Advances in
Physical Organic Chemistry
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Advances in
Physical Organic Chemistry ...
27 downloads
1557 Views
16MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Advances in
Physical Organic Chemistry
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Advances in
Physical Organic Chemistry Edited by
V. GOLD Department of Chemistry King’s College, University of London
VOLUME 4
1966
Academic Press, London and New York
ACADEMIC PRESS INC. (LONDON) LTD. Berkeley Square House Berkeley Square, London, W.l
U.S. EditiolL publislld by ACADEMIC PRESS INC. 111 Fifth Avenue New York, New York 10003
Copyright @ 1966 by Academic Press Inc. (London) Ltd.
All rights reserved
No part of this book may be reproduced in any form by photostat, microfilm, or any other means, without written permission from the publisher.
Librury of Congress Calalog Card Number: 62-22125.
PRINTED IN QKEAT BRITAIN BY SYOTTISWOODB, BALLANTYNE AND COMPANY LIMlTEU LONDON AND COLCBESTEK
CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME 4 R. P. BELL,Physical Chemistry Laboratory, Oxford, England H. M. FREY,Chemistry Department, Southampton University, England H. H. GREENWOOD,Quantum Theory Group, University of Keele, Xtaffrdshire, England R. MCWEENY, Quantum Th,eoryGroup, University of Keele, Staffordshire, England GEORGEA. OLAH, Department of Chemistry, Western Reserve University, Cleveland, Ohio, U.S.A.
H. H. PERKAMPUS, Department of Molecular Spectroscopy of the Institute for Organic Chemistry, Technische Hochschule, Braunschweig, Germany CHARLESU. PITTMAN, JR., Department of Chemistry, Western Reserve University, Cleveland, Ohio, U.S.A.
D. W. TURNER, Department of Chemistry, Imperial College of Science and Technology, University of London, England
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
CONTENTS CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME 4
.
.
v
The Reversible Hydration of Carbonyl Compounds R. P. BELL I. Introduction . 11. Hydration Equilibrium Constants . 111. Acidity of Carbonyl Hydrates . IV. Kinetics of Hydration and Dehydration Reactions References .
. .
.
1 2 12 16 27
I. Introduction . . 11. The Measurement of Ionization Potentials . . 111. Molecular Structure Dependence of Ionization Potentials References . .
31 35 46 69
. .
Ionization Potentials D. W. TURNER
Reactivity Indices in Conjugated Molecules: The Present Position H. H. GREENWOOD and R. MCWEENY I. Introduction . 11. Some Applications of the Indices . 111. Properties of the Secular Equations . IV. The Isolated Molecule Method . V. The Localization Method . VI. Relationship between the Indices . VII. Frontier Orbital and Charge Transfer Theories Vii
.
.
. . . . . .
73 81 88 95 102 107 112
viii
CONTENTS
VIII. The Physical Basis of Reactivity Indices . IX. Reactivity Indices in Many-Electron Theory . X. Conclusions and Future Prospects References .
118 129 141 143
.
The Gas Phase Pyrolyses of Some Small Ring Hydrocarbons H. M. PREY I. Introduction . 11. Cyclopropane . 111. Alkylcyclopropanes . IV. Unsaturated Cyclopropanes . V. Bicyclopropyl . VI. Bicyclic Systems Containing Cyclopropane Rings . VII. Tricyclic Systems Containing Two Cyclopropane Rings VIII. Cyclopropene . IX. Systems Containing Four-membered Rings . X. Unsaturated Cyclobutanes . XI. Bicyclic Compounds Containing Cyclobutane Rings XII. Tricyclic Systems Containing a Cyclobutane Ring XIII. Cyclobutene . XIV. Bicyclobutenes . XV. Tricyclic Systems Containing Cyclobutene Rings . XVI. Conclusion . References .
.
. .
148 148 151 155 165 165 169 170 170 175 180 183 183 188 189 190 191
The Basicity of Unsaturated Com pounds H.-H. PERKAMPUS 195 I. Definition of Basicity . 200 11. The Structure of the Proton Addition Complexes . 111. Methods for Determining the Basicity of Unsaturated Hydrocarbons . 232 IV. Basicity Scale and Basicity Constants of Unsaturated 262 Compounds . V. Theoretical Treatment of Proton Addition Complexes . 284 VI. Supplementary Remarks . 297 References . 300
ix
CONTENTS
Spectroscopic Observation of Al kylcarbonium Ions in Strong Acid Solutions GEORGEA. OLAH and CHARLESU. PITTMAN,JR. I. Introduction . 11. Remarks on Nomenclature 111. Alkyl Halide-Lewis Acid Halide Systems . IV. Alcohols and Olefins in Strong Bronsted Acids V. Cyclopropylcarbonium Ions . VI. Alkylarylcarbonium Ions . References .
AUTHORINDEX. CUMULATIVEINDEX OF AUTHORS CUMULATIVE INDEX OF TITLES .
. . . . . .
305 307 307 324 333 338 345
.
349
.
. 357
.
357
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
THE REVERSIBLE HYDRATION OF CARBONYL COMPOUNDS R. P. BELL
Physical Chemistry Laboratory, Oxford, England I. Introduction 11. Hydration Equilibrium Constants . A. Experimental Methods . B. Results and Discussion C. Isotope Effects on Hydration Equilibria 111. Acidity of Carbonyl Hydrates . A. Experimental Methods B. Results and Discussion IV. Kinetics of Hydration and Dehydration Reactions A. Historical B. Mechanism and Relation to other Reactions C. Experimental Methods D. Catalytic Behaviour . E. IsotopeEffects . F. The Hydration of Carbon Dioxide . References .
.
. .
.
.
.
.
I
. . .
2 2 7 12 12 12 14 16 16 16 19 22 26 26 27
. . . . . . . . . . . .
I. INTRODUCTION THEformation of stable solid hydrates is well known for aldehydes and ketones containing several electronegative substituents and for some diand triketones. The classical example is chloral hydrate, for which there is direct evidence from proton magnetic resonance measurements (Bishopand Richards, 1959) and from Raman spectra (Hibben, 1931) for the gem-diol formula CCl,.CH(OH)2, rather than any looser mode of hydration. The majority of carbonyl compounds do not give solid hydrates, except sometimes a t low temperatures, but there is frequently evidence for the reaction RlR2C0 + H20+R1R2C(OH)2 in aqueous solvents: this is accompanied by the disappearance or weakening of the characteristic U.V. absorption band of the carbonyl group at about 280 mp, again confirming the nature of the hydrate. This reaction represents the simplest example of the important class of reversible additions to the carbonyl group. The present review
2
R. P. BELL
attempts to summarize our present knowledge of the equilibrium constants and kinetics of these reactions, with special reference to recent work. Such equilibria are undoubtedly of importance in interpreting the chemical and biological reactivity of carbonyl compounds in aqueous solution, and they have proved kinetically very convenient for studying problems of homogeneous catalysis. 11. HYDRATION EQUILIBRIUM CONSTANTS
A. Experimental Methods 1. Historical
Most of our information about the thermodynamics of hydration relates to solutions in water, and aqueous solutions of acetaldehyde have been widely investigated. The presence of considerable proportion of CHs.CH(OH), in these solutions was first suggested by Ramsay and Young (1886) on the basis of the unusually large evolution of heat (about 5 kcal mole-I) accompanying the dissolution of acetaldehyde in water. Perkin (1887) made the same observation, and reported erroneously that an initial absorption of heat is followed by a larger evolution. He also noted that dilute aqueous solutions of acetaldehyde are denser than pure water, although pure acetaldehyde has a density of about 0.8. Density measurements over a range of temperatures (Homfray, 1905) indicated that the degree of hydration diminished with rise of temperature, in conformity with the sign of the observed heat change, but gave no quantitative information. 2. Ultra-violet absorption
The commonest modern method for determining the degree of hydration is to measure the intensity of the broad nlr* carbonyl absorption band at about 280 mp, which disappears on hydration. Early measurements (Schou, 1926, 1929; HBrold and Wolf, 1929, 1931) show considerable discrepancies, but the results of later workers are in reasonable agreement. The main uncertainty lies in the value to be assigned to em, the maximum extinction coefficient of the unhydrated carbonyl compound, which varies between 12 and 80 for different compounds. This is commonly taken as the value measured in a non-hydroxylic solvent such as hexane or cyclohexane,but this is not strictly valid, sincethe intensities of n-n* transitionsvary somewhat with the solvent (see e.g. Dertooz and Nasielki, 1961) ;moreover, since the shape of the band and the value of em are also solvent-dependent it may make some difference whether the extinction coefficients are compared at the same wavelength, a t the respective maxima, or in terms of the band area. Special difficulties arise
REVERSIBLE HYDRATION O F CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
3
with substances such as biacetyl, where there are several maxima and the spectrum changes in a complicated manner on hydration (Bell and McDougall, 1960). For a series of aldehydes the assumption has been made (Rumpf and Bloch, 1951)that em is the same as for aqueous solutions of ketones of similar structure, which are very little hydrated. It is occasionally possible to obtain an independent check on the correct value of em. Bell and Clunie (19528) measured the U.V. absorption of aqueous acetaldehyde solutions in the temperature range 0"-54" C, and also studied the heat changes on dissolving acetaldehyde in water at 0" C and 25"C, a calorimeter with rapid response being used. Since the hydration reaction in pure water has a half-time of about 1 min at 25" C and 8 min at O"C, the heat evolved during the first second could be identified with the physical heat of solution, AHs. Calorimetric measurements were also made in very dilute alkali, in which the hydration reaction has a half-time < 0.01 sec : the heat evolved in these experiments is AH8+ (1- a)AHh,where a is the equilibrium degree of dissociation of the hydrate and AHh the enthalpy change for the hydration reaction in solution. By assuming a value for em, the spectrophotometric measurements can be used to calculate a at each temperature, and a plot of logcr/(l -a) against 1/T then gives AHh. The same plot can be used to interpolate values of a at 0" C and 25" C, and these values used to determine a second value of AHh from the calorimetric values of (1 - cr)AHh at 0" C and 25" C. If the correct value of em has been chosen, there will be agreement between AHhfrom the isochore and the calorimetric values at both temperatures (assumingthat both AHh and em are sensibly constant over the temperature range concerned). This method gave em = 17.0 f 0.2 at 278 mp for aqueous acetaldehyde, compared with E,,, = 16.2 a t 288 mp for hexane solutions: in this instance the use of the latter value would have produced an error of only a few per cent in a. A less setisfactory method is to choose em so as to produce a linear plot of logK, against 1/27 (Gruen and McTigue, 1963a). These uncertainties may well produce errors of up to l0-20% in the derived equilibrium constants. Compounds which are almost completely hydrated in pure water are more readily studied in dioxan +water mixtures, which have been used by Rumpf and Bloch (1951)and by Federlin (1952)who used the volume concentrations of water to relate the results to those in pure water. Bell and McDougall (1960) studied 1,3-dichloroacetone at 25"-53"C in dioxan-water mixtures containing 10-100 wt. yo water (mole fraction xHaO ; activity uIInO), and found that Z ~ , ~ ~1C a) / ( varied much less with solvent compositionthan did uHsOcr/( 1 - E ) :this suggests that the activity coefficientsof the species concerned cancel to a considerableextent as the medium is changed from pure water. The same authors studied the
4
R . P. B E L L
dissociation of O ~ O O ~ M - O ~ O chloral ~M hydrate solutions in cyclohexane, but the equilibrium constant which they obtained cannot be compared with those in aqueous media. It may be noted that if an aqueous solution of a carbonyl compound shows absorption a t about 280 mp which is unaffected by the addition of dioxan or by change of temperature, this provides evidence that the compound is very little hydrated (Bell and Wright, 1961). 3. Raman and nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy
Measurements of Raman spectra should in principle distinguish between hydrated and unhydrated species in solution, but rather concentrated solutions must be used, and little work has yet been done. The measurements of Matsushima (1963) on aqueous acetaldehyde are in qualitative accord with other methods. Proton magnetic resonance measurements offer greater possibilities. The spectrum of pure acetaldehyde contains a doublet due to the methyl group, and a quartet from the hydrogen of the aldehyde group. Aqueous solutions of acetaldehyde give these same two peaks, with reduced intensities, and also two new peaks due to CH, .CH(OH)2(Lombardi and Sogo, 1960; Fujiwara and Fujiwara, 1963; Ahrens and Strehlow, 1965). The extent of dissociation of the hydrate follows from the relative areas of the two sets of peaks, most accurately from those arising from the methyl group. Similar measurements have been made for isobutyraldehyde (Hine et al., 1965). The advantage of this method is that the areas of the peaks are directly proportional to the numbers of hydrogen atoms concerned, thus avoiding the calibration which is necessary for most spectroscopic methods. The appearance of separate signals for the two species RlR2C0 and RIR,CH( OH), shows that their interconversion must be relatively slow, and in the presence of sufficient concentrations of catalyst (for example, hydrogen or hydroxide ions) only one set of peaks is observed. The use of N.M.R. measurements for studying the kinetics of the interconversion is mentioned in the second part of this review. In principle, N.M.R. measurements can be used to determine the reaction velocity in both directions, leading to an independent estimate of the equilibrium position : this has been done for acetaldehyde (Evans et al., 1965). This method may be particularly useful for detecting small extents of hydration, for example for acetone, which is normally regarded as unhydrated. Preliminary measurements by Hine and Redding (1964) of the N.M.R. spectrum at 60 Mc/s of a 20% solution of acetone in water (H20or D20)show a weak signal 48 c/s upfield from that due to acetone. The attribution of this signal to Me,C(OH), is confirmed by the fact that
REVERSIBLE HYDRATION O F CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
5
it is broadened by 0 . 0 1 0 perchloric ~ acid and is undetectable in 0 . 1 acid, ~ in which the interconversion of the two forms should be very fast. By comparing the area of the peak with that of a neighbouring 13C satellite the proportion of hydrate in dilute aqueous acetone can be estimated as 0.2 & 0.1%. 4. Polarography
Polarography has been applied mainly to study the rate of the reaction CH2(OH)2+CH20+H20 (see Section IV, C), the equilibrium position being assumed, but in principle it can also be used to determine equilibrium constants provided that the degree of dissociation of the hydrate is small and the rate of dissociation not too high. The most accurate method employs oscillographic polarography. Valenta ( 1960) used triangular pulses of short duration with unbuffered formaldehyde solutions: under these conditions a measure is obtained of the concentration of unhydrated aldehyde, since methylene glycol (which is not directly reducible) does not have time to dissociate appreciably in the time of a pulse. Less accurate results for unbuffered formaldehyde solutions were obtained by Landqvist (1955). 5. Miscellaneous methods
Many physical properties of solutions of carbonyl compounds will be modified by hydration, and in principle might be used to determine its extent. An attempt to use the refractive index of aqueous acetaldehyde solutions for this purpose (Lauder, 1948) led to the erroneous conclusion that the degree of hydration is small. The partial vapour pressure of carbonyl compounds over their aqueous solutions will be reduced by hydration, since the gem-diols will have a lower volatility because of hydrogen-bonding to water, and will be more completely dissociated in the vapour-phase in the absence of a high concentration of water molecules. If it is assumed that the systems obey Raoult's law (or some other theoretical relation) then the observed partial pressure and vapour composition can be used to calculate the degree of dissociation of the hydrate both in the vapour and in the liquid phase. This procedure has so far been applied only to formaldehyde (Piret and Hall, 1949; Iliceto, 1954) and for the equilibrium in solution gives a result in agreement with other methods (see Table 1). It is interesting to note that methylene glycol is incompletely dissociated in the vapour phase : for example, K p is 1 atm at about 50' C. All the other gem-diolsare likely to be completely dissociated in the vapour under attainable conditions. It has recently been shown (HQnaff,1963; Bell and Evans, 1966) that under suitable conditions the reaction of various carbonyl reagents (e.g.
R . P. B E L L
6
hydrazine, hydroxylamine, semicarbazide, bisulphite) with unhydrated carbonyl compounds may be faster than the establishment of the hydration equilibrium. If the reaction is followed continuously, for example, spectrophotometrically, carbonyl reagent added to an aqueous solution will react almost instantaneously with the unhydrated compound, followed by a slow subsequent reaction determined by the rate of dissociation of the hydrate. The proportion of unhydrated compound is then determined by extrapolating the reaction curve back to zero time : this method has so far been applied only to acetaldehyde (see Table 1). The occurrence of isotopic exchange of “0 between water and carbony1 compounds has been observed to take place slowly with acetone (Cohn and Urey, 1938) and much more rapidly with acetaldehyde (Herbert and Lauder, 1938). This gives qualitative evidence for reversible hydration (since no other reasonable mechanism exists for isotopic exchange), but gives no quantitative information about the equilibrium position. Similarly, the fact that lS0exchange occurs in the unhydrolysed ester during the hydrolysis of carboxylic esters (Bender, 1951) shows that the species RC(OH),OR’ is a stabIe intermediate rather than a transition state. The hydration of carbon dioxide according to the scheme
is a special case of the reactions considered here, and has been much investigated. (For a review, see Edsall and Wyman, 1958.) The small proportion of carbon dioxide which is hydrated (about 0.2%) makes it difficult to measure the equilibrium constant directly. The most accurate equilibrium determinations (Wissbrunn et al., 1954) depend upon conductivity measurements at high field strengths. A powerful electrostatic field displaces the equilibrium H2C03+H++ HCO, to an extent which depends upon the equiIibrium constant. This dependence can be predicted theoretically, and the theoretical expressions tested with acids of known dissociation constant. Since the experimental method uses pulses of high field-strength and short duration, the equilibria H20 C02+H2C03 and H20+ C02+H+ + HCO, are not appreciably displaced, so that the observed field can be used to derive the “true” dissociation constant of carbonic acid, and hence the extent of hydration of carbon dioxide.
+
REVERSIBLE HYDRATION O F CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
7
B. Results and Discussion 1. Compilation of results The available information on equilibrium constants is collected in Table 1. Since they relate mainly to dilute aqueous solutions, they are expressed as Kd= [R1R2CO]/[R1R2C(OH),],and are independent of the concentration scale used. The values given for constanta measured in aqueous dioxan represent Kd= xH,o[RlR2CO]/[RlRzC(OH)z],where xHaO is the mole fraction of water. The values of AH are derived from the temperature coefficient of K d , except for acetaldehyde, where a confirmatory calorimetric value is also available. The Table does not include the early measurements of HBrold (1932). When corrected to 25" C, with AH = 6 kcal mole-l, his values for the chloroacetones and for biacetyl agree with those given in the Table,l but his measurements for five aliphatic aldehydes differ considerably from later work ; in particular, the variation of Kd with chain-length is in the opposite direction. Other values given by HBrold (converted to 25°C) are for MeC(OH),.CH,Br (& = 0-96)and for MeC(OH), .CH20H (Kd= 6.7). The species CH2(0H)2and MeCH(OH)2have been studied by a number of authors and methods, and the results call for special comment. The most accurate value for methylene glycol is probably that of Valenta (1960) from oscillographic polarography. Study by spectrophotometry suffers fmm two difficulties, the very low concentration of free aldehyde and the difficulty of estimating a value for E,. Bieber and Trumpler (1947b) used 0 . 8 7 ~solutions of formaldehyde in a 70-cm optical cell at 54", 58" and 64" C and assumed E,,, = 12.5 by extrapolation from higher aliphatic aldehydes. Their results were consistent with AH = 14.6 kcal mole-', which they used to make a long extrapolation to Kd= at 25" C. Gruen and McTigue (1963a)used 3.4-13.3 M solutions in a 1-cm cell at 25"-90°C and chose ~ , = 7 as giving the best linear at 25" C and AH = 5.7 plot of logK, against 1/T, leading to K , = kcal mole-l. Their value of em seems improbably low, and AH=5.7 kcal mole-l implies a standard entropy change of 5.4 e.u. for formaldehyde, compared with 19 to 27 e.u. foranumber of otheraldehydes, including chloral. It seems likely that the interpretation of their results is vitiated by polymerization to (CH20H)20,or higher polymers :thus Bezzi et al. (1 951)have estimated from vapour pressure data that solutionsof the concentrations used by Gruen and McTigue contain only 30-70% of 1 No temperature is specified by HBrold. but later work from the same laboratory (Gauditz, 1941) is stated to be at 18' C.
TOLE 1 Dissociation Constants for gem-Diols in Aqueous Solution ~
K d
Substance
CHZC1. CH(0H)z MeCHz .CHCl .CH(OH)2 (CHza)zC(OH)z MeCHz .CBrz.CH(OH)z Me(CH&. CHCl.CH(OH)z MezCCl. CH(0H)z MeCHz. CHBr .CH(0H)z MeC(0H)z.COMe Me(CHz)&HBr. CH(0H)z MeC(0H)p. CHClz MeC(0H)z.COzH MeCH(0H)z
Method
U.V. Polerog. Polarog. U.V. U.V. v.p. U.V. U.V. U.V. U.V.
u v.
U.V. U.V. U.V. U.V. U.V. U .v. U.V. U.V. U.V. U.V. N.M.R. N.M.R. N.M.R. N.M.R. Chem.
Temperature "C 25 t o 90 20
20
- 18 t o
25 23 25
obs 3.6 x 10-5 5.5 x 10-4* ~a
54 t o 64 25 to 90 30 to 60 20 20 25 t o 68 20 20 20 20 25 t o 53 20 25 t o 53 25 20 18 to 54 20 25 t o 90 25
+27
at 25'
10-4
5.3 x 10-4t I x 10-3$ 4.5 x 10-48 0.027 11 0.063 [I 0.10
c calc
3.6 x 10-5 9.0x 10-4
a e
1.08
f
0.007
f
w
f
W
9
f
f f
0.50
f"
0.6
h i
9
j
k a
0.67
1
0.81
m n
0.81** 0.82ti 0.67
R
0.002
0.1911
0.651 0.6i 0.827
a b C
0.1611
0.42 7 0 %
Reference
d
O.ll/j 0.27 / / 0.30 0.35 11 0.35
AH kcal mole-'
8 0
M
F
F
MeCHz. C(OH)2.CO2H MezCH. C(0H)z.COzH MeCHa .CH(OH)z MeC(0H)Z.CHzCl Me(CHz)2CH(OH)z
U.V. U.V. U.V. U.V. U.V. U.V. U.V. N.M.R. N.M.R. Cond.
25 25 25 to 90 25 to 53 25 t o 90 20 25 to 90 25 t o 35 25
0.71 1.0 1.4 1-6 2.1 2.611 2.3 1.6 ea. 5 x 102 3.9 x 103
1-6 2.0 5.0 7.0
5 x lo2
6.5 2.0 7.1
-
7.3 6.5
-
2.7
h h a 9
a
f
a
P P r
Gruen and McTigue, 1963a. b Valenta, 1960. c Landqvist, 1955. d Bieber and Triimpler, 1947b. C niceto, 1954. Federlin, 1952. 0 Bell and McDouga11, 1960. h Strehlow, 1962. Rumpf end Bloch, 1951. f Bell and Clunie, 1952a. Edwards et aZ., 1962. 'Lombardi and Sogo, 1960. Fujiwara and Fujiwara, 1963. "Evans et al., 1965. Bell and Hine and Redding, 1964. 'Wissbrunn et al., 1954. ' Ahrens and Strehlow, 1965. Evans, 1966. Hine et aZ., 1965. 5
f
'
* Calculated from value at 20' C, with A H = 9 kcal mole-'. t Calculated from values at 54"-64' C, with A H = 8 kcal mole-'. 3 34-13.3
M solutions, probably partly polymerized. $ Calculated from value at 30' C, with AH =8 kcal mole-'. 11 Calculated from measurements at 20" C in dioxan containing 12.5% and 25% water. Constants converted to pure water by multiplying by mole fraction of water, and to 25" with AH = 6 kcal mole-'. 7 Calculated from value at 20" C, with AH = 5 kcal mole-1. ** From ratio of forward and reverse rates. tt Calculated from value at 23" C with A H = 5 kcal mole-'.
W
10
R . P. B E L L
monomer at 35" c. Support for the polarographic value of Kd comes from an analysis of vapour pressure data by Iliceto (1954), who finds, after at 25", A H = 8.0 kcal mole-l ; allowing for polymerization, K , = 4.5 x if the latter value is used to extrapolate the measurements of Bieber and at 25"C. Trumpler (retaining E,,, = 12.5) we arrive a t K , = 5.3 x It thus seems safe to conclude that Kd = 5( 0.5) x for this substance. It may be noted that attempts to estimate A H from calorimetric measurements of the heat of solution of formaldehyde (Walker, 1933)are inconclusive because of the unknown heat of mixing of liquid formaldehyde and water to give a solution containing unhydrated CH20. For the equilibrium between acetaldehyde and MeCH(OH), several methods agree in giving K p 0 . 7 at 25" C. The value 1-08given by Gruen and McTigue (1963a) is the only discrepant one, and this is due to their choice of em = 14.5 (obtained by the method described in the last paragraph), compared with ,,€, = 17.0 found by Bell and Clunie (1952a) and E,,, = 16.2 in hexane. It is commonly found (seee.g. Dertooz and Nasielski, 1961)that the carbonyl absorption of ketones, which are not appreciably hydrated, is stronger in water than in hydrocarbon solvents, and it seems likely that the value of E,,, used by Gruen and McTigue is considerably too low. Moreover,the effect of an erroneous value of€,,,will increase with rise of temperature, so that the derived value of A H will be too high. The same considerations apply to the values given by Gruen and McTigue for other aliphatic aldehydes, which show an unexpected increase of A H with chain length. The values in the Table are those given by the authors, but in converting the results of Federlin (1952)from 20"to 25"C we have used a uniform value of A H = 6.0 kcal mole-l. Ahrens and Strehlow (1965) have used the broadening of N.M.R. lines to investigate aqueous solutions containing 1-4 to 56 mole % acetaldehyde. Their values of Kd increase with aldehyde concentration ; this may be partly because of the decrease in water activity a t high aldehyde concentrations, but may also be related to the presence of the hemihydrate (MeCHOH)20in concentrated solutions. Their value for low concentrations (given in Table 1) is in good agreement with other methods. 1. Discussion of results
An examination of Table 1 shows that the value of Kd is decreased by the presence of electron-attracting substituents, and increased by bulky groups. The former effect can be attributed to de-stabilization of the carbonyl compound, and the latter to steric strain in the diol. It is therefore of interest to compare the observed values of Kd with the polar and steric substituent constants CT*and E, derived by Taft (1952, 1953,
REVERSIBLE HYDRATION O F CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
11
1956; see also Leffler and Grunwald, 1963) from the rates of acid and alkaline hydrolysis of aliphatic esters. The values of Kd (calc.)in Table 1 are &om the expression
log Kd = 2.70 - 2.6 U* - 1.3 E, (1) where the summation involves both the substituents in R,R,C(OH),, the methyl group representing the standard (u*=O, E8=0). The agreement is fair, and many of the compounds for which experimental substituent constants are not available give values of Kd in the expected region. Apart from the rates of alkaline ester hydrolysis, on which the substituent constants are based, the only other reaction for which a quantitative correlation with both polar and steric constants has been demonstrated is the very similar methanolysis of Z-menthyl esters in presence of methoxide ions (Pavelich and Taft, 1957). Similar relations should hold for the equilibrium constants of other reactions involving addition to the carbonyl group, but these reactions are often complicated by subsequent loss of water, and few systematic data are available for aliphatic systems. The equilibrium constants measured by Gubareva (1947) for the addition of bisulphite to aliphatic aldehydes and ketones show qualitatively the importance of both polar and steric factors. It should be noted that the last term of equation (1) implies the summation of steric substituents for two groups attached to the same carbon atom. This is not normally a valid procedure, since steric effects are not usually additive, but it appears to work fairly well in the present instance. Since the a* values are of wide application, relations could no doubt be found between the degrees of hydration and many other properties of carbonyl compounds, though because of the importance of steric effects in the former such correlations will be of limited validity. Thus Bell and McDougall (1960) pointed out that the values of K d for formaldehyde, acetaldehyde and acetone were in the same order as the thermochemical stabilities of the carbonyl groups, as measured by Q(R,R,CH,)Q(R,R,CO), where Q is a heat of combustion or formation, but the necessary thermochemical values are not available for most of the substances in Table 1. The values of Adkins et al. (1949) for redox potentials of systems RIRzCO- RIRzCHOH also show some correlation with Kd, though the experimental conditions are very different (toluene solutions at 60" C). Similarly, since the infra-red carbonyl frequencies correlate well with u* for many aliphatic aldehydes and ketones (Sullivan and Sadler, 1957) these frequencies will also be roughly related to the degrees of hydration, though the spectral frequencies do not reflect any steric interactions. The very small extent of hydration of carbon dioxide cannot be
12
R. P. BELL
accounted for within the above frame-work, but is clearly related to the great stability of the unhydrated species, as revealed by its heat of formation and bond length. It can in fact be included in the thermochemical series noted by Bell and McDougall (1960), as is shown by the following heats of formation : Q(CH4)- Q(CH20) = 9.8 kcd, Q(C2He)- Q(MeCHO)= 19.4 kcal, Q(C3Hs)-Q(Me&O) =27 kcal, &?(CH4)- Q(C02) =40 kcal
K ~ ( c H ~ ( o H )= ~ )5 x 10-4 Kd(MeCH(OH)2)=0.7 Kd(Me&(OH)Z) = 5 x lo2 K ~ ( o c ( o H ) ~ ) = 4 x 103
C. Isotope Effects on Hydration Equilibria There is a limited amount of information on the extent of hydration of aldehydes in deuterium oxide. Gruen and McTigue (1963a) concluded that Kdfor five aliphatic aldehydes at 25" C is 16% to 25 % smaller in D20 than in HzO, the differences between the different aldehydes being probably within experimental error. They also find that AH is smaller in D20, so that the change in Kd appears as an entropy effect, but i t is doubtful whether this is firmly established. Edwards et al. (1962) found a somewhat smaller effect (10%) for acetaldehyde at 20"C. Pocker (1960) has also reported a 10% effect in the same direction for acetaldehyde in water at 0" and in 9 : 1 dioxanlwater at 25' C, but does not mention his experimental method. Because of the change of solvent involved it is difficult to give even a qualitative interpretation of this isotope effect. Both the diol and the water molecule formed by its dissociation will be hydrogen-bonded to the solvent, and the overall effect presumably reflects the balance of rather complex changes of zero-point energy which depend upon the mass of the hydrogen isotope. The hydrogen atoms on carbon atoms adjacent to a carbonyl group can exchange with the solvent, but such exchange is slow in neutral solution and is unlikely to have taken place appreciably in the measurements quoted above. In this connection it is interesting to note that Jones and Bender (1960)have reported secondary deuterium isotope effects of up to 40% for analogous equilibria such as (CD,)&O + MeOH$(CD,),C(OH)OMe, though their equilibrium constants show considerable variations and a trend with concentration. 111. ACIDITYOF CARBONYL HYDRATES
A. Experimental Methods The gem-diols are considerably stronger acids than the glycols or the monohydric alcohols, and the equilibrium R1R2C(OH),+ R,R,C(OH)O- + Hf can be investigated in alkaline aqueous solutions.
REVERSIBLE HYDRATION OF CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
13
The anion can also be thought of as being formed by the addition of a hydroxide ion to the unhydrated carbonyl compound, and the following constants may be defined [RiRzC(OH)O-l [H+l/[RiRzC(oH)zl =Ki [RiRaC(OH)O-I/[RiRaC(OH)al [OH-] =Kz [RiRaC(OH)O-][H+]/[RiRaCO] =K3 [R1RzC(OH)O-]/[RiRzCO] [OH-] =K4
with the obvious relations K z = K l / K w , K , = K 1 / K , , K 4= K l / K w K d where K d is the constant defined in the last section. If K , is large and unknown it may be possible to determine only K , and K 4 of the above constants. It should be pointed out that many carbonyl compounds can also give rise to enolate ions, even when the equilibrium content, of enol is very low, and that most of the experimental methods employed do not discriminate between the two kinds of anion. It is probable that for simple aldehydes and ketones (the only classes whose acidity has been hitherto investigated) the amount of enolate ion is extremely small, but it would be desirable to check this independently, for example spectrophotometrically or by utilizing the rapid reaction of enolate ions with halogens. It has been reported (Taft and Cook, 1959) that hexafluoroacetylacetone and thenoyltrifluoroacetone, although quite strong acids in aqueous solution, appear to ionize very slowly in IMsodium hydroxide. As pointed out by Stewart and Van der Linden (1960) this is no doubt because the stable form of the ion is the enolate, which is formed slowly from the very small amount of unhydrated ketone present. The acidity of the gem-diols is not usually great enough to be determined by the usual methods of pH-measurement, though the pK of chloral hydrate (10.04) has been determined by potentiometric titration with a glass electrode (Bell and Onwood, 1962). A more useful general method is that employed by Ballinger and Long (1969,1960) for measuring the acidity of alcohols, which employs the change of conductivity of dilute sodium hydroxide solutions produced by the addition of a weak acid. It is necessary to know the mobility of the anion produced, but an approximate estimate is sufficient on account of the high mobility of the hydroxide ion. It is possible in principle to obtain both the anion mobility and the constant K 2from the conductivity measurements. This method has been applied to the hydrates of carbonyl compounds by Bell and McTigue (1960) and by Bell and Onwood (1962).l Many carbonyl compounds undergo slow condensation or reaction in alkaline solution, 1 Equation (3)of Bell and Onwood (1902)is actuallyvalid only if both the concentration of &on and that of added alkali are much smaller than that of the diol. This is not the case for all the measurements to which the equation was applied, but the resulting errors are small. Equation (3) also contains a misprint: the factor I,, - I,, should read I,, + I,.
14
R. P . B E L L
so that the observed conductivities must be extrapolated back to zero time : this is often a limitation to the application of the method. It is interesting to note that the anion mobilities thus obtained are all considerably smaller than those of the corresponding carboxylate ions, and the same is true of the anions of the alcohols studied by Ballinger and Long (1959, 1960). The difference may be due to the tetrahedral arrangement of groups round the carbon atom, as compared with the planar arrangement in a carboxylate ion, but it may also reflect the fact that the negative charge is concentrated on one oxygen atom rather than being shared between two, thus leading to increased solvation and a greater effective ionic size. If the solution contains an appreciable concentration of unhydrated carbonyl compound, the variation of carbonyl U.V. absorption with pH 1965). Simican be used to obtain K 4 (Bunnett et al., 1061; Hine et d., larly, in the weakly dissociated compounds X .CoH,.C(OH)2.CF, the variation of the aromatic absorption with pH provides a means of determining K 1 or K z (Stewart and Van der Linden, 1960). Since the reactivities of the species RIRzCO, R,R,C(OH), and R1R2C(OH)O-will normally be very different, the variation of reaction velocities with pH can sometimes give information about the equilibria involved. Thus Bunnett et al. (1961)showed that the alkaline cleavageof 2,6-dihalobenzaldehydesto m-dihalobenzenesand formate ion took place with an apparent fist-order velocity constant given by k' = k;K4[OH-l2/ (1 + K4[OH-]), where K 4(defined above) was measured independently by spectrophotometry, but could also have been derived from the kinetic results. I n this system there is no detectable amount of the unionized hydrate, and the cleavageis believed to involve reaction of the anion with another hydroxide ion. A similar kinetic investigation with chloral hydrate (Gustafsson and Johanson, 1948) leads to a value of pK1 (9.77) in fair agreement with that given in Table 2. Frequently the unhydrated carbonyl compound will be the most reactive species :thus measurements in this laboratory have shown that the velocity of the reaction CH2Cl.CHO + OH-+CH20H. CHO + C1- is proportional to the total aldehyde concentration and to the quantity [OH-]/( 1 + K,[OH-]), thus providing a means of determining K , . B. Results and Discussion Only a small number of substances have so far been investigated, and the available results are given in Table 2. These compounds should be more suitable than carboxylic acids for correlating acidity with inductive effects, since the negative charge is concentrated on one oxygen atom,
15
R E V E R S I B L E H Y D R A T I O N O F CARBONYL COMPOUND8
while in the carboxylate anions it is shared between two atoms, and the charge distribution may vary with the nature of the substituents and even with the solvent. (The same simple situation is of course also present with the alcohols, but few of these are sufficiently strong acids to be investigated accurately in aqueous solution.) Steric effects should be negligible. I n fact it was shown by Stewart and Van der Linden (1960) TABLE 2 Acid Strengths of gem-Diols in Water at 25"C
Ki = [RiR2C(OH)O-] [H+]/[RiRzC(OH)z] Substance
Method
pK1
Ref.
__ .___ ~
CH2(0H)z MeCH(OH)2 MezCH. CH(OH)2 CCls. CH(0H)z CaH5.C(OH)a.CF3 p-MeO.CaH4.C(OH)zCF3 p-Me.CaH4.C(0H)z.CFS m-Br.CeH4.C(OH)z.CFs m-NOa.CeH4.C(OH)a.CF3
~~
~
Conductivity Conductivity U.V. Conductivity U.V.
U.V. U.V. U.V.
U.V. ____
13.27 13.57 13.77 10.04 10.00 10.18 10.15 9.51 9.18
a a
b a C
C C C C
-
Bell and Onwood, 1962. b Hine et al., 1965. c Stewart and Van der Linden, 1960.
that the last five values in Table 2 correlate well with Hammett u-constants, and slightly better with the revised uO-constantsof Taft et al. (1959),in each case with p = 1.1. A similar correlation was found for the CHOH. CF3,with p = 1.0. the acidity of the carbinols X . CBH4. For the aliphatic compounds the appropriate substituent constant is u*, and the first four values in Table 2 correlate well with u* if p* = 1.4, which is identical with the value found by Ballinger and Long (1959,1960) for ten methanols with electronegative substituents. We can in fact include both the alcohols and the gem-diols in the same series if we take u* = 1.28 for the substituent OH and allow statistically for the number of OH-groups. Extrapolation of the values for gem-diols to u* = 0 gives pK- 14.5forMe2C(OH),.Sincethis speciesispresenttotheextentofonly about 0.2% in aqueous solutions of acetone (see Table l),these solutions would not be expected to show detectable acid properties, in agreement with experiment.
16
R. P . BELL
Iv. KINETICSO F HYDRATION AND DEHYDRATION REACTIONS A. Historical Although equilibrium in the system RlR2C0 + H,0+R1R2C(OH), is achieved rapidly a t ordinary temperatures, there has long been qualitative evidence that i t is not established instantaneously. Thus Perkin (1887) observed that when acetaldehyde and water are mixed the evolution of heat occurs over a period of several minutes : he also found that in measuring the densities of aqueous acetaldehyde solutions at different temperatures it was necessary to keep them at constant temperature for a considerable time before consistent results could be obtained. Brown and Pickering (1897) also observed the slow evolution of heat on mixing, and found that it was accelerated by the addition of small quantities of ammonia. They attributed this to the intermediate formation of aldehyde-ammonia, but it would now be explained in terms of catalysis by hydroxide ions. Cohn and Urey (1938) observed slow exchange between acetone and l80in water, which was accelerated by acids and bases: thiscanonlybedue to thepro~essMe~CO+H~O+Me~C(OH)~. Herbert and Lauder (1938) found that the rate of the corresponding exchange with acetaldehyde was much higher but still measurable. I n the same year Booth and Roughton (1938) measured the rate of hydration of carbon dioxide, and showed that it was catalysed by bases. Some years later both Vesely and Brdi6ka (1947) and Bieber and Triimpler (1947a) showed that the magnitude of the polarographic reduction current of aqueous formaldehyde solutions depended on the rate of dissociation of methylene glycol and varied with the pH of the solution. The first systematic study of the catalytic behaviour of this class of reaction was carried out by Bell and Higginson (1949) for the dissociation of MeCH(OH), in aqueous acetone. B. Mechanism and Relation to other Reactions The addition of water to a carbonyl group is a special case of the more general reaction R,R,CO + R30H+R,R2C(OH)OR3. Many reactions of this type have been studied kinetically and shown to be catalysed by acids or bases or both, for example the reversible formation of semiacetals (Dieckmann, 1916, 1917; Meadows and Darwent, 1952) the mutarotation of glucose (Lowry and Smith, 1927 ;Bronsted and Guggenheim, 1927) and the reversible dimerization of /3-hydroxyaldehydes and p-hydroxyketones (Bell and Baughan, 1937; Bell and Hirst, 1939). The last two reactions involve respectively the intramolecular and intermolecular making and breaking of semi-acetal linkages. Similar catalytic
17
REVERSIBLE HYDRATION O F CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
effects are found in the mutarotation of optically active a-keto-esters in alcoholic solution (McKenzie and Mitchell, 1929 ;McKenzie and Ritchie, 1931, 1932) and in exchange reactions between alcohols and esters (Alquier, 1943; Schaefgen et al., 1945), both of which presumably take place by the reversible addition of alcohol to the carbonyl group. All these reactions will have a common mechanism, which for the hydration reaction can be written as follows (Bell and Higginson, 1949) :
Acid Catalysis
+
\ +H ~ +OHB + /c(oH)oH2 + B\ + \ /C(OH)OHz + B- + /C(OH)z + HB >CO
(i) (ii)
Basic Catalysis
+ /C(OH)O-+HB \
)CO+H~O+B-
,C(OH)O\
+HB + )c(oH)~+ B-
(iii) (iv)
Of these four reactions (ii) and (iv)involve simple proton transfers to and from oxygen atoms, and experience shows that such equilibria will be set up very rapidly. The rate-limiting steps then become (i) and (iii), which involve greater structural changes and are likely to be slow. They are both formally termolecular reactions, and it is of interest to enquire whether either of them can be split up into consecutive bimolecular processes, one of which is rate-limiting. The only possibilities are as follows :
Reaction (i)
r
1
H B + H ~ O+ B - + H ~ o +
)CO+H.O+
I.+
$
/C:OH+H~O
+ /C(OH)OHz \
+
+ )C(OH)OH~
+
R . P. B E L L
18
Reaction (iii) B-+HzO )CO+OH-
[ )CO+HzO
p HB+OH-
+ )C(OH)O-
+
$
>C(O-)OHz
It appears that all these possibilities can be excluded. If reactions (a) or (9)were rate-limiting the reaction velocity would be independent of the concentration of the substrate, while reaction (e) (identical with (I)) would predict no catalysis by acids or bases. If reactions ( b ) , ( d ) or (h) determined the rate the reaction would show specific catalysis by hydrogen or hydroxide ions, in place of the general acid-base catalysis actually observed. Reactions (c), d f ) and (m) are unacceptable as rate-limiting processes, since they involve simple proton transfers to and from oxygen. Reactions 0’) and (k)might well be slow, but their rates would depend upon the nucleophilic reactivity of the catalyst towards carbon rather than on its basic strength towards a proton: as shown in Section IV,D it is the latter quantity which correlates closely with the observed rates. There is thus good evidence that the transition state contains a t least one molecule of water, and it has been suggested (Eigen, 1966) that a more reasonable physical picture is obtained if two more are included, when it becomes possible to replace the two steps (i)and (ii) or (iii) and (iv) by a concerted process involving a cyclic hydrogen-bonded transition state. The arguments for this proposal depend on a more detailed consideration of the rates of the individual processes concerned. I n the first place, if reasonable estimates are made of the equilibrium constants of reactions (ii) and (iv), it is found that for some catalysts the observed rates would demand velocity constants higher than the diffusion controlled value for the reverse of reactions (i) and (iii): in other words, there would be insufficient time for the species B- or HB to become free and move to the other oxygen atom of the hydrate. I n the second place, even if the required rate constants do not exceed the diffusion controlled values, they are so high that considerable curvature would be expected in the plots of log (catalytic constant) against pK for a series of catalysts. As shownin Section IV,F this curvature is not observed. There is thus a considerable
REVERSIBLE HYDRATION OF CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
19
amount of evidence for a concerted mechanism, including several water molecules, which for acid catalysis can be written H
H
0-H---
0-€I
I
I
,\
-
L
\
/"
No
H
H
H-oO--.H
I
I
I
\
/O
='\
R
0-H"
0-H
I
with a similar scheme for basic catalysis. Some variants on the above mechanism have been proposed. Gibert
+
(1954) has suggested that the species R,R,C: OH is formed by reaction
with an acidic species, and then reacts witheitherHzO or OH- to give the hydrate (cf. reactions (c) and (d) above). Under certain simplifying assumptions this scheme leads to the observed kinetic behaviour, but it predicts general acid-base catalysis only if proton-transfers to and from oxygen are rate-determining : moreover, it predicts a relation between the catalytic constants of an acid-base pair which is not observed in practice (Bell et al., 1956), Gruen and McTigue (1963b) have proposed
+
that in acid catalysis the species RIRzC:OH is formed reversibly, and then reacts in a rate-determining termolecular step with water and the conjugate base of the catalysing acid. This corresponds to a transition state of the same composition as the mechanism proposed above, but to a different arrangement of its components, i.e. d+
\ &
d-
..O - - - l i - - - J J
/ c.
8 -
_I H
,
\ /O---H---B
OH
ant1
C>,
-~
'0-H
I
H
A t present there appears to be no evidence which distinguishes between these two possibilities, and they become indistinguishable in terms of the cyclic transition states proposed above.
C. Experimental Methods Since water is normally present in large excess, the reaction can be characterized by two first-order velocity constants, kd for hydrate dissociation, and k, for hydration. Any method which measures the rate of approach to equilibrium will give an overall rate constant k = k d + k h ,
20
R. P. BELL
but some methods will give kd or Jch separately. They are of course related by kdlk),= Kd, the equilibrium constant for dissociation of the hydrate. The reactions are accompanied by a considerable volume change, and a dilatometric method was employed by Bell and Higginson (1949)) who added acetaldehyde-water mixtures (containing about equal quantities of MeCHO and MeCH(OH),) to an excess of acetone, and thus measured kd in presence of a large number of acid catalysts. The direct hydration of acetaldehyde in aqueous buffer solutions is inconveniently fast at room temperatures, but (kd+ kh)was measured dilatometrically at 0" C by Bell and Darwent (1950), who established the existence of general acid-base catalysjs. Lauder (1948)also gives data for the rate of hydration of acetaldehyde based on dilatometric and refractometric measurements. He did not realize the catalytic nature of the reaction, and worked in unbuffered solutions which presumably contained small but variable quantities of acetic acid : this may account for the erratic nature of his results and for the fact that his rates decrease with increasing temperature. It is more difficult to explain the fact that most of his recorded rates are considerably lower than the minimum (water-catalysed) velocity obtained by other methods. He used concentrated solutions of acetaldehyde, which may have contained considerable quantities of the hemihydrate (MeCHOH)20. The presence of this species has been recently suggested by Ahrens and Strehlow (1965) on the basis of N.M.R. spectra: there is evidence for the existence of analogous species in aqueous formaldehyde solutions (Bezzi et al., 1951),and the hemihydrate (CH2Cl.CHOH),O can be isolated as a solid (Natterer, 1882). The rate of heat evolution can be used to follow reactions with halflives down to a second or less. This method was h t applied by Bell and Clunie (1952b) to the hydration of acetaldehyde in aqueous acetate buffersat 0"C, and a more detailed study was made at 25" C by Bell et al. (1956). A similar method was later used by Gruen and McTigue (1963b) for other aldehydes. The appearance or disappearance of the U.V. absorption of the carbony1 group can in principle be used for kinetic measurements. Bell and Jensen (1961) applied this method to 1,3-dichloroacetone: the reaction is too fast in pure water, but proceeded a t a convenient rate in 5% water+dioxan mixtures, in which there is about 50% hydration at equilibrium, Catalysis by many acids and bases was observed. Much faster reactions can be studied by relaxation methods, and the pressurejump technique has been applied to the reaction MeC(OH)2.C02H+ MeCO.CO,H+H,O by Strehlow (1962).
REVERSIBLE HYDRATION O F CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
21
In the polarography of aqueous formaldehyde solutions the only reducible species is the unhydrated aldehyde, and under suitable conditions the observed current is dependent on the rate of dissociation of methylene glycol. This was f i s t shown by Vesely and BrdiEka (1 947) and by Bieber and Trumpler (1947a); later work (BrdiEka, 1955) demonstrated catalysis by borate and hydroxide ions, but no extensive study has been made by this method. An exact mathematical solution of the diffusion problem is difficult to obtain: a recent review has been given by BrdiEka (1960). For suitable substances the average life-time of the hydrated or unhydrated species can be deduced from the broadening of nuclear magnetic resonance lines. This has recently been applied to acetaldehyde (Evans et al., 1965; Ahrens and Strehlow, 1965) and to isobutyraldehyde (Hine and Houston, 1965); the velocities deduced for catalysis by hydrogen ions are in fair agreement with those obtained by other methods. It has been shown by HBnaff (1963)that the rate of reaction of several carbonyl reagents (bisulphite, hydrazine, phenylhydrazine, semicarbazide and hydroxylamine) with aqueous formaldehyde solutions is independent of the nature and concentration of the reagent, and is therefore determined by the rate of dehydration of methylene glycol. He obtained catalytic constants for hydrogen and hydroxide ions, and a detailed study of acid-base catalysis has been made by the same method by Bell and Evans (1966). I n principle the velocity of dehydration could be measured if a physical rather than a chemical method were available for removing the unhydrated carbonyl compound at a rate comparable to its hydration. It was claimed by Bieber and Trumpler (1947a) that this could be achieved by the removal of formaldehyde in a rapid gas stream, the rate of which appeared to be dependent on the pH of the solution. However, attempts to repeat their experiments have proved unsuccessful ; moreover, although they give no experimental details, calculation in terms of known kinetic and equilibrium constants shows that for a 1-ml liquid sample a gas flow of at least 30 litreslmin would be required to produce an appreciable perturbation of equilibrium conditions (Bell and Evans, 1966). It is thus clear that this method has no practical application, at least to formaldehyde solutions. The rate of exchange of l 8 0 between a carbonyl compound and water should give information about the velocity of the reversible hydration process, as shown in the early work of Cohn and Urey (1938)with acetone. Herbert and Lauder (1938) showed that isotopic exchange is faster with acetaldehyde, but no quantitative information was obtained. It would
22
R. P . B E L L
be of interest to carry out further studies on l*O exchange, and nuclear magnetic resonance measurements with "0 should give information about rapid exchanges.
D. Catalytic Behaviour Hydration and dehydration reactions have proved particularly convenient for studying catalysis by acids and bases over a wide range of structures and catalytic power. The results usually show a good correlation between acidic and basic catalytic constants (k, and kJ and the pK of the catalyst, accordingto the usual Bronstedrelations k,/p = G,(qK/p)", kJq = Q,(p/qK)@,where p and q are statistical corrections. (These statistical corrections have not always been applied consistently, but the discrepancies thus introduced are not serious.) The information so far obtained is summarized in Table 3, and comments on the individual reactions follow. TABLE 3 Hydration-dehydration Reactions at 25" C
n = number of catalysts
d = mean deviation of logk from linear relationship Solvent
Substance Acetaldehyde Acetaldehyde Acetaldehyde Formaldehyde Formaldehyde 1,3-Dichloro-acetone 1,3-Dichloro-acetone 1,3-Dichloro-acetone a c
Water Water 92.5% acetone Water Water 95% dioxan 95% dioxan 95% dioxan
Bell et al., 1956. Bell and Evans, 1966.
Catalyst type Ao,A+ BO, BA0 A", A+ BO, BA0 BO Bb d
PK
n
range
A
12 14 52 13 29 24 13 7
8 17
0.10 0.13 0.03 0.06 0.11 0.16 0.10 0.10
10
9 17 17 6 4
a o r p Ref. 0.54 0.45 0.54 0.23
a 6
0.46
c
0.27 0.50 0.50
d d
c
d
Bell and Higginson, 1949. Bell and Jensen, 1961.
1. Acetaldehyde
The catalytic constants for acids in aqueous solution correlate well with pK, and there is no apparent difference between uncharged and cation acids (carboxylic acids and pyridinium cations), though some steric inhibition is evident for 2,6-substituted pyridinium cations. The catalytic constants for bases behave somewhat more erratically, a.nd it has been suggested by Gruen and McTigue (1963b)that errors are intro-
REVERSIBLE HYDRATION O F CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
23
duced into the thermal method used for measuring the reaction velocities by the formation of addition compounds between acetaldehyde and the anions used as catalysts, for which there is some independent evidence. It may be significant that earlier measurements at 0' C by a dilatometric method (Bell and Darwent, 1950) gave a better correlation between kb and pK for seven bases of varying types, and further investigation would be desirable. The catalytic constants in 92.5% acetone have been correlated with pK-values in water, but essentially the same picture emerges if we use relative strengths in n-butanol, which has a dielectric constant similar to that of 92.5% acetone: these strengths are available for twenty-two of the acid catalysts used (Wooten and Hammett, 1935). The fifty-two acids included in Table 3 comprise carboxylic acids, phenols and NHacids, and somewhat better correlations are obtained by considering separately aliphatic carboxylic acids, aromatic carboxylic acids, and phenols. Large positive deviations (up to two powers of ten) were observed for oximes as catalysts, and large negative ones for nitroparaffins and the enols of /3-diketones : these substances are not included in the summary in Table 3.l Structural interpretations were originally suggested for these deviations (Bell and Higginson, 1949),but, at least in detail, they are often more ingenious than convincing. A recent report (Pocker and Meany, 1964) states that the enzyme carbonic anhydrase is a powerful catalyst for the reversible hydration of acetaldehyde, but no details have yet been published. 2. Formaldehyde
Apart from a limited amount of information from polarographic measurements (BrdiEka, 1955)catalytic data for this system have been obtained by using carbonyl reagents as scavengers, thus measuring the rate of dehydration of methylene glycol (HBnaff, 1963;Bell and Evans, 1966). The thirteen acids and twenty-nine bases listed in Table 3 include species derived from carboxylic acids and amines, and also inorganic species derived from arsenate, phosphite, phosphate, tellurate, borate, sulphite, sulphate and fluoride. Catalysts of all chemical types (including H,O+, HzO and OH-) confqrm to the same relationships, and there is little effect of charge, except that the anion acids HzPO;, HzPO; and HzAsO; show positive deviations of about 0.5 in logk. I n deriving the correlations in Table 3 the usual statistical factorsp and q have been used, but the general agreement is almost as good if they are omitted. The 1 The deviation reported for chloral hydrate as a catalyst disappears if wo use a more recent value of pK (Bell and Onwood, 1962). 2
.
24
R . P . BELL
independence of charge and structural type is in marked contrast to the behaviour reported for the hydration of carbon dioxide (see Section IV, F). 3. 1,3-Dichlmoacetone The catalytic constants measured in 95% aqueous dioxan have been compared with pK-values in water. The twenty-four acids referred to in Table 3 are mainly carboxylic acids, but also include nitric acid, o-chlorophenol and water. Two oximes show large positive deviations, and saccharin has considerably less catalytic activity than anticipated : these substances have not been included in the correlation. A number of “strong ” acids gave closely similar catalytic constantsHC1 (3.05), HBr (2.30), CBH6.S03H(2*30),MeS0,H (2*15),HC104 (1*25)-and the minor variations within this series are not in the expected order of acid strengths HCIOl HBr > HCI > C6H6.S03H> MeSOSH. Presumably all these acids are converted in solution to the hydronium ion, the catalytic power of which is somewhat modified by ion-pairing with different anions in the solvent of low dielectric constant. The catalytic constants observed are consistent with the conventional value pK = - 1.74 for H30+. The plot of logk against pK for basic catalysts gives two parallel straight lines, carboxylate anions being about 1000 times as effective as amine bases of the same pK. This can be largely attributed to the use of pK-values in water rather than in aqueous dioxan, since the equiIibrium RC02H+H,O+RCO, +H,O+ will be affected much more than R,NH++H20+R,N +H30+by a decrease in dielectric constant. (No such effect of charge is observed in the results for acetaldehyde and formaldehyde in aqueous solution, where both k and pK refer to the same solvent.) Some steric inhibition is again evident for 2,6-substituted pyridines.
=-
4. Comments on catalytic behaviour
The reversible hydration of carbonyl compounds shows an unusual degree of conformity to the Bronsted relation, both in the range of pK over which linearity is observed and in the lack of dependence on the charge or chemical nature of the catalyst. Eigen (1963) has produced much evidence to support the original contention of Bronsted and Pedersen (1923)that an apparently linear Bronsted plot represents only part of a continuous curve having slopes of unity and zero at its two extremities. Eigen refers to the unusually wide range of linearity observed in the mutarotation of glucose and in the dehydration of MeCH(OH)2,and attributes it to the fact that the rate-determining step
R E V E R S I B L E H Y D R A T I O N O F CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
25
is not a simple acid-base reaction, but is coupled with other processes such as the addition or removal of a water molecule. For this reason the absolute rate constants are relatively low even with very strong acids or bases, and diffusion-controlled rates are not approached for either the forward or the reverse reactions. As shown in Section IV,B, it is probably necessary to include several water molecules in the transition state, and the same arguments will apply. The absence of individual deviations due to variations of charge or chemical type can also be given a reasonable explanation. Conventional pK-values are defined in terms of equilibria for proton-transfers to and from the oxygen atom of water and steric effects will be neglibigle, whereas most of the reactions for which the Bronsted relation has been tested depend on proton transfers to or from carbon or nitrogen, and frequently involve the possibility of steric or other interactions between non-reacting groups. I n the reactions considered here the proton transfers take place to and from oxygen, and steric effects involving the catalyst will be small, especially if we accept the cyclic transition state suggested in Section IV,B: thus there should be a particularly close parallelism between the observed rate and the pK in water. Measurements by relaxation of the rapid reversible hydration of pyruvic acid (Eigen et al., 1962 ;Strehlow 1962) have producedinteresting results. Reactions involving the anions MeCO .CO, and MeC(OH),CO, make a negligible contribution, but the reaction MeCO .COzH + H20+ MeC(OH),. COzH is catalysed by hydrogen ions, pyruvic acid molecules and pyruvate ions. There is also a “spontaneous” rate, which (by comparison with the results for other hydration reactions) seems much too great to be interpreted as catalysis by water molecules. It was suggested by the authors that this part of the observed rate is due to intramolecular catalysis of the hydration process by the carboxyl group, and this explanation seems particularly likely in terms of a cyclic transition state containing two additional water molecules (see Section IV,B). It is of interest to note that intramolecular catalysis by the carboxylate group has also been established for the iodination of pyruvic acid and a number of other keto-carboxylic acids (Albery et al., 1965; Bell and Fluendy, 1963). I n these reactions the rate-determining step involvestheloss to the carboxylate group of a proton attached to carbon, and cyclic transition states can be constructed without the intervention of water molecules. Finally, it may be noted that the reversible addition of water to 2-hydroxypteridine is subject to general catalysis by acids and bases (Inoue and Perrin, 1962). The reaction here is -CH=N-+H20+ 4HOH-NHand the mechanism is presumably analogous to that of the hydration reactions discussed in this review.
26
R. P . B E L L
E. Isotope Eflects The only kinetic isotope effects so far reported for these reactions are those given by Pocker (1960), without experimental detail. He reports closely similar values for the rates of solvent-catalysed hydration of the species CH,. CHO, CD,. CHO, CH, .CDO and CD, .CDO in water at O°C ; the replacement of CH, by CD, increases the velocity by about 7%. The same effect is reported for solutions in deuterium oxide a t 0" C, presumably super-cooled. A comparison was also made of rates of hydration in H20 and D,O at O O C , giving the following values for k(H20)/k(D20)in presence of different catalysts :H+/D+,1-3;AcOH/AcOD, 2.5; AcO-, 2.3 ; H20/D20,3.6. Almost exactly the same ratios were obtained by measuring rates of dehydration at 25°C in dioxan containing 10% of H,O or D20and various catalysts. The presence of a considerablesolvent isotope effect is consistent with the mechanism given in Section IV,B, and i t would not be expected that substitution of deuterium on carbon would have an appreciable effect on the rate. It should be noted that the methyl group of acetaldehyde will exchange with the hydrogen of the solvent a t an appreciable rate, especially in presence of acids or bases. It is not clear whether such exchange had taken place in the above experiments.
F. The Hydration of Carbon Dioxide
A review of this reaction has recently been published (Edsall and Wyman, 1958), and only some particular points will be mentioned here. Early work a t 0' C (Booth and Roughton, 1938) showed that the absorption of carbon dioxide is catalysed by the anions of weak inorganic acids, and further catalytic constants (at 5°C) were obtained by Kiese and Hastings (1940). Two recent investigations at 0°C by flow techniques (Ho and Sturtevant, 1963; Gibbons and Edsall, 1963) are in good agreement as regards the rate of the uncatalysed reaction, but disagree on the existence of detectable catalysis by the ion HPOI-. A recent paper by Sharma and Danckwerts (1963) summarizes earlier results and adds new ones, catalytic constants being given for thirty-one bases. They conclude that there is a correlation between basic strength and catalytic power within a group of structurally similar catalysts, but that structural variations can cause wide deviations from this correlation, especially among inorganic anions with several oxygen atoms. This behaviour contrasts markedly with that of the hydration reactions discussed in the last section (especially the dehydration of methylene glycol), for which relations between acid-base strength and catalytic power are valid over
R E V E R S I B L E H Y D R A T I O N O F CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
27
wide variations of structure; it is therefore possible that the hydration of carbon dioxide involves some special mechanism. However, examination of the experimental data shows that many of the reported catalytic constants vary with pH (often by a factor of two to three, and sometimes by a factor of ten), while the values of different authors often disagree: for example, the value for the catalyst SO;- is given as 0.65-1-3 (Sharma and Danckwerts, 1963), 0-4-2.8 (Kiese and Hastings, 1940) and 1.9 (Booth and Roughton, 1938). It is possible that the gas absorption method does,not give a correct measure of the rates of the chemical processes invblved, and it seems premature to speculate until the experimental position is clearer. REFERENCES Adkins, H., Elofson, R. M., Rossow, A. G., and Robinson, C. C. (1949). J . Amer. Chem. SOC.71, 3622. Ahrens, M.-L., and Strehlow, H. (1965). Disc. Faraday SOC.39, 112. Albery, W. J., Bell, R. P., and Powell, A. L. (1965). Trans. Farad. SOC.61, 1194. Alquier, R. (1943). Bull. soc. chim. France ( 5 ) 10, 197. Ballinger, P., and Long, F. A. (1959). J . A m . Chem. SOC.81, 1050, 2347. Ballinger, P., and Long, F. A. (1960). J . A m . Chem. SOC.82, 795. Bell, R. P., and Baughan, E. C. (1937). J . Chem. SOC.1947. Bell, R. P., and Clunie, J. C. (1952a). Trans. Faraday SOC.48, 439. Bell, R. P., and Clunie, J. C. (1952b). Proc- Roy. SOC.212,33. Bell, R. P., and Darwent, B. de B. (1950). Trans. Faraday SOC.46, 34. Bell, R. P., and Evans, P. G. (1966). Proc. Roy. SOC.A, in the press. Bell, R. P., and Fluendy, M. A. D. (1963). Trans. Faruday SOC.59, 1623. Bell, R. P., and Higginson, W. C. E. (1949). Proc. Roy. SOC.A, 197, 141. Bell, R. P., and Hirst, J. P. H. (1939). J . Chem. SOC.1777. Bell, R. P., and Jensen, M. B. (1961). Proc. Roy. SOC.A, 261, 38. Bell, R. P., and McDougall, A. 0. (1960). Trans. Furaday SOC.56, 1281. Bell, R. P., and McTigue, (1960). J . Chem. SOC.2983. Bell, R. P., and Onwood, D. P. (1962). Trans. Faraday SOC.58, 1557. Bell, R. P., and Wright, G. A. (1961). Trans. Faraday Soc. 57, 1386. Bell, R. P., Rand, M. H., and Wynne-Jones, K. M. A. (1956). Trans. Faraday Soc. 52, 1093.
Bender, M. L. (1951). J . A m . Chem. SOC.73, 1626. Bezzi, S., Dallaporta, N., Giacometti, G., and Iliceto, A. (1951). Gnzz. chim. ital. 81, 915.
Bieber, R., and Triimpler, G. (1947a). Helw. Chim. Acta 30, 706. Bieber, R., and Trumpler, 0. (1947b). HeZw. Chim. Acta 30, 1860. Bishop, E. O., and Richards, R. E. (1959). Trans. Faraday Soc. 55, 1070. Booth, V. H., and Roughton, F. J. W. (1938). Biochem. J . 32,2049. BrdiEka, R. (1955). Collection Czechoslav. Chem. Commun. 20, 387. BrdiEka, R. (1960). “Advances in Polarography”, Pergamon Press, Oxford, p. 655. Bronsted, J. N., and Guggenheim, E. A. (1927). J . A m . Chem. SOC.49,2554. Bronsted, J. N., and Pedersen, K. J. (1923). 2. physikal. Chem. 108, 185. Brown, H. T., and Pickering, P. S. U. (1897). J . Chem. SOC.71, 774.
28
’
R . P. B E L L
Bunnett, J. F., Miles, J. H., and Nahabedian, K. V. (1961). J . Am. Chem.SOC. 83, 2512. Cohn, M., and Urey, H. C. (1938). J . Am. Chem.SOC. 60, 679. Dertooz, M., and Nasielski, J. (1961). Bull. SOC.chim. Belges, 70, 794. Dieckmann, W. (1916). Chem. Ber. 49, 2213. Dieckmann, W. (1917). Chem. Ber. 50, 1375. Edsall, J. T., and Wyman, J. (1958). “Biophysical Chemistry”, Academic Press, New York, Vol. I, Chap. 10. Edwards, J. O., Ibne-Ram, K. M., Choi, E. I.,and Rice, C. L. (1962). J.Phye. Chem. 66, 212. Eigen, M. (1963). Angew. Chem. 75,489. Eigen, M. (1965). Disc. Faraday Soc. 39, 7. Eigen, M., Kustin, K., and Strehlow, H. (1962). 2. physik. Chem. 31, 140. Evans, P. G., Kreevoy, M. M., and Miller, G. R. (1965). J . Phy8. Chem. 69,4325. Federlin, P. (1952). Compt. rend. 235, 44. Fujiwara, Y., and Fujiwara, S. (1963). Bull. Chem. SOC. Japan 36, 574. Gauditz, I. L. (1941). Z.phy&k. Chem. B , 48, 228. Gibbons, B. H., and Edsall, J. T. (1963). J . Biol. Chem. 238, 3502. Gibert, R. (1954). J . chim. phy8.51, 372. Gruen, L. C., and McTigue, P. T. (1963a). J . Chem. SOC.5217. Gruen, L. C., and McTigue, P. T. (1963b). J . Chem. SOC. 5224. Gubareva, M. A. (1947). Zhur. Obshchei. Khim. 17,2259. Gustafsson, C., and Johanson, M. (1948). Acta Chim. Scand. 2,42. HBnaff, P. L. (1963). Compt. rend. 256,1752. Herbert, J. B. M., and Lauder, I. (1938). Trans. Faraday Soc. 34, 432, 1219. Hbrold, W. (1932). 2.physik. Chem. B,, 18 265. HBrold, W., and Wolf, K. L. (1929). 2. physik. Chem. B, 5, 121. HBrold, W., and Wolf, K. L. (1931). 2. physik. Chem. B , 12, 165. Hibben, J. H. (1931). J . Am. Chem. Soc. 53, 2418. Hine, J., and Houston, J. G. (1965). J . Org. Chem. 30, 1328. Hine, J., and Redding, R. (1964). Personal communication. Hine, J., Houston, J. G., and Jensen, J. H. (1965). J . Org. Chem. 30, 1184. Ho, C., and Sturtevant, J. M. (1963). J . Biol. Chem. 238, 3499. Homfray, I. F. (1905). J . Chsm. SOC. 87, 1436. Iliceto, A. (1954). Qazz. chim. itul. 84, 536. Inoue, Y., and Perrin, D. D. (1962). J . Phys. Chem. 66, 1689. 82,6322. Jones, J. M., and Bender, M. L. (1960). J . Am. Chem.SOC. Kiese, M., and Hastings, A. B. (1940). J . Biol. Chem. 132, 267. Landqvist, N. (1955). Acta Chem. Scad. 9 , 867, 1127. Lander, I. (1948). Trans. Faraday SOC.44, 729. Leffler, J. E., and Grunwald, E. (1963). “Rates and Equilibria of Organic Reactions”, John Wiley, New York, Chap. 7. Lombardi, E., and Sogo, P. B. (1960). J . Chem. Phys.32,635. Lowry, T. M., and Smith, G. F. (1927). J . Chem. SOC.2539. Japan 36, 954. Matsushima, M. (1963). Bull. Chem. SOC. McKenzie, A., and Mitchell, A. G. (1929). Biochem. 2.208, 456. McKenzie, A., and Ritchie, P. D. (1931). Biochem. 2.231, 412; 237, 1. McKenzie, A., and Ritchie, P. D. (1932). Biochem. 2.250, 376. Meadows, G. W., and Darwent, B. de B. (1952). Trans. Faraday SOC. 48, 1015. Natterer, M. (1882). Monatsh. 3, 449.
REVERSIBLE HYDRATION OF CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
29
Pavelich, W. A., and Taft, R. W. (1957). J . A m . Chem. SOC.79, 4935. Perkin, W. H. (1887). J . Chem. SOC.51, 808. Piret, M. W. andHall, E. L. (1949). Ind. Eng. Chem. 41, 1277. Pocker, Y. (1960). Proc. Chem. SOC.17. Pocker, Y., and Meany, J. E. (1964). Abstracts, Amer. Chem. SOC.Meeting, Chicago, Sept. 1964. Ramsay, W., and Young, S. (1886). Phil. Trans. 177, 71. Rumpf, P., and Bloch, C. (1951). Compt. rend. 233, 1364. Schaefgen, J. R., Verhoek, F. H., and Newman, M. S. (1945). J . A m . Chem. Soc. 67, 253.
Schou, S. A. (1926). Compt. rend. 182, 965. Schou, S. A. (1929). J . Chim. phys. 26, 69. Sharma, A., and Danckwerts, P. V. (1963). Trans. Paraday SOC.59, 386. Stewart, R., and Van der Linden, R. (1960). Can. J . Chem. 38, 399. Strehlow, H. (1962). 2. Elektrochem. 66, 392. Sullivan, D. G. O., and Sadler, P. W. (1957). J . Chem. Soc. 4144. Taft, R. W. (1952). J . A m . Chem. Soc. 74, 2729, 3126. Taft, R. W. (1953). J . A m . Chem. SOC.75, 4538. Taft, R. W. (1966). “Steric Effects in Organic Chemistry”, ed. M. S. Newman, John Wiley, New York, Chap. 13. Taft, R. W., and Cook, E. H. (1959). J . A m . Chem. SOC.81,46. Taft, R. W., Ehrenson, S., Lewis, I. C., and Glick, R. E. (1959). J . A m . Chem. SOC. 81, 5352.
Valenta, P. (1960). Collection Czechoslav. Chem. Commun. 25, 853. Vesely, A., and BrdiEka, R. (1947). Collection Czechoslav. Chem. Commun. 12, 213. Walker, J. F. (1933). J . A m . Chem. SOC.55, 2821. Wissbrunn, K. F., French, D. M., and Patterson, A. (1954). J . Phys. Chem. 58,693. Wooten, L. A., and Hammett, L. P. (1935). J . A m . Chem. SOC.57,2289.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
IONIZATION POTENTIALS' D. W. TURNER Department of Chemistry, Imperial College of Xcience and Technology, University of London, England I. Introduction . 11. The Measurement of Ionization Potentials A. Historical . B. Recent Advances in Techiiique . 111. Molecular Structure Dependence of Ionization A. Introduction B. Amines . C. Alcohols and Ethers D. Aldehydes and Ketones . . E. Aromatic Compounds . F. Alkenes, Radicals and Alkanes. . References
.
.
.
31 35 35 39 46 46 47 50 62 65 63 69
Foreword Attempts to show the bearing of ionization potential data upon the electronic structure of complex organic molecules were greatly stimulated by the development of mass spectrometry which gave, quite easily, appearance potentials for a large number of molecular ions. More recently, notably in a review by Streitwieser (1963), the more readily reproducible photon impact values have begun to be employed. Lately, however, further advances in technique have given data on hitherto inaccessible higher ionization potentials and it seems worth while to see whether any clarification of previous uncertainties in interpretation can be expected from them. Owing to the still rather fragmentary coverage it has proved necessary to use both electron impact and photon impact results, though the one gives ideally vertical and the other adiabatic I.P. values. On the semi-empirical level of most of the arguments the difference is rather unimportant but should be borne in mind.
I. INTRODUCTION The Bohr theory of atomic structure allotted to each extra-nuclear electron within the atom a definite geometrical orbit and, more important, associated with each orbit a fixed total energy value. 1 We have used throughout the term ionizationpotentinl (I.P.)in preference to the more precise ionization energy on grounds of common usage.
2*
32
D . W . TURNER
Whilst the concept of definite geometrical orbits has been lost with the development of wave-mechanical pictures of atomic and, more recently, molecular structures, the idea of the existence of states of discrete energy or the existence of energy levels for extranuclear electrons in the field of one or more positive nuclei remains. It has become commonplace to make use of energy level diagrams to illustrate the manner in which the energies associated with the various orbitals (the wave mechanical equivalent of the Bohr orbits) are distributed on the energy scale. Such a diagram is illustrated in Pig. 1. This is constructed by placing a line for each orbital
lS’O-
- 1000
- 2000
‘\
- s-c-0 s: -
-
0:
- 20
S-C
-30
\-
c-0
- 40
1s.s-
FIa. 1. Orbital energy level diagram for carbon oxysulphide using theoretical values (Clementi, 1962). The deeper levels are essentially localized atomic orbitals. The energy scale is in electron volts, expanded on the right to show the valence shell structure.
spaced at distances proportional to the energy differences between orbitals. The absolute scale of energy is determined by the distances from a zero line correspondingto the energy of an electron a t an infinitely large distance from the central positive charge. The values used in the construction of Fig. 1 were theoretical (Clementi, 1962) and illustrate the occurrence of both large intervals between groups associated with differencesin principal quantum numbers n, and smaller intervals within each group or “shell”. The vertical scale is in the unit of energy most commonly used experimentally, the electron volt (e.v.), corresponding to the energy gained by an electron in traversing an electrostatic field whose limits differ in potential by 1 volt. The results of theoretical calculations are often expremed, however, in atomic units whose basis was originally the energy of ionization of the hydrogen atom, the Rydberg (R).Since the proton is light enough to contribute by its motion appreciably to the ionization energy, it has become the practice to employ units
IONIZATION POTENTIALS
33
based upon a hypothetically infinitely heavy (i.e. immobile) (‘proton” (Rm). The “double Rydberg” is also used and a recent rationalization proposed by Shull and Hall (1969) suggests replacing this by the Hartree ( H =me4/h2). The relation between these units and some practical units using the present values of rn, e, h, etc. are given in Table 1. TABLE1 Some Energy Units in Common Use 1 H = 27.210e.v. 1 R = 13.605e.v. 1 e.v. = 8,066 cm-1 1 e.v. = 23.06 kcal mole-1
The manner of fixing the absolute scale of energies in such a presentation equates the orbital energy (theoretically calculable) with the ionization potential, the energy necessary to remove to infinity or ionize an electron occupying the particular orbital in question. This is, briefly, Koopmans’ theorem. Whilst this is questionable in detail and is discussed further below, it is nevertheless true that there will be at least as many ionization potentials for a polyelectronic system as there are occupied orbitals. That there may be even more follows from the possibility of removing two electrons together or removing one and promoting another. The lowest ionization potential which can be observed, I , must relate to the removal of the most loosely bound electron (from the uppermost orbital level in such a diagram as Fig. 1 ) to leave the ion in an unexcited state. Kooprnans’ theorem. According to the concept of molecular orbitals developed from atomic orbitals (L.C.A.0.-M.O.) the electrons are allotted one at a time to spin orbitals of energy Ei which occur in pairs of equal Ei but of opposite spin i,bi (u),t,bi (p) until all available electrons are used up. Thus we can describe such a collection of occupied orbitals which form the molecule by the spectroscopic type of symbol a2,b2, . . . i2 . . . n.’, where the exponent shows the number of electrons in each twoelectron. orbital (i = & (u)t,hi p). Such a configuration on ionization affords a corresponding configuration with an electron missing from one of the spin orbitals: a2,b2 . . . i . . .n2 (i=a+n). I n the quantitative development of the structure in the self-consistent field approximation (S.C.F.) using the Hartree-Pock method the energy Ei is made up of three terms, one for the mean kinetic energy of the electron in i,hi, one for its mean potential energy in the field of the nuclei, and a correction term for the effect of all the other electrons, The total energy
34
D. W. TURNER
of the system would lose only these terms on removal of the ith electron so that the total energy of the ion is just Ei less than that of the molecule. Ei is thus equal to the negative of the ionization energy. It is somewhat artificial, however, to describe the effects of ionization so simply. The configuration of the ion is certainly not to be described accurately in terms of the same two-electron orbitals which were appropriate for the molecule. The presence of the positive charge results in altered ci values-the effective electronegativities of the constituent atoms-so that slightly altered atomic orbitals have to be used in the linear combination method. Further, the effects of electrostatic polarization in systems of mobile electrons can assume significant proportions, which amounts to saying that the positive hole left by the ith electron does not correspond exactly to t+hi. It is hardlysurprising, therefore, that ionization potentials calculated using Koopmans’ theorem have been found to be as much as 2-4 e.v. too large. Quite successful attempts to rectify this have been made by Hoyland and Goodman (1960) by allowing for deformation of both u- and n-electrons. Ehrenson (1962) similarly has shown that, using the w-technique (see p. 66), most of the deviations from Koopmans’ theorem come from the n-electrons and that an effective correction to the calculated value I only requires the use of the total number 7 of n-electrons: 1 = I - (7 - l)w/lo/q. This result is of considerable significance, for Koopmans’ theorem is of greatest value in the interpretation of data on higher ionization potentials. If it were to be found that the deviations were highly variable from one orbital to another within a particular system then the ionization potentials would not necessarily fall in the same order as the energies of the two-electron orbitals to which they relate. Fortunately this seems not to be the case. Examples are already to hand where predicted orbital energies from exact calculations agree well with observed ionization potentials and the associated bonding characters are in agreement with the experimental data. It seems that, though the flrst ionization potential predicted by Koopmans’ theorem may be in error by up to 4 e.v., rather similar deviations may appear for the higher values, so that the order and spacing of orbital energy levels can be inferred from ionizationpotential data. The energy associated with ionization processes is large since complete charge separation is involved. Most first ionization potentials are about 6-10 e.v. (140-280 kcal mole-l) and are thus much larger than bond energies, whilst the deepest valence shell electrons may have ionization potentials about three times greater (20-30 e.v.). Such high energies are not generally available chemically but the ionization energy is supplied by physical means, e.g. light (1) of the appropriate wavelength in the
35
IONIZATION POTENTIALS
vacuum ultraviolet region of the spectrum between 2000-400 e.v.).
M+hv
-+
A
(6-30
M++e
(1)
Alternatively the necessary energy can be supplied by the impact of electrons accelerated through the appropriate potential difference (2) or more subtly by collision with another positive (often atomic) ion with a higher recombination energy (the reverse of its ionization) (3).
M + e -+N++2e
M+X+
--f
M++X
(2) (3)
Although the energy required for ionization is so much larger than that associated with most chemical processes, considerable use has been made of ionization potential data in certain fields in which electron transfer, even if only partial, plays an important part. An early example (Compton, 1916) is to be found in attempts to relate minimum ionization potentials to the “looseness ” of the outermost molecular electrons requiredby dielectric theory. Subsequently in the years between 1928 and 1940 ionization-potential data were extensively used by R. S. Mulliken (c.f. Mulliken, 1935) in his development of the molecular orbital theory of the structure of simple molecules. With the increasing availability of reliable data associated with rapid developments in technique in the fields of vacuum ultraviolet and mass spectroscopy, attempts have been made to establish extensive correlations between ionization potentials on the one hand and polarographic oxidation potentials, the absorption spectra of charge-transfer species, basicities, and fluorescence quenching e&ts on the other, in all of which some degree of electron transfer from a donor molecule occurs. The effect of substituent groups in modifying ionization potentials has also been extensively examined in order to throw light on the manner of operation of substituent effects in general.
11. THEMEASUREMENT OF IONIZATION POTENTIALS A. Historical 1. The Hertz experiment
I n the first decade of the century a number of experiments were described which were interpreted as involving the ejection of molecular electrons and indicated the order of magnitude of the ionization poten-
36
D . W. TURNER
tials. These were particularly experiments with X-rays and with U.V.emitting discharge tubes. The first generally applicable method of more exact determination was described by Franck and Hertz (1913) and involved measuring the critical kinetic energies at which electrons were most likely to lose energy to the molecule under investigation. One such critical energy was of course the first molecular ionization potential but much early confusion sprang from the possibility of mere excitation resulting in characteristic critical kinetic energy values (Fig. 2).
1
FIG.2. Schematic representation of ionization ( I )and excitation ( E )potentials.
This experiment may be regarded as the forerunner of mass spectrometric appearance-potential determination in that both are threshold techniques, that is they depend on slow variation in the energy supplied by the impacting electron until a change in the electron-molecule interaction is observed. Thus, just as the Hertz experiment did not distinguish between excitation and ionization potentials, mass spectrometric appearance potential measurements are subject to similar ambiguities in interpretation as between ionization and autoionization. The Hertz experiment may also be regarded as the forerunner of the recently revived technique (Kuppermann et al., 1962) of electron loss spectroscopy applied to vapours. I n this, the characteristic energy losses (V,) are revealed as groups of scattered electrons of energy V, volts less than that of the incident beam whose energy is large compared with V , (see Fig. 3). Electron loss spectroscopy bears obvious similarities to Raman spectroscopy but, though ionization potentials are among the critical potentials detected, its greatest usefulness probably lies in the detection of excitation processes forbidden in optical absorption.
37
IONIZATION POTENTIALS Target molecule excited or ionised (VJ
Inelastic scatter
6
65
4.8
5
7.7
8.8
10 C
2 4 a x
=
3
(b) n
Y
2
\
U H Y
1
0
2
8
6
4
10
vc
FIG.3. (a) The inelastic scattering of electrons. (b) The energy loss spectrum for electron scattering by ethylene gas; 0 near 90'. (Reproduced with permission from Kupperman and Ruff, 1862.)
2 . Rydberg series molecular spectra
The ionization potential measurement to which the least ambiguity attaches is that which depends on the observation of a Rydberg series. Rydberg series stem from atomic spectroscopy. I n atomic spectra such series frequently form obvious features as groups of sharp, often intense lines showing a characteristic rapid convergence to shorter wavelengths up to a limit a t which they merge into a continuous absorption. Each line in such a series corresponds to the promotion of an electron to bound states of higher and higher principal quantum number n until, at the commencement of the continuum, it is just completely freed. The positions of the lines can be fitted to a series expression (4) v , ~= v, - R / ( n -
A)2
(4)
38
D. W . TURNER
where ( n - A ) is an effective quantum number. The sucess in fitting a number of observed lines to such a series is strong indication that a true ionization potential is associated with the limiting value v, . Rydberg series were detected in molecular spectra in the early 193O’s, notably by W. C. Price who showed that they arose from the outer electrons. These can usually be fairly well classified in terms of the structure of the molecule, e.g. non-bonding electrons on particular atoms or electrons of double bond systems. Non-bonding electrons give more nearly “atomic ” Rydberg series, with many numbers observable, and correspondingly accurate ionization potentials have been recorded. Most of the earlier measurements belong t o this class. The great difficulty lying in the way of extending these measurements to more complex molecules and to higher ionization potentials has been the rapidly increasing spectral complexity associated with the prescncc
FIG.4. Vacuum-ultra violet absorption spectrum of oxygen gas. The positions at which Rydberg series convergence limits occur are marked X-X. (We are indebted to Professor W. C. Price for this photograph.)
of many different types of electron and the many possible excitation processes available. Even for such a relatively simple molecule as oxygen the Rydberg series are not a t all obvious in the absorption spectrum (Fig. 4). Aside from the spectral complexity associated with polyelectronic molecules, the presence of many lines in the emission spectra of the Lyman continua used as backgrounds added to the early workers’ difficulties. 3. Mass-spectrometric appearance potentials
The combination of a mass analyzer with the electron impact apparatus enabled the scope of the pioneer work of Hertz, Lenard, Franck, and Lozier to be greatly extended, and results of less ambiguity were obtainahle. Such experiments lead in general to a curve relating the ion current
39
IONIZATION POTENTIALS
produced at each mass number to the potential used to accelerate the electron beam. Where such curves possessed a more or less distinct threshold in the case of the molecular ion, relative ionization potentials could be inferred. These were not in general absolute, though calibration using rare gases narrowed the range of uncertainty. The position of the threshold and the shape of the curve depended on so many instrumental variables that the results tended to lack absolute significance. Subsequently the shape of the curve above the threshold was given theoretical significance to provide an alternative method of calculation ionization potentials-the method of " critical slope ". The greatest advances in this direction have, however, probably been technical ones aimed at removing the instrumentally produced curvature and the uncertainties in and variability of electron energy.
B . Recent Advances in Technique 1. Photoionization cross-sectionmeasurement
It had long been recognized that some regions of strong continuous absorption, which appeared to be so-to-speaksuperimposedupon the more detailed vacuum ultraviolet absorption spectra of some simple molecules, were ascribable to ionization into a molecular ion, in its ground or an excited state, and an electron. I n many cases the long wavelength edge
M+e+MElectron copture M + hv --c M * Photo excitation
*
M+e-+M +e Electron excitation
+
M + hu -+ M+ e Photo ionization
M+e+M++2e Electron ionization M
+ hu -+ M t t + Photo double ionization
M+e+M+++3e Electrori double ionization
2e
M + h w - t Mt++ Photo triple ionization
+ 3e
FIG.5. Ideal formofexcitation cross-section((I) versusenergy ( E )functionsfordifferent fundamental processes.
of this continuum corresponded roughly to the limit of a Rydberg series or to an ionization potential inferred from electron impact measurement, but the presence of strong underlying intra-valence shell transitions prevented the general determination of ionization potentials from total absorption cross section measurements. I n 1953, however, Watanabe suggested a simple way of obtaining just the photoionization crosssection q, a function which theoretically has the form of a step
40
D . W. TURNER
at the ionization limit. This abrupt increase to a limiting value is to be contrasted with the continuous and, a t first, linear increase in ionization cross-section above the ionization potential expected for electron impact. The idealized forms of the variations of cross-section with energy for different types of excitation are shown in Fig. 5. The applicability of a step function to photoionization contributed largely to the success of Watanabe's method for measuring first ionization potentiaIs of awiderange of complex molecules (Watanabe, 1957). In addition, the values attracted greater confidence as to their absolute magnitudes since the energy of the excitation (=hv)was exactly defined by the monochromator setting, no uncertainties about contact potential variations arising. 2. Monoenergetic electron sources
It could be argued that by showing what can be done with one kind of monoenergetic excitation, the main contribution of photon impact I
Retardina
FIG.6. Potential distribution and electron kinetic energy functions in 8 simple ion source using the R.P.D. method (see text) : the effect of a variable retarding potential is shown Schematically.
studies has been to focus attention upon the problem of the precise form of the threshold laws and to stimulate work on monoenergetic electron sources. This problem has been approached in three ways. One method, first suggested by Fox and his associates (1 955), is known as the retarding potential difference (R.P.D.)method. I n this a retarding electrode at - V volts is included within the beam: electrons having energies up to
IONIZATION POTENTIALS
41
this value are repelled, and only the higher energy portions of the quasiMaxwellian distribution are passed on to be accelerated further (Fig. 6). If this electrode potential is slightly changed, the resultant variation in ionization is derived only from the electrons within this small energy range. With this apparatus an effective energy spread as low as 0.06 e.v. half-width has been achieved. An improved version has been described by Cloutier and Schiff (1959). Another method involves the use of an electrostatic or magnetic velocity selector (e.g. Marmet and Kerwin, 1960). The disadvantage of this type of instrument, which uses a narrow slit to select a particular group of electrons whose orbital radius is
Electron energy (eV)
!\'I
Pro. 7. Ionization efficiency curve for oxygen (a)obtained using monoecergetic electrons ( d E = f 0.06 e.v.)from anelectrostaticvelocityselector. The positionsof thresholds due to the ground state and vibrationallyexcitedstates of the 2Z7, ion are indicatedby the arrows (b). (Reproduced with permission from Brion, 1964.)
determined by the field magnitude is the very small output current obtainable. However, an energy spread as low as 0.03 e.v. has been achieved; about fifty times better than without velocity selection. Fox and others have also removed the effect of the uncertain contribution of this ion draw-out field to the electron energy by applying the draw-out and electron-accelerating potentials as alternate pulses (Frost and McDowell, 1955). With such refinements in technique the information which can be derived from electron impact experiments has become more exact and of a more detailed character. In simple molecules, for example, it has been
42
D . W. TURNER
possible to detect changes in slope, many of which relate to higher ionization potentials. I n the simplest it has even been possible to discern the “breaks ” associated with increases in the vibrational quantum number of the product ion. An example of this is seen for oxygen in Fig. 7. 3. Photoionization with mass analysis
Photoionization, as already pointed out, is characterized by a step function for ionization probability versus energy. The change in mode of ionization is thus much more easily detectable than for electron impact which produces only changes of slope. The combination of photon impact ion sources with mass analysis has been a major advance in technique since i t has allowed the direct study of formation and breakdown of excited ions. The first account of such an experiment was given by Hurzeler, Inghram and Morrison (1958) who employed the especially convenient Seya-Namioka type of monochromator, which had then just been described, in conjunction with a conventional magnetic sector mass
X
I
I
X
FIG.8. Vacuum monochromator and mass spectrometer combination. (Reproduced with permission from Hurzeler et al., 1958.) (A) Ultraviolet monochromator; (B) mass analyzer; (C) sections of ion source. The planes of the ultraviolet monochromator and the maw analyzer intersect at right angles along the line XX‘. 1, Discharge lamp; 2, window and entrance slit; 3, bellows for adjusting lamp; 4, micrometers for adjusting entrance slit; 5, light baffles; 6, grating; 7, grating micrometer; 8, pumping lead for monochromator; 9, light shutter; 10, micrometers for adjusting exit slits; 11, ion source pot; 12, gas inlet; 13, entrance slit of maw andyzer; 14, qumpinglead to ion source pot; 15, pumpmg lead to analyzer; 16, micrometers for adjusting exit slits of maw analyzer; 17, electron multiplier; 18, photoelectron suppressors; 19, exit slit of monochromator; 20, ionization chamber; 21, filament for producing ions by electron impact; 22, light monitoring plates; 23, gas inlet; and 24, ion gun.
IONIZATION POTENTIALS
43
spectrometer, (Fig. 8). Later instruments have employed a somewhat simpler combination using a time-of-flight mass spectrometer. It has, however, been common practice to isolate the gas in the light source from the ionization region by placing a LiF window either before or after the monochromator. This has the effect of limiting the photon energy accessible to the range below about 11.6 e.v. so that only the lowest ionic excitation levels have been accessible so far. Dibeler and Reese (1964) have however described a windowlessapparatus in which a large-capacity pumping system allowed the use of even several hundred millimetres pressure of rare gas in the light source. With this apparatus photoionization yield measurements with mass analysis have been extended to 14 e.v. A further draw-back has been that of low sensitivity; it has been estimated that when the full advantages of monochromatioity are realized, with spectral slit widths of ca. 0.001 e.v., only some 108particles enter the mass analyser as compared with perhaps 10l2in an electron impact experiment with velocity selection and up to 1014without velocity selection. N
4. Photoelectron spectroscopy I n November 1962 Professor M. Inghram remarked that much inform-
ation was being missed from impact studies by not studying simultaneously the electrons given off in the ionizing collision. As it happened, at about this time two laboratories had shown independently that the energy spectrum of photoemitted electrons contained a wealth of data and led directly to the higher ionization potentials. Vilesov et al. (1961)in Leningrad used a vacuum monochromator as the source of ionizing radiation separated by a LiF window from an ionization chamber containing a pair of cylindrical grids for electron velocity analysis. They were thus restricted to using photon energies less than 11 e.v. Turner and Al-Joboury (1962) at Imperial College, London, employed a windowless system with a helium resonance lamp as the source of monochromatic radiation (584 A=21.21 e.v.). The much more copious light output obtained with this arrangement made possible the direct recording of electron energy spectra which showed great detail, in particular ion vibrational structure. Furthermore the whole range of ionization potentials to 21-21 e.v. was covered. Both adiabatic and vertical ionization potentials should be derivable from photoelectron energy measurements, the former from the highest electron energy (within a group) and the latter from the energy of the most abundant electrons, i.e. from the peaks in the electron energy spectrum (Fig. 9a, b). (See for example the discussion in Al-Joboury and Turner 1963,1964). However, the present technique, using electron retardation by grids, introduces a
D. W. TURNER
44
characteristic asymmetry into the shapes of the bands in the electron energy spectra (Fig. 9c) so that only the adiabatic ionization potentials are readily derived (from the high electron-energy “edges)’). A large number of higher (as well as first) ionization potentials have now been measured in this way. Those which have also been measured from RydVertical I
M i a batic I
f
504r (b)
(a)
FIQ.9a, b. A portion of a photoelectron spectrum (idealized) showing (a) the identification of adiabatic and vertical ionization potentials with resolved ( 1 ) and unresolved (2) vibrational structures, (b) the identification of a higher adiabatic ionization potential with a “break”.
LJ IJ, 5
0
5
Electron-retarding potential
FIG. 9c. Photoelectron spectra for argon, krypton, and xenon, excited by the helium resonance line (684 A; 21.21 e.v.). Ionization energy increases from left to right within each section (see text).
berg series are in excellent agreement with them, but some significant disagreements with electron impact values have been noted and ascribed inter alia to the occurrence of autoionization in the latter case (v. AlJoboury and Turner, 1964; Al-Joboury et al., 1965). Future developments. It seems probable that a considerable increase in electron energy resolving power can be achieved without great loss in
IONIZATION POTENTIALS
45
sensitivity by using sector spectrometers which would also show advantages in giving “undistorted” spectra (see above). Some progress along these lines has already been made and the spectra obtained-an example is shown in Fig. 10-show promise of giving vertical ionization potentials and in favourable cases Franck-Condon factors directly.
Electron energy ( V )
FIG.10. Photoelectron spectrum of oxygen using the helium resonance line (21.21 e.v.) obtained with a magnetic electron energy analyser (May and Turner, unpublished work). Ionization energy increasing from left to right. The spectrum reveals four levels of ionization and the vibrational structure associated with each state of the ion can be clearly distinguished. This spectrum may be compared with that obtained using an electrostatic retarding field analyser (Al-Joboury et al., 1965).
5 . Ion-Molecule reactions
There is another way in which the large energy required for ionization of one molecule (1) can be supplied; that is by utilizing the recombination energy (R.E.) released upon neutralizing another ion (2). This was demonstrated by Kallmann and Rosen (1930)who showed the condition for charge exchange to occur to be just that R.E.(2) =I.P.(l). It is of course possible with ions of great velocity that during charge exchange the kinetic energy of the incident ion takes part in the process so that I.P.(l)may be somewhat greater than R.E.(2). Lindholm (1954) and his associates have developed this technique extensively and have described means (Fig. 1 1 ) whereby a wide variety of ions having a range of recombination energies can be produced and selected using one mass
46
D. W. T U R N E R
spectrometer, retarded to a low kinetic energy, and the collision products analysed in a second mass spectrometer. Magnef A -Ian
beam A in vertical plane Refording slits
source
Collision chamber---[ CallecforA
--
(Electraomelert
17
--I I
T
I o n beam B i n horizonlol plone
,
b-
Collector 8
4~iir;y
FIG. 11. Double mass spectrometer for investigation of dissociation after chargo exchange. The ions A in mass spectrometer A move in a vertical plane and the ions B move in a horizontal plane. The permanent magnet core is shown only in magnet A.
The results presented in the form of point-by-point plots of the ion abundance against the energy supplied (R.E.) give approximate fragment appearance potentials which can be related in some cases to higher ionization potentials. 6. Abbreviations
The following abbreviations are used to refer to the different methods in the tables of ionization potentials (I.P.):
E.I. P.I. P.S. R.P.D. S.
electron impact photoionization cross-section photoelectron spectroscopy retarding potential difference = spectroscopic
= = = =
111. MOLECULARSTRUCTURE DEPENDENCE
OF
IONIZATION POTENTIALS
A. Introduction By about 1930the orbital structure and ionization potentials for atoms were generally known in detail and had been related, for example, to chemical properties and periodic table regularities. In a series of papers of far-reaching importance, Mulliken (1935b) employed these atomic ionization potentials in construction of molecular orbitals, formulating rules which showed how bonding, non-bonding, and antibonding orbitals could be constructed from atomic orbitals of the appropriate energy and symmetry. I n particular, the idea was introduced that some electrons remained essentially localized in atomic-like orbitals, for example the
IONIZATION POTENTIALS
47
outer electrons of halogen in halogen acids and alkyl halides and the lone pair electrons of nitrogen, oxygen and sulphur in a variety of compounds. Since increasing bonding character waa associated with an increase in ionization potential, it seemed likely that, for compounds containing heteroatoms with lone pair electrons, these electrons occupied the highest energy orbitals, so that the first ionization potentials of such compounds pertained to the removal of one of these localized electrons. For such compounds the effects of structural changes can be expressed in terms of substituent effects, changes in grouping attached to the heteroatom being supposed to produce only a small perturbation in the essentially atomic character of the orbital in question. This is equivalent to saying that the “positive hole” left on ionization is largely confined to the heteroatom, and substituents are effective in part to the extent to which they assist positive charge dispersal, in addition to any effect due to raising or lowering of the non-bonding orbital energy in the unionized molecule.
B. Amines 1. First ionization potentials
The assumption of small perturbation is clearly justified in the case of TABLE 2 Adiabatic First Ionization Potentials of Amines (0.v.) Ammonia Methylamine Dimethylamine Trimethylamine Ethylamine Diethylamine Triethylamine n-Propylamine Di-n-propylamine Tri-n-propylamine i-Propylamine Di-i-propylamine n-Butylamine Di-n-butylamine t-Butylamine Benzylamine
10.15 8.97 8.24 7.82 8.86 8.01 7.50 8.78 7.84
7.23 8.72 7.73 8.71 7.69 8.64
8.70b
P.I. values, Watanabe et al. (1959). 0 P.S. value, Turner et al. unpublished result. The P.I. value usually quoted, 7.66 e.v. is probably much too low and may represent the energy for photodissociation. 0
48
D. W. TURNER
the aliphatic amines where the first ionization potential must relate to the loss of a nitrogen lone-pair electron since the first ionization potentials of the correspondingalkanes are nearly 3 e.v. higher. The amines have been rather fully investigated and an abundant body of data using different methods of investigation is available. The most accurate and selfconsistent values seem to be those measured by photoionization (Table 2). The effects of alkyl substitution are clearly cumulative to some degree, reflecting the degree of branching in the alkyl group close to the nitrogen atom. Kaufman and Koski (1 960) introduced a substituent constant sk to describe the change in ionization energy as each hydrogen atom of ammonia is replaced by alkyl radicals and showed that the values are group-characteristic, i.e. independent of the order of substitution. Some “saturation” was noted, sk changes going from R,NH, say, to R3N being less than for the change from NH, to RNH2. The saturation effects have also been rationalized empirically (Turner, 1962) in terms of inductive TABLE3 Stabilization energies (S) of the ground and ionized states of alkylethylenes referred to ethy1ene.a S(,,,,,)derived from A Y ( ~using ~ ~ the ~ ~observed ) changes in ionization potential (in e.v.) S(,,Ormd)
Propylene But- 1-ene But-2-ene (cis) But-2-ene (trans) 2-Methylpropene (Isobutene) Trimethylethylene Tetramethylethylene a
0.131 0.114 0.185
0.230 0.200 0.268 0.266
AZ
S(i00)
0.78 0.93 1.27 1.27 1.56 1.71 2.20
0.91 1.04 1.45 1.50 1.76 1.76 2.49
Data, from Isartcs et al. (1957).
polarization of the C-C and C-Helectronsof thealkylgroupsin the field of the nitrogen positive charge. Kaufman and Koski also considered that the ionization potentials of such amines reflected the Lewis basicities of the lone pair, free from steric effects which normally complicate discussion of structure-basicity correlations. They further argue, however, that ground stateinductive effects play the major part, largely on the grounds of correlation with Hammett u values. That is to say, alkyl groupings are most effective by raising the N lone-pair orbital energy. However, this seems to underestimate the great importance of polarization processes in the ion. Price has pointed out that, even in the alkylethylenes
49
IONIZATION POTENTIALS
where ground state resonance might be more important, substituent stabilization of the ground state is opposed to and small compared with the observed ionization potential changes (Table 3). The major part of the changes are ascribed to stabilization of the ion, values for which were derived. 2. Higher ionization potentials in amines The large difference in ionization potential between the nitrogen lone pair and the electrons of alkyl groupings has made it comparatively easy TABLE4 Ionization Potentials of Methylamine (e.v.) by Electron Impact and Photoelectron Spectroscopy Electron impact (R.P.D.)@
Photoelectron spectroscopyb
Estimatodc -~
9.45 0.08 12.35f0.10 13.90 0.30 17.70 f 0.70 21.75 f 0.20 23.75 f 0.70? a C
9.18 & 0.02 12.16f0.02 13.94+ 0.10 15.07 f0.10 16.57 0.02 19.89 f0.10
Collin (1961). Mulliken (1935a).
~
.-
11 (N:) 13.5 (C-N) 14.5 (C-H,CHz) 16 (NH2) 22 (CH2) 27 (N) b
Al-Joboury et al. (1964).
TABLE5 Tho second ionization potentials (e.v.)of aliphatic amines compared with first ionization potentials of the isoelectronic hydrocarbons
Primary Methylamine, Ethylamine, i-Propylamine, n-Butylamine, Secondary Dimethylamine, Diethylamine, Tertiary Trimethylamine, Triethylamine, b
Amine I2
Alkane I,
Diff.
cthano propano i-butane n-pentane
12.16 11.86 11.26 10.75
11.49 11.07 10.78 10.35a
0.67 0.79 0.48 0.40
propane n-pentane
12.88 11.08
11.49 10.35'
0.39 0.73
i-butane 3-ethyl-pentanc
1143 10.79
10.78 9.9b
0.85 0.9
From Watanabe et al. (1959). Estimated.
to observe the higher ionization potentials. Using the R.P.D. method (see p. 40) with electron impact, Collin (1961) has detected five higher potentials which compare surprisingly well (since they are vertical 1.P.s)
60
D . W. TURNER
with the adiabatic values measured by photoelectron spectroscopy. The results are compared in Table 4 with Mulliken's estimated values for the various molecular orbitals involved. The higher ionization potentials for the homologues of methylamine might be expected to reflect those of the corresponding isoelectronic hydrocarbons, but with some values increased by virtue of the greater nuclear charge of nitrogen. Some such effect can be seen for the second ionization potentials given in Table 5, measured by photoelectron spectroscopy.
C. Alcohols and Ethers Though there was little doubt in the case of amines that the heteroatom lone-pair electrons were the least firmly bound in the molecule, this assumption cannot generally be made with confidence when nitrogen is TABLE6 The Adiabatic Ionization Potentials of Aliphatic Alcohols (e.v.)
Methanol Ethanol Propan-1-01 Propan-2-01 Butan-1-01 Butan-8-01 2-Methylpropan-2-01 (t-butyl alcohol) Dimethyl ether Methyl ethyl ether Diethyl ether a b
10.85 10.50 10.1 10.1 10.1 10.1 9.7
10.83 10.63
12.33 11.81
14.67 12.80
17.23 15.69
17.38
10.00 9.81 9.63
Watanabe et al. (1959). Al-Joboury and Turner (1964) (see also Fig. 12).
replaced by oxygen, owing to the increase in ionization potentials associated with the larger nuclear charge of oxygen. Thus, there is only about 0-3-0.6 e.v. difference between the first ionization potentials of the aliphatic primary alcohols (Table 6 ) and the isoelectronic hydrocarbons. The second ionization potentials, however, seem to relate to the first ionization potentials of the corresponding hydrocarbons and thus are probably the ones to be associated with the hydrocarbon groupings moved
51
IONIZATION POTENTIALS
to higher values by the inductive effect of the heteroatom as before. The second ionization potentials in the pairs (1) methanol/methylamine, (2) ethanol/ethylamine, (3) diethyl ether/diethylamine are in fact very similar in each case: ( 1 ) 12.33/12.16, (2) 11.81/11.86, (3) 11.08/11-08e.v. The assignment of the first ionization to a non-bonding electron is also supported by the shape of the first (highest electron energy) peak in the photoelectron spectrum of methanol (Fig. 12). Confirmation of the
-
Electron energy (V)
FIG.12. Photoelectron spectrum of methanol vapour using the helium resonance line (21.21 e.v.). Ionization energy increases from left to right. T h e adiabatic ionization potentials measured (Al-Jobouryand Turner, 1964) are indicated by vertical arrows, and can be compared with (probably) vertical I.P. values derived from electron impact appearance potentials by Collin (1961) (dotted arrows).
general correctness of this view has been provided from a different quarter. Von Koch and Lindholm (1961) and Pettersson (1963) have shown that in charge-transfer reactions, the molecular ions of ethanol and propanol are produced by phosphorus ions (Pf) having recombination energies (10.48, 10-81 e.v.) only a little greater than the first ionization potentials of the alcohols, that is no bonding electron is transferred, e.g. +
CHS-CHZ-OH
+P+ -+ CHa-CHa-0-H
+P
(5)
On the other hand Xe+ (R.E. 12.13,13.44 e.v.) gives almost entirely mass 31, i.e. a bonding electron has been transferred: CH3-CHz-OH
+ Xe+
f --+
CH2=O-H
+ CH3 + X e
(6)
D. W. TURNER
52
D. Aldehydes and Ketones The effect of substituent groupings upon the first ionization potential of, at least, the aliphatic aldehydes and ketones does not seem to provide clear evidence for a choice between loss of a rr-electron from the C=O double bond or one of the oxygen lone-pair electrons. Concordant data for the homologous series of aliphatic ketones have been obtained by TABLE 7 The Adiabatic Ionization Potentials of Aldehydes and Ketones (e.v.) p.1.a
Formaldehyde Acetaldehyde Propionaldehyde Acetone Butan-2-one Pentan-2-one Hexan-2 -one Heptan-4-0110 Octan-4-one Nonan-5-0110 Decan-2-one 2,B-Dimethylbutan%One 2,2,4,4-Tetramethylpentme-3-one Cyclopentanone Cyclohexanone Camphor Acrolein But-2-enal Benzaldeh yde Acetophenone
P.S.
P.1.b
10.90 10.87 kO.03 kO.01 10.20 10.21 9.98 9.71 9.69 9.54 9.54 9.47 9.44 9.12 9.10 9.04 9.40
10.87
13.99
15.86
16.6
10.23 9.67
12.75 12.16
13.90 14.15
15.09 15.55
16.26 17.62
9.99
10.82
13.19
14.5G
15.94
19.05 19.88
9.18 8.65 9.42 9.14 8.71 10.10 9.73 9.51 9.77c
(See Table 8) (See Table 8)
P.I. = Photoionization cross section, (a)Vilesov, (1960); (b) Watanabe, (1957) P.S. = Photoelectron spectroscopy. D. W. Turner et al., unpublished work.
Vilesov (1960) and by Watanabe (1957) using photoionization (included in Table 7) which show effects due to alkyl substitution rather similar to those found in simple olefins. This might be taken to indicate loss of a 7r-electron. The changes produced by homologation are indeed appreciably larger than those found for the corresponding alcohols :
I 0 N IZA TI 0N P O T E N TI A L S
53
H H
However, the ready distortion of the n-electron system provides an additional mechanism whereby the charge dispersal can reach the substituents. The greater substituent effects in ketones compared to the alcohols are therefore equally consistent with the loss of an oxygen nonbonding electron. Unsaturated substituents which can conjugate with the carbonyl double bond do not have the expected large effect in reducing
I
I
t
I
I
\
,
,
,
.
,
,
,
,
,
Electron energy (V)
FIG.13. Photoelectronspectra of formaldehyde (a)and acrolein (b) vapours using the helium resonance line. Ionizationenergyincreasesfromleft to right. (D. P. May and D. W. Turner, unpublished work.)
the ionization potential, and acrolein (I.P. 10.10) even has a higher value than propionaldehyde (I.P. 9.98). Thus direct conjugation with the ionic centre is absent and in this case the electron-withdrawing inductive effect of the vinyl grouping is dominant. The photoelectron spectra of formaldehyde (Fig. 13) and acrolein show
D . W. T U R N E R
54
'85
I-
I800
16001
I
80
90
I
10 0
IP
II 0
1
12 0
eV
FIQ.14. Variation of VC=O with I.P.:0 ,class A; 0 , class B compounds I.P. Compound vc=o vc=o (in cc14) (gm) 1 COClz 1828 1813 11.57' 2 CHCla CO c1 1810 11-00= 3 CHs. CO. Cl 1822 1808 4 ace.OCHs 1795 1786 5 CHa CO OCaH5 1793 1780 6 CCla CO OCsH5 1787 1770 7 CHs. CO. OH 1785 10.35" 1768 8 CzHa .CO OH 1787 10.27' 1758 n-CsH7. CO O H 9 10.02' 1761 10 1777 (CHa0)zCO 1754 11 HCO .OCHs 1757 1734 12 CHa CO OCHs 1774 1751 10.31d 13 (CzH60)zCO 1767 1744 14 (i-C4Hg0)~C0 1744 15 1765 CHa CO OCaH5 10.10' 1740 16 n-CsH7CO.O-n-CsHg 1752 1735 17 C H a CHO 1752 10.21' 1733 18 CaHs. CHO 1757 9.86b 1738 19 n-C&. CHO 1745 9.81' 1729 20 i-C&. CHO 1742 9.72' 1729 21 CHa CO CHs 1742 1717 9.69" 22 CH3. CO CsH5 1742 9.54' 1722 23 CHs CO n-CsH7 1737 1717 9.39' 24 CHa CO n-C4H9 1734 9.38' 1718 25 Cyclohexanone 1742 1716 26 HCO N H z 1740 10*84* 1722 27 CHs :CH.CO. OH 10.70' 1721
. .
. .
. .
.
.
. .
. . .
. . .
. . . .
.
[continued onfacing page
55
IONIZATION POTENTIALS
that the first ionization is of a nearly non-bonding electron and that, at least in these instances, the oxygen lone pairs are the least tightly bound electrons. On the assumption that all the reported aldehyde first ionization potentials refer to the oxygen lone-pair electrons Cook (1958) has classified the effect of substituents into two classes, A and B, according to whether inductive or resonance effects predominate. Two different linear correlations (Fig. 14) were found between ionization potential and the carbonyl stretching frequency. Anomalies were noted for diacetyl, benzaldehyde and mesityl oxide, ascribed in the last instance to noncoplanarity interfering with resonance. It seems more likely, however, that in these cases the first ionization potential refers to 7r-electrons and higher values for the lone-pair electrons (as yet undetermined) might remove the anomalies.
E . Aromatic Compounds To some degree of approximation aromatic hydrocarbons can be considered to behave as electrically conducting bodies having a definable electrostatic capacity C, by virtue of the fact that the highest occupied orbitals extend over the whole molecule. The removal of an electron then charges this capacity and the work done is inversely proportional to C so that ionization potentials (Table 8) should fall rapidly and asymptotically to that of graphite as the molecular size increases. This approach has been developed quantitatively by Smith (1961). The calculated values however prove to be rather low but account in a general way for the low ionization potentials of, for example, circumanthracene CS2Hz2 (5.5 e.v.) and quaterrylene C,oHzo (4.9 e.v.) which approach that of 28
CH3.CO.CO.CH3
29 30
CH3. CO .NH2 CeH6.CHO
31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 0
;;:I} 1717
9.25"
1714 1710
10.16d 9.51"
1704
10.10"
1700 1697 1696 1692 1689 1684 1668 1662 1649 1647
10.Ola 9.05" 9.73" 9.576 9.71b 9.1 I"*= 9.00' 8.80"
1725 1733 CH2:CH.CHO 1714} CH3.CO.NH.CH3 1718 (CH3)2C:CH.C0.CH3 1715 CH3.CH:CH.CHO 1715 CH3. CO .C B H ~ 1707 CH2: C H . CO. CH3 HCO.N(CH3)z CsH5. CO .CeHs C H B . C O . N ( C H ~ ) ~ 1689 CH3.CO.N(C2Htj)2 1678 CHs.CO.N(n-C4Hg)z
Watanahe (1967). b Morrison and Nicholson (1962). c W. C. Staele, quoted by d Higasi e l 02. (1966). e K. U. Ingold, quoted by Cook, (1968).
Cook (1968).
56
D . W. TURNER
graphite (4.40 e.v.). These last measurements were made by an interesting method based on Millikan's oil drop experiments (cf. Pope, 1962), the photoionization threshold for particles of the solids being detected from their motion in an electrostatic field. Though these values are not true molecular parameters they probably indicate the right order. 1. Benzene derivatives
There is no doubt that even in benzene itself the first ionization potential refers to the removal of a 7~ electron from the highest of the rr levels (7r2 7r3, el,) (doubly degenerate, Fig. 15). This has been amply
Orbital energy
FIQ.16. Occupied r orbital energy levels of benzene.
demonstrated spectroscopically (El-Sayed and Kasha, 1961). Also, the highest-energy band in the photoelectron energy spectrum of benzene vapour appears to be rather weakly bonding, as expected of rr electrons when compared with u electrons (Al-Joboury and Turner, 1964). It is less certain, however, whether the deeper rr level, 7r (alu)lies above or below the highest ulevel. The ionization potential found from the second Rydberg series is 11.489 e.v. and almost certainly relates to the deepest rr level (alu).Photoelectron spectroscopy shows no intermediate values but it is clear that there are other ionization potentials, presumably therefore u-electron ionization potentials, near 11 -5 e.v. The effect of substituents on the first ionization potential can be mainly inductive in character. Strongly electron withdrawing groups, such as -CHO, -NO2 or -CP3, which are meta directing lower the energy of, inter alia, the highest rr level (7r3, el,) causing an increase in ionization potential (Table 8). On the other hand, substituents having unshared electron pairs which can conjugate with the benzene ring can stabilize the positive ion by mesomeric charge transfer into the ring to cover up the
57
IONIZATION POTENTIALS
TABLE8 The Ionization Potentials of Benzene Derivatives (e.v.) Method
Benzene T,,, Benzene x , (upper) (lower)
{t.S.
Benzene Monosubstituted
{%If
-CN
{
-CF3
t.S.
P.I.
{::; * :{: ; {.::: {.;:
-CHO 4 0 . CH3
-c1 -Br -CHzOCH3
P.I.
-C=CH -CH3 -CHz. CH3 -1 -CHz. CHz .CHI -C4& (n,i -C4H9 (s,t)
{.:: {.::; P.I. P.I. P.I. P.I. P.I.
9.248 9.25 9.95 9.70 9-65, 10 9.683 697 9.68 9.51 9.46 9.27 9.24 9.07 8.99, 9.60 8.98 8.96, 9.59 8.85 8.82 8.77, 9.37 8.82 8.84, (9.15)a
11.489 11.49
11.76 11.92
11.48 11.63 11.88 11.8
11.17
8.77 8.73 8.72 8.69 8.68
z.
-CH=CHz -0Me
-CHz .NHz
(0)
-CH3, -CH3 (m)
3
10.68, 11-18
11.21
8.50
-CH3,-CH3
16.84 16.73
8.46, 9.34 11.30 {.;:; 8.35 11.29 10.29 (?C=C) {2.8.42, 9.18 8.20 8.20, 9.10 10.81 { 7.66 (See note t o Table 2) {p.': 8.70 11.19 7.71, 8.95 10.49 11.42 (?N) {s'.;p
-OH
-NH2 Disubstituted -CH3, -CHI
Other
(p)
P.I. P.S. P.I. P.S. P.I. P.S.
8.52 8.66, (9.01) 8.66 8.55, (9.0) 8.45 8.44, (9.4)
10.89 10.90 10.89
D. W . T U R N E R
58
TABLE S-Continued Method -CH3, -C1, ( p ) -CH3, -Br, ( 0 ) -CH3, -Br, ( p ) 5
Benzene x,, (upper)
P.I. P.I. P.I.
,
Benzene x , (lower)
Other
8.69 8.78 8.67
Values in parentheses tentative.
“positive hole”. Thus -OH and -NH2 groups lower the first ionization potential of benzene by 0.75 and 1.75 e.v. respectively. This is in contrast to the effect of oxygen and nitrogen upon alkyl group ionization potentials (see above) in which the inductive effect dominates, formal conjugation being absent. These effects of electron withdrawal from and release to the ring also find quantitative expression in the a+ substituent constants (Brown and Okamoto, 1957))and linear correlations between o+ values and ionization potentials have been reported (Crableand Kearns, 1962). More recently, the very strongly electrophilic reagent CF; has been shown to attack the benzene ring at a rate, k2, determined by an activation energy linearly related to the ionization potential of the benzene electrons in
1.2 1.11.0-
0.9 &?g
-g
0.8070.6 -
0.50.4 -
0‘3
0.2
8-6
9.0
9.4
9.8
10.2
lonizotion potentiol (eV)
FIG. 16. Ionization potential u8. log k4k1 of substituted benzenes: 1, CeHs-CN; 2, CeH5-NOz; 3, CeH5-COCH3; 4, CeH5-CI; 6, CeHs-Br; 6, C E H ~ - C ( C H ~ ) ~ ; 7, CeH5-H; 8, CeH5-I; 9, CeH5-CzHs; 10, CeH5--CH(CH3)2; 11, CeH5-CH3; 12, C&.-OH; 13, C&-OCH3. (Reproduced from Whitternore et al., 1962, with permission.)
IONIZATION POTENTIALS
59
substituted benzene derivatives. Thus a graph of log k2/kl against I.P. is linear (Fig. 16; kl is rate of attack on solvent). I n this reaction the transition state must involve almost complete one-electron transfer, analogous to gaseous ionization. A roughly equivalent viewpoint is to consider the charge dispersal in the positive ion by conjugating substituents to result from the delocalization in the molecule which conjugation produces. I n other words, the positive hole has the same distribution as i,h2, the electron density associated with the orbital that is losing the electron. The effect of a conjugating substituent (Fig. 17) is then to raise the energy levels of two of the three n orbitals (nl,n 2 )of the ring to an extent dependent upon its electronegativity. At the same time the substituent level is depressed. The thirdn orbital ( n s )originally , degenerate with n2,is largely unaffected since this has a node at the ring carbon atom bearing the substituent and, in the f i s t order, does not interact with it.
____-(x:
1
I
FIG.17. Perturbation (in a first approximation) of occupied m orbitals of benzene by a conjugating substituent X.
We would therefore expect to find in monosubstituted benzenes a second ionization potential, corresponding to the unperturbed orbital, at a value not very different from that of benzene ( 9.2 e.v.), as well as the higher value, corresponding to the lowest n-level ( n l ) ,and differing from the benzene nl-value by an amount similar to the first ionization potential difference. This has in fact been found in those compounds which have so far been studied by photoelectron spectroscopy (see Table 8). The simple monoalkylbenzenes and styrene have second ionization potentials in the range 9.0-9.1 e.v. Phenylacetylene has a second N
60
D . W. T U R N E R
ionization potential at 9.36 e.v. which probably reflects the marked electronegativity of the acetylenic grouping. The moving apart of the upper n levels n2 and n3 on perturbation should, for disubstituted benzenes, increase in the order o < m < p , and the separation of the first two ionization potentials of the xylenes is ordered in this way (AI, ortho = 0.50, meta = 0.55, para = 0-62e.v.). Somewhat larger intervals are found for the halogenated benzenes but the order remains the same. 2. Heterocyclic aromatic compounds a. Pyridine and other azabenzenes. The azabenzenes, compounds in
groups replace -CH= groups, often bear remarkable which -N= chemical spectroscopic similarities to the parent homocyclic hydrocarbons. This is associated with their being rr-isoelectronic with them. T ~ L9 E Ionization Potentials of HeterocyclicAromatic Compounds (e.v.) Pyridine 4-Picoline Pyridazine Pyrimidine Pyrazine
P.I. P.S. P.I. P.S. P.S. E.I.
(6.
P.I. E.I. P.S. E.I. E.I.
10.0 9.29 9.27 8.20 8.22 9.06 8.89 9.04 8.77 8-31 8.01
E.I. P.I. P.I.
9.31 8.91 8.68
P.S.
Pyrrole
Furan 2-Methylfuran 2,3-Dimethylfuran Furfwal Thiophene 2-Chlorothiophene
9.23 9.28 9.01 8.91 9.47
{E:.
10.54
12.22
13.43(?)
10.55 10-39
11.13 11.11
13.59 13.60
15.69 15.48
16.73 16.59
10.11
11.15
11.68
13.10
14.78
9.03
12.38
14.23
17.08
10.21
12.62
Pyridine has practically the same ionization potential as benzene ; it does not, however, necessarily follow that the first ionization potentials (Table 9) relate to an electron of the highest occupied n-orbital. These compounds are bases, though weaker than aliphatic amines, and parallels have been noted between base strength and ease of ionization (Nakajima and Pullman, 1968; Krishna and Chowdhury, 1963), which might indicate that the first ionization potential is that of a lone-pair
IONIZATION POTENTIALS
61
electron. Certainly the similar wavelengths for the n-m* (2700 d) and T+T* (2510 d)transitions in pyridine suggest that the nitrogen doublet and the highest rr orbitals are very similar in energy (Mason, 1959). The evidence from substituent effects is somewhat conflicting but the most systematic examination favours the ionization of a rr electron (Basila and Clancy, 1963). This is based upon a comparison between the effects of particular substituents on the electron impact ionization
1.P pyridines
FIG.18. Linear relationships between the ionization potentials of 4-substituted pyridines and the corresponding substituted benzenes (upper line -0-) and toluenes (lower line -X-). After Basila and Clancy (1963), electron impact data.
potentials of benzene, toluene and pyridine, the effect in either the benzene or toluene series being linearly related to that in the pyridine series (Fig. 18). It can be concludedthat the nitrogen atom produces a constant perturbation at least for substituents in the 4-position. Other experimental evidence leads to essentially the same conclusion regarding the rr ionization of pyridine. El Sayed and Kasha (1961) have detected Rydberg series in the absorption spectrum similar to those in benzene and ascribable to rr orbitals (9.266 e.v., a,; 11.56 e.v., b,) and, in addition, reported a fragmentary series leading to a third ionization potential of 10.3 e.v. which they ascribed to the nitrogen lone pair. Similar values are found by photoelectron spectroscopy which also indicated the 10.3 e.v. (10-54 e.v.) level to be only weakly bonding, N
D. W. TURNER
62
consistent with its assignment to a lone pair. The charge-transfer bands between azines and iodine appear to involve unshared-pair electrons of nitrogen and do not show a correlation with the first ionization potentials in the cases of pyrazine and pyrimidine (Krishna and Chowdhury, 1963).
It seems possible, however, that in the polyazines the order could be reversed, with n-electrons higher than rr-electrons, since the effect of heteroatoms in increasing the rr orbital ionization is likely to be cumulative. b. Pyrrole. I n this compound the nitrogen unshared pair of electrons is incorporated into the aromatic sextet. The effect upon degeneracy of the rr2, rr3 orbital is thus greater than in pyridine, giving a separation of
t
F
15
FIG.19. Comparison of the two lowest adiabatic ionization potentials in benzene with the three lowest in pyrrole and furan. The values arranged as an energy level diagram were obtained by photoelectron spectroscopy. (T. N. Radwan and D. W. Turner, unpublished work.)
-
0.8 e.v., so that all three occupied rr levels can be separately observed by photoelectron spectroscopy. I n furan one of the lone pairs is part of the aromatic sextet, the other is not. The greater electronegativity of oxygen leads to a larger rr2-7r3 level separation than in pyrrole (1.14 e.v.). The remaining non-bonding lone-pair orbital must be predominantly s in character and these electrons are much more tightly bound than in ordinary ethers. Figure 19 summarizes the orbital energy levels obtained
IONIZATION POTENTIALS
63
by photoelectron spectroscopy for the series of compounds from benzene to furan in which the effects of increasing electronegativity upon the TI levels is shown.
F. Alkenes, Radicals and Alkanes In the simple Hiickel molecular orbital theory of velectronic systems, molecular orbitals are derived by combinations of 2p orbitals, one from each bonded atom. All of the exchange integrals for bonded atoms are taken as equal and interactions between non-adjacent atoms are ignored. The energy Eiof each molecular orbital then has the form,
Ei = a + m i / l the coefficients mi being positive for bonding orbitals and negative for antibonding orbitals and taking the same number of values as there are contributing 2p atomic orbitals. This results in the series of orbital energy diagrams shown in Fig. 20. When the appropriate numbers of electrons
ff -2p
N -13
a u +j3 cc+2/3 a
b
a
b
FIG.20. 2psr molecular orbital energies in the Huckel approximation for simple radicals (a) and olefins (b).
are fed into these systems to maintain electrical neutrality we obtain, alternately, radicals (Fig. 20a) and olefins (Fig. 20b). The first ionization potential in each case should equal - a for the radicals and for the olefins a value greater than - a and decreasing towards - a as the number of double bonds increases. Whilst this accounts in a qualitative way for the fall in ionization potentials in a series of olefins (Table lo), the variation is larger than predicted and the radical ionization potentials (Table 11) vary over a range of more than 2 e.v. Part of these discrepanciesis obviously due to the use of constant a and equal /3 values. However, a major defect in the simple treatment is
64
D. W . T U R N E R
TABLE10 The Ionization Potentials of Alkenes (e.v.)
Mono-ole$ns Ethylene Propylene But-1-ene cis-But-2-ene trans-But-2-ene Z-Methylpropene (Isobutene) Pent-1-ene cis-Pent-2-ene trans-Pent-2-ene 2-Methylbut-1-me 3-Methylbut-1-me 2-Methylbut-2-ene Hex-1-ene trana-Hex-Z-ene trans-Hex-3-ene 2,3-Dimethylbut-2-ene 2-Ethylbut-1-ene Hept-1-ene Oct-1-ene Oct-2-ene Dec-1-ene
Method P.I. P.I. P.I. P.I. P.I. P.I.
10.516 9.73 9.58 9.24 9.13 8.95
P.I. E.I. E.I. P.I. P.I. P.I., s. P.I. E.I. E.I. P.I., s. E.I. E.I. E.I. E.I. E.I.
9.50 9.11 9.06 9.12 9.51 8.80 9.46 9.16 9.12 8.30 9.21 9.54 9.52 9.11 9.51
Allene 1,Z-Butadiene 1,2-Pentadiene 2,3-Pentadiene cis-1,3-Butadiene trans- 1,3-Butadiene 1,3-Pentadiene 1,4-Pentadiene Z-Methy1-1,3-butadiene 2,3-Dimethyl-butadiene 1,B-Hexadiene
P.I., s. E.I. E.I. E.I. S. S. E.I. E.I. P.I., s. P.I., s. E.I.
10.19 9.57 9.42 9.26 8.75 9.02 8.65 9.58 8.86 8.72 9.51
1,3,5-Hexatriene
S.
8.26
Tetruenes 1,3,5,7-0ctatetraene
S.
7.8
Cyclo-olefins Cyclopropene Cyclopentene Cyclohexene Cyclopentadiene Cyclohexadiene
E.I. P.I. P.I. S. S.
9.95 9.01 8.95 8.58 8.40 8.6 8.04
Dienes
Triener,
Cyclo-octatetraene
65
IONIZATION POTENTIALS
TABLE11 The Ionization Potentials of Some Radicals (e.v.) Aliphatic Methyl Ethyl 1-Propyl 2-Propyl n-Butyl i-Butyl S-Butyl t-Butyl
Fluoromethyl Difluoromethyl Trifluoromethyl Chloromethyl Dichloromethyl Trichloromethyl Bromomethyl Dibromomethyl Methylene Difluoromethylene Dichloromethylene Dibromomethylene Vinyl Ally1 Propargyl Formyl Acetyl Aromatic Phenyl Pentafluorophenyl Benzyl m-Cyanobenzyl m-Nitro p-cyan0 m-Fluoro p-Chloro p-Fluoro p-i-propyl p -Methoxyl 0-Xylyl m-Xylyl P-XYlYl Benzoyl
Method P.I., s. P.I. P.I., E.I. P.I. E.I. E.I. E.I. E.I. P.I. E.I. E.I. E.I. E.I. E.I. E.I. E.I. E.I. E.I. E.I. E.I. E.I. E.I. E.I. E.I. E.I. E.I.
9.84 8.78 7.80 7.77 8.11 8.35 7.93 7.4 7.19 9.35 9.45 10.15 9.32 9.30 8.78 9.30 8.13 11.9 13.30 13.10 10.11 9.4 8.16 8.25 9.88 8.08
E.I. E.I. E.I. E.I. E.I. E.I. E.I. E.I. E.I. E.I. E.I. E.I. E.I. E.I. E.I.
9.90 10.6 7.76 8.68 8.56 8.36 8.18 7.95 7.78 7.42 6.82 7.61 7-65 7-46 7.91
undoubtedly due to the neglect of electron repulsion effects which are different in molecule and ion. One way in which these can be allowed for is to choose empirical values of CL and /?to absorb the differences in electron repulsion. If the charge distribution in the ion (q, a t the rth atom) is 3*
66
D. W . T U R N E R
known from the distribution of the simple Huckel orbital or can be guessed at, individually modified o! values can then be used for each constituent atom to calculate an improved charge distribution, a process which can be reiterated using the new derived a values. This procedure, introduced by Wheland and Mann (1949), has been modified by Streitwieser (1961) who d e h e d the o! values in terms of a disposable parameter w (the so-called w technique) so that cr, = .o+w(1-!?r)ls
(7)
The best value of w is then found so that in a range of systems the best fit with ionization potential data is obtained. I n spite of its apparent simplicity this approach has been shown capable of removing the big discrepancies between simple Huckel M.O. values and experimental results. The improvement in results for simple n-systems is indicated in Fig. 21.
1.P calculated (eV)
FIG.21. Improvement in agreement between calculated and observed ionization potentials for simple T systems aa between values derived on the simple H.M.O. basis (left-handend of arrows) and those derived using the w technique (right-handend of arrows). See text. 1, Methyl; 2, Allyl; 3, Pentadienyl; 4, Benzyl; 6, Ethylene; 6, Butadiene; 7, Benzene; 8, Styrene; 9, Naphthalene; 10, Phenanthrene.
TABLE12 The Ionization Potentiah of Alkanes (e.v.)
Open chain Methane
Ethane Propane n-Butane i-Butane n-Pentene i-Pentane neo-Pentane n-Hexane i-Hexane 3-Methylpentane 2,3-Dimethylb~tane 2,Z-Dimethylb~tane n-Heptane Cycloalknee Cyclopropane
Methylcyclopmpane Cyclobutane Cyclopentane Cyclohexane Methylcyclohexane
5. P.I., P.S. P.I. P.S. P.I. P.S. P.I. P.S. P.I. P.S. P.I. P.I. P.I. P.I.
P.I. P.I. P.I. P.I. P.I.
{.;:;
{E. P.I. P.I. P.I. P.S. P.I.
12.95 12.99 11.65 11.49 11.08 11.07 10.65 10.50 10.55 10.78 10.33 10.30 10.37 10.17 10.09 10-06 10.00 10.04 10.06 10.06 9.96 9.88 9.52 10.50 10-51 9-88 9.79 9-86
14.74
20*13(?)
13.17
15.17
19*18(?)
12.36
14.13
15-70,
18.57(?)
12.54
14.51
15.69(9 )
19.96(?)
11.05
12-27
15-17
16-52(?)
18*8(?)
10.50
11.86
13-2(?)
15.00
16-25
11-33(?)
12.22
14.37
19.43
20.26(?)
18.1(?)
68
D. W. TURNER
This semiempirical approach has been extended to cover the effects of methyl substitution by either regarding the methyl group as contributing a pair of “pseudo T ” electrons (i.e. like a vinyl group with modified Q and values) or by considering its effect on the electronegativity (a)of the carbon atom to which it is attached (Streitwieser, 1962). These alternatives correspond to a hyperconjugative and an inductive model respectively. The two have also been combined with some success. An alternative similar to the first above is the heteroatom model envisaged by Matsen (1950) and Stevenson in which the whole methyl group is treated as a single atom X which contributes a pair of electrons to the 7r-system. The agreement with experiment is again, on the whole, quite good, with an average deviation of 0.1 1 e.v. for a range of olefins, radicals and aromatic hydrocarbons. The heteroatom model has also had considerable success in accounting for the decrease of ionization potential with increasing size in saturated hydrocarbons where there are no formal rr-electrons (Table 12). Methane has two orbital energy levels, the highest, correspondingto the I.P. 12.99 e.v., made from carbon 2p and hydrogen Is orbitals, is triply degenerate and has high p (antisymmetric) character whilst the deepest (I.P.> 21 e.v. ; carbon 2s +hydrogen Is) is largely s in character (Fig. 22). If a
2 s ( C ) +ls(H‘) +ls(H2)+Is(H3)+ls(H‘)
FIG.22. Molecular orbital energy levels for methane.
saturated hydrocarbon is built up from such units some of the highest orbitals, those not involved in C - C bonding (symmetric with respect to the carbon skeleton), will therefore be antisymmetrical with respect to the carbon skeleton and resemble in symmetry the carbon 2p orbitals used in the Hiickel M.O. approximation. Each will however contribute two electrons instead of one to the “pseudo T ” system. All the “T” orbitals will therefore be filled and the change in first ionization
IONIZATION POTENTIALS
69
potential can be related to /3, the best fit being obtained with /3 = 1.6 e.v. There should, on the simple H.M.O. basis, be a symmetrical development of the orbital energy levels as the chain length increases, and it is of interest that, at least in simple hydrocarbons (up to butane), this is reflected in the higher ionization potentials observed (Fig. 23). Ethane
20 -
I
Methane Ethane Propane Butane
FIG.23. Adiabatic ionization potentials for methane, ethane, propane, and butane arranged as an energy level diagram.
shows only two prominent values lower than 20 e.v. which differ by just the expected amount 3.25 e.v. ( = 2/3) whilst propane shows the expected three values, the middle one, 13-17 e.v., being close to that of methane, 12.99 e.v. It may be, therefore, that the first ionization potentials of saturated hydrocarbons relate to electrons in essentially C-H bonding orbitals rather than C-C orbitals, as is often assumed. REFERENCES Al-Joboury, M. I., and Turner, D. W. (1963). J . Chem. SOC. 5141. Al-Joboury, M. I., and Turner, D. W. (1964). J . Chem. SOC.4434. Al-Joboury, M. I., May, D. P., and Turner, D. W. (1965). J . Chem. SOC. 616. Basila, M. R., and Clancy, D. J. (1963). J . Phys. Chem. 67,1551. Brion, C. E. (1964). J . Chem. Phye. 40, 2995. Brown, H. C., and Okamoto, Y . (1957). J . A m . Chem. SOC.79,1913. Clementi, E.(1962). J . Chem. Phys. 36,750. Cloutier, G.G., and Schiff, H. I. (1959). J . Chem. Phys. 31, 793.
70
D. W. TURNER
Collin, J. E. (1961). IX Colloq. Spectr., Lyon, p. 596. Compton, K. T. (1916). Phye. Rev. 8,412. Cook, D. (1958). J. Am. Chem. SOC. 80,49. Crable, G. F., and Kearna, G. L. (1962). J. Phye. Chem. 66,436. Dibeler, V. H., and Reese, R. M. (1964). J. Chem. Phye. 40, 2034. El-Sayed, M. F. A., and Kasha, M. (1961). J. Chem. Phye. 34,334. Ehrenson, S. (1962). J. Phye. Chem. 66,706. Fox, R. E., Hickam, W. M., Grove, D. J., and Kjeldaas, J. (1955). Rev. Sci.Imtr. 26, 1101. Franck, J., and Hertz, G. (1913). Ber. phyaik. am. 34 (the early work is summarized in Franck, J. and Jordan, P., “Anregung von Quantenspriingen durch Stosse”, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1926.) Frost, D. C., and McDowell, C. A. (1955). Proc. Roy. SOC. A232, 227. Higasi, K., Omura, I., and Baba, H. (1956). Nature 178, 652. Hoyland, J. R., and Goodman, L. (1960). J. Chem. Phy8. 33, 946. Hurzeler, H., Inghram, M. G., and Morrison, J. D. (1958). J. Chem. Phy8. 28, 76. Isaacs, L. D., Price, W. C., and Ridley, R. G. (1967). “Threshold of Space”, ed. M. Zelikoff,Pergamon Press, Oxford. Kallmann, H., and Rosen, B. (1930). 8.Elektrochem. 36, 748. Kaufman, J. J., and Koski, W. S. (1960). J. Am. Chem. SOC. 82,32,3262. von Koch, H., and Lindholm, E. (1961). Arkiv Fyaik 19, 123. Krishna, V. G., and Chowdhury, M. (1963). J. Chem. Phy8. 67, 1067. Kuppermann, A., and Ruff, L. M. (1962). J. Chem.Phye.37,2497 (seealso Simpson, J. A., andMielczarek, S. K. ibid. 39,1606; andLassettre, E. N., andFrancis, S. A. ibid. 40, 1208). Lindholm, E. (1954). 8.Naturforsch. 9a, 535 and later papers. Marmet, P., and Kerwin, L. (1960). Can. J. Phy8.38, 787. Mason, S. F. (1959). J. Chem. SOC.1240. Matsen, F. A. (1950). J. Am. Chem. SOC.72, 5243. Morrison, J. D., and Nicholson, A. J. (1952). J. Chenz. Phy8. 20, 1021. Mulliken, R. S. (1935a). J. Chem. Phy8.3, 506. Mulliken, R. S. (1935b). J. Chem. Phy8.3,664. Nakajima, T., and Pullman, B. (1968). Bull. BOG. chim. France 1502 (see also Compt. rend. 246, 1047). Pettersson, E. (1963). Arkiv. Fyaik 25, 181. Pope, M. (1962). J. Chem. Phy8.37, 1001; 36, 2810. Shull, H., and Hall, G. G. (1959). Nature 184, 1539. Smith, F. T. (1961). J. Chem. Phy8.34, 793. Streitwieser, A., Jr. (1961). “Molecular Orbital Theory for Organic Chemists”, Chap. 7, Wiley, New York. See also J. Amer. Chem. SOC.82, 4123 (1960). Streitwieser, A., Jr. (1962). J.Phye. Chem. 66, 368. Streitwieser, A., Jr. (1963). “Progress in Physical Organic Chemistry”, Vol. 1, Interscience, New York, Chap. 1. Turner, D. W. (1962). “Determination of Organic Structures by Physical Methods”, Vol. 2, eds. Nachod, F. C. and Phillips, W. D., Academic Press, New York, pp. 353 ff. Turner, D. W., and Al-Joboury, M. I. (1962). J. Chem. Phy8.37,3007. Vilesov, F. I. (1960). Doklady Akad. Nauk.S.S.S.R. 132, 1332. Vileeov, F. I., Kurbatov, B. L., and Terenin, A. N. (1961). Doklady A M . Nauk. S.S.S.R. 138, 1329.
IONIZATION POTENTIALS
71
Watanabe, K. (1957). J. Chem. Phys. 26, 642. Watanabe, K.,Marmo, F., and Inn, C. Y. (1956). Pby.9. Rev. 91,1155. Watanabe, K.,Nakayama, T., and Mottl, J. (1959). Final Report on Ionization Potentials of Molecules by a Photoionization Method, Dept. Army No. 5B-99-01004, ORD TB2-0001-00R-1624. Wheland, G . W., and Mann, D. E. (1949), J . Chem. Phya. 17,264. Whittemore, I. M., Stefani, A. P., and Szwarc, M. (1962). J. Am. Chem. SOC.84, 3799.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
REACTIVITY INDICES IN CONJUGATED MOLECULES: THE PRESENT POSITION H. H. GREENWOOD and R. McWEENY Quantum Theory Group, University of Keele, Staffordshire, England
.
I. Introduction A. Reactivity Indices . B. HuckelTheory C. Nature of the Methods D. Derivatives and Heterocyclics . 11. Some Applications of the Indices . . A. Heterolytic Reactions B. Homolytic Reactions . 111. Properties of the Secular Equations A. Partial Derivatives and Polarizability Coefficients . B. Energy Level Diagrams and Parameter Variations . IV. The Isolated Molecule Method A. Analytical Properties of Approximate Methods . B. Analytical Properties of Exact Methods . V. The Localization Method A. Analytical Properties of Approximate Methods . B. Analytical Properties of Exact Methods . VI. Relationship between the Indices VII. Frontier Orbital and Charge Transfer Theories VIII. The Physical Basis of Reactivity Indices . A. Polarization and Electrophilic Substitution . B. The Structure of a-Complex Intermediates . C. Some Related Topics IX. Reactivity Indices in Many-Electron Theory . A. Perturbation Methods in SCF Theory . B. P , and r,,,as Reactivity Indices . . C. Effect of Heteroatoms . D. Alternant Hydrocarbons. Finite Changes . X. Conclusions and Future Prospects . References
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. .
73 73 76 78 80 81 82 87 88 89 90
95 97 99 102 105 106 107 112 118 119 122 125 129 130 135 138 140 141 143
I. INTRODUCTION A. Reactivity Indices MOLECULARorbital theories of the substitution reactions of conjugated molecules have been presented and reviewed on many occasions. I n general, the validity of a theory has been judged according to its performance in predicting, by reference to the numerical values of certain
74
H . H . GREENWOOD A N D R . MCWEENY
indices, the observed reactivities of different positions in the molecule. A detailed and critical study of the theoretical basis of the various indices, of their anaIytical properties and interrelationships, and, more especially, of their connection with physical situations likely to arise during a reaction, is much more difficult to find. The aim of the presentreviewis to remedy this omission by trying to rationalize the somewhat confused state of the subject and by seeking a better understanding of the principles involved in setting up reactivity indices. For this reason, a complete documentation of the literature will not be attempted and references will be confined largely to a relatively small number of key papers ; references to many varied applications of the indices, covering a vast field, may be found in other recent review articles. For the same reason, only a limited amount of strictly new material will be presented, this relating mainly to the introduction of more elaborate quantum mechanical techniques and to prospects for the future. Since the discussion will be confined entirely to the properties and significance of reactivity indices, details of the reaction process itself and its description in terms of rate equations will not be considered. This means that certain assumptions are implicit throughout, and these must be mentioned at the outset. Briefly, a reaction rate is determined by an activation energy AE, defined by reference to the variation of energy as reagent and molecule approach along some assumed reactionpath (Fig. 1). Often the configuration corresponding to the peak is assumed to be essentially that of a certain transition complex, which has only a transient existence before breaking down to give the reaction products : AE may then be calculated, in principle, by reference to this hypothetical complex. More accurately, under conditions of constant temperature and pressure, the reaction rate is determined by the free energy of activation
A @ = AH-TAS where AH and AS are enthalpies and entropies of activation. For a limited temperature range
AH
=
AU-RT
where A U is the activation energy, A U =NAE, and the Arrhenius rate equation is then k = Ae-AUIRT = Ae-AEtkT with
It is generally assumed that the entropy change AS is substantially the
R E A C T I V I T Y I N D I C E S I N C O N J U G A T E D MOLECULES
76
same for all positions of substitution, involving a similar modification of the a-bonded framework, and that the relative rates of reactions leading to a given substitution a t different positions are therefore determined purely by the factor exp ( - AE/kT). The activation energy AE is then subdivided into two parts, one (AE,) relating to changes in the n-electron energy alone and the other containing contributions associated with distortion of the a-bonded framework, steric and solvent effects and all other terms not included in AE,. Again, it is customary to assume that energy changes of the second type are substantially similar for different
Reaction co-ordinate
FIG.1. Energy variation in reaction (purely schematic).
positions of attack. With these assumptions, it is possible to discuss the relative reactivities of different positions in terms of r-electron properties alone. For comparative purposes, the energy curve to be discussed (Fig. 1) may then be regarded as that of E , against a reaction coordinate -such as the distance of approach of a reagent (charged or otherwise) along some chosen reaction path towards a given position. It must be emphasized that the form of the complete energy curve is largely hypothetical in so far as reliable calculations have not been performed expect on the simplest (and most atypical) reactions, such as H+Ha +Hz+H
In particular, there is no convincing evidence for a discrimination among active positions according to values of AE, alone, and indeed the barrier itself may arise very largely from the other terms in AE (including not only n-electron effects but also, for example, the energy required to
76
H . H . GREENWOOD A N D R . MCWEENY
dissociate an attacking ion from its solvation complex). Authors frequently fail to indicate the nature of the terms included in their hypothetical energy curves; and it is by no means self-evident that these should be approximately constant for different positions of attack. I n this somewhat unsatisfactory situation, the discussion of E, alone is clearly a temporary expedient, without which little progress could be made. This limitation is accepted throughout the present review except in later Sections where the physical interpretation of the reaction mechanism is discussed and where future prospects are indicated. Two main methods of approach are used in discussing the variation of E,. These have been associated with different parts of the reaction path; the isolated molecule method is usually assumed to refer to the initial stages of the reaction, and the localization method is generally associated with a transition state in the region of the maximum of the energy curve. Each method has its own reactivity indices; these are defined in detail in later Sections, but at this point it is useful to list them, along with certain additional indices relating to models introduced more recently, and to indicate their applicability. Method Isolated molecule
Property (at atom r)
Index
charge self-polarizability free valence
qr Vr, r
p, ~
Localization method
L,+ L; Lr
Recent methods
fr
frontier charge superdelocalizability Z value
zr
} heterolytic homolytic
~~
localization energy
$r
Reaction
electrophilic nucleophilic free radical
,t
}
heterolytic and homolytic
B. Huckel Theory The indices are all defined in terms of the Huckel molecular orbital method. This has been described on many occasions, and need not be discussed in detail here, but a brief statement of the basic equations is a necessary foundation for later sections. The method utilizes a “oneelectron ” model in which each rr electron moves in a effective field due partly to the o-bonded framework and partly to its averaged interaction with the other rr electrons. This corresponds conceptually to the HartreeFock approach (Section IX) ; but at this level no attempt is made to define more precisely the one-electron Hamiltonian F, which contains the effective field. Instead, each rr-type molecular orbital (MO) is approxi-
REACTIVITY INDICES I N CONJUQATED MOLECULES
77
mated as a linear combination of (2p) atomic orbitals (LCAO approximation), one on each of the n conjugated centres,
and best approximations to the desired MO’s are then obtained by solving the secular equations
hc
=
ESC (matrix form)
78
i.e.
C h,c,
s=1
78
= E
z S,c,
(2)
(r = 1,2 ,.... n)
s=1
Here S is the overlap matrix with elements xrs =
J 4F48dT
(3)
and h has for its diagonal elements (hrr)the “coulomb integrals ” denoted by (4) E Y = 47“h4rd7
J
and off-diagonal elements (h,) the “resonance integrals ” PYS
=
J 4Fh48dT
(5)
Solutions of ( 2 ) occur for n particular values of E , namely the “orbital energies ” cl, E ~ , .. .E ~ , . .. E,, each yielding its own set of A 0 coefficients (c,$ and a corresponding MO : #j = Z C r j 4 r (6) The quantities (4)and (5) are treated, in Huckel theory, as purely empirical parameters, while S , is usually neglected for r # s. As a further approximation Pr8 is neglected unless atoms r and s are connected; and the values of E ~ pr8 , are assumed to depend only on the nature of atoms r and s (e.g. ar=ct0 if r is a carbon atom, &=/30 if r-s is a C-C bond). Both quantities are negative, larger magnitudes corresponding to more electronegative atoms and to stronger bonds, respectively. With these approximations ( 2 )takes the simpler form
hc
(7)
= EC
and the n simultaneous equations represented by (7) have non-trivial solutions only when
A ( € )=
1912
1913
1921
ff2-E
1923
1931
1932
u3-E
... ... = o
(8)
*.-
which is an nth degree equation whose roots are the n orbital energies.
78
H. H. GREENWOOD A N D R . MCWEENY
The n-electron distribution is described in terms of the q, at each atom (assuming for simplicity real orbitals
(T)
“charge”
t#r)
and the (T)“bond order” p,, for any pair of atoms s and t (Coulson, 1939) Pst =
C njcsjctj
(10)
j
where nj is the number of electrons in thejth MO. The “free valence” F, is also defined (Coulson, 1947) in terms of the bond orders: where N, is the sum of the orders of bonds between atom s and its = d3 being a theoretical maximum value of IV, neighbours, Nmax derived from trimethylenemethane (Streitwieser, 1961). The equations (9)-( 11) represent generalized definitions for any orbital occupancy nj obtained by filling the available MO’s in ascending energy order; but for the usual closed shell ground state nj = 2 for occupied MO’s and 0 otherwise. I n Huckel theory, Enis approximated as a sum of orbital energies, E say, computed just as if the electrons were independent. Coulson and Longuet-Higgins (1947a,b) showed that the total r-electron energy in the ground state is then
and that for variations subject to (8) a8
q8 =
and Pd =
(a,)
a(2)
The charges and bond orders thus indicate the response of the system to infinitesimal changes of its coulomb and resonance integrals, respectively.
C. Nature of the Methods The isolated-molecule method stems from the pioneering work of Wheland and Pauling (1935) on the orientation effects of substituents in benzene derivatives. It assumes that electrophilic and nucleophilic reagents attack preferentially at positions of high and low charge (a,) respectively, thus providing a more precise formulation of earlier
R E A C T I V I T Y I N D I C E S I N C O N J U G A T E D MOLECULES
79
electronic interpretations of heterolytic reactions due to Ingold, Lapworth and Robinson. I n discussing active positions it is convenient to use the following conventions : r = position a t which a reaction is envisaged (a carbon atom) u = position already substituted (or replaced by a hetero-atom) in the molecule considered. For the majority of simple hydrocarbons (i.e. for the “alternants” discussed in Section IV) the charge qris unity for any position of attack, and Wheland and Pauling therefore determined active positions by considering the relative magnitudes of the charges qi produced in the polarized molecules corresponding to various choices of position r, the polarization being caused by the field of the approaching reagent. The effect of the charged reagent was supposed to be a change Sa, in coulomb integral at the position r of attack, and the resultant charge qi may in this case be written (to first order)
a: = q r + n ; , , . ~ % (15) where nr,?is the “self-polarizability ” of atom r. Coulson and Longuet, for ~ the corresponding Higgins (1947b) derived expressions for T ~and changes 66 in rr-electron energy : 66 = qrSar+&,,,Sa2, and the self-polarizability T,., ,thus determines the second-order energy change. Even at this point it is worth noting the gross approximation involved in simulating the effect of the charged reagent by changing one coulomb integral only. I n fact, all a’s and /3’s are changed, many of them by amounts not much smaller than Sa,. A rough estimate (cf. Brown, 1963) gives for the change due to unit positive charge at point X =
- e2 R,
where Rx, is the distance between X and centre r.l Even at a distance of 5 A this corresponds to about 2 e.V. (for E N l),which compares with a carbon-carbon resonance integral (which is the natural energy unit in Huckel calculations) usually assumed to be of the order 1 e.V. The polarization effect must therefore be large, and because of the simple inverse-distance form of 60; must affect even more distant centres to a considerable extent. The importance of polarization will become clear 1 Sometimes a “dielectric constant” E is added in the denominator to allow empirically for solvent effects.
80
H. H. GREENWOOD AND R . MCWEENY
in Section 11, and the basis of the approximations will be re-examined in Section IX. The other isolated molecule index, the free valence F,,is used in discussing homolytic reactions, and determines the effect of reduction of resonance integrals between an atom r under attack and its two neighbours. Denoting the two neighbours by p and q, the change in resonance integral v m =
W‘J( =w
produces a change 6 6 in n-electron energy given by
66
2Nr6P = 2 ( 2 / 3 - F r ) 6 p (16) where N , is the total (generally non-integral) number of n bonds formed by r with its neighbours, and Fv is introduced as in (1 1). The change &3 is generally associated with a postulated change in hybridization from trigonal to tetrahedral due to incipient u bonding with an uncharged reagent in the neighbourhood of atom r ; and for this reason (16) is used in discussing radical reactions. The indices of the localization method will not be defined in detail at this point, but they relate to the considerably greater changes in T electron energy which occur at a more advanced stage of the reaction. I n the corresponding transition complex the reagent is supposed to be a-bonded to the molecule, and the original path of conjugation is therefore broken. The energy changes L,+,L, and L; are calculated assuming that 2, 1 or 0 electrons (respectively) are “localized” a t centre r and consequently withdrawn from the conjugated system. The remaining indices originate from somewhat more elaborate interpretations of the reaction mechanism, and have a considerably Iess clear-cut theoretical significance ;their consideration is deferred until Section VII. =
D. Derivatives and Heterocyclics The indices of the isolated molecule method are frequently used in another context; €or the presence of a substituent group, or a heteroatom, at position u formally resembles that of a charged reagent in so far as it results in a coulomb integral au which differs from that (ao,say) €or the corresponding “parent” hydrocarbon, i.e. a, = a. +&a,. Thus, for any system which differs from a parent hydrocarbon only by changes 6a, in coulomb integrals (the number of 7~ electrons and conjugated centres being the same) the charges can be obtained from those of the parent by perturbation formulae analogous to (15). I n fact, with a change $a,, (17) % % + n.9.u 6% where rrs,u is the “atom-atom polarizability” which gives the change in --f
REACTIVITY INDICES I N CONJUGATED MOLECULES
81
q8per unit increase in au (for the parent) and is a self-polarizability in the case s =u. Expressions for these coefficients were also given by Coulson and Longuet-Higgins (1947b) and a precisely similar analysis applies to , in resonance integrals. The values of q6and F6obtained for changes Sg a derivative or heterocycle in this way may then be used in discussing its active positions; and i t is because of this double use of perturbation methods that the r and u convention for reactive and substituted positions (Section IB) is useful. I n using the isolated molecule indices in this way, it is important to distinguish the two types of substituent, commonly referred to as “inductive ’’ and “mesomeric ”. An inductive substituent is adequately described by making the parameter change au+au + &xu, this change resulting essentially from the formation of a polar 0 bond which modifies the effective electronegativity of atom u without otherwise changing the v system. A mesomeric substituent, on the other hand, is generally regarded as extending the region of conjugation; in aniline, for example, the nitrogen becomes part of the conjugated system and benzene may no longer be regarded as a parent molecule in the sense that the electron distribution may be obtained from that of the parent merely by a parameter change. I n such cases the perturbation equation (17) does not apply directly, and it is necessary to consider the derivative as a new molecule with a new conjugated framework, the mesomeric group either donating or accepting T electrons. It is, however, possible to utilize the polarizabilities if these are defined with respect to a new parent hydrocarbon isoelectronic with, and having the same conjugated path as, the derivative. Thus the appropriate parent hydrocarbon for aniline would be the benzyl anion, with the same pattern of seven centres and the same number of electrons. The electron distribution in the derivative is frequently close to that in the appropriate parent, and any modifications due to the replacement of C by N, for example, may then be inferred from the change ac+aN (exactly as for a purely inductive effect). There is of course no sharp distinction between inductive and mesomeric effects ; both may occur together and the present definition of the two terms simply indicates the theoretical models appropriate to two limiting situations. 11. SOMEAPPLICATIONS OF
THE
INDICES
I n general, reactivity indices are tested by comparing a predicted sequence of active positions, deduced from the magnitudes of a given index, with that observed experimentally. I n some applications calculated localization energies have been substituted directly into relative
’
82
H . H . G R E E N W O O D A N D R. M C W E E N Y
rate equations (Dewar and Sampson, 1956a; Dewar et al., 1966b), but here the test is more severe and satisfactory results often require adjustment of empirical parameters. The aim of this sectionis not to discuss the general correlation of theory and experiment but rather to investigate a few selected molecules in some detail, in order to illustrate the relevance of various indices and to show how easily wrong conclusions may be drawn if they are used with insufficient care or in a wrong context. The emphasis will be initially on the isolated molecule approach and different types of reaction will be considered in turn.
A. Heterolytic Reactions The second-order equation for the 7-electron energy change, due to change in the coulomb integral at position r, S& = q,6ur+~7r,~,6u2,
(18)
forms the basis of the isolated molecule theory of heterolytic reactions. I t is frequently invoked only to illustrate the function of qr and rr,.,, which are then used quite separately in seeking correlations with experimental data. This procedure is certainly not justified by the form of equation (18) but appears to have been carried over from the study of alternant hydrocarbons, in which the leading term is the same for all positions, and discrimination among them depends on r,,,alone. I n other systems, however, the two terms in (18) may represent a h e balance of opposing effects, depending in a critical way upon the actual value of Su, and hence upon the position of the reagent when directing effects begin to operate. The index q, alone would adequately describe the effect of a Su, so small as to cause no appreciable polarization of the molecule ; but an order-of-magnitude estimate of Su, (Section I) shows that the polarizing effect of an ion even two or three bond lengths away from r may outweigh the effect of a heteroatom in the conjugated framework, and the terms in (18)are then of comparable importance. There are also limitations on the magnitude of Surfor which (18)is a useful approximation, depending on the rate of convergence of the infinite expansion. The finite change A& in 7-electron energy due to an arbitrary change in coulomb integral Su,, can however be calculated by direct solution of the secular equations. There is thus a distinction between the upper limit on 6u, set by the equation (18), and that which may be used in computing A& and is determined only by the validity of the model. Current theory has not established to what extent the model is over-simplified though clearly i t could be improved by, for example, changing the coulomb integrals at other atoms: this problem will be taken up in Section IX.
REACTIVITY
INDICES IN CONJUGATED MOLECULES
83
On the basis of this model, however, it is interesting to investigate one or two applications which illustrate the interplay of the two indices in (18) when Su, is fairly large. For this purpose we must consider heterocycles, substituted systems or non-alternants in which considerable charge inequalities occur, and q, becomes a significant index. The heterolytic reactions of such molecules are then almost invariably discussed in terms of the charges q, alone, one reason perhaps being that the polarizabilities T,,,are seldom available except for alternant hydrocarbons (Sandorfy et al., 1950; Sandorfy and Yvon, 1949). Discrepancies arise quite frequently when q8 is compared with experimental data, quinoline providing a good example (Ridd, 1963). The nitrogen atom will be represented by a change So(, = 0*5p, though this choice does not significantly affect the conclusions.
The charges q, at perimeter atoms in the ground state are shown in Fig. 2. Experimental data on nitration (Dewar and Maitlis, 1957) and bromination (Derbyshire and Waters, 1950) indicates that electrophilic substitution occurs exclusively, and almost equally, at positions 5 and 8, whereas Fig. 2 indicates 3 > 8 > 6 as the sequence of active positions. There is therefore a serious discrepancy in the predictions. Since this situation is by no means uncommon in heterocyclicsand other substituted systems, Ridd (1963)justifiably concludes that the charge q, is overrated as a reactivity index, and that little evidence exists to suggest that it determines orientation properties. However, the correlation is not so much with q, but with the implied finite change A 8 defined earlier, and the growing importance of the second (and higher) terms in (18) means that it is in the context of the polarized molecule that the role of q, as a reactivity index must be considered. To illustrate the situation we present in Figs. 3a and 3b the “exact” charges q: in the polarized molecules (cf. equation (15))when Scr, due to the attacking ion takes the values 0.5 Po and 1-5 Po respectively, for the atom positions r=3,5,6 and 8 (Greenwood and McWeeny, 1965). Each molecular diagram shows the results of four calculations r = 3,5,6,8) and should not be confused with the charge distribution of a single calculation such as that shown in Fig. 2. The results show
84
H . H . GREENWOOD A N D R . MCWEENY
clearly that in the polarized molecules the charge builds up more rapidly at the site of attack when this coincides with the 5 or 8 positions than when it coincides with position 3. I n the same way the energy changes Ad may be calculated.
1,522
1.205 (a).
1.544
6ar = 0.6po
(b). 6ar = 1.5P0
FIG.3. Charges p i in the polarized molecule
The changes Ad are negative, correspondingto increased stability, and are given in units of Po; each diagram corresponds to four calculations ( 6 ~ r=3,5,6,8), ~ ; and shows how, as 6ar the polarization parameter increases, positions 8 and 5 overtake 3 as the “active” positions. The predictions and results show that discrepancies between’theoretical
(a).6ar = 0.5 j30
(b). 6ar = 1.5j30 FIG.4. Energy changes dB
experimental results begin to disappear when the change in field at the position r of attack, produced by an approaching reagent, is similar in magnitude to the change 6a, at the position u occupied by a heteroatom, that is when 6 a , S~cr,. This result bears out our earlier conjecture that polarization effects may outweigh those due to a heteroatom, in this case nitrogen, and that the charges “seen” by an ion near the molecule might in fact correlate with the observed active positions. To summarize, the results can be understood qualitatively as a reduction in the influence of the nitrogen atom as the polarizing effect of an approaching positive charge begins to dominate, or alternatively as the emergence of the polarization terms in (18) as the major factor determining orientation, this exerting its greatest effect, in the case of quinoline, a t the 5 and 8 positions. It is now possible to interpret more clearly the roles of the charges qs and self-polarizabilities rr, of the unperturbed heterocycle in equation (18). Although the values of n,,r are not often available, it is permissible for qualitative discussion to invoke those of the parent hydrocarbon,
REACTIVITY
INDICES
IN CONJUGATED MOLECULES
85
and, since the absolute value of T,,,in naphthalene is greater at a than at /Ipositions, it follows that (IT5.51
3
sII >
ITS,
I T S , 31
so that when 6a, is sufficiently large the second-order terms in (18) can offset the first order terms, for which q3
>
,
k S q5>
It is interesting to note that at the inactive position 4, a large polarizability term does not apparently compensate for the low charge, q 4 = 0.932, which arises from deactivation by nitrogen in the same ring (Fig. 2). Clearly, both q, and T,,,must be taken into account. Non-alternant hydrocarbons possess uneven charge distributions in the ground state, even when no substituents are present, and again comparisons of qr and T,,,separately with experimental data may produce
0 . k
0.959
0,241
FIG.5
2.341
(b)
discrepancies. I n azulene the active positions of electrophilic attack are correctly indicated by the charge distribution. The localization theory (SectionI)is also successful in this case. On the other hand, fluoranthene, which has been discussedin some detail (Streitwieser, 1961 ;Brown, 1964 ; Fukui, 1964) shows several discrepancies. Electrophilic substitution occurs at the positions 3 and 8 (Streitwieser, 1961) with small yields at the 1 and 7 positions (Streitwieser and Fahey, 1962). The charges and self-polarizabilities are shown attached to the right and left perimeter atoms respectively in Fig. 5a. The performance of two other indices is indicated in Fig. 5b : localization energies for electrophilic attack are shown on the right perimeter atoms, and the frontier electron charges of Fukui on the left. I n addition to these, free valence (P8)and 2, values have been studied (Brown, 1964). The localization energy gives easily the best correlation with observed reaction rates, the only anomaly being the high activity predicted for the 7 position; none of the other
86
H . H . GREENWOOD A N D R . MCWEENY
indices appear to correlate with experiment. Since, in quinoline the effect of polarization compensated for the effect of the charges to give substantial agreement with experimental data, it seemed at least possible that the large self-polarizability 7r3, = 0.462 (Fig. 5a) might similarly compensate for the low charge q3 = 0.959, and the low value n2, = 0-400 nullify the higher charge q2 = 1.005, and so on. Calculations were therefore performed (Greenwood and McWeeny, 1965) to determine A 8 and the charges q: a t the position r of attack in the polarized molecule. To avoid ambiguities, a fairly large value Sa,=2*0 Po was taken, though again this is not unrealistic as a representation of the effect of an ion a few bond lengths away. Figure 6 gives the changes A 8 in n-electron
8
I.fi3li 1.648
1.363
1,366
1.335
1.632 1.623 1.655
n:
1.358 1.354
A8
FIG.6. Charges and energy changes due to polarization (6ar = 2.0 P o )
energy, in units of Po, against the perimeter atoms on the right, and charges qi in the polarized molecule against those on the left. Again, the results of all five calculations (8ar= 2.0 Po; r = 1,2,3,7,8)are shown in the same diagram. Thus, the same change Sa, at each atom produces the largest charge qh= 1.655 at position 3, and the smallest, qL= 1-623 at position 2 in the corresponding polarized molecules. Consequently, the charge distribution in the ground state (Fig. 5a) gives a poor reflection of the availability of electrons produced by the polarizing effect of the ion, as represented by the change Sa,. I n comparing the changes A& in 7r-electron energy with experimental data, a single anomaly remains for atom 7, where a large energy of stabilization A& = 1.366 is obtained. A similar anomaly appears in the localization energy L t (Fig. 5b) for atom 7, which again suggests a highly active position, contrary to experiment. It must of course be remembered that the theoretical model is still oversimplified, using the same a and P values for the five-memberedring, and that the sequence of active positions might still easily be modified by further refinement. To summarize, there is strong evidence that when qr and nr,?are considered together, in their complementary role in (1 8) for systems in which
REACTIVITY
INDICES IN CONJUGATED
MOLECULES
87
the charge distribution is uneven in the ground state, the discrepancies that may be obtained by comparing the indices separately with experimental data largely disappear. It is then possible to obtain a better performance from the indices of the isolated approximation than has generally been supposed. It is also clear (e.g. from the inactive 4 position in quinoline) that there , ~than for using qr; is in general no more justification for using 7 ~ by~ itself it is only for alternant hydrocarbons that the self-polarizability is the discriminating factor, and in all other cases rr,r should be considered only to the extent that it modifies conclusions based on the leading term qr8ur in (18). Moreover, the relative importance of the two terms depends on the value of 8ar, and this in turn upon the position of the reagent.
B. Homolytic Reactions The free valence P,was proposed by Coulson (1947,1948) as a suitable index for predicting, in the isolated molecule method, the free radical reactions of conjugated molecules. The main physical justification for the index is that it represents a measure of the available r bonding at an atom, which may be significant in reactions that are not primarily ionic in character. The free valence has received only moderate acceptance as an index for radical reactions, perhaps because its physical basis is comparatively obscure. Yet in performance i t is seldom inferior to other indices; it is in fact related mathematically both to the corresponding localizationenergy (SectionVI)and to the self-polarizability (SectionIX). Kooyman and Fahrenhorst (1953) showed that the relative reactivities towards trichloromethyl radicals correlate with the highest free valence in a variety of aromatic hydrocarbons. Since there is an empirical linear relationship between localization energiesand free valences (Streitwieser, 1961), i t follows that the correlations found by Szwarc (1955, 1957; Szwarc and Binks, 1959) between relative reactivities of conjugated molecules towards methyl radicals and localization energies (Coulson, 1955), would also hold for free valences. It is however in the reactions of substituted aromatic molecules that patterns emerge which clearly indicate the relevance of the free valence in radical reactions. The benzene derivatives provide a good example. Orientation effects in benzene derivatives operate in two ways. If the substituent is inductive there are large f i s t order charge displacements at the ortho and para positions, and these can be estimated approximately using the atom polarizabilities ns,u(which is very small at the meta position). The changes of bond order, however, and consequently of free valence, vanish in first order and hence depend on 8ar2. The charge qsat position s therefore increases or decreases from the value unity in the
88
H . H . GREENWOOD A N D R . MCWEENY
parent hydrocarbon according to the nature of the substituent ; but the change in free valence F , is always of the same sign, irrespective of electronegativity of the substituent. Similar results hold for mesomeric substituents; large changes in q, are confined to the ortho and para positions, their signs depending on whether the substituent is electron-attracting or electron-donating, while the changes in F, are independent of the nature of the substituent and arise purely from the introduction of a non-zero 8 connecting it with the ring. These properties are in accord with the experimental fact that radical reactions occur at the same atom positions, regardless of the nature of the substituent group (Wheland, 1942). More recent experimental evidence on benzene derivatives investigated by Hey et al. (Chang Shih et al., 1958; Hey et al., 1960; Hambling et al., 1960) supports these findings, even when the reagent contains strongly polar bonds which may have some small effect on the a’s; for, although these effects change the relative rates somewhat, they do not alter the occurrence of substitution in ortho-para positions. Another result of a similar character was obtained by Fahrenhorst and Kooyman (1955)on the relative reactivities of 9-substituted anthracenes ; they showed that the activity towards radical attack at the 10-positionis enhanced by 9-substitution, irrespective of the polarity of the substituent group (Greenwood, 1955b).The free valence therefore shows a correspondence with radical reactivity in situations where discrimination amongst reactivity indices is possible.
111. PROPERTIES OF THE SECULAR EQUATIONS In this section we discuss, in general terms, certain properties of the secular equations (8) which provide insight into the various methods employed in defining reactivity indices. The energy levels arise from solution of the equation
I a1-E
B12
813
* * -
I (8)
Different methods employ the same equation, but make different choices of the way in which one or two of the coulomb or resonance integrals vary as a particular region of the molecule comes under attack, these parameters being chosen to simulate the changes likely to be produced by the approaching reagent. It is a relatively straightforward matter, as illustrated in sub-section C, to trace the variation of energy levels when these few integral parameters change, and this technique serves to establish
REACTIVITY INDICES I N CONJUGATED MOLECULES
89
relationships between the various theoretical methods and the context in which they are defined.
A. Partial Derivatives and Polarizability Coeficients Expansion of (8) yields a polynomial, the characteristic or secular polynomial, whose roots are determined by the values of the parameters a,,, pm. The ground state energy (12) is likewise a function of the (a,/?) parameter values, as are all quantities such as A 0 coefficientsinthe MO’s, charges qs, bond orders psi, etc. It is possible, therefore, to specify the kth partial derivative with respect to any au or ?,/ at an arbitrary point defined by a set of values (a,/?)in the parameter space, and to make expansions such as
where A = ej, csj, qs, pst,F,, and so on. The first and second derivatives are the polarizability coefficients defined by Coulson and LonguetHiggins (1947a,b); for example,
are the atom-atom and atom-bond polarizabilities respectively. The coefficients are, therefore, slopes, curvatures and, in general, partial derivatives in the a,/? space, and individual terms of the expansions (19) and (20)represent contributions to the finite change AA. Now AA may be a mathematical representation of a physical quantity, but considerable care must be exercised in associating calculated values of the coefficients themselves with experimental data. It must be remembered that alternative forms of expansion about the arbitrary point (a,/?)can be found, with successive terms different from those of (19) and (20) and that the polarizability coefficients are unique only in the sense of being defined in terms of the power series. Some reference must now be made to the properties of the basic set of equations for the special case of alternant hydrocarbons. The secular polynomial A (e) acquires important analytical properties when all a’s and all /?’stake common values a. and Po, and when, in addition, the molecule is “ alternant ” in the sense of the Coulson-Rushbrooke (1940) theorem. The following results are well known : (i) Bonding and antibonding molecular orbitals are “paired”, with energy levels lying symmetrically below and above a. respectively. 4
90
I€. H . G R E E N W O O D A N D R . M C W E E N Y
(ii) A non-bonding orbital with energy a. is obtained for systems with an odd number of conjugated atoms. (iii) When the MO’s are filled in ascending energy order, the rr-electron charge density qs at each conjugated atom of the neutral molecule is unity. Simplification in the discussion of spectroscopic states (Dewar and Longuet-Higgins, 1954; McLachlan, 1959) and many developments of analytical expressions (Coulson and Longuet-Higgins, 1947a,b; Fukui et al., 1957a; Greenwood, 1952b) for quantities describing the ground state, originate in these properties. Their relation to the reactivity problem, and to analytical properties of the polarizability coefficients appearing in (19) and (20) are described in some detail in Sections IV and VI.
B. Energy Level Diagrams and Parameter Variations Energy level diagrams have seldom been used to show how the disposition of levels changes with variations of the a and /3 parameters describing the system, and how such processes can be related to spectroscopic changes and postulated reaction mechanisms. Yet, they can often give a qualitative understanding of the effects of molecular modifications with a minimum of effort, and for this reason at least deserve mention. The diagrams are best understood in terms of the apparent “repulsion” between the energy levels of combining systems, which can easily be related to a perturbation treatment of the secular equations. For example, two carbon atom rr electron levels (1) and (2) with energies a. would interact to remove the degeneracy
-I-
-
a0 -
_____--_-- (1)
(2)
- --- - - --(3)
FIQ.7. Splitting of levela by interaction.
and produce two separated rr electron levels (3) as in the ethylene molecule. Working on this basis, the distribution of levels in many aromatic hydrocarbons can be constructed systematically, by reference to a few simple molecules whose levels are known. I n the case of benzene and other molecules with high symmetry, the process is sometimes obscured by additional degeneracies, but the general idea of repulsion amongst levels persists. Let us consider, for example, how the levels of styrene (c) can be synthesized from benzene (b) and ethylene (a), and
REACTIVITY I N D I C E S I N CONJUGATED MOLECULES
91
those of stilbene (d) from styrene and benzene; and, finally, how the “twisting ” of stilbene about the central bond produces the levels of two benzyl systems (e).
(a)
---
-
__--
--
(b)
(d 1
(C)
FIG.8. Effect of ‘‘fusion”on energy levels: a,b-+c;b,c-*d; d-,e
(el on “twisting”.
For this purpose let the levels be labelled from the lowest in each system upwards, and let a plus sign indicate “interaction” leading to repulsion so that, for example, a1 (bz + b3) + cz, c3, c4 implies that the threefold degeneracy consisting of the level a, (cl= 1.0g) in ethylene (a)and the twofold degeneracy be, b3 ( c Z = c3 = 1.Og) in benzene (b) interact to produce the levels cz, c3, c4 ( c Z = 1.414 /I,c3 = 1-0 fl and c4= 0.662 g) of styrene (c). Note also that the “repulsion” produces a lowering from bl to cl. Next, the imaginary “fusion” of benzene and styrene to form stilbene is characterized by
+
c4
-+ a
7
d4, d6,
bZ+b3+C3
CZ
df3
+ d3
dl, dz
bl+Cl -+
On the other hand, the relationship between the levels of stilbene and the two benzyl systems (e) follows a different pattern,
dl, dz
% + e l +-
ez+ez -+d3,d4
4,dtl
e3+e3 e4+e4
--f
4,d 8
92
H . H . GREENWOOD A N D R . MCWEENY
every degenerate pair of Ievels of the two benzyls corresponding to two distinct levels of stilbene. It is clear that the construction of such diagrams requires no actual calculation, but that they may be of considerable value in discussing the effects of structural changes in a molecule. They are useful, for example, in the interpretation of the U.V. spectra of related molecules; and there are many instances, in which effects are normally discussed in terms of numerical calculations, where the diagrams can provide an immediate qualitative explanation. We turn now to the use of energy level diagrams in discussing the effect of parameter variations of the kind envisaged in defining reactivity indices.
Case (i): a,.variation The energy levels of an alternant hydrocarbon (AH),equal in number to the number of conjugated carbon atoms, are arranged symmetrically about a. (Fig. 9)
I + da,
FIG.9. Change of energy levels AH of alternant hydrocarbon with ar;limiting levels coincide with the levels RM of the residual molecule.
A “residual molecule” (RM) can be defined for every atom T of an even alternant hydrocarbon as the odd alternant hydrocarbon obtained by omitting atom r from the original system. The secular determinant for the residual molecule with atom r removed is obtained from A ( € ) in
R E A C T I V I T Y I N D I C E S I N C O N J U G A T E D MOLECULES
93
equation (8) by crossing out the rth row and column; this determinant so that will be denoted by & ( E ) , 4 , T ( 4
= 0
(22)
gives the energy levels of the residual molecule. It can be proved that for all possible residual molecules, corresponding to all atoms r of the system, the energy levels “separate” those of the parent hydrocarbon (Fig. 9), their actual positions depending upon which atom r is selected. The central level lies at the zero of energy a0 and the corresponding MO is usually termed the non-bonding orbital (NBMO). We select a particular atom r , of an even alternant hydrocarbon, and change the coulomb integral by an amount &a, so that the new value becomes a, = ao+Sa,
A change in which Sa, is negative is characterized by the foIlowing properties (Greenwood, 1955a). (1) All energy levels are lowered. The lowering of the deepest bonding level is limited only by the magnitude of 6a,. The remaining levels are lowered towards those of the residual molecule as limiting values (Fig. 9). (2) The molecular orbitals are changed so that correspondingto the deepest level q,becomes increasingly localised a t the atom r , and all others tend towards the MO’s of the residual molecule. This condition is achieved by the migration of a node of each orbital until it cuts the bonds which connect atom r with the residual molecule. Alternatively, 6a, may become positive, in which case the pattern of energy levels is the mirror image in the zero of energy (ao)of that obtained for the case when Sa, is negative (Fig. 9). It is not difficult to show that, in this case, the levels of the residual molecule are now the limiting values of the lowest levels, and the uppermost antibonding level is now limited only by the magnitude of &a,. I n the same way, the orbital corresponding to the uppermost level tends to become localized in the region r , all other orbitals changing towards those of the residual molecule.
Case ( i i ): pr8variation A second important type of change involves variation of a selected resonance integral : A 8
= Bo+SPm
where &Pr8represents an arbitrary finite change. Remembering that ,!I is a negative quantity, Sp,, is first taken positive so that a limiting choice sp= - p will make pr8= 0 ; this corresponds formally to a condition of no interaction between atoms r and s. This case is easy to understand and
94
H. H . GREENWOOD AND R . MCWEENY
has in fact already been described for the stilbene molecule, in which putting Spx = -Po for the X bond of Fig. (10) changes the energy levels of stilbene to those of benzene and styrene, while putting S/3, = -Po for the Y bond changes the levels to degenerate pair of benzyl levels. No further comments are necessary.
FIG.10
Case (iii): &,, /Irp variation The next case is that in which the resonance integrals between a perimeter atom r and its two neighbours, r, and q, are reduced equally to final values /Irp =prU= 0.
AH
RM
FIQ.11. Change of energy levels AH of alternant hydrocarbons as p( =pIp=&,)+O.
I n this case (Greenwood, 1957) the energy levels change towards those of the residual molecule, but by a general " contraction " of levels towards the zero of energy a. as shown in Fig. (1 1). The innermost pair produces, in the limit, a degenerate pair with energy ao. The molecular orbitals also change in general towards those of the residual molecule, with the exception of those of the innermost pair, which retain a uniform distribution over the complete parent hydrocarbon. I n the limit Sp = -Po, when the
R E A C T I V I T Y I N D I C E S I N C O N J U G A T E D MOLECULES
95
innermost pair becomes degenerate, an alternative solution may be obtained by taking orthogonal combinations of the degenerate orbitals. I n this way it is possible to transform these two orbitals into the n--electron atomic orbital localized a t atom r , and the non-bonding orbital of the residual molecule (i.e. to the solutions physically appropriate to the “separated” system).
Case (iv): Pr8large and negative Finally, we consider the case in which SP,, is negative, and makes /3,8 large and negative. The lowest and uppermost levels then break away from below and above the others respectively, the corresponding MO’s becoming formally equivalent to bonding and antibonding orbitals associated with the bond r-s. The remaining levels tend towards those of a molecule with centres T and s missing, which is thus a residual molecule The “bond ” r-s obtained in the defined with respect to the bond r-s. limiting configuration is not to be confused with an ethylenic double bond, since, although the M O ’ s are formally similar in the limit as PIS becomes more negative, the bond described by this artificial /3 value would be much stronger. By the same token, the process should be distinguished from that defining the bond localization energy (Brown, 1949), in which localization is introduced by putting Pa =/38u= 0, where t and u are neighbours of r and s respectively. The present case is, in fact, similar to that discussed by Muller et al. (1954) in considering the structure of a transition state complex with hyperconjugation, and will be discussed in some detail in Section VIII.
IV. THEISOLATED MOLECULEMETHOD This section deals with analytical properties of the Huckel molecular orbital theory and the associated isolated molecule method of predicting the active positions in a conjugated molecule. We shall deal with polarizability coefficients defined as certain partial derivatives with respect to the coulomb and resonance integrals described in Section 111. The important derivatives are those relating to the total nelectron energy 8,and to the charges q8,free valencesB’*,and bond orders pst, which derive from the ground state electron density. To limit the amount of information to be presented, attention will be focused on derivatives with respect to the 12sonly, ignoring for the most part those which relate to the p’s. The treatment of effects arising from /3 variation proceeds along completely similar lines. We must, at the outset, distinguish between the two kinds of change in coulomb integral that are applied in practice.
96
H . H . GREENWOOD A N D R . MCWEENY
( 1 ) The change Scr, may represent the effect of a substituent or heteroatom at the uth position. I n this case the T electron energy levels, charges q,, free valences F, and bond orders patcan be obtained by direct solution of the secular equations (8) using
a, = ao+Sa,
(23)
Alternatively, perturbation formulae may be employed to derive the same results approximately, starting from the parent alternant hydrocarbons and using the polarizability coefficients. Thus, for example, =
TS,U%L
(24)
gives the approximate change in charge density at the sth atom in passing from the parent hydrocarbon to the derivative, where
is the atom-atom polarizability associated with atoms s and u in the hydrocarbon. Corresponding atom-bond polarizabilities =,t,u
= __
8%
and free valence polarizabilities
are both zero, and second derivatives are needed to obtain Sp,, and SF,. From (24) the charge q, in the derivative is q 8
=
1+T8,UScrU
(28)
since qs= 1 in the parent hydrocarbon. These approximate values will not, in general, coincide with the “exact” values obtained by direct solution of the secular equations, since SLY, is seldom small in practice. Usually changes in coulomb integral are expressed in units of Po so that
k/3o (29) where k is positive or negative for substituent groups or atoms that are respectively more or less electronegative than a conjugated carbon atom. Values for nitrogen substitution, for example, have been selected from the range k = 0.2 to 1.0, and for oxygen substitution from the range k = 1.0 to 2.0 (Streitwieser, 1961). (2) The change Sa, at the position r of attack may be employed in discussing the ionic reactions of conjugated molecules, through the equation Sau =
6 8 = q,Sar as described in earlier Sections. I
+
4Tr,,8a:
(18)
REACTIVITY INDICES I N CONJUGATED MOLECULES
97
The charges q8 of equation (28) may be used as reactivity indices, either intuitively as relative measures of coulombic attraction or electron availability, or through equation (18), bearing in mind that in this case 6 6 approximates the “exact” change A&, as discussed in Section 11. Since the leading term in (28) is unity, predictions of the active positions in derivatives can be made in terms of computed values of the r8,u coefficients for the parent hydrocarbons. Moreover, changes with the same sign of 6au necessarily yield the same active positions, which, in practice, provides a theoretical explanation of orientation in benzene derivatives. Now the polarizability coefficients for alternant hydrocarbons have interesting analytical properties, like the secular equations themselves (Section 111).These properties arise as special cases from a more general analysis which applies to theJinite changes dq,, q 8 = +’ q 8 (30) obtained by exact solution of the secular problem with au= a,, +actu. The two developments, approximate and exact, will be presented in turn. Fortunately, the results must be closely parallel, and this gives some justification for the qualitative description offered by the polarizability method. A. Analytical Properties of Approximate Methods Expressions for polarizability coefficientswere first developed (Coulson and Longuet-Higgins, 1947a,b)in two forms, on the one hand as contour integrals in which the integrands are functions of the determinant (8)and its minors, and on the other hand by perturbation methods in terms of the energy levels ej and the corresponding molecular orbitals t,hj of the parent molecule. The first method will be consideredin some detail, for although it involves the mathematical device of integration in the complex plane, the procedure is ultimately straightforward for alternant hydrocarbons and will be used later to determine the finite changes. I n contrast, the terms of the perturbation method beyond the second order are too unwieldy for general analysis, though the definitions of some polarizability coefficients will be given in the perturbation form for completeness. We select without proof, from the theory of Coulson and LonguetHiggins (1947a,b), those formulae which relate to quantities used in the description of chemical reactivity, as follows :
4*
98
H . H. G R E E N W O O D A N D R. M C W E E N Y
Integration is along the y axis of the complex plane between - co and + 00 and ( i y ) is the argument in all secular determinants or minors; the same limits of integration apply to all formulae in this section, and will therefore be omitted. Aa,b is the determinant obtained by crossing out the ath row and bth column of A in equation (8) and A' is the derivative of A with respect to the argument (iy). The discussion will now be specialized to parent molecules which are even alternant hydrocarbons. All the analytical properties to be referred to originate from the basic properties of these molecules. Thus, for an even alternant hydrocarbon, with n = 2m conjugated atoms, A ( € ) is a polynomial with even powers of E in which successive non-zero terms alternate in sign, so that
A ( € ) = (a,r"-aa,,En-2+an-4E"-4.. .+a,) (35) The polynomials of the minors A , that arise contain either odd or even powers of E only ;when odd, ( 6 ) can be taken out as a factor multiplying a polynomial with even powers only. The substitution r-.(iy) then gives polynomials in which all terms carry the same sign and are real functions of y multiplied by the factors unity or ( i y ) . I n practice the factors (iy) either cancel between numerator and denominator in the integrals, or yield integrands that are odd functions of y and therefore integrate to zero. Integration is then straightforward, though numerical methods are usually required for the larger molecules which give rise to high-order polynomials (Coulson and Jacobs, 1949). The polarizability coefficients can now be derived by differentiation of the forms (31) to (34), to give first order derivatives
Coulson and Longuet-Higgins made an extensive study of the properties of these expressions and showed, for example, that the coefficients
REACTIVITY I N D I C E S I N CONJUGATED MOLECULES
99
(37) and (38) are zero. The alternative forms obtained by perturbation methods involve the coefficients csj of A 0 q5s in the j t h MO :for example, r8,u
=4
22
j=1 k = m + l
c8jcujc8kcuk Ej EL
-
(39)
The fact that certain coefficients are identically zero for alternants, also exhibit characteristic properties, is clearly of great and that the rssu importance. It means that the properties of all molecules which derive from a given alternant hydrocarbon parent, as estimated using the polarizabilities, will have many features in common. The most important general properties of the atom-atom polarizabilities are (i)that in passing along the perimeter of the molecule from the position of substitution, successive r 8 ,alternate , in sign (Coulson and Daudel(l955); (ii)that if s belongs to the same (starred) set as u, then ther,,values aresmall, as for meta positions; whereas if s and u belong to opposite sets the rs,u are large, as for ortho and para positions, though diminishing with distance from the site u. These features reflect the orienting effects of substituents in heterolytic reactions, as embodied in the " law of alternating polarity" (Coulson and Longuet-Higgins, 1947a,b). A further conclusion, useful in the case of free radical reactions arises from the fact that F , , in equation (38) is analytically zero, and that consequently, to second order,
This shows that the change 6F, is independent of the sign of the electronegativity change produced by the substituent group, a result in accord with the experimental findings mentioned in Section IIB, and lends support to the notion that F , is a useful index for free radical attack. The general features of the theory, expressed in analytical properties which are largely parameter-independent, are thus in accordance with observation, and there seems to be a good case for further investigation of the q and F indices.
B. Analytical Properties of Exact Methods As noted in Section 11, truncated series may give misleading results, depending upon the magnitude of the parameter, 6u, say, used in the expansion ; and certainly the values currently used in the representation
100
H. H. GREENWOOD A N D R . MCWEENY
of substituents (Streitwieser, 1961) cast some doubts on the numerical values and predicted properties derived from polarizability coefficients. It is possible, however, to find analytical properties of theJinite changes due to an arbitrary 6a,. For this reason, and because it applies equally not only to the effect of substituents but also to the large changes 6a, at an attacked atomand hence to the reactivity indices used in the isolated molecule method, the theory of finite changes will be briefly outlined. A finite change in any quantity A can be written as the Taylor series
where A r q , , F,, p,, and, as usual, we consider the one parameter, 6a,. Then, starting from the integral formulae (31) to (34), successive differentiations under the integral sign give for the general derivative of q, (Greenwood, 1952b)
with similar expressions for the derivatives of F, and p,,. Consequently from (42).
m
AF,
=
2
k=l
(-
7r
1
(iy)
(SCL,)~ ( T )(7dy)
A,,
A,,
k-l
(45)
The properties of the minors of the secular determinant of an alternant hydrocarbon may again be used to show that the integrals for which the index k is even in (44)and odd in (45) and (46)are zero. It follows that the finite change Aq, is an odd function, of 6au, while AF, and Ap,, are even. Any inequalities between values of any index for two different positions (u),as defined in equations (31) to (34) which arise as first terms of the corresponding infinite series in (44) to (46)) persist term-by-term in the expression for the exact finite changes (Baba, 1957). I n consequence, the broad agreement with experiment found earlier in the description of ionic and radical reactions by the approximate method carries over to the exact form.
R E A C T I V I T Y I N D I C E S I N C O N J U G A T E D MOLECULES
101
Since alternate terms of the expansions (44) to (46) are zero, it follows that the integrands of successive terms differ only by the factor ( A u , U / A ) 2 . This shows how the expansion can be summed to give expressions in closed form, and forms the basis of the formulae given by Fukui et al. (1957a). I n fact Fukui prefers to introduce
which is real, since AU.Ucan be factored into the product of (iy) and a polynomial containing even powers of ( i y ) only. With this notation, equations (44) to (46) take the form (47)
(48) (49) to which may be added the change in energy A&, given by Fukui et al. (1957a)
A& = Su, - In (1 + (SCL,)~y 2 G:] d y
(50)
Corresponding formulae can be deduced for the finite changes obtained by variation of an arbitrary resonance integral Bw (Fukui et al., 1957a). The formulae (47) to (50) provide a means for calculating the exact changes Aq, etc. for any prescribed values of &au,changes which should form the basis of comparisons with experimental data. The correlation between exact and approximate results, already referred to, follows directly from these formulae and was originally emphasized by Fukui et al. (1957a): for a given position u of substitution the term ( A , . / A ) determines the relative magnitudes of changes in q, at different atoms s of a conjugated system in the expressions for both the approximate (36) and exact finite (47) changes, thus ensuring that the same inequalities hold in both cases. Similar properties hold for changes in free valences F,, and bond orders pst. The same formulae may be applied, with the replacement u+r to determine the finite change in rr electron energy due to polarization by an approaching charged reagent. As described earlier, the change Su, is then assumed to be due to the presence of the reagent in the neighbourhood of the atom position r under attack.
102
H . H . GREENWOOD A N D R . MCWEENY
V. THELOCALIZATION METHOD The context in which the localization method is defined has already been explained in the introductory Section I, but although the method itself is well known the physical basis of its premises remains in many ways obscure. I n particular, the concept of “localization of n electrons’’ requires clarification, and the validity of theoretical relationships between reactivity indices of the isolated molecule and localization methods needs further discussion. I n this Section we recall the original statement of the method in some detail, and then review some subsequent developments; the relationship between the two methods is discussed in Section VI. The localization method was originally described by Wheland (1942) with reference to resonance theory, the activated complex being considered as a resonance hybrid consisting of a variable mixture of structures including (I)and (11).
Type (I)describes the substrate with the ionic reagent R close to the carbon atom under attack, but not joined to it by a covalent bond. The structure was assumed to correspond to a “polarized ground state” as considered in the earlier work of Wheland and Pauling (1935), and therefore to the situation envisaged in the isolated molecule approximation. If structure (I) largely determines the form of the activated complex, then the charge distribution and polarizability indices of the substrate would determine the ease of reaction and the preferred positions of attack as in the isolated molecule approach. I n structure (11),on the other hand, the reagent R is joined to the substrate by a covalent bond; this defines a so-called “residual molecule” (RM) as the conjugated system obtained by excluding the position of attack (cf. Section 111).It is supposed that electrophilic attack will occur at positions where a pair of electrons can be easily localized, and nucleophilic a t positions where a (r vacancy” is easily formed. A label z is used in structure (11)to indicate the net charge ( + or - ) which appears within the residual molecule as a result of the corresponding charge displacements. To obtain a practical method, Wheland considered the extreme situation in which structure (11)would outweigh all others in describing the activated complex, and
R E A C T I V I T Y I N D I C E S IN C O N J U G A T E D M O L E C U L E S
103 assumed that the carbon atom under attack would a t this stage be essentially tetrahedral. He then defined the localization energy as the difference in energy of the T electrons in the unperturbed ground state, and the Same number of electrons in structure (11). Thus, for example, Wheland gave for the energy of the six T electrons in the ground state of benzene 6ao + 5.8667 /I and for the energy of the six electrons in structure (11), 6a0+ 4.0174 /I in the three cases corresponding to the localization of 2 , O or 1electrons (cf. Fig. 13, which refers to the general case). The localization energy in each case was then d W = - 1.8493 /I. A fundamental difficulty in Wheland’s approach is that the number of T electrons in I1 may be essentially different from the number in I, for any electrons localized leave the T system to engage in u bonding. Wheland’s procedure therefore amounts to formally assigning an energy a. to each localized electron, corresponding to removal of its contribution to T bonding, without enquiring too closely into the physical nature of the localization; and it is already clear (Fig. 13) that for an alternant molecule the localization energies so defined will be the same for electrophilic or radical attack. Of course, the localized electrons do not really occupy a 2p atomic orbital with energy ao, but any changes arise essentially from u bonding effects and may plausibly be assumed the same for different positions of attack. With this assumption, the localization energy as estimated by Wheland (1942) should properly reflect the differences of activation energies between different positions for any one type of reaction. An alternative prescription for calculating the localization energy has also been widely used, the energy of the 0 , l or 2 localized electrons simply being omitted; and again failure to allocate a realistic energy to the excluded electrons is irrelevant so long as only diflerences of activation energy are being considered. The crux of the argument, in each case, is simply that the whole of the a-bonding rearrangement energy is a “local ” quantity not depending on position of the attacked atom in the framework. At a slightly deeper level, the difficulty of this approach lies in its acceptance of a transition complex in which the original classification into u and 7r electrons has been broken; consequently pure T electron theory is inadequate for the prediction of energy changes, and a complete analysis must await the inclusion of the u bond modifications at the point of attack. Preliminary attempts to include such effects have invoked hyperconjugation (Muller et al., 1954; Fukui et al., 1954a) and other factors (Dewar et al., 1956), but little progress has yet been made towards a more detailed theoretical interpretation based on more complete calculations.
104
H . H . GREENWOOD A N D R . MCWEENY
Here, therefore, we return to the localization theory in its simple form and investigate the utility of localization energies as reactivity indices. Energy level diagrams have frequently been used to indicate occupancy of the orbitals in type I1 structures as follows :
I
-
I
I
I
I
I I I
-
-
i
& RM
(E)
FIG.13. Occupation of energy levels in Wheland structures I1 for (E) electrophilic, (N) nucleophilic, and (R) radical reactions.
I n these diagrams the energy level schemes denoted by RM refer to the residual molecule of an even alternant hydrocarbon, while urdenotes the level associated with an electron localized at position r of attack, this quantity taking thc value uoin Wheland’s formulation. These features of the energy level scheme for residual molecules indicate why, for an even alternant hydrocarbon, there is in general no distinction between Wheland’s localization energies for electrophilic ( E ) , nucleophilic ( N ) and attack, the localized electron(s)and the NBMO of the residual radical (R) molecule having the same energy. Since, however, the assumption u,= uo amounts to little more than an arbitrary fixing of the zero of activation energy, different in the different types of attack, no absolute significance can be attached to the apparent equality of E , N and R localization energies. Only differences for the different positions of attack in areaction of given type are likely to be significant; and the use of localization energies in trying to estimate a given barrier height must be doomed to failure in view of the many energy terms which have been omitted on the grounds that they are likely to be about the same for different positions. We therefore concentrate on the possibility of estimating activation
R E A C T I V I T Y I N D I C E S I N C O N J U G A T E D MOLECULES
105
energy differences for substitution a t different positions in, say, heterocyclics or hydrocarbon derivatives, and to the effects of the heteroatoms or existing substituents in determining their differences. The description is parallel to that for other indices (SectionIV), the alternative procedures involving (A) perturbation theory using a parent hydrocarbon as a starting point and (B) exact solution of the secular problem for the derivative or heterocyclic and for the residual molecules for various positions of attack. The broader questions of the physical interpretation of localization, of its connection with the formal processes introduced in Section 111,and of the mathematical relationship between localization energies and other indices will be taken up in Sections V I and VIII.
A. Analytical Properties of Approximate Methods I n this subsection we consider analytical properties of first- and second-order approximations to the change in localization energies produced by a change Sa, in coulomb integral at a position u of substitution. This change indicates the influence of substituent groups or atoms by determining differences between localization energies in derivatives and in the parent hydrocarbon. Longuet-Higgins (1950a) developed a simple and elegant method for calculating the change in localization energy L, with change in coulomb integral Sa, at any position u, to the first order in Sa,. Let &’ be the r electron energy in an even alternant hydrocarbon and bRM the energy of the electrons in the residual molecule corresponding to localization at the rth atom position. This atom position is denoted by r, since a position of localization is to be identified as a position of attack. Strictly the label r should be added to localization energies throughout the following analysis, but is omitted for simplicity. Let 8’and BkM be the corresponding values when a change Sa, is made in coulomb integral at the uth position, where u is not the position of attack. Then &” = &‘+q,Sau+O(Sa~) and SiM = b R M q,”” Sa, O(Sa3
+
+
by equation (13), where q,, qEMare the charges at atom u in the even alternant hydrocarbon and its residual molecule respectively, and the symbol 0 denotes “order of”. The localization energy L for the alternant is
L
= &‘RY-&‘
and for the derivative
L’
=
biM--b’
106
H . H . GREENWOOD A N D R . MCWEENY
The change 6L in localization energy is then obtained to the first order in &a, as 6L = L ' - L = (qE'-
1)6au
since q, = 1 for the alternant. It is well known (e.g. Coulson and Rushbrooke, 1940) that 9,"" differs from unity by the contribution at the uth atom due to electrons occupying the NBMO ; and that this term may be obtained (Longuet-Higgins, 1950b) by inspection, using only simple arithmetic. We now use the symbols L:, L; and L, to represent the localization energies for electrophilic, nucleophilic and radical attack respectively, at the same atom position r, reintroducing the appropriate label. Thus 6L: = c ~ , S a , (51)
SL, = -c~,Sa, (52) where c,, is the coefficient of $, a t the position of substitution, in the NBMO ($m,say) of the residual molecule. Longuet-Higgins did not treat specifically the case for radical attack, but it is interesting to note that the non-bonding orbital in this situation is singly occupied so that ":9 = 1 at all atoms u of the residual molecule, which shows that SL, (86,) is zero to the first order in 6a,. The second order term is non-zero, so that SL,(6a,) is, like 6F, in the isolated molecule approximation, an even function of 8a,, and therefore independent of the sign of the electronegativity of the substituent relative to carbon.
B. Analytical Properties of Exact Methods The analytical properties of the exact changes in localization energies, of which ( 5 1 ) and ( 5 2 ) represent the first order terms in 6a,, can be obtained by a direct method depending upon the properties of the secular equations (Greenwood, 1952a). The results may be summarized as follows. The changes AL)- and AL; ( A denoting exact changes) in the localization energies for ionic reactions are odd functions of the parameter change &,, and the relationship
dL,+(&xu) = AL; ( - Sa,)
(53)
holds for localization at any atom r defining a residual molecule. I n contrast, the change AL, in the localization energy for radical reactions has the property dL,(Ga,) = dL,( -6aJ (54)
REACTIVITY INDICES I N CONJUQATED MOLECULES
107
so that AL, is independent of the sign of the electronegativity change relative to carbon. The predictions of the perturbation analysis are therefore confirmed by the exact theory; furthermore, the analytical dependence of indices used in the localization method upon the sign of the change in electronegativity relative to carbon, is analogous to that of corresponding indices used in the isolated molecule method (Section IV). VI. RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN
THE
INDICES
The general agreement obtained between the two basic methods of approach in predicting the active positions of alternant hydrocarbons was originally interpreted as a confirmation of the validity of the theoretical models on which they were based (Wheland, 1942). However, the results of numerical calculations on large numbers of different molecules suggested that the various indices were mathematically related and therefore bound to be in agreement. Later, other reactivity indices, such as the “superdelocalizability ” (Fukui et al., 1954a) and “2 values ” (Brown, 1969)-which arise from variants of the two basic methods and are discussed in Section VII-were also found to show essentially the same pattern of agreement. These similarities between the predictions of different methods have been noted on many occasions by various authors and are summarized in detail in Streitwieser (1961). I n the case of the alternant hydrocarbons it is therefore seldom possible to say that agreement between predictions and observed reaction rates, based on a given index, points unambiguously towards a particular reaction mechanism. On the other hand, it is clear from previous sections (11,I V and V) that such ambiguities may often be partially resolved by considering how the indices are changed by the effect of heteroatoms or inductive substituents. For example, in Section IIB it became evident that the theoretical interpretation of the roles played by the various indices was in harmony with experimental evidence based on the reactions of benzene derivatives, We now show that for even alternant hydrocarbons the observed correlations among reactivity indices can in fact be ascribed to analytical properties of the equations from which they are determined. The existence of mathematical relationships among the indices follows essentially from the contour integral methods referred to in Section IV, but before sketching the theory it is useful to make some preliminary qualifications concerning the method of approach. At this stage we shall in fact consider the relationships from a purely mathematical standpoint, regardless of whether the limiting processes used in establishing them are physically realistic. This does not appear to inhibit the usefulness of the
108
H . H . GREENWOOD A N D R . MCWEENY
approach, because here the aim is merely to trace the relationships between numerical quantities calculated using different prescriptions. It has already been remarked that the problem of interpreting the localization processes, and in particular of allocating an appropriate energy to the localized electrons is a difficult one. I n developing the theory, therefore, it is important to remember that the physical plausibility of any of the processes envisaged is not a t this stage an issue. The analytical relationships depend for proof upon expressions for the finite changes in n electron energy developed in Section 111,which will be considered in the compact form given by Fukui et al. (1957a). I n the treatment of heterolytic reactions of alternant hydrocarbons, a change Sa,in coulomb integral is assumed to occur at the position r of attack and the replacement u+r must therefore be made in the formulae of Sections I V and V, which refer to the change Sa, due to a substituent or heteroatom. The corresponding finite changedbis then given by (equation(50))
and the corresponding approximate form is, by equation (18),
where q, = 1for an even alternant hydrocarbon, and the self-polarizability
from equation (36),with s and u replaced by r. The first point to note is the appearance of the function G, in the integrands in (55) and (56). This permits the comparison of magnitudes for different positions r and s of attack in the same molecule. Thus if nr,r
r
=8,8
(57)
we have, for a given change Sa,=Sa,=Su, db,(Sa,) 5 db,(Sa,)
(58)
the inequalities being taken algebraically. The inequalities given here disagree with those given by Fukui et al. (1957a) which seem to need rather more careful consideration. For example, the self-polarizabilities T , , ~are negative quantities so that (57) implies ln,,,l 2 1n8,,1. Since the second term on the right hand side of (55) depends on Sa2, and carries a negative sign, its contribution is always negative. Thus when SCL(= Sa, = Sa,) is negative, corresponding to electrophilic attack, the
REACTIVITY INDICES I N CONJUGATED MOLECULES
109
negative contribution is increased, and the total change A 8 is negative. Then (58) implies IAd,(W I L I A & S ( W I (59) which means the lowering of n electron energy is greatest at the position of absolute largest self-polarizability. When Sarispositive, corresponding to nucleophilic attack, the first term on the right hand side of ( 5 5 ) , which dominates, is diminished by the negative second term. Then (58)implies that IA8r(Sa)I 5 I d ~ s ( W l
(60)
which means that the raising of n electron energy is least at the position of absolute largest self-polarizability. These results are not altogether clear from the original formulation (Fukui et al., 1957a). We can now consider the theoretical relationships between reactivity indices of the isolated molecule and localization methods. First we quote a generalized definition of the localization energy at atom r given by Fukui et al. (1957a)
L, (Fukui)
m
= 2 j=1
(6: - ej)
+ ( 2 - v ) ( a ,- EL)
(61)
Here 6; are the energy levels of the residual molecule defined by isolating atom r, and ej those of the parent alternant hydrocarbon; j = m indicates the non-bonding orbital which contains v electrons ( v = 0 , 1 , 2 for electrophilic, radical and nucleophilic attack) ; and a, is the coulomb integral for a localized electron on atom r. This quantity differs from the localizof Wheland in allowing the localized electrons to take ation energy (L,) an energy ar#ao. Its meaning is clear from Fig. 14 from which the formula is easily derived. To obtain L,it is necessary only to subtract ( 2 - v )a, (i.e. to remove the localized electrons with energy a,) and to add ( 2 - v ) a. (i.e. to give them energy a. instead). Thus the Wheland localization energy is
L,
=
L,(Fukui)+ ( 2 - v ) (ao- a,)
It is now possible to obtain L,as the result of an actual limiting process of the kind considered in Section 11; for the orbitals which result on letting a,-+ k co are identical with those of the residual molecule by itself, with energies depicted in Fig. 14, while the energy of the electrons removed from conjugation is given the standard value a. after completing the limiting process. To allow for a,-+ k co, the equation may be written more cautiously
L, = ar-trt 2t
{~d,(~,)+(2-v)(ao-~r)} 4)
(62)
110
H . H . G R E E N W O O D A N D R. M C W E E N Y
where A&,(a,) is the actual energy change defined by ( 5 5 ) for the hypothetical perturbation ao+ar and is thus a continuous function of a,. We note also that L, (Fukui), allowing a finite ar # a,,,may be written in the form (62) using a in place of the variable ar, and then putting a, in place of uo.
-
I
I
I
I
I
I I I
-
UO-_
I
ek RM
(El
FIQ.14. Occupation of energy levels after localization. The position of a, is purely schematic; in general a7 # ao.
It is also possible to correlate differences of localization energy with differences of atom polarizability. For suppose we consider electrophilic attack on two alternative positions r, s with a,, as-+- co ; then from(62)
L:-L$ =
9t m
a+-
(db,(a)-db,(a)}
(63)
but if nT,,> ns,8the right hand side will be positive for all values and L f > L $ . A similar treatment may be applied in the case u,,a,++a, hence rr,? > n,,, implies
Lf > L$ L; > L,
(64)
The existence of these inequalities is less surprising when it is remembered that the early stages of the localization process described above correspond precisely to polarization of the isolated molecule, and that the subsequent changes in levels and orbitals, as discussed in Section 111,follow essentially by an analytic continuation. It follows that predictions of the sequence of active centres, in an even alternant hydrocarbon, based on localization energies must agree with those based on polarizabilities. This
R E A C T I V I T Y I N D I C E S I N C O N J U G A T E D MOLECULES
111
is not the case for other types of system and it is therefore extremely valuable to be able to estimate the effect of heteroatoms and substituents by the methods of Section I V (for T,,,) and Section V (for L,). It must be stressed that the precise nature of the limiting process u,+ f 03 is not in question; it is sufficient that this leads in the limit to the localized orbitals envisaged in the Wheland-Fukui definition (61), as described in Section 111. Fukui et al. (1957a) also derived a further important relationship connecting the free valence and the localization energy L,. I n this case the changes imposed were not in coulomb integrals, but in the two resonance integrals pTPand /Ir4 connecting the atom position r under attack with its two carbon neighbours p and q. The proof follows a similar pattern to that which applied in the case of a change Su, in coulomb integral. The free valence enters the expression for the approximate change Sb in T electron energy due to changes Sp,=Sp,, (=Sp) in the resonance integrals /Irp =pPg=/I involving the position of attack r through equation (16)
6 6 = 2 (<3 -F,)
Sp
(16)
The formula for the corresponding finite change d b was given by Fukui et al. in the closed form
Now the free valencep, can be expressed in the integral form (Fukui et al. 1957s)
which, as before, provides a basis for establishing a relationship between F,, F , on the one hand and db,, on the other, according to the magnitudes of G, and G,. This correlation is independent of the magnitudes which makes of S/3 and therefore holds for the limiting case a/? = -#I /I=p,,=&=O. It is clear that this condition corresponds to isolating atom r from the rest of the conjugated system, so that db,(p)-+L,as /I-+O. The correlation between the free valences and localization energies at any two atoms r and s can then be expressed in the form
F , > F , implies L, < L,
(66)
During the corresponding localization process, in which p+O for the two bonds connecting atom r to the rest of the molecule, the MO's for the innermost pair of orbitals change as described in Section I11 (Fig. 11).
112
H. H . G R E E N W O O D A N D R. M C W E E N Y
There are no charge shifts in this process, q8remaining equal to unity at all atoms. The limiting n electron distribution therefore indicates localization of a single n electron at the position of attack as required for the case of a radical reaction. The inequalities (64) and (66)thus cover all three cases envisaged in the localization theory.
VII. FRONTIER ORBITALAND CHARGETRANSFER THEORIES The frontier orbital approach (Fukui et al., 1952,1954b) has met with considerable success in so far as frontier orbital charges correlate well with experimental data. The performance of these indices is often superior to that of others, with the possible exception of localization energies. It is, however, difficult to give meaning to the correlation since physical interpretations of the role of the frontier electrons in reaction mechanisms are often obscure, and attempts to give substance to Fukui’s hypothesis have frequently embodied questionable procedures or models. For electrophilic reactions, the “frontier orbital ” is the highest occupied orbital of the unperturbed ground state of the molecular system under attack, and the frontier electron “density” f,. (or, more properly, “charge”) is the contribution to q,. arising from the pair of electrons occupying this orbital. The frontier orbital for nucleophilic attack is defined as the lowest empty orbital of the same system, and the frontier electron charge f,.is the contribution to qr that would result from double occupancy of this vacant orbital. For radical attack both orbitals are taken into account, and the frontier electron charge is that which would result from one electron in each. The frontier electron charge f r is then used as an index to predict the active positions in a given molecule. Unlike other indices, however, the frontier charge cannot be used for comparative purposes amongst different molecules, forfr clearly becomes smaller as the frontier orbital becomes more delocalized-as in a large molecule. Whereas the isolated molecule and localization methods were based on fairly well defined physical models, the basis for the conception of frontier electrons was slight. Originally they were conceived as participating in active triplet states (Fukui et al., 1952),then as being intimately concerned in the formation of u bonds at the position of attack (Fukui et al., 195413). Later (Fukui et al., 1954a, 1957a) a formal theoretical development associated the frontier electron density with T electron energy changes similar to those used in conventional isolated molecule approximations, but now embodying the notion of hyperconjugation at the position of attack. We sketch briefly Fukui’s analysis. The atomic orbital basis of the n electron system is assumed to be increased by the
R E A C T I V I T Y I N D I C E S I N C O N J U G A T E D MOLECULES
113
addition of a pseudo rr type orbital +* associated with the attacking reagent X and the hydrogen atom H at the position r of attack.
FIQ.15
A roughly symmetrical disposition of the centres X and H about the plane of the molecule is assumed, and the pseudo (or “group”) orbital has the form 4; where 4: = ( 4 X - $ H ) / & (67) and 4x and tjH are valence orbitals associated with atoms X and H . The trigonal arorbital of the carbon atom is assumed to be concerned with a-bonding with the symmetrical combination
4:
= (4X
+$ H ) / d 2
(68)
The coulomb integral associated with 4: is a* and the resonance integral between 4; and dr is 8*. The secular determinant defining the augmented system takes the form 0 0
0
0
a*-€
a11-e
p12
821
aZ2-E
. . .p* ... ...
= o
(69)
8* a r r -E where the leading minor refers to the molecule under attack. Fukui used perturbation methods, assuming 8* to be small, to derive an approximate expression for the change 8 6 due to hyperconjugation, or augmentation of the T electron system :
86=
2 j=l
(vj-v)c;j ej - a*
j?*2 + v(a* - a x )
The index jis taken over all MO’s of the molecule under attack, and vj is the occupancy; v is 0, 1 or 2 according as the reagent is electrophilic, radical or nucleophilic. The coefficient of /3*2in (70) is itself independent of 8*,and is thus merely an expansion coefficient, analogous to those of
114
H . H . GREENWOOD A N D R . MCWEENY
the isolated-moleculemethod. The coefficient depends, however, through a*,upon the nature of the attacking reagent. At this point, Fukui et al. (1954a) define a quantity, the superdelocalizability S,, by the expression 8, =
2
j=1
(vj-v)c?j Ej
- uo
(71)
which differs from the coefficient in (70) in replacing a* by the standard coulomb integral ao. The index S,, like those of the isolated-molecule approximation, is then independent both of the perturbation ,8* and of intrinsic properties of the attacking reagent ; that is, it can be defined, like other indices, in terms of the properties of the substrate alone. It is then argued that since Iej- aol is least for the levels of the two frontier orbitals, which are nearest to the zero of energy ao,the summation S, is dominated by the corresponding terms, which (from the properties of alternants) yield :f where Af = )ef - a o / Si = 2 c(72) hf and f indicates a frontier orbital. It is claimed that this equation then gives a theoretical foundation for the frontier orbital hypothesis. It is clear that there are a number of questionable steps in the treatment. I n particular the replacement of a* by a0 is wholly responsible for the special significance given to the frontier electrons; for equation (70) shows that if a* is close to any ej ofthe substrate, the correspondingorbital term would tend to dominate the sum. Yet, even if we grant that the determinant (69)with p* small could represent a model for the transition state complex, it is not difficult to show that the sum of terms neglected in passing from equation (71) to (72)is often larger than#: itself. Clearly, the significanceof the frontier electrons cannot be established unequivocally on this basis. Fukui et al. (1957b)have developed further the idea of charge transfer through hyperconjugation a t the position of attack. Noting that, for electrophilic attack, this mechanism would result in the transfer of two electrons from the substrate to the reactant, they propose that the coulomb integral of the pseudo T orbital should vary, to prevent a large effect of this kind, from the value u* to Ef, the energy of the frontier orbital, at which stage normal conjugation may begin to operate. It is not clear how the assumed change in a* to ef is to be made compatible with the adjustment of a* to a,,employed in the definition of the superdelocalizctbility. Although an analysis is constructed on these ideas, the approach seems to be empirical and speculative. Further comment will be reserved for the general discussion of Section VIII.
REACTIVITY I N D I C E S IN CONJUGATED MOLECULES
115
Brown (1959) has presented a charge transfer model of the transition state for electrophilic reactions which differs appreciably from that proposed by Fukui and his collaborators and leads to the definition of a new reactivity index termed the “ 2 value ”. The model is based on a more conventional formulation of the charge transfer mechanism, which avoids the complete transfer of electrons associated with v=O,1,2 in Fukui’s model. There is no dependence on the formation of a pseudo 7~ orbital in the transition state, nor is hyperconjugation invoked. A wave function @c.t. for a charge transfer complex is written as a linear combination of a wave function@odescribingthe unperturbed ground state of the molecule under attack, and a function Q 1 which differsfrom@oin the replacement of one of its orbitals by the valence orbital of the reagent. Thus the wave function Qc.t. = a@,+b@,
(73)
describes a condition of partial transfer of one electron from the substrate to the reagent. The method used bears a close resemblance to that introduced by Dewar (1949) in consideringthe “ connection’’ of two 7~ electron systems; but this is purely formal, since the Q0, are here molecular wave functions rather than orbitals. Let be the ground state of the molecule under attack, and represent the configuration obtained by transfer of an electron from the ith occupied MO to the vacant orbital of an attacking electrophilic reagent. Then a general wave function @c.t. for describing one-electron charge transfers can be written as the linear combination of configurations @c.t.
=
ao@o+al@i,+a~@,+...
(74)
which gives rise to a configuration interaction problem, with eigenstates given by
Hoo Hoo-EE H10 H10 H20 H20
HOl H11-E H 11-E
HO2
HO2
HOl
... ...
Hoj Hoj
==oo
H22-E H 22-E
Hjo Hjo
... ...
Hjj--EE
Hjj
(75)
where Hij is the matrix element between @i and Ojof a Hamiltonian operator #* representing the charge transfer complex. I n the oneelectron scheme, this operator is regarded as a sum of terms, one for each electron, X‘* = h ( l ) +h(2) . . . . The approximations of Huckel theory
+
116
H . H . GREENWOOD A N D R . MCWEENY
(e.g. neglect of overlap)then ensure that the matrix elements H,(i #j# 0 ) are all zero, and with the substitutions
w = H0,-E Hoo-Hjj
Aj =
(76)
equation (75) then leads to
The remaining matrix elements are
Hoj = inwhich @,
=
I
dSjd7
dSO&'+
(78)
{ $ ~ ( 1 ) ~ ~. .( .2 ~) j ( ~ ) ~1)j ... ( ~~+ ~ ( ~ - l ) ~ , ( ~ ) }
and
+ {. .
.y$(U)$j(U+
1).
.
where t,hi is an occupied MO of the molecule under attack $i
=
2 c,i+a
the bar denoting j? spin, and its absence u spin, and c $ ~ is the vacant orbital of the electrophilic reagent. With the Huckel approximations already introduced, H o jreduces to the single term Hoj =
d/5~,.j+ei@*#,dr
= &crjPer
(79)
where peris the resonance integral associated with +e and the r orbital 4, a t the position r of attack. This quantity relates to some characteristic separation of molecule and reagent, corresponding to the postulated transition state and per may thus be written in terms of the standard integral Po in the form Per =
gbP0
(80)
where g$ is a multiplying factor characterizing the type of transition complex. On substitution, equation (77) takes the form
The diagonal elements dj=Roo- H j jrelate to the formal transfer of an electron from the j t h MO of the molecule under attack to the vacant
REACTIVITY I N D I C E S IN CONJUGATED MOLECULES
117
orbital of the electrophile, which can be approximated, in the usual way, by comparing the ionization energy Ij of the j t h MO with the electron affinity A * of the electrophile
Aj
A*-Ij Now Ij can be expressed in terms of Po as ,w
(82)
Ij = ao-kjpo (83) and for convenience A* can be written in similar units, and with respect to the same origin, as Therefore where
is a pure number. If W is also written in the same units as
W = -2po equation (81)becomes
(87)
and the most positive value of 2 then corresponds to the most stable charge transfer complex derived by mixing the configurationsof equation (74). I n principle this defines the 2 value for a given position r of attack, but Brown has found that configurations arising from replacements of orbitals other than the highest occupied, that is the frontier orbital, make a small, and virtually negligible contribution to the lowest charge transfer state. Therefore all terms except the frontier orbital (j =f) term in (88) are dropped, and the 8,value is then obtained from the resulting simple expression 2, = Yf+ 2 g t (c%/ Yf) (89) Brown concludes, therefore, that the frontier orbital density distribution c,: determines the position of attack. The concept is in many ways attractive, and is based upon less speculative applications of quantum mechanical ideas than those described earlier in this section, but it does not result in any form of chemical bonding in the usual sense either by partial or complete u bonds or v bonds. It would seem to be, in fact, more appropriate in describing stable v complexes as visualized by Mulliken (1950) and Dewar (1951). The role of the frontier orbitals in providing the configuration that
118
H . H . GREENWOOD AND R . MCWEENY
contributes the greatest weight to the most stable charge transfer state is fairly obvious from the equations : but, although the mechanism of charge transfer complexing has long been associated with the idea of an ionization, it must be stressed that an actual ionization process is not involved.
VIII. THEPHYSICAL BASISOF REACTMTYINDICES The previous sections have been concerned mainly with the definition and analytical properties of reactivity indices relating to various simplified theoretical models and with relationships amongst them. Effects such as polarization and localization, which undoubtedly occur, have been discussed in terms of the indices, but difficulties in relating these effects to the various stages of a real reaction process have also become apparent (e.g. localization as discussed in Section V ) ; and when the physical significance of the indices is investigated more closely, it appears that there are comparatively few criteria upon which an evaluation can be made. The correlations between numerical values of the indices and experimental data provide the most satisfactory criterion, a t the lowest level, but the introduction of new indices, based on rather different physical models, that invariably correlate equally well, frequently obscures earlier hypotheses. Nevertheless a good deal can be learned about the role of reactivity indices from the theoretical background already discussed, especially by reference to recent experimental work. A good correlation between theoretically predicted sequences of active centres and observed sequences is, of course, the ultimate test of success, but ignorance of the reaction mechanism involved, and the consequent use of a variety of hypothetical models, has been seen to lead to some ambiguity. To obtain more detailed information about the role of the various indices, it is necessary to refer to experimental work, particularly that of recent years. The following sources of information and methods of analysing postulated reaction mechanisms seem to be particularly relevant : (i) experimental work revealing the existence of .Ir-complexes and a-complexes as reaction intermediates. This stems mainly from work on reaction kinetics, but spectroscopic evidence is also important; (ii) theoretical considerations of the plausibility of proposed mechanisms.
It will not be possible to describe the extensive and stimulating experimental work that has done much to clarify the role of r-complexes
R E A C T I V I T Y I N D I C E S I N C O N J U G A T E D MOLECULES
119
and a-complexes as possible intermediates in reaction mechanisms (Dewar, 1951; Dewar et al., 1956b; Brown et al., 1952, 1953; Stock and Brown, 1963; Melander, 1950; Olah, 1958,1961 ;Berliner, 1964), but it is important that theoretical methods of approach should take cognizance of these significant developments. First, it is necessary to distinguish the two types of complex envisaged. A a-complex structure (Stock and Brown, 1963) for substitution by the electrophile X+takes the form
FIQ.16
and is essentially similar to the Wheland structure (Fig. 12) used in the localization method, except that i t receives a more literal interpretation as an actual system, rather than a structure in the sense of resonance theory; it involves formation of a a-type bond with X a t the position of attack by means of two electrons withdrawn from the 7-electron system, with the remaining 7-electrons confined to the residual molecule. In the general definition of n-complexes (Dewar, 1951) the electrophile X+ forms a loose addition complex
tx+ FIQ.17
with the whole n-electron charge cloud, and is not associated with a particular carbon atom. Similar complexes are well known involving aromatic molecules and various electron acceptors, such as halogens, silver ions and larger systems such as picrates, trinitrobenzenes and so on. I n general, n-complexes are conceived as low-energy intermediates, that precede the formation of high-energy a-complex intermediates ;these are associated with the transition state configuration which then “decomposes” to give products (Stock and Brown; 1963).
A. Polarization and Electrophilic Xubstitution From the various accounts that have been given of the role of n-complexes and a-complexes as possible intermediates in reaction mechanisms, that described by Olah et al. (1961)is selectedfor special attention, since it
120
H . H . GREENWOOD A N D R . MCWEENY
embodies most of the currently accepted interpretations (see Stock and Brown, 1963;Berliner, 1964),and, more particularly because it includes the notion of localized .rr-complexes,which appear to find a natural place in the theory. Several descriptions of the process of addition of the electrophile X+ to aromatic substrates, based on kinetic and other evidence have been given and most versions agree that the potential energy surface does not consist of a simple barrier, but involves details relating to metastable intermediates.
Reocfion co-ordinofe
FIQ.18. Energy variation in electrophilic reactiom following Olah.
The form of potential energy curve deduced by Olah from kinetic evidence on the nitration of benzene, and some alkyl- and halo-benzenes, by nitronium ions derived from NO; B F r is shown in Fig. 18. I n this diagram, position D is associated with a localized structure analogous to that of Fig. 16 and 19b.
The electronic configurations in the transition states C and E, through which D is formed and destroyed, are also assumed to resemble D in electron configuration, in accordance with Hammond’s hypothesis (1955). Position B is associated with r-complexing between NO; BF4and aromatic substrate, but a particular feature of Olah’s interpretation is the recognition of localized wcomplexing at particular atoms with high r-electron charges. The reactions concerned are fast, and show little
REACTIVITY INDICES IN CONJUGATED MOLECULES
121
substrate selectivity, since the rates of nitration are almost the same for various derivatives. Nevertheless, there is orientation, and the isomer distributions are substantially the same as for conventional nitrations. Olah interpreted the low substrate selectivity as due to a form of rcomplexing involving the complete rr-electron cloud, but differing from Dewar’s model (1951)in that the r-complexing is assumed to be localized at atoms of high rr-electron charge. This interpretation appears to be necessary in order to explain the observed orientations. Now this idea should clearly find a place in the isolated molecule picture where, if Olah’s , ~ indicate the interpretation is to be followed, the charge qr and T ~would energy of attraction, including polarization, according to (18) 66 = qr6ar + &rr,r8a; with which the reagent X+ would adhere at position r . The physical
nature of the problem suggests, as emphasized previously, that the polarization effect must be appreciable in this r-complexing process. The structure used by Olah to describe the r-complexing is that of Fig. 19a; the r-electron charge distribution cannot be uniform over the molecule in the presence of the NO: ion, and therefore charge displacements have been included to represent polarization in the figures. The inclusion of polarization simply extends Olah’sinterpretation which assumed that the charge qr would determine favourable positions of rr-complexing. The interpretation gives a new significance to the basic equation (18) used in the isolated molecule method, and a more satisfactory explanation of the role of the reactivity indices qr and rrr9r . The localized wcomplex is thus associated with the partial localization of an electron pair at the position of attack, and a charge distribution in the residual molecule already resembling that of the a-complex. Olah et a.2. (1962a,b)include in the barrier leading from A to the localized r-complex represented by B in Fig. 18, anactivation energy required to break the NO: BF,--solvent complex, the potential energy referring to the complete system of “ion pair plus molecule”, with solvent effects to some extent included. Thus theessentialdepression of r-electron energy (equation (18))due to polarization leads to a metastable r-complex in Olah’s scheme, when balanced against the energy required to detach X+ from the solvent. The main barrier can be associated with separation of the ion pair and changes of hybridization that involve the orbital partially localized at the position of attack, and lead to the formation of the a-bonded transition state complex ;it is the energy changes during this phase of the reaction which, in the localization theory (Section V), are assumed to be substantially similar for different positions of attack. It is important to recognize that the description given above goes 6
122
H . H . GREENWOOD A N D R . MCWEENY
somewhat further than that of Section I1A, though both are based upon equation (18),which provides a fair description of thepolarization process. It also gives substance to the part actually played by the qr and T?,?,a desirable feature of any theoretical description. Obviously they can provide no more than an approximate measure that is useful for purposes of prediction in comparative studies. What is important from the interpretive point of view is that the simple theory provides a general guide through which it is possible to recognize that energy changes and charge shifts due to a normal physical polarization process provide a realistic account of localized .rr-complexesas deduced experimentally, in which appropriate valence conditions are provided in the molecular substrate at the position of attack.
B. The Structure of a-Complex Intermediates The formation of o-complexes as metastable intermediates is essentially linked to the idea of a change from trigonal towards a tetrahedral form of hybridization at the position r of attack; the change is formally translated in the theory into reductions in the resonance integrals between r andits two neighbouring atomsp and q ; this leads to an “interruption” in the path of conjugation that isolates atom r from its corresponding residual molecule. I n heterolytic reactions, this process follows polarization, represented approximately by equation (1S), which occurs a t distances of separation larger than those at which hybridization changes become operative. I n the case of homolytic reactions, polarization is either non-existent or small, and orbital localization is supposed to arise purely from changes in hybridization initiated by a neighbouring reagent; the localization of orbitals associated with this process was described by case (iii)in Section I11and developed in Section VI. According to equation (16) of the isolated molecule method, the .rr-electron energy increases by an amount given approximately by (8s = sg, = Sg), which suggests that localized .rr-complexes are unlikely in homolytic reactions. Thus the same energy levels and orbitals of the residual molecule in the a-complexes are obtained as the limits of three distinct physical processes ; for electrophilic reactions the energy levels are lowered towards those of the residual molecule, and the level associated with the localized orbital emerges, before hybridization changes become operative, from below the “band” of energy levels; for nucleophilic reactions the levels are raised, and the localized level emerges similarly from above the “band” ;and for radical reactions the occupied levels are raised, the unoccupied lowered, as a consequence of hybridization 6 6 = 2(d3-P,)sg
REACTIVITY I N D I C E S I N CONJUGATED MOLECULES
123
changes, and the localized orbital is associated with a level at the centre of the “band ”. The remaining distinction resides in the occupancy of the localized orbital which participates in changes of hybridization at the position of attack, and which automatically satisfies the valency requirements of the attacking reagent in the three types of reaction. I n contrast, these conditions are imposed in the formulation of the localization method when defining Wheland structures. The localization energies L,f,L; and L,obviously apply to corresponding a-complexesin which the energies of localized electrons involved ultimately in a-bonding are formally set equal to (Section VI). Thus reactivity indices of the two basic methods, the isolated molecule (sub-section A) and the localization method, fit naturally into the physical pattern described in terms of n- and a-complexing. A case for the frontier orbital hypothesis is more difficult to establish on similar physical grounds. For both electrophilic and nucleophilic attack the frontier orbitals are amongst those which are “repelled ” from the position under attack and become increasingly associated with the residual molecule. It appears therefore that no physical significance can be attached to the fact that the numerical values of frontier orbitals in the molecule under attack predict the active positions successfully. On the other hand, when no polarization occurs, as in free radical reactions, the frontier orbitals are precisely those that combine to form a localized orbital at the position of attack. It seems logical, therefore, to bestow some significance on the frontier orbitals in the case of free radical reactions only. It will be noted that the remaining reactivity indices, the superdelocalizability S, and the 2, value, that have been specially identified with frontier orbitals, are defined within a context which ignores polarization. Charge shifts are derived from these forms of definition, but these do not result from appropriate representations of the field of approaching charged reagents. Apart from difficulties, previously discussed, concerning the definition of the superdelocalizability, the validity of the models upon which these indices are based is, therefore, open to question. Both the “hyperconjugation” effect that forms the basis of the definition ofS,, and the charge transfer basis for Z, apply at distances of separation of the order of one to two bond lengths whereas polarization, which is ignored, is already appreciable at several bond lengths. Mulliken’s model of the transition state (Pickett et al., 1953; Muller et al., 1954) is related indirectly to the structure of a-complexes. It is based on the idea of hyperconjugation effects stabilizing the transition state, and, although not directly invoking reactivity indices, must be mentioned as perhaps the most satisfactory description given so far.
124
H . H . GREENWOOD A N D R . MCWEENY
Mulliken draws on the equivalence between two descriptions of a localized double bond, as (a) a 7 and u bond superposed and (b) two “bent” u bonds, as applied, for example, to the case of bonding in ethylene (Hall and Lennard-Jones, 1951). I n the present case a pseudo-double bond is visualized involving the rr orbital c $ ~ on the atom r under attack and a pseudo-rr orbital 4; formed by combining the valence orbitals of the reagent X+ and the hydrogen atom attached to atom r , as described in Section VII. The equivalent structures are then
(a)
FIG.20
in which (A)represents a CJ and pseudo-7 bond superposed and (B) corresponds to the a-complexversion of the transition state. Mulliken emphasized that the equivalence holds only for a high degree of double bond character in the superposed u and pseudo-7 bond of structure (A) and imposed a large negative value (in fact ,3*=2P0) on the resonance integral connecting bTand 4: to ensure that this condition was fulfilled. It was also pointed out that hyperconjugation itself, in the transition state, is meaningful only when the interacting 7-electron systems largely preserve their identity, and this again is ensured by taking a large neg!,* which preserves 7 character in the pseudo-doublebond. ative value of 3 A number of interesting refinements were introduced, notably a degree of self-consistency, but only the more general properties of the model, relevant to our present discussion, can be considered here. By imposing a large negative value /?*= 2p0, solutions are obtained analogous to that described in case (iv) in Section I11; the lowest and uppermost levels break away from below and above the other levels, the corresponding MO’s becoming roughly equivalent to bonding and antibonding orbitals associated with the pseudo-double bond. This is, in fact, obvious from the alternative interpretation (in Hiickel approximation, rather than Mulliken’s refined treatment) of hyperconjugation introduced between a pseudo-double bond with energy levels f 2.000,3,, and the residual molecule for benzene with levels & 1.732,3,,, & 1.000,30 and 0.0,3,; a simple energy level diagram shows that when hyperconjugation is included the
REACTIVITY
INDICES IN CONJUGATED MOLECULES
125
pseudo-double bond is largely associated with the lowest bonding level with an energy lower than 28,. Mulliken’s model is entirely compatible with the descriptions given previously in this Section, since charge shifts that result from polarization are already taken into account in forming the a-complex by subsequent changesin hybridization. Fukui’s model, upon which the definition of the superdelocalizability is based, resembles Mulliken’s only in the use of a pseudo-.rr orbital cj:, and the formulation of the “ hyperconjugation” problem is quite different, since P* is taken by Fukui to be small, so that S, can be defined by perturbation formulae. I n particular, the bonding of the pseudo-.rr orbital cj: in Fukui’s model primarily involves the least bound, or frontier orbitals, whereas in Mulliken’s model the most bound MO is involved.
C . Some Related Topics 1. Spectroscopic evidence for o-complexes Important information has been obtained on the possible structure of reaction intermediates from spectroscopic studies of protonated aromatic molecules (Gold and Tye, 1952; Reid, 1954). Gold and Tye (1952) measured the U.V. absorption spectrum of anthracene in concentrated sulphuric acid under reversible conditions, and showed that the spectrum differs from that in inert solvents, resembling that of diphenylethylene (Fig. 2lb) in concentrated sulphuric acid. The similarities were attributed to proton addition a t a mesoanthrenic position which by “extracting ” this position from conjugation gives a residual molecule analogous to that of the cation formed by protonation of diphenylethylene as shown.
@p& H H
Descriptions of the changes in spectroscopicproperties show important differences according as the process leading to localization of electrons required for bond formation with the added proton is attributed to polarization or to “interruption” of the path of conjugation. Figures 228 and b represent part of the energy level diagram for the two cases respectively, and the relevant excitation, in the simple Hiickel approximation, from the highest occupied to the lowest unoccupied orbital is
126
H . H . GREENWOOD AND R . MCWEENY
illustrated (i) for the molecule under attack, (ii) at a stage of partial localization, and (iii) for complete localization where the excitation refers to transitions between .rr-levelsof the residual molecule. An interpretation based upon “interruption” of the path of conjugation would lead to singly occupied degenerate orbitals, one on the residual molecule and one at the point of localization. The latter would not suffice for formation of an incipient a-bond, and the spectrum would correspond to a neutral residual molecule. The a-complexing usually
(0)
(b)
FIG.22. Changes in spectrum due to (a) polarization (b) “interruption” of path of conjugation.
assumed, however, corresponding to a point near the maximum of the potential barrier (D in Fig. 18), would follow the polarization process described in Section VIIIA and is consistent with the observed spectral changes. Whether or not the attached proton does actually form a acomplex is debatable : the reversibility observed in the dilution experiments of Gold and Tye might in fact lend more support to the idea of a localized .rr-complex,for which the potential barrier involved (A to B in Fig. 18) would be much smaller. On the other hand, provided two electrons have been localized at the point of attack, the further change towards tetrahedral hybridization (i.e. a-complexing) is not ruled out, and there is some evidence from the NMR experiments of MacLean et al. (1958) that the two hydrogen atoms are indeed equivalent. Further experimental work could throw light on this important question.* *See the Chapter by Perkampue in the present Volume,
REACTIVITY INDICES
IN CONJUGATED MOLECULES
127
2. flurface states in solids
Surface states in solids have been intuitively associated with mechanisms of catalysis in chemical reactions and are, therefore, relevant to the subject of this review. Moreover, the formal treatment of surface states by the tight-binding approximation (Goodwin, 1939 ; Baldock, 1952 ; Grimley, 1958) corresponds closely to the techniques used in the isolated molecule method for conjugated molecules, and many of the qualitative ideas described previously can be carried over to the theory of surface states. Such ideas form a useful background that should assist the development of suitable models for catalytic mechanisms, which are still in the earliest stages of formulation (Grimley, 1958). It is possible to use energy level diagrams and corresponding orbital properties, as described in Section 111, to obtain a simple and direct understanding of the results obtained by more complete methods of analysis; these concern, in the main, the origin, enumeration and classification of surface states. A brief indication of the method of application, and the form of results will be given. Coulomb integrals a. and resonance integrals are employed for all atoms and nearest neighbours in the bulk of the solid, and surface potentials are introduced by changes in the parameters, usually confined to coulomb integrals
so
ar = ao+Sar
(90)
where r is an atom in a surface layer. Consider, as a simple model, a linear chain of N atoms, each with one valence atomic orbital, such that all coulomb integrals and resonance integrals are initially equal to a. and Po respectively. Then a band of N energy levels with N corresponding “molecular ’’ orbitals is obtained from the equations of the tight binding approximation, which are completely equivalent to the secular equations of (8) when the values a. and are inserted. Let the coulomb integral of the end atom, r = 1 , now be changed according to (go), where 6a, increases or decreases from zero. At a particular threshold value for 6 q , a single level emerges from below or above the band according aa 6al is negative or positive; the remaining levels, according to the rules mentioned in Section 111, tend towards those of the “residual molecule’’ which is the linear chain excluding the end atom r = 1, These levels remain, therefore, within the band, as originally defined. The lowest, or uppermost, orbital (according as Sal is negative or positive) becomes increasingly localized at the position r = 1, and this orbital describes the single surface state that can be generated by the change in one coulomb integral. Nodes of the remaining orbitals move towards the atom r = 1 until, in the limit, one node coincides with the bond joining atoms 1 and 2.
so
128
H . H . GREENWOOD A N D R . MCWEENY
I n this way nodal properties of the orbitals of the “residual ” molecule are preserved. Suppose now the coulomb integral a t the other end atom, r =N , is modified by changing Sa, from zero to the value S q . Then a second level emerges from above or below the band to near coincidence with the first emerging level, and the corresponding orbital becomes increasingly localized at the Nth atom. The remaining levels are approximately those of a new “residual ” molecule formed by excluding r = 1 and N from the original linear chain and these, therefore, lie within the original band; the nodal properties of orbitals are again correctly preserved. Alternatively, both coulomb integrals can be changed simultaneously by Sal=&a, and both levels emerge from the band nearly together but the
r = 1 2 3 4 ....
.... N
FIG.23. “Surface” states of linear chain.
orbitals are no longer localized separately atoms r = 1 and N . Suppose, for example, Sal= Sa, is negative under these circumstances ; then the two lowest levels emerge from below the band and the orbitals that emerge are, successively, the nodeless orbital and the next orbital with one node. These are “localized” in both atoms, r = 1 and N , as indicated in Fig. 23, and, since they correspond to a twofold degeneracy, can be combined in sum and difference forms to give two alternative forms that are substantially localized on each atom separately ; these new orbitals are then equivalent to the two “surface ” state orbitals extracted separately, as described previously. I n real crystals the potential rises as the surface is approached from inside, so that Sa, is positive, and surface states emerge from above the band, from corresponding orbitals having the largest number of nodes; these are difficult to sketch, and for this reason only the case with Sa, negative is considered above. The extension of these ideas to a two-dimensional model is straightforward. Consider a regular rectangular lattice with edges, parallel to x and y axes, containing respectively N and M atoms, and suppose all N
REACTIVITY INDICES I N CONJUGATED MOLECULES
129
atoms in one edge parallel to z are modified by 6a, (positive). At some threshold value of 8ar,N surface state levels emerge from above the band; the remaining levels are approximately equal to those of the corresponding two-dimensional residual molecule, and necessarily remain within the band. The surface states emerge in the sequence given by the number of nodes ( N - 1)) (N- 2), (N- 3 ) . .. 2 , 1, 0 in the z coordinate of the corresponding orbitals, each orbital having the maximum number ( M - 1) of nodes in the y coordinate. When two parallel edges are modified, 2 N surface states emerge from above the band, and this case can be treated as an extension of the linear chain with two modified end atoms. The development for four modified edges in a two-dimensional model follows the same pattern. Clearly the description of surface states in threedimensional systems becomes increasingly difficult to describe, but not too difficult to visualize, since substantially the same principles hold. IX. REACTIVITY INDICES IN MANY-ELECTRON THEORY The discussion so far has turned entirely on Huckel theory. Indeed, almost all the work on reactivity theory during the past twenty years or more has been built on the somewhat insecure foundation of a oneelectron model which is known to possess many defects, perhaps the most serious being the complete neglect of interaction among the electrons (often amounting to many hundreds of electron volts), except in so far as this can be absorbed into the empirical parameters. This is a particularly disturbing situation when it is remembered that chemical significance is frequently attached to indices which differ by one or two units in the second decimal place-corresponding perhaps to energy differences of the order of 1/10 e.v. On the other hand, there have been significant advances in many-electron theory, including for example the development (Pople, 1953 ;McWeeny, 1956) of semi-empiricalversions of Roothaan’s approximate self-consistent field (SCF) theory (Roothaan, 1951). Most of these developments may be applied most directly within the framework of the isolated molecule method, in which the reactivity indices are the charges and self-polarizabilitiesof the unperturbed ground state of a given molecule; calculations based on the localization model (e.g. Nesbet, 1962) have made less progress, and will not be considered. It is therefore natural to enquire whether indices similar to qr and T,,? in Huckel theory can still be defined, and calculated more precisely, in self-consistent field theory. The obvious questions are
(i) Is it possible to find indices with properties similar to those of the charges, bond orders and polarizabilities of Huckel theory, using 6*
130
H . H . GREENWOOD A N D R. MCWEENY
a complete many-electron theory which properly includes electron interaction effects? (ii) How far is it possible to characterize the actual effects of an approaching reagent (e.g. charged or uncharged ion) in terms of these indices? (iii) Is it possible, as it is in Huckel theory, to use the same polarizability indices to estimate the effect of heteroatoms upon the electronic structure and properties of a given parent hydrocarbon?
It will appear that there is, in fact, a strong correspondence between Huckel and SCF methods in which the SCF charge qr and self-polarizability rr?,). at a position r of attack are related to the change in rr-electron energy 6E produced by variation of parameters associated with the rth atom (see Section IXB) as in equation (18). Similarly, the charges q8 in a molecule substituted at position u can be calculated approximately from the SCF atom-atom polarizabilities rr8,u of the parent (see Section IXC), and used subsequently as indicators of the active positions in the derivative. The results are completely general but again alternant hydrocarbons have specially interesting properties. The notation used previously in discussing the isolated-molecule method distinguished carefully between the change Suu in coulomb integral due to a substituent at any atom u of the conjugated system, and a similar change 6ur in coulomb integral at the position r of attack due to the proximity of a charged reagent. The distinction was made to avoid the confusion which often arises when the polarizabilities are used for the two purposes just indicated. I n view of the slightly greater complexity of the SCF formulation, however, we shall now use r,8,t,u, as general indices, distinguishing a particular choice by explicit reference to, for example, “the position r of attack”. I n practice, the context is usually sufficient to eliminate risk of ambiguity. A. Perturbation Methods in SCF Theory It would be out of place to give a detailed review of the a