorationwas in black figure or in red figure, we have included it in the small miscellaneous category at the end of this chapter (p. 71). The rest of the Agora panel amphorae are too fragmentaryto determinethe type they are, for none preservestracesof a flangedhandle or a foot in two degrees, and the size of each comparedwith the thicknessof its wall suggests a vase of modest proportions. SPECIAL ONE-PIECE AMPHORAE
117-119
Pls. 13-15
Three one-piece amphorae stand somewhat apart from those with separate decorationon body and neck and from those with panels. 117 (P1. 13) by the Nettos Painter is the earliest of the three, and it shows a single subjectextending over both neck and body without framing ornament at the sides,17the only Attic black-figuredexample to do so for certain.18The two fragments118 (PI. 14) and 119 (PI. 15) come from large amphoraewith the decorationprobablyset in several friezes, an unusual arrangementof both figures and ornament.They could perhaps be includedwith the onepiece amphorae discussed above that are decoratedaccordingto the principle establishedfor neckamphorae (1-6), but because so little of the decorationremains, it is difficultto be sure of the complete arrangement, and it is best to keep them apart. 118 is decoratedon one side only and very likely was a tomb marker.19 NECK-AMPHORAE 128-225
Figs. 4-6
Pls. 16-26
The neck-amphorais distinguishedfrom the one-piece amphorachiefly by having its neck sharply set off from its shoulderand body.' In Attic black figure, neck-amphoraeare very common,particularly in the second half of the 6th century. In the late 7th and early 6th centuries, they are outnumberedby one-piece amphoraeand large kraters,but by about 560 B.C. they are being produced 16Cf. footnote 2
above, p. 4. area given to the figured decoration,the Siren amphora,Athens, N.M. 221 (ABV6; Paralip. 6), is similar to 117 (PI. 13), except that the figure on each side is set in a very broad panel, the sides of which appear next to the handles. 18 120, 121, and 123 (PI. 15) may come from amphoraedecorated as 117, but too little is preservedto be certain. 19 For Protoattic and earlier black-figured amphorae and 17 In the amount of
kraters used as grave markers, cf. Miiller, Liwen und Mischwesen, pp. 112-117; for some decoratedon one side only, cf. ibid., p. 116. 117 was probablyalso a grave marker. 'Cf. Agora XII, p. 47, note 1; also K. Stahler, JOAI 49, 1968-1971, pp. 87-97; Mommsen, Affecter,pp. 8-11.
SHAPE STUDIES
8
in quantity by various workshops, and many painters, such as those of the Tyrrhenian Group, specialize in the shape. Neck-amphorae come in more varieties of shape and size than any other type of pot in the Attic repertory,and their schemesof decorationalso vary considerably.The neckamphorae from the Agora, although for the most part quite fragmentary,illustrate this range in both size and shape, as well as in decoration.2 LATE7TH CENTURY 128-137
P1. 16
The earliest Attic black-figured neck-amphoraeare large pots, close in size to their one-piece counterparts,and, like them, they probablyhad a funeraryuse. Some, such as the Piraeus Painter's amphoraor the namepieceof the Nettos Painter,3are decoratedwith figureson one side only.4This scheme of decorationis not found for certain among the Agora neck-amphorae,owing largely perhaps to their fragmentarystate, but it occurs on 118 (PI. 14), a large one-piece amphora of ca. 560-550 B.C. 136 (PI. 16), though decoratedon both sides, seems in size and style to be a direct ancestorof the Piraeus Painter's namepiece,5and 131 is probablyfrom a neck-amphoraof similar size.6 The handles providea natural frame for the decorationon the necks;on the bodies, the decoration may be set in panels like two from Vari by the BellerophonPainter,7or it may extend to the handle zone without limits, as it does on the Piraeus Painter's neck-amphora.8 NON-STANDARD: FIRST HALF OF THE 6TH CENTURY
138-164
Pls. 17-20
Early 6th-century black-figuredneck-amphoraeare smaller than those of the late 7th century. There are not very many examples, yet there is considerablevariety within the shape. Some have a flaring mouth, usually decoratedwith a frieze of geese on the sloping inner surface, with a molded verticalexterior that may have an ornamentalpattern.The handles are concave,the body is ovoid:9 141-144 and 147 (P1. 18) are good, though fragmentary,examples from the Agora. Sophilos may have introduceda long-neckedversionwith flaring mouth and foot that is very likely inspiredby the loutrophoros,'0 but it lacks mourning figures, hence it is not classed by Beazley as a loutrophoros but as a neck-amphora.140 (P1. 17) may come from such a neck-amphora,and perhaps also 152 and 153 (P1. 19), which are fragmentsof tall, slender necks decoratedwith animals. The version used by the Polos Painter is a variantof the one with groovedrim, concavehandles, and ovoidbody. 2
Among the varietiesof large size, the type with the figured decorationon the shoulder and body is not known among the neck-amphoraefrom the Agora. It is the type used by Exekias and by painters close to him, including some of Group E. It was also used by the Princeton Painter and his companion, the Painter of Berlin 1686, as well as by the Amasis Painter. Its period of productionis the third quarter of the 6th century B.C. It may be pure chance that all the attributed examples with known provenances come from sites outside Greece, mainly from Italy with exception of the fragmentaryone by Exekias in Narbonne (ABV 144, 2), but it may also indicate that this type of neck-amphorawas intendedmainly for export. Cf. also footnote 37 below, p. 12. 3 Athens, N.M. 353 (ABV 2; Paralip. 1, 1); Athens, N.M. 1002 (ABV4, 1; Paralip. 2, 6). 4 The Piraeus Painter's neck-amphorahas loopworkon the back, which recalls such well-known Protoatticexamples as the New York Nessos amphora and the Polyphemos amphora at Eleusis, which have mere ornament on the reverse. For
these and other vases used as grave markers, cf. footnote 19 above, p. 7. 5 R. Young, Hesperia, Suppl. II, Athens 1939, p. 119. 6 E. Brann, Hesperia 30, 1961, p. 361, H 9. 7 Cf. footnote 10 above, p. 6. 8AB V2;Paralip. 1,1. 9 The shape of the foot is less certain. Two examples, 141 (PI. 18) in the mannerof the Gorgon Painter and Florencen.n., by Sophilos (ABV38, 3; Baklr,Sophilos,pl. 25), do not preserve the foot. The namepieceof the Painter of Eleusis 767 (ABV 21, 1;Paralip. 13, 1) has a flaringfoot, and those by the Polos Painter (ABV 44, 5 and 9), which are later, have an echinus foot. 10Athens, N.M. 991 (ABV 38, 1; Bakir, Sophilos, pls. 4951) and Warsaw 138537 (Paralip. 18, 1 bis; Baklr, Sophilos, pi. 71: here [p. 72] the vase is considereda workshop piece). Athens, N.M. 1036 (ABV 38, 2) is similar but with a shorter neck, ribbed rather than flat handles, and a more ovoid body. The namepiece of the Anagyrus Painter (ABV 20, 1) is a less able version of these.
NECK-AMPHORAE
9
It is squatter and less elegant than those of his predecessors.1 160 (Pl. 20) is his best preserved example from the Agora, but 161 is from the same type. Akin to these is the small one relatedto the Swan Group, 164 (P1. 20), the latest vase in this section. The decorationon early 6th-centuryblack-figuredneck-amphoraeas a rule is set in friezes,12 and 138 (PI. 17) in the manner of the Gorgon Painter may be the earliest example of this schemeon this shape. Normally the figures are animals and monsters,although human figures appear occasionally on the shoulder,13sometimes on the neck,14but rarely in a mythologicalnarrativecontext. 141 (P1. 18), with the figure of Aristaios on the neck, is the only Agora example of a mythologicalfigure on a neck-amphoraof this period. The scheme of decorationon 164 is odd:two zones of ornament on the neck, figures on the shoulder, the rest of the body black. Superficiallyit resemblesthose by the Camtar Painter discussedbelow. OVOID NECK-AMPHORAE
165-177
Pls. 20, 21
The type of neck-amphoracharacterizedby an ovoid body, echinus mouth and foot, and round handles is preferredduring the secondquarterof the 6th centuryB.C.15 One of the earliest examples is the fragmentary one in Oxford attributed to Sophilos,16which should belong to the late first quarter of the century. Since the four neck-amphoraepainted by Sophilos vary considerablyand since Sophilos was probably both a potter and a painter,17it is possible that he may have played a role in creatingthis type of neck-amphora.The generationafter Sophilossees the adventof painters who specialize in decorating ovoid neck-amphorae:the painters of the Tyrrhenian Group, the Camtar Painter, and the Painter of Vatican 309, a companion of Lydos. Three early works by Lydos are ovoid neck-amphorae,18and 172 (PI. 21) is perhaps by him. The decorationon the bodies of ovoid neck-amphoraemay appear in friezes, as it does on most Tyrrhenians,19or it may be set in panels like those by the Painter of Vatican 309 and by the Painter of Louvre F 6, another companionof Lydos. Lydos, himself, tried out both schemes.20A variant of the panel type is the one preferredby the Camtar Painter, which allows the figured decorationto reach the handles without a framing device and usually has no decorationbelow the figures, not even rays.21On this type, the decoration on the neck varies. Most frequently, it is ornamental, 1 Brussels R 219 (ABV 44, 5); Louvre E 814 (ABV 44, 9).
An exception is the neck-amphora in Richmond by the Gorgon Painter (footnote 12 above, p. 6). Here, the decoration on the body is in a panel complete with framing lines that is similar to those on contemporaryone-piece amphorae:A, panther to right; B, the like. On the neck:A, rosette;B, the like. Just below the panel, three lines that continue round the vase;below that three more lines. No rays above the foot. For others, cf. footnote 10 above, pp. 5-6. 13 Cf., e.g., two by Sophilos:Athens, N.M. 1036 (ABV38, 2; Baklr, Sophilos, pi. 30, fig. 53) and Florence n.n. (ABV 38, 3; Baklr, Sophilos, pl. 25). 14 The best example is the namepieceof the Painter of Eleusis 767 (ABV 21, 1; Paralip. 13, 1). 15The ovoid neck-amphorasurvives in the work of the Affecter who fashioned his own version that does not seem to depend upon the type used by his precedessors.Cf. Mommsen, Affecter, pp. 8-9. An odd late example is Boston, M.F.A. 01.8052, which is like those by the Affecter in shape and ornamental decoration,but its figureddecorationis in the mannerof 12
the LysippidesPainter (ABV 242, 35 and 259, 26; Paralip. 110; Mommsen, Affecter,p. 109, no. 102). 16Oxford G.128.20 (ABV 38, 4; Baklr, Sophilos, pl. 65, fig. 127). 17Cf. Athens, N.M. 15499 (ABV 39, 16; Paralip. 18, 16; Baklr, Sophilos, pi. 6, fig. 10), which very likely has a double signature. Cf. footnote 53 below, p. 79 and also Beazley, Development, pp. 18-19. Without a potter'ssignature, it is always difficultto be certainwho shaped a vase, but the varietyof shapes decoratedby Sophilos suggests that he took considerable interest in shapes as well as decoration. 18 ABV 110, 30-32. 19For exceptions,cf. Mommsen, Affecter,p. 8, note 30. 20 Friezes: Florence 70995 (ABV 110, 32; Paralip. 44, 32; Tiverios, pls. 22, 23). Panels: Louvre E 868 (ABV 110, 30; Tiverios, pl. 3) and Louvre C 10634 (ABV 110, 31; Paralip. 44, 31; Tiverios, pls. 10, 11:a). 21 The examples are given by Mommsen (Affecter,p. 8, note 30). Exceptions to this scheme of decorationin the work of the Camtar Painter are Louvre C 10521 (ABV 84, 4; Paralip. 31,
SHAPE STUDIES
10
usually a lotus-palmette cross (166: PI. 20; 171), occasionally a festoon or, more rarely, a star pattern.22Neither of these last two appearsamong the preservedovoidsin the Agora. Rare, too, are ovoids with animals on the necks (175: PI. 21).23 There are not too many ovoid neck-amphorae from the Agora, but the two main systemsof body decoration,panels and friezes, are representedby fragmentaryexamples. This section includes all the ovoid neck-amphoraethat cannot be shown with certainty to come from the panel type. With exception of the neck-amphoraeof Panathenaic shape, all panel neck-amphorae,whether ovoid or not, are presentedin the next section as a separate variant. PANEL NECK-AMPHORAE
178-182
Pls. 21, 22
Neck-amphoraewith their decorationset in very broad panels, known in late 7th-centuryAttic black figure and on the early 6th-century ovoid panel neck-amphorain Richmond, have already been noted (p. 6, footnotes 10 and 12). These few are, however, exceptional for their time. In the second quarter of the 6th century, many ovoid neck-amphoraeare decoratedwith panels, a tongue pattern appears above the panel at the junction with the neck, and on the neck itself there is a male head to left, usually between wavy lines. Ovoid neck-amphoraeby the Painter of Vatican 309, who prefers this type of neck-amphora,and the Painter of Louvre F 6 are decoratedin this manner. Earlier painters of ovoid panel neck-amphoraeoccasionallyglaze the area between the top of the panel and the ring, and they usually omit the wavy lines on the neck.24179 (P1.21) was decorated accordingto this principle and perhaps also 180 (PI. 21), for there are no lines next to the face, but without some of the shoulderof the vessel it is difficultto be certain. 178 (PI. 21) is unusual, for the head faces to right.25Sometimesthe neck is decoratedwith a lotus-palmettecross,and at least once during the secondquarter of the century, it was left black.26 After the middle of the 6th century,it becomesunusual for neck-amphoraeto have the decoration set in panels. 181 (PI. 22) with its squat proportions,rilled mouth, and torus foot with groove is a special example that seems to have no exact parallel. 182 (Pl. 22) is probablya neck-amphoraof standardshape. NECK-AMPHORAEOF PANATHENAICSHAPE 183-188
Pls. 22, 23
These neck-amphoraetake their shape from the prize vase, but their schemes of decorationand 4), band of lotus-palmette festoon below the figures; Laon 371017 (Paralip. 31, 9), frieze of upright lotuses and below that, animals. 22 For the festoon, cf., e.g., most of the ovoids by the Camtar Painter. For the much rarer star pattern, cf., e.g., Madrid 10929 (CVA, Madrid 1 [Spain 1], pl. 1 [17]:6); New York, M.M.A. L.1985.5. 23 Cf. also the following: Tiibingen D 7 (S./715), by the Camtar Painter (Paralip. 31, 8; CVA, Tiibingen 2 [Germany 44], pl. 34 [2135]); Florence 70995 by Lydos (ABV 110, 32; Paralip. 44, 32; Tiverios, pls. 22, 23); and an unattributedexample in the Bareiss Collection once on loan to the Metropolitan Museum (L.69.11.7) that is decoratedwith figureson the neck only:A, panther;B, the like; tongue patternon shoulderatjunction with neck;rays abovefoot. Perhapsadd also, the ovoidneckamphora that has a horse protomewith forelegs in each panel and a dolphin to left on the neck (Paralip. 10; Moon, Midwestern Collections,Chicago 1979, pp. 48-50, no. 29). Later examples of this system of decoration,but not necessarilyon ovoids, are given by H. Hoffmann, CVA, Boston 1 [USA 14], pp. 14-15. Cf. also the brief discussionby Mommsen, Affecter,p. 31.
24Glaze between top of panel and ring: New York,M.M.A. 56.171.16 by the Painter of London B 76 (ABV 87, 14;Paralip. 32, 14; CVA, New York 4 [USA 16], pl. 12 [740]:1, 2); Munich 1449, unattributed (CVA, Munich 7 [Germany 32], pl. 328 [1542]:3,4). No lines next to head on neck:New York, M.M.A. 56.171.16; Geneva MF 153 by the Painter of Acropolis 606 (ABV 81, 6; CVA, Geneva 2 [Switz. 3], pl. 52 [108]:1-4); one near him, Munich 1447 (ABV 81, 1; Paralip. 30, 1; CVA, Munich 7 [Germany 32], pl. 328 [1542]:1, 2); Munich 1448, near the Painter of London B 76 (ABV 88; CVA, Munich 7 [Germany 32], pl. 329 [1543]:2, 3) and Florence 3770 near the Painter of Vatican 309 (ABV 122, 1). Munich 1448 is unusual in that the panel reaches to the ring at the junction of the neck, as it does on the Richmondneck-amphora,p. 6 abovewith footnote 12 and footnote 12 above, p. 9). 25 Cf. Geneva MF 153 by the Painter of Acropolis 606 (ABV 81, 6; CVA, Geneva 2 [Switz. 3], pl. 52 [108]:1-4) and one near him, Munich 1447 (ABV81, 1; Paralip. 30, 1; CVA, Munich 7 [Germany32], pl. 328 [1542]:1, 2). 26New York, M.M.A. 06.1021.29, unattributed (CVA, New York 4 [USA 16], pl. 12 [740]:3, 4).
NECK-AMPHORAE
11
their subjects are, as a rule, very different. Not many examples are known, and nearly all are productsof the second half of the 6th century. The earliest preservedexample, Oxford 1920.107,27 belongs, however, to the Burgon Group, which producedthe earliest known prize vase.28On the Oxford piece, the figures (the Return of Hephaistos) appear on the shoulderonly, the one example decoratedin this manner. On its neck is the rare star pattern. Examples of these neck-amphorae after the middle of the century may show the figured decorationcontinuing round the vase,29or it may be set in the more conventionalpanels,30184, 185, and 188 (P1. 23) being certain panel examples from the Agora. The other three, 183 (P1.22), 186, and 187 (P1.22), do not preserveany of the edge of the panel, so one may not be certain of the system of decoration.Normally, there is a tongue pattern at the junction with the neck and on the neck, a lotus-palmette chain. On those where the figured decorationcontinues round the vase, an ornamentalfrieze often appears below the figure zone,31as is customaryon standardneck-amphoraeof the time. The subjectsare usually mythologicalones, occasionallyunidentifiednarratives.A few vases show Athena as she appearson true Panathenaics but with accompanyingfigures, instead of alone.32188 comes from such a vase; 183 is more likely from a Gigantomachy,as Beazley suggested,33especially since Athena strides to right, not to left. The other Agora examples, 184-187, are too fragmentaryto allow a precise interpretation of the subjectmatter. Although no painter may be said to have specialized in decorating neck-amphoraeof Panathenaic shape that are not true Panathenaics,three are by the Princeton Painter and two others by his colleague, the Swing Painter;34183 is close to the Swing Painter, and 187 by the Rycroft Painter adds a new artist to those known to have decoratedthis rather rare type of neck-amphora.35 NECK-AMPHORAE STANDARD 189-205
Pls. 23, 24
From about 540-530 B.C.on, the favoritetype of neck-amphorahas a ratherovoid body, echinus mouth, triple handles, and torus foot. A configurationof palmettes and buds under each handle separates the figured decorationon the two sides, a tongue pattern on the shoulder at the junction with the neck outlines it above, and ornamentalbands, most frequentlyupright lotus buds that may or may not be accompaniedby the key pattern, terminateit below. The neck usually has the lotuspalmette chain. This is the main arrangement,but the sequence of patterns below the figures and 27
ABV 89, 2; Paralip. 33, 2. London, B.M. B 130 (ABV 89, 1; Paralip. 33, 1). 29 Tarquinia RC 1061 by Group E (Paralip. 56, 58 bis); London, B.M. B 208 in the manner of the Lysippides Painter (ABV 260, 29); Princeton 169 by the Princeton Painter (ABV 298, 6); Rhodes 12174 by the Bucci Painter (ABV315, 5); London, B.M. B 206 of the Leagros Group (ABV 369, 120; Paralip. 162, 120); five unattributedexamples, London, B.M. B 207 (CVA, London 4 [GB 5], pl. 47 [192]), Naples, inv. no. 81103 (CVA, Naples 1 [Italy 20], pl. 11 [955]), Boston, M.F.A. 01.8059 (CVA, Boston 1 [USA 14], pls. 36 [658], 38 [660]:1, 2), Munich 1437 (CVA, Munich 7 [Germany 32], pls. 339, 340 [1553, 1554]), and Munich 1438 (CVA, Munich 7 [Germany 32], pl. 341 [1555]). Although the figured decorationon these amphorae continues under the handles, only the one in Boston and the two in Munich show continuity of subject.The others have different subjectson each side. 30 Two by the Princeton Painter, New York, M.M.A. 53.11.1 (ABV298, 5; CVA, New York 4 [USA 16], pl. 13 [741]) and Swiss, private (Paralip. 130, 5 bis); two by the Swing Painter, Copenhagen 3672 (ABV 307, 58; Bohr, Schaukelmaler, pl. 88) and Brooklyn L.68.155.1 (ABV 307, 61; Paralip. 133, 61; Bohr, Schaukelmaler,pl. 172 and p. 110, no. P 5 where 28
the attributionis removedfromthe Swing Painterand said to be near the Princeton Painter); three by the Acheloos Painter, London, B.M. B 167 (ABV 382, 1; Paralip. 168, 1), Florence 3871 (ABV 383, 2), and Toledo 58.69 A (Paralip. 168, 2 bis; CVA, Toledo 1 [USA 17], pl. 14 [794]);two unattributedexamples, Liverpool56.19.27 (Gerhard,AV, pl. 66) and Vatican 356 (Albizzati, pl. 46). 31 Two, Boston, M.F.A. 01.8059 and London, B.M. B 208, have ornamentalfriezes similar to those on standardneck-amphorae. Two others, Naples, inv. no. 81103 and Rhodes 12174, have upright lotus buds with dots, and London,B.M. B 207 has the same but without the dots. Princeton 169 has a chain of upright lotuses and palmettes. The three by the Acheloos Painter have upright lotus buds with dots. 32 On Liverpool 56.19.27, she stridesto left toward Hermes, the two gods between columns surmountedby cocks. On New York, M.M.A. 53.11.1, she faces an aulos player;behind her is a young girl carryinga folded peplos on her head and holding a fillet in her right hand. For these, cf. footnote30 above. 33ABV693. 34 Cf. footnotes29 and 30 above. 35 For other artists, cf. footnotes27, 29, and 30 above.
12
SHAPE STUDIES
details of the handle ornamentvary a good bit from painterto painter and even within the work of a painter. Three early examples of this schemeof decorationappear on neck-amphoraeby Exekias,36 who perhaps played a role in determiningthe canonical scheme of late Archaic neck-amphorae.37 Unfortunately, the examples from the Agora are too fragmentaryto illustrate very well the basic characteristicsof this shape and the variationsin decoration. SMALL LATE NECK-AMPHORAE
206-225
Pls. 24-26
In details of shape, these neck-amphorae are by and large diminutive, often hastily worked counterpartsof standardneck-amphorae,and frequently they exhibit the same decorativescheme as well. 209 (PI. 24) is the best preservedexample from the Agora, and 215 (PI. 25) by the Edinburgh Painter is similar except for the up-and-down palmetteornamenton its neck, a patternthat frequently occurs on small late neck-amphoraeand may have been borrowedfrom the painters of lekythoiwho often used this ornamenton the shouldersof their vessels. The up-and-downpalmette ornament, instead of the normal lotus-bud frieze, below the figures on 223 (PI. 26) seems to be unparalleled on neck-amphorae. It appears, however, below the panel of the Rycroft Painter's amphoraType A in Worcester38and is well known on shoulderedhydriai. PANATHENAIC AMPHORAE 226-338
Pls. 26-34
Panathenaic amphoraetake their name from the festival held every four years in Athens, for they contained the oil that was awarded as prizes in the games.1 According to historical tradition, the Panathenaic festival was reorganized around 566 B.C., and at that time new competitions, especially athletic contests and perhaps also horse races, were introduced.2The earliest preserved 36
One of these, Berlin 1720 (ABV 143, 1; Paralip. 59, 1; Bothmer,AmasisPainter, p. 29, fig. 16), bearsthe doublesignature of Exekias and is probablyhis earliest preservedwork. The other two, London, B.M. B 209 (ABV 144, 8; Paralip. 60, 8) and Dublin 1921.97 (Paralip. 61; AJA 72, 1968, pl. 122:7), are later and belong with his signed neck-amphora in London (ABV 144, 7; Paralip. 60, 7). See footnote 37 below. 37There is considerablevariation in shape and in scheme of decorationamong the ten neck-amphoraeby Exekias (ABV 143144, 1-8; Paralip. 59-60, 1-8 and 1 bis;also 61). Stahler (JOAI 49, 1968-71, p. 93) has suggestedthat the shape of the late Archaic neck-amphorais based to a large extent on the potting of Exekias, but he does not make enough of a distinctionbetween the type with very broadshouldersoften decoratedwith figures, which enjoys a brief vogue in the third quarterof the 6th century, and the more slender ovoid type, which becomes the standard shape in the late 6th centuryB.c. Exekias signs both types as potter, Berlin 1720 and London, B.M. B 210, and on four unsigned neck-amphoraeincludes figureson the shoulder:Narbonne (ABV 144, 2); New York, M.M.A. 17.230.14 (ABV 144, 3; Paralip. 59, 3; CVA, New York 4 [USA 16], pls. 16-19 [744747]); Boston, M.F.A. 89.273 (ABV 144, 4; Paralip. 59, 4; CVA, Boston 1 [USA 14], pls. 29-32 [651-654]); and Munich 1470 (ABV 144, 6; CVA, Munich 7 [Germany 32], pls. 351354 [1565-1568]). The configurationof palmettes and lotuses appears under each handle of the early signed neck-amphorain Berlin (1720). London, B.M. B 210, his other signed neck-
amphora,is a reworkingof the shape and becauseof its slender proportions is closer to the late 6th-century type than to its predecessors.Its ornamentaldecoration,but for the handle configuration which consists of elegantly drawn spirals, is that of the normal scheme. London, B.M. B 209 and Dublin 1921.97, both contemporarywith London, B.M. B 210, are particularly close to the standardtype in shape and ornament. 38 Paralip. 148, 5 bis; Buitron, New England Collections, pp. 44-45, no. 17. The literatureon Panathenaicamphoraeis vast. Cf., particularly, Beazley, Development, chap. VIII (with bibliography); also, D. A. Amyx, Hesperia 27, 1958, pp. 178-186 (the listings of Panathenaicamphoraein the Attic stelai); Frel, PPA; AEAr 29, 1974 [1977], pp. 142M. Tiverios, <
PANATHENAIC AMPHORAE
13
Panathenaic amphorae may be stylistically placed so soon after this date that it is tempting to suggest that they were given as prizes when the games were reorganized.3The size of the prize vases from the middle of the 6th centuryB.C. to the middle of the 5th seems to vary between 0.60 and 0.65 m. in height and between 0.40 and 0.45 m. in width.4The amount of oil that they held is more difficult to calculate since so few are well enough preserved to allow a test to be made, but the capacities for six of them range from 38 to 39 liters when filled to the brim.5 The Panathenaic amphora resemblesa storage amphorawith a foot added. It has a very narrow neck and an echinus or flaring mouth that is flat on top, sometimes with glaze. The body tapers sharply to a narrow echinus or disk foot that is comparablein diameterto the width of the mouth. The shape has a very long history, beginning just before the middle of the 6th century B.C. and lasting until the 4th century after Christ,6but only those of the 6th to 4th centuriesB.C. will be discussed here.7 The earliest Panathenaic amphorae are rather squat, heavy, very sturdy-looking vases. Gradually, they become taller and slimmer until they reach the exaggerated proportions characteristicof the shape in the late 5th and 4th centuriesB.C.By the middleof the third quarterof the 6th century B.C., the canonical scheme of decorationfor Panathenaicshas been established.It is a simple and unchangingone, owing no doubt to the officialpurpose for which the vase was intended. The figures are set in a panel on each side. A statue of Athena Polias appears on the obverse, placed between columns on all but the earliest Panathenaics.Here, the panel reachesto the tongue pattern on the shoulder at the junction with the neck. On the reverse,the scene representsthe event for which the vase was awarded as a prize. On this side, the panel is separated from the tongue pattern by a band of glaze. On the neck there is a lotus-palmettechain;abovethe foot are rays. The effect is neat, tidy, rather elegant and sober, especially before 450 B.C.8 Throughout the history of the shape, the figure of Athena retains its archaicstylistic character,and in the 4th centurybecomes quite mannered-looking.The drawing on the reverse,however, keeps abreastof the stylistic development of Greek sculpture and painting and thus offers a good criterionfor dating the vases. The Panathenaic amphorae from the Agora, though very fragmentary, provide a continuous series for the period under discussion. A significant number of them, 226-318 (Pls. 26-32), are prize vases. Included in this section are the following: all those with part of the prize inscriptionor an archon'sname; all those that may be dated after 450 B.C. when Panathenaicswere the only large Attic vases being decorated in the black-figure technique; 226 (PI. 26), which has a potter's 3
Beazley, Development, p. 88; Frel, PPA, p. 5. For undersizedbut prize Panathenaics,cf. M. Vos, "Some Notes on Panathenaic Amphorae," OudheidkundigeMededelingen uit het Rijksmuseumvan Oudhedente Leiden 62, 1981, pp. 33-46, esp. pp. 38-46. Add to the list on p. 40, these two: London, B.M. B 144 by the Swing Painter, which lacks the canonical prize inscriptionbut tells us that the horse of Dysniketos wins (ABV307, 59; Brandt[ActaNorvegiae 8, 1978, p. 12] calls this a non-prize vase; Bohr, Schaukelmaler,pls. 170, 171 and p. 110, no. P 4 where the vase is reattributedto near the Princeton Painter); Madrid 10901 (CVA, Madrid 1 [Spain 1], pl. 27 [45]:2). Our Panathenaic of the Robinson Group, 256 (PI. 29), was of prize size; other Panathenaics of the group are shorter than the standard prize vase (ABV 410, 2-4). Bothmer has suggested orally that these undersized but inscribedPanathenaics could be test vases instead of prizes awarded in the games. Vos offers another explanation, namely that in times of "waror financial stringency, the Festival was held on a more moderate scale with reducedprizes" (p. 42). M. Tiverios (loc. cit. [footnote 1 above, p. 12]) notes that the full-size uninscribed Panathenaics are far fewer in number than the inscribedvases and believes that they are competition 4
samples producedby the workshops eager to receive the commission (for a possible competitionsample from the Agora, cf. 274: PI. 31). Other possible explanations are that these vases are the result of a slight overrun or oversight in productionor even that a few extra amphorae were made as a precaution against breakage, and when they were not needed, they were simply fired uninscribedand sold off. Here are good examples of uninscribed,full-size vases: Boston, M.F.A. 01.8127 in the mannerof the Lysippides Painter, 0.60-0.62 m. (ABV 260, 28; CVA, Boston 1 [USA 14], pl. 56 [6781)and an unattributedone, London, B.M. B 135, 0.624 (CVA, London 1 [GB 1], pl. 3 [27]:2); also Liverpool 56.19.23 and Naples n.n. (Brandt, Acta Norvegiae 8, 1978, p. 12, f, g, and note 2: "Size like a prizeamphora",no measurementsgiven). 5 Cf. Agora X, p. 59. 6 Frel, PPA, p. 3 and passim. 7 For Hellenistic and Roman Panathenaics, cf. G. R. Edwards, Hesperia 26, 1957, pp. 320-349, with bibliography. 8 For a well-preservedexample to serve as an illustrationof the canonicalschemeof decoration,cf. the namepieceof the Euphiletos Painter, London, B.M. B 134 (ABV 322, 1; Paralip. 142,1).
14
SHAPE STUDIES
signature;229-236,239-243, and 246-253 (Pis. 27, 28) becauseof their large size and quality, and 228 (Pis. 26, 27) because of its size and subject,the Pentathlon.To estimate the original size of the vases from which these uninscribed fragments come, we used a tracing of the prize vase in New York by the Euphiletos Painter as a standardagainst which the comparablefigured part of each Agora fragment could be measured.9Some of these fragmentsmay indeed come from uninscribed vases of prize size, but given the paucity of this type,'0 we decidedto include in the prize category the fragmentsfrom full-size vases. The rest of the Agora Panathenaicsare groupedas follows:nonprize vase, 319 (PI. 32); uncertain if prize or non-prize vases, 320-337 (Pls. 33, 34). The latter group includes severalof good quality which may be undersizedbut inscribedvases, yet without the inscription it is best to keep them apart from the prize vases. Oddly enough, no obverse fragment may be matched with a reverse fragment for either the prize vases or the non-prize vases. In addition one fragment,338, comes from a miniature Panathenaic. PRIZE VASES 226-318
Pls. 26-32
In the 6th and 5th centuries B.C., the prize vase may be distinguished from the non-prize vase mainly by the inscriptionthat names it as one of the awards in the games. The inscriptionappears on the obverse,written verticallyfrom left to right on the right-handside of the left column, so that Athena faces it." The earliest preservedPanathenaic prize amphoraelack columns, and on these the inscriptionis placed next to the left side of the panel. The Burgon amphoraand the one in New York signed by the potter Nikias, who is otherwise unknown, are well-preservedexamples of this arrangement,12but 228 (Pls. 26, 27), which is surely a prize vase, may have been similar. Other early Panathenaics, besides the one in New York just mentioned, preserve the signature of the potter. A fragmentary Panathenaic from the Kerameikos,PA 443, gives in addition to the prize inscriptionthe name of the potter Hypereides and his patronymic,Androgenes.l3Frel has seen that 226 (PI. 26), which preservesthe verb and the last three letters of the patronymic,is by the same hand, and it too ought to be a prize vase, even though the prize inscriptionis not preserved.After 550 B.C.,the signaturesof the potters cease to appear on Panathenaicamphorae,probablybecause of their official use, although they reappearoccasionallymuch later, in the first half of the 4th century B.C. On the earliest Panathenaics,i.e. those before 550 B.C.,the ornamenton the neck is usually a lotus-palmettecross,not the lotus-palmettechain of the vases decoratedaccordingto the canonical 9 New York, M.M.A. 14.130.12 (ABV 322, 6; Paralip. 142,6). 10Cf. footnote4 above, 13. p. 1An exception is the prize vase by Lydos, Florence n.n. (ABV 110, 33; Tiverios, pls. 66:4, 67). Here, the inscription appears on the reverse above the chariot team. Normally the inscriptionis written in blackglaze, but on some early examples the letters are in added red:Agora P 10353 and P 10361, omitted from this study because they were found outside the Agora grid (cf. C. Boulter, Hesperia 32, 1963, pp. 113-137, esp. p. 135); London, B.M. B 130, the Burgon amphora(ABV 89, 1; Paralip. 33, 1); Oxford G 141.45 (CVA, Oxford 2 [GB 9], pl. 2 [403]:26); Karlsruhe 65.45 by Exekias (Paralip. 61, 8 bis); Acropolis 1086 (Graef, pl. 63). Add also an early fragmentary one in a Swiss private collection signed by Kallikles as potter. The prize inscriptionon this vase is not preserved. 12 London, B.M. B 130 (ABV 89, 1; Paralip. 33, 1); New York, M.M.A. 1978.11.13 (Notable Acquisitions, 7975-1979,
p. 14; Bothmer,Amasis Painter, p. 44, fig. 37). 13 Cf. Frel, PPA, p. 7, fig. 4, and p. 10. Here are some examof other kinds of inscriptionson 6th-centuryprize Panatheples naics: Acropolis 921: AIAYAA[OAPOMO...], retrograde (Graef, pl. 59); Athens, N.M. 2468 (CC 761): AIAYAOAPOMOEIMI (Athleticsin Ancient Greece,I. Douskou, ed., Athens 1976, p. 166, fig. 73); Halle 560: AN]APON (ABV 120, -); the namepieceof the Euphiletos Painter, London, B.M. B 134: EYIAETOE : KAAOt (ABV 322, 1; Paralip. 142, 1); London, B.M. B 144 by the Swing Painter: AYNEIKETY: HIIOE:: NIKAI (footnote4, p. 13 above);Munich 1451: ETAAION ANAPONNIKE (Brandt, Acta Norvegiae 8, 1978, p. 4, no. 26, and pl. 2:b); New York, M.M.A. 1978.11.13: NIKIAlEHOIElEN on A and ANAPONETAAIO[N] on B (Notable Acquisitions, 1975-1979, p. 14); Naples 112848: YIKEAOIEFPA4YEN (ABV 403, -, 1); Swiss, private: KALIKLE[?]EFOIE[IEN (footnote 11 above).
PANATHENAIC AMPHORAE
15
arrangement and type of embellishment. On the preservedexamples, there is no tongue pattern above either panel. On these early vases, Athena has both feet flat on the ground,as on 228 (PI. 26) and on 320 (P1.33), and her helmet is a simple cap with the crest attached,14not the more elaborate head coveringcompletewith cheekpiecesthat will appear later. Her garmentsare simple, although often decoratedwith ornamentalpatterns,15and the heads of the snakes on the aegis are frequently seen from above instead of in profile and intertwinedas is customarylater. The earliest known Panathenaic amphorawhere Athena appears between columns surmounted by cocks occurs on the prize vase in Karlsruhe attributedto Exekias, which is an early work of about 540 B.C.16 It is not certain if Exekias introducedthe conventionof placing Athena between columns on prize Panathenaic amphorae,but he may have. On the Karlsruhevase, oddly enough, the inscriptionappears behind Athena next to the column on the right, the only 6th-centuryexample where it does, although at least one later example is known, 279 (P1. 31). On the Karlsruhe Panathenaic, the lotus-palmette chain now decoratesthe neck, and there is a tongue pattern above the obversepanel. Here, for the first time, the heel of Athena's right foot is raised slightly, an innovation that is retained, although with time the heel is raised higher and higher until only the ball of the foot and the toes touch ground. This conventiongives Athena's pose new energy and a dramatic force. 236 and 237 (PI. 27) are the earliest prize vases from the Agora that show Athena between columns. 236 preservespart of the cock above the left column, and 237 gives the top of the shaft of the left column. Here, the prize inscription (the first two letters remain) is written in the normal place. This small fragment is later than Exekias' Panathenaic and ought to date between 530 and 510 B.C. Thus, it is contemporarywith the prize vases by the Euphiletos Painter who is the first artist known to have painted many Panathenaics.17Unfortunately, no Agora fragment of a prize vase may be attributedto the Euphiletos Painter, but of the next group of painters known to have decoratedmany Panathenaics (the EucharidesPainter, the KleophradesPainter, the Berlin Painter, and his pupil, the Achilles Painter18)251 (PI. 28) may be by the Kleophrades Painter, 250 (PI. 28) compareswith vases in his manner,252 (PI. 28) is by the Berlin Painter, and 254 (P1.29) is probably by the Achilles Painter. This brings us to the high Classical period, for which our only certain attributedexample is the rather well preservedone, 256 (Pl. 29), belonging to a painter of the Robinson Group. Part of the initial letter of the inscriptionconfirmsthis as a prize vase. 257 (PI. 29) may belong to this group. Many of the Panathenaics from this period are glazed on the inside, apparentlybecause the clay at that time was not sufficientlymaturedbefore it was used and thereforewas too porous.19254, 257, and 261-263 are examples from the Agora. The largest numberof prize Panathenaicsfrom the Agora belong to the 4th centuryB.C., 271-318 (Pls. 30-32). Most of them are very small fragments, but together they illustrate the various important innovationsthat appear during this time. The first is another inscription,which is written verticallynext to the shaft of the column on the right, usually on the left side of it to complementthe prize inscription next to the opposite column. This inscription names the archon who held office 4 Cf., e.g., the Burgon amphora, London, B.M. B 130 (ABV 89, 1; Paralip. 33, 1); Kerameikos PA 443 (Frel, PPA, p. 7, fig. 4); New York, M.M.A. 1978.11.13 (Notable Acquisitions, 1975-1979, p. 14); and Karlsruhe 65.45 by Exekias (Paralip. 61, 8 bis). 15 Cf. the examples given in footnote 14 above. 16 Karlsruhe 65.45 (Paralip. 61, 8 bis). 17 Beazley, Development, p. 91; ABV 322, 1-12; Paralip. 142. For a brief discussion of these vases, cf. most recently,
Brandt (Acta Norvegiae 8, 1978, pp. 13-14 and 20) who suggests that they may have been part of the lot commissionedfor the games of 522 B.C.. To these, Stenico (loc. cit. [footnote 1 above, p. 12]) adds anotheronce in the Milan Market. 18 Eucharides Painter: ABV 395-396, 1-20; Paralip. 173. KleophradesPainter:ABV 404, 1-16; Paralip. 175-176. Berlin Painter: ABV 408, 1-11; Paralip. 177. Achilles Painter: ABV 409, 1-5; Paralip. 177. 19 Frel, PPA, p. 9.
16
SHAPE STUDIES
during the year in which the oil was collectedthat would in the next year be awardedto victors in the games. Thus, these vases may be dated to a given year.20Archons' names appear on Panathenaics late in the first quarter of the 4th century B.C.,21 and the earliest sure example is 271 (Pl. 30) which names Pythias, 380/379, as archon. Other sure names are Kallimedes, 360/359 (286: PI. 31); Themistokles, 347/6 (289); and Demokleides, 316/5 (296: PI. 32). 273 (PI. 30) probablynames Phrasykleides,371/0, as archon,278 (PI. 31) either Charikleides,363/2, or Theophrastos, 340/9, and 290 (Pl. 31) gives either Aristodemos,352/1, or Pythodeles,336/5, probably the latter. 297 and 298 preserveonly part of the word, archon.During the secondquarterof the 4th century, the names of two potters of the same family, Bakchiosand Kittos, appear three times on Panathenaic amphorae. 274 (PI. 31) probably bore the potting signature, too, for it gives some of the prize inscriptionon the right side of the left column and on the left side of the same column, a X, which very likely is the last letter of Bakchiosor Kittos. An inscriptionon each side of one column seems paralleled only on the fragment in Istanbul signed by Bakchios,22and this may be an argumentin favor of restoringthe name on 274 as Bakchios. In the second quarter of the 4th century B.C., four new features appear, which accompanythe names of the archons. From now on, there are no rays above the foot, and the cocksthat surmount the columnsare replacedby small-scalefigures, which sometimesreproducesingle statues or statue groups.23Among the Agora fragments, 287 (Pl. 31) and 288 preserve small parts of Eirene and Ploutos, which reproducethe famous group by Kephisodotos.Another,302 (P1.32), gives part of a seatedAphroditewith Eros standingbeside her. Two others, 280 and 298, preservethe lower parts of figures, but the type may not be identified for certain. These small figures atop the columns change from year to year and thus may be understoodas "symbols"of the archonwho held officethe year the vase was made.24About the same time that the small figures replace the cocks, the artists begin to write the inscriptions columnlike, kionedon,that is with the letters horizontal instead of lengthwise. Up until this time, all inscriptionsare written from left to right. The earliest preserved kionedoninscriptionson Panathenaicsseem to be those that date from 367/6, the year that Polyzelos was archon. These vases belong to the Kittos Group.25The earliest kionedoninscriptionon an Agora Panathenaicoccursvery soon after this, on 286 (PI. 31), which preservessome of the name of Kallimedeswho was archon in 360/359. From this time on, all Panathenaicinscriptionsare written kionedon,and all those from the Agora that may be dated after 360 B.C. conformto this new convention. About 360 B.C., the figure of Athena is reversed,and from now on she stridesto right insteadof to left.26No one knows the reason for this change, but one of its results is that on many vases one no longer sees the device on her shield,27which in the case of certain earlier artists is an identifying symbol.28The earliest examples of the change in directionseem to be from the year that Kallimedes 20
Beazley, Development, pp. 96-97, with bibliography, The earliest example is Berlin 3980, which preservesthe letters ]E EPXEN (A. Smets, L'antiquite classique 5, 1936, p. 97, no. 98; Frel, RA, 1972, pp. 285-286 where Siisserot'sattributionto the archonshipof Philokles [392/1] is discussedand rejected). 22 Istanbul L. 3149 (ABV413, 2). 23 Beazley, Development, p. 97; Frel, PPA, pp. 19-21 and 23. 24 Beazley, Development,p. 97; Frel, PPA, p. 21. 25 London, B.M. B 604 (ABV 413), the namepiece,does not have a prize inscription and may have been a competition 21
sample (Beazley, Development, p. 97). For the Kittos Group, cf. ABV 413-414, 1-5; Paralip. 177. 26The Panathenaicsfrom Eretria that name Kallimedesas archon (360/359 B.c.) are the earliest preserved examples (P. Themelis, AAA 2, 1969, pp. 409-416 and Ir7jX, pp. 265271). 27 On some of the 4th-century B.c. Panathenaicsthat show Athena to right, her shield appears in profile so that part of the device may be seen. Cf., e.g., two from Eretria (footnote 26 above). 28 This is especially so with the Kleophrades Painter, who uses the deviceof a Pegasos, and with the Berlin Painter and his
PANATHENAIC AMPHORAE
17
was archon, 360/359.29 Oddly enough, the one fragmentfrom the Agora that preservespart of his name shows Athena to left, not to right, 286 (PI. 31). The earliest inscribedexample fromthe Agora that depicts Athena to right is 290 (PI. 31), which may date from either 352/1 or 336/5 depending upon how the archon's name is restored. If the later date is correct, as suggested in the Catalogue, then 276, which ought to date about 350 B.C.,is the earliest Agora example. From the middle of the 4th century B.C.,Athena wears a long shawl over her shouldersthat hangs down ending in a kind of swallowtail, and her skirt has very many narrow folds. No doubt, this style of dress is intendedto representan old-fashionedarchaistictype of Athena. No well-preservedexample of this type of dress occurson the Agora fragments,but 293 (PI. 32) gives a good idea of how close together the folds of the skirt are, and 295 is a good example of the shawl ending in a swallowtail. One last innovationremains to be discussed.In 403 B.C.,the Ionian alphabetwas officiallyadopted in Athens.30Three Panathenaic amphorae inscribed in this alphabet must date from just this time, for the shield device of Athena on all three representsthe bronze statues of the Tyrant Slayers by Kritios and Nesiotes and very likely symbolizes the restorationof democracy.31The use of the Ionian alphabet on Panathenaicsdoes not becomestandarduntil 336 B.C.,32but it is used frequently during the first half of the century for both the prize inscription,e.g. 265 and 274 (PI. 31), and the name of the archon, e.g. 278 and 286 (PI. 31). NON-PRIZEVASE 319
P1. 32
Only one certain example of a non-prize vase may be included in this section, a well-preserved amphora that gives all of both panels. Like many non-prize vases, it is rather small (only 0.277 m. in height), but its scheme of decorationconformsto that of the prize vase.33On the obverse,Athena strides to left between two columns surmountedby cocks;on the reverse, the event for which the vase would be awardedis depicted.Aboveeach panel is a tongue patternwith the customaryarea of black glaze on the reverse that separas the pattern from the panel. On the neck is the lotus-palmette chain; above the foot are rays. 319 is perhaps a little unusual, for its neck and foot are much larger in proportionto the body when comparedwith other Panathenaicamphorae,whether prize or non-prize vases. UNCERTAINIF PRIZEOR NON-PRIZEVASES 320-337
Pls. 33, 34
Most of these fragmentsbelong to the last years of the 6th centuryB.C.and to the first years of the 5th, thus to the period when both prize and non-prize Panathenaicsare produced.Therefore, in spite of the very high quality of some of these fragments, without part of the inscription it is impossible to determine if any is a prize vase. Two, 320 and 321 (P1. 33), may be dated around the middle of the th century B.Ofthe. se, 320 is worth mentioningfor it shows part of the very early type of Athena that has both feet flat on the ground,and it may be one of those Panathenaicamphorae that doesths not show the goddess between columns. Among e later fragments,one (325: P1.33) may be a new attributionto the Group of Copenhagen99. pupil, the Achilles Painter, who show the gorgoneion.Cf. Beazley, Development,pp. 94-95. 29 Cf. the two from Eretria (footnote 26 above, p. 16). 30 In the archonship of Eukleides. Cf. Price and Jeffery, OCD, p. 47. 31 London, B.M. B 605 (ABV 411, 4); Hildesheim 1254 (ABV 412, 1); Hildesheim 1253 (ABV 412, 2). Beazley, Development, p. 96. 32 Frel, PPA, p. 15.
33Their use was probablyan unofficialone. For general remarks about the small size of non-prize Panathenaicsand exceptionsthat are large, cf. Brandt,ActaNorvegiae 8, 1978, p. 3, note 1 and pp. 11-12; also, T. B. L. Webster,Potterand Patron in Classical Athens, London 1972, pp. 64 and 159-160, who suggests that these may have held the wine at the victor'ssubsequent celebration. In this discussion (p. 64) he also includes London, B.M. B 144 by the Swing Painter (footnotes4 and 13 above, pp. 13, 14).
SHAPE STUDIES
18
AMPHORAE, TYPE UNCERTAIN 339-366
Figs. 7-10
Pls. 34-36
A numberof amphorafragmentsdo not preserveenough of the curveof the wall or other characteristic featuresthat would identify the exact shape. Most of these may be dated in the late 7th century or early 6th. Among them, one (341: PI. 34) may have been very like the namepieceof the Piraeus Painter.1Some (343 and 344, 351 and 352, and 354 and 355: PI. 35) are from amphoraewith the figured decorationset in friezes. 358, with part of an inscriptionon the top side of the mouth, may come from a Panathenaicamphora, and 363 (P1.36) is perhaps a neck-amphora.
AMPHORA LIDS 367-372
P1.36
None of these six lids may be connectedwith any of the one-piece amphoraeor neck-amphoraein the Agora, and it is difficultto be certain which kind of amphoraeach covered.1Thus, they appear in this small separatesection.367-369 (P1.36) have figureddecorationand seem to have been without ornamentalpatterns, which is unusual. 370 has rays at the base of the knob and ivy round its brim, a combinationof patterns that is frequent on the lids of amphorae(cf. comparisonswith 370 in the Catalogue).
LOUTROPHOROI 373-389
Pls. 36-38
Both varietiesof loutrophoros,the hydria and the neck-amphora,are known as early as the late 8th century B.C., as attested by the work of the Analatos Painter.1Examples from the 7th century are few.2 The shape has a long history, but it was never exportedto Etruria. Most of the black-figured loutrophoroicome from Attic cemeteriesor from sacredplaces such as the Shrine of Nymphe on the South Slope of the Akropolis,which produceda significantquantity.3 In general, the loutrophorosis recognizedby its ovoid body and tall flaring neck. Early blackfiguredexamples have a flaring mouth and an echinus or flaring foot. Later ones may have a similar but more flaring mouth in one or two degrees,and the foot may also be flaring or in two degrees, often a vertical member above a torus. The two varieties are distinguished by the handles. The
'Athens, N.M. 353 (ABV2; Paralip. 1). 'For lids of amphorae, cf. Agora XII, p. 48, with bibliography. 'For early loutrophoroi,cf. E. Karydi, AthMitt 78, 1963, pp. 90-103 with bibliography and emphasis on examples from the Kerameikos. For the significance of the shape, cf.
R. Ginouves, Balaneutike: recherchessur le bain dans l'antiquitegrecque, Paris 1962, pp. 254-264. 2 Karydi,op. cit., p. 90. 3 T "Epyov, 1957, p. 11, fig. 9 (whence BCH 82, 1958, p. 664, fig. 11; J. Travlos, Pictorial Dictionary of Ancient Athens, London 1971, p. 363, fig. 466). This material is being prepared for publication by Charikleia KanellopoulouPapadopoulou.
LOUTROPHOROI
19
hydria type shares with the hydria the disposition of the handles:the tall, vertical strap handle in back reaches from the shoulder to the top of the neck, and two small, horizontalupright handles on the shouldercurve upward at each side. The neck-amphoratype has two strap handles, one on each side of the neck; they are often strengthenedby partly filling the space between them and the neck with a slab of clay decoratedwith an ornamental pattern. The handles themselves are frequently decoratedwith ornament. The hydria type is more commonin the first half of the 6th centuryB.C., the neck-amphorain the second half. In the Agora, both types are to be found, but only 373-376 (Pls. 36, 37) may be identifiedas hydriai and 377 (PI. 36) as a neck-amphora,for each preservesall or part of the handles. The rest are too fragmentaryto be certain of the type or even to give a good idea of the original appearance.Yet, if the later 6th-centurydate for most of these fragmentsmay be used as an indicatorof shape, then 378-389 (Pls. 37, 38) are probablyof the neck-amphoratype. In Attic black figure, the earliest attributedloutrophoroiare the unpublishedones by the Nettos Painter and the Gorgon Painter found in the Sanctuary of Nymphe. Slightly later are the very fragmentary hydria by the Ceramicus Painter and the well-preserved neck-amphoraby the KX Painter.4Two unattributedhydriai from the Shrine of Nymphe are contemporarywith these.5The same system of decorationis used for both types of loutrophoroi.On the body, there are friezes of animals and above the foot, a zone of rays; on the neck appear a processionof mournersand below them a frieze of animals or a band of ornament.6The earliest black-figuredloutrophoroifrom the Agora, 373-376 (Pls. 36, 37) are of the hydria type and are later than these (ca. 560-540 B.c.). Here, the friezes of animals on the body are given up in favor of a single zone with human figures. Also new is the tongue pattern on the shoulderat the junction with the neck, which is to be found on nearly all contemporaryand later examples.7The neck of 373 (P1. 36) is decoratedin the standard manner;the necks of 374 and 375 (Pls. 36, 37) have just a single row of mourners.From now on, human figures appear on the body as well as on the neck. From about 540 B.C.on, black-figuredloutrophoroiare taller and more slenderthan those of the earlier decades of the 6th century.8Frequently, a prothesis scene appears on the body, sometimes with a frieze of horsemenor animals below, sometimeswith a single band of ornament.When other themes appear, such as a wedded pair in a chariot, one cannot be certain whether such a scene is mythologicalor reflects daily life.9 On the necks, there are usually mourners,often with a frieze of animals or ornament at the junction with the shoulder.10White ornamenton black glaze becomes the customary manner of decoratingthe mouths and handles of later loutrophoroi,although it is 4 We
wish to thank Charikleia Kanellopoulou-Papadopoulou for allowing us to mention these earliest examples. Ceramicus Painter: New Jersey, private (Paralip. 12); KX Painter: Kerameikos,inv. no. 2865 (Paralip. 15). 5 To "Epyov,1957, p. 11, fig. 9: first row, secondfrom right and third row, center (whence BCH 82, 1958, p. 664, fig. 11; Travlos, op. cit. [footnote3 above, p. 18], p. 363, fig. 466). 6 Cf. Kerameikos,inv. no. 2865 by the KX Painter (Paralip. 15) and those in footnote 5 above. 7 Exception:Athens, once private (Karydi, op. cit. [footnote 1 above, p. 18], Beil. 52:3 and 53). 8 Compare, e.g., 373 (PI. 36) and 375 (P1. 37) or Eleusis 765 (ABV 88; Paralip. 33) and Athens, Benaki 7676 (Karydi, op. cit. [footnote 1 above, p. 18], Beil. 50, 51). 9 With exception of the loutrophoroi from the Shrine of Nymphe, mythological themes do not normally appear on black-figured loutrophoroi. We wish to thank Charikleia Kanellopoulou-Papadopouloufor showing us the photographs
of her material from this Sanctuary.For a mythologicaltheme, cf. also the fragment by the Painter of London B 76, also from Athens, which shows the Departure of Amphiaraos (Paralip. 32, 6 bis). 10For well-preserved examples, cf. four unattributed late 6th-century B.C. ones: Athens, Benaki 7676 (Karydi, op. cit. [footnote1 above, p. 18], Beil. 50, 51); Cleveland27.145 (CVA, Cleveland 1 [USA 15], pls. 15, 16 [695, 696]); Berlin 1888 (Ath Mitt 53, 1928, Beil. 13); and New York, M.M.A. 27.228 (Noble, Techniques,fig. 169). For the weddedpair in a chariot, cf. Athens, once private (Karydi, op. cit., Beil. 52:3 and 53). Noteworthy exceptions to the prothesis scene on the body are two from the Kerameikosdating 540-530 B.c.: inv. no. 1682 by a painter of Group E, which shows two rows of men and youths with tripods (ABV 137, 66; Paralip. 55, 66); inv. no. 1680, near Group E, which has wrestlers in the main zone on one side, mourners on the other (ABV 139, 15; Karydi, op. cit., Beil. 44-46).
20
SHAPE STUDIES
used sparingly as early as the third quarter of the 6th century B.C.375 (PI. 37) is the earliest example from the Agora.1IMost commonof these white patternsis the wavy line, as on 377 (PI. 36), or 383 and 385 (PI. 37), which are very likely the painted counterpartsof the plastic snakes on late Geometric and Protoattic loutrophoroi.'2Other patterns include the key (375: PI. 37) and the zigzag, the latter unknown on Agora black-figuredloutrophoroi.The effect of the amount of white is colorful and lively. PELIKAI 390-397
P1.38
The pelike is a shape invented by the Pioneers, and, therefore,all the known black-figuredexamples are later than the introductionof red figure. The shape derivesfromthe amphoraType C, and it is characterizedby a rather sagging body with its maximum diameter close to the foot, a torus mouth, segmental handles, and an echinus or spreading foot. In Attic black figure, the figured decorationis set in panels, framed by a variety of patterns that are combinedrather freely, for in this shape there is no standardizationof ornamentas there is with many other Attic black-figured shapes.2Only a few Attic black-figuredpelikai have been found in the Agora, and all of them may be dated in the late 6th or early 5th centuriesB.C.391 (PI. 38) is the best preservedand is unique for having rays above the foot instead of solid black glaze.3
PSYKTER 398
Fig. 11 P1.39
The psykter, or wine-cooler, like the pelike, is a shape invented in the late 6th century. It first appears about 530-520 B.C.and, although never very popular, continues until shortly before the middle of the 5th centuryB.C. The earliest known black-figuredexample seems to be the one in the Menil Collection signed on the top side of the mouth by Nikosthenes and attributedby Bothmerto the Antimenes Painter,2who, togetherwith painters in his circle, has left us other examples of the shape.3 When filled with wine, the psykter was placed in a krater containing iced water or snow,
I1 For other early examples from the third quarter, cf. those from the Kerameikos cited in footnote 10 above, p. 19; also Oxford 1930.619 (CVA, Oxford 3 [GB 14], pl. 25 [640]:9). 12Karydi, op. cit. [footnote 1 above, p. 18], p. 91.
For the shape, cf. Agora XII, pp. 49-51, with bibliography; more recently, R.-M. Becker, Formen attischer Peliken von der Pioneer-Gruppebis zum Beginn der Friihklassik,Ttibingen 1977. 2 For the variety of ornamental patterns and their various combinations,cf. Bothmer,JHS 71, 1951, pp. 42-44. 3 Bothmer,op. cit., p. 44. On psykters, cf. Agora XII, p. 52, esp. note 1, with
bibliography; most recently, the monograph by S. Drougou, Der attische Psykter, Wurzburg 1975. For the psykteramphora, a rare double-walled vessel, cf. H. Hoffmann in CVA, Boston 1 [USA 14], p. 25. 2 Hoffmann, Ten Centuries, fig. 175. For the attribution, cf. M. B. Moore, Etudes delphiques [BCH, Suppl. IV], Paris 1977, p. 314, note 38. 3 Antimenes Painter: Louvre C 12296 (ABV 275, 136); manner: Leipzig T 367 (ABV 280, 57; CVA, Leipzig 2 [DDR 2], pl. 27 [88]); Louvre F 319 (ABV 280, 58); Louvre F 320 (ABV 280, 59); related:Louvre F 321 (ABV282, 22; Drougou, op. cit. [footnote 1 above], pl. 14:1); Group of Wurzburg 199: Villa Giulia 50674 (ABV 289, 28).
PSYKTER
21
which chilled the wine,4 and it may be no accidentthat both the psykter and the calyx-kraterfirst appear at about the same time, for the flaring shape of the krater accommodatesthe psykter very well.5 This is not to suggest, however, that the calyx-kraterwas invented for the psykter, for there can be no doubt that the krater was used independently,although occasionallyboth a calyx-krater and a psykter may have been made and sold as a set. The shape of the psykter is well suited to its use. It has a broad,bulging body that curvesinward sharply to the tall, thick stem supported by a torus foot or sometimes by one in two degrees, a vertical member above a torus. The cylindrical stem serves as a keel, allowing the psykter to float upright in the krater.6The mouth is usually flat on top,7similar to that of the amphoraType A or B or the standardneck-amphora.Two varieties of psykter are known. The first has two small loops on the shoulder through which a string or thong may be passed so that the vessel may be carried.8 This type also has a lid that slips over the mouth. The secondtype of psykterhas neither loops nor a lid. 398 (P1. 39) belongs to this variety. The scheme of decorationis a simple one. There is a tongue pattern on the shoulderat the junction with the neck, which is sometimesaugmentedby a secondpattern between it and the figures.9 The neck and mouth are usually black.10On psykterswithout loops, the figurescontinueroundthe body without interruption;on those with loops, it is dividedinto obverseand reverse.Occasionally, the figures are set in panels, but this arrangementis rare.11Normally, the area below the figures 4
See particularly Bothmer,Bull. Metr. Mus. 19, 1960-61, pp. 141-142; A. Greifenhagen, Jahr. Berl. Museen 3, 1961, p. 126; most recently, J. Boardman, ABFV, p. 188. Drougou (op. cit. [footnote 1 above, p. 20], pp. 31-35) argues, however, that the psykter held the snow or iced water, for its closed shape would preserve the coolant longer than the open shape of the krater would. This conclusion, refuted by Bothmer (AA [JdI 91], 1976, p. 487), ignores the fact that a containerof liquid is cooled more quickly if it is surroundedby cold water than if the reverse method is used. Furthermore, some of the representations of psykters in vase painting lend support to our opinion that the psykter held the wine and the kratercontainedthe iced water or snow. For a list of 19 illustrations, cf. Drougou, op. cit., pp. 38-39. In 13 of these scenes (Drougou, nos. 1, 2, 5, 7, 8, 10, 11, 13, 15-19), there is a ladle, which makes sense only if used with the psykter. In three scenes, the ladle is in the psykter: Heidelberg 279 (CVA, Heidelberg 1 [Germany 10], pl. 42 [476]:7); Bonn, inv. no. 574 by the Painter of the Vogell Pelike (ABV 339, 1; Paralip. 152, 1); Vienna 137 (CVA, Vienna 1 [Austria 1], pl. 1 [1]:2). In five scenes, the ladle and the psykter appear without the krater: Vienna 137: psykter on ground, youth about to ladle wine; Berlin, inv. no. 3251 by the Thalia Painter: psykter being carried; ladles suspended from stands (AR V2 113, 7; Paralip. 332, 3); Berlin 1960.32 by the Cerberus Painter: woman stands before psykter, holds up ladle (ARV2 1630); Florence 8 B 17 by Myson: ladle held just above psykter (AR V2 238, 8); Greifswald 316 in the manner of the Antiphon Painter: ladle held just above psykter (ARV2 342, 2). Those who wish to believe that the psykter held the coolant would argue that in scenes, such as those on Heidelberg 279 or Bonn, inv. no. 574, where the psykter with its ladle stands in the krater, cold water is being ladled from the psykter into the drinking vessel to be mixed with the wine it already contains. But this view is extremely difficultto support when the psykter and the ladle appear in a symposionor revel without the krater,
for in these illustrations, only the psykter can be the source of the wine. 5 Two good illustrations:Athens, N.M. 1045 by Kleisophos (ABV 186;Jahr. Berl. Museen 3, 1961, p. 123, fig. 8) and Bonn, inv. no. 574 by the Painter of the Vogell Pelike (ABV 339, 1; Paralip. 152, 1). 6 Cf. Bothmer,AA (Jd 91), 1976, p. 487. 7E.g. the Menil psykter (Hoffmann, Ten Centuries, fig. 175). 8 A good example: Brussels A 1652 in the manner of the Acheloos Painter (ABV 387, 19; Drougou, op. cit. [footnote 1 above,p. 20], pl. 13:1). This type is more commonin plain black than it is in figured. Drougou (pp. 18-25) lists 24 examples in black, 6 in black figure, and 9 in red figure. The bronze psykter in New York illustrates the purpose of the loops, for it has two swinging handles which pass through them (M.M.A. 60.11.3: Bull. Metr. Mus. 19, 1960-61, pp. 138-139, figs. 7, 8). 9Cf. the Menil psykter by the Antimenes Painter, which has a ribbon pattern (Hoffmann, Ten Centuries,fig. 175), and Heidelberg 215, an unusual key pattern (CVA, Heidelberg 1 [Germany 10], pi. 32 [466]:8). Leipzig T 367 in the manner of the Antimenes Painter has a narrow black band (ABV 280, 57; CVA, Leipzig 2 [DDR 2], pl. 27 [88]). 10Exceptions:the Menil psykterwhich has a frieze of horsemen on the neck and ivy with dots on the side of the mouth (Hoffmann, Ten Centuries, fig. 175); Brussels A 1652 which has a ribbon pattern on the neck (ABV 387, 19; Drougou, op. cit. [footnote 1 above, p. 20], pl. 13:1); Bloomington, Indiana University Art Museum 75.102.1 which has ivy on the side of the mouth (Moon, Midwestern Collections, pp. 112-113, no. 64). ' Examples: Brussels A 1652 (ABV 387, 19; Drougou, op. cit. [footnote1 above,p. 20], pl. 13:1);Jena (JdI 80, 1965, p. 83, fig. 7).
22
SHAPE STUDIES
and the entire stem are glazed, although on some psyktersthere may be a narrow reservedbandor a zone of ornament.'2 The foot is usually glazed but occasionally may be reserved.13398 (PI. 39) seems to be unique for having its stem unglazed except for a black band above the foot. SKYPHOS-KRATERS 399-413
Fig. 12 Pls. 39-41
The skyphos-kraterhas a very long history in Attic pottery, reaching back to the Late Geometric period, but it is not a very common shape.' All the examples with known provenancescome from Athens and its environs.In Attic black figure,there are less than 40 skyphos-kraters,and the largest number of attributed examples are by the Nettos Painter or close to him. The skyphos-krater disappearsby the end of the first quarter of the 6th century,the four examples by the Group of the Dresden Lekanis being the latest.2 As the name implies, the skyphos-krateris a very large, deep bowl. It has two horizontal strap handles with returns, and its rim is flanged or incurvingto receive a domed lid. The bowl may be supportedby an echinus foot,3or joined to a conical stand. The inside may be unglazed or banded. The Agora skyphos-kratersare very fragmentaryand do not illustrate the shape very well. The majorityof fragments, 404-413, are from lids, but none may be joined with the bowl it once covered. 399, 401, and 403 (Pls. 39, 40) are rim fragments;400 and 402 (PI. 39) preservepart of the bottom of the bowl and the top of the stand. It is possible that some of the fragmentsof very early conical stands from the Agora (e.g. 526-530: PI. 51) belong to skyphos-kraters,but without part of the bowl preserved,there remains a measure of uncertainty,and they are best kept apart. On both the bowl and the stand, the figures appear on the obverseonly, in keepingwith the use of the skyphos-krateras a grave marker.The reverseof the bowl is decoratedwith large ornamental patterns or loopwork,4and in this respect the scheme of decorationrecalls that of large grave amphorae.5On the three well-preserved skyphos-kratersby the Nettos Painter, which illustrate the shape best, there is a palm tree on the backof each stand.6On the bowl of the 7th-centuryexamples, the figures are large and extend over the entire surface.The formatis not yet dividedinto friezes as it will be on the later skyphos-kraters,7as well as on many other large vases of the early 6th century B.C. Below the figures on the bowl, there is sometimesa band of ornament and below that a zone of rays. Often at the sides, next to the handle return, there is a vertical framing pattern, and beneath the handle itself, a figure such as a bird or an ornamentalpattern.On the preservedstands, which are all early, the figures are large, but presumablyon the standsof later skyphos-kratersthe 12 Narrow reservedband:Louvre C 12296 by the Antimenes Painter (ABV275, 136); Villa Giulia 73655 (M. Moretti, Villa Giulia. Nuove scopertee acquisizioni nell'Etruriameridionale, pl. 16:5); London, B.M. B 299 (Jdl 80, 1965, p. 88, fig. 14). Ornament: Brussels A 1652: upright lotus buds below figures; invertedrays on stem (ABV 387, 19; Drougou, op. cit. [footnote 1 above, p. 20], pl. 13:1). 13E.g., Louvre F 321 in the mannerof the Antimenes Painter (ABV 282, 22; Drougou, op. cit. [footnote 1 above, p. 20], pl. 14:1); Munich SL 461 (Drougou, op. cit., pl. 27:1); Vienna IV 3069 (Jdl 80, 1965, p. 91, fig. 18). On Brussels A 1652, which has a foot in two degrees,the verticalmemberis reserved (ABV387, 19; Drougou, op. cit., pi. 13:1).
For the shape, cf. KerameikosVI, ii, pp. 150, 156-158. 2ABV 22, 3-6.
3 For example, Athens, N.M. 16399 by a follower of the Nettos Painter (ABV 7, -). 4 Three by the Nettos Painter:Athens, N.M. 16382 (ABV 3, 4; 3; 4; Paralip. 3, 10);Athens, N.M. 16383 (ABV7, y; Paralip. 3, 12); Athens, N.M. 16384 (ABV 6; Paralip. 3, 13); also Kerameikos,inv. no. 801 by the Painterof Berlin A 34 (ABV 1, 2; KerameikosVI, ii, no. 115, pl. 88); Kerameikos,inv. no. 153 (KerameikosVI, ii, no. 62, pl. 61); Kerameikos,inv. no. 129 (KerameikosVI, ii, no. 96, pl. 79); Athens, N.M. 16400: spirals. 5 Footnote 19 above, 7. p. 6 Footnote4 above. 7 Examples: Athens, N.M. 907 by the Ceramicus Painter (ABV 19, 4); Akropolis496 from the Group of the Dresden Lekanis (ABV 22, 3); probablytwo others in this group, but little remains: Akropolis 497 (ABV 22, 4); Akropolis 498 (ABV 22, 5).
COLUMN-KRATERS
23
figures appeared in friezes just as they do on the bowls. At the top of the stand, just below the junction, there may be three or four lines (400: P1.39) or a black band (402: P1.39), andjust above the torus molding at the bottom,there is usually a zone of rays. Contraryto the system of decoration on the bowl and stand, the decorationon the lids of skyphos-kraters,which may be either ornament or figures, continues aroundwithout interruption.On the 7th-centurylids, the figuresare large and cover the entire surface except for a zone of ornament at the rim and around the knob, 404-411 (Pls. 40, 41);8on those of the 6th century,beginning with the Gorgon Painter,9the decorationis set in friezes, 412, 413 (P1.41).
COLUMN-KRATERS 414-490
Pls. 41-46
The column-krateris the most commontype of krater in Attic black figure,1and the Agora examples range in date from the early th to the early 5th centuriesB.C. Although the column-krateris mainly a shape of the Archaic and Classical periods, it may have been known to Late Geometric artists, for a handle-plate from that period was found in the Agora.2Some have contestedthat this fragmentprovides firm evidence for the existence of the column-kraterin so early a period, mainly becauseonly the handle-plate remains, no telling fragmentsof rim, neck, and body,but also because nearly a century elapses before the next example is known.3 Still, since Late Geometric and Protoatticpotters produce many innovativechanges in shape, ornament,and subjectmatter, there seems to be no good reason to rejectthe Agora handle-plateas evidencefor the column-kraterbefore the beginning of Attic black figure. The earliest undisputed Attic black-figuredcolumn-krateris Athens, N.M. 16388 from Vari.4 Bakir connected it with the workshop of the Nettos Painter,5and thus it should date in the last quarter of the 7th century B.C.,perhaps a little earlier than 414 (PI. 41), the earliest black-figured example from the Agora. The Vari krater has a short, broad, spherical body and no handle-plate, the handle columns being attached directly to the rim. Its shape is paralleled best in Corinthian,6 but its ornament, subject,and style of drawing are pure Attic. Attic black-figured column-kratersof the first quarter of the 6th century B.C. are influencedby Corinthian examples. Those by painters of the Komast Group are direct imitations of the Corinthian shape, and these painters are also strongly influenced by Corinth in their choice of subjects and in their style of drawing. The shape now is taller, and the columnssupportingthe rectangular plate are almost vertical.The Agora examples of this period are particularlyfragmentary,and thus they do not shed much light on the appearanceof the shape as a whole at this time, but they are importantfor the schemeof decorationand for the subjects.The figureddecorationmay still appear in panels with solid black glaze below the figures, 417 (P1.41) being the one certain example from 8 Good
examples: the three by the Nettos Painter (footnote 4 above, p. 22); Athens, N.M. 16399 by a follower (ABV7, -). 9 Cf. Agora A-P 1734 by the Gorgon Painter (ABV 8, 6). 1 For the shape, cf. Agora XII, p. 54, with bibliography; also, T. Bakir, Der Kolonnettenkraterin Korinth und Attika zwischen 625 und 550 v. Chr., Wurzburg 1974; P. Zaphiropoulou, BCH 94, 1970, pp. 380-398; and M. Tiverios, IpoSr arT77rKj KEpa,uiLK?, Thessaloniki i,Xqi'JAara7rjs UeXAavopLopp
1981, passim. For Corinthianexamples, the best discussionstill
is NC, pp. 300-301. 2 P 7006 (AgoraVIII, p. 85, no. 487, pl. 29). 3 Cf., particularly, Bakir, op. cit. (footnote 1 above), p. 60. 4 Tiverios, op. cit. (footnote 1 above), pl. 44. The figured decorationis set in panels: A, two eagles devouringa snake; B, sirens. On the top side of the rim, rosettes. 5 Op. cit. (footnote 1 above), p. 60. 6 Cf. ibid. 7 Cf., particularly,ibid., pp. 61-63.
24
SHAPE STUDIES
the Agora.8But more often, Attic black-figurepainters prefer the new schemeof decorationadopted by Corinthianartists shortly after 600 B.C. Here, the figureddecorationof the main zone extends to the columnsof the handles without framingornament;beneaththe handlesthere is often a figure, usually a bird or a monster,sometimesan ornament.Most important,however, is the additionof a subsidiaryfrieze of animals below the main zone. 421 (PI. 42) preservespart of this zone, and 416 may give just the start of it, for the area below the groundline is unglazed. 420 (PI. 42), to judge by its scale, very likely had a frieze below the symposionscene. The decorationon the top side of the rim is normally ornamental,most often rays or rosettes,9and the vertical overhangis plain black. 422 with its frieze of horsemenon top and incised rosetteson the overhangis most unusual for the period.10On the handle-plate, there may be an animal, such as the feline on 418 (PI. 41), or a floral.11The tongue pattern appears on the shoulderat the junction with the neck, except on those kratersthat are decoratedaccordingto the principleused by Corinthianpaintersduring the late 7th and early 6th centuriesB.C., which allows the figuresof the main zone to extend to the junction with the neck.12426 is the best example from the Agora.13The tongue pattern on 417 (PI. 41) is an exception among column-kratersby the Komast Group.14 Most of the Attic black-figuredcolumn-kratersdatedin the middledecadesof the 6th centuryB.C. come from the workshop of Lydos and his companion,the Painter of Louvre F 6. Comparedwith earlier column-kraters,the ones in this period are taller in proportionto their width, the necks are not so short and they flare slightly; the columns of the handles slant outward a little.15A new scheme of decoration appears in which the subsidiary frieze of animals is given up in favor of allowing the main zone to extend fartherdown the bodyof the vase. 436 (PI. 43), the best-preserved example from the Agora, illustrates well the effect of simplicity achievedby this new system. Beneath each handle is a figure, usually a bird as on 436. Rarely are the figures on each side set in a panel.16On the top side of the rim, rays are the normal decoration,as on 436, 437, and 447; the overhangis black.17The lotus-palmettefestoonon the top side of 428 (PI. 42) and the lotus buds on 8 Other examples: Athens, N.M. 12587 by Sophilos (ABV 40, 24; Bakir, Sophilos, pl. 18); two unattributedones: Louvre C 11250 (CVA, Louvre 12 [France 19], pl. 157 [830]:1, 2) and London, B.M. B 101 (Beazley and Payne, JHS 49, 1929, p. 255, fig. 3). 9 Rays: e.g., Athens, N.M. 12587 by Sophilos (ABV 40, 24; Bakir, Sophilos, pl. 18); Louvre E 623 by the Ptoon Painter (ABV 83, 1; Paralip. 31, 1). Rosettes:e.g., two by the KY Painter, Conservatori212 (ABV 31, 2; Paralip. 16, 2) and Louvre C 11249 (ABV 31, 4; Paralip. 16, 4); Louvre 12251 by Sophilos (ABV 40, 23; Paralip. 18, 23; F. Villard in CVA, Louvre 12 [France 19], p. 124, not illustrated). 10 Louvre C 12251 by Sophilos is also unusual for it has a frieze of Z's on the overhang (ABV 40, 23; Paralip. 18, 23; F. Villard in CVA, Louvre 12 [France 19], p. 124). 11Animals or monsters:Conservatori212 (panther) by the KY Painter (ABV 31, 2; Paralip. 16, 2); three by Sophilos: Athens, N.M. 12587, a sphinx (ABV 40, 24; Baklr, Sophilos, pl. 20, fig. 38); Aigina 1175 a, a swan (ABV 41, 25; Bakir, op. cit. [footnote 1 above, p. 23], p. 21, A 7; Baklr, Sophilos,pl. 77, fig. 150: here [p. 42] the vase is considereda workshop piece), and Louvre CA 1750, a sphinx (Paralip. 19, 24 bis; Baklr, Sophilos, pl. 63, fig. 121); two by the Ptoon Painter, each with a swan: Louvre E 623 (ABV 83, 1; Paralip. 31, 1) and Athens, N.M. 1001 (ABV 83, 2). Floral:three by the KY Painter:London, B.M. 1928.1-17.39 (ABV31, 1); Athens (ABV31, 3); and Louvre C 11249 (ABV 31, 4; Paralip. 16, 4: the number incorrectly given as C 12249). 12 Baklr, op. cit. (footnote 1 above, p. 23), pp. 57-58 and 61.
An exception among Early Corinthian column-kraters is Louvre E 635, which has a lotus-palmettefestoonon the shoulder at the junction with the neck (NC 780; Baklr, op. cit., p. 12, K 20; Arias, pls. 32 and IX). The tongue patternon the shoulder is normal in Corinthian from about 590 B.C. on. 13 For others, cf., e.g., two by the KY Painter, Conservatori 212 (ABV 31, 2; Paralip. 16, 2) and Louvre C 11249 (ABV 31, 4; Paralip. 16, 4); one connected with the Komast Group, Athens, N.M. 441 (ABV 36, 3); one by Sophilos, Louvre C 12251 (ABV 40, 23; Paralip. 18, 23; Bakir, Sophilos,pl. 82: here [p. 42] the vase is considereda workshoppiece);one by the Ptoon Painter, Louvre E 623 (ABV 83, 1; Paralip. 31, 1); and two unattributed, London, B.M. B 101 (Beazley and Payne, JHS 49, 1929, p. 255, fig. 3) and Louvre C 11250 (CVA, Louvre 12 [France 19], pl. 157 [830]:1, 2). 14Also unusual for the Komast Group is the checkerboard patternon the shoulderof the London/Oxfordfragments(AB V 33,4). 15Compare, e.g., 436 (PI. 43) with Conservatori212 by the KY Painter (ABV31, 2; Paralip. 16, 2). 16For example, Louvre C 11252 (ABV 119, 2: related to Lydos; Paralip. 50, the number wrongly given as 12252: the Painter of Vatican 309). 17 Some exceptions show the zigzags on the overhang, undoubtedlyinspiredby Corinth.Cf., e.g., Berlin, inv. no. 3763 by the Painter of London B 76 (ABV87, 17); three by Lydos:London, B.M. 1948.10-15.1 (ABV 108, 8; Paralip. 44, 8; Tiverios, pl. 8; Bothmer,Amasis Painter, p. 42, fig. 29:b:zigzags also on the top side of the rim); Harvard 1925.30.125 (ABV 108, 9;
VOLUTE-KRATERS
25
459 (PI. 44) are oddities for the period.18On the handle-plate there is usually the head of a man to left (439-441, 446-448: Pls. 43, 44) or a bird to right, preening (442 144: P1.43).19From now on, a row of tongues nearly always appears on the shoulder at the junction with the neck, 437 (P1.43) and the reverseof 436 in the manner of Lydos being the exceptionsfrom the Agora.20Abovethe foot are rays. On column-kratersof this period, there is a distinct lessening of Corinthianinfluence. From about 540 B.C. on, the Attic black-figuredcolumn-kraterbecomestaller and more elegant than before, and the figured decorationis most often set in panels framedby ivy at the sides and by at the junction with the On the top side of the rim, there is usually a rneck. tongues on the shoulder chain of lotus buds, often with dots in the interstices,on the overhangthere is more ivy, and on each handle-plate appears a palmette with volutes. 474, a late 6th-century column-krater,is the bestpreservedexample of this system from the Agora;461 is an earlier one but more fragmentary.This is the normal scheme of decorationfor late Archaic black-figuredcolumn-kraters,but a number of exceptions are known. Occasionally,the figured decorationcontinuesround the vase. 462 (PI. 44), which shows an amphora painted in the area beneath the handle, is probablyone of these.21A few Attic black-figured column-kraters of the late 6th and early 5th centuries B.C. have a frieze of animals on the top side of the rim, instead of an ornamentalpattern,476 (PI. 46), 477, 478, and 490 being examples from the Agora. Most unusual is 479 (PI. 46) which has a frieze of animals on the overhang of the rim, a variation that does not seem to have a parallel. Other variations, such as ornament on the neck of the obverseor figured decorationon the handle-plate, are not to be found on the Agora examples, owing perhaps to their extremely fragmentarycondition. VOLUTE-KRATERS 491-500
Pls. 46 and 47
The volute-krater is a rather rare shape in Attic black figure, and most of the known examples, including all those from the Agora, date after 530 B.C. The body of the volute-krateris shaped like that of the column-krater,but its neck is taller and in two degrees,and the side of its rim is narrow and flaring with no overhang. The handles are composedof two elements, a loop on the shoulder and a flanged part that rises above the rim and terminatesin a volute after it is attachedto the rim. Early volute-kratershave an echinus foot, later ones a foot in two degrees,a verticalmemberabove a torus, like the foot of the amphora Type A and the calyx-krater. Tiverios, pl. 19; and Athens (Paralip. 45); two unattributed examples in Salonica (P. Zaphiropoulou, BCH 94, 1970, p. 372, fig. 6 and p. 375, figs. 12, 13). 18 Other exceptions to the normal decorationon the top side of the rim appear in the work of Lydos: New York, M.M.A. 31.11.11, animals (ABV 108, 5; Paralip. 43, 5; Tiverios, pl. 55:a); Harvard 1925.30.125, lotus buds (ABV 108, 9; Tiverios, pl. 20:a). 19Three exceptions by Lydos: New York, M.M.A. 31.11.11, gorgoneion (ABV 108, 5; Paralip. 43, 5; Tiverios, pl. 55:a); Harvard 1925.30.125, siren on one, sphinx on the other (ABV 108, 9; Tiverios, pl. 20:a). 20 Around the middle of the 6th century B.C. a few other exceptions appear on column-kraters in the manner of Lydos, e.g., Louvre C 11253 (ABV 117, 29; Paralip. 47, 29) and Louvre E 677 (ABV 117, 28; Paralip. 47, 28) where the presence or absence of the tongue pattern helps to distinguish between obverseand reverse. Cf. also two others in his manner without a tongue pattern on either side: Louvre C 11257 (ABV
117, 30; Paralip. 47, 30) and Louvre C 11256 (ABV 117, 31; Paralip. 47, 31). 21 For the figures continuing round the vase, compare also one by the Rycroft Painter, Scarborough-on-Hudson,Vanderlip (Paralip. 149, 235), and an unattributed example, New York, M.M.A. 07.286.76 (Bothmer, Festschrift Brommer, pls. 17, 18). Two by a painter of the Leagros Group are an odd variation for the pictures continue past the side frames: Paris Market (ABV 376, 226) and Villa Giulia (ABV 376, 227). A fragmentfrom the Loeb Collectionwas probablyfrom a similar krater (J. Sieveking, Bronzen, Terrakotten,Vasender Sammlung Loeb, Munich 1930, pl. 45:1). For the shape, cf. S. Karouzou, BCH 79, 1955, pp. 192204; K. Hitzl, Die Entstehung und Entwicklung des Volutenkratersvon derfriihestenAnfangen bis zur Auspriigungdes kanonischen Stils in der attisch schwarzfigurigen Vasenmalerei, Frankfurt-am-Main 1982, also, Agora XII, p. 54.
SHAPE STUDIES
26
The earliest Attic black-figuredvolute-kraterseems to be the one by Sophilosin the Metropolitan Museum.2 Here, the flanges rise only slightly abovethe rim, and their ends are not tightly curledas they will be on the next volute-krater,the famous one signed by Kleitias and Ergotimos.3Between these two and the next, there is a time gap of more than 30 years.4All the later black-figuredvolutekraters,unlike the earlier ones, have black bodies that are decoratedwith only a tongue patternon the shoulder at the junction with the neck. This new scheme of decorationmay derive from bronze volute-kraters.5On Attic black-figuredexamples, an ornamentalpattern, most often ivy, appears on the handles. On the side of the rim, there is usually a key pattern;the top may be plain or decorated with ornament, although the latter is rarer. The Agora volute-kratersare extremely fragmentary, and only 491 (Pl. 46) gives a good idea of the appearanceof the shape. The rest are neck fragments,some with part of the rim, e.g. 495 (PI. 47) and 496. The arrangementof the decorationon the necks of Attic black-figuredvolute-kratersvaries. On some, the figured decorationappears on the upper zone, and the lower one is left black. 492 and 495-497 (PI. 47) may be examples, although without part of the lower zone, one may not be absolutely certain. Others have an ornamentalpattern on the upper zone and figures on the lower one. 491 is our one sure example. The third variation has figures on both zones of the neck on the obverse, resulting in a double-deckereffect. No example of this decorativearrangementmay be identified for certain among the Agora fragments. CALYX-KRATERS 501-509
Pis. 47 and 48
Calyx-kraters are more numerous in red figure than they are in black figure. 1 The earliest preservedexample is the well-known one attributedto Exekias, found in the North Slope excavations,2 which also producedanother early, although very fragmentary,one that has stylistic affinitieswith it.3 The calyx-kraterhas a flaring wall, an offset rim ending in a thick torus, a cul to which the upturned handles are attached,and a foot in two degrees (a verticalmemberabove a torus). Between the cul and the foot, there is a fillet. In several respectsthe shape of the calyx-kraterresemblesthat of the earlier chalice.4The earliest black-figuredcalyx-kratersare somewhatbroaderthan they are M.M.A. 1977.11.2, attributed by Bothmer (Notable Acquisitions, 1975-1979, p. 14). Accordingto Bothmer,this is the earliest preservedvolute-kraterof "Chalcidian"shape (for the type, cf. A. Rumpf, ChalkidischeVasen, Berlin/Leipzig 1927, pp. 122-124 and NC, p. 330; also, Agora XII, p. 54, note 1). Karouzouhas suggestedthat the Nettos Painter may have decorated a volute-krater.Akropolis391 (ABV 5, 10;Paralip. 4, 16) preservespart of the neck and rim of a krater,and, accordingto Karouzou, what remains is intelligible only if there was once some kind of volute handle attachedto the rim (Karouzou, op. cit. [footnote 1 above, p. 25], pp. 195-196). 3 Florence 4209 (ABV 76, 1; Paralip. 29, 1; Cristofani, Vaso Francois, passim). Bothmer suggested orally that the fragment in Moscow (ABV 77, 2) comes from a volute-krater,and recently he joined it to a volute-krater fragment in the Cahn Collection, Basel HA 1418 (AK 24, 1981, pp. 66-67). 4 Fragments by the Painter of Acropolis 606, Akropolis 625, may belong to a volute-krater(ABV 81, 3). They preserve part of the neck with figureddecorationand a bit of the rim, but without more to go on, it is difficult to be absolutely certain of the shape. 2
5 Cf. Karouzou, op. cit. [footnote1 above, p. 25], pp. 194197. For the shape, cf. P. Jacobsthal, MMSt. 5, 1934-1936, esp. pp. 117-121, 133-134, 136. For other bibliography, cf. Agora XII, p. 54, note 1. 2 Agora A-P 1044 (ABV 145, 19; Paralip. 60, 19). Exekias may have signed this vase as potter,just as he signed others that are either new shapes, such as the Munich eye-cup (ABV 146, 21; Paralip. 60, 21), or that offer new and innovativetreatment of existing shapes, such as two of his neck-amphorae,Berlin 1720, which has a double signature (ABV 143, 1; Paralip. 59, 1), and London, B.M. B 210 (ABV 144, 7; Paralip. 60, 7). For signatures of Exekias in relation to the shapes that bear them, cf. K. Stahler,JOAI 49, 1968-1971, pp. 79-113. 3 Cf. C. Roebuck, Hesperia 9, 1940, pp. 153-158, no. 8. Eleven fragmentsfrom the same calyx-krateras Akropolis 615 a-p. All the known fragmentsare given on pp. 154-155. 4Jacobsthal, op. cit. (footnote 1 above), p. 117, with bibliography.
LEBETES GAMIKOI
27
tall. Later examples are just the opposite, and the trend toward a taller, more slendershape continues in red figure.5Examples of calyx-kratersin the Agora are very few and are so fragmentarythat their proportionsmay not be determined. The main figured decoration on calyx-kraters appears on the body. The figures are not set in panels as they are on so many column-kraters,but those on the obverseare separatedfrom those on the reverse by a vine, often laden with grapes, which is painted above each handle. The earlier kraters, including the one by Exekias, also have figures on the cul, usually extending to each handle,6 or, as on one in the manner of Exekias and on another related to the Antimenes Painter, framed by a palmette on each side.7 On late black-figuredexamples, the cul is solid black. The calyx-krater by Exekias has a lotus-palmette chain on the offset part of the rim below the torus. This is the pattern favoredby Exekias who uses it abovethe panels of his one-piece amphoraeand on the necks of his neck-amphorae.In the last quarter of the 6th century B.C., the lotus-palmette chain is a very common ornament on amphorae, but elsewhere on the rims of calyx-kraters it appears only on the one from Pharsalos attributedto the mannerof Exekias.8The rest, but for one exception,9have the ivy pattern, including one in the manner of Exekias.10The use of ivy on the offset part of the rims of calyx-kraters recalls its use on the overhang of rims of many columnkraters,1 and there may well be a link in the similar use of the same pattern. Usually the rows of ivy leaves are separatedby a wavy black line, although occasionallythe line is red, as on 504, on one by the Rycroft Painter in Toledo, or on an unattributedone in the Louvre.12The earliest blackfigured calyx-kratershave a zone of rays on the bottom of the cul just above the fillet. On the later ones, small narrow tongues take the place of rays,13whether the cul is decoratedor left black.
LEBETES GAMIKOI 510-518
Pls. 48 and 49
The lebes gamikos is a standed and lidded vase that is associatedwith marriage, probablyto hold the water for the bridal bath.' The body of the lebes gamikos is shaped somewhat like that of a 5 For comparative measurements of both Attic black-figured and Attic red-figured calyx-kraters, cf. ibid., p. 136; for additions, cf. E. Vermeule, AJA 70, 1966, p. 22. 6 E.g., Volos, now in the National Museum in Athens, in the manner of Exekias (ABV 148, 9); Vienna 3618 in the manner of the Antimenes Painter (ABV 280, 56). For a red-figured example, cf. Louvre G 163 by the Eucharides Painter (ARV2 227, 12; Paralip. 347, 12). 7 Manner of Exekias: Louvre C 11298 (Paralip. 62, 9 bis); related to the Antimenes Painter: Syracusen.n. (AB V 281,18). For a cul decoratedwith encircledpalmettes, cf. Louvre F 316, also related to the Antimenes Painter (ABV 281,19). An oddity on a calyx-krater by the Antimenes Painter himself is the key pattern below the figures on the body of Louvre C 11292 (ABV 275, 135; Paralip. 119, 135). 8 ABV 148, 9. 9 The fragmentarycalyx-kraterfrom the North Slope (footnote 3 above, p. 26) has a high rim in two degrees,recallingthat of a volute-kraterthough the two parts are not equal in height. The upper zone is narrowerthan the lower one and is decorated with a tongue pattern. On the lower part is a chariot race to right, with the top of the goal post on one fragment (d). This occurrence of figured decoration on the rim of a calyx-krater
appears to be unique. Also unknown to us on other black-figured calyx-kratersis the tongue pattern on the bodyjust below the rim. The appearanceof the tongue pattern here recalls its similar use on the two chalicesby Lydos, 1446 (PI. 99) and 1447 (PI. 99), where its appearanceon this shape is also unparalleled. 10 Louvre C 11298 (Paralip. 62, 9 bis). It also occurs on some early red-figuredcalyx-kraters:Berlin 2180 by Euphronios (ARV2 13, 1; Paralip. 321, 1; AA [dI 91], 1976, pp. 500501, figs. 17-20); Leningrad, inv. no. 1843 by Phintias (ARV2 23, 5); Louvre CA 5950 (A, Amazonomachy;B, Dionysos between a maenad and a satyr); London Market (Cat. Sotheby, 1 July, 1969, no. 93); Kiel, Schauenburg. " P. 25 above. 12Toledo 63.26 (Paralip. 149, 23 bis; CVA, Toledo 1 [USA 17], pls. 17-19 [797-799]) and Louvre F 315 (CVA, Louvre 2 [France 2], pl. 7 [79]:1, 2). 13An exception is the rather small, unattributedexample in the Louvre, which retains rays in this area (CVA, Louvre 2 [France 2], pi. 7 [79]:1, 2). For the shape, cf. Richter and Milne, Shapesand Names, p. 11; also, J. Boardman, BSA 47, 1952, pp. 31-32 and BSA 53-54, 1958-1959, pp. 160-162.
28
SHAPE STUDIES
column-krater.It has two upright double handles on the shoulder, a short neck, and a groovedor rilled rim. The stand has a flaring or straightwall, a torus foot, and a sharplyoutturnedmolding at the top that separatesbowl from stand. The stand is usually piercedtwice near the top at a point in line with the handles above, as on 516 (PI. 49).2 Stand and bowl are not separate pieces but are joined. The lid may be flat, as that of 516, or it may be somewhat domed as on London, B.M. B 298.3 There are not very many Attic black-figured lebetes gamikoi, and most of those with known provenancescome from Attica.4Two of the Agora examples, 512 and 516 (Pls. 48, 49), give a good idea of the shape. The rest are fragments.The earliest certain Attic black-figuredlebes gamikos is the one by Sophilos found in the excavationsat Old Smyrna.5The earliest example from the Agora is 510 (P1.48) by the Painter of Louvre F 6, and it probablywas very similar to the painter'swellpreservedlebes gamikos in Houston.6The remainderof the Agora lebetes gamikoi are from the last two decades of the 6th century B.C.
The bowl and stand of the lebes gamikos are decoratedwith both figures and ornamental patterns; the lid has ornament only. On the bowl the figures may continue round the vase, as on 514 and 516 (PI. 49), or they may be set in panels, as on 512 (P1.48). On the shoulder, at the junction with the neck is a tongue pattern;at the base,just abovethe moldingat the top of the stand are rays. Lebetes gamikoi with the figures set in panels follow the principle of decorationestablishedfor the one-piece amphora by having black glaze between the panel and the rays, as on 512. Those that have the figures continuingroundthe vase, 514 and 516 (P1.49), have a frieze of upright lotus buds between the figure zone and the rays, which recalls similar use of ornament on neck-amphorae. Within this general scheme of decoration, there is considerablevariation. On the earliest wellpreservedexamples, the one by Sophilos and the one in Houston by the Painter of Louvre F 6,7 there is a frieze of animals below the main scene. The shoulderof the Houston lebes is figured;510 by the same painter has both figures and a tongue pattern, the only example known to us to do so. Above the figures on 514 there are two friezes of ornament, hanging lotus buds with dots in the intersticesbelow a tongue pattern, a combinationof ornamentparalleled on an unpublishedfragmentary lebes in New York that is very close in style.8 The same ornament also occurs on 517 (PI. 48). On the stand of the lebes gamikos, there is a zone of figures with an ornamentalpattern above and below. On all the examples known to us, there is a frieze of inverted rays above the torus.9 The lebes gamikos by Sophilos and an unattributed fragmentaryone of about 560 B.c., 2 Boardman(BSA 53-54, 1958-1959, p. 161) has suggested that the holes were made to allow the gases to escape fromthe stand during firing. An exception to the piercing of the stand is Petit Palais 309 (CVA, Petit Palais [France 15], pl. 9 [649]:1-4). 3 Boardman,ABFV, p. 166, fig. 293. 4 The main exception is the one by Sophilos found in the excavationsof Old Smyrna and now in Izmir (ABV 40, 20; Paralip. 18, 20; Baklr, Sophilos, pls. 39-45). Another may be the fragment by the Painter of Acropolis 601, London, B.M. B 601.13 from Naukratis, which Beazley thought might be a lebes gamikos, but he left the question open (ABV 80, 2). 5 Footnote 4 above.J. Boardman(BSA 53-54, 1958-1959, p. 160, note 41) has suggested that the fragmentary standed krater by the Gorgon Painter, Akropolis 474 (ABV 8, 2), may be a lebes gamikos, presumably because of the inverted rays above the torus foot of the stand. But this ornamentappears in
the same place on three skyphos-kraters from Vari by the Nettos Painter: Athens, N.M. 16382 (ABV 3, 4; 4; Paralip. 3, 10); Athens, N.M. 16383 (ABV 7, y; Paralip. 3, 12); Athens, N.M. 16384 (ABV 4; 6; Paralip. 3, 13). Therefore, it is not a sure criterionfor identifyingthe lebes gamikos in the early 6th century B.C.,as it may be later on when the skyphos-kraterhas gone out of fashion. The fragmentsof Akropolis474 lack a feature that identifiesthis vase for certain as a lebes gamikos. 6 Houston 34.129 (ABV 125, 32; Paralip. 51, 32; Hoffmann, Ten Centuries,fig. 166). The foot is restoredas an echinus one. 7 Footnotes4 and 6 above. 8 New York, M.M.A. 57.12.8. 9 Similar use of this ornament occurs on epinetra. Cf. below, p. 69.
29
STANDS
found in the excavations of the North Slope,'0 have friezes of animals. After the middle of the 6th century B.C., the normal scheme is a single row of human figures.11The ornamentabovethe figures and directlybelow the molding is usually a lotus-palmettechain12or a frieze of invertedlotus buds, as on 516.13
KRATERS, TYPE UNCERTAIN 519-525
P1. 50
These fragmentsdo not seem to belong for certainto any of the types of kratersdiscussedabove.520 (PI. 50) is among the earliest of the group and is closest to the mid-7th-centuryegg-shaped krater, Agora P 4948,1 but that 520 is squatter and heavier. These two vessels do not seem to have good parallels. 520 is unglazed on the inside and might thereforebe identifiedas an amphora,were it not for its upright loop handle. 521 (P1.50) may be a skyphos-krater.The rim fragment,523 (PI. 50), is an odd piece. Karouzou called it the handle-plate of a column-krater,Vanderpool more generally the rim of a krater,2but the projectionat the inner edge of the rim does not correspondto what we know of column-kraters. Nor does it find a parallel among other types of kraters. Its best comparison is the unattributeddinos, Vatican 306.3 STANDS 526-602
Pls. 51-56
The distinctionin terminologybetween a stand and a supportthat was made by Richter and Milne and used by Sparkes and Talcott for the Agora plain black glaze will also be used here. The basic differencesare size, shape, and scheme of decoration. SUPPORTS 526-601
Pls. 51-56
A support is a tubular base with thick walls that bears the weight of the vase. Two types may be distinguished. The earlier of the two is conical in shape, much greater in diameter at the bottom than at the top, and has a thick torus foot. It is unglazed on the inside. 550 (PI. 52) is the best-preserved example of this type from the Agora. The conical support is not freestandingbut is attached directlyto the bottom of the vase. Usually there is a molding that articulatesand perhaps strengthens the area where the two are joined. The appearanceis sturdy and practical.The secondtype of support is cylindrical,with a concavewall terminatingin a thin, slightly projectingmouth and foot. 10A-P 74 a-i, A-P 15, A-P 104, A-P 398, A-P 680, K 4-5 (Hesperia 4, 1935, pp. 255-257, fig. 21). 11An exception is New York, M.M.A. 57.12.8, which has a narrow frieze of animals between the figures and the inverted rays. 12 No example has been found in the Agora. Cf. London, B.M. B 298 (footnote 3 above, p. 28) and Athens, Vlasto Collection (photo D.A.I. Athens, varia 1060-1063). 13 For the key pattern below the molding, cf. Petit Palais 309 (CVA, Petit Palais [France 15], pl. 9 [649]:1-4) and
Kerameikos,inv. no. 79 (Jdl 61-62, 1946-1947, pl. 23). 1AgoraVIII, p. 93, no. 549, pi. 34. Karouzou, AthMitt 62, 1937, p. 134, note 1; E. Vanderpool, Hesperia 15, 1946, p. 129, no. 13. 3 Albizzati, pl. 29. 2
Richter and Milne, Shapesand Names, p. 31; AgoraXII, pp 179-180.
30
SHAPE STUDIES
On the inside there are bands of glaze, varying in width. The cylindrical support is somewhat smaller than the conical one, and it is not attachedto the bottomof the vase but is open at the top, and the vase is set into it. 575 (PI. 55) gives a good idea of this type. In Attic vase painting, conical supports appear in the Geometricperiod and are also well known in Protoatticwhere they may have solid or fenestratedwalls.2 They appear throughoutAttic black figure, mainly as bases for skyphos-kratersin the early period and later for lebetes gamikoi, occasionally for louteria. Most of the Agora examples may be dated in the late 7th century down through the first quarterof the 6th. A small group, 555-560 (PI. 53), comes from the last decadeof the 6th century, and just three of this type, 552-554, belong to the years between 560 and 520 B.C. The conical supportsfrom the Agora are too fragmentaryto be certainwhich type of vase each bore, and for this reason they are groupedunder the general classificationof stands.The late 7th-century examples, 526-530 (P1. 51), may be the stands of skyphos-kraters,since they predate the earliest known Attic black-figuredlebes gamikos, the one in Izmir by Sophilos.3The later examples of conical supports from the Agora are probably from lebetsesstanded skyphos-krater gamikoi;the seems to have gone out of fashion early in the 6th century.4The Attic black-figuredmaterial from Menidi, however, contains at least two standed louteria,5and some of the Agora fragments may therefore be from supports of such vases. 533 (PI. 51) preserves the start of the vase, and 553 (PI. 53), which is pierced, may be the support of a lebes gamikos, but without more to go on, it is probablysafer to include these fragmentswith stands. The scheme of decorationon conical supportsvaries a good deal. The late 7th-centuryexamples have large figures, usually confrontedanimals or monsters,that occupy most of the surface, except for a narrow band of glaze or ornamentat the top and a zone of rays at the bottomjust above the torus. The supports of two well-preserved skyphos-kratersby the Nettos Painter offer the best illustrationof this scheme.6528 (PI. 51) is similar, except that the invertedrays are omitted and an ornamentalconfigurationappears between the two sphinxes. The compositionon 527 (PI. 51) may the supportof a the Nettos Painter, othird have been a processionof women as on skyphoskrater by the in friezes, as it is set the decoration have conical 6th in the Athens 16384.7 Early supports century, on many contemporarykraters and amphorae. This remains the preferredarrangementdown to about 550 B.C. 550 (PI. 52) is the best example from the Agora;532 (PI. 51), by the Gorgon Painter, or in his manner, is the earliest. The favoritesubjectsare friezes of animals. Occasionally,a human figure appears, e.g. 536 and 544, but the subject is uncertain.8533 (P1. 51) shows part of a Chimaera, and Bellerophon may have been on the left, since the Chimaera does not usually appear with other animals (cf., however, 402: P1.39), although it may appear alone, as it seems to have on 698 (PI. 67). If the interpretationof the scene on 533 is correct,it is the only sure mythologicalrepresentationpainted on an early Attic black-figuredsupport.After 550, decorationin friezes is given up in favor of large figures in a narrativeor a mythologicalcontext. Above the heads of the figures there is a band of ornament,which varies considerably.On the three Agora fragmentsthat preserve some of this ornament, each pattern is different:rosettes (552); invertedrays (553: Pl. 53); lotuspalmette chain (557: PI. 53).9 Above the torus foot, there is usually a zone of inverted rays. This 2Cf. Callipolitis-Feytmans, "Louteria",pp. 2-4; Agora
VIII, pp. 41-43, nos. 92-96, p. 5 and pp. 90-91, nos. 523-531, pi. 32; also, KerameikosVI, ii, pp. 162-168: standed kraters with protomeson the rims, standed cups, and plates. 3 ABV40, 20; Paralip. 18, 20; Bakir, Sophilos,pls. 39-45. 4 Cf. above, p. 22. 5 Callipolitis-Feytmans, "Loute'ria", pp. 43-59. 6 Athens, N.M. 16382 (ABV 3, 4; Paralip. 3, 10) and Athens, N.M. 16383 (ABV 7, y; Paralip. 3, 12).
Athens, N.M. 16384 (ABV 6; Paralip. 3, 13). 8 Akropolis 584, a fragmentarystand near Sophilos, shows most of a human figure standing to right, but the subjectdoes not appear to be a mythologicalone (ABV 43, 1; Bakir, Sophilos, pl. 83, fig. 169). 9 For four other examples of this patternat the top of a conical support, cf. the one from Menidi that belongs with a louterion, Athens, N.M. 15934 (Callipolitis-Feytmans, "Louteria", pls. 18-21) and three lebetes gamikoi: Athens, Vlasto
31
STANDS
may be the only decorationbetween the figures and the foot, as on 555, or there may be a second pattern, as on 554, which has a frieze of hanging lotus buds. Others may have a frieze of animals or of figures between the rays and the main zone. 558-560 (PI. 53), all with animals, are the examples from the Agora.'1 Cylindrical supports do not appear in Attic black figure until after the middle of the 6th century, and not very many examples are known.11The Agora seems to have yielded the largest number, and all of them date between 510 and 490 B.C. Cylindrical supports were probably used for such shapes as the pointed amphora, which cannot stand unaided, and the Panathenaicamphora,which is prone to tip over.12No cylindricalsupport from the Agora has been connectedwith the vase that rested in it, but elsewhere, two pointed amphorae by the Acheloos Painter have been found with supports.13These two supports are not by the Acheloos Painter but by anotherartist who probably also decoratedthe cylindrical support in Toronto.14From this admittedly slender evidence, it is tempting to speculatethat painterswho specializedin decoratinglarge pots may have left the task of decoratingcylindricalsupportsto those accustomedto working with the smaller shapes. The examples from the Agora furnish some evidence for this suggestion. The one attributed support, 564 (PI. 54), is by the Edinburgh Painter, or near him, and 575 (Pl. 55) may best be comparedwith the Diosphos Painter. Both are painters of small vases, especially lekythoi and small neck-amphorae. The remaining cylindrical supports from the Agora are unattributed,except for 569-573, which may belong to the Leagros Group. The stylistic characterof most of these supports suggests that they come from late black-figue workshopsspecializing in smaller vases. The drawing on many is rather hasty, and details, such as the pupils of eyes,a, re sometimesomitted (e.g. 579-582: P. 55). The scheme of decorationon cylindricalsupportsis similar to that on contemporaryconicalones. The figures occupy most of the surface, with ornamental patterns painted above and below, although occasionally as on 584 these areas are undecorated.15The ornamental pattern above the figures was probablysimilar to that below, as on 575, but this conclusionmay seem hasty in view of the fragmentarycondition of the Agora supports and the paucity of whole examples elsewhere.16 Yet, the Agora material gives a good idea of the range of patternsthat may appear above and below the figures. 564 (P1. 54), 572, and 574 have rays above the figures; 575 (Pl. 55) has rosettes, 582 (PI. 55) has rosettes above a zone of white maeander on black glaze; 578 (Pi. 55) has a ribbon pattern;and 583 (P1. 55) has upright lotus buds.17Below the figures, a zone of invertedrays is the most commonornament, sometimesby itself as on 569, 571, and 573, at other times with a band of ornament above, such as dots (563: PI. 54) or a wavy line (577) painted in added white on black glaze. The band of chevronson 576 very likely appearedabovea zone of rays. 568 has dots between the tips of the rays. 575 is our only example that has rosettes. A number of fragments, 587-601 (Pls. 55, 56), come from supports,but it is uncertainto which Collection (photo D.A.I. Athens, varia 1060-1063); London, B.M. B 298 (Boardman, ABFV, p. 166, fig. 293); New York, M.M.A. 57.12.8, fragments. All but the Vlastos fragment are contemporarywith 557 (PI. 53). The Vlastos stand is earlier. For a key pattern at the top of a conical support, cf. the small lebes gamikos, Petit Palais 309 (CVA, Petit Palais [France 15], pi. 9 [6491:1-4);for hanging lotus buds, cf. 516 (PI. 49). 10For animals, cf. also the fragmentarylebes gamikos, New York, M.M.A. 57.12.8. For figures, cf. the louterion from Menidi, Athens, N.M. 15934 (Callipolitis-Feytmans, "Louteria",pls. 18, 20): chariot race. n For a list, cf. R. Lullies, Die Spitzamphorades Kleophrades-Malers, Bremen 1957, p. 18, note to p. 6. His no. 9 is now Toledo 58.69 B (Paralip. 168, 2 bis; CVA, Toledo 1 [USA 17], pi. 16 [7961).
12 Lullies, op. cit., pp.
6-7.
13London, B.M. B 167 (ABV 382, 1; Paralip. 168, 1) and
Toledo 58.69 A-B (Paralip. 168, 2 bis; CVA, Toledo 1 [USA 17], pls. 14, 15 [794, 795]:1, 2, and 16 [796]). 14Toronto 919.5.140 (Paralip. 169; CVA, Toronto 1 [Canada 1], pl. 28 [28]:4-6). 15 Also, Toledo 58.69 B (Paralip. 168, 2 bis; CVA, Toledo 1 [USA 17], pl. 16 [796]); London, B.M. B 167 (ABV 382, 1; Paralip. 168, 1); Toronto 919.5.140 (Paralip. 169; CVA, Toronto 1 [Canada 1], pl. 28 [28]:4-6); and Athens, N.M. 501 (CC 685), unpublished. 16The only other completeexample with the same ornament above and below the figures that is known to us is Eleusis 1244 (Hesperia 5, 1936, p. 67, fig. 6). 17 For this pattern, cf. also Eleusis 1244 (ibid.).
32
SHAPE STUDIES
type each belongs. 589, 591, and 592, late 7th and early 6th-centuryexamples, have a band of glaze on the inside, characteristicof cylindrical supports which begin only after the middle of the 6th century. 587 (P1. 55), 590 (P1. 55), 594, and 596 are fenestrated,and 593 (PI. 56) may be from a fenestrated support or from a leg. The three late fragments, 599-601 (PI. 56), do not preserve enough of the wall to determinewhether the shape was conicalor cylindrical. SOSIANSTAND 602
P1. 56
Stands are much smaller than supports. They have a flat or slightly convex top surface surroundedby a thick torus molding and are supportedby a stemmedfoot. The top may be decorated in black figure or in red figure. The rest is plain black. The type is called Sosian after the one in Berlin of about 500 B.C. signed by the potter Sosias and decorated in red figure.18Not many examples of Sosian stands are known, and with one exception,19all of them date in the secondhalf of the 6th century and the first two decades of the 5th. The only black-figuredexample from the Agora is 602 (P1. 56), which is probably late 6th century, but the type also appears in the Agora black pattern, as well as in plain black.20The purpose of these small stands is unknown. LOUTERIA 603-607
Pls. 56 and 57
The louterion is a wide, shallow, spouted krater that has a very low rim and upright loop handles attachedto the shoulder.1Like the kraters,it is glazed on the inside. Normally the louterionhas an echinus foot, but in the dromosof a tomb at Menidi, fragmentsof 13 standedlouteria were found. They seem to constitutea special group ranging in date from the Late Geometricperiod to the 4th century B.C. with the largest number dating before 550.2 Two are decoratedin black figure, one of them signed by Sophilos as potter,3the other still unattributedbut having Antimenean features.4 Louteriaoccur in Geometricbut are most commonin Protoattic.Very few are known in Attic black figure, and nearly all those with known provenancescome from Attica.5Most of them date before the middle of the 6th century.Only five very fragmentarylouteria,603-607, have been identifiedin the black-figuredmaterial from the Agora. The shape and scheme of decorationof 6th-centurylouteria are influencedby both the dinos and the column-krater.6The low rim and the sharply curvedshoulderrecall the dinos;the echinus foot with rays above comes from the column-krater.The rim may be flat on top, like that of the dinos, and decoratedwith a pattern, usually rosettes,7as on 605 and 606 (P1. 56), or the vase may have a 18 Berlin 2315
(ARV2 21, -). 19New York, M.M.A. 31.11.4 signed by Ergotimos and Kleitias (ABV78, 12; Paralip. 30, 12; Bothmer,Amasis Painter, p. 152, fig. 93). 20 To the list given in Agora XII, pp. 179-180 add the folall Athens, N.M. 961: rider to left (silunpublished: lowing, houette technique); Eleusis: Herakles running to left, looking back, holding the tripod (Bothmer,FestschriftBrommer,p. 61, no. 169); Oxford, fragment:man (head) to right, with spear or staff. The black-patternedexample from the Agora is P 6575: rosette. 1
For the shape, cf. Callipolitis-Feytmans, "Louteria".On the use of the term "louteria"for spoutedbowls, cf. AgoraVIII, p. 43. 2 Callipolitis-Feytmans,"Louteria",pp. 43-65.
3 Athens, N.M. 15918 and 15442 (ABV 40, 21 and 42, 36; Paralip. 18, 21 and 36; Baklr, Sophilos, pls. 8-10). The old numbersare 2035.2 and 2035.1, respectively.Callipolitis-Feytmans ("Louteria",p. 54) has suggestedthat this louterionbore a double signature, as that of the dinos Athens, N.M. 15499 (ABV39, 16;Paralip. 18, 16; Baklr,Sophilos,pl. 6, fig. 10), and that Sophilos may have contributedto the developmentof both the louterionand the lebes gamikos. 4Athens, N.M. 15929, 15933, and 15934 (CallipolitisFeytmans, "Louteria",pp. 56-59, pls. 18-21). 5 The two main exceptionsare Corfu E 61.09, from Garitsa, close in style to Sophilos (Paralip. 19), and Berlin F 1722, from Chiusi, by the PrometheusPainter (ABV 104, 124; Paralip. 39, 124). 6 Cf. Callipolitis-Feytmans,"Louteria",pp. 24-25, 33-34. 7 Otherswith rosettes:Corfu E 61.09 (Paralip. 19);Athens,
DINOI
33
simple roundedrim, as 604. The main figureddecorationappears high on the shoulderand is most often set in unframedpanels,8usually without even a tongue patternon the shoulderat the junction with the rim.9605 and 606 (P1. 56) are unusual for having tongues,10and 605 probablyhad its decoration continuing round the vase as on column-kraters.The area between the main figure zone and the rays above the foot may be black, or there may'be one or more friezes of animals or ornament. The Agora louteria are rim and shoulder fragments,so one may not be certainhow this area was treated on them. The main figure zone on the back of the vase is a long narrow panel, usually with a frieze composition. The cavalcadepainted on the louterion found on Corfu that is close to Sophilos in style provides a good illustration,'1and 606 was probablysimilar. On the front of the louterion,the figures may be set in two panels, one on each side of the spout, as on 604, or there may be a single composition that takes into account the position of the spout. Two large confronted animals, with a smaller one or a floral ornament below the spout, is the preferred subject. The louterion in Corfu and the one in Athens attributedto Sophilos offer good examples.'2 603 (P1. 56) very likely was similar, with two confrontedsirens. DINOI 608-617
Fig. 13 Pls. 57 and 58
The dinos is a large round-bottomedbowl that sits on a stand. It has a flat rim that may be plain on the side or may have a slight overhang,similar to that of the column-krater.2Dinoi have very short necks and no handles, thus allowing the decorationto continueroundthe vase uninterrupted.Their stands suggest a metal prototype.The shape is known throughoutall Attic black figure and continues well down into red figure, but it is never so popular as the more practical column-krater,and not too many examples are known. The earliest attributed Attic black-figureddinos is the wellpreservedone by the Gorgon Painter.3Sophilos has left us the largest number attributedto a single painter, seven in all, mostly fragmentarybut one almost completelypreserved,including its stand.4 N.M. 16385 (ABV 40, 19; Paralip. 18, 19); Athens, N.M. 15920 (Callipolitis-Feytmans, "Louteria",p. 49, no. M 8); Athens, N.M. 15918 and 15442 (ABV 40, 21 and 42, 36; Paralip. 18, 21 and 36). Other patterns on the rims of black-figured louteria: Rays: once Berlin 1682 (ABV 5, 4; Paralip. 2, 8); Kerameikos, inv. no. 1295 (Callipolitis-Feytmans, "Louteria", p. 19, no. 10); Athens, N.M. 19168 (ibid., p. 28, no. 2). Tongues: Athens, N.M. 16386 (ibid., p. 19, no. 11). Guilloche: Athens, N.M. 16387 (ibid., p. 33, no. 1). Step pattern: Berlin F 1722 (ABV 104, 124; Paralip. 39, 124). 8 Louteria with the figures not in panels: Kerameikos,inv. no. 1295 (Callipolitis-Feytmans, "Louteria",p. 19, no. 10); Athens, N.M. 16386 (ibid., p. 19, no. 11); Athens, N.M. 19168 (ibid., p. 28, no. 2); Athens, N.M. 16387 (ibid., p. 33, no. 1); Berlin F 1722 (ABV 104, 124; Paralip. 39, 124). The last two are particularly influenced by the column-kraterin shape and in scheme of decoration. 9 Callipolitis-Feytmans, "Louteria",p. 24. 10For a later louterion with tongues at the junction with the rim, cf. Athens, N.M. 15929, 15933, and 15934 (CallipolitisFeytmans, "Louteria,"pp. 56-59). l Corfu E 61.09 (Paralip. 19). 12 Corfu E 61.09 (Paralip. 19); Athens, N.M. 16385 (ABV 40, 19;Paralip. 18, 19; Baklr, Sophilos,pls. 85,86: here [pp. 4546] Baklr, following Scheibler, withdraws the attribution to Sophilos).
'For the shape, cf. esp. Richter and Milne, Shapes and Names, pp. 9-10; Bothmer,BMFA 46,1948, p. 42; R. Lullies, AK 14, 1971, pp. 49-51. For black-bodieddinoi, cf. the list by Bothmerin CVA, Boston 2 [USA 19], pp. 9-10. 2 For the plain rim, cf. Athens, N.M. 15499 by Sophilos (ABV 39, 16; Paralip. 18, 16); for the rim with overhang, cf. Madrid 10902 by the Antimenes Painter (ABV 275, 133). Difficult to parallel is the tall flaring rim of the namepiece of the Painter of Louvre E 876 (ABV 90, 1). This dinos also has an echinus foot. Two exceptionsto the rim being completelyflat on top: Vatican 306 (Albizzati, pl. 29), which has a small upright projectionat the inner edge, and Akropolis 590 (Graef, p. 64 and pl. 27), which has a small rounded projectionat its outer edge just above the tongue pattern on the shoulder. 3 Louvre E 874 (ABV 8, 1; Paralip. 6, 1). For the 7th-century examples, Attic and non-Attic, cf. Lullies, AK 14, 1971, p. 50, note 40. 4 Louvre E 873 (ABV 39, 12; Baklr, Sophilos, pls. 46-48); London, B.M. B 100 and B 601.26 (ABV 39, 13; Baklr, Sophilos, pls. 66-70: here [p. 39] the dinos is considereda workshop piece); CambridgeN 128 (ABV 39, 14; Baklr, Sophilos,pl. 65, fig. 129); Akropolis 587 (ABV39, 15; Baklr, Sophilos,pls. 3-5, 89-90); Athens, N.M. 15499 (ABV39, 16; Paralip. 18, 16; Baklr, Sophilos, pls. 6, 7); Herakleion (Paralip. 18, 14 bis; Baklr, Sophilos,pls. 80, 81, figs. 158-160: here [pp. 40 and 42] the vase
34
SHAPE STUDIES
Not very many Attic black-figureddinoi have been found in the Agora excavations:except for one, 610 (Pl. 58), they are very fragmentary,yet they give an idea of the various schemesof decoration used for this shape. The earliest Attic black-figureddinoi have the decorationon the body set in friezes. Usually, there are human figureson the shoulderin the largest of the friezes and below that zones of animals and ornament.Occasionallythere is a secondzone of human figures below the first, as on 610, the best example of the system among the Agora dinoi. Normally, there are tongues on the shoulderat the junction with the neck and ornamenton the top side of the rim. 610 is unusual in having neither. The ornament on the top side of the rim varies a good bit, just as it does on the rims of columnkraters.On the very bottom of the vessel, there is often a whirligig. Again, 610 is unusual in being reserved.5 This schemeof decorationcontinuesuntil the middleof the century,perhapseven a little past it to judge by the splendiddinos from the Akropolissigned by Lydos that ought to date between 550 and 540 B.C.6In the late second quarter of the 6th century, a new system of decorationappears which reducesthe numberof friezes and leaves a wide band of glaze between the figuresand the whirligig or reservedmedallionon the bottom.7The Agora dinoi are too fragmentaryto be certainif any one of them was decoratedin this mannerinsteadof with friezes. 612 (PI. 57) may have been, for it finds its best parallel with the one in Brussels.8An oddity of the time is the namepieceof the Painter of Louvre E 876, which has a wide flaring neck, a rolled rim, and an echinus foot.9On its shoulderis a narrow frieze of figures and below that two larger zones of figures. The bottomof the vase, including the foot, is black. 613 (P1. 57) may be from a dinos decoratedin a similar manner,although one may not be certain about the shape of the rim or if it had a foot. Very late in the third quarter of the 6th century, the system of decorationof the Attic blackfigureddinos undergoesa final change. From now on, figuresappearonly on the top side and inside of the rim. On the overhangthere is usually ivy, as on column-kraters.The rest of the vase is black, except for the tongue pattern on the shoulderat the junction with the neck and for the whirligig on the bottom. The inside of the rim is nearly always decoratedwith ships,10which would appear to float on the mixture of wine and water when the vessel was filled. The top side of the rim may have 1 figures or ornament. The earliest example of this new scheme of decorationappears on the dinos is judged to be a workshoppiece;the vase has been mendedsince photography);and London, B.M. 1971.11-1.1 (Paralip. 19, 16 bis; Bakir, Sophilos, pls. 1, 2; D. Williams, "Sophilos in the British Museum," Greek Vasesin the J. Paul Getty Museum 1, 1983, pp. 9-34). Perhaps add, London, B.M. B 103.14.2 (E. A. Gardiner, Naukratis II, London 1888, pl. 9, 7; Beazley and Payne,JHS 49, 1929, p. 255, fig. 2, no. 3). Also, two dinoidvessels: Akropolis 585 a (ABV 40, 17; Baklr, Sophilos,pl. 35, figs. 64, 65, and pl. 36) and Akropolis 585 b (ABV 40, 18; Baklr, Sophilos,pl. 34, fig. 63). 5 For a reservedmedallion, cf. also Louvre C 11243 (CVA, Louvre 12 [France 19], pl. 152 [825]). 6 Akropolis 607 (ABV 107, 1; Tiverios, pls. l:a, 48-50, 98:a, /; most recently, M. B. Moore, AJA 83, 1979, pp. 79-99). 7 For examples, cf. Brussels R 222 (CVA, Brussels 1 [Belgium 1], pl. 2 [13]:1); Louvre C 11243 (CVA, Louvre 12 [France 19], pl. 152 [825]) and Louvre E 738 (CVA, Louvre 12 [France 19], pls. 153, 154 [826, 827]:1). 8 Brussels R 222 (CVA, Brussels 1 [Belgium 1], pl. 2 [13]:1). 9 ABV 90, 1. 10A late example of the older system of decorationseems to be a fragmentary dinos in Tiibingen, S./10 1508, that is
attributedto the manner of the Antimenes Painter (CVA, Tiibingen 3 [Germany47], P!. 10 [2225]:1, 2). An exception to ships appears on the small dinos in Copenhagen, inv. no. 4219 (CVA, Copenhagen3 [Denmark3], pl. 124 [126]:3), which has a frieze of vertical dolphins (for this motif, cf. 1353: PI. 93). Ships occuron the insides of rims of other kraters. Cf., for example, Copenhagen, inv. no. Chr. VIII 754 (CVA, Copenhagen 8 [Denmark 8], pl. 322 [325]:3) and Heidelberg S 39 (CVA, Heidelberg 4 [Germany 31], pl. 146 [1485]:6), both volute-kraters;or Basel, Antikenmuseumund Sammlung Ludwig (E. Berger and R. Lullies, Antike Kunstwerkeaus der SammlungLudwig, I, Friihe Tonsarkophageund Vasen, Mainz 1977, p. 77), Boston, M.F.A. 68.777 (CVA, Boston 2 [USA 19], pl. 109 [9431:2), Louvre C 11270 (CVA, Louvre 12 [France 19], pi. 173 [846]:1), and New York, M.M.A. 07.286.76 (Bothmer, Festschrift Brommer, pls. 17, 18), all column-kraters;also, 1704 (PI. 111), a cup with ships roundthe rim on the inside. This and the two that go with it are not earlierthan the firstoccurrenceof ships on kratersand dinoi. 1I For a list, cf. the one compiledby Bothmerin CVA, Boston 2 [USA 19], pp. 9-10.
HYDRIAI
35
in the Villa Giulia signed by Exekias,12who very likely is responsible for its introduction.His innovativechanges in existing shapes and his inventionof new ones are well attested.13614 (P1.57) is the only dinos from the Agora decoratedin this manner. Stands for dinoi are slender, metallic-looking supports. They may be plain black or decorated with friezes of ornamentand animals.14 Three fragmentsof stands for dinoi have been found in the Agora, but none may be connectedwith one of the dinoi that has survived.Nor do they illustratethe characterof these stands very well. 615 is a foot fragment with a rilled vertical surface and ornamental decorationon the top side; 616 (P1. 57) has rays on the side and animals on the top side. 617 (P1. 57) comes from the top of a stand that supported a dinos about the size of 610 (PI. 58). It is unusual for having a frieze of human figures below the top molding.
HYDRIAI 618-669
Pls. 59-63
The hydria, or water jar, is commonin Attic black figure.1Unlike many other shapes it is also well known in bronze,2and many clay examples have rims and handles that suggest metal prototypes.3 In Attic pottery,the hydria appears in the Geometricperiod and is well known in early Protoattic,4 the namepieceof the Analatos Painter being the most completeand the most famousexample.5The hydria seems to go out of fashion in Attic vase painting after about 675 B.C., but it reappearsearly in the 6th century. No Attic black-figuredexample is known among the vases decoratedby the first generation of painters nor does there seem to be an example among the unattributed vases contemporarywith them. The fragmentaryone from Samos by the KX Painter,6which dates about 580 B.C., is still the earliest preserved.
The hydria is characterizedprimarilyby two horizontalhandles attachedto the shoulderor to the body, which are used for lifting and setting down, and a vertical handle at the back, which is used for pouring or for carrying when empty.7 Three types of Attic black-figuredhydriai are known. 12Villa Giulia 50599 (ABV 146, 20). 13Cf. K. Stahler, JOAI 49, 1968-1971, pp. 79-113; also,
M. B. Moore, AJA 84, 1980, p. 432 and notes 125, 126. 14 Examples: Louvre E 874 by the Gorgon Painter (ABV 8, 1;Paralip. 6, 1); London, B.M. 1971.11-1.1 by Sophilos(Paralip. 19, 16 bis; Baklr, Sophilos,pls. 1, 2; Williams, loc. cit. [footnote 4 above, pp. 33-34]; Vatican 306 (Albizzati, p. 102); Wurzburg 453 (Langlotz, pl. 129); Brussels R 222 (CVA, Brussels 1 [Belgium 1], pl. 2 [13]:1); Louvre E 720 (CVA, Louvre 2 [France 2], pl. 1 [73]:1); Boston, M.F.A. 90.154 (CVA, Boston 2 [USA 19], pl. 65 [899]:2-4); Heidelberg 63/20 (CVA, Heidelberg 4 [Germany 31], pl. 179 [1518]:4, 5). 1 For the shape, cf. esp. E. Folzer, Die Hydria. Ein Beitrag zur griechischen Vasenkunde, Leipzig 1906; Richter and Milne, Shapes and Names, pp. 11-12; E. Diehl, Die Hydria: Formgeschichte und Verwendung im Kult des Altertums, Mainz 1964, which should be consulted along with the review by Bothmer in Gnomon 37, 1965, pp. 599-608; also, Agora XII, p. 53 with further bibliography. 2 Cf. Bothmer, Studies in ClassicalArt and Archaeology.A Tributeto Peter Heinrich von Blanckenhagen,New York 1979, p. 63; also the bibliographyin note 1. 3 Especially corrugated rims and concave horizontal handles. Cf., e.g., the namepiece of the Painter of London B 76 (ABV 85, 1; Paralip. 32, 1); two more by him, New York, M.M.A. 45.11.2 (ABV 85, 2) and Copenhagen 13536 (ABV
714; Paralip. 32, 2 bis). It is tempting to suggest that in representationsof the pursuit of Troilos where Polyxena has dropped her hydria and it lies on the ground intact, as in the illustration on the FranCoisvase and in many others,the painterhas in mind a metal vessel. For a broken hydria in Troilos representations, cf., e.g., Leipzig T 49 (CVA, Leipzig 2 [DDR 2], pl. 24 [85]:3); Heidelberg 72/1 (AA [JdI 92], 1977, p. 29, fig. 11); Hanover 1965.30 by the AntimenesPainter (Paralip. 119, 27 ter, formerly in the Bareiss Collection;CVA, Hannover 1 [Germany 34], pl. 19 [1651]:1);Munich 1722 by the Antimenes Painter (ABV 269, 33); London, B.M. B 307 by a painter of the Leagros Group (ABV 361, 17); and New York, M.M.A. 06.1021.50 in the mannerof the Red-line Painter (ABV 606, 21). 4 J. N. Coldstream, Greek Geometric Pottery, London 1968, pp. 59-60; J. Cook, BSA 35, 1934/1935, pp. 165-169, and especially the inventoryon pp. 212-219; also, Agora VIII, pp. 34-35. 5 Athens, N.M. 313. Cf. Cook, op. cit., pls. 38:b, 39. 6 ABV25, 18. 7 On methods of carrying, cf. Folzer, op. cit. (footnote 1 above), p. 10; Richter and Milne, Shapes and Names, pp. 11-12. For illustrationscf., e.g., two by the Priam Painter, Boulogne 406 (ABV 332, 21) and London, B.M. B 332 (ABV 333, 27); also Vatican 417 by the Acheloos Painter (ABV 384, 26). For the pad worn by the women as a cushion for the water jar, called a rv?Xror i7renpa, cf. Bothmer and Moore, CVA, New York 4 [USA 16], p. 45.
36
SHAPESTUDIES
The earliest has a roundor ovoid body;the secondhas the shouldersharplyoffset fromthe bodyand is the principaltype in Attic black figure from about 540 B.C.on; the latest, known also as the kalpis, has a neck and a bodythat forma continuous-curveprofile, similarto that of the one-pieceamphora and the pelike. All three types of hydria have been found in the Agora, but consideringthe popularity of the shape in the last third of the 6th century,it is surprisingthat there are so few examples from these excavations.It may well be that this shape was mainly one for export or was used more in sanctuariesand tombs than in civic centersand domesticquarters.8 HYDRIAI 618-624 ROUND-BODIED
P1. 59
The earliest type of Attic black-figuredhydria has a plain or corrugatedrim, a round or slightly ovoid body, and an echinus foot. The horizontalhandles are attachedto the body at about the point of greatestdiameter.The verticalhandle is shortand does not rise abovethe top of the rim, as it does on many of the later shoulderedhydriai, but its upper part is attachedto the neck itself, occasionally well below the rim. On the neck, there is sometimesa drip ring.9The round-bodiedhydria appears in Attic black figure at just about the same time as the loutrophorosand the ovoid neck-amphora, i.e. about 580 B.C.,and it is the preferredtype of hydria untiljust after the middleof the 6th century. Early examples, such as the namepiece of the Painter of London B 76,10tend to be rather squat; later ones, like the one in Boston by the Archippe Painter,11are taller and more elegant. The round-bodiedhydriai from the Agora, 618-624, do not give a good idea of the shape itself, but 618 (P1. 59) and 620 (P1. 59) are importantfor their metallic features. The scheme of decorationfor round-bodiedhydriai varies considerably.The only consistentelements are the tongues on the shoulderat the junction with the neck and the rays abovethe foot. On the neck, there may be an ornamentalpattern,or it may be left black as is the case with the hydriai by the Archippe Painter and with most shoulderedhydriai.'2620 and 622 are unusual for having figures on the neck. On the bodies of the early examples, the figureddecorationis set in friezes,just as it is on so many contemporaryovoid neck-amphorae.618 (PI. 59), 619, and 623 (PI. 59) were probablydecoratedin this manner. 618 has an ornamentalfrieze directlybelow the handles instead of in the handle zone itself as is customary.Later round-bodiedhydriai often have the figureddecoration on the shoulder set in a frieze and that on the body placed in a panel,13just as it is on the shoulderedhydria. The frieze on the shoulderis normallyunframed.The panel on the bodymay be framedor unframed,and the area below it may have a frieze of animals, or it may be left black.The Agora examples are too fragmentaryto be certain whether any one of them had the figured decoration set in a panel. 8 For ordinarydaily needs, the plain hydria was most commonly used, and many of them have been found in the Agora. Cf. Agora XII, pp. 38-39, 200-201. 9 Cf., e.g., London, B.M. B 76 (ABV 85, 1; Paralip. 32, 1); also New York, M.M.A. 06.1021.48 (Richter and Milne, Shapes and Names, fig. 77). Cf. also, Villa Giulia 22308 that is Lydan in style (MonAnt 42, 1955, p. 1064, no. 29 and pl. 3). o0ABV 85, 1; Paralip. 32, 1. I Boston, M.F.A. 67.1006 (Paralip. 43; CVA, Boston 2 [USA 19], pls. 69 [903]:2-4 and 70 [904]). 12 For the Archippe Painter, cf. Bothmer, AK 12, 1969, pp. 26-29. Some others with black necks:two by the Painter of London B 76: Swiss, private (Paralip. 32, 1 bis), and New York, M.M.A. 45.11.2 (ABV 85, 2); New York, M.M.A. 06.1021.48 (Richter and Milne, Shapes and Names, fig. 77).
Round-bodied hydriai with black necks seem to appear only after the shoulderedhydria is introduced. 13 Cf., e.g., three by the Archippe Painter: Vienna 3613 (ABV 106, 1); Louvre E 869 (ABV 106, 2); and Basel (AK 12, 1969, pls. 17,18); also, New York, M.M.A. 06.1021.48 (Richter and Milne, Shapes and Names, fig. 77) and New York, M.M.A. 74.51.1331 (G. M. A. Richter,Handbookof the Greek Collection,Cambridge,Mass. 1953, pl. 28:a). Two by the Archippe Painter have a single panel placed high with a frieze of ornamentbelow in the handle zone: Cab. Med. 253 (ABV 104, 127) and Italian Market (ABV 104, 129). For the attribution, cf. Bothmer,AK 12, 1969, pp. 26-29. Most unusual is the unattributedhydria in the Villa Giulia, inv. no. 22308 (MonAnt 42, 1955, p. 1064, no. 29 and pl. 3), that has a frieze of figures on the shouldercontinuinground to the vertical handle.
HYDRIAI
37
625-649 Pls. 59-62 This type of hydria differs from the round-bodiedone chiefly by having its shoulder set at an angle to its body so that there is no longer a continuouscurvebetween the two parts when the vase is seen in profile. In Attic black figure, it appears most often from about 530 B.C. on, althoughthe type is known as early as the second quarter of the 6th century B.C.It is not certain who was the first potter to fashion the shouldered hydria,14but the earliest painters to decoratethem are Kleitias, Lydos, and a contemporary,the Painter of London B 76,15 who also painted the round-bodied variety.16One by each artist, 625-627 (Pls. 59, 60), has been found in the Agora, and togetherwith three unattributedexamples, 628-630 (P1. 60), they comprisethe earliest shoulderedhydriai from these excavations.625 (PI. 59) is of special interest for it adds a new shape to the ones known to be decoratedby Kleitias. The shoulderedhydria fashionedbefore 540 B.C.has a somewhatflaring neck with a torus mouth and a broad body supported by an echinus foot. The shoulder is slightly convex with the angle formed by it and the body not very sharp. 626 (Pl. 59) by the Painter of London B 76 and 632 (PI. 60) by a painter of Group E are the best examples from the Agora. After 540, the shouldered hydria becomes increasingly tall in proportionto its diameter and more elegant in appearance.17 This later type has a torus foot and a wide flaring mouth with torus molding. The horizontal handles often curve upward slightly, and the vertical handle may still be round or oval in section, although sometimesit is ridged. The Agora examples are too fragmentaryto present a good picture of the later type, but 635 (P1. 60) has a decorativefeature that does not seem to appear on other hydriai (see below). The scheme of decorationfor the shoulderedhydria is regulated by the natural divisions of the vase. A friezelike compositionappears on the shoulder,similar to that on the type of neck-amphora having the figureson both the shoulderand the body.18On the body of the hydria,the figuresare set in a broad panel, which is normally framed at the sides by pattern with an ornamentalfrieze or a figured predella below. On a few examples, such as 628 (P1. 60), the side and bottom edges of the panels are left plain. As on the round-bodiedhydria, the only consistentornamentalelements are the tongues on the shoulder at the junction with the neck and the rays above the foot. At the top of the panel on the turn of the shoulder,there is usually a single line; occasionally,as on 644 and 645 (PI. 61), there is a key pattern. The ornament framing the panel at the sides varies a good bit, although ivy with or without dots or dot clusters seems to be the most frequentpattern, e.g. 626, 627, 632, and 640 (Pls. 59-61). The wavy line with dots on 635 (PI. 60) appears to be unique. Some of the Agora hydriai have figured predellas, 636, 638, and 639 (P1. 61); others, 642 and 643 (PI. 61), have ornamentalfriezes. SHOULDEREDHYDRIAI
14
The earliest signed examples seem to be the two by the potter Timagoras, which are attributedto the Taleides Painter: Louvre F 39 (ABV 174, 5; Paralip. 72, 5) and Louvre F 38, which also praises Andokides (ABV 174, 7; Paralip. 72, 7). These date about 540 B.C.,roughly two decades later than the shouldered hydriai by Lydos (ABV 108, 12-18), which were decoratedin the early part of his career and thus should not be later than about 560 B.C.,although the one in Gottingen (ABV 109, 19) and the one in the Kerameikos (Paralip. 45) may be about 550 B.C.It is tempting to suggest that Lydos may have potted as well as painted, but it has not yet been shown conclusively that he did (cf. M. B. Moore, AJA 83, 1979, p. 99, note 166). A shouldered hydria contemporarywith these by Lydos, Louvre E 735 (ABV 85, 2), has been loosely connectedwith the
painter of the neck-amphorain Eleusis potted by Kleimachos (ABV 85), but this is a painting connection,not a potting one. 15Kleitias: 625 (PI. 59). Lydos: ABV 108-109, 12-19; Paralip. 45. Painter of London B 76: ABV 86, 4, 5; Paralip. 32, 4. 16 ABV 85-86, 1-3; Paralip. 32, 1-2 bis. 17For a brief study of some late 6th-centuryshoulderedhydriai, cf. H. Bloesch,JHS 71, 1951, pp. 29-39, esp. 35-37. 18 E.g., New York, M.M.A. 17.230.14 by Exekias (ABV 144, 3; Paralip. 59, 3; CVA, New York 4 [USA 16], pls. 16-19 [744-747]). Two hydriai by the Antimenes Painter have black shoulders, the figures appearing on the neck (white ground) and on the body: Dresden ZV 1779 (ABV 268, 21) and Dresden ZV 1780 (ABV 268, 22).
SHAPE STUDIES
38
KALPIDES 650-669
Pls. 62, 63
In Attic black figure, the kalpis, in imitation of the red-figuredkalpides by the painters of the Pioneer Group, appears in the late 6th century and continuesinto the 5th. Not too many examples are known, for the shape is more frequentin red figure than it is in black figure, and in black figure it never competessuccessfullywith the more popularshoulderedhydria.The kalpis is distinguished from the shouldered hydria primarily by the continuous curve formed by its neck, shoulder, and body. It has a torus mouth and a torus or echinus foot. The horizontal handles usually curve upward slightly; the short, vertical handle rises from the shoulderand is attachedto the neck well below the mouth, similar to that of the round-bodiedvariety. 650 (P1. 62), 653, 657 (P1. 62), 658 (P1. 63), 665, and 666 (P1. 63) are the best-preservedexamples from the Agora. Two systems of decoration are used for the kalpis. The first, perhaps the earliest, shows the figures on the shoulder only. The rest of the vase is black, except for a broad band of ornamentin the handle zone. The secondsystem has the figures set in a panel on the body. PICTUREON THE SHOULDER 650-652
P1. 62
The figures appear in a panel, usually with an ornamentalframeat the top and on the sides, as on 650 and 652 (P1. 62).19Occasionally,there is ornamentonly at the top of the panel, and the sides are left plain,20although this is rare, and on those where the panel is particularlysmall, there is often no ornamentat all.21Sometimesall four sides have decorativeborders,22and there may be no ornamentin the handle zone unless the panel is placed very high. Above the figures, the preferred ornamentsare the key pattern, the net pattern, and the invertedlotus-bud frieze. On the sides, the net pattern is used most often. The type of ornamentin the handle zone varies, but ivy, as on 650 (P1.62), seems to appear most often.23652 (P1.62) is unusual for having simply a narrow reserved line. PICTUREON THE BODY
653-669
Pls. 62, 63
Most of the Agora kalpides are decoratedaccordingto this arrangement.The figuresappear in a panel that extends over some of the shoulderand much of the body of the vase, 657 (P1.62) and 658 (P1. 63) being good though small examples. The panel is decoratedat the top by a band of ornament, most often a frieze of inverted lotus buds as on 655 (PI. 62) or a net pattern as on 657, 658, 663 (Pls. 62, 63), and 664. The sides may be framed as on 665 or unframedas on 653, 657, 658, 663, and 664. Rarely are all four sides without ornament as on 659 and 666 (P1. 63).24 Most unusual is the frieze of upright lotus buds below the figures on 653 for which there seems to be no parallel. 19The appearanceof ornament on the side of the panel on 652 (PI. 62) indicatesthat there was a decorativepattern above, even though this is not preserved. 20 Ornament at the top of the panel only: e.g., Sydney 46.04 in the manner of the Acheloos Painter (ABV 386, 17); Kassel T. 683 (CVA, Kassel 1 [Germany35], pls. 24 [1704]:3,4 and 25 [1705]:1); Princeton 170, near the Madrid Painter (Paralip. 145, ii). 21 Examples: Florence 3858 (CVA, Florence 5 [Italy 42], pl. 42 [1906]); Vatican 428, 429, and 430 (Albizzati, pl. 66); Hamburg 1971.987 (CVA, Hamburg 1 [Germany 41], pl. 26 [1992]); Wurzburg 324 (Langlotz, pi. 98); Louvre C 10693 (CVA, Louvre 11 [France 18], pl. 151 [824]:7). 22 Cf., e.g., the Tampa Museum, Tampa, Florida, ex Maplewood, Noble, of the Leagros Group (ABV 695, 83 bis;
Parke-Bernet 9. April, 1953, p. 25, no. 150); Greenwich, Bareiss,once on loan to the MetropolitanMuseum, L.69.11.12 (Greek Vases: Molly and Walter Bareiss Collection [The J. Paul Getty Museum], Malibu 1983, p. 39). 23 Some examples of other ornaments:Key pattern:Florence 3858 (CVA, Florence 5 [Italy 42], pl. 42 [1906]); Hamburg 1917.987 (CVA, Hamburg I [Germany41], pl. 26 [1992]). Circumscribedpalmettes:Greenwich, Bareiss, once on loan to the MetropolitanMuseum, L.69.11.12 (footnote22 above). Inverted lotus buds: Vatican 431 (Albizzati, pl. 66). Upright lotus buds: Princeton170, near the Madrid Painter (Paralip. 145, ii). 24 Even rarer seem to be panels with decorationon all four sides. Cf. one near the Nikoxenos Painter, Montreal 39.Cb.1, which has circumscribedpalmettes on all four sides (Paralip. 172,3).
OINOCHOAI
39
OINOCHOAI 670-786
Fig. 14 Pls. 64-73
The oinochoe is a jug used for pouring wine and other liquids.1The shape is well known in pottery from the Geometricperiod on,2and a significantnumberof bronzeexamples from the 6th to the 4th centuries have come down to us.3 The oinochoe is generally characterizedby a single vertical handle, either high or low, a trefoil or plain mouth, and an echinus or torus foot. The over-all appearance is sturdy and practical looking. There are two basic types of pouring jug, each distinguished by the shape of its body:the olpe, which is rather a slender vessel with a continuous-curve profile between the mouth and the foot, and the oinochoe,which has a much more swelling, sometimes globular, body that usually has the shoulder offset from the neck. One kind of oinochoe, however, the chous, has a continuous-curveprofile. In Attic black figure, both the olpe and the oinochoe appear simultaneouslyin the workshopof the Gorgon Painter, but the largest numberof Attic black-figuredexamples and types belong to the secondhalf of the 6th centuryB.C. OLPAI 670-722
Pls. 64-69
The olpe has a gently swelling body that forms a continuous curve between the foot and the mouth. The foot may have an echinus shape or simply be a low disk. There are two main categories of olpe: those with a trefoil mouth and those with a plain one. Each is discussedseparatelybelow. TREFOIL 670-681
Pls. 64-66
This type of olpe has a high handle that rises well abovethe mouth, then curvesdownwardto the rim. The handle is usually double and reservedexcept for the lines of glaze as accents,as 673 or 677 (PI. 64), but it may be concaveand completelyglazed.4The earliest preservedtrefoil olpai in Attic black figure are unattributed and seem to belong to the very late 7th century B.C.,5 although 671 (PI. 64) by the Gorgon Painter, which is the earliest attributedexample from the Agora, is hardly later than these. The Gorgon Painter and the artistsworking in his mannerare the first Attic blackfigure painters to decoratenumerous olpai,6 and although these belong within the larger Group of Early Olpai put together by Beazley,7the chief features of the shape and its system of decoration were probablydevelopedin the Gorgon Painter'sworkshop.The ratherheavy, sagging appearance of the earliest examples soon gives way to a more elegant, refinedform that is retainedthroughout the period during which this type was manufactured.8672 (PI. 64) in the manner of the Gorgon For the shape, cf. Agora XII, pp. 58-63, 76-78, with bibliography;ABV, chaps. 28-31; KerameikosVI, ii, pp. 173-181. A dissertationon the shape is being preparedby Andrew Clark under the supervisionof Dietrich von Bothmer. 2 Cf. J. N. Coldstream, Greek GeometricPottery, London 1968, passim; Agora VIII, pp. 35-41 for the Late Geometric and Protoatticexamples from the Agora. 3 Most recently, Bothmer, Studies in ClassicalArt and Archaeology. A Tribute to Peter Heinrich von Blanckenhagen, New York 1979, pp. 63-67. 4 Cf. Copenhagen, inv. no. 8076 (ABV 14, 9); Munich, private (Paralip. 9); and Warsaw 14249 signed by Kriton as potter (ABV 446, 2; Paralip. 192, 2). An oddity is the female mourner attached to the top of the handle of Kerameikos,inv. no. 40 by the CeramicusPainter (ABV 19, 2; KerameikosVI, ii, no. 107, pl. 93). 5 Cf. London, B.M. 88.6-1.566 (ABV 15, 22) and Delos
591 (ABV 15, 27; Paralip. 9, 27). Both are includedby Beazley in his Group of Early Olpai without a more specificattribution. Karouzou ('Avayvpoivros, pp. 134-135) suggested that the Delos olpe is the work of the Nettos Painter, close in time to his namepiece.For Protoatticpredecessors,cf. AgoraVIII, no. 544, with bibliography,esp. E. Brann, Hesperia 30, 1961, pp. 348349; also, KerameikosVI, ii, pp. 173-179. 6 Gorgon Painter: ABV 9, 11-13; Paralip. 7, 13 bis-135; manner of the Gorgon Painter: ABV 10-11, 4-7; Paralip. 8. For those with a flat mouth, cf. below, pp. 40-41. Severalothers do not preservethe mouth, so one may not be certainof the type: Gorgon Painter: ABV 9, 14 and 15; manner of the Gorgon Painter:ABV 11, 8-15; Paralip. 8 including 703 (PI. 67), 707, and 708 (PI. 68). For a discussion,cf. I. Scheibler,JdI 76, 1961, pp. 1-47. 7 ABV 14-15, 1-36; Paralip. 9 (including676 [PI. 65]). 8 Scheibler, cit. (footnote6 above), pp. 34-35. op.
40
SHAPE STUDIES
Painter is a good illustrationof the canonicalshape. The decorationis usually set in a panel on the right side of the body (the pourer'sright), e.g. 672, 677, or 680 (Pls. 64, 65), often with two reserved triangles (an "eye")on the opposite side in the area of maximum diameter.9This position of the handle enables the guest to see the figureddecorationwhile his host pours wine into his cup. A few examples have the figured decorationcontinuinground the vessel, 671 and 679 (Pls. 64, 65) being the best examples from the Agora.'1 This system of decoration places the focal point of the compositionopposite the handle, instead of on the side. The area above the panel is often plain, as on 672 and 677 (PI. 64), or, as on so many panel amphorae,there may be a frieze of ornament.The only examples from the Agora, 680 and 681 (Pls. 65, 66), have the lotus-palmette festoon. 671 (P1. 64) is unusual for having a figured frieze in this area. The panels of early trefoil olpai often have rosettes or hanging spirals for filling ornament, another link with contemporary panel amphorae.Trefoil olpai are most commonin the first quarterof the 6th century,and nearly all the Agora examples are from that period. Later, the shape is taken up by the Amasis Painter (681: PI. 66) and by painters contemporarywith him, some of them unnamed,e.g. 680 (P1. 65)." 682-694 Pls. 66, 67 The type of olpe with a flat, thin rim, which otherwise is like its trefoil counterpartin shape and decoration, is rather rare in Attic black figure, and no early example of it may be identified for certainamong the black-figuredolpai at the Agora.12The earliest olpe in this sectionis 682, a "redbodied"one of special shape with an elongatedbody, a short neck, and a thickenedrim. Although not attributedto a painter, the style of the drawing suggests an artist working aroundthe middleof the 6th centuryor perhaps a little later. It belongs to a group of olpai whose paintersdo not confine the rather few figures to a panel but allow them to spread out over the entire surfaceof the vase.13 Some, like 682, have a wide zone of black glaze at the bottomjust above the foot; others have this area reserved. All the other black-figuredolpai from the Agora included here belong to the years after 530 B.C. when a new type of olpe is introduced.'4This variety also has a gently swelling body, yet it curves inward toward the neck more sharply than that of its trefoil counterpart.But its shape differs from the latter in more essential points: the thickened rim or one that is applied separately forming a torus, 692 (PI. 67), or occasionallyflaring and flat on top, 687 (PI. 66); the low strap handle that often has metallic-lookingprojectionson either side of the rim attachment,686 (Pl. 66) or 692; the low disk foot. The figureddecorationappears in a panel placedoppositethe handle so that the focus is on the front of the vase, not on the side as with the trefoil panel olpe. Above the panel there is almost always decoration,usually more than one band of ornament,and the arrangementof these patternedfriezes varies considerablyfrom painter to painter. 686, 687, and 692 (Pls. 66, 67) with MOUTHNOT TREFOIL
9 An "eye" sometimes appears below the handles of column-kraters, e.g., Leningrad St. 55, perhaps by the Swing Painter (ABV 310; Bohr, Schaukelmaler, pi. 144: here [pp. 101-102] this detail is overlooked in the description). For remarkson the earliest panels in Attic pottery,cf. above, p. 5. 10Here are examples of three others:Tiibingen 5445/28 by the Gorgon Painter (ABV 9, 11; Paralip. 7, 11; CVA, Tubingen 3 [Germany 47], pi. 18 [2263]); two by the Ceramicus Painter: Kerameikos,inv. no. 40 (ABV 19, 2; KerameikosVI, ii, no. 107, pl. 93) and Athens, N.M. 16285 (ABV 19, 3). '1 Amasis Painter: ABV 152-153, 29-31; Paralip. 66 (including 681 [P1.66]); Bothmer,Amasis Painter, passim. Group of Trefoil Olpai: ABV 445, 1-12; Paralip. 192. 12This type of olpe is known only from the workshopsof the
Gorgon Painter, Amasis, and the Kriton Group. Cf. ABV 446, top; also Agora XII, p. 77. The earliest examples are these: Athens, N.M. 19176 by the Gorgon Painter (ABV9, 16;Paralip. 7, 16) and London, B.M. B 32 in his manner (ABV 11,16; Paralip. 8, 16); Boston, M.F.A. 1973.9: helmet between two seated panthers. Each has the decorationcontinuinground the vase. Athens, N.M. 19176 and London, B.M. B 32 have concave strap handles, Boston, M.F.A. 1973.9 a reserveddouble handle normally seen on trefoil olpai. 13ABV450-451; Paralip. 195. 14 There do not seem to be black-figuredexamples of this new type before the beginning of red figure (cf. Agora XII, p. 78).
OINOCHOAI
41
their combinationsof ivy, net, and key patterns provide a general illustrationof a few of the possibilities. Normally, the sides of the panel are accentedonly by a line of glaze, similar to those of the panel-amphora, but sometimes, as on 684, 686, and 691 (Pls. 66, 67), the panel is framed at the sides by ornament,ivy or net being the most common.Often the mouth is decoratedwith a checkerboard pattern, 686, 687, and 692, or it may be glazed, 683 and 694 (Pls. 66, 67). TYPE UNCERTAIN: MOUTH LOST
695-722
Pls. 67-69
Most of the olpai in this sectionbelong to the late 7th centuryB.C.or to the first quarterof the 6th. 703-710 (Pls. 67, 68) are decoratedin the mannerof the Gorgon Painter, and 713-716 (Pls. 68, 69) may be attributedto the Group of Early Olpai. Since many of these fragmentsbelong to olpai with the figures set in a panel, it is tempting to place them in the trefoil-olpe section, not only because there are so few contemporaryolpai with plain mouths but also becausethe three earliest examples of this type have the decorationcontinuingroundthe vase.15But without the mouth, it is impossible to be absolutelycertain to which type of olpe each fragmentbelongs, and thus it is best to keep them apart. OINOCHOAI723-776
Pls. 69-72
The oinochoe, in contrast to the olpe, has a much more globular body and often a heavyset appearance.But, like the olpe, the mouth of the oinochoemay be trefoil or plain, the handle high or low, and the foot echinus or torus. Often there are one or two rings on the neck, and the handle may have a ridge. Some of the clay varieties with their crisp contoursand sharply articulatedparts are metallic looking, and their potters may have had metal vessels in mind when they fashioned their clay counterparts.There are many types of oinochoai,16but only Shapes 1, 2, and 3, as well as two special models, the Vraona type and a flat-bottomedone, are known in black figure from the Agora. SHAPE1
723-745
Pls. 69-71
This is the most common type of Attic black-figured oinochoe, and the largest number of oinochoai found in the Agora are of this type.17As with the olpai, the earliest examples appear in the workshop of the Gorgon Painter, although none so far is attributedto the painter himself.'8 723 (PI. 69) is in his manner, and 724 (Pl. 69) is contemporary.This type of oinochoe continuesuntil the early years of the 5th centuryB.C.with the greatestnumberof them made duringthe secondhalf of the 6th. Three early fragments,725, 726 (PI. 69), 731, are includedin this section. The curve of each is too strong to be that of an olpe, and it correspondsbest to that of oinochoaiof Shapes 1, 2, and 3. Since Shapes 2 and 3 do not appear until the secondhalf of the 6th centuryB.C.,these three fragmentsought to be Shape 1. Shape 1 is characterizedby a roundedor ovoid body that tapers sharply toward the foot with the maximum diameterset at about the middle or a little above.The shouldermay be rounded,e.g. 734 (PI. 70), or rather flat, e.g. 736 (PI. 70), and it is often offset from the neck. On the neck, there are sometimesone or two rings, e.g. 724 or 734 (Pls. 69, 70), giving the effect of a collar. 736 is unusual for having a double ring just below the start of the mouth. The handle is usually high, and it may be ridged, e.g. 735 (P1. 70) or concave, e.g. 736. The mouth is normally trefoil, but occasionallyit is plain, e.g. 735, and the foot is an echinus or a torus. The figures may be set in a panel opposite the handle, or they may continue round the vase, although the latter is less common.723 (PI. 69), 729, 15 Cf. footnote 12 above, p.
16ABV, chaps. 28-30.
40.
17Cf. Agora XII, pp. 58-59, with bibliography. 18ABV 10, 1-3; Paralip. 8, 1 bis (723: PI. 69).
SHAPE STUDIES
42
730, 733 (P1. 70), and the two miniatures,727 and 732, are the examples from the Agora. 729 and 730 have their figures set in friezes, similar to those on many contemporaryneck-amphoraeand hydriai.19The panels may or may not have lateral frames,but normallythere is a tongue patternon the shoulderat the junction with the neck. Dots or ivy are favoriteframingornaments.The upright encircledpalmetteson 736 seem to have no parallel on oinochoai;their nearestcounterpartsappear on some contemporaryhydriai. The collar may be black, e.g. 723, 724, and 734 (P1. 70), or it may be decoratedwith a pattern,ivy, net, and hanging lotus buds being the types that occuron the Agora examples, 736, 737, 741 (Pls. 70, 71), and 742. 2 746 and 747 SHAPE ofet This type of oinochoeis very similar to Shape 1 in many of ts details shape and its principlesof of two that the are decoration.20The main differencesbetween the body Shape 2 tapers very little towards the foot and the foot is very low and flat. The over-all effect is rather squat, heavy, and sturdy. Shape 2 begins much later than Shape 1, and it appears mainly during the last thirty years of the 6th t century B.c. The largest number of them belong to the Class of Vatican G. 47.21There are only two certain examples in the Agora black figure, 747 which has lost its mouth and handle, and 746, a miniature one which is very early. SHAPE3 (CHOUS) 748-765
Pls. 71, 72
The chous is a squat jug with a continuous-curveprofile between neck and body, similar to the one-piece amphora and the pelike. It has a trefoil mouth, a low handle that is often ridged, and a broad flaring foot.22In many respects, the shape seems to combinethe continuous-curveprofile of the olpe with the round body of the oinochoe of Shape 1. The chous is most common in Attic red figure and in plain black. In Attic black figure, the earliest attributed choes are by the Amasis Painter and the Taleides Painter;23Boston M.F.A. 10.210 is signed by Taleides as potter.24The earliest black-figured choes at the Agora, 748-753 (PI. 71), are of that time, but none may be attributedto either of these artists. The rest of the Agora examples, 754-765 (PI. 72), belong to the late 6th or the early 5th centuriesB.C. The figures are normally set in a panel oppositeethe handle, and th width of the panel varies accordingto the maximum breadthof the chous. Above the panel, there is a band of ornamentthat varies considerably,just as it does abovethe panel of the one-pieceamphora.753 (PI. 71) is unusual for having hanging lotus buds with dots, a rare ornamentabovethe panel of a chous. Sometimesthe panels have lateral frames, most often a net patternor two rows of dots, but more often the sides of the panels are simply accentedby a line of glaze, as they are on all the Agoraexamples. 764 is a rare example where the figures are not set in a panel but continueroundthe vase, and it ought to belong to the Class of Red-bodiedOinochoaiof Shape 3.25 SPECIAL: FLAT-BOTTOMED
AND VRAONA
766 and 767
Pl. 72
766 is a miniature vase that resemblesthe larger conical oinochoeof Corinthianmanufacture.26 767 is of the rare Vraona type, which is named after the example in London that was found at 19Cf. above, pp. 9 and 36.
20
Cf. Agora XII, p. 60, with bibliography, 21 ABV 429-430, 1-27; Paralip. 184-185. 22 Cf. Agora XII, pp. 60-63, with bibliography. 23 Amasis Painter: ABV 153-154, 41-46; Paralip. 64, 4145; New York, M.M.A. 1978.11.22 (Bothmer,AmasisPainter, pp. 154-155, cat. no. 33). Taleides Painter:ABV 174, 3 and 4.
Sparkesand Talcott (AgoraXII, p. 63) have suggestedthat the appearance of Shape 3 is to be linked with these two artists, especially the workshopof Amasis where experimentationwas particularlylively. 24 ABV 174, 3. 25 For the class, cf. ABV 439-440, 1-6 and Paralip. 191. 26 See the catalogueentry for 766.
LEKYTHOI
43
Vraona (Brauron) near Spata.27It has a short cylindricalbody with slightly concavesides, a rather flat shoulder, and a high double handle. The neck is mostly lost, but the height of the handle indicates that it was long. The mouth is not preserved,but on the few Vraonas where it remains, it is flat. The general effect of the Vraona type is very metallic looking. OINOCHOAI, TYPE UNCERTAIN
768-776
P1. 72
All these, except 768 and 769, are late black-figuredoinochoai. 768 and 771-774 preservethe shoulder and therefore can be seen to be Shape 1 or 2, but without the lower part of the body it is impossible to be more specific. The rest of the oinochoai in this section are too fragmentaryto permit identificationof the type. OLPAIOROINOCHOAI777-786
P1. 73
None of these fragments preserves a feature that would identify it specifically as an olpe or an oinochoe. 777 is by the Gorgon Painter or in his manner, and 778 has certain affinities with Sophilos. LEKYTHOI 787-1256
Fig. 15 Pls. 73-87
The lekythos is the most common of all the shapes decoratedin black figure found in the Agora, particularlyfrom ca. 510-480 B.C.,the period when many artists specializedin the shape.1In general, the lekythos is characterizedby a narrow neck with a flaring mouth, a short vertical handle attached at the shoulder and the neck, and a sturdy foot. The shape of the mouth, body, and foot varies a good deal from period to period and from potter to potter. Most of the Agora black-figured lekythoi are small vessels of the type used to furnish out commongraves.2Only a few, such as 789 (P1.74) and 817 (PI. 75), are of the very highest quality. The Agora lekythoi span the entire period that the shape is decoratedin black figure, and a remarkablylarge number of them from a single deposit are especially well preserved.3 In Attic black figure, there are two main types of lekythos. The earliest is the Deianeira type, named after the subjecton London, B.M. B 30, attributedto the mannerof the Gorgon Painter.4It has a biconical body supported by an echinus foot, a curving mouth roundedon top, a thick drip ring, and a short concave handle. The type derives from the Corinthian alabastron5but is then borrowedby the Corinthiansfor their lekythoi. Most of the known Deianeira lekythoi are from the early 6th century B.C.,although some occur as late as the third quarter, e.g. 798 (P1.75), but these are rather weakened versionsof the earlier examples.6The earliest black-figuredlekythosfrom the Agora, 787 (P1. 73), is a unique variant of the Deianeira type. It is contemporarywith the first generationof Attic black-figurepainters but is difficultto attributeto a specificartist. In shape and date, it stands somewhat apart from the other lekythoi from the Agora. 27
London, B.M. 1905.7-11.1 (ABV 443, 3).
' For the shape, cf. particularlyABL; Agora XII, pp. 150152; also, Kurtz, Athenian White Lekythoi, pp. 5-22, and 7781 for black figure. For the name, cf. Richter and Milne, Shapes and Names, pp. 14-15. On the origin of the Attic type, cf. J. de la Geniere, BCH 108, 1984, pp. 91-98. 2A good idea of these offerings may be gained from U. Knigge, Kerameikos,IX, Der Siidhiigel, Berlin 1976.
3 The deep well of the late Archaicperiod beneath the gutter of the Stoa of Attalos (H. A. Thompson, Hesperia 24, 1955, pp. 62-63). These and the other vases found with them are the subjectof a separatestudy by S. R. Roberts(Hesperia 55, 1986, pp. 1-74), which focuses on workshopsand potters. 4 ABV 11, 20; NC, p. 191. 5ABL, p. 1. 6 ABL, chaps. 1 and 3.
44
SHAPE STUDIES
The second type is the shoulderedlekythos, which is the dominanttype from the second quarter of the 6th century B.C. on. It is a purely Attic shape7 and first appears at just about the time the shoulderedhydria is introduced.8The sloping shoulderof the lekythosis well set off from the body, which is broad at the top, slightly swelling in contour,and tapering downwardtoward an echinus foot. Early examples retain the mouth, drip ring, and concavehandle of the Deianeira type, but later, these featuresare given up. It is not certainwho was the first potterto fashion the shouldered lekythos, but the earliest examples are decoratedby the C Painter and one or two of his contemporaries.9A large number of shouldered lekythoi are by the Amasis Painter,10although none is signed by Amasis as potter, and all of them are earlier than his signed vases.11789 (PI. 74), the very fragmentarylekythosby Lydos, is the earliest example in the Agoraof the shoulderedtype, and it is probablynot very much later than some of the lekythoi by the Amasis Painter. The figures on 789 continuedroundthe vase, as on so many others of the time, including791 (P1.74), an odd piece that is difficultto parallel in shape, although its figure style has some affinitieswith Elbows Out. Both of these lekythoi have figures on the shoulder as well, rather than a floral pattern as is generally the case later. A single line usually separates the shoulder from the body decoration, although occasionally a pattern may appear at the top of the figure zone on the body, e.g. 790 (P1. 74). The mouth and handle and the area below the figures, includingthe foot, are black. Normally, the neck is unglazed, except for those lekythoi with drip rings, which have a black band.'2This rather squat type of shoulderedlekythos becomesthe preferredtype in the third quarter of the 6th centuryB.C., and artists such as those of the Dolphin Group, e.g. 797 and 798 (PI. 75), the Fat-runner Group, e.g. 800-802 (PI. 75), and the Group of Vatican G. 52, e.g. 805-813 (P1.75), preferdecoratingthis shape.13 7ABL, p. 1. 8ABL, p. 7. 9 C Painter: Orvieto 296 (ABV 58, 126; Bothmer, Amasis Painter, p. 38, fig. 20); Kerameikos (ABV 58, 127); Oberlin 41.44 (ABV 58, 128). The Sandal Painter:Athens, N.M. 1056 (ABV 70, 4); Barcelona 52 (ABV 70, 5); Paris, Musee Rodin 237 (ABV 70, 6); Bologna PU 204 (ABV 70, 7; Paralip. 28, 7); Oxford 1934.353 (ABV 70, 8; Paralip. 28, 8). Not far from the Sandal Painter: Athens, N.M. 415 (ABV 70, -); Related to him: Athens, N.M. 371 (ABV 70, -); Near him: Sofia 6285 (Paralip. 28). Recalls the Griffin-bird Painter: Athens, N.M. 413 (ABV 75, -). 10ABV 154-155, 49-61; Paralip. 66; Bothmer, Amasis Painter, pp. 168-191, cat. nos. 39-50. Furthermore,the Amasis Painter also decorated a lekythos of the Deianeira shape (Athens, N.M. 404: ABV 155, 62; Bothmer, Amasis Painter, p. 193, fig. 101) and two of the sub-Deianeira shape (Villa Giulia: ABV 155, 63; Bothmer,Amasis Painter, p. 153, fig. 94; Copenhagen, inv. no. 14067: Paralip. 66; Bothmer, Amasis Painter, pp. 192-193, cat. no. 51). 11 Signedvases:three neck-amphoraeof a special shouldered type: Cab. Med. 222 (ABV 152, 25; Paralip. 63, 25; Bothmer, Amasis Painter, pp. 125-129, cat. no. 23), Boston, M.F.A. 01.8026 (ABV 152, 26; Paralip. 63, 26; CVA, Boston 1 [USA 14], pls. 26 [648], 28 [650]:1, 2; Bothmer, Amasis Painter, pp. 130-133, cat. no. 24), and Boston, M.F.A. 01.8027 (ABV 152, 27; Paralip. 63, 27; CVA, Boston 1 [USA 14], pls. 27 [649], 28 [650]:3;Bothmer,Amasis Painter, pp. 134-137, cat. no. 25); two olpai with trefoil mouth: Louvre F 30 (ABV 152, 29; Paralip. 63, 29; Bothmer,Amasis Painter, pp. 140-142, cat. no. 27) and Wurzburg 332 (ABV 152, 30; Paralip. 63, 30; Bothmer, Amasis Painter, pp. 143-144, cat. no. 28); two olpai with flat mouth: London, B.M. B 471 (ABV 153, 32; Paralip. 64, 32;
Bothmer, Amasis Painter, pp. 150-151, cat. no. 31) and once Canino (ABV 153, 33); a band cup in Malibu, 79.AE.197 (Bothmer, Amasis Painter, pp. 204-207, cat. no. 55); a cup of special type: Vatican 369 a (ABV 157, 87; Paralip. 65, 87; Bothmer,AmasisPainter, pp. 223-225, cat. no. 62). Add, probably, the small beakerlikevessel from the North Slope, R. 294, which preserves the name but not the verb (ABV 157, -), and the fragmentary tripod-pyxis found at Aphaia (photo D.A.I. Athens, 72. 3409-3415; Bothmer, Amasis Painter, pp. 236-238, Appendix no. 4), which has the last two letters of the verb;also a black-figuredlekythosin the J. Paul Getty Museum attributedto the Taleides Painter and signed by Amasis on the undersideof the foot (76. AE. 48: J. Frel, "Three Notes on Attic Black Figure in Malibu," Greek Vases in the J. Paul Getty Museum 1, 1983, p. 37, fig. 3; B. Legakis, "A Lekythos Signed by Amasis,"AK 26, 1983, pp. 73-76; Bothmer,Amasis Painter, p. 229, Appendix no. 1). In addition, Bloesch has suggested that the potting of Lydos' psykter-amphorain Londonis by Amasis (ABV 109, 29), but this has been stronglyquestioned (Paralip. 44, 29). D. Callipolitis-Feytmans(Les plats attiques, pp. 87 and 91) believesthat Amasis may have fashioneda plate decoratedby Lydos, Akropolis 2402 (ABV 111, 49; Tiverios, pl. 81:e). Furthermore,Bothmerhas shown that Amasis is very likely the father of the potter Kleophrades (D. von Bothmer, 'AAazobos,"The Journal of the J. Paul Getty Mu"'"AAautrm, seum 9, 1981, pp. 1-4; Bothmer,Amasis Painter, pp. 230-231, Appendix no. 2). 12Cf. ABL, pp. 7-19 for a full discussionof the treatmentof the mouth, neck, and shoulderof early shoulderedlekythoi. 13Dolphin Group (ABL, pp. 193-194, 1-18; ABV 457458, 1-22; Paralip. 199); Fat-runner Group (ABV 459-460, 1-12; Paralip. 201-202); Group of Vatican G. 52 (ABV 460461, 1-37; Paralip. 202). Many of the vases by the Dolphin
LEKYTHOI
45
Around 530 B.C.,the so-called cylinderlekythos is introduced,a more graceful, elegant versionof the shoulderedlekythos than the earlier one.'4 The shape of the body gives the type its name. The neck and shoulder form a continuous curve, the mouth is flaring or calyx shaped and flat on top. Beneath the figure zone, the body curves downward toward the torus foot and is sometimes separated from it by a fillet. The new shape provides a taller pictorial surface, and, together with a short-livedvariant that slopes sharply toward the foot,15it becomesthe prevalenttype of lekythosin Attic black figure, although the older shoulderedtype continues,particularlyin the workshopof the Phanyllis Group, 824-836 (PI. 77).16 The scheme of decorationon cylinder lekythoi is a simple one. Normally, there is an ornamental pattern on the shoulder, often hanging lotus buds or palmettes, with a tongue pattern above at the start of the neck. On the body, there is usually a pattern above the figures at the junction with the shoulder. The figures themselvesmay be confinedto the principal view of the vase, or they may continuecompletelyaround,the subjectdeterminingthe use of the format. The area below the figures is glazed black, although often there is a narrow reserved band that serves as a transitionfrom the very light backgroundfor the figuresto the solid black zone below. The sides of the mouth and handle and the top surface of the foot are glazed. As may be expected, there is considerablevariation in details of shape and scheme of decorationaccordingto potter and workshop. There are not very many black-figuredcylinderlekythoi from the Agora that may be datedbefore 500 B.C.The most impressiveof them, if perhapsthe most enigmatic,is the earliest, 817 (PI. 75), the very beautiful fragmentaryone that may be by Psiax. The figured decorationis painted on white ground, an early example of the technique17and the earliest in the Agora. Below the main zone, there is a figured predella, a feature that does not seem to occur elsewhere on lekythoi but may in this case derive from other funerary shapes, loutrophoroi and plaques, where it is well known. Thus, one need not look too far to discoverwhat may be the sourceof inspirationfor the predellaon 817. The best-preservedlekythos of this period from the Agora is 821 (P1.76), which has affinities with the Leagros Group but is difficultto attributeto one of its painters. Both 821 and 822 (P1.77) are unusual for having a band of ornamentbelow the figures. The chief painter of lekythoi during the late years of the 6th century is the Edinburgh Painter whose handsome,elegant cylinder lekythoi are well known. Only two certain examples of his lekythoi have been found in the Agora (884 and 885: P1. 80), although another may be by him (886: P1. 80), but these are too fragmentaryto give an idea of the shape preferredby him. By far the largest number of Agora lekythoi from this time belong to the Phanyllis Group (824-836: P1. 77) and the Cock Group (837-863: P1. 78), whose painters specialize in the shape and whose period of activity lasts beyond the turn of the century, the time when the lekythos begins to enjoy its greatestpopularity. The painters of the Phanyllis Group continue to decoratethe older type of shoulderedlekythos that was the normal shape before the introductionof the cylinder, but their potters modify its appearance somewhat by making it slimmer. The body of the Phanyllis lekythos has a slightly swelling contour, and the tapering toward the foot beginsjust beneath the figure zone, which is set rather high. The foot is disk shapedwithout a fillet between it and the body. The mouth is wide and flaring. 829 and 830 are very broad, rather heavy examples of the type. 827, 831 (PI. 77), and 832 are more typical of the Phanyllis shape. Painters of the Phanyllis shape also decoratea cylinder type of lekythos. This has a rather weak contour, a wide mouth, and a disk foot with or without a Group have been shown to be Euboean (Paralip. 199; Bothmer, Metr. Mus. Journal 2, 1969, pp. 32-38). Some of the Agora examples may fall into the Euboean category, but since they appear in ABV or Paralip. without a Euboean designation,we have included them here.
14ABL, p. 41. ABL, p. 48. 16 ABL, p. 63. 17For the early use of white ground, cf. Mertens, Attic White-Ground,pp. 27-43. 15
SHAPESTUDIES
46
fillet between it and the body. The body tapers below the figureddecoration.835 (PI. 77), although very fragmentary,is the only example from the Agora. The chief differencebetween the two types of lekythoi used by the Phanyllis Group is that on the cylindertype the figures occupy more of the surface of the body, resulting in a more pleasing relationship between the shape and the figured decoration.The ornamentaldecorationon the shouldervaries but may be the same for each type: palmettes (e.g. 835), invertedlotus buds (e.g. 824, 825: PI. 77), or as in the Group of the Hopliteleaving-home, an upright palmette between draped figures (e.g. 829-834: P1. 77). Above the figures, there is sometimesa key pattern (e.g. 835), but more often there is just a line of glaze at the junction of the shoulderwith the neck. The area below the figuresis glazed black. Closely relatedto the Phanyllis Group are the more numerouslekythoiof the CockGroup, which takes its name from the long-tailed cock painted on the shoulder. The shape is similar to the Phanyllis type, but the quality of the decoration is lower. The examples from the Agora, 837-863 (PI. 78), are good illustrationsof the group. Contemporarywith the majority of lekythoi of the Phanyllis Group and the Cock Group are those by the Gela Painter who deriveshis name from the large number of his vases that have been found at Gela in Sicily.18Very few of the Gela Painter's vases have been excavatedin mainland Greece, but the comparativelylarge numberof his lekythoifrom the Agora indicatesthat there was also a market for his work at home. The Gela Painter's lekythoi are slender cylindersand usually have a top-heavy appearance,for the body is too short for the tall neck and the large calyx-shaped mouth. Between body and foot, there is a fillet. The foot may be a plain torus or one in two degrees, similar to the feet of amphoraeType A and calyx-kraters.869 and 870 (PI. 79) are good examples from the Agora. On the shoulder, there is a configurationof palmettesthat is often combinedwith buds. Above this, there is a tongue pattern.Of the eight variationsdistinguishedby Haspels,19four appear on Agora lekythoi: II a, five palmettes between two buds (869-871: P1. 79); II b, five palmettes between vestiges of buds (873); III a, three palmettes between two horizontal buds (872: P1. 79); III b, three palmettes between two downward buds (874-876). Normally, the neck is reserved.872 (P1.79) is unusual for having patternsand in this respectrecalls the one in Boston.20 The Gela Painter nearly always includes a band of ornamentabove his figures, most often the net pattern (e.g. 869,871, and 874: P1.79), the key patternto right (870,877: PI. 79), and, on his better pieces, a checkerboardof which there is no example on his lekythoifrom the Agora.Occasionallyhe omits the ornament(872,878: PI. 79). The area below the figuresis glazed, either completelyplain, (e.g. 869, 870) or with a reservedband (e.g. 871,874). The top surfaceof the foot is always glazed. Those in two degrees have a reservedvertical member and a glazed torus (869, 870: PI. 79). The side of the plain torus foot may be glazed (874, 875, and 879: PI. 79) or reserved(878: P1.79). During the first three decadesof the 5th centuryB.C., the mass productionof small black-figured lekythoimust have occupiedmany artists in the Kerameikos.The workshopthat fashionedlekythoi of the Class of Athens 581 seems to have been particularlybusy, at least to judge by the very large number of its products that have survived. In the Agora, they are the most numerous of all the lekythoi, 887-1124 (Pls. 80-85), surpassingin numberthose of the Haimon workshop,which was also bursting with activity around the time of the Persian Wars. These small lekythoi of the Class of Athens 581 have a calyx-shapedmouth, and the body tapers below the figures to a simple disk foot. Two variationsmay be distinguished,each accordingto the shoulderdecoration.Lekythoiof the Class of Athens 581, i have hanging lotus buds, often with dots in the interstices, and tongues above. They are usually of slightly higher quality than the second 1sABL, 78. p. 19ABL, pp. 205-212.
20Boston, M.F.A. 93.99 (ABL, p. 206, no. 5 and pi. 23:1).
ALABASTRON
47
variation, the Class of Athens 581, ii, on which the buds have been reducedto rays, although the tongues are retained. Both types have a line at the junction of the shoulder, and the black glaze below the figures is usually interruptedby a narrow reservedband. 890 (P1. 80) and 948 (P1. 82) are good examples of each type. Of the other major lekythos workshops, only productsof the Haimon Group have been found in any quantity in the Agora (1182-1237: PI. 87). The Haemonian lekythos is a tall, slender vessel. The contourof its body may be gently convexor slightly concave.It has a calyx-shapedmouth and a foot in two degrees, consisting of a high vertical member above a very low torus. The ornamenton the shoulder recalls that of the Class of Athens 581, ii: a tongue pattern,then lotus buds reducedto rays. Above the figures is an ornamentalpattern, usually a key (e.g. 1182, 1184, 1188: P1.87) or a dot band (e.g. 1187, 1216: PI. 87). Many of the Agora Haemonians are very fragmentary,but 1188 and 1221 (P1.87) are good, well-preservedexamples of the productsof this workshopand illustrate their basic characteristics. One small fragment (1160: PI. 86) may be by the Diosphos Painter, but other than this, the only lekythoi from the workshop of the Sappho Painter and the Diosphos Painter belong to the Littlelion Class (1161-1176: PI. 86), which seems to be an invention of this workshop.21These small lekythoi take their name from the decorationon the shoulder:lions (e.g. 1172, 1173). The shape is characterizedby an echinus mouth, a long neck, a very flat shoulder,and a bodythat curvessharply toward a thin disk foot. Instead of lions on the shoulder,most of the Agora examples have inverted lotus buds with tongues above. The area below the figures is solid black. A number of Little-lion lekythoi belong to the Hound-and-hare Group, named for the subject on the shoulder. Four examples have been found in the Agora, 1177-1180 (P1. 86), two of them almost completely preserved. Only one Agora lekythos comes from the workshopof the Theseus Painter and the Athena Painter, 1181 (PI. 87), a white-ground one attributedto the latter. The mouth, neck, and shoulder are missing, but all of the torus foot is preserved, and enough of the body remains to determine the shape. It is derived from the tall cylinders favoredby the Edinburgh Painter that in turn are preferred by the Athena Painter.22 In addition to the large quantity of mass-producedlekythoi of the early 5th century, the Agora excavationshave also yielded one small example of a squat lekythos, 1256 (P1.87), a variantthat is more familiar in red figure than it is in black figure.23 Attic black-figuredlekythoi continue to be produceduntil the middleof the 5th centuryB.C.,24 but the series from the Agora seems to end by about 460 B.C. ALABASTRON 1257
P1. 88
The alabastron is a small, elongated perfume pot with a rounded bottom, a narrow neck, and a wide-rimmedflat mouth with a small opening much like that of the aryballoswith which it shares a similar function. It may or may not have small lug handles set high on the wall above the figures.1 21
ABL, p. 98. ABL, p. 147. 23 For the shape, cf. W. W. Rudolph, Die Bauchlekythos. Ein Beitrag zur Formengeschichteder attischenKeramikdes 5. Jahrhundertsv. Chr., Bloomington 1971. 24 Beazley, Development,p. 87. 22
For the shape, cf. Richter and Milne, Shapes and Names, p. 17; more particularly,H. Angermeier,Das Alabastron(Ein Beitrag zur Lekythen-Forschung), Giessen 1936 and ABL, pp. 100-104; also E. Vanderpool,Hesperia 8, 1939, p. 251. For
48
SHAPE STUDIES
The shape has a long history at Corinth, and it is especiallycommonin Early Corinthianpottery.2 It does not appear in Attic black figure until about the middle of the 6th century B.C.;the earliest example is 1257 by the Amasis Painter who also decoratedone of the earliest Attic black-figured aryballoi, which is of the Corinthian, not the Attic, type.3 1257 is heavier, fuller, and more ovoid than the later type of alabastron, which is somewhat elongated and more cylindrical. It is most unfortunatethat the mouth and neck of 1257 have not survived. After 1257, the next Attic black-figured alabastra are the three examples by Psiax of about 520-510 B.C.,4 which are almost contemporarywith the earliest red-figuredexamples, the Group of the Paidikos Alabastron.5Elsewhere in Attic black figure, alabastraappear only in the work of the Diosphos Painter and the Emporion Painter, and thus they continue until the very end of Attic black figure.6Very many of these late alabastrahave the decorationon white ground. The scheme of decorationis a simple one. Usually there is a single zone of figures that continues roundthe vase.7Above,there are bandsof ornamentalpatterns.The rest of the vase is black,but for one or more reservedlines below the figures. 1257 is unusual for being reservedbelow the figures except for the pattern on the very bottom. PHORMISKOI 1258 and 1259 P1.88 The phormiskos has a bulbous, ovoid body with a rounded or flat bottom. The shoulder slopes sharplyto a narrowcylindricalneck that terminatesin a small knobor tapersto a curvedpoint. The top of the neck is often pierced with two holes for suspension.1The decorationis set in friezes of varying widths with a prothesis often depicted in the main zone. Above and below, there may be several friezes of ornament or, occasionally,one or two animal friezes, then ornamentalpatterns. The exact use of the phormiskosis uncertain,but it seems to have serveda funerarypurpose.There are not very many Attic black-figuredphormiskoi,and 1258 and 1259, shoulderfragments,are the only examples from the Agora.
white-ground examples, cf. Mertens, Attic White-Ground, pp. 35-40, 95-100. 2 For a summary, cf. NC, p. 281. 3New York, M.M.A. 62.11.11 (Paralip. 66; Bothmer, Amasis Painter, pp. 194-197, cat. no. 52). Cf. also, Bothmer, "Three Vases by the Amasis Painter," MadrMitt 12, 1971, pp. 123-130, esp. pp. 125-127, with bibliography for the shape. Bothmer (p. 130) places this aryballos among the early works by the Amasis Painter. The zigzags on top of the mouth recall their use abovethe figures on 1257, which Beazley places very early in the career of the Amasis Painter (ABV 155, 64). Hence, the two cannotbe far apart in time, and it is temptingto ask if Amasis may have had a hand in forming the two vessels. 4 Leningrad 381 (ABV 293, 12; Paralip. 127, 12) and Munich 2294 (ABV 293, 13), both on white ground;London,B.M. 1900.6-11.1 (ABV 294, 25), in Six's technique. For discussion,
cf. Mertens, Attic White-Ground,pp. 35-40. 5ARV2 98-101, 1-30; Paralip. 330-331; Mertens, Attic White-Ground,pp. 128-129, 131-132. 6 Diosphos Painter: ABL, p. 237, nos. 102-117 bis; ABV 510, 21-24; 703, 24 bis; Paralip. 249-250. Emporion Painter: ABL, pp. 263-264, nos. 1-26; ABV 584-585, 1-14; 709, 2 bis; Paralip. 291; manner of the Emporion Painter: ABV 585, 1 and 2; Paralip. 292; connected with the Emporion Painter: ABL, p. 265, nos. 1-5. Cf. also, Mertens, Attic White-Ground, pp. 95-100. 7 For an alabastron with two friezes of figures, cf., e.g., Athens, N.M. 12768 in the manner of the Haimon Painter (ABL, p. 245, no. 83; ABV 555, 423). For the shape, cf. O. Touchefeu-Meynier, RA, 1972, pp. 93-102 and R. Hampe, AA (Jd 91), 1976, pp. 192-202.
PYXIDES
49
KOTHONS 1260-1264 Pls. 88 and89 The kothon is a vessel used to hold scented liquid. It may not have been called so in antiquity, and there has been a recent attempt to identify it with the exaleiptron,but until its real name has been agreed upon, we shall retain the conventionalname "kothon",as in AgoraXII (p. 180) and in AB V (passim).I The basic characteristicof all kothonsis the curvedshoulderwith deep overhang,which preventedthe liquid from spilling. There are two main types, each known in Attic black figure. The first is multiple-legged, usually tripod,2with each leg attachedto the outside of the receptacle.3The second has a central support, a flaring foot joined to the bottom of the receptacle.4Occasionally, there are two or three lug handles attachedto the rim. The shape is known from the late 7th century B.C. until the beginning of the 4th.5 In Attic black figure, the earliest are by the Gorgon Painter, Akropolis 506, a shoulderfragment,and Athens, N.M. 19172, which is well preserved.6Most Attic black-figuredexamples belong to the first half of the 6th century B.C., particularlyto the Komast Group, the Polos Painter, and the C Painter.7Most of these, but for Athens, N.M. 19172, are of the tripod type. Those from the Agora are very fragmentary. 1260-1262 (Pls. 88, 89) are shoulder fragments, including one by Lydos, and one may not be certain to which type of kothon each belonged. 1263 (PI. 88) is the lid of a tripod-kothonby the Polos Painter, and 1264 (PI. 89) is a patterned lid.
PYXIDES 1265-1296
Fig. 16 Pls. 89-91
The pyxis is a receptacle for cosmetic powder or jewelry, and it is used mainly by women.1 Although a domesticarticle, pyxides are found mostly in graves, which explains the paucity of examples from the Agora. Most of these are tripod-pyxides, 1267-1278, or pyxides of Type A, 12791286. 1290-1296 are lids, mostly fragments, belonging either to tripod-pyxides or to pyxides of Type A, except for 1295 (P1. 91), which comes from the type having a receptaclethat looks like a variant of the Nicosthenic pyxis. The receptacleis plain black;decorationis confinedto the lid.2 TYPE 1265 and 1266 CORINTHIAN
P1. 89
This type of pyxis is identified chiefly by its convex wall that gives the vessel a globular appearance.3 Some are without handles;4 others, as 1266, have two upright cylindrical handles For the shape, cf. Agora XII, pp. 180-181, with bibliography; ABV 348-349; also B. F. Cook, Bull. Metr. Mus. 21, 1962/63, p. 32; P. Mingazzini, AA (Jdl 82), 1967, pp. 344361; I. Scheibler,AA (JdI83), 1968, pp. 389-397; F. Brommer, AA (JdI 95), 1980, pp. 544-549; J. de la Geniere, MonPiot 63, pp. 31-34. For kothonswith splaying feet, cf. Bothmer,ArtBull 57, 1975, p. 122. 2 Munich 6072 has four legs (CVA, Munich 3 [Germany9] 35, p. fig. 5, and pl. 139 [421]:3-5). 3A good example: Brussels A 3 by the Painter of London B 76 (ABV 87, 21). 4A good example: Athens, N.M. 19172 attributed by Scheibler to the Gorgon Painter (JdI 79, 1964, p. 97, figs. 18, 19; Paralip. 7 where the number is given as 16172).
5
Agora XII, p. 181. Akropolis 506 (ABV 9, 10); Athens, N.M. 19172 (footnote 4 above). Komast Group: ABV 25, 13 and 14; 29; 33, 1. Polos Painter: ABV 45, 23-27; Paralip. 20, 25. C Painter:ABV 58, 122-124; 681, 122 bis; Paralip. 23, 122. For the Lille kothon (ABV 681, 122 bis), cf. MonPiot 63, 1980, pp. 35-38, figs. 2-6. 6
1 For the shape, cf. Agora XII, pp. 173-178; also, for the earlier examples, KerameikosVI, ii, pp. 182-183, 186-187. 2 For a list, cf. Paralip. 284. 3 NC, pp. 305-307. 4 NC, 306, p. esp. no. 861, fig. 141 (Corinthian).
SHAPE STUDIES
50
attachedto the shoulder.The rim is fittedto receivea lid and is either incurving,as 1265 (PI. 89), or upright for a lid that fitted over it, similar to the lid of the powder pyxis but with a knob in the center. 1266 is of the latter type. The foot is an echinus one. The system of decorationon 1266 is unusual, for on each side the figures are set in a panel with a frieze of figures above.5 TRIPOD-PYXIDES 1267-1278
Pls. 89, 90
The tripod-pyxis has broad, slightly flaring legs that are usually decoratedwith figures. The foot is normally an echinus one and glazed black, as 1267-1270 and 1274 (Pls. 89, 90), although sometimes on the lesser examples, e.g. 1271 or 1272 (PI. 90), the vessel lacks feet and the legs themselves are the supports.The rim is also glazed black and fitted to receivea lid whose diameterequals that of the rim when measuredat the outside. No Agora lid may be matchedwith its pyxis. The interior of the receptacleis glazed black. The earliest preservedattributedAttic tripod-pyxisseems to be the fragmentaryone from the Akropolisby a painter of the Group of the Dresden Lekanis.6The shape is known throughoutAttic black figure, but it neverbecomesvery common,and the greatestnumber of attributedexamples, including 1275 (PI. 90) and 1276, are by paintersof the Swan Group. Most of the Agora tripod-pyxides belong to the second quarter of the 6th century, particularly to the years around the middle of the century. TYPE A
1279-1286
P1. 90
This type of pyxis is mainly a figuredshape.7Its walls are slightly concaveor nearly straight.The inside of the rim is often flangedto receivea lid with downturnededge, e.g. 1282 and 1286 (P1.90), or it may be plain, e.g. 1280 and 1285. On the latter type, the lid has a flange on its undersideto preventit from slipping off the pyxis. The foot is very low and may be tripartiteor quadripartite,or it may be a simple ring, e.g. 1283 (P1. 90). Occasionally,the vessel lacks a foot, and the floor of the receptacleacts as its base, e.g. 1281 (PI. 90). To judge by 1279, which has a lid with very careless decoration,this type of pyxis in Attic black figure begins early in the 6th century B.c.,8 although most of the examples, including those from the Agora, belong to its secondhalf and to the early 5th. POWDER PYXIDES
1287-1289
Pls. 90, 91
This little vessel is characterizedby its lid, which slips completelyover the receptacle.9The sides may be straightor slightly flaring, and the bottomof the box often protrudesslightly so that the side of the lid rests on a narrow ledge and the profile is not interrupted.1288 and 1289 (P1.91) are good examples. The top edge of the lid is roundedand sometimesprojectsslightly, e.g. 1287 (P1.90) and 1288. Only the lid is decorated;the receptacleis reservedor glazed. Powder boxes appear in Corinthian during the 7th century,but in Attic black figure they are mainly late products,decoratedin a hasty careless manner. A good number of them, including 1287, are by painters of the Swan Group. LIDS 1290-1296 P1.91 See above, p. 49. 5 For another, cf. Princeton 48.54, attributed to the Dolphin Group (ABV 458, 26). 6 Akropolis 510 (ABV 22, 10). A well-preservedbut unattributed example, Kerameikos, inv. no. 44, is probably from about the same time, or even a little earlier (KerameikosVI, ii,
no. 130, pl. 100). 7 For this type, cf. Roberts,Pyxis. 8 KerameikosVI, ii, p. 183; Roberts, Pyxis, p. 9. 9 Cf. AgoraXII, p. 175. Add:Prague 22.88 (CVA, Prague 1 [Czechoslovakia1], pl. 34:2, 3).
LEKANIDES
51
LEKANIDES 1297-1360
Pls. 91-93
The lekanis is a low, rather wide bowl with two horizontal, metallic-lookinghandles. Early examples have a short, conical foot, later ones a flaring ring base. The vessel may be lidless or lidded.1 In Attic black figure, the lekanis is best known in the early period, particularlyin the work of the Nettos Painter and the Panther Painter, as attested by the finds in the cemeteryat Vari.2 About a dozen were decoratedby the KX Painter, including 1336 (PI. 92), and a few others appear in the work of his contemporaries.3Later, more than 60 are known in the work of the Polos Painter, including 12 found in the Agora, 1311-1321 (PI. 92) and 1344 (Pl. 93).4 Elsewhere, the lekanis appears as an isolated example or two in the work of various painters,5and in Attic black figure does not seem to last beyond 500 B.c.6The Agora examples stop well before this date. LIDLESS 1297-1329
Pls. 91, 92
The largest number of lekanides from the Agora are of the lidless variety, which is characterized by a broad, flat, projectingrim. It appears earlier in Attic black figure than the lidded type, for the gap in time between the beginning of the one and that of the other appears to be a little more than two decades (see below, p. 52). The earliest example from the Agora, 1297 (PI. 91), is by the Gorgon Painter and thus is a bit later than those by the Nettos Painter but about the same time as the ones by the Panther Painter.7The largest numberof lidless lekanidesfrom the Agora attributed to a single painter are the 11 by the Polos Painter, 1311-1321 (PI. 92). 1322 may be by him or his companion,but the surface is too worn to be certain of an attribution. The scheme of decorationis a simple one. In the tondo there is a figure or an ornament.Among the Agora examples, only 1297 with its whirligig(?) preservesthis part, but the lekanidesfrom Vari give a good idea of the range of subjects.8On the outside, there is usually an animal frieze on each side that continues under the handles, e.g. 1300 (PI. 91), 1308, or 1315. Abovethe foot are rays, and between the rays and the figures there is often an ornamentalband, e.g. 1297, 1299, 1301 (PI. 91), or 1323. The figures may reach to the rim, e.g. 1303, 1306, 1309, 1310 (PI. 91), and those by the Polos Painter, 1311-1321 (Pl. 92), but more often there is a band of decorationsuch as the guilloche, rosettes,or verticallines, e.g. 1298 and 1299 (PI. 91) or 1304. Occasionallythere is morethan For early Attic black-figured lekanides, cf. Kerameikos VI, ii, pp. 188-189; also, Karouzou,'AvayvpogvTros,pp. 1534, 50-73. For the lidded variety, cf. Richter and Milne, Shapes and Names, pp. 23-24. The best discussion is, however, that in
AgoraXII, pp. 164-173.
2 Nettos Painter:Paralip. 4, 17-24; Panther Painter:Paralip. 11-12, 1-20. The group is fully discussed by Karouzou, 'Avayvpovvros, locc. citt. 3 KX Painter: ABV 24-25, 1-10; Paralip. 14-15, 1-4 bis; manner of the KX Painter: 1337 (P1.92). For examples by contemporaries of the Komast Group, cf. the namepiece of the Group of the Dresden Lekanis, Dresden ZV 1464 (ABV 21, 1) and three from Vourva by Sophilos, Athens, N.M. 998, 997, 999 (ABV 41, 28-30; Bakir, Sophilos, pls. 58-61); also two by the Ceramicus Painter, Kerameikos, inv. no. 39 (ABV 19, 5; KerameikosVI, ii, no. 105, pls. 93, 97) and Kerameikos, inv. no. 41 (ABV 19, 6; KerameikosVI, ii, no. 106, pls. 94-96). The
latter is unusual in having upright handles attachedto the flat surface of the rim, each surmountedby a seated mourner;compare a similar example but with just the handles, Copenhagen, inv. no. 7327 (CVA, Copenhagen 3 [Denmark 3], pl. 100 [102]:4). 4 ABV 45-46, 29-85; Paralip. 20. 5 E.g., mannerof Lydos f: animal pieces (ABV 118,41-47, including 1350: PI. 93), a large number of examples for the time; also 1351 (P1. 93), or three from the Akropolis near the Ready Painter (ABV 130, 1-3), or the one by the Painter of the Vatican Mourner, Wurzburg 442 (ABV 140, 5). 6 The liddedversion lasts much longer and is well known in later red figure. Cf. Agora XII, pp. 165-167. 7 Nettos Painter: ABV 5, 6-9; Paralip. 4, 17-24; Panther Painter:ABV 18, 1-5; Paralip. 11-12, 1-20. 8 Karouzou, 'Avayvpovvros,pls. 29-74.
52
SHAPE STUDIES
one animal frieze, 1301 being the best example from the Agora.9The top of the rim may be glazed or reserved,e.g. 1298 or 1326, but most often it is embellishedwith a simple ornamentsuch as rays (e.g. 1299, 1300), zigzags (e.g. 1301, 1303), or a borderof esses (1310). An odd piece is the whiteground lekanis, 1329, decoratedin silhouette technique that has affinitieswith the Swan Group. It is our only example from the Agora that has its figured decorationpainted upside down so that it may be viewed properlywhen the vessel is hung on the wall.10It is probablyour latest lekanis. LIDDED 1330-1355
Pls. 92, 93
The earliest certain Attic black-figuredexamples of the lidded lekanis are the four by the KX Painter and the namepieceof the Group of the Dresden Lekanis,11which date in the middleto late years of the first quarter of the 6th century B.C.and thus more than two decadesafter the earliest lidless examples by the Nettos Painter.12Among the Agora lekanides, only 1330 (PI. 92), a mid6th-centuryexample comparedwith the Ready Painter, preservesboth bowl and lid. The rest are all quite fragmentary,and since none of the lid fragmentsmay be safely matchedwith any of the bowl fragments,the two parts will be discussedseparately,following the model given by AgoraXII, pp.165-168. BOWLS 1330-1333
P1. 92
The bowl of the lidded lekanis is distinguished from that of the lidless variety chiefly by its flangedrim and its reservedtondo on the inside insteadof one that is decorated.The detailsof shape and the schemeof decorationare the same as that of the lidless type but that there is no ornamenton the rim, which is usually glazed on the side and reservedon the top. LIDS 1334-1355
Pls. 92, 93
The lid of the lekanis is slightly domed,its profilerepeatingroughlythat of the bowl. The stem of the knob flares a little toward the top. The knob itself is flat on top, and if that of 1330 (PI. 92) is typical, its diameteris about equal to that of the foot.13The undersideof the lid may be glazed, e.g. 1330,14 1336, or 1351, or unglazed, e.g. 1337. The resting surface is reserved,e.g. 1354. As mentioned above, with the exception of 1330, which is somewhat unusual, no black-figured lekanis lid from the Agora has been paired with its bowl. But, to judge from the lids comparedwith the contemporarybowls, the scheme of decorationand the choice of subjectson the lids, like their shape, often reflect those of the bowl, so that when the two are seen together, they form a harmonious unit. Rays emanate from the base of the knob, then there may be a zone of ornament,such as dots, e.g. 1336 (PI. 92), or, particularlyon the later examples, a line or two, e.g. 1330, 1350, and 9 For a well-preserved Dreserved example, . Athens, N.M. 296 by the KX Painter (ABV 24, 7). 10Often skyphoi by painters of the Swan Group have the decoration painted upside down. Compare also, two Proto-A cups, Louvre F 131 bis and Boston, M.F.A. 03.784 (CVA, Boston 2 [USA 19], pl. 100 [934]:1-4). Each is an eye-cup with a frieze of upside-down animals between the handle zone and the rays at the bottomof the bowl. Similar friezes may also appear on Droop cups (see below, p. 66). 11KX Painter: ABV 24-25, 7-10, including 1336 (PI. 92);
den Lekanis:ABV 21, 1. Group of the 12Paralip. 4, 17-24. For the chronologyof the Nettos Painter, cf. Karouzou, 'AvayvpovvTroS, pp. 123-136. 13The diameterof the lid on 1330 is broadenough so that it might even be considereda reversiblelid, that is, one that may also be used as a bowl, were it not that this type of lid does not seem to be known before the 5th century B.C.Cf. Agora XII, p. 168. 14 1330 has a reservedband near the center.
PLATES
53
1351 (Pis. 92, 93), that separates the rays from the figures below, which are often animals, arranged in either one or two friezes. 1330 is unusual in having figures on the lid only, its bowl decoratedjust with ornament. 1346 (PI. 93), which preservespart of Herakles and Triton, is the only example from the Agora of a black-figuredlekanis lid with mythologicaldecoration,and 1354 (PI. 93), which preservespart of a chariotto right, is the only other Agora lekanis lid with narrative decoration,15although it occurs on the lids of other shapes, e.g. 369 (PI. 36), 1382 (PI. 95), or 1385 (PI. 94). The stem of the knob is glazed; on the flat surface of the top, there may be concentric circles, e.g. 1330. UNCERTAIN IF LIDLESS OR LIDDED
1356-1360
P1. 93
This small section contains a few fragmentsof lekanideswhich do not preservepart of the rim or the tondo so that the type may be identifiedas lidless or lidded.All of them date beforethe middleof the 6th century B.C.
LIDS 1361-1387
Fig. 17 Pls. 94 and 95
This section includes lids that are too fragmentaryto be certain which kind of vessel each covered. For lids of amphorae, cf. 367-372 (P1. 36), of skyphos-kraters,404-413 (Pls. 40, 41), of pyxides, 1290-1296 (PI. 91), and of lekanides, 1334-1355 (Pls. 92, 93). 1361-1366 (PI. 94), which date from the late 7th or early 6th century B.C.,are fragmentsof large lids and may belong to skyphoskraters,but without more of the curve of the wall preserved,it is difficultto be certain,and they are best kept apart from the skyphos-kraterlids discussedabove, p. 23.-1373 and 1374 are too small to be the lids of skyphos-kraters,at least to judge by the ones known to us, and they seem too large to be the lids of lekanides, although the decorativearrangementis suitable. 1378 is very flat and may be from a tripod-pyxis. 1381 (P1. 95) with its downturnedrim is probablythe lid of a pyxis or a small lekanis, and 1386 (PI. 95) may also come from a lekanis, although it seems a bit flat. 1382 (P1. 95) looks as though it is the lid of a Nicosthenic pyxis. PLATES 1388-1426
Pls. 95-97
The plate is a rather rare shape in Attic black figure.1It was probablynot used during dining, for the unglazed portions would come into contact with the food; more likely, the plate served a religious or a funerary purpose, and the holes for suspension drilled in the rims of many plates, e.g. 1399 (P1. 96), support this suggestion.2There are two main types of Attic black-figured plate, 15For three lids with narrativedecoration,cf., e.g., these by the C Painter: Naples (ABV 58, 119); Akropolis 2112 (ABV 58, 120); Akropolis 2116 (ABV 58, 121). The fullest study of Attic black-figuredplates is D. Callipolitis-Feytmans, Les plats attiques. Here, the evolutionof each type of plate is thoroughly discussed and the individual plates
assigned to their respectiveworkshopsand classes or attributed to painters. Most of the Agora black-figuredplates appear in this volume. For Late Geometricand Protoatticplates from the Agora, cf. Agora VIII, pp. 45-46, nos. 113-119. For the shape in the Archaic period, cf. also, Agora XII, pp. 144-145. 2 Callipolitis-Feytmans,Les plats attiques,p. 21.
54
SHAPE STUDIES
Type A and Type B. They have a parallel development,but examples of Type B are more common during the last quarter of the 6th centuryB.C. than they are in its earlier decades. TYPEA
1388-1410
Pls. 95, 96
The Type A plate has a convex rim and a flat floor,which may thickenslightly towardthe center. The base is attacheddirectly below the junction of the rim. Both the shape of the base and the curve of the rim vary considerablyfrom workshopto workshop. Plates of Type A may be subdividedinto four categoriesaccordingto size: A I is of normalsize (1388-1397: Pls. 95, 96); A II is small (13981407: PI. 96); A III is miniature (1408 and 1409: PI. 96); and A IV is so tiny that it may even have been a child's toy (1410: PI. 96).3 There are two basic systems of decoration.The first has the figures or ornamentset in concentric friezes on the floor of the plate so that it may be seen from all angles and an intendedviewing point is less apparent. 1390, 1399, 1400, 1403, and 1408 are the best though rather fragmentaryexamples from the Agora. The plate in Baltimoreby the Gorgon Painter is a well-preservedexample of this system.4The secondarrangementof the decorationtreats the floorof the plate like that of the tondo of a cup. The figures are shown vertically, and they may utilize the entire surface, as they surely did on 1392 (PI. 95) and 1397 (P1. 96), or there may be an exergue at the bottomcontaining figures or ornament, e.g. 1396.5 Sometimes, in addition, there is a figured or ornamentalexergue abovethe heads of the main figures so that they are isocephalicwithout changingtheir proportions.6 1391 (P1. 95) seems to have been decoratedin this manner, for there is a small amount of tongue pattern at the very top of the fragment. Occasionally,the figures are placed in registers, but this does not occur very often, and it is primarily an early 6th-centuryconventionthat may be inspired by large vases such as dinoi and neck-amphorae,which have the decorationset in friezes.7 1389 (PI. 95) is one of these rare plates and the earliest known example.8On the rim, there is usually an ornamentalpattern, tongues and lotus buds (1396) being the most commonthroughoutthe period during which the Type A plate is in use, but other patterns, such as the lotus-palmette festoon (1389: P1. 95), rosettes (1399 and 1403: P1. 96), or ivy (1409: PI. 96), may also appear. Occasionally, there may be figures on the rim (1401 and 1402: Pl. 96).9 The undersideof the rim is usually glazed but may also be reserved.1399 and 1401-1403, by the Polos Painter, have rays on the underside.The undersideof the floor normally has concentriccircles, 1390 being a good example where the circles are broad flat ridges or 1391 where the two painted circles are of different thicknesses.Occasionally,particularlyon plates by the Polos Painter, 1399, 1400, 1404, and 1405, the undersideof the floor has figures as well, resulting in a two-sided effect to the plate. The earliest attributedAttic black-figuredplates of Type A are by the Gorgon Painterwho seems 3
Ibid., p. 149. For the four categories of Type A: A I, pp. 25-148; A II, pp. 149-167; A III, pp. 169-189; and A IV, pp. 191-198. 4 Baltimore48.215 (ABV9, 18; Paralip. 7, 18; CallipolitisFeytmans, Les plats attiques, p. 309, no. 1,pl. 14, fig. 18). 5 For a figured exergue, which may not be attested on the Agora plates owing to their fragmentarynature, cf. Kerameikos, inv. no. 1637 near the Painter of Vatican 309 (ABV 122, 4; Callipolitis-Feytmans, Les plats attiques, p. 310, no. 5,pl. 16, fig. 19) and Athens, N.M. 19758 (ibid., p. 312, no. 18 bis, pl. 20, fig. 21). 6 Figures: cf., e.g., Akropolis 2401, related to Lydos
(Paralip. 48; Callipolitis-Feytmans,Les plats attiques, p. 301, no. 17,pl. 4) and Florence V 102 a by Lydos (ABV 111, 45; Callipolitis-Feytmans,Les plats attiques, p. 315, no. 2, pl. 21, fig. 23; Tiverios,pl. 71:a). Ornament:cf., e.g., Florence 9674 (ABV 118; Callipolitis-Feytmans, Les plats attiques, p. 320, no. 33,pl. 30, fig. 28) and Swiss, private (ibid., p. 321, no. 38, pl. 32 and fig. 28). 7 Cf. ibid., pp. 39-40. 8 Ibid., pp. 39, 81-82. 9 For a well-preserved example, cf. Baltimore 48.215 by the Gorgon Painter (ABV 9, 18; Paralip. 7, 18; CallipolitisFeytmans, Les plats attiques,p. 309, no. 1,pl. 14, fig. 18).
PLATES
55
to be the first Attic painter to apply himself to decoratingplates.'10None of the Agora plates is by him or in his manner, but 1389 (PI. 95), one of the earliest examples fromthe Agora, is close in time to his late work, and to judge from what remains of the drawing, it is not far from him in style. The next group of large plates are painted by Lydos, who has left us several handsome examples and whose companionsand followers were also interestedin this shape.111391-1393 (PI. 95) are contemporarywith Lydos but do not seem to be connectedwith him. The platesjust discussedare of the bigger, more impressiveType A I. Of the smaller varieties,the greatestnumberfrom the Agora are Type A II, and most of these are by the Polos Painter, 1399-1405 (PI. 96).121398 is close to him in style but seems a bit earlier. The rest of the Agora plates of Type A belong to the last decadesof the 6th century B.C. and to the beginning of the 5th. 1407 is signed by the potter, Salax, who is otherwise unknown, and also bears an inscriptionthat praises Eumares.This plate is not decoratedwith figures, but since it is cited by Beazley in AB V (p. 351), it is included here. 1406 (PI. 96) is a late 6th-century plate with a gorgoneion painted in the center of its floor, which recalls similar decoration in the tondi of late black-figuredcups (1785-1792: Pls. 114, 115), and thus offers a certain link between the decorationof plates and that on the insides of cups. TYPE B
1411-1424
Pls. 96,97
The Type B plate is a more articulated variety than its Type A counterpart. It has a flat or slightly convex floor and a curved rim that often has a molding or a ridge at the point where it is attachedto the floor. The edge of the rim may be moldedor plain, although the formeris more common. On many plates, the outer part of the floor curvesupward to the base of the rim. The ring base is not joined to the floor directly beneath the junction of the rim, as on the Type A plate, but is recessedbeneath the floor. Like the Type A plate, the curve of the rim and the shape of the foot of the Type B plate vary considerably,and also like the Type A, the Type B may be subdividedinto four categories.13In the Agora black figure, only two of these, B I (1411-1416) and B II (14171424), appear. For the most part, the Type B plate derivesfrom the Subgeometricplate, particularlythe position of the ring base and the characterof the rim.14The system of decorationon its top side follows that of Type A, while on the underside,the concentriccirclesor large areas of plain blackemphasizethe structure.15There are not very many Type B plates that may be dated before the beginning of red figure,16and there is none from the Agora. This type of plate is associatedprimarilywith red-figure painters,17 in the early period particularlywith Psiax, Paseas, and Epiktetos,artistswho painted in both the black-figure and the red-figure techniques.18The decorationof certain late 6th-century plates, especially those of Type B II, is influencedby black-figuredcups, and these plates seem to 10 ABV 9-10, 18-21; Paralip. 7, 18 and 19. For a detailed discussion, cf. Callipolitis-Feytmans, Les plats attiques, pp. 63-67. I1 Lydos: ABV 111-112, 45-57; Paralip. 44, 50-57 bis, 46. For plates by Lydos and their relationship to various potters and workshops,as well as plates by his companions,cf. Callipolitis-Feytmans, Les plats attiques, pp. 87-119; for the wider circle of Lydos, pp. 123-139. 12 Other plates by the Polos Painter: ABV 47, 103-126, including 1399-1404 (PI. 96); Paralip. 20, 103-125, 21 (including 1405); Callipolitis-Feytmans, Les plats attiques, pp. 160-167. 13 For the type, cf. Callipolitis-Feytmans, Les plats attiques,
pp. 201-209, 231-284; for the categories: B I, pp. 257-277; B II, pp. 231-238, 241-255; B III, pp. 238-240; and B IV, pp. 279-284. 14Ibid., pp. 201-203. 15Ibid., p. 206. 16For these, cf. ibid., pp. 201-209. 17 For red-figuredplates of Type B, cf. ibid., pp. 211-229. 18 Psiax: black figure:ABV 292-295; Paralip. 127-128; red figure: ARV2 6-8, 1-12; Paralip. 321. Paseas: black figure: ABV 399-400; Paralip. 160; red figure:ARV2 163-164, 1-14; Paralip. 337. Epiktetos:bilingual cups:ARV2 70-71, 1-4,7, 8, 10, and 12.
SHAPE STUDIES
56
come from cup workshops.191423, with its large area of glaze surroundingthe central gorgoneion, is an example.20 All the Type B plates from the Agora belong to the late 6th centuryB.C.or to the first half of the 5th. There are not many of them, and most are very fragmentary.1411 (PI. 96) is decoratedin Six's technique, and besides one from the Akropolis,it may be the only example of this techniqueused to decoratea plate.211414 and 1415 (Pls. 96, 97) are attributedto the KleiboulosPainter, the principal decoratorof plates during the first quarter of the 5th century B.C.His known work was put together by Callipolitis-Feytmans, and he takes his name from a white-ground ostrakon found between the Areopagus and the Hill of the Nymphs.221414 (P1. 96), like the ostrakonand many other plates by the Kleiboulos Painter, has its decorationon white ground. OTHERPLATES1425 and 1426 P1.97 1425 is a floor and rim fragment, and its type may not be identifiedfor certain. It comparesbest with plates by Psiax, and it probablyhad one figure, or at most two, paintedon its floor. 1426 is the leg of a tripod-plate,and there does not seem to be a good parallel for its shape. PHIALAI 1427-1439
Pls. 97 and 98
The phiale is a low, shallow, footless bowl without handles, used mainly for pouring libations, occasionallyalso for drinking. On the inside is an omphalos, and on the undersidethere is a correspondingdepressionthat is essential for holdingthe vessel. The shape is best known in metal;clay examples are not very common. The outside of the black-figuredphiale is unglazed, except for the rim, which is black and slightly outturned,e.g. 1429 or 1437. The inside is glazed except where the decorationappears. The figures surroundthe omphalosand may be set in one or two friezes, 1429, 1431, and 1433 (Pls. 97, 98) being the best examples from the Agora, and usually the ground line for the figures is toward the rim, not toward the omphalos. 1428 (PI. 97) is a rare exception,being also glazed on the outside. Round the omphalosthere is a zone of tongues (1428 and 1433: Pls. 97, 98), although this area may be plain (1427: P1.97). Usually the omphalosis black;1438 (PI. 98) is unusual for having figureddecoration. In Attic black figure, most of the known phialai, including 1428-1439, are late 6th or early 5th centuryB.C. 1427 (P1.97), by a painter of the Swan Group, is the earliest black-figuredphiale from the Agora, and it may even be one of the very earliest in silhouette technique, for it comes from a context with a lower date of the first quarterof the 6th centuryB.C.2 1428 (P1. 97) is one of the very few examples decoratedin true black figure, i.e., with incision, ratherthan in Six's technique,3e.g. 19Callipolitis-Feytmans,Les plats attiques,p. 235. Ibid., p. 255. Callipolitis-Feytmans (Les plats attiques, p. 229) gives Akropolis 1074 and 1411 (PI. 96) as the only examples but goes on to suggest (note 57) that a lost plate reproducedin a drawing by Benndorf (Griechische und sicilische Vasenbilder, Berlin 1869-1883, pl. 8:2) may have been decoratedin Six's technique. 22 p 17970, which preserves the letters ]OAEMO; another ostrakon found in the Agora at the same time, P 17678, preserves the name KAIBOLOL NIKOAEMO, thus permitting the inscriptionon P 17970 to be similarly restored.Cf. Callipolitis-Feytmans, Les plats attiques, p. 267 and p. 396, no. 9. For the painter, cf. ibid., pp. 266-276 and pp. 395-399, nos. 1-40. 20 21
'The basic study is H. Luschey, Die Phiale, Bleicherodeam-Harz 1939, esp. pp. 147-155 for clay examples; cf. also, Agora XII, pp. 105-106, with bibliography;most recently, C. Cardon, "Two Omphalos Phialai," The J. Paul Getty Museum Journal 6-7, 1978-1979, pp. 131-138, esp. p. 133, note 12 for a list of clay examples. 2 E 14:8 (below, p. 331). Other phialai by the Swan Group: ABV 655, 23-25 and 27-30. On the difficulty of dating individual Swan Group vases, cf. ABV655 and Hesperia 13, 1944, p. 57. 3 For other vases in Sixs technique, cf. the catalogue entry for 1175 (PI. 86).
CHALICES
57
1430 and 1431 (PI. 97), or in plain silhouette. The silhouette phialai may have the decorationin plain black glaze (1427 and 1429: PI. 97), like that of many late lekythoi, cups, and skyphoi, or the decorationmay be applied in white over the black glaze, e.g. 1434-1436 (P1. 98). Very few Attic black-figuredphialai have been attributedto painters,4but the generally small size of many suggests that they are very likely productsof workshopsspecializingin small shapes (lekythoi,skyphoi, or cups), rather than those producinglarge pots.5 MASTOID 1440 PI. 98 The mastoid is a deep, flat-bottomedbowl with a sharply outturnedrim. It may or may not have handles, and on those that have, they are attachedto the bowl at the level of the maximum diameter. On the handleless variety, the figureddecorationcontinuesaround;on the handledtype, it is divided between obverse and reverse, and sometimesthe figures appear between eyes, just as they do on some contemporaryskyphoi and cups. The rim is glazed black, its outer edge reserved;the area below the figures is also black, usually with a narrow or wide reservedband.1 In Attic black figure, the mastoid appears in the late 6th century and continueswell into the first quarter of the 5th.2 Most attributedexamples are decoratedin the mannerof the Haimon Painter,3 and a few others belong to the Leafless Group and to the Caylus Painter,4an artist principally involved with the decorationof cups. In the Agora black figure, 1440 is the only mastoid, a fragment of the rim and bowl with the figures in silhouette on white ground. It is uncertainwhether it had handles.
CHALICES 1441-1450
Pls. 98 and 99
There are not very many Attic black-figuredchalices, and all those known to us come from Athens or near Athens.1 Most of them were found in the Agora.2 The chalice has a flaring wall with a narrow, projecting rim or one that is plain, like that of a kantharos, a cul to which handles are attached, and a conical foot. The Attic shape may have been inspired by the Chian one, which is 4 Three with tongue pattern round the omphalos are signed by Nikosthenes:London, B.M. B 368 (ABV 234, 1); Wiirzburg 429 (ABV 234, 2); Cab. Med. 334 (ABV 234, 3). With these, Luschey (op. cit. [footnote1 above, p. 56], p. 151) connectedtwo others: Delos 640 (Delos X, pl. 52) and London, B.M. B 678 (AZ, 1881, pl. 5:1). On the London phiale and its Nicosthenic connections, cf. also, Mertens, Attic White-Ground,pp. 103104, and C. Cardon, op. cit. (footnote 1 above, p. 56), p. 133, note 12. 5 Cf. Luschey, op. cit., pp. 149 and 151.
Here are a few examples that illustrate the shape: Handleless: FrankfurtVF 8 315 (CVA, Frankfurt2 [Germany30], pl. 51 [1442]:7, 8); once Castle Ashby (CVA, Castle Ashby [GB 15], pl. 23 [678]:11-13). Handles: Frankfurt VF 8 313, 314, and 316 (CVA, Frankfurt 2 [Germany 30], pl. 51 [1442]:1-6); Hanover 759 (CVA, Hannover 1 [Germany 34], pl. 24
[1656]:4-6). 2 For an early special model with a rather roundedbody, a broad flaring foot, and two vertical handles, cf. Louvre F 70 by the Amasis Painter (ABV 156, 76; Bothmer, Amasis Painter, pp. 198-199, cat. no. 53). 3 ABV 557-560, 449-512; 707; Paralip. 271. 4 ABV648-649, 238-246; Paralip. 311, 241, and 313. Other than Agoraexamples, cf. Athens, Vlasto Collection, from Spata, by the Anagyrus Painter (ABV 21, 2); Athens, N.M. 995, from Vourva, by Sophilos (ABV 39, 11; Bakir, Sophilos, pls. 55-57); Louvre CA 2988, from near Menidi (CVA, Louvre 12 [France 19], pl. 193 [866]); and Akropolis 1957NAK 1580 (AcAr 27, 1972 [1973], p. 300, no. 279 and pl. 140). 2 Besides the black-figured ones, cf. also the black-patterned ones: P 2745 (E. Vanderpool,Hesperia 15, 1946, p. 326, no. 296, pl. 66), P 5210, and P 6582.
SHAPE STUDIES
58
more commonand appears earlier than the Attic examples.3Very little Chian potterywas exported to mainland Greece, yet fragments of four Chian chalices were found on the Akropolis,4and two small, well-preserved, late 7th-century examples as well as four fragmentscome from the Agora excavations.5 Attic black-figured chalices normally have figures painted on the flaring part of the wall and usually two zones of decorationon the cul. The upper one may containeither figures or ornament; the lower one has rays paintedjust above the junction of the foot.6The verticalpart of a projecting rim is most often decoratedwith a row of dots. A plain rim has a black line. The handles and foot are plain black. The Agora black-figuredchalices are too fragmentaryto give a good idea of the complete appearanceof a single vase, but they do furnish evidencefor the variation in decoration. All of them have figures on the flaring part of the wall. On the three fragmentsthat preservesome of the cul, 1441 has three zones of decoration,one of figures, two of ornament (row of dots above rays), 1444 (PI. 98) shows only part of one figure but probablyhad rays in the lower zone, and 1445 may have had ornamentonly, for the upper part containsverticallines. Four projectingrims have the customaryrow of dots on the vertical part (1441-1443 and 1446: Pls. 98, 99). 1447 (PI. 99) by Lydos has a border of esses. 1445 has a plain rim like that of the chalice by Sophilos.7The two chalice fragmentsby Lydos, 1446 and 1447, have a tongue pattern below the rim at the top of the figure zone. SKYPHOI 1451-1657
Figs. 18 and 19 Pls. 99-107
The skyphos is a popular drinking cup with a deep bowl, two handles attachedjust below the rim, and a broad foot that insures stability when the vessel is filled with wine.1 A large number of Attic black-figuredskyphoi have been found in the Agora excavations,most of them dating from the last years of the 6th century B.C. and the beginning of the 5th. Two main varieties of skyphos, the Corinthianand the Attic, appear in Agora black figure, but examples of the Attic type are far more numerous. CORINTHIANTYPE
1451-1471
P1. 99
This type of skyphosis a directborrowingfrom Corinth,and while it never becomesvery popular in Attic black figure, in Attic red figure and in black-glazed ware it continues into the 4th Cf. R. M. Cook, BSA 44, 1949, pp. 155 and 158. For the shape, cf. also Hayes in Boardman and Hayes, Tocra, 19631965, pp. 57-63 and Boardman,Excavations in Chios, 19521955: GreekEmporio, London 1967, pp. 119-122 for the Geometric and 7th-centuryexamples, pp. 156-161 for the 6th. 4 Cook, BSA 44, 1949, pp. 159-160 for the findspotsof exported Chian pottery, and p. 160 for the Akropolis fragments. 5 E. Brann, Hesperia 30, 1961, p. 357, G 54 and G 55. 6 The main exceptionto this general schemeof decorationis the unattributedchalice in the Louvre, CA 2988 (CVA, Louvre 12 [France 19], pl. 193 [866]). The flaring part of the wall is decoratedinside and outside with figures.On the cul, below the handle zone, there are two wide black bands separated by a narrow reservedstrip, and just above the foot are tongues. 3
7 Athens 995 (ABV39, 11; Bakir, Sophilos,pls. 55-57). Cf. also, Louvre CA 2988 (CVA, Louvre 12 [France 19], pl. 193 [866]).
For the shape, the best summary is in Agora XII, pp. 81-87, with bibliography. Cf. also, Richter and Milne, Shapesand Names, pp. 26-28; B. Freyer-Schauenburg,JdI 85, 1970, pp. 20-22. For the series in Attic black figure from Rhitsona, cf. Ure, Sixth, pp. 57-73. For the 7th-century predecessors,cf. Brann,AgoraVIII, pp. 49-50. For red-figured skyphoi of Corinthian type, cf. A. Lezzi-Hafter, Der Schuwalow-Maler, eine Kannenwerkstattder Parthenonzeit[Kerameus II], Mainz 1976, pp. 35-36 and the additionsby Bothmer in his review, AJA 82, 1978, p. 127.
SKYPHOI
59
century B.C.2 The Corinthian type of skyphos has very thin walls that curve inward slightly at the rim, narrow handles, and a ring foot. No complete black-figured example of the type has been found in the Agora, but taken together, the few fragmentsgive a reasonableidea of the shape. The scheme of decorationis a simple one. The figures reach right to the rim with only one or two lines for a border (e.g. 1461 or 1464: P1. 99). Above the foot are very narrow rays (e.g. 1460 or 1465: PI. 99), and between the rays and the figure zone, there may be a band of glaze (1465), a zone of ornament,3or a mere line separating the rays from the figures (1459 or 1460: PI. 99). Beneath the handles there is often an ornamentalconfiguration(1452: PI. 99), or else the figures may continue round the vase (1465). The whole effect is delicate and light. The earliest Attic black-figured skyphoi of Corinthian type are by painters of the Komast Group,4 the same artists who decoratedcolumn-kratersshowing a strong Corinthian influence in both shape and style of drawing. 1452 is by the KX Painter, and 1454 (PI. 99) probablybelongs to the Komast Group but is difficult to attribute to a painter. Contemporarywith these is the unpublished one in Athens by Sophilos,5and a little later than all of them is the well-known one in the Louvre by the C Painter.6Around the middle of the 6th century B.C., the painters of the Group of the Oxford Lid decoratedseveral skyphoi of this type,7including three from the Agora, 1463-1465 (PI. 99), and one that may be compared,1466, to which we have added a second, 1467. From later in the century come the nearly two dozen miniature examples of the Swan Group,8and although some of these were found in Athens, none comes from the Agora. Elsewhere in Attic black figure, this type of skyphos is very rare. ATTICTYPE
1472-1656
Pls. 100-107
The Attic type of skyphos is adaptedfrom the Corinthianbut has a thickerwall, heavierhandles, and a strong torus foot.9The chief difference,however, is the outturnedrim. The type begins about the middle of the 6th century B.C.but undergoes a long period of experiment before attaining its canonical shape in the early 5th century.10Throughout the history of the shape, the profile and the scheme of decorationmay vary considerablyfrom workshop to workshop or from potter to potter. The Agora examples give a good illustration of the possibilities. The earliest attributedblack-figuredskyphoi of the Attic type from the Agora are two that belong to the Hermogenian Class,11which is rather light in make with a deep bowl that tapers toward the foot and an offset lip that is glazed black. The decorationis confinedto the handle zone, as on bandcups, and may be either figuredor simply bear a potting signature,as on the Agora examples, 1473 and 1474. At the top of the handle zone there is a black line and at each handle a palmette.The area below this is glazed black except for a reservedband. One of the Agora examples, 1473, is signed by Hermogenes himself;the other also bore a signature,but not enough letters remain to be sure of the 2 Agora XII, p. 83. For the Corinthian type, cf., in addition to Agora XII, pp. 81-83 and to the referencesin note 2, p. 81, Greifenhagen, pp. 20-21; footnote 1 above, p. 58. 3 There is no example from the Agora. Cf. the net pattern on Athens, N.M. 640 by the KX Painter (ABV 26, 21) and the tongue pattern with the net above and below on Louvre MNC 676 by the C Painter (ABV 57, 118; Bothmer, Amasis Painter, p. 202, fig. 105). On the latter, the characteristicornament round the tondi of the painter'sSiana cups has been transferred to the outside of a skyphos (cf., e.g., Athens, N.M. 531 [ABV 55, 92] where it also appears below the figures on the outside). 4 KX Painter: ABV25-26, 19-25 and Paralip. 15; manner
of the KX Painter: ABV 28, 2; manner of the KY Painter: Paralip. 16, 8 bis; KomastGroup:VIII, Unallotted:ABV 35, 1 and 2, and 36, 19; Paralip. 17; connected with the Komast Group: ABV 37, 6-9. 5 Athens, N.M. 19044 (Paralip. 19, 32 bis). 6 Louvre MNC 676 (footnote3 above). 7 ABV 616, 1-10; Paralip. 306, 5 bis. 8 ABV 655, 1-21. 9 Agora XII, pp. 84-85. 10 Agora XII, p. 84. 1' Cf. ABV 166, 1-3 and Paralip. 87-88 for extensive lists, both with bibliography.
60
SHAPE STUDIES
name. These two skyphoi are too fragmentaryto illustrate the shape well, but they convey the systemof decoration.Contemporarywith these is 1475 (PI. 100), the very beautifulfragmentwhich may be by Lydos and, if so, adds a new shape to the many decoratedby him. Not very many black-figuredskyphoi from the decadesca. 550-510 B.C.have been found in the Agora, but the few that have come to light furnish evidencefor the experimental attitude of Attic potterstoward the shape during this time. 1476 (PI. 100) is an odd piece with rays abovethe foot as on the Corinthian type but with a slightly flaring rim. Its best parallel is one from Rhitsona,'2 which, however,was not classedby Ure. 1480 (PI. 100) is a fragmentof Ure's Class of SkyphoiA 1, which is identified mainly by its rounded rim glazed black and separatedfrom the body by a reservedgroove.131481 and 1482 belong to Ure's Class of SkyphoiA 2, which differs from Class A 1 by having a slightly outturnedrim.14Both types have the same kind of handle decorationas the FP Class of cups:15a very large horizontal palmette at each handle, two small palmettes north and south, and beneath the handle, a flower of very distinct shape. 1481 is a good illustration of this ornamentaldecoration. The most important black-figuredskyphos of this period from the Agora is 1483 (P1. 100), related to the KrokotosPainter, who takes his name from the yellow garment worn by his maenads and dancing girls.16The skyphoi of this workshopbelong to Ure's Class B: large handsomevessels with an outturnedrim, a thick wall, and a heavy torus or flaring foot with a fillet between it and the body.17An ivy pattern embellishesthe rim; the figures occupymost of the space on the body. Above the fillet is a tongue pattern, and between it and the figures there are lines, usually three. The decorativeeffect is colorful owing to the liberal use of added red and white, and the white is often yellowish. About 500 B.C., this workshop initiated the skyphoi of the Heron Class, so called for the white heron often painted directlyon the clay beneath each handle.18A numberof artists decorated skyphoi of this type. The best are those by the Theseus Painter, 13 of which were found in the Agora, 1484-1496 (Pls. 100, 101). Several are very fragmentary,but others, 1484, 1486, and 1490 (Pls. 100, 101), are well preserved.1484 and 1485 have the characteristicwhite heron beneaththe handle. Others, such as 1486 or 1490, do not, and in the case of the fragmentaryexamples, there is no way to be certain what was beneaththe handles. The Theseus Painter'sskyphoi have much less accessorycolor than others of this type, and their effect is a more somberone. Contemporarywith these is 1657 (P1. 107), a shallow cup-skyphos of special shape, also decoratedby the Theseus Painter. Its rim is flat on top and glazed black. On each side is a single figure and at each handle, a spiral and pomegranateconfiguration.The effect is elegant and delicate, similar to that on 1825 (P1. 117), a cup that recalls the Painter of Nicosia C 975. The decorativescheme of each is similar to that of the special type of cup in Oxford by the Amasis Painter.19 The largest number of Attic black-figured skyphoi from the Agora may be dated in the first quarterof the 5th centuryB.C., the same periodthat producedsuch large quantitiesof lekythoi.The Agora skyphoi come mainly from two workshops, that of the Haimon Painter and his associates and that of the CHC Group, whose painters often decoratedskyphoi of the Heron Class. The skyphoi of the Haimon Group are of various classes.20In general, they are rather small, 12 Ure, Sixth, p. 72 (49.265). 13Ure, Sixth, p. 58. For a list, cf. Paralip. 83-86, 1-51, with bibliography. 14Ure, Sixth, p. 58. For a list, cf. Paralip. 91, 1-12. Some of these have tongues above the foot (7-12). 15 For the class and decoration,cf. Paralip. 80-82. 16On this group, cf., particularly,A. D. Ure, "Krokotosand
White Heron,"JHS 75, 1955, pp. 90-103. Also, ABV 205-209 and Paralip. 93-99. 17 Ure, Sixth, pp. 59-61. 18ABV 617, with bibliography. 9 Oxford 1939.118 (ABV 157, 89; Paralip. 65, 89; Bothmer,Amasis Painter, pp. 227-228, cat. no. 63). 20ABV 565-571, 598-710 and Paralip. 271 and 285-287.
SKYPHOI
61
sturdy vessels, well suited to everyday use. 1502 (P1. 102) is a cup-skyphos of the pinchbase type (Ure's Group R21),which gets its name from the sharp inward curveof the body towardthe foot. Its glazed rim is offset, and its foot is in two degrees,a glazed torus beneatha reservedverticalmember. At each handle, next to the hastily drawn figures is a large, upright palmettewith a reservedheart. 1503 is similar to the pinchbase type but lacks the incurve at the base. Most of the Haemonian skyphoi belong to Ure's Class K 2, 1504-1516 (Pls. 102, 103), each a rather shallow, squat vessel with a glazed outturnedrim and a broad torus foot that is also glazed. The figures usually stand on a broad ground line, and at each handle there is an upright palmette with a solid heart that is often decoratedwith a white dot.22On the inside below the rim there is a reservedline as on cups, and on the underside of the floor there are concentriccircles with a central dot. 1512 and 1513 are good, characteristicexamples from the Agora. Three skyphoi in the manner of the Haimon Painter, 1531-1533 (PI. 103), have a deep bowl and an incurving rim, but in other respectsthey recall the K 2's.23The Haemonian skyphoi of this class take with them those by the Painter of Elaious I, 1536 (P1. 104) and two that may be compared, 1537 and 1538. Connectedwith the late membersof the Haimon Group are the painters of the LanicutGroup, whose skyphoi are hastily decorated in silhouette style. Some are minature skyphoi of Hermogenian type (e.g. 1539); others are cup-skyphoi of pinchbase type (e.g. 1540: P. 104). Not far from all of them are a large number of skyphoi of Class K 2, decoratedby differenthands in either silhouetteor incision, of which many have been found in the Agora, 1543-1569 (P1. 104). Akin to the Lancut Group are the miniature whiteground skyphoi of the Lindos Group, 1570-1577 (Pls. 104, 105). These are of ordinary blackfigure shape with an offset rim and diagonal handles. The silhouette figures are sloppily drawn, and the whole effect is rather wretched. Well over 100 skyphoi have been attributedto the CHC Group, a rather rough group of painters.24As mentioned above, these skyphoi are of the Heron Class and are much larger vessels than those of the Haimon Group just discussed. 1578-1603 (PI. 105) are the examples from the Agora, and 1604-1612 (Pls. 105, 106) have been connected with the group. The figured decorationon these skyphoi is placed rather high so that there is a large area of black glaze between it and the tongues above the foot, which are usually reducedto elongatedblobs. There are lines between the figures and the black below, and usually there is a line at the top of the figure zone just below the rim. The figures may extend to the handles, e.g. 1578 or 1588 (PI. 105), or they may be framedby solid upright palmettes at each handle, e.g. 1596 or 1597 (PI. 105). On those connectedwith the group, the figures are often set between eyes, e.g. 1608 or 1610 (PI. 106). The rim may be glazed black, e.g. 1590-1592 (P1. 105), or it may be decoratedwith ivy that has degeneratedto two rows of dots with a line between, e.g. 1588 (PI. 105). Rather elegant skyphoi are those of the Pistias Class, which have plain rims and mastoid bodies.251613-1616 (P1. 106) are the examples from the Agora, and 1617 may also be from a Pistian skyphos. The decorationis simple, only one or two figures between a palmette at each handle, and may be on white ground (1615: PI. 106) or on red (1613, 1614, and 1616: PI. 106). Below the figures there are bands and lines, e.g. 1614, or ornament, 1613 (PI. 106). The crenellationpatternon 1615 (PI. 106) is rare and recalls its use on other white-groundvessels, particularlyin the work of Psiax.26Above the foot are rays. 1614 is unusual for being reservedand undecoratedin this area. 21
Ure, Sixth, pp. 71-72. Ure, Sixth, p. 68. 23 For others, cf. ABV 570-571. 24 AB V 617-626 and Paralip. 306-308. 22
25 Ure, Sixth, pp. 69-71; ABV 627-628; Paralip. 309; Mertens, Attic White-Ground,pp. 91-92. 26 Cf. the note under the catalogue entry for 1615.
SHAPE STUDIES
62
CUPS 1658-1846
Figs. 20 and 21
Pls. 108-118
The cup is the most commontype of black-figureddrinkingvessel, and from the second quarter of the 6th century B.C.on, we have the names of many potters who fashion the shape.1 Of all the smaller vessels accountedfor in Attic black figure from the Agora, cups are outnumberedonly by lekythoi and skyphoi. The drinking cup has a wide, rather shallow bowl, with or without an offset lip, and two horizontal handles. The shape of the foot and the height of the stem, as well as the system of decoration,vary accordingto the type of cup. Every majortype of Attic black-figuredcup has been found in the Agora, as well as a few special types. CUPS 1658 and 1659 KOMAST
PI. 108
The Komast cup, which is the earliest type of Attic black-figuredcup, takes its name from the paddeddancersthat decorateeach side of its exterior.2This sturdy,practical-lookingcup has a deep bowl with thin horizontalhandles attachedjust below the narrowoffset lip and with a broadconical foot. The shape derivesfrom Corinthian,3but with modifications,mainly that the Attic versionhas longer handles and taller proportions.4The scheme of decorationis a simple one. On each side of the body, there are two or three komasts, and at the handles, a configurationof a lotus and a palmette with tendrils, in contrast to the Corinthian preference for leaving this area undecorated. Above the foot there are thin rays similar to those above the foot of the Corinthiantype of skyphos, and between the rays and the figures, there are three lines. On the rim is a simple ornamental pattern. The interior is plain black, unlike the Corinthianwhich has a decoratedtondo. In Attic black figure, Komast cups first appear in the workshopof the Komast Group, to which belong the two very fragmentaryexamples, 1658 and 1659 (PI. 108), and they are decoratedmainly by the KY Painter (1658).5 The shape does not have a very long history in Athens and lasts only until the early secondquarter of the 6th century,at which time it is replacedby the Siana cup. SIANACUPS 1660-1684
Pls. 108-110
The Siana cup is named after the site on Rhodes where two well-known examples now in the British Museum were found.6It is the principal type of Attic cup during the secondquarter of the 'See particularly ABV chaps. III-V, XII-XIV, and XLIII. 2 On the shape, cf. esp. Greifenhagen;Payne, NC, pp. 194, 197-198, 200 and for the Corinthiantype, pp. 310-312; F. Villard, REA 48, 1946, pp. 155-157; G. M. A. Richter in CVA, New York 2 [USA 11], p. 1; Beazley, Development, p. 20; Brijder,Siana Cups I, pp. 10-12, 17-20, 59-131; P. J. Connor and H. A. G. Brijder, "A Komast Cup," Greek Vasesin the J. Paul Getty Museum 1, 1983, pp. 1-8. 3 Cf. Brann (Agora VIII, p. 47) who shows that the Subgeometric skyphos, which shares similarities of shape with the Komast cup, particularly the deep bowl and offset rim, can be tracedinto the last quarterof the 7th centuryB.c. and goes on to say, "the shape is well on the way to the black ware cups of komast shape (P 17837), thus showing that this foremost 6th century Attic cup has an Attic ancestry."P 17837 (AgoraXII, no. 381, pl. 18) belongs to the Class of Athens 1104, named after the cup signed by Exekias, and the majorityof examples of this shape, which derives from the Komast Group, date from the second quarter of the 6th century and a little later (Agora XII, pp. 88-89). This leaves a significantgap in time (10 to 20
years) between the end of Brann's Subgeometricseries and the beginning of the 6th-century Attic black-figuredcups. Brijder (Siana Cups I, pp. 17, 39-44), on the other hand, sees a direct line of descent from these late Subgeometricskyphoi through the late 7th-centuryand early 6th-centuryAttic plain-ware vessels of Pre-Komast shape to the Attic black-figured Komast cup. It seems difficult to believe that the black-figuredKomast cup derivedfroma plain-ware version.The truth may lie somewhere in between, especially since this varietyof cup, as well as the skyphos of Corinthian type, begins in the workshop of the KomastGroup (see below); it seems more likely that these very Corinthianizing Attic artists borrowed the shape from their Corinthianneighborsand modifiedit to suit the Athenian taste. 4 Compare the profile drawings given by Greifenhagen, p. 19. 5 AB V 32, 9-28, and top of 33; Paralip. 17 (including 1658 and 1659). 6 London, B.M. B 380 by the C Painter (ABV 55, 91) and London, B.M. B 379 in his manner (ABV 60, 20; Paralip. 26, 20). For the shape, cf. F. Villard, REA 48, 1946, pp. 157-159; G. M. A. Richter in CVA, New York 2 [USA 11], p. 1; Beazley,
CUPS
63
6th century B.C.The shape derives from the Komast cup but differs in having a deeper bowl, a higher lip, and a taller conical foot, resulting in a lighter, more elegant-looking vessel than its predecessor.The scheme of decorationvaries, and it differs from that of the Komast cup chiefly in that the Siana cup has a decoratedtondo, usually containing one or two figures surroundedby a wide band of ornament. 1669 and 1678 (PI. 109) are two good examples from the Agora. On the outside, there are two schemes of decoration. One maintains the natural division of the cup by keeping the decorationon the lip separate from that on the bowl, thus achieving a double-decker effect. The decorationin the handle zone of the bowl is nearly always figured,7while that on the lip may be either figuredor ornamentalwith a markedpreferencefor the latter.8The kind of ornament varies considerably, although ivy seems to be the most frequent type. 1678 (PI. 109) is the best preservedexample of the double-deckerscheme from the Agora. The second scheme of decoration on the outside allows the figures to extend over both the handle zone and the lip with only a black line defining the junction between the two parts of the bowl. 1662, 1669, and 1671 (Pls. 108, 109) are good but fragmentary examples from the Agora. Siana cups decoratedin the double-decker scheme are more likely to have ornamentalpatterns below the figures on the bowl than those with overlap decoration,which usually have a simple reservedband with lines, e.g. 1660, 1662 (PI. 108), or 1669.9 On a few Siana cups, the two schemes are combined.10 In Attic black figure, the chief painters of Siana cups are the C Painter, the Heidelberg Painter, and the Griffin-birdPainter.111660-1667 (Pls. 108, 109) are by the C Painter;1668 (PI. 109) is in his manner;1669, 1670, and perhaps 1678 (PI. 109) are relatedto him. 1671,1672, 1679, and 1682 (Pls. 109, 110) are by the Heidelberg Painter. No Agora Siana cup has been attributed to the Griffin-bird Painter who, to judge from the large number of his cups found at Taranto and other sites not in mainland Greece, may have worked chiefly for the export market. The Siana cup does not last much beyond the middle of the 6th centuryB.C., after which the Little Master cup becomes the preferred type.12 Most of the Agora Siana cups, except for 1678, are very fragmentary, but examined collectively, they present a reasonable illustration of this shape and its scheme of decoration.
Development, p. 21; Brijder, Siana Cups I, pp. 20-23, 135295; and E. Rhode in Studies in Honour of Arthur Dale Trendall, p. 135. 7 Here are a few exceptions:Three by the C Painter: Hillsborough, Hearst, ivy on the lip and upright lotus buds in the handle zone (ABV 56, 101; Paralip. 23, 101; Brijder, Siana Cups I, pl. 43:a); London, B.M. 1906.12-15.3, ivy on the lip and a black bowl but for a band of tonguesjust below the place where the figures would end (ABV 57, 109); Oxford 1965.120, ivy on the rim and an inscriptionbetween palmettes in the handle zone (ABV 57, 112; Paralip. 23, 112). One by the Painter of Boston C.A.: New York, M.M.A. 12.234.3, black rim; lotuspalmette chain in the handle zone; below that, tongue pattern between net and rays (ABV 69, 3). Two attributedby Bothmer to the Ptoon Painter: New York, M.M.A. 12.234.2, male head between grazing deer on the rim, chain of palmettes in handle zone (CVA, New York 2 [USA 11], pl. 4); Tocra, ivy on the rim, chain of palmettes in handle zone (Boardmanand Hayes, Tocra, 1963-65, pl. 76, no. 1040). Unattributed:Cologne P 5, ivy on the rim, reservedhandle zone with tongues below. 8 For figures on the lip, cf., e.g., two Siana cups by the C Painter, Munich 2121 (ABV 56, 96) and Hamburg 1908.255 (ABV 56, 102; Paralip. 23, 102; CVA, Hamburg 1 [Germany 41], pl. 34 [2000]; Brijder,Siana Cups I, pl. 49:a, b), each with
hounds pursuing a hare, two fawns; Dijon 1299 by the Griffinbird Painter (ABV 74, 52), swans between drinkinghorns. Occasionally, on the rim, animals are combined with ornament. Here are two, both by the Griffin-birdPainter:Honolulu 3591 (ABV 73, 32), bull between florals, and Baltimore48.36 (ABV 73, 39), deer between florals. 9 For a good example of the more decorativeeffect of the double-decker Siana cups, cf. London, B.M. B 380 by the C Painter (ABV 55, 91). For a double-deckerSiana cup with a reservedband, cf. 1678 or Hamburg 1908.255 by the C Painter (ABV 56, 102; Paralip. 23, 102; CVA, Hamburg 1 [Germany 41], pl. 34 [2000]; Brijder,loc. cit.). 10Examples: Two by the C Painter: Berlin, inv. no. 4281 (ABV 56, 98) and Athens, N.M. 534 (ABV 56, 105); Kassel T. 663 that is not so like the C Painter on the outside (Paralip. 25; CVA, Kassel 1 [Germany 35], pl. 29 [1709]:2 and 30 [1710]:2). Warsaw 198521 by the Griffin-bird Painter (ABV 72, 22; Paralip. 28, 22). Thera, from Sellada (RA, 1972, p. 75, notes 2 and 3). 11C Painter:AB V 51-61; Paralip. 23-26. HeidelbergPainter: ABV 63-67; Paralip. 26-27. Griffin-bird Painter: ABV 71-75; Paralip. 28-29. 12For late Siana cups influenced by Little Master cups, cf. D. Callipolitis-Feytmans,RA, 1972, pp. 73-82.
64
SHAPE STUDIES
LITTLEMASTERCUPS 1685-1745
Pls. 110-112
The Little Master cup descendsfrom the Siana cup in shape, but it is lighter in make and more elegant in appearancethan its predecessor.13There are two main types of Little Master cup, the lip and the band. Each derives its name from the scheme of decoration,and of the two, the lip-cup is often of higher quality. Very many Little Master cups, especially lip-cups, are signed by potters, some of whom specialize in this shape. Foremost among them are Tleson, who signs as the son of Nearchos, and two contemporaries,Hermogenesand Zenokles.14Among the Little Master cups at the Agora, only 1686 by Tleson bears a signaturethat may be restoredcompletely;two others, 1743 and 1744 (P1. 112), preservepart of the potting verb. LIP-CUPS 1685-1696
PI. 110
The lip-cup has an offset lip, a rather shallow bowl, and a broad, flat foot with a tall stem. The upward swing of the handles often echoes the curve of the bowl resulting in a harmonious relationship of all parts of the cup. The scheme of decorationis a simple one. The inside is glazed, except for the tondo, which may be reservedbut for a centraldot within a circle (e.g. 1685), or, like the Siana cup, it may have figured decorationsurroundedby an ornamental pattern (e.g. 1689: P1. 110). On the outside, the lip is reservedand decoratedwith small figures,often one, seldommore than three.15It is this feature of the decorationthat gives the cup its name. In the handle zone, there is normally an inscription, usually the potter's name, as on 1686, occasionally drinking exhortations or words of praise.16On less careful cups, the inscriptionsmay be imitation (e.g. 1688) or nonsense ones (e.g. 1695: PI. 110), but even these are an integralpart of the decoration.Often there is a palmette at each handle, as on 1685 (PI. 110) and 1686, or this area may be left plain, e.g. 1688. Beazley distinguished four chief types of lip-cup decoration:figured decorationoutside only; figured decoration inside only; figured decorationboth inside and outside; no figured decoration.'7 Among the Agora lip-cups, 1685 has decorationon the outside only, and another, 1686, may have had no figures, only the signature of the potter, Tleson, between the handle palmettes. 1687 (PI. 110) is of particular interest for it comes from a lip-cup decoratedaccordingto the band-cup principle, i.e., with the figures in the handle zone.18The rest of the Agora lip-cups, 1688-1696 (P1. 110), are too fragmentaryfor one to be certain of the schemeof decoration. BAND-CUPS 1697-1742
Pls. 111, 112
The band-cup differs in shape from the lip-cup mainly by having its lip pass gradually into the bowl without the sharp offset of the lip-cup.19Often there is a fillet between the stem of the foot and the bowl. The chief differencebetween these two types of cup lies in the system of decoration.The lip of the band-cup is black both inside and outside, and the tondo is mostly reserved,usually with a circle and a central dot. The figured decorationis restrictedto the narrow reservedband in the 13 For the type, cf. Beazley, JHS 52, 1932, pp. 167-203; F. Villard, REA 48, 1946, pp. 162-169; G. M. A. Richter, CVA, New York2 [USA 11], pp. xvii, 4 and 8; and Beazley, Development,pp. 52-56. More recently, Bothmer,AJA 66, 1962, pp. 255-258; D. Callipolitis-Feytmans, RA, 1972, pp. 73-82; and K. Schauenburg,AA (Jd 89), 1974, pp. 198-219. 14For these and others, cf. Beazley, JHS 52, 1932, pp. 195202; ABV, chap. XII, 159-197 and Paralip. 67-80. 15 For exceptions, cf. Schauenburg, op. cit. (footnote 13 above). Of particularinteresthere is the unattributedlip-cup in Florence, inv. no. 3897, which is decorated according to the overlap principle established for Siana cups (ibid., p. 212,
fig. 21). 16For the full range, cf. ABV, chap. XII, 159-197 and Paralip. 67-80. 17Cf. JHS 52, 1932, p. 168. 18For others, cf. JHS 52, 1932, p. 183; more recently, K. Schauenburg,AA (Jdl 89), 1974, p. 201, note 11. 19F. Villard (REA 48, 1946, pp. 166-167) has suggested that the curve of the lip of the band-cup may be more suitable for the lips of the drinker and that the glaze both inside and outside may have a practical consideration,namely that the glaze is not porous and will not absorbliquid.
CUPS
65
handle zone and is the feature which gives the cup its name. The number of figures may vary greatly, from just a few to very many in a crowded composition.Occasionally,in the handle zone, there are inscriptions,either by themselvesor combinedwith one or two figures, a clear imitationof the lip-cup.20 Below the handle zone, there is usually a reservedband. The general effect of the band-cup is dark, in contrastto the light effect of the lip-cup. As in the case of the lip-cup, Beazley distinguishedfour basic types of band-cup decoration:full decorationon outside;decorationoutside and inside; brief pictures outside; no figured decoration.21Among the Agora band-cups, seven, 1697-1703 (PI. 111), have full decorationon the outside. 1704 (PI. 111), with its decorationboth inside and outside, is especially important for the rare occurrenceof ships round the rim on the inside, as on dinoi and on a few column-kratersand volute-kraters.22Not enough of the decoration on the outside remains to identify the subject,but presumablythe compositionwas a full one. Very likely, the tondo of the cup was also figured, as on the comparableexamples with ships round the rim,23but no part of it has survived. 1705 and 1706 (PI. 111) have inscriptionsin the handle zone, but not enough remains to tell if they were combinedwith figures or appearedalone. That on 1706 may be a nonsense inscription.The rest of the Agora band-cups, 1707-1742 (Pls. 111, 112), are too fragmentaryfor one to be able to identify the scheme of decorationwith certainty. TYPE UNCERTAIN 1743-1745
PI. 112
Each of these fragments preservespart of an inscriptionin the handle zone. Those on 1743 and 1744 (PI. 112) are potting verbs;that on 1745 (PI. 112) may be a nonsense inscription.They probably come from lip-cups, but without part of the lip preserved,it is difficultto be certainof the type, and for this reason we have kept them separate. 1744 may be from a lip-cup decoratedaccordingto the band-cup principle. CASSELCUP 1746
P1. 112
The Cassel cup, which takes its name from one in Kassel without figureddecoration,24retains the band-cup shape but gives up its austere system of decorationin favor of a more ornamentalone, which may owe its inspiration to that of the Siana cup.25On the lip there is usually an upright tongue pattern, and on the bowl, bands of ornament of various kinds.26Occasionally,as on 1746 (P1. 112), there may be figures in the handle zone. At the bottomof the bowl, just abovethe stem of the foot, is a zone of rays. There are not very many Cassel cups, and 1746 is the only black-figured one from the Agora. DROOPCUPS 1747-1752
P1. 112
The Droop cup is named after the scholarwho first examined a series of them within the context of a larger study of Laconian pottery.27Droop recognizedthat these cups were Attic but thought 20JHS 52, 1932, pp. 189 and 191. 52, 1932, pp. 187-191. above, pp. 34-35. 23 Louvre F 145 and Berlin 1800 (see catalogue entry for 1704). 24 Inv. no. A 37 from Samos (J. Boehlau, Aus ionischenund italischen Nekropolen,Leipzig 1898, pl. 10:2). Cf. also, R. Lullies in CVA, Kassel 1 [Germany 35], p. 52 (under T. 487). 25 For the shape, cf. Beazley, JHS 52, 1932, pp. 191-192; F. Villard, REA 48, 1946, p. 169; more recently, W. Hornbostel, Kunst der Antike. Schdtze aus norddeutschem Privatbesitz, Mainz 1977, p. 276, no. 243, with bibliography. 21 JHS 22 Cf.
J. Boardman (ABFV, p. 62) has suggested that the scheme of decoration derives from the Siana cup rather than the Little Masters. One may comparesome of the more lavishly decorated Siana cups, such as the two namepieces:London, B.M. B 380 by the C Painter (ABV 55, 91) and London, B.M. B 379 in his manner (ABV 60, 20; Paralip. 26, 20). 26 Cf. two well-preservedexamples that illustrate the character of the cup: London, B.M. 90.7-31.30 (CVA, London 2 [GB 2], pl. 16 [74]:8) and New York, M.M.A. X.248.16 (CVA, New York 2 [USA 11], pl. 20:33 a-c). Also, the fragmentsfrom Kavala ('ApX'E4, 1938, pp. 147-149). 27J. P. Droop, JHS 30, 1910, pp. 1-34, esp. pp. 21-27. The
66
SHAPE STUDIES
that they might be intentional imitationsof Laconian.The Droop cup resemblesthe Little Master cup in principle but differs from it in a number of details. Its rim is glazed inside and outside, as in the band-cup, but unlike the latter, it is more sharply offset from the bowl, and it has a reserved band on the inside placed well below the rim instead of right at the top as in both types of Little Master cup. The inside of the bowl is either entirelyblackor is decoratedwith a reservedmedallion that often has a centraldot within a single or two concentriccircles.The high stem is reservedat the top and often channeled,and there is a broad black band on the inside, as on 1752 which is signed by Nikosthenes. The lower part of the bowl is occasionallyblack with a reservedband, as on the Little Master cup, but there are exceptions. Normally, there are zones of ornament below the handle zone, either various patternsor patternscombinedwith a frieze of silhouetteanimals drawn upside down, as 1747 and 1748 (PI. 112).28Ure dividedthis class of cups into three groups according to the treatment of the handle zone: I, upright lotus buds; II, lotus-palmettefestoon;III, animals or human figures.29The frieze of inverted animals does not occur on cups that have human figures or animals in the handle zone.30Thus, 1747 and 1748 must belong to either Group I or Group II (without part of the handle zone it is uncertainto which) and 1750 and 1751 (P1. 112) to Group III. TYPE A ANDSUB-A 1753-1779
PI. 113
This sturdy-looking,rather heavy-set cup displaces the Little Master cup and is the type preferredby black-figureartists from about 530 B.C.on.31The cup Type A has a deep bowl without an offset lip, a low flaring foot with a pronouncedconcaveedge, and usually a fillet between the thick stem and the bowl.32The inside is black except for a narrow reservedband below the rim and the tondo, which may be left plain but for a central dot within a circle or decoratedwith figures, most often a gorgoneion.On the outside, the figures occupy the entire height of the bowl except for the underside, which frequently has ornamentaldecoration.There are often rays above the foot, and between them and the figureddecorationthere may be lines, bandsof glaze, or simple patterns.The favorite decorationon the main portion of the bowl is a pair of large apotropaiceyes,33sometimes with a nose between, or else figures. Occasionally,there is additional figure work at the handles. The eyes may be drawn in outline and reservedexcept for the iris and pupil, as 1753 (PI. 113), or they may be painted white or black, as 1754 (P1. 113) and 1755, so that they contrastwith the clay ground. The pupil is black;red, white, and black compass-drawnrings comprisethe iris. The earliest preservedAttic black-figuredeye-cup of Type A is the famousone in Munich signed by Exekias as potter.34Exekias did not invent the shape, for there exist precursorscalled Proto-A cups that have very deep, almost hemisphericalbowls, stems that vary in height, and feet with a concaveedge as Type A,35and these providethe backgroundfor the cup by Exekias. But Exekias' cup is the earliest example of the conventionof painting a pair of large apotropaiceyes in the handle zone on each side. The eye-cup becomesvery popular in Attic black figure duringthe last quarterof basic study of Droop cups: P. N. Ure, JHS 52, 1932, pp. 55-71. Cf. also G. M. A. Richter in CVA, New York 2 [USA 11], p. 12; F. Villard, REA 48, 1946, pp. 171-172; AgoraXII, p. 91. 28 Silhouette animals drawn upside down are not restricted to Droop cups but also occur on two Proto-A eye-cups, Louvre F 131 bis (at each handle, a maenad; beneath each handle, a kneeling satyr) and Boston, M.F.A. 03.784 (CVA, Boston 2 [USA 19], pl. 100 [934]:1-4). 29JHS 52, 1932, pp. 56-68. 30Ibid., p. 64. 31For the shape, cf., particularly, H. Bloesch, Formen attischer Schalen von Exekias bis zum Ende des strengen Stils,
Bern 1940, pp. 1-39; F. Villard, REA 48, 1946, pp. 173-180; Beazley, Development, p. 67; G. M. A. Richter in CVA, New York 2 [USA 11], p. 14. 32 Sometimesthe fillet is omitted. For an early example, cf. New York, M.M.A. 25.78.6 (ABV 116). 3 D. A. Jackson (East Greek Influences on Attic Vases, London 1976, pp. 60-68) has shown that the practiceof painting large eyes on cups may have an Ionian origin. 34 Munich 2044 (ABV 146, 21; Paralip. 60, 21). 35 A large number of these are to be found in ABV, chap. XIII. For a discussion of the precursors,cf. Bloesch, op. cit. (footnote31 above), pp. 2-4.
CUPS
67
the 6th century B.C.,but there are very few examples from the Agora, and they are so fragmentary that they do not illustrate the type very well (1753-1756). A number of well-preserved cups, classifiedby Beazley as sub-A, have been found in the Agora, e.g. 1761-1764 and 1769 (P. 113). This type retainsthe generallysquat, heavy-setappearanceand the foot with concave edge of the canonical Type A, but its bowl is somewhat shallower, and the fillet between bowl and stem is given up in favor of a continuous curve between the wo parts. In this respect, the sub-A cup resemblesthe Type B cup, but it lacks the characteristicchamferon the top surfaceof the foot near the edge. The scheme of decorationis more restrainedthan that of Type A, for there are no rays or ornamental patterns on the undersideof the bowl but merely a narrow reservedband. The figures on the outside may appear between eyes, althoughthis is not standardas it is for Type A, and none of the Agora sub-A's has eyes. The tondo usually has a single figure, not the gorgoneion of Type A. The Agora sub-A cups are late products, belonging to the 5th century B.C., and most of them are decoratedby painters of the Leafless Group. The fragmentsin this section, 1765-1767 and 1770-1778 (PI. 113), may also be sub-A cups, but without the foot and the stem it is difficultto be certain. TYPEB
1780
Pl. 113
The bowl of the cup Type B passes directlyinto the stem without an interruption;the shape of the foot is a torus, and there is usually a small chamferon its top surfacenear the edge.36The schemeof decoration on the black-figured examples follows that for the sub-A. The Type B cup comes in shortly after the invention of the red-figuretechnique and is mainly a red-figureshape. It is never popular in Attic black figure, and most of the known examples are late ones, a good numberof them attributedto the manner of the Haimon Painter.371780 is the only black-figuredexample from the Agora. It is a rather heavy piece, and its deep bowl resembles that of the Type A, but it is distinguishedeven from the sub-A by its torus foot which, however,lacks the characteristicchamfer. STEMLESS CUPS 1781-1800
Pls. 114, 115
In black figure these are small cups of Type C that belong to the group designatedby Bloesch as conservativein character.38The bowl of the Type C cup is rather shallow and has a plain or an offset lip. In plain black, the type with the offset lip is the commonestof the stemmedcups, but in black figure, including the examples from the Agora that preserve all or part of the lip, the lip passes into the bowl without interruption.The stem itself is very short with a fillet at its base, and the foot is a thick torus.39In the stemlessvariety, as the name implies, the stem is omitted,and there is simply a fillet between bowl and foot. 1781-1785 (P1. 114) are Top-band Stemlesses.40These have black rims and a reservedband in the handle zone that may be plain, as 1785, but normally contains figures often set between eyes, as 1781-1784 (PI. 114). Below the figure zone, there is a narrow reservedband. The inside is black except for the tondo,which may be reserved,as 1783 and 1784, or decoratedwith a gorgoneiondrawn in outline, as 1785. 1786-1793 (Pls. 114,115), which preserve parts of tondi with gorgoneia, may be Top-band Stemlesses, but without the rim it is difficultto be certain. 1794 (PI. 114) is unusual for having a figure in the tondo. 36 For the type, cf. Bloesch, op. cit. (footnote 31 above, 66), p. pp. 41-109, esp. pp. 42-44 for the transitionalearly examples; also Beazley, Development, pp. 61-62 for cups by the Amasis Painter, including one signed by Amasis himself, that approximate Type B; Bothmer, Amasis Painter, pp. 223-228, cat. nos. 62, 63. 37ABV 561-562, 531-557; Paralip. 271, 515, and 284. 38 Bloesch, op. cit. (footnote 31 above, p. 66), pp. 113-118.
39The shape as a whole is best discussedby Bloesch (op. cit., pp. 111-136). Cf. also Agora XII, pp. 91-92, with bibliography. In ARV2, p. li, Beazley limits the term "Type C" to those cups with "an offset lip as well as the characteristicstem and foot,"but classifiesas Type C both 1784 (Paralip. 101, 13) and another in the Basel Market (Paralip. 101, 16), which have plain rims. 40 Paralip. 100-102, 1-45.
68
SHAPE STUDIES
An interesting group of stemless cups are those of the Segment Class41(1795-1800: PI. 115), which have the same shape as the Top-band Stemlesses.They take their name from the scheme of decorationon the inside where the figures cover the entire surface, which is often divided into a main zone and a small exergue near the bottom, similar to the tondi on the insides of many other types of cups and on plates.42The exergue may be plain,43or figured, as 1798-1800 (PI. 115) which have dolphins, or it may simply contain a few dots.44Occasionally,the exergue is omitted,as 1797 (PI. 115) and perhaps 1796 (P. 115), and the compositionadapted to the full circle.45The exterior is normally undecorated.46 CUPS, TYPE UNCERTAIN
1801-1846
Pls. 116-118
This section contains fragmentsthat may not be assigned with certaintyto a specifictype of cup, and among them are to be found some pieces of particular interest. 1802 (P1. 116), perhaps the earliest, recalls the C Painter. It preservespart of the potter'sname and the first two letters of the verb. 1811 (PI. 116), which is either a band-cup or a Gordion cup, gives the potting verb, but nothing of the maker'sname remains. 1830-1846 (Pls. 117, 118), the late pieces, are probablycups of Type A and sub-A, but one may not rule out Type B, especially among those by painters of the Leafless Group. BOWL 1847 P1.118 Bowls are well known in plain black from the late 5th century on, and their range in size is considerable.1Figured bowls are particularly rare, and the three attributed black-figuredbowls or "bowl-likevessels",to use Beazley's phrase, are so fragmentarythat they do not illustratethe shape very well.2 In the Agora, one fragmentaryblack-figuredbowl has been found, 1847 (PI. 118). It has a thickened,roundedrim, but since much of the interioris lost, the rest of its appearancemay not be determined.The figured decoration,drawn in silhouette, coversthe entire interior;the exterior is black except for a reservedband below the rim.
41Eleven members of the class were first put together by Bloesch who named them Segment Cups (op. cit. [footnote31 above, p. 66], pp. 118-119). Since then, their number has grown to more than 70. Cf. also ABV 212-215, 1-60; 690, 21 bis, 21 ter, and 46 bis;Paralip. 102-103; and V. Poulsen, "Eine attische Augenschale," Opus nobile. Festschrift zum 60. Geburtstagvon UlfJantzen, Wiesbaden 1969, pp. 125-128; K. Schauenburg, "Zu einer Segmentschale in der Kieler Antikensammlung,"Rivista di Archeologia1, 1977, pp. 16-18. 42 The scheme of decoration also recalls that of many Laconian cups, which, although earlier than all the Segment Cups, very often have similar inside decoration. Cf. C. M. Stibbe, Lakonische Vasenmalerdes sechsten Jahrhunderts v. Chr., Amsterdam1972. 43Two examples: Hamburg 1962.171 (Paralip. 103, 22 bis; CVA, Hamburg 1 [Germany 41], pl. 44 [2010]); Heidelberg 285 (ABV 213, 31).
44E.g. Turin 4112, new number 5776 (ABV 214, 50; CVA, Turin 2 [Italy 40], pl. 2 [1786]). 45 An unusual scheme is to show the two figures standing "north-south",so that no matter how the picture is viewed, one of them always appears to be upside down. Cf., e.g., London, B.M. B 458 (ABV 213, 28); two in the Argos Museum (ABV 213, 29, and 214, 48). 46 It may sometimes have a plain band in the handle zone, e.g. Vatican 244 (ABV 213, 30). One is decoratedon the outside as a Top-band Stemless: Milan, Bernareggi (Paralip. 103, 38 ter). 1 For bowls, including saltcellars, cf. Agora XII, pp. 128138. 2 Two by the Amasis Painter: Palermo (ABV 156, 78) and Akropolis 1241 (ABV 156, 79); one by Elbows Out: Villa Giulia (ABV 250, 19).
THYMIATERIA
69
EPINETRA 1848-1850
P1. 118
The epinetron is used for the preparationof wool for weaving.1It is shaped to fit over the thigh of the worker, for it is wider at the open end where the thigh is thickerand closedat the narrow end to fit over the knee cap. Usually, at the closed end, there is a molded female head. The open end terminates in a torus molding;the side edges are straightand flat. The general appearanceis similar to that of a very elaborate Corinthian cover tile.2 The top of the epinetron is coveredwith an incised scale pattern, which producedthe necessary roughness when the wool was rubbed against it. Directly above the torus molding, there is an ornamentalpattern, such as rays or lotus buds, and often there is a narrowerone at the opposite endjust beforethe start of the curveof the knee. The figured decorationappears in a frieze on each side, and between it and the scale pattern there is usually a narrow band of ornament.3 There are not very many Attic black-figuredepinetra. Nearly all of them were found in Greece, and they come from workshops active around 500 B.C.which specialize in decoratingsmall vessels. Particularly important are the three by the Sappho Painter and the two by his companion, the Diosphos Painter,4as well as the contemporaryones of the Golonos Group, which takes its name from the epinetrononce in Goluchow5and seems to have specializedin the shape. Only three small fragmentaryblack-figuredepinetra have been found in the Agora. 1849 (PI. 118) preservespart of the scale pattern, the wreathed head of a male to right, and some of the key pattern (white on black glaze) separating the two zones. 1848 and 1850 (PI. 118) give only part of the figured area. 1848 (PI. 118) with women working wool is no doubt a referenceto the use of this shape.6
THYMIATERIA 1851-1853
P1. 119
The thymiaterionis an incense burner.1The appearanceis so metallic-lookingthat presumablythe clay examples depend upon metal prototypes.The thymiaterionhas a rather deep bowl fitted with a conical lid pierced to allow the fragranceof the incense to escape. The bowl joins a tall slender stem that flares toward a central molding useful for holding the vessel. The stem is thicker below the molding than above it, and it flares toward the spreadingfoot that has two or three degrees.The 1For the shape, cf. Agora XII, p. 230. Of the references cited, most importantfor Attic black figure is D. M. Robinson, AJA 49,1945, pp. 480-490. An unpublisheddissertationon the subjecthas been completedby Pamela Benbow, Epinetra (diss. Harvard, 1975). 2 Epinetra have been interpreted as elaborate roof tiles or tiles for tombs, as well as for other purposes. Cf. D. M. Robinson, AJA 49, 1945, p. 482, note 10. 3 For two well-preserved epinetra, cf. Athens, N.M. 2184 the by Sappho Painter (ABL, p. 228, no. 53) or Leyden I 1955/1, 2 unattributed(CVA, Leiden 2 [Netherlands4], pl. 68 [162]). Usually the area around the molded head is black, but on Athens, N.M. 2185 (ABV 481, -, y), a fragment, it is coveredwith a pattern of encircled palmettes with black birds in the interstices. This may have been purely a patterned
epinetron,not a black-figuredone. 4 Sappho Painter: ABL, p. 228, nos. 53-54 bis; Diosphos Painter:ABL, p. 237, no. 118, Paralip. 250, and probably1850. 5 Warsaw 142454, ex Goluchow 225 (ABV 480,4; Paralip. 220, 4). For the group, cf. ABV 480-481 and Paralip. 220. 6 For other representationson epinetra, cf. catalogue entry for 1848. Cf. Agora XII, pp. 182-183, with bibliography, esp. K. Wigand, "Thymiateria,"BJb 122, 1912, pp. 1-97; C. Roebuck, Hesperia 9, 1940, pp. 181-182, nos. 74 and 75, and p. 180, fig. 21; KerameikosVI, ii, p. 165 for a 7th-centuryexample; for a small plate from the Shrine of Nymphe that is decorated with a thymiaterion, cf. Callipolitis-Feytmans, Les plats attiques, p. 403, no. 4 and fig. 74.
SHAPE STUDIES
70
molding may be a concaveband, e.g. 1851 (PI. 119), or it may flare outward terminatingin a crisp edge, e.g., 1852 (PI. 119) or two well-preservedexamples from Eleusis.2 The scheme of decorationhas figures on the stem above and below the molding and occasionally on the top surface of the foot as well.3 Above the figures, there may be an ornamentalpattern or simply a band of glaze, e.g. 1851. On the central molding, there is an ornament,such as ivy (e.g. 1851) or tongues (e.g. 1852). There are very few Attic black-figuredthymiateria, and the few examples from the Agora are parts of stems. Taken together,they illustrate the general appearance and system of decoration. 1851 shows some of the stem above and below the molding, 1852 gives part of the stem directlyabove the flaring molding, and 1853 comes fromjust abovethe foot. CLOSED VASES, SHAPE UNCERTAIN 1854-1908
Pls. 119-121
None of these fragments preserves a feature that will identify the shape with certainty. In some cases, the date of the fragment is helpful, for it preventsthe piece from being identifiedas a shape not yet in the Attic repertoryor as one that has gone out of use. For all the fragmentsin this section, the choice of shape lies between at least two possibilities. 1858 (PI. 119) could be a small one-piece amphoraor an olpe; 1880 (P1. 120) might be an oinochoeor an amphora;1882 (PI. 120) is probably an amphora or a hydria. 1859 (PI. 119), attributedto the Group of the Dresden Lekanis, is probably a neck-amphorarather than a hydria or an oinochoe,for thus far neither of the last two shapes is known in this group. The large number of fragmentsby the Polos Painter, 1862-1868 (P1. 119), are probablyeither hydriai or neck-amphorae.1874 (Pl. 120) comes from a large vessel, and what remainsof the curve does not seem strongenough for either a neck-amphoraor a hydria. The shape may be a one-piece amphorawith the figuresset in friezes, and if so, it will add a new shape to those known to be decoratedby Kleitias, but it is hard to be sure. 1883 (P1. 120) by the Swing Painter is very puzzling. It has a strong horizontalcurve, and at the very top, the surfaceis rough as if it fitted into somethingor was coveredby the downturnedrim of a lid. The verticalcurve indicatesthat the vase widened toward the top. The curveof 1890 (PI. 121) suggestsan olpe, but the wall is too thick. An odd feature is the horsemen drawn to different scales within the same scene. 1906 (P1. 121) comes from some kind of small vessel with a little round hole in the top. OPEN VASES, SHAPE UNCERTAIN 1909-1932
Fig. 22
Pls. 121-123
Like the fragmentsof closed vases in the precedingsection, none of these fragmentsof open vases preservesany sure means of identifying the shape. The early fragmentsof larger vases, e.g. 1909, 1912, or 1915 (Pls. 121, 122), are very likely kraters or dinoi, although 1920 (PI. 122) may be a lebes gamikos. 1913 is a rim fragmentwith figureddecorationon both the inside and the outside, a system of decorationthat recalls later cups with a figuredfrieze running roundthe tondo,as well as exterior decoration.11916 (P1. 122) is a very deep cup or bowl, rather small in diametercompared 2
K. Kourouniotis, Classical Studies presented to Edward Capps on his SeventiethBirthday, Princeton 1936, opp. p. 204, figs. 1 and 3. The edge of 1852 is very broken, but enough remains to indicate its original appearance.
3 Ibid., opp. p. 204,
fig. 1.
For these, cf. K. Schauenburgin Studienzurgriechischen Vasenmalerei[AK, Beiheft 7, 19701,pp. 33-46.
PLAQUES
71
with its estimated depth. 1923 (PI. 122) preserves some of the tondo of a low bowl with a broad flaring foot. The tondo is divided into two zones of almost equal size, and what remains of the exterior is undecorated. 1924 (PI. 122) is the rim of a Gordion cup or a Hermogenian skyphos. 1928 (PI. 122) preservespart of the rim and flaring wall of a drinkingvessel, perhaps a kantharos, although a black band above and below the figures is unusual and the size seems too small. 1929 (PI. 123) has been recut for use as a stopperor a disk. 1931 (PI. 123) is the most perplexing of all in this section. These fragments come from a vessel with a deeply curved wall, possibly similar in shape to a chalice, and part of its figured decorationmay have been overlappedby the handles. MISCELLANEOUS 1933-1935
PI. 123
The three entries in this small category do not fit into any of the sections above. 1933 (PI. 123) depicts part of a frieze of figures, probably horsemen, and may be a fragment of the mouth of an amphora,1although it seems a bit thin and flares slightly. 1934 (PI. 123) is the only certainexample of an amphoraType A from the Agora, but it is unclear if the figureddecorationwas in black figure or in red figure, for nothing remains of the figures or of the sides of the panels which are plain in black figure and have ornamentalframes in red figure. 1935 (PI. 123), a fragmentof a loutrophoros handle, finds good parallels in both black figure and red figure.
PLAQUES 1936-1946
Pls. 123 and 124
Plaques are slabs of clay used for funerary or votive purposes.1They may be rectangularor have roundedtops. Their clay may be very fine like that used for the best of vases, or it may be coarseand gritty like that used for roof tiles and pithoi. If the latter, the surface of the plaque is coatedwith a thin layer of fine clay before it is painted. 1938 is a good example. Funerary plaques are decorated on one side only, for they were attachedto the exterior of the tomb;2votive plaques may be figured on one or both sides, dependingupon whether they were attachedto a solid surfaceor suspendedin mid-air to hang freely.3 There are two basic types of funerary plaques: single plaques and those that form a series. The plaque series is the earlier and the more elaborateof the two, beginningin black figure,ca. 600 B.C., and lasting to about 530 B.C.,4 those by Exekias being among the latest.5When the manufactureof
1For figureson the mouth of an amphora,cf., e.g., the large amphora in a Swiss private collection attributedto the Painter of Vatican 342 (Paralip. 187, 3) or the unattributedamphora Type A in Bologna (no inv. no.): figures on Side A of mouth only (CVA, Bologna 2 [Italy 7], pl. 6 [305]:1). For funerary plaques, cf. J. Boardman, BSA 50, 1955, pp. 51-66; for votive plaques, J. Boardman, BSA 49, 1954, pp. 183-201. 2 The means of attachmentis not known for certain, for no tomb has been found with a plaque in situ or with a wall that
bears marks of an attachmentfor a plaque. For a discussionof the possibilities, cf. J. Boardman, BSA 50, 1955, pp. 52-53; more briefly, D. Kurtz and J. Boardman, Greek Burial Customs, London 1971, p. 83. 3 Cf. J. Boardman,BSA 49, 1954, pp. 192-193. 4 The earliest example of a plaque series seems to be the two relief plaques in New York, M.M.A. 14.146.3 a and b (J. Boardman, BSA 50, 1955, p. 58, no. 1; E. Vermeule, Aspectsof Death in Early GreekArt and Poetry,Berkeley 1979, p. 11, fig. 6). 5 Berlin 1811-1826 (ABV 146, 22; Paralip. 60, 22) and Athens, N.M. 2414-2417 (ABV 146, 23).
72
SHAPE STUDIES
the plaque series comes to an end, the makingof single plaques begins. The reasonfor this changeis not known but may perhaps reflect restrictionsagainst elaborateand costly grave decoration.6Funerary plaques that form part of a series are rather uniformin size and thickness,in contrastto the single plaques which vary greatly in their dimensions.7Although the subjectpainted on both the plaque series and the single plaques is the same, the system of decorationdiffers. In the plaque series, the narrative consists of several scenes having to do with the prothesis and the preparation for the ekphora. Ornamentalpatternsare omittedentirely or limited to a simple frieze near the top or at the bottom of the plaque.8The sides are plain. On single plaques, the prothesis scene is confined to essential elements the bier and some of the mourners.And usually a double or single line, or an ornamental pattern, frames the scene.9 1942 (P1. 124), which shows mourners, is the only sure example of a funeraryplaque from the Agora, and it very likely formedpart of a series. It is on the same scale as the plaques by Exekias. Votive plaques offer a wide range of subjects,they vary more in sie than funeraryplaques, and they last much longer, well into the 4th centuryB.C.10Often there are holes for suspensionor for the attachmentto a wall.11 1943 (PI. 124) has such a hole. It is not always possible to identify votive plaques, particularly when only fragments have survived, an observationrightly emphasized by Boardman.12Among the Agora fragments,only 1943, with its hole for suspensionand its representation of Hermes, is certainto be a votive plaque. The othersmay be, but without more to go on it is difficultto be certain. DISKS 1947-1949
PI. 124
Disks are flat, circularobjectsthat usually have a slightly thickenededge. They resemblethe floors of plates and may sometimeseven be mistakenfor plates if the smoothedge is not preserved,for the undersideis finished and often decoratedwith concentriccircles. 1948 (PI. 124) is a good example, but since a small portion of the edge remains, it cannotbe a plate. Fragmentarydisks may also even be mistaken for fragmentsof Sosian stands. 1949 (P1. 124) is a disk, for although it has a torus rim, its undersideis smooth and it lacks a stemmedfoot, and so it cannotbe a stand. Disks are decorated accordingto the principle establishedfor plates.2The figuresmay be drawn rounda centralmedallion, 1947 (PI. 124) being a good example from the Agora, or large figures may fill the entire format, as 1948. There are not very many disks, and their purpose is unknown. They may have been small votive objects,or they may have servedas lids. 6J. Boardman,BSA 50, 1955, p. 53. 7 For a discussionof dimensions,cf. J. Boardman,BSA 50, 1955, pp. 52-53. 8 For a simple key pattern at the top, cf. those in Berlin by Exekias (ABV 146, 22; Paralip. 60, 22). For a key pattern at the bottom, cf. Athens, N.M. 2412 and 2413 (ABV 687, top; J. Boardman, BSA 50, 1955, p. 60, no. 11 and pl. 2:c, d). Athens, N.M. 2410 has an inscription at the top, and presumablyAthens, N.M. 2412 and 2413 did also, for they are part of the same series (Boardman,op. cit., p. 60, no. 11). The lotus-palmette festoon at the top and the tongue pattern at the bottom of the plaques by Sophilos seem to be unparalleled
(ABV42, 38-40; Boardman,op. cit., p. 59, no. 6; Bakir, Sophilos, pis. 37, 38). 9J. Boardman,BSA 50, 1955, pp. 53-54. 10 J. Boardman,BSA 49, 1954, p. 193. I' Ibid., p. 192. 12 Ibid., pp. 194-195. 'Cf. D. Callipolitis-Feytmans, BCH 79, 1955, pp. 467477 and Les plats attiques, pp. 36, 124, 187, and 241; Agora xiI, p. 178. 2 D. Callipolitis-Feytmans,BCH 79, 1955, pp. 473-474.
POTTERS AND PAINTERS The distinction between Protoattic and Attic black figure is not so obvious as the one between black figure and red figure, which is mainly a question of two techniques. The differencebetween Protoatticand Attic black figure rests primarilyon the differencebetween a style of painting on the one hand and a technique on the other. A small numberof vases from the Agora may be datedin the third quarter of the 7th century or in the early part of the last quarter, and they illustrate well the problem of whether to call a piece Protoatticor Attic black figure, for as Brann remarked,"which term one prefers depends on what one is looking for."1Brann includes all these vases in her studies of the Protoatticpottery from the Agora, and in her Agora volume she extendsthe term Late Protoattic to cover the earliest black figure, datable between the Kynosargesamphora and the Nettos Painter.2All these vases, however, were classed as black figure by Beazley during a visit to Athens in the spring of 1958.3 Since they exhibit both Protoatticand Attic black-figurecharacteristics,we have repeated tthem here in the back-figure volume and discuss them in this short section of the chapter on attributedAttic black-figuredvases from the Agora. In addition, we have included 128 (P1. 16), a fragment of a neck-amphoracalled transitional-to-blackfigure by Beazley, and 129, a fragment of another called black figure or transitional-to-blackfigure by him during the same visit in 1958. 128 combines bold Protoatticornamentwith silhouette figures enlivened by incision.4The same can be said for 1936 (Pl. 123), a disk cut from a plaque, which preservespart of a chariot horse to right, or 587 (PI. 55), two fragmentsof a fenestratedstand that was probablyconical in shape. 519 and 1854 have ornamentdrawn partly in outline and partly in silhouettewith incision. 132 (PI. 16) is decorated with two confronted horse protomes, a composition that is likely to be of Cycladic origin,5but in Attic black figure becomesthe single protomeknown from many one-pieceamphorae (e.g. below, Catalogue, 13-23). 133 (PI. 16) is decoratedin the full black-figuretechnique, but the shape of the mouth of this neck-amphoraand the style of the figures are Protoattic.1361 (PI. 94), from what is preserved, seems to be in black figure, but the style of the horse is Protoattic.This discussion of the earliest black figure from the Agora concludeswith three fragmentsthat preserve parts of human heads, which have the faces drawn in outline and the hair either solid or incised. 129 may be a male siren6 and, if so, is an early example, slightly earlier perhaps than 133. 1855 (PI. 119) preservesjust the upper part of the face of a woman whose closest kin seems to be the Athena painted on Berlin 1682 by the Nettos Painter.77 (PI. 2) is of special importancefor it is the 1Agora VIII, p. 25; cf. also, the remarks by Beazley, Development, p. 12 and Kubler, KerameikosVI, ii, pp. 311-327. 2 Agora VIII, p. 25. 3 In addition to the early vases mentioned below, the following were also called black figure by Beazley: 130, 131, and 695. 4 One may also cite here P 13279 by the KynosargesPainter (Agora VIII, p. 95, no. 565, pl. 35) and P 22299 by the Pair
Painter (AgoraVIII, p. 96, no. 572, pls. 2, 36, 42), which also combine these features, and on P 22299 accessoryred appears as well. 5Agora VIII, p. 97, under no. 573. 6 Agora VIII, p. 97, no. 577, pls. 37, 44. 7 Agora VIII, p. 98, no. 580, pl. 37. For Berlin 1682, cf. ABV 5, 4; Paralip. 2, 8 (d).
74
POTTERS AND PAINTERS
earliest example of a human protome in the panel of a one-piece amphora, a decorativeidea that, like the horse protome,may have a Cycladicorigin.8 Painter of Berlin A 34 The earliest attributedAttic black-figuredvase from the Agora is 340 (Pl. 34), a fragmentof an amphoraof uncertaintype by the Painter of Berlin A 34, formerlycalled the Woman Painter after the subjecton his namepiece.He is the first artist to appear in the pages of ABV and Paralipomena, and 340 adds a new shape to the few vases known by him, which until now were all kraters.134 is thought by Brann to come from the workshop of the painter, but without figured decorationit is difficult to be certain. An argument in favor of her attribution is the presence of two shades of accessoryred, a bright hue and a duller one, in addition to white, which gives a rich polychrome effect seen also on 340. The profile of the woman on 588 is close to the Painter of Berlin A 34, and its subject,a woman holding a poppy or a pomegranate,is a forerunnerof the women holding palmettes on the stand of Athens, N.M. 16384 by the Nettos Painter.9Contemporarywith or slightly later than 340 is 341 (P1.34), also from an amphoraof uncertaintype, which may be by the Piraeus Painter. The incision does not seem quite so fine or the drawing so firm as on his namepiece,10but it is surely close to him. Nettos Painter In the late 7th centuryB.C., Attic black figure is best illustratedby the work of the Nettos Painter, the earliest Attic black-figurepainter whose personality is distinct and who has left us vases sufficiently large in number to make it possible to chart his development.'1The five vases by the Chimaera Painter, who is named after the large grave amphora found on Aigina near the modern town,'2 are now consideredto be the early work of the Nettos Painter.13No vase fromthe Agora has been attributedto this early phase, but 406 (P1.40), a fragmentof a lid from a skyphos-kraterthat shows a massive, powerful boar striding to left, recalls the Chimaera Painter. Only one vase from the Agora has been attributedwith certaintyto the Nettos Painter, 117 (P1. 13), the famous sphinx amphora,which belongsto the maturework of the painterand ought to date about 610 B.C. On each side is a large seated sphinx which spreads out over the whole surface of the vase, the obverse separated from the reverse only by ornamental configurationsat the handles. Here, the arrangement of the figures relates betterto the shape of the vase than it does on Eleusis Z 21, Aigina 565, or London, B.M. 1874.4-10.1,14 which are earlier one-piece amphoraeby the painter, decoratedaccording to the principle established for neck-amphorae,'5 and the profile of the sphinx on 117 is more developedand betterproportionedthan it is on either Eleusis Z 21 or Aigina 565. 137 (P1. 16) p. 99 under no. 589. Human protomesmay be seen occasionallyin early black figure, the best known examples being 7 (PI. 2) and the one on Munich 1360, which has a horseheadon the reverse (ABV 16, 2; Paralip. 9, 2; M. G. Picozzi, Studi Misc. 18, 1971, no. 1, pl. 1). Cf. also the confronted male protomeson Copenhagen 13796 (ABV 714, 9 bis;Paralip. 7, 9 bis) and the male protome on the obverse of a horsehead neck-amphorain the Louvre (E 822: ABV 17; Picozzi, op. cit., no. 44 and pl. 37). For a human protome on a lid, cf. 1372 (PI. 94). For a subhuman protome on an oinochoe, cf. 723 (PI. 69). For the subject, cf. 0. von Vacano, Zur Entstehung und Deutung gemalter seitenansichtiger Kopfbilder auf schwarzfigurigen Vasen des griechischen Festlandes, Bonn 1973. 9 ABV 6; Paralip. 3, 13. '0 Athens, N.M. 353 (ABV 2; Paralip. 1). 8 Agora VIII,
1 ABV 4-6; Paralip. 1-5; also Karouzou, 'Avayvpoivros, pp. 123-136. For some of the vases by the Nettos Painter and others contemporarywith them, cf. the remarks by Kiibler in his discussionof the early Attic black figure from the Kerameikos (KerameikosVI, ii, pp. 316-323). It is difficultto perceive why KiiblerrejectsKarouzou'sattributionto the Nettos Painter of Kerameikos,inv. no. 658, and even more, of the three skyphos-kraters from Vari, Athens, N.M. 16382, 16383, and 16384. 12 Aigina 565 (ABV 3, 1; Paralip. 1, 1). 13
Paralip. 1. 14Eleusis Z 21 (ABV 679, 2 bis; Paralip. 2, 3); Aigina 565
(ABV3, 1; Paralip. 1, 1); London,B.M. 1874.4-10.1, formerly A 1531 (ABV 3, 2; Paralip. 2, 2). 15Above, p. 5.
POTTERSAND PAINTERS
75
was originally attributedto the Nettos Painter by Beazley in AB V but judged to be only near him in Paralipomena. Three other pieces, an amphora, a louterion, and a lid, 120 (P1. 15), 603 (P1. 56), and 1362 (PI. 94), were also attributedby Beazley to near the painter, and others,401 (PI. 39), 407 (PI. 40), 527 (P1. 51), and 697 may be added.527, a stand fragment,preservesthe head of a woman to right who is comparableto those on the stand of Athens, N.M. 16384 and may even be by the Nettos Painter himself. 697, two fragmentsof an olpe that show part of a rider and his mount, is also close to the Nettos Painter and belongs with the cavalcadeon Athens, N.M. 16383 and the two horsemenon Kerameikos,inv. no. 658.161 (P1. 1), 121 (PI. 15), 409 (P1.40), and 1363 (P1.94) are perhaps also near the Nettos Painter. The heads of the swans on 1363 are weaker versions of the ones on Athens, N.M. 16382,17the earliest of the three well-preservedskyphos-kratersfrom Vari. The face of the siren on 121 is close to that of the sphinx on 117 (PI. 13), and the wheel rosettes recall those on Athens, N.M. 16383 and Kerameikos,inv. no. 658. 399 (PI. 39), also close to the Nettos Painter, belongs with these. 343 (P1. 35) is by or near the painter. GorgonPainter In the early 6th century B.C., the most prolific Attic vase painter is the Gorgon Painter who takes his name from the dinos in the Louvrethat depicts Perseus fleeing fromthe Gorgons.18A numberof vases by the Gorgon Painter himself and several in his manner have been found in the Agora. The Gorgon Painter continues the tradition establishedby the Nettos Painter, which is best illustrated perhaps in his early work where the figures may be rather ample and cover large areas of the vase. 671 (Pl. 64) belongs to this early period, thee e only Agora example that does. The somewhat heavy proportionsmark 671 as an early trefoil olpe, and the two large sirens filling the entire surface of the body as well as the use of the dot-wheel rosettefor filling ornament meanalso argue for early date, a conclusion reached by Scheibler.19The frieze of geese above the sirens on 671 is similar to that near the top of the large lid from the North Slope, also an early work.20Five other fragmentsfrom the Agora are somewhat later: 1297 (PI. 91) is a lekanis; 412 (P1.41) and 1367-1369 (P1. 94) are lids, the last of which is attributedhere. hese lids have their decorationset in friezes, unlike those by the Nettos Painter, which havejust a few large figures occupyingmost of the surface.21In Attic black figure, animal friezes first appear in the work of the Gorgon Painter and his contemporaries; the idea very likely derivesfrom Corinthianvase painting where it had long been used, particularly the arrangementof the animals in groups,22not just in confrontedpairs, which may be seen, for example, on the Gorgon Painter's namepiece. The faces of the sirens or sphinxes on 1369 (P1. 94) seem to belong stylistically between the sirens on 671 (PI. 64) and the sphinxes and sirens on the 367 (P1.94) are also close 297 (PP.41), 1and Gorgon Painter's plate in Baltimore.23412 (P. 91), 16 Athens 16383 (ABV 7, y; Paralip. 3, 12); Kerameikos, inv. no. 658 (ABV 3; Paralip. 1; KerameikosVI, ii, no. 116, pis. 89-91). For the attributionof the Kerameikosamphora,cf. footnote 11 above, p. 74. 7 ABV 3, 4; 4; Paralip. 3, 10. 18 Louvre E 874 (AB , 1; Parali. 6, 1). For the rest of his vases, as well as those in his manner, cf. ABV 8-13; Paralip. 6-9. G. Bakir (AA [JdI 93], 1978, pp. 26-43) has separatedfive of the vases attributedby Beazley to the manner of the Gorgon Painter and added three others to form a new painter, named after the lekythosin Istanbul, inv. no. 7314 (ABV 11, 18). Bakir attributes these eight vases to the same hand as the Bonn amphoriskos by a Boeotian imitator of the Gorgon Painter (ABV 14, 2) and suggests (p. 41) that the painter is an Attic one who may have emigrated to Boiotia. K. Kalinsky, II (AK 21, 1978, pp. 12-16) has argued more cautiously that the Bonn
amphoriskostakes with it only two in Bakir'slist, Istanbul7314 (ABV 11, 18) and LouvreCA 823 (ABV 12, 23), and postulates an Attic artist, the Istanbul Painter, who worked for a time in the circle of the Gorgon Painter, then movedto Boiotia. ' . Scheibler,JdI 76, 1961, pp. 15-16, 18. 20 A-P 1734 (ABV8, 6; Paralip. 6, 6). For the early date, cf. Scheibler,op. cit., pp. 14 and 18. 21 The best examples are those on the well-preserved skyphos-kratersin Athens: N.M. 16382 (ABV 4; Paralip. 3, 10), N.M. 16383 (ABV7, y; Paralip. 3, 12), and N.M. 16384 (ABV 6; Paralip. 3, 13); also 405 (PI. 40) and 407 (PI. 40). 22 Beazley, Development,p. 17. 23Baltimore48.215 (ABV 9, 18; Paralip. 7, 18). For plates from the Gorgon Painter'sworkshop,cf. Callipolitis-Feytmans, Les plats attiques,pp. 63-67.
76
POTTERS AND PAINTERS
to this plate. The lions on 412 have the same slender bodies, and the small part of one lion's mouth that remains shows it to have the rectangularcornerstypical of the Gorgon Painter'smature phase, not the roundedones seen on the North Slope lid.24The siren on 1367 and the goat or deer on 1297 also have their counterpartson the Baltimore plate. 1368 (PI. 94), another lid, probably belongs here, although so little remains that it is difficultto be certain. 139 (PI. 17) is the only neck-amphoraby the Gorgon Painter from the Agora, although four others, 138 and 141-143 (Pls. 17, 18), are in his manner or comparedwith it, the last two attributed here. 140 (PI. 17), if not by the painter himself, is certainlyin his manner. 139 very likely had its decorationset in friezes and is close in style to the kraterfrom the Akropolis,a one-piece amphora in the Louvre, and the round-bodiedlekythos in London.25The Gorgon Painter is credited with introducinga single walking animal in the panel of an amphora.26He may also have been the first to paint a lone horsemanon a galloping mount in a panel, for the earliest preservedexamples are in his manner. The galloping horsemanon 673 (P1.64), perhapsby the Gorgon Painter himself, takes with it 709 (P1. 68), which preservespart of a similar horseman. Severalvases, including some of those alreadymentioned,are in the mannerof the Gorgon Painter: 4 (PI. 1), 11 (PI. 2), 138 (PI. 17), 141 and 142 (Pl. 18), 672 and 673 (Pl. 64), 703 (P1. 67), 705-708 (P1. 68), 723 (P1. 69), and 1857 (P1. 119); 125 (P1. 15), 143 (P1. 18), 531 (P1. 51), 710 (P1. 68), and 1911 (P1. 121) are compared with his manner; and 12 (PI. 2), 123 (PI. 15), 140 (PI. 17), 532 (PI. 51), 704 (P1. 68), 709 (P1. 68), 777 (P1. 73), and 1370 (P1. 94) may be by the painter himself or in his manner. Together they enlarge our picture of the Gorgon Painter's workshop. 138 is a large neck-amphoradecoratedwith horseheadson the neck and two zones of animals on the shoulder and body. The hanging spirals and the stacked rays, as well as the dot rosettes,which are the same as those on Athens, N.M. 19176,27indicate an early date. 140, which preservespart of a very lively lion, is from a similar, contemporaryneck-amphoraof comparable size. 531 and 532 are fragments of two conical stands used to support kraters or bowls and are slightly later, for they compare best with the mature work of the Gorgon Painter. 672, a wellpreservedtrefoil olpe with a single large siren in its panel, belongs with these. Most interesting among these vases is 723, a ring-collaroinochoewith two confrontedsatyr heads of the same type as that of the satyr on the lekythos in Buffalo and probably also on the unpublished oinochoai in Taranto and Berlin.28 The olpai by the Gorgon Painter belong to a larger group of early 6th-centuryolpai that are by differenthands, although none is far in style from the Gorgon Painter and his followers.29675 and 676 (Pls. 64, 65), 713, and 714 (P1.68) were attributedby Beazley,30and three more may be added, 677, 678 (Pls. 64, 65), and 715 (Pl. 68). 675, to judge by the hanging spiral and dot rosette, is contemporarywith 138 (P1. 17), an early neck-amphorain the mannerof the Gorgon Painter, and the square corners of the lion's mouth on 714 are comparableto lions on vases of the painter's mature period. Horse-head amphorae first appear around 600 B.C.and continue until at least the middle of the 6th century.31The 11 examples from the Agora, 13-23 (PI. 3), with perhaps the exception of 22, 24 Cf. I. Scheibler, Jdl 76, 1961, p. 15 for this detail as a criterionfor dating. 25 Akropolis474 (ABV8, 2); Louvre E 817 (ABV9, 7; Paralip. 6, 7); London, Russell (ABV 9, 17). 26 I. Scheibler,Jdl 76, 1961, pp. 42-43. 27 AB V 9, 16; Paralip. 7, 16. 28 Buffalo G 600 (ABV 12, 22); Taranto (ABV 10, 2); Berlin (ABV 10, 3). 29ABV 14-15; Paralip. 9.
30 Also 716 (P1.69), which is by the KY Painter (ABV 14, 5; 33, 7). 31 The Group of Horse-head Amphorae has been studied most recently by M. Picozzi (Studi Misc. 18, 1971, pp. 5-64) and by A. Birchall (JHS 92, 1972, pp. 46-63). For a possible imitationof an Attic Horse-head amphorain anotherfabric,cf. R. Lullies, "Eine neue korinthischeAmphora,"Festschriftfir GerhardKleiner, Tiibingen 1976, pp. 21-32, esp. pp. 29-30.
POTTERS AND PAINTERS
77
belong to the earlier phase of productionof this species and thereforeare presentedin the catalogue as a group. The type of head goes back to Protoattichorses, especially its shape, the large eye and droopy chin, and the mane divided into long wispy locks.32Protoatticexamples usually include the forelegs,33as do the two on a neck-amphoraby the Lion Painter.34Horse-head amphoraeshow the head and neck only and thus are true protomes.35It is not certainwho was the first artist to produce Horse-head amphorae,but surely it was a painter of the late 7th centuryB.C. with strong Protoattic conventionsof drawing combinedwith a preferencefor the austerity of the black-figuretechnique. Karouzou thought perhaps it might have been the Nettos Painter, since a Horse-head amphora, Athens, N.M. 1003, was found with his namepiece,36but so far no panel amphora has been attributed for certain to the Nettos Painter, and the restrainedfigures of early panels producea very different effect from the powerful, animated figures that spred out over the surfacesof his vases.37 Beazley suggested, with reservation,that the Gorgon Painter might be creditedwith the invention of the Horse-head amphora, and Scheiblerfollowed Beazley by agreeing that the Horse-head amphorae should in some way be connectedwith the Gorgon Painter and his workshop.38138 (P. 17), a neck-amphorain the manner of the Gorgon Painter, strengthensthis suggestionconsiderablyfor it has four horseheadson the neck that are of the same type as those on Horse-head amphorae.That the Gorgon Painter is the first artist to decoratemore than one panel amphorawould also appear to argue in favor of this theory, were it not that his four known panel amphorae seem to be later in date than the earliest Horse-head amphorae.39And even though the heads of the horseson the Gorgon Painter's namepiece are very similar in type to those on Horse-head amphorae,40the two may depend upon a commonprototype.Thus, until more substantialevidencelinks the inventionof the Horse-head amphora with a specific painter, it is perhaps best to leave the question open. Panther Painter and CeramicusPainter The work of the Panther Painter and the CeramicusPainter is contemporarywith the early work of the Gorgon Painter, dated in the first years of the 6th century B.C.41 The Panther Painter is primarily a painter of lekanides decoratedwith animal friezes, of which all known to us have been found in the cemetery at Vari. 534 (PI. 51), a fragmentof a stand, and 1451 (Pl. 99), the rim of a skyphos, are close in style but may not be attributed to him for certain. More variety of shapes appears in the work of the Ceramicus Painter than in the work of the Panther Painter. Like his contemporaries,he shows a markedpreferencefor animal friezes, but his trefoil olpe from Vari has a representationof Aristaios,42a rare subjectalso known from 141 (PI. 18), a neck-amphorain the manner of the Gorgon Painter. 535 (PI. 51) is a stand fragment attributedby Philippaki, and we 32 E.g., Agora VIII, nos. 573, 587, pls. 36, 37; Berlin, inv. no. 31 333 (CVA, Berlin 1 [Germany2], pl. 48 [94]:2);compare also the horseson the Piraeus Painter's amphora(AB V 2; Paralip. 1, -, 1), which have a strong Protoatticcharacter.The type may also be seen on horses by the Nettos Painter (e.g. Athens, N.M. 16383: ABV7, y; Paralip. 3,12) and the Gorgon Painter (e.g. Louvre E 874: ABV 8, 1; Paralip. 6, 1). 33Cf. Agora P 22551 (Agora VIII, no. 573, pl. 36); also Kerameikos,inv. no. 74 (KerameikosVI, ii, no. 34, pl. 24, and the brief discussion of horse protomeson p. 222). 34 Athens, N.M. 16393 (AB V 2, 1). 35 For an Attic horseheadneck-amphorawhere the forelegs are included, cf. the one formerly in a Swiss private collection and now in the Indiana University Art Museum, 74.10.1 (Paralip. 10; Moon, Midwestern Collections,no. 29, pp. 48-50). 36 Karouzou,Amasis Painter, p. 42; Picozzi (Studi Misc. 18, 1971, p. 53) gives a summary of the problem.
Cf. above, pp. 74-75. ABV 15-16; I. Scheibler,JdI 76, 1961, p. 1. 3912 (PI. 2); Louvre C 10620 (ABV 9, 9; Paralip. 7, 9); Avallon 50 (Paralip. 7, 9 bis); Hanover 1965.13 (Paralip. 7, 95; CVA, Hannover 1 [Germany 34], pl. 5 [1637]:3, 4), all rather late in the firstquarterof the 6th century.For a discussionof the late work of the Gorgon Painter, cf. Scheibler,op. cit., pp. 6-14. 40 Louvre E 874 (ABV 8, 1; Paralip. 6, 1). A further connectionbetween Horse-head amphoraeand the Gorgon Painter may be the manes of his lions which end in long locks that fall loosely over the shoulder. 41 Panther Painter: ABV 18; Paralip. 11-12. Ceramicus Painter: ABV 18-19; Paralip. 12-13; for a discussion of the plates from his workshop, cf. Callipolitis-Feytmans, Les plats attiques, pp. 204-205. 42Athens, N.M. 16285 (ABV 19, 3). 37 38
POTTERS AND PAINTERS
78
have added two others, 536 (PI. 51) and 537, which go with the namepieces in the Kerameikos. These three stands add a new shape to the known ones by the CeramicusPainter. 1356 (P1.93) is a lekanis that may be by him, for it is close in style to the one in the Kerameikos.609 (P1. 57) is compared by Beazley with the works of the Ceramicus Painter which recall the KX Painter, a younger contemporarywhose work found in the Agora is discussedbelow. AnagyrusPainter and Painter of Eleusis 767 Less well known contemporariesof the Gorgon Painter are the Anagyrus Painter and the Painter of Eleusis 767 whose work should probablybe dated late in the first quarterof the 6th centuryB.C. or the beginning of the second.43The Anagyrus Painter is named after the ancient deme, where modernVari is now located,and most of his small numberof known vases come from the cemetery there.44Callipolitis-Feytmanshas suggestedthat the Anagyrus Painter may have learned his craft in Athens but practicedit at Vari, for the color of the clay of his vases and the characterof the glaze match the local ware.45If so, then 540 (PI. 52), his only piece from the Agora and the only stand attributedto him, may have been exported to Athens.46The same may be true for 590 (P1. 55), a fenestrated stand by the Painter of Eleusis 767, a man of decidedly less talent than most of his contemporaries.He, too, may have workedoutside Athens, in this case at Eleusis. Groupof the Dresden Lekanis Several fragmentsfrom the Agora belong to the Group of the Dresden Lekanis whose vases have been found mainly on the Akropolis and in the Agora, although the namepiece comes from Corinth.471442-1444 (PI. 98) and 1859 (PI. 119) were attributedby Beazley to the main painterof the group, and he thought that 150 (PI. 19) and 413 (PI. 41) were also by him.48591 (PI. 56), a stand, goes with these and adds a new shape to the painter, although not to the group, for 541 (P1. 52), a stand fragment by another hand, was already attributed.592 (PI. 56), also a stand, may be compared with the Group of the Dresden Lekanis, but it is an inferiorwork, perhaps a workshoppiece. So too for 5 (PI. 1), a one-piece amphora. 610 (PI. 58), the best preserveddinos from the Agora, is connectedwith the Group of the Dresden Lekanis, but it does not seem to be by one of its painters. The liveliness of the figures, as well as the painter's interest in mythologicalrepresentationsand narrative, keeps the vase apart and suggests an artist well acquaintedwith the work of Sophilos. The Painter of the Dresden Lekanis seems to have emigrated to Boiotia, for his vases cannot be separated from a large group of Boeotian vases called the Horse-bird Group after the horse protome ending in a bird's tail painted on an alabastronin London.491300 (PI. 91) may be compared with this group. The paintersjust discussedstand somewhatoutside the mainstreamof Attic black figure. The most importantartists of the late first quarterof the 6th centuryand the beginningof the secondare those of the Komast Group and Sophilos.50Together, they carry on the tradition established by the 43 Anagyrus Painter:ABV
20-21; Paralip. 13; CallipolitisFeytmans, Les plats attiques,pp. 69-75. Painter of Eleusis 767: AB V 21; Paralip. 13. 44 Exceptions: 540 (PI. 52); Athens, Vlasto, from Spata (ABV 21, 2). 45Callipolitis-Feytmans,Les plats attiques,p. 69. 46 Callipolitis-Feytmans,Les plats attiques, p. 70. 47 Dresden ZV 1464 (ABV 21, 1). A neck-amphora has also been found at Taranto (ABV 21, 2) and two lekanides at Smyrna (ABV 680, 1 bis and ter, Paralip. 14, 1 bis and
ter). For the rest of the group's vases, cf. ABV 21-23 and Paralip. 14. 48AB V 22. 49ABV22-23. 50Komast Group: ABV 23-37; Paralip. 14-17. Sophilos: ABV 37-43; Paralip. 18-19; Williams, op. cit. (footnote 4 above, pp. 33-34), pp. 9-34; Baklr, Sophilos.Add: New York, M.M.A. 1977.11.2, a volute-krater (footnote 2 above, p. 26) and New York, M.M.A. 1977.193, a fragmentof a krateror a dinos (unpublished):a satyr.
POTTERS AND PAINTERS
79
Gorgon Painter and lead to the painters of the next generation,in particular Kleitias and the chief painters of Siana cups, the C Painter and the Heidelberg Painter. Komast Group The Komast Group is named after the padded dancers who appear on many of its vases, particularly drinking vessels. 417 (P1. 41) is a good example of one. These cheerful revelers were borrowed from Corinth along with certain shapes, specificallythe column-krater,the Corinthian type of skyphos, and the Komast cup,51which was adaptedfor Athenian use. Generally, the painters of the Komast Group, unlike their predecessors,prefer to decorate rather small shapes, and within the group there is a good variety of them. The two chief artists are the KX Painter (short for Komast X), the abler of the two, and the KY Painter, who is perhaps slightly younger. In the Agora, several vases by the KX Painter himself have been found: 126 (PI. 15), 151 (PI. 19), 351 (PI. 35), 523 (PI. 50), 1310 (PI. 91), 1336 (P1.92), and 1452 (P1.99), as well as two in his manner, 616 (P1. 57) and 1337 (P1.92). Of the KY Painter, there is only 716 (P1.69), a fragmentaryolpe in his manner. In addition, 417 (PI. 41), 1658, and 1659 (PI. 108) were attributed to the Komast Group but not given to a specific painter. 1453 and 1454 (Pl. 99), fragmentsof two skyphoi, the former with two zones of figures, may be added. Besides komasts, the most frequent subjectson vases by the Komast Group are animal friezes or confrontedpairs of animals. Occasionally,mythological scenes appear, including the earliest examples in Attic black figure of the Judgment of Paris and of Achilleus receiving his armor.52126, which preservesthe upper part of a youth holding out his cloak, is surely from a scene of myth or legend. The first four lettersof his name (HEKA)appear next to the right break, and the possible restorationsappear to be either an epithet of Apollo or the name of the eponymous hero, Akademos. Sophilos Sophilos is the first Attic black-figureartist whose name is known from signatures, for twice he signs as painter, once as potter, and very likely once as both potter and painter.53He has given us the earliest Attic black-figuredvolute-krater,funerary plaques, and probablytoo, the lebes gamikos,54and he is the first to make liberal use of inscriptionsto identify the figures in his narrative scenes. Unlike the painters of the Komast Group, Sophilos prefersto decoratelarge vessels, and all his vases found in the Agora are large. 6 (P1. 1) and 29 (P1.4) are one-piece amphorae,the former decoratedwith animal friezes, the latter with the figures set in panels. 419 (PI. 42) is a columnkrater, and 1912 (PI. 121), which may be by Sophilos himself, is from a krater or a dinos. 542 (P1. 52) is a conical stand close in style to the London dinos, and 30 (P1.4), a panel-amphoranear the painter, is a weaker version of his amphora in Jena.55 Although Sophilos paints animal friezes on many of his vases, as on 6 (P1. 1), in keeping with the taste of the time, he is clearly more interested in mythological representationsthan any of his 51 For these shapes, cf. above, pp. 23-24, 58-59, 62. 52Berlin 3987 (ABV 25, 16); Rhodes 5008 (ABV 24, 1; Paralip. 14, 1). 53 As painter, Akropolis 587 (ABV 39, 15; Baklr, Sophilos, pl. 3) and London, B.M. 1971.11-1.1 (Paralip. 19, 16 bis; Baklr, Sophilos, pls. 1, 2; Williams, op. cit. [footnote 4 above, pp. 33-34]). As potter, Athens, N.M. 2035, 1 and 2 (ABV 40, 21; 42, 36; Paralip. 18, 21; Baklr, Sophilos, pl. 8, fig. 16): the new numbers are 15918 and 15442 (D. Callipolitis-Feytmans ["Louteria,"p. 54] postulates a double signature for this vase,
but only the potting verb remains). As potter and painter, very likely Athens, N.M. 15499 (ABV39, 16;Paralip. 18,16; Bakir, Sophilos, pl. 6, fig. 10). 54 Volute-krater:New York, M.M.A. 1977.11.2 (footnote2 above, p. 26); funerary plaques: Athens, Vlasto (ABV 42, 38-40; Baklr, Sophilos,pls. 37, 38); lebes gamikos:Izmir (ABV 40, 20; Paralip. 18, 20; Bakir, Sophilos,pls. 39-45). Boardman doubts the attribution of the latter (BSA 53-54, 1958-1959, pp. 155-158). 55ABV 39, 7; Paralip. 18, 7; Baklr, Sophilos, pls. 11, 12.
80
POTTERS AND PAINTERS
predecessors,and it is probably no accidentthat each of his signed vases has an ambitious mythological scene in the main zone.56Furthermore,he may have introducednew subjectsinto the Attic vase painter's repertory, specifically the Wedding of Peleus, the Funeral Games for Patroklos, Herakles and the Centaurs,and the Weddingof Menelaos and Helen.57And the satyrswho appear on the fragmentin Istanbul and on the one in New York are among the earliest, if not the earliest, in Attic black figure.58Moreover, his scenes are extended narratives with a full complementof participants;they are not restrictedto the main characters.59419 (PI. 42), which preservespart of a building in antis, belongs with two of his signed vases, Akropolis 587 and London, B.M. 1971.11-1.1, which show the Wedding of Peleus in the main frieze. The interpretationof the scene on 419 is uncertainbut surely must be mythological. 1912 (PI. 121), which shows part of a frontal chariot team and a grieving old man, goes with these. Painter of Xanthos A 6.3444 and Eridanos Workshop Contemporarywith the late phase of the KomastGroup and Sophilos are three attributedpieces. 127 (PI. 15) is a one-piece amphora by the Painter of Xanthos A 6.3444, whose only other known work seems to be his namepiece,60a column-kraterin Istanbul. 1389 and 1390 (PI. 95) are of more interest. Both are large plates attributed by Callipolitis-Feytmans to the Eridanos Workshop, named after the river that flows through the Kerameikoswhere two of them were found.61The floor of 1389 is decoratedin registers, the earliest preservedexample of this scheme.62Although little remains of the figures on either plate, the lotus-palmettefestoon on each is a less well drawn version of the one used by Sophilos.63 Kleitias The interest in narrativeshown by Sophilos is continuedby Kleitias, the next Attic black-figure painter whose name is known, for he signed five vases as painter; four of them were potted by Ergotimos.64Like Sophilos, Kleitias prefersto place his figuresin friezes ratherthan in panels, and usually he inscribestheir names. His drawing is more precise than that of Sophilos, and his love of detail is perhaps greater too, but the figures of the two painters have the same spontaneityof expression. One need only compare the cheering spectatorsat the Games of Patroklos by Sophilos with the joyous Athenians in the Theseus scene on the FranCoisvase to see that the two share a common interest in visual narrative.65Two vases by Kleitias have been found in the Agora. 625 (PI. 59) is the shoulderof a hydria with animal decorationthat finds its nearestkin in the lowest figured frieze on the body of the Frankoisvase.661874 (P. 120), which shows the neck, chest, and hair of a youth, is more puzzling with regardto both shape and subject.It seems to be from an amphora, and the scene is surely mythological,for one letter of the youth's name is preserved,but the precise subjectis uncertain. 56
Weddingof Peleus and Thetis on Akropolis587 and London, B.M. 1971.11-1.1; Herakles and the Centaursand an unexplained subjecton Athens, N.M. 15918 and 15422; Funeral Games for Patrokloson Athens, N.M. 15499. 57 For the first three, cf. footnote 56 above. Menelaos and Helen appear on the Izmir lebes (ABV 40, 20; Paralip. 18, 20; Bakir, Sophilos, pls. 40, 45). 58 Istanbul (ABV 42, 37; Baklr, Sophilos,pl. 35, fig. 66); New York, M.M.A. 1977.193 (unpublished). 59 Compare, e.g., the representationof Thetis giving armor to Achilleus, which is inserted into an animal frieze on the Rhodes lekanis by the KX Painter (ABV 24, 1; Paralip. 14, 1), with any of the works in footnotes 56 and 57. 60 Paralip. 18, 1.
61
Callipolitis-Feytmans,Les plats attiques,p. 77. Cf. above, p. 54 and footnote8. 63 Examples: 6 (PI. 1); Akropolis 587 (ABV 39, 15; Baklr, Sophilos,pl. 3); London,B.M. 1971.11-1.1 (Paralip. 19, 16 bis; Baklr, Sophilos, pls. 1, 2; Williams, op. cit. (footnote 4 above, pp. 33-34). 64 For Kleitias, cf. ABV 76-79 and Paralip. 29-30. The collaborativevases are nos. 1, 12-14. 65 Athens, N.M. 15499 by Sophilos (ABV 39, 16; Paralip. 18, 16; Baklr,Sophilos,pi. 6, fig. 10); Florence4209 by Kleitias (ABV 76, 1; Paralip. 29, 1; Cristofani, Vaso Franqois,fig. 63). 66 Best seen in A. Minto, II vaso Franqois,Florence 1960, pls. 31, 32 and Cristofani, VasoFranfois, figs. 97, 98, 101. 62
POTTERS AND PAINTERS
81
C Painter The C Painter (C for Corinthianizing) and his slightly younger contemporary,the Heidelberg Painter, are the two best known painters of Siana cups, the chief type of Attic black-figuredcup in the second quarter of the 6th century B.C.67
The C Painter draws short, compact figures with large heads, firm stances, and lively gestures. His preferredsubjectsare friezes of standing figures, symposia, duels, and cavalcadesof horsemen to left. Occasionally, he paints mythological scenes, in particular Achilleus and Troilos, Perseus and the Gorgons, Achilleus and Memnon, the Judgment of Paris, and the Birth of Athena, which is one of the earliest representationsof this theme.68His style and his non-mythologicalsubjectsshow a strong Corinthian influence,69although he is not the first Attic black-figurepainterto be indebted to Corinth.70On some of his more ambitiouspieces, such as the Louvrepyxis, there also seems to be some influence from Kleitias.71All the Agora pieces by the C Painter himself, 1660-1667 (Pls. 108, 109), are Siana cups decoratedaccordingto the overlap scheme generally preferredby him. These cups are extremely fragmentary,but the compositionson most of them may be understoodby comparing them with others by the painter that are well preserved.The frieze of standing figures on 1661 (PI. 108) and that on 1662 (P1. 108) were probablysimilar to the one on the cup in Berkeley or the cup in the Villa Giulia;72the symposionon 1667 finds its best parallel on a cup in London.73 The cavalcadeof horsemen on 1660 (PI. 108) and the warriors on 1663-1666 (Pl. 109) have their counterpartson many cups, e.g., London, B.M. B 382, Mainz 89, Corinth CP 552, and Montreal 59.Cb.2.74Besides these cups by the C Painter, seven other pieces belong here. Two other Siana cups, 1669 and 1670, are related to him, 1668 (PI. 109) and 1937 (PI. 123) are in his manner, and 1937, a plaque, adds a new shape to those known to be by the painter and his companions. 1678 (P1. 109) is the best-preservedSiana cup from the Agora, the only one that may be fully restored, and one of the few examples from these excavationsdecoratedaccordingto the double-deckerprinciple (cf. above, p. 63). Of particular interest is 1802 (P1. 116), perhaps a fragmentof a Siana cup, which preserves the last five letters of the potter's name and the first two letters of the verb. The style recalls the C Painter, particularly his best pieces such as the Louvre pyxis and the Naples lekanis.751683 also recalls his work. 67 The C Painter: ABV 51-61; Paralip. 23-26; J. Hemelrijk, BABesch 46, 1971, pp. 110-114. The Heidelberg Painter: ABV 63-67; Paralip. 26-27. 68 Achilleus and Troilos: New York, M.M.A. 01.8.6 (ABV 51, 4). Perseus and the Gorgons: Vatican 335 (ABV 57, 111). Judgment of Paris: Louvre CA 616 (ABV 58, 122; Paralip. 23, 122) and Lille 763 (ABV 681; MonPiot 63, 1980, p. 35, fig. 3 and p. 37, fig. 4). Achilleus and Memnon: Lille 763. Birth of Athena: Louvre CA 616. The Birth of Athena on Akropolis 597 a-e by Kleitias (ABV 77, 3) may be slightly later than the one by the C Painter (Beazley, Development, p. 108, note 55). 69 See particularly Beazley, MMSt 5, 1934-1936, pp. 100102 and Development, pp. 22-23. 70 Corinthian influence on Attic black figure may be detected as early as the Nettos Painter who seems to be the first to use the incised rosette typical of Early Corinthian pottery. The use of animal friezes by the Gorgon Painter, the Komast Group, and Sophilos also seems inspired from Corinth, as noted above. Sophilos and Kleitias both use added white in the Corinthian manner, laying it directly on the clay ground with the details drawn in glaze, instead of applying the white on top of the black glaze and incising details, which is the Attic method. For Corinthian influence on the earliest Attic black figure as well as
problems of chronology, cf. T. Dunbabin, BSA 45, 1950, pp. 193-202; Karouzou, 'Avayvpov^ros, pp. 115-122; for the first part of the 6th century,cf. Payne, NC, pp. 190-202; for the second quarter, cf. H. R. W. Smith, The Hearst Hydria. An Attic Footnote to Corinthian History [University of California Publicationsin ClassicalArchaeologyI, 10], Berkeley/Los Angeles 1944, pp. 241-290 and W. Kleinbauer, AJA 68, 1964, pp. 355-370; also, Zaphiropoulou, BCH 94, 1970, pp. 380398. 71 Louvre CA 616 (ABV 58, 122; Paralip. 23, 122); also, Lille 763 (ABV 681; MonPiot 63, 1980, pp. 35-38, figs. 2-6). Compare especially the incised decoration on garments with many of those in the Wedding of Peleus scene on the Francois vase. 72 Berkeley 8.1 (ABV 54, 71); Villa Giulia 16336 (ABV 55, 74). 73 London, B.M. B 382 (ABV 51, 5). 74 London, B.M. B 382 (ABV 51, 5); Mayence 89 (Paralip. 23, 12 bis); Corinth CP 552 (ABV 52, 13); Montreal 59 Cb 2 (ABV 52, 14; Paralip. 23, 14). 75 Louvre CA 616 (ABV 58, 122; Paralip. 23, 122); Naples (ABV 58, 119; Paralip. 23, 119).
82
POTTERS AND PAINTERS
HeidelbergPainter The Heidelberg Painter, whose work resemblesthe early work of the Amasis Painter, takes his name from the two Siana cups in Heidelberg.76His known output does not rival in quantity that of the C Painter, but he seems to be the more ambitious artist of the two, at least with regard to the variety of subjectmatter. Like the Agora cups by the C Painter, the four attributedto the Heidelberg Painter are very fragmentary,but what remains of the figures may be better understoodwith the help of his well-preservedworks. The runner on 1671 (PI. 109) with his red chest and a cloak over both arms is similar to the warriorson Munich, inv. no. 7739, and the satyr on 1682 (PI. 110), a rare subjectfor the Heidelberg Painter, was probablylike those on the cup in Copenhagenwho accompanyDionysos.77The woman on 1672 is very likely a spectator,as those on Louvre A 478 who watch Pandareosand the Golden Hound.781679 (PI. 110) probablyshowed a phalanx. Polos Painter The Polos Painter, named for the headdress worn by his women, sirens, and sphinxes, stands considerablyapart from his contemporaries,for he shares neither their drawing ability nor their interest in narrative.79His modesttalent stands in great contrastto his large output, much of which was exportedto many parts of the Greek world. The Polos Painter decoratesmany shapes, but his range of subjects is limited, consisting of animal friezes, sirens and sphinxes often in confronted pairs, and rows or pairs of women. His style reflects a certain influence from Corinth, and his hastily executed, almost mechanically drawn figures are quickly recognizable. There are more vases from the Agora attributedto the Polos Painter than to any other painter of his time, a circumstancethat may be fortuitous or may reflect civic and domesticpractices.Among these vases, there is a good varietyof shapes, typical for the painter:neck-amphorae,160 (P1.20), 161; columnkrater, 427; stand, 594; hydria, 621 (P1. 59); oinochoe, 733 (P1. 70); tripod-pyxis, 1271 (PI. 90);
lekanides,1311-1321 (PI.92); lids, 1263 (PI.88), 1344 (PI.93), 1377;plates,1399-1405 (PI.96);
and several fragmentsof closed vases which do not preserveenough to be sure of the shape, 18621868 (PI. 119). In addition, one hydria fragment, 622, is near him. All the subjectsare his usual ones. Painter of LondonB 76, Burgon Group, TyrrhenianGroup, CamtarPainter, and Groupof North Slope AP 942 Among the many painters whose work is contemporarywith those just discussed,vases by only three have been found in the Agora:the Painter of London B 76, the PrometheusPainter, and the Camtar Painter. Four of these vases are by the Painter of London B 76,80 whose techniquein some respects,particularlyits colorfuleffects,recalls the C Painter. He is not a cup painter, however,but prefers to decoratepots and has left us a good variety of them. Each of the four from the Agora is a different shape. 611 (PI. 57), 626 (PI. 59), and 1346 (PI. 93), attributedby Beazley, are a dinos, a shoulderedhydria, and the lid of a lekanis, respectively;34 (PI. 5), addedhere, is a panel amphora. 767 (PI. 72) is an oinochoe of the Vraona type, a rare and special shape (see above, pp. 42-43), which belongs to the Burgon Group, whose painters are near the Painter of London B 76 and with whom the series of Panathenaicamphoraebegins.81170 (PI. 21) is the only vase from the Tyrrhenian Group found in the Agora, for normallytheir work was exportedto Italy.82170 preservespart of 76 Heidelberg vi. 29 a (ABV 63, 1) and S 61 (ABV 63, 2). For the rest of his work, cf. footnote 67 above, p. 81. 77 Munich, inv. no. 7739 (ABV 64, 28; Bothmer, Amasis Painter, p. 72, fig. 55); Copenhagen, inv. no. 5179 (ABV 64, 24). 78 Louvre A 478 (ABV 66, 54).
79 ABV 43-50; Paralip. 19-22; Hemelrijk,op. cit. (footnote 67 above, p. 81), pp. 105-110; Callipolitis-Feytmans,Les plats attiques,pp. 160-167. 80 ABV 85-88; Paralip. 32-33. 81 ABV 89-90; Paralip. 33. 82 ABV 94-106; Paralip. 34-43.
POTTERS AND PAINTERS
83
a warrior and generally recalls the PrometheusPainter, who takes his name from the subjecton his neck-amphorain Florence.83166 (PI. 20) is by the Camtar Painter whose name is a contractionof Cam[bridge]and Tar[quinia] where his namepieces are located today.84The Camtar Painter is primarily a painter of ovoid neck-amphorae,although he decoratedan amphora Type B and a round-bodiedhydria.85His style recalls somewhat that of the Painter of London B 76,86 but his drawing is strongerand the quality higher. In this respect,he is more akin to other contemporaries, in particularthe Painter of Acropolis627,87 whose four known vases come from the Akropolis.Our last vase here, 375 (P1. 37), belongs to the Group of North Slope AP 942, a small group of loutrophoroi found so far only on the Akropolis, the North Slope, and in the Agora, 375 being a wellpreserved example.88Although somewhat later than the work of the painters just discussed, the style is linked with Eleusis 252 (766) by the Painter of London B 76.89 The next group of painters is active from about 570 to 540 B.C.Thus, in the beginning they are contemporarywith those just discussed, but they continue to work well past the middle of the century. The most importantartists are Lydos and two companions,the Painter of Louvre F 6 and the Painter of Vatican 309. Lydos Lydos, as his ssignatureHO AYdAO suggests, was probably a foreigner who came to Athens from the East.90He signed two of his vases as painter, the one-piece amphorain the Louvreand the splendid dinos from the Akropolis, which although very fragmentary,ranks as one of the masterpieces of all Attic black figure.91Lydos worked for at least two potters, each confirmedby a signature on one of his vases, and probablyfor others as well, yet one may not exclude that he himself also potted on occasion.92Lydos is chiefly a pot painter, although he decoratedseveral cups, a few other small vessels, and also some funeraryplaques. His career seems to have spanned about three decades,his hydria in Munich being a very early piece (ca. 570 B.C.), the New York column-krater, the signed dinos, and the Naples amphora comprising some of his later works (ca. 540 B.C.).93 Although principally a painter of scenes with human figures, on some of his early vases Lydos paints animal friezes below the figured scenes or occasionallyanimals by themselves,and for one of 83
Florence 76359 (ABV 97, 28; Paralip. 37, 28). 84ABV 84; Paralip. 31-32. 85 New York,private,once Basel, Bloch (Paralip. 31, 10;Cat. Sotheby 13-14. July 1981, no. 243); Rome, Fondazione Lerici (Paralip. 32, 11; E. A. Arslan and E. M. Menotti, Gli Etruschie Cervetri [Nuove acquisizioni delle Civiche Raccolte Archeologiche], Milan 1980, p. 197, no. 11 [wrongly called Corinthian]). 86 Bothmer, AK 2, 1959, p. 8. 87 ABV 82; Paralip. 30, 1. 88ABV89. 89
ABV 86, 6; 89; Paralip. 32, 6. 90For Lydos, cf. ABV 107-120; Paralip. 43-49; and the monograph by Tiverios, 'O Avtos KaL7rripo
o TOy, Athens
1976. Also, M. B. Moore, AJA 83, 1979, pp. 79-99 (Akropolis 607). For plates by Lydos and his workshop, cf. CallipolitisFeytmans, Les plats attiques,chap. 3. On the name Lydos as reflecting his origins, cf. J. Boardman, ABFV, p. 52; also, M. Robertson, "Beazleyand After,"MJb 27, 1976, p. 42. The vase referred to by Robertson as indicating that Lydos was a slave is a kyathos in the Villa Giulia that shows an assembly of gods. It is not, however, by the mid-6th-centuryartist but by a later one working around 520 B.C. Cf. F. Canciani and G. Neumann, "Lydos,der Sklave?"AK 21, 1978, pp. 17-22. 91 Louvre F 29 (ABV 109, 21; Paralip. 44, 21; Tiverios,
pls. 1:,S, 17:/3, 18); Akropolis 607 (ABV 107, 1; Tiverios, pls. l:a, 48-50, 98:a, ,8; AJA 83, 1979, pls. 11-13, figs. 1-12 and ills. 1, 2 opp. p. 99). 92 For the potting signatures,cf. Berlin 1732 signed by Kolchos (ABV 110, 37; Paralip. 44, 37; and 48 where the attribution is questioned; Tiverios, pls. 57-59); Oxford 1966.768 signed by Nikosthenes (ABV 113, 80; 229; Paralip. 45, 80; 108; Tiverios, pl. 47:3, y). Nikosia C 440 (ABV 109, 28; Paralip. 44, 28; Tiverios, pls. 25:y, 26:a) is also madeby Nikosthenesfor it is the same shape as the signed amphora in the Villa Giulia (ABV 229). Berlin 1685 (ABV 109, 24; Tiverios, pls. 46, 47:a) may have been potted by Amasis. That Amasis potted the psykter-amphorain London (ABV 109, 29; Paralip. 44, 29; Tiverios, pls. 51, 52) is doubted by Bothmer. Callipolitis-Feytmans (Les plats attiques,pp. 87-93) postulatesthat Lydos may have decoratedplates for seven differentpotters, a number that seems rather high. For Lydos as potter, cf. AJA 83, 1979, p. 99, esp. note 166. 93 Munich 1681 (ABV 108, 12; Tiverios, pl. 2); New York, M.M.A. 31.11.11 (ABV 108, 5; Paralip. 43, 5; Tiverios, pls. 53-55); Akropolis 607 (footnote 91 above); Naples, N.M. 2770 (ABV 109, 23; Paralip. 44, 23; Tiverios, pl. 56). Berlin 1732 (footnote 92 above), if it is by Lydos, is probably a bit later.
POTTERS AND PAINTERS
84
his ovoid neck-amphorae,he adoptedthe decorativescheme used by Tyrrhenian painters.94Mainly, however, Lydos prefers to paint scenes of myth or of everydaylife. His style of painting is bold; his figuresare large and amply proportioned.On his early vases they tend to be ratherplain looking with a minimum of decorativeincision, especially for garments and hair. In his mature and later work, incised patterns on garments and careful incision for hair or pelts, combinedwith accessory red and white, create a rich tapestryof texture and color that helps to clarify overlappingfigures in his frequently innovativeand sometimescomplicatedcompositions.95 Ten vases by Lydos himself have been found in the Agora, more than that of any other major Attic black-figure artist. Nine of these were attributed by Beazley; 50 (PI. 6) is added here. In additionto the vases surely by his hand, seven others may be by him, but too little remainsto be certain. Although very fragmentary,these vases represent all phases but the very earliest in Lydos' career,and the range of shapes as well as subjectsis quite broad. The five earliest are 378 (PI. 37), 429 (PI. 42), 627 (PI. 60), 1262 (PI. 89), and 1447 (PI. 99). On all these there is economyof incision, and the compositionon each, from what remains, seems to be rather simple without very much overlappingof the figures. 378, the neck of a loutrophorosdecorated with pairs of mourners,is the exception. It goes with the other loutrophoroiby Lydos,96and the sphinx or siren in the frieze below the mournersis a less decorativeversion of the sphinxes on the neck-amphorain Florence.97The youth finds his counterpartin the men on the neck-amphora in the Louvre and on the column-kraterin London, as well as in the youth on the column-kraterin Salonica.98The frontal chariot on 627 (an infrequent subjectfor Lydos who preferredto draw his horses in profile) compareswith that on Louvre E 868, and the ivy framingthe sides of the panel of + this hydria is simpler and plainer than that on the slightly later hydriai in Gttingen (Gnttingen is close to Siana kothon his the known in the Kerameikos.99 and Cab. Med.) 1262, by Lydos, only of the century. The hair of is nearer to the middle chalice a in Herakleion.100 1447, fragment, cup the figures is still solid, but the X decorationon the inside of the bride'sveil is a precursorof that on the Kerameikoscup where it is used abundantlyon the garments of the mourners.101Five of the seven vases that may be by Lydos comparebest with his early work: 172 (P1.21), 430 (PI. 42), 628 (PI. 60), 790 (PI. 74), and 1475 (P1. 100). The last, a skyphos, is of special interest, for if it is by Lydos, it adds a new shape to his already wide repertory.The key pattern on 790, a fragmentof a lekythos, is slightly simpler than the one on the lekythos in Riehen;102the drawing of the cock is closest to the early ones by Lydos. The next two vases by Lydos himself are not much later than thosejust discussed.789 (PI. 74) is an early shoulderedlekythos. Here, the hair of the figures is still solid and the women's flesh left black as it was on 1262 (PI. 89),103 but there is more pattern incised on the drapery,and the composition is more ambitiousthan the one on the kothon, 1262. The scene on 789 depictsa successful hunter returning home with his quarry, welcomed by a man and two women, perhaps his family. (footnote91 above,p. 83).
pls. 7:,, 8, 9); Salonica, inv. no. 825 (ABV 108, 10; Tiverios,
Animals by themselves: Harvard, Fogg 1925.30.125 (ABV 108, 9; Tiverios, pl. 19:,B). Tyrrhenian scheme: Florence 70995
pl. 70:A3). 99 Louvre E 868 (footnote 98 above); Gottingen + Cab.
94 Animal frieze:e.g. Louvre F 29
(ABV 110, 32; Paralip. 44, 32; Tiverios, pls. 22, 23).
Med. (ABV 109, 19; Tiverios, pl. 31); Kerameikosn.n. (Para-
95 For examples of the latter, cf. particularly Akropolis 607 (footnote 91 above, p. 83) and New York, M.M.A. 31.11.11 (footnote 93 above, p. 83).
lip. 45; Tiverios, pl. 29). 100Herakleion 217 (ABV 684, 71 bis; Tiverios, pls. 14:,3, 15-17:a).
109, note 234. 97Florence 70995 (footnote94 above). 98 Louvre E 868 (ABV 110, 30; Tiverios, pls. 3, 4:a); Lon-
96 Tiverios, p.
don, B.M. 1948.10-15.1
(ABV 108, 8; Paralip. 44, 8; Tiverios,
101Kerameikosn.n. (ABV 113, 81; Paralip. 45, 81; Tiverios, pls. 42-44). 102 Riehen, Kuhn Coll. (ABV 111, 41; Tiverios, pl. 65:a). 103
For this detail, cf. Tiverios, p. 121, note 451.
POTTERSAND PAINTERS
85
He is accompaniedby his dog and precededby a chariot.1041446 (PI. 99) is a chalice fragment, similar to 1447 (PI. 99) but with surer and finer drawing. The woman's hair and the horse'smane are finely incised, even the teeth of the horse are included,and the scale patternembellishesthe skirt of the woman's peplos. 1446 is closest to the lovely fragment from Delphi, probably a columnkrater, that preserves part of the right trace horse of a frontal chariot and a siren flying to left.105 435 (PI. 43), a fragmentof a column-kraterthat may be by Lydos, belongs here. From the little that remains of the two horses, the scene showed either two horsemen or a horseman leading a void horse, similar to the one on the Kerameikoshydria. The rest of the vases are late works. The scene on 49 (Pl. 6), a small panel amphora by Lydos himself, was probably much like the one on the Kerameikoshydria but later, a conclusionreached independently by Tiverios.10650 (PI. 6), two fragments of what must have been a splendid amphora, bore a similar subject.It is almost a replica of the painter'smasterpiecein Naples,107but for the absence of ornament above the panel. It has the same monumental quality, refined elegance, and restraineddrawing as the Naples amphora. 1349 (P1.93), the lid of a lekanis, is our latest vase firmly attributedto Lydos, at least to judge by the three-dimensionalfolds of the warrior'schiton.108 It probably had an uninterrupted battle scene, and the compositionwas very likely a more ambitious version of the fight on one of Lydos' Siana cups in Taranto,109but the amount of overlapping of the warriors'legs on 1349 suggests a much later date than the cup, one of about 540 B.C.The last piece in this section on Lydos is 51 (P1. 7), an amphora fragmentthat shows a satyr about to drink from a horn. Many of the details unmistakablyrecall Lydos, but it is not certain if the hand is his. Besides the ten vases firmly attributedto Lydos and the seven that may be by him, seven others, 436,437 (PI. 43), 442-445 (P1.43), and 1350 (P1.93), are in his manner,and three more, 439-441 (Pl. 43), are related. All but one of these, 1350, the lid of a lekanis, are column-kraters.436, a wellpreserved krater, and 1350 are good examples of the animal style connectedwith Lydos. 437, a shoulder fragment added here, goes with another in his manner in the Louvre. The rest of the kraters in his manner, 442-445, are handle-plates decoratedwith a bird, three of them preening. The three pieces relatedto Lydos are also handle-platesbut are decoratedwith human heads facing to left, a favoritedecorationfor handle-plates (above, p. 25). 439 has a man and a woman; 440 and 441, both attributedhere, have a single male head. Painter of LouvreF 6 and Painter of Vatican309 In Paralipomena (p. 47) Beazley suggestedthat 442-445 might be by the Painter of Louvre F 6, but he kept these four kratersin his list of vases in the manner of Lydos without cross-listingthem. We are inclined to do the same, even though the sketchiness of the drawing seems closer to the Painter of Louvre F 6 than it does to Lydos, but without more to go on, it is perhaps preferableto leave them where they are. The Painter of Louvre F 6 is a conservative,old-fashionedartist who is linked with Lydos chiefly through his animals.1"0The drawing on his earlier vases is finer and more elaboratethan in his later work, which exhibits marksof hastiness. Throughout his careerhe pays scant attentionto details of anatomyand rarely embellishesgarmentswith patternsother than 104For scenes of hunters, cf. M. B. Moore, Metropolitan Museum Journal 18, 1984, pp. 37-38. 105 Paralip. 46; Tiverios, p. 102, note 122 for the interpretation of the scene, and pl. 70:8. The flying siren brings to mind the one on the obverseof Louvre F 53, a nearly contemporary, special one-piece amphora signed by Exekias as potter but attributed to Group E (ABV 136, 49; Paralip. 55, 49).
106
Tiverios, p. 105, note 176. Naples, N.M. 2770 (footnote93 above, p. 83). 108 Tiverios (p. 122, note 467) also considersthis a late work. 109Taranto 52130 (ABV 112, 67; Paralip. 44, 67; Tiverios, pl. 13). 110 ABV 123-129; Paralip. 50-53. 107
86
POTTERS AND PAINTERS
broad stripes. The Painter of Louvre F 6 decoratesa good variety of shapes, but his subjectsare frequently repetitious. He shows a marked preference for departure scenes and combats, often flankedby spectators. Ten vases from the Agora were attributedby Beazley to the Painter of Louvre F 6: 54-56 (PI. 7), 58 and 59 (P. 8), 447 and 448 (PI. 44), 561 (PI. 54), 768 (P1.72), and 1922 (P1. 122). 449 may be by him, and two others, 57 (PI. 7) and 1351 (PI. 93), are in his manner. These are mostly columnkratersand amphorae. 561 is a stand, 768 an oinochoe.All but one are late in the painter's career. 54 is the exception for it is closest to the painter'slebes in Houston,11 one of his best vases. The late work of the Painter of Louvre F 6 leads on to the Ready Painter, also a somewhat old-fashioned artist. 1330 (P1.92), a lekanis with its cover,is near him. Like the Painter of Louvre F 6, the Painter of Vatican 309, who is the second companion of Lydos, is also linked to the masterchiefly by his animal style." 2 His known output, however,is only about one-third that of the other two painters. The quality of his drawing is frequentlyhigher than that of the Painter of Louvre F 6, and his style is closestto the early phase of Lydos. 13The Painter of Vatican 309 decoratesmainly ovoid neck-amphorae,although he has left us a few hydriai and column-kraters,one of the latter, 446 (P1. 43), from the Agora, two amphorae, and a plate. 176 (P1. 21) may be addedto his ovoid neck-amphorae. In the third quarterof the 6th century,Attic black-figurepaintersachievetheir greatestdistinction. This is the period of the Amasis Painter and Exekias, the two great masters of Attic black figure. Alongside these two are many other able artists who, although not nearly so skilled, have nevertheless left us a good many vases of high quality. They are painters such as the Painter of Berlin 1686, those of the PrincetonGroup, the Swing Painter, and the paintersof Group E, just to mention a few whose work may be dated between 550 and 530 B.C. After them come artists such as the Lysippides Painter, who was probably a pupil of Exekias, the Antimenes Painter and his group, and Psiax, all important artists who begin working between 530 and 520 B.C. but who continue well beyond. In the third quarterof the 6th century,the workshopof the potter Nikosthenes also comes into prominence. Exekias The work of Exekias, who signs as both potter and painter, demonstratesmore clearly than that of any other black-figureartist the brilliant resultsthat may be achievedwithin the strict limitations of this technique, and his accomplishmentremains unrivaledthroughoutall Attic black figure.'"4 Although his known output hardly exceeds 35 vases, from these the mark of his genius is clear. As potter, he fashions new shapes or reworksold ones. As painter, he understandsbetterthan most the integral relationshipbetween the shape of a vase and its decoration,both ornamentand figures. He has an unparalleled sureness of drawing and an unfailing eye for subtle details that enliven his compositions.In Exekias' narratives,a somber mood and a dignified calmness often prevail. Frequently, the moment shown is the one that precedesor follows that of the greatest drama, in contrast to the custom of Archaic artists who prefer lively movementand vigorous gestures instead of understatedemotion or allusion to action past or future. This restraint combinedwith the monumentality of his figures and his sensitivity to human situations will not be seen again in Greek art until the Classical era. 11 Houston 34.129 (ABV 125, 32; Paralip. 51, 32; Hoffmann, Ten Centuries,fig. 166:a-e). 112ABV 120-123; Paralip. 49-50. 113 Compare,e.g., his namepiece(ABV 121,7; Paralip. 49,7) with Florence 70995 (ABV 110, 32; Paralip. 44, 32; Tiverios,
pis. 22, 23) or Brunswick241 (ABV 122,21) with the hydria in Berlin (ABV 108, 15; Tiverios, pls. 4:/, 5). 14 For Exekias himself, cf. ABV 143-146; Paralip. 59-61; M. B. Moore, AJA 84, 1980, pp. 417-434, with bibliography since Paralipomenaappeared.
POTTERS AND PAINTERS
87
Group E and the Lysippides Painter So far, no vase found in the Agora proper has been attributedto Exekias himself or even to his manner. The painters of Group E, who form the backgroundfor Exekias and to whose vases his early work is closely related, are representedby only two vases, 74 (PI. 9), a panel amphora attributedby Beazley, and 632 (PI. 60), a shoulderedhydria addedhere.115The representationof the Birth of Athena on 74 was probably similar to the one on Berlin 1699, and the frontal chariot without flanking figures on 632 is a favorite subject among painters of Group E.116None of the painters around Group E and Exekias, such as the Painter of the Vatican Mourner, the Towry Whyte Painter, or the Painter of London B 174, seems to appear in the Agora black figure.117 Neither are there any vases by Exekias' follower and pupil, the Lysippides Painter, although two panel amphorae in his manner, 86 and 87 (PI. 10), are attributed here. All this may be purely fortuitous, but it may also indicate that these painters worked for clients outside the Agora. The provenancesof many of their vases are known, and, as is to be expected, the greatest number of them were found in Etruscan Italy, chiefly at Vulci and Cervetri.But of those found in Greece, it is perhaps worth noting that almost all seem to come from dedicatoryor funerarycontexts, in particular the Akropolisand the Kerameikos.118 While any results drawn from such observationsmust be used with extreme caution, they may, however, reflect economicfactors influencing the Athenian ceramicindustry. Amasis Painter With the Amasis Painter we are more fortunate,for three vases from the Agora are attributedto him, and two others may be by him. Amasis signs as potter only, whence the painter takes his name.119The Amasis Painter's career spans at least four decades,beginning in the second quarter of the 6th century and lasting until ca. 520 B.C. or slightly later.120Well over 130 of his vases have survived.The Amasis Painter decoratesa wide variety of shapes ranging in size from very small to quite large and including some that are rare.121His early work has its greatestkinship with painters of Siana cups, particularlythe Heidelberg Painter and to a certain extent with Kleitias, especially with regard to his precise drawing and attention to ornamentaldetails.1221257 (P1. 88), the earliest Attic black-figuredalabastron,is one of the Amasis Painter's very early works. The generous amount of space between the figures suggests that it predates slightly another of his small vases, the exquisite aryballos in New York.123Here, too, the figures are loosely grouped, but they are closer together, and there is more overlapping.An ornamentallink between the two vases is the step pattern above the figures on 1257, which reappearson top of the mouth of the aryballosbut is rare elsewhere.124 115
For Group E, cf. ABV 133-138; Paralip. 54-57. Berlin 1699 (ABV 136, 53; Paralip. 55, 53); for examples of frontal chariots, cf. New York, M.M.A. 56.171.12 (ABV 134, 22; Paralip. 55, 22) or Munich 1380 (ABV 135, 34). 117 I.e., those painters on pp. 138-143 of ABVand pp. 57-59 of Paralip. 118 A tabulation of the Greek findspotsfor these painters may be of interest. Group E: Copenhagen, inv. no. 7068 (ABV 134, 14), from Thebes accordingto the vendor (C. Blinckenbergand K. Friis Johansen in CVA, Copenhagen 3 [Denmark 3], p. 83); Akropolis 821 (ABV 136, 51); Akropolis 789 (ABV 137, 64); Akropolis 790 (ABV 137, 65); Kerameikos,inv. no. 1682 (ABV 137, 66; Paralip. 55, 66); Akropolis 649 and 650 (ABV 137, 67); Akropolis 648 (ABV 137, 68); Kerameikosn.n. (ABV 138, 70). Near Group E: three loutrophoroi in the Kerameikos (ABV 139, 13-15). Exekias: Agora, North Slope A-P 1044 (ABV 145, 19; Paralip. 60, 19); Berlin 1811-1826, from Athens (ABV 146, 22; Paralip. 60, 22); Athens, N.M. 2414116
2417 (ABV 146, 23; Paralip. 60, 23); Brauron, from Myrrhinous (Paralip. 61); Athens, N.M. 1044 (ABV 147, 5), from Corinth (CC 692). Manner of Exekias: Akropolis 853 (ABV 147, 7); Akropolis 926 (ABV 147, 8); Athens, N.M., from Pharsalos (ABV 148, 9); Akropolis 647 (ABV 148, 10). So far, the work of the Lysippides Painter has not been found in mainland Greece. 119 ABV 150-158; Paralip. 62-67; Bothmer,AmasisPainter, passim. On his name, cf. J. Boardman,JHS 78, 1958, pp. 1-3. 120 For the range in time, cf. Bothmer,AmasisPainter, p. 239. 121 The varietyin shape of the signedvases is also large. For a list, cf. footnote 11 above, p. 44. All these are mature or late works. 122 S. Karouzou (Amasis Painter, p. 28) suggests that the Amasis Painter may have been a pupil of Kleitias. 123New York, M.M.A. 62.11.11 (Paralip. 66-67; Bothmer, Amasis Painter, pp. 194-197, cat. no. 52). 124 Later it appears on two lekythoi: London, B.M. B 548
88
POTTERS AND PAINTERS
The middle and late works of the Amasis Painter, to which 95 (PI. 11) and 681 (PI. 66) belong, are contemporarywith vases by the painters of Group E, Lydos, and Exekias, but he seems not to be influencedby these artists. The drawing of the Amasis Painter lacksthe vigor and expressiveness of Exekias and Lydos, but always it is delicate and sure, the ornamentalpatternsclear and precise, and the relationshipbetween shape and decorationwell understood.The Amasis Painter's compositions are generally less ambitious than those by Exekias, and sometimesthey may be rather repetitious, but they are never dull. Occasionally,he paints subjectsthat are quite rare, such as Achilleus receiving his armor, horse taming, boisterous satyrs making wine, or the stable of Poseidon, which seems to be unique.'25If the illustration on 681 is mythological,it may representDionysos and Ikarios or Dionysos and Oinopion, both unusual subjects. Two other Agora fragmentsfrom this period may be by the Amasis Painter. 779 (P1.73), a small fragmentof an olpe or an oinochoe,was attributedby H. R. W. Smith. Very little remains,and it is difficultto be certain of the attribution,but if it is by the painter, it is one of his slighter pieces. Of more interest is 1753 (P1. 113), which comes from an eye-cup. It shows part of an eye and on the right the back of a woman's head and neck. Her flesh is reserved,which finds good parallels in the best work of the Amasis Painter, and the careful incision comparesfavorably,yet an attributionis not completelycertain. Painter of Berlin 1686, Swing Painter, Painter of Munich 1410 Other pot painters contemporarywith Exekias and the Amasis Painter are representedin the black figure from the Agora. 73 (PI. 9), a fragmentof a panel amphora,recallsthe Painterof Berlin 1686, whose slightly more than two dozen vases consist mainly of one-piece amphorae and neckamphorae, although he may have decorateda hydria.'26 The quality of his work is about equal to that of the painters around Group E. He paints several differentmythologicalthemes and has also left us two unusual representations,a feast in honor of Athena, which appears on his namepiece, and a chorus of "knights"on another amphorain Berlin.'2773 probablyshowed a fight flankedby spectators,similar to one by the painter himself, once in the Basel Market.'28 A younger contemporaryof the Painter of Berlin 1686 is the Swing Painter who takes his name from the amphora in Boston that shows a girl on a swing.'29His known output numberswell over one hundred vases, most of which are panel amphoraeand neck-amphorae,but he has also left us hydriai, Panathenaic amphorae, a loutrophoros,and perhaps also a column-kraterand a lebes.130 The quality of his work varies considerably,from well-planned compositionswith carefullydrawn (ABV 154, 58; Bothmer, Amasis Painter, pp. 188-189, cat. no. 49) and Montclair (N.J.), Dusenbery (ABV 155, 59; Paralip. 64, 59; Bothmer,Amasis Painter, pp. 190-191, cat. no. 50). 125 Achilleus receivingarmor:Boston 01.8027 (ABV 152, 27; Paralip. 63, 27; CVA, Boston 1 [USA 14], pl. 27 [649]:2;Bothmer, Amasis Painter, pp. 134-137, cat. no. 25). Horse taming: Leningrad, inv. no. 161 (ABV 151, 15; Paralip. 63, 15; Bothmer, Amasis Painter, p. 195, fig. 102) and New York, M.M.A. 62.11.11 (footnote 123 above, p. 87). Satyrs making wine: Wirzburg 265 (ABV 151, 22; Paralip. 63, 22; Bothmer, Amasis Painter, pp. 113-117, cat. no. 19) and Basel (Paralip. 65; Bothmer,Amasis Painter, p. 46, fig. 40:a), and also Kavala 983 a (Paralip. 65; Bothmer, Amasis Painter, p. 116, fig. 70) and the new fragment found at Samos (AA [JdI 95], 1980, p. 341, fig. 7; Bothmer,Amasis Painter, p. 116, fig. 71). Stable of Poseidon: King's Point, Schimmel (Paralip. 67; Bothmer, Amasis Painter, pp. 217-220, cat. no. 60). 126ABV 296-297; Paralip. 128-129. For a hydria that should be by him, cf. LouvreC 10651 (CVA, Louvre 11 [France
18], pl. 135 [808]). Compare with this: London, B.M. B 197 (ABV 296, 1; Paralip. 128, 1); Orvieto, Faina 73 (ABV 296, 2; Paralip. 128, 2); and Munich 1375 (ABV 297, 15). 127 Berlin 1686 (ABV 296, 4; Paralip. 128, 4); Berlin 1697 (ABV 297, 17; Paralip. 128, 17). 128
129
Paralip. 129, 14 bis.
Boston, M.F.A. 98.918 (ABV 306, 41; Paralip. 132, 41; CVA, Boston 1 [USA 14], pl. 4 [626]:2; Bohr, Schaukelmaler, pls. 64:1 and 191:e). For the rest of the painter'swork, cf. AB V 304-310; Paralip. 132-135. For a comprehensivemonograph, cf. Bohr, Schaukelmaler. 130 For the column-krater, cf. Leningrad 1524 (St. 55), judged by Beazley as "probablyby the Swing Painter" (ABV 310; Bohr, Schaukelmaler,pl. 144). The lebes is an unpublished fragmentin the Vlasto collectionknown to us from Bothmer's photograph. It depicts the departureof a chariot and in style compares best with these: Vatican G 36 (ABV 304, 1; Bohr, Schaukelmaler,pl. 1); Boston, M.F.A. 89.257 (ABV304, 2; CVA, Boston 1 [USA 14], pl. 3 [625]:1;B6hr, Schaukelmaler,
POTTERS AND PAINTERS
89
figures to those that have a rough and ready character.Three vases by the Swing Painter have been found in the Agora. 77 (PI. 9), a panel amphora, preserves part of a satyr, very likely one that accompaniedDionysos, and it belongs with his other amphoraethat have abovethe panel the same inverted lotus-bud frieze with thick links.'31190 (PI. 23), a neck-amphora,shows a wedded pair, presumably in a chariot (given their high position on the vase), a subject that does not seem to appear again in the work of the Swing Painter. In style, it seems to comparefavorablywith some of his early vases such as one of the amphoraein Boston.32 1883 (P1. 120), a closedvase of uncertain shape, is slightly later. It preserves part of Herakles and the Lion, probablyconfronted,with the lion's head turned around. This scheme offers a variant of the compositionused elsewhere by the Swing Painter, for these have either the hero and beast completelyfacing, or each moving to right with the head of the lion turned around.133183 (PI. 22), a neck-amphoraof Panathenaic shape, may be comparedwith the Swing Painter, and is probably contemporarywith his psykter-neckamphora in Boston where the garmentsof several figureshave the same pattern as Athena's peplos on 183.134 A vigorous artist near the Swing Painter is the Painter of Munich 1410 who has left us scarcelya dozen vases but each one of high quality.135His panel amphorafrom the Agora, 82 (PI. 10), shows a mounted squire and a warrior dismounting. The next painters to be discussed, Nikosthenes, the Antimenes Painter, and Psiax, are contemporary with the first generationof Attic red-figureartists. Nikosthenes The signature of the potter Nikosthenes appears on nearly one hundred vases, far more frequently than that of any other artist, and his workshop producedmany differentkinds of vases, in Productsby Nikosthenes were mostly exported particular its own special type of neck-amphora.136 to Etruria, as the known provenances indicate; thus, very few of his vases have been found in Athens.'37In view of this, it is not surprising that only one by him, 1752, a fragmentaryfoot of a Droop cup with the first four letters of his name painted on the underside,has been found in the Agora. The painters of the Nicosthenic workshop stand somewhat apart from the mainstreamof pl. 2); and Boston, M.F.A. 00.331 (ABV 307, 62; CVA, Boston 1 [USA 14], pls. 33-35 [655-657]; B6hr, Schaukelmaler, pls. 132-135). 131 E.g., Vatican G 37 (ABV 305, 13; Bohr, Schaukelmaler, pi. 22); Conservatori 6 (72) (ABV 305, 17; Paralip. 132, 17; Bohr, Schaukelmaler,pl. 31); New York, David Rockefeller (ABV 306, 40; Paralip. 132, 40; Bohr, Schaukelmaler,pl. 48). These are without dots in the top interstices.For two with dots, cf. New York, M.M.A. 41.162.184 (ABV 305, 22; Paralip. 132, 22; Bohr, Schaukelmaler,pi. 41); Orvieto, Faina 52 (ABV 306, 31; Bohr, Schaukelmaler,pl. 7). It is uncertainif 77 (PI. 9) had dots. 132 Boston, M.F.A. 89.257 (ABV 304, 2; CVA, Boston 1 [USA 14], pl. 3 [625]:1; Bohr, Schaukelmaler,pi. 2). 133For the two completely facing, cf. Naples, N.M. 2503 (ABV 305, 26; B6hr, Schaukelmaler,pl. 6) and Munich 1395 (ABV 305, 24; Bohr, Schaukelmaler,pl. 34); for the two moving to right, the lion's head turned around, cf. Berlin 1693 (ABV 305, 25; Bohr, Schaukelmaler,pl. 24). To judge from Jahn's description of Munich 1559 (ABV 308, 75), unpublished and destroyed in World War II, the composition of Herakles and the Lion may have been similar to 1883 (PI. 120). 134 Boston, M.F.A. 00.331 (ABV 307, 62; CVA, Boston 1
[USA 14], pls. 33-35 [655-657]; Bohr, Schaukelmaler, pls. 132-135). 135 ABV
311; Paralip. 135.
Cf. ABV 216-235; Paralip. 104-109; ARV2 122-123. For his white-ground work, cf. Mertens, Attic White Ground, pp. 31-33; for his kyathoi, cf. M. Eisman, Attic KyathoiPainters, diss. University of Pennsylvania1971 (availableUniversity Microfilms International,no. 72-17,345), pp. 54-76. 137 All are very fragmentary. Cf. two Little-Master cups: Akropolis 1748 (ABV 230, 2) and Akropolis 1746 (ABV 230, 3); two other cups of uncertaintype: Akropolis 1749 (ABV 232, 17) and Akropolis 1747 (ABV 232, 18); four skyphoi of Corinthian type: Akropolis 1409 (ABV 233, 1), Akropolis 1411 (ABV 233, 2), Akropolis n.n. (ABV 233, 3), and Akropolis 1410 (ABV 234); two lids or the like: Akropolis 1296 (ABV 234) and Akropolis 1297 (ABV 234); and a fragment of uncertain shape: Akropolis 1408a (ABV 234). In addition, an unsigned plate, Akropolis 2414 (ABV 233), has been connected with Nikosthenes on the basis of its similarity to a signed cup Type A, Louvre F 123 (ABV 231, 8; Paralip. 109, 8; Callipolitis-Feytmans, Les plats attiques, p. 305, no. A I, 51, pi. 9 and fig. 14). 136
POTTERS AND PAINTERS
90
Attic black figure, although recently Psiax has been connectedwith Nikosthenes, chiefly through his use of white ground.138The career of Nikosthenes begins early in the third quarter of the 6th century, as indicated by his signed cup in Oxford that is decoratedby Lydos,139and from the evidence of other signed vases, a kyathos painted by Oltos, a cup and a kantharosby Epiktetos,'40he continues to work until roughly 515-510 B.C.His name appears on vases decorated in a wide varietyof techniques:black figure, red figure, bilingual, white ground,and Six's technique.And the subjectsdecoratinghis vases are equally varied. AntimenesPainter The Antimenes Painter, who takes his name from a hydria in Leyden that praisesAntimenes,141 is one of the chief painters of standard neck-amphoraeand hydriai, but he also decoratedpanel amphorae,calyx-kraters,psykters,includingone signed by Nikosthenes,and a dinos.'42His career begins about 530 B.C.and lasts for approximatelytwo decades.The Antimenes Painter may have been a pupil of Lydos,'43for the massiveness and the proportions of his figures bear a certain relationshipto the older artist, but there is less incision, less interestin patternand texture, and less overlapping of figures than in the work of Lydos. In the Agora black figure, only 89 (P1. 10), a panel amphora with Herakles, one of the painter's favorite subjects,is by the Antimenes Painter himself. 90 (P1. 11), another panel amphora,preservespart of the Birth of Athena that in composition is closest to one by the Antimenes Painter and thus may be by his hand, but so little remains that it is difficultto be certain. 361 (PI. 35) is by the painter or in his manner. Psiax Although the Antimenes Painter is contemporarywith the earliest red-figure artists, so far no vase in the new technique has been attributedto him. This is not the case with Psiax, the "brother" of the Antimenes Painter,144who signed two red-figuredalabastrathat also bear the signature of the potter Hilinos.145Psiax worked for at least two other potters, as the vases signed by Andokides and Menon attest.146Although the style of Psiax shares many similarities with that of the Antimenes Painter, particularlyon his larger black-figuredvases,147he is a more experimentalartist, and his style is more refined, more ornamental. He also decorates a greater variety of shapes, particularlysmall ones, than the Antimenes Painter. But the most importantdistinctionis Psiax's use of varioustechniques in innovativeways. Besides decoratingvases completelyin black figure or 138
Cf. J. Mertens, AK 22, 1979, pp. 27-30. Oxford 1966.768 (ABV 113, 80; 229; Paralip. 45, 80; 108; Tiverios, pl. 47:/8, y); also the amphora by Lydos in Nikosia, C 440 (ABV 109, 28; 229; Paralip. 44, 28; Tiverios, pls. 25:y, 26:a) has the same shape as the one in the Villa Giulia signedby Nikosthenes (ABV 229). 140 Oltos: Florence 2 B 11 (ARV2 54, 8). Epiktetos:Wiirzburg 468 (ARV2 45, 105 and 71, 8) and Odessa (ARV2 77, 87; G. Sokolov,AntiqueArt on the Northern Black Sea Coast,Leningrad 1974, p. 26, figs. 5, 6). 141 Leyden PC 63 (ABV 266, 1; Paralip. 117, 1; CVA, Leiden 1 [Netherlands 3], pls. 13-16 [107-110]:3). 142 For the painter himself, cf. ABV 266-275; Paralip. 117121; M. B. Moore, Metropolitan Museum Journal 18, 1984, pp. 29-38, esp. pp. 34-38; for his use of white ground, cf. Mertens, Attic WhiteGround,pp. 40-43; for the psyktersigned by Nikosthenes, cf. footnote 2 bis above, p. 20. 143Beazley, Development, p. 79. 144 For Psiax as the "brother"of the Antimenes Painter, cf. 139
Beazley, Development,p. 79; AB V 292. 145Karlsruhe 242 (ARV2 7, 4; Paralip. 321, 4); Odessa (AR V2 7, 5). For the rest of his work, cf. ABV 292-295; Paralip. 127-128; ARV2 6-9; Paralip. 321. For his bilingual work, cf. B. Cohen, Attic Bilingual Vases and their Painters, New York 1978, pp. 195-239; for his black-figuredplates, cf. Callipolitis-Feytmans,Les plats attiques, pp. 376-377; for his kyathoi, cf. Eisman, op. cit. (footnote 136 above, p. 89), esp. pp. 125-174; for his white-ground vases, cf. J. R. Mertens, Attic White Ground, pp. 35-40; also, Kurtz, Athenian White Lekythoi, pp. 9-12; most recently, Mertens, AK 22, 1979, pp. 22-37. 146 Andokides:London, B.M. 1980.11-29.1 ex Castle Ashby, black figure (ABV 293, 7; Paralip. 127, 7; CVA, Castle Ashby [GB 15], pls. 6, 7 [661, 662]:1) and Madrid 11008, bilingual (ABV 294, 24; ARV2 7, 2; Paralip. 321, 2). Menon: Philadelphia 5399 (ARV2 7, 3). 147 Cf. Beazley, Development.pp. 79-80; J. R. Mertens, AK 22, 1979, p. 34.
POTTERS AND PAINTERS
91
in red figure, Psiax has also left us two bilingual amphorae,severalvesselswith the figureson white ground, and one example each of Six's technique and coral red. Most importanthere is his use of white ground, for Psiax is the first artist to decoratea significantnumber of vases in this technique and to cover the entire surface with white slip before drawing the figures.148817 (P1. 75), three fragmentsof a large lekythos, is the earliest preservedexample of the white-groundtechnique from the Agora and may be by Psiax himself, or at least is near him. In any case, it is the only Agora black-figuredvase linked with this artist. A unique feature of 817 is the predella below the main zone, which finds its best parallel on loutrophoroiand funeraryplaques. The drawing seems closest to that on his very fine white-ground plate in Basel.'49 Contemporary with these pot painters just discussed are those who specialize in small vessels, chiefly cups, lekythoi, and skyphoi, and also oinochoai. Although the names of many potters of small vases working between 550 and 520 B.C.are known from their signatures and numerous artists, groups, and classes have been identified,the work of surprisinglyfew has been found in the Agora. Pottersand painters of Little Master, Proto-A,and Type A cups Among the specialists in Little Master cups, the potting signatures of only two are known for certain in the Agora, both on very fragmentaryvessels. 1473 is a skyphos signed by Hermogenes, and 1686 is a lip-cup by Tleson with only part of the signature remaining,150but the restorationis likely. Three others, 1743, 1744 (PI. 112), and 1811 (PI. 116), which may be a Gordion cup, give just part of the verb. None of these has any of the figured decorationleft. The most completely preserved, attributed Little Master cup from the Agora is 1708 (PI. 111), the namepiece of the Painter of Agora P 1241. It is decoratedwith satyrs and maenads, as are his other two band-cups, which comprisethe rest of his known work.15' 1924 (P1. 122) is a small fragmentof a Gordioncup or a Hermogenian skyphosthat recalls the Taleides Painter who, besidessmall vases, also decorates amphoraeand hydriai, the most famous being the hydria in the Louvrewhich is signed by Timagoras as potter and praises Andokides.'52 Other contemporarypainters specialize in a different kind of cup, the Proto-A or Type A. These artists are fewer in number than decoratorsof Little Master cups, but like them none has signed his name to a vase, although one potting signature is preserved.153The work of only one, the Marmaro Painter,'54has been found in the Agora: 1426 (P1.97), the leg of a tripod-plate,with a lively scene of Herakles attackingthree Amazons,a subject also representedon his other vases known to us, two cups. Painters of small lekythoi Around the middle of the 6th century B.C. comes the first of a long series of painterswho specialize in small lekythoi.155Among the earliest are those of the Dolphin Group which gets its name from the two leaping dolphins that often decoratethe shoulder.156Two of their lekythoi, 797 and 798 (P1. 75), the latter a well-preservedexample of the rather rare sub-Deianeira type, have been 148Mertens (Attic WhiteGround,p. 42) makes the point that other contemporaryartists who use white ground, in particular the Antimenes Painter, use it to emphasize structuraldetails of their vases, not to furnish a backgroundfor the decorationas a whole. 149 ABV 294, 21; Paralip. 128, 21; Callipolitis-Feytmans, Les plats attiques, p. 377, no. 5, pl. 73, fig. 60; Mertens, Attic White Ground,pi. 4:1. 150Hermogenes: ABV 164-166; Paralip. 68. Tleson: ABV
179-183; Paralip. 74-76. 151 ABV 191; Paralip. 79. 152 Louvre F 38 (ABV 174, 7; Paralip. 72, 7). 153 Louvre CA 1778, signed by Timenor (ABV 201). 14 ABV 198. '5s ABV, chap. 32. 156 ABL, pp. 14-16, 193-194; ABV 457-459; Paralip. 199200. For the Euboeanaspectof this group, cf. footnote13 above, pp.44-45.
92
POTTERS AND PAINTERS
found in the Agora, as well as a third, 796, which is related.Neither of the two shoulderedlekythoi, 796 and 797, has the dolphins on the shoulder, and all three are connectedwith the group by the style of drawing. Linked with the Dolphin Group but more carelessin executionare the lekythoiof the Fat-runner Group, named after the amply proportionedrunner between spectatorsthat appears on most of them, including 800 (PI. 75) and 801.157802 deviates from the usual composition by showing a sphinx between youths. The same representationappears on Vatican 448, which is near the lekythoi in the Group of Vatican G. 52.158 The painters of the Group of Vatican G. 52 descend from the Painter of Louvre F 6 and those immediately around him.159Nine lekythoi, 805-813 (PI. 75), belongingto the Group of Vatican G. 52 have been found in the Agora. These are small vessels with simple decoration often composed of three standing figures, r one figure in motion between spectators.An upright palmettebetween ivy leaves comprisesthe shoulderdecoration. These painters also decorated amphorae, neck-amphorae,hydriai, and small oinochoai of Shape I. Near the Group of Vatican G. 52 is the North Slope Group, also connected with the Painter of Louvre F 6.160 Small size and hasty drawing characterizetheir work, including60 (P. 8) and 748, a small panel amphoraand a chous. Contemporarybut of somewhathigher quality is 683 (PI. 66), an olpe near the Honolulu Class that shows the departureof a warrior. 1409 (PI. 96), a small, late 6th-centuryplate attributedby Callipolitis-Feytmansto the Workshopof Delos 636, is related to the late work of the Painter of Louvre F 6.161 Groupof the OxfordLid Also of mid-century is the Group of the Oxford Lid, a group of painters who decoratemainly small skyphoi of Corinthian type, although the namepiece and one other are pyxides.162Like the type of skyphos preferredby these painters, their style of drawing is rather old-fashioned,tending toward confrontedpairs of animals or monsters,with rosettesfor filling ornament.Three fragmentary skyphoi from the Agora, 1463-1465 (P1. 99), were attributedby Beazley, and one, 1466, was comparedby him with the group, to which a second, 1467, is addedhere. In the last two decades of the 6th century B.C., the more talented artists turn to the red-figure technique, which gradually becomesthe predominantone, although black figure of high quality is still produced, notably by some of the Antimenean painters, the Priam Painter and the Rycroft Painter, and also painters of the Leagros Group. The work of other, less productiveand less able pot painters helps to round out the picture of large vases decoratedin Attic black figure during this time. Far more numerousand prolificare the painters who specialize in small vessels, in particular lekythoi. Most importantof these are the EdinburghPainter, the Theseus Painter, the Gela Painter, and also painters of the Cock Group and the Phanyllis Group, all of whose work continuesinto the early 5th century B.C. In this period, there are very few signaturesand none in the Agora black figure. Groupof Wurzburg 199 and the Michigan Painter Although a good many pot painters working in the late 6th century are known, very few of their vases have been found in the Agora. One of the earliest is 502 (PI. 47), a calyx-kraterattributedby Beazley to the Group of Wurzburg 199,163which belongs to the circle of the Antimenes Painter. 157 ABL, pp. 16-18; ABV459-460;
'58 ABV 460, 12. 159 ABV 460-462; Paralip. 202-203. 160 ABV 129.
Paralip. 201-202.
161
Callipolitis-Feytmans, Les plats attiques, p. 329, no. 44, pl. 40 and fig. 44. 162 ABV 616-617; Paralip. 306. 163 ABV 287-290; Paralip. 126.
POTTERS AND PAINTERS
93
239 (PI. 28) is a contemporary,prize Panathenaicamphoraattributedhere to the Michigan Painter,164who is the only black-figure artist to decoratemany stamnoi,165a shape known primarily in red figure. Leagros Group The painters of the Leagros Group, which gets its name from the kalos inscriptionon five blackfigured hydriai, produce the last importantblack-figuredpots.166Its 300-odd known vases consist mainly of hydriai and neck-amphorae, the group's favorite shapes, panel amphorae, and a few column-kraters,as well as about 40 lekythoi. Examples of other shapes also appear but are few in number. Significantly, perhaps, the two known examples of volute-kratersin this group, 492 and 493 (PI. 47), are from the Agora. Each is a neck fragment decoratedwith a chariot and warriors. And if our attributionof 505 (PI. 48) is correct,it adds a new shape, the calyx-krater,to the group. 569-573, fragments of cylindrical stands, also a shape hitherto unknown in the Leagros Group, comparebest with several of its vases and are probablyby one of its painters. Five other vases were attributedby Beazley: 197 (P1. 23), a neck-amphora;392 (P1. 38), a pelike; 654 (PI. 62), a hydria; and 818-820 (Pls. 76, 77), three lekythoi. Bold line combined with limited internal incision for anatomy and texture generally characterize the drawing of the Leagros Group painters and emphasize the heroic proportionsof their figures.Violent subjectsillustratedby rugged figureswith vigorous gestures are preferredthemes. Of Leagran characteris the Painter of Munich 1519,167a companionof the Nikoxenos Painter, whose small output is composedof standardneck-amphorae and Panathenaics, 328 (P1. 33) being one of the latter. RycroftPainter and Painter of TarquiniaRC 684 7 Contemporarywith the Leagros Group, but very differentin spirit, is the RycroftPainter, who is related to Psiax.'68He decoratesmainly panel amphoraeand neck-amphoraebut also hydriai, and recently calyx-kratersand column-kratershave been addedto his known output of about 50 vases. 195 (P1.23) is a neck-amphoraattributedby Beazley, to which another, 196 (P1.23), is addedhere. Two other vases, also added here, are new shapes for the painter: 187, a neck-amphoraof Panathenaic shape and 513 (PI. 48), a lebes gamikos.470 (P1.45), a column-krater,is probablyby him, at least to judge by the drawing of the horses. A second lebes, 514 (P1.49), is either by the Rycroft Painter or by his close associate, the Painter of Tarquinia RC 6847,169 and a third, 512 (P1. 48), compares with the reverse of the latter's namepiece. The Rycroft Painter's incision is rather thin and sparse, which suggests a certain influence from red figure. He prefers quiet subjects with stately figures to those with violent action, and when he shows scenes of struggle, his figures never exhibit the same degree of intensity as those of the Leagros Group. Three other attributedpots may be dated in the late 6th centuryB.C. 99 and 100 (P1. 12) probably belong to the Hypobibazon Class, which takes its name from the amphora in the Kerameikosthat shows a warrior about to mount his horse.170This class of amphoraType B has a very thick mouth that gives the vase a slightly top-heavy appearance,and a key pattern to left is the usual ornament above each panel, as on 99 and 100. An oddity of the class is the tongue pattern round the root of 164
ABV 343-344; Paralip. 156-157. B. Philippaki, The Attic Stamnos, Oxford 1967, pp. 1214,22. 166 ABV 354-382; Paralip. 161-167. 167ABV 393-394; Paralip. 173. 168ABV 335-338; Paralip. 148-150; J. R. Mertens, Indiana University Art Museum Bulletin, Bloomington (Ind.) 1979, 165
pp. 6-15; W. G. Moon, "Some New and Little-Known Vases by the Rycroftand Priam Painters,"Greek Vasesin the J. Paul Getty Museum 2, 1985, pp. 41-70. 169 ABV 338; Paralip. 150. 170 Kerameikos,inv. no. 48 (ABV 339, 2). For the rest of the vases of this class, cf. ABV 338-339; Paralip. 150. Bothmer adds a fragmentaryamphora in Stockholm,inv. no. 2228.
94
POTTERS AND PAINTERS
each handle. This ratherspecial shape survivesin red figure.'71100 is unusual for having Panathenaic subjects.Our last pot of this period is 650 (P1.62), a kalpis by the Painter of London B 343.172 EdinburghPainter Stylistically related to the Leagros Group, the Edinburgh Painter is the first artist to decorate many large cylinderlekythoi,'73which becomesthe type preferredby the betterpainters,especially red-figureones. Besides lekythoi, the EdinburghPainter decoratesother shapes, particularlysmall neck-amphorae,e.g. 215, and at least two panel amphorae of standard size are by him.174Two fragmentarycylinder lekythoi, 884 and 885 (Pl. 80), are by him, and a third, 886 (PI. 80), recalls him. 564 (PI. 54), a cylindricalstand with the Judgment of Paris, is by the painteror near him. The EdinburghPainter often coversthe picture surfaceof his lekythoiwith white slip,175but none of his white-groundwork comes from the Agora. He paints a wide varietyof mythologicalsubjects,ranging from such well-known favoritesas Herakles and the Lion to rarerones such as Herakles in the Garden of the Hesperides or Odysseus and the Sirens.176His figures are lively and vigorous, his compositionsclear and rather simple without too much overlappingof figures. TheseusPainter The Edinburgh Painter's cylinder lekythoi lead on to those by the Theseus Painter, an imaginative artist who begins his careerslightly later than the EdinburghPainter and continueswell past 500 B.C.177 He takes his name fromthe subjecton many of his vases, the deeds of Theseus. Although included by Beazley in his section on lekythoi painters in AB V and Paralipomena, the Theseus Painter decoratesmany shapes besides lekythoi'78and actually turns to them only ratherlate in his career.His early work is best understoodfrom his handsomelarge skyphoithat belong to the Heron Class,179and of his works found in the Agora, all but one, 1657 (PI. 107), a shallow cup-skyphos, are skyphoiof this type: 1484-1496 (Pls. 100, 101). 1499 (P1. 102), which may be by him, and 1497 (PI. 102), which recalls him, are also skyphoi of the Heron Class. These take with them 1500, a slightly later Heron Class skyphos by the Painter of Rodin 1000.180The elegant spiral decoration on 1657 reappears on a similarly decoratedcup, 1825 (P1. 117), that may be by the Painter of Nicosia C 975,181a contemporaryof the Theseus Painter. His other two similar cups, the namepiece in Nikosia and one in the Basel Market, are decoratedaccordingto the same principle as the three special cups by the Amasis Painter and thus offer a link with the older artist. Like the Edinburgh Painter, the Theseus Painter illustrates many mythological subjects and in addition also Cf. D. von Bothmer,ArtBull 57, 1975, p. 121. ABV 342; Paralip. 154. 173 ABL, pp. 86-89, 215-221; ABV 476-480; Paralip. 217220; Kurtz, Athenian WhiteLekythoi,pp. 13-14. 174 London, B.M. B 170 (ABL, p. 220, no. 87); Wurzburg 266 (Langlotz, pls. 75, 77), an amphora Type A attributedby Bothmer;perhaps also Boston, M.F.A. 89.256 (Paralip. 115, 4 bis; CVA, Boston 1 [USA 14], pl. 10 [632] and the remarkson p. 7). 175 ABL, p. 89. 176 Normally the Edinburgh Painter shows Herakles and the Lion in the standing position (ABL, p. 88). On the lekythos in the Goulandris Collection (Paralip. 218; C. Doumas and L. Marangou, Exhibition of Ancient Greek Artfrom the N. P. GoulandrisCollection,Athens 1978, p. 288, no. 160), however, he shows the hero holding the beast upside down while he beats it with his club. To a certain extent, the compositionrecalls the one by the AndokidesPainter, which shows Herakles about to 171 172
hurl the lion (London, B.M. B 193: ARV 2 4, 8; Paralip. 320, 8), a scheme which recurson a late 6th-centurygem in Boston, M.F.A. 27.674 (J. Boardman,Archaic Greek Gems, London 1968, pl. 17, no. 254). For Herakles and the Hesperides in the work of the Edinburgh Painter, cf. Gela 125/B (ABL, p. 218, no. 46; Paralip. 217, 46; CVA, Gela 3 [Italy 54], pls. 17 [2394]:3, 4 and 18 [2395]:3, 4); for Odysseus and the Sirens, cf. Athens, N.M. 1130 (ABL, p. 217, no. 27; Paralip. 217, 27). 177 For the Theseus Painter, cf. ABL, pp. 141-147, 249-252; ABV 518-521; Paralip. 255-260; Kurtz, Athenian White Lekythoi, pp. 14-15. For his unusual scene of Herakles leading Lamia, cf. E. Vermeule, "Herakles Brings a Tribute," FestschriftBrommer,pp. 295-301. 178 Cf. the references in footnote 177 above. These include rare shapes like the alabastronand the neck-pelike. 179 For the characteristicsof the group, cf. p. 60 above. 180ABV 521-522. 181 Paralip. 99-100.
POTTERS AND PAINTERS
95
favors representationsof the komos and occasionally of athletes. His figures are amply proportioned and lively; his drawing is sometimesa bit sketchybut nonethelessattains a simple elegance. Gela Painter, Cock Group,and Phanyllis Group Contemporarywith the EdinburghPainter and the Theseus Painter are the Gela Painter and the painters of the Cock and Phanyllis Groups.'82 All of them specialize in lekythoi, and their careers extend beyond the turn of the century. Their types of lekythoi are discussedabove (pp. 45-46), and numerousexamples of them have been found in the Agora:Gela Painter 869-879 (PI. 79); Phanyllis Group: 824-836 (P1. 77); Cock Group: 793 (PI. 75) and 837-863 (P1. 78). The style of these painters never reaches the level achieved by the Edinburgh Painter and the Theseus Painter, although to some extent the Gela Painter shares the interest of these two in unusual subjects and mythologicalrepresentations.More often, their compositions,particularlythose of the Cock Group and the Phanyllis Group, are stock scenes, and their work signals the beginning of mass production of small lekythoi that will play such a significantrole in late Attic black figure. The Agora examples by these painters are for the most part standardproducts.793 (PI. 75), however,given its date in the third quarter of the 6th century,183seems to be a very early example from the Cock Group, and the runners on it are to be associatedwith those of the Fat-runner Group. 822 (P1.77), a white-ground cylinder lekythos, may belong to the Capodimonte Group,184which is contemporarywith the paintersjust discussed. The drawing is similar, and it shares the same rare net pattern below the figures. OtherAttic black-figurepainters The largest number of black-figuredvases from the Agora are small lekythoi of poor quality, most of them belonging to the Class of Athens 581.185They are decoratedby numerous painters that form groups within the class. Many of the namepiecesof these groups come from the Agora, chiefly from a large well found beneath the Stoa of Attalos:the Group of Agora P 24340, 976-989 (PI. 83); of Agora P 24366, 990-993 (PI. 83); of Agora P 24377, 994-1001; of Agora P 24402, 1002-1008 (P1.83); of Agora P 24381, 1011-1014 (P1.83); of Agora P 24486, 1022-1026 (PI. 83); and of Agora P 24327, 1027-1029 (P1. 83). A few others belong to the Kalinderu Group, 10741089 (Pls. 84, 85) and 1113-1115, named after a lekythos in the Kalinderu Museum in Bucharest;186others, 899 (PI. 81), 900 and 1099-1103, belong to the Geron Group which takes its name from the old man who appears on several of them.187Numerous also are lekythoi in the mannerof the Haimon Painter, 1186-1236 (PI. 87).188 Many other painters who specialize in lekythoi are known, but the work of very few has been found in the Agora. There is an epinetronvery likely by the Sappho Painter, 1850 (P1. 118), and three vases near his companion,the Diosphos Painter.189 1160 (P1. 86) and 1161 are lekythoi; 1501 (P1. 102) is a skyphos. Four other lekythoi, 1177-1180 (P1.86), are by the Hound-and-hare Group,190who are companionsof the Sappho Painter and the 182
Gela Painter: ABL, pp. 78-86, 205-215; ABV 473-475; Paralip. 214-216; J. Hemelrijk, BABesch 49, 1974, pp. 117158. Phanyllis Group: ABL, pp. 64-66, 199-205; ABV 463466; Paralip. 206-208. Cock Group:ABL, pp. 67-68,108,109; ABV 466-471; Paralip. 208-212. 183 Compare the shape with those discussed by Haspels in ABL, chap. 2. 184 The association is made here. For the group, cf. Paralip. 214. 185 Above, pp. 46-47. 186 ABV 504, 12. For the work of the rest of the group, cf.
ABV 503-504; Paralip. 243-245. 187 Paralip. 224. 188 ABL, pp. 130-141, 241-249; ABV 539-571; Paralip. 269-287. 189ABL, pp. 94-130, 232-241; ABV 508-511; Paralip. 248250; C. H. E. Haspels, RA, 1972, pp. 103-109. Frel has suggested that the Sappho Painter is but a late phase of the Madrid Painter (J. Frel, "Three Notes on Attic Black Figure in Malibu," Greek Vasesin the J. Paul Getty Museum 1, 1983, p. 35). 190 ABL, pp. 118, 230-231; ABV 514-515; Paralip. 253.
POTTERS AND PAINTERS
96
Diosphos Painter. One lekythos, 1181 (PI. 87), is attributedby Beazley to the Athena Painter, and 759 (Pl. 72), a chous, may be by him.19'Our last lekythos,1237 (Pl. 87), is a white-groundwork by the Pholos Painter who is closely associatedwith the Haimon Painter.192Besidesthe archaeological importanceof these small ubiquitous lekythoi, their chief value lies in the various and sometimes rare subjects that decorate them. Examples from the Agora include Theseus and Prokrousteson 1160, which is near the Diosphos Painter, Theseus fighting a human-headedMinotaur on 1162 (PI. 86), a lekythosof the Little-lion Class, and the Theban Sphinx on 1216 (PI. 87), in the manner of the Haimon Painter. The next group of vases contemporarywith thosejust discussedare skyphoi.Slightly less than 30, 1502-1527 (Pls. 102, 103) and 1531-1533 (PI. 103), are in the mannerof the Haimon Painter, and many more are Haemonian in style. 1536 (P1. 104) is a skyphosby the Painter of Elaious I, whose namepiece in the Louvre comes from Elaious in Thrace.1931780 (P1. 113) and 1830 (PI. 117) are cups by him, and two more skyphoi, 1537 and 1538, are compared.Connectedwith the late vases of the Haimon Group are miniature skyphoi of the Lancut Group, which have their decorationin silhouette.'94Three have been found in the Agora, 1539-1541 (P1. 104), and 1542, a shallow skyphos of Ure's Class K 2, is connected.Akin to the LanicutGroup are the miniature skyphoi of the Lindos Group.195Their decorationis in silhouetteon white groundand is usually a wretchedly drawn figure between palmettes. 1570-1577 (Pls. 104, 105) are examples from the Agora. Contemporarywith the Haemonian skyphoi are those of the CHC Group, which often show a war chariot wheeling around or a courting scene, CHariot-Courting.196These are large skyphoi of the Heron Class decoratedin a sketchy,rough style. 1578-1601 (P1. 105) offer a goodrepresentationof the characteristicsof the group as a whole. Other groups may be connectedwith the CHC Group, including the Pistias Class discussed above.'97Another of these is the Dog Group, which gets its name from the dogs on 1607 (PI. 105) and on another vase from Thebes.1981606 and 1608 also belong to the Dog Group. Four other skyphoi, 1609-1612 (Pls. 105, 106), are attributed to the Group of Ferrara T.800.199 Almost all the attributed late black-figuredcups from the Agora belong to the Leafless Group, named because its painters usually draw branches without leaves.2001761-1765 and 1767-1778 (P1. 113), 1833, and 1834 belong to this group, and severalare attributedto specificpainterswithin the group. 1768 and 1769 (P1. 113) and 1776-1778 (P1. 113) are by the Caylus Painter.2011775 (P1. 113) is by or near the Painter of Oxford 236, and 1773 belongsto the Painter of Oxford 237.202 Several black-figuredplates from the Agora have now been attributedby Callipolitis-Feytmans in her monograph on the shape. Of particular interest are 1414 and 1415 (Pls. 96, 97) by the Kleiboulos Painter who takes his name from the inscribedostrakonfound between the Areopagus and the Hill of the Nymphs.2031414 is a large, handsomeplate with the figured scene, Herakles and Amazons, painted on white ground,set off by the glazed rim. 1397 (PI. 96), also large, is by the Painter of Agora A-P 428, most of whose work consists of plates found on the Akropolis.204His 191ABL, pp. 147-165, 254-262; ABV 522-533; Paralip. 260266.
ABL, pp. 137-139,247-248; ABV 571-572; Paralip. 287. Louvre El. 1 (ABV 575, 5); for the rest of his work, cf. ABV 574-576; Paralip. 289. 194ABV 576-579; Paralip. 289-290. 195 ABV 581-583; Paralip. 290-291. 196 ABV 617-623; Paralip. 306-308. 197 Cf. above, p. 61. 192 193
198 ABV623-624. 199 Paralip. 308-309.
ABV 632-653; Paralip. 310-313. 650-651; Paralip. 313-314. 202 Painter of Oxford 236: ABV 652; Paralip. 314. Painterof Oxford 237: ABV 651-652; Paralip. 314. 203 Cf. above, p. 56. 204 Cf. Callipolitis-Feytmans,Les plats attiques, p. 335. 200
201 ABV
POTTERS AND PAINTERS
97
favoritesubject,as on 1397, is a woman running to right holding a palmette-tendrilornament.The remainder of our attributed plates are small ones. Two have been attributed as follows: 1418 (PI. 97) very likely to the Snake-and-spotsGroup; 1417 (Pl. 97) to the workshop of the Anavysos Painter.205 A few other painters of small black-figuredvases from the Agora remain. 657 (PI. 62) is a small kalpis attributed to the Red-line Painter who is known primarily as a painter of small neckamphorae.206Three other Agora vases are in his manner, a small neck-amphora,209 (PI. 24), and two pelikai, 395 (PI. 38) and 396. Another small kalpis, 658 (PI. 63), is connectedwith him. The Red-line Painter gets his name from the two lines drawn in accessoryred insteadof black glaze that frame the ornamentalpattern below the figures. His style of drawing is often rather careless,as it is on all our vases connectedwith him, but occasionallyhe decoratesfull-size pieces with some care, such as his two Leagran neck-amphorae.207 Near the Red-line Painter is the Painter of the Rhodes Pelike.208737 (PI. 70) is a small oinochoe near him. Another small oinochoe, 754 (PI. 72), is near the Painter of Villa Giulia M. 482, a minor painter of small neck-amphoraeand oinochoai.209665 is a small kalpis by a companion of the Haimon Painter, the Painter of Half Palmettes, whose palmettes used as filling ornamentwithin the picture are cut in half, hence his name.210 A few vases do not find appropriateplaces in the above discussion.Two are signed. One of these is a late 6th-century plate, 1407, signed by the potter Salax, which, besides the inscription,is decorated only with concentriccircles. The second is 226 (PI. 26), an early Panathenaicamphorawith some of Athena's shield, most of the potting verb, and the last two lettersof the name with tracesof a third. Other Panathenaicsfollow. The next is 325 (P1. 33), attributedhere to the Group of Copenhagen 99, whose few known vases are all Panathenaic amphorae.211325 shows parts of two vigorous participantsin a foot race, a favorite subjectof the group. 250 (P1. 28) is a little later and compares with the manner of the Kleophrades Painter,212251 (PI. 28) may be by the painter himself, 252 (Pl. 28) is by the Berlin Painter.213All three show parts of Athena and are probably prize vases. 254 and 255 (PI. 29), attributed here to the Achilles Painter, a pupil of the Berlin Painter, are very likely prize vases, as are his other known Panathenaics.214Six other prize vases from the Agora may be dated in the 5th century.256 (PI. 29) and perhaps 257 (PI. 29) belong to the Robinson Group, named for the three in the Robinson Collection;215259-261 (PI. 30) ought to be from the Kuban Group, which takes its name from the one found in the Kuban and whose other Panathenaics with known provenancesdo not come from Athens;216277 (PI. 31) is probablyby a Nikomachos Series of about the middle of the 4th century B.C.:218 286 (Pl. 31), 291, 293 (PI. 32), and 295.
Snake-and-spots Group: ABV 131-132; CallipolitisFeytmans, Les plats attiques, pp. 385-388. Anavysos Painter: ibid., pp. 388-389. 206 ABV 600-607; Paralip. 300-304. 207 Villa Giulia M. 488 (ABV 603, 64; Paralip. 300, 64); Orvieto, Faina 72 (ABV 604, 65). 208ABV 608; Paralip. 304. 209 ABV 590-591; Paralip. 295-297. 210 ABV 573; Paralip. 287-288. 211 ABV 403; Paralip. 175. 205
212 For his other Panathenaics, cf. ABV 404-406; Paralip. 175-176. 213For his other Panathenaics, cf. ABV 407-409; Paralip. 177. 214 ABV 409; Paralip. 177. 215ABV410. 216ABV 411-412; Paralip. 177. 217 London, B.M. B 604 (ABV 413). For the rest of their Panathenaics,cf. ABV 413-414; Paralip. 177. 218 ABV 414-417; Paralip. 178.
POTTERS AND PAINTERS
98
Our last three vases to be discussed belong to the Swan Group, painters of miniature vessels usually decoratedwith swans often painted upside down.219The decorationis without incision and often rather sloppy. The Agora Swan Group vases are two oinochoai, 732 and 765, five pyxides, 1275 (PI. 90), 1276, 1281, 1287 (PI. 90), and 1294, and a phiale, 1427 (P. 97), all but 732, 765, and 1294 attributedby Beazley. These little vases are difficult,if not impossible,to date on the basis of style. To judge by the shapes, the range in time for the Swan Group is considerable,reaching back perhaps as early as the first half of the 6th centuryB.C. 219
ABV 655-660; Paralip. 315-316.
CATALOGUE ONE-PIECE AMPHORAE
FIG.1. One-pieceamphora1 (P 6155 a) DECORATED ON NECK AND BODY, NOT SET IN PANELS
1-6
P6155a E 14:8 1 Fig. 1;Pl. 1 Neck fragment.Max. dim.0.081. Bandof glazeon inside. Slippedon outside. Sphinx (head)to right.On the right, a siren (someof her backhair,one wavy side lock,partof her breast)to left, with her head turned around. Hanging spirals at top of figure zone. Wheel rosettefor filling ornament.Red: face. White: fillet. Althoughcalleda neck-amphorain ABV, the wall of this fragmentflarestoo muchto comefroma vase of that shape, especiallywhen comparedwith a contemporaryexampleof similar size, such as 138 (PI. 17). The closest parallel in shape, althoughnot in size, to 1 is Aigina 565, a very large early workof the Nettos Painter(ABV 3, 1; Paralip. 1, 1). 0. von Vacano's interpretationof 1 as a male protome cannot be supported (Zur Entstehung und Deutung gemalter seitenansichtiger Kopfbilder auf schwarzfigurigen Vasen des griechischen Festlandes, [Bonn 1973], pp. 15, 34). The composition on 1 probably showed two confronted seated
sphinxes,as on Aigina 565, but with a sirenbetweenthem, her head turned around,similar to the one perchedon a palmettebetweentwo confrontedhorsemenon Kerameikos, inv. no. 658 by the Nettos Painter (ABV 3; Paralip. 1; KerameikosVI, ii, no. 116, pls. 89-91) andthe oneon the lid of his skyphos-krater,Athens,N.M. 16382 (ABV 4; Paralip. 3, 10).
Perhapsalso nearthe Nettos Painter(ABV 7, 3; Paralip. 5,4). Ca. 620-610 B.C.
2
P6155b,c E14:8 Two non-joining fragments. Max. dim. b) 0.078, c) 0.052. Froma vasesimilarto 1 but with clayslightlymore buff in color. Fragmentb givespartof a birdor siren (someof one foot and tail) to right.Fragmentc showspartof a rosetteand on the right,glaze that may be the leg of an animal. Fragment b probably comes from a compositionthat showedtwo confrontedbirdsor sirens. Cf. the two feeding birds on London,B.M. 1874.4-10.1, formerlyA 1531, by
100
CATALOGUE
the Nettos Painter (ABV 3, 2; Paralip. 2, 2). The representationon 2 cannothavebeen feedingbirds,for the tail is in the wrong position:it shouldbe up, not down. Size and shapeof this amphoracomparebestwith thoseof the Nettos Painter;so little of the drawingremainsthat it is difficultto be certainof an attribution,althoughone may comparethe feet of the eagle on the right on Athens,N.M. 16382 (ABV 4; Paralip.3, 10; Karouzou,'Avayvpov7ros,pl. 9). Ca. 620-610 B.C.
P 18524 A 17:1 (U) Two non-joiningfragments.P.H. a) 0.256; max. dim. b) 0.17. Mouth, one handle,part of body (a); lower part of body without figureddecoration(b). A whitish slip covers the reservedparts.Glaze has firedbrownand is abradedin manyplaces. On neck, frieze of incised rosettes.On one side, sphinx with elongatedbody,to right. Incisedrosettesfor filling ornament.On the otherside of the vase very little remains.A small amountof glaze may be partof a tail or an ornament. Red: markingon hindquartersof sphinx, wing bow, and alternatefeathers;rosetteson neck;bandjust below figured decoration,anotherlower down (on b). The internalincision indicatingthe individualleaves of each rosetterecallsthe similarbut neaterincisionin rosettes on the namepieceof the Nettos Painter(ABV 4, 1; Paralip. 2, 6; Karouzou,'Avayvpovoros,pl. 90). Late 7th centuryB.c.
3 P1.1
4 P1.1
P 25417 N7:3
Fragmentof neck with root of one handle. Max. dim. 0.082. On neck,lotus-palmettefestoon.Red:cuffs and frondsof lotuses;heartsand alternatepetalsof palmettes;links. Manner of the Gorgon Painter (Paralip. 8): compare LouvreE 817 by the painterhimself (ABV 9, 7; Paralip.6, 7). The Gorgon Painter'sfragmentsfrom the Olympieion (Paralip.7, 9 ter) are probablyfroma similaramphora. First quarterof the 6th centuryB.C. 5 PI. 1
P 6660 R-V 16-19
Wall fragment.Max. dim. 0.10. Siren(hair,someof breast,wing, tail, legs) to left. Incised rosettes for filling ornament. Red: breast, upper part of wing, baron tail;line at bottomof fragmentat break.White: dots at basesof wing and tail feathers. Comparethe Groupof the DresdenLekanis,particularly for the incision and for the carelessmanner in which the accessoryred is applied:e.g. 1442-1444 (PI. 98) or 1859 (PI. 119). But the drawingis not quitethe same,andthe use of addedwhite doesnot seemto occurin the knownworkof this group. Late firstquarterof the 6th centuryB.C. P 6 Fig. 2;PI. 1 5088 S21:2 Three non-joiningfragmentsof mouth, neck, and body. Max. dim. a) 0.203, b) 0.108, c) 0.061. Mouth is flat on top and has a slightoverhang.Bakir,Sophilos,pl. 79, figs. 154156.
FIG.2. One-pieceamphora6 (P 15088). Scale 1:2 Fragmenta preservespartsof threeanimalfriezes:I) bird or siren (feet) to left; II) feline (hindquarters,tail), eagle, and goat (head, some of neck, one foreleg),all to left; III) goat (hindquarters)and panther to left. Below III, rays. Fragmentb gives part of the mouth and neck: on side of mouth, frieze of rosettes;on neck, lotus-palmettefestoon (partof one palmetteand one lotus).Fragmentc givesmore of the rays abovethe foot. Red:a) ribs, markingson hindquarters;wing bows,baron tail;neckof goatandof panther; two lines above rays; b) heart of palmette;three lines on insidebelowrim, line on outeredgeof rim, line abovelotuspalmettefestoon. For rosetteson the side of the mouth of other one-piece amphorae,cf., e.g., 34 (P1. 5); also Louvre E 817 by the Gorgon Painter (ABV 9, 7; Paralip. 6, 7); New York, private,once Basel, Blochby the CamtarPainter(Paralip. 31, 10; Cat.Sotheby,13-14. July, 1981,no. 243); threeunattributed:LouvreE 816 (CVA,Louvre1 [France1], pl. 1 [31]:3,9); LouvreE 818 (CVA, Louvre1 [France1], pl. 1 [31]:5, 11); OxfordG 128.2 (CVA, Oxford2 [GB 9], pl. 2 [403]:24);New York, Bastis, signed by Andokides(ABV 253; ARV2 1; Paralip. 113). Sophilos(ABV 39, 9). Bakir (Sophilos,pp. 40 and 42), without good reason, demotesour fragmentsto those of a late workshoppiece, standingonly on the peripheryof the workof Sophilos. Ca. 580 B.C. PANELAMPHORAE 7-116
7 P1.2
P17393
M 1:3
Three non-joiningfragments. Max. dim. a) 0.195, b) 0.185, c) 0.08. Mouth and neck (a); body fragments (b, c). Some of the glaze has fired brown on fragmentc. AgoraVIII, p. 97, no. 578, pls. 37, 42. In eachpanel,headof a womanto right,herfacedrawnin outline. Fragmenta gives the crown of one head and the upper right cornerof the panel. Fragmentb (illustrated) showsthe faceandneckof a womanto right,perhapsthe one on fragmenta. Fragmentc comes from the oppositepanel (the glaze misfiredslightly)and preservessome of the hair lying againstthe neck. H. Diepoldersuggestedthat 7 is an earlyworkof the Nettos Painter (Festschriftfiir Carl Weickert,Berlin 1955, pp. 111-120), an attributionrejectedby Brann(AgoraVIII, pp. 97-98) but acceptedby Karouzou ('AvayvpovTros, pp. 131-132, 135) who comparedit with the stand of
ONE-PIECE AMPHORAE Athens,N.M. 16384, a matureworkof the painter(ABV 6; Paralip. 3, 13). Althoughthe similaritiescannotbe denied, the drawingon the standis heavierand less elegantthan on 7 (comparethe drawingof the mouthand chin), andthe two ought to be kept apart. Furthermore, the restrictions imposedby a panel do not seem suited to the style of the Nettos Painter. Ca. 620
B.C.
8 P. 2
P22151
Jll
Fragmentof mouth, neck, and panel. Max. dim. 0.21; p.H. 0.17. White slip on surface. Some of the glaze is abraded. Upper left cornerof panel preservingforepartsof an animal (someof its back,shoulder,and locksof hair alongback and neck)to right. Red:neck. The compositionprobablyshowed two confrontedforeparts, a type of representationknown in Protoattic (cf. Agora VIII, pp. 96-97, no. 573, pl. 36). An early Attic black-figuredexampleoccurson the Eleusisamphoraby the Nettos Painter(ABV 679, 2 bis;Paralip.2, 3), but here the headsare conjoined.8 is one of the veryearliestexamplesof such decorationin a panel. P 27324 S16:1 Max. dim. Wall fragment. 0.058. Animal,perhapsa ram (partof hind leg, andat the break, the end of the tail), to right. Incisedrosettefor filling ornament. Red:dotson rosette. 9
Late 7th century B.C.
10 PI. 2
P 24944 Q13:5 Body fragment. P.H. 0.249; diam. 0.24. Mouth, neck, handle,muchof wall, and all of foot missing.H. A. Thompson, Hesperia25, 1956, p. 58, pl. 16:b. Figureddecorationset in small panels.A, male head and neck with start of snaky body to right. B (not illustrated), feline or sphinx (partof one hind leg, a bit of the tail) seated to right. Red: face and pupil; dots on fillet;two lines below panel that continueroundthe vase. White: cornersof eye, ear, dotson neck;claw. The subjecton 10 does not seem to have exact parallels. Althoughrelatedto the satyr heads on 723 (PI. 69) and to otherhumanforepartsin the mannerof the GorgonPainter (beneaththe handle of two lekythoi:Berlin, inv. no. 3764: ABV 11, 19; Nikosia 1958.iv-233: Paralip. 8, 19 bis; E. Gjerstad,GreekGeometricand ArchaicPotteryfound in Cyprus [Skrifter Utgivna av Svenska Institutet i Athen, XXIV], Stockholm1977, pl. 63:1;two pairedforepartsin a panel:Copenhagen13796:ABV714, 9 bis;Paralip.7, 9 bis; 8), it differsdistinctlyfromthese by continuingto the left as a snakyshapecut off by the edgeof the panel.The othersare truncatedforms.The two on the lekythoihaveveryrounded bottoms;those in Copenhagen,and probably1372 (P1.94) also, are only slightly rounded.As a group, these are very differentin conceptionfromthe simplemale or femaleforepart in a panel that lookslike a figurepassinga windowat shoulderlevel (e.g. Munich 1360:ABV 16, 2; Paralip.9, 2). For humanforepartson black-figuredvasesof all fabrics,
101
cf. 0. von Vacano,op. cit. (under 1). He rightly saw that those in the mannerof the Gorgon Painter, includingthe two unpublishedones on oinochoaiin Taranto and Berlin (ABV 10, 2 and 3), were probablyby one hand, and he thoughtperhaps10 mightbe the firstattemptby this painter to deal with this form (p. 37 and pp. 153-154, note 119). Althoughthe generalstyleof drawingandthe decorativeuse of white recall vases in the mannerof the GorgonPainter, the crosshatchingon the snakypart differsfromthe smooth serpenton the Berlin lekythosand from the scaly part of Nereus on the lekythosin the Louvre (ABV 12, 23), and thereforeit probablyshouldbe kept apart. For redfaces,cf. H. R. W. Smith,TheHearstHydria.An AtticFootnoteto CorinthianHistory[Universityof California Publicationsin Classical ArchaeologyI, 10] Berkeley/Los Angeles1944, p. 270, note 36. Ca. 600
B.C.
11 P. 2
P 14485 G 19
Wall fragmentfrom upper right cornerof panel. Max. dim. 0.092. Horseman(partof mount'sheadand mane)to right.The interruptionin the locksof maneon the far left at the break is partof the rider'shand. Red:all of the head;pupil of eye. The compositionof the horseandriderwas verysimilarto the one galloping to right on the Baltimoreplate by the GorgonPainter(ABV9, 18;Paralip.7, 18);the composition of a mountstandingor walkingdoesnotappearuntilthe late first quarter of the 6th century. An unattributeddinos fragment (London, B.M. B 103.14.2: W. M. F. Petrie, NaukratisII, London1888, pl. 9:7; Baklr,Sophilos,pl. 64, fig. 123) closein styleto Sophilosis oneof the earliest(Baklr attributesthe fragmentto Sophilos).The GorgonPainter's unpublishedfragmentin Hildesheim(ABV 10, 29) showsa riderwith his handin the samepositionas the one on 11. Mannerof the GorgonPainter(ABV 13, 43). Early 6th century B.C.
12 PI. 2
P 12673 P8:5
Mouth,neck,handles,wall to belowhandles.P.H. 0.219; diam.of mouth0.165;est. max. diam.0.272. Missingpieces restoredin plaster.Glazehas misfiredreddishbrownon half of vase. A (illustrated)and B, ram (mostof eachhead,the forelegs and partof bodymissing)to right.Red:necks;two lines below panelsthat continueroundthe vase. Comparethe ram on the GorgonPainter'solpe in Munich, inv. no. 8757 (Paralip. 7, 135). The drawingof the horn,the doubleline forthe shoulder,andthe incisioninside one ear on 12 are particularlycloseto the GorgonPainter's ram,and what remainsof the hindquartersdoesnot seemso far fromit either.The shapeof the Agoravase,exceptfor its broaderpanel,is similarto LouvreC 10620 (ABV9, 9; Paralip. 7, 9), a late workof the painteraccordingto I. Scheibler (Jdl 76, 1961,p. 20). What remainsof the backgroundis void, unusualfor the GorgonPainterbut paralleledon his namepiece,LouvreE 874 (ABV 8, 1; Paralip.6, 1), and on the late amphorain Hanover,inv. no. 1965.13 (Paralip.7, 95;CVA,Hannover1 [Germany34], pl. 5 [1637]:3,4). Ca. 590-580 B.C.
102 13
CATALOGUE P 12526 R 17:3
Completebut for foot and most of handles(the rootsremain). Rest. H. 0.257; diam. 0.194; diam. of mouth0.109. T. L. Shear,Hesperia8, 1939, p. 229, fig. 25; M. Picozzi, StudiMisc. 18, 1971, p. 12, no. 2, pl. 2:2;A. Birchall,JHS 92, 1972, p. 57, U I, 12. A and B, horsehead"fantasticallymannered"(ABV 17, 43). The Horse-headAmphorae(ABV 17, 43). Early 6th century B.C.
14 P1.3
P 290 G 15:3 with the missingpartsreMendedfrommanyfragments storedin plasterand painted.Rest. H. 0.515; max. dim. of body 0.376; at handles 0.39. Restored:half of mouth and neck,lower partsof handles;most of B; all of foot. Someof the glaze has fired red;in places it is abraded.M. Picozzi, StudiMisc. 18, 1971, p. 14, no. 7 and pl. 8; A. Birchall,JHS 92, 1972, p. 54, FIII, 10. A (illustrated)and B, horsehead(missing:A, some of cheek,partof neck;B, all of headbut for partof cheek,much of mane). Red: manes, nostrilon A; two lines below panel that continueroundthe vase. For the red nostril, a rarely seen feature,see the second horsefromthe left on the Nettos Painter'scavalcadekrater, Athens, N.M. 16383 (ABV 7, y; Paralip. 3, 12) and the Horse-head amphora,Athens, N.M. 16402 (Picozzi, op. cit., p. 19, no. 21, pl. 17; Birchall,op. cit., p. 53, F II, 9); also 18 (P1.3), 22, and 408 (P1.40). The Horse-headAmphorae;Relatedto the New YorkAthensHorse-headGroup[Birchall]. Early 6th centuryB.C. 15 PI. 3
P 25352 S-U 19-21
Wall fragment.Max. dim.0.077. M. Picozzi,StudiMisc. 18, 1971, p. 44, no. 86, pl. 64; A. Birchall,JHS 92, 1972, p. 58, U II, 16. Horsehead(top of head with forelockand part of mane). Edgeof panel at right. Red:forelock;mane. The doublelines separatingeach lock of mane are unusual but may be paralleledon two horseheadprotomesby the NettosPainter,Athens,N.M. 16366 (ABV5, 8; Paralip. 4, 19). The Horse-headAmphorae(Paralip.10). Early 6th centuryB.c. 16 P1.3
P 26636 T 18:3
Wall fragmentwith rootof one handleon the right.Max. dim.0.27. Someof the glazefiredbrownish.M. Picozzi,Studi Misc. 18, 1971, p. 16, no. 11, pl. 10;A. Birchall,JHS 92, 1972, p. 59, U II, 19. Horsehead(part of forehead,eye, forelock,and mane). The cheekstrapof the halter passesover the locksof mane, an unusualfeature;the forelockand ear overlapthe edgeof the panel slightly.Red:mane;pupil of eye. The Horse-headAmphorae(Paralip.10). Early 6th century B.C.
17 P1.3
P 18528 A 17:1(U)
Four non-joining fragments. Max. dim. a) 0.314, b) 0.304, c) 0.227; diam.of mouth0.20. Fragmentsa and b are fromthe body,b with one handle;fragmentc givesmost of the other handle;fragmentd preservesabouthalf of the mouth. M. Picozzi, Studi Misc. 18, 1971, p. 16, no. 12, pi. 11;A. Birchall,JHS 92, 1972, p. 53, F II, 5. A (illustrated)and B, horsehead.Fragmenta preserves mostof one horseheadbut for the top of its headand a bit of its mane. Fragmentb gives about the same amountof the other horsehead.Red: manes; irises; dots at junction of cheekstrapand nosebandof halter on b; two lines below panelsthat continuedroundthe vase.White:cornersof eyes. The Horse-headAmphorae(ABV 16, 8); Sub-Groupof Athens903 [Birchall]. Early 6th century B.C.
P 13385 T24:3
18 Pl. 3
Preservedto just below the handles. P.H. as restored 0.224;max. diam.0.303;diam.of mouth0.198. Smallparts of wall restored.M. Picozzi, Studi Misc. 18, 1971, p. 17, no. 13, pl. 12;A. Birchall,JHS 92, 1972, p. 54, F III, 12. A (illustrated)and B, horsehead.Paintedon A: qI
Red:manes,forelocks,insidesof ears, pupils, nostrils;lines framingpanelsat top and sides;line on neckaboveand below attachmentof handles;bandsinsideand outsidelip and one at bottomof exterior.White:dot on halter. For the red nostril,cf. 14. The Horse-headAmphorae(ABV 16, 7); Relatedto the New York-AthensGroup[Birchall]. Early 6th century B.C.
P 26631 U 19 19 Three non-joining fragments of panel. Max. dim. a) 0.045, b) 0.042, c) 0.03. Verypoorglaze. M. Picozzi,Studi Misc. 18, 1971, p. 44, no. 87, pl. 64; A. Birchall,JHS92, 1972, p. 58, U II, 1. Horsehead:fragmenta preservesmost of the face;fragment b gives the base of the neck with the ends of locksof mane;fragmentc shows someof the mane. It is not certain thatthe threefragmentscomefromthe samesideof the vase. Red:mane. The Horse-headAmphorae(Paralip.10). Early 6th century B.C.
P 18529 A 17:1(U) 20 Fournon-joiningfragmentsof panel.Max. dim.a) 0.118, b) 0.124, c) 0.048, d) 0.037. M. Picozzi, Studi Misc. 18, 1971, p. 17, no. 15, pl. 13;A. Birchall,JHS92, 1972,p. 59, U II, 18 (a and b are reversedin the description). A and B, horsehead.Fragmenta preservesmost of the face, some of the