ffirs.fm Page iii Wednesday, March 15, 2006 4:54 PM
Developing Affordable Housing A Practical Guide for Nonprofit Organ...
76 downloads
4879 Views
25MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
ffirs.fm Page iii Wednesday, March 15, 2006 4:54 PM
Developing Affordable Housing A Practical Guide for Nonprofit Organizations Third Edition
Bennett L. Hecht, JD, CPA
John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
ffirs.fm Page ii Wednesday, March 15, 2006 4:54 PM
ffirs.fm Page i Wednesday, March 15, 2006 4:54 PM
Developing Affordable Housing
ffirs.fm Page ii Wednesday, March 15, 2006 4:54 PM
ffirs.fm Page iii Wednesday, March 15, 2006 4:54 PM
Developing Affordable Housing A Practical Guide for Nonprofit Organizations Third Edition
Bennett L. Hecht, JD, CPA
John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
ffirs.fm Page iv Wednesday, March 15, 2006 4:54 PM
This book is printed on acid-free paper. Copyright © 2006 by John Wiley & Sons. All rights reserved. Published by John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Hoboken, New Jersey. Published simultaneously in Canada. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, scanning, or otherwise, except as permitted under Section 107 or 108 of the 1976 United States Copyright Act, without either the prior written permission of the Publisher, or authorization through payment of the appropriate per-copy fee to the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, 978-750-8400, fax 978-646-8600, or on the web at www.copyright.com. Requests to the Publisher for permission should be addressed to the Permissions Department, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 111 River Street, Hoboken, NJ 07030, 201-748-6011, fax 201-748-6008, or online at http://www.wiley.com/go/ permissions. Limit of Liability/Disclaimer of Warranty: While the publisher and author have used their best efforts in preparing this book, they make no representations or warranties with respect to the accuracy or completeness of the contents of this book and specifically disclaim any implied warranties of merchantability or fitness for a particular purpose. No warranty may be created or extended by sales representatives or written sales materials. The advice and strategies contained herein may not be suitable for your situation. You should consult with a professional where appropriate. Neither the publisher nor author shall be liable for any loss of profit or any other commercial damages, including but not limited to special, incidental, consequential, or other damages. For general information on our other products and services, or technical support, please contact our Customer Care Department within the United States at 800-762-2974, outside the United States at 317-572-3993 or fax 317-572-4002. Wiley also publishes its books in a variety of electronic formats. Some content that appears in print may not be available in electronic books. For more information about Wiley products, visit our Web site at http://www.wiley.com. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data: Hecht, Bennett L., 1959Developing affordable housing : a practical guide for nonprofit organizations / Bennett L. Hecht.—3rd ed. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN-13: *978-0-471-74346-0 (cloth) ISBN-10: 0-471-74346-1 (cloth) 1. Housing development—United States—Handbooks, manuals, etc. 2. Housing rehabilitation—United States—Handbooks, manuals, etc. 3. Housing management—United States—Handbooks, manuals, etc. 4. Nonprofit organizations—United States—Handbooks, manuals, etc. I. Title. HD259.H43 2006 333.73'150973—dc22 2005058121 Printed in the United States of America 10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
ffirs.fm Page v Wednesday, March 15, 2006 4:54 PM
To Lynn, Eliza, and Sam
ffirs.fm Page vi Wednesday, March 15, 2006 4:54 PM
ftoc.fm Page xvii Wednesday, March 15, 2006 4:26 PM
Contents PART ONE
GETTING STARTED
1
Chapter 1 Developing Affordable Housing in the Twenty-First Century 3 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5
Introduction The Current State of America’s Affordable Rental Housing The State of America’s Working Poor Seeking Affordable Housing Current Trends in Affordable Housing Unique Opportunities for Nonprofit Organizations: Rental and Homeownership
3 4 4 6 10
Chapter 2 The Real Estate Development Process for Nonprofit Organizations: An Overview 2.1 2.2 2.3
Nonprofit Organizations and the Real Estate Development Process An Overview of the Real Estate Development Process Addressing the Specific Needs of a Community and a Specific Project Site
Chapter 3 Establishing the Development Team 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.6 3.7 3.8 3.9 3.10 3.11 3.12
In General The Sponsor The Financial Development Specialist Attorneys Accountant/Bookkeeper Architect Property Management Company General Contractor Construction Manager Community Organizer Appraiser Conflicts, Multiple Roles, and Oversight
13 13 14 17 19 19 20 20 21 25 26 28 29 29 29 31 32
ftoc.fm Page xviii Wednesday, March 15, 2006 4:26 PM
CONTENTS
PART TWO PROJECTING COSTS, INCOME, AND EXPENSES
33
Chapter 4 Project Feasibility and Total Development Costs
35
4.1 Project Feasibility Defined 4.2 Determining Preliminary Project Feasibility 4.3 Estimating Total Development Costs Appendix 4A Sample Letter of Value
35 36 36 60
Appendix 4B Summary of Key Federal Regulations Governing Underground Storage Tanks
63
Appendix 4C Summary of Relevant Laws and Regulations Governing Lead-Based Paint
66
Chapter 5 Determining Projected Income and Expenses 5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4
Introduction Projecting Income—Generally Identifying Targeted Income Levels Determining Affordability as a Percentage of Income and Market Rents 5.5 Income from Nonresidential Use 5.6 Projecting Expenses—Generally 5.7 Evaluating Past Operating Expenses 5.8 Projecting Expenses Where No Operating History Exists 5.9 Allowances and Reserves 5.10 The Role of Lenders Appendix 5A Controllability of Expenses
PART THREE
RAISING CAPITAL
6.1 Introduction 6.2 Sources of Capital—Generally 6.3 Loans 6.4 Grants 6.5 Equity and Sales Proceeds Appendix 6A Example of an Amortizing Loan Appendix 6B Example of a Nonamortizing Loan
Chapter 7 Sources of Capital: Loans
xviii
71 74 74 75 77 80 83 84
87 87 88 88 102 103 105 106 107
Who are Possible Lenders? Sources of Loan Funds from Public Lenders—Generally Sources of Loans from State and Local Governments 䡲
69 70 70
85
Chapter 6 Raising Capital to Meet Total Development Costs
7.1 7.2 7.3
69
䡲
107 107 108
ftoc.fm Page xix Wednesday, March 15, 2006 4:26 PM
CONTENTS
7.4 Sources of Loans from the Federal Government 7.5 Sources of Loan Funds from Private For-Profit Entities 7.6 Sources of Loan Funds from Private Nonprofit Entities Appendix 7A 501(c)(3) Bond Terminology Appendix 7B List of Local CDFI Organizations Financing Housing
Chapter 8 Sources of Capital: Grants 8.1 8.2 8.3 8.4
225
Grants from the Federal Government Grants from State and Local Governments Grants from Private Nonprofit Foundations Grants from For-Profit Corporations
Chapter 9 Sources of Capital: Equity
Appendix 9B Partial Listing of Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Tax Syndicators
Chapter 10 Sources of Capital: Public Housing Funds
10.2 10.3 10.4 10.5 10.6
225 236 236 244 245
9.1 Creation of an Equity Fund for Housing Development 9.2 Use of the Low-Income Housing Tax Credit 9.3 Other Equity Sources Appendix 9A Tax Credit Information Resources List of State and Regional Tax Credit Equity Funds
10.1
128 138 149 218 219
How Public Housing Resources Contribute to Affordable Housing Mixing Public Housing Capital with other Capital: Mixed Finance Uses of Public Housing Funds in Mixed-Finance Transactions Considerations in Mixing Public Housing Development Funds with other Sources of Affordable Housing Funds Elements of Public Housing Development Transactions Conclusion
245 246 259 266 275 279 280 286 288 293 298 313
PART FOUR ENHANCING FEASIBILITY AND PACKAGING THE PROJECT
315
Chapter 11 Enhancing the Feasibility of an Affordable Housing Project 11.1 11.2 11.3 11.4 11.5
317
Increasing Access to Capital—Credit Enhancement Increasing Access to Capital—Loan Sales on Secondary Market Reducing Total Development Costs Increasing Income Reducing Operating Expenses 䡲
xix
䡲
318 325 344 349 360
ftoc.fm Page xx Wednesday, March 15, 2006 4:26 PM
CONTENTS
Chapter 12 Developing the Project Feasibility Report: Six Case Studies
363
12.1 Introduction 12.2 The Feasibility Report and Financial Pro Formas 12.3 The Development of Affordable Housing: Six Case Studies 12.4 Conclusion Appendix 12A The Whitelaw Reference Information
363 364 368 384 385
Appendix 12B
397
Friendship Court Reference Information
Appendix 12C Garden Terrace Reference Information
399
Appendix 12D The View Reference Information
406
Appendix 12E
Kentucky Mountain Housing Reference Information
415
Appendix 12F
Lease-Purchase Reference Information
420
PART FIVE
PURCHASING AND DEVELOPING THE PROPERTY
427
Chapter 13 Securing Site Control over the Property: Signing the Option or Purchase Agreement
429
13.1 Introduction 13.2 Site Control Must Be Secured in Writing 13.3 The Use of Purchase Contracts 13.4 The Use of Options Appendix 13A Documents Pertaining to Purchase Contracts
429 429 430 444 448
Appendix 13B
457
Documents Pertaining to Option Agreements
Chapter 14 Prepurchase Considerations 14.1 14.2 14.3 14.4 14.5
Introduction Applying for Financing and Operating Subsidies Determining the Ownership Entity—Generally Determining the Ownership Entity—Corporations Determining the Ownership Entity—Partnerships 14.6 Determining the Ownership Entity—Factors 14.7 Establishing the Ownership Entity: Divided Ownership and Leasehold Interests 14.8 Interviewing and Selecting the Management Company 14.9 Developing Plans for Renting or Selling Units Appendix 14A Monthly Management Reports
Chapter 15 Partnerships and Joint Ventures 15.1 15.2 15.3
Issues Concerning Organization’s Tax-Exempt Status Options for Structuring the Relationship Partnerships and the Use of the Low Income Housing Tax Credit 䡲
xx
䡲
465 465 465 466 466 468 470 476 477 478 483 503 503 510 518
ftoc.fm Page xxi Wednesday, March 15, 2006 4:26 PM
CONTENTS
Appendix 15A
Joint Venture Checklist
523
In General Board Involvement Day-to-Day Management
523 524 525
Chapter 16 Purchasing the Property: Settling on Acquisition
527
16.1 The Settlement Process—Generally 16.2 The Role of the Settlement Agent 16.3 Title Insurance 16.4 Selecting the Settlement Agent 16.5 Preparing for Settlement 16.6 Settlement 16.7 Postsettlement 16.8 Lender Requirements 16.9 Governmental Regulations Appendix 16A Settlement Checklist and Sample Documents
527 527 528 529 531 533 537 538 539 541
Chapter 17 Constructing or Rehabilitating the Property: Settling on the Construction Loan and Surviving the Construction Process 17.1 17.2 17.3
Introduction Settling on the Construction Loan The Construction Process—The Participants and Their Responsibilities 17.4 Technology in 21st Century Affordable Housing Construction and Rehabilitation 17.5 Negotiating the Construction Contract and Bidding 17.6 Elements of the Construction Contract 17.7 Rehabilitating an Occupied Property 17.8 Completion of Construction Appendix 17A Construction Process Checklist and Sample Contractor Agreements
Chapter 18 Selective Rehabilitation 18.1 18.2 18.3 18.4 18.5 18.6
xxi
553 554 555 575 577 593 602 603 605 665
Overview Introduction to Selective Rehabilitation Managing Selective Rehabilitation: Formal Versus Informal Approaches Implementing a Formal Approach to Selective Rehabilitation: The Rehabilitation Specialist Choosing A Property for Selective Rehabilitation: Building Inspection Techniques of Rehab Specialists Conceptualizing the Project: Rehabilitation Standards 䡲
553
䡲
666 666 673 675 676 678
ftoc.fm Page xxii Wednesday, March 15, 2006 4:26 PM
CONTENTS
18.7 18.8 18.9 18.10 18.11 18.12
Designing the Project: Work Write-Ups and Cost Estimates Computerized Specification-Writing and Estimating Systems Defining Methods and Materials: Performance Specifications Selective Rehabilitation and Construction Management Selective Rehabilitation and the Contractor Pool The Role of Government Agency/Public-Purpose Organizations in Selective Rehabilitation 18.13 Avoiding Gut Rehabilitation: Tips of the Trade 18.14 Improving Energy Efficiency in Selective Rehabilitation 18.15 Dealing With Lead-Based Paint Hazards in Selective Rehabilitation 18.16 Dealing With Other Recurring Health and Safety Issues in Selective Rehabilitation 18.17 Applying Construction Codes and Existing Housing Codes to Selective Rehabilitation 18.18 Standards Issues with Funders and Selective Rehabilitation 18.19 Information Sources and Tools for Selective Rehabilitation Appendix 18A Sample Documents Regarding Rehabilitation
PART SIX
COMPLETING AND MANAGING THE PROPERTY
679 681 681 682 683 684 685 686 687 689 691 692 693 695 711
Chapter 19 The Project Completion Phase: Completing the Development and Maintaining an Ownership or Rental Community 19.1 19.2 19.3 19.4
Introduction Settling on the Permanent Loan Maintaining a Rental Property Developing Additional Resident Services As Part of a Comprehensive Property Management Plan 19.5 Key Points on Setting Performance Standards for Comprehensive Property Management 19.6 Key Points on Deciding Whether to Contract for Management or Manage Directly 19.7 Key Points on Selecting a Good Management Company 19.8 Key Points on Evaluating Property Management Performance 19.9 Financial Management of Rental and Multifamily Homeownership 19.10 Converting the Property to Homeownership for Residents 19.11 Managing and Budgeting for Rental or Multifamily Ownership Appendix 19A Sample Documents and Disclosure Statements Index
713 713 714 717 733 734 734 735 740 745 754 757 763 805
䡲
xxii
䡲
fabout.fm Page vii Saturday, March 11, 2006 3:37 PM
About the Author Bennett Hecht is an experienced nonprofit executive, author and social entrepreneur. He founded One Economy Corporation in 2000 to bring the power of the Internet and the economic mainstream to low-income families living in affordable housing across the country. In five years, One Economy has earned the support of America’s leading foundations and corporations, brought high speed Internet to $2 billion of affordable housing and helped more than five million low-income people to help themselves at www.theBeehive.org. Immediately before One Economy, Mr. Hecht was senior vice president at the Enterprise Foundation. In that capacity, he led the organization’s efforts beyond housing— building well-respected programs in childcare, workforce development and economic development. Under his leadership, the number of community-based organizations working with the foundation doubled from 750 to more than 1,500 in 48 states; capitalization of the organization’s revolving loan fund grew from $30 million to $200 million; and regional networks of nonprofit organizations linked by technology were born in New England and the Northwest. Mr. Hecht received his JD from Georgetown University Law Center and his CPA from the State of Maryland. For 10 years he taught at Georgetown University Law Center, and built the premier housing and community development clinical program in the country. In 1992, with Congressional support, Mr. Hecht founded the National Center for Tenant Ownership at Georgetown, a program facilitating affordable housing development by nonprofits and tenant groups nationwide. Prior to his work at Georgetown, Mr. Hecht worked for the public accounting firm of Coopers & Lybrand in Washington and served as counsel to the nonprofit National Rural Development and Finance Corporation. He has been an adjunct professor of law at Georgetown University Law Center for 17 years, teaching accounting concepts for lawyers. In 1997, he was awarded Georgetown’s prestigious Charles Fahy Distinguished Adjunct Professor Award. Over the years, Mr. Hecht has served on the boards of nonprofit housing organizations in Portland, Oregon; Cleveland, Ohio; and New York City and on the national boards of numerous organizations. He currently sits on the Georgetown Day School and One Economy Board of Directors.
䡲
vii
䡲
fabout.fm Page viii Saturday, March 11, 2006 3:37 PM
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Mr. Hecht has written two other books in addition to Developing Affordable Housing: A Practical Guide for Nonprofit Organizations: ManagingNonprofits.org (2001) with Rey Ramsey and Managing Affordable Housing: A Practical Guide for Building Stable Communities (1996), with James Stockard and the Local Initiatives Support Corporation, both published by John Wiley & Sons.
䡲
viii
䡲
fforw.fm Page ix Saturday, March 11, 2006 3:38 PM
Foreword Housing matters—especially decent, stable, affordable housing. While education, health care, and workforce development often receive more attention, there is mounting evidence that housing is a critical factor in opening opportunities to individuals and improving communities. Recent studies confirm what we know intuitively—that decent, stable housing improves the ability of individuals to get and keep jobs, increases psychological well-being, and leads to better social behavior and school achievement among children. Other studies link the availability of affordable housing to the economic vitality of cities and regions. An adequate supply of such housing depends on a broad commitment to our communities and their residents. Nonprofit housing developers work closely with architects, bankers, construction contractors, property managers, public officials and others. Together, they are making a critical difference. For nearly three decades, nonprofit housing developers have demonstrated how essential they are to the revitalization of communities. They increasingly understand the relationship between the bricks and mortar they provide and the critical social and economic supports that residents of their properties need to flourish. In the early years of the twenty-first century, challenges abound. Federal funding is likely to diminish. The regulatory environment that has helped bring conventional capital to communities needing a revitalized stock of affordable housing is weakening. It is difficult for nonprofit developers to purchase, recapitalize, and improve the thousands of affordable housing units that were built in the 1970s and 1980s and whose federal subsidies are coming to an end. However, these are all challenges that a greatly strengthened field of nonprofit housing developers and their many allies are prepared to meet. For over twenty-five years, the MacArthur Foundation has invested in housing. Today, our interest is deeper than ever. Since 2000 alone, more than $100 million in grants and loans have been committed to the development and preservation of affordable housing. These resources have helped nonprofit developers, and the specialized financing intermediaries that support them, ensure that decent, affordable housing is available in both urban and rural communities.
䡲
ix
䡲
fforw.fm Page x Saturday, March 11, 2006 3:38 PM
FOREWORD
To be even more effective, these organizations need the kind of clear, practical guidance that can be found in Ben Hecht’s influential book. It has stood the test of time, as the state of the field has changed, as development has become more complex, and as the need for affordable housing has grown. I recommend it to everyone who cares about American communities and understands the crucial role of affordable housing in their success. Jonathan F. Fanton President John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation
䡲
x
䡲
fpref.fm Page xi Monday, March 13, 2006 12:09 PM
Preface This is my third edition of Developing Affordable Housing. Much has changed in the housing industry since I wrote the first edition more than ten years ago. The federal government’s commitment has declined precipitously while the level of state investment has grown. The idea of demolishing the most problematic public housing developments and putting new, mixed income communities back in their place has not only become a reality, but the norm. The federal low income housing tax credit has become a permanent part of the rental housing landscape and expanded dramatically into the suburbs. Preserving the existing stock of affordable housing, not just building new units, has been embraced by an increasing number of communities as leaders realize that lost units will never be recaptured. Homeownership rates, especially for people of color and immigrants, have hit historic high levels. The face of America and those who live in its affordable rental housing has changed as well. Immigrants accounted for more than a third of all U.S. household growth in the 1990s. In fact, the number of renter households in America would have fallen during that period was it not for immigrant and minority households. These changes have been accelerated further by historically low mortgage interest rates that helped move millions of renters into homeownership. Two other things also have grown over these ten plus years: the demand for affordable housing and the capacity of nonprofit organizations to develop and manage these units, when sufficient resources are made available to them. Americans do not have income sufficient to afford decent, safe and affordable housing. As recently as 2001, 95 million Americans had excess housing costs burdens (pay more than 30% of their income for housing) or lived in crowded or inadequate conditions. In 2004, the number of people earning $32–50,000 who spent more than 30% of income on housing jumped to 4.5 million. Nonprofit organizations, large and small, public and private, are the only entities ready, willing and able to meet this demand. A 2005 study by the Joint Center for Housing Studies at Harvard found that for-profit developers are building for the high end of the market in increasing numbers. Of all the rental housing units built since 2000, 43% cost more than $800 per month compared to 25% of all units built prior to that date. Only 10% of the units built since 2000 rented for less than $400 a month. Relatedly, a 2000 study by the Urban Institute found that many nonprofit developers substantially increased their capacity to produce affordable housing from 1990 to 2000. Many parts of the industry have become much more sophisticated — using multiple sources of financing, highly 䡲
xi
䡲
fpref.fm Page xii Monday, March 13, 2006 12:09 PM
PREFACE
leveraging developer fees and shopping various funders for the most attractive terms. Housing for the hardest to serve, such as the homeless, mentally ill and addicted, can be found not just in dense urban areas, but in suburban and rural communities. My goal has been for Developing Affordable Housing to meet the user wherever they are—to provide a living resource for the citizens, policymakers, nonprofit executives and professionals who want to make affordable housing a reality in their community. For the newcomer to the sector, this book provides a step-by-step analysis of the nonprofit real estate development process, from feasibility to long-term management including checklists and sample forms and reports, where necessary. For the more experienced, the book allows you to expand your possibilities by helping you identify relevant federal, state and local programs. The book provides a description of the existing federal loan, grant, mortgage insurance, rent and operating subsidy programs (e.g., HOME, CDBG, HOPE VI, McKinney Grants) and of common state and local government mechanisms used to finance affordable housing. Users over the years have found the detailed case studies that I provide, with accompanying financial pro formas, to be one of the book’s most valuable features. This edition highlights six very different affordable housing organizations and developments. Each development serves a unique population (e.g. homeless, seniors or families), utilizes a multiplicity of funding sources (e.g., low income housing tax credits, tax-exempt bonds, private and public grants) and now manages unique types of housing (e.g., single room occupancy, homeownership or rental). What these six organizations have been able to do and the way they accomplished these developments is an inspiration to me and I hope to you. Many communities have skilled and committed professionals such as lawyers, accountants, bankers, architects, and financial development specialists who have never worked on affordable housing development projects but would like to do so or to help existing nonprofit organizations to do so. This book provides these professionals with the kind of orientation and guidance that they would need to enable them to play an active and valuable role as a development team member in local affordable housing development projects. Finally, many state and local governments have not developed the programs or earmarked the resources necessary to facilitate the wholesale creation of affordable homeownership and rental housing opportunities by nonprofits in their jurisdictions. This book provides a laundry list of ways that government can promote affordable housing, from providing tax relief to nonprofits purchasing or transferring property and establishing flexible “soft second” mortgage programs with CDBG funds, to providing technical assistance and HOME funds. Chapters 1 to 5 provide guidance in putting together the right development team and in helping the team through the steps necessary to determine if an affordable housing project will be financially feasible. Chapters 6 to 12 highlight the various sources of capital available for affordable housing development (loans, grants, and equity), ways to reduce the costs of developing this housing, and methods for presenting the financially feasible project to funding sources, profit and nonprofit, public and private. Chapters 13 to 18 discuss the steps necessary to 䡲
xii
䡲
fpref.fm Page xiii Monday, March 13, 2006 12:09 PM
PREFACE
contract for, purchase, and rehabilitate or construct an affordable housing project. Finally, Chapter 19 takes the nonprofit housing developer through the steps needed to complete the project, sell out the units (if home-ownership developed), and manage and maintain the property including the ongoing financial management of a multifamily property, whether ownership or rental. This third edition has been updated to reflect the latest information and issues facing the affordable housing industry. Major revisions have been made to my earlier treatment of public housing finance and “mixed finance” opportunities (Chapter 10), joint ventures of nonprofit and for profit entities (Chapter 15), and the case studies noted above (Chapter 2). Decent and affordable housing often is the foundation whereby entire neighborhoods or individual families achieve a sense of stability. The information provided in this book should help nonprofit organizations, governments, technical assistance providers, private and public lenders and foundations to work together to bring this stability to people and communities throughout the United States. BENNETT L. HECHT Washington, DC February 2006
䡲
xiii 䡲
fpref.fm Page xiv Monday, March 13, 2006 12:09 PM
fpref.fm Page xv Monday, March 13, 2006 12:09 PM
Acknowledgments This third edition could not have been possible without the work and support of a lot of people. My law clerks—Aimee Ferrer, Matthew Peed, Donald Saelinger, Helki Spidle, and Jennifer Walrath—were invaluable in helping me to collect, update, and summarize changes to housing loan, grant, and equity programs throughout the country. I want to thank the law firm of Reno & Cavanaugh, Washington, DC—especially, Julie McGovern, Jaime Alison Lee, Megan Glasheen, and Lee Reno—for updating their excellent and important chapter, Chapter 10, on public housing. Thanks go to Michael Sanders for permission to excerpt his fine book on joint ventures between nonprofit and for-profit organizations found throughout the book, including Chapter 15. I want to thank Rick Eisen, Eisen & Rome, Washington, DC; Barry Mullen, Chicago, IL; and Peter Werwath, Vice President with the Enterprise Foundation, for their contributions to Chapters 14, 16, 17, and 18, respectively. I am indebted to the nonprofit groups featured in Chapter 12 for their leadership in the field, cooperation, time, and efforts. I want to thank Susan McDermott, my editor at John Wiley & Sons, for her support of this edition and her navigation of it through the production process. Finally, I want to acknowledge my wife, Lynn Leibovitz, my daughter, Eliza, and my son, Sam, for all the support, love and joy that they bring me everyday.
䡲
xv 䡲
fpref.fm Page xvi Monday, March 13, 2006 12:09 PM
p01.fm Page 1 Saturday, February 18, 2006 9:33 AM
P A R T
O N E 2
Getting Started
p01.fm Page 2 Saturday, February 18, 2006 9:33 AM
c01.fm Page 3 Monday, March 6, 2006 12:00 PM
C H A P T E R
O N E 1
Developing Affordable Housing in the Twenty-First Century 1.4 Current Trends in Affordable Housing 6
1.1 Introduction 3 1.2 The Current State of America’s Affordable Rental Housing 4
1.5 Unique Opportunities for Nonprofit Organizations: Rental and Homeownership 10
1.3 The State of America’s Working Poor Seeking Affordable Housing 4
1.1
INTRODUCTION
Affordable housing development came of age in the twentieth century. Many significant federal programs were created from the Federal Housing Act of 1934 through the Affordable Housing Act of 1990 that stimulated supply and subsidized demand for both homeownership and rental housing. By the early 1990s, these programs had helped to provide decent, safe, and affordable homes to millions of working American families. At its height, the industry was managing more than 5.5 million units of federally supported, affordable rental housing. By 2005, more than 33 million people had utilized federally insured mortgage programs to become homeowners.1 Today, the homeownership rate is at an all-time high of almost 70 percent. The private sector has created loan programs that now make it possible for very-low-income people, especially people of color, to buy a home with no money down and to prove creditworthiness in many unconventional ways such as showing 12 months of cell phone bill payments. 2 In fact, these innovations have helped whole segments of the population who historically have been shut out of homeownership to do so in record numbers. For example, Hispanic homeownership increased 1 2
www.hud.gov/offices/hsg/fhahistory.cfm. “Housing Industry Awakens to the Latino Market,” Wall Street Journal, August 3, 2005, page B8. Innovative efforts by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac to help low-income people become homeowners are discussed fully in Chapter 11.
䡲
3
䡲
c01.fm Page 4 Monday, March 6, 2006 12:00 PM
DEVELOPING AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN THE TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY
by almost 20 percent from 1993 to 2004 due to increasingly flexible underwriting and outreach.3 The same type of robust growth cannot be found in affordable rental housing. Today, less than 4 million of the more than 5 million units available in the 1990s still exist. The last major piece of housing legislation was enacted more than 15 years ago. No new major initiatives are expected in the coming years. Despite the fact that almost 100 million Americans are in need of affordable housing, resource constraints mandate that the industry focus on how to preserve the units still remaining and how to get the most out of the shrinking pool of resources available to build new ones. This chapter helps the nonprofit housing developer to understand the current state of the affordable housing industry. It highlights the trends that are likely to shape and impact development in this first decade of the twenty-first century. 1.2
THE CURRENT STATE OF AMERICA’S AFFORDABLE RENTAL HOUSING
America’s affordable rental housing stock is dwindling. According to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), as of 2000, there were 1.3 million units of public housing, 1.8 million units made affordable through rent vouchers provided to tenants, and 800,000 units developed through the low-income housing tax credit. Many more units are inhabited by low-income people; however, they often provide substandard shelter or are made affordable by crowding multiple families into a single unit. The single largest funding source of funding for new rental housing is the low-income housing tax credit (LIHTC).4 Approximately 1,300 new projects, adding 90,000 new units each year are funded through this program. In contrast, less than 50,000 units were built in the entire decade from 1990 to 2000 using every other federal program such as public housing, Section 8, and other federally insured loan programs.5 1.3
THE STATE OF AMERICA’S WORKING POOR SEEKING AFFORDABLE HOUSING
While the supply of affordable rental housing shrinks, need continues to rise. Simply put, Americans do not have income sufficient for decent, safe, and affordable housing. As recently as 2001, 95 million Americans had 3 4 5
Id. See Chapter 9 for a full discussion of this important source of equity. Huduser.org/datasets/lihtc.html. See Chapters 7, 8, and 11 for a full discussion of other federal grant, loan, and project enhancement programs.
䡲
4 䡲
c01.fm Page 5 Monday, March 6, 2006 12:00 PM
1.3 THE STATE OF AMERICA’S WORKING POOR SEEKING AFFORDABLE HOUSING
excess housing costs burdens (paid more than 30 percent of their income for housing) or lived in crowded or inadequate conditions.6 In 2004, the number of people earning $32,000—50,000 who spent more than 30 percent of income on housing jumped to 4.5 million.7 Even more troubling, fully one-half of the lowest-income Americans spent at least 50 percent of their income on housing—leaving an estimated $161 a month available for food and $34 a month for health care.8 These statistics do not even address the more than 2.5 to 3.5 million homeless people on the streets each year. Today, more than twice as many people face housing problems as lack health insurance, widely considered the biggest issue facing working class Americans.9 Immigrants account for more than a third of household growth since the 1990s.10 Of the 12 million foreign-born householders, 3.4 million (28 percent) arrived in this country during the 1990s.11 In fact, the number of renter households in America would have fallen during that period were it not for immigrant and minority households.12 If this influx continues at this level, more than 1 million new immigrant households could be added in the next ten years. This reality has significant ramifications for the sector. First, affordable housing developments will have to be more immigrant-friendly. That means that property management staff, tenant communications, unit size, and more will have to reflect the language and culture of this customer base. Second, the median income of these renters continues to drop, meaning that even less money will be available industry-wide for rent payments.13 But demand is not stimulated only by the growing immigrant population. Increasingly, communities are recognizing that they cannot recruit and retain essential workers because their housing costs are prohibitively high. Firefighters, teachers, police officers and service workers are being priced out of many markets. This leaves local governments and industry without the workers they need. This reality has led many in the industry to change the vernacular from “affordable housing” to “workforce housing.” This change is important for two reasons. First, it speaks directly to public and private sector leaders because it is their inability to attract a workforce that will engage them in housing issues. Second, it better frames the issues surrounding affordable housing as ones about real 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
The State of the Nation’s Housing, 2004, Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard University at 25. Id. at 27. Id. at 26. Id. at 27. Id. at 2. Id. at 11. Id. Id. at 23.
䡲
5
䡲
c01.fm Page 6 Monday, March 6, 2006 12:00 PM
DEVELOPING AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN THE TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY
working people, like teachers that you know and trust, not theoretical welfare recipients. 1.4 (a)
CURRENT TRENDS IN AFFORDABLE HOUSING The Rise of the States and the Decline of the Federal Government
The role of the states in financing affordable housing continues to grow especially as federal programs and funds become more scarce. The states have become increasingly important players since the enactment of the federal Low Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHC) in 1986. Unlike prior federal housing programs that were largely managed and approved by HUD, the LIHTC delegated awarding of these credits to the states. Since 1986, each state, usually through their housing finance agency, has determined the best way to allocate the credits. In the process, each state has developed its own affordable housing expertise, development priorities (for example, homeless, rural, disabled) and, in many cases, their own state funded housing programs. In short, the increased professionalism at the state level has led to a much more sophisticated and more highly funded response to affordable housing issues in that state. For example, a number of states, such as California and New Jersey, have created programs to preserve affordable housing units in their states that were developed originally under federal housing programs but that are now at risk of loss.14 This growth of state action in affordable housing is in contrast to the decline in federal support over the past two decades. Federal support has shrunk in every category. Funds for housing rehabilitation fell 60 percent from 1992 to 2002. Section 8 rent subsidies were reduced from $32 billion to $16 billion during that same period. At the time that this book went to press, it appears that this trend will continue for Fiscal Year 2006. Tenant-based rental assistance is expected to remain about $16 billion ($15.53 billion). However, Home Ownership Partnership (HOME) funds are scheduled to drop $41 million to $1.9 billion; Community Development Block (CDBG) funds are expected to fall $250 million to $4.2 billion with most other programs staying at or about 2005 levels (homeless programs $1.346; public and Indian housing $6.8 billion; housing for people with AIDS $285 million, and elderly housing programs $741 million). A big question mark for 2006 remains the comprehensive 14
California, Colorado, Iowa, Massachusetts, Maryland, Minnesota, Michigan, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Vermont, Washington, and Wisconsin have all taken actions to utilize state resources to preserve their affordable housing stock. See State Housing Finance Agencies: Developing Programs to Preserve Affordable Housing, September 2004, National Housing Trust and New Jersey Housing and Mortgage Finance Agency, http://content.knowledgeplex.org/kp2/cache/documents/66651.pdf.
䡲
6 䡲
c01.fm Page 7 Monday, March 6, 2006 12:00 PM
1.4 CURRENT TRENDS IN AFFORDABLE HOUSING
public housing redevelopment program, HOPE VI. The president and the House propose to eliminate the program for 2006. Experts believe that it will be salvaged but funded at low levels, possibly for the last time in 2006. (b)
The Shift to the Suburbs
The LIHTC has not only shifted power to the states, but it has also brought affordable housing to the suburbs in record numbers. Prior to the LIHTC, approximately 76 percent of all federal housing funds were invested in central cities. Since the inception of the LIHTC and its administration by the states, housing investment in the suburbs has increased almost 75 percent. A recently published Brookings Institution study found that approximately 42 percent of all LIHTC developments have been built in suburban locations.15 This trend is significant given the fact that most affordable housing built today is built with the LIHTC. Moreover, it is likely to continue as power bases in many states shift from largely Democratic urban central cities to largely Republican suburban and rural areas. (c)
Emerging Role of Affordable Housing As a Platform for Bringing Individual Economic Development Opportunities to Low-Income Residents
Five years ago, Rey Ramsey and I started a new nonprofit organization, One Economy Corporation, in order to use affordable housing as a platform for connecting low-income people to the opportunities provided by the Internet. Our goals were: (1) to change state housing finance policies so all units financed with the LIHTC provided free or low-cost high-speed Internet access to residents, and (2) to build a “self-help, self-sufficiency” destination online that residents could use to find a better job, qualify for health insurance, help their children with homework, or learn how to save money. In January 2004, we launched the Bring IT Home campaign with the U.S. Senate majority and minority leader as co-chairs and underwriting from housing giants Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae and support from technology and telecommunications companies such as Verizon, Qwest, SBC, Bell South, Yahoo!, eBay, Google, Cisco, Intel, and Microsoft. Over the campaign’s first 18 months, more than 33 state housing finance agencies changed their LIHTC requirements to require or incent affordable housing developers to bring affordable high-speed access to each resident in the privacy and dignity of their own homes. 15
Lance Freeman, Siting Affordable Housing Location and Neighborhood Trends of LIHTC Developments in 1990s, Washington D.C. The Center on Urban and Metropolitan Policy, Brookings Institution (2005).
䡲
7
䡲
c01.fm Page 8 Monday, March 6, 2006 12:00 PM
DEVELOPING AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN THE TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY
Mayors, governors, and other elected officials have embraced this approach enthusiastically. They see affordable housing as a cost-effective way to insure that low-income people have the means to take advantage of economic opportunities available through the Internet. These opportunities include continuing education, workforce training or retraining, applying for and receiving public benefits, and finding new markets for microenterprises. One Economy’s online portal, the Beehive (www.thebeehive.org) has helped make these possibilities a reality. The site, now localized to serve 26 different cities and states, serves more than 150,000 people a month in English and Spanish. (d)
Fall in Rental Housing Supply Overall
The United States has seen an extraordinary boom in homeownership over the past ten years. This boom, in many ways, has been to the detriment of the rental housing market. Fewer rental units are being built, and more and more existing units are being lost from the housing stock. Overall, rental housing production fell from 275,000 units in 2002 to 262,000 units in 2003.16 Unlike rental housing built prior to 1990, today’s rental units are being built for higher-income people. Nearly half of the rental housing units that have been built since 1990 have rents greater than $750. Only one-fifth of new rentals during this period were targeted to the bottom income tier. This is in stark contrast to the rents at units built prior to 1990. Only 29 percent of those units had rents at the $750 level or above.17 In many areas of the country, new units barely replaced the number of units lost to the housing stock. From 1992 to 2001, for every three new units added, two existing units were removed.18 In the Midwest, more units were lost than were added over this period. The Northeast added only 100,000 more units than were lost.19 Nationwide, many LIHTC developments are at particular risk of being lost from the housing stock because their initial 15-year use restrictions are expiring. While the LIHTC was enacted in 1986, the program did not begin producing units at any level of scale until the early 1990s. Thus, many of these projects reach their 15-year anniversary in the next few years. As noted above, state housing finance agencies are waking up to this reality and developing programs to preserve these units for the long term.
16 17 18 19
State of Nation’s Housing at 20. Id. at 23. Id. at 22. Id.
䡲
8 䡲
c01.fm Page 9 Monday, March 6, 2006 12:00 PM
1.4 CURRENT TRENDS IN AFFORDABLE HOUSING
(e)
Fundamental Transition in the Industry to Fewer, Longer Term Owners
In many ways, we have seen the nature and character of the affordable housing industry change dramatically since the 1990s. Federal policies from the 1950s to the 1970s were focused on stimulating the supply of affordable housing. These policies brought an array of for-profit developers into the emerging sector with the promise of making money by sheltering profits from federal taxation, generating considerable fees from financing, construction and management activities, and the later conversion of these developments into for-profit housing in no more than 30 years. As time passed, federal policy turned from stimulating supply to supporting demand (rent subsidies). As noted above, more than 50 percent of HUD’s budget is dedicated to rent subsidies currently. More importantly, the ability to use rental housing as a way to shelter income from federal taxation was all but eliminated by tax reform in 1986. These changes have had dramatic impacts on the sector. First, many of the developers who were in the business simply to shelter income and for the quick fees are long gone. They left once their primary reasons for keeping their capital in affordable housing were no longer available to them. Second, the exodus of the opportunistic many has left the committed few. That means that the industry now is primarily populated by entities that are in the business based on its inherent economics, cash flow from rents, not short-term fees and tax benefits. This evolution has led many of the remaining owners, policymakers and funders who work with them, to look more to the long term. In many ways, this is bringing a new, holistic discipline to the sector. Historically, programs and policies would veer from focusing exclusively on supply or on demand. Now, many are focusing on how to stabilize and grow the sector by insuring that new and existing developments are structured financially so they will both remain in the housing stock for the long term. (f)
Broad Embracing of Mixed-Income Communities
The federal government’s emphasis on supply from the 1950s to the 1970s had another unexpected outcome: extreme concentrations of low-income people in a limited number of neighborhoods. Troubled “projects,” such as Cabrini Green public housing in Chicago or HUD-insured Geneva Towers in San Francisco, became the face of federal housing policy. By the late 1980s, policymakers began looking for alternatives to this “warehousing of the poor.” The Affordable Housing Act of 1990 authorized funds that would demolish the worst of these developments. New “mixedincome” communities would rise up in their place populated with people 䡲
9
䡲
c01.fm Page 10 Monday, March 6, 2006 12:00 PM
DEVELOPING AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN THE TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY
of low, moderate, and even high incomes. Although the federal program that initiated this approach, HOPE VI, has had its detractors, the reality of building or rebuilding neighborhoods as mixed-income communities has become the norm. Today, many of the most successful “new communities” across the country are composed of inhabitants with incomes from across the spectrum. (g)
Increased Scrutiny of Government-Sponsored Enterprises (Fannie and Freddie)
Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are two government-sponsored enterprises (GSEs) that were created in the 1960s and 1970s to buy home mortgages made to low- and moderate-income households by financial institutions around the country. Fannie and Freddie buy home mortgages of low- and moderate-income households that financial institutions otherwise would have had to hold for 15 to 30 years, thereby freeing the capital up earlier and enabling the lenders to make more homeownership loans. This approach has not only increased homeownership dramatically but also created two incredibly profitable companies that enjoy the perception that their activities are guaranteed by the full faith and credit of the federal government. In the past decade, the GSEs have come under sharp attack by many on Wall Street who believe that Fannie and Freddie, as for-profits, enjoy an unfair advantage because of their special federal relationship. Critics also argue that the market no longer needs the GSEs because there now are many other players who do the same work as Fannie and Freddie without the implicit federal guarantee. Pressure on the federal government to act on the GSEs has increased in the past three years as they both have been found to have had accounting improprieties. Congress is considering legislation that could result in greater focus on and increased investment in affordable housing. 1.5
UNIQUE OPPORTUNITIES FOR NONPROFIT ORGANIZATIONS: RENTAL AND HOMEOWNERSHIP
As a whole, these trends point to unique opportunities for nonprofit organizations as we turn to the second half of this millenium’s first decade. The increased pressure on Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac is forcing them both to focus more on their missions of serving the underserved. They both have raised the visibility and support of initiatives to help minorities and people of color to become homeowners. Moreover, a number of proposals pending before Congress suggest that
(i) Homeownership.
䡲
10
䡲
c01.fm Page 11 Monday, March 6, 2006 12:00 PM
1.5 UNIQUE OPPORTUNITIES FOR NONPROFIT ORGANIZATIONS
the two GSEs use a portion of their profits to establish a fund that will make resources available for affordable housing.20 (ii) Rental Housing. Most opportunities, however, are likely to be found in the developing of rental housing for a number of reasons. One, the sector has shown that it can attract and allocate tax credits efficiently and effectively. The private sectors interest in investing more than $5 billion a year in housing through the LIHTC has strengthened this tool in the eyes of everyone, most importantly, elected officials. These successes not only have made affordable housing advocates of the American business community but also have laid the foundation for possible expansion of the LIHTC or the creation of new tax credit initiatives. The establishment of the New Markets Tax Credit in 2000 is an excellent example of this. Second, government, financial institutions, and philanthropic organizations now acknowledge the need to both preserve the existing affordable housing stock and continue to build new stock. This reality combined with the third factor, that the public and private sector has an enormous amount of confidence in the nonprofit housing development sector, means that nonprofits are poised to play an ever-increasing role in the future. Nonprofits now have a 20-year track record of taking on troubled developments and turning them around in communities big and small. Nothing succeeds like success.
20
www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2005/07/26/ AR2005072602033.html.
䡲
11
䡲
c01.fm Page 12 Monday, March 6, 2006 12:00 PM
c02.fm Page 13 Saturday, February 18, 2006 9:34 AM
C H A P T E R
TW O 2
The Real Estate Development Process for Nonprofit Organizations: An Overview 2.3 Addressing the Specific Needs of a Community and a Specific Project Site 17
2.1 Nonprofit Organizations and the Real Estate Development Process 13 2.2 An Overview of the Real Estate Development Process 14
2.1
NONPROFIT ORGANIZATIONS AND THE REAL ESTATE DEVELOPMENT PROCESS
Any organization, regardless of profit motive, that is interested in developing housing must grasp the fundamentals of the real estate development process. The basic steps in the development process are summarized in this chapter and detailed in Chapters 3 through 19. The nonprofit housing developer, however, must know more than the basics because affordability for a targeted clientele (based on special needs or income levels), not simply marketability, is the goal. Affordable housing development requires creativity and the ability to access private and public programs, funds, and incentives, especially those available only to nonprofit organizations. For example, nonprofit housing development organizations are usually able to complete projects only by accessing inexpensive funds uniquely available to them (e.g., proceeds from “501(c)(3)” bonds1) and funds available generally to real estate developers (federal, state, or local funds) and tax incentives available only to nonprofits (e.g., payments in lieu of taxes) and operating expense exemptions available only to nonprofits (e.g., water and sewer tax forgiveness).2 Additionally, a nonprofit housing developer must have the capability to address problems caused by the fact that the nonprofit has a limited 1 2
Reference is to I.R.C. § 501(c)(3). See discussion of these various programs in Chapter 11.
13
c02.fm Page 14 Saturday, February 18, 2006 9:34 AM
THE REAL ESTATE DEVELOPMENT PROCESS
track record as a developer and a limited ability to invest significant equity in any project. For example, a lender of construction funds will often require borrowers to obtain a performance and payment bond (P&P bond) prior to releasing any funds. This bond is the lender’s security that funds will be available to complete the job even if the developer defaults on its obligations. Although this appears to be a reasonable requirement of the lender, it creates a significant problem for nonprofit housing developers. Generally, bonding companies will not issue a P&P bond to developers who do not have significant development experience and assets. The nonprofit must be able to convince the lender to waive the requirement or must provide alternative security such as letters of credit, compensating account balances, and so on.3 As each step in the development process is addressed, special attention will be given to problems or opportunities such as those noted above that are unique to the nonprofit housing developer. These issues are of primary importance as the organization seeks to set standards for determining project feasibility (see Chapters 4 and 5); for accessing financing and financial assistance from public and private sources, including funds to help defray costs of determining project feasibility, completing rehabilitation, and providing rental subsidies to tenants or homeowners (see Chapters 6 through 12); and for adhering to rigid construction lending and bonding requirements (see Chapters 17 and 18). 2.2
AN OVERVIEW OF THE REAL ESTATE DEVELOPMENT PROCESS
The real estate development process can be broken down into three phases: (a) feasibility, (b) acquisition and construction, and (c) project completion. (a)
Feasibility Phase
This phase, often referred to as the predevelopment phase, includes all the tasks and studies that must be completed prior to actually settling on the purchase of a particular property. The feasibility phase is the most important phase in the development process because, in this phase, the nonprofit housing developer must decide whether the project is feasible: Can the property be purchased and developed into housing affordable to the targeted clientele? Generally, feasibility phase activities are comprised of the following: 1. Tasks related to determining project feasibility and securing site control over the property for later purchase. To determine whether 3
See discussion in Chapter 17.
14
c02.fm Page 15 Saturday, February 18, 2006 9:34 AM
2.2 AN OVERVIEW OF THE REAL ESTATE DEVELOPMENT PROCESS
a project is feasible, the nonprofit housing development organization must:
Associate itself with a development team of experienced professionals who can assist in completing the necessary studies and negotiations (see Chapter 3).
Determine, with the assistance of the development team, a project’s projected total development costs (see Chapter 4) and projected income and expenses (see Chapter 5).
Estimate, with the assistance of the development team, the sources, amounts, and cost of funds that will be available to the developer on a short- and long-term basis for the purchase and rehabilitation of the project (see Chapter 6 through 12).
If a project is deemed feasible, the nonprofit organization must execute a written agreement with the existing property owner that gives it “site control” or the right to purchase the property at a later date under specific terms (see Chapter 13). 2. Tasks that must be completed after execution of the purchase contract but prior to the organization’s purchase of the property. After securing site control over the property, the nonprofit housing developer must:
Determine whether it will take title to the property at settlement in its own name or in the name of another corporation or partnership.
Interview and select an architect, management company, and appraiser.
Apply for and obtain commitments for financing and rent subsidies from sources identified during the feasibility process.
Identify potential tenants from targeted clientele and market.
Develop a sales and marketing plan. All of these issues are addressed in Chapter 14 and 15.
(b)
Acquisition and Construction Phase
This phase includes all the tasks involved in completing the following: 1. Tasks required to complete the transfer of the property to the nonprofit organization (see Chapter 16). To complete the transfer of the property to the nonprofit, the organization must:
Evaluate the seller’s title to the property.
Obtain title and property insurance.
15
c02.fm Page 16 Saturday, February 18, 2006 9:34 AM
THE REAL ESTATE DEVELOPMENT PROCESS
Obtain title to the property.
Record the title in the land records.
Adhere to all local provisions, if any, that regulate the operation and licensure of rental housing or homeownership entities.
2. Tasks required to complete the construction or rehabilitation of the housing on the property (see Chapters 17 and 18). To complete the construction or rehabilitation of the housing on the property, the nonprofit organization must work with the development team to:
(c)
Develop detailed architectural drawings, specifications, and a narrative description of the work to be performed.
Select a contractor to perform the work.
Negotiate the terms of a construction contract, including cost.
Address preconstruction requirements such as permits, approvals, bonds, insurance, and tenant relocation.
Supervise the successful completion of the work, including the securing of necessary government certifications.
Project Completion Phase
The project will be in a state of equilibrium at the completion of this phase (see Chapter 19). In this phase, the organization’s short-term loans, which were used to acquire, construct, or rehabilitate the property, will be paid off. These interim loans will be replaced with long-term or “permanent financing” that will stay with the property for 5 to 30 years. The use and character of the housing also will be stabilized during this phase. If rental housing has been produced, the nonprofit organization will develop and implement a long- and short-term management plan for the property as well as appropriate tenant services and tenantmanagement outreach programs. If ownership housing was the organization’s goal, the nonprofit housing developer will create the necessary legal structure (fee simple, cooperative, condominium) to allow for homeownership during this phase. The nonprofit must also make provisions for ongoing training and legal assistance for owners and cooperative or condominium boards of directors.
16
c02.fm Page 17 Saturday, February 18, 2006 9:34 AM
2.3 ADDRESSING THE SPECIFIC NEEDS OF A COMMUNITY
2.3
ADDRESSING THE SPECIFIC NEEDS OF A COMMUNITY AND A SPECIFIC PROJECT SITE
After a nonprofit housing developer identifies a potential project and begins working its way through the steps outlined in the preceding section, it must keep in mind that the process and the potential financing programs available for that project may differ, based on the following factors:
Homeownership vs. rental.
Multifamily vs. single family.
Occupied vs. unoccupied properties.
New construction vs. rehabilitation of existing structures.
These distinctions are made throughout the book, where appropriate.
17
c02.fm Page 18 Saturday, February 18, 2006 9:34 AM
c03.fm Page 19 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:33 PM
C H A P T E R
T H R E E 3
Establishing the Development Team 3.1 In General 19 3.2 The Sponsor 20 3.3 The Financial Development Specialist 20 3.4 Attorneys
21
3.5 Accountant/Bookkeeper 25
3.7
Property Management Company 28
3.8
General Contractor
3.9
Construction Manager
29
3.10
Community Organizer
29
3.11
Appraiser
3.12
Conflicts, Multiple Roles, and Oversight 32
3.6 Architect 26
3.1
29
31
IN GENERAL
One of the most important tasks that the nonprofit housing development organization must undertake is the assembly of a team of experienced real estate professionals with whom it will work on specific development projects. Generally, the team selected by the sponsor of the housing development will consist of one or more attorneys, a financial development specialist, an accountant, an architect, a property management company, a general contractor, a construction manager, a community organizer, and an appraiser. Whether the development team members are employees of the sponsoring organization or consultants hired by the sponsor, they should have extensive experience in real estate development and management, especially nonprofit-sponsored housing development. Assembling an experienced development team is crucial to a nonprofit for two reasons: 1. A nonprofit housing development organization rarely has on its own staff all the experienced professionals needed to complete a project of this nature—for example, an architect, a zoning attorney, and a property manager. The nonprofit must contract for the services that it cannot reasonably expect to perform in-house. As the
19
c03.fm Page 20 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:33 PM
ESTABLISHING THE DEVELOPMENT TEAM
nonprofit housing development organization gains development experience and in-house capacity, many of the roles of development team members described here may actually be performed by the organization’s staff. 2. The organization generally will need to “piggyback” on the successful real estate development track record of its development team members in order to convince lenders, government officials, and other interested parties that the project will be a success. Assuming that the nonprofit has had little housing development experience of its own, it must associate with other professionals and organizations that have had the requisite experience. This chapter discusses the roles and basic tasks of each development team member. Later chapters describe many of these tasks in greater detail, where appropriate. 3.2
THE SPONSOR
For purposes of this book, the nonprofit housing development organization is considered to be the sponsor of the housing development. The sponsor is the entity often referred to as the “developer.” Generally, the sponsor is the entity that intends to own the property after acquisition and construction are completed. Where homeownership opportunities are being created, the sponsor may serve as only an interim owner of the property until all units are sold to homeowners. The sponsor is the ultimate decision maker. Its responsibilities include the determination of whether the project should in fact go forward, the appropriate purchase price for homeownership units prior to sale, the extent of construction or rehabilitation, the hiring and firing of professionals, and the appropriate level of payment for all outstanding bills, taxes, and license fees. The development team members work on the project only as long as the sponsor desires their services. In contrast to the other development team members, who generally end their relationship to the project once they have received payment for their services, the sponsor generally invests its own funds—its “equity”—into the project on a long-term basis (if rental housing is being developed) or until the project can be sold out (if homeownership housing is being developed). 3.3
THE FINANCIAL DEVELOPMENT SPECIALIST
The financial development specialist is the chief financial officer and number cruncher for the development project. Generally, the financial
20
c03.fm Page 21 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:33 PM
3.4 ATTORNEYS
development specialist performs the following tasks, often with significant input from the other development team members: •
Analyzes the financial feasibility of the project by considering projected income and expenses, costs of acquisition, construction, or rehabilitation, and potential funding sources.
•
Prepares for the project a development plan that includes pro forma development budgets identifying interim (acquisition and construction) and/or permanent financing requirements, construction or rehabilitation expenses, operating income and expense projections, and subsidy needs; if homeownership is being developed, the budgets indicate unit cost, monthly ownership costs, and downpayment projections.
•
Determines the project’s eligibility under various financing programs and prepares the applications for these loan, grant, and mortgage insurance programs.
•
Communicates regularly with private and public lenders on all matters involving loan applications and loan closings, including new project developments, necessary changes to loan commitments, and terms and conditions of loans.
•
Secures acquisition and construction for rental and homeownership housing development, arranges permanent financing for rental and cooperative housing, and often facilitates or identifies permanent lending sources for buyers of homeownership housing.
•
Provides advice and assistance concerning the scope of construction or rehabilitation, the selection of a general contractor, architect, and management company, and the development of a sales and/or marketing plan for the housing development.
•
Acts as the organization’s representative in administering any construction contracts, depending on the nonprofit’s own capacity and the use of a construction manager.
The specialist may review and approve all payment requisitions and change orders, and may be responsible for ensuring that construction budgets and schedules are met and that costs are effectively controlled and remain consistent with estimates. 3.4
ATTORNEYS
The nonprofit housing development organization will need to retain one or more attorneys to assist it in the creation of the housing development. Depending on the complexity of the development project, the developer
21
c03.fm Page 22 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:33 PM
ESTABLISHING THE DEVELOPMENT TEAM
may need an attorney to act as the organization’s general counsel for the entire transaction and separate counsel to handle specialized issues such as taxation, land use, bond issuances, and foreign transactions. (a)
General Counsel
The general counsel will perform the bulk of the organization’s legal work. Generally, the tasks will include:
(b)
•
Establishing the legal existence of the sponsor, if a new organization, including its nonprofit status on the federal and state levels, if appropriate.
•
Negotiating all contracts between the organization and development team members.
•
Negotiating and drafting the written agreement that will provide the organization with site control over the property.
•
Representing the organization before government agencies and lenders.
•
Reviewing all loan documents.
•
Establishing the legal existence of the entity that will take title to the property, if different from the development organization itself.
•
Ensuring that the organization complies fully with all local laws and regulations, if any, that regulate the operation or licensure of rental housing or homeownership entities.
•
Negotiating, reviewing, and revising all construction-related contracts (architect, general contractor, construction manager).
•
Establishing the legal existence of the cooperative or condominium structure, if the organization is developing homeownership opportunities.
•
Drafting the disclosure documents—public offering statements, condominium declarations, and so on—required for the sale of homeownership opportunities. Specialized Counsel
Although the organization’s general counsel may be qualified to handle most transactions alone, the organization inevitably will face circumstances where it will need counsel who is experienced in specialized areas of the law, such as taxation, land use, and foreign corporations. Generally, tax counsel should be retained if a major component of the organization’s development plan can only be achieved if the transaction
22
c03.fm Page 23 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:33 PM
3.4 ATTORNEYS
meets certain requirements of the Internal Revenue Code (the Code). Affordable housing developments utilizing the low-income housing tax credit, and bargain-sale agreements between for-profit owners and nonprofit purchasers1 are two examples of transactions that succeed or fail based on tax code compliance. The nonprofit organization should seek tax counsel who has extensive experience in completing projects that utilized parallel tax provisions, for example, tax credits or bargain sales. The nonprofit housing developer should consider retaining special land use counsel if the existing zoning or use classification of the property needs to be changed in order to create the type of housing intended by the organization. Land use changes sought by the nonprofit may be minor, requiring only a variance, such as for allowing a basement to be converted into an accessory apartment, but they are often major, such as a change of zoning that allows dense, multifamily housing developments to be built on land formerly used solely for single-family homes. Whether the required use change is major or minor, if it is not secured, the nonprofit organization will not be able to create the type of housing it set out to develop. In selecting land use counsel, the nonprofit organization should select an attorney who has practiced land use law extensively in the jurisdiction where the property in question is located. Local counsel is required because land use law is uniquely local. The most effective land use lawyer knows the law and all the local people who administer and interpret the laws and regulations. Special bond or foreign counsel also may be necessary, depending on the organization’s development plan. Bond counsel will be required if the nonprofit developer is planning on utilizing Code Section 501(c) (3) bonds in its financing.2 If the nonprofit is purchasing property from a foreign corporation, counsel experienced in transactions involving similar non-U.S. entities should be consulted. (c)
Retaining Counsel on a Fee for Service or Pro Bono Basis
Many state and local bar associations have developed programs in which licensed attorneys in their jurisdictions volunteer to assist low-income individuals and nonprofit organizations in particular tasks. Interested sponsors should contact the local or state bar association to determine the availability of these pro bono or free services. The sponsor should consider the following issues before retaining counsel:
1 2
See discussion of low-income housing tax credits in Chapter 9 and bargain sales in Chapter 11. See discussion of I.R.C. § 501(c)(3) bond financing in Chapter 7.
23
c03.fm Page 24 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:33 PM
ESTABLISHING THE DEVELOPMENT TEAM
As discussed in Section 3.1, the sponsor needs counsel experienced in working with the type of housing development being contemplated by the sponsor and with the local housing officials with whom the sponsor will have to interact. Counsel also must be willing to provide the sponsor with legal opinions required by lenders or government agencies in order to secure financing. Inexperienced counsel may balk at providing these opinions without charge, if acting pro bono, or without an additional charge, if acting under a fee for service arrangement, because of counsel’s lack of understanding of the programs and inability to assess the risks to counsel’s firm in providing the opinion. Sponsors must find out the answers to these questions before the problems arise. Counsel with little or no real estate development experience, whether the services are offered pro bono or for a fee, will be of little assistance to the sponsor. The sponsor may have a false sense of security that all necessary legal issues are being addressed and learn of problems later in the development process as counsel realizes the extent of the complicated legal problems that arise in affordable housing development and the limited resources of its client.
(i) Experience.
(ii) Need for General Counsel. The sponsor may decide to retain a fee for service attorney if the sponsor has or reasonably can foresee having a need for a corporate general counsel to handle longer-term, nondevelopmentrelated legal needs of the sponsoring organization and pro bono counsel will be available only for one specific transaction. For example, if the sponsor has legal service needs in such areas as corporate formation, taxation, or employee relations, it may want to establish a relationship with an attorney who will be available to serve the organization beyond the specific development project. (iii) Responsiveness. Although many pro bono attorneys provide the same
quality and responsiveness to their fee and nonfee clients, attorneys, like all service providers, pay their bills from the collection of professional fees. Sponsors receiving pro bono legal assistance know this reality and, to the detriment of the project, they often choose, consciously or subconsciously, not to utilize or to push their counsel because they are not paying for the service. In the worst cases, pro bono counsel simply may neglect the housing development organization when the number of hours in the attorney’s day do not meet the needs of the paying clients. Although the counsel can be disciplined for this type of behavior, the problems caused to the housing development organization and the affordable housing development can be fatal.
24
c03.fm Page 25 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:33 PM
3.5 ACCOUNTANT/BOOKKEEPER
3.5
ACCOUNTANT/BOOKKEEPER
The nonprofit sponsor must have an accountant/bookkeeper to set up an accounting system for the organization and the project, if a system does not already exist. This system must be able to track and report income and expenses related to a specific development project, especially during the feasibility, acquisition, and construction phases. These tasks are particularly important if the organization has had limited experience accounting for funds to date or if the organization—a tenant group, for example—was established solely to complete one project. The accountant/ bookkeeper can be on the staff of the nonprofit housing development organization or hired as a consultant to a specific project. Tracking and regular reporting of income and expenses related to the development are important for a number of reasons: 1. If federal, state, or local funds are utilized in the project, the nonprofit likely will have to have an independent accountant certify, at the end of the development process, that the costs of the project were indeed what the organization stated they were. This cost certification will be difficult and extremely costly without an accounting system in place that has generated monthly income and expense reports. 2. Tracking will assist the organization in keeping within its development budget. Cost overruns unrelated to construction or rehabilitation can be avoided if the nonprofit receives and evaluates monthly reports that show how much money has been received for the project to date, including funds from loans, and how much money has been spent on the project to date. Reports that compare these actual numbers to budgeted figures also will be helpful. 3. All funds raised and spent on a project by the nonprofit developer will be considered part of the developer’s equity in the project. As discussed in greater detail in Chapters 6–11, the more equity the organization can bring to the project, the easier it will be to finance. Tracking this equity from the outset of the project will ensure that it is fully accounted for when needed. The organization also needs accurate records that identify which residents have contributed funds and the amount of each resident’s contributions toward the development. Generally, these contributions will be credited to the resident as equity when the resident ultimately closes on the purchase of a homeownership unit in the project. This contribution determination is particularly important for federal programs that require a down payment by each homeowner at the time a home is purchased.
25
c03.fm Page 26 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:33 PM
ESTABLISHING THE DEVELOPMENT TEAM
4. Tracking is especially important to a nonprofit developer (such as a tenant group) that cannot qualify for federal tax-exempt status and exists only to complete a specific development for the benefit of existing residents. This organization must worry about owing federal and state taxes each year because of its tax status; therefore, tracking will ensure that it can accurately prove that it owes no taxes because its income has not exceeded its expenses. 5. Tracking of income and expenses will be very important if the nonprofit has employees. The existence of even one paid employee exposes the organization to significant liabilities for employee-related costs such as federal income, Social Security, and Medicaid taxes as well as unemployment insurance and compensation expenses. The accountant, in conjunction with the attorney, may be utilized to establish the legal existence of the entity that will take title to the property, if different from the development organization itself. This will be particularly important if the acquiring entity is a partnership, C corporation, or S corporation created to maximize the tax benefits of certain income tax provisions (the low-income housing tax credit, for example) or to avoid the passive loss rules to the greatest extent possible.3 3.6
ARCHITECT
Generally, the nonprofit organization will select an architect in the very early stages of the feasibility phase. As the development progresses through the feasibility, acquisition, and construction phases, the architect’s role and responsibilities change considerably, as discussed below and in Chapter 17. An affordable housing sponsor needs an architect who is experienced in the planned type of housing development and is able to help the sponsor get the project done within a very tight budget. Given budget constraints of affordable housing development, a sponsor should seek to retain an architect who understands that an ability to solve problems within a limited budget likely will be more beneficial to the sponsor than creative abilities in the area of design. (a)
During Feasibility
The architect plays a vital role in developing a scope of work for the property and in projecting costs for this work. These cost projections are relied 3
Real estate development has become increasingly complicated and difficult since the Tax Reform Act of 1986. The sponsor and its investors, if any, must use experienced counsel and accountants when structuring any venture, to maximize tax benefits and minimize passive loss burdens. See I.R.C. § 469 (passive loss rules).
26
c03.fm Page 27 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:33 PM
3.6 ARCHITECT
on by the financial development specialist in completing a financial feasibility analysis and development plan for the project. When constructing a new building, the architect will meet extensively with the nonprofit’s representatives. Together, they will develop a preliminary design for the building, a construction schedule, and a construction budget. After approval of this preliminary plan, the architect will prepare preliminary drawings, called schematic drawings, that will illustrate the proposed structure to scale. When rehabilitating an existing structure, the architect usually will team up with structural, electrical, and mechanical engineers or contractors to complete an evaluation of the existing units and systems in the building. The architect will then submit to the nonprofit developer a report that may: 1. Describe the present condition of the existing facility’s architectural, structural, mechanical, electrical, and plumbing components and its elevators, if any. 2. List proposed renovation work, including repairs to correct deferred maintenance, address housing code and safety regulations, improve energy conservation, correct existing or pending structural defects, repair or replace major building components with less than ten years of useful life expectancy, and enhance the marketability of the property. 3. List proposed renovation work to meet the objectives of the nonprofit developer, for example, increase the number of three-bedroom units, install individual utility meters for each unit. 4. Contain certifications from registered engineers indicating the structural integrity of the building, its present condition, the remaining useful life expectancy in years, and costs to cure deficiencies in major building components, including heating, cooling, plumbing, and electrical systems, and the roof. 5. Determine what improvements may be required to obtain a local building occupancy permit—sprinkler systems, additional means of ingress and egress, accessibility for the handicapped. 6. State the architect’s preliminary construction budget for the rehabilitation described in the report. After the nonprofit organization has had an opportunity to review this report and to discuss it with the architect, the architect will prepare preliminary schematic drawings, like those for new construction, that incorporate the proposed changes and will develop a preliminary construction budget to reflect the established scope of work.
27
c03.fm Page 28 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:33 PM
ESTABLISHING THE DEVELOPMENT TEAM
In many cases, prior to acquisition, the architect will complete design drawings—a set of drawings that individually detail the architectural, structural, mechanical, and electrical systems that will be used in the project. (b)
During Acquisition and Construction
The architect’s role after acquisition is basically the same, whether the project involves new construction or the substantial rehabilitation of an existing structure. For example, if the project is going to be competitively bid, as discussed in Chapter 17, the architect always will prepare construction documents (design drawings and written specifications regarding the exact type and quality of materials to be used) and provide them to all contractors interested in bidding on the project. The architect then will assist the nonprofit in analyzing bids, negotiating the construction contract, and obtaining any permits required prior to renovation. The architect’s role in projects that are not competitively bid is discussed in Chapter 17. During the construction phase, the architect usually visits the site frequently to review the work being performed. When the contractor believes that the work is complete in whole or in part, the architect often inspects the work on behalf of the nonprofit sponsor. The roles of the various players who participate in the construction or rehabilitation phase of the development are described in greater detail in Chapters 17 and 18. 3.7
PROPERTY MANAGEMENT COMPANY
Most sponsors have a property management company join the development team immediately prior to the nonprofit developer’s acquisition of the property if the property acquired has a building with tenants in place, or at the time when construction is completed and the property is ready for occupancy. To the extent possible, however, sponsors should seek to retain a property management company much earlier in the feasibility phase. A property management company experienced in managing the same type of housing that the nonprofit is intending to develop can provide a financial development specialist whose operating income and expense projections could make the financial feasibility analysis all the more accurate. In addition, problems that will inevitably arise in the development process and will have an impact on the residents—temporary relocation, conversion to homeownership, rent increases, or in-place rehabilitation— may be less disruptive if the management company has had an opportunity to develop a strong relationship with the resident leaders and the residents themselves.
28
c03.fm Page 29 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:33 PM
3.10 COMMUNITY ORGANIZER
3.8
GENERAL CONTRACTOR
Like the property management company, the general contractor usually joins the development team after the property has been acquired. As discussed in greater detail in Chapter 17, the general contractor often is selected by the sponsor through a competitive bid or negotiated bid process. The general contractor contracts with the nonprofit housing developer to complete a scope of work specified by the architect in the construction documents described in Section 3.5. The general contractor agrees to complete the work within a certain time frame at an agreed-on cost or under provisions allowing for increasing the time and cost if necessary. The general contractor usually attempts to recover the actual costs incurred by the contractor in completing the project plus an allowance for the contractor’s overhead and profit. 3.9
CONSTRUCTION MANAGER
A construction manager may be brought into the development team at the time when an architect is usually retained or at the same time as the general contractor. Generally, a construction manager has greater expertise than an architect in accessing the needed scope of work, in estimating costs, and in evaluating possible defects or deficiencies in the work of the general contractor or the subcontractors. Therefore, if sufficient funds are available, the nonprofit may want to look to a construction manager to complement the architect’s services in this area from the outset. Often, construction managers are retained at the time of construction to provide the nonprofit with added capacity to review costs incurred and work performed by the general contractor. Although construction management services would enhance any development team, many nonprofit housing developers do not retain a construction manager. Instead, to save costs, they rely on the architect to perform these services because the architect is already needed on the job to perform architectural functions. Where few or no architectural drawings or designs are required in a rehabilitation project, the nonprofit sponsor might have a construction manager fulfill the role of the architect, as described in Section 3.5. The role of the construction manager is described in greater detail in Chapter 17. 3.10
COMMUNITY ORGANIZER
The community organizer may be the most critical member of a development team when the nonprofit developer is a tenant organization or is working to improve housing conditions in a tenanted property. The community organizer acts as the information conduit for the project—getting
29
c03.fm Page 30 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:33 PM
ESTABLISHING THE DEVELOPMENT TEAM
information about the status of the development out to the tenants, getting information about the tenants back to the development team, and getting tenants to provide information about their project to interested outside parties. This role can be best illustrated in the context of a tenantsponsored homeownership project. Generally, in a tenant-sponsored development, the tenant organization is the sponsor and the goal is rehabilitating the property and tailoring homeownership opportunities so all existing residents can afford to purchase. In this context, the community organizer might provide the following services: 1. Be a conduit to the tenants.
Go door-to-door to inform residents of the tenant organization’s efforts, the status of the development, the schedule for meetings, and the projected costs and fees for ownership.
Assist the tenant organization in developing and producing a regular (e.g., monthly) newsletter for distribution to residents.
Assist the tenant organization in scheduling and conducting regular (e.g., monthly, quarterly) meetings of the tenant board of directors and the residents.
Assist the tenant organization in developing and implementing a strategy for maximum resident participation in the development, including membership, fundraising, and community outreach.
2. Be a conduit from the tenants.
Go door-to-door to obtain information from the residents (e.g., income, expense, family size) for use by the financial development specialist in developing the financial feasibility analysis.
Go door-to-door to obtain resident information about the physical condition of individual units and building systems.
Facilitate discussions at meetings of the tenant organization to obtain input of residents on ownership structure (cooperative vs. condominium), and understanding of the rights and responsibilities of the board of directors and the residents or owners as stated in the organizational documents (e.g., articles of incorporation, bylaws).
3. Be a conduit for tenant information to outside parties.
Facilitate meetings for resident leadership with potential private funding sources (e.g., financial institutions, foundations).
Facilitate meetings for resident leadership with public officials, public funding sources, and local, state, and federal governments;
30
c03.fm Page 31 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:33 PM
3.11 APPRAISER
if necessary, give testimony before legislative bodies that appropriate funds.
Facilitate meetings of resident leadership with media, to increase public support for the development efforts.
Assist residents in completing necessary applications for public and private financing.
For a vacant rental property, the community organizer can be utilized to generate interest in the project and act as a pipeline for applications for vacant units. For a vacant or partially vacant homeownership entity, the community organizer can serve a broader housing counseling role to prepare people for homeownership by providing: •
Homeownership counseling and training.
•
Facilitation of homebuyer’s clubs, as discussed in Chapter 14.
•
Assistance to potential purchasers in completing the necessary applications for financing.
3.11
APPRAISER
An appraiser’s expertise generally is in determining the current and future value of property. An appraiser’s services either will be utilized early in the development process in order to get a general idea of what a property is worth, for the purpose of negotiating site control or at the time that a loan is being requested. There may be situations involving government lenders where the nonprofit would be able to select its own appraiser, but generally, lending institutions, not borrowers, select an appraiser for a proposed project. As discussed in greater detail in Chapter 4, an appraiser will be retained by a lending institution to determine what the property is currently worth and what the property will be worth after the development is completed. In determining the current value, the appraiser will consider the condition of the property (e.g., the building’s plumbing and heating systems), the existing use of the property (e.g., rental housing or single-room occupancy), the amount of income that is left over at the end of the year after paying all expenses, and the sales prices of similar buildings that have recently been sold. In determining future value, the appraiser will consider how much work the nonprofit is proposing to do on the property after acquisition (new construction or rehabilitation), the proposed use for the property after acquisition and construction (e.g., to convert a rental building to homeownership), how much income realistically can be expected to be earned from operating the property, how much expense realistically can
31
c03.fm Page 32 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:33 PM
ESTABLISHING THE DEVELOPMENT TEAM
be expected to be incurred to operate the property, and the sales prices of similar properties that have been recently sold. 3.12
CONFLICTS, MULTIPLE ROLES, AND OVERSIGHT
Conflicts inevitably arise whenever two or more persons work together on a project over an extended period of time. This maxim is especially true in affordable housing development because of the mix of professionals— architects, attorneys, general contractors, and others—who have strong opinions about everything, especially how to allocate the limited resources available for the project. These problems may be exacerbated when some development team members play multiple roles. For example, a sponsor may retain a local community development corporation to provide financial development and community organizing services to the project. The sponsor must be aware of these potential conflicts, plan ahead to avoid them to the extent possible, address them immediately as they arise, and make it clear to all parties that it, and no one else, has oversight and decision-making responsibility over the project.
32
p02.fm Page 33 Saturday, February 18, 2006 9:35 AM
P A R T
T W O 2
Projecting Costs, Income, and Expenses
p02.fm Page 34 Saturday, February 18, 2006 9:35 AM
c04.fm Page 35 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 5:41 PM
C H A P T E R
F O U R 4
Project Feasibility and Total Development Costs 4.1 Project Feasibility Defined 35
Appendix 4B Summary of Key Federal Regulations Governing Underground Storage Tanks 63
4.2 Determining Preliminary Project Feasibility 36 4.3 Estimating Total Development Costs 36 Appendix 4A Value 60
Appendix 4C Summary of Relevant Laws and Regulations Governing Lead-Based Paint 66
Sample Letter of
The primary goal of the development team during the feasibility phase is to assist the sponsor in determining whether the project can be completed as planned. A project that looks as though it will be a success is considered “feasible.” Chapters 4 through 12 detail the steps that must be taken to complete a feasibility analysis and develop pro forma financial statements that will reflect the project’s feasibility and will be required by potential sources of capital. This chapter defines project feasibility, sets out the various elements that must be considered in determining feasibility, and explains how one element of feasibility, total development costs (TDCs), can be estimated. 4.1
PROJECT FEASIBILITY DEFINED
Generally, a project will be considered feasible if the sponsor can convince itself that: •
The total costs of acquiring and developing the housing (the TDCs) can reasonably be secured by the nonprofit developer from its own equity, investors, grants, and loans, or from proceeds from sales to purchasers, if homeownership opportunities will be offered.
•
The ongoing costs of operating the units and maintaining the debt service on the project can reasonably be provided by the targeted clientele after construction or rehabilitation is completed.
35
c04.fm Page 36 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 5:41 PM
PROJECT FEASIBILITY AND TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS
4.2
DETERMINING PRELIMINARY PROJECT FEASIBILITY
The nonprofit sponsor, working with its development team, will be able to determine the preliminary feasibility of a project if it can make reasonable estimates about what the property is worth; what the project will cost to build, rehabilitate, and complete; how much income will be generated; and what amount of expenses will be incurred each year after the project is operational. The sponsor must determine the extent to which equity, low-interest loans, grants, operating subsidies, and proceeds from sales of units can be secured in order to keep expenses from exceeding the income that can reasonably be expected from rents set to attract a targeted, low-income clientele. Specifically, the sponsor must estimate: •
Total development costs (TDCs) for the project.
•
Annual operating expenses for the project, based on the proposed use of the property.
•
Annual income from rents for the project, based on projected income levels of targeted clientele.
•
Annual debt service expenses for the project.
If annual income from rents is insufficient to meet annual expenses, including projected debt service, the sponsor must determine whether expenses can be reduced through lowered TDCs, cost savings, a lower interest rate on debt, or additional grants or equity; or whether income can be increased through rent subsidies. Unless otherwise stated, the term “rent,” when used throughout this book, refers to monthly housing costs incurred by the occupant, whether in a rental or ownership setting. Generally, terms such as “carrying charges,” “co-op fees,” or “condo fees,” not “rent,” will be used in cases of ownership. A discussion of how to estimate TDCs follows. 4.3 (a)
ESTIMATING TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS Total Development Costs Defined
Total development costs (TDCs) are the expenses that the sponsor can reasonably expect to incur in order to complete the project.1 TDCs include “hard costs,” or the costs of purchasing the property and making improvements to the property, including new construction or rehabilitation; 1
Different programs, such as HOPE VI, described in Chapter 10, may have their own statutory or regulatory definition of TDC, which may also limit the dollars that the program will allow a sponsor to spend on a project.
36
c04.fm Page 37 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 5:41 PM
4.3 ESTIMATING TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS
and “soft costs” or all the other costs and fees, such as professional services, financing fees, sales commissions, and similar charges that likely will be incurred to complete the project. Once the TDCs are determined, the sponsor must develop a strategy for securing a combination of equity, grants, debt, and subsidy that will allow the sponsor to meet the TDCs and still keep the housing affordable. As discussed in Chapter 5, if affordability cannot be achieved by securing the necessary amounts of equity, grants, debt, and subsidy, then the sponsor must go back and try to reduce the TDCs to an affordable level. Securing a reasonably accurate estimate of TDCs early in the development process is crucial. The sponsor must be able to make a threshold determination about its ability to approach various sources and obtain funds sufficient to cover the TDCs. If the estimates are too high, a feasible project may look infeasible initially, and the sponsor may pass up an excellent opportunity. If the estimates are too low, an infeasible project may look feasible initially and the sponsor may waste its limited resources on a venture that will soon prove to be unworkable. The ability of a sponsor to accurately estimate TDCs is directly related to the amount of “good” information that the sponsor has been able to secure about the cost of each element of the TDCs. (The TDC elements— “hard” costs and “soft” costs—are described in detail later in the chapter.) Unfortunately, good information about each of these elements usually costs money to obtain, and this money may be wasted if the TDCs are simply too high to be feasible. For example, the sponsor may be able to develop an accurate estimate of construction costs, an important element of the TDCs, if it spends $10,000, early in the development process, on architects, engineers, and construction managers who will supply the necessary schematic drawings and cost projections. However, if the project is deemed infeasible, because of high construction costs or for other reasons, the sponsor will have spent $10,000 and will be no closer to having developed the desired housing. The sponsor must balance the need to obtain good information that will allow it to accurately estimate TDCs against the desire not to spend too much money on any project during the feasibility phase. The sponsor must develop reasonably accurate estimates of the costs to purchase the property, to improve the property (through construction or rehabilitation), and all other costs to complete the project, in order to project the TDCs. (b)
Purchasing the Property (“Hard” Costs)
One of the most significant development costs incurred by the sponsor will be the cost to purchase the property from the prior owner. This cost can be very difficult to estimate unless the nonprofit is limited to matching
37
c04.fm Page 38 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 5:41 PM
PROJECT FEASIBILITY AND TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS
a preestablished sales price determined by law or regulation or the terms of a third-party purchase contract,2 or the sponsor is purchasing the property for little to no cost under special circumstances, such as government homestead or excess property disposition programs.3 If the purchase will be market driven, with the seller seeking the maximum sales price, the sponsor should seek to determine a realistic purchase price by evaluating the property’s current market value. The current market value can be determined in one of the following ways. An appraisal is an estimate of the current value of a property performed by a professional, often licensed or certified, appraiser. An appraiser will appraise the property using one or more of the following methods: the market comparison approach, the cost approach, and the income capitalization approach. An appraiser may use all of these approaches to some extent; the decision of which to rely on most will be based on the purpose of the appraisal and the characteristics of the property being valued.4 The market comparison approach5 estimates the value of a property by evaluating recent sales of similar properties in the same market and comparing them to the property being appraised.6 No two properties are the same, however, so adjustments must be made for factors such as location, financing arrangements, conditions of sale, encumbrances on property rights, differences in use and physical characteristics, and other differences that affect the value of the property.7 Sales comparisons are very effective in residential markets where many similar transactions have taken place recently, but they are less useful when the property to be appraised is unique or the project is the first (i) Appraisal Methods.
2
3
4
5 6 7
In some situations, local or state law may set a sales price. For example, in the District of Columbia, resident groups in multifamily properties have the legal right to match the sales price of a contract already executed by the seller with another purchaser. Many jurisdictions have programs where governments dispose of property in their inventories to nonprofit housing providers or other priority purchasers for little to no money. Nonprofit sponsors should check with their local, state, and federal housing departments to determine whether properties of this nature are available. Some of these programs are discussed in Chapter 11. Stuart M. Saft, Commercial Real Estate Transactions, § 10.20, at 306–307 (1989). Basic appraisal textbooks have taught these three methods for many years; see American Institute of Real Estate Appraisers, The Appraisal of Real Estate 63 (1964). The appraisal standards mandated by the Financial Institutions Reform, Recovery and Enforcement Act of 1989 (FIRREA) require appraisers “to conform to generally accepted appraisal standards as evidenced by the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP) unless principles of safe and sound banking require compliance with stricter standards. 12 C.F.R. 564.4. The USPAP can be found on the Internet at www.appraisalfoundation.org/s_appraisal. This approach is also known as the market data approach. Appraisal Institute, The Appraisal of Real Estate 403, 10th ed. (1992). Id., at 404–405.
38
c04.fm Page 39 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 5:41 PM
4.3 ESTIMATING TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS
of its kind in the area, because no market exists for comparison. Despite the uncertainty involved in comparing dissimilar properties, this method has been widely used. Those who evaluate an appraisal report must keep in mind that the more factors that need adjustment, the more judgments the appraiser must make and the higher the degree of uncertainty in the final estimation of value.8 The cost approach method of estimating value involves figuring the amount it would cost to reproduce the property. 9 The appraiser will begin by estimating the land value (most likely using the market comparison approach), and then adding the amount it would currently cost to build the existing structures new. The appraiser must then estimate the depreciation of those structures and subtract that amount from the total, thus arriving at the value of the property as calculated by the cost approach.10 The cost approach is most applicable in appraising new construction because the difficulty of estimating the accrued depreciation in older improvements diminishes the reliability of the appraiser’s valuation.11 Most appraisers do not consider the cost approach, or give little or no weight to this method, when appraising existing structures. The income capitalization approach12 estimates the present value of a property by projecting the property’s future potential net income and the rate of return on investment that an investor might expect in the future.13 The appraiser begins by predicting the future rental income that the property can produce and the future expenses that the property may incur. These figures often are based on the property’s recent income-andexpense history. After subtracting expenses from income, the net income must be converted to its present value by dividing it by a capitalization rate or the rate of return that investors would want to receive from their investment. The result is the present value of the future income from the business.14 For example, if projected income from a property is $2,000,000, projected expenses are $1,000,000, and investors are currently requiring a 12 percent return on their equity for similar investments, the income capitalization value of the property would be $8,333,333 ($2,000,000 in income
8 9 10 11 12 13 14
American Institute of Real Estate Appraisers, supra note 3, at 68. Id., at 63, 64. Saft, supra note 3, at 306–307. American Institute of Real Estate Appraisers, supra note 3, at 65–66. This approach is also referred to simply as the income approach. Appraisal Institute, supra note 5, at 424. Saft, supra note 3, at 307.
39
c04.fm Page 40 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 5:41 PM
PROJECT FEASIBILITY AND TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS
less $1,000,000 in expenses = $1,000,000. $1,000,000 divided by .12 = $8,333,333). This method involves considerable speculation and is thus subject to uncertainty. It is typically used to derive an indication of market value, but can also be used to estimate the value of the property to a potential investor.15 The Financial Institutions Reform, Recovery and Enforcement Act of 1989 (FIRREA), passed in response to the savings and loan crisis of the 1980s, has imposed appraisal regulations on many real estate transactions.16 Because the banking crisis was blamed in part on fraudulent or faulty valuation of real estate, the law included reform measures directed at the appraisal profession.17 FIRREA requires appraisals used in federally related transactions to be performed by state-certified or state-licensed appraisers.18 Federally related transactions are real estate–related transactions19 that a federal financial
(ii) Appraisals and Federal Regulations.
15 16
17 18
19
Appraisal Institute, supra note 5, at 425. “Amer-Appraisal; S&L Bailout Boosts Appraisal Reform,” Business Wire (Apr. 21, 1989). Appraisal reform provisions of FIRREA are found at 12 U.S.C.A. §§ 3310–3351 (1998). “Amer-Appraisal,” supra note 15. Many commentators thought appraisal reform was long overdue (id.). State standards for both certification and licensing are subject to approval by the Appraisal Subcommittee of the Federal Financial Institution Examination Council, a body created to oversee the requirements and establish a registry of qualified appraisers in each state. 12 U.S.C.A. §§ 3310, 3332 (1998). State-certified appraisers must satisfy state certification criteria that meet the minimum criteria issued by the Appraisal Foundation, including passing a state certification examination that is consistent with and equivalent to the Uniform State Certification Examination. 12 C.F.R. § 564.2(j) (1998). State-licensed appraisers must satisfy licensing requirements in a state where licensing procedures comply with the minimum standards of FIRREA. 12 C.F.R. § 564.2 (k) (1998). Those standards, set out in 12 C.F.R. § 564.4 (1998), include conformity with uniform standards of the appraisal profession, which have been adopted by the Appraisal Foundation. FIRREA defines a real estate-related financial transaction as: any transaction involving— (A) the sale, lease, purchase, investment in or exchange of real property, including interests in property, or the financing thereof; (B) the refinancing of real property or interests in real property; and (C) the use of real property or interests in property as security for a loan or investment, including mortgage-backed securities. 12 U.S.C. § 3350(5) (1998).
40
c04.fm Page 41 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 5:41 PM
4.3 ESTIMATING TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS
institution’s regulatory agency20 engages in, contracts for, or regulates.21 Because many nonprofit housing developments are financed in part by funds provided by or regulated by a lending institution that is regulated by the FDIC or the Federal Home Loan Bank Board, this law has an impact on low-income housing development projects nationwide. The federal regulations provide that a state-certified appraiser is required for: •
All federally related transactions valued over $1 million.
•
Nonresidential and residential (other than 1–4-family) transactions of $250,000 or more.
•
Complex residential transactions of $250,000 or more (including 1–4family).22
For all other federally related transactions, either state-certified or statelicensed appraisers must be used.23 No appraisal is required by FIRREA in transactions valued at $50,000 or less, and in some particular types of real estate transactions.24
20
21 22
23
24
The term “[f]ederal financial institutions regulatory [agency]” means “the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporations, the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, the Office of Thrift Supervision, and the National Credit Union Administration.” 12 U.S.C. § 3350(6) (1998). The Code of Federal Regulations contains separate regulations pursuant to this title for each of these institutions. The regulations are essentially identical, with the exception of an extra section in the Office of Thrift Supervision (OTS) regulations entitled “Appraisal policies and practices of savings associations and subsidiaries.” The OTS regulations, 12 C.F.R. §§ 564.1–564.8 (1998), are cited throughout this section. Citations for parallel regulations for other institutions appear in the following sections of 12 C.F.R.: 12 C.F.R. Comptroller of the Currency §§ 34.41–.47 Federal Reserve 225.61–.67 Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation 323.1–.7 National Credit Union Administration 722.1–.7 12 U.S.C.A. § 3350(4) (1998). 12 C.F.R. § 564.3(d) (1998). Complex 1–4-family transactions are those in which “the property to be appraised, the form of ownership, or market conditions are atypical.” 12 C.F.R. § 564.3(d) (1998). 12 C.F.R. § 564.3(e) (1998). Appraisal standards do not apply to appraisals on 1–4family properties and existing multifamily properties prepared on Federal National Mortgage Association forms, Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation forms, or other approved forms (subject to some qualifications). 12 C.F.R. § 564.8(d) (1998). The other circumstances not requiring an appraisal are real estate–related financial transactions except those in which: 1) The transaction value is $250,000 or less. 2) A lien on real estate has been taken as collateral in an abundance of caution. 3) The transaction is not secured by real estate. (footnote continues)
41
c04.fm Page 42 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 5:41 PM
PROJECT FEASIBILITY AND TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS
(iii) Appraisals and Subsidized Housing. Nonprofit sponsors must be aware
of the fact that a property that is subsidized complicates the appraisal process. Favorable financing and income subsidies enhance the value of the property, but operating and disposition restrictions imposed by government regulations and limits on profits reduce the value of the property. In applying each of the three appraisal methods, the appraiser must keep these and other peculiarities of the property in mind.25 In this context, the cost approach generally is the least reliable of the three traditional methods, because the value of a subsidized lowincome housing project is, by definition, less than the cost of its construction. That is why a subsidy is necessary. To appraise the property using the cost approach, therefore, would overstate its value.26 In addition, this 4) A lien on real estate has been taken for purposes other than the real estate’s value. 5) The transaction is a business loan that: (i) Has a transaction value of $1 million or less; and (ii) Is not dependent on the sale of, or rental income derived from, real estate as the primary source of repayment. 6) A lease of real estate is entered into, unless the lease is the economic equivalent of a purchase or sale of the leased real estate. 7) The transaction involves an existing extension of credit at the lending institution, provided that: (i) There has been no obvious and material change in market conditions or physical aspects of the property that threatens the adequacy of the institution’s real estate collateral protection after the transaction, even with the advancement of new monies; or (ii) There is no advancement of new monies, other than funds necessary to cover reasonable closing costs. 8) The transaction involves the purchase, sale, investment in, exchange of, or extension of credit secured by, a loan or interest in a loan, pooled loans, or interests in real property, including mortgaged-backed securities, and each loan or interest in a loan, pooled loan, or real property interest met OTS regulatory requirements for appraisals at the time of origination. 9) The transaction is wholly or partially insured or guaranteed by a U.S. government agency or U.S. government–sponsored agency; 10) The transaction either: (i) Qualifies for sale to a U.S. government agency or U.S. government–sponsored agency; or (ii) Involves a residential real estate transaction in which the appraisal conforms to the Federal National Mortgage Association or Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation appraisal standards applicable to that category of real estate. 11) The regulated institution is acting in a fiduciary capacity and is not required to obtain an appraisal under other law. 12) The OTS determines that the services of an appraiser are not necessary in order to protect Federal financial and public policy interests in real estate–related financial transactions or to protect the safety and soundness of the institution. 25 26
See, for example, Barbara Christiansen, Subsidized Housing and the Three Approaches, Real Estate Appraiser and Analyst 52, 53 (Spring 1986). Id., at 53.
42
c04.fm Page 43 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 5:41 PM
4.3 ESTIMATING TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS
approach is largely blind to the operating and disposition requirements imposed on subsidized housing.27 The market comparison approach is a more reliable method of appraising subsidized housing when competent market data exist. In comparing the property to other sales, the appraiser must consider factors such as leverage, income tax shelter, rental subsidies, holding periods, and reduced interest rates, in addition to making the usual adjustments for location, amenities, square footage, and so on.28 The reliability of the appraisal, of course, depends on the abundance of market data and the number of factors to be adjusted for. Because markets for subsidized housing may be relatively unformed, and because so many factors must be compared, a fair amount of uncertainty must be expected in the sales comparison approach.29 The income capitalization approach can also be used to produce an estimate of the value of a subsidized project. In estimating the expected income from the property, however, the appraiser must rely on the contract rent, which is determined by government regulation, and not on the market rent, for comparable unsubsidized space.30 In addition, benefits such as reduced income tax liability and favorable financing, and limitations such as operational regulations must be factored into the calculus if the appraisal is to account for the peculiarities of subsidized housing.31 The analysis is further complicated by adjustments for reversion of the property to unsubsidized use after a specified holding period.32 Like all appraisals, an appraisal of a subsidized housing property is likely to involve a combination of methods, with an explanation of how the appraiser arrived at the final valuation figure. 33 A competent appraisal must account for the unique characteristics of subsidized housing,34 and the developer should be aware of the uncertainties caused by the appraiser’s adjustments for those factors. Although an appraisal may provide the “best” information about the current market value of a property, it also will be the costliest way to get that information. In today’s marketplace, appraisals can easily cost the 27 28 29 30 31
32 33 34
David S. Kirk and David A. Smith, “Using the Reversion/Shelter Approach to Appraise Subsidized Housing,” Appraisal J. 326, 332 (July 1983). Christiansen, supra note 25, at 53–54. Kirk and Smith, supra note 27, at 331–332. Christiansen, supra note 25, at 54. Kirk and Smith, supra note 27, at 332–333. Note, however, that income distributions to owners are usually limited to a certain percentage of return on the original equity. The limit is commonly a 6 percent return on the original equity of 10 percent of cost. Laurence G. Allen, “Valuing Subsidized Housing for Property Tax Purposes,” Appraisal J. 66, 67 (January 1986). Kirk and Smith, supra note 27, at 330–331, 333–337. For example, Kirk and Smith, supra note 27, propose an approach that uses different methods to value each component of a subsidized housing property. See, for example, Christiansen, supra note 25, at 64.
43
c04.fm Page 44 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 5:41 PM
PROJECT FEASIBILITY AND TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS
sponsor $5,000 to $20,000, given the demand for appraisal services and the liability faced by the appraiser who has certified the conclusions. Incurring this cost at such an early stage of the development process may be ill-conceived when there are less costly ways to estimate the market value and the appraiser’s certification is not needed at this stage. The sponsor must be conscious of the fact that any appraisal it obtains for the purpose of determining current value may be unacceptable to the various lenders from whom the sponsor will later seek financing. Generally, lenders will require borrowers to use only those appraisers approved by the lenders. Additionally, lenders often require that they direct the appraiser to do the work and that they receive the findings. Practically speaking, a sponsor who engages an appraiser to perform an appraisal in order to determine current market value should assume that it will have to pay full price again for another appraisal done at a lender’s direction and request. The sponsor, with limited resources, often must look to alternative and less costly methods for determining current market value of a property. One less costly means of determining market value is through the use of a letter of value. A letter of value essentially is an appraiser’s or an experienced real estate broker’s best guess of the current market value of a property, based on limited information and investigation. The appraiser or broker will survey the marketplace, evaluate recent sales of comparable properties, and provide the sponsor with a range of current market values for the targeted property. With a letter of value, the appraiser or broker is not certifying its analysis or conclusions. The market values suggested in a letter of value will be significantly less specific and accurate than those provided in an appraisal, but the letter will provide the sponsor with a good idea of the property’s market value at a limited cost, usually only a few hundred dollars. For example, the range of values provided by the appraiser in the letter of value shown in Appendix 4A allowed the sponsor to evaluate the reasonableness of the seller ’s offer and helped the sponsor to determine whether the property was worth closer to $13 million or $20 million.
(iv) Letter of Value.
(v) Self-Determination. The sponsor’s least costly option may be to try to determine the market value without outside help. The sponsor can reach its own rough conclusions about market value by gathering and evaluating much of the same information that an appraiser gathers to perform its appraisal. Generally, the sponsor will have to gather information concerning three or four properties that were recently sold and that are similar to the property in question (the “target property”) based on property condition, location, unit sizes, number of units, number of bedrooms in
44
c04.fm Page 45 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 5:41 PM
4.3 ESTIMATING TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS
each unit, amenities available at the property such as pools, front desk, indoor parking, and so on. If the sponsor accepts the challenge of determining the property’s market value on its own, it will need to know how much these similar properties recently sold for, their unit sizes, the number of bedrooms in each unit, the number of units in each property, the level of amenities offered at each property, and the condition of the properties. The sponsor also will need to know the level of net income that was being generated annually by the owners of these similar properties prior to their sale. As noted above, net income is the amount of income left over for the owner to use as it pleases after all expenses for the property other than debt services, have been paid. The net income of the targeted property must be determined as well . The sponsor will have to gather this information from various sources. Sales prices, dates of sales, and property addresses usually can be determined by consulting a directory of real estate sales published in your community by government or for-profit entities. These publications are essential to the work of an appraiser and usually can be easily accessed by the public. Armed with this information, the sponsor will have to visit each of the recently sold properties to determine whether they are comparable to the targeted property. The sponsor will be able to determine property condition, unit sizes, the number of bedrooms in each unit, and the number of units in the property by visiting the site and meeting with the property’s on-site management. When visiting the properties, the sponsor also should seek to obtain the previous year’s income and expense information needed to complete the market value analysis. If the net income information cannot be secured by the sponsor and the properties are subject to rent control regulations, the sponsor may be able to estimate income for the individual properties by checking the current, legal rent levels for the units as reflected in government records. The sponsor would then assume that these legal levels are the rents currently charged. Expenses can be projected either by using the average per-unit, permonth operating expense estimates generated by the Institute of Real Estate Management (IREM)35 for that type of building in that particular jurisdiction, or by estimating these expenses based on discussions with local management companies that manage similar properties.
(vi) Gathering the Information.
35
IREM issues regional reports entitled Income & Expense Analysis—Apartments. IREM can be contacted at (312) 329-6000.
45
c04.fm Page 46 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 5:41 PM
PROJECT FEASIBILITY AND TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS
From this information, the sponsor must determine which properties are in fact similar to the targeted property. Once that determination is made, the sponsor can evaluate the information in two ways, to get an idea about the current market value: (vii) Evaluating the Information.
1. Compare the per-unit cost reflected in the recent sales with the perunit cost asked by the seller of the targeted property. This analysis is quite simple. Divide the sales price paid for each property by the total number of units in the property. The result is the per-unit price paid by the purchasers when they bought the properties. If the analysis is being completed on four similar properties, add up the per-unit costs for the properties and divide by four. This will yield the average per-unit price of similar properties. Now divide the asking price for the targeted property by the number of units in the property. That figure is the per-unit asking price being sought by the seller. Compare this per-unit price with the average per-unit price paid by recent purchasers. If the prices are reasonably similar, the asking price may be reasonable—at or close to the market value. If the prices are very different, with the targeted property costs considerably higher, then the targeted property is either priced too high or the similar properties may have been sold at artificially low prices at distressed or foreclosure sales. If the targeted property costs are considerably lower, then the sales price may be a very good ideal. 2. Perform a “modified income capitalization approach” analysis. As discussed above, the appraiser will complete a complicated, formulaic analysis of the net income of the targeted property and the current financial markets, using the capitalization of income approach to determine an estimated value. The sponsor can attempt to do this analysis as well. However, the sponsor can perform a less scientific but still useful analysis if the income, expenses, and net income of these similar properties can be identified or estimated. Under this modified income capitalization approach, the sponsor determines the net income of each property and then divides the net income for each property by the sales price to establish a “capitalization (cap) rate” for that property. After determining and considering the cap rate for all recent and similar sales, the sponsor sets a cap rate for the property being appraised. The current value of the targeted property would be estimated by taking the net income that is currently being generated at the targeted property and dividing it by the sponsor’s estimated cap rate.
46
c04.fm Page 47 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 5:41 PM
4.3 ESTIMATING TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS
The per-unit cost analysis and the modified income approach are illustrated in Exhibit 4.1. E XHIBIT 4.1 The Per-Unit Cost Analysis and Modified Income Capitalization Approach for Property Evaluation STEP ONE: EVALUATE SIMILAR PROPERTIES Recent Sale 1
Recent Sale 2
$250,000 $100,000 70,000 $ 30,000
$339,000 $139,000 100,000 $ 39,000
$ 30,000 250,000 12%
$ 39,000 339,000 11%
$250,000 12 $ 20,833
$339,000 14 $ 24,214
Recent Sale 3
Recent Sale 4
$210,000 $ 95,000 75,000 $ 25,000
$375,000 $125,000 90,000 $ 35,000
$ 25,000 210,000 12%
$ 35,000 375,000 9%
$210,000 10 $ 21,000
$375,000 22 $ 17,045
Sale Price Income for Year Less: Expenses for Year Net Income for Year Determine Capitalization Rate: Net Income Divided by Sales Price Equals Cap Rate Determine Per Unit Cost: Sales Price Divided by Number of Units Equals Per-Unit Cost
Sale Price Income for Year Less: Expenses for Year Net Income for Year Determine Capitalization Rate: Net Income Divided by Sales Price Equals Cap Rate Determine Per Unit Cost: Sales Price Divided by Number of Units Equals Per-Unit Cost
STEP TWO: DETERMINE VALUE OF TARGETED PROPERTY USING DATA FROM SIMILAR PROPERTIES Summary of Information on Targeted Property: Sales Price Sought by Seller Number of Units in Property Income for Year Less: Expenses for Year Net Income for Year
$236,500 11 $105,000 $ 78,000 $ 27,000 (continues)
47
c04.fm Page 48 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 5:41 PM
PROJECT FEASIBILITY AND TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS
E XHIBIT 4.1 The Per-Unit Cost Analysis and Modified Income Capitalization Approach for Property Evaluation (continued) Summary of Information on Similar Properties under Each Method: Per Unit Analysis Recent Sales
Modified Income Approach
Per-Unit Cost
Recent Sales
Cap Rate
1 2 3 4
$ 20,833 24,214 21,000 17,045
1 2 3 4
12% 11 12 9
Total Costs
$ 83,092
Average Cap Rate
11%
(the sum of Per-Unit Costs for all 4 recent sales = $83,092) Average Per-Unit Cost
(the sum of cap rates for all 4 recent sales divided by 4 = 11%) $ 20,773
Net Income of Targeted Property
$ 27,000
Projected Market Value for Targeted Property
$245,454
(Total costs of $83,092 divided by 4 properties = $20,773) Number of Units in Targeted Property
11
Projected Market Value for Targeted Property
$228,503
($20,773 average PerUnit Cost times 11 units = $228,503) Asking Price for Targeted Property
($27,000 divided by 11% average cap rate = $245,454) Asking Price for Targeted Property
$236,500
$236,500
Like the letter of value, the sponsor’s analysis is helpful because it offers the sponsor a level of comfort in knowing what the property is worth generally. The seller’s asking price of $236,500 in Exhibit 4.1 is probably reasonable and close to market, based on these two analyses. The decision on whether the overall project is feasible at that sales price, however, requires the sponsor to complete its estimation of total development costs. (c)
Improving the Property (“Hard” Costs)
Estimating the purchase price of the property is only one part of determining the TDCs. The sponsor also must determine how much it will
48
c04.fm Page 49 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 5:41 PM
4.3 ESTIMATING TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS
cost to improve the property through rehabilitation or new construction so that it can be used for the purposes envisioned by the sponsor. For example, if the sponsor’s purpose is to build town houses on vacant land for low-income purchasers or to rehabilitate a boarded-up hotel as senior citizen housing, then the sponsor must estimate how much it will cost for the labor, materials, and so on, often referred to as “sticks and bricks” needed to build these particular town houses or to renovate this designated hotel. To complete this cost estimate, the sponsor must first determine what work must be performed at the property (the scope of work), whether new construction or rehabilitation of an existing structure, and then determine the costs that likely will be incurred to complete that desired scope of work. The sponsor ’s tasks in determining the appropriate scope of work differ greatly if the project is the rehabilitation of an existing structure and not the construction of a new building. The sponsor must conduct some type of preliminary building evaluation of the existing structure before deciding to rehabilitate a property. The preliminary evaluation, done by qualified professionals, would investigate the present condition of the existing building—its structural integrity, the heating and air conditioning system and components, the electrical system and wiring, the roof, the plumbing system, and the elevators. Based on this evaluation and a review of any housing or fire code violation reports outstanding against the property, the sponsor would, ideally, receive a list of proposed rehabilitation tasks that would correct deferred maintenance, remedy housing code and safety regulations, address environmental concerns, improve energy conservation, replace existing or pending structural defects, repair or replace major building components that have less than ten years of useful life expectancy, and enhance the marketability of the property. The report also should list the proposed renovation objectives of the nonprofit developer, for example, add a bathroom and shower on each floor for a single-room occupancy facility, or increase the number of three-bedroom units for a tenantsponsored conversion of a rental property to homeownership. Finally, the evaluation should include a preliminary estimate of the construction costs that would be incurred in order to complete each aspect of the proposed rehabilitation work. To secure all of the information described above, the evaluation would almost certainly have to be performed by an architect and a team of structural, electrical, and mechanical engineers who would certify
(i) Rehabilitation.
49
c04.fm Page 50 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 5:41 PM
PROJECT FEASIBILITY AND TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS
their findings.36 Like an appraisal, this approach, while providing the sponsor with the “best information,” comes at a cost of several thousand dollars, depending on the size and condition of the property. Given the high level of risk inherent in the feasibility process, many nonprofits are not prepared to invest that much money in a building evaluation at the stage when there is little certainty that the project will go forward. If a report by professionals is not an option, the sponsor must seek an affordable alternative that yields at least a “ballpark” idea of the future construction costs for TDC purposes. Retaining an experienced construction manager (CM) or general contractor (GC) may serve this need. A sponsor who intends to complete the construction or rehabilitation through the use of negotiated bid (discussed in Chapter 17) will identify a CM and/or GC early in the process and be able to use their expertise to prepare a preliminary scope of work and construction budget. Even if a negotiated bid process is not contemplated by the sponsor, a GC or CM may be willing to provide these services at little or no charge, in hope of future business with the nonprofit. In either case, the GC or CM would conduct a building evaluation by walking through the building. Ideally, the CM or GC would do the walk-through with heating and air conditioning, electrical, roofing, plumbing, and elevator subcontractors who could assist the CM or GC by evaluating what they see. After the walk-through, the CM or GC would give the sponsor a summary of the findings and cost estimates, orally or in writing. This alternative generally will not provide the level of specificity and detail available from an architect and engineers, nor the type of building evaluation report that will ultimately be needed to present to a lender when applying for financing. However, given the limited cost of this approach and the fact that GCs or CMs with current experience in developing the type of housing desired by the sponsor are often very good cost estimators, this information may be an acceptable alternative for TDC purposes. New construction will require a very different approach. The sponsor does not have to worry about the condition of an existing structure because none exists. Instead, the sponsor must work with its development team members, primarily the architect, to design from scratch a building that can be used for the purposes envisioned by the sponsor. As with rehabilitation work, the development must be in
(ii) New Construction.
36
The cost estimates of an architect are not always the best information that money can buy because they are based on average costs for improvements, gleaned from a book, and not actual costs incurred for similar jobs. General contractors and construction managers who cost out and purchase these types of improvements every day will usually be able to provide more accurate cost estimations.
50
c04.fm Page 51 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 5:41 PM
4.3 ESTIMATING TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS
compliance with local housing and fire codes and must address any outstanding environmental problems on the site. During the feasibility stage, the sponsor must meet with the architect to develop together a preliminary building design that meets the sponsor’s programmatic needs (e.g., transitional housing with on-site offices for social service providers or AIDS housing with on-site offices for health care or counseling providers). After designing the facility, the architect must develop construction cost estimates for completion of the building as designed. (iii) Costs to Address Environmental Conditions. Environmental problems
may be the area of housing development that generates the greatest level of concern among lenders. If environmental problems exist, the cost to remedy them may be so enormous as to render infeasible an otherwise feasible project. For example, a leaking underground storage tank that has caused extensive contamination on the property could easily cost $25,000 to $100,000 to clean up. A sponsor needs to receive reliable information on this type of problem as soon as possible so it can terminate its feasibility analysis of the property, if necessary, without incurring additional costs. Early in the feasibility phase, the sponsor must determine whether there are any environmental problems on the property and include the costs (if any) to address these problems in the construction costs portion of the TDC estimate. This requirement holds whether the sponsor is rehabilitating an existing structure or building a new one. Sponsors, and their potential lenders, generally will identify environmental problems through a Phase I environmental assessment of the property. In a Phase I study, environmental experts survey the property for asbestos, PCBs, radon, underground storage tanks, toxic waste sites, leadbased paint, chemical releases in the air, lead in the water supply, and sewage disposal.37 The site engineer provides the sponsor with a written summary of the findings, stating whether any or all of these conditions exist and, if so, whether they can be remedied; a plan for remedying these conditions, including costs, if appropriate; and a recommendation for a more in-depth study of certain conditions, if necessary. Because of heightened lender concern in this area and the enormous costs that the sponsor could incur if it purchases a property with significant environmental problems, the sponsor should arrange for a Phase I survey, to get the best available information about existing environmental conditions. A Phase I survey may be the most costly approach, but, on 37
Radon received a lot of attention in the 1980s; however, it generally is the least problematic environmental condition of those addressed in a Phase I study. Radon tends to exist only in certain areas of the country and usually can be abated with little cost to the property owner through the use of fans or other devices that blow the radon gas out of a specific area in the housing accommodation.
51
c04.fm Page 52 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 5:41 PM
PROJECT FEASIBILITY AND TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS
balance, most sponsors will find that it is worth the investment. No alternative method of determining environmental conditions can give the sponsor an equivalent level of comfort that the findings are reasonable and reliable. Sponsors should be aware of federal laws, regulations, and administrative actions governing environmental hazards. The four most significant and potentially costly environmental issues that sponsors of affordable housing are likely to face are: 1. Underground storage tanks—the most highly regulated of today’s environmental problems. Federal law, often expanded by states and localities, exposes property owners, in a number of ways, to significant costs in relation to underground storage tanks. The law holds property owners liable for the costs to:
Clean up any environmental damage caused by storage tanks located on their property.
Create and maintain a leak-monitoring and -reporting system.
Remove and replace or close any existing tank that does not conform to federal safety standards.38
2. Asbestos—the most pressing environmental problem affecting housing prior to the 1980s, when the national focus turned to underground storage tanks. Asbestos, like underground storage tanks, is regulated by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).39 Over the past decade, the government and industry have modified their views on asbestos and now recommend that asbestos should be left alone or encapsulated (covered) where possible. Where removal is required because of the deteriorating condition of the materials that contain the asbestos, such as pipe insulation or flooring tiles, or for other reasons, the sponsor must adhere to federal and local laws and hire a certified hazardous waste contractor.
38
39
Federal laws concerning underground storage tanks are codified in Subtitle 1 of the Resource and Conservation Recovery Act (RCRA) and Section 205 of the Superfund and Reauthorization Act of 1986 (SARA). Regulations can be found in 40 C.F.R. § 280. Generally, the tanks are regulated in five ways: (1) requirements are imposed on the quality and construction of the tanks themselves, including the required replacement by 1998 of tanks currently being used that are not constructed of the required materials, (2) owners must maintain a system for detecting leaks, (3) owners must report a tank’s existence, and certain activities such as a spill or a tank closure, (4) owners must take corrective action in response to any release, and (5) methods are imposed for closing tanks to avoid future leakage. A summary of the key federal regulations is given in Appendix 4B. See 40 C.F.R. § 763 et seq.
52
c04.fm Page 53 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 5:41 PM
4.3 ESTIMATING TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS
3. Lead-based paint—a concern believed by many housing advocates and developers to be more important and damaging than underground storage tanks and asbestos. The Lead-Based Paint Poisoning Prevention Act of 1971 (LPPPA)40 and the Residential Lead-Based Paint Hazard Reduction Act of 1992 (“1992 Act”)41 authorized HUD to seek aggressively to put an end to lead hazards in public housing, federally assisted housing, and certain nonfederally assisted housing built prior to 1978. Appendix 4C summarizes the other relevant laws and regulations concerning lead-based paint. 4. Chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs).42 Unlike underground storage tanks, asbestos, and lead-based paint, CFCs are not viewed as an environmental risk to the persons living in the housing accommodation or the immediate community. CFCs will likely have a significant economic impact on housing in the coming years because the air conditioning in much of the nation’s housing stock uses CFCs, and they are likely to be phased out over the next 10 or 15 years. Therefore, any sponsor of housing must plan for the time when existing systems will have to be changed or when the cost of maintaining the CFC system will become too great. Nonprofit developers must be aware of the potential costs of having to comply with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) when either building a new building or rehabilitating an existing structure. The act, enacted on July 26, 1990, provides comprehensive civil rights protections in the areas of employment, public accommodations, state and local governmental services, and telecommunications, for individuals with disabilities.43 The provisions of the act relating to public accommodations, Title III, may impose increased construction costs on nonprofit developers. Although private housing generally is not required to comply with the ADA, the ADA does apply if a portion of the private housing is a “place of public accommodation.” Among other definitions, a “place of public accommodation” includes places of lodging; establishments that serve food or drink; sales or rental establishments such as grocery stores or bakeries; places for public gatherings; service establishments such as laundromats, dry cleaners, beauty shops, and professional offices; nurseries or other places of education; day care centers, homeless shelters, or
(iv) Costs to Address the Americans with Disabilities Act.
40 41 42 43
42 U.S.C. §§ 4821–4846; section 7(d), Department of Housing and Urban Development Act, 42 U.S.C. § 3535(d). Residential Lead-Based Paint Hazard Reduction Act of 1992, §§ 1001–1061; H.R. Conf. Rep. No. 1017, 102nd Cong., 2nd Sess. 235–267 (1992). Housing and Development Reporter: Current Developments 181 (July 20, 1992). Pub. L. No. 101–336, 42 U.S.C. § 12101 et seq.
53
c04.fm Page 54 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 5:41 PM
PROJECT FEASIBILITY AND TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS
other social service centers; and gymnasiums or other places of exercise or recreation. Therefore, the ADA may apply if the nonprofit developer intends to combine residential use of a property with almost any other nonresidential use. If the ADA does apply, then, whether the nonprofit is developing a new building or rehabilitating an old one, some or all of the buildings may have to be built or rehabilitated to be “readily accessible to and usable by individuals with disabilities.”44 In the case of a property being rehabilitated, the rehabilitated portions, to the maximum extent feasible, must be readily accessible to and usable by individuals with disabilities, including people in wheelchairs.45 Under Title III, whether new construction or property rehabilitation is involved, when a commercial facility is located in a private residence, the portion of the residence used exclusively for residency is not subject to the Act. However, that portion used exclusively for the commercial facility or that portion used for both commercial and residential purposes is covered.46 This coverage would include those elements used to enter the commercial facility (the front sidewalk, for example), any doors or hallways, and public restrooms. Sponsors should consult early with architects and counsel who are experienced in meeting ADA requirements. The advice gained may help to avoid later “surprises.” Early consultation will ensure that the nonprofit understands the full implications of the design decisions that it makes, especially the costs involved. Future nonresidential uses of the property and the impact of ADA compliance on the construction budget are two major concerns.47 When preparing its construction cost estimate, the sponsor must build in a construction cost contingency. Generally, after the sponsor develops what is believed to be a realistic construction cost estimate, it will then add 5 percent to 10 percent as a buffer against the uncertainties associated with construction. An original construction cost estimate of $100,000 would be budgeted at $110,000, for feasibility purposes, to allow for a 10 percent construction contingency.
(v) Construction Contingency.
44 45
46 47
ADA, § 303(a)(1), and 28 C.F.R. § 36.401. This applies to all commercial facilities that are located in private residences. 28 C.F.R. § 36.401(a)(1). Commercial facilities are facilities whose operations affect commerce that is intended for nonresidential use by a private entity. 28 C.F.R. § 36.104. 28 C.F.R. § 36.401(b)(1). For a comprehensive discussion of the ADA, see Americans with Disabilities Act Handbook, published by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission and the U.S. Department of Justice (October 1991); available from U.S. Government Printing Office, Superintendent of Documents, Mail Stop: SSOP, Washington, DC 20402.
54
c04.fm Page 55 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 5:41 PM
4.3 ESTIMATING TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS
(d)
Completing the Project (“Soft” Costs)
The final element of the TDCs that must be estimated is the collection of costs commonly referred to as “soft costs”—costs that the sponsor will likely incur to complete the development, other than the purchase price and the cost of making the improvements to the property. Completion costs are described in the following sections. (i) Property Transfer and Recordation Taxes and Fees. Many jurisdictions, at the state, county, and/or municipality level, tax real estate transactions as a means of generating additional revenue. These taxes, usually imposed as a percentage of the purchase price paid for a property (e.g., 1 percent of the purchase price) may be charged simply for the privilege of transferring ownership of a property from one party to another (transfer taxes) and/or for recording one’s interest in the property in the land records of that jurisdiction (recordation taxes). In some jurisdictions where these taxes apply, the state, county, and/or municipality will require the entity recording its interest to pay a perpage recordation fee. The convention concerning who pays these taxes differs from jurisdiction to jurisdiction. In some jurisdictions that impose these taxes, standard practice has the purchaser and the seller splitting these costs; in other jurisdictions, the seller may pay the transfer taxes and the purchaser may pay the recordation taxes. Regardless of the accepted convention, responsibility for paying these costs can be negotiated between the parties.
The sponsor must build in an estimated cost for the legal and accounting fees that it expects to incur throughout the development process. Regardless of what many sponsors may think, professional fees usually are negotiable. Sponsors should discuss the availability of reduced or discounted fees with the professionals they interview. Sponsors also should discuss a fixed fee versus an hourly fee arrangement with their professionals. With a fixed fee, one mutually agreed-on amount of money covers all the professional services rendered. The professional sets the fee high enough to cover its potential time on the project, hoping that the project will take less time than anticipated and provide a greater profit on the services rendered. The sponsor eliminates the possibility that professional fees will skyrocket and make the project infeasible. An hourly fee arrangement does not provide the sponsor with certainty as to professional fee costs. However, if the professional completes its tasks in less time than originally anticipated, the professional is paid only for actual work performed, not a fixed fee. The sponsor is able to reduce the TDCs or apply the cost savings to other parts of the development budget. (ii) Professional Fees.
55
c04.fm Page 56 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 5:41 PM
PROJECT FEASIBILITY AND TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS
The sponsor must build in an estimated cost for the architectural work that may be required in the development process. Initial schematic drawings, completion of a preliminary building evaluation and cost estimation, bid documents including a full set of drawings and specifications, and site visits during renovation and/or construction are necessary and chargeable activities. If an architect or a construction manager will be used to develop a preliminary building evaluation and rehabilitation cost estimate, the fee must be included in this category. Architectural fees often are negotiable: Discounts may be available and fixed or hourly fee arrangements are possible. (iii) Architectural Fees.
The sponsor must build in the estimated cost for fees that will have to be paid to each lender for the privilege of borrowing money from that institution. These fees, which may be referred to as application, commitment, or origination fees, are imposed in addition to the interest that a lender will charge a borrower over the life of a loan. Generally, lenders will refer to these fees in terms of “points.” Each point, or fraction of a point, is equal to 1 percent or a fraction of 1 percent of the loan amount sought. Assume, for example, that a sponsor is planning on applying for a $100,000 loan from Community Bank in order to purchase a property, and that Community Bank generally commits to a loan of this amount only after the applicant has paid it a commitment fee of 1 point. Under this scenario, the sponsor will have to estimate financing fees of at least $1,000 (1 percent of $100,000), when developing its TDCs during the feasibility period. The TDCs must include projected financing fees that may be incurred by the sponsor when it seeks to borrow money at each step of the development process. The borrower likely will pay these fees when: buying the property (acquisition settlement), improving the property (construction settlement), and repaying the acquisition and construction lenders (permanent settlement). Financing fees of government lenders and other nonprofit lending institutions, however, may be nominal or zero.
(iv) Financing Fees.
(v) Costs to Pay Interest on Loans Prior to Completion. The sponsor may have
to include in the TDCs the costs of paying some or all of the interest that it incurs during the development process. For example, assume that a nonprofit tenant association borrows $4,000,000 to purchase and renovate its 200-unit property at an annual interest cost of $400,000. Assume that the renovation will take a year to complete. If rents from the 100 habitable and occupied units are sufficient to cover operating costs plus $100,000 of the $400,000 projected interest cost during this period, the resident council would estimate an interest carry cost of $300,000 in the TDCs.
56
c04.fm Page 57 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 5:41 PM
4.3 ESTIMATING TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS
The sponsor must include in its TDCs projected legal fees that it will be charged by lenders. To the surprise of many organizations, lenders charge borrowers for the lender’s legal costs incurred in making the borrower a loan. As with financing fees, the sponsor must budget for the payment of lender’s legal fees at acquisition, construction, and permanent settlement. Government lenders and other nonprofit lending institutions may choose not to pass their legal costs on to nonprofit borrowers.
(vi) Lender’s Legal Fees.
(vii) Costs Related to Securing Title Insurance. The sponsor must estimate costs that it will incur to secure title insurance. Generally, these will be the costs of a property survey by an engineer, a search of the jurisdiction’s land records to determine who has what interests in the title of the property (title search), and the premium necessary to secure the appropriate amount of title insurance. These costs are described further in Chapter 16. (viii) Environmental Study. As noted earlier in this chapter, a Phase I study
of the existing environmental conditions of the property must be conducted. The cost of this study—and, potentially, a subsequent Phase II study—should be included in the TDCs. The sponsor should enlist the help of environmental engineering firms in estimating the cost to conduct these environmental studies. (ix) Appraisal. As discussed in Chapter 3, the sponsor must estimate a cost for securing an appraisal of the property. The sponsor may have to budget for more than one appraisal if multiple lenders are contemplated. If an appraisal will be used to establish the value of the property for purchase purposes, that cost must also be included in this category.
The sponsor must estimate costs that it is likely to incur for licenses and permits required by local law for the operation of rental housing or homeownership entities. These costs may vary, based on the type of housing sought to be developed. For example, rental housing laws may require a sponsor to obtain a license to operate an apartment building for rental purposes, but a similar license may not be required for a condominium association.
(x) Licenses and Permits.
The sponsor must estimate costs that may have to be paid to the local, county, or state government for the privilege of converting a property into a condominium or cooperative for the purpose of selling the units to homeowners. These fees may be assessed whether the property was previously used for rental purposes or was built solely to provide homeownership opportunities.
(xi) Conversion Fees.
57
c04.fm Page 58 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 5:41 PM
PROJECT FEASIBILITY AND TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS
Depending on the jurisdiction, the sponsor may have to pay local, county, and/or state government fees for: •
Holding an election by the tenants to determine their interest in converting the property, if required.
•
Certifying the results of the election.
•
Transferring the converted unit to a purchaser.
Nonprofit sponsors must become familiar with their jurisdiction’s regulation of conversions and determine whether a waiver of these fees can be obtained by nonprofit developers. (xii) Marketing Expenses. The sponsor must estimate what amount it will
spend to market the units, for rental or sale, to the public. These expenses would include advertising and sales commissions to real estate agents who bring renters or purchasers to the property to fill vacant units. To complete these estimates early in the feasibility process, the sponsor must project how many units it expects to have for sale or rental to the public and the average percentage of commission that would be due to real estate agents for their services. For example, if a tenant association intends to buy a 12-unit building and 10 of the existing residents are committed to buying their units, the association would have to estimate a marketing cost to fill only the two uncommitted units. This budget entry may be zero if the association has a realistic waiting list for these units. Otherwise, the association would have to estimate the sales price for each vacant unit (assume $40,000), determine the average real estate commission paid in that community (assume 6 percent) and budget $4,800 for marketing expenses ($40,000 plus $40,000 times .06). Temporary or permanent relocations of residents may be required to make the affordable housing project feasible. The costs of these relocations must be estimated and included in the TDCs. Temporary relocation costs often are incurred by sponsors when residents are moved out of a property and then return to it when construction is completed. Sponsors often pay moving expenses and supplement the increased rent costs faced by residents in their temporary accommodations. Sponsors may be required to pay reasonable moving costs, housing counseling costs, and, for a period of months after relocation, the difference between a relocated resident’s prior rent and the new rent if a resident is displaced permanently as a result of the sponsor’s actions. Many states and the federal government (in the Uniform Relocation Assistance (xiii) Relocation Expenses.
58
c04.fm Page 59 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 5:41 PM
4.3 ESTIMATING TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS
and Real Property Acquisition Policies Act of 1970)48 have detailed programs and protections for displaced residents. Because compliance with these regulations may be extremely costly, sponsors should plan the development wisely, to minimize displacement costs. The sponsor may consider estimating an amount of money that could be used to “prefund” a replacement reserve for the property. A replacement reserve is considered “prefunded” when a sponsor deposits a significantly large amount of money in the replacement reserve account early in the project’s life—for example, when it settles on the acquisition or permanent loan for the property. Prefunding a reserve allows the sponsor to have some resources available to replace items that are not part of the property’s basic systems during the first year or two of ownership and that are not being replaced as part of the initial scope of rehabilitation without significantly increasing costs to residents. (See Chapter 18, Selective Rehabilitation, for more information) Although all of a property’s basic systems—heat, air conditioning, water supply, waste, roofing, and electricity—should be replaced when the property is rehabilitated, in some cases, where funds are limited and systems have an expected remaining useful life of five or more years, these systems are kept in place. The “prefunded” reserve would act as a safety net for these older systems while the reserve is being built up with additional dollars coming from operations. (A more complete discussion of replacement reserves is given in Chapter 5.)
(xiv) Prefunded Replacement Reserves.
The sponsor should consider building a soft cost contingency into its soft cost estimate. Following the recommendation for estimating the construction cost contingency, discussed above, the sponsor would develop what it believes is a realistic soft cost estimate and then add 5 percent to 10 percent to that estimate, to cover the uncertainties affiliated with real estate development. An original soft cost estimate of $100,000 would be budgeted at $110,000, for feasibility purposes, to allow for a 10 percent soft cost contingency.
(xv) Soft Cost Contingency.
48
See 49 C.F.R. pt. 24 for the implementing regulations for this program.
59
c04.fm Page 60 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 5:41 PM
SAMPLE LETTER OF VALUE
A P P E N D I X
4 A
Sample Letter of Value Mr. John Q. Jones 4900 Brookeway Lane Smithville, GA 33345 Re: Kalorama Towers 123 Kalorama Avenue Smithville, GA 33345 Dear Mr. Jones: As requested, I have researched the market area for the above-referenced property. The purpose has been to establish a preliminary value range for the subject property both “As Is” and “Post-Rehab.” In addition, I have outlined several neighborhood trends. A brief discussion of my findings is presented as follows: MARKET AREA/NEIGHBORHOOD The subject market area is located within Smithville in Jones County. Smithville’s official boundaries extend beyond the border into Delray County. The overall market area extends to the east to Darnestown, Eaglebury, and Needham. It extends to the north to Phillipsburg. The market area encompasses a mix of residential (both single-family and multifamily), commercial uses (strip shopping centers and plazas, and small office parks). Singletary State University occupies a large area to the northeast. The immediate subject neighborhood is located along the Kalorama Avenue corridor, just south of University Boulevard. It is residential in character with apartment buildings and strip commercial uses along Kalorama Avenue. PROPERTY VALUES (GROSS RANGES) Single-Family Detached Homes Flats Apartment Buildings Condominium Units Efficiencies One-Bedroom Two-Bedroom Three-Bedroom
—$90,000 to $150,000 —$100,000 to $200,000 —$32,500 to $36,000 per unit —$30,000 to $50,000 —$40,000 to $60,000 —$45,000 to $70,000 —$57,000 to $75,000 60
c04.fm Page 61 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 5:41 PM
PROJECT FEASIBILITY AND TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS
Rents Efficiencies One-Bedroom Two-Bedroom Three-Bedroom
—$400 to $510 per month —$500 to $640 —$645 to $735 —$725 to $840
Trends Property Values—Overall property values have been appreciating and continue to do so due to the market’s relative location within the Smithville Metro Area. In addition, the area is considered fully developed. Very little vacant land exists; therefore, the market competition for existing housing stock remains in balance. Single-family homes have outperformed condominiums and cooperatives in their appreciation in value. Rent Controls—Currently, rents are monitored by the City of Smithville and Jones County for all multifamily buildings. Allowable rent increases are established on a yearly basis. The allowable rent increases have been around 4 percent annually in recent years. Multifamily Housing Stock—The existing supply of rental apartments has remained stable since the 1970s, due to lack of available land and to economics. These buildings, although well maintained, are in need of major rehab as they age. Upgrading of existing buildings will put upward pressure on rental rates, which will be allowed to exceed the allowable rent control rates. Condominiums—This particular market has accepted the condominium form of ownership since the 1970s. Typically, conversions of large-scale projects were slowly absorbed. The condominium concept is fairly well understood by the market at this time. Financing—Real estate transactions are financed both conventionally and by FHA or VA. Government financing is prevalent in this area because of relative property values and buyer income levels. Conversion—Condo conversions have taken place on a small scale because of economics. Income levels make it more difficult to qualify buyers. SUBJECT PROPERTY The subject property, Kalorama Towers, consists of two high-rise towers totaling 447 residential apartment units. The buildings were constructed in the 1964– 1968 period. They contain a mix of efficiencies, one-bedroom, two-bedroom, and three-bedroom apartments. The buildings are of concrete and brick, good quality overall. Maintenance over the years has been good overall. Normal wear and tear has taken its toll in certain areas and will require rehabilitation as is typical for this type of property, given its age. (continues)
61
c04.fm Page 62 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 5:41 PM
SAMPLE LETTER OF VALUE
SUBJECT VALUE “As Is” The existing property, as a viable income-producing property, is best valued on both a direct comparison basis or market approach and an income approach. My examination of the subject market has revealed that $34,000 to $36,000 per unit is realistic for this type of property. From an income capitalization point of view, it appears that buildings in this area have sold based on an 8 percent cap rate plus or minus. Both of these approaches tend to indicate a value range for the subject property of $15,000,000 to $16,000,000. “POST-REHAB” Assuming a rehab of the existing property as outlined in the preliminary building evaluation by The Design Group, Inc. dated April 1, 1993, the subject’s value would be enhanced due to increases in the rent structure or a potential sellout of the individual units as a cooperative or condominium conversion. Looking at the potential increase in value conservatively, as a rental property, a value range of $18,500,000 to $19,500,000 appears realistic as the first year’s rents are adjusted. The values are subject to the attached limiting conditions, [not shown here].
62
c04.fm Page 63 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 5:41 PM
PROJECT FEASIBILITY AND TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS
A P P E N D I X
4 B
Summary of Key Federal Regulations Governing Underground Storage Tanks 1. Definition. An underground storage tank (UST) is a tank and piping holding an “accumulation of regulated substances” that has 10 percent or more of its volume underground. 2. Exemptions. Tanks exempt from federal regulations include, among others, any underground storage tank system whose capacity is 110 gallons or less; any tank used for storing heating oil for consumptive use on the premises where stored; septic tanks; and USTs that hold less than 1,100 gallons of motor fuel for noncommercial purposes. 3. Performance Standards. A “new” UST system is one for which installation began after December 22, 1988. All new USTs must meet the design, construction, and installation requirements promulgated under 40 C.F.R. § 280.20. An “existing” UST system is one for which installation began on or before December 22, 1988. No later than December 22, 1988, all existing UST systems must meet new UST system performance standards defined in 40 C.F.R. § 280.20, or be upgraded under 40 C.F.R. § 280.12(b), or be closed pursuant to 40 C.F.R. § 280.70–74. 4. Generally: a.
b. c.
Corrosion. All USTs and piping must be protected from corrosion using either either cathodic protection, fiberglass coating, or other comparable means. USTs installed before December 22, 1988 can use some otherwise prohibited retrofit approaches. Spill and overfill protection. All USTs must be protected from spills and overfills. Leaks. New USTs must have leak detection capabilities such as automatic tank gauging in conjunction with monthly inventory control or monitoring performed at least monthly.
63
c04.fm Page 64 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 5:41 PM
KEY FEDERAL REGULATIONS GOVERNING UNDERGROUND STORAGE TANKS
d.
Financial responsibility. Owners must be able to demonstrate they are financially equipped, through insurance or other means, to pay to clean up a leak or compensate others for injuries or property damage.
5. Reporting and Record Keeping. All owners of UST systems must submit the following information:
c.
Notification for all UST systems, which includes certification of installation for new UST systems, within 30 days of the date the UST is first used. Reports of all releases or suspected releases (investigated and results reported within 7 days). Corrective actions planned or taken.
d.
Notification before permanent closure or change in service.
a.
b.
All owners must maintain the following information: a.
b. c. d.
Documentation of operation of corrosion protection equipment including required inspections and tests of the corrosion protection system. Compliance with release detection requirements. Documentation of UST system repairs or upgrades. Results of the site investigation conducted at permanent closure, kept for at least three years after closing the UST.
6. Out-of-Service UST Systems and Closure. If a UST system is temporarily closed, owners must continue operation and maintenance of corrosion protection and release detections systems. However, release detection is not required if the UST system is empty. The UST system is empty when all materials have been removed so that no more than 2.5 centimeters of residue, or .3 percent by weight of the total capacity of the system, remain in the system. If a UST system is temporarily closed for three months or more, owners must leave vent lines open and functioning and they must cap and secure all other lines, pumps, manways, and ancillary equipment. If a UST complies with the new tank standards or has been upgraded, it may remain indefinitely in a temporarily closed condition. For USTs not complying with the new tank standards, or USTs which have not been upgraded, if a system is temporarily closed for more than 12 months, owners must permanently close the system if it does not meet either performance standard for new UST systems (40 C.F.R. § 280.20) or upgrading requirements (40 C.F.R. § 280.21). Spill and overfill requirements do not have to be met. Owners not wishing to permanently close a UST system at the
64
c04.fm Page 65 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 5:41 PM
PROJECT FEASIBILITY AND TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS
end of the 12-month period may apply for an extension upon the completion of a state assessment. Owners must notify the proper agency of their intent to permanently close or make a change in service of an UST system at least 30 days prior to beginning such actions. After notification, owners must measure for the presence of a release according to the requirements of 40 C.F.R. § 280.72. If a release is detected, owners must begin corrective action. To permanently close a tank, owners must empty and clean it by removing all liquids and accumulated sludges and must either remove it from the ground or fill it with an inert solid material. Continued use of an UST system to store a nonregulated substance is considered a change in service. Before a change in service, owners must empty and clean the tank, removing all liquid and accumulated sludge.
65
c04.fm Page 66 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 5:41 PM
RELEVANT LAWS AND REGULATIONS GOVERNING LEAD-BASED PAINT
A P P E N D I X
4 C
Summary of Relevant Laws and Regulations Governing Lead-Based Paint 1. On March 6, 1996, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) published a final rule, “Lead; Requirements for Disclosure of Known Lead-Based Paint and/or Lead-Based Paint Hazards in Housing,” (61 FR 9064-9088). For more information on lead paint contact the following website: www.hud.gov/lead/leadwnlo.html. 2. HUD Notification to Residents and Prospective Purchasers. HUD must use an EPA-approved pamphlet (“Protect Your Family From Lead In Your Home”) to notify residents and prospective purchasers of housing that is HUD-owned or HUD-assisted, or property owners applying for HUD assistance, including mortgage insurance, that a property was constructed prior to 1978 and may contain leadbased paint, and must indicate the hazards and symptoms of leadbased paint poisoning. If lead paint is known to have been used on the property, HUD must also notify residents and prospective purchasers as to the location of the lead-based paint and the condition of the painted surfaces, and provide them with any records or reports concerning lead-based paint on the unit, and in common areas if applicable. 3. Prohibition of the Use of Lead-Based Paint. Lead-based paint is strictly prohibited in HUD projects. 4. Abatement of Lead-Based Paint Hazards in HUD-Owned or HUDAssisted Housing. The 1992 Residential Lead-Based Paint Hazard Reduction Act requires inspections of these properties to determine the existing risk or the reduction of hazards during a rehabilitation of the property, if the project receives less than $25,000 per unit in federal funds; and abatement of the hazards, if more than $25,000 in federal funds are provided for the rehabilitation project. The 1992 Act designates inspection and removal of lead-based
66
c04.fm Page 67 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 5:41 PM
PROJECT FEASIBILITY AND TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS
paint as allowable costs and activities under various FHA mortgage insurance programs and for HOME, HOPE, and Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) funds. These various programs are discussed in Chapters 6 and 7. 5. Abatement of Lead-Based Paint Hazards in Federally Owned Properties Prior to Their Sale by the Federal Government. All properties owned by the federal government that were built prior to 1960 must be inspected and lead-based paint risk assessment performed. Additionally, all lead-based paint hazards must be abated before the properties are transferred. For properties built between 1960 and 1977, a lead-based paint inspection must be completed and the inspection report provided to prospective purchasers.
67
c04.fm Page 68 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 5:41 PM
c05.fm Page 69 Monday, March 6, 2006 11:59 AM
C H A P T E R
F I V E 5
Determining Projected Income and Expenses 5.1 Introduction 69
5.6
5.2 Projecting Income— Generally 70
Projecting Expenses— Generally 74
5.7
5.3 Identifying Targeted Income Levels 70
Evaluating Past Operating Expenses 75
5.8
Projecting Expenses Where No Operating History Exists 77
5.9
Allowances and Reserves
5.10
The Role of Lenders
5.4 Determining Affordability as a Percentage of Income and Market Rents 71 5.5 Income from Nonresidential Use 74
5.1
80
83
Appendix 5A Controllability of Expenses 84
INTRODUCTION
When a sponsor has completed its TDC estimate, its next feasibility task is to develop income and expense projections for the property. If a sponsor is considering developing rental housing or cooperative housing,1 it must determine the amount of annual income it can reasonably expect to earn from the entire property through rents, and the amount of annual expenses that it can reasonably expect to incur in operating the entire property, exclusive of debt service. The funds that remain (after paying 1
As discussed in Chapter 14, rental housing and cooperative housing often are financed as commercial properties, with one or more blanket loans secured by the property. Lending institutions consider the overall income and expenses of these types of properties before making lending decisions. Sales of condominiums and single-family homes, on the other hand, primarily are financed through individual loans. Lending institutions consider the individual income and expenses of the borrower/homeowner before making lending decisions. For purposes of this chapter, cooperative carrying charges are assumed to cover all of the expenses of operating the property. This is not always the case. For example, if utilities are separately metered, the cooperator will have to pay the monthly cooperative charge and the additional utility costs. Sponsors should be conscious of additional housing costs not included in cooperative or condominium fees when developing their feasibility analysis for a property.
69
c05.fm Page 70 Monday, March 6, 2006 11:59 AM
DETERMINING PROJECTED INCOME AND EXPENSES
expenses) would be available to pay debt service and/or provide a return on investment to investors. If a sponsor is considering developing single-family as well as condominium homes, its task will be similar but its approach to it will be different. For purposes of projecting income for these types of homeownership, “income” will be the income available to the homeowner to pay housing costs, not the income earned by the sponsor or the property owner from rents or carrying charges. In addition, for single-family homeowners, “expenses” will be the costs likely to be incurred directly by the homeowner in operating and maintaining the home. In the case of a condominium, where many expenses are common to all units (e.g., management fees, trash collection, and landscaping), the annual expense projection should include costs incurred directly by the family (e.g., gas for cooking, homeowner’s insurance) and the common costs or condominium fees incurred by the property as a whole. These individual and common fees associated with condominium ownership are referred to as “condominium costs.” 5.2
PROJECTING INCOME—GENERALLY
To accurately project income, the sponsor must: 1. Identify targeted income levels or the income levels of the individuals or families for whom the sponsor is trying to provide rental or homeownership housing. 2. Determine how much these individuals or families at these targeted income levels can afford to pay each year for housing. 3. Determine which rental units, if any, will be occupied by tenants who earn above the targeted income levels, and how much rent these units will be able to generate in the open market. 4. Project other income that can be earned from laundry facilities, commercial space, parking, and so on. As noted in Chapter 4, the term “rent” is used throughout this book to refer to monthly housing costs incurred by an occupant, whether in a rental or ownership setting, unless otherwise specified. Generally, terms like “carrying charges,” “co-op fees,” or “condo fees,” not “rent,” will be used in cases of ownership. 5.3
IDENTIFYING TARGETED INCOME LEVELS
The sponsor’s first step toward projecting the future income from rents, or the rent stream that can be expected from the property, is to identify or
70
c05.fm Page 71 Monday, March 6, 2006 11:59 AM
5.4 DETERMINING AFFORDABILITY AS A PERCENTAGE OF INCOME
target the expected income level(s) of the persons whom the sponsor is seeking to house in the project. This threshold issue is important because any rents that the sponsor will seek to charge can be only a reasonable percentage of the total income available to the residents. The following example may help to clarify the “reasonable percentage.” Assume that a nonprofit sponsor is seeking to convert a rental property to a housing cooperative for the benefit of the existing residents. Assume also that the sponsor is seeking to complete the project with little or no displacement. The sponsor would have to base future income projections (from cooperative carrying charges) in its feasibility study on a reasonable percentage of the existing incomes of the current residents. If the same rental housing project was 100 percent vacant, the sponsor could set a targeted income level—for example, persons earning 60 percent or less of the area median income—as the anticipated income level or even set multiple income levels for the property, with some units at 60 percent of the area median and others at or above the area median. A sponsor seeking to develop a partially tenanted property could mix these approaches. For example, assume five units of a ten-unit apartment building were occupied. Assume further that the sponsor would like to target three of the vacant units to persons earning 60 percent of the area median income and the remaining two units to anyone who can pay the market rent. The sponsor would identify these income levels and then move on to the step described in the next section, to see what income levels could reasonably be expected from this mix of units. If income is insufficient, the sponsor could consider increasing the mix of upperincome residents, in effect, to subsidize the lower-income residents. 5.4
DETERMINING AFFORDABILITY AS A PERCENTAGE OF INCOME AND MARKET RENTS
Once the sponsor is able to target the specific income levels of the future residents, it must decide what percentage of those incomes will likely be paid out by the residents for monthly housing costs (for rent in rental housing, for cooperative carrying charges in cooperative housing, and for condominium costs in condominium housing). HUD, as a general rule, assumes that residents should not pay more than 30 percent of their income for monthly housing costs.2 If the sponsor is using HUD programs, such as HOPE VI, HUD funds passed through to local jurisdictions, such as Community Development Block Grants (CDBG), or the Low Income Housing Tax Credit,3 it may be required to utilize this or a 2 3
The Section 8 rental assistance program, described in Chapter 11, is based on this principle. For a more detailed discussion of these programs, see Chapter 9.
71
c05.fm Page 72 Monday, March 6, 2006 11:59 AM
DETERMINING PROJECTED INCOME AND EXPENSES
substantially similar standard. If no HUD funds are used and local, county, or state funding sources do not require a similar percentage test for affordability, the sponsor may be able to use a more aggressive percentage, such as 32 percent to 35 percent. As an example, assume that the sponsor, during the feasibility phase, is attempting to determine the future income potential for the ten-unit property described in the previous section. As a first step, the sponsor would identify the existing incomes of the current tenants and the projected incomes for persons at the targeted income levels. Assume that 60 percent of the median income in this area is $18,000 for a family of two. The sponsor’s analysis would be: Step 1 Unit No. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Status
Targeted Income
Occupied Occupied Occupied Occupied Occupied Vacant—reserved for 60% of median Vacant—reserved for 60% of median Vacant—reserved for 60% of median
$10,000 actual 10,000 actual 10,000 actual 10,000 actual 10,000 actual 18,000 18,000 18,000
Next, the sponsor must determine what percentage of these projected incomes reasonably can be committed to rent. Assuming it is 30 percent of the annual income, the rental projections would be:
Step 2 Unit No.
Targeted Income
Annual Rent @ 30% of Income
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
$10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 18,000 18,000 18,000
$3,000 3,000 3,000 3,000 3,000 5,400 5,400 5,400
Monthly $250 250 250 250 250 450 450 450
Finally, to project rents for the remaining two units, the sponsor must determine what rents could be charged in the market for these units. Assume that market rents are $500. The final chart would read as follows:
72
c05.fm Page 73 Monday, March 6, 2006 11:59 AM
5.4 DETERMINING AFFORDABILITY AS A PERCENTAGE OF INCOME
Step 3 Unit No. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Projected Annual Rent Stream
Targeted Income
Annual Rent @ 30% of Income
$10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 18,000 18,000 18,000 — —
$3,000 3,000 3,000 3,000 3,000 5,400 5,400 5,400 — —
Annual Rent @ Market
$6,000 6,000
Monthly $250 250 250 250 250 450 450 450 500 500
$31,200 + $12,000 = $43,200
The sponsor always must be concerned about projecting rents that are higher than the market can bear, even if these rents are within 30 percent of the residents’ income. Rarely will a sponsor be able to get existing residents to pay more than the market will bear for rent unless they are already paying it. More importantly, a sponsor will be unable to attract residents for the vacant units, or convince lenders that it will be able to do so, if the projected rents are above the market rents. Thus, if the market rents for the above building were $350 per month, not $500, the chart and potential rent stream would be quite different because the maximum annual rent would be $350 × 12 months, or $4,200, not $5,400:
Unit No. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Projected Annual Rent Stream
Targeted Income
Annual Rent = Lesser of 30% or Market
Monthly
$10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 10,000 18,000 18,000 18,000 — —
$ 3,000 3,000 3,000 3,000 3,000 4,200 4,200 4,200 4,200 (at market) 4,200 (at market)
$250 250 250 250 250 350 350 350 350 350
$36,000
73
c05.fm Page 74 Monday, March 6, 2006 11:59 AM
DETERMINING PROJECTED INCOME AND EXPENSES
5.5
INCOME FROM NONRESIDENTIAL USE
The final piece of the income portion of the feasibility study is projecting what income, if any, can be earned from nonresidential use of the property. Nonresidential income is rarely if ever an issue for developers of single-family homes. Common sources of nonresidential income are: •
Laundry facilities.
•
Vending machines.
•
Parking spaces.
•
Storage spaces.
•
Application fees.
•
Utility charges for telephone, cable, and Internet access.
A less common but potentially significant source of income is rental of commercial space. Where ground-level space can be used or created for commercial purposes—grocery or convenience store, dry cleaner, hair stylist—the sponsor may be able to use market-rate income generated from commercial rents to “subsidize” the rents of residential tenants. These commercial facilities, if coordinated and/or sponsored by the sponsor, also can act as sources for job training and jobs for the residential tenants. Certain housing cooperatives, however, must be careful not to generate too much income from nonresidential sources because the cooperative’s members could lose their right to deduct on their individual tax returns their portion of mortgage interest and property taxes paid during the tax year.4 5.6
PROJECTING EXPENSES—GENERALLY
The final step in completing the revenue and expense portion of the feasibility study is to estimate operating expenses. Generally, this estimate will be completed by analyzing past operating expenses, if they exist, determining the likely expense categories that the sponsor will incur in operating the property, and estimating the reasonable costs for each category, including the appropriate vacancy, replacement, and operating reserves. Vacancy, replacement, and operating reserve issues generally are not considered when developing single-family homes. 4
I.R.C. § 216 allows shareholders in a cooperative housing corporation to deduct their portion of mortgage interest and property taxes paid to the cooperative as an itemized deduction for federal income tax purposes under certain circumstances. This deductibility will be lost, however, if more than 20 percent of the cooperative’s gross income for the year is paid by parties other than cooperative shareholders. This means that a well-managed housing cooperative that seeks to provide tax deductibility of these payments to its shareholders must be sure not to generate more than 20 percent of its income from the rental of commercial space.
74
c05.fm Page 75 Monday, March 6, 2006 11:59 AM
5.7 EVALUATING PAST OPERATING EXPENSES
Annual operating expenses in the industry are often referred to by their per-unit amounts; a sponsor will be described as spending $3,000 (or whatever amount) per unit per year to operate the property. This perunit cost is derived by taking the annual total operating expenses—say, $36,000—and dividing it by the number of units in the property—say, 12. The figure includes all costs actually applicable to the individual units as well as the common areas. 5.7
EVALUATING PAST OPERATING EXPENSES
The sponsor should evaluate the prior years’ income and expense statements for the property if the property was operating during that period. Three years’ worth of statements, if available, would provide the sponsor with a good basis of knowledge. (A sample income and expense statement can be found in Appendix 14A.) For new construction or where the sponsor is contemplating a substantial gutting and rehabilitation of an existing structure, past history will be unavailable or irrelevant. See Section 5.8. Where past history is available and relevant, the sponsor may consider it in the following manner: 1. Determine an average annual cost for each expense category. An expense category is an individual line item on the statements; electricity and property taxes are two examples. An average annual cost for each category would be determined by adding up the total annual cost for that category in each of the years for which information is available and then dividing that amount by the number of years for which information was available. For example, if three years’ electricity expenses are available and statements reflect that $10,000 was spent on electricity in 1996, $8,000 in 2002, and $9,000 in 2004, the average annual cost would be $9,000 ($10,000 + $8,000 + $9,000 = $27,000 divided by 3, or $9,000). By using the average cost over a multiyear period, the sponsor can avoid relying too heavily on any one year that may have included extraordinary, nonrecurring costs. 2. Adjust average annual cost figures, if necessary. After this average annual cost is determined for each expense category, the sponsor must then evaluate each category to determine whether adjustments to these average expense figures should be made in the feasibility study. Adjustments may be caused by the following factors:
Inflation—an upward adjustment, based on projected inflation rates, in order to have the estimated or budgeted figure more accurately reflect future estimated costs.
75
c05.fm Page 76 Monday, March 6, 2006 11:59 AM
DETERMINING PROJECTED INCOME AND EXPENSES
Changes in services provided—an upward or downward adjustment, based on changes in services envisioned by the sponsor. For example, if the current owner provided only 12-hour daily security at the property for the past three years and the sponsor is considering increasing the security to 24 hours per day, the average expense for “security” would have to be increased accordingly.
Changes in policies or goals—an upward or downward adjustment, based on changes in policies or goals envisioned by the sponsor. For example, a housing cooperative may determine that, to establish a sense of responsibility and community, each member will be responsible for maintaining the landscape at the property for one week per year. The expense category “landscaping” could be adjusted downward by the sponsor if the current owner had been paying to have the property landscaped professionally.
Changes in the owner’s approach to controllable expenses—an upward or downward adjustment, based on changes that the sponsor intends to make in the handling of certain controllable expenses. For vehicle expenses, uniforms, employee apartment rental costs, and similar expenses, the owner may be able to completely control the level of expenses incurred or even eliminate these costs entirely. These costs often are referred to as controllable costs. Other costs, such as management fees and vacancy losses, for example, are controllable up to a certain point but then must be incurred at some level. These costs may be referred to as partially controllable costs. A chart showing the controllability of costs faced by a sponsor appears as Appendix 5A. The sponsor has the ability to evaluate the current owner’s treatment of controllable costs and may make changes that would require an adjustment of an average annual cost. For example, the sponsor may determine that the two maintenance persons that it expects to have on staff at the property will not be required to wear uniforms. Costs for uniforms would then be reduced or eliminated in the feasibility study.
Utility and property tax rate changes—an upward adjustment (or, in the unlikely case, a downward adjustment), based on utility rate and property tax rate changes that have been requested and granted or are likely to be granted. Generally, the sponsor will have to determine the likelihood of such rate changes by speaking with local regulatory agencies and government officials.
Changes in vacancy and collection losses—a downward adjustment, based on changes envisioned by the sponsor in this area. For
76
c05.fm Page 77 Monday, March 6, 2006 11:59 AM
5.8 PROJECTING EXPENSES WHERE NO OPERATING HISTORY EXISTS
example, the sponsor, in conjunction with a local banking institution, may seek to have all future residents make monthly rental payments through a direct deposit into the sponsor’s rent accounts. This approach will reduce vacancy and collection losses significantly. The sponsor would make the appropriate downward adjustment in the projected vacancy and collection loss category of its feasibility study.
5.8
Changes in deposits to reserves—an upward or downward adjustment, based on changes envisioned by the sponsor. Operating and replacement reserves are discussed in detail below; however, there are numerous scenarios where the sponsor would want to estimate an operating and/or replacement reserve expense figure that is quite different from the historical average. For example, if the current owner has not budgeted for operating reserves, the sponsor would want to do so. Replacement reserves budgeting also may differ because of the owner’s intentions. For example, suppose that the current owner, for the past three years, has been budgeting for a replacement reserve at a high level, on the theory that the reserves must be sufficient to cover imminent failure of the building’s systems. If the sponsor intends to fully replace the existing systems during the rehabilitation of the property, future payments to the replacement reserve could be significantly less because of the improved condition of the property. The sponsor’s feasibility study should reflect these realities. PROJECTING EXPENSES WHERE NO OPERATING HISTORY EXISTS
Projecting future operating expenses where no history exists is a more difficult proposition. The sponsor must be able to project an annual cost for each expense category, as discussed above, but without any historical basis as a guide. To complete this task, the sponsor must perform the following steps: 1. Determine which expense categories apply to the property. Following are the most common expenses faced by owners of multifamily properties, although some categories apply equally to single-family homes:
Professional management—Most owners of real estate, except singlefamily homeowners who occupy their homes, hire professional management companies to manage their properties, especially if they are multifamily properties. Management companies, often for a fee based on the percentage of rents collected, provide rent
77
c05.fm Page 78 Monday, March 6, 2006 11:59 AM
DETERMINING PROJECTED INCOME AND EXPENSES
collection services, monthly income and expense statements, and advice as to preventive maintenance and repairs.
Maintenance and repairs—Every property, regardless of its current condition, will incur costs to maintain or repair the building(s) and their improvements. Items such as painting, groundskeeping, landscaping, and building and unit maintenance and repairs can be listed as separate categories in the budget.
Payroll—This category would be necessary only if the sponsor intends to have on-site staff at the property.
Payroll taxes and benefits—Generally, if the sponsor has on-site staff, it will have to budget for the taxes and benefits that the sponsor-employer will incur.
Property insurance—Aside from a situation where a property may be in such poor condition as to make it uninsurable, almost every property would have this expense category.
Water and sewer—Even if each unit is individually metered for water and sewer consumption, every property will incur these costs because of water and sewer charges that apply to common areas such as lobby bathrooms, lawn sprinkling, and so on.
Gas, electric, and fuel—The sponsor first must determine what type of energy will be used for appliances (gas or electric) and for heat and hot water (gas, electric, or oil). The sponsor will likely incur costs in each of these categories, even if each unit is individually metered for these services, because of usage in the rental office, lobby, and common areas.
Maintenance contracts—The sponsor often will find it cost-effective to maintain some assets, such as an elevator, swimming pool, and boiler, under a maintenance contract with a private vendor. If this approach is appropriate for the property in question, the sponsor would include this expense category.
Licenses and permits—The local, county, or state jurisdiction may require housing licenses and permits to be secured for a fee.
Office expenses and telephone—The sponsor would include this expense category if it will have on-site offices or telephones for use by on-site staff.
Advertising—A rental property will have costs of advertising to fill vacancies as they occur. Ownership housing would not usually have this expense category because each owner would incur any expense to advertise the sale of his or her unit. Limitedequity cooperative housing may be an exception to this rule.
78
c05.fm Page 79 Monday, March 6, 2006 11:59 AM
5.8 PROJECTING EXPENSES WHERE NO OPERATING HISTORY EXISTS
This type of cooperative may incur advertising costs if the cooperative’s bylaws require the cooperative to buy back units from shareholders when they wish to move, and then to resell them to the public. Limited-equity cooperatives are discussed in greater detail in Chapter 14.
Accounting and legal fees—Every property will incur these costs to some extent, whether the property is operated for rental or home-ownership purposes. Accounting costs for rental, cooperative, and condominium properties likely will include an annual audit by certified public accountants and the preparation of local, state, and federal tax returns for the property. These properties also are likely to incur legal fees for evicting nonpaying residents or homeowners, assisting the sponsor or ownership association in the conduct of its corporate affairs, and enforcing the rules established to regulate resident and homeowner use of the property.
Real estate taxes—Every sponsor must budget for the payment of annual real estate taxes unless the property is located in a jurisdiction that provides some tax relief to properties operated by nonprofit organizations. The sponsor should discuss with legal counsel, during the feasibility phase, the possibilities of applying for and receiving permanent or temporary property tax exemption or deferral. See a further discussion of this in Chapter 11.
Personal property taxes—Some jurisdictions tax the personal property—cars, equipment, and so on—of the sponsor. During the feasibility phase, the sponsor must determine whether the local jurisdiction assesses these types of taxes and discuss with legal counsel the possibilities of applying for and receiving permanent or temporary exemption or deferral.
2. Determine the estimated annual expense for each category that has been identified—This estimate can be completed using one of the following methods or a combination of both:
Gather operating information from similar properties—The best alternative to having an operating history for the property in question is to get the operating history of a property that is similar in size, use, and geographic location. A sponsor may be able to secure an operating history by contacting management companies that manage properties that appear similar, by contacting owners of neighboring properties, and by having the management company that is a member of the sponsor’s development team contact the managers (if any) of these properties.
79
c05.fm Page 80 Monday, March 6, 2006 11:59 AM
DETERMINING PROJECTED INCOME AND EXPENSES
If this information can be secured, the sponsor should evaluate each category, as described above. Should the annual expenses of the sponsor’s property be adjusted upward or downward (if at all)? Should additional expense categories be added to reflect operations unique to the property, such as health services, counseling, day care, and similar facilities? Answers to these and other questions will vary from property to property.
5.9
Gather information from the Institute of Real Estate Management (IREM)—The IREM conducts national and regional studies of average operating costs for certain types of properties.5 The sponsor can use these average costs as a basis for its projections or, prior to developing its final budget figures, for comparison with operating expense information gathered about similar properties.
ALLOWANCES AND RESERVES
In addition to estimating annual operating expenses by category, a sponsor of a multifamily property must include in its feasibility study an annual allowance for vacancies and bad debts and annual contributions to separate operating reserve and replacement reserve accounts. (a)
Vacancies and Bad Debts
Property owners rarely can point to a year when they can boast of having received, every month of the year, the full amount of rent from all of the units in a particular property. Inevitably, for a variety of reasons, rents were not received or only partial rent was received from one or more units over the year. The owner may have needed to keep a unit vacant for a month, for remodeling; or the occupant may have moved out without notice or without payment of the last month’s rent. The sponsor must budget for the fact that it will not actually receive all of the rents that it had hoped to realize during the year. Therefore, the sponsor must project, in its feasibility study, the amount of rent that it expects not to collect. This amount, often referred to as a vacancy allowance, includes nonpayment due to vacancies as well as nonpayment of past-due rent that the owner never was able to collect. The allowance is usually estimated as a percentage of the total possible rents collectible during the year. A 5 percent to 10 percent vacancy rate is not uncommon; however, the rate should be established by each sponsor
5
See note 35 in Chapter 4.
80
c05.fm Page 81 Monday, March 6, 2006 11:59 AM
5.9 ALLOWANCES AND RESERVES
based on the vacancy rate experienced by similar properties in the same geographic location. For example, assume that a sponsor is seeking to purchase a ten-unit apartment building that the sponsor believes has the ability to provide $100,000 in income for the year. If the average vacancy rate for properties of that capacity in that area is 10 percent, then the sponsor should budget the vacancy allowance at 10 percent of $100,000, or $10,000. This vacancy allowance is usually shown in the projected income portion of the feasibility study, as an offset to income. (b)
Operating Reserves
Operating reserves are funds set aside by the sponsor to cover unexpected fluctuations in actual operating expenses during the year. These reserves are critical to the financial health of a property for the following reasons: 1. The annual expense estimates developed by the sponsor for each expense category are nothing more than best-guess estimates of future activity. These estimates almost certainly will be a little higher or lower than actual costs. 2. These estimates can never account for unforeseen circumstances. The operating reserve provides the sponsor with a cushion to absorb unexpected costs and modest cost increases incurred during operations, without jeopardizing the project or passing on rent increases to occupants. Like the vacancy allowance, the operating reserve is usually estimated as a percentage of the total possible rents collectible during the year. A 3 percent operating reserve rate is not uncommon; however, a higher rate might be advisable if the sponsor has little confidence in its annual expense estimates because an operating history for the property was unavailable or because operating histories for similar properties were unavailable. Operating reserves work like this. Assume that a sponsor is seeking to purchase a ten-unit apartment building that the sponsor believes has the ability to provide $100,000 in income for the year. If a 3 percent operating reserve is utilized, then the sponsor should budget an operating reserve of $3,000. This operating reserve is usually shown after all the other expense categories in the feasibility study. At the end of the year, if the operating reserve was not used, the owner can use it to reduce future rent increases, return it to the occupants, or contribute it to the replacement reserve account. Owners of cooperatives and condominiums should review their bylaws to determine whether the bylaws direct the
81
c05.fm Page 82 Monday, March 6, 2006 11:59 AM
DETERMINING PROJECTED INCOME AND EXPENSES
board of directors to treat an ending balance in operating reserves in a certain way. (c)
Replacement Reserves
The replacement reserve basically is a savings account set up by the owner to cover some or all of the costs to replace assets as they are used up (e.g., roof, plumbing, appliances). This reserve is critical to the financial viability of the property. The “savings account” most likely will be the only source of funds available to the owner to replace these assets. Most nonprofit-sponsored projects do not have the flexibility to raise rents to cover these one-time charges and still remain affordable. Similarly, the rent stream usually does not provide enough cash to service more debt should the owner wish to borrow money to pay for these capital improvements. Any private or public lender understands the importance of replacement reserves and will require them in almost every project. The most common way that sponsors determine the appropriate level to fund a replacement reserve is to use a percentage of the total possible rents collectible during the year. A 2 percent replacement reserve rate is not uncommon. This method is used most often where the property: 1. Is new (0 to 5 years old). 2. Has recently undergone a substantial rehabilitation that would allow the sponsor to treat the property as if it were new. 3. Has recently undergone a rehabilitation and the replacement reserve was “prefunded” at that time to give the fund a significant balance at the beginning. Assume, as before, that a sponsor is seeking to purchase a ten-unit apartment building that the sponsor believes has the ability to provide $100,000 in income for the year. If a 2 percent replacement reserve is utilized, then the sponsor should budget a replacement reserve of $2,000. The other method for estimating the appropriate annual contribution to the replacement reserve is to conduct a careful evaluation of the remaining useful lives of the property’s systems (roof, heating, electricity, water/sewer) and to develop a multiyear budget and plan for replacement of these items. The annual contribution will be established by calculating the amount of money that must be collected each year in order to have enough money available to replace systems as they wear out.
82
c05.fm Page 83 Monday, March 6, 2006 11:59 AM
5.10 THE ROLE OF LENDERS
Assume, for example, that a property has these assets with the indicated useful lives and replacement costs:
Asset
Remaining Useful Life (UL)
Replacement Cost (RC)
Roof 10 years $10,000 HVAC 8 5,000 Plumbing 20 40,000 Annual Contribution to Replacement Reserve
Contribution/Year (RC divided by UL) $1,000 625 2,000 $3,625
This reserve is usually shown after all the other expense categories in the feasibility study. 5.10
THE ROLE OF LENDERS
As discussed in Chapter 6, lenders closely scrutinize a sponsor’s expense projections when analyzing a property’s debt coverage ratio. To the extent that the sponsor can base its expense projections on historical data and comparable properties, lenders should be satisfied.
83
c05.fm Page 84 Monday, March 6, 2006 11:59 AM
CONTROLLABILITY OF EXPENSES
A P P E N D I X
5 A
Controllability of Expenses Fixed Expenses Real estate taxes Payroll taxes Property and liability insurance Workers’ compensation insurance Mortgage insurance premiums Mortgage interest Operating reserves Replacement reserves
Partially Controllable Expenses
Controllable Expenses
Vacancy and collection loss Management fee Legal expenses
Petty cash Subscriptions/Dues
Audit expenses
Vehicle expenses
Telephone
Uniforms
Office expenses Miscellaneous administration expense Payroll Fuel Electricity Water and sewer Janitor and maintenance supplies Exterminating Grounds maintenance Painting and decorating Repairs Equipment purchases
Miscellaneous insurance Employee health insurance
Source: National Association of Housing Cooperatives.
84
Employee apartment rent
p03.fm Page 85 Monday, February 20, 2006 5:00 PM
P A R T
T H R E E 2
Raising Capital
p03.fm Page 86 Monday, February 20, 2006 5:00 PM
c06.fm Page 87 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:45 PM
C H A P T E R
S I X 6
Raising Capital to Meet Total Development Costs 6.1 Introduction 87
6.5 Equity and Sales Proceeds
103
6.2 Sources of Capital— Generally 88
Appendix 6A Example of an Amortizing Loan 105
6.3 Loans
Appendix 6B Example of a Nonamortizing Loan 106
88
6.4 Grants 102
6.1
INTRODUCTION
At this stage in the feasibility study, the sponsor now knows two crucial elements of its development plan: 1. How much money it is going to need to do the development or cover its total development costs (TDCs). 2. How much money it will have available, after paying operating expenses, to service any debt incurred in order to meet the TDCs. The sponsor, with this information in hand, then must evaluate all the potential sources of capital—loans, grants, equity, and proceeds from sales of units—to determine if the project can be financed (TDCs covered) by using a combination of these sources. A proposed affordable housing development should be considered feasible if capital sufficient to cover TDCs can be identified from these sources and if income projections1 can 1
Income projections for rental housing and most cooperative homeownership housing would be the income that the owner of the property expects to receive from monthly payments from residents and cooperative shareholders that will be used to meet operating expenses and debt coverage on blanket debt. The financing structure of these types of housing is described more fully in Chapter 19. Income projections in the case of single family or condominium homeownership, however, would be the income available to the homeowners to pay costs incurred to operate their homes and to pay debt service on their individual home mortgages. Financing structures common to these types of housing also are described in Chapter 19.
䡲
87 䡲
c06.fm Page 88 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:45 PM
be expected to cover both the costs of operating the property and the costs of servicing any debt associated with the development’s financing. This chapter defines these basic sources of capital: loans, grants, equity, and sales proceeds. Subsequent chapters identify specific sources of capital that a sponsor should consider applying to for funding: public nonprofit and private for-profit loan funds (Chapter 7), and public sector and private for-profit and nonprofit sector grant programs (Chapter 8). Chapter 9 describes methods for raising equity from the private sector. Chapter 10 highlights resources from public housing. If a project is deemed infeasible because capital funds sufficient to meet TDC could not be identified, then the sponsor should consider pursuing credit enhancement vehicles that are likely to make access to loan proceeds easier and reevaluating TDC to determine if costs can be pared down or paid for by parties other than the sponsor. If a project is deemed infeasible because income expected to be available to pay operating costs and debt service from loans identified by the sponsor will be insufficient, then the sponsor should revaluate initial income and expense projections and consider ways of increasing income (including subsidies) and decreasing operating expenses. This process of revisiting initial assumptions made by the sponsor and of seeking ways to make the project more feasible is described fully in Chapter 11. In most cases, a sponsor should closely analyze TDC, income, and expenses of a project if it is considered “infeasible” after the potential sources of capital have been evaluated. 6.2
SOURCES OF CAPITAL—GENERALLY
A nonprofit sponsor generally will have to secure its TDCs from a number of sources in order to ensure affordability. Nonprofit sponsors commonly have to piece together funds for each housing development from: 1. Loans from private for-profit lenders and from private and public not-for-profit lenders. 2. Grants from private and public nonprofit organizations. 3. Equity from the sponsor, the investors (if any), the purchasers of ownership entities (cooperatives, condominiums, or single-family homes), and the proceeds from the sales of ownership units. 6.3 (a)
LOANS Kinds of Loans a Sponsor Can Anticipate
A sponsor can anticipate having to secure one or more acquisition loans in order to buy a property and (i) Acquisition and Construction Loans. 䡲
88
䡲
c06.fm Page 89 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:45 PM
6.3 LOANS
one or more construction loans in order to build or rehabilitate improvements on the property. Generally, acquisition and construction loans are short-term loans that mature or must be paid back in 12 to 18 months. One lender may provide the sponsor with funds to complete both acquisition and construction, or these loans may be secured from two different lenders. In practice, the sponsor may have difficulty attracting a construction lender if an acquisition lender is already in the deal because of the prior lien position held by the acquisition lender. The construction lender would lend to the sponsor and would be secured by the property; however, because the acquisition lender lent its money and filed its claim against the property first, it would get paid in full before the construction lender received anything in the event of a foreclosure sale. This problem may be avoided if the acquisition lender is willing to share its priority position with the construction lender or if the construction lender is a private or public nonprofit lender willing to take an inferior position. A more complete discussion of lien positions can be found in Section 6.3(d). (ii) Permanent Loans. The sponsor will have to secure one or more permanent loans in order to pay off or “take out” the acquisition and construction loans. These “take out” loans got the name “permanent loans” because they historically have been viewed as the last loans that an owner would ever have to have on a property. These loans have terms of 25 to 30 years with a fixed interest rate. At the end of the loan term, the loan is paid off in full and the owner is debt-free. Permanent loans are still available for single-family and condominium ownership. Sponsors of residential rental and cooperative ownership developments may be able to find similar term loans from public sector lenders, but they are rarely offered by private for-profit lenders. Permanent loans for rentals or housing cooperatives often are treated by the private for-profit lending community as “commercial loans,” not homeowner loans, and they rarely have terms that exceed 10 or 15 years. Some private lenders will provide loans referred to as “mini-perms”; they require payments only of interest and they have terms of 2 to 5 years. Interest rates on these shorter-term “permanent” loans often “adjust” or change periodically; at the end of the loan term, the principal of the loan may have been reduced nominally or not at all. (b)
Common Loan Provisions
Every loan that is obtained by a sponsor, whether from private or public lenders, will carry some variation of interest rates, maturity and amortization, financing fees and other lender charges, and prepayment provisions. 䡲
89
䡲
c06.fm Page 90 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:45 PM
When a lender agrees to lend money, it not only wants the money or principal paid back according to a payment schedule but it also wants the borrower to pay interest on the amount of the original loan that has not yet been repaid. A lender usually determines how much interest it will charge a borrower by considering:
(i) Interest Rates.
1. Interest costs, if any, incurred by the lender to borrow the money that it is lending the borrower. 2. The amount of interest that the lender could earn if it invested its money elsewhere, given similar risks. 3. The amount of interest being earned from investments that the lender will have to liquidate in order to make the loan. 4. The amount of money that the lender will spend over the loan term to service the loan or track the loan and the loan payments. 5. The amount of money (“profit”) that the lender wants to make over and above the direct costs incurred to borrow the money and service the loan. 6. The riskiness of the loan, as perceived by the lender. Historically, if private for-profit lenders lent to nonprofit housing developers at all, the loans carried high rates of interest. These rates reflected the lenders’ views: affordable housing development was too risky, and the amount of time that their staff had to spend to understand this type of development was too burdensome. A decade of successful nonprofit development, the availability of credit enhancements, and Community Reinvestment Act lending, as discussed below, have made the private for-profit sector a critical and more active player in this field. This increased lending activity by private for-profit lenders has made more capital available for nonprofit development. The interest rates on these funds, however, still approximate the going rate of interest in the marketplace. Therefore, the role of the private nonprofit or the public lender who can provide low- or no-interest loans remains crucial to the success of most nonprofit housing development. These low-cost funds, blended with higher market rates of interest, often constitute the last piece of the financing puzzle needed to ensure affordability. All loans carry interest rates regardless of the profit motive of the lender. Interest rates can be “fixed” or constant throughout the loan term, or they can “adjust” or change periodically over the life of the loan. With a fixed interest rate loan, the interest rate on the loan never varies. The borrower pays, during the entire loan term, whatever interest rate it agreed to pay when it secured the loan. If the borrower borrowed
䡲
90
䡲
c06.fm Page 91 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:45 PM
6.3 LOANS
$10,000 at a 10 percent interest rate for 30 years in 1970, the borrower will pay 10 percent interest on that loan until 2000. This will be true even if interest rates during that 30-year period fluctuate from 2 percent to 20 percent. Interest rates on adjustable rate loans, often referred to as adjustable rate mortgages (ARMs), can change frequently over the loan term. Every adjustable rate loan should clearly state when the loan adjusts; how the new, adjusted interest rate will be established; and any limitation on the amount of increase in the interest rate that can be imposed on the borrower on a date of adjustment. ARMs with interest rates that are adjusted once a year, once every three years, or once every five years are common in the industry. However, some ARMs are adjusted every month or even more frequently. Where an interest rate is adjusted every three years, the borrower actually has secured a hybrid fixed and adjustable rate loan. The loan remains at a fixed rate of interest for three years, is adjusted, and then stays “fixed” at the adjusted rate for three more years, continuing in this manner until the end of the loan term. A number of common mechanisms are used for establishing the new, adjusted interest rate. Each of these mechanisms establishes a standard benchmark from which to start and then usually provides for the lender to add a “margin” or a preestablished amount of interest to the benchmark. The prime rate of interest as published in The Wall Street Journal on the date of adjustment; the interest rate paid, as of the date of adjustment, on U.S. Treasury securities having various maturity dates from 30 days to 30 years; and the Federal Home Loan Bank Board Series of Closed Loans for a 30-day period, are common benchmarks. As previously noted, the lender then may be able to add its margin to the benchmark. Lenders’ margins commonly range from 100 basis points (1 percent) to 375 basis points (3.75 percent). Many individual homeowner loans, but few rental or cooperative loans, limit the amount of increase that can be imposed on the borrower at the time of adjustment. Lenders of ARMs to single-family and condominium homeowners, for example, often agree to cap any interest rate increase on any adjustment date at 2 percent. Loans for rental or housing cooperative properties often have no cap. Consider this example. Opportunity Housing, Inc., a nonprofit housing developer, borrows $100,000 for ten years from First National Bank on January 1, 2002. The loan requires Opportunity to pay 10 percent interest for the first three years of the loan. In year 3 and every third year thereafter, the interest rate adjusts to the prime rate of interest as published in The Wall Street Journal on the day of adjustment plus a margin of 225 basis points (2.25 percent) with no cap. During years 1 through 3, Opportunity
䡲
91
䡲
c06.fm Page 92 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:45 PM
pays 10 percent interest. On December 31, 2004, the prime rate of interest is 8.50 percent. As of January 1, 2005, and for the next three years, Opportunity will pay interest of 10.75 percent (the prime rate of 8.5 percent plus the margin of 2.25 percent). The same type of adjustment will be made three years later and three years after that. Generally, all lenders require that their borrowers pay back, by a specific date, the full amount of any principal borrowed and interest incurred during the period of the loan. This due date is referred to as the “maturity date.” The amount of principal and interest that is due on the maturity date will depend on how the loan was amortized. A loan can be fully or partially amortized or not amortized at all. A loan is an amortizing loan if the principal amount of the loan is reduced gradually as a result of periodic payments by the borrower to the lender.2 A loan is considered fully amortizing if the periodic payments are sufficient to completely pay off the loan (including interest) within the term of the mortgage. The most common fully amortizing loans are 30year “permanent” loans or mortgages provided to single-family and condominium homeowners. A borrower of a fully amortizing loan, usually by making equal, periodic payments to the lender during the term of the loan, will have completely paid off the principal and interest by the maturity date. The amount of the last payment, which completes the payback of the loan, is equal in amount to the first payment. A loan is considered “partially amortizing” when the periodic payments reduce only a portion, but not all, of the loan principal during the mortgage term. Most permanent loans provided to rental and cooperative housing developers by the private for-profit sector, as noted above, are partially amortizing loans. Loans are considered “nonamortizing” if the principal amount of the loan is not reduced at all during the term of the mortgage. Most acquisition and construction loans are nonamortizing loans. A partially amortizing loan will be mature after a specific period of time (e.g., 10 years) but will be amortized over a longer period of time, usually 30 years. Thus, the borrower makes equal monthly payments to the lender as if the loan is due and will be fully paid off in 30 years when in fact it will be due in 10 years. At the end of 10 years, the entire amount
(ii) Maturity and Amortization of Loans.
2
This definition and the other definitions of amortization in this chapter are based on definitions in Alvin L. Arnold and Jack Kusnet, The Arnold Encyclopedia of Real Estate 2nd ed. New York: John Wiley & Sons (1978).
䡲
92
䡲
c06.fm Page 93 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:45 PM
6.3 LOANS
of the loan is due, even though only 10 years’ worth of a scheduled 30year principal repayment plan has been met. At maturity, the borrower must pay the entire principal back to the lender; the last payment in the payment schedule increases or “balloons” dramatically. Refer to the example in Appendix 6A. The borrower borrows $100,000 at 10 percent interest per year. The loan has a ten-year term. For the loan to be repaid in full by the end of the loan term, the loan would have to be amortized over a ten-year period. This would cause the monthly payments to be $1,322 per month. To make the monthly payments affordable to the borrower, the lender allows the borrower to pay the loan off as if it is a loan with a 30-year amortization. The monthly payments fall to $878 per month; however, on the maturity date, ten years later, the borrower owes $90,938, not just $878, the amount paid each month for the past ten years. Nonamortizing loans work in a similar way. Generally, these loans do not pay back the principal at all over the term of the loan. The monthly payments include only interest on the principal amount of the loan. At the end of the loan term, the entire principal is due, which causes a dramatic ballooning on the maturity date. The example in Appendix 6B reflects how a nonamortizing loan works. The borrower borrows $100,000 for three years, agreeing to pay only interest each month; interest is 10 percent per year or $833 per month. For the loan to be repaid in full by the end of the loan term, the loan would have to be amortized over a three-year period, which would cause the monthly payments to be $3,227 per month. The borrower ’s monthly costs are significantly reduced by paying only interest, but, at the end of three years, the entire $100,000 is due from the borrower. Because of the nature of these loans, partial and nonamortizing loans are often referred to as “balloon mortgages.” In a balloon mortgage, the entire amount of the principal, which was not paid back as a result of the periodic payments, becomes due on the maturity date; the final loan payment balloons far in excess of previous periodic payments. Generally, on the maturity date, borrowers will replace the partially amortizing or nonamortizing loan with another partially amortizing loan from either the same or a different lender. Historically, the short-term permanent lender will “roll over” the loan, providing the borrower with another loan under the same or similar terms as long as the borrower has been making the loan payments regularly. Recent scrutiny of the savings and loan and commercial bank industry has forced lenders to reevaluate their investments in real estate generally and this practice in particular. Today, borrowers can no longer rely on this rollover with any kind of certainty. However, a loan with a multiyear, unblemished track record is significantly easier to finance than a new loan. 䡲
93
䡲
c06.fm Page 94 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:45 PM
Any nonprofit housing developer of rental or cooperative housing must learn how to manage balloon mortgages. Virtually all acquisition and construction loans will have this feature, and, as noted above, the private for-profit lending community generally will not lend beyond a ten-year period. This means that some or all of the sponsor’s debt may never be fully paid off because it is never set on a fully amortizing basis. Balloon mortgages, however, do allow the nonprofit to access private capital and to reduce monthly mortgage costs from the levels that would be required if the loan was amortized fully over a short period of time. The sponsor should consider establishing a reserve fund and contributing to it throughout the project. The fund will help the sponsor to build capital and thereby reduce principal at the end of the loan term. Moreover, as the loan term nears, the sponsor should constantly seek alternative financing sources for the purpose of converting this partially amortizing debt into long-term, affordable, and fully amortizing debt. Generally, lenders recoup their costs and make a profit from charging interest on their loans and charging fees for the privilege of borrowing their money. Interest, as discussed earlier, is earned throughout the life of the loan. Financing fees are earned prior to or at the time when the loan is provided. Some fees are direct pass throughs of costs incurred by the lender; other fees are charged as a flat amount or percentage of the loan to cover the lender’s staff time for underwriting or considering the loan request and profit. The following are common fees and charges:
(iii) Financing Fees and Other Lender Charges.
•
Application fee—A lender usually charges a flat fee to consider a loan application. Some lenders will waive this fee for nonprofits or will charge the borrower only if the loan is provided. Many public and private nonprofit lenders do not charge application fees.
•
Commitment fee—A commitment fee usually is assessed as a percentage of the total amount of the loan that the lender agrees to provide. The fee must be paid by the sponsor in order to receive the lender’s written commitment to make the loan and only after the bank has committed verbally to make the loan to the borrower. Most public and private nonprofit lenders do not charge a commitment fee.
•
Loan discount or origination fee—A lender may charge the borrower a loan discount fee at the time when the loan is provided. This fee, usually assessed as a percentage of the loan provided, allows the lender effectively to increase the interest rate on the loan indirectly. For example, if the lender provides the borrower with a $1,000,000 loan at 10 percent interest per year, amortized over 30 years, the 䡲
94
䡲
c06.fm Page 95 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:45 PM
6.3 LOANS
regular monthly payments to fully amortize the loan would be $8,820. However, if the lender also charges a 1 percent discount fee for the loan, the borrower must pay $10,000 at the time it borrows the money. This $10,000 cost, if paid over the life of the loan, would increase the monthly costs by $28. At $8,848 per month ($8,820 + $28), the lender is obtaining a 10. rate of interest, not 10 percent (.10). Most public and private nonprofit lenders do not charge these fees. •
Appraisal fee—As noted in Chapter 4, the lender will order an appraisal of the property from a list of its approved appraisers. Lenders will seldom accept an appraisal from an appraiser selected by the borrower. The lender will require the borrower to pay for the appraisal, often in advance of both the appraisal’s completion or the lender’s commitment to the project. Many public and private nonprofit lenders will accept the appraisals performed for other lenders participating in the project. To the extent possible, in order to limit uncertainty, sponsors should negotiate with lenders in advance to predetermine the appraisal cost and all related costs.
•
Credit reports—Most lenders will require the borrower to pay the costs incurred to secure a credit report on the borrower and/or its principal partners.
•
Property inspection fee—Many lenders, especially construction lenders, will hire an architect or construction manager to inspect the property prior to payment of a draw request. These costs will be passed on to the borrower.
•
Attorney’s fee—The lender will pass through to the borrower all of its legal costs incurred to process and close the loan.
All of these costs should be reflected in the soft costs portion of the sponsor’s feasibility study. Many borrowers learn long after they have borrowed money from one or more lenders that those lenders will not let them pay off their loans any time they wish to do so. Some loans cannot be paid before their maturity date for any reason, others can be prepaid only at certain times, and others can be prepaid only upon payment of a prepayment penalty, which can be as much as 4 percent or 5 percent of the outstanding amount of the loan. Lenders often have good reasons for these prepayment restrictions; for example, they may be facing similar restrictions imposed on them by the secondary markets to which they will be selling the loan (see Chapter 11). The important point about prepayment provisions is that the sponsor must be aware that they may exist in the loan agreement and must be
(iv) Prepayment Provisions.
䡲
95
䡲
c06.fm Page 96 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:45 PM
sure that they do not conflict with any fundamental financial assumptions. For example, assume that the sponsor is borrowing $100,000 today at 10 percent interest per year, with the full loan due in 30 years. Assume further that: 1. The sponsor has been actively raising grant funds and intends to fully pay off the $100,000 next year from these contributions. 2. The project cannot afford to pay the 10 percent interest or any part thereof from operating income beyond next year. If the $100,000 loan has a prepayment provision that does not allow the borrower to pay off the loan at all for five years, the sponsor simply cannot use the $100,000 to pay off the loan next year. Instead, it will be legally obligated to pay the 10 percent interest for five years, imposing a debilitating cost on the project and potentially bankrupting the housing development. (c)
Security Required by Lenders
A lender generally will not make a real estate loan unless it knows that it has some protections, other than the borrower’s promise to pay, in case the borrower fails to pay off the loan according to plan. These protections are considered “security” to the lender in case of a loan default. Lenders generally require borrowers to provide security in the form of a mortgage or deed of trust, an assignment of leases and rents, or security agreements for chattels and other tangible property (UCC-1). A mortgage or a deed of trust gives the lender a legal “security” interest in the property. These two instruments are almost identical and serve identical purposes. They provide the lender with the legal power, after a loan default by the borrower, to sell the property in order to raise funds equivalent to the unpaid portion of the borrower’s loan. Some jurisdictions use mortgages, others use deeds of trust. A mortgage is an instrument used in some states to make real estate security for a debt. It is a two-party instrument between the mortgagor (the borrower) and the mortgagee (the lender). A deed of trust serves the same purpose but is a three-party instrument among a trustor (the borrower), a trustee (designated by the lender to act on its behalf), and the beneficiary (the lender).3 A mortgage or deed of trust must be recorded in the land records of the jurisdictions where the property is located. An additional description of mortgages and deeds of trust can be found in Chapter 16. (i) Mortgage or Deed of Trust.
3
Id.
䡲
96
䡲
c06.fm Page 97 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:45 PM
6.3 LOANS
An assignment of leases and rents gives the lender a legal “security” interest in property leases and the rents generated by these leases. This instrument generally allows the lender, in case of a loan default by the borrower, to control who leases what space in the property and to receive the rents paid by the occupants. These powers provide the lender with security in two ways:
(ii) Assignment of Leases and Rents.
1. The lender ensures that any vacant space is leased to reliable, paying occupants by controlling the leases. 2. The lender ensures that any rents paid will go directly to the lender, not to the borrower. Many lenders record this assignment in the land records of the jurisdiction where the property is located. (iii) Security Agreements for Chattels and Other Tangible Property (UCC-1).
A security agreement for chattels and other tangible property gives the lender a legal “security” interest in everything else (apart from the real estate itself) that is owned by the borrower at the property. The mortgage or deed of trust provides the lender with legal protections as to the land and improvements (real property); the security agreement provides the lender with legal protections as to everything but the land (personal property). This agreement, commonly referred to under the Uniform Commercial Code of most states as a UCC-1, provides the lender with the legal power, after a loan default by the borrower, to sell the personal property—light fixtures, lawn mowers, and maintenance trucks, for example—in order to raise funds equivalent to the unpaid portion of the borrower’s loan. A UCC-1 may or may not be recorded in the land records. However, it must be recorded in the appropriate government office in the jurisdiction where the property is located.4 (A sample UCC-1 can be found in Appendix 16A.) (d)
What Lenders Look for in a Project
A lender generally will consider the following issues when evaluating or “underwriting” a loan request. As noted in Chapter 3, a nonprofit housing developer often does not have the net worth and/or track record sufficient to command a lender’s respect and confidence. Therefore,
(i) Track Record of the Development Team.
4
Lenders will not be satisfied simply because they have recorded a security interest in the real and personal property of the borrower and the leases and rents. They will want to know that these security interests allow them to get paid first if these assets have to be sold and not take what is left over after someone else is paid. This lien priority issue is discussed below.
䡲
97
䡲
c06.fm Page 98 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:45 PM
the borrower has to convince the lender of its abilities and credibility vicariously, through the members of its development team. The lender will look for development team members who have experience in the type of real estate development for which the borrower is seeking funds. The lender will look very carefully at each line item and category in the sponsor’s income and expense projections, including reserves, to determine their reasonableness. Generally, the lender will want to know the assumptions on which the projections were based. If the projections were based on past operating history of the property, the lender will often request copies of the income and expense reports for the periods reviewed. The lender will be very concerned about income and expense projections because it will want to make sure that there will be enough net operating income (NOI)—the money left over after paying all expenses—to cover the debt service on its loan and any other debt anticipated by the borrower.
(ii) Reasonableness of Income and Expense Projections.
(iii) Debt Coverage Ratio. Even after the lender is able to convince itself of the reasonableness of the income and expense projections, it will still not be satisfied. Lenders generally will want to see that the income and expense projections actually provide enough NOI to cover the debt service and to create a cushion for unanticipated expenses. Lenders evaluate the sufficiency of NOI by analyzing the debt coverage ratio for the project—the ratio between NOI and the debt service projected for the project.5 If NOI is $10,000 and debt service is projected at $7,500, the debt coverage ratio is 1.33 ($10,000 ÷ $7,500). A 1.33 ratio means that, after all debts are paid, the project still has 33 percent of NOI available to pay other costs. The higher the debt coverage ratio, the less risk there is to the lender. Public and private nonprofit lenders may be satisfied with a debt coverage ratio of 1.05; private for-profit lenders may require as much as a 1.30 debt coverage ratio. For a project with a 10 percent vacancy allowance, a 3 percent replacement reserve, a 2 percent operating reserve, and a debt coverage ratio of 1.30, the income projections for the project must be 45 percent higher than the actual projected operating costs, simply to meet all these reserve and ratio requirements.
A lender generally will not provide a borrower with a loan in an amount equal to or greater than the appraised value of the property that is serving to secure repayment of the loan. Although some public lenders may provide loans that equal 100 percent of the property’s value, most lenders lend only a portion of the appraised value
(iv) Loan-to-Value Ratio.
5
See Arnold and Kusnet, supra note 1.
䡲
98
䡲
c06.fm Page 99 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:45 PM
6.3 LOANS
of the property. The relationship between the amount of a mortgage loan and the value of the real estate that secures it is known as the loan-tovalue (LTV) ratio.6 For example, if a sponsor is seeking to purchase a property appraised at $100,000 and the lender utilizes a 75 percent LTV ratio, the borrower will be able to borrow only $75,000 from that lender. Why will lenders lend only less than 100 percent of a property’s value? Lenders understand that they will not be able to sell the property for 100 percent of its value if they have to foreclose on the property after a borrower’s default and then sell the property to realize the defaulted amount. The lower the LTV ratio, the less risk of nonpayment upon default. In addition, lenders often do not have the discretion to lend at a high ratio. Laws and regulations set the maximum LTV that some lenders, such as commercial banks and savings and loans, can utilize. Federal banking regulators have adopted final regulations that establish the following guidelines for maximum LTV ratios for all commercial banks and savings and loans: raw land, 65 percent; land development, 75 percent; commercial construction, 80 percent; residential construction, 85 percent; and improved property and farmland, 85 percent. The regulations also state that permanent loans on residential properties are expected to carry private mortgage insurance if the LTV ratio exceeds 90 percent. These guidelines do not apply to loans guaranteed by federal or state governments, problem loans that must be refinanced or restructured, loans that facilitate the sale of foreclosed properties, and loans that will be promptly sold into the secondary market.7 A lender generally will not want to make a loan to a borrower if another lender or entity previously has recorded a claim against the real and/or personal property that is being offered by the borrower to secure the loan. Parties who record claims first have the right to have their debt paid first, in the event of a foreclosure sale of the property. This priority is called a first lien position. The higher the lien position, the less risk there is to the lender that its debt will not be repaid upon foreclosure. Consider this example. A sponsor borrows $100,000 in order to purchase a ten-unit apartment building on January 1, 2005. There are no prior claims on record against the property. At the time of the loan, the entity that lent the $100,000 will record its mortgage or deed of trust and an assignment of leases and rents in the land records and will record its UCC-1 in the appropriate government office. These actions will provide the lender with a first lien position as to all of these assets. (v) Lien Priority Position/Good Title.
6 7
Id. 12 C.F.R. 34.62 (1998). Appendix A to subpart D of Part 34—Interagency Guidelines for Real Estate Lending.
䡲
99
䡲
c06.fm Page 100 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:45 PM
The sponsor then seeks another $100,000 loan to complete the rehabilitation of the property. If the rehabilitation loan lender makes this loan and records its interests in the appropriate government records on February 1, 2005, it will have a second lien position as to all the real and personal property of the borrower. If the borrower defaults on March 1, 2005, and the property is sold for $75,000, the entity holding the first lien position receives all of the proceeds of the sale plus foreclosure costs up to a maximum of the amount of loan outstanding at the time of sale. The second lienholder receives whatever is left over. The first lienholder would receive $75,000 and the second lienholder would receive $0. The first lienholder is provided the greatest amount of security, and each lienholder that claims an interest subsequently is provided less and less security. If for-profit lenders are being asked to provide loans that can be secured only in a second position or worse, the lenders either will not participate or will charge a higher interest rate to reflect the increased risk. Therefore, to get participation by for-profit lenders in a multiloan transaction and to secure lower interest rates, for-profit lenders almost always obtain a first lien position and public and private nonprofit lenders usually agree to subordinate their preexisting claims or to take an inferior lien position to a for-profit lender even if the nonprofit lenders’ loan amount is greater.8 A lender will determine what lien position is being offered by the borrower by reviewing the title insurance commitment on the property. The title insurance commitment, as discussed in greater detail in Chapter 12, will reflect any and all claims against the property that are on file in the appropriate government records. A lender’s concerns about the creditworthiness of a borrower can be minimized if the lender knows that it will be able to sell the loan into the secondary market as soon as the loan is closed. The lender must worry more about the borrower’s ability to repay the loan if the loan is going to be held in the lender’s portfolio throughout the loan term. A discussion of the criteria and standards set by the major players in the secondary market—Federal National Mortgage Association (Fannie Mae), Government National
(vi) Ability to Sell the Loan in the Secondary Market.
8
A lender can be provided with a first lien position, even if another entity previously has recorded a claim against the borrower’s assets, by getting the first lender to subordinate its prior claim to the claims of the new lender. This subordination agreement (or amended UCC-1, in the case of personal property) among the first lender, the new lender, and the borrower would be filed in the appropriate records in the jurisdiction where the assets reside and would provide the new lender with a first lien position. In the example above, if the government provided the sponsor with the $100,000 acquisition loan and secured a first lien position, it would not be unusual for the government to subordinate its first lien position to the rehabilitation loan lender in order to get that entity to participate in the transaction.
䡲
100
䡲
c06.fm Page 101 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:45 PM
6.3 LOANS
Mortgage Association (Ginnie Mae), and Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation (Freddie Mac)—for purchasing real estate loans is provided in Chapter 11. (vii) Ability to Have Repayment of the Loan Guaranteed or Insured. A lender’s
concerns about the creditworthiness of a loan also can be minimized if the lender knows that the repayment of the loan will be guaranteed by a personal or corporate guarantee or insured by a state or federal agency. Given the substantial default problems faced with real estate loans provided by commercial banks and savings and loans in the 1980s, many lenders are requiring developers to guarantee their loans with their own personal or corporate assets. These loans are known as recourse loans. If the borrower has assets sufficient to secure repayment of the loan upon default, then the lender will be less concerned about the economic viability of the real estate project being financed. The same is true if the borrower can insure repayment of the loan by securing a state or federal mortgage insurance commitment. In most cases, given the limited resources of most nonprofit sponsors, personal or corporate guarantees are not sufficient insurance for a lender. These guarantees often supplement other guarantees or insurance. A discussion of third-party guarantees and federal mortgage insurance programs, many of which have served as models for similar state insurance programs, is provided in Chapter 11. Lending institutions may be willing to be more flexible in their underwriting in order to meet their general commitment under the federal Community Reinvestment Act (CRA)9 or to meet their specific community reinvestment commitments made with local community organizations. Under the CRA, commercial banks and savings and loans have a statutory responsibility to meet the credit or lending needs of the low- and moderate-income communities in which they do business. The CRA states that these lenders have a continuing and affirmative obligation to meet these needs while simultaneously observing safe and sound operations. In reality, lenders are seldom sanctioned for failing to meet this obligation. However, over the past ten years, community organizations have challenged financial institutions’ performance in this area by objecting to federal regulators when the institutions have requested a merger, acquisition, new branch opening, change in charter, or acquisition of federal deposit insurance. As a result of these challenges, many banks have made multimillion-dollar and multiyear commitments to provide financing to low- and moderate-income communities, which should make
(viii) Community Reinvestment Act Considerations.
9
12 U.S.C. § 2901 et seq.
䡲
101
䡲
c06.fm Page 102 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:45 PM
financing for nonprofit, affordable housing development more plentiful. For example, in 2004, Bank One Corporation merged with J.P. Morgan Chase and Company and committed to invest $800 billion in communities across the country over the subsequent ten years. Key aspects of this commitment included $675 billion in mortgages for minority and lowincome communities, $90 billion in loans and investments to assist small businesses and community-based organizations, and $35 billion in loans and investments for affordable housing, commercial and economic development in low- and moderate-income communities. Similarly, beginning in 2005, Bank of America will lend and invest at least $100 billion in community development in the Northeast as part of its acquisition of Fleet Bank. The loan package includes home mortgages, small business loans, economic development financing, as well as $115 billion for affordable housing. Nonprofit sponsors must become aware of the existence of similar agreements in their communities and aggressively seek their financing from these sources. A description of various loan programs and sources of loan funds is provided in Chapters 7 and 11. (e)
Making a Loan Application More Attractive to a Lender
As noted earlier, a nonprofit sponsor’s loan will be more attractive to lenders if the loan has credit enhancement and/or can be sold by the lender on the secondary market. Even if these mechanisms are not available to a sponsor, a loan may be made more attractive and a project more financially feasible by: 1. Increasing the property’s income through operating subsidies. 2. Reducing the property’s operating costs through exemptions, waivers, or deferrals of certain operating expenses. 3. Reducing the TDCs by acquiring properties at little or no cost. These issues are discussed and described fully in Chapter 11. 6.4
GRANTS
Grants are sums of money that must be spent in an agreed-on manner but, unlike debt incurred with loans, do not have to be paid back. The more grants a nonprofit sponsor is able to obtain to help meet its TDCs, the less it has to borrow from lending institutions or raise through equity. Lenders and sponsors like grants and equity because neither requires debt service payments each year. The lower the debt, the lower the required debt service payments. Lower payments make it easier for the borrower to meet lender debt coverage ratios and for the lender to agree to lend the 䡲
102
䡲
c06.fm Page 103 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:45 PM
6.5 EQUITY AND SALES PROCEEDS
money. The ability or inability of a sponsor to raise grant funds for a project often makes or breaks a proposed development. If history is any guide, nonprofit housing developers in the 1990s will continue to find their need for grant funds far exceeding the availability of these funds from all sources. A discussion of various grant programs and sources for grant funds is provided in Chapter 8. 6.5 (a)
EQUITY AND SALES PROCEEDS Equity
Equity is money contributed by the sponsor to the housing development. In the case of resident-sponsored conversions of rental housing to homeownership, equity is likely to be contributed in the form of down payments made at the time of settlement on the individual ownership interests. In most cases, however, the equity is expected to be committed by the sponsor early in the development process and not contingent on sales of units. Like grants, these funds do not have to be paid back. Unlike grants, however, there are no restrictions on how the money must be spent because it is the sponsor’s own money. The more equity a sponsor can raise to help meet its TDCs, the less it has to borrow from lending institutions or raise through grants. Lenders like grant funds because they free a project from additional debt service payments, but they like equity even more because it requires the sponsor to make a real cash commitment to the project. The higher the amount the sponsor has invested in the project, the more comfortable the lender will be with investing in the project as well. The higher the equity, the lower the debt and the lower the required debt service payments. A low level of debt will make it much easier for the borrower to meet lender debt coverage ratios and for the lender to agree to lend the money. A discussion of various methods for raising equity is provided in Chapter 9. (b)
Proceeds from the Sales of Homeownership Housing
Proceeds from the sponsor’s sales of homeownership housing, particularly single-family homes and condominium units, although not technically equity, are a critical source of debt-free capital that will be available to the sponsor in order to meet the TDCs or to be used for other purposes such as establishing a down-payment assistance fund for purchasers, capitalizing a replacement or operating reserve, or capitalizing a reserve to be used to subsidize monthly costs for the homeowners. The proceeds from these sales are a debt-free source of capital to the sponsor, but the money does not come without a cost. Most homebuyers have to incur costly debt in order to provide these sales proceeds. The monthly costs to 䡲
103
䡲
c06.fm Page 104 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:45 PM
the homebuyers to maintain this debt must not make the project unaffordable to the clientele targeted by the sponsor. This source of capital is less common in the development of housing cooperatives for low- and moderate-income families, especially limitedequity cooperatives. In most cooperative developments targeted for these income levels, as described in Chapters 14 and 19, purchasers assume a portion of the blanket debt on the property and do not secure their own financing. The only capital provided in these types of homeownership sales is a nominal down payment or purchase price for the share.
䡲
104
䡲
c06.fm Page 105 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:45 PM
RAISING CAPITAL TO MEET TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS
A P P E N D I X
6 A
Example of an Amortizing Loan Option I: Option II:
amortize the loan amortize the loan
fully over balance is as if a 30 balance is
Principal Interest Rate (annual) Term (years) Payment (annual) Amortization
10 year term; at end of 10 years, zero year term; at end of 10 years, $90,311.
Option I Option II --------------$100,000 $100,000 10.0% 10.0% 10 30 $16,275 $10,608 Full Balloon (Yr 10)
END OF YEAR 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
O P T I O N I ----------------------------------------BALANCE PRINCIPAL INTEREST PAYMENT 100,000 93,725 6,275 10,000 16,275 86,823 6,902 9,373 16,275 79,231 7,592 8,682 16,275 70,880 8,351 7,923 16,275 61,693 9,187 7,088 16,275 51,588 10,105 6,169 16,275 40,472 11,116 5,159 16,275 28,245 12,227 4,047 16,275 14,795 13,450 2,825 16,275 0 14,795 1,480 16,275
END OF YEAR 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
O P T I O N I I ----------------------------------------BALANCE PRINCIPAL INTEREST PAYMENT 100,000 99,392 608 10,000 10,608 98,723 669 9,939 10,608 97,988 736 9,872 10,608 97,179 809 9,799 10,608 96,289 890 9,718 10,608 95,309 979 9,629 10,608 94,233 1,077 9,531 10,608 93,048 1,185 9,423 10,608 91,745 1,303 9,305 10,608 90,311 1,433 9,174 10,608
䡲
105
䡲
c06.fm Page 106 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:45 PM
EXAMPLE OF A NONAMORTIZING LOAN
A P P E N D I X
6 B
Example of a Nonamortizing Loan Option I: Option II:
no amortization over the 3 year term; at end of 3 years, the loan balance is still $100,000 amortize fully over 3 year term; at end of 3 years, the loan balance is $0.
Principal Interest Rate (annual) Term (years) Payment (annual) Amortization
Option I -------$100,000 10.0% 3 $10,000 None
Option II -------$100,000 10.0% 3 $40,211 Full
END OF YEAR 0 1 2 3
O P T I O N I ----------------------------------------BALANCE PRINCIPAL INTEREST PAYMENT 100,000 100,000 0 10,000 10,000 100,000 0 10,000 10,000 100,000 0 10,000 10,000
END OF YEAR 0 1 2 3
O P T I O N I I ----------------------------------------BALANCE PRINCIPAL INTEREST PAYMENT 100,000 69,789 30,211 10,000 40,211 36,556 33,233 6,979 40,211 0 36,556 3,656 40,211
䡲
106
䡲
c07.fm Page 107 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:50 PM
C H A P T E R
S E V E N 7
Sources of Capital: Loans 7.1 Who are Possible Lenders? 107 7.2 Sources of Loan Funds from Public Lenders— Generally 107
7.5 Sources of Loan Funds From Private For-Profit Entities 138 7.6 Sources of Loan Funds from Private Nonprofit Entities 149 Appendix 7A 501(c)(3) Bond Terminology 218
7.3 Sources of Loans from State and Local Governments 108
Appendix 7B List of Local CDFI Organizations Financing Housing 219
7.4 Sources of Loans from the Federal Government 128
This chapter and the four chapters that follow were developed as reference tools for nonprofit sponsors, not necessarily to be read from beginning to end. Each of these chapters identifies programs that are available primarily to nonprofit housing developers. Where programs apply only to specific types of housing development—for example, multifamily rental, transitional housing for the homeless, or housing for the elderly—these restrictions are highlighted. 7.1
WHO ARE POSSIBLE LENDERS?
As discussed previously, nonprofit sponsors likely will have to seek loans from various sources: public lenders, private for-profit lenders, and private nonprofit lenders. Therefore, sponsors must be aware of all of the possible types of lenders and all of the specialized loan programs that might be available. This chapter identifies direct lenders of funds. Chapter 11 identifies additional programs, such as mortgage insurance, that sponsors may be able to use to secure loan funds from lenders highlighted in this chapter or others. 7.2
SOURCES OF LOAN FUNDS FROM PUBLIC LENDERS—GENERALLY
Public lenders generally include state and local governments (cities, counties, and municipalities) as well as the federal government. Many state and local programs, as described below, have been created from
107
c07.fm Page 108 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:50 PM
SOURCES OF CAPITAL: LOANS
funds passed through by the federal or state government to local jurisdictions. Participation by public lenders in a nonprofit housing development is usually critical to the success of the project. Public lenders, depending on the program and its source of funds, often can: 1. Provide no- or low-interest loans. 2. Provide fully amortizing permanent financing with 30-, 40-, or 50year amortization periods. 3. Provide financing up to and in some cases exceeding 100 percent of the value of the property (see discussion of loan-to-value ratio in Chapter 6). 4. Accept a lien priority position behind other lenders, which is something that traditional lenders will not do. 5. Provide down-payment assistance loans that serve as permanent no- or low-interest loans as long as the low-income individual or family resides in the property. 7.3 (a)
SOURCES OF LOANS FROM STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENTS Community Development Block Grants
The federal government, specifically the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), passes through millions of dollars to states, counties, and cities each year through the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) program. The money is intended to be used in a wide range of community development activities directed toward neighborhood revitalization, economic development, and improved community facilities and services. Metropolitan cities of at least 50,000 people, other local governments designated as central cities of metropolitan areas, and urban counties with populations of at least 200,000 are entitled to receive annual grants directly from the federal government. States have the option of administering CDBG funds for communities that are not entitled to direct government grants. Communities have broad discretion in determining how best to use these funds. They develop their own programs and funding priorities and consult with local residents before making final decisions. All CDBG activities must either benefit low- and moderate-income people, or aid in the prevention or elimination of slums and blight, or address other serious and immediate community development needs, At least 70 percent of CDBG funds must be used to benefit low- and moderate-income people either in the form of specific assistance to low- and moderate-income
108
c07.fm Page 109 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:50 PM
7.3 SOURCES OF LOANS FROM STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
people, or in the form of generalized programs that benefit communities with majority low- and moderate-income residents. CDBG activities that can be carried out with community development funds include acquisition of real property or demolition and clearing of property in anticipation of other land use; rehabilitation of residential and nonresidential properties; provision of public facilities and improvements, such as water and sewer, streets, and neighborhood centers; assistance to profit-motivated business to help with economic development activities; job-training, welfare-to-work, and other activities designed to help people obtain employment; public assistance to youth, the elderly, or disabled people; crime reduction activities including neighborhood watches and demolishing abandoned buildings; direct financial assistance to low-income homebuyers through methods such as down-payment assistance, subsidzed interest rates or reduced closing costs; enforcing building codes to maintain existing structures; and paying for administrative costs. These funds can be granted or loaned to individuals or entities that are furthering a community’s CDBG goals. Many CDBG communities use these funds to provide low- or no-interest property acquisition, construction and/or permanent financing for affordable housing development, and/or homeownership. Sponsors must check with their state, county, or local housing department or housing finance agency to determine the availability of CDBG funds for nonprofit housing development. (b)
Community Development Block Grants Loan Guarantees
Communities entitled to CDBG funds can use their right to future CDBG allocations to guarantee loans for housing rehabilitation, economic development, and large-scale physical development projects. Section 108 of the Housing and Community Development Act of 1974, as amended, is the loan guarantee provision of the CDBG program. Under this program, the CDBG community pledges its current and future CDBG funds as the principle security for the loan guarantee. The guarantee may secure a private loan for a borrower or a loan from a public agency. The guarantees, commonly referred to as Section 108 loans on loan guarantees, can be used to secure loans for: •
CDBG-eligible economic development activities.
•
Real property acquisition.
•
Rehabilitation of publicly owned real property.
•
Housing rehabilitation eligible under the CDBG program.
•
Related relocation, clearance, and site improvements.
109
c07.fm Page 110 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:50 PM
SOURCES OF CAPITAL: LOANS
•
Construction, reconstruction, or installation of public facilities.
•
Interest payments on the guaranteed loan and issuance costs of public offerings.
•
Debt service reserves.
•
Public works and site improvements in the Colonias.
In addition, the guaranteed loan funds may be used to finance housing construction by nonprofit organizations when undertaken as part of a project financed under the Housing Development Grants (HODAG) or Nehemiah Housing Opportunity Grants programs, two formally active HUD programs. Loan guarantees are discussed in greater detail in Chapter 11. Economic Development Initiative (EDI) or Brownfield Economic Development Initiative (BEDI) grants may also be combined with loan commitments in order to pay predevelopment costs of a CDBG-funded project. EDI and BEDI grants may also be used as a loan loss reserve, to write–down interest rates, or establish a debt service reserve. As with the CDBG program, all projects and activities must principally benefit low- and moderate-income people, or assist in eliminating or preventing slums or blight, or meet other community development needs having particular urgency. (c)
The HOME Program: HOME Investment Partnerships
Congress created the HOME Program (HOME) as part of the National Affordable Housing Act of 1990 (NAHA). HOME was designed to stimulate the formation of creative local, state, and federal partnerships for the purpose of meeting community housing needs, with a special emphasis on nonprofit, community-based housing development organizations. HOME provides federal grants, through HUD, to states, units of local government, and Indian tribes to implement local housing strategies designed to increase homeownership and affordable housing opportunities for low- and very low-income Americans. As in the CDBG program, this will meet the community’s affordable housing needs. Participating jurisdictions may use HOME funds in ways that are crucial to nonprofit housing development—loans, grants, interest rate subsidies, rental assistance, security deposits, and equity. HOME funding may be used to provide incentives and support for affordable housing development that offers permanent housing for disabled homeless persons, transitional housing, and single-room occupancy housing. 1 The funds
(i) Use of HOME Funds.
1
NAHA, § 212(a)(1), as amended.
110
c07.fm Page 111 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:50 PM
7.3 SOURCES OF LOANS FROM STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
may be used for site acquisition, site improvements, demolition, housing rehabilitation, new construction, relocation, and other necessary and reasonable activities related to the development of HOME-eligible housing, for tenant-based rental assistance, and for assistance to first-time homebuyers. Funds also may be used on a limited basis for administrative costs; however, they may not be used for public housing modernization, matching funds for other federal programs, operating subsidies for rental housing, or activities under Title VI. (See the discussion of Title VI in Chapter 8.) The Multifamily Housing Property Disposition Reform Act of 1994 (“the Act”), P.L. 103-233, made a number of changes to the HOME program. One important change simplifies the income targeting requirements for HOME funds when they are being sued for rental housing. Under the Act, not less than 90 percent of the families receiving the benefits of HOME funds must have incomes not exceeding 60 percent of area family median income. The remainder of HOME funds utilized for rental housing must go to either to: (1) families that qualify as low-income families (other than those who meet he 60 percent or area median requirement; or, (2) dwelling units occupied by such low-income families. This amended income-targeting language will make it easier for jurisdictions to comply with program rules without forfeiting the income-targeting goals of the legislation. Current HOME rules require participating jurisdictions to contribute 25 percent of the total funds drawn from the jurisdiction’s HOME Investment Trust Fund in a fiscal year with respect to rental assistance, housing rehabilitation, and substantial rehabilitation. For new construction, a 30 percent match is required. Section 205 of the 1994 Reform Act amended the matching requirement by eliminating the higher 30 percent match for new construction. Instead, there is now a 25 percent match for all funds drawn from the jurisdiction’s HOME Investment Trust Fund for “housing that qualifies as affordable housing under this title.” The 1994 Act also allows HOME administrative costs to be paid for from CDBG program funds. Similarly, the Act allows CDBG funds to be used for housing counseling in connection with tenant-based rental assistance, energy auditing, preparation of work specifications, loan processing, inspections, tenant selection, management of tenant-based rental assistance, and other services related to assisting owners, tenants, contractors, and other entities participating under affordable housing programs assisted under Title II of the Cranston-Gonzalez National Affordable Housing Act (including HOME program). (ii) HOME Matching Requirements.
111
c07.fm Page 112 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:50 PM
SOURCES OF CAPITAL: LOANS
Many cost limitations are imposed by federal regulations on HOME funds. Among them are:
(iii) Limitations on the Use of HOME Funds.
2 3 4 5 6
•
Maximum per-unit cost limits—HUD has set maximum limits on the amounts of HOME funds, but not matching funds, that can be spent on a per-unit basis. For multifamily housing, the limits cannot be less than the per-unit dollar limitations of the Section 221(d)(3) program, adjusted up to 140 percent of those amounts in areas where multifamily housing construction costs exceed the national average.2 Cost limits on single-family units are set on a market-by-market basis, taking into account that HOME is for nonluxury housing with suitable amenities.3
•
Restrictions on rents for rental housing—Rental housing will qualify as “affordable housing” under HOME only if it meets six criteria: 1.
Rents do not exceed the lesser of the existing fair market rents as established by HUD for the Section 8 program or 30 percent of the adjusted income of a family use income equals 65 percent of the median income for the area, adjusted for the number of bedrooms in the unit.4
2.
No less than 20 percent of the units are occupied either by very-low-income families paying no more than 30 percent of their income toward rent or by very low-income families who are at the allowable level of rents under a project financed through the low-income housing tax credit.5
3.
The housing is occupied only by households that qualify as low-income families (80 percent or less of the area median).
4.
No person holding a Section 8 certificate or voucher is refused residency because of his or her status as a holder of the certificate or voucher.
5.
The property will remain affordable for its remaining useful life or the longest feasible period of time pursuant to a binding commitment entered into with HUD.
6.
If new construction, the property must meet energy efficiency standards.6
NAHA, § 212(d)(1); 42 U.S.C. § 12742(d)(1), as amended. Id. The Secretary can set higher or lower ceilings if necessary for a particular jurisdiction. NAHA, § 215(a)(1)(A); 42 U.S.C. § 12745(a), as amended. Restrictions on rents chargeable under the low-income housing tax credit are discussed in 9.2; see also I.R.C. § 42(g)(2). NAHA, § 212(a)(1)(A)-(F); 42 U.S.C. § 12745(a)(1)(A)-(F), as amended.
112
c07.fm Page 113 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:50 PM
7.3 SOURCES OF LOANS FROM STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
Rents may be adjusted only if HUD finds that the adjustment is necessary to support the continued financial viability of the project.7 Moreover, the property will continue to qualify as HOME-eligible housing even if the percentage occupancy requirements are not being met because of increases in tenant income or unit turnover as long as vacancies are filled with income-eligible families. Tenants who are no longer incomeeligible will pay as rent not less than 30 percent of the family’s income; however, tenants in HOME properties financed with low-income housing tax credits are not protected by this limitation.8
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
•
Tenant-based rental assistance—HOME funds can be used for tenantbased, not project-based rental assistance. These funds can be used for grants and loans for security deposits, in combination with rental subsidies, or separately. The conditions for use of the HOME funds are that they must be an “essential element of the jurisdiction’s housing strategy,”9 the housing strategy must specify the local market conditions leading to this choice, and the eligible recipients must be selected based on written selection policies that are reasonably related to federal and local preference policies. Assistance is limited to two years and may be renewed. This does not affect the jurisdiction’s Section 8 allocation.10
•
Homeownership, HOME imposes limitations on homeownership projects financed with HOME funds. Under HOME, the sales price is to be not more than 95 percent of the area’s median sales price.11 Eligible buyers must be income-eligible, first time homebuyers.12 However, purchasers will not be disqualified as first time homebuyers if they owned a mobile home or a manufactured home that does not comply with state/local codes or has not been affixed to a permanent foundation over the past three years.13 Single parents and displaced home-makers qualify. Resales may be made to eligible low-income buyers or the jurisdiction may recapture, at the time when the property is sold, all or a portion of the HOME funds used to assist a homebuyers and may then use the recaptured funds to NAHA, § 215(a)(2); 42 U.S.C. § 12745(a)(2), as amended. NAHA, § 215(a)(3); 42 U.S.C. § 12745(a)(3), as amended. See the discussion in note 16, infra. NAHA, § 212(a)(4); 42 U.S.C. § 12742(a)(4), as amended. NAHA, § 212(b)(1); 42 U.S.C. § 12742(b)(1), as amended. NAHA, § 212(b)(2) and (3); 42 U.S.C. § 12742(b)(2) and (3), as amended. Under NAHA, each jurisdiction seeking HOME funds must develop a Comprehensive Housing Affordability Strategy (CHAS) that describes, among other things, the jurisdiction’s housing needs, housing capacity, and strategy for dealing with these issues. See NAHA, § 105; 24 C.F.R. pt. 91.
113
c07.fm Page 114 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:50 PM
SOURCES OF CAPITAL: LOANS
assist other eligible homebuyers. The jurisdiction must devise resale restrictions for HUD approval.14 Newly constructed homes must meet HUD standards for energy efficiency.15 Two significant changes were made to the HOME program in 1994 concerning homeownership. Congress removed the restriction that HOME funds could be used for homeownership only when the purchaser was a first-time homebuyer. Removal of the first-time homeowner provision broadens the population eligible for HOME homeownership programs. In addition, Congress removed the restriction that all funds recaptured when HOME homeownership housing is sold must be used for future HOME homeownership activities. These funds may now be used for any HOME-eligible activity. What sets HOME apart from other federal housing programs is Congress’s inclusion of specific benefits for nonprofit housing developers. HOME provides nonprofits with an almost guaranteed access to capital. Under HOME, 15 percent of all HOME funds must be set aside for use by nonprofit housing development organizations. At the 2005 HOME appropriation level of nearly $2 billion, this provides $300 million in new money for nonprofit housing development. NAHA requires every participating jurisdiction to set aside 15 percent of its HOME allocations for use by community-based nonprofit housing development organizations, called Community Housing Development Organizations (CHDOs pronounced cho-dos), seeking to conduct allowable HOME activities in its community. If a jurisdiction does not use the nonprofit set-aside funds, it loses them. As long as they are not the owners, developers or sponsors of other housing, CHDOs may participate in other HOME-eligible activities. The HOME money committed to those other activities, however, will not count toward the set-aside. If the funds are not used by CHDO within 24 months, HUD recaptures the funds and reallocates them to other jurisdictions for nonprofit housing development. This 15 percent is a floor, not a ceiling. Jurisdictions can commit a greater percentage or even all of their HOME funds for use by CHDOs. Participating jurisdictions must make reasonable efforts to locate CHDOs that can be expected to carry out CHDO set-aside projects. However, jurisdictions having difficulty identifying CHDOs can use up to 20 percent (an amount not to exceed $150,000 in a 24-month period) of their set-aside funds for capacity building. These funds can be utilized only if (iv) Special Nonprofit Set-Aside of HOME Funds.
14 15
NAHA, § 212(b); 42 U.S.C. § 12742(b), as amended. NAHA, § 212(b)(4); 42 U.S.C. § 12742(b)(5), as amended.
114
c07.fm Page 115 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:50 PM
7.3 SOURCES OF LOANS FROM STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
a participating jurisdiction is unable to identify a sufficient number of capable CHDOs during the first 24 months of the jurisdiction’s participation in HOME. Finally, HOME allows jurisdictions to provide operating support for CHDOs. Participating jurisdictions can use up to 5 percent of their entire HOME allocation (not just 5 percent of the CHDO set-asides) for CHDO operating support. This assistance cannot exceed $50,000 to any individual group or 50 percent of the organization’s operating budget, whichever is greater. These funds do not require a match as do the other uses of HOME money.16 A CHDO is defined as a nonprofit organization that has among its purposes the provision of decent housing that is affordable to lowincome and moderate-income people in a clearly identified geographic area. Such an organization maintains, through significant representation on the organization’s governing board and otherwise, accountability to low-income community residents and, to the extent practicable, to lowincome beneficiaries with regard to decisions on the design, siting, development, and management of affordable housing. The CHDO must have a demonstrated capacity for carrying out HOME-approved activities and a history of serving the local community or communities within which the HOME-assisted housing is to be located.17 Most jurisdictions receiving HOME funds have established a mechanism whereby nonprofits can be certified as CHDOs for purposes of HOME. In addition to the 15 percent set-aside, HOME provides CHDOs with access to significant and valuable technical assistance. Each year, HUD awards millions of dollars in technical assistance grants to organizations throughout the country. The grantees are funded to provide CHDOs with direct technical assistance and training that will strengthen their capacity to participate effectively in the HOME program. A list of these organizations can be found at www.hud.gov/communityconnections. They enable CHDOs to maintain, rehabilitate, and construct affordable housing in jurisdictions participating in the HOME program. Each participating jurisdiction is responsible for designating the CHDOs that are eligible for these services. Although CHDOs have significant access to funds and technical assistance that they never had before, they are restricted by the general 16 17
12 U.S.C. § 12750, as amended. The law allows on a temporary basis the award of CHDO funds to organizations that meet all CHDO requirements other than those for board composition. An organization receiving CHDO funds on this basis has six months from the date it receives funds whichever is earlier, to bring its board into compliance. Multicounty CHDOs are not required to include on their boards at least one low-income representative from each county that the organization serves. Moreover, community land trusts, described in 7.6(h) can qualify as CHDOs.
115
c07.fm Page 116 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:50 PM
SOURCES OF CAPITAL: LOANS
HOME program limitations discussed above and by the following restrictions: If the CHDO is developing and operating rental housing, it must devise and get approval for a plan for tenant participating in the management of the housing accommodation and must develop a tenant grievance procedure, and the CHDO cannot receive more than 50 percent of its operating budget through HOME. (d)
Appropriated Funds/General Obligation Bonds/Repayment of Prior Loans
State, county, and city legislatures with active housing and community development departments or housing finance agencies often authorize these agencies to create loan programs for affordable housing development. The money for these loans usually comes from a variety of nonfederal sources, including appropriated funds or funds provided by the legislature to the government agency from tax dollars raised by the government, proceeds from bonds issued by the state for this purpose, and funds received from the repayment of previously made loans. Loans provided from these sources can be used for any purpose authorized by the legislature unless, as is the case with certain types of bonds, federal laws restrict the use of bond proceeds. (Bonds commonly used in housing development are discussed in the next section.) Legislatures often authorize housing agencies to use these funds to meet specific housing needs in their jurisdiction, such as rehabilitation of properties for low-cost rental or development of affordable homeownership housing opportunities. Moreover, legislatures usually provide their housing agencies with broad discretion, allowing them to adjust loan terms to meet the specific needs of the project, perhaps by providing low-interest loans for a short period of time or market rate loans for a long period of time. Governments often seek to leverage their funds with funds from other government entities (city funds may be leveraged with state funds) and with private loans and equity. Nonprofit housing developments commonly are financed using a mix of appropriated funds, CDBG funds, funds from bond proceeds (as discussed below), and/or proceeds of a private loan from a for-profit lending institution. As an example, in the State of Maryland, the legislature has authorized the Department of Housing and Community Development to use proceeds of state general obligation bonds, revolving funds of prepayments and repayments of previously made loans, federal subsidies, and tax-exempt revenue bonds and notes18 to provide: •
18
Low-interest construction and permanent financing for multifamily rental housing developments. See the discussion of tax exempt bonds Chapter 6, 6.3(d)(iv).
116
c07.fm Page 117 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:50 PM
7.3 SOURCES OF LOANS FROM STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
•
Below–market interest rate mortgage loans for low- and moderateincome families wishing to purchase a single-family home.
•
Low-interest financing for rehabilitation and energy conservation, to improve and preserve single- and multifamily housing.
•
Low-interest financing for construction or acquisition and rehabilitation of a variety of types of housing for people with special needs.
In many of these programs, the department has the discretion to provide special loan terms to make the project feasible, including no interest payments during the construction period, loans at a 100 percent loan-to-value ration,19 and loan terms in excess of 30 years. In addition, many of these programs require local jurisdictions (cities and counties) to commit their resources to a project as a condition of state participation. (e)
Bond Financing—Generally
Bonds issued by state and local governments and their agencies can provide a valuable source of funds for the development of affordable housing, both single-family and multifamily. Generally, jurisdictions with the authority to issue bonds can issue two kinds of bonds: 1. General obligation bonds, which are secured by the full faith and credit of the government issuer. 2. Revenue bonds, which are payable from and secured by the revenues generated from the projects they finance. Bonds used for housing generally are revenue bonds, secured by the project’s revenues, not the full faith and credit of the government. Technically, these revenue bonds fall into the category of tax-exempt or qualified private activity bonds (see Section f) and taxable private activity bonds (see Section g). Regardless of the type of bond issued for an affordable housing development, sponsors should be aware of two important factors related to bond financing: 1. The costs of issuing bonds are substantial. Government issuers usually will pool together a number of housing projects, fund them with proceeds from a common issuance, and split the issuing costs among the borrows. A single nonprofit housing development project can rarely afford to absorb the full costs of a bond issuance and maintain project affordability. 19
See the discussion of loan-to-value ratios in Chapter 6, 6.3(d)(iv).
117
c07.fm Page 118 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:50 PM
SOURCES OF CAPITAL: LOANS
2. Credit enhancement usually is required for a revenue bond issuance because the project is secured only by the project’s revenues and not by the full faith and credit of the government issuer. (Credit enhancement is discussed in Chapter 11.) The better the credit enhancement or security for repayment, the higher the bond rating in the bond markets, the lower the risk to the bondholders, and the lower the interest rate that the issuer must pay to the bondholders. For housing bonds, credit enhancement has typically been provided by federal, state, or private mortgage insurance, bond insurance, bank letters of credit, or insurance company guarantees. (f)
Tax-Exempt Bond Financing
Generally, bonds that are issued by state and local governments to pay for the costs of building government facilities or financing government operations are tax-exempt: interest paid to bondholders is not subject to income tax. This tax-exempt status allows the government to secure credit at interest rates lower than the market would bear and provides bondholders with tax-free investments. Bonds issued for most housing, however, are issued to finance privately owned for-profit or nonprofit housing, not government operations or government-owned facilities. Therefore, these bonds, referred to as private activity bonds, are taxable unless they meet the requirements of a “qualified private activity bond” under Section 141 of the Internal Revenue Code (the Code).20 The major categories of qualified private activity bonds commonly used for housing development are: Mortgage revenue bonds, exempt-facility bonds, redevelopment bonds, and Internal Revenue § 501(c)(3) bonds. These bond categories are discussed in the following sections. (i) Mortgage Revenue Bonds: Single-Family Homes, Condominium Units, Cooperatives. Mortgage revenue bonds are issued primarily to help
finance the purchase by low- to moderate-income homebuyers of singlefamily homes, two- to four-family properties, and individual condominium units. 21 These bonds can also be used for the rehabilitation or improvement of single-family homes and condominium units and for the development of limited-equity cooperatives. Proceeds from the bonds are used by the government issuers to make loans directly to qualified borrowers or to purchase loans made by the private lenders. Reductions in interest rates that result from the use of tax-exempt bonds are passed 20 21
I.R.C. § 141. A two- to four-unit property must be used by the borrower as a principle residence, and a one unit must have been occupied by the owner for at least five years prior to the bond-financed mortgage.
118
c07.fm Page 119 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:50 PM
7.3 SOURCES OF LOANS FROM STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
through by the government to the qualified borrowers in the form of lower interest rates. S INGLE F AMILY (1–4 UNITS) AND C ONDOMINIUM U NITS
Certain restrictions apply when mortgage revenue bonds are to be used to finance single-family (1–4 units) and condominium unit purchases. These funds must be earmarked for first-time homebuyers or families that have not owned a home in the prior three years.22 This restriction, however, does not apply to purchases of homes in targeted areas,23 or to home improvement and rehabilitation loans. In addition, the purchase price of a unit cannot exceed 90 percent of the average home purchase price for the areas, or 110 percent if the home is located in a targeted areas of economic distress. These limits are adjusted upward for two-, three-, and four-family homes and for whether the homes are new or existing. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) publishes “safe harbor” limits or prices that the developer can aim for that would be safely within the allowable purchase prices for that area. These funds also carry income restrictions. The annual income of the borrower may not exceed 115 percent of the median family gross income for the state or area in which the home is located, whichever is greater. If the property is located in a targeted area, at least two-thirds of the financing provided must go to borrowers with incomes no higher than 140 percent of the higher of state or area median family gross income. The remaining one-third may be lent without any income restrictions. Home improvement and rehabilitation loans also have restrictions. Home improvement loans may not exceed $15,000 and must be used to finance alterations, repairs, or improvements to an existing residence that substantially protect or improve the basic livability or energy efficiency of the property.24 Rehabilitation loans are only available for properties owned by the borrower or for the acquisition and rehabilitated property where the borrower will be the first occupant after the rehabilitation is completed.25 L IMITED-E QUITY C OOPERATIVES
Proceeds from mortgage revenue bonds can be used to acquire and rehabilitate a multifamily property in order to establish a limited-equity cooperative. Under Code Section 143(k)(9), a limited-equity cooperative is any 22 23
24 25
I.R.C. § 143(d). Targeted areas include (1) qualified census tracts where at least 70 percent of the families have annual incomes no higher than 80 percent of the statewide median income, and (2) areas of chronic economic distress as designated by the states. I.R.C. 143(k). Id.
119
c07.fm Page 120 Wednesday, March 15, 2006 3:50 PM
SOURCES OF CAPITAL: LOANS
cooperative housing corporation26 in which the appreciation available to a shareholder when reselling a cooperative share is limited to the consideration paid for the share, payments made to improve the unit, and payments made to reduce principle on the outstanding debt. To have access to proceeds from a tax-exempt mortgage revenue bond, the cooperative must irrevocably elect to set aside a portion of its cooperative units for low-income use27 and to waive the rights of shareholders to include mortgage interest and property tax payments as itemized deductions in their federal and state tax returns.28 Limited-equity cooperatives are discussed more fully in Chapter 16. Exempt-facility bonds can be issued to finance “qualified residential rental projects.” Generally, these projects include any property characterized by nontransient use: detached housing, row houses, high rises, or other buildings with one or more units, or the residential portion of a mixed-use project.29 Under the exempt-facility provisions of the Internal Revenue Code, even multiple properties owned by the same owner and financed under a common plan may be treated as a single project. Like mortgage revenue bonds, exempt-facility bonds are subject to significant use restrictions. The first restriction concerns unit set-asides for low-income use. Developers of qualified residential rental projects must elect either a 20-50 or a 40-60 set-aside by the time of the bond issue. The 20-50 set-aside requires that at least 20 percent of the project’s units must be occupied by tenants with annual incomes of 50 percent or less of area median gross income. The 40-60 set-aside requires that at least 40 percent of the units (25 percent in New York City) must be rented to tenants at or below 60 percent of area median gross incomes.30 A set-aside tenant will continue to be treated as a low-income tenant even if the tenant’s income increases or if there is a decrease in household size, unless the tenant’s income has increased to more than 140 percent of the area median gross income in effect at the time when the tenancy began.31 If a tenant’s failure to qualify as low-income places a project in noncompliance with the set-aside requirement, no penalties will be assessed if the next vacant project unit of comparable or smaller size is rented to a new, qualified low-income tenant and the project is returned to compliance.32 (ii) Exempt-Facility Bonds: Multifamily