ADVISORY BOARD B. Feringa University of Groningen, The Netherlands E. Fukuzumi Osaka University, Japan E. Juaristi CINVESTAV-IPN, Mexico J. Klinman University of California, Berkeley C. Perrin University of California, San Diego Z. Rappoport The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Israel H. Schwarz Technical University, Berlin, Germany C. Wentrup University of Queensland, Australia
Advances in Physical Organic Chemistry Volume 43
Editor J. P. RICHARD Department of Chemistry University at Buffalo, SUNY Buffalo, NY 14260-3000, USA
Amsterdam – Boston – Heidelberg – London – New York – Oxford Paris – San Diego – San Francisco – Singapore – Sydney – Tokyo Academic Press is an imprint of Elsevier
Academic Press is an imprint of Elsevier Linacre House, Jordan Hill, Oxford OX2 8DP, UK 32, Jamestown Road, London, NWI 7BY, UK Radarweg 29, PO Box 211, 1000 AE Amsterdam, The Netherlands 30 Corporate Drive, Suite 400, Burlington, MA 01803, USA 525 B Street, Suite 1900, San Diego, CA 92101-4495, USA First edition 2009 Copyright 2009 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise without the prior written permission of the publisher Permissions may be sought directly from Elsevier’s Science & Technology Rights Department in Oxford, UK: phone (þ44) (0) 1865 843830; fax (þ44) (0) 1865 853333; email:
[email protected]. Alternatively you can submit your request online by visiting the Elsevier web site at http://www.elsevier.com/locate/permissions, and selecting Obtaining permission to use Elsevier material Notice No responsibility is assumed by the publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. Because of rapid advances in the medical sciences, in particular, independent verification of diagnoses and drug dosages should be made ISBN: 978-0-12-374749-5 ISSN: 0065-3160 For information on all Academic Press publications visit our website at elsevierdirect.com Printed and bound in Great Britain 09 10 11 12 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Working together to grow libraries in developing countries www.elsevier.com | www.bookaid.org | www.sabre.org
Editor’s Preface
The editor is grateful to the contributing authors for their efforts in preparing the six chapters in Volume 43 of Advances in Physical Organic Chemistry. Each chapter focuses on a significant topic in organic chemistry and includes themes from chemical biology, environmental and computational chemistry. The landmark studies by Grunwald and Winstein of solvent effects on organic reactions are part of the fabric of modern physical organic chemistry. Water has many advantages as a solvent for organic reactions and the significant disadvantage that organic reagents show a low solubility in this medium. This solubility problem can be ameliorated by the use of surfactants that contain a hydrophobic part that interacts favorably with organic molecules and a hydrophilic part that interacts favorably with the aqueous medium. Niklaas Buurma describes the results of recent approaches to model the kinetics of organic reactions at such surfactants in water. Light triggers rapid photochemical reactions, in processes that are readily adapted in the design of molecular systems known as photoswitches. A recurring element in the design of photoswitches is the use photoenolization to trigger rapid removal of a protecting group in order to expose short-lived reactive organic functionality to interesting chemical and biochemical environments. The chapter by Sankaranarayanan, Muthukrishnan, and Gudmunsdottir provides a compelling discussion of the application of the results of fundamental studies on the mechanism of photoenolization to the design of photoswitches. Two chapters in this volume describe the mechanism for the formation of radicals and the impact of their reactions in strikingly different milieu. Combustion processes that convert chemical energy into heat and mechanical energy play many important roles in modern society. The chemistry of combustion is dominated by the formation and reaction of a variety of reactive radical intermediates. These include alkyl radicals, alkoxy radicals, and peroxyradicals. The gap between the complex and poorly defined chemistry that occurs during the rapid combustion of organic material and the rigorous experiments required for the systematic study of these reactions has been nicely bridged by Hayes, Merle, and Hadad. Their chapter focuses on the importance of reactive oxygen species in these combustion processes. A fundamental hypothesis of chemical carcinogenesis is that damage to DNA represents the first step in the initiation of tumor formation. The addition of the hydroxyl radical, the nitrogen dioxide radical, the phenoxide radical, and other radical species to DNA nucleobases lie on the pathways to DNA damage, and these reactions are therefore ix
x
EDITOR’S PREFACE
strongly associated with carcinogenesis. The chapter by Manderville highlights recent advances in our understanding of the mechanism for direct radical addition to DNA nucleobases that have resulted from detailed characterization of the reaction products Two chapters in this volume describe the generation of carbocations and the characterization of their structure and reactivity in strikingly different milieu. The study of the reactions in water of persistent carbocations generated from aromatic and heteroaromatic compounds has long provided useful models for the reactions of DNA with reactive electrophiles. The chapter by Laali and Borosky on the formation of stable carbocations and onium ions in water describes correlations between structure–reactivity relationships, obtained from wholly chemical studies on these carbocations, and the carcinogenic potency of these carbocations. The landmark studies to characterize ‘‘reactive’’ carbocations under stable superacidic conditions led to the award of the 1994 Nobel Prize in Chemistry to George Olah. The chapter by Reddy and Prakash describes the creative extension of this earlier work to the study of extremely unstable carbodications under conditions where they show long lifetimes. The chapter provides a lucid description of modern experimental methods to characterize these unusual reactive intermediates and of ab initio calculations to model the results of experimental work. John P. Richard University at Buffalo
Contributors to Volume 43 Gabriela L. Borosky Unidad de Matema´tica y Fı´ sica, INFIQC, Facultad de Ciencias Quı´ micas, Universidad Nacional de Co´rdoba, Ciudad Universitaria, Co´rdoba 5000, Argentina Niklaas J. Buurma Physical Organic Chemistry Centre, School of Chemistry, Cardiff University, Main Building, Park Place, Cardiff CF10 3AT, United Kingdom Anna D. Gudmundsdottir Cincinnati, OH 45221, USA
Department of Chemistry, University of Cincinnati,
Christopher M. Hadad Department of Chemistry, The Ohio State University, 100 W. 18th Ave., Columbus, OH 43210, USA and Department of Chemistry, Winston-Salem State University, 601 Martin Luther King Jr. Dr., Winston-Salem, NC 27110, USA Carrigan J. Hayes Department of Chemistry, The Ohio State University, 100 W. 18th Ave., Columbus, OH 43210, USA Kenneth K. Laali Department of Chemistry, Kent State University, Kent, OH 44242, USA Richard A. Manderville Departments of Chemistry and Toxicology, University of Guelph, Guelph, Ontario N1G 2W1, Canada John K. Merle Department of Chemistry, Winston-Salem State University, 601 Martin Luther King Jr. Dr., Winston-Salem, NC 27110, USA Siva Muthukrishnan Department of Chemistry, University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati, OH 45221, USA G. K. Surya Prakash Department of Chemistry and Loker Hydrocarbon Research Institute, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, CA 90089-1661, USA V. Prakash Reddy Department of Chemistry, Missouri University of Science and Technology, Rolla, MO 65409, USA Jagadis Sankaranarayanan Cincinnati, OH 45221, USA
Department of Chemistry, University of Cincinnati,
xi
Kinetic medium effects on organic reactions in aqueous colloidal solutions NIKLAAS J. BUURMA Physical Organic Chemistry Centre, School of Chemistry, Cardiff University, Main Building, Park Place, Cardiff CF10 3AT, UK 1 2
Introduction 1 Self-aggregating amphiphiles 3 Hydrotropes 3 Micelle-forming surfactants 4 Vesicle-forming surfactants 7 3 Reactivity effects in aqueous colloidal solutions 8 An inventory of factors affecting reactivity 8 Binding location and substrate positioning 9 4 Kinetic models 10 (Pseudo) unimolecular reactions 11 Bimolecular reactions 13 The pseudophase ion exchange model 13 The pseudophase model for bimolecular reactions 13 Data analysis 14 5 Hydrotropes and organic reactivity 15 6 Micelles and organic reactivity 17 Micellar medium effects as experienced by (reactive) probes 17 Arenediazonium salts as probes of the Stern region 17 Arenediazonium salts and cationic surfactants 18 Arenediazonium salts and anionic, zwitterionic, and nonionic micelles Solvatochromic probes 20 Pseudounimolecular reactions 21 Reactions involving counterions 25 Bimolecular reactions involving neutral reactants 27 7 Vesicles and organic reactivity 28 8 Conclusions and future directions 30 Acknowledgments 30 References 31
1
19
Introduction
Interest in organic reactivity in aqueous solutions has been growing steadily over the last decades and water is increasingly regarded as a viable alternative for more traditional organic solvents.1–4 Water as a solvent has many advantages: it is (generally) readily available and cheap; it is environmental friendly,5 nontoxic, and nonflammable; and it can have significant beneficial effects on organic reactions (see, e.g., Otto and Engberts,6 Hailes,7 and Rideout and Breslow8). These advantages are not recent discoveries, of course, and therefore cannot explain the increased interest 1 ADVANCES IN PHYSICAL ORGANIC CHEMISTRY VOLUME 43 ISSN: 0065-3160 DOI: 10.1016/S0065-3160(08)00001-4
2009 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved
2
N.J. BUURMA
in water as a solvent for organic chemistry. In fact, despite the advantages, water and aqueous solutions have historically been avoided by organic chemists because of two relatively straightforward reasons: (1) the low solubility of typical organic compounds in water and (2) the reactivity of water. One could therefore state that the recent change in attitude toward water in essence stems from a re-evaluation of these two factors. The issue of water’s reactivity will, to some extent, obviously remain; butyllithium and water are simply not compatible. However, the increase in subtlety of organic chemistry and improved control of reactivity leads to processes that are increasingly compatible with an aqueous environment. For example, while C—C bond formation through traditional procedures involving lithiation or Grignard reactions is preferably (though for the case of Grignard reactions no longer necessarily9,10) done under the exclusion of water, palladium-catalyzed C—C bond-forming reactions are far more tolerant of water. The Suzuki–Miyaura cross-coupling reaction frequently even benefits from aqueous reaction conditions.1 This leaves us with the issue of solubility of organic reactants in aqueous solutions. This is actually a rather intriguing issue. Arguably, the low solubility of typical organic compounds in water would render water an impractical solvent for organic reactions; reactant concentrations are limited. However, it should be kept in mind that the chemical potential of a solute in equilibrium with its liquid/solid phase is equal to the chemical potential in the neat compound. In addition, the remarkable rate enhancements observed for ‘‘on water chemistry’’11,12 illustrate that limited solubility is not necessarily a problem.13 Hydrophobic interactions, while also resulting in the low solubility of reactants, can drive reactants together (enforced hydrophobic interactions)14 resulting in reaction rate accelerations. Driving reactants together – for example, through favorable pairwise interactions, that is, stabilized encounter complex formation15 en route to the transition state – is not necessarily beneficial, however, if reactant and/or catalyst orientations cannot be carefully controlled. In this respect, hydrophobic interactions may currently seem less convenient for the design of highly selective recognition patterns compared to traditional hydrogen bonding strategies as used in organic solvents. Nevertheless, the effects of pairwise interactions, both between reactants and between reactants and cosolutes, on rates of reaction in aqueous solutions have been studied in detail (the reader is referred to Otto and Engberts14 and references therein for further information). Further work on such aqueous systems in combination with an improved understanding of intermolecular interactions will certainly result in increasingly successful use of the ‘‘molecular recognition toolbox’’16 in aqueous solutions – with Nature providing (at least) occasional inspiration! While pairwise hydrophobic interactions can be favorably employed for the acceleration of organic reactions, one can alternatively overcome the lower solubility of many organic reactants using solubilizers. Typically, solubilizers are amphiphiles containing both a hydrophobic and a hydrophilic moiety, and as a result, they are able to effectively bridge between a hydrophobic solute and solvent water. For sufficiently hydrophobic solubilizers and at higher concentrations, interactions higher than pairwise become increasingly important. In fact, a range of different self-aggregation states
COLLOIDAL MEDIUM EFFECTS ON ORGANIC REACTIONS
3
exists for amphiphilic molecules with the exact structure and stability of the aggregates depending on factors such as shape and hydrophobicity of the amphiphile in question. When organic reactants undergo reactions while bound to amphiphile aggregates, the aggregates can cause a variety of effects depending on, among others, size, precise structure, and the potential presence of catalytic functionality within these aggregates. While remarkable successes in enhancing reaction rates have been achieved by the introduction of catalytic moieties in micellar and vesicular solutions, we limit our discussion here to medium effects on organic reactions as they occur in solutions of unfunctionalized amphiphiles. Admittedly, the distinction between medium effects and surfactants equipped with catalytic moieties may occasionally be rather artificial, as for example in the case of micelles with catalytic counterions (see, e.g., Otto et al.17) or counteranions that act as bases (vide infra). In addition, despite (and because of) the wealth in available literature on some of the topics discussed here, this chapter focuses on relatively recent developments.
2
Self-aggregating amphiphiles
Self-aggregating amphiphiles can broadly be divided into hydrotropes and surfactants. The main difference between hydrotropes and surfactants lies in the fact that hydrotropes are typically not sufficiently hydrophobic to cooperatively self-aggregate and form organized structures, whereas surfactants form distinct aggregates such as micelles and vesicles above their critical aggregation concentrations.
HYDROTROPES
The most elusive of self-aggregation processes is presented by the so-called hydrotropes;18,19 amphiphilic compounds with the hydrophobic moiety being typically too small to induce micelle formation.20 Examples of hydrotropes are butylmonoglycosulfate (BMGS), p-toluenesulfonate (PTS), and cumenesulfonate (CS) (Scheme 1).
Scheme 1
4
N.J. BUURMA
Hydrotrope action is characterized by a steep increase in aqueous solubilities of otherwise sparingly soluble hydrophobic compounds at a certain threshold concentration (typically 0.1–1.0 M) called the minimum hydrotrope concentration (MHC). This solubilizing power of hydrotropes was recognized as early as 1916 by Neuberg.21 The steep increase in solubility of the solubilizate around the MHC has been attributed to a cooperative self-aggregation process since the threshold concentration for solubilization appears to be rather solubilizate insensitive.22 This cooperativity is disputed,22–24 however, as is the exact mechanism of solubilization by hydrotropes.24 It should be noted in this respect that solubilization by hydrotropes differs from that of typical salting-in compounds and cosolvents in that the increase in solubility is typically sigmoidally dependent on hydrotrope concentration. Salting-in cosolutes and cosolvents usually cause a monotonic increase in solubility without a levelling off at higher concentrations.22 A recent study, however, found no fundamental differences between hydrotropes and cosolvents and attributed the higher solubilizing power of hydrotropes simply to a larger hydrophobic moiety.25 Compared to micelle-forming surfactants, hydrotropes are often more effective in solubilizing organic solutes and can be more selective.20,22,26,27 Phase diagrams of their respective aqueous solutions reveal a crucial difference between micelle-forming surfactants and hydrotropes. Aqueous solutions of hydrotropes lack the lamellar liquid crystal region found for solutions of micelle-forming surfactants. Instead, phase diagrams for aqueous solutions of hydrotropes show a single continuous isotropic liquid phase.28,29
MICELLE-FORMING SURFACTANTS
Contrary to hydrotropes, micelle-forming surfactants spontaneously self-aggregate cooperatively above the critical micelle concentration (cmc) even in the absence of solubilizate. Typical examples of micelle-forming surfactants include sodium dodecylsulfate (SDS), dodecyltrimethylammonium bromide (DTAB), cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB), and heptaoxyethylene dodecyl ether (C12E7) (Scheme 2). Depending on the shape of the surfactant, different highly dynamic aggregates can be formed. The morphologies of different micelles (and vesicles – vide infra) are
Scheme 2
COLLOIDAL MEDIUM EFFECTS ON ORGANIC REACTIONS
5
conveniently predicted from the shape of the constituent surfactants as described using the dimensionless packing parameter P [Equation (1)] as developed by Ninham and Israelachvili.30 P¼
V ao lc
ð1Þ
Here, V is the volume of the hydrocarbon chain(s) of the surfactant, ao the mean cross-sectional (effective) headgroup surface area, and lc is the length of the hydrocarbon tail in the all-trans configuration. Surfactants with P < 1/3 are cone-shaped and form spherical micelles. For 1/3 < P < 1/2, surfactants are truncated-cone-shaped, resulting in wormlike micelles (the term ‘‘wormlike’’ is preferred over ‘‘rodlike’’ to highlight the highly dynamic nature of these micelles). For spherical micelles, one of the more commonly accepted models for the micellar structure is that proposed by Gruen (Fig. 1).31 This model features a rather sharp interface between a dry hydrophobic hydrocarbon core and a region filled with surfactant headgroups, part of the counterions (for ionic surfactants), backfolding surfactant tails, and water, namely, the Stern region. In the remainder of this chapter, intramicelle volumes with specific features such as the Stern region and the hydrophobic core will be referred to as ‘‘zones.’’ Typical radii for spherical micelles (related to the length of a typical surfactant tail) are around 5 nm. Aggregation numbers N (surfactant monomers per micelle) are typically 40–100.32 The fractional counterion binding of micelles generally lies
1 nm
Fig. 1 Gruen’s standard picture of ionic micelles, reproduced from Gruen31, with kind permission of Springer Science and business Media.
6
N.J. BUURMA
between 0.7 and 0.9 (not to be confused with the degree of ionization , which simply is 1 – ). The incomplete counterion binding results in an electrostatically non-neutral local environment for ionic surfactants. It has been estimated33–35 that the concentration of headgroups in the Stern region lies in the range of 3–5 mol dm3 though lower values have been suggested based on chemical trapping experiments.36,37 The concentration of counterions is obviously slightly less than the concentration of headgroups due to incomplete counterion binding as mentioned above. Nevertheless, local concentrations of both headgroups and counterions are sufficiently high for ion pair formation to play a role.38 The headgroup concentration in the Stern region can be estimated from known micellar and molecular dimensions,39 together with the aggregation number N and counterion binding .32 If one assumes a simple model for spherical micelles involving two concentric spheres, where one sphere represents the hydrophobic core (with a radius equal to the length of the hydrophic tail, lc) and the other sphere representing the total micelle (with a radius equal to the total length of a surfactant molecule, lc þ dStern), then the volume difference between these two spheres corresponds to the volume of the micellar Stern region. All surfactant headgroups and part of the counterions reside in this volume leading to calculated ‘‘salt concentrations’’ in the micellar Stern region between 2 and 6 mol dm3 for ionic surfactants and even higher ‘‘ethylene glycol concentrations’’ (expressed in ethylene glycol monomers) for typical nonionic surfactants (Table 1). This calculation is for spherical micelles, but a similar calculation could be used to obtain estimates of salt concentrations for ionic wormlike micelles. Such ‘‘salt concentrations’’ for wormlike micelles are expected to be increased in comparison to spherical micelles. In fact, the addition of counterions or a sufficient increase in surfactant concentration often leads to a transition from spherical micelles to wormlike micelles. As the free counterion concentration in solution increases, so does the counterion binding. As a result, electrostatic repulsion between the charged headgroups is increasingly shielded and the mean cross-sectional (effective) headgroup Table 1 Calculated salt concentrations in the micellar Stern region of selected surfactants Surfactant SDS CTAB DTAB C12E7
[Headgroup]/mol dm3 2.7–5.4 2.9–5.7 2.6–5.3 7–10a or 15–18b
The following parameters were used in the estimation of headgroup concentrations in the Stern region – SDS: lc = 16.7 A˚, dStern = 3.7–6.5 A˚, N = 64, = 0.65; CTAB: l = 21.7 A˚, dStern = 4.0–6.6 A˚, N = 110, = 0.8; DTAB: lc = 16.7 A˚, dStern = 4.0–6.6 A˚, N = 60, = 0.75; C12E7: lc = 16.7 A˚, dStern = 3.6 A˚, N = 64–100. See Van Os et al.32 a Monomer concentration assuming completely stretched ethylene glycol chain. b Monomer concentration assuming backfolded ethylene glycol chain.
COLLOIDAL MEDIUM EFFECTS ON ORGANIC REACTIONS
7
surface area ao decreases accordingly. This eventually leads to the formation of wormlike micelles. Computational studies such as that by Gruen31 are now increasingly complemented by detailed experimental studies involving a combination of techniques including time-resolved fluorescence quenching and electron paramagnetic resonance. Such studies are now producing detailed information on aggregation numbers, counterion binding, hydration, and microviscosity as a function of surfactant concentration, concentration of added salts and temperature for cationic,40,41 anionic,41–49 and mixed50,51 micelles. Finally, it is stressed that all of the abovementioned micellar properties represent averages over a continuous range of highly dynamic structures. For example, the typical lifetime of a micelle is 103–102 s while individual surfactants exchange on a 106–105 s time scale.52 In addition, many features of micelles are the result of rather delicate balances between opposing forces53 (e.g., hydrophobic interactions between surfactant tails vs. electrostatic repulsion between surfactant headgroups) rendering them sensitive to temperature and concentrations of additives, and so on. Both the dynamic nature of micelles and the delicate balance of the interactions holding micelles together and shaping them strongly affect our understanding of the micellar pseudophase as a (reaction) medium; aggregation numbers, shapes, and sizes of different zones, the extent of water penetration in the hydrophobic core, and microviscosities, to name a few, are all potentially changing averages over highly dynamic aggregates.
VESICLE-FORMING SURFACTANTS54
Surfactants for which the packing parameter P lies between 1/2 and 1 are roughly cylinder-shaped, resulting in the formation of vesicles or flat bilayers for P = 1. Vesicles consist of a surfactant bilayer encompassing a volume of water and as a result can be used for encapsulation.55,56 In addition, both unilamellar and multilamellar vesicles can be formed. Often, vesicle-forming surfactants are double-tailed amphiphiles such as dioctadecyldimethylammonium bromide (DODAB) and dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC) (Scheme 3). Vesicle size, bilayer fluidity, membrane permeability, microviscosity, ability to bind small molecules, susceptibility to pore formation, flip-flop rates, extent of water penetration, lateral amphiphile diffusion, vesicle fusion, and kinetic medium effects (some of which will be discussed briefly below) all depend on the packing of
Scheme 3
8
N.J. BUURMA
the surfactants in the bilayer. This packing itself depends on various factors including the length of the hydrophobic tails, the presence of double bonds in the hydrophobic tails, the presence or absence of cholesterol57 or other additives,58 and counterion concentration and type59,60 as well as pH.60,61 In extreme cases, pH-dependent packing parameters can even result in a vesicle to micelle transition.62,63 In addition, while micelles are highly dynamic aggregates, the dynamics of vesicles are temperature dependent and vesicles typically go through a gel to liquid-crystalline phase transition at a temperature where the vesicle bilayer fluidity and lateral diffusion of individual surfactant molecules increases considerably.64 This phase transition temperature again depends on surfactant packing and hence on the factors already mentioned above. Vesicle formation is frequently not spontaneous; in fact, vesicles are typically relatively long-lived (metastable) structures rather than stable equilibrium structures.65 As a consequence, uniform vesicles can often not be produced by simple dissolution of surfactants in aqueous solutions, and the preparation of vesicular solutions typically involves a series of manipulations in order to try to reproducibly generate uniform unilamellar vesicles.66 As a corollary, vesicular properties depend on the method of preparation,54 and once vesicles have been formed, solutions can be diluted below their critical aggregation concentrations without the vesicles falling apart.67 As is the case for micelles, the vesicular bilayer can be subdivided into a hydrophobic core and two Stern regions (in the direction orthogonal to the bilayer), again featuring incomplete counterion binding resulting in an electrostatically non-neutral environment. For a vesicle, the two Stern regions are not identical, however, as one distinguishes the inner from the outer leaflet. That this is not just an arbitrary distinction is nicely illustrated by a ganglioside that preferably resides in the outer leaflet of DPPC vesicles.68 Transfer of amphiphiles from the inner to the outer leaflet and vice versa (‘‘flip-flop’’) is generally a slow process occurring on a timescale of several hours.69 Related to the flip-flop process, vesicular bilayers are of varying permeability toward small molecules. Bilayer permeability for small nonionic organic molecules is typically good, but for ionic compounds including hydroxide, bilayer permeability appears to be a complicated function of vesicle structure and charge and may even depend on the bilayer permeability of charge-balancing ions flowing in the opposite direction.56,70–83 In addition to the inner and outer bilayer leaflet being different, ‘‘raft’’ formation has been found. Raft formation is caused by different surfactants mixing nonideally along the bilayer surface resulting in patches or rafts enriched in one of the component surfactants.84–87 For example, phospholipids with hydrophobic tails of markedly dissimilar length (>4 carbons longer) are thought to segregate into domains.88,89 Intriguingly, it has recently been found that even nonionic surfactants accumulate OH at the vesicular surface,62,63,90,91 an effect that has been attributed to the molecular orientation of water molecules in the first two hydration layers of hydrophobic surfaces.92,93 Finally, as for micelle-forming surfactants, increasingly detailed experimental information on aggregation numbers, counterion binding, hydration, and
COLLOIDAL MEDIUM EFFECTS ON ORGANIC REACTIONS
9
microviscosity are becoming available from combined time-resolved fluorescence quenching and electron paramagnetic resonance experiments.94,95
3
Reactivity effects in aqueous colloidal solutions
AN INVENTORY OF FACTORS AFFECTING REACTIVITY
From the perspective of the overall solution, both hydrotropes and surfactants can be used to solubilize reactants in aqueous solutions in order to increase overall reactant concentrations with the aim of increasing reaction rates. In addition to such an overall increase in reactant concentration, local reactant concentrations in surfactant aggregates can be increased even more provided that the reactants bind to micelles or vesicles reasonably strongly. Whereas this probably is true to some extent for hydrotropes as well, no clear examples of increased local concentrations appear to have been reported (vide infra). This may be a result of the more open, less defined aggregate structures in hydrotrope solutions. Ideally, interactions with surfactant aggregates bring together all reactants and a catalyst required for reaction. Whether this results in an increased rate of reaction depends on a series of factors. If reactants and catalyst share the same binding site (vide infra), high reaction rates are in principle achievable. However, local reaction rate constants may then be higher or lower than those in bulk water. If local rate constants are lower, this counteracts increased concentrations. The final result then is a fine balance between increased local concentrations and reduced local reaction rate constants. Whether local rate constants are in fact higher or lower depends on the local reaction medium. Key features of the local reaction medium in micelles and vesicles in comparison with bulk water are (1) the lower local water concentration, (2) the reduced polarity, (3) the high ionic strength in the Stern region, and (4) the local charge in the Stern region. All of these factors can affect reaction rate constants. If reactants and catalyst do not share the same binding site, local concentrations may still be significant but only partially overlapping, reducing reaction rates, unless of course local reaction rate constants are considerably higher than those in bulk aqueous solution. As a result, micelles and vesicles can both accelerate reactions and slow them down and it may not be immediately apparent why reaction rates vary. In order to understand these different contributions to micellar and vesicular rate effects, medium and concentration effects have to be separated first, after which the medium effects are interpreted further.
BINDING LOCATION AND SUBSTRATE POSITIONING
To understand the effects of micelles and vesicles on (organic) reactions, it is important to know where reactants are located in the micellar and vesicular pseudophase and what this region looks like in terms of a reaction medium. As mentioned above, micelles (but similar arguments are valid for vesicles) can be thought of as offering
10
N.J. BUURMA
several binding sites in different zones. These binding sites include sites in the hydrophobic core and binding sites located in the Stern region. The Stern region is particularly flexible in binding molecules as it contains highly hydrophilic surfactant headgroups and hydrophobic domains due to backfolding of the surfactant tails31,96,97 as well as water molecules. Various techniques are suitable for the study of binding locations of organic solubilizates in micelles and vesicles. Typically, these methods have included changes in NMR chemical shifts as a result of aromatic ring current effects,98–100 paramagnetic relaxation enhancement experiments,101–103 fluorescence probing experiments,104 fluorescence lifetime experiments,105 and combined time-resolved fluorescence quenching and electron paramagnetic resonance experiments.106–108 Despite difficulties in the interpretation of the results of such studies, it is now commonly assumed that most solubilized molecules preferably bind to micelles in the Stern region99,106,108–119 and the same appears to be true for vesicles.120 However, as an illustration of the difficulty in predicting binding locations, for benzene the binding depends on surfactant structure with the preference for binding in the Stern region being higher for trimethylammonium headgroups (DTAB and CTAB) than for sulfate headgroups (SDS).121 This highlights one of the additional problems in assigning binding sites to solubilized compounds; instead of residing in only one clearly defined zone such as the Stern region, there is no reason why a solubilizate cannot be distributed over a series of different binding zones. In fact, one could subdivide the micellar pseudophase into as many zones as required and devise equilibrium constants or partition coefficients for the distribution of a solubilizate over all of these zones. This could be done, for example, to represent gradual variations in local environment along the axis of a spherical micelle such as local water concentration. However, there currently do not appear to be situations where subdividing the micellar pseudophase into more than two zones is required and it is not immediately obvious where the interface between such zones would be. Rather, some authors have chosen to describe the different distributions of reactants using simple descriptive distribution functions. For example, in the case of a micellar Diels–Alder reaction, different micellar binding sites for diene (hydrophobic core) and dienophile (Stern region) were thought to be behind the observed low micellar rate constant.17 Further studies designed to probe this possible mismatch in binding sites through kinetic studies involving dienes of markedly different polarity and paramagnetic relaxation enhancement experiments did not confirm the initial suspicion.122 However, it was noted that the relaxation enhancement experiments only provide an average binding site, without any indication of the width of the distribution in binding sites. If the distribution of one of the reactants over the micelle is rather broad, then the local concentration of this reactant in the overlap region may still not be high, even if the centers of the distributions of the two reactants over the micelle coincide. In a different study involving a combination of time-resolved fluorescence quenching and electron spin resonance, indications of slightly mismatched binding zones of pyrene and quenchers dimethylbenzophenone and 5-doxyl stearic acid methyl ester were in fact found.108,123 To worsen matters further, as a result of changing size and shape of micellar structures (vide supra), the description of the different zones may change with surfactant and counterion concentrations or temperature as well. This may lead
COLLOIDAL MEDIUM EFFECTS ON ORGANIC REACTIONS
11
to the solubilizate sensing a changing environment, the solubilizate itself may redistribute itself over different zones, or both of these occur. For example, with increasing SDS concentration, solubilized pyrene on average is found progressively in the Stern region.106 Once again, the dynamic and changing nature of colloidal structures in aqueous solutions renders one single unified description of micelles and vesicles difficult and maybe even unrealistic. Finally, reactant orientation in the micelle might conceivably influence reactivity as well, but opinions differ on this topic.124–129
4
Kinetic models
Despite the abovementioned difficulties, kinetic models reproducing typical micellar kinetics have found widespread use and typically reproduce micellar reactivity well. Whereas these models are described here in terms of micellar kinetics, they can equally be adopted for the analysis of most vesicular rate effects, as long as bilayer permeation is either slow or fast compared to the rate of reaction. The issue of bilayer permeation-dependent rates of reaction has been addressed in detail by Moss et al.55,56,74 and will not be discussed here. A brief overview of the basic kinetic models typically employed for the analysis of micellar catalysis and inhibition is presented here, but for a more detailed discussion and an overview of additional kinetic models for micelle-catalyzed reactions, the reader is referred to Khan52 and Romsted.130
(PSEUDO) UNIMOLECULAR REACTIONS
The most straightforward of the various models describing micellar kinetics is the Menger–Portnoy model for (pseudo) unimolecular reactions.131 The Menger–Portnoy model assumes rapid equilibration of the reactant of interest over bulk water and the micellar pseudophase with equilibrium constant Km. The reaction then proceeds in both pseudophases with rate constants kw and km in bulk water and the micellar pseudophase, respectively (Scheme 4).
Scheme 4
12
N.J. BUURMA
This model leads to Equation (2) describing the observed rate constant kobs as a function of surfactant concentration [S], cmc, and aggregation number N; ([S]-cmc)/N corresponds to the concentration of micelles. kobs ¼
kw þ km Km ð½S cmcÞ=N 1 þ Km ð½S cmcÞ=N
ð2Þ
Traditionally, the Menger–Portnoy equation was frequently used in its linearized form [Equation (3)]. ðkw kobs Þ 1 ¼ ðkw kmic Þ 1 þ ðkw kmic Þ 1
N ð½S cmcÞ 1 Km
ð3Þ
It should be noted, however, that the linearization process introduces significantly nonconstant error margins, both on the y-axis value (kw – kobs)1 and on the x-axis value ([S]-cmc)1. As a result, unless datafits are carefully weighted, results from the nonlinearized model should be considered more reliable. The Menger–Portnoy model is closely related to the Berezin model employing partition coefficients instead of equilibrium constants.132 For the case where only two pseudophases (bulk water and micelle) are considered, the partitioning of the reactant is given by the partition coefficient Pm. This leads to Equation (4) describing observed rate constants as a function of surfactant concentration. kw 1 ½Sm Vm;S þ km Pm ½Sm Vm;S kobs ¼ ð4Þ 1 þ Pm ½Sm Vm;S Here, kobs, kw, and km are defined as before, [S]m is the concentration of micellized surfactant and Vm,S is the molar volume of the surfactant. Both the model based on equilibrium constants and the model based on partition constant will result in micellar rate constants and micellar binding or partitioning constants. For neutral reactants, these micellar binding (or partitioning) constants are often thought to be governed to a significant extent by hydrophobic interactions.133 In terms of transition state theory, the micellar rate constant represents the activation Gibbs energy change for the reaction occurring within the micelle. In combination with the micellar binding constant, this can be used to calculate a micellar binding constant for the transition state Km,TS.134–137 The binding constant for the transition state can then be interpreted in terms of stabilizing and destabilizing interactions of the activated complex with the micelle. While for certain reactions, this may be a valuable approach, it should be kept in mind that the transition state in the micellar Stern region may be different from that in the bulk aqueous pseudophase (cf. enzyme catalysis, see Carpenter138). In addition, this approach begins to lose its appeal if the process is pseudounimolecular rather than truly unimolecular. For example, in the case of water-catalyzed hydrolysis reactions involving two water molecules in the activated complex (vide infra), the water concentration in the Stern region [H2O]m will be different from the concentration of water in the bulk [H2O]w and this should ideally be factored in (and it may even be better to use water activities instead of
COLLOIDAL MEDIUM EFFECTS ON ORGANIC REACTIONS
13
concentrations139). The resulting expression for Km,TS [Equation (5)] becomes somewhat unwieldy.140 00
Km;TS ¼
km Km k ½H2 O2m Km ¼ m 00 kw kw ½H2 O2w
ð5Þ 00
00
Here, variables are as defined before and kw and km are the third-order rate constants for hydrolysis. Both the Menger–Portnoy model and the model by Berezin were effectively derived on the assumption that micellar solutions contain two pseudophases, namely the micellar pseudophase and bulk water. However, both models can be expanded to take more than one micellar pseudophase into account. For example, this could be done when the micellar pseudophase is seen to consist of two separate pseudophases (zones) itself, namely a pseudophase corresponding to the hydrophobic core and a pseudophase corresponding to the micellar Stern region.140–142 If one then assumes a reaction to occur with a rate constant kS in the Stern region while the reaction does not occur in the micellar core, the expression for km includes the distribution of the reactant over different zones [Equation (6)].140 VStern PwS km ¼ kS ð6Þ Vmic Pm Here, ks is the rate constant for hydrolysis in the Stern region, VStern and Vmic are the volumes of the Stern region and of the micelle, respectively, PwS and Pm are the water-to-Stern region and water-to-micelle partition coefficients, respectively. Equation (6) shows that, for the assumptions described above, the micellar rate constant is given by the rate constant for the reaction in the Stern region, multiplied by a factor representing the distribution of the reactant within the micelle. Further subdivision of the micellar pseudophase is (mathematically) possible143,144 but may not be warranted. BIMOLECULAR REACTIONS
If reactions are not (pseudo) unimolecular but bimolecular, data analysis becomes considerably more complicated (higher order reactions will not be discussed here, but kinetic schemes can be derived following similar approaches). Two limiting cases can be discerned: (1) the second reactant is a counterion to the surfactant or (2) the second reactant is a neutral molecule. THE PSEUDOPHASE ION EXCHANGE MODEL
For the first case, one can use the so-called pseudophase ion exchange (PIE) model.145–147 The PIE model is based on the Menger–Portnoy model but additionally allows for ion exchange to occur in the micellar Stern region where a reactive counterion competes with nonreactive counterions (Scheme 5).
14
N.J. BUURMA
Scheme 5
The additional assumptions underlying the PIE model compared to the Menger–Portnoy model are that the degree of counterion binding remains constant, that is, counterion exchange occurs strictly 1:1 and the micellar Stern region effectively behaves as an ion exchange resin.33,52 Based on these assumptions, one can calculate local concentrations of the reactive counterion if the equilibrium constant for counterion exchange is known. This local counterion concentration is then used in conjunction with the pseudophase model to yield second-order rate constants for the bimolecular reaction of interest. Typically, counterion competition reflects, among others, the hydration energies of the counterions, with better hydrated counterions binding most weakly. For organic counterions, hydrophobic interactions (which in essence are also related to hydration energies of course) may play a role as well. Although the assumption that counterion exchange occurs strictly 1:1 (i.e., total counterion binding remains constant) is known to break down for a variety of systems,148,149 the PIE model remains popular for the analysis of bimolecular kinetics involving reactive counterions.
THE PSEUDOPHASE MODEL FOR BIMOLECULAR REACTIONS
The second case of a bimolecular reaction occurring between two uncharged reactants A and B requires further extensions of the pseudophase model. The simplest of the possible expansions involves bimolecular reactions not involving reactions crossing the interface between the pseudophases, in other words, reactant A in the aqueous pseudophase reacts only with reactant B in the aqueous pseudophase while reactant A in the micellar pseudophase reacts only with reactant B in the micellar pseudophase (Scheme 6). To what extent the reaction occurring in each of the two separate pseudophases contributes to the overall observed reaction depends on the local reaction rate constants and local concentrations. Typically, plots representing the rate of reaction or the (related) observed second-order rate constant kobs,2 as a function of surfactant concentration go through a maximum. This maximum is related to the lowest surfactant concentration where both reactants are fully bound in the micellar pseudophase, that is, local concentrations in the micellar pseudophase are highest.
COLLOIDAL MEDIUM EFFECTS ON ORGANIC REACTIONS
15
Scheme 6
Addition of further surfactant then dilutes the reactants by increasing the volume of the micellar pseudophase and the observed reaction rate (or reaction rate constant) decreases. This kinetic scheme results in Equation (7) describing the observed secondorder rate constant kobs,2 as a function of micellized surfactant concentration [S]m. kw;2 1 ½Sm Vm;S þ km;2 Pm;A Pm;B ½Sm Vm;S kobs;2 ¼ ð7Þ 1 þ Pm;A 1 ½SVm;S 1 þ Pm;B 1 ½SVm;S Here variables are defined as before, kw,2 and km,2 are the (second order) rate constants in water and in the micellar pseudophase, respectively, Pm,A and Pm,B are the partition coefficients for reactants A and B, respectively.
DATA ANALYSIS
For (pseudo) unimolecular reactions, the Menger–Portnoy and Berezin approaches both typically result in reasonably well-defined optimized (fitted) parameters. This is not the case for the models describing bimolecular reactions. As a result of the number of optimizable parameters in combination with their relative appearances (as products or ratios) in the rate equations, several of the kinetic parameters typically show strong covariance. This is most easily demonstrated for the PIE model, where the reaction rate within the micelle is related to the product of the local counterion concentration and the local rate constant. As a result, one can reproduce (fit) kinetic data equally well for a range of values of the counterion binding and second-order rate constant, as long as the product of these two variables remains virtually the same. This parameter correlation was found by several authors149–153 and discussed in some detail154,155 (though it is noted that the procedure described in Fig. 2 of Klijn and Engberts154 is applicable only for the reduced w2 and not for w2,156 the conclusions of Klijn and Engberts154 still stand). Similar arguments are applicable to the description of micellar kinetics involving secondorder reactions between two uncharged reaction partners. As a result, several of the parameters used in these models to reproduce kinetic data are therefore ideally determined independently. An additional issue with the models describing
16
N.J. BUURMA
bimolecular kinetics is the definition of the micellar volume and the related problem that the reaction does not necessarily take place in the whole aggregate volume.157 Finally, these kinetic models typically require experiments at varying surfactant concentrations while assuming that the surfactant pseudophase remains the same. While this assumption is not strictly correct (vide supra), for most studies effects resulting from changing aggregate morphology appear not to be significant. The exception to this involves systems undergoing radical changes in aggregate morphology, such as sphere-to-wormlike micelle transitions.
5
Hydrotropes and organic reactivity
Compared to surfactants, reports on the effects of hydrotropes on organic reactivity are sparse. Nevertheless, the fact that hydrotropes affect organic reactivity in aqueous solutions is beyond doubt. The aqueous condensation reaction of benzaldehydes with ammonia and acetoacetic esters leading to 4-aryl-1,4-dihydropyridines was accelerated by aliphatic hydrotropes.158 This procedure was subsequently improved by condensing methyl a-aminocrotonate, methyl and ethyl acetoacetate, and substituted aromatic and alkylated aldehydes in the presence of the hydrotrope butylmonoglycosulfate under batch microwave conditions.159 In a more recent report, the same reaction was also performed under continuous microwave conditions using p-toluenesulfonate as the selected hydrotrope.160 In these cases, aqueous hydrotrope solutions were chosen over organic solvents for their ‘‘green’’ credentials. The Claisen–Schmidt condensation of benzaldehydes and acetophenones similarly benefited from the addition of a range of different hydrotropes.161 The Maillard reaction between amino acids and reducing sugars was found to be accelerated greatly by hydrotropes even below the MHC and the results were interpreted in terms of mixed aggregate formation between the reactants and the hydrotrope.162 Similarly, mixed aggregate formation between amino acids and hydrotropic sodium benzoate has been proposed as the cause for the observed enhancement in the rate of the reaction between ninhydrin and a series of amino acids.163 The alkaline hydrolysis of benzylchloride was accelerated significantly, but also rendered more selective for the formation of dibenzyl ether, by the addition of sodium cumenesulfonate. Both the increased rate and the increased selectivity were principally attributed to the increased solubility of the reactant.164 A number of hydrotropes was found to similarly enhance (up to 17-fold) the rates of reaction of the biphasic (solid–liquid) hydrolysis of phenyl benzoate, ethyl p-nitrobenzoate, and 2,4-dichlorophenyl benzoate. It was noted that the products of some of these hydrolysis reactions were hydrotropes themselves, further enhancing reaction rates.165 Such ‘‘autocatalysis’’ was also found for the biphasic alkaline hydrolysis of aromatic esters.166 In summary, reaction rates can be increased through the use of hydrotropes. However, for the currently known examples, the increased solubility of organic reactants appears to be the main reason for the observed rate enhancements. In an attempt to understand the processes involved in organic reactions in hydrotrope solutions, the group of Engberts167,168 studied a series of hydrotropes using
COLLOIDAL MEDIUM EFFECTS ON ORGANIC REACTIONS
17
NMR and through their effects on the pH-independent water-catalyzed hydrolysis of the hydrolytic probe 1-benzoyl-3-phenyl-1,2,4-triazole (vide infra). In particular for the least hydrophobic hydrotropes, concentration-dependent NMR studies suggest self-aggregation without the occurrence of critical concentrations. More hydrophobic compounds eventually showed a critical self-aggregation concentration, possibly indicating the transition from hydrotropes to surfactants. The effect on the hydrolysis of the hydrolytic probe again showed little evidence for the self-aggregation of the hydrotropes. Interactions between individual hydrotropes and the hydrolytic probe turned out to be relatively weak (with equilibrium constants up to 3 kg mol1 – the molality scale was used) but still appeared stronger than interactions between the hydrotrope molecules themselves. It was suggested that electrostatic repulsion between the ionic moieties of the hydrotropes can typically not be overcome by the hydrophobic interactions between the relatively small hydrophobic moieties of the hydrotropes, unless these hydrophobic interactions are further strengthened or bridged by interactions with an uncharged hydrophobic solubilizate such as 1-benzoyl-3-phenyl-1,2,4-triazole. This suggestion was subsequently confirmed by others.169,170 In this respect, a tentative link between hydrotropy, premicellar aggregation, and solubilizate-induced premicellar aggregation could be made. Furthermore, this suggestion offers an attractively simple explanation for the high solubilizing power of hydrotropes as being the result of the high availability of hydrophobic binding sites. As hydrotropes do not self-aggregate without the solubilizate, the solubilizate does not have to compete for the hydrophobic binding sites with hydrotrope molecules.
6
Micelles and organic reactivity
MICELLAR MEDIUM EFFECTS AS EXPERIENCED BY (REACTIVE) PROBES
Contrary to the situation for hydrotropes, the literature on the use of micelles in organic reactions is truly vast (for overviews see, e.g., Khan,52 Tas¸ ciog˘lu,171 and Dwars et al.172). Here, we focus on studies of the reaction medium as offered by micelles using (reactive) probe molecules. Understanding the local reaction medium offered by micelles is crucial for the selection of appropriate surfactants for micellar catalysis. A nice recent example of surfactant selection based on predicted medium effects is provided by Mubofu and Engberts.173 In addition, in particular for bimolecular reactions, the analysis of reaction data is sufficiently nontrivial (vide supra) to warrant a search for alternative procedures leading to estimates of reaction rate constants in the micellar pseudophase. Such estimates would preferably result from a thorough understanding of the reaction medium offered by the micellar Stern region and ideally from kinetic experiments using model solutions accurately mimicking the micellar Stern regions of different micelles. Because the majority of reactants appears to bind to micelles in the micellar Stern region (vide supra), we will focus on this zone. A number of approaches has been
18
N.J. BUURMA
employed to study the local environment offered by the micellar Stern region (several of these are equally valid for reactions in vesicular solutions which we discuss below). Here, we discuss some of the more recently used methods.
ARENEDIAZONIUM SALTS AS PROBES OF THE STERN REGION
A particularly successful approach in probing the micellar Stern region was developed by the group of Romsted, who realized that the dediazoniation of substituted arenediazonium ions results in the rate-determining production of highly reactive (and rather unselective) aryl cations which will react at a diffusion controlled rate37 even with weak nucleophiles such as chloride anions and urea174 (Scheme 7). As a result, the aryl cation will react with any nucleophile in its vicinity, thereby effectively sampling its environment. In fact, the product distribution of the dediazoniation reaction represents the equilibrium distribution of the diazonium cation–anion and diazonium cation–molecule intimate pairs.37 For cetyltrimethylammonium halides, the arenediazonium moiety of a long-tailed arenediazonium salt was found to reside in the micellar Stern region based on its fluorescence quenching of Ru(bpy)3 2þ.175 With the aryl cation in the micellar Stern region, the product distribution provides a snapshot of all the nucleophiles present in that zone. This effect was first observed when comparing reaction products from a micelle-forming diazonium salt with those of a diazonium salt that does not form micelles, both with bromide counterions; the micellar dediazoniation resulted in only the corresponding bromide, whereas the nonmicellar dediazoniation resulted in only the corresponding phenol.176 This approach has subsequently been used to study a variety of systems and some of the results are summarized here.
Scheme 7
COLLOIDAL MEDIUM EFFECTS ON ORGANIC REACTIONS
19
ARENEDIAZONIUM SALTS AND CATIONIC SURFACTANTS
The concentrations of interfacial water, counterions, and even some additives in the micellar Stern region of examples of cationic, anionic, zwitterionic, and nonionic micelles have all been sampled using the arenediazonium trapping method. For cetyltrimethylammonium-based surfactants, the counterion concentration in the Stern region was found to increase with added NaCl and NaBr. The same study found the counterion exchange between Cl and Br to be relatively insensitive to ionic strength and surfactant concentration.177 In an extension of this work,37 a second water-soluble diazonium salt was used as a reference probe for use in model aqueous solutions. The selectivity of the micelle-bound probe for the different nucleophiles was assumed to be the same as that of the water-soluble probe – this water-soluble reference arenediazonium salt was used in all further studies employing this approach. Counterion binding was found to be 0.75 for CTABr and 0.71 for CTACl, while the equilibrium constant for ion exchange KBr/Cl was found to be 2.6 0.4. For cationic cetyltrialkylammonium halides at 40 C and a bulk counterion concentration of 0.1 mol dm3, increasing surfactant headgroup size (and hydrophobicity) was found to result in a decreasing counterion concentration in the Stern region whereas interfacial water concentration remained more or less the same.178 Counterion binding and related headgroup hydration further vary with surfactant concentration and counterion concentration and type.178 An increase in counterion concentration in the bulk aqueous phase [X]w universally leads to an increase in the counterion concentration in the Stern region [X]m (i.e., counterion binding increases). An increase in [X]m is also found with increasing surfactant concentration together with the concomitant decrease in Stern region water concentration. For the surfactants with the largest headgroups and at sufficiently high added salt concentrations, [X]m eventually increases linearly with [X]w suggesting that added counterions, presumably as ion pairs, freely move between the bulk aqueous phase and the micellar Stern region. Reminiscent of this increase in [X]m with increasing [X]w as a result of freely diffusing ion pairs is the behavior of added urea in solutions of cetyltrimethylammonium halide; Stern region urea concentrations are only slightly lower than bulk urea concentrations,174 and the micelle-destabilizing effect of added urea was attributed to the destabilization of the headgroup–counterion pairs in the micellar Stern region. For the cetyltrialkylammonium surfactants with smaller headgroup size, however, added counterion leads to a sphere-towormlike transition. At this sphere-to-wormlike transition, [X]m increases significantly while [H2O]m shows the corresponding decrease.53,178 In this model, the sphere-to-wormlike transition is attributed to the formation of tight ion pairs between the surfactant headgroups and the counterions, resulting in partial dehydration and compaction of the micellar Stern region. This compaction effectively corresponds to a change in packing parameter (vide supra). Importantly, it is noted that the increase in [X]m with increasing [X]w is at odds with the assumption of the PIE model that the total counterion binding remains constant.179 The sphere-to-wormlike transition of micelles of gemini surfactants was also probed through the determination of ion-pair formation of the component bolaform diammonium cations with
20
N.J. BUURMA
counterions,38 together with arenediazonium trapping experiments on the gemini surfactants themselves.180 As for simple cetyltrimethylammonium halides, the sphere-to-wormlike transition of gemini surfactants is associated with the formation of tight ion pairs, the formation of which leads to a loss of hydration water molecules for the Stern region. Added 3,5-dichlorobenzoate counterions similarly induce a sphere-to-wormlike transition where the concentration of 3,5-dichlorobenzoate increases significantly through the transition. On the contrary, added 2,6dichlorobenzoate does not induce a sudden increase in local counterion concentration, highlighting the subtlety of the interactions resulting in micellar morphology changes.181 Combining these results suggests that the sphere-to-wormlike transition results from a delicate balance of intermolecular forces, with hydrophobic interactions driving the formation of headgroup–counterion pairs if headgroup size, counterion type, and concentration are all suitable.53,180 The effective surface area then decreases as a result of this ion-pair formation together with the concomitant release of hydration water. Within the packing parameter description, this is equivalent to an increase in P, or a surfactant shape change from cone to truncated cone, and hence a change in micellar shape from spherical to wormlike.
ARENEDIAZONIUM SALTS AND ANIONIC, ZWITTERIONIC, AND NONIONIC MICELLES
The arenediazonium probe has similarly been used to study a range of anionic, zwitterionic, and nonionic micelles. The concentrations of Cl and Br (as co-ions to the counterion Naþ) in the Stern region of sodium dodecylsulfate compared favorably with their concentrations as predicted by the Poisson–Boltzmann equation.182 Hydration numbers and local concentrations of terminal OH-groups were determined for nonionic C12E6.183 Hydration numbers were found to decrease both with increasing surfactant concentration and with increasing temperature. Hydration numbers in mixed nonionic micelles (C10E4/C12E6, C10E4/C16E8, C10E5/C16E8, C12E6/C16E8, and C10E5/C12E5 – cf. Scheme 2) were found to be around three at room temperature while the distribution of the terminal OH was found to follow a simple radial one-dimensional random walk pattern.179,184 For zwitterionic micelles of 3-(N-hexadecyl-N,N-dimethylammonio)propanesulfonate and hexadecylphosphorylcholine, the effects of added salts of Cl and Br were investigated. Interfacial Br concentrations were found to be consistently higher than interfacial Cl concentrations, but these interfacial concentrations themselves depend on the added cations.185
SOLVATOCHROMIC PROBES
Solvatochromic probes report on the polarity of the local medium through changes in their UV vis absorption spectra. Perhaps the most famous example of these solvatochromic probes is provided by the ET30 probe developed by Reichardt186 (Scheme 8).
COLLOIDAL MEDIUM EFFECTS ON ORGANIC REACTIONS
21
Scheme 8
As reporters of local medium properties, polarity in particular, solvatochromic dyes have found obvious use in the study of micellar pseudophases187 and are often used in combination with kinetic studies (see, e.g., Rodrı´ guez et al.188). For such combined studies, it should be noted, however, that the binding site of a reactant or reactants may differ significantly from the binding site of the solvatochromic probe. Hence, one has to be careful with direct comparisons. Typically, solvatochromic probes report the micellar pseudophase to be less polar than water. As an example, the ET30 value for water is 63.1,186 whereas the ET30 values for SDS, CTAB, and C12E20 are 57.5, 53.4, and 52.8,189 respectively. In principle, different solvatochromic probes can show different sensitivities to certain aspects of the micellar pseudophase such as local water concentration, suggesting that the use of a variety of probes may be beneficial. The drawback to the use of several probes is that these, a priori, do not necessarily bind in the same zone. The group of El Seoud190192 in particular has used series of solvatochromic dyes to study the medium offered by the micellar pseudophase. Using a series of solvatochromic dyes in conjunction with a series of cationic surfactants of different headgroup size, it was found that the reported polarity depends on both solvatochromic probe structure and headgroup size. This result was interpreted in terms of different binding sites of the different solvatochromic probes as caused by their different polarities. Water concentrations at the average binding locations of typical solvatochromic dyes (as determined through comparison with model aqueous solutions typically containing 1-propanol or dioxane) for cationic surfactants all lie roughly in the 35–45 mol dm3 range. The interfacial water concentration of anionic micelles (SDS) was similarly found to be in the 35–40 mol dm3 range using two ET30-related probes as well as a merocyanine dye.187,193 An increasing surfactant headgroup size was found to gradually ‘‘dehydrate’’ the Stern region.190 Similar to kinetic probes for the micellar pseudophase (vide infra), ET30 values at a range of surfactant concentrations are determined. The observed concentration-dependent ET30 values are analyzed to provide micellar ET30 values.192 Related to this, it was suggested that ET30 values
22
N.J. BUURMA
of surfactant solutions should be used and interpreted with care as experiments using gemini surfactant at a low concentration suggested the possible existence of probesurfactant mixed aggregates.194 Finally, recent reports suggest that anionic organic counterions can displace certain betaine dyes from cationic surfactants,195,196 suggesting that solvatochromic dyes can provide further information on surfactant solutions, provided they are used with care.
PSEUDOUNIMOLECULAR REACTIONS
As mentioned in Section 4, the analysis of rate data resulting from unimolecular reactions is considerably easier than the analysis of such data for bimolecular reactions, and the same is true for pseudounimolecular reactions. Kinetic probes currently used to study the micellar pseudophase showing first-order reaction kinetics are almost exclusively compounds undergoing hydrolysis reactions showing in fact pseudofirst-order kinetics. In these cases, water is the second reactant and it is therefore anticipated that these kinetic probes report at least the reduced water concentration (or better water activity139) in the micellar pseudophase. As for solvatochromic probes, the sensitivity to different aspects of the micellar pseudophase can be different for different hydrolytic probes and as a result, different probes may report different characteristics. Hence, as for solvatochromic probes, the use of a series of hydrolytic probes may provide additional insight. Most of the pseudounimolecular hydrolytic probe reactions involve watercatalyzed pH-independent hydrolysis of activated esters, amides, or acid chlorides140,188,197–204 (Scheme 9). The hydrolysis of these probes occurs via a dipolar
Scheme 9
COLLOIDAL MEDIUM EFFECTS ON ORGANIC REACTIONS
23
Scheme 10
activated complex in which two water molecules, one acting as a nucleophile and the other as a general base, are involved with three protons in flight. Scheme 10 illustrates this mechanism for 1-benzoyl-1,2,4-triazole.205–207 The fact that most hydrolytic probes currently in use for the study of micellar pseudophases react according to the same general mechanism provides an excellent opportunity for comparisons of micellar rate effects beyond the single hydrolytic probe level. Based on the mechanism of these hydrolysis reactions, one expects the following properties of the micellar pseudophase to play a role in the increase or decrease of rate constants: (1) the lower local water concentration in the micellar Stern region, (2) the polarity of the micellar Stern region, (3) the high ionic strength in the micellar Stern region, and (4) the local charge in the micellar Stern region resulting from incomplete counterion binding. All of these properties have indeed been used to explain observed micellar rate effects. In addition, when comparing different kinetic probes, one could add (5) the average micellar solubilization site of the probe as becoming a factor as well. With respect to the reduced water concentration (1), it seems as if all but one of the hydrolysis reactions following the mechanism shown in Scheme 10 are retarded in micellar solutions (the exception being the hydrolysis of 4-nitrophenyl chloroformate 1a in cationic micelles197) and the lower water concentration in the micellar Stern region (estimated to be 45 mol dm3 for CTAB36,37 and 33 mol dm3 for SDS208) will surely play a role in this. This suggestion is further corroborated by the observation that increasing headgroup bulk and counterion binding affinity, as well as the addition of perchlorate counterions (all of which decrease the water content of the micellar Stern region), increase the micellar rate retarding effect.200 The decreased local water concentration alone is seldom sufficient, however, to explain the full rateretarding effect caused by micelles and other factors will play a role.
24
N.J. BUURMA
The lower polarity of the micellar Stern region (2) is also widely thought to make a significant contribution to the rate retarding effects of micelles; in fact, the transition state of the type of hydrolysis reactions commonly used to probe the micellar pseudophase is thought to be more polar than the reactants, indicating that a more polar medium would be favorable for reaction to occur.197,201,209 The effects of the high ionic strength (3) appear to depend rather much on the details of the hydrolytic probe. For example, aqueous rate constants for 4-nitrophenyl 2,2-dichloropropionate 2 decrease as a function of added electrolyte (as typically happens), but the origin of this rate decrease by added electrolytes was interpreted to be different from the rate-retarding effect exerted by micelles based on activation parameter considerations.198 For another hydrolytic probe, phenyl chloroformate 1b, increasing electrolyte concentrations also decrease the rate of reaction, but this effect is negligible in comparison to the micellar rate effects.201 The effect of the local non-neutral environment (4) should be considered together with the detailed reaction mechanism of the hydrolysis reaction and together with the charge development in the activation process in particular. The electrostatically non-neutral environment offered by ionic micelles is generally thought to be the reason for the observation that rate-retarding effects exerted by anionic surfactants on this type of hydrolysis reaction are typically stronger than those by other surfactants.140,197,200,201 This stronger rate retardation by SDS was explained in terms of the development of a partial negative charge on the activated complex.201 The generation of such a partial negative charge in the activated complex is considerably less favorable in a negatively charged local environment than in any other environment. The potential impact of the local charge in the micellar Stern region is further illustrated by the rate enhancement of hydrolysis of 4-nitrophenyl chloroformate 1a in cationic surfactants, with other surfactants having decreasing rates.197 However, the exact impact of the micellar charge is rather sensitive to the detailed reaction mechanism as shown by Bunton’s observation that, for a series of differently substituted hydrolytic probes, kCTACl/kSDS increases with increasing electron withdrawing ability of the substituent.210 In subsequent work involving a series of different kinetic probes reacting by different mechanisms, Bunton et al.199,211 found a marked relation between the mechanism of the reaction and the charge of the micellar Stern region. Reactions involving rate-determining bond breaking (SN1 hydrolyses) were least decelerated by anionic surfactants, whereas reactions involving ratedetermining bond making were least decelerated by cationic surfactants. The results were interpreted in terms of partial charge formation in the activated complex and such partial charges were determined for the hydrolysis of substituted acid chlorides 3.211 If the kinetic probe itself is charged, however, the micellar excess charge may stabilize the reactant more than the transition state, resulting in a rate decrease.212 Finally, changes in the average binding location (5) of kinetic probes could in principle always be invoked to explain differences in micellar rate constants. NMR experiments have suggested, however, that for several of these hydrolytic probes, the binding site in the micellar Stern region does not change significantly with surfactant charge or length of the hydrophobic tail.197 Nevertheless, comparison of the rates of hydrolysis of 4-nitrophenyl chloroformate 1a and 4-nitrophenyl 2,2-dichloropropionate 2 shows a
COLLOIDAL MEDIUM EFFECTS ON ORGANIC REACTIONS
25
marked difference in the rate effects exerted by different surfactants. Whereas the hydrolysis of 4-nitrophenyl chloroformate 1a was accelerated by cationic micelles and most strongly decelerated by anionic micelles, the micellar rate constants for hydrolysis of 4-nitrophenyl 2,2-dichloropropionate 2 were far more similar. This difference was attributed to an ‘‘average nearness to the micellar Stern region’’ with the data suggesting that the more hydrophobic 4-nitrophenyl 2,2-dichloropropionate 2 binds more deeply within the micelle. Considering the number of factors influencing micellar rate constants, it is no wonder that not even the order of reactivity in micellar aggregates can be reliably predicted,202,203 and a separation of the micellar medium effect into its component parts would be advantageous. Not surprisingly, it is rather difficult to separate the different contributions of the different interactions as they occur in the micellar Stern region. In an attempt to solve this problem, the group of Engberts used a series of hydrolysis reactions of activated esters and amides to probe the reaction environment offered by micelles. The reactions initially involved the water-catalyzed pH-independent hydrolysis reactions of p-methoxyphenyl dichloroacetate 4 and 1-benzoyl-3-phenyl-1,2,4-triazole 5, as extensive information on the rate retarding effects of added cosolutes on this reaction was available.213–225 It was initially140 found that the rate-retarding effects of DTAB, CTAB, SDS, and C12E7 micelles could be reproduced using aqueous mimicking solutions containing only headgroup mimics tetramethylammonium bromide (for DTAB and CTAB), sodium methylsulfate (for SDS), and tetraethyleneglycol (for C12E7). This observation led to the conclusion that the micellar retardation of the hydrolysis of 4 and 5 is dominated by a salt effect. In this description, the salt effect includes the effect of the hydrophobic groups forming part of the surfactant headgroup such as the methyls of the trimethylammonium headgroup of CTAB. For nonionic C12E7 micelles, the term ‘‘salt effect’’ denotes the effect of the oligoethyleneoxide moieties in the C12E7 headgroup even though these are not ionic. The Stern region was therefore regarded as a separate phase with a high surfactant headgroup and counterion concentration. However, it was noted that the discrepancy between the micellar rate constant and the rate constant in the model compound solution was largest for 4, which was known to be more sensitive toward hydrophobic interactions than 5. In addition, the solvatochromic ET30 probe indicated a much more hydrophobic environment and other authors similarly found systems for which a model solution only mimicking the surfactant headgroups was insufficient to reproduce properties of the micellar pseudophase.201 The Hammett -value for hydrolysis of substituted 1-benzoyl-1,2,4-triazoles 6a–f could similarly not be reproduced using a model solution mimicking ionic interactions only.204 These observations were taken as an indication that further interactions needed to be included in a subsequent study.204 The most obvious candidate was the interaction with the hydrophobic micellar tails, and the model solution originally containing only ionic headgroup mimics was extended with a mimic for the hydrophobic tail, namely 1-propanol (as the longest unbranched single-tail alcohol miscible with water in all ratios). It was found that the sensitivity of the hydrolysis of substituted 1-benzoyl1,2,4-triazoles 6a–f to added 1-propanol and tetramethylammonium bromide varied
26
N.J. BUURMA
Table 2 Molalities m and concentrations c of 1-propanol and tetramethylammonium bromide (TMAB) in solutions mimicking the Stern regions of DTAB and CTAB micelles DTAB 1
1-Propanol TMAB Water
CTAB 3
1
m (mol kg )
c (mol dm )
m (mol kg )
c (mol dm3)
ma (mol kg1)
9.3 1.5
5.1 0.8 30
5.0 4.9
2.6 2.6 29
7.7 5.7
Concentrations were determined using the experimentally determined densities of the solutions. a Make-up of the ‘‘second-order solution.’’
in a way that allowed hydrophobic effects of surfactant tails (mimicked by 1propanol) and ionic effects of surfactant heagroups (mimicked by tetramethylammonium bromide) to be separated using singular value decomposition. This approach resulted in a quantitative separation of the hydrophobic and ionic effects exerted by DTAB and CTAB micelles (Table 2). To correct for nonideal behavior of the 1-propanol and tetramethylammonium at these high concentrations, a further optimization of the mimicking solution was required. A ‘‘second-order solution’’ for CTAB was elaborated using the ‘‘first-order solution’’ as a starting point. This second-order solution was found to reproduce not only the micellar rate constants for the hydrolysis of the substituted 1-benzoyl-1,2,4-triazoles 6a–f but the hydrolysis rate constant for 5 and the ET30 value with good accuracy as well.204
REACTIONS INVOLVING COUNTERIONS
Literature on reactions involving micellar counterions is particularly rich and for good reasons. The local concentration of counterions in the micellar Stern region is extremely high compared to typical aqueous solutions. As a result, bimolecular reactions involving bases such as hydroxide and acetate or oxidants such as perchlorate can be accelerated significantly by using these as a counterion for cationic surfactants. Discussion here will be restricted to a selected number of relatively recent examples of particular interest. This should not, however, distract from the merit of many of the other publications in this field. The kinetic profile of reactions involving the micelle’s counterions is frequently analyzed in terms of the PIE model. Despite the known shortcomings of this model, it nevertheless typically reproduces kinetic data rather well – though one should remain conscious of the potential problems related to parameter covariance (vide supra). Despite the sometimes impressive reaction rate enhancements, second-order rate constants for most bimolecular reactions involving counterions actually decrease,126,127,209,212,226–232 with just a few remaining virtually constant233 or increasing.232,234–238 As discussed (vide supra), micellar rate constants for (pseudo) unimolecular reactions are frequently lower than rate constants in water. Many of the
COLLOIDAL MEDIUM EFFECTS ON ORGANIC REACTIONS
27
arguments for rate constant decreases for (pseudo) unimolecular reactions are valid for reactions involving reactive counterions as well. For example, stabilization of a developing partial charge is a factor in reactions involving reactive counterions as well238 and can even lead to interesting differentiation between reaction pathways.227 Similarly, the micellar Stern region has been found to be less polar as reported by an increased Hammett for micellar reactions compared to reactions in bulk water.126,129,212,239 As the reasons for rate retardations have been discussed for pseudounimolecular probe reactions already, we focus on the reported increased bimolecular rate constants. Two main reasons for increases in bimolecular rate constants come to the fore: (1) dehydration of the reactive counterions and (2) charge delocalization during the activation process leading to the transition state. An intriguing third reason (although, admittedly, not strictly equating to an increased bimolecular rate constant) is (3) the increase in local counterion concentration as a result of comoving counterions. We will discuss these three effects in order. In virtually all cases, bimolecular reactions involving reactive counterions involve cationic surfactants and anionic (basic and/or nucleophilic) counterions. Typical water concentrations in the Stern region are lower than in bulk water and local counterion concentrations are high. As a result, the counterions are partially dehydrated. This partial dehydration renders these counterions more reactive. Such effects have been found, for example, for the SN2 reactions of alkyl naphthalene-2-sulfonates with Br and OH, where increasing headgroup hydrophobicity resulted in an increase in the second-order rate constant for the reaction with Br (but not for the more strongly hydrated OH).232 In one example, F which is normally strongly hydrated was found to catalyze the dephosphorylation of p-nitrophenyldiphenyl phosphate even in competition with the a-effect nucleophile isonitroacetylacetone.228 The effect of charge delocalization en route to the activated complex is the result of the relatively nonpolar micellar environment; compared to bulk water, charges in the micellar pseudophase are less stabilized by interactions with their environment (cf. stabilization of developing charges by the electrostatically non-neutral environment for (pseudo) unimolecular reactions). This effect was found for the dehydrobromination reaction of 2-(p-nitrophenyl) ethyl bromide234,235 and the dehydrochlorination of 1,1,1-trichloro-2,2-bis(p-chlorophenyl)ethane.235 Finally, as an example of the effect of ion-pairing of surfactant counterions with co-moving ions, the reaction of methyl 4-nitrobenzenesulfonate with Br was accelerated when the concentration of Br in the Stern region was increased through the appropriate choice of cation.237
BIMOLECULAR REACTIONS INVOLVING NEUTRAL REACTANTS
Compared to micellar bimolecular reactions involving reactive surfactant counterions, considerably less work has been done on micellar bimolecular reactions involving two neutral reactants. We will discuss here micellar effects on cycloaddition reactions though this is by no means the only system for which micellar catalysis has been investigated (see, e.g., Bonollo et al.240).
28
N.J. BUURMA
Diels–Alder reactions provide one of the prime examples of beneficial effects of aqueous solvents. Following extensive research of the aqueous acceleration of Diels–Alder reactions,6 it is now thought that the two main reasons for this acceleration are enforced hydrophobic interactions and hydrogen bonding. Given the beneficial effects of water on the Diels–Alder reaction, additional micellar acceleration was envisaged. However, it turned out that micellar catalysis of the Diels–Alder reaction using unfunctionalized surfactants was less successful than hoped241 (with one notable exception17). Attempts at catalysis of Diels–Alder reactions using chiral surfactants resulted in low e.e.,242 and for cycloaddition reactions in general, only modest rate enhancements were found,122,157,243–245 which typically result from increased local reactant concentrations counteracted by decreased local second-order rate constants. In some cases, no rate effect or even rate retardation was found.17,246 Reduced hydrogen bonding to the transition state was found to be a key contribution to the rate-retarding effect through a simultaneous study of a Diels–Alder reaction and its retro Diels–Alder reaction.245 Both the micellar rate constant for the Diels–Alder reaction and for the retro Diels–Alder reaction were found to be decreased compared to bulk water. This decreased micellar rate constant was compensated by increased local reactant concentrations for the Diels–Alder reaction, resulting in a higher reaction rate, a concentration effect not ‘‘available to’’ the unimolecular retro Diels–Alder reaction. A further study17 resulted in a combination of initially confusing findings. Whereas the second-order micellar rate constant for a series of Diels–Alder reactions was found to be exceptionally low compared to bulk water, endo/exo ratios, and Hammett -values still very much resembled those for aqueous solutions. In combination with paramagnetic relaxation enhancement studies, the low micellar rate constant was attributed to different micellar binding sites of diene and dienophile. This conclusion was partially refuted, however, by a subsequent study122 involving reactants designed to bind in different micellar zones. This study showed that the main factor in decreasing rate constants for Diels–Alder reactions is the local water concentration, which was estimated to be rather low, namely 10–15 mol dm3, at the micellar reaction site. This local water concentration was similarly found to provide a good model for the micellar reaction site for 1,3-dipolar cycloadditions.157 These 1,3-dipolar cycloadditions are catalyzed rather considerably by micellar solutions, however, because they are less sensitive to solvent effects. As a result, micellar rate constants are decreased less compared to bulk water, but local concentration effects remain operative. Finally, part of the decreased hydrogen bonding effects of the micellar pseudophase (compared to bulk water) were reinstated in a study employing a carefully designed combination of specific acid catalysis, surfactants with hydrogen bonding capacity and Lewis acid counterions.173
7
Vesicles and organic reactivity247
Micelles offer a variety of highly dynamic binding sites, which makes their description as a reaction medium an intricate affair. Whereas vesicular dynamics are slower than micellar dynamics, this by no means results in more straightforward descriptions of the
COLLOIDAL MEDIUM EFFECTS ON ORGANIC REACTIONS
29
vesicular pseudophase as a reaction medium. To an important extent, this is caused by the fact that vesicles are not equilibrium structures. As a result, it can be difficult to compare vesicular effects on organic reactions even if the same surfactant is used, as the properties of the vesicular solutions themselves may depend on the method of preparation. In addition, reactivity could be affected by membrane fluidity differences (below and above Tm) and membrane permeability of one or more of the reactants. Such membrane permeability effects have been discussed in detail by Moss et al.55,56,73,75,248 and will not be discussed here. Most of the characteristics invoked to explain rate accelerations and rate retardations by micelles are valid for vesicles as well. For example, the alkaline hydrolysis of N-methyl-N-nitroso-p-toluenesulfonamide is accelerated by cationic vesicles (dioctadecyldimethylammonium chloride). This rate acceleration is the result of a higher local OH concentration which more than compensates for the decreased polarity of the vesicular pseudophase (compared to both water and micelles) resulting in a lower local second-order rate constant.70 Similar to effects found for micelles, the partial dehydration of OH and the lower local polarity are considered to contribute significantly to the catalysis of the Kemp elimination249–251 by DODAB vesicles.252 Even the different sensitivities of reactions following associative and dissociative reaction mechanisms, as found for micellar systems,199,253 were found for vesicles as well.254 As discussed above, the packing parameter for vesicle-forming surfactants differs from that for micelle-forming surfactants. One would expect this to have an effect on the properties of the Stern region as a reaction medium. The high vesicular counterion binding (compared to micelles) of 0.87 for small vesicles and 0.96 for large vesicles appears to confirm such a difference.255 Nevertheless, arenediazonium trapping experiments for DODAB255 suggest Br concentrations of 1.2 mol dm3 for small vesicles and 1.6 mol dm3 for large vesicles, not dissimilar from typical values for micellar solutions without added salt.178 Vesicle size was found to affect reaction kinetics for the alkaline hydrolysis and thiolysis of p-nitrophenyl octanoate, with small vesicles being more effective as catalysts, and it was concluded that this size dependence itself was brought about by differences in ion dissociation, substrate binding constants, and intrinsic reactivities.256 Similarly, the decarboxylation of 6-nitrobenzisoxazole (6-NBIC)249,257,258 was found to be faster in incomplete surfactant assemblies than in fully formed vesicles.259 Contradicting results were found, however, for vesicle-catalyzed Diels–Alder reactions, where the reaction rate in the absence of catalytic Cu2þ does not appear to be size dependent260 but in the presence of Cu2þ it is.261 Similarly, vesicular reactivity is dependent on bilayer fluidity and Arrhenius (or Eyring) plots for the decarboxylation of 6-NBIC show a break around Tm.262–264 For the Kemp elimination in different bilayers, it was found that the bilayer for which kinetic data had been gathered below its Tm was least effective as a catalyst.252 Ester hydrolysis has also been found to be faster above Tm.265 For the decarboxylation of 6-NBIC, the increase in catalytic efficiency was attributed to different aggregate surface dynamics based on the observation that vesicles above Tm showed intermediate activation parameters between vesicles below Tm and micelles.263 One could, of course, discuss causality here considering the fact that many of the bilayer
30
N.J. BUURMA
properties change significantly at Tm and improved substrate solubilization has also been used as an explanation for the superior catalytic properties of vesicles above their Tm.256 There may even be a link between the enhanced rate effects of small vesicles and vesicles above their Tm, as Tm is lower for small (more curved) vesicles.266 The effect of additives betrays the intricacy of the balance of rate effects even more. The addition of cholesterol to catalytic bilayers has been found to be beneficial for the Kemp eleminiation252 but to inhibit the decarboxylation of 6-NBIC.264 In general, the effects of additives on the decarboxylation of 6-NBIC appear to subtly depend on the structure of the hydrophobic tail and hydrophilic headgroup of additives.264 Similarly subtle effects were found for the Kemp elimination and nucleophilic attack by Br and water on aromatic alkylsulfonates; depending on the choice of additive, hydrogen bonding effects, reactivity of partially dehydrated OH, and local water concentrations all played a role and vesicular catalysis could be increased or decreased.116,267
8
Conclusions and future directions
The highly dynamic colloidal structures described in this chapter result in considerable complexity in behaviors. This complexity has resulted in relatively slow improvement in our understanding of colloidal systems despite the fact that the structure of micelles was in essence described almost a century ago already.268 Results from a series of relatively recent approaches to describe colloidal aggregates are now beginning to coalesce into a model of colloidal structures incorporating the dynamic and nonhomogeneous structures of these aggregates. Further work on mapping out binding locations and local reaction media offered by aqueous colloidal structures will benefit from continuous effort using all of the approaches described in this chapter. It is anticipated that combining the results from such detailed studies will eventually result in meaningful predictions of binding sites and local medium properties. Such predictions in turn can then be used to carefully select or design amphiphiles to assist organic reactivity in aqueous solutions. Based on currently available work, this situation would be achievable first for micellar systems with vesicular systems following suit. The extremely dynamic structure, if one can even speak of a structure, of the aggregates formed by hydrotropes may well continue to escape accurate description for some time to come. A situation that is only worsened by an apparent lack in interest in, or fear of, these systems in academia. It is tempting to speculate about the reasons for the observation that surfactant aggregates often do not appear to be as effective as hoped. In the author’s opinion, the reasons for this could well be (1) the choice of reactions and (2) the way in which reaction rates are compared. Starting with the first point, it appears as if micellar and vesicular catalysis is often studied for reactions for which water is intrinsically a good solvent, that is, a better solvent than less polar organic solvents. By using the less polar pseudophase formed by surfactant aggregates as a ‘‘base’’ for catalysis, part of
COLLOIDAL MEDIUM EFFECTS ON ORGANIC REACTIONS
31
the beneficial effects of water as a solvent will be lost. In that respect, micelles and vesicles may be viewed in a far better light if micellar or vesicular catalysis of reactions for which water is not a good solvent were to be studied. Regarding the second point, many studies (correctly) report relative rate enhancements or compare first- or second-order rate constants. When comparing micelle- or vesicle-catalyzed reactions with reactions in bulk water, however, it should not be forgotten that reactant concentrations can also be increased as a result of the solubilizing effects of surfactants. The increased reactant concentrations should then result in higher overall reaction rates as long as the added reactants do not disrupt aggregate formation.
Acknowledgments The EPSRC is thanked for support [grant number EP/D001641/1]. Prof. Dr. Jan B. F. N. Engberts, Prof. Radha Ranganathan, and Dr. Lavinia C. Onel are thanked for fruitful discussions. JBFNE and LCO are further thanked for constructive criticism on the manuscript.
References 1. Li C. J Chem Rev 2005;105:3095–165. 2. Li C, Chan T. Comprehensive organic reactions in aqueous media. 2nd ed. Hoboken (NJ): Wiley; 2007. 3. Lindstrom U, editor. Organic reactions in water: principles, strategies and applications. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing; 2007. 4. Grieco PA, editor. Organic synthesis in water. London: Blackie; 1997. 5. Andrade CKZ, Alves LM. Curr Org Chem 2005;9:195–218. 6. Otto S, Engberts JBFN. Pure Appl Chem 2000;72:1365–72. 7. Hailes HC. Org Process Res Dev 2007;11:114–20. 8. Rideout DC, Breslow R. J Am Chem Soc 1980;102:7816–7. 9. Zhang WC, Li CJ. J Org Chem 1999;64:3230–6. 10. Li CJ, Zhang WC. J Am Chem Soc 1998;120:9102–3. 11. Narayan S, Muldoon J, Finn MG, Fokin VV, Kolb HC, Sharpless KB. Angew Chem Int Ed 2005;44:3275–9. 12. Klijn JE, Engberts JBFN. Nature 2005;435:746–7. 13. The chemical potential of a solute in equilibrium with its solid or liquid phase is equal to the chemical potential of the neat compound. It is therefore hardly surprising that some papers claiming to report on ‘‘on water chemistry’’ merely report reactivity comparable to reactivity of the neat reactants. In the author’s opinion, the term ‘‘on water chemistry’’ would preferably be reserved for those processes for which additional rate-enhancing effects are found. 14. Otto S, Engberts JBFN. Org Biomol Chem 2003;1:2809–20. 15. Buurma NJ, Pastorello L, Blandamer MJ, Engberts JBFN. J Am Chem Soc 2001;123:11848–53. 16. Hunter CA. Angew Chem Int Ed 2004;43:5310–24. 17. Otto S, Engberts JBFN, Kwak JCT. J Am Chem Soc 1998;120:9517–25. 18. Friberg SE. Curr Opin Colloid Interface Sci 1997;2:490–4.
32 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30. 31. 32. 33. 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41. 42. 43. 44. 45. 46. 47. 48. 49. 50. 51. 52. 53. 54. 55. 56. 57. 58. 59. 60. 61.
N.J. BUURMA Hodgdon TK, Kaler EW. Curr Opin Colloid Interface Sci 2007;12:121–8. Srinivas V, Balasubramanian D. Langmuir 1998;14:6658–61. Neuberg C. Biochem Z 1916;76:107–76. Balasubramanian D, Srinivas V, Gaikar VG, Sharma MM. J Phys Chem 1989;93:3865–70. Da Silva RC, Spitzer M, Da Silva LHM, Loh W. Thermochim Acta 1999;328:161–7. Horva´th-Szabo´ G, Yin Q, Friberg SE. J Colloid Interface Sci 2001;236:52–9. Bauduin P, Renoncourt A, Kopf A, Touraud D, Kunz W. Langmuir 2005;21:6769–75. Poochikian GK, Cradock JC. J Pharm Sci 1979;68:728–32. Koparkar YP, Gaikar VG. Sep Sci Technol 2004;39:3879–95. Flaim T, Friberg SE. J Colloid Interface Sci 1984;97:26–37. Friberg SE, Rananavare SB, Osborne DW. J Colloid Interface Sci 1986;109:487–92. Israelachvili JN, Mitchell DJ, Ninham BW. J Chem Soc Faraday Trans 1976;2: 1525–68. Gruen DWR. Prog Colloid Polym Sci 1985;70, 6–16. Van Os NM, Haak JR, Rupert LAM. Physico-chemical properties of selected anionic, cationic and nonionic surfactants. Elsevier: Amsterdam; 1993. Bunton CA, Nome F, Quina FH, Romsted LS. Acc Chem Res 1991;24:357–64. Mukerjee P. J Phys Chem 1962;66:943–5. Menger FM, Yoshinaga H, Venkatasubban KS, Das AR. J Org Chem 1981;46:415–9. Chaudhuri A, Romsted LS. J Am Chem Soc 1991;113:5052–3. Chaudhuri A, Loughlin JA, Romsted LS, Yao J. J Am Chem Soc 1993;115:8351–61. Geng Y, Romsted LS. J Phys Chem B 2005;109:23629–37. Stigter D. J Phys Chem 1964;68:3603–11. Lebedeva N, Zana R, Bales BL. J Phys Chem B 2006;110:9800–1. Griffiths PC, Paul A, Heenan RK, Penfold J, Ranganathan R, Bales BL. J Phys Chem B 2004;108:3810–6. Lebedeva NV, Shahine A, Bales BL. J Phys Chem B 2005;109:19806–16. Bales BL. J Phys Chem B 2001;105:6798–804. Bales BL, Benrraou M, Tiguida K, Zana R. J Phys Chem B 2005;109:7987–97. Benrraou M, Bales BL, Zana R. J Phys Chem B 2003;107:13432–40. Bales BL, Tiguida K, Zana R. J Phys Chem B 2004;108:14948–55. Tcacenco CM, Zana R, Bales BL. J Phys Chem B 2005;109:15997–16004. Paul A, Griffiths PC, Pettersson E, Stilbs P, Bales BL, Zana R, et al. J Phys Chem B 2005;109:15775–9. Bales BL, Messina L, Vidal A, Peric M, Nascimento OR. J Phys Chem B 1998;102:10347–58. Peric M, Alves M, Bales BL. Chem Phys Lipids 2006;142:1–13. Bales BL, Howe AM, Pitt AR, Roe JA, Griffiths PC. J Phys Chem B 2000;104:264–70. Khan MN. Micellar catalysis. Surfactant science series, vol. 133. Boca Raton (FL): CRC Press; 2007. Romsted LS. Langmuir 2007;23:414–24. Carmona-Ribeiro AM. Chem Soc Rev 1992;21:209–14. Moss RA, Swarup S, Zhang H. J Am Chem Soc 1988;110:2914–9. Moss RA, Swarup S. J Org Chem 1988;53:5860–6. Blandamer MJ, Briggs B, Cullis PM, Rawlings BJ, Engberts JBFN. Phys Chem Chem Phys 2003;5:5309–12. Abuin E, Lissi E, Aravena D, Zanocco A, Macuer M. J Colloid Interface Sci 1988;122:201–8. Nascimento DB, Rapuano R, Lessa MM, Carmona-Ribeiro AM. Langmuir 1998;14:7387–91. Carmona-Ribeiro AM, Midmore BR. J Phys Chem 1992;96:3542–7. Carmona-Ribeiro AM, Hix S. J Phys Chem 1991;95:1812–7.
COLLOIDAL MEDIUM EFFECTS ON ORGANIC REACTIONS
33
62. Scarzello M, Klijn JE, Wagenaar A, Stuart MCA, Hulst R, Engberts JBFN. Langmuir 2006;22:2558–68. 63. Klijn JE, Stuart MCA, Scarzello M, Wagenaar A, Engberts JBFN. J Phys Chem B 2007;111:5204–11. 64. Raudino A. Adv Colloid Interface Sci 1995;57:229–85. 65. Laughlin RG. Colloids Surf A 1997;128:27–38. 66. Klijn JE. Catalysis in membrane mimetic reaction media, PhD Thesis, University of Groningen; 2004. 67. Herrmann U, Fendler JH. Chem Phys Lett 1979;64:270–4. 68. Hirai M, Iwase H, Hayakawa T, Koizumi M, Takahashi H. Biophys J 2003;85:1600–10. 69. Kornberg RD, McConnell HM. Biochemistry 1971;10:1111–20. 70. Herve´s P, Leis JR, Mejuto JC, Pe´rez-Juste J. Langmuir 1997;13:6633–7. 71. Carmona-Ribeiro AM, Yoshida LS, Sesso A, Chaimovich H. J Colloid Interface Sci 1984;100:433–43. 72. Lim YY, Fendler JH. J Am Chem Soc 1979;101:4023–9. 73. Moss RA, Fujita T. Tetrahedron Lett 1990;31:2377–80. 74. Moss RA, Schreck RP. J Am Chem Soc 1985;107:6634–9. 75. Moss RA, Ihara Y, Bizzigotti GO. J Am Chem Soc 1982;104:7476–8. 76. Deamer DW, Nichols JW. J Membr Biol 1989;107:91–103. 77. Deamer DW. J Bioenerg Biomembr 1987;19:457–79. 78. Deamer DW, Bramhall J. Chem Phys Lipids 1986;40:167–88. 79. Kaiser S, Hoffmann H. J Colloid Interface Sci 1996;184:1–10. 80. Nichols JW, Deamer DW. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 1980;77:2038–42. 81. Bramhall J. Biochemistry 1987;26:2848–55. 82. Bramhall J, Hofmann J, DeGuzman R, Montestruque S, Schell R. Biochemistry 1987; 26:6330–40. 83. Georgallas A, MacArthur JD, Ma XP, Nguyen CV, Palmer GR, Singer MA, et al. J Chem Phys 1986;86:7218–26. 84. Brown RE. J Cell Sci 1998;111:1–9. 85. Edidin, M. Annu Rev Biophys Biomol Struct 2003;32:257–83. 86. Dietrich C, Bagatolli LA, Volovyk ZN, Thompson NL, Levi M, Jacobson K, et al. Biophys J 2001;80:1417–28. 87. Harder T, Scheiffele P, Verkade P, Simons K. J Cell Biol 1998;141:929–42. 88. Wu SHW, McConnell HM. Biochemistry 1975;14:847–54. 89. Davidson SMK, Regen SL. Chem Rev 1997;97:1269–79. 90. Johnsson M, Engberts JBFN. J Phys Org Chem 2004;17:934–44. 91. Klijn JE, Stuart MCA, Scarzello M, Wagenaar A, Engberts JBFN. J Phys Chem B 2006;110:21694–700. 92. Klijn JE, Scarzello M, Stuart MCA, Engberts JBFN. Org Biomol Chem 2006;4:3569–70. 93. Zangi R, Engberts JBFN. J Am Chem Soc 2005;127:2272–6. 94. Alves M, Bales BL, Peric M. Biochim Biophys Acta Biomembr 2008;1778:414–22. 95. Peric M, Alves M, Bales BL. Biochim Biophys Acta Biomembr 2005;1669:116–24. 96. Bo¨cker J, Brickmann J, Bopp P. J Phys Chem 1994;98:712–7. 97. John Shelley KWMLK. Int J Quantum Chem 1990;38:103–17. 98. Bunton CA, Cowell CP. J Colloid Interface Sci 1988;122:154–62. 99. Eriksson JC, Gillberg G. Acta Chem Scand 1966;20:2019. 100. Ulmius J, Lindman B, Lindblom G, Drakenberg T. J Colloid Interface Sci 1978;65:88. 101. Gao ZS, Wasylishen RE, Kwak JCT. J Phys Chem 1989;93:2190–2. 102. Fox KK, Robb ID, Smith R. J Chem Soc Faraday Trans 1972;1:445–9. 103. Jagannathan NR, Venkateswaran K, Herring FG, Patey GN, Walker DC. J Phys Chem 1987;91:4553–5. 104. Almgren M, Grieser F, Thomas JK. J Am Chem Soc 1979;101:279–91. 105. Cang H, Brace DD, Fayer MD. J Phys Chem B 2001;105:10007–15.
34 106. 107. 108. 109. 110. 111. 112. 113. 114. 115. 116. 117. 118. 119. 120. 121. 122. 123. 124. 125. 126. 127. 128. 129. 130. 131. 132. 133. 134. 135. 136. 137. 138. 139. 140. 141. 142. 143. 144. 145. 146. 147. 148.
N.J. BUURMA Lebedeva N, Ranganathan R, Bales BL. J Phys Chem B 2007;111:5781–93. Lebedeva N, Bales BL. J Phys Chem B 2006;110:9791–9. Ranganathan R, Vautier-Giongo C, Bales BL. J Phys Chem B 2003;107:10312–8. Abuin E, Lissi E. J Colloid Interface Sci 1986;112:178. Yoshino A, Yoshida T, Okabayashi H, Kamaya H, Ueda I. J Colloid Interface Sci 1998;198:319–22. Menger FM. Acc Chem Res 1979;12:111–7. Mukerjee P, Cardinal JR, Desai NR. In: Mittal KL, editor. Micellisation, solubilisation and microemulsions. New York: Plenum; 1977. p. 241. Russell JC, Whitten DG. J Am Chem Soc 1982;104:5937–42. Bunton CA, Romsted LS, Smith HJ. J Org Chem 1978;43:4299–303. Vitha MF, Dallas AJ, Carr PW. J Phys Chem 1996;100:5050–62. Fendler JH, Patterson LK. J Phys Chem 1971;75:3907–7. Fendler JH, Patterson LK. J Phys Chem 1970;74:4608–9. Fendler JH, Fendler EJ, Infante GA, Shih PS, Patterson LK. J Am Chem Soc 1975;97:89–95. Gallivan JP, Dougherty DA. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 1999;96:9459–64. Kachel K, Asuncion-Punzalan E, London E. Biochim Biophys Acta Biomembr 1998;1374:63–76. Hawrylak BE, Marangoni DG. Can J Chem/Rev Can Chim 1999;77:1241–4. Rispens T, Engberts JBFN. J Org Chem 2002;67:7369–77. Singh J, Miller J, Ranganathan R. J Phys Chem B 2007;111:9317–24. Broxton TJ, Christie JR, Sango X. J Org Chem 1989;54:1919–22. Broxton TJ, Christie JR, Chung RPT. J Org Chem 1988;53:3081–4. Van De Langkruis GB, Engberts JBFN. J Org Chem 1984;49:4152–7. Witte FM, Engberts JBFN. J Org Chem 1985;50:4130–4. Engberts JBFN. Pure Appl Chem 1992;64:1653–60. Bartoletti A, Bartolini S, Germani R, Savelli G, Bunton CA. J Chem Soc Perkin Trans 1994;2:723–8. Romsted LS, Bunton CA, Yao JH. Curr Opin Colloid Interface Sci 1997;2:622–8. Menger FM, Portnoy CE. J Am Chem Soc 1967;89:4698–703. Martinek K, Yatsimirskii AK, Levashov AV, Berezin IV. In: Mittal KL, editor. Micellization, solubilization and microemulsions, vol. 2. New York: Plenum; 1977. pp. 489–508. Blokzijl W, Engberts JBFN. Angew Chem Int Ed 1993;32:1545–79. Tee OS, Fedortchenko AA. Can J Chem 1997;75:1434–8. Tee OS, Yazbeck OJ. Can J Chem 2000;78:1100–8. Kurz JL. J Am Chem Soc 1963;85:987–91. Kraut J. Science 1988;242:533–40. Carpenter BK. In: Allemann RK, Scrutton NS, editors. Quantum tunnelling in enzyme catalysed reactions. Cambridge: RSC Publishing; 2009. Chapter 1. Blandamer MJ, Engberts JBFN, Gleeson PT, Reis JCR. Chem Soc Rev 2005;34:440–58. Buurma NJ, Herranz AM, Engberts JBFN. J Chem Soc Perkin Trans 1999;2:113–9. Da Rocha Pereira R, Zanette D, Nome F. J Phys Chem 1990;94:356–61. Minero C, Pramauro E, Pelizzetti E. Langmuir 1988;4:101–5. Davies DM, Gillitt ND, Paradis PM. J Chem Soc Perkin Trans 1996;2:659–555. Davies DM, Foggo SJ. J Chem Soc Perkin Trans 1998;2:247–51. Romsted LS. In: Mittal KL, Lindman B, editors. Surfactants in solution. New York: Plenum; 1984. pp. 1015–68. Romsted LS. In: Mittal KL, editor. Micellization, solubilization and microemulsions. New York: Plenum; 1977. pp. 509–30. Quina FH, Chaimovich H. J Phys Chem 1979;83:1844–50. Bunton CA, Gan LH, Moffatt JR, Romsted LS, Savelll G. J Phys Chem 1981;85:4118–25.
COLLOIDAL MEDIUM EFFECTS ON ORGANIC REACTIONS 149. 150. 151. 152. 153. 154. 155. 156. 157. 158. 159. 160. 161. 162. 163. 164. 165. 166. 167. 168. 169. 170. 171. 172. 173. 174. 175. 176. 177. 178. 179. 180. 181. 182. 183. 184. 185. 186. 187. 188. 189. 190. 191. 192. 193. 194. 195.
35
Al-Lohedan H, Bunton CA. J Org Chem 1982;47:1160–6. Al-Lohedan H, Bunton CA, Romsted LS. J Phys Chem 1981;85:2123–9. Broxton TJ, Christie JR, Sango X. J Org Chem 1987;52:4814–7. Lajis NH, Khan MN. J Phys Org Chem 1998;11:209–15. Germani R, Savelli G, Romeo T, Spreti N, Cerichelli G, Bunton CA. Langmuir 1993;9:55–60. Klijn JE, Engberts JBFN. Org Biomol Chem 2004;2:1789–99. Mohammad Niyaz K, Ismail E. J Chem Soc Perkin Trans 2001;2:1346–50. Bevington PR, Robinson DK. Data reduction and error analysis for the physical sciences. 3rd ed. London: McGraw-Hill; 2003. Rispens T, Engberts JBFN. J Org Chem 2003;68:8520–8. Sadvilkar VG, Khadilkar BM, Gaikar VG. J Chem Technol Biotechnol 1995;63:33–6. Khadilkar BM, Gaikar VG, Chitnavis AA. Tetrahedron Lett 1995;36:8083–6. Khadilkar BM, Madyar VR. Org Process Res Dev 2001;5:452–5. Sadvilkar VG, Samant SD, Gaikar VG. J Chem Technol Biotechnol 1995;62:405–10. Kambo N, Pandey S, Upadhyay SK. J Dispers Sci Technol 2006;27:1113–8. Pandey E, Upadhyay SK. J Dispers Sci Technol 2006;27:213–8. Mathew DS, Gaikar VG. Ind Eng Chem Res 2005;44:434–41. Janakiraman B, Sharma MM. Chem Eng Sci 1985;40:2155–8. Chen X, Micheau JC. J Colloid Interface Sci 2002;249:172–9. Buurma NJ, Blandamer MJ, Engberts JBFN. Adv Synth Catal 2002;344:413–20. Buurma NJ. Water, a unique medium for organic reactions, PhD Thesis, University of Groningen; 2003. Kumar S, Parveen N, Kabir Ud D. J Surfactants Deterg 2005;8:109–14. Koparkar YP, Gaikar VG. J Chem Eng Data 2004;49:800–3. Tas¸ ciog˘lu S. Tetrahedron 1996;52:11113–52. Dwars T, Paetzold E, Oehme G. Angew Chem Int Ed 2005;44:7174–99. Mubofu EB, Engberts JBFN. J Phys Org Chem 2007;20:764–70. Romsted LS, Zhang J, Cuccovia IM, Politi MJ, Chaimovich H. Langmuir 2003;19:9179–90. Cuccovia IM, Da Silva IN, Chaimovich H, Romsted LS. Langmuir 1997;13:647–52. Moss RA, Dix FM, Romsted L. J Am Chem Soc 1982;104:5048–50. Loughlin JA, Romsted LS. Colloids Surf 1990;48:123–37. Soldi V, Keiper J, Romsted LS, Cuccovia IM, Chaimovich H. Langmuir 2000;16:59–71. Keiper J, Romsted LS, Yao J, Soldi V. Colloids Surf A 2000;176:53–67. Geng Y, Romsted LS, Menger F. J Am Chem Soc 2006;128:492–501. Geng Y, Romsted LS, Froehner S, Zanette D, Magid LJ, Cuccovia IM, et al. Langmuir 2005;21:562–8. Cuccovia IM, Agostinho-Neto A, Wendel CMA, Chaimovich H, Romsted LS. Langmuir 1997;13:5032–4. Romsted LS, Yao J. Langmuir 1996;12:2425–32. Romsted LS, Yao J. Langmuir 1999;15:326–36. Cuccovia IM, Romsted LS, Chaimovich H. J Colloid Interface Sci 1999;220:96–102. Reichardt C. Chem Rev 1994;94:2319–58. Grieser F, Drummond CJ. J Phys Chem 1988;92:5580–93. Rodrı´ guez A, Del Mar Graciani M, Mun˜oz M, Moya´ ML. Langmuir 2003;19:7206–13. Zachariasse KA, Van Phuc N, Kozankiewicz B. J Phys Chem 1981;85:2676–83. Tada EB, Novaki LP, El Seoud OA. Langmuir 2001;17:652–8. Tada EB, El Seoud OA. Prog Colloid Polym Sci 2002;121:101–9. Novaki LP, El Seoud OA. Phys Chem Chem Phys 1999;1:1957–64. Martins CT, Lima MS, El Seoud OA. J Phys Org Chem 2005;18:1072–85. Luchetti L. Colloids Surf A 2007;297:249–52. McHedlov-Petrossyan NO, Vodolazkaya NA, Kornienko AA, Karyakina EL, Reichardt C. Langmuir 2005;21:7090–96.
36
N.J. BUURMA
196. McHedlov-Petrossyan NO, Vodolazkaya NA, Reichardt C. Colloids Surf A 2002;205:215–29. 197. Possidonio S, Siviero F, El Seoud OA. J Phys Org Chem 1999;12:325–32. 198. E1 Seoud OA, Ruasse MF, Possidonio S. J Phys Org Chem 2001;14:526–32. 199. Bunton CA, Gillitt ND, Mhala MM, Moffatt JR. Croat Chem Acta 2001;74:559–73. 200. Brinchi L, Di Profio P, Micheli F, Germani R, Savelli G, Bunton CA. Eur J Org Chem 2001;1115–20. 201. Mun˜oz M, Rodrı´ guez A, Del Mar Graciani M, Moya´ ML. Int J Chem Kinet 2002;34:445–51. 202. Rodrı´ guez A, Mun˜oz M, Del Mar Graciani M, Chaco´n SF, Moya´ ML. Langmuir 2004;20:9945–52. 203. Rodrı´ guez A, Mun˜oz M, Del Mar Graciani M, Moya´ ML. J Colloid Interface Sci 2006;298:942–51. 204. Buurma NJ, Serena P, Blandamer MJ, Engberts JBFN. J Org Chem 2004;69:3899–906. 205. Fife TH, McMahon DM. J Am Chem Soc 1969;91:7481–5. 206. Karzijn W, Engberts JBFN. Tetrahedron Lett 1978;19:1787–90. 207. Engbersen JFJ, Engberts JBFN. J Am Chem Soc 1975;97:1563–8. 208. Angell AD, Cipiciani A, Germani R, Savelli G, Cerichelli G, Bunton CA. J Colloid Interface Sci 1988;121:42–8. 209. Chiarini M, Gillitt ND, Bunton CA. Langmuir 2002; 18:3836–42. 210. Bunton CA, Mhala MM, Moffatt JR. J Org Chem 1985;50:4921–4. 211. Bunton CA. J Phys Org Chem 2005;18:115–20. 212. Marin MAB, Nome F, Zanette D, Zucco C, Romsted LS. J Phys Chem 1995;99: 10879–10882. 213. Apperloo JJ, Streefland L, Engberts JBFN, Blandamer MJ. J Org Chem 2000;65:411–8. 214. Hol P, Streefland L, Blandamer MJ, Engberts JBFN. J Chem Soc Perkin Trans 1997;2:485–8. 215. Streefland L, Blandamer MJ, Engberts JBFN. J Am Chem Soc 1996;118:9539–44. 216. Streefland L, Blandamer MJ, Engberts JBFN. J Phys Chem 1995;99:5769–71. 217. Noordman WH, Blokzijl W, Engberts JBFN., Blandamer MJ. J Chem Soc Perkin Trans 1995;2:1411–4. 218. Noordman WH, Blokzijl W, Engberts JBFN, Blandamer MJ. J Org Chem 1993;58: 7111–4. 219. Kerstholt RPV, Engberts JBFN, Blandamer MJ. J Chem Soc Perkin Trans 1993;2:49–51. 220. Benak H, Engberts JBFN, Blandamer MJ. J Chem Soc Perkin Trans 1992;2:2035–8. 221. Engberts JBFN, Kerstholt R, Blandamer MJ. J Chem Soc Chem Commun 1991; 1230–1. 222. Blokzijl W, Engberts JBFN, Blandamer MJ. J Am Chem Soc 1990;112:1197–201. 223. Blandamer MJ, Burgess J, Engberts JBFN, Blokzijl W. Annu Rep Prog Chem Sect C: Phys Chem 1990;87:45–74. 224. Blokzijl W, Engberts JBFN, Jager J, Blandamer MJ. J Phys Chem 1987;91:6022–7. 225. Blokzijl W, Jager J, Engberts JBFN, Blandamer MJ. J Am Chem Soc 1986;108:6411–3. 226. Al-Lohedan HA, Bunton CA, Romsted LS. J Org Chem 1982;47:3528–32. 227. Blagoeva IB, Toteva MM, Ouarti N, Ruasse MF. J Org Chem 2001;66:2123–30. 228. Ouarti N, Blagoeva IB, El Seoud OA, Ruasse MF. J Phys Org Chem 2001;14:823–31. 229. Ferna´ndez A, Mun˜oz M, Del Mar Graciani M, Ferna´ndez G, Moya´ ML. New J Chem 2001;25:1084–90. 230. Yao H, Richardson DE. J Am Chem Soc 2003;125:6211–21. 231. Bosco Bharathy JR, Ganesan TK, Rajkumar E, Rajagopal S, Manimaran B, Rajendran T, et al. Tetrahedron 2005;61:4679–87. 232. Brinchi L, Di Profio P, Germani R, Savelli G, Gillitt ND, Bunton CA. J Colloid Interface Sci 2001;236:85–95. 233. Tada EB, Ouarti N, Silva PL, Blagoeva IB, El Seoud OA, Ruasse MF. Langmuir 2003;19:10666–72.
COLLOIDAL MEDIUM EFFECTS ON ORGANIC REACTIONS
37
234. Del Mar Graciani M, Rodrı´ guez A, Mun˜oz M, Moya´ ML. J Colloid Interface Sci 2001;235:260–4. 235. Rodrı´ guez A, Mun˜oz M, Del Mar Graciani M, Moya´ ML. J Colloid Interface Sci 2002;248:455–61. 236. Costas-Costas U, Bravo-Dı´ az C, Chaimovich H, Cuccovia IM. Colloids Surf A 2004;250:385–94. 237. Del Mar Graciani M, Rodrı´ guez A, Mun˜oz M, Moya´ ML. Langmuir 2002;18:3476–81. 238. Del Mar Graciani M, Rodrı´ guez A, Mun˜oz M, Moya´ ML. React Kinet Catal Lett 2003;78:113–9. 239. Brinchi L, Di Profio P, Germani R, Savelli G, Spreti N, Bunton CA. Eur J Org Chem 2000;3849–54. 240. Bonollo S, Fringuelli F, Pizzo F, Vaccaro L. Synlett 2007:2683–6. 241. Otto S, Engberts JBFN. In: Texter J, editor. Reactions and synthesis in surfactant systems. New York: Marcel Dekker Ltd.; 2001. pp. 247–63. 242. Diego-Castro MJ, Hailes HC. Chem Commun 1998;1549–50. 243. Van der Wel GK, Wijnen JW, Engberts JBFN. J Org Chem 1996;61:9001–5. 244. Nishimoto K, Kim S, Kitano Y, Tada M, Chiba K. Org Lett 2006;8:5545–7. 245. Wijnen JW, Engberts JBFN. J Org Chem 1997;62:2039–44. 246. Manabe K, Mori Y, Kobayashi S. Tetrahedron 1999;55:11203–8. 247. We focus on non-enzymatic organic reactions despite the wealth of information on bilayer-based enzymatic catalysis. 248. Moss RA, Bhattacharya S, Chatterjee S. J Am Chem Soc 1989;111:3680–7. 249. Kemp DS, Cox DD, Paul KG. J Am Chem Soc 1975;97:7312–8. 250. Casey ML, Kemp DS, Paul KG, Cox DD. J Org Chem 1973;38:2294–301. 251. Kemp DS, Casey ML. J Am Chem Soc 1973;95:6670–80. 252. Pe´rez-Juste J, Hollfelder F, Kirby AJ, Engberts JBFN. Org Lett 2000;2:127–30. 253. Bunton CA. Adv Colloid Interface Sci 2006;123–126:333–43. 254. Cabaleiro-Lago C, Garcı´ a-Rı´ o L, Herve´s P, Pe´rez-Juste J. J Phys Chem B 2006;110: 8524–30. 255. Scarpa MV, Maximiano FA, Chaimovich H, Cuccovia IA. Langmuir 2002;18:8817–23. 256. Kawamuro MK, Chaimovich H, Abuin EB, Lissi EA, Cuccovia IM. J Phys Chem 1991;95:1458–63. 257. Kemp DS, Paul KG. J Am Chem Soc 1975;97:7305–12. 258. Kemp DS, Paul K. J Am Chem Soc 1970;92:2553–4. 259. Germani R, Ponti PP, Savelli G, Spreti N, Cipiciani A, Cerichelli G, et al. J Chem Soc Perkin Trans 1989;2:1767–71. 260. Rispens, T. Cycloadditions in weakly and highly organized aqueous media, PhD Thesis, University of Groningen; 2004. 261. Rispens T, Engberts JBFN. Org Lett 2001;3:941–3. 262. Kunitake T, Okahata Y, Ando R, Shinkai S, Hirakawa SI. J Am Chem Soc 1980;102:7877–81. 263. Patel MS, Bijma K, Engberts JBFN. Langmuir 1994;10:2491–2. 264. Jongejan MGM, Klijn JE, Engberts JBFN. J Phys Org Chem 2006;19:249–56. 265. Kunitake T, Sakamoto T. Chem Lett 1979;8:1059–62. 266. Lichtenberg D, Freire E, Schmidt CF, Barenholz Y, Felgner PL, Thompson TE. Biochemistry 1981;20:3462–7. 267. Klijn JE, Engberts JBFN. Langmuir 2005;21:9809–17. 268. McBain JW. Trans Faraday Soc 1913;9:99.
Photoremovable protecting groups based on photoenolization JAGADIS SANKARANARAYANAN, SIVA MUTHUKRISHNAN and ANNA D. GUDMUNDSDOTTIR Department of Chemistry, University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati, OH 45221, USA 1 2
Introduction 39 Photoenolization 41 Photoenolization of o-alkyl arylketones 41 Photoenolization of 2-nitrotoluene 45 3 Photorelease via photoenolization 47 Photoelimination from b-substituted o-alkyl arylketones 48 Photoelimination from a-substituted o-alkyl acetophenone derivatives 54 Photorelease via photoenolization followed by intramolecular lactonization 57 Photorelease from nitrotoluene derivatives 66 4 Conclusion 72 Acknowledgments 72 References 72
1
Introduction
In the past decade, a series of useful molecular systems known as phototriggers, photoswitches, photocaging groups, or photoremovable protecting groups have been used in a wide variety of applications. Their utility has spanned a wide variety of areas, including the release of fragrances from household goods (Fig. 1), aiding in multistep syntheses, and drug and gene delivery.1–11 Photoremovable protecting groups also allow biochemists to release bioactive compounds in living tissue with both high temporal and spatial accuracy, thus making it possible to study physiological events such as enzyme activity, ion channel permeability, protein folding, and muscle contraction by ATP hydrolysis. For example, nitric oxide has only recently been shown to be involved in various bioregulatory processes, such as blood clotting, blood pressure control, and neurotransmission.12–16 Additionally, it has just been determined that macrophages, blood cells that ingest foreign substances, kill cancerous cells and intracellular parasites by releasing large amounts of nitric oxide. However, since nitric oxide is a reactive molecule, with a half-life of only a few seconds in physiological settings, it is convenient for researchers to use photoremovable protecting groups to liberate in a controlled manner nitric oxide in biological systems and investigate the resulting physiological responses.17 In the same way, photoremovable protecting groups are being developed to release nitric oxide for photodynamic therapy applications.18 39 ADVANCES IN PHYSICAL ORGANIC CHEMISTRY VOLUME 43 ISSN: 0065-3160 DOI: 10.1016/S0065-3160(08)00002-6
2009 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved
40
J. SANKARANARAYANAN ET AL. (a)
(b)
Fig. 1 Caging fragrance molecules to a photoremovable protecting group (a) and releasing the fragrance molecules by exposure to sunlight (b).
Photorelease mechanisms can be divided into two main categories: those in which directly cleave from a reactive excited state of the photoremovable protecting group and those in which the cleavage can take place from the ground state of a high-energy photoproduct that has a low-energy barrier for releasing the protected molecule. Photocleavages from excited states can result in very rapid photorelease although the formation of highly reactive radical intermediates may lead to undesirable by-products. In comparison, the efficiency of cleavage from ground state photoproducts will depend on both the structure of the molecule being released and the protecting group; this efficiency is therefore expected to be different for dissimilar groups. Detailed knowledge of the photorelease mechanism makes it easier to determine the possible shortcomings of the photoremovable protecting groups for each application. For example, knowledge of the actual release rate in physiological conditions is a prerequisite for using photoremovable protecting groups to study any time-dependent biological responses because the rate of the photorelease must exceed that of the biological response being investigated. The ideal conditions for fragrance delivery in detergents are a slow release with low quantum yields so that the scent will linger.5,19,20 In contrast, investigation of protein folding requires photoremovable protecting groups with release rates shorter than a submillisecond.21–27 At the same time, both of these applications need photoremovable protecting groups that are not quenched by molecular oxygen. The above examples represent only fractions of the photoremovable protecting groups that are being developed and used for applications; thus, it is clear that the choice of photoremovable protecting group is critical, depends on the system under investigation, and must be tailored to each application.
PHOTOREMOVABLE PROTECTING GROUPS BASED ON PHOTOENOLIZATION
41
Moreover, there is a need for new photoremovable protecting groups that can satisfy the requirements of diverse applications. Understanding mechanistic details makes it easier to select the most suitable photoremovable protecting group for each specific application and to design new photoremovable protecting groups that can be tailored to specific applications. This chapter focuses mainly on photoremovable protecting groups that rely on photoinduced intramolecular H-atom abstraction to form photoenols that then release their protected or caged molecules. However, we will also compare these photoremovable protecting groups to others that release their protected molecule by different mechanisms. The most widely used photoremovable protecting groups are o-nitrotoluene derivatives, but since this group has been reviewed recently,2,11,28–30 we will focus more on others that also rely on photoenolization to release their protected molecules. The examples in this chapter do not offer a comprehensive review of the literature but rather illustrate the mechanisms of photorelease from several photoremovable protecting groups, making it easier to determine their ability and limitations in distinct applications.
2
Photoenolization
PHOTOENOLIZATION OF o-ALKYL ARYLKETONES
Intramolecular g-hydrogen abstraction in o-alkyl phenyl ketones or o-nitrotoluenes results in the formation of photoenols, which will regenerate their starting materials and can therefore be described as a photochromic system (Scheme 1).31–36 Several photoremovable protecting groups have been designed that, on exposure to light, undergo photoenolization followed by the elimination of the caged substrate. Reketonization of the photoenols competes with the elimination of the protected substrate. Thus, for better understanding of the release mechanism from these photoremovable protecting groups, we will describe the mechanisms of photoenolization for o-alkyl arylketones and o-nitrotoluene. Several researchers have investigated the photoenolization of various o-methyl acetophenone and o-methyl benzophenone derivatives.37–41 The mechanism of photoenolization of o-methyl benzophenone, 1, has been studied with laser flash photolysis and can be described as follows (Scheme 2): Irradiating 1 forms its first H
O R
O
hν
R R
O
+
H
hν ′ or Δ Z-photoenol
Scheme 1 Photoenolization of o-alkyl arylketones.
E-photoenol
42
J. SANKARANARAYANAN ET AL.
O
O
*
O
H
hν
1
2
T1K of 1
ISC 1,5-Hydrogen shift H O O H Z-3
E-3
Scheme 2 Photoenolization of o-methyl benzophenone 1.
singlet excited state, which undergoes efficient intersystem crossing to the first excited triplet ketone (T1K) of 1.37,42–48 The lifetime of T1K of 1 has been estimated to be around 2 ns. Intramolecular H-atom abstraction quenches T1K of 1 effectively and yields biradical 2, which has a maximum absorption of around 520 nm and a lifetime of 30 ns. Biradical 2 decays by intersystem crossing to form photoenols Z-3 and E-3. In ethanol, photoenols 3 have maximum absorption at 420 nm, and E-3 and Z-3 are formed in the approximate ratio of 1:4. The ratio of the Z and E photoenols is affected somewhat by the solvent; however, the Z-photoenol is always the major product. Photoenol Z-3 decays back to 1 through a sigmatropic 1,5-H-atom shift. The lifetime of Z-3 in ethanol is between 3 and 4 ms, whereas E-3 has a much longer lifetime that has been measured to be between 3 and 7 ms in ethanol.46,47 Enol E-3 reketonizes via the aid of the solvent, and the reketonization can be facilitated with acids or bases.49 Furthermore, photolysis of 1 in CH3OD or CH3OT leads to the incorporation of deuterium or tritium atoms on the methyl group of 1 (Scheme 3), thus verifying that reketonization of E-3 is solvent-assisted.50 Enol E-3 undergoes electrocyclic ring closure to form cyclobutanol 4; however, since 4 can revert back thermally, its yields are most likely underreported.51–56 Yang and Rivas reported the first successful trapping of photoenols by using dienophiles to form Diels–Alder adducts, 5.57 The rate of trapping E-3 with dienophiles such as acetylenedicarboyxlates has been reported to be in the order of 102 M 1 s 1.39 Sammes et al. demonstrated that only the E-photoenol formed from o-methyl benzaldehyde is trapped in Diels–Alder reactions, presumably since the Z-photoenol is too short-lived to be intercepted.58 Currently, photoenols have been shown to be indispensible in organic synthesis and have been intercepted in Diels–Alder reactions to make various antitumor agents, antiretroviral agents, and natural products.59–64
PHOTOREMOVABLE PROTECTING GROUPS BASED ON PHOTOENOLIZATION
43
R R
R
R OH
Ph O
Diels–Alder
Electrocyclic ring closure
O
H
H E-3
5
4
CH3OD
CH2D O
1-d
Scheme 3 Interception of photoenol E-3.
H O
Z-7 Cyclohexane Benzene Methanol Dimethyl sulfoxide
50 ns 30 ns 2600 ns 35,000 ns
Scheme 4 Solvent dependency of the lifetime of photoenol Z-7.
Wagner and coworkers have shown that the lifetime of Z-7, formed from 2,4dimethyl benzophenone (6), is solvent-dependent (Scheme 4).37 Solvents with the ability to form H-bonding stabilize Z-7 and retard the 1,5-H-atom shift to reform 6. For example, the lifetime of Z-7 is 50 and 30 ns in cyclohexene and benzene, respectively. Conversely, the lifetime of Z-7 in methanol and dimethyl sulfoxide is increased to 2.6 and 35 ms, respectively. In comparison, Hamanoue et al. demonstrated that the lifetime of E-3 is also significantly longer in benzene and acetonitrile, at 840 and 990 ms, respectively, than in ethanol, where the lifetime of E-3 was measured to be only 3 ms.46 The authors suggested that methanol could facilitate reketonization of E-3 via double H-atom transfer through an ethanol bridge, as shown in Scheme 5.
44
J. SANKARANARAYANAN ET AL. O H
O
O H 1
E-3
Scheme 5 Proposed double H-atom transfer of E-3 in ethanol.
Photolysis of 1 in oxygen-saturated solutions yields the products displayed in Scheme 6.65 T1K of 1 is too short-lived to be quenched by the diffusion of oxygen in solution, but presumably, biradical 2 is intercepted with molecular oxygen to yield these products. It is also possible that singlet oxygen can add to E-3 to form the products in Scheme 6. However, oxygen trapping of 2 can be expected to be close to diffusion rates, whereas the trapping of E-3 is expected to be much slower and to depend on the concentration of singlet oxygen. Formation of 8 presumably comes from secondary reaction of E-3. In the same way, photolysis of 9 in oxygen-saturated solutions yields peroxide 10 (Scheme 7).58,66 The photoreactivity of o-methyl acetophenone 11 has been studied extensively;37,67–77 it is somewhat different from 1 because the singlet excited ketone (S1K) in 11 intersystem crosses to its triplet state in less than quantitative yields, as observed for 1 (Scheme 8). Thus, S1K in 11 decays by both intramolecular H-atom abstraction to form exclusively photoenol Z-13 and intersystem crossing to T1K of 11. Haag et al. estimated that T1K of 11 has a lifetime of 10 ns in benzene and decays by intramolecular H-atom abstraction to form biradical 12.37 The maximum
O
O
O
hν
O
OH O
O
O
O
O2 O
1
Scheme 6
8
Photo-oxidization of o-methyl benzophenone 1.
O
O
O
hν O2
9
Scheme 7 Photo-oxidization of 9.
10
OH
PHOTOREMOVABLE PROTECTING GROUPS BASED ON PHOTOENOLIZATION O*
O*
O
O
hν
11
Singlet excited ketone
45
H
12
Triplet ketone
ISC
1,5-Sigmatropic hydrogen shift
H
O H
O
O
H
Z-13
E-13
14
Scheme 8 Photoenolization of o-methyl acetophenone 11.
absorption of biradical 12 is 330 nm. Like biradical 2, 12 intersystem crosses to form photoenols Z-13 and E-13, which have maximum absorbance at 385 nm. In cyclohexane, Z-13 has a lifetime of 20 ns; it is longer-lived in methanol ( = 730 ns). As expected, E-13 is considerably longer-lived and has a lifetime in the order of 1 s in cyclohexane and 8 s in 2-propanol.78,79 In benzene, Z-13 and E-13 are formed in the ratio of 9:1. The major difference between the photoenolization of 1 and 11 is that, in solvents capable of H-bonding, such as methanol, 11 yields only Z-13, from its S1K. Since S1K of 11 is short-lived, presumably only a few picoseconds, it cannot undergo internal rotation to form E-13 and, thus, yields exclusively Z-13. Wirz et al. proposed that the intermolecular H-atom bonding between methanol and 11 reduces the intersystem crossing rate for S1K of 11. Thus, biradical 12 is not formed, and consequently, E-13 is not formed either.69 Wessig et al. used density functional theory to calculate the transition state for the sigmatropic 1,5-H-shift of Z-13 to reform 11; they found that this transition state is only 2 kcal/mol above the energy of Z-13,80 which explains the efficient reketonization of Z-13. In comparison, the calculated transition state for E-13 undergoing electrocyclic ring closure to form butanol 1481 is located 20 kcal/mol above E-1380 and is reflected in E-13 having a much longer lifetime than Z-13. As with photoenol E-3, the reketonization of E-13 is facilitated by acids and bases,49 and E-13 can be trapped in Diels–Alder reactions.58,82–85 For example, photoenols formed from derivatives of 11 have been used to functionalize fullerenes.86
PHOTOENOLIZATION OF 2-NITROTOLUENE
The most extensively used photoremovable protecting groups are based on o-nitrotoluene derivatives, which, on exposure to light, undergo intramolecular H-atom abstraction to form photoenols (Scheme 9), followed by the elimination of their protected or caged substrate.28,30,36,42,43,87–97
46
J. SANKARANARAYANAN ET AL. O– NO2
N
hν
15
OH
+
N
OH
E-16
+ –
O
Z-16
Scheme 9 Photoenolization of o-nitrotoluene 15.
The mechanism of photoenolization of o-nitrotoluene derivatives, studied extensively in the past, is different from the photoenolization of o-alky arylketones.98–114 For example, irradiation of 15 gives rise to a singlet excited state of 15, which has a weak absorption between 300 and 600 nm and a lifetime in the order of 10 ps.115–117 Most of the singlet excited state of 15 decays by internal conversion to the ground state of 15, and presumably, a small fraction yields photoenols 16 (Scheme 9), which have maximum absorption of around 400 nm.118 In organic solvents, this absorption decays at a biexponential rate due to different isomers of 16. For example, in dried hexane, the fast component decays with a rate constant of 1 105 s 1, and the slower one decays with a rate constant of 18 s 1. The short-lived component was designated as Z-16, which reformed 15 by a sigmatropic 1,5-H-atom shift. The ratio of Z-16 to E-16 was estimated to be between 0.4 and 1, depending on the reaction medium. Interestingly, the lifetime of Z-16 decreased in H-bonding solvents, behavior opposite to that observed for Z-photoenols formed from o-alkyl arylketones. Presumably, in polar solvents, deprotonation of Z-16 yields nitronic acid 17, which can be reprotonated to form E-16 (Scheme 10). Thus, isomerization of Z-16 into E-16 competes with its 1,5-H-atom shift to reform 15. Calculations demonstrate that Z-16 is approximately 4 kcal/mol higher in energy than E-16; thus, formation of E-16 should be favored.119 In aqueous solutions, irradiation of 15 results in the formation of a transient absorption due to 16, with max at 390 nm.98,119 This absorption band is shifted to 405 nm, indicating ionization of 16 to form 17. The rate constant for forming 17 was measured to be 2 107 s 1, whereas 17 decayed with a rate constant of 1.67 s 1. In addition, photolysis of 15 in D2O leads to deuterium incorporation at the benzylic position, thus verifying the mechanism of solvent-assisted reformation of 15 from 16.120
O– N
E-16
–
O
+
+
+
–H OH
N
H+
–
O
17
Scheme 10 Isomerization of E-16 into Z-16 via anion 17.
H+ –H+
OH N
Z-16
+
O
–
PHOTOREMOVABLE PROTECTING GROUPS BASED ON PHOTOENOLIZATION
47
The transient absorption formed from laser flash photolysis of 15 was not quenched in oxygen-saturated solutions, presumably because the photoenolization to form 16 takes place from a singlet excited state of 15. Furthermore, Schworer and Wirz did not observe any transient absorption that can be attributed to the formation of the triplet excited state of 15 from direct irradiation. In contrast, Hurley and Testa used energy transfer to estimate that the triplet excited state of 15 is formed in 67% yield,121 whereas Takezaki et al. have measured the yields for forming the triplet excited state of 15 to be slightly higher or above 80%.122 They estimated the lifetime of the lowest triplet excited state of 15 to be 350 ps in ethanol.
3
Photorelease via photoenolization
Photoremovable protecting groups that use photoenolization of o-alkyl arylketones to release their protected group or caged substrate can be categorized into two major groups. First, there are arylketones that have a good leaving group on either the o-alkyl substituent or the a-position next to the aryl ketone (Scheme 11). The leaving L
L O
O
hν R
H
O
–HL
R
R
L hν
O
–HL
L
O
O H
O O
O
L
H hν
O
O
R = Alkyl or aryl L = Leaving group
Scheme 11 Photorelease from o-alkyl arylketones.
L
O –HL
48
J. SANKARANARAYANAN ET AL.
L
O L
O
hν
NO2
H
O N
O
+
O
–L
–
NO
Scheme 12 Photorelease from o-nitrobenzyl compounds.
groups have to be stable enough on the o-alkyl arylketones that they do not cleave in the absence of light yet also good enough leaving groups on the photoenols to be liberated faster than the photoenols reketonisize to reform the starting materials. Presumably, the driving force for the elimination from the photoenols is rearomatization. The second category of photoremovable protecting groups achieves the release of the caged compound by intramolecular lactonization of the photoenol alcohol moiety with an ester group. The intramolecular lactonization also needs to be able to compete with the reketonization of the photoenols. The quantum yields for the photorelease of these systems will depend mainly on whether both the Z and the E photoenols contribute to the photorelease. The mechanism of photorelease from o-nitrotoluene derivatives is different from and more complicated than the release mechanism of the photoenols from o-alkyl arylketones (Scheme 12). The photorelease mechanism from o-nitrotoluene derivatives is strongly affected by the reaction medium and its pH value.
PHOTOELIMINATION FROM b-SUBSTITUTED o-ALKYL ARYLKETONES
Tseng and Ullman demonstrated in 1976 that substituting the b-alkyl position of the o-alkyl benzophenone with good leaving groups leads to the elimination of the b-substituent on irradiation, presumably via formation of photoenols (Scheme 13).123
L
Ph
O OH
Ph
18
L
L
hν
E-19
L = a) –OH, b) (C6H3)3CO– c) p-CH3C6H4SO3– d) p-C2H5OCOC6H4NHCO2– e) p-O2NC6H4CO2– f) N
Scheme 13 Photoelimination from 18.
+
OH
O
Ph
Z-19
Ph
20
+ LH
PHOTOREMOVABLE PROTECTING GROUPS BASED ON PHOTOENOLIZATION
49
Table 1 Quantum yields for photoelimination from 18 Reactant 18c 18d 18e 18f a
Fa 0.47 0.22 0.16 0.25
Irradiation in methanol with 254 nm light.
According to the authors, the driving force for the elimination was the rearomatization of the photoenols; thus, b-substituents that were unreactive in the benzophenone precursor could be eliminated. Tseng and Ullman studied leaving groups such as tosyl, trityl, piperidyl, and substituted carboxylic acids. They found that the quantum yields for the elimination from 18 correlated directly with leaving ability of the b-substituent from the ground state (Table 1). The authors proposed that the elimination came from photoenols 19 based on several observations. Irradiation of 18e and 1 in ether–ethanol solution at 150 K resulted in transients with maximum absorption at 400 nm, comparable to the transient absorption observed for photoenols E-3 and Z-3. The investigators noted that the transient absorbance for 19e decayed faster than that for 3. In similar experiments at room temperature, irradiation of o-ethyl benzophenone yielded a transient absorption with a maximum at 400 nm, which took minutes to decay, while irradiating 18e under identical conditions did not yield any transient absorption. Based on these findings, Tseng and Ullman concluded that the E-19 undergoes solvent-assisted reketonization but that this process is sufficiently slow to compete with b-elimination. The authors theorized that the increased quantum yield for product formation from 18 was simply due to the better leaving groups being able to eliminate from E-19 more efficiently than it reketonized or due to elimination also taking place from Z-19. In 2003, Banerjee et al. designed an efficient photoremovable protecting group for the release of carboxylic acids based on similar b-elimination from photoenols (Scheme 14).124 They showed that o-alkyl acetophenone derivatives with various ester groups in the b-position release their ester moiety in high chemical yields. The authors proposed that the photorelease took place as shown in Scheme 14 but did not support the mechanism with transient spectroscopy. Formation of 21, which is expected to be the major product in the reaction, was not confirmed, and thus, the authors speculated that 21 undergoes polymerization to yield oligomers. Sobczak and Wagner showed that o-acetylphenyl and o-benzoylphenyl acetic acids in benzene also undergo efficient decarboxylation on exposure to light (Scheme 15).125 However, the corresponding ester and amide derivatives of 22 were photostable. Furthermore, since the corresponding meta- and para-derivatives of 22 did not undergo photodecarboxylation, the authors concluded that the photorelease
50
J. SANKARANARAYANAN ET AL. OCOR′
OCOR′ O
R
OCOR′ O 3*
R
•
R
OH
hν
•
20
Triplet ketone
Biradical ISC
OCOR′
OCOR′ OH
R 1,5-H-atom shift
R +
OH
Z-Enol
E-Enol
O
R
+ R′COOH
21
Scheme 14 Photoelimination from 20.
R
R O
22
O
hν
O
+
CO2
OH
R = CH3 R = Ph
Scheme 15 Photodecarboxylation of 22.
from 22 takes place not by electron transfer but by photoenolization. The authors speculated that ester and amide derivatives of 22 are unreactive because the corresponding photoenols will be reketonized by trace impurities of carboxylic acid since decarboxylation is not possible.
PHOTOREMOVABLE PROTECTING GROUPS BASED ON PHOTOENOLIZATION
51
In comparison, photodecarboxylation of various other carboxylic acids has been studied extensively.126 For example, photodecarboxylation of 23 in water presumably involves electron transfer from the carboxylate anion to the phenyl ring (Scheme 16).126–130 The electron transfer is followed by decarboxylation to form the anion 24, which is protonated by the solvent. As shown in Scheme 16, in less polar aprotic solvents, homolytic cleavage leads to decarboxylation subsequent to charge transfer in 23. Interestingly, nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, such as ketoprofen 25 (Scheme 17), which are used to treat a wide range of ailments, such as inflammation, pain, and fever, also undergo photodecarboxylation.131–136 Unfortunately, many of these drugs have been shown to have cutaneous side effects, which are caused by their photodecomposition. Various research groups have demonstrated that irradiation of ketoprofen 25 yields 26 under anaerobic conditions, whereas in oxygen-saturated solutions, the compounds shown in Scheme 18 are formed in addition to 26.137,138 hν Water O
O
–
–
23
24
hν
•
+ •
Methanol O
O
OH
OH
23
Scheme 16 Photodecarboxylation of 23. O
O
O O –
hν
–
+
H
–CO2
O 25
26A
26
Scheme 17 Photodecarboxylation of 25.
O O
–
hν O2
25
Scheme 18 Photo-oxidation of 25.
O
O
O
O
OH
OOH
O
52
J. SANKARANARAYANAN ET AL.
Scaiano et al. used laser flash photolysis to show that irradiation of 25 forms anion 26A, which has a maximum absorption at 600 nm.139,140 Anion 26A is considered stable in anhydrous solvents but is efficiently quenched by water. Furthermore, molecular modeling done by Eriksson et al. shows that the initial excitation of 25 leads to its first excited singlet state, which intersystem crosses to a triplet excited state.141,142 Decarboxylation is presumably spontaneous from the triplet state of carboxylate anion 26A. However, several low-lying singlet excited states of 25 were also identified as being capable of undergoing decarboxylation with an activation barrier between 3 and 5 kcal/mol. The mechanism for the addition of oxygen to anion 26A to give the corresponding peroxyl radical has also been investigated.141,142 Scaiano and coworkers designed the two new photoremovable protecting groups 27 and 28, based on ketoprofen 25.139,143 Photolysis of 27 in aqueous solutions releases ibuprofen in quantum yields of 0.75 (Scheme 19). Furthermore, the rate constant for the release of ibuprofen from 27 was measured to be 5 106 s 1. Thus, 27 can release ibuprofen both rapidly and in high quantum yields. In the same way, irradiation of 28 in aqueous solutions led to efficient decarboxylation with a quantum yield of 0.67 (Scheme 20). Recently, Falvey and coworkers have designed photoremovable protecting group 29 for carboxylic acids.144–146 Irradiation of 29 releases, in quantitative chemical yields, its carboxylic acid moiety (Scheme 21). Furthermore, N-protected amino acids and phosphates can also be released from 28. Falvey et al. studied the mechanism of the photorelease from 28, which is initiated by photoinduced electron transfer.
O
COOH
O
hν
O O
O
O
HOOC
27
Ibuprofen
Scheme 19 Photoremovable protecting group (27) for ibuprofen.
O
O COO– O 28
Scheme 20 Photodecarboxylation of 28.
hν –CO2
O
PHOTOREMOVABLE PROTECTING GROUPS BASED ON PHOTOENOLIZATION O
53
O Photoinduced R
O N + ClO4–
+ Sensitizer
O
•
Electron transfer
R
•
+ Sensitizer
+
N ••
29
• O R
O
–
N +
Scheme 21 Photorelease of carboxylic acid derivatives from 29.
Kamdzhilov and Wirz reported a new photoremovable protecting group (30) that uses photoenolization for photorelease (Scheme 22).147 Since 30 is both watersoluble and absorbs light out to 400 nm, it could have potential use in biological applications. The authors measured the quantum yields for the release of bromine and diethyl phosphate anion to be 0.47 and 0.67, respectively. The mechanism of the photorelease from 30 was studied using time-resolved UV and IR spectroscopy. Laser flash photolysis of 30 in acetonitrile yields a transient absorption with max at 550 nm. The authors assigned this transient absorption to 31. Furthermore, since this transient absorption was not quenched with molecular oxygen or triplet quenchers such as piperlyne or naphthalene, Kamdzhilov and Wirz proposed that the singlet excited state of 30 underwent H-atom abstraction to form photoenol 31. The decay of photoenol 31 was biexponential, which indicates that two isomers, E-31 and Z-31, are formed. The rate constants of release from the two isomers of 31a in water were 2.13 107 and 1.57 106 s 1, respectively. Conversely, the release rate constants for 31b were somewhat lower at 3.3 104 and 1 104 s 1. As expected, both the rate of release and the quantum yields of photorelease from 30 are dependent on the structure of the leaving group.
hν L
O
O
O
O
+ L– + H+
+ L
OH
OH L
30
O
E-31
30a: L = Br 30b: L = OPO(OEt)2
Scheme 22 Photorelease from 30.
Z-31
O
54
J. SANKARANARAYANAN ET AL. H H O
C5H11
O Pr
OH
• O
Pr
C5H11
O Pr
hν
OH O H
O2 O
32
H
O
O
O •
O C5H11 OH
Scheme 23 Photorelease from 32.
Jones et al. have designed photoremovable protecting group 32 for aldehydes that is based on a somewhat similar structure to 30.148,149 The authors proposed that the photorelease from 32 was initiated by intermolecular -H-atom abstraction (Scheme 23).
PHOTOELIMINATION FROM a-SUBSTITUTED o-ALKYL ACETOPHENONE DERIVATIVES
In 1978, Bergmark determined that photorelease can also take place when the a-position of an o-methyl acetophenone has a good leaving group, such as a chlorine atom.150 He showed that photolysis of 33 in benzene resulted in the formation of 36, whereas in methanol, both 36 and 37 were formed (Scheme 24). In 1985, Bergmark followed up his earlier work with a more detailed study and showed that the elimination of a chorine atom from 33 took place in high quantum yields, especially in methanol.150 Thus, Bergmark concluded that both E-34 and Z-34 released their chlorine atoms. Additionally, he theorized that the release from Z-34 took place via solvolysis to from carbocation 35. Bergmark theorized that photosolvolysis of Z-34 in methanol resulted in the release of the chlorine atom and the formation of 35 but that release from E-34 took place in a concerted reaction to form a chlorine atom and 36. This claim was further supported by the photoreactivity of 38 (Scheme 25). Photolysis of 38 in methanol resulted in products 39, 40, 41, and 42, and Bergmark suggested that the formation of 42 came from a ‘‘photo-Favorksii’’ rearrangement, which supports the notion that products 39–42 were formed via a carbocation intermediate. Scaiano and Netto-Ferreira studied the photorelease mechanism of 33 with transient spectroscopy,151 and more recently, Wirz et al. reinvestigated the mechanism.69 It was determined that the main photoreactivity of 33 is photoenolization and that the major reactivity of 33 in methanol was not from the triplet ketone but, rather, from the singlet excited state of the ketone. Laser flash photolysis of 33 produces a transient absorption, which has a maximum around 385 nm and a lifetime of 22.5 ms. Since this transient absorption was not quenched in oxygen-saturated solutions or by the addition of a triplet quencher such as piperylene, the authors assigned it as Z-34 and proposed that it was formed directly from the singlet excited state of the ketone chromophore. The long lifetime of Z-34 was attributed to the hydrogen bonding
PHOTOREMOVABLE PROTECTING GROUPS BASED ON PHOTOENOLIZATION O
O Cl
R
hν
O
Cl
ISC
R Singlet excited ketone
33 R = H, Ch3
•
O Cl
55
Cl
•
R Triplet excited ketone
R Biradical ISC
Cl
OH Cl
1,5-H-atom shift
OH
R
R
Z-34
E-34
–Cl–
–HCl
OH O
+
O
R
O
R
36 MeOH +
OH
R
37 Cation 35 R
Scheme 24 Photoelimination from 33.
O
O
Cl
O
O
O
O O
hν Methanol
38
Scheme 25
39
40
41
42
Photolysis of 38 in methanol.
between Z-34 and the methanol solvent, which retarded the sigmatropic 1,5-H-atom shift to reform 33. The authors proposed that preassociation of methanol with the ground state of 33 through hydrogen bonding reduced the intersystem crossing rate
56
J. SANKARANARAYANAN ET AL.
constant from the singlet excited ketone in 33. Additionally, since E-34 is not formed in significant amounts in methanol and the quantum yield for forming 37 and 36 from 33 is 0.76, the photorelease must come from Z-34.150,152 In comparison, irradiation of 33 in benzene resulted in a transient spectra with max = 390 nm. The decay of transient absorption was resolved into a slow and a fast component ( = 10 ms and 225 ns), which were assigned to E-34 and Z-34, respectively. Enol Z-34 is short-lived in benzene because it reketonizes efficiently via sigmatropic 1,5-H atom shift, which is not retarded with H-atom bonding, as occurs in methanol. Addition of triplet quenchers in benzene solutions did not completely quench the formation of Z-34; thus, the authors concluded that both triplet and singlet pathways were prevalent in benzene. However, the low quantum yield, 0.11,150,152 for product formation from 33 in benzene suggests that only E-34 eliminates the chlorine atom. Klan and coworkers have studied in further detail the photorelease from 33 and compared that with photorelease from 43 and 44 (Scheme 26).153–157 Klan et al. determined that sulfonate esters and phosphonate esters are released in high quantum yields when 43 is irradiated in methanol (Table 2).69,154,156,158 In comparison, photolysis of 43 in benzene released the sulfonate and phosphonate esters in poor quantum yield. Thus, the authors proposed that the mechanism of photorelease from 43 is similar to that observed for 33.69 Klan and coworkers also measured the quantum yield for the photorelease of acids, alcohols, amines, and amino acids from 44, finding that they were released in moderate to low quantum yields in protic and aprotic solvents such as methanol, O L
32: L = Cl 43: L = Sulfonate esters or phosphonate esters 44: L = Carbonates and carbamates
Scheme 26 Photoremovable protecting groups 33, 43, and 44.
Table 2
Quantum yields for product formation from 33 and 43
Compound (L) Cl OPO2 OTS OSO2C8H17
Methanol
Benzene
0.76 0.71 0.68 0.68
0.11 0.09 0.19 0.16
PHOTOREMOVABLE PROTECTING GROUPS BASED ON PHOTOENOLIZATION Table 3
57
Quantum yields for photorelease from 44
Compound (L) OCOPh OCOCH2Ph OCOMe OCOOEt OCOOPh OCOOBn OCOODecyl OCOOGalactopyranosyl OCONHPh OCOpiperdyl
Methanol
Benzene
Cyclohexane
0.09 0.11 0.14 0.13 0.20 0.14 0.09 0.16 0.027 0.056
0.23 0.18 0.25 – – – – – – –
– – – 0.51 0.5 0.48 0.36 0.4 0.054 0.087
benzene, or cyclohexene (Table 3). The authors demonstrated that the release took place mainly via the triplet ketone in 44 and elimination from the E-photoenols of 44. The Z-photoenols formed from 44 undergo solvolysis, presumably too slowly to compete with sigmatropic 1,5-H atom shifts to reform 44. Klan et al. proposed that both alcohols and amines are initially released as carbonates and carbamates from 44; these undergo thermal decarboxylation to release CO2 and form their respective alcohols and amines.153 Furthermore, the chemical yields of the protected amine were reduced since they were involved in electron transfer reactions that decomposed 44.
PHOTORELEASE VIA LACTONIZATION
PHOTOENOLIZATION
FOLLOWED
BY
INTRAMOLECULAR
We have designed photoremovable protection groups 45, 46, and 47, which release alcohols on irradiation (Scheme 27).159–161 Ester 45 releases its alcohol independent of the reaction medium. For example, photorelease of geraniol from 45 takes place in solvents such as benzene, chloroform, toluene, and methanol (Fig. 2). Furthermore, the photorelease also takes place when thin films of ester 45 are deposited inside flasks sealed under ambient air and exposed to daylight. In oxygen- and air-saturated solutions, 45 released its alcohol moiety and formed products 49 and 48, respectively (Scheme 28). The quantum yields for forming 49 and 48 were 0.17 and 0.14, respectively.159
O
O
45
OR
O
O
OR
46
Scheme 27 Photoremovable protecting groups 45, 46, and 47.
O
O
47
OMe
58
J. SANKARANARAYANAN ET AL. 100 Toluene 2-Propanol Benzene Chloroform
% Conversion of 45
80 60 40 20 0 0
2
4 Irradiation time (hours)
6
8
Fig. 2 Photorelease from 45 in various solvents.
O
OO
O
O
hν
O
OR
O
O
hν
Argon –ROH
Oxygen –ROH 49
45
48
Scheme 28 Photorelease from 45 in oxygen- and argon-saturated solutions.
In a similar way, 46 released its alcohol moiety and formed 50 in argon-saturated solvents (Scheme 29).160 In comparison, 47 was unreactive in solvents that do not have easily abstractable H-atoms, such as benzene and chloroform. However, photolysis of 47 in solvents such as methanol, ethanol, and toluene, which have H-atoms that can easily be abstracted, released the alcohol moiety of 47 and yielded lactone 51 (Scheme 30). The quantum yield for forming 51 was 0.02 in 2-propanol. Lactone 51 must come from intermolecular H-atom abstraction of 47 from the solvent rather than intramolecular H-atom abstraction to form photoenols. O O O
O
OR hν
Argon –ROH 46
Scheme 29 Photorelease from 46 in argon-saturated solutions.
50
PHOTOREMOVABLE PROTECTING GROUPS BASED ON PHOTOENOLIZATION
O No reaction
O
OR
O
hν
hν
Argon benzene
Argon methanol –ROH 47
59
O
51
Scheme 30 Photorelease from 47 in argon-saturated benzene and methanol.
The reaction mechanism of photorelease from esters 45, 46, and 47 was determined using transient spectroscopy. The lifetime of T1K of 45 was estimated to be less than a nanosecond. T1K of 45 presumably decays by H-atom abstraction to form biradical 55 (Scheme 31), which intersystem crosses to yield Z-56 and E-56. Photoenols 56 have max at 390 nm, and their transient absorption is quenched with isoprene, verifying that they come from the T1K of 45. Enol Z-56 has a lifetime of 1300 ns in chloroform and, as expected, it is shorter-lived than E-56, which has a lifetime in the order of seconds. However, in nonhydrogen bonding solvents, Z-56 is considerably longer-lived than Z-3, presumably because it is stabilized by intramolecular H-bonding that is not possible for Z-3. This theory is further supported by the fact that the lifetime of Z-56 in solvents like methanol and 2-propanol is only increased to about 3000 ns. The ratio of E-56 and Z-56 is in the order of 1:4, and it was not affected strongly by the solvent. Since the quantum yield in the photorelease is low, or around 0.14, we concluded that only E-56 is long-lived enough to undergo intramolecular lactonization to release the alcohol moiety. Laser flash photolysis of 46 showed results similar to those obtained for 45. The lifetimes and yields of Z and E photoenols from 46 are comparable to those obtained for 56. Similarly, laser flash photolysis of 47 reveals that the major reactivity pattern of 47 is intramolecular H-atom abstraction to form Z-58 and E-58 even though no products were observed that can be attributed to the formation of photoenol 58. Laser flash photolysis of 47 in methanol showed formation of biradical 57 (max 330 nm, = 22 ns), which was efficiently quenched with oxygen (Scheme 32). Biradical 57 intersystem crosses to form Z-58 and E-58, which have maximum absorption at 400 nm. Enols Z-58 to E-58 were formed in the approximate ratio of 1:4. Enol Z-58 had a lifetime of 6.5 ms in methanol, but its lifetime in dichloromethane was only 110 ns. The measured lifetime of E-58 in methanol was 162 ms, while it was 44 ms in 2-propanol. Thus, E-58 is considerably shorter-lived than E-56. Furthermore, E-58 is also shorter-lived than the analogous E-59 (Scheme 33), which cannot decay by intramolecular lactonization and has a lifetime of 3.6 ms in methanol. Thus, we proposed that E-58 undergoes solvent-assisted reketonization that is facilitated by the intramolecular H-atom bonding, as shown in Scheme 34. Photolysis of 47 in oxygen-saturated solution yielded 60 as the major product, whereas at low conversion, 61 and 62 were the major products (Scheme 35).161 Therefore, we proposed that, in oxygen-saturated solutions, biradical 57 was trapped with oxygen to form 63, which can undergo intramolecular lactonization
60
J. SANKARANARAYANAN ET AL.
R
OR
O
O
45 hν
O
O
*
OR
1,5-H-atom shift R
Triplet excited ketone (0.08–0.8 ns)
⋅•
OR O O H
H
H O
O
OR
⋅•
ISC
O
O
OR
ISC R
R R E-56
Biradical 55 Fast O2 trapping –ROH
–ROH
O
Z-56
O OO O
O
R R 48
49
Scheme 31 Proposed mechanisms for photorelease from 45.
to release the alcohol moiety and form 61. In competition with lactonization, 63 must also undergo dehydration to form 62. Secondary photolysis of 62 results in the formation of 60, presumably via formation of ketene 64. Thus, the photooxidation of 47 is similar to that reported for 2-benzoyl-benzaldehyde and 2-methyl benzophenone.65,162 The photo-oxidization of 47 further verifies that the main
PHOTOREMOVABLE PROTECTING GROUPS BASED ON PHOTOENOLIZATION
O
O
O
*O
O
• H O O
O
hν
46
•
O Intersystem crossing
+
Intermolecular H-atom abstraction O OH
O
Z-58
57
Triplet excited state
O OH
61
O O OH
O
E-58
•
59
51
Scheme 32 Photolysis of 46.
O
O
OH
E-59
Scheme 33 Photoenol E-59.
O O
47
O H
E-58
Scheme 34 Reketonization of E-58.
reactivity of 47 is photoenolization that does not lead to any products in the absence of molecular oxygen. Furthermore, we concluded that the intramolecular lactonization of E-56 and E-58 must be a slow process and that only photoenols that are long-lived can undergo intramolecular lactonization to release their alcohol moiety faster than they reketonize.
62
J. SANKARANARAYANAN ET AL.
O
O
H
OMe
O hν
O
O
OMe
O
O
O OH
hν
O2
OMe
–H2O
OH
47
O
OMe
O
63
62
64
–MeOH O
OO
O
O
O
61
O
OMe
60
Scheme 35 Proposed mechanism for photo-oxidization of 47.
Porter et al. studied the photorelease of various alcohols from ester 65, which release their alcohol moiety and form lactones 67 and 68 in solvents with abstractable H-atoms (Scheme 36).163 They also reported that the photorelease from 65 could be initiated by electron transfer from amines. We used transient spectroscopy to elucidate the photorelease mechanisms of 65 in 2-propanol. Laser flash photolysis of 65 resulted in the formation of the triplet excited state of 65, which has a max at 330 and 530 nm. The triplet excited state of 65 decayed with a rate constant of 3 108 s 1 in 2-propanol to form radical 66. The quantum yield for photorelease from 65 was determined to be 0.62 in 2-propanol. In comparison, photoremovable protecting groups such as 69 also release their protected molecule via intramolecular lactonization, but the photorelease is initiated by cis–trans isomerization. Cis–trans isomerization has been extensively used to turn molecular switches off and on,164 but there are a few examples where cis–trans isomerization has been used to activate photorelease. Initially, Stoermer showed that photoinduced cis–trans isomerization of trans-69 yields 71, presumably via intramolecular lactonization of cis-70 (Scheme 37).165,166 In a similar way,
O
O
OR
O
O
OR
*
hν
H
O
O
OR
O Ph
–ROH
•
2-Propanol
65
Triplet excited ketone
66
O –ROH toluene
O
68
Scheme 36 Photorelease form 65.
Ph
O
O
67
O
PHOTOREMOVABLE PROTECTING GROUPS BASED ON PHOTOENOLIZATION
63
H O
O H
H O O
O
O
O
hν
H
O –H2O
cis-70
trans-69
71
Scheme 37 Photoisomerization of trans-69 and intramolecular lactonization.
O
X
O
H
X 72: X = Cl or MeO
Scheme 38
Photoremovable protecting group 72.
NH2HCl O
NH
O
Protein-OH
O O
O
H
O H
Protein hν OO H
74
–Protein–OH O Protein
O
O
75
NH2HCl
73
NH HO
Scheme 39 Photorelease from 73.
Arad-Yellin et al. and Morrison et al. demonstrated that the photolysis of trans-72 also yields 71 (Scheme 38).167,168 However, Morrison et al. reported that the quantum yield for forming lactone from trans-72 was low or less than 0.04.168 Porter et al. developed photoremovable protecting group 73, based on 69, and used it to inhibit several serine proteases such as thrombim and trypsin (Scheme 39).169 Trans-esterification between 73 and a hydroxyl group in the proteases render these enzymes inactive. However, irradiation liberated the enzymes from their protecting group and restored the enzymatic activity. Porter et al. subsequently designed other photoremovable protecting groups to inhibit serine proteases.169–171 There are several examples in the literature where similar cis–trans isomerizations of o-hydroxy cinnamic acid derivatives have been used to deliver fragrances.5 For example, ester 76, which was absorbed into cloth and exposed to sunlight, released its fragrant alcohol moiety, whereas samples that were stored in the dark did not
64
J. SANKARANARAYANAN ET AL.
(Scheme 40). Various derivatives of 76 have been used to deliver fragrances on exposure to light.172–174 Flachsmann and Bachmann designed photoremovable protecting group 77, which has to undergo hydrolysis before its fragrant alcohol moiety can be released by exposure to light (Scheme 41).173 The protection of the phenol group as a carbonate was incorporated into the photoremovable protecting group to avoid discoloration of the substrates into which 77 was absorbed on. More recently, Porter et al. investigated the photorelease of 78 absorbed on CdSe nanocrystals (Scheme 42).175 Irradiation of 78 at 374 nm under aerobic conditions released 79 and degraded the nanocrystals. Irradiating 78 on CdSe nanocrystals with visual light (78 does not absorb it, but the nanocrystals do) resulted in photorelease.
O OH
O
O
hν
O
+
HO
76
Scheme 40 Photorelease from 76.
O O
O
O
O
77 H2O OH
–CO2
O OH +
O
hν
O
O HO
Scheme 41 Hydrolysis and photolysis of 77.
PHOTOREMOVABLE PROTECTING GROUPS BASED ON PHOTOENOLIZATION
65
O S
O
n
n
CdSe-nanocrystals hν
+ N
O
N
78
O
R
HO
O
S n
n
CdSe-nanocrystals
79
R = H, Me, 4-I-PhCH2
Scheme 42 Photorelease from 78 on CdSe nanocrystals.
Thus, the authors theorized that the photorelease was initiated by electron transfer from the CdSe nanocrystal surface to 78 to form the anion of 78, which undergoes cis–trans isomerization, followed by lactonization to release 79. The authors suggested that photorelease from CdSe nanocrystals may have potential use in the areas of drug delivery and imaging. Photorelease in the solid state also has potential applications, such as surface modification and solvent-free synthesis. Thus, we have included an example of photorelease from molecular crystals. Photolysis of 80 in solution releases hydrazoic acid (Scheme 43).176 The high volatility of hydrazoic acid and its small size make it possible to use solid-state irradiation of 80 to release hydrazoic acid. The reaction mechanism has been proposed to be as follows: Irradiation of azide 80 with light above 300 nm populates the first excited state of the triplet ketone (n,*), which results in cleavage of the C—N bond. The formation of radical 81 was confirmed by laser flash photolysis in toluene, which showed formation of a transient with max at 310 nm. To verify that the azido radical formed by irradiating azide 80 abstracts an H-atom to form hydrazoic acid, crystals of 80 were placed in a Pyrex segment inserted into an argon deposition line. The glass segment of the line was irradiated while argon flowed over the crystals. The flowing argon was condensed on the matrix cold window at 14 K and monitored by IR spectroscopy. IR bands were observed at 2135 and 1146 cm 1, which match the two most intense bands reported for hydrazoic acid in argon matrices.177 1H-NMR spectra of the remaining yellow solid in the glass tube showed formation of mainly trans-82. The X-ray structure of 80 showed that it crystallizes in a conformer with the carbonyl and azido groups in a pseudosyn alignment (Fig. 3). Additionally, the crystal structure revealed that the distances from N1 to H-atoms Ha and Hb are only 2.64 and 3.35 A˚, respectively (Fig. 3). Thus, we proposed that solid-state irradiation of 80 breaks the C—N bond to form 81 and an azido radical, which abstracts a nearby H-atom on C8 and forms hydrazoic acid and trans-82.
N3
O
Ph
Ph
80
O
hν Crystals
O •
Ph
Ph
+ •N3
81
Scheme 43 Photorelease of hydrazoic acid from 80.
–HN3 Ph
Ph
82
66
J. SANKARANARAYANAN ET AL.
C5 C4
C6 C12 Hα
C3
C7
C1
C8
C2
Hβ
C13
C11
C14 C9
C10
C15
N1 01 N2
N3
Fig. 3 X-ray structure of 80.
The calculated bond dissociation energy for 80 to form 81 and the azido radical is 55 kcal/mol. Since the bond dissociation energy for breaking the C—N bond in 80 is considerably lower than the energy of its triplet ketone (74 kcal/mol), it is feasible to break the C—N bond photochemically to form an azido radical and 82. The photorelease from 80 is an example of a photorelease from an excited state and thus it is fast enough to take place in crystals.
PHOTORELEASE FROM NITROTOLUENE DERIVATIVES
Even though most commonly used photoremovable protecting groups in applications are based on o-nitrobenzyl derivatives, the mechanistic details of photorelease from nitrobenzyl derivatives were not known. Recently, Wirz et al. and Corrie et al. investigated the mechanism.178–182 The mechanism of photorelease from the photoenols formed by irradiating 2-nitrobenzoyl compounds is more complex than for o-alkyl arylketones. Wirz et al. showed that irradiating 83 yields the singlet excited state of 83, which decays by intramolecular H-atom abstraction to form 84 (Scheme 44).178,179 In acetonitrile, tautomers 84 have a broad absorption with max at 425 nm. There are four different isomers possible for 84, and density functional theory calculations predict that the E,E and E,Z isomers are the more stable ones. The initial H-atom transfer in 83 will presumably lead to the formation of Z,E-84 and Z,Z-84 where the N—OH moiety is in close proximity to the o-alkyl group. However, these isomers are several kcal/mol higher in energy than E,E-84 and E,Z-84. Photoenols 84 decay by
PHOTOREMOVABLE PROTECTING GROUPS BASED ON PHOTOENOLIZATION O
RO
R NO2
hν
O–
OR – O
+
+
N
83a: R = H 83b: R = CH3
N
OH
E,E-84
RO
OR OH
OH +
N
OH
E,Z-84
67
+
N
–
O
Z,E-84
–
O
Z,Z-84
Scheme 44 Photoenolization of 83.
HO
HO
H
R
R NO2
O
OH
–
R
+
N
hν
83
N
OH
84
R
O
OH OH
OH
NO
87
88 –H2O
a: R = H b: R = CH3
O
R
R OH N
OH
NO
–H2O
85
Scheme 45
O
86
Proposed mechanism for photoelimination of water from 83.
two competing mechanisms, leading to the formation of 85 and 87 (Scheme 45). The yields of 84 and 87 depend mainly on the reaction medium. In aprotic solvents such as hexane, 84 decays mainly to 85, which has been characterized with time-resolved IR spectroscopy. The decay of 84a obeyed a second-order rate law (k (1–2) 1010 M 1s 1) rather than biexponential decay. Thus, Wirz et al. proposed that irradiation of 84a results mainly in Z,Z-84a, which undergoes proton transfer with the aid of another Z,Z-84a molecule to form E,Z-84a. The resulting E,Z-84a consequently undergoes rapid intramolecular proton transfer to yield 85. In comparison, the decay of 84b followed a first-order rate law, but the observed rate constant increased linearly with the concentration of its precursor 83b, presumably because the H-atom shift to convert Z,Z-84b to E,Z-84b is accelerated by the precursor. Finally, 85 dehydrated to form 86. The rate constant for the dehydration of 85 is slow in hexane and was estimated to be in the order of k 1 s 1.
68
J. SANKARANARAYANAN ET AL.
In comparison, photolysis of 83 in protic solvents such as methanol, ethanol, and water yields 84 as expected, but 84 forms mainly 87 rather than 85. Furthermore, in these solvents, the transient absorption (max 425 nm) due to 84 decays not with a second-order rate law but by biexponential decay. For example, the decay of transient absorption of 84 (max 420 nm) in water at pH 7 had rate constants of 2 107 and 3 104 s 1. Subsequent to the decay of 84, a transient absorption was formed with max 330 nm and a weak absorption band at 740 nm. However, this transient was formed much slower than 84 decayed. The absorption at 330 nm was described as a biexponential growth with rate constants of 584 and 21 s 1. The authors assigned this absorption to 88. Since 84 and 88 do not form and decay at the same rate, the authors theorized that 84 decays into 87, which then furnishes 88. Even though intermediate 87 does not absorb in the near UV, the authors characterized it with time-resolved IR spectroscopy. The authors demonstrated that, in hexane and a strongly acidic or basic aqueous solution, the photorelease from 83 goes through the formation of 87, whereas in near neutral aqueous solution, formation of 85 predominates. The authors concluded that the dehydration of intermediates 85 and 88 to form 86 is the rate-determining step for the release from 83 and that the release rate is affected by the reaction medium. Wirz and coworkers also studied photorelease from o-nitrotoluene derivative 89 (Scheme 46). The authors proposed a mechanism of photorelease from these compounds that is similar to that proposed for 83. The authors demonstrated that the reaction medium, including solvent, pH, and buffer concentration, affects the rate of release (Scheme 45). For example, in methanol (pH up to 8), the rate of release from 89 is limited by the decay of 94, whereas under acid-catalyzed conditions, the reaction goes through intermediate 93. At a pH above 10, the release of methanol took place in a single step from 92. Thus, the authors concluded that the decay of 91 is not a good indicator for the rate of release of 89 since intermediates 93, 94, and 95 may be longer-lived, depending on the reaction medium. Wirz and coworkers also studied the photorelease of ATP from 89 and found that it correlated with the decay rate of 91 at pH > 6, as previously reported by Walker et al.183 However, for pH < 6, the decay of 91 exceeded the rate of formation of 86, and Wirz et al. concluded that the release of ATP went through intermediate 94. Wirz et al. also studied photorelease of glycolic acid from 96 (Scheme 47). They used spectroscopy to reinforce that the mechanism of photorelease from 96 is similar to that observed for 89. They found that the hydrolysis from 101 limits the release rate from 96 in aqueous solutions at pH 7. Additionally, they also observed that the release from 98 can be retarded by buffers. As an example, they showed that 98, in aqueous solution, was trapped intramolecularly to form 100, which had lifetimes in the order of minutes. Corrie et al. studied the photorelease of a caged sulfate from 102 and demonstrated that the mechanism of release of sulfate is, in principle, similar to that observed for 96 (Scheme 48).182 Steiner et al. designed photoremovable protecting group 103 for photolithographic in situ DNA-chip synthesis (Scheme 49).184,185 These protecting groups have a
PHOTOREMOVABLE PROTECTING GROUPS BASED ON PHOTOENOLIZATION
69
R O NO2
89 hν
R
R O
N
R
O
OH
OH
–H+
+
OH
+
N
H+
–
O
–H+
O
O– +
N
H+
O–
91
90
92 Nu = OH or base R
R O
Nu
O
O
OH N
N OH
OH
94
93
H+
–H2O
R O
OH
O
NO
R = CH3 R = ATP
95
–ROH
NO
86
Scheme 46 Proposed mechanism of photorelease from 89.
built-in triplet sensitizer, thioxanthone, that is covalently bonded to o-nitrotoluene derivatives. The thioxanthone chromophore was incorporated into the photoremovable protecting group to ensure better light sensitivity during the photorelease. Thus, irradiating 103 where the thioxanthone moiety absorbs yields its first
70
J. SANKARANARAYANAN ET AL. CO2H O
O N
– +
OH
96 hν CO2–
CO2H O
O
–
O–
O
–H+
N
OH
N
OH
H+ 98
97
O CO2H O
O O
O
–
O N
N
OH
OH 100
99 H2O
CO2H O
OH NO
101
O
OH
–H2O
NO
HO
CO2H
86
Scheme 47 Proposed mechanism for photorelease of glycolic acid from 96.
excited state, which has a (,*) configuration. The first excited state of the thioxanthone intersystem crosses to the second excited triplet state, which has a (n,*) configuration. The authors theorized that when the linker between the thioxanthone and the o-nitrotoluene is flexible and short, the energy transfer between the
PHOTOREMOVABLE PROTECTING GROUPS BASED ON PHOTOENOLIZATION
71
O
OSO3– hν
NO2
NO
+
H+
SO4–2
+
102
Scheme 48 Photorelease of sulfate from 102. O
O
NH
O N O
103
NO2
N
O O
O
S
OH
O
O
O
hν
O
O
S
NH
O*
OH
O
NO2
O
Triplet ketone Energy transfer
NH
O N
O
O O
O
S
*
OH
O
NO2
Triplet nitrotoluene
H-atom abstraction ISC
O O
NH
NH
O N
N O
O
S
+
HO
–CO2
OH
105
O
O
+
104
O
O
S
NO2
O
N
O
–
O
OH
OH
Scheme 49
Photorelease from 103.
thioxanthone and the o-nitrotoluene takes place from the triplet (n,*) of the thioxanthone. In comparison, when the linker in 103 is long or inflexible, internal conversion of the (n,*) state to the first triplet excited state of thioxanthone, which has a (,*) configuration, takes place before energy transfer to the nitrotoluene moiety. The authors theorized that the triplet state of the nitrotoluene moiety of 103 undergoes intramolecular H-atom abstraction to yield enol 104, which then cleaves to release 105. Robles and Bochet showed that nitrotoluene derivatives 106 (Scheme 50) can be used as a photoremovable protecting group for aldehydes.186 Irradiation of 106 released aldehydes in good yields, and the authors demonstrated that aldehydes such as phenylacetalaldehyde and citronellal, which are important for flavor and fragrances, are released efficiently from 106.
72
J. SANKARANARAYANAN ET AL. OAc MeO
O
R
O
hν H
MeO
R
NO2 106
Scheme 50 Photorelease of aldehydes form 106.
4
Conclusion
From the examples described in this chapter, it can be seen that the mechanisms of photoenolization has been determined for various o-alkyl arylketone and o-nitrotoluene derivatives. However, the mechanism of the release from photoenols is more complicated and has been elucidated for only some of the systems. Photoremovable protecting groups that rely on photoenolization for release all have in common low quantum yields, unless all the isomers of the photoenols release faster than they reform the starting material. Thus, there is a need to control the stereochemistry of the photoenols to favor the longer-lived E-isomers. Furthermore, it might also be possible to prevent the sigmatropic 1,5-H-atom shift from the Z-photoenols and, thus, to make them long-lived enough to release. Even though the quantum yields can be low for release from photoenols, it is an added benefit that the photoenols decay back to the starting material rather than form undesired by-products. The rate constants of release for the photoenols depend on the structure of the leaving group as well as the photoenols; these rate constants have been measured to be anywhere from a few ms 1 to a s 1. The rate of the release is also affected by the reaction medium, such as the solvent, pH value of the solvent, and the presence of oxygen. However, there is still immense opportunity to design new photoremovable protecting groups, especially those where the rate of release from photoenols can be effectively controlled.
Acknowledgments We thank our collaborators, Professor Cornelia Bohne, and Tamara Pace at the University of Victoria, and Dr. Jana Pika at Firmenich for valuable discussions while preparing this manuscript. We also express our gratitude to Dr. Kristinn Kristinsson for his technical and pedagogical support that made it possible to prepare this chapter. We also thank ACS-PRF for their support.
References 1. Mayer G, Heckel A. Angew Chem Int Ed 2006;45:4900–21. 2. Pelliccioli AP, Wirz J. Photochem Photobiol Sci 2002;1:441–58. 3. Goeldner M, Givens R, editors. Dynamic studies in biology. Weinheim: Wiley-VCH; 2005.
PHOTOREMOVABLE PROTECTING GROUPS BASED ON PHOTOENOLIZATION
73
4. Ellis-Davies GCR. Nat Methods 2007;4:619–28. 5. Herrmann A. Angew Chem Int Ed 2007;46:5836–63. 6. Pincock JA. CRC handbook of organic photochemistry and photobiology. 2nd ed. 2004; pp. 66/1–17. 7. Conrad PG, II, Chavli RV, Givens RS. Methods Mol Biol 2007;356:253–65. 8. Bochet CG. Pure Appl Chem 2006;78:241–7. 9. Bochet CG. Adv Org Synth 2005;1:3–23. 10. Young DD, Deiters A. Org Biomol Chem 2007;5:999–1005. 11. Bochet CG. J Chem Soc Perkin Trans 1 2002;125–42. 12. Pavlos CM, Xu H, Toscano JP. In: Goeldner M, Givens R, editors. Dynamic studies in biology. Weinheim: Wiley-VCH; 2005. pp. 178–205. 13. Miranda KM, Nagasawa HT, Toscano JP. Curr Top Med Chem 2005;5:649–64. 14. Furchgott RF. Angew Chem Int Ed 1999;38:1870–80. 15. Ignarro LJ. Angew Chem Int Ed 1999;38:1882–92. 16. Murad F. Angew Chem Int Ed 1999;38:1856–68. 17. Thomas DD, Liu X, Kantrow SP, Lancaster JR, Jr. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 2001;98:355–60. 18. Hofseth LJ, Hussain SP, Wogan GN, Harris CC. Free Radical Biol Med 2003;34:955–68. 19. Pika J, Herrmann A, Vial C. (Firmenich S.A., Switz.). WO, 1999. p. 75. 20. Levrand B, Herrmann, A. Flavour Fragrance J 2006;21:400–9. 21. Zhu Y, Wang T, Gai F. In: Goeldner M, Givens R, editors. Dynamic studies in biology. Weinheim: Wiley-VCH; 2005. pp. 461–78. 22. Hansen KC, Rock RS, Larsen RW, Chan SI. J Am Chem Soc 2000;122:11567–8. 23. Huang C-Y, Klemke JW, Getahun Z, DeGrado WF, Gai F.J Am Chem Soc 2001;123:9235–8. 24. Jones CM, Henry ER, Hu Y, Chan CK, Luck SD, Bhuyan A et al. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 1993;90:11860–4. 25. Volk M, Kholodenko Y, Lu HSM, Gooding EA, DeGrado WF, Hochstrasser RM. J Phys Chem B 1997;101:8607–16. 26. Wittung-Stafshede P, Lee JC, Winkler JR, Gray HB. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 1999;96:6587–90. 27. Kumita JR, Smart OS, Woolley GA. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 2000;97:3803–8. 28. Corrie, JET. In: Goeldner M, Givens R, editors. Dynamic studies in biology. Weinheim: Wiley-VCH; 2005; pp. 1–28. 29. Givens RS, Yousef AL. In: Goeldner M, Givens R, editors. Dynamic studies in biology. Weinheim: Wiley-VCH; 2005. pp. 55–75. 30. Givens RS, Kotala MB, Lee J-I. In: Goeldner M, Givens R, editors. Dynamic studies in biology. Weinheim: Wiley-VCH; 2005. pp. 95–129. 31. Sammes PG. Tetrahedron 1976;32:405–22. 32. Wagner P, Park BS. Org Photochem 1991;11:227–366. 33. Collie JN. J Chem Soc Trans 1904;85:971–80. 34. Huffman KR, Loy M, Ullman EF. J Am Chem Soc 1965;5417–23. 35. Wettermark G. Nature 1962;194:677. 36. Margerum JD. J Am Chem Soc 1965:87:3772–3. 37. Haag R, Wirz J, Wagner P. J Helv Chim Acta 1977;60:2595–607. 38. Scaiano JC. Acc Chem Res 1982;15:252–8. 39. Porter G, Tchir MF. J Chem Soc A 1971;23:3772–7. 40. Porter G, Tchir MF. J Chem Soc D 1970;20:1372–3. 41. Takahashi Y, Miyamoto K, Sakai K, Ikeda H, Miyashi T, Ito Y, et al. Tetrahedron Lett 1996;37:5547–50. 42. Ujiie K, Kikuchi K, Kokubun H. Chem Lett 1977;5:499–502. 43. Ujiie K, Kikuchi K, Kokubun H. J Photochem 1979;10:145–57.
74
J. SANKARANARAYANAN ET AL.
44. Nakayama T, Hamanoue K, Hidaka T, Okamoto M, Teranishi H.J Photochem 1984;24:71–8. 45. Ishida A, Yamamoto K, Takamuku, S. Bull Chem Soc Jpn 1992;65:3186–8. 46. Nakayama T, Torii Y, Nagahara T, Hamanoue K.J Photochem Photobiol A 1998;119: 1–7. 47. Suzuki T, Omori T, Ichimura T. J Phys Chem A 2000;104:11671–6. 48. Suzuki T, Ichimura T. Anal Sci 2001;17:s23–5. 49. Scaiano JC, Wintgens V, Netto-Ferreira JC. Tetrahedron Lett 1992;33:5905–8. 50. Michalak J, Wolszczak M, Gebicki J. J Phys Org Chem 1993;6:465–70. 51. Wilson RM, Hannemann K, Peters K, Peters EM. J Am Chem Soc 1987;109:4741–3. 52. Wilson RM, Hannemann K, Heineman WR, Kirchhoff JR. J Am Chem Soc 1987;109:4743–5. 53. Horner L, Subramanian PV, Eiben K. Justus Liebigs Ann Chem 1968;714:91–111. 54. Arnold BJ, Sammes PG. J Chem Soc Chem Commun 1972;18:1034–5. 55. Arnold BJ, Sammes PG, Wallace TW. J Chem Soc Perkin Trans 1 1974;3:415–20. 56. Tripathy S, Reddy R, Durst, T. Can J Chem 2003;81:997–1002. 57. Yang NC, Rivas C. J Am Chem Soc 1961;83:2213. 58. Arnold BJ, Mellows SM, Sammes PG, Wallace TW. J Chem Soc Perkin Trans 1 1974;3:401–9. 59. Moorthy JN, Mal P, Singhal NVP, Malik R, Venugopalan P. J Org Chem 2004;69:8459. 60. Kraus GA, Zhao G. J Org Chem 1996;61:2770–3. 61. Nicolaou KC, Gray D, Tae J. Angew Chem Int Ed 2001;40:3679–83. 62. Nicolaou KC, Gray D, Tae J. Angew Chem Int Ed 2001;40:3675–8. 63. Nicolaou KC, Gray DLF. J Am Chem Soc 2004;126:607–12. 64. Nicolaou KC, Gray DLF, Tae J. J Am Chem Soc 2004;126:613–27. 65. Pfau M, Molnar J, Heindel ND. Bull Soc Chim Fr 1983;5–6:164–9. 66. Yates P, Mackay AC, Garneau FX. Tetrahedron Lett 1968;52:5389–92. 67. Small RD, Scaiano JC. J Am Chem Soc 1977;99:7713–4. 68. Das PK, Encinas MV, Small RD, Scaiano JC. J Am Chem Soc 1979;101:6965–70. 69. Pelliccioli AP, Klan P, Zabadal M, Wirz J. J Am Chem Soc 2001;123:7931–2. 70. Grellmann KH, Weller H, Tauer E. Chem Phys Lett 1983;95:195–9. 71. Siebrand W, Wildman TA, Zgierski MZ. J Am Chem Soc 1984;106:4089–96. 72. Lami A. Chem Phys 1987;115:399–404. 73. Marcinek A, Michalak J, Rogowski J, Tang W, Bally T, Gebicki J. J Chem Soc Perkin Trans 2 1992;8:1353–7. 74. Wagner PJ, Sobczak M, Park B-S. J Am Chem Soc 1998;120:2488–9. 75. Iida K, Saito M, Yoshioka M. J Org Chem 2000;65:4909–12. 76. Wagner PJ, Chen CP. J Am Chem Soc 1976;98:239–41. 77. Das PK, Scaiano JC. J Photochem 1980;12:85–90. 78. Lutz H, Breheret E, Lindqvist L. J Chem Soc Faraday Trans 1 1973;69:2096–102. 79. Findlay DM, Tchir MF. J Chem Soc Faraday Trans 1 1976;72:1096–100. 80. Wessig P, Glombitza C, Mueller G, Teubner J. J Org Chem 2004;69:7582–91. 81. Wagner PJ, Subrahmanyam D, Park BS. J Am Chem Soc 1991;113:709–10. 82. Tsuno T, Sugiyama K. Heterocycles 1991;32:1989–2004. 83. Tsuno T, Sugiyama K. Heterocycles 1994;38:859–76. 84. Tsuno T, Sugiyama K. Trends Heterocycl Chem 2001;7:91–106. 85. Connors R, Durst T. Tetrahedron Lett 1992;33:7277–80. 86. Nakamura Y, O-Kawa K, Minami S, Ogawa T, Tobita S, Nishimura J. J Org Chem 2002;67:1247–52. 87. Pelliccioli AP, Wirz J. Photochem Photobiol Sci 2002;1:441–58. 88. Pirrung MC, Rana VS. In: Goeldner M, Givens R, editors. Dynamic studies in biology. Weinheim: Wiley-VCH; 2005. pp. 341–68. 89. Wettermark G. Nature 1962;194:677.
PHOTOREMOVABLE PROTECTING GROUPS BASED ON PHOTOENOLIZATION
75
90. Gebicki J, Marcinek A, Michalak J, Rogowski J, Bally T, Tang W. J Mol Struct 1992;275:249–55. 91. Chen PC, Wu CW. Theochem 1995;357:87–95. 92. Michalak J, Bally T, Gebicki J. Radiat Phys Chem 1995;45:749–51. 93. Khrapkovskii GM, Shamov AG, Shamov GA, Shlyapochnikov VA. Russ J Org Chem 1999;35:866–76. 94. Machacek V, Lycka A, Kavalek J. Magn Reson Chem 2000;38:1001–4. 95. Dunkin IR, Gebicki J, Kiszka M, Sanin-Leira D. J Chem Soc Perkin Trans 2 2001;8:1414–25. 96. Il’ichev YV. J Phys Chem A 2003;107:10159–70. 97. Blanc A, Bochet CG. J Am Chem Soc 2004;126:7174–5. 98. Wettermark G. J Phys Chem 1962;66:2560–2. 99. Wettermark G. J Am Chem Soc 1962;84:3658–61. 100. Wettermark G, Black E, Dogliotti L. Photochem Photobiol 1965;4:229–39. 101. Langmuir ME, Dogliotti L, Black ED, Wettermark G. J Amer Chem Soc 1969; 91:2204–7. 102. Lin M-F, Lee YT, Ni C-K, Xu S, Lin MC. J Chem Phys 2007;126:064310/1–11. 103. Kosmidis C, Marshall A, Clark A, Deas RM, Ledingham KWD, Singhal RP. Rapid Commun Mass Spectrom 1994;8:607–14. 104. Marshall A, Clark A, Deas RM, Kosmidis C, Ledingham KWD, Peng W, et al. Analyst 1994;119:1719–24. 105. Kumar S, Davis AP. Water Environ Res 1997;69:1238–45. 106. Smith DF, McIver CD, Kleindienst TE. J Atmos Chem 1998;30:209–28. 107. Castle KJ, Abbott JE, Peng X, Kong W. J Phys Chem A 2000;104:10419–25. 108. Corrie JET, Gilbert BC, Munasinghe VRN, Whitwood AC. Perkin 2 2000;12:2483–91. 109. Ghaly MY, Hartel G, Mayer R, Haseneder R. Ozone: Sci Eng 2001;23:127–38. 110. Shariq Vohra M, Tanaka K. Water Res 2001;36:59–64. 111. Abbott JE, Peng X, Kong W. J Chem Phys 2002;117:8670–75. 112. Diehl CA, Jafvert CT, Marley KA, Larson RA. Chemosphere 2002;46:553–60. 113. Weickhardt C, Tonnies K. Rapid Commun Mass Spectrom 2002;16:442–6. 114. Chen W-S, Juan C-N, Wei K-M. J Hazard Mater 2007;147:97–104. 115. Yip RW, Wen YX, Gravel D, Giasson R, Sharma DK. J Phys Chem 1991;95:6078–81. 116. Yip RW, Sharma DK, Giasson R, Gravel D. J Phys Chem 1985;89:5328–30. 117. Yip RW, Sharma DK, Giasson R, Gravel D. J Phys Chem 1984;88:5770–2. 118. Schworer M, Wirz J. Helv Chim Acta 2001;84:1441–58. 119. Il’ichev YV, Wirz J. J Phys Chem A 2000;104:7856–70. 120. Morrison H, Migdalof BH. J Org Chem 1965;30:3996. 121. Hurley R, Testa AC. J Am Chem Soc 1968;90:1949–52. 122. Takezaki M, Hirota N, Terazima M. J Phys Chem A 1997;101:3443–8. 123. Tseng S-S, Ullman EF. J Am Chem Soc 1976;98:541–4. 124. Atemnkeng WN, Louisiana LD, Yong PK, Vottero B, Banerjee A. Org Lett 2003;5: 4469–71. 125. Sobczak M, Wagner P. J Org Lett 2002;4:379–82. 126. Budac D, Wan P. J Photochem Photobiol A 1992;67:135–66. 127. Meiggs TO, Grossweiner LI, Miller SI. J Am Chem Soc 1972;94:7981–6. 128. Epling GA, Lopes A. J Am Chem Soc 1977;99:2700–4. 129. Grossweiner LI, Joschek HI. Adv Chem Ser 1965;50:279–88. 130. Zwicker EF, Grossweiner LI, Yang NC. J Am Chem Soc 1963;85:2671–2. 131. Kochevar IE, Hoover KW, Gawienowski M. J Invest Dermatol 1984;82:214–18. 132. Navaratnam S, Hughes JL, Parsons BJ, Phillips GO. Photochem Photobiol 1985;41: 375–80. 133. Encinas S, Bosca F, Miranda MA. Chem Res Toxicol 1998;11:946–52. 134. Encinas S, Miranda MA, Marconi G, Monti S. Photochem Photobiol 1998;67:420–5.
76
J. SANKARANARAYANAN ET AL.
135. Bosca F, Marin ML, Miranda MA. In: Horspool W, Lenci F, editors. CRC handbook of organic photochemistry and photobiology. 2nd ed. Boca Raton: CRC Press; 2004. pp. 64/1–10. 136. Miranda MA, Morera I, Vargas F, Gomez-Lechon MJ, Castell JV. Toxicol In Vitro 1991;5:451–5. 137. Bosca F, Miranda MA, Carganico G, Mauleon D. Photochem Photobiol 1994;60:96– 101. 138. Costanzo LL, De Guidi G, Condorelli G, Cambria A, Fama M. Photochem Photobiol 1989;50:359–65. 139. Lukeman M, Scaiano JC. J Am Chem Soc 2005;127:7698–9. 140. Laferriere M, Sanrame CN, Scaiano JC. Org Lett 2004;6:873–5. 141. Musa KAK, Matxain JM, Eriksson LA. J Med Chem 2007;50:1735–43. 142. Musa KAK, Eriksson LA. J Phys Chem B 2007;111:13345–52. 143. Blake JA, Gagnon E, Lukeman M, Scaiano JC. Org Lett 2006;8:1057–60. 144. Sundararajan C, Falvey DE. J Am Chem Soc 2005;127:8000–1. 145. Sundararajan C, Falvey DE. Org Lett 2005;7:2631–34. 146. Sundararajan C, Falvey DE. Photochem Photobiol Sci 2006;5:116–21. 147. Kamdzhilov Y, Wirz J. Photochem Photobiol Sci 2007;6:865–72. 148. Brinson RG, Jones PB. Org Lett 2004;6:3767–70. 149. Brinson RG, Hubbard SC, Zuidema DR, Jones PB. J Photochem Photobiol A 2005;175:118–28. 150. Bergmark WR, Barnes C, Clark J, Paparian S, Marynowski S.J Org Chem 1985;50: 5612–15. 151. Netto-Ferreira JC, Scaiano JC. J Am Chem Soc 1991;113:5800–3. 152. Bergmark WR. J Chem Soc Chem Commun 1978;61–2. 153. Kammari L, Plistil L, Wirz J, Klan P. Photochem Photobiol Sci 2007;6:50–6. 154. Klan P, Paola Pelliccioli A, Pospisil T, Wirz J. Photochem Photobiol Sci 2002;1:920–3. 155. Literak J, Wirz J, Klan P. Photochem Photobiol Sci 2005;4:43–6. 156. Zabadal M, Pelliccioli AP, Klan P, Wirz J. J Phys Chem A 2001;105:10329–33. 157. Klan P, Zabadal M, Heger D. Org Lett 2000;2:1569–71. 158. Literik J, Relich S, Kulhanek P, Klan P. Mol Diversity 2003;7:265–71. 159. Pika J, Konosonoks A, Robinson RM, Singh PND, Gudmundsdottir AD. J Org Chem 2003;68:1964–72. 160. Pika J, Konosonoks A, Singh P, Gudmundsdottir AD. Spectrum 2003;16:12–7. 161. Konosonoks A, Wright PJ, Tsao M-L, Pika J, Novak K, Mandel SM, et al. J Org Chem 2005;70:2763–70. 162. Netto-Ferreira JC, Scaiano JC. Can J Chem 1993;71:1209–15. 163. Jones PB, Pollastri MP, Porter NA. J Org Chem 1996;61:9455–61. 164. Mayer G, Heckel A. Angew Chem Int Ed 2006;45:4900–21. 165. Stoermer R. Ber Dtsch Chem Ges 1910;42:4865–71. 166. Stoermer R, Friemel C. Ber Dtsch Chem Ges 1911;44:1838–53. 167. Arad-Yellin R, Green BS, Muszkat KA. J Chem Soc Chem Commun 1976;14–5. 168. Terrian DL, Mohammad T, Morrison H. J Org Chem 1995;60:1981–4. 169. Turner AD, Pizzo SV, Rozakis G, Porter NA. J Am Chem Soc 1988;110:244–50. 170. Porter NA, Bruhnke JD. J Am Chem Soc 1989;111:7616–18. 171. Porter NA, Thuring JW, Li H. J Am Chem Soc 1999;121:7716–7. 172. Anderson D, Frater G, Kumli F. (Givaudan Roure (International) S.A., Switz.). EP, 1999. p. 31 173. Flachsmann F, Bachmann J-P. (Givaudan S.A., Switz.). WO, 2005. p. 45 174. Anderson D, Frater G. (Givaudan Roure (International) S.A., Switz.). EP, 1999. p. 16. 175. Wijtmans M, Rosenthal SJ, Zwanenburg B, Porter NA. J Am Chem Soc 2006;128:11720–6. 176. Klima RF, Jadhav AV, Singh PND, Chang M, Vanos C, Sankaranarayanan J, et al. J Org Chem 2007;72:6372–81.
PHOTOREMOVABLE PROTECTING GROUPS BASED ON PHOTOENOLIZATION
77
177. Himmel H-J, Junker M, Schnockel H. J Chem Phys 2002;117:3321–6. 178. Gaplovsky M, Il’ichev YV, Kamdzhilov Y, Kombarova SV, Mac M, Schwoerer MA, et al. Photochem Photobiol Sci 2005;4:33–42. 179. Il’ichev YV, Schwoerer MA, Wirz J. J Am Chem Soc 2004;126:4581–95. 180. Corrie JET, Barth A, Munasinghe VRN, Trentham DR, Hutter MC. J Am Chem Soc 2003;125:8546–54. 181. Hellrung B, Kamdzhilov Y, Schwoerer M, Wirz J. J Am Chem Soc 2005;127:8934–5. 182. Abbruzzetti S, Sottini S, Viappiani C, Corrie JET. J Am Chem Soc 2005;127:9865–74. 183. Walker JW, Reid GP, McCray JA, Trentham DR. J Am Chem Soc 1988;110:7170–7. 184. Woell D, Smirnova J, Pfleiderer W, Steiner UE. Angew Chem Int Ed 2006;45:2975–8. 185. Woell D, Laimgruber S, Galetskaya M, Smirnova J, Pfleiderer W, Heinz B, et al. J Am Chem Soc 2007;129:12148–58. 186. Lage Robles J, Bochet CG. Org Lett 2005;7:3545–7.
The chemistry of reactive radical intermediates in combustion and the atmosphere CARRIGAN J. HAYES,a JOHN K. MERLEb and CHRISTOPHER M. HADADa a
Department of Chemistry, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH 43210, USA Department of Chemistry, Winston-Salem State University, Winston-Salem, NC 27110, USA
b
1 2
Introduction 79 Basic concepts of combustion chemistry 80 Free radicals 80 Combustion at different temperatures 81 Methods for studying reactive combustion species 87 3 Reactive radical intermediates in combustion chemistry 91 Aliphatic systems 91 Aromatic systems 98 4 Future challenges in combustion chemistry 121 Fuel additives 122 Biodiesel 123 5 Conclusions 125 Acknowledgments 126 References 126
1
Introduction
Combustion processes convert chemical energy into heat and work, playing several important roles in today’s society. Oxidation processes provide power to beneficiaries ranging from automobiles to electrical generators; atmospheric oxidation reactions impact a wide range of environmental phenomena (i.e., ozone formation, photochemical smog, and acid rain). To fully understand combustion chemistry, it is necessary to understand the properties of the common reactive intermediates that participate in these reactions. Alkyl radicals (R•), alkoxy radicals (RO•), and peroxy radicals (ROO•) constitute the main classes of reactive radical intermediates involved in combustion. The occurrence and stability of the intermediates is governed by the temperature and pressure at which combustion (or oxidation) class takes place. Understanding these complex and dynamic relationships presents challenges for experimentalists and also for theorists. This review will first examine the fundamental chemistry that occurs during combustion of a fuel and then move into an exploration of some key classes of reactive intermediates. In particular, we will focus on the importance of reactive oxygen species (ROS) to combustion processes, highlighting our work on the unimolecular dissociative pathways available to the peroxy radicals of alkyl, aromatic, and heteroaromatic compounds. 79 ADVANCES IN PHYSICAL ORGANIC CHEMISTRY VOLUME 43 ISSN: 0065-3160 DOI: 10.1016/S0065-3160(08)00003-8
2009 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved
80
2
C.J. HAYES ET AL.
Basic concepts of combustion chemistry
FREE RADICALS
Any type of combustion chemistry is essentially dictated by the radical intermediates present. Before discussing how this occurs, it is first instructive to review some key aspects of radical chemistry. Most simply, free radicals are molecules with unpaired electrons. The lifetimes of these species vary widely given molecular composition and reaction environment, but the alkyl radicals of interest in combustion chemistry are highly reactive and thus short-lived. Radicals can vary in their hybridization (sp3, sp2, or sp), as well as the nature of the orbital in which their unpaired electron is placed (one dominated by s or p character); these orbital characteristics dictate the geometry around the radical center. Substituents (or functional groups) play a large role in stabilizing or destabilizing radicals. A free radical is stabilized by alkyl substituents on the radical center; tertiary radicals are more stable than secondary radicals, which are correspondingly more stable than primary radicals. Resonance stabilization (electron delocalization) also plays a role in radical stability: a radical adjacent to a p network (i.e., an allylic or benzylic system, or a carbonyl functionality) can delocalize the unpaired electron through this system and gain stability. Finally, inductive effects caused by an electronegative atom such as chlorine or a functionalized alkyl chain can affect radical stability. A radical is an odd-electron molecule, due to an unpaired electron, which can be oriented either spin-up (") or spin-down (#), leading to two degenerate electronic states as a doublet. The unpaired electron enables reactions that are different from those of closed-shell molecules. The basic steps of a radical chain reaction are familiar from undergraduate organic chemistry: initiation, whereby a reactive radical species forms; propagation, the processes by which the newly-formed radicals react with other molecular species to generate other radicals; and termination, via the collision of any two radical species to form one closed-shell molecule, thereby removing radicals from the system. Initiation can occur either thermolytically (when heat homolytically breaks a molecule’s bond) or photolytically (when high-energy light homolytically breaks a molecule’s bond). Once a radical forms, it can undergo a variety of propagation reactions, including hydrogen atom transfers, eliminations, additions, and unimolecular fragmentations; any reaction step that begins with a radical reactant and yields a radical product is classified as a chain-propagating step. Often, in flame chemistry, a reactive hydroxyl (HO•) radical is first formed, which then reacts with the fuel molecule via an initiation step (R—H þ HO• ! R• þ H2O). The ensuing variety of propagation possibilities constitute much of the chemistry of interest in combustion processes; this topic will be revisited shortly. Bond dissociation enthalpies (BDEs) aid in predicting relative reactivities for different organic (fuel) molecules. BDEs correspond to the enthalpy change for the homolytic cleavage of a chemical bond. The more stable the resulting radical is, relative to the reactant, the more favorable it is for the bond to break. General explanations for radical stability include alkyl substitution and resonance effects (as noted above). Additionally, Gronert has recently summarized work leading to an alternative explanation, that the
THE CHEMISTRY OF REACTIVE RADICAL INTERMEDIATES
81
potential for release of 1,3 repulsive energy (strain) has the greatest effect on these quantities: that is, a tertiary radical is more stable than a primary radical not because of the larger number of alkyl substituents attached to the radical center, but because of the greater magnitude of the geminal interactions in the parent (more congested) hydrocarbons that are relieved upon C—H bond cleavage to form the radical.1 Regardless of the origin of the effect, these BDE quantities are useful in rationalizing initiation steps for given fuels. Free radicals are involved in a wide variety of reactions, due to their reactivity and versatility; understanding their behavior as it relates to combustion is a goal of many experimentalists and theoreticians. Two specific classes of radicals of interest to combustion processes are peroxy (ROO•) radicals and oxy (RO•) radicals; along with hydroxyl (HO•) radical, many of these radicals are important members in the general class referred to as reactive oxygen species (ROS).2
COMBUSTION AT DIFFERENT TEMPERATURES
The concept behind combustion is straightforward – when a hydrocarbon fuel reacts with oxygen, the organic component is eventually converted to carbon dioxide and water – but the reality is more complicated. For instance, the combustion of methane (Reaction 1) is often used to teach students how to balance reaction equations: CH4 þ 2O2 ! CO2 þ 2H2O
ð1Þ
However, the combustion process for methane requires no fewer than 325 individual mechanistic steps (elementary reactions) to be accurately described, rather than the one-step route shown above.3 As such, incomplete combustion is a common occurrence and ROS are pervasive byproducts of that phenomenon, affecting an engine’s fuel efficiency and producing atmospherically detrimental emissions. Moreover, combustion varies with system temperature, as different oxidative pathways become accessible, as well as fuel/oxidizer ratio (equivalence ratio). By examining the representative cases of methane oxidation at high and low temperatures, this phenomenon becomes clearer. High-temperature combustion At high temperatures (as a general rule, T >1000 K), methane oxidation4 is initiated via hydrogen atom abstraction by hydroxyl radical, oxygen atom, or hydrogen atom (all of which are species generated in flames, oxygen to the smallest extent). Subsequently, in the most direct oxidative route (Fig. 1), methyl radical is oxidized to formaldehyde, which then loses a hydrogen atom to form formyl (HCO•) radical. Formyl radical can subsequently lose a hydrogen atom via collisional dissociation or reaction with molecular oxygen, thereby forming carbon monoxide (CO). A final oxidation step via the reaction of CO with hydroxyl radical yields the fully oxidized carbon dioxide as a final product. To more completely characterize the overall methane combustion mechanism,
82
C.J. HAYES ET AL.
Fig. 1 High-temperature methane combustion. Adapted from Reference 7.
additional reactions such as methyl radical recombination and hydrocarbon eliminations, as well as ethene and acetylene oxidations, must also be considered. In this basic scenario, methyl, methoxy, and formyl radicals are intermediates of great interest; extending beyond this most straightforward case, the reactions of alkyl, alkenyl, alkynyl, alkoxy, and aldehydic radicals are all reactive intermediates of interest in high-temperature fuel combustion. Low-temperature combustion The low-temperature oxidation of methane (as a general rule, T < 1000 K) requires a more complex reaction scheme (Fig. 2). In reality, low-temperature oxidation of methane is unlikely to proceed readily, due to its substantial C—H bond strength; nevertheless, these pathways are shown below chiefly to illustrate common hydrocarbon oxidation pathways at low temperatures. The reaction scheme for oxidation of methane can be rationalized as proceeding in two phases.4 Since reactive flame species such as O(3P), H•, and HO• are not observed at low temperatures, the formation of the methyl radical must be achieved instead via an endothermic reaction with molecular oxygen.5 Once methyl radical is formed, it reacts with another oxygen molecule to form methylperoxy radical (CH3OO•), which abstracts a hydrogen atom from methane to form methyl hydroperoxide (CH3OOH) and methyl radical. Methyl hydroperoxide can unimolecularly dissociate to produce methoxy (CH3O•) and hydroxyl (HO•) radical. These last two steps are crucial, as they build up a reactive radical pool. Once a sufficient amount of methyl, methoxy, and hydroxyl radicals has formed, these species appropriate the initial duty of abstracting H atoms from methane, driving the reaction rate forward rapidly. Methyl radical is now formed at an appreciable rate and can undergo oxidation and recombination steps. More generally, low-temperature combustion relies heavily on the tendency of radical propagation to yield chain-branching reactions, a phenomenon first explored
THE CHEMISTRY OF REACTIVE RADICAL INTERMEDIATES O2
O2
•
•
CH3
CH4 •
•
CH4
83 •
CH3OOH + CH3
CH3O2
•
R = CH3, OH, CH3O • •
R•
CH4
CH3O + OH
•
CH3 + RH
•
•
CH3O2 •
O2
CH3OH + HCO
CH3OH •
CH3O + CH3O
•
CH3OH
CH3O2 •
CH3O2
•
CH2OH + CH3OH
CH2O
•
R
•
CH3OH + CH2O + O2
CH3OOH + HCO
O2 •
CH2O + HO2•
CH2OH + RH
• •
2CH3O + OH •
H + CO
•
HCO + RH
CH3OH + CH2O
Fig. 2 Low-temperature methane oxidation. Adapted from Reference 4.
by Semenov.6 Semenov’s reaction scheme is most relevant for species with two or more carbons and can be written as R• þ O2 ! alkene þ HO2•
ð2Þ
R• þ O2 þ M ! RO2• þ M •
ð3Þ
RO2 þ R—H ! RO2H þ R •
•
ð4Þ
•
ð5Þ
HO2• þ R—H ! H2O2 þ R•
ð6Þ
0
00
RO2 ! R CH(TO) þ R O
RO2H ! RO• þ •OH
ð7Þ •
R0 CH(TO) þ O2 ! R0 C (TO) þ HO2
•
ð8Þ
Using this scheme, we can track the original alkyl radical through the most likely mechanisms for oxidation at low temperatures that lead to chain-branching. Once formed from the parent molecule (R—H), an alkyl radical (R•) can react with molecular oxygen to form an alkene and hydroperoxyl (HO2•) radical [Equation (2)], via
84
C.J. HAYES ET AL.
1,4-H-atom abstraction from the peroxy radical adduct. Alternatively, alkylperoxy radicals can be stabilized by collisionally transferring some excess energy, obtained during formation, to other molecules or atoms (M). The branching ratio between Reactions 2 and 3 is therefore highly pressure-dependent (i.e., it depends on the concentration of M). Once formed, the peroxy radical can abstract a hydrogen atom from an alkane to form a new radical [Equation (4)] or dissociate unimolecularly, yielding an aldehyde and alkoxy radical [Equation (5)]; both of these reactions produce a molecule that can participate in a chain-branching reaction. Since HO2• is unreactive at lower temperatures, Reaction 6 is less likely than the self-reaction of HO2• resulting in H2O2 and O2. Reactions 7 and 8 are chain-branching steps, which figure heavily in the exponential increase in radical concentration necessary to achieve ignition for the combustion of a given fuel (R—H). As shown, peroxy radical chemistry plays a substantial role in low-temperature combustion as opposed to the alkoxy radical chemistry of high-temperature combustion. Thus, the peroxy radicals constitute an important class of reactive intermediates with significant implications for low temperature combustion and atmospheric reactions. Negative temperature coefficient phenomenon In terms of temperature regions, low-temperature combustion occurs over the range 298–550 K, whereas high-temperature combustion mechanisms dominate at temperatures over 1000 K. Intermediate temperatures, from 550 to 700 K, demonstrate an unusual phenomenon called the negative temperature coefficient (NTC), which is observed for methane and larger hydrocarbon fuels.7 As shown in Fig. 3, when the correct alkylperoxy radical chemistry is included in a fuel’s combustion mechanism, a NTC range exists (Fig. 3, plot C) where an increase in temperature causes a decrease
Ignition delay
(a) (a) High T chemistry only (b, c) Peroxy radical chemistry included
(c)
(b)
Initial temperature
Fig. 3 Typical ignition delay of an alkane fuel as a function of the initial mixture’s temperature. Three different kinetic models are shown: (a) High temperature chemistry only; that is, no peroxy radical chemistry. (b) Same as (a), but the ‘‘Q•OOH’’ chain-branching channel of the peroxy radicals has been considered. (c) Same as (b), but the concerted elimination of RO2• to olefin þ HO2• has been considered (courtesy of Dr. Timothy Barckholtz, ExxonMobil Research and Engineering).8
THE CHEMISTRY OF REACTIVE RADICAL INTERMEDIATES
85
in reaction rate (i.e., a longer time to ignition).8 A simplified view9 of this phenomenon can be rationalized via an examination of the low-temperature combustion mechanism. Again, a crucial step in achieving the combustion of hydrocarbon fuels involves the unimolecular dissociation of an alkyl hydroperoxide (ROOH) into alkoxy (RO•) and hydroxyl (HO•) radicals, that is, chain-branching. The alkylperoxy radical leading to an alkyl hydroperoxide [Equation (4)] is in equilibrium with the reactants: alkyl radical and molecular oxygen (O2) [reverse of Equation (3)]. As the temperature increases, entropy favors the reactants, so that the alkylperoxy radical concentration will be minimized, and therefore, so will the alkyl hydroperoxide concentration. Thus, the chain-branching step cannot drive the oxidation forward, and the ignition time will increase. Moreover, for a hydrocarbon with two or more carbons, molecular oxygen can instead abstract a hydrogen atom from the alkyl radical, yielding an alkene and (notoriously unreactive) hydroperoxyl (HO2•) radical [Equation (2)]. It is also important to note the pressure-dependence of the competition between Equations (2) and (3); to persist, peroxy radicals must be stabilized after formation via collisions with other species. The NTC regime will remain in effect until the temperature increases sufficiently to allow for high-temperature, chain-branching pathways. At high temperatures, NTC is no longer relevant and the ignition rate increases with increasing temperature once again. Atmospheric oxidation The chemistry of the troposphere (the layer of the atmosphere closest to earth’s surface) overlaps with low-temperature combustion, as one would expect for an oxidative environment. Consequently, the concerns of atmospheric chemistry overlap with those of combustion chemistry. Monks recently published a tutorial review of radical chemistry in the troposphere.10 Atkinson and Arey have compiled a thorough database of atmospheric degradation reactions of volatile organic compounds (VOCs),11 while Atkinson et al. have generated a database of reactions for several reactive species with atmospheric implications.12 Also, Sandler et al. have contributed to the Jet Propulsion Laboratory’s extensive database of chemical kinetic and photochemical data.13 These reviews address reactions with atmospheric implications in far greater detail than is possible for the scope of this review. For our purposes, we can extend the low-temperature combustion reactions [Equations (4) and (5)], whereby peroxy radicals would have the capacity to react with prevalent atmospheric radicals, such as HO2•, NO•, NO2•, and NO3• (the latter three of which are collectively known as NOy): RCH2O2• þ NO• ! RCH2O• þ NO2• •
•
ð9Þ
RCH2O2 þ NO þ M ! RCH2ONO2 þ M
ð9aÞ
RCH2O2• þ NO2• þ M ! RCH2OONO2 þ M
ð10Þ
RCH2O2• þ HO2• ! RCH2OOH+O2
ð11Þ
86
C.J. HAYES ET AL.
RCH2O2• þ HO2• ! RCHO þ H2O þ O2
ð11aÞ
RCH2O2• þ RCH2O2• ! RCH2O• þ RCH2O• þ O2
ð12Þ
RCH2O2• þ RCH2O2• ! RCHO þ RCH2OH þ O2
ð12aÞ
RCH2O2 þ NO3• ! RC(¼O)H þ HOx þ NOx
ð13Þ
Oxidation in the atmosphere begins photolytically with radiation from the sun rather than thermolytically; thus, atmospheric chemistry differs between day and night. In the daytime, the most common initiation step for VOC degradation involves photolysis of ozone by the sun’s ultraviolet light, leading to hydroxyl (HO•) radical generation: O3 þ h ! O(1D) þ O2 1
O( D) þ H2O ! 2HO
ð14Þ
•
ð15Þ
Once formed, the peroxy radicals have longer tropospheric lifetimes than HO• and can maintain larger concentrations. Common reactions of peroxy radicals include self-reactions to yield two carbonyl functionalized molecules and O2 [Equations (12) and (12a)]; reactions with HO2• to yield alkylhydroperoxides, aldehydes, H2O, and O2 [Equations (11) and (11a)]; and reactions with NOx species [NOx = NO• and NO2•] to yield alkoxy, alkylnitrate, and alkylperoxynitrate species [Equations (9), (9a) and (10)]. NOx reactions are of significant interest because alkylnitrate and alkylperoxynitrate molecules are stable enough to act as reservoirs, traveling long distances from VOC emission sources before decomposing, thus affecting distant air quality. For example, alkylnitrates can decompose to yield RO• and NO2•, and alkoxy radicals readily react with O2 to yield aldehydes. After H-atom transfer, the weak aldehydic CH bond is readily abstracted to yield an acyl radical, which can react with O2 and NO2• in succession to form peroxyacylnitrates (RC(¼O)OONO2 or PANs). PANs have various detrimental effects; in addition to the reservoir behavior described above, they are lachrymators and demonstrate mutagenic effects.14 Reactions of alkylperoxy radicals with NO3• can serve as an alternative nighttime source for HO• via a complicated series of reactions approximated by Equation (13). At night, when the sun’s radiation is minimal, the dominant VOC oxidant is nitrate radical (NO3•). The chemistry initiated by NO3• differs from that initiated by HO• radical in that NO3• prefers to react with unsaturated compounds via addition to one of the carbons of the p-system, rather than by hydrogen atom abstraction: NO2• þ O3 ! NO3• þ O2
ð16Þ
NO3• þ CH3CHTCH2 ! CH3•CHCH2ONO2 •
•
CH3 CHCH2ONO2 þ O2 ! CH3CH(OO )CH2ONO2
ð17Þ ð18Þ
THE CHEMISTRY OF REACTIVE RADICAL INTERMEDIATES
87
As shown, NO3• radical leads to different chemistry than does HO• radical; the peroxy radical can decompose to yield several products, including acetaldehyde, formaldehyde, 1,2-propanediol dinitrate (PDDN), nitroxyperoxypropyl nitrate (NPPN), and a-nitrooxyacetone. The reactions of the peroxy radicals with NOx species can lead to highly functionalized (and oxidized) organic compounds. The interplay of HO•, peroxy radicals, VOCs, and NOx species has substantial implications for tropospheric air quality. For instance, VOCs, NOx, and sunlight result in poor visibility from ozone and aerosol formation, together denoted as photochemical smog, which can lead to adverse health effects in sensitive individuals. Normally, we think of minimizing either class of compounds as beneficial to the atmosphere. However, minimizing VOC emissions only impacts ozone concentration in high-NOx areas. Moreover, in VOC-sensitive areas, reductions in NOx may lead to the overproduction of ozone. We can examine a simplified scheme15 for ozone production: NO2• þ h ! NO• þ O(3P)
ð19Þ
O(3P) þ O2 þ M ! O3 þ M
ð20Þ
In an ideal troposphere, O3 would react with NO• yielding NO2• and ultimately regenerating O3 [Equations (19) and (20)], thus no over-production of ozone could occur. However, in the presence of VOCs, the resultant peroxy radicals formed can compete with O3 by also reacting with NO• to form excess NO2•, thus resulting in the formation of excess ozone. This is just one example of the complexity of atmospheric chemistry; peroxy radicals and NOx have substantial implications for reaction with climate gases, acid rain formation, and other aspects of air quality. Saunders et al.16 and Jenkin et al.17 have provided a wealth of information on the tropospheric degradation of aliphatic and aromatic VOCs. Additionally, the interested reader may wish to consult References 10–17 for further discussion of these important topics. An additional concern in the commercial applications of combustion chemistry involves understanding and minimizing the production of harmful emissions [such as CO, carbon dioxide, and the oxides of sulfur (SOx), in addition to NOx] in combustion processes. Carbon dioxide increases the amount of greenhouse gas in the atmosphere and contributes to global warming, while NOx and SOx (oxidized derivatives of nitrogen and sulfur) can be transformed in water aerosols resulting in acid rain (via HNO3 and H2SO4, respectively). Another concern involves the formation of soot particles that can have severe respiratory effects. Many studies in combustion chemistry seek to reduce the production of these harmful byproducts.18
METHODS FOR STUDYING REACTIVE COMBUSTION SPECIES
Experimental methods Experiments performed in the 1960s and 1970s used a variety of approaches to detect molecular species and determine rate coefficients for the elementary steps that
88
C.J. HAYES ET AL.
comprised hydrocarbon combustion. Many of these experimental methods are still widely used in combustion studies today. We will briefly discuss these methods as well as surveying some of the more sophisticated methods developed in recent decades. In combustion experiments, there are two key considerations: first, generating a flame and second, detecting the species of interest. Gaseous flows in a flame can be classified as laminar (streamlined layers) or turbulent. While these flames can be analyzed directly, it is less confounding to study flame chemistry through controlled generation of reactive species in one of a wide variety of experimental apparata. One such device is the shock tube.19 This cylindrical apparatus has both a highpressure region filled with an inert gas and a low-pressure region that contains the reactants of interest – fuel only if pyrolytic (thermal decomposition) processes are being examined, fuel and oxidizer if combustion processes are being examined – separated by a thin membrane. After the membrane is ruptured, a high-pressure shock wave travels down the low-pressure region and is reflected back on a microsecond time scale. The system temperature increases rapidly enough to yield hightemperature chemistry and is rapidly quenched for clean analysis. Other techniques simulate postignition flame processes. In the flow reactor, reactants of interest enter the reactor at one end and travel through a constant temperature region.7 Ideally, all concentrations and temperatures are consistent across the cross section of the reactor, so that all movement is in one direction and wall reactions are minimized. A similar approach involves the use of crossed molecular beams,20 wherein two molecular beams are directed into one another; the area of collisional intersection demonstrates chemistry that can occur in flames. Additionally, specific flame species of interest can be directly generated. Radicals can be generated photolytically (via light), thermolytically (via heat), chemically, or via microwaves. Laser-based methods are used to photolytically generate radicals. However, not every radical of interest can be generated from a convenient precursor; moreover, radicals generated via photolytic methods have excess internal energy, which increases the potential of their side reactions. Likewise, pyrolytic sources can be used with a wider range of species, but often necessitate a long residence time (ms) for radicals in the heating zone, giving high probabilities for radical–radical reactions and radical–wall reactions. These drawbacks have been circumvented via novel instrumentation in certain cases. For instance, Chen et al. developed a hyperthermal pyrolytic nozzle21 that works on a shorter time scale (ms) and generates thermally cold radicals via a jet expansion; this nozzle has been coupled with several targets and techniques by various researchers.22 In terms of coupling flame generation and detection methods, several combinations are common. Generally, shock tubes are coupled with IR and UV absorption and gas chromatography (GC) detectors, while flow reactors are used in tandem with GC, electron spin resonance, and resonance fluorescence detection. More advanced techniques are also available. For instance, mass spectrometry (MS) can be used by converting neutral radicals to ions, via chemical ionization and electron impact; these ions are then separated and detected according to their massto-charge ratios (m/z). The primary drawback of this method is that it cannot directly
THE CHEMISTRY OF REACTIVE RADICAL INTERMEDIATES
89
discern between isomers; structural isomers have identical m/z ratios but may behave in chemically unique fashions. Moreover, when MS is coupled with a flamegenerating system, the probe location must be chosen carefully, as the species population can vary greatly given the distance from the flame. Instrumental methods have become more sophisticated to face these challenges.23 In particular, Westmoreland and Cool have developed a flame-sampling mass spectrometer that has provided several revelations in terms of relevant molecular intermediates in combustion.24 Their setup couples a laminar flat-flame burner to a mass spectrometer. This burner can be moved along the axis of the molecular beam to obtain spatial and temporal profiles of common flame intermediates. By using a highly tunable synchrotron radiation source, isomeric information on selected mass peaks can be obtained. This experiment represents a huge step forward in the utility of MS in combustion studies: lack of isomer characterization had previously prevented a full accounting of the reaction species and pathways. When paired with an appropriate radical target, laser-based methods can serve either diagnostically, to discern which intermediates are present in a flame, or analytically, to explore the kinetics and dynamics of elementary steps of interest. Laser-induced fluorescence (LIF) and Raman spectroscopy (RS) are two typical diagnostic techniques; the former explores electronic transitions of a radical of interest, while the latter explores structural aspects of a species via observation of changes in its polarizability. Laser flash photolysis (LFP) is a common kinetic technique, in which a radical precursor is generated via a laser pulse, and the resultant radicals react with a target of interest; the rate of this reaction can be thus extrapolated by monitoring decreasing radical concentration over time. Many laser techniques are currently available and can provide a wealth of information on the structural, vibrational, and electronic properties of reactive radical intermediates. Several reviews of the use of lasers in combustion chemistry have been compiled, including those by Wolfrum,25 Crosley,26 and Eckbreth.27 Computational methods Computational and experimental methods clearly benefit from a symbiotic relationship in combustion studies.28 Theoretical calculations can propose important pathways to yield empirically observed intermediates by providing reaction energies and rate coefficients of elementary reactions, thereby guiding experiments. Moreover, theoretical calculations can potentially fill some gaps caused by limitations in experimental approaches: the vast majority of analytical techniques fail to distinguish between structural isomers and to identify short-lived intermediate species, both of which are important objectives in delineating overall combustion behavior. Finally, modeling can identify species to look for experimentally. Quantum chemical calculations are the most accurate theoretical methods available for studying the structures, energies, and elementary reactions of molecules. It is possible to determine the structure, energy, and geometrical parameters (i.e., vibrational frequencies, electronic states, and rotational constants) for reactants, transition states, and products of a chemical reaction. With this information,
90
C.J. HAYES ET AL.
reaction thermodynamics [enthalpy (H), entropy (S), and free energy (G)] at specified temperatures can be estimated and reaction barriers and energies predicted. Furthermore, since reaction barriers can be calculated, absolute rate coefficients can be determined according to transition state theory (TST).29
k ðT Þ TST ¼ GðTÞ
kB T ðD G6¼ = kBT Þ 0 e h
ð21Þ
In Equation 21, T is the absolute temperature, h is Planck’s constant, kB is Boltzmann constant, and DG6¼ 0 is the free energy barrier height relative to infinitely-separated reactants. The temperature-dependent factor (T) represents quantum mechanical tunneling and the Wigner approximation30 to tunneling through an inverted parabolic barrier: 1 h i 2 ð22Þ GðTÞ ¼ 1 þ 24 kB T where i is the imaginary vibrational frequency representing the curvature of the transition state barrier. Transition state theory yields rate coefficients at the high-pressure limit (i.e., statistical equilibrium). For reactions that are pressure-dependent, more sophisticated methods such as RRKM31 rate calculations coupled with master equation32 calculations (to estimate collisional energy transfer) allow for estimation of lowpressure rates. Rate coefficients obtained over a range of temperatures can be used to obtain two- and three-parameter Arrhenius expressions: Ea kðTÞ ¼ Aeð RT Þ
ð23Þ
Eo kðTÞ ¼ AT m eð RT Þ
ð24Þ
Common quantum mechanical methods for exploring the energetics of elementary reaction steps include ab initio33 and density functional theory (DFT).34 As computational speeds have increased, use of higher levels of theory have allowed for more accurate prediction of properties and reactions for reactive radical intermediates, further advancing our understanding of combustion chemistry. Using these methods, the elementary reaction steps that define a fuel’s overall combustion can be compiled, generating an overall combustion mechanism. Combustion simulation software, like CHEMKIN,35 takes as input a fuel’s combustion mechanism and other system parameters, along with a reactor model, and simulates a complex combustion environment (Fig. 4). For instance, one of CHEMKIN’s applications can simulate the behavior of a flame in a given fuel, providing a wealth of information about flame speed, key intermediates, and dominant reactions. Computational fluid dynamics7 can be combined with detailed chemical kinetic models to also be able to simulate turbulent flames and macroscopic combustion environments.
THE CHEMISTRY OF REACTIVE RADICAL INTERMEDIATES
91
Kinetic mechanism
Thermodynamic data
Reactor model
Results
Transport data
Fig. 4
Flow chart for a typical combustion simulation method. Adapted from Reference 35.
While theoretical calculations generally have been used to supplement experimental findings, they also hold enormous promise for fully discerning the potential energy surfaces of relevant combustion pathways, as well as identifying and exploring the chemistry of relevant reactive intermediates.
3
Reactive radical intermediate chemistry in combustion
ALIPHATIC SYSTEMS
Methane combustion The simplest hydrocarbon, methane, has posed a wealth of challenges to experimentalists and theoreticians seeking to discern its combustion mechanism. Methane’s reactions have been explored in a wide variety of contexts over the past several decades. We have discussed these briefly; the interested reader is referred to the reviews cited in our previous discussion for further details. Due to the scope of this review, we are primarily interested in these reactions insofar as they provide useful benchmarks for the reactions of larger alkylperoxy (RO2•) and alkoxy (RO•) systems. With respect to the reactive intermediates present in methane combustion and their implications for larger systems, Lightfoot has published a review on the atmospheric role of these species,36 while Wallington et al. have provided multiple overviews of gas-phase peroxy radical chemistry.37 Lesclaux has provided multiple reviews of developments in peroxy radical chemistry.38 Batt published a review of the gas-phase decomposition reactions available to the alkoxy radicals.39 Notably, the Gas Research Institute’s mechanism (GRI-MECH) for methane combustion3 is well-established, drawing on research from several groups over several decades to define and calibrate kinetic and thermodynamic data for each elementary reaction step. Additional mechanisms40 for methane oxidation are also available and updated periodically to include the most recent data. Methoxy (CH3O•) and methylperoxy (CH3O2•) radicals have been subjected to substantial study. Zaslonko et al. have reviewed several reactions involving the
92
C.J. HAYES ET AL.
methoxy radical.41 More specifically, several experimental methods have been employed in studying this species. As early as 50 years ago, methoxy radical was an experimental target in mass spectrometric studies by Lossing.42 Burcat and Kudchadker used IR vibrational spectra of methanol at varying temperatures to extrapolate the ideal gas properties of methoxy radical.43 Ruscic and Berkowitz used photoionization MS44 to determine the ionization potential (IP) and heat of formation (DfH0) of methoxy radical. Martinez et al. used LIF to determine the temperature and pressure dependence of the rate coefficients for CH3O• þ NO2• over the 250–390 K temperature and 50–600 Torr pressure ranges.45 Wollenhaupt et al. examined the same reaction using pulsed laser photolysis (PLP).46 Computationally, Carter and Cook completed an extensive assessment of theoretical approaches for methoxy radical,47 while Page explored the kinetics of its unimolecular decomposition.48 Subsequent studies have focused on methoxy radical’s reactivity with a variety of molecules: Pan et al.49 and Sun et al.,50 with NO2•; Pang et al.,51 with NO•. Gomez et al.52 have modeled the addition and H-atom abstraction reactions of methoxy radical with various hydrocarbons. In early studies of methylperoxy radical, Simonaitis and Heicklin53 observed its reaction with NO• and NO2•, while Cox and Tyndall54 used molecular modulation spectroscopy to supplement these findings, and Kan and Calvert studied the water vapor dependence of the CH3O• self-reaction.55 More recently, Wallington et al. obtained absorption spectra of methylperoxy and other alkylperoxy radicals, over the 200–400 nm range.56 Tyndall et al. explored the self-reaction of methylperoxy radical via Fourier Transform Infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy, while Ghigo et al. have modeled the reaction energy surface computationally.57 Their findings complemented an earlier FP study by Lightfoot et al.58 Lesar et al. completed a quantum mechanical investigation of the reaction of CH3O2• with NO•.59 Biggs et al. explored the reaction of methylperoxy radical with NO3•60 as a possible source of nighttime HO• radical. Atkinson and Spillman have explored the kinetics of CH3O2• using cavity ring-down spectroscopy (CRDS), confirming previous findings by Hunziker61 and Pushkarsky.62 Enami et al. explored the kinetics of the reaction between bromine monoxide (BrO•) and methylperoxy radical.63 Together, these experimental and computational investigations provided mechanistic insights, rate constants, pressure dependences, branching ratios, and so on for the creation and validation of the 325step GRI-MECH for methane combustion. Ethyl radical þ O2 Intramolecular reactions become increasingly important as the size of the alkyl chain increases, for a given radical. Ethylperoxy (CH3CH2O2•) radical is a target of significant interest because it can undergo intramolecular rearrangement via a low-strain, fivemembered ring transition state structure. Historically, ethyl radical has been implicated as a discrete intermediate in many reactions. While early experimental studies of ethyl radical suggested that this species reacts bimolecularly with O2 to yield ethene (H2CTCH2, or C2H4) and hydroperoxyl (HO2•) radical,64 subsequent observation of other products such as acetaldehyde and oxirane imply a more complex mechanism. In
THE CHEMISTRY OF REACTIVE RADICAL INTERMEDIATES
93
1975, Hickel65 affirmed that this initial view of ethyl radical oxidation was incomplete, with support by Dechaux and Delfosse66 in 1979. Rather, it was deemed likely that ethyl radical oxidation proceeded through a Semenov-type mechanism [Equation (3)], in which ethylperoxy radical is an intermediate, formed by collisional cooling, which could transfer a hydrogen atom intramolecularly and decompose via multiple pathways. Subsequent experimental work bolstered the likelihood that ethylperoxy radical was an ethane oxidation intermediate. Baldwin postulated in 1986 that molecular oxygen adds to ethyl radical to form ethylperoxy radical, which then undergoes concerted H-atom transfer and elimination to yield ethene and hydroperoxyl radical.67 These and other experimental findings have been summarized in several reviews, including those of Fish,68 Walker,69 and Pilling et al.70 The small size of the CH3CH2• þ O2 system makes high-level computational exploration of its reaction energy surface tractable. Rienstra-Kiracofe et al. have provided an excellent review of the advances made in ab initio modeling of the CH3CH2• þ O2 potential energy surface over the past several years.71 These authors also summarized their own high-level calculations, noting the five most plausible pathways for the ethyl radical þ O2 reaction, four of which involve the unimolecular decomposition/rearrangement of ethylperoxy radical. C2H5• þ O2 ! C2H4 þ HO2•
ð25Þ
• • • C2H5• þ O2 ! CH3CH2OO ! CH2CH2OOH ! c-CH2CH2O+HO
ð26Þ
• • • C2H5• þ O2 ! CH3CH2OO ! CH3 CHOOH ! CH3CHO þ HO
ð27Þ
• • • C2H5• þ O2 ! CH3CH2OO ! CH2CH2OOH ! C2H4 þ HO2
ð28Þ
•
C2H5 þ O2 ! CH3CH2OO
•
• ! C2H4 þ HO2
ð29Þ
Equation (25) accounts for the NTC range observed for the ignition of ethane. Essentially, these reactions are refinements of the Semenov mechanism, since unimolecular reactions are important pathways in the oxidation of ethane. Due to its importance to hydrocarbon combustion as a model alkylperoxy radical, ethylperoxy radical continues to be the subject of experimental studies. Xing et al. used time-resolved, negative-ion MS to explore the reaction of ethylperoxy radical and nitric oxide.72 In separate works, Maricq and Szente explored the kinetics of ethylperoxy’s reaction with acetylperoxy radical73 and NO74 using transient diode laser absorption and time-resolved ultraviolet (TR-UV) spectroscopy. Atkinson and Hudgens have used ultraviolet cavity-ringdown spectroscopy (CRDS) to perform kinetic studies on the ethylperoxy radical self-reaction,75 while Rupper et al. used CRDS to explore the A˜ X˜ electronic transition of CH3CH2O2•.76 Hasson et al. used FT-IR and high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) with fluorescence detection to study the reaction of CH3CH2O2• with HO2•,77 while Mah et al. produced a mid-IR spectrum of this species.78 Ethoxy radical (CH3CH2O•) has enjoyed considerable interest as well. Choi et al. explored its photodissociation dynamics via photofragment translational
94
C.J. HAYES ET AL.
spectroscopy,79 while Faulhaber et al. pursued the same goal using photofragment coincidence imaging.80 Computationally, Matus et al. performed CCSD(T) calculations81 to generate quantities of interest for this radical, including computing a heat of formation (–2.7 0.8 kcal/mol) via atomization energies. The development of an ethane combustion mechanism provides a historical context for understanding some overall trends of alkyl radical combustion. An understanding of the likely pathways for this small system is useful in modeling chemistry of larger systems, as can be observed from an examination of some other reactive radical intermediates. n-Propylperoxy radical (CH3 CH2 CH2 O2 ) In longer chain hydrocarbon radicals, isomerization reactions become more important; these pathways compete with bimolecular oxidation reactions and can impact ignition rates at low temperatures. For instance, n-propylperoxy radical can undergo several unimolecular dissociations/rearrangements:82 CH3CH2CH2OO• ! CH3CH2CH•2 þ O2
ð30Þ
CH3CH2CH2OO• ! CH3CHTCH2 þ HO•2
ð31Þ
CH3CH2CH2OO• ! CH3CH2CH•OOH
ð32Þ
CH3CH2CH2OO• ! CH3CH•CH2OOH
ð33Þ
CH3CH2CH2OO• ! •CH2CH2CH2OOH
ð34Þ
Reversion to reactants [Equation (30)] is straightforward; similarly, the concerted H-atom transfer and elimination pathway [Equation (31)] observed for ethylperoxy radical can also occur for CH3CH2CH2O2•. However, multiple isomerization pathways [Equations (32–34)] are now possible because the length of the alkyl chain has increased. In particular, the 1,5-H-atom transfer occurs via a six-membered ring transition state, thereby minimizing ring strain. Rearrangement reactions lead to a more complex mixture of products. Extrapolating from our knowledge of the ethylperoxy radical pathways, these isomerization products can decompose into propene, propanal, and other oxidation products. The preferences of n-propylperoxy radical will impact overall propane combustion. Because n-propylperoxy radical is small and can undergo low-barrier rearrangements, it is important to understand its possible rearrangement products; these findings have implications for larger hydrocarbons. DeSain et al. studied the production of hydroperoxyl radical via the reaction of n-propyl radical with O2 and proposed an activation barrier of 26.0 kcal/mol for Reaction 31;83 moreover, they have also observed sizable amounts of HO• radical, likely following one of the unimolecular H-atom transfer steps.84 Zalyubovsky et al. examined the A˜ X˜ • transition of CH3CH2CH2O2 (using CRDS) and detected several of its rotational isomers at 298 K.85b Chow et al. explored the kinetics of CH3CH2CH2O2• þ NO• via
THE CHEMISTRY OF REACTIVE RADICAL INTERMEDIATES
95
high-pressure chemical ionization mass spectrometry (CIMS).86 Kaiser explored the production of propene from the CH3CH2CH2• þ O2 reaction as a function of temperature and pressure and posited that chemically activated CH3CH2CH2O2• was an intermediate, resulting from the addition reaction’s exothermicity.87 Computationally, DeSain et al.88 performed QCISD(T) studies to explore the 1,4- and 1,5H-atom transfer reactions for several RO2• systems (including CH3CH2CH2O2•), generating RRKM/master equation rates to model HO2• and HO• production. Naik et al.89 performed a similar study using quantum RRK rates to yield rates for hydroperoxyl radical production in the n-propyl radical þ O2 system. Chen and Bozzelli have completed ab initio and DFT studies on the thermochemical and kinetic parameters of the n-propyl radical þ O2 reaction; they hypothesized that low-temperature ignition for this system results from intramolecular H-transfer reactions of CH3CH2CH2O2• followed by the addition of a second oxygen molecule making it capable of forming products that undergo chain-branching.90 Our group has examined the conformations of CH3CH2CH2O2•, as well as its possible unimolecular decomposition pathways.91 n-Propylperoxy radical conformations are described by two torsion angles: CC—CO in an anti orientation [here called trans (t)] or gauche (g) orientation and CC—OO in an anti orientation [trans (T)] or gauche (G) orientation. Energy profiles for these torsions were generated computationally, minima were obtained, enantiomers were noted, and five unique conformers were identified (Fig. 5). These conformers could rapidly interconvert, as the highest torsional barrier was predicted to be less than þ5.0 kcal/mol. Using the CBS-QB3 theoretical method,92 the 298 K distribution of rotamers was calculated to be 28.1, 26.4, 19.6, 14.0, and 11.9% for the gG, tG, gT, gG0 , and tT conformers, respectively. Therefore, all five conformers will be present as seen experimentally by Zalyubovsky et al.85b The unimolecular reactions of CH3CH2CH2O2• were studied in detail (Fig. 6); complete potential energy surfaces were generated using both DFT [B3LYP/ 6–31þG(d,p) and mPW1K/6–31þG(d,p)]34,93 and CBS-QB392 methods. As expected, 1,5-H transfer [Equation (34)] occurs with the lowest barrier, followed by simultaneous 1,4-H transfer and HO2• expulsion [Equation (31)]. The overall decompositions of each H-atom transfer product (i.e., each QOOH radical) were modeled. It
tG
gT
tT
gG′
gG
Fig. 5 Conformers of n-propylperoxy radical, named according to the conformational preferences around the central C—C bond, then around the C—O bond. [courtesy of John Merle (J Phys Chem A 2005;109:3637–3646). Reprinted with permission of J Phys Chem A.]
96
C.J. HAYES ET AL. ‡ 42.6 45.9 40.8
1,3-H transfer TS
‡ •
CH3CH2CH2 + O2 31.4 31.3 36.1
1,4-H transfer TS
Concerted 1,4-H transfer/elimination ‡
32.4 35.7 31.7 ‡
23.8 26.7 23.2
27.5 37.0 30.8
1,5-H transfer TS
ΔH(298 K), kcal/mol, relative to n-propylperoxy 0.0 B3LYP/6–31+G** 0.0 mPW1K/6–31+G** 0.0 CBS-QB3
Fig. 6 Initial reaction barriers for unimolecular reactions of n-propylperoxy radical. [courtesy of John Merle (J Phys Chem A 2005;109:3637–3646). Reprinted with permission of J Phys Chem A.]
was shown that, although the 1,5-H-transfer reaction has the lowest barrier, the resultant •CH2CH2CH2OOH cannot easily undergo further unimolecular rearrangements. Rather, the 1,4-H atom transfer routes [Equations (31) and (33)] encounter lower barriers in subsequent steps. This pathway for n-propylperoxy radical parallels a likely pathway involved in the decomposition of ethylperoxy radical.71 The CBS-QB3 potential energy surface accounts for the various experimentally observed products, including hydroperoxyl radical, propene, HO•, propanal, and oxirane (c-C3H6O). The activation barrier for simultaneous 1,4-H transfer and HO2• expulsion, obtained via calculations, compares well to the experimentally observed barrier (26.0 kcal/mol) of DeSain et al.83,84 This work provides some ramifications for larger alkylperoxy radicals: multiple conformers of long alkylperoxy radicals are likely to play a role in the overall oxidation chemistry and dictate consideration for correct treatment of thermochemistry; at lower temperatures (T < 500 K), unimolecular reactions dictate peroxy radical chemistry. n-Butoxy radical (CH3CH2CH2CH2O•) Just as n-propylperoxy radical is the smallest peroxy radical that can undergo the 1,5H-atom transfer, n-butoxy radical is the smallest alkoxy radical that can do so, while
THE CHEMISTRY OF REACTIVE RADICAL INTERMEDIATES
97
pentyl radical is the smallest alkyl radical with this potential. Similarly, these species are often used as models to understand the chemistry of larger alkoxy radical and alkyl radical systems. n-Butoxy radical exists in multiple conformer forms and can undergo a facile 1,5H-atom transfer. Vereecken and Peters94 exhaustively examined this possibility, via DFT calculations and TST rate coefficients, to recommend a rate coefficient of 1.4 105 s1, which agreed well with the experimental rates of both Atkinson95 and Hein et al.96 Vereecken and Peters used multiple approaches for deriving their multirotamer transition state theory expressions and demonstrated consistency through all of these. Ferenac et al. examined this unimolecular isomerization (1,5H shift) for n-butoxy radical and its functionalized derivatives, noting substantial substituent effects (more dependent on substitution patterns than on the functional groups themselves).97 Lendvay and Viskolcz examined unimolecular reactions available to n-butoxy radical via ab initio and RRKM calculations and noted that, while 1,5-isomerization was the fastest route, fragmentation reactions would compete at combustion temperatures.98 This finding was corroborated by exhaustive quantum chemical/RRKM dynamics calculations by Somnitz and Zellner.99 Jungkamp et al. generated an exhaustive atmospheric mechanism for n-butane via DFT and ab initio methods, proposing that n-butoxy radical will react primarily via 1,5-H transfers to ultimately form 4-hydroxy-1-butanal, while 2-butoxy radical will tend to decompose via b-scission to ethyl radical and acetaldehyde.100 Cassanelli et al. completed relative rate studies of 1-butoxy radical using FT-IR spectroscopy, noting that reaction with oxygen competed with isomerization.101 1-Pentyl radical (CH3 CH2 CH2 CH2 CH2 ) For pentyl radical, internal H-atom transfers can occur regardless of whether further oxidation occurs. These unimolecular reactions can directly compete with oxidation steps and so have implications for low-temperature combustion. For instance, n-pentyl radical can quickly isomerize to iso-pentyl radical via 1,4-H atom transfer; each of these radicals can undergo b-scission reactions to yield a new alkyl radical + alkene: C3 H7 þH2 C¼CH2
n-pentyl ! iso-pentyl ! H2 C¼CHCH3 þC2 H5
ð35Þ
Several experimental studies, over the past several decades, have modeled the overall combustion of this system.102 Jitariu et al. have calculated unimolecular rates for reactions of pentyl radical (i.e., intramolecular H-atom transfer, b-scission, and elimination) noting that isomerizations have lower barriers than b-scissions.103 Larger aliphatic species In general, the trends predicted by n-propylperoxy radical, 1-butoxy radical, and n-pentyl radical provide good benchmarks for understanding the oxidation chemistry of longer chain radicals.104,105 For instance, 1,5-H-atom transfer and
98
C.J. HAYES ET AL.
1,4-H-atom transfer concurrent with elimination provide two important routes with implications for both low- and high-temperature combustion. These possibilities constitute an important subclass of the reactions included in comprehensive mechanisms106 for the corresponding parent compound (i.e., propane,107 butane,108 and pentane). Also, developing larger mechanisms by substituting reaction data for similar, smaller species is a common practice in mechanism development (referred to as lumping109); thus, the reactions of these model compounds have parallels in the chemistry of larger fuels (in particular, n-heptane110 and iso-octane,111 which together constitute the primary reference fuels used to model gasoline combustion,112 as well as n-hexadecane, which shows promise for understanding diesel oxidation113). Chemistry taking place through five- and six-membered ring transition states is consistently favored kinetically over larger and smaller transition states. Gasoline and diesel fuels are two largely aliphatic hydrocarbon fuels that merit further discussion.114 These fuels are primarily used in different types of combustion environments: gasoline, in a spark-ignition (SI) engine, and diesel, in an autoignition engine. A SI engine relies on a four-stroke internal combustion process, involving the reciprocating piston, the intake valve, the exhaust valve, and a spark plug. In terms of the mechanism of combustion, a spark plug ignites the compressed fuel–air mixture, and the resultant flame ideally propagates smoothly across the engine cylinder. The speed at which the flame propagates is dependent on the fuel used. In a diesel engine, ignition relies on compression of the fuel until the autoignition temperature can be reached; no spark ignition is used, and no flame propagation occurs, and thus fewer emissions are involved. Similarly, autoignition temperature varies between given fuels. Even from this general overview, it is clear that the efficiency at which either type of engine operates depends heavily on fuel identity. Common metrics for understanding the ignitability of gasoline and diesel fuels are referred to as the octane number and the cetane number, respectively. Essentially, octane number refers to the volume percent of iso-octane in a given gasoline sample; cetane number refers to the volume percent of cetane (n-hexadecane) in a given diesel sample. In practice, the octane and cetane numbers refer to the practical efficiency of a given fuel to that of iso-octane and n-hexadecane, respectively. Wallington et al. have recently provided an excellent tutorial review of these and other related topics involving chemistry’s many roles in automotive fuels and engines.114
AROMATIC SYSTEMS
Soot formation Before we examine the oxidation pathways available to aromatic systems, it is first instructive to review the most notorious role of these compounds in combustion chemistry: their propensity to lead to soot formation. Soot is a byproduct of fuel-rich combustion, and soot particles can affect respiration and general health in humans.115 Soot production is a result of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH) formation in flames: as reactive hydrocarbon radical intermediates combine to grow
THE CHEMISTRY OF REACTIVE RADICAL INTERMEDIATES
99
and propagate, they can also cyclize into rings, which ultimately yield large networks of aromatic rings.116 To work toward minimizing harmful soot emissions, it is important to understand the mechanisms by which soot forms. Generally, the first cyclization step, whereby a benzene ring is formed from acyclic radical species, has been postulated to occur by one of two steps based on acetylene (C2H2) experiments: (1) the reaction of acetylene with either 1,3-butadien-1-yl radical (H2CTCH—CHTCH•) or buta-1-en-3-yn-1-yl radical (HCUC—CHTCH•) and (2) propargyl radicals (HCUC—CH2•) self-reaction, followed by H-atom transfers. More recently, cyclopentadiene has also been implicated as a likely precursor to benzene formation.117 Once the initial benzene ring has cyclized, it can undergo sequences of H-atom abstraction followed by acetylene addition, to yield PAHs. This is known as the H-abstraction-C2H2-addition (HACA) process, proposed by Frenklach and Wang.118 As an aromatic species aggregates to a size over 500 amu, it adopts a particulate form and can coalesce with other PAHs to further increase in size. When many of these particles agglomerate, they form soot.119 Efforts to minimize soot production are widespread. Notably, decreasing the carbon content relative to oxidizer concentration in a fuel/oxidizer mixture decreases the amount of soot formed.
Benzene and toluene In addition to their roles in soot formation, aromatic compounds undergo oxidation processes unique from acyclic saturated hydrocarbons. Aromatic species comprise 10–40% of gasoline and 5–30% of diesel; they reduce undesirable autoignition events (engine knock), thereby increasing a fuel’s octane rating. Therefore, aromatic oxidative decompositions have implications for combustion and atmospheric chemistry. The C—C and C—H bonds present in aromatic hydrocarbons are substantially stronger than those of alkanes, due to their sp2-hybridized carbons. When we consider the combustion reaction of a simple unsaturated species such as benzene or toluene, a new initiation step is possible. A reactive radical (for instance, HO•) may either abstract a hydrogen atom or add directly to the ring’s p-system, generating an allylic-type radical system: these multiple pathways compete (Fig. 7). Both pathways contribute to the combustion chemistry of aromatic species; HO• addition to the aromatic ring is the more prevalent at 298 K.120 In a monoalkyl-substituted aromatic species, such as toluene, abstraction of a hydrogen atom from the side chain can compete with HO• addition at positions ipso, ortho, meta, or para to the side chain. Thus, the possibilities for oxidative initiation and subsequent peroxy radical reactions increase.
Benzene oxidation Of the aromatic hydrocarbons, the oxidative pathways of benzene have been studied most exhaustively. Fujii et al.121 proposed a global mechanism in the early 1970s, in which the C—H bond of benzene is broken to form the phenyl (C6H5•) radical that
100
C.J. HAYES ET AL.
Fig. 7 Reactions of toluene with HO• radical. HO• can abstract a benzylic hydrogen atom (a) or add to the aromatic ring at the ipso (b), ortho (c), meta (d), and para (e) positions relative to the methyl group. Each resultant radical can decompose by various pathways, depending on temperature and pressure.
subsequently reacts with molecular oxygen to form the phenylperoxy (C6H5OO•) radical: C6H5• þ O2 ! C6H5OO• ! 2CO þ C2H2 þ C2H3•
ð36Þ
Although greatly simplified, this model demonstrates the importance of phenylperoxy radical (C6H5OO•) as a reactive intermediate and accounts for some of the major combustion products. However, several other mechanistic intermediates (C3, C4, and C5 hydrocarbons) were also observed. Subsequently, Glassman’s mechanism for benzene combustion accounted for several more products, proposing that phenoxy (C6H5O•) radical was the chief reactive intermediate driving the combustion of benzene. The stepwise mechanism for benzene combustion122 began with H-atom loss to form a phenyl radical (C6H5•), then proceeded through reaction with O2, and then CO expulsion to form cyclopentadienyl (c-C5H5•) radical, which could react with O2 and expel CO again to form smaller hydrocarbon species (Fig. 8). However, this model still over-predicted the formation of phenyl, phenoxy, and cyclopentadienyl radicals; moreover, it failed to account for additional experimentally observed products (i.e., furan, pyranyl radical, and oxobutadiene).123 The tendency of the benzene combustion mechanism to substantially overestimate the formation of phenoxy radical suggested either flaws in the kinetic data involving C6H5O• or incompleteness of the combustion mechanism. Subsequent work verified the kinetics and energetics used in modeling C6H5O• decomposition. In separate studies, Liu et al.124 and Olivella et al.125 used ab initio and DFT models, along
THE CHEMISTRY OF REACTIVE RADICAL INTERMEDIATES
101
Fig. 8 High-temperature oxidation pathways of benzene, as proposed by Glassman in Reference 122.
with RRKM rate coefficients, to confirm the data for these pathways. (More recently, these data were also borne out in a quantum mechanical/RRKM study by Hodgson et al.126) Consequently, the benzene oxidation mechanism was further developed by considering additional decomposition and oxidation steps. Sethuraman et al. proposed that phenyl radical decomposition can occur by either of two key pathways:127 b-scission of phenyl radical or by breakdown of the phenylperoxy radical formed by the oxidation of phenyl radical (Fig. 9). Using PM3 calculations,128 which were ultimately verified by DFT studies,129 Carpenter predicted that another species, 2-oxepinoxy radical (3 in Fig. 9b), is an important intermediate due to its relative stability, formed via a spirodioxiranyl intermediate (2 in Fig. 9b) from phenylperoxy radical. Pathway A in Fig. 9b is the thermodynamically preferred pathway at temperatures increasing up to 432 K, while pathway B has an entropic benefit at higher temperatures. While pathway B essentially matched the traditional view of benzene combustion, pathway A introduced a new route for phenylperoxy radical, which could resolve discrepancies observed using previous models. This supposition was validated by experimental studies that demonstrated the prevalence of different ROS at different temperatures. Using CRDS, Yu and Lin studied the reaction of phenyl radical and oxygen, noting that phenylperoxy radical was the only adduct formed at temperatures ranging up to 473 K;130 Venkat et al. completed flow reactor studies of benzene combustion at 1200 K and identified phenoxy radical as a key intermediate.122 Our group has completed several studies of key reactions for some relevant reactive intermediates in benzene oxidation. Barckholtz et al. examined the oxidation pathways of several aromatic species, using benzene as a benchmark.129a General
102
C.J. HAYES ET AL.
(a)
a b
– O
(b)
A
1
O•
B
O O
O• + O(3P)
• 2
6
O •
• O
O 7
3 –CO O
• O 4
• –CO2 5
Fig. 9 (a) Enthalpies (kcal/mol) leading to 2-oxepinoxy radical formation via unimolecular rearrangement of phenylperoxy radical. PM3/UHF = DfH and DFT (B3LYP/6–311 þ G(d,p)// B3LYP/6–31G(d)) = DH298. (b) Potential decomposition pathways for phenylperoxy radical A involving 2-oxepinoxy radical and B involving oxygen atom loss. [courtesy of Steven Kroner (J Am Chem Soc 2005;127:7466–7473). Reprinted with permission of J. Am. Chem. Soc.]
models were proposed for aromatic hydrocarbon and heterocycle oxidation (namely, benzene, pyridine, furan, and thiophene) in preparation for more specific studies of each relevant species. Carbon-centered radicals at each relevant position underwent exoergic oxidation, and the resulting peroxy radical unimolecular decomposition pathways were delineated. It was proposed that these peroxy radicals could undergo rearrangements that make them of significant atmospheric interest. A subsequent study examined phenylperoxy radical in greater detail. Fadden et al.129b identified five possible unimolecular decomposition pathways for phenylperoxy radical (Fig. 10): via oxygen atom loss to form phenoxy radical (Fig. 10, route A), via a dioxiranyl radical species (Fig. 10, route B), via a dioxetanyl radical
THE CHEMISTRY OF REACTIVE RADICAL INTERMEDIATES
103
Fig. 10 Potential unimolecular reaction pathways for phenylperoxy radical. Adapted from Reference 129b.
intermediate (Fig. 10, route C), via a 1,3-peroxy radical species (Fig. 10, route D), and via a p-phenylquinone radical intermediate (Fig. 10, route E). These routes were examined using DFT (B3LYP/6–31G(d)) and ab initio (CASSCF) structures, with high-level CAS-MP2, and UCCSD(T) single-point energies. Formation of the dioxetanyl species was predicted to be most favorable based on DG298 energies. This radical could unimolecularly decompose to produce smaller species, including cyclopentadienyl and pyranyl radicals, as well as acyclic oxygenated species, that are experimentally observed. At higher temperatures (T > 500 K), the entropic benefit afforded via oxygen atom loss becomes a contributing factor, and pathway A is the major decomposition route. Moreover, route B leads directly to 2-oxepinoxy radical (3 in Fig. 9b), which is potentially an important intermediate in low-temperature benzene oxidation. The stability of 2-oxepinoxy radical qualified it as a target for further theoretical and experimental study. The calculations of Barckholtz et al.129a allowed the refinement of a feasible energetic pathway toward 2-oxepinoxy radical; these DFT calculations supplemented the semiempirical work of Carpenter and also proposed a triradical intermediate between the dioxiranyl and oxepinoxy species (Fig. 9a). Consequently, the unimolecular decomposition of 2-oxepinoxy radical (3 in Fig. 9b) was thoroughly modeled by Fadden et al. using DFT (B3LYP) methods.131 Gibbs free energy profiles (T = 298–1250 K) were generated. A wide range of decomposition pathways were examined, which could account for typical experimentally observed products (Fig. 11). Notably, the delineated decomposition pathway did not require the generation of cyclopentadienyl radical. Cyclopentadienone is a commonly observed product in benzene combustion, and most mechanisms presume that cyclopentadienyl radical is its most likely precursor. However, it was shown that
O
40.8 + 2CO
H + CO 15 +30.3
16 +20.2
18 +54.2
13 +27.9
17 +26.2
49.0
+ CO H 19 –11.7
12.0
O CH2 C
H
O
3.4
6 +0.1
O
36.7
+ CO
12 +4.3
7 + 14.1
8 +36.6
H
O
C 6.8 36.3 O
+ HCO
C 22 +46.7
O C
O C
C
21 +25.0
+ CO 9 +39.0
O 30.5
C
H
2.7
6 +0.1
O
O
7.6
O + CO
O + CO
5 +28.9 C
H + CO
0.3
O
O
35.5
O
+ CO2 4 –28.1
3 +17.3
CO
23.4
7.7 H
2 +10.0
10.0
+ CO C 14 +3.3 O
–0.7
8.6
CH2
+ 2CO
CO2
39.4
43.8
29.4 4.6
O
8.8
+ 2CO
C2H3 + C2H2 + 2CO
104
O
O CO
O C
O C 26.6
34.7
13.3
2.8 H O
O + C2H2 + CO
40.2
11 +65.7
41.3 O
O H 30 +22.9
27.6
O O
C 29 +6.1
C 19.5
28 +7.3
40.6 C
26 +22.4
O
25 +42.3
O C
8.6
+ C2HO
C + C2H2O 27 +47.5
O 34.7
CO O 5 +28.9
0.3
O + CO 6 +0.1
Fig. 11 Unimolecular decomposition pathways of 2-oxepinoxy radical (1). The relative free energies (298 K, kcal/mol) at the B3LYP/ 6–311 þ G(d,p)//B3LYP/6–31G(d) level are shown for each intermediate relative to 1, and each free energy of activation is relative to the reactant for that specific step. [courtesy of Michael Fadden (J Phys Chem A 2000;104:8121–8130) Reprinted with permission of J Phys Chem A.]
C.J. HAYES ET AL.
+ C2HO 31 +34.2
22.8
O
23 +7.7
50.3 O
10 +38.8
O C O
20 +10.9 H + CO
C 24 +24.6 O
THE CHEMISTRY OF REACTIVE RADICAL INTERMEDIATES
105
2-cyclopenten-1-yl radical (19 in Fig. 11), a feasible source of cyclopentadienone, could be formed from the 2-oxepinoxy radical. These computed pathways supported the experimental results of Pfefferle and coworkers,140b in their work on the lowtemperature combustion of benzene, in which C2, C3, and C4 hydrocarbons were observed without formation of C5 constituents. 2-Oxepinoxy radical is highly stabilized by its unique structure; Mebel et al. determined, via PUMP3/6–31G(d)//UHF/6–31G(d) calculations, that it would have a relative enthalpy of DH0 = –91.8 kcal/mol as compared to phenylperoxy (C6H5O2•) radical.132 The stability of this species suggests that it will be fairly longlived and thus could undergo reactions of atmospheric interest, such as the addition of molecular oxygen. Merle and Hadad studied the oxygen-initiated decomposition of 2-oxepinoxy radical using both DFT and CBS-QB3 calculations.133 Calculations predicted that from T = 298–750 K, O2 addition routes compete with unimolecular decomposition (Fig. 12); for T > 750 K, however, the entropic penalty associated with the O2 addition step causes the unimolecular decomposition of 2-oxepinoxy radical to be more favored. The most stable O2 addition adduct below T = 1250 K is 6-peroxyoxepinone (route A in Fig. 12), which can cyclize to form a 1,4-peroxy intermediate which subsequently releases CO2 to form a 5-oxopentanalyl radical. This species can cyclize and fragment, yielding formyl radical, furan, and carbon dioxide. Above T = 1250 K, the
Fig. 12 Most favorable oxidative decomposition pathways for 2-oxepinoxy radical, at 298 K (path A) and 1250 K (path B). Adapted from Reference 131.
106
C.J. HAYES ET AL.
dissociative pathway (route B in Fig. 12) afforded by 2-peroxyoxepinone’s loss of oxygen atom becomes more favorable. Even though 2-oxepinoxy radical (3 in Fig. 9b) may be an important intermediate in benzene oxidation, no confirmatory experimental evidence exists. Recently, Kroner et al. published an experimental study of the gas-phase acidity of 2(3H)oxepinone (C6H6O2), obtained via flowing-afterglow MS.134 They postulated that this quantity could be used along with a thermodynamic cycle to determine the heat of formation of 2-oxepinoxy radical: C6H6O2 ! C6H5O2 þ H þ
DHacid
ð37Þ
C6H5O2 ! C6H5O2• þ e
EA(C6H5O2)
ð38Þ
Hþ þ e ! H•
IP(H)
C6H6O2 ! C6H5O2• þ H•
ð39Þ BDE=DHacid þ EA IP
DHf(2-oxepinoxy radical, C6H5O2•)=BDE þ DHf(H•) DHf(C6H6O2)
ð40Þ ð41Þ
A value of DHacid = 352 2 kcal/mol was determined for Equation (37). This experimental evidence could ultimately be valuable in conclusively identifying 2-oxepinoxy radical as a reactive species of interest. The overall pathways of benzene oxidation and the decompositions of possible intermediates have been well characterized via theoretical methods. Thus far, we have discussed these species mainly in the context of their oxidation mechanisms, but phenylperoxy and phenoxy radicals have also been investigated as individual experimental targets. The chemistry of phenoxy (C6H5O•) radical has been of interest for several decades. Benson et al. proposed the first rate coefficient for its unimolecular decomposition,135 while Lin and Lin provided information on the Arrhenius parameters for the reaction.136 Experimental and theoretical studies have examined phenoxy radical’s electronic states,137 molecular vibrational frequencies,138 and spin density, as well as its thermal and oxidative decomposition.139 Benzene combustion mechanisms rely heavily on the inclusion of phenoxy radical data;121,122,140 additionally, phenoxy radical decomposition reactions are necessary in the mechanisms for combustion of several other species, including propane,141 butane,142 and anisole.143 More notoriously, phenoxy radical has recently been implicated in routes to dioxin and polychlorinated naphthalenes; several theoretical studies have been completed on these potential reactions.144 Finally, the roles of phenoxy radical in flame chemistry,145 emissions,146 and other aspects of combustion147 have been compiled in several reviews. Phenylperoxy radical has similarly been a topic of experimental and theoretical interest. Tokmakov et al.148 calculated a potential energy surface for phenyl radical and O2 using ab initio G2(MP2) calculations. Weisman and Head-Gordon used timedependent density functional theory (TD-DFT) calculations to examine the effect of substituents on the phenylperoxy radical’s UV-vis absorption spectrum.149 Lin and Mebel used ab initio methods to study the phenoxy radical þ O-atom reaction.150
THE CHEMISTRY OF REACTIVE RADICAL INTERMEDIATES
107
Just et al. have examined the A˜ X˜ electronic transition of phenylperoxy using CRDS.151 Tonokura et al.152 used CRDS to study the visible absorption spectrum of the phenyl radical, as well as the kinetics of its reaction with O2. Krauss and Osman examined the UV absorption spectra of vinylperoxy radical (H2CTCHO2•) and phenylperoxy radicals.153 Phenylperoxy radical, originally assumed to be a factor in low-temperature combustion only, has actually been shown to play a substantial role in dictating the overall combustion trends of benzene. Just as the isomerizations and eliminations of the alkylperoxy radicals significantly affected their overall combustion pathways, rearrangements and other intramolecular pathways available to phenylperoxy radical similarly impact the overall progress of benzene combustion. This knowledge can be extrapolated to more complex aromatic species. Alkylated aromatics Like benzene, toluene (C6H5CH3) is a common constituent of gasoline. Much of the literature concerning toluene’s oxidation focuses on a global mechanism for understanding its combustion. Emdee et al.154 proposed that toluene’s combustion mechanism is most sensitive to its reaction with O2 to form benzyl radical (C6H5—CH2•) and HO2•. Dagaut et al. proposed that toluene oxidation is initiated by benzylic H-atom abstraction by O2 to form the benzyl radical, which can unimolecularly decompose to acetylene and cyclopentadienyl or react with an additional O2 and unimolecularly decompose to phenyl and formyl radicals (via benzaldehyde, (C6H5—C(TO)H).155 Pitz et al. generated a comprehensive mechanism for toluene combustion in varying settings, due to its widespread use as a fuel additive.156 El Bakali et al. noted an overall similarity between the chemistry of benzene and the chemistry of toluene, based on their oxidation mechanisms.157 Ethylbenzene has also been the subject of mechanistic studies,158 most recently by Ergut et al.159 As mentioned previously, the low-temperature oxidation of toluene is proposed to begin with either of two steps; if hydroxyl radical is present, HO• can abstract a benzylic hydrogen atom or add directly to the aromatic ring. Once a radical is generated on the aromatic ring or side chain of toluene, rapid oxidation can occur. The resulting peroxy radical has several viable pathways available. Atkinson compiled data on low-temperature atmospheric reactions for both the benzyl radical and the C6H5—CH3/HO• adduct.11 Andino et al. modeled the atmospheric oxidation of toluene and disubstituted xylenes, noting that several cyclized peroxy radical rearrangement products were energetically stable.160 Additionally, studies have focused on benzylperoxy radical (C6H5CH2O2•), although this is a less common target than phenylperoxy radical, because HO• addition to the aromatic ring is more dominant than H-atom abstraction from the benzylic C—H bond, in toluene combustion.120 Elmaimouni et al. studied the equilibrium for benzylperoxy radical and benzyl radical þ O2 over the temperature range 393–433 K, extrapolating the addition reaction enthalpy to be –20.1 kcal/mol at 298 K, and the free energy to be 11.4 kcal/mol.161 Fenter et al. performed a kinetic study162 using the same equilibrium at 760 torr with a temperature range of 298–398 K, proposing a
108
C.J. HAYES ET AL.
rate expression kf(T) = (7.6 2.4) 1013 exp[(190 160)/T(K)] cm3/molecule-s, equilibrium Kp = 6.3 0.2 104 atm1, and reaction enthalpy DH298 = –21.8 kcal/mol. Buth et al. used a flow reactor coupled to mass spectrometric detection in a comparable study,163 determining kf = (4.44 1.3) 1011 cm3/molecule-s and Kp = 57,200 bar1 at 298 K. Noziere et al. monitored the reaction of benzylperoxy radical with hydroperoxyl radical using LFP/UV absorption and continuous photolysis/FTIR.164 El Dib et al. performed a LFP kinetics study of the self-reaction of benzylperoxy radical.165 It was again observed that rearrangement pathways comprise a substantial portion of the oxidation routes for alkylated aromatics.11,160 Since this phenomenon is mainly due to peroxy radical reactivity rather than to identity of the parent compound, it is clear that comparable rearrangements would be factors for PAHs, as well as for nitrogen-, oxygen-, and sulfur-containing heteroaromatic rings and their alkylated derivatives. Heteroaromatic combustion Considering additional functionalities in an aromatic ring allows for conclusions with implications for coal chemistry. Coal is a vital fossil fuel; about 50% of the United States is dependent on coal for electric power generation, and its use accounts for 90% of Ohio’s electrical power. Current clean-coal engineering efforts are underway to maximize coal’s energy potential while minimizing harmful environmental emissions (i.e., Hg, SOx, NOx, and CO2).166 Unlike hydrocarbon-based fuels like methane and gasoline, coal has never been subjected to a comprehensive mechanistic analysis, due to the complexity of its molecular structure. However, coal’s complex structure consists of various monocyclic units that can be explored: aromatic hydrocarbons and heteroaromatic rings are recurring units in coal’s structure, even while the overall structure varies geographically. Understanding low- and high-temperature oxidation reactions for these subunits and their reactive radical intermediates will facilitate a better understanding of their chemistry in combustion. Heteroaromatic compounds (Fig. 13) have been used as models for understanding coal chemistry in several pyrolytic studies. The azabenzenes (N-containing
Fig. 13 Heteroaromatic compounds of interest in coal combustion.
THE CHEMISTRY OF REACTIVE RADICAL INTERMEDIATES
109
heteroaromatics) have historically been most often studied; their pyrolysis has been shown to proceed through reactive radical intermediates although the identity of these intermediates can vary with reaction conditions.167 Using a shock tube, Mackie et al. observed the pyrolytic decomposition of pyridine,168 noting that three initial radicals derived from C—H bond scission: o-pyridinyl, m-pyridinyl, and p-pyridinyl. Of these, o-pyridinyl radical was dominant and was observed to yield cyanoacetylene (NUC—CUCH) through a ring-opening process, while m- and p-pyridinyl radicals formed HCN as a major product, via a less discernable pathway. Similarly, Kiefer et al. studied the pyrolysis of pyrazine, pyrimidine, and pyridine;169 all were observed to undergo ring-scission to yield 2-cyanovinyl radical (•CHTCH—CUN), which accounts for several combustion products upon decomposition, including HCN, NUC—CUCH, and acetylene. 2-Cyanovinyl radical has been identified in several pyrolytic studies of the azabenzenes, originally via the shock-tube study of Doughty et al.167f,g These authors proposed that the relative position of the nitrogen atoms in the ring substantially impacts the reactivity of a ring toward pyrolysis: for example, pyrazine dissociates more quickly than pyrimidine. Overall, the azabenzenes demonstrate increased reactivity relative to benzene; their C—H BDEs range from 93 to 98 kcal/mol, compared to benzene’s C—H BDE of 112 kcal/mol.170 The smallest C—H BDEs occur at positions ortho to nitrogen [although being a C—H bond that is twice ortho to N (as in pyrimidine) does not render a further lowering of the BDE].167 Kikuchi et al,171 Mackie et al.,172 and Jones et al.173 have attributed the lower BDE to the nitrogen atom’s in-plane lone pair electrons interacting with the unpaired electron on the carbon center of the radical, thereby reducing the strength of the C—H bond via radical product stabilization. The oxidative decomposition of the azabenzenes has not been studied in such great detail. Tabares et al. studied the reaction of pyridine with O-atom, noting a decrease in reactivity relative to benzene.174 Alfassi et al. studied the formation and reactivity of pyridylperoxy radicals in solution.175 Eisele postulated that the presence of ions derived from pyridine and picoline in the troposphere implicates these species as atmospherically significant.176 Yeung and Elrod explored this claim via chemical ionization MS to study the reactions of HO• with pyridine, the picolines, the lutidines, and the ethylpyridines and postulated that pyridinated compounds could indeed have substantial implications on tropospheric ion content.177 As with toluene, the reaction of HO• with pyridine and alkylated pyridines is likely to proceed either via HO• addition to the aromatic ring or hydrogen atom abstraction from a C—H bond. The new radicals can unimolecularly decompose or undergo reaction with O2. These reactions have been modeled for toluene and the hydrocarbon analogues by Andino et al.160 Heteroaromatic compounds have the potential to add O2 at the ring nitrogen and thus form NOx species,178 potentially leading to excess tropospheric ozone and acid rain.179 The five-membered heteroaromatic (furan, oxazole, pyrrole, and thiophene) are of additional interest. Besides their role in coal combustion, these have been implicated as emissions of biomass burning,180 residential fires,181 waste tire burning,182 cigarette smoking,183 and motor vehicles.184 Bruinsma et al. examined the pyrolysis of heteroaromatic rings most commonly found in coal volatiles,185 determining a rank of increasing pyrolytic reactivity: thiophene < benzene < pyridine < pyrrole < cyclopentadiene < furan; they also noted that an additional, fused aromatic ring
110
C.J. HAYES ET AL.
has a stabilizing effect, especially for pyridine and furan. Cullis and Norris also studied the pyrolytic processes of the heteroaromatics, yielding methane and benzene as major products, via hydrocarbon radical intermediates. Qualitative product analysis revealed that these heteroaromatics decomposed by similar mechanisms regardless of identity; the heteroatoms were generally not present as major combustion products; they were lost as water, hydrogen sulfide, or hydrogen cyanide.186 Braslavsky and Heicklen extensively reviewed the thermal and photochemical decomposition of heteroaromatic compounds.187 Klein et al. studied variations in heteroaromatic C—H BDEs for substituted aromatic compounds.188 In particular, furan and pyrrole, as well as their methylated derivatives, have been common targets of pyrolytic studies. The pyrolysis reactions of furan and its methylated derivatives have been shown to lead to various products, including CO, acetylene, acetaldehyde, propyne, and allene. Grela et al. observed that methylated furan is likely to undergo C—O bond scission, yielding either benzene and water, via the biradical •C(CH3)TCH—CHTC(CH3)O•, or to isomerize prior to decomposition to produce CO and C5H8.189 Organ and Mackie also suggested that the biradical intermediate was the most likely intermediate.190 The mechanism has since been re-evaluated. Fulle et al. noted that the major decomposition products of unsubstituted furan were formed via one of two pathways,191 one which resulted in C2H2 and ketene (H2CTCTO) and one which led to propyne and CO; Sendt et al. confirmed these pathways and proposed that they were achieved via 1,2-H transfer in the original furan molecule, which led to cyclic carbene intermediates.192 The pyrolysis of pyrrole produces a variety of products: hydrogen cyanide, propyne, allene, acetylene, cis-crotonitrile, and allyl cyanide, among them. Lifshitz et al. hypothesized that pyrrole undergoes 1,2-bond (N—C) cleavage, then an internal H-atom transfer, to yield a radical intermediate that can isomerize to either cis-crotonitrile or allyl cyanide, or dissociate to HCN and propyne.193 Bacskay et al. completed quantum chemical comparisons of the isoelectronic pyrrolyl and cyclopentadienyl radicals; they hypothesized that pyrrolyl radical is formed via C—H bond scission in the intermediate pyrrolenine (2H-pyrrole) rather than directly via N—H bond cleavage (Fig. 14).194 Mackie et al. explained a similar finding, postulating that it was the formation of pyrrolenine that dictated the rate at which pyrrole pyrolysis occurred.195 While most studies have focused on the pyrolytic unimolecular decomposition of these monoheteroaromatic compounds, our group has explored their oxidative decomposition. As with benzene, where phenylperoxy radical plays a major role in dictating oxidation pathways, we hypothesize that the peroxy radicals derived from heteroaromatic rings are reactive species of considerable interest for combustion and atmospheric reactions.
Fig. 14 Likely pyrolysis pathway of pyrrole, via intermediate pyrrolenine. Adapted from Reference 194.
THE CHEMISTRY OF REACTIVE RADICAL INTERMEDIATES
111
Barckholtz et al. surveyed a variety of computational methods and basis sets to select an appropriate theoretical model for study of these molecules, finding that DFT provided a good balance of accuracy and computational economy.196 This study also validated the use of heteroaromatic monocyclic rings as constructive models for their polycyclic analogues (by extension, this finding could also confirm the similarities between the chemistry of coal and these smaller model compounds). BDEs were compiled for a variety of polyheteroaromatic rings; the resulting values were compared to the corresponding monoheteroaromatics. For example, for benzofuran, the C—H BDE at the 2-position of the furan ring is 117.8 kcal/mol, which is 0.6 kcal/mol less than the corresponding BDE in furan itself. These calculations showed that increasing the number of rings in the compound did not have a substantial effect on BDE, except in the case of a C—H bond adjacent to a bridgehead junction when an electronegative heteroatom was present on the other side of the bridgehead. Even in such cases, the deviation between the monocyclic analogue and the polycyclic derivative was only 2 kcal/mol. In separate DFT studies, Fadden et al. examined the rearrangement pathways (Fig. 15) of peroxy radicals from azabenzenes197 and five-membered heteroaromatic rings.198 It was observed that each azaphenylperoxy radical can lose molecular oxygen (2 ! 1), rearrange to a dioxiranyl species (2 ! 3) or a dioxetanyl species (2 ! 4), or lose atomic oxygen (2 ! 5). Other unimolecular decomposition pathways afforded to alkylperoxy radicals (i.e., H-atom transfer and b-scission) are not possible for their aromatic analogs. From the calculated energies, several main conclusions were drawn. Loss of O2 is less endoergic at 298 K than loss of O-atom for most heteroaromatic peroxy radicals; two exceptions are 3-pyridinylperoxy radical, which mimics phenylperoxy radical in this aspect of its reactivity as well as many
Fig. 15 Unimolecular pathways available to heteroaromatic peroxy radicals; example shown for 2-pyridinylperoxy radical. Adapted from Reference 198.
112
C.J. HAYES ET AL.
others, and 3-pyridazinylperoxy radical, in which the oxy radical is a -radical (2A0 ) and maintains aromaticity not observed in the peroxy radical. Dioxiranyl formation is generally less endoergic than O2 and O-atom loss at 298 K; however, at temperatures greater than 500 K, the entropic contributions reverse the stabilities. Dioxetanyl intermediates are more strained and, therefore, unstable intermediates; a few exceptions are observed for compounds in which an alkyl chain is adjacent to a ring nitrogen and cyclization can form stable nitrosyl radicals (as for Pathway 4b for 2-pyridinylperoxy radical), but these reactions still incur high reaction barriers. Similar routes are available to peroxy radicals of O-, S-, N-, and O,N-containing five-membered ring heteroaromatics. The kinetic and thermodynamic parameters for the viable arylperoxy radical unimolecular dissociation steps were calculated for the furanylperoxy radicals; the effect of a second heteroatom was examined by a comparable approach for the oxazolylperoxy radicals. Thermodynamic parameters for these reactions were compared to those of the pyrrolylperoxy and thiophenylperoxy radicals. For smaller heteroaromatic peroxy radicals, loss of O-atom to form the corresponding aryloxy radical is preferred at 298 K to other decomposition routes. Dioxiranyl formation (Fig. 15, pathway 3) competes thermodynamically with oxygen atom loss (Fig. 15, pathway 5) in some cases and is universally more favorable than O2 loss (Fig. 15, pathway 1). The dioxetanyl route (Fig. 15, pathway 4) is disfavored for five-membered ring heteroaromatic peroxy radicals, often due to formation of an anti-Bredt double bond in the ring system. As with the azabenzenes, the dissociative pathways become more favorable than rearrangements at high temperatures. Overall, reactivity of the heteroaromatic peroxy radicals was shown to depend heavily on ring size. For azabenzylperoxy radicals, losing an oxygen atom is substantially unfavorable, and reversion to reactants (aryl radical þ O2) is a more likely dissociation pathway; the peroxy radical of the five-membered ring heteroaromatics can lose oxygen atom at a lower cost. For both sets of arylperoxy radicals, isomerization pathways are important at low temperatures. Additionally, intramolecular cyclizations compete with O-atom loss, and some cyclizations lead to nitroso radicals, creating implications via possible NOx formation. As with phenylperoxy radical, the azabenzylperoxy radicals have lower barriers for rearrangement than for loss of oxygen atom, and consequent products will influence overall combustion pathways. Alkylated heteroaromatics Substantially fewer studies have been published for the reactions of alkyl-substituted heteroaromatics, although these compounds also have implications for coal combustion. Several references discussed in the previous section contain information on methylated heteroaromatic rings. Mackie and coworkers completed experimental199,200 and theoretical201 studies of the pyrolytic decomposition of 2-picoline (2-methylpyridine). They concluded that decomposition proceeded mainly through o-pyridinyl and 2-picolinyl radicals. The former tended to decompose predominantly to yield cyanoacetylene, while the latter favored decomposition to a cyano-functionalized cyclopentadiene (Fig. 16).
THE CHEMISTRY OF REACTIVE RADICAL INTERMEDIATES
113
Fig. 16 Cyanocyclopentadiene.
Despite the authors’ assertion that alkylated heteroaromatic compounds provide a better model for fuel-bound nitrogen than do the unsubstituted heterocycles, their pyrolytic study remains the most comprehensive look at substituted heteroaromatic chemistry, even several years later.196–202 Kinetic studies are more common in the literature: Frerichs et al. examined the reaction of the picolines with oxygen atom,202 while Yeung and Elrod studied reactions of HO• with pyridine and its methyl- and ethyl-substituted derivatives.177 Both groups noted that the presence of nitrogen did not demonstrably affect the species’ chemistry; generally, reactivity is comparable to toluene. The oxidation pathways for alkylated heteroaromatics start with the formation of a radical species, via hydrogen atom loss or alkyl group homolytic bond cleavage. We calculated these BDEs for methyl- and ethyl-substituted derivatives of several key heteroaromatics (Tables 1–3).203 Few of these experimental values exist;204 therefore, Table 1 Thermodynamic and spin density information for methyl hydrogen atom loss reactions of methyl-substituted heteroaromatic rings. Enthalpies and energies in kcal/mol, obtained at the B3LYP/6–311þG**//B3LYP/6–31G* (designated as B3LYP) and CBS-QB3 (designated as CBS) levels
DH298
Toluene Pyrrole Furan Thiophene Oxazole Pyridine Pyridazine
DG298
( – )
Methyl
B3LYP
CBS
Experimental BDE
B3LYP
CBS
1 2 3 2 3 2 3 2 4 5 2 3 4 3 4
86.7 83.1 86.8 83.1 87.4 85.2 87.0 86.4 88.1 84.5 88.2 87.0 87.9 88.9 87.6
90.6 86.1 90.1 86.3 90.5 86.5 89.9 89.9 91.1 87.9 92.0 91.0 91.6 93.3 91.7
88.0–90.3a
79.4 75.3 78.9 75.3 79.5 84.2 88.1 78.7 80.2 76.6 80.5 79.6 80.6 81.3 80.5
83.8 78.9 82.4 78.6 82.7 79.1 82.2 82.3 83.3 80.1 84.7 83.7 84.6 85.8 84.6
96.0b
0.72 0.63 0.74 0.60 0.73 0.60 0.71 0.64 0.63 0.72 0.73 0.72 0.74 0.76 0.75
114
C.J. HAYES ET AL.
Table 1 (continued ) DH298
Pyrimidine Pyrazine
Methyl
B3LYP
CBS
2 4 5 2
89.5 89.3 87.5 88.0
93.1 92.7 91.4 92.3
DG298 Experimental BDE
( – )
B3LYP
CBS
82.4 81.9 80.7 80.5
86.7 85.5 84.7 85.0
0.73 0.75 0.72 0.72
See Fig. 13 for structures and numbering. a Reference 158. b Reference 173.
Table 2 Thermodynamic and spin density information for ethyl (or methylene) hydrogen atom loss reactions of ethyl-substituted heteroaromatic rings; enthalpies and energies in kcal/ mol, obtained at the B3LYP/6–311þG**//B3LYP/6–31G* (designated as B3LYP) and CBSQB3 (designated as CBS) levels
DH298
Ethylbenzene Pyrrole Furan Thiophene Oxazole Pyridine Pyridazine Pyrimidine Pyrazine a
Reference 118.
DG298
( – )
Ethyl
B3LYP
CBS
Experimental BDE
B3LYP
CBS
1 2 3 2 3 2 3 2 4 5 2 3 4 3 4 2 4 5 2
83.9 80.8 83.8 80.1 84.2 79.8 83.5 82.4 84.5 81.5 84.2 82.9 83.7 84.7 83.7 84.2 83.9 84.3 83.8
88.1 84.6 87.7 83.9 87.9 83.8 87.1 86.5 88.3 85.6 88.1 85.6 87.2 90.1 88.7 89.0 88.5 89.1 90.2
85.4–86.9a
75.2 72.2 75.3 71.6 75.4 71.1 74.4 74.1 76.0 73.0 75.2 74.8 74.5 77.6 75.1 76.1 75.7 74.9 75.1
79.7 75.9 78.9 75.5 79.1 75.2 78.1 78.4 79.9 77.1 80.0 77.2 78.7 83.1 79.7 80.9 80.4 80.5 81.4
0.68 0.61 0.71 0.57 0.69 0.55 0.67 0.61 0.68 0.60 0.67 0.69 0.69 0.68 0.68 0.69 0.70 0.66 0.68
THE CHEMISTRY OF REACTIVE RADICAL INTERMEDIATES
115
Table 3 Thermodynamic information (kcal/mol, 298 K, B3LYP/6–311þG**//B3LYP/ 6–31G*) for alkyl group loss reactions of methyl- and ethyl-substituted heteroaromatic rings
Pyrrole Furan Thiophene Oxazole Pyridine Pyridazine Pyrimidine Pyrazine
Methyl
DH298
DG298
Ethyl
DH298
DG298
2 3 2 3 2 3 2 4 5 2 3 4 3 4 2 4 5 2
106.1 104.3 108.8 105.7 103.9 100.9 109.8 106.9 110.8 94.1 98.3 97.6 96.2 97.1 97.4 90.3 99.7 94.9
89.3 87.7 92.1 89.1 87.3 84.2 93.3 90.3 94.1 77.9 82.1 81.7 79.7 81.2 81.5 74.1 84.1 78.5
2 3 2 3 2 3 2 4 5 2 3 4 3 4 2 4 5 2
101.1 99.1 103.9 100.6 99.1 95.6 104.9 102.1 105.9 89.3 93.4 92.7 91.4 92.2 92.5 89.7 94.9 87.1
87.1 85.6 89.9 86.8 85.3 81.6 91.1 88.3 92.1 75.5 79.4 78.9 77.7 78.6 78.8 75.9 81.1 72.3
we also briefly examined the chemistry of benzylperoxy radical, because it is a hydrocarbon analog for methylated heteroaromatics and a more common experimental target. Calculations at the CBS-QB3 level closely replicated toluene’s experimentally determined geometry, spectroscopic information, and BDE; additionally, DFT (B3LYP) calculations replicated the qualitative trends predicted by the CBSQB3 calculations. Quantitatively, the DFT calculations consistently underpredicted the BDEs and reaction energies relative to CBS-QB3. The reactivity of methyl- and ethyl-substituted azabenzenes was explored by calculation of the homolytic BDEs and free energies for alkyl C—H hydrogen atom and alkyl side-chain loss. These values were analyzed as a function of heteroatom, ring size, side chain length, spin density, and temperature. Furthermore, the impact on the thermodynamic values derived from the harmonic oscillator approximation was analyzed, by treating side-chain torsions as hindered rotors. At 298 K, loss of hydrogen atom to form a benzylic-like radical is roughly 10 kcal/mol more favorable than loss of the alkyl group, due to the electron delocalization possible for the benzylic-like radical, regardless of ring size or heteroatom; this trend is consistently exhibited over a wide temperature range (T = 298–2000 K) although both reactions become increasingly favorable with increasing temperature, due to entropic effects on the free energy (Fig. 17). Spin densities for heteroaromatic radicals correlate well with the BDE values: the more diffuse the spin density, the lower the corresponding BDE. This is most dramatically evident for the five-membered ring heteroaromatics. Both the harmonic oscillator and hindered rotor treatments give comparable values for reaction enthalpies and free energies. The ethyl derivatives have lower reaction enthalpies and free energies than methyl derivatives.
116
C.J. HAYES ET AL. 90
90
80
20
20
10
10
0
0
13
10
70
50
30
30
00 15 00 18 00 20 00
30
0
30
00
40
0
40
0
50
0 70 0 10 00 13 00 15 00 18 00 20 00
50
0
60
ΔG rxn (kcal/mol)
70
60
50
ΔG rxn (kcal/mol)
70
80
(b)
(a)
Temperature (K)
Fig. 17 Variation of reaction free energy (kcal/mol) with temperature (K) for alkyl C—H hydrogen atom loss in (a) five-membered ring methyl-substituted heteroaromatic rings and (b) six-membered ring methyl-substituted heteroaromatic rings.
With respect to predicting the chemistry of larger heteroaromatic systems (such as those in coal), these calculations suggest that both hydrogen atom and alkyl group loss can contribute to the combustion of coal in initiation reactions; the subsequent oxidation pathways of both the aromatic peroxy radicals (previously explored197,198) and the alkylated aromatic peroxy radicals are of interest. Reactivity will likely increase with increasing alkylation of a subunit, and the azabenzene units are more likely to react than the five-membered heteroaromatic rings. The initial steps of radical formation are expected to become more favorable at higher temperatures, primarily due to entropic considerations. Oxidative decomposition of alkylated heteroaromatics When alkylated heteroaromatic radicals are formed, these species can rapidly react with O2 to form various peroxy radicals. Again, it seems likely that these resultant reactive species will have an impact on overall combustion processes. Benzylperoxy radical was initially explored computationally to obtain a qualitative picture of peroxy radical decomposition for species containing both alkyl and aromatic components; these findings were then extended to peroxy radicals of methyl- and ethylsubstituted azabenzylperoxy radicals.205 The alkyl chains of these species are large enough than conformeric considerations are a concern. We performed calculations to analyze rotational profiles for alkyl group torsions to isolate the most stable conformation. In all cases, rotation of and alkyl dihedral angle occurred with a
THE CHEMISTRY OF REACTIVE RADICAL INTERMEDIATES
117
Fig. 18 Unimolecular pathways for 2-picolinylperoxy radical, a representative peroxy radical for alkylated azabenzenes.
barrier less than 5 kcal/mol. As shown in Fig. 18, alkylated heteroaromatic peroxy radicals (2) can revert to reactants (1) or cyclize via attack of the side chain’s terminal O at a position ipso (3) or ortho (4) to the alkylperoxy chain. Oxygen atom loss can occur (5). Given the presence of the exocyclic methylene group, isomerization via H-atom transfer (6) can occur from a methylene carbon to the terminal peroxy oxygen; this cannot occur in the nonalkylated parent compounds. Additionally, entire side chain loss (as dioxirane in the case of methyl-substituted aromatics) is possible (7). Calculated kinetic and thermodynamic values for unimolecular decomposition of benzylperoxy radical and 2-picolinylperoxy radical (2-methylpyridinylperoxy radical) at 298 K are presented in Table 4 (representative structures shown in Fig. 18). The energies for decomposition of these two compounds are similar: bicyclic ring formation at the carbon ortho to the alkyl group (pathway 4) occurs with a barrier of 30 kcal/mol; cyclization at the carbon ipso to the alkyl group (pathway 3) occurs with a barrier of 35–40 kcal/mol; internal H-atom transfer (pathway 6) occurs with a barrier of 40 kcal/ mol. The added functionality afforded by the nitrogen atom in 2-picolinylperoxy radical allows a cyclization resulting in a stable N—O radical after O—O bond scission (pathway 4b), which has potential for yielding precursors to NOx chemistry; however, this process has a substantially high barrier (50 kcal/mol) and is unlikely to be a factor at atmospheric temperatures. While the qualitative trends were replicated between benzylperoxy radical and 2-picolinylperoxy radical, the latter has slightly higher reaction barriers and energies in nearly every case, which can be attributed to the relative stabilization of the allylic systems in the cyclized derivatives. CBS-QB3 calculations helped demonstrate that the DFT (B3LYP) approach provides good qualitative predictions for the energetic trends. The trends for 2-picolinylperoxy radical were similar for other picolinylperoxy radicals, as well as peroxy radicals of alkylated diazabenzenes (i.e., pyridazine, pyrimidine, and pyrazine). It was observed that the presence of a second ring nitrogen has little effect on either the identity or energetics of the preferred pathways. Likewise, the ethyl
118
C.J. HAYES ET AL.
Table 4 Comparison of reaction pathway energetics (kcal/mol) for benzylperoxy radical and 2-picolinylperoxy radical at 298 K, via B3LYP/6–311þG**//B3LYP/6–31G*. Numbers refer to pathways depicted in Fig. 18. All enthalpies and free energies are relative to the peroxy radical (2); when preceded by TS, the relative data are the enthalpy and free energies of activation Benzylperoxy radical B3LYP
2!1 TS(2–3) 2!3 TS(2–4a) 2 ! 4a TS(2–6) 2!5 2!6 2!7
CBS-QB3
DH
DG
–16 35.7 33.2 33.5 35.6 37.9 56.5 –33.9 53.7
–5.5 37.2 34.2 35.6 23.7 38.9 47.3 –35.4 42.9
DH
Experiment
DG
–22.7 30.1 25.8 29.7 14.6 38.4 61.9
–12.2 31.7 26.9 31.8 15.1 39.2 52.5
55.8
45.3
a
DH
DG
–20.1b, –21.8c
–12.2
a
2-Picolinylperoxy radical B3LYP
2!1 TS(2–3) 2!3 TS(2–4a) 2 ! 4a TS(2–4b) 2 ! 4b 2!5 TS(2–6) 2!6 2!7
CBS-QB3
DH
DG
DH
DG
16.3 37.1 34.2 30.4 20.6 47.1 –5.8 61.6 38.0 –24.7 49.2
6.5 39.4 35.7 33.2 23.2 49.8 –4.1 53.0 39.4 –33.6 38.7
22.7 31.0 26.1 25.6 13.2
13.2 33.4 27.9 28.7 16.0
37.6 –23.7
39.2 –32.4
Where applicable, 4a refers to cyclization at a ring carbon and 4b refers to cyclization at nitrogen. a Geometry could not be optimized. b Reference 161. c Reference 162.
analogs favored similar reaction pathways, with energies of activation and reaction varying by only 2 kcal/mol between the methyl and the ethyl analogs. When present, the disparities in the reaction energetics were rationalized via consideration of the inductive effects caused by the nitrogen atom(s) and varying amounts of geometric strain introduced in the rearrangement pathways. Fig. 19 shows that with increasing temperature, formation of 1, 5, and 7 benefit entropically and become substantially exoergic reactions. Formation of 3 and 4a exhibit little entropic benefit. As shown in Fig. 20, the reaction barriers similarly
THE CHEMISTRY OF REACTIVE RADICAL INTERMEDIATES
119
80 60
ΔGreaction (kcal/mol)
40 20 0 –20
0
1000
500
1500
2000
2500
×
–40
× ×
–60
×
–80
× ×
–100
×
–120
×
–140
T (K)
Fig. 19 DGrxn versus temperature for the unimolecular pathways of 2-picolinylperoxy radical. 2 ! 3 denoted by open diamond; 2 ! 4a denoted by solid square; 2 ! 4b denoted by open triangle; 2 ! 5 denoted by dash; 2 ! 6 denoted by symbol ; 2 ! 7 denoted by solid diamond. All energies calculated at the B3LYP/6–311þG(d,p)//B3LYP/6–31G(d) level of theory.
50 45 40 ΔGactivation (kcal/mol)
× ×
35
×
30
×
25
× ×
20
×
15
×
10 5 0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
T (K)
Fig. 20 DGactivation versus temperature for unimolecular pathways for 2-picolinylperoxy radical. Activation energy for 2 ! 3 denoted by open diamond; activation energy for 2 ! 4a denoted by solid square; activation energy for 2 ! 4b denoted by open triangle; activation energy for 2 ! 6 denoted by symbol . All energies calculated at the B3LYP/ 6–311þG(d,p)//B3LYP/6–31G(d) level of theory.
120
C.J. HAYES ET AL.
demonstrate minimal entropic effects. Formation of 4b has a similarly small entropic benefit but maintains a high reaction barrier, such that any NOx formation via this process is expected to be minimal except at extremely high temperatures. Formation of 6 exhibits a precipitous drop in its barrier and is the dominant processes at T 1250 K. This last reaction is of considerable interest given its relevance to both lowand high-temperature combustion, since it essentially constitutes a dissociative rearrangement pathway. Both the direct and the indirect decomposition intermediates (1, 5, 6, and 7) will play a substantial role in combustion as temperatures rise above 298 K, as peroxy radicals, themselves ROS, demonstrate the potential to generate reactive O-atom and hydroxyl radical. The overall chemistry of alkylated azabenzylperoxy radicals was consistent regardless of alkyl substitution or number of nitrogen atoms. The picolinylperoxy radicals provide excellent models for the chemistry exhibited by this larger class of species. Moreover, aromatic hydrocarbons can themselves predict several aspects of this chemistry, the exception being those processes involving oxidation or rearrangement with ring nitrogens. When this approach is extended to alkylated derivatives of the five-membered heteroaromatic rings,206 the energetic trends can be considered in light of ring size and heteroatom effects. In general, the same six pathways are available, such that rearrangements and dissociations are observed to contribute to the chemistry of these species. Many trends are consistent between both sets of alkylated heteroaromatics: increasing alkyl substitution leads to small stabilization of reaction barriers and energies. Increasing temperature leads to a shift in preference for the dissociation pathways. However, a difference was observed for smaller rings: while cyclizations are favored pathways at 298 K regardless of parent ring size, alkyl-substituted heteroaromatic peroxy radicals of the five-membered rings cyclize in such a manner as to generate an allylic radical system (cyclizing at a position either ipso or ortho to the side chain). On the other hand, alkyl-heteroaromatic peroxy radicals of the sixmembered rings preferred to form five-membered rings via ortho cyclization, due to their increased stability over spirodioxetane structures (which would result from ipso cyclization). This general trend is represented in Fig. 21.
Fig. 21 Qualitative depiction of favorable cyclization pathways for representative peroxy radicals of methyl heteroaromatics (top, pyridine and bottom, furan). Cyclization for the alkylated six-membered heteroaromatics is driven by the thermodynamic stability of the resulting ring, while cyclization for the alkylated five-membered heteroaromatics is dictated by which pathway allows the generation of a stable allylic radical system.
THE CHEMISTRY OF REACTIVE RADICAL INTERMEDIATES
121
Heteroatom identity also has an impact on the reactions of interest. Oxygen, nitrogen, and sulfur atoms affected heteroaromatic chemistry to slightly different quantitative extents (though qualitative trends were consistent), and the effect of multiple heteroatoms (as in oxazole) led to small differences in reaction energetics. Notably, the pyrrole, oxazole, and thiophene analogs reacted to form various species wherein their heteroatoms are oxidized, and these effects were unique to each heterocycle. Thus, data for aromatic hydrocarbon species are useful in estimating the energetics of these species but cannot completely predict their chemistry, due to the propensity of increasing functionalization to lead to different products and pathways. Relative to nonalkylated heteroaromatic peroxy radicals,197,198 we observed that alkylated species demonstrated a greater affinity for intramolecular reactions, due to the length and flexibility of their side chains. Dissociative reactions were less favorable for alkylated derivatives, due to a reduction of aromatic character. Our studies have provided important details regarding the oxidative decomposition of alkyl-substituted heteroaromatic rings: in particular, pathways originating with peroxy radicals derived from the heteroaromatic rings and temperature effects on these pathways. We have shown that the alkylated five-membered heteroaromatics demonstrate certain unique tendencies in their reactivity. Given the differences in reactivity between the five- and the six-membered heteroaromatics, as well as between the alkylated and the nonalkylated heteroaromatics, it seems likely that the chemical behavior of coal could vary somewhat depending on the abundance and nature of the cyclic subunits present in its structure. However, these discrepancies are mainly limited to the variety of products formed via combustion rather than the overall kinetics and thermodynamics of the relevant processes.
4
Future challenges in combustion chemistry
In closing this review, it seems logical to highlight some of the most recent progress in combustion chemistry. Alternate forms of energy and methods of combustion are continually being developed, thereby continuously invoking new challenges for experimentalists and theoreticians. Some alternatives involve new combustion processes, as in the case of homogenous-charge compression-ignition (HCCI)207 chemistry, which depends on autoignition (low temperature) chemistry within a homogenous gas mixture (unlike a SI engine). This new combustion method has the potential to increase fuel efficiency and decrease harmful emissions.208,209 One significant issue with HCCI is adequately controlling fuel ignition during the compression stroke of the engine; this is essentially a kinetics problem, requiring understanding of the reaction rates and mechanisms of the radical species generated by the fuel. Thus, reactions normally associated with low-temperature combustion and often treated cursorily in oxidative mechanisms can have a greater impact on combustibility. In this review, we are most interested in the implications of the changing energy landscape for the reactive pathways involved. As the nature of the fuels used in everyday life change, the reactive radical intermediates formed in their combustion will also change. We will examine the context of two classes of relevant fuel developments.
122
C.J. HAYES ET AL.
FUEL ADDITIVES
Oxygenated molecules have long been used to augment gasoline formulations. For instance, since the elimination of tetraethyl lead (Pb(C2H5)4) as an additive. oxygenates have been used as gasoline additives to reduce harmful CO emissions and increase a fuel’s octane rating. The most prominent oxygenate has been methyl tert-butyl ether (MTBE); however, this additive has since been flagged as a potential carcinogen and odorous component that can taint water supplies.210 Moreover, MTBE necessitates the use of the industrial byproduct, isobutene, for its generation, further competing with crude oil supplies for a value-added product. As the downsides to MTBE use have become more apparent, ethanol has emerged as an attractive alternative oxygenate. Ethanol does not demonstrate the negative health effects of MTBE, and moreover, it can be produced from renewable (biomass) materials.211 Compared to MTBE, ethanol has a higher oxygen-to-carbon ratio. Ethanol has been used primarily as a gasoline additive; in fact in the years since the Energy Policy Act of 1992,212 a shift has occurred, such that current manufacturers are building cars with the capacity to run on fuel blends of 85 and 95% ethanol, along with a small amount of gasoline – these fuels are often referred to as E85 or E95, respectively. (However, some engine modifications are necessary for vehicles to run effectively on blended fuels with greater than 20% ethanol.) This advance has been hampered by the general lack of availability of ethanol at fueling stations, a shortage that is being gradually remedied. Currently, the cost benefits of using ethanol over gasoline are substantial, but the availability of the former is still limited.213 Ethanol itself demonstrates several drawbacks as an alternative fuel, despite its increasing availability. Most notably, ethanol absorbs water. Thus, it cannot travel through existing gasoline pipelines, as the water could subsequently separate and freeze during colder temperatures, possibly bursting the pipelines; moreover, ethanol is also corrosive.214 Thus, ethanol has to be transported via other means (a fact which, ironically, generally necessitates the use of gasoline, diesel, or other fuel and results in a higher cost that negates one monetary benefit of using ethanol as a fuel). Moreover, ethanol evaporates relatively quickly, and so in warmer temperatures, it must be blended carefully.215 Butanol possesses the chemical benefits of ethanol while avoiding its drawbacks. Its use is considerably less temperature-sensitive: it is six times less evaporative than ethanol, and it is not corrosive, so can be shipped via existing fuel pipelines.216 In terms of fuel benefits, due to its higher number of carbons, it has higher energy content (110,000 Btu/gallon) than ethanol (84,000 Btu/gallon) and is comparable to gasoline (115,000 Btu/gallon); it can also be generated more easily from biomass than can ethanol.217 Unlike ethanol, it can be used as a direct replacement for gasoline rather than as an additive therein, since butanol’s air/fuel ratio is comparable to that of gasoline.218 Finally, butanol’s primary combustion byproduct is carbon dioxide; it avoids formation of the pollutants NOx, SOx, and CO.219 Thus, butanol is a potential fuel of substantial interest. Studies have been completed specifically on combustion processes of ethanol and butanol, and several of the peroxy and oxy radical species have been examined.95–108
THE CHEMISTRY OF REACTIVE RADICAL INTERMEDIATES
123
Marinov proposed an exhaustive mechanism for ethanol’s combustion.220 Cavalli et al. examined the initial reaction of HO• radical with 1-butanol by FTIR spectroscopy,221 and Chen et al. studied the anodic oxidation of this species.222 Recent experiments by McEnally and Pfefferle led them to propose that butanol combustion primarily occurs via a complex fission reaction rather than H-atom abstraction.223 While we have discussed the historical background of the main gasoline oxygenates, it is worthwhile to note that several other species have been discussed in this context as well. Notably, it has been shown that simply adding oxygen to a given combustion environment does not in itself achieve soot reduction; the role of the oxygen within the structure of the oxygenate plays a major part. For instance, Westbrook et al. completed a modeling study on the effect of various oxygenated hydrocarbons on soot production.224 They saw a significant reduction in the number of alkynyl radicals serving as soot precursors in a diesel flame via the inclusion of alcohol (ROH) and ether (ROR0 ) additives, but noted a lesser effect when esters (RCO2R0 ) were included. This is due to the fact that esters can readily fragment to generate CO2, so that their oxygen atoms are not involved in the processes that can affect soot reduction. Similarly, Sinha and Thomson225 studied three C3 oxygenated hydrocarbons – isopropyl alcohol, dimethoxy methane (DMM), and dimethyl carbonate (DMC) – all in comparison to propane, noting different effects for each. DMM and DMC lack C—C bonds. Thus, the concentration of the alkenyl and alkynyl radicals necessary to form benzene and larger aromatic hydrocarbons is correspondingly smaller in these species and soot production drops. Nag et al.226 have postulated that the identity of a given oxygenate contributes to the resultant balance of CO and CO2 in the emission pool; CO has a greater propensity for PAH reduction than does CO2. The implications for power output and efficiency are important as well, since a significant amount (33%) of the eventual heat is generated by the conversion of CO to CO2 in the combustion environment (usually mediated by HO• radical). The structure of an oxygenate has notable implications for both its reactivity and its propensity for the formation of emissions.
BIODIESEL
Having alluded briefly to biomass compounds in the previous section, as sources for ethanol and butanol, we turn now to the potential of these species as fundamental alternatives to fossil fuels. In 1912, Rudolf Diesel presciently stated,227 ‘‘The use of vegetable oils for engine fuels may seem insignificant today. But such oils may in the course of time become as important as petroleum and the coal tar products of the present time.’’ Biodiesel can be produced from a variety of sources,228 including animal fats (on small scales), algae, and vegetable oils: the fuel itself is produced via esterification of these lipids with methanol or ethanol. In terms of the overall benefits and sources of fuels, several reviews are currently available. As early as 1987, Schwab et al. reported on the potential of vegetable oils for forming diesel fuels.229 More recently, Graboski and McCormick,230 Srivastava and Prasad,231 and Lin et al.232 have reviewed the fuel properties (emissions, engine performance, etc.) of
124
C.J. HAYES ET AL.
these species. Ma and Hanna have compiled a review of the general benefits of biodiesel chemistry.233 The emergence of biofuels as potential energy sources demands a mechanistic approach comparable to those currently in use for hydrocarbon compounds. Biofuels are commonly esters (RCO2R0 ) of large long-chain fatty acids, so their reactivity will depend on more factors than these extant mechanisms. Kulkarni and Dalai have summarized mechanistic aspects of biodiesel chemistry, with respect to waste cooking oil.234 Thermolytic decomposition can yield alkanes, alkenes, ketones, esters, and small acids. Oxidative decomposition leads to highly functionalized peroxy radicals, which then can add a hydrogen atom to form hydroperoxides, ultimately decomposing to aldehydes, hydrocarbons, and acids; additionally, these peroxy radicals might dimerize or oligomerize if excess oxygen is present. Hydrolytic reactions comprise an additional possibility: triglycerides readily decompose to glycerol, monoglycerides, diglycerides, and free fatty acids (FFA), in the presence of water. Zhenyi et al. have completed thermodynamic calculations on the pyrolysis of vegetable oils, postulating that, for a given ester, the key initiation step proceeds via breaking of the alkyl (sp3) C—O bond.235 We can summarize the different possible initiation routes for a given triglyceride, familiar from our previous discussions (Fig. 22). Even from this basic view, it is clear that several classes of reactive radical intermediates will play a role in biofuel combustion: alkyl (sp3) and alkenyl (sp2) radicals are readily formed, as well as peroxy radicals and functionalized derivatives of each of these original species.
Fig. 22 Initial reaction steps for fatty acid ester decomposition, represented by ethyl butanoate, which can decompose via thermolysis (pyrolysis), oxidation, or hydrolysis.
THE CHEMISTRY OF REACTIVE RADICAL INTERMEDIATES
125
Mechanism development traditionally depends on the inclusion of data for relevant, smaller compounds; that philosophy will apply in this case, where the reactions of both small hydrocarbons and small esters are of interest. Mechanisms for methyl butanoate (CH3CH2CH2CO2CH3) have been developed by Gail et al.236 and Curran et al.;237 the latter notes the NTC range demonstrated by this species, suggesting that future work may benefit by exploring comparisons to hydrocarbon chemistry. Good and Francisco have modeled the tropospheric oxidation mechanism of methyl formate (HCO2CH3).238 Metcalfe et al. explored unimolecular decomposition pathways and derived combustion mechanisms for methyl butanoate and ethyl propanoate, using shock-tube experiments and CBS-QB3 calculations.239 Recent studies by Glaude et al.,240 Schwartz et al.,241 and Sarathy et al.242 have provided experimental information on larger esters, in an effort to model further reactions with implications for biofuel combustion. This area is of significant interest, and it is expected that the next few years will provide a more thorough understanding of the important species and relevant mechanisms involved in biofuel combustion.
5
Conclusions
Throughout this review, we have provided a historical context for understanding combustion chemistry as it applies to some of the most fundamental hydrocarbon compounds. We have explored the implications of these processes for larger and increasingly functionalized molecules. These species can be used to model the chemistry of petroleum and coal, in addition to smaller hydrocarbon fuels. Combustion is a complex topic, such that both theoretical and experimental methods are useful in exploring chemistry with implications for high-temperature oxidation and lowtemperature atmospheric reactions. In particular, the master equation methods developed over the past few decades can consider the collective chemistry of thousands of elementary steps to predict the overall oxidation of a given fuel; the kinetics and thermodynamics of each of these elementary steps can be generated via experiment or computational modeling. ROS and other radical intermediates dictate the oxidative decomposition of fuels. We have noted that peroxy radical intermediates provide an enormous amount of flexibility in the combustion of a given compound, specifically in the unimolecular steps available to that compound. In an instructive display of the interaction of experimental and theoretical techniques, rearrangement pathways of the peroxy radicals have been modeled computationally and provide justification for several unexpected products. At the start of the twenty-first century, efforts are underway to decrease society’s dependence on fossil fuels. It is clear that alternate energy forms will bring with them their own sets of reactive radical intermediates and revisit the important intermediates seen from smaller model compounds, as we consider future challenges in combustion chemistry. We expect that advances in experimental techniques and computational approaches will correspondingly be developed in the years ahead.
126
C.J. HAYES ET AL.
Acknowledgments We are grateful to Dr. Timothy Barckholtz (ExxonMobil Research and Engineering) for helpful discussions and for providing Fig. 3. We extend sincere thanks to Dr. Donald Burgess, Jr. (NIST) for his help in the editing of this review.
References 1. Gronert S. J Org Chem 2006;71:1209–19. 2. Zerefos CS, Isaksen ISA, Ziomas I. Chemistry and radiation changes in the ozone layer. Boston: Kluwer Academic Publishers; 2000. 3. Smith GP, Golden DM, Frenklach M, Moriarty NW, Eiteneer B, Goldenberg M, et al.
[Online. Internet. Accessed 1 June 2007]. 4. Compiled by Glassman I. Combustion. 3rd ed. San Diego: Academic Press; 1996. 5. Schlegel HB. J Chem Phys 1986;84:4530–4. 6. (a) Semenov NN. Some problems in chemical kinetics and reactivity. Princeton (NJ): Princeton University Press; 1958. (b) Semenov NN. Chemical kinetics and chain reactions. Oxford: The Clarendon Press; 1973. 7. Kee RJ, Coltrin ME, Glarborg P. Chemically reacting flow: theory and practice. Hoboken (NJ): John Wiley and Sons; 2003. 8. Courtesy of Tim Barckholtz, ExxonMobil Research and Engineering. 9. The NTC phenomenon actually varies with pressure and combustion environment; it is much different in a jet engine than in a diesel engine, which in turn is much different than in an internal combustion engine, which in turn is much different from a flat-flame burner. For the purposes of this review, we have focused on a simplified case. 10. Monks PS. Chem Soc Rev 2005;34:376–95. 11. Atkinson R, Arey, J. Chem Rev 2003;103:4605–38. 12. Atkinson R, Baulch DL, Cox RA, Crowley JN, Hampson RF, Hynes RG, et al. Atmos Chem Phys 2004;4:1461–738. 13. Sander SP, Friedl RR, Ravishankara AR, Golden DM, Kolb CE, Kurylo MJ, et al. Chemical Kinetics and Photochemical Data for Use in Atmospheric Studies: Evaluation Number 15. Jet Propulsion Laboratory Publication 06–2. July 2006. NASA/Jet Propulsion Laboratory, Pasadena, CA.
[accessed 3 December 2007]. 14. Pate CT, Sprung JL, Pitts JN, Jr. Org Mass Spec 2005;11:552–5. 15. Finlayson-Pitts BJ, Pitts JN. Chemistry of the upper and lower atmosphere: theory, experiments, and applications. San Diego (CA): Academic Press; 2000. 16. Saunders SM, Jenkin ME, Derwent RG, Pilling MJ. Atmos Chem 2003;3:161–80. 17. Jenkin ME, Saunders SM, Wagner V, Pilling MJ. Atmos Chem 2003;3:181–93. 18. (a) Warnatz J, Maas U, Dibble RW. Combustion: physical and chemical fundamentals, modeling and simulation, experiments, pollutant formation. New York: Springer; 2001. (b) Williams A, Pourkashanian M, Jones JM, Rowlands, L. J Inst Energy, 1997;70:102–13. (c) Streit GE, Spall DE, Hall JH. Environ Sci Technol 1987;21:519–25. 19. Tsang W, Lifshitz, A. Ann Rev Phys Chem 1990;41:559. 20. Casavecchia P. Rep Prog Phys 2000;63:355. 21. (a) Chen P, Colson SD, Chupka WA, Berson JA. J Phys Chem 1986;90:2319. (b) Kohn DW, Clauberg H, Chen P. Rev Sci Instrum 1992;63:4003. 22. (a) Rohrs HW, Wickham-Jones T, Ellison GB, Berry D, Argrow BM. Rev Sci Instrum 1995;66:2430–41. (b) Zhang X, Maccarone AT, Nimlos MR, Kato S, Bierbaum VM, Ellison GB, et al. J Chem Phys 2007;126:44312. (c) Zhou D, Nag M, Russel AL, Read D, Rohrs HW, Gross ML, et al. Sil Chem 2005;3:117–22.
THE CHEMISTRY OF REACTIVE RADICAL INTERMEDIATES
127
23. Raffaelli A, Saba, A. Mass Spec Rev 2003;22:318–31. 24. Cool T, Qi F, McIlroy A, Westmoreland PR, Law M, Poisson L, et al. Rev Sci Instrum 2005;76:941021–7. 25. Wolfrom J. Faraday Discuss 2001;119:1–26. 26. Crosley DR. Laser probes for Combustion Chemistry (ACS Symposium Series 134). Washington, DC: American Chemical Society; 1980. 27. Eckbreth AC. Laser diagnostics for combustion temperatures and species. 2nd ed. Amsterdam B.V., Netherlands: Gordon and Breach Publishers; 1996. 28. Westbrook CK, Mizobuchi Y, Poinsot TJ, Smith PJ, Warnatz, J. Proc Combust Inst 2005;30:125–57. 29. Laidler KJ. Chemical kinetics. New York: Harper & Row, Publishers, Inc.; 1987. 30. Wigner, EPZ. Phys Chem Abst B 1932;19:203. 31. (a) Rice OK, Ramsperger HC. J Am Chem Soc 1928;50:617–20. (b) Kassel LS. J Phys Chem 1928;32:1065–79. (c) Marcus RA. J Chem Phys 1952;20:359–64. (d) Gilbert RG, Smith SC. Theory of unimolecular and recombination reactions. Oxford: Blackwell Scientific Publications; 1990. (e) Forst W. Theory of unimolecular reactions. New York: Academic Press; 1973. (f) Robinson PJ, Holbrook KA. Unimolecular reactions. New York: Wiley; 1972. 32. Miller JA, Klippenstein SJ. J Phys Chem A 2006;110:10528–44. 33. Hehre WJ, Radom L, Schleyer, PVR, Pople JA. Ab initio molecular orbital theory. New York: John Wiley and Sons; 1986. 34. (a) Parr RG, Yang, W. Density functional theory in atoms and molecules. New York: Oxford University Press; 1989. (b) Labanowski JW, Andzelm, J. Density functional methods in chemistry. New York: Springer; 1991. (c) Becke AD. Phys Rev A 1988;38:3098–100. (d) Lee C, Yang, W, Parr RG. Phys Rev B 1988;37:785–9. (e) Becke AD. J Chem Phys 1993;98:1372–7. 35. Kee RJ, Rupley FM, Meeks LM, Miller JA. A fortran chemical kinetics package for the analysis of gas-phase chemical kinetics. Livermore (CA): Sandia National Laboratories; 1996 [SAND96–8216]. Kee RJ, Rupley FM, Miller JA, Coltrin ME, Grcar JF, Meeks E, Moffat HK, Lutz AE, Dixon-Lewis G, Smooke MD, Warnatz J, Evans GH, Larson RS, Mitchell RE, Petzold LR, Reynolds WC, Caracotsios M, Stewart WE, Glarborg P. CHEMKIN Collection, Release 3.5. San Diego (CA): Reaction Design, Inc.; 1999. 36. Lightfoot PD. Atmos Environ 1992;26A:180. 37. (a) Wallington TJ, Dagaut R, Kurylo MJ. Chem Rev 1992;92:667–710. (b) Wallington TJ, Nielsen OJ, Sehested J. In: Alfassi Z, editor. Peroxyl radicals. New York: John Wiley and Sons; 1997. 38. (a) Lesclaux R, Lightfoot PD, Veyret B. Poll Atmos 1991;10:69–79. (b) Lesclaux, R. Recent developments in peroxy radical chemistry. Global Atmospheric Change and its Impact on Regional Air Quality (NATO Science Series IV: Earth and Environmental Sciences, Ed. Barnes, I. Norwell, MA: Kluwer Academic Publishers, 2002;16:79–84. 39. Batt L. Int J Chem Kinet 1979;11:977–93. 40. (a) Hughes KJ, Tura´nyi T, Clague A, Pilling MJ. Int J Chem Kinet 2001;33:513–38. (b) Konnov AA. 28th Symposium (Int.) on Combustion, Edinburgh, 2000. Abstr Symp Pap. p. 317. (c) Warnatz J. In: Gardiner WC, Jr, editors.Combustion chemistry. New York: Springer-Verlag; 1984 [chapter 5]. 41. Zaslonko IS, Mozzhukhin EV, Smirnov VN, Tyurin AN. Kinet Katal 1991;24:131–53. 42. Lossing FP. Ann NY Acad Sci 1957;67:499–517. 43. Burcat A, Kudchadker S. Acta Chim Acad Scient Hung 1979;101:249–58. 44. Ruscic B, Berkowitz J. Preprints Papers Am Soc Div Fuel Chem 1991;36:1571–5. 202nd American Chemical Society National Meeting, New York, August 25–30, 1991. 45. Martinez E, Albaladejo J, Jiminez E, Notario A, Diaz de Mera Y. Chem Phys Lett 2000;329:191–9. 46. Wollenhaupt M, Crowley JN. J Phys Chem A 2000;104:6429–38. 47. Carter JT, Cook DB. J Mol Struct: THEOCHEM 1991;83:111–22. 48. Page M, Lin MC, He Y, Choudhury TK. J Phys Chem 1989;93:4404–8.
128
C.J. HAYES ET AL.
49. 50. 51. 52. 53. 54. 55. 56. 57. 58. 59. 60.
Pan XM, Fu Z, Li ZS, Sun CC, Sun H, Su ZM, et al. Chem Phys Lett 2005;409:98–104. Sun Y, Huang X-R, Li Z-S, Sun C-C. Gao Xue Hua Xue 2002;23:278–82. Pang X, Feng W, Wang Y, Zhang S. Wuli Huaxue Xuebao 1996;12:391–5. Gomez N, Henon E, Bohr F, Devolder, P. J Phys Chem A 2001;105:11204–11. Simonaitis R, Heicklen J. J Phys Chem 1974;78:2417–21. Cox RA, Tyndall GS. Chem Phys Lett 1979;65:357–60. Kan CS, Calvert JG. Chem Phys Lett 1979;63:111–4. Wallington TJ, Maricq MM, Ellermann T, Nielsen OJ. J Phys Chem 1992;96:982–6. Ghigo G, Maranzana A, Tonachini G. J Chem Phys 2003;118:10575–83. Lightfoot PD, Lesclaux R, Veyret B. J Phys Chem 1990;94:700–7. Lesar A, Hodoscek M, Drougas E, Kosmas AM. J Phys Chem A 2006;110:7898–903. Biggs P, Conosa-Mas CE, Frachebod JM, Shallcross DE, Wayne RP. J Chem Soc Faraday Trans 1994;90:1205–10. Hunziker HE, Wendt HR. J Chem Phys 1976;64:3488. Pushkarsky MB, Zalyubovsky SJ, Miller TA. J Chem Phys 2000;112:10695. Enami S, Yamanaka T, Nakayama T, Hashimoto S, Kawasaki M, Shallcross DE, et al. J Phys Chem A 2007;111:3342–8. (a) Knox JH, Wells CHJ. Trans Faraday Soc 1963;59:2786. (b) Knox JH, Wells CHJ. Trans Faraday Soc 1963;59:2801. (c) Knox JH. Combust Flame 1965;9:297. (d) Baker RR, Baldwin RR, Walker RW. J Chem Soc Faraday Trans 1 1975;71:756. (e) Baldwin RR, Cleugh CJ, Walker RW. J Chem Soc Faraday Trans 1 1976;72:1715. (f) Batt L, Robinson GN. Int J Chem Kinet 1979;11:1045. (g) Baldwin RR, Bennett JP, Walker RW. J Chem Soc Faraday Trans 1 1980;76:1075. (h) Baldwin RR, Pickering IA, Walker RW. J Chem Soc Faraday Trans 1 1980;76:2374. Hickel B. J Phys Chem 1975;79:1054. Dechaux JC, Delfosse L. Combust Flame 1979;34:169. Baker RR, Baldwin RR, Walker RW. J Chem Soc Faraday Trans 1 1975;71:756. Fish A. Angew Chem Int Ed Engl 1968;7:45. Walker RW. In: Hussaini MY, Kumar A, Voigt RG, editors. Major research topics in combustion. New York: Springer-Verlag; 1992. p. 277. Pilling MJ, Robertson SH, Seakins PW. J Chem Soc Faraday Trans 1995;91:4179. Rienstra-Kiracofe JC, Allen WD, Schaefer III HF. J Phys Chem A 2000;104:9823–40. Xing J-H, Nagai Y, Kusuhara M, Miyoshi A. J Phys Chem A 2004;108:10458–63. Maricq MM, Szente JJ. J Phys Chem A 2000;104:7239–45. Maricq MM, Szente JJ. J Phys Chem 1996;100:12374–9. Atkinson DB, Hudgens JW. J Phys Chem A 1997;101:3901–9. Rupper P, Sharp EN, Tarczay G, Miller TA. J Phys Chem A 2007;111:832–40. Hasson AS, Tyndall GS, Orlando JJ. J Phys Chem A 2000;108:5979–89. Mah DA, Cabrera J, Nation H, Ramos M, Sharma S, Nickolaisen SL. J Phys Chem A 2003;107:4354–9. Choi H, Bise RT, Neumark DM. J Phys Chem A 2000;104:10112–8. Faulhaber AE, Szpunar DE, Kautzman KE, Neumark DM. J Phys Chem A 2005;109:10239–48. Matus MH, Nguyen MT, Dixon DA. J Phys Chem A 2007;111:113–26. Merle J, Hayes C, Zalyubovsky S, Glover B, Miller T, Hadad C. J Phys Chem A 2005;109:3637–46. DeSain J, Klippenstein S, Miller J, Taatjes C. J Phys Chem A 2001;105:4415–25. DeSain J, Clifford E, Taatjes C. J Phys Chem A 2001;105:3205–13. (a) Tarczay G, Zalyubovsky SJ, Miller TA. Chem Phys Lett 2005;406:81–9. (b) Zalyubovsky SJ, Glover B, Miller TA, Hayes CJ, Merle JK, Hadad CM. J Phys Chem A 2005;107:1308–15. Chow JM, Miller AM, Elrod MJ. J Phys Chem A 2003;107:3040–7. Kaiser EW. J Phys Chem A 1998;102:5903–6.
61. 62. 63. 64.
65. 66. 67. 68. 69. 70. 71. 72. 73. 74. 75. 76. 77. 78. 79. 80. 81. 82. 83. 84. 85. 86. 87.
THE CHEMISTRY OF REACTIVE RADICAL INTERMEDIATES
129
88. (a) DeSain JD, Klippenstein SJ, Miller JA, Taatjes CA. J Phys Chem A 2003;107:4415– 27. (b) DeSain JD, Klippenstein SJ, Miller JA, Taatjes CA. J Phys Chem A 2004;108:7127–8. 89. Naik C, Carstensen H-H, Dean AM. Proceedings of the Third Joint Meeting of the U.S. Sections of the Combustion Institute, Chicago, IL, 2003. 90. Chen C-C, Bozzelli JW. Fourth Joint Meeting of the U.S. Sections of the Combustion Institute: Western States, Central States, Eastern States, Philadelphia, PA, March20–23, 2005. 91. Merle JK, Hayes CJ, Zalyubovsky SJ, Glover B, Miller TA, Hadad CM. J Phys Chem A 2005;109:3637–46. 92. (a) Ochterski JW, Petersson GA, Montgomery JA, Jr. J Chem Phys 1996;104:2598–619. (b) Petersson GA, Frisch MJ. J Phys Chem A 2000;104:2183–90. 93. Lynch BJ, Fast PL, Harris M, Truhlar DG. J Phys Chem A 2000;104:4811–5. 94. Vereecken L, Peters J. J Chem Phys 2003;119:5159–70. 95. Atkinson R. J Phys Chem Ref Data 1997;26:215. 96. Hein H, Somnitz H, Hoffmann A, Zellner R. Proceedings of the Second Workshop EUROTRAC-2 CMD, Karlsruhe, Germany, 1998. 97. Ferenac MA, Davis AJ, Holloway AS, Dibble TS. J Phys Chem A 2003;107:63–72. 98. Lendvay G, Viskolcz B. J Phys Chem A 1998;102:10777–86. 99. Somnitz H, Zellner RZ. Phys Chem 2006;220:1029–48. 100. Jungkamp TPW, Smith JN, Seinfeld JH. J Phys Chem A 1997;101:4392–401. 101. (a) Cassanelli P, Cox RA, Orlando JJ, Tyndall GSJ. Photochem Photobiol A 2006;177:109–15. (b) Cassanelli P, Johnson D, Cox RA. Phys Chem Chem Phys 2005;7:3702–10. 102. (a) Barker JR, Ortiz NF. Int J Chem Kinet 2000;33:246. (b) Watkins KW. J Am Chem Soc 1971;93:6355. (c) Watkins KW. J Phys Chem 1973;77:2938. (d) Endrenyi L, Le Roy DJ. J Phys Chem 1966;70:4081. (e) Frey HM, Walsh R. Chem Rev 1969;69:103–124. (f) Walsh R. Chem Rev 1969;69:103–24. (g) Dearden DV, Beauchamp JL. J Phys Chem 1985;89:5359. (h) Tardy DC. Int J Chem Kinet 1974;6:291. (i) Yamauchi N, Miyoshi A, Kosaka K, Koshi M, Matsui H. J Phys Chem A 1999;103:2723. (j) Tsang W, Walker JA, Manion JA. Symp (Int) Combust [Proc] 1998;27(1):135. (k) Tsang W, Bedanov V, Zachariah MR. Ber Bunsen-Ges Phys Chem 1997;101:491. (l) Pacansky J, Waltman RJ, Barnes LA. J Phys Chem 1993;97:10694. 103. Jitariu LC, Jones LD, Robertson SH, Pilling MJ, Hillier IH. J Phys Chem A 2003;107:8607–17. 104. Ross PL, Johnston MV. J Phys Chem 1995;99:16507–10. 105. Mereau R, Rayez M-T, Caralp F, Rayez J-C. Phys Chem Chem Phys 2003;5:4828–33. 106. Miller JA, Pilling MJ, Troe J. Proc Combust Inst 2005;30:43–88. 107. (a) Curran HJ, Jayaweera TM, Pitz WJ, Westbrook CK. Western States Section of the Combustion Institute. Spring Meeting, Davis, CA, March 29, 2004. (b) Qin Z, Lissianski VV, Yang H, Gardiner WC, Davis SG, Wang H. Proc Combust Inst 2000;28:1663–9. 108. Marinov NM, Pitz WJ, Westbrook CK, Castaldi MJ, Senkan SM, Melius CF. Combust Flame 1998;114:192–213. 109. Huang H, Fairweather M, Griffiths JF, Tomlin AS, Brad RB. Proc Combust Inst 2005;30:1309–16. 110. Curran HJ, Gaffuri P, Pitz WJ, Westbrook CK. Combust Flame 1998;114:149–77. 111. Curran HJ, Gaffuri P, Pitz WJ, Westbrook CK. Combust Flame 2002;129:253–80. 112. (a) Curran HJ, Pitz WJ, Westbrook CK, Callahan CV, Dryer FL. Proc Combust Inst 1998;27:379–87. (b) Huang Y, Sung CJ, Eng JA. Combust Flame 2004;139:239–51. (c) Huang Y, Sung CJ, Eng JA. Proc Combust Inst 2002;29:759–66. 113. Fournet R, Battin-Leclerc F, Glaude PA, Judenherc B, Warth V, Come GM, et al. Int J Chem Kinet 2001;33:574–86.
130
C.J. HAYES ET AL.
114. Wallington TJ, Kaiser EW, Farrell JT. Chem Soc Rev 2006;35:335–47. 115. (a) Albagi A, Oja H, Dubois L. Environ Lett 1974;6:241. (b) Pavanello S, Simioli P, Lupi S, Gregorio P, Clinfero E. Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev 2002;11:998. (c) Williams JA, Martin FL, Muir GH, Hewer A, Grover PL, Phillips DH. Carcinogenesis 2000;21:1683–9. (d) WHO (1997). The World Health Report. World Health Organization, Geneva, Switzerland. 116. (a) Richter H, Howard JB. Phys Chem Chem Phys 2002;4:2038–55. (b) Miller JA, Melius CF. Combust Flame 1992;91:21–39. (c) D’Anna A, Violi A. Proc Combust Inst 1998;27:425–33. (d) Bittner JD, Howard JB. Proc Combust Inst 1981;18:1105. (e) Westmoreland PR, Dean AM, Howard JB, Longwell JP. J Phys Chem 1989;93:8171. 117. (a) Melius CF, Colvin ME, Marinov NM, Pitz WJ, Senkin SM. Proc Combust Inst 1996;26:685. (b) Friderichsen AV, Shin EJ, Evans RJ, Nimlos MR, Dayton DC, Ellison GB. Fuel 2001;80:1747–55. 118. (a) Frenklach M. Phys Chem Chem Phys 2002;4:2028. (b) Frenklach M, Wang H. Proc Combust Inst 1991;23:1559. 119. Richter H, Howard JB. Prog Energy Combust Sci 2000;26:565. 120. (a) Atkinson R. J Phys Chem Ref Data 1989;1:1–246 (b) Atkinson R. J Phys Chem Ref Data,1994;2:1–216. 121. Asaba T, Fujii N. Symp (Int) Combust [Proc] 14th 1971;155–164. 122. Venkat C, Brezinsky K, Glassman I. Symp (Int) Combust 19th 1982, 143–52. 123. Bittker DA. Prog Energy Combust Sci 1991;79:49–72. (b) Zhang H-Y, McKinnon JT. Combust Sci Technol 1995;107:261–300. 124. Liu R, Morokuma K, Mebel AM, Lin MC. J Phys Chem 1996;100:9314–22. 125. Olivella S, Sole A, Garcia-Raso A. J Phys Chem 1995;99:10549–56. 126. Hodgson D, Zhang H-Y, Nimlos MR, McKinnon JT. J Phys Chem A 2001;105:4316–27. 127. Sethuraman S, Senkan SM, Gutman D. Combust Sci Technol 1992;82:13–30. 128. Carpenter BK. J Am Chem Soc 1993;115:9806–7. 129. (a) Barckholtz CA, Fadden MJ, Hadad CM. J Phys Chem A 1999;103:8108–17. (b) Fadden MJ, Barckholtz C, Hadad CM. J Phys Chem A 2000;104:3004–11. 130. Yu T, Lin MC. J Am Chem Soc 1994;116:9571–6. 131. Fadden MJ, Hadad CM. J Phys Chem A 2000;104:8121–30. 132. Mebel AM, Lin MC. J Am Chem Soc 1994;116:9577–84. 133. Merle JK, Hadad CM. J Phys Chem A 2004;108:8419–33. 134. Kroner SM, DeMatteo MP, Hadad CM, Carpenter BK. J Am Chem Soc 2005;127: 7466–73. 135. Colussi AJ, Zabel F, Benson SW. Int J Chem Kin 1977;9:161. 136. Lin C-Y, Lin MC. Int J Chem Kinet 1985;17:1025. 137. (a) Land EJ, Porter G, Strachan E. Trans Faraday Soc 1961;57:1885. (b) Roebber JL. J Chem Phys 1962;37:1974. (c) Ward B. Spectrochim Acta A 1968;24:813. (d) Bent DV, Haydon E. J Am Chem Soc 1975;97:2599. (e) Schuler RH, Buzzard GK. Int J Radiat Phys Chem 1976;8:563. (f) Pullin D, Andrews L. J Mol Struct 1982;95:181. (g) Johnston LJ, Mathivanan N, Negri F, Siebrand W, Zerbetto F. Can J Chem 1993;71:1655. (h) Hinchliffe A, Steinbank RE, Ali MA. Theor Chim Acta 1966;5:95. (i) Chang HM, Jaffe HH. Chem Phys Lett 1973;23:146. (j) Chang HM, Jaffe HH, Masmandis CA. J Phys Chem 1975;79:1118. 138. (a) Frank P, Herzler J, Just Th, Wahl C. Proceedings of the 25th International Symposium on Combustion. Pittsburgh (PA): The Combustion Institute; 1994. p. 833. (b) Beck SM, Brus LE. J Chem Phys 1982;76:4700. (c) Tripathi GNR, Schuler RH. Chem Phys Lett 1983;98:594. (d) Tripathi GNR, Schuler RH. J Chem Phys 1984;81:113. (e) Johnson CR, Ludwig M, Asher SA. J Am Chem Soc 1986;108:905. (f) Tripathi GNR, Schuler RH. J Phys Chem 1988;92:5129. (g) Tripathi GNR. In: Clark RJH, Hester RE, editor. Time resolved spectroscopy. New York: Wiley; 1989. p. 157.
THE CHEMISTRY OF REACTIVE RADICAL INTERMEDIATES
131
139. (a) Colussi AJ, Zabel F, Benson SW. Int J Chem Kinet 1977;9:161. (b) Harrison AG, Honnen LR, Dauben HJ, Lossing FP. J Am Chem Soc 1960;82:5593. (c) Schmoltner A-M, Anex DS, Lee YT. J Phys Chem 1992;96:1236. (d) Lin C-Y, Lin MC. Int J Chem Kinet 1985;17:1025. (e) Lin C-Y, Lin MC. J Phys Chem 1986;90:425. 140. (a) Schoebel A. Wissenschaftliche Berichte-Forschungszentrum Karlsruhe 2000, i–vii, 1–143. (b) Chai Y, Pfefferle LD. Fuel 1998;77:313–20. (c) Zhang H-Y, McKinnon JT. Combust Sci Technol 1995;107:261–300. (d) Bermudez G, Pfefferle L. Combust. Flame 1995;100:41–51. 141. (a) Marinov NM, Castaldi MJ, Melius CF, Tsang W. Combust Sci Technol 1998;131:1–6. (b) Marinov NM, Castaldi MJ, Melius CF, Tsang W. Combust Sci Technol 1997;128:295–342. 142. Marinov NM, Pitz WJ, Westbrook CK, Vincitore AM, Castaldi MJ, Senkan SM, et al. Combust Flame 1998;114:192–213. 143. Sanders WA. Gov Rep Announce Index (U.S.) 1986, 86(15), Abstr. No. 633–265. 144. (a) Kim DH, Mulholland JA, Ryu J-Y. Proc Combust Inst 2005;30:1245–53. (b) Kim DH, Mulholland JA, Ryu J-Y. Organohalogen Compd 2004;66:1026–32. (c) Kim DH, Mulholland JA. Environ Sci Technol 2005;39:5831–6. (d) Babushok VI, Tsang W. Chemosphere 2003;51:1023–9. (e) Wiater-Protas I, Louw R. Eur J Org Chem 2001;20:3945–52. (f) Grotheer H-H, Louw R. Combust Sci Technol 1998;134:45–63. (g) Huang H, Buekens A. Organohalogen Compd 1998;36:131–4. (h) Grotheer H-H, Louw R. Symp (Int) Combust [Proc] 26th, 1996, 2405–11. (i) Louw R, Grotheer H-H, Kanters MJ, Wiater I. Organohalogen Compd 1996;27:26–9. (j) Kim DH, Mulholland JA. Environ Sci Technol 2005;39:5831–6. 145. Hausmann M, Hebgen P, Homann KH. Symp (Int) Combust [Proc] 24th, 1992, 793–801. 146. Wang Z, Wang J, Richter H, Howard JB, Carlson J, Levendis YA. Energy Fuels 2003;17:999–1013. 147. (a) Sebbar N, Bockhorn H, Bozzelli JW. J Phys Chem A 2005;109:2233–53. (b) Sebbar N, Bockhorn H, Bozzelli JW. Phys Chem Chem Phys 2002;15:3691–703; (c) Vovelle C, Delfau JL, Formation of aromatics from combustion systems. Pollutants from Combustion: Formation and Impact on Atmospheric Chemistry (NATO Science Series, C: Mathematical and Physical Sciences) Ed. Vovelle C. Norwell, MA: Kluwer Academic Publishers, 2000;547:183–203. 148. Tokmakov IV, Kim G-S, Kislov VV, Mebel AM, Lin MC. J Phys Chem A 2005;109:6114–27. 149. Weisman JL, Head-Gordon M. J Am Chem Soc 2001;123:11686–94. 150. Lin MC, Mebel AM. J Phys Org Chem 1995;8:407–20. 151. Just GMP, Sharp EN, Zalyubovsky SJ, Miller TA. Chem Phys Lett 2006;417:378–82. 152. Tonokura K, Norikane Y, Koshi M, Nakano Y, Nakamichi S, Goto M, et al. J Phys Chem A 2002;106:5908–17. 153. Krauss M, Osman R. J Phys Chem 1995;99:11387–91. 154. Emdee JL, Brezinsky K, Glassman I. J Phys Chem 1992;96:2151–61. 155. Dagaut P, Pengloan G, Ristori A. Phys Chem Chem Phys 2002;4:1846–54. 156. (a) Pitz WJ, Seiser R, Bozzelli JW, Da Costa I, Fournet R, Billaud F, et al. 2nd Joint Meeting of the U.S. Section of the Combustion Institute: Oakland, CA, March 25–28, 2001. (b) Pitz WJ, Seiser R, Bozzelli JW, Seshadri K, Chen CJ, Da Costa I, et al. Thirtieth Symposium (International) on Combustion. Chicago (IL): The Combustion Institute; July 25–30, 2004. 157. El Bakali A, Dupont L, Lefort B, Lamoureux N, Pauwels JF, Montero, M. J Phys Chem A 2007;111:3907–21. 158. (a) Muller-Markgraf W, Troe, J. J Phys Chem 1988;92:4914–22. (b) Clark WD, Price SJ. Can J Chem 1970;48:1059. 159. Ergut A, Granata S, Jordan J, Carlson J, Howard JB, Richter H, et al. Combust Flame 2006;144:757–72.
132
C.J. HAYES ET AL.
160. Andino JM, Smith JN, Flagan RC, Goddard WA, III, Seinfield JH. J Phys Chem 1996;100:10967–80. 161. Elmaimouni L, Minetti R, Sawerysyn JP, Devolder P. Int J Chem Kinet 1993;25:399–413. 162. Fenter FF, Noziere B, Caralp F, Lesclaux R. Int J Chem Kinet 1994;26:171–89. 163. Buth R, Hoyermann K, Seeba J. 25th Symposium (International) on Combustion. Chicago (IL): The Combustion Institute; 1994. pp. 851–858. 164. Noziere B, Lesclaux R, Hurley MD, Dearth MA, Wallington TJ. J Phys Chem 1994;98:2864–73. 165. El Dib G, Chakir C, Roth E, Brion J, Daumont D. J Phys Chem A 2006;110:7848–57. 166. Sussingham R. Can Coal Be Clean? Chemistry, Spring 2007. 167. (a) Axworthy AE, Dayan VH, Martin GB. Fuel 1987;57:29. (b) Houser TJ, McCarville ME, Biftu T. Int J Chem Kinet 1980;12:555. (c) Houser TJ, Hull M, Alway RM, Biftu T. Int J Chem Kinet 1980;12:569. (d) Leidreiter HI, Wagner H. Gg Z Phys Chem Neue Floge 1987;153:99. (e) Rawlins WT, Tanzawa T, Schertzer SP, Kreck RH. Final Report to DOE, 1983, Contract No. DEAC228OPC30392. (f) Kern RD, Yong JN, Kiefer JH, Shah JN. 1988. Shock Tubes and Waves, Proc. 16th Int. Symp. on Shock Tubes and Waves, pp. 437–44. New York: VCH PuN. (g) Doughty A, Mackie JC. J Chem Soc Faraday Trans 1994;90:541. (h) Doughty A, Mackie JC, Palmer JM. Symp (Int) Combust [Proc] 25th 1994, 893–203. 168. Mackie J, Colket M, Nelson P. J Phys Chem 1990;94:4099–106. 169. Kiefer J, Zhang Q, Kern R, Yao J, Jursic B. J Phys Chem A 1997;101:7061–73. 170. Carey FA, Sundberg RJ. Advanced organic chemistry: part A, structure and mechanism. New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers; 2000. 171. Kikuchi O, Hondo Y, Morihashi K, Nakayama M. Bull Chem Soc Jpn 1988;61:291. 172. Mackie JC, Colkey MB, Nelson PF. J Phys Chem 1990;94:4099. 173. Jones J, Bacskay GB, Mackie JC, Doughty A. J Chem Soc Faraday Trans 1995;91:1587. 174. Taberes FL, Gonzalez-Urena A. J Phys Chem 1983;87:4933–6. 175. Alfassi ZB, Khaikin GI, Neta P. J Phys Chem 1995;99:4544–8. 176. Eisele FL. Int J Mass Spectrom Ion Phys 1983;54:119–26. 177. Yeung LY, Elrod MJ. J Phys Chem A 2003;107:4470–7. 178. Williams A, Pourkashanian M, Jones JM, Rowlands L. J Inst Energy 1997;70:102–13. 179. Streit GE, Spall DE, Hall JH. Environ Sci Technol 1987;21:519–25. 180. (a) Molto J, Font R, Conesa JA. Energ Fuels 2006;20:1951–8. (b) Ciccioli P, Brancaleoni E, Frattoni M, Cecinato A, Pinciarelli L. Anal Lett 2001;34:937–55. (c) Sidhu S, Graham J, Stribech R. Chemosphere 2001;42:681–90. 181. (a) McDonald JD, Zielinska B, Fujita EM, Sagebiel JC, Chow JC, Watson JG. Env Sci Technol 2000;34:2080–91. (b) Ozawa T, Ishiguro Y, Toyoda K, Nishimura M, Sasahara T, Doi T. Chem Sensors 2004;20:56–7. 182. (a) Levendis YA, Atal A, Carlson JB. Combust Sci Technol 1998;134:407–31. (b) Lemieux PM, Ryan JV. Air Waste 1993;43:1106–15. 183. Baker RR, Bishop LJ. J Anal Appl Pyrol 2005;74:145–70. 184. (a) Xie H, Wang J, Zhang S, Ding Y, Sun C. J Chem Phys 2006;125:124317. (b) van der Laarse JD, van Leuven HCE. Anal Chim Acta 1966;34:370–1. 185. Bruinsma OS, Tromp PJJ, DeSauvage Nolting HJJ, Mouljin JA. Fuel 1988;67:334–40. 186. Cullis CF, Norris AC. Carbon 1972;10:525–37. 187. Braslavsky S, Heicklin J. Chem Rev 1977;77:473–511. 188. Klein E, Lukes V, Cibulkova Z, Polovkova J. J Mol Struct 2006;758:149–59. 189. Grela MA, Amorebieta VT, Colussi AJ. J Phys Chem 1985;89:38–41. 190. Organ PP, Mackie JC. Chem Soc Faraday Trans 1991;87:815–23. 191. Fulle D, Dib A, Kiefer JH, Zhang Q, Yao J, Kern RD. J Phys Chem A 1998;102:7480–6. 192. Sendt K, Bacskay GB, Mackie JC. J Phys Chem 2000;104:1861–75. 193. Lifshitz A, Tamburu C, Suslensky A. J Phys Chem 1989;93:5802–8. 194. Bacskay GB, Martoprawiro M, Mackie JC. Chem Phys Lett 1998;290:391–8.
THE CHEMISTRY OF REACTIVE RADICAL INTERMEDIATES 195. 196. 197. 198. 199. 200. 201. 202. 203. 204.
205. 206. 207.
208. 209. 210. 211. 212. 213. 214. 215. 216. 217. 218. 219. 220. 221. 222. 223. 224. 225. 226. 227.
133
Mackie JC, Colket MB, Nelson PF, Esler M. Int J Chem Kinet 1991;23:733–60. Barckholtz C, Barckholtz TA, Hadad CM. J Am Chem Soc 1999;121:491–500. Fadden MJ, Hadad CM. J Phys Chem A 2000;104:6088–94. Fadden MJ, Hadad CM. J Phys Chem A 2000;104:6324–31. Terentis A, Doughty A, Mackie J. J Phys Chem 1992;96:10334–9. Ikeda E, Mackie J. J Anal Appl Pyrolysis 1995;34:47–63. Doughty A, Mackie J. J Phys Chem 1992;96:10339–48. Frerichs H, Schliephake V, Tappe M, Wagner H. Z Phys Chem 1990;166:145–155. Hayes CJ, Hadad C.M. J Phys Chem A, submitted. (a) Doughty A, Mackie J. J Phys Chem 1992;96:10339–48. (b) Ebert KH, Ederer HJ, Schmidt PS, Baulch DL, Cobos CJ, Cox RA, et al. J Phys Chem Ref Data 1992;21:411–29. (c) Wang H, Frenklach M. J Phys Chem 1994;98:11465–89. (d) Hippler H, Troe J. J Phys Chem 1990;94:3803–6. (e) Walker J, Tsang W. J Phys Chem 1990;94:3324–7. (f) Ellison GB, Davico GE, Bierbaum VM, DePuy CH. Int J Mass Spectrom Ion Proc 1996;156:109–31. (g) Muralha V, dos Santos R, Simoes J. J Phys Chem A 2004;108:936–42. Hayes CJ, Hadad CM. J Phys Chem A, submitted. Hayes CJ, Hadad CM. J Phys Chem A, submitted. (a) Onishi S, Jo S, Shoda K, Jo PD, Kato S. SAE Paper #790501; 1979. (b) Noguchi M, Tanaka Y, Tanaka T, Takeuchi Y. SAE Paper #790840; 1979. (c) Najt PM, Foster DE. SAE Paper #830264; 1983. (d) Aceves SM, Smith JR, Westbrook CK, Iptz WJ. J Engin Gas Turb Power 1999;121:569–74. (e) Westbrook CK. Symp (Int) Combust [Proc] 2000, 1563–77. (f) Aceves SM, Flowers DL, Martinez-Frias J, Smith JR, Chen JY. SAE Paper # 149614; 2002. (g) Bunting BG. SAE Paper # 010872; 2006. (a) Aceves SM, Flowers DL, Martinez-Frias J, Smith JR. SAE Paper #01-2077; 2001. (b) Wang RC, Fang T. SAE Paper #011519; 2006. Thring RH. Homogeneous-charge compression-ignition (HCCI) engines. Warrendale (PA): SAE; 1989. Carlsen W. San Francisco Chronicle, September 15, 1997. Marinov NM. Int J Chem Kinet 1999;31:183–220. Energy Policy Act of 1992 (42 USC 10141 n), [accessed 15.02.07]. DiPardo J. ‘‘Outlook for Biomass Ethanol Production and Demand.’’ EIA Forecasts Online. [accessed 06.07.06]. Chase R. DuPont, BP join to make butanol, USA Today, June 30, 2006. Butanol—Better than Ethanol as a Gasoline Substitute. [accessed 30.06.06]. Environmental Energy: Butanol Replaces Gasoline. [accessed 30.06.06]. Ramey D, Yang S-T. Production of Butyric Acid and Butanol from Biomass. U.S. Department of Energy: Morgantown, WV, 2004. [accessed 15.07.06]. Butanol. [accessed 15.07.06]. Ramey D. Advances in Biofuels: Alternative Energy and New Markets for Farmers. [accessed 24.07.06]. Marinov NM. Int J Chem Kinet 1999;31:183–220. Cavalli F, Geiger H, Barnes I, Becker K.H. Environ Sci Technol 2002;36:1263–70. Chen YL, Chou T-C. Ind Eng Chem Res 1996;35:2172–6. McEnally CS, Pfefferle L.D. Proc Combust Inst 2006;30:1363–70. Westbrook CK, Pitz WJ, Curran HJ. J Phys Chem A 2006;110:6912–22. Sinha A, Thomson MJ. Combust Flame 2004;136:548–56. Nag P, Song KH, Litzinger TA, Haworth DC. Int J Engine Res 2001;2:163–75. Quoted by: Knothe G. Inform 2001;12:1103–7.
134
C.J. HAYES ET AL.
228. Bowman FM, Seinfeld JH. Prog Energy Combust Sci 1995;21:387–417. 229. (a) Schwab AW, Bagby MO, Freedman B. Fuel 1987;66:1372–8. (b) Schwab AW, Dykstra GJ, Selke E, Sorenson SC, Pryde EH. JOACS 1988;65:1781–6. 230. Graboski MS, McCormick RL. Prog Energy Combust Sci 1998;24:125–64. 231. Srivastava A, Prasad R. Renew Sust Energ Rev 2000;4:111–33. 232. Lin C-Y, Lin H-A, Hung L-B. Fuel 2006;85:1743–9. 233. Ma F, Hanna MA. Bioresour Technol 1999;70:1–15. 234. Kulkarni MG, Dalai AK. Ind Eng Chem Res 2006;45:2901–13. 235. Zhenyi C, Xing J, Shuyuan L, Li L. Energy Sources 2004;26:849–56. 236. Gail S, Thomson MJ, Sarathy SM, Syed SA, P. Dagaut b, Dievart P, P. Marchese AJ, Dryer FL.: Proc Combust Inst 2007;31:305–311. 237. Fisher EM, Pitz WJ, Curran HJ, Westbrook CK. Proc Combust Inst 2000;28:1579–86. 238. Good DA, Francisco JS. J Phys Chem A 2000;104:1171–85. 239. (a) Metcalfe WK, Dooley S, Curran HJ, Simmie JM, El-Nahas AM, Navarro MV J. Phys Chem A 2007;111:4001–4014 (b) El-Nahas AM, Navarro MV, Simmie JM, Bozzelli JW, Curran HJ, Dooley S, Metcalfe WJ. Phys Chem A 2007;111:3727–39. 240. Glaude PA, Pitz WJ, Thomson MJ. Proc Combust Inst 2005;30:1111–8. 241. Schwartz WR, McEnally CS, Pfefferle LD. J Phys Chem A 2006;110:6643–8. 242. Sarathy SM, Gail S, Syed SA, Thomson MJ, Dagaut P. Proc Combust Inst 2007;31:1015–22.
Stable carbocations and onium ions from polycondensed aromatic and heteroaromatic compounds as models for biological electrophiles and DNA-transalkylating agents KENNETH K. LAALIa and GABRIELA L. BOROSKYb a
Department of Chemistry, Kent State University, Kent, OH 44242, USA Unidad de Matema´tica y Fı´sica, INFIQC, Facultad de Ciencias Quı´micas, Universidad Nacional de Co´rdoba, Ciudad Universitaria, Co´rdoba 5000, Argentina
b
1 Introduction 135 2 Protocols 138 3 Pyrenium ions 139 4 Phenanthrenium ions 147 5 Benzanthracenium ions 152 6 Chyrsenium and benzo[c]phenanthrenium ions 156 7 Carbenium ions and onium cations from hetero-PAHs 160 8 Carbenium ions derived from nonalternant PAHs 166 9 Miscellaneous systems 173 10 Concluding remarks 174 Acknowledgement 174 References 175
1
Introduction
Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) are environmental pollutants well known as mutagenic/carcinogenic agents.1 They exert their biological activity principally through metabolic formation of their diol epoxides (DEs) and generation of carbocations by DE ring opening.2 Bay-region DEs (Fig. 1) exhibit increased mutagenic and carcinogenic properties,3 and these observations led to the development of the so-called bay-region theory.4 Metabolic formation of bay-region DEs involves oxidation of a terminal, angular benzo ring of the hydrocarbon to form an arene oxide, hydration of the arene oxide to form a trans-dihydrodiol, and subsequent epoxidation of the bay-region double bond of the dihydrodiol. Benzylic carbocations, generated from these electrophilic DEs by opening of the O-protonated epoxide, are capable of forming covalent adducts with the nucleic acids.2 Adduct formation by reaction with the nucleophilic sites in DNA and RNA has been recognized as an important event in the mechanism of chemical carcinogenesis by PAHs (Fig. 2).2 For PAHs with lower ionization potentials, direct biological single-electron oxidation to the radical cations (RCs) could intervene, with the resulting PAHþ• undergoing nucleophilic attack by DNA nucleotides to form PAH–DNA adducts (Fig. 2).5 135 ADVANCES IN PHYSICAL ORGANIC CHEMISTRY VOLUME 43 ISSN: 0065-3160 DOI: 10.1016/S0065-3160(08)00004-X
2009 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved
136
K.K. LAALI AND G.L. BOROSKY
Fig. 1 Different types of DEs or epoxide derivatives from model PAHs.
With the methylated PAHs, another bioactivation pathway leading to benzylic carbocations becomes available through side chain oxidation to form a benzylic alcohol, followed by esterification and solvolysis.5 Thus, benzylic sulfate ester formation (via initial formation of benzyl alcohol) constitutes an additional route that could contribute to metabolic activation (Fig. 2).5 Nitration opens up another pathway to metabolic activation. Nitro-PAHs are wide-spread environmental pollutants that are mutagenic and carcinogenic. Metabolism of nitro-PAHs could occur via nitro-activation (reduction to hydroxylamine, eventually leading to nitrenes that can bind to nucleotides) and/or by ring oxidation and formation of DEs.6 Generation and NMR studies of the carbocations from various classes of PAHs under stable ion conditions, in combination with computational studies, provide a powerful means to model their biological electrophiles. These approaches allow the determination of their structures, relative stabilities, charge delocalization modes, and substituent effects, as a way to understand structure/reactivity relationships. Theoretical calculations complement and enhance the experimental NMR studies, by providing charge delocalization maps via changes in computed charges (Dq) and through computed Dd 13C values from gauge-independent atomic orbitals (GIAO)NMR (Section 2), for comparison with the charge delocalization maps derived from experimental Dd 13C values. Computed relative arenium ion energies establish comparative links with the experimentally observed site(s) of protonation, while the density functional theory (DFT)-optimized structures give insight into the geometries and steric factors. Substituent effects on charge delocalization and relative
STABLE CARBOCATIONS AND ONIUM IONS
137
Fig. 2 Various metabolic activation pathways for PAHs.
carbocation stabilities/reactivities provide a bridge to structure/activity relationships that are determined by biological tests, namely by relative DNA-binding studies and/ or comparative mutagenicity assay. A long-term goal is to evaluate the correspondence between carbocation-derived structure/reactivity relationships and those derived from biological assays. Such comparisons could prove valuable toward predictability of cancer induction in various environmentally relevant classes of PAHs and hetero-PAHs. Earlier progress in these studies has been summarized in reviews published in the last decade, emphasizing carbocations and oxidation dications,7–9 RCs,7 as well as reactive intermediates from the nitro- and nitroso-derivatives.9,10 The review article published in 1996 emphasized groundwork studies on protonation as well as oxidation (both RCs and stable dications) of polycyclic arenes and explored possible relationships between charge distribution and carcinogenicity, in concert with its
138
K.K. LAALI AND G.L. BOROSKY
modulation via strategically positioned substituents.7 These topics were updated in a 2004 review, where related theoretical calculations were also discussed.8 Furthermore, Laali and Okazaki9 summarized stable ion studies involving the nitro- and nitrosopyrenes in various superacid media. Under appropriate combustion conditions, incorporation of nitrogen into the aromatic ring system leads to the formation of aza-PAHs.11 Substantial evidence has been obtained, suggesting that the aza-analogs are also metabolically activated to DEs according to the bay-region theory.12 Experimental data have revealed that the position of the nitrogen heteroatom in the aza-PAHs could have a significant effect on the carcinogenic potencies of their dihydrodiol and bay-region DE metabolites. Recently, model computational studies aimed at understanding structure/reactivity relationships and substituent effects on carbocation stability for aza-PAHs derivatives were performed for several families of compounds, and comparisons were made with the biological activity data when available.13 The goal of this chapter is to highlight the more recent studies on several classes of PAHs and hetero-PAHs from our laboratory, with stronger emphasis being placed on quantum-chemical calculations and their relationships with the biological activity data.
2
Protocols
PAH arenium ions are typically generated in low concentrations at low temperatures in FSO3H/SO2ClF. Diprotonation can be effected with FSO3HSbF5 (4:1)/SO2ClF. The use of higher acidity, more oxidizing, FSO3HSbF5 (1:1)/SO2ClF could lead to competing oxidation and/or polymerization. The resulting carbocation(s) are examined directly by high-field NMR (whereas earlier studies were performed on a 300-MHz instrument, working with a 500-MHz instrument became essential in later studies involving more complex systems) to assign their structure and to deduce charge delocalization modes from Dd 13C values. Specific assignments of the ring carbons including the ring junction carbons are accomplished via HMQC and HMBC experiments. Assignments are assisted by NOED experiments that also provide conformational information in relevant cases. The NMR studies are complemented with theoretical work. Given the size of the systems, AM114 minimizations and single-point calculations were performed in earlier studies. Relative arenium ion energies are typically computed for all possible carbocations derived from a given PAH, for comparison with experiment (this method proved to work quite well). Subsequently, DFT methods (B3LYP functional15) were employed to compute (1) natural charges from which changes in charges are mapped out for comparison with the NMR-based conclusions, (2) GIAO-NMR16 to predict the chemical shifts for comparison with the experimental results, and (3) nuclear-independent chemical shift (NICS)17 in order to evaluate relative aromaticity in different rings. Finally, solvent effects were estimated by the polarized continuum model (PCM).18 In selected cases, parallel DNA-binding studies (with MCF-7 human mammary
STABLE CARBOCATIONS AND ONIUM IONS
139
carcinoma cells) were performed, starting with the covalent precursors of model benzylic carbocations (typically alcohols and chlorides) for comparative purposes. Comparative mutagenicity assay (Ames test) were performed on the nitroderivatives.
3
Pyrenium ions
It was shown in earlier studies19 that dihydropyrene 1 and its 2,7-di-tBu derivative 3 were both monoprotonated with FSO3H/SO2ClF at C-3. Diprotonation of 3 gave the 3,6-diprotonated cation selectively, that of 1 produced primarily the 3,6diprotonated dication. When lHþ was heated, it was oxidized to 2Hþ (Fig. 3). This process was explained by equilibrium deprotonation at higher temperature and stepwise oxidation. Protonation of a mixture of 2 plus 1 led to NMR detection of 2Hþ only (Fig. 3). This was rationalized by a facile H abstraction from lHþ by 2þ, which was formed from 2 in the superacid. Formation of lþ was inferred from Electron Spin Resonance (ESR). Protonation of a mixture of 4 and 1, on the other hand, produced lHþ and 4þ. This was consistent with the NMR spectrum showing no signals for the chlorochrysene (Fig. 3). Heating of this sample led to NMR detection of 2Hþ. A series of regioisomeric tertiary and secondary methylcarbenium ions bearing 1-pyrenyl, 4-pyrenyl, and 2-pyrenyl substitutents were generated from their carbinol precursors.20 Charge delocalization into the pyrene moiety was evaluated on the basis of the magnitude of the Dd13Cs and the chemical shift of the cation center. For both tertiary and secondary 1-pyrenylmethylcarbenium ions, the positive charge was effectively delocalized. The pyrenium ion character of the resulting benzylic carbocations decreased in the order 1-pyrenyl > 4-pyrenyl > 2-pyrenyl. As a guiding tool and for comparison with the solution NMR studies, AM1 energies and charges were calculated for a set of tertiary and secondary a-pyrenyl carbocations. The AM1 relative stability order was in accord with the NMR-based stability trends for the regioisomeric secondary pyrenyl(methyl)methylcarbenium ions. For the regioisomeric tertiary pyrenyldimethylcarbenium ions, peri interactions raised the energy. Thus, from the model carbocations generated in this study, the carcinogenic activity in benzo[a]pyrene (BaP) was related to the enhanced stability and the highly delocalized nature of 5aþ as compared to 5bþ (Fig. 4), while the lack of carcinogenicity in benzo[e]pyrene (BeP) could stem from lower relative stability of 6þ. A series of regioisomeric PyCþ(CF3)R (R = Me, Ph) (Py = pyrene) and (9-Phe)Cþ(CF3)Me (Phe = phenanthrene) carbocations, having a CF3 group a to the cation center, were generated from their carbinols in order to examine the influence of carbocation destabilization (increasing electron demand) on the magnitude of p-participation by an a-pyrene (or a-phenanthrene) moiety.21 Multinuclear (13C, 19F, and 1H), NOED, and 2D NMR (H/H COSY and C/H HETCOR) were used to deduce the mode and magnitude of charge delocalization and the extent of Ar—Cþ double-bond character in the carbocations. AM1 calculations were used to examine their energies, charges, and conformations for comparison with NMR.
140
Fig. 3 Mono- and diprotonation of pyrene derivatives.
K.K. LAALI AND G.L. BOROSKY
STABLE CARBOCATIONS AND ONIUM IONS
141
Fig. 4 Simplified carbocations generated as model for carbocations from the BaP and BeP skeletons.
Since charge delocalization into the 1-Py-, 4-Py-, and 9-Phe-substituents was quite effective, the presence of a-CF3 greatly increased p-participation and the arenium ion character. On the other hand, diminished charge delocalization into a 2-Py-substituent, coupled with destabilization by a-CF3, provoked ring protonation. Representative 13C NMR data for these carbocations are shown in Fig. 5. Furthermore, the crowded carbenium ions, (1-pyrenyl)diphenylmethylcarbenium ion and the 1,6- and 1,8-bis(diphenylmethylenium)pyrene dications, were generated along with their brominated analogs (Fig. 6).22 By use of semiempirical MO and force field calculations, the minimum energy conformations of the trityl cation and the preferred ring rotations were evaluated and compared with experiments. Subsequently, the conformations and the charge distribution patterns in the more crowded (1-pyrenyl)diphenylmethyl cations and their related dications were probed along with dynamic NMR (DNMR) studies of the persistent ions. Since there is no degeneracy in these carbenium ions, flipping of the rings could be followed by DNMR; the cation showed a conventional two-ring flip (ph,ph), whereas the disubstituted pyrene dications showed one-ring flips (py) and two-ring flips (ph,ph) with a higher rotational barrier in agreement with AM1 calculations. The AM1 method gave the transitionstate energies in best agreement with experiment. The charge at the Cþ carbon was most extensively delocalized in the cation, whereas in the species with two Cþ groups, the pyrene moieties were less effective in charge delocalization.
142
K.K. LAALI AND G.L. BOROSKY
Fig. 5 13C NMR data for the carbocations. Dd 13C values: cation minus carbinol. a, b, c, and d denote interchangeable assignments within a cation; n.o. means not observed.
Fig. 6 Generated (1-pyrenyl)diphenylmethylcarbenium ion, 1,6- and 1,8-bis(diphenylmethylenium)pyrene dications, and the brominated analogs.
Low-temperature protonation of 1-nitropyrene and its 15N-labeled isotopomer with FSO3HSbF5 (1:1) (‘‘magic acid’’)/SO2ClF (or SO2) or with FSO3HSbF5 (4:1)/SO2ClF generated either the dihydroxyiminium–pyrenium dication (NO2 diprotonation) or the hydroxyiminium–pyrenium dication as the principle NMR-observable persistent species (Fig. 7).23 The latter was independently generated by diprotonation of
STABLE CARBOCATIONS AND ONIUM IONS
143
Fig. 7 Mono- and dications generated from nitropyrenes.
authentic 1-nitrosopyrene. Variable formation of dihydroxyiminium–pyrenium and hydroxyiminium–pyrenium dications was also observed in the protonation of sterically crowded 1-nitro-2,7-di-tert-butylpyrene, which gave the corresponding dihydroxyiminium–pyrenium dication in FSO3HSbF5 (1:1)/SO2ClF (or SO2) and the hydroxyiminium–pyrenium dication by low-temperature reaction with FSO3H/SO2ClF or CF3SO3H/SO2. Protonation of the buttressed 1-nitro-2,4,6,8,10-pentaisopropylpyrene
144
K.K. LAALI AND G.L. BOROSKY
and its 15N-labeled isotopomer produced the dihydroxyiminium–pyrenium dication that underwent a facile cyclization to the oxazoline-fused pyrenium cation. Diprotonation and subsequent cyclization of the singly 15N-labeled 1,3-dinitro-2,4,6,8,10pentaisopropylpyrene were also studied. PM3 semiempirical calculations were used as a complementary tool to examine the geometries and energies of the resulting dications. Regioisomeric monoacyl- and monobenzoyl-substituted pyrenes are diprotonated in FSO3HSbF5(4:1)/SO2ClF to give persistent carboxonium–pyrenium dications, whereas diacetyl- and dibenzoylpyrenes were diprotonated to give dicarboxonium dications.24 The resulting dications were studied by lowtemperature NMR. Conformational aspects of the carboxonium group in various regioisomers were addressed by a combination of NOED spectra and 2D NMR and AM1 calculations. Charge delocalization pathways were gauged and compared on the basis of the magnitude of Dd13C values. Some representative examples are shown in Fig. 8. It was concluded that the carboxonium group is a robust electron-withdrawing substituent whose electronic response is sensitive to steric factors. In this way, it could be used to modulate charge delocalization into PAHs and their carbocations, as a function of substitution position. In stable ion studies of BaP derivatives, 7,8-dihydro-BaP gave a bay-region benzylic carbocation with extensive charge delocalization into the pyrene moiety.25 In contrast, a persistent carbocation could not be generated from 9,10-dihydro-BaP; introduction of bulky substituents at C-6 prevented side reactions, and the initially formed carbocation underwent rearrangement to the corresponding bay-region carbocation. Introduction of methoxy substituents into the 1- or 3- positions of 9,10dihydro-BaP-7(8H)-one increased its electrophilic reactivity to the extent that stable carboxonium–arenium dications were produced in FSO3H/SO2ClF (Fig. 9). Energies for various possible arenium ions and regioisomeric benzylic cations were computed at the DFT B3LYP/6-31G(d) level or by AM1 for comparison with the experimental results. These findings provided further evidence in support of the stability sequence: 1-pyrenyl > 4-pyrenyl > 2-pyrenyl in a-pyrene-substituted carbocations as models for the intermediates arising from BaP-epoxide ring opening (Fig. 10). In an effort to bridge the reactivity trend emerged from the stable ion studies, a series of a-pyrenylcarbinols were subjected to a DNA-binding study using human MCF-7 cells.25 DNA-binding data were compatible with the relative stability orders deduced from direct studies of regioisomeric a-pyrene-substituted carbocations, and the importance of steric contribution to DNA binding was emphasized. A systematic carbocation concentration dependency study on NMR chemical shifts was performed for the C-1-protonated 4H-cyclopenta[def]phenanthrenium cation 7Hþ and the C-1-protonated pyrenium cation 2Hþ (Fig. 11).26 Shielding of the PAH arenium ion protons and carbons was observed with decreasing FSO3H : PAH ratios without noticeable line-broadening. This was attributed to cation–anion interactions in the low FSO3H : PAH domain and possible formation of contact ion
STABLE CARBOCATIONS AND ONIUM IONS
145
Fig. 8 13C NMR data for the carbocations and Dd 13C values in parenthesis (a and b denote interchangeable assignments within a cation; * means one of the two or both D values were derived from chemical shifts that were interchangeable; n.o. means not observed).
pairs. Lowering the ratio gave separate sets of resonances for the unprotonated PAH, indicative of the presence of the equilibrium: þ PAH þ FSO3H ! PAHH þ FSO3
Variations in the absolute concentration of the carbocation solutions and temperature had minor effects on chemical shifts. The counter ion effect and the equilibrium could be minimized by going to higher superacidity systems with lower nucleophilicity counter ions. Resonances due to the PAH itself were considerably shielded. Solvation by FSO3H and the formation of ion pair-molecule clusters were suggested as possible reasons.
146
K.K. LAALI AND G.L. BOROSKY
Fig. 9 Mono- and dications generated from BaP derivatives.
Fig. 10 a-BaP-substituted carbenium ions as simplified models for BaP-epoxide ring opening.
STABLE CARBOCATIONS AND ONIUM IONS
147
Fig. 11 Protonation of 7 and 2 with FSO3H/SO2ClF.
4
Phenanthrenium ions
Superacid protonation studies on 2-methyl-, 3-methyl-, 3,6-dimethyl-phenanthrene, and 4H-cyclopenta[def]phenanthrene (7) resulted in the generation of phenanthrenium mono- and dications.27 Their charge delocalization paths were examined by 13C and 2D-NMR studies. AM1 energies and charges were calculated for all conceivable mono- and diprotonated phenanthrenes, for comparison with experiments, in order to compare their relative stabilities and charge delocalization modes. Persistent monocations were generated from four compounds. The monomethylated structures were partially diprotonated, while the dimethylated analog gave a symmetrical dication (Fig. 12). The observed mono- and dications were in most cases those predicted by AM1 to be the most stable. A parallel was drawn between stable ion and AM1 studies of methylphenanthrenes and solvolytic studies of K-region and non-K-region phenanthrene oxides.28 The carbocation formed by opening of the 1,2-epoxide closely resembled the 2-methylphenanthrene cation (and 7Hþ), and the regiochemistry of phenol formation (1-phenanthrol) could be understood. Similarly, phenanthrenium cations derived from the 3-methyl and dimethylated compounds served as models for carbocations formed by solvolysis of phenanthrene-3,4-epoxide (formation of 4-phenanthrol following hydride shift). Subsequently, a series of regioisomeric a-phenanthrene-substituted carbocations were generated from their alcohols by ionization with FSO3H/SO2ClF.29 Model carboxonium ions were also generated by O-protonation of the isomeric acetyl- and
148
K.K. LAALI AND G.L. BOROSKY
Fig. 12 13C NMR data for the carbocations and Dd 13C values in parenthesis (a and b denote interchangeable assignments within a cation; * means one of the two or both D values were derived from chemical shifts that were interchangeable).
benzoylphenanthrenes. The charge delocalization paths and the arenium ion character in the resulting carbocations and carboxonium ions were evaluated via lowtemperature NMR studies and by AM1 calculations (Fig. 13). Conformational aspects in the carboxonium ions were also analyzed. The carbocations and carboxonium ions studied may be viewed as simplified models of DE ring opening in several classes of PAHs. The magnitude of charge delocalization into the phenanthrene system was much larger in the carbocations than in the carboxonium ions. In all cases, the protonated ketones showed the same delocalization path as the carbocations, but the arenium ion character was significantly lower. Charge delocalization into the phenanthrene system in the model arenium ions and carboxonium ions was most effective from the meso position. The phenyl group reduced phenanthrenium ion character, whereby additional stabilization was gained by delocalization into the phenyl group, as compared to the methyl groups.
STABLE CARBOCATIONS AND ONIUM IONS
149
Fig. 13 13C NMR data for a-phenanthrene-substituted carbocations and carboxonium ions and Dd 13C values in parenthesis.
150
K.K. LAALI AND G.L. BOROSKY
In a later study, persistent carbocations were generated from five A-ring monoand disubstituted phenanthrenes [3-OMe, 4-OMe, 1,3-bis(OMe), 2,4-bis(OMe), and 1,3-bis(Me)].30 In all cases, protonation occurred in the A-ring, ortho/para relative to methoxy or methyl substituent(s). Mild nitration (with 20–50% aqueous HNO3 at – 10C or at room temp.) and bromination (NBS/MeCN/room temp.) of these substrates resulted in the synthesis of several novel mononitro-/dinitro-derivatives as well as monobromo/dibromo-derivatives, including those with the nitro- or bromosubstituent in the bay region. There was very good overall correspondence between the low-temperature protonation study and the regioselectivity observed in mild aqueous nitration. In most reactions, two nitro-products were obtained, one of them arising from a common type of carbocation intermediate as in protonation and the other likely arising from a higher energy regioisomeric carbocation or by further nitration of the initial product. In 2,4-bis(OMe), identical regioselectivity was observed in protonation and nitration. With bromination, steric control of regioselectivity was much more significant, but nevertheless bay-region bromination reflected the highly favorable carbocation stabilizing effects of the 1,3-dimethoxy substituents. A comparative DNA-binding study with MCF cells on three of the synthesized mononitro- and one dinitro-derivative showed that 1,3-dimethyl-9-nitro- (nitro at the meso position), 3-methoxy-4-nitro- (nitro in bay-region), and 1,3-dimethoxy-4,9dinitrophenanthrenes (nitro in both meso and bay regions) formed DNA adducts.30 The X-ray structures of 2,4-dimethoxy-1-nitro- and 1,3-dimethyl-4-nitro-Phe indicated that in both cases the nitro-group was severely buttressed. In line with previous observations that nitro-Phes with nitro-group forced out of coplanarity exhibited low or no activity (presumably because they were unable to intercalate into DNA),31 2,4dimethoxy-1-nitro-Phe did not exhibit DNA-binding activity. Moreover, HOMO/ LUMO energies for the nitro-compounds were calculated at the B3LYP/6-31G(d) level. Although only a limited set of compounds was studied for DNA binding, it appeared that the methoxy and methyl substituents increased bioactivity in the nitroderivatives, and consideration of HOMO/LUMO energies suggested that the tendency for nitro-reduction as a main metabolic pathway had diminished in the case of 1,3-dimethoxy-4,9-dinitro- and 3-methoxy-4-nitro-Phe relative to their unsubstituted nitro-derivatives. Protonation studies were carried out for a series of cyclopenta[a]phenanthrenes in superacid media (Fig. 14).32 Charge delocalization modes in the resulting mono- and dications (deduced primarily based on magnitude of Dd13C) were discussed and compared. In an effort to further enhance the NMR assignments, and for comparison, monoarenium ions 8Hþ, 11Hþ, 13Hþ, 14Hþ, and their neutral precursors were calculated at the B3LYP/6-31G(d,p) level of theory, their 1H and 13C NMR chemical shifts were computed by the GIAO method, and their overall charge delocalization paths were deduced via differences in the natural population analysis (NPA) charges (cation minus neutral). Hydrocarbons 8, 11, and 14 were ring-protonated in FSO3H/ SO2ClF to form monoarenium ions. The observed substituent dependency of the site of protonation in hydrocarbon carbocations 8Hþ, 11Hþ, and 14Hþ pointed to relative carbocation stability and relief of steric crowding at the bay region as
STABLE CARBOCATIONS AND ONIUM IONS
151
Fig. 14 Structures of cyclopenta[a]phenanthrene derivatives and their carbocations and carboxonium ions.
152
K.K. LAALI AND G.L. BOROSKY
important factors in directing electrophilic attack under kinetic control. Despite predominant charge localization in the ring undergoing attack, the overall delocalization pattern in the monoarenium ions signified an extended charge alternation path within the Phe moiety, hence phenanthrenium ion character. The 16(17)-ene compounds 10 and 13 were protonated at the D-ring double-bond to form stable a-Phe-substituted carbocations.32 Although the ease of formation and stability of both carbocations 10Hþ and 13Hþ implicated their potency, compound 13 is a stronger tumorigen than 10, which led to the suggestion of an additive effect. The 17-keto derivatives 9, 12, 15, 16, 21, and 22 were CO-protonated to form carboxonium ions.32 Low-temperature protonation of 15 and 16 with FSO3HSbF5 (4:1)/SO2ClF gave their corresponding carboxonium–arenium dications (protonation of 9 gave a mixture of mono- and dications), where ring protonation sites were controlled by the position of the methyl group and occurred in the A-ring for the Aring-methylated derivatives (15, 16). Whereas the 11-methoxy derivative (18) formed a carboxonium ion analogous to the 11-Me derivative (12), the 11-phenol derivative (17), the ethoxy (19), and propoxy (20) derivatives were more reactive, forming a mixture of mono- and dication (with 17 and 19) or gave mostly a carboxonium– arenium dication (with 20). Under thermodynamic control, carboxonium ions underwent fluorosulfonation in the biologically important A-ring. Moreover, a stable ion protonation and model nitration study of the methoxysubstituted hydrocarbon 23, its 15-ol 24, and the dimer 27 was performed in order to evaluate OMe substituent effects on directing electrophilic attack and on charge delocalization mode/conformational aspects in the resulting carbocations (Fig. 14).33 It was found that the C-11 methoxy group directed the electrophilic attack to C-12 and C-14. Thus, protonation of 23 with FSO3H/SO2ClF gave a 4:1 mixture of monoarenium ions 23Hþ/23aHþ. Prolonged reaction times and increased temperature induced fluorosulfonylation at C-14 (23þ-SO2F), whereas ambient nitration with NOþ 2 BF4 occurred at C-12. These observations supported the notion that increased activity of 23 stems from attack by electrophilic oxygen at C-14/C-15 producing the biologically active 24 as a major metabolite. The 15-ol derivative 24 was cleanly ionized to 25þ, providing the first example of an a-Phe-substituted carbocation from Phe C-1 position. Contrasting behavior of the D-ring methylsubstituted 28 and the C-11 methoxy-substituted 27 dimers was remarkable in that unlike 28, which was readily cleaved to produce the monomeric arenium ion 26þ, protonation of 27 resulted in two skeletally intact diprotonated dications, with major species diprotonated at the two C-12 sites and the minor species protonated at C-12 and C-14.
5
Benzanthracenium ions
Low-temperature protonation of 9-isopropenylphenanthrene led to direct observation of 5,6-dihydrobenzanthracenium cation 29Hþ from which the corresponding benzo[de]anthracene was obtained in 92% yield upon quenching.34 Charge delocalization mapping in 29Hþ, as deduced from Dd 13C values, showed arene
STABLE CARBOCATIONS AND ONIUM IONS
153
p-participation primarily via a naphthalenium ion (AB ring of phenanthrene moiety) and was in qualitative agreement with the overall mode of charge delocalization deduced based on the A