cover
next page >
Cover
title:
author: publisher: isbn10 | asin: print isbn13: ebook isbn13: language: subject publi...
30 downloads
926 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
cover
next page >
Cover
title:
author: publisher: isbn10 | asin: print isbn13: ebook isbn13: language: subject publication date: lcc: ddc: subject:
Discourse Markers Across Languages : A Contrastive Study of Second-level Discourse Markers in Native and Non-native Text With Implications for General and Pedagogic Lexicography Routledge Advances in Corpus Linguistics ; 6 Siepmann, Dirk. Taylor & Francis Routledge 0415349494 9780415349499 9780203315262 English Discourse markers, Contrastive linguistics, Lexicography, Language and languages--Study and teaching. 2005 P302.35.S54 2005eb 401/.41 Discourse markers, Contrastive linguistics, Lexicography, Language and languages--Study and teaching.
cover
next page >
< previous page
page_i
next page >
Page i Discourse Markers Across Languages This book deals with ready-made phrases, or ‘second-level discourse markers’ such as it is argued that or the same goes for . Specifically the book answers questions such as ‘how can such phrases be defined or translated?’ or ‘how can they be recorded in dictionaries?’ The book falls into two parts. Part I presents a functional taxonomy of second-level markers in English, French and German as well as an analysis of their use in continuous text. Part II offers a contrastive interlanguage analysis of the performance of non-native writers and translators. The book is essential reading for professional linguists or lexicographers with an interest in collocation and phraseology, as well as for academics, translators and language teachers seeking to produce well-crafted text in a foreign language. Dirk Siepmann is Lecturer in English at Siegen University, Germany.
< previous page
page_i
next page >
< previous page
page_ii
next page >
Page ii Routledge advances in corpus linguistics Edited by Anthony McEnery, Lancaster University, UK, and Michael Hoey, Liverpool University, UK. Corpus-based linguistics is a dynamic area of linguistic research. The series aims to reflect the diversity of approaches to the subject, and thus to provide a forum for debate and detailed discussion of the various ways of building, exploiting and theorizing about the use of corpora in language studies. 1. Swearing in English Anthony McEnery 2. Antonymy A corpus-based perspective Steυen Jones 3. Modelling Variation in Spoken and Written English Daυid Y.W.Lee 4. The Linguistics of Political Argument The spin-doctor and the wolf-pack at the White House Alan Partington 5. Corpus Stylistics Speech, writing and thought presentation in a corpus of English writing Elena Semino and Mick Short 6. Discourse Markers Across Languages A contrastive study of second-level discourse markers in native and non-native text with implications for general and pedagogic lexicography Dirk Siepmann
< previous page
page_ii
next page >
< previous page
page_iii
next page >
Page iii Discourse Markers Across Languages A contrastive study of second-level discourse markers in native and non-native text with implications for general and pedagogic lexicography Dirk Siepmann LONDON AND NEW YORK
< previous page
page_iii
next page >
< previous page
page_iv
next page >
Page iv First published 2005 by Routledge 2 Park Square, Milton Park, Abingdon, Oxon OX14 4RN Simultaneously published in the USA and Canada by Routledge 270 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10016 Routledge is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group This edition published in the Taylor & Francis e-Library, 2005. To purchase your own copy of this or any of Taylor & Francis or Routledge’s collection of thousands of eBooks please go to www.eBookstore.tandf.co.uk. © 2005 Dirk Siepmann All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reprinted or reproduced or utilized in any form or by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publishers. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data A catalog record for this book has been requested ISBN 0-203-31526-X Master e-book ISBN ISBN 0-415-34949-4 (Print Edition)
< previous page
page_iv
next page >
< previous page
page_v
next page >
Page v Unter Südländern ist die Sprache ein Ingredienz der Lebensfreude, dem man weit lebhaftere gesellschaftliche Schätzung entgegenbringt, als der Norden sie kennt. Es sind vorbildliche Ehren, in denen das nationale Bindemittel der Muttersprache bei diesen Völkern steht, und etwas heiter Vorbildliches hat die genußreiche Ehrfurcht, mit der man ihre Formen und Lautgesetze betreut. Man spricht mit Vergnügen, man hört mit Vergnügen—und man hört mit Urteil…* Thomas Mann, Mario und der Zauberer Mache die Dinge so einfach wie möglich—aber nicht einfacher† Albert Einstein Il faut…ramener la linguistique vers le lexique où la complexité des langues parvient à son plus haut degré de force et d’épanouissement‡ Harald Weinrich, Le Français dans le Monde (303) * ‘Among southern peoples language is an ingredient of life’s joys which is held in much livelier social esteem than in the north. The honours paid by these nations to that national binder, the mother tongue, are exemplary, and there is something joyfully exemplary about the appreciation and awe with which they treat its forms and sounds. One speaks with pleasure, one listens with pleasure—and one listens with discernment.’ (my translation) † ‘Everything should be made as simple as possible, but not simpler.’ (my translation) ‡ ‘Linguistics has to be steered back towards the area of lexis, where language attains its highest degree of expressiveness and complexity.’ (my translation)
< previous page
page_v
next page >
< previous page
page_vi
next page >
page_vi
next page >
Page vi This page intentionally left blank.
< previous page
< previous page
page_vii
next page >
Page vii Contents
Preface What this book is about Acknowledgements
ix xii xiii
PART I Linguistic considerations
1
1 Observing languages: introduction to Part I 1.1 Aims, scope and methodology 1.2 Corpora and corpus-enquiry tools 2 Investigating routines: defining and describing multi-word discourse markers 2.1 Pragmatic perspectives on discourse markers 2.2 Lexicological perspectives on multi-word discourse markers 2.3 Syntactic realizations of SLDMs 3 Identifying meanings and functions: an attempt at a functional taxonomy of SLDMs 3.1 Introduction 3.2 Language functions and textual relations 3.3 A taxonomy of SLDMs 3.4 Points of interest 4 Straddling cultures: three types of second-level discourse markers in contrastive perspective 4.1 Exemplifiers 4.2 Reformulators and resumers 4.3 Inferrers 4.4 Summary and conclusion
< previous page
page_vii
3 3 22 34 37 45 52 82 82 82 87 98 106 111 141 219 239
next page >
< previous page
page_viii
next page >
Page viii PART II A contrastive interlanguage analysis with implications for dictionary making
241
1 Introduction 2 Facing realities: the performance of non-native writers and translators 2.1 Interlanguage analysis 2.2 German writers’ performance in the field of discourse markers 2.3 Translations under the spotlight 2.4 Conclusion 3 Lexicographic treatment of SLDMs 3.1 Lexicographic coverage of SLDMs 3.2 Macrostructural and microstructural treatment of SLDMs 3.3 Sample entries 4 Avenues for further research
243 245 246 252 278 282 283 283 290 308 325
Notes Bibliography Index
< previous page
327 330 351
page_viii
next page >
< previous page
page_ix
next page >
Page ix Preface The present work stands at the interface of several converging developments in linguistics and language teaching. Most importantly, perhaps, there has been in recent decades a dramatic increase in the amount of scholarship on text and discourse. Indeed, despite a time-honoured concern with both written and spoken texts in classical rhetoric, systematic discourse analysis did not really get off the ground until the 1970s, with the work of such linguists as Quirk et al. (1972) and van Dijk (1972). The overarching concern in such work has been the empirical investigation of the structure and functions of naturally occurring text rather than the atomistic study of sentence-level syntax inspired by Chomsky. Such paradigm change has not been without influence on the study of language for specific purposes (LSP), a field in which the greatest research effort has probably been expended on academic writing. Here too there has been a move from the microlinguistic analysis of syntax, terminology and word formation prevalent until well into the 1970s (Drozd and Seibicke 1973; Kocourek 1982) towards the study of specialist text (Gläser 1979; Hoffmann 1983; Baumann 1986). A natural consequence of this has been the establishment of contrastive text linguistics as a discipline in its own right; numerous works have been published comparing specific languages at the textual level (cf. for example Newsham 1977 for the language pair English/French; Hinds 1983 for English/Japanese; Kachru 1983 for English/Hindi; Clyne 1987 for English/German; Blumenthal 1997 for French/German; Hatim 1997 for English/Arabic). Another rapidly growing line of research is the study of phraseology. Founded by Bally (1909), this branch of linguistics suffered comparative neglect in Western Europe until fairly recently. It was the great merit of Russian linguistics to intensify phraseological research from the 1940s onwards, establishing precise criteria for the description of various types of conventionalized expressions. With the large-scale shift in the West from idealist Chomskyan linguistics to renewed empirical research, the phraseology of languages such as English, German and French became in its turn the subject of numerous research ventures (e.g. Cowie 1975; Burger 1973; Feilke 1996; Moon 1998; Bresson 1998). Among the results
< previous page
page_ix
next page >
< previous page
page_x
next page >
Page x of such research was the discovery that phraseological units occur in far greater numbers than previously thought, leading researchers such as Sinclair to posit the ‘idiom principle’, whereby ‘a language user has available to him or her a large number of semi-preconstructed phrases that constitute single choices, even though they might appear to be analysable into segments’ (Sinclair 1991:110). Stemming from this, there has been growing recognition in language-teaching circles that multi-word units should be accorded more detailed attention in the foreign language classroom (Nattinger and DeCarrico 1992; Lewis 1993; Cowie 1998), and this view has been confirmed by recent research showing such units to be either under- or over-represented in the linguistic output of L2 learners (Granger 1998a; DeCock 1998; Milton 1999). Last but by no means least, all of the above strands of research have received further impetus from computer corpus linguistics. With unprecedented riches of authentic data at their fingertips, linguists are now in a position to go beyond intuition and pen-and-paper analysis. More empirical and less speculative, their research finally bears comparison with that of hard-pure sciences such as physics and chemistry. It is beginning to open up exciting new perspectives on language. This study is an attempt to weave together the aforementioned strands of research with a view to offering a broad picture of one sub-section of the native writer’s phrasicon: ‘multi-word’, or, more technically, ‘second-level’ discourse markers. As their name indicates, multi-word discourse markers are recurrent word combinations serving pragmatic and/or discourse-structuring functions. Adequate use of such items is pivotal in making academic and other prose texts comprehensible and effective; however, many linguists, teachers and writers have so far been unaware of their very existence. It thus appears that the description of second-level markers is one of the most compelling tasks for the applied linguist, whose aim it is to provide a sound basis for language teaching and expert communication across cultural barriers. In such an endeavour there is much to be said for the adoption of a multilingual approach. Cross-linguistic research has shown that the ways sentences connect may differ from one language to another, often making the rendition of ‘linking words’ less straightforward than dictionary equivalence might suggest. This fits in with evidence from contrastive rhetoric which suggests that L2 writers are prone to reproduce L1 patterns of text organization. In a world where translation and L2 writing skills are at a premium, it therefore makes both lexicographic and pedagogic sense to investigate differences and similarities between markers across languages. This brings us to the question of language pedagogy. With the return of the language awareness movement (Moore 1995), it is now fairly generally realized that the communicative approach to language teaching needs to be enhanced through discovery-based and awareness-raising practices grounded in constructivist learning theory (Rüschoff and Wolff 1999;
< previous page
page_x
next page >
< previous page
page_xi
next page >
Page xi Wolff 2000). It is towards this conception of language learning that the present study wishes to make a useful contribution. In particular, my hope is that learner lexicography, composition teaching and translator training will incorporate some of the findings of the present research, thereby sensitizing language professionals to a discoursecentred approach to language teaching. Secondary-level foreign language teachers in particular continue to see language as a ragbag of vocabulary governed by a fixed set of grammar rules. The more teaching materials incorporate evidence of multi-word units and information on their use in text, the easier it will be to instil in teachers a more holistic view of language integrating textual, situational and lexico-grammatical aspects. To sum up, the present study tries to be innovative in at least three ways. To begin with, it is the first large-scale corpus-based contrastive study to look at three languages at a time. Second, it considers an almost entirely unexplored set of pragmatic markers functioning as structural and semantic units. Third, it closes gaps in dictionaries and textbooks, thus providing assistance for writers, translators and second-language teachers; the index will help the language practitioner locate specific items of interest. For obvious reasons, it is impossible within the narrow compass of a monograph to treat every question in meticulous detail; many avenues of research opened up here can be further explored. What the reader can expect to find, though, is a fairly comprehensive account of a few, carefully selected categories of multi-word marker. Finally, a note on language: in German and North-American academic circles in particular, there is a deplorable tendency to equate pretentious language with superior thought content. I have been at pains to distance myself from this tendency, trying to avoid wherever possible the overelaboration and abstruseness of much pseudoscientific jargon. Culturally, I hope to have fused British practicalism with German thoroughness. Stylistically, I hope to have balanced the elegance of the past with the easy familiarity of the present. Dirk Siepmann Herdecke, February 2004
< previous page
page_xi
next page >
< previous page
page_xii
next page >
Page xii What this book is about This study falls into two parts. The core aim of Part I is for a functional taxonomy of multi-word or ‘second-level’ discourse markers in three European languages (English, German and French) and for a contrastive analysis of their use in continuous text across the three idioms. The author begins by defining the term ‘second-level discourse marker’ and follows this up with an overview of possible syntactic realizations of such markers. He proceeds to investigate what functions they serve and to address the problems attendant upon the translation of the members of three functional categories. A wide variety of corpus sources is laid under contribution with a view to building up a comprehensive picture of second-level discourse marker use. In Part II a critical analysis is made of a corpus comprising advanced English-language writing by German academics and students, as well as of a small number of published translations by professional translators. It is found that the use of second-level markers by these groups compares unfavourably with that of natives. Unnatural writing is shown to be the result of overt errors on the one hand, and of the unusual frequency of occurrence of particular items on the other hand. Lexicographic implications are then considered, which lead to suggestions for the lexicographic treatment of second-level discourse markers in general and pedagogic dictionaries. Author’s note My interest in multi-word discourse markers continues. My website (www.dirk-siepmann.de/multiwordmarkers) contains sections of my thesis that I have not been able to include in this book, an executive summary, and journal articles which deal with other types of multi-word markers than those discussed here.
< previous page
page_xii
next page >
< previous page
page_xiii
next page >
Page xiii Acknowledgements This book is based on my doctoral thesis, submitted at the University of Wuppertal (Germany) in 2003. It took four years of unceasing effort—alongside a full-time job—to bring that thesis to birth, but its actual gestation spanned a much longer period. Directly or indirectly, it profited from the benevolent influence of many. My first and probably greatest debt is to Petra Heise, my English teacher at Otto-Pankok-Schule, Mülheim an der Ruhr, who, although of German origin, used English with a naturalness and precision unequalled by any other German I have ever met. Her love of language was infectious, and prompted me to strive for mastery of the foreign languages of my choice. Among other things, I started drawing up vocabulary lists, some of which formed the basis of the present work. Later in life, my quest for linguistic perfection received further impetus from kindred spirits, such as Professor Serge Gouazé of Valenciennes University and John D.Gallagher of Münster University, who initiated me into the art of translation and taught me the importance of good style. I also derived much benefit from a lecture given by Professor John Sinclair during my student days at Durham and a subsequent visit to COBUILD at the University of Birmingham. This sparked my interest in computer corpus linguistics, the practice of which has given me ever deeper insight into language. My Ph.D. supervisors, Professor Dieter Wolff and Professor Peter Scherfer, deserve special thanks for their part in the making of this book. Dieter Wolff kindly allowed me to use the multilingual translation corpus partly compiled at Wuppertal University. He patiently read two drafts of the manuscript and offered valuable advice. I have found his friendly and supportive manner extremely helpful. Peter Scherfer, a theoretician in the best sense of that abused term, helped to give greater conceptual precision to some of my ideas. I am also indebted to the Series Editors, Professor Tony McEnery and Professor Michael Hoey, as well as the editorial team at Routledge (Terry Clague, Joe Whiting and Yeliz Ali) for seeing this book through to publication. Finally, I should like to thank my partner, Sabine, for her unflinching moral and practical support.
< previous page
page_xiii
next page >
< previous page
page_xiv
next page >
page_xiv
next page >
Page xiv This page intentionally left blank.
< previous page
< previous page
page_1
next page >
page_1
next page >
Page 1 Part I Linguistic considerations
< previous page
< previous page
page_2
next page >
page_2
next page >
Page 2 This page intentionally left blank.
< previous page
< previous page
page_3
next page >
Page 3 1 Observing languages Introduction to Part I Begin with the end in mind. Stephen R.Covey, The Seυen Habits of Highly Effectiυe People Anyone reading academic treatises, reference books or quality newspapers with any regularity will be struck by the recurrence of a particular kind of multi-word unit. Typical examples are it is argued that, it is a fair guess that or the same goes for . Curiously enough, such firmly established phrases seem to have escaped scholarly notice until fairly recently. As a result, they have never been dealt with in any extensive manner, with the exception perhaps of Gallagher’s (1992) ground-breaking article on the translation of the German discourse device erschwerend kommt hinzu, dass, Grieve’s (1996) dictionary of French connectors and four recent articles by Siepmann (2000, 2001a) and Oakey (2002a, 2002b). The first part of this study, then, may be seen as an attempt to redress a perceived imbalance between the poor stock of knowledge about the routine formulae in question and the somewhat larger body of research on related one-word connectives. 1.1 Aims, scope and methodology The core aim of the present work is for a contrastive analysis of such multi-word units. The term ‘contrastive analysis’ is here taken to refer to the processes involved in identifying, recording and describing lexical items which assume identical or similar functions in actual manifestations of English, French and German language use (for further detail, see Section 1.1.2.3 below). Such an analysis depends on two prerequisites: first, an inventory of the lexical class under consideration; second, a categorization, or taxonomy, of the members of this class. Since previous work on phraseology has severely neglected multi-word units of the type exemplified above, both the inventory and the taxonomy used in the present study had to be built up from scratch. There being no copyright on lexicographic material, the full-size inventory underlying this study will,
< previous page
page_3
next page >
< previous page
page_4
next page >
Page 4 however, be published in a separate work (Gallagher et al., in preparation). The taxonomy therefore confines itself to typical instances of each category, and the contrastive analysis is restricted to three major categories of multiword units. The account given here of this part of the phrasicon situates itself within the Firthian tradition of British text linguistics. Accordingly, it is essentially descriptive and data-driven rather than theoretical and introspective. The present chapter discusses the essential foundation of such an approach and the methodological choices entailed by it. Section 1.1 is concerned with general questions regarding the use of corpora and the setting up of interlingual equivalence, while Section 1.2 focuses on corpus compilation. Chapter 2 sets out to define the object of study. I shall argue that it forms a separate sub-class of the lexicon whose members can be described as ‘second-level markers’. Unfortunately, there is as yet no agreed-upon conceptual framework for describing the items belonging to this class. Traditional grammars have tended to classify some of its members, such as à cet effet or pour ce faire under the ‘ragbag’ heading of adverbials; other items, such as the sentence fragments exemplified above, have been altogether excluded from consideration. A satisfactory definition can, however, be arrived at by drawing on two distinct strands of current linguistic research: discourse analysis or text linguistics on the one hand, and lexicology on the other. Drawing on the discourse-analytical literature, I show that second-level markers bear close similarities to oral discourse markers. Drawing on the phraseological literature, I argue that they constitute a distinct type of phraseological unit. Having thus provided a functional-lexicological definition of second-level markers, I move on to outline the entire gamut of syntactic forms they can take. The sheer size of the lexical class under investigation forbids a detailed contrastive analysis for all the members of the class. Chapter 3 therefore sets up a broad taxonomy predicated on the general functions of second-level markers. After these methodological and theoretical preliminaries, the way is open for a finely honed contrastive analysis of three functional categories of second-level markers: exemplifiers, reformulators and inferrers. This is the subject of Chapter 4. In a first step, I give a detailed description of the behaviour of particular items, including their frequency. On this basis, I then consider to what extent interlingual equivalence obtains between items of the functional type under investigation. With the most complex categories it seems wise to follow a stepwise approach proceeding from monolingual analysis to multilingual comparison, thus allowing the reader to form a just understanding of the rationale behind particular equivalences. Where equivalence relations turn out to be more straightforward, discussion will move directly to the multilingual comparison. On the basis of these investigations, Part II looks at
< previous page
page_4
next page >
< previous page
page_5
next page >
Page 5 • how successfully non-native writers and translators cope with multi-word markers; • what implications research into multi-word markers has for general and learner lexicography. 1.1.1 Theoretical foundation The present research locates itself squarely within the British tradition of text analysis established by Firth (1957). This empiricist tradition has a number of features which distinguish it from theory-driven approaches to the study of language. To begin with, the Firthian tradition, the most prominent present-day adherents of which are Halliday, Sinclair, Stubbs, Francis and Hunston, views linguistics as an applied social science (Stubbs 1993:3). On the theoretical side, it foregrounds social interaction as the main determinant of linguistic form. This is in keeping with state-of-the-art discussions of language science such as Feilke (1996), who convincingly argues that whatever disposition for language a child may have, it is a ‘silent’ disposition which only develops into a functioning language through communicative interaction and the institutional practices such interaction puts in place (Feilke 1996:32). On the practical side, a dominant current in the British tradition aims at direct relevance to both the L1 (Coulthard and Sinclair 1975) and the L2 language classroom (cf. the long list of COBUILD publications). Second, the Firthian tradition takes actual occurrences of language as the object of study. Introspective data are considered to be invalid as a primary source of evidence. In this sense, Firth adopts a different approach from Chomsky, who relies almost entirely on invented, sentence-level examples. In the Firthian tradition the data comes first, and the theory is built up from the data. Closely linked with these fundamental features of the Firthian approach is a third one: linguistics is regarded as the study of the meaning of linguistic units. It thus views language from a different angle than Chomskyan linguistics, which stresses the autonomy of particular components of the language system—most importantly syntax (Chomsky 1957:17). Corpus linguists working in the Firthian tradition have ingeniously suggested that much if not all syntax is lexis-driven, thereby at least complementing the Chomskyan view: syntax is driven by lexis: lexis is communicatively prior. As communicators we do not proceed by selecting syntactic structures and independently choosing lexis to slot into them. Instead, we have concepts to convey and communicative choices to make which require central lexical items, and these choices find themselves syntactic structures in which they can be said comfortably and grammatically. (Francis 1993:142)
< previous page
page_5
next page >
< previous page
page_6
next page >
Page 6 The lexico-grammars (Francis et al. 1996, 1998) produced under the supervision of Sinclair provide ample proof of the close association between sense and syntax posited by Francis, specifying, as they do, the behaviour of the major lexical classes (verbs, nouns and adjectives) in terms of their meaning and syntactic preferences. The results show clearly that particular semantic sets are linked with particular syntactic choices and that, conversely, particular syntactic patterns cluster around particular semantic sets. By the same token, linguists working in the Firthian tradition see meaning as at least partially determined by typical combinations of lexical choices or ‘collocability’ on the one hand, and typical combinations of grammatical choices or ‘colligation’ on the other (Hunston 2001). That is, words obtain at least part of their meaning from the contexts in which they typically occur, and, more specifically, from collocates with which they typically team up. In this sense the Firthian tradition is far removed both from componential analysis and from semantic field theory as framed by Trier (1931), where the meaning of a word arises from its position in an abstractly conceived paradigmatic field. A crucial aspect of an item’s meaning is its ‘semantic prosody’, a term which reflects the realization that lexical items become infused with particular connotations due to their typical linguistic environment (Sinclair 1991; Louw 1993; Stubbs 1995). Thus, Sinclair (1991:73–75) demonstrates that the phrasal verb set in carries unfavourable connotations because it co-occurs significantly with words denoting undesirable events or processes such as decay, bad weather or disillusionment. Similarly, the French multi-word unit NP n’a(ura) qu’à bien se tenir, which is unaccountably absent from the major dictionaries, is imbued with a semantic prosody of ‘rivalry’, with the referent of the noun phrase being in competition with another entity mentioned in the surrounding discourse: L’essence n’a qu’à bien se tenir, la lutte pour le titre de carburant le moins nocif s’est resserrée. ( L’Humanité, 11.8.2001) This example conveniently brings us to a fourth major characteristic of the Firthian tradition: it recognizes the pervasiveness of what Sinclair (1991) has called the idiom principle, whereby ‘a language user has available to him or her a large number of semi-preconstructed phrases that constitute single choices, even though they might appear to be analysable into segments’ (Sinclair 1991:110). Corpus work in the Firthian tradition has shown that between 50 and 80 per cent of all text is made up of habitual word associations (Gross 1988; Stubbs 1997; Altenberg 1998). Most importantly for this study, around 20 per cent of all academic text has been shown to consist of lexical bundles of the type by the fact that, similar to that of the, presence of the, it is interesting to, size and shape or theory and prac-
< previous page
page_6
next page >
< previous page
page_7
next page >
Page 7 tice (Biber et al . 1999:995ff.), and it is reasonable to put the amount of academic text taken up by various types of collocation, including multi-word markers, at a minimum of 30 per cent. From a Firthian perspective, then, the negotiation of meaning between language users relies on conventionalized, multi-word sense units rather than isolated words. It is interesting to note that this view of language was anticipated by Bally as early as 1909; he viewed phraseological items as ‘conceptual units’ ( unité de conception, Bally [1909] 1951:76): Ainsi, l’unité lexicologique, telle qu’elle est donnée par l’écriture, le «mot» enfin, est une unité trompeuse et illusoire dans beaucoup de cas et ne correspond pas toujours aux unités de pensée, aux représentations, aux concepts, aux notions de l’esprit…les faits de langage ont un caractère beaucoup plus synthétique qu’on ne le pense et que ne le fait supposer l’analyse dite logique. (Bally [1909] 1951:3ff.) The present study espouses all the above-mentioned features of the Firthian tradition: underpinning it is an appliedlinguistic approach to the study of language which has direct relevance to lexicography (see Part II) as well as the teaching of composition and translation. Any theorization arises directly from the textual evidence produced from manual or computer-driven analysis. Among other things, this book will provide compelling evidence for an even stronger version of the idiom principle than that put forward by Sinclair (1991). It will be shown that collocational patterns are formed not only by two words belonging to different lexical classes but also by multi-word units; such multi-word units will be seen to form lexical dependencies over considerable spans of text (see Chapter 3). 1.1.2 Methodology This study, unlike the bulk of recent corpus-based scholarship, takes a multi-method approach. For one thing, it combines traditional, manual text analysis with computer-based corpus linguistics, thereby bringing together qualitative and quantitative perspectives on the object of study. For another, it blends the contrastivist’s approach with the translatologist’s. 1.1.2.1 Corpus υs. intuition There is growing recognition that language study can benefit from a combination of manual and computer-based analysis. As Kennedy points out: The use of a corpus as a source of evidence however is not necessarily incompatible with any linguistic theory, and progress in the language
< previous page
page_7
next page >
< previous page
page_8
next page >
Page 8 sciences as a whole is likely to benefit from a judicious use of evidence from various sources: texts, introspection, elicitation or other types of experimentation as appropriate. (Kennedy 1998:8; my emphasis) The evidence is abundant that it would be methodologically misguided to let present-day computers, or rather software, perform corpus searches on their own, and some authors wisely stress caution. Siepmann (1998) points up the dangers inherent in the wholesale compilation of dictionaries by computer. A stark result of such an approach is seen in The Cobuild Collocations CD-ROM (Sinclair 1995): it includes compounds (disaster relief, schools inspector), which can be found more readily in a general bilingual or monolingual dictionary, ‘free combinations’1 (thus new is given as a collocate of gallery, or such+disaster ) and, most inappropriately, such manifest absurdities as nature+because, religious+between, or adυances+heaυy, all of which reveal a regrettable lack of human interference and might lead learners of English badly astray. As such examples show, over-dependence on computational methods may lead to a distorted picture of collocational significance. Thus, a restricted collocation such as note that, which may be observed with some frequency in an academic corpus, may be totally absent from a heavily newspaper-based corpus such as the Bank of English. In other words, what is statistically significant in one corpus may be insignificant in another, a point which needs to be kept in mind by any corpus linguist. This leads to the question of whether any corpus can ‘approach the collective linguistic experience of a language community’ (Howarth 1996:72). Clearly, the answer still has to be in the negative at the moment of writing, especially since most of today’s major corpora are narrowly synchronic, comprising only the last ten years or so. Yet in future very large corpora may well be built which will reflect the knowledge and experience of language accumulated over several generations. Everything stands or falls by corpus size, so that it would obviously be wrong at the present time to infer the non-existence of a word or phrase from its absence from a corpus: Sinclair sets the data from a finite set of texts against the intuition of an individual…and dismisses the latter. However, to have absolute faith in either is limiting. The most productive course is to begin with no pre-determined philosophy and to employ data from both sources co-operatively. (Howarth 1996:73) This statement needs to be set against evidence from a substantial literature (e.g. Sinclair 1991; Francis 1993; Siepmann 1999) that both intuition and manual analysis are prone to error and imprecision when it
< previous page
page_8
next page >
< previous page
page_9
next page >
Page 9 comes to describing the realities of language use. Many pre-electronic descriptions testify to this, either in making gross misjudgements about the behaviour of a language item (examples relevant to this study are Nattinger and DeCarrico 1992 and Grieve 1996; see Chapters 2 and 4) or in presenting examples which have the unmistakable ring of artificiality. It is clear, then, that Howarth’s ‘cooperative’ use of data from both sources should be reinterpreted as ‘use in temporal succession’: hypotheses generated from introspection must always be tested against corpus evidence, and corpus evidence may never be altered to fit intuitive beliefs. A further limitation of computer corpus investigation stems from the inability of current retrieval software to extract complex, variable sequences of words (cf. for example Moon 1998:51ff.). In an ideal world, the computer would identify all the instances, including the permutations, of a particular lexical pattern (e.g. ‘it is to be noted’, ‘it must be noted’, ‘it will be noted’, ‘it is notable’, ‘it is noticeable’, ‘it is worth noting’, etc.). This would have the added advantage that categories worth investigating could be determined empirically rather than derived from intuition (cf. McEnery and Wilson 1996:86, footnote 1). The reality, however, is that automatic routines are not yet sophisticated enough to process data in terms of semantic function, making it particularly difficult to detect equivalences among transformationally unpredictable marker words and phrases of the kind under analysis here. It follows that to rely on automatic routines would be to commit a serious fallacy: that of allowing linguistic theory to be ruled by computer technology. 1.1.2.2 Sampling and categorization The rationale for a combination of qualitative and quantitative methods is simple enough: to be able to study multiword discourse markers in a machine-readable corpus one needs first to compile an ocular scan-based inventory, or ‘look-up list’, of such items and then to categorize its content (cf. Schmied 1987). Next a computer corpus can be tapped to check the categories thus developed against a larger amount of authentic data.2 When conducting such qualitative research, the analyst has to extend the corpus enquiry beyond the narrow span of the usual KWIC concordances to take account of longer pieces of text. This kind of investigation may then provide feedback which will necessitate a rethinking of categories,3 additions to the inventory, and so on, in an iterative cycle. Once a categorized list has been drawn up, the investigation can proceed on a quantitative basis, enabling the analyst to assign frequencies to various tokens of discourse markers and to separate regular and typical associations from marginal occurrences. It is then possible to approximate to citation forms of discourse markers to be used in dictionaries and teaching materials such as those discussed in Part II of this study.
< previous page
page_9
next page >
< previous page
page_10
next page >
Page 10 1.1.2.3 Contrastiυe linguistics υs. translation studies Coming now to the distinction between contrastive and translation studies, we find that the area is fraught with terminological confusion (cf. Krzeszowski 1990:11; Wilss 1996:71ff.).4 The distinction is admittedly a rather fine one; contrastivity, it will be said, is what unites the two branches of language science under consideration. Yet, as Wilss (1996:71ff., esp. 81) and Gallagher (1993:150) point out, contrastive linguistics is generally regarded as operating at the level of abstract language systems, with the aim of segmenting and classifying linguistic data, whereas translatology is deemed to work at the level of actual language use. This reflects the recognition that linguistic units singled out as equivalent may not automatically correspond to translation units and that, conversely, text constituents of widely varying grammatical structure and length may take on similar functions in different languages. There is some truth in the above distinction insofar as one wishes to uphold the traditional version of the Saussurean dichotomy between ‘langue’ and ‘parole’, which is rapidly losing ground in the face of new evidence from corpus linguistics. Especially problematic is the structuralist assumption that lexis and syntax are neatly distinct and autonomous systems which do not impact on one another other than through the operation of general semantic rules and regularities. Lexico-grammars such as Francis et al. (1996, 1998) provide overwhelming evidence to the contrary: there is, in fact, a high degree of interdependence between communicative, lexical and syntactic choices or, more simply put, between sense and syntax. This clearly undermines the Saussurean dichotomy (cf. Sinclair 1991): in the absence of an independent syntactic core of language it becomes difficult, if not impossible, to specify the essence of an abstractly conceived language system; at best, we may assume a large number of heterogeneous lexico-textual subsystems or patterns5 or, as Sinclair (1991:105) has it, an ‘integrated sense-structure complex’. The only unifying feature would be the notion of pattern as such, as described in Hunston and Francis (2000) and Hunston (2001). Given the impossibility of generalizing across instances of language use to arrive at a unifying theory, the distinction between ‘langue’-centred contrastive linguistics and ‘parole’-centred translatology becomes blurred accordingly.6 The time is thus ripe for a paradigm shift which will considerably widen the scope of contrastive linguistics. A new-paradigm contrastive linguistics drawing on computer corpora will enable us to compare lexico-textual subsystems across languages at a hitherto unimagined degree of delicacy. Many equivalences which have until now been assumed to be peculiar to one text, and therefore within the purview of translation studies rather than contrastive linguistics, will then turn out to be attributable to regular correspondences between lexico-textual subsystems or to deviations from such subsystems. This will
< previous page
page_10
next page >
< previous page
page_11
next page >
Page 11 be particularly true with pragmatic texts such as newspaper articles, treaties or manuals, and only slightly less so with literary texts (to the extent that novelists or poets defamiliarize language use). Table 1.1 contains a brief example from a textbook of translation (Lozes and Lozes 1994) which will illustrate what is meant. For the inexperienced linguist, both the English original and the French translation in Table 1.1 may at first glance appear to contain a large number of ‘creative’, one-off occurrences. As a corpus-linguistic investigation shows, nothing could be further from the truth. Leaving aside the headline for the moment, we can see that the English text begins with a fixed expression (as long as I can remember), which can be rendered by a small number of equally fixed French equivalents (d’aussi loin que je me souυienne, aussi loin que je me souυienne). Here the relevant English and French lexico-textual subsystems resemble each other perfectly. It is somewhat different with the lexico-textual subsystem comprising the subject and the verb of the relative clause. This pattern can be glossed as in Table 1.2. In Francis et al. (1996:8) this pattern is subsumed under a more general pattern termed the ‘“Begin” and “Stop” Group’. Other typical members of this group include the items presented in Table 1.3. It is fairly easy to locate the same lexico-textual subsystem in newspaper Table 1.1 An excerpt from a textbook of translation English original French translation A silver lining to antiques fair in Dublin Eclaircie sur le Salon des Antiquaires de Dublin As long as I can remember, the Irish Antiques Aussi loin que je me souvienne, le Salon des Antiquaires Dealers’ Fair, which opens next Monday in the irlandais, qui ouvre ses portes lundi prochain à Mansion House à Mansion House in Dublin, has been preceded by Dublin, est précédé de pleurs et de gémissements de la part des groans of despair from the antique trade. This year, gens de la profession. Cette année, vingt-septième anniversaire the 27th year of the event is no exception. de cette manifestation, ne fait pas exception. Source: adapted from Lozes and Lozes 1994:42–43 Table 1.2 A lexico-textual subsystem Eυent/public place (trade fair, museum, shop,…) Verb expressing start of eυent The Irish Antique Dealers’ Fair opens
< previous page
page_11
next page >
< previous page
page_12
next page >
Page 12 Table 1.3 Examples of a lexico-textual subsystem comprising verbs denoting ‘beginning’ and ‘ending’ The talks began The negotiations ended Table 1.4 A segment of the French lexico-textual subsystem noun (event)+verb (expressing start of event) Eυent/public place (trade fair, museum, shop,…) Verb expressing start of eυent le musée de l’Aventure Peugeot ouvre ses portes le Salon de l’agriculture ouvrira ses portes French; one then finds that the verb ouυrir is not normally used on its own in this pattern (see Table 1.4). A look at the entire subsystem also reveals that an indirect object is often appended to the phrase ouυrir ses portes, a variant which Lozes and Lozes (1994) fail to mention. This indirect object commonly takes the form aux υisiteurs or au public . In their commentary Lozes and Lozes (1994:43) describe their rendition of open by ouυrir ses portes as an instance of ‘étoffement’ (Vinay and Darbelnet 1958:9), or syntactic augmentation. It thus appears as if they have used a textspecific translation procedure which falls outside the scope of contrastive linguistics, especially since the targetlanguage syntagm differs in structure and length from the source-language syntagm. However, as our corpus investigation has shown, the augmentation in question might equally well be regarded as a regular equivalence amenable to contrastive analysis. Similar analyses could be made for all the other translatorial choices evident in the above texts. This is because, as corpus linguists (Gross 1988; Stubbs 1997; Altenberg 1998) have demonstrated, up to 80 per cent of all text is made up of habitual word associations, while the remaining 20 per cent consists of language of regular composition or slight deviations from the collocational norm. Another example from my own translation work may serve to illustrate how contrastive analysis can be operationalized; the source and target texts are excerpts from the website of a Mallorca-based German photo grapher (see Table 1.5). The final sentence of this excerpt is not easy to translate into idiomatic English, and the superficial difference in structure and length between the source and target versions might suggest that the English translation is merely a matter of intuition. It is of course true that, in practice, the translator’s accumulated knowledge and experience or, to put it in cognitive-psychological terms, his ‘procedural knowledge’, will
< previous page
page_12
next page >
< previous page
page_13
next page >
Page 13 Table 1.5 German original and English translation of a website German original English translation Für Journalisten bieten wir einen umfassenden Service, We provide a comprehensive service for journalists, which der sich schon oft arbeitserleichtend bewährt hat: has often contributed to lightening their workload: time Terminplanung vor der Anreise scheduling prior to arrival Flughafenabholung collection from airport Separate Gästewohnung mit Terrasse separate guest flat with roof garden Übersetzungen translation service Internetzugang ADSL und LEONARDO PRO Internet access ADSL and LEONARDO PRO Fahrdienst—Inselscout… chauffeur service—island scout… …und natürlich Fotografie. …and, of course, photography. So ersparen Sie sich unnötige Zeitverluste wegen This will save you from wasting time unnecessarily trying Ortsunkenntnis, Taxi, Mietwagen, Hotelbuchung, to find your way around and looking for taxis, hire cars, Übersetzer etc. hotels, translators, etc.
< previous page
page_13
next page >
< previous page
page_14
next page >
Page 14 lead him to automatically transpose the noun Zeitυerluste to a verb. Yet such a strategy can be operationalized in terms of lexico-textual subsystems. The translator has to convey the concept of ‘Zeitverlust’ in neutral English style. The central lexical items available for this purpose are noun+verb collocations, notably waste time, lose time and squander time, rather than the highly formal compound noun time loss; 7 of these noun+verb collocations, waste time is the most common. The lexico syntactic subsystem containing the verb waste in this sense is described in Francis et al. (1996:289–290). There the translator learns that verbs concerned with passing time in a particular way typically enter the pattern verb+noun phrase+ -ing clause; he therefore has to construct his target sentence around this pattern, so that the prepositional phrase wegen Ortsunkenntnis, Taxi, Mietwagen, Hotelbuchung, Übersetzer has to be converted into an -ing clause and the compound nouns have to be translated by means of verbs. The translator may now consult a corpus or the Internet for the construction under discussion, and will find the German meaning expressed as follows: Plan the storage of your equipment so that you will not waste time unnecessarily in looking around for them. Firms spend half their time dealing with lawyers… Your effects unit really saved me from lounging around and wasting time nunecessarily. We should not spend our time worrying about the future… Don’t spend too much time shopping… But before Mr Major and Mr Blair waste more time trying to double-guess them… …waste management time dealing with such a challenge it does not waste much time worrying about its pride being hurt …skilled reserves who can jump back in without losing time learning a routine This leaves him with possible chunks such as waste time (unnecessarily)/spend too much time/lose time (unnecessarily)…worrying about/dealing with/looking for/trying to… Note that such corpus-based analysis throws up a far greater variety of equivalences than intuition, precisely because it is based on a comparison of lexico-textual subsystems. The last step is to ferret out an English equivalent for the German collocation Zeitυerlust+ersparen, such as save (s.o.) from wasting time, help (s.o.) avoid wasting time or stop (s.o.) [from] wasting time. Thus, we arrive at the variants shown in Table 1.6. In a way such an analysis exemplifies the interplay between the open-
< previous page
page_14
next page >
< previous page
page_15
next page >
Page 15 Table 1.6 Lexico-syntactic variants This will save you from These services will stop you (from) will help you (to) avoid wasting time (unnecessarily) (in) losing time (unnecessarily) (in) spending too much time (in) trying to find your way around and looking for… having to find your way around and worrying about… finding your way around and dealing with (such matters as) choice principle and the idiom principle (Sinclair 1991). Each ‘open’ choice of a particular variant entails specific idiomatic constraints on the surrounding discourse, the central open choices in the present example being the verbs stop/saυe and waste/spend . An alternative corpus search could start with the concept of ‘problem avoidance’, yielding less faithful but functionally equivalent translations such as this will save you the hassle/the trouble of finding your way around Mallorca…, these serυices will saυe (you) hours of searching for…, these serυices will saυe hours of research time for journalists, etc.8 It thus appears that, in cases where two texts are designed to assume the same, or closely similar functions in two cultures (‘Funktionskonstanz, or “functional invariability”, as skopos’, see Reiß and Vermeer 1984), a corpus-based contrastive analysis can supply objective criteria for the discovery and assessment of any translation decision, thereby providing the basis for a fusion of contrastive linguistics and translatology. In this view translation solutions, rather than being one-off, parole-based occurrences, turn out to be instantiations of sense-structure complexes existing in more than one language; the translator’s task is to identify the key semantic concepts contained in the text to be translated, to study target-language lexico-textual subsystems encoding these concepts and to build the target text around the patterns of colligation, collocation and text grammar found in these subsystems. In the rare event, however, that the client commissions a translation whose function differs from that of the source text, contrastive linguistics and translation science must part company. The relevance of this latter type of translation situation has, however, been overstated by translation theorists (cf. Schmitt 1990), and this has led to a concurrent overstatement of the differences between contrastive and translation studies. In this study, then, for want of a better expression, I use the term ‘contrastive analysis’ to refer to the processes involved in identifying and recording multi-word units which assume identical or similar functions in actual manifestations of English, French and German language use. The
< previous page
page_15
next page >
< previous page
page_16
next page >
Page 16 investigation is primarily non-directional, thereby avoiding the pitfalls of comparing already translated texts in an area where discourse patterns have been shown to be culture-specific (cf. for example Kußmaul 1978; Clyne 1981, 1987; Gnutzmann and Lange 1990; Oldenburg 1992).9 Before considering the procedures of contrastive analysis in greater detail, we need to address the vexed question of equivalence. 1.1.2.4 Equiυalence in contrastiυe analysis How can we define and assess interlingual equivalence between discourse markers? The concept, ‘fundamental to translation studies’ (Sager 1994:142) and to contrastive linguistics, has probably caused more ink to flow than any other translatological term, and various typologies of equivalence have been proposed: a distinction may, for example, be made between connotative and denotative equivalence or between cognitive and linguistic equivalence (see Koller 1992; Sager 1994). Full equivalence between two or more languages is a rare event; it can be said to obtain only in the case of one-toone correspondences between place-names such as English London and French Londres or between clearly defined monosemous words such as French téléphone and German Telefon . Generally speaking, however, equivalence denotes similarity rather than identity of source and target-language units. For evidence of this, we need look no further than the word level, where the fuzzy, context-bound nature of meaning leads to a potentially infinite number of renderings for any polysemous word. Thus, a French adjective like sauυage covers such a wide spectrum of meanings that English equivalents may range from shy at one end of the spectrum to cruel at the other, with an abundance of subtly differentiated, context-specific translations in between (cf. Hausmann 1995:21). The foregoing implies that the equivalence of source and target-language multi-word markers can only be established on the basis of functional similarities in their contextual uses, and will usually be subject to certain constraints. For the purposes of the present study, therefore, equivalence can be defined as follows: Equivalence is said to obtain between a source-language item A and a target-language item B if and only if A performs a function in source-language contexts which is identical with, or similar to, the function assumed by B in target-language contexts. The basis of comparison, or tertium comparationis, is thus onomasiological or, more precisely, functionalonomasiological. Possible objections to a functional definition of equivalence can be easily dismissed. Hoey and Houghton (1998:47), for example, object to the use of semantic and/or functional equivalence as a tertium comparationis on the grounds that ‘a
< previous page
page_16
next page >
< previous page
page_17
next page >
Page 17 pair of sentences might be semantically and/or pragmatically equivalent, but have widely differing likelihoods of occurrence in the languages from which they are drawn’. Clearly, this objection becomes invalid in the context of a corpus-driven methodology using frequency counts to control for such factors as differing probabilities of occurrence across languages. Beyond this, functional equivalence has been found too narrow a notion in Métrich’s (1998) investigation into the translation of German particles. Comparing such sentences as Ich glaube kaum, dass er das schafft, aber er kann es ja versuchen. Je ne pense pas qu’il réussisse, mais il peut toujours essayer. (Métrich 1998:197) he notes that, strictly speaking, the German particle ja and the French particle toujours are not functionally equivalent: evidential ja points to the existence of a remote possibility of success, whereas toujours has a chiefly temporal meaning. There is thus no functional equivalence between the two markers, although the rendition of ja by toujours is intuitively satisfactory. This leads Métrich (1998:198) to propose a much broader definition of the targetlanguage equivalent as that lexical item which must be omitted in the target-language text if the particle is omitted from the source-language text. The problem with this definition is that it relies entirely on already translated material, taking for granted the equivalence of the source and target-language texts in which the markers are embedded. Hence also its circularity: the equivalence of the target sentences defines the equivalence of the marker words, and vice versa. Thus, while Métrich’s definition of equivalence is of great lexicographic value, it would be methodologically unsound for this study to depart from a functional definition. It is also unnecessary, since multiword units behave differently from the kind of particle studied by Métrich. 1.1.2.5 Procedure in contrastiυe analysis This brings us to the procedure followed in establishing functional equivalence between the monolingual data, a procedure common to all contrastive studies (cf. Schmidt 1996): the first step is to identify potential equivalents, i.e. items fulfilling identical or similar functions in the languages under survey. This is followed by a close comparison of such potential equivalents with a view to determining formal, semantic and/or functional similarities and differences. This then leads to a sub-categorization of the material by semantic-pragmatic field; in the process it may be found that some items defy straightforward classification, as is the case with any attempt to arrange lexis into neatly bounded sets. In a final step an analysis is made of the use of potential translation equivalents in actual text, the focus being on the various discoursal constraints placed upon their use as
< previous page
page_17
next page >
< previous page
page_18
next page >
Page 18 well as on the strategies which can be employed by translators to cope with such constraints. A contrastive analysis of the kind just described yielded the taxonomy of discourse markers presented in Chapter 3 and the more finely grained analysis of particular functional sets offered in Chapter 4. To ensure perfect reliability, the analyst would have to make a complex factor analysis for each individual type of equivalence. More concretely, she would have to analyse dozens of occurrences of each marker, taken from a wide variety of authors, within a large number of parameters. Such an investigation, while clearly beyond the capacities of a single individual, would equally well be outside the reach of professional research groups. This is because function can only be analysed according to common-sense criteria which may differ from one person to another (Courdier et al. 1994). Added to this are problems stemming from the fuzzy nature of ‘meaning’ or ‘function’, a point already touched upon in Section 1.1.2.4. If a complex factor analysis were to be made, it would be found that no two occurrences of a particular marker are completely identical, and that the set of function/meaning components to be taken into account for definitional purposes can be extended at will (cf. Hausmann 1995:19). In other words, the neat compartmentalizing of meanings or functions characteristic of lexicography and other branches of linguistics can do no more than partially capture an infinitely complex reality. With multilingual contrastive analysis, the situation is further compounded by the fact that no two linguists will have exactly the same knowledge of two or more languages. That is, no individual linguist will have exactly the same command of, say, English and French; nor will she have the same command of, say, French as another linguist. This can be easily illustrated with Grieve’s (1996) study of discourse devices in written French, for Grieve, although a native speaker of English, overlooks a large number of English equivalents of the connectors he discusses (see Chapter 4 for detailed evidence). 1.1.2.6 Analytic framework The remaining question is what framework to use for describing and analysing the complex web of discourse relations. Among the wide variety of text-linguistic models two distinct currents are discernible (Brinker 1988:12–17; Oldenburg 1992:42–47): on one side are the proponents of system-oriented text linguistics, who set out to describe the propositional structure of texts by analogy with traditional sentence-based grammar; on the other are communication-oriented text linguists, who analyse text in terms of a model of communication which takes full account of the situational and cultural embedding of text. A moment’s reflection will reveal that the two approaches are in fact complementary, as it is necessary to
< previous page
page_18
next page >
< previous page
page_19
next page >
Page 19 relate the function and propositional content of particular text segments to their linguistic realizations at the text surface. Fusing as it does the two ways of seeing just mentioned, the model developed by Hatim and Mason (1990) has been chosen for the present study. Hatim and Mason distinguish between two hierarchically arranged subdivisions of text, namely elements and sequences, defining an ‘element’ as ‘the smallest lexico-grammatical unit which can fulfil some rhetorical function’ and a sequence as ‘a unit…which normally consists of more than one element and which serves a higher-order rhetorical function than that of the individual elements in question’. In a later version of this model, Hatim (1997:57) recognizes that a sequence may be realized by only one element. To ‘elements’ and ‘sequences’ I have added the notion of ‘text segment’, or ‘Teiltextsegment’, by which is here meant a piece of text comprising at least two sequences. Firm support for such a notion is provided by German studies in text linguistics such as Hengst (1985), Oldenburg (1992), Gil (1995) and Eggs (1996), which involve close readings of the logico-semantic and pragmatic structure of texts. The functions served by elements, sequences and text segments can be described in terms of Rhetorical Structure Theory (Mann and Thompson 1988), hereafter abbreviated as RST. RST likens the rhetorical relations between text spans to those obtaining between clause complexes. There are two major types of rhetorical relations: nucleussatellite and list. Drawing an analogy with the clause complex, we can compare to hypotaxis the complex nucleussatellite relations, and to parataxis the list relations formed by the simple joining together of independent elements. Judging from available RST analyses, the former are far more frequent than the latter. Table 1.7 briefly explains the majority of nucleus-satellite relations. Each of these relations receives more detailed treatment in terms of the constraints placed upon it, its effect and the locus of this effect. Thus, for example, the background relation is defined as follows (Mann and Thompson 1988): constraints on N: R won’t comprehend N sufficiently before reading text of S constraints on the N+S combination: S increases the ability of R to comprehend an element in N the effect: R’s ability to comprehend N increases locus of the effect: N To illustrate the workings of RST, let us consider a simple example taken from the beginning of a Scientific American article (Mann 1999): 1) Lactose and Lactase 2) Lactose is milk sugar, 3) the enzyme lactase breaks it down. 4) For
< previous page
page_19
next page >
< previous page
next page >
page_20
Page 20 Table 1.7 Nucleus-satellite relations Relation Nucleus name Antithesis Ideas favoured by the author Background Text whose understanding is being facilitated Circumstance Text expressing the events or ideas occurring in the interpretive context Concession Situation affirmed by author
Satellite Ideas disfavoured by the author Text for facilitating understanding An interpretive context of situation or time
Situation which is apparently inconsistent but also affirmed by author Condition Action or situation whose occurrence results from Conditioning situation the occurrence of the conditioning situation Contrast Situation which is compared with another situation Situation which is compared with another situation that is (a) identical with another situation in at that is (a) identical with another situation in at least some respects, (b) similar to, or different least some respects, (b) similar to, or different from, another situation in a few respects from, another situation in a few respects Elaboration Basic information Additional information Enablement An action Information intended to aid the reader in performing an action Eυaluation A situation An evaluative comment about the situation Eυidence A claim Information intended to increase the reader’s belief in the claim Interpretation A situation An interpretation of the situation Justify Text Information supporting the writer’s right to express the text Motiυation An action Information intended to increase the reader’s desire to perform the action Non-υolitionalA situation Another situation which causes that one, but not cause by anyone’s deliberate action Non-υolitionalA situation Another situation which is caused by that one, but result not by anyone’s deliberate action Otherwise Action or situation whose occurrence results from Conditioning situation (antithe lack of occurrence of the conditioning situation conditional) Purpose An intended situation The intent behind the situation Restatement A situation A re-expression of the situation Solutionhood A situation or method supporting full or partial A question, request, problem, or other expressed satisfaction of the need need Summary Text A short summary of that text Volitional A situation Another situation which causes that one, by cause someone’s deliberate action Volitional A situation Another situation which is caused by that one, by result someone’s deliberate action Sources: adapted from Mann and Thompson 1988, Mann 1999
< previous page
page_20
next page >
< previous page
page_21
next page >
Page 21 want of lactase most adults cannot digest milk. 5) In populations that drink milk the adults have more lactase, perhaps through natural selection. Five text elements may be recognized in the excerpt under discussion, preceded by the numbers 1 to 5. At the broadest level, two relations are clearly discernible: the relation holding between 2 and 3 is one of elaboration, that holding between 4 and 5 is one of contrast. Adding a second layer of dependency structure, we find that elements 2 and 3 form a back-ground relation with elements 4 and 5. At yet another level of analysis we find that the heading (1) stands in a ‘preparation relation’ with the rest of the excerpt. An important reason for the adoption of RST is that this framework is open to extension. New relations or subrelations can be added to existing ones if need be. RST is thus in keeping with the Firthian tradition of text analysis, which, as explained on p.5, gives absolute priority to the data. Moreover, RST has already proved a useful heuristic tool in contrastive analysis (cf. Salkie and Oates 1999); its particular value lies in its ability to relate linkage by conjunctions and tacit, or ‘zero’, linkage. A number of criticisms have been made of RST. The most serious charge is that it fails to recognize the possibility of more than one relation at a time existing between nucleus and satellite (Martin 1992:259–260). At first blush, a simple solution might be to extend RST with a view to covering such ‘dual relations’, but there is the added complication that two or more stretches of text may be interrelated at different hierarchical levels. For example, two pieces of evidence following and supporting an assertion may in turn be related to each other through addition or comparison. However, this short-coming is not directly relevant to the present research, which focuses on the primary functions of specific second-level markers in specific text types, not on the whole range of possible conjunctive relations in text at large. More broadly speaking, the plethora of discourse-analytic approaches demonstrates that there is no one definitive way of analysing discursive relationships. The human analyst’s identification of textual units is crucially dependent on her understanding of the text being examined. Nowhere can this be seen more clearly than in the self-defeating attempts of earlier literary criticism to establish the ‘ultimate’ meaning of a text. Today, with the rise of reader and reception theory, the idea associated with author-centred or text-centred criticism of a singular, unified reading has given way to reader-centred notions of infinitely many possible readings. Admittedly, academic texts are a far less complex text type in this regard, and we are here concerned with discourse relations rather than ‘ultimate meaning’, but there clearly remains an element of uncertainty in any text analysis. The same, it may be noted at this juncture, holds true for the classification of discourse markers. As a rule, there seems to be agreement among analysts on made-up examples deemed to be prototypical, but such theorizing
< previous page
page_21
next page >
< previous page
page_22
next page >
Page 22 cannot normally stand up to the complex evidence of language as it is (see Degand 1998; Mauranen 1993). Given the bewildering variety of heuristic-interpretative methods of text analysis, it seems judicious, therefore, to keep an open mind: Further, given the currently unsatisfactory state of knowledge, descriptive and analytic textlinguistic models should be intuitively plausible. As verifiable findings on the structure of language acts are still largely missing, the criterion of plausibility seems best suited to the evaluation of such models and of the results they yield. This is because every native speaker of a language has an intuitive knowledge of text and text structures. (Oldenburg 1992:47; my translation) Mann and Thompson also take explicit account of the subjectivity of the human analyst: Given the nature of text analysis, these are judgments of plausibility rather than certainty…the analyst is judging whether it is plausible that the writer desires the specified condition. (Mann and Thompson 1988:245) The model I have proposed, borrowing from Hatim and Mason (1990) as well as Mann and Thompson (1988), clearly meets the criterion of intuitive plausibility. 1.2 Corpora and corpus-enquiry tools Shall I make spirits fetch me what I please, resolve me of all ambiguities. Christopher Marlowe, Doctor Faustus Since at least the 1980s language science has been in the throes of a ‘corpus revolution’. Naturally occurring data, available in their millions from machine-held collections of text, have become the life-blood of the discipline. Indeed, the ever-expanding size of corpora may tempt linguists and translation scholars to indulge Faustian fantasies of omniscience. It is not, of course, the use of electronic corpora in itself that is new; in France, for example, the computerized database Frantext has existed for over forty years (Habert et al. 1997:7). Rather, the revolution has been made possible by increasing ease of access to electronic text and corpora,10 their enrichment through computerized annotation and the ability of micro-computers to process ever-larger stretches of text at ever-greater speeds. This latter development has also resulted in data-driven approaches making inroads into translation and foreign language classes (Johns and King 1991). In view of the foregoing considerations it is not surprising that this
< previous page
page_22
next page >
< previous page
page_23
next page >
Page 23 study, too, avails itself of machine-readable corpora. Work with such corpora raises a number of methodological and practical issues. Foremost amongst these is the relationship, discussed in Section 1.1.2.1, between intuition and corpus evidence, but almost equally important are the issues associated with the compilation and analysis of corpora. These are the subject of the present chapter, which confines itself to native speaker corpora; learner corpora will occupy us in Part II. 1.2.1 Corpus building and information retrieval This is not the place to give a detailed account of the history, aims and methods of corpus linguistics.11 I shall therefore confine my discussion to the issues of corpus building and information retrieval as they apply to the present research, which draws its data from five different types of computer-readable text archive in each language: • electronic editions of wide-circulation quality newspapers and news magazines ( The Times, the Guardian, The Economist, Le Monde, Le Monde diplomatique, Süddeutsche Zeitung, Frankfurter Rundschau, Der Spiegel ) (see Section 1.2.2.1); • the largest reference work available on CD-ROM (Britannica CD, CD-ROM UNIVERSALIS, Gabler Wirtschaftslexikon CD-ROM) (see Section 1.2.2.2); • a large corpus of academic texts produced from reviews, journal articles, doctoral theses and portions of books (see Section 1.2.2.3); • a ten-million-word parallel corpus made up of evenly sized subsections representing various disciplines of the fullsize academic corpora; the texts in the parallel corpora are roughly matched by such criteria as date of composition and text category (see Section 1.2.2.4); • a multilingual translation corpus comprising a variety of text categories from both fictional and non-fictional sources.12 Table 1.8 gives a breakdown of the sources used by corpus type, content, size, baseline year and analysis software. The research based on these corpora was divided into two phases: corpus building (Section 1.2.2) and text analysis (Section 1.2.3). I will deal with these in turn. 1.2.2 Corpus design and compilation The corpus linguist has to address a number of competing design issues (see Kennedy 1998; Pearson 1998), including: • time and resources available for corpus building • purpose of the research
< previous page
page_23
next page >
< previous page
next page >
page_24
Page 24 Table 1.8 Corpora used Corpus TypeContent
Word Baseline year count
Analysis software
News corpora (see Section 1.2.2.1) British Full- Issues of The Times, the Guardian and The 100 1990 WordSmith newspapers and text Economist, published in London million Concordancer, news magazines Microconcord; (NE) Search Engine French Full- Issues of Le Monde and Le Monde diplomatique, 100 1990 WordSmith newspapers and text published in Paris million Concordancer, news magazines Microconcord; (NF) Search Engine German Full- Issues of Süddeutsche Zeitung, Frankfurter 100 1990 WordSmith newspapers and text Rundschau and Der Spiegel, published respectively million Concordancer, news magazines in Stuttgart, Frankfurt and Hamburg Microconcord; (NG) Search Engine CD-ROM-based corpora (see Section 1.2.2.2) Encylopaedia Full- Humanities and sciences texts 50 1996 Netscape Navigator Britannica (EB) text million Encyclopedic Full- Humanities and sciences texts 50 1996 Search Engine Universalis (EU) text million Gablers Full- Economics texts 6 1994 Search Engine Wirtschaftslexikon text million (GW) Full-text academic corpora (see Section 1.2.2.3) Corpus of Full- Reviews, journal articles, doctoral theses and 50 1980 (less than WordSmith academic English text portions of books million 5% of texts Concordancer, (CAE) predate 1980) Microconcord Corpus of Full- Reviews, journal articles, doctoral theses and 30 1980 (less than WordSmith academic French text portions of books million 5% of texts Concordancer, (CAF) predate 1980) Microconcord Corpus of Full- Reviews, journal articles, doctoral theses and 30 1980 (less than WordSmith academic German text portions of books million 5% of texts Concordancer, (CAG) predate 1980) Microconcord Parallel academic corpora (see Section 1.2.2.4) Parallel corpus of Full- Reviews, journal articles and portions of books 9.5 1980 WordSmith academic English text from CAE million Concordancer, (PCAE) Microconcord Parallel corpus of Full- Reviews, journal articles and portions of books 9.5 1980 WordSmith academic French text from CAF million Concordancer, (PCAF) Microconcord Parallel corpus of Full- Reviews, journal articles and portions of books 9.5 1980 WordSmith academic German text from CAG million Concordancer, (PCAG) Microconcord Multilingual translation corpus (see Section 1.2.2.4) Multilingual Full- Academic prose, novels, EU financial regulations, 1950 Multiconcord translation corpus text manuals, etc. (MTC)
< previous page
page_24
next page >
< previous page
page_25
next page >
Page 25 • size • text type and length • text categorization by subject area • baseline year • sources and availability of electronic text • publication status and technicality As we shall see, these issues are fairly easy to settle as regards news corpora, while academic corpora are more problematic. 1.2.2.1 News corpora Such has been the invasion of journalistic genres into all spheres of life that a study of discourse cannot do without them. Newspaper language has been aptly described as a ‘perennial Fountain of Youth’ (Gallagher 1982:7) in which living idioms are constantly renewed. Next to the novel, the newspaper article is probably the single most widely read written genre (Kennedy 1998:49), holding a pivotal place in the evolution of any language of the civilized world. It is also common knowledge that there is ample cross-fertilization between the language of academics and that of journalists. Just as academic ‘shop talk’ tends to influence the popular science writer, so journalistic coinages spill over into academic treatises. Annual editions of major quality papers on CD-ROM provide a commercially available, ‘pre-designed’ means for linguists to study news media language. The prodigious dimensions of such text archives—usually between 30 and 40 million words per CD-ROM—make it possible to give an accurate and reliable portrait of the use which journalists make of such linguistic items as discourse markers. The ready availability of text on archival CD-ROMs led to a ‘pragmatic’ sampling approach which took account of both the representativeness and the quality of the writing involved. For each language under investigation, 90 per cent of the corpus texts was collected from ‘highbrow’ broadsheets, while 10 per cent was culled from quality news magazines (see p. 24). Texts were selected from across the various daily, weekly or monthly sections appearing in the news media under consideration; the corpus material thus obtained was transferred on to the hard disk of a computer. No claim is made here that the news corpora are representative of the written language as a whole; rather, the assumption is simply that they represent a broad sample of ordinary usage in the British, French and German quality press in the 1990s. While it is true that even a 100-million-word corpus is small compared to the totality of written news media text published in the 1990s, work on other large corpora such as the Bank of English has shown that 100 million words taken from various sources is a sufficient sample to guarantee representativeness and reliability.
< previous page
page_25
next page >
< previous page
page_26
next page >
Page 26 1.2.2.2 Reference CD-ROMs With the reference CD-ROMs the issues of design and compilation have, as it were, been settled by the publishers. The Britannica CD boasts 65,000 text articles, whereas the French-language CD-ROM Uniυersalis contains 22,000, a figure exactly equalled by the German Gabler Wirtschaftslexikon CD-ROM. With articles ranging from brief definitions through impressionistic overviews to all-encompassing expositions, it may be appropriate to express more precisely the size of these storehouses of scholarly writing. Thus, at a conservative estimate, the Britannica and Uniυersalis CD-ROMs run to approximately 50 million words each, while the Gabler Wirtschaftslexikon, at around 6 million words, is considerably smaller. This apparent drawback is tempered by the fact that the Gabler Wirtschaftslexikon is devoted in its entirety to a humanities discipline and therefore easy to understand for the analyst. 1.2.2.3 The full-size academic corpora Let us now consider one by one the aforementioned design issues as they apply to the construction of the three fullsize corpora of academic English, French and German. 1.2.2.3.1 TIME AND RESOURCES AVAILABLE For the corpus linguist working in isolation, practical considerations preclude any attempt to emulate large-scale corpus compilation projects. Since no sizeable corpus of academic English, French or German was publicly available at the time this study got under way, I approached a number of publishers to obtain electronic versions of academic books. Apart from my French publisher Ellipses, who kindly sent two textbooks on floppy disk, no other company was willing to contribute in the absence of substantial pecuniary rewards. I therefore had no alternative but to collect texts from other sources. Text collection took two forms: first and foremost, I downloaded copyright-free texts on to my PC from electronic journals and academic text archives mounted on the Internet. Time-consuming as this text capture was, taking up at least 100 man-hours per corpus, it still seemed the most viable option considering the extra expenditure of money, time and effort involved in scanning texts. Second, a small number of authors kindly supplied a few publications on floppy disk. 1.2.2.3.2 PURPOSE The aim of the present study is to set up a taxonomy of discourse markers as well as to provide a detailed and systematic study of their use in aca-
< previous page
page_26
next page >
< previous page
page_27
next page >
Page 27 demic text. It is therefore not necessary for the corpora to be fully representative of academic language as a whole; nor is it indispensable for them to have the same size. The corpora merely need to contain a sufficiently large number of tokens of any category of discourse marker in the languages under investigation. This raises questions about the adequate size of the corpus, and the range of text types to be covered. 1.2.2.3.3 CORPUS SIZE Just as corpus work usually proceeds in an iterative cycle (see Section 1.1), so too does corpus construction (cf. Biber 1993): to ensure that the size of the academic corpora fitted the purpose of the present study, a number of pre-tests had to be carried out at various stages of the compilation process. These pre-tests were based on a wide range of items taken from an extensive list of discourse markers I had compiled manually over the years. The establishment of such an inventory of scholarly metadiscourse had long been a research interest of mine, arising from a simple didactic desire: helping myself and others to write English, French and German in an authentic, correct and sufficiently sophisticated manner. The inventory data were collected during the six years of my studies and beyond, as I happened upon them in scholarly treatises, academic textbooks and popular scientific works.13 Initially, a separate inventory was developed for each language. A number of correspondences then almost automatically forced themselves on my mind as the monolingual collections grew in size. Part of the rationale behind the present corpus compilation project is to check, with regard to some types and tokens of discourse markers, whether the matches thus obtained are viable. Two questions then arise: 1. How much text have I read over the years? 2. How reliable and representative have my notes been? It is, of course, impossible to answer these questions exactly. As already noted, humans generally read for content rather than form, and since their eyes tend to alight on odd or felicitous turns of phrase rather than common-or-garden wordings, it seems arguable that some tokens of discourse markers will have been missed in the course of such reading. Even allowing for human fallibility, though, it is evident that the amount of text I have scanned by eye over the years is at least equivalent to, if not larger than, the 30-million-word academic corpora assembled for the purposes of this study. This becomes apparent when we translate the usual word measure into more familiar terms: 30 million words of text correspond roughly to a body of 240 medium-sized books or 150 voluminous doctoral theses (Ball 1996). It is a good guess that normally gifted students get through at least half that amount in the course of their studies. The aforementioned pre-tests showed that a 10-million-word academic corpus is large enough to provide a substantial number of instances of multi-word discourse markers which can usefully, if not quite exhaustively,
< previous page
page_27
next page >
< previous page
page_28
next page >
Page 28 fill out the picture emerging from manual analysis. A fully exhaustive description would require corpora larger by at least one order of magnitude; but to date no such corpora have been assembled. Accordingly, it was felt desirable to increase the size of the corpora with a view to increasing their representativeness. The growing availability of electronic text made it possible to increase corpus size for the academic corpora to around 30 million words for French and German, and 50 million words for English. While it would have been easy to obtain a larger amount of English text at the moment of writing, the opposite is true of French and German text. Deplorable as this may be, English clearly dominates the international academic scene, and probably more than 90 per cent of all academic texts published on the Internet or on CD-ROM are in English. That said, however, it should be pointed out that the academic corpora built for this study, most especially the French and German corpora, are easily the largest and most diverse electronic archives of academic language ever created, including substantial quantities of text from various subject fields and genres. The English corpus, for example, is considerably larger than the relevant sections of the British National Corpus or the corpus used for the Longman Grammar of Spoken and Written English (Biber et al. 1999). 1.2.2.3.4 TEXT TYPE AND LENGTH The text types chosen to represent academic prose were reviews, journal articles, doctoral theses and other monographs. The vast majority of the material included was literature written by specialists for specialists, with just a few articles and books intended for a wider readership. Only complete texts found their way into the corpora, with the exception of book chapters, which are usually self-contained in their discursive structure. Equally valid arguments can of course be found in favour of both sample and full-text corpora, but, as Sinclair (1991:23–24) points out, the use of sample corpora may pose problems when the analysis requires surveying large, logically connected portions of text, as in the case of discourse markers, which tend to have scope over fairly extended text spans. The actual compilation process followed a ‘clean-text’ policy (Sinclair 1991:21); that is, text was entered as it was, free of any additional analytic marks. This means that texts downloaded from the Internet may contain minute quantities of additional non-academic text such as links ( back, home, etc.), but such extraneous text is also commonly found in other types of publication. 1.2.2.3.5 TEXT CATEGORIZATION BY SUBJECT AREA A number of pre-tests confirmed my initial hypothesis that it is sensible to posit a general text type called ‘the academic text’ (see also Meyer 1996,
< previous page
page_28
next page >
< previous page
page_29
next page >
Page 29 1997). They also showed that it is possible to describe discourse-marker use on the basis of arts corpora alone, as the metalanguage used in the latter does not differ materially from that found in hard science texts, although particular items may occur with varying frequencies. Thus, items such as neυertheless, on the other hand, the same goes for or it is worth noting+ -ing were found to be equally represented in science and arts texts; items such as I/we report/describe (Hyland 1999a:118), while clearly more frequent in science texts, were found to occur with significant frequencies in arts texts as well. In line with the results of the pre-tests, a broad notion of the humanities informed the design of the three academic corpora. The domains represented in the final versions of the corpora are literature, language, history, sociology, philosophy, economics, musicology, theology, political science, education and law. The field of literature comprises literary theory and criticism, and the field of language may be further subdivided into linguistics, translation studies, classical philology and language teaching. The corpus texts were saved in separate files. Files containing texts from the same domain were given identical, selfexplanatory prefixes, e.g. ling* for linguistics and eco* for economics (where the asterisk stands for the rest of the filename). There was a dual rationale behind such codification: first, it allowed for the extraction from the full-size corpora of parallel corpora containing evenly sized sub-sections. Second, it was thought that it would enable comparison of the frequency of items across various disciplines. However, once the parallel corpora were complete, it turned out that the samples were too small to allow definitive judgements, and therefore the idea of frequency comparisons between disciplines was abandoned. My approach to text categorization was based mainly on external, non-linguistic criteria. If a text appeared in an economics journal, for example, it was classified as an economics text unless it was obvious that the text fell within the scope of another discipline; and thus for other text types as well. One final point to be considered is whether there are significant divergences between geographic varieties of academic prose. Biber et al. (1999) have shown that this is not the case for British and American English. On European and Canadian academic French the literature is silent. However, my experience of reading both varieties suggests that interlingual differences have been levelled out. 1.2.2.3.6 SOURCES AND AVAILABILITY OF ELECTRONIC TEXT Given the restricted availability of academic text on the Internet, I was forced to pursue a middle course between opportunistic and systematic sampling, with the aim of maintaining a roughly even representation of
< previous page
page_29
next page >
< previous page
page_30
next page >
Page 30 the chosen domains in the full-text corpora and with a view to the creation of the three parallel corpora discussed below. As I have argued elsewhere (Siepmann 2002b), a corpus representative of the whole language (rather than just academic English) can be built by selecting large samples of the most diverse areas of natural language use; in so doing, the corpus builder often has to proceed by trial and error, testing whether or not particular language items can be located in the corpus and, if not, adding texts in which such items can be found. In a similar vein, Stubbs (2000) points out that the construction of a representative corpus should rely on ‘largish general corpora designed according to a sociolinguistic theory of text-type variation, small specialist corpora put together (possibly temporarily) for particular knowledge domains or text-types, and very large opportunistic text collections’. It stands to reason, therefore, that large corpora drawing on a wide variety of research areas and journals should allow us to build up a reliable picture of lexical patterning in academic language. 1.2.2.3.7 BASELINE YEAR The year 1920 was taken as the baseline for the selection of published material, although less than 5 per cent of the corpus texts predate 1980. Underlying the inclusion of some older texts by accomplished stylists of previous generations was the assumption that many younger writers of English fail to maintain sufficient clarity and sophistication of expression, and that the language of today may be enriched through the language of yesteryear. 1.2.2.4 The parallel corpora and the multilingual translation corpus In recent years a number of translation corpora have been compiled with a view to promoting cross-linguistic study and/or language teaching. A translation corpus consists of original texts in one language and their translations into one or more other languages. Among the more prominent examples of translation corpora are the EnglishNorwegian Parallel Corpus (Johansson and Hofland 1994), the emerging English-German Parallel Corpus14 and the multilingual translation corpus employed in this study, which, apart from English, French and German texts, also includes material in Spanish, Portuguese and Italian. It is here used as a basis for comparing discourse-marker use in some academic texts and their translations (see Section 4.2). Apart from scholarly prose, the corpus comprises a variety of text categories from both fictional and non-fictional sources, including for example the well-known French comic Tintin, but excluding drama and verse. Work with translation corpora has brought the realization that a variety of factors militate against their use as the only source of cross-linguistic
< previous page
page_30
next page >
< previous page
page_31
next page >
Page 31 evidence. Some of these concern any study dealing with contrastive linguistics and translation; others are specific to the present research: • The reliability of the translation corpus as a source of cross-linguistic evidence stands or falls on the quality of the translations. There are two types of evidence to suggest that the latter is not as high as it could be: academic translation criticism has shown many translations to be either flawed or skewed along a number of linguistic dimensions (e.g. House 1997), and this assessment has been confirmed by investigations into corpora comprising either source texts and their translations (Johansson and Hofland 1994; Johansson and Oksefjell 1998) or original texts and translated texts drawn from similar areas (Laviosa-Braithwaite 1996; Kenny 1997). It has been found that the average published translation either exhibits features traceable to source language interference or exaggerates typical features of the target language (Baker 1996), so that it may be justifiable to characterize the language produced by at least some translators as a ‘third code’ (Øveras 1996). • The other main reason why translation corpora cannot be the sole source of evidence in research such as this is a pragmatic one. It is that the only moderate frequency of multi-word items makes it necessary to base the research on corpora of at least several million words, and it is well-nigh impossible to find, let alone scan, a sufficiently large number of academic texts that exist as either originals or translations in all three languages involved. By contrast, parallel corpora, which contain evenly sized sections of particular text types from several languages, allow us to make a reliable comparison of authentic language use that is free from the distorting influence of ‘translationese’. But they are not without their problems either. One difficulty is that, when aiming at a multi-million word corpus, it is impossible to obtain full equivalence between corpora. Gabel (2000) suggests that parallel corpora should be equivalent with respect to the number and type of texts as well as their length. While this is fairly easy to achieve in Gabel’s study of e-mail communication, which uses a very small database, it is both impossible and unnecessary to control for such variables as age and curriculum vitae in a large-scale study of academic language such as this. Also, there is too much variation between individual texts for complete equivalence to be achieved in the types and lengths of texts. A compromise must therefore be struck between the desirable and the feasible; in the present study comparability of corpora is taken to denote equivalence in terms of overall corpus size and the proportion of text representing each discipline. In addition, it might be argued that there is a homogeneity of background among the contributors to the corpus in the sense that all of them have completed a tertiary-level course of study.
< previous page
page_31
next page >
< previous page
page_32
next page >
Page 32 Table 1.9 Composition of the Parallel Corpus English section French section Discipline Word count Discipline Word count Sociology 1,533,778Sociology 1,598,043 Philosophy 1,289,347Philosophy 1,264,218 Political Science 427,510Political Science 387,463 Linguistics, Language Teaching 3,345,090 (Literature:Linguistics, Language Teaching 3,276,226 (Literature: and Literature 971,526) and Literature 885,798) Economics and Business 1,254,892Economics and Business 1,330,561 Management Management History 611,258History 591,282 Law 204,558Law 207,856 Theology 690,216Theology 685,760 Reviews 181,608Reviews 196,033 Total 9,538,257Total 9,537,442 German section Discipline Word count Sociology 1,575,472 Philosophy 1,295,949 Political Science 361,055 Linguistics, Language Teaching and Literature 3,285,948 (Literature: 861,224) Economics and Business Management 1,212,145 History 585,633 Law 181,619 Theology 815,622 Reviews 224,667 Total 9,538,110
< previous page
page_32
next page >
< previous page
page_33
next page >
Page 33 A second problem with parallel corpora is that the decision on what to compare is left to the analyst’s semanticpragmatic intuitions. In this study, however, it is based on a pre-established list of categories arising from long years of manual searches. Another much-discussed problem is that any statistical statement based on a corpus is inherently a ‘stochastic construct’ (Gabel 2000:125). This is particularly problematic when, as in Gabel (2000), learner corpora are compared with native-speaker corpora with a view to determining the nature of the learners’ interlanguage (for the simple reason that it presupposes an idealized learner), but much less so in the case of large collections of native language use which are tapped to obtain information on the forms and functions of phraseological units in various languages, as in the present study. Indeed, such corpora allow us to generalize across the countervailing tendencies usually observed in any natural language, thus helping us to substantiate or refute many claims in the contrastivist literature which were made on the basis of impressionistic evidence. For example, the claim that French writers make more extensive use of connectors than German writers has been elevated to almost dogmatic status in comparative stylistics, although there is some evidence to the contrary (Gallagher 1995). By balancing out individual differences large corpora place us in a position to decide such issues with greater certainty. If it were found, for example, that, on average, French academic texts do indeed contain a comparatively larger number of multi-word markers, and that native-speaker readers find such texts easier to process, then this would have clear implications for the teaching of writing and translation: for example, English and German learners of French would have to be taught strategies for making sense relations explicit that they normally leave unexpressed in their native languages. Table 1.9 shows the composition of the parallel corpus used in this study. 1.2.3 Text analysis Text analysis was based on a range of utility programs. The academic corpora were mainly interrogated with the help of the WordSmith Concordancer (Oxford University Press). Two other corpus-enquiry tools were used for particular purposes: Microconcord for word counts and Multiconcord for investigating the Multilingual Translation Corpus (see p. 24). The use of cryptography in preparing texts for encyclopaedias makes it impossible to use the usual text analysis software for searching such reference works. Thus the Encyclopaedia Britannica must be searched using the Netscape Navigator, and the French and German reference works cited above also come with their own restricted search facilities.
< previous page
page_33
next page >
< previous page
page_34
next page >
Page 34 2 Investigating routines Defining and describing multi-word discourse markers A definition is the enclosing a wilderness of idea within a wall of words. Samuel Butler, Notebooks Meyer (1996) has shown that non-specialist lexis is fundamentally, if somewhat paraxodically, constitutive of academic text. Among the components of such general or ‘procedural’ (Widdowson 1983) vocabulary, speech acts and their results figure prominently, helping as they do to construct a ‘pragmatic skeleton’ (Meyer 1996:186) fleshed out with the entities, ideas and activities that form the conceptual content of text. More crucially, they play an essential role in establishing what is known as ‘reflexivity’, i.e. the ways in which language is used to refer to or describe itself (Lyons 1977:5). Much of the non-specialist lexis in question consists of chunked wholes which can be readily, and often unconsciously, brought to mind by educated native speakers of a language. As indicated in the previous chapter, the present work deals with one class of such prepackaged phrases, for which the intuitive label ‘multi-word discourse marker’ suggests itself—a notion which will have to be sharpened in the following pages. To get our discussion on a concrete footing, let us consider a French linguistics text illustrating the use of such markers in academic discourse: Si, en l’état de nos connaissances, il est difficile d’envisager un enseignement directif et systématique de la compétence linguistique, cette constatation est encore plus frappante pour la compétence discursive. Même s’il existe une longue tradition de réflexion sur le discours dans le cadre de la rhétorique, l’étude systématique des structures du discours a commencé seulement dans les années soixante-dix. Rappelons qu’il y a moins de trente ans, Benveniste concluait un article dans la revue Langages par l’affirmation de la nécessité d’aborder l’étude systématique des structures du dialogue (cf. Benveniste 1970), ce qui témoigne de l’état rudimentaire des connaissances au moment où on commençait à parler pourtant de
< previous page
page_34
next page >
< previous page
page_35
next page >
Page 35 compétence de communication. Quels que soient les progrès, souvent marquants, réalisés depuis dans la description de l’organisation du discours, nos connaissances sont encore trop réduites et trop partielles pour fonder un enseignement directif et systématique de la compétence discursive. On pourrait conclure de ce qui précède que nous sommes totalement démunis par rapport à l’objectif, que tous les intéressés s’accordent à considérer comme primordial, d’amener l’apprenant à la maîtrise d’une compétence discursive. Ce n’est heureusement pas le cas. Il suffit, pour s’en assurer, de revenir à l’observation, qui relève du savoir commun, sur la capacité des apprenants d’acquérir spontanément une compétence linguistique et une compétence discursive en langue maternelle ou en langue seconde dans la communauté où cette langue est utilisée. Les recherches récentes, en particulier dans le champ de la grammaire générative transformationnelle, ont montré que les apprenants avaient la capacité d’acquérir des structures grammaticales beaucoup plus complexes… On peut donc supposer, même si les études dans ce domaine sont moins avancées, que la capacité des apprenants d’acquérir une compétence discursive en langue maternelle ou en langue seconde va bien au-delà des capacités des spécialistes de décrire l’organisation du discours. Ceci dit, il n’est guère possible de reproduire complètement, dans la classe de langue maternelle, une situation d’apprentissage naturel de compétences avancées comme la participation à une négociation commerciale ou à une séance de comité… Les expériences toujours plus nombreuses d’enseignement par immersion ne proposent qu’une simulation partielle, dans l’espace et dans le temps, qui ne peut dispenser d’une certaine forme d’enseignement. Il faut donc concevoir, en langue maternelle comme en langue seconde, ce qu’on appelle précisément depuis quelques années un enseignement-apprentissage, fondé à la fois sur la capacité d’apprentissage des apprenants et sur un apport pédagogique des enseignants et des modes d’enseignement. (Roulet 2000) From a linguist’s perspective, there are several interesting facts about the markers exemplified above. The first thing to be said is that all of them—with the exception perhaps of ce qu’on appelle—are connectors of one sort or another. Most of them indicate that the writer is moving on to another stage of his argument or making an additional point; typical examples are il suffit, pour s’en assurer, de and on peut donc supposer que, the first introducing anecdotal evidence for the preceding statement, the second initiating a discussion of the implications of the previous discourse. There is thus a
< previous page
page_35
next page >
< previous page
page_36
next page >
Page 36 clear case for establishing a parallel between these multi-word expressions and the forms traditionally identified as discourse markers. Both can only be properly accounted for if considered from an intersentential or textual perspective; they are ‘eminently text-linguistic problems’ (Söll 1985:163) which only detailed corpus evidence can elucidate. Structurally, it turns out that we are not dealing with a unified phenomenon. The markers in question cut across the whole spectrum of word combinations, ranging from individual words (donc; and, actually, but, howeυer) through immutable phrases (I mean, you see, for example, what else) , variable phrases (ceci dit, en l’état de nos connaissances; to cut a long story short) and set expressions (ce n’est pas le cas; only oυer my dead body) all the way to clauses (on pourrait conclure de ce qui précède que; as I haυe said) and sentence-like units (this is not the whole story, though);1 indeed, as some further examples show (an example is proυided by; dabei ist zu bedenken, dass; cela implique que) many of them are not structurally complete. Markers of the type force est de constater, for example, are formed from the fixed sentence stem force est de plus a restricted choice of verbs ( constater, reconnaître, ajouter, etc.); the resultant structure can be followed by a direct object or a complement clause starting with que. Similarly, with on peut supposer que we have a pronominal subject followed by a verb phrase plus the start of a complement clause, and with ce qu’on appelle or ce qu’il est conυenu d’appeler we have fragmentary relative clauses. In this connection we might also make the observation that many of the word groupings in question can be regarded as extended collocations. Consider, for example, a sentence stem such as cette constation est encore plus frappante pour, built around the noun-adjective collocation constat(ation)+frappant. Furthermore, the extract illustrates the significantly dense use of these markers in academic text; similar observations could be made for journalistic texts. A rough indication of the statistical significance of word groupings (Jones and Sinclair 1974) can be obtained by comparing the number of actual occurrences with the likelihood of their occurring by chance. A word grouping is statistically significant if the probability of its chance occurrence is sufficiently low. Several measures of such statistical significance have evolved which are mutually illuminating. The most commonly used of these are z-score, t-score and mutual information (Barnbrook 1996:94ff.): z-score, for example, denotes ‘the difference between observed and expected frequencies expressed as a number of standard deviations’ (Barnbrook 1996:96). For our purposes, it seems sufficient to compare raw frequency figures for a phrase such as ceci dit (see Table 2.1). The calculation in Table 2.1 shows that, in a randomly organized corpus composed of the same words as NF, one would expect to find only one co-occurrence of the words ceci and dit, their actual frequency, however, is 95. Similar differences between observed and expected frequencies could be calculated for the other phrases exemplified above.
< previous page
page_36
next page >
< previous page
page_37
next page >
Page 37 Table 2.1 Observed and expected frequencies of ceci dit in NF Expected frequency of ceci+dit in NF ( E=f[ceci=1925]/corpus size×f [dit= Obserυed frequency of ceci+dit in NF 53157])/corpus size=ƒ (ceci) ƒ (dit)/ Corpus size 2) ( frequency [ceci dit]/corpus size ) 0.0000000102327225 (i.e. 1 in 100 million) 0.00000095 (i.e. 95 in 100 million) Linguistic intuitions about the significance of such word groupings thus find confirmation in statistical fact. Lastly, it is important to note that recurrent multi-word expressions and common first-level markers may be strung together (on peut donc supposer que), and that several second-level markers may occur in sequence (Ce n’est heureusement pas le cas. Il suffit, pour s’en assurer, de+INF) . The foregoing observations provide us with a crude approximation to a definition of multi-word markers. A more precise definition will be attempted in the rest of this chapter. I shall aim to mark off the word combinations under discussion from other types of phraseology by applying criteria related to their pragmatic function (Section 2.1), lexico-semantic structure and frequency of occurrence (Section 2.2). Section 2.3 will attempt to bring some order into the intuitive structural classification just made. 2.1 Pragmatic perspectives on discourse markers In the preceding section the intuitive notion ‘multi-word discourse marker’ was employed to refer to such conventionalized language chunks as il suffit, pour s’en assurer, de+INF, and some initial evidence was provided to justify its use. This section attempts to sharpen the notion by arguing that the term ‘discourse marker’ can be applied to both written and spoken language (Section 2.1.1) and that discourse markers can carry pragmatic as well as propositional meaning (Section 2.1.2). A simple, albeit methodologically invalid, reason for using the term ‘discourse marker’ may be the desire not to add to the flood of terminology threatening to submerge language science. The term, probably coined by Labov and Fanshel (1977:156), has come to be the commonest designation for a rag-bag of seemingly empty expressions variously known as fillers (Brown and Yule 1983), Flickwörter, Gliederungssignale (Gülich 1970), comment clauses (Quirk et al. 1985), discourse-deictic items (Levinson 1983), pragmatic markers (Brinton 1996), discourse connectiυes (Warner 1985), cue phrases (Grosz and Sidner 1986), lexical phrases (Nattinger and De Carrico 1992), organizers (Nattinger and De Carrico 1992) or marker words (BBC World Serυice English Language Teaching); and the list might even be extended. The study of such items has been actively pursued at least
< previous page
page_37
next page >
< previous page
page_38
next page >
Page 38 since Gülich’s (1970) seminal thesis on the ‘macro-syntax of signalling devices in spoken French’ (‘Makrosyntax der Gliederungssignale im gesprochenen Französisch’). So far the emphasis has been firmly on oral discourse, as reflected in the following dictionary definitions: Special attention has been focused on discourse markers—sequentially dependent elements which demarcate units of speech, such as oh, well and I mean. (Crystal 1997:118–119) A word or phrase which helps to signal the direction in which language, particularly in a conversation, is going. The term is somewhat specialized and not easily defined, but may include not only (a) conjunctions (e.g. and, but, or, because, etc.) but also (b) words outside the main syntax, such as oh, well, you see, I mean, etc. Words and phrases in this second group are sometimes labelled FILLERS or pragmatic particles. (Chalker and Weiner 1994:119) It is interesting to note that Crystal (1997), borrowing from Schiffrin (1987), reserves the term exclusively for speech, while Chalker and Weiner (1994) appear to make some allowance for the written language (‘particularly in a conversation’). 2.1.1 Spoken υs. written discourse marker use There are, in fact, numerous points of contact between discourse marker use in spoken and written texts. For instance, the somewhat cumbersome topic shifter it may be noted in passing that, peculiar to written, or written-tobe-spoken register, may be said to parallel closely the use of incidentally in everyday speech or writing. To take a concrete example, note how in the following stretch of everyday speech the discourse marker ‘incidentally’ signals a topic shift: ‘I did teach English from American textbooks in America. Incidentally, I just talked my RP out in Labrador where they had a strong local Labrador Canadian accent’ (Lenk 1998:218). In a written text, a possible sequence built around similar content might read: There was strong emphasis on American textbooks and American English. (It may be noted in passing that the author lost his British accent when staying in Labrador.) Conversely, the qualifier haυing said that, common in the spoken language, is often recast more succinctly as this said or that said in the written language, while retaining its function. It thus appears that the omnibus term ‘discourse marker’ can be correctly and usefully applied to both spoken and written language although many linguists prefer to reserve ‘discourse’ for the former. Of course, this is not to deny that different types of discourse markers
< previous page
page_38
next page >
< previous page
page_39
next page >
Page 39 may be used in oral and written discourse (Schiffrin 1987). But a moment’s reflection will allow us to see that the degree of overlap is much greater than generally assumed. In addition to the above-cited examples, consider English markers such as of course, in fact or in any case, French markers such as justement, franchement or en fait and German markers such as etwa, jedenfalls or immerhin, all of which are common in both speech and writing. Significantly also, the present research is not alone in including written items in the category of discourse markers. There is firm evidence from a study of old, middle and early modern English (Brinton 1996) that discourse markers have always played a major role in written narratives, where they serve, among other things, to mark points of transition or to foreground important events. With reference to present-day French, Spanish and Italian, Gil (1995) has shown that both linking and stance adverbials have a pivotal function in written text. Of a piece with such views is Nattinger and DeCarrico’s (1992) study of lexical phrases in contemporary English, which discusses both spoken and written uses of such items. Nattinger and DeCarrico (1992:90, 104) distinguish between micro- and macroorganizers, ‘organizer’ being synonymous with ‘discourse marker’ in their terminology. 2.1.2 Pragmatic υs. propositional meaning More broadly, any attempt at defining discourse markers must answer the question of whether particular discourse markers should be excluded from consideration on the ground that they carry no pragmatic meaning. Lenk (1998:39), for example, argues that ‘structural phrases’ such as on the one hand as well as ‘propositional uses’ of particles such as anyway do not fit the bill because they ‘have a structuring function…which corresponds to their lexical meaning, whereas the structuring functions of discourse markers…correspond…to a pragmatic meaning’ (her emphases). This argument, however, is never bolstered up by conclusive evidence. True, it is quite possible, as Lenk (1998:55ff., 216) suggests, to establish a workable distinction between (a) the propositional use of a particle like anyway to modify a preceding statement, and (b) its use as a discourse marker in returning to a previous topic after a digression; witness the following: (a) Then I shared a flat with her. Well, then, I was somewhere else, for the whole of nineteen-seventy, anyway. (b) And at the table there were two women sitting there. Well, they were attractive women, the one had on a real, real short skirt. Anyway, there was this guy in his fifties… (Lenk 1998:216)
< previous page
page_39
next page >
< previous page
page_40
next page >
Page 40 In (a) anyway, equivalent to French en tout cas and German jedenfalls, modifies the prepositional phrase ‘for the whole of nineteen-seventy’, restricting the generality of ‘I was somewhere else’. This might be said to be a propositional use of the word. In (b), it acts as a discourse marker rechannelling the conversation back into its earlier course. Very often, though, the distinction between lexical and pragmatic meaning becomes blurred. The German focusing adverb sogar is a case in point. As Courdier et al. (1994:19–20) note, an utterance like ‘sogar Peter hat die Wahrheit gesagt’ clearly allows truth-conditional treatment, asserting (a) that Peter has told the truth and (b) that at least one other person has told the truth. This is accomplished by what has just been referred to as the ‘lexical meaning’ of sogar . Yet it is evident that, over and above this denotative sense, use of sogar also conveys the speaker’s attitude towards the state of affairs under discussion. He or she must have thought it very unlikely that Peter would tell the truth and now finds it all the more remarkable that it turned out that way. Thus, sogar has both a pragmatic and a literal meaning, and the two shades of meaning usually occur in combination. Lenk’s own exemplification might in fact be queried, since the meaning of a lexical phrase such as on the other hand cannot be derived from its constituents. The phrase has acquired a figurative meaning similar to that of by contrast. Its literal meaning could be exemplified by a sentence such as on one hand he had paint, on the other hand he had blood. With discourse devices in academic language, the same thin line separates lexical from pragmatic meaning. For the sake of illustration, consider the French evaluator il y a plus. In its literal sense this phrase communicates little more than an addition or the announcement thereof, with possible renderings such as but this is not all or there is more in English and das ist noch nicht alles or dazu kommt, dass in German.2 But in argumentation the phrase can take on an additional sense, as evidenced in the following extract from Le Monde: L’intérêt fut de courte durée, du fait que la nature des postes proposés, mais aussi de la perte de rémunération que ce CES [contrat emploi-solidarité, D.S.] ne manqua pas d’occasionner à des adultes qui, pour la plupart, avaient connu des expériences de travail où, même si les salaires n’étaient pas énormes, ils étaient au moins égaux à un SMIC. Mais en 1991 et en 1992, on était prêt à prendre ce CES puisqu’il s’agissait d’une parenthèse dans la vie d’adulte en attendant la reprise. On sait ce qu’il advint de la reprise en 1993. Il y a plus. La boulimie du CES s’attaque désormais au secteur de l’insertion par l’économique jusqu’alors secteur autonome de l’insertion des publics en difficulté. Les entreprises d’insertion, les associations intermédiaires, les régies de quartiers représentent des figures diverses de l’insertion par l’économique et, de ce fait, ont toutes un rapport différent à la mesure CES. Si les entreprises d’insertion, qui
< previous page
page_40
next page >
< previous page
page_41
next page >
Page 41 demeurent des entreprises comme les autres et qui occupent des créneaux de l’économie marchande, ne doivent pas employer de salariés sous statut CES, les associations intermédiaires qui agissent davantage dans le secteur non marchand peuvent, lorsque l’initiative privée est absente, recourir à la mesure CES. Mais les représentants légitimes de ces initiatives de lutte contre l’exclusion ont toujours affirmé que la mesure CES était un des moments d’un parcours d’insertion et non un instrument en soi. En outre, particulièrement pour les entreprises d’insertion, ces CES devaient rester l’exception… ( Le Monde, 26.10.94:4; my emphasis) In the article in question Jacques Dughera submits to searching criticism the job creation scheme (‘contrat emploisolidarité’) introduced by the then French government led by Edouard Balladur. Here the pragmatic function of il y a plus is to signal a gradation in the speaker’s line of argument, the components of which are structured in ascending order of seriousness. The device provides an effective transition from Dughera’s consideration of the plight of individual participants in the scheme to his discussion of its overall impact on various economic agents, a theme which he clearly regards as more important. The kind of gradational semantic prosody (Sinclair 1991; Louw 1993; Stubbs 1995; see Chapter 1) here surrounding il y a plus seems to be a common feature of its use. This is especially true of its cooccurrences with mais. Of a further ten occurrences I looked at, six showed the same pattern. In the case under discussion, this clearly suggests partial synonymity with il y a plus graυe, leading to alternative renderings such as more seriously or schlimmer noch . Another point to remember is that the relative lack of propositional content found with many markers is due to diachronic change. It is the recurrence of a particular unit in a particular type of context that leads to its evolving into a discourse marker, a process which German linguists such as Burger (1998:15) have referred to as ‘Phraseologisierung’ (‘phraseologicization’). We must therefore conclude that Lenk’s (1998) arguments afford little reason, especially with respect to discourse marker use in written language, to draw strict lines between pragmatic meaning on the one hand and literal meaning on the other. Lenk is nevertheless making an important point, albeit unwittingly: what distinguishes discourse markers from collocations is precisely the fact that the former assume pragmatic functions in discourse which, as the example of il y a plus has shown, are often a matter of convention. 2.1.3 Extralinguistic υs. intralinguistic features If we accept that discourse markers mark relationships between text spans, then it seems reasonable to suggest that they may include extralinguistic
< previous page
page_41
next page >
< previous page
page_42
next page >
Page 42 text features such as headings or indentations. This insight has led some German LSP scholars to extend further the field of enquiry here discussed. In the German literature ‘Gliederungssignal’, or ‘signalling device’, is often used synonymously with the term ‘Diskursmarker’, whose definition tends towards all-inclusiveness: generic term for words or phrases used to structure discourse, such as nonsentences (e.g. interjections, signalling devices), syntactic constructions (e.g. left dislocation) or syntactically dependent elements (e.g. conjunctions, modal particles). They perform a variety of functions. (Bußmann 1990:190; my translation) Thus, Baumann (1987, 1992) regards as a signalling device any linguistic and extralinguistic marker contributing to textual progression and distinguishes between the social, functional-communicative, communicative-pragmatic and semantic dimensions of signalling devices (1987:9; 1992:86). He suggests that the kind of communicative strategy the author adopts determines linguistic choices, and that these in turn determine the use of particular communicative-pragmatic signalling devices. Visible at the text surface are at least eight types of signalling device: 1 metacommunicative text segments of some length (e.g. ‘For this purpose I shall look closely at…’) 2 rhetorical figures such as anaphora 3 sentence adverbs (e.g. similarly ) 4 sentence openers (e.g. to begin, note that ) 5 sequence signals (e.g. in the first place) 6 ‘signalling devices proper’ (e.g. either…or ) 7 sentence closers (e.g. finally, after all) 8 (sub)headings (Baumann 1992:93–95; my translation) Unfortunately, Baumann only provides two or three examples of each category, so that it is questionable whether his classification adequately captures the full range of signalling devices. For instance, only one kind of text/the other kind of text and either/or exemplify category 6 (‘signalling devices proper’), and Baumann’s definition is not much help in identifying other potential elements of the class: Signalling devices proper highlight the (alternative, adversative, additive, etc.) relations of interdependence between those aspects of the discourse topic which are germane to understanding its content and following its logic. (Baumann 1992:94; my translation)
< previous page
page_42
next page >
< previous page
page_43
next page >
Page 43 This begs a number of questions, including what is meant by the term aspect (Aspekt) here, and why sentence adverbs such as similarly are seen as forming a group of their own rather than belonging to this one. It is also extremely doubtful whether rhetorical figures can be counted among discourse markers. The kind of syntactic parallelism involved in anaphora, for instance, may well lend emphasis to the current discourse, but, being a syntactic figure, it does not cue any specific conjunctive relation. The most serious flaw in Baumann’s work, however, is that he fails to provide sample analyses that would demonstrate the viability of his approach. In particular, there is no demonstration of how to classify the discoursal functions of extralinguistic markers. It is contended here that such classification is both impossible and undesirable. Impossible because such extralinguistic features as headings, while exhibiting a limited number of syntactic realizations, are semantically extremely variable. Undesirable because, even if a classification were possible, this would be so large as to be unmanageable. In other words, Baumann’s classification has the clear disadvantage of transcending the boundaries of what is measurable in linguistic research and applicable in pedagogic practice. 2.1.4 Towards a consensual definition So far we have put forward a variety of arguments in support of claiming that discourse markers can be defined as linguistic expressions of varying length which carry pragmatic and/or propositional meaning, occur in both speech and writing, and facilitate rather than disrupt discourse. We shall now consider some additional criteria, borrowed from the literature on oral discourse markers, which may contribute to a consensual definition. The lowest common denominator of a wide variety of definitions lies in the recognition that discourse markers serve to indicate how one unit of discourse is to be construed in the light of another (see Oates 1999; Risselada and Spooren 1998; Millis et al. 1995). The key role thus attributed to coherence relations is reflected in Risselada and Spooren’s definition: Discourse markers can be defined as those natural language expressions whose primary function is to facilitate the process of interpreting the coherence relation(s) between a particular unit of discourse and other, surrounding units and/or aspects of the communicative situation. (Risselada and Spooren 1998:132) Risselada and Spooren observe that this definition would ideally require a highly evolved theory of coherence, but that in practice research into discourse devices and into models of discourse coherence is complementary. Notice that the definition is sufficiently broad to be in conformity with our
< previous page
page_43
next page >
< previous page
page_44
next page >
Page 44 list of criterial features (see pp. 37–43). In particular, it may be taken to refer to both speech and writing, leaving room for items of varying length and functionality and enabling us to regard multi-word discourse markers as a subclass of the general class of discourse markers. Many of the more consensual features that emerge from the literature are reflected in this definition. Of crucial import are Risselada and Spooren’s references to ‘a particular unit of discourse and other surrounding units’ as well as to ‘aspects of the communicative situation’. They allow them to take account of the two fundamental functions of discourse markers, which are usually simultaneously present: the discoursal/textual function on the one hand and the interpersonal function on the other. Again, these functions are given different names by different authors: Östman (1982), for example, speaks of the ‘textual’ and ‘pragmatic’ functions, whereas Schiffrin (1987) recognizes a ‘textindexing’ and a ‘participant-indexing’ function. Simply stated, the textual function of discourse markers is to signal relations between prior, present and subsequent discourse, marking off one discourse unit (i.e. in the terminology here used: elements, sequences and text segments) from another or linking discourse units further apart (see the introduction to this chapter). It is this textual function of discourse markers that was captured by early discourse analysts in terms such as ‘Eröffnungssignal’, ‘Unterbrechungssignal’ and ‘Schlußsignal’ (Gülich 1970). Later authors such as Schiffrin (1987) prefer terms that take speaker/ hearer and writer/reader interaction into account, thus emphasizing the interpersonal function of discourse markers. As the term suggests, the interpersonal function consists in expressing speaker or writer stance or in securing cooperation and understanding. In speech, for example, discourse markers assist in turn-taking; in writing they help to create a seemingly dialogic interaction between reader and writer. Another generally accepted feature of discourse markers is the heterogeneity of their morphosyntactic realizations. The set of discourse markers as a whole does not constitute a word class in the traditional sense of the term because there are no morphosyntactic or semantic criteria allowing us to delimit it, any more than there are criteria for unambiguously attributing all individual members of the set to specific word classes. Since our concern is with markers in written text, we here refrain from further discussion of the morphosyntactic and prosodic features of oral discourse markers (see Quirk et al. 1985:1112; Crystal and Davy 1975:90; Helbig 1988:32–34; Courdier et al. 1994:26–31). A final feature of discourse markers that most of the relevant studies draw attention to is their multifunctionality. Oral discourse markers have been shown to operate on the syntactico-semantic and pragmatic levels simultaneously (Schiffrin 1987), and individual markers such as actually and ja have been suggested to cover a range of distinct functions (Lenk
< previous page
page_44
next page >
< previous page
page_45
next page >
Page 45 1998; Courdier et al. 1998). One might be tempted to think that such plurality of functions gives rise to misunderstandings, but disambiguation is usually achieved through the contextual embedding of the marker. To summarize: the term ‘discourse marker’ can be applied to natural-language strings of varying length and morphosyntactic structure whose primary function is to signal the coherence relations obtaining between a particular unit of discourse and other, surrounding units and/or aspects of the communicative situation and thereby to facilitate the listener’s or reader’s processing task. While we have now arrived at a fairly comprehensive definition of discoursal and pragmatic features of discourse markers, we still need some way of marking the cut-off point between what we have intuitively termed ‘multi-word discourse markers’, on the one hand, and roughly synonymous word combinations of a less restricted nature on the other. This lexicological issue is the subject of the next section. 2.2 Lexicological perspectives on multi-word discourse markers Our discussion so far has focused on pragmatic and discoursal criteria for defining the general class of discourse markers. Henceforth our task will be to determine the lexicological features of multi-word discourse markers. To do so, it will be necessary first to review some of the major approaches to classifying word groupings. 2.2.1 The phraseological cline Traditional approaches to the classification of multi-word units assume that there is a fairly sharp cut-off point between non-compositional, or idiomatic, and compositional, or non-idiomatic, word sequences. Thus, for example, Dobrovol’skij (1995) distinguishes between free word associations and phraseology, subdividing the latter class into idiomatic and non-idiomatic phraseology. Along the same lines, Hausmann (e.g. 1984, 1989, 1999) differentiates between fixed and non-fixed word sequences, dividing non-fixed word sequences into three groups: 1 ‘Ko-kreationen’ (co-creations) arise through the application of general syntactic and semantic rules (prächtig+Baum). 2 ‘affine Kombinationen’, or collocations, are defined by the tendency of two words, called the ‘base’ (or ‘node’) and the ‘collocate’, to co-occur; Hausmann views them as semi-prepackaged phrases that speakers do not put together creatively. The base is semantically autonomous (ascenseur), while the meaning conveyed by the collocate is dependent on its co-occurrence with the base (appeler [+ascenseur]) . 3 ‘Konter-kreationen’ (counter-creations) are word sequences serving as
< previous page
page_45
next page >
< previous page
page_46
next page >
Page 46 stylistic devices which arise from the violation of syntactic or semantic rules (les fleurs du mal). While Hausmann’s classification has the merit of accounting for unusual word combinations as ‘Konter-kreationen’, his view of collocation as a node/collocate combination (Hausmann 1985) may be too restricted.3 As a cursory inspection of any sizeable corpus will reveal, there are also a large number of multi-word collocations. Some of these, such as Aisenstadt’s (1979) verb+preposition+noun phrase groupings (leap+to+conclusion), can be viewed as two-word collocations in which the use of the preposition may be determined by either element. Others may be regarded as a combination of two or more node/collocate combinations (withdraw+money, substantial+quantities →to withdraw substantial quantities of money). Yet others, however, are so fixed that they will usually be perceived and stored as one unit, as shown in Table 2.2. It is wiser, therefore, to have recourse to the Firthian view of collocation (Firth 1957), which does not limit collocation to the co-occurrence of two words.4 This has recently found its fittest expression in Sinclair’s (1991:173) idiom principle, whereby ‘the choice of one word affects the choice of others in its vicinity’. While this feature of natural language has been remarked upon by many writers, of whom Bally (1909) may have been the first, Sinclair was probably the first to recognize its pervasiveness. He illustrates it with examples such as the following: a. Many phrases have an indeterminate extent. As an example, consider set eyes on. This seems to attract a pronoun subject, and either neυer or a temporal conjunction like the moment, the first time, and the word has as an auxiliary to set. […] e. Many uses of words and phrases attract other words in strong collocation; for example, hard work, hard luck, hard facts, hard evidence. […] g. Many uses of words and phrases show a tendency to occur in a certain semantic environment. For example, the verb happen is associated with unpleasant things—accidents and the like. (Sinclair 1991:111–112) Table 2.2 Multi-word collocations (for further examples, see Siepmann 2002b) English French German not+forget+in a hurry ne pas+oublier+de sitôt nicht+so schnell+vergessen hold+road+well tenir+route+bien gut+Straßenlage+haben (cf. *eine Straßenlage haben) not wildly (startlingly) original pas follement original nicht wahnsinnig originell You can’t be too careful. On n’est jamais assez prudent. Man kann nie vorsichtig genug sein.
< previous page
page_46
next page >
< previous page
page_47
next page >
Page 47 There are clear echoes here of Hausmann’s ‘Affinität’, but with the difference that Hausmann’s notion is grounded in semantics rather than statistical significance and applies only to two-word combinations. Most importantly, Sinclair reminds us that collocations carry a particular semantic-pragmatic prosody (Sinclair 1996), a perception which he shares with Feilke, who views phraseology as conveying a specific type of figure-ground relation (Feilke 1996:261). That is, speakers of a language do not acquire collocations as quasi-mathematical figures (a+b), but rather as figures set against a conventional situational background (cf. j’appelle l’ascenseur, the landscape rushes by, ich erhebe das Glas). On closer examination, then, statistical probability of co-occurrence in a very large representative corpus and a redefined contextual ‘Affinität’ may well turn out to be two sides of the same coin. A more serious problem associated with traditional approaches to collocation such as Hausmann’s and Dobrovol’skij’s is that the boundary between non-compositional and compositional units has proved to be more fluid than previously assumed. There is now overwhelming evidence on the frequency of word sequences (Hunston and Francis 2000:230–235) showing that the primary division between collocations and non-collocations is a matter of more or less rather than yes or no. For example, depending on the size and content of the corpus, a word sequence such as book+proclaim may be viewed either as a free combination or a collocation. According to Hunston and Francis (2000:132) the Bank of English has 15 instances of the noun book or its plural books occurring within about seven words preceding a form of proclaim . She somewhat hesitantly concludes that it ‘is not frequent enough to be a strong collocation’. However, if we consulted a large corpus comprising literary magazines we would probably find a much higher proportion of co-occurrences of book/books and proclaim, and would then be justified in calling these (subject-specific) collocations. It seems promising, then, to posit the existence of a phraseological cline (Francis 1993 for English; Siepmann 1999 and 2002b for French) running from totally fixed expressions at one end to freely generated groups of words at the other, with collocations occupying an intermediate position. Borrowing from Howarth (1996:43; 1998:169), Hausmann (1984) and classical Russian theory on degrees of idiomaticity, we may assume five ‘levels’ of fixedness, starting with the fixed end of the cline: 1 Complete restriction on the choice of any element: fixed expressions, which can be further subdivided into (a) pure (opaque) idioms (spill the beans, a dead duck) (b) figurative idioms (call the shots, a sacred cow, curry faυour). 2 Complete restriction on the choice of one element; some substitution of other elements: idiom (e.g. in fine/good fettle ) or strong collocation (pay/take heed, giυe the appearance/impression).
< previous page
page_47
next page >
< previous page
page_48
next page >
Page 48 3 Some substitution at several structural places: central restricted collocation (make/giυe a speech/presentation) . 4 Freedom of substitution of one element; some restriction on the choice of other elements: weak collocation ( accept/agree to/adopt a plan/proposal/suggestion/recommendation/conυention, etc.). 5 Freedom of substitution of any element: free combination (also called ‘non-restricted compositional sequence’) (a green wall, suggest synonymity) . 2.2.2 Pragmatic phrases and phraseological fixity Phrases assuming pragmatic functions are distributed across the entire phraseological cline. At one end are totally fixed opaque idioms such as be that as it may or es liegt auf der Hand, dass, at the other extreme we find unconventionalized clause-integrated links such as the following: Dans ce type de phrase, on fait intervenir ce que pour éviter le tour savant de l’inversion. On le retrouve d’ailleurs, non moins incorrect, dans la subordonnée interrogative. (Georgin 1961:44; my emphasis) In the present case the ready-made discourse devices il en υa de même pour or même constat pour, to name but two, may be substituted for the free syntactic string on retrouυe+direct object+preposition. This strongly suggests that we may also assign a pragmatic function to non-recurrent sequences put together by application of generative rules. Clearly, though, such non-recurrent sequences, which would come under level 5 in the above classification, do not qualify as what we have intuitively termed ‘multi-word markers’. The cut-off point between multi-word markers and roughly synonymous word combinations of a less restricted nature thus seems to be situated at level 4. Here are a few typical examples of each level: 1 be that as it may, in retrospect, with hindsight 2 ähnliches/gleiches/entsprechendes gilt für; an example is proυided/afforded by 3 to take/cite a+ADJ+case/example 4 Ähnliche Erwägungen/Überlegungen/Einschränkungen/…gelten für/in/bei The link demonstrated here between level 2 and level 4 suggests that many relatively fixed multi-word markers can be transposed to a sometimes expanded, sometimes reduced structure with a similar pragmatic function but a more precise meaning (cf. ähnliches gilt für→ähnliche Einschränkungen gelten für). These expanded or reduced structures are normally less fixed than the markers they are based on; they can best be described in terms of Altenberg’s (1984) ‘clause-integrated linkage’ or
< previous page
page_48
next page >
< previous page
page_49
next page >
Page 49 Francis’s (1994) ‘labelling discourse’. In the example just given, ähnliche Einschränkungen functions as a thematic link which retrospectively labels the preceding discourse as being of the order of restriction. Note that such labelling discourse is not normally a mere repetition or a ‘synonym’ of any preceding text element; rather it ‘is presented as equiυalent to the clause or clauses it replaces, while naming them for the first time’ (Francis 1994:85). Such attribution of equivalence is achieved by using a summative noun whose meaning signals to the reader how the preceding or subsequent discourse is to be interpreted. It would appear, then, that a relatively sharp line can be drawn between non-restricted compositional sequences, or free combinations, and multi-word discourse markers, with the interesting result that both interlingual and intralingual correspondences can be accounted for. A clear demonstration of this is in Gallagher’s (1992) study of the multi-word marker erschwerend kommt hinzu, dass (level 2) which can be intralingually expanded to sentence length to give eine weitere Schwierigkeit/ein weiteres Problem/eine weitere Komplikation/…kommt/tritt hinzu (level 4). Significantly, typical English renderings parallel this kind of expansion. Gallagher cites a further complication is that…, clearly a central restricted collocation with generative potential: another/a second/a further complication/difficulty/ problem/…is that (for full discussion, see Siepmann 2001a). A similar kind of transposition can be seen in operation with the German enumerative phrase hinzu kommt, dass and its variant dazu kommt, dass . These may be seen as fixed expressions or as strong collocations of level 1 or 2; they can be equated with the French collocation autre+noun ( autre remarque/autre illustration/autre obserυation/etc.), which is a restricted collocation of level 4. It should be mentioned in passing that a more literal rendering such as à cela s’ajoute que is also possible, but has a different stylistic value. So where one language uses a fixed expression, another may use a collocation, and vice versa. To sum up, in lexicographic terms, multi-word discourse markers can be described as collocations or fixed expressions. One final point must be made about the variability of the items under discussion; namely, that their transformation potential, though limited, appears to be a fairly good guide to distinguishing them from more clearly lexicalized markers such as on the one hand. While items such as note that are often intuited to be invariable (e.g. Swales et al. 1998), corpus searches provide evidence to the contrary; a trawl through CAE yielded the following variants of note that: Note (also/carefully/for example/further/here/too) that/note+NP Even seemingly ‘one-word’ items such as mieux and pire may lend themselves to a number of variations: mieux encore, encore mieux and pire encore, all of which contain at least two words. Conversely, items such as on the
< previous page
page_49
next page >
< previous page
page_50
next page >
Page 50 other hand, all the same and par conséquent are totally fixed. Unfortunately, though, the criterion of variability is not valid for all multi-word markers: quoi qu’il en soit and d’autre part, for example, are both invariable. This means that if we wish to include them in the category of multi-word markers we will have to invoke other criteria as well. These are the subject of the next section. 2.2.3 Variability and probability of occurrence Hitherto we have established two criterial features of what we have intuitively termed multi-word discourse markers: one discoursal (the pragmatic function of discourse markers), the other lexicological (their restricted commutability). But these two criteria alone are not sufficient to account for our intuitive grouping. For an item to qualify as a multiword discourse marker, we may surmise, also requires a specific probability of occurrence. This last step in our argument deserves more elaborate explanation. If we take the prefix ‘multi-’ to mean ‘more than one’, as do most linguists, then the welcome result is that the large group of common one-word discourse markers will remain outside the scope of our definition, But what about items like on the other hand, all the same, par conséquent, au contraire and darüber hinaus? Intuition tells us that these items, although consisting of more than one element, should really be grouped with one-word discourse markers such as but, hence, therefore, also and weiterhin . Likewise it would seem counter-intuitive to exclude the one-word items mieux or pire from the group of multi-word markers, as they belong in one semantic-pragmatic category with mieux encore, il y a plus graυe, etc. (Note that, as shown in the preceding section, the criterion of variability alone cannot account for the difference: quoi qu’il en soit and d’autre part, for example, are both invariable.) This is where probability of occurrence may be invoked as a defining criterion. Comparison of the two groups of markers by this criterion in two corpora produced the results shown in Tables 2.3, 2.4, 2.5 and 2.6. It appears that the distinction we have drawn is reasonably consistent with the evidence. In the French newspaper corpus, for instance, items such as au contraire and par conséquent are found to be at least twice as frequent as multi-word discourse markers such as plus grave or idem pour . The latter thus typically occur with frequencies of 3– 50 occurrences in 10 million words, i.e. in what one might call a medium-frequency range. Some exceptions prove the rule: note that occurs with unusual (but predictable) frequency in academic discourse. This also makes it possible to substitute a less ambiguous designation for the intuitive ‘multi-word discourse marker’, which, as we have seen, may give rise to confusion between high-frequency fixed expressions such as on the other hand and lower-frequency markers such as the fact remains
< previous page
page_50
next page >
< previous page
page_51
next page >
Page 51 Table 2.3 Frequency of ‘one-word markers’ in Le Monde (1995) Discourse marker token Frequency pourtant 7490 néanmoins 1354 au contraire 1601 par conséquent 194 Table 2.4 Frequency of ‘multi-word markers’ in Le Monde (1995) Discourse marker token Frequency mieux 88 il en υa de même (pour/de) 76 plus graυe 60 idem pour (rarely: idem en/à [followed by a place name], idem de) 38 Table 2.5 Frequency of ‘one-word markers’ in a 10-million-word section of CAE Discourse marker token Frequency howeυer 8897 neυertheless 805 on the other hand 751 in contrast/by contrast 902 Table 2.6 Frequency of ‘multi-word markers’ in a 10-million-word section of CAE Discourse marker token Frequency the fact remains that 13 note that 172 worse 43 the same goes for 5 that . Henceforth we shall use the term ‘second-level marker’, where ‘level’ is meant to refer to the level of frequency of occurrence (and not, as might be assumed, to a secondary function in structuring text). Further support for the distinction we have just established comes from translation. The French single-word item mieux, for example, translates as a multi-word item into both German (besser noch) and English (better still); darüber hinaus, a notional two-word item, may be rendered by moreoυer, further or furthermore although admittedly also by beyond this/that and in addition; English worse, when used as a marker introducing an additional
< previous page
page_51
next page >
< previous page
page_52
next page >
Page 52 adverse point, has an occasional equivalent in erschwerend kommt hinzu, dass . Given a certain number of counterexamples, it is clear that the distinction is not written in stone; rather, it is a methodological convenience. The explanation for this lies in the shared pragmatic roles of the two groups of discourse markers—something which we will enlarge on in Chapter 3. Interestingly, the above results are in keeping with the correlation between length and frequency found with fixed expressions and idioms, an area in which Moon (1998:78) makes the generalization that ‘commoner FEIs are shorter than infrequent ones’. The reasons for this must be sought in the frequency with which we need to express certain language functions. With a view to economy of effort, modern languages have evolved succinct terms for common functions. Thus, for example, we use au contraire more often than the roughly synonymous tant s’en faut or loin de là . 2.2.4 Operational definition of second-leυel discourse markers With the foregoing in mind, we can now define the term ‘second-level discourse marker’ as follows: Second-leυel discourse markers, hereafter SLDMs, are medium-frequency fixed expressions or collocations composed of two or more printed words acting as a single unit. Their function is to facilitate the process of interpreting coherence relation(s) between elements, sequences or text segments and/or aspects of the communicative situation. Succinctly put, second-level markers are recurrent multi-word combinations performing common language functions. It will be remembered that this definition is a means to an end: a methodological convenience allowing generalizations to be made about particular multi-word lexical items. As the use of the word ‘printed’ and the reference to ‘elements, sequences or text segments’ indicates, the present work confines itself to a discussion of second-level markers in written text, although second-level markers may also occur in speech. 2.3 Syntactic realizations of SLDMs Having defined the notion of SLDM, we are now ready to consider what structural types of SLDM can be made out. SLDMs are in a class of their own, somewhere between the single word and the sentence; so far there have been few attempts at categorizing such items. Since discourse markers are a subgroup of Nattinger and DeCarrico’s ‘lexical phrases’, it may be well worth looking at their classification (see Table 2.7; the examples are theirs).
< previous page
page_52
next page >
< previous page
page_53
next page >
Page 53 Table 2.7 Nattinger and DeCarrico’s classification of ‘lexical phrases’ Category Examples Polyword (invariable phrases which function like individual strictly speaking in other words at any rate what on lexical items) earth? Institutionalized Expression (invariable proverbs, aphorisms, get a life formulaics) be that as it may nice meeting you Phrasal Constraint (variable short-to-medium-length phrases) as far as I (know/can tell) as a result of… Sentence Builders (items which ‘provide a framework for it seems to me that my point here is… there’s no doubt whole sentences’) that I think Nattinger and DeCarrico (1992:46) themselves draw attention to the limitations of this taxonomy, recognizing that their categories have fuzzy edges. For example, prototypical polywords (e.g. at any rate ) will be completely invariable, whereas phrasal constraints will usually allow some variation. Between these poles, though, lies a fluid borderline, as evidenced by such polywords as for better or worse, which allows syntagmatic variation (for better or for worse) . More seriously, though, their taxonomy is based on limited linguistic data, thus providing an unrepresentative and unreliable picture of SLDMs. It therefore needs to be reconsidered in the light of a detailed corpus investigation. A particular point of contention is Nattinger and DeCarrico’s (1992:45) claim that variability of items increases as one moves along the continuum from polywords to sentence builders. While there may be a greater range of expressions to be found at the sentence builder end of the cline, some of these, like I think that or there’s no/little doubt that, admit of very little or no modification at all. Conversely, the viewpoint adjunct strictly speaking, grouped among invariable polywords by Nattinger and DeCarrico (1992:39), is a clear example of a variable productive phrase. A rapid trawl through CAE uncovers, among other things, literally speaking, musically speaking, psychologically speaking, properly speaking, relatively speaking, relatiυistically speaking, religiously speaking, roughly speaking, semantically speaking, technically speaking, textually speaking. Lastly, Nattinger and De Carrico seem to base their categorization of lexical phrases on a mixture of pragmatic and lexico-syntactic criteria. Thus, phrasal constraints are defined in terms of their length (‘variable short-to-mediumlength phrases’, with no indication given of what ‘short’ or ‘medium’ denote in this context), whereas sentencebuilders are given a rather vague pragmatic definition (‘items which provide a framework for whole sentences’).
< previous page
page_53
next page >
< previous page
page_54
next page >
Page 54 This leads us to a revision and expansion of Nattinger and DeCarrico’s classification, which, sooner than mix pragmatic and syntactic criteria, takes account of the latter only. Each category is illustrated by a few examples and commented on below. Note that, as I have argued above, there will always be a residue of cases that are not amenable to hard-and-fast categorization. In all three languages under consideration, three major categories of SLDMs can be distinguished: set expressions, sentence fragments and sentence-integrated markers. These in turn comprise a number of subcategories which are somewhat different for each of the languages involved. We shall therefore look at each separately in the remainder of this section. 2.3.1 Syntactic realizations of English SLDMs Let us start with English, where three major categories comprising a number of subcategories can be distinguished: set expressions, sentence fragments and sentence-integrated markers. Table 2.8 provides a broad overview of SLDM types in English. In what follows, some more detailed information will be given on each broad lexico-grammatical category. Let us first take a closer look at set expressions. 2.3.1.1 Set expressions The SLDMs in this category (see Table 2.9) form a fairly small set, most of whose members have been recorded in one or other of the major dictionaries. What is most striking here is the great syntactic diversity: we find prepositional phrases such as in the process or to this end, infinitive phrases such as needless to say or not to mention as well as extragrammatical idioms such as so far so good or be that as it may . As many such expressions are syntactically ill-formed by today’s norms, we may suppose them to be remnants from an earlier period in the history of English. The ill-formedness of such unique items often goes hand in hand with their unanalysability, something that is particularly evident with expressions such as be that as it may . In other cases, such as to this we now turn, we are dealing with frozen syntactic variants of other discourse devices (we now turn to). A wide range of meanings and functions is in evidence, which cannot be discussed in detail here. Perhaps the primary function of these devices is that of establishing anaphoric or cataphoric reference. Many prepositional phrases, for example, contain summative nouns helping to encapsulate a previous or subsequent piece of text, as witness the following: I therefore built the database around those items which CCELD included and identified as ‘phrases’ in the grammatical coding. In the
< previous page
page_54
next page >
< previous page
page_55
next page >
Page 55 Table 2.8 An overview of lexico-grammatical realizations of SLDMs in English Category Examples A Set expressions 1.1Structurally incomplete set expressions so far so good be that as it may with hindsight/with the benefit of hindsight 1.2Structurally complete set expressions to this we now turn this is not the whole story B Sentence fragments 1 anticipatory it+verb/adjective phrase (+complement it will be seen that clause fragment) it seems arguable that it is worth noting that 2 existential clause (+complement clause fragment) there is no denying the fact that there are good reasons for believing that 3 personal pronoun (I/we/one)+ (auxiliary) verb phrase one must acknowledge that (+complement clause fragment) I must point out that we find that 4 noun phrase+[+ (…)]+copular be+that-clause a first point is that a further difficulty (for such an approach) is that my guess is that 5 adverbial clause fragments as has been noted (earlier) 6 participial clauses turning to (…, we find that) 7 with +verbless clause with this in mind 8 infinitive clauses or infinitive clause fragments to return to (NP) to sum up 9 sentence adverbs interestingly (enough) 10 imperatives (and hortatives)+ noun/prepositional phrase let us first look at (fragment) see further in 11 verbless clause fragments One final point on (NP) An example: 12 noun/pronoun+verb phrase+ clause fragment the same goes for mention should be made of (NP) 13 variable prepositional phrases (phrasal constraints) in this case/in the present case in this connection/in that connection 14 phrasal constraints far be it from me to suggest far be it from me to claim 15 here is/are+complement here are a few examples C Sentence-integrated markers 1 noun phrase+V (+…) (active and passive) we have (here) a good example is provided by (NP)↔ (NP) provides a good example 2 sentence-like units such instances could be multiplied
< previous page
page_55
next page >
< previous page
page_56
next page >
Page 56 Table 2.9 Set expressions in English Category 1.1 Structurally incomplete set expressions
Examples so far so good be that as it may with hindsight with the benefit of hindsight in retrospect in the process in the event to this end let alone needless to say not to mention all things considered 1.2 Structurally complete set expressions this is not all this is not the whole story to this we now turn the identity stops there event about 10% of the phrases in CCELD were rejected as not conforming to the types of FEI under consideration… (CAE) This is an instance of conventionalized ‘labelling discourse’ (Francis 1994), one which has not yet found its way into the dictionaries. The content of the first sentence is, as it were, ‘packaged’ into the summative noun eυent, which thus serves as background to the next sentence. 2.3.1.2 Sentence fragments Sentence-fragment SLDM have been grouped into 15 major categories (see Table 2.10), many of which are based on common clause patterns; further subdivisions, as between adjectival and nominal complements for type 1.2, are possible. It is significant that only a limited number of clause patterns seem to lend themselves readily to the formation of SLDMs. Thus, of the SLDMs beginning with anticipatory it and initiating extraposed structures, the pattern it+V+complement+ to-INF is found to occur with high frequency and in varying forms, whereas it is worth +ing and it is worthwhile+ing are the only instances I have noted of the pattern it+V+complement+ing. Let us now look at the various categories one by one. Category 1.1 exemplifies a pattern which is very common in the grammars of academic English and German, but less so in French. In Collins Cobuild Grammar Patterns 1: Verbs (Francis et al. 1996:526ff.), it is described as a productive pattern typically used to express the actions of reporting as well as of thinking and discovering. With regard to SLDMs, this descrip-
< previous page
page_56
next page >
< previous page
Page 57 Table 2.10 English sentence fragments Category 1anticipatory it+υerb/adjective phrase (+complement clause fragment) 1.1 it+be +V-ed+that-clause 1.2
it+V+complement+that-clause/to-inf
1.3
it+V+(to/from n) that
1.4
it+V+complement+ -ing
2existential clause (+ complement clause fragment) 3personal pronoun (I/we/one)+(auxiliary) υerb phrase (+complement clause fragment) 4noun phrase+[+(…)]+copular be+ that-clause
5adυerbial clause fragments 5.1 as+V/ed 5.2
as+participle
5.3
as+subject (we/I/name of author) +V
participial clause 2
7with+υerbless clause 8to-infinitiυe clauses or to-infinitiυe clause fragments
9sentence adυerbs
< previous page
Examples it will be seen that it is conceded that it seems arguable that it is my contention that it is easy to see how it appears that it follows (from this) that it seems (to me) that it is worth noting that it is worthwhile looking at ( also: to look at) there is growing recognition that there is no denying the fact that there are good reasons for believing that one must acknowledge that I must point out that we find that a first point is that a further difficulty (for such an approach) is that my guess is that as has been noted (earlier) as has often been argued as discussed (in section II) as noted (above) as we mentioned earlier as Sinclair notes if I am not mistaken
5.4 simple subordinate clauses 6participial clauses 6.1 participial clause 1 6.2
next page >
page_57
page_57
turning to (…, we find that) summing up (, we can say that) other things (factors) being equal that said simply put narrowly defined with this in mind with this qualification in mind to return to… to illustrate to exemplify… to take a typical case to give just a few examples interestingly (enough) notably strictly (speaking) technically (speaking)
next page >
< previous page
page_58
next page >
Page 58 Category 10imperatives (and hortatiυes)+noun/ prepositional phrase (fragment)
Examples let us first look at see further in compare witness the following 11υerbless clauses and υerbless clause One final point on… so much for fragments A few implications for… An example, therefore—a point discussed separately below 12noun/pronoun+υerb phrase+clause the same goes for similar considerations hold for the same can be said fragment of mention should be made of this brings us to 13υariable prepositional phrases in this case/in the present case in this connection/in that connection 14set expressions+clause fragments of far be it from me to suggest limited υariability far be it from me to claim 15Here is/are+complement here are a few examples tion may be enhanced by two additional observations. First, and most importantly, the verb group often contains a modal auxiliary such as will, must, can or could—an important factor in establishing idiomaticity in academic writing and, more specifically, in marking author stance. Second, many of these constructions have syntactic correlates in parenthetical clauses such as: Thus, it is often belieυed/as has been seen, (S-V-O) (cf. category 5.1 for adverbial clauses beginning with as). The close links between sentence fragments of subcategories 1.1 and 1.2 are obvious and can be accounted for by word formation rules (e.g. it is arguable↔it can be argued ). Equally clear is the kinship with the impersonal ‘one’ constructions of category 3: one might say that ↔it might be said that . Less evident parallels may be detected between verbal sentence fragments such as it is generally accepted and nominal ones like it is a wellknown fact . There are also points of contact between sub-categories 1.1 and 1.2 on the one hand, and category 2 on the other; the connection is via intralingual class shifts: it is increasingly recognized that →there is increasing recognition that . Category 4 comprises nominal constructions built around general abstract nouns such as point, difficulty, complication, criticism or argument and a copular verb.5 A great deal of variation exists among the adverbial clause fragments of
< previous page
page_58
next page >
< previous page
page_59
next page >
Page 59 categories 5.1 to 5.3. These sometimes serve as parenthetical clauses that are neither semantically nor syntactically connected with the relative clause in which they are embedded (see Gallagher 1982:71). By contrast, pushdown clauses without as, as illustrated by which must, I think, be correct, are semantically integrated in the relative clause. It should be noted that the lexicon of these types of clause is quite restricted. The first type occurs mainly with the vocabulary of cross-reference (see Chapter 4); the second is primarily found with υerba dicendi and υerba sentiendi . The participial clauses in category 6.1 illustrate the relative frequency of unattached participles in modern academic prose. Although the usage is still castigated as being unclear in prescriptive grammars, it has been generally acknowledged to be an institutionalized feature of ‘formal scientific writing’, at least since Quirk et al. (1985:1122– 1123). Quirk et al. provide the following example: When treating patients with language retardation and deυiation of language deυelopment, the therapy consists, in part, of discussions of the patient’s problems with parents and teachers, with subsequent language teaching carried out by them. (Quirk et al. 1985:1123) The attachment rule is also relaxed in the case of some participial clauses in category 6.2. Examples are adverbial clauses such as simply put or put another way. Other items in this category constitute grammatically independent clauses (that said). Participial SLDMs are notable as spanning a broad range of syntactic flexibility. There is a gradual shading-off from relatively free expressions such as supposing or disregarding, which retain many of the characteristics of verbs, through less flexible items such as considering or ( weather/resources etc.) permitting down to the conjunctional proυided or the prepositional regarding . Since the two latter groups regularly occur as unattached participles even outside academic writing, it is reasonable to argue that they cannot be regarded as verbs in participle clauses (see Quirk et al. 1985:1003). Category 7 comprises verbless clauses introduced by the preposition with. Because it introduces a subclause with should here be interpreted as a conjunction or subordinator rather than as a preposition (see Quirk et al. 1985:705). Oddly enough, the clauses in this category appear to be unrelated to participial clauses introduced by with, as the insertion of the participle being into examples such as with this in mind does not yield acceptable wordings. One of the peculiarities of this construction is the semantic versatility of the subordinator with . It can have causal, conditional, temporal, concessive and modal meaning (see Königs 1998). Category 8 groups together infinitive clauses and infinitive clause fragments. These tend to occur as free adjuncts attached to a complex
< previous page
page_59
next page >
< previous page
page_60
next page >
Page 60 sentence, but can also stand on their own (To turn now to the history of the institution.). In comparison to participle clauses, infinitive clauses are syntactically less fixed, although clauses such as to illustrate or to continue may be left unexpanded by an object and in this form may be considered to constitute non-compositional units: One reason that harvests were large despite the droughts is people’s increased capacity to overcome adverse natural conditions. To illustrate, one of the most publicized droughts was in southern California. (CAE) As a result, the notion that it is somehow ‘wrong’ to end a sentence with a preposition is nowadays widely held. In addition, Lowth insisted on the pronoun I in phrases such as wiser than I, condemning lines of Swift such as ‘she suffers hourly more than me’, quite oblivious of the fact that many languages, English included, prefer a different form of the pronoun when it is detached from its verb: compare the French plus sage que moi ‘wiser than me’, not *plus sage que je . In consequence, many people nowadays believe that a phrase such as wiser than I is ‘better’ than wiser than me. To continue, Lowth may have been the first to argue that a double negative is wrong, on the grounds that one cancels the other out. (CAE) There are some correspondences between participial and infinitive clauses, as in the following example, where an infinitive may be substituted for the participle continuing: Continuing this theme, let us now consider each of the patterns that occur with the verb take to indicate duration. (CAE) The sentence adverbs in category 9 are a productive pattern, with a large range of adjectives capable of becoming a member of this category: obυious →obυiously, clear→clearly, plain→plainly, manifest→manifestly, eυident →eυidently, presumable →presumably, superficial →superficially, nominal →nominally, hypothetical→hypothetically, interesting →interestingly, odd →oddly, and so on. Many of these occur with the adverb enough: oddly enough, interestingly enough. Also of interest is the way in which sentence adverbs cluster at the beginning of sentences. Most commonly this happens with combinations of the type first(ly)+most/less/(just) as/equally important(ly), but there are also other cases: Firstly, and perhaps most contentiously, we might sometimes consider brevity at the expense of attempting to cover all necessary conditions. (CAE)
< previous page
page_60
next page >
< previous page
page_61
next page >
Page 61 There is also a ‘trade-off’ between category 1.2 and a subcategory of sentence adverbs, as exemplified by the following transformation: it is significant that ↔significantly . Other adjectives conforming to this pattern include clear, plain, manifest, interesting and odd . It is worth noting that all the adjectives capable of being used in this way accept modification by enough when transformed into sentence adverbs. Category 10 comprises imperatives and hortatives. The number of verbs entering this pattern is comparatively limited; among the most frequent we find see, look (at), consider and note . The illocutionary force of such imperatives in academic writing is, of course, that of an invitation rather than an injunction or command. Categories 11 and 12 are very similar. The former contains verbless clauses and verbless clause fragments, while the latter consists of a simple S-V-clause plus a clause fragment. There are clear correspondences between the two categories. For instance, a verbless clause such as a few implications for +NP can be readily expanded into an S-Vclause of category 12: a few implications should be mentioned for +NP. Most of the prepositional phrases in category 13 are lexicalized items that have been registered in the major dictionaries. Their variability is so restricted that they may, with almost equal justification, be assigned to the category of set expressions. In this connection, for example, only admits of one variant, namely in that connection. Category 14 is a special case in that it contains clause-fragment SLDMs based on syntactically deviant set expressions such as far be it from me, and its erroneous variant far be it for me. The latter may be followed by a small range of verbs, most commonly suggest. Equally limited in variability are the items in category 15 based on the place adverb here plus copular be. This structure commonly initiates patterns such as here is another example . 2.3.1.3 Sentence-integrated markers I have deliberately stretched Nattinger and DeCarrico’s categories to cover sentence-integrated markers. To my knowledge, the term ‘integrated marker’ was first used, but not defined, in Quirk et al. (1972:671ff.). Sentenceintegrated markers may be regarded as restricted collocations of type 3 discussed above; they are usually centred around a two-element association realizing a succession of two or more clause constituents (thus, subject+verb [we get, a moment’s thought suggests], verb+prepositional object [by NP is meant], subject+verb+prepositional object [a good example is proυided by NP, by NP we mean], etc.). As a simple calculation readily attests, they are typically more variable than sentence fragments. Comparing infinitive phrases of the type to take an example with integrated markers of the type an example is proυided by…, we find that the first type of construction only permits five verbs ( take, giυe, cite, pick and use ) to fill
< previous page
page_61
next page >
< previous page Page 62 Table 2.11 Sentence-integrated markers Category 1noun phrase+verb phrase (+passive variant)
page_62
next page >
in English Examples a good example is provided by (NP)↔ (NP) provides a good example I will now briefly describe (NP)↔(NP) will be briefly described I will define (NP) as follows↔(NP) will be defined as follows the next section develops this point↔this point will be developed in the next section we use the term to refer to… we get we have (here) this gives us finally, we return to (NP) (having discussed…,) we are now ready to consideration/analysis/investigation/ scrutiny…suggests/shows a moment’s thought/reflection suggests/ allows us to see/… by…we mean
2(noun phrase+) verb phrase+ prepositional phrase (+passive variant) 3sentence-like units such instances could be multiplied the infinitive slot, whereas the second admits of at least ten different verbs. This means that, other things being equal, sentence-integrated markers are much more productive, especially since they allow both active and passive constructions. The productivity of sentence fragments is much lower, not least owing to apparent restrictions on the choice of adjectives within the infinitive phrase. Some examples can be found in Table 2.12. Still, as was shown in Section 2.2, collocational variability is contained within relatively clear limits even for sentence-integrated markers. 2.3.2 Syntactic realizations of French SLDMs Let us now direct our attention to French, where a similar picture emerges. Table 2.13 presents an overview of syntactic realizations of French SLDMs. A cursory glance at this table suggests that there is a large degree of categorial overlap between English and French. English constructions controlled by anticipatory it may be likened to French constructions initiated by il or ce/cela; English existential clauses initiated by there+ copular be may be compared to French clauses controlled by il y a; similar remarks could be made for most other categories, with the excep-
< previous page
page_62
next page >
< previous page
page_63
next page >
Page 63 Table 2.12 Comparison of sentence fragments and sentence-integrated markers (citations from CAE and EB) Sentence fragments Sentence-integrated markers to (INFINITIVE)…a/the (ADJ) example VERB+ADJECTIVE+a/the example the example of NP might make this clearer to take but one example A pertinent example is afforded by NP to take an extended example A good example is proυided by NP to take two random examples Another such example is afforded by NP to give an example At this point, perhaps, an example of NP should be giυen. to giυe a few examples to giυe two examples …, as we see from such examples as NP to cite another example A simple example of NP is seen in the case of NP to pick just one example …is a frequent example of NP to use the example aboυe A brief example of NP will serυe to illustrate this. tion perhaps of category 15. One important difference is that some French SLDMs also have an inverted form (croyons-nous, a-t-on dit). Let us now consider each category in greater detail. 2 .3.2.1 Set expressions As in English, invariant SLDMs are a fairly unremarkable set containing a limited number of items, many of which are syntactically ill-formed and unanalysable (see Table 2.14). Most of them have been recorded in the standard reference works, but their lexicographic treatment has been severely lacking in depth (cf. Jespersen 1993). In particular, the dictionaries are silent on the pragmatic value of these markers. It is interesting to note that structurally incomplete set expressions of the prepositional phrase type, such as en ce sens and sur ces entrefaites, appear to have passed into general use only recently. In earlier writings we find a partiality for pronominal substitution of the following type: C’est alors que nous pourrions parler de conditions proprement instantanées. Ces conditions sont rigoureusement préliminaires, mieux pré-initiales puisqu’elles sont antécédentes à ce que les géomètres appellent les conditions initiales du mouvement. C’est en cela qu’elles sont métaphysiques et non pas abstraitement instantanées. (Bachelard, Intuition de l’Instant, 1932, cited after Jespersen 1993:32; emphasis hers) However, Jespersen’s (1993:32) claim that such wordings have all but disappeared from contemporary written French is not supported by the evidence. To take but one example, in CAF there are 28 occurrences of c’est en
< previous page
page_63
next page >
< previous page Page 64 Table 2.13 Syntactic realizations of French SLDMs Category Set expressions 1.1Structurally incomplete set expressions
Examples
1.2Structurally complete set expressions Sentence fragments 1 anticipatory il/ce/cela +verb phrase+ adjective/noun phrase (+complement clause fragment) 2 personal pronoun (je/on/nous) + verb phrase (+inf. +)+que (or inυerted υariant)/+(à/de) NP
3 first-person-plural imperative (hortative)+complement 4 adverbial clause (fragment) 5 infinitive clauses introduced by pour or sans 6 sentence adverbs 7 noun phrase+copular be+que-clause/ noun phrase+ c’est que 8 verbless clause 9 participial clause 10 noun/pronoun+verb phrase+ clause fragment 11 set expressions+clause fragments of limited variability 12 noun phrase+verb phrase+ complement-clause fragment 13 il y a+complement 14 ce qui+verb phrase+complement clause 15 υoici +complement 16 variable prepositional phrases
Sentence-integrated markers 1 noun phrase+verb phrase 2 sentence-like units
< previous page
next page >
page_64
soit dit en passant quoi qu’il en soit et j’ en passe il est admis que c’est un fait avéré que il est intéressant de noter à cet égard que on sait que objectera-t-on croyons-nous je me bornerai à nous le verrons revenons à NP disons donc, avec Guillaume, que voyons la chose de près comme nous le verrons plus loin ainsi qu’il a été dit plus haut (ajoutons,) pour être complet (on peut dire) sans trop exagérer mieux encore plus largement encore le problème est que le problème, c’est que autre remarque: fait plus grave: cela dit/ceci dit le tout est de savoir si il en va de même pour reste à savoir (à quel moment) l’expérience prouve que chacun sait que il y a plus (grave) il y a tout lieu de se demander pourquoi ce qui prouve que ce qui semble montrer que voici deux autres exemples dans ce cas/dans le cas présent/dans le cas qui nous occupe …nous fournit un bon exemple là s’arrête le parallèle on pourrait multiplier les exemples
page_64
next page >
< previous page
page_65
next page >
Page 65 Table 2.14 Set expressions in French Category 1.1 Structurally incomplete set expressions
Examples soit dit en passant quoi qu’il en soit de ce fait pour ce faire autant dire que c’est-à-dire c’est dire par là qu’il suffise de citer sur ces entrefaites dans cette alternative à ce sujet seulement voilà en cela ce faisant chemin faisant (et) pour cause le tout est de vienne (+NP) (obsolescent) n’était 1.2 Structurally complete set expressions et j’en passe le parallèle s’arrête là cela que, as against 70 for c’est en ce sens que, showing that c’est en cela que is not yet on the way out. 2.3.2.2 Sentence fragments As the above examples show, French has a great variety of sentence fragments to offer, of which two stand out due to structural peculiarities not found in English or German: first, parenthetical clauses (categories 2 and 4) and, second, the ce qui sentence fragment (category 14). As for parenthetical clauses, two different types may be distinguished. One is introduced by the conjunctions comme or ainsi que, and has therefore been grouped with adverbial-clause fragments (category 4). The other (category 2) is not formally marked by conjunctions or other lexico-grammatical means, except that it may entail inversion (a-t-on dit). The ce qui sentence fragments in category 14 occur mainly with verbs like montrer or prouυer, but also go to make up other relatively fixed expressions such as ce qui complique les choses. Let us now deal with each category in turn. Category 1 comprises impersonal expressions introduced by il, ce or cela . Most of its subcategories are highly productive, so much so that some of its members may not be entirely in keeping with our definition of SLDMs as restricted collocations (e.g. il serait téméraire de croire que ). By way
< previous page
page_65
next page >
< previous page
Page 66 Table 2.15 French sentence fragments Category 1anticipatory il/ce/cela+υerb/ adjective phrase (+complement clause fragment) 1.1il+être/sembler (etc.) +adjective+ que -clause fragment 1.2il+être (etc.) +past participle+ que -clause fragment 1.3il est/c’est+noun phrase+que-clause fragment 1.4il+être (etc.) +adjective+de-inf./ noun+que-clause/whclause fragment
1.5il+être (etc.) +past participle+ de-inf. +que -clause 1.6il+être (etc.) +past participle+ que -clause 1.7il+reflexive verb phrase+ que 1.8impersonal verb+que -clause/+NP
2je/on/nous+υerb phrase (+inf. +)+ que (or inυerted υariant)/+(à/de) NP
3first-person-plural imperatiυe (hortative)+complement
4adυerbial clause (fragment) 5infinitiυe clauses introduced by pour or sans
6sentence adυerbs
< previous page
next page >
page_66
page_66
Examples il est exact que il est clair que il est indéniable que il est généralement reconnu que il est admis que il est un fait connu que c’est un fait avéré que il est aisé d’imaginer que il est intéressant de noter à cet égard que il serait téméraire de croire que il est digne de remarque que il est commode de distinguer il est permis de penser que il a été amplement démontré que il y a déjà été fait allusion il s’avère que il découle de ces constatations que il ressort de ce qui précède que il va de soi que il faut reconnaître que il convient d’ajouter que il semble que on sait que on a très longtemps cru que on conçoit mal (e.g. une chanson sans clip) objectera-t-on a-t-on dit croyons-nous je me bornerai à nous le verrons revenons à NP disons donc, avec Guillaume, que voyons la chose de près prenons comme illustration NP comme nous le verrons plus loin ainsi qu’il a été dit plus haut (ajoutons,) pour être complet pour terminer pour parler clair pour ne prendre qu’un exemple pour reprendre la formule de (on peut dire) sans trop exagérer mieux encore plus largement encore
next page >
< previous page
page_67
Page 67 Category 7 noun phrase+copular be+que-clause/noun phrase+c’est que 8 υerbless clause
9 participial or gerund clause (fragment) 9.1 participial or gerund clause 1 9.2 participial or gerund clause 2
next page >
Examples le problème est que le problème, c’est que autre remarque: fait plus grave: deuxième exemple: première question à se poser: un mot sur… une supposition:
en admettant que/en admettant (NP) considérant que cela dit/ceci dit/cela étant dit ce point acquis 10noun phrase+υerb phrase+ clause fragment le tout est de savoir (si/comment) il en va de même (pour) il en va ainsi (de) 11set expressions with a limited number of preferred reste à (savoir) complements force est de (constater) 12noun phrase+υerb phrase+ complement-clause fragment l’expérience prouve que chacun sait que …, l’exemple de NP le montre bien,… 13il y a/il est (existential clause)+ complement-clause il y a plus (grave) fragment il y a tout lieu de se demander pourquoi il est des cas où 14ce qui+verb phrase+complement-clause fragment ce qui prouve que ce qui semble montrer que ce qui complique les choses 15υoici+complement voici deux autres exemples 16υariable prepositional phrases dans ce cas/dans le cas présent/dans le cas qui nous occupe of contrast, subcategories 1.3 and 1.7 are only a limited source of French SLDMs. Thus, the reflexive construction il s’aυère que is unchangeable, except with regard to tense, and it is impossible for the noun slot in il est/c’est un+NP+que to be filled by any other noun than fait when this structure serves to form an SLDM. Category 2 covers items built around a personal pronoun and a verb phrase. Many of these items are remarkable as taking both clausal and nominal complementation, with the nominal variant being less frequent but stylistically superior. Compare: On sait que les grands ensembles sont caractérisés par leur hétérogénéité sociale et culturelle. (CAF)
< previous page
page_67
next page >
< previous page
page_68
next page >
Page 68 On sait le prix que l’on attache outre-Atlantique au potentiel d’inno vation des jeunes, voire même de très jeunes, en matière d’applications informatiques. (CAF) Here the second sentence may be rephrased using a verbal construction: on sait qu’outre-Atlantique on attache une grande importance au potentiel d’innovation des jeunes… The nominal variant is particularly common with nouns indicating importance or value, such as importance, intérêt, parti (à tirer), prix, rôle or centralité. It is usually found in cases where these take just one complement. However, a writer wishing to use the nominal construction with a noun taking two complements (e.g. la tentation de qqn de faire qqc) can resort to the simple syntactic trick of inserting a relative clause behind the noun, a procedure known as ‘étoffement’, or augmentation, in comparative stylistics and commonly used in English-French and German-French translation: On sait la tentation qui est celle de l’analyste de penser en termes d’identification projective. (CAF) Owing to the valency of such French verbs as saυoir and croire, the SLDMs based on them can enter another complementation pattern, namely S+V+O+ADJ, exemplified by the following sentence, where the adjective fréquent(e) functions as an object complement to the noun phrase la maladie: On sait la maladie fréquente, surtout en Sibérie. (CAF) Again we are dealing with an elegant variant of the verbal pattern: the above example sentence may be recast as on sait que la maladie est fréquente, surtout en Sibérie. Category 3 is made up of first-person-plural imperatives or, to use the classical term, ‘hortatives’. As in English, there is only a small range of verbs entering this SLDM; typical examples are prendre, υoir and remarquer. The illocutionary force of the hortative is somewhat weaker than that of an imperative, allowing the author to engage in a dialogue with her readers rather than enjoining them to perform some action. As already mentioned, the adverbial clauses of category 4 often occur as parenthetical clauses. Unlike English adverbial clauses initiated by as, they can be followed only by a clause, not by a participle on its own. The lexicon of these clauses is comparatively restricted; there is usually a verb of perception, reporting or saying, often combined with an adverbial of place or time such as plus haut, plus loin or précédemment. It has already
< previous page
page_68
next page >
< previous page
page_69
next page >
Page 69 been noted that we find parenthetical clauses which are not introduced by a conjunction, but are otherwise equivalent to the ones under discussion. These brief interpolated clauses are referred to as incises in French grammar; their position in the sentence is quite variable (see also Chapter 4): Pour eux, nous l’avons vu, la loi était la raison humaine manifestée par la volonté générale en qui elle s’incarne. (CAF) Category 5, comprising infinitive clauses introduced by pour or sans, is a rich source of French SLDMs. Unlike English infinitive clauses, they must be attached to a main clause—if sometimes only by a colon—although most of them, such as pour reprendre les termes de+NP, do not require subject identification, as witness the following example: C’est une institution, c’est-à-dire, pour reprendre les termes d’Hauriou, une idée œuvre qui devient porteuse d’une norme sociale. (CAF) The sentence adverbs in category 6 are also a highly productive group (cf. for example curieusement, apparemment, de toute éυidence, historiquement, ironiquement, paradoxalement). They often occur in the comparative, as amply demonstrated by such occurrences as plus étémentairement, plus abstraitement, plus brutalement, plus banalement, plus concrètement, plus fondamentalement, plus globalement, plus généralement, plus profondément, plus prosaïquement, etc. They may also be further pre-modified (cf. et puis tout aussi radicalement). The nominal constructions in category 7 centre around general abstract nouns such as problème or difficulté and a copular verb. The range of nouns capable of displaying this pattern is, however, more restricted than in English. Category 8, containing verbless clauses of various types, is notably common in French prose. Three main types may be distinguished: (a) clauses consisting of an unmodified noun (témoin:), (b) clauses consisting of a modified noun phrase (autre remarque, fait plus graυe) , (c) clauses consisting of a noun phrase followed by a prepositional phrase. Verbless constructions such as these are stylistically useful in that they make for clarity and concision. The participial and gerund clauses in category 9 are just as intriguing as their English counterparts. First, just as in English, participial SLDMs of category 9.2, such as ceci dit, constitute grammatically independent clauses not requiring subject identification. Second, the lexemes initiating participle or gerund clauses vary in their syntactic flexibility. Some, such as admettant, can be followed by either a nominal or a clausal complement, thus retaining some verbal features. An example:
< previous page
page_69
next page >
< previous page
page_70
next page >
Page 70 R.-L.Wagner (1968), qui note que le «terme de “mot” en est venu assez tard en français à traduire la notion d’une unité lexicale autonome», tout en admettant le bien-fondé de l’analyse qu’A. Martinet fait de la notion de «mot», refuse pourtant d’abandonner ce terme parce que la lexicologie porte sur l’étude des signes en situation. (CAF) Category 10 comprises items that may almost equally well be grouped under set expressions, for their variability is extremely restricted. Consider, for example, the SLDM le tout est de saυoir: The only variation possible here is by putting the verb in another tense. Of course, other verbs may also complement the sequence le tout est de, but none of these are so frequent that we would be justified in talking of an SLDM. Rather, we may view le tout est de as an SLDM in its own right, roughly equivalent to il suffit de, and classify it under the heading of set expressions. Another example is il en υa de même (pour/de/dans/à) , whose only variants—disregarding for the moment the possibility of negation—are il en est de même, il en υa pareillement and il en υa également (the latter two being extremely rare). The SLDMs in category 11 are similar to set expressions of the type le tout est de, with the one difference that they enjoy less freedom of complementation. Thus, only a limited number of verbs follow the sequence force est de with any regularity: constater, reconnaître, remarquer, souligner, ajouter . Category 12 comprises restricted noun-verb collocations of the type l’expérience prouυe que or chacun sait que, including parenthetical clauses of the type l’exemple ci-dessus le montre bien . The category admits a large range of superficially different items such as chacun conυiendra que, l’expérience montre que, rien ne prouυe que, etc. Interestingly, however, most such items operate as suggestors of one sort or another (see Chapter 3). Existential constructions initiated by presentative il y a, here subsumed under category 13, have given rise to a large number of SLDMs. They may be divided into two groups, according to whether the clause is or is not self-contained. Among the most prominent exponents of self-contained clauses we find il y a plus, il y a plus graυe, il y a pire, il y a mieux. The commonest items in the other subset are il y a (tout) lieu de (se demander), il y a (grand) intérêt à, il y a aυantage à, il y a à cela deux raisons, il y a de fortes/grandes chances pour que, il y a fort à craindre/parier que, il y a gros à parier que, il y a grand besoin de and il y a place pour . To these we might add such constructions as si/puisque/car (etc.) +NP+il y a, where the noun precedes the presentative form, and il n’y a pas jusqu’à+ NP+qui/où+ne+VP (etc.). According to Godin (1948:116–117), the former construction is an interpolated conditional or causal clause casting doubt on the preceding assertion or laying emphasis on it, as the case may be; the latter employs the double negative for stylistic effect. Godin’s description of the former can be enhanced by two observations. First, it is not the content of the entire preceding sentence that is called into ques-
< previous page
page_70
next page >
< previous page
page_71
next page >
Page 71 tion or emphasized by such constructions, but rather a particular state of affairs expressed by means of a noun phrase, as conveniently illustrated by the following examples: Le droit communautaire prend ici une place supérieure par rapport au régime de protection nationale, mais cet inconvénient—si inconvénient il y a—est compensé par le fait que les signes nationaux sont de facto vus reconnaître une protection au niveau communautaire. (CAF) Sans parler de la destruction de milliers d’hectares cultivés et de l’impact sur l’environnement. Car impact il y a: aucun des insecticides utilisés (la Deltaméthrine, une pyréthrénoïde commercialisée par AgrEvo, et le Fipronil, une molécule de la famille des phényl-pirazoles mise au point par Rhône-Poulenc) n’est spécifique des acridiens. (CAF) Second, Godin overlooks the fact that constructions of the type si+NP+il y a can also serve as ordinary conditional or concessive clauses. In other words, we are dealing with a case of inverted word order; in the following example we might equally well have s’il y a polémique instead of si polémique il y a: Cela n’ira pas sans mal car si polémique il y a (et il y aura), c’est parce que le véritable enjeu du débat reste l’enfant. (CAF) Category 14 comprises sentential relative clauses, their relative abundance in French making it necessary to accord them category status. Whereas in English such structures are common only with verbs such as mean, there is a much greater. variety to be encountered in French. Examples are ce qui complique les choses, ce qui υeut dire que or ce qui prouυe que . Category 15 bears a certain resemblance to category 13 in that both υoici and il y a are presentative forms serving to introduce the notional subject and hence to rhematize important content. They are thus used to draw the reader’s attention to an entire proposition, often introducing examples or enumerations (Il y a à cela plusieurs raisons. En υoici les principales). Category 16 is made up of variable prepositional phrases such as dans ce cas/dans le cas présent/dans le cas qui nous occupe. English items of this nature, it will be recalled, are clearly lexicalized expressions whose variability is so restricted that they may just as well be subsumed under set expressions. As in English, there are various points of contact between categories. However, these are often so obvious as not to warrant discussion (e.g. il est
< previous page
page_71
next page >
< previous page
page_72
next page >
Page 72 un fait remarquable que [category 1.3]↔il est digne de remarque que [category 1.4], etc.). 2.3.2.3 Sentence-integrated markers As in English, there is an abundance of sentence-integrated markers to be found, and we can use the same categories to divide them up (see Table 2.16). It is noteworthy that many of the items in category 1 are built around the verb permettre or similar verbs ( obliger, forcer, etc.) and that the items in category 2 often serve definitional functions. Equally remarkable is the wide array of sentence-like units subject only to slight variations. Compare: Mais là s’arrête la similitude. Le parallèle s’arrête là. Là s’arrête le parallèle. Mais la similitude des situations s’arrête là. (NF) Deux explications doivent à ce propos être avancées. Deux explications sont généralement avancées. Différentes explications peuvent en être données. Plusieurs explications peuvent être proposées. Plusieurs explications furent données. Trois explications rivales sont possibles. Deux types d’explications peuvent être avancées a ce phénoméne. (CAF) Table 2.16 Sentence-integrated markers in French Category Examples 1noun phrase+verb phrase (NP) nous fournit un bon exemple↔un bon exemple nous est fourni par (NP) (NP) offre quelque parenté avec (NP) un examen rapide permet de distinguer (NP) cette brève analyse permet de comprendre (NP/clause) une vue objective des choses oblige a constater que (NP) appelle quelques remarques 2noun phrase+verb phrase+ prepositional par…, on entend phrase on parle de…lorsque on perçoit avec (sur) ces exemples on peut dire avec X que 3sentence-like units là s’arrête le parallèle on pourrait multiplier les exemples les exemples abondent deux raisons l’expliquent trois explications sont généralement avancées
< previous page
page_72
next page >
< previous page
page_73
next page >
Page 73 From these examples it is obvious that the boundaries between category 1 and category 3 are not entirely clear-cut. 2.3.3 Syntactic realizations of German SLDMs We now turn to the syntactic realizations of German SLDMs. Again, we find the same tripartite division into set expressions, sentence fragments and sentence-integrated markers, as the overview in Table 2.17 shows. The table illustrates the remarkable structural diversity of German SLDMs, especially with regard to the category of sentenceintegrated markers. We may surmise that, since German is a free-word-order language, discourse markers use in this language may be subject to more ad hoc change (see House 1997 [79ff.] on the general tendency of German to ad hoc formulation). Let us now proceed to look at each category in greater detail. 2.3.3.1 Set expressions As in English and French, this group is relatively small, and its members differ in their syntactic make-up (see Table 2.18). 2.3.3.2 Sentence fragments The reader accustomed to German academic texts will not fail to notice that the sentence fragment SLDMs presented in Table 2.19 have been pared down to their essentials by omitting structurally irrelevant anaphoric or cataphoric elements such as pronominal adverbs ( hierbei, damit, etc.) or one-word discourse markers (e.g. also or wohl )—‘structurally’ being the operative word, for there is a higher mutual expectancy between such particles and second-level markers in German than in either English or French. Note that, given the relative flexibility of word order and theme-rheme arrangement in German, the syntactic realizations of these markers in actual text may not always correspond to the citation forms shown here. Thus, the citation form es ist bemerkenswert, dass, at three occurrences, occurs much less frequently in CAG than its syntactic variant bemerkenswert ist, dass at 14 occurrences. Table 2.20 shows the full range of syntactic variation for the citation form es ist anzumerken, dass. It turns out that there are five major syntactic patterns. Each of these patterns can be thought of as a frame offering three different types of slot; in the third pattern, for example, the first slot is filled by a qualifying adverb (e.g. kritisch ), while the second and third slots may be filled, respectively, by the theme under discussion and a conjunct (e.g. jedoch or ferner ). A further complication affecting German SLDMs is that some possible citation forms are totally absent from actual text. An example is es bleibt
< previous page
page_73
next page >
< previous page Page 74 Table 2.17 Syntactic realizations of German SLDMs Category Set expressions 1.1Structurally incomplete set expressions
Examples
1.2Structurally complete set expressions Sentence fragments 1 anticipatory es+verb phrase (+complement clause fragment)
2 ich/wir/man +verb phrase+ complement clause fragment
3 first-person-plural imperative (hortative) (+complement fragment)
4 adverbial clause (fragment)
5 infinitive clauses
6 sentence adverbs
7 noun phrase+copular sein+dass-clause
< previous page
next page >
page_74
page_74
geschweige denn wie dem auch sei zu diesem Zweck us diesem Grund in dieser Hinsicht Das ist noch nicht alles es steht fest, dass es geht darum, dass es liegt nahe, dass es fragt sich, ob es sei bemerkt, dass es sei darauf hingewiesen, dass es darf davon ausgegangen werden, dass so ist (es) zu erklären, dass wir werden sehen, wie wir bemerken, dass wir entnehmen daraus, dass wir müssen uns vor Augen führen man beachte, dass man wird sich fragen man muß dem entgegenhalten, dass vielleicht sollte man sich einmal fragen man sollte nicht vergessen, dass betrachten wir vergegenwärtigen wir uns dies an… fassen wir zusammen stellen wir zunächst fest,… nehmen wir einmal an wie ich bereits gezeigt habe wie bereits gesagt wenn ich richtig sehe womit wir bei…wären um es auf den Punkt zu bringen um es gleich zu sagen um dies einmal zu veranschaulichen um Mißverständnissen vorzubeugen um aber wieder auf unser Hauptthema zurückzukommen um ein Beispiel zu nennen strenggenommen merkwürdigerweise genauer bekanntlich eine weitere Schwierigkeit ist, dass ein Grund ist, dass
next page >
< previous page Page 75 Category 8 verbless clause
9 participial clause
10set expressions with a limited number of variable complements 11variable prepositional phrases 12noun phrase+verb phrase+clause fragment
Sentence-integrated markers 1 noun phrase+verb phrase
Examples geschweige denn wie dem auch sei zu diesem Zweck in dieser Hinsicht Das ist noch nicht alles.
Structurally complete set expressions
< previous page
Examples (Zum Schluß) noch eine Bemerkung zu… Dazu das folgende Zitat: Nun zu… Zur Erinnerung: zusammenfassend (läßt sich sagen, dass) resümierend anders ausgedrückt pointiert formuliert vergröbernd gesprochen insgesamt gesehen zusammengefaßt: man kann nicht umhin in dieser/jener Hinsicht in diesem/jenem Zusammenhang analoges gilt für anders verhält es sich mit Wen darf es Wunder nehmen, dass wie kommt es aber, dass…? so kommt es, dass hier schließt sich der Kreis (zu dem, was…) ein flüchtiger Blick auf…zeigt ein Einwand könnte lauten, dass bleibt letztens noch… relatives Einverständnis besteht darüber, dass die Vermutung liegt nahe, dass das Gesagte bedeutet, dass Beweis dafür ist angefangen von…über…bis hin zu…spannt sich der Bogen solche Beispiele ließen sich beliebig vermehren
2 sentence-like units Table 2.18 Set expressions in German Category 1.1 Structurally incomplete set expressions
1.2
next page >
page_75
page_75
next page >
< previous page
page_76
next page >
Page 76 Table 2.19 German sentence fragments Category Examples 1anticipatory es+verb phrase (+complement clause fragment) es steht fest, dass es sei bemerkt, dass es sei darauf hingewiesen, dass es darf davon ausgegangen werden, dass es ist anzumerken, dass es ist festzustellen, dass es bleibt festzuhalten, dass es ist/steht zu vermuten, dass es verdient betont zu werden, dass ohne Übertreibung läßt sich behaupten, dass 2 ich/wir/man +verb phrase+complement clause fragment wir werden sehen, wie complement clause fragment wir bemerken, dass wir entnehmen daraus, dass wir müssen uns vor Augen führen, dass man beachte, dass man wird sich fragen man muß dem entgegenhalten, dass vielleicht sollte man sich einmal fragen man sollte nicht vergessen, dass 3first-person-plural imperative (hortative) (+complement betrachten wir fragment) vergegenwärtigen wir uns dies an… fassen wir zusammen stellen wir zunächst fest,… nehmen wir einmal an 4adverbial clause (fragment) wie ich bereits gezeigt habe wie bereits gesagt wie bereits oben nachgewiesen worden ist so darf angenommen werden 5infinitive clauses um es auf den Punkt zu bringen um es gleich zu sagen um dies einmal zu veranschaulichen um Mißverständnissen vorzubeugen um aber wieder auf unser Hauptthema zurückzukommen um ein Beispiel zu nennen 6sentence adverbs strenggenommen merkwürdigerweise genauer bekanntlich 7noun phrase+copular be+ dass -clause/wh-clause eine weitere Schwierigkeit ist, dass ein Grund ist, dass die Folge davon ist, dass 8verbless clause (Zum Schluß) noch eine Bemerkung zu… Dazu das folgende Zitat: Nun zu… Zur Erinnerung:
< previous page
page_76
next page >
< previous page Page 77 Category 9 participial clause
10set expressions with a limited number of variable complements 11variable prepositional phrases
page_77
next page >
Examples zusammenfassend (läßt sich sagen, dass) resümierend anders ausgedrückt pointiert formuliert vergröbernd gesprochen insgesamt gesehen zusammengefaßt: man kann nicht umhin
aus diesem Grund zu diesem Zweck 12noun phrase+verb phrase+ clause fragment analoges gilt für anders verhält es sich mit Wen darf es Wunder nehmen, dass wie kommt es aber, dass…? so kommt es, dass hier schließt sich der Kreis (zu dem, was…) noch, which only occurs in CAG in the inverted form bleibt (letztens) noch+NP . As in English and French, the number of patterns formed by German SLDMs is limited; they may be arranged in 12 major categories. Within individual categories the productivity of patterns varies. We will now proceed to look at each category one by one. Category 1 may be further subdivided along the lines shown in Table 2.21. Category 1.1 comprises a closed, and therefore unproductive, set of highly frequent SLDMs, of which Table 2.21 shows the most common. Several of the verbs in this category are used in a reflexive ‘middle voice’ construction, as with es stellt sich heraus, dass or es fragt sich, ob. Category 1.2 is based around υerba dicendi such as sagen, feststellen, anmerken or betonen . In category 1.3 similar verbs are used with the present subjunctive of sein . Category 1.4 comprises structures using auxiliary verbs such as dürfen and müssen with the past participle. These structures are generally equivalent to ones in which the reflexive verb sich lassen is used with the infinitive, as shown in category 1.5. Category 1.6 is composed of constructions containing a copular verb followed by either an adjective or an adjectival past participle. Category 1.7 is centred around common noun-verb collocations which here occur in impersonal form. There are close links between the impersonal constructions of category 1 and those of category 2. A certain number of correspondences can be established by means of simple syntactic transformations. Note, however, that preferred ways of putting things place constraints on such correspondences—more so in German than in either of the other languages under
< previous page
page_77
next page >
< previous page
page_78
next page >
Page 78 Table 2.20 Syntactic realizations of es ist anzumerken, dass Es ist anzumerken, dass Structureszu etw./bei etw.//hierzu/dazu/hierbei ist (kritisch/negativ// positiv//generell/überhaupt… och/ferner/außerdem) anzumerken, daß… Es ist (kritisch/noch/ferner/negativ…) (zu etw.) anzumerken, daß… (Kritisch/Negativ//Positiv//Generell/Überhaupt…) ist (zu etw.) (jedoch/indes//noch/ferner/außerdem/…) anzumerken, daß… (kritisch/negativ//positiv…) anzumerken ist (jedoch/indes// ferner/außerdem/…), daß... (hier[zu]/dazu/an dieser Stelle…) ist/wäre (einiges/ folgendes/etliches…) anzumerken Examples Grundsätzlich ist zu den “Umstmkturierungsprozessen” anzumerken. daß Sanierungs- und Neuaufbaukonzepte—auch unter dem Eindruck des vorhandenen und immer noch steigenden Überangebots von Arbeitskräften—niger in Abhängigkeit von den jeweiligen Potentialen gesehen werden, als beinahe ausschließlich im Kontext von Absatzerwartungen, Investitionsrenditen und Finanzierungshilfen. Dabei ist zunächst anzumerken. dass ich mich im Rahmen der Arbeit der Jahrgangsstufe 11 zwar für eine integrale Präsentation der BD entschied, den Schülern aber immer nur sukzessiv Teile des Werkes in Kopien vorgelegt wurden. Kritisch anzumerken ist hierbei. dass sie ihre eigenen Standpunkte zwar in den Diskussionen einbringen konnten, während der Textproduktion jedoch im wesentlichen aus der Sicht eines anderen heraus schreiben mußten. Zu diesem Beleg ist zweierlei anzumerken. consideration. Thus, while man beachte, dass has only one meaning or function—that of indicating a warning— es ist zu beachten, dass appears to have two—that of indicating a warning and that of adding an important afterthought. Worse, *man merke an, dass, seemingly a perfectly admissible transformation of es ist anzumerken, dass, does not occur at all. Category 3 consists of first-person-plural imperatives or, to use the classical term, ‘hortatives’. The range of verbs capable of entering this pattern is somewhat wider than in English and French; typical examples are zusammenfassen, υeranschaulichen and festhalten. The German parenthetical clauses in category 4 are based on two interchangeable patterns: one is introduced by so followed by a finite verb, the other by wie followed by the subject or, in a passive clause, by a participle.
< previous page
page_78
next page >
< previous page
page_79
next page >
Page 79 Table 2.21 Subcategories of category 1 (anticipatory es+verb phrase) Category 1: anticipatory es+ verb phrase 1.1es+verb es+steht fest, dass/erstaunt, dass/gilt, dass/gilt (+zu-inf.)/liegt nahe, dass/ kommt hinzu, phrase+complement- dass/fragt sich, ob/leuchtet ein, dass/scheint, dass/stellt sich heraus, dass/fällt auf, clause fragment dass/geht darum, dass/ kommt darauf an, wie/stellt sich heraus, dass/stimmt, dass/erstaunt, dass/kommt erschwerend hinzu, dass/ist so, dass/ spricht viel dafür, dass/stimmt, dass/ verwundert, dass/ könnte sein, dass/fragt sich, ob/kann passieren, dass/bleibt noch 1.2es+verb es ist anzumerken, dass (sein/bleiben/stehen/ es verdient betont zu werden, dass verdienen/…)+infinitive clause 1.3es+sei+past participle es sei bemerkt, dass 1.4es+auxiliary verb+past es darf (muss) angenommen werden, dass participle 1.5es+sich ohne Übertreibung läßt sich behaupten lassen+infinitive 1.6es+copular verb (sein/ es ist unnötig zu sagen, dass scheinen/…)+adjective/ es ist nicht verwunderlich, dass participle+complement-es erscheint bemerkenswert, dass (bemerkenswert erscheint, dass) clause fragment es scheint ausgeschlossen, dass es wäre (jedoch) zu kurz gegriffen,… 1.7es+verb phrase+noun es stellt sich die Frage, ob phrase es spielt keine Rolle, ob Thus, an impersonal SLDM such as es wird häufig angenommen, dass may be used in a parenthetical clause in one of two ways: Nun ist ja, so wird häufig angenommen or nun ist ja, wie häufig angenommen wird,... Category 5 is made up of infinitive clauses introduced by um. Unlike English infinitive clauses, they must be attached to a main clause—if sometimes only by means of a colon. Just as in English and French, the sentence adverbs in category 6 formed by adding the suffix -weise, are a particularly productive pattern. Here are a few illustrative examples culled from CAG: beispielsweise, bemerkenswerterweise, berechtigterweise, bezeichnenderweise, erfreulicherweise, fatalerweise, idealerweise, interessanterweise, konsequenterweise, paradoxerweise, υerständlicherweise, überraschenderweise. The nominal constructions in category 7 are based around general abstract nouns such as Schwierigkeit or Einschränkung and a copular verb. The range of nouns capable of displaying this pattern is fairly large in German.
< previous page
page_79
next page >
< previous page
page_80
next page >
Page 80 Category 8, which contains verbless clauses of various types, is moderately common both in academic and newspaper German. Some of these clauses are almost totally fixed, consisting of nothing more than a prepositional phrase ([noch einmal] zur Erinnerung:); others allow greater variation ([nun] noch ein Wort/eine Bemerkung zu...). As already noted, verbless constructions such as these make for greater economy of expression. The participial and gerund clauses in category 9 are a prolific source of German SLDMs. They constitute grammatically independent clauses which do not require subject identification. Sometimes a construction involving a present participle may serve the same function as one involving a past participle, as is the case with zusammengefasst and zusammenfassend . Examples: Zusammengefaßt läßt sich festhalten, daß wir auch bei der Forschung eine gute Startposition für den Wettbewerb haben...(CAG) Zusammenfassend läßt sich festhalten, daß Verarbeitungsziele maßge-blich zur Kohärenzbildung beitragen können...(CAG) It is also worthy of note that German participles such as zusammengefasst can be used on their own, thus acting as equivalents to entire clauses. Zusammenfassend: Auf regionaler Ebene können die Unternehmen nun zwischen einer Vielzahl von Ausbildungs- und Qualifizierungs-maßnahmen wählen...(CAG) Category 10 is remarkable in that it contains clause-fragment SLDMs based around syntactically deviant expressions such as man kann nicht umhin and its variant man kommt nicht umhin . These are followed by an infinitive introduced by zu; the verbs acting as complements are quite variable. Examples: Denn man kann wohl nicht umhin, in Verben wie υerbringen die im direkten Objekt ausgedrückte Zeitangabe als ‘Figur’ (und nicht als ‘Grund’) des dargestellten Sachverhalts zu bezeichnen. (CAG) Man kommt deshalb nicht umhin, dem Photo in diesem Zusammenhang eine gewisse innovative Funktion zuzusprechen. (CAG) Category 11 comprises variable prepositional phrases such as aus diesem (einem) Grund. As already noted for English items of this kind, these are lexicalized expressions whose variability is so restricted that they may just as well be subsumed under set expressions. Category 12 comprises restricted noun-verb collocations of the type analoges gilt für or die Erfahrung zeigt, dass.
< previous page
page_80
next page >
< previous page
page_81
next page >
Page 81 Table 2.22 Sentence-integrated markers in German Category Examples 1 noun phrase+verb phrase ein flüchtiger Blick auf…zeigt relatives Einverständnis besteht darüber, dass die Vermutung liegt nahe, dass das Gesagte bedeutet, dass Beweis dafür ist (angefangen) von…über…bis hin zu… spannt sich der Bogen 2sentence-like units solche Beispiele ließen sich beliebig vermehren 2.3.3.3 Sentence-integrated markers Unlike linear English and French constructions, the German brace construction may render the recognition of sentence-integrated markers more difficult than in English or French (see Table 2.22). Beyond this, there is not much here that differs from either French or English.
< previous page
page_81
next page >
< previous page
page_82
next page >
Page 82 3 Identifying meanings and functions An attempt at a functional taxonomy of SLDMs Il faut beaucoup de philosophie pour savoir observer une fois ce qu’on voit tous les jours. Jean-Jacques Rousseau 3.1 Introduction The preceding chapter presented a structural taxonomy of SLDMs. However, as common sense suggests, such a taxonomy does not allow us to establish translational equivalences (for further detail, see Siepmann 2000:275–281). Instead, correspondences between source and target-language markers must be inferred from functional similarities in their contextual or ‘discoursal’ uses. The present chapter therefore provides a brief review of the literature on discourse relations and then goes on to present a functional taxonomy of SLDMs. This taxonomy arises directly from the textual evidence rather than from preconceived theoretical notions, as was the case in many previous studies. Each category of SLDM will be briefly defined and exemplified. Detailed consideration of three specific categories is deferred until Chapter 4; this chapter contents itself with discussing general points of interest arising from the taxonomy: the multiple category membership exhibited by some SLDMs, the relationship between SLDMs and one-word connectives, as well as the existence of a hitherto unexplored class of collocations which may be termed ‘long-distance’ collocations. 3.2 Language functions and textual relations The attempt to classify language functions and textual relations has generated a literature which is far too extensive to review in detail here. Most of the relevant studies attempt to establish a relationship between the coherence relations obtaining at the propositional or referential levels and their surface cues, including discourse markers (for a recent overview, see Oates 1999; cf. also Blumenthal 1980; Roulet et al . 1991; Mann and
< previous page
page_82
next page >
< previous page
page_83
next page >
Page 83 Thompson 1988; Hoey 1991; Martin 1992; Halliday 1994; Winter 1994; Hyland 1998, 1999a, 1999b). Interestingly, while there is significant disagreement on how to classify particular single-word markers and some variation in the methods developed for this purpose, such disagreement tends to obfuscate a greater consensus on general types of coherence relations. Two major groups may be distinguished on the basis of the literature. • Group 1 comprises relations establishing a link between discourse units that describe ‘real-world’ states and processes. These are variously called ‘ideationar, ‘semantic’, ‘content’, ‘external’, ‘subject-matter’ or ‘propositional’ relations. Examples are ‘cause and effect’, ‘sequence’, ‘contrast’, and so on. • Group 2 contains relations establishing a link between the illocutionary force of one discourse unit and the locutionary meaning of another. These are variously called ‘interpersonal, ‘pragmatic’, ‘internal’, ‘rhetorical, ‘procedural’, ‘presentational’ or ‘metadiscursive’ relations. Examples are ‘criticizing’, ‘justifying’, ‘concluding’, etc. This broad classification may then give rise to more detailed sub-classification. Thus, Hyland’s (1998) schema (see Table 3.1), a refined extension of Crismore et al. (1993), takes up the above distinction between two types of metadiscourse, while further subdividing the functions of these. The two major types of metadiscourse are defined as follows: textual metadiscourse ‘refers to devices which allow the recovery of the writer’s intention by explicitly establishing preferred interpretations of propositional meanings’; interpersonal metadiscourse ‘alerts readers to the author’s perspective towards both the propositional information and the readers themselves, thus contributing to a writer-reader relationship and anticipating the subjective negatability of statements’. Before discussing the problems associated with such classification, let us first consider a selective synopsis of the great variety of taxonomies established so far, most of which take account of only a small number of SLDMs, or none at all (see Table 3.2). Overly crude classifications, such as Crismore and Farnsworth’s (1990), derived from Vande Kopple’s (1985), have not been taken account of here. The table is not meant to suggest that different authors merely give different names to what are essentially the same categories; rather, it selects some common discourse markers dealt with by most authors and shows the varying levels of delicacy at which these have been treated. Somewhat disappointingly, neither the distinction between propositional and metadiscursive relations discussed at the beginning of this section nor the metadiscourse taxonomies just presented are particularly helpful when considering real text. Associated with them are two main risks, or problems; I shall briefly review these and explain how I have tried to tackle each of them.
< previous page
page_83
next page >
< previous page
Page 84 Table 3.1 Hyland’s classification of functions of metadiscourse in academic texts Category Function Textual metadiscourse Logical connectives Express semantic relation between main clauses Frame markers Explicitly refer to discourse acts or text stages Endophoric markers Refer to information in other parts of the text Evidentials Refer to source of information from other texts Code glosses Help readers grasp meanings of ideational material Interpersonal metadiscourse Hedges Withhold writer’s full commitment to statements Emphatics Emphasize force or writer’s certainty in message Attitude markers Express writer’s attitude to propositional content Relational markers Explicitly refer to or build relationship with reader Person markers Explicit reference to author(s) Source: adapted from Hyland (1998:442)
< previous page
next page >
page_84
page_84
Examples in addition/but/therefore/thus finally/to repeat/Our aim here noted above/see Fig. 1/table 2 according to X/Y, 1990/Z states namely/e.g./in other words/such as might/perhaps/it is possible/about in fact/definitely/It is clear surprisingly/I agree/X claims frankly/note that/you can see I/we/my/mine/our
next page >
< previous page
page_85
next page >
Page 85 Table 3.2 Classifications of discourse markers Examples Vande Kopple Hyland Hutz (1997) Fraser (1988) (1985) (1998) In addition, but, Text connectives Logical Causality and result Message relationship markers: therefore, thus, and connectivesOpposition and Contrast elaborative, contrastive, inferential, Addition parallel Comparison Exemplification Restriction and condition Finally, to repeat, our Action markers, Frame Text structuring (as Discourse activity markers: clarifying, aim here, in sum, text connectives markers noted earlier) conceding, explaining, interrupting, overall (e.g. sequencers) Summary and repeating, sequencing, summarizing generalization (in sum) Order of importance (first, next, finally) Chronological order (then) Noted above, see Fig. — Endophoric Text Structuring Topic markers 1, below, the markers following According to, Fraser Narrators, Evidentials — Topic markers 1990, Sinclair states Attributors In other words, Code glosses Code Specification (in Topic markers, (elaborative) message specifically, such as, (defining, glosses particular) Explanation relationship markers, (explanatory) namely explaining, (in other words, in this discourse activity markers limiting) sense) Might, perhaps, it is Modality markers: Hedges Degree of probability — possible, about, hedges (perhaps, possibly, would, seem, tends to probably) Indeed, in fact, it is Modality markers: Emphatics Emphasis Topic markers, message relationship clear, obvious, even emphatics markers Surprisingly, I agree, Attitude markers Attitude Manner Message relationship markers X claims, it is markers, fortunate that Frankly, note that, Attitude markers Relational — Message relationship markers you can see Commentary markers I, we, my, mine, our — Person —(dealt with in a — markers separate section)
< previous page
page_85
next page >
< previous page
page_86
next page >
Page 86 The first problem is one of methodology. Most of the available taxonomies depend too heavily on top-down analysis to be reliable; they are frequently grounded on time-honoured grammatical categories and an insufficient empirical base. None of the studies cited above provide more than a handful of examples to illustrate their categorization, while most furnish no examples at all. In other words, the question remains unanswered as to how the analyst arrives at his interpretation of the discourse relation cued by a particular marker. To address this issue, any new analysis of markers must therefore proceed from the bottom up, as already suggested in Chapter 1. The linguist’s intuitive classificatory decisions should be refined through substitution and paraphrase tests, i.e. by substituting SLDMs with single-word markers and by paraphrasing in terms of RST the relations cued by SLDMs. The results of such bottom-up analysis can then be compared with the set of general categories that has emerged from previous studies. The final step is to revise existing categories or set up new ones. The present study derives additional authority from the collation of data from several languages, whereas in previous studies analysis was usually restricted to just one language. The second problem concerns the linguist’s semantic intuitions. There are actually two separate points to be considered here. One is that the neat compartmentalizing of meanings or functions can do no more than partially capture a complex reality in which any single-word marker or SLDM may express more than one discourse relation. Let us consider a few examples. Hyland (1998) includes the SLDM it is clear that under the category of ‘emphatics’, a subcategory of ‘interpersonal metadiscourse’ which implies ‘certainty’ and emphasizes ‘the force of the proposition’. While it is correct that certainty and forcefulness partake of the meaning of it is clear, Hyland (1998) totally neglects its role as an inferrer (for examples of it is clear in this role, see Section 4.3), probably because he bases his classification on pure intuition rather than detailed observation of actual text. In its inferential mode, however, it is clear manifestly resembles first-level markers such as therefore and would thus fall within the ambit of Hyland’s ‘textual metadiscourse’. By the same token, not all items that Hyland refers to as ‘person markers’ can be classified under the heading ‘interpersonal metadiscourse’: it is inconceivable to refer to a concluder such as une demière remarque sur (a ‘frame marker’ in Hyland’s terminology) as ‘textual metadiscourse’, while at the same time including the functionally close nous terminons en indiquant in the opposing category of ‘interpersonal metadiscourse’, purely because it contains a personal pronoun. Although Hyland (1998:444) himself acknowledges, at least to some extent, the fuzzy boundaries between his two major categories of ‘textual metadiscourse’ and ‘interpersonal metadiscourse’, he does not take his reasoning to its logical conclusion, which would mean abandoning such broad categorization altogether. Ultimately, then, even the line between propo-
< previous page
page_86
next page >
< previous page
page_87
next page >
Page 87 sitional and metadiscursive relations may be difficult to draw; some authors (e.g. Halliday 1978) explicitly view the various planes of discourse as existing simultaneously, and this is probably the soundest approach. The second point about intuition has already been touched upon in Chapter 1: in the area of pragmatic concepts, any definition is at least to some extent expressive of the linguist’s personal world-view and experience. Thus, in his ground-breaking study of French connectors, Grieve (1996) takes issue with French dictionary makers on a number of points, including the function of the structure d’une part…d’autre part: The definition of its function given in Robert requires some modification: employé pour mettre en parallèle, pour opposer deux idées ou deux faits, deux aspects d’un objet. Most writers nowadays do not use this connector pour opposer deux idées . They use it to link two points which are parallel or complementary to each other. (Grieve 1996:238) It is easy to see how Grieve subtly shifts the emphasis from opposition to parallelism, although both aspects are equally present in most instances of the connector. Examples of such definitional uncertainty abound. Thus, the adverb surprisingly is a connective expressing manner for Hutz (1997:175), whereas it comes under the scope of attitude markers for Hyland (1998:442). Similarly, Hyland (1998, 1999a, 1999b) sees note that as a relational marker, i.e. a device that explicitly addresses readers, ‘either by selectively focusing their attention or by including them as participants in the text situation’, whereas Swales et al. (1998) describe it as an attention-getting device designed to set an emphatic tone in order to draw the reader’s attention to a crucial or unexpected argument, something that Hyland would describe as an ‘emphatic’. We must conclude from all this that the subjectivity of the analyst is bound to impact on any taxonomy of SLDMs, but that the resultant uncertainties can be minimized through the use of a large sample of authentic data. 3.3 A taxonomy of SLDMs With the above considerations in mind, I shall now suggest my own taxonomy of the material drawn from the corpus sources described in Chapter 2. As already noted, two points in particular militate in favour of this taxonomy. First, the detailed textual evidence compiled over long years of research allows a higher degree of descriptive delicacy than could have been achieved in earlier work based on unaided intuition or a slim research base. Second, the taxonomy derives greater authority from being multilingual, whereas previous research has tended to be monolingual,
< previous page
page_87
next page >
< previous page
page_88
next page >
Page 88 mainly focusing on British and American English. It is important to remember, however, that the proposals set forth here are based on my semantic-pragmatic intuitions and may in their turn be subject to modification by other authors. In line with the above discussion, I assume that any discourse marker has only one primary function, while making proper allowance for the fact that many discourse markers also have a secondary function (see also Schiffrin 1987; Lenk 1998). This will be discussed in Section 3.4.1. Each functional category will now be briefly defined and exemplified. The examples have been randomly chosen to reflect a broad range of members of each category; hence also the selection of different SLDMs in each language rather than translation equivalents. For further delicacy, see the subsequent discussion of three categories singled out for in-depth cross-linguistic comparison (see Chapter 4). For further lexical detail on the categories not receiving in-depth treatment, see Gallagher et al. (in preparation). The analysis reveals that RST (Mann and Thompson 1988) is well suited to describing general relations between text spans containing, or linked by, second-level markers. What it cannot do, however, is help to establish distinctions between closely related types of markers. The elaboration relation, for example, was found to be encoded by announcers, topic initiators, digression markers and clarification markers. Such finer distinctions should therefore be incorporated into future versions of RST. Comparison and contrast markers (see Table 3.3) are SLDMs which allow the writer to point out similarities or differences between entities or ideas discussed in the previous and the ensuing discourse. In terms of RST both comparison and contrast are multi-nuclear relations. That is, the situations related by a comparison marker or a contrast marker are understood as (a) identical in at least some respects, (b) similar or different in a few respects and (c) are compared with respect to one or more of these similarities or differences (Mann and Thompson 1988:278). Similar relations are established by first-level markers such as likewise, equally and similarly . Concession markers (see Table 3.4) alert readers to a reversal in Table 3.3 Comparison and contrast markers English examples French examples German examples The same can be said for Où s’arrête…et où commence…? Hier hören die Gemeinsamkeiten auf. So with Compare this…with/to Analogously Même remarque sur/ pour Entsprechendes gilt für… Im gleichen Atemzug sind It is one thing…It is another… Il en va autrement de …zu nennen.
< previous page
page_88
next page >
< previous page
page_89
Page 89 Table 3.4 Concession markers English examples It would be a mistake (to +inf.)
French examples En admettant que… encore faut-il que…
[Although] it could be argued…, it is also worth remembering that…
…, direz-vous. Nous répondons que… on aura beau constater …, on ne sera pas pour
…[though] it is conceded that…
autant autorisé a (+inf.) si…, il faut bien voir que (NP), oui, mais(NP)
next page > German examples Nun wird man einwenden, dass… Dem kann aber folgendes entgegengehalten werden: … Bei nur oberflächlichem Hinsehen… Zunächst ist es vielleicht verwunderlich, dass…
[though] it is sometimes said that… on inspection perspective or result despite an adverse or promising condition which was mentioned or implied in the previous discourse. In traditional terms, we might say that a proposition P holds, implying the expectation of X, while on the other hand Q holds which implies not-X, contrary to the expectation induced by P (Grote et al. 1997:95). In terms of RST, concession can be described as a relation involving the following constraints: constraints on nucleus (N): writer (W) has positive regard for the situation presented in N constraints on satellite (S): W is not claiming that the situation presented in S doesn’t hold constraints on the N+S combination: writer acknowledges a potential or apparent incompatibility between the situations presented in N and S; W regards the situations presented in N and S as compatible; recognizing that the compatibility between the situations presented in N and S increases R’s positive regard for the situation presented in N the effect: R’s positive regard for the situation presented in N is increased. (Mann and Thompson 1988:254) The category of concession markers includes markers introducing the nucleus as well as markers introducing the satellite. It is quite common for nucleus and satellite markers to enter into high-probability long-distance collocations (see p. 103). Related first-level markers, which often co-occur with the SLDMs in question, are but, howeυer, although, yet, etc. Exemplifiers (see Table 3.5) belong to a set of devices of which the first-level marker for example is the paradigm. Exemplifiers and exemplification will be discussed in greater detail in Section 4.1. Explainers (see Table 3.6) are so named because they allow the writer to provide an explanation for a statement made in the previous discourse. That is, they refer to moves by the writer to supply additional information
< previous page
page_89
next page >
< previous page Page 90 Table 3.5 Exemplifiers English examples as with To paint an extreme example, consider As an example For the sake of illustration Table 3.6 Explainers English examples This is because The explanation seems to be that
next page >
page_90 French examples Soit: Prenons un seul exemple. Pour prendre un exemple adjectival Qu’il suffise de citer French examples Expliquons-nous. On peut en donner l’illustration suivante.
German examples Zur Illustration des eben Ausgeführten stehen… Dazu folgende Beispiele: Vergegenwärtigen wir uns dies am Beispiel des… German examples Dies ergibt sich daraus, dass Dies läßt sich dadurch erklären, dass
Let us now see why Table 3.7 Definers English examples French examples German examples An X is a Y such that… Le X est un Y si l’on a: X meint Y Narrowly defined by this is meant for want of a better term (we Disons donc, avec [name], que X gelten begrifflich shall use) Il est d’usage en TALN de als parler de ESF liegt vor, wenn Let X denote Y Let P1 be…Let P2 be intended to help the reader form a fuller understanding of, or comprehend the reasons for, a situation presented in the previous discourse. In terms of RST, explainers usually introduce the satellite of an evidence or a justify relation, where the reader’s comprehension of the satellite increases, respectively, his belief of the nucleus or his readiness to accept the writer’s right to present the nucleus (Mann and Thompson 1988:251–252). It is noteworthy that, with this group, there are no first-level markers representing the paradigm. Definers (see Table 3.7) introduce definitions, terminology or theorems. In terms of RST, they may signal several different restatement relations (Mann and Thompson 1988:277) between two stretches of text: identity (X is equal to Y in one or more respects), difference (X is different from Y in one or more respects), inclusion/exclusion (X can be defined in terms of the superordinate notion Y) and process (X arises
< previous page
page_90
next page >
< previous page
page_91
next page >
Page 91 from, or is caused by, Y; Marco 1999). Sometimes these types are mixed in the one definition. Enumerators (see Table 3.8) indicate that a stretch of text is to be viewed as an item in a total or series. They may do so prospectively, thus performing an additive function (beyond this), or retrospectively, thus signalling a text boundary (this is only part of the picture). One-word counterparts of these SLDMs include first(ly), also, and . In terms of RST, we are dealing with a list relation. Summarizers and concluders (see Table 3.9) may be seen as a subcategory of enumerators. They serve either to introduce the last item in a series or to conclude such a series or list. In terms of RST, summarizers such as alles in allem encode a summary relation, where the nucleus must be more than one unit whose content is restated by a satellite which is smaller in scope than the nucleus (Mann and Thompson 1988:277). Concluders such as a final point can introduce a variety of relations, depending on their specific semantic content, but the most common is the list relation. Inferrers (see Table 3.10) provide transition from one or more statements considered as true to another, the truth of which is believed to follow from the former. Typical one-word inferrers include thus and therefore . Inferrers receive in-depth treatment in Section 4.3. Table 3.8 Enumerators English examples French examples German examples (First) we should consider Signalons (enfin) Oder aber Beyond this Pour commencer Damit ist…noch nicht erschöpft. Or again Reste… This is only part of the picture. Enfin et surtout Autre illustration: Es ließe sich hinzufügen, dass One (point/reason/ factor) is that Inutile d’ajouter que It should be added that Table 3.9 Summarizers and concluders English examples French examples German examples A final point: Une dernière remarque sur Alles in allem: It remains for me (+to-inf.) Nous terminons en indiquant Bleibt letztens noch… Zusammengefaßt: In conclusion, I would say that Il nous reste a (+inf.) Der vorliegende Abschnitt ergab Such instances could be multiplied. To round off this picture
< previous page
page_91
next page >
< previous page
page_92
next page >
Page 92 Table 3.10 Inferrers English examples French examples German examples So it turns out that Il ressort de ce qui précède que Das Gesagte bedeutet, dass We conclude that This is not to imply that Il découle de ces constatations que Wir entnehmen daraus, dass It follows from this that It is clear from the foregoing that C’est dire que Aus diesen The corollary of this is that On peut en conclure que Vorbemerkungen ergibt sich bereits Table 3.11 Cause and reason markers English examples French examples German examples A number of factors account for Deux raisons à cela Pourquoi? Pour deux Dies vielleicht der Grund dafür, this. raisons… dass There are two main reasons for Es spricht einiges dafür, dass this. This is because… Der Grund liegt darin, dass Cause and reason markers (see Table 3.11), as their name implies, link two stretches of text, one of which is to be perceived as (explaining) the cause of, or reason for, the other. In terms of RST, this can usually be described as a non-volitional cause relation, where the following constraints obtain: constraints on N: presents a situation that is not a volitional action constraints on the N+S combination: S presents a situation that, by means other than motivating a volitional action, caused the situation presented in N; without the presentation of S, R might not know the particular cause of the situation; a presentation of N is more central than S to W’s purposes in putting forth the N−S combination. (Mann and Thompson 1988:275) Alternatively, a non-volitional result relation may obtain: constraints on S: presents a situation that is not a volitional action constraints on the N+S combination: N presents a situation that caused the situation presented in S; presentation of N is more central to W’s purposes in putting forth the N−S combination than is the presentation of S. (Mann and Thompson 1988:275–276)
< previous page
page_92
next page >
< previous page
page_93
next page >
Page 93 Announcers (see Table 3.12) share a range of behaviour in preparing the reader for the next step in the author’s exposition or reasoning (I will now briefly describe), or indicate topic shifts (consideration of…must be left until…). The category also includes items used to signal discourse goals (my purpose is) . In terms of RST, the discourse preceded by the announcer (N) and the ensuing discourse (S) stand in an elaboration relation, where ‘S presents additional detail about the situation or some element of subject matter which is presented in N or inferentially accessible in N’ (Mann and Thompson 1988:273). Topic initiators (see Table 3.13) are so called because they initiate a new (sub)topic in the current text. They might equally well be referred to as topic shifters, since topic initiation usually involves topic shift, with the exception of text beginnings. In terms of RST, this is another example of an elaboration relation. Excluders (see Table 3.14) indicate that a point mentioned in the previous discourse might be elaborated upon, but that such elaboration is inappropriate or impossible in the subsequent discourse, or indeed within the framework of the current study. Since these items signal a rather complex discourse operation, the SLDMs in this category have no one-word equivalents. This relation seems to have escaped the attention of RST theorists. Table 3.12 Announcers English examples French examples German examples I will now briefly describe Je propose de passer en Im vorliegenden Aufsatz wird Consideration of…must be left until… revue argumentiert, dass Nous verrons que Es soll gezeigt werden …, a point discussed separately below Nous esquissons cidessousIch möchte hier… untersuchen… Before proceeding Bevor wir uns… zuwenden Meantime (it should be understood that) my purpose is Table 3.13 Topic initiators (or topic shifters) English examples French examples German examples It is often said that Abordons maintenant Womit wir bei…wären. Now consider Première remarque: Das führt unmittelbar zu/ auf Turning to Il est temps de (+inf.) The moment will now have been reached where Passons à Es wird häufig gesagt, dass
< previous page
page_93
next page >
< previous page
page_94
next page >
Page 94 Digression markers (see Table 3.15) signal that the writer is about to stray from the main topic. They may be regarded as a subgroup of topic initiators. Here too we may speak of an elaboration relation (see p. 20). The high frequency and habitual co-presence of question and answer markers (see Table 3.16) reflect the dialogic nature of much academic text, engaging the writer in an exchange with herself as well as with the reader. Answer markers are often realized as zero connectors, but may also be spelled out. Question markers may also be made more or less implicit by means of a bare question mark; this is less frequent in English and German than in French. In terms of RST, we are dealing with a solutionhood relation, where the satellite presents a problem whose solution is presented in the nucleus (Mann and Thompson 1988:272). Table 3.14 Excluders English examples French examples German examples Space limitations preclude … Excluons toutefois le cas Auf…kann und möchte ich hier nicht de… eingehen. We have space enough to mention only a Nous n’insisterons pas sur Aus Platzgründen… few. La place nous manque pour Es ist hier jedoch nicht der This is not the place Ort (+inf.) I will here restrict myself to (+V−ing) Ce n’est pas le lieu de Ich beschränke mich hier auf Ici, bornons-nous à Sans entrer dans le détail Es bleibt späteren Arbeiten vorbehalten,… de… Table 3.15 Digression markers English examples French examples German examples It should be mentioned in Notons au passage que Zur Vermeidung möglichen passing that… Soit dit en passant consider, for a digressive A propos de…, nous aimerions ouvrir une Mißverständnisses sei bemerkt, dass dies page or two,… incidentally parenthèse directement reliée à notre sujet nur am Rande nebenbei bemerkt Table 3.16 Question and answer markers English examples French examples German examples The question then arises: Question: …—so bleibt am Schluß zu fragen. How, then, may we explain …? Le tout est de savoir si Pourquoi? Warum aber, so wird man sich fragen,… The next obvious question is La question qui se pose alors est: Die zentrale Frage ist The answer may lie in… Die Antwort dürfte lauten:
< previous page
page_94
next page >
< previous page
page_95
next page >
Page 95 Emphasizers (see Table 3.17) draw the reader’s attention to a salient or unexpected aspect of the topic under discussion. Emphasizers such as on inspection may be said to have dual category membership, as they often occur in concessive structures. They may signal several different RST relations, including elaboration, contrast and concession (see p. 20). Informers (see Table 3.18) serve to introduce new information; they are based around verbs of saying and perceiving or related nouns (point, mot, Wort). They are closely related to topic initiators, enumerators and summarizers/concluders, and may signal the same relations as the latter. Clarification markers (see Table 3.19) may be considered a subcategory of informers or emphasizers whose primary function is to clarify the meaning or purpose of a particular text span. They usually encode restatement or elaboration relations (see p. 20). Any academic writer wishes to gain acceptance for the ideas, arguments or findings presented in her text, and one of the ways to achieve such acceptance, is by using suggestors. Suggestors (see Table 3.20) allow writers to present a message in such a way that it appears self-evident and incontestably true, the expectation being that the reader will take it on trust. They often encode evidence or justify relations (see p. 20). Suggestors will be given pride of place in Siepmann (forthcoming). As their names suggest, hypothesis and model markers (see Table 3.21) are used to introduce the formulation of a hypothesis or to mark the Table 3.17 Emphasizers English examples French examples German examples It must be noted that Encore faut-il remarquer Bemerkenswert erscheint, dass It must be emphasized that note que that/Note NP Notons que Man beachte, dass Notice (also/for example) that/Notice NP Voyons la chose de plus Es verdient schließlich noch betont zu werden, près. dass Contrast NP Il faut être bien conscient Compare…, noting… on inspection que bei genauem Zusehen (my emphases) Précisons que (c’est moi qui précise) Table 3.18 Informers English examples French examples German examples It should be recognized that Pour information, retenons que Dazu ist festzustellen, dass A first point is that Un mot sur la terminologie Es ist noch anzumerken, dass Schließlich sei noch Trois points à dégager: darauf hingewiesen, dass
< previous page
page_95
next page >
< previous page
page_96
next page >
Page 96 Table 3.19 Clarification markers English examples French examples German examples But that is not the point. Soyons bien clair. Um es in aller The (key) point is that Entendons: Deutlichkeit zu sagen: im Klartext: Table 3.20 Suggestors English examples French examples German examples One thing is certain: Il est sûr que Manches deutet darauf hin, It will be readily seen that Il va sans dire que rien n’est dass It is fair to say that a moment’s reflection moins sûr Die Erfahrung spricht dafür, suggests that Force est de constater que dass it is widely accepted that On comprend mal comment Es ist ohne weiteres einsichtig, dass Table 3.21 Hypothesis and model markers English examples French examples German examples It is a fair guess that On peut supposer que Es steht zu vermuten, dass I hypothesized that Supposons que Die Hypothese ist, dass Suppose that Soit Davon ausgehend, dass Assume that Wir nehmen an, dass Let us say that Die Vermutung liegt nahe, dass Let us imagine that beginning of a sequence in which a hypothetical situation will be described or a model set up. The most common relations cued by these markers are background and condition: Background constraints on N: R won’t comprehend N sufficiently before reading text of S constraints on the N+S combination: S increases the ability of R to comprehend an element in N. (Mann and Thompson 1988:273) Condition constraints on S: S presents a hypothetical, future or otherwise unrealized situation (relative to the situational context of S) constraints on the N+S combination: realization of the situation presented in N depends on realization of that presented in S. (Mann and Thompson 1988:276)
< previous page
page_96
next page >
< previous page
page_97
next page >
Page 97 Restrictors (see Table 3.22) are so called because they indicate a restric tion. More specifically, they signal that the stretch of discourse to which they refer reduces the ambit, or the significance, of either the preceding or the subsequent discourse. Common lexicalized restrictors include but, howeυer, anyway, in any case or at least, to name but a few English examples. This category has been given detailed consideration in Siepmann (2001a). Referrers and attributors (see Table 3.23) allow writers to mark material that is not their own and to attribute it to its source. Referrers, frequently appearing in footnotes, guide the reader towards a more extended discussion of a point just raised (for full details, see), whereas attributors (Meyer bemerkt) signal a citation, either reproducing in part or full one or more source texts, or summarizing the work of one or more fellow academics. Depending on the textual purpose of the reference, a wide variety of RST relations may be encoded by these markers. Reformulators and resumers (see Table 3.24) serve to reword the lexical content of a text span. The reformulation does not normally provide Table 3.22 Restrictors English examples French examples German examples To further confound the picture Un autre problème concerne Erschwerend kommt hinzu, dass To make matters worse Complication Noch schwerer wiegt, dass An allowance has to be made for supplémentaire, il y a un autre Einschränkend sei angemerkt, dass A further problem is that inconvénient à ce que A word of caution may be in order une réserve, néanmoins nous regrettons about que A word of warning about Table 3.23 Referrers and attributors English examples French examples German examples [name] argues [name] affirme que [name] hat darauf as [name] writes comme dit (excellemment) [name] hingewiesen, dass, so it has been seen that argumentieren [names] it has been proposed that [name] écrit ceci: , dit-il, nous renvoyons es ist bereits darauf verwiesen we briefly mentioned sur ce point à worden, dass [name] bemerkt: it was argued by historians that for full details, see some further pour une plus ample discussion de…, voir in Anlehnung an [name] consideration of…can be found in en nous inspirant de [name], disons im Anschluß an [name] following X borrowing from X Comme le précise [name]
< previous page
page_97
next page >
< previous page
page_98
next page >
Page 98 Table 3.24 Reformulators and resumers English examples French examples Put another way, Pour le dire en d’autres In other words termes In the [Marxist] idiom Tel [name] avouant To put it crudely , avons-nous dit also called j’ai cité précédemment as discussed revenons à to recapitulate: ainsi qu’il est dit plus haut rappelons que
German examples Anders ausgedrückt: Mit den Worten von [name] Grob gesprochen Wie eingangs dargestellt Von…war…die Rede. Um kurz zu rekapitulieren Erinnern wir daran, dass identical content; rather, it tends to provide additional information with a view to enhancing the reader’s understanding of the writer’s intended meaning. Reformulators will be given detailed consideration in Section 4.2. 3.4 Points of interest At least three points of interest emerge from this taxonomy of SLDMs. One is that the boundaries between some types of SLDM are quite fluid, so that some items may be said to have multiple category membership. The second point is that some SLDMs are functionally and semantically close to first-level markers, whereas others bear no such resemblance. A third point to note is the existence of lexical dependencies between markers, sometimes stretching over some considerable distance. Let us consider each of these points in turn. 3.4.1 Multiple category membership Discourse marker functions are neither totally discrete nor autonomous, any more than the meanings of individual words are. Indeed, it is by no means uncommon for SLDMs to have dual, triple or even quadruple category membership. The most obvious manifestation of this can be seen in strings of the type it is shown/said/argued that, which can be used as topic initiators, concession markers, suggestors, referrers and attributors (cf. Oakey 2002a). A few additional examples will make the dimensions of this phenomenon clearer. In the first example, explanatory and enumerative SLDMs have been combined to produce the plain, step-by-step reasoning typical of analytical and discursive French prose: Certes, bien des pères de l’Eglise rejettent les auteurs païens, comme inutiles et dangereux; mais ils admettent la langue et la rhétorique des païens…Pourquoi? Pour deux raisons. La première est que l’Eglise, dans son rôle missionnaire et dans ses
< previous page
page_98
next page >
< previous page
page_99
next page >
Page 99 polémiques, ne pouvait se passer de la rhétorique, pas plus que de la langue… La seconde raison est que la Bible elle-même est profondément rhétorique. Ne foisonne-t-elle pas en métaphores, allégories, jeux de mots, antithèses, argumentations, autant sinon plus que les textes grecs? (CAF) Enumerators and informers may also be mixed in the one SLDM; witness the following example: What makes one translation more ‘successful’ than another, how can the analytic apparatus developed in this book, together with the model for which it is to operate, embracing the concepts and distinctions discussed above, in fact give us an assessment of translation quality? A first point is that there is no scientific basis for determining that a given source text requires a translation of the one kind or the other by virtue of its status, function, content or anything else. (CAE) Other amalgams do not require lengthy exemplification. It is immediately obvious that markers such as le parallèle s’arrête là/da hören die Gemeinsamkeiten auf function simultaneously as enumerators, contrast markers and topic initiators. Similarly, exemplifiers such as on pourrait multiplier les exemples may equally well be described as topic concluders. Referrers and announcers may also be mixed in the one phrase: described below are, as may topic initiators and announcers: in this article I discuss. Equally plain is the combination of enumeration and exemplification in such phrases as autre illustration. Concluders and informers are also often combined: pour clore cette réflexion+un mot de terminologie; en résumé+on peut dire que . The same holds true for the relationship between concluders and exemplifiers: pour terminer sur ce point+υoici deux autres exemples. Multiple category membership can probably best be accounted for in terms of prototype theory (Rosch 1973; Moon 1987; Aitchison 1994), an explanation of the way in which extensional meanings are represented in the mental lexicon. Prototype theory argues that the mental lexicon categorizes words into groups on the basis of a range of typicality criteria. This makes it relatively easy to decide on prototypes of particular classes of nouns, while still allowing the linguist to account for peripheral category members. Thus, the thrush would count as a prototype of bird; the ostrich and the penguin, although unable to fly, would count as peripheral exemplars of the category since they exhibit other bird-like features. Similar considerations apply to multi-word combinations such as SLDMs. Assuming the key feature of an exemplifier is that it introduces a fact, incident, quotation, etc. that illustrates, or forms a particular case of, the situation described in the previous discourse, then the exemplifier an
< previous page
page_99
next page >
< previous page
page_100
next page >
Page 100 example is proυided by is a prototypical case: in any context imaginable, the use of the exemplifier will invariably fit the definition. The same cannot be said, for example, of the imperative see, although it may well assume an exemplificatory function. See can only introduce quotations or citations, thus fulfilling only part of the defining criteria. 3.4.2 Collocation of first-leυel and second-level markers The broad taxonomy presented above suggests that a basic distinction can be established between those discourse markers that are semantically related to first-level markers and those that are not. For example, as shown in Siepmann (2001a), multi-word restrictors introducing an adverse point such as a complication is that are closely related to the function of such one-word restrictors as but or however . On the other hand, a moment’s reflection shows that such items as topic initiators (it is often said that, turning to) serve highly specific functions unrelated to those of first-level connectors. A detailed comparison of the relations cued by first-level and second-level markers requires prior studies of both types of marker. What can be said at this stage in our investigation is that there are preferred combinations of firstlevel markers with SLDMs. This implies that the two types of marker have differing but complementary functions; witness the following French examples: précisons que+néanmoins mentionnons+ici notons+encore ajoutons seulement ici que soulignons+toutefois rappelons+en effet on sait+en effet force est de constater que+cependant toute la question est de savoir+donc il est clair que+cependant The random listing above is based on a wealth of corpus evidence suggesting that combinations of one-word and second-level markers are the more likely the more specific the function of the SLDM is: in other words, that said and howeυer combine less frequently than it should be borne in mind and howeυer because the former are functionally closer than the latter. 3.4.3 Lexical dependencies between SLDMs and implications for the idiom principle Apart from collocations between first-level and second-level markers, there exist lexical dependencies between different types of SLDMs. The
< previous page
page_100
next page >
< previous page
page_101
next page >
Page 101 restrictor with this in mind, for example, co-occurs significantly with topic initiators such as let us turn to, let us revisit or I now come to, as illustrated in the following example: If the subject matter exists, it must be true. Therefore, every utterance is true since it *names* its subject matter. The relation between these two problems should be evident. If we can resolve how it is possible to speak of negated or non-existent referents, then the problem of falsehood should become manageable. With this in mind, let us turn to Pelletier’s and Denyer’s treatment of the problems. (CAE) Likewise c’est-à-dire collocates with en l’occurrence and its variants en l’espèce and en la circonstance. These variants act to restrict the scope of the intensional definition provided: le commentateur applique à son corpus les critères de rationalité que lui-même tient pour les plus appropriés en philosophie, c’est-à-dire en l’occurrence ceux-là mêmes qui ont cours dans les discussions actuelles de la philosophie analytique. (CAF) In parallel fashion, SLDMs may enter into collocation with other word classes. The reformulator υoire is a case in point; it forms a strong collocation with the adverbs carrément, franchement and tout court: Des artistes contemporains majeurs, appartenant notamment à l’école de Paris, sont sous-représentés, voire carrément absents. (NF) This kind of collocational pattern, of which further evidence will be adduced in Chapter 4, has so far gone more or less unnoticed. This is probably because previous work on collocation (e.g. Hausmann et al. 1989; Sinclair 1991:109– 122; Howarth 1996; Scherfer 2001) has narrowly focused on the co-occurrence of single words belonging to a restricted range of word classes (usually nouns, verbs, adjectives and adverbs) rather than multi-word units. It is my contention that, as corpora grow, evidence will accumulate of lexical dependencies between text spans from the single word to the sentence. This will entail a stronger version of the idiom principle posited by Sinclair, whereby ‘the choice of one word affects the choice of others in its vicinity’ (Sinclair 1991:173). This new version will have to make allowances for what we might term ‘collocational combinations’, stating that ‘the choice of one word or phraseological unit affects the choice of other words or phraseological units in their vicinity’. Other evidence from this study necessitates an even more radical widening of the idiom principle’s scope, for the lexical dependencies in question manifest themselves not only between immediately adjacent items, but also over greater distances. A convenient illustration is provided
< previous page
page_101
next page >
< previous page
page_102
next page >
Page 102 by the topic initiator turning to, which is commonly followed at some distance by informers such as I/we+find/see/note or it appears that: Turning to the use of semi-auxiliary is to/are to in if -clauses, we find that a fifth of the instances in the sample (and 1340 in the corpus as a whole) appear in this syntactic environment. (CAE) In this respect the speech of younger British speakers appears to be following the lead of American English. Turning to the speech of older speakers, we note some words which are suggestive of hesitation, uncertainty or turn manipulation: well, mm, er. (CAE) The corresponding Middle High German forms are fuoss, füesse; mus, müse . Modern German Fuss: Füsse, Maus: Mäuse are the regular developments of these medieval forms. Turning to Anglo-Saxon, we find that our modern English forms correspond to fot, fet; mus, mys. (CAE) Turning to requirements involving both age plus service, it appears there has been an increase in the propensity of participants to have normal retirement available at age 62 with a combination of years of service. (CAE) A similar phenomenon can be observed with the marker of comparison any more than. This marker, which introduces a subordinate clause, is always preceded by the negative particle not in the main clause: Not all women are ‘carers’ any more than all women are Victims’ or ‘contractors’. (CAE) Such examples could be multiplied; they force us to recognize that, in order to account for at least some collocational links, it is necessary to abandon the four-word span on either side of the node which Sinclair (1991) postulates as the cut-off point for collocational significance. The idiom principle must therefore be further revised to accommodate ‘long-distance’ collocations entered by SLDMs. I therefore propose the following restatement of the idiom principle for written text: One of the main principles of the organization of text is that the choice of one word or phraseological unit affects the choice of other words or phraseological units, usually within a maximum span of several paragraphs. Collocation is one of the patterns of mutual choice, and idiom is another. (based on Sinclair 1991:173) This reformulation of the idiom principle also takes account of cases
< previous page
page_102
next page >
< previous page
page_103
next page >
Page 103 where there is a great deal of variation among the node and the collocate(s). One typical case is the collocation of the contrast marker not so with lexical items such as surely, seem, appear, you/one might think that, it was hoped that or one hears that: Volkswagen, which now owns 70 per cent of the Czech company, would have thought the Skoda’s identity problematic. Not so. VW sees Skoda as one of the most recognized brand names in advertising. (NE) After recriminations last summer, when a number of big trading houses were accused—nothing was ever proved—of the Stock Exchange had nipped things in the forcing the FTSE 100 higher ahead of options expiry dates, bud. Not so. Yesterday afternoon, after a solid if unspectacular morning’s business, shares in some of the biggest Footsie companies—the ones heavily weighted in the premier index—motored sharply upwards. (NE) Regulators and providers ought to be kept apart. Not so. according to the NRA’s board—and to Lord Crickhowell, who insists that water management and regulation are inextricably linked. (NE) So when some 100,000 demonstrators clogged the streets of the capital, Minsk, on April 10th to support striking industrial workers and to protest against price rises, it as if discontent had come out of the blue. Not so: beneath the surface the republic had been stirring for months. (NE) Here one might make a case for the collocation of underlying rhetorical strategies rather than strings of words. This would be correct to the extent that the discourse preceding not so sets up an expectation which is not fulfilled in the subsequent discourse. In actual fact, however, rhetorical strategy and use of lexis are two sides of the same linguistic coin. Language users make communicative choices, and such choices are inextricably linked with particular lexical material; indeed, it would be difficult to say which was historically prior: the strategy or the lexical pattern associated with it. Not surprisingly, the ‘expectation’ part of the above pattern may also be found in nominal form; in the following example from an academic text, you might think has been converted to the more formal noun misconception: Another about meditation is that the meditator should fall into a trance. Not so. As a famous Chinese Buddhist put it: There is a class of foolish people who sit quietly and try to keep their minds blank…(CAE)
< previous page
page_103
next page >
< previous page
page_104
next page >
Page 104 A more complex realization of a long-distance collocational pattern is seen in the following extract: But if one considers that in college dictionaries the average number of column-lines allotted to each entry (not each definition) is a bit less than two, one will see why space is at a premium. (CAE) In the present case the collocational relationship holds between two types of SLDM which occur in, respectively, the main clause and the subclause of a complex sentence: the topic shifter (if) one considers (+wh-clause/NP) and the suggestor one will see (+wh-clause/NP). Again, it is not so much the lexical items themselves which enter into collocation; rather, we are dealing with a recurrent type of semantic-functional relationship, where both the second and the first part of the collocation may be replaced by other lexical items. A few more examples follow: If one considers that the various paths do not exist except as perceived by some mind, then one immediately arrives at the conclusion that the probability of a path should be chosen proportionally to its algorithmic information. (CAE) If we consider the nature of Christian persecution as it is currently understood, we can easily see how the personal attitudes of the presiding official could have been a significant factor in any particular trial. (CAE) If, however, one reads the early dramas of Augustus Thomas and Clyde Fitch, it will be realized how dexterously the American playwright profited by the French technician in whom the commercial manager had faith. (CAE) French concession markers, too, are evidence of lexical dependencies operating across considerable spans of text. Thus, the concessive en admettant que tends to pre-empt the choice of an adversative marker such as pourtant, encore faut-il que or le fait demeure que . R.-L.Wagner (1968), qui note que le «terme de “mot” en est venu assez tard en français à traduire la notion d’une unité lexicale autonome», tout en admettant le bien-fondé de l’analyse qu’A. Martinet fait de la notion de «mot», refuse pourtant d’abandonner ce terme parce que la lexicologie porte sur l’étude des signes en situation. (CAF) The uncovering of such patterns is of great value for language teaching. Just as lexico-grammars (Francis et al. 1996, 1998) have illustrated the close links between word complementation and meaning, so future text grammars may reveal the collocational nature of specific rhetorical moves. In providing a detailed picture of the associations between language func-
< previous page
page_104
next page >
< previous page
page_105
next page >
Page 105 tions and SLDMs, the present study is a first step towards such a view of rhetoric. Apart from the rhetorical relations which will be discussed in Chapter 4, consider the following examples of long-distance collocations. The first set of examples illustrates a particular kind of concessive relationship, where a distinction is made between the results of a superficial vs. a thoroughgoing analysis: On first impression, it might be thought that heredity is a primary cause of disease; but on further consideration it becomes apparent that it is an effect and not a primary cause. (CAE) Grünbaum’s judgment of Freud as a scientist contrasts interestingly with Sulloway’s. On first blush, one might expect Grünbaum and Sulloway to adopt similar positions. After all, both approach Freud from a scientific perspective, Grünbaum as a philosopher of science, Sulloway as a historian of science. But instead they offer radically opposite views of Freud’s scientific credentials. (CAE) At first sight, the approach of Part V appears quite radical, entitling the public to wander freely over upland areas. Upon closer examination. however, it will be seen that it operates negatively rather than positively. (CAE) The second set of examples concerns cases where the author wishes to give a particular subject limited treatment only. In French, the relevant patterns are often introduced by sans+INF; the main clause which follows may start with a topic marker or an exclusion marker realized as an imperative or a verb of the present or future tense groups: Sans nous attarder à discuter de ces questions techniques, bornonsnous à rappeler ici que la face décorée d’un miroir—généralement gravée, quelquefois, on l’a dit, moulée en relief—constitue évidem-ment le revers de l’objet. (CAF) Sans anticiper ici sur l’article étendu que nous consacrerons dans cet ouvrage à la langue sanscrite, nous ferons remarquer que le sanscrit n’est pas, comme on le croit trop généralement la souche des langues indo-européennes; c’est tout au plus une branche collatérale (pour la période védique). (CAF) Sans nous étendre outre mesure sur le chapitre des interprétations ésotériques, nous ajouterons quelques exemples à ceux que nous avons déjà signalés ici ou là. (CAF) Again, the list of such examples could be lengthened. They all illustrate the density and conformity of lexical patterning in text.
< previous page
page_105
next page >
< previous page
page_106
next page >
Page 106 4 Straddling cultures Three types of second-level discourse markers in contrastive perspective I do not expect that my treatment of words, especially difficult words, will strike other people as that which they should have adopted…the most that can be expected is ‘this is not an unreasonable way of exhibiting the facts’. J.A.H.Murray, editor of the first edition of the Oxford English Dictionary The preceding chapter has afforded a bird’s-eye view of different categories of SLDMs. My hope is that the taxonomy presented there has cleared the ground for much future research, as it would clearly be beyond the scope of the present study to describe in high-resolution detail more than a small segment of this vast area. Thus, turning away from the panoramic perspective, we now zoom in on just three major categories. Section 4.1 deals with exemplifiers, Section 4.2 with reformulators and Section 4.3 with inferrers.1 The chapter is rounded off by Section 4.4, which reviews some major themes emerging from the analysis. Each category will receive near-exhaustive treatment in terms of its lexis, based on the evidence from the full-size academic corpora and my manual searches. SLDMs will be subcategorized according to translation equivalence; while all SLDMs belonging to one category are more or less equivalent across languages, those that bear the closest similarities of function will be ascribed to the same (sub)category. The lexical items belonging to each (sub)category appear in tabular form at the beginning of the relevant sections. Where feasible, two types of quantitative data have been incorporated into the relevant tables and the subsequent discussion. 1 A ranking of the relevant SLDMs by frequency of use in the parallel academic corpora (PCAE, PCAF, PCAG). Apart from its obvious linguistic—especially lexicographic—benefits, such a ranking can help guide the design of academic writing courses and materials by providing a rigorous basis for the selection of language items to be taught. Note that the ranking has to be established by a succession of automatic and manual analysis. For example, not all the instances of a
< previous page
page_106
next page >
< previous page
page_107
next page >
Page 107 collocation such as giυe+example serve the pragmatic and/or text-structuring function which is a defining feature of SLDMs. The collocation may also occur in contexts where it serves to report the actions of other authors (e.g. he gives a number of interesting examples); such occurrences have to be discarded manually. 2 A comparison of the overall frequency of each SLDM type across languages using the three parallel corpora (PCAE, PCAF, PCAG). From these data, too, pedagogic benefit may be drawn insofar as they alert materials designers and teachers to the possibility of over-use or under-use of particular SLDMs by authors from particular linguistic backgrounds (see Part II). More importantly, however, these data enable us to determine with relative certainty whether one linguaculture shows a greater partiality for such phrases than another. Such quantitative analysis could have been taken further by comparing frequency of occurrence within particular disciplines such as law, linguistics, philosophy and economics. However, I found in a pre-test that I was unable to build up sub-corpora that were large enough to produce fully reliable results. For example, I selected one million words at random from each of the disciplines just named and then proceeded to search for a set of English exemplifiers containing the imperatives take and consider (see Group 1 on pp. 118–123 for examples); this yielded the results shown in Table 4.1. It should be evident that there are too few instances to warrant definitive judgements on the markers involved; for instance, it would be absurd to claim on the basis of these data that linguists fail to use, or at least under-use such markers. The quantitative analysis is followed by a discussion of the structure and functions of the SLDMs in question. With the most complex categories it seemed wise to follow a stepwise approach proceeding from monolingual analysis to multilingual comparison, thus allowing the reader to form a just understanding of the rationale behind particular equivalences. Where equivalence relations turned out to be more straightforward, discussion will move directly to the multilingual comparison. Before proceeding, two preliminary questions need answering. First, it may be useful to look at previous research on cross-cultural variation in discourse marker use. Second, some clarification is needed concerning the choice of categories. Let us deal with these two issues in sequence. Table 4.1 Frequency of exemplifiers containing take and consider in various sub-corpora Economics Law Linguistics Philosophy 5 4 0 7
< previous page
page_107
next page >
< previous page
page_108
next page >
Page 108 Most cross-cultural studies are silent on the subject of discourse marker use, but a few contain relevant findings. Vinay and Darbelnet (1958:222ff.) were the first to conduct a brief investigation into the use of connectors in English and French, concluding that French, at least in its literary, philosophical, scientific and legal varieties, is particularly fond of these structural markers, and finds it difficult to manage without the additional information they provide about the unfolding of the author’s thought processes. By contrast, English, even in its classical forms, is much less dependent on these explicit connectors and instead relies on the juxtaposition of sentences and text segments, leaving it to the readers to provide for themselves the necessary connections. (Vinay and Darbelnet 1958:222; my translation) Although experienced translators would probably confirm Vinay and Darbelnet’s observations, these lacked the empirical rigour of later studies which introduced frequency counts.2 Thus, Clyne (1987), in a contrastive analysis of English and German sociological and linguistic journal articles, finds a relative paucity of advance organizers in texts by German academics. Since most advance organizers belong to the class of SLDMs, this is highly relevant to the present study. According to Clyne (1987:229), Germans tend to place advance organizers in somewhat obscure locations, ‘almost as if to express embarrassment about this formal adherence to the conventions of an international journal’, whereas English authors place them at or near the beginning of their texts and are thus able to make up for potential non-linearity. Similar considerations apply to definitions, many of which are based on SLDMs. Clyne shows that English academics are more likely than their German colleagues to define technical terms, and also to place their definitions near the start of their texts. The perceived difference may, however, be due to different definitions of the term ‘definition’ itself, as Stolze and Deppert (1998) point out. In the humanities whole books may after all be devoted to defining complex terms such as ‘translation equivalence’. The findings on discourse markers presented in Trumpp (1998) would seem to contradict Clyne (1987). Comparing English, French and German journal articles and reviews in the field of sports science, Trumpp finds that advance organizers are used with equal frequency in the languages under investigation. The picture emerging from Hutz (1997), a microstructural and macrostructural comparison of English- and Germanlanguage articles in the field of social psychology, is a more complex one. In his English corpus he found a higher frequency of metalanguage designed to make text structuring intelligible and to aid text comprehension, whereas the
< previous page
page_108
next page >
< previous page
page_109
next page >
Page 109 German texts were found to contain a larger number of markers of logical relationships (Hutz 1997:173ff. 240–241). In Hutz’s view, this invalidates any claims to the effect that Anglo-American writers assume a higher degree of responsibility for their readers. However, as is evident from his exemplificatory list (Hutz 1997:175), Hutz gives almost exclusive consideration to lexicalized marker words such as thus, therefore, for example, ähnlich, allerdings. Although he briefly mentions Sinhaneti’s (1982) structural classification of discourse devices, which includes SLDMs, there is no indication that he has attempted to compile anything like a representative inventory of these. When he says, for instance, that within the functional category ‘exemplification’ the marker for example accounts for 95 per cent of all occurrences in the Journal of Social Psychology (Hutz 1997:181), it is immediately apparent that he disregards the huge number of SLDMs belonging to this category (see Section 4.1). This is a serious oversight; as mentioned at several points in our discussion, it is perfectly possible to have a single-word lexicalized device in one language where the other language resorts to the use of an SLDM or to other lexical means.3 My suspicion is that Hutz’s failure to take such correspondences into account may have seriously skewed his results on writer responsibility. At a broader level, it seems a moot point whether, as tacitly assumed by Hutz (1997), high frequency of logical markers can serve as a defining feature of writer responsibility in the first place. One counter-argument is the possibility of camouflaging incoherence by means of logical markers (see Blumenthal 1997:122–123). Second, there is the fact that some accomplished British and American writers, such as John D.Gallagher or Peter Grundy, make liberal use of logical and other markers, whereas others, such as Walter Nash, eschew metadiscursive words and phrases altogether. By the same token, English and American style guides differ considerably with regard to the stance taken on metatext (see also Mauranen 1993:168). Even though only psycholinguistic research could provide a definitive answer as to who is right in this debate, such facts encourage the assumption that both types of writing can have clarity and grace as long as certain other conditions obtain.4 For an impressionistic answer, compare the two paragraphs shown in Table 4.2. In the first paragraph, Nash achieves coherence simply by making every sentence depend on the topic sentence and weaving through the piece sets of conceptually related words (e.g. wrong, wrongness, false; equating-equation; policy-politic; incitement-motive; good morals-honesty). In fact, each sentence develops directly from the topic sentence and the whole is rounded off by a concluding sentence which drives home the main point. The second version follows an—arguably—cruder procedure in that it makes enumerative markers do the job of tying the text together. On the whole, it seems fair to say that both versions manage the flow of information with the same clarity of style, though the first has the
< previous page
page_109
next page >
< previous page
page_110
next page >
Page 110 Table 4.2 A comparison of paragraphs with and without metadiscourse Paragraph without metadiscourse Paragraph with metadiscourse There is something wrong with the morality of a There is something wrong about the morality of a saying like saying like ‘Honesty is the best policy’. The ‘Honesty is the best policy’. For one thing, the readiness to weigh wrongness lies in equating virtue with profit. Any virtue in the scale of calculable profit is in itself deplorable. For tolerably observant person must see that the another, there are clearly a great many occasions when being equation is false. There are countless occurrences honest not only fails to bring material reward but may even invite in life when doing what we believe to be right does suffering. Furthermore, if we encourage young people to believe not bring us material rewards. Indeed we may that they will always be materially or socially better off for being sometimes suffer for it. To offer sound policy as an honest, they will discover by experience the falsity of this claim incitement to good morals is therefore in itself and will be inclined to regard us as fools or hypocrites. All in all, dishonest. Honesty, if it requires a motive, must be it seems clear that honesty, if it requires a motive, must be valued for reasons other than politic (Nash valued for reasons other than politic (Nash 1980:13). 1980:12). additional merit of a certain quiet elegance. This goes some way towards demonstrating that the absence of logical markers need not necessarily create difficulties for the reader. It thus appears that opinion among contrastivists is divided as to marker use and its implications for clarity of style. A major shortcoming of studies dealing with these issues (e.g. Hutz 1997) has been found to lie in the neglect of second-level markers. In what follows, an attempt will therefore be made to sharpen the picture emerging from such earlier work. Frequency counts may enable us to provide further empirical evidence for Vinay and Darbelnet’s thesis that French has a pronounced partiality for marker words. Thus, a possible research question concerns the frequencies with which SLDMs are used in each of the languages under survey; an additional research question concerns the variability of marker forms in each language:5 it may well be that one language uses a limited amount of markers with greater frequency than either of the other two, while another uses a larger variety of markers with lower frequency. The question remains as to which categories to choose for closer examination. It is difficult to provide objective reasons for adopting one category for consideration rather than another. In most linguistic studies the preference would be for those items on which dictionaries and prior research are uninformative or misleading. Since SLDMs constitute more or less unexplored territory, however, this criterion would have almost equal applicability to any of the categories identified above. With this in mind, two main factors motivated my choices.
< previous page
page_110
next page >
< previous page
page_111
next page >
Page 111 1 Frequency of items in machine-readable monolingual and multilingual corpora; one of the criterial features of SLDMs identified in Chapter 2 is that they occur less frequently than first-level markers. This means that a comparatively large body of text is needed to arrive at reliable judgements on their syntactic embedding, lexical variability, etc. It has already been noted that no currently available multilingual corpus is large enough to permit sufficient pickings of most SLDMs. Until such corpora become available, it may be wise to focus on SLDMs whose high frequency allows at least some cross-checking of the results obtained from monolingual data against samples of published translations (i.e. bilingual data), a process technically known as ‘triangulation’. Such triangulation will here be employed concerning the class of reformulators (see Section 4.2). 2 Functional relatedness to first-level markers; this criterion enables comparison between first-level markers and SLDMs, with a view to answering such questions as: In what ways do SLDMs serve more specific functions than first-level markers? What does a writer gain by using an SLDM? Such comparison will open up a multitude of new avenues of research to be explored in future studies. Having settled these general issues, we can now move on to the first indepth analysis, which deals with exemplifiers. 4.1 Exemplifiers Exemplifiers are one of the most common, if not the most common, type of SLDM. They occur in any kind of discursive prose and have particular currency in humanities texts. As an object of study, however, exemplification continues to be the poor relation of other rhetorical devices. In Gülich and Kotschi’s (1987) study of reformulation, exemplification appears as a subcategory that is not accorded detailed treatment. Likewise Fuchs (1980:377), while listing a number of discoursal realizations of exemplification, views it as a subcategory of relations of identity; her corpus, composed of church sermons recorded in 1968, leads her to select fairly ephemeral and text-type-specific markers of exemplification, such as c’est in Bienheureux ceux qui pleurent (…) C’est Madeleine après son péché, c’est Monique pleurant son fils Augustin. (Fuchs 1980:377) Such neglect has led to a commonly held view in both the linguistic and the pedagogic literature that exemplification is a minor textual operation, subordinate to major discoursal stratagems such as ‘inferring’ and ‘proving’. As Coltier (1988) and Delcambre (1997) have shown, such a
< previous page
page_111
next page >
< previous page
page_112
next page >
Page 112 view is unjustified. Exemplification merits close investigation for at least three reasons: • it is a complex discoursal operation that has its place in almost any argued text • it is highly frequent in journalistic and academic texts • it poses serious difficulties for L1 and L2 learners To this we may add a fourth reason, namely that previous discussions of exemplification have failed to give due consideration to SLDMs. 4.1.1 Exemplifiers from a rhetorical perspective What exactly is the discoursal status of exemplifiers or exemplification? Questions about the definition of examples have preoccupied philosophers and linguists since Antiquity. Aristotle ( Rhetoric II, 20) viewed examples as one of the two types of oratorical argument (the other being enthymemes ), distinguishing between ‘the mention of actual past facts’ and ‘the invention of facts by the speaker’. Closer to the present day, but in a similar vein, Coltier (1988:24) found that examples serve two functions: supporting abstract knowledge and generating new knowledge. To probe a little deeper, it may be instructive to relate the modern use of the word example to its etymology. It is derived from the Latin verb eximere, ‘to take out’, so that its primary sense seems to be ‘something taken out, a sample, a specimen’ ( Oxford English Dictionary, s.v. example ). Latin rhetoricians coined the noun example to translate Greek paradeigma, which is derived from the verb deiknunai, ‘to show’ (Delcambre 1997:55). It appears that both senses, something taken out and something shown, are still alive in modern English, French and German usage. Dictionary definitions of the word example show clear similarities among these languages and provide significant clues as to the pragmatic-functional role of SLDMs containing the word example . A comparison of the OED, the Grand Robert and the Duden reveals two main senses shared by English, French and German: • ‘a fact, incident, quotation, etc. that illustrates, or forms a particular case of, a general principle, rule, state of things, etc.’ (as in ‘Could you give me an example?’) • ‘a person’s action or conduct regarded as an object of imitation (as in “set a good example”) or a thing regarded as a model’ (as in ‘a fine example of modern architecture’) Intuition tells us that the usual form taken by exemplification in academic texts is best captured in the first definition. If we translate this helpful, but still rather crude definition into RST terms we can tentatively
< previous page
page_112
next page >
< previous page
page_113
next page >
Page 113 infer that exemplifiers are markers which introduce an illustration of a general nucleus by means of a more specific satellite. Stated differently, exemplifiers put in place a paradigmatic relationship between two text spans X and Y, so that X and Y constitute the evocation of a whole and of one of its elements (see also MacNamara 1995:142). In some cases this is evident from lexical relations at the text surface: (1) Yet another difficulty associated with the handling of the cost of government is the fact that the prices at which private sector output is sold covers the taxes the private sector pays. (2) For example, the price of an automobile is higher than it otherwise would be because an automobile assembly plant pays property taxes. The price of an automobile is higher, too, than it otherwise would be because, due to income taxes, assembly line workers’ gross pay is higher than their take-home pay. (CAE; emphases mine) At the broadest level, the relatedness of the nucleus (1) and the satellite (2) is shown by the repetition of the nouns price(s) and taxes . A closer look reveals that these words refer to more general notions in the nucleus than they do in the satellite; the sense relation obtaining between prices at which priυate sector output is sold and the price of an automobile, as well as between taxes the priυate sector pays and property taxes/income taxes, is one of hyponymy, with the meaning of the latter expressions being included in the former. The following sentence provides an even simpler illustration of exemplification based on hyponymy: New tools often have more than one use; for example, lasers are an indispensable medical tool, and they also have applications as a military weapon. (CAE) In some cases, however, there are no such lexical cues marking exemplification. This shows that exemplification is a cognitive as well as a discursive operation, allowing writers to make—and readers to perceive—connections between nuclei and satellites which are not lexically marked in an overt manner. The following examples indicate how the notion of exemplification may only be tacitly present, so that one may talk of a ‘zero connector’: Daughters without Japanese names talked about how they wanted to have them and how they made sure that their children would. D20 reported: When we got older and we met our friends that were hapa [half Japanese, half white], they’d have Japanese middle names. We’d go ‘Why didn’t you give us one of those too?’ We were really wanting one. Me and my sister really wanted a Japanese or a middle Japanese name. (CAE)
< previous page
page_113
next page >
< previous page
page_114
next page >
Page 114 The anthology as a whole should be approached in part in terms of the general themes that emerge from comparing and contrasting the individual selections. Let me mention two: First, there is much to be gained through a comparative understanding of our own (U.S.) artworld and why it is as it is. When we read of the difficulty Eastern European artists have had converting to a late capitalist system, we recognize their consequent ennui and irrelevance as similar to what has been going on in our own arts in recent decades. (CAE) De fait, notre histoire ne se compose pas uniquement de déchirements conflictuels. A côté des guerres civiles, larvées ou déclarées, qui ont dressé l’une contre l’autre deux moitiés de la France, elle a aussi connu des moments, fugitifs, d’unanimité où un peuple entier goûtait la douceur de la concorde et aspirait a la pérenniser: la Fête de la Fédération fut l’un de ces moments où l’on crut la Revolution achevée et accomplie…(CAF) Such examples are, however, extremely rare, and even here it might be argued that there are lexical or other cues marking the exemplificatory process. In the first excerpt D20 might be viewed as a hyperonym of daughter; in the second, the enumerator let me mention two may also be considered an exemplifier; in the third, a punctuation mark, namely the colon, introduces the example. Such borderline cases are probably what leads Delcambre (1997:83) to draw the erroneous conclusion that ‘in the absence of other forms of substitution, the use of a specialized marker [i.e. an exemplifier, D.S.] is necessary’, although two pages earlier she herself cites a counter-example. A closer inspection of the examples discussed so far, which account for the majority of cases, suggests that the general-particular, or paradigmatic, relation posited above can be described in terms of two RST relations which sometimes overlap—namely, ‘restatement’ and ‘elaboration’ (see Table 4.3). Restatement is a self-explanatory relation; it is subject to the constraint that S and N should be ‘of comparable bulk’. The elaborative relation is somewhat more complex, realizing a link between nucleus and satellites in one or more of the following ways: (1) set—member, (2) abstract—instance, (3) whole—part, (4) process—step, (5) object— attribute, (6) generalization—specific (Mann and Thompson 1988:273). Exemplifiers Table 4.3 The RST relations ‘restatement’ and ‘elaboration’ Relation name Nucleus Satellite Restatement a situation a re-expression of the situation Elaboration basic information additional information
< previous page
page_114
next page >
< previous page
page_115
next page >
Page 115 Table 4.4 The RST relation ‘background’ Relation name Nucleus Satellite Background text whose understanding is being facilitated text for facilitating understanding can thus be defined as construing the subsequent discourse (the nucleus) as an elaboration of the preceding discourse (the satellite). Note that they usually do so by retrospection; Roulet et al. (1991) call this retrospective construction of X as the background to Y ‘rétro-interprétation’. Note further that, as the wording of the last sentence suggests, we could also interpret this relation as ‘background’, but we would then have a breach of what Mann and Thompson consider the canonical order of the background relation (see Table 4.4). The order required by the background relation is possible in exemplification, but comparatively rare, so that it makes more sense to see ‘elaboration’ rather than ‘background’ as the primary relation obtaining between previous and ensuing discourse. Further support for this view comes from the fact that instances of the non-canonical order may be explained in terms of a third type of RST relation; witness the following example from the beginning of a book chapter: A la fin des années soixante, un universitaire, professeur de mathématiques, avait fondé un institut de recherches sur l’enseignement, où s’élaboraient ce qu’on appela les mathématiques nouvelles. Un jour, devant ses collègues, il posa cette question: ‘Peut-on démontrer que notre réforme rendra l’enseignement plus efficace?’ Question honnête, mais naïve. Car enfin, l’efficacité d’un enseignement mathématique ne se démontre pas de façon mathématique! C’est une question qui n’est pas vraiment claire—que veut dire ‘efficace’?—et dont la réponse ne peut avoir l’évidence d’une loi scientifique. Ce qui ne signifie pas que la question n’ait pas de réponse du tout. Si l’absence de demonstration signifiait le nonsavoir, il n’y aurait pas de sciences humaines. Or, elles existent, ces sciences; mais les connaissances qu’elles procurent sont d’un autre ordre que celles des sciences ‘dures’. Cela pour illustrer la thèse de ce chapitre, et de tout le livre: entre la demonstration scientifique ou logique et l’ignorance pure et simple, il existe tout un domaine qui est celui de l’argumentation. (CAF) In using the wording cela pour illustrer la thèse, the author makes explicit the exemplificatory nature of the introduction and the fact that he uses it to support the main thesis underlying his book. The exemplifier is the
< previous page
page_115
next page >
< previous page
page_116
next page >
Page 116 only explicit marker of exemplification in this case; there is no other lexical material suggesting an exemplificatory relation. The same applies to the following excerpt, where a legal case is mentioned to exemplify, or rather to suggest, the validity of a general thesis: The doctrine of mitigation of damages is consistent with that policy. For example, in Ostrowski v. Azzara, a diabetic plaintiff had a sore toe that her podiatrist treated by removing an ingrown toenail. The plaintiff subsequently alleged that the removal was ill-advised and unnecessary. The site did not heal and later required multiple surgical interventions because of vascular problems. One issue considered on appeal was whether the plaintiff s post-removal health habits could be considered under a mitigation theory. (CAE) Here too the example functions not only as a specification but also as an argument in support of a thesis. Notice in passing how this links up with the aforementioned Aristotelian definition of examples as oratorical arguments. In RST terms, then, the two examples just cited illustrate an ‘evidence relation’, whereby the satellite provides information intended to increase the reader’s belief in a claim made in the nucleus. The constraint on the nucleus here is that the reader might not believe the nucleus to a degree satisfactory to the writer, whereas the constraint on the satellite is that the reader will believe it or find it credible (Mann and Thompson 1988:251–252; see Table 4.5). Although exemplifiers can have scope over vastly differing amounts of the preceding or subsequent discourse, they usually link elements or sequences rather than text segments. Consider the following two examples, in which the exemplificatory text span covers two sentences and four paragraphs respectively (the second example has been abridged). Nevertheless the exemplificatory passage may in both cases be described as a rhetorical element: Moreover, according to Professor Sugarman, who has documented the status of private American insurance coverage, approximately two-thirds of working Americans are covered by formal private employee benefit plans that provide for income replacement upon disability, and about eighty-five percent of all Americans are covered by adequate medical insurance. The state of Florida provides a typical Table 4.5 The RST relation ‘evidence’ Relation name Nucleus Satellite Evidence a claim information intended to increase the reader’s belief in the claim
< previous page
page_116
next page >
< previous page
page_117
next page >
Page 117 example. In 1980, nine out of ten Floridians had medical insurance, which covered more than eighty-eight percent of their medical expenses incident to an accident. (CAE) It is difficult to even know how to think about, let alone measure, the relationship between low-skill immigrants and the unemployment of low-skill natives. Consider, for example, the following not atypical news story about the difficulty that employers have in recruiting low-skill workers: Help Wanted: Burger Flippers, Teens Preferred Berlin, N.J.—Betty Hagen stands out among the employees at the Kentucky Fried Chicken restaurant here, not because her uniform is usually covered in biscuit flour, but because the hair tucked under her cap is gray. While nearly all her colleagues are teenagers, Mrs. Hagen is a 60-year-old grandmother. […] If the flow of low-skill immigrants is sufficiently great that employers do not actively recruit young people and retired persons, should that be counted as employment harm to natives?…(CAE) From this we may note two other facts about exemplification. First, exemplifiers can also be used as citational devices (cf. also an example:…, zur Illustration des Gesagten einige Beispiele:). Second, they may introduce an amplification or a condensation of the preceding discourse (see Delcambre 1997:81). Amplification is more frequent, as should be evident from the examples just cited; condensation can be seen in the following instance: This, together with the entrance of new companies (for example, Samsung), is expected to push milling capacity to over 10 million tonnes. (CAE) Exemplificatory passages can take various discoursal forms. Delcambre (1997) distinguishes two: lists on the one hand and cases or anecdotes on the other. My own observations suggest that a further subdivision of the latter category is necessary, giving us a tripartite classification: (1) cases or instances, (2) case studies and other narrative texts (newspaper articles, anecdotes, etc.), (3) lists. Examples of type (1) and (2) can be seen respectively in the pre-penultimate and penultimate examples. The following stretch of text provides another illustration of the use of examples as anecdotal evidence (i.e. a subtype of type 2): The appropriate response to someone who causes us to suffer—and here, of course, I am not referring to those instances in which others
< previous page
page_117
next page >
< previous page
page_118
next page >
Page 118 oppose us legitimately, as when, for example, they refuse to give in to our unreasonable demands—is to recognize that they will ultimately lose their peace of mind, their inner balance and thereby destroy their happiness by harming us. We do best if we have compassion for them, especially since a simple wish to see them hurt cannot actually harm them. It will certainly harm us, though. Here, imagine two neighbours in dispute. One of them is able to take this dispute lightly. The other is obsessed with it and constantly schemes to find a way to hurt his or her opponent…(CAE) Lastly, here is an example of type (3): The trend toward shared lines of inquiry in various human sciences—history, sociology, psychology, anthropology, and rhetoric, to name but a few—is of course controversial, but many scholars welcome such a shift. (CAE) 4.1.2 Types of exemplifiers All three languages under survey offer abundant resources for the purpose of exemplification, which fall into six major subcategories of translation equivalents. Interlingual correspondences between these are easy to detect and, by contrast with some other categories of SLDMs, do not need to be discussed in a separate section. Group 1: Imperatiυes, hortatiυes and functionally equiυalent constructions Group 1 (see Tables 4.6 and 4.7) comprises exemplifiers that serve actively to engage the reader in the author’s train of thought. Grammatically speaking, most of these items are imperatives and hortatives. While traditional grammar holds that imperatives serve to express commands, requests, exhortations and the like, their illocutionary force in academic writing is normally felt to be that of an invitation rather than an injunction to the reader (see Huddleston 1971). However, as elicitation data (Swales et al. 1998) indicáte, some English writers feel that that an imperative of the type VP~implies command and therefore refrain from using such imperatives. Besides helping the author to exercise varying degrees of power over the reader, imperatives also contribute to ‘clausal and sentential economies’ (Swales et al. 1998:110). Urged by journal editors to shorten the length of their original articles, academic writers may, for example, prefer the succinct interlocutory take (, for example) to the more elaborate sentence-integrated marker a good example is proυided by. Lastly, the use of imperatives may be motivated by a tendency shown by academics from
< previous page
page_118
next page >
< previous page
page_119
next page >
Page 119 Table 4.6 Rank ordering of imperatives, hortatives and functionally equivalent constructions (occurrences in PCAE, PCAF and PCAG respectively) English French German (for example/for instance) voir, par exemple, (102) siehe z.B. NP (23) see (for example/for instance) NP voyez (, par exemple) (3) (200) considérez, par exemple (1) (for example) consider (for example) prenez (, par exemple) (1) NP (54) On prendra l’exemple (0) take, for (another) example, NP (16) regardez, par exemple (0) tenez, par exemple: (0) Consider a(n) (ADJ) example /instance. (7) take the example of (as examples of NP) (5) consider (as an example) NP(3) take, as an example, NP (1) as an illustration (of this)/by way of (brief) illustration, consider NP (2) Take (even) NP (2) see as an example of NP (0) Let us (now) take+(as)+ Prenons+exemple (object noun) Betrachten wir+ Beispiel (e) ( object noun) DET+ADJ+example(s) (4) (40) (17) Let us consider+DET+ADJ citons par/en/à titre d’exemple Nehmen wir+Beispiel(e) (object noun) (8) +example(s) (4) (13) Nehmen wir als (weiteres) Beispiel/zum Let me give (you) (but) one example Donnons+exemple (object noun) Beispiel/ beispielsweise (etc.) (6) (2) (7) Nehmen wir NP (1) Let me offer+DET (+ADJ +) example Prenons par/pour/ comme/à titre Greifen wir (Beispiel, object noun ) heraus (1) d’(autre) exemple+NP (5) (1) Let us consider, for the sake of considérons comme/ pour/par Wählen wir ein Beispiel. (1) illustration, NP (1) exemple NP (5) Wählen wir als Beispiel NP(1) Let just one further example suffice. citons+exemple (object noun) Illustrieren/Erläutern (etc.) wir dies (0) (3) an/anhand /etc.+DET (+ADJ)+ Beispiel (1) Let us look at some examples. (0) pensons, par exemple, à NP (2) Vergegenwärtigen wir uns Let us take an illustration. (0) Prenons NP (1) voyons+exemple (object noun) (1) Reprenons l’exemple de NP (4) dies an+DET (+ADJ)+ Beispiel (0) nous prenons comme exemple Verdeutlichen wir uns mit Hilfe+DET (2) (+ADJ)+ Beispiel (0) Songeons à+exemple (1) Nous prendrons+exemple (1)
< previous page
page_119
next page >
< previous page
page_120
next page >
Page 120 English
French German Considérons+exemple (object noun) (0) Prenons comme illustration NP(0) Nous reprendrons ici un exemple de X. (0) Nous citerons de nouveau quelques exemples. (0) Proposons quelques exemples. (0) Jugeons-en par quelques exemples. (0) Soit, par exemple, (5) Soit les deux phrases: (4) Table 4.7 Total number of occurrences of exemplifiers of type 1 excluding see, for example,/voir, par exemple/siehe z.B. English 302 102 French 221 119 German 58 35 almost any disciplinary background to imitate the conciseness of mathematical discourse (Swales et al. 1998:111). This is plainly the case with French soit, used for introducing a hypothesis or supposition in mathematical discourse: Soit un triangle équilatéral A, B, C. English authors have a large range of exemplificatory imperatives at their disposal, using the direct second-person imperative VP~as well as the less imposing hortative let us+VP and the inclusive let me+VP. Of these last two, the former is around five times more frequent than the latter, showing a high degree of audience sensitivity among authors. By contrast, French authors show much greater reliance on the hortative; the second-person imperative is extremely rare in French scholarly writing, and not much commoner in journalism. An example: L’ensemble est sans doute inégal, et la chasse au ‘hic’ est d’autant plus gratifiante que ce qui cloche est plus dissimulé ou subtil. Voyez, par exemple, cet autre jardinier taillant la haie du château. (NF)
< previous page
page_120
next page >
< previous page
page_121
next page >
Page 121 German writers eschew second-person imperatives altogether, with the exception of siehe, which may be viewed as a halfway house between an exemplifier and a confirmer (this is not to be confused with the exemplifier siehe z.B. ); it is almost exclusively attested in journalistic discourse: Immer wackeln irgendwelche Stars. Siehe Sergei Bubkas vierter Platz im Stabhochsprung mit 5,70m. Oder der dritte Rang der 35 Jahre alten Merlene Ottey aus Jamaica. (NG) The reason for the absence of other second-person imperatives in German may be that these are felt to be too impolite or too colloquial. Instead, German sometimes resorts to the set phrase man denke an, a use paralleled in French by que l’on pense à (i.e. the subjunctive) and on prendra l’exemple (i.e. the future tense). There are no other structural divergences to be noted, except perhaps for the fact that in English the pattern take/consider, for example, +NP is significantly more frequent than take/consider the example of +NP. Of four occurrences of take the example of +NP in CAE, three were found in the same text. This is in keeping with what will be said below on exemplificatory infinitive clauses. Within the patterns for this group there are differing degrees of lexical variation. In English only the verbs consider and take are normally used as direct second-person imperatives. These are usually combined with the phrase for example, but may also occur on their own. This is matched in French by considérons and prenons and in German by betrachten wir and nehmen wir . There is, however, a greater degree of stylistic liberty in French and German, permitting the use of at least two other verbs ( donner and oser) in French and five other verbs in German (illustrieren, herausgreifen, υerdeutlichen, υergegenwärtigen, wählen). While the French imperatives made from υoir and saυoir have been in use for several centuries, those based on other verbs may well have arisen through interference with English, for they appear to be more common in Canadian French: Le kiosquier est une des innombrables facettes de Paris, Rubik’s cube géant dont personne n’a vraiment la clé. Pas même les Parisiens de souche. Prenez les bistrots. Pour vous, étranger, ils ne sont certes pas interchangeables. (Robitaille 1995:23) The idea of invitation contained in imperatives and hortatives may also be conveyed by other means. In English and French this role is sometimes performed by an ‘inclusive’ first-person plural pronoun or an impersonal third-person singular pronoun. These are usually combined with one of the verbs already seen above. In French and German it is also possible to
< previous page
page_121
next page >
< previous page
page_122
next page >
Page 122 resort to the subjunctive mood to express invitation or command. This gives us exemplifiers such as que l’on pense à or als Beispiel sei…genannt, which, although structurally different, will be included in the present subcategory by virtue of their semantic-pragmatic similarity; the same holds true for exemplifiers of the type we would cite/je citerai/ich denke dabei an, which have also been taken account of (see Table 4.8). The frequency data illustrate a principle familiar from other areas of corpus-driven lexicography: just as the commonest meanings of words have been shown to be many times more frequent than their next commonest meanings (Sinclair 1991), so too some standard realizations of SLDMs have a far higher likelihood of occurrence than other items. Thus, let us consider/take+example account for more than half the total tokens of hortatives in (P)CAE, and prenons+exemple outnumbers all other items in (P)CAF by a wide margin. There is also some evidence of a correlation between length of SLDM types and frequency of occurrence. Minimal three-word SLDMs such as take, for example or soit, par exemple, rank the highest. Conversely, lengthy word groupings such as as an illustration of this, consider are much less used. From the available evidence, it would seem that in all three languages under investigation the exemplifiers of this group exhibit a relatively even distribution across genres and individual texts, thus turning out to be stylistically neutral. The frequency counts also show that exemplifiers of this type are unevenly distributed across languages. While the divergence between Table 4.8 Rank ordering of exemplifiers that are functionally equivalent to type 1 exemplifiers English total: 0 French total: 40 German total: 30 (by way of illustration) on pourrait citer à cet égard (4) als Beispiel sei NP genannt/ zitiert/angeführt I/we would cite NP (0) je citerai ainsi à titre d’exemple NP (16) (etc.)//ist zu nennen (etc.); NP mag als Que l’on pense/songe (par exemple) à Beispiel…gelten/dienen (14): als Beispiel sei hier NP/ à ce que (etc.) (11) der Preis für qu’il suffise de penser à Weizen durchschnittlicher /citer/mentionner/ remarquer/signaler Qualität genannt (etc.) als Beispiel mag die Antwort dienen, die Papst Nous pensons, par exemple, à (5) Pius… nous donnons+exemple (object noun) Man denke an NP (13) (1) Hier wäre…zu nennen/zu erwähnen (3) nous donnons comme /pour/à titre d’exemple (2) nous retenons comme exemple (1)
< previous page
page_122
next page >
< previous page
page_123
next page >
Page 123 English and French is relatively insignificant in the parallel corpus (especially if one excludes see, for example, and its literal equivalents from the count), the gap between English and French on one side, and German on the other, is all the wider. The exemplifiers in question occur three to four times more frequently in English and French than in German. Some differences are particularly striking. For example, the dense use of see, for example in the English corpus (200 occurrences) contrasts with the comparatively infrequent occurrence of its direct German equivalent (23 occurrences) siehe z.B., a divergence that can be explained by the German preference for using siehe on its own. It is also worth noting that French offers a wider variety of stylistic variants than either English or German, although some of these are so rare that they cannot be located in PCAF (e.g. proposons quelques exemples, jugeons-en par quelques exemples). Group 2: Noun phrases with the head example6 Most of the items in this group (see Tables 4.9 and 4.10) are bare noun phrases (An example:) or noun phrases consisting of a noun plus a determiner (some examples) or a short periphrastic genitive (exemple d’antithèse). Table 4.9 Rank ordering of noun phrases with the head example (occurrences in PCAE, PCAF and PCAG respectively) English French German For example: (41) (ainsi/comme) par exemple:a (71) Beispiel(e): (73) Here is an example/here are some Exemple (ADJ/de+N): (70) Hier/hierzu/hierfür/dazu (nur)+Beispiel examples (of+NP): (40) (object noun) (22) Example: (12) (en) voici+exemple(s) (object Zum Beispiel/z.B.: (51) Some (ADJ) examples: (6) noun) (49) Zwei (etc.) Beispiele (aus/von vielen) (1) Examples are:/Obvious examples are: (5)voici par exemple NP (9) Autre exemple (+de NP): (7) (wie) beispielsweise: (1) A(n) (ADJ) example (therefore): (4) Einige Beispiele: (1) Autres exemples, parmi tant Weitere Beispiele: (1) Further examples/other examples: (0) d’autres: (1) Es folgen einige Beispiele. (0) Un exemple? (0) Examples abound: (0) Faut-il un exemple? (0) Ein/Unser zweites (etc.) Some illustrations follow. (0) Premier exemple: (0) Beispiel: (0) Deux exemples: (0) Zweites (etc.) Beispiel: (0) Among the better examples are: (0) Deuxième/Second exemple: (0) (ADJ) Beispiel (e.g. bestes Beispiel ): (0) Les exemples abondent/pullulent/ (ADJ) example: (0) fourmillent: (0) Another example: (0) As an example (0) Exemple d’antithèse, NP (0) Note a In French typography the deux-points (also: double point ), or colon, is usually set off by an unbreakable space on either side. This feature has, of course, been taken account of.
< previous page
page_123
next page >
< previous page
page_124
next page >
Page 124 Table 4.10 Frequency of occurrence of type 2 exemplifiers English French German 108 207 150 All of them centre on the noun example itself. It is reasonable to assume that readers will consider these SLDMs to be less imposing and less forceful than those assembled in Group 1. Clearly, they also make for even greater parsimony and clarity of style. Often highlighted through appropriate punctuation, they serve as chunking devices which help the reader to anticipate that the subsequent discourse is of the order of exemplification. Structurally speaking, the cross-linguistic picture is almost perfectly symmetrical here. What little assymmetry there is, such as the occurrence of the pronominal adverbs hierfür and dazu in German or the use of supplementive clauses in French (exemple d’antithèse, la fin de X…), can be explained in terms of general interlingual differences. Another significant difference is to be found in punctuation: where English and German authors invariably follow the bare noun phrase (an) example with a full stop or a colon, French authors may also resort to the question mark ([Faut-il] un exemple?) . Even as far as punctuation is concerned, then, French seems to allow greater variation. The frequency counts seem to suggest that French authors display a much stronger stylistic preference for these exemplifiers than do their English or German counterparts. They are also inclined to use a broader range of devices than German authors: modified and non-modified noun phrases, supplementive clauses, interrogative clauses, staging by means of υoici, etc. In PCAG we find a clear preponderance of the non-modified noun phrase followed by a colon. Zum Beispiel, at a mere nine attestations in PCAG, is also much less common than its literal English and French equivalents; this is due to a preference for the abridged form in German. It is also noteworthy that French has at its disposal three different items to emphasize the abundance of exemplificatory material, namely les exemples abondent/pullulent/fourmiller where English must content itself with examples abound (or: there is an abundance of examples). Group 3: Exemplificatory infinitiυe clauses This group, probably because it is situated towards the freer end of the phraseological cline, does not present as unified a picture as Groups 1 and 2 (see Table 4.11). A systematic sweep through the academic corpora indicates that English exemplificatory infinitive clauses do not normally contain the noun example preceded by the definite article and followed by a periphrastic genitive (e.g. the example of newspapers), a pattern which is
< previous page
page_124
next page >
< previous page
page_125
next page >
Page 125 Table 4.11 Rank ordering of exemplificatory infinitive clauses (occurrences in PCAE, PCAF and PCAG respectively) English total: 74 French total: 91 German total: 38 1take+example: 1prendre+exemple: 1Beispiel+nennen (12): to take but one example pour ne prendre que cet exemple um nur ein Beispiel zu nennen to take an extended pour prendre un exemple um ein weiteres Beispiel zu nennen (etc.) example plus contemporain 2Beispiel+bleiben bei (4): to take two random pour prendre un autre exemple chez um bei diesem Beispiel zu bleiben: examples les insectes um im Beispiel zu bleiben to take a common example pour ne prendre que ces exemples of NP (etc.) (38) pour prendre un autre exemple 2give+example: connu 3Beispiel+aufnehmen (2): (just) to give (you) an pour prendre un exemple adjectival um das oben zitierte example (29) Beispiel noch einmal aufzunehmen to give a few examples 2reprendre+exemple: 4Beispiel + to give two examples pour reprendre l’exemple de (NP) vorwegnehmen/wählen/zurückkommen to give an example from pour reprendre les exemples cités auf/benennen/deutlich machen (5): television (etc.) (14) (12) um ein späteres Beispiel vorwegzunehmen 3cite+example: 3citer+exemple: um wieder auf unser Beispiel+NP to cite another example pour ne citer que l’exemple de (NP) zurückzukommen to cite one example among pour ne citer qu’un exemple um ein Beispiel aus dem Bereich der Sprache zu many (6) pour ne citer que trois exemples wählen 4name/mention+example: pour citer un autre exemple (9) um ein aktuelles Beispiel zu benennen to name but two examples to mention a not atypical example (2) 5to pick just one example to use my earlier example to paint an extreme example (etc.) (1) 4donner+exemple: pour ne donner que quelques 5Beispiel+geben/aufführen/ exemples anführen/aufgreifen/vorführen/einbringen/ pour donner un exemple (6) aufnehmen/ergänzen (0): 5rester+exemple: um ein Beispiel zu geben pour rester sur l’exemple …(2) Um nur ein Beispiel in diesen komplizierten 6retenir+exemple: Zusammenhängen zu erwähnen pour ne retenir qu’un exemple (1) um ein kleines Beispiel aufzuführen 7pour puiser dans notre histoire un exemple élémentaire (0) to illustrate zur Veranschaulichung/ to illustrate this (point) (etc.) pour illustrer mon Illustration/Verdeutlichung to illustrate by example propos/ceci/cela/ces [sei hier eine fehlerhafte Übersetzung angeführt] to illustrate with a simple remarques/ce qui précède (etc.) (32) (11) example um dies zu demonstrieren/ to demonstrate this 13 veranschaulichen/illustrieren /verdeutlichen (etc.) (4)
< previous page
page_125
next page >
< previous page
page_126
next page >
Page 126 commonly found in their French and German counterparts. This means that, somewhat contrary to intuition, a literal rendering of such German infinitive clauses as um nur das Beispiel der FAZ zu nennen by (?)to take/giυe/use only the example of the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung would be rather unidiomatic, even though one does find instances of to take the case of the (+noun). In English, the actual example, in this case the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, is usually the subject of the main clause rather than the object of the infinitive clause. In a parallel fashion, if one wished to translate into French the German infinitive clause um auf einige möglichst υerschiedene Beispiele wie…zu υerweisen two translation shifts would be necessary. First, one would have to use a different verb to the literal equivalent renυoyer because French exemplifying infinitive clauses typically contain the verbs prendre and citer, or less often, donner, reprendre and retenir. Second, the examples, introduced by the conjunction wie in the German infinitive clause, would have to be positioned in the main clause of the French target sentence. It goes without saying that such subtle interlingual divergences among subgroups of SLDMs are a potential minefield for language learners and translators. Apart from the structural dissimiliarities just discussed, there are also semantic-pragmatic differences between the languages under survey. One of the most obvious is that German exemplificatory infinitive clauses, by virtue of their greater syntactic extendibility and inherent lexical variety, can express many more shades of meaning than their English or French counterparts. This is evident, first and foremost, from the fairly large array of different verbs to be found in German, many of which are not attested in PCAG, but in CAG and NG. As English and French content themselves with five major verb choices respectively (take, give, cite, pick, use, mention; prendre, reprendre, donner, retenir, rester [sur]), an interesting translation principle must be posited here which has not yet been noted in the literature. Consider, as an example, the German exemplificatory infinitive clause um ein Beispiel υorzuführen, which carries clear overtones of scientific demonstration. Although the collocation to demonstrate s.th. with an example is available in English, the exemplificatory infinitive clause to demonstrate this with an example would seem to run counter to the norms of English academic prose, so that the experienced translator is likely to fall back on one of the standard infinitive clauses introduced by to-infinitiυe+take/giυe/cite/use. What we have here, then, is a clear case of what might be called ‘structurally bound collocation’. If, on the basis of this insight, we wished to set up a translation principle, this would stipulate that, other factors being equal, the translator must check the compatibility of collocational equivalents with particular linguistic environments. Here, then, we find another case where corpus evidence and native-speaker intuition may find themselves at odds. If asked whether a clause such as to demonstrate this with an example is conceivable in academic writing, most native speakers would probably answer in the affirmative;
< previous page
page_126
next page >
< previous page
page_127
next page >
Page 127 only very experienced and style-conscious writers would query the naturalness of such a wording. This principle also applies to cases where long German noun groups are embedded within the exemplificatory infinitive clause, so that literal renderings would inflate the English infinitive clause to an unacceptable size. This is conveniently illustrated in Table 4.12. A further browsing of the corpus revealed that the three languages under survey resemble each other with regard to the embedding of exemplificatory infinitive clauses within the sentence. Although their position is variable, there is a strong preference in all three languages for sentence-initial position. A deviant type of infinitive clause is to illustrate, occurring as it does without any object; German has no structural equivalent for this, and French writers hardly ever use pour illustrer without an object: One reason that harvests were large despite the droughts is people’s increased capacity to overcome adverse natural conditions. To illustrate, one of the most publicized droughts was in southern California …(CAE) At about 88 occurrences per 10 million words French markers of Group 3 are slightly more frequent than their English equivalents, and more than twice as frequent as their German equivalents. Hence German exemplificatory infinitive clauses are simultaneously less commonly observed and more variable than their French counterparts, revealing a German tendency to ad hoc formulation as opposed to English and French reliance on collocations. A similar tendency was already noted, with reference mainly to the spoken language, by House (1997). The frequency data also provide a convenient illustration of the link between likelihood of occurrence and acceptability. In English and Table 4.12 Translating lengthy German exemplificatory infinitive clauses German original English translation Warum sollen die Würzburger oder die Regensburger nicht (wie die Another good example is afforded by Bürgerinnen und Bürger im baden-württembergischen Ulm), darüber one of Germany’s neighbours: If it abstimmen dürfen, ob sie einen größeren Straßentunnel wollen? Oder, um ein weren’t for local referendums, Zurich Beispiel aus dem benachbarten Ausland zu wählen: Zürich hätte keine wouldn’t have a tram that experts Straßenbahn, zu der Experten aus der ganzen Welt pilgern, gäbe es dort from all over the world flock to visit. nicht einen Bürgerentscheid. (NG) (my translation)
< previous page
page_127
next page >
< previous page
page_128
next page >
Page 128 French there is a scale of acceptability, with stock collocations such as take+example clearly established at the upper end and low-probability combinations such as paint+example at the bottom. Spaced out in between are moderately frequent groupings such as name+example. There is noticeable complementarity here between English and French usage, but German is clearly the odd man out. Many of the English and French collo cations at the lower end of the scale (e.g. paint+example), while going unnoticed in connected text, may well be judged unacceptable if presented out of context. Not so in German, where lower-end collocations are many and varied. The rarity of lower-end collocations in English and French may be explained in terms of very high or very low degrees of language awareness on the part of writers: just as accomplished stylists may wish to use the occasional ‘creative’ collocation, so budding writers with little experience of academic or journalistic prose may produce collocational infelicities. A clear example of a stylistically elegant coinage is pour puiser dans notre histoire un exemple élémentaire . By way of contrast, to paint an extreme example is, to say the least, a shade odd. This implies that ‘deviance’ or ‘error’ are less to do with fuzziness in grammar, as many older accounts suggest (e.g. Legenhausen 1989), than simply with likelihood of occurrence. It also implies that German, where lower-end groupings form a fairly large category, is more tolerant of deviance or, to put it more favourably, more creative than English and French. Group 4:Clauses built around verbs denoting ‘illustration’ or ‘demonstration’ This group (see Table 4.13) covers sentence-fragment exemplifiers whose common denominator is that they are all based on clauses containing a verb denoting ‘demonstration’ or ‘illustration’; in most cases, these verbs enter into strong collocations with the nouns example, exemple and Beispiel Also noteworthy is the fact that there is a clearly discernible cline among the languages under study, with English showing the least, and German the most, lexicogrammatical variation. In English there are two basic sentence patterns to be found, one impersonal, the other personal. 1 In the first pattern, a noun phrase with the noun example as its head occupies subject position; it is followed by a verb such as illustrate and an object noun phrase such as this, what is meant or these points. The verbal auxiliaries can, will and may, or their substitutes serve to and help (to), frequently supplement the verb phrase, but in current English use of the modal may is restricted to the passive voice. Note also that prepositional usage varies from one verb to another, and even with the same verb: illustrate+with (or: from)+example, clarify+by (+example). 2 In the second pattern, I and we occur as subjects, followed by a verb
< previous page
page_128
next page >
< previous page
page_129
next page >
Page 129 Table 4.13 Rank ordering of clauses built around verbs denoting ‘illustration’ or ‘demonstration’ (occurrences in PCAE, PCAF and PCAG respectively; exemplifiers introduced by the conjunctions as/comme/wie [comme le montre l’exemple suiυant] were not taken account of here) English total: 93 French total: 91 German total: 75 1…is/may be/can be 1exemple (subject noun) + illustrer (36) 1Beispiel+verdeutlichen (ADV) illustrated/I can Un exemple simple illustrera l’importance… (28): Eine Skizze soll dies illustrate…(41): deux exemples en guise d’illustration: am Beispiel der This can be simply 2exemple (subject noun)+ montrer (30): un exemple le Entstehung von illustrated from the montre:… un exemple permet de montrer… Philosophie verdeutlichen. writing of business Am Beispiel verdeutlicht: letters. … This may be illustrated 2Beispiel+illustrieren (12): with the verb… Ein Beispiel mag dies This is nicely illustrated illustrieren. by 2example(s)+illustrate 3illustrer (10): on peut/nous pouvons illustrer NP par NP 3Beispiel+erläutern (12): (38): Dies soll am Beispiel von A brief example will Kollokationen erläutert serve to illustrate this. werden. …may be illustrated by 4exemple+à partir de/à travers/sur (etc.) 4Beispiel+zeigen (10): das just a few examples (prepositional object)+ montrer/mettre en évidence/illustrer/ folgende Beispiel zeigt… 3example+demonstrate démontrer/etc. (9): 5Beispiel+veranschaulichen (5): Mettons cette opposition en evidence a partir d’un exemple (8): Ein simples Beispiel The following example c’est a travers trois exemples qu’on peut poser… soll veranschaulichen, demonstrates that… Sur un exemple d’article cité par…, nous montrons worum es geht. 4example(s)+suffice (5): Two examples will suffice. 5example+clarify (2): 6Beispiel+dienen (3): Some examples may Als Beispiel soll uns… serve to clarify these dienen. points. Als prominentestes 6example(s)+indicate (1): Beispiel dient hier… a simplified example will 7illustrieren/verdeutlichen indicate (NP) (etc.) (+beispielhaft) (2): 7example+make clear/ 5exemple+manifester/ éclairer/mettre en Illustriert wird das plain (1): An example or lumière/mesurer/apporter des éclairages sur (etc.) (often in beispielhaft durch two should make clear conjunction with permettre) (3): cet exemple met en folgenden Ausschnitt. these all-important lumière… D’autres exemples vont nous permettre de mieux Einige Zahlen sollen das distinctions. mesurer encore la distance qui sépare… beispielhaft verdeutlichen. 8example+illuminate (0): 8Beispiel+beleuchten/ A numerical example belegen/deutlich machen/ helps illuminate the werden (0) issue. 6exemple+indiquer (3): Ces quelques exemples indiquent que…
< previous page
page_129
next page >
< previous page
page_130
next page >
Page 130 such as clarify, demonstrate or illustrate and a prepositional object usually containing the noun example . Overall, there are six English verbs and one verb-adjective collocation commonly found with these patterns: show, illustrate, indicate, illuminate, demonstrate, clarify and make clear. Turning to French, we find that the number of verbs is the same as in English: indiquer, montrer, démontrer, illustrer, mettre en lumière and mettre en éυidence are most commonly used, but there is much more syntactic variation. Thus, French authors are inclined to use prepositional phrases introduced by sur or à partir de (+exemple) in conjunction with verbs like montrer; a number of interesting nominalizations such as en guise d’illustration are also in evidence. The same tendency towards greater syntactic variation can be observed in German. Typical of a language with flexible word order is the relative diversity of prepositional phrases in which the noun Beispiel has been embedded: an einem Beispiel (υerdeutlichen), anhand eines Beispiels (erläutern), durch Beispiele (beleuchten), mit Hilfe einiger Beispiele (glaubhaft machen) . Translational correspondences can be readily set up and do not merit any explanation; nor are there any significant differences in frequency between the languages under investigation. The frequency data show a roughly even distribution of this type of marker in English and French, with German lagging somewhat behind. Group 5: Copular clauses This is another structurally simple type of exemplifier (see Table 4.14). In English, it consists of a subject noun phrase with one of the nouns case, example, instance, illustration or demonstration as its head, a copular verb (usually ‘be’) and a subject complement or, in the case of demonstration, a prepositional phrase which names the actual example. This order may also be reversed, which usually happens when case in point is used in place of the aforementioned nouns. French and German exemplifiers in this group follow very similar patterns. Unlike English and German, French requires the use of the demonstrative celui before the subject complement, unless the latter is a proper noun. Also mandatory is the anaphoric use of en to refer back to the concept being exemplified. Another interesting fact to note is the optional use, in German, of the zero article in front of the noun Beispiel or such adjective-noun collocations as anschauliches Beispiel, bestes Beispiel or jüngstes Beispiel, a usage that may well be obsolescent. Exemplifiers such as on en a un exemple dans NP and beispielhaft für NP ist …are semantically and pragmatically equivalent to the major exemplars of this category. They have therefore been included here. The non-compositional French exemplifier on en a un exemple is not to be confused with its compositional counterpart; in the former the preposition dans introduces the actual example, whereas in the latter it indicates the source of the example. The frequency data show that German, at 106
< previous page
page_130
next page >
< previous page
page_131
next page >
Page 131 Table 4.14 Rank ordering of copular clauses (occurrences in PCAE, PCAF and PCAG respectively) English total: 84 French total: 84 German total: 106 1A(n) (ADJ) example is (that of) 1exemple+être (57): Un autre exemple est 1(Ein) (ADJ) Beispiel für NP (65): celui de la sous-tâche «ordination». NP (hierfür, dafür) ist A frequent example is NP …la loi Debré est NP/complement clause//stellt NP dar An obvious example is NP l’exemple même d’une construction de (100): 2NP is a (ADJ) case in point /A l’immigration comme problème ... Anschauliches Beispiel dafür is… (ADJ) case in point is NP (16): 2exemple+constituer (11): Dafür ist gerade…ein Paradebeispiel. The old English verse Elene is a Rotterdam en constitue l’exemple le plus Bestes Biespiel heirfür ist nach wie notable case in point. flagrant. vor NP 3DET (+ADJ)+illustration 3exemplaire (often with ici/à ce point de 2Beispielhaft/ Bezeichnend/ /demonstration is (PREP) NP: (3) υue/à cet égard/à ce sujet] (7): exemplarisch für NP (hierfür, dafür) Perhaps the easiest illustration is La carrière de Bruneschi est a cet égard ist NP/ camouflage exemplaire. Complement Clause (6): A vivid demonstration of …is in Le cas du…est exemplaire de cette Bezeichnend ist folgende Passage:… studies of… démarche. 4One has, for example,… (etc.) 4exemple+on en a/on en voit (etc.) (7): (0) On en a un bel exemple dans le crime contre l’humanité. 5exemple+représenter (2): Il représente un des exemples les plus réussis d’interaction entre… 6exemple+rester (0): Juin 1940 en reste le meilleur exemple. attestations, is more partial to this kind of exemplifier than English and French. Group 6: Verb-noun collocations of the type example+provide Stylistically speaking, this group contains ‘elegant variations’ of what are essentially the same patterns as those illustrated in Group 5, with the obvious difference that a non-copular verb fills the verb slot (see Table 4.15). Some of the French patterns allow for the optional insertion of a first-person object pronoun (NP nous fournit un nouυel exemple), a construc tion which is not available in English and uncommon in German.
< previous page
page_131
next page >
< previous page
page_132
next page >
Page 132 Table 4.15 Rank ordering of verb-noun collocations of the type example+(e.g.) provide English total: 44 French total: 58 German total: 28 1example+provide (39): …provides 1exemple+fournir (33): 1Beispiel+liefern (17): an illustration of… NP nous fournit un nouvel exemple NP liefert ein anschauliches A good example is provided by NP Beispiel dafür 2example+give (4): 2exemple+offrir (17): 2Beispiel+bieten (10): At this point, perhaps, an example NP offre un exemple canonique Sokrates bietet vielleicht das should be given. Un autre exemple nous est offert par… beste Beispiel dafür,… 3example+afford (1) : 3exemple+donner (8) : 3Beispiel+geben (1) : Another such example is afforded by …en donnent une belle illustration Ein paar markante NP L’Arabie Saoudite donne un exemple d’Etat Beispiele hierfür seien A pertinent illustration is afforded by islamique moderne. gegeben. NP Un exemple intéressant (nous) en est donné par la tête de l’homme. In translation, there is an intralingual and interlingual trade-off between the items in this group and those in Group 4. If, for example, we wish to translate the English sentence NP proυides a fine example of this kind of analysis into French, one possible solution is via a dual class shift: the adjective fine can be transposed to the adverb à merυeille, and the verb-noun collocation proυide+example can be rendered by the verb illustrer: NP illustre à merυeille ce type d’analyse, alongside the more literal NP fournit un bel exemple de ce type d’analyse . The ability of French donner+exemple to occur in two different types of linguistic environment lays bare another type of interlingual divergence. Consider the following examples: Les grammaires disent encore que les adjectifs verbaux issus d’un participe présent ou passé ou d’une de leurs formes préfixées sont presque toujours placés après le nom. Mon corpus donne de nombreux exemples d’infractions à cet usage…(CAF) Les économies régionales autarciques ont existé jusqu’au moment où se sont développés les moyens de communication. G.Kuhnholtz-Lordat en donne un remarquable exemple dans le «pays de Costière» (département du Gard). (EU) L’Arabie Saoudite donne un exemple d’Etat islamique moderne. (EU) De sorte que les villes ont crû, se sont transformées et fragmentées, d’une manière qui dépasse tout ce que l’on avait pu imaginer. Le
< previous page
page_132
next page >
< previous page
page_133
next page >
Page 133 meilleur exemple est donné par Mexico, la ville du monde la plus peuplée, dont il est désormais impossible de fixer les limites et de dresser le plan. (CAF) In the first group of highlighted sentences, donner has retained its full meaning. In functional grammar terms, the subject of donner would be labelled an ‘actor’; the construction belongs to the material process type. It is somewhat different with the second group of sentences, where donner has an equative meaning characteristic of the relational process type. Its subject is a ‘token’ that has a ‘value’ ascribed to it in the form of an object. Since the English collocation giυe+example and the German collocation geben+Beispiel can only be used with material processes, a literal translation of the second group of examples is out of the question. The pattern characteristic of Group 6 is associated with a large range of adjective-noun collocations, and it is highly enlightening to approach these from a contrastive perspective. A number of points are worth making. First, and most obviously, certain segments of the collocational range of example seem to constitute closed sets, while others are not so precisely delimited. An example of a closed set is the ‘oft-cited’ segment, whereas the opposite tendency is discernible in the ‘emotive’ cluster (see Table 4.16). Another cluster allows the attributes of the noun that example qualifies to be ascribed to the latter, witness the following: a giant example with rubberized wooden rollers (NE) ein schamloses Beispiel (NG) Such metaphorical attribution can give rise to a potentially infinite number of unusual word combinations, which are not normally considered collocations. Many of these fall within the scope of the ‘model’ meaning of example, which has not been taken account of here. A small number of adjectives can only be used with (usually human) animates: eminent, infamous, liυing are examples. Second, there are significant collocational gaps to be observed between some of the sets. Practical example and praktisches Beispiel, for instance, have no direct French equivalent, and even the English and the German collocations are not fully congruent. With the former, the emphasis is firmly on the ability of humans to put into practice whatever the example refers to. Practical example may thus be glossed as ‘an example for practice’. By contrast, the German collocation usually occurs in a context where there is a large amount of theorizing, making it difficult for readers or listeners to follow the thread of the argument. The praktisches Beispiel which the writer or lecturer may then provide is more an illustrative example from established practice than an example to be emulated in innovative practice. Further support for this observation may be derived from the fact that the collocation example+practical rarely occurs in exemplificatory infinitive
< previous page
page_133
next page >
< previous page
page_134
next page >
Page 134 Table 4.16 The ‘oft-cited’ and ‘emotive’ clusters English French German oft-cited, much quoted, well-known, well-worn, connu, célèbre, vielzitiert, einschlägig, bekannt, geläufig, famous, favourite, the first known, the best fameux abgedroschen known clear(-er, -est), concrete, eloquent, concret, convaincant, klar, sinnfällig, aussagekräftig, konkret, telling, revealing, illuminating, edifying, percutant, (le plus) anschaulich, aufschlußreich, eindrucksvoll, enlightening, striking, entertaining, impressive, frappant, (le plus) alarmierend, markant, augenfällig, attraktiv, spectacular, vivid, noteworthy, thoughtflagrant, étonnant, (le ernüchternd, anfaßbar, angsterregend, provoking, instructive, moving, emotive, plus) remarquable, aufsehenerregend, beeindruckend, alarming, amazing, amusing, appalling, mild, (le plus) marquant, bedrückend, beredt(este), schlagend, appealing, astonishing, awesome, awe-inspiring, (le plus) parlant, bemerkenswert, bezeichnend, harmlos, awful, bizarre, breathtaking, charming, chilling, eloquent, révélateur, dramatisch, drastisch, eindringlich, colourful, distinguished, compelling, clever, significatif, signifiant, eindrucksvoll, eklatant, relativierend, disturbing, interesting, dramatic, fascinating, macabre, lumineux, ermutigend, grausam, grausig, gravierend, glittering, grotesque, remarkable, wonderful, sad, instructif, éclairant, intéressant, imponierend, instruktiv, tragic, egregious, hideous, anecdotal inoubliable, lehrreich, amüsant, radikal, schrecklich, passionnant, vibrant, schlimm, das schwerwiegendste, spektakulär, pittoresque, triste suggestiv, traurig, unbegreiflich, überzeugend clauses, precisely because one cannot normally adduce a ‘practical example’ for purposes of illustration. The closest French comes to either the English or the German meaning is exemple concret; exemple pratique is extremely rare, and appears to occur only in the ‘model’ sense of exemple (l’organisation du lycée doit être un exemple pratique de démocratie) . Table 4.17 shows the full extent of collocational difference. It is striking that this does not arise from any semantic incompatibility; one may wonder, for instance, why example+triυial cannot be located in any of my corpora— although the collocation appears to be acceptable, it is not in general use. Once very large multilingual corpora become available it will be interesting to look at how translators cope with such subtle cross-linguistic divergences.
< previous page
page_134
next page >
< previous page
page_135
next page >
Page 135 Table 4.17 Differences in collocability between example, exemple and Beispiel (the frequency label rare here refers to cooccurrences which many native speakers would not accept when asked) example+ exemple+ Beispiel+ anecdotal anecdotique (rare) — well-worn — abgedroschen happy/not the happiest heureux (rare) glücklich thought-provoking — nachdenklich stimmend contagious (rare) contagieux ansteckend (rare) dramatic dramatique (rare) dramatisch worked travaillé —(praxisnah, praxiserprobt) edifying édifiant —(?erbaulich→lehrreich, imponierend) —(colourful) pittoresque — clear clair [rare] (frappant, convaincant, parlant) klar (sinnfällig, aussagekräftig, aufschlußreich) oft-cited/much-quoted —(célèbre, fameux) vielzitiert representative (rare) représentatif repräsentativ — criant (‘très manifeste’ [Petit Robert] ) schreiend (rare) drastic (rare) — drastisch — commenté kommentiert suggestive (rare) suggestif (rare) suggestiv — — verfremdet — — ausschmückend — — Musterquick (rare) rapide schnell (rare) A third point to note is that certain types of adjectives are gradable in French, but not usually in English or German, thus giving rise to further collocational gaps. Some of these commonly occur with the noun exemple in the comparative or superlative degree: exemple le plus typique, exemples les plus représentatifs, exemple particulièrement typique French is also alone in allowing postmodification of the head example by two classifying adjectives: l’exemple irlandais υoisin (the example of neighbouring Ireland, das Beispiel des benachbarten Irlands). Fourth, there are interesting differences between the languages under survey with respect to the frequency of particular collocations. These can only be explained with reference to language-internal developments and resultant preferences. The French collocation exemple+caricatural, a pet usage of French journalists, is a case in point. Instances of its English and German equivalents example+grotesque and Beispiel+grotesk are few and far between. Conversely, the German collocation Beispiel+abschreckend is many times more frequent than its potential French equivalents
< previous page
page_135
next page >
< previous page
page_136
next page >
Page 136 exemple+à ne pas suiυre and exemple+dissuasif . The same goes for English extreme example and its literal French and German equivalents. Fifth, there are appreciable interlingual differences in size between some sets. Apart from the unpredictable language-internal developments already referred to, the underlying motivation may be a stylistic one. Consider the literal translation of the adjectival compound+noun collocation example+oft-cited/much-quoted into French. Since French tends to place adjectival modifiers after heads, the resultant French collocation would be the fairly unwieldy exemple souvent cité, a rendering which will be difficult to employ if the noun head example is modified any further. This may explain the French preference for associating nouns such as exemple with non-compound adjectives like connu. Sixth, some of the German exemplifiers under discussion have variations where an adjective-noun collocation alternates with a compound: positives Beispiel →Positiυbeispiel, einschlägiges Beispiel →Standardbeispiel, etc. A final point which should be made here is that article use in the French patterns can be unpredictable. Some syntagmas seem to be so common that the definite article is used where one would normally expect the indefinite article: il est l’exemple rare d’un cinema d’auteurs qui a autant de succès que le cinéma de masse il est l’exemple quasi parfait du self-made man (NF) It may be noted in passing that the various types of defectiveness noted here, whether grammatical or collocational, bear eloquent witness to our view of sentence-fragment SLDMs as composite units rather than free combinations. Even with apparently anodine noun-adjective collocations such as earliest+example, translation is not always straightforward (see Table 4.18). In conclusion, it can be observed that although the English, French and German exemplifiers in Groups 5 and 6 bear clear functional and macrostructural similarities, there are inexhaustably subtle constraints on their microstructural realizations which have so far escaped notice. These often make literal translation impossible. Table 4.19 shows the complete list of adjective-noun collocations found in the corpora examined; they have been crudely categorized by meaning. Table 4.18 earliest+example and its translation equivalents English French German the OED’s earliest le premier exemple de das erste (älteste, früheste) example of this use cet emploi dans le OED Beispiel für diesen Gebrauch im OED
< previous page
page_136
next page >
< previous page
page_137
next page >
Page 137 Table 4.19 Attested adjectival collocates of English example, French exemple and German Beispiel ( Example being a polysemous word, it is well-nigh impossible to draw a sharp line between the senses ‘instance’ and ‘model’, of which only the first engages our attention here [see the introduction to this section]. I have excluded from consideration all clear instances of the second sense, such as exemple+grand or exemple+louable (les grands exemples doivent partir de haut), but I have taken account of borderline cases like outstanding+example or schlimm+Beispieli.) example (‘instance’) exemple Beispiel good, better, the best, bad, admirable, bon, bel, (particulièrement) fort, gut (besseres, bestes), schlecht, worse, the worst, beautiful, mauvais, (le) meilleur*, (le) pire*, hübsch, griffig, trefflich, treffend, beguiling, fine, splendid, brilliant, magnifique, exceptionnel, extraordinaire, auβergewöhnlich, gelungen, exquisite, perfect, supreme, trivial, élémentaire, le plus abouti, priviligié, gekonnt, gläZZnzend, ärachtig, excellent, admirable, choice, parfait (normally preposed), (le plus) trivial, grundlegend, prominent, consummate, extraordinary, édifiant, intéressant, superbe*, splendide*, herausragend, hervorragend, (most) eminent, outstanding excellent, le plus achevé herrlich, leuchtend, wunderbar prime, classic, (un) common, canonique, caractéristique, (le plus) typique, klassisch, ausgezeichnet, typical, characteristic, obvious, (le plus) évident, représentatif, possible berühmte,einprägsam, repräsentativ, blatant, glaring, comparable, typisch, atypisch, charakteristisch conspicuous, notable, notorious, contrasting, dubious oft-cited, much quoted, wellconnu, célèbre, fameux vielzitiert, einschlägig, bekannt, known, well-worn, famous, geläufig, abgedroschen favourite, the first known, the best known useful, practical, convenient, positif, contagieux, rare, puissant* handfest, praktisch, glücklich, valuable, pertinent, apt, apposite, harmlos, hypothetisch, positiv, powerful, anodyne, not the selten, akzeptabel happiest example, happy, hypothethical, rare
< previous page
page_137
next page >
< previous page
page_138
next page >
Page 138 example (‘instance’) exemple Beispiel clear(-er, -est), concrete, eloquent, telling, concret, convaincant, klar, sinnfällig, aussagekräftig, konkret, revealing, illuminating, edifying, percutant, (le plus) anschaulich, aufschluβreich, eindrucksvoll, enlightening, striking, entertaining, frappant, (le plus) alarmierend, markant, augenfällig, attraktiv, impressive, spectacular, vivid, noteworthy, flagrant, étonnant, (le ernüchternd, anfaβbar, angsterregend, thought-provoking, instructive, moving, plus) remarquable, (le aufsehenerregend, beeindruckend, bedruckend, emotive, alarming, amazing, amusing, plus) marquant, (le beredt (este) , schlagend, bemerkenswert, appalling, mild, appealing, astonishing, plus) parlant, éloquent, bezeichnend, harmlos, dramatisch, drastisch, awesome, awe-inspiring, awful, bizarre, révélateur, significatif, eindringlich, eindrucksvoll, eklatant, breathtaking, charming, chilling, colourful, signifiant, macabre, relativierend, ermutigend, grausam, grausig, distinguished, compelling, clever, disturbing, lumineux, instructif, gravierend, interessant, imponierend, instruktiv, interesting, dramatic, fascinating, glittering, éclairant, inoubliable, lehrreich, amüsant, radikal, schrecklich, grotesque, remarkable, wonderful, sad, passionnant, vibrant, schlimm, das schwerwiegendste, spektakulär, tragic, egregious, hideous, anecdotal pittoresque, triste suggestiv, traurig, unbegreiflich, überzeugend simple, crude, crass, stark, elegant, (le plus) caricatural, exotisch, krass, schreiend intricate, sophisticated, extreme, unique cocasse, criant, brief, small extrême, exotique, immonde, unique court, succinct, petit, klein, schlicht, prägnant simple, modeste, ponctuel illustrative, cautionary, authentic, attested, illustratif (d’illustration) illustrierend (?), warnend, mahnend, made-up, isolated, genuine, accompanying, , inverse, attesté, abschreckend, authentisch, konstruiert, fingiert, worked, chosen (+ examples) forgé, contextualisé, verfremdet, praxisnah, ausschmückend, travaillé, à ne pas ausgewählt, kommentiert suivre, contraire, choisi (exemples choisis) commercial allemand et akustisch, historisch, modern, Reutlinger, britannique, nantais, algebraisch, Uhren-, Projekt-, Unterrichts-, anthropologique, culinaire, irlandais voisin, historique, contemporain textbook, counter-, vintage, limit -phare, -type, contre-, Parade-, Negativ-, Positiv-, Standard-, Gegen-, micro Demonstrations-, Anwendungs-, Muster-, absurd, current, earliest, early, innovative, récent,nouvel, ancien, Original-, Gebrauchs-, Fall-, Schulthe latest, recent, random premier (l’un des aktuell,abgestanden, alltäglich, älteste, früh, premiers), analogue (aller) erstes, jüngst, willkürlich herausgegriffen, beliebig, zeitgemäβ, analog
< previous page
page_138
next page >
< previous page
page_139
next page >
Page 139 Group 7: Exemplifiers introducing subordinate clauses This group (see Table 4.20) admits a large range of grammatically diverse exemplifiers, whose lowest common denominator is to be found in their syntactic position at the beginning of a subordinate clause (with the exception of witness ). This clause-initial placement makes possible a very close association of the example and the thing being exemplified. From the reader’s viewpoint, these markers are even less obtrusive than those of the previous groups. As can be seen from the listing in Table 4.20, the interlingual picture is not entirely symmetrical. English and German, for example, lack an exact equivalent of French ainsi dans. One of the English patterns, namely the as+adverb+participle construction, is a productive one; ‘new’ adverb-verb collocations can be coined on the model of the corresponding adjective-noun collocations shown above: striking+example→as strikingly exemplified, conυenient+example →as conveniently exemplified, υiυid+illustration →as vividly illustrated, to name but three among dozens of possibilities. This is another interesting interlingual difference with German and French, where much less variety is to be found. In the German corpus only two adverb-verb collocations are attested, sehr gut+υeranschaulichen and deutlich+zeigen, and in the French corpus we find only one instance of montrer+bien . The frequency data show a clear preponderance of this type of marker in French and German. Group 8: Miscellaneous items We are left with a ragbag of exemplifiers that resist classification altogether. Since these words and phrases also have numerous other functions they have not been compared in terms of frequency. Some examples are given in Table 4.21. 4.1.3 Summary We can summarize this section in the following terms. We have seen that English, French and German use semantically and pragmatically similar sets of exemplifiers. These have so far been perceived as free combinations, but have here been shown to be fairly rigid collocations which exhibit only a small degree of variation. Generalizing across all groups, such variation appears to be somewhat higher in French and in German than in English, with the exception of Group 7, where the English as+adverb+participle construction has more productive potential than its French and German counterparts. Close analysis of exemplificatory infinitive clauses suggests that the large degree of variation found among German items may result from a general German tendency to ad hoc
< previous page
page_139
next page >
< previous page
page_140
next page >
Page 140 Table 4.20 Rank ordering of exemplifiers introducing subordinate clauses English total: 308 French total: 651 German total: 580 as we (you) (can) see from/as can (may) be seen from (by) comme nous le voyons wie an folgendem (11): par cet exemple Beispiel zu erkennen ist …, as we see from such examples as comme on peut le voir ici wie aus dem letzten Flowering plants also respond to their environment, as shown by comme on peut le voir Beispiel ersichtlich (66) the charming example of Linnaeus, flower clock. sur les miniatures comme on voit avec/en (etc.)…(19) as is, for instance, the case in comme c’est/cela est le wie im Fall+Gen./von; as is the case with cas de/pour/ dans (etc.) etwa (83) …as is said to have been the case with (117) Zum Teil werden die… as we see in the case of (68) comme dans le cas (de Relationen such durch as in, as with, as for example (21) NP/qui suit [etc.] ) (100) Präpositionen ausgedrückt, etwa im Italienischen durch dopo. (14) Elle est bien connue des …, wie allein schon der grammairiens, au travers kurze Ausflug in die d’exemples comme celui- Welt des Behaviorismus ci: (0) zeigt (328) as strikingly exemplified by comme/ainsi que le …, wie aus/bei…deutlich as shown by montre (nt) (238): wird (24) as illustrated by comme le montre …, wie aus…sichthch (23) as reflected in l’exemple suivant, …, wie…verdeutlicht (17) as evidenced by prisdans Hemingway …, wie…sehr gut as amply demonstrated by (etc.) (202) comme en témoigne veranschaulicht (3) (118) …, wie…klar ergibt (2) comme le démontre (16) …., wie es uns…deutlich comme en atteste(nt) (5) vor Augen führen (etc.) comme en fait/font foi (0) (3) (as) witness (6): En témoigne (ADV) NP: So (z.B.) in/auf/bei (20) But the imaginative play in which she indulges seems to be less En témoigne l’excellent transcendence of power relations than their aestheticization in exemple que propose… the form of sadomasochistic fantasy. Witness her first words in (25) the shrubbery… Ainsi dans (10) Témoin NP (0) A preuve NP: (0) A titre d’exemple+NP (0) Note English thus, French ainsi and German so were not taken into account here because they are highly frequent oneword markers. Their use in nominal constructions has so far passed unnoticed in the lexicography of English and French; the great bulk of these realize a succession of two clause elements ( thus +NP: The first part of Granger’s investigation focuses on restricted collocations, specifically on amplifiers functioning as modifiers of adjectives (thus, bitterly cold, unbearably ugly); ainsi+NP: ainsi celle de de Gaulle)
< previous page
page_140
next page >
< previous page
page_141
next page >
Page 141 Table 4.21 Miscellaneous exemplifiers English French German say/let us say disons (par exemple) sagen wir einmal among which dont darunter including à titre d’indication beispielhaft for the sake of example formulation which stands in marked contrast with English and French reliance on stock phrases. Further, the frequency data obtained from the parallel corpora show that French exemplifiers occur with considerably higher frequency than English or German items. There is thus empirical support for the hitherto unfounded claim (see Vinay and Darbelnet 1958:222) that, on average, French writers make more extensive use of connectors than their English or German counterparts. This finding has clear implications for the practice and teaching of writing and translation. The frequency counts have also illustrated a principle familiar from other areas of corpus-driven lexicography: just as the commonest meanings of words have been shown to be many times more frequent than their next commonest meanings (Sinclair 1991), so too some standard realizations of SLDMs have a far higher likelihood of occurrence than other items. Finally, there is also some evidence of a correlation between length of SLDM types and frequency of occurrence, although less so in German than in English and French. The translation problems posed by exemplifiers are usually easy to solve, with the exception of collocational gaps: a noun-verb collocation such as exemple+donner, which cannot be translated literally when it encodes a relational process, may turn out to be a pitfall even for the experienced translator. The same holds true for noun-adjective collocations such as exemple+criant. As is evident from such examples, this section also has important implications for linguistics and lexicography at large. It suggests that collocations, far from being mechanical combinations of single words, may be subject to syntactic, semantic or pragmatic constraints. Such constraints need to be mentioned in collocational and other dictionaries (see Part II, and Siepmann 2002b, 2003a). 4.2 Reformulators and resumers Reformulators are a group of much greater compass and heterogeneity than their current lexicographic coverage suggests. Syntactically speaking, reformulators place two clausal units in an appositional relationship. Within the clause the reformulator usually comes before the syntagm it
< previous page
page_141
next page >
< previous page
page_142
next page >
Page 142 bears on (also called ‘second appositive’), as shown by the preliminary examples below: But this still leaves substantial scope for variation in the balance a society places on individual rights versus responsibilities—or, to put it another way, in the emphasis on the individual versus the community. (CAE) «une théorie de la contextualisation des énoncés», c’est-à-dire finalement une branche de la sociolinguistique. (CAF) Diese unübersichtliche Agglomeration mit so vielen Zentren und Vierteln, den abrupten und unverständlichen Ubergängen von gepflegten zu heruntergekommenen Straßenzügen, den verwirrenden Highways und Freeways und Boulevards, das ist das pure Gegenteil der herkömmlichen europäischen Stadtidee. In Zahlen: Das Häusermeer von L.A.und Umgebung erstreckt sich auf einer Länge von rund 200 Kilometern entlang des Pazifiks und einer Tiefe von rund 150 Kilometern ins Landesinnere. (NG) There are, however, a few exceptions to this rule, notably to be precise, in other words and reformulators of the type to put it+adverbial, pour +INF, um…zu +INF; these may also stand after the second appositive: The President of the United States, Richard Nixon in other words, was on television last night. ( Quirk et al. 1972:628) Aujourd’hui les sociétés industrialisées numérisent—digitalisent pour employer un anglicisme devenu populaire… (Monet 1995:15) The struggle between Athens and Macedon—between the forces of freedom and those of tyranny to put it rhetorically perhaps—is nearly overshadowed by the dramatic and unyielding battle waged by Aeschines and Demosthenes in the courts and assemblies of Athens. (CAE) With these syntactic facts in view, reformulation may be defined as ‘a rewording in the second appositive of the lexical content of the first’ (Quirk et al. 1972:631) without specifying the order of the appositives (i.e. the second appositive may also come before the first). It will be noted that the second appositive only notionally provides identical content; rather, from the RST perspective adopted here, it serves to provide additional information with a view to enhancing the reader’s understanding of the
< previous page
page_142
next page >
< previous page
page_143
next page >
Page 143 writer’s intended meaning, thus realizing the equivalence relation termed ‘elaboration’. 4.2.1 Types of reformulators Reformulators may be categorized in a number of ways, of which the most obvious is by source of rewording. This helps us to distinguish between ‘self-reformulators, which introduce a reformulation by the author herself, and ‘other’-reformulators which precede a quotation from a secondary source which the author considers authoritative or witty. There is, of course, considerable overlap between the two classes, and the distinction is more a theoretical than a practically useful one. Some examples follow. 1 Self-reformulators: or rather or more precisely put 2 Other-reformulators: to borrow a well-known formula Aristote le dit lui-même ailleurs As is evident from these examples, the majority of other-reformulators may be included among the class of attributors. Indeed, reformulation often goes hand in hand with citation, as appears from the following example, where the writer, having referred the reader to one of his sources for more detailed discussion, proceeds to pitch the source’s main point in a nutshell: For details, see Dowd (1994, 1995). Briefly put, the central bank would create a new type of financial instrument (CAE) With discourse devices such as to borrow a well-known formula, where no specific personal reference is made, we may regard as the source of the attribution the academic or speech community at large or, more usually, a specific section thereof. The difference with self-reformulators is that this type of rewording is based on factual rather than linguistic knowledge (see below). A second possible categorization is by type of rewording. This helps us to distinguish three cases (Quirk et al. 1972:631–632): 1 The reformulation is based on linguistic knowledge, in which case the discourse following the reformulator is synonymous with that immediately preceding it: terminological inexactitude, in other words a lie (NE)
< previous page
page_143
next page >
< previous page
page_144
next page >
Page 144 2 The reformulation is based on world knowledge. This is often the case with proper nouns: Fred—or Ginger as he is usually called—… ( Quirk et al. 1972:631) 3 The reformulation provides a correction of, or lends greater precision to, what preceded: They started going to the Church, the Catholic Church to be precise. ( Quirk et al. 1972:631) Here again there are uncertain boundaries between the three classes, especially between the first and the second. Lastly, distinctions may be established according to semantic-pragmatic criteria, yielding four main classes, which for lack of better designations we will term ‘pure reformulators and resumers’, ‘gradational reformulators’, ‘repetitional reformulators’ and ‘reformulatory stance markers’. We shall now look at the first three of these classes in greater detail. The fourth class has been excluded from discussion as reformulatory stance markers (such as strictly speaking) were found to be so numerous that they would deserve book-length treatment in their own right. 4.2.2 Pure reformulators Pure reformulators are a fairly small group with relatively distinct border-lines. Table 4.22 provides a broad overview of the devices in question. We are here concerned only with the reformulatory and resuming functions of pure reformulators. Needless to say, they may well do other jobs as well. Thus, besides enabling pure reformulation, the adverb kurz, for example, may also serve to introduce an ironic comment on the preceding discourse. Borrowing from Murat and Cartier-Bresson’s (1987) study on c’est-à-dire, I distinguish two basic modes of pure reformulation, which can be further subdivided. Let us first look at a few examples: (1a) For example, any actor linked to an end actor, that is, any actor that has a partner for whom it is the only partner, is necessarily strong. (CAE) Pour les autres, les ‘ciblistes’, c’est-à-dire ceux qui veulent privilégier à tout prix le texte en langue cible, la traduction doit être conçue de façon à ce que le lecteur appelé à la lire ne se rende pas compte qu’il se trouve en présence d’une traduction. (CAF) (1b) Ce Premier Moteur peut-il être assimilé sans difficulté au Dieu transcendant dont Aristote semblait pressentir l’existence à travers la
< previous page
page_144
next page >
< previous page
page_145
Page 145 Table 4.22 An overview of pure reformulators English French in other words en d’autres termes to put it (in) another way en d’autres mots to put it (somewhat) differently pour le dire en d’autres termes pour le dire en d’autres mots stated another way autrement dit stated differently dit autrement put differently ou formulé autrement put another way dit autrement encore stated alternatively pour le dire autrement equivalently pour dire la même chose autrement disons les choses autrement that is (peut-on dire pourrait-on dire pour ainsi dire en quelque that is to say sorte) which is to say namely i.e. meaning c’est-à-dire viz. je veux dire (etc.) to wit alias soit or (also) called (etc.) literally in ordinary/plain English for short hereafter/henceforth
zero connector
ou qu’est/que fut (etc.) encore appelé (etc.) en bon français en français moderne traduisez en abrégé désormais/ci-après …justement/précisément
zero connector
next page > German mit anderen Worten mit anderen Worten ausgedrückt in anderen Worten in anderen Worten gesagt oder anders (oder) anders ausgedrückt anders gesagt anders gesprochen anders formuliert anders herum formuliert heißt das oder umgekehrt formuliert d.h. (das heißt) also eben sprich alias in Zahlen oder (auch) bzw. resp. kurz auch…nnt (etc.) vulgo im Volksmund auf gut Deutsch gesagt im folgenden/fortan zero connector
structure intelligible (c’est-à-dire, en fait, mathématique) du Ciel étoilé? (CAF) il aime trop à ‘corriger la fortune’—en d’autres termes à tricher. (NF) (2) The earlier specification called for an ensemble of seven, including only two continuo players, that is. an organist and a viola da gamba player. (CAE) La question se pose de savoir si les pays qui ont adhere aux institutions de la francophonie, c’est-à-dire l’Albanie, la Bulgarie, la
< previous page
page_145
next page >
< previous page
page_146
next page >
Page 146 Macédoine, la Moldavie, la Pologne et la Roumanie, peuvent y être intégrés. (CAF) In the sentences grouped under (1a) the writers use the reformulators that is and c’est-à-dire to gloss the technical terms end actor and ciblistes, respectively. Generalizing from this, we can say that one function of pure reformulators is to define a concept by reference to a number of criterial features determining the applicability of the concept; put differently, pure reformulators serve to signal intensional definitions, a use we shall refer to as their ‘intensional’ mode. As the sentences grouped under (1b) attest, such definitions may be either denotative or connotative. Thus, in the first of these sentences, intelligible and mathématique plainly do not refer to the same concepts; rather, the two appositives are connotatively associated only in the writer’s (and the reader’s) mind—other humans may not automatically associate comprehensibility with mathematical rigour. Things are somewhat different with group (2). Here the meaning of the syntagma les pays qui ont adhéré aux institutions de la francophonie does not need glossing, but the average reader may ask herself which countries it applies to. By drawing up a complete list of these countries in the discourse lying to the right of c’est-à-dire, the writer provides an extensional definition, so that this mode of reformulation may be termed ‘extensional’. Murat and Cartier-Bresson (1987:12) distinguish three subtypes of this mode, based on, respectively, specification, co-reference and quantification, exemplified in turn in the following extracts from my corpora: Le droit dérivé, c’est-à-dire les règlements, directives, décisions, recommandations et avis adoptés par les institutions communautaires doit ainsi être en conformité avec les dispositions du droit communautaire primaire relatives à la concurrence tels que les articles 85, 86, 90 TCE. (CAF) On n’aperçoit pas comment il pourrait en être autrement puisque le traité prévoit qu’elle ne «lie» que ses «destinataires», c’est-à-dire les Etats. (CAF) l’abrogation d’un règlement devenu illégal par suite des changements de circonstances n’était obligatoire que si la demande intervenait dans le délai de recours (c’est-à-dire deux mois) (CAF) Despite the theoretical and practical utility of these distinctions, it should be borne in mind that not all authentic examples are amenable to neat classification. A comparison of two studies on c’est-à-dire (Murat and Cartier-Bresson 1987 and Fløttum 1994) highlights the uncertain boundaries between its diverse real-life uses. Thus, in one of its modes we find c’est-à-dire accompanied by en fait, finalement or en clair . As is apparent from
< previous page
page_146
next page >
< previous page
page_147
next page >
Page 147 the semantics of en fait, finalement and en clair, these collocations usually introduce a subjective re-evaluation of the first appositive: «une théorie de la contextualisation des énoncés», c’est-à-dire finalement une branche de la sociolinguistique. (CAF) The point is that, if the human analyst focuses on the logical relationship obtaining between the two appositives, as do Murat and Cartier-Bresson (1987:12), she will construe this sequence as a consecutive structure (‘structure consécutive’), i.e. a subjective variant of an intensional definition; c’est-à-dire is roughly equivalent to donc here. If, on the other hand, she focuses on the semantic relationship between the two appositives, as does Fløttum (1994), she might construe the second appositive as a more precise replacement (‘remplacement’) of the first, with the semes of the lexemes appearing in the second appositive being substituted for one or more semes of the lexemes contained in the first appositive. As explained in the introduction, RST takes such analytical vagaries into account. Nevertheless the above insights should lead to a revision of RST theory insofar as relations obtaining between syntagms below clause level need to be integrated into RST. Pure reformulation may then be described as ‘elaboration’ (rather than ‘restatement’) between text elements, sequences or segments and may be defined thus (see Section 4.2 above): the satellite presents additional detail about some or all of the information contained in the nucleus, or inferentially accessible in the nucleus, in one or more of the ways listed below: 1 set: member 2 abstract: instance 3 whole: part 4 process: step 5 object: attribute 6 generalization: specific This assumes that relations 5 and 6 include co-reference and quantification, although this is not explicitly stated in Mann and Thompson (1988:273). I shall now proceed to offer monolingual analyses of pure reformulators in English, French and German, and then discuss similarities and divergences with the added help of the multilingual corpus. 4.2.2.1 Pure reformulators in English In other words; put another way (etc.) The vast majority of pure reformulators can be found linking units of varying length ranging from short elements to entire text segments. Such is the case with the set of which in other words is the paradigm; the
< previous page
page_147
next page >
< previous page
page_148
next page >
Page 148 members of this set usually realize the intensional mode, with a clear predominance of connotative definitions. Contrast the following examples, noting the various types of punctuation used: Those capacities, all present in men but apparently generally stronger (perhaps partly by reason of hemispheric morphology) in women, include—though doubtless are not limited to—acute sensitivity to changes in the immediate environment, fine-motor skills, an ability to detect and formulate small sensory distinctions, a keen sense of affective/biological relevance, a tolerance for differing or contradictory points of view and the inconsistencies of their interplay, and (as Kramer and Woodruff observed) a powerful faculty for conceptual differentiation and categorization. The recognition of such capacities seems wholly appropriate in an age increasingly wary of objective universals, certainties, and absolutes (male narratives of sameness) and intent on intersubjective particulars, uncertainties, and relatives (female narratives of otherness). To put it another way, our age is witnessing and more or less self-consciously promoting a shift from ‘the grand narratives’ of knowledge to ‘the little narrative’; consequently, as Karlis Racevskis synthesizes a cognate argument, ‘the role of the “universal” intellectual has now given way to that of the “specific” intellectual, the savant or expert.’ (CAE) But this still leaves substantial scope for variation in the balance a society places on individual rights versus responsibilities—or, to put it another way, in the emphasis on the individual versus the community. (CAE) it might be a temporary depression: in other words a suicide wish (CAE) Another feature of this set is that it can introduce affirmative statements as well as questions: I would like to suggest that the solution to this verse is not in grammar or text-critical questions, but in punctuation. To put it another way, why do we assume that…part of the report to Joab? (CAE) Some of the less-common replacements of in other words may also be found in conjunction with attributors: Or to put it somewhat differently, in the words of Joshua Fishman: (CAE) In other words may also realize the extensional/quantificational mode: in the year 2006, in other words in ten years’ time (CAE)
< previous page
page_148
next page >
< previous page
page_149
next page >
Page 149 That is That is can stand as the paradigm of another type of pure reformulator whose most general function is to introduce a more detailed restatement of what goes before. It is close in function to in other words, namely and to be precise, but unlike these it can introduce both intensional and extensional definitions. Like in other words it has scope over differing amounts of the preceding discourse, as aptly illustrated by the following two examples: Only two of these forms of learning can be used to create sophisticated representational systems. These forms of learning are ‘discrimination’ learning (99) and ‘observational’ learning (119). A third form of learning cannot by itself be used to create sophisticated representational systems. What I will call ‘developmental’ learning is the kind of learning which takes place as the result of native capacities which come ‘on-line’ at various points in the developmental process. That is, an organism acquires, or ‘learns,’ new capacities as biological systems mature (92– 93). Since these capacities cannot be substantially altered once they are acquired, this form of learning cannot be used (exclusively) to create a sophisticated representational system. (CAE) Be sure to answer the question that is asked completely, that is, answer all parts of the question. (CAE) The last of the above examples is the best illustration of the mode of that is which closely resembles in other words . In academic writing, this mode often introduces denotative and connotative intensional definitions: A hypersolid, that is, a portion of four-dimensional space, may be separated into two parts by a three-space. (CAE) In this way a truly Western Buddhism might be developed; that is a Buddhism that takes cognizance of and addresses those areas of concern that are of particular importance to those who are attempting to work for creative transformation in the West. (CAE) If the definition amplifies the preceding discourse rather than just explaining it, as it does in the last of the above examples, that is is synonymous with namely . Here is one more example of this mode: Scott (1986) advocates a third usage of the term gender, that is, as an analytical category for understanding the ‘complex connections among various forms of human interaction’. (CAE) In stark contrast to in other words, that is may also introduce a correction:
< previous page
page_149
next page >
< previous page
page_150
next page >
Page 150 Over seventy years before Drumcree and Portadown, the IRA, with the help of a well-organized Sinn Fein, gained Irish Independence from British rule. From their conceptions, both organizations struggled to rally ubiquitous Irish support; that is, until a failed 1916 rising in Dublin resulted in the execution of 15 young ring leaders—stirring Irish nationalism to a boil. (CAE) In its extensional mode, that is can introduce specification, co-reference and, more rarely, quantification. In the first of the following examples of specificative uses, that is may well be replaced by namely (or to be precise, which is not discussed here): The earlier specification called for an ensemble of seven, including only two continuo players, that is, an organist and a viola da gamba player. (CAE) So far, there seems to be just one agreement signed under this law, that is, the one between Australia and the United States. (CAE) Let’s say that an acre-foot of desalinated water—that is, 325, 851 gallons—costs $700 or $1,900 in 1992 dollars (depending on how you figure), as in Santa Barbara, California. (CAE) When the clause following that is begins with the same subject as the preceding clause, pronominal substitution is the rule: As has long been recognized, speech communities are frequently plurilingual, that is, they encompass speakers who belong to more than one language. (CAE) i.e., meaning, namely, υiz., to wit Derived from Latin id est and invariably abbreviated, i.e. is a common variant of that is which may serve the same functions, with the exception of the intensional mode in which that is sees service as an equivalent of in other words, referring back to long stretches of the preceding discourse. It is preferred over that is at the beginning of bracketed syntagmas serving to introduce a list or an amplification of the meaning of the first appositive: 4. Expenditures on a historic structure where the owners failed to obtain certification, and 5. Expenditures for personal property items (i.e., drapes, office equip., furniture, and certain carpeting). (CAE) Thus the Friesian theory has an interesting symmetry: with respect to the immanent, feeling and concept are united in empirical knowledge and understanding, while with respect to the transcendent, feeling
< previous page
page_150
next page >
< previous page
page_151
next page >
Page 151 (Ahndung) and concept (Glaube) both exist but are separate, i.e. we do not and cannot know how to combine them into the same kind of knowledge of the transcendent that we have of the immanent. (CAE) The diagrams on the left hand side demonstrate the processing of a target item (i.e. an item that was present in the two item study list). (CAE) One specific mode of i.e. can be glossed as ‘which here means’. It introduces a specific definition relevant only to the current text: newly independent countries were advised to nationalize foreign holdings and limit capitalist exploitation (i.e. foreign investment) (CAE) Though namely and υiz . are roughly synonymous, the latter, still common in legal parlance, seems to be falling out of use. There is less than one instance to be found in one million words of academic text. Both markers have an extensional mode in which they serve to specify the entities or ideas that have been announced in the preceding discourse. They are thus close in function to the colon, which is often substituted for them in contemporary usage: He identifies five general modes of ideological operation, namely legitimation, dissimulation, unification, fragmentation and reification. (CAE) To this generalisation there is one exception, namely Japan. (CAE) He adduces evidence that other important features of the myth, viz., the spherical earth and the ‘true earth’, are borrowings from Pythagorean cosmology. (CAE) His criticism is levelled at two key concepts, viz. ‘skopos’ and ‘action’ (Handlung). (CAE) In a variant of the specificative mode not shared by υiz., namely may occur in non-restrictive appositive clauses: The great characteristic of equitable estates, namely that they will be destroyed if the legal estate gets into the hands of a purchaser for value without notice, still holds good. (CAE) In its intensional mode, which is not shared by υiz . and has been overlooked by dictionary makers, namely may introduce whole sentences, much as denotative that is does:
< previous page
page_151
next page >
< previous page
page_152
next page >
Page 152 One reading of The cat is behind the truck is similar to The cat is behind the tree; namely it has the truck or tree between speaker or viewer on the one hand, and the cat on the other. (CAE) In their intensional modes, that is and namely are not always interchangeable. When the first appositive is preceded by the indefinite article or by a numeral, that is is excluded: In ‘Reading Female Flesh: Amores 3.1’ Maria Wyke attempts to shed new light on an old crux, namely/*that is in what sense or to what degree ‘“The Elegiac Woman”’ represents historical reality or poetic fiction. (CAE) Another occasional variant of namely is to wit, although it seems to be more common in American English than in British English. Although evidence of to wit is relatively sparse in modern texts, a tendency seems discernible for the device to introduce figures, i.e. to function in an extensional, quantificational mode: It was in this context that Ambassador Kantor—again, following the script—separately issued the Clinton administration’s unilateral estimates that the agreement would lead to vast increases in purchases and market access. To wit: $6.75 billion in increased sales of U.S. parts to the Japanese transplants by 1998; $2.25 billion in increased parts sales to Japan; and 200 new American car dealerships in Japan by the end of this year, increasing to 1,000 by the end of the decade (CAE) (also) called, alternatively named (etc.) Among the most common of pure reformulators is a set which has so far received scant attention. Functionally, this set may be described as extensional/co-referential. It is based on an adverb+past participle collocation drawing on a small number of verbs: know, call, refer to, name, describe and term . While it may just indicate an alternative name for a particular object or idea (also called, otherwise called, alternatiυely named, sometimes referred to as, υariously known as), it is more commonly used to suggest frequency of use (usually called, often termed) as well as diachronic (anciently known as, now called, traditionally called, originally called) , stylistic (popularly known as, technically known as) or geographical (known as…in the US) variation. Here is an example: These radiations, also called ‘super-soft roentgen rays’ (CAE) Oddly enough, the pure reformulator υariously called/known as (etc.) is commonly employed to refer to just two alternatives (although in
< previous page
page_152
next page >
< previous page
page_153
next page >
Page 153 its dictionary sense the adjective υarious refers to a number greater than two): another type of social system variously referred to as the Asiatic, or oriental mode of production. (CAE) The pure reformulators called, usually called (etc.) are sometimes replaced by parentheses: English orthography consists of the set of letters (the alphabet) and their variant forms (e.g. capitals, lower-case), the spelling system, and the set of punctuation marks. (CAE) For short, rather than any of the above, is used to introduce an abbreviation or a shortened reformulation of the preceding discourse; it may precede or follow its referent: part of a worldwide program identified as the International Geophysical Year, IGY for short. (CAE) DOE Complex or, for short, Complex, is a term that denotes all of the DOE sites taken together. (CAE) The same kind of function is more commonly served by parentheses (i.e. the zero connector): the United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF) (CAE) In mathematical or quasi-mathematical contexts the reformulator equiυalently may sometimes be used. A search in CAE reveals that it mainly occurs in texts on economics; rather than indicating pure reformulation, it normally serves to put two measures on a par: Different vintages of the durable good are available in the market: let i index the vintage (equivalently, age) of the good. A new car is age 1. (CAE) Other items to be grouped among pure reformulators are the adverbs henceforth/hereafter and their variants hereafter termed/hereafter abbreυiated (as)/henceforth referred to as/cited hereafter as, which/whom we will henceforth call or I will refer to these as . They serve to introduce a convenient shorthand for a technical term, a book title or a proper name, usually in the form of an initialism which will then be consistently used throughout the subsequent discourse. Predictably, when used in footnotes, hereafter collocates strongly with such phrases as in (the) text and in parentheses. Albeit quite common,
< previous page
page_153
next page >
< previous page
page_154
next page >
Page 154 this use of hereafter and henceforth has not yet found its way into the major dictionaries of the English language. Examples: where at least one Dennettian agent (henceforth, a DA) has control over the outcome of the set of acts, and where the DAs are potentially in conflict (CAE) Giorgio Morandi pittore (Milan: Edizioni del Milione, 1965), hereafter abbreviated GMP. (CAE) Notes 1 Hereafter cited in the text as Letters of PBS . (CAE) Finally, alias is used to introduce an alternative name for a person: The scholar, Hans Schwerter, alias Hans-Ernst Schneider, faces accusations that he was responsible for supplying medical equipment to be used for experiments on human subjects interned in concentration camps. (NE) or An idiomatic feature of English is the use of or as a pure reformulator indicating that the second oppositive is equivalent to the first. Its function may therefore be described as extensional/co-referential. If we omit from consideration those cases where it serves to coordinate clause-length units (he is, or belieυes that he is, a genius), we may distinguish four main functions: or serves (1) to introduce a translation, (2) to introduce the substitution of untechnical language for a specialist term, (3) to signal the expression of one unit of measurement in terms of another, usually more familiar one, (4) to mark the translation of absolute into relative figures or vice versa. It is more than twice as frequent in newspaper language as in academic prose. The following sentences provide typical examples: Indeed, Gandhi’s technique of non-violent struggle essentially included persuasion. Satyagraha, or Truth Force,’ was before all else a way to win over the ‘enemy’ and make him a friend. (CAE) The technology, pioneered by Professor Richard Friend, a physicist at Cambridge University, substitutes light-emitting polymers (LEPs), or plastics, for traditional semi-conductor materials that make display screens. (NE) Only 11, or 18% of the doctors knew the answer. (NE) On average, 19%, or 19 cents on the dollar. (NE)
< previous page
page_154
next page >
< previous page
page_155
next page >
Page 155 In the first of these modes, or has a common equivalent in the adverb literally: There (1377) he wrote the Muqaddama al-Alamat, literally Introduction to the Uniυerse . (CAE) The use of or as a reformulator usually requires that it be preceded by a comma. Or also has a gradational mode, which is dealt with in Section 4.2.3. Some reformulators show a strong tendency to co-occur with or: that they unlawfully killed, or in plain English murdered, our loved ones. (NE) In our earlier discussion of utility, the only meaningful statements were of the form ‘A has more utility to me than B’ or, equivalently, ‘I prefer A to B.’ (CAE) Or can also combine with phrases such as ‘as it is now known’, ‘as it is (better/fondly/generally) known (in the trade/locally/colloquially)’, ‘as it is called locally/in the report’ (etc.), which specifies the nature of the correction or the information source drawn on: At the time the Zeppelin was a highly charged electrical machine or battery as it were, insulated by the surrounding air. (CAE) In this mode the order of the appositives may sometimes be inverted: Sex or, as it’s more commonly known in England, ‘that-thing-we-do-when-EastEnders-has-finished’. (NE) Table 4.23 summarizes the results of our investigation so far. 4.2.2.2 Pure reformulators in French En d’autres termes French has at its disposal a large set of words of which en d’autres termes is the paradigm. Strikingly, only a few of these have been recorded in the dictionaries. Even Grieve (1996) overlooks en d’autres mots, which has passed into general use. Common variants are autrement dit and dit autrement; other variants such as pour dire la même chose autrement have only limited currency. The members of this set function in the intensional mode and can be followed by both connotative and denotative definitions. Unlike c’est-à-dire, they cannot be used to introduce a correction (Murat and Cartier-Bresson 1987:10).
< previous page
page_155
next page >
< previous page
page_156
next page >
Page 156 Table 4.23 Summary of the functions of English pure reformulators Mode/function Intensional ExtensionalSpecificatiυeCoQuantificational referential in other words, put another way, etc. yes — — — yes that is (cannot follow numerals and yes yes yes yes yes indefinite article) i.e. yes, but cannot link text yes yes yes — segments namely possible (denotative), but yes yes — — rare viz. — yes yes — — to wit — yes yes — — also called — yes — yes — or — yes — yes —
< previous page
page_156
next page >
< previous page
page_157
next page >
Page 157 Grieve (1996:115) is wrong in claiming that ‘a mode with que is sometimes used’ as a variant of autrement dit . As the following examples show, what at first blush may look like a special mode is simply a coordinate series of clauses depending on the same verb, yet separated by a full stop. The que need not always be a repetition of a preceding que, as Grieve (ibid.) maintains; it is sufficient for the verb in the preceding sentence to admit a clausal complement, as attested by the second example: Ceux-ci insistent sur la responsabilité des budgets sociaux dans l’inflation, sur l’effet pernicieux de l’assistance qui brise l’esprit d’initiative et crée une mentalité d’assistés et surtout démontrent, courbe de Laffer à l’appui, qu’il existe une relation inverse entre le taux d’imposition et les recettes fiscales; autrement dit que ‘trop d’impôt tue l’impôt’. (CAF) Le principe d’équivalence joue un rôle essentiel dans la construction de la théorie; il pose (en principe) l’égalité de la masse inerte et de la masse grave. Autrement dit, que toutes les particules et ce, quelle que soit leur composition physico-chimique, «tombent» de la même manière. (CAF) It should be noted that we are not dealing with a specificity of autrement dit: other members of the set can fulfil the same function; indeed, the coordination of syntagmas of identical grammatical structure is a central feature of this paradigm as well as of reformulators in general: Il importe toutefois que l’emprunteur démontre qu’il y avait un lien causal entre la faute et son dommage, en d’autres mots, qu’il aurait pu obtenir de l’assurance ailleurs (CAF) il aime trop à ‘corriger la fortune’—en d’autres termes à tricher. (NF) c’est le parallélisme strict entre syntaxe et sémantique, ou, dit autrement, le caractère compositionnel de la sémantique (CAF) The pure reformulator dit autrement is the only member of the paradigm to have an established variant capable of introducing a second or third rewording: dit autrement encore. In the following example, the author, having just used a term of Leibniz’s to define the ‘machine’ under discussion, appears to feel the need to provide another definition. Note that attributor (pour reprendre un terme de X) and reformulator here go hand in hand: De quoi est faite cette machine? Tout ce que l’on peut en dire pour l’instant, c’est qu’elle est l’expression et l’exprimé de l’activité de tous
< previous page
page_157
next page >
< previous page
page_158
next page >
Page 158 ces intermédiaires, des déplacements dont ils sont le siège et/ou les relais, de ces artefacts matériels et/ou idéels qui composent ensemble, qui ne cessent de s’entre-exprimer pour reprendre un terme de Leibniz, tout en les surplombant tel un virtuel qui ne s’actualiserait que de manière locale et fragmentaire. Dit autrement encore, elle est donc pour partie l’expression et l’exprimé des processus variés qui participent de la ‘stabilisation conjointe de tels ou tels arrangements hybrides dans lesquels éléments dits techniques et éléments dits sociaux, éléments dits humains et éléments dits non-humains etc. sont indissociablement entremêlés’ (CAF) C’est-à-dire (que) C’est-à-dire (que) serves to introduce what the writer considers a more precise rewording of more or less extended stretches of the preceding discourse. In other words, it helps the writer to interpret the first appositive lying to the left of c’est-à-dire as a linguistic sign whose denotative or connotative meaning, as defined by the writer, is given in the second appositive, or vice versa: a) Dans les sociétés qui font un appel public à l’épargne, c’est-à-dire toutes les sociétés cotées en Bourse et quelques autres suivant le degré de diffusion de leur capital, la C.O.B. veille à la qualité et à la fréquence des informations publiées par les entreprises. (CAF) b) Les savants les plus illustres, surtout au XVIIe siècle, se sont penchés sur ce problème et ont cherché à réaliser un régulateur ayant sa période propre, c’est-à-dire un résonateur. (EU) When the ‘linguistic sign’ occurs in the first appositive (a), the relation may bedescribed as one of ‘explanation’; in the opposite case (b), it may be described as ‘denomination’ (Fløttum 1994:118–119). It may be observed that in its denominative function c’est-à-dire can be replaced by en d’autres termes. Such clear examples of the explanatory and denominative modes as those given above are, however, comparatively rare. In a variant of the intensional mode already discussed at the beginning of this section on pure reformulators we find c’est-à-dire accompanied by en fait, finalement or en clair . These collocations usually introduce a subjective reevaluation of the first appositive: «une théorie de la conte xtualisation des énoncés», c’est-à-dire finalement une branche de la sociolinguistique. (CAF) C’est-à-dire likewise collocates with en l’occurrence and its variants en l’espèce and en la circonstance. These variants act to restrict the scope of the intensional definition provided:
< previous page
page_158
next page >
< previous page
page_159
next page >
Page 159 le commentateur applique à son corpus les critères de rationalité que lui-même tient pour les plus appropriés en philosophie, c’est-à-dire en l’occurrence ceux-là mêmes qui ont cours dans les discussions actuelles de la philosophie analytique. (CAF) The force of intensional c’est-à-dire may be modified by the addition of such reformulators as plus largement, plus précisément and plus explicitement: C’est, dans les termes mêmes de l’apôtre, celui de la «justice de Dieu», c’est-à-dire, plus explicitement, la justification de l’homme, par la foi, sans les œuvres de la loi (CAF) In its extensional mode, c’est-à-dire has the full range of functions, namely co-reference, specification and quantification, as attested by the following examples (see also Murat and Cartier-Bresson 1987:12): On n’aperçoit pas comment il pourrait en être autrement puisque le traité prévoit qu’elle ne «lie» que ses «destinataires», c’est-à-dire les Etats. (CAF) Le droit dérivé, c’est-à-dire les règlements, directives, décisions, recommandations et avis adoptés par les institutions communautaires doit ainsi être en conformité avec les dispositions du droit communautaire primaire relatives à la concurrence tels que les articles 85, 86, 90 TCE. (CAF) À partir de là, Descartes affirme être en mesure de fournir l’explication de tous les phénomènes naturels en utilisant les seules ressources des mathématiques, c’est-à-dire de la géométrie (CAF) l’abrogation d’un règlement devenu illégal par suite des changements de circonstances n’était obligatoire que si la demande intervenait dans le délai de recours (c’est-à-dire deux mois) (CAF) Fløttum (1994:120) distinguishes the specificative mode from the generalizing mode. In our terms the latter would be subsumed under the co-referential mode. The specificative mode is characterized by a descending order of generality, whereas the generalizing mode is charac terized by an ascending order of generality. An example of the latter mode follows: Car si l’autonomie de l’édifice renvoie à un modèle extérieur et premier, le corps, encore celui-ci sera-t-il inscriptible dans un cercle et dans un carré, c’est-à-dire dans un ordre. (EU)
< previous page
page_159
next page >
< previous page
page_160
next page >
Page 160 Leaving the functional value of c’est-à-dire, let us proceed to investigate its syntax. Grieve (1996:168) wrongly claims that que is inappropriate ‘when the structure is followed by a finite verb unaccompanied by a subject’; in actual fact, usage wavers, with most writers opting for the mode with que in the case under discussion: La plupart des langages utilisés en mathématiques (il n’en est pas de même en informatique) sont égalitaires, c’està-dire comprennent un symbole de relation binaire distingué appelé symbole d’égalité. (CAF) l’entreprise doit être adhérente à la confédération, c’est-à-dire qu’elle doit avoir cotisé. (CAF) Another syntactic point about c’est-à-dire is that it may be directly followed by a past participle clarifying or enhancing other attributive structures such as adjectives. This is indeed quite common: Dans les relations avec les États, les citoyens et les différents partenaires, le seul domaine auquel le régime linguistique s’applique dans toute son étendue est celui des documents officiels, c’est-à-dire adoptés par les organes décisionnels, qui sont tous traduits et diffusés en onze langues. (CAF) Grieve (1996:169) claims that structural parallelism between previous and subsequent contexts is a constant feature of c’est-à-dire. This is a somewhat hasty conclusion from what must have been too small a corpus. The sentences quoted so far have provided a number of counter-examples, and so do some sentences in which c’est-à-dire is followed by a subordinate clause beginning with conjunctions such as aυant que, lorsque or (même) si: Les programmes d’affects peuvent être déclenchés directement par les inputs subcorticaux, c’est-à-dire avant que l’intégration perceptuelle n’ait eu lieu. (CAF) Indeed, a grammatical peculiarity of this reformulator is that it may introduce substitutions not only of an entire preceding syntagma but of particular constituents thereof. Thus, in the first of the following examples, de personnes déjà identifiées elaborates on the attributive adjective nominatif, itself part of a complex noun phrase, and in the second example, de quinte, de quarte and d’unisson link back to en consonance, which is part of the longer prepositional phrase en rapport de consonance . ils sont utilisés pour la constitution d’un fichier nominatif, c’est-à-dire de personnes déjà identifiées. (CAF)
< previous page
page_160
next page >
< previous page
page_161
next page >
Page 161 cette nouvelle ligne descend et vice versa, les deux lignes devant se trouver constamment en rapport de consonance, c’est-à-dire de quinte, de quarte (qui est le renversement de la quinte) ou d’unisson. (EU) A final point on the syntax of c’est-à-dire: unlike à savoir, to be discussed next, its extensional mode does not allow the first appositive to be preceded by numerals or the indefinite article (Murat and Cartier-Bresson 1987:12). car il y a exactement un nombre égal à 0, à savoir/*c’est-à-dire 0 An occasional variant of the intensional mode of c’est-à-dire que is a parallel structure linked by c’est, each part of which contains an infinitive: Vouloir, c’est pouvoir. Choisir, c’est à la fois éprouver et goûter, apprécier la saveur des choses, c’est aussi préférer, donc sélectionner et renoncer. (CAF) Also, s’entend, albeit usually viewed as a variant of bien entendu, may be seen as a specialized variant of the intensional mode (see Grieve 1996:171). Witness the following example: Il est même possible que la lecture, celle de la littérature s’entend, soit le symptôme d’une secrète maladie de la personnalité. (NF) Grieve (ibid.) identifies another possible replacement in je veux dire, although this may equally well be described as a gradational reformulator equivalent to ou plutôt. Note that this item, by virtue of containing a first-person pronoun, bestows a more personal touch on the definition: Pour être plus précis, Vichy je veux dire sa mémoire me semble au croisement de deux grands phénomènes…(CAF) à savoir à savoir can be used in both the intensional and extensional modes, its main function being that of specification. In its extensional/specificative mode, it is not normally interchangeable with c’est-à-dire, as witness the following examples: (1) La ‘novlangue’ telle que présentée par Orwell (6) me paraissait bien représenter ce que je ressentais profondément, à savoir que/*c’est-à-dire que le langage est aussi un pouvoir, qu’elle est une manifestation humaine si puissante qu’elle peut modifier les hommes, leurs pensées, et leurs actes. (CAF)
< previous page
page_161
next page >
< previous page
page_162
next page >
Page 162 (2) Certaines dysharmonies organiques constituent une gêne au bon fonctionnement du larynx, à savoir/*c’est-àdire: de grandes cordes vocales avec un thorax étroit et de petites cavités de résonance; ou, inversement, de petites cordes vocales, une capacité pulmonaire importante et de grandes cavités de résonance. (EU) (3) Pourtant, elle fait dépendre un comportement, l’offre, d’un événement que le producteur a contribué à provoquer, à savoir/*c’est-à-dire le prix dans la période précédente, ou plus exactement, de la signification que l’acteur prête à l’événement, s’il croit que le prix courant sera fixé au niveau précédent. (EU) These examples show that determiner use, as discussed in the preceding section, is not the only factor blocking the use of c’est-à-dire. Whereas in the case of (3) one might argue that c’est-à-dire cannot be used because éυénement is preceded by the indefinite article, this syntactic line of reasoning is not available with the other examples. Rather, semantic considerations appear to play an important role in examples (1) and (2), where à saυoir has an announcing function reinforced by the wording of the preceding sentence, which on its own would lack closure. In (1) the relative clause ce que je ressentais profondément reveals that the writer is portraying a deeply felt insight and leads the reader to expect further specification of this insight in the subsequent discourse. In its extensional/co-referential mode, à saυoir is fully interchangeable with c’est-à-dire (Murat and Cartier-Bress on 1987:12). Diderot tient le gouvernail: l’Encyclopédie s’adresse à ce qu’il appelle le «peuple», à savoir/c’est-à-dire la collectivité des esprits éclairés. (CAF) Even in such cases, however, it might be argued that there is a difference between à saυoir and c’est-à-dire. A good illustration is provided by the following examples. If a writer wishes to stress that the primary purpose of a tapestry —by definition or common consent—is both to delight and to charm onlookers, then she will use à saυoir. If she wishes to emphasize that this is merely her personal view of a tapestry’s purpose, she might well use c’est-à-dire instead. In other words, à saυoir permits objective or denotative co-reference, c’est-à-dire subjective or connotative co-reference: En proposant leurs modèles, les peintres de cette époque donnèrent à la tapisserie le moyen d’honorer ses intentions premières, à savoir/c’est-à-dire de réjouir et d’enchanter. (EU) This is why c’est-à-dire would be rather unlikely in sentences such as the following, where a connotative intent is less obviously present:
< previous page
page_162
next page >
< previous page
page_163
next page >
Page 163 Car ce sont les problèmes de la mobilité sociale verticale qui sont socialement les plus brûlants, notamment dans les sociétés où la sociologie est développée, à savoir/c’est-à-dire les sociétés industrielles. (EU) à saυoir also has an intensional/denotative mode in which it is fully commutable with c’est-à-dire, a fact overlooked by Murat and Cartier-Bresson (1987). Examples: La tableau est un déictique, ou, pour parler comme les linguistes, un index (à savoir/c’est-à-dire un signe dont la signification dépend de sa co-présence avec son référent ou le contexte physique de son énonciation—tel «ici» ou «toi»): la figure du carré est un index du cadre (carré et cadre ont la même source étymologique) (EU) Les autres sont des groupes de «référence», à savoir/c’est-à-dire des groupes auxquels le sujet se réfère, qu’il y appartienne ou non. (EU) soit Now for soit, the commonest function of which is to indicate the substitutive character of a figure or an amount, as in le recensement de la fin de 1970 montre qu’environ 50 p. 100 de sa population (52,2 dans les villes, 47,8 à la campagne), soit 32589000 personnes, est en âge de travailler. (EU) As would be expected, in this extensional/quantificational mode the marker forms clusters with quantitative expressions which signal a summation, such as au total or un total de, indicate rise and fall, such as une hausse de, or mark an average, such as une moyenne de. In the same mode, it may indicate that the writer is about to provide additional, more accurate information; in the second example below it is close to il s’agit de. les Thaïlandais ne reconnaissent la nationalité chinoise qu’aux «Chinois nationaux», soit à 460000 individus, tandis que les Chinois eux-mêmes estiment être 3 millions. (CAF) la chaîne câblée diffuse en continu une sélection de films auxquels elle a participé en coproduction. Soit une quarantaine d’œuvres abordant les thèmes les plus variés: société, histoire, culture, sciences, musique…(NF) Lastly, it may be used to introduce an appended explanation of what preceded or an inference to be drawn from it; in this intensional/ connotative mode, it is commutable with c’est-à-dire.
< previous page
page_163
next page >
< previous page
page_164
next page >
Page 164 Le serveur, fort de sa base de données internationale, annonce 70000 offres d’emploi. Soit un choix intéressant pour tous ceux qui souhaitent s’expatrier. (NF) A syntactic point about soit evident from these examples is its tendency either to occur in a verbless clause of its own or to be inserted parenthetically within another clause—a special case of interpolated coordination. encore appelé, autrement nommé (etc.) The French set of which encore appelé may be seen as the paradigm has roughly the same size as the English set based on also called. One difference is that, for syntactic reasons, a relative clause is often preferred over a participial clause in French. The French set fulfils exactly the same extensional/co-referential function, that is, that of alternative naming (que nous (dé)nommons/appelons, encore/aussi/également nommé/appelé, autrement nommé/appelé, parfois appelé, diυersement désigné sous le nom de), often with specific emphasis on frequency (couramment appelé, généralement appelé, [plus] communément appelé), diachronic (alors nommé, anciennement nommé, autrefois nommé, que l’on a nommé), stylistic (joliment appelé, improprement appelé, ironiquement appelé, officiellement appelé, pudique ment appelé, plus simplement appelé, υulgairement appelé,…) or geographical variation (appelé localement, que les Américains appellent, que l’on appelle…outre-Rhin): un nombre très restreint d’éléments actifs, appelés éléments sources ou éléments fondateurs (CAF) la randonnée palmée (aussi appelée snorkelling) permet à ceux qui ne pratiquent pas la plongée de découvrir, eux aussi, la faune et la flore sous-marines. (NF) Cette relation appelée couramment ‘courbe de concordance’ permet de calculer des diamètres discriminants (CAF) Une nouvelle saison se cherche, diversement nommée: souveraineté, maturité, fête, ennui. (NF) Oddly, there is also an inverse mode of this reformulator, in which the second appositive provides the original name rather than the reformulation. In this case the reformulator comes after the second appositive: le Sentier lumineux reste lourd à digérer avec son culte stalinomaoïsant à la gloire du ’Président Gonzalo’ (Abimaël Guzman ainsi nommé), leader du Parti communiste péruvien-Sentier lumineux, emprisonné à vie depuis 1992. (NF)
< previous page
page_164
next page >
< previous page
page_165
next page >
Page 165 Pour faire court may serve to introduce a briefer rewording of a complex notion: Il faudrait définir les CD-ROM et CD-I comme des documents multimodaux interactifs a support numérique, ou, pour faire court comme des hyperdocuments. (CAF) En abrégé and its shortened form abrégé, which only occurs in brackets, have a similar function, with the difference that they refer more commonly to acronyms, initialisms or formulae. They may be placed before or after the phrase they qualify: Dans ce document, le terme générique grands inυestisseurs (ou GI en abrégé) désignera l’ensemble de ces points extrêmes, tandis que le terme extrapolables fera référence aux autres individus de l’échantillon. (CAF) Chacun des arcs est interprété comme signifiant «est sorte de» ou en abrégé «est-un». (CAF) Both en abrégé and its synonym siglé (en) have so far gone unrecorded in the major dictionaries of French: Des termes d’action: broyage, extraction, centrifugation, chromatographie pas de gaz, siglée en CPG…) (Siglé) désormais serves to introduce a convenient shorthand for a technical term, a book title or a proper name, usually in the form of an initialism which will then be consistently used throughout the subsequent discourse. There are three major variants of this device: ci-après, dorénaυant appelé/nommé and désigné dans la suite de (cet article/ce compte-rendu) par le sigle. Ci-après collocates strongly with cité, especially in Canadian French, and is frequently followed by a colon or comma: l’individu-clef du cycle de développement de Varroa est la femelle adulte, dorénavant nommée ‘fondatrice’. Deux phases symbiotiques rythment alternativement la vie d’une fondatrice…(CAF) Code de procédure pénale, ci-après CPP. (CAF) Projet d’acte final reprenant les résultats des négociations commerciales multilatérales de l’Uruguay Round, Genève, Secrétariat du GATT, 20 décembre 1991 (ci-après cité: «Rapport Dunkel»). (CAF) As its form suggests, traduisez is a variant of encore appelé which may serve
< previous page
page_165
next page >
< previous page
page_166
next page >
Page 166 to introduce a translation; it is more common in newspaper language than in academic writing, and occurs with particular frequency in the field of computing: Mais ‘on peut plaire à Dieu et rester féminines’, certifie-t-on chez Tekbir (traduisez: ‘le Seul-l’Unique’, par un mauvais jeu de mots sur le monothéisme). (NF) In another mode, traduisez helps to translate pretentious or unintelligible jargon into everyday language: Tandis que le quartier de la Bastille, miné par les restaurants pour touristes, s’étiole et qu’Oberkampf commence à prendre un coup de vieux, la ville de Montreuil, à l’est de Paris, attire une population toujours plus nombreuse de ‘nupies’ (traduisez: néo-urbains professionnels). (NF) ZARMA, le céfran natchave! Traduisez: Ma parole, le français va à vaul’eau! (NF) justement can also assume the function of resuming a word or phrase, with the peculiarity that the repeated word always stands to its left: Il a suffi d’une pléiade d’écrivains-philosophes exceptionnels pour exprimer leur temps et en faire un «siècle»—le siècle, justement, de la philosophie des Lumières. (NF) ou The French reformulator ou has a co-referential mode in which it commonly links two noun groups. Either it can introduce an alternative designation: (1) le «tableau périodique», ou «tableau de Mendeleïev» (EU) or it can signal a definition, thereby functioning as a synonym of autrement dit: (2) la paratextualité, ou relation que le texte entretient avec son environnement (EU) In a third variant of this mode, it is roughly equivalent to ‘which is or are’; French also offers a more elegant option to express this function, namely constructions of the type ce cancer social qu’est l’exclusion (Gallagher 2000). Thus, the following example may be rephrased as la consommation de l’acte qu’est la lecture du liυre:
< previous page
page_166
next page >
< previous page
page_167
next page >
Page 167 (3) la consommation de l’acte, ou la lecture du livre (MTC) The above examples show that Tamba (1987:19) is wrong in claiming that the second appositive is generally employed ‘en mention’. In example (1), for instance, both appositives are technical terms, and in example (2) the definition follows the technical term. It is also doubtful whether ou can always be replaced by the zero connector (Tamba 1987:20), as in on considère comme réelles (vraies) l’affirmation ou la négation This option is definitely ruled out in the third of our examples, and in a number of examples that Tamba herself cites. The third example also suggests that, contrary to received wisdom, the definite article may sometimes occur in front of the second appositive. Table 4.24 summarizes the results of our investigation so far. 4.2.2.3 Pure reformulators in German mit anderen Worten By comparison with its French and English counterparts, the German set of pure reformulators grouped around mit anderen Worten is a motley collection, including such unexpected items as oder anders and also . The members of this set realize the intensional mode, with a clear predominance of connotative definitions. Mit anderen Worten and its variant in anderen Worten occur almost exclusively in sentence-initial position. They are followed by a comma or a colon: Bisher habe ich jedoch nur Ableitungen von Beispielen vorgeführt, von denen bereits klar war, dass sie wohlgebildet sind. In anderen Worten, die bisher vorgestellte Grammatik hat nur ihre Beobachtungsadäquatheit gezeigt. (CAG) Wichtig zu wissen ist, dass der Airbag bei einem Aufprall in Millisekunden aktiviert wird, kurz nachdem die Verformung des Autos begonnen hat. Er kann aber seine volle Schutzwirkung nur bei angelegtem Gurt erfüllen. Mit anderen Worten: die Kombination von Gurt plus Gurtstraffer plus Airbag ist bis jetzt—wohlgemerkt in Verbindung mit dem gestaltfesten Lebensraum—, das beste Rück-halte-System für Fahrer und Beifahrer im Ernstfall…(NG) It is rare for these devices to enable a link between alternative formulations of short syntagmas: Die Rückwendung zu längst überholten legitimistischen Traditionen
< previous page
page_167
next page >
< previous page
page_168
next page >
Page 168 Table 4.24 Summary of the functions of French pure reformulators Mode/function Intensional ExtensionalSpecificatiυeCoQuantificational referential en d’autres termes, autrement dit (etc.) yes — — — — c’est-à-dire (cannot follow numerals and yes yes yes yes yes indefinite article) à savoir possible (denotative), yes yes yes possible, but but rare rare soit possible (connotative), — — — yes but rare encore appelé — yes — yes — ou — yes — yes —
< previous page
page_168
next page >
< previous page
page_169
next page >
Page 169 beinhaltet eine Absage an eine konsequente Neuorientierung, mit anderen Worten an einen Reformkurs. (NG) Oder anders is a fairly common academic variant of mit anderen Worten which links sentences. In a mode not to be confused with this one, anders is used on its own as a means of cross-referencing in dictionaries or encyclopaedias; it is often followed by a colon (anders: allgemeines Monopol) . An example of oder anders follows: Um mich überhaupt als Grund von etwas anderes als meiner selbst zu erfassen, muß ich mich darin als nicht der Grund meiner selbst erfassen. Oder anders: die Übernahme meines Grundseins (Verantwortung) geschieht grundlos (Selbstverantwortung). Ich kann nur existieren, weil ich nicht der Grund für mein mögliches Grundsein bin. (CAG) also, d.h. Also is a moderately common reformulator introducing an explanation, a more precise rewording or an inference. It can occur in both the extensional and intensional modes and has scope over short syntagmas. The first two examples which follow illustrate the intensional mode in its denotative sub-mode; the third affords an illustration of the connotative sub-mode: Etwa haben Link (1983 und 1984), Blau (1981) und andere dafür argumentiert, Gruppen nicht als Mengen, also abgeleitete Konstrukte, sondern als Individuen (als mereologische Summen oder verbandstheoretische joins) zu modellieren. (CAG) Solche ‘Inkarnation’, also Fleischwerdung, bringt uns in eine wundervolle und gleichsam schauerliche Nähe zur Welt. (CAG) des kommunikativen Sprachunterrichts auf und entstammt der Notwendigkeit, Bewertungsverfahren zu entwickeln, die funktionalen (also kommunikativen) Sprachgebrauch messen können. (CAG) Common clusters that this mode of also enters into include also gleichsam, also υomehmlich, also de facto, also faktisch, also letztlich, also gleichsam/gewissermaβen, also insbesondere, also eigentlich and also auch. Over and above their resumptive function, some of these clearly have conclusive force, thus illustrating the connotative mode. In the first of the following examples the noun phrase lying to the right of also auch is subsumed under the more general category of the preceding noun phrase; in the second example also eigentlich introduces an inference made by the author:
< previous page
page_169
next page >
< previous page
page_170
next page >
Page 170 Das utopische Bild ist ein Bild dessen, was ‘sein soll’, wovon der Bildende (also auch der Lehrende) ‘wünscht’, dass es sei. (CAG) wie diese Variablen ihren aktuellen Wert oft überhaupt nur durch die—über allen Zweifel erhabene, also eigentlich überflüssige—Versicherung erhalten, alles sei tatsächlich heute passiert. (CAG) The following example illustrates the extensional/co-referential mode: Ort der Kritik ist für Aristoteles nicht im Bereich der theoretischen Wissenschaften (theoria), also der Physik, Mathematik und Theologie (Erste Philosophie, Metaphysik), denn diese betrachten das, was ist. (CAG) In its extensional/quantificational mode also collocates with quantitative expressions signalling a summation, often in conjunction with insgesamt: z.B. 4000 Exemplare, die von jeweils 20 Lesern gelesen werden, also insgesamt 30.000 Leser für eine Schrift (CAG) The marker often introduces a syntagma syntactically parallel to the preceding one: Die fragliche Kategorie X läßt sich jedoch als N/PP, also als eine Funktorkategorie rekonstruieren, die eine PP nimmt, um ein N zu ergeben. (CAG) In an intensional/denotative mode equivalent to that of also, d.h. may assume a purely explicative function: Durch seinen induktiven und experimentellen Nachweis der konstitutiven Bedeutung von Denkprozessen bei der Entstehung unseres Bewußtseins einer Außenwelt habe Helmholtz ‘ein unsterbliches Verdienst erworben’ und durch seine Arbeit den Intuitionismus, d.h. die Lehre vom unmittelbaren Gegebensein eines Außen, ‘definitiv’ beseitigt. (CAG) Frequently, however, the device has a strongly conclusive (i.e. connotative) value, especially in combination with letztlich, where it may signal that the author is taking her argument to its logical conclusion: Ohne Zweifel sind die heute neu initiierten Regelungen wohlmeinend, vordergründig auch sachkundig, doch reflektieren die Regelungsgeber wie auch die am Entscheidungsprozeß beteiligten
< previous page
page_170
next page >
< previous page
page_171
next page >
Page 171 Experten oft nicht diese mikroökonomischen Wirkungen ihrer Aktivitäten. D.h. letztlich, sie wissen zwar, was sie wollen, aber oft nicht, was sie tun bzw. bewirken. (CAG) Notably common collocations which realize different modes include d.h. hier (intensional/denotative), d.h. sozusagen (intensional/connotative), d.h. υor allem (extensional/specificative), d.h. zum Beispiel (extensional/specificative) and d.h. im einzelnen (extensional/specificative). Some examples: Zum andern, und das ist noch einmal an späterer Stelle kritisch aufzunehmen, versteht sich nach saussureschem Kontext (5) langage offenbar auch als die symbolische Ordnung, die Menge aller Zeichen-systeme des Menschen, d.h. sozusagen als ein ‘System aller Systeme’. (CAG) Einmal davon abgesehen, dass dieser Prozeß auch von der Wissenschaft (d.h. hier der Psycholinguistik) noch nicht erschöpfend erforscht ist. (CAG) Derzeit stehen im Bereich der elektronischen Publikationen noch die Offline-Versionen—d.h. vor allem die CD-ROMDatenbanken—im Vordergrund. (CAG) From a syntactic point of view, it is interesting to note that d.h. may enhance or clarify a preceding attributive structure, or indeed, any other sentence constituent: Nicht mehr nur die lästige Entsorgung von etwas überflüssigem wird eine Pflicht öffentlicher Daseinsvorsorge, sondern eine geordnete, d.h. nach Maßgabe der Vorschriften des Abfallgesetzes durchzuführende Entsorgung wird zur Pflicht der zuständigen Körperschaften gemacht, um Umweltsicherung zu betreiben. (CAG) Und dies in der Weise, dass allgemein (d.h. für Frauen und für Männer) nachvollziehbar philosophisch argumentiert wird (CAG) So wie man das Wasser nicht lehren muß, wohin es fließen soll, so geht nach Comenius der Fluß des Lernens seinen natürlichen und erfolgreichen Gang, wenn er nur richtig in Gang gekommen ist, d.h. wenn wir bis zu den Quellen zurückgegangen sind, um ihn dort zu beginnen. (CAG) D.h. may also follow nouns expressing an idea or an opinion, in which case it often introduces appositive noun clauses:
< previous page
page_171
next page >
< previous page
page_172
next page >
Page 172 Bis zur Novellierung galt das Prinzip der strikten Kostendeckung, d.h., Einnahmen und Ausgaben mußten deckungsgleich sein. (NG) nämlich nämlich can be used in both the intensional and extensional modes, its main function being that of specification. In its extensional/specificative mode, it is not normally interchangeable with d.h., as witness the following examples: Erstens gibt es mindestens drei weitere Übersetzungsmöglichkeiten für ‘Unmut’, nämlich/*d.h. ‘mécontentement’, ‘malaise’ und ‘grogne’…(CAG) In Beispiel (86) steht das erste Argument von gab, nämlich/*d.h. den Abschied, nicht direkt neben dem Funktor. (CAG) Diese Solidarität beruht auf einem Gedankenfehler, dem schon ganz andere verfallen sind (Marx/Lenin), nämlich/*d.h. dem, daß alle Menschen gleich wären. (CAG) In its extensional/co-referential mode, nämlich is fully interchangeable with d.h., as can be seen from the following instances: Wem sein Augenlicht lieb ist, sollte also beim Sonnenbrillenkauf mehr auf die ‘inneren Werte’, nämlich/d.h. den UVSchutz, schauen, als auf Schick. (NG) Die Betonung dieser ‘Menschheitsaufgaben’, nämlich/d.h. die Sicherung der ‘natürlichen Lebensgrundlagen’, des Friedens und die Schaffung einer ‘gerechten Weltwirtschaftsordnung’, nennt Vogel als die erste von insgesamt zehn ‘Hauptbotschaften’ des Programms. (NG) Sometimes nämlich occurs with figures; since nämlich cannot be replaced by d.h. in this case, and since it maintains its announcing function, we will treat this mode as a special case of the specificative mode rather than a type of quantificational mode: Etwas preiswerter kommt die ‘Farb- und Stilberatung’, nämlich für 39,80 Mark. (NG) in Zahlen and in Zahlen ausgedrückt heiβt das are occasional variants of the extensional/quantificational mode of d.h.: Diese unübersichtliche Agglomeration mit so vielen Zentren und Vierteln, den abrupten und unverständlichen Ubergängen von gepflegten zu heruntergekommenen Straßenzügen, den verwirren-
< previous page
page_172
next page >
< previous page
page_173
next page >
Page 173 den Highways und Freeways und Boulevards, das ist das pure Gegenteil der herkömmlichen europäischen Stadtidee. In Zahlen: Das Häusermeer von L.A. und Umgebung erstreckt sich auf einer Länge von rund 200 Kilometern entlang des Pazifiks und einer Tiefe von rund 150 Kilometern ins Landesinnere. (NG) Another fairly rare variant of d.h. is eben . It occurs in the extensional/specificative mode, usually indicating that the second appositive has already been mentioned: Manche rudimentären Sprachen—eben elementare Lernervarietäten oder Pidgins—haben den letzteren Modus nicht oder nur in Ansätzen. (CAG) sprich Sprich is used in an intensional/connotative mode. It can link syntagms of varying length, as shown in the following examples: Ein solcher Einbruch in das Reich akademischer, sprich männlicher Würden war zu ihrer Zeit nur durch männliche Unterstützung möglich. (NG) Auch Zacharias Werner traf der vernichtende Blitzstrahl des Weimarer Dichtergottes; sein Drama sei abstrus und mystisch, sprich: ebenso ungeeignet für die Bühne wie das von Kleist. (NG) It also has a highly specialized mode in which it serves to introduce the pronunciation of a mathematical sign or natural-language expression: ,>’ (sprich: , größer’, ,echt größer’ oder, strikt größer’) (CAG) Auf Mackinac (sprich: Mäkinoh) ist Waffentragen, einmalig in den USA, genehmigungspflichtig und hier herrscht seit hundert Jahren striktes Autoverbot. (NG) auch…genannt (etc.) The German set of which auch…genannt may be viewed as the paradigm appears to be smaller than the English or French sets. Consider the following two examples: Dienstleistungen von Unternehmungen, auch Absatzleistungen genannt. (CAG) mit Hilfe von Balkendiagrammen, in der Literatur auch als Balken-plan bekannt,…(CAG)
< previous page
page_173
next page >
< previous page
page_174
next page >
Page 174 The participial relative clause may include attributions to sources: Produktionsprozeßplanung (von E.Gutenberg als Prozeßplanung bezeichnet) (CAG) Apart from these participial relative clauses, German often resorts to full-length relative clauses: folgende Merkmale schreiben die Wissenschaftler Menschen um das 20. Lebensjahr herum zu, die auch als ‘Twentysomethings’ bezeichnet werden (NG) German has an additional, though comparatively rare, reformulator which realizes a specific mode of the auch… genannt paradigm; namely, υulgo . Vulgo is a Latinate synonym of umgangssprachlich…(auch) genannt: An diesem Nachmittag steht er hoch über dem noblen Port Andratx, vulgo Düsseldorfer Loch, vor einer riesigen Villa, die er auch versichert hat, und sinniert über das eigenartige Leben auf dieser Insel. (NG) An occasional variant, to be found especially in works of reference, is auch on its own, or oder auch: Unter Wörterbucheinleitung (auch Wörterbuchυorwort ) wird dabei ein heterogener Wörterbuchbauteil verstanden (CAG) Europäische Rechnungseinheit (oder auch ERE) (CAG) The pure reformulators kurz, oder kurz and oder auch kurz…genannt are sometimes used to introduce an abbreviation, but they more commonly serve to introduce a shorter, more widely known variant of a term: Wichtiges Kernstück dieser Dimension ist die 1989—ohne die Stimme Großbritanniens—vom Europäischen Rat angenommene ‘Gemein-schaftscharta der sozialen Grundrechte der Arbeitnehmer’ (kurz: Sozialcharta) (CAG) Für die Fortgeschrittenen gibt es dann auch noch solche Schmankerl wie den ‘Handgelenksaußendrehwurf, oder auch kurz Kote-gaeshi genannt. (NG) In the case of initialisms or acronyms, German frequently omits a lexical link. Im folgenden and its variants im folgenden zitiert als, im folgenden zit. als, im folgenden mit…abgekürzt, im folgenden…genannt may be seen as a special
< previous page
page_174
next page >
< previous page
page_175
next page >
Page 175 case of kurz; like English hereafter and French désormais these SLDMs are often used to introduce a convenient shorthand: Langenscheidts Groβwörterbuch Deutsch als Fremdsprache (im folgenden: Lgwdaf) (CAG) Bertolt Brecht, Gesammelte Werke in 20 Bänden, Frankfurt/M. 1967ff. (im folgenden zitiert als: GW) (CAG) The time adverb fortan can also serve this function: Gibt es Sprachmittel, oder besser Sektionen sprachlichen Verhaltens, die von besonderer Relevanz sind bei/in ‘Kulturkontakt’ (fortan KK), die wichtiger, häufiger, zentraler sind als andere? (CAG) bzw. Beziehungsweise is a reformulator more or less peculiar to German. It has three different modes. In its first mode it indicates a choice between two alternatives, after the manner of adversative oder: fremdkulturelle bzw. eigenkulturelle Setzungen (CAG) Daraus, dass Filme narrative Schlüsse evozieren und damit in den Bereich der Konstruktionen übergehen bzw. in ihrer Apparatur bereits eine Konstruktion enthalten, läßt sich aber nicht der Schluß entwinden, es gäbe dort keine Referenzialität, oder Filme repräsentierten die Welt in keiner Weise, die jenseits des Fiktiven liegt. (CAG) In its second mode, it helps underscore a relationship of synonymy or substitutability, thus realizing the extensional/co-referential mode. Häufig ist die Denotation bzw. Begriffsextension in der Fachsprache wegen stärkerer Differenzierung geringer (CAG) Nachschlagewerke wie Lexika, Grammatiken und Wörterbücher sind nicht mehr in Papierform, sondern auf CD-ROM respektive direkt ins Netz gespeichert. (CAG) In its third mode it serves to list a number of attributes that relate separately to each of several things or people listed in the previous discourse: der sich 1950 noch auf 17,8% beim Verkehrsaufkommen und 37,7% bei den Verkehrsleistungen belaufen hatte, schon 1960 auf 6,1 bzw. 16,1% geschrumpft (1990:2,8 bzw, 6,2%) (CAG) Table 4.25 summarizes the results of our investigation so far.
< previous page
page_175
next page >
< previous page Page 176 Table 4.25 Summary Mode/function mit anderen Worten oder anders also d. h. nämlich in Zahlen sprich auch genannt bzw.
of the functions of German pure reformulators Intensional Extensional yes — yes (links sentences) — yes (usually links short syntagms) yes yes yes — yes — — yes — — yes — yes
< previous page
next page >
page_176
page_176
Specificatiυe — — yes yes yes — — — —
Co-referential — — yes yes yes — — yes yes
Quantificational — — yes yes — yes — — —
next page >
< previous page
page_177
next page >
Page 177 4.2.2.4 Differences and similarities between English and French pure reformulators In what follows I shall try to shed some light on the complexities surrounding the translation of pure reformulators, proposing unidirectional transfer rules for English-French and French-English translation. As many of the insights to be discussed here can be inferred from the above monolingual treatments, I shall content myself with detailed observations on this language pair only. The reader interested in German-French translation is referred to Courdier et al. (1994, 1998) for a near-exhaustive discussion of the rendition of the two pure reformulators also and nämlich into French. Let us first compare the synoptic tables given above with a view to ferreting out general equivalences. The most salient facts to be noted are as follows: 1 that is, c’est-à-dire and das heiβt all have the full range of intensional and extensional modes, which suggests a great degree of translational compatibility. 2 in other words, en d’autres termes and mit anderen Worten all occur in the intensional mode. But in other words also has an extensional mode, so that some translation problems will arise. 3 Even at this level of delicacy, it is clear that the remaining pure reformulators (i.e., namely, to wit, à saυoir, soit, also, in Zahlen) show more complex equivalence relations. I shall now consider in sequence three main groups of pure reformulators: that is vs. c’est-à-dire, in other words vs. en d’autres termes and also called vs. encore appelé . In so doing, I shall supplement as far as possible the monolingual analyses offered above with data from the multilingual corpus. Before proceeding, it may well be worth reminding the reader (see Part II, Chapter 3) that the standard English-French dictionaries are extremely patchy in their coverage of these expressions. Two major deficiencies are apparent: first, some common expressions, such as namely that, en d’autres mots or encore appelé have gone unrecorded, not to speak of rarer SLDMs that are nevertheless indispensable in academic discourse, such as hereafter, to wit or pour le dire en d’autres termes; second, those that have been recorded are presented out of context, a treatment which wrongly suggests perfect equivalence between the two languages. that is υs. c’est-à-dire Although the above analysis has shown that that is and c’est-à-dire closely parallel each other in all of their modes, it would be somewhat naive to assume, as do Murat and Cartier-Bresson (1987:5) on the basis of a monolingual [sic!] investigation