Advances in Physical Organic Chemistry
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Advances in Physical Organic Chemistry Vo...
38 downloads
2068 Views
17MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Advances in Physical Organic Chemistry
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Advances in Physical Organic Chemistry Volume 11 Edited by
V. Gold Department of Chemistry King’s College University of London Associate Editor
D. Bethel1 The Robert Robinson Laboratories University of Liverpool England
1975
Academic Press London New York A Subsidiary o f Harcourt Bruce Jouunouich, Publishcrs
San Francisco
ACADEMIC PRESS INC. (LONDON) LTD 24-28 Oval Road, London NWI
U S . Edition published by ACADEMIC PRESS INC. 111 Fifth Avenue, New York, New York 10003, San Francisco
Copyright
0 1975 By Academic Press Inc. (London) Ltd
All Rights Reserved
No part of this Book may be reproduced in any form by photostat, microfilm, or any other means, without written permission from the publishers
Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 62-22 125 ISBN 0-12-033511-5
PRINTED IN GREAT BRITAIN BY WILLIAM CLOWES & SONS LIMITED LONDON, COLCHESTER AND BECCLES
Contributors to Volume 11
J. Cornelisse, Department of Organic Chemistry, Gorlaeus Laboratories, Leiden University, The Netherlands
G. P. de Gunst, Department of Organic Chemistry, Gorlaeus Laboratories, Leiden University, The Netherlands
D. G . Farnum, Department of Chemistry, Michigan State University, East Lansing, Michigan, U.S.A. T. H. Fife, Department of Biochemistry, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, California 90033, U.S.A. E. Havinga, Department of Organic Chemistry, Gorlaeus Laboratories, Leiden University, The Netherlands G. M. Kramer, Corporate Research Laboratories, Exxon Research and Engineering Co., Linden, New Jersey 07036, U.S.A.
M. Liler, School 0.f Chemtitry, The University, Newcastle upon Tyne, England
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Preface
With the appearance of Volume 11, Advances in Physical Organic Chemistry enters the second decade of its life. Many exciting developments of the subject have taken place since the publication of the first volume. It is a matter of some pride to be able to state that the contents of the first ten volumes have not only reflected these advances but, in many cases, have pointed the way and had a seminal influence on later work. Over the same period, Physical Organic Chemistry has become “respectable”, as is shown by the titles of several books and by the institution of professorships and other academic appointments in the sub.ject. The value of physical organic methods has become widely appreciated in industry. Biennial International Conferences on Physical Organic Chemistry have been started under the auspices of the International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry, who have also appointed a Commission on Physical Organic Chemistry. No doubt, these tokens of recognition give some satisfaction to many scientists who have found the search for glimpses of a quantitative understanding of organic chemistry the most fascinating field of study. Yet this very respectability has its dangers. What made Physical Organic Chemistry a dynamic movement in science was that some outstanding men refused t o be type-cast as physical or organic chemists and instead pursued the investigation of absorbing problems irrespective of the nature of the techniques required. Physical Organic Chemistry as an institutionalized “discipline” runs the risk of losing this spirit. It will be a continuing objective of our series not t o allow this to happen, by encouraging the publication of contributions which do not as yet conform to established notions of the scope of the field. It is natural that a living subject should at times produce quite extreme divergences of opinion. This series will continue t o include
... Vlll
PREFACE
contributions which may present a topic from an unfashionable point of view. At other times, complementary accounts of controversial issues may be published, with the dual aim of pinpointing problems and resolving confusion. Thus, the present volume contains a reappraisal of the structure of the norbornyl cation by George Kramer, and in a subsequent one the problem of the norbornyl cation and of its significance in organic chemistry will be discussed in an article by George Olah, Eric Nordlander and Paul Schleyer. Beginning with the present volume, the series will have the benefit of the specialist knowledge of Dr. Donald Bethell who is joining me as Associate Editor. At the same time, some changes have been made in the production of volumes, so as to improve lay-out and speed up publication. It is a pleasure to acknowledge the service to the subject provided by the publishers, Academic Press, and especially the indefatigable assistance given to the Editor over the years by Messrs R. S. Lawrence and R. Adams. My main thanks go to the contributors who have so readily come forward with ideas or responded to suggestions for timely reviews. Dr. Bethel1 and I hope that we shall continue to receive such cooperation, and will always welcome expressions of views on the series and its contents. V. Gold London, November 1974.
Con tents
Contributors to Volume 11 .
.
v
Physical Organic Model Systems and the Problem of Enzymatic Catalysis - Thomas H. Fife
1. Introduction . 2. Enzymatic Catalysis: General Principles . 3. General Base, Nucleophilic Catalysis: a-Chymotrypsin 4. Metal-Ion Catalysis: Carboxypeptidase . . 5. General Acid Catalysis: Lysozyme 6. Conclusion .
. .
1 5 . 29 . 64 . 81 .115
Charge Density-NMR Chemical Shift Correlations in Organic Ions - D. G. Farnum
1. Introduction
.
2. Theory. 3. Empirical Observations. 4. Conclusions .
.
. 123 . 126 .135
. 172
The Norbornyl Cation: A Reappraisal o f its Structure Under Stable Ion Conditions - G. M . Kramer
1. Introduction
.
.177
CONTENTS
X
2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
7. 8. 9. 10. 11.
Possible Structures of the Norbornyl Cation Solvolytic Background. . Theoretical Status . The Search for a Protonated Cyclopropyl Ring ESCA . 13C-nmr . 'H-nmr. . Raman Spectra . Related Ions. Summary .
. 179
. 180
. 192 .194 .199 .202 f211 .215 . 218 .221
Nucleophilic Aromatic Photosubstitution - J. Cornelisse, G . P. de Gunst, E. Havinga
1. Introduction . .225 2. The Excited State from which the Nucleophilic Aromatic Photosubstitution Starts. Kinetics . .236 3. Orientation Rules in Nucleophilic Aromatic Photosubsti.245 tution . .253 4. Investigations on Intermediates . 5. Epilogue . .261
Alternative Protonation Sites in Ambident Conjugated Systems - M. Liler
1. 2. 3. 4.
Introduction . . Methods of Investigation Cation Stability and Solvation . Protonation Sites in Conjugated Molecules
.
.267 .270 .287 .300
Physical Organic Model Systems and the Problem of Enzymatic Catalysis
THOMAS H. FIFE
Department of Biochemistry, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, California 90033, U.S.A. 1. 2.
3.
.
Introduction Enzymatic Catalysis: General Principles Intramolecular Catalysis Multifunctional Catalysis . Conformation and Strain Effects . General Base, Nucleophilic Catalysis: a-Chymotrypsin Imidazole Catalysis Hydroxyl Group Catalysis . Mechanistic Conclusions Metal-Ion Catalysis: Carboxypeptidase. . Metal-ion Catalysis of Ester and Amide Hydrolysis Carboxyl Group Catalysis . Mechanistic Conclusions General Acid Catalysis: Lysozyme General Acid Catalysis . Intramolecular Catalysis Nucleophilic Catalysis Acylal Hydrolysis. Mechanistic Conclusions Conclusion References
.
.
.
.
4.
5.
.
. .
6.
. .
.
.
.
.
1
.
5
.
.
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
. .
. .
5 19 28 29 30 39 60 64 66 73 80 81 81 90 105 108 112 115 117
1. INTRODUCTION Enzymes are the best catalysts known. They catalyse chemical reactions in aqueous solution near neutral pH and at mild temperatures with attainment of great velocities. Although suitable standards 1
2
T. H. FIFE
of comparison are often lacking, still it can be calculated (Bruice and Benkovic, 1966; Jencks, 1969; Bender, 1971) that certain enzymes will give rate enhancements by factors of the order of 1010-1014 compared with similar non-enzymatic reactions. Therefore, knowledge of the mechanism of action of enzymes is of great importance, not only because enzymes are of biological interest, but also for the greater chemical understanding of catalysis in aqueous solution that would result. A complete description of the mechanism of action of an enzyme requires knowledge of a number of factors, among which are: (a) The structure of the active site and of enzyme-substrate complexes. (b) The specificity of substrates and their ability to bind to the enzyme. (c) The rate constants for the various steps in the reaction and the chemical mechanism of each step, ie., a description of all of the intermediates and transition states along the reaction coordinate. (d) An explanation for the magnitude of the rate constants. Hence, in approaching the problem of enzymatic catalysis, infonnation must be obtained from a number of experimental techniques. Being proteins, enzymes are extremely complicated molecules, and the mechanistic interpretation of kinetic data is generally difficult. It is this complexity that in large part explains why, although kinetic studies have been conducted with many enzymes since the end of the nineteenth century, there is still n o enzyme for which a mechanism has been definitely established. Extensive effort has been expended in recent years on mechanistic investigations of model reactions, chemical reactions similar t o a post-binding enzymatic reaction, but where the number of variables is limited and strong evidence can be obtained pertaining to mechanism. Model work can begin only after enzymologists have provided information about the structure of the enzyme and the identity of groups in the active site. Once this basic information is available, the next step is to attempt t o gain understanding of the chemistry of the process. In some cases it has not been possible to begin with sophisticated models, but rather, chemical work has been necessary to determine whether mechanisms suggested for an enzyme were even chemically feasible. Work on acetal hydrolysis (Fife, 1972) related t o the mechanism of action of lysozyme is an illustration of this point.
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
3
In addition to determining the mechanism of action of an enzyme, it is important t o be able t o explain, in quantitative terms, the rapid rate of the enzyme reaction. That is, if factors A, B, and C are important, we would like to analyse the observed rate of the reaction in terms of these factors according t o equation 1 and give numerical values to the coefficients. To date this has not been possible for most log kobsd = aA + bB
+ cC + . . . nN
enzymes and possible only to an approximation with a-chymotrypsin (Bender et al., 1964). It is apparent that this type of information can best come from detailed chemical studies where the various factors are examined in isolation. Chemical models then fulfil a twofold purpose: first, in providing reasonable mechanisms for the enzyme and casting doubt on others, thereby suggesting experimental approaches having a heightened chance of being fruitful; and second, in leading t o explanations of the observed rates in terms of structure and mechanism [items (c) and (d)]. The number of different functional groups that an enzyme can use in the catalytic process is quite limited. Among them are the imidazole ring, aliphatic and phenolic hydroxyl, carboxyl, sulphhydryl, and amino groups. A reasonable speculation is that enzymes which catalyse similar reactions will have mechanistic features in common. This supposition is supported by the fact that several different esteratic enzymes having serine at the active site have an identical sequence of amino-acids around the active serine (Bruice and Benkovic, 1966; Bender, 1971). The amino-acid sequences for chymotrypsin and subtilisin (Wright et ~ l . ,1969) are dissimilar, but the catalytically important groups are the same and are arranged in nearly the same geometrical relationship, implying identical mechanisms of action. Also, it seems reasonable that common mechanistic features may extend to enzymes which catalyse different reactions if the same catalytic group can function. For example, if an aliphatic hydroxyl group acts as a nucleophile in two different reactions, at least some common factors will probably be important in promoting catalysis. Consequently, from studies of catalysis by relatively few functional groups in carefully selected reactions it may be possible t o formulate general principles for catalysis in aqueous solution including enzyme catalysis. The purpose of the present review is to summarize the pertinent data concerning several well-studied reactions, to draw reasonable conclusions, and to point out some of the questions remaining to be
4
T. H. FIFE
answered. T o restrict the discussion to a manageable level, concern will be mainly with hydrolysis reactions relevant to the research interests of the author. Many important mechanism studies must therefore be omitted. For the most part only those reactions will be considered in detail which bear direct analogy to corresponding enzyme reactions and can therefore be considered true models. The enzymes themselves will not be discussed except to give necessary background information pertaining t o postulated mechanisms. Chemical model investigations will be described which relate to three hydrolytic enzymes, a-chymotrypsin, carboxypeptidase, and lysozyme. Numerous excellent review articles have appeared concerning these enzymes, and their reactions (see for example, Boyer, 1970) and the mechanisms of the enzyme-catalysed reactions (Westheimer, 1962; Bruice and Dunn, 1973; Kaiser and Kaiser, 1972). These enzymes serve as perhaps the best examples of the model approach because detailed structural information is available. In each case the complete amino-acid sequence of the enzyme is known, and the three-dimensional structure has been determined by x-ray crystalloresolution (for three dimensional structural graphic analysis at 2 drawings, see Dickerson and Geis, 1969). Also, the basic chemistry of the types of reactions catalysed has been extensively studied over a long period of time, and there is a wealth of background chemical information (Bender, 1960; Bruice and Benkovic, 1966; Johnson, 1967; Jencks, 1969; Cordes, 1967; Fife, 1972). The enzymes have the aliphatic hydroxyl group of serine, the imidazole ring of histidine, and carboxyl groups as catalytically important functional groups at the active sites. The problem resolves itself into determining how such functional groups can participate in the hydrolytic reactions and how the rates of the enzymatic reactions can be accounted for in mechanistic terms. Model studies have made a major contribution towards an understanding of the mechanistic possibilities which lysozyme might employ. Indeed, the model approach is perhaps the method with the greatest chance of success in attempts t o comprehend the complex reactions of enzymes such as lysozyme where the natural substrates are not suitable for detailed kinetic work. a-Chymotrypsin can be studied with a variety of ester and amide substrates of low molecular weight, and much mechanistic information is available from direct work on the enzyme. Chemical models have been chiefly useful in promoting understanding of the chemistry of the reactions and in providing a basis for comprehension of the magnitude of the rate
a
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
5
constants in terms of individual mechanistic factors. At the other extreme, crucial model systems have not yet been investigated in relation to carboxypeptidase, but that enzyme illustrates types of questions that well-designed chemical models might answer. Information is currently available which allows more definite conclusions than have previously been possible. Rate enhancements have been obtained in several simple chemical reactions that are of similar magnitude to those observed in analogous enzyme-catalysed reactions, and the goal of analysing the individual factors that can give such large rate accelerations is now perhaps within reach. The recent work will be stressed in this review. Deeper insight into complex enzyme reactions has resulted from the study of simpler chemical models; but also, fundamental and novel observations concerning catalysis in aqueous solution have been made. The chemical work is therefore o f interest in its own right, apart from any applicability t o enzymatic catalysis. It.is the author’s. opinion that this has not been stressed t o a sufficient extent in previous discussions of enzymatic catalysis. Apart from the practical advantages that might result from understanding how enzymes function, the primary scientific importance would appear to be greatly increased knowledge of chemical catalysis. From this inverted viewpoint it is the chemistry that is elucidated that will prove to have ultimate scientific value, whether or not it directly applies to enzymes.
2. ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS: GENERAL PRINCIPLES Intramolecular Catalysis Several fundamental aspects of enzymatic catalysis must be considered in any discussion of the chemistry of enzymatic reactions. First, an enzyme-catalysed reaction proceeds with formation of an E+S
kl
k- 1
ES
k cat
E+P
(2)
enzyme-substrate complex which then breaks down t o product and free enzyme [equation (2)]. The evidence for this is in most cases only suggestive (saturation kinetics), but an ES complex has been observed in some reactions (Chance, 1943, 1947), and it is generally assumed that such a complex is formed in most, if not all,
6
T. H. FIFE
enzyme-catalysed reactions. Second, it is held that reaction takes place in a limited, specific area of the protein surface (the active site) with functional groups of amino-acid residues participating in the reaction. These ideas have been highly advantageous in regard to the development of chemical catalysis in aqueous solution. If the above concepts are correct, then an enzymatic reaction proceeding through an enzyme-substrate complex with the substrate bound close to appropriate functional groups is quite analogous to a chemical intramolecular reaction. Substantial effort has therefore been expended on the study of such reactions in attempts better to comprehend enzyme catalysis (Bruice, 1970; Kirby and Fersht, 1971). Intramolecular reactions usually occur rapidly in comparison with similar bimolecular reactions, and a number of explanations have been put forth concerning the efficiency of intramolecular catalysis. Westheimer (1962) pointed out that intramolecular reactions should have a more favourable entropy of activation than their bimolecular counterparts because translational entropy of the catalyst is not lost as it is in the bimolecular reaction. To determine the efficiency of an intramolecular reaction, the first-order rate constant is often compared with the second-order rate constant of the corresponding bimolecular reaction proceeding by the same mechanism. This ratio has units of molarity ( s - ~ /-M‘ s - ’ ) and is taken to be the “effective molarity” of the neighbouring group, i.e. the concentration of bimolecular catalyst required to give a pseudo-first order rate constant of the magnitude observed in the intramolecular reaction. An intramolecular dimethylamino-group has an effective molarity of 1000-5000 M for attack at the ester carbonyl (Bruice and Benkovk, 1963) and there is a more favourable AS* value than in the intermolecular reaction between trimethylamine and aryl acetates (see the data in Table 1). Page and Jencks (1971) have calculated that favourable changes in AS* in intramolecular reactions could be large enough to explain the rapid rates of some enzymatic reactions, and effective concentrations of the order of l o 8 M may be accounted for without introducing new chemical concepts. Intramolecular nucleophilic reactions could also be facilitated over their intermolecular counterparts if the reaction centre and the nucleophile are compressed in the ground state. Part of the van der Waals repulsion energy could thereby be overcome in the ground state, resulting in a more favourable AH* value. Solvation
TABLE 1 Activation Parameters (kcal mole-')ofor Nucleophilic Displacement by the Dimethylamino-Group at 25 (Bruice and Benkovic, 1963)
m 0 2
m-NOz p-CI H P-CH3
12.3 12.1 12.5 12.9
-6.3
-8-0 -9-1 -9.4
11.9 11.5 15.9 12.5 13.7
-1.9 -4.3 -2-2 -5-7 -5.1
11.5 11-8 13.8 12.3 14.4
-2.6 -4.4 -4.1 -6.4 -5-5
m z N
4
5
=!
n
T. H. FIFE
8
factors might also be of great importance. Before a nucleophile can attack it must be desolvated, requiring expenditure of substantial energy. However, an intramolecular nucleophile would be less heavily solvated in the ground state than an intermolecular nucleophile in dilute solution if the neighbouring group and the reaction centre are immediately adjacent in the same molecule so that water molecules cannot fit between. As an intramolecular nucleophile is more rigidly held with respect to the reaction centre, the rate of the reaction increases as illustrated in Table 2. Bruice and Pandit (1960b) concluded that the rate increases were due t o restriction of unfavourable rotamer distribution. The most energetically favourable ground state conformation would have the carboxyl group extended into the solvent, viz. 0
II -0-c-c-o
0
"
-0
where it could not attack the carbonyl. Removal of rotational degrees of freedom would therefore greatly enhance the rate of reaction. As seen in Table 3, similar rate enhancements have been observed in lactonization reactions as the reacting groups are held in proximity t o each other (Storm and Koshland, 1970, 1972a). A rate enhancement of 10'' M is observed in lactonization of [ l ] with respect to the bimolecular esterification in equation (4) (Milstien and Cohen, 1972). The methyl group in the 3-position of [ l ] fits between the geminal methyl groups in the side chain and locks the system. One function of an enzyme is t o bring the substrate by binding at the active site into proximity with functional groups of the enzyme. 0
5--. \
+ HzO
CH3
(3)
9
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
TABLE 2 Effect of Structure on Carboxyl Group Participation in Hydrolysis of Phenyl Esters (Bruice and Pandit, 1960b) Compound
Relative rate
1
19.3
230
10,300
0
53,000
Koshland (1962) has calculated, however, that such a “propinquity” effect will not explain the large rate enhancements observed with enzymes unless there are more than two functional groups involved; with utilization of five functional groups ( 2 substrates and 3 catalytic groups) a rate increase of 1 0 l 8 would be possible. Such multifunctional catalysis would, of course, be impossible to demonstrate
T. H. FIFE
10
TABLE 3 Acid Catalysed Lactonization at 25' in 20% EtOH-H20, pa = 0.4 (Storm and Koshland, 1972a) Correctedb rel. rate
klac
'
(M- min- ')
Substrate
c::
EtOH + CH3C02H
(Co2H
VH
0.00 109
krel
1.0
1
0.086
80
413
0.127
117
200
0.344
316
17
6620
1660
1,030,000
18,700
I
CI13
&COzH CH2 OH
7.23
1120
'Ionic strength. Corrected for torsional strain and proximity effects and normalized t o a value for the bimolecular reaction of EtOH and HOAc.
in chemical tions. Koshland reason why an increase
models and appears very improbable in enzymatic reac-
(1962) argued that if proximity effects were the only intramolecular reactions are favoured, that is, because of in local concentration of the catalytic function, then
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
11
effective molarities of 5-50 M would be observed. In an intramolecular reaction [equation (5)] each A must have B as a nearest neighbour. In a bimolecular reaction [equation ( 6 ) ] A and B will A + B
kl
AB
(6)
encounter each other randomly. Only a fraction of A molecules will have a B nearest neighbour depending upon the concentration of B. The ratio of rate constants (k /k, ) should be the concentration of B necessary to give A one nearest neighbour B. The upper limit in concentration would be liquid B. For a reaction in water (where B is H,O) this ratio should be no greater than 55.5 M . Assuming that reactant species are about the size of a water molecule and that in a dilute solution of A there would be about 12 nearest neighbour B molecules, a theoretical ratio of rate constants of 55*5/12= 4.6 M is obtained. Effective molarities of 5-50 M have been observed but much larger ratios have also been measured ( l o 8 M ). For a detailed discussion see: Bruice, 1970. From studies of intramolecular lactonization reactions, where rate enhancements of l o 3 t o lo6 over the bimolecular counterpart were found (Table 3 ) , Koshland proposed the concept of “orbital steering” (Storm and Koshland, 1970). Since collision of a nucleophile and receptor atom will be effective on only a small portion of the surface of each, the reaction velocity should be sensitive to proper orientation; steric factors which caused favourable alignment of orbitals might give rise to large rate increases. Bruice et al. (1971) have argued forcibly that some of the rate enhancements seen in intramolecular reactions are much larger than expected from orientation effects. After correcting for proximity effects, orientation factors of 106-107 would be necessary. Bruice argues that this would require covalent bonds to be approximately 100 times more resistant toward bending deformations than spectroscopic data and molecular orbital theory indicate. Consequently, “orbital steering” will not account for rate enhancements of up t o 10’. Koshland has recently replied to the criticisms that have been levelled at the concept of orbital orientation as an important factor in intramolecular reactions (Storm and Koshland, 1972a, b). The data in Table 4 were presented showing effects on lactonization of minor changes in structure, such as changing the carbon superstructure, changing orientation by the presence of methyl groups, and changing the nucleophile from oxygen to sulfur. The lactonization rate is sometimes promoted while in other cases rate decreases are brought
T. H. FIFE
12
TABLE 4 Effect of Ring Structure, Methyl Groups, and Nucleophile on Rates of Lactonization (See Table 3 for Reference Compounds; Storm and Koshland, 1972b) at 25O in 20% EtOH-H20 (p = 0.4)
Compd.
4 f4
&lac (M-'min-')
Rate relative to unsubstituted compound
10.0
C02 H
OH
0.950
CO2H
152
&c02H CH2OH
2.88 x 10-4
4
0
1.50 x
4700'
3.0 x 10-3
936'
2 H CH2 SH
71.0 OH
90'
CO2H
0.63 x lo-'
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
13
TABLE 4-continued Compd.
&CH3 OH
OH
k h c (M-' min-')
0.30
Rate relative to unsubstituted compound
2.7 x 10-4
CO2H
107.0
113
100
1
CO2H
d? COzH
522
5 2.2
a CH3. CH2. SH + CH3C02H: k~ = 3.20 x 10-6M-' min-': re1 rate = 1.0
about by structural modifications. Koshland argues that such changes would be expected if orbital orientation was of great importance. This controversy forms part of the large general question of why intramolecular reactions are so favourable. Increases in the rate of anhydride formation due t o bulky substituents in the 3-position of mono-/3-bromophenyl glutarates (the 3,3-diisopropyl derivative cyclises 1030 times faster than the unsubstituted compound) are accompanied by more positive AS*-values (Bruice and Bradbury, 1968). Tetramethylsuccinanilic acid [ 21 cyclises rapidly at 25" t o the anhydride with carboxyl group participation which is 1200 times more favourable than with succinanilic acid (Higuchi et al., 1966). Furthermore, rate enhancement is associated with a more favourable AH*,the value of AS* actually being more negative. The activation parameters were rationalized by Kirby and Fersht (1971) by assuming that the geminal methyl groups force
14
T. H. FIFE
the carboxyl and carbonyl groups into such close alignment in the ground state that part of the van der Waals repulsion energy is 0
17)
CH3 0
overcome. The unfavourable effect on AS* was ascribed to greater solvation of the transition state than of the ground state. Thus, structural effects on activation parameters in intramolecular carboxyl group-catalysed ester and amide hydrolysis can be manifested in either AS* or AH*, depending upon the compound or type of reaction. The ester hydrolysis reactions studied by Bruice and Bradbury (1968) are more easily interpretable examples since the amide cyclization probably involves a pre-equilibrium protonation step. Effects of structure on AH* and AS* could arise from effects on either the pre-equilibrium step or the rate-determining nucleophilic attack. Bunnett and Hauser (1965) found that lactonization of [3] proceeded 300 times faster than lactonization of 2-hydroxy-. methylbenzoic acid. Steric compressional effects are probably responsible, and again the rate increase is characterized by a more favourable AH*.
Bruice and Benkovic (1964) and Bruice (1970) have noted that conversion of a bimolecular reaction into an intramolecular reaction corresponds t o a reduction in kinetic order. Comparison of reactions of varying kinetic order (Table 5 ) reveals that a change of 45 kcal mole-' in TAS* accompanies reduction in order by one. These reactions include 17 displacement reactions on phenyl esters and 4 on thiol esters with an average value of -TAS*/(kinetic order)
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
15
TABLE 5 Comparison of the Value of TAS*/Kinetic Order in Displacement Reactions of Phenyl and Thioiesters (Bruice, 1970) Reactants
-TAs* /kinetic order (kcal mole-')
Ref.
4-0-6
U
1
4
b
1
3
b
1
5
C
5
d
4
d
Kinetic Order
II
0
0
1
T. H. FIFE
16
TABLE 5-continued ~~
Reactants
+ HzO
X
X
G
O
A
c + (CH3)3N
e OAc
+ -OH
~
~~~~~~
Kinetic Order
-TAS*/kinetic order (kcal mole-')
Ref.
2
4
e
4
e
2
3
f
2
5
f
4
d
4
g
3
d
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
17
TABLE 5-continued Kinetic Order
Reactants
o OAc + 2(NH2)2
X
3
N ~ N H X
o
O
A
c
+ 2
L J
3
;;1...(1
3
-TA.S*/kinetic order (kcal mole-')
Ref.
4-5
g
5
g
5
h
5
h
5
h
5
h
a Bruice and Bradbury, 1968.
Gaetjens and Morawetz, 1960. Thanassi and Bruice, 1966. Bruice and Benkovic, 1963. Felton and Bruice, 1969. f Fersht and Kirby, 1967. g Bruice and Benkovic, 1964. Fedor and Bruice, 1964.
being 4-4 f 0-8 kcal mole-'. At 25" a rate decrease of about l o 5 will result for each additional species incorporated in the transition state. Bruice (1970) points out that only to an approximation can kinetic and potential energies of activation be associated with observed
18
T. H. FIFE
values of AS* and AH*. Also, since AH* and AS* are not completely independent, compensation may occur, favourable changes in one being accompanied by unfavourable changes in the other. Therefore, the treatment’s success with a fairly large body of data is striking. Undoubtedly the effects observed by Koshland and earlier by Bruice are produced by the same cause. Whether orientation effects are due to “orbital steering” or elimination of conformations unfavourable for the reaction makes a conceptual difference only in that “orbital steering” would include a transition-state effect whereas the latter would arise from restriction of possible ground states. What is unmistakably clear from available data is that constraining an intramolecular nucleophile close to the reaction centre can produce large rate increases. Thus, from the data of Bruice and Pandit (1960) in Table 2, p-bromophenyl exo-3,6-endoxo-A-4-tetrahydrophthalate cyclizes 53,000 times faster than p-bromophenyl glutarate. In the bicyclic compound the carboxyl group is constrained adjacent to the carbonyl and degrees of freedom have been removed, whereas in the glutarate ester free rotation is possible about two single bonds. Bruice and Pandit note that removal of each degree of freedom will increase the rate about 230 times. It is doubtful whether unfavourable conformations could be eliminated more effectively than in the bicyclic ester without steric compression effects becoming important. Bruice’s viewpoint is that the advantage of intramolecular reactions is entropic because of the freezing out of degrees of freedom in the ground state. This results in favourable changes in translational and rotational entropy of activation compared with corresponding bimolecular reactions. This is considered to be entirely a proximity effect. In the intramolecular reactions studied by Bruice and Koshland and their co-workers, proximity effects (reduction in kinetic order and elimination of unfavourable ground state conformations) and orientation effects might give rate accelerations of l o 7- l o 8 . Hence, these effects can by themselves account for the enhancements seen in most intramolecular reactions. However, a factor of 107-108 is less than the rate acceleration calculated for many enzyme reactions and certain intramolecular reactions, for example, hydrolysis of benzaldehyde disalicyl acetal (3 x 10’) (Anderson and Fife, 1973) and the lactonization reaction of [ 11 (10’ ) where a trimethyl lock has been built into the system. If hydrolysis of tetramethylsuccinanilic acid (Higuchi et al., 1966)represents a steric compression effect ( l o 3 rate acceleration), then proximity, orientation, and steric compression
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
19
might give rate increases of 10' '-10' '. Thus there can be a factor of 102-104 in the rate constants n o t accounted for by th e three effects above; transition state stabilization and release of ground state strain are likely candidates. Diamines of varying structure show rate enhancements of 20- 200 fold, compared to monofunctional aliphatic amines, in nucleophilic reactions with N-acetylimidazole (Page and Jencks, 1972). These were attributed to intramolecular general base catalysis of proton removal from the attacking nitrogen, viz., -0
The low effective molarity of -1.0 M for the catalysing base and lack of sensitivity t o diamine structure suggested a loose transition state with minimal geometric requirements. General base catalysis of aminolysis of N-acetylimidazole approaches the lower limit 01 the range of rate accelerations in intramolecular reactions. If a bimolecular reaction takes place with a tight transition state, loss o f substantial translational an d rotational cntropy of the reactants (40-50 C.U. for typical molecules in solution) will be required. In a n intramolecular reaction o r intracomplex enzymatic reaction, a significant portion of this entropy has already been removed so that little further entropy loss nccd occur, resulting in a large rate enhancement (1O8 M). If, however, the transition state has only limited geometrical requirements, little cntropy nccd be lost in the bimolecular case and the rate acceleration in the intramolecular reaction will be small.
hilultifunctionul Catalysis Another fundamental idea that has been invoked to explain enzymatic catalysis is that such reactions utilize bifunctional or multifunctional catalysis; that is, several functional groups in the active site are properly aligned with the substrate so that concerted catalysis may occur. Mutarotation of tetramethyl glucose is frequently cited as an example o f bifunctional catalysis. Lowry and
20
T. H. FIFE
Faulkner (1923; 1927) reported that mutarotation occurred much more readily in a mixture of pyridine and cresol than in either by itself. Swain and Brown (1952) extended this work and found that a-pyridone, where an acidic and a basic group are incorporated in the same molecule, is an excellent catalyst, 0.05 M concentration giving rise to a reaction 5 0 times faster in benzene solution than a solution of 0.05 M phenol and 0-05 M pyridinc. A 0.001 M solution of a-pyridone was 7000 times more effective than equivalent concentrations of phenol and pyridine. A concerted mechanism was proposed [4].
The advantage of bifunctional over monofunctional catalysis could arise from reduction in the number of species in the transition state, which would presumably affect AS*, and elimination of high-energy intermediates which might affect AH*. Rony (1968) measured activation parameters for the mutarotation of tetramethylglucose in benzene solution and found that 2-pyridone has a low activation enthalpy relative to pyridinium-phenoxide. The enhanced catalytic ability of 2-pyridone was attributed to the fact that it can exchange two protons without forming a high-energy dipolar ion. Zeffren and Hall (1973) have commented that, since reactions with polar transition states in nonpolar solvents can be accelerated by several orders of magnitude by the presence of low concentrations of salts (Winstein e t al., 1959), the rate enhancement of tetramethylglucose mu taro tation provided by the presence of acid-base pairs such as phenol and pyridine may be due t o formation of ion pairs in benzene solution. Salts which do not act as acids and bases catalyse mutarotation of tetramethylglucose in aprotic solvents (Eastham et a/., 1955; Blackall and Eastham, 1955; Pocker, 1960). The efficiency of enzymatic catalysis could arise largely from electrostatic catalysis
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
21
in a non-polar region of the enzyme. The presence of ion pairs could be extremely important in such a region. Examples of catalysis involving concerted cyclic proton transfer in water have recently been reported in the hydrolysis of N-phenyliminotetrahydrofuran (Cunningham and Schmir, 1966, 196 7). There is no effect of H,PCT4, HCO;, and CH,COOH on the rate of hydrolysis, but the type of product obtained, butyrolactone or y-hydroxybutyranilide is dependent on their concentration. The following scheme was proposed [equation (8)].
?
+
?
I
I
The buffer species were suggested to increase the rate of formation of butyrolactone by the cyclic concerted mechanism [ 5 ] . Hydrolysis of yhydroxybutyranilide is also catalysed by H2 PO, and HCO; but not by imidazole. A similar mechanism has been postulated in the hydrolysis of trifluoroacetanilide [ 61 (Eriksson and Holst, 1966).
&OJ F3
There are few, if any, examples of intramolecular bifunctional catalysis in aqueous solution. Maugh and Bruice (1971) examined ester hydrolysis reactions where two functional groups are present in
22
T. H. FIFE
the ester. In all cases the bell-shaped pH-rate constant profiles were shown to be the result of participation by one functional group and a substituent effect by the second group. Higuchi et al. (1971) reported an example of possible bifunctional catalysis in the hydrolysis of the monosuccinate ester of hexachlorophene [ 71 . The monoacetate ester hydrolyses 500 times faster than the diacetate below pH 8, and the monosuccinate hydrolyses
61
C1
[71
lO’-fold faster than the diacetate below pH 5. These relative rates plus a bell-shaped pH-rate profile for the succinate ester were taken to indicate intramolecular nucleophilic-general acid catalysis. However, Oka and Bruice (personal communication) have recently found that methylation of the phenolic group decreases the rat& of carboxylate anion attack by only 3-2-fold. They ascribe the bellshaped profile to inhibition of attack of the succinyl carboxylate anion by ionization of the phenolic hydroxyl group and conclude that no genuine examples of bifunctional catalysis in ester hydrolysis are at present known. Hydrolysis of benzaldehyde disalicyl acetal is characterized by a bell-shaped pH-rate constant profile (Anderson and Fife, 1971a,
yCD 0
II
e H : : .
‘’
-0 : ‘ O D C ‘
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
23
1973). The large enhancement in kObd of 2.7 x l o 9 in comparison with the dimethyl ester establishes that carboxyl-group participation is occurring. The bifunctional mechanism shown in [ 8J involving intramolecular general acid catalysis and electrostatic stabilization of a developing carbonium ion by the carboxylate anion is an attractive possibility for hydrolysis of the monoanionic species, but the monoanion rate constant is only 65 times greater than that for the completely unionized species. Part of this difference is due t o changes in the inductive effect produced by ionization of the carboxyl group. This reaction will be considered in more detail in Section 5 in connection with acetal hydrolysis and the mechanism of action of lysozyme. Jencks (1972) has concluded that concerted bifunctional acid-base catalysis is rare or nonexistent because of the improbability of meeting simultaneously at two sites on reactant and catalyst the conditions of the rule which he has proposed for concerted reactions. The rule states that concerted general acid-base catalysis of complex reactions in aqueous solution can occur only (a) at sites that undergo a large change in pK in the course of the reaction, and (b) when this change in pK converts an unfavourable to a favourable proton transfer with respect to the catalyst, i.e., the pK-value of the catalyst is intermediate between the initial and final pK-values of the substrate site. It is clear that bifunctional catalysis does not necessarily represent a favourable process in aqueous solution even when a second functional group is held sterically in proper position to participate in the reaction. Caution should then be used in assuming that most enzymes are utilizing bifunctional or multifunctional catalysis. Nevertheless, this idea has played a leading role in concepts of enzymatic catalysis. Several examples of intramolecular catalysis of bimolecular attack by a nucleophile have been reported. Bromilow and Kirby (1972) reported an interesting example in hydrolysis of salicyl phosphate dianion. In opposition to the previous mechanistic explanations forthe relatively rapid reaction of the dianionic species (40-200 fold greater than the para-carboxyl derivative) of nucleophilic attack (Chanley and Feageson, 1955) and carboxylate ion stabilization of a proton on the leaving group (Bender and Lawlor, 1963), Bromilow and Kirby proposed intramolecular general acid catalysis by the carboxyl group with substantial P-0 bond breaking but little proton transfer in the transition state. Mechanism [9] was arrived at from
24
T.
€3. FIFE
consideration of the following data: the reaction shows no significant solvent deuterium isotope effect, AS* is close to zero, and substituent effects in the 4-and 5-positions are consistent. The latter data 0
were analysed by means of equation (9) from a plot of o;'log k/ko o z / o l ,giving p1 (carboxyl) = 0.99 f 0.18; and p z (phenol) = 1.74,
us.
values thought impossible to reconcile with the mechanism of Bender and Lawlor (1963). The sensitivity to the leaving group is greater than found for hydrolysis of monoaryl phosphate monoanions where proton transfer is complete and is closer to that for the dianions, showing that transfer of a proton is not complete in the transition state for salicyl phosphate hydrolysis. The p-value for the carboxyl group, -0.99, was taken as equal to the Bronsted coefficient for general base catalysis by the carboxylate anion corresponding to a Bronsted 01 of 0 for the carboxyl group acting as a general acid. Graphical analysis employing a transformed equation can lead to erroneous results with the extended Hammett equation. The proper procedure is by multiple regression analysis of the four-parameter equation (E. Anderson, personal communication) giving p (carboxyl) -0.76. The multiple regression coefficient so obtained is not high (0-87), signifying poor fit of the data to the extended Hammett equation. This is not surprising because the treatment ignores possible substituent effects on both the phenolic oxygen and the carboxyl group. Of great interest, however, was the finding that the reaction of substituted pyridines with the salicyl phosphate dianion was subject t o general acid catalysis by the carboxyl group [ 101 with the rate enhancements as high as 108-fold. Reaction of n-butylamine with methyl salicylate in dioxane is second-order in amine (Snell e t al., 1967), but reaction with methyl p-hydroxybenzoate could not be detected. The aminolysis of phenyl
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
25
salicylate in acetonitrile occurs 132 times faster than reaction with the corresponding methoxy compound; general base catalysed attack of n-butylamine assisted by the neighbouring hydroxyl group [ 111 was proposed (Menger and Smith, 1969). H.
Examples of possible intramolecular general acid-base catalysis were reported by Kupchan et al. (1962). The methanolysis of coprostanol acetate and coprostane 3/3,5/3-diol 3-monoacetate [ 121 in aqueous methanol was conducted in triethylamine-triethylammonium acetate buffer. The rates of methanolysis at constant
buffer ratio were proportional to the concentration of the amine base. The presence of a neighbouring hydroxyl group in [ 121 gave a 300-fold rate enhancement. The following mechanism [ 131 was
26
T. H. FIFE
1131
suggested. Concerted intramolecular general base-general acid catalysed solvolysis of complex alkaloids having a tertiary nitrogen was claimed to proceed by mechanism [ 141 (Kupchan et al., 1966%b).
1141
Phenoxide ion is released relatively rapidly from tetrahydrofurancis-2,3-diol phenyl phosphate [15] at 50' (Usher et al., 1970; Oakenfull et aL, 1967). A cyclic phosphate diester intermediate is formed with pronounced general species catalysis. The pH-rate
0
\
OH
o=eo/
b constant profile for spontaneous hydrolysis (reaction at zero buffer concentration) shows apparent hydronium ion and hydroxide ion catalysis and, of most interest, a pH-independent region from
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
27
approximately pH 4- 6. The apparent hydroxide ion catalysed reaction was thought to be nucleophilic attack of the oxide ion on the phosphate monoanion as shown in (10).
+
eo-
The pH-independent reaction could involve either of two kinetically equivalent possibilities [ 16a and b] . From the observed rate constants it was calculated that, if the mechanism is possibility (a),
then protonation of the phosphate oxygen gives a rate enhancement of l o s [compared to the apparent hydroxide ion catalysed reaction of equation ( l o ) ] . If the mechanism is possibility (b), then nucleophilic attack by an oxygen anion on the phosphate monoanion is lo7 times more favourable than attack by an unionized hydroxyl group. Mechanism (a) was thought most likely. If this mechanism is operative then it is clear that general acid catalysis by a group in the active site of ribonuclease, partially protonating a phosphate oxygen, could be a factor of great significance. Although a detailed report of the buffer-catalysed reaction has not appeared, it is likely that the mechanism involves partial proton abstraction from a neighbouring alcohol hydroxyl group as the
28
T. H. FIFE
oxygen attacks phosphorus [ 171, analogous to a proposed mechanism for ribonuclease. Conformation and Strain Effects
A corollary to the idea that binding to enzyme may bring the substrate into proximity with functional groups in the active site is the concept of “induced fit” which assumes that binding of a specific substrate may induce a conformational change in the flexible enzyme that brings functional groups into proper relationship with the substrate, thereby enhancing the catalytic process (Koshland, 1958). A portion of the binding energy of the substrate would be utilized in bringing about the conformational change. There is evidence suggesting that this idea is correct for certain enzymes. X-ray crystallographic studies of lysozyme (Blake et al., 1965; Johnson and Phillips, 1965) and carboxypeptidase (Hartsuck and Lipscomb, 197 1) have demonstrated movement of groups when a substrate or inhibitor binds to the active site. Conformational changes in the substrate or the enzyme have also been invoked in attempts to explain how an enzyme might increase the ease of bond-breaking or bond-formation by introduction of steric strain. For an excellent discussion of strain and conformational effects in enzyme reactions see Jencks (1969). The rack hypothesis of Eyring was an early example (Eyring e t al., 1954). This proposed that, after binding of the substrate to the enzyme, the bond to be broken is stretched by a conformational change of the enzyme. More recently, it has been suggested (Phillips, 1969; Lowe e t al., 1967) but not proved, that when substrates for lysozyme bind to the enzyme, the hexose ring in subsite D is distorted from the normal chair conformation to a half-chair resembling the conformation of the transition state, thus promoting bond breaking.
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
29
To devise analogues of such effects of conformational changes in chemical models is difficult. Almost invariably studies have been directed at elucidating the mechanism of bond-breaking and -making whilst ignoring possible conformational or strain effects. This is necessary in our present state of knowledge of enzymes and of solution chemistry, but for a complete description such effects must be taken into account. A recent example of a chemical study showing how strain effects could be important in an enzymatic reaction, dealt with the hydrolysis of benzaldehyde di-t-butyl acetal [ 181 (Anderson and Fife, 1971b). As shown by a Stuart-Briegleb model, substantial groundstate strain is present which would be partially relieved in the
transition state as the C-0 bond breaks. The rate of the hydronium ion-catalysed reaction is facilitated in comparison with the rate of hydrolysis of the unstrained benzaldehyde diethyl acetal, but more important, general acid catalysis by buffer acids occurs in contrast with the lack of such catalysis in hydrolysis of benzaldehyde diethyl acetals. Ease of bond breaking is the predominant effect in giving rise to general acid catalysis of acetal hydrolysis (Fife, 1972), and in [18] the bond breaking process has been sufficiently enhanced that general acid catalysis is observable. Distortion of the substrate could, therefore, have important mechanistic consequences as well as an effect on the rate in enzyme-catalysed reactions.
3. GENERAL BASE, NUCLEOPHILIC CATALYSIS: a-CHYMOTRYPSIN a-Chymotrypsin is a proteolytic and esteratic enzyme upon which a monumental amount of experimental effort has been expended (Bender et al., 1964; Bruice and Benkovic, 1966; Jencks, 1969).
30
T. H. FIFE
Chymotrypsin catalysis takes place through a three-step process, equation ( l l ) ,where ES is an enzyme substrate complex which breaks down to give an acylated enzyme intermediate, ES' and P1,
the alcohol or amine portion of the ester or amide substrate. Deacylation then occurs to regenerate the free enzyme and to liberate the carboxylic acid. There is conclusive evidence for involvement of serine-195 and more ambiguous but still convincing evidence for participation by histidine-57 in the catalytic process. This evidence has been extensively reviewed (Bender and Kkzdy, 1964; Bruice and Benkovic, 1966; Bender, 1971). Imidar ole Catalysis
The early problem in regard to the mechanism of action of a-chymotrypsin was to determine how serine and histidine could participate with maximum effectiveness in the hydrolysis of esters and amides. In 1957 it was found that imidazole would act as a nucleophile towards p-nitrophenyl acetate (Bender and Turnquest, 1957a; Bruice and Schmir, 1957). When the pK,-value of the conjugate acid of the phenolic leaving group exceeds that of imidazolium ion by 3 pK,-units, general base assistance of imidazole attack becomes important (Bruice and Benkovic, 1964; Kirsch and Jencks, 1964). With aliphatic esters, imidazole general base catalysed attack of water is the only observable mechanism. The influence of the pK,-value of the leaving group on mechanism reflects the necessity of an attacking species with a basicity comparable to that of the leaving group. Bruice and Sturtevant, (1959) and Bruice, (1959) found extremely facile intramolecular nucleophilic attack by neighbounng imidazole in the hydrolysis of p-nitrophenyl y-(4-imidazoyl)butyrate [ 191. The rate constant for imidazole participation (release of p-nitrophenolate) in this reaction is nearly identical with the rate constant for a-chymotrypsin catalysed release of p-nitrophenolate ion [ 190 min-' ; K 2 in equation (11) at pH 7 and 25'1 from p-nitrophenyl acetate. Comparison of the rate constant for intramolecular imidazole participation t o that for the analogous bimolecular reaction (imidazole attack on p-nitrophenyl acetate) (s-' /M s - l )
-'
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
31
gives a value of 9-4 M for the effective molarity of the neighbouring group (Bruice and Benkovic, 1963). Neighbouring imidazolium ion participation was also observed in the hydrolysis of the corresponding amide (Bruice and Sturtevant, 1959), proceeding with
nucleophilic attack by the basic imidazole group on the protonated amide. However, there was no intramolecular participation in hydrolysis of the methyl ester. This cast serious doubt upon the ability of imidazole to act as a nucleophile in acylation reactions of chymotrypsin, which is a good catalyst for hydrolysis of methyl and ethyl esters of the aromatic amino-acids, tyrosine, phenylalanine, or tryptophan. The y(4-imidazoy1)butyrate system does not afford maximum opportunity for participation since the imidazole ring is not held adjacent to the carbonyl group; nevertheless, nucleophilic participation by imidazole has not to date been observed in cases where the pK,-value of the leaving group is much greater than that of the attacking base. Imidazole will function as a general base in the hydrolysis of acyl-activated esters such as ethyl dichloroacetate (Jencks and Carriuolo, 1961) and esters where the pK,-value of the leaving group is 2-3 units lower than that of ethanol and methanol such as
NHC * CH3
/ \
H
H
It
0
32
T. H. FIFE
2,2-dichloroethyl acetate (Bruice et al., 1962a) or N,O-diacetylserinamide (Anderson et al., 1961; Milstien and Fife, 1968). The mechanism in these examples involves proton transfer in the critical transition state as shown by ratios of rZY2 '/k:Ao of 2-3. Thus, the most likely mechanism is [ 201 or a kinetic equivalent. Intramolecular general base catalysis has been detected in the case of 2-(4-imidazoyl phenyl acetate) (Felton and Bruice, 1968, 1969), mechanism [21a]
being proposed on the basis of the magnitude of TAS' (-8.9 kcal mole-' ) and the D, 0 solvent isotope effect (kH o/kD = 3.23). Intramolecular general base catalysis of hydrolysis (21a) was unexpected since the ester has a phenolic leaving group. Felton and Bruice (1968, 1969) reasoned that, if nucleophilic attack occurred, the leaving phenolate ion group would be properly positioned to attack the intermediate acylimidazole and thereby reverse the reaction. The normally less efficient general base reaction then becomes the favoured pathway, as in hydrolysis of acetyl salicylate (see Section 4). Likewise, Fife and McMahon (1970) explained bimolecular general base catalysis by imidazole (21b) in hydrolysis of 0-(4-nitrophenylene) carbonate (k:; /I$!,' = 3.49) by reversibility of the nucleophilic reaction by neighbouring phenoxide ion. There is now convincing evidence that an acyl chymotrypsin intermediate is formed from both specific and non-specific substrates (Bender and Ktzdy, 1964; Bender e t a/., 1964). This intermediate is undoubtedly an acylserine. Acyl- and phosphorylserine derivatives have been isolated and identified. In view of evidence such as a D20 solvent isotope effect (kH o / k D ) of 2- 3 for both acylation and deacylation (Bender and Hamilton, 1962), alcohol and amine nucleophiles showing little dependence on the pK,-value of the nucleophile in reaction with furoyl enzyme (Inward and Jencks, 1965), and the influence of increasing steric bulk in the acyl group (Fife and Milstien, 1967; Milstien and Fife, 1968, .1969), consistent
'
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
33
with a general base mechanism, it is now generally believed that histidine is functioning as a general base in both acylation and deacylation [equation (13)] or by a kinetically equivalent process. The reaction in equation (13) has been depicted as proceeding with formation of tetrahedral intermediates. 0
II
RC-OR'
0
+ R'OH
The pH-dependence of chymotrypsin-catalysed hydrolysis of formylphenylalanine formylhydrazide and semicarbazide substrates implies the existence of an intermediate between the Michaelis complex and the acyl enzyme which is probably a tetrahedral intermediate (Fersht and Raquena, 1971; Fersht, 1972). A difference was found in the pK-value of the Michaelis complex determined from V , a x and K , measurements. The Iower apparent pK,-value of kcat (6.08) was attributed to a pH-dependent change in rate-determining step for acyl enzyme formation. At low pH the rate-determining step in acylation was considered to be formation of the intermediate from the Michaelis complex, whereas at high pH breakdown of this intermediate to acyl enzyme is rate-limiting. Such a change in rate-determining step is consistent with that found by Blackburn and Jencks (1968) in aminolysis of methyl formate, the microscopic reverse of the dcoholysis of an amide, and Cunningham and Schmir (1967) for intramolecular alcoholysis of y-hydroxybutyranilide. In contradiction, Lucas et al. (1973) have recently reported that, in the case
34
T. H. FIFE
of N-formylphenylalanine formylhydrazide, pK-values influencing V m a X and K , are almost identical. In an investigation of achymotrypsincatalysed hydrolysis of acetyl tyrosine and acetyl tryptophan anilide substrates, Caplow (1969) favoured a scheme in which build-up of a tetrahedral intermediate occurs when an electron-withdrawing substituent is present. A nitrogen isotope effect (1*006,1-010,and 1.006 at pH 6.73, 8.0, and 9-43)has been observed in the chymotrypsin-catalysed hydrolysis of N-acetyl-L-tryptophanamide which requires the C-N bond of the amide to be broken in the rate-determining step (O’Leary and Kluetz, 1972). The isotope effect is similar to that observed for the reaction of amides with hydroxide ion which is known to proceed through a tetrahedral intermediate. The Hammett p-value for a-chymotrypsin-catalysed acylation (k ) of phenyltrimethyl acetates is +1.4 (Bender and Nakamura, 1962), whereas that for hydrolysis of substituted anilides of N-acetyl-Ltyrosine is - 2 0 (Inagami et al., 1965). These values are most easily interpreted as indicating that phenyl esters containing a good leaving group form tetrahedral intermediates in the rate-determining step, but that amide substrates, where the leaving group is poor, hydrolyse with rate-determining breakdown of the tetrahedral intermediate and require general acid catalysis by the imidazolium ion. Protonation in the rate-limiting step would give rise to the negative value of p observed with anilides. Philipp et al. (1973), however, found little dependence of k c a t on pK, for the leaving group for N-acetyl-Ltyrosinamides. All of this evidence supports the existence of tetrahedral intermediates in a-chymotrypsin-catalysed reactions, but it should be noted that 0-exchange with water is not observed in deacylation of cinnamoyl-’ 0-chymotrypsin, in contrast with the hydrolysis of 0-cinnamoyl-N-acetylserinamidewhere such exchange is detected (Bender and Heck, 1967). Lack of exchange in the enzyme reaction could reflect interactions of the tetrahedral intermediate with the protein. Acylation and deacylation in equation (13) proceed through similar transition states. If deacylation occurs through attack of an alcohol molecule R’OH rather than water on the carbonyl carbon atom, then deacylation is the microscopic reverse of acylation. Bender and coworkers (Bender and Kizdy, 1965) have demonstrated the symmetry of the reaction about the acyl enzyme in reactions in which reversibility can be observed.
PHYSICAL. ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
35
Hubbard and Kirsch (1972) have recently proposed that histidine may act as a nucleophile in a-chymotrypsin acylation reactions of esters having a good leaving group (p-nitrophenol). This suggestion was based on a similarity in p-value for acylation by p-substituted nitrophenyl and dinitrophenyl benzoates and nucleophilic attack on these compounds by imidazole, in contrast with less positive p-values for hydroxide ion catalysis. Hammett p-values for hydrolysis of substituted phenyl esters are given in Table 6 and show little apparent trend. The values for hydroxide ion and alcoholate ions are TABLE 6 Rho Values for Hydrolysis of Phenyl Esters Reaction
+
Imidazole OHtris(Hydroxymethyl) aminomethane anion Pentaerythritol NH3 Hydrazine Trimethylamine
p
Ref.
1.9
n
1.0
0.64 0.98 2.1 2.9 2.6
1-3
b
1.7
c
22
d
1.46
f
0
HN
0
\ / II
0
+
Enz ( K z ) ~
36
T. H. FIFE
TABLE 6-continued
p
Ref.
2.1
g
1.21 0.97 2.01
h, i
1.73 Enz ( k ~ l K $ ~ 1.60 OH2.20
h, i
Reaction
+
Imidazole Enz ( k z / K d e OH-
+ Imidazole
\ /
~ - @ + b N 0 2
\ /
Bruice and Benkovic, 1964. Bruice and Sturtevant, 1959. Bruice and Pandit, 1960a. Caetjens and Morawetz, 1960. orChymotrypsin. f Bender and Nakamura, 1962. g Caplow and Jencks, 1962. Hubbard and Kirsch, 1972. f 33%CH3CN-HzO;r = 0.3. Bruice and Benkovic, 1963. a
*
less than for any other catalyst and may reflect a transition state with little bond breaking. The p-values for the less basic catalysis are more positive, and it will be noted that p for intramolecular carboxylate is comparable or greater than the values for the more basic nitrogen nucleophiles. Substituent effects in the leaving group are much larger in cyclization of monophenyl glutarates and succinates than in acetate ion catalysed hydrolysis of phenyl esters p = 1-1 (Gaetjens and Morawetz, 1960). The p-value will, of course, depend on transition state structure which can be altered upon going from a bimolecular reaction
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
37
to an intramolecular reaction. Thus, there is little basis for drawing mechanistic conclusions from comparisons of p in bimolecular reactions and the intracomplex reactions of an enzyme. Nucleophilic attack on the acyl enzyme p-nitrophenoxycarbonylchymotrypsin, where the leaving group has a pK,-value comparable to that of histidine, takes place by a group in the active site which is most probably histidine (Fife et a1.,1972; Hutchins and Fife, 1972; Bender and Wedler, 1972), showing that nucleophilic attack is sterically possible [equation (14)]. p-Nitrophenolate ion is released
b’
+ -0
HN-N
and a partially inactive enzyme is produced. Nucleophilic attack is, however, markedly hindered; the effective molarity of histidine in the nucleophilic reaction is only 0.2 M in comparison with the rate constant calculated for imidazole attack on the acyl enzyme in a bimolecular reaction (Hutchins and Fife, 1972). In contrast, the effective molarity of neighbouring imidazole in substituted phenyl y-(4-imidazoyl)butyrates ranges from 9-4 M to 33 M (Bruice and Benkovic, 1963). Deacylation also takes place to a nearly equal extent by a mechanism not giving an inhibited enzyme which must be the normal general base mechanism. When the leaving group and the catalysing base are of comparable pK,, nucleophilic attack is the only reaction usually observed in non-enzymatic reactions. If histidine is the nucleophile in deacylation of p-nitrophenoxycarbonylchymotrypsin then it must be located in an environment which seriously restricts its ability to function as a nucleophile. X-ray crystallographic analysis of a-chymotrypsin reveals that the carboxyl group of aspartic acid-102 is hydrogen bonded to histidine-57 in the interior of the protein (Blow et aL, 1969). Blow has proposed involvement of aspartate-1 02 in the catalytic process by means of what was termed a “charge relay” system [22] which would produce a negative charge on the serine oxygen. The pK,value of a carboxyl group in a hydrophobic environment in the
38
T. H. FIFE
P21
interior of a protein might be quite high so that the anionic species could be a powerful general base catalyst, but there is no evidence that this is actually a feature of chymotrypsin catalysis. Polgar and Bender (1969) have instead suggested that the function of aspartic acid-102 is to form a hydrogen bond to histidine-57 and thereby to stabilize on it the proton which is received from serine in the initial step of the reaction. This proton could then be donated to the leaving group when the tetrahedral intermediate partitions to products. Hunkapiller et al. (1973) have recently inferred from NMR data that the pL-value of ca. 7 in serine proteases is actually that of aspartic acid while histidine has a lower pK, ( < 4 ) so that at pH-values from 3-6-7 these residues will be neutral. A mechanism was proposed, utilizing the asp-102-hist-57-ser-195 charge relay system which would avoid charge separation. Rogers and Bruice (1974) have measured rates of hydrolysis of aryl acetates containing a 2-imidazole group with a carboxyl group substituent within hydrogen bonding distance of the imidazole nitrogen [23]. Hydrolysis is by pathways previously determined for esters of this type without carboxyl group substitution [ Z l ] . N o 0 + N
1231
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
39
transfer of the acetyl group was detected. Only a %fold rate facilitation can be attributed to the carboxyl group in the imidazole general base catalysed attack of H2 0. In 94% CH, CN-6% H2 0, no enhancement of catalysis is observed. Unequivocal assignment of pK, -values in both water and organic mixed solvents shows no inversion of carboxyl and imidazolyl base strengths. Numerous attempts have been made to explain why the serine oxygen is such a potent nucleophile in a-chymotrypsin. The “charge relay” mechanism of Blow e t al. (1969) is only one of these attempts. What all such explanations have not taken into account is the enormous effective molarity of an oxide ion nucleophile in an intramolecular reaction ( l o 6 - l o 8 M ; Hutchins and Fife, 1973a, b). Oxide ions are therefore normally powerful intramolecular nucleophiles, and even at the low concentrations determined by their pK, (13.6 in N-acetyl serineamide; Bruice e t al., 1962b) and the pH of the solution, the reaction will be rapid. It is probable that the rates of a-chymotrypsin reactions will eventually be accounted for in terms of the normal chemical properties of the species involved without invoking extraordinary features due to the protein. In view of the reduced ability of histidine to function as a nucleophile even when the leaving group in the reaction is p-nitrophenol and the great efficiency of a hydroxymethyl group as an intramolecular nucleophile (see below), it is not surprising that the role of histidine-5 7 in a-chymotrypsin catalysed reactions should be that of a general base catalyst or its kinetic equivalent.
Hydroxyl Group Catalysis Bender and Glasson (1959), in studies of alcoholysis and hydrolysis of alkyl esters in aqueous alcohol, found that the rate of disappearance of ester is decreased by increasing alcohol concentration. However, product analysis led to the conclusion that both methanolysis and ethanolysis are faster than hydrolysis in alcoholwater mixtures. It was calculated that in pure water attack by hydroxide, methoxide and ethoxidr ions would occur at about the same rates. Bruice and Lapinski (1958) reported that logarithms of secondorder rate constants for reaction of p-substituted phenoxide ions with p-nitrophenyl acetate were a linear function of the pK,-value of the phenol with a slope of 0.8. Phenolate ions cannot displace
T. H. FIFE
40
alkoxide ion from an alkyl ester. Tni-(hydroxymethy1)aminomethane (Jencks and Carriuolo, 1960; Bruice and York, 1961) will displace p-nitrophenolate from p-nitrophenyl acetate. Jencks and Carriuolo favoured a mechanism in which the amino-group acts as an intramolecular general base for transesterification. Bruice and York, however, determined that the reaction involving the amino group was simple aminolysis (It; * '/kFzo = 1.0). Transesterification, k F 2 ° } k t 2 0 = 0.55, occurs by a specific base catalysed pathway CH2 0-
CHz OH
I
H,N--C--CHzOH 1
CH20H
+-OH
I
S NHz-C-CH20H + H2O I CH2 OH
(15)
0
+
[equation (15)]. Pentaerythritol (pK, = 14) also transesterifies p-nitrophenyl acetate in an apparent hydroxide-catalysed reaction. The reaction of oxyanions with p-nitrophenyl acetate was reported to be characterized by a linear plot of log I t , us. pK, of the nucleophile with a slope of 0.78 (Bruice et al., 1962b). N-acetylserinamide, a model for the active site serine of a-chymotrypsin, displays normal reactivity for an alcohol of pK, 13.6. Likewise N,O-diacetyl serinamide undergoes base-catalysed hydrolysis at a rate in accord with the pK,-value of the leaving group and a slope of -0.3 in a plot of log koH vs. leaving group pK, for a series of acetate esters. Jencks and Gilchrist (1962) reported a non-linear plot of log kT us. pK, for reaction of oxyanions with p-nitrophenyl acetate. Jencks and Gilchrist (1968) also reported curved plots of the logarithms of the rate constants us. pK, of oxyanion nucleophiles for esters with varying leaving groups. Curvature is most pronounced with the esters having the poorer leaving groups e.g., phenyl acetate. The slope changes from -1.0 to -0.3 as the basicity of the nucleophile increases. Thus, the sensitivity of the reaction to basicity is greater with weakly basic anions and esters with poor leaving groups.
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
41
These results arise either from a change from rate-determining formation to breakdown of a tetrahedral intermediate or from a continuous change in a concerted reaction in which there is no intermediate. Attack of strongly basic oxygen anions on esters with good leaving groups is characterized by rate constants proportional t o those obtained for hydroxide ion catalysed hydrolysis. The rate constants increase with increasing pK, of the nucleophile and decreasing pK, of the leaving group. Very weakly basic nucleophiles (acetate ion) act predominantly as general base catalysts. The types of transition states shown in [ 241 are in accord, where [a] represents the transition 6-
0
1:
0
6-
1:
6-
6-
RO-------C---OR'-
RO---C-------OR' I
I
R
R
state when pK, (nucleophile, OR-) < pK, (leaving group, OR'-) and [b] the case pK, (nucleophile) > pK, (leaving group). If tetrahedral intermediates are formed (a) would then represent rate-limiting breakdown ( / z - ~> k 2 ) and (b) rate limiting formation (k2 > k - I ) of the intermediate in equation (16). 0 RO-
+
II
RC-OR'
0kl k-1
0
I
k2
I
k -2
RC-OR'
II
RC-OR
+ -OR' (16)
OR
Oakenfull and Jencks (1971) have investigated reaction of oxygen anions with the model amide N-acetylimidazole and N-acetyl imidazolium ion. The pKa-value of the leaving group of the neutral compound is 14.2, and that of the protonated species is 7.0. The reactions are uncomplicated by general acid-base catalysis, unlike corresponding aminolysis reactions. The plot of log k, for reaction of the protonated species us. pK, of the nucleophile shows pronounced curvature with a slope varying from 0 to 1.7. There is little sensitivity of the reaction to base strength for nucleophiles of high pK,. Phenolate and trifluoroethoxide have almost identical reaction rates, in spite of their 100-fold difference in basicity. This indicates that there can be little bond formation in the transition state (25a) (rate-determining attack, if there is a tetrahedral intermediate). A
T. H. FIFE
42
slope of 1.7, for weak bases is identical to the slope of the graph of the logarithms of the equilibrium constants for transfer of the acetyl group to acyl acceptors us. the pK, of the acceptor. Hence, there must be considerable C-N bond breaking in the transition state [25b] for the sensitivity of the rate constants and equilibrium con-
stants to pK, of the nucleophile to be the same. The plot of log k, is reasonably linear with neutral N-acetylimidazole for all nucleophiles and has a slope of 1.3, signifying a transition state resembling products with expulsion of imidazole anion. Toward neutral N-acetylimidazole, trifluoroethoxide is 1O5 times more reactive than phenolate ion. Oakenfull and Jencks conclude that reactions of strong bases with neutral and protonated species proceed by a concerted pathway in one or both cases, or, alternatively, that there is a tetrahedral addition intermediate whose lifetime is too short for it t o reach equilibrium with respect t o proton transfer. Since serine-195 is the site of acylation, a good deal of recent work has been directed towards determining the efficiency of neighboring alcohol and phenol groups as intramolecular nucleophiles in ester and amide hydrolysis. In comparison with acetamide and butyramide, the hydrolysis of y-hydroxybutyramide [equation (17)] in the alkaline and neutral pH-range is accelerated 800-fold (Bruice and Marquardt, 1962). These reactions are attack of alkoxide ion on the neutral and protonated amide function,
us. pK,
Jt
-k
H+
43
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
respectively. Both general base and general acid catalysis was reported (Belke et al., 1971) in the lactonization of 2-hydroxymethylbenzamide [equation (18)] . The Bronsted 0-value for general base catalysis is 1.0, indicating that proton transfer is diffusioncontrolled (Eigen, 1964). A Bronsted plot of log k, us. pKa of the 0
I1
-
-
"H2
~
CH2 OH
0
II
W O + NH3 \ (18)
catalysing base shows apparent curvature, the slope changing t o 0.2 at high pK,. Belke et al. (1971) interpreted this as signifying a change in rate-determining step at about pH 8 from decomposition of a tetrahedral intermediate at low pH to formation of a tetrahedral intermediate at more alkaline values. Okuyama and Schmir (1972) have come t o the opposite conclusion from studies of the decomposition of l-benzylimino-l,3-dihydroisobenzofuran as a function of pH [equation (19)]. A tetrahedral intermediate identical to that of equation (18) is formed. 2-Hydroxymethylbenzamide is the major product at high pH whereas phthalide is the product at low + HNR H+
+
1IHz0
0
I1 C-NHR
HO
e 0
(19)
0
NHR
+ RNH2
CH2 OH
0
II
-0 NHR
-
4
\
d \
o+
RNH2
+ -OH
44
T. H. FIFE
pH, showing preferential amine expulsion from the tetrahedral intermediate at low pH. The conclusion that the Bronsted plot for cyclization of 2-hydroxymethylbenzamide is curved rests heavily on the position of the point for hydroxide ion. A reasonably straight line can be drawn through the other points. It is well known that hydroxide ion generally shows negative deviations in Bronsted plots. Also, Okuyama and Schmir (1972) observed curved plots of k o b s d us. bicarbonate buffer concentration for both reactions (18) and (19), indicating a change in rate-limiting step with increasing buffer concentrations and thereby casting doubt on the Bronsted plot reported by Belke et al. and its mechanistic interpretation.
[26] R = H [27] R = C H 3
I
R
Hutchins and Fife (1973a) studied cyclization of the carbamate esters (26) and (27) having a neighbouring phenolic hydroxyl group. Phenoxide ion is released in the reaction and a benzoxazolinone is produced in quantitative yield. These reactions are very rapid, requiring stopped-flow rate measurements, in contrast with the great stability normally exhibited by carbamate esters. Compound [ 271 cyclized approximately 10 times more rapidly than [ 261 . Aromatic carbamate esters with hydrogen on nitrogen can undergo elimination to give an isocyanate at rates lo6 times greater than for hydrolysis of N-substituted carbamates where such elimination is precluded (Bender and Homer, 1966). In view of the similarity in rate constants for cyclization of [ 261 and [27], it is likely that the mechanism is the same for both, i.e., nucleophilic attack by the oxygen anion on the ester carbonyl. The pH-rate constant profile for cyclization of the N-methylated ester [27] is sigmoid (Figure 1) with pK,,, = 8.9. Hydroxide ion catalysis is not observed, even at pH-values as high as 13. In the case of [26], however, apparent hydroxide ion catalysis is
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
45
detectable at high pH. Buffer catalysis is not observed in any of the cyclization reactions. Therefore the reactions must involve preequilibrium ionization of the phenolic hydroxyl to phenoxide ion as in equation (20).
PH
Figure 1. Plot of kobsd for ring closure of phenyl N-(2-hydroxypheny1)-N-methyl carbamate to N-methyl-2 benzoxazolinone and phenoxide ion at 25" in HzO with /J = 0.5 M (with KCl).
Intermolecular alcoholysis of carbamate esters will also take place, but the reactions are very slow. In comparison with intermolecular nucleophilic attack by a phenoxide ion of the same pK, on the unsubstituted ester [ 281, the effective molarity of the neighbouring phenoxide ion of [27] is 3 x lo8 M. Thus, a phenoxide ion is an
extremely powerful intramolecular nucleophile for attack at the ester carbonyl. A comparable effective molarity ( l o 8 M ) has been determined for neighbouring carboxylate in carboxyl group assisted phenolic ester hydrolysis (Bruice and Turner, 1970). These are the largest effective molarities that have been determined to date for neighbouring groups in ester hydrolysis reactions. T h e largest effective molarity of a neutral nitrogen base is 5 x lo3 M found for the dimethylamino-group of p-nitrophenyl ydimethylaminobutyrate (Bruice and Benkovic, 1963).
46
T. H. FIFE
Part of the great efficiency of the intramolecular reactions of [ 261 and [27] is undoubtedly due to the correct alignment of the rigidly held nucleophile and carbonyl group. Molecular models show that in one of the conformations of [27] in which steric interactions are minimized, the phenoxide ion is immediately adjacent to the carbonyl group and in an excellent position for perpendicular attack (Bender, 1960); but other factors must also be important. Correct orientation would not explain why anionic nucleophiles are superior to neutral nucleophiles. Extensive studies have not been carried out with nitrogen nucleophiles in carbamate ester hydrolysis, but Hegarty and Frost (1972) found that carbamate [29] underwent elimination to an isocyanate. This can be contrasted with the
nucleophilic attack occurring with [26] and in reaction of the analogous carbamate with an ortho-carboxyl group which proceeds with nucleophilic attack by the carboxylate anion (Frost and Hegarty, 1973). Release of phenoxide is approximately 1O6 times faster than in the case where the carboxyl group is in the paraposition. The difference in basicity of the phenoxide nucleophile of [26] and the amine group of [29] makes firm conclusions difficult, but an aromatic amine and a carboxyl should have similar pK,values. A possible explanation for the great efficiency of anionic nucleophiles in intramolecular reactions is that desolvation of the nucleophile is not as energetically unfavourable as in corresponding bimolecular cases where the anion would be highly solvated in the ground state. Desolvation of anions in solution is energetically difficult (Gibson and Scheraga, 1967). Bruice and Turner (1970) found that the effective molarity of neighbouring carboxylate in ester hydrolysis is not altered appreciably on changing the solvent from H20 to lhrl H,O-DMSO, but it is not certain that a carboxylate anion would be completely desolvated in the latter case: Hydroxide ion is highly solvated by HzO in that solvent (Goitein and Bruice, 1972). Any explanation of the efficiency of anionic nucleophiles in intramolecular reactions must at the present time be
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
47
speculative, but the observation of effective molarities of 10' M is striking and undoubtedly of importance in regard to the reactivity of the serine hydroxyl that is acylated in reactions of serine proteases. Participation by neighbouring alkoxide ion is observed in the cyclization of p-nitrophenyl and ethyl esters of 2-hydroxymethyl-Nmethylcarbanilic acid [30] -[33] (Hutchins and Fife, 1973b). As with the carbamates having a neighbouring phenolic hydroxyl, ring R O
I 1I
0
N-C-OR'
[30] R = H;
R' = p-nitrophenyl R' = p-nitrophenyl
CH2 OH
[ 311 R = CH3 ; [32] R = H; [33] R = C H 3 ;
R' = -Et R'=-Et
closure occurs t o give a quantitative yield of the corresponding cyclic compound, and buffer catalysis is not observed in any case. The unmethylated nitrophenyl ester [ 301 releases p-nitrophenoxide ion 1O4 times more rapidly than does the corresponding N-methylated ester [31] , so that it is probable that an isocyanate intermediate is being produced [equation (21)]. Cyclization still occurs quite rapidly with [31], koH , the second-order rate constant for hydroxide H O
a N = ' = O
~301
I
+
- O e N 0 2
CH2 OH
ion catalysis, being 3 x lo5 times greater than k O H for the hydrolysis of p-nitrophenyl N-methyl carbanilate. The value of koH for [31] is lo5 times greater than the second-order rate constant for transesterification of p-nitrophenyl N-methylcarbanilate by pentaerythritol (pK, of the hydroxyl groups of pentaerythritol is 14). Ring closure also occurs rapidly with the ethyl esters [32] and [33]. The k O H values for these reactions are nearly the same and
48
T. H. FIFE
1.3 x lo6 times greater than koH for the hydrolysis of ethyl Nmethylcarbanilate. Both reactions must involve intramolecular nucleophilic attack by the neighbouring alkoxide ion on the ester carbonyl. Plots of log kobsd us. pH for cyclization of these compounds are linear with slopes of 1.0, indicating apparent hydroxide
ion catalysis. This fact, plus the lack of buffer catalysis, shows that pre-equilibrium ionization of the hydroxymethyl group is occurring as in equation (22). According to the scheme of equation (22), K O
is given by equation (23), where K, is the dissociation constant of the hydroxymethyl group and Kw is the ionic product of water. The effective molarity of the neighbouring hydroxymethyl groups in compounds [30]-[33] cannot be calculated, since this would require evaluation of k I from equation (23). This cannot be accomplished because K , cannot be directly measured. However, from the linear pH-rate constant profiles, it is apparent that pK, is no lower than 14. Assuming a pK,-value of 14 for the N-methylated ethyl ester, a lower limit of the effective molarity of the neighbouring group of l o 5 M can be calculated from the comparison with the hydroxide ion-catalysed hydrolysis of ethyl N-methylcarbanilate. Considering that a kinetically less favoured 6-membered ring transition state is being formed, compared to a 5-membered one with the compounds having neighbouring phenoxide, it appears that neighbouring alkoxide and phenoxide ions are comparable in
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
49
catalytic efficiency. Bruice and Pandit (1960b) found that intramolecular carboxylate attack on phenyl esters was 230 times faster with succinate than glutarate monoesters (Table 2). Thus, as with phenoxide ions, alkoxide ions are extremely powerful nucleophiles towards esters but only in intramolecular reactions. Buffer catalysis is observed in the intramolecular tranesterification of ethyl 2-hydroxymethyl benzoate to phthalide [equation (24)] (Fife and Benjamin, 1973). There is general base catalysis by 0
cikEt <\
CHzOH
N+NH
I1
+
+ EtOH CH2
(24)
+ Im
[341
imidazole and a variety of other bases. The D,O solvent isotope effect for imidazole catalysis (kzo/kfm20) is 3-46, showing that proton transfer is occurring in the critical transition state. The mechanism could therefore be closely analogous to the mechanism for acylation of a-chymotrypsin by ethyl esters [equation (13) or a kinetic equivalent]. A Bronsted plot of log k, for general base catalysis us. pK, of the catalysing base is linear (Figure 2) with a slope (p) of 0.87, showing that proton transfer is nearly complete in the transition state. The cyclization reaction to phthalide is quite rapid. The second-order rate constant for apparent hydroxide ion catalysis, k O H , is l o 5 times greater than koH for the hydrolysis of ethyl benzoate (Bender, 1951). Buffer catalysis is not seen in cyclization of the carbamate esters [26], [27], and [30] -[33]. This is possibly because the acyl group is strongly deactivated by the adjoining nitrogen, necessitating nucleophilic attack by a fully developed negative charge. The acyl group of the benzoate ester [34] is not as deactivated and nucleophilic attack will proceed much more readily, allowing proton transfer t o become part of the rate-limiting step. General base catalysis of the cyclization of ethyl 2hydroxymethyl Pnitrobenzoate [ 3 5 ] , where the acyl group is further activated by electron withdrawal by the nitro-substituent, is characterized by a Bronsted coefficient of 0-97, i.e. unity within the limits of error, suggesting that proton transfer is a diffusion-controlled process (Fife
50
T. H. FIFE
4 -
2-
c
I
u
%
c
-5
O-
m 2
OI
-0 -2 -4
CH3COO-
5
7
9
11
13
15
PK, Figure 2. Bronsted plot of log kg us. pK. for the catalysing base in the cyclization of ethyl 2-hydroxymethylbenzoate to phthalide at 30" in H 2 0 (u= 0-5).
and Benjamin, unpublished data). Considering the observed rate constants for the reaction, it is apparent that, if proton transfer is diffusion-controlled, then it must be preceded by an equilibrium step. Thus, the mechanism is general base catalysed decomposition of a tetrahedral intermediate [equation ( 2 5 ) ] or the kinetically equiva-
0
II
+ EtO-
+ BH*
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
51
lent process of equation (26). The rate-determining step for intramolecular carboxylate ion attack on phenyl esters may be breakdown of a tetrahedral intermediate (Goitein and Bruice, 1972), whereas in bimolecular hydroxide ion catalysis formation of a tetrahedral intermediate is rate-determining (Gaetjens and Morawetz, 1960; Bruice and Pandit, 1960b). The attack step in an intramolecular reaction is facilitated in comparison with bimolecular counterparts, and departure of the leaving group may be rate-limiting in cases where the nucleophile is less basic than the leaving group. 0
0
+ H+
0
II
+ EtOH + B From the second-order rate constant for imidazole-catalysed cyclization of the ethyl ester (34) (8 x l o m 3M -ls-l) and the rate constant for acylation of a-chymotrypsin by N-acetyltyrosine ethyl ester (1600 s - l ) , it can be calculated that, in order to attain a rate constant of the magnitude seen in the a-chymotrypsin reaction, a neighbouring imidazole would have to possess an effective molarity of 200,000 M . An effective concentration of this magnitude is not unreasonable, but it is probable that other factors are also important in the enzymatic reaction. Aryl esters of 4-hydroxybutyric acid, 5-hydroxyvaleric acid, 2hydroxyphenylacetic acid, and 3-(2-hydroxyphenyl)propionic acid lactonize with rate constants proportional to lopH - p K w (Capon et al., 1973). The second-order rate constant at 30" for lactonization of phenyl 4-hydroxybutyrate is cu. 3000 times greater than k, for hydrolysis of phenyl acetate at 25". Lactonization of phenyl 4hydroxybutyrate is catalysed by acetate and phosphate buffers in
52
T. H. FIFE
what was considered to be general base-catalysed reactions although no further evidence was presented. Imidazole catalysis of phenoxide ion release proceeds with nucleophilic attack by imidazole at the carbonyl of the ester. In this system therefore, where the leaving group is a phenol, general base-catalysed intramolecular alcoholysis is
not sufficiently advantageous to compete with nucleophilic attack by imidazole. It would be quite important to determine whether this is the case when the alcohol group is rigidly held close to the carbonyl in contrast with the 4-hydroxybutyrate system where degrees of rotational freedom exist. Belke et al. (1971) reported general base and general acid catalysis in cyclization of 2-hydroxymethylbenzamide [equation (18)] . However, with 2-hydroxymethyl-6-aminobenzamidestrict general base catalysis by buffer bases is observed with a Bronsted coefficient of 0 3 9 (Fife and Benjamin, unpublished data). In contrast with the unsubstituted amide, the Bronsted plot is nicely linear. An aminogroup in the 6-position might assist decomposition of a tetrahedral intermediate as in [37a, b] or a kinetic equivalent. The pH-rate constant profile for spontaneous cyclization at zero buffer concentra-
tion is very similar in shape to that of 2-hydroxymethylbenzamide. There is hydronium ion catalysis, hydroxide ion catalysis, and a pH-
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
53
independent reaction, but the values of kobsd for the pH-indepdndent reaction at 30" are 10 to 100 times less than those for 2-hydroxy__ rnethylbenzamide at 40'. The value of k o H is lo3 timesless than that for the 4-amino-derivative (0 = 0.43) where the effect of the substituent group is entirely electronic. Thus, a 6-amino-group greatly reduces the rate instead of promoting the reaction.
2
4
6
8
1 0 1 2
PH
Figure 3. Plot of log hex for 3-amino-24tydroxymethybenzamide (rate constant obtained by extrapolation to zero buffer concentration) us. pH at 30" and p = 0.5 in 50% dioxane-H2O (v/v) 0 and 50%dioxane-D2O 0 . The rate constants are for appearance of product (4aminophthalide).
The neighbouring amino-group of 3-amino-2-hydroxymethylbenzamide facilitates the pH-independent cyclization between pH 3.5 and 10 (Fife and Benjamin, 1974), as seen in Figure 3. That reaction proceeds lo3 times faster than in the case of the 6-amino-, 5-amino-, or unsubstituted derivatives. There is no clearly defined pH-independent reaction with the 4-amino-substituted amide because of relatively rapid hydroxide and hydronium ion catalysis. The point of intersection of these limbs on the pH-rate constant profile, which gives a maximum rate constant for a possible pHindependent reaction, is s-l at 30°, l o 3 times less than for the 3-amino-derivative. An amino-group in the 3-position could interact only with the hydroxymethyl group. Intramolecular general base catalysis is indicated by the D20solvent isotope effect ( k ~ 2 0 / k ~ z o = 2.82) and the lack of bimolecular general base catalysis observed with the other 2-hydroxymethylbenzamides in the series. The effective molarity of the neighbouring group, in comparison with catalysis by an amine of pK, 3.5 in cyclization of the 4-amino-amide, is 15 M . A Stuart-Briegleb model shows that the stenc situation is
54
T. H. FIFE
not favourable for the concerted process shown in [38]. Substantial restriction of rotational freedom would be required, as reflected in the AS* of -23 e.u. for pH-independent cyclization, thus explaining
the small effective molarity of the intramolecular general base. Such restriction is perhaps an important reason why bifunctional mechanisms are uncommon. General base catalysis through one or more solvent molecules [39] would be in accord with the highly negative AS* and would avoid the steric complications of mechanism [38]. The steric situation would
be more favourable if the 3-amino group of [38] is replaced by a 3-methylamino-group. A seven-membered ring for proton transfer would be required, but since the hydroxyl group must approach the carbonyl carbon in a concerted reaction the resulting steric fit would be excellent. The 3-methylamino-compound is at present being studied in our laboratory. Neighbouring phenoxide ion will act as an intramolecular general base in situations where nucleophilic attack is precluded. Bender et al. (1963) found such catalysis in the hydrolysis of p-nitrophenyl 5-nitrosalicylate. Mechanism [401 was favoured over the kinetically equivalent hydroxide ion attack on the neutral species, the reason
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
55
being that charged nucleophiles, such as fluoride or azide, the action of which might be aided by general acid catalysis by the unionized hydroxyl group but not by general base catalysis by the ionized
species, do not have an enhanced rate constant for reaction with the neutral species. Similar evidence and reasoning was employed in assigning an intramolecular general base mechanism t o hydrolysis of ethyl 2-hydroxy-5-nitrophenyl carbonate [4 11 (Fife and Hutchins, 1972). Intramolecular general base catalysis in these systems
produces only moderate rate increases in comparison with spontaneous hydrolysis of the neutral compound, 30-fold with p-nitrophenyl 5-nitrosalicylate and 50-fold in the case of the carbonate ester. Bruice and Tanner (1965) have also reported intramolecular general base catalysis in hydrolysis of o-hydroxybenzamide [ 421.
The number of well-established intramolecular general basecatalysed reactions is quite small, but from the available examples a tentative conclusion is possible that such a mechanism is not greatly
56
T. H. FIFE
favoured over bimolecular counterparts and will not afford large rate increases. The largest is l o 3 in hydrolysis of [Zla] . Involvement of solvent in the general base-catalysed reaction may minimize the entropic advantage of an intramolecular reaction. It would appear that rate enhancements in ester hydrolysis reactions comparable to those seen with enzymes will require intramolecular nucleophilic attack with the leaving group breaking away from the remainder of the molecule so that AS* will be favourable. Numerous suggestions have been made that enzymes might owe part of their catalytic efficiency to the opportunity they afford for stabilization of intermediates or transition states by hydrogen bonding to functional groups near the active site. For example, in the case of &-chyrnotrypsin this might be represented as in [43] where O R
0
II I
-N-C-CH-pC-
II
H
[431
the transition state for acylation of chymotrypsin by a tyrosyl ester is being stabilized by hydrogen bonding from amide groups of the protein chain (Henderson, 1970; Robertus et al., 1972). Several examples of facilitation of alkaline hydrolysis of esters by a neighbouring aliphatic alcoholic hydroxyl group have been reported (Henbest and Lovell, 1957; Kupchan et al., 1959; Kupchan and Johnson, 1956; Kupchan and Narayanan, 1959; Kupchan et al., 1960; Zachau and Karau, 1960; Bruice and Fife, 1962). Bruice and Fife (1962) concluded that the neighbouring-group effect on alkaline hydrolysis of acetate esters of cyclopentanediols is due to stabilization of the transition state [44] by internal hydrogen bonding. There was no correlation between the observed rate and ground state hydrogen bonding either with regard to the
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
57
position (carbonyl or alkoxyl oxygen) or to the strength of the hydrogen bond determined by high dilution infra-red studies. The effect must therefore be on the transition state of the reaction. The
influence of the neighbouring hydroxyl group is to make AS* much more favourable, whereas AH* is actually unfavourable in comparison with reaction of the reference compounds cyclopentyl acetate and truns-2-methoxycyclopentylacetate. A similar change of the activation parameters is noted when an ester hydrolysis is transferred from the solvent water to alcohol-water mixtures. Thus the effect of the neighbouring hydroxyl group in the cyclopentanediol acetates can be looked upon as an internal solvation. The alcoholic hydroxyl group would not solvate the transition state as well as water, resulting in a less favourable AH*,but fewer water molecules would have to be restricted in the transition state giving a much more positive AS*. Rate enhancements in the cyclopentanediol series are fairly small. In comparison with hydrolysis of cyclopentyl acetate, cis-l,2-cyclopentanediolmonoacetate hydrolyses 33 times and the truns-isomer 1 7 times more rapidly. trans-2-Methoxycyclopentyl acetate hydrolyses 3 times faster than cyclopentyl acetate. Inductive effects of neighbouring hydroxyl and methoxyl groups are nearly identical (Taft, 1956). While small, the rate increases due to a neighbouring hydroxyl group are significant and show that transition state stabilization is chemically reasonable and quite possibly a factor in enzymatic catalysis. The magnitude of the acceleration that might be obtained from such an effect will, of course, depend upon the nature of the transition state. Transition state stabilization would be of the greatest importance in reactions having highly solvated polar transition states. This is the case in ester and amide hydrolysis reactions when bond-making with a nucleophile or bond breaking in decomposition of a tetrahedral intermediate has progressed to a substantial extent.
T. H. FIFE
58
A neighbouring hydroxyl group provides little rate enhancement in the general base-catalysed hydrolysis of acyl-activated esters (Bruice et al., 1962a). The imidazole-catalysed hydrolysis of trans-2hydroxycyclopentyl dichloroacetate is only 2 times faster than that of the 2-methoxy-substituted ester. A consequence of the strong acyl activation is that in the transition state for formation of the tetrahedral intermediate there would be little bond-making with the attacking nucleophile and therefore little charge development on the carbonyl oxygen. Acyl group activation would greatly facilitate attack of a nucleophile. Cyclodextrins are cyclic polymers of glucose having 1 , k t - D glucopyranose units in a staggered chair conformation (Hybl et al., 1965). The molecules are cylindrical in shape. The 2- and 3-hydroxyl groups are located around the top of the cylinder and the 5-hydroxy methyl groups at the bottom. The cyclodextrins are of interest because of their ability to form inclusion compounds within the cavity with a variety of organic molecules. With suitable substrates such binding may be followed by reaction of the substrate with a hydroxyl group of the cyclodextrin. Thus, these compounds can be considered unique model enzymes. Spectral shifts due to binding of dyes indicate that the interior of the cavity is much less polar than H, 0. The hydrolysis of substituted phenyl acetates has been studied in the presence of cyclodextrins (Van Etten et al., 1967a, b). No correlation was found between the rate constants for hydrolysis and 0 for the substituent group. Specificity was directed towards metasubstituents. m-t-Butylphenyl acetate hydrolyses 240 times faster in the presence of 0.01 M cyclohepta-amylose. Comparison of spectral shifts upon inclusion of p-t-butyl and m-t-butylphenol indicated that benzene rings of p-substituted phenols are included within the cavity of cyclodextrins [45] but that the benzene ring of the meta-isomer )
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
59
[46] extends into the aqueous solvent. 4-Nitrophenol binds to cyclos-l (Cramer et at., dextrin with a rate constant of about 10' M 1967), whereas the rate constant for binding of 1,3-substituted compounds is only about 10 M s-'. A double displacement reaction (27) was shown to occur with aryl benzoates (Van Etten, 1967b).
-'
-'
J
9 NO*
0
-
+
fJ
In accord with the above scheme, variation of the meta-substituent altered the rate of acylation but not that of deacylation. The reaction of equation (27) is similar to reaction of a-chymotrypsin with phenolic esters.
60
T. H. FIFE
Brass and Bender (1973) have recently studied reaction of bis (ib-nitrophenyl) carbonate with cyclohepta-amylose. MichaelisMenten kinetics were observed, and two equivalents of p-nitrophenol released. Release of the first equivalent of p-nitrophenol is ratedetermining, the second one being released in a fast step. The latter
+ -
O
G
t
X
-
O
O
x
process is an intramolecular reaction of a second adjacent hydroxyl group on the cycloamylose forming a cyclic carbonate diester, demonstrating once more the effectiveness of a hydroxyl group as an intramolecular nucleophile.
Mechanistic Conclusions The mechanism given in equation (13) for a-chymotrypsin is almost certainly correct in its essential details. The evidence is strong and for the most part convincingly in favour of general base catalysis by histidine in both acylation and deacylation or a kinetic equivalent. Wang and Parker (1967) have argued for a kinetic equivalent possibility in which the serine anion is the nucleophile, attacking a partially protonated substrate, but Williams (1970), Fersht (1971), and Phillip et al. (1973) have discounted this mechanism. The only serious chdlenge to the picture of equation
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
61
(13) in recent years is the suggestion by Hubbard and Kirsch (1972) that acylation of the enzyme by phenolic substrates entails nucleophilic attack by histidine. Comparative p-values for the enzyme reaction and for imidazole attack on substituted nitrophenyl and dinitrophenyl benzoates do not however provide compelling evidence. Nucleophilic attack does take place in deacylation of p-nitrophenoxycarbonyl-a-chymo trypsin, but is much less favourable than in corresponding intramolecular reactions (Hutchins and Fife, 1972). In view of the extremely large effective molarity of a neighbouring alcohol group in an intramolecular reaction, it is likely that the serine hydroxyl is the attacking nucleophile, regardIess of the nature of the leaving group. A problem in the chymotrypsin mechanism concerns the nature of general base catalysis. Does histidine partially abstract a proton from the serine hydroxyl? Does it catalyse decomposition of a tetrahedral intermediate formed by nucleophilic attack of the serine oxygen anion? Or does histidine catalyse both nucleophilic attack by serine and decomposition of the tetrahedral intermediate? When the leaving group is poor as with amides and esters of aliphatic alcohols, catalysis of the decomposition of a tetrahedral intermediate to product may be required (as in the general base-catalysed intramolecular alcoholysis of the ester [35] ). When the leaving group is a phenol, it is probable that formation of the tetrahedral intermediate will be rate-determining, with acylation assisted by catalysis of nucleophilic attack. The positive p-values for acylation by aryl acetates and trimethylacetates do not require electrophilic catalysis, but Williams (1970) found little sensitivity of k c a t and k c a t / K mto substituents in the leaving group of aryl hippurates. Bender et al, (1964) made an attempt to explain the rate constants attained in a-chymo trypsin reactions as follows for N-Acetyl-Ltryptophan amide: Rate constant for hydroxide ion-catalysed hydrolysis
3x
1 0 - 4 ~ u r - ls-l
(1) Conversion to an intermolecular general base-catalysed reaction involving imidazole (1.6 x 4.8 x 1 0 - ' o ~ - ' s - l
(2) Conversion to an intramolecular general base-catalysed reaction involving imidazole 4.8 x 10-9 (10 M )
s-l
62
T. H. FIFE
(3) Change in rate determining step ( l o 2 )to an alcoholysis (4) Freezing of substrate specificity ( l o 3 ) (5) General acid catalysis by imidazole ( l o 2 ) Experimental rate constant
4.8 x 10-7 s-l 4.8 x 10-4 s - l 4.8 x s-’ 4-4x s-1
This type of analysis is desirable in enzymatic reactions. However, at the time of its presentation, only very rough estimates could be given of the effect of some of the presumed factors on the rate. From work on ester and amide derivatives of 2-hydroxymethyl benzoic acid, more accurate numbers can now be ascribed to these factors. Thus, conversion to an intramolecular alcoholysis will give a rate enhancement of lo5 times in comparison with hydroxide ion-catalysed ester and amide hydrolysis, rather than the factor lo2 estimated by Bender. The effective molarity for an amino-group acting as an intramolecular generd base in intramolecular dcoholysis of [38] is only 15 M. Bender’s estimate of the effective molarity of histidine-57 is therefore possibly close, but the unfavourable alignment of groups in [38] for a concerted reaction leads to the conclusion that much more efficient reactions would occur if orientation were favourable as in the active site of an enzyme. Nevertheless, on the basis of model work, there is a partly unexplained factor of 10-lo2 in the rates of acylation of a-chymotrypsin by amide substrates. Bender and coworkers (1964) found the difference in rate constants for deacylation of acetylchymotrypsin and Nacetyltyrosylchymotrypsin to be entirely in a more favourable AS* for deacylation of the acyl enzyme derived from the specific amino-acid substrate. It was postulated that the aromatic acyl group binds in a specific site so that the resulting steric situation is more favourable for the ensuing reaction. Bender termed this “freezing of substrate specificity”. The effect appears to be similar to that of geminal substitution on intramolecular nucleophilic attack by the carboxyl group in glutarate monoesters which is also manifested in a more favourable ASq (Bruice and Bradbury, 1968). Thus achymotrypsin exerts an effect on specific substrates that is akin to proximity effects in simple intramolecular reactions and which enhances the rate by a factor of approximately lo3 in comparison with nonspecific substrates. In like manner, increased steric bulk in the acyl group of acyla-chymotrypsin progressively retards the rate of deacylation [ 6 in the
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
63
Taft equation, log ( k 3 / k 0 ) = p*o* + 6 E s , is -1.0; Fife and Milstien, 19671 , but hexanoylchymotrypsin displays an enhanced rate of deacylation. The point for the hexanoyl group lies well above the line in a plot of log ( k 3 / k 0 ) us. E s , probably because of binding of the hexanoyl group in a hydrophobic site. Furthermore, the more rapid reaction of hexanoyl- than acetyl-chymotrypsin is again entirely due to a more favourable AS*. Compensation may take place in deacylation of acylchymoirypsins with straight-chain acyl groups, AH* becoming more unfavourable as AS* becomes less negative. A plot of AH* us. AS* is linear (Fife and Milstien, 1967). This was confirmed by Martinek et al. (1972) who also found a parallel linear plot in deacylation of N-acyl amino-acid acyl enzymes. The difference in AS* for corresponding acyl groups in the .two series is 1 2 e.u. Lumry and Rajender (1972) have observed compensation between AH* and AS * in deacylation of N-acetyltyrosylchymotrypsin as the pH is varied. Among the questions of importance remaining to be answered concerning the chemistry of the a-chymotrypsin reactions are the following: (1) What is the effective molarity of imidazole as an intramolecular general base in intramolecular alcoholysis and hydrolysis? This is perhaps the most important single piece of information that is currently missing for analysis of the rates of a-chymotrypsin reactions in terms of specific catalytic effects. (2) What is the explanation for the large effective molarity of a neighbouring alcohol function in ester and amide hydrolysis? (3) Of what magnitude are orientation effects due to binding of substrate to enzyme? Certainly no more than a factor of lo3 need be ascribed to such effects. (4)What contribution does transition state stabilization make? From the chemical work cited, it is probable that such an effect is small. ( 5 ) Does the charge relay mechanism play an important role and, if so, what rate enhancement would such a mechanism provide? It appears that it will not be necessary to invoke a charge-relay mechanism t o account for the rates of achymotrypsin reactions in terms of known chemistry. The presence of aspartic acid in the interior of serine proteases could, of course, have structural rather than mechanistic significance.
T. H. FIFE
64
4. METALION CATALYSIS: CARBOXYPEPTIDASE A Carboxypeptidase A is a hydrolytic enzyme containing zinc bound at the active site. Carboxypeptidase A catalyses hydrolysis of ester and amide linkages of N-acyl-a-amino-acids and 0-acyl-a-hydroxy acids adjacent to free terminal carboxyl groups (Hofmann and Bergmann, 1940; Snoke, et al., 1948). The complete amino-acid sequence is known (Bradshaw et al., 1969) as well as the threedimensional structure from x-ray crystallographic studies at 2 A resolution (Lipscomb et al., 1968; 1970; Lipscomb, 1970). Such studies were also carried out with glycyl-L-tyrosine bound t o the active site. The following conclusions were drawn: (I) the zinc ion is coordinated to the carbonyl group of the substrate; (2) the carboxyl group of glutamic acid-245 is located in close proximity and is presumably involved in the catalytic action of the enzyme; (3) the phenolic hydroxyl group of tyrosine-248 is also located close t o the substrate. Structure [47] can then represent the active site of carboxypep tidase.
glu-245-c
/
0-
O \
[471
Lipscomb has commented that glutamic acid-245 might act either as a general base or a nucleophile. The available mechanistic information has been reviewed by Kaiser and Kaiser (1972), who postulated that the carboxylate anion of glutamic acid-245 acts as a nucleophile forming an anhydride intermediate [equation (29)]. The divergent DzO solvent isotope effects, k,"$o/k:a$o = 1.33 for the peptide substrate N-(N-benzoylglycy1)-L-phenyl alaninate
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYlL4TIC CAT.4LYSE
63
and 2.0 for the specific ester substrate O-(trans-cinnamoyl)-L-& phenyl-lactate, were explained by rate-limiting formation of the anhydride in the case of the peptide substrate and rate-limiting breakdown of the anhydride with the ester substrate. It is known that spontaneous hydrolysis of anhydrides proceeds with a sizable D20 solvent isotope effect (Butler and Gold, 1961), whereas rate-limiting nucleophilic attack should give a rate constant ratio in the two solvents near unity. It must, of course, be borne in mind that mechanistic interpretation of D20 solvent isotope effects in enzymatic reactions is difficult (Jencks, 1963). Co(II1) carboxypeptidase., which /R2
I,:="[ exchanges ligands slowly, is fully active in ester hydrolysis but has lost all peptidase activity (Kang and Storm, 1972). Thus, mechanisms for ester hydrolysis through a substrate-metal ion complex are quest ionable. There are three fundamental questions concerning the mechanism of action of carboxypeptidase: ( 1 ) How do metal ions affect ester and amide hydrolysis? (2)Under what conditions will a neighbouring carboxyl group participate in ester and amide hydrolysis and what is the mechanism of such participation? (3) How will a metal ion affect
66
T. H. FIFE
intramolecular carboxyl group participation in ester and amide hydrolysis? These are questions pertaining to the chemistry of ester and amide hydrolysis which should be answerable from model studies. There is considerable information concerning questions ( 1) and (Z), but the experimental difficulties in attempts to answer question (3) are formidable, for example, finding a system where carboxyl-group participation is possible but where the metal ion does not bind the carboxyl group. Metal-ion Catalysis of Ester and Amide Hydrolysis
Metal-ion catalysis has been extensively reviewed (Martell, 1968; Bender, 1971). It appears that metal ions will not affect ester hydrolysis reactions unless there is a second co-ordination site in the molecule in addition to the carbonyl group. Hence, hydrolysis of the usual types of esters is not catalysed by metal ions, but hydrolysis of amino-acid esters is subject to catalysis, presumably by polarization of the carbonyl group (Kroll, 1952). Cobalt (11), copper (11), and manganese (11) ions promote hydrolysis of glycine ethyl ester at pH 7-3-7-9 and 25", conditions under which it is otherwise quite stable (Kroll, 1952). The rate constants have maximum values when the ratio of metal ion to ester concentration is unity. Consequently, the most active species is a 1 :1 complex. The rate constant increases with the ability of the metal ion to complex with amines. The scheme of equation (30) was postulated. The rate of hydrolysis of glycine ethyl R
H0
R'CH-C
EtOH+
I
1
'.+ p
H2N,
M
#'
-
R -0
I
I I
CH-C-OEt
/ H2N.
0
',+ /'
M
ester and phenylalanine ethyl ester in glycine buffer depends on the concentration of glycine co-ordinated to Cu++. Bender and Turnquest (1957b) found ratios of khYdrolysis/kexchange = 3.9 for
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
67
Cu++-catalysed hydrolysis and 5.4 for alkaline hydrolysis of 180-labelled ester. Formation of the tetrahedral intermediate in the scheme of equation (31) is indicated by the observed 80-exchange. However, interactions of the carbonyl oxygen and the metal ion
hydrolysis
exchange
might not permit the tetrahedral intermediate to become completely symmetrical so that the ratio of 12hydro,ysis/12exchange need not have been expected. An alternative mechanism could involve intramolecular attack of Cu++-bound hydroxide ion (Bruice and Benkovic, 1966). There is a difference of approximately lo6 in rate between the Cu+ -catalysed and alkaline hydrolyses of dl-phenylalanine ethyl ester. Comparison of rate constants for hydrolysis of phenylalanine ethyl ester at 25" and pH 7-3 for catalysis by hydronium ion, hydroxide ion, and Cu++ (0-0775 M ) is of interest in showing the facility of the reaction promoted by the metal ion. Under these conditions the respective rate constants are 1-46 x lo-' s - l , 5.8 x s - l , and 2.67 x s-l (Bender and Turnquest, 195713). The following relative second-order rate constants have been obtained for hydroxide ion-catalysed hydrolysis: glycine ethyl ester, 1; protonated glycine ethyl ester, 41; and the cupric ion complex of glycine ethyl ester, 1.3 x l o 5 (Conley and Martin, 1965). The large effect of the cupric ion cannot be due entirely to electrostatic effects, but rather to catalysis by direct co-ordination with the ester function. Metal-ion catalysis in these systems could take place by coordination of the metal ion with the amino-group and either the +
68
T. H. FIFE
carbonyl oxygen [48a] or the alkoxyl oxygen [48b]. In either case the metal ion would polarize the carbonyl group, thereby promoting attack of hydroxide ion. Coordination to the carbonyl oxygen would
also stabilize the transition state for attack of hydroxide ion. Catalysis might also be explained if the metal ion binds both substrate and hydroxide ion, as suggested for the hydrolysis of ethyl oxalate and ethyl malonate catalysed by calcium, barium and thallium(1) (Hoppe and Prue, 1957). Metal ions will catalyse hydrolysis of a number of amides where the metal ion can complex to another functional group besides the amide group (Meriwether and Westheimer, 1956). Metal ion effects are apparently not as large in the hydrolysis of amides as in that of esters; glycinamide hydrolyses only 30 times faster in the presence of 0 0 2 M copper(I1) ion at pH 7-9-9-35. This must be due to the different leaving groups. If the effect of metal ion is to facilitate nucleophilic attack at the carbonyl group, then the observed rate enhancement could be less in amide hydrolysis where the poor leaving group makes breakdown of a tetrahedral intermediate ratedetermining, the tetrahedral intermediate partitioning preferentially to starting material. Ni++-ion produces a 400-fold enhancement in the hydroxide ion-catalysed hydrolysis of 1,I O-phenanthroline-2carboxamide (Breslow, et al., 1967). Much larger rate accelerations are seen in the hydration of phenanthroline carbonitrile, Ni++giving lo', C u + + lo9, and Z n + + 104-fold enhancement. The large rate increases are due entirely to more favourable AS* values. In all of these studies the free metal ion is in equilibrium with the complex species and ligand exchange can occur. Stable cobalt(II1) ion complexes with which ligand exchange does not occur were prepared by the scheme of equation (32) (Alexander and Busch, 1966; Buckingham et al., 1967a, b, c), and were isolated and characterized. Large rate enhancements in hydrolysis are observed in comparison with the uncomplexed esters for attack of H z O at pH 1-4, but it is of greatest interest that the reactions are markedly catalysed by general bases. It has been observed that
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
c1
C1
69
0
I
catalysis by both oxygen and nitrogen bases takes place in the hydrolysis of cobalt-chelated glycine isopropyl ester (Buckingham et al., 1970a, 1972; Alexander and Busch, 1966). In view of the different Bronsted 0-values (0.4 for oxygen bases and 0-8 for nitrogen bases) and the large D20 solvent isotope effect for catalysis by chloroacetate, ( K D o / k , 0 = 5 , it was originally concluded that catalysis by nitrogen bases followed a nucleophilic mechanism but that oxygen bases functioned as classical general bases. However, it was later shown by competition experiments that both types of bases were nucleophiles (Buckingham, et al., 1972). It should be noted that the metal ion in these systems is not exerting a catalytic effect since the metal ion is incorporated during synthesis of the compound to give a highly reactive molecule, tantamount to synthesis of a protonated ester. Glycine amide chelated through its carbonyl oxygen and terminal nitrogen atoms and peptide complexes of the type C CON^ (glyNR1R 2 ) ] show lo4 to 106-fold rate increases for hydroxide ioncatalysed hydrolysis compared to the unco-ordinated amides (Buckingham e t al., 1970b). Amides in this system hydrolyse l o 5 - lo6 times more slowly than esters. Monodentate amides and esters show only small rate enhancements. Buckingham calculates that the carboxypeptidase-catalysed hydrolysis of benzoylglycyl-r.phenylalanine is -lo4 times faster than would be afforded by C o + + + activation. It is unlikely that divalent Z n + +would be more effective at polarizing the carbonyl group of a peptide than Co+++.Although direct activation of a carbonyl group by metal ions can result in large + + +
70
T. H. FIFE
rate enhancements for hydrolysis (-lo6), the enzyme must also be exerting an extra effect. Hydrolysis of the cis [Co(en);?OHglyNH2)]++ion [49] requires a rate at least l o 7 times greater than hydrolysis of the unco-ordinated glycine amide (Buckingham et al., 1 9 7 0 ~ )Thus . amide hydrolysis via coordinated hydroxide is rapid. Buckingham points out that, if attack of bound hydroxide is rate-determining, (1) the rate of hydrolysis will be maintained at biological pH-values since the complex will exist mainly in the hydroxo form (pK, 6); and (2) despite the greatly reduced basicity of coordinated hydroxide (-lo8), it is a much more efficient nucleophile than hydroxide ion from the solvent. If loss of ammonia from a tetrahedral intermediate were rate-determining, a second-order rate constant 1O7 times greater than that for the hydrolysis of glycine amide would be required. The Co +++-induced intramolecular hydrolysis reaction is much more efficient than direct metal-ion polarization of a carbonyl group. A increases the effective zinc-hydroxide mechanism in which Zn
-
+
0
-
II
+%NHzCH2 C-NH2 (en)2Co,0H
+
+ 3 / NH2 \
(en)2Co
b-c
CH2
I
+
[491 0
(33)
\o
NH3
concentration of bound hydroxide was considered as a possibility for carb oxypep tidase . The Ni++- and Zn++-complexes of phenyl and salicyl esters of pyridine-2,6-dicarboxylic acid [ 50a and b] hydrolyse much faster than the uncomplexed esters (Breslow and McAllister, 1971); the rate of hydroxide ion catalysis of the Ni++-complexesincreases 9300
and 3100 times, respectively. The Ni++-complex of the salicyl ester hydrolysed 1.7 times more rapidly when the salicyl carboxyl group was ionized than when it was unionized. On this basis it was
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
71
suggested that the carboxylate anion was exerting a weak catalytic effect. A metal ion complex of pyridine carboxaldoxime [51] is an excellent catalyst for deacetylation of 8-acetoxyquinoline-8-sulfonate
(Breslow and Chipman, 1965). The metal-nucleophile combination is quite reactive toward a coordinating substrate compared with p nitrophenyl acetate. Reaction of the m-nitrophenyl ester of pyridine-2,5-dicarboxylic acid with cyclodextrin (see Section 3) gives a picolinate ester [52] of a cyclodextrin secondary hydroxyl group (Breslow, 197 1; Breslow and Overman, 1970) which will bind metal ions or a metal ionpyridine carboxaldoxime complex. Such a complex will catalyse hydrolysis of p-nitrophenyl acetate bound within the cyclodextrin cavity leading to a rate constant approximately 2000-fold greater at
pH 5.11 than in the absence of catalyst. Binding to cyclodextrin gives only a modest rate enhancement factor of 4 in comparison with the Ni++-pyridine carboxaldoxime-complex acting alone. A Cu++cyclodextrin picolinate ester will cause p-nitrophenyl glycinate to hydrolyse about four times faster than in the presence of C u + + alone. Although showing modest effects, these studies are of interest
72
T. H. FIFE
as attempts to demonstrate the influence of a metal ion in systems where an ester is hydrophobically bound in proper steric relationship with a nucleophilic group. Sigman et al. (1972) have reported an example of metal-ion facilitated phosphorylation of an alcohol by adenosinetriphosphate (ATP). Complexing of the metal ion, ATP, and 2-hydroxymethyl-
phenanthroline (1:1:1) brings the terminal phosphoryl group of ATP and the hydroxymethyl group into the proper relationship for the ensuing reaction. Reaction takes place through the alcoholate anion and is analogous to an intramolecular alcoholysis. Sigman reasons that complexing takes place as shown in [53a] or [53b]. The metal
A-O-
ion serves several apparent functions: (1) it binds Z-hydroxymethylphenanthroline and ATP together; (2) it promotes attack of the alcoholate ion by polarizing the substrate or by screening the negative charge of the phosphoryl group; and (3) it lowers the pK,-value of the alcohol to 7.5 so that an appreciable fraction is ionized at experimental pH-values. Acetylation of the alcohol by p-nitrophenyl acetate in the presence of a metal ion was also observed. This system is not, of course, a model for the carboxypeptidase reaction, but it does illustrate nicely the possible effects of a chelated metal ion.
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
73
Carboxyl Group Catalysis More information is available on carboxyl as an intramolecular catalyst in ester and amide hydrolysis than on any other functional group. It was earIy found that aspirin [54] hydrolysed readily and gave a pH-rate constant profile signifying participation by the carboxyl group in the ionized form (Edwards, 1952; Garrett, 1957). A nucleophilic mechanism was originally preferred [equation (35)] but several pieces of evidence have cast doubt on this interpretation. The value of AS* is -24-7 e.u. (Garrett, 1957), considerably more negative than expected in a unimolecular reaction, and the reaction is 0
0
I I
(35)
slower in D 2 0 than HzO ( J Z H 2 0 / J Z D 2 0 = 2-2). A D 2 0 solvent isotope effect near unity is expected for a nucleophilic reaction (Butler and Gold, 1960). Substituent effects in the 4- and 5-positions of the benzene ring were interpreted to be in accord with a general base process, [55], as are the AS* value and Dz O solvent isotope effect (Fersht and Kirby, 1967). Furthermore, it was found, contrary
to the report of Bender et al. (1957), that 8 O is not incorporated into the salicylic acid product when the reaction is run in water
T. H. FIFE
74
enriched in " 0 (Fersht and Kirby, 1967). Lack of 180-incorporation is not consistent with a nucleophilic mechanism. General acidcatdysed attack of hydroxide ion is unlikely because of the magnitude of the calculated rate constants for such a reaction and because general acid catalysis of the attack of other oxygen nucleophiles is not observed. The 3- and 5-nitrosalicylates also hydrolyse with general base participation by the carboxyl group, even though the leaving group is a nitrophenol (Fersht and Kirby, 1968a). The carboxyl group does act as a nucleophile in hydrolysis of acetyl 3,5-dinitrosalicylate [ 561, as shown by incorporation of l 8 0 into the 3,5-dinitrosalicyIate product. However, the D 2 0 solvent isotope effect is 2-0 and AS* is -20-6 e.u. Fersht and Kirby reason that an intermediate anhydride is formed, the decomposition of which is rate-determining and catalysed by the adjacent phenoxide ion in a general base mechanism.
[561
products
A bell-shaped pH-rate constant profile is obtained in hydrolysis of 3-acetoxyphthalic acid [ 571 although bifunctional catalysis is not possible (Fersht and Kirby, 1968b). Kirby concludes that both carboxyl groups are involved in the reaction in a stepwise manner 0
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
75
which he terms “series nucleophilic catalysis”. The second carboxyl group causes the hydrolytic rate constant of [57] to be 6.3 x l o 3 times larger at pH 3-8 than that for ionized acetylsalicylate. 3Hydroxyphthalic anhydride was ascertained to be an intermediate in the reaction [equation (37 ) ]. Carboxyl group participation has also been investigated in the hydrolysis of phthalate monoesters. Bender et al. (1958a) reported a pH-rate constant profile for hydrolysis of monomethyl phthalate showing maximum participation by the dissociated carboxyl group. An anhydride intermediate and nucleophilic attack by the carboxylate ion on the neutral ester were postulated. It was later reported that the undissociated carboxyl group is the catalytic species in the hydrolysis of monomethyl 2,3-di-t-butyl succinate, and monomethyl 3,6-dimethylphthalate, which give anhydride intermediates (Eberson, 1964). In contradiction of the work of Bender, Thanassi and Bruice (1966) found a pH-rate profile for hydrolysis of monomethyl phthalate showing maximum participation by the carboxyl in the undissociated form. The carboxylate ion is probably attacking the
eYH+
0
0
I
+
- a) OH
0
p c H 3
CH30H
+
o y y II
II
0
0
protonated species [equation (38)]. The corresponding phenyl ester, where the leaving group is of low basicity, did hydrolyse with participation by the ionized carboxyl group [equation (39)]. The leaving
-
a\: ; o II
0
+
(\- t o/ -
(39)
76
T. H. FIFE
group of N-acetyl serinamide or propargyl esters is of intermediate basicity (pK,-values of the alcohols are 13.6 and 13.5 respectively), and the hydrolysis is pH-independent over the entire range studied. Hence, the two mechanisms are energetically comparable with. esters having such leaving groups. The pH-rate constant profile for hydrolysis of phthalamic acid showed participation by the undissociated carboxyl group, and an anhydride intermediate was detected (Bender, 1957; Bender et al., 1958b). Hydrolysis was l o 5 times faster than in the case of p-carboxybenzamide. A four-center mechanism [ 581 was postulated.
II
0 ~581
The D2O solvent isotope effect for such a reaction should be large since proton transfer is occurring in the transition state, but the = 1-5).As suggested reaction is actually faster in D2 0 ( k , /KH by Bender, nucleophilic attack by the carboxylate ion on the protonated amide [equation (40)] may be the actual mechanism. Thus, the
II
0
II
0
I
0
mechanisms for the amide and the methyl ester are probably similar, requiring protonation of the poor leaving group before nucleophilic attack by the carboxylate anion can occur.
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
77
While a carboxylate anion is a potent nucleophile in an intramolecular reaction it is not powerful enough to displace methoxide or an unprotonated amine, unless the nucleophile and the carbonyl group are held even more rigidly than in the phthalate system. Kirby and Lancaster (referred to by Kirby and Fersht, 1971) have found that such displacement can occur in disubstituted maleate monoesters and amides. The estimated rate constant for cyclization of N-methyl dimethylmaleamic acid [equation (41)] is 16,000 times greater than that for the unsubstituted compound. Below pH 5.6 hydrolysis of the cyclic anhydride becomes rate-determining. 0
0
II
I1
-
0
0
-
products
(41)
0 + CH3 NH2
An ionized carboxyl group can displace methoxide ion from methyl hydrogen diisopropyl maleate (Aldersley et al., 19 72). There is a plateau in the pH-rate constant profile from pH 8-14 which was ascribed to reaction catalysed by the carboxylate anion [equation (42)i. 0
i-prIco2 i-Pr
/
i-Pr
co2-CH3
i-Pr
I1 0
- 120 i-Pr
i-Pr
II
4
(42)
y o
+ CH30products
Nucleophilic carboxyl group participation is much more favourable with the phthalate, maleate, glutarate, and succinate monoesters than the acetylsalicylic acid derivatives. Monophenyl phthalate hydrolyses more than lo6 times as fast as aspirin. The carboxylate ion acts as a nucleophile with monophenyl phthalate but as a general base in the case of acetylsalicylic acid, even though the leaving group
78
T. H. FIFE
from both compounds is a phenol. This is probably because with monophenyl phthalate the leaving group breaks away from the rest of the molecule (one particle breaks down to two). A favourable entropy change results which would not occur if the carboxyl group of acetylsalicylic acid acted as a nucleophile, since the leaving group would then still be attached to the remainder of the molecule; much of the advantage of intramolecular nucleophilic attack would thus be 0
I/
0
lost. Furthermore, the neighbouring phenoxide ion of the intermediate compound would itself be a potent nucleophile and should attack the anhydride carbonyl group, leading to marked reversibility in the reaction [equation (43)]. As a consequence, general base catalysis becomes the most favourable mechanism. It can be concluded that, for maximum effectiveness of intramolecular nucleophilic attack, the leaving group must actually break away. Morawetz and Oreskes (1958) postulated that intramolecular general acid catalysis occurs in concert with nucleophilic attack by carboxylate anion in the hydrolysis of the monoanion of succinyl salicylate. At pH 4 the observed hydrolytic rate constant was found to be lo4 times greater than that for hydrolysis of acetylsalicylate. A 0
II
0
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
79
bell-shaped pH-rate profile was in accord with bifunctional catalysis, but Maugh and Bruice (1971) ruled out concerted bifunctional catalysis after examining the para-carboxyl derivative. The profile is similar to that for 3-acetoxyphthalate and a similar mechanism involving series nucleophilic catalysis [equation (44)] is possible. A carboxylate anion is an efficient nucleophile in succinate and glutarate monoesters (Section 2). Gaetjens and Morawetz (1960) varied substituents in the phenolic leaving group. A linear plot of the logarithms of the rate constants us. (T is obtained, with a p-value of +2-2, close to that for ionization of phenols. Furthermore, differences in rate within each series are due to differences in AS'. These results were interpreted as indicating a concerted mechanism [59] with considerable bond breaking in the transition state. They are equally consistent with rapid formation of a tetrahedral intermediate whose breakdown is rate-limiting.
A carboxylate anion will function as an intramolecular nucleophile even when there is a large difference in pK, between the attacking species and the leaving group. Thus, with a p-methoxy-substituent in the phenyl succinate and glutarate series ApK, will be 5-6, and catalysis is still nucleophilic, in marked contrast to corresponding intermolecular reactions where a ApK, of 2- 3 is sufficient to change the mechanism to general base catalysis. The acetate-ion catalysed hydrolysis of p-nitrophenyl acetate proceeds in large part by a general base mechanism (Oakenfull et al., 1966; Gold et al., 1968). The ability of an intramolecular carboxylate anion to act as a nucleophile in spite of a poor leaving group is a reflection of the extremely large effective molarity of such a group. The effective molarity of the carboxyl group of p-methoxyphenyl 3,6-endoxo-A-4tetrahydrophthalate is 10' M in comparison with acetate-ion catalysed hydrolysis of p-methoxyphenyl acetate (Bmice and Turner, 1970).
80
T. H. FIFE
Mechanistic Conclusions It is apparent from the above discussion that much less can be said in a conclusive manner about the carboxypeptidase mechanism than that of a-chymotrypsin. While the general features of carboxypeptidase catalysis are understood (Kaiser and Kaiser, 1972), the critical experiments that would allow a quantitative explanation of the rates of carboxypeptidase-catalysed reactions have not been performed. What is needed specifically is knowledge of the effect of a metal ion on intramolecular carboxyl group participation in ester and amide hydrolysis. The important work of Buckingham and coworkers on hydrolysis of Co+++-complexed amino acid esters comes close, in that oxygen bases were found to catalyse hydrolysis. However, in those reactions the metal ion is built into the ground state of the molecule, and catalysis is not intramolecular. Consequently, the effects are striking but do not provide the necessary information. The metal-ion complexes of the salicyl ester of pyridine-2,6-dicarboxylic acid might be taken as models for carboxypeptidase action (Breslow and McAllister, 1971), but the rate increase associated with the salicyl carboxylate ion is too small to permit conclusions. Kaiser and Kaiser (1972) concluded that the most likely role for the carboxyl group of glutamic acid-245 is that of a nucleophile. In view of the presence of a metal ion (super acid) and possible general acid catalysis by a tyrosine hydroxyl group, it is probable that, in the active species, glutamic acid-245 is ionized. A nucleophilic mechanism is more probable than general base catalysis because, when they are sterically possible, intramolecular nucleophilic processes are much more effective. The few examples of intramolecular general base catalysed-reactions occur in systems where nucleophilic attack is hindered because of an unfavourable steric situation or because the leaving group does not break away from the rest of the molecule (“endocyclic displacement”). A factor of great importance in promoting a nucleophilic mechanism could be that a carboxylate ion is involved since the effective molarity of such a group in an intramolecular or intracomplex reaction ranges up to 10’ M. The original postulation of general acid catalysis by tyrosine-248 rested on closeness of that group to the amide function of the substrate in the crystal. However, the conformation in the crystal and solution states may be different in regard to the position of tyrosine248 (Riordan and Muszynska, 1974). Thus, mechanistic inferences concerning that group may not be warranted.
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
81
5. GENERAL ACID CATALYSIS: LYSOZYME
General Acid Catalysis Lysozyme is a glycosidic enzyme of particular interest since the complete amino-acid sequence is known (Jollks, 1964; Canfield, 1963), as is the three-dimensional structure from x-ray crystalloresolution (Blake e t al., 1965; Johnson and graphic studies at 2 Phillips, 1965). Substrates for lysozyme include polysaccharides composed of alternate repeating units of N-acetylglucosamine (NAG) and muramic acid (NAM). Polysaccharides made up entirely of N-acetylglucosamine repeating units will also serve as substrates. It is likely that carboxyl groups from glutamic acid-35 and aspartic acid-52 are part of the active site. Several mechanisms have been suggested for lysozyme (Phillips, 1966; Lowe e t al., 1967; Raftery and Rand-Meir, 1968). All of these mechanisms involve glutamic acid-35 acting as a general acid, partially donating a proton to the leaving group in the transition state. A proposal [60] recently receiving support entaiIs general acid catalysis by glutamic acid-35 and electrostatic stabilization of a developing carbonium ion by the carboxylate anion of aspartic acid-52 (Raftery and Rand-Meir, 1968). A from the glycocarboxyl oxygen of glutamic acid-35 is located 3 sidic oxygen of the leaving group in the reaction, allowing proton
a
a
I I
CHzOH
H
NHCCH?.' .,
II
0
-c
I
transfer readily to occur. The pK,-value of this carboxyl group may be abnormally high so that a significant percentage would be in the un-ionized form at the pH-values at which the enzyme displays maximum velocity. Macroscopic pK,-values of 4-5 and 5.9 have recently
82
T. H. FIFE
been assigned to aspartic acid-52 and glutamic acid-35 respectively, ir 0 1 5 M KC1 and at 25" (Parsons and Raftery, 1972), although this work has been challenged (Banerjee et al., 1973). Kinetically determined values of pK,,, are 3.8 and 6-7 for k c a t and 4-2 and 6-1 for k c , , / K , (Banerjee et al., 1973) in hydrolysis of the P (1-+ 4) linked hexasaccharide of N-acetylglucosamine at 40" and p = 0.1. A role for aspartic acid-52 has been difficult to ascertain. It could participate in the anionic form as a nucleophile or by electrostatic stabilization of an incipient carbonium ion. A nucleophilic mechanism has been looked upon with disfavour because of the 3 i% distance between the carboxyl oxygen of aspartic acid-52 and C-1 of the hexose unit undergoing cleavage (Vernon, 1967), and no evidence for formation of a glucosyl-substituted enzyme has been found. The evidence that ratios of transfer products (with various alcohols) to hydrolysis products are constant suggests that a carbonium ion intermediate is produced, but is not conclusive (Rupley et al., 1968). Also, upon substitution of deuterium for hydrogen at C-1, adjacent to the bond undergoing cleavage, a k ~ / ratio k ~ of 1.11 was obtained, consistent with formation of a carbonium ion intermediate in lysozyme-catalysed hydrolysis of phenyl-P-NAG-glucoside at pH 3.1, 5.5, and 8.3. Acid-catalysed hydrolysis of phenyl 0-D-glucoside, which goes through a carbonium ion intermediate, has k H / k D = 1.13 while base catalysis gives k H j k , = 1-03 (Dahlquist et al., 1969). Nucleophilic participation by the neighbouring acetamido-group in the substrate has also been postulated, but substrates lacking this group have been developed which give enzymatic rates (Raftery and Rand-Meir, 1968). It is therefore not necessary to invoke such participation to explain the rates attained with the enzyme. The binding site of lysozyme will accommodate six hexose residues (A-F). The carboxyl groups of glutamic acid-35 and aspartic-52 are located between sites D and E. The lactyl groups at C-3 of the NAM residues cannot fit in sites A, C, and E. Therefore NAM residues must be located at sites B and D. Cleavage occurs at the reducing end of the NAM residue in site D (the bond being broken is between residues D and E). In addition to x-ray elucidation of the structure of the crystalline enzyme, the structure of a crystalline complex of lysozyme and tri(N-acetylglucosamine) was determined (Phillips, 1966). The trisaccharide occupied sites A, B, and C. Assuming that binding of a hexamer (adding hexose residues D, E, and F) would not change the conformation of the enzyme, the conformations of the substrate at
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
83
sites D, E, and F were deduced. It was concluded that the ring occupying site D must be distorted to a half-chair because of interartions between the 6-hydroxymethyl group and residues 58 and 108 of the enzyme and the N-acetyl group of the hexose residue bound in site C. It must be emphasized that this conclusion was based on model building and pot direct experimental evidence. Distortion of the substrate in site D from the favoured chair conformation to a half-chair should greatly favour bond breaking at C-1 because a half-chair should resemble the transition state, assuming that a cyclic glycosyl carbonium ion intermediate is being formed. Chipman and Sharon (1969) have estimated that AG for binding in sites A, B, C, E, and F is negative (-5.5 kcalmole-’ in site C) but positive (‘3 to +6 kcal mole-’) in site D, supporting the conclusions based on model building. At the time the mechanism shown in [ 601 was proposed it was not known whether it was even chemically reasonable. Bimolecular general acid catalysis involving proton transfer in the transition state [equation (45)] had never been observed in the hydrolysis of glycosides or simple acetals. Bronsted and Wynne-Jones (1929) had
RCH /OR‘ ‘OR‘
+HA
-
H OR’ RCH::6+ ‘*OR’
(45)
I
found hydrolysis of the orthoesters, ethyl orthoacetate, ethyl orthopropionate, and ethyl orthocarbonate to be catalysed by general acids but had not detected such catalysis with acetals. In subsequent years a number of investigators made a diligent search for general acid catalysis of acetal hydrolysis without success. Capon (1963) and Capon and Smith (1965) had reported that a neighbouring carboxyl group in o-carboxyphenyl 0-D-glucoside [61] and o-methoxymethoxy benzoic acid [62] facilitated the rate of hydrolysis by factors of lo4 and 600 in comparison with the para-substituted
a4
T. H. FIFE
compounds, but the mechanism of the carboxyl group participation remained obscure because of kinetically indistinguishable possibilities.
Prior to 1967 acetal hydrolysis had been found to be a specificacid catalysed reaction with the accepted mechanism [ equation (46)] involving fast pre-equilibrium protonation of the acetal by hydronium ion, followed by unimolecular rate-determining decomposition of the protonated intermediate to an alcohol and a resonance stabilized carbonium ion (Cordes, 1967). An A-1 mechanism was supported by an extremely large body of evidence, but it appeared unlikely that such a mechanism could explain the
RCH,,OR' OR'
+ H30'
a
H RCH
+ H20
rapid rates obtained in the hydrolysis of glycosides catalysed by glycosidic enzymes functioning near neutrality. A free-energy reaction-coordinate diagram for the specific acidcatalysed A-1 hydrolysis of simple acetals might appear as shown in Figure 4(a) (Anderson and Fife, 1969). Decomposition of the protonated acetal is normally the rate-determining step. To obtain partially rate-determining protonation by hydronium ion [Figure 4(b)] and general acid catalysis, either basicity must be reduced, increasing the height of the peak for the protonation step, and/or the ease of C-0 bond breaking must be increased, decreasing the height of the peak for the bond breaking step. If the two peaks are of comparable height, the reaction might become concerted.
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
85
Employing this as a guide, the author and his coworkers were successful in conclusively demonstrating general acid catalysis in the hydroIysis .of three different types of acetals and ketals, 2-@substituted phenoxy) tetrahydropyrans having electron withdrawing
~
Reaction coordinate Figure 4. Free energy-reaction co-ordinate diagrams for acid-catalysed hydrolysis of simple acetals
substituents in the leaving group [63] (Fife and Jao, 1968; Fife and Brod, 1970), tropone diethyl and ethylene ketals [64] (Anderson and Fife, 1969; Fife and Anderson, 1971b), and benzaldehyde di-tertbutyl acetals [18] (Anderson and Fife, 1971b). With all of these
1631
~ 4 1
compounds the rate constants for buffer acid catalysis are less in D 2 0 than H, 0, indicating that proton transfer occurs in the critical transition state, the reactions proceeding by classical general acid catalysis. This work has recently been reviewed in detail (Fife, 1972), so only a summary of the pertinent conclusions will be given here. Electron withdrawal by the para-substituent in the leaving group of the tetrahydropyran derivatives both lowers basicity and promotes ease of bond breaking. The positive value of the Hammett p-factor for formic acid catalysis (+0*9)in comparison with the negative value for hydronium ion catalysis (-0.9) shows that ease of bond breaking becomes more important as the catalysing acid becomes weaker, i.e., bond breaking has progressed further in the transition state when the catalyst is a weak acid. This conclusion has been supported by secondary deuterium isotope effects (Bull et al., 1971). The
86
T. H. FIFE
reaction is therefore best represented as a concerted process [ 6 5 ] , a representation further supported by the Bronsted coefficient of 0.5 for general acid catalysis in water. The proton should be closest to
the weakest base in the transition state. Consequently, to account for an a-value of 0-5 (implying that the proton is halfway between catalyst and substrate) it is necessary to postulate that basicity is increased in the critical transition state, i.e., the C-0 bond is breaking. That bond breaking is quite facile can be seen from the fact that spontaneous hydrolysis of the p-nitro-derivative is pHindependent at pH-values greater than 4. The D 2 0 solvent isotope effect ( k H /kD 0 = 0.9) and the AS* (-2.2 e.u.) indicate that the pH-independent reaction is a unimolecular decomposition [ 661 made possible by the good leaving group and the moderately stable
carbonium ion intermediate produced in the reaction (Fife and Brod, 1970). Anderson and Capon (1969) similarly showed that the hydrolysis of benzaldehyde aryl methyl acetals is subject to general acid catalysis. The same structural features are undoubtedly important as in the case of phenoxytetrahydropyrans, and again, p is positive in the acetic acid-catalysed reaction. A phenolic leaving group is not by itself sufficient for general acid catalysis to occur if the intermediate carbonium ion is not of sufficiently great stability. Thus, general acid catalysis is not observed in the hydrolysis of phenolic glycosides (Piszkiewicz and Bruice, 1967). A glycosyl carbonium ion is quite unstable owing to inductive electron withdrawal by the ring hydroxyl groups. The tetrahydropyranyl carbonium ion, however, is of moderate stability.
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
87
It is primarily this difference in carbonium ion stability that makes 2-methoxytetrahydropyran 3 x 1O7 times more reactive than methyl a-D-ghcopyranoside (Dyer et al., 1962). A phenolic leaving group and moderate carbonium ion stability must be present together for general acid catalysis to occur; the hydrolysis of 2-ethoxytetrahydropyran is specific acid-catalysed (Fife and Jao, 1968). Low basicity, even in combination with a reasonably stable carbonium ion intermediate, will not permit general acid catalysis if the leaving group is not sufficiently good. Thus, hydrolysis of benzaldehyde methyl S-phenyl thioacetaIs [67] is not subject to general acid catalysis (Fife and Anderson, 1970) even though
hydrolysis of the exactly analogous oxygen acetals is general acidcatalysed. It was shown conclusively that thiophenol is the leaving group in the hydrolysis of the thioacetals. It was important to find general acid catalysis in the hydrolysis of acetals having poor (aliphatic) leaving groups because the natural substrates for lysozyme are of that type. Tropone diethyl ketal 164-1 has a poor leaving group and its basicity is presumably normal, but ease of bond breaking has been greatly enhanced by the extraordinary stability of the intermediate carbonium ion. That such high carbonium ion stability is necessary for general acid catalysis to occur with poor leaving groups was shown by the study of a series of acetals having similar (aliphatic alcohol) leaving groups and carbonium ion intermediates of progressively increasing stability (Fife and Anderson, 1971b). In the series benzophenone diethyl ketal, p , p’-dimethoxybenzophenone ethylene ketal, 2,3-diphenylcyclopropenone diethyl ketal, ferrocene diethyl acetal, and tropone diethyl and ethylene ketal, general acid catalysis was observed only with the tropone ketals. I t is concluded that bimolecular general acid catalysis will be observed in cases where the leaving group is an aliphatic alcohol only when carbonium ion stability approaches that of an alkoxytropylium ion. Benzaldehyde di-t-butyl acetal [ 181 has an aliphatic alcohol leaving group, but the bond breaking process is aided by relief of ground
88
T. H. FIFE
state strain [ 681. The general acid catalysis observed with t-butyl acetals (a = 0.6) (and not detectable with the analogous diethyl acetals) is attributable primarily to greater ease of bond breaking.
General acid catalysis by H,POi and imidazolium cation has recently been detected in hydrolysis of 2-methoxy-3,3-dimethyloxetane [69] (Atkinson and Bruice 1974). Such catalysis must be due t o relief of ground state strain as the ring breaks to give an open-
chain carbonium-ion intermediate [ 701. Initial bond cleavage was accelerated by a factor of at least 5 x l o 5 compared to hydrolysis of simple acyclic acetals by an A-1 mechanism. Relief of ground state
strain can be sufficient, therefore, to allow general acid catalysis when the leaving group is poor and the carbonium ion is not highly stabilized. It should be noted that the open-chain carbonium ion
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
89
would be less stable than the alkoxybenzyl ion from [ 181 but should be more stable than a glucosyl carbonium ion. Giudici and Bruice (1971) concluded that planarity of an acetal would not by itself permit general acid catalysis by buffer acids since none was observed in the hydrolysis of [71]. Consequently, relief of
strain must occur for a change in mechanism when the leaving group is an aliphatic alcohol and the carbonium ion intermediate only moderately stable. From this work the structural features in an acetal or ketal that will give rise to general acid catalysis are clear. General acid catalysis will be seen in hydrolysis of an acetal when the leaving group is good (a phenol) in cases where the intermediate carbonium ion is of moderate stability. General acid catalysis will also occur with acetals having a poor leaving group (an aliphatic alcohol) when the intermediate carbonium ion is of great stability, approaching that of an alkoxytropylium ion, or when relief of steric strain facilitates bond breaking. In all cases ease of bond breaking is the key feature with basicity considerations being of secondary importance. Jencks (1973) proposed that concerted general acid catalysis will be detected only when pK,-values for the ground state and the product are widely separated, with the basicity of the transition state being intermediate. Proton transfer then becomes concerted with bond breaking to avoid a high-energy protonated intermediate. Acetal hydrolysis appears to fit this criterion nicely. A reasonable estimate of the pK,-value of 2-(p-nitrophenoxy)tetrahydropyran would be -10 while that of the product, p-nitrophenol, is 7. The Jencks postulate appears to be generally useful, but nevertheless it is conceptually misleading when applied to acetal hydrolysis because it stresses low basicity as a principal cause of general acid catalysis, whereas ease of bond breaking is the key factor. Spontaneous
90
T. H. FIFE
hydrolysis of acetals subject to general acid catalysis, such as 2-@-nitrophenoxy)tetrahydropyran, is a pH-independent unimolecular decomposition over much of the pH-range. General acid catalysis can then be looked upon as a genuine facilitation; it does not arise simply to avoid a protonated intermediate. While this viewpoint and the Jencks postulate are formally equivalent, more insight is provided into the mechanism of acetal hydrolysis by laying proper stress on bond breaking rather than basicity considerations. After reflecting upon the structural features in an acetal necessary for general acid catalysed hydrolysis, it might be concluded that the lysozyme reaction would not proceed by that mechanism since the natural substrates have poor leaving groups and an intermediate carbonium ion in the reaction would be quite unstable. However, relief of ground state strain in the transition state will promote bond breaking to an extent sufficient for general acid catalysis to occur; and an integral feature of postulated mechanisms for lysozyme is distortion during binding of ring D to a half-chair. Estimates obtained from unstrained lactone substrates show that relief of ground state strain could increase the rate of lysozyme reactions by 103-104 (Secemski and Lienhard, 1971; see also the calculation on p. 104). Also, a simple consideration of structure does not take into account the large effective molarity of an intramolecular catalyst which might be sufficient to bring that type of mechanism into operation.
In tram olecular Catalysis Intramolecular carboxyl group catalysis has been found in a number of salicyl acetals. Capon et al. (1969) preferred intramolecular general acid catalysis as the mechanism of carboxyl group participation in the hydrolysis of o-carboxyphenyl P-D-glucoside and o-methoxymethoxybenzoic acid although the kinetically equivalent possibilities were not convincingly eliminated in the case of the glucoside. Capon e t al. considered three possible mechanisms [equation (47)] for hydrolysis of o-methoxymethoxybenzoic acid. Mechanisms (a) and (b) involve nucleophilic attack by the carboxylate anion on the protonated acetal, and mechanism (c) proceeds with intramolecular general acid catalysis. Capon was able to rule out mechanisms (a) and (b) since the synthetically prepared intermediate in (a) is stable under the reaction conditions. That in (b) leads to products at
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
91
a faster rate than the overall reaction, but there is no UV absorbance due to the intermediate at the isosbestic point between reactant and H
+ CH30H
II
0
+ CH2 0
I1
0
product, whereas such absorbance would have been expected if the intermediate in (b) were indeed being produced. Capon prefers mechanism (c)-intramolecular general acid catalysis. The usual A-1 mechanism was not considered because of the observed facilitation of the rate of hydrolysis by the ortho-carboxyl group. Dunn and Bruice (1970, 1971) presented evidence that the mechanism of hydrolysis of methoxymethoxybenzoic acid is actually A-1. Evidence included a Bronsted coefficient for intramolecular catalysis of 1.0, based upon points for the unsubstituted compound and the 5-N02 derivative, and p*-values that were the same (-3.0) for both the methyl ester and the carboxyl derivatives of [ 721 when
92
T. H. FIFE
R was varied. Since the mechanism for the methyl ester is certainly A-1 and since intramolecular general acid catalysis should give a different transition state structure and therefore a different p* value, it was concluded that the mechanism was A-1 in both cases. The rate enhancement provided by the carboxyl group substituent was ascribed to electrostatic catalysis whereby a proton is stabilized on the acetal oxygen, thus lowering the dissociation constant of the conjugate acid. Complete protonation of methoxymethoxybenzoic acids might be required because of the unstable carbonium ion intermediate. An A-1 mechanism for hydrolysis of methoxymethoxybenzoic acids and electrostatic stabilization are reasonable postulates to explain the fairly small rate enhancements (-lo3) seen in comparison with reference compounds. Such a mechanism is similar to the electrostatic mechanism invoked to explain the modest increase in rate (-100 times) of hydrolysis of salicyl phosphate in comparison with p-carboxyphenyl phosphate (Bender and Lawlor, 1963), but it is debatable whether electrostatic stabilization of a proton on oxygen could account for the large rate enhancement factors of 10' O - 10' seen in enzymatic reactions. There does not appear to be convincing evidence in the literature that a neighbounng carboxyl group has an extraordinary effect on the pK,-values of neutral bases. For example, the pK,-values of 0-and p-aminobenzoic acids are about the same. A hydrophobic environment for the active site might make electrostatic catalysis quite effective, but pK, for aspartic acid-52 in lysozyme is normal and the pK,-value of glutamic acid-35 is close to 6.0, corresponding roughly to that of acetic acid in 50% dioxane-water, a solvent that is still quite polar. The active site of lysozyme must then be in a reasonably aqueous environment despite previous suggestions to the contrary. The effect of carboxyl group substitution is not greatly different for acetal hydrolysis in water and 50%-dioxanewater (Fife and Anderson, 1971a; Anderson and Fife, 1973). Craze and Kirby (19 74) have recently proposed that hydrolysis of methoxymethoxybenzoic acids proceeds with intramolecular general acid catalysis with little proton transfer from the carboxyl group and alarge amount of bond breaking in the transition state. This suggestion was, however, based solely on substituent effects and a graphical analysis using the extended 4-parameter Hammett Equation (see Section 2). In view of the problem of kinetic equivalence it was important to study carboxyl-substituted acetals where bimolecular general acid
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
93
catalysis had been observed in hydrolysis of the unsubstituted compounds. It is a reasonable assumption that the mechanism of the intramolecular reaction will be the same as that of the corresponding
II
[ 731
0
[ 741
intermolecular reaction, i.e., general acid catalysis. Fife and Anderson (1971a) therefore examined hydrolysis of 2-(o-carboxyphenoxy) tetrahydropyran [ 731 and benzaldehyde methyl o-carboxyphenyl acetal [74]. 40
0
PH Figure 5. Plot of kobsd for hydrolysis of 2-(o-carboxyphenoxy)-te~ahy&opyranin 50% dioxane-HzO at 15" us. pH.
The pH-rate constant profile shown in Figure 5 was obtained for hydrolysis of (73) in 50% dioxane-water at 15'. A large plateau in the profile is to be noted. As in the other cases of intramolecular catalysis, kinetically equivalent possibilities exist, and the curve in Figure 5 can be calculated from either equation (48) or equation (49) with appropriate values of the rate constants, where kl is the
94
T. H. FIFE
second-order rate constant for hydronium ion-catalysed hydrolysis of the unionized acetal, k2 is the second-order rate constant for hydronium ion-catalysed hydrolysis of the ionized species, k, is the rate constant for intramolecular general acid catalysis, and K, is the dissociation constant of the carboxyl group. The neighbouring carboxyl group greatly accelerates hydrolysis. The value of k2 is 6-1x 10' times greater than kH+ for the corresponding ethyl ester and 3-8 x lo' greater than k H + for the unsubstituted compound. These are maximum differences in k,bsd for hydrolysis of the compounds at any pH (k2/kH+). The k2-value for the p-carboxylsubstituted compound could not be determined since its rates of hydrolysis are much too slow to measure accurately at the required pH at 15". However, from the measured value of K , and a reasonable assumption as to the difference between k, and k,, based on the known p-value for hydronium ion-catalysed hydrolysis of 2-(4substituted phen0xy)tetrahydropyrans and the a-values for C 0 2 H and CO;, it was calculated that K 2 @ m u ) must be only 1.6 x times the magnitude of k 2 (ortho). These differences in the rate constants are many times larger than expected on the basis of inductive effects. The usual method for establishing partidly rate-limiting proton transfer, determination of the rate constants in D 2 0 , would give ambiguous results (Bruice and Piszkiewicz, 1967). However, intramolecular general acid catalysis [equation (48)] is the preferred mechanism in view of the intermolecular buffer acid catalysis observed with the unsubstituted compounds. General acid catalysis [ 751 should therefore be favoured in the intramolecular reaction.
The ratio of rate constants for intramolecular general acid catalysis of the hydrolysis of [ 731 and intermolecular formic acid-catalysed hydrolysis of 2-phenoxytetrahydropyran is 580 M , a minimum value since the intramolecular reaction was studied at 15" while the bimolecular rates were measured at 50". The ratio would be much larger if comparisons could be made at the same temperature
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
95
(-10,000 M ). The calculated ratio represents the concentration of formic acid in the bimolecular reaction required to give a pseudofirst-order rate constant comparable to that obtained in the intramolecular reaction. It is evident that intramolecular catalysis is greatly favoured, and that an increase in the local concentration of the carboxylic acid catalyst cannot explain the great efficiency of the reaction relative to intermolecular catalysis. The ratio of 580 M may reflect the nearly optimal geometry of the system in [73] for proton transfer between the two oxygen atoms. The magnitude of the rate constant k 2 for hydrolysis of benzs - l ) rules aldehyde methyl o-carboxyphenyl acetal (1.2 x l o 7 M out nucleophilic attack of a carboxylate anion on the protonated substrate or any mechanism involving a completely transferred proton, if the basicity of the acetal is normal. It can be calculated that L l , the rate constant for transfer of a proton from the conjugate acid of the substrate to water, would then necessarily have to be greater than that for a diffusion-controlled process. A decrease of l o 5 in the dissociation constant of the conjugate acid would be required to account for the rapid rate of hydrolysis since k, for (74) is 1.9 x lo5 times greater than kH+ for the corresponding methyl ester. As in the case of [73], the most likely mechanism is intramolecular general acid catalysis. These acetals then provide relatively unambiguous examples of intramolecular general acid catalysis. In hydrolysis of the analogous thioacetal, benzaldehyde methy1 S-(0-carboxyphenyl thioacetal [ 7 61 , carboxyl group participation cannot be observed. There is a difference of only 3 0 between k and
-'
II
0
k , , supporting the contention that the same structural features will permit both intramolecular catalysis and buffer acid catalysis. In view of the low basicity of sulphur, intramolecular general acid catalysis would be a favourable process if low basicity were of predominant importance in permitting general acid catalysis. A most important
96
T. H. FIFE
feature of these reactions must be that the salicyl anion is a better leaving group than the thiosalicyl anion. Release of salicylic acid from benzaldehyde disalicyl acetal gives a bell-shaped pH-rate constant profile (Figure 6 ) analogous to lysozyme-catalysed reactions (Anderson and Fife, 1973). The maximum
Figure 6. Plot of kobsd us. pH for hydrolysis of benzaldehyde disalicyl acetal in 50% dioxane-H20 at 25".
enhancement in kobsd in comparison with the dimethyl ester is a factor of 3 x l o 9 , is a rate enhancement of the magnitude seen in enzymatic reactions. It is probable that intramolecular general acid catalysis [ 771 is occurring. General acid catalysis by buffer acids is observed in hydrolysis of the dimethyl ester, and, as in the case of
II
0
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
97
[ 731 and [ 741 , it is a reasonable supposition that the intramolecular reaction proceeds by the same mechanism. Likewise, if the reaction were A-1,transfer of the proton from the conjugate acid to water would necessarily have a rate constant greater than that of a diffusion-controlled reaction. The monoanionic species is most reactive, but its associated rate constant for intramolecular general acid catalysis is only 65 times greater than that for the unionized species. Most of the large rate enhancement in comparison with the dimethyl ester is due to participation by one carboxyl group, as is the case with the unionized acetal [ 771. If the carboxylate anion of the monoanionic species is electrostatically stabilizing the incipient carbonium ion in the reaction [ 81 , its effect on the rate must be small. Part of the rate difference between the monoanion and the unionized species is due to a changing inductive effect caused by ionization of the carboxyl group. The magnitude of the inductive effect was determined by studying the p-nitrobenzaldehyde acetal with one of the carboxyl groups in the para-position. The pH-rate constant profile for p-nitrobenzaldehyde disalicyl acetal is bellshaped with a rate factor of 260 between the monoanion and unionized species. When one carboxyl group is in the para-position the profile is still bell-shaped, but the magnitude of the bell is greatly reduced; there is a factor of only 5 between the rate constants and this must result from the changing inductive effect. The rate constants for the two unionized compounds are about the same. Thus, a factor of -50 in the rate constant for the monoanion of p-nitrobenzaldehyde disalicyl acetal cannot be accounted for by an inductive effect. This could represent the effect of carbonium ion stabilization by the carboxylate anion, but an effect of this size could also be steric. It is known that ortho-substituted phenyl glycosides and phenyl methyl formals hydrolyse slightly faster than the corresponding compounds substituted in the para-position (Nath and Rydon, 1954;Dunn and Bruice, 1970). The leaving group of the salicyl acetals, where intramolecular carboxyl group participation has been observed, is quite good. A question arises, therefore, concerning the ability of an intramolecular carboxyl group to catalyse hydrolysis of an acetal with a poor (aliphatic alcohol) leaving group. Intermolecular buffer acid catalysis is not normally observed with such compounds (with the exceptions noted above). In view of the large effective molarity for an intramolecular general acid, however, it is theoretically possible that intra-
98
T. H. FIFE
molecular general acid catalysis could be taking place. Benzaldehyde diglycolic acid acetal [78] gives a pH-rate constant profile for hydrolysis which is quite similar in shape to that found for the monocarboxyl substituted compound o-carboxyphenoxy tetrahydropyran (Fife and Anderson, unpublished data). The data do not give a good ,OCH2COOH m c H \ 0 C H 2
COOH
fit to the rate equation for the hydrolysis of an acetal with two carboxyl groups unless it is assumed that the difference in rate constants for the monoanion and the unionized acetal is small. Thus, a carboxylate anion is not facilitating the reaction. The maximum factor between k o b s d for [78] and the dimethyl ester is 390, which is larger than expected on the basis of inductive or steric effects. It is probable that a carboxyl group is participating, perhaps as a general acid [ 791. While the observed rate enhancement is small, it is still significant in showing that intramolecular catalysis can take place when the leaving group is an aliphatic alcohol. I t must be noted that pKa for the leaving group of [ 781 is probably less than that for ali-
phatic alcohols such as ethanol because of the inductive electronwithdrawing ability of a carboxyl group. This could explain why only weak carboxyl-group catalysis is observed. For large rate enhancements to occur when the leaving group is poor, the carboxyl-group catalyst and the reaction centre will presumably have to be held much more rigidly, in the proper steric relationship, than is possible with [ 781. A model in which the leaving group is an aliphatic alcohol and where a carboxyl group is held rigidly in position for participation is
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
99
benzaldehyde methyl cis-2-carboxycyclohexyl acetal [ 801 , but carboxyl group participation is not observed (Fife and Anderson,
[go1
unpublished data). Compound [ 801 hydrolyses only 10 times faster than the methyl ester. The data in Table 7 reveal that leaving-group ability and not carbonium ion stability is the key factor permitting intramolecular TABLE 7 Hydrolysis of Carboxyl Substituted Acetals and Ketals Compd.
1.
Ref.
Rate C02H enhancement participation factof
C+
Leaving group
/OEt (CH\oEt
b
no
Stable
Poor
no
Stable
Poor
Stable
Poor
Stable
Poor
jC02H
2.
no
3.
HoocKx: C
no
4. Yes
OH
lo4
Unstable Good
100
T. H. FIFE
TABLE 7-continued Ref.
Rate COzH enhancement participation factora
d
yes
600
Unstable
e
yes
105-106
Moderately Good stable
e
yes
lo5
Stable
f
Yes
3~ 109
Moderately Good stable
~cH\OCH2C02H g
390 Yes
Moderately Interstable mediate
Compd.
9.
C+
Leaving POUP
Good
Good
/OCHzCO2H
10. Stable
a Rate enhancements are in comparison with the para carboxyl substituted or
unsubstituted compounds or corresponding methyl esters. Fife, unpublished work. Bruice and Piszkiewicz, 1967. Capon et a l , 1969. Fife and Anderson, 1971a f Anderson and Fife, 1971a, 1973. Fife and Anderson, unpublished work.
Poor
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
10 1
carboxyl group participation. Thus, when the leaving group is phenolic (salicyl), participation occurs when the carbonium ion intermediate is unstable (compounds 4 and 5), moderately stable (compound 6), or stable (compound 7). On the other hand, when the leaving group is poor (an aliphatic alcohol), intramolecular participation is not observed, even when the intermediate carbonium ion is reasonably well stabilized (compounds 1, 2, 3, and 10). As discussed above, the weak carboxyl group participation in hydrolysis of benzaldehyde diglycolic acid (compound 9) can be explained by a reduced pK,-value of the leaving group in comparison with ethanol and cyclohexanol. With acetals having a normal aliphatic alcohol of high pK, as leaving group, bond breaking must be so difficult that intramolecular general acid catalysis or a kinetic equivalent does not take place even in cases where the carbonium ion is an alkoxybenzyl ion; specific hydronium ion catalysis is then the only observable mechanism. If the intermediate carbonium ion could be made exceedingly stable, as for example with the tropone ketal [ 8 1 ] , bond breaking might be sufficiently easy for carboxyl group participation even with an aliphatic alcohol leaving group, but this possibility is at present untested.
~-O-@-D -Glucopyranosyl-L -gulonic acid [ 821 hydrolyses more than 100 times faster than 4 - 0 - p --glucopyranosyl-D ~ -glucitol [ 831 at pH 4 and exhibits a plateau in its pH-rate profile (Smidsrod et al., 1966), although a complete profile was not obtained. Intramolecular catalysis [84] was proposed and likewise for hydrolysis of alginate
102
T. H. FIFE
which contains uronic acid residues, but more evidence is necessary before these can be considered legitimate examples of general acid catalysis. In particular, it is necessary to assess the changing inductive effect.
--....op “o Note should be made of the fact that all of the mecha&rxls for lysozyme in which a carbonium ion intermediate is formed are depicted as proceeding through a cyclic glycosyl 0x0-carbonium ion. In the acid-catalysed hydrolysis of glucosides the carbonium ion formed is probably cyclic rather than an open-chain ion (Capon, 1969), even though the cyclic ion would necessarily have to adopt a
+
R‘OH
(50)
HO
V30+
G
HO
\
+
H=OR OH
I
products
/
strained half-chair conformation [ 851 (strain energy amounting to 8-10 kcal mole-’ ; Eliel, 1962). Formation of a cyclic carbonium ion would be preferred because: (1) AS* should be favourable for a
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
103
process in which one particle decomposes into two; and (2) reversal of the formation of the ion would be more favourable for an
open-chain carbonium ion because of intramolecular reaction with a neighbouring hydroxyl group [equation (SO)] . Hydrolysis of benzaldehyde- 1,3-dioxolanes, where re-closure of the ring can similarly take place after carbonium ion formation, proceeds about 35 times more slowly than that of analogous benzaldehyde diethyl acetals (Fife and Jao, 1965; Fife and Hagopian, 1966). The difference in rate is due entirely to an 8-10 e.u. AS * . p-Methoxyphenyl-4,4,5,5-tetramethyl1,3difference in dioxolane [86] hydrolyses 40,000 times more slowly than the corresponding diethyl acetal (Fife, 1967; Fife and Brod, 1968). There is evidence for a change in mechanism to A-2 with the tetramethyl- 1,Sdioxolanes. It is likely that the great facility of ring closure due to the geminal methyl substitution makes an A-1 mechanism unfavourable and thereby leads to a normally less favoured mechanism not involving a discrete carbonium ion intermediate. Geminal substitution would restrict rotation of the
hydroxyl group away from the carbonium centre and might lead to faster reaction with the neighbouring hydroxyl than with a water molecule. Thus, the factors of AS’ and reversibility have a profound influence on rate and mechanism in hydrolysis of cyclic acetals. It is reasonable that a cyclic glycosyl carbonium ion would be formed in lysozyme-catalysed reactions, but this expectation must be viewed in the light of the postulated straining of the substrate during
104
T. H. FIFE
binding. Pronounced strain in the hexose ring would prevent reclosure of the ring if an open-chain carbonium ion were formed. Thus, a major factor in cyclic carbonium-ion formation would be removed. An open-chain carbonium ion would not only be more stable than a cyclic ion, but cleavage of the ring would release all strain energy in the ring. The bond breaking process might then be quite facile in spite of the poor leaving group so that general acid catalysis by glutamic acid-35 could occur. The question that must be asked is whether reversibility or AS * considerations are more important in regard to the position of bond cleavage. If the AS* difference of 8-10 e.u. for benzaldehyde diethyl and ethylene glycol acetals (Fife and Jao, 1965) accurately represents the change expected for cleavage of an acetal ring as compared to an acyclic bond, then reversibility must be the predominant influence. D Glyceraldehyde dimethyl acetal hydrolyses at 25" with a secondM-' s-' (Capon order rate constant for acid catalysis of 1 - 7 7 x and Thacker, 1965), whereas methyl p-D -glucopyranoside has a M s-' at 60" (data corresponding rate constant of 3.5 x from Capon, 1969, Table 9). If one makes a reasonable allowance for the temperature difference, the glycoside hydrolyses approximately lo4 times more slowly. The rate difference must be primarily caused by strain in the cyclic carbonium-ion intermediate of the glucoside. Transglycosidation with retention of configuration (Chipman and Sharon, 1969) would be more difficult to explain if an open-chain carbonium ion were formed in lysozyme reactions, necessitating an equilibrium reaction with free aldehyde. It seems unlikely, however, that a cyclic carbonium ion intermediate could have a sufficiently long lifetime to react with a saccharide molecule that can bind to the enzyme only after displacement of the leaving group in a fairly aqueous environment (above discussion). Therefore, the concept of a cyclic carbonium ion also presents difficulties for interpretation and should not be accepted uncritically. Reaction of the carbonium ion with water could be reduced if overlap occurred with the carboxylate anion of aspartic acid-52 either during or after the glycoside-cleavage step. Since the carboxylate anion would be held adjacent to the carbonium ion in the active site, equilibrium should be far to the side of the acylal. Reaction of acylal with H,O would then very probably be ratedetermining in the forward direction. Evidence has been obtained that the solvent is directly involved in the hydrolysis of the cyclic acylal 2-(p-nitrophenoxy)phthalide where steric factors are similar
-'
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
\O-
\O-
NHCOCH3
105
NHCOCH3 (52)
(Fife and De, 1974). Hence, the above scheme [equation (52)] would lead to build-up of a detectable concentration of acylal intermediate which is contrary to fact.
Nucleophilic Catalysis Piszkiewicz and Bruice (1967) found both hydronium ion and hydroxide ion catalysis in the hydrolysis of p-nitrophenyl 2-acetamido-6-D -glucoside and also, pH-independent hydrolysis from pH 2-1 1. Such a reaction is not seen in the hydrolysis of the corresponding a-derivative, and at neutrality the p-isomer hydrolyses 1O3 times more rapidly. There is also a pH-independent hydrolysis (pH 3-7) with p-nitrophenyl p-D -glucoside, but the reaction is 300 times more favourable with the P-acetamido-derivative. The large rate difference indicated that the acetamido-group was participating in the reaction. A nucleophilic mechanism [87] involving attack of the neutral amide at C-1 of the glycoside was favoured since a kinetically equivalent mechanism in which the negatively charged amide oxygen attacked the protonated glycoside would require unreasonably large rate constants. The p-value for nucleophilic catalysis is 2.6. Thus, catalysis becomes less effective as the leaving group becomes worse.
106
T. H. FIFE
Acid-catalysed hydrolysis of corresponding a- and P-methyl 2acetamido-D -glucosides was studied with similar results (Piszkiewicz and Bruice, 1968a). The a-derivative has a second-order rate constant ( k H + ) one-fourth of that of the fi-anomer. When log k,+ values for O-D -glycosides of N-acetylghcosamine are plotted us. log k H + for the corresponding p-D-glucopyranosides, a linear relationship exists. The point corresponding to the methyl glycosides deviates from this plot and can be accounted for as a 50-fold enhancement in the rate of hydrolysis of methyl 2-acetamido-fi-D-glucoside. Mechanism [ 881 was proposed in which the amide oxygen attacks the protonated gly coside.
CH3 [881
A neighbouring carboxyl group in o-carboxyphenyl-2-acetamidogives further rate enhancement, hydrolysing 8.1 x lo4 times faster than expected from a Hammett up plot
p-D-glucopyranoside [ 891
(89)
of log k H + for a series of substituted phenyl 2-deoxy-2-acetamidoglycopyranosides us. u (Piszkiewicz and Bruice, 1968b). Concerted intramolecular nucleophilic attack by the acetamido-function and general acid catalysis by the ortho-carboxyl group was suggested. oCarboxyphenyl 2-deoxy-2-acetamidoglucopyranoside hydrolyses only 7 times faster than o-carboxyphenyl 0-D-glucoside so that catalytic effects of the two groups are not additive. Incorporation of a second functional group within the molecule should lower M* but would entail additional restrictions in the transition state. Orientation of the second group would make TAS" more unfavourable, assuming that M* is a measure of potential
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
107
energy changes and AS* measures kinetic energy changes. The observed values of the activation parameters (kcal mole-' ) for o-carboxyphenyl 0-D-glucopyranoside (AH*,28.4; TAS*, leg), ocarboxyphenyl 2-acetamido-2-deoxy-P-~ -glucopyranoside (M, 24.6; TAS*, 0-0), and o-nitrophenyl-2-acetamido-2-deoxy-~-~-glucopyranoside (AH*, 27.0; TAS*, 0-2)are in accord. The decrease in TAS' necessary to orient the second catalytic group is about one-half of that predicted if the second group were acting as a bimolecular catalyst. These studies with acetamidoglycosides provide support for the plausibility of mechanisms for lysozyme in which nucleophilic attack by the neighbouring group takes place. The synthetic substrates developed for lysozyme which lack this group (Raftery and RandMeir, 1968) render unnecessary any postulate of involvement of the 2-acetamido-group, but, of course, do not rule out the possibility. Perhaps the greatest importance of the work of Bruice and Piszkiewicz is in showing that intramolecular nucleophilic attack HOCH2
I
-
HOCH2
HOCH2 I H
I
H
H+
OH
+
OH
CH30H
CH3S 'CH2' CH
/OEt 'OEt
H30'
, -
EtOH + CH3S.CH2-C<
CHjS.CH2.CH
I
H ,OEt +
'OEt
0
H20
+ EtOH
+ -
H
+
CH2--CH--OEt
(54)
108
T. H. FIFE
by a suitable nucleophile will take place in the hydrolysis of glycosides. Capon and Anderson have also found an example of intramoIecular nucleophilic attack with o-carboxybenzaldehyde diethyl acetal in 82% dioxane-water (referred to in Capon, 1969). The carboxyl group does not participate in the reaction at dioxane concentrations less than 82%. In 82% dioxane, pK, for the neighbouring carboxyl group would be approximately 11-12 so that it would be a potent nucleophile under such conditions. Nucleophilic participation has also been suggested in the reactions (53) and (54) on the basis of small rate enhancements in comparison with reference compounds (Capon and Thacker, 1965; Speck, et al., 1965).
Acylal Hydrolysis
If aspartic acid-52 acts as a nucleophile in lysozyme reactions a glycosyl enzyme intermediate will be formed [60]. There is no evidence, kinetic or otherwise, for substituted enzyme intermediates, but rapid breakdown might preclude attainment of detectable concentrations. Formation of a substituted enzyme could explain the observed retention of configuration at the anomeric carbon in transglycosidation reactions, provided backside attack in a subsequent reaction is chemically reasonable. It has therefore been important to attempt t o understand the chemistry of acylal hydrolysis so as to assess the properties that would be expected of an acylal intermediate in reactions catalysed by the enzyme. y-Ethoxy-y-butyrolactone undergoes both hydroxide- and hydronium ion-catalysed hydrolysis but, in addition, there is a pHindependent rate (Figure 7) from pH 4-9 (Fife, 1965). The hydronium ion-catalysed reaction was considered to proceed by an A-1 mechanism. The AS* of -6.9 e.u. is slightly more negative than is usual for A-1 reactions but is of the magnitude obtained in other A-1 ring cleavage reactions (Fife and Jao, 1965; Fife and Hagopian, 1966). Acylals have generally been observed to undergo acidcatalysed hydrolysis by an A-1 mechanism (Salomaa, 1957; Salomaa and Laiho, 1963; Salomaa, 1964); although Salomaa (1957) suggested that methoxymethyl formate hydrolyses by both A-1 and A-2 mechanisms and Weeks et al. (1968) concluded that methyl pseudo2-benzoylbenzoate [ 9 11 hydrolyses by an A-2 mechanism (ratedetermining attack of H, 0 on the protonated substrate). The pH-independent reaction of yethoxy-y-butyrolactone is a
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
109
unimolecular S N 1-type decomposition [92] similar to that in hydrolysis of the acetals 2-(pnitrophenoxy)tetrahydropyran [ 631 and
tropone diethyl ketal [64] where bond breaking is quite facile. y-Ethoxyr-butyrolactone possesses structural features similar to 2-(p-nitrophenoxy)tetrahydropyranin that the leaving group is quite good and the intermediate carbonium ion of moderate stability. A unimolecular mechanism was supported by the D, 0 solvent isotope effect ( k D 2 0 / k H 0 = 0.9) and lack of detectable general base catalysis even at very high concentrations of acetate or imidazole. If water acts as a nucleophile in the pH-independent reaction, much stronger bases should also function. Brown and Bruice (1973) found a similar pH-independent reaction from pH 3- 5 in hydrolysis of glucosylbenzoates. a-Acetoxy p-nitrophenyl benzyl ether [ 931 and 2-(p-nitrophenoxy)phthalide [ 941 also have large pH-independent regions in their pH-rate constant profiles (Fife and De, 1974). The AS*-value for reaction of the cyclic acylal is -47-1 e.u. and k f z 0 / k ; 2 O = 1-84
/o-No2 DNO'
o""-. 0
\
I
CH3 [931
aFO \
tl [941
so that the reaction undoubtedly involves solvent, in contrast with the unimolecular decomposition of y-ethoxy-y-butyrolactone. The rate constants for hydroxide ion catalysis and for the pH-independent reactions are similar for [93] and [94]. It is therefore likely that the mechanisms are the same, namely nucleophilic attack at the carbonyl group. Catalysis by imidazole and formate ion takes place
T. H. FIFE
110
in the hydrolysis of [93] and [94] in the pH-region where the spontaneous reaction is pH-independent. Unimolecular decomposition may not represent a favourable mechanism because the stabilization of a carbonium ion intermediate by an adjoining p-nitrophenoxy group would be weak. The pH-independent unimolecular hydrolysis of glucosyl benzoates (pH 3-5) is without buffer catalysis (Brown and Bruice, 1973). While the rates of alkaline and pH-independent hydrolysis of [93] and [94] are similar, hydronium ion catalysis is 2500 times less favourable in the case of the cyclic acylal. The large rate difference in comparison with the open chain analogue may reflect the fact that, if a carbonium ion intermediate with a carboxyl group held rigidly adjacent to the carbonium carbon atom were formed in an A-1 reaction, rapid reclosure of the ring would result from recapture of the carbonium carbon by the carboxyl group [equation (55)]. A greatly diminished rate of hydrolysis would result. Perhaps there is a
II 0
1
0
change in mechanism t o A-2 (which is supported by a Bunnett w-value of +2-3)so that a carbonium ion intermediate is not involved. This has consequence for the lysozyme reaction because, if an acylal intermediate were formed by nucleophilic attack or carbonium ion capture by aspartic acid-52, the steric situation would be similar to that of a cyclic acylal. Unimolecular decomposition would result in a carbonium ion and a carboxyl group held in juxtaposition [equation
(5211. Weeks and Crane (1973) have recently studied acid-catalysed hydrolysis of 3-methoxyphthalide in aqueous sulfuric acid. Values of AS* (-3.1 e.u.), k H /k, (0-51) and a linear plot of log kobsd us. -H, with a slope of 0.96 were consistant with an A-1 mechanism. A cyclic carbonium ion intermediate was proposed on the basis of substituent effects at the 3-position, the following reactivities being observed: H > CH3 > Et Ph. It was thought that A-1 ring opening
-
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
11 1
would not explain this order. However, the acid catalysed ring opening of 2-substituted-2-phenyl-1,3-dioxolanes, proceeding by an A-1 mechanism, displays a similar order of reactivity (Fife and Hagopian, 1966). A mechanism utilizing a cyclic carbonium ion can
OH
I
be criticized on the basis that, ( 1 ) an open-chain carbonium ion with an adjacent methoxy-group would be stabilised to a greater extent by resonance interaction with oxygen; (2) the carboxyl group would be the best leaving group in the reaction; and (3) if formation of a cyclic carbonium ion is energetically favourable, it would be formed in the pH-independent reaction of compound [941 , but that reaction unquestionably involves solvent participation. Slopes of log kobsd us. -H0 deviate greatly from unity and AS* values become quite negative with increasing size of substituents at the 3-position; the 3-phenyl derivative gives a slope of 0.67 and AS* is -20.6 e.u., a value more in accord with an A-2 mechanism. Acid-catalysed hydrolysis of 3-methoxyphthalide occurs approximately 1000 times faster than reaction of 39-nitrophenoxyphthalide. A rate factor of lo3 is not consistent with a mechanism in which a cyclic carbonium ion is formed as an intermediate. Electron withdrawal in the leaving group has only a small effect on the rate in the hydrolysis of glycosides and tetrahydropyran acetals (Hammett p-values are -0.66 and -0.9 respectively), and in both cases the p-nitrophenoxy- and methoxy-derivatives hydrolyse at comparable rates. The reactivities of the phthalide acylals probably reflect differing stabilities of a ring-opened ion resulting in a difference in mechanism [A-2 in the
T. I€ FIFE
112
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
L
I
I
J
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 1 1
PH Figure 7. Plot of log k o h d us. pH for the hydrolysis of rethoxy-y-butyrolactone in HzO 0 and D2O Q (pH = pD) at 30" and p = 0.25 M.
case of [ 941 1. The influence of reversibility would be greater with the less stable carbonium ion intermediate since equilibrium would lie further on the side of protonated acylal.
Mechanistic Conclusions The problem of the mechanism of action of lysozyme can be considered in regard to possible effects by glutamic acid-35 and aspartic acid-52, the two amino-acids implicated as participants in the reaction. Glutamic acid-35 might function as an intracomplex general acid, partially transferring a proton to oxygen of the leaving group in the transition state or by carboxylate anion stabilization on oxygen of a completely transferred proton. General acid catalysis of acetal hydrolysis must now be regarded as a perfectly reasonable chemical mechanism since it has been unambiguously demonstrated as bimolecular buffer acid catalysis in a number of systems and relatively unambiguously as intramolecular carboxyl group catalysis of hydrolysis of types of acetals subject t o buffer acid cataIysis. A point of concern is that structural features in an acetal shown t o be necessary for general acid catalysis (a good leaving group or an extraordinarily stable carbonium ion intermediate) are not present in normal substrates for lysozyme. Intramolecular catalysis does not occur in model compounds where the leaving group is an aliphatic alcohol of high pK, even with an acetal, such as benzaldehyde methyl cis-2-carboxycyclohexyl acetal [ 801 , where the carbonium ion is a well-stabilized methoxybenzyl ion. A plausible viewpoint is
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
113
that relief of ground state strain in the transition state of lysozyme reactions enhances the ease of bond breaking to the point where general acid catalysis can take place, i.e., proton transfer only need be partial. This possibility has been demonstrated in benzaldehyde di-t-butyl acetals and 2-methoxy-3,3-dimethyloxetane, but it has not yet been investigated in intramolecular systems. Stabilization of a proton on oxygen by a carboxylate anion (the mechanism suggested by Dunn and Bruice for methoxymethoxybenzoic acids) is a doubtful possibility for lysozyme. It is unlikely that such a mechanism would give large rate enhancements, and indeed those observed with methoxymethoxybenzoic acids are relatively small. The electrostatic stabilization mechanism cannot be generally favourable, for it is not seen when the leaving group is an aliphatic alcohol or with thioacetals. While it can be explained that intramolecular general acid catalysis does not take place with such compounds because of the poor leaving group, it is difficult to see why carboxyl group stabilization of a protonated intermediate might not be important, particularly with thioacetals where the low basicity of sulfur would allow only a small concentration of conjugate acid. General acid catalysis by glutamic acid-35 represents at present the mechanism for lysozyme best able to explain the kinetic and structural data. For it to occur, however, distortion of the hexose ring in subsite D to a half-chair must take place so that relief of strain in the transition state will make bond breaking sufficiently easy. A question that must be answered for this picture to be tenable is whether relief of strain can so greatly facilitate bond breaking when the carbonium ion is a glycosyl ion [see also the discussion in Fife (1972) and Atkinson and Bruice (1974)l. In regard to possible mechanistic effects by the carboxylate anion of aspartic acid-52, the proposal that it acts as a nucleophile forming an acylal intermediate in concert with general acid catalysis by glutamic acid-35 is unsupported. From the chemical work on hydrolysis of the acylal 3-@-nitrophenoxy)phthalide it can be concluded that, when the carbonium ion is not highly stabilized and a carboxyl group is held adjacent to it, as in the active site of lysozyme, the rate of acylal hydrolysis will be slow and may involve solvent or nucleophile participation. Reversal of the enzyme reaction through the same transition state as in the forward direction would require an SN 2-type attack of alcohol at C-1 of the hexose ring if an acylal intermediate were formed. There is no indication from studies of acylal hydrolysis that this represents a feasible mechanism. On the
114
T. H. FIFE
other hand, reactions catalysed by lysozyme are readily reversible, as shown by the occurrence of transglycosidation. The simplest explanation is that an acylal intermediate is not produced in the rate-determining step. Formation of an acylal after the ratedetermining step by carbonium ion capture by the aspartate anion is an attractive possibility in explaining transglycosidation but should lead to detectable concentrations of acylal. The alternative role for direct involvement of aspartic acid-52 is electrostatic stabilization of an oxocarbonium ion, a reasonable expectation in view of the steric situation in the active site, the poor internal stabilization of a glycosyl carbonium ion, and the apparent need for some kind of stabilization if general acid catalysis by glutamic acid-35 is t o occur. Nevertheless, this assignment is questionable since electrostatic stabilization has not been demonstrable with o-methoxymethoxyisophthalic acid (Dunn and Bruice, 1970) and benzaldehyde disalicyl acetals (Anderson and Fife, 1973). In the former example, such stabilization should be favourable because the carbonium ion intermediate is unstable. For general acid catalysis to occur, bond breaking must be easy. The transition state will then be reached earlier along the reaction coordinate than with an acetal where bond breaking is difficult. Electrostatic stabilization, however, will be of maximal importance when the carbonium ion is unstable and the transition state closely resembles the carbonium ion. Thus, structural features in an acetal that facilitate one type of catalysis will tend to inhibit the other. It is not surprising that bifunctional catalysis of the type postulated for lysozyme has not been demonstrated in acetal hydrolysis. The best opportunity for observation of concerted bifunctional catalysis might be provided by an acetal where bond breaking in the transition state is midway between protonated acetal and carbonium ion, but in such a case electrostatic catalysis would not be highly efficient. Bell-shaped pH-rate profiles are obtained in lysozyme reactions (Rupley et al., 1967) which are consistent with direct involvement of two groups in the reaction. However, bell-shaped pH-rate constant profiles are also observed in the hydrolysis of benzaldehyde disalicyl acetals, and in the case of p-nitrobenzaldehyde o-carboxyphenyl p-carboxyphenyl acetal only one carboxyl group can participate. One should then take care in postulating bifunctional catalysis in the lysozyme reaction, since the observed kinetics and the rate enhancements are explicable in terms of a chemically simpler mechanism (general acid catalysis by glutamic acid-35 along with release of ground state
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
115
strain). It is possible that aspartic acid-52 influences the reaction by stabilizing a particular conformation of the enzyme or by some other indirect effect without direct involvement in the critical transition state.
6. CONCLUSION The three hydrolytic enzymes that have been discussed, a-chymotrypsin, carboxypeptidase A, and lysozyme, cover a wide range of substrate types and mechanistic possibilities. Formulation of principles which might apply to enzymatic catalysis in general is difficult from such a small sampling, but certain features of the enzymatic and model reactions warrant some comment. First and most important, it is clear that enzymatic rates can be approached in simple chemical models where the mechanism involves monofunctional catalysis or a slightly more complicated possibility in which two intramolecular groups act in a stepwise manner. In no case has concerted intramolecular general acid-general base bifunctional catalysis been observed in aqueous solution even though systems have been studied which were specifically designed to afford maximum opportunity for demonstration of such catalysis. As a consequence, it is not invariably necessary to postulate chemically complex mechanisms for enzymes catalysing analogous reactions. The chemical difficulties of bifunctional mechanisms are great. Perhaps by ridding ourselves of the idea that they are essential in order to attain enzymatic rates of reaction, greater progress can be made. A more specific generalization that might be made is that nucleophilic attack in enzyme reactions will usually be by nucleophiles bearing a negative charge or at least a partial negative charge, although the great efficiency of such nucleophiles in intramolecular and presumably intracomplex reactions cannot at present be completely explained. The role of neutral nitrogen bases would appear to be preferentially that of general bases either assisting nucleophilic attack or facilitating the reaction by catalysing breakdown of stable intermediates. Intracomplex general acid catalysis or its kinetic equivalent may be necessitated when the bond breaking process is difficult, as seen in the mechanisms suggested for all three enzymes. The presence of other factors may be required, however, before general acid catalysis will be effective.
116
T. H. FIFE
The importance of factors such as strain and orientation of reacting groups in enzymatic reactions is difficult to assess in quantitative terms even when the precise geometry of the active site is known from x-ray crystallographic studies. It is probable that these factors are important not only in promoting bond making and bond breaking but in allowing certain mechanisms t o take place. Likewise, the influence of orientation of reacting groups on mechanism goes beyond mere accessibility to the reaction centre, as seen, for example, in the general base catalysis by imidazole observed in cyclization of 2-hydroxymethylbenzamide. The hydroxyl group is rigidly held adjacent to the carbonyl group, whereas in the cyclization of y-hydroxybutyramide and anilide the groups are not rigidly held and imidazole catalysis does not take place. The greater ease of nucleophilic attack when the groups are properly aligned may permit proton transfer steps to become partially rate-limiting. Thus, mechanism, structure of the active site, and the steric situation resulting when the substrate is bound in the active site are intimately interrelated. It may be that a single “perfect” model for any enzyme is not possible. Nevertheless, by studying the chemical features of enzyme reactions and by designing models which mimic the action of enzymes as closely as possible, greater understanding may be gained of enzymatic catalysis and, in general, of chemical catalysis in aqueous solution. Certainly, models of ever-increasing sophistication will be forthcoming in the future. REFERENCES Aldersley, M. F., Kirby, A. J., and Lancaster, P. W. (1972). Chem. Commun. 834. Alexander, M. D., and Busch, D. H. (1966).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 88, 1130. Anderson, B. M., Cordes, E. H., and Jencks, W. P. (1961). J. BioL Chem. 236, 455. Anderson, E., and Capon, B. (1969). J. Chem. SOC. ( B ) , 1033. Anderson, E., and Fife, T. H. (1969).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 91, 7163. Anderson, E., and Fife, T. H. (1971a). Chem. Comm. 1470. Anderson, E., and Fife, T. H. (1971b).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 93, 1701. Anderson, E., and Fife, T. H. (1973). J . Amer. Chem. SOC.95, 6437. Atkinson, R. F., and Bruice, T. C. (1974).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 96, 819. Banerjee, S. K-, Kregar, I., Turk,V., and Rupley, J. A. (1973).J. Biol. Chem. 248, 4786. Belke, C. J., Su, S. C. K., and Shafer, J. A. (1971). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 93, 4552. Bender, M. L. (1951).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 73, 1626. Bender, M. L. (1957).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 79, 1258.
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
117
Bender, M. L. (1960).Chem. Rev. 60,55. Bender, M. L. (1971).“Mechanisms of Homogeneous Catalysis from Protons t o Proteins”, Wdey-Interscience, New York, N.Y. Bender, M. L., Chloupek, F., and Neveu, M. C. (1958a).J. Amer. Chem. SOC.89,
5384.
Bender, M. L., Chow, Y., and Chloupek, F. (195813).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 80,
5380.
Bender, M. L., and Hamilton, G. A. (1962).J.Amer. Chem. SOC. 84, 2570. Bender, M. L., and Heck, H. d’A. (1967).]. Amer. Chem. SOC.89, 1211. Bender, M. L., andHomer, R. B. (1965).J.Org. Chem. 30,3975. Bender, M. L., and KCzdy, F. J. (1964).J . Amer. Chem. SOC. 86,3704. Bender, M. L., KCzdy, F. J., and Gunter, C. R. (1964).J.Amer. Chem. SOC. 86,
3 7 14.
Bender, M. L., Kizdy, F. J., and Zerner, B. (1963).J. Amer. Chem. SOC.85,
301 7.
Bender, M. L., and Lawlor, J. M. (1963).J.Amer. Chem. SOC. 85,3010. Bender, M. L., and Nakamura, K. (1962)..I. Amer. Chem. SOC. 84, 2577. Bender, M. L., and Turnquest, B. W. (1957a).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 79, 1652,
1656.
Bender, M. L., andTurnquest, B. W. (1957b).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 79, 1889. Bender, M. L., and Glasson, W. A. (1959).J.Amer. Chem. SOC. 81, 1590. Bender, M. L., and Wedler, F. C. (1972).J.Amer. Chem. SOC. 94, 2101. Blackall, E. L., and Eastham, A. M. (1955).J. Amer. Chem. SOC.77, 2184. Blackburn, G. M.,and Jencks, W. P. (1968).J . Amer. Chem. SOC.90, 2638. Blake, C. C. F., Koenig, D. F., Mair, G. A., North, A. C. T., Phillips, D. C., and Sanna, V. (1965).Nature 206, 757. Blow, D. M., Birktoft, J. J., and Hartley, B. S. (1969).Nature 221, 337. Boyer, P. D. (1970).Ed., “The Enzymes”, 3rd ed., Academic Press, New York. Bradshaw, R. A, Ericsson, L. H., Walsh, K. A., and Neurath, H. (1969).Proc. Natl. Acad. S c i U.S. 63, 1389. Brass, H. J., and Bender, M. L. (1973).J.Amer. Chem. SOC.95, 5391. Breslow, R. (1971).I n “Bioinorganic Chemistry”, Advances in Chemistry Series, R. P. Gould, Ed., American Chemical Society, Washington, D.C. Breslow, R., and Chipman, D. J. (1965).J. Amer. Chem. SOC.87,4195. Breslow, R., Fairweather, R., and Keana, J. (1967).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 89,
2135.
Breslow, R., and McAllister, C. (1971).]. Amer. Chem. SOC. 93, 7096. Breslow, R., and Overman, L. E. (1970).J.Amer. Chem. SOC. 92, 1075. Bromilow, R. H., and Kirby, A. J. (1972).J.C.S. Perkin I1 149. Bronsted, J. N., and Wynne-Jones, W. F. K. (1929).Trans. Faraday SOC.25, 59. Brown, A., and Bruice, T. C. (1973).J.Amer. Chem. SOC.95, 1593. Bruice, T. C. (1959).]. Amer. Chem. SOC. 81,5444. Bruice, T. C. (1970). In “The Enzymes,” Third Edition, P. D. Boyer, Ed., Academic Press, New York, Vol. 11, p. 217. Bruice, T. C.,and Benkovic, S. J. (1963).J.Amer. Chem. SOC.85, 1. Bruice, T. C., and Benkovic, S. J. (1964).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 86,418. Bruice, T. C., and Benkovic, S. J., (1966). “Bio-organic Mechanisms”, W. A. Benjamin, New York, N.Y. Bruice, T. C., and Bradbury, W. A. (1965).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 87,4838. Bruice, T. C., and Bradbury, W. A. (1968).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 90,3808. Bruice, T. C., Brown, A., and Harris, D. 0. (1971).Proc. Nut. Acad. S c i , US.
68, 658.
Bruice, T. C., and Dunn, B. (1973).Adv. Enzymol. 39, 1.
118
T. H. FIFE
Bruice, T. C., and Fife, T. H. (1962).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 84, 1973. Bruice, T. C., Fife, T. H., Bruno, J. J., and Benkovic, P. (1962a). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 84, 3012. Bruice, T. C., Fife, T. H., Bruno, J. J., and Brandon, N. E. (1962b). Biochemistry 1, 7. Bruice, T. C., and Lapinski, R. (1958). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 80, 2265. Bruice, T. C., and Marquardt, F. H. (1962). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 84, 365. Bruice, T. C., and Pandit, U. K. (1960a). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 82, 3386. Bruice, T. C., and Pandit, U. K. (1960b). J. Amer. Chem. SOC.82, 5858. Bruice, T. C., andpiszkiewicz, D. (1967).j. Amer. Chem. SOC. 89, 3568. Bruice, T. C., and Schmir, G. L. (1957). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 79, 1663. Bruice, T. C., and Sturtevant, J. M., (1959). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 81, 2860. Bruice, T. C., and Tanner, D. W. (1965). J. Org. Chem. 30, 1668. Bruice, T. C., and Turner, A. (1970).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 92, 3422. Bruice, T. C., and York, L. (1961).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 83, 1382. Buckingham, D. A., Davis, C. E., Foster, D. M., and Sargeson, A. M. (1970b). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 92, 5571. Buckingham, D. A., Dekkers, J., Sargeson, A. M., and Wein, M. (1972).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 94,4032. Buckingham, D. A, Foster, D. M., and Sargeson, A. M. (1970a).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 92, 5701. Buckingham, D. A., Foster, D. M., and Sargeson, A. M. ( 1 9 7 0 ~ )J. . Amer. Chem. SOC. 92, 6151. Buckingham, D. A., Marzilly, L. G., and Sargeson, A. M. (1967a). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 89, 2772. Buckingham, D. A., Collman, J. P., and Happer, D. A. R. (1967b). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 89, 1082. Buckingham, D. A., Marzilly, L. G., and Sargeson, A. M. ( 1 9 6 7 ~ ) J. . Amer. Chem. SOC. 89,4539. Bull. H. G., Koehler, K., Pletcher, T. C., Ortiz, J. J., and Cordes, E. H. (1971). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 93, 3002. Bunnett, J. F., and Hauser, C. F. (1965).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 87, 2214. Butler, A. R., and Gold, V. (1960). Proc. Chem. SOC. 15. Butler, A. R., and Gold, V. (1961). J. Chem. SOC. 2305. Canfield, R. C. (1963). 1. Biol. Chem. 238, 2699. Caplow, M., and Jencks, W. P. (1962). Biochemistry 1, 883. Caplow, M. (1969). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 91, 3639. Capon, B. (1963). Tetrahedron Lett. 911. Capon, B. (1969). Chem. Rev. 69,407. Capon, B., McDowell, S, T., and Raftery, W. V. (1973).J.C.S. Perkin 11, 1118. Capon, B., andsmith, M. C. (1965). Chem. Comm. 523. Capon, B., Smith, M. C., Anderson, E., Dahm, R. H., andSankey, G. H. (1969). J . Chem. SOC. 1038. Capon, B., and Thacker, D. (1965).]. Amer. Chem. SOC.87, 4199. Chance, B. (1943).J. Biol. Chem. 151, 553. Chance, B. (1947). Acto. Chem. Scand. 1, 236. Chanley, J. D., and Feageson, E. (1955).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 77, 4002. Chipman, D. M., and Sharon, N. (1969). Science 165,454. Conley, H . L., Jr., and Martin, R. B. (1965). J. Phys. Chem. 69, 2914, 2923. Cordes, E. H. (1967). Progr. Phys. Org. Chem. 4, 1. Cramer, F., Saenger, W., and Spatz, H-Ch (1967).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 89, 14. Craze, G., and Kirby, A. J. (1974). J. Chem. SOC. ( B ) 61. Cunningham, B. A., and Schmir, G. L. (1966).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 88, 551.
PHYSICAL. ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
119
Cunningham, B. A., andSchmir, G. L. (1967). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 89, 917. Dahlquist, F. W., and Raftery, M. A. (1968). Biochemistry 9, 3277. Dahlquist, F. W., Rand-Meir, T., and Raftery, M. A. (1969). Biochemistry 8 , 4214. Dickerson, T. A., and Geis, S. M. (1969). “Structure and Action of Proteins”. Harper-Row, New York. Dunn, B., and Bruice, T. C., (1970).J. Amer. Chem. SOC.92, 2410. Dunn, B., and Bruice, T. C., (1971).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 93, 5725. Dyer, E., Glaudemans, C. P. J., Koch, M. J., and Marchessault, R. H. (1962). J. Chem. SOC. 3361. Eastham, A. M., Blackall, E. L., and Latremouille (1955). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 77, 2182. Eberson, L. (1964). A c t n Chem. Scand 18, 2015. Edwards, L. J. (1952). Trans Faraday SOC. 48, 696. Eigen, M. (1964). Angew Chem. Ink E d 3, 1. Eliel, E. L. (1962). ‘Stereochemistry of Carbon Compounds”, McGraw-Hill, New York, p. 196. Eriksson, S. O., and Holst, C. (1966). Acta Chem. Scand. 20, 1892. Eyring, H., Lumry, R., and Spikes, J. D. (1954). In “The Mechanism of Enzyme Action”, W. D. McElroy and B. Glass, Eds., Johns Hopkins Press, Baltimore, p. 123. Fedor, L. R.. and Bruice, T. C . (1964).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 86,4117 Felton, S. M:, and Bruice, T. C. -(1968).-Chem.Comm. 907. Felton, S. M., and Bruice, T. C. (1969). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 91, 6721. Fersht, A. R. (1971). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 93, 3504. Fersht, A. R. (1972). J. Amer. Chem. SOC.94, 293. Fersht, A. R., andKirby, A. J. (1967). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 89, 4857, 4953. Fersht, A. R., and Kirby, A. J. (1968a).J. Amer. Chem. SOC.90, 5818. Fersht, A. R., and Kirby, A. J. (1968b). J. Amer. Chem. SOC.90, 5833. Fersht, A. R., and Raquena, Y. (1971). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 93, 7079. Fife, T. H. (1965). J. Amer. C h e m SOC. 87, 271. Fife, T. H. (1967).J. Amer. C h e m SOC.89, 3228. Fife, T. H. (1972). Acc. C h e m Res. 5 , 264. Fife, T. H., and Anderson, E. (1970). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 92, 5464. Fife, T. H., and Anderson, E. (1971a). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 93, 6610. Fife, T. H., and Anderson, E. (1971b). J. Org. Chem. 36, 2357. Fife, T. H., and Benjamin, B. (1973). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 95, 2059. Fife, T. H., and Benjamin, B. (1974). Chem. C o m m u n 525. Fife, T. H., and Brod, L. H. (1970).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 92, 1681. Fife, T. H., and Brod, L. H., (1968).J. Org. Chem. 33, 4136. Fife, T. H., and De, N. C. (1974).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 96, 6158. Fife, T. H., and Hagopian, L. (1966). J. Org. Chem. 31, 1773. Fife, T. H., and Hutchins, J. E. C. (1972).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 94, 2837. Fife, T. H., Hutchins, J. E. C., and McMahon, D. M. (1972).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 94, 1316. Fife, T. H., and Jao, L. K. (1965). J. Org. Chem. 30, 1492. Fife, T. H., and Jao, L. K. (1968). J. Amer. Chem. SOL. 90, 4081. Fife, T. H., and McMahon, D. M. (1970). J. Org. Chem. 35, 3699. Fife, T. H., and Milstien, J. B. (1967). Biochemistry 6, 2901. Frost, L. N., andHegarty, A. F. (1973). Chem. Comm. 82. Gaetjens, E., and Morawetz, H. (1960). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 82, 5328. Garrett, E. R. (1957).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 79, 3401, 5206. Gibson, K. D., and Scheraga, H. (1967). PYOC.Nut. A c a d S c i U.S. 58,420.
120
T. H. FIFE
Giudici, T. A., and Bruice, T. C. (1970). Chem. Comm. 690. Goitein, R., and Bruice, T. C. (1972). J. Phys. Chem. 76, 432. Gold, V., Oakenfull, D. G. and Riley, T. (1968). I. Chem. SOC. ( B ) 515. Hartsuck, J. A., and Lipscomb, W. N. (1971). I n “The Enzymes,” 3rd Edition, Vol. 3, P. D. Boyer, Ed., Academic Press, New York. Hegarty, A. F., and Frost, L. N. (1972). Chem. Comm. 500. Henbest, H. B., and Lovell, B. J. (1957). J. Chem. SOC.1965. Henderson, R. (1970). J. Mol. Biol. 54, 341. Higuchi, T., Eberson, L, and Herd, A. K. (1966). J. Amer. Chem. SOC.88, 3805. Higuchi, T., Takechi, H., Pitman, 1. H., and Fung, H. L. (1971).]. Amer. Chem. SOC. 93, 539. Hofmann, K., and Bergmann, M. (1940). J. Biol. Chem. 134,225. Hoppe, J. I., and Prue,J. E. (1957).J. C h e m SOC. 1775. Hubbard, C. D., Kirsch, J. F. (1972). Biochemistry 11, 2483. Hunkapiller, M. W., Smallcombe, S. H., Whitaker, D. R., and Richards, J. H. (1973). Biochemistry 12, 4732. Hutchins, J. E. C., and Fife, T. H. (1972).J. Amer. Chem. SOC.94, 8848. Hutchins, J. E. C., and Fife, T. H. (1973a).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 95, 2282. Hutchins, J. E. C., and Fife, T. H. (1973b)..]. Amer. Chem. SOC.95, 3786. Hybl, A.,-Rundle, R. E., and Williams, D.-E. (1965). J. Amer. C h e m SOC. 87, 2779. Inagami, T., York, S. S., and Patchornik, A. (1965). J. Amer. Chem. SOC.87, 126. Inward, P. W., andJencks, W. P. (1965). J. Biol. Chem. 240, 1986. Jencks, W. P. (1963). Ann Rev. Biochem 32, 639. Jencks, W. P. (1969). “Catalysis in Chemistry and Enzymology”, McGraw-Hill, New York, N.Y. Jencks, W. P. (1973). Chem. Rev. 73, 705. Jencks, W. P. (1972).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 94, 4731. Jencks, W. P., andCarriuolo, J. (1960). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 82, 1778. Jencks, W. P., and Carriuolo, J. (1961). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 83, 1743. Jencks, W. P., and Gilchrist, M. (1962).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 84, 2910. Jencks, W. P., and Gilchrist, M. (1968).]. Amer. Chem. SOC. 90, 2622. Jollhs, P. (1964). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 3, 28. Johnson, L. N., and Phillips, D. C., (1965). Nature 206, 761. Johnson, S. L. (1967). Adv. Phys. Org. C h e m 5, 237. Kaiser, E. T. and Kaiser, B. L. (1972). Acc. Chem. Res. 5, 219. Kang, E. P., a n d s t o r m , C. B. (1972). Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 49, 621. Kirby, A. J., and Fersht, A. R. (1971). In “Progress in Bioorganic Chemistry,” E. T. Kaiser and F. J. Kkzdy, Ed. Wiley, New York, Vol. 1. p. 1. Kirsch, J. F., and Jencks, W. P. (1964). /. Amer. Chem. SOC. 86, 833, 837. Koshland, D. E., Jr. (1958). Proc. Nut. A c a d SOC.,U.S. 44, 98. Koshland, D. E., Jr. (1962). J. Theoret. Biol. 2, 75. Kroll, H. (1952).]. Amer. Chem. SOC. 74, 2036. Kupchan, S. M., Johnson, W. S., and Rajagopalan, S. (1959). Tetrahedron 7, 47. Kupchan, S. M., and Narayanan, C. R. (1959).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 81, 1913. Kupchan, S. M., Eriksen, S. P., and Friedman, M. (1962). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 84, 4159. Kupchan, S. M., Eriksen, S. P., and Friedman, M. (1966a). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 88, 343. Kupchan, S . M., Eriksen, S. P., and Liang, Y. T. (1966b). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 88, 347. Kupchan, S. M., and Johnson, W. S. (1956).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 78, 3864.
PHYSICAL ORGANIC MODEL SYSTEMS: ENZYMATIC CATALYSIS
121
Kupchan, S. M., Slade, P., and Young, R. J. (1960). Tetrahedron Lett. 24, 22. Lipscomb, W. N. (1970). Acc. Chem. Res. 3, 81. Lipscomb, W. N., Hartsuck, J. A, Reeke, G. N., Jr., Ouiocho, F. A., Bethge, P. H., Ludwig, M. L., Steitz, T. A., Muirhead, H., and Coppola, J. C. (1968). Brookhaven Symp. BioL 21, 24. Lipscomb, W. N., Reeke, G. N., Jr., Ouiocho, F. A.. and Bethge, P. H. (1970). Phil. Trans. Roy. SOC.( B ) 251, 177. Lowe, G., Sheppkd, G.,'Sinnott, M. L., and Williams, A. (1967). Biochem. J. 104, 893. Lowry, T. M., and Faulkner, I. J. (1925). J. Chem. SOC. 2883. Lowry, T. M., and Faulkner, I. J. (1927). Z . Physik Chem. Leiprig 130, 125. Lukas, E. C., Caplow, M., and Bush, K. J. (1973).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 95, 2670. Lumry, R., and Rajender, S. (1971).J. Phys. C h e m 75, 1387. Martell, A. E. (1968). Pure AppL Chem. 17, 129. Martinek, K., Dorovska, V. N., Varfolomeyev, S. D., and Berezin, I. V. (1972). Biochim Biophys. Acta 271, 80. Maugh, T., and Bruice, T. C. (1971).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 93, 3237. Menger, F. M., and Smith, J. H. (1969). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 91, 5346. Meriwether, L., and Westheimer, F. H. (1956).J. Amer. Chem. SOC.78, 5119. Milstien, J. B., and Fife, T. H. (1968). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 90, 2164. Milstien, J. B., and Fife, T. H. (1969).Biochemistry 8, 623. Milstien, S., and Cohen, L. (1972).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 94, 9158. Morawetz, H., and Oreskes, I. (1958).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 80, 2591. Nath, R. L., and Rydon, H. N. (1954). Biochem. J. 57, 1. Oakenfull, D. G., and Jencks, W. P. (1971). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 93, 178. Oakenfull, D. G., Riley, T., and Gold, V. (1966). Chem. Comm. 385. Oakenfull, D. G., Richardson, D. I., and Usher, D. A., (1967). J. Amer. Chem. SOC.89,5491. Okuyama, T., and Schmir, G. L. (1972). J. Amer. Chem. SOC.94, 8805. O'Leary, M. H., and Kluetz, M. D., (1972).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 94, 3585. Osawa, T., and Nakasawa, Y . (1966). Biochim. Biophys. Acta 130, 56. Page, M., and Jencks, W. P. (1971). Proc. Nut. Acad Sci, 1J.S. 68, 1678. Page, M. I., andJencks, W. P. (1972).]. Amer. Chem. SOC. 94, 8818. Parsons, S. M., and Raftery, M. A. (1972). Biochemistry 11, 1623. Phillipp, M., Pollack, R. M., and Bender, M. L. (1973). Proc. Nut. Acad. Sci U . S . 70, 517. Phillips, D. C. (1969). Sci Amer. 215, 78. Piszkiewicz, D., and Bruice, T. C. (1967). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 89, 6237. Piszkiewicz, D., and Bruice, T. C. (1968a). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 90, 5844. Piszkiewicz, D., and Bruice, T. C. (196813). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 90, 2156. Pocker, Y. (1960). Chem. Znd (London) 968. Polgar, L., and Bender, M. L. (1969). Proc. Nut. Acad. Sci, U S . 64, 1335. Raftery, M. A., and Rand-Meir, T. (1968). Biochemistry 7, 3281. Riordan, J. F., and Muszynska, G. (1974). Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 57, 447. Robertus, J. D., Kraut, J., Alden, R. A., and Birktoft, J. J. (1972). Biochemistry 11, 4293. Rogers, G. A., and Bruice, T. C. (1974). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 96, 2463. Rony, P. R. (1968).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 90, 2824. Rupley, J. A. (1967). Proc. Roy. SOC. B167, 416. Rupley, J. A., and Gates, V. (1967). Proc. Nut. A c a d Sci U.S. 57, 496. Rupley, J. A., Gates, V., and Bilbrey, R. (1968). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 90, 5633. Salomaa, P. (1957). Acta Chem. Scand 11, 132, 141, 239.
122
T. H. FIFE
Salomaa, P. (1964). Suomen Kemistilehti B37, 86. Salomaa, P., and Laiho, S. (1963). Acta Chem. Scand 17, 103. Secemski, I. I., and Lienhard, G. E. (1971).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 93, 3549. Sigman, D. S., Wahl, G. M., andcreighton, D. J. (1972). Biochemistry 11, 2236. Smidsrod, O.,Haug, A., and Larson, B. (1966). Actn Chem. Scund 20, 1026. Snell, R. L., Kwok, W. K., and Kim, Y. (1967).J. Amer. Chem. SOC.89, 6728. Snoke, J. E., Schwert, G. W., and Neurath, H. (1948). I. BioL Chem. 175, 7. Speck, J. C., Rynbrandt, D. J., and Kochevar,‘I. H. (1965). J. Amer. Chem SOC. 87, 4979. Storm, D. R., and Koshland, D. E., Jr. (1970). Proc. Nut. Acad Sci, U.S. 66, 445. Storm, D. R., and Koshland, D. E., Jr. (1972a). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 94, 5805. Storm, D. R., and Koshland, D. E., Jr. (1972b).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 94, 5815. Swain, C. G., and Brown, J. F. (1952). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 74, 2534. Taft, R. W., Jr. (1956). In “Steric Effects in Organic Chemistry”, M. S. Newman, Ed., Wiley, New York, N.Y., p. 556. Thanassi, J. W., and Bruice, T. C. (1966). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 88, 747. Usher, D. A., Richardson, D. I., Jr., and Oakenfull, D. G. (1970). J. Amer. Chern. SOC.92,4699. Van Etten, R. L., Clowes, G. A., Sebastian, J. F., and Bender, M. L. (1967a).J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 89, 3242. Van Etten, R. L., Clowes, G. A., Sebastian, J. F., and Bender, M. L. (1967b).J. Amer. Chem SOC. 89, 3253. Vernon, C. A., (1967). Proc. Roy. SOC. ( B ) 167, 389. Wang, J. H., andParker, L. (1967). Proc. Nut. Acad Sci, US.58, 2451. Weeks, D.P., andcrane, J. P. (1973). J. Org. Chem. 38, 3375. Weeks, D. P., Grodski, A., and Fanucci, R (1968). J. Amer. Chem. SOC.90, 4958. Westheimer, F. H. (1962). Adu. Enzymol. 24, 441. Williams, A. (1970). Biochemistry 9, 3383. Winstein, S.,Smith, S., and Darwish, D. (1959). J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 81, 5511. Wright, C. S., Alden, R. A., and Kraut, J. (1969). Nutwe 221, 235. Zachau, H. G., and Karau, W. (1960). Ber. 93, 1830. Zeffren, E., and Hall, P. L. (1973). “The Study of Enzyme Mechanisms”, John Wiley and Sons, New York, N.Y., p. 127.
Charge Density-NMR Chemical Shift Correlations in Organic Ions
D. G . FARNUM Department of Chemistry, Michigan State University, East Lansing, Michigan, U.S.A. 1. 2.
3.
4.
.
Introduction Theory General . Pnmr and Cnmr screening parameters summary . Empirical Observations . . General Basic correlations . Selected problems Conclusions . . References
.
. . . .
.
. . . . . .
123 126 126 127 135 135 135 136 148 172 173
1. INTRODUCTION Five years ago a brief review focused on the applications of nuclear magnetic resonance (nmr) as a method for determining charge density in carbonium ions and pointed out some of the precautions required (Fraenkel and Famum, 1968). Since then, proton nmr (pnmr), which was emphasized in that review, has continued to attract primary attention as a probe into the structure and charge density of organic cations and anions (Olah and Schleyer, 1968,1970,1972, 1973; 0 t h e t al., 1972; Takahashi e t al., 1973; van
124
D. G. FARNUM
der Kooij et al., 1972). Recently, its supremacy as a charge-density probe has been challenged by carbon- 13 nmr (cnmr), whose potential was noted in the early review, but whose practical applications awaited the development of more nearly routine instrumentation (Stothers, 1972). AIthough there are many excellent general reviews of the principles and applications of both pnmr (Becker, 1969; Bovey, 1969; Jackman and Sternhell, 1969; Paudler, 1971; Dixon, 1972) and cnmr (Levy and Nelson, 1972; Stothers, 1972) which treat, in part, their use in determining charge densities, there does not seem to be a comprehensive review which concentrates on a comparison of the two methods, both in theory and in practice, as charge density probes. It is because of this need, particularly at a time when moderately priced, routine cnmr instrumentation promises to swell the already perplexing flood of data appearing in the literature, that this review is presented. The common division into sections on theoretical concepts and empirical observations is followed, but pnmr and cnmr are treated jointly where feasible in each of these sections. The section on theory is unlikely to satisfy those theorists who would like a critical presentation and analysis of conflicting theories. That task, important as it is, is well outside the competence of this reviewer. The presentation here is directed to practising organic chemists who could use a qualitative description of some key concepts emerging from the theoretical treatments to help them avoid possible pitfalls in data interpretation, and prompt them to design models to test some of the ideas. The section on empirical observations is designed to flesh out the theoretical bones as well as provide some data which raise some puzzling problems. The data presented, therefore, do not even approach an exhaustive survey, but are chosen in accordance with the bias of the reviewer t o illustrate points felt to be of particular significance. A less selective approach would obscure the purpose. No attempt has been made in this review to treat other nuclei, since they have not enjoyed the general attention that pnmr and cnmr have. Nonetheless, both theoretical and experimental effort has been spent on fluorine-19 (Adcock et al., 1973; Timberlake et aZ., 1971), and, more recently, oxygen-17 and nitrogen-14 (Mateescu, 1973) nmr as charge density probes. The following conventions and assumptions will be used in reporting data: (1) The practice of reporting both proton and carbon-13 chemical shifts in parts per million (p.p.m.) downfield
CHARGE DENSITY-NMR CHEMICAL SHIFT CORRELATIONS
125
from tetramethylsilane (TMS) will be followed, with a positive sign indicating values downfield. Carbon-13 values are rounded to the nearest p.p.m. (2) Where the reference used experimentally was other than TMS, it is designated in parentheses, along with its chemical shift value used to convert the data to TMS. In some cases, authors have determined chemical shifts using TMS and then converted them to other standards (e.g. CS,) for reporting. In such cases the chemical shift value used by the authors for that standard is given in parentheses and used to convert the data back to TMS, even though it may differ from the accepted value. For example, a chemical shift reported in this review as “214 (ext. TMS, conv. to CS, = 194-6)” means that the authors determined the chemical shift with external TMS as standard, converted it to CS, using the value 194.6 as the chemical shift of CS2 relative to TMS, and reported it relative to CS,. The reported value has been reconverted to 214 relative to external TMS using the authors conversion factor of 194.6. Proton data are reported relative to internal TMS unless otherwise indicated. Carbon-13 data are generally reported relative to external TMS, although the original work does not always state clearly whether the standard is internal or external. The difference is not likely to be significant for the comparisons made here. (3) Chemical shift differences will be reported with a negative sign indicating a downfield shift and a positive sign signifying an upfield shift. Although this may seem inconsistent with convention ( l ) ,it is in accord with most current practice. (4) Solvents used are reported in parentheses in most cases where it is clear from the original work, although in some cases of carbonium ion spectra the solvent is not indicated and may be assumed to be one of several different strong acids used interchangeably. Concentrations are not reported since they are usually not known. The effect of solvent and concentration on chemical shifts will surely be more significant for proton spectra than carbon-13 spectra, and the attempt made in this review to compare data obtained under different conditions of soIvent and concentration (and temperature as well) suffers from the scarcity of systematic studies of these effects on ion spectra. However it seems unlikely that the carbon-13 spectra will be affected too drastically by changes among solvents of comparable acidity, and, even for proton spectra, we can still make use of the trends that emerge. The related phenomenon of ion association has also generally been ignored in this review except in those few cases of carbanions where its influence has been demonstrated. Again, the effect is probably more
126
D. G. FARNUM
significant for protons than carbon-13, and the general feeling seems to be that it is more significant for carbanions than for carbonium ions in powerful acids.
2. THEORY General The development of a general theory of nmr c..emical shifts as a function of electronic structure has been the product of a number of theoretical minds, and has been reviewed by Memory (1968). As is usually the case, the rigorous theory is unmanageable for any compounds of interest, and the manageable theories involve so many approximations that they lose their rigor. Nonetheless, several approximate theories have been developed which correlate chemical shifts (both proton and carbon-13) remarkably well in closely related compounds (e.g., aromatic hydrocarbons, Lazeretti and Taddei, 1971). Furthermore, as stated several times by Grant (Pugmire et al., 1973) the value of approximate theories probably lies less hi their ability to predict chemical shifts accurateIy than in their ability to point out important trends and identify structural features of dominant importance in determining chemical shifts. The familiar separation of the screening constant for an atom A, uA, into a summation of screening constants from several conceptually identifiable factors, as in (l),provides a convenient approximation for elaboration.
Here, ui A is a positive term resulting from diamagnetic shielding by electrons “localized” on atom A, u t A is a term (usually negative) which corrects for any deviation from spherical symmetry of the electrons’ localized on atom A, u A B represents the effect on atom A (shielding or deshielding) of circulation of electrons localized on other atoms, and represents the effect on atom A (shield~
’
~
p
~
~
’
~
~
.
The up term includes excited state mixing and can be separated into both positive and negative terms (Pugmire and Grant, 1968a) corresponding to shielding and deshielding effects as noted in the next section.
CHARGE DENSITY-NMR CHEMICAL SHIFT CORRELATIONS
127
ing or deshielding) of circulation of electrons in delocalized R systems (generally “ring current” effects). The dependence of each of these terms on structure, and a comparison of the contribution each makes to the total screening constant uA for protons and carbon-13 will be explored in the next section.
Pnmr and Cnmr Screening Parameters The “other atom” terms uA and uA~deloc. These terms are treated first since, although they do contribute to uA, their contribution is independent of the nature of the atom A or the charge on atom A (Fraenkel and Farnum, 1968; Stothers, 1972). Their magnitude is therefore the same for both protons and carbon13, and is unchanged by the charge on these atoms.* Since cnmr screening constants are very large compared to u A B and uAide’oc., these “other atom” terms generally contribute 10% or less to u A and not more than 2 p.p.m. to the chemical shift, and are usually ignored in cnmr analysis. For protons, however these terms often dominate uA and the chemical shifts, and accurate corrections for them must be found and applied before chemical shifts can be used t o probe other structural features such as charge density (Fraenkel and Farnum, 1968). An analysis of the quantitative effect on atom A of electron circulations elsewhere in the molecule usually requires an accurate knowledge of the geometry of all important conformations of the molecule, as well as accurate mathematical or empirical models for the screening contribution. With the many assumptions that are necessary, it is usually difficult to make a convincing analysis (Farnum, 1967). The influence of u A B and uA9de’oc. is probably the single most important factor that obscures the effect of charge density on proton chemical shifts. It is no wonder that cnmr was greeted with such enthusiasm as a way to circumvent this problem. The local diamagnetic term, of A This term is comparable in magnitude to u A B and u ~ ~for ~ both protons and carbon-13. Before considering the effect of charge
*
This is not strictly true if the ring current contribution to r ~ ~ includes ~ ~ atom ~ A’ in the delocalized ring. However, the perturbation of an asymmetric charge distribution on the ring current generally seems to be ignored.
~
~
~
’
*
~
D. G. FARNUM
128
on ~2A , it is important to distinguish the ways in which pnmr and cnmr are used to probe charge distribution. Thus, for protons, the chemical shift is interpreted in terms of the charge on the attached carbon, while for carbon-13, the chemical shift is interpreted in terms of the charge directly on the carbon whose chemical shift is being determined. This difference has an important consequence which complicates the interpretation of proton chemical shifts. In fact, the electron density at the proton, which determines u t A , is rarely obtained directly. Rather, the electron density at the attached carbon is calculated by some procedure, and its effect on the electron density at the proton by polarization of the C-H bond is then calculated. In addition to polarization of the C-H bonding electrons by the component of the field along the C-H bond axis, E z , Buckingham (1960) has pointed out that there is also a deshielding effect on u which is proportional to E 2 [equation (211
-
A u = - aEZ - bE2
(2)
Although the E 2 correction is usually negligible, it can assume importance with high fields (i.e., high charges), and Musher (1962) has found that correction of the raw data for some aromatic cations and anions by the E 2 term improves the now well known 10 p.p.m. per unit charge correlation of Fraenkel et al. (1960) (see Section 3). He has also suggested that charged atoms elsewhere in the molecule would polarize the C-H bond, and that corrections from these terms may not be negligible. When both E Z and E 2 terms for all charged carbon atoms are considered, the pnmr spectra of phenyl carbonium ions is adequately correlated by HMO charge densities, while, when the additional terms are ignored, SCF-MO charge densities provide a better fit (Farnum, 1967). In spite of their demonstrated importance, Musher’s corrections seem to have been ignored, probably because they introduce another mathematical complication into the analysis which increases one’s scepticism and resistance. Conversion of the Musher equations into frequency units (Schweizer et al. 1964), as in equation (3), makes them easier to use. As given here, the units of Au are p.p.m., a negative sign is deshielding, q i is the total charge at the carbon in question in units of one electron (a positive charge has a positive sign), and cos Bi and R i (in A) are defined as in Figure 1 (see
CHARGE DENSITY-NMR CHEMICAL SHIFT CORRELATIONS
129
Figure 1. Definition of the terms used in equation (3).
Jackman and Sternhell, 1969, pp. 67-9).3
Aa=
-
1 3 . 3 ( 7 qi
"i)
-
17.0
(2%
R:)2
If one ignores the charge on all but the attached carbon atom. cos B i becomes 1, and the equation then R i becomes -1.09 further reduces to equation (4).Routine application of equation (4)
a,
A~=-11-2q-l2*0q~
(4)
to anions and cations could easily be done, and would allow an estimate of the importance of the q 2 term. Musher has cautioned, however, that use of the bond terminus (the carbonium ion carbon) as the vector terminus violates an assumption in the derivation of equation (3). Thus it is not clear that the theory applies in this simple form. Perhaps dramatization of the cos 0 term by preparation of a system in which a positive charge resulted in shielding of a proton of appropriate geometry as in [ l ] or [2] would call attention to its importance. In each of these geometries the polarization of the C-H bond should result in an increase in the electron density around the proton, an increase in a$ *, and an upfield shift of about 1.3 p.p.m. at a distance of 3 A.4 In Musher's original equations, the vector Ri was measured from the midpoint of the carbon-hydrogen bond to the midpoint of the carbon-carbon bonds. However, subsequent users of his equations seem to have measured the vector from atom to atom. The latter calculation is much easier, and the error inkoduced seems to be small for most molecular geometries encountered, provided the correct values for the constants are used. The value for the first constant is determined empirically to fit the observed linear dependence of u on q for the aromatic cations and anions. Differences in the magnitude of this constant in the literature reflect differences in the accepted proportionality constant and in the assumed geometrical parameters. The value given here (13'3) differs from the Schweizer value (12*5), and was calculated assuming a carbon-hydrogen bond length of 1.09 A and a proportionality constant of 11.2 [see equation (4)] as determined by Mushcr after correction for the E a term It is within the theoretically expected range of -10-16 (Buckingham, 1960; Musher, 1962). The second constant (17.0) is a theoretical estimate (Musher, 1962; Schweizer et aL 1964). If the field vector is taken at the midpoint of the carbon-hydrogen bond the predicted shift is smaller, but still greater than 0-5 p.p.m.
130
D. G. FARNUM
A clear demonstration of the importance of the E 2 term might be achieved in a system where cos 0 was 0, thus cancelling the E Z term. The remaining E 2 term is independent of the s i p of the charge, so that two systems with geometries and charges as in [3] and [4] should give the sume deshielding effect on the indicated proton relative to system [ 5 ] , other factors being equal. For R = 3 A the predicted effect is about 0.2 p.p.m. which is easily detectable.
9
131
[41
[51
By contrast, the influence of charge on udAA for cnmr shifts is determined by direct calculation of the charge on carbon atom “A”. Hence, no correction for the E 2 term or electron polarization by other charged atoms is necessary. The accuracy of the calculated charge density depends only on how faithfully the mathematical model chosen reflects reality. Grant (Pugmire et al. 1973) has emphasized that the effect of charge on u s A is twofold: (1) an increase in electron density at atom A increases the diamagnetic current density and results in an upfield shift, and (2) an increase in electron density increases the effective radius of the orbitals (by , and shielding the nuclear charge), decreases the magnitude of results in a partially compensating downfield shift. Clearly if u$* were the dominant parameter determining the effect of charge on chemical shifts for both protons and carbon-13, cnmr shifts could be more easily and reliably correlated with charge for density than could pnmr shifts. Unfortunately, although protons is negligible (Memory, 1968) because of the high energy of therefore accounts for the full 10 the proton excited states, and p.p.m. per electron (on carbon) charge dependence found for proton
utA
atA
utA
CHARGE DENSITY-NMR CHEMICAL S H F T CORRELATIONS
131
chemical shifts, u t A for carbon-13 can be quite large, and 02, accounts for only some 10% of the charge dependence found for carbon-13 (of the order of 13-18 p.p.m. per electron according to Pugmire et al. (1969)). We must therefore turn to an analysis of the factors affecting ut A if we are to understand cnmr shifts.
The local “paramagnetic” term, up”A This term in the total screening constant corrects for the symmetrical dectron distribution used to calculate the diamagnetic term us A by mixing excited electronic states with the ground states. The resultant electron distribution is a closer approximation to that of the molecule, and the resultant screening constant is a more accurate value. The term enters the total screening expression as though there were a “paramagnetic” circulation of electrons superimposed on the diamagnetic circulation, although this is simply an artifact of the calculation. Like the diamagnetic term, the paramagnetic term shows a direct dependence on electron density (i.e., if there are no electrons in an orbital, there is no u, term for that orbital, and therefore no correction, required), and an indirect dependence as a result of an increase in average orbital radius, r , with an increase in orbital electron density (actually a l / r 3 term for up). In addition there is an inverse dependence on the energy difference, AE, between the ground and excited states for promotion of the electron in question. Obviously, the l/AE term simply says the larger the energy gap between ground and excited states, the less distortion in electron distribution by excited state mixing. Clearly the l/AE dependence accounts for the fact that a t A is negligible in pnmr where electronic excited states require promotion of an electron from a 1s to a 2s or 2p orbital. The term is dominant, however, in larger atoms where excited states are much lower lying. In fact, it is as a “correction” to u t A for quite misleading to speak of carbon-13 screening constants, since changes in up are an order of magnitude greater than those in O d . The dependence of these changes on various structural parameters has been analysed by Grant (Pugmire e t al., 1968, 1973) and a conceptual paraphrase of some of his conclusions follows. Following and elaborating on the approach of Karplus and Das (1961) Grant accepts a separation of up for carbon-13 into a term ubl ) for electrons in orbitals centred entirely on the carbon atom in for electrons in orbitals centred both on question, and a term that atom as well as other atoms in the molecule (ie., “bonding”
utA,
utA
062)
132
D. G. FARNUM
orbitals). He then treats the dependence of u$l ) on orbital charge in some detail. Following the practice of many others in the field, it was assumed that the change in AE with charge could be ignored, and an average value for AE of 10 eV (Pople, 1962), was taken for computational simplification. A number of other assumptions were made at the sacrifice of quantitative accuracy in order to obtain a very useful qualitative picture of the dependence of u$') on q', the orbital electron charge. The direct dependence of of,') on q1 is graphed by the solid line in Figure 2, which is the sum of a deshielding term linear in q' and a shielding q t 2 / 2 term (dashed lines). From this treatment there emerges the surprising prediction that, for a carbon atom denuded of valence electrons (charge = +4), the addition of electron density results in an increase in the deshielding term u ; ' ) , which opposes the shielding term u d . This deshielding increases until q' = 1 (charge = 0), at which point it reverses in direction and additional increase in electron density results in increased shielding. This curious behaviour makes some sense in that, with n o electrons in the orbital there is n o fJd term, and therefore n o "correction" term, up, necessary, while with a completely occupied orbital, the effects of the q' and q f 2 terms exactly cancel (to a first approximation) and u$')goes to zero again. It is important that, if the direct dependence on q f illustrated in Figure 2 were the only effect of q' on uf,'), there would be a zero dependence of of,') on q f in the region q' = 1, the very region most investigated for charge-density-chemical shift correlations, and the region covered by the early empirical correlation of Spiesecke and Schneider (1961). However, the expansion of the orbital with increasing orbital electrolJl density results in an indirect inverse dependence on q' which in the case of u $ ' ) , shows up as a l / r 3 factor. This indirect dependence is represented by Grant by inclusion of the effective nuclear charge parameter $ of Karplus and Pople (1963). This term enters a factor t 3 , which increases the magnitude of 0;') as [, the effective nuclear charge, increases (i.e., as the electrons are held closer t o the nucleus, thereby affecting the field at the nucleus more'). The resultant dependence of u ; ' ) on q f is 3 '2 illustrated by the solid line in Figure 3 as the sum of the q /2 and -E3qf terms (dashed lines). Thus, the slope of the correlation in
as
It must be emphasized that E also enters into the expression for U d , where it results in increased shielding with increasing effective nuclear charge. However, it only enters as a first-order term, so its effect is much less significant than in the already dominant up term, where it enters as a cubic term.
CHARGE DENSITY-NMR CHEMICAL SHIFT CORRELATIONS
133
the region q' = 1 (formal charge = 0) is seen t o be almost entirely the result of the .t3 factor, which results in increased shielding with increasing electron density. Although some other approaches give the
/
-2.01 0
I
I .o
\ '
2.0
91 Figure 2. Direct dependence of the one atom paramagnetic screening constant, oc), on the orbital electron density, q ' , for carbon-13. Modified from Pugmire et al. (1968).
same result (e.g.,'Emsley, 1968), Tokuhiro and Fraenkel (1969) conclude that the t3 dependence accounts for only about one-half the downfield shift in N-heterocycles (see also page 169). In summary, then, the above treatment predicts that, if one starts with a neutral carbon atom in a molecule, and adds electron density to it, the contribution of ubl) to the overall screening constant should decrease (i.e., become less deshielding) in accordance with the t3 dependence. To the extent that oil) is important in the total screening constant, the chemical shift should move upfield. If, however, electron density is removed from the carbon in question, the contribution of to the screening constant should increase (become more deshielding) up to a point. Then, as further electron
06')
134
D. G. FARNUM
density is removed, 0;') should begin to decrease and, to the extent that ug' ) dominates the total screening constant, shielding should actually increase. This startling suggestion has yet to be examined experimentally, but some evidence bearing upon its validity will be explored in Section 3 on empirical observations. I
1
TWO-ELECTRON TERM
\
\,'
I
*.,
.*-
__----.
I
I'
ONE- ELECTRON TERM
3 Figure 3. Total dependence of the one atom paramagnetic screening constant, 0;). on the orbital electron density, q', for carbon-13. Copied with permission from Pugmire et al. (1968).
062)
The term is not treated as explicitly, but its magnitude seems to be primarily dependent on the bond order between the carbon in question and its bonded atoms. An increase in the bond order increases the magnitude of the negative term u p ) and results in deshielding, while a decrease in bonding decreases and results in shielding.
DY
Higher order terms Grant (Pugmire et al., 1973) has suggested that third and fourth order perturbations on the electron distributions, though significant
CHARGE DENSITY-NMR CHEMICAL SHIFT CORRELATIONS
135
in magnitude, are of opposite sign and probably cancel, so that their net effect is not likely t o refine the total screening constant significantly.
Summary The above interpretation of the factors indicated by current theory to be important in determining proton and carbon-13 chemical shifts does not offer much encouragement for the optimistic statement that “[carbon-13 chemical shifts] should provide a more reliable index of charge than the hydrogen shifts” (Fraenkel and Farnum, 1968, p. 251). It is true that the “other atom” terms are a more serious perturbation on proton than on carbon-13 chemical shifts, and are difficult to evaluate. However it is also apparent that carbon-13 shifts are determined by a number of terms (Td, oil), and o i 2 ) whose charge dependence may well be in opposite directions (and variable), and whose relative magnitudes will be very difficult t o assess. A graphical analysis of u y ) as in Figure 2 and Figure 3 for u;’) would be exceedingly valuable, as would a graphical comparison of ud, o i l ) and ui2) as a function of q. However, this has yet to be done. Furthermore, it has been suggested that the assumption that AE is unchanged introduces an unacceptable error into the estimates of up (Jones et al., 1969). In fact, Pugmire e t al. (1969, 1973) now suggest that u- and n-electron densities, bond orders, and AE are all important in determining carbon-1 3 chemical shifts. Clearly, reliable interpretation of carbon-13 chemical shifts in terms of charge densities will require empirical verification of the above ideas and the discovery of reliable correlations. It seems likely that, in cases where magnetic anisotropy of other atoms is not significant, proton shifts will be useful, while in other cases carbon-13 may be better. It is t o illuminate these problems that we now turn t o a consideration of empirical correlations of proton and carbon-13 chemical shifts with charge densities.
3. EMPIRICAL OBSERVATIONS General That ‘H and I3C chemical shifts correlate linearly with charge density in carbonium ions and carbanions has been an operating
136
D. G. FARNUM
assumption for many of us, even though we acknowledge, in principle, the gross oversimplification in that assumption. Indeed, the Fraenkel, and Spiesecke and Schneider expressions, Ao = -10 Aq for pnmr, and A U = -160 Aq for cnmr, have become a part of our grammar. In Section 2 we explored the theoretical bases for these expressions, and found that, although they seem to be sound for small charge densities, we can expect problems at high charge densities such as those found in ions. In this section we will explore the empirical bases for these correlations, attempt to discover other empirical correlations from data available in the literature, and discuss selected problems. The practice of reporting chemical shifts for both protons and carbon-13 in p.p.m. downfield from TMS will be followed.
Basic Correlations Although many workers recognized the possibility of a linear correlation of chemical shift with charge density, the credit for discovery of the values of the constants and clear expression of the relationships usually goes to Fraenkel e t al. (1960), Spiesecke and Schneider (1961), Lauterbur (1961), and MacLean and Mackor (1961). The familiar plot from the Spiesecke and Schneider work is reproduced in Figure 4. The charge densities6 of tropylium ion, benzene, and cyclopentadienide per carbon atom are plotted against the chemical shifts. N o corrections are made for ring current effects, hybridization changes, or E 2 terms. The slopes of the lines in the plots are close to 10 and 160, and these values, since they are good round numbers, have stuck, even though different workers have found somewhat different values. Since the plots cover a narrow range of charge ( - 0 2 to + 0 14),7 and consist of only three points, it would clearly be very desirable t o extend the range and add additional points before using the correlation with confidence, and particularly before making any gross extrapolations. Some attempts to add more points, as well as improve the fit, will be described below. Charge densities are determined by symmetry, and therefore represent total charge density at the carbon in question (neglecting dispersion of charge to the hydrogens), as required for the theoretical analyses described earlier. In some cases in the literature, calculated n-charge densities are used instead of total charge densities. In the sequel the term “charge density” will refer to total charge density unless otherwise qualified. The point for cyclo-octatetraene dianion was not used in determining the slope because of uncertainty about the magnitude of its ring current and extent of dissociation.
137
CHARGE DENSITY-NMR CHEMICAL SHIFT CORRELATIONS
Figure4. Dependence of proton and carbon-13 chemical shifts on charge density. Copied with permission from Spiesecke and Schneider (1961).
The pnmr correlation In order to explore the significance of the E 2 term in determining Aa, Musher (1962) calculated its effect for the C7H: and C5H; ions and found that the correlated points provided a near perfect fit with a correlation line of slope 11.2. Fraenkel et al. (1960) introduced a correction for the variation of ring current with ring size and found it to be small. In Table 1, the raw data for the pnmr shifts for these ions as well as some other monocyclic aromatic ions are given, along TABLE 1 Chemical Shifts and Corrections for Monocyclic Aromatic Ions
Ion
6H
C3H; C,H? C6H6 CgHG CsH3 CsHg
10.80' 9.18a 7*27a 6.8od 5-44' 5.6ga
Ring currenta correction E 2 correctionb Corrected
+la18 -0.07 0 -1.17 +O*ll -1.16
-1-33 -0.24 0 -0.15 -0.48 -0-75
6 H 6 13C
10.65 8-87
7-27 5.48 5-07 3-77
177e 155f 129f logd 102f 85f
~
a Schaefer and Schneider, 1963 ( C & j in CH3CN, 7.27). b tiom equation (4).
Breslow et al., 1967; Farnum et al., 1967 (TMA in HS03F, 3.13). h t z and Garratt, 1963; LaLancette and Benson, 1963 ( C & j in THF, 7-27). Olah and Mateescu, 1970 (ext. TMS, conv. to CS2= 194.6). f Spiesecke and Schneider, 1961 (CH30C02CH3 ext., converted to C6H6 = 128.7).
138
D. G. FARNUM
with the calculated E Z corrections [from equation (4)], ring current corrections (using a point-dipole approximation; Fraenkel et al. 1960; Schaefer and Schneider, 1963; Katz and Garratt, 1964), and corrected values[i.e., the values the chemical shifts would have if the linear first term of equation (4) were the only factor determining
1
3
.
0
0
1
12.0-
11010.09.0-
5 8.07.060-
5.01
4.0
td.1
3.01 td4 td.3 +d.2 do CHARGE
-6.1 -6.2 -d3 4 4
Figure 5 . Dependence of corrected proton chemical shifts on charge density. See Table 1 for data and references.
them]. The corrected values are plotted against charge density in Figure 5. The effect of the various corrections can be seen by comparing the uncorrected, partially corrected, and fully corrected points. The line is drawn through the three corrected original points. Their chemical shifts are considered to be the most reliable since the ring current corrections and the assumptions of complete dissociation and absence of hybridization effects for C9 H i , CBH i , and C3H< are of questionable validity.' It is gratifying that the additional points fall near the line, but the deviations are well outside experimental error, and do little to improve the reliability of the Although the data for C 3 H l were determined in fluorosulfuric acid, while the other shifts were determined in THF, solvent effects o n the aromatic cations are usually only a few tenths p.p.m in contrast to those o n the anions (Grutzner et al., 1972).
CHARGE DENSITY-NMR CHEMICAL SHIFT CORRELATIONS
139
original correlation.' Furthermore, if the effect of hybridization on C3H:, which is probably more than 1 p.p.m.,l0 is considered, the corrected point for C3H: moves upfield and becomes quite bad. Although the correlation of Figure 5 has proved quite useful (see Jackman and Sternhell, 1969, p. 68 for a number of references) it should be realized that neither the theory nor the empirical correlation has been tested outside the narrow range of charge covered by C,H; (-0.2) and C7H: (+0.14). In fact, the chemical shift of the 2-proton of the 2-propyl cation (dimethylcarbonium ion) (13.5) is not satisfactorily correlated by either equation (4)(which predicts -29) or by extrapolation of the line of Figure 5 (which predicts -17) if the carbon atom is assumed to have a single positive charge, and the absence of the ring current effect is taken into account. There are many factors that could account for the discrepancy; including such things as (1) a reduction of the estimated charge at C-2 by dispersion to the methyl groups [e.g., a charge on C-2 of about +0*4 would fit equation (4),while +0.65 would fit Figure 11; (2) incomplete dissociation of the cation [Bacon and Gillespie have established complex formation between methyl or ethyl fluoride and antimony pentafluoride (1971), and ion-pair complexation is a common occurrence with anions (Grutzner et ul., 1972)] ; (3) erroneous theory; (4)all of these. Clearly much more information is necessary if an assessment of the relative importance of these and other factors is to be obtained.
The cnmr correlation The original Spiesecke and Schneider correlation of carbon-13 chemical shifts with calculated charge densities (Figure 4) has been extended by Olah and Mateescu (1970) as replotted in Figure 6. As noted on page 127, correction of the raw data for ring current effects and E 2 terms is unnecessary for carbon-13 shifts. Therefore one would expect an excellent correlation, provided hybridization effects did not interfere. The calculation of charge density is not as reliable for some of the points on the Olah plot, since for triphenylcyclopropenium cation and tetraphenylcyclobutadiene dication it requires assumption of an approximate molecular orbital model which, in If we wanted to be cavalier, we could claim that the deviations for C9HG and C& result fro? the overcoaection for the ring current effect. If so, then C9H; is exhibiting 50%. and C B H 40% ~ of the expected ring current effect. l o Compare the chemical shift of cyclopropene vinyl hydrogens (7-0, Wiberg and Nist, 1961) with normal alkenes (-6.0).
D. G. FARNUM
140
fact, gives .rr-charge, not total charge, and for tetramethylcyclobutadiene dication it requires the assumption that no charge is dispersed on to the methy1 groups. It is questionable to use the raw value for cyclopropenium ion, since hybridization effects are likely to interfere here (compare cyclopropane, 6' C = -2-6, and cyclo-
220 200 -
I80 I60 -
-no140 -
a
120 -
100 -
80 -
60I-
I
l
l
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
+0.6 4 5 +0.4 +0.3+0.2 +0.1 0.0 -01 -0.2 -0.3-0.4
CHARGE
'
Figure 6. Dependence of carbon-13 chemical shifts on charge density. Replotted k o ~ Olah and Mateescu (1970) with permission. The point marked by a cross represents C3H3 corrected for hybridization (see text).
hexane, 6l 3 C = 27.8; Stothers, 1972, p. 270). If the former points are ignored as being unreliable, and the C 3 H i point is corrected by 30 p.p.m. to approximate the hybridization effect, then the data are moderately well correlated by the dashed line of slope 190 p.p.m./unit charge. The solid line in Figure 6 is Olah's original correlation line of slope 160 p.p.m./unit charge-identical with the slope of the original Spiesecke and Schneider correlation.' The dashed line is not suggested as a necessarily better correlation, but does indicate that the proportionality constant varies widely, dependent upon the assumptions one chooses to accept. As has been noted by Spiesecke and Schneider, the scatter of the points is well outside expected experimental error. As in the case of the pnmr
''
Olah h'aa suggested a value of 180 p.p.m./unit charge based on, aa yet, unpublished arguments (Olahet al., 1 9 7 2 ~ ) .
CHARGE DENSITY-NMR CHEMICAL SHIFT CORRELATIONS
141
plot above, the value of 280 p.p.m. obtained by extrapolation of the slope 160 line t o unit positive charge does not correctly predict the carbon-13 shift for the dimethyl- or trimethyl-carbonium ions (320 and 330 respectively), although use of the slope 190 line gives a value of 320. Whichever line is chosen, it must be clearly emphasized 120
I
I
I
I
I
I
110-
100 90 I m
-
-
Figure 7. Correlationof corrected proton chemical shifts with carbon-13 chemical shifts See Table 1.
that the data give no evidence for the upfield shift at high positive charge values suggested by Grant’s theoretical treatment (see page 134). Once again, however, the range of charge (+0.5 to -0-25), though greater than that for the pnmr correlation, may not be great enough. As a final counterpoint to this section on these basic correlations, the “corrected” proton shifts are plotted against the carbon-13 shifts in Figure 7. The excellence of the correlation indicates that errors causing scatter in the original plots have largely cancelled. The slope of 13.4 should be a good indication of the ratio of the charge dependence of carbon-13 chemical shifts to the first order charge dependence of proton chemical shifts over the range covered by the data.’
**
A similar plot of proton shifts us. carbon shifts for para-substituted benzenes, where charges differences are much smaller, gives a line of slope 17-2 {Stothers. 1972, p. 199).
142
D. G . FARNUM
Correlation of methyl group chemical shifts The first attempt to correlate proton chemical shifts of methyl groups in carbonium ions with charge on the adjacent carbon atom seems to have been made by MacLean and Mackor (1961). They examined the pnmr spectra of a number of cyclohexadienyl cations (benzenium ions) [6] where R was CH3, and found that chemical shifts for protons directly attached to positive carbons were linearly
[GI
related to those of methyl groups attached in the same position. The correlation slope was about 2-8. Using approximate calculated charge densities, they determined a proportionality constant of 13.4 for the charge dependence for the chemical shift of protons attached to positive carbon, and a value of 4.7 for that of methyls. These values can be considered as only very approximate, however, since they use a very approximate model for the charge density calculation, and are not corrected for either the E 2 term or the influence of other charged atoms suggested by Musher. Indeed, Musher (1962) reanalyzed MacLean and Mackor’s data including these corrections, and found a value 11-0 for the proton correlation, in excellent agreement with his corrected empirical value of 11-2. In addition, he found the corrected methyl shifts to be in agreement with theory. Using Musher’s equations, the empirical value of 11.2 for the linear part of the proton dependence, and reasonable values for bond lengths and angles, one can calculate the expected charge dependence of the proton shifts of methyl groups attached to carbonium ion centres. Relevant distances and angles are given in Figure 8. Thus, using equation (3):
Substituting the appropriate values from Figure 8, and ignoring all contributions from remote charges (the error thus introduced is rather small) gives equation ( 5 ) :
A0 = - 2-33 q
- 0.94 q 2
(5)
CHARGE DENSITY-NMR CHEMICAL SHIFT CORRELATIONS
143
Figure 8. Parameters used to calculate the charge dependence of the proton chemical shift for methyl groups o n carbonium ion centres.
The value 2.33 for the linear dependence is rather far from the uncorrected value of 4.7 from MacLean and Mackor's data. However, it can be shown to be in better agreement with the more reliable empirical correlations following. Data now available in the literature permit further attempts to determine the charge dependence of the chemical shifts of methyl groups attached to carbonium ion centres. Thus, a SpieseckeSchneider type plot for a few systems is given in Figure 9 and the relevant data are tabulated in Table 2. The slope of 3-2 is closer to theory than that from MacLean and Mackor's data. However, the calculation of charge still assumes no charge dispersion on to the methyls, which must be wrong. Also, the number of points is minimal, and, even though the fit is excellent, the correlation cannot be taken too seriously. Once again, the dimethylcarbonium ion shows less than the expected downfield shift-in this case exhibiting about 80% of the expected value. An alternative approach to determination of the charge dependence of the methyl proton shifts is illustrated in Figure 10
CHARGE Figure 9. Charge dependence of proton chemical shifts of methyl groups on ions. See Table 2 for data and references. o Raw data; A corrected for ring current; 0 corrected for ring current and E2.
144
D. G. FARNUM
TABLE 2 Chemical Shifts and Corrections for Some Methyl-Substituted Ions and Molecules
Compound (CH3)IdH
Ring current Charge 6H(CH3) correction
E Z correction
+1-0
5-04a
0
-0.94
4.10
+0.33
2-95'
-0.2
-0.1 1
2-64
2-23d
-0.6
Corrected
6H
CH3
0
1.63
0
CH3 CH3 a
Olah and White, 1969 (ext. TMS in SbFS-SOz). Olah e t al., 1969 (ext. TMS in SbFJ-SOz). Closs et al., 1968 (TMS in CH3CN). Emanuel and Randall, 1969 (TMS in CDCI,).
-
Jz
3.6-
A
3.4-
I
I
I
I
1
I
I
210 220 230 240 250 260 270 280 Figure 10. Correlation of proton chemical shifts of methyl groups in carbonium ions with carbon-13 shifts of the adjacent trigonal carbon atoms. See Table 3 for data and references. o Aryldimethylcarbonium ions; 0 cycloalkenyl cations; A phenylmethylcarbonium ions.
145
CHARGE DENSITY-NMR CHEMICAL SHIFT CORRELATIONS
(data used for Figure 10 and 11 are in Table 3). Here, the methyl proton shifts for a number of closely related carbonium ions are plotted against the carbon-13 shifts of the carbonium ion centres. If both are linearly related to charge, then the slope of the resultant straight line should give the ratio of the dependences. Two systems TABLE 3 Proton and Carbon-13 Chemical Shifts for Methyl Groups Attached to Carbonium Ion Centres Compound
Substituents
X-C6H46(CH3)2a
X
= p-OCH3 X = p-CH3 X = P-F X=H X = m-F X = p-CH3
X-C6H46HCH3
x =p X X X X
- 0 ~ ~ ~ 6
= 2, 4, 6(CH3)3 = p-CH3
=H = P-CF3
R1 = H, R2 = CH3C R , = R2 = CH3C
6HCH3
3.12 3.45 3-38 3.48 3.61 3-71 2.98 3.02 3.6 1 3.73 3-93
220 244 249 256 262 270 200 213 223 235 248
3.36 3.14
247 229
43 34
3.61
262
49
3-45
255
47
R2
Rl
o-,,, a
C
Data from Olah et al., 1972a (ext. TMS, 13C conv. to CS2 = 1946). Data from Olha et al., 1971 (ext. TMS, I3C conv. to CS2 = 1946). Data from Olah and Liang, 1972 (ext. TMS, 13C conv. to CS2 = 1946).
studied by Olah (Olah and Liang, 1972; and Olah e t al., 1972a) were chosen-the methyl substituted cycloalkenyl cations, represented by solid dots, and the substituted aryldimethylcarbonium ions, represented by open circles. The correlation to a line of slope 0-0146 is excellent for all but two of the points. If the Spiesecke-Schneider value of 160 p.p.m. is used for the linear charge dependence of the carbon-13 shifts, then the calculated value for the methyl shifts is
146
D. G. FARNUM
(0.0146) x (160) % 2-3, in excellent agreement with the theoretical vaIue of 2-33. The agreement, of course, depends on the value chosen for the carbon-13 dependence, but even an outside value of 200 still gives 2-9, which is not far from theory. It seems likely that the original proportionality constant of 4-8 suggested by MacLean and
I” 0 50 c 0
0 n 40
60
30 200
220
8 l3c
240 at
260
C+
280
Figure 11. Correlation of carbon-13 chemical shifts of methyl groups in ca~- mium ions with carbon-13 shifts of the adjacent trigonal carbon atoms. See Table 3 for data and references.
Mackor is too large and the actual value may be closer to 3 or less. Attenuation of the effect of the positive charge by a factor near 3 upon insertion of a carbon atom seems reasonable. The correlation should not be taken too seriously, however, since the values for the phenylmethylcarbonium ions (Olah et al., 1971), represented by triangles in Figure 9, which should give a displaced but nearly parallel line, give a rather poor correlation. A more thorough study is needed. A similar approach could be used to calculate the charge dependence of the carbon-13 shifts for methyl groups attached to carbonium ion centres, but only limited data are available. In Figure 11 the carbon-13 shifts for methyl groups in cycloalkenyl cations are plotted against the shifts of the attached carbonium ion carbons as determined by Olah and Liang (1972). The correlation line for the limited number of points has a slope near 0-4, suggesting a value of (0.4) x (160) % 60 for the charge dependence of the carbon-13 shift for methyls attached to carbonium ion centres. Again the attenuation factor of 2.5 seems reasonable. It would be very valuable to have a reliable assessment of both the linearity and
147
CHARGE DENSITY-NMR CHEMICAL SHIFT CORRELATIONS
magnitude of this correlation. It seems quite possible that carbon-13 shifts of methyl groups attached to carbonium ion centres will be quite sensitive to charge, while relatively insensitive to other factors such as diamagnetic anisotropy, hybridization, and bond order which render both proton and carbonium carbon-13 shifts ambiguous.
Other correlations and conclusions Although a number of other attempts have been made to correlate carbon-13 and proton chemical shifts, they do not extend either the range or precision of those already described, and are mentioned in
300 -
-
Figure 12. Correlation of carbon-I3 and proton chemical shifts for trigonal carbon atoms in a number of cations, anions,and neutral molecules.
other reviews quoted above. In order to give an overview of the current possibilities, however, a scatter plot of proton chemical shifts us. carbon-13 chemical shifts for trigonal carbon atoms in a number of cations, anions, and neutral molecules is given in Figure 12. No attempt has been made to correct the raw data for the host of factors which might interfere, although protons and carbons next to heteroatoms have been excluded, since . they are well known to be anomalous, as will be discussed later. If both proton and carbon-13 shifts were precisely proportional to charge with proportionality constants of 10 and 160 respectively, all points should fall on the line of slope 16 drawn through the data. Simplistic as the approach
148
D. G. FARNUM
is, nonetheless the graph dramatizes the following points: (1) There is a general correlation whose slope vanes from about 10 to about 30; (2) the scatter of the points is far too great to allow interpretation of the data in a given case without a careful assessment of the factors which might render the interpretation ambiguous; (3) there is no evidence for a reversal of slope at high positive charge density as would be expected if the up term dominated the carbon-13 shifts throughout and behaved according to theory; (4) many more points are needed in the carbanion region (below 6H-7) and for highly charged carbonium ions (the region above 6H-10). Surely refinement and extension of all of the correlations described above would be valuable. Systematic studies are desperately needed in which spectra of compounds chosen to minimize changes in extraneous variables are determined under carefully controlled conditions of solvent, concentration and temperature.
Selected Problems In this section we shall examine some problems in which cnmr and pnmr spectroscopy have been used to try to answer questions about charge distribution. The selection is, of course, biased, but an attempt has been made to choose examples which one might have expected to be simple, but which turn out, on further analysis, to be quite puzzling.
The triphenylmethyl cation and anion Surely one would expect a system as hoary with age as the triphenylmethyl cation to be well understood by now! Yet despite the effort of many groups to use pnmr and cnmr techniques to determine the detailed charge distribution in both the cation and anion, theory and experimeni are still far from agreement. Perhaps the lack of congruence simply illustrates the principle that the more we know, the more we want to know. Whatever the reason, the fact is a sobering one. The difficulty in determining charge distribution in the triphenylcarbonium ion by pnmr has been discussed in an earlier review (Fraenkel and Farnum, 1968), and only the salient conclusions will be noted here. In short, there are too many approximate models with undetermined variables that intervene between the raw data (the proton shifts) and the rigorous theoretical determination of charge distribution. One must assume an approxi-
CHARGE DENSITY-NMR CHEMICAL SHIFT CORRELATIONS
149
mate model to describe the magnetic anisotropy of the benzene ring, an approximate model for the effect of remote charges on proton shifts, and a more or less arbitrary value for the twist angle of the propeller-shaped ion before one can calculate the “experimental” charge density for comparison with the “theoretical” charge density determined by some approximate theoretical model at the chosen twist angle. Needless to say, the results are not very satisfying, although getting to them provides an interesting exercise in equation juggling and computer programming. TABLE 4 Chemical Shifts for the Triphenylmethyl Cation and Anion _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Position
~
1(4
2
Cation 1Ha I3cb
7-68 2 10.9
Anion
139.9
143.3
7.27
1HC
13cd
3(0)
4(m) 7-86 130.3
6.49
5(P)
8-24 143.1 5.93
92
Farnum, 1967 (TMA in HS03F, 3.13). Ray et. al., 1971 (ext. CS2 in HS03F, 192-8). Sandel and Freedman, 1963 (TMS in THF). Waack et. al., 1966 (ext. CS2 in THF, 192.8).
The pnmr shifts for the anion have also been determined (Sandel and Freedman, 1963; Grutzner et al., 1972) and are compared with those for the cation in Table 4. Although Grutzner e t al. clearly demonstrated a large dependence of the chemical shifts of a number of anions on solvent, counter-ion, and temperature (in contrast to many cations) they also demonstrated that lithium triphenylmethide was reasonably well behaved, particularly in oxygenated solvents. Hence, the shifts reported for the lithium salt in THF are most probably those for the “free” ion. Sandel and Freedman noted that the pnmr spectra of the cation and anion, reproduced in Figure 13, did not show the mirror-image relationship “expected on theoretical grounds.” However, the mirror-image relationship is expected only if charge density at the position in question is linearly related to the proton-shift and is the only factor which determines that shift, sicce it is the charge distribution which theory predicts should have a
150
D. G. FARNUM
Figure 13. Pnmr Spectra for the triphenylmethyl cation and anion. Copied with perkssion horn Farnum (1967), and Sandel and Freedman (1963).
mirror-image relationship. From the earlier comments on the importance of ring-current effects and E 2 terms in determining the observed proton shifts it should be apparent that a mirror-image
Figure 14. Schematic presentation of correction of the proton chemical shifts for the triphenylmethyl cation and anion.
CHARGE DENSITY-NMR CHEMICAL SHIFT CORRELATIONS
151
relationship in the spectra would have been a cause for great concern
over the validity of the theory. Figure 14 is a schematic presentation of an attempt to correct for some of the more important sources of error, largely as an exercise in data juggling to illustrate the ambiguity of interpretation. The chemical shifts determined for the ortho-, metu-, and para-protons for the cation and anion are corrected for the ring current effect of the two other benzene rings assuming a twist angle of 45” about the bond between the phenyl groups and the trigonal carbon in a symmetrical, propeller-shaped cation and anion (Farnum, 1967). These corrected values are then corrected further for the large E 2 term felt by the ortho-protons
Figure 15. Parameters used to calculate E2 corrections for Figure 14.
from the proximate rather high charge on the central carbon. The bond lengths and angles, and distance parameters used for these calculations are shown in Figure 15. The E 2 correction is determined for three different charges ( 4 ) at C-1 using the second term of equation (3), since the charge at C-1 is not known with certainty. It can be seen that for q = +035 the chemical shifts show a nearly mirror image relationship with the anion showing a wider spread. Of course, other corrections have been ignored, and it is not necessary to assume that the cation and anion have the same twist angle or charge at C-1. With so many variables to choose from, it seems likely that the data could be “corrected” to fit almost any theory one would like to choose. The ambiguity of the interpretation of the pnmr spectrum motivated Ray et ul. (1971 and earlier papers) to determine and analyse the cnmr spectrum of the triphenylcarbonium ion (as well as some of its derivatives). The chemical shifts they obtained are given in Table 4, and a comparison of the “empirical” charge densities with those calculated by the HMO and CNDO techniques
152
D. G. FARNUM
TABLE 5 Comparison of Empirical Charge Densities with those Calculated by the HMO and CNDO Methods for Triphenylcarbonium Ion (twist angle = 30')' Position
HMO
1 (Central) 2 3 4 5
0.41 7 0.000 0.065 0~000 0.065 1.00
Total q, a
CNDO
0-249
-0.0 13
0.071 0-015 0.08 1 0.969
Empirical
0.267 -0.048 0-094
0.020 0-107 1.13
Data from Ray e t al. (1971).
for a twist angle of 30° is presented in Table 5. The empirical charge density changes, Aqi, for all carbon atoms except C-1 were obtained using the relationship
Aqi = -ASi/160 where ASi is the chemical shift difference between triphenylcarbinol and the cation for C-i. For the central carbonium ion carbon atom C-1, the charge density q 1 was calculated assuming that the charge on the central carbon atom of trimethylcarbonium ion was +1, and that the charge difference between it and the central carbon atom of triphenylcarbonium ion was proportional t o the chemical shift difference (330-6 ) with the usual constant of 1/160. Thus:
q1 = 1 - (33O-61)/160
It is not at all certain that q 1 can be determined in this way (see page 140), but if it is, the total charge on the cation summed over all positions, q, = +1*13. This is in better agreement with the expected value of +1-0 than the value of +1-48 obtained if q 1 is determined from Figure 6 to be +O-52. The agreement of the empirical charge with the CNDO charge is quite good, at least relatively, as seen by the correlation line of Figure 16 (slope = 1.14, correlation coefficient = 0-985).' Of special interest is the prediction of negative charge density at C-2, which seems to be borne out by the empirical charge densities. This conclusion must be taken with caution, however, since the central carbon atom, attached t o C-2, is undergoing a change l 3 Indeed, if the proportionality constant is taken to be 180, as suggested by Olah et aL (1972), instead of 160, the slope of the line of Figure 16= 1.01.
CHARGE DENSITY-NMR CHEMICAL SHIFT CORRELATIONS
153
from tetrahedral to trigonal on conversion from the carbinol to the carbonium ion. Therefore the carbinol may not be a good model for the chemical shift at C-2.In fact, such a structural difference can be accompanied by an upfield shift of 6-8 p.p.m. For example, the alkyl-substituted carbon of the aromatic ring of cyclohexylbenzene
3
Figure 16. Plot of empirical charge densities us. CNDO charge densities (0 = 30") for triphenylcarbonium ion. Copied with permission from Ray et al. (1971).
resonates at 148, while C-1 in biphenyl resonates at 142; the corresponding carbon resonances of isopropylbenzene and (Ymethylstyrene appear at 149 and 141 p.p.m. respectively (Stothers, 1972, p. 90, 97; Dhami and Stothers, 1965).Correction for that upfield shift accounts for most of the 9 p.p.m. upfield shift observed at C-2 between the carbinol and carbonium ion. Indeed, the shift at C-2 in the carbonium ion (140)is within experimental error of the shift of the similarly constituted atom in amethylstyrene, suggesting it may have n o charge at all. Thus, although the work of Ray et al. (1971)clearly is the best analysis available of the charge distribution in the triphenylcarbonium ion as determined by NMR spectroscopy, it is not free from the ambiguity which plagues attempts t o draw accurate quantitative conclusions using models of uncertain accuracy. Nonetheless, one would hope that some group would find the time and motivation to complete an equally thorough, careful investigation of the triphenylcarbanion for comparison. l4
Work in progress along these lines by Grutzner (1973) should appear soon.
154
n r.. F A R N T I M
The inductive effect of methyl groups The downfield shift of the central carbon resonance in trimethylcarbonium ion (330 p.p.m.) as compared with dimethylcarbonium TABLE 6 Comparison of Chemical Shifts of Methyl Substituted and Unsubstituted Carbonium Ions Case
Rl
1.
2.
R2
Position
R1 R 2 d H
R l R26CH3
A6
320 62 5-04
330 48 4.35
-10
254 35 3-34
281 32,41 2.70, 3-18
-27 +3, -6 +-64, +.16
+14(+13f) + -69
3.
C6H5
235c 3.73c 8-7c
256d 3*48e 8-63e
-21 +-25 + -07
4.
C6H5
227 150
-20
C6H5
200 152 8.38
247 146 230 149 8-32
200c
220d
5.
6.
2.9gc 223c 3.6 lC 234c 248c 3.93c
7. 8. 9.
3-12d 244d 3.45d 24gd 27od 3.7 Id
+4 -30 +3 +so6 -20 -*14 -21 +-16 -15 -2 2 +.22
a Olah
and White, 1969. Olah et al., 1970. (ext. TMS, "C conv. to CSz = 194.6). Olah et al., 1971. Olah et al., 1972. Farnum, 1967 (TMA in HSOJF= 3-13). f Olah and Westerman, 1973 (ext. TMS, conv. to CS2 = 1946).
ion (320 p.p.m.) has been taken as evidence in support of extended Huckel theory calculations which place more positive charge on the central carbon of the tertiary ion than on that of the secondary ion (Olah and White, 1969). Thus, one might conclude that the methyl
CHARGE DENSITY-NMR CHEMICAL SHIFT CORRELATIONS
155
TABLE 7 Chemical Shifts of Some Methyl Substituted and Unsubstituted Allylic Cations4 Case
Position
1.
Unsubstituted cation
0
1
.-.I
3
2
21gb 138’ 8-32
G1, C-3 c-2 H- 2
Methyl substituted cation
0
A6
2
229 139 8.04
-10 -1 +028
2. 1 2
c-1,c - 3 c-2
236’ 147’
249 157
-13 -10
c-1, c-5 c-2, c - 4 c-3 H-2, H-4
182 140 202 8.49
197 136 197 7-70
-15 +4 +5
3.
+ o 79
4.
3
c-1, c-5 (2-2, c - 4 c-3 H-2, H-4
172 139 161 8-20
175 139 186 7-66
-3 0 -25 +054
Gl, C-5 (2-2, c-4 c-3 H-2, H-4
175 139 186 8-05
186 137 176 7.66
-11 +2 +10 +039
5.
156
D. G. FARNUM
TABLE 7-continued -
Case
Position
Unsubstituted cation
0
6.
1
.-4
2
c -2 c-3 H- 2 H- 3 7.
n3 2
c-1 c-3 CH3 cH3
A6
2
24 7 141 206
-28 -3 +13 +0m24 +052
8.08
9.73
/o, 2
24 7 141 206 43 3.36
c-2
~~
3
219‘ 138’ 219’ 8.32 10-25
G1
~
Methvl substituted cation
+18 +2 -23 +10 +022
229 139 229 33 3-14
8. l
a
3
J
32 3
2
c-1 c-2 c-3 H- 2 H-3 9.
262 148 219 8-36 10.60
-26
262 148 219 3.61
249 157 249 2.8 7
+13 -9 -3.0 + u 74
2
2
207 152 207 8-34 10.18
255 141 21 1 8.05 9-58
236’ 147’ 236’ 8.65 11-26
-1 +17 +0.29
m3 q
+0*66
2
c -1 c-2 c-3
W a -1 10.
0, o3
1
c -1 c -2 c-3 H- 2 H- 3
.-4
-48 +11 -4 +-29 +0m60
“Data from Olah c t af., 1972b, Olah and Liang, 1972, and Olah and Porter, 1971 (cxt. TMS. I3C conv. to CS2 = 194-6). The data for the cyclohcxenyl and cyclopcntcnyl cations were transposed in the original article.
CHARGE DENSITY-NMR CHEMICAL SHIFT CORRELATIONS
157
group is electron-withdrawing by comparison with hydrogen. The fact that that conclusion does violence t o our intuition is not sufficient reason for rejection, especially since our intuition is based on indirect evidence from rate and equilibrium comparisons rather than knowledge of actual charge distribution. Nonetheless, it is sufficient reason t o ask that the data be compelling. The data collected in Tables 6 and 7 show unequivocally that the usual effect of a methyl group on the carbon-13 shift of a carbonium ion centre is t o deshield it and cause a downfield shift in the neighbourhood of 20 p.p.m. (bold face entries in last column). The effect is often larger than the ca. 9 p.p.m. deshielding observed upon substitution of methyl for hydrogen in alkanes, and very much larger than that observed upon substitution of methyl for hydrogen at neutral trigonal centres. For example, ethylene, 2-butene, and 2,3dimethyl-2-butene all show resonance at 123 k 1 p.p.m., while the aromatic carbons of benzene and hexamethylbenzene appear at 129 and 133 p.p.m. respectively (Stothers, 1972, Chapter 3). The effect is not restricted to cations, as is shown by a comparison of diphenylmethyllithium ( a - C = 7 9 p.p.m., Waack et a/., 1966) and 1,ldiphenylhexyl lithium (a-C= 83 p.p.m., McKeever et al., 1971). Nevertheless, t o conclude that the downfield shift reflects an increase in positive charge at the carbonium ion centre results in some serious inconsistencies in the data. For example, the carbon-13 shift of a methyl group attached to a carbonium ion centre moves upfield as much as 10 p.p.m. when the carbonium ion is substituted further by a methyl group (Table 6, cases 1 and 2, Table 7, case 7). The proton shift of such methyl groups similarly moves upfield (Table 6, cases 1, 2, 3, 6, 7, 9; Table 7, cases 7 and 9) with only one exception (Table 6, case 6). Both of these results indicate that the positive charge at the carbon to which the methyl group is attached has become less upon further methyl substitution, a conclusion difficult to reconcile with an electron withdrawing methyl group. The upfield shift of both the para-carbon (Table 6, cases 4, 5) and para-hydrogen (Table 6, cases 3, 5) in phenylcarbonium ions upon further substitution of methyl for hydrogen at the carbonium ion centre is also indicative of less positive charge. Finally, the upfield shift of the remaining uncharged carbon atoms and vinyl protons in most of the cases of Table 7 suggests that positive charge is being dispersed by the methyl groups leaving less charge on the allylic system. Since our earlier analysis concluded that there was neither theoretical nor empirical justification for a linear relationship of
158
D. G. FARNUM
positive slope between charge density and carbon-13 chemical shift at high positive charge density, it would seem very premature to interpret the downfield shift which accompanies methyl substitution on carbonium ions in terms of increased positive charge density, particularly in the face of the considerable evidence to the contrary.
Charge delocalization b y phenyl and cyclopropyl Olah and Westerman (1973) have determined the carbon-13 spectra of a number of phenyl and cyclopropyl carbonium ions in order to assess the reIative abilities of phenyl, cyclopropyl, and methyl to delocalize charge. In Table 8 their results are presented in such a way as to simplify the assessment of their conclusion that TABLE 8
Comparison of Chemical Shifts of Methyl, Cyclopropyl, and Phenyl Carbonium Ionsa
1.
2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7.
8. 9.
320 62 5.04 330 48 4-35 281 32,41 254 276 235 8.7 255 36 157 8.63 247 146 230 149 8.32
254 35 3.34 28 1 41 3-18,2*70 276 39 255 272 227 150 247 24 146 262 137 236 146,151
235 3-73 255 36 3-57 247 24 226 262 200 152 8.38 230 32 149 8-32 236 151,146 21 1 143 8.24
Data from Olah and Westerman, 1973 (ext. TMS, I3C conv. to CS2 = 194.6).
CHARGE DENSITY-NMR CHEMICAL SHIFT CORRELATIONS
159
phenyl is better than cyclopropyl, which, in turn is better than methyl at delocalizing positive charge. If we accept the thesis that, for these closely related ions, the carbonium centre carbon-13 shift will parallel the positive charge at that centre, then the carbon-13 resonance should move progressively upfield from left to right within each group of three cations in the table, if Olah and Westerman are right. With only few exceptions (cases 4, 8, and 9), this is so. Even the exceptions interchange the cyclopropyl and methyl cations, but leave the phenyl substituted cation at highest field. The chemical shifts of the methyl carbons also are in general accord with the order with a few exceptions, while the protons show more discrepancies.
Figure 1 7. Possible geometry for the cyclopropyldiphenylcarboniurnion.
The proton shifts, of course, will be more affected by neighbounnggroup anisotropies. One might be concerned over the order of the para-carbon chemical shifts in cases 6, 7, and 8, which suggest that there is less positive charge at the para-position when the benzylic cation is substituted by cyclopropyl than by phenyl. However, the charge at the para-position will parallel the charge at the alphaposition only if all the ions have the same degree of coplanarity. Because of the different size of methyl, cyclopropyl, and phenyl, this may well not be the case (cfi Farnum, 1967). The cyclopropyldiphenylcarbonium ion of case 8 provides an interesting illustration of this paint. The phenyl groups in this ion are not equivalent, as evidenced by the quite different ring carbon resonances. For one ring, the para-carbon resonates at 151 p.p.m., for the other at 146 p.p.m. The difference of 5 p.p.m. is much too large to be accounted for by a long-range anisotropic effect of the cyclopropane ring. Furthermore, the difference is similar at the ortho-positions (4-3 p.p.m.) and much less at the meta-positions (1.5 p.p.m.) which seems quite inconsistent with an explanation based on magnetic anisotropy. The phenomenon finds a ready explanation, however, in different degrees of coplanarity of the two phenyl groups as illustrated in Figure 17. Thus, the more hindered, more
160
D. G. FARNUM
twisted phenyl syn to the cyclopropyl group would not delocalize charge as effectively as the more nearly planar anti-phenyl. The difference in charge delocalization on to the phenyls would be manifest in a difference in the chemical shifts of the ring carbons, which should be greatest at the ortho- and para-positions, as observed. It seems likely that a similar distortion from coplanarity is involved in the anomalous para-carbon resonances of c a s ~ s6 , 7, and 8. Our confidence, then, in the conclusion that phenyl is more effective at delocalizing positive charge than 'cyclopropyl parallels our confidence in the charge density chemical shift correlation for these compounds. Caution is again warranted, particularly since we have already seen that conversion of an adjacent carbon atom from tetrahedral to trigonal can cause a significant upfield shift (page 153). Just such a change takes place upon replacement of cyclopropyl by phenyl. The effect of heteroatoms Substitution of heteroatoms on carbonium ion centres often has a profound and unexpected effect on the carbon-13 chemical shift which is hardly designed to bolster our confidence in the simplicity of the charge density-chemical shift correlation. A few examples will illustrate the point (in the following structures carbon-13 shifts are given in regular type, proton shifts in italics). In example (a) (Stothers and Lauterbur, 1964) the carbonyl carbon-13 resonance moves upfield when placed next to an electronCH3. CO .CH3
t
t
198
205
CH3COi 4
I
182
.
CH3. CO .CO CH3
CHjC02H
+
2.101 177
CH3CO;Hz 4
3.18
1
196
(4
CHARGE DENSITY-NMR CHEMICAL SHIFT CORRELATIONS
7.95
7-69
161
9.53
withdrawing carbonyl group. In example (b) (Gray et al., 1969; Olah and White, 1969) the carboxyl carbon resonances of both acetate anion and the protonated cation are downfield from that of acetic acid. In (c) (Pugmire and Grant, 1968a) the alpha-carbon of pyridine moves upfield on N-protonation, while the other carbons move downfield as expected. In (d) (Pugmire and Grant, 1968b) all carbons of imidazole move upfield with increasing positive charge on the system as one goes through the series anion, neutral molecule, cation. Proton shifts, where reported, are much more in accord with expectation. Much effort has been expended, particularly by Grant, to unravel the complex interplay of factors which produce these phenomena. Data abound, many collected by Olah. Yet our understanding of the data still leaves much to be desired. In this section some data available on the oxygen substituted systems will be presented, followed by a summary of the nitrogen heterocycles. Oxygen substitution Olah has determined the pnmr and cnmr spectra of a number of protonated carbonyl compounds in fluorosulphuric acid-antimony pentafluoride-sulphur dioxide solution (Olah and White, 1968; Olah et al. 1972). The carbon-13 data are given in Tables 9 and 10. The proton data are not included in Table 9, since the anisotropy of the oxygen function obscures any interpretation. A correlation of some
TABLE 9
Carbon-13 Chemical Shifts of, Hydroxycarbonium Ions (in FS03H-SbF5-SO2 Solution at -78 ) and Their Uncharged Precursorsu (CH3)3C13 + (CH C ~ ~ O H + CH,3d?3(OH)f 0 3 (OH); CH3OC l 3 (OH); HC13 (OH) f a
341 250 193 166 164 178
(CH3)2C13=CH2 (CH3)2C13=0 CH3C1302CH3 (CH3O)2Cl3O (CH30)2C130 HC1302CH3
Data from Olah and White, 1968 (ext. TMS,conv. to CS2 = 194.6).
140 207 172 159 159 162
162
D. G. FARNUM
W
0.50.4 O3
3;O
I
I
I
I
300
250
200
150
~TMS
Figure 18. Correlation of carbon-13 chemical shifts with charge for some oxygcnated cations. Copied from Olah and White (1968). with permission.
of the data with a-electron charge density as calculated by a simple HuckeI treatment was done, and this is reproduced in Figure 18, The correlation, although quite satisfactory, is subject to a number of qualifications: more points are needed; the charge on the central carbon atom of the t-butyl cation was assumed to be unity; the mathematical model used to calculate charge on the other systems is a very approximate one, and the adjustable parameters are somewhat arbitrarily chosen. The slope of 306 p.p.m. per unit charge may, therefore, be quite misleading. It is certainly much larger than the approximately 160 p.p.m. value found for most other systems, and may reflect an unusual sensitivity of the carbon-13 resonance of oxygenated cations to positive charge density. Olah’s data for protonated a,P-unsaturated ketones are given in Table 10. In the abstract of the article it is concluded that the generaIIy Iarger downfield shift of the p-carbon resonance (C-3) than the oxygenated carbon (C-1) upon protonation indicates more positive charge at the 0-carbon. However, that conclusion is modified in the text of the article because of uncertainties introduced by the oxygen function. If, indeed, the charge dependence of the carbon-13 chemical shift at an oxygenated carbon is 300 p.p.m./unit charge as determined above, then one could conclude at least that there was more buzld-up of charge at C-3 than C-1, since it would then be true that the calculated change in charge at C-3 (Aq3 in the last
TABLE 10
I onb
6C1
6a
214 (-19) 214 (-1