Advances in Physical Organic Chemistry Volume 28
Edited by
D. BETHELL The Robert Robinson Laboratories Department of ...
56 downloads
1666 Views
13MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Advances in Physical Organic Chemistry Volume 28
Edited by
D. BETHELL The Robert Robinson Laboratories Department of Chemistry University of Liverpool P.O. Box 147 Liverpool L69 3BX
ACADEMIC PRESS Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, Publishers London San Diego New York Boston Sydney Tokyo Toronto
ACADEMIC PRESS LIMITED 24/28 Oval Road London NWl 7DX United States Edition published by ACADEMIC PRESS INC. San Diego, CA 92101 Copyright 0 1993 by ACADEMIC PRESS LIMITED All rights reserved
No part of this book may be reproduced in any form by photostat, microfilm, or any other means, without written permission from the publishers
A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library ISBN 0-12-033528-X ISSN 0065-3160
FILMSET BY P&R TYPESETTERS LTD, SALISBURY, WILTSHIRE. UK AND PRINTED IN GREAT BRITAIN BY HARTNOLLS LIMITED, BODMIN, CORNWALL
Contents
vi i
Preface
viii
Contributors t o Volume 28
Electron Storage and Transfer in Organic Redox Systems w i t h Multiple Electrophores
1
MARTIN BAUMGARTEN, WALTER HUBER KLAUS MULLEN
AND
Introduction 1 Design and synthesis 5 Extended redox sequences 10 Mechanism of successive electron transfers 14 5 Structural transfer relevant to intramolecular electron transfer 17 6 Conclusion 39
1 2 3 4
Chirality and Molecular Recognition in Monolayers at the Air-Water Interface
PHILIP L. ROSE, NOEL G. HARVEY EDWARD M. ARNETT 1 2 3 4
Introduction 45 Monolayer methods 49 Chiral monolayers 71 Conclusions 133 ... 111
AND
45
CONTENTS
IV
Transit ion-St ate Theory Revisited
139
W. JOHN ALBERY 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
Introduction 139 The classical paradox 140 An alternative derivation 140 Where is the transition state? 143 The adiabatic case 145 Multistep reactions in solution 147 Proton transfers to cyanocarbon bases 152 Extension to include XR 153 Reactions at liquid/liquid interfaces 155 Colloidal deposition 158 Free energy profiles 163 Summary 167
Neighbouring Group Participation by Carbonyl Groups in Ester Hydrolysis
171
KEITH BOWDEN 1 2 3 4 5
Introduction 171 Catalysis by carbonyl groups 172 Intramolecular catalysis in ester hydrolysis 173 Implications for enzymic catalysis 202 Conclusions and summary 203
Electrophilic Bromination of Carbon-Carbon Double Bonds: Structure, Solvent and Mechanism
MARIE-FRANCOISE RUASSE 1 Introduction 208 2 Methods for obtaining reliable bromination rate constants 21 1 3 Bromine-olefin charge transfer complexes as essential intermediates in bromination 216 4 The ionic intermediates: bridged bromonium ions or open fi-bromocarbocations 220 5 Kinetic substituent effects 243
207
CONTENTS
6 Solvent effects and solvation in bromination 267 7 The reversible formation of bromonium ions 279 8 Concluding remarks 285 Author Index
293
Cumulative index of Authors
303
Cumulative index of Titles
305
ADVISORY BOARD W. J. Albery, FRS University of Oxford, Oxford A. L. J. Beckwith The Australian National University, Canberra R. Breslow Columbia University, New York L. Eberson Chemical Center, Lund H. Iwamura University of Tokyo G. A. Olah University of Southern California, Los Angeles Z. Rappoport The Hebrew University of Jerusalem P. von R. Schleyer Universitat Erlangen-Niirnberg G. B. Schuster University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
Preface
In pursuit of the objective of the series, which is to present considered reviews of areas concerned with the quantitative study of organic compounds and their behaviour - physical organic chemistry in its broadest sense - in a manner accessible to a general readership, this twenty eighth volume contains five contributions on a diversity of topics. Two of these reflect the increasing importance of physical organic studies in providing fundamental knowledge relevant to the development of new materials with novel physical properties. The others represent more traditional areas of physical organic interest, where recent research has thrown new light. As ever, the Editor and his Advisory Board invite comments, criticism (preferably, but not necessarily, constructive) and proposals from readers and potential writers. Suggestions concerning developments in physical organic chemistry where a forward-looking review might help in the development of a new research area, or of established topics in need of an up to date treatment, should be directed to any of us. D. BETHELL
vii
Contributors t o Volume 28
W. John Albery Physical Chemistry Laboratory, University of Oxford, South Parks Road, Oxford, UK Edward M . Arnett Department of Chemistry, Duke University, Durham, North Carolina 27706, USA
M. Baumgarten Max-Planck-Institut fur Polymerforschung, AckermannWeg 10, Mainz, Germany Keith Bowden Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, University of Essex, Wivenhoe Park, Colchester, Essex C 0 4 3SQ, UK Noel G. Harvey Exploratory Plastics Research, Rohm and Haas Company, PO Box 219, Bristol, Pennsylvania 19007, USA
W. Huber Hoffmann La Roche Ltd, Grenzacher Strasse 124,4002 Basel, Switzerland K. Mullen Max-Planck-Institut fur Polymerforschung, Ackermann-Weg 10, 6500 Mainz, Germany Philip L. Rose Exploratory Chemicals Research, Rohm and Haas Company, 727 Norristown Road, Spring House, Pennsylvania 19477, USA Marie-FranGoise Ruasse Institut de Topologie et de Dynamique de Systhmes, Universite de Paris 7, associe au CNRS-URA 34, 1 rue Guy de la Brosse, 75005 Paris, France
...
Vlll
Electron Storage and Transfer in Organic Redox Systems w i t h Multiple Electrophores M. BAUMGARTEN,~ W. H U B E R and ~ K. M ~ L L E N ~ Max-Planck-lnstitut fur Polymerforschung, Ackermann- Weg 10,6500 Mainz, Germany Hoffmann La Roche Ltd, Grenzacher Strasse 124,4002 Basel, Switzerland
Introduction 1 Design and synthesis 5 Highly charged states via extended redox sequences 10 Mechanisms of successive electron transfers 14 Structural factors relevant to intramolecular electron transfer The nature of the subunit 22 The length of the bridging group 25 The conformation of the bridging group 29 Ion pairing 32 The mode of linking 36 6 Conclusion and outlook 39 References 40
1 2 3 4 5
1
17
Introduction
Unsaturated carbo- and hetero-cycles are known to constitute active electrophores that can be subjected to chemical or electrochemical redox processes forming persistent cations or anions. Depending on the number of electrons transferred, the charged products can be either diamagnetic or paramagnetic. Crucial questions in describing the redox-activity of cyclic 7c-systems concern: (i) the number of accessible redox-states (Meerholz and Heinze, 1989, 1990); (ii) the mode of charge distribution (Heilbronner and Bock, 1978; Salem, 1966; Eliasson et al., 1986, 1990); (iii) the stabilization of charge by ion-pairing and/or conjugative effects (Hogen-Esch, 1977; Miillen et al., 1990); (iv) the possibility of charge-induced configurational and conformational changes (Eliasson et al., 1986; Huber and Miillen, 1986); (v) the chemical reactivity (Hogen-Esch, 1977; Szwarc, 1968; Miillen, 1986, 1 ADVANCES IN PHYSICAL ORGANIC CHEMISTRY VOLUME 28 ISBN 0-12-033528-X
Copyright 0 1993 Academic Press Limited A / / rights of reproduction in any form reserved
2
M. BAUMGARTEN ET AL.
1987). A particularly attractive group of substrates are the annulenes, since electron transfer allows an interconversion of (4n + 2)n- and (4n)x-systems, and thus a switch between x-bond delocalization and n-bond localization (Mullen, 1984). A relevant step from the viewpoint of electron-transfer activity is the linking of two or more identical electrophores to bis-, oligo- or polyelectrophoric systems. In an attempt to extrapolate the description of the single electrophore to that of the higher homologues, the above questions maintain their significance, but additional attractive aspects arise. First of all, it is appropriate to subdivide multi-electrophoric species into two classes depending on whether the linkage between the building blocks is an unsaturated or saturated chemical unit. In the former case, with extended x-conjugation, one expects successiveelectron-transfer steps to create strongly interacting redox states in which the excess charge is distributed over the whole n-system. In the latter case, with electronically “decoupled” electrophores, one expects the electron-transfer steps to occur independently, with only electrostatic interactions of the redox states; the excess charge is localized on the electrophores (Smith et al., 1976; Flanagan et al., 1978). Within the domain of materials science, the classification of multielectrophoric organic systems according to the mode of linking of the subunits has led to the definitions of conducting polymers and redox polymers (Wegener, 1981; Baughman et al., 1982; Heinze, 1990; Nowak et al., 1980; Murray, 1984). The present review is restricted to “dimeric” or (low molecular weight) “oligomeric” redox systems with identical, electronically decoupled electrophores A. Consider the biselectrophore A-1- A, where 1 represents a saturated spacer (Fig. 1A). Injection of an electron into one subunit A under formation of a radical anion raises the immediate question of whether the electron will tend to localize in the original subunit or whether it will undergo a degenerate electron transfer to the neighbouring unit. In the terminology of electron-transfer kinetics such electron hopping between identical redox groups is termed self-exchange (Cannon, 1980). Depending upon the rate of this process, one will observe an “effective delocalization” over two or more units within the timescale of the experiment, or a localization of charge on one unit. Upon further contact with a redox reagent or at higher redox potentials, additional electrons can be transferred. After a two-electron transfer, each redox unit can accept one charge with formation of a singlet or triplet dianion, or (less favourably from an electrostatic point of view) both charges can enter one redox unit. Here again, an intramolecular electron-exchange process is possible. Further relevant questions concern the nature of the highest accessible
ORGANIC REDOX SYSTEMS WITH MULTIPLE ELECTROPHORES
A-I-A
a.
3
a. or
m a. or
m
or
Fig. 1 Charging of a biselectrophore (A) and a triselectrophore (B).
redox state and the way in which the molecule copes with the increasing electrostatic repulsion. Clearly, the charging mechanism of the substrate and the particular electron-transfer kinetics are expected to be more complicated if the redox groups are different; this can be the case in the homologous tris-electrophore (Fig. lB), since the outer and inner electrophoric units now have a different substitution pattern, or in the bis-electrophore A-1-A when one unit A is slightly perturbed, e.g. by alkyl substitution. A major concern of this review is the tailoring of the redox behaviour of organic compounds, i.e. the optimization of such systems for electron storage and electron hopping. While the emphasis is on reduction and thus on anion formation, it has been shown on many occasions that oxidative cation formation leads to analogous conclusions (Meerholz and Heinze, 1990; Lewis and Singer, 1965). The structure of this text is thus obvious. (a) One will first have to consider the design and synthesis of suitable systems in which the structural conditions relevant for the energy profiles of inter- and intra-molecular electron-transfer processes can be systematically varied. The variation of the structure comprises the nature of the redox-unit A and of the spacer 1. It will be shown that
4
M. BAUMGARTEN ET AL.
this can be brought about readily by the synthetic technique of reductive alkylation (Mullen, 1984, 1986, 1987). (b) The second question is whether such species can serve as efficient electron acceptors in successive charging reactions. This aspect, if expressed in terms of structure, will focus on electrophores A that can be charged to a high charge density and on spacer groups 1 that tend to minimize the consequent Coulombic repulsion. It is obvious that this approach is closely related to the search for organic electronstorage materials that can be used as battery electrodes ( McDiarmid, 1979; Bitthin et al., 1987; Shacklette et al., 1987). (c) A third question concerns the sequence of the successive charging processes. It is clear that, depending on the particular charging mechanism and upon the number of electrons transferred, one can arrive at para- or dia-magnetic products that differ in the prevailing charge (spin) density distribution. (d) The fourt!? and main topic is how the intramolecular electron transfer between the redox groups of the systems depends upon structural phenomena. The energy profiles of intramolecular electron-transfer processes are important for many areas of chemistry. Some representative examples are (i) the photochemically induced electron transfer and the lifetime of charge-separated states in porphyrin-quinone diads, which serve as model compounds in photosynthetic studies (Gust et al., 1986, 1988; Wasielewski et al., 1985); (ii) the possibility of a long-range electron transfer and the relation between rate and reaction enthalpy according to the Marcus theory (Marcus, 1956, 1963, 1965) in benzenoid species attached to a steroidal spacer (Closs and Miller, 1988; Closs et al., 1989; Liang et al., 1990); and (iii) the influence of chain length and chain conformation on electron transfer between metal complexes (Reimers and Hush, 1990; Gray and Malmstrom, 1989), e.g. at the ends of an oligopeptide chain (Isied et al., 1988). In contrast with these approaches, the present account is restricted to degenerate, intramolecular electron transfer occurring in the charged ground state of the bis-electrophore A-1-A. It should be emphasized that our approach is a purely empirical one: knowledge of the structural dependence of the charge-storage capacity and of intramolecular electron-hopping processes might enable us specifically to design dimers, oligomers and polymers in which the electron-transfer rate, and thus the resulting charge distribution, can be controlled precisely.
5
ORGANIC REDOX SYSTEMS WITH MULTIPLE ELECTROPHORES
2
Design and synthesis
It is appropriate to begin with an overview of the compounds that have been specifically selected and synthesized for the present purposes. They are made up of redox-active subunits such as the benzenoid hydrocarbons naphthalene [ 11 and anthracene [2], the [4n]annulene cyclo-octatetraene [3] and the bridged (aromatic = 4n + 2) [ 14lannulene [4]. Each subunit is known to form a radical anion and dianion in chemical or electrochemical reductions (Meerholz and Heinze, 1989; Rabinovitz, 1988). Cyclo-octatetraene is an outstanding electrophore because, in the course of an electron transfer, its tub-shaped structure undergoes a flattening of the ring, while the other hydrocarbons possess rigid n-systems that do not experience extensive structural change upon undergoing a redox process (Katz, 1960; Anet et al., 1964; Heinze et al., 1974). R
2 m
3 4
0 0 -
5
When linking these redox-active building blocks to form dimers and oligomers, care has to be taken to vary the steric and electronic interaction of the subunits systematically. In [51 an orthogonal arrangement of the two of the subunits systematically. In [51 an orthogonal arrangement of the two cyclo-octatetraene units is enforced (via the spiroconjugation). Compounds [6]-[ 103 contain a flexible connection of the anthracene species, while in the arrangement. Another type of face-to-face-arrangement is found in the multi-layered annulene systems [ 141 and [ 151. Here, unlike the para-cyclophanes, in which the phenyl units are connected by “external” alkanediyl groups, the stacking of annulene layers is achieved by “internal” linkages, with the bridge located inside the n-clouds. The advantage of the latter structure is that one can
M. BAUMGARTEN ET AL.
6
&yJ C6l
a:n=2 b:n=3 c:n=4 d:n=6 e:n=ll
3
&
‘ 0
C8l 0
c71
a:n=3 b:n=4
%I&0
c91
0
0
0
0
0
0
L
Jn
a: m = 3, n = 1 b:m=3,n=2 c: m = 11, n = 2
readily vary the inter-plane distance and that the multi-layered system can be created in a true polymer forming reaction (see below). The common feature of compounds [5]-[15] is that the electrophoric units are linked by saturated spacers, thus establishing only weak electronic (through-bond or through-space) interaction of the .n-systems. In contrast, the binaphthyl [ 161, the biperylenyl [ 171 and the bianthryl [ 181 as well as the structurally related homologues [19], [20] and [21] allow for a direct .n,.n-interactionof the subunits; it will be shown, however, that for both steric and electronic reasons the inter-ring conjugation can be weak and thus lead to electronically independent redox groups in a similar fashion as in [51-[151.
ORGANIC REDOX SYSTEMS WITH MULTIPLE ELECTROPHORES
[14]a: R = CH3
b: R = 2-dodecyl
%%
[ 15]a: R = CHs
b: R = 2-dodecyl
%p%%
&6 '0 0
T p
I/
c 171
21 a : R = R ' = hexyl 21 b: R = H,R'= lsopentyl
In
c 191
21c: R = hexyl
7
a
M. BAUMGARTEN H A L .
[22]
a:n=l b:n=2
c:n=3
Compounds [6] and [7] have been described in the literature (Mullen, 1987; Fiedler et al., 1986; Huber et al., 1983). The ortho-anthracenophane [13] has been prepared by Diels-Alder cycloaddition as part of a project devoted to ladder-type polymers (Wagner et al., 1988; Wegener and Miillen, 1991; Pollmann et al., 1990). Compound [ 171 as well as the oligomers and polymers [ 19)-[22] have been prepared recently using various methods of aryl-aryl coupling (Bohnen et al., 1990; Fahnenstich et al., 1989; Koch and Mullen, 1991; Baumgarten et al., 1992a; Schenk, 1989). The most appropriate method, however, for the versatile linking of conjugated hydrocarbons by saturated spacer groups is reductive alkylation (Mullen, 1984, 1986, 1987; Bender et al., 1988, 1989; Bender and Mullen, 1988; Krummel and Mullen, 1988).This approach is based on the formation of carbanionic hydrocarbons by reduction of conjugated n-systems or by deprotonation of dihydroprecursors and their subsequent reaction with electrophilic reagents such as haloalkanes in SN2-type reactions. For the synthesis of the bis-cyclo-octatetraene compound [51 (Krummel et al., 1987; Auchter-Krummel and Mullen, 1991), cyclo-octatetraene dianion was quenched with tetrabromoneopentane to give the bis-adduct [231, which exists in an equilibrium between valence isomers [23a) and [23bl. Hexacycle [23a] was actually isolated in about 60% yield (Fig. 2) (Krummel et al., 1987). Accordingly, in the subsequent dehydrogenation, the formation of [23a] must be avoided by working at low temperatures; in this case it was possible to deprotonate the originally formed isomer [23b], obtaining a
Fig. 2 Quenching of cyclo-octatetraene with tetrabromoneopentane.
ORGANIC REDOX SYSTEMS WITH MULTIPLE ELECTROPHORES
9
tetra-anion that was then subjected to oxidation with cadmium chloride to obtain the target molecule [51. This concept of reductive alkylation can be extended to polymer synthesis (Bender et al., 1988, 1989). A typical starting compound is the anthracene dianion, which is treated with a bifunctional electrophile such as a 1,n-dihaloalkane to obtain the intermediate [241. The latter constitutes both a nucleophile and an electrophile and one can now attach a second carbanion such as [25] to the electrophilic end. This process, after protonation and subsequent dehydrogenation, gives rise to the dianthrylalkane compound [6]. A related procedure provides dianthryl compounds such as [7] in which the oligomethylene spacer is replaced by an oxoethylene chain (Fiedler et al., 1986). Under appropriate experimental conditions the bifunctional intermediate [241 can undergo polymerization. Not surprisingly, the polymerization also proceeds upon mixing of the bis-nucleophile [261 and the bis-electrophile [27]. The yield of the polymer is higher than 95%, the average molecular weight is about 10000, and the product possesses high structural homogeneity. Finally, the poly( dihydroanthrylene) systems can be dehydrogenated to obtain the corresponding unsaturated polyanthrylene compounds [lo] (Bender et al., 1988, 1989).
A crucial aspect of the present carbanion alkylation is its high regioselectivity. Thus, under the prevailing experimental conditions, the kinetically controlled alkylation only proceeds at the positions of the highest local n-charge of the carbanions. In the anthracene dianion or in [25] these positions are at C-9 and C-10, respectively. An important consequence of this regioselectivity is given for the example of the pyrene isomer [28]. The corresponding dianion can be regioselectively alkylated at the two inner positions since these are the positions of the highest local n-charge. When applying a haloalkane as electrophile, the bridged [ 14lannulene [4] is obtained, and by carefully controlling the stoichiometry of nucleophile and electrophile one can, for example, obtain the doubly layered system [ 141
10
M. BAUMGARTEN H A L .
and the triply layered system [ 151 with varying spacer groups. This reaction can even be extended to polymer synthesis yielding [29b1, where, again, the crucial intermediate [29a] is obtained after alkylation of the dianion [28]’with a bifunctional species such as [271 (Irmen et al., 1984; Alexander et al., 1989). According to crystal-structure analysis, the products do indeed adopt a face-to-face arrangement of the annulene layers (Irmen et al., 1984; Maresch et al., 1989). In general, the technique of carbanion alkylation is the method of choice for providing a broad series of compounds for the study of electron-transfer reactions. In this way, indeed, it is possible systematically to vary (i) the type of the n-conjugation and the rigidity of the electrophoric subunits; (ii) the length and conformational behaviour of the spacer; and (iii) the relative orientation and the degree of overlap of the n-systems. These structural factors are relevant for the redox-activity of bis- and oligo-electrophoric systems and for the reorganization energy associated with intramolecular electron hopping.
3
Highly charged states via extended redox sequences
The first question is whether the redox systems can be subjected to successive electron-transfer reactions in extended redox sequences. What one needs to know thereby are the number of charges that can be transferred and what is the Coulombic repulsion arising between the charged subunits. The experimental methods that have to be applied are obvious. Cyclic
ORGANIC REDOX SYSTEMS WITH MULTIPLE ELECTROPHORES
11
voltammetry (Heinze, 1984) provides information on the number of charges being transferred and on the energies of the available redox states. The ionic species formed along an extended redox sequence can be characterized spectroscopically: diamagnetic products by nmr spectroscopy, and the paramagnetic products by esr and ENDOR spectroscopy (Eliasson et al., 1990; Huber and Mullen, 1986; Mullen, 1987; Klabunde et al., 1987; Gerson, 1967, 1970; Kurreck et al., 1988). Quenching reactions can also be applied since they reflect the number of charges in the reduced system, and they can prove that the framework of molecules remains intact upon charging. From the pronounced tendency of cyclo-octatetraene toward dianion formation upon chemical or electrochemical reduction, it is not surprising that the rigid bis-electrophore [51 transforms into a tetra-anion upon chemical or electrochemical reduction. The geometry of the tetra-anion does not lead to significant Coulombic repulsion. The effective compensation of electrostatic energies in oligocyclo-octatetraenyls is even more astonishing if the subunits are brought into conjugative interaction. This is the case in the linear n-chains [30] and [31] that have recently become available and
r
c:n=2
c 321
12
M. BAUMGARTEN E T A L .
in which each cyclo-octatetraene unit accepts two electrons upon reduction ( Auchter-Krummel and Mullen, 1991; Staley et al., 1985).
The situation is less obvious for other electrophores such as anthracene, which upon electrochemical reduction forms a dianion salt, although at a much more negative potential than cyclo-octatetraene. The redox activity of a corresponding “dimer” will, of course, depend upon the chemical mode of linking. The example of l,n-di(9-anthryl) alkanes [6] is revealing (Huber et al., 1983; Becker et al., 1991). Here, the Coulombic interaction between two monocharged anthracene units depends sensitively on the length of the alkanediyl spacer. This energy is reflected by the difference between the first and second reduction potentials in the cyclic voltammogram (Heinze, 1986). Thus an interaction energy can be detected for spacers shorter than butanediyl. Further charging steps up to tri- and tetra-anions are distinctly shifted to more negative potentials than for the anthracene dianion itself and, additionally, a higher repulsion between the doubly charged redox groups is reported (Mortensen et al., 1991). Accordingly, dianthryl compounds with a close proximity, such as [6] and even [ 181,are capable of accepting four electrons although an appreciable electrostatic repulsion is built up (Becker et al., 1991; Huber and Miillen, 1980).When considering the question of how a bis-electrophore accommodates the extra charge it is important to note that, for example, the tetra-anion of di(9-anthry1)ethane [61 adopts an anti-conformation with respect to the central C-C bond, thus minimizing the electrostatic repulsion (Huber et al., 1983). In this context it is noteworthy to refer to the unsaturated analogue 1,2-di(9-anthryl)ethene [ 321 (Weitzel and Mullen, 1990; Weitzel et al., 1990). Like [6] (Becker et al., 1991), compound [32] forms a stable dianion and tetra-anion upon reduction. In the cyclic voltammogram of [321, the first two electrons are transferred at nearly the same potential, pointing to an effective minimization of the Coulombic repulsion between the charged anthryl units (Bohnen et al., 1992). This situation, which again corresponds to that in [6], could imply a torsion about the central olefinic bond (Bock et al., 1989). In contrast to the conformationally mobile dianthrylethanes, the rigid cyclophane [ 111, with a face-to-face arrangement of the n-layers, is electrostatically less favourable for reduction and only gives rise to a dianion upon alkali-metal reduction (Huber et al., 1983). It is straightforward in the charging of a layered electrophore to increase the interplane distance of the n-layers and thus to “relax” the resulting Coulombic strain; this approach is discussed for the doubly layered annulenes [ 141. In this particular case, a stable tetra-anion is available which can be characterized by a highly resolved ‘H-nmr spectrum (Irmen et al., 1984).
ORGANIC REDOX SYSTEMS WITH MULTIPLE ELECTROPHORES
13
There are two remarkable findings: (i) While the neutral compound is made up of two diatropic [14]annulenes, the tetra-anion is composed of two strongly paratropic dianionic subunits; therefore the reduction is accompanied by drastic chemical shift changes, i.e. the ring protons of the tetra-anion appear at very high field (A& ca. - 8 ppm) and the bridge protons at very low field (AdH ca. 18 ppm). (ii) Unlike the neutral compound, the tetra-anion exists in two isomers that from an analysis of the 'H-nmr chemical shifts can be identified as syn- and anti-conformers of [ 141. Surprisingly enough, these two conformational isomers of the tetra-anion do not interconvert even at about + 80°C. Another question concerns the behaviour of redox systems containing more than two separate electrophores. It is characteristic that the tetra-anthrylene [ lOc] with a long undecanediyl spacer group can be reversibly charged with two electrons per electrophore without significant electrostatic interactions between the anthracenes (Becker et al., 1991; Mortensen et al., 1991; Bohnen et al., 1992). A related redox activity is found for the trisanthrylene [ lOa] with short propanediyl spacers (Bohnen et al., 1992). It should be noted, however, that in the cyclic voltammogram there is only one wave for a three-electron transfer; in other words, each anthracene can be charged with one electron without the creation of strong Coulombic repulsion, and only further reduction will then give rise to detectable electrostatic effects. Independent evidence for the redox capacity of these systems can be obtained from quenching reactions; the structure of the hydro-derivative obtained upon protonation of the charged hydrocarbon, i.e. the number of electrophiles being incorporated, reflects the number of charges in the anion. Figure 3 indicates that one can thus chemically prove the formation of both a dianion and a tetra-anion. This example is significant because the reduction of 1,2-di-(9-anthryl)ethanehas been claimed in the literature to cause a rapid cleavage of the ethane o-bond (Gerson et al., 1976; Hammerich and Saveant, 1979). In contrast, under appropriate experimental conditions, even the tetra-anion is a stable species (Huber et al., 1983). The homologous series of oligo( 1.4-naphthylene)~[ 191(Anton et al., 1992) and oligo(9,lO-anthrylene)~ [21] (Baumgarten et al., 1992a) are examples of directly connected electroactive units. In their cyclic voltammograms the first reduction and oxidation potentials are independent of the chain length due to the steric hindrance of conjugation. The second charging step is facilitated with increasing number of electroactive units because of the smaller Coulombic repulsion between the charges residing on the outermost units.
+
14
M. BAUMGARTEN E T A L .
Fig. 3 Quenching of the di- and tetra-anions of 1,2-dianthrylethane [6a] with protons.
At the end of a charging process, nearly every n-unit is singly charged in the case of the naphthylene derivatives and doubly charged in the oligoanthrylenes. The conclusion from the above examples is that under appropriate experimental conditions these systems can be subjected to successive electron-transfer reactions forming highly charged derivatives with intact molecular frameworks.
4
Mechanism of successive electron transfers
As has been pointed out already, the description of successive reduction processes meets with a fundamental problem. If one electron has been injected into a bis-electrophoric system (see Fig. l), the second charge can enter the same unit, forming a dianionic moiety, or it can enter the second neutral unit. The former case is only conceivable if the two extra charges on one redox group give rise to conjugative or ion-pairing effects compensating for the electrostatic repulsion. In the latter, electrostatically more favourable, case the dianion could exist either as a singlet or a triplet species. The situation is even more complicated when a tris-electrophoric system is charged. The first question is which subunit will be charged initially. Then, if a dianion with the two electrons in separate electrophores has been formed, the charges can reside either on neighbouring electrophores or on those allowing the greatest possible distance between charges (see Fig. 1 ). What experimental evidence is available to clarify the resulting mode of spin-density and charge-density distribution? If one characterizes the reduction of (i) a single annulene, (ii) a doubly layered and (iii) a triply layered analogue by cyclic voltammetry, one derives a first criterion (Alexander et al., 1989; Bohnen et al., 1992; Fry et al., 1985). The potential
ORGANIC REDOX SYSTEMS WITH MULTIPLE ELECTROPHORES
15
wave for the diannulenyl [14] shows two very close redox steps, each describing a one-electron transfer. The simulation of these waves provides the potential difference for the first and second reduction; from this, after correcting for the entropy term, one obtains an interaction energy of about 1.7 kcal mol- '. In a similar fashion, the triply layered analogue [ 151 reveals one wave indicating a three-electron transfer. The interaction energy corresponding to a two-fold charging of [ 151 is below 0.2 kcal mol-'. Accordingly, one must describe the dianion of [l5] as a species in which the first two extra electrons reside in the outer layers. Only the injection of the third electron, then, creates a significant interaction energy. It is clear that the charging sequence can be affected not only by the (inner/outer) position of the electrophore within the oligomeric chain, but also by substituents slightly affecting the redox potentials. The oligo( 1.4naphthy1ene)s [ 191carry t-butyl groups only in the terminal units, in contrast to the corresponding oligo( 1,5-naphthylene)s [203, which are substituted with (cation-stabilizing) alkyl groups in each unit. This different substitution pattern explains why the oxidation of [20] occurs with greater ease ( A E z 110 mV) than that of [19] (Bock et al., 1989; Anton et al., 1992). The tris-9,lO-anthrylenes [21a] and [2lb] (Baumgarten et al., 1992a) possess a different number of solubilizing alkyl groups in the central anthracene unit. As a result, the first oxidation of [21a] occurs at a potential 120 mV lower than for [21b] owing to the second stabilizing group. When , alkyl substituents are placed turning to the tetrameric anthrylene [2 1 ~ 1the on the terminal units, which are then preferentially oxidized to the dication, and consequently no Coulombic repulsion is seen. The reduction, on the other hand, is favoured in the central unsubstituted units and the second charging step takes place against a higher interaction energy. As we have shown previously for two different series of oligo( p-pheny1ene)s [22] and [33] (Bohnen et al., 1991; Heinze and Meerholz, 1990), the substitution of central units of a chain can influence the charging behaviour drastically. In [331 with methyl substituents, the conjugation is interrupted as soon as two substituents interfere, leading to hindered rotation around the connecting bond. Thus, independent units of biphenyl ([ 33a], [33cl and [33e]) or terphenyl ([33b] and [33d]) - depending on the hindrance between the subunits -are charged, even in the case of long phenylene chains. While cyclic voltammetric experiments provide thermodynamic and kinetic information on the charging processes (Heinze, 1986), only indirect information on the structure of the redox products is available. Fortunately, independent evidence can be obtained from spectroscopic experiments. Figure 4 depicts the esr spectra recorded for both a dianion and a trianion of [21a] in solid solution. From the zero-field splitting D, which is proportional to the inverse distance of the unpaired electrons, one can roughly
16
M. BAUMGARTEN ET AL.
estimate the location of the charge; there is no doubt that in the dianion the two electrons have entered the outer anthracene moieties. Analogous findings can be obtained for the related tetramer [21c] (Baumgarten et al., 1992a). The detection of zero-field splitting for dianions of [ 181 or [21] is very important; it reveals not only the existence of a triplet state, but it also provides information on the mode of spin density distribution. Even more
Fig. 4 Esr spectra of high-spin trianthrylene [2la] at 120K in MTHF/K: A, biradical triplet state [2la]*-' (labelled 0); B, triradical quartet state [21aI3-' (labelled *); C , biradical triplet state [21aI4-' (labelled m).
ORGANIC REDOX SYSTEMS WITH MULTIPLE ELECTROPHORES
17
subtle structural information is available from the esr spectra, however. Thus, for the conformationally mobile dianthrylalkanes [6]-[9], the zero-field splittings observed for solid solutions of the dianions together with model considerations indicate that the oligomethylene spacers adopt an all-anti conformation, so that the redox-active subunits have the largest possible separation. A related finding appears for the dianions of the doubly layered system [ 141; their esr spectra taken in the glass provide evidence for a triplet structure, and from the D-value the inter-plane distance in the charged species can be readily determined (Irmen et al., 1984; Alexander et al., 1989). The important conclusion to be drawn from the cyclic voltammetric and esr spectroscopic data is that the charging of redox systems with electronically separate units follows a certain sequence. Thus, according to the esr spectra, the first electron will enter the inner unit of the triply layered system [ 151 while, according to the cyclic voltammogram and zero-field splitting derived from the esr spectra, the corresponding dianion has the two electrons in the outer layers. Accordingly, transition from the monoanion to the dianion will require a redistribution of charge, i.e. an electron-hopping process (Alexander et al., 1989).
5
Structural factors relevant t o intramolecular electron transfer
The occurrence of intramolecular electron-hopping processes will now be discussed in detail, considering on an empirical basis systematic variation of relevant structural factors in the substrates. First, however, a few theoretical and experimental aspects will be summarized. In a general description of intramolecular electron-transfer (ET) processes one has to differentiate between charge separation in donor/acceptor (D/A) systems via the formation of photoexcited states and a “charge-transfer” or “charge-shift” reaction that is thermally activated (Cannon, 1980; Fox and Chanon, 1988; Meyer, 1978). For systems such as A-1-A, where each subunit A can act as donor or acceptor, the latter case may also be described in some cases as resonance as in ( l ) , because the electronic configuration can be written without a
difference in energy. If we think of a charge transfer (Ulstrup, 1979) between particle A+‘/-‘ and A, however, it is possible to define a rate constant k for
18
M. BAUMGARTEN E T A L .
this process, which, according to the Arrhenius equation, possesses an exponential temperature dependence (2), where A is a proportionality factor,
E , the activation energy,k , the Boltzmann constant and T the temperature. Following Eyring’s transition-state theory (Eyring, 1935a,b), one may replace A by Z K , where Z is either the collision frequency in bimolecular reactions or the vibrational frequency in intramolecular reactions in bridged systems, and K is the transmission coefficient, i.e. the probability that activated complexes (transition states) yield the product. By using the free energy of activation AG*, Marcus (1956, 1963, 1965) described the rate constant as a function of AG* and the thermal energy k,T as in (3). At large values of r, k = Zrc(r)exp( -AG*/k,T).
(3)
is assumed to change exponentially with r. The kind of process involved (adiabatic or non-adiabatic) depends on the J may be coupling J between the wavefunctions Y(+”-’lo)and Y(ol+.’-’). expressed as a function of overlap S of both states (Heilbronner and Bock, 1978; Hoffmann, 1971) by (4), in which the parameters are defined as in (4a) K
and He, is the Hamiltonian for the system in the Born-Oppenheimer approximation. The adiabatic and non-adiabatic processes may be visualized in terms of two intersecting potential curves, one of them representing the electronic configuration ( +./-.lo) and the other one the configuration (01 +./ -.). This is demonstrated in Fig. 5A-C for the cases of very strong, strong and weak coupling, where the first two examples are generally called adiabatic and the last non-adiabatic. A very strong coupling (large value of J ) results in the formation of a single minimum surface with a symmetric chargedelocalized ground-state ion (either anion or cation, Fig. 5A). For somewhat smaller values of J the process is still adiabatic, and the resulting surface has a double-minimum potential. Interconversion between the degenerate charge-localized states takes place via the avoided crossing region on the
ORGANIC REDOX SYSTEMS WITH MULTIPLE ELECTROPHORES
4
A
B
19
C
nuclear coordinates
Fig. 5 Potential energy hypersurfaces as a function of the reaction coordinate for adiabatic (A, single-minimum potential; B, double-minimum potential) and non-adiabatic (C) electron-transfer reactions.
lower surface, while the electronically excited state surface has a single minimum. The magnitude of the avoided crossing region is given by twice the electron coupling integral J (Fig. 5B).In the non-adiabatic region with two separate curves an energy of 1would be necessary for electron transfer between the states, if no reorganization of the solvation shell takes place. Thermal activation of the solvent to a configuration in which the free energy of the ion is unchanged, is, however, possible at lower energies. For isoenergetic parabolic potential curves the energy of this point is $2 (Fig. 5C). Comparing J with the thermal energy, one can differentiate between the two processes. For adiabatic surfaces the coupling J >> kb’T; while in the non-adiabatic case J << kb i? A quantitative description of the two types of process can be made using the Landau-Zehner parameter g (Ziilicke, 1985; Onuchic et al., 1986) defined in ( 5 ) . Here, o,is the frequency of the vibrational g=-
2rcIJ(’ ho,1
mode determining the ET. If g >> 1, the reaction is adiabatic, and for g << 1 it is non-adiabatic. If we consider ET in the ground state, we shall deal with an adiabatic case where the occurrence of charge transfer depends on the activation energy between the double-minimum potential (Meyer, 1978). When defining the activation energy AG +, one typically uses the approximations of harmonic
M . BAUMGARTEN ET AL.
20
oscillators and parabolic potential curves, yielding a quadratic dependence (6) on 1 and AGO (Marcus, 1956, 1963, 1965; Closs and Miller, 1988; AG+
= (AGO
+~ ) ~ / 4 1
(6)
Closs et al., 1989; Liang et al., 1990; Hush, 1961, 1975), where 1 is the total reorganization energy, and AGO the difference in free energy of the two minima. The reorganization energy 1 is the sum of two terms, As + ili, the inner sphere reorganization ,Ii for changes of D/A (structure, geometry, and vibrational states) and the solvent reorganization 1,.In a simple model A, can be expressed by (7) in terms of the optical (cop) and static ( E , ) dielectric
1, = e2 +al + +a2 -
(
--)(& 1
-
t)
(7)
constants of the medium, the radii of donors and acceptors ai, the electronic charge e and the centre-to-centre distance r (Closs and Miller, 1988; Closs et al., 1989; Liang et al., 1990; Wasielewski, 1989). il may be determined experimentally, for example from charge-transfer bands ( Wasielewski, 1989; Siders and Marcus, 1981) or from the self-exchange rates for identical subunits where AGO is zero and k,, depends only on 1 through (8) (Grampp et al., 1990a).
k,,
= ZKexp[
+
-
'1
4AkbT
In the quantum mechanical formulation of electron transfer (Atkins, 1984; Closs et al., 1986) as a radiationless transition, the rate of ET is described as the product of the electronic coupling term J 2 and the Frank-Condon factor FC, which is weighted with the Boltzmann population of the vibrational energy levels. But Marcus and Sutin (1985) have pointed out that, in the high-temperature limit, this treatment yields the semiclassical expression (9). k
= 4n ~
h
J2(
-)'"
1 4nlk,T
exp[ -
+
41kb T
(9)
Thus the distance dependence of ET can be divided into the distance dependence of J and that of 1.For J an exponential decrease with increasing distance is assumed (Wasielewski, 1989). A principal distinction is made between outer-sphere and inner-sphere mechanisms in ET reactions (Kochi, 1988). In the outer-sphere reactions the
ORGANIC REDOX SYSTEMS WITH MULTIPLE ELECTROPHORES
21
donor and acceptor are viewed as separate units even in the transition state of the transfer, and the kinetics show an exponential decrease with increasing distance (Kuznetsov and Ulstrup, 198 1). In the inner-sphere mechanism a compact transition state is formed where the coordination spheres of D and A penetrate each other (overlap), and the structure of the reactants is changed. The outer-sphere reactions may be described by the Marcus theory. This approach is widely used for explaining inter- and intra-molecular chargetransfer processes including systems such as A-1-A (Kuznetsov and Ulstrop, 1981) as long as no direct overlap occurs between the orbitals of each A (Fukuzumi et al., 1980; Hay et al., 1975). A number of different techniques have been applied to test the distance and orientation dependence of ET reactions (Closs and Miller, 1988; Closs et al., 1989; Liang et al., 1990; Reimers and Hush, 1990; Fox and Chanon, 1988; Wasielewski, 1989; Paddon Row and Jordan, 1988; Joachim et al., 1990; McConnell, 1961). Our method of analysing the mode of charge distribution in charged species is esr spectroscopy, which defines the timescale of the detectable dynamic species (Gerson, 1967; Kurreck et al., 1988; Wertz and Bolton, 1972). If an electron transfer is slow relative to the esr timescale ( < l o - ’ s) the spectrum corresponds to that of monomeric model compounds with a single electrophore. If the hopping process is rapid on the esr timescale, one will detect an effective delocalization. The charged electrophores are prepared by chemical or electrochemical electron transfer (reduction or oxidation) in solution and exist as ion pairs (Hogen-Esch, 1977; Huber and Miillen, 1986; Gerson, 1967). This situation differs significantly from that in which, for example, radical anions are prepared by pulse radiolysis (Closs and Miller, 1988; Closs et al., 1989; Liang et al., 1990). In the latter only “naked” anions exist, which possess no interaction with counterions. As has been described above, intramolecular hopping of electrons between electrophoric units requires a reorganization of the ion pair and of the solvent shell. Not surprisingly, therefore, the rate constants of such processes are similar to those observed in pulse-radiolysis experiments. It should be added that under the prevailing experimental conditions (e.g. high dilution) intermolecular electron-exchange processes are slow and do not affect the appearance of the esr spectra (Kurreck et al., 1988; Becker et al., 1991). In several cases studied in the literature the rates of exchange processes are within the esr timescale and give rise to dynamic line broadening (Ward and Weissman, 1957; Freed and Fraenkel, 1964). With the assumption of a short time for the jump itself, an adequate description of the exchange process is given by the modified Bloch equation (Gutowsky and Holm, 1956). The lineshape for an equilibrium is then described by the complex transverse magnetization M . The alternating linewidth effects have been particularly
M. BAUMGARTEN E T A L .
22
useful within kinetic analyses (Freed and Fraenkel, 1964; Sullivan and Bolton, 1970). Once the rate constants have been evaluated by spectral analysis for a series of temperatures, the determination of the activation parameters is achieved. While similar examples will also be reported herein, the emphasis is on the discrimination between localization of spin density in a single redox unit and effective delocalization over the entire molecule, i.e. on a yes/no decision between two borderline cases. Thus, in the present approach, the major focus is on the question of how we can influence the “external” parameters like solvent and counterion and the “intrinsic” structural parameters within the systems A-1-A to force the electron-hopping process into the timescale of the experiment, or at least to establish clearly the borderline cases. That we are still looking at an electron-hopping process in the case of “effective charge delocalization” over the entire molecule and not at a pure resonance phenomenon may be reassured by VIS/NIR spectroscopy of the neutral and charged species; the absorption of a single chromophore should be detected unless a very fast process > lo’, Hz is taking place. THE NATURE OF THE SUBUNIT
The first structural factor that is relevant for electron hopping is the electrophoric subunit. The reduction of the spirodicyclo-octatetraenylsystem [ 5 ] again serves as a suitable introductory case. Upon prolonged metal contact in solution [ S ] can be charged to a tetra-anion, where the number of H- and 3C-nmr signals reflects the D,, symmetry (Krummel et al., 1987; Auchter-Krummel and Mullen, 1991;Krummel, 1988).The intermediate ions such as the monoanion and the dianion are more interesting since they can represent “mixed”-valence states (Reimers and Hush, 1990; McConnell, 1961). It follows from the esr spectrum of the monoanion, which closely corresponds to that of a “monomeric” cyclo-octatetraene radical anion, that the unpaired electron is localized on one ring and that, even at elevated temperatures, there is no rapid hopping between the two rings. A completely analogous finding is obtained for the corresponding dianion. The 13C-nmr spectrum of the latter can be looked at as a superposition of a “neutral” and a “dianionic” spectrum. It is thus clear that the two excess charges are both localized on one subunit; even at +90°C the spectra fail to show any changes and to reveal any hopping process. Another important point can be deduced from the splitting pattern of the methylene protons in the ‘H-nmr spectrum of the dianion salt [5I2-/2Li+. It appears from the equivalence of, for example, H-9,11 and the nonequivalence of H-9’,11’ that the charged ring is planar, while the uncharged ring is tub-shaped (Fig. 6) (Krummel et al., 1987). The latter
’
’
23
ORGANIC REDOX SYSTEMS WITH MULTIPLE ELECTROPHORES
H - 9 a .b
H-9'a.b
T
O°C
I
11 I
8
6
.
.
~
'
~
t
'
'
4
~
'
~
~
'
T = -6OOC
.
2
.
"
'
.
'
~
~
'
.
.
0
Fig. 6 Nmr spectra ofthe dianion of [ 51 with the molecular positions and assignment of protons.
"
'
'
24
M. BAUMGARTEN E T A L .
undergoes a rapid ring inversion whose slow-exchange domain is reached at -60°C. The localization of two electrons in one ring and the failure to observe an intramolecular electron transfer in [ 51 and [512- is again related to the specific redox-behaviour of the parent system, cyclo-octatetraene (Anet et al., 1964; Krummel et al., 1987; Staley et al., 1985).It is characteristic for the latter that (i) upon injection of an electron, the ring experiences a flattening and that (ii) the electronic stabilization of the dianion overcompensates the Coulombic energy associated with the second electron transfer upon transition from the radical monoanion to the dianion (Katz, 1960; Anet et al., 1964; Eliasson and Staley, 1985). Such a flattening is also likely to occur for the second (uncharged) ring of [5]’- in the course of an intramolecular electron transfer. This flattening will require some steric strain, an energy term that contributes to the inner-sphere reorganization energy Izi of the intramolecular electron transfer, and this will increase the overall activation barrier. Accordingly, if we want to bring about a rapid intramolecular electron transfer between identical electrophores, we shall have to introduce rigid electrophores that do not experience a significant structural change upon charging. The “extra stabilization” of charged cyclo-octatetraene and the reluctance of cyclo-octatetraenes to be involved in intra- or inter-molecular electrontransfer processes is also documented by the behaviour of the cyclooctatetraenylenevinylenes [301 and [311 ( Auchter-Krummel and Mullen, 1991; Staley et al., 1985). In the dianion of e.g. [30a] and [31a] the charge is localized on one eight-membered ring, although a complete 7c-charge delocalization within the conjugated systems is not inhibited by a saturated spacer. The reason is again the steric strain associated with the flattening of the cyclo-octatetraene moiety. Characteristically enough, a charge-shift occurs in [30a12 - at temperatures above - 20°C whereas [3 la] does not exhibit dynamic behaviour even above room temperature. A localization of the spin density on one redox-group of a bis-electrophore has also been observed for the radical anion of spiro [5.51undeca-1,4,6,9tetraene-3,8-dione [341 (Gerson et al., 1972). The authors emphasize, however, that in this case the localization is mainly due to the interaction of the oxygen atoms with the counterions. In contrast to this finding, the unpaired electron is delocalized over both z-systems in the radical anion of the spirobifluorene [35] (Gerson et al., 1974). This seems to support the assumption that an effective delocalization can be brought about by introducing two rigid electrophores for which injection of an extra electron induces no conformational change; an orthogonal arrangement of the two electrophores, however, does not necessarily inhibit rapid electron transfer. In contrast to the dianion of the spirodicyclo-octatetraenyl [51, the dianion of the spirobifluorene [35] exists as a triplet biradical. This spin state of the -’
’-
ORGANIC REDOX SYSTEMS WITH MULTIPLE ELECTROPHORES
25
dianion can be rationalized in terms of a double degeneracy of the lowest antibonding orbitals of [351.
THE LENGTH OF THE BRIDGING GROUP
1,n-Di-(9-anthry1)alkanes [61 are suitable for investigating the influence of the distance between the single redox groups A, since the length of the conformationally mobile alkane chain 1 can readily be varied. As pointed out above, injection of an electron into the bis-electrophore forming a radical anion raises two main questions: (i) is the unpaired electron localized in one subunit or does a rapid electron-hopping process occur so that within the timescale of the esr experiment one observes an effective delocalization over both units; and (ii) can one clearly distinguish between the extremes experimentally? The obvious criteria are the magnitude -of the esr/ENDOR hyperfine coupling constants and the multiplicity of the hyperfine coupling constants, which reflects the number of equivalent hydrogen atoms coupling with the unpaired electron (Kurreck et al., 1988; Wertz and Bolton, 1972). It is clear from Fig. 7 that the potassium salt of the dianthrylethane radical anion in a mixture of dimethoxyethane (DME) and hexamethylphosphoramide (HMPA) as solvent has the unpaired electron effectively delocalized over both units (Fiedler et al., 1986). This outcome, however, depends on the
M. BAUMGARTEN E T A L .
26
A
B
Fig. 7 Esr and ENDOR spectra of 1,2-dianthrylethane [6a] for different ion-pair conditions: A, DMEiHMPA, K'; B, MTHF, K + at 190 K in solution.
length of the alkanediyl spacer group. Thus, an analogous finding, i.e. effective delocalization over both anthracene units, can be made for the propanediyl-, and butanediyl bridged system, while the corresponding dianthrylhexane radical anion shows localization of the unpaired electron in one anthracene unit under all experimental conditions, both in different solvent systems and at different temperatures. In the latter case, the esr- and ENDOR spectra closely correspond to those of the 9-alkylanthracene radical anion (Fiedler et al., 1986; Huber et al., 1983). Thus an electron transfer is hampered by the activation barrier between the double-minimum potential; we can no longer differentiate between an adiabatic process with large activation and a non-adiabatic process (McConnell, 1961; Kuznetsov and Ulstrup, 1981). This occurs even for the flexible alkanediyl bridging chains, where a rapid rotation and reorientation of the spacer and electrophores is possible in solution. Furthermore, the delocalization is strongly distance-dependent, so that a through-space mechanism seems to be responsible for the exchange, while through-bond transfer is not favourable in longer alkanediyl chains. The average distance between the electrophores is too large for an effective through-space coupling; therefore, no Coulombic interaction (CV) and zero-field splitting (esr) is observed in the doubly charged species, which should be a biradical (Becker et al., 1991). The distance dependence of the electron-transfer rate can also be demonstrated for the non-benzenoid systems [ 141 and [ 151, which
ORGANIC REDOX SYSTEMS WITH MULTIPLE ELECTROPHORES
27
incorporate [ 14lannulenes (Alexander et al., 1989; Irmen et al., 1984). Like the dianthrylalkanes, they possess flexible spacer groups; the connection of the Ir-layers, however, enforces a direct n,n-interaction (Irmen et al., 1984). The radical anion of the bridged [14]annulene [14] can again serve as reference system. Its esr hyperfine coupling constants are in accord with a simple MO model (Mullen, 1978). When one proceeds to the radical anion of the analogous doubly layered system with a propanediyl chain as a spacer [ 14a], one observes only half the magnitude of the coupling constants (Irmen et al., 1984). This is convincing evidence for an effective delocalization of the spin density over both layers, and thus for rapid electron transfer. When the inter-plane distance is increased, however, the esr and ENDOR spectra closely correspond to those of the monomer. Consequently, by setting the appropriate length of the spacer, one can control the rate of the degenerate electron transfer and switch between a spin-localized and spin-delocalized situation. Accordingly, from spectroscopic evidence we can clearly distinguish whether radical anions derived from bis-electrophores exhibit rapid or slow electron hopping on the timescale of the experiment. Furthermore, there is a certain maximum of the spacer length beyond which intramolecular electron transfer is no longer detectable. For long, flexible spacer groups and electronically “decoupled” electrophores, the contribution of spacer reorganization to the activation barrier of the exchanger process is too large. A theoretical treatment of electron hopping in bis-electrophores with flexible spacers will have to consider different conformations of the spacer. Inclusion of rigid biselectrophores (with a fixed distance) is therefore relevant. The question of “how far an electron can be transferred” in radical anions of bis-electrophores has been the subject of several articles (Harriman and Maki, 1963; Shimada et al., 1972; Shimada and Szwarc, 1974, 1975; Gerson et al. 1984); the systems studied possess both flexible and rigid spacer groups between the electrophores. The findings accumulated for a series of 1,n-dinaphthylalkanes (Shimada et al., 1972; Shimada and Szwarc, 1975) are in qualitative agreement with the above results on dianthrylalkanes. An analogous scaling for rigid spacers does not exist, but it was demonstrated for compound [36a] and higher homologues [36b] and [36c] with more than one spiro-bonded cyclobutane unit (Shimada and Szwarc, 1974; Gerson et al., 1984) that electron hopping can occur for distances up to 0.8 nm. Long-range electron transfer has also been reported in a recent esr/ENDOR study of stable radical anions of naphthalenes attached to rigid norbornane spacers of variable length (Gerson et al., 1990). No counterion or solvent effects were found for the dinaphthobicycloheptadienc [37al with a small edge-to-edge (e-e) separation [ r = 0.24 nm(e-e); r = 0.63 nm (centre-tocentre)], and complete delocalization could generally be detected. The esr/ENDOR spectra of dinaphthotetracyclododecadiene [ 37b] and di-
28
M. BAUMGARTEN ET AL.
naphthohexacyclohexadecadiene [37c] revealed that the electron transfer between the naphthalene moieties in the radical anion is slowed down, but still within the esr timescale. This occurs even though the centre-to-centre distances between naphthylene groups are r = 0.8 nm in [37b] and r = 1.03 nm in [37c]. The long-range interaction of n-systems across rigid saturated bridges has also been studied by PES in the gas phase, where the ionization potentials provide a direct measure of 25 (Paddon-Row and Jordan, 1988). These studies demonstrated that through-bond coupling is considerable and easily exceeds through-space coupling in rigidly linked olefins. Linear extrapolation of J-values for the cation radicals of [38a; n = 13 and [38b] as a function of the number of single bonds separating the alkene moieties allowed estimation of the rate constants for thermal electron transfer in the ground state cation radicals of [ 38a; n = 2, 3 and 41 by use of equation (9). In a study of long range ET between aromatic donor (biphenyl) and acceptor molecules separated by steroid spacers [391, pulse radiolysis and electron beam techniques have been used for the injection of electrons (Closs and Miller, 1988; Closs et al., 1989; Liang et al., 1990). Here, the reaction rates (observed by changes in the absorption spectra) pass through a
[37b]
a
a
c401
29
ORGANIC REDOX SYSTEMS WITH MULTIPLE ELECTROPHORES
maximum for different acceptors, and the results confirm the inverted region predicted by Marcus (A < (AG'I) (Miller et al., 1984). For a cyclohexane and decalin bridge, the dependence of ET rates on the orientation of a biphenyl donor and naphthyl acceptor was studied. Although a considerable difference in the centre-to-centre distance results for two decalin isomers (2,7-a,a and 2,7-e,e) [40a] and [40b], the reaction rates did not change in a dramatic way. Through-bond coupling is therefore assumed to dominate over a through-space mechanism. THE CONFORMATION OF THE BRIDGING GROUP
Turning again to flexible spacers, it appears that in oligo( anthrylene) species [lo] a long, flexible (CH,),-chain improves the solubility of the compound, which is particularly important in the related polymers. The question therefore arises whether one can bring about rapid electron transfer even for long spacer groups and thus whether a fine-tuning of the electron-transfer behaviour is possible for a given spacer length. The solution of the problem comes from a conformational analysis of oligomethylene chains, which are known to adopt preferentially an all-anti conformation (Dale, 1974). A different situation is encountered in oxaethylene chains, which prefer a gauche conformation with respect to the carbon-oxygen bond, thus giving rise to a helical conformation of the chain. The crystal structure of the biselectrophore [7a] provides a convincing example (Fiedler et al., 1986). The corresponding hydrocarbon species with the same spacer length, the dianthrylundecane [6e], forms a radical anion that always exists as a spin-localized species. The esr spectrum obtained for the radical anion of the structurally related ether [7a] (see Fig. 8) is temperature-dependent, which
Ill
A. \
T=233K
Fig. 8 Esr spectra of the alkoxy-bridged dianthryl [7] at two temperatures: A, 190 K; B, 233 K.
30
M. BAUMGARTEN E T A L .
indicates that intramolecular electron transfer occurs on the timescale of the experiment. The measurement has been performed on the potassium salt in dimethoxyethane, and similar results have been obtained for the lithium salt in 2-methyltetrahydrofuran. By means of lineshape analysis, we can determine the free energy of activation of the intramolecular electron transfer as AG* = 3.5 kcal mol-’. A similar rate-increasing effect is detected with the homologous ether [7b] (Fiedler et al., 1986). When rationalizing the significant difference of the hydrocarbon- and ether-bridged radical anions, the main aspect will certainly be the conformation of the oxyethylene chain, which brings the electrophores into closer contact. An additional aspect follows from the ability of the oxygen centres along the chain to chelate the counterion and thus to fix the cation between the electrophores. It is not possible from the available experimental evidence to discriminate between the two effects. The role of ion pairing and the relative position of the counterion and carbanion will be dealt with below. There is, however, another obvious effect of conformation upon the electron-transfer rate. In the p-anthracenophane [ 111, the mode of linking enforces a face-to-face arrangement of the 7c-layers (Huber et al., 1983; Gerson et al., 1976). Correspondingly, for its radical anion effective delocalization has been detected under all experimental conditions in solution. It is not clear from the available evidence whether a hopping process occurs, thus giving rise to a double-minimum profile, or whether there is a true spin-delocalized structure representing a single-minimum energy profile. This question will be answered below. When comparing the esr hyperfine coupling constants of [ 111-. with those of the flexible dianthrylethane radical anion [61 -’, a close correspondence can be seen between flexible and rigid species (Becker et al., 1991). Even the coupling constants of the methylene protons are very similar, although they are known to be sensitively dependent upon conformation. What these data seem to suggest is that the dianthrylethane radical anion adopts a conformation in solution with an (at least partially) eclipsed position of the electrophores. Such a structure would differ from that of the triplet dianion [6a]’-., where the zero-field splitting suggests an anti-conformation of the anthryl units with respect to the central C-C bond (Becker et al., 1991). In agreement with this are the results for other “phane” structures, which may also be compared with their corresponding flexible alkanediyl bridged forms as in paracyclophane [41] (McConnell, 1961; Gerson and Martin, 1969), syn- and anti- [2,2] naphthalenophane [42] (Gerson et al., 1976; Hamacher et al., 1986; Konishi and Reddoch, 1977) and syn- and anti-[2,2]( 1,4)-anthracenophane [ 121 (Nemoto et al., 1980). For bridged naphthalenes with a flexible alkanediyl chain [43] and a more rigid cyclohexane bridge [441 it was found that the intramolecular electron transfer
ORGANIC REDOX SYSTEMS WITH MULTIPLE ELECTROPHORES
31
is around five times faster within the open chain structure possessing the same number of bonds as for the rigid cyclohexane (Shimada and Szwarc, 1974). Aromatic spacers have also been used; thus it could be shown for a phenylene-bridged diporphyrinyl system that electron hopping between both subunits can occur (Huber et al., 1990). Here the phenylene bridge is twisted out of conjugation with the two porphyrin rings, and the effect is observed for 1,4-(para) [45a] and the 1,3-(meta) [45b] substitution. While the rate of an electron-transfer process and thus the mode of the resulting spin-density distribution can be controlled by the length and the conformation of the spacer groups, the ion pairing creates an additional factor that can serve as some “external” control even for a given choice of subunits and spacers.
Plr
Ar
[45a] Ar=CCHs,M=Zn
Ar
[45b] Ar=C6Hs,M=Zn
32
M. BAUMGARTEN €T AL.
I O N PAIRING
It has been pointed out already that formation of a radical anion by a redox process in solution produces an ion pair and that any hopping of the electrons will thus be bound to the migration of the cation, which then becomes rate-limiting (Gerson et al., 1972, 1974, 1990). The ,ion-pair structure of the radicals is mainly affected by the size of the counterions and the ion-solvating capability of the solvent (Hogen-Esch, 1977; Szwarc, 1968). The example in Fig. 7 is significant for the reorganization of the ion-pair structure in the course of an electron transfer. It has been shown already that the radical anion of dianthrylethane as its potassium salt in a DME/HMPA solution possesses an effective delocalization of the spin (Huber et al., 1983; Becker et al., 1991). If this solvent system is replaced by 2-methyltetrahydrofuran, leaving all other conditions unchanged, one can readily switch from a spin-delocalized to a spin-localized situation. It is known from various pieces of evidence (Huber et al., 1983; Szwarc, 1974) that 2-methyltetrahydrofuran has a poor cation solvating ability and strongly favours contact ion pairs, i.e. a tight interaction of counterion and carbanion, while, on the other hand, HMPA and dimethoxyethane with their strong cation coordinating ability generate solvent-separated ion pairs. If an intramolecular electron transfer requires a reorganization not only of the redox units but also of the ion-pair structure, it is clear that the existence of a tight ion pair increases the overall activation barrier of the electron-hopping process. Not surprisingly, therefore, increasing cation coordinating ability of the solvent allows one to accelerate the intramolecular electron transfer. This feature provides the opportunity of controlling the electron-transfer rate just by the experimental conditions. It thus constitutes an “external” factor in contrast to the “internal” factors such as the nature of the redox group and of the spacer. The same “control mechanism” can be put to work for the doubly layered electrophores [ 141. From esr measurements it appears that a change only of the ion pairing brings about a different hopping rate and creates a different spin-density distribution within the timescale of the experiment. The important role of ion pairing for the rates of intramolecular electron transfers has been addressed in nearly all articles concerned with this subject. The most direct pieces of evidence for the high influence of anion-cation interaction result from the investigation of radical anions of phane species such as [ l l ] , [12] and [41]-[43] (Huber and Miillen, 1980; Gerson et al., 1976; Gerson and Martin, 1969; Hamacher et al., 1986; Konishi and Reddoch, 1977; Nemoto et al., 1980). Owing to the strong interaction of the two n-systems as a result of the face-to-face arrangement, rapid electron
ORGANIC REDOX SYSTEMS WITH MULTIPLE ELECTROPHORES
33
transfer is expected for all these derivatives. However, even for the radical anions, the intramolecular self-exchange is somewhat slowed down in solvents of low cation-solvating power. For defining the timescale of the actual electron-transfer processes, it is crucial to apply solvents of high solvating ability, since otherwise the exchange rate is tied in with the significantly lower rate of concomitant migration of the cation. Fixing the location of the counterion midway between two identical electrophores has been achieved in the radical anion of the dibenzo [ 18lcrown-6 derivative [46] (Mazur et al., 1980). When its radical anion exists as the ion pair with Na or K +,the intramolecular electron transfer becomes detectable on the esr timescale. The activation energy determined for the electron transfer (1.4 kcal mol-') clearly demonstrates that in this case a significant contribution to the activation barrier from ion pairing can be negated. In the radical anions of the norbornane-linked naphthalenes [ 371 mentioned earlier (Gerson et al., 1990) no counterion effects were detected for [37a], which has a small spatial separation, but the esr/ENDOR spectra of [37b] and [37c] -. indicate that the electron-spin transfer between the naphthalene moieties is determined by the rate of synchronous counterion migration (Gerson et al., 1990). For tight ion pairs the electron is localized, while for loose ion-pair conditions, e.g. by using solvents of high cation-solvating power, the transfer becomes fast on the hyperfine timescale (k > lo7 Hz). Esr spectroscopy has also been used to study pure solvent dynamics in electron self-exchange reactions (Grampp et al., 1990a; Grampp and Jaenicke, 1984a,b). When the systems are not linked by a spacer (i.e. TCNQ-'/TCNQ (TCNQ = tetracyanoquinodimethane), the homogeneous bimolecular rate constants khom are given by ( 1O), with kA the association constant and kET +
-'
the actual electron-transfer rate, comparable to our intramolecular exchange rate. The solvent dependence of the rate constant is explained in terms of Marcus theory by using an outer-sphere reorganization energy. This leads to an experimental reaction distance between the two molecules in the transition state for this adiabatic process (Grampp et al., 1990a). As an extension of the intermolecular self-exchange described above, the solvent-induced intramolecular electron exchange kinetics in radical anions of 1,3-dinitrobenzene [47] and benzene 1,3-dicarbaldehyde [48] have been studied by several authors (Freed and Fraenkel, 1964; Grampp et al., 1989, 1990b; Shohoji et al., 1987).The advantage of [47] and [48] is their structural simplicity and their high stability, which allows measurements even in protic
M.BAUMGARTEN ET AL
34
NC
ray
CN
0
solvents; in particular, the fixed distance and orientation of the redox centres open the possibility of a straightforward application of theoretical models. From alternate line-broadening effects in the esr spectra, the solventdependent intramolecular exchange rates can be derived, which in turn allows the calculation of values for the outer-sphere reorganization energy. If, on the other hand, the electron transfer in solution is determined by some rearrangement within the ion-pair structure, it is crucial to investigate the feasibility of electron transfer for an immobilized ion-pair structure in the solid state. For three substrates, the doubly layercd annulene [ 14a], the dianthrylethane [6a] and the anthracenophane [ 111, the radical anions were prepared under experimental conditions bringing about a spin-delocalized structure in solution. The solutions were then frozen into a glass by cooling, and the solid-state ENDOR spectra measured using the Davis pulse method (Davis, 1974; Grupp and Mehring, 1990; Rautter et al., 1992). It appears from the interpretation of the experimental spectra that, independently of the temperature in the glass, there is only a spin-localized structure. This occurs in the case of a doubly layered system [14a] and for the dianthryl [6a] (Fig. 9) (Rautter et al., 1992). What is even more surprising is that it also holds for the anthracenophane [ 111 with a short interplane distance of about 3 A. In solution the slow-exchange domain of the hopping process could never be achieved. Accordingly, if in a rigid system with strong n,n-overlap of the electrophoric group the position of the cation is fixed, the localization of the electron on one side of a bis-electrophoric molecule is enforced. Computer simulation of the experimental spectra in the frozen solution points to a spin-localized structure independent of the temperature. This interpretation is unambiguous because, in the solid state, the dipolar contributions of the hyperfine interaction A( dip) for all three principal
ORGANIC REDOX SYSTEMS WITH MULTIPLE ELECTROPHORES
35
Fig. 9 Pulse ENDOR spectra of 1,3-dianthrylpropane[6b] at different temperatures.
directions must sum to zero, leaving the isotropic components a(iso), which are directly proportional to the spin densities at the carbon centres [see ( 1 la,b)]. Furthermore, by warming the samples until the solutions liquify A
= a(iso)
+ A(dip)
( 1l a )
(ca. 200 K), a drastic decrease in hyperfine splittings and thus spin densities
to one-half of the original values can be observed within the same experiment. For the examples of [11]-'/K+ and [14]-'/K+, it could also be proved that the transition between localized and delocalized states takes place at the phase transition between solid and liquid state (Rautter et al., 1992). In order to obtain kinetic parameters for the electron transfer of [ 1l ] - ' / K + , the dephasing time t, of the electron-spin echo near the phase-transition temperature T, was measured. These"experiments gave a correlation time t , of 100 ns for the electron transfer at T, = 170 K. From the assumption of an exponential decrease oft, in solution, a value of 100 ps was estimated for t , at room temperature (Rautter, 1989; Rautter et al., 1992).
36
M. BAUMGARTEN ET AL.
It has been shown so far that “internal” and “external” factors can be combined in the control of the electron-transfer rate. Although in most cases a simple theoretical treatment, e.g. by the Marcus approach, is prevented by the coincidence of these factors, it is clear that the observed features for the isoenergetic self-exchange differ by the electronic coupling and the free energy of activation. Then it is also difficult to separate the inner- and outer-sphere reorganization energies.
THE MODE OF LINKING
It will be shown that even more subtle structural changes can bring about drastic consequences in the electron-transfer kinetics. At first glance, the “dianthryl” compounds [61, [81 and [9] are closely related since they possess the same electrophoric subunit and the same ethanediyl bridge (Becker et al., 1991).Yet it appears that the different mode of linking profoundly affects the redox behaviour. The first evidence comes from cyclic voltammetric data. The question is whether the presence of the second redox group could facilitate the reduction oT the first one. This aspect could in principle be evaluated by comparison with the first redox potentials of suitably substituted monomeric analogues. More important in the present context is the interaction energy between the two electrophores, each carrying one extra electron. The experimental measure of this interaction is clearly the difference AE 1 , 2 between the first and second redox potentials (Bohnen et al., 1992). Considering first the anthracenophanes [ l l ] and [12], it is quite reasonable that the strong interaction of the n-systems as a result of the face-to-face arrangement should give rise to a significant potential difference upon dianion formation. More interestingly, a significant potential difference AE1,2can be detected for the di(9-anthry1)ethane [6] but not for the isomeric species [8] and [9] in which the bridge is attached to the centres C-1 and C-2 respectively. Even in the ortho-cyclophane [ 131 with two linkages there is no detectable interaction energy (Becker et al., 1991). It is thus possible to classify the closely related dianthryl systems according to the degree of interaction of the subunits; the question that immediately follows is whether such a clustering also develops from esr spectroscopic study of the corresponding radical anions. In the radical anions of the di(2-anthryl) system [9] and of the ortho-cyclophane [ 131 a spin-localized situation prevails independently of temperature and ion pairing. On the other hand, for the corresponding di(9-anthryl) species and even for the di( 1-anthryl) species a rapid hopping process can be detected if suitable ion pairing is established (Becker et al., 1991). Thus, according to both cyclic voltammetric and esr spectroscopic
ORGANIC REDOX SYSTEMS WITH MULTIPLE ELECTROPHORES
37
evidence, the closely related dianthrylethane systems can be classified into three groups: (i) compounds [ 111 and [ 123 with strong interaction energy whose radical anions under all experimental conditions undergo rapid electron hopping in solution;
(ii) compounds [6a] and [8] whose radical anions show rapid or slow hopping, that is spin localization or effective delocalization, depending on the experimental conditions; and (iii) compounds [9a] and [ 131 with weak interaction, whose radical anions fail to exhibit electron transfer on the timescale of the experiment. When rationalizing the different behaviour of closely related biselectrophores, one must be aware that the intramolecular electron-transfer process requires some mixing of product and educt wave functions. The mode of linking seems to allow a fine tuning of the coupling integral J. The degree of interaction between the starting and the final situation will, of course, depend upon the spin density at the bridgehead position because these positions are closest in space. This may also be expressed by the distances between the average centre of spin density of the single electrophore. The lowest unoccupied molecular orbital of anthracene (see Fig. lo), i.e. the orbital that actually accepts the excess electron, has a high AO-coefficient at C-9 and a relatively small AO-coefficient at C-2 (Heilbronner and Bock, 1978). What is found experimentally is that rapid hopping is detectable in all those cases in which the linking is at C-9 or at C-1, i.e. at centres with a large or moderate AO-coefficient. This may be expressed in terms of through-space and through-bond mechanisms, which are both favoured in the case above, while a through-bond mechanism becomes much less probable as soon as the spin density at the bridgehead position is small as for [9] and [13]. Even though [9] is much more flexible than [13], which has two bridges, the situation encountered is comparable. It seems that a second bridge at a position of low spin density does not improve the through-bond exchange and thereby diminish the activation barrier. Thus it appears that
Fig. 10 Atomic orbital coefficients for the LUMO of anthracene.
38
M. BAUMGARTEN ET AL.
even with the same electrophore and with the same linking group very subtle structural changes, i.e. the position of attachment of the spacer to the electrophore, can influence the degree of interaction and the rate of electron hopping. Biaryl compounds, although formally possessing direct n-conjugation between the aryl moieties, can give rise to electronically independent subunits as outlined in Section 3. From the viewpoint of redox chemistry, there are two basic criteria by which to classify this situation: for "decoupled" electrophores (i) injection of one electron will give rise to spin localization and (ii) injection of a second electron may produce a triplet dianion. Clearly such a situation does not prevail in biphenyl and its analogue the 1,l'-binaphthyl derivative [ 161. In the radical anion of the latter, one detects a set of coupling constants [ a H= 0.39 mT ( n = 2), 0.225 mT ( n = 2), etc.], which indicates a simultaneous distribution of the spin density over both entities. From the asymmetry of spin density at positions 4 and 5, a twisting angle of 50" has been determined (Koch, 1991; Baumgarten et al., 1992b). Another extreme is 9,9'-bianthryl [ 181; as a result of the near orthogonality of the anthryl rings, the dianion exists as a triplet, and, in agreement with this finding, the esr spectrum of the biradical dianion shows a large zero-field splitting D = 15.5 mT and a half-field signal for the Ams = 2 transition (Baumgarten et al., 1992a). When considering the prevailing non-bonded interaction in the binaphthyl [ 161 and the corresponding biperylenyl [ 171,
MA h
T=240K
Fig. 11 Temperature-dependent esr spectra of the monoanion of biperylene [ 171 in MTHF.
ORGANIC REDOX SYSTEMS WITH MULTIPLE ELECTROPHORES
39
a similar inter-ring torsional angle would be expected. It is characteristic, however, that the esr spectrum of [ 171 reveals also the presence of localized forms for strong counterion conditions in solution, while lowering the temperature to the frozen state (ca. 160K) yields nearly exclusively the localized structure (Fig. 11). If the inter-ring torsional angle is comparable in both cases, the differences in the exchange rates may be traced back to the A 0 coefficients and spin densities at the bridgehead position ( p = 0.2 vs. 0.13) and the large differences in the centre-to-centre distance (0.49 vs. 0.87 nm).
6
Conclusion and outlook
The rate of degenerate intramolecular electron-transfer processes in biselectrophoric redox systems, and the observed spin-density distribution over one or two units depend upon the overall reorganization energy and thus upon
(i) the nature of the subunit; (ii) the spacer between the subunits; (iii) the ion pairing; and (iv) the way in which the subunits are linked. In essence, these empirical findings allow control of the rate of electrontransfer processes by creating the appropriate structural conditions. It is, of course, straightforward to extend such a correlation of structure and electron-transfer kinetics to higher homologues. The esr spectra of the radical anion obtained for the triply layered annulene system [lS] points to a situation with one electron being effectively delocalized over three layers (Alexander et al., 1989). The same holds true for the higher homologues. A closely related finding can be made for the anthrylene structure [lo], i.e. a redox system with three anthracene electrophores. It is obvious from the esr data for the radical anion that, depending on the ion pairing, the unpaired electron resides on the inner anthracene unit or is effectively delocalized over the whole chain (Fiedler et al., 1986). Accordingly, when one proceeds to the related oligomers and polymers, by a proper choice of the subunit, the bridging group and the ion pairing, one can control the energy profiles of intramolecular charge-transport processes in an analogous fashion. Systems such as [6], [lo], [I81 or [21] have also been the subject of photophysical studies (Rettig, 1988; Mataga et al., 1989; Yao et al., 1989)
40
M. BAUMGARTEN € T A L .
in which energy transfer between the separate anthracene chromophores is considered as a function of the molecular geometry. Although a direct comparison is not straightforward, for example, in view of the role of the ion pairing, it is a tempting approach to compare the processes of energy and charge transport (Heine et al., 1990). Another aspect is that intramolecular electron transfer is a fundamental process in intramolecular electronics in which a single molecule is used to process electrical signals (Joachim et al., 1990; Joachim and Launay, 1990). In this context, the electron transfer through a spacer group has been related to its “conductance” if placed between two conducting wires. Thus, accepting the definition of conduction of a single molecule or spacer group, the control of an electron transfer between redox centres closely corresponds to the control of the current passing through an electrical circuit. Upon electrochemical oxidation at a platinum electrode, many polycyclic compounds such as naphthalene, fluoranthene and pyrene form deeply coloured, crystalline radical cation salts (Maresch et al., 1989; Enkelmaan et al., 1985; Endres et al., 1985; Krohnke et al., 1980). According to crystal structure analysis, these salts adopt a stack-type structure with a face-to-face arrangement of the n-layers and an alternating array of neutral and monocationic units. The complexes have a high electrical conductivity along the stacking axis, and one way of explaining this conductivity is based on the assumption of a charge-hopping process between the n-layers. Such a charge-transport mechanism is thus closely related to the electron transfer in multi-layered systems such as [lo], [l5] and [21].
References Alexander, J., Ehrenfreund, M., Fiedler, J., Huber, W., Rader, H.-J. and Miillen, K. (1989). Angew. Chem. 101, 1530; Int. Ed. Engl. 28, 1531 Anet, A. L., Bourn, A. J. R. and Lin, Y. S. (1964). J . Am. Chem. SOC. 86, 3576 Anton, U., Bohnen, A., Koch, K.-H., Naarmann, H., Rader, H.-J. and Miillen, K. (1992). Adu. Mat. 4,91-93 Atkins, P. W. ( 1984).Molecular Quantum Mechanics. Oxford University Press, Oxford Auchter-Krummel, P. and Miillen, K. (1991). Angew. Chem. 103, 996; Znt. Ed. Engl. 30, 1003 Baughman, R. H., Bredas, J. L., Chance, R. R., Elsenbaumer, R. L. and Shacklette, L. W. (1982). Chem. Rev. 82, 209 Baumgarten, M., Miiller, U., Bohnen, A. and Miillen, K. (1992a). Angew. Chem. 104, 482-485 Baumgarten, M., Koch, K.-H. and Miillen, K. (1992b). Accepted for publication Becker, B., Bohnen, A., Ehrenfreund, M., Wohlfarth, W., Sakata, Y., Huber, W. and Miillen, K. (1991). J. Am. Chem. SOC. 113, 1121 Bender, D. and Miillen, K. (1988). Chem. Ber. 121, 1187
ORGANIC REDOX SYSTEMS WITH MULTIPLE ELECTROPHORES
41
Bender, D., Herbst, H., Schade, P. and Miillen, K. (1988). Chem. Ber. 121, 1177 Bender, D., Przybylski, M. and Miillen, K. (1989). Makromol. Chem. 190, 2071 Bitthin, R., Ely, G., Wolffler, F., Munstedt, H., Naarmann, H. and Naegele, D. (1987). Makromol. Chem. Macromol. Symp., 8, 51 Bock, H., Ruppert, K. and FenskelD: (1989). Angew. Chem. 101, 1717; Int. Ed. Engl. 28. 1685 Bohnen, A., Koch, K.-H., Liittke, W. and Miillen, K. (1990). Angew. Chem. 102, 548; Int. Ed. Engl. 29, 525 Bohnen, A., Heitz, W., Miillen, K., Rader, H.-J. and Schenk, R. (1991). Makromol. Chem. 192, 1679 Bohnen, A., Rader, H.-J. and Miillen, K. (1992) Synth. Met., 47, 37-63. Cannon, R. D. ( 1980). Electron-Transfer Reactions. Butterworth, London Closs, G. L. and Miller, J. R. (1988). Science 240, 440 Closs, G. L., Calcaterra, L. T., Green, N. J., Penfield, K. W. and Miller, J. R. (1986). J . Phys. Chem. 90, 3673 Closs, G. L., Johnson, M. D., Miller, J. R. and Piotrowiak, P. (1989). J . Am. Chem. SOC. 111, 3751 Dale, J. (1974). Tetrahedron 30,1683 Davies, E. R. (1974). Phys. Lett. 47A, 1 Eliasson, B. and Staley, S. W. (1985). Prepr. Am. Chem. SOC.Diu. Pet. Chem. 30, 620; Chem. Abstr. 104, 50494a Eliasson, B., Edlund, U. and Miillen, K. (1986). J . Chem. SOC.Perkin Trans. 11, 937 Eliasson, B., Johnels, D., Sethson, I., Edlund, U. and Miillen, K. (1990). J . Chem. SOC. Perkin Trans. 11, 897 Endres, H., Keller, H. J., Miiller, B. and Schweitzer, D. (1985).Acta Cryst. C41,607 Enkelmann, V., Gockelmann, K., Wieners, G. and Monkenbusch, M. (1985). Mol. Cryst. Liq. Cryst. 120, 195 Eyring, H. (1935a). J . Chem. Phys. 3, 107 Eyring, H. (1935b). Chem. Rev. 17, 65 Fahnenstich, U., Koch, K.-H. and Miillen, K. (1989). Makromol. Chem., Rapid Commun. 10, 563 Fiedler, J., Huber, W. and Miillen, K. (1986). Angew. Chem. 98, 444; Int. Ed. Engl. 25,443 Flanagan, J. B., Margel, S., Bard, A. J. and Anson, F. C. ( 1978). J . Phys. Chem. 82,1101 Fox, M. A. and Chanon, M. (1988). Photoinduced Electron-Transfer. Elsevier, Amsterdam Freed, J. H. and Fraenkel, G. K. (1964). J . Phys. Chem. 41, 699 Fry, A. J., Powers, T. A., Miillen, K. and Irmen, W. ( 1985). Tetrahedron Lett. 26,4879 Fukuzumi, S., Wong, C. L. and Kochi, J. K. (1980). J . Am. Chem. SOC. 102,4790 Gerson, F. ( 1967). HochauJlosende ESR-Spektroskopie. Verlag-Chemie, Weinheim; ( 1970). High Resolution ESR Spectroscopy. Verlag-Chemie, Weinheim Gerson, F. and Martin, W. A. Jr (1969). J . Am. Chem. SOC. 91, 1883 Gerson, F., Gleiter, R., Moshuk, G. and Dreiding, A. S. (1972). J . Am. Chem. SOC. 94, 2919 Gerson, F., Kowert, B. and Peake, P. M. (1974). J . Am. Chem. SOC. 96, 118 Gerson, F., Martin, W. B. Jr and Wydler, C. (1976). J . Am. Chem. SOC. 98, 1318 Gerson, F., Huber, W., Martin, W. B. Jr, Caluwe, P., Pepper, T. and Szwarc, M. (1984). Helu. Chim. Acta 67, 416 Gerson, F., Wellauer, T., Oliver, A. M. and Paddon-Row, M. N. (1990). Helu. Chim. Acta. 73, 1586
42
M. BAUMGARTEN ET AL.
Grampp, G. and Jaenicke, W. (1984a). Ber. Bunsenges. Phys. Chem. 88, 325 Grampp, G. and Jaenicke, W. (1984b). Ber. Bunsenges. Phys. Chem. 88, 335 Grampp, G., Sohoji, M. C. B. L. and Herold, B. J. (1989). Ber. Bunsenges. Phys. Chem. 93, 580 Grampp, G., Harrer, W. and Hetz, G. (1990a).Ber. Bunsenges. Phys. Chem. 94,1343 Grampp, G., Sohoji, M. C. B. L., Herold, B. J. and Steenken, S. (1990b).Ber. Bunsenges. Phys. Chem. 94, 1507 Gray, H. B. and Malmstrom, B. G. (1989). Biochemistry 28, 7449 Grupp, A. and Mehring, M. (1990). In Modern Pulsed and Continuous Wave Electron Spin Resonance, p. 195. Wiley, New York Gust, D., Moore, T. A,, Moore, A. L., Barrett, D. and Harding, L. 0. (1986). J . Am. Chem. SOC.108, 8028 Gust, D., Moore, T. A., Moore, A. L., Barrett, D., Harding, L. O., Makings, L. R., Liddell, P. A., De Schryver, F. C., Van der Auweraer, M., Bensasson, R. V. and Rougee, M. (1988). J . Am. Chem. SOC.110, 321 Gutowsky, H. S. and Holm, C. H. (1956). J . Chem. Phys. 25, 1228 Hamacher, V., Plato, M. and Mobius, K. (1986). Chem. Phys. Lett. 125, 69 Hammerich, 0. and Saveant, J.-H. (1979). J . Chem. SOC. Chem. Commun., 938 Harriman, J. E. and Maki, A. W. (1963). J . Chem. Phys. 39, 778 Hay, P. F., Thibeault, J. C. and Hoffmann, R. (1975). J . Am. Chem. SOC.97, 4884 Heilbronner, E. and Bock, H. (1978). Das HMO Model1 und seine Andwendungen. Verlag-Chemie, Weinheim/New York Heine, B., Sigmund, E., Maier, S., Port, H., Wolf, H. C., Effenberger, F. and Schlosser, H. (1990). J . Mol. Electron. 6, 51 Heinze, J. (1984). Angew. Chem. 96, 823; Int. Ed. Eng. 23, 831 Heinze, J. (1990). Top. Curr. Chem. 152, 1 Heinze, J. and Meerholz, K. (1990). Angew. Chem. 102, 695; Int. Ed. Engl. 29, 692 Heinze, J., Serafimov, 0.and Zimmermann, H. E. (1974). Ber. Bunsenges. Phys. Chem. 78, 652 Hoffmann, R. (1971). Acc. Chem. Res. 4, 1 Hogen-Esch, T. E. (1977). Adu. Phys. Prog. Chem. 15, 153 Huber, M., Kurreck, H., Maltzan, B. von, Plato, M. and Mobius, K. (1990). J . Chem. SOC.Faraday Trans. 86, 1087 Huber, W. and Miillen, K. (1980). J . Chem. SOC. Chem. Commun., 698 Huber, W. and Miillen, K. (1986). Acc. Chem. Res. 19, 300 Huber, W., Unterberg, H. and Miillen, K. (1983). Angew. Chem. 95, 239; Int. Ed. Engl. 22, 242 Hush, N. S. (1961). Trans. Faraday SOC.,57, 557 Hush, N. S. (1975). Chem. Phys. 10, 361 Irmen, W., Huber, W., Lex, J. and Miillen, K. (1984). Angew. Chem. 96, 800; Int. Ed. Engl. 23, 818 Isied, S. S., Vassilian, A., Wishart, J. F., Creutz, C., Schwarz, H. A. and Sutin, N. (1988). J . Am. Chem. SOC. 110, 635 Joachim, C. and Launay, J. P. (1990). J . Mol. Electron. 6, 37 Joachim, C., Launay, J. P. and Woitellier, S. (1990). Chem. Phys. 147, 131 Katz, T. J. (1960). J . Am. Chem. SOC.82, 3784 Klabunde, K.-U., Huber, W., Lex, J. and Miillen, K. (1987). Chem. Ber. 120, 1491 Koch, K.-H. (1991). Dissertation, Mainz Koch, K.-H. and Miillen, K. (1991). Chem. Ber. 124, 2091. Kochi, J. K. (1988). Angew. Chem. 100, 1331; Int. Ed. Engl. 27, 1227
ORGANIC REDOX SYSTEMS WITH MULTIPLE ELECTROPHORES
43
Konishi, S. and Reddoch, A. H. (1977). J . Magn. Res. 28, 41 Krohnke, C., Enkelmann, V. and Wegner, G. (1980). Angew. Chem. 92,941; Int. Ed. Engl. 19, 912 Krummel, G., Huber, W. and Miillen, K. (1987). Angew. Chem. 99, 1305; Int. Ed. Engl. 26, 1290 Krummel, G. (1988). Ph.D. dissertation, Mainz Krummel, G. and Miillen, K. (1988). Tetrahedron Lett. 29, 2809 Kurreck, H., Kirste, B. and Lubitz, W. (1988). Electron nuclear double resonance spectroscopy of radicals in solution. In Methods in Stereochemical Analysis (ed. A. P. Marchand). VCH Publishers, Weinheim/New York Kuznetsov, A. M. and Ulstrup, J. (1981). J . Chem. Phys. 75, 2047 Lewis, I. C. and Singer, L. S. (1965). J . Chem. Phys. 43, 2712 Liang, N., Miller, J. R. and Closs, G. L. (1990). J . Am. Chem. SOC. 112, 5353 Marcus, R. A. (1956). J . Chem. Phys. 24, 979 Marcus, R. A. (1963). J . Phys. Chem. 67, 853, 2889 Marcus, R. A. (1965). J . Chem. Phys. 43, 679 Marcus, R. A. and Sutin, N. (1985). Biochim. Biophys. Acta 811, 265 Maresch, G. G., Mehring, M., Schiitz, J. U. von, Werner, H.-P., Gokelmann, K., Enkelmann, V., Miillen, K. and Klabunde, K.-U. ( 1989).J . Chem. Phys. 91,4543 Mataga, N., Yao, H., Okada, T. and Rettig, W. (1989). J . Phys. Chem. 93, 3383 Mazur, S., Dixit, V. M. and Gerson, F. (1980). J . Am. Chem. SOC. 102, 5343 McConnell, H. M. (1961). J . Chem. Phys. 35, 508 McDiarmid, A. D. (1979). J . Chem. SOC.Chem. Commun., 594 Meerholz, K. and Heinze, J. (1989). J . Am. Chem. SOC. 111, 2325 Meerholz, K. and Heinze, J. (1990). J . Am. Chem. SOC. 112, 5142 Meyer, T. J. (1978). Acc. Chem. Res. 11, 94 Miller, J. R., Calcaterra, L. T. and Closs, G. L. (1984). J . Am. Chem. SOC. 106, 3047 Mortensen, J., Heinze, J., Herbst, H. and Miillen, K. (1992). J . Electround. Chem., accepted for publication Miillen, K. (1978). Helu. Chim. Acta 61, 2307 Miillen, K. (1984). Chem. Rev. 84, 603 Miillen, K. (1986). Pure Appl. Chem. 58, 177 Miillen, K. (1987). Angew. Chem. 99, 192; Int. Ed. Engl. 26, 204 Miillen, K., Heinz, W., Klarner, F.-G., Roth, W. R., Kindermann, I., Adamczak, O., Wette, M. and Lex, J. (1990). Chem. Ber. 123, 2349 Murray, R. W. (1984).In Electroanalytical Chemistry, Vol. 13 (ed. A. J. Bard), p. 191. Dekker, New York Nemoto, F., Ishizu, K., Toyoda, T., Sakata, Y. and Misumi, S. (1980).J . Am. Chem. SOC. 102, 654 Nowak, R. J., Schultz, F. A,, Umana, M., Lam, R. and Murray, R. W. (1980). Anal. Chem. 52, 315 Onuchic, J. N., Beratan, D. A. and Hopfield, J. J. (1986).J . Phys. Chem. 90, 3707 Paddon Row, M. N. and Jordan, K. D. (1988). In Modern Models of Bonding and Delocalization (ed. J. F. Liebman and A. Greenberg), Chap. 3. VCH Publishers, New York Pollmann, M., Wohlfarth, W., Lex, J. and Miillen, K. ( 1990).Tetrahedron Lett. 31,2701 Rabinovitz, M. (1988). Top. Curr. Chem. 146, 99 Rautter, J. (1989). Diploma thesis, Stuttgart Rautter, J., Grupp, A., Mehring, M., Alexander, J., Miillen, K. and Huber, W. (1992). Mol. Phys. accepted for publication
44
M. BAUMGARTEN ET AL.
Reimers, J. R. and Hush, N. S. (1990). Inorg. Chem. 29, 3886 Rettig, W. (1988). Mol. Struct. Energetics 6, 229 Salem, L. (1966). The Molecular Orbital Theory of Conjugated Systems. Benjamin, New York Schenk, R. (1989). Ph.D. thesis, University of Mainz Shacklette, L. W., Maxfield, M., Gould, S., Wolf, J. F., Jow, T. R. and Baughman, R. H. (1987). Synth. Met. 18, 611 Shimada, K., Moshuk, G., Connor, H. D., Caluwe, P. and Szwarc, M. (1972). Chem. Phys. Lett. 14, 396 Shimada, K. and Szwarc, M. (1974). Chem. Phys. Lett. 28, 540 Shohoji, M. C. B. L., Herold, B. J. and Novais, H. M. (1987). J . Chem. SOC. Perkin Trans. 11, 1465 Siders, P. and Marcus, R. A. (1981). J . Am. Chem. SOC.103, 748 Smith, T. W., Kuder, J. E. and Wychick, D. (1976). J. Polym. Sci. 14, 243 Staley, S. W., Dustman, C. K., Facchine, K. L. and Linkowsky, G. E. (1985). J . Am. Chem. SOC. 107,4003 Sullivan, P. D. and Bolton, J. R. (1970). Adu. Magn. Reson. 4, 39 Szwarc, M. ( 1968). Carbanions, Living Polymers and Electron-Transfer Processes. Wiley, New York Szwarc, M. ( 1974) Ions and Ion-Pairs in Organic Reactions. Wiley-Interscience, New York Ulstrup, J. ( 1979). Charge- Transfer Processes in Condensed Media. Springer-Verlag, Berlin Wagner, M., Wohlfarth, W. and Miillen, K. (1988). Chimia 42, 377 Ward, R. L. and Weissman, S. I. (1957). J . Am. Chem. SOC.79, 2086 Wasielewski, M. R., Niemczyk, M. P., Svec, W. A. and Pewitt, E. B. (1985). J. Am. Chem. SOC. 107, 5562 Wasielewski, M. R. (1989). In Photoinduced Electron-Transfer (ed. M. A. Fox and M. Chanon), Chap. 1.4. Elsevier, Amsterdam Wegner, G. (1981). Angew. Chem. 93, 352; Int. Ed. Engl. 20, 361 Wegener, S. and Mullen, K. (1991). Chem. Ber. 124, 2101 Weitzel, H.-P. and Miillen, K. (1990). Makromol. Chem. 191, 2837 Weitzel, H.-P., Bohnen, A. and Miillen, K. (1990). Makromol. Chem. 191, 2837 Wertz, J. E. and Bolton, J. R. (1972) Electron Spin Resonance. McGraw-Hill, New York; reprinted by Chapman and Hall, London, 1986 Yao, H., Okada, T. and Mataga, N. (1989). J. Phys. Chem. 93, 7377 Ziilicke, L. (1985). Quantenchemie, Bd.2 p 49ff. VEB Deutscher Verlag der Wissenschaften, Berlin
Chirality and Molecular Recognition in Monolayers a t the Air-Water Interface PHILIP L. ROSE; NOELG. H A R V Eand Y ~ EDWARD M. ARNETT' Exploratory Chemicals Research, Rohm and Haas Company, 727 Norristown Road, Spring House, Pennsylvania 19477, U S A bExploratory Plastics Research, Rohm and Haas Company, PO Box 219, Bristol, Pennsylvania 19007, U S A Department of Chemistry, Duke University, Durham, North Carolina 27706, U S A a
1 Introduction 45 2 Monolayer methods 49 Film balance techniques 49 Equilibrium thermodynamic properties 51 n / A curves and phase transitions 54 Dynamic methods 57 Mixing criteria as applied to the elucidation of intermolecular interactions at surfaces 63 Techniques for visualizing films and aggregates 68 3 Chiral monolayers 71 Enantiomeric systems 71 Diastereomeric systems 102 4 Conclusions 133 Symbols 134 References 135
1
Introduction
The purpose of this chapter is to provide a review of research conducted in the senior author's laboratory over the past 15 years on the stereochemistry of intra- and inter-molecular interactions in a special kind of highly oriented system-monolayers. On two previous occasions we have reviewed the behavior of chiral surfactants at the air-water interface; first as an introduction to the 45 ADVANCES IN PHYSICAL ORGANIC CHEMISTRY VOLUME 28 ISBN 0-12-033528-X
Copyright 0 1993 Academlc Press Limited All rights of reproduction in any form reserved
46
P. L. ROSE ET AL.
opportunities for research in the field (Stewart and Arnett, 1982) and, more recently, as a brief outline, by the present authors, of work accomplished during the first decade (Arnett et aZ., 1989). In contrast, the present report presents an extensive summary of what has been done, and what was learned, from the perspective of a decade and a half. Since the majority of the research on chiral monolayers has been done in our laboratories, this chapter can be regarded as a nearly complete review of research accomplished in the field. From the perspective of physical organic chemistry, the study of chiral monolayers is a classic example of how the purposeful interaction of two fields that were separated by their traditional identifications with organic and physical chemistry can help to illuminate both areas. Stereochemistry is one of the most powerful tools of organic chemistry for demonstrating, and exploiting, the influences of molecular shape and symmetry on reactivity. The extensive role of chirality for providing selectivity in biochemical processes has stimulated enormous activity by organic chemists towards achieving asymmetric syntheses of ever greater stereochemical control and breadth of scope. During the 15 years of this project, organic chemists have also become increasingly aware of the importance of intermolecular attractive forces for the development of the detailed molecular architecture of complexes, intermediates and transition states. This awareness has been manifested by the introduction of such terms as molecular recognition, enzyme mimicry, and host-guest chemistry. Although organic chemists have always been sensitive to the specific effects of repulsive interactions through the popular term “steric hindrance”, the skillful manipulation of such attractive forces as London-van der Waals, dipole-dipole, n-n stacking, and especially hydrogen bonding, for the generation of multimolecular aggregated systems of closely specified geometry has now engaged some of the best minds in organic chemistry. Parallel developments in the physical chemistry of surfaces have also proceeded rapidly during the same period. An extensive battery of new spectroscopic and microscopic techniques have brought analysis and even observation down to the molecular and atomic ideal of “seeing” and manipulating these ultimate units of chemistry. Much of the driving force for these advances has come from the microelectronics industry, where the ability towards mass production of microstructures approaching nanometer dimensions is proceeding with remarkable speed and success. Again, we are reminded that Nature provides the ultimate model for emulation in the use of cooperative interactions of an enormous number of small structural components through many weak, reversible attractions and repulsions to produce such complex microstructures as proteins, enzymes, viruses, and cells with virtually perfect fidelity (Whitesides, 1991). One important strategy for producing ultra-thin films of promise for microelectronics
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
47
employs the well-established Langmuir-Blodgett technology for handling monolayers of surfactants at the air-water surface and is related directly to the subject of this review. Although the notion of monomolecular surface layers is of fundamental importance to all phases of surface science, surfactant monolayers at the aqueous surface are so unique as virtually to constitute a special state of matter. For the many types of amphipathic molecules that meet the simple requirements for monolayer formation it is possible, using quite simple but elegant techniques over a century old, to obtain quantitative information on intermolecular forces and, furthermore, to manipulate them at will. The special driving force for self-assembly of surfactant molecules as monolayers, micelles, vesicles, or cell membranes (Fendler, 1982) when brought into contact with water is the hydrophobic eflect. The immiscibility of oil and water has been noted since antiquity and been put to use for calming troubled seas. Benjamin Franklin, benefitting from the rapidly developing atomic-molecular theory of discontinuous matter, noted that a teaspoon of oil spread over the half acre of Clapham pond not only stilled all surface agitation but produced a film so thin as to give “prismatic colors”.’ Self-organization at interfaces with water can be achieved by compounds whose molecules combine an appropriate polar functionality (e.g., carboxylate, hydroxyl, or alkylammonium) that is strongly attracted to water, and an extensive hydrocarbon framework or chain that is rejected by it. If molecules of such amphipathic compounds (i.e., soaps, surfactants, and surface-active agents) are introduced to a water surface, the polar headgroup is attracted to the subphase and the fatty tail “floats” on the surface. The actual orientation of the surfactant molecules is determined by their surface concentration in terms of area per molecule and the attractive-repulsive interactions between nonpolar portions of adjacent molecules. Thus, the molecules are preorganized at the surface through the balance of hydrophilic attraction to the headgroup and hydrophobic repulsion of the fatty portion. However, most importantly, the rest of the organization process can be varied at will by changing the surface area and measuring the balance of repulsive and attractive forces that resist compression of the monolayer in a direction parallel to the surface. This point will be re-emphasized below. The beautifully simple and elegant tool for studying the response of monolayers on a water surface to compression was invented in 1882 by Fraulein Agnes Pockels when she was 20 years old from observations made at her kitchen sink. As physical chemistry developed, an appreciation for the
’
For extensive and authoritative monographs on the nature of the hydrophobic effect and the history of its use, see Tanford, 1973, 1989.
48
P. L. ROSE ET AL.
significance of the monolayer state as a means for studying intermolecular forces grew with it. In the hands of Harkins at the University of Chicago, McBain, N. K. Adam, and, most notably, Irving Langmuir and his colleague Kathleen Blodgett at General Electric Co., the basic techniques for handling monolayer films and the correct physico-chemical interpretations of their behavior were developed. Langmuir’s development of Fraulein Pockel’s trough for handling monolayers bears his name and is described in detail below. In 1932 Langmuir received the Nobel Prize for this research. Since its first important flowering in the hands of purely physical chemists, interest in monolayers at the air-water interface has waxed and waned with a frequency of roughly 25 years. The first resurrection of interest came from biochemistry, primarily during the 1955-65 decade as phospholipid monolayers were studied as models for the cell membrane (see, for example, Chapman, 1968).This is still a very productive field of biophysical research. The second recrudescence has been driven by thin film physics and technology as noted above. During their work at General Electric, Langmuir and Blodgett learned how to transfer monolayers from the surface of water to various solid surfaces such as glass. A variety of clever routines were developed for building up multilayers containing up to 200-300 layers, most commonly of alkaline earth stearates (Gaines, 1966). A commercial step-gauge of exact thickness based on the known thickness of stearate monolayers was actually marketed by General Electric. Polymerizable functionalities, such as acetylene linkages, may be used to bind the chains of surfactant molecules, properly oriented at the surface, to each other and thus manufacture polymeric microfilms of known thickness as an ultimate step towards etch-resistant films. An important recent development is the self-organization of long chain thiols on gold surfaces (for a brief review, see Bain and Whitesides, 1988). Against this background, the opportunity of using the techniques of monolayer chemistry to manipulate the approach of preoriented chiral molecules to each other at an aqueous surface in attractive. To the organic chemist, it provides a means for determining how the interplay of molecular structure, conformation and proximity of packing can affect the way chiral molecules “read” each other’s shapes and finally pack in the lowest energy state of surface aggregation. To the physical chemist, the introduction of stereochemistry provides greater subtlety in considering intermolecular interactions in condensed matter. For our part, the study of chiral molecules has provided an enjoyable and often surprising excursion into truly interdisciplinary physical organic chemistry.
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
2
49
Monolayer methods
FILM BALANCE TECHNIQUES
The elegant tool by which monolayers may be studied and also manipulated at the air-water interface was developed by Langmuir and Blodgett during the 1920s and 1930s. The film balance described here was developed from that designed by Langmuir (Langmuir and Schaefer, 1937);a picture is presented in Fig. 1. For the purposes of detecting stereochemical effects, a much more sensitive trough is necessary; a description of the apparatus used in the authors' laboratory follows. The trough was milled from solid Teflon (80 cm x 14 cm x 0.3 cm) and mounted on a magnesium base, which rests on four leveling screw legs. A serpentine glass coil connected to a constant-temperature circulating bath may be placed in the trough base in order to hold the subphase temperature in the desired range. In addition to the water circulation coil, the surface temperature is controlled further by placing the entire apparatus in a Puffer-Hubbard Unitherm temperature control cabinet. In the 15-40°C temperature range, these controls are capable of regulating surface temperatures to k0.5"C. After being filled with subphase water, a floating hydrophobic Teflon barrier (12cm x 1 cm x 1 mm) is connected to both sides of the trough by means of two flexible Teflon Mylar ribbons so as to divide the surface of the trough into two sections. The floating barrier is arranged so that it floats freely but remains in contact with the torsion arm lever of the torsion strip spring system. The torsion strip is connected to a transducer coil, which in turn is connected to a strip-chart recorder and an torsion strip + & , hanging weight + holder
ever arm transducer
barrier
Fig. 1 Schematic representation of the Langmuir film balance used for the measurement of pressure-area monolayer film properties. Reprinted with permission from Arnett et al., 1989. Copyright 1989 American Chemical Society.
50
P. L. ROSE €T AL.
analog-to-digital converter system (Johnson, 1985). The film balance is therefore divided into two compartments, with the monolayer film being spread on the side with the greater surface. The area of the compartment containing the monolayer may be varied by means of a motor-driven Teflon barrier. As the area per molecule of the film is reduced, the surface tension of the film-covered side of the trough is lowered with respect to the other side, and a surface pressure is registered against the floating barrier. This surface pressure is related to surface tension at any given film area by expression ( l ) , where ll is the surface pressure, y o is the surface tension of
the film-free surface, and y is the surface tension of the film-covered surface. The result is a continuous surface pressure versus area ( I I I A ) isotherm. Because of the extreme sensitivity of monolayers to contamination and the resulting likelihood of erroneous results, every precaution must be taken to ensure that all materials and instruments are clean. A great bonus for the stereochemical studies reported here is that comparison of the properties of enantiomers provides a rigorous check for internal consistency and purity that is not available to studies of achiral systems. Details have been given elsewhere and will not be included here (Thompson, 1981). Appropriate molecules for study as monolayers are natural or synthetic surfactants. The surfactants have divergent functional groups that give rise to their amphiphilic nature: a highly polar functionality (carboxylate, amino, or hydroxyl) as a head group and a fatty chain of 10 carbons or more as a tail group. If a very dilute solution of surfactant molecules, in a suitable spreading solvent, is deposited on the surface of pure water, and the solvent evaporates or dissolves, the surface-active molecules are left at the interface with their polar head groups bound to the aqueous subphase and their fatty tails assuming various orientations relative to the surface plane. The orientation of the hydrocarbon tail will be dependent upon the available surface area per molecule. Because surfactant molecules have hydrocarbon chains that are insoluble in the aqueous subphase, they are constrained to stay at the interface, or aggregate to form microcrystals. If the area per molecule is large (over 1000 A2/molecule), a “gaseous” monolayer is usually formed in which the molecules float freely and independently on the surface. The Langmuir film balance allows for the manipulation of surfactant molecules from molecules floating freely with little or no interaction to highly condensed phases where the hydrocarbon chains are interacting significantly. The manipulation of the available area per molecule is all that is needed to effect such a phase transition.
-
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
51
The significance of the above discussion is to point out that the orientation of the hydrocarbon chains with respect to the surface and to each other can be monitored, and controlled, as a function of the surface pressure (which in turn is directly proportional to the surface tension if the monolayer is insoluble in the subphase). Another means of measuring the properties of insoluble films at the air-water interface is through the use of surface potentials. Surface potential (A V) measures the charge separation created by the vector component of the surfactant’s molecular dipole that is perpendicular to the air-water interface. Thus, the surface potential yields information about the orientation of the surfactant molecules. Surface potential values are often expressed alternatively as surface dipole moments p L I according to (2), where n is the 1 AV pcLI= --
4x n number of molecules per cm2 in the monolayer. If the area A is expressed in A2/molecule and A V in millivolts then (2) reduces to ( 3 ) where p l is A AV PLI =-
12x
(3)
obtained in millidebye units (mD). A common method for measuring the surface potential of a monolayer film uses an ionizing electrode. The ionizing electrode utilizes a radioactive source (e.g. lOmCi, 224Cm)to ionize the air gap above the film so that it becomes conducting. The potential difference between the electrode above the film and the one in the aqueous subphase can then be measured directly. A typical experimental set-up is shown in Fig. 2. Surface potentials are measured either with the monolayer film at a constant area per molecule or while the film is undergoing compression. Static measurements are performed by delivering a known amount of surfactant in a suitable spreading solvent to the subphase surface in a container of known dimensions. Dynamic surface potential measurements are made concurrently with compression and expansion cycles on the Langmuir trough.
EQUILIBRIUM THERMODYNAMIC PROPERTIES
The Langmuir film balance experiment as described above is generally considered to be thermodynamically determined by the relation between the independent variables temperature, surface pressure, and molecular area.
P. L. ROSE E T A L .
52
glass electrode reference electrode
ionizing reference electrode
glass electrode
subphase
I
Fig. 2 Monolayer surface potential measurement apparatus.
However, the spreading of a surfactant monolayer from a volatile solvent leaves behind a film that may not be in thermodynamic equilibrium with its bulk crystalline form or the aqueous subphase. It has been proposed that this is a result of the relatively high energy barriers to film collapse or dissolution into the subphase as compared with lowered interfacial free energy when a stable, insoluble surfactant monolayer is formed (Gershfeld, 1976). The rate at which a whole system approaches true equilibrium in such a system is often so slow that the monolayer film can be treated for most purposes as though it were at equilibrium with the subphase. The question may then be raised as to whether insoluble monolayers may really be treated in terms of equilibrium thermodynamics. In general, this problem has been approached by considering: (i) the equilibrium spreading pressure of the monolayer in the presence of the bulk crystalline surfactant, and (ii) the stability of the monolayer film as spread from solution. These quantities are obtained experimentally and are necessary in any consideration of film thermodynamic properties. In both cases, time is clearly a practical variable.
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
53
7he equilibrium spreading pressure ( E S P ) The equilibrium spreading pressure (ESP) is defined as the surface pressure of the monolayer when it is in equilibrium with the stable crystalline phase (Fig. 3) (Gaines, 1966). This surface pressure is determined experimentally by depositing surfactant crystals on the water surface and allowing the development of a constant surface pressure at constant temperature over the course of several hours. This operation may be performed on a Langmuir film balance of the type shown in Fig. 1. This approach allows the experimentalist to observe the evolution of surface pressure with time. Alternatively, the ESP may be determined by surface tensiometry (duNuoy, 1929). Spreading will occur from the crystal under these conditions only if a reduction in the free energy of the interfacial system results. In principle, three-way equilibrium is set up between the crystal, the monolayer, and the surfactant monomer that has dissolved in the subphase (Gershfeld, 1982). It is generally assumed that the amount of dissolved surfactant is negligible, and that the monolayer-forming material is nonvolatile. These assumptions allow the monolayer-crystal equilibrium to be treated thermodynamically as a two-phase equilibrium analogous to the sublimation of a solid, and allows the calculation of surface excess free energy of spreading, AGs, by (4)
AG, = -IIeAe
(4)
Air Phase
Water Phase
Fig. 3 The model of equilibrium spreading from a surfactant crystal at the air/water interface. The ESP is attained when crystal, monolayer, and subphase solution are at equilibrium.
P. L. ROSE ET AL.
54
(Harkins et al., 1940), where II" is the ESP, and A" is the average area per molecule at the ESP as obtained from the I I / A isotherm of the spread film. The temperature dependence of the ESP may then be used to calculate the excess surface entropies from (5) and enthalpies of spreading from (6).
ASs = A
drI" " dT
AHs = AGs + T AS = TA'-
~
dll" - II'A" dT
(5)
(6)
Monolayer stability limits The monolayer stability limit is defined as the maximum pressure attainable in a film spread from solution before the monolayer collapses (Gaines, 1966). This limit may in some cases correspond directly to the ESP, suggesting that the mechanism of film collapse is a return to the bulk crystalline state, or may be at surface pressures higher than the ESP if the film is metastable with respect to the bulk phase. In either case, the monolayer stability limit must be known before such properties as work of compression, isothermal compressibility, or monolayer viscosity can be determined. During the film balance experiment, the monolayer stability limit is determined by compressing the spread film isothermally to a selected surface pressure, halting compression, and measuring the decay in pressure as a function of time. Two criteria for stability have been proposed: Cadenhead (1969) suggested that films decaying in surface pressure at a rate no more than 1.0 dyn cm-' min-' be considered stable, while Gershfeld (1982) has proposed a more stringent criterion of 0.1 dyncm-' min-'. It is important to note that, ultimately, all monolayers are probably metastable and that these criteria are simply useful rules of thumb for comparing relative stabilities, which must be time dependent.
n/A CURVES AND PHASE TRANSITIONS
The film balance may be regarded as a two-dimensional piston, and the most commonly studied property is the surface pressure (II) versus area ( A ) isotherm. The analogy to a PV isotherm is so appropriate that in the "gaseous monolayer regime" the two-dimensional analogue of the ideal gas law pertains: rIA = nRT. It is therefore reasonable to relate discontinuities in I I / A isotherms as the monolayer film is compressed in two dimensions to
55
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
Collapse to a rnuItiIayer
8
s,
30-
? t
“Solid”
20-
8
I ,
rn
“Gaseous”
0
10
20
30
40
Are&
50
60
70
80
90
100
/molecule)
Fig. 4 Idealized surface pressure ll versus area A isotherm detailing the inferred molecular orientation and aggregation states during a compression cycle. Reprinted with permission from Arnett et a[.,1989. Copyright 1989 American Chemical Society.
phase changes like those that take place in three-dimensional condensed matter. Figure 4 represents a typical surface pressure versus area isotherm, and the inferred orientation of molecules with respect to the surface as the monolayer is compressed from a gaseous to a solid-like state. Assuming that the polar head group is constrained to lie in the liquid surface throughout the compression cycle, what is the true nature of the changes in molecular orientation and packing as we pass from random arrangements in the gaseous state to the highly ordered “two-dimensional crystalline state”? The “two-dimensional” monolayer film may be taken through a variety of phase changes. At large areas per molecule, the film is presumed to be the two-dimensional analogue of a gas, with random interactions occurring between amphiphile molecules, and a high degree of hydrocarbon chain disorder. As the film is compressed, these chains interact in a manner analogous to those in a liquid hydrocarbon until the ‘‘lift-off’point is reached (defined as the point where a surface pressure greater than a few tenths of a dyn cm- is first registered). Further reduction in molecular area results in more highly ordered packing, with the polar headgroups interacting directly at the aqueous subphase surface and the tail sections neatly stacked above it. Over-compression past this point generally leads to a collapse of the monolayer to a multilayer or back to the crystalline state. The physical transformations are usually signalled by the presence of a
P. L. ROSE €T AL.
56
“plateau” (indicative of a first-order phase change characterized by a plateau region where the surface pressure is invariant to a change in the area per molecule), or a sudden discontinuity in the isotherm (indicative of a second-order phase change characterized by a discontinuity in the slope of the pressure/area curve). These phase changes, along with the finite thickness of the film, illustrate the true three-dimensional character of the monolayer by taking account of the layer of hydrocarbon chains immediately above the water surface. An interesting example of the manual manipulation of surfactant orientation on a water surface is shown by Fig. 5, which compares the isotherms for dipalmitoyl phosphatidylcholine with a similar compound bearing a hydroxyl group at the 12-position along the hydrocarbon chain. The enormous difference in area occupied by this molecule at low surface pressure is readily attributable to the fact that at large molecular areas this molecule has two polar groups interacting with the water surface, the usual choline system and the 12-hydroxyl group, which anchors part of the chain to the surface. Upon reduction in the available area per molecule (i.e., driving the piston in the above analogy), extra work must be invested to pull the hydroxyl group out of the surface to bring the chain to the standing position.
I
g
>. e
\
2
\
10-
,-
_ \ \ \
07
,
- - __ - _ _ A2hnolecule
Fig. 5 Surface pressure/area isotherm for the compression cycle of dipalmitoylphosphatidyl choline (dashed line) and 1-palmitoyl-2-(12-hydroxystearoyl)phosphatidyl choline (solid line) on a pure water subphase at 25°C. Reprinted with permission from Arnett et al., 1989. Copyright 1989 American Chemical Society.
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
57
Once the chains are out of the water surface, the cross-sectional areas of the molecules are defined by the choline head groups and have similar limiting molecular areas. The area enclosed between the two isotherms is a quantitative measure of the extra free energy required to pull the molecule from the inchworm arrangement with the hydroxyl group in the surface to the vertical arrangement with the hydroxyl group out of the water surface (L. C . Gold, unpublished; see also Tachibana and Hori, 1977).
DYNAMIC METHODS
The dynamic behavior of fluid interfaces is usually described in terms of surface rheology. Monolayer-covered interfaces may display dramatically different rheological behavior from that of the clean liquid interface. These time-dependent properties vary with the extent of intermolecular association within the monolayer at a given thermodynamic state, which in turn may be related directly to molecular size, shape, and charge (Manheimer and Schechter, 1970). Two of these time-dependent rheological properties are discussed here : surface shear viscosity and dynamic surface tension. Surface shear viscosity
Viscosity, defined as the resistance of a liquid to flow under an applied stress, is not only a property of bulk liquids but of interfacial systems as well. The viscosity of an insoluble monolayer in a fluid-like state may be measured quantitatively by the viscous traction method (Manheimer and Schechter, 1970), wave-damping (Langmuir and Schaefer, 1937), dynamic light scattering (Sauer et al., 1988) or surface canal viscometry (Harkins and Kirkwood, 1938; Washburn and Wakeham, 1938). Of these, the last is the most sensitive and experimentally feasible, and allows for the determination of Newtonian versus non-Newtonian shear flow. As originally designed by Harkins (Harkins and Kirkwood, 1938) and modified for continuous viscosity measurement (Fig. 6 ) , the surface canal viscometer is a “two-dimensional” analogue of the familiar Ostwald viscometer. A monolayer spread and compressed to a fixed surface pressure in one compartment of the trough is allowed to flow isobarically through a canal of known length and width to a clean water surface in a second trough compartment. According to the theory of monolayer flow as proposed by Moore and Eyring (1938), the flowing monolayer may be-modeled as a series of “rows” of molecules within the viscometer canal (Fig. 7). The monolayer responds to an applied surface pressure at one end of the canal by flowing toward the low-pressure end, resulting in a shear force (or drag) between
P. L. ROSE ET AL
58
Cahn Electrobalsnce
Surface Shear Viscomefer
Fig. 6 Detail of the Verger film balance modified for measurement of surface shear viscosity. Reprinted with permission from Harvey et al., 1988. Copyright 1988 American Chemical Society.
Direction of Pressure Gradient
-
Canal Wall
/A
Fig. 7 The Eyring model of Newtonian monolayer flow. The white circles represent “holes” vacated by flowing molecules.
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
59
each row of molecules and the canal wall. As the distance between a given row of molecules and the canal is increased, a laminar flow is induced in which those rows farthest from the canal wall experience the least drag and are the first to flow. In this manner, the rate of the monolayer flow is a direct function of the canal dimensions and may be used to calculate the monolayer’s shear viscosity using the Harkins-Kirkwood equation (7), where rs is the
monolayer viscosity coefficient, ylo is the viscosity of the pure water surface (usually taken as its bulk liquid viscosity), IT, - IT, is the surface pressure difference, Q is the film flow rate, L is the canal length, and Wis the canal width. The viscosity exhibited by a monolayer may be Newtonian, where the viscosity is independent of the rate of shear, or non-Newtonian, where viscosities vary with the rate of flow. Experimentally, this may be determined simply by varying the width of the canal and measuring the surface viscosity at different A l l (Jarvis, 1965). According to Eyring (Moore and Eyring, 1938) and Joly ( 1956), Newtonian flow in a monolayer is the result of a cohesive attraction between surfactant molecules. For every molecule that flows from higher to lower surface pressure in a motion parallel to the canal walls, there is another molecule ready to “fill the hole” vacated by the first. The mechanism for this cohesive flow is presumably attractive van der Waals interactions between hydrocarbon chains. This model assumes that the average intermolecular separation in a surface-continuous monolayer does not exceed the cross-sectional area of the molecule as defined by the average molecular area A of the film at the surface pressure l7 in the pressurized compartment of the viscometer. Non-Newtonian flow may result if the monolayer array consists of molecules that interact by specific Coulombic or dipole interactions to form “floating islands”, which in turn may interact by van der Waals forces around their peripheries (Joly, 1956). Non-Newtonian flow may also be a property of collapsed films. The resulting differences in viscosity over a range of flow rates may then reflect film-component segregation or partial monolayer collapse. The surface shear viscosity of a monolayer is a valuable tool in that it reflects the intermolecular associations within the film at a given thermodynamic state as defined by the surface pressure and average molecular area. These data may be used in conjunction with l l / A isotherms and thermodynamic analyses of equilibrium spreading to determine the phase of a monolayer at a given surface pressure. This has been demonstrated in the shear viscosities of long-chain fatty acids, esters, amides, and amines (Jarvis, 1965). In addition,
60
P. L. ROSE ET AL.
factors such as temperature, surface pressure, and subphase pH have been shown to alter monolayer flow properties dramatically (Jarvis, 1965; Joly, 1956). It is not surprising, therefore, that this dynamic technique was chosen to provide information on chiral interactions in compressed films. Given that these stereochemically differentiated systems may have dramatically different l l / A isotherm characteristics, and hence different packing arrangements, it is plausible that their flow properties are stereochemically differentiated as well. Dynamic surface tension
The dynamic surface tension of a monolayer may be defined as the response of a film in an initial state of static quasi-equilibrium to a sudden change in surface area. If the area of the film-covered interface is altered at a rapid rate, the monolayer may not readjust to its original conformation quickly enough to maintain the quasi-equilibrium surface pressure. It is for this reason that properly reported l l / A isotherms for most monolayers are repeated at several compression/expansion rates. The reasons for this lag in equilibration time are complex combinations of shear and dilational viscosities, elasticity, and isothermal compressibility (Manheimer and Schechter, 1970; Margoni, 1871;Lucassen-Reynders et al., 1974).Furthermore, consideration of dynamic surface tension in insoluble monolayers assumes that the monolayer is indeed insoluble and stable throughout the perturbation; if not, a myriad of contributions from monolayer collapse to monomer dissolution may complicate the situation further. Although theoretical models of dynamic surface tension effects have been presented, there have been very few attempts at experimental investigation of these time-dependent phenomena in spread monolayer films. The difference between the static or equilibrium and “dynamic” surface tension is often observed in the compression/expansion hysteresis present in most monolayer l l / A isotherms (Fig. 8). In such cases, the compression isotherm is not coincident with the expansion one. For an insoluble monolayer, hysteresis may result from very rapid compression, collapse of the film to a surfactant bulk phase during compression, or compression of the film through a first or second order monolayer phase transition. In addition, any combination of these effects may be responsible for the observed hysteresis. Perhaps understandably, there has been no firm quantitative model for time-dependent relaxation effects in monolayers. However, if the basic monolayer properties such as ESP, stability limit, and composition are known, a qualitative description of the dynamic surface tension, or hysteresis, may be obtained.
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
61
“Clockwise”Hysteresis Rotation
c
1 w
Compression
“Counterclockwise”Hysteresis Rotation
ArealMolecule
Fig. 8 Representative compression and expansion l l / A isotherms showing “clockwise” and “counterclockwise” hysteresis.
The simplest model of hysteresis in monolayers is based upon a loose analogy with the closed Carnot cycle (Dragcevic et al., 1986), in which the work of compression is compared to the work of expansion for a stable film in order to obtain the net work done during the cycle. The work of compression from an initial average molecular area A , to the final average molecular area A , at which the monolayer is stable is the change of Helmholtz free energy of compression F, (this symbol is used in surface chemistry because A is universally used for area) given by (8). Conversely, the work
AF,= -j;IIdA of expansion from A , to A , is described by (9). The net. work of the cycle,
AFcycle,may then be expressed as ( 10). The simple difference between the AFcycle= AF,
- AF,
(10)
62
P. L. ROSE E T A L .
work of compression and the work of expansion allows for a simple treatment of the hysteresis “loop” exhibited in the n / A isotherm. As shown in Fig. 8, the compression/expansion hysteresis may be ‘‘clockwise’’ or “counterclockwise” in nature. If the hysteresis is clockwise, the expansion regime occurs at a higher surface pressure than the compression throughout the cycle. The net work done by the surroundings on the monolayer during the closed cycle, as calculated from the simple relations above, is therefore negative, and the monolayer system is considered to have done work on the surroundings. In essence, this implies that the film is elastic, or springy, in its dynamic response to compression. If the sense of hysteresis is counterclockwise, the net work done by the surroundings on the monolayer system is positive, and energy that was expended upon compression has been lost to some other process (monolayer component reorganization, film collapse, dissolution, heat transfer, etc.) upon expansion back to the original average molecular area. The sense of hysteresis has been shown to depend significantly on the rate of film compression and expansion (Munden and Swarbrick, 1973). This treatment of monolayer dynamic surface tension is simplistic in that it does not take into account the fact that most monolayers are metastable, and therefore may not be used for quantitative thermodynamic analysis of irreversible systems. However, it does provide a qualitative comparison of the dynamic properties of differing film systems, and the direction of energy transfer for the cycle may be used in determining the nature of molecular interactions during dynamic processes. The few examples of deliberate investigation of dynamic processes as reflected by compression/expansion hysteresis have involved monolayers of fatty acids (Munden and Swarbrick, 1973; Munden et al., 1969), lecithins (Bienkowski and Skolnick, 1974; Cook and Webb, 1966), polymer films (Townsend and Buck, 1988) and monolayers of fatty acids and their sodium sulfate salts on aqueous subphases of alkanolamines (Rosano et al., 1971). A few of these studies determined the amount of hysteresis as a function of the rate of compression and expansion. However, no quantitative analysis of the results was attempted. Historically, dynamic surface tension has been used to study the dynamic response of lung phosphatidylcholine surfactant monolayers to a sinusoidal compression/expansion rate in order to mimic the mechanical contraction and expansion of the lungs. Until very recently, there has been little or no experimental protocol for obtaining quantitative dynamic surface tension data on monolayer films. In most cases, the experimental set-up has consisted of a simple Langmuir film balance equipped with a variable-speed motor to drive the moving barrier. Hysteresis data were then obtained at a number of compression/expansion rates and compared qualitatively. This experimental set-up was improved considerably by Johnson (Arnett et al., 1988a), who modified a special
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
63
To Electmbalance
Drive Cable Detector Bamer System
Trough
Fig. 9 Schematic of the modified dynamic surface tension apparatus.
Langmuir trough (Cahn Instruments Surface Tension Accessory No. 099-002910-30)in which the film could be rapidly compressed and expanded at a linear rate by means of moving barriers at either end of the balance (Fig. 9). This equipment was redesigned to reduce leaks and to follow a linear rather than sinusoidal cycle. Unlike the Langmuir film balance experiment, the dynamic surface tension (DST) apparatus compresses and expands the film from both ends of the small Teflon trough (11.4 cm x 4.8 cm x 1.8 cm) by means of two moving Teflon barriers, which are connected by a clean Viton elastomer (12 cm x 1.0 cm x 0.035 cm). Over the period of the experiment, the barriers are driven at a constant rate by means of a spindle and pulley system powered by a Hurst CA 1/4 rpm motor. The rates of compression and expansion may be varied by a set of interchangeable gears of 3:1,2: 1, 1: 1, 1:2, and 1:3 gear ratio. Ultimately, the barrier compression/expansion cycle speeds may be varied from 0.11 to 1.0 cycle min-'. The reversal of compression and expansion modes is accomplished by means of an infrared emitter-detector diode pair that is switched by a pair of indicator flags attached to the drive cable. The concomitant changes in surface pressure can then be detected via a Wilhelmy plate, which is connected to a Cahn RG electrobalance detector.
MIXING CRITERIA AS APPLIED TO THE ELUCIDATION OF INTERMOLECULAR INTERACTIONS AT SURFACES
It is possible to study monolayers composed of more than one compound by the techniques described above. Mixed monolayers are of considerable
P. L. ROSE ET AL.
64
interest because of their relevance to natural systems, such as biological membranes. If one considers that the monolayer properties of these multicomponent films vary with the composition of the film, binary monolayers provide an opportunity to study the effects of molecular structure on intermolecular interactions between species whose only common feature is surface activity. Conversely, these films also provide an opportunity to check interactions between molecules whose main structural difference is isomerism. One may then reasonably treat monolayers cast from enantiomers as a specialized case of a mixed binary monolayer. Of course, films cast from diastereomers, structural isomers, or purely nonisomeric pairs may be treated in the same manner. The first question that must be addressed in considering interactions in binary monolayers is whether or not an intimately mixed monolayer is formed at all. Unlike three dimensional systems (such as a mixture of oil and water), the miscibility or immiscibility of the two monolayer components usually cannot be determined visually. Spreading a mixture of surfactants from a homogeneous solution of surfactants 1 and 2 does not ensure that they mix homogeneously at the air-water interface (Fig. 10). If the film components are immiscible, they will segregate into separate microdomains (Gershfeld, 1972). The small size of these domains renders their direct microscopic observation or physical detection difficult, so that thermodynamic methods are needed to provide criteria for film component miscibility. Non-ideally miscible and ideally miscible components will of course have differing degrees of randomness in their component distribution, which depend on the mole fraction of each component in (or composition of) the film. As in the case with three-dimensional systems, the associations between film components may then be inferred by the dependence of monolayer properties on composition. Two methods have been used classically to determine component
Segregated
Mixed
Fig. 10 Idealized representation of mixed and unmixed monolayers.
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
65
miscibility in binary films, using data readily obtained from the l T / A isotherm: (i) the monitoring of average molecular area (or some other monolayer property) as a function of film composition at constant l7 (Gaines, 1966); and (ii) the monitoring of phase transition pressures for one of the components as a function of film composition (Crisp, 1949; Defay, 1932). When these tests indicate ideal or at least partial miscibility, quantitative methods may be used to determine the energetics of mixing (Goodrich, 1957). Combined, these techniques provide a potentially powerful tool for determining the stereospecific associations in monolayer mixtures of chiral surfactants. Determination of miscibility by additive properties such as average molecular area can give only qualitative interpretations of I I / A data. For example, if the film components are ideally miscible, the average molecular area of the binary film at a fixed surface pressure will be the sum of each of the molecular areas of the individual components 1 and 2 in their pure films, and will follow equation ( 1 l), where N is the mole fraction. Unfortunately,
exactly the same result will be obtained if the components are completely immiscible, since they will segregate and occupy the same average molecular areas in their domains as they would in their separate pure films. At best, a linear relationship between the measured molecular area and composition may indicate ideal miscibility or complete immiscibility at a given surface pressure, but cannot distinguish between them; however, any deviation from this ideal line is useful in that it indicates at least partial miscibility. This additive relationship may be applied to any other property of the system (i.e., viscosity, surface potential, etc.) under isothermal and isobaric conditions with the same result (Gaines, 1966). When a reversible transition from one monolayer phase to another can be observed in the n/Aisotherm (usually evidenced by a sharp discontinuity or plateau in the phase diagram), a two-dimensional version of the Gibbs phase rule (Gibbs, 1948) may be applied. The transition pressure for a phase change in one or both of the film components can be monitored as a function of film composition, with an ideally miscible system following the relation (12). A completely immiscible system will not follow this ideal law, but will
yield instead a flat, horizontal plot (Fig. 1 1 ) showing no deviation from transition pressure of the pure components (Gershfeld, 1972). This result can be understood in the light of Crisp and Defay’s proposal of a “two-dimensional” phase rule (Crisp, 1949; Defay, 1932). At constant
P. L. ROSE E T A L .
66
0
100
Composition
100 % # 2 0 %#1
Fig. 11 Defay-Crisp diagram for a binary monolayer: A, ideal mixing; B, non-ideal mixing; C , complete immiscibility. II, and II, are the phase transition pressures of components 1 and 2.
temperature and external pressure, the number and degrees of freedom, f, for the system is given by (13), where Cb is the number of components
equilibrated throughout the system (air and water), C, is the number of components in the surface monolayer (2), P, is the number of bulk phases equilibrated throughout the system (air and water), and Psis the number of surface phases in equilibrium with each other. The quantity 2 represents the two variables surface pressure and film composition. If components 1 and 2 are miscible, then the number of surface phases in equilibrium at the transition pressure is two, and f = 2. In this case, the surface pressure varies continuously with film composition. If the components are immiscible, the number of surface phases in equilibrium at the transition pressure will be 3, andf= 1. Variation of film composition will not alter the transition pressure. The utility of this method is limited by the fact that not all spread films show a true phase transition in their l l / A isotherms and also by the dubious application of equilibrium thermodynamics to metastable monolayers. Gershfeld has determined carefully the gas-liquid transition pressures of simple fatty acid mixtures (Pagano and Gershfeld, 1972) and the phosphatid ylcholine-cholesterol binary film system (Gershfeld and Pagano, 1972a,b,c)and applied the Defay-Crisp phase rule. However, these transitions occur at surface pressures of only a few mdyn cm- and are out of the range of detection for most film balances. This presents a problem in dealing with
',
67
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
binary films in which neither of the components undergoes a readily observed, reversible phase change in the course of compression. Furthermore, this method indicates miscibility only at surface pressures equal to the transition pressure and higher (Crisp, 1949; Defay, 1932). The phase rule has been applied more conveniently to ESP measurements taken as a function of temperature. Again, Gershfeld (1982) has shown that a plateau or discontinuity in the ESP versus temperature plot may be indicative of a three-way equilibrium between the floating crystal and the separate monolayer phases that have spread from this crystal. This treatment has been used to argue for the existence of surface bilayers of phosphatidylcholine derivatives (Gershfeld, 1986, 1988). Once it has been established that the components of a binary monolayer are to some degree miscible, the energetics of their interaction may be calculated directly from the II/A isotherms of the mixture and its individual components. As proposed by Goodrich (1957), this technique employs the differences in the work of compression of the binary film and the work required to compress each of the films of the pure components to the same surface pressure. The result is the total free energy of mixing as expressed by the sum of the excess and ideal free energies of mixing in (14), where N ,
S,n
Acmix
=
( A , , , - N , A , - N,A,)dn
+ R T ( N , In N , + N , In N , ) (14)
and N , are the mole fractions of components 1 and 2, A , and A , are the average molecular areas of components 1 and 2 in their own pure films at n, and A , , , is the average molecular area of the mixed film at a given n. The excess free energies of mixing are then easily determined by integrating the area under the I I / A isotherms from ll = 0 to the specified surface pressure n. An excess free energy versus composition diagram may be plotted if data are taken at several different compositions, affording a quantitative determination of the energy required for non-ideal mixing. The excess entropy and enthalpy of mixing may also be determined if the n/A isotherms are obtained at several temperatures. The inherent assumptions of this technique are: (i) the monolayers of the components and their mixtures are stable and behave reversibly, and the upper limit of integration is below the ESPs of each of the components; (ii) ideal free energies of mixing describe the mixing behavior of the films accurately at very large average molecular areas so that the ll = 0 lower limit of integration may be assumed valid at the film’s lift-off point; (iii) the film components do not reorganize or reaggregate during the compression process; and (iv) the monolayer is surface-continuous at all surface pressures.
68
P. L. ROSE ET AL.
These assumptions have been expanded upon (Shah and Capps, 1968; Lucassen-Reynders, 1973; Rakshit and Zografi, 1980), especially in regard to the application of the ideal mixing relationship in gaseous films (Pagano and Gershfeld, 1972). It has been pointed out that water may contribute to the energetics of film compression if the molecular structures of the surfactants are sufficiently different (Lucassen-Reynders, 1973). It must be noted that this treatment assumes that the compression process is reversible and the monolayer is truly stable thermodynamically. It must therefore be applied with considerable reservation in view of the hysteresis that is often found for II/A isotherms. Excess free energies of mixing have been used indirectly to determine the effects of surfactant structure on mixing. Excess thermodynamic properties have been reported for structurally simple molecules such as the straight chain fatty acids (Pagano and Gershfeld, 1972; Rakshit and Zografi, 1980), but have also been determined for more complex systems, such as vitamin K , and chlorophyll-a (Gaines et al., 1965), octadecanol and docosyl sulfate (Goodrich, 1957), and hexadecanol/tetradecanol mixtures, with sodium hexadecyl sulfate (Goodrich, 1957). Recently, free energies of interaction were determined for mixtures of chlorophyll-a with a-tocopherylquinone and plastoquinone-3 and -9 (Guay and LeBlanc, 1987). Comparisons of the effect of molecular structure on mixing suggested that the carbonyl moieties of the quinone were responsible for the large negative deviations from ideal mixing in mixtures with chlorophyll-a. The implications for films cast from mixtures of enantiomers is that diagrams similar to those obtained for phase changes (i.e., melting point, etc.) versus composition for the bulk surfactant may be obtained if a film property is plotted as a function of composition. In the case of enantiomeric mixtures, these monolayer properties should be symmetric about the racemic mixture, and may help to determine whether the associations in the racemic film are homochiral, heterochiral, or ideal. Monolayers cast from nonenantiomeric chiral surfactant mixtures normally will not exhibit this feature. In addition, a systematic study of binary films cast from a mixture of chiral and achiral surfactants may help to determine the limits for chiral discrimination in monolayers “doped” with an achiral diluent. However, to our knowledge, there has never been any other systematic investigation of the thermodynamic, rheological and mixing properties of chiral monolayers than those reported below from this laboratory. TECHNIQUES FOR VISUALIZING FILMS AND AGGREGATES
Although the standard l l / A isotherms of chiral monolayers can disclose much information on stereospecific packing arrangements, they do not allow
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
69
for direct visualization of packing patterns. Standard crystallographic techniques can be used on the bulk solids of the surfactants used to form the monolayer, but there is no guarantee that the packing arrangements responsible for the display of chiral discrimination within the film are identical to those in the bulk solid phase. X-ray crystallography and ellipsometry have been performed on Langmuir-Blodgett films of fatty acids and related materials transferred to solid substrates, but these techniques can only give quantitative information on the orientation of the headgroup and the tilt of the hydrocarbon chains at highly defined surface pressures. We have found that, when combined with the quasi-thermodynamic information provided by II/A isotherms, surface rheology, and equilibrium spreading pressures, direct visualization of the monolayers and film aggregates via ultramicroscopy provides useful insights into stereospecific packing. nansmission and scanning electron microscopy
Electron microscopy of Langmuir-Blodgett films is generally confined to multilayers of surfactant deposited on to a solid substrate. Scanning electron microscopy allows for direct visualization of the uppermost layer of molecules deposited on the substrate, and this may be sufficient for the distinction of packing differences in chiral films. Transmission electron microscopy can be used in the same multilayer aggregates to give information on the number of layers deposited, the average thickness of each layer, and the topographical features of the uppermost layer. These techniques are currently incapable of resolving reproducibly the features of a single-layer small molecule film. Because they operate reliably on only multilayer films, they are not adequate for describing the more subtle packing arrangements in loosely aggregated monolayers. Scanning tunneling microscopy
Scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) allows for the imaging of a single layer of non-insulating molecules transferred to a solid substrate. Under optimal conditions, scanning tunneling microscopy has the necessary resolution to provide visual evidence of stereo-dependent packing between R- and S-enantiomers versus interactions between S- and S- and R- and R-enantiomers. At lower resolutions, the technique can provide dramatic pictures of chiral packing in a broad monolayer array or in a sufficiently conductive multilayer. Unfortunately, the films of surfactant must be stationary and highly ordered for the film to be effectively imaged. This is usually accomplished by transferring the monolayer from the water surface to a solid, conducting surface (usually pyrolytic graphite). This transfer does
70
P. L. ROSE ET AL.
not allow for an accurate description of the film as it sits on the water surface, and there is no guarantee that the film is ordered on the solid substrate in the same fashion as at the air-water interface. However, the simplicity of the technique and the availaility of several commercial instruments and imaging software make it an attractive investigative tool. Epijluorescence optical microscopy
Unlike electron and scanning tunneling microscopy, the use of fluorescent dyes in monolayers at the air-water interface allows the use of contrast imaging to view the monolayer in situ during compression and expansion of the film. Under ideal circumstances, one may observe the changes in monolayer phase and the formation of specific aggregate domains as the film is compressed. This technique has been used to visualize phase changes in monolayers of chiral phospholipids (McConnell et al., 1984, 1986; Weis and McConnell, 1984; Keller et al., 1986; McConnell and Moy, 1988) and achiral fatty acids (Moore et al., 1986). The optical epifluorescence technique utilizes a small Langmuir trough (usually made of Teflon) mounted on the stage of a photomicroscope. The surface pressure of a spread film can be manipulated if the trough is equipped with a moveable barrier driven by a smoothly operating motor. The surface pressure can be monitored by use of a small Wilhelmy plate and electrobalance, and disruption of the film-covered surface by air currents can be minimized by placing a microscope coverslip or some other optically transparent glass over the trough. Visualization is accomplished by mixing dilute solutions of the surfactant of interest with dilute solutions of a fluorescent-label tagged analogue of the surfactant. For example, in work performed with chiral phospholipids, an NBD-functionalized phospholipid was used as a dye, and added to the lipid-spreading solution in two mole percent concentration. The solution is spread on the water surface, the spreading solvent allowed to evaporate, and fluorescence is then excited by an argon or helium laser. As the film is compressed, the image of the monolayer usually appears dark against a brightly fluorescing field. This allows for direct observation of monolayer aggregation during compression. Despite its attractive capabilities, the epifluorescence technique has some drawbacks. The fluorescent surfactant probe must not be miscible with the major phase of interest, and must not interact with the major phase in any way that changes the rheological flow or compression characteristics of the film. In addition, the probe itself must form a stable monolayer on the air-water interface. The area in which this work is to be performed must also be clean enough for accurate film balance work and must be free of vibration.
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
3
71
Chiral monolayers
The following sections describe examples of the application of these approaches to the study of chiral molecular recognition in thin film systems, using the battery of techniques outlined above.
ENANTIOMERIC SYSTEMS
N- (a-Methylbenzy1)stearamide
Our first investigations of the stereospecific aggregation of molecules in a monolayer involved the use of a novel chiral surfactant, N-(amethylbenzyl)stearamide, spread on aqueous acid subphases ( Arnett and Thompson, 1981; Arnett et al., 1982). This surfactant was chosen for study because of the potential for strong hydrogen bonding between enantiomers, which should in theory yield closely packed aggregates in a film system. In the bulk crystalline phases, large differences exist in the properties of the racemic mixture and the pure enantiomers. X-ray powder diffraction patterns showed that the racemic mixture was a true racemate, and the melting transition points and heats of fusion of the racemate were markedly different from those of the pure enantiomers [which were identical (Arnett and Thompson, 1981)l. Enantiomeric recognition was clearly displayed in films spread from solution and films in equilibrium with their crystals, and was sharply dependent on the acidity of the subphase. Protonation of the amide group appeared to be necessary for spreading to stable monolayers. For example, the crystals of the racemate deposited on a ION H,S04 solution at 25°C spread quickly to yield a film with an ESP of 7.7 dyn cm-', while the single enantiomers spread only to a surface pressure of 3.9dyncm-' (Table 1). Similar effects are observed at 15 and 35°C. The effect of stereochemistry on equilibrium spreading is even more pronounced at lower subphase acidities. On 6~ sulfuric acid, the racemate spread to an equilibrium surface pressure of 4.9 dyn cm-', while the enantiomeric systems spread to less than 1 dyn cm-'. When spread from dilute hexane solution, acid-dependent enantiomeric discrimination was observed in the l l / A compression isotherms of the monolayer at 25°C (Fig. 12). It is interesting to note that at higher subphase acidities, both racemic and enantiomeric film systems become more highly expanded, and the surface pressures where enantiomeric discrimination commences occur at high (85-90 A2/molecule) average molecular areas. This may be taken as direct evidence of headgroup ionization effects. The surface
Table 1 Equilibrium spreading pressures ( ESPs) of racemic and optically pure N - ( cemethylbenzy1)stearamides at various temperatures and subphase acidities."*b ION H,SO, Racemate
6~ H,SO, Enantiomers
Temp./"C
II/dyn cm-'
Areac
lT/dyn cm-
15 25 35
4.8 f 0.3 7.7 f 0.3 20.9 & 0.6
76 f 3 70 f 3
0.89 f 0.1 3.9 f 0.4 10.3 & 0.5
Racemate
Enantiomers
Area'
II/dyn cm-'
Area'
lT/dyn cm-'
Area'
86 f 3 82 f 3
4.9 f 0.2
73 f 1
0.6 f 0.2
77.5 f 0.1
"Reprinted with permission from Arnett et al., 1982. Copyright 1982 American Chemical Society. obtained from normalized 11-A isotherms, is area at He at 15 and 12°C. Weight of crystals used was about 300mg. Area of trough was 565.4cm2. lTeis equilibrium spreading pressure (ESP); A' is area per molecule at He. 'Az/molecuIe.
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
301 7
5
0
---------"r% H
20 -
I
....,.
I11
U h
2
73
10-
***... t \
'....
I1 '\* *.
--&+ I
Fig. 12 Force/area curves of stearamide films on 6~ H$O, at 25°C: 1, natural racemate; 11, enantiomeric stearamide; 111, mixture of solutions of enantiomers on the surface in 1: 1 ratio. Reprinted with permission from Arnett and Thompson, 1981. Copyright 1981 American Chemical Society.
pressures required to pack the racemic system are higher at every average molecular area than that required in the enantiomeric systems. In addition, the racemic monolayer is more highly expanded as a function of subphase acidity than the enantiomeric system at surface pressures less than 5 dyn cm- Above this surface pressure, the enantiomeric system becomes unstable and apparently collapses to some other surface state at subphase . observation is consonant with the ESP acid concentrations less than 6 ~This values obtained from the bulk crystals (Table 1). Several aspects of the properties of the chiral N - ( wmethylbenzy1)stearamide film systems indicate that kinetic, as well as thermodynamic, factors may contribute to enantiomeric discrimination. The instability of the spread films of the enantiomeric system and the low ESP values of films spread from enantiomeric crystals suggest that slow collapse to a surface crystalline state may be responsible for film instability. Conversely, the racemic monolayer spread from solution is stable at higher ( > 5 dyncm-') surface pressures and attains a higher surface pressure when in equilibrium with its crystal, ~ acid subphase. However, when a racemic film of especially on 1 0 sulfuric R( + )- and S ( - )-N-(wmethylbenzy1)stearamide is spread on this same subphase from solutions of the separate enantiomers (first depositing a film of one enantiomer and then depositing a film of the opposite enantiomer over the same surface), the I I / A isotherm of the resulting monolayer is very similar to that of the single enantiomer. These seemingly contradictory data suggest that, when spread from a homogeneous solution, collapse of the racemic film to separate enantiomeric crystalline domains is probably
'.
74
P. L. ROSE ET A L .
inhibited by the presence of the opposite enantiomer. Resolution of the racemic film into separate homochiral domains may therefore be kinetically inhibited. These results for spread film and equilibrium spreading suggest that films of racemic N - ( a-methylbenzy1)stearamide may be resolved by seeding the racemic film with crystals of either pure enantiomer. Indeed, when a monolayer of racemic N-( a-methylbenzy1)stearamide is compressed to 45 A'/molecule (27 dyn cm-'), deposition of a crystal of either R ( + )- or S ( - )-enantiomer results in a decay of surface pressure from the initial 28 dyn cm-' film pressure to 3.0 dyn cm-', the ESP of the enantiomeric ~ acid subphase (Table 1). When the experiment systems on a pure 1 0 sulfuric is repeated with racemic crystals, the system reaches an equilibrium surface pressure of 11 dyn cm- l, nearly the ESP of the racemic crystal on the clean acidic interface. In either case, equilibrium pressure is reached within a two hour time period. The implication of these results is that deposition of, for example, R( +)-crystals on to the racemic films provides a nucleation site for R( + )-molecules in the film, leaving behind a partially resolved film of predominantly S ( - )-molecules. Deposition of S ( - )-crystals should, alternatively, leave behind a film composed predominantly of R( + )molecules. This model is supported by the ESP data obtained on the clean acidic surface, where the free energy of enantiomer crystals appears to be lower compared with liquid-like film states than that of the racemic crystals. The combined data given above indicate that intermolecular attractions within the monolayer at any given state are stronger for the enantiomeric systems than for their racemic mixture. It is evident from the fact that the film systems are formed only on strongly acidic subphases that hydrogen bonding and ionization of the headgroups are major factors in the transmission of shape-selective information from one molecule to the next. The quasi-thermodynamic ESP data and film stabilities, combined with the reported resolution phenomena, suggest that enantiomeric recognition in these films occurs most readily in condensed film states. The question remains as to whether enantiomeric discrimination may be observed in the more highly expanded, fluid-like states that are characteristic of most biological surfactants in uiuo. Phospholipids
Phospholipids are perhaps the most ubiquitous of chiral surfactants in cell biology. It is well known that only the L-isomer is naturally occurring in the cell membrane of most living organisms, yet the question of whether or not this homochirality plays a role in the regulation of cell chemistry has barely
75
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
been addressed. Such a large proportion of biochemical reactions are stereospecific that one might reasonably conclude that membrane chirality plays a significant role in cell processes. The environment of a cell membrane is often modeled by a monolayer of phospholipid on the air-water interface. Our attempts to detect enantiomeric recognition in such films has largely involved dipalmitoylphosphatidyl choline (DPPC), which has a chiral headgroup situated at the junction of two 16-carbon unit chains. The l l / A isotherms of the racemic and enantiomeric forms of DPPC are identical within experimental error under every condition of temperature, humidity, and rate of compression that we have tested. For example, the temperature dependence of the compression/expansion curves for DPPC monolayers spread on pure water are identical for both the racemic mixture and the D- and L-isomers (Fig. 13). Furthermore, the equilibrium spreading pressures of this surfactant are independent of stereochemistry in the same broad temperature range, indicating that both enantiomeric and racemic films of DPPC are at the same energetic state when in equilibrium with their bulk crystals. The dynamic surface tension properties of the heterochiral and homochiral DPPC films are also independent of stereochemistry. Figure 14 shows the hysteresis loops of five successive compression/expansion cycles obtained on the modified Cahn DST apparatus. Although all five compression/expansion cycles of the DPPC films are not coincident, the areas and shapes of the
-'
6
30-
h
ze
2010 - _ _ _ I
50
60
70
80
90
100
110
A */ molecule Fig. 13 Force/area curves of dipalmitoylphosphatidyl choline monolayers spread on ure water at 25°C (solid line) and 45°C (dashed line). The compression rate is 7.2 '/molecule per minute. The shape of the isotherms is identical for homochiral and heterochiral films.
x
P. L. ROSE ET AL.
76
1 . a
40
2 3
I
20
70
50
30
W * / molecule Fig. 14 Compression/expansionhysteresis loops for monolayers of dipalmitoylphosphatidyl choline at 25°C on pure water subphase. Rate of compression/expansion is 12.5 A2/molecule per minute.
hysteresis loops are independent of chirality. Furthermore, this lack of stereodifferentiation is constant throughout the 15-60°C temperature range and at every compression/expansion rate we have tested. Shorter chain analogs of DPPC were also investigated in order to determine if the lack of stereo-differentiation in monolayer properties could be due to DPPC’s higher gel point or complicating steric effects. Figure 15 shows the compression/expansion isotherms of DPPC as compared with racemic and enantiomeric dimyristoylphosphatidyl choline (DMPC) and dilauroyl phosphatidyl choline (DLPC). Again no stereodifferentiation in monolayer properties was observed as reflected by l T / A isotherms or dynamic surface tension. One point of interest in the comparison of DPPC with its shorter chain analogs is the apparent first-order phase transition in the DPPC compression/expansion isotherm. The constant surface pressure plateau is indicative of a change in film state from a highly expanded surface phase to a more tightly packed, highly condensed film. In the latter intermolecular associations are dominated by short-range forces, which should yield some expression of stereo-recognition in film properties. Although we have not been able to detect any dependence of the phosphatidyl choline monolayers’ thermal or mechanical properties on chirality in this I I / A region, epifluorescence microscopy has yielded dramatic evidence of chiral aggregation in the plateau region. McConnell and others (McConnell et al., 1984, 1986; Weis and McConnell, 1984; Keller et al., 1986; McConnell and Moy, 1988) have shown that films of the ( - )-isomer form star-shaped aggregates having a swirl-like pattern to the domain symmetry opposite to that of films cast from the ( + )-isomer when compressed through the constant pressure region
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
40
77
t
I
E
U
h c
2-
Fig. 15 Force/area curves for monolayers of dipalmitoylphosphatidyl choline (solid line), dimyristoylphosphatidyl choline (dashed line), and dilauroylphosphatidyl choline (dotted line) at 25°C.
of the I I / A isotherm. The swirl symmetry is a result of stereoselective packing and consists of a rotation of the domain shape, which is mirrored in the shape of ( - )- versus ( + )-domains. Conversely, films cast from the racemic mixture have aggregates exhibiting no definite symmetry when compressed to this film state. The question remains as to why this stereo-differentiation is not as easily detected in film properties. In any event, these results highlight the extremely subtle nature of the forces which play a role in chiral molecular recognition. Stearoylamino acids and esters
Both the N-(a-methylbenzy1)stearamide and phospholipid systems as detailed above proved to be difficult systems with which to work. The inability of N - ( a-methylbenzy1)stearamideto form stable monolayers or even to spread from the crystal on anything but very acidic subphases presents a significant technical challenge despite the presence of a chiral headgroup that is unobstructed by other molecular features. On the other hand, the phospholipid surfactants that spread to form stable films both from solution and from their bulk crystals on pure water subphases at amBient temperatures displayed no discernible enantiomeric discrimination in any film property. The chiral functionality on these biomolecules is apparently shielded from intermolecular interactions with other chiral centers to the extent
78
P. L. ROSE € T A L .
that we are unable to detect any expression of stereoselectivity in monolayer properties. One may contemplate the significance of this lack of stereoselectivity in such an important living structure as the cell membrane considering the widespread employment of chiral recognition for natural selection in many other biological systems. The primary focus of our work with stearoylamino acids and esters was essentially the same as the above-mentioned efforts with the phospholipids: to test the extent of molecular recognition between chiral molecules of biological significance. While our work with the phospholipids was limited to natural materials and their antipodes, the work discussed here is based upon fatty versions of natural amino acids constructed by us in the laboratory. This work is also related to the N-(a-methylbenzu1)stearamidestudies in that the molecules as constructed are simple, single-chain surfactants with an exposed chiral headgroup well-known for intermolecular hydrogen bonding. N-Stearoylamino acids and their methyl esters were synthesized from enantiomeric and racemic forms of tyrosine, serine, alanine, and tryptophan (Fig. 16). Analogs of these molecules were investigated initially over 30 years ago by Zeelen and Havinga, who found stereochemical differentiation in the monolayer n/A isotherms of these materials (Zeelen, 1956; Zeelen and Havinga, 1958). We have extended this study using more sensitive Langmuir balances, a wider array of dynamic and equilibrium techniques, and the N-stearoyl methyl esters of the amino acids (Harvey et al., 1989; Harvey and Arnett, 1989). Figure 17 shows the l l / A isotherms of racemic and enantiomeric films of the methyl esters of N-stearoyl-serine, -alanine, -tryptophan, and -tyrosine on clean water at 25°C. Although there appears to be little difference between the racemic and enantiomeric forms of the alanine surfactants, the N-stearoyl-tyrosine, -serine, and -tryptophan surfactants show clear enantiomeric discrimination in their II/A curves. This chiral molecular recognition is first evidenced in the lift-off areas of the curves for the racemic versus enantiomeric forms of the films (Table 2). As discussed previously, the lift-off area is the average molecular area at which a surface pressure above 0.1 dyn cm- is first registered. The packing order differences in these films, and hence their stereochemical differentiation, are apparently maintained throughout the compression/expansion cycles. In addition, it should be noted that none of the compression and expansion cycles for these films are coincident. The considerable hysteresis exhibited during the compression/expansion cycle is evidenced at every compression/expansion rate investigated, and is indicative of a stereoselective kinetic process that must occur upon film compression. Table 3 gives the monolayer stability limits of the amino acid methyl ester films as defined by
79
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
OH
HO
Stearoyltyrosinemethyl ester
R-(4-
%+)-
Stearoylserine methyl ester
S(+b
Stearoylalaninemethyl ester
S(+)-
R-0-
H,C02C C,,H,,CONH
y7
R-C)-
H
3
C,,H,,CONH
c
0
o"'H
2
c
Q $0 y2 ,cH3
/ \ / \ / \ N
I
H
R-H-
w
NHCOC17H35
N
I
H
Stearoyltryptophanmethyl ester
S(+b
Fig. 16 Chiral amino acid soaps.
Table 2 Lift-off areas per molecule for different chiral surfactants studied at 25°C on a pure water subphase.
Surfactant Stearoylserine methyl ester Stearoylalanine methyl ester Stearoyltryptophan methyl ester Stearoyltyrosine methyl ester
Enantiomeric monolayer"
Racemic monolayer
42.5 f 0.9* 51.5 f 3.2 75.9 f 1.4 74.5 & 0.6
67.4 f 1.4 49.8 f 3.2 79.3 f 3.5 59.9 5.1
Compression and expansion rates of 7.1 A'/molecule/min.: Values in units of A2/molecule. bStandard deviations are at the 95% confidence level.
P.
80
L. ROSE E T A L .
D
Azhnolecule
Fig. 17 Surface pressure/area isotherms for the compression and expansion cycles of racemic (dashed line) and enantiomeric (solid line) stearoylserine (A), stearoylalanine (B), stearoyltryptophan (C), and stearoyltyrosine methyl esters (D) on a pure water subphase at 25°C carried out at a compression rate of 7.1 b;2/molecule per minute. Arrows indicate the direction of compression and expansion.
Table 3 Stability results for the stearoylamino acid esters on pure water subphases at 25°C using Cadenhead's criterion for stability. Surfactant
Enantiomeric monolayef
Racemic monolayer
Stearoylserine methyl ester Stearoylalanine methyl ester Stearoyltryptophan methyl ester Stearoyltyrosine methyl ester
Unstableb Unstable Stable to 27' Stable to 4'
Stable to 2.5' Unstable Stable to 25' Unstable
'Compression and expansion rates of 7.1 A2/molecule per minute. bGreater than 1 dyn cm-' min-' deviation in surface pressure at low surface pressure. 'Values in dyn cm-'.
the criteria given previously. None of these films is stable at pressures exceeding 5 dyn cm-'. If the collapse of the monolayer, or its dissolution into the aqueous subphase, occurs at a rate greater than or equal to the rate of compression, the hysteresis in the l l / A isotherms may be readily explained.
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
81
The instability of these chiral monolayers may be a reflection of the relative stabilities of their bulk crystalline forms. When deposited on a clean water surface at 25"C, neither the racemic nor enantiomeric crystals of the tryptophan, tyrosine, or alanine methyl ester surfactants generate a detectable surface pressure, indicating that the most energetically favorable situation for the interfacial/crystal system is one in which the internal energy of the bulk crystal is lower than that of the film at the air-water interface. Only the racemic form of N-stearoylserine methyl ester has a detectable equilibrium spreading pressure (2.6 0.3 dyn cm- I). Conversely, neither of its enantiomeric forms will spread spontaneously from the crystal at this temperature. Despite the clear evidence of stereodifferentiation exhibited in the II/A isotherms of these chiral surfactants, the instabilities of the films as spread from solution at temperatures of experimental feasibility prevent a thorough description of the factors that might lead to molecular recognition in monolayers at equilibrium with their environments. Our next line of approach to this problem has been to conduct a broad investigation of the most attractive candidate from this group. N-Stearoylserine methyl ester. We chose N-stearoylserine methyl ester (SSME) as the molecule which would most probably demonstrate the highest degree of molecular recognition in monolayer properties at temperatures between 20 and 100°C. This choice was based on several factors: (i) the monolayers of the racemic form are stable up to approximately 2.5 dyn cm-' when spread from hexane solution at 25°C while the films spread from either of the enantiomers are unstable; (ii) the racemic form spreads spontaneously from the crystal at the same temperature (ESP = 2.6 If: 0.3 dyn cm-') while the enantiomeric forms do not; and (iii) the differences in the I I / A isotherms of the enantiomeric versus racemic films at 25°C are very large (Fig. 16a). These clear differences in the film properties as spread from solution and as spread under equilibrium conditions from the crystal are evidence of molecular recognition and discrimination in highly ordered film and bulk crystalline states. Our experimental strategy was therefore designed to elucidate the state or phase in which clearly stereo-dependent physical properties could be detected. We began this approach by determining some of the fundamental properties of the bulk crystals. Associations within the bulk crystalline phase. The physical property of enantiomeric solids and their mixtures which is cited most often is melting point. Figure 18 gives the melting point versus composition diagram for mixtures of S ( + )- and R( - )-SSME. The solid-liquid coexistence line of
P. L. ROSE €T AL.
82
P
P 0
al
40
8
m
100
%RC)smm
Fig. 18 Melting point versus composition diagram for stearoylserine methyl ester crystals. Reprinted with permission from Harvey et al., 1989. Copyright 1989 American Chemical Society.
Table 4 Heats and entropies of fusion for crystalline stearoylserine methyl ester.'.b Sample ( S ) - ( + ) - or ( R ) - (-)-stearoylserine methyl ester ( R , S ) - ( )-stearoylserine methyl ester
Transition temp./K
AH:/ kcal mol-'
362.1
23.0 f 1.3
-63.5
367.2
16.4 f 1.5
-45.0 f 4.1
ASP/
cal K - ' mol-' 4.0
ASf = AH,/'&. Reprinted with permission from Harvey et a[( 1989).Copyright 1989 American Chemical Society.
this diagram is highly suggestive of a racemic compound or racemate in which the smallest unit consists of a heterochiral pair of molecules (Eliel, 1962).The onset of eutectic formation at the extreme ends of the composition diagram indicates th?? the racemate is stable (Jacques et al., 1981; Petterson, 1956). The strength of the crystalline interactions is also shown in the solid-liquid transition thermodynamics. The thermal solid-liquid phase transition enthalpies and entropies for enantiomeric and racemic forms of SSME as obtained by differential scanning calorimetry indicate significant differences in the energetics of intermolecular interaction during melting (Table 4),with the racemic crystals having a lower enthalpy of fusion despite a higher melting point. In addition, the infrared spectra of these materials indicated significant differences in packing in the homochiral versus heterochiral crystals. The
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
83
crystals of the racemate display a pronounced broadening in the -CH, -CH, bending bands between enantiomeric and racemic crystals, indicating differences in packing about the chiral headgroups in both forms. Repeated attempts to grow crystals of sufficient quality for X-ray analysis failed, however. Given the information above, the question remains as to the nature of the monolayer states responsible for the stereo-differentiation of surface properties in racemic and enantiomeric films. Although associations in the crystalline phases are clearly differentiated by stereochemical packing, and therefore reflected in the thermodynamic and physical properties of the crystals, there is no indication that the same differentiations occur in a highly ordered, two-dimensional array of molecules on a water surface. However, it will be seen below (pp. 107-127) that conformational forces that are readily apparent in X-ray and molecular models for several diastereomeric surfactants provide a solid basis for interpreting their monolayer behavior. Associations within the monolayer jilm. The difficulties in comparing the properties of crystals and monolayers spread from them, as described above, result from ambiguity regarding molecular associations in a dry, tightly packed, crystalline environment in contrast to those in a more loosely packed, wet monolayer spread on an aqueous subphase. The ideal interpretation of the molecular associations responsible for chiral recognition and the monolayer phase in which they occur would have to account for the orientation of chiral functionality at the air-water interface, the disruption and depth of the water surface, the hydration state of the chiral headgroup at every I I / A state of the film, and the dependence of these associations on variables such as temperature and humidity. Until all these structural and energetic factors can be accounted for, the best line of approach is to measure the mechanical, rheological, and thermodynamic properties of the continuum as represented by the monolayer. The first line of comparison between associations within a monolayer and those in a crystal can be obtained from equilibria between crystal and film. Table 5 gives the equilibrium spreading pressures and surface free energies, enthalpies, and entropies of spreading for racemic and enantiomeric films of SSME spread from their crystals in the 20-40°C temperature range. It is clear that the ESPs of these films are dependent upon chirality. In each case, the free energy of spreading is small and negative, with spreading of the racemic form being more spontaneous than that of the enantiomers. Within the propagation of experimental error, the heats and enhopies of spreading for these films are identical. Figure 19 gives the I I / A isotherms of the racemic and enantiomeric films of SSME at several different temperatures. At the lower temperature limit
Table 5 Equilibrium spreading pressures of SSME and surface free energies, enthalpies, and entropies of spreading for the resulting film". n'/dyn cm-'
Ae/A2/molecule
AGJkcal mol- '
ASJcal K - ' mol-'
AH:/kcal mol-
'
~~
293 298 303 313
2.5 f 0.3 4.2 f 0.3 11.3 f 1.5
0.5 f 0.2 5.7 f 0.7
58 f 3 54 If: 2 49 2
64 f 3 54 f 4
-0.21 f 0.03 -0.33 f 0.03 -0.77 0.11
47 f 4 -0.05 f 0.02 -0.44 f 0.06
"Reprintedwith permission from Harvey et al., 1989. Copyright 1989 American Chemical Society.
44 f 4
14.3
+ 1.2
13.3 f 1.2
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
85
of 20°C, there appears to be little difference in the isotherms for either enantiomeric or racemic films. However, at higher temperatures the shapes of the compression/expansion isotherms are clearly stereo-differentiated, with the racemic films being more highly expanded. It should be noted that the shapes of the I'I/A isotherms indicate clearly that a phase transition, possibly first-order, occurs during the compression of both racemic and enantiomeric films at temperatures above 20°C. This transition occurs at lower surface
I "
a) 20"c
1 0 ° 10 L
'i
b, 25"c
'L 0
10
Fig. 19 Surface pressure/area isotherms for the compressioq/expansion cycle of enantiomeric (dashed line) and racemic (solid line) SSME monolayers on pure water subphase at (a) 20"C, (b) 25"C, (c) 30°C and (d)40°C. The compression rate is 29.8 A'/ molecule/min. Reprinted with permission from Harvey et al., 1989. Copyright 1989 American Chemical Society.
86
P. L. ROSE ET AL
i
c)
30°C
Fig. 19 Continued.
pressures for the enantiomeric films. There appears to be the same general trend noted in the ESPs of films spread directly from the crystalline state, for which equilibrium is reached at lower surface pressures in the homochiral systems. The general, qualitative conclusion that may be reached by comparison of these data is that upon compression, the enantiomeric films may undergo transition to a tightly packed, solid-like state at lower surface pressures than do the racemic monolayers. It is interesting to note that when varying ratios of S ( +)- and R( - )-enantiomem are spread as monolayer films, their lift-off areas show a compositional dependence with temperature from 20 to 30°C (Fig. 20).
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
a
1
a7
T I 30-40 "C
%
R-(-)-SSME
Fig. 20 "Liftoff area versus composition diagram for SSME films on pure water subphase at 20,25,30, and 40°C. Reprinted with permission from Harvey et al., 1989. Copyright 1989 American Chemical Society.
+
At 25"C, chiral differentiation occurs as a function of R ( - ) / S ( ) ratio. At this temperature the stereo-differentiation in film l l / A isotherm properties is most completely expressed. Below this temperature, the racemic and enantiomeric films are nearly identical in compression/expansion properties, while at the higher temperature extremes the degree of expansion of both homochiral and heterochiral films are identical at lower surface pressures. Although the general shape of the lift-off area versus composition diagram at 25°C is similar to the melting point diagram of the crystalline surfactant mixtures, it must not be taken as a definite indication of surface racemic compound formation. It must be remembered that the enantiomeric and racemic films at this temperature have significantly different stability limits and equilibrium spreading pressures. We believe that the compositional dependence of the lift-off area is an indication of the onset of the formation of a more highly expanded, liquid-like phase induced by the mixing of the enantiomers. The stability limits of these monolayers are given in Table 6 , and demonstrate the fact that the more highly expanded racemic film is also the more stable system over the temperature range studied. However, the general trend that can be observed in the l I / A isotherms and the monolayer stability limits is that, as the enantiomeric films become increasingly stable, their isotherms begin to take on the characteristics of the racemic system. Coupled with the observation of the temperature and compositional dependence of the
88
P. L. ROSE ET AL.
Table 6 SSME monolayer stability limits, llL. n,/dyn cm-' TI K
Racemic
Enantiomeric
293 298 303 313
Unstable at all II 2.5 15 -21
Unstable at all ll Unstable at all ll 0.5 19
Table 7
-
SSME surface shear viscosity."sb
ll = 2.5 dyn cm-'
TIK 293, 298 303 308 313
ll = 5.0dyncm-'
Racemic
Enantiomeric
Racemic
Enantiomeric
C
C
C
C
0.553 f 0.026 0.472 f 0.026 0.419 f 0.047
2.00 f 1.11 0.504 f 0.038 0.393 f 0.036
0.573 f 0.42 0.535 f 0.040 0.507 f 0.039
No flow 0.666 0.109d 0.493 f 0.020
"Reprinted with permission from Harvey et al. (1989). Copyright 1989 American Chemical Society. 'Surface viscosity in millisurface poise. Condensed films, no surface flow. Measurable non-Newtonian flow.
lift-off area, this may be taken as direct evidence of the thermodynamic dependence of the recognition phenomena, and suggests that the enantiomeric discrimination exhibited is a function of the phase (i.e., solid-like versus liquid-like) of the film. The latter point is illustrated by the surface shear viscosities of the homochiral and heterochiral films at surface pressures below the monolayer stability limits. Table 7 gives the surface shear viscosities at surface pressures of 2.5 and 5 dyn cm- in the temperature range given in Fig. 19 (20-40°C). Neither enantiomeric nor racemic films flow under these conditions at the lower temperature extreme, while at 30°C the racemic system is the more fluid, Newtonian film. However, in the 35-40°C temperature range, the racemic and enantiomeric film systems are both Newtonian in flow, and have surface shear viscosities that are independent of stereochemistry. These results are not surprising when one considers that (i) when the monolayer stability limit is below the surface pressure at which shear viscosity is measured, the film system does not flow, or flows in a non-Newtonian manner; (ii) when the monolayer stability limit is above the surface pressure
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
89
at which shear viscosity is measured, the flow is Newtonian and independent of stereochemistry; and (iii) when the shear viscosity of the film is stereochemically dependent, the stability limit of the enantiomeric system is below the surface pressure at which the shear viscosity is measured. Taken together, the equilibrium spreading pressures of films spread from the bulk surfactant, the dynamic properties of the films spread from solution, the shape of the l l / A isotherms, the monolayer stability limits, and the dependence of all these properties on temperature indicate that the primary mechanism for enantiomeric discrimination in monolayers of SSME is the onset of a highly condensed phase during compression of the films. This condensed phase transition occurs at lower surface pressures for the R( - )- or S ( + )-films than for their racemic mixture. Although the quasi-thermodynamic and rheological data show the effects of stereochemistry on film properties, ultramicroscopy of the film in situ at the water surface provides a glimpse at the effect of chiral recognition on film packing as the monolayer is compressed. Figure 21 shows the epifluorescence micrographs of racemic and enantiomeric films of SSME at surface pressures below 10 dyn cm- at 25°C. The racemic films show a high degree of ordering, forming swirling clusters akin to those formed by chiral phospholipids under similar conditions (McConnell et al., 1984, 1986; Weis and McConnell, 1984; Keller et al., 1986; McConnell and Moy, 1988). There appears to be no set packing pattern. Conversely, the enantiomeric films show only a highly condensed film in which no ordering can be observed. Along with scanning tunneling and transmission electron microscopy of these films transferred to carbon substrates (Harvey et al., 1989), the message of all the data on the SSME system is that a tightly packed crystalline or quasi-crystalline surface state is necessary for detection of enantiomeric discrimination by our methodology. N-Stearoyltyrosine. The case of N-stearoylserine methyl ester illustrates temperature-dependent enantiomeric discrimination in both monolayers spread from solution and in equilibrium with the bulk phase. Although the n / A isotherms suggested large differences in the intermolecular associations in homochiral and heterochiral films of SSME, there exist chiral systems in which enantiomeric discrimination as exhibited in .film compression properties is much more subtle. N-Stearoyltyrosine (STy) is such a system. When spread from a benzene/hexane solution on to a slightly acidic water subphase, spread films of racemic and enantiomeric STy exhibit nearly the same lT/A isotherms (Fig. 22) and surface shear viscosities (Harvey et al., 1990). The shapes of these isotherms and the apparently small differences between the compression/expansion characteristics of these fluid homochiral and heterochiral monolayers is conserved throughout the
90
P. L. ROSE ET AL.
Fig. 21 In situ epifluorescencemicrographs of (a) “fluid” racemic and ( b )“crystalline” enantiomeric SSME monolayers at the air-water interface at 25°C. Lighter domains are fluorescing probe L-NBD PC; darker domains are SSME. Total magnification is - 5 0 0 0 ~ . Reprinted with permission from Harvey et al., 1989. Copyright 1989 American Chemical Society.
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
91
Area Az/molecule
Fig. 22 Surface pressure/area isotherms for the compression cycles of stearoyltyrosine on a buffered pH 6.86 subphase carried out at a compression rate of 19.24 A2/molecule per minute at 16, 19,22,25,28,31, and 34°C. Reprinted with permission from Harvey et al., 1990. Copyright 1990 American Chemical Society.
T e m p e r a w "C
+
Fig. 23 Equilibrium spreading pressures of (R,S)-(& ) - and ( R ) - ( )-stearoyltyrosine on an aqueous subphase of pH 6.86 (potassium phosphate/disodium phosphate buffer) as a function of temperature. Film type I1 is the film at. temperatures above the transition and film type I is the film at temperatures below the transition. Reprinted with permission from Arnett et al., 1990.Copyright 1990American Chemical Society.
15-35°C temperature range. However, when spread from their bulk crystalline phases, the equilibrium spreading pressures of these films are clearly dependent on stereochemistry (Fig. 23) across the same temperature range. The conclusion that can be reached from these preliminary data is
92
P. L. ROSE ET AL .
that the presence of the bulk surfactant phase is necessary for detectable expression of enantiomeric discrimination in films of N-stearoyltyrosine. If we assume that the data of Figs. 22 and 23 can be treated by equilibrium thermodynamics, the discontinuities in the ESP versus temperature phase diagram should indicate the presence of a three-way equilibrium between bulk surfactant and two different film types in both homo- and hetero-chiral systems. The surface heats of transition ( U )between the two film types in either system may be obtained by relation (15), where lIe is the equilibrium
spreading pressure, A' is the average molecular area in the monolayer at the equilibrium spreading pressure as obtained from the l l / A isotherm of the spread film, and T' is the temperature at the transition "kink" in the ESP versus temperature diagram in Fig. 23. The subscripts I and I1 refer to the film states that exist in equilibrum at the transition temperature. This simultaneous approach eliminates the internal energy of the bulk surfactant in water, solving for the surface thermodynamic properties of film transition only. Similar transformations may be used to determine the surface free energies and entropies of spreading. Table 8 gives the results of this thermodynamic analysis for the spreading of film types I and I1 from the bulk, and the direct transition from film types I and 11. It is obvious that the Helmholtz free energies, entropies, and enthalpies are differentiated stereochemically. We believe that the chiral discrimination reflected by the transition thermodynamics represents the energetics of molecular recognition operating during an equilibrium transition to the more highly ordered crystalline state. Considering the very small differencesin the l l / A isotherms of the monolayers of racemic and enantiomeric STy as spread from solution, the equilibrium spreading pressure and the thermodynamic quantities derived from them strongly suggest that enantiomeric discrimination in this film system is heavily dependent on the presence of the crystalline bulk phase of the surfactant at the surface. The point of similarity between this system and the Nstearoylserine methyl ester system is the necessity of a closely packed state for enantiomeric recognition to be reflected by monolayer physical properties. Mixed chiral monolayers: special systems diferentiated only by symmetry
Given the strong expression of enantiomeric discrimination in monolayers of N-stearoylserine methyl ester, the question arises as to whether this discrimination can be maintained in the presence of other, achiral surfactants
Table 8 Helmholtz free energy, entropy, and internal energy of spreading and of transition for N-stearoyltyrosine on an aqueous subphase of pH = 6.86 at the transition temperature for each film."
bulk -+ film Ib bulk -+ film II' film I + film I1
- 1.40 f 0.07 - 1.50 f 0.07
0.10 f 0.09
-0.22 f 0.04 -0.24 f 0.05 0.02 f 0.01
38 f 6 126 f 7 88 f 9
0 40 6 40 f 6
a Reprinted with permission from Arnett et al., 1990. Copyright 1590 American Chemical Society. bFilm I: T < '7;. 'Film 11: T > 7;.
10.10 f 1.80 36.71 f 2.20 26.26 f 2.80
-0.23 f 0.04 11.93 f 1.80 12.10 f 1.80
P. L. ROSE € T A L .
94
where stereochemical interactions in the film would be -“diluted (Harvey and Arnett, 1989). Accordingly, dilute spreading solutions of SSME were mixed with solutions of simple fatty acids such as stearic or palmitic acid. Figure 24 shows the II/A isotherms of mixed monolayers of palmitic acid and racemic and enantiomeric SSME as a function of composition. At compositions of 16.7% and 33.3% palmitic acid, there is no difference between the compression/expansion isotherms of the racemic and enantiomeric systems, and the films have the I I / A characteristics of a pure palmitic acid film. However, at compositions of 50% SSME and above, the l l / A isotherms of the homochiral and heterochiral systems are significantly different. It is also at the 50% SSME mark that the monolayer stability limits of the mixed films begin to diverge according to stereochemistry (Table 9), with the enantiomeric systems being less stable. The difference in the l l / A properties of these mixed chiral/achiral systems was also observed in the films’ dynamic properties. Figure 25 gives the surface shear viscosities of the palmitic acid/SSME systems at surface pressures of 2.5 and 5.0 dyn cm-’ at 25°C. It is clear that stereo-dependence of film flow
A ’/ molecule Fig. 24 Surface pressure/area isotherms for palmitic acid/stearoylserine methyl ester films at 25°C on a pure water subphase and compressed at 29.8 A2/molecules per minute. A, 16.7-33.3%; B, 50%; C, 66.6%; D, 83.3% SSME.
95
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
Table 9 Monolayer stability limits of palmitic acid/stearoylserine methyl ester films at 25°C. Stability limit/dyn cm Monolayer composition (palmitic acid/SSME)
( R ) - (- 1 or ( S ) - ( + 1
( R , S ) - (f 1
----
--20.0 --15.0 15.0 2.0 1.0 Unstable at all ll
20.0 15.0 15.0
100% palmitic acid 5/1 (16.7% SSME) 2/1 (33.3% SSME) l / l (50.00/, SSME) 1/2 (66.6% SSME) 1/5 (83.3% SSME) 100% SSME
~
10.0 8.5 6.0 2.5
Unstable at all ll
I
25-
I I
20-
I
15-
0
I
I
/
a
D
4
o
m
a
0
1
a
l
%ssME
0
2
0
4
0
m
m
1
a
O
%ssME
Fig. 25 Surface shear viscosity us. film composition for the palmitic acid/stearoylserine methyl ester film system at 25°C.
96
P. L. ROSE E T A L .
properties occurs at compositions greater than 50% SSME, with the enantiomeric systems being much more resistant to flow than the racemic. As in the case of the pure SSME films, the lower stabilities and greater viscosities of the enantiomeric films indicate a higher degree of aggregation than in the more stable, fluid racemic monolayers. The question remains as to whether the mechanism of enantiomeric recognition is a collapse back to a surface quasi-crystalline state, even in the presence of the achiral diluent. Enantiomeric discrimination and its relation to film component reorganization upon compression can also be observed in dynamic surface tension hysteresis loops. Figure 26 shows the l l / A isotherms generated upon five successive compression/expansion cycles (from ll = 0 to 10 dyn cm- ) of racemic and enantiomeric films containing 17 mole percent palmitic acid. The hysteresis loops, obtained on the apparatus described in Section 2 (p. 63), show that the first compression/expansion cycle of the racemic system is repeated in each successive cycle. Upon expansion of the film from the maximum surface pressure back to 0 dyn cm-', the racemic film returns to its original state without detectable reorganization of the components. However, the
A 1.09 midcycle 75.2 AZ/molecule/min
. x
W
E
30
m
al
A2tm01em1.e
B
-
10
1.09 midcycle 7 1.6 A2/molecule/min
I
i s
x n
2
0
25
Az/molecule Fig. 26 Hysteresis isotherms for the 1/5 palmitic acid/(A) racemic and ( B ) enantiomeric stearoylserine methyl ester ( 17% palmitic acid) monolayer system at 25°C. Arrows indicate direction of expansion and compression. Reprinted with permission from Arnett et al., 1989. Copyright 1989 American Chemical Society.
97
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
enantiomeric system apparently reorganizes significantly from its original expanded state, as indicated by the large hysteresis loop, to a more condensed state as exemplified by the subsequent, smaller hysteresis loops. This observation is consistent with the lower monolayer stability limits of the homochiral films, their higher surface shear viscosities, and their lower ESP values. In order to test the mechanism of recognition, equilibrium spreading pressures of both racemic and enantiomeric forms of SSME were obtained in pre-spread films of palmitic acid/SSME mixtures. The films were spread from solution and then compressed to their lift-off areas. A crystal of the racemic SSME was placed on surface film mixtures of the fatty acid with racemic SSME, and the enantiomeric crystals were placed on surface film mixtures of the fatty acid and enantiomeric SSME. The results of the equilibrations are given in Fig. 27. As on pure water substrates, the enantiomeric crystals of SSME did not spread on the enantiomeric SSME/palmitic acid monolayer-covered surfaces, while the spreading of the racemic crystals on the racemic film-covered water was actually enhanced. The palmitic acid crystals deposited on either racemic or enantiomeric film covered substrates spread to the same surface pressure, independent of stereochemistry. When treated by the modified Gibbs phase rule (Crisp, 1949; Defay, 1932), these results suggest that at equilibrium, the enantiomeric monolayer system
- - -5~,,--4- _.
-
-p- 4- - 4
b) R,SW
i
I
?
8
3
a)
R O or S(+)
,+.- .-. - .1 ,
'
I
'
.-.I
'
I
-
_.+
-Q
' . '
98
P. L. ROSE E T A L .
consists of three phases: bulk crystalline SSME enantiomer, palmitic acid monolayer domains, and enantiomeric SSME monolayer domains. This situation appears to occur at every monolayer composition, and suggests that the considerably higher monolayer stability limits of the spread enantiomeric films reflect a metastability of the multicomponent film at surface pressures above the ESP. It is therefore reasonable to assume that the reorganization of the monolayer at surface pressures above the stability limit is most probably due to a squeezing out of the less stable enantiomeric SSME component. Conversely, the racemic film system appears to be “solubilized” by the achiral fatty acid component. At compositions of 10-33% palmitic acid, the ESP of the racemic system varies linearly with film composition, indicating that the monolayer in equilibrium with the racemic crystal is a homogeneous mixture of racemic SSME and palmitic acid. At compositions of less than 33% palmitic acid, the ESP is constant, indicating that three phases consisting of palmitic acid monolayer domains, racemic SSME monolayer domains, and racemic SSME crystals exist in equilibrium at the surface. This last result is consonant with the observation that enantiomeric discrimination as reflected by the l l / A isotherms is not observed until the composition reaches greater than 33% palmitic acid. On statistical average, the 33% achiral fatty acid mark is the lowest palmitic acid composition at which each chiral headgroup in the mixed film can be surrounded completely by six neighboring achiral carboxylatc headgroups, effectively blocking the communication of shape-specific packing from one chiral center to another. It is therefore not surprising that there is a first-order transition in the ESP versus composition diagram for the racemic film system, and that this occurs at a composition of 33% palmitic acid. All of the experiments in pure and mixed SSME systems, as well as in the N-stearoyltyrosine systems, have one common feature, which seems characteristic of chiral molecular recognition in enantiomeric systems and their mixtures: enantiomeric discrimination as reflected by monolayer dynamic and equilibrium properties has only been detected when either the racemic or enantiomeric systems have reverted to a tightly packed, presumably quasi-crystalline surface state. Thus far it has not been possible to detect clear enantiomeric discrimination in any fluid or gaseous monolayer state. Following the successful examination of stearoylserine methyl ester monolayers by a variety of techniques, a detailed study of the effects of several subtle changes in the headgroup has been performed by Heath (1991; Heath and Arnett, 1992). Figure 28 compares the structural variations as the hydroxyl group of SSME is replaced by a thiol in stearoylcysteine methyl ester (SCME);two SCME chains are linked through their sulfurs to produce
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
Stearoylserine Methyl Esters (SSME)
Y C O C 17Hz
NHCOCI7H3, I
c s
C R
H,COOC* ~'CH,OH H
HOH2Cf H'COOCH,
L-SSME
D-SSME
Stearoylcysteine Methyl Esters (SCME) NHCOCI7H,,
YCOC17H35
I
C S
C R H , C O O C ~H ~'CH,SH
HSH,C~~'COOCH,
LSCME
D-SCME
Dilauroylcystine Dimethyl Esters (DLCDME)
NHCOCI~HB I YCOCliH,, C R C R H,COOC':'CH,S SH,C'~'H H COOCH,
-
~COCiiHz,
yCOCilH23
cs
c s
H'~'CH,S-SH,C'~'COOCH, EOOCHR H
L-DLCDME
D-DLCDME
YCOCiiHz,
FcoC1lH23
C R
C S
H,COOC*~'CH,S-SH,C'~'COOCH, H
H
meso-DLCDME
Stearoylthreonine Methyl Esters (STME) H3COOC,y
NHCOC 17H,
H,,C~,OCHN,H/COOCH,
c'2
C
c 3
c
I
HO'~\CH,
LSTME (2S.3R) H3COOC,!,NHCOC,,H,
I C
H,C$' OH
Lallo-STME (2S,3S)
I
H,C'~\OH D-STME (2R,3S)
H,CI,0CHN,~/COOCH3 C I C HO'~'CH~
D-allo-STME (2R,3R)
Fig. 28 Structural comparisons of chiral surfactants.
99
100
P. L. ROSE € T A L .
diastereomeric ( + )- and ( - )-dilauroylcystine dimethyl esters (DLCDME) and a methyl group is attached to the hydroxyl-bearing carbon in SSME to produce the bulkier stearoylthreonine methyl esters (STME) and the ( + )- and ( - )-do-stearoylthreonine methyl esters [( + )- and ( - ) - d o STME]. Figures 19 (SSME), 29 (SCME), 30 (STME), and 31 (DLCDME) compare the effects of these changes, all of which are significant except that the normal and allo isomers of STME are indistinguishable. The figures speak for themselves in representing the effects of these changes in headgroup structure and temperature on the energetics of compression and phase changes with kinetic effects for relaxation in hysteresis. Melting point versus composition diagrams for the four sets of compounds showed racemate formation that was echoed in plots of the monolayer phase transitions points versus enantiomeric composition. Similar analysis of the lift-off areas versus composition for mixed monolayers of many combinations of the four systems showed great sensitivity to headgroup functionality and stereochemistry. Even the differences between combinations of normal and do-STME were defined clearly. Comparison of these many results indicates that the principal locus of stereoselectivity in the packing of these films lies in the stereoche-nical arrangements around the carbon between the ester and amide functions. The importance of the hydroxyl group of SSME, presumably through its interaction with the aqueous subphase, is clearly evident.
AZ/mOleeule
Fig. 29 Surface pressure/area isotherms for compression and expansion of enantiomeric (dashed line) and racemic (solid line) stearoylcysteine methyl esters (SCME) on an aqueous subphase at various temperatures. Arrows indicate the direction of compression and expansion.
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
101
Fig. 30 Surface pressure/area isotherms for compression and expansion of enantiomeric (dashed line) and racemic (solid line) stearoylthreonine methyl esters (STME) on an aqueous subphase at various temperatures. Arrows indicate the direction of compression and expansion.
Fig. 31 Surface pressure/area isotherms for compression and expansion of (A) enantiomeric (dashed line) and racemic (solid line) lauroylcysteine methyl esters and (B) enantiomeric (dashed line) and meso (solid line) dilauroylcystine esters at 25°C. Arrows indicate the direction of compression and expansion.
102
P. L. ROSE H A L .
DIASTEREOMERIC SYSTEMS
Interactions between chemically distinct chiral species that are not enantiomers may be treated by a parity relationship analogous to that for enantiomers. Interactions between two different sets of antipodes, R or S and R' or S', are related by (16). These interacting pairs may be regarded as
homochiral (S-S', R - R ' ) or heterochiral (R-S', S-R') diastereomeric complexes. The equation holds for interactions between any dissimilar chiral molecules, whether they are diastereomeric or non-isomeric [or, in Craig's terminology (Craig and Mellor, 1975), chirodiastaltic] pairs. This rule is the basis for the resolution of enantiomeric mixtures by chiral resolving agents, as was first demonstrated by Pasteur's (1848) resolution of sodium ammonium tartrate with ( - )-cinchonhe. The energetics of chiral aggregation have been approached by calorimetry. Diastereomeric discrimination in the energetics of chiral ion aggregation has been demonstrated by Arnett and Zingg (1981). Heats of neutralization for ephedrine and pseudoephedrine with mandelic acid were obtained in dimethyl sulfoxide, dioxane and water. They showed clear differences in the energetics of ephedrinium mandelate and pseudoephedrine mandelate salt formation. The structures of these salts were confirmed by high-field nmr spectroscopy and X-ray crystallography. Calorimetric techniques related the structural differences to thermochemical terms (Zingg et al., 1988). Examples of diastereomeric complex formation between chiral solutes in achiral solvents abound, and have been reviewed elsewhere (Zingg, 1981). Diastereomeric complex formation is also used as the model for the stereoselectivity of chiral chromatography ( Pirkle and Pochapsky, 1987). Much less often examined are the interactions in neat chiral media into which another chiral species is introduced. In principle, interactions of the enantiomeric forms of an asymmetric molecule with an asymmetric environment or medium must be different (Craig and Mellor, 1975). If the differences in the physicochemical properties of the pure chiral components of the system are sufficiently large then chiral discrimination may be detected more easily than is the case in enantiomeric systems. If the components do not interact ideally then the properties of the mixture may reflect stereochemically dependent deviations from ideality. When the two components do not interact homogeneously, any chiral recognition effects must arise from interfacial interactions, and may therefore be more difficult to detect. Reports of differences in I I / A properties of monolayers cast from diastereomers are few. Stallberg-Stenhagen and Stenhagen ( 1951) reported
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
103
differences in the n/A properties of the diastereomers of 7-keto-acids of ( )-2(~ ) - 9 -L( or D)-dimethyltetracosanoic acid, although they questioned the purity of their materials. However, their experiments compared monolayer properties of individual diastereomeric surfactants with each other rather than mixtures of two different optically active surfactants. Lundquist, in her quasi-racemic’ monomolecular film experiments, demonstrated differences in the force-area characteristics for mixed films of S-( )-Ztetracosanyl acetate and methyl esters of R-( - )- or S-( + )-2-methylhexacosanoic acid (Lundquist, 1965). Malcolm ( 1973, 1975) reported possible observable differences between the pressure-area curves of poly( L-alanine) mixed with poly( D-a-amino-nbutyric acid) and the corresponding mixture containing poly( D-alanine). Shafer (1974) observed differences in the film pressure between ( R ) phosphatidyl serine with poly-L-lysine and the corresponding film with poly-D-lysine injected under the film. It is evident then that good precedent exists for detection of diastereomeric discrimination in monolayer films at the air/water interface. The method of quasi-racemates has been considered as a means of examining steric factors in living systems (Fredga, 1944). Lundquist recognized its potential for testing the arrangement of asymmetric molecules in monolayers in view of the loosely packed ordering which has been proposed for them. Our interest was aroused in the further application of the method of quasi-racemates to chiral monolayers because of its potential for establishing the configuration of very small quantities of biomolecules. The methyl esters of stearoylalanine [ 11 and stearoylserine [2] were considered as quasi-racemate candidates because of their slight structural differences. No quasi-racemate behavior was observed, however, in their force-area isotherms although clear diastereomeric discrimination was seen for this combination (Verbiar, 1983). We have seen no indication of quasi-racemate behavior for any other mixed chiral monolayers.
+
+
0
H3C0,C
I
II C17H35-C-N-C-CH3 I
H R-( -)-
H
H 3C-C-N-C-C
i 1
7H35
I
H
s-(+ )-
A quasi-racemate is a molecular compound that is related to a true racemic compound by a small structural change in one of the enantiomers (Fredga, 1944).
P. L. ROSE € T A L
104
0
II TOzCH3 C1,H3,-C-N-C-CHzOH I
H,CO,C
I
HOHzC-C-N-C-C17H35
I
H
H
C2I
R-( - )-
s-(+)-
Mixtures of N- (a-methylbenzyl) stearamide and difeerent esters of stearoylamino acids
When compressed to surface pressures greater than their stability limits (see Table lo), diastereomeric mixtures of N-(a-methylbenzy1)stearamides with both stearoylalanine and stearoylserine methyl esters provided clear evidence of chiral discrimination. Force-area isotherms at 35"C'for homochiral and heterochiral pairs of N - ( a-methylbenzy1)stearamide and stearoylalanine methyl ester show differences in both their lift-off and touchdown (the area per molecule where the surface pressure returns to zero on the expansion arm of the isotherm) areas per molecule (Fig. 32). In addition, monolayers of the heterochiral pair could be compressed to lower areas per molecule than monolayers of the homochiral pair. Heterochiral mixtures of N - ( a-methylbenzyl)stearamide and stearoylserine methyl ester show a collapse of the film at 20 &/molecule to some unstable state (Fig. 33). The homochiral mixture can be compressed to a higher
-
Table 10 Stability limits for diastereomeric monolayers cast from heterochiral (R-S', S-R) and homochiral ( S - S ' , R - R ) surfactant pairs. Diastereomeric monolayers"
+ +
Stearoylalanine methyl ester N - ( a-methylbenzy1)stearamide Stearoylalanine methyl ester stearoylserine methyl ester Stearoylserine methyl ester + N - ( wmethy1benzyl)stearamide Stearoyltyrosine methyl ester + N - ( CI -methylbenzyl)stearamide Stearoyltryptophan methyl ester N - ( a-methylbenzy1)stearamide
+
Combination
Stabilityb
Heterochiral Homochiral Heterochiral Homochiral Heterochiral Homochiral Heterochiral Homochiral Hzterochiral Homochiral
Unstable' Unstable Stable to 4 Unstable Stable to 15 Stable to 9 Stable to > I 0 Stable to >10 Stable to > 11 Stable to > 11
"Compression rates were 7.1 A2/molecule per minute. bValuesin dyn cm-I. 'Greater than one dyn cm-' min-' decrease in surface pressure even at low pressure.
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
105
A-; a
0
10
P
m
W
--- - B’)
1
m
A%noMe
Fig. 32 Surface pressure/area isotherms for the compression/expansion cycles of diastereomeric monolayers of ( R or S ) - N - (a-methylbenzy1)stearamidesmixed 1 : 1 with (R’ or S’)-stearoylalanine methyl esters on a pure water subphase at 35°C. Dashed lines denote heterochiral pairs ( R :S’ or R ‘ : S )and solid lines denote homochiral pairs (R:R’ or S:S’).
Fig. 33 Surface pressure/area isotherms for the compression/expansion cycles of diastereomeric monolayers of ( R or S ) - N - (a-methylbenzy1)stearamidesmixed 1 : 1 with (R’ or S’) stearoylserine methyl esters on a pure water subphase at 35°C. Dashed lines denote heterochiral pairs (R:S’or R ’ : S )and solid lines denote homochiral pairs ( R : R ‘ or S:S’).
pressure than the corresponding heterochiral pair before collapsing. It must be noted, however, that the diastereomeric discrimination detected in these systems is not due to stereochemical differences in packing arising from interactions in a stable fluid film. Rather, detectable differences are a reflection of the stereochemistry as it is expressed in the reorganization and collapse
P. L. ROSE €T AL.
106
A
4)-
aE
B 9)-
E
; my
10-
0-
1
m
30
4)
8)
8)
m
1
m
Aymoleeule
Fig. 34 Surface pressure/area isotherms for the compression/expansion cycles of diastereomeric monolayers of N - ( a-methylbenzy1)stearamides mixed 1:1 with ( A ) stearoyltyrosine methyl esters and ( B ) stearoyltryptophan methyl esters on a pure water subphase at 35°C. All isotherms are for R:R' o r S:S' and R:S' or S:R' films.
of the films as they are compressed beyond their stability limits to some metastable or unstable state. Mixtures of N - ( a-methylbenzy1)stearamides with both stearoyltyrosine and stearoyltryptophan methyl esters show no discrimination in their pressure-area relationships at 35"C, regardless of the surface pressure to which the films are compressed (Fig. 34). The n/A curves for homo- and hetero-chiral pairs are exactly coincident. No discrimination in the pressure/area characteristics was seen for diastereomeric monolayer films spread from all possible mixtures of pure racemates ( R - and S - ) and their racemic mixtures ( R - ,S - ) of stearoylalanine, stearoylserine, stearoyltyrosine, and stearoyltryptophan methyl esters. The one exception was heterochiral and homochiral mixtures of stearoylalanine methyl esters and stearoylserine methyl esters at 35°C. The force/area
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
107
Fig. 35 Surface pressure/area isotherms for the compression/expansion cycles of diastereomeric monolayers of ( R or S)-stearoylalanine methyl esters mixed 1 : 1 with (R’ or S’) stearoylserine methyl esters on a pure water subphase at 35°C. Dashed lines denote heterochiral pairs (R:S’ or R ’ : S )and solid lines denote homochiral pairs ( R : R ’ or S:S’). Reprinted with permission from Arnett et al., 1989. Copyright 1989 American Chemical Society.
isotherms are given in Fig. 35. Again, no discrimination is noted until surface pressures are reached which exceed the stability limits of the film (greater than 1 dyn cm-’ min- decrease in surface pressure once the compression is stopped). The film spread from the homochiral pair is unstable at all ll, while that spread from the heterochiral pair is stable to 4 dyn cm-’.
’
Diazene-linked diacids Meso- and ( f )-azobis [6-( 6-cyanododecanoic acid)] were synthesized by Porter et al. (1983) as an amphipathic free radical initiator that could deliver the radical center to a bilayer structure controllably for the study of free radical processes in membranes. The decomposition pathways of the diazenes are illustrated in Fig. 36. When the initiator was decomposed in a DPPC multilamellar vesicle matrix, the diazenes showed stereo-retention yielding unprecedented diastereomeric excesses, as high as 70%, in the recombination of the radicals to form meso- and ( f )-succinodinitriles (Brittain et al., 1984). When the methyl esters of the diazene surfactants were decomposed in a chlorobenzene solution, poor diastereoselectivity was observed, diastereomeric excesses of 2.6% and 7.4% for meso- and ( f )-isomers respectively, which is typical of free radical processes in isotropic media (Greene et al., 1970). Porter et a f .(1986a) found that these surfactants also exhibited significantly enhanced diastereoselectivity when photolyzed alone in a pH 10 buffer
P. L. ROSE E T A L .
108
COOH
<
COOH
>
HOOC
R=H,CH,
Fig. 36 Structure of meso- and ( f)-azobis[6-(6-~yanododecanoicacid)] and their decomposition scheme.
solution. Studying the meso/( ) product ratio for the succinodinitrile recombination products, significant retention of stereochemistry was observed; ( f)-diaxenc resulted in greater ( f)-succinodinitrile product and, likewise, meso-diazene resulted in greater meso-product. At high dilution, well below their CMCs, stereochemical retention was preferred with a ratio of about 3.5:l. Above the CMC, ( f )-diazene exhibited a remarkable 6 : l retention of stereochemistry most likely as a result of the viscous, restricted environment of the micellar matrix. Counterintuitively, meso-diazene showed a decrease in diastereoselectivity, dropping from 3.5: 1 to 2: 1, upon micellization. We were interested in examining the corresponding monolayer photolysis products of the diazenes as a function of surface pressure. This goal was not reached due to our inability to collect enough material from the film balance experiment (typically, 1OI6 molecules per run) for HPLC analysis. However, the physical data acquired by interfacial techniques has given information about the nature of the aggregates and their diastereoselectivity. The meso and ( k )-azobis [6 4 6-cyanododecanoic acid)] provided strong
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
109
Fig. 37 Surface potential versus molecular area plot for monolayers of meso- and ( f )-azobisC6-(6-cyanododecanoic acid)] spread statically on a pH 3 subphase.
evidence of chiral discrimination in every property examined. It was predictable, though, that discrimination resulting from the intramolecular interactions of chiral centers within diastereomeric compounds would be far greater than the discrimination resulting from the looser intermolecular interaction of enantiomers. All of the monolayer data reflected clear and consistent discrimination between properties of the meso- and (+)-films. The meso-films exhibited lower surface potentials, indicating less orientation of their molecular dipoles
(Fig. 37) and lower viscosity, indicating less intermolecular association; they were also more expanded, indicating that their molecules had a greater tendency to spread themselves out over the interface in comparison to the ( f )-diazene (Fig. 38). In fact, the meso-films were so expanded that significant surface pressures were measured with more than 200 A2 available per molecule. Lift-off areas of this magnitude are typical of ionized monolayers which are highly expanded because of the electrostatic repulsions exerted between head groups. The insensitivity of the diazene films to the subphase acidity ruled out the possibility that the difference observed in the degree of expansion of the films was a result of a difference in pK,-values in the meso- and ( k )-monolayer. The higher degree of association of the ( f)-surfactant was also reflected in other aggregated forms. Micellization of the ( f)-diastereomer was more exergonic or, in other words, more spontaneous. Porter et al. (1986a) found correspondingly anomalous behavior in the photolysis of these compounds as presented above. While the physical data describing the aggregate forms are most probably related to the stereochemistry of the aggregates, we have no precedent for the following interpretation.
110
P. L. ROSE ET AL.
--_._ -.
*...
i
. ---_.._
0 J)
I
m
I
9D
I
120
I
160
I
180
I
210
Fig. 38 Surface pressure/area isotherms for the compression/expansion cycles of meso- (dashed line) and ( f)-(solid line) azobis- [6-(6-cyanododecanoic acid)] on a pH 3 subphase at 22°C. Compressed at a rate of 15.5 Az/molecule per minute. Reprinted with permission from Porter et al., 1986a. Copyright 1986 American Chemical Society.
The decomposition of the diazene methyl ester derivatives in chlorobenzene solution resulted in no retention of stereochemistry in the succinodinitrile products. Since under these conditions, the diazenes were probably monomeric rather than aggregated, the inherent electronic properties of the isolated molecules have been excluded as a possible source of the stereochemical retention. When the free acid derivatives of the diazenes were decomposed in chlorobenzene solution, retention was observed. In this non-polar solvent, the diazene diacids were probably aggregated as reversed micelles with their head groups linked by intra- and inter-molecular hydrogen bonding, decreasing the radical centers' opportunity to escape from one another and thereby resulting in more direct recombination of the radicals. In water, decomposition of the free acids at concentrations below the CMCs also led to stereochemical retention in the products. Stereochemical retention under these conditions was most probably due to hydrogen bonding between the diazene head groups as before, and hydrophobic association of the aliphatic chains. These factors would again reduce the mobility of the radicals. Up to this point, we have not had to address the unexpected photolysis behavior of the meso-compound, namely, that the stereochemical retention in the products resulting from the decomposition of this stereoisomer actually decreased at concentrations above the CMC. Intuitively, one would expect that the restricted environment created by micellization of the diazenes would enhance stereochemical retention. The (_+j-diazene behaves as we would have predicted, but the meso-isomer does not. To explain the behavior of the meso- and ( f)-diazenes upon micellization, the differences in the molecular structures and the aggregates they form must both be examined since either (or both) may be responsible for the anomaly.
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
mesa
b
111
‘twisted” mesa C
Fig. 39 Possible conformations of ( & )- and meso-diazenes. Reprinted with permission from Porter et al., 1986a. Copyright 1986 American Chemical Society.
By placing both acid head groups on the same end of the molecule (a requirement for packing the surfactant into a monolayer, bilayer, or a micelle), the diazene moiety of the ( f )-surfactant is constrained to the “S-planar” conformation illustrated in Fig. 39( a). Incidentally, this conformation allows for the maximum anomeric interaction of the diazene lone pair electrons and the adjacent carbon-cyano bond. However, when the meso compound is arranged with both head groups proximately, the diazene moiety adopts the “U-planar” conformation as shown in Fig. 39( b). Alternatively, if the diazene moiety of the meso form remains fixed in the “S-planar” conformation to take advantage of the available anomeric interaction, disposing the head groups to the same end of the molecule would result in the “twisted” meso-conformation depicted in Fig. 39(c). Examining the monolayer data in terms of these models yields two possible, but unresolvable, explanations of the results (Porter et al., 1986a). In one scenario, the monolayer packing differences expressed by their degree of expansion are explained in terms of the symmetry of the diazene moiety. If, in the monolayer, the meso- and ( f )-diazenes adopt the “U-planar” and “S-planar” conformations, respectively, a projection of the ( )-structure parallel to the diacid chains shows nearly perfect C,, symmetry whereas the meso isomer’s projection is dissymmetric. The CZv symmetry of the (-t-)-diazene may allow for extended packing in the monolayer similar to that found in crystalline AIBN (Jaffe et al., 1972). The tight, crystal-like packing available to the ( f )-stereoisomer could result in highly condensed, highly ordered monolayers, which is consistent with the experimental data. By the same reasoning, the dissymmetry of the meso’s “U-planar” conformation would not allow for extended packing and would result in
112
P. L. ROSE ET AL.
more expanded, more disordered monolayers relative to those of the ( f )-isomer.
If, on the other hand, the meso-isomer maintains the anomeric interaction, thereby adopting the “S-planar” conformation, the head groups would be disposed on opposite ends of the molecule. Maintaining this conformation about the diazene fragment while constraining the head groups to the interfacial plane of the monolayer would force the molecule to adopt the “twisted” conformation as the area available per molecule is reduced. This conformation would result only if the gauche interactions created in the chain were energetically less costly than the loss of whatever anomeric interaction exists. The broad, irregular shape of the “twisted” conformer would also be consistent with the highly expanded, disordered films observed. In analyzing these two models, it is also important to note that the anomeric and gauche interactions may trade-off their optimal conformations, resulting in a structure that is some compromise of the two. With either model, though, the retention of stereochemistry may be the result of aggregation forces which reduce the mobility of the radical centers after formation thereby maintaining them in an optimum position to recouple directly after the expulsion of the nitrogen molecule. In the micellar matrix, the ( f)-molecules suffer a dramatic decrease in their mobility, leading to increased stereochemical retention in the photolysis products. Due to the geometric problems involved in packing the meso-molecules into micelles described by either model above, the meso-molecules are less apt to pack tightly and therefore more easily lose their stereochemistry. By these models, the decrease in stereochemistry of the meso-isomer upon micellization reflects a decrease in the aggregation forces experienced by them. Keto-linked diacids Recently, Porter et al. (1986b, 1988) have reported the synthesis of both meso- and (+)-forms of a series of two-chain carbonyl diacids made by joining two pentadecanoic acid units by a carbonyl group at the 3,3‘, 6,6, 9,9‘ and 12,12’ positions, 3,5-didodecyl-4-oxoheptanedioic acid (C- 15:3,3’), 6,8-dinonyl-7-oxotridecanedioicacid (C-15:6,6’), 9,lldihexyl-10-oxononadecanedioic acid (C-15:9,9‘) and 12,14-dipropyl-13oxopentacosanedioic acid ((2-15: 12,127, respectively. The diacids were used to probe further the question of stereochemical preference in two-chain amphiphiles. The method used for examining the diastereomeric preference was equilibration by base-catalyzed epimerization in homogeneous, bilayer and micellar media. This method allows for stereoselection based on hydrophobic/ hydrophilic considerations rather than classic steric size effects. When the diastereomeric diacids were epimerized in aqueous base at 6WC,
113
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
at concentrations above the critical micelle concentration, all of them showed a preference for the meso-form in accordance with predictions from molecular mechanics based on the model compound 2,4-dimethyl-3-pentanone (Cram, 1984). However, epimerization in homogeneous media (e.g., benzene solution, TsOH catalyst) or in water (hydroxide ion catalyst) below the CMC gave 50: 50 mixtures of meso- and ( )-diastereomers. It was thus concluded that hydrophobic forces perturb the equilibrium between diastereomers in favor of the meso-form. We report here a study of these eight diastereomeric compounds as monolayers at the air-water interface, a special set of circumstances representing an extreme of hydrophobic control in which intermolecular and intramolecular forces may be opposed directly. Figures 40-43 compare the position of the bridging carbonyl group in each diastereomeric pair and the effects of stereochemistry on their force-area curves at 25°C.It is clear that there is a large effect of stereochemistry on the energetics of compression and expansion for a wide variety of ketodiacid surfactants; all of the ketodiacids in this study showed a dependence of the shapes of their l 7 / A isotherms on their stereochemistry. Several facts are striking. In every case there is a sharp differentiation between the behavior of films cast from meso- and (*)-isomers. The isotherms for the
*
-
40
-
30
-
c-15:3,3’
I
E
=x
2
20 -
10 -
0 - ,
,
,
,
,
I
I
,
I
I
I
1
A * / molecule Fig. 40 Surface pressure/ area isotherms for the compression and expansion cycles of ( + ) - and rneso-C-15:3,3’ ketodiacids on a pure water subphase at 25°C carried
out at a compression rate of 19.24A2/molecule per minute. Arrows indicate the direction of compression and expansion. Reprinted with permission from Harvey et al., 1988. Copyright 1988 American Chemical Society.
P. L. ROSE ET AL.
114
40
HOOC HOOC
30
C-I5:6.6‘
E
0
h 20 e
F!
e
10
0 C1
u)
40
60
100
80
120
I
I
I
I
140
160
180
200
A*/moIecuIe
Fig. 41 Surface pressure/area isotherms for the compression and expansion cycles of ( * ) - and meso-C-15:6,6 ketodiacids on a pure water subphase at 25°C carried out at a compression rate of 19.24!IZ/molecule per minute. Arrows indicate the direction of compression and expansion. Reprinted with permission from Harvey et al., 1988. Copyright 1988 American Chemical Society.
1
HOOC HOOC-
0 C-15:9,9’
30
-
:
I
x
20-
P e
10 -
0 -0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
200
A2/moIecuIe
Fig. 42 Surface pressure/area isotherms for the compression and expansion cycles of ( + ) - and meso-C-15:9,9’ ketodiacids on a pure water subphase at 25°C carried out at a compression rate of 19.24!12/molecule per minute. Arrows indicate the direction of compression and expansion. Reprinted with permission from Harvey et al., 1988. Copyright 1988 American Chemical Society.
115
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
-
40
-
30
1-
I
r
HOOC
t
-
35
20-
e
I0I
i 7
HOOC meso
C-15: 12,12‘
10 -
020
, 40
I
60
80
100
120
140 160 180 200
I
I
220
240
A*/mo~ecu~e
Fig. 43 Surface pressure/area isotherms for the compression and expansion cycles of ( f )- and meso-C-15:12,12’ ketodiacids on a pure water subphase at 25 “C carried out at a compression rate of 19.24 A/molecule per minute. Arrows indicate direction of compression and expansion. Reprinted with permission from Harvey et al., 1988. Copyright 1988 American Chemical Society.
meso-diastereomers are virtually identical at surface pressures greater than 5 dyn cm- regardless of the position of the carbonyl bridge or the length of the hydrocarbon chains. The limiting molecular area for the meso compounds is in the neighborhood of 60 A2/molecule, and their isotherms are highly reminiscent of the condensed nature of single-chain fatty acids. In contrast, films cast for the ( f )-diacids are more highly expanded films at lower pressures and have collapse pressures that are dependent on the position of the bridging carbonyl group. These results are quite compatible with the preferred conformations of the two-chain carbonyl diacids in aqueous media mentioned above (Porter et al., 1986b, 1988). The meso-compounds’ preferred collinear conformation, which places the hydrogens at the asymmetric carbons in a nearly eclipsed position relative to each other (Fig. 44), is more stable than that of the ( & )-diastereomer by about 1.2 kcal mol- In this conformation, the two carboxylic acid groups at the ends of the chain can be attached to the water surface side-by-side. The entire molecule can then behave as a “goodamphiphile” whose structure is similar to a pair of single-chain fatty acid molecules bound side-by-side, each chain mirroring the other about the molecules’ plane of symmetry.
’,
’.
116
P. L. ROSE E T A L .
-1
compression
HOOb
bOOH
preferred conformation
preferred conformation
HOOC- C
meso
It)
subphase
subphase
O
O
7
mesn
I f )
Fig. 44 Preferred lowest energy conformations of ( f )- and meso-diastereomersand the effect of stereochemistry on the mechanism of film compression. Reprinted with permission from Arnett et al., 1989. Copyright 1989 American Chemical Society.
There is little variation in the shape of the isotherms for a series of meso structural isomers (C-15:3,3’-C-15: 12,12’)upon moving the carbonyl group up the hydrocarbon chain. There is an expansion of the film, as would be expected if the head groups were allowed to drift apart at large areas ( > 240 A’) per molecule. A comparison of the r I / A isotherms for the series of structural isomers shows that the meso-diastereomers become more expanded at low surface pressures as the carbonyl group is moved up the hydrocarbon chain. In contrast to the preferred conformation of the meso-diastereomers, the ( & )-isomers are most stable if the carboxylate head groups are maximally separated with a rather wide range of pseudotorsional angles through which the hydrogens on the carbons carrying the bridging carbonyl group can be twisted until a minimum energy is reached when they are nearly eclipsed (Fig. 44). When one of the ( k )-diacids is spread on an aqueous surface, the carboxylate acid groups are separated from each other and the orientation of the molecule can be compared to a pair of open hedge-clippers resting on the water surface. Since the head groups are separated from one another ,along the axis of the molecule, it takes up more space on the surface and produces a more expanded monolayer, typical of “bolaform” amphiphiles (Furhop and Fritsch, 1986; Furhop et al., 1986; Jeffers and Daen, 1965; Morawetz and Kandaniem, 1966). The steady increase in the area per molecule at low surface pressures for the series of structural isomers correlates with the movement of the position of the carbonyl bridge away from the head groups. The differences in the energetics of compression can be related ultimately
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
117
9)-
I
5 -?
m-
10
-
0 -
I
0
a,
I
e
I 8)
I 8 )
I m
1
I 2
o
I u
o
I m
1
I 8
o
I
m
A?/mOleCUlt?
Fig. 45 Surface pressure/area isotherms for the compression cycle of 12ketooctadecanoic acid (A) and octadecanoic acid ( B ) on a buffered subphase ( A R hydrochloric acid; pH4.0) at 30°C carried out at a compression rate of -2.0-3.0 b;’/molecule per minute.
to the stereochemically dependent intramolecular conformation of the isomers at the air-water interface. During the compression cycle for rneso-isomers, work must be done on the system to raise the hydrocarbon portion of the molecule out of the water surface until the hydrocarbon chains are normal to the water surface. Since there is an absence of a plateau region or any apparent resistance to compression, other than raising the hydrocarbon tail out of the surface, in the I I / A isotherm for all meso-diastereomers, it can be inferred that the carbonyl linkage group has only a small interaction with the water subphase. This is in contrast to the I I / A isotherm shown in Fig. 45, where a carbonyl group on a monosubstituted single-chain fatty acid adds a large energetic contribution to the work of compression necessary for raising the hydrocarbon chain out of the water surface (Nagaranjan and Shah, 1981). During the compression cycle of the ( f)-isomers, the surface area is reduced and the carboxylate groups are forced together in the plane of the water interface. The chains are gradually forced together until they are side-by-side (Fig. 44), an arrangement similar to that proposed for the rneso-diacid under similar compression. However, for the ( f)-acids, in addition to the work necessary to raise the hydrocarbon chains from the surface, additional work must be done against intramolecular conformational forces resulting in chains which are collinear and normal to the water surface.
118
P. L. ROSE €T AL.
Table 11 Work ofcompression of the C-15:3,3', C-15:6,6, C-15:9,9', and C-15: 1 2 3 ' ketodiacids on a pure water subphase at 25°C compressed at a rate of 19.24 A2/molecule per minute. Work of compression"/cal mol-' Monolayer
C-15: 3,3' C-l5:6,6' C-15:9,9' C-15: 12,12'
n / d y n cm-'
15.0 15.0 15.0 15.0
meso
78.89 f 3.41 157.83 3.90 245.17 f 7.50 460.94 f 16.48
(f) 166.95 f 5.65 333.80 f 21.00 857.64 f 21.40 1493.79 f 67.94
( f)-meso
88.06 f 6.60 175.97 f 21.36 612.47 f 22.68 1032.85 f 69.91
'Work of compression calculated from the equation W=
:j n
dA,
where A , and A, are the initial and final areas per molecule, respectively.
This additional work of compression has been calculated from the differences in the I I / A isotherms to be 15dyncm-' (see Table 11). The further apart the carboxylate groups are to begin with, the greater is this n/A work and the greater the integrated area under the curve. It must be kept in mind that the ( f )-diastereomer is a mixture of enantiomers that were not separable by reverse phase HPLC. Since the method for separation of ( f)- and meso-diastereomers (reverse phase HPLC, C- 18 column) is based on the difference in conformation between isomers (related ultimately to their differential attraction to the column), it is unlikely that the two enantiomers of the ( f)-diastereomer have different conformations at the air-water interface. It is not known, however, how the energetics of compression and expansion will differ for films cast from either R,R or S,S enantiomer from those cast from the racemic mixture. Table 12 shows the equilibrium spreading pressures of each diacid. It is immediately apparent that for three of the diastereomeric pairs there are statistically significant differences. These distinctions relate stereochemical preferences in the spontaneous spreading of ( f )- versus meso-monolayers in equilibrium with their respective crystalline phases. However, there appears to be no discernible trend in either the ( f)- or meso-ESPs as a function of carbonyl position despite clear trends seen in their monolayer properties in the absence of any bulk crystalline phase. It is readily apparent that the (f)-C-15:6,6, C-15:9,9' and C-15:12,12' compounds show a collapse to some three-dimensional state, as has been observed for most over-compressed lipid films (Handa and Nagaki, 1979; Stewart and Arnett, 1982). However, the ensuing plateau region is
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
119
Table 12 Equilibrium spreading pressures of the C-15:3,3’, C-15:6,6’, C-15:9,9’, and C-15: 12,12’ ketodiacids on a pure water subphase at 25°C.
Monolayer
meso
C-15: 3,3‘ C-15:6,6’ C- 15 9,9’ C-15:12,12
15.48 f 0.84 17.90 0.84 16.75 f 1.43 3.45 f 0.43
(f) 0.97 _+ 1.36 12.93 f 0.76 20.73 f 3.82 10.45 f 0.56
extraordinarily stable. No change in surface pressure is seen even when compression is halted for several hours. In accordance with the twodimensional phase rule of Defay (1932) and Crisp (1949), this indicates that there are two phases in equilibrium. The most likely composition is one of monolayer and three-dimensional aggregates. Compression in the plateau region below the limiting molecular area of the collinear molecule does not result in increased surface pressure. The exact nature of the collapsed phases in this plateau region is not clear.
Surface viscosities. In view of the dramatic expression of the stereochemically directed conformation on rI/A curves, it seems reasonable to ask if corresponding differences in surface viscosities may be found. Variations in surface pressure as a function of molecular area must be a result of confounding intramolecular conformation and intermolecular interactions between molecules as they lie in the surface and are gradually compressed. Rheological properties such as the surface viscosity might reasonably show considerable differences depending on the stereochemistry of the diacid and the surface pressure. Table 13 presents all the surface shear viscosity data that could be measured. Several trends may be perceived in the data. As the surface pressure is increased, the surface viscosities increase. This is not surprising owing to increased intermolecular chain-chain contact at higher surface pressures. There are differences between meso- and ( f )-isomers for all measurable pairs of diastereomers, albeit small for 6,6- and 9,9‘diastereomers and negligible for 3,3’-diastereomers. However, if the precise thermodynamic state of the film is considered, i.e., surface pressure/area relationships, then significant differences in the free energies of activation to flow are seen (Table 13). Free energies of activation to flow increase as the carbonyl group is moved up the hydrocarbon chain. This may relate to the increased ability for intercalation of the molecules as they sit at the water surface. We saw previously that movement of the carbonyl linkage up the hydrocarbon chain
120
P. L. ROSE H A L .
Table 13 Rheological properties of diastereomeric films at various surface pressures n.'
Surface shear viscosity qs/ milli surface poise Monolayer
C-15: 3,3'
C- 15: 6,6'
C- 15:9,9'
C-15: 12,12'
ll/dyn cm-'
2.5 5.0 7.5 10.0 12.5 15.0 2.5 5.0 7.5 10.0 12.5 15.0 2.5 5.0 7.5 10.0 12.5 15.0 2.5 5.0 7.5 10.0 12.5 15.0
meso
0.70 f 0.06 0.83 f 0.08 0.78 f 0.03 0.80 f 0.04 0.78 f 0.03
(f) 0.66 f 0.03 0.84 f 0.04 0.83 f 0.03 0.79 0.05 0.80 f 0.05
C
C
0.69 f 0.03 0.68 f 0.02 0.70 f 0.02 0.82 f 0.01
0.70 0.03 0.75 f 0.03 0.88 f 0.03 0.93 f 0.03
d
d
d
d
1.19 f 0.13 1.06 f 0.11 0.93 f 0.08 0.85 0.02 0.90 f 0.03 0.91 f 0.01
0.96 f 0.06 0.92 f 0.03 0.97 f 0.02 1.00 f 0.03 1.13 f 0.10 1.18 f 0.02 1.07 f 0.11 0.70 f 0.03 0.86 f 0.07 0.95 f 0.04 1.09 f 0.05 1.29 f 0.05
b b b b b b
AAGi,,,b/cal mol ( f)-meso 208 f 74 243 f 76 254 f 44 199 f 59 210 f 55 181 f 48 182 f 39 238 f 41 136 f 38 361 f 87 322 f 74 402 f 32 346 f 57 354 f 64 271 f 39
Reprinted with permission from Harvey et al., 1988. Copyright 1988 American Chemical Society. Free energies of activation for viscous flow, AGj,,,, calculated from surface viscosities qs. 'These films were too unstable to allow viscosity measurements. These films flowed too fast for accurate viscosity measurements.
a
resulted in expanded monolayer films. The expanded nature of the film may then allow for greater entanglement as measured by the free energies of activation to viscous flow. Furthermore, for all diacid pairs the ( k )-isomer has a higher AGf,,, than its corresponding meso-isomer. On the basis of previous arguments, it is reasonable to relate this difference to the stereochemically dependent conformation at the air-water interface, which in some manner leads to different degrees of intermolecular entanglement. These four pairs of diastereomeric two-chain surfactants provide an unprecedented opportunity to compare the effects of stereochemistry on
121
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
intramolecular interactions in monolayers. The monolayer films showed divergent behavior as a function of the stereochemistry at the chiral centers. The energetics of compression for meso-diastereomers were reminiscent of two single-chain fatty acids joined together. The extra work required to bring the stereochemically directed chains of the ( f )-isomer into a standing position reflect their preferred orientation. Rheological data show that definite differences exist in the resistance of the films to flow as a function of stereochemistry. These differences reflect the conformations of ( * ) - and meso-isomers as they sit at the air-water interface. What is much harder to elucidate is the effect of stereochemistry on intermolecular interactions. How does changing the stereochemistry at one chiral center affect interactions between diastereomers? Ab initio molecular orbital calculations have been used to address the problem of separating stereochemically dependent inter- and intra-molecular interactions in diastereomeric compounds (Craig et al., 1971). For example, diastereomeric compounds such as 2,3-dicyanobutane exhibit significant energetic dependence on intramolecular configuration about their chiral centers. So far, however, little experimental attention has been focused on this problem. Separation of intermolecular interactions. The keto-linked diastereomeric surfactants present a novel opportunity to compare not only the effect of stereochemistry on intermolecular interactions, but also the effect of carbonyl linkage position and overall fatty acid chain length. It is reasonable to assume that chiral discrimination exists between diastereomers in these monolayers as has been shown for several enantiomeric systems (Stewart and Arnett, 1982; Arnett et al., 1982); the problem is to separate these effects from the intramolecular contributions to film compression energetics. Accordingly, we have undertaken a Goodrich analysis of the excess free energy of mixing of mixtures of C-15:6,6’ and C-15:9,9 (p. 112), and two analogous diacid diastereomeric pairs constructed from chains of 12 and 18 carbons, 6,8-dihexyl-7-oxotridecanedioic (C-12: 6,6) and 6,8-didodecyl-7oxotridecanedioic acids (C-18:6,6). Goodrich’s original derivation and treatment for obtaining excess free energies of mixing utilizes the differences between the free energies of compression of the pure film components and their mixtures from n 0 to some specified pressure as expressed by ( 17).
-
n AGgisi, = Jn-o
(A1.2
- NlAl - NA2)
(17)
Excess free energies of mixing can be used to separate the contributions of stereochemistry to intermolecular interactions from their contributions to
122
P. L. ROSE €T A L .
intramolecular interactions. If one knows the role that stereochemistry plays in mesolmeso-interactions (which can be deduced easily from the appropriate surface pressure uersus area isotherm), and one knows the role that stereochemistry plays in ( )/( f)-interactions, then one can mix meso- and ( *)-isomers in a monolayer film and separate out the contribution of mesolmeso interactions, N , A , , and ( f)/( 5 )-interactions, N,A,, from ( f )/meso-interactions, A , , , . One is then left with a property AGZix, which can be used to determine what effect, if any, stereochemistry has on intermolecular interactions. The inherent assumptions of this method have been detailed in Section 2 (p. 67). The treatment given here has accounted for these where possible and is based for the most part on the basic assumptions of Goodrich ( 1957). Figures 46 and 47 show the effect of successive incorporation of meso-diastereomer on the phase transition characteristic of the ( f )-isomer; as the concentration of meso-isomer increases, the phase transition surface pressure IT occurs at higher n. The same'result was found (Arnett et al., 1988b) for mixtures of (f)-and meso-C-15:6,6' and C-15:9,9', which are not shown here. According to the surface phase rule, this is indicative of
4)-
C-lZP,6
D
-
10
a -
t
o
I
rn
1
41
I
m
I
m
I
m
I
m
1
140
I
160
I
180
I
am
Fig. 46 Surface pressure/area isotherms for the compression cycles of ( + ) - and rneso-C-12:6,6 ketodiacids and their mixtures on a pure water subphase at 25°C carried out at a compression rate of 19.24 A2/molecule per minute: A, 0% ( f ) (or 100% meso); B, 25% ( f); C, 50% ( f); D, 75% ( f ); E = 100% ( f). Reprinted with permission from Arnett et al., 1988b.Copyright 1988 American Chemical Society.
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
123
Fig. 47 Surface pressure/area isotherms for the compression cycles of ( f ) - and meso-C-18:6,6 ketodiacids and their mixtures on a pure water subphase at 25°C carried out at a compression rate of 19.24Az/molecule per minute: A, 0% ( f ) (or 100% meso); B, 25% ( f); C, 50% (k); D, 75% ( f); E, 100% ( f ). Reprinted with permission from Arnett et al., 1988b. Copyright 1988 American Chemical Society.
mixing between the ( + ) - and meso-components at ll > II‘ (Crisp, 1949; Defay, 1932). The additive area relationship was used to monitor the mixing of ( f )/meso-surfactants below the phase change. Nonideal miscibility was seen for all sets of surfactants at the lower surface pressures, assuming a more ideal (or conversely, segregated) matrix at 15.0 dyn cm- (Arnett et al., 1988b). Coupled with the change in IT with varying meso-composition, we conclude that ( )/meso-diastereomers form nonideal mixtures for all four sets (C-12:6,6‘, C-15:6,6’, C-18:6,6‘ and C-15:9,9’). Since it has been shown that nonideal mixing occurs in the 2.5- 15.0 dyn cmrange, the excess free energies of interaction were calculated for compressions of each pure component and their mixtures to each of these surface pressures. In addition, these surface pressures are below the ESPs and/or monolayer stability limits so that dynamic processes arising from reorganization, relaxation, or film loss do not contribute significantly to the work of compression. The fact that the (*)-diastereomer is a mixture of enantiomers will have no effect on the interactions of meso- and ( f )-isomers. The interaction between diastereomers may be conceptualized easily in the symmetry
+
124
P. L. ROSE €T AL.
relationship ( 18), where R,R and S,S configurations are represented in the R,R-R,R
= S,S-S,S
# R,S-S,R = S,R-R,S
(18)
( f)-diastereomer and R,S and S,R in the meso-isomer. Since the meso-isomer
has a plane of symmetry (R,S and S,R will be indistinguishable), R,R-R,S interactions will be the same as S,S- R,S interactions. However, there will be an inherent R In 2 difference in the entropy of mixing for pure ( f )- and pure meso-compounds in a monolayer since the ( f )-compound is composed of two enantiomers. Assuming that the individual enantiomers in the ( f)-film mix ideally, the entropy of mixing is given by ASmix= - R( N R , RIn N R , R+ Ns,s In N s , s ) per mole (that is, for the racemate, where Ns,s = N R , R= 0.5, ASmix= R In 2). Parts (a)-(d) of Fig. 48 give the excess free energies of mixing for all four sets of diastereomers. The highly expanded C-12:6,6 and C-l5:9,9’ films show marked deviation from ideality (AG”‘ # 0) upon compression to 10.0 and 15.0 dyn cm- indicating a dependence of packing on stereochemistry as the film is compressed. Conversely, the C-15:6,6’ and C-18 :6,6 systems show no deviation from ideality at every surface pressure across the entire composition range. Stereochemistry appears to play little or no role in the molecular interactions between ( f )- and meso-isomers for these films or are compensating each other. These differences in AGxs can be interpreted on the basis of molecular properties by an analogy to a pair of ordinary hedge-clippers. Consider each molecule to be divided above and below the carbonyl linkage. The head-group section below the linkage group is represented by the “blades” of the hedge-clipper and the hydrocarbon tails above the linkage groups are represented by the “handles” of the hedge-clipper. The linkage carbonyl group can then be considered as the “bolt” holding everything together (Fig. 49). The meso-diastereomer is then the ordinary hedge-clipper with its plane of symmetry bisecting the bolt. If one blade and handle section trade positions about the bolt, the hedge-clippers represent the ( f )-diastereomer. One may vary molecular properties by changing the position of the carbonyl linkage, the overall length of the fatty acid units and the stereochemistry of the carbonyl bolt. These compounds then present a unique set in which all three variables are presented: (i) The case where the blade lengths are kept constant and the handle lengths are varied is represented by the C-12, C-15, and C-18 diastereomers linked at the 6,6 positions. Of this set, the short-handled C-12 system is the only one that shows excess free energies of mixing.
’,
(ii) The case of varying blade length with constant handle length is represented by the C-12:6,6’ and C-15:9,9’ systems. Both of these
125
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
300
300
r
I
I
-g -
200
p
100
.-P .E r r
0
0
-
?m .-.-x
u-
-100
O
2
3
-200
300
-
5
?m
-100-
3
-200-
::
.-
.5
5
2.5,5.0, 10.0,15.0
O
z
2.5.5.0,10.0,15.0
-2001
.
1
.
1
-
1
300
I
,;,---r---i---i---.*
u-
--d
;200 -
r
-t! m 100-
;.
-100-
-300
200 -; m .-
: --- 4--- t--- r
0,
0
1 -300
I
loo-
I
: m
-
-; 2oo-
c
vO
0 U
100 0
-100
3 -200
0
-300
W 1
.
1
.
1
.
1
-300
systems have significant deviation from ideal mixing thermodynamics. The C-12:6,6 films are more highly expanded- than those of the C-15:9,9. We saw earlier that moving the carbonyl linkage (bolt) up the hydrocarbon chain for the case of the C-15 diastereomers increases the head-group-to-head-group distance, resulting in expansion of the monolayer films and increased energetics of film compression (Harvey et al., 1988). Here, C-12:6,6, having a shorter carboxylate/carbonyl distance, forms a more expanded film, indicating a large handle contribution to film compression energetics.
126
P. L. ROSE € T A L .
meso
0
0
0 ’bolt”
Fig. 49 Schematic representation of stereochemically dependent conformations for
( & ) - and meso-C-15:9,9’ ketodiacids at the air-water interface. The portion of the
molecule most affecting intermolecular interactions is in brackets. Reprinted with permission from Arnett et al., 1988b.Copyright 1988 American Chemical Society.
(iii) The case of overall clipper size remaining constant and varying the position of the bolt is represented by the C-15:6,6 and C-15:9,9’ systems. This variation results in a change of both blade and handle length. Both systems show an effect of stereochemistry on intermolecular interactions. It must be kept in mind that the Goodrich treatment separates out contributions to intermolecular interactions that arise from film expansion. The differences in film expansion are a reflection of conformation and are accounted for in the pure meso- and (k)-films. However, since ( f )- and rneso-film components do interact, the intramolecular contribution to film compression may be altered. This effect would arise from conformational perturbations as molecules interact, thereby precluding complete separation of inter- and intra-molecular contributions to the thermodynamics of compression. However, these complicating factors can be mitigated by comparing several molecules with varying structures, as has been carried out in this instance. The repeating theme seen in these comparisons is that the handle portion of the molecules plays a significant role in intermolecular interactions between meso- and ( f )-isomers.At low surface pressures, the carboxylate head groups
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
127
and carbonyl linkage should be interacting with the water subphase, leaving the hydrocarbon handles free to interact with each other (Fig. 49). It is, therefore, not surprising that the shorter-handle (i.e., six-carbons) system express stereochemically dependent ( )/meso-interactions through excess free energies of mixing. The van der Waals interactions of the short hydrocarbon chains must occur at points closer to the chiral bolt section than those of their longer-chain counterparts. The steric contribution to packing is preserved as the mixed films are compressed. The systems with long handles have their interactions occurring at points further removed from the chiral bolt. Any stereochemical effect on intermolecular interaction is lost through the large number of degrees of freedom represented in intervening methylene units. Therefore, the mixing thermodynamics serve to extract the limits of the effects of chirality on intermolecular interactions. Unlike the case of stearoylserine methyl ester and most other systems presented here, the chiral molecular recognition between the diastereomers occurs in a monolayer phase that is stable and fluid.
*
Amide-linked diacids The effect of stereochemistry on inter- and intra-molecular interactions for a series of straight chain fatty acids linked by a carbonyl group at various positions along the hydrocarbon chains has already been shown. The lowest energy conformations for ( * ) - and rneso-ketodiacids at the air-water interface resulted in very different behavior in their energetics of compression. Much more work was required to overcome the intramolecular conformational forces of the (*)-isomer in order to bring the hydrocarbon chains into collinearity. In contrast, the lowest energy confirmation of the meso-isomer already had the hydrocarbon chains side-by-side, resulting in a much lower work of compression. The amide-diacids presented here represent the case where the carbonyl linkage group has been replaced by an amide group. What effect then, does going from a carbonyl linkage to an amide linkage have on the energetics of compression as a function of the stereochemistry at the points of attachment? Although, unfortunately, the assignment of stereochemistry could not be made, several interesting comparisons between the keto- and amide-linked diacids are apparent. The diastereomers are differentiated by their affinity for a C-18 reverse phase HPLC column. Accordingly, the terms “first eluting” (FE) and “second eluting” (SE) are used to reflect their relative HPLC retention times. The l l / A isotherms for ( * ) - and meso-C-12:6.6’ keto diacids were given in Fig. 46. As was discussed, there are differences between the compression and expansion cycles for films cast from these diastereomers, which reflect
P. L. ROSE E T A .
I28
0
40
80
120 160 d2/moIecuIe
200
240
Fig. 50 Surface pressure/area isotherms for the compression and expansion cycles of first (solid line) and second (dashed line) eluting C-12:6,6-A amide diacids on a pure water subphase at ( A ) 2 5 T , (B) 30"C, and (C) 35"C, carried out at a compression rate of 19.24 Az/molecule per minute. Arrows indicate the direction of compression and expansion.
their conformations at the air-water interface. Both the meso- and ( * ) isomers form highly expanded monolayers at low surface pressures with lift-off areas of approximately 300 and 500 A2/molecule, respectively. In contrast, the first and second eluting diacids, 6-( 6-dodecanoiccarbamoy1)dodecanoic acids (C-12:6,6-A), form more highly condensed monolayers than either diastereomer of the keto diacids (Fig. 50A). There is an additional attraction between amide-linked molecules, which is absent in the interaction of keto diacids. The proclivity of the amide group for hydrogen bonding (to amide groups on neighbouring diacids) could lend itself to intermolecular interactions in monolayers cast from amide-linked diacids resulting in a condensed film. Conversely, hydrogen bonding of the amide group to water might also lead to greater expansion of the film. Comparison of the compression and expansion cycles for C- 15:6,6 diacids linked with a carbonyl group (Fig. 4 1) and those linked with an amide group (Fig. 51A) show that the C-15 amide diacids, 6 4 6-pentadecanoiccarbamoy1)pentadecanoic acids (C- 15:6,6-A), also form much more highly condensed monolayers than do their keto counterparts. Addition of three methylene
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
129
Fig. 51 Surface pressure/area isotherms for the compression and expansion cycles of first (solid line) and second (dashed line) eluting C-t5:6,6-A amide diacids on a pure water subphase at (A)2 5 T , ( B ) 30"C, and (C) 35"C,carried out at a compression rate of 19.24 A2/molecule per minute. Arrows indicate the direction of compression and expansion.
groups to the hydrocarbon chains above the amide linkage increases chain-chain, van der Waals interactions to the point where there is no measurable effect of stereochemistry on the energetics of compression; the compression and expansion cycles are almost coincident. The stereochemically dependent conformations manifested in the films cast from the C-12:6,6-A compounds are masked in the films cast from the C-15 analog due to their condensed nature. This, presumably, is the result of intermolecular hydrogen bonding interactions at the amide bridges and chain-chain interactions along the hydrocarbon chains, which hold the molecules in a tightly packed arrangement. An increase in the temperature of the C-l5:6,6-A film should perturb intermolecular hydrogen bonding interactions, possibly resulting in any stereochemically dependent conformations being expressed in the energetics of compression. Figures 51(A-C) give the compression and expansion cycles for the two isomers of the C-l5:6,6'-A diacids at 25,30 and 35°C. At 30"C,the energetics of compression of the second eluting C-l5:6,6'-A diacid are similar to those of the second eluting C-12:6,6-A diacid at 25°C. Raising the temperature causes a weakening of the intermolecular interactions in the monolayer spread
130
P. L. ROSE E T A L .
from the SE C-15: 6,6‘-A compound. The stereochemically directed conformation seen in the FE C-12 diacid at 25°C and masked in the SE C-15 diacid at 25°C is now expressed at 30°C for the second eluting C-15 diacid as a change in the energetics of resisting compression (expansion of the monolayer at low surface pressures). The stereochemically directed conformation of the F E isomer affords stronger intermolecular associations. The behavior of the molecules in a monolayer film is relatively insensitive to the temperature of the subphase over the same range of temperatures where the SE isomer is quite sensitive. It is seen from Table 14 that the FE isomer spread less spontaneously from the bulk crystal to a monolayer state. This is an indication that associations in the bulk crystal are stronger for the FE isomer than for the SE. In addition, the entropy of spreading is lower for the FE isomer, indicating a more ordered and conversely a more tightly packed film or a less ordered crystal. It cannot be ruled out at this time that the absence of a difference in the n/A isotherms for the FE and SE isomers-of the C-15:6,6-A diacids is the result of a stereochemically dependent intramolecular amide-carboxylate hydrogen bonding interaction leading to conformations at the air- water interface that are indistinguishable on the Langmuir film balance. If this were the case, raising the temperature of the subphase could result in weakening preferentially any inter, or intra-molecular hydrogen bonds, giving the results seen in Figs. 51(A-C). At this point, it is not known whether temperaturedependent energetics of compression are the result of inter- or intra-molecular hydrogen bonding. It has been shown by Harvey et al. (1989) that incorporation of palmitic acid into a monolayer spread from stearoylserine methyl ester (SSME) breaks up intermolecular SSME interactions. The palmitic acid acts as a two-dimensional diluent. Figures 52( A-C) give the l l / A isotherms for mixtures of FE and SE C-l5:6,6’-A with palmitic acid. Dilution of the monolayer cast from the second eluting isomer with 15 mol% palmitic acid separates the diacid molecules from one another on the water surface and perhaps allows for the expression of their stereochemically dependent conformations. The mixed film ( 15% palmitic acid/85% C-15:6,6-A) expands at low II and behaves in much the same manner as the single-component monolayer (C- 15:6,6’-A) behaves at 30°C. Addition of 15 mole% palmitic acid into a monolayer cast from the FE C-15 diacid has little effect on its energetics of compression, indicating a stronger intermolecular interaction afforded by its stereochemically dependent conformation at the air-water interface. Incorporation of higher mole percent palmitic acid in films spread from both isomers causes an expansion of the films beyond that obtained from simple additivity relationships. At all mole fractions of palmitic acid, the
Table 14 Equilibrium spreading pressures lTe and surface excess free energies, entropies, and enthalpies of spreading for first and second eluting C-15:6,6-A amide diacids.
A e / A Zmolecule-
lTe/dyncm-'
AG:/cal mol-
Temp./K
1st eluting
2nd eluting
1st eluting
2nd eluting
298 303 308 313
0.20 f 0.18 0.55 f 0.21 0.58 f 0.22 0.89 f 0.28
0.41 f 0.36 1.38 f 1.08 4.44 f 0.57 5.70 f 0.36
62.8 f 1.0 56.0 f 0.6 54.4 f 0.8 58.5 f 0.5
53.9 f 1.1 55.3 f 0.5 58.9 0.8 59.5 f 1.0
AS:/calmol-'
K-'
1st eluting -18.1 -44.3 -45.4 -75.0
AH:/kcal mol-
'
1st eluting
2nd eluting
1st eluting
2nd eluting
3.4 f 0.8
32.7 f 5.0
1.0 f 0.2
9.74 f 1.52
f 11.5 f 12.1 f 12.4 f 16.8
'
2nd eluting -31.8 f 19.8
- 109.8 f 60.4 - 376.2 f 37.1
-488.4 f 27.1
132
P. L. ROSE E T A L .
A 0 -
w -
I
La-
?.
10
-
Afiwleoule
Fig. 52 Surface pressure/area isotherms for the compression and expansion cycles of mixtures of (A) 15, (B) 30, and (C) 50moIe % palmitic acid with first eluting C-15:6,6'-A amide diacid (solid line) and second eluting C-15:6,6'-A amide diacid (dashed line) on a pure water subphase at 25"C, carried out at a compression rate of 19.24A'/molecule per minute. Arrows indicate the direction of compression and expansion.
energetics of compression are different for mixtures with each isomer. These data, and those reported for the temperature dependence of C-l5:6,6'-A molecules in a monolayer film, indicate that the condensed nature of the monolayers cast from the long-chain amide diacid is due to increased chain-chain interactions of the long hydrocarbon chains and intermolecular hydrogen bonding of the amide linkages. Furthermore, the strength of hydrogen bonding interactions depends on the stereochemistry of the chiral carbons at the points of attachment of the amide group; the stereochemistry gives each isomer its own conformation, which then allows for varying degrees of intermolecular interactions. At 25"C, the isomeric conformations are masked by the condensed nature of the film. However, raising the temperature and/or adding an achiral diluent breaks up intermolecular interactions preferentially, which allows the diastereomers to express their stereochemically dependent conformations. The effects of temperature and added achiral diluent to C-15:6,6-A amide diacids can also be due to differences in intermolecular interactions based on the molecule's configuration. The arguments given above are based on the assumption that the different configurations, the stereochemistry at the chiral
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
133
carbons, for FE and SE isomers results in different conformations on the water surface. Although this seems reasonable given the data presented here, the case is more ambiguous in the absence of X-ray crystal structures than for the keto diacids. 4
Conclusions
This chapter has reported the only extensive and coordinated investigation of the effects of chirality on the properties of monolayer films spread at the air-water interface. Twenty compounds of varied headgroup and chain length have been examined carrying one and two chiral centers. In every case, all of the optical isomers-enantiomers and diastereomers-were made and their properties measured both as pure compounds and as mixed monolayers in order to compare phase changes in the films with mixed melting points of the crystals. Since the laws of symmetry require that all properties of enantiomers (except their interactions with other chiral systems) be exactly the same, these studies have profited by the application of an absolute test for the presence of impurities, a perennial problem in monolayer research. In every case, all measurements were repeated with both enantiomers. Unless the results agreed within experimental error, the compounds were purified repeatedly until they did agree. An unusually extensive battery of experimental techniques was brought to bear on these comparisons of enantiomers with their racemic mixtures and of diastereomers with each other. A very sensitive Langmuir trough was constructed for the project, with temperature control from 15 to 40°C.In addition to the familiar force/area isotherms, which were used to compare all systems, measurements of surface potentials, surface shear viscosities, and dynamic suface tensions (for hysteresis only) were made on several systems with specially designed apparatus. Several microscopic techniques, epifluorescence optical microscopy, scanning tunneling microscopy, and electron microscopy, were applied to films of stearoylserine methyl ester, the most extensively investigated surfactant. The most important series of compounds used for examining the effects of stereochemical variation in the headgroup was the long-chain (mostly stearoyl) amino acid methyl esters. These were chosen because of the commercial availability of both enantiomers, their relevance to biochemistry, and the previous demonstration by Zeelan and Havinga (1958) that such compounds produce good monolayer films. Several series of diastereomeric two-chain dicarboxylic acids, synthesized by Porter’s research group, were used to explore the effects of joining the chains at different points relative
P. L. ROSE ETAL.
134
to the hydrophilic carboxylic acid groups in the water surface. Large differences between meso- and ( )-diastereomers were interpreted readily in terms of conformational forces around the points of attachment at the linkages between the chains. With only one significant exception, the phosphatidylcholines, pronounced stereochemical discrimination was expressed in all of the properties used to compare enantiomers with their racemic mixtures or diastereomers with each other. Moreover, the degree of chiral discrimination was highly dependent on the structure of the headgroup, the temperature and degree of compression of the film. Generally, clear stereochemical recognition was only well defined when films had reached liquid-condensed states. The failure to detect any degree of chiral recognition in monolayers of phospholipids remains an interesting sideline of this study, consider their importance in cell membranes and the ubiquitous employment of chirality for providing selectivity in biochemical processes. For a number of the systems, comparisons were made between the effects of enantiomeric composition in the monolayer and corresponding meltingpoint--composition curves for the crystals. All of the latter gave clear evidence of racemic compound formation in the crystals, and this type of pattern was repeated in the monolayer properties. Hysteresis was generally observed in the compression-expansion cycles of the force-area isotherms, indicating that the timescale for relaxation of the fully compressed film back to its expanded state was slower than the movement of the barrier of the Langmuir trough. Our studies, like many others, imply that monolayers are metastable and that reversible thermodynamics can only be applied to their analysis with caution.
Acknowledgements
We are glad to acknowledge here the contributions of our many colleagues who worked on this project, especially Drs Martin Stewart, Orlean Thompson, Barbara Kinzig, Jeffrey Gold, Lynne Collins-Gold, Eric Johnson, Robert Verbiar, Patricia Zingg, Graham Whitesell, Dorla Mirajovsky, Jonathan Heath, and Mrs Marjorie Richter, and for financial support, at various stages, from the National Science Foundation, the U.S. National Institutes, AT&T and Duke University. Symbols
n Y
Surface pressure Surface tension
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
135
Pi Surface potential Number of molecules Surface dipole moment Molecular area Gas constant Temperature Mole fraction Number of degrees of freedom Number of components equilibrated throughout the system Number of components in the surface monolayer Number of bulk phases equilibrated throughout the system Number of surface phases in equilibrium with each other Free energy of mixing Phase transition surface pressure Equilibrium spreading pressure (ESP) Molecular area at lIe Excess entropy of spreading Excess enthalpy of spreading Surface shear velocity Rate of shear Canal length Canal width Viscosity of subphase Helmholtz free energy of compression Helmholtz free energy of expansion Work of compression/expansion cycle Transition temperature
References Arnett, E. M. and Thompson, 0. (1981). J. Am. Chem. SOC. 103, 968 Arnett, E. M. and Zingg, S. P. (1981). J. Am. Chem. SOC. 103, 1221 Arnett, E. M., Chao, J., Kinzig, B. J., Stewart, M. V., Thompson, 0. and Verbiar, R. J. (1982). J. Am. Chem. SOC. 104, 389 Arnett, E. M., Gold, J. M., Harvey, N., Johnson, E. A. and Whitesell, L. G. (1988a). In Advances in Experimental Medicine and Biology, Vol. 238 Amett, E. M., Harvey, N. and Rose, P. L. (1988b). Langmuir 4, 1049 Arnett, E. M., Harvey, N. G. and Rose, P. L. (1989). Acc. Chem. Res. 22, 131 Arnett, E. M., Harvey, N., Mirajovsky, D. and Rose, P. L. (1990). J . Am. Chem. SOC. 112. 3547 Bain, C. D. and Whitesides, G. M. (1988). Science 240, 62 Bienkowski, R. and Skolnick, M. (1974). J. Colloid Interface Sci. 48, 350
136
P. L. ROSE E T A L .
Brittain, W. J., Porter, N. A and Krebs, P. J. (1984). J. Am. Chem. SOC. 106, 7652 Cadenhead, D. A. (1969). Ind. Eng. Chem. 61(4), 22 Chapman, D. ( 1968). Biological Membranes. Academic Press, New York Cook, A. and Webb, W. R. (1966). Ann. Thorac. Surg. 2, 327 Craig, D. P. and Mellor, D. P. (1975). Phys. Scr. 79, 119 Craig, D. P., Radom, L. and Stiles, P. J. (1971). Proc. Roy. SOC. Lond. A343, 1 1 Cram, D. J. (1984). Proc. 29th ZUPAC Congress; Pure Appl. Chem., p. 3 Crisp, D. J. (1949). Surface Chem. ( S u p p l . Res., London), p. 17 Defay, R. ( 1932). Doctoral dissertation, Brussels Dragcevic, D., Milunovic, M. and Pravetic, V. (1986). Croatia Chim. Acta 59, 397 DuNouy, L. (1929). Science 69, 251 Eliel, E. L. (1962). Stereochemistry of Carbon Compounds, pp. 43-47. McGraw-Hill, New York Fendler, J. H. (1982). Membrane Mimetic Chemistry. John Wiley, New York Fredga, A. (1944). In The Suedberg Memorial Volume (ed. A. Tiselius and K. 0. Pederson). Almquist and Wiksell, Uppsala Furhop, J. H. and Fritsch, D. (1986). Acc. Chem. Res. 19, 130 Furhop, J. H., David, H. H., Mathieu, J., Liman, U., Winter, H. J. and Boekema, E. J. (1986). J. Am. Chem. SOC. 108, 1785 Gaines, G. L. (1966). Insoluble Monolayers at Liquid-Gas Interfaces, Chaps. 7 and 8. Wiley, New York Gaines, G. L., Tweet, A. G. and Bellamy, W. D. (1965). J. Phys. Chem. 42, 2193 Gershfeld, N. L. (1972). In Techniques of Surface Chemistry and Physics (ed. R. J. Good, R. R. Stromberg and R. L. Patrick), Vol. I. Marcel Dekker, New York Gershfeld, N. L. (1976). Ann. Reu. Phys. Chem., 27, 349 Gershfeld, N. L. (1982). J . Colloid Interface Sci. 85, 28 Gershfeld, N. L. (1986). Faraday Disc. Chem. SOC. 81, 19 Gershfeld, N. L. (1988). J . Membr. Bio. 101, 65 Gershfeld, N. L. and Pagano, R. E. (1972a). J . Phys. Chem. 76, 1231 Gershfeld, N. L. and Pagano, R. E. (1972b). J . Phys. Chem. 76, 1238 Gershfeld, N. L. and Pagano, R. E. (1972~).J. Phys. Chem. 76, 1248 Gibbs, J. W. ( 1948). Collected Works,Vol. 1, p. 219. Yale University Press, New Haven Gold, L. C. Unpublished results, Duke University Goodrich, F. C. (1957). Proc. 2nd Int. Congr. Surf: Act. 1, 85 Greene, F. D., Berwick, M. A. and Stowell, J. C. (1970). J . Am. Chem. SOC.92, 867 Guay, D. and LeBlanc, R. M. (1987). Langmuir 3, 575 Handa, T. and Nakagaki, M. (1979). Colloid Polyrn. Sci. 257, 374 Harkins, W. D. and Kirkwood, J. G. (1938). J. Phys. Chem. 6, 298 Harkins, W. D., Young, T. F. and Boyd, E. (1940). J. Chem. Phys. 8, 954 Harvey, N. G. and Arnett, E. M. (1989). Langmuir 5, 998 Harvey, N., Rose, P., Porter, N. A., Huff, J. B. and Arnett, E. M. (1988). J. Am. Chem. SOC. 110,4395 Harvey, N. G., Mirajovsky, D., Rose, P. L., Verbiar, R. and Arnett, E. M. (1989). J . Am. Chem. SOC. 111, 1115 Harvey, N. G., Rose, P. L., Mirajovsky, D. and Arnett, E. M. (1990). J. Am. Chem. SOC. 112,3547 Heath, J. G. ( 1991). Doctoral dissertation; Duke University Heath, J. G. and Arnett, E. M. (1992). J. Am. Chem. SOC. 114, in press Jacques, J., Collet, A. and Wilen, S. H. (1981). Enantiomers, Racemates and Resolutions, pp. 93-97. Wiley, New York
CHIRALITY AND MOLECULAR RECOGNITION IN MONOLAYERS
137
Jaffe, A. B., Skinner, K. J. and McBride, J. M. (1972). J . Am. Chem. SOC.94, 8510 Jarvis, N. L. (1965). J . Phys. Chem. 69, 1789 Jeffers, P. M. and Daen, J. (1965). J . Phys. Chem. 69, 2368 Johnson, E. A. (1985). Doctoral dissertation, Duke University Joly, M. (1956). J . Colloid Interface Sci. 11, 519 Keller, D. J., McConnell, H. M. and Moy, V. T. (1986). J . Phys. Chem. 90, 231 1 Langmuir, I. and Schaefer, V. J. (1937). J . Am. Chem. SOC.59, 2400 Lucassen-Reynders, E. H. (1973). J . Colloid Interface Sci. 42, 554 Lucassen-Reynders, E. H., Lucassen, J., Garett, P. R., Giles, D. and Holloway, F. (1974). In Monolayers (Advances in Chemistry Series 144) (ed. E. D. Goddard), p. 272. American Chemical Society, Washington, DC Lunquist, M. (1961). Ark. Kemi 17, 183 Lunquist, M. (1963). Ark. Kemi 21, 395 Lunquist, M. (1965). Ark. Kemi 23, 299 Malcolm, B. R. (1973). Prog. Membrane Sci. 7, 123 Malcolm, B. R. (1975). Ado. Chern. 145, 338 Manheimer, R J. and Schechter, R. S. (1970). J . Colloid Interface Sci. 32, 225 Margoni, N. (1871) Nuooo Cim. 2, 5 McConnell, H. M. and Moy, V. T. (1988). J . Phys. Chem. 92,4520 McConnell, H. M., Keller, D. K. and Gaule, H. J. (1986). J . Phys. Chem. 90, 1717 McConnell, H M., Tamm, C. K. and Weis, R. M. (1984). Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. U S A 81, 3249 Moore, B., Knobler, C. M., Broseta, D. and Rondelez, F. (1986). J . Chem. SOC., Faraday Trans. 2 82, 1753 Moore, W. . I and . Eyring, H. (1938). J. Chern. Phys. 6, 394 Morawetz, H. and Kandaniem, A. Y. (1966). J . Phys. Chem. 70, 2995 Munden, J. W. and Swarbrick, J. (1973). Biochim. Biophys. Acta 291, 344 Munden, J. W., Blois, D. W. and Swarbrick, J. (1969). J . Pharm. Sci. 58, 1308 Nagaranjan, M. K. and Shah, J. P. (1981). J . Colloid Interface Sci. 80, 7 Pagano, R. E. and Gershfeld, N. L. (1972). J . Colloid Interface Sci. 41, 31 1 Pasteur, L. (1848). Ann. Chim. 24,442 Petter, R. C., Mitchell, J. C., Brittain, W. J., McIntosh, T. J and Porter, N. A. (1983). J . Am. Chem. SOC. 105, 5700 Petterson, K. (1956). Ark. Kemi 10, 297 Pirkle, W. H and Pochapsky, T. C. (1987). J . Am. Chem. SOC. 109, 5975 Porter, N. A., Arnett, E. M., Brittain, W. J., Johnson, E. A. and Krebs, P. J. (1986a). J . Am. Chem. SOC. 108, 1014 Porter, N. A., Ok, D., Adams, C. M. and Huff, J. B. (1986b).J . Am. Chem. SOC.108,5025 Porter, N. A., Ok, D., Huff, J. B., Adams, C. M., McPhail, A. T and Kim, K. (1988). J . Am. Chem. SOC. 110, 1896 Rakshit, A. K. and Zografi, G. (1980). J . Colloid Interface Sci. 80, 474 Rosano, H. L., Yin, D-N. and Cante, C. C. (1971). J . Colloid Interface Sci. 37, 706 Sauer, B., Chen, Y-L., Zografi, G. and Yu, H. (1988). Langmuir 4, 11 Shafer, P. T. (1974). Biochim. Biophys. Acta 373,425 Shah, D. 0. and Capps, R. W. (1968). J . Colloid Interface Sci. 27, 319 Stallberg-Stenhagen, S. and Stenhagen, E. (1951). Acta. Chem. Scand. 5,481 Stewart, M. and Arnett, E. M. (1982). Top. Stereochem. 13, 195 Tachibana, T. and Hori, K. (1977). J . Colloid Interface Sci. 61, 398 Tanford, C. (1973). The Hydrophobic Efect. John Wiley, New York Tanford, C. (1989). Ben Franklin Stilled the Waves. Duke University Press
138
P. L. ROSE ET AL.
Thompson, 0. ( 1981). Doctoral dissertation, University of Pittsburgh Townsend, D. F and Buck, E. J. (1988). Langmuir 4, 938 Verbiar, R. J. ( 1983). Doctoral dissertation, Duke University Washburn, E. R. and Wakeham, H. R. R. (1938). J . Am. Chem. SOC.60, 1294 Weis, R. M. and McConnell, H. M. (1984). Nature 310, 47 Whitesides, G. M (1991). Science 254, 1312 Zeelen, F. J. (1956). Doctoral dissertation, The State University of Leiden Zeelen, F. J. and Havinga, E. (1958). Red. Trav. Chim. Pays-Bas 77, 267 Zingg, S. P. ( 1981). Doctoral dissertation, University of Pittsburgh Zingg, S. P, Arnett, E. M., McPhail, A. T., Bothner-By, A. A. and Gilkerson, W. R. (1988). J. Am. Chem. SOC. 110, 1565
Transition-State Theory Revisited W. Jom ALEERY
Physical Chemistry Laboratory, University of Oxford, South Parks Road, Oxford O X 1 3QZ, U K
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
Introduction 139 The classical paradox 140 An alternative derivation 140 Where is the transition state? 143 The adiabatic case 145 Multistep reactions in solution 147 Proton transfers to cyanocarbon bases 152 Extension to include xR 153 Reactions at liquid/liquid interfaces 155 Colloidal deposition 158 Free energy profiles 163 Summary 167 Acknowledgments 168 Appendix 168 References 170
1
Introduction
Most physical organic chemists use transition-state theory to model their reactions and try to devise ingenious experiments to measure the properties of the transition state. Such properties include for instance the geometry, the volume, the charge and the dipole moment. Despite the success of this approach, many physical chemists and nearly all gas-phase kineticists regard the transition-state theory with suspicion, if not outright hostility. For instance we find the following in Peter Atkins’ textbook on ‘PhysicalChemistry (Atkins, 1982): “That is not to say that the theory is complete or even very reliable.” And again he writes, “. .. the basic assumption that the rate process involves an equilibrium is often a stumbling block to its acceptance.” In this 139 ADVANCES IN PHYSICAL ORGANIC CHEMISTRY VOLUME 28 ISBN 0-12-033528-X
Copyright 01993 Academic Press Limited A / / rights of reproduction in anyform reserved
140
W. J. ALBERY
chapter I am first going to discuss a number of difficulties with the theory as it is classically presented. I am then going to show how the theory can be extended to include a wide variety of different kinetic processes ranging from atom-transfer reactions through electron- and ion-transfer reactions to the kinetics of colloidal deposition. Finally I am going to discuss free energy profiles and how they should be used. 2
The classical paradox
The classical derivation of transition-state theory starts by assuming that the transition state, Xs, is in equilibrium with the reactants A and B as represented in (1). The rate of reaction, u, is given by (2)where vT is some
frequency. We are now told that Xs is committed to reaction. For instance Levine and Bernstein ( 1987) write “. . . the concept of a configuration of no return such that when the system has reached the critical configuration it will necessarily proceed to reaction and not “turn back” to the reactants region.” The paradox arises because (1) and equilibrium require a formulation as in (3), where most of Xt that is formed returns to reactants and only a small
fraction is converted to products. Commitment and (2) require exactly the reverse (4);all the Xi that is formed is committed to reaction. It is the
incompatability of (3) and (4)that quite rightly gives transition-state theory a bad name. 3
An alternative derivation
In escaping from the paradox, we have to recognize that, as shown in Fig. 1, in the region of the transition state the species on the free energy surface change from being in equilibrium with the reactants and totally uncommitted
TRANSITION-STATE THEORY REVISITED
141
G
Fig. 1 A typical free energy profile showing how the fraction committed to reaction varies from zero through at the transition state and finally reaches unity.
to reaction to having passed the point of no return and being totally committed. This is shown by the fraction f of species committed to reaction. The IUPAC glossary of terms used in physical organic chemistry (Gold, 1983) defines the transition state as being the point where f = 0.5. We now proceed to derive the rate expression by creating an intermediate X, as shown in Fig. 2; X is a species that is equally likely to form products or to return to the reactants. Applying the steady state approximation to X we obtain ( 5 ) where R is the reactant(s). u = $k,[R]
= kJX]
(5)
Fig. 2 A hypothetical intermediate that is equally likely to return to reactants or to transform into products.
142
W. J. ALBERY
+
Hence, instead of (l),we find expression (6). The factor of arises because
X is half committed to reaction and half in equilibrium with R. It is interesting to note that at equilibrium when the back reaction is included, as shown in Fig. 3, then [ X I doubles, with equal contributions coming from R and from the products, P. At equilibrium, the concentration of X is given by (7) and now has its full Boltzmann value.
Now in ( 5 ) k, can be expressed in terms of the frequency v,, shown in Fig. 4, by (8). The factor of 4 arises because it takes one-quarter of a cycle
k,
= 4v,(4) = 2v,
(8)
to escape from the minimum; the factor of arises because X is equally likely to be moving left to right or right to left. Next, as shown in Fig. 5, we squeeze
.
k-l
Fig.3 The effect of adding in the back reaction at equilibrium is to double the concentration of X.
kl k,
.
2*
X
\
Fig. 4 The rate constant k , can be related to the frequency vt.
143
TRANSITION-STATE THEORY REVISITED
Fig. 5 The hypothetical intermediate X is transformed into a transition state.
out the artificial dip to obtain a surface with a clean barrier. As we do so, by the usual arguments, vt -+ 0, and the associated partition function q$ goes to its limiting value (9), The combination of (6), (8) and (9) then g